This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
hM;v: Úyh`, Ola‘ hwì :hy“ .Úvâ,p]n"Alk;b]W Ú`b]b;l“Alk;B] Úyn< +b;W hT∞ ;a' µw Y–ho ' Ú¡ù W“x'm] yk∆InOa;Arv,a} r ví ,a} µyM+i['h¢;AlK;mi Ú!x]B,qiw“ bc;wO“ Úm-<j}riw“ Ú¡t]Wbv]Ata, Úyhi à,fila‘ hwí :hy“ bv;! w“ 30:3 >hM;vâ; Úyt™l, øa‘ hw :hy“ IÚàx]ypâih‘ ⁄ 112
Ibid., 59.
115
The author adds “at the end of days,” creating an eschatological significance for the text which is to be realized contemporarily113 and omits the phrase “which I have set before you.” The omission of >hM;vâ; Úyh™ l, øa‘ hwì :hy“ Úài j}yDihi r ví ,a} µy+wOi Gh'Alk;B] constitutes a more important move because, if intentional, it finds the author erasing the allusion to the historical dispersion of Israel. This achieves the following for the sect: it sets its experience in an eschatological context, and, while ostensibly seeking to convert the addressee to the sectarian worldview, it implicitly exhorts those already “in” to remain faithful and so achieve salvation. Furthermore, it implies that the scriptural text finds its telos in the sect’s own generation, degrades the opponents as those who stray from Torah, and espouses a clear notion of judgment for non-sectarians. C 17–20 (GM 103–106a): [It is written in the book] of Moses [and in the books of the Prophets] that there will come [. . .] [the blessings have (already) befallen in . . .] in the days of Solomon the son of David. And the curses [that] have (already) befallen from the days of Jeroboam the son of Nebat and up to when Jerusalem and Zedekiah King of Judah went into captivity that He will bring them [. . .].
The author exhorts the addressee to turn to Scripture, especially the history of the kings, in order to learn from them. The passage achieves the following for the sect: it sets their experience in an eschatological context, implies that the scriptural text finds its telos in the sect’s own generation, and espouses a clear notion of divine judgment. C 20 (GM 106b–107a): And we know that some of the blessings and the curses have (already) been fulfilled as it is written in the bo[ok of Mo]ses.
This passage echoes C 17 and as such achieves the same for the sect: it sets their experience in an eschatological context, especially with the “fulfillment” language, implies that the scriptural text finds its telos in the sect’s own generation, espouses a clear notion of divine judgment, and shows the sect’s special knowledge.
113 Where Qimron and Strugnell see “an addition,” Bernstein suggests another biblical allusion rising from Deut 31:29 or even Deut 4:30: lKø¡ ÚWaÈx;m]W Ú+l] rX¢'B' >wløâqøB] T™[; ]m'v;w“ Úyh+,loa‘ hw∞:hy“ Ad[' T!;b]v'w“ µym+iY:h' t!yrIj}a'B] hL,aeh; µyr¢ib;D]h.' Qimron and Strugnell, DJD X, 59; Bernstein, “Employment,” 48 and n. 43.
116
Indirect Use of Scripture in 4QMMT As with the Fourth Gospel, while space does not allow extensive comment on biblical allusions, indirect references, or the mere use of biblical phraseology, a few words are certainly in order. Like most Qumran texts, 4QMMT is suffused with biblical language.114 For example, at C 24 the author observes that kings who followed Torah were “delivered from troubles” (twrxm lxn), a common phrase which is used of King David at 1 Sam 26:24 and Ps 34:18.115 References to “Torah” (hrwt) abound (C 24 [twice], 27, 28) and function in the important capacity of canon for setting boundaries and determining whom to include or exclude. So the opponents are those who do not “fear” or “do” Torah, whereas the sectarians are defined as “seekers of the Torah” (hrwt yçqbm). Knowing Torah is not as important as fearing or doing Torah, since the (unknown) addressee proves that knowledge of Torah certainly does not necessitate observance of it (C 28). Other indirect references to Scripture appear in the form of “the book” (rps) C 10 (twice), 11; Moses (hçm) C 10, 17, 21; David (dwd) C 10, 18, 25; prophets (aybn) C 10; and “former events,” C11, 12. These last five congregate in 4QMMT C 7–11, so it bears closer attention. C 7–11:116 [And you know that] we have separated ourselves from the multitude of the people [and from all their impurity] and from being involved with these matters and from participating with [them] in these things. And you [know that no] treachery or deceit or evil can be found in our hand (i.e. in us), since for [these things] we give [. . . And] we have [written] to you so that you may study (carefully) the book of Moses and the books of the Prophets and (the writings of ) David [and the] [events of ] ages past.
At the “narrative level,” the author writes to the addressee to explain why his group has separated and to invite the addressee to scrutinize Scripture more seriously so that he might at least concede the authors’ points and at most convert to the sect. 114 Though Qimron’s claim (DJD X, 136) seems a bit exaggerated: “In most of the halakhot there are allusions to the biblical passages on which the particular halakha is based. Some words from each biblical parallel occur in the halakha of MMT (sometimes in a grammatical form different from that of the source).” 115 Ibid., 62 n. 24. 116 Ibid., 56–57.
117
For the sect that preserved the letter, the appeal to “the book of Moses,” “the books of the Prophets,” “the writings of David,” and “the events of ages past” degrades “them” as “the people and all their impurity.” It helps to create “us” through etiological propositions—both the claim that the sectarians deliberately separated at some point and the claim that “events of ages past” as recorded in Scripture validate that withdrawal. It elevates “us” as an honest, faithful group in whom there is “no treachery or deceit.” As always, it reflects the authority of Scripture for the group. Cases where the author refers to the biblical text, but does not indicate he is doing so by using a citation formula (bwtk), occur at B 69, 70. There the lack of citation formula serves an intentional function since the author’s goal at those points is paraenetic; he acts as though the addressee does not need to be directed to the scriptural passage because the addressee should “know” already that the author is alluding to Scripture. So the author says, “And you know [that if someone violates a prohibitive commandment unintentionally], and the fact escapes him, he should bring a purification offering.” In referring to Lev 5:2 the author assumes (whether actually or rhetorically)117 that this addressee who has “wisdom and knowledge of the Torah” (C 28) knows the reference. Put that way, the addressee would be ashamed to admit he does not. The technique compels the reader to assume the author’s position.118 A similar pattern of indirect reference usage appears in the following places, but detailed analysis of them would add little to what we have already seen: B 11–13 (Lev 22:16); B 14 (Num 19:8, 10, 21); B 39–41 (Deut 23:2–4); B 40 (Gen 2:23–24); B 49 (Lev 19:30); B 62–64 (Lev 19:23–24 and Lev 27:32); B 72–74 (Num 19:16 or 19:18); C 25 (2 Sam 7:15, Ps 89:25, 29, 34, 50; 2 Chr 6:42); C 31–32 (Gen 15:6; Deut 6:18, 24–25; 12:28; Ps 106:3).119
117
Cf. Rom 7:1. David Koresh was fond of this technique. 119 Moshe Bernstein distinguishes between biblical imitation for “purely stylistic” purposes and “theological” purposes. I disagree with such a categorization because what Bernstein designates “mere stylistics,” I would place on our chart under the rubric of “shaping worldview” or “production of culture,” noting the power of language in a way he apparently does not. If we ignore his categories, his identifications of biblical allusions are useful. For a discussion of how Bernstein arrives at these scriptural echoes, see “Employment,” 36–38. 118
118
Charting Results How Scripture Functions in the Qumran Sect A. BREAKING AWAY: CREATING AND DEGRADING “THEM” 1QpHab 2:1–3; 5:8–12 4QMMT B 9–11, 27–35, 70, 75–76, 77–78; C 6–7, 12 CD 3:7–8; 4:12–14; 5:8ff.; 6:11–19; 7:9–8:3 B. FORMATION OF SECT 1. Etiology: celebrate origins of the community; ground community in the past 1QpHab 5:8–12 4QMMT C 6–8; 11 CD 3:20ff.; 6:2–7; 6:11–19; 7:9–8:3 2. Show sect’s founder to have special insight regarding Scripture 1QpHab 2:2; 7:4–5 CD 6:7–11 3. Defining and elevating “us” a. An elect group 1QpHab 5:4–5, 6–8; 9:12; 10:13 CD 8:14–18 b. An honest, faithful group 4QMMT B 8–9 1QpHab 5:7; 7:10 c. A persevering group 1QpHab 5:6–8; 7:10–11; 8:1 CD 7:12–14 d. A privileged group 1QpHab 11:1 4QMMT C 20 CD 3:18–4:4; 6:2–7; 6:11–19 e. A group affording access to salvation 1QpHab 8:2 f. A group that observes the Law 1QpHab 5:5–6; 12:2–5
119
C. CREATING A DISTINCT WAY OF LIFE 1. Ethical behavior a. Setting boundaries: purity/defilement 4QMMT B 66–67, 75–76, 76–77, 77–78; C 6–7 CD 3:20ff.; 6:11–19 b. Providing ethical imperatives 1QpHab 5:5; 7:10–11; 8:1 4QMMT B 9–11, 37–38, 66–67, 75–76, 76–77, 77–78 CD 6:11–19; 7:6–9; 7:9–8:3 2. Ritual practice 1QpHab 11:7–8 4QMMT B 27 CD 6:11–19 3. Language and rhetoric All of 1QpHab, which clothes contemporary experience in biblical terms CD 6:2–7; 7:9–8:3 4. Use of sacred texts a. The sectarian community as Scripture’s telos 1QpHab 1:2–3; 2:8–10; 7:2 CD 1:13ff.; 4:12–14; 6:11–19 b. Scripture validates the sect’s views 4QMMT B 9–11, 27–35, 37–38, 66–67, 70, 75–76, 77–78; C 6–7, 12 CD 4:19ff.; 7:6–9; 20:13–17 5. Roles of authoritative leaders a. Teacher of Righteousness 1. The leader is righteous, chosen by God or otherwise admirable 1QpHab 1:13 CD 6:7–11; 7:18ff. 2. Unjustly persecuted 1QpHab 5:9–12; 9:9–10; 11:4–6 3. Privy to special insight 1QpHab 2:2; 7:4–5 CD 6:7–11 4. Warrants fidelity and belief; salvation and judgment depend upon one’s stance vis-à-vis him 1QpHab 2:2; 8:2–3; 9:9–12
120
b. Priest 1QpHab 2:8–10 c. “We” of 4QMMT who pronounce rulings (dabar) according to their opinion 4QMMT B 1–2, 29, 36, 37, 42, 55, 64, 73; C 10, 11–12, 20, 26–27 6. Definition of the future 1QpHab 7:1–2, 7, 9–14 CD 3:20ff. D. OPPOSITION TO AND FROM THE PARENT TRADITION 1. Named opponents a. High Priest/Wicked Priest ([çrh ˆhkh) 1QpHab 1:13; 8:8–13; 11:13–14 4QMMT as a whole; 4QMMT C 26–27(?) b. Man of the Lie 1QpHab 2:1–2; 5:11; 10:9(?) CD 1:14(?) c. Seekers-After-Smooth-Things CD 1:18 d. House of Absalom and its partisans 1QpHab 5:9–12 e. Other priests of Jerusalem 1QpHab 9:4 2. Those who break Scripture 1QpHab 5:11–12 4QMMT B 9–11, 27–35, 70, 75–76, 77–78; C 6–7, C 12 CD 1:20; 3:7–8; 4:19ff.; 5:8ff. E. OPPOSITION FROM WITHIN THE SECT: DEALING WITH DEFECTION 1. Reward adherence to the sect 1QpHab 8:2 4QMMT C12 2. Castigate potential and actual deserters 1QpHab 2:3–4, 14–15 CD 7:20–8:3; 8:14–18
121
F. OPPOSITION TO AND FROM WITHOUT 1. Romans 1QpHab. 2:12–14; 3–4; 6:1–12; 9:4–6 2. The nations 1QpHab 12:10–13:4 G. JUDGMENT AGAINST OPPONENTS 1. Against Parent Religion 1QpHab 5:4–5; 9:1–2, 4–7, 12; 10:3–5, 12–13; 12:2–5 CD 1:16–17; 1:21–2:1; 3:20ff. 4QMMT C 12, 17, 20 2. Against Sect-Defectors 1QpHab 2:3–4, 14–15120 CD 7:20–8:3; 8:14–18; 20:13–17 3. Against the “World” (the nations, the Romans) 1QpHab 5:4; 12:12–13:4 H. GROWING THE SECT 1. Proselytizing 1QpHab 2:6 4QMMT B 37–38 CD 3:20ff. 2. The next generation
Conclusions Formation of the Sect A sect, by definition, forms in opposition to a parent tradition, and as long as its members remain sectarian they maintain opposition to and from that tradition. The process of developing an identity, group
120 Protest might be raised against the inclusion of the 1QpHab passages here insofar as they do not overtly announce judgment on the sect defectors at this particular point, but merely mention them with disgust. Other passages, however, make it clear that, in addition to drawing attention to them, the author implies judgment on them as well (cf. e.g., 13:4).
122
boundaries, and a worldview requires distinguishing the group from other groups, defining the community over against actual or constructed opponents. Regardless of which, if any, of the scenarios presented at the beginning of the chapter actually inhered in the birth of the sect, the author of 1QpHab envisions a schism centered on the acceptance or rejection of the Teacher of Righteousness (1QpHab 5:8–12). The sectarian insiders, the “we,” identify with those who accepted the Teacher of Righteousness, while the opponents, the “they,” are those who are identified with the rejecters. The latter are not only identified, but also clearly degraded; they are “traitors” who are associated with the Man of the Lie (1QpHab 2:1–3). The author of 4QMMT ascribes the break to issues of purity and draws the dividing line between the “we” who maintained the purity laws and the “they” who patently transgressed them. 1QpHab also identifies “them” as those who rejected the law (1QpHab 5:8–12). The distinctions and characterizations made by the Qumran authors in recounting the emergence of the sect remain consistent for opponents as described in the sect’s contemporary situation. Just as the original opponents to the Teacher of Righteousness rejected him, so also the contemporary opponents reject the sectarians; just as the original opponents were treacherous, deceitful, and willing to sacrifice their integrity to save themselves, so also the contemporary opponents are treacherous, greedy, and deceitful; just as the original opponents broke Torah, so also the contemporary opponents do the same. By the same token, the contemporary sectarians resemble their founding counterparts. They accept the words of the Teacher of Righteousness, that is, the word of God. They remain faithful to Torah (1QpHab 5:5–6); they are honest and persevere in the truth no matter what the cost to them. These consistent characterizations are in keeping with Garfinkel’s observations regarding degradation techniques. It is not enough simply to denounce the actions of the opponents; the grounds of their actions must be identified. In the Fourth Gospel the essence of the opponents is defined primarily by whether one’s father is the devil or God. In the Qumran literature, the opponents, in their very essence, are opposed to God’s desires and seek to fulfill their own desires (CD 3:7); the exact opposite can be said of the sectarians. The Qumran authors (i.e., the denouncers) use Scripture deftly to accomplish what Garfinkel describes thus: “any sense of accident, coincidence, indeterminism, chance, or monetary [sic] occurrence must not merely be
123
minimized. Ideally, such measures should be inconceivable. . . .”121 This is accomplished in part by the authors’ indication that the sect’s contemporary situation was already inscribed in Scripture long ago and that Scripture finds its telos in the group. There are no surprises for the sect: their experiences are simply the unfolding of what was already foretold in Scripture. The opponents are made to be totally “other”; they are ritually separated from a place in the legitimate order and are instead doomed to divine destruction. As it turns out, although the Qumran group separated from its parent tradition, each text manifests a residual concern for the parent tradition and its affairs; theirs was not “a clean break.” The people of the Qumran community, in typical sectarian fashion, never considered themselves anything but Jews. Their distinction lay in their understanding themselves as the true, purified, fulfilled Israel, the faithful inheritors of the covenant indicated in Scripture. Their etiology is grounded in the hoary past; to one initiated into the sect’s special jargon, they can be seen in the pages of Scripture, the “we” of Hab 1:12ff., the “princes” of Num 21:18. The fact that the sect simultaneously envisioned itself both as a “new” phenomenon (members of a “new” covenant, e.g.) and an “old” phenomenon (rightful claimants to the original covenant, faithful remnant) results in tension that may explain in part why the authors give more attention and vehement castigation to Jews than to Gentiles. Though adamantly defining themselves as radically different from those in the parent tradition, they are not so different as to be defined apart from that tradition. So, the person who expects the Qumran sect to wash its hands of the Jews who opposed it and whom it opposed, and to turn its sights upon Samaritans or Gentiles, will find little supporting evidence. It is not the case that the authors’ interest in the parent tradition terminates with their having narrated the original break; rather, it continues to express tension with the tradition. Recall Swidler’s characterization of unsettled periods which, in the process of forming new strategies of action, nevertheless maintain a basic connection with the parent tradition insofar as “much of their taken-for-granted understanding of the world and many of their daily practices still depend on traditional patterns.”122 Scripture itself may be counted among those “traditional patterns,” as Wayne Meeks indicates when he writes with 121 122
Garfinkel, “Conditions,” 42. Swidler, “Culture,” 279.
124
regard to the Fourth Gospel: “While in Philo’s writings we see the Moses traditions being used in a broad Kulturkampf, here in John they are employed in a sectarian controversy. And both sides in this controversy have used the same scripture and similar traditions.”123 Creating a Distinct Way of Life Like the Branch Davidians, the Qumran community evinced its break with its parent tradition in a rather literal way by physically residing together in a separate community whose boundaries were drawn clearly. As Bainbridge notes: “A successful religious movement typically goes through a formative period, when it develops its distinctive doctrine and practices.”124 Those forging a sectarian community must provide the group a sense of identity, which involves adopting or inventing culture, actions, habits, ascribing to them particular meaning, and assimilating members into that culture so that everyone in the group operates with a set of shared assumptions and strategies of action. Residents of Qumran were expected to abide by uniform ethical and ritual practices. Recall Swidler’s argument: Bursts of ideological activism occur in periods when competing ways of organizing action are developing or contending for dominance. People formulate, flesh out, and put into practice new habits of action. In such situations, culture may indeed be said to directly shape action. Members of a religious cult wear orange, or share their property . . . because their beliefs tell them to. . . . During such periods, differences in ritual practice or doctrine may become highly charged, so that statuary in churches . . ., the clothing and preaching style of ministers . . . are fraught with significance. Ritual acquires such significance in unsettled lives because ritual changes reorganize taken-for-granted habits and modes of experience.125
She argues, “In unsettled periods, ideologies—explicit, articulated, highly organized meaning systems (both political and religious)—establish new styles or strategies of action. When people are learning new ways of organizing individual and collective action, practicing unfamiliar habits until they become familiar, then doctrine, symbol, and ritual directly shape action.”126 Sects, as representatives of unsettled lives, are impa123 124 125 126
Meeks, “Divine Agent,” 54. Bainbridge, Sociology, 82–83. Swidler, “Culture,” 279. Ibid., 278.
125
tient of the ambiguities, varieties, and even profound inconsistencies which “settled lives” tolerate; rather, they provide a comprehensive answer to the question of “how human beings should live. In conflict with other cultural models, these cultures are coherent because they must battle to dominate the worldviews, assumptions, and habits of their members.”127 Sects seek to dominate the worldview of their members, and the sects studied here rely heavily on the invocation and interpretation of Scripture to effect it. The reader should not be surprised, then, to find an emphasis on ethical and ritual practice at Qumran or to discover Scripture as a vehicle of culture which plays a prominent role in designing the new strategies of action. In the most general terms, the sectarians are consistently exhorted to “observe the Law” (1QpHab 8:1) or “keep the commandments” (1QpHab 5:5), but more specific practices are enjoined as well, such as those related to consuming a cereal offering (4QMMT B 9–11), eating a fetus (4QMMT B 37–38), lepers (4QMMT B 66–67), marriage (4QMMT B 75–76), and others. Rituals related to slaughtering (4QMMT B 27) and keeping the sabbath and festival days (CD 6:11–19; 1QpHab 11:7–8) appear as well. Issues of purity and defilement loom large in the deployment of Scripture in the chosen Qumran texts. This is a community that appears to have concerned itself seriously with setting boundaries between insiders and outsiders. The same applies to the Branch Davidians under Koresh, who expected his people to abide by particular dietary laws, marriage boundaries, codes of dress, and observance of the sabbath. In addition to ethical and ritual means, creating and using a special insider language is effective in developing a sense of group identity among sectarians. Recall the discussion concerning language and rhetoric as a means to cultural inclusion or exclusion. Leaders and members may insist that their belief system is unique but deliberately not present those beliefs thoroughly or transparently. They may appeal to esoteric, historical, philosophical, and theological sources of wisdom to keep the belief system somewhat inaccessible to outsiders. They may also use special language.128 This type of move is made often in the Qumran literature where the authors speak in a code, even a double code. For example, 1QpHab12ff. quotes Hab. 1:4 and then “explains” that the “evildoer” of Hab 1:4 is the “Wicked 127 128
Ibid., 279. Wuthnow, Producing, 101.
126
Priest” and Habakkuk’s “upright man” is the Teacher of Righteousness. The biblical code is thus cracked for the sectarians who, as insiders, know the Wicked Priest and the Teacher of Righteousness, but the “interpretation” remains opaque to the outsider whose only hope of discovery rests upon extensively searching all of the Qumran literature to make an educated guess as to the identity of these figures. Other examples of special language include: “traitors,” the “poor ones,” the “simple ones of Judah,” “the last generation,” “those who live in the land of Damascus,” “Ephraim,” “the House of Judah,” “the House of Absalom,” “Man of the Lie,” “seekers-after-smooththings,” and “Kittim.” In observing how these authors wield Scripture to establish boundaries and place various people and groups of people into orderly categories, it is useful to visit part of Wuthnow’s explanation of the dramaturgic approach to culture: The term “dramaturgic” is used to describe this approach because of its emphasis on the capacity of rituals, ideologies, and other symbolic acts to dramatize the nature of social relations. It is in these dramatizations that definitions of the situations are communicated. In saying that culture is symbolic-expressive, therefore, this approach tends to focus less on information that is simply and straightforwardly transmitted than on messages that may be implicit in the ways in which social life is arranged, in rituals, and in the choice of words in discourse. Put simply, what is “given off ” may be as important as what is “given.”129
Loci of Authority Scripture The authors of our texts plied Scripture extensively and variously to maintain the sect. In addition to setting boundaries, providing ethical imperatives,130 and insisting on ritual/devotional practices, much scriptural interpretation focused on the loci of authority, specifically the leaders of the group and Scripture. In the establishment of new strategies of actions for the Qumran sectarians, Scripture and the 129
Wuthnow, Meaning, 13–14. “Keep,” “learn,” and “practice” are all words used often in the Qumran texts with regard to the keeping of God’s “statutes,” “ordinance,” “commands,” and “words”; the Fourth Gospel uses strikingly similar language. 130
127
authoritative leaders play a special role. Clearly, the group considered itself subject to Scripture, called variously the word of God, the Law, the commandments, the words of his servants the prophets, or “that which is written.” In its break with the parent tradition, the Qumran sect did not attempt to downplay the role of Scripture; rather it viewed itself as those who take Scripture most seriously and adhere to what is communicated therein. Indeed, the group patently distinguishes itself as those who take Scripture seriously as opposed to the parent tradition, which is definitively characterized by its “rejection” of Scripture. Recall Wuthnow’s identification of the three dynamics at work when religious groups compete with one another: selective adaptation, isomorphism, and specialization. Selective adaptation concerns the “fit” between the group and its host environment; the Qumran community’s fit and the parent tradition’s fit in Roman Palestine appears to have been equal and requires no attention. Isomorphism has to do with the organizations having enough resemblance to one another to ensure a certain part of the available resources. The Qumran sect appears to have been a strictly Jewish phenomenon; its members came from a worldview previously shaped by the parent tradition. “Specialization” was achieved, at least in part, by the Qumran community’s commitment to reforming, purifying, and revitalizing the covenant community as indicated in Scripture. Hence, in presenting its views, the community readily argued that those views emerged from and were validated by Scripture. The authors all resolutely indicate that the sectarian community is Scripture’s telos. They typically “prove” that their views are in keeping with Scripture.131 Davies addresses the role of Scripture in the Qumran community: This state of affairs is misconceived if CD is dismissed as a mere ‘mosaic’ of quotations to which no evidential value may be attached. There are certainly numerous examples of biblical phraseology which must be regarded as unconsidered and even as only part of the author’s own biblically saturated vocabulary. But the cumulative force of the numerous quotations and allusions amounts to a statement that the ‘plot’ of CD can be read in the Bible: the community, the time in which it lives, its laws, everything is anticipated, described, regulated in 131 This aspect of scriptural usage has been commented on by myriad scholars usually under the rubric of “proof-texting.” See, e.g., Geza Vermes, “Biblical ProofTexts in Qumran Literature,” Journal of Semitic Studies 34/2 (1989): 493–508.
128
the Bible. The conclusion is forced upon one that not only is the Bible used by the community to present its appeal, but also that it was in the Bible in the first place that the community found its identity.132
The authors use Scripture to denote the centrality of Scripture. As noted previously, the relationship between the community and Scripture was symbiotic (a point which applies to any community, ancient or modern, which espouses a notion of scriptural authority). The community rests under the authority of Scripture but certainly influences how Scripture is interpreted by “closing down” possible meanings so that the “proper interpretation” becomes “evident and inevitable.” Leaders The “specialization” of the group does not end with Scripture, however. As will be seen in the cases of both the Branch Davidians and the Johannine community, it is Scripture as mediated through the authoritative leader or leaders of the group. 1QpHab uses Scripture to elevate especially the figure known as the Teacher of Righteousness, who makes only a slight appearance in CD’s scriptural interests and is absent from 4QMMT’s. Some may find this surprising given the febrile attempt to place him as the founder and primary leader of the sect and to compare his to the role of Jesus of Nazareth for Christianity. To be sure, we have included only evidence pertaining to the use of direct citations, so the inclusion of entire texts in our analysis might have secured him a more central role. Because he has engendered so much debate, a few words are in order regarding the Teacher of Righteousness. While the exact date, identification, and function of the Teacher of Righteousness continues to befuddle students of Qumran, no one would contest his significant role in the community and especially the authority wielded by him regarding biblical interpretation. Jesus enjoyed a similar authority in the community of the Fourth Gospel, as did David Koresh in the Branch Davidian community. Unlike the latter two groups, however, the Qumranians did not impute divinity to their teacher. In speaking of the authority of Mikra, Fishbane proposes a “twofold chain of authority: God and His authoritative spokesmen.”133 Mikra is 132 133
Philip R. Davies, “Eschatology at Qumran,” JBL 104 (1985): 55. Fishbane, “Use,” 360.
129
the revelation of God to which Moses and the Prophets attest. Next in line are the community’s teachers.134 The role of the teacher is highlighted in CD 6:10–11: “Without [the Staff of Instruction] they will not grasp [the meaning of the revelations of God] until there arises one who teaches righteousness in the end of days.” And in 1QpHab 2:1–9 we learn that “the true meaning of the ancient prophecies were not even known to the authoritative spokesman of God who revealed them in past times. Only through the interpretations of the Teacher will the community know of the final day and their ultimate vindication.”135 The same point is made in 1QpHab 7:1–2. 1QpHab attests to the special interpretive authority imputed to the Teacher of Righteousness. His words are to be believed because it has been given to him to unravel the mysteries set forth in Scripture; indeed, his interpretation is presented as coming from the “mouth of God.” His special revelatory relationship vis-à-vis Scripture is the cynosure of his authority. Because of this, not only should his words command belief, but he himself should be the object of fidelity. As is the case with the Branch Davidian and Fourth Gospel groups, the leader is shown to be especially righteous or chosen by God to fulfill his role. He is unjustly persecuted; he is privy to special insight regarding Scripture and other matters. In all three cases, that is, with the Teacher of Righteousness, Jesus, and David Koresh, the authors insist that to reject the leader is to reject the word of God or Godself and thereby to lose one’s salvation. While the three leaders mentioned occupy the central leadership roles for the groups studied, both the Qumran and Branch Davidian sects admit other, if lesser, authorities as well. So, 4QMMT never mentions the Teacher of Righteousness; rather, the halakic exhortations and rulings are handed down from the “we” who are indicated in the text. 1QpHab also allows room for a “priest” mentioned in 1QpHab 2:8–10. The Branch Davidians reserve an authoritative position for a number of previous leaders in the group’s history, but Koresh is the ultimate authority. The Fourth Gospel strictly eschews Jesus’ sharing authority with anyone, even John the Baptist.
134 135
Ibid. Ibid., 361.
130
Definition of the Future As noted already by Meeks and sociologists of sectarianism, sects require great sacrifice from their members. As a result, they must compensate by providing rewards and by providing a deep sense of belonging. Rewards can be envisioned as a present or a future phenomenon. One common reward among all of the groups under study here is that of salvation from God’s judgment. Both 1QpHab and CD concern themselves with the future, or, as 1QpHab denotes it, “the end time.” At that time, divine justice will be meted out and the sectarians will receive God’s favor, eternal life, all the glory of Adam (CD 3:20ff.), while the opponents of the group will not (1QpHab 7:9–14). One stands either with the sect or against the sect; one receives either God’s favor or disfavor; the Qumran authors envision no “middle ground.” Of course, eschatology and judgment go hand in hand. By proclaiming judgment the author exhorts the sectarians to continued faithfulness despite tribulation, retrieves those in danger of defecting, and insists that the apparent chaos and violence surrounding them from the parent religion and the Romans is not ultimate; rather, God’s sovereignty is to be trusted. The author takes the opportunity to inspire the faithful sectarians to endure by assuring them that salvation inheres only in the sect, whereas those outside will reap divine wrath. Scripture is used to portend this fate variously for non-sectarian Jews, sect-defectors, and pagans. Opponents Attention to the sect’s enemies is in order. First, because the sect seems to have developed over time, we must allow that the enemies in each era and/or each text might be somewhat different. In other words, the particularities of each text must be honored rather than harmonized under the rubric of a principal text which one has chosen as “the key text.” Having said that, one generalization supported by this study is that the most often and most vociferously denounced enemies of the Jewish sect are always other Jews, with the pagan world lagging behind substantially. Even when pagan opponents do appear, more often than not they are presented as agents of God’s divine wrath due to the treatment of the sectarians by the rest of Judaism. Campbell makes an observation which will apply to the Fourth Gospel as well:
131
With regard to the significance of the use of scripture in CD 1–8 and 19–20, we may go one stage further in view of the polemical air of much of the document. This adversarial tone, as already implied in our consideration of the sect’s supposed exilic origins, may profitably be related to conflicting claims in the second half of the Second Temple period truly to represent and continue ancient Israel’s traditions. Indeed, rival interpretations of revelation held in common among the various Jewish groups at this time have been highlighted by Vermes, whose own words we may borrow once more: “From the one body of sacred writings . . . and employing the same methods of interpretation, each evolved a distinct religious outlook and way of life in conflict, very often, with those of the others.”136
Numerous named enemies surface in the texts we have chosen. Realizing that various sobriquets may apply to an individual or a group, and that some of these may designate the same historical figure(s), we list the following: Wicked Priest, traitors, Man of Lies, SeekersAfter-Smooth-Things, Man of Scorn, Spouter of Lies, House of Absalom and its partisans, other Jerusalem priests, and all those who do not keep Torah precepts. The Romans and “the nations” occasionally appear as well. Recurring characteristics of the enemies include trafficking in deceit, violence, profanation of God’s name, disbelief, and apostasy. Notably, our Qumran authors (like the Fourth Gospel) can distinguish between “the people” and “rulers of the people” when speaking of both Jewish and Roman opponents.137 Parent Tradition By definition, sects stand in opposition to at least one other group, the parent tradition. Those of the parent tradition are most generally and often referred to as those who do not keep Torah precepts. Specific figures are also named. The Wicked Priest is an evildoer, proud, a deserter of God, a betrayer of the Law, greedy, inebriate, a robber, and the performer of acts of defiling impurity. The Man of Lies is primarily charged with rejecting the Law and not believing the words of the Teacher of Righteousness which were from the mouth of God, two of the most egregious offenses the author can imagine. He leads others astray (the same charge made against Jesus 136
Campbell, Use, 207. Campbell’s n. 79 refers us to 4QMMT as well. So, e.g., 1QpHab 3:9 speaks of “the Kittim,” whereas 4:5 refers to “the rulers of the Kittim.” 137
132
in the Fourth Gospel; John 7:12 and 7:47) subjecting them to deceit and falsehood and causing them to persecute the sectarians. CD 1:18ff. speaks of “the scoffer” who arose in Israel and caused people to stray so that the people became unjust, broke the covenant, and sought easy interpretations (also translated “seekers-after-smooththings”). The “House of Absalom and their partisans” are castigated primarily for their inaction rather than action insofar as they remained silent when the Teacher of Righteousness underwent persecution by the Man of the Lie in their midst. The author of the Fourth Gospel exhibits the same impatience with “fence-sitters” and indicates that one belongs to the sect and receives all due reward or one does not belong to the sect and receives all due punishment. Neither he nor the Qumran authors shows sympathy to those who try to occupy neutral ground. The last priests of Jerusalem, like other opponents, are characterized by their greed and injustice. Sect-Defectors Sects demand much of their adherents and they often lose members. Not only do many sects expect material, physical, and social sacrifices, all of them ask the new member to adopt a new worldview, to learn new strategies of action. In the case of Qumran, the authors indicate that they draw members from the parent Judaism. As such, the Qumran community would afford some common traditions and assumptions that would feel comfortable to the potential convert but at the same time would require a shift from the old worldview. In studying how culture functions in a high-ideology period, Swidler suggests that the group that is offering new strategies of action and patterns of organizing people is “in active competition with other cultural frameworks—at least in competition with common sense and usually with alternative traditions and ideologies as well.”138 That is to say, the Qumran community certainly competed with temple-based Jerusalem Judaism, which would have represented common sense, and it may also have found itself competing with other forms of Judaism as well.139 That the group did experi138
Swidler, “Culture,” 280. That Second Temple Judaism was marked by variety has become axiomatic, against the older view of a “normative Judaism.” How various the forms were depends in part on the angle one takes when investigating the groups. Regarding political 139
133
ence defection from the sect is indicated in the chosen texts. The authors castigate the defectors as “traitors” and those who did “not remain steadfast.” The authors clearly announce divine reward (life, blessings, salvation from the house of judgment) at some future day of judgment for those who remain faithful to the sect and condemnation (destruction, curses) for the defectors. The Fourth Gospel, through its particular concern for “abiding” in Jesus (of the one hundred twelve occurrences of m°nv in the , thirty-eight appear in the Fourth Gospel, twenty-three in 1 John, and three in 2 John), reflects a similar problem of sect-defection. Like Qumran, it offers “life” (zvÆ) and not a place in the house of judgment, but a room in God’s house ( John 14:2) as a reward for those who remain faithful despite suffering much tribulation on account of their membership in the group. The Branch Davidian materials exhibit the same problem and a similar solution. The “World” Of the Qumran texts chosen for scrutiny, only 1QpHab evinces any interest in what David Koresh and, perhaps, the Fourth Gospel call “the world”; i.e., those who belong to neither the sect, its defectors, or the parent tradition. 1QpHab, in its typical “double-code,” interprets Habakkuk’s Chaldeans as “Kittim,” which signifies the Romans. The reader may refer to the analysis at 1QpHab 2:12–14 for a full description of their vices, but the Romans are primarily defined in terms similar to those used against the other opponents: they are violent, greedy, proud, unjust, and deceitful. Like all of the other opponents, the author confidently consigns them to divine destruction on the day of visitation. Because of their identical (degraded) natures, it is only fitting then that God will use the Romans to destroy the Jewish opponents of the sect. The Romans are presented as a violent force in the land of Israel, annihilating everything in
attitudes, there were Jews who were avidly nationalistic as opposed to those who embraced a more cosmopolitan stance. Regarding issues of personal piety, Pharisees may have adopted temple piety into their own and advocated that others do the same. Regarding particular doctrinal considerations, there was some variety among different groups of Jews. We might categorize varieties of Judaism by taking class issues into account. At any rate, Second Temple Judaism was a complex phenomenon, and the Qumran community would have found itself having to take that into consideration when seeking members.
134
their path, but the author never indicates that the mighty forces had any particular cognizance of the small Qumran community. In this way the Romans differ from the opponents in Jerusalem who persecute the group qua sect. 1QpHab also mentions “the nations” but in a very stock way. They are idolaters who will receive destruction along with everyone else who does not belong to the Qumran community. Growing the Sect Like the Branch Davidian and Johannine communities, the authors of the Qumran texts looked to the parent tradition for new members. After all, all three saw themselves as the rightful and true incarnation of the parent tradition as indicated by Scripture. They all used Scripture to convince those who already lent Scripture authority that their group was the purified form of God’s covenant community. None of the Qumran texts chosen for study addresses the next generation. The same is true of the Fourth Gospel. The Branch Davidian materials show only very occasional and brief interest in the subject. Conclusion Sects are engaged in the production of culture, a production in which Scripture plays a key role and which is fundamentally shaped by the need to distinguish the sectarian culture from various external cultures, especially a parent tradition. That the sectarian Qumranians successfully created and maintained a community cannot be doubted given the fact that it seems to have perdured over time and created enough distinction for itself to be noticed by Josephus. Wuthnow suggests three requirements for the success of a religious group. It must: a) draw individuals into an intimate community; b) encourage them to worship; and c) provide them and their children with instruction. While none of the texts chosen for this study reveals concern for the instruction of children, they do demonstrate concern for the instruction of members and meet the other two criteria as well. All of the sociologists of religion cited in this study have called us to attend to the concrete social and historical circumstances in which a religious group functions to better understand the group. Swidler urges us to analyze “the structural constraints and historical cir-
135
cumstances within which ideological movements struggle for dominance.”140 She contends: Culture has independent causal influence in unsettled cultural periods because it makes possible new strategies of action—constructing entities that can act (selves, families, corporations), shaping the styles and skills with which they act, and modeling forms of authority and cooperation. It is, however, the concrete situations in which these cultural models are enacted that determine which take root and thrive, and which wither and die.141
For both Qumran and its parent tradition, those “historical circumstances” included operating under Roman rule and, finally, suffering destruction by the Romans. Jerusalem fell to the Romans and the temple was destroyed, but the tradition arose from the ashes, perhaps in the form of Rabbinic Judaism. On the other hand, the Qumran community appears to have been destroyed. Thus, it “lost” its competition with the parent tradition.
140 141
Swidler, “Culture,” 280. Ibid.
CHAPTER FOUR
THE BRANCH DAVIDIAN COMMUNITY
We are entering into a period of time where the Bible is gonna be understood by somebody. David Koresh Ezekiel 21:31: ‘I will pour out my indignation upon you, with the fire of my wrath I will blow upon you. I will deliver you into brutish hands, those skillful to destroy.’ The Lord destroys with fire these days. David Koresh People like dead religions. David Koresh
Introduction On April 19, 1993, the group known as the “Branch Davidians” was catapulted to momentary notoriety when the United States government smashed through the walls of the citizens’ residence1 with military tanks and released CS gas into the home, which was housing some eight-five children, men, and women, all the while shouting over a loudspeaker: “This is not an assault. This is not an assault.” Within minutes the so-called “compound” and seventy-four of its residents were consumed by flames. Twenty-one of the eighty were children, not including the two fetuses, one seven months and one full-term, which appear to have been born “as the result of an evolutionary reflex, instants after their mothers . . . expired.”2 Before the
1 This act alone killed six mothers and children who, according to Coroner Rodney Crow, were crushed and suffocated “from the falling concrete in the bunker that fell on them.” Among those crushed was one of the two pregnant women. Dick J. Reavis, The Ashes of Waco (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1995), 275. 2 Ibid., 277.
137
fire was fully extinguished, the Mt. Carmel flag was replaced with an ATF flag. For the most part, interest in the group lingers only in the occasional TV episode devoted to “cults”3 and among a small group of scholars. The main question posed by James D. Tabor and Eugene V. Gallagher appears in the title of their monograph: Why Waco? As one of the few scholarly accounts of the group known as the Branch Davidians and its conflict with the American government, the work attempts to set the sect in its historical, religious, and social contexts.4 Tabor asks, “Who were the 130 Branch Davidians living at Mt. Carmel in the spring of 1993, how had they come there, and why did they choose to stay, even if remaining there might lead to death?”5 Contrary to popular sentiment, the Branch Davidians were not a cult; that is, they were neither a “new” religious movement nor did they hail from some exotic land. They were strictly a homegrown phenomenon sown in the Millerite movement, watered in the SeventhDay Adventist church, blossoming under the leadership of Victor Houteff. Historically speaking, scholars trace the heritage of Koresh’s group to 1818 when a Baptist named William Miller concluded that the Second Coming would occur in 1844. It did not. Disciples responded variously to this “Great Disappointment,” and one group, under the leadership of Ellen G. White, who had heard Miller himself on more than one occasion, formed the Seventh-Day Adventist church (hereafter, SDA). White was privy to numerous divine visions and revelations upon which she based her teachings. Among those teachings were Saturday Sabbath keeping; abstinence from meat, alcohol, tobacco, and caffeine; and a belief in the imminence of Christ’s return. She proclaimed that, though 1844 did not see Christ’s return to earth, it was the occasion of Christ’s entering the Holy of
3 April 1999 saw the airing of an episode of “First Wave,” which featured an alien taking human form, attracting followers, imprisoning them within a compound, killing those who crossed the leader, and treating the women as a personal harem. The episode used the words “cult” and “deprogramming” and presented both Jim Jones and David Koresh as analogues. Such is the influence the anti-cult network has had on the media and, in turn, on the American mind. 4 See also Stuart A. Wright, ed., Armageddon in Waco: Critical Perspectives on the Branch Davidian Conflict (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1995). 5 James Tabor and Eugene Gallagher, Why Waco? Cults and the Battle for Religious Freedom in America (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1995), 23.
138
Holies in heaven where he cleansed the sanctuary in preparation for his second advent to earth, at which time only Adventists would receive salvation. White died in 1915, and her writings remain authoritative for Adventists. The General Conference has never validated a new prophet.6 In the late 1920s one devoted SDA by the name of Victor Houteff set about to reform the church which had become, in his estimation, too lax.7 William Pitts makes this astute comment: “As has been the case with the leaders of countless other sectarian movements in the history of the church, Houteff did not initially want to start a new denomination. Rather, he wanted to reform an old one; but the old one did not welcome his reform.”8 By 1935 the schism could not be bridged; Houteff had been excised from the church roll, and the group broke away under the name Shepherd’s Rod. During WWII it changed its name to the Davidian Seventh-Day Adventists in order to enjoy the rights afforded to the SDA church regarding conscientious objection. Tabor, echoing the sentiments of Pitts, summarizes the break this way: “Although Houteff had never intended to separate from the mother church, after he was forced out, his movement officially took the name Davidian Seventh-Day Adventists. . . . As time went on and opposition from the main body stiffened, Houteff began to view the Seventh-Day Adventists as a ‘heathen’ apostate group, in contrast to his own small band of followers, whom he identified as the ‘remnant’ true church.”9 Certain characteristics of Houteff ’s teaching and leadership style perdured throughout the group’s history, many of them especially prominent in Koresh’s reign. First, Houteff never considered himself or his group as anything other than Seventh-Day Adventists. He continually attempted to influence the denomination and drew his adherents from it. Second, he declared himself a prophet and insisted upon the notion of “present truth,”
6 For a brief history of the Adventist movement, see Bainbridge, Sociology, 89–118. Pp. 110–17 are devoted to the Branch Davidians. 7 Indeed, Victor Houteff would not have been surprised to find a prominent sociologist of religion say this in 1997: “Despite holding Sabbath services on Saturday and stemming from the same millenarian tradition as the Witnesses, the SeventhDay Adventists fit right into the standard Protestant tradition.” Bainbridge, Sociology, 110. 8 William L. Pitts, Jr., “Davidians and Branch Davidians: 1929–1987,” in Armageddon (ed. Stuart A. Wright; Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1995), 23. 9 Tabor and Gallagher, Waco, 35.
139
a continual unfolding and further revelation of the truth as presented in Revelation and Daniel, the two most central books of Adventism. His treatment of all of Scripture as an enclosed universe allowed him to ignore any borders between individual books of the Bible and freely to illuminate any verse of Scripture by drawing on innumerable other biblical texts. This constant blending of literal and symbolic readings left room for an infinite amount of “play” and adjustment of interpretation as events unfolded. This method allowed every line, every word, every symbol in the entire Bible to serve, on some level, as a coded indicator for the contemporary situation, often directly addressing Houteff and his group. Even in cases where a text had an obvious historical fulfillment or point of reference, it could always have a “double” hidden meaning, revealed only through the “spirit of prophecy.” Koresh employed precisely the same methods in his own exposition of the Scriptures, often to the utter bafflement of the FBI negotiators.10
The King James Version served as the authoritative biblical text for the group. Houteff continued Ellen G. White’s ethical requirements regarding vegetarianism, alcohol, and caffeine. He settled his group at a site they named Mt. Carmel, where they lived together, studied together, sent out missionaries and tracts, attempted to gather the 144,000 (as indicated in Revelation), and awaited the second advent of Christ. Upon his death in 1955 Houteff was succeeded by his wife, Florence. Notably, she does not figure in Koresh’s own version of the group’s history. Her tenure was quite brief and she made no lasting contributions to the group. She did set a particular date for the second Advent, April 22, 1959, which inspired about nine hundred people to sell all of their possessions and convene at Mt. Carmel to await the Parousia. The day comprised yet another disappointment, which sparked a number of splinter groups, one of which fell under the leadership of Ben Roden who added the “Branch” to the Davidian SDA name based on Isa 11:1, Zech 6:2, and a revelation that Roden received that he himself was the branch referred to therein. In addition, he claimed other branches would be associated with him, basing such a claim on John 15:1–3. For the most part, Roden simply built upon Houteff ’s work, though he emphasized more heavily the
10
Ibid., 36.
140
observance of Levitical feasts and the need to relocate the center of Adventism to Israel. He also injected new life into the anti-Catholic sentiments born in early Adventism. Ben Roden died in 1978 and was succeeded by his wife, Lois, only after she prevailed over her son George Roden in a battle for authority over the group. She continued the group in the same vein as earlier Branch Davidian prophets but provided the innovative teaching that the Holy Spirit is feminine. She died in 1986. Roden groomed as her successor Vernon Howell, a young Adventist who had joined the group in 1981 after being removed from the church rolls of his Seventh-Day Adventist church for causing dissension regarding his belief that the Adventist church had become corrupt and lax. Howell, too, had to contend with George Roden to assume leadership of the group.11 By 1988 Howell had ascended to unrivaled primacy, though he held de facto power as early as 1985. In 1990 Howell changed his name to David Koresh, the first name after King David and the cognomen after Cyrus, the Persian king and “christ” discussed in Second Isaiah. Koresh continued in the same vein as his predecessors, considering himself a prophet appointed by God, the recipient of divine revelations, and the final authority on scriptural interpretation. He inherited his exegetical technique from the former leaders, though his interpretation differed on a number of points, as we will see when we review his own teachings. His innovation lay in an unprecedented focus and concentration on unraveling the mysteries of the seven seals. He “corrected” the earlier leaders by showing that, though they thought they were about the business of gathering the 144,000, in actuality their responsibilities lay in different areas. This “correction” presents no problem for a group which embraces the notion of “present truth” and progressive revelation. His other innovation lay in his understanding of his role in building the House of David, which would rule in the millennium. On the basis of this, Koresh had sexual relations not only with his wife, Rachel, but also with many of the other women at Mt. Carmel, some married, some under legal age, and all with the consent of parents and husbands.
11 The details of the power struggle are unusual and interesting insofar as they include both a small gun battle between Roden and Koresh’s followers and a challenge from Roden to Koresh involving raising a corpse that Roden had illegally exhumed.
141
In 1993 the group came under attack, ostensibly because of weapons violations and accusations of child abuse. The latter charge has never been substantiated though investigated more than once. Popular sentiment assumes that the conflict regarding weapons centered on stockpiling them; in fact, it is not illegal in Texas to stockpile weapons, and the charge had to do with a technicality regarding the assembling of the weapons. The group was partially in the business of selling the weaponry at gun shows. This is not the place to provide details about the legality or the wisdom of the ATF raid, though I urge the reader to familiarize herself with the scholarly analysis of the facts. That consensus exists as to the catastrophic actions sanctioned by the government is obvious throughout the literature, the less restrained providing titles to their work such as “Killed by Semantics: Or Was it a Keystone Kop Kaleidoscope Kaper?” or “Did the G-men Sleep Through Soc 100?” and the more restrained entitling their works “Misguided Tactics Contributed to Apocalypse in Waco” and “Cult Label Made Waco Violence Inevitable.”12 Everyone, however, agrees with Nancy T. Ammerman’s judicious observations: After the disastrous BATF raid on the home of the Branch Davidians, as the FBI settled into their long siege and the world’s news organizations created a small village outside the perimeter, scholars of religion—with near unanimity—shook their head in collective disbelief at the strategies being adopted by federal law enforcement. Did they not know that a group was more likely to rally behind its charismatic leader than to surrender to his enemies? Did they not know that apocalyptic beliefs should be taken seriously, that they were playing the role of the enemies of Christ? Did they not know that any course of action that did not seem to come from the Bible would be unacceptable to these students of Scripture? Did they really believe they were dealing with hostages? I have yet to encounter a single sociologist or religious studies scholar who has the slightest doubt that the strategies adopted by the FBI were destined for tragic failure.13
In March 1993 Philip Arnold of the Reunion Institute in Houston went on the air (radio) and discussed the relevance of Revelation, Koresh’s primary text, for the Branch Davidians’ self-understanding. 12 All four articles are found in James R. Lewis, ed., From the Ashes: Making Sense of Waco (Lanham, Maryland: Rowman & Littlefield, 1994). The authors and page numbers are as follows: Moorman Oliver, Jr., 71–86; William H. Swatos, Jr., 201–4; Stuart A. Wright, 95–98; and Robert C. Hicks, 63–66. 13 Nancy T. Ammerman, “Waco, Law Enforcement, and Scholars of Religion,” in Armageddon, ed. Stuart A. Wright, 282–83.
142
Koresh heard the show on his transistor radio and requested that he be allowed to discuss Scripture with Arnold. The FBI denied the request but sent tapes of the broadcasts to the group. This prompted Arnold and James Tabor to develop a plan for communicating with Koresh. On April 1, 1993, they went on the radio and discussed the “prophetic technicalities of the Waco situation as it might be viewed by the Branch Davidians.”14 Koresh expressed pleasure that he had finally found biblical scholars who understood what he was trying to say, or at least spoke his language. The government did not capitalize upon this whatsoever. The night before the April 19, 1993 fire, Koresh began to write his document on the Seven Seals, after which he intended to come out. He did not, quite obviously, have the chance to finish it; however, he did make sure that what he had written made it to Tabor through one of his followers, Ruth Riddle. In keeping with Koresh’s wishes, Tabor has provided that material to the public.15 The conflagration ended the Koresh era of the movement. Eleven of the survivors have been incarcerated on conspiracy charges; others manage The Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, which distributes Koresh’s materials free of charge. To date, no new leader has arisen. This brief history has situated the group in its historical context, for, in one scholar’s words: “Only through an understanding of Adventist history can one ever hope to accurately comprehend Koresh within a meaningful context. The media and the federal government were satisfied with the generic label ‘cult’ leader, as if Koresh somehow existed outside time and place.”16 Tabor answers his own question, “Why Waco?” thus: scriptural interpretation and an apocalyptic worldview were central to this group and its leader, and this fact was never recognized or taken seriously by the negotiators, one of whom thought that Koresh meant aquatic animals when he referred to the Seven Seals. While some rely primarily on disaffected apostates from the group, Tabor interviews faithful Branch Davidians who survived the fire to discover why they followed Koresh and
14
Tabor and Gallagher, Waco, 14. For a more detailed history of the Branch Davidians, see Pitts, “Davidians”; see also David Bromley and Edward D. Silver, “The Davidian Tradition: From Patronal Clan to Prophetic Movement,” both in Stuart A. Wright, ed., Armageddon. See also Tabor and Gallagher, Waco, 23–51. 16 Tabor and Gallagher, Waco, 43. 15
143
lived in that community. Both the faithful and the apostates cite Koresh’s exegetical skills as the primary draw to the group. Scripture functioned as the central core of the Branch Davidians, whose quotidian Bible studies could occasionally last fifteen hours. These were people to whom Scripture mattered, for whom Scripture provided a symbolic worldview that approximated their experience. Initially, the group’s proselytizers attempted to interest these people in hearing Koresh, who was said to have great wisdom and skill in expounding the entire Bible, particularly the prophets and the book of Revelation, in a way that none could equal. Koresh’s entire efforts rested on the fundamental presupposition, sacrosanct through 150 years of Adventist history, that humankind was living in the last days, and that God’s true people would be guided by the voice of a living prophet. The crux of the Davidian claim was that no one could have the wisdom and skill that Koresh had in the Scriptures unless God had inspired him or her. Koresh viewed the parent body of Seventh-Day Adventists as apostate and corrupt. . . . The absolute center of life at Mount Carmel was the Bible studies that Koresh conducted for the group. He claimed that those who lived at Mount Carmel were exposed to his deeper teachings, which had never been revealed before. Within the group there was a sense that God was beginning to reveal more and more truth and understanding, and Koresh and his followers spoke of this with joy and exhilaration. The Davidians thought themselves to be on the absolute edge of God’s latest revelation regarding all the matters that would pertain to the final events of history and their own vital participation therein—and it was all being expounded to them through the mouth of David Koresh.17
Already the reader might notice some similarities with the Johannine community, and there are legion others. For instance, just as Jesus is the center of the message and the center of Scripture, so too is Koresh for this group: “You reject Cyrus, you reject God.”18 More than once in the Fourth Gospel John has Jesus claim that to know him is to know the Father and to reject him is to reject the Father. John’s community was rejected by its parent tradition though the community saw itself as the true and pure form of that tradition. It saw itself as standing against the “world”; likewise, the Branch Davidians, accused of brainwashing people, claim, “No, the truth is,
17
Ibid., 26–31. David Koresh, Ancient of Days, audiocassette transcript, June 14, 1986, as quoted in Tabor and Gallagher, Waco, 32. 18
144
it is the world that is brainwashed.”19 An analysis of the group at Waco promises to provoke interesting questions concerning John’s community.
Primary Sources The primary evidence for the role of Scripture in the life of the Branch Davidians comes from the cassette tapes of Koresh’s exegesis and the final written transcript given to James Tabor. I will analyze such data to ask how Scripture functioned in that group, providing identity and boundaries for the group, legitimating the authority of its leader, and prescribing particular ethics. Tabor prefaces his own attempt to do so with words somehow appropriate to the Fourth Gospel: “Koresh and his followers lived within a coded world of biblical language that created for them a sacred context they perceived to be concrete, systematic, and reliable. Those ‘outside’ had few, if any, clues to comprehending this world, so that the most technical and vital aspects of the group’s understanding of Scripture simply became ‘mumbo jumbo’ and ‘Bible babble.’”20 Most of the cassettes that feature Koresh undertaking scriptural exegesis are simply recordings of group Bible study or worship.21 A few find Koresh alone elucidating Scripture for the sake of those about to receive the tape, whether it be a group in Australia (see Letter to Australia) or Wisconsin (Letter to Steve Schneider and the Wisconsin Brethren). These electronic epistles serve as do Paul’s letters to the early Christian communities. They are composed not for the sake of a general audience but seek to shape a community with whom there is already a connection and a certain amount of shared knowledge and worldview. As the common saying among Pauline scholars goes, then, “It is like listening to one side of a telephone conversation.” The tapes have been entitled, though it is unclear who has chosen the titles.22 It should also be noted that of the twenty-four I
19
Ibid., 33. Ibid., 52. 21 At the time of my inquiry, The Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund offered twentyfour cassettes through its catalogue. Those are the twenty-four alluded to above. 22 Because the Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund maintains a catalogue from which anyone can order the materials, it may be that the titles were assigned for the sake 20
145
own, two are from 1984, three from 1985, four from 1986, eleven from 1987, none from 1988, and one from 1989. There is a gap from 1989 to 1993, and the only recording from 1993 is the March 2 radio broadcast conducted just after the February raid and just before the April destruction. Two are undated. The literary evidence consulted comprises The Decoded Message of the Seven Seals of the Book of Revelation, Daughters of Zion, Get Ready! The Message, Letter to Sister Smith, Letter to the Seventh-Day-Adventist Church, and Blow Ye the Trumpet in Zion, all downloaded from Mark Swett’s website. Though I have personally listened to them, I have relied upon Mark Swett’s transcriptions of Jonah, Judge What I Say, and Enter Into Rest—the Seventh Seal.23 Where I rely upon a transcript, I have indicated the name of the transcriber and the online location of the transcript; when I refer to the content of a sound recording, I indicate that by “audiocassette.” While I do not want to prematurely announce or provide a detailed summary of the similarities between the Branch Davidian and the Johannine evidence, it is useful to indicate some broad similarities and dissimilarities at the start. I suggest the following as points of similarity: 1) both express a concern for proper interpretation of Scripture; 2) both insist that only a privileged leader can execute such an interpretation; and 3) both are composed for a specific, already committed (albeit to various degrees) audience. But there are also points of dissimilarity. The Branch Davidian materials are abundant, they cover a period of nine years, they consist of both oral and written materials, and they contain materials directed to a variety of audiences. I distinguish four types of evidence and present them in descending order of priority: 1) that whose primary audience was the group residing at Waco; 2) that directed to Davidians residing elsewhere: Letter to Australia, Letter to Steve Schneider and the Wisconsin Brethren; 3) that directed to Adventists and lapsed Branches: Judge What I Say; and 4) that directed to complete outsiders including other denominations and “the world”: Radio Sermon and The Decoded Message of the Seven Seals of the Book of Revelation. I weight the materials composed
of ordering ease. The titles in the catalogue and those on the cassettes themselves do not always exactly agree. 23 Mark Swett maintains a website regarding Koresh and the Branch Davidians which is located at http://home.maine.rr.com/waco.
146
for the sake of the community most heavily because I consider the Fourth Gospel and the Johannine Epistles to be materials of that order. My interest in the Branch Davidian material lies in its potential for illuminating understanding of the Fourth Gospel.
Analysis of Primary Sources I now lay aside what outside observers suggest about the Branch Davidians and turn instead to the Davidians’ own understanding of themselves, always with a view to what function Scripture plays in encouraging particular self-understandings and discouraging others. I report on the salient concerns, themes, and techniques that repeatedly occur in Koresh’s exegesis and use of Scripture. Does Scripture function for this sect as I have hypothesized it might for sects in general? Formation of the Sect All scholars who provide a history of the sect’s emergence record its birth date as 1929, under the leadership of V. Houteff. Every comprehensive historical account begins with William Miller ca. 1818. The Davidians themselves, however, trace their history to a much earlier date. Koresh finds in the biblical texts, especially Revelation, clear reference to the group’s continually unfolding history. Rev 7 figures prominently in this and appears in most of the study sessions. I commence my explication of how Scripture is used to highlight and make certain claims regarding the group’s emergence with an interpretive example that showcases other aspects of Koresh’s techniques as well: “And after these things ( John says) I saw four angels standing on the four corners of the earth” (Rev 7:1a). These are the mysteries, these four angels here. “. . . holding the four winds of the earth, that the wind should not blow on the earth, nor on the sea, nor on any tree” (Rev 7:1b). Now inspiration revealed through the seventh angel’s message that seeing that 144,000 have not been sealed yet, and seeing that there must be four prophetic messages holding the strife from the world against the church, we have to look today for a present interpretation of who these four angels are. Now we know that all the messages from Enoch
147
all the way down to our day . . . well, let me back up. From Enoch all the way down to 1844, the judgment of the dead, all those messages are contained in Ellen G. White. Ellen G. White brought us the modern Israel of the day. Israel, Sabbath keeping people. That’s the third angel’s message. Now seeing that the Sabbath is still present truth, still present truth, and that the world is held accountable for knowing this true Sabbath, Saturday, that is one of the angels. But there is also another angel that joined the third angel that is important for the people to know about today, and that was Victor Houteff. His message was about the New Jerusalem. And then we had another message about the Branch name, the Branch He. That’s the other angel. But then to our surprise we have a sixth angel, Lois I. Roden, who brought us the Branch She message, who started revealing the mystery of Christ, the fullness of the Godhead bodily. Now these four angels Branches, use your senses, common sense, are the main four prophetic messages which the world is held responsible for today of knowing. Now remember, this is a revelation. And these messages hold, or keep the persecution of the world away from the church. And we also know something else, that another angel is ascending from the east. [The] east represents the old country but it also represents dry wind. Now notice, this angel comes and tells the four angels, “Do not hurt the wicked until we have sealed.” So right there people have always wanted to know when the 144,000 were going to be sealed. They’ve always . . . now wait a minute . . . Sister White was the first one who saw the vision of the 144,000. Her first vision was of the 144,000, so we know one of those four angels is Ellen White. Brother Houteff came teaching he was to seal them. And Brother Roden the same, and Sister Roden point blank says that her message is mainly for wave sheaf. So here’s another point. Wave sheaf is barley. We also know that Sister White, Brother Houteff, Brother Roden, Sister Roden, they never gathered the 144,000 to seal them. They’ve been gathering barley. Now, how do we know this? Remember, according to Ezekiel four, six grains, from Luther all the way to Ellen White, were to be combined into what? One barley cake. In other words, barley . . . Ellen G. White said that when all those who died under the third angel’s message would be resurrected in the special resurrection. So the third angel’s message gathered barley. And Victor Houteff came in Leviticus declaring to be the Vanguard, the first of the first fruits. So that right there, everyone who joined the Shepherd’s Rod became what? Not 144,000, they became wave sheaf, Vanguard. Then Brother Roden came declaring that all those who joined the Branch He message become what? Wave sheaf. And then Sister Roden comes along and point blank and teaches her message is to gather wave sheaf. So here we have four angels holding the winds, that the winds should not blow until the servants of God, the 144,000, the antitypical disciples of the day, are going to be sealed. So now it’s not until the angel ascends from the east, which would be the seventh angel. Let me
148
repeat now, Sister White’s the third, Brother Houteff is the fourth, Brother Roden is the fifth, Sister Roden is the sixth, and the angel ascending from the east is the seventh angel, the seventh angel saying, “Hurt not till we have sealed the servants of our God in their foreheads with the seal of the living God.” Who’s the living God? The Sabbath seal, the Sabbath seal. Now the question is, we have been taught the Branches may say, that Brother Houteff was the seal with the New Jerusalem and Brother Roden sealed with the Kingdom seal but now someone here now is teaching that they don’t have these seals and [that is] true. Let’s see what the Bible says. We turn to Revelation, chapter 14, where again this same subject is being brought to view.24
A number of points should be noted. First, Koresh’s interpretation, what he calls “common sense,” is comprehensible only within a specific privileged context, that is, the Branch Davidians under Koresh. In-group jargon abounds, including “inspiration,” “revelation,” “the 144,000,” “1844,” “present truth,” “Ellen G. White, V. Houteff, B. Roden, L. Roden,” “Branch He,” “Branch She,” “wave sheaf,” “antitypical,” and “the special resurrection.” This reflects the use of rhetorical techniques to effect inclusion or exclusion. Second, the Davidians are an elect, elevated group, “wave sheaf,” “first fruits,” “modern Israel.” Third, Koresh uses Scripture to interpret Scripture. In elaborating upon the four angels holding the four winds, he declares: “So the third angel’s message gathered barley,” drawing upon Ezek 4. Through the quotation and interpretation of a single verse, Rev 7:1, Koresh has managed to achieve a number of necessary ends. He has helped to create a sense of “us” by appealing to the group’s history and grounding it not only in the more recent past, but tracing it all the way back to Enoch. As a part of that history, he indicates that the founder of the sect (and most of its subsequent leaders) enjoyed special insight regarding Scripture. He also elevates “us” in at least two ways, one overtly and one covertly, the former via such laudatory sobriquets as “first fruits” and “wave-sheaf ” and the latter by adopting Ellen G. White, a figure who belongs to the Seventh-Day Adventist Church, as the sect’s own and connecting her with three of the sectarian leaders, Houteff, Roden, and Roden when presenting an interpretation of Rev 7:1. Unlike the scholarly
24 David Koresh, Judge What I Say, audiocassette recorded April 2, 1985. Transcribed by David Bunds. Online: http://home.maine.rr.com/waco.
149
presentations, the move from White to Houteff is seamless and smooth in Koresh’s own. The interpretation does more, though, than simply rehearse the group’s past, as indicated by the scriptural verse; it sets boundaries, establishes the loci of authority for the group, and encourages perseverance. In this single passage we find Koresh using Scripture, here Rev 7:1, to establish boundaries in two ways. First, he declares that one of the four angels is Ellen G. White, whose primary message had to do with keeping the Sabbath on Saturday. He thereby enjoins his followers to observe a Saturday Sabbath, expressing concern for ritual practice. Second, by using jargon he draws a line between insiders, for example, those who understand what is meant by the mere mention of 1844 or Branch She, and outsiders, who do not. This reflects the use of rhetorical techniques to effect inclusion or exclusion. By means of Rev 7:1 Koresh insists that Scripture stands at the center of the group. When a question arises, which here regards Koresh’s teaching that some of the former leaders were mistaken about their role in the ingathering of the 144,000, Koresh says, “Let’s see what the Bible says.” While Scripture certainly does enjoy elevated status, Koresh’s interpretation makes it clear that Scripture’s authority for the group depends upon “inspiration revealed through the seventh angel’s message,” which, as the sect knows, refers to Koresh’s own message. His authority prevails. Koresh begins his interpretation of the passage by indicating an imminent period of trial: “There must be four prophetic messages holding the strife from the world against the church.” Later he says, “And these messages hold, or keep the persecution of the world away from the church.” By this he means to say that each of the four angels named, White, Houteff, Roden, and Roden, was about the business of gathering the 144,000, after which the consummation of the eschaton would arrive. None of them achieved it, so the Final Judgment, the wind, has been held back so that the seventh angel’s message could accomplish the ingathering.25 The former leaders would 25 For the tyro, some confusion inheres in the numbering of the angels. There are seven angels with messages in Revelation. The four angels who appear in Rev 7:1 are the third, fourth, fifth and sixth angels, and they divulged their messages to White, Houteff, Roden, and Roden, respectively. The first two angels are both connected with William Miller; the first angel’s message was that preached by him prior to 1844 and the second was that preached after 1844.
150
not have seen themselves as the four angels of Rev 7:1 and clearly thought that they were, in fact, to gather the 144,000; it is only in hindsight, or with the aid of “inspiration,” “present truth,” and “new light,” that all of the group’s history up to Koresh has been placed in its proper perspective. Koresh’s message is the clarion call, and those who persevere will be “sealed.” By reviewing all of the primary sources one can compose a brief outline of the group’s self-presentation of its history. Note that Koresh clearly and unwaveringly identifies with Christianity in general and Adventism in particular. In the course of amply listening to and reading Koresh’s interpretation of Scripture, one pieces together Koresh’s view concerning how his group came to be. As he exegetes Jonah, we learn that it is a story of “movements who failed to progress into the ever unfolding ray of truth, the spirit of prophecy, God’s purpose on earth.”26 He quotes the first half of Amos 3:7: “ ‘the Lord God will do-’” and the group finishes it: “-nothing, but he revealeth his secret unto his servants the prophets.”27 It is a story of figures, prophets, arising in a denomination, insisting on reform among their brethren, having their message largely fall on deaf ears and, consequently, a new group developing.28 So, after centuries of “darkness”, which comprises the hegemony of the Catholic Church, Martin Luther appears and leads the Protestant Reformation. “They reformed in that they chose not to follow the heresies and the traditions of Rome, but to follow only the ‘thus saith the Lord’ as recorded in the word of God. Luther brought this out to them ‘the just shall live by faith as it is written,’ not as it is prelated through
26
David Koresh, Jonah, audiocassette recorded April 25, 1989. Transcribed by Mark Swett. Online: http://home.maine.rr.com/waco. Though Houteff might not have conceded Koresh’s point, Koresh declares that Houteff ’s movement “failed,” at least in part, and explains why that happened: “They did the same thing they’d been preaching against the Adventists were doing—consulting with flesh.” David Koresh, Ezekiel 21, audiocassette recorded October 19, 1984. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. 27 Amos 3:7 and Rev 10:7 comprise the most frequently completed Bible verses by the group. 28 This type of reasoning is evident in the following excerpt: “In 1929, the fourth angel came according to Rev 14:15. This message came to join the third angel of the dead—Ellen G. White’s message. This message came to announce the imminent judgement of the living. This movement was called The Shepherd’s Rod. It was given the greatest amount of light we’ve had heretofore. But folks were proud and arrogant so God took another route—the Branch Davidians. To begin the judgment at the house of God was to begin with the Davidians” Koresh, Ezekiel 21.
151
the prelates, huh?”29 Though Luther “didn’t have all the light,”30 he “faithfully gave his message to the Nineveh of that time.” The Catholic Church rejects Luther’s message and the Lutheran church is born. Luther dies and the next prophet to arise is John Knox. As the “new ray of light” he attempts to reform his Lutheran brethren teaching that one must be born again by the agency of the Holy Spirit as testified to in Scripture. The Lutherans reject Knox and Presbyterianism is born. Wesley arises and exhorts the Presbyterians. “The Methodists had to finally become the Baptists, and the Baptists become the Adventists, and the Adventists become the Seventh-Day-Adventists.”31 The Adventists grew out of the Baptists insofar as William Miller, the founder of Adventism, was a Baptist. Often Koresh alludes to what “we as Adventists” know, believe, or do. For example: “We as Seventh-Day Adventists we might be more blind than we think. We might be more judgmentive [sic] of others and we need to judge ourselves a bit more”;32 or, “We know as Adventists we have the judgment message;” or, “What is truth? What is this message to the Laodicean church of which I, being a Seventh-Day Adventist, I know I’m a part because our denomination proclaimed the judgment according to Daniel’s prophecies?”33 Koresh sees the Branch Davidians as the continuation and perfection of the Reformation.34 In keeping with the observation made by sociologists of sectarianism, Koresh sees his group not as outside Christianity or Seventh Day Adventism but as a purified form of them, the genuine expression of what they call for. At the same time, he does recognize that his group constitutes a small, contentious part of these larger bodies. Koresh prefaces his explication of “the marriage feast” by saying
29
Koresh, Jonah. His dietary habits indicate that Luther still lacked some light. Koresh asks the group how Luther died and they answer, “Overeating.” He confirms that Luther “didn’t know how to regulate his mouth, did he? That had not yet been given to him yet, huh? Back in those days when you used to be sick, do you know what they prescribed to you? Food! You got a bellyache you need to eat some food. Any kind of pain in the stomach was you were hungry. Dark days in those days.” Koresh, Jonah. The Davidians, as Adventists, consider dietary habits an important part of the religious life, as we shall see further when discussing the group’s ethics. 31 Koresh, Jonah. 32 David Koresh, What is Truth?, undated audiocassette. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. 33 Tabor and Gallagher, Waco, 48. 34 David Koresh, Ezekiel 47, audiocassette recorded November 11, 1984. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. 30
152
that when people hear the explanation, “you’ll know why our little group is in so much trouble all the time.”35 Regarding his “little group,” Koresh originally taught that the group was living during the sixth seal and within that seal are four angels, White, Houteff, Roden, and Roden. In the latter part of his tenure, Koresh would claim that the seventh seal was being revealed via himself. For example: In other words, we want to know who the Lord’s feet are according to Zechariah 14. So therefore, if Uzziah represents Victor Houteff then Jotham must represent Brother Roden and Ahaz Sister Roden and then Hezekiah must also represent the seventh angel’s message. In other words we’re taking from Brother Roden’s writings and showing that Victor Houteff was Uzziah, then Jotham would be Brother Roden. Sister Roden would be Ahaz and Vernon Howell, the seventh angel’s message, would be Hezekiah.36
Though he traces the group’s history ultimately back to creation down through the Reformation, the period from White to Koresh commands the majority of discussion regarding the group’s history. As noted above, Koresh often chooses Rev 7 for study and rehearses the group’s history by interpreting Rev 7:3. Now remember these four angels here are standing on the four corners of the earth and they have power to hurt don’t they? That means their message has come, has been rejected, and now they have power to hurt. Now this angel who is ascending from the east has the seal of the living God. Who are these four messages—these four angels? It should be very simple. The only message that we’ve ever had as pertaining to judgment that deals with the 144,000—the first message that is, was contained in the third angel’s message, the Sabbath. The Sabbath seal, or the third angel of 1844, contains all the truth from creation to the time of Christ. And the third angel’s message was a review of that history, so that all the world would realize that the judgment for the dead had begun. The first vision that Ellen G. White had was of the 144,000. That’s simple isn’t it? Now if that interpretation is true then we should easily be able to see that as far as the world is concerned today; what four messages is all the earth responsible for? Well, the message of the Sabbath, the message of the Kingdom, the message of the new name both he and she. In other words, we
35 David Koresh, Voice of Fire, audiocassette undated. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. 36 Koresh, Judge.
153
see these four angels as Sister White, Brother Houteff, Brother Roden, and Sister Roden.37
In Koresh’s scheme, as in all Adventist interpretations, William Miller conveyed the first two angels’ messages, the first in 1833 and the second prior to 1844.38 On October 22, 1844, Christ entered the celestial Holy of Holies and at that time the judgment of the dead occurred. Also in keeping with Adventism, Ellen G. White represents the third angel’s message, which largely teaches the observance of a Saturday Sabbath. Koresh presents White as simply the next step in the unfolding Christian, meaning Adventist, meaning Branch Davidian, history: “Ezekiel 4 tells us that the third angel’s message consisted of six grains—six grains: Luther, Knox, Wesley, Campbell, Miller, White. But they were combined into what kind of cake? A barley cake. Branches, what is barley? Wave sheaf.”39 Victor Houteff offered the fourth angel’s message, which Koresh often refers to as the New Jerusalem. While all secondary sources trace the emergence of the Branch Davidian movement to V. Houteff in 1930 and indicate it in terms of a crucial disjuncture, Koresh once again moves immediately and smoothly from Ellen White to V. Houteff in his rehearsal of the group’s “myth of origins”: “Only those who joined the third angel’s message, who died when Sister White was alive, will be resurrected as wave sheaf. But when Brother Houteff came in 1930, he came to seal with the Sabbath seal . . . . Those who were Adventists, who joined the Shepherd’s Rod, became true Sabbath keepers and they received the Sabbath seal.”40 In fact, Koresh depicts a seamless history from the to the present. Each successive stage represents further progress and “light” so that no earlier phase of Christianity enjoys a privileged status. Take, for example, his attitude toward Miller’s message in relation to Paul’s: “So William Miller’s message was just as much a part of the gospel as Paul’s message, wasn’t it? Those who rejected William Miller couldn’t be saved.”41 37
David Koresh, The Seventh Angel—Enter Into Rest, audiocassette recorded on January 31, 1985 in Jerusalem. Transcribed by Mark Swett. Online: http://home. maine.rr.com/waco. 38 David Koresh, Confusion, Part I, audiocassette recorded July 18, 1987. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. 39 Koresh, The Seventh. 40 Koresh, Judge. 41 Koresh, Confusion, Pt. 1.
154
Florence Houteff, who succeeded Victor Houteff, does not factor into Koresh’s version of the group’s history. Rather, he skips to Ben Roden as the bearer of the fifth angel’s message, which he usually refers to as the Branch He message. Lois Roden related the sixth angel’s message “revealing the mystery of Christ, the fullness of the Godhead bodily.” Branch She42 is the shorthand for Lois Roden’s addition of the feminine to teachings on God. While occasional reference is made to George Roden’s unjustified attempt to seize leadership of the group, he is never depicted as anything but an imposter. The group history moves from Lois Roden to Koresh’s own era of leadership, at which time the seventh, and last, angel’s message is revealed. That message primarily concerns the opening and interpretation of the seven seals, which reveals the final and ultimate truth about all matters, especially history, the restoration of the House of David, the meaning of Scripture, the solution to scriptural puzzles, and the nature and imminence of the apocalyptic eschaton. David Koresh’s ministry represents the time when the 144,000 would be gathered: “1985, the ministry begins and the sealing of the 144,000 is to start.”43 Thus, Scripture functions prominently in the retelling of the group’s history in at least three related ways. First, in the Davidians’ estimation, Scripture itself points forward to and adumbrates the group’s history. Second, the twentieth-century group looks back to Scripture and views itself in light of it. Finally, Scripture is used as an excuse to rehearse the group’s history. In other words, while the ostensible goal of a Bible study is simply to interpret correctly whatever Scripture is at hand that day, the choice of Scripture to interpret as well as its fittingness for presenting the group’s history is no accident. In this way, Koresh uses Scripture to build an identity for his group and the individuals who comprise it. He instills a bold confidence
42 The Branch “He” and the Branch “She” stem from a twofold observation. First, Ezek 36:8 refers to the mountains of Israel shooting forth their branches. Second, the Gospels contain the parable of the fig tree, a judgment parable in which “Matthew says the branch he, Mark says the branch she, and Luke tells us, learn the parable of the fig tree and all the trees” [italics mine]. Koresh, Judge. It is true that the KJV translates ı klãdow aÈt∞w “his” branch at Matt 24:32 and “her” branch at Mark 13:28, but why it ascribes a masculine translation to a feminine possessive remains a mystery. At any rate, like Rabbi Akiba and others, Koresh finds significance in such details. 43 Koresh, Judge.
155
in this afflicted minority community so that, equipped with the certain knowledge that they are a privileged, elect group, they might persevere and abide with the group. Like the Qumran sect, the Branch Davidian situation corroborates Wuthnow’s claims about the importance of constructing and relating a group’s collective history: “These, like our individual stories, are perhaps myths that reconstruct the past and have minimal connections to actual history, yet they play a powerful role in making the sacred concrete. They do so by making it public, visible, so it can be internalized into the consciousness of individual members.44 Former Leaders and Their Works Koresh does more than list former leaders in his recounting of the group’s history; he also refers to their teachings as authoritative. For instance, while interpreting Ezek 21 Koresh claims, “And the only plan of salvation there is is contained in the everlasting gospel presented by William Miller. . . . You’ll also find that same gospel continued on by Ellen G. White, picked up again by Brother Houteff, also found through Brother Roden’s message. Sister Roden’s. And there is a seventh angel too.”45 Like all Adventists, Koresh often invokes the teachings of “Sister Ellen G. White.” At least as often he quotes the sect’s founder, “Brother Houteff ” who, like White, produced numerous writings. For example, “Our study aim—in the message of The Loud Cry—is to find out who are the foolish virgins. As we learn in 2nd Shepherd’s Rod 185, Brother Houteff says they’re the ones who had confidence in men. They saw no necessity for more light, more prophets, truth, or a message.”46 Elsewhere he narrates the group’s history as shown in Revelation and says this of Houteff: “In 1929, the fourth angel came according to Rev 14:15. This message came to join the third angel’s message of the dead— Ellen G. White’s message. The message came to announce the imminent judgment of the living. This movement was called The Shepherd’s Rod. It was given the greatest amount of light we’ve had heretofore.”47 It is clear from the cassettes that the group uses charts composed
44 45 46 47
Wuthnow, Producing, 61. Koresh, Ezekiel 21. Koresh, The Seventh. Koresh, Ezekiel 21.
156
by Houteff and successive Davidian prophets. The following quote, whose context is an interpretation of Ezek 47, indicates both the use of such charts and the fact that Koresh views the leaders as Christ figures: Brother Roden hasn’t reaped the 144,000, though he will. Because he as Christ and Brother Houteff as Christ and all those from the third angel’s message on will be resurrected as Christ was resurrected to finish the work, to gather the 144,000. To prove it, Brother Houteff shows on the ceremonial chart he shows from 31 .. on the wave sheaf offering. And in 1844 the door was opened and he shows, what’s the symbol up there? Barley. Proves it to the tee doesn’t it?48
He alludes to the Rodens’ work rather than quoting them verbatim. For instance, “Sister Roden used to tell us that the days of creation was a compacted prophecy.”49 All of these examples attest to the group’s leaders as loci of authority and those that showcase Houteff show the sect’s founder to have special insight regarding Scripture. As important as they are, none of these writings enjoys the same level of authority as Scripture, and each is considered enlightened only insofar as possible given the limitations and constraints imposed upon it by virtue of its place in the progressive revelation of truth. So, in referring to White’s work, “The Great Controversy,” he cautions his listeners: “Sure, take ‘Great Controversy,’ read it through, but Ellen G. White will tell you point blank that she didn’t have all the light.” Loci of Authority Scripture Studying Scripture’s function within a group from a sociological perspective always involves a twofold task: (1) to understand how the group itself describes the role of Scripture in its midst and (2) to understand how an outsider might view the role of Scripture in the group. Anthropologists designate the former the “emic” function of Scripture and the latter the “etic” function of Scripture, but only with certain qualifications. First, the emic and the etic may coincide; second, the etic may be considered an addition to the emic rather
48 49
Koresh, Ezekiel 47. Koresh, The Seventh.
157
than a denial of it; finally, where the emic treads on holy or supernatural ground, the etic cannot follow insofar as sociology and empirical analysis are inherently limited to natural ground. The overwhelming conviction presented in the exegetical tapes is that Scripture is the inviolable source of all truth. Quoting John 10, Koresh announces: “The law [by which Koresh means to indicate “Scripture”] cannot be broken.”50 Without question, Scripture stands at the center of the group’s activity and identity. Koresh conducted lengthy quotidian Bible studies, and the most common reason given by converted Davidians for why they chose to join the group was Koresh’s command, understanding, and ability to elucidate the Scriptures. Koresh continually emphasizes the centrality of Scripture: “How did Christ overcome? Well, I know one thing—Christ overcame through scripture. It is written. It is written. It is written. Christ also overcame through prophecy which was written.”51 And again, “Christ is quite well-versed in the scriptures . . . always referring, ‘It is written, it is written, it is written’ when he comes up against the devil.”52 He says, “God will have a people who will uphold the Bible and the Bible only.”53 After recapitulating Rev 8:1ff., Koresh warns his listeners: “You better start looking for the angel from the east who’s coming to gather.” The angel is going to seal 144,000 then a “great multitude.” The seventh seal opens and one finds “an angel at the altar only for those who know the truth. He has a censer for the saints. Saints believe in God’s word. They know what truth is. They believe God’s word.”54 By this statement, Koresh implies that Scripture and truth are coextensive so that what is said about one applies to the other. “What is truth? Well, let me tell you, the Lord is truth. He’s the Word. Look at this book—is it truth?” Truth saves: “Truth that doesn’t save you is gonna hurt you. The truth you don’t listen to is gonna 50 David Koresh, Radio Sermon, audiocassette recorded March 2, 1993. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. Koresh quotes John 10:34–35 very quickly. In 10:34 Jesus says, “Is it not written in your law, I said, Ye are gods?” The quote is actually not from the Pentateuch but from Ps 83, indicating that the fourth evangelist used the word “law” rather loosely. I believe Koresh simply misquoted 10:35 which says, “scripture cannot be broken” accidentally because of the presence of “the law” in 10:34. At any rate, he clearly intends to quote the verse and clearly means “Scripture.” 51 Koresh, What is Truth? 52 Koresh, Radio Sermon. 53 Koresh, What is Truth? 54 Ibid.
158
hurt you. No ostrich games in God’s kingdom. . . . People today are not really concerned about truth.”55 In Koresh’s teaching, truth is closely bound to judgment and exists in unexpected form: “The prophecies teach something contrary to any human planning.”56 Scripture is the basis for all that the community says and does. “Being Christian, our foundation is supposed to be the Bible. . . . I’m building up to this point: we’re supposed to be Christians who are founded upon a sacred parchment known as the Bible which is a record of men who have gone before.”57 There is a war being waged and Scripture is a weapon, a sword: “The sword is a message that comes not to the world to destroy the wicked but to destroy or save the wicked in the church.”58 Who is the slayer of Ezek 21:11? Koresh asks. He answers: “Paul tells us that the word of God is a two-edged sword. The word of God given to a messenger is the same as giving a man a sword in a battle to obtain a victory.”59 When he refers to Paul’s words about the sword, Koresh must have Heb 4:12 in mind, implying that he assumes Paul wrote it. We should not be surprised to find Koresh picking up the sword theme in Ezekiel and Paul because, of the thirty-seven times the word appears, eleven are found in Revelation, Koresh’s favorite book. Of those eleven, six refer to the words that come from Jesus’ mouth (1:16, 2:12, 2:16, 19:15, 19:21, 19:21). Revelation is the Alpha and Omega of all of Koresh’s exegesis; it is the preeminent, ultimate canon within the canon. Next in respective order of importance stand Daniel, other prophetic texts, and then the remaining texts, but they hold significance only insofar as they illuminate Revelation. “You need to understand the full meaning of each passage of scripture, of the prophecies, and its relationship to the book of Revelation. This is the only way that we can have a complete understanding of prophecy and revelation and the way that they both work together. I’m sure we can all agree on this.”60 Koresh inherited this rating of the various texts directly from his predecessors, who received the tradition from Adventism itself.
55 56 57 58 59 60
Koresh, Koresh, Koresh, Koresh, Ibid. Koresh,
What is Truth? What is Truth? Voice of Fire. Ezekiel 21. The Seventh.
159
He admits that people often ask him why he does not “talk about the gospel. How come you always want to talk about prophecy?” His response: Well, you see, prophecy, Peter tells us, is a light that shines in a dark place. Now, how would you have liked to have been Cyrus the King of Persia who came according to prophecy, and understood the prophecies, and demanded that Gath be returned to the land, and yet they did not because they did not fully understand the prophecies? How would you like to have been Alexander the Great who died a death because simply he was fulfilling prophecy, and knew not the day of his visitation? How would you like to be the Jews, who did not fully understand the significance of Daniel chapter nine so that when the Messiah came, he found them unprepared for his gospel, and yet today, we ourselves are in a period of time where we don’t even understand the prophecies?”61
Because one’s salvation depends upon it, knowledge or ignorance of prophecy is no trivial matter. In exegeting Rev 10:7, Koresh turns to Dan 12:1 for illumination: “And at that time shall Michael stand up, the great prince which standeth for the children of thy people: and there shall be a time of trouble, such as never was since there was a nation [even] to that same time: and at that time thy people shall be delivered, every one that shall be found written in the book.” Koresh then warns: Now brethren, honestly before God. If we do not know the events that are foretold by Christ’s own testimony, which Revelation 19 tells us—“the testimony of Jesus Christ is the spirit of prophecy”—then we can be assured that our name is not in that book, because how can we fulfill that which we know not? The Pharisees fulfilled prophecy. They killed the Son of God, did they not? They did, because they knew not the truth pertaining to the events of their day.62
He also turns to Joel to elucidate Rev 10:7 and reiterates the importance of understanding biblical prophecy: Let’s look into the book of Joel and see what wisdom God has placed there that we might understand these things; as God has given each messenger a portion of the truth we must harmonize each prophecy
61 David Koresh, Letter to Steve Schneider and the Wisconsin Brethren, audiocassette recorded in 1987. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. 62 Ibid.
160
of the Bible that we may know the whole truth and be prepared to be delivered, because we are written in the book. If we are the ones who fulfill prophecy in these days then it is God who has spoken of us long ago that through the writings of the prophets God may foreknow us by the spirit of prophecy. If we do not fulfill God’s word we are not written in this book, but if we fulfill that which is written we are in God’s book as a surety, we are children of light.63
He himself indicates that the preoccupation with Daniel and Revelation stems from the Adventist movement. In other words, he did not invent the focus on those texts. One cassette opens with a song entitled “Understand,” which exhorts: I got a secret that I’d like you to understand; see the Book there in the angel’s hand; the book of Daniel’s got a message, a message for you. See the angel with a book in his hand, the book of Daniel, it contains the eternal plan, seven thunders won’t you see, won’t you listen to me, we’ve got the key.64
He claims that “Daniel fits hand in hand with Revelation because Daniel also includes all the other prophecies.”65 If we imagine a set of concentric circles with Revelation at the very center, the next circle would consist of Daniel, followed by the prophetic texts in general and, finally, parts of non-prophetic books which contain prophecy. The following statement is not atypical for Koresh: “Now look at ya. You mean to tell me you don’t know what the prophecies teach in the Old Testament? You don’t know what Isaiah 2 or Micah 4 teaches? Or Jeremiah 36 or Jeremiah 30? You don’t know what Ezekiel 36 or Zechariah 2 teaches? You mean to tell me you don’t know who that mighty army of Joel 2 is? Or of Isaiah 5? Who’s that bird in Ecclesiastes 12? What is the fall of Babylon according to Isaiah 13? . . . You don’t know what happens in Daniel 11 or 12?”66 Elsewhere he prods, “What does Isaiah say about it? What does Malachi? What does Ezekiel? What does Amos? Hosea [which he pronounces Ho-she-a]? Zechariah?” Or, “Do the prophets have
63 64 65 66
Ibid. Koresh, Voice of Fire. Koresh, What is Truth? Ibid.
161
the mystery written within their pages? Isaiah 2; Micah 4; Ezekiel 36; Zechariah 2? Do they relate to Revelation 11?”67 At times Koresh invokes less prophetic books, but uses them only to pull out material related to prophecy. So, he turns to 2 Peter, but the only aspect that interests him is the prophetic one. After reading 2 Pet 1:15, he explains that Peter is “fixin’ to die.” He then reads vv. 16–21. Commenting on v. 19, he says, “Prophecy is like a light that shines in darkness.” In an interpretive move that downplays the authority of apostolic witness and moves the spotlight to biblical prophecy, Koresh interprets Peter’s words, “So we have the prophetic message more fully confirmed,” this way: “Prophecy is an even more sure word than Peter’s own eyewitness.” He draws attention to the mention of “daystar,” which points to the future coming of Christ. He concludes his interpretation of the section with this assertion: “Since God can’t lie, all the prophecies must harmonize.”68 Koresh has an unwavering conviction that “prophecy relates to the future.”69 Early in his teaching he placed his community in the period of Revelation’s sixth seal, though later he would locate them at the beginning of the seventh. “You know the first cases to be judged are those who died in the flood. You know that as well as I do. And you know the seals represent judgments or truth that God has sent to the world since the beginning of the world, since Adam’s time. The sixth seal is our period of time. You know that. Doesn’t take a nit-wit to know those kinda things. But the key is, what do the symbols actually teach? Well, there’s an answer and it’s very clear.”70 Before leaving the topic of Scripture’s role as attested to by Koresh himself, it is important to note that only the King James Version suffices as the authoritative text for interpretation: “[S]tay with the King James and the original renderings but not these modern ones, you know, go with the original King James.”71 Again, Koresh inherited this contention from his predecessors. According to their self-presentation, the Davidians were a scriptural people. They spent a vast amount of time studying it, seeking to 67
Ibid. Koresh, Voice of Fire. 69 Ibid. 70 Koresh, What is Truth? 71 David Koresh, Root of Jesse, audiocassette recorded August 27, 1987. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. 68
162
understand it, and conforming to it. If Geertz is right that culture comprises “the publicly available symbolic forms through which people experience and express meaning,” then Scripture is the most potent cultural element for the group. These were not people who accommodated themselves to the host environment six days a week and made room for the rather odd world of Scripture once a week. For the Davidians, a group whose high degree of tension with its surrounding culture persisted for the course of its existence, Scripture was an absorbing state. The numerous examples given in this section attest to the primacy of Scripture’s authority for the Branch Davidians. Leader Koresh’s Authority To say that Scripture enjoys an authoritative position for the Branch Davidians is correct as far as it goes, but it lacks nuance. Repeatedly the centrality of Scripture is asserted, but nowhere is blind, unquestioning acceptance of it counseled. Quite the contrary. Koresh says: “See why we’re supposed to read the Bible? To see if these things really happened. That’s why the book was written—to judge these men. To see if they be of God or not.”72 Scripture stands under judgment by the group (“we’re supposed to read the Bible”). That is the first note of nuance. Such a proclamation may lead the listener to the assumption that this degrades the authority of Koresh himself as interpreter, that what we have here is the notion that any faithful believer (i.e., member of Koresh’s group at Mt. Carmel) is capable of exacting such judgments, but such is not the case. An extended exchange between Koresh and a potential Branch Davidian reveals, inter alia, that Koresh alone owns the right “to judge these men.” Our second note of nuance, then, is that, much like the Fourth Gospel, it is not Scripture itself which is authoritative, but Scripture as interpreted by the divinely inspired leader of the community. As a corollary, the “we” who are advised to read the Bible and see if it approximates history is not a group of individuals who have undertaken personal studies and then convened to discuss their insights in hopes of arriving at a consensus, but rather a “we” with Koresh at the head leading the group 72 David Koresh, The Assyrians, audiocassette recorded January 10, 1987. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX.
163
qua group into “light,” as he often calls it. Conformity to Koresh’s own interpretation constitutes attainment of truth. So, while Scripture indeed enjoyed a central role at Mt. Carmel, it did so only as interpreted by David Koresh. He alone retained absolute authority over every aspect of life at Mt. Carmel, including the proper understanding of Scripture. Koresh exerts control, elevates his own authority, and puts members in their place all the while doing so in the context of scriptural interpretation. While interpreting Zephaniah, for example, Koresh is teaching about Assyria. A man raises his hand and Koresh says, “Yes, David?” and the exchange proceeds as follows: David: “Manasseh paid tribute to the king of Assyria.” Koresh: “Yes, he did.” David: “He was taken captive and taken to Babylon . . .” (at this point, Koresh talks over the top of him) Koresh: “But again, that title, the scholars have put that title of Assyria. He was taken where again David? You already answered your question. He was taken to Babylon. What was he taken to Babylon for?” David: “Babylon had not conquered Assyria at that time.” Koresh: “Yes they had. Yes they had.” David: “Assyria fell in 612 ..” Koresh: “Yes, that’s what the historians tell us, but there’s somethin’ I know that y’all don’t know yet.” At this point, Koresh turns to an amalgamation of Chronicles, Daniel, and Revelation, commencing with this comment: “Now, inspiration recently revealed—now, I don’t mean to throw our understanding of history away, but I’m just saying we have to understand something more clearly than any scholar has ever understood.” He goes on to ask whether Dan 7:8–9 concerning the little horn head has occurred yet. The group answers in the negative and Koresh confirms it, saying: “No, but Zephaniah is telling us about this event. See what I’m saying, David?” Apparently David remains unabashed because later in the study Koresh asks, “Now, you still with us David? Huh? Are you understanding this or are you having a problem over there?” To which David responds, “I don’t agree with that.” At this point Koresh assails him: “I know you don’t, but I don’t agree with the way you’ve been doin’ your past few weeks here either. I mean,
164
you know, we’ve been talking in the past few years about inheritance and things like that. I’m here to warn ya. We’ve had this experience over and over again. God’s a little bit wiser than what we are and our human wisdom is gonna end up as ashes one of these days.”73 Again, David persists; this time he requests further clarification of Koresh’s assertion that “The Assyrians were the ancient Americans,” asking whether Koresh means that literally or symbolically. Koresh interrupts him and charges: “You’re not listening. I’ve been explaining it here for the past five minutes,” and goes on to exegete a passage of Daniel for him after which he declares, “You see, we’ve been having studies every day some of us here, right? So David and the Bonds are at a disadvantage because this is a very unique subject we’ve been opening up.” Strict boundaries are drawn between those who “understand” and “know” (language used by the Fourth Gospel for the same purpose) and those who do not. Elsewhere Koresh phrases it this way: “Not all of us here have the same knowledge of the truth.”74 Another lengthy exchange between Koresh and a visitor to the group whose sister appears to be a member provides a further example. Troubled by Koresh’s suggestion that he alone can interpret Scripture, she asks if it is not the case that God, by the power of the Holy Spirit, reveals things to the individual who earnestly studies. He responds negatively. At that point, a man asks, “Only you can give it?” to which Koresh replies with his own question: “Does that offend you?” The woman persists and Koresh peremptorily declares: “You may not, by asking God, understand the mysteries of God. God will do nothing but reveal his secret to his servants the prophets. Should you, should you receive an enlightened message from God then you’ll be sittin’ here and I’ll be sittin’ out there.”75 The woman chooses to leave, which Koresh says, “happens all the time.” Like his predecessors, Koresh claimed exclusive authority on the basis of his prophetic office, an office won not by human election but by divine designation. In this role, Koresh was privy to various genuine revelations.76 “But by the mercy of God, God allowed me
73
Ibid. Ibid. 75 Koresh, Confusion, Pt. 1. 76 As opposed to those that are invalid. For instance, referring to a book esteemed by some Adventists, Daniel and Revelation by Uriah Smith, Koresh assures his listeners that the information contained therein “never was a real revelation.” 74
165
to have such a wonderful vision and a wonderful understanding of the seventh angel’s message.”77 In The Assyrians, dated to 1987, Koresh speaks of “The vision in Australia that I had.”78 Elsewhere he claims, “The Lord revealed a very special thing to me here recently”79 and “You see we’re in Jerusalem right now and the Lord revealed something to me here a year and a half ago. . . .”;80 given that he made this statement in April, 1985, this particular revelation must have occurred in 1983. Because he is an anointed messenger, a christ, there is no true knowledge and understanding apart from his teaching. Regarding the interpretation of Ezek 36, Koresh says, “Let each of the Branches read this at their own leisure, and then we’ll be sending out some studies on it because only inspiration can bring it to light.”81 He invites them to admit his privileged status: “Branches, judge in your own hearts. Everything that I’ve spoken, you know is true. Everything. Judge what I say. ‘And when this cometh to pass (lo, it will come), then shall they know that a prophet hath been among them’ (Ezek 33:33).”82 During a study of Hebrews, he quotes Heb 3:12 and then explains its meaning: “How do you depart from the living God, Branches? Well you depart from the living voice, don’t you? The living mouthpiece, right? No Prophet—no truth. That’s the rule.”83 In traditional prophetic style, the leader of the Branch Davidians is to be about the business of reformation. “Where there is any true reform in the Word of God there is a living prophet directing that truth. Otherwise, the church is as it is now.”84 Like the Fourth Gospel, so key is the leader that to reject him is to reject Scripture and, therefore, truth; like the Fourth Gospel, Koresh makes this point explicitly to the listeners: I myself, I been watchin’ people here for quite a while, observing, seeing how they respond to me, seeing how they respond to—well, some of you know how it is in the world when somebody gets mad, who do they get mad at usually? Me. That lady acted like she was [indiscernible word] yesterday, the lady we saw at the store. Right? I’m the devil and Paul’s the good guy, right? He’s the angel there with the 77
Koresh, Judge. Koresh, The Assyrians. 79 David Koresh, A Letter to Australia, audiocassette recorded June 14, 1986. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. 80 Koresh, Judge. 81 Ibid. 82 Ibid. 83 Koresh, The Seventh. 84 Koresh, The Bird. 78
166
halo on his head. You see? Why does that stuff happen all the time for? Because they don’t have to accept Paul. You see, they can accept everything Paul says and have the light in their heads and still be lost. But the test is God has given them a person as a covenant to the people. That’s what Isaiah tells us, right? That’s the people who don’t like me from the day go when they just see me for some reason. ’Cause actually in their hearts they don’t like truth, you see?85
Compare Koresh’s presentation of himself here with John 3:19–21 and 8:31–59, in which Jesus indicates that rejection of him signifies rejection of truth and Scripture.86 All of this material corroborates the leader as a locus of authority. Given the elevated status of Scripture and its ostensible authority, it is surprising that Koresh frequently calls attention to discrepancies in the Bible rather than ignoring or denying that contradictions exist. He deals with this “problem” in three different ways. Sometimes he presents the disharmony as a mere fact to be accepted. For example, in his lengthy study on The Assyrians,87 he raises a number questions. For example, when exegeting Zephaniah, Koresh points out that “the destruction of the Land” prophesied has never happened. How does Koresh address the problem? We can’t worship Zephaniah just because he claims to be a prophet, can we? No. That would be stupid, wouldn’t it? We have to prove Zephaniah gibes with history. . . . Always there’s been people in Jerusalem. . . . I’m not gonna worship a dead prophet. . . . The prophet must have been stretching the story a little bit. If that’s the case, the prophet’s a liar. . . . What if the Bible’s a false book? And those of us who are traditional Christians accept it because everybody else does. And that’s tradition too, isn’t it? That’s no different than being a Jew accepting God because your fathers accepted him. And not knowing anything about God.88
85
Koresh, The Assyrians. The parallel is not exact insofar as Koresh speaks in own name, whereas the “leader” in the Fourth Gospel, that is, the author, speaks through the mouth of Jesus. The difference in strategy can be imputed both to the genre difference of the materials (the Fourth Gospel is a narrative, Koresh’s material is an exposition of Scripture) as well as the nature of authority in each group. The Branch Davidians had a tradition of successive authoritative leaders who were elected by God; the evidences various techniques designed to lend authority to the text, from Paul’s insistence on his “apostleship,” to the practice of pseudepigraphy, to the use of characters in a narrative who promulgate the author’s own agenda. The Fourth Gospel falls into the last category. 87 Koresh, The Assyrians. 88 Ibid. 86
167
He provides no immediate resolution but proceeds to the next verse of interest in Zephaniah.89 Finally, at other times he actually accounts for the discrepancies by appealing to “mystery,” which, along with other special jargon such as “revelation,” “present truth,” and “inspiration,” comprises an insider vocabulary, which simultaneously binds group members together more intimately and helps to identify “outsiders.” Discrepancies are only apparent, not actual: “The Bible does contradict itself, bite my tongue, according to man. With inspiration, we can find out why there’s a he tree and a she tree. . . .”90 Unlike, say, a Paul, Koresh is not content to shepherd from afar. His program for the ingathering of the elect seeks to draw all Branch Davidians to Mt. Carmel. In the context of interpreting the eschatological marriage supper on the basis of Zephaniah, Matthew, and Revelation, Koresh indicates this concern: Well, isn’t a marriage supper a sacrifice? Right? You’re blessed just ’cause you’re invited to it. Now you’re tenfold cursed if you don’t accept the response, you see, if you don’t give a response to the call. We had a letter from one of our professed Branches from Canada recently. And you know what they wrote to us? I’m telling this for the benefit of those who haven’t seen this yet. [He goes on to talk about a woman who has given various excuses for not migrating to Waco]. Now she can’t come because some guy proposed though he’s not an Adventist or a Branch or anything but yet he knows what she believes and doesn’t say anything about it. So she’s gonna go ahead and marry him. She hopes to see me in Israel in 1989 for the resurrection. Now that’s deception isn’t it?
He tells the group that his response is: “Well, you’re not gonna see nobody resurrected. You see? What is the test of this message? Come to Texas! Right? God didn’t say come to Texas meaning to stay where you’re at and get the truth ’cause you can’t get it. It’s impossible.”91 To have the group physically reside together, of course, draws clear boundaries between insiders and outsiders and serves as a crucible for inculcating the desired worldview and ethical regulations.
89 Koresh never seriously entertains the notion that the Bible could be a false book but aims rather to present the case as an uninitiated reader might see it. The point is, here he freely raises the problem and does not provide a solution. 90 Koresh, Confusion, Pt. 1. 91 Koresh, The Assyrians.
168
Koresh’s Technique Koresh adopts a number of techniques and assumptions in his scriptural interpretation that deserve to be highlighted. First, one subtle technique of persuasion is his tendency to pepper his interpretation with the phrase, “It’s so plain” or “simple” or “clear,” leaving the listener little choice but to agree unless she wants to appear ignorant. One prominent feature is his dialogical style, even on a cassette that finds him alone. He tends to read a verse or two and then ask a question about it. He then either does or does not answer it. For instance, he reads Rev 3:20: “ ‘Behold, I stand at the door and knock.’ What door? Door of your heart? It doesn’t say that, does it?”92 This stylistic feature is important to note because it reveals information about both leader and group. First, one immediately realizes just how essential scriptural knowledge and interpretation is not only to the leader, but to the members. This is a people steeped in Scripture. Often Koresh will ask them to finish a scriptural verse. Quoting Rev 10:7, Koresh asks, “ ‘The mystery of God should be finished’; how?” to which the group as a group responds by completing the verse, thus indicating the importance of Scripture memorization.93 In addition to simple verse completion, another technique comprises his reading a verse and asking a question about it, the answer not being contained within the verse itself. So he cites Ps 20:1 and then asks, “Who was Jacob’s God’s name?” to which the group responds, “El-Shaddai.”94 Clearly the members have been initiated into special knowledge. What is even more striking is that the answer in no way furthers the exegesis, but appears only to “keep the group on its toes,” so to speak. Second, this method serves as a useful tool for Koresh insofar as it allows him to monitor the group, gauge what people are thinking, and correct any erroneous notions they may be harboring. For example, when exegeting Zephaniah he asks the group what is meant by “fish gates.” He receives no reply and promptly chastises them, saying in a frustrated tone, “Come on, you already forgot since the last Sabbath?”95
92
Koresh, What is Truth? Ibid. The context indicates that people would not have had their Bibles opened to Rev 10:7 but were quoting from memory. 94 Ibid. 95 Ibid. 93
169
Third, it serves to draw potential converts in by alerting them to the fact that there are many important, even life-and-death questions to be answered about Scripture and showing them that, in fact, they do not know the answers. Koresh indicates that only by joining his group will they escape this fatal ignorance. Koresh, like all Davidians before him and probably most exegetes in Christian history, consistently assumes that Scripture helps to interpret itself. He has a penchant for visiting a plethora of biblical books while exegeting any given text. Sometimes the connection rests upon a word or phrase that appears in more than one biblical book. For example, a portion of The Assyrians study proceeds as follows. Koresh turns to Ps 20. After having the group identify the name of Jacob’s God alluded to in v. 1 as El-Shaddai (though the verse itself does not do so), Koresh then indicates that the “banners” mentioned in v. 5 refer to a prophecy, a prophecy also alluded to in Song 2:4 and Isa 13:2.96 Ps 20:8 speaks of those who are “risen” and those who are “brought down.” The former, he claims, is connected with Eccl 12:4, which reads: “And the doors shall be shut in the streets, when the sound of the grinding is low, and he shall rise up at the voice of the bird, and all the daughters of music shall be brought low.” This verse from Ecclesiastes appears often in Koresh’s exegesis and is considered prophetic. He designates those who are “brought down” as “the Assyrians.” Having made these connections, he observes: “We look at these prophecies and we look at this psalm and we
96 While suspect to modern sensibilities, this exegetical technique, whereby texts are connected and used to interpret one another on the basis of a single word or phrase that appears in both, appears in the (e.g., Hebrews on “rest”). It is a regular feature of Rabbinic exegesis (usually treated under the rubric of gezerah shewa). For a brief introduction to examples of Scripture used to interpret itself, see Michael Fishbane, “Inner Biblical Exegesis: Types and Strategies of Interpretation in Ancient Israel,” in Midrash and Literature (ed. Geoffrey H. Hartman and Sanford Budick; New Haven: Yale University Press, 1986), 19–37; and James L. Kugel and Rowan A. Greer, Early Biblical Interpretation (Philadelphia: Westminster, 1986). The balancing act between the authority of Scripture and the authority of Koresh is illuminated by Fishbane, “Inner Biblical Exegesis,” 34: One of the features that emerges prominently is the fact that for inner biblical exegesis there is no merely literary or theological playfulness. Exegesis arises out of a practical crisis of some sort—the incomprehensibility of a word or a rule, or the failure of the covenantal tradition to engage its audience. There is, then, something of the dynamic of “tradition and the individual talent” here—where the tradition sets the agenda of problems which must be creatively resolved or determines the received language which may be imaginatively reworked.
170
realize it’s more than just somebody gibber-jabbering a poetic prayer, isn’t it? It’s more than what meets the eye. . . . But we have to have the mind of the prophet to see what he saw in order to discern it properly.”97 The technique appears again when Koresh attends to Zeph 1:8 and notices that a) there is no record of this invitation to sacrifice ever having occurred and b) Zephaniah refers to “strange apparel.” He gets the group to agree that this sounds like some passages, moves to the wedding garment episode in Matt 22:11–14, and then declares: “So, the sacrifice [in Zephaniah] must have something to do with the wedding or the marriage.”98 He also alludes to the parable immediately preceding the wedding garment pericope, the invitation to the wedding feast (Matt 22:1–10). Eventually he ties all of this to Rev 19. He asks “Blessed are those who are called to the what?” and the group responds, “Marriage supper.”99 When exegeting the book of Jonah, they come upon this text: “Then said the Lord, ‘Doest thou well to be angry?’” Koresh puts this question to the group: “You hear that same statement echoed from something we heard earlier before. Who can tell me where that was echoed from?” The class answers: “Cain and Abel,” and Koresh goes on to draw an analogy between Cain and Jonah insofar as “Cain chose to do his own predetermined will.”100 Next, like his predecessors, Koresh relies upon typological interpretations.101 A few examples will suffice. According to Koresh, the seven seals of Revelation represent seven different eras. In his estimation his group was living during the sixth and seventh seals. He sees typology in the Passover. In the first Passover, the Passover of Moses, the Israelites put blood on their doorposts. In the time of Christ there was also a Passover and because “Judas didn’t put blood on the doorpost of his mind, he lost out. What about in our day? 97
Koresh, The Assyrians. Ibid. 99 Ibid. 100 Koresh, Jonah. 101 Koresh did not invent this technique. The evinces this strategy (e.g., Rom 5:14; Heb 8:5) as does much subsequent exegesis. See Patrick Fairbairn, The Typology of Scripture: Viewed in Connection with the Entire Scheme of the Divine Dispensations (New York: Funk & Wagnalls, 1900); Richard M. Davidson, Typology in Scripture: a Study of Hermeneutical tÊpow Structures (Berrien Springs, Mich.: Andrews University Press, 1981); John E. Alsup, “Typology,” ABD 6:682–85; Kugel and Greer, Early Biblical Interpretation, 140–41. 98
171
Will there not be an antitypical Passover for God’s people? That angel has a special message, a seal that’s gonna seal 144,000 and we’d better know what it is, especially as God’s people Israel today, Sabbath keepers.”102 Interpreting Ezek 21:2, “Son of man, set thy face toward Jerusalem, and drop [thy word] toward the holy places, and prophesy against the land of Israel,” Koresh declares this “a message for Jerusalem, antitypically, the church.”103 In explaining why the death of Christ abolished the necessity of animal sacrifice, Koresh asserts that in Christ’s cross “type met antitype.”104 Regarding the former leader of the group, Ben Roden, Koresh avers: “We know that brother Roden was a type [sic] of anti-typical [sic] Nebuchadnezzar.”105 A final example: “And when David destroyed the Philistines, we find in Revelation that’s a type of the last days when it says, ‘Who [is] like unto the beast? Who is able to make war with him [Rev 13:4]?’” The answer: “A stone cut out of a mountain [Dan 2:45].”106 The next salient feature is Koresh’s system, which he claims stems from the Adventist church, for the reckoning of prophetic time. In discussing the half hour of silence mentioned in Rev 8:1, Koresh says, “A half an hour equals thirty minutes but in prophetic time each day for a year which, as Adventists, we use a lot. It’s actually seven days.”107 The seven seals of Revelation represent seven historical periods: In 1833 the first angel’s message began to sound. 1844, the Spring, the second angel’s message. 1844, the Fall, shortly afterwards, the third angel arose judging the dead. Other messengers have come proclaiming to be the fourth, fifth, and sixth. What do they teach? Well, to make a long story short, we know one thing: if they teach anything it better be according to the Bible.108
Koresh unabashedly claims that biblical prophecy refers to Koresh’s contemporaries. He substantiates this claim in part by pointing out that many of the events predicted in prophecy have yet to occur, which leaves the reader with two explanations: either the prophets 102 103 104 105 106 107 108
Koresh, Koresh, Ibid. Ibid. Koresh, Koresh, Ibid.
What is Truth? Ezekiel 21. The Assyrians. What is Truth?
172
were wrong and the Bible lies or the prophets were right, the Bible is trustworthy, and these events are taking place now. Koresh opts for the latter: “The unique thing about these prophecies [referring to Isa 7–8], though misunderstood by all Christiandom [sic], is these prophecies are written in a way to where when you go back and research history, the majority of what the prophets wrote never came to pass.”109 Rev 10:7, “But in the days of the voice of the seventh angel, when he shall begin to sound, the mystery of God should be finished, as he hath declared to his servants the prophets,” serves as a key text for the claim that the prophecies apply to modern times since adherents of the sect are taught that Koresh, as an inspired prophet, has the message of the seventh angel. According to Koresh’s teaching, before his ministry it was simply impossible to understand certain aspects of Scripture because the seventh angel had not yet come with the key necessary for unlocking the truth. Early in his tenure, he preached: “The sixth seal is our period of time. You know that. Doesn’t take a nit-wit to know those kinda things.”110 Koresh later preached that he and his contemporaries were living during the shift from the sixth to the seventh seal. In his words, “The seventh angel’s message is here. . . . The future is laid out plainly.” Like many biblical numerologists, Koresh privileges the number seven: “[Adventists] will admit that everything God does is in sevens.”111 In his interpretation of Ezek 21:2, “Son of man, set thy face toward Jerusalem, and drop [thy word] toward the holy places, and prophesy against the land of Israel,” Koresh declares that Jerusalem antitypically refers to the church and the “land of Israel” refers to the United States. He supports his interpretation by pointing out that Lois Roden, a former leader of the group, taught this. “Today modern Israel is embedded where in the world? In the United States. This is where the first, second, and third angels’ message has come in the judgment of the dead.”112 The Ammonites of Ezek 21:28 comprise “people of the world,” and the “land of origin” in v. 30 is the United States. As part of his explication of Ezek 21, Koresh alludes to the struggle for power between himself and George Roden. He insists that Roden is not a legitimate candidate because he has not
109 110 111 112
Koresh, Koresh, Koresh, Koresh,
The Assyrians. What is Truth? Cf. Judge What I Say. What is Truth? Ezekiel 21.
173
been appointed by God and, therefore, does not have the gift of inspiration. At the end of his exegesis of Ezek 21, Koresh offers an application of the text to Mt. Carmel: “A prophetic message has come. George is losing his position. He’s lost it. By his own works he shows he doesn’t have the spirit. God is purifying his church.”113 When asked by a member of the class whether the prophecies were not originally intended for the prophets’ contemporaries that they might repent, Koresh emphatically replies, “No. That’s a mystery. No, because God knew they wouldn’t. . . . The books they wrote were for the future.”114 Koresh’s position is fully summarized in this statement: “That prophecy was put there specifically for us.”115 The Branch Davidians clearly assumed that Scripture referred to their contemporary situation, that they were the telos of Scripture. The relationship between Scripture, Koresh’s technique and authority, and the history of the sect is complex and not easily separated into its various components. Koresh’s intention and ability to shape his community into a preconceived mold affected his interpretation of Scripture. Recall Walzer’s understanding of Calvin: He “opportunistically” revised and reworked his doctrine in order to achieve a particular psychological effect. Calvin needed potent theological imagery to inscribe within his congregants the rigorous control of thought and action he sought. Indeed, tightly argued doctrine, austere ritual, and potent imagery were the weapons Calvin crafted to teach a new ethos. But doctrine ‘caused’ ethos only in an immediate sense. In a larger explanatory perspective, commitment to a specific ethos, a style of regulating action, shaped the selection and development of doctrine.116
Were one to replace “Calvin” with Koresh, one would arrive at an equally accurate conclusion. Attention to ethics will corroborate this. Ethics David Koresh used Scripture in all of the ways described above in order to inculcate a worldview that would mark the boundaries between the group and outsiders. He wanted the Davidians to think
113 114 115 116
Ibid. Koresh, The Assyrians. Ibid. Swidler, “Culture,” 280.
174
a certain way, and he attempted to accomplish that by invoking certain biblical texts and providing an authoritative interpretation of them. Discerning what he wanted them to think is somewhat more difficult than discovering what he wanted them to do. One of the most transparent indicators of group boundaries appears in the form of ethics. Earlier I argued that sects represent what Swidler has called “unsettled lives.” In unsettled lives, culture serves to create new strategies of action, and one should expect to find a high level of ideology, defined as “explicit, articulated, highly organized meaning systems (both political and religious).”117 Throughout this study I maintain that Scripture comprises a powerful, efficacious subcategory of culture for groups which claim it as a locus of authority. Though never counseled to “wear orange,” Koresh’s followers were exhorted to adhere to particular rules of dress and other behavior as presented below. The angels of Rev 7 must hold back from hurting the earth so that people might have one more opportunity to hear the message of salvation as presented by Koresh. In defense of his argument that people have spurned Sister White’s message, he specifies: “They’ve not been health reformers, they’ve not been dress reformers. . . . They do not believe specifically in inspiration. . . . They don’t keep the feasts. . . .”118 Like all Adventists, Koresh insists on Saturday Sabbath observance,119 and one obvious identifying characteristic of the group’s opponents is failure to do so. So important was the issue of Sabbath observance that, according to Koresh, it comprised the third angel’s message. His interpretation of Rev 10:6 contains the following observation: “This is the God of Sabbath. The Sabbath, the fourth commandment of God, contains the sign and the seal that those who worship on that day worship not a god, but the living God of creation.”120 They keep Levitical feasts. They celebrate Passover. “This last Passover, those who didn’t keep it with us, they have the mark of the beast.”121 They participate in twice daily Bible studies: “If you
117
Ibid., 278. Koresh, Judge. 119 In explicating the meaning and requirements of Sabbath, he relies at times on Heb 4. It should be noted that such an interpretation is standard in scholarship. See Harold W. Attridge, The Epistle to the Hebrews: A Commentary on the Epistle to the Hebrews (Hermeneia; Philadelphia: Fortress, 1989). 120 Koresh, The Seventh. 121 Koresh, Ezekiel 47. 118
175
don’t study [Scripture] every day, you cannot be familiar with it.”122 This indicates concern for ritual practice. Strict123 dress codes in accordance with modesty apply. In interpreting Isa 3:9, Koresh enjoins: “Ladies, button up your shirt; close up the slits. Guys take off your shorts and put on pants.” He is especially dismayed at what he finds at Loma Linda University, an Adventist school, “a fashion show you never saw before. Peacocks would be ashamed.”124 Smoking and drinking are prohibited. Interpreting Ezek 33:27–28, in which God promises destruction for Israel, Koresh warns: “A lot of people like George [Roden] and certain of his following believe that God’s going to bless the land over here like it is. But when you drive down the middle of Jerusalem and see pictures of indecent women and the way the people dress over here and all the smoking and drinking and the different crimes that are taking place now, believe me, God is not going to bless these type of people.”125 Strict dietary regulations apply to both adults and children. Interpreting Ezek 33:24, “Thus saith the Lord God; Ye eat with the blood and lift up your eyes toward your idols and shed blood: and shall ye possess the land?” Koresh proclaims: “No meat eater is going to receive the kingdom of God.”126 In the context of Isa 2:8, Koresh says: “There’s more to the beast than just Sunday-keeping. The beast says, ‘It’s alright to eat a Snickers candy bar.’ God says it’s not. The beast says, ‘That soda pop’s good for you.’”127 That their food intake could be minimal at times is implied by his explanation that “justification by faith is saying: ‘Thank God for the little food Vernon gave me today.’ If it weren’t for God, you’d get discouraged. ‘If it’s up to you, I hope Vernon’s hand slips tomorrow and I get a few more beans.’”128 By the time the ATF attempted its “dynamic entry,” Koresh apparently had a change of heart regarding active vs. passive resistance.
122
Koresh, The Assyrians. “Strict,” of course, is a decidedly relative term and is used in comparison with the group’s surrounding environment since it is only by such a comparison that one can label a group “sectarian.” 124 Koresh, Confusion, Pt. 2. 125 Koresh, Judge. 126 Ibid. 127 Koresh, Confusion, Pt. 1. 128 Koresh, Ezekiel 47. 123
176
Formerly he had taught: “At least the people that follow the seventh angel’s message don’t go around shooting guns at people and things like that. We got to come to our senses. We let the Lord be our protection.”129 Traditionally Davidians, like their Adventist brothers and sisters, refused to participate in military combat for fear of killing another Christian. The issue of military service never arose in Koresh’s tenure or teaching. The ATF raid, however, found the Davidians relying on firearms for protection and, indeed, killing ATF officers in the process. Whether or not this indicates an ethical modification is difficult to say. Nowhere on the cassettes, even those recorded during the time of the siege, does Koresh advocate the use of violence against the ATF or the FBI. Rather than proudly assuming credit for “killing infidels,” the Davidians spent more time trying to persuade outsiders that the government was the aggressor. Furthermore, the Davidians deny stockpiling weapons in an apocalyptic manner; they insist that they owned so many weapons because they earned money by selling guns at gun shows, which in fact they did. From an emic perspective, it appears that there was no ethical modification. From an etic perspective, one might make a case contrariwise, but the argument would remain speculative. The call to leave one’s home and follow Koresh to Waco deserves mention under ethics. As noted above, Koresh contended that, unless one did so, it was impossible to obtain truth and salvation since he alone had been designated to reveal it. It almost goes without saying that having the group reside together was the surest way to directly and completely influence the thought and behavior of the members. Such a context would serve as a crucible for what Swidler calls “establishing new strategies of action.” She maintains that “when people are learning new ways of organizing individual and collective action, practicing unfamiliar habits until they become familiar, then doctrine, symbol, and ritual directly shape action.”130 When people share a common life as the residents of Mt. Carmel did, eating, sleeping, studying, raising children, and maintaining the property together, the opportunity to make the “ideology” become “common sense” is greatly enhanced. The central ritual of the group was worship and Bible study, which occurred twice a day. Thus, two of the requisite features delineated by Wuthnow apply at this point: a) 129 130
Koresh, Judge. Swidler, “Culture,” 278.
177
encouraging members to worship, and b) providing members and their children with instruction. The third, drawing individuals into an intimate community, will be discussed later in the chapter. How does Scripture fit into the group’s ethics? Recall Swidler’s inquiry into “chunks of culture,” which I argue includes Scripture: “A crucial task for research is to understand how cultural capacities created in one historical context are reappropriated and altered in new circumstances. . . . The significance of specific cultural symbols can be understood only in relation to the strategies of action they sustain.”131 It is clear that vis-à-vis the Davidians, Scripture is a “cultural capacity created in one historical context” and “reappropriated and altered in new circumstances.” Just as each ancient Jewish group, including Qumran and earliest Christianity, reappropriated Hebrew Scripture, so also all Christian groups, including the Davidians, reappropriate and alter the Old and New Testaments to serve new circumstances. Rarely do any two groups derive the exact same strategies of action from Scripture, which indicates that Scripture does not perspicuously necessitate particular strategies of action. As Swidler reckons: “Culture does not influence how groups organize action via enduring psychological proclivities implanted in individuals by their socialization. Instead, publicly available meanings facilitate certain patterns of action, making them readily available, while discouraging others.”132 This means that it is wrongheaded to assume that the group simply “followed scripture” any more than any other radically biblically based group does. Rather, one must recognize that, in his efforts to wrest control over Scripture from the parent community, Koresh made choices about which Scriptures to focus on and what meanings to extract and simultaneously closed down certain potential meanings the text might yield. But he did not work from scratch; instead, his own method of wresting Scripture, not only from the ancient church but especially from the SDA church, was influenced and constrained by the “publicly available meanings which facilitated certain patterns of action.” That is, he was constrained by SDA beliefs dating back to the nineteenth century and by Davidian beliefs that had been promulgated since 1929. This section has provided ample evidence for the Branch Davidian concern for boundary setting by means of ethical imperatives. 131 132
Ibid., 283. Ibid.
178 Opponents
In Koresh’s rhetoric, one can identify all of the opponents postulated on the chart; he inveighs against “the world,” against sectdeserters, and against the parent tradition, which must be defined as twofold for Koresh: he opposes both “the church” in the larger sense and the main body of Seventh Day Adventism. He also treats scholars with scorn. The World As part of a running commentary on John 12:23–44, Koresh indicates his attitude toward “the world” when he quotes and interprets John 12:28a. The whole passage is cited because it displays not only his view of “the world,” but also some of his common exegetical techniques (e.g., appealing to the authoritative writings of Ellen G. White and using other biblical passages to inform the present one), pedagogical moves (e.g., use of the interrogative to elicit agreement with his teaching as when he asks, “wasn’t it?” or “hasn’t it?”; exhortation in the form of “We need to open our eyes”), and thematic concerns (e.g., the necessity of observing Sabbath): Now we want to read this scripture very carefully, Branches. Verse 28 again, “Glorify thy name.” Ellen G. White tells us that the name of God is contained in the fourth commandment. Well, what is that name? Sabbath. Now remember the Sabbath is a memorial of creation. Those who worship the Sabbath, worship the God of creation. In other words, the whole testimony of the Bible is that “thus saith the Lord.” God said something. And when God said it, those who would see what God spoke, it was good. In other words, everything that God spoke in the days of creation was good, wasn’t it? We need to open our eyes. It was good. That’s our whole hope of salvation, is receiving that first dominion, the first kingdom. But because of man and his evil works, God’s word has been twisted up, muddled, it’s been blackened. And the effects of that has been seen in the world, hasn’t it? But now notice. When God created everything by the spoken word, God created the Sabbath as a memorial, and we were to rest in that word, weren’t we? In other words, the Sabbath is a memorial of all things that God created, and to enter into God’s rest is to believe in his word, and his word is also made manifest by his name [emphasis added].133
133
Koresh, Judge.
179
In interpreting Rev 7:1, Koresh says: “And these messages hold, or keep the persecution of the world away from the church.”134 The world is a persecuting force. “Christianity” and “the world” are mutually exclusive spheres. When interpreting Rev 15:2 Koresh denotes the victors as those “who don’t mix Christianity with worldliness.”135 Koresh interprets the Ammonites of Ezek 21:28 to be “people of the world.” As is the case with Pesher Habakkuk, the ruling government constitutes an antagonistic force for the Davidians. In explicating Rev 15:2, Koresh declares simply: “the beast represents the earthly governments.”136 God’s judgment lies in store for these governments: “Fools!! Get wise, wisdom says!! Get wise!! The man on the white horse comes first!! That’s Psalms 1, that’s Psalms 2, that’s Psalms 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8!! Learn ’em!! That’s what God says is going to happen!! Do you hear?! Do you understand!! It’s war!!! These governments of this world are coming to an end.”137 The Church Koresh refers to those in the larger church as “Sunday-keepers,” as opposed to his own group, which he refers to as “Sabbath-keepers.” For example, he refers to a “book in Adventism called Daniel and Revelation by Uriah Smith. It’s kinda crazy. . . . The majority of the information came through ‘Sunday-keepers.’ The information never was a real revelation. Since when do we get our truth from people who aren’t in the truth?”138 Koresh draws heavily on truth/falsehood language and accuses his opponents of trafficking in the latter; “Sunday-keepers” are counted in that group. Koresh claims that he was formerly Baptist and therefore attended church on Sunday. Then he discovered that “that wasn’t biblical but traditional.” He imagines entering a Baptist church as a Seventh-Day Adventist and telling them to keep the true Sabbath, Saturday. He suggests they are unlikely to welcome his biblical insight and change their ways, though
134
Ibid. Ibid. 136 Ibid. 137 The Foundation. Audiocassette recorded October 1989. Transcribed by David Bunds. No pages. Online: http://home.maine.rr.com/waco. 138 Koresh, What is Truth? 135
180
he does hold out the possibility that “there may be somebody that is honest and sincere, but today with as much light as there is, everybody knows that the Sabbath is Saturday.”139 Most, however, are unlikely to change. Why? “Most of ’em [i.e., Baptist pastors] are getting paid a good pay check, they got a nice church, they got people who want an easy way to be saved, who like to sit in their seats and hear a watered down sermon. He’s [i.e., the pastor] gonna make you sound like a fanatic because you know the Bible.”140 Though he recognizes that Christ rose on a Sunday, he explains that, like Ellen G. White, he finds no evidence that Scripture abrogates the Saturday observance; rather the Bible says “not one jot or tittle will pass from God’s law.”141 The Branch Davidians alone represent the only true religion and are characterized by truth, spirit, heaven, salvation, and light; all others are false, carnal, earthly, damned, and consigned to darkness. Koresh designates the “nation not desired” which is to “gather together” in Zeph 2:1 as “the Assyrians,” which he further defines as: “American-sponsored religionists. I say religionists because they’re Baptists, Methodists, Presbyterians, Episcopalians, Catholics, Jewish. All false apostate religions are trying to put their headquarters over where? Jerusalem.”142 Elsewhere, he inveighs against “the Papacy and apostate Protestantism.”143 Even when Koresh attacks “the world,” he makes it simultaneously an opportunity to attack the church: Let me try to attack things this wise. You been to several churches and things just didn’t hit you right. Well, remember today when we go to church we’re looking for God. And this seems to be something that the whole world takes for granted. Everybody claims to know God or to have an experience of God. At least those in religion do. And yet you know as well as I do that they’re no different than the world is. The world and the church go hand in hand today. We know that the name Jesus Christ is basically an excuse for sinning. Tammy Baker and Jim Baker, Oral Roberts, Robert Schuller and all these people spending multi-mega bucks. The church’s music, Amy Grant, Sandi Patti, it’s all ‘la-la-la-la-la’ type of big mega bucks, ‘I’m secure.’”144 139 140 141 142 143 144
Koresh, Ibid. Ibid. Koresh, Koresh, Koresh,
Voice of Fire. The Assyrians. Letter to Australia. Voice of Fire.
181
In the same way, when interpreting Ezek 21:3 for his listeners he insists that the sword “is a message that comes not to the world to destroy the wicked but to destroy or to save the wicked in the church. . . . Take notice; there are many people in the church of God today that are quite wicked. They’re trying to do the best that they know how to do. Let’s call them Jacobites. Jacob was a wicked man. Like the angel who wounds Jacob, the person who wields the word will wound the Jacobites for the sake of truth.”145 Perhaps his most transparent critique of the churches comes in his Radio Sermon. Addressing Rev 19:2, he says: [The whore] will probably be responsible for the blood of God’s servants because she probably won’t know where they’re coming from. So we know that Babylon is a big whore, right? I mean she’s not really very faithful when it comes to God’s word, when it comes to knowing God’s truth and I bet you she’s the kind of person that’ll claim to be with a guy, love a guy and not even know where he’s coming from. That’s how most whores are, isn’t it?
He then applies this to those who claim to love Jesus Christ yet do not even know where the seals are found in the prophecy.146 The (Other) Adventists Never in their history did the Branch Davidians consider themselves as anything other than “true” Adventists. From their inception they sought reform within Adventism. This is why they continued to attend Adventist worship services and conventions and cause disturbances in hopes of attracting members. Though ethnically and nationally diverse, most of the sectarians had been Adventists before joining the group. As already discussed, they share not only the Bible with their parent tradition, but also a common history, which began with William Miller and a common respect for the writings of early leaders, most notably the prophetess Ellen G. White. How to wrest control from the parent tradition over proper interpretation of both the Bible and the writings of Ellen G. White? The first is accomplished by showing that the sect’s leaders have been granted special knowledge by means of inspiration, revelation, or visions. This is claimed, of course, for Houteff, the Rodens, and Koresh. Laying rightful claim 145
Koresh, Ezekiel 21. Koresh, Radio Sermon. Not only Revelation, but at least also Isa 13, Hosea, and Joel speak of the seals in Koresh’s estimation. 146
182
to White is accomplished by showing that the Adventists misinterpret her. For example, Koresh narrates his attending a convention of the Reformed Adventists and engaging in debate over Ellen G. White’s teaching that Jerusalem will not be purified until God does so with fire. “This guy was smilin’ real big, and all that, you know, because they think this is after the thousand years, at the end of the millennium. But Sister White’s correct. It’s just that their application of her writings is wrong.”147 As with all those who oppose or even remain indifferent to the sect, judgment lies in store for these other Adventists. After quoting Ezek 35:15, which promises desolation for all Idumea, Koresh provides this interpretation: “Now we know that Idumea represents the fleshly Jews and also the modern SDA and Davidian groups who have not progressed with present truth. . . . And verse fourteen of Ezek 35 tells us that when all the earth shall rejoice, the Lord’s going to execute his judgments upon the Adventist people and upon, well, Zech 14 is going to be fulfilled also at that time.”148 The main complaint that Koresh voices about the Adventist church is its failure to admit any “present truth” or “new light” in the form of an authoritative prophet after Ellen White’s death in 1915. “The Adventist church is a rejected church. They are not God’s people. They have not been for years. You see? That’s why they had no commission in the world. They haven’t ever preached the Sabbath as it is to be preached. They don’t keep it as it is to be kept. They know nothing of it ’cause they have no spirit of prophecy.”149 This precludes their ability to interpret Scripture correctly, which results in doctrinal error, a failure to understand how modern events reflect God’s plan for the eschaton, and a loosening of morals. Koresh’s shorthand for these charges is “Laodicean,” a reference from Revelation that describes the church at Laodicea as “lukewarm”; the Laodicean church was to be vomited out of the mouth of Christ. This sobriquet is reserved not only for the SDA church but also for those in the sect who may not adhere strictly to the coherent, hermetic, overarching ideology presented. What Koresh calls “Laodicean,” Swidler would called “settled lives.” As all scholars of Adventism note, the
147
Koresh, The Assyrians. Koresh, Judge. 149 Koresh, The Shower Head Tape, audiocassette recorded August 24, 1987. Transcribed by Mark Swett. Online: http://home.maine.rr.com/waco. 148
183
SDA church has reduced its tension with its surrounding sociocultural environment to such an extent that Bryan Wilson can say that Adventists “have gradually accepted a less intensely sectarian stance, and in some respects have come closer to a denominational position.”150 Mainline Adventism, as the dominant Adventist group, incorporates diversity and tolerates inconsistencies as characteristic of “settled lives” as previously discussed; sectarian Adventism, as represented by the Branch Davidians, does not. A final result of what Koresh considers “apostate Adventism” is its tendency to dismiss or persecute the “true Adventists,” that is, the Branch Davidians. By claiming that Houteff, the Rodens, and Koresh are the genuine successors to the leadership of Adventism; by insisting on a singular interpretation of Scripture that admits no diversity; by calling followers to a radical and costly discipleship that entails leaving job and family to abide at Mt. Carmel; and by instituting a lifestyle with rigorous ethics regarding food, dress, and twice daily worship, Koresh validates Hostetler’s observation cited in chapter two: “A sectarian movement must establish an ideology different from that of the parent group in order to break off relations with it. A sect must establish cultural separatism, involving symbolic and often material as well as ideological differences, from those of the parent group.”151 The one correction to his observation, which applies at least to the three sects under study here and probably all sects, is that none seek deliberately to break off relations with the parent group; rather, they seek to reform it, convert it, and embody its truest form. In accounting for the relationship between the Davidians and the SDA church, Meeks’s description of the Johannine community’s struggle with its parent Jewish tradition applies. Of the Fourth Gospel he writes: What drove the Johannine Christians to make just these connections, in the face of the social pain that it obviously cost them? We must remember that the social pain was but the negative side of the process by which they had become a distinctive community. . . . In this Gospel, “abiding” in the truth about Jesus has positive and negative social dimensions: It
150 Bryan Wilson, Social Dimensions, 140; quoted in Ronald Lawson, “Seventh-Day Adventist Responses to Branch Davidian Notoriety: Patterns of Diversity within a Sect Reducing Tension with Society,” JSSR 34 (1995): 327. 151 Bainbridge, Sociology, 264.
184
entails stalwart “love” for fellow disciples of Jesus and brave separation from those who reject him. The claim that constitutes the identity of this special group of former Jews is that in their abiding in the Son of Man they have been granted what the whole of Israel’s Scripture and tradition— both Jewish and Samaritan versions—pointed to. . . . They alone are Israel. . . . They are epitomized in one of the first of those “given by God” to Jesus, Nathanael the élhy«w ÉIsrahl¤thw. Here we have the very model of a sectarian consciousness. To “Pharisees” and to ordinary Jews of all kinds, as the narrative makes clear, these claims did not fulfill but rather subverted the classical Scripture and traditions. These [Christological] claims broke the community with other Jews by their audacity, their exclusiveness, and their persistence.152 (emphasis added).
Likewise, we may wonder what drove the Davidians to make the connections they did in spite of the social pain it cost them. And, likewise, we realize the concomitant benefits of belonging to a distinctive, intimate, exclusive group. Like the Johannine community, the Davidians claimed that they, rather than the parent tradition, constituted the true Israel. Like the “ordinary Jews” of the Gospel’s world, the SDA church did not concede that the Davidians fulfilled Scripture but asserted that they had subverted it. The SDA excised Davidians from church rolls, allowed them no part in national meetings, and, at the time of the 1993 destruction, officially denied any connection with them whatsoever. Unlike the cases of the Fourth Gospel and Qumran communities, we have external evidence that reveals the stance of the other Adventists to the Branch Davidians. The official response, by which is meant that generated by the General Conference of Seventh-Day Adventists, to the Branch Davidian debacle indicates no ties between the Branch Davidian Seventh-Day Adventists and Seventh-Day Adventists. One press release declared: “Although the Seventh-Day Adventist Church has no affiliation with the Branch Davidians or any other cult, our hearts go out to those who have lost loved ones in the Waco, Texas, tragedy. As compassionate, peace-loving people, our prayers are with these families;”153 this, in spite of the fact that another work published by the church’s official publishing house avowed: “because Davidian theology could be built only on Adventist
152
Meeks, “Equal to God,” 318–19. Lawson, “Seventh-Day,” 329. The liberal Adventist response, according to Lawson, did not seek to distance itself from the Davidians. 153
185
theology, you had to have an Adventist understanding of the Bible even to understand what the Davidians were talking about.”154 In Producing the Sacred, Robert Wuthnow suggests that we consider religious groups to be in competition with one another, and this is evidenced well in Koresh’s treatment of relevant opponents in this regard, namely, the church universal and the SDA church. Wuthnow suggests three dynamics that obtain in the conflict. First, isomorphism contributed to the group’s continued existence from 1929 on and to whatever proselytizing success it could be said to have had. That is, it resembled the wider church and especially the SDA church enough to survive in the host environment, which has always paid at least considerable lip service to the validity of Christianity. Second, the group definitely specialized and thereby retained its distinctiveness. The most salient specializing feature was its commitment to continued prophecy dispensed exclusively by Davidian leaders from Houteff to Koresh. Where the group failed in the competition was in the third dynamic, “selective adaptation,” which has to do with how well the group “fits” its host environment. Obviously, the wider church and even the SDA defeated the Davidians insofar as the Davidians maintained such a high level of tension with their host environment that they were destroyed. This section testifies to opposition to and from the parent tradition. Sect-Defectors Koresh recognizes the cost of abiding with him and, as does Jesus in the Fourth Gospel, he announces rather than suppresses this news: Always the Lord brings darkness before he brings light, and I’ve been goin’ through some darkness. . . . But now things are starting to come to light. See, there’s a portion of time when God’s people will have to flee out of the land and go to another place until something happens before another phase of work comes into existence. There’s a lot of details we don’t know yet. But these truths have to be very, very intricately presented because wouldn’t it be terrible to be a Judas amongst us? And hear these sacred truths and yet not be firm and determined to follow truth no matter where it could lead us? Right? So we have to each step of the way count the cost. Now we first began with several people in the beginning of the message and some of these people have fallen away. And it’s for their own benefit too. 154
Ibid., 330.
186
Because it’s a whole lot better to fall away at the beginning of the message and be lost than it is to be right there at the very end and decide to take a shortcut. Everyone has to search their heart and see if they are willing to go the way the Lord says he wants you to go, putting aside their own feelings and opinions.155
In one fell swoop, Koresh accomplishes three ends. First, he passes judgment on apostates by saying they have fallen away and are therefore “lost.” Second, he uses their example to encourage the rest of the group to adhere to the sect. Their reward will come when, “at the very end,” that is, the final judgment, they will be found to have “go[ne] the way the Lord says he wants [them] to go.” Finally, he encourages perseverance through difficulty, exhorting them to “follow truth no matter where it could lead,” and “each step of the way count the cost.” The following comment on Jesus’ proclamation in the Fourth Gospel, that Christ came not to condemn the world, indicates that apostasy among the sectarians created concern: “But if they would not accept that truth then the truth in the end would judge them because they would try to establish their own righteousness and they would lose out, the same as many Branches have done these days”156 (my italics). This also castigates potential and actual deserters. Koresh acknowledges that he is not the first Branch Davidian leader to encounter defection. The problem of apostasy visited earlier incarnations of the sect as well, and Koresh teaches that Heb 3:11 (“So I sware in my wrath, ‘They shall not enter into my rest’”) refers to the deserters: “So those who came in and joined with the Branch movement under Brother Roden; they started looking at his faults and his frailties and then they found some excuse to jump off the boat.”157 I have previously referred to the struggle Koresh endured to assume leadership at Mt. Carmel when Lois Roden’s reign concluded. Koresh and his followers did not reside there at the time. Her son George tried to assume power. During this time Koresh recorded Ezekiel 47, which he intended to send to Mt. Carmel. He accuses those living there of trafficking in unrighteousness and sets their misdeeds in the larger context of the cosmic struggle between good and evil repre155 156 157
Koresh, The Assyrians, 572. Koresh, Judge. Koresh, The Seventh.
187
sented in Revelation: “So this is why there’s so much fighting and stinginess and lying and theft and adultery and things taking place on Mt. Carmel, because people have the mark of the beast.”158 Like the author of the Fourth Gospel, the Branch Davidians know schism, and the fact of schism is an opportunity to identify true followers and liars: We have a schism amongst us. We have schism. There is competition now. I’m happy. I’m happy to see that the Spirit now has opportunity to manifest herself in a way that we’ve never before seen. That we might discern the children of light and the children of darkness. There are those who have walked with us in the flesh. They have not been children of light. They say they have seen, they have seen, but now you see they have seen nothing.159
Koresh understands well that the most intense hatred often appears between those who are most alike. He warns: The last persecuting power, the one that’s gonna be the most fierce in opposition against the church of God, the seventh church, the complete church, is gonna be those who at one time were the closest of brethren, and who have the greatest amount of light and who yet have turned and apostatized [sic] from following progressive truth. They will be our worst enemies. We don’t have to fear Catholicism or the apostate Protestantism. What we have to fear are those who at one time shared the work with us and who are the farthest from us by being the closest to us.160
It is not entirely clear whether he here implicates apostates from the sect or the Seventh-Day Adventist church. Because his next words are “You can have two members in one room, both of them doing the same worship in the flesh but one doing it of the spirit and the other doing it of the flesh; one of them through spiritual knowledge, another through carnal knowledge,” he appears to refer to sect members. Either way, it displays the same principle evident at Qumran and in the Fourth Gospel, namely, the most vehement vituperation flies at those closest to the group, for that is where the real struggle, including the appropriation of Scripture, lies. Also like the Fourth Gospel, the Branch Davidians present the devil as holding sway over opponents and remain on guard against 158 159 160
Koresh, Ezekiel 47. Koresh, The Foundation. Koresh, Ezekiel 47.
188
his beguiling ways. For instance, Koresh compares those who will not know that the Lord’s hand is lifted up (Rev 10:5) with those who, in 1844, refused to believe that Christ had entered the Holy of Holies. The devil is responsible for this unbelief: “The devil took over and the devil was leading them and has ever since been leading those people who will not progress with present truth.”161 On at least two different occasions, women preface their questions to Koresh with the disclaimer, “You might think I have the spirit of the devil.”162 Scholars Finally, scholars usually appear as opponents: “Now we should, as Adventists, be scholars today. And very few Adventists are scholars. Even our scholars are stupid people. That’s hard to say, isn’t it? Can you imagine that the majority of theologians in the world are ignorant of what the Bible is teaching?”163 Castigating one member who invokes his historical knowledge to contest Koresh at one point, Koresh responds: “Your scholarly studies are of benefit for the sake of argument to those who wanna go by that type of study,”164 implying that Koresh does not. Scholarly studies, which are devoid of inspiration and recent revelation, are relegated to the category of human wisdom, about which Koresh happily announces: “We have the privilege of breaking down the walls of human wisdom.”165 To show his disdain for mainline theological education, Koresh turns to the example of Christ: The schools of Israel ordained by the Sanhedrin and also the Pharisees were schools similar to the ones of our own theological schools of today of which the careful student of Scripture observes that nowhere is it written in the Gospels that Christ ever attended these schools, but at the age of twelve he did enter into the Temple and had a most unique and interesting discussion with the religious leaders by which they were quite amazed at such a young lad’s knowledge of Scripture.166
All of these groups, the world, the church universal, the SDA church, sect-defectors, and scholars, are cultures or subcultures against which
161 162 163 164 165 166
Koresh, Koresh, Koresh, Ibid. Ibid. Koresh,
Judge. Confusion, Part I. The Assyrians. Radio Sermon.
189
the Davidians vied for dominance and all are considered opponents by the Davidians, though the converse is not necessarily true. Far from belligerent animosity, the church universal and scholars do not even express interest in the small sect. While the SDA church has never recognized the validity of the group, it has never actively persecuted it. For the most part, the SDA church has simply ignored the group, paying attention to it only when the Davidians forced it to by disrupting national meetings or local church services. The one opponent that has shown the least interest in the Davidians throughout its history is the one group that proved most fatal, that is, the United States government (one part of “the world”). Anyone who doubts the accuracy of speaking of a “culture” with respect to the government agencies dispatched to contend with the Davidians is referred to Nancy Ammerman’s work, “Waco, Federal Law Enforcement, and Scholars of Religion.”167 I address the argument at greater length in the conclusion of the chapter, but the thrust of it appears in this sentence referring to why those government agencies ignored professional advice from scholars of religion: “Those ears were deaf for a number of reasons, many of which have to do with the training and culture of the FBI”168 (my italics). Why the two cultures clashed and why the government culture emerged victorious depends upon the concrete historical and social circumstances obtaining in 1993 in the United States involving at least internal government politics, law enforcement culture, the anti-cult network, the media, and a popular emphasis on the welfare of children. Having presented evidence regarding the Davidians, Koresh as their leader, and Koresh’s attempt to shape his group in a very particular way using Scripture, I can use Garfinkel’s work to help explain how Koresh achieves the vilification of certain groups as “opponents.” Recall that a successful status degradation requires that the denouncer (here, Koresh) must present himself or herself as an authentic representative of the witnesses (the Davidians) and must show that he or she shares the same essence as they. As the leader directly chosen by God and privileged to have received numerous revelations and visions from God, Koresh unquestionably serves as the authentic representative. Koresh must separate the denounced from
167 168
Ammerman, “Waco,” 282–96. Ibid., 292.
190
the denouncer and the group, drawing boundaries so rigid that distance between the two sides is guaranteed. “The denounced . . . must be ritually separated from a place in the legitimate order, i.e., he must be defined as standing at a place opposed to it. He must be placed ‘outside,’ he must be made ‘strange.’”169 One way to accomplish this distance is to employ typology, a favorite technique of Koresh’s. This allows the group to think in uniform and dialectical terms such that they “should not be able to contemplate the features of the denounced person without reference to the counterconception”170 so that character traits are further clarified when viewed in light of their opposites. Once Koresh has established such a situation, the group is constrained to regard the denounced as entirely “other” and logically deserving of denunciation. For Koresh, of course, the types are drawn from the Bible. So, the government and those who traffic with it are “Babylon.” Non-Davidian Christians are those referred to as the “whores” in the books of Hosea and Revelation, those who claim to have a commitment to Christ but are not faithful to him. On the other hand, the Davidians are the “bride” referred to in Revelation as well as Ps 45:10. A potential sect-defector is spoken of as being “a Judas,” meaning that he or she appears to be of one nature, godly, but are actually of another, diabolical. Koresh succeeds in drawing such stark boundaries not only because he serves as an authentic representative of the group and draws attention to what Garfinkel calls the group’s “ultimate values” but also because those “ultimate values” are purportedly ensconced in Holy Writ so that even if the group could disagree with Koresh, it certainly could not disagree with Scripture. Judgment lies in store for all opponents of the group. Interpreting Heb 3:11, Koresh says, “Always, men fail to hold to the promises of God because they know not when prophecy is gonna be fulfilled, nor [do] they know how they’re gonna be fulfilled. So they fell short of perfection. They don’t enter into that rest because they do not endure the trial. ‘So I sware in my wrath, “They shall not enter into my rest” God says.’”171
169 170 171
Garfinkel, “Conditions,” 423. Ibid., 422–23. Koresh, The Seventh.
191
Growing the Sect Koresh proselytized. He believed that his ministry represented the last chance for people to receive inclusion in God’s salvific plan. Toward this end, every cassette contains such comments as: “I want to be part of the 144,000 or at least a part of the ‘great multitude.’ How about you?”172 or, “We’re trying to agitate your thinking; we wanna get you to study. Because you see, we have answers to this [i.e., to identifying various figures in prophecy]. It’s very clear. The seventh angel’s message is here.”173 Or: My job is to prove to you that the Bible in regards to the prophecies harmonize one hundred percent with Daniel chapters eleven and twelve. My challenge is for you to come, to get into contact with us to ask the questions, to demand answers in the name of the Lamb. . . . Brethren, my name is Cyrus. The message is from Israel. The truth is in the Bible. Give us a call. Remember the question: What is Truth?174
Koresh took some interest in proselytizing those who had sampled churches but had not found a home there: “You been to several churches and things just didn’t hit you right.”175 He took more interest in those who already considered themselves Christian, as when he says: “I am trying to proselate [sic]. I’m trying to say ‘Why don’t you come serve my God. You serve Jesus Christ, the Greek name, Iesous Christos, you see. I serve God whose name is the Word.’”176 In his Radio Sermon just before the annihilation of the Davidian residence and residents, Koresh appealed to all Christians. He first invokes Rev 19:7, which refers to the marriage of the Lamb and the bride who has made herself ready. He then appeals to Ps 45 to explain that the wife of Rev 19:7 is none other than the woman of Ps 45:10, the daughter who is to “forget [her] own house,” which he interprets as a call to forget one’s own denomination.177 But as we have previously noted and as Koresh’s Letter to Steve Schneider and the Wisconsin Brethren shows, Koresh primarily targeted Adventists. In that study, he undertakes an exegesis of Rev 10 for
172
Koresh, What is Truth? Ibid. 174 Ibid. 175 Koresh, Voice of Fire. 176 Koresh, The Bird, audiocassette recorded August 24, 1987. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. 177 Koresh, Radio Sermon. 173
192
them and upon arriving at verse six which, in part, declares “there should be time no longer,” he reminds them, “Now we as SeventhDay Adventists understand this to refer to prophetic time.”178 The focus on Adventists as potential members comes as no surprise given that Koresh’s teachings and exhortations would be quite difficult to understand for anyone who had not been previously initiated into Adventism. As one scholar has noted: David Koresh had grown up as an Adventist, had attended an Adventist school, and was an active church member until he pressed divergent views too strongly and was disfellowshipped by his congregation, at which point he was drawn to the Branch Davidians. . . . Nevertheless, he continued to speak in the ‘prophetic-apocalyptic idiom of Adventism.’ . . . Under his leadership, the Branch Davidians had earnestly pursued Adventists, and were especially successful in gaining recruits in Hawaii, England, and Australia. . . . Consequently, the vast majority of those living, and killed, at Mount Carmel at the time of the BATF and FBI raids had been drawn recently from the ranks of Adventists, where they had often played active and even prominent roles in their congregations. Following Davidian practice, the names of many of them were no doubt still on the rolls of Adventist churches; most of them had family members who were Adventists.179
The following implies that, at least in part, Koresh attempts to attract twenty- to thirty-year-olds: “This is your friend Vernon from Waco, TX. I’m gonna be your orator in regards to sharing with you some things we feel are very important. And I wanna remind you, brothers, that the things I’m gonna show you are strictly biblical. And we’re gonna lay some points together from the Scriptures that are so dynamic and so unreal that hopefully it’ll do for you what it’s done for me and many other people in my own age category.”180 Koresh was born in 1959; he was thirty-three when he died near Passover, 1993. Though most of the converts to the group did indeed come from an Adventist background, Koresh was unsuccessful in attracting a large group. Given Swidler’s work, we should not be surprised. It is notoriously difficult to convince those whose lives are settled to abandon the cultural equipment they have acquired: “Settled cultures constrain action over time because of the high costs of cultural retool178 179 180
Koresh, Letter to Steve. Lawson, “Seventh-day,” 324. Koresh, Voice of Fire.
193
ing to adopt new patterns of action.”181 Davidians demanded that proselytes leave job, family, and church in order to reside at the Waco residence and undergo “cultural retooling.” That the cost was high is hardly debatable. One aspect of proselytizing that the student of sects must attend to has to do with how the group goes about raising up the next generation in the tradition. This usual sectarian concern, however, receives short shrift in the primary materials studied. That children attended the Bible studies is clear because one hears them talking on the cassettes. That the children themselves were immersed in Bible study is indicated when, in interpreting Isa 26:12’s mention of “works” Koresh says, “Even our little children now are studying the Bible. And instead of playing silly games, they play Bible study. And you can ask them if they want a chocolate candy bar and they’ll say point blank, ‘No, that’s not good for my body.’”182 Elsewhere, when treating Isa 3:5 (“the child shall behave himself proudly against the ancient”) he ponders the habit of children not behaving properly in Sabbath school and parents pleading with the children to do so and wonders, “What happened to good ol’ fashioned whippins?”183 Apart from these comments, Koresh does not attend directly to where children fit into the sect’s future. This may be largely explained by the fact that Koresh, like the Apostle Paul before him, did not envision a lengthy future. Creating a Sense of Belonging Any group must create a sense of belonging among the members if it would be successful. As Iannoccone indicates, sects must excel at this because they particularly ask members to sacrifice much. Koresh does not shy away from this; for example, he declares, “It’s going to cost everything to know this truth.”184 Relocating to Texas means sacrificing one’s job, security, and family. He compares his group to Jesus’ group, identifying Jesus as “a bum who didn’t have a job because he quit working and went around preaching, not like the Pharisees and Sadducees who got paid every week.” Peter “put his
181 182 183 184
Swidler, Koresh, Koresh, Koresh,
“Culture,” 284. Judge. Confusion, Pt. 2. Judge.
194
family on welfare and stuff. Those guys suffered, following Jesus around. So, you know, they were considered weird too, putting this Jesus Christ first instead of, you know, their family responsibilities. In those days, Christ was a troublemaker. He busted up families. He called dummies around to be preachers.”185 Clearly, this is a group which expects and finds itself in high tension with its surrounding culture.186 It does not honor traditional family bonds or society’s status standards as they relate to education and careers and the supposed “security” offered therein. One elevated member of the group, Steve, serves as an exemplar: he “wasted” his money on a seminary education, he was kicked out of his church, and, at the time of the recording was “fixin’ to be kicked out of his family.”187 Koresh helps to create a sense of belonging in multifarious ways. The use of jargon, of special language, speaking in code, contributes to group cohesion. Regardless of one’s status from a secular perspective, this group is a place where those limitations or advantages can be overcome. One may have no secular education whatsoever but may be considered quite knowledgeable and educated within the group if one can show that she has mastered necessary subjects. In a veritable enactment of the biblical observation that “the last shall be first and the first shall be last,” the Branch Davidians tend to laud the uneducated among them (Koresh included) and reserve suspicion for the educated. Indeed, more than once Koresh uses one of his prominent followers, Steve, as an example. Steve apparently received seminary training and went into debt to do so. Koresh often bemoans and ridicules that situation, both the training from what Koresh considers ignorant scholars and the idea of charging people to learn about God. As noted earlier he appeals to the idea that Jesus himself was uneducated.188
185
Koresh, Root of Jesse. For instance, he says, “Sabbath-keepers are pushed around and abused and are being mistreated” (Letter to Steve). Interpreting Nah 1:11, Koresh says: He speaks contrary to revealed truth. He tells the people what they should do to that guy who is on the mountains. He is the one that suggests that while we need to do this and that and this it would be a good example for the world to show the world what happens to people who are part of cults. Their object is they want to stop cults and sects (The Shower Head Tape). 187 Koresh, The Bird. 188 Koresh, Radio Sermon. 186
195
He also implies eulogy for the uneducated when he intimates himself as an example: “Maybe some of you are educated; I am not.”189 Those who have status in the group are those who have learned the teachings of Koresh, those who presumably do not falter when, during an interpretation of Rev 10, Koresh asserts: “And Christ comes down to execute Ezekiel nine,” and moves right along without giving a single word of explanation regarding the content of Ezek 9. While the present state of the evidence does not permit a statistical analysis of Koresh’s language, the speeches and papers are marked by the frequent repetition of such special terms as “investigative message,” “judicial message,” “executive judgment,” “wave sheaf,”190 “present truth,” “inspiration,” “loud cry,” “the refreshing,” and “1844.” This is in keeping with Wuthnow’s observation that in order for a group to succeed against its competitors, it must offer something and make access to that something limited to ensure its value. Recall the example of the Ivy League degree, which remains valuable not only because it has been defined as “good” but especially because access to it has been limited. In the same way, Koresh draws boundaries for the group by presenting a unique belief system without definitively delineating beliefs or by peppering the presentation with references to esoteric, historical, philosophical, and theological sources of wisdom. In Koresh’s case he draws upon Scripture, SDA assumptions, the writings of Ellen White and former Davidian leaders, and his own revelations and visions. Concrete rewards inhere in belonging to the group. Koresh purports that others will become Christians when they see the blessings bestowed on the group, including lawn mowers that do not break down, cars that run fast, girls who are plain but beautiful, men who are strong, generosity.191 Salvation is the peculiar inheritance of the Branch Davidians: “But by his everlasting grace he saved us; we are going to enter into that rest as the Bible declared in John and in Luke.”192 Koresh uses the rhetoric of biblical language to draw lines between insiders and outsiders. Just as he elevates the group by labeling them 189
Koresh, Confusion, Pt. 1. Koresh defines “wave sheaf ” as “those who believe in the third, fourth, fifth, and sixth and have received the seventh angel’s message.” Judge. 191 Koresh, Ezekiel 47. 192 Koresh, Judge. 190
196
with laudable biblical sobriquets, he denigrates those who stand outside the group. “Now we’re looking for a certain period of time which we’re not going to explain on this tape because we want to be as wise as serpents and harmless as doves and we don’t want to cast our pearls before swine. And it’s up to each individual to decide whether they’re swine or whether they’re actually the Lord’s children or not. But time will tell.”193 Notice, the full teachings (“pearls”) are reserved for those who have proven themselves to be insiders (“the Lord’s children”) rather than outsiders (“swine”). The ultimate reward belongs to the future. In interpreting Heb 3:1, speaking of Christ, Koresh says: “Yet he endured the shame of this world and he received a greater reward didn’t he? So now let’s consider whether we want to actually live a life like Christ and receive the reward, or whether we want to have our reward now.”194 He encourages perseverance regularly. In the context of interpreting Heb 4:7–10, Koresh exhorts: “So they didn’t endure the trial. In other words, many people say when they come in God’s church; well I can’t make it. I can’t overcome. I’m just gonna go back into the world. Well that shows no faith in what was spoken in the beginning doesn’t it?”195 While he certainly tries to bind the group together cohesively against the group’s opponents, Koresh always keeps a certain level of mistrust among them in order to make certain that each member remains loyal to him first. So, he informs them that looks can be deceiving, that two members can appear to be worshipping exactly the same way, but in actuality one is spiritual and one is carnal. Elsewhere, he criticizes a member of the group who is not there and this prompts another member to mention someone else whose behavior has been less than stellar. Koresh attempts to extract the name of the member from the man speaking. Koresh wants the group to cohere, but the first loyalty must remain to him.
193
Ibid. Koresh, The Seventh. 195 Ibid. His statement also reveals the mutual exclusivity of “the world” and “God’s church,” a theme that recurs often. 194
197
Charting Results It is now fitting to summarize in chart form what a review of the Branch Davidian materials has yielded. The reader will find a minimum of exemplary quotes followed by a list of other relevant references cited by cassette title and counter or page number. The list is not exhaustive but refers only to examples included in this chapter. How Scripture Functions in the Branch Davidians A. BREAKING AWAY: CREATING AND DEGRADING “THEM” “movements that failed to progress” ( Jonah) B. FORMATION OF SECT 1. Etiology: celebrate origins of the community; ground community in the past “From Enoch all the way down to 1844, the judgment of the dead, all those messages are contained in Ellen G. White” ( Judge). 2. Show sect’s founder to have special insight regarding Scripture “But when Brother Houteff came in 1930, he came to seal with the Sabbath seal. . . . Those who were Adventists, who joined the Shepherd’s Rod, became true Sabbath keepers and they received the Sabbath seal” ( Judge). “In 1929, the fourth angel came according to Revelation 14:15. This message came to join the third angel’s message of the dead—Ellen G. White’s message. The message came to announce the imminent judgment of the living. This movement was called The Shepherd’s Rod. It was given the greatest amount of light we’ve had heretofore” (Ezekiel 21). 3. Defining and elevating “us” “That’s the only true Israel, those who believe in the Word” (Letter to Steve). “Brethren, upon hearing these tapes and seeing this truth as written in the Bible, you are being called to be a part of a remnant of those who uphold the Bible and the Bible only as the only rule of faith” (Letter to Steve). “wave sheaf,” “first fruits,” “modern Israel” ( Judge)
198
C. CREATING A DISTINCT WAY OF LIFE 1. Ethical Behavior “There comes a time when sin is done out in the open. For instance, Davidians and Branches, and Adventists never wear shorts, those driven by the spirit of God. Neither do they eat things like meat and defiled foods, especially like depleted white sugar, white flour (etc.). These are abominations to soul temple” (Ezekiel 21). Cf. Confusion, Pt. 2; Judge; Confusion, Pt. 1; Ezekiel 47 2. Ritual practice a. Daily Bible study The Assyrians b. Levitical feasts “This last Passover, those who didn’t keep it with us, they have the mark of the beast” (Ezekiel 47). c. Sabbath observance “This is the God of Sabbath. The Sabbath, the fourth commandment of God, contains the sign and the seal that those who worship on that day worship not a god, but the living God of creation” (The Seventh Angel ). 3. Language and rhetoric “inspiration,” “revelation,” “the 144,000,” “1844,” “present truth,” “Ellen G. White, V. Houteff, B. Roden, L. Roden,” “Branch He” “Branch She,” “wave sheaf,” “antitypical,” “the special resurrection” ( Judge) 4. Use of sacred texts a. The sectarian community as Scripture’s telos “The sixth seal is our period of time. You know that. Doesn’t take a nit-wit to know those kinda things” (What is Truth). Cf. Ezekiel 21; The Assyrian b. Scripture is authoritative “Let’s see what the Bible says” ( Judge). “Being Christian, our foundation is supposed to be the Bible. . . . I’m building up to this point: we’re supposed to be Christians who are founded upon a sacred parchment known as the Bible which is a record of men who have gone before” (Voice of Fire).
199
Cf. Radio Sermon; What is Truth?; Voice of Fire; Ezekiel 21; The Seventh Angel; Letter to Steve and the Wisconsin Brethren 5. Roles of authoritative leaders a. Former leaders: William Miller, Ellen G. White, Victor Houteff [F. Houteff is not mentioned], Ben Roden, Lois Roden “In other words, we want to know who the Lord’s feet are according to Zech 14. So therefore, if Uzziah represents Victor Houteff then Jotham must represent Brother Roden and Ahaz Sister Roden and then Hezekiah must also represent the seventh angel’s message. In other words we’re taking from Brother Roden’s writings and showing that Victor Houteff was Uzziah, then Jotham would be Brother Roden. Sister Roden would be Ahaz and Vernon Howell, the seventh angel’s message, would be Hezekiah” ( Judge). “We see these four angels as Sister White, Brother Houteff, Brother Roden, and Sister Roden” (The Seventh Angel ). “And the only plan of salvation there is is contained in the everlasting gospel presented by William Miller. . . . You’ll also find that same gospel continued on by Ellen G. White, picked up again by Brother Houteff, also found through Brother Roden’s message. Sister Roden’s. And there is a seventh angel too” (Ezekiel 21). b. David Koresh 1. The leader is righteous, chosen by God or otherwise admirable “You may not, by asking God, understand the mysteries of God. God will do nothing but reveal his secret to his servants the prophets. Should you, should you receive an enlightened message from God then you’ll be sittin’ here and I’ll be sittin’ out there” (Confusion, Pt. 1). 2. Unjustly persecuted The Assyrians 3. Privy to special insight “But by the mercy of God, God allowed me to have such a wonderful vision and a wonderful understanding of the seventh angel’s message” ( Judge). 4. Warrants fidelity and belief; salvation depends on one’s stance vis-à-vis him “You reject Cyrus, you reject God” (Ancient of Days).
200
“How do you depart from the living God, Branches? Well you depart from the living voice, don’t you? The living mouthpiece, right? No Prophet—no truth. That’s the rule” (The Seventh Angel). Cf. The Assyrians; A Letter to Australia; Judge; The Bird; The Seventh Angel; Ezekiel 47 6. Definition of the future The Assyrians; Letter to Steve and the Wisconsin Brethren; Judge D. OPPOSITION TO AND FROM THE PARENT TRADITION 1. Named opponents “The Adventists didn’t regard [Ben Roden]” (Ezekiel 21). 2. Those who break Scripture “The Adventist church is a rejected church. They are not God’s people. They have not been for years. You see? That’s why they had no commission in the world. They haven’t ever preached the Sabbath as it is to be preached. They don’t keep it as it is to be kept. They know nothing of it cause they have no spirit of prophecy” (The Shower Head Tape). E. OPPOSITION FROM WITHIN THE SECT: DEALING WITH DEFECTION 1. Reward adherence to the sect “lawn mowers that don’t break down, cars that run fast, girls who are plain but beautiful, men who are strong, not stingy” (Ezekiel 47) 2. Castigate potential and actual deserters The Assyrians; The Seventh Angel; Ezekiel 47; The Foundation; Judge F. OPPOSITION TO AND FROM WITHOUT 1. The (non-Adventist) church “And yet you know as well as I do that they’re no different than the world is. The world and the church go hand in hand today” (Voice of Fire). Cf. The Assyrians; Letter to Australia; Ezekiel 21; Radio Sermon 2. The world The Ammonites of Ezek 21:28 are “people of the world” (Ezekiel 21). “And these messages hold, or keep the persecution of the world away from the church” ( Judge).
201
3. The government “the beast represents the earthly governments” ( Judge). 4. Scholars The Assyrians; Radio Sermon G. JUDGMENT AGAINST OPPONENTS 1. Against parent tradition “Now we know that Idumea represents the fleshly Jews and also the modern SDA and Davidian groups who have not progressed with present truth . . . And verse fourteen of Ezekiel 35 tells us that when all the earth shall rejoice, the Lord’s going to execute his judgments upon the Adventist people and upon, well, Zechariah 14 is going to be fulfilled also at that time” ( Judge). 2. Against sect-defectors “But if they would not accept that truth then the truth in the end would judge them because they would try to establish their own righteousness and they would lose out, the same as many Branches have done these days” ( Judge). 3. Against the world “Fools!! Get wise, wisdom says!! Get wise!! The man on the white horse comes first!! That’s Psalms 1, that’s Psalms 2, that’s Psalms 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8!! Learn ’em!! That’s what God says is going to happen!! Do you hear?! Do you understand!! It’s war!!! These governments of this world are coming to an end (The Foundation).” H. GROWING THE SECT 1. Proselytizing “Brethren, upon hearing these tapes and seeing this truth as written in the Bible, you are being called to be a part of a remnant of those who uphold the Bible and the Bible only as the only rule of faith” (Letter to Steve). “I am trying to proselate [sic]” (The Bird ). Cf. What is Truth? Voice of Fire; Radio Sermon 2. The next generation
202
Conclusion
The Branch Davidians under David Koresh manifest typical sect characteristics and concerns and almost without exception use Scripture to achieve certain ends necessary for the sect to succeed. Comparing the primary evidence with Bainbridge’s chart of factors that either increase or decrease tension between the sect and its surrounding sociocultural environments, I surmise that the group experienced high tension. The group never grew out of minority status and never developed a bureaucratic leadership, both factors which would have reduced tension; rather, it emphasized specific compensators for the apparent lack of worldly success (e.g., being part of the elect who would receive salvation on judgment day). Koresh was one in a line of charismatic leaders who sought to heighten rather than reduce tension. Scripture anchored the group at a high level of tension, especially because the apocalyptic books of Revelation and Daniel stood at the center of the group’s attention. Though the sect included members who had been raised as Davidians, converts constituted the majority of the group. The raising up of a new generation of members born into the group is usually considered a factor that decreases tension, whereas attending primarily to the needs of converts increases it. Raising a new generation did not emerge as a fundamental concern of the group; this may be explained by the apocalyptic worldview of the sect. Apocalyptic groups expect an imminent eschaton and therefore focus their attention on conversion rather than on establishing long-range plans involving the next generation. The external evidence bears out the correctness of my hypothesis that the Davidians remained in high tension with their surrounding sociocultural environment. First, their government considered them deviant enough to warrant an almost unprecedented attack with weapons usually reserved for war, namely, tanks and CS gas. Second, the official response of their parent tradition, Seventh-Day Adventism, was to distance itself from the sect.196 In order to do so, they hired 196 Scholars agree that Seventh-Day Adventism has sought to reduce its tension with the surrounding society and has largely succeeded. As recently as 1992 the North American Division of Seventh-Day Adventists claimed: Adventists have often been thought of as a sect or cult. . . . But Adventists have always looked upon themselves as being in solidarity with historic Christianity. . . . Seventh-Day Adventists hold to the central core truths of Christian faith. . . . [They] meet all the criteria of an authentic church. The idea of cult or sect does not apply. Lawson, “Seventh-Day,” 327.
203
professional consultants who presented a crisis management plan to the General Conference of Seventh-Day Adventists, which stated the following goals: “To successfully distinguish the Davidian Cult from the Seventh-Day Adventist Church, ensuring public support for Seventh-Day Adventism as a mainstream religion, providing spiritual guidance, disaster relief, education and health care services to millions of people worldwide.”197 In addition, the local Adventist pastor in Waco spearheaded a Waco-wide and an Adventist-wide special offering to donate to the families of the officers killed in the attempt at a “dynamic entry”; no attention was paid to the families of the deceased Branch Davidians. Recognizing that both the SDA parent tradition and the United States government of 1993 were opposed to the sect helps to explain its defeat. Recall Swidler’s insistence that in order to understand why one ideology prevails over another one must attend to “the structural constraints and historical circumstances within which ideological movements struggle for dominance.”198 In the cases of the Branch Davidians and Qumran, it is the conflict with the government, not the parent tradition, that was fatal. Interestingly, both communities expected persecution from the godless government, as attested in their written and oral texts. The Fourth Gospel, on the other hand, shows little concern with the government as a persecuting force, and there is no evidence that the community was destroyed by the government. In fact, the existence of the Johannine Epistles indicates that the community perdured. For the Qumranians, the structural constraints and historical circumstances that most impacted their community were being a Jewish group during the Roman campaign of 66–72 .. against Palestine, which resulted in the destruction of the Second Temple. For the Davidians, the constraints and circumstances may be described in terms of a confluence of conservative groups whose aim is to eradicate groups they have identified as “cults,” United States government internal politics especially regarding the BATF and FBI, the secular nature of both the government and the media that disallowed an understanding of the group, the
For a review of the relevant arguments, see Lawson, “Seventh-Day” and Bainbridge, Sociology, 89–118. See also Laura Vance, Seventh-Day Adventism in Crisis: Gender and Sectarian Change in an Emerging Religion (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1999). 197 Lawson, “Seventh-Day,” 329. 198 Swidler, “Culture,” 280.
204
rejection by the official body of Seventh-Day Adventists, and numerous other factors. Not only must one ask “how concrete structural circumstances affect the relative success of competing cultural systems,”199 as I have just done, but one must also ask “how the capacity of particular ideas, rituals, and symbols to organize given kinds of action affects the historical opportunities actors are able to seize.”200 To address the latter would involve two tasks: first, to ask what factors led those who lived at Mt. Carmel to come there in the first place. Some Adventist publications tried to address that question in the aftermath of the destruction, citing various strains in Adventist theology as primary factors. Sociologists of sectarianism usually explain the attraction in terms of social status and arrive at the conclusion that most sectarians have little to lose and much to gain by joining a sect. Converts tend to be poor, uneducated, and have a minority status in terms of gender or race. Of the eighty members living there, some were English, some were American, some were Caribbean, and some were Australian. Some of the older members had come as children with their parents when the Rodens were the leaders and had, in turn, raised their own children in the group. Many of the residents were children who had come with their parents under Koresh, and no small number were children born of various women but sharing Koresh as father. It is not difficult to discern why they stayed. Like the earliest founders of Adventism, not to mention most of the authors, the Davidians believed in the imminent Parousia. Having studied and believed Revelation, they expected to be persecuted by both apostate churches and, most especially, by Babylon, that is, the government. The attack by the government only validated their interpretation of Scripture and put them in the position to make one of two choices: to obey God or human beings. As Philip Arnold argues in his article, “The Davidian Dilemma: To Obey God or Man?”201 the choice was clear for them. As most scholars have noted, given their cultural toolkit, the one way they could have both obeyed God
199
Ibid. Ibid. 201 Philip Arnold, “The Davidian Dilemma: To Obey God or Man?” in From the Ashes: Making Sense of Waco (ed. James R. Lewis; Lanham, Md.: Rowman and Littlefield, 1994), 23–32. 200
205
and survived would have been to understand Scripture in a different way. Both Tabor and Arnold argued with Koresh via cassette (because the government would not allow them to speak directly to him) that, in fact, there was another way to interpret a specific passage of Revelation that would require Koresh to live and spread his message. Koresh was in the process of doing just that when the government decided to attack anyway. Both groups, the government agencies and the Davidians, operated from extremely rigid and all-encompassing cultures, which made the disaster likely.202 It may be easily argued that the Davidians understood the government much better than the government understood the Davidians. In this competition between the two cultural systems, the strategies of actions available and chosen resulted in the demise of Mt. Carmel. The high-tension Davidians maintained the high ideology already characterized by Swidler. When a group is struggling to establish itself and is vying for dominance, one should expect explicit and rigorous demands concerning belief and behavior. This ideology will conflict with the traditions and common sense assumed in the surrounding culture as the group attempts to establish new strategies of action. Koresh doggedly exhorted, instructed, corrected, and shaped the beliefs and actions of those residing at Mt. Carmel, all the while
202 In her article, “Waco,” Ammerman argues cogently and compellingly that the culture of law enforcement either caused or largely contributed to the debacle. She details the various strains that conjoined to create the mentality and actions of the agencies, not only the “culture of disbelief,” which had the most impact on decisions, but also the attitudes of those whose own religious beliefs contributed to their animosity toward the Davidians. She describes (284–92) the law enforcement stance: During our first round of briefings, especially in our conversations with the hostage negotiators who had been involved in Waco, the most striking finding was the FBI’s near total dismissal of the religious beliefs of the Branch Davidians. . . . They saw no reason to try to understand his religious beliefs, indeed thought them so bizarre as to be incomprehensible by normal people. The negotiators expressed deep regret at this state of affairs, but could see no alternatives to the way they had come to understand the situation. The tactical commanders had no real regret, seeing the final outcome as unavoidable. . . . The tendency to discount the influence of religious beliefs and to evaluate situations largely in terms of a leader’s individual criminal or psychological motives is, I believe, very widespread in the FBI. In our initial briefings with negotiators and tacticians, the consensus around the table was that when they encountered people with religious beliefs, those beliefs were usually a convenient cover for criminal activity. They continued to refer to the members of the group as hostages, failing to recognize the free choice those people had made in following Koresh.
206
knowing and admitting the conflict with the traditions of the surrounding culture: “What we’re trying to do is we’re trying to bust up your foundation like this concrete out here.”203 With Swidler, I contend that “strategies of action are cultural products; the symbolic experiences, mythic lore, and ritual practices of a group or society create moods and motivations, ways of organizing experience and evaluating reality, modes of regulating conduct, and ways of forming social bonds, which provide resources for constructing strategies of action.”204 For the Davidians, the single most significant “chunk of culture” used to create culture is Scripture. Earlier in the chapter I noted that the Davidians indeed had two of the three features necessary to enjoy significance, that is, providing ethical instruction for members and their children and encouraging worship. I now add the third: drawing individuals into an intimate community. Clearly, Koresh succeeded in his use of Scripture to effect an allencompassing worldview out of which his followers acted.
203 204
Koresh, The Assyrians. Swidler, “Culture,” 284.
CHAPTER FIVE
THE COMMUNITY OF THE FOURTH GOSPEL
In every family worthy of the name, there are especial stories that so early amuse, then later so tickle and tantalize memory that the phrase which recalls one of them becomes a shibboleth in the family. These are in-jokes, the use of which can leave an outsider so puzzled and bewildered in the presence of collective hilarity that explanations are in order, albeit convolutedly forthcoming. Ferrol Sams, “Harmony Ain’t Easy”
Most of the details regarding the social situation of the Fourth Gospel continue to elude scholars. We do not know with any certainty who wrote the Fourth Gospel, where it was written, or when it assumed its final form. It is reasonable to posit a late first-century date for the final redaction. Irenaeus ascribes authorship to the beloved disciple of John 13:23 whom he identifies as John, one of the twelve disciples. Others have nominated Lazarus, John Mark, or other “Johns.” Irenaeus names Ephesus as the Gospel’s provenance, though Alexandria and Antioch have also been suggested.1 This chapter will primarily attend to an analysis of the passages in which scriptural quotations are central to discover how they may or may not contribute to the repertory of things that sects need to do in order to establish and sustain themselves. Because there is no direct evidence of how the scriptural echoes functioned for the Johannine community, I will rely on educated imagination, the Johannine Epistles, and the evidence studied from the two groups about whom I do have more concrete evidence, namely, the Qumranians and the Davidians. Two cautionary notes on methodology are in order. First, in relying upon the proposed theoretical framework posited in chapter two as well as its application in chapters three and four, I do not
1 For a synopsis of the various positions, see Raymond Brown, The Gospel According to John, I–XII (AB; New York: Doubleday, 1966), LXXX–CIV.
208
intend to force the evidence from the Johannine material into a mold created from the analysis of Qumran and the Branch Davidians; rather, I use the previous investigations to understand how or if a given instance of scriptural quotation, along with its context, might contribute to the Johannine community’s success, given my understanding of what it must achieve to succeed. Second, the Fourth Gospel is written in narrative form2 and tells the story of the sojourn on earth of the Word made flesh. After the hymnic Prologue, the narrative commences with the appearance of John the Baptist and relates a three-year ministry on the part of Jesus of Nazareth climaxing with his crucifixion and resurrection. Unlike the materials studied for the Branch Davidians and the Qumranians, the genre of the Johannine material is narrative. So, in addition to the issue addressed in chapter two, how Scripture functions in the formative discourse of a sect, a further methodological question must be asked: how does a narrative function in a sect when the narrative incorporates scriptural interpretation? This can be broken down into two subtopics: (1) roles of narrative in the life of a sect and (2) roles of Scripture and its interpretation when embedded in or implied by narrative.
Roles of Narrative in the Life of a Sect No one has undertaken systematic inquiry regarding either of the two questions, both of which deserve a full-scale study. In treating the first, roles of narrative in the life of a sect, it would make sense to collect narratives belonging to various sects (sects preferably representing a broad temporal and geographical spectrum) and study their function within the groups. The present study, of course, has the use of Scripture, not the use of narrative, at its center, and, as a result the materials chosen from the Branch Davidian and Qumran cultures highlight Scripture, not narrative. Absent a theory regarding the roles of narrative in the life of a sect, I will take my lead from work done in the sociology of religion and from adumbrative efforts on the part of both Meeks and Martyn.
2 For an analysis of the Fourth Gospel as a narrative, replete with plot and characters, see Culpepper, Anatomy.
209
Three decades ago, Wayne Meeks sought to understand the social function that myth may have had for the Johannine community. In “developing [his] own method” he drew upon the work of V. Turner, J. Z. Smith, and W. D. O’ Flaherty. He writes: I shall argue that one function of the “symbolic universe” communicated in this remarkable body of literature was to make sense of all these aspects of the group’s history. More precisely, there must have been a continuing dialectic between the group’s historical experience and the symbolic world which served both to explain that experience and to motivate and form the reaction of group members to the experience. In the following pages an attempt is made to discern the function which the motif “ascent and descent” serves, first, within the literary structure of the Fourth Gospel, then, by analogy, within the structure of the Johannine community and its relationships to its environment.3
Similarly, I contend that the narrative form of the Fourth Gospel serves to equip the Johannine Christians with a symbolic universe that helps them to make sense of their historical experience, “to explain that experience and to motivate and form the reaction of group members to the experience.” Just as Meeks moves by analogy from the literary level of the text to the social level, so do I. The same method is employed by J. Louis Martyn. Like Meeks, Martyn argues that the Fourth Gospel reflects the lived experience of the Johannine community. Noting that the Fourth Gospel did not “drop from heaven straight into our time,” Martyn seeks to flesh out the historical community signified by the Fourth Gospel: Our first task, however, is to say something as specific as possible about the actual circumstances in which John wrote his Gospel. How are we to picture daily life in John’s church? Have elements of its peculiar daily experiences left their stamp on the Gospel penned by one of its members? May one sense even in its exalted cadences the voice of a Christian theologian who writes in response to contemporary events and issues which concern, or should concern, all members of the Christian community in which he lives? If we should encounter data in the Gospel which indicate an affirmative answer to these questions—and we shall do so very shortly—it becomes imperative that we make every effort to take up temporary residence in the Johannine community. We must see with the eyes and hear with the ears of that community. We must sense at least some of the crises that helped to shape the lives of its members. And we must
3
Meeks, “Man from Heaven,” 49–50.
210
listen carefully to the kind of conversations in which all of its members found themselves engaged.4
Throughout his analysis of the Fourth Gospel, Martyn argues by analogy. He describes the Fourth Gospel as a two-level drama, designating the first the einmalig, or the “once upon a time” level as opposed to the “here and now” level, which comprises the second level.5 About this methodological approach he insists: “We cannot be satisfied, however, merely to speak of the evangelist’s art. We must ask whether in his composition it is possible to detect specific reflections of some definite situation in the life of his church. To this end we may find it illuminating to formulate our questions as we transpose the narrative into a more developed dramatic form.”6 Like Martyn, I assume that the Fourth Gospel is a narrative that purports to relate events that occurred ca. 30 .., not a dispassionate church history that overtly recounts late first century events. This means that in every case I will have to ask whether the implied use in the Gospel’s own rhetorical situation approximates the narrated use in Jesus’ situation. Recall Robert Wuthnow’s observation about narrative as a powerful tool in the life of a religious community: [Narrative’s] fundamental characteristic is the unfolding of events according to a temporal sequence. Narrative is thus especially well suited for connecting moral prescriptions with tradition. Narrative also tends to be self contained; it employs a high degree of intratextuality or selfreferencing. As such it is not easily disconfirmed by outside events or alternative stories. Understanding the narrative requires the listener to enter into its own internal logic. Narrative also invites this sort of identification between the listener and characters in the story. Whether there is true intersubjectivity between the subject and the text or not, the text suggests there is.7
My approach will approximate Wuthnow’s “dramaturgic approach” as presented in chapter two where he claims that “what is given off” may be as important as what is “given.”8
4 5 6 7 8
Martyn, History, 18. Ibid., 29–30, especially p. 29 n. 22. Ibid., 27. Wuthnow, Producing, 164. Wuthnow, Meaning, 13–14.
211
So, Meeks, Martyn, and Wuthnow all attest to the social function served by narrative. Narrative helps the auditors make sense out of their lived experiences. It both draws one into a particular symbolic universe and then insists that one has to be a part of the special group in order to fully understand and use the language of that universe meaningfully. In this way, it creates boundaries for the group between insider and outsider.
Roles of Scripture Embedded in a Narrative The second issue, roles of Scripture and its interpretation when embedded in or implied by narrative, has also been neglected. We might expect a literary-critical monograph such as Alan Culpepper’s Anatomy of the Fourth Gospel: A Study in Literary Design, which patently deals with the Fourth Gospel as narrative, to account for the frequent presence of Scripture, the intertextuality of the narrative. It does not. Martyn has demonstrated how we might move from narrative to social history and he insists upon the importance of tradition for the Fourth Gospel, but he does not treat “Scripture” under the rubric of tradition. In fact, he does not mention the use of Scripture. Still, the presentation of his own method holds promise for mine. In response to his own question, “How shall we sharpen our senses so as to perceive elements in the Gospel which are clues to the circumstances in which it was written?” he responds: “A word about the role of tradition in early Christian thought may help us find such an approach.” Martyn claims: The early church shared with many groups of its time a concern for tradition which exceeds by far that known to most of us. The past— specific events and teachings of the past—lived on with power and somehow mingled with events of the present. To the ancients it was far more obvious than it is to us that one’s response to contemporary issues involves careful consideration of the tradition inherited from one’s forebears. Indeed it was responsible contemporary involvement which most often sharpened the sense of need for tradition and which is therefore mainly to be thanked for preserving the voice of the past. Of course not everyone in the early church viewed alike the relationship between a concern for tradition and effective involvement in contemporary issues. One of the most pressing needs in New Testament study may be a careful analysis of the various ways which the New Testament authors viewed this relationship. No one will want to insist,
212
I think, that the problem of connecting past traditions with current concerns is viewed in precisely the same way by, say, Paul and Matthew. Yet each has wrestled long and honestly and effectively with just this problem, and a priori there is no reason to doubt that each may have a much-needed word for us as we face the same problem.9
Though his appraisal of the situation was and remains accurate, Martyn himself never takes up in detail the relationship between Scripture (though it clearly stands as part of John’s tradition) and effective involvement in contemporary issues. Martyn finds in the Fourth Gospel more than narrative; he finds drama, and it is drama which seeks to encounter the auditor as more than art, as theology. I suggest that the Fourth Gospel is also a sermon, religious discourse composed for the benefit of an audience. I am interested then, in the influence and interplay of Scripture and interpreter for the sake of this community. How does Scripture work for communities who have it? What effect does its use have upon individuals and communities? What are the overt reasons for calling upon Scripture? What are the covert reasons? Power? Identity formation? The structuring of a symbolic world and a worldview? An attempt to motivate conformity or deviance or both? To date, it is those sociologists who have begun to ask about how narrative and Scripture work within sermons whose work has been the most suggestive for answering the second issue. Susan Harding, a sociologist of religion, has attended to the complex nexus of factors that may affect the efficacy of the deployment of Scripture by a narrative preacher. In her work, “The Gospel of Giving: The Narrative Construction of a Sacrificial Economy,”10 she analyzes Jerry Falwell’s use of Scripture and narrative to achieve certain fund-raising goals for his ministry. She specifically focuses on a sermon that Falwell delivered at Liberty Baptist College’s first chapel service in fall 1978. In it, Falwell asks God to supply five million dollars for the school by September 24, 1978, which Falwell designated “Miracle Day.” After exclaiming the need, Falwell went on to preach a sermon from Joshua. Harding quotes from an authorized biography:
9
Martyn, History, 18–19. Susan Harding, “The Gospel of Giving: The Narrative Construction of a Sacrificial Economy,” in Vocabularies of Public Life: Empirical Essays in Symbolic Structure (ed. Robert Wuthnow; London: Routledge, 1992), 39–56. 10
213
He described the people of Israel and their situation as they faced the high strong walls of Jericho. The Thomas Road Baptist Church was facing similar obstacles. “The Jews had come through four hundred years of bondage. God delivered them from the Red Sea by the hand of Moses, and after forty years of wandering in the wilderness, delivered them from the river Jordan by the hand of Joshua. They had come far by faith, but now, having arrived in the Promised Land, they found the walls of Jericho immovable. The inhabitants of Jericho had been reported to Joshua to be ‘giants.’ Everything seemed lost to the children of God. Defeat seemed imminent.” Jerry drew a parallel: “Liberty Mountain is our Promised Land. For many years we have prayed for this thirty-five hundred acres of sanctified property. After twenty-two years of miracles, we have arrived on Liberty Mountain. But now we find ourselves looking up at the high walls of bills and unfinished buildings. A miracle is needed.” The students listened attentively as their chancellor told how Joshua met the unseen Captain. The Lord assured Joshua of victory and gave him the plan for it. The Jews were told to march around the walls once a day for six days. Then, on the seventh day, they were to march around seven times. The men of war were to march up front. The seven priests with trumpets of rams’ horns were to march directly behind them each day, sounding the trumpets all the way. The ark of the covenant would be carried in their midst. The congregation was to follow the ark. Drawing an analogy between men of war and prayer warriors, Jerry called for thousands of local prayer warriors to “walk point,” symbolic of those who go first into battle. He asked millions who were watching by television to do the same. He assured the prayer warriors that, as they circled the walls of impossibility, the preachers at Thomas Road would keep preaching and sounding forth the message of the gospel. He asked Christians of North America to join with him on this trek of faith and pray with them for a miracle. On each of the six days preceding the September 24 ‘Miracle Day,’ Jerry drove along the circumference road of Liberty Mountain, an 11.3 mile trip. He began at the main entrance of the college and prayed continually as he drove. On Sunday, September 24, Jerry rose early and encircled the mountain seven times—79.1 miles—before the early church service at Thomas Road. The offering that day and from the previous six weeks totaled more than $7 million. $2 million more than what had been prayed for. People stood and wept and praised God who loves to answer the prayers of his people.11
11 Gerald Strober and Ruth Tomczak, Jerry Falwell: Aflame for God (Nashville: Nelson, 1979), 79–81; quoted in Harding, “The Gospel,” 40–41.
214
A number of Harding’s observations about how Falwell’s sermons “worked” are suggestive for my project. First, neither the biographers nor perhaps Falwell himself completed the story of the walls of Jericho in their narrations; they did not have to; their audiences knew the rest of the scriptural story from previous experience with Scripture. Likewise, when reading the Fourth Gospel, we should remember that most, if not all, of the Johannine sectarians were familiar with Scripture. Second, Harding notes: “From the beginning, Falwell interlaced Joshua’s tale with a second, contemporary, story that reiterated with exquisite precision and updated details the same tests of faith and imagination evoked by the first.”12 The author of the Fourth Gospel has done as much and even more. He has not only interlaced Scripture with the story of Jesus and his first disciples, but has also interlaced all of that with his own community’s story. To explain Falwell’s interlacing of the old and the contemporary to a largely secular discipline of sociology, she writes: Both these stories are entirely true. Indeed, they are not simply “true stories,” they are “storied events.” Event and story in fundamentalist discourse have not been torn asunder. Biblical narrators, past and present, are literally historians. They tell histories, the way things actually happened. Their stories do not represent history, they are history. Likewise, the connections that appointed narrators propose between one story, such as Joshua’s, and another, such as Jerry’s, are not mere filaments of interpretation tying tales together in some folk Imaginary. They are historical tissues, sinews of divine purpose, design, and will that join concrete events across millennia.13
In presenting the case thus, Harding virtually echoes Martyn’s own understanding of the connection between tradition and contemporary issues felt by early Christians: “The past—specific events and teachings of the past—lived on with power and somehow mingled with events of the present.”14 Harding’s work is also useful in reminding the student of the Fourth Gospel that various factors impinged upon the original audience’s hearing of the text. The original auditors did not hear the text in a vacuum any more than modern auditors do. Regarding Falwell’s appeal, she maintains that the auditors
12 13 14
Ibid., 43. Ibid. Martyn, History, 18.
215
filtered his appeal through an endless mesh of traces and presuppositions: other tellings of Joshua’s tale, including the biblical text, and a variety of commentaries on the story; a set of side texts and contexts— other stories and storied situations in Falwell’s discursive church which framed and infilled his appeal that sunny afternoon; and a characteristically fundamentalist Baptist set of preconceptions about how juxtaposed stories, their characters, and their outcomes are related as divinely designed events.15
Typology serves as one way that juxtaposed ancient and contemporary stories work for both Falwell’s, Koresh’s, and the authors’ audiences, including the Fourth Gospel’s.16 We might ask two questions of the author of the Fourth Gospel: Why narrative? and Why Scripture? We might argue that the author could just as easily state her propositions and consider her task completed. But, as Wuthnow reminds us, narrative functions particularly well for achieving certain ends. Likewise, to ask the author of the Fourth Gospel to simply “make his point” without clothing it in biblical language and symbolism would reveal the outsider position of the inquirer. Harding’s argument regarding the Falwell fund-raising campaign speaks to the student of the Fourth Gospel: All this translates into money rather elegantly and, under the influence of a master preacher such as Falwell, amply. The pitch, no matter how it is dressed up biblically, sounds to the unborn-again ear like mere fund-raising (“Send us money so we can build a college”). But the biblical attire is everything to the faithful. An appeal for sacrificial giving catches them up in a sacred enactment of core gospel meanings. Just as Joshua obeyed God and was, necessarily, blessed, so was Jerry, and so will they be. They too will complete Joshua’s story, not only through prayer but through sacrificial giving.17
All of the sects under study here demand great sacrifice from their members, even unto death. The sectarians view themselves in continuity with biblical characters and injunctions, and they are taught 15
Harding, “The Gospel,” 44. Among others, Harding explores mountain typology over the course of a few years in Falwell’s fund-raising efforts, from Ararat to Sinai, to Moses’ viewing the Promised Land from a mountain, to Jesus’ ascension, etc. When Falwell later “fashioned himself as Joshua on the verge of the Promised Land, the scene was already heavily saturated with mountainous biblical innuendos. Jerry was not only Joshua, but a touch (at least) of Noah, Abraham, Moses, Elijah, Haggai, and Christ himself. His gathered church resembled their gatherings, their peoples. His and his church’s trials, persecutions, sacrifices, and triumphs fulfilled theirs.” Ibid., 47. 17 Ibid., 51. 16
216
that struggle and sacrifice are both inevitable and heavily rewarded with blessings of various sorts. All of this is to say that, far from being a mere shell that can be discarded once the pearl inside has been retrieved, the narrative and scriptural form of the materials studied are themselves part of the pearl. Recall Steven Fraade’s words: Cultural history requires us to take seriously the forms by which a culture transmits its knowledge, and thereby shapes its members’ competencies and self-conceptions. As Roger Chartier asks: “How are we to understand the ways in which the form that transmits a text to its readers or hearers constrains the production of its meaning? The appropriation of discourse is not something that happens without rules or limits. Writing deploys strategies that are meant to produce effects, dictate a posture, and oblige the reader. . . . If we want to understand the appropriations and interpretations of a text in their full historicity, we need to identify the effects in terms of meaning that its material forms produced.”18
The work of Marsha Witten as presented earlier contributes to the present discussion. From the outset she identifies herself as an intellectual descendant of Robert Wuthnow. As such, she contends: Sociologists of religion are criticizing meaning-centered approaches to culture (for example, symbolic analysis (Bellah 1970; Berger 1969) and thick description (Geertz 1973)) as overly subjective and are calling for more systematic methods for analyzing religious practices, doctrines and discourse (see, for example, Wuthnow 1987) [Meaning and Moral Order]. Instead of attempting to pin down the meaning of worship practices, or of religious talk, for participants—a nearly impossible task because meaning can vary so widely among people, depending on their situations, prior experiences, competence in the communicative code, and so forth—the analyst is urged to discover the conditions that make behaviors meaningful. This can be done by exploring the context and form of the practices and discourse. On the broad environmental level, the conditions of meaningfulness may be sought by examining, for example, the institutional contexts within which people act; on the microscopic level, by studying the internal structure or the practice of discourse itself (Wuthnow 1987).19
To demonstrate this approach, Witten seeks to illustrate how such an examination of the internal formal properties of a text may be a useful tool in the study of religious discourse, by the in-depth analysis of the narratives used in a fundamentalist Christian sermon. My concern here is not with what the sermon means, but 18 19
Fraade, “Looking,” 75. Witten, “Restriction,” 19.
217
with the way in which the structure of the information it presents makes its messages meaningful, delimiting and disambiguating the messages it communicates. In other words, I explore how the text exploits what Northrop Frye (1982) would term its “centripetal tendency”: structures of information that turn in on themselves, close meaning down, license or authorize a particular set of messages, discourage plural readings. To do so, I examine features in and among the narratives in the text that create a tight structural coherence, a relatively “airless” textual space, that present the sermon as a hermetic entity, a self-reinforcing utterance. Although this paper is devoted to the analysis of one sermon in depth, the method I display here would seem to offer much promise for the systematic, comparative study of the degree of disambiguation in religious texts in general.20
Lest suspicions arise concerning Witten’s usefulness for the present project because the Fourth Gospel is not a fundamentalist sermon, it is worth highlighting Witten’s statement that the approach should apply to other religious texts as well.21 Recall Witten’s focus on three mechanisms which, through narrative, serve to delimit and disambiguate the sermon’s messages and restrict its meaning: compactness, coherence, and redundancy of communicative structures. Individual stories within the sermon give discourse “the possibility of radical compactness while at the same time maintaining a high degree of coherence.”22 The Seneca story serves as an example of that compactness. The second element, coherence, Witten describes as the “extent to which elements in the text ‘stick together,’ rely on one another for their meaning, create an ‘airless’ textual structure.”23 Stories are especially suited to coherence because they do not require reference to or evidence drawn from the world outside the story. Witten uses a mathematical formula to measure coherence in terms of both lexical and grammatical connections. The process need not detain us here; it is enough to note that a text that shows a high degree of lexical and grammatical connectedness limits the possible meanings. Redundancy restricts meaning: Insofar as a text is redundant, it places limits on the amount of total information it communicates, thus heightening its interpretive predictability; redundancy constitutes a “surplus of communication” regarding 20
Ibid., 20. In fact, Witten herself intends to apply the method to conservative and liberal sermons as well. Ibid., 33 n. 2. 22 Ibid., 22. 23 Ibid., 24. 21
218
the same information, augmenting the probability that its message will be transmitted unambiguously (Suleiman 1983: 55).24
Drawing upon the work of Susan Suleiman, Witten lists the following as possible redundancies among narratives: 1. Several characters have the same qualities (or a single character displays the same qualities throughout the story). In the particular sermon analyzed by Witten, the stories typically contained characters who were “lost” (e.g., Seneca) and, conversely, characters who were “settled.” In all stories where a minister appeared, the minister played the role of “settled” person, the person with the correct answers to the meaning of life. 2. Goals of several characters’ actions are the same (or a single character displays the same goals throughout the story). In the second quarter of the sermon, for example, each story portrays a single character or group who desires some resource that may hold the answer to life. 3. Actions of several characters are the same (or a single character displays the same actions throughout). Each of the “lost” characters mentioned above relies on worldly structures of action (such as questing for knowledge, conducting scientific experiments). 4. Means of actions of several characters are the same. 5. Outcomes of several characters’ actions are the same. All of those characters fail. 6. The context is metonymically redundant with the character. This category is not applicable to the sermon Witten analyzes because no context is given. 7. Several characters pronounce the same interpretive commentary (or a single character repeatedly does so). 8. An event is redundant with the interpretive commentary made by a character concerning it. 24
Ibid., 25.
219
As an example of (1), in many of the sermon’s thirteen different narratives, the preacher presents two characters, one in the position of being “lost” and the other in an admirably settled state who attempts to lead the “lost” person to truth. Not only are the characters’ qualities the same, but so are their actions: the lost person asks and listens, the found person answers. The outcomes are the same: those questing for knowledge outside the purview of Christianity fail. This is what Witten means by redundancy on the level of individual stories. Witten examines redundancy not simply at the story level or level of narrative discourse, but also “structural parallels between the story content and the narrator’s interpretive commentary.”25 Witten proposes that narrative or interpretive commentary can take three forms. First, narrative commentary can create tension between itself and the story’s message (by denying its plausibility, by using irony, by expressing caveats about its “truth”). Second, it can remain neutral by simply reporting the story. Finally, it can affirm the story’s content. In the sermon analyzed, the commentary was always redundant with the story’s result. So if the story implied a failure, as did the first twelve, the preacher affirmed that, indeed, failure had occurred. The thirteenth story, the only “positive” story in the sermon, narrates the preacher’s discovering the answer to the meaning of life on a highway billboard that declares: “Jesus is the answer.” The narrator, who in this case is the preacher, immediately affirms that, indeed, “Jesus is the answer.” Thus, the preacher’s conviction that “ ‘Jesus is the answer’ has been confirmed on the three levels of narrative communication—that of the level of the story, the level of the narrative discourse, and the level of the relationship between the two—as the single, ‘correct,’ authorized answer to the problems of life.”26 The goal of redundant communication is thus to reduce interpretive ‘space’—the possibility of gaps appearing in the text that might enable a plural reading.27 This feature is especially of interest to the student of the Fourth Gospel as the narrator intrudes upon
25
Ibid., 29. Though operating at the level of a single sermon, Witten hopes that her essay will lead to further study: “In isolating these features and demonstrating how they may work, this paper suggests several directions for future research in religious discourse. First, it makes it possible to conduct systematic comparisons of the degree of meaning-restriction in sermons or other authoritative religious utterances, and the types of discursive devices used to close down meaning.” (Ibid., 30; my italics) 27 Ibid., 25. 26
220
the narrative, especially when Scripture is deployed.28 I will employ Witten’s work when analyzing the narratives or passages in which John invokes Scripture to see if John may be better understood using her method.29 Summarizing, then, some of the insights gleaned from these scholars, the use of Scripture within a group’s narrative points to what Martyn has deemed “the relationship between tradition and contemporary issues.” Scripture may be used to indicate a boundary between those who understand it and those who do not; it may, in Wuthnow’s words, “connect moral prescriptions with tradition.” It may help the auditor make sense of his or her lived experience and remind him or her that that experience, especially suffering or persecution, is part of God’s divine design. In her analysis of Falwell’s use of Scripture over a number of years, years which included real difficulties for Falwell’s ministry, Harding discovered that “what Falwell mastered during the mid-1970s was the biblical language to convert defeat into victory, death into life.”30 And surely Falwell is not too far off of one role of Scripture in a narrative when, speaking of his friend’s attempt to encourage him at a difficult time, he says: Old Dr. Lakin spent the week. There was nothing he could do legally to end our troubles. But he ministered personally to my own tired 28 So, for example, in 12:29–36 the narrator tells a story about the interaction between Jesus and “the crowd.” Jesus says his piece and departs. The narrator proceeds to declare a negative outcome, the crowd “did not believe in him,” and provides an explanation for its disbelief by citing Scripture. 29 Jonathan Z. Smith has also spent some time worrying about texts, preachers, and audience, especially in his article, “Sacred Persistence: Toward a Redescription of Canon,” in Approaches to Ancient Judaism: Theory and Practice (ed. William Scott Green; Missoula, Mont.: Scholars Press, 1978), 1:11–28. In pursuing John’s comment that “scripture cannot be broken” we lend an ear to Smith, who urges historians of religion to understand canon (the community’s surrender of freedom with regard to texts) and exegesis (the community’s rediscovery of that freedom through its exercise of “ingenuity” within the boundaries of canon), 44. Smith defines canon as “the arbitrary fixing of a limited number of ‘texts’ as immutable and authoritative,” and claims that canon is common. (Smith maintains that “texts” do not necessarily have to be written; this insight will play a fundamental role in my argument concerning Jesus’ words as scriptural in the Fourth Gospel). The essence of canon is its closed nature. A closed canon necessitates a hermeneute whose task lies in applying the canon to new situations not covered within it without appearing to alter the canon in any way. Appropriately Smith likens the process to preaching in which the preacher seeks to make the text speak to a modern situation. Such motives and skills can be attributed to John. 30 Harding, “The Gospel,” 51.
221
spirit. He retold the stories about ancient clashes between the government and the prophets. He reminded me of the stand the apostles and first-century Christians had to take against kings, governors, courts, and ruling bodies. He dragged out all his best dramatic accounts of the prophets and the priests, the martyrs and the saints. And he inspired me through the telling.31
Harding provides one answer to Martyn’s question about the relationship between tradition and contemporary issues when she finds the following connections between Scripture, narrative, and a community’s life of faith, connections to be found in the Fourth Gospel as well: Fundamentalists are still writing the Bible, inscribing it into their lives, endlessly generating a third Testament in their speech and action. Their Bible is alive, its narrative shape enacts reality, infills it with form and meaning. It is, we might say, miraculous, this discourse which effects the world it speaks by constituting subjects who bring it about.32
Scripture While one has the sense that Scripture pervades the Fourth Gospel, at nineteen particular places the author explicitly announces that Scripture is being directly quoted, implying that these passages deserve special attention. Since I am interested in determining how John uses Scripture to shape his group, I will privilege first and foremost those places where he himself clearly indicates that Scripture is being cited and only secondarily turn to a few representative instances where John quotes or alludes to Scripture without explicitly indicating that he is doing so. Having done that, I will explore the role of Jesus’ own words in the Fourth Gospel. The text itself calls for attention to Jesus’ own words, which, as it turns out, share a unique relationship with the words of Scripture. The words of Jesus become the ultimate authority for the group; indeed, the author transfers the language that is usually reserved for Scripture to Jesus’ own words such that his words are given priority. As the Johannine sectarian knows, Scripture is not self-evident but is open to misinterpretation. It cannot be the solid rock upon which one stands to begin her journey toward understanding 31 32
Ibid., 49. Ibid., 54.
222
God; only Jesus’ words constitute that solid rock. One must start from Jesus’ own words, the hermeneutical key, and only then attempt to understand Scripture’s testimony to God, not vice versa. Direct Citations According to the Author of the Fourth Gospel Fourth Gospel
Indicator
Situation in Narrative
1:23
kay∆w e‰pen ÉHsa˛aw ı profÆthw
John the Baptist says it
2:17
gegramm°non §st¤n
disciples recall a relevant scriptural passage
6:31
kay≈w §stin gegramm°non
Jews quote it to Jesus in a challenge
6:45
¶stin gegramm°non §n to›w profÆtaiw
Jesus quotes it to Jews
7:38
kay∆w e‰pen ≤ grafÆ
Jesus quotes it to Jews
8:17
§n t“ nÒmƒ d¢ t“ Ímet°rƒ g°graptai
Jesus quotes it to Jews
10:34
¶stin gegramm°non §n t“ nÒmƒ Ím«n
Jesus quotes it to Jews
12:13, 16
taËta ∑n §pÉ aÈt“ gegramm°na
narrator indicates that disciples remembered citation
12:14–15
kay≈w §stin gegramm°non
narrator explains Jesus’ actions
12:38
·na ı lÒgow ÉHsa˛ou toË profÆtou plhrvhyª
narrator explains Jewish disbelief
12:39–40
e‰pen ÉHsa˛aw
narrator explains Jewish disbelief
12:41
e‰pen ÉHsa˛aw
narrator regarding Isaiah’s vision
13:18
·na ≤ grafØ plhrvyª
Jesus regarding Judas
15:25
·na plhrvyª ı lÒgow ı §n t“ nÒmƒ aÈt«n gegramm°now
Jesus regarding Jewish rejection
17:12
·na ≤ grafØ plhrvyª
Jesus in prayer regarding Judas
19:24
·na ≤ grafØ plhrvyª
narrator regarding Jesus’ clothes
19:28
·na teleivyª ≤ grafÆ
narrator regarding Jesus’ thirst
19:36
·na ≤ grafØ plhrvyª
narrator regarding Jesus’ bones
19:37
grafØ l°gei
narrator regarding piercing
223
It is now appropriate to commence analysis of the direct scriptural quotes that appear in the Fourth Gospel.33 John 1:23: ¶fh, ÉEg∆ fvnØ bo«ntow §n tª §rÆmƒ, EÈyÊnate tØn ıdÚn kur¤ou, kay∆w e‰pen ÉHsa˛aw ı profÆthw. Here the author has John the Baptist quote part of Isa 40:3: fvnØ bo«ntow §n tª §rÆmƒ •toimãsate tØn ıdÚn kur¤ou eÈye¤aw poie›te tåw tr¤bouw toË yeoË ≤m«n. This citation also appears in the Synoptics
but differs in two ways. First, John quotes only the first part of the verse, whereas the Synoptics include the latter part as well. The Synoptics quote the passage in full, as we have it transmitted in , while John replaces §toimãsate with eÈyÊnate, the verb that approximates the eÈye¤aw poie›te found in the second part of the verse, thereby paraphrasing and compressing Isa 40:3. Second, and more importantly, John puts the citation in the mouth of John the Baptist so that he himself fully understands and proclaims what exactly his role is and is not. We might be tempted to ascribe little significance to this citation if we quickly notice that all four Gospels cite it in one form or 33 In initially undertaking a study of John’s use of Scripture, it is tempting to rely upon a resource such as NA26, as it demarcates scriptural use in three different ways: 1) marginal references; 2) italics in the text itself; and 3) an appendix entitled: “Loci Citati vel Allegati.” For the casual inquirer, it serves as a starting place, but for the serious student of the Fourth Gospel, it will not do for a number of reasons. First, there are occasions where the Fourth Gospel explicitly claims to refer to Scripture but NA26 does not include it in the Appendix (e.g., 8:17). Second, there are occasions where the Fourth Gospel does not explicitly claim to refer to Scripture and NA26 nonetheless includes them in the list of direct citations (e.g., 1:51; 12:27; 16:22). Third, there are inconsistencies between the marginal notes and the Appendix (so, NA26 italicizes Isa 40:9 in the body of the text but not in the Appendix). Fourth, NA26 provides the ostensible scriptural references for John’s quotations, but quite often it is impossible to determine which text John intends in a given passage since he rarely quotes verbatim the or . Fifth, if such is the case for the instances in which John overtly declares that he invokes Scripture, how much more difficult it is to determine the text upon which an allusion is based? Finally, positing allusions at all is necessarily a speculative endeavor that precludes certainty. NA26 finds allusions to at least 217 texts and twenty-seven apocryphal or pseudepigraphical texts. It has almost certainly omitted some and probably included some that do not belong. Regarding omissions, the number for Genesis should be higher insofar as Dahl has shown that 8:44 comprises an unmistakable allusion to Genesis 4. See Dahl, “Der Erstgeborene,” 70–84. Furthermore, the number of references to Numbers cited by NA26 is certainly too low insofar as NA26 notes only one reference to Numbers in ch. 6. Peder Borgen has proven that almost the entire chapter is nothing but a reworking of Scripture.
224
another and all do so with respect to John the Baptist. This may inappropriately cause us to estimate that it is simply such an established piece of Christian tradition that John cannot help but include it. Attention to the Johannine context as well as a comparison with the Synoptics, however, demonstrates that the Fourth Gospel’s use of the quotation serves a unique function. From the beginning of the Gospel, the author takes great pains to relegate John the Baptist to a subordinate role. Immediately after introducing Jesus as God, the author turns his attention to John the Baptist and declares that his role was that of a witness (martur¤a) to Christ, “the true light which enlightens everyone” and which “shines in the darkness.” The author apparently does not consider the positive statement of John’s role enough and clarifies further what John’s role was not, namely, he was not the light ( John 1:8). The fact that the author “protesteth too much” indicates that some people were positing that John himself was the light. The author returns to the topic of Christ at v. 14: Ka‹ ı lÒgow sårj §g°neto ka‹ §skÆnvsen §n ≤m›n, ka‹ §yeasãmeya tØn dÒjan aÈtoË, dÒjan …w monogenoËw parå patrÒw, plÆrhw xãritow ka‹ élhye¤aw. Verse 16, ˜ti §k toË plhr≈matow aÈtoË ≤me›w pãntew §lãbomen ka‹ xãrin ént‹ xãritow logically follows v. 14, especially because of the linking words “fullness” and “grace.” Verse 15 appears as a discordant interruption, blazoning: ÉIvãnnhw marture› per‹ aÈtoË ka‹ k°kragen l°gvn, Otow ∑n ˘n e‰pon, ÑO Ùp¤sv mou §rxÒmenow ¶mprosy°n mou g°gonen, ˜ti pr«tÒw mou ∑n. Noting the intrusive nature of the verse, Bultmann explains it as an addition to the original Prologue meant to subordinate John the Baptist. Es handelt sich bekanntlich vor allem darum, ob die Verse 6–8 und 15 zum ursprünglichen Bestande gehorën. Ich schließe mich hier ganz dem Urteil Wellhausens an, der diese Verse für spätere Einfügungen erklärt, und will seine Gründe nicht weiderholen, die mir auch durch Ed. Meyer und H. Leisegang neuerdings nicht widerlegt zu sein scheinen.34 Aber vor einer Entscheidung ist zu erwägen, ob man vielleicht doch den ganzen Prolog außer den Versen 6–8.15 und 17 und den christlichen Zusätzen in V. 1 (?) 9 (?) und 12 als vorchristliche Vorlage verstehen kann, ob hier schon gestanden haben kann: ka‹ ı lÒgow sårj §g°neto. Schon die Vorlage hätte dann den Gedanken der früheren Offenbarungsträger
34 Rudolf Bultmann, “Der religionsgeschichtliche Hintergrund des Prologs,” in Erich Dinkler, ed., Exegetica (Tübingen: J. C. B. Mohr, 1967), 10.
225
zurückgedrängt, um alles Licht auf den entscheidenden Offenbarer zu konzentrieren, und dieser wäre dann offenbar in einer geschichtlichen Gestalt der unmittelbaren Vergangenheit geschaut gewesen. Wer sollte das gewesen sein? Aus dem eigentlichen Judentum könnte die Vorlage dann kaum stammen, sondern wohl nur aus dem Täufertum, in dessen Kreisen man vom Täufer Johannes ausgesagt hätte, daß in ihm der Logos Fleisch ward. So würde sich auch erklären, daß der Evangelist (der diese Vorlage aus hellenistisch-jüdischen Täuferkreisen übernimmt und auf Jesus überträgt) in V. 6–8 und V. 15 den Täufer zum Zeugen für Jesus herabdrückt.35
Not a few scholars have commented on the disruption of v. 15, and English translations often enclose the verse with parentheses. As Raymond Brown states, “It is agreed today that this verse is an addition to the original hymn, an addition of the same type as vv. 6–8 (9), awkwardly breaking up vss. 14 and 16.”36 Just as in his two preceding appearances, John is presented in v. 19 with “witness” language (martur¤a). Again, as in the two preceding appearances, John defines his role vis-à-vis Christ. He denies being the Messiah, Elijah, or the prophet, that is, Moses, or the “prophet like Moses” (Deut 18).37 Having proclaimed who he is not, John proceeds to announce that he is the voice spoken of by Isaiah. This will not be the last time that “the Jews” trouble themselves over defining a character’s identity in this Gospel. At v. 19 the author identifies the authoritative senders as “the Jews”; in v. 24 he further specifies that they are “the Pharisees.” The “priests and Levites from Jerusalem” appear as the Pharisees’ lackeys. They then express concern that he is baptizing, a privilege apparently reserved for the Messiah, Elijah or the prophet, all of which John has just denied being. The issue of who baptizes and how will
35
Ibid., 32–33. Brown, John, 15. According to Brown’s judgment: “Verse 14 has stated that the pre-existent heavenly Word became flesh. Apparently the redactor who added vss. 6–9 has also added 15, intending to confirm vs. 14 with John the Baptist’s testimony that Jesus is pre-existent. There is obvious polemic against any suggestion that John the Baptist might be greater than Jesus because he began his ministry first” (35). John Painter writes: “The witness of the Baptist is appropriately introduced at 15. But this verse interrupts the first person plural confession (‘we beheld . . .’) which is continued in 16. This indicates that 15 has been introduced into an existing composition because of the proclamation of the incarnation in v. 14.” “Christology and the History of the Johannine Community in the Prologue of the Fourth Gospel,” NTS 30 (1984), 462. 37 Meeks, Prophet-King. 36
226
arise again a few verses later. The author closes the pericope, not accidentally, by saying that this controversy of identity took place in Bethany. None of the Synoptics envisions Bethany as the place connected with John’s testimony. Bethany will appear three more times in the Gospel, always in close connection with Jesus’ identity. It occurs twice in the story of Lazarus’ resurrection, a sign that foreshadows Jesus’ own death and resurrection. It occurs again in the story of Mary’s anointing Jesus, which again foreshadows his death, or, as Jesus says, “Leave her alone, so that she might observe it for the day of my burial” (my translation). John ensures that the connection will be made in the reader’s mind by opening the story of the anointing by saying, “Six days before the Passover Jesus came to Bethany, the home of Lazarus, whom he had raised from the dead” (12:1). Indeed, right after that he enters Jerusalem, which signals the beginning of the end for his earthly existence. The Synoptics place John the Baptist in the ¶rhmow, which presumably provides the rationale for invoking Isa 40:3. Thus, in the Synoptics Isa 40:3 serves as a fulfillment of prophecy. The author of the Fourth Gospel neither places John the Baptist in the ¶rhmow nor does he have Jesus driven there to be tempted. The author uses the word sparingly38 and usually in contexts reminiscent of Moses. In ch. 3 he alludes to Moses’ lifting up the serpent in the wilderness (¶rhmow) which he considers the type to which his death and resurrection will correspond as anti-type. In ch. 6, known as the Bread Discourse, Jesus’ audience twice claims that Moses gave their ancestors manna to eat in the wilderness (¶rhmow). The Bread Discourse and the direct allusion to the manna in the wilderness does not appear in the Synoptics, though one could argue that the Synoptic authors certainly intend to evoke that very context by placing the Feeding of the Five Thousand in the ¶rhmow (Matt 14:15; Mark 6:35; Luke 9:13). Matthew and Mark do the same with the Feeding of the Four Thousand (Matt 15:33; Mark 8:4), a story that appears in neither Luke nor John. As it turns out, the pericope in which Isa 40:3 is located in John has almost nothing in common with the Synoptic parallels. The Synoptics do not have John wrangle with “the Jews” over whether
38 Only four times outside the Isaiah quote as compared with Matthew’s seven, Mark’s eight, and Luke’s nine.
227
he is the Messiah, Elijah, or the prophet; they do not place the citation in John’s own mouth. They have John operating in the wilderness, not in Bethany. Mark quotes Exod 23:20, which is linked to the Isaiah quotation by the concern for “preparing the way” and which makes John’s primary role that of a messenger (êggelow) who prepares Jesus’ way; both Matthew and Luke apply the same quote to John at a later point in their Gospels. For the author of the Fourth Gospel, John is not a messenger but a witness. Both the Synoptics and the Fourth Gospel have John perform the role they have assigned him, so the Synoptics depict him declaring a message, namely, “Repent, for the kingdom of God is at hand.” Never does the word “repent” appear on John the Baptist’s or anyone else’s lips in the Fourth Gospel. But the Fourth Gospel claims from the beginning that John’s role was one of a mãrtuw and the author depicts him fulfilling such a role thoroughly. His only “message” in the Fourth Gospel is his testifying to Jesus as the Messiah. In no way is Jesus’ ministry dependent upon John’s. On the other hand, the Synoptics never depict John using mãrtuw language. The next passage, 1:29–34, which follows the interrogation concerning John’s identity, once again finds John testifying (martur°v) to Jesus’ lofty identity, a point that is made twice (vv. 32 and 34), once by the author and once by John himself. Again, the Synoptic parallels reveal that the Fourth Evangelist goes his own way. The most significant difference between the accounts is that the Synoptics have John baptize Jesus, an idea which the Fourth Evangelist eschews entirely. In no way does this author imagine a passing of the baton, so to speak, from John to Jesus. This is not a cooperative venture; Jesus stands alone with John never anything but subordinate to him. Another glaring difference lies in the author’s having John repeat the saying about Jesus’ ranking before him. This is now the third time (cf. 1:15 and 1:27) the author has explicitly made the point which the Synoptics make only once, namely, John’s lowly ranking vis-à-vis Jesus. Finally, the narrative about the Spirit descending upon Jesus like a dove differs greatly between the Synoptics and the Fourth Gospel. The Synoptics narrate the event as occurring immediately after his baptism by John. They depict heaven opening, the Spirit descending upon Jesus like a dove, and a voice from heaven proclaiming to or about Jesus that he is God’s Beloved Son. This marks the beginning of Jesus’ ministry in the Synoptics. In Mark and Luke, God
228
directly addresses Jesus, and it could be argued that it marks the beginning of Jesus’ own understanding of his calling. Matthew has a more general proclamation, saying, “This is my Beloved Son,” rather than “You are my Beloved Son.” In all of the Synoptic accounts, it is somewhat unclear as to who, besides Jesus, hears the voice, and no mention is made of John the Baptist. In the Fourth Gospel, however, the event is imagined as happening primarily so that John the Baptist might be able to testify to Jesus’ identity. The narrator indicates this when he begins the story by saying, “And John bore witness (martur°v)” and then changes to a first person account on the part of John the Baptist in which he relates seeing the Spirit descend upon Jesus and remain upon him. Unlike the Synoptics, this does not occur in the context of Jesus being baptized. God does not address Jesus or anyone else but John the Baptist, and apparently the address occurred before the actual sending of the Spirit on Jesus. God had told John the Baptist ahead of time what to expect, and when it happened John recognized its fulfillment and, according to his first person account, dutifully proceeded to testify (martur°v) that Jesus is the Son of God. This is a radically different story from the Synoptic accounts. The next passage, 1:35–42, finds John the Baptist directing two of his own disciples to Jesus by proclaiming him to be the Lamb of God; he made the same proclamation the day before, in v. 29. Where Andrew and the other disciple had once followed (ékolouy°v, v. 40) John, they have transferred their discipleship to Jesus (ékolouy°v, v. 38). John appears again in ch. 3 where, uniquely, the narrator depicts John and Jesus baptizing simultaneously. The simultaneous baptizing serves two functions. First, it obliterates any notion of the “passing of the baton” found in the Synoptics, which implies that Jesus cannot begin his ministry until John ends his, thereby making Jesus’ ministry dependent on John’s. Second, it sets John the Baptist up for yet another opportunity to humble himself and testify to Jesus’ exalted identity. Like the first passage that evidenced John’s doing this, the event is instigated by the Jews,39 an interesting ascription
39 The ancient evidence is evenly divided on whether “Jew” or “Jews” should be read. Lectio difficilior demands that the singular be read, assuming that a singular is more likely to have been changed to the plural in keeping with the majority of the Gospel. Also in support of the singular is the fact that nowhere does the
229
given that John, his disciples, and Jesus were all Jews. I will return to this point when I analyze the text at the social-historical level rather than the narrative. John’s disciples depict the relationship between John and Jesus as competitive; they worry that everyone whom John baptizes is “crossing over” (p°ran in v. 26) on both a literal level, from the Decapolis, where Aenon and Salim are located, to Judea, and on a metaphorical level, from John to Jesus. But John refuses to engage in competition and instead shows that such a situation is God’s will; it is what has been “given from heaven” (v. 27). Furthermore, he reminds them that they themselves witnessed (martur°v) John’s insistence that he is not the Messiah. He then identifies himself as merely a “friend of the bridegroom” whose role is to listen to the bridegroom. Jesus is the bridegroom who now stands center stage, with John taking a seat in the audience. For anyone doubting John’s intention to humble himself and even remove himself from the picture, the author has John declare, “He must increase, but I must decrease” (3:30). The author has thus insisted that John’s disciples became Jesus’ disciples and that such a move was authorized and celebrated by John (“For this reason my joy has been fulfilled,” v. 29). The material about John in 3:22–30 shares much in common with that in 1:19–28, both structurally and substantially. Both depict “the Jews” initiating a pointed conversation which results in John’s defining his role vis-à-vis Jesus. In both cases he declares that he is not the Messiah, but rather one who has been sent ahead to testify to him who is coming. In fact, at 3:28 the author has John refer back to and quote what he had said in 1:20ff.: “You yourselves are my
plural occur without the definite article, which would be the case here if one adopted the plural reading. On the other hand, because the singular is so rare in the Gospel, occurring only at 4:9 and 18:35, both in reference to Jesus’ being a Jew, reason might impel one to assume that the plural is more likely. Furthermore, John’s first confession of “I am not the Messiah” was instigated by “the Jews” (1:19) who are later identified as “Pharisees” (1:24). That the present instance of the same confession is instigated by “Jews” is made probable by the fact that John 4:1 refers to “the Pharisees” having heard that Jesus was making more disciples that John, which can only refer to the preceding passage, and, in fact, seems to serve no other purpose than to further identify the “Jews” in v. 25. Its apparent reason for inclusion is given as the impetus for Jesus’ departing, but as such it is a strange verse. Perhaps the deciding factor is that nowhere does the plural occur without the definite article, which would be the case here if one adopted the plural reading. Hence, the singular is more probable.
230
witnesses that I said, ‘I am not the Messiah, but I have been sent ahead of him.’” Finally, John the Baptist concludes both passages by using metaphorical language to show his subordinate position to Jesus, first as unworthy to untie Jesus’ sandal and second as a friend of the bridegroom. John appears twice more in the Gospel; not surprisingly, both instances depict him solely in the role of testifying to Jesus. In ch. 5, however, John does not make first person proclamations about his role as testifier; rather, Jesus invokes John as a witness to his true identity. Jesus is engaged in a controversy with “the Jews” (5:18) over his making himself “equal to God” (5:18) and he declares: “§ån §g∆ martur« per‹ §mautoË, ≤ martur¤a mou oÈk ¶stin élhyÆw: êllow §st‹n ı martur«n per‹ §moË, ka‹ o‰da ˜ti élhyÆw §stin ≤ martur¤a ∂n marture› per‹ §moË . Íme›w épestãlkate prÚw ÉIvãnnhn , ka‹ memartÊrhken tª élhye¤&” (5:31–33). Lest anyone think that Jesus depends upon John’s testimony of him, however, Jesus quickly offers these caveats: “§g∆ d¢ oÈ parå ényr≈pou tØn martur¤an lambãnv, éllå taËta l°gv ·na Íme›w svy∞te” (5:34) and “§g∆ d¢ ¶xv tØn martur¤an me¤zv toË ÉIvãnnou” (5:36a). He goes on to specifically identify that greater testimony as his works and his father: “tå går ¶rga ì d°dvk°n moi ı patØr ·na telei≈sv aÈtã, aÈtå tå ¶rga ì poi« marture› per‹ §moË ˜ti ı patÆr me ép°stalken: ka‹ ı p°mcaw me patØr §ke›now memartÊrhken per‹ §moË” (5:36–37).
Notice the frequency with which the author employs “witness” language in this passage, ten times in all. Chapter one comes in second place with seven occurrences. Of the forty-six times that “witness” language is used, one quarter of them refer to John the Baptist. His role is nothing in this Gospel but a witness to Christ’s identity.40 Chapter ten is the last time that listeners hear of John the Baptist. The same tight connection observed between 3:22–30 and 1:19–28 exists also between 5:16–47 and 10:22–42. In both cases, the scene has been set at the time of a Jewish festival in Jerusalem. In ch. 10 “the Jews” ask Jesus about his identity, whether or not he is “the Christ” (v. 24), and he reminds them of what he had said in ch. 5 regarding his works: épekr¤yh aÈto›w ı ÉIhsoËw, E‰pon Ím›n ka‹ oÈ pisteÊete: tå ¶rga ì §g∆ poi« §n t“ ÙnÒmati toË patrÒw mou taËta
40
Cf. Dahl, “Johannine Church,” 106.
231
marture› per‹ §moË: éllå Íme›w oÈ pisteÊete, ˜ti oÈk §st¢ §k t«n probãtvn t«n §m«n. Looking back to ch. 5, we find that Jesus is cor-
rect; he did formerly explain that he does works in his father’s name which testify to him, but the interrogators do not believe because they do not belong to Jesus’ own. A number of verses from ch. 5 validate this. Verses 36–38 deserve special attention; I have marked the parallels with 10:25–26. 5.17 ı d¢ É[IhsoËw] épekr¤nato aÈto›w, ÑO patÆr mou ßvw êrti §rgãzetai, kég∆ §rgãzomai. 5.19 ÉApekr¤nato oÔn ı ÉIhsoËw ka‹ ¶legen aÈto›w, ÉAmØn émØn l°gv Ím›n, oÈ dÊnatai ı uflÚw poie›n éfÉ •autoË oÈd¢n §ån mÆ ti bl°p˙ tÚn pat°ra poioËnta: ì går ín §ke›now poiª, taËta ka‹ ı uflÚw ımo¤vw poie›. 5.20 ı går patØr file› tÚn uflÚn ka‹ pãnta de¤knusin aÈt“ ì aÈtÚw poie›, ka‹ me¤zona toÊtvn de¤jei aÈt“ ¶rga, ·na Íme›w yaumãzhte. 5:36 §g∆ d¢ ¶xv tØn martur¤an me¤zv toË ÉIvãnnou: tå går ¶rga ì d°dvk°n moi ı patØr 10:25b: tå ¶rga ì §g≈ poi« §n ·na telei≈sv aÈtã, t“ ÙnÒmati toË patrÒw mou aÈtå tå ¶rga ì poi« marture› per‹ §moË ˜ti ı patÆr me ép°stalken:
10:25c: taËta marture› per‹ §moË:
5:38 ka‹ tÚn lÒgon aÈtoË oÈk ¶xete §n Ím›n m°nonta, ˜ti ˘n ép°steilen §ke›now, toÊtƒ Íme›w oÈ pisteÊete.
10:25a: oÈ pisteÊete; 10:26: Íme›w oÈ pisteÊete
10:25 épekr¤yh aÈto›w ı ÉIhsoËw, E‰pon Ím›n ka‹ oÈ pisteÊete: tå ¶rga ì §g∆ poi« §n t“ ÙnÒmati toË patrÒw mou taËta marture› per‹ §moË: 10.26 éllå Íme›w oÈ pisteÊete, ˜ti oÈk §st¢ §k t«n probãtvn t«n §m«n. The points made in 10:25–26, namely, that the Jews do not believe because they do not abide with Jesus, that Jesus’ works stem from the Father, and that the works bear witness to Jesus, do specifically hearken back to 5:36–38, where Jesus previously made the same points. Moving to the next verses in ch. 10, we see the following comparisons:
232
10:27 tå prÒbata tå §må t∞w fvn∞w mou ékoÊousin, kég∆ gin≈skv aÈtã ka‹ ékolouyoËs¤n moi, 10:28 kég∆ d¤dvmi aÈto›w zvØn a`fi≈nion
5:37 oÎte fvnØn aÈtoË p≈pote ékhkÒate 5:39 §raunçte tåw grafãw, ˜ti Íme›w doke›te §n aÈta›w zvØn afi≈nion ¶xein: ka‹ §ke›na¤ efisin afl marturoËsai per‹ §moË: 5:40 ka‹ oÈ y°lete §lye›n prÒw me ·na zvØn ¶xhte (cf. 5:21 Àsper går ı patØr §ge¤rei toÁw nekroÁw ka‹ zƒopoie›, oÏtvw ka‹ ı uflÒw oÓw y°lei zƒopoie›) (cf. 5:24 ÉAmØn émØn l°gv Ím›n ˜ti ı tÚn lÒgon mou ékoÊvn ka‹ pisteÊvn t“ p°mcant¤ me ¶xei zvØn afi≈nion ka‹ efiw kr¤sin oÈk ¶rxetai, éllå metab°bh ken §k toË yanãtou efiw tØn zvÆn.
Both passages worry about hearing Jesus and therefore receiving eternal life, or not. Numerous other parallels from the passage in ch. 5 could be listed, especially the hearing, resurrection from the dead, and eternal life language in 5:25–29, but the point is made without enumerating them in detail. The next aspect of the present pericope which is paralleled in ch. 5, and only in ch. 5, is the Jews’ animosity towards Jesus because of his “making himself God.” Note the language about the works which appears in both passages; at present I will focus only on the charge of Jesus’ identity as God. 10:30 §g∆ ka‹ ı patØr ßn §smen
10:31 ÉEbãstasan pãlin l¤youw ofl ÉIouda›oi ·na liyãsvsin aÈtÒn.
5:18c: éllå ka‹ pat°ra ‡dion ¶legen tÚn yeÒn ‡son •autÚn poi«n t“ ye“. 5.18a §zÆtoun aÈtÚn ofl ÉIouda›oi épokte›nai
10:32 épekr¤yh aÈto›w ı ÉIhsoËw, Pollå ¶rga kalå ¶deija Ím›n §k toË patrÒw: diå po›on aÈt«n ¶rgon §m¢ liyãzete;
10:33 épekr¤yhsan aÈt“ ofl ÉIouda›oi, Per‹ kaloË ¶rgou
5:18 diå toËto oÔn mçllon §zÆtoun aÈtÚn ofl ÉIouda›oi épokte›nai, ˜ti
oÈ liyãzom°n se éllå per‹ blasfhm¤aw, ka‹ ˜ti s`Á ênyrvpow Ãn poie›w seautÚn yeÒn.
233
oÈ mÒnon ¶luen tÚ sãbbaton, éllå ka‹ pat°ra ‡dion ¶legen tÚn yeÒn ‡son •autÚn poi«n t“ ye“.
In both instances, Jesus has recently done a good work that has upset the Jews, but even more so, they seek to harm him because he is making himself equal to God. As all students of the Fourth Gospel know, the irony in the charge is thick, since, of course, Jesus is in no way a mere human being making himself God, but is God Incarnate, which the audience knows from the Prologue. The last element of the two controversies centers on Scripture: 10:34 O`Èk ¶stin gegramm°non §n t“ nÒmƒ Ím«n ˜ti ÉEg∆ e‰pa, Yeo¤ §ste; efi §ke¤nouw e‰pen yeoÁw prÚw oÓw ı lÒgow toË yeoË §g°neto, ka‹ oÈ dÊnatai luy∞nai ≤ grafÆ, ˘n ı patØr ≤g¤asen ka‹ ép°steilen efiw tÚn kÒsmon Íme›w l°gete ˜ti Blasfhme›w, ˜ti e‰pon, UflÚw toË yeoË efimi; 10:37 efi oÈ poi« tå ¶rga toË patrÒw mou, mØ pisteÊet° moi: 10.38 efi d¢ poi«, kín §mo‹ mØ pisteÊhte, to›w ¶rgoiw pisteÊete, ·na gn«te ka‹ gin≈skhte ˜ti §n §mo‹ ı patØr kég∆ §n t“ patr¤.
5:39 §raunçte tåw grafãw, ˜ti Íme›w doke›te §n aÈta›w zvØn afi≈nion ¶xein: ka‹ §ke›na¤ efisin afl marturoËsai per‹ §moË:
5:45 mØ doke›te ˜ti §g≈ kathgorÆsv Ím«n prÚw tÚn pat°ra: ¶stin ı kathgor«n Ím«n Mv#s∞w, efiw ˘n Íme›w ±lp¤kate. 5:46 efi går §pisteÊete Mv#se›, §pisteÊete ín §mo¤: per‹ går §moË §ke›now ¶gracen. 5:47 efi d¢ to›w §ke¤nou grãmmasin oÈ pisteÊete, p«w to›w §mo›w =Æmasin pisteÊsete;
The parallels between the texts could be discussed at great length, but here I simply mention them. All references to Scripture have been singly underlined and those referring to believing have been doubly underlined. The main point to be understood in both cases is that Scripture witnesses to Christ’s identity. In both cases Jesus makes a rhetorical move about believing such that, rather than simply saying, “Believe in me,” he invites them to believe in something else (what Moses wrote and Jesus’ works) which then leads to believing in Jesus and to an understanding of the relationship between Jesus and the Father.
234
The pericope in ch. 10 ends with what appears to be a gratuitous mention of John the Baptist. But when we have recognized that John only ever appears to witness to Jesus’ identity, the point of his mention becomes clear on the rhetorical level, if not the narrative level. That is, at the beginning of the Gospel John appears testifying to Jesus’ identity as the Son of God (1:34).41 Between there and ch. 10, the author has employed God, Scripture, and Jesus’ works as “witnesses” as well. By the end of ch. 10 we have come full circle so that what was presented in ch. 1 is validated in ch. 10. John made certain proclamations regarding Jesus’ identity; now we find anonymous believers remembering what John had said: ka‹ pollo‹ ∑lyon prÚw aÈtÚn ka‹ ¶legon ˜ti ÉIvãnnhw m¢n shme›on §po¤hsen oÈd°n, pãnta d¢ ˜sa e‰pen ÉIvãnnhw per‹ toÊtou élhy∞ ∑n (10:41).
Jesus’ works, God the Father himself, Scripture, and John the Baptist all serve as mighty witnesses to Christ’s identity. In this way, John’s testimony is elevated in status, for surely the trinity of Jesus’ works, Scripture, and God is quite an impressive one with which to be listed; however, his role is limited to witnessing and, unlike Jesus’ works and God, he enjoys no other importance in this Gospel. As always, the narrator is especially eager to emphasize this and does so here by having the believers concisely declare that John did no sign. It is a rather odd thing to say because it does not seem logically connected to the second part of the proposition. Why not leave it at, “Everything John said about this man was true”? The author is subordinating John to Jesus who, in stark comparison with John, did do shme›a, a characteristic so important to Jesus’ ministry that the first twelve chapters of the Fourth Gospel are commonly called “The Book of Signs” by scholars. That John does not appear after this point should not surprise us; his only function was to testify publicly to Jesus’ identity, and the rest of the Gospel shows Jesus turning toward his “hour,” toward his farewell discourse and passion. Upon first glance, then, the ostensible reason for the invocation of Scripture at 1:23 is to show that John’s role was predicted by Scripture. But the scriptural citation itself is used by John to solidify his immediately preceding assertions, which functioned to put him in proper relation to Jesus. By tracing John’s role through the Gospel
41 Of course, John’s is not the first announcement to the reader about Jesus’ identity as Son of God; the narrator has made the point in the Prologue.
235
we discover that his other appearances corroborate this initial scriptural announcement so that the author heavily subordinates John to Jesus. The author’s treatment follows the technique observed by Witten in the sermon that used redundancy to restrict meaning. John the Baptist displays the same qualities, goals, and actions throughout the story. Furthermore, the narrator’s own commentary restricts meaning for the reader insofar as his own commentary affirms what is stated about John by both Jesus and John himself. It is not within the scope of this book to identify the function of John the Baptist in each of the Synoptics, but it is safe to say that he stands on his own as an authoritative figure there. There he is sent as a “messenger” to “prepare the way” for Jesus. He has his own message. In Mark and Luke he preaches a baptism of repentance for the forgiveness of sins (Mark 1:4; Luke 3:3); in Matthew he preaches, “Repent for the Kingdom of heaven is at hand.” In Luke he preaches particular ethics (Luke 3:10–14). In Q, he can engage in debate with those who claim to have Abraham as their Father (Matt 3:7–10; Luke 3:7–9). In the Fourth Gospel, on the other hand, Jesus is the one who debates their claim to have Abraham as their father ( John 8). In the Synoptics, John rebukes Herod about his morality (Matt 14:3ff. and parallels) and Herod imagines that Jesus is John redivivus. In direct contrast to the Fourth Gospel, Matthew has Jesus testify to John and to declare that John is Elijah, an identity the Fourth Gospel overtly has John deny. At any rate, John is clearly not a cipher in the Synoptics; he is a rich character.42 How does this treatment of John the Baptist relate to the realities of the late first-century Johannine community? It would appear that some people were elevating John to a very high status,43 probably at least to the level of being Elijah, a figure who had to come
42 All of the Gospels, however, do subordinate John to Jesus, but not so unreservedly. 43 Bultmann, The Gospel of John, 18, explains: “The motive for the insertion of vv. 6–8, 15 is clear from their polemical character. For their purpose is not only the positive one of proclaiming the Baptist as witness for Jesus; it is also polemical: to dispute the claim that the Baptist has the authority of the Revealer. This authority must therefore have been attributed by the Baptist sect to their master; they saw in him the f«w, and thus also the pre-existent Logos become flesh. This suggests that the source-text was a hymn of the Baptist-Community. By referring it to Jesus, the evangelist would then have been acting in a way similar to that of the Church Fathers, who saw a prophecy of Jesus Christ in the 4th Eclogue of Vergil. There is no difficulty in this conjecture, if one may suppose that the evangelist once
236
before Jesus could be designated or operate as Messiah. Such a claim is certainly legitimated by the Synoptics. It looks as though some were even raising him to the same status as Jesus so that the author has to declare that John was not the light. Whether the author’s community was battling an outside group of John the Baptist’s disciples or insiders who were unclear about Jesus’ solitary authoritative status is not clear. That some number of the Johannine community were those who transferred their discipleship from John to Jesus is indicated by chs. 1 and 3, which show John himself directing his own followers to Jesus. One can imagine lingering loyalty to John that disallowed Jesus to stand as the only authority. Matthew calls John Elijah. The author of the Fourth Gospel does not envision John as anything but a witness, and specifically a strictly human one (ênyrvpow, 5:34).44 In addition to the possibility of an outside group
belonged to the Baptist community, until his eyes were opened to perceive that not John, but Jesus was the Revealer sent by God. For without doubt the narrative I. 35–51 bears witness to the fact that one section of the disciples of the Baptist went over to the Christian community; and must we not therefore assume that Baptist tradition was taken over by the Christians?” Paul Lemarche writes about John the Baptist’s role in the Prologue: “As has often been rightly stated, John may have wished to show honour to his previous master, whilst at the same time trying to draw over to Christ the laggard disciples of the precursor.” “The Prologue of John,” in The Interpretation of John (ed. John Ashton, 2d ed.; Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1997), 47. In “Johannine Church,” 106, Dahl contends: “Like the earlier evangelists and the tradition before them, John begins the Gospel story with John the Baptist. But in the Fourth Gospel the point is not that a new epoch within a continuous history of salvation begins. The Baptist is nothing but the voice of one crying in the wilderness; he is misunderstood if he is taken to have any greatness of his own (1:19–27; 3:25–30). His only function is to bear witness to Christ (1:6–8; etc.).” Cf. Wayne A. Meeks, “Man from Heaven,” 173: “It is astonishing that attempts to solve the Johannine puzzle have almost totally ignored the question of what social function the myths may have had. . . . We know at least a few things about its history—all from direct allusions in the documents themselves. The group had to distinguish itself over against the sect of John the Baptist and even more passionately over against a rather strong Jewish community with which highly ambivalent relationships had existed.” Cf. David Rensberger, Johannine Faith and Liberating Community (Philadelphia: Westminster, 1988), 56: “Turning to John the Baptist, we may note that it has long been recognized that behind the portrait of him in the Fourth Gospel there lies a rivalry current in the evangelist’s days between Christians and followers of the Baptist who made messianic claims on his behalf. . . . In this way John the Baptist’s followers are made to hear their own master call on them to accept the claims of Jesus—or rather, the claims made about Jesus by the Johannine Christians. Thus John the Baptist also is important not simply as an individual but as evoking a group on whom the evangelist wished to press his christological claims.” 44 Compare this to 10:33 where the Jews claim that Jesus is making himself God, though he is only human (ênyrvpow).
237
of John the Baptist’s disciples, an inside group that came from John the Baptist, or an inside group familiar with the Synoptic vision of John, it may be that the Jews who were putting Johannine Christians out of the synagogue were using John the Baptist traditions against the group. Perhaps more than one of the above obtained. Regardless of which was the case, the scriptural quote at 1:23 subordinates John in order to portray Jesus as the only leader who enjoys special status. Both the Qumran and Branch Davidian materials show Scripture used to define the role of the group’s leaders, usually to justify the groups’ ascription of authority to the leader. There is, however, a notable difference. While the Teacher of Righteousness unquestionably enjoyed the most authority of any leader in the Qumran culture, there was also room for the Priest and the “we” of 4QMMT. In the Branch Davidian evidence, Ellen White, V. Houteff, Ben Roden, and Lois Roden were acknowledged as authoritative for their time, but Koresh is careful to insist repeatedly that they are subordinate to him and his authority, that they, unlike him, did not have “all the light.” Both groups, unlike the Fourth Gospel, had some room for more than one leader as a locus of authority. John 2:17: ÉEmnÆsyhsan ofl mayhta‹ aÈtoË ˜ti gegramm°non §st¤n, ÑO z∞low toË o‡kou sou katafãgeta¤ me. After 1:23, the next place at which the author himself indicates that he is quoting Scripture is 2:17. The narrator tells us that, in the midst of Jesus’ rage in the temple, the disciples collectively remembered an appropriate verse, Ps 68:10:45 ı z∞low toË o‡kou sou kat°fag°n me. It is interesting to note that 2:16 finds Jesus declaring: “Take these things away; you shall not make my Father’s house a house of trade,” which parallels the Synoptic citation of Isa 56:7 and Jer 7:11 (Mark 11:17 and par.). The Synoptics announce that this is a scriptural quote, but the author of the Fourth Gospel simply puts it in Jesus’ mouth and instead of “my house” speaks of “my Father’s house.” In the next verse the Fourth Gospel author does signify that he is quoting Scripture and then uniquely cites Ps 68:10. In the narrative, the quote shows that Scripture witnessed to Christ; the author subtly accomplishes this by changing the verb from the past tense
45
The reference is to the ; English 69:9; Ps 69:10: ynIt]l-…k;a} Ú¢t]yyB ta'¢n“qiAyKâ.i
238
as it appears in Ps 68:10 to the future, which appears in v. 17. Also on the narrative level, it depicts Jesus’ disciples as scripturally adept. Unlike the Jews who are castigated in ch. 5 for searching the Scriptures but coming up short even though the Scriptures testify to Jesus’ identity, the disciples know the Scriptures, believe them, and therefore believe (pisteÊv) Jesus. 2:17 proves what Jesus declares in 5:46: “If you believed Moses, you would believe me, for he wrote of me.”46 The disciples, therefore, stand in direct contrast with the opponents who are characterized as not believing. The author divides people into two categories: those who believe and those who do not. While pisteÊv appears in most books,47 it is fair to consider it special Johannine language. It appears ninety-eight times in the Fourth Gospel as opposed to eleven in Matthew, fourteen in Mark, and nine in Luke.48 The verb mimnÆskomai appears twice more in the Fourth Gospel, both times depicting the disciples remembering Scripture as it relates to Jesus. The Cleansing of the temple ends with the narrator informing the reader: ˜te oÔn ±g°ryh §k nekr«n, §mnÆsyhsan o‹ mayhta‹ aÈtoË ˜ti toËto ¶legen, ka‹ §p¤steusan tª grafª ka‹ t“ lÒgƒ ˘n e‰pen ı ÉIhsoËw (2:22). On the narrative level, three things are accomplished. First, the disciples are once again portrayed as knowing Scripture and interpreting events in light of it. Second, it implies that Scripture can only be truly understood after the resurrection. Finally, it puts the word of the Word on par with Scripture. Whereas in 2:17 and 12:16 the disciples remember Scripture, at 2:22 they remember Jesus’ word, which incites their belief in Scripture and Jesus’ word. The final appearance of the word mimnÆskomai occurs in 12:16: taËta oÈk ¶gnvsan aÈtoË o‹ mayhta‹ tÒ pr«ton, éllÉ ˜te §dojãsyh ÉIhsoËw tÒte §mnÆsyhsan ˜ti taËta ∑n §pÉ aÈt“ gegramm°na ka‹ taËta §po¤hsan aÈt“. This comment follows two scriptural texts invoked
in relation to the Triumphal Entry: 46 That Moses is not the author of the Psalms should not trouble the reader insofar as in ch. 10 Jesus quotes a Psalm and refers to it as being in the law, traditionally ascribed to Moses. In the Fourth Gospel, “what is written by Moses,” is shorthand for all of Scripture. 47 With the exception of Colossians, Philemon, 2 Peter, 2 John, 3 John, and Revelation. 48 “Believing” becomes more prominent in Acts, where the word occurs thirtyseven times.
239
12:12 Tª §paÊrion ı ˆxlow polÁw ı §ly∆n efiw tØn •ortÆn, ékoÊsantew ˜ti ¶rxetai ı ÉIhsoËw efiw ÑIerosÒluma 12:13 ¶labon tå ba˛a t«n foin¤kvn ka‹ §j∞lyon efiw Ípãnthsin aÈt“ ka‹ §kraÊgazon, ÑVsannã: eÈloghm°now ı §rxÒmenow §n ÙnÒmati kur¤ou [ka‹] ı basileÁw toË ÉIsraÆl. 12:14 eÍr∆n d¢ ı ÉIhsoËw Ùnãrion §kãyisen §pÉ aÈtÒ, kay≈w §stin gegramm°non, 12:15 MØ foboË, yugãthr Si≈n: fidoÁ ı basileÊw sou ¶rxetai, kayÆmenow §p‹ p«lon ˆnou.
No indication that it is a quotation accompanies the first citation, but the second notes that Scripture had previously indicated Jesus’ sitting on the young donkey. I will address the second citation later but here want to focus on the fact that for the third time the disciples remember (mimnÆskomai) Scripture. The narrator claims that, at first, the disciples did not understand (gin≈skv) that these Scriptures had been written of Jesus. Only after Jesus’ death and resurrection did they remember. In this way, the disciples stand in stark contrast to “the Jews” who are described already in the Prologue patently as “his own who did not know him (gin≈skv)” and proceed to validate this description throughout the narrative. To know or not to know is a defining character feature in the narrative of the Fourth Gospel, which uses gin≈skv fifty-seven times and o›da eighty-four times; Matthew, Mark, and Luke use gin≈skv twenty, twelve, and twentyeight times, respectively, and o‰da twenty-four, twenty-one, and twentyfive, respectively. So, in addition to showing that Scripture can only be understood post-Easter and that the disciples are “in the know,” so to speak, their recollection implies that the ancient Scripture was written precisely about Jesus. All of this leads to the conclusion that the literary role of Scripture in John 2:17 is fourfold. First, it shows that the disciples are paradigmatic characters because they remember (mimnÆskomai), they understand (gin≈skv, o‰da), and they believe (pisteÊv). Witten’s “centripetal tendency,” or observations on redundancy as it relates to the characters in a narrative, applies once again. The disciples, either as a group or individually, evince the same qualities, goals, actions, means of action, and outcomes of actions throughout the story. Second, the disciples can only remember, understand, and believe Scripture after the glorification, that is, the passion and resurrection of Jesus. There is no understanding and believing Scripture outside of “the Christ Event.” Third, it sets the reader up to evaluate critically and negatively the opponents who are described in opposite terms, by “not understanding” and “not believing.” The author cannot characterize
240
the Jewish opponents as “not remembering” Scripture; in fact, at times in the narrative they do remember and quote the Scriptures and even mistakenly attempt to find life in them. At other times, as in 2:17–18, while Jesus’ action triggers the disciples’ memory of Scripture, the opponents show no flicker of recognition but rather they must inquire after Jesus’ authority. Finally, it implies a fulfillmentof-Scripture theme. Adopting Witten’s scheme, the fulfillment-ofScripture motif effects restriction of meaning for the community insofar as an event is redundant with the interpretive commentary. So, the narrator directly connects the cleansing of the temple with Scripture through the memory of the disciples. What, if anything, does it accomplish for the author’s own community? It affirms the community’s/Jesus’/the disciples’ viewpoint and restricts meaning for them. It gives them an elevated status as the ones who have the necessary key truly to understand and believe Scripture, in this case post-Easter faith. Shared assumptions mark a group, and post-Easter faith is a primary shared assumption. The post-Easter faith stance as mediated through the Johannine community and its texts also serves as a strong boundary marker, effecting cultural exclusion. As Wuthnow argues, one element of boundary construction has to do with the presentation of beliefs wherein boundaries are set by making the belief system one not accessible to everyone. This may be done by the group’s claim to maintain unique beliefs while simultaneously not definitively delineating those beliefs. Additionally, the group may pepper its presentation with references to esoteric, historical, philosophical, and theological sources of wisdom. This is similar to the situations at Qumran and Waco, where the key lay in the teachings of the Teacher of Righteousness and the revelations of David Koresh. The opponents of the group, especially the religious establishment as represented by those who were executing the synagogue expulsions, would certainly have used Scripture as traditionally understood to combat the claims and behavior of the Christians who had only lately been among them. But the author’s community should not be discouraged, as they should understand that those opponents are in error regarding Scripture. The passage also situates Jesus as a locus of authority because Scripture cannot be understood apart from him. Finally, it shows that Scripture, what “is written,” is an authoritative source. Moreover, John 2:17 implies that Ps 69:9 was written with Jesus in mind, so that one finds the community assuming that it is the telos of Scripture. As noted ear-
241
lier, given a society that has traditionally associated the sacred with certain religious institutions, a congregation can take advantage of that situation by tying itself to such institutions. In producing his own sacred cultural product, the author of the Fourth Gospel augments its sanctity by attaching it to that which is traditionally sacred.
Excursus: 5:31–47 Though ch. 5 contains no direct citations, it is so central to understanding what the author is trying to accomplish by using Scripture that it deserves some attention. In 5:31–47 Jesus attacks the Jews (ofl ÉIouda›oi) because of their attitude toward Scripture. As is usually the case when Jesus comes into conflict with the Jews concerning Scripture, John is careful to set the scene in the temple, the traditional center of Judaism. As has often been noted, the cleansing of the temple episode sets the tone for the whole Gospel’s attitude toward the temple (as well as Jerusalem; cf. ch. 4): the center has shifted to Jesus himself—his body is the new temple. So it is no mistake that John repeatedly sets these confrontations between Jesus and the scriptural traditions in the context of the temple. Jesus charges the Jews with not having God’s Word abiding in them (ka‹ tÚn lÒgon aÈtoË oÈk ¶xete §n Ím›n m°nonta, ˜ti ˘n ép°steilen §ke›now, toÊtƒ Íme›w oÈ pisteÊete). The reader familiar with John knows that every word is saturated with meaning here. The “Word of God” has triple significance; it refers to Jesus, to Jesus’ words (lÒgoi, =Æmata, §ntola¤), and to Scripture. First, it refers to Jesus, the Word made flesh, the Word sent by God. The Jews do not “believe,” which immediately identifies them as outsiders since abiding belief constitutes salvation in this Gospel. Those who do believe abide in Jesus and he in them, and they abide in Jesus’ words and his words abide in them. This point is driven home in the portion of John’s Gospel directed strictly to the disciples, or insiders, who represent John’s community, most notably at 15:1–10: 15:1 ÉEg∆ efimi ≤ émpelow ≤ élhyinÆ, ka‹ ı patÆr mou ı gevrgÒw §stin. 15:2 pçn kl∞ma §n §mo‹ mØ f°ron karpÒn a‡rei aÈtÒ, ka‹ pçn tÚ karpÚn f°ron kaya¤rei aÈtÚ ·na karpÚn ple¤ona f°r˙. 15:3 ≥dh Íme›w kayaro¤ §ste diå tÚn lÒgon ˘n lelãlhka Ím›n: 15:4 me¤nate §n §mo¤,
242
kég∆ §n Ím›n. kay∆w tÚ kl∞ma oÈ dÊnatai karpÚn f°rein éfÉ •autoË §ån mØ m°n˙ §n tª émp°lƒ, oÏtvw oÈd¢ Íme›w §ån mØ §n §mo‹ m°nhte. 15:5 §g∆ efimi ≤ êmpelow, Íme›w tå klÆmata. ı m°nvn §n §mo‹ kég∆ §n aÈt“ otow f°rei karpÚn polÊn, ˜ti xvr‹w §moË oÈ dÊnasye poie›n oÈd°n. 15:6 §ån mÆ tiw m°nh §n §mo¤, §blÆyh ¶jv …w tÚ kl∞ma ka› §jhrãnyh ka‹ sunãgousin aÈtå ka‹ efiw tÚ pËr bãllousin ka‹ ka¤etai. 15:7 §ån me¤nhte §n §mo‹ ka‹ tå =Æmatã mou §n Ím›n me¤n˙, ˘ §ån y°lhte afitÆsasye, ka‹ genÆsetai Ím›n. 15:8 §n toÊtƒ §dojãsyh ı patÆr mou, ·na karpÚn polÁn f°rhte ka‹ g°nhsye §mo‹ mayhta¤. 15:9 kay∆w ±gãphs°n me ı patÆr, kég∆ Ímçw ≤gãphsa: me¤nate §n tª égãp˙ tª §m˙. 15:10 §ån tåw §ntolãw mou thrÆshte, mene›te §n tª égãp˙ mou, kay∆w §g∆ tåw §ntolåw toË patrÒw mou tetÆrhka ka‹ m°nv aÈtoË §n tª égãp˙.
Abiding in the words of the Word causes believers to produce good fruit and gives them the right to ask for anything they wish with the assurance it will be granted. Such is not the case for those who do not abide in the Word; rather, they are thrown into the fire and burned. John provides only two categories: those who abide in the words of the Word and therefore bear fruit and receive divine favors, and those who are incinerated. “The Jews” in ch. 5 belong to the latter group. The Jews are shortsighted regarding the word of God. To them “the word of God” refers solely to Scripture as it has been written rather than to Jesus and his words, much as bread from heaven refers to that which Moses gave rather than that which God is presently giving. Scripture operates like the many other traditions and ancestors, which have become dead weight that drags the Jews down and keeps them from putting their belief in the proper place, namely, Jesus. They have their word and the Johannine community has the word of its Word. John sets them next to each other and proceeds to demote Scripture, much as he does with John the Baptist, Moses, et al. They search (§raunãv) the Scriptures (grafa¤) because they consider them the source of eternal life (zvÆ afi≈niow). But John has already shown that the proper paradigm is to seek Jesus, come to him, and receive eternal life. Jesus alone is the source of eternal life. The Jews have mistaken the testifier for the one who is testified to. Scripture merely serves to point to the words of God made known through the Word of God. It is another witness. In v. 42 Jesus pronounces that they do not have the love of God
243
in them (tØn égãphn toË yeoË oÈk §xete §n •auto›w). Again the experienced reader (and John’s own community) sees the connection for John between the word of God and the love of God because she has read 15:1–10, which also moves from a discussion about abiding in Jesus and his words to how that amounts to abiding in Jesus’ love. Jesus clinches his argument by saying that these very Scriptures from which they seek life will lead them not into life but into judgment. At the end of the attack John invokes Moses in Moses’ capacity as author of Scripture. 5:38–39 parallels 5:45–46 as follows: 5:38 ka‹ tÚn lÒgon aÈtoË oÈk ¶xete §n Ím›n m°nonta, ˜ti ˘n ép°steilen §ke›now, toÊtƒ Íme›w oÈ pisteÊete. 5:39 §raunçte tåw grafãw, ˜ti Íme›w doke›te §n aÈta›w zvØn afi≈nion ¶xein: ka‹ §ke›na¤ efisin afl marturoËsai per‹ §moË:
5:45b ¶stin ı kathgor«n Ím«n Mv#s∞w, efiw ˘n Íme›w ±lp¤kate. 5:46 efi går §pisteÊete Mv#se›, §pisteÊete ín §mo¤: per‹ går §moË §ke›now ¶gracen. 5:47 efi d¢ to›w §ke¤nou grãmmasin oÈ pisteÊete, p«w to›w §mo›w =Æmasin pisteÊsete; Jesus moves thus: “You do not have God’s word abiding in you because you did not believe me. You should have believed me because you have the Scriptures which Moses wrote. But the fact is that for all of your supposed homage to and respect for Moses, you do not actually believe what he wrote.” And, then, in a qal vehomer climax: “And if you have not even gotten to the point of believing Moses, who is a mere first step (who is your highest authority, the one you trust the most, which obviously is not very much), how are you going to move to the higher ground which is me?” They are liars—they claim to honor Moses but they do not. Just before this, Jesus is pitted against Moses because the Jews have “set their hope” on Moses. As it turns out, Moses becomes just another witness to Jesus and even accuser of the Jews. So it is not Jesus against Moses—it is (a) putting Moses in his proper place and (b) pitting Jews against Jesus via Moses since Moses is a witness to Jesus; because he is a witness to Jesus, he is simultaneously an accuser of those who do not hear Moses’ testimony. So, again, Jesus catches them coming up short because he proves that, in fact, though they
244
claim to believe Moses, they actually must not, because if they did it would be “ergo: Jesus”. The very last verse, much like 2:22, shows John setting the words of Jesus above the words which Moses wrote. Jesus’ words must increase; Moses’ must decrease so that they serve as a witness to Jesus, a stepping stone, but not the Final Word. One would like to know what texts John has in mind when he has Jesus say this, but he never cites a specific text. I assume that they include at least all those which John deploys or alludes to in the Fourth Gospel. John 6:31: ofl pat°rew ≤m«n tÚ mãnna ¶fagon §n tª §rÆmƒ, kay≈w §stin gegramm°non, ÖArton §k toË oÈranoË ¶dvken aÈto›w fage›n. The next indication from the author that he is quoting from Scripture comes at 6:31 in the Bread Discourse.49 As previously noted, the scriptural interpretation has been recognized by Peder Borgen and others (including Wayne A. Meeks) as central to the form of this passage. The present task lies in discovering any clues to its social function. 6:1–15 narrates a day near Passover filled with epiphanies of Jesus’ divinity: the miraculous feeding of the five thousand and Jesus’ walking on water. He only narrowly escapes coronation. The next day, the audience that had been left behind by Jesus and his disciples discovers the abandonment, and John rather comically devotes a few verses to getting the crowd reunited with Jesus, no small task since the disciples had taken the only boat. Even this small part of the chapter relates to the Bread from Heaven insofar as a fresh round of boats arrives for the abandoned audience, and at that point the author writes: êlla ∑lyen ploiã[ria] §k Tiberiãdow §ggÁw toË tÒpou ˜pou §fagon tÚn êrton e`ÈxaristÆsantow toË kur¤ou (6:23). The crowd locates Jesus and asks him why he chose to go across the sea, to which he responds by accusing them in terms of the previous day’s feast of bread, ÑAmØn émÁn l‹gv Ím›n, zhte›t° me oÈx ˜ti e‡dete shme›a, éllÉ ˜ti §fãgete §k t«n êrtvn ka‹ §xortãsyhte (6:26), and then turning their attention away from earthly bread to heavenly bread. Jesus then calls them to believe in him, but the crowd wants to know 49 There is much scriptural play going on in this passage. NA26 cites Ps 78.24, but Exod 16 is the more likely source. No one else quotes Ps 78.24, and only 1 Corinthians alludes to the bread of Exod 16.
245
what sign Jesus will do to warrant their belief; it would appear that (a) they had forgotten the previous day’s miracle or (b) Jesus was right in his estimation that they had not even comprehended the sign but had simply eaten well (6:26). The crowd then attempts to pit Moses against Jesus, with Moses emerging as the victor since he performed a sign by giving the Jews bread from heaven, whereas, in the crowd’s estimation, Jesus has not only not performed an equal sign with his bread multiplication, he has simply not performed a sign. As Jesus’ Jewish opponents are wont to do in this Gospel, they use Scripture against him: ofl pat°rew ≤m«n tÚ mãnna ¶fagon §n tª §rÆmƒ, kay≈w §stin gegramm°non, ÖArton §k toË oÈranoË ¶dvken aÈto›w fage›n (6:31). Jesus responds in a surprising way, which practically obsoletes Scripture, when he tells the crowd that what really matters is not that God gave bread from heaven, but that God is giving them bread from heaven; what is more, this bread, in comparison with that given in the wilderness, is the “true” bread: oÈ Mv#s∞w d°dvken Ím›n tÚn êrton §k toË oÈranoË, éllÉ ı patÆr mou d¤dvsin Ím›n tÚn êrton §k toË oÈranoË tÚn élhyinÒn:
Most interpreters mention the play in the ambiguity of the third person singular, ¶dvken, so that Jesus changes the subject of the verb from Moses to God. I disagree that the major contrast has to do with the subject of the verb, Moses or God; rather, the contrast is between the obsolete past and the pregnant present.50 The import of 50 Brown, ( John, 232), directly opposes this argument. He notes the contrast in verb tenses, but stresses continuity rather than contrast: “Notice the contrast between the past (aorist of perfect) and the present tense in the final line in v. 32: the Father’s giving has begun and will continue.” Bultmann’s argument ( John, 227–28) stands closer to mine insofar as it emphasizes discontinuity with the past: “The reference to manna is important also, because according to the Jewish belief the coming Messiah, as the ‘second Redeemer,’ must correspond to Moses, the ‘first Redeemer,’ because, that is to say, the miracle of manna must be repeated in the final age. Thus this reference to the manna gives expression to man’s folly in imagining that he knows the signs by which the Redeemer is to be recognised, his folly in imagining that he has criteria at his disposal to which the revelation must conform in order to gain recognition; whereas in fact God’s revelation destroys every picture which man’s desires make of it, so that the real test of man’s desire for salvation is to believe even when God encounters him in a totally different way from that which he expected.” After first translating John’s verbs “back into Hebrew” (a dubious enterprise, perhaps), Peder Borgen allots considerable attention to establishing that 6:31–33 represents “midrashic method, patterns and terminology” (Bread
246
the contrast lies in the fact that at 5:39 Jesus accuses the Jews of seeking eternal life in the Scriptures and in doing so failing to attain the eternal life inherent in Jesus. In that passage, just as in the present one, the Jews used Scripture as a defense against Jesus, and in that passage, just as in the present one, Jesus claims that they should turn their eyes from Scripture to him if they want to have eternal life. This interchange is yet another example of Scripture as a hindrance to the Jews’ coming to belief in Jesus. Again, Witten’s observations about the rhetoric of the preacher are relevant. The Jews display the same qualities, the same goals, the same actions, use the same means of actions throughout the narrative. The outcomes of their actions are also almost always the same. The narrator always affirms the impression given by the narrative regarding the Jews. While the character portrait appears to be exaggerated for homiletic purposes, it is not unreasonable to imagine that the exchange reflects that which is occurring in the author’s own community; that is, on the basis of Scripture itself, those from the parent tradition challenge the Johannine Christians and their claims. Moses, as the preeminent prophet and purveyor of divine doings and discourse, is the likeliest figure against whom to pit the Jesus of these Johannine Christians. The author faces the issue directly and shows the community how to work around the Moses problem both here and elsewhere.51 He takes up the comparison and the result, in the words of Wayne Meeks, is this: “Here as in 9:28, the decision has to be made whether to be disciples of Moses or disciples of Jesus. Only the latter receive the ‘real bread,’ the ‘food that remains for eternal life.’”52 The author has used Scripture here, in the mouth of the opponents, as a rhetorical technique to effect inclusion or exclusion. The opponents’ very act of quoting Scripture thus degrades them and shows them to be obtuse as well as recalcitrant in their insistence on adhering to
from Heaven, 67). With respect to the actual significance of the tense changes, Borgen says only this: “The midrashic pattern of contrast makes clear the significance of the tenses of the verbs in v. 32, referring back to a different vocalization of the verb in the Hebrew text (not ˆtn, but ˆtwn). Parallels in the midrash indicate that the preferred vocalization of a participle (ˆtwn, in Greek present tense d¤dvsin) makes the verb refer to eschatological time” (Ibid.). 51 See also John 3:14–15 where Moses was able to grant a bit of mortal life but Jesus grants eternal life. Because this passage is only an allusion and not a direct quote, it does not receive attention in this study. For a thorough treatment of the relationship between Moses and Jesus in the Fourth Gospel, see Meeks, Prophet-King. 52 Meeks, Prophet-King, 92.
247
Scripture rather than Jesus. This depiction of the Jews furthers the status degradation effect presented in chapter two using John 8. He also uses the opportunity to show Jesus’ special insight regarding Scripture and, in a negative way, to show once again Jesus and only Jesus as the group’s locus of authority. If it is correct to suggest that this exchange reflects polemic between the parent tradition and the Johannine community, then we have evidence of opposition to and from the parent tradition. John 6:45: ¶stin gegramm°non §n to›w profÆtaiw, Ka‹ ¶sontai pãntew didakto‹ yeoË: pçw ı ékoÊsaw parå toË patrÚw ka‹ may∆n ¶rxetai prÚw §m°. This passage represents a significant trump for John’s community in that its members obviously are those designated as “taught by God” who have heard, learned, believed, and gained eternal life. These characteristics are the very ones that the opponents lack: throughout the Fourth Gospel they are described antithetically as those who do not hear, do not understand, do not know, do not believe; they die, vainly seeking eternal life in the Scriptures. It also represents another claim for Jesus’ equality with God. John produces the sacred by tying his community in with that which is traditionally sacred. He also performs what Wuthnow calls “cultural exclusion” by insisting that one must be taught by God, which for him can only be done through Jesus. Before leaving John 6, I want to comment on the possibility of sect-defection that appears to be implied in 6:66. Recall that the scriptural quotation was invoked by the crowd at the beginning of the discourse and served to structure the remaining speech on Jesus’ part. He concludes his peroration with a reference back to that original citation and, just as he did at the opening, he once again takes up their scriptural challenge and simultaneously distances himself from any authority that Scripture might have: otÒw §stin ı êrtow ı §j oÈranoË katabãw, oÈ kay∆w ¶fagon ofl pat°rew ka‹ ép°yanon: ı tr≈gvn toËton tÚn êrton zÆsei efiw tÚn afi«na (6:58). The distance is felt on a number of counts, not least of which is the contrast between what “your fathers”53 and the present consumers eat and gain as a 53
Those textual witnesses that include Ím«n simply make explicit the possessive pronoun implied by the fact that the fathers alluded to here are those introduced on the lips of the opponents at 6:31 as “ofl pat°rew ≤m«n.”
248
result. At this point, “many of Jesus’ disciples” (pollo‹ oÔn ékoÊsantew §k t«n mayht«n aÈtou) find themselves questioning what Jesus has said; with customary Johannine irony, the author depicts them in light of the very Moses who served as the cause for the speech by describing their complaining as goggÊzv, a term he uses three times in this passage and which is reminiscent of the wilderness situation.54 As was the case in the Exodus wilderness, manna has been miraculously provided, but rather than effecting belief and understanding in the recipients, the “sign” evokes nothing but murmuring. Similarly, it is easy to overlook the fact that Jesus’ warning not to work for “food that perishes” alludes to the fact that manna spoiled if left overnight (Exod 16:19–20). Further, the complaints that led to the provision of manna are paralleled by the story of craving also for “flesh,” which God supplies in another miracle (Exod 16:12–13; Num 11:31–32). There is a very intricate argument built up in Jesus’ discourse here, a discourse that has many more dimensions when the reader is aware of these allusions. At the very least, the author heavily degrades the opponents by implicitly defining them in terms of Moses’ opponents, much as he explicitly degrades them when he attributes their paternity to the devil. Jesus’ opponents are the antitype to Moses’; both the Davidians and Qumranians use the same technique. Using scriptural images and categories to define the social relationships among the actors in the narrative contributes to the building of that powerful “special vocabulary” that Wuthnow has indicated exists among successful groups.55 Jesus announces that only the elect whom God has chosen can come to him; this declaration overly taxes the patience of “many of his disciples” (pollo‹ [§k] t«n mayht«n aÈtoË) who apostatize upon hearing it. Those who apostatize are degraded as the “not chosen.” 54 The Israelites’ “murmuring” (goggÊzv) in the wilderness begins in Exodus and provides one of the leitmotifs of Numbers. In Numbers, it appears especially in chs. 11, 12, 13, 14, 16, 17, 21, and 25. Of particular interest to the present discussion, at 11:1ff. they murmur (goggÊzv) about the manna that God has miraculously provided in the wilderness. In Johannine terms, they remain blind and hostile in the face of a sign from God. God responds to their murmuring with judgment (Num 14:2, 27, 29). goggÊzv appears twenty-seven times in the : five times in Exod, nine times in Num, and once at the beginning of Deut. Its occurrence in Ps 105:25 refers back to the murmuring in the wilderness. Likewise, of its thirteen appearances in the , goggusmÒw occurs five times in Exod 16 and twice in Num 17. 55 Duke also recognizes the scriptural heritage of goggÊzv: “That they still bear the blindness of their fathers to the true Father is clear from the designation of their unbelief as “murmuring” (vss. 41, 43)—a deliberate echo of the murmuring which surrounded the first gift of manna.” Irony, 65.
249
If we assume that the author does not aim here to show the failure either of Jesus’ 30 .. community or his own ca. 90 .. group, we must ask why he would present such a falling away. One reasonable suggestion is that it reflects his response to the problems of apostasy in his own community, a problem evident and treated in the Branch Davidian and Qumran communities as well. But the author recognizes that rewards are necessary for the sacrifice on the part of the sectarians and therefore he bolsters his group in various ways here. First, unlike the apostates, the committed members will receive eternal life. Second, when a leader loses “many” disciples, how does he or she encourage the others to abide? The leader reminds them that they can be assured they are among “God’s chosen,” as John does. Once again John faces his problem directly; rather than smooth over the defection, he has Jesus confront the remaining disciples: “Do you also wish to go away?” The response of Jesus’ faithful disciples would surely have inspired those faced with the same choice in John’s own community: “Lord, to whom can we go? You have the words of eternal life. We have come to believe and know that you are the Holy One of God” (my italics). It pays to stay. As Susan Harding notes: A people gives its church many gifts, of course—sociability, services, creativity, loyalty, prayers, and more—and all of them, insofar as they are free gifts, function, like tithes and offerings, “outside” the market economy, according to noncommercial logic. They generate an invisible world, a “kingdom of the spirit,” in which God is worshiped continuously through all sorts of sacrificial giving and God blesses people with “good measure, pressed down, and shaken together, and running over.56
Sects represent what Swidler has identified as “unsettled lives,” which are characterized by high ideology and demanding, rigid expectations. This ideology and the concomitant expectations conflict with both tradition and common sense, which are represented singularly in the Fourth Gospel by “the Jews.” John 7:38: ı pisteÊvn efiw §m°, kay∆w e‰pen ≤ grafÆ, potamo‹ §k t∞w koil¤aw aÈtoË =eÊsousin Ïdatow z«ntow. To treat 7:38 properly I must attend to nearly the whole of ch. 7. For purposes of analysis, the chapter will be treated in two parts, 7:14–24 and 7:37–52. 56
Harding, “The Gospel,” 53.
250
7:14–24 The saying of Jesus at 7:38 provides the climax of the episode that begins with his declaration in 7:14–24. Once again the temple is the setting for conflict regarding Scripture. In ch. 5 Jesus accuses the Jews of searching the Scriptures because they thereby hope to have eternal life. There they never get the opportunity to defend themselves against the charge. Now they do and, as it turns out, they act in complete accordance with Jesus’ prediction about them. This serves at least two purposes for John: (1) it again shows the Jews as fatally mistaken and obdurate (thus, showing John’s own opponents as such), and (2) it shows the power of Jesus’ own words: what he says is true. Only in chs. 5 and 7 does the word grãmma appear. In 5:47 it refers to what Moses wrote. When Jesus goes into the temple and teaches in the middle of the Festival of Booths (7:15) the Jews marvel and ask, P«w otow grãmmata o‰den mØ memayhk≈w; The teaching function is important here as it sets up numerous comparisons. First, it takes the reader back to 5:47 where there is a comparison between what Moses wrote (grãmma) and Jesus’ own words (=∞ma), with more importance being placed on the latter. So, the reader already has that comparison in mind when she arrives at 7:15. And, indeed, John reiterates the distinction and superiority of Jesus’ own words because they come from God: “My teaching (didaxÆ) is not my own but his who sent me,” as opposed to the law which is written (grãfv) by Moses, given (d¤dvmi) by Moses (7:19, 1:17), and is defined as being “of Moses” (Mv#s°vw). On the surface, grãmma has quite different meanings in the two passages, but the initiated Johannine reader is accustomed to John’s penchant for multivalent diction. Second, John deploys his usual irony in this passage to make the opponents look foolish. The Jews claim that Jesus has never been taught (manyãnv; 7:15), but Jesus has just said in 6:45: ¶stin gegramm°non §n to›w profÆtaiw, Ka‹ ¶sontai pãntew didakto‹ yeoË: pçw ı ékoÊsaw parå toË patrÚw ka‹ may∆n ¶rxetai prÚw §m°. The Johannine play on words and irony act to reveal the Pharisees’ lack; Jesus, the authoritative Word, “knows” not only letters, the literal meaning, but also Mosaic writings as the word grãmma means at the only other place it appears. John probably deliberately avoids referring to grafÆ in 5:47. Jesus knows what Moses wrote (grãmma) and not only has he learned from God, but everyone who has been taught by God
251
(didakto¤; in the narrative, the followers of Jesus; in John’s community, the sectarians themselves) arrives at Jesus and his teachings. They get beyond the law of Moses (though the opponents actually fail even to comprehend the law of Moses). Jesus uses Moses for two different arguments in this passage. First, Jesus indicates that Moses gave them the law and Jesus categorically declares that none of them keeps it. In the second argument, he approaches the matter differently. In a statement that appears to contradict what he has just said, he grants that they do keep the law of circumcision given by Moses and argues that if they follow through with their logic, they will see that if it is proper to attend to a small part of man’s body on the sabbath, then it must be even more proper to attend to the whole body. The net effect is to attack the Jews on all sides, to cover all the bases of attack. None of them keeps the law; but even if they do, they still fall short ultimately. The passage achieves three goals. Primarily, it shows the Jews/John’s opponents as bumbling fools and degrades them emphatically and en masse. Furthermore, it sets the reader up for the supremacy of Jesus’ own teaching that will come especially in chs. 13–17 by showing the law, which Moses gave, to be a human gift as opposed to Jesus’ commandments (§ntolÆ) which are a gift from God. There is no reason one should expect the opponents to be didakto‹ yeoË when they do not even allow themselves to be taught by Moses. If they did, they would have to grant Jesus’ qal vehomer argument regarding circumcision, but instead they try to kill him. Finally, it makes thicker the line between insider and outsider insofar as Jesus deploys distancing pronouns. It is not the case that Moses gave the law “to us” and “you” do not keep it while we really do, but rather Moses gave the law “to you” (Ím›n) and “you” do not follow it. They have Moses; John’s community has Jesus. John is the only Gospel author not to include Deut 6:5 and Lev 19:18. The only binding law is that which Jesus himself lays down.57 The argument deployed here is identical (even with respect to diction) to that which 57 Again, Moses “gave” the law “to you all” ( Jews); the Jews do not “do” the law. The Fourth Gospel expects one to adopt both beliefs and actions. The author contrasts what the Jews “do not do” (poi°v) and what followers of Jesus and Jesus himself “do.” At 5:27 Jesus announces that God grants resurrection of life to those who “do” (poi°v) good, and resurrection of judgment to those who “do” (prãssv) evil. The law is something you do; Scripture is something you believe. Likewise, Jesus demands that his followers “believe” his words and “do” his commandments.
252
appears in ch. 10, where Jesus indicates their apparent concern not to break (lÊv) Scripture as here they appear to be concerned about breaking the law. It implies that 10:35 should be seen as a concession, not as a proclamation on Jesus’ part. 7:37–52 Verses 25–36 relate the remaining events of that day. At 7:37 we reach the final part of the chapter, the last day of the Festival of Booths and an important passage for those interested in John’s use of Scripture. The precincts of the temple provide the setting (cf. v. 45). Jesus initiates discussion of the role of Scripture. The passage betrays contrivance insofar as Jesus simply stands up in the temple unprovoked and shouts out (krãzv) that folks should believe in him and invokes Scripture in his outburst. It is only Scripture that ties the passage together, and it is Scripture which John wants to focus on in this passage. The result of the conflict, in typical Johannine style, is a schism (sx¤sma; cf. 7:43; 9:16; 19:24; 21:11) between those who believe and the leaders who take action against Jesus. Jesus’ proclamation results in others expressing their opinions concerning where Scripture fits into this picture. What does this say about John’s own community? It shows that Jesus and his relationship to Scripture constituted a “problem” with respect to both claims about his identity and his actions. This relationship between Jesus and Scripture caused schism among not only the leaders of the parent tradition, but also the ordinary Jew, Greek, and Samaritan represented in the narrative by the people from the ˆxlow. In terms of structure and content, 7:12–13 and 7:40–44 share parallels: 7:12a ka‹ goggusmÚw per‹ aÈtoË ∑n polÁw §n to›w ˆxloiw:
7:12b: ofl m¢n ¶legon ˜ti ÉAgayÒw §stin,
7:12c: êlloi [de] ¶legon, OÎ, éllå planò tÚn ˆxlon.
7.43 sx¤sma oÔn §g°neto §n t“ ˆjlƒ diÉ aÈtÒn: 7:40 ÉEk toË ˆxlou oÔn ékoÊsantew t«n lÒgvn toÊtvn ¶legon, OtÒw §stin élhy«w ı profÆthw: 7:41a: êlloi ¶legon, OtÒw §stin ı XristÒw,
7:41b: Ú d¢ ¶legon, MØ går §k t∞w Galila¤aw ı XristÚw ¶rxetai;
7:13 oÈde¤w m°ntoi parrhs¤& §lãlei per‹ aÈtoË diå tÚn fÒbon t«n ÉIouda¤vn.
253
7.44 tin¢w d¢ ≥yelon §j aÈt«n piãsai aÈtÒn, éllÉ oÈde›w §p°balen §pÉ aÈtÚn tåw xe›raw.
The crowd experiences conflict over Jesus (7:12a, 43a). Some are inclined positively toward him (7:12b, 40) while others speak against him (7:12c, 41b). Trepidation keeps people from acting upon their wishes regarding Jesus (7:13, 44). As indicated above, I am often as struck by what John does not quote as by what he does. John does not beat one over the head with Scripture in the fashion of Matthew—he is at once more subtle and more powerful, even when he works with the “fulfillment” material in the passion narrative. This passage illustrates his skill in wielding Scripture. Surely John has in mind Isa 55:1 (ofl dic«ntew poreÊesye §fÉ Ïdvr ka‹ ˜soi mØ ¶xete érgÊrion bad¤santew égorãsate ka‹ p¤ete êneu érgur¤ou ka‹ tim∞w o‡nou ka‹ st°ar) when he puts the words of 7:37 on Jesus’ lips: ÉEãn tiw dicò §rx°syv prÒw me ka‹ pin°tv. But while he appears to be the only author (apart from
the author of Revelation, if different) to allude to Isa 55:1, he does not quote it directly. This may surprise the reader given (a) his frequent use of living, flowing water imagery (e.g., the wedding at Cana, Jesus’ side on the cross, the woman at the well, the blind man washing himself ) and (b) his penchant for quoting from Isaiah. This obvious and probably intentional omission highlights the power of John’s allusive technique; John does not aim for one-to-one correspondences, but rather infuses the world of his converts with biblical language and symbol, thereby shaping the very categories and language with which they think. Immediately following, however, he does purport to quote directly but refers to a passage undetectable to the modern who has all the advantages of concordance, computer, and NA26. If this happened only here, one might assign it to accident, but it happens elsewhere as well. John invokes Scripture in a formidable fashion here, introducing the “citation” with a solemn formula: kay∆w e‰pen ≤ grafÆ. Such a move lends authority to John’s own creative urges, corroborates Jesus’ words found in v. 37,58 and explains the validity of the claims of John’s community to have access to the Holy Spirit. There
58 It is no accident that Jesus’ words are presented first and then supported by Scripture rather than Scripture being cited first and Jesus saying, “Therefore. . . .”
254
is, as usual, a self-referential quality insofar as the reader is transported back to ch. 3 and the Nicodemus story, where we see water and Spirit linked. Koil¤a appears only elsewhere at 7:38 as it does in ch. 3, namely, in connection with pneËma so that one is born from above, from water and pneËma. The narrator directly informs the reader of the correct interpretation of the citation, no doubt because the interpretation is less than obvious. “These words” (ofl lÒgoi otoi) cause a schism. The members of the crowd are not privy to the narrator’s kindly interpretation about reference to the Spirit, so their reaction has nothing to do with that interpretation. In fact, in terms of the narrative itself, the interpretation is irrelevant and obtrusive. What has made these people voice such high claims regarding Jesus’ identity as prophet or Messiah? First, Jesus expects people to “believe in him” (pisteÊv efiw me—see the many references in John below). As noted above, the Scripture cited in v. 38 must refer to the believer’s heart, given that the word appears elsewhere only in the Nicodemus story. I noted that there would be nothing unusual about such an interpretation because John is so self-referential. John, however, is also the master of double entendre. In order for the ensuing schism to make sense, the “his” of v. 38 should apply to Jesus so that he is seen as explaining why people should believe in him based on Scripture. Indeed, the narrator has already told the reader that all of these words are somehow tied up in Jesus’ death, by which he refers to 19:34. But even those not advantaged by the narrator, namely, the crowd, sense that Jesus is talking about himself, so they argue about his identity rather than what a “believer” must do to drink or believe as Nicodemus and the Samaritan woman wonder. To this cryptic scriptural claim there are at least two responses concerning Jesus’ identity, probably three. The reader already expects this, however, as John prepared her in v. 12: “And there was considerable complaining about him among the crowds. While some were saying, ‘He is a good man’ (cf. v. 40–41a), others were saying, ‘No he is deceiving the crowd’ (41b–42). Yet no one would speak openly about him for fear of the Jews” (cf. v. 44). Some say he is a prophet. Others say he is the Messiah. Interest is momentarily lost in the prophet designation and the Messiah identity explored. Here we once again see John accomplishing two feats at once. First, he ridicules those who are quite caught up in Scripture on the one hand, but, finally, miss the point. They argue over “what Scripture
255
says” concerning Jesus and “where he is from.” The irony involving the motif of whence Jesus comes has been attended to,59 and what we want to notice presently is John’s determination to rise above such mundane details through that irony. As upon every occasion in which John employs irony, the irony here effects a line between insider and outsider and highly elevates the insider while degrading the outsider. Under the subheading “Irony as Weapon,” Paul Duke explains one of irony’s functions thus: “While Irony has her allurements and richly rewards those who dance with her, she can be positively cruel to her enemies. . . . One of the functions of irony is the making and the mocking of victims. While irony is a witness to those who will see, it is a weapon against those who will not see.”60 With respect to the Fourth Gospel itself, Duke proclaims: “So irony in the Fourth Gospel, with discourse splendidly extraordinary, invites the reader to abide with an ascended Christ and to see from that height what a world that loves darkness will not see.”61 Second, John says something about Scripture here, and this is the main point of vv. 37–44. Note John’s clever way of contrasting Jesus and the crowd in citing Scripture: in vv. 37–38 Jesus tells them what the Scripture said (≤ grafØ e‰pen); at v. 42 we hear some of them pondering what Scripture said (≤ grafØ e‰pen). Jesus declares that Scripture attests to him, and if one believes in Scripture, one should believe in Jesus, whereas vv. 40ff. reveal that such is not the case for the members of the crowd, whose “knowledge” of Scripture obfuscates their view instead. The character referents in this snippet are difficult to identify. Verse 40 identifies one group: ÉEk toË ˆxlou . . . ékoÊsantew . . . ¶legon; v. 41a introduces êlloi who proclaim Jesus as Messiah. The texts vary concerning whether or not a third group enters at 41b, but the evidence strongly favors a third group.62 Presumably it is those of 41b who represent the tinew of v. 44 who want to arrest Jesus. 59
Duke, Irony, 64–69. Ibid., 39–40. Wayne Booth also comments on the dual nature of irony, its creative and destructive powers: “The building of amiable communities is often far more important than the exclusion of naïve victims. Often the predominant emotion when reading stable ironies is that of joining, of finding and communing with kindred spirits. . . . every irony inevitably builds a community of believers even as it excludes.” Wayne Booth, A Rhetoric of Irony (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1974), 28; quoted in Duke, Irony, 151. 61 Duke, Irony, 1. 62 The appearance of a third group enjoys strong external and internal support. 60
256
John can provide details when the intended effect warrants as much. “Nicodemus came by night”; they brought “a hundred pounds of spices”; Peter warmed himself by a “charcoal fire”; the aroma of the perfume filled the air; and so on. So why such ambiguity regarding which Scriptures are being cited by Jesus and those in 41b, and why such vagueness regarding the characters in this episode? The story primarily presents the contention between John’s community and those outside the group who attack the validity of Jesus and John’s community vis-à-vis the . That is incontestable on the general level. We might speculate in further detail and imagine in Martyn-type fashion that the “story” represents the following scenario: a Johannine preacher63 preaches the words of Jesus, including Jesus’ exegesis, and some hearers have taken the first step toward belief as evidenced by their confession of him as prophet or Messiah.64 These potential converts are then confronted by Jews well versed in Scripture (religious authorities, studious neighbors)65 who seek to show that Scripture does not support the claims of the Johannine community at all and, in fact, undermines those claims. The two sides wrestle for possession of Scriptures.66 First, the evidence includes P66 and a, among others. Formerly, Nestle-Aland included the third group as the preferred reading. Internally, a third group is logical given that the ofl of 41b assume that Jesus is not the Christ while those of 41a declare him to be the Christ. 63 For Martyn’s defense of “doubling” Jesus with an early Christian preacher, see History, 28ff. 64 The Samaritan woman of ch. 4 and the blind man of ch. 9 fit this category. For a full account of Martyn’s interpretation of John 9 as a two-level drama that reflects not only a story that happened “once upon a time” in Jesus’ ministry, but also the contemporary situation of the evangelist’s community, see History, 24ff. 65 The purpose behind naming “religious authorities” and “studious neighbors” lies in indicating that the Johannine community faced opposition not only from “the men in power” (represented in ch. 9 by “the Jews”) but also from their ordinary Jewish neighbors (represented by “the crowd”); both groups could use Scripture against the sect. Martyn identifies the religious authorities as “the Gerousia in John’s city” by which he refers to “the ruling body of Jewish elders in John’s city.” History, 32. Or, asking who the leaders are to whom the formerly blind man is led, Martyn says: “The Pharisees in chapter 9 probably reflect the authority of the Bet Din in Jamnia much more than they reflect an historical ‘Pharisaic Sanhedrin’ of Jesus’ day.” History, 31 n. 29. 66 That the deployment of Scripture in this passage reflects the situation of the Johannine community itself is also suggested by Wayne A. Meeks when he addresses John 7:41–42: “Here the opponents appeal directly to ‘the Scripture’ in asserting that ‘the Christ comes from the seed of David and from Bethlehem . . .’ The simplest explanation for the evangelist’s inclusion of this objection is that it played a role in the polemic between the Jews and the Christian community he represents.”
257
John 8:17: ka‹ §n t“ nÒmƒ d¢ t“ Ímet¤rƒ g°graptai ˜ti dÊo ényr≈pvn ≤ martur¤a élhyÆw §stin. This is part of an odd passage. At 8:13 the Pharisees reject Jesus’ testimony regarding himself, declaring the invalidity of a self-testimony. Jesus agrees that he is bearing witness to himself but argues that nevertheless the testimony is true. In 8:17 Jesus quotes to his Jewish opponents out of “their law,” identifying himself and his Father as the two men. Furthermore, Jesus’ statement in 8:14, “Even if I do bear witness to myself, my testimony is true, for I know whence I have come and whither I am going, but you do not know whence I come or whither I am going,” contradicts his own words at 5:31–33: “If I bear witness to myself, my testimony is not true; there is another who bears witness to me, and I know that the testimony which he bears to me is true. You sent to John, and he has borne witness to the truth.” The point at 8:17 is not for Jesus to express his own commitment to Scripture but rather to argue using his opponents’ own terms. By his comment in 8:14 he indicates that he is not beholden to the regulations of Scripture, as he is quite above and beyond its confines due to his unique status as one equal to God. As we shall see throughout the Fourth Gospel, when Jesus engages the Jews in debate, his pattern is to try to move them from their present state of commitment, namely, searching the Scripture in order to have eternal life, to the ultimate teleological commitment, namely, himself and his Father. In such instances, he invokes that which they know and
Prophet-King, 36. Martyn provides detailed exposition of ch. 7 in History. He shows how the Pharisees would have appealed to Torah in legally charging Jesus with leading people astray (pp. 73–81); at the end of this argument, he concludes: In portraying action taken against Jesus on the basis of this charge, John is not dependent on “Jesus-tradition,” but rather primarily on his own experience. In his city the second and awesome step taken by the Jewish authorities (16:2b) was designed not to frighten synagogue members with the threat of excommunication, but rather to stop Jewish-Christians once and for all from missioning among their own people. Do not such missioners persuade others to worship Jesus as a god alongside of God (5:18)? In spite of their having been excommunicated, they are, therefore, in the technical and legal sense, persons who lead the people astray. The law itself warns about them (Deut 13:6ff.) and provides the punishment due them. They are to be legally arrested, tried, and if found guilty, executed (p. 81). Martyn also provides an excursus on planãv (158–60), and an excursus on “John 7:45–52 and Acts 5,” (161–63).
258
firmly grant, Scripture, to argue on their own terms. In this particular passage, what is at issue is the validity of Jesus’ testifying to himself. This passage shows redundancy with ch. 5 so that the author has yet another opportunity to degrade the opponents as obtuse and driven by the sinister desire to “catch Jesus out,” especially with regard to Scripture. If there is redundancy in the character of the Jews, so too with Jesus’ character. He is adept and masterful with Scripture and puts it in its proper place. John 10:34: épekr¤yh aÈto›w [ı] ÉIhsoËw: oÈk ¶stin gegramm°non §n t“ nÒmƒ Ím«n ˜ti §g∆ e‡pa: yeo¤ §ste; The next direct quote occurs at 10:34. During the controversy with the Jews who want to stone him, Jesus invokes part of Ps 82 (81):6: §g∆ e‰pa yeo‹ §ste ka‹ uflo‹ Íc¤stou pãntew. The pericope begins at v. 22 and is introduced by an announcement that the following took place during the Festival of Dedication. “The Jews” encircle Jesus (v. 24) and they demand that he frankly (parrhs¤&) tell them whether or not he is the Messiah. Of the thirty-one times parrhs¤a appears in the , nine are in the Fourth Gospel. The English phrase “out in the open” approximates the meaning of the word, so it can have the sense of something done publicly or frankly. Certain motifs recur that would remind a competent reader of the former episode in ch. 7. That chapter begins with the narrator informing the reader that Jesus was avoiding Judea because “the Jews” were trying to kill him. His brothers assume incorrectly that he wants to be out in the open (§n parrhs¤&) so they encourage him to go up to Judea (the very place that the reader knows Jesus is avoiding), particularly Jerusalem, for the Festival of Booths to perform his works rather than remaining in secret (§n krupt“) in Galilee. They further insist: efi taËta poie›w, fan°rvson seautÚn t“ kÒsmƒ, making clear that for them, at least, Jerusalem comprises “the world.” Jesus plays on this by saying, “The world cannot hate you, but it hates me because I testify against it that its works are evil.” That “the world” can be synonymous with “the Jews” is easily proven, and I will offer just one example. In 15:18, Jesus warns his disciples: “If the world hates you be aware that it hated me before it hated you” (v. 18). He goes on to characterize this “world” as “they” who “do not know him who sent me. If I had not come and spoken to them, they would not have sin; but now they have no excuse for their sin” (v. 22). As
259
noted above, in a number of places in the Fourth Gospel, Jesus speaks to the Jews, meets with disbelief, and then later reminds them of what he had earlier spoken (e‰pon). In addition, Jesus’ comment about their sin takes the reader back to ch. 9, where an intense controversy between the Jews and the healed man (not to mention between the parents of the man, as well as among “the Jews” themselves) ensues after the healing. At the end of the incident, Jesus uses the same language that he uses in 15:22, when he says to the Pharisees: “If you were blind you would not have sin, but now that you say, ‘We see,’ your sin remains” (9:41).67 The “centripetal tendency” in the Fourth Gospel is strong. Jesus rejects his brothers’ suggestion and remains in Galilee (v. 9), but just until they leave. Then he does, in fact, go up to Jerusalem, not publicly (faner«w) as they had urged but in secret (§n krupt“). While there, “the Jews” seek him out and disagree over him, but the author indicates that even these people did not speak openly (parrhs¤&, 7:13) for fear of “the Jews.”68 But in ch. 10 Jesus comes out into the open, ironically, teaching “the Jews” not only in “the temple” but specifically in the portico of Solomon, that great Wisdom figure. Everything Jesus says in response to their exhortation to openness he has said to them already, as Jesus himself notes (10:25). Regarding his works, they need only remember the controversy over his healing the man ill for thirty-eighty years and the ensuing discussion (esp. 5:17–18 and 5:36); regarding his sheep, they need only recall the recent controversy over Jesus as the good shepherd (10:1–21); regarding Jesus’ unity with the Father, they may once again recall the controversy of ch. 5.69 Just as in ch. 5, “the Jews” attempt to kill Jesus. He stalls the attack by patronizingly asking which good work from the Father has inspired the attack? Just as in ch. 5, they
67 Bultmann contends: “The term ofl ÉIouda›oi, characteristic of the Evangelist, gives an overall portrayal of the Jews, viewed from the standpoint of Christian faith, as the representatives of unbelief (and thereby, as will appear, of the unbelieving ‘world’ in general).” John, 86. 68 This passage attests to the author’s somewhat inconsistent use of groups as single characters. “The Jews” look for Jesus, but “the crowds” (presumably Jewish crowds) argue over him (7:12) and operate in fear of “the Jews” (7:13). At 7:43 “the crowd” again appears divided over Jesus. At 9:16 it is “the Pharisees” who are divided over him, and at 10:19 it is “the Jews.” 69 The reader, of course, knows of this unity from the start, John 1:1.
260
miss the point that the works and the unity with the Father are inseparable and claim that it is not the good works that have incited them (of course the reader of chs. 5, 9, and 11 knows that this comment is patently untrue), but his blasphemy. There is further repartee from Jesus in which he invokes part of Ps 82 (81):6, which he claims comes from “your law” (OÈk ¶stin gegramm°non §n t“ nÒmƒ Ím«n):70 “I said, ‘You are gods.’” “Even stronger is the heightening of the initially innocuous claim in John, for there the form of the argument is explicitly a fortiori: ‘If [Scripture] calls those yeo¤ to whom the Word of God came . . . are you saying that I blaspheme because I said that I am God’s son—I whom the Father consecrated and sent into the world as his envoy?’ (vv. 35–36).”71 There are three other subtle moves going on at the narrative level in this scriptural exchange. First, the rest of the line of Ps 82 (81):6 which remains unquoted, but perhaps assumed, is (¶ste) uflo‹ Íc¤stou, and it approximates Jesus’ own claim for himself as a uiÚw toË yeoË. Second, the exchange further validates the claim initially made in the Prologue, namely, the Word (lÒgow) efiw tå ‡dia ∑lyen, ka‹ ofl ‡dioi aÈtÚn oÈ par°labon. If these “Jews” who are contesting Jesus were not blind, surely they would see the irony at play in Jesus’ characterizing the psalm as being spoken to §ke¤nouw . . . prÚw oÓw ı lÒgow to# yeoË §g°neto; that is, they are ofl ‡dioi. Third, the clause ka‹ oÈ dÊnatai luy∞nai ≤ grafÆ has traditionally been translated as an aside on the part of Jesus, but there is no reason to do so. Rather, the proposition that Scripture cannot be broken is not a proclamation by Jesus but simply a second protasis of a conditional clause.72
70
Both the “your” and the “law” call for explanation. Regarding the former, there is a textual variant that omits the troubling Ím«n, but given its attestation at 8:17, and the likelihood that the possessive makes the more difficult reading, the possessive remains. Regarding the latter, it appears that for first-century Christians and Jews, the term nÒmow had a larger application than the Pentateuch. 71 Meeks, “Equal to God,” 314. One might argue contrary to Meeks’s proposal. That is, one might expect Jesus to argue via a fortiori here: “If those to whom the word of God came were called ‘gods’ how much more so the Word of God himself.” But the author does not play on lÒgow in that way here. Instead, he argues from the greater to the lesser, using Scripture deftly to make them look the fool. That is, he argues that if the psalmist is to be trusted (and, a priori, for them he is) when he records either God or himself calling those to whom the word of God came “gods” then surely Jesus’ simply calling himself a “child of God” should cause no offense (emphasis added). 72 In personal correspondence, dated November 15, 1996, Victor Bers, Professor of Classics, Yale University, wrote: “Now, as I read the sentence, it seems to me
261
This argument is substantiated by reference to 7:23 where, again, the reference to the breaking (lÊv) of the law of Moses is provided as the protasis of a condition. If, as is obviously the case, both conditions A and B are true, then it follows that a human person can innocuously be called yeÒw (or an equivalent, i.e., uflÚw yeoË), especially if that person was also loved by God and sent as God’s envoy into the world. It appears that the common translation has been influenced by Matthew where, in fact, Jesus does proclaim that Scripture cannot be broken. But John is not Matthew. The controversy concludes, as usual, with Jesus having the last word, and just as in ch. 5, he proclaims his unity with the Father, which incites “the Jews” to arrest him. After reading this controversy story, the Johannine Christian has every reason to feel superior to her synagogue-Jew opponent who claims that confession of Jesus is erroneous, even blasphemous and deserving of death. The deployment of Scripture here further delineates the camps, and the opponents of the sect are identified and degraded as those who do not even understand their own law, surely the deepest of insults for a Jew. That explains the force of the possessive, Ím«n, which has troubled various translators needlessly. It is used for ironic purposes to degrade the opponent. It also demonstrates that the group’s founder, Jesus, has special insight regarding Scripture; unlike the opponents who believe themselves to be acting in accordance with “their” law by stoning Jesus, Jesus truly knows Scripture. The Johannine Christians, as confessors of Jesus, are defined and elevated here, as elsewhere, as those who believe Jesus, believe his works (cf. 2:11), and know and understand that “the Father is in me and I am in the Father.” The use of irony on Jesus’ part in
that there is no way to be sure whether the second clause is parenthetical or not. My intuition, though, is that it is parallel to the first. In general, classical Greek does not require, and in fact avoids, repetition of elements in a second clause that can be easily supplied from the first, hence it’s natural that there isn’t a second efi to introduce oÈ dÊnatai. Moreover, both verbs are indicative, with no indication by the particle én that we have a contrary-to-fact condition; and the difference in tense is required by the logic, i.e., a past tense since the calling happened in the past, and a present for a permanent truth about Scripture. My guess is that if the author wanted to indicate an unmistakable difference in the status of the two clauses, he could have done so. One way would be to postpone the oÈ dÊnatai clause so that it would stand after the (rhetorical) question; or even clearer, to postpone it and add a gãr after the oÈ. Then Jesus would be saying, first, that Scripture says thus and so, and then that he himself was applying a principle.”
262
the narrative effects inclusion and exclusion. The insiders are those who “get” both the play on Scripture that leaves the opponents speechless and the play on the language concerning “those to whom the Word of God came;” those who do not understand are outsiders. The passage reveals Jesus as the locus of authority. If Scripture is presented as a locus of authority for the Johannine Christians, it is done in a manner less obvious than the fulfillment quotations or a passage like 1:23, where John the Baptist identifies himself by the invocation of Scripture. At the narrative level, Jesus seems to employ Scripture merely to cast Scripture back into the faces of the opponents, fighting fire with fire, so to speak. The opponents intend to obey their law, which requires stoning for blasphemy, so in that sense, they themselves bring up the issue of Scripture. This inspires Jesus to best them. He shows that these “Jews” of the parent tradition who accuse Jesus of breaking Scripture have broken it themselves by attempting to stone him unjustifiably. It also manifests the author’s continual effort toward status degradation with respect to the parent tradition. They are murderers, liars, etc., and in depicting them as such, he further augments the myth of the opponents as “totally other.” It is tempting to register this as evidence for degrading those who break Scripture. That category raises an interesting point with respect to the Fourth Gospel: unlike the authors of the Qumran material, Jesus does not care, from a halakic viewpoint, if the opponents break Scripture; he himself takes no pains to observe it. Rather, he uses their breaking Scripture simply as a way to lampoon them on their own terms. They are supposedly concerned with obeying Scripture, but they fail to maintain consistency. Finally, Jesus’ use of the word Ím«n serves as a stark boundary marker indicating here those who are entrenched in “settled lives” and unwilling to sacrifice the rewards inherent in a settled life.73 73 A note on ethics. This passage in ch. 10 draws heavily upon Ps 82 (81):6. Not only does Jesus directly quote it, but also he appears to draw upon it in his claim to be a son of God, as noted above. But there is additional interesting play. Jesus’ invocation of the psalm is somewhat misleading; he presents God as calling the mere listeners “gods,” but in the psalm itself, God proclaims that only to deflate by contrast those listeners by saying, “nevertheless, you shall die like mortals, and fall like any prince” (v. 7). Just before those declarations of God, the psalmist complains: “They have neither knowledge nor understanding, they walk around in darkness” (v. 5a–b). Knowledge (gn«siw and its cognates) is a favorite word and theme for the author of the Fourth Gospel, and, in fact, in response to the “Jews” in ch. 10 he remarks: “But if I do them . . . believe the works, so that you may believe
263
John 12:12–15: Tª §paÊrion ı ˆxlow polÁw ı §ly∆n efiw tØn •ortÆn, ékoÊsantew ˜ti §rxetai ı ÉIhsoËw efiwÉ ÑIerosÒluma 12.13 ¶labon tå ba˝a t«n foin¤kvn ka‹ §j∞lyon efiw Ípãnthsin aÈt“ ka‹ §kraÊgazon, ÑVsannã: eÈloghm°now ı §rxÒmenow §n ÙnÒmati kur¤ou, [ka‹] ı basileÁw toË ÉIsraÆl. 12.14 eÍr∆n d¢ ı ÉIhsoËw Ùnãrion §kayisen §pÉ aÈtÒ, kay«w §stin gegramm°non, 12.15 MØ foboË, yugãthr Si≈n: fidoÁ ı basileÊw sou ¶rxetai, kayÆmenow §p‹ p«lon ˆnou. The next place in which the author indicates that he is directly quoting Scripture appears at 12:13–15. The author himself does not immediately indicate that the material in v. 13 is to be found in Scripture, and indeed it appears to draw from at least two texts. The first part, eÈloghm°now ı §rxÒmenow §n ÙnÒmati kur¤ou, comes from Ps 118 (117):26 and appears also in Mark, Matthew, and, with modification, in Luke. The phrase ı basileÁw toË ÉIsraÆl appears nowhere in Scripture, but Zeph 3:1574 does contain the phrase basileÁw ÉIsraÆl.75 The argument for inclusion of v. 13 as a direct quote must depend on the taËta found in the authorial note, which informs the reader that taËta oÈk ¶gnvsan aÈtoË ofl mayhta‹ tÚ pr«ton, éllÉ ˜te §dojãsyh ÉIhsoËw tÒte §mnÆsyhsan ˜ti taËta ∑n §pÉ aÈt“ gegramm°na ka‹ taËta §po¤hsan aÈt“ (12.16).
and understand that the Father is in me and I am in the Father” (v. 38; whereas both the psalmist and Fourth Gospel author use gin≈skv for the first word, the psalmist uses sun¤hmi where the evangelist uses gin≈skv again for the second word). The psalmist goes on to criticize the people for walking in darkness, skot¤a, another favorite Johannine term. (Of the sixteen occurrences of the word in the , eight occur in the Fourth Gospel and six in 1 John.) Could it be that Ps 82 (81) was a signature Scripture for the Johannine Christians? If so, might we not expect the ethics therein to be presumed by the group? If this is the case, the ethics delineated there include judging justly (kr¤siw and its cognates being favorite Johannine terms), not showing partiality to the wicked, giving justice to the weak and the orphan, maintaining the right of the lowly and the destitute, and rescuing the weak and the needy. Or does a different ethic apply for sectarians such that they do not care for anyone outside the group? In other words, the traditional Jewish ethic may have been turned on its head such that the ethics of the Psalms do not apply and are replaced by “love one another.” Both Matt and Luke worry about the lowly, the poor, etc., terms missing from the Fourth Gospel. 74 NA26 provides an italicized reference to Zeph 3:15 in the text, indicating the conviction that the author quotes that Scripture; however, the reference is not included in the appendix. 75 Meeks observes: “The Scripture quotation in John 12.15 differs from Matthew as well as from all known text traditions of both Hebrew and Greek Old Testaments. The coincidence that both Matthew and John quote the Zechariah passage is therefore best explained by positing a common tradition at some point behind both,
264
At 12:15 the author clearly signifies that he draws directly from Scripture by using the introductory formula, kay«w §stin gegramm°non, but then offers a quotation found nowhere in Scripture. Parts of the quotation are reminiscent of Scripture, and scholars have offered various suggestions. NA26 lists Zech 9:9, Isa 35:4, and Isa 40:9.76 The center of the quotation is a paraphrase or variant of Zech 9:9. xa›re sfÒdra becomes mØ foboË, a common biblical phrase.77 The references which NA26 gives, Isa 35:4 and 40:9, have second person plural imperatives. While the context of the second may apply somewhat to the location in John, it is more reasonable to assume that the Genesis and Deuteronomy references are alluded to, given the epiphanic nature of the Gospel’s christology, given the idea of God’s movement with the people, and given the Fourth Gospel’s penchant for making Jesus a Mosaic figure. Most likely, the author has more than one text in mind, though it is difficult to see how Isa 35:4, as suggested by NA26, should be considered among them. The next part of the “quotation,” yÊgathr Si≈n . . . ¶rxetai, appears to come from Zech 9:9, though the author may have other texts in mind as well.78 The last part also appears to stem from Zech 9:9 but has some variation of it. The text reads: §pibebhk∆w §p‹ ÍpozÊgion ka‹ p«lon n°on. How to account for the difference is debatable. Perhaps the author is (mis)quoting from memory or perhaps he is working from an alternative text of the passage.
which in turn reinforces the conclusion that the Zechariah passage shaped the tradition of the entry at its earliest stages. . . . The title is motivated by the confluence of the fourth evangelist’s theological concerns with the royal implications of the whole scene, especially the quotation from Zechariah itself.” Prophet-King, 86. 76 To be more precise, NA26 lists Isa 40:9 in the margin but not in the appendix. 77 It appears forty-two times in the . In Gen it is spoken by God or an angel of God (Gen 15:1; 21:17; 26:24; 28:13; 46:3); the rendition of 28:13 includes mØ foboË whereas BHS does not). Moses says it twice in Deut 31:6: mØ foboË mhd¢ deil¤a mhd¢ ptohyªw épÚ pros≈pou aÈt«n, ˜ti kÊriow ı yeÒw sou ı proporeuÒmenow meyÉ Ím«n, and 31:8: ka‹ kÊriow ı sumporeuÒmenow metå soË oÈk énÆsei se oÈd¢ mØ §gkatal¤p˙ se: mØ foboË mhd¢ deil¤a. 78 For instance, one might hear echoes of Isa 62:11, given that passage’s interest in proclaiming salvation to daughter Zion. Likewise, Zech 2:14 () is a good candidate since in it God proclaims to come (¶rxetai) and dwell (kataskhnÒv, cf. John 1:14) with daughter Zion (yÊgater Si≈n). Yet another possibility is Zeph 3:14–15 where daughter Zion is to rejoice because the “king of Israel, the Lord, is in your midst.” The language of “king of Israel” and “in your midst” is Johannine. Or it may reflect Mic 4:8–9 where daughter Zion is questioned as to the cause of her crying aloud: mØ basileÁw oÈk ∑n soi.
265
Unlike John, Matthew has Jesus direct the disciples to procure a donkey and a colt for Jesus and then explains: ToËto d¢ g°gonen ·na plhrvyª tÚ =hy¢n diå toË profÆtou l°gontow, E‡pate tª yugatr‹ Si≈n: ÉIdoÁ ı basileÊw sou ¶rxeta¤ soi pra#w ka‹ §pibebhk∆w §p‹ ˆnon ka‹ §p¤ p«lon uflÚn Ípozug¤ou (21:4–5). Matthew then has the crowds
shout, “Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord,” but does not indicate that this was to fulfill Scripture. On the other hand, John has Jesus get his own single young donkey and indicates that both the crowd shouting and the securing of the donkey (taËta as opposed to Matthew’s toËto) reflects material recorded in Scripture. But beyond these superficial differences, there is an even more striking and significant one; that is, whereas Matthew narrates the occurrence of the events in a chronological fashion and promptly proceeds with the story, John uses the scriptural citations as an opportunity to elevate Jesus, elevate the disciples, and indicate that the true understanding of Scripture is enjoyed only by those who understand Jesus’ glorification. The disciples’ original lack of understanding is swept away presumably at some point after the Gospel narrative itself ends, and they “remember” that these particular Scriptures actually applied to Jesus all along. Recall that the same thing occurred with reference to the cleansing of the temple in ch. 2. Only John places the disciples in this position of “remembering” that amounts to revelation. Likewise, the author maintains that such knowledge is dependent upon Jesus’ “glorification,” or death and resurrection, and, therefore, belongs only to the Christian. What does this do for the community that used this text? First, it designates Scripture as a locus of authority. Theoretically, John could have told the story without reference to Scripture. For example, both Matthew and Luke mark the inauguration of Jesus’ ministry with quotations from Isa 9 and 61, respectively; John does not. This is an important point: we must resist the temptation to casually skim over John’s use of Scripture by saying, “Well, those scriptural passages are just part of his received tradition and John does not really have a choice as to whether or how he uses it.” To the contrary, often John draws upon Scriptures that appear nowhere else in the Gospels or even the ; at other times, he uses the same scriptural passage that appears in other texts but places it elsewhere in his narrative; finally, some scriptural passages that appear in all of the other Gospels and some other texts are not present in John. John’s inclusion of Scripture in the story of the triumphal
266
entry implies that Scripture, “what is written,” matters a great deal to the story. This is an example of the persistence of tradition; in unsettled lives such as sects, the sectarians will still think in traditional patterns to some degree. The passage also serves as one more way for the preacher to shape authoritatively the worldview of the listener, by having both Scripture and the narrator’s interpretive commentary confirm that the event was in keeping with what Scripture had foretold. The passage also functions to elevate Jesus insofar as he is the one about whom it was written. Scripture signifies Jesus, and his ministry and glorification are in accordance with it, despite the accusations contrariwise probably being made against the Johannine Christians. Not only does Scripture serve that function, but the quote about the donkey also allows the author to clarify that Jesus fulfilled the Scripture without assistance. This deployment of Scripture also sets up an impermeable boundary, with the Johannine Christians on the inside and their opponents on the outside. The Johannine Christians are those whose (collective) memory is jogged on the basis of Jesus’ glorification, and the opponents are those who do not believe or understand Jesus’ glorification and, therefore, cannot hope to understand that “these things were written of him” (12:16) and, in Jesus’ own words, “testify on my behalf ” (5:39). The passage illustrates cultural exclusion in action. Beliefs are presented but in such a way that the belief system is not readily accessible to everyone. The exclusion may be facilitated both by the group’s claiming to maintain unique beliefs while simultaneously not definitively delineating those beliefs and by peppering their presentation with reference to esoteric, historical, philosophical, and theological sources of wisdom. In the process, a boundary is drawn between insider and outsider. Here, as in ch. 2, the “insider” is the one who receives revelation through remembrance which occurs only after Easter. In a subtle way the passage grounds the community in the hoary past because it claims that what was written long ago actually referred to the Jesus in whom the group believes. With Scripture, John has a built-in tool, a “chunk of culture” that facilitates certain patterns of action such as formation and maintenance of a sectarian lifestyle and worldview. After all, he is competing with the parent tradition for followers; what better tool than its own Scriptures?
267
John 12:37–41: TosaËta d¢ aÈtoË shme›a pepoihkÒtow ¶mprosyen aÈt«n oÈk §p¤steuon efiw aÈtÒn, 12.38 ·na Ù lÒgow ÉHs˛ou toË profÆtou plhrvyª ˘n e‰pen, KÊrie, t¤w §p¤steusen tª ékoª ≤m«n; ka‹ ı brax¤vn kur¤ou t¤ni épekalÊfyh; 12.39 diå toËto oÈk ±dÊnanto pisteÊein, ˜ti pãlin e‰pen ÉHs˛ou 12.40 TetÊflvken aÈt«n toÁw ÙfyalmoÁw ka‹ §p≈rvsen aÈt«n tØn kard¤an, ·na mØ ‡dvsin to›w Ùfyalmo›w ka‹ noÆsvsin tª kard¤& ka‹ straf«sin, ka‹ fiãsomai aÈtoËw. 12.41 taËta e‰pen ÉHs˛ou ˜ti e‰den tØn dÒjan aÈtoË, ka‹ §lãlhsen per‹ aÈtoË. This is the next place that the author himself denotes a scriptural quotation.79 The narrator intrudes here to explain the apparent resistibility of Jesus’ message on the part of “the crowd” (ı ˆxlÙw). As a character in the narrative, the crowd is difficult to define precisely.80 At 12:34 the crowd initiates a conversation on Jesus’ messiahship. He responds by exhorting them to “believe” (v. 36). It is the crowd then, which is logically indicated by the third person plural language in the passage that follows. This passage indicates that the crowd did not believe in Jesus (TosaËta d¢ aÈtoË shme›a pepoihkÒtow ¶mprosyen aÈt«n oÈk §p¤steuon efiw aÈtÒn), which contradicts 7:31 (ÉEk toË ˆxlou d¢ pollo‹ §p¤steusan efiw aÈtÒn) and 7:40f. (ÉEk toË ˆxlou oÔn ékoÊsantew t«n lÒgvn toÊtvn ¶legon, OtÒw §stin élhy«w ı profÆthw: êlloi ¶legon, OtÒw §stin ı XristÒw). Their stance vis-àvis Jesus is not the only perplexing issue; one also wonders who comprises this “crowd.” In 12:9 they are presented as Jews ([ı] ˆxlow polÁw §k t«n ÉIouda¤vn) and the present passage contributes to such a characterization by saying, ˜mvw m°ntoi ka‹ §k t«n érxÒntvn pollo‹ §p¤steusan efiw aÈtÒn, éllå diå toÁw Farisa¤ouw oÈx …molÒgoun ·na mØ éposunãgvgoi g°nvntai. All of these “characters,” that is, the crowd, the authorities, and even the Pharisees, have been characterized in earlier chapters as suffering divisions among themselves on account of Jesus’ identity and validity.81 The author seems to collapse the groups so that there is overlap among the crowd, the Jews, the Pharisees, and the authorities. The author displays ambivalence
79 NA26 lists 12:27 as the next direct quote, but the author himself does not indicate this. 80 See Culpepper’s treatment of the crowd in Anatomy, especially pp. 131–132. 81 The crowd at 7:43, the Pharisees at 9:16, the “Jews” at 10:19, and the authorities, especially represented by Nicodemus, at 7:45–52.
268
toward those from the group who believe. As noted above, he can characterize these people as “believing,” but then go on to exclude them categorically from the group of believers (e.g., at 12:37 he does not say that “some” did not believe, but rather simply that “they” did not believe), only to claim a few verses later that “many, even of the authorities believed in him” (v. 42), but ultimately reveals disappointment with them by qualifying that belief thus: éllå diå toÁw Farisa¤ouw oÈx …molÒgoun ·na mØ éposunãgvgoi g°nvntai (v. 42b).82 The progression from initial belief to hostility occurs also in chs. 6 and 8 and probably indicates the trouble the sect had with defectors. Before we leave the crowd, it should be noted that, in typical Johannine fashion, “the crowd” serves as yet another witness (§martÊrei oÔn ı ˆxlow, 12:17) to Jesus. It might strike the reader of the Fourth Gospel as odd that Jesus’ message could, in fact, remain resistible. Twice Jesus seems to indicate that he expects the crowd to believe. In a prayer delivered to his Father just before he raises Lazarus, Jesus thanks his Father for having heard him. He declares: §g∆ d¢ ædein ˜ti pãntot° mou ékoÊeiw, éllå diå tÚn ˆxlon tÚn periest«ta e‰pon, ·na pisteÊsvsin ˜ti sÊ me ép°steilaw (11:42). Again, in 12:36 Jesus exhorts the crowd: …w tÚ f«w ¶xete, pisteÊete efiw tÚ f«w, ·na uflo‹ fvtÚw g°nhsye. Immediately after that (12:37) the author informs the reader that, in fact, “they” did not believe in him. For him who “knew what was in everyone,” this is a strange predicament in which to find himself. The author makes some attempt to account for Jesus’ resistibility by claiming that “the word spoken by the prophet Isaiah” was thus “fulfilled” by the unbelief of the crowd which Jesus had just evangelized. So strongly does the author want to make this point that he immediately repeats his argument but draws upon a different scriptural text the second time. He says, “For this reason they could not believe (oÈk ±dÊnanto), because Isaiah also said, ‘He has blinded their eyes and hardened their heart so that they might not look with their eyes, and understand with their heart and turn—and I would heal them’” (12:40). Moreover, the motif appears already in 2:23–25 and is illustrated by Nicodemus in ch. 3.
82 Raymond Brown argues that these “crypto-Christians” remain outsiders in the eyes of the Johannine community. Raymond Brown, The Community of the Beloved Disciple (New York: Paulist, 1979), 89.
269
Why does John reiterate this point so emphatically? As previously noted, it is not enough to imagine compulsion on the author’s part since his work seems to argue against such a simple explanation. The question of Jesus’ resistibility probably arose either from the Johannine community itself, seeking to understand how God’s message could remain uncompelling for so many of their contemporaries, or the question was put to them by their Jewish contemporaries in the form, “If this person was who you say he was, then why does the majority of your Jewish brothers and sisters remain unconvinced?” Most likely the “answer” given bolstered the insiders and offered an apology regarding outsiders. Two observations lead me to suspect that social reality drove this apology. First, the Synoptics nowhere use Isa 53:1. In fact, the only other occurrence of the text appears in Rom 10:16 (and then only the first part of Isa 53:1) where Paul explicitly addresses the very question I imagine the Johannine sect to have asked or have been asked, namely, how to explain the unbelief of the majority of Jews. Paul writes, “But not all have obeyed the good news; for Isaiah says, ‘Lord who has believed our message?’” Paul then explains that the Jews’ disbelief serves a definite and intentional function in God’s salvific plan. So, the only other appearance of the text occurs in a situation much like the one I imagine for John 12:38ff. Furthermore, the second text that John quotes, Isa 6:10, is used differently in the Synoptics. There it is always used to explain the obscurity of Jesus’ parables. John, who includes no parables, groups this text with Isa 53:1 to explain the disbelief of those whom the Johannine community would have expected to have believed. If my explanation for the inclusion of these scriptural texts is accurate, it becomes easy to imagine the functions served for the sect. First, the authority of Scripture as well as the contention that Scripture refers to the evangelist’s contemporary community is affirmed; the author claims that because (˜ti) Isaiah said so, the crowd could not believe. (Matthew places more blame on Jesus’ audience, stating that they simply “did not” perceive, listen, or understand, unlike John’s crowd who “could not” believe.) Scripture is clearly a locus of authority for the group. Second, the author of the Fourth Gospel not only quotes Isaiah, but he even explains why the prophet was moved to say such a thing in the first place: ˜ti e‰den tØn dÒjan aÈtoË, ka‹ §lãlhsen per‹ aÈtoË. The author shows that hoary Scripture actually applies and finds its telos in Jesus. Third, this use of Scripture
270
may be characterized as a rhetorical technique that validates the experience of the community and draws clear boundaries between insiders and outsiders. That is, there are those, indeed the majority, who have not joined the group. Why not? The answer, according to John and Paul: “Do not be troubled, all is going according to plan, as you can see by referring to Scripture.” This passage provides a good example of Garfinkel’s phenomenology of degradation rituals. The opponents are different in essence; they are those who are “not chosen.” A successful sect must offer heavy rewards to balance the sacrifices made by its members. The second scriptural quote implies a reward for the sectarians, namely, “healing”: ka‹ fiãsomai aÈtoÊw. The association between healing, salvation, and sin, especially the sin of faithlessness, is heavily attested in the and is assumed by some authors as well. It is a particularly favorite metaphor of the psalmist and the prophets, and applies both to individuals and to collective Israel. In Ps 40:5 (41:4), the author entreats God: KÊrie §l°hsÒn me: ‡asai tØn cujÆn mou, ˜ti ¥martÒn soi.83 The prophets, especially Jeremiah and Isaiah, frequently use this language. After proclaiming Israel’s faithlessness, God says, §pistrãfhte, uflo‹ §pistr°fontew, ka‹ fiãsomai tå suntr¤mmata Ím«n ( Jer 3:22). Later Jeremiah implores God: ‡asa¤ me, kÊrie, ka‹ fiayÆsomai: s«sÒn me, ka‹ svyÆsomai (17:14).84 Isaiah, from whom the author has taken both quotations in this passage, demonstrates an inseparable link between healing and salvation from sin. Isa 53:5 can speak of a certain salvific figure thus: aÈtÚw d¢ §traumat¤syh diå tåw énom¤aw ≤m«n ka‹ memalãkistai diå tåw èmart¤aw ≤m«n: paide¤a efirÆnhw ≤m«n §pÉ aÈtÒn, t“ m≈lvpi aÈtoË ≤me›w fiãyhmen. Isa 61:1, which serves a programmatic function at the inauguration of Jesus’ ministry in Luke, announces: pneËma kur¤ou §pÉ §meÄ, o e·neken ¶xris°n me: eÈaggel¤sasyai ptvxo›w ép°stalk°n me, fiãsasyai toÁw suntetrimm°nouw tª kard¤&, khrÊjai afixmal≈toiw êfesin ka‹ tuflo›w énãblecin. The author of the Fourth Gospel has adopted Isaiah’s vision of God as one who “hardens hearts” and one who “heals hearts.” The quote from Isa 6:10 is the first mention of heart (kard¤a) in the Fourth Gospel. As previously noted, that Scripture citation helps 83 Cf. Ps 102 (103):2–3: eÈlÒgei ≤ cuxÆ mou tÚn kÊrion ka‹ mØ §pilanyãnou pãsaw tåw éntapodÒseiw aÈtoË: tÚn eÈilateÊonta pãsaiw ta›w énom¤aiw sou, tÚn fi≈menon pãsaw tåw nÒsouw sou. 84
Cf. also Lam 2:13; Hos 6:1; 14:5.
271
to explain the resistibility of Jesus’ message and implies reward for the faithful sectarians. If the sectarians are to identify themselves with the disciples in the narrative, then the reward implied in the present passage becomes clearer in the succeeding narrative. Kard¤a is first mentioned at 12:40 as part of the quote. After that it occurs five more times, always with reference to Jesus’ disciples. In 13:2, the reader learns that the devil puts it into Judas’ heart to betray Jesus. Three times the disciples are described as troubled, afraid, and sorrowful in heart (14:1, 27; 16:6). The final occurrence of the word appears in a passage that once again acknowledges their pain but points toward the promise of joy: ka‹ Íme›w oÔn nËn m¢n lÊphn ¶xete: pãlin d¢ ˆcomai Ímçw, ka‹ xarÆsetai Ím«n ≤ kard¤a, ka‹ tØn xarån Ím«n oÈde‹w a‡rei éfÉ Ím«n (16:22). In addition to healing, then, the disciples in the narrative and the sectarians receive inalienable joy. That healing and salvation are synonymous is indubitable to any reader of the Synoptics; John’s own connection between healing and salvation is displayed in 3:14, where the author alludes to Moses’ lifting up the serpent in the wilderness to signify what effect Jesus’ crucifixion will have. The author does not explain what transpired in the Moses event but assumes that the reader already knows. In fact, Moses’ raising the serpent brought healing (ka‹ §po¤hsen Mvus∞w ˆfin xalkoËn ka‹ ¶sthsen aÈtÚn §p‹ shme¤ou, ka‹ §g°neto ˜tan ¶daknen ˆfiw ênyrvpon, ka‹ §p°blecen §p‹ tÚn ˆfin tÚn xalkoËn ka‹ ¶zh, Num 21:9), that is, life and salvation, two of the author’s favorite words. All of these, healing, salvation, and joy, are no small rewards for the insiders. Finally, in his concluding remarks on the pericope, the author implies that there are some potential sectarians who remain on the fringe for fear of being put out of the synagogue. The author has no patience for such people and contrasts Isaiah’s seeing Jesus’ glory and professing it with those who have seen but do not profess because they are more concerned with human glory than Jesus’. Such a presentation both calls the fence-sitters to complete allegiance and confirms those already wholly aligned with the group. We are once again reminded of the sect as a high ideology group characterized by unsettled lives prone to apostasy. Those in settled lives are wary of joining due to the heavy social dislocation involved. John 13:18: oÈ per‹ pãntvn Ím«n l°gv: §g∆ o‰da t¤naw §jelejãmhn: éllÉ ·na ≤ grafØ plhrvyª: ı tr≈gvn mou tÚn êrton §p∞ren §pÉ §m¢ tØn pt°rnan aÈtoË.
272
If the reader of 12:37 was struck by the author’s doubly-expressed explanation for the disbelief of the crowds, that reader will feel almost bludgeoned by the author’s response to what appears to have been the embarrassing fact of Jesus’ betrayal by one of his closest disciples. The Synoptics narrate Judas’ betrayal in roughly similar fashion. Judas confers with the chief priests and is promised money to betray Jesus; Jesus indicates his knowledge of his imminent betrayal by Judas; Judas leads the police to the garden and identifies the suspect with a kiss. Mark says no more about Judas. Luke claims that Judas bought a field with the “reward of his wickedness” (misyÒw t∞w édik¤aw), and then fell down and died, simultaneously getting his just reward and fulfilling Ps 69:26 (Acts 1:15ff.). Matthew narrates quite a different story. Matthew, whose community evidences a polemical engagement with fellow Jews similar to the Fourth Gospel’s in intensity, also seems to have suffered some assault and embarrassment on account of Jesus’ resistibility even to an “insider” like Judas. Matthew solves the problem by restoring Judas in a sense; he has Judas not only repent, but also return the money and tell the chief priests that Jesus was innocent. As if that were not enough, he even has Judas kill himself. So, Matthew handles the problem in a typically Matthean fashion, namely, by showing the disciples in the best possible light. Likewise, the author of the Fourth Gospel solves the Judas problem in a typically Johannine fashion, namely, by showing that Jesus is eminently in control of the situation, orchestrates everything that occurs, and is diminished in no way by anyone, even Judas. Jesus displays no sadness or frustration; rather, he comes across as a person who has received special information before anyone else and enjoys dropping enough hints to prove that he knows what is going to happen and can hardly stand the anticipation of seeing it all come to pass so that he can say, “See, I told you so.” Apart from the general comment at 2:24–25, the first specific evidence of Jesus’ knowledge regarding Judas’ betrayal appears at 6:71. Jesus has recently concluded the Bread Discourse and lost some disciples as a result. He then asks the Twelve if they want to depart, to which Peter responds with his confession of Jesus as the Holy One of God. On the heels of this climactic moment, Jesus indicates that one of the twelve is a “devil” (diãbolow). The author then identifies Judas as the culprit. Twice more the author mentions diabolical influence on Judas (13:2 and 13:27). By the time we arrive at ch. 13, we not only expect Judas to oppose Jesus, but we also have placed him into the
273
same category of degraded opponents who appear in ch. 8 and are portrayed as progeny of the devil. The narrator goes on to say (6:71), otow går ¶mellen paradidÒnai aÈtÒn, eÂw §k t«n d≈deka, his concessive clause implying that he is compelled to respond to the fact that Jesus was betrayed by an intimate insider. John again faces the problematic fact of Judas squarely in 12:4, which narrates the exchange between Jesus and Judas when Judas castigates Jesus for the waste of precious ointment. The author introduces the conflict with this description of Judas: ÉIoÊdaw ı ÉIskari≈thw eÂwÑ [§k] t«n mayht«n aÈtoË, ı m°llvn aÈtÚn paradidÒnai. He is once again boldly presented both as one of the twelve and as the betrayer. Whereas in 6:71 the author further characterizes Judas as a devil, here he adds “thief ” (kl°pthw) to the image. Judas appears more often in the Fourth Gospel than in any other work and, in the Fourth Gospel, he is never mentioned without the concomitant identification as the betrayer. The author begins ch. 13 by announcing both that Jesus “knew” that his hour had come and that he loved his own (ofl ‡dioi, cf. 1:11, etc.).85 The next verse (v. 2) shows that the devil came unto his own and his own, Judas, received him. Next, the reader hears once again that Jesus “knows” of his imminent return to God, and this knowledge leads him to wash the disciples’ feet; he initiates the process by telling Peter that Peter does not “know” what Jesus is doing. Jesus then pronounces almost all of the disciples clean. While Jesus does not tell the disciples who remains unclean, the author does apprise the reader: ædei går tÚn paradidÒnta aÈtÒn: diå toËto e‰pen ˜ti OÈx‹ pãntew kayaro¤ §ste (v. 11).86 Any disciple who was paying close attention two chapters later would deduce that Judas was the unclean disciple because Jesus proclaims to the disciples without qualification: ≥dh Íme›w kayaro¤ §ste diå tÚn lÒgon ˘n lelãlhka Èm›n 85 The concern about who belongs to whom in the Fourth Gospel is prominent. In the end, chs. 13ff indicate that only the disciples comprise Jesus’ “own.” It is not difficult to imagine that all of this “belonging” language established clear boundaries for the sect. The auditors are supposed to be among Jesus’ own and have God as their father. Those who are not Jesus’ own belong to the devil and have the devil as their father. Even Moses is not legitimate as a father; nor are ancestors such as Abraham or Jacob. 86 This kind of aside is consistent with the author’s insistence that the disciples could not understand all of Jesus’ words before the glorification, whereas the reader, who exists post-glorification, is privy to the information. The author distinguishes narrative time from the contemporary readers’ time.
274
(15:3). Judas was not among them (having gone out into the night at 13:30), and that is why Jesus could speak about cleanliness without caveat. Jesus goes on in ch. 13 to command the disciples to wash one another’s feet, arguing from greater to lesser; that is, if Jesus as Lord behaves that way, surely the disciples as slaves should. He then acknowledges them as insiders, literally, those in the “know” (13:17),87 but again, he qualifies his statement by adding oÈ pãntew, referring to Judas without explicitly saying so. At this point, the author once again highlights Jesus’ omniscience: “I know whom I have chosen.” The author again connects ch. 13 and ch. 6. At 6:70f. Jesus’ reference to his choosing of the Twelve is followed by a word against Judas, just as his reference to his choosing of the Twelve at 13:18b is followed by a word against Judas.88 Unlike ch. 6, however, the word against Judas is spoken by Jesus in a rather obscure way, from the narrative point of view. That is, Jesus follows his statement, “I am not speaking of all of you; I know whom I have chosen,” with a scriptural quote that he claims will be fulfilled. He roughly quotes Ps 40 (41):10:89 “the one who ate my bread has lifted his heel against me” and goes on to explain that he is telling them this prÚ toË gen°syai, so that when “it” happened it would effect belief in him regarding his identity. A passage such as this shows that the Gospel was written primarily with an eye to the contemporary audience rather than an eye to simple historical recounting, because from a narrative point of view the disciples would have been quite confused about the “it” that is going to happen. While the reader, as one who shares the narrator’s omniscient point of view, has been repeatedly prepared for Judas’ betrayal, the disciples have no idea that Judas has any nasty motives. We might expect the narrator to tell us here that after it happened they remembered what he had said and realized that the Scripture had been written of him. At the very
87 O‰da appears eighty-four times in the Fourth Gospel, twenty-four in Matt, twenty-one in Mark, and twenty-five in Luke; gin≈skv appears fifty-seven times in the Fourth Gospel, twenty in Matt, twelve in Mark, and twenty-eight in Luke. These figures have not been lost on those who want to see a gnostic influence on the Gospel. 88 Jesus mentions the fact that the disciples are his “chosen” (§kl°gv; he never uses §klektÒw) again at 15:16 (twice) and 15:19. 89 Quite likely Ps 41 as a whole was a psalm used by the community; it is a psalm that could easily be read christologically.
275
least, we might expect them to ask him to explain himself. That does not happen. Only at v. 21 does Jesus speak more clearly, “Very truly, I tell you, one of you will betray me.”90 Jesus further specifies the traitor as the fellow to whom he will give the intincted, baptized bread, and then gives that bread to Judas. Again, ch. 13 reminds the reader of ch. 6, the other place where bread, Jesus, and discipleship congregate. Just as Jesus indicated in ch. 6, and the narrator indicated in 13:2, Judas traffics with the devil. Jesus encourages Judas to complete his task. Oddly, the disciples do not “know” what Jesus means by this. Apparently no ruckus has emerged among them after Jesus has handed the baptized bread to Judas as they still seem to have no idea that he is the traitor. The episode ends with Judas departing into the darkness (v. 30). Clearly the author’s first concern is not with scrupulous narrative logic. What purpose is served by the quotation of Scripture here? The “problem” of Judas lends itself to two different, but not mutually exclusive, interpretations. First, the community may be sustaining attack on account of the scandal of Judas. Second, if we adopt Martyn’s proposal of a “two-level” drama, then Judas represents sectdefectors in John’s own community.91 The author uses Scripture apologetically to explain that the Judas affair amounts to no real crisis for the sectarians; quite to the contrary, it shows that Scripture validates the community’s experience, that Scripture was written with a view to the Johannine community. It also reveals, as do all invocations of Scripture, that Scripture is a locus of authority, certainly for the community, but it would appear that this is also the case for the opponents. The author not only reassures the community, but also provides them with a scriptural arsenal so that they might be equipped to battle the opponents on that front. In other words, bothering to show that a certain event is in keeping with Scripture implies that Scripture serves as a locus of authority for both the arguer and his 90 Passages like this elicit sympathy for those who long to help the evangelist arrange his Gospel more logically. For instance, narratively it would make more sense to place the scriptural quotation found in 13:18 between the first and second halves of 13:26, right after Jesus has told the disciples that one of them will betray Jesus and made the comment about dipping the bread. Furthermore, v. 20 seems a bit in the way. 91 Dahl finds in Judas a paradigmatic opponent: “Die Welt in ihrem Widerspruch zu Gott und seinem Gesandten existiert jedoch nicht nur außerhalb der Kirche, sondern auch im Kreis der Jünger Jesu. Dafür ist im vierten Evangelium Judas das typische Beispiel.” Dahl, “Der Erstgeborene Satans,” 80.
276
opponent. As is the case with both the Davidian and Qumran communities, Scripture is assumed to point to the Johannine community. The use of Scripture here also shows the sect’s founder to have special insight into Scripture as it is Jesus, not the narrator, who refers to the scriptural text. That the author intends to elevate Jesus is further intimated by Jesus’ comment immediately after his scriptural quotation in which he displays not only the supernatural gift of augury, but also that he is God.92 Jesus’ decision to quote Scripture at 13:18 does not make much narrative sense insofar as the disciples have no way of understanding what he means at that point. Unlike the reader, the disciples have no idea that Judas will betray Jesus and they have not yet begun eating bread. The author has his eye toward the reader, not the characters. The reader does, in fact, already suspect that Judas is the one to whom Jesus refers, and the author reveals a bit of woodenness here in having Jesus foretell the future, thus revealing his divine nature, and then immediately having it come to pass only a few verses later. In other words, had the author inserted the quote at the more “natural” place in terms of narration, namely, between 13:26a and 13:26b, it would manifest Jesus’ divinity less effectively, insofar as the occasion of eating bread could have “instigated” the quote, so to speak, and it would give the reader less cause to feel like an insider, one who knows and understands beforehand what is going to happen in the narrative. The reader would be more on the level with the disciples in the narrative. Instead, the reader has a full understanding of what is signified by Jesus’ giving the bread to Judas. This type of move falls under the use of literary and rhetorical techniques to effect inclusion or exclusion. Finally, the author “solves” the problem of Judas for the Johannine community, the problem of an insider apostatizing, through status degradation; the author shows not that Judas used to be “one of 92 The §g≈ efimi statements are a peculiar Johannine feature that has engendered much consideration. Generally speaking, they are taken to approximate God’s selfrevelation in the as “I am.” Bultmann distinguishes among John’s various uses of §g≈ efimi ( John, 225 n. 3). Edwin D. Freed has explored the §g≈ efimi phenomenon in various articles: “Ego Eimi in John 1:20 and 4:25,” CBQ 41 (1979): 288–91; “Ego Eimi in John viii.24 in the Light of Its Context and Jewish Messianic Belief,” JTS 33 (1982): 163–67; “Who or What Was before Abraham in John 8:58?” JSNT 17 (1983): 52–59. Neyrey provides a useful synopsis of John’s use of the phrase in An Ideology, Appendix I. See also Philip B. Harner, The “I Am” of the Fourth Gospel: A Study in Johannine Usage and Thought (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1970).
277
them” and then had a change of heart, but rather that Judas never really was one of them. It is worth exploring this feature, unique to the Fourth Gospel, using Garfinkel’s model. As discussed earlier, status degradation involves three dramatis personae: the denouncer, the denounced, and the group which the denouncer is trying to convince (which Garfinkel denominates “witnesses”). In the narrative, Jesus and the narrator collude as the denouncer, Judas is the denounced, and the disciples are the witnesses. On the historical level of the author’s contemporary audience, the author is the denouncer, the sectarians are the witnesses, and apostates from the sect are the denounced. Recall that the denouncer must present himself or herself as an authentic representative of the group, one who embodies the group’s ultimate values. Jesus plays this role. At the very beginning of the pericope, 13:1, one learns that Jesus loved his own (ofl ‡dioi); immediately after saying this, the narrator separates Judas from this group by marking him as the betrayer and as one associated with the devil: ka‹ de¤pnou ginom°nou, toË diabÒlou ≥dh beblhkÒtow efiw tØn kard¤an ‡na parado› aÈtÚn ÉIoÊdaw S¤mvnow ÉIskari≈tou (13:2). It is important to consider previous passages with which 13:2 is connected. First, this association with the devil is extremely significant given the first analysis of degradation that I performed regarding “the Jews” of ch. 8; there, one characteristic feature of the Jews was their connection to the devil. This connection must be remembered when reading ch. 13. Second, the opponents were characterized in ch. 12 as those whose hearts (kard¤a) were hardened. Judas’ heart (kard¤a) is controlled by the devil. Furthermore, ch. 12 found the narrator insisting that Judas was a thief (kl°pthw). Next Jesus washes the disciples’ feet. During that act, Jesus declares his disciples “clean.” Once again, Judas is immediately singled out as different and separate from the rest of the group: ka‹ Íme›w kayaro¤ §ste, éllÉ oÈx‹ pãntew. ædei går tÚn paradidÒnta aÈtÒn: diå toËto e‰pen ˜ti OÈx‹ pãntew kayaro¤ §ste (13:10b–11). Now not only is Judas controlled by the devil, but he is also unclean. Jesus emphasizes the essential connection between his disciples (servants) and himself (the master).93 Recall Garfinkel’s note: “What the denouncer says must be regarded by the witnesses as true on the 93 The intimate and essential connection between Jesus and the disciples is especially emphasized in the Farewell Discourse.
278
grounds of a socially employed metaphysics whereby witnesses assume that witnesses and denouncer are alike in essence. . . . For bona fide members it is not that these are the grounds upon which we are agreed but upon which we are alike, consubstantial, in origin the same.”94 Yet again, Jesus draws a strict boundary between himself and the witnesses on the one side and Judas on the other when he separates Judas out by saying: oÈ per‹ pãntvn Ím«n l°gv: §g∆ o‰da t¤naw §jelejãmhn, thereby doubly excluding him: first by not including him in the speech about the connection between Jesus and the disciples and second by labeling him “not-chosen.” Now Judas is controlled by the devil; his heart is in the wrong place; he is unclean; enjoys no servant relationship with the master; and is not among “the elect.” As Garfinkel claims, a successful status degradation requires first that the denounced and that which is being blamed on the denounced (Garfinkel calls the latter “the event”) must be “removed from the realm of their everyday character and be made to stand as ‘out of the ordinary.’”95 Second, the denounced and the event must be seen in terms of types rather than unique occurrences so that a certain uniformity regarding both is engendered. “[A]ny sense of accident, coincidence, indeterminism, chance, or monetary [sic] occurrence must not merely be minimized. Ideally, such measures should be inconceivable. . . .”96 Having been convinced of the typed nature of the denounced, the group must then think in dialectical terms such that “they should not be able to contemplate the features of the denounced person without reference to the counterconception,” so that character traits are further clarified when held to the light of their opposites. Having set the situation up in this way, the denouncer aims to have the witnesses in such a position that no real choice is involved when regarding the denounced; rather, morality constrains the group to believe that the need for denunciation is obvious, if not commonsensical. The rest of ch. 13 manifests these very features. Every single time Judas is mentioned, the author tags him as the “betrayer” so that the reader never really considers him to be a true disciple. Therein lies the irony that usually accompanies degradation ceremonies; that is, the disparity between what the denounced 94 95 96
Garfinkel, 423 body and n. 12. Ibid., 422. Ibid.
279
seemed to be and what he or she is now proved to be in reality is highlighted. Successful degradation requires that the character of Judas as presently described is taken to be the essential character which may have previously escaped notice. Throughout the Gospel, Judas appears to be one of the disciples, but the reader knows from Judas’ first introduction that such is not the case. In ch. 13 Jesus announces to the group that one of those present would betray him. While the reader knows exactly who is meant, the disciples in the narrative have no idea. They ask Jesus to be specific. He indicates that it is the one to whom he will hand the bread. As soon as he does so, the narrator once again paints Judas in terms of a heart controlled by the devil/Satan (efis∞lyen efiw §ke›non ı Satançw), just as he did in v. 2. The irony continues as the disciples, even after Jesus has given the bread to Judas identifying him as the traitor, think that Judas is going to help the poor, though the narrator has informed the reader in ch. 12 that Judas is patently not interested in helping the poor. The denunciation is further clinched by having Judas depart and the narrator conclude with these words: ∑n d¢ nÊj. In a Gospel that identifies true disciples with light and opponents with darkness, the comment is not accidental. Once Judas, the outsider, is eliminated from the group picture, the “insider-instruction” can begin, which it does at 13:31. The author has achieved stunning success in his status degradation; an impermeable boundary has been constructed between Judas and the other disciples (or, in the author’s community, between apostates and sectarians). The denounced has been separated from the group and denouncer. So much distance has been established between the witnesses and the denounced that Judas has been “ritually separated from a place in the legitimate order; i.e., he [has been] defined as standing at a place opposed to it.” He has been “placed outside” and “made strange.”97 John 15:25: éllÉ ·na plhrvyª ı lÒgow ı §n t“ nÒmƒ aÈt«n gegramm°now ˜ti §m¤shsãn me dvreãn. All would agree that John evinces a concern for love. Of one hundred forty-two occurrences of égapãv in the , thirty-seven occur
97
Ibid., 423.
280
in the Fourth Gospel and thirty-one in 1, 2, and 3 John. égãph is a particularly Johannine word; the Fourth Gospel harbors seven of its nine appearances.98 In addition, of the twenty-five occurrences of fil°v, thirteen appear in the Fourth Gospel. But John is even more disproportionately concerned with hate, which is showcased in 15:18–25.99 Hatred of Jesus (mis°v) forms an inclusio in the passage which has vv. 18 and 25 as its brackets. The first part of the passage alludes to the world’s hatred of the disciples and the second part to hatred of the Father; both the hatred of the disciples and the Father is tied to the hatred of Jesus. The world hates the disciples on account of Jesus’ name because they do not know the Father (v. 21). Whoever hates Jesus also hates the Father (vv. 23, 24). In addition to the author’s explicit treatment of hate (mis°v), close attention to the author’s use and non-use of Scripture corroborates the point. John, for all his attention to love, is the only Gospel writer not to have Jesus quote Lev 19:18, “You shall love your neighbor as yourself.” Either the author did not know the tradition, which, given its appearance in both Paul and James seems unlikely, or the author knew it and chose to omit it for some particular reason.100 98 égaphtÒw, which occurs sixty-one times in the , never appears in the Fourth Gospel. The “beloved disciple” of the Fourth Gospel is always referred to with the verb (e.g., 21:7, ı mayhtØw §ke›now ˜n ±gãpa ı ÉIhsoËw). 99 Of the twenty-five occurrences of mis°v in the Gospels, twelve occur in the Fourth Gospel (3:20; 7:7 [twice]; 12:25; 15:18 [twice], 19, 23 [twice], 24, 25; 17:14). Of those twelve, seven occur in ch. 15. Outside the Gospels and Acts, mis°v occurs only fifteen times (Rom 7:15; 9:13; Eph 5:29; Titus 3:3; Heb 1:9; 1 John 2:9, 11; 3:13, 15; 4:20; Jude 1:23; Rev 2:6 [twice]; 17:16; 18:2); notice that of those fifteen, one-third occur in 1 John. 100 The argument somewhat approximates that surrounding the Bethlehem tradition in which some scholars suggest, improbably, that the author simply did not know the tradition, whereas others argue for the author’s intentional omission. So Raymond Brown states: “The objection raised against Jesus’ being the Messiah indicates that there was no knowledge in Jerusalem that Jesus had actually been born in Bethlehem, an indication that is hard to reconcile with Matt ii.3 where ‘all Jerusalem’ is upset by the birth of the child. Some commentators would transfer the ignorance of Jesus’ birth at Bethlehem from the crowd to the evangelist. They maintain that the silence of John in not giving a rebuttal to the objection in vs. 42 means that the author did not know the tradition of Jesus’ birthplace as it is found in Luke and Matthew.” The Gospel, 330. Duke also attests to the debate: “Though no one doubts irony’s presence here, scholars debate its actual locus. Some say the author has in mind the tradition of Jesus’ birth in Bethlehem. Others say John neither knows nor cares about that tradition, the ironic point being that Jesus is the Christ precisely in spite of his Galilean origin, because he is really from God.” Duke, Irony, 67. On p. 174 n. 11 Duke provides a bibliography of those who consider John knowledgeable about the Bethlehem tradition (Barrett, Brown, Bernard,
281
If John is indeed sectarian, as we argue, then the group’s boundaries preclude any possibility of love for outsiders. The sect is a persecuted minority whose very survival depends on separation from, not sympathy or collusion with, its opponents. As the language throughout the Fourth Gospel indicates, there is an “us” (represented in the text by the disciples who “remember Jesus’ words” and “understand”) and there is a “them,” which indicates all who are “not us.” The fact that the author is concerned primarily, if not exclusively, with the boundary between his group and those outside his group helps to explain why the boundaries between all of those in the Gospel who are “not us” remain so ill-defined; the line drawn between “the Jews,” the Pharisees, the crowd, Nicodemus, the world, Judas, etc., is not always clear. John is the only evangelist who omits the “love” quote of Lev 19:18, and the only author the entire who includes the “hate” quote: “they hated me without cause,” which the author claims derives from “what is written in their law.” In fact, the sentence, §m¤shsãn me dvreãn, never appears in the ; rather, the phrase ofl misoËnt°w me dvreãn appears twice (Ps 68 [69]:5 and 34 [35]:19). Although the author once again (cf. 10:34) claims to quote from the Law (nÒmow), in actuality he does not quote (he paraphrases) and the “text” is not from the Law (it is a psalm).101 Though it offers the most concentrated attention to hate, ch. 15 is not the first time the author has addressed it. Already at 3:20 “hate” identifies which camp a person inhabits: pçw går ı faËla prãssvn mise› tÚ f«w ka‹ oÈk ¶rxetai prÚw tÆ f«w, ‡na mØ §legxyª tå ¶rga aÈtoË. While this may sound like conventional wisdom or proverbial language, for John it is technical language, so that “hating the light” signifies hating Jesus.102 Those who hate Jesus are further
Culpepper, Hoskyns, Morris, and Schlatter), those who dissent from this view (Bultmann, Lindars, de Jonge, and Meeks), and those who remain neutral (Dodd and Schnackenburg). 101 Campbell’s observation regarding Pauline literature obtains: “Secondly, it appears that Moses was viewed as a prophet and the Torah as the prophetic work par excellence, with the corollary that all his godly successors and their writings could be viewed as analogous, if secondary. The latter factor explains the flexibility evident in the terminology employed in the likes of 1 Cor 14:21, citing Isa 28:11, 12 as part of ‘the law.’” Campbell, Use, 17. 102 The word f«w is particularly Johannine, occurring twenty-three times as opposed to seven times in both Matt and Luke, and once in Mark. Of the twentythree appearances in the Fourth Gospel, all but one (5:35) refer to Jesus. E.g., ∑n
282
defined as those who “effect bad things” (ı faËla prãssvn, 3:20).103 In stark contrast, followers of Jesus, defined as “those who come to the light” are those who “do truth” (ı d¢ poi«n tØn élÆyeian). The next time the reader hears of “hate,” at 7:7, she is both reminded of what she has learned in 3:20 and is taught something additional. She finds Jesus explaining to his unbelieving brothers: oÈ dÊnatai ı kÒsmow mise›n Ímçw, §m¢ d¢ mise›, ˜ti §g∆ martur« per‹ aÈtoË ˜ti tå ¶rga aÈtoË ponhrã §stin, and is thereby reminded that “Jesus-haters” do “evil works”; but she also learns that “the world” (ı kÒsmow) falls into the camp of “Jesus-haters.” Thus she is surprised neither by Jesus’ announcement in 15:18ff. that the world hates him nor that people fall into two and only two distinct categories, here “those who belong to the world” (§k toË kÒsmou, 15:19)104 and “those who do not belong to the world.” In this passage Jesus identifies the latter as his disciples. There are two related principles at work in Jesus’ words: (a) one can only love and be loved by that which is one’s own (tÚ ‡dion), that to which one belongs, and (b) one can belong to only one group. So, the world must love its own (15:18); the disciples are not the world’s own but rather are Jesus’ own, as the reader already knows from 13:1: égapÆsaw toÁw fid¤ouw toÁw §n t“ kÒsmƒ efiw t°low ±gãphsen aÈtoÊw (cf. 1:11). Therefore, the disciples must be hated by the world. The world’s hatred is inevitable, but tÚ f«w tÚ élhyinÒn, ˘ fvt¤zei pãnta ênyrvpon, §rxÒmenon efiw tÚn kÒsmon (1:9), Pãlin oÔn aÈto›w §lãlhsen ı ÉIhsoËw l°gvn, ÉEg≈ efimi tÚ f«w toË kÒsmou: ı ékolouy«n §mo‹ oÈ mØ peripatÆs˙ §n tª skot¤&, éllÉ ßjei tÚ f«w t∞w zv∞w (8:12), etc. In 9:5 Jesus indicates that he will not always be in the world: ˜tan §n t“ kÒsmƒ Œ, f«w efimi toË kÒsmou and, as is often the case, the Gospel goes on to verify this
when Jesus’ hour comes and he returns to the Father. The end of the so-called Book of Signs finds the last references in the Fourth Gospel to Jesus as the “light”: …w tÚ f«w ¶xete, pisteÊete efiw tÚ f«w, ·na ufio‹ fvtÚw g°nhsye. TaËta §lãlhsen ÉIhsoËw, ka‹ épely∆n ɧkrÊbh épÉ aÈt«n,” (12:36) and §g∆ f«w efiw tÚn kÒsmon §lÆluya, ·na pçw ı pisteÊvn efiw §m¢ §n tª skoti& mØ me¤n˙ (12:46). Jesus’ words in 12:46 indicate a closure of his activity as the light that shines in the darkness (skot¤a) that was announced in the Prologue (ka‹ tÚ f«w §n tª skot¤& fa¤nei, ka‹ ≤ skot¤a aÈtÚ oÈ kat°laben; 1:5), thus forming an inclusio for the “Book of Signs.” 103 The only other time prãssv occurs is in a passage much like the present one, which distinguishes between two types of people, those who do (poi°v) good and those who accomplish (prãssv) the bad: mØ yaumãzete toËto, ˜ti ¶rxetai Àra §n √ pãntew ofl §n to›w mnhme¤oiw ékoÊsousin t∞w fvn∞w aÈtoË ka‹ §kporeÊsontai, ofl tå égayå poiÆsantew efiw énãstasin zv∞w, ofl d¢ tå faËla prãjantew efiw énãstasin kr¤sevw (5:28–29). 104 In “Derivation,” Keck argues that “indeed, this gospel relies repeatedly on one preposition—§k (of, from)—to express not only its Christology but also its anthropology and soteriology” (274).
283
Jesus encourages the disciples in two ways. First, he identifies with their experience. Second, he shows foreknowledge of what the future holds such that his credibility is high; so, if it is the case that what he says about the world’s hatred comes to pass, it should also be the case that comforting promises (of an advocate, of eternal life, etc.) will come to pass. So, just when the disciples begin to undergo their persecution, they should, ideally, remember that Jesus predicted this and be encouraged by the promises that they should expect to be fulfilled. As happens a number of times in the Fourth Gospel, Jesus refers to a statement which he has made earlier in the Gospel. Here he says, mnhmoneÊete toË lÒgou o §g∆ e‰pon Ím›n, OÈk ¶stin doËlow me¤zvn toË kur¤ou aÈtoË (15:20); by referring back to 13:16 we can see that Jesus indeed quotes himself correctly: oÈk ¶stin doËlow me¤zvn toË kur¤ou aÈtoË, though in that context Jesus uses the maxim to enjoin the disciples to act in a certain way toward one another rather than endure the ignominy of the world. The effect of this middle section of 15:18–26 is to list numerous ways in which the disciples are united with Jesus against the world; they are his own, so that which holds true regarding the world’s attitude towards him obviously holds true for them: the world hates them, the world persecutes them, and the world will not keep their word. Jesus then turns his attention from the relationship between the disciples and the world back to the relationship between the world and himself and in doing so largely repeats material he has stated earlier in the Gospel: (1) the world does not know the Father (cf. 16:3) who sent Jesus;105 (2) had the world been ignorant of Jesus it would not be culpable (cf. 9:41); (3) it hates Jesus and his Father; (4) it does not heed Jesus’ words (14:24). Four times in 15:18–25 the author indicates the world’s hatred of Jesus and his father: in vv. 18, 23, 24, and, finally, in v. 25 where Jesus announces that all of this hatred is in accordance with the word that is written in their law.106 Surely the irony is thick when Jesus quotes from “their” law. Throughout the Gospel one has seen a battle raging about the proper
105 Jesus is often described as the one whom God has sent (épost°llv; p°mpv) and God is often described as the one who sent (épost°llv; p°mpv) Jesus. E.g., 3:17, 34; 5:36, 38; 6:29, 57; 7:29; 8:42; 10:36; 11:42; 17:3, 8, 18, 21, 23, 25; 20:21. 106 The author already indirectly indicated the world’s hatred of Jesus at 3:20 and directly at 7:7.
284
interpretation of Scripture. The opponents and Jesus confront one another at every turn regarding it, with the opponents claiming that Scripture must be fulfilled, such that Jesus cannot be the Messiah because he breaks the Sabbath (ch. 9), he does not come from Bethlehem (ch. 7), and so on. The irony throughout lies in the fact that Scripture, rightly understood, is fulfilled in Jesus, though the opponents cannot see this because, as Jesus says to them, “You search the scriptures because you think that in them you have eternal life; and it is they that testify on my behalf ” (5:39). The opponents long to see Scripture fulfilled; when Jesus fulfills it, they cannot see it. They long to fulfill Scripture; when they do so, they are blind to its ramifications. At 15:25, Jesus declares that they have achieved their goal, they have, indeed, fulfilled their law, but in the most tragic of ways: “It was to fulfill the word that is written in their law, ‘They hated me without a cause.’” This is a sophisticated move on the author’s part. Unlike Qumran, where the opponents are characterized forthrightly as “law-breakers,” the author of the Fourth Gospel grants, ironically, that the opponents are, indeed, fulfillers of the law, but not in the way that they imagine themselves to be. What does this scriptural citation do for the late-first-century Johannine community? The author intends his community to identify with the disciples/Jesus/Father, so the citation warns the members of John’s community to expect the world’s hatred and persecution, and it provides a theodicy for those already experiencing it. That this experience of hatred was actual rather than hypothetical is suggested by the unusual attention given it; as noted above, John uses “hatred” language more than any other author, and this passage, 15:18–25, includes the most intense focus upon it, climaxing with a scriptural citation. Moreover, John is the only evangelist to employ either Ps 35:19 or 69:5. Like all sects, the Johannine community is in conflict with the larger community, here fellow Jews. Unlike the Qumran and Davidian groups, this group seems to experience no substantial conflict with the ruling government; this suggestion is corroborated by the Johannine epistles, which indicate not only that the Johannine community survived, but survived long enough to split into factions. In contrast with David Koresh, who distinguished between the parent tradition (Seventh-Day Adventism), “apostate Christianity” (all other Christian groups), and “the world” (everybody else), the fourth evangelist’s use of the cognomen “the world” overlaps with other referents to the parent tradition, rather
285
than indicating mere paganism. It is difficult to say whether “the world,” “the Jews,” and “the Pharisees” all apply to one group of opponents or whether the Johannine sect is suffering attack from different Jewish groups (comparable to the various Christian groups which harassed the Branch Davidians), or even if “the world” includes some non-Jews. The group is being attacked at least by the parent tradition which shows up in this passage as “the world.”107 The use of Scripture in this passage draws definite boundaries between insiders and outsiders. The opponents, here called “the world,” are degraded and shown to be, as Garfinkel suggests, something essentially different from the followers of Christ. Simultaneously the opponents are degraded and the sectarians elevated. This is done in both obvious and subtle ways. When Jesus makes statements such as: efi §k toË kÒsmou ∑te, ı kÒsmow ín tÚ ‡dion §f¤lei: ˜ti d¢ §k toË kÒsmou oÈk §st°, éllÉ §g∆ §jelejãmhn Ímçw §k toË kÒsmou, diå toËto mise› Ímçw ı kÒsmow (15:19), he degrades the world as hostile towards him and elevates the disciples as those he has “chosen out of the world”; his disciples are both “chosen” and separate from “the world.” Keck recognizes the “essential difference” of which Garfinkel speaks; referring to the use of §k in John 3:6 he contends: “Here, derivation—one’s ‘of-ness’—determines not only one’s ‘nature’ but also one’s (future) destiny, for only the Spirit-begotten can enter the kingdom.”108 Recognizing the distinction between those who are “of this world” and those who are not “of this world” as primary in this Gospel, Keck characterizes the two groups thus: [W]hen Jesus says, “You are not of this world,” he is not simply identifying his opponents as earthlings or even as denizens of the known solar system. Rather, he is making an anthropological accusation about the derivation of their real “nature”; he is identifying the hostile “whence” that accounts for their obduracy, for their not knowing either him or the Father (8:9), and for their not understanding that his words about the Sender are about the Father (8:27). Their resistance to him actualizes and demonstrates their “of-ness.”109 107 By “the world” the author may signify more than varieties of Judaism. After all, Jesus performs works among non-Jews. Also, the world is a strange category because both Jesus and the Jewish leaders castigate that group (“see the whole world has gone after him”). The author indicates a broad mission: “For God so loved the world. . . .” (3:16); “When I am lifted up I will draw all people to myself ” (12:32), etc. 108 Keck, “Derivation,” 276. 109 Ibid., 280.
286
Jesus’ last word, however, states the condition on which the alternative destiny depends: namely, accepting his christological claim— “believe that I AM”—the enigmatic appropriation of God’s own self-proclamation in Isa 43:10. To paraphrase, those who believe what Jesus says about himself—John’s “high” Christology—will not die in their sins because believing this makes them no longer “of this world.”110
So the author degrades the opponents and elevates the sectarians by associating them with their respective forebears who have been placed in their distinct categories. But the passage also reveals a slightly more subtle method of elevating the disciples: for every negative and degrading characteristic Jesus ascribes to the opponents, the author has depicted the disciples in opposite terms. The world “hates” the disciples and Jesus, whereas the disciples “love one another” (cf. 13:35) and Jesus (e.g., 14:15; 15:17; 17:26; 21:15, 16, 17). The world loves its own, whereas the disciples are not the world’s own (17:14). The world persecutes on account of Jesus (cf. 16:2), whereas the disciples are persecuted on account of Jesus’ name (cf. 16:2). The opponents do not keep Jesus’ word (cf. 14:24), whereas the disciples do (esp. 17:6, “they have kept your word;” cf. also 14:15, 21, 23; 15:10). The opponents do not know God (cf. 16:3), whereas the disciples do (14:7). The opponents’ response to viewing Jesus’ works is hatred of Jesus and his Father (10:38–39), whereas the disciples respond with belief (cf. 2:11). Finally, the scriptural citation provides the ultimate degradation of the opponents, because not only do they hate Jesus, they hate him for no reason at all. That is to say, by means of the scriptural citation, Jesus summarizes the point he has made throughout the Gospel: though the opponents claim to hate him on account of his words and deeds, in actuality they are never able to make their case viable. The only reason they hate Jesus is because their father is the devil (8:44); they are, in their very essence, opponents of Jesus. The Johannine community is supposed to identify with the disciples, Jesus, and God in the narrative such that the text, by depicting the disciples’ and Jesus’ opponents in a degrading light, depicts the Johannine community’s own opponents in the same light.
110 Ibid., 281. While Keck’s argument largely convinces, his logic falters somewhat when he speaks of believers as those who “no longer” are of this world, indicating that the boundaries between the disciples and opponents are permeable, whereas the rest of his argument patently argues for an essential “nature” based on derivation.
287
Simultaneously, then, John has used the scriptural citation to mark a boundary between insider and outsider, to degrade the opponents, and to elevate the sectarians. Furthermore, the scriptural citation evinces the practice of setting boundaries by means of literary and rhetorical techniques to effect inclusion or exclusion; those “outside” the group are those who “fulfill Scripture” by hating Jesus “without a cause.” The author also bolsters the confidence of the Johannine sectarians by showing Jesus’ special insight regarding Scripture. The opponents lord Scripture over Jesus and the disciples in the narrative and John’s first-century community, but the disciples are shown the errors of the opponents’ ways. The opponents think they know what Scripture means, but Scripture cannot be understood apart from knowledge of and belief in Jesus (5:39), knowledge and belief that only the Johannine community possesses. The author has a bit of fun in the passage by showing the irony of the opponents’ situation; for all their concern about events and personages corresponding to Scripture and all their smugness about their own adherence to Scripture, they fail to see that they adhere by fulfilling the roles ascribed to God’s enemies, rather than God’s followers in Scripture. As always in the Fourth Gospel, Jesus wields Scripture t