SCRIPTURE CANNOT BE BROKEN: The Social Function of the Use of Scripture in the Fourth Gospel
Jaime Clark-Soles
BRILL
SCRIPTURE CANNOT BE BROKEN
This page intentionally left blank
SCRIPTURE CANNOT BE BROKEN The Social Function of the Use of Scripture in the Fourth Gospel
BY
JAIME CLARK-SOLES
.. .
TU
..
.
.
P AA LL LL AA S S
TA SU
AEGID E
B
B A P, I. B • L 2003
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Clark-Soles, Jaime, 1967– Scripture cannot be broken : the social function of the use of Scripture in the Fourth Gospel / by Jaime Clark-Soles. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0 –391–04141–X 1. Bible. N.T. John—Social scientific criticism. 2. Bible—Use—History. 3. Johannine school. 4. Qumran community. 5. Branch Davidians. I. Title: Scripture cannot be broken. II. Title. BS2615.52.C57 2003 226.5'067—dc21 2003001119
ISBN 0–391–04141–X © Copyright 2003 by Brill Academic Publishers, Inc., Boston All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, translated, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission from the publisher. Authorization to photocopy item for internal or personal use is granted by Brill provided that the appropriate fees are paid directly to The Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Suite 910 Danvers, MA 01923, USA. Fees are subject to change.
To Wayne Meeks ˜w én≈mbrhsen sof¤an épÚ kard¤aw aÈtoË —Jesus ben Sirach 50.27
This page intentionally left blank
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I have been most privileged to work with exceptional faculty who first inspired my scholarly imagination and then set about the more difficult task of directing that imagination toward disciplined thought and articulate expression. Preeminent among them stands Susan R. Garret, who first encouraged me to consider advanced work in New Testament. Wayne Meeks has been a steady presence from my first Greek exegesis course in seminary until now, as I serve as a faculty member at Perkins School of Theology. As both teacher and friend he has generously shared his time and counsel. I first met Lou Martyn in a Galatians course at Yake Divinity School; he has influenced my scholarship in diverse ways. I thank David Bartlett, whose contributions to my life and work are hard to categorize. At one point or another over the past ten years he has served as my professor, my fellow American Baptist minister, my boss, my pastor, and now my colleague. Through it all he has been a friend. Dale Martin and Harold Attridge were kind enough to read and comment on the manuscript. I thank Daniel Boyarin for his interest in and encouragement of the project. Nancy Ammerman’s expertise as a sociologist of religion permeates this project. By directing me to literature in various subfields of sociology, she enabled me to find a language useful for asking the particular questions I wanted to ask of the Fourth Gospel and useful for venturing possible answers. I have learned much from Stephen Fraade and Victor Bers and appreciate their continued willingness to serve as resources whenever my research takes me into their fields. Thanks to Perkins School of Theology for providing a wonderful work atmosphere and support for research assistance in preparing this manuscript. David Watson, Jeremy Bakker, and Lee Jefferson provided valuable assistance. I thank my editors, Patrick Alexander and Renee Ricker, for their impressive expertise and patient help through the publication process. My most profound gratitutude goes to my family. My husband, Thad Clark-Soles, has helped me to carve out a life in which I “have it all,” including our wonderful children, Chloe and Caleb. I hope to lend them the same faith and support that I have enjoyed from my mother- and father-in-law, Caroline and Lewis Soles, and my parents, Margot and Harold Clark.
This page intentionally left blank
CONTENTS
Acknowledgments ......................................................................
vii
Chapter One: Introduction ......................................................
1
The Question .......................................................................... Questions Usually Posed ........................................................ Useful Predecessors .................................................................. J. Louis Martyn .................................................................. Nils A. Dahl ...................................................................... Wayne A. Meeks ................................................................ Method of Inquiry ................................................................
1 2 4 4 6 7 8
Chapter Two: Sociological Models ..........................................
10
Wayne A. Meeks on Early Christianity .............................. Rodney Stark on Early Christianity .................................... Shaye Cohen on Second Temple Judaism .......................... A New Proposal .................................................................... Charting Results .................................................................... The Production of Culture .................................................... Relationship Between Sect and Parent Tradition .............. Establishing Distance .......................................................... Applied Theory .................................................................. Capitalizing on Closeness .................................................. Creating a Distinct Way of Life .......................................... Ethics and Ritual Practices .............................................. Language and Rhetoric .................................................... Sacred Texts ...................................................................... Role of Authoritative Leaders .......................................... Definition of the Future .................................................... Opposition from within the Sect .......................................... Opposition from Without ...................................................... Judgment against Opponents ................................................
12 15 18 20 24 24 37 37 39 46 47 47 49 52 53 54 54 54 55
x
Growing the Sect .................................................................. Excursus: A History of Church and Sect ............................ Sect-Cult Distinctions ........................................................ Why Label the Group? .................................................... Conclusion ..............................................................................
55 56 62 63 65
Chapter Three: The Qumran Community ............................
66
Why Qumran? ........................................................................ The Origins of the Sect ........................................................ The Evidence from Qumran ................................................ Exegesis at Qumran .............................................................. Pesherite Exegesis .................................................................. Explicit Citations ................................................................ Allusions .............................................................................. Analysis of Primary Sources .................................................. Pesher Habakkuk ................................................................ The Damascus Document ................................................ 4QMMT ............................................................................ Indirect Use of Scripture in 4QMMT ...................... Charting Results .................................................................... Conclusions ............................................................................ Formation of the Sect ........................................................ Creating a Distinct Way of Life ...................................... Loci of Authority ................................................................ Scripture .......................................................................... Leaders ............................................................................ Definition of the Future .................................................... Opponents .......................................................................... Parent Tradition ............................................................ Sect-Defectors ................................................................ The “World” .................................................................. Growing the Sect .............................................................. Conclusion ..........................................................................
66 67 69 71 75 77 79 80 80 93 105 116 118 121 121 124 126 126 128 130 130 131 132 133 134 134
xi
Chapter Four: The Branch Davidian Community ................ 136 Introduction ............................................................................ Primary Sources .................................................................... Analysis of Primary Sources .................................................. Formation of the Sect ........................................................ Former Leaders and Their Works .................................. Loci of Authority ................................................................ Scripture .......................................................................... Leader ............................................................................ Koresh’s Authority .................................................... Koresh’s Technique .................................................... Ethics .................................................................................. Opponents .......................................................................... The World ...................................................................... The Church .................................................................... The (Other) Adventists .................................................. Sect-Defectors ................................................................ Scholars .......................................................................... Growing the Sect .............................................................. Creating a Sense of Belonging ........................................ Charting Results .................................................................... Conclusion ..............................................................................
136 144 146 146 155 156 156 162 162 168 173 178 178 179 181 185 188 191 193 197 202
Chapter Five: The Community of the Fourth Gospel .......... 207 Roles of Narrative in the Life of a Sect ............................ Roles of Scripture Embedded in a Narrative .................... Scripture .................................................................................. Excursus: 5:31–47 .................................................................. 7:14–24 .............................................................................. 7:37–52 ................................................................................ Jesus’ Own Words .................................................................. mimnÆskomai ........................................................................ plhrÒv ................................................................................ thr°v .................................................................................... pisteÊv ................................................................................ Allusions .................................................................................. Charting Results ....................................................................
208 211 221 241 250 252 294 294 296 297 303 311 314
xii
Chapter Six: Conclusions .......................................................... 316 Formation of the Sect ............................................................ Creating a Distinct Way of Life .......................................... Ethical Behavior ................................................................ Ritual Practice .................................................................... Loci of Authority .................................................................... Scripture .............................................................................. Roles of Authoritative Leaders .......................................... Definition of the Future ........................................................ Opponents .............................................................................. Parent Tradition ................................................................ Sect-Defectors .................................................................... The World .......................................................................... The Government ................................................................ Judgment against Opponents ................................................ Growing the Sect .................................................................. Creating a Sense of Belonging ............................................ Success of the Group ............................................................ The Potency of Scripture ......................................................
316 319 319 321 322 322 325 328 329 329 331 332 333 334 335 336 341 342
Bibliography ................................................................................ 343 Index of Ancient Sources .......................................................... 353 Index of Authors ........................................................................ 361
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
The Question John 10:35 contains a puzzling phrase: in the middle of a debate with the Pharisees, Jesus says, “Scripture cannot be broken.” What does John mean by this? Is the phrase a definitive statement,1 a parenthetical aside by Jesus,2 an intrusion by the narrator,3 or simply part of the protasis of a conditional sentence?4 How does this statement about Scripture compare to the rest of the Fourth Gospel’s attitude toward Scripture? To inquire after John’s use of Scripture is not to ask a new question. To inquire after the social function of John’s use of Scripture is. If David Kelsey5 has taught us anything about Scripture, it is that Scripture functions, and it functions within and for the sake of communities. Oddly, those who have worried about the social history of the Johannine community have not undertaken an extensive study of the way John uses Scripture to do something for and to his community, while those who have attended to the issue of Scripture in John have shown little, if any, interest in a flesh and blood community living sometime in the late first century ..6 I intend to bridge the gap. The and the treat it thus. The , the , and the set the phrase off by dashes, indicating a parenthetical aside by Jesus. 3 Though the marks with parentheses what it interprets as narrative intrusions, it apparently does not consider John 10:35 as such. No English translation, in fact, interprets John 10:35 this way. 4 Though no English translation interprets the phrase as part of the protasis, it is the most natural grammatical translation. The topic will be discussed in more detail in chapter five. 5 David Kelsey, The Uses of Scripture in Recent Theology (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1975). 6 The omission of socio-historical questions as they refer to scriptural interpretation is not unique to as Devorah Dimant manifests in her article, “Use and Interpretation of Mikra in the Apocrypha and Pseudepigrapha” (in Martin Jan Mulder, ed., Mikra: Text, Translation, Reading and Interpretation of the Hebrew Bible in Ancient Judaism and Early Christianity [ed. Martin Jan Mulder; Assen/Maastrich: Van Gorcum, 1988] 379–419): “A thorough and systematic application of the functional 1 2
2
Questions Usually Posed
Various aspects of John’s use of Scripture have been studied.7 One older and now outdated debate in Johannine scholarship centered on the “Jewish” versus “Hellenistic” background or character of John’s Gospel. John’s use of Scripture provided evidence for the “Jewish” side of the debate.8 The textual tradition used by John has been explored.9 The “fulfillment” theme in John has been a favorite of those who express interest in John’s use of Scripture.10 The theological and christological functions of the citations have evoked interest as well.11 Peder Borgen has conducted one of the most noteworthy investigations of this type in Bread from Heaven, a monograph devoted to the manna tradition as it appears in both John 6:31–58 and Philo. Regarding form, Borgen detects in the discourse “midrashic exegesis within the framework of a homiletic pattern common to Judaism and the early church,” a particular homiletical pattern whose original Sitz im Leben was preaching in a synagogue.12 Regarding the function of the content, Borgen argues: analysis outline above would demand a full understanding of . . . their social and historical background. . . . [The present survey] will not be able to go into the social and historical background of various usages of Mikra. . . .” (pp. 381–82). 7 For an extensive bibliography of Johannine research arranged by topic see Gilbert Van Belle, Johannine Bibliography: 1966–1985 (Brussel Wetenschappelijk Comite voor Godsdienstwetenschappen, Koninklijke Academie voor Wetenschappen, Letteren en Schone Kunsten van Belgie, 1988). 8 See Joseph A. Fitzmeyer, “The Use of Explicit Old Testament Quotations in Qumran Literature and in the New Testament,” NTS 7 (1960–1961): 297–333. 9 See, for example, Bruce G. Schuchard, Scripture Within Scripture: The Interrelationship of Form and Function in the Explicit Old Testament Citatitons in the Gospel of John (Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1992), whose main concern is the textual tradition used by John. He concludes (p. xvii) that John relies upon “one and only one textual tradition, the OG.” OG signifies “Old Greek,” the first Greek translation of the Bible. 10 Richard Morgan, “Fulfillment in the Fourth Gospel: The Old Testament Foundations,” Int 11 (1957): 155–65; John O’Rourke, “John’s Fulfillment Texts,” ScEccl 19 (1967): 433–43; C. F. D. Moule, “Fulfillment-Words in the New Testament: Use and Abuse,” NTS 14 (1967–68): 293–320; F. F. Bruce, The Time is Fulfilled: Five Aspects of the Fulfillment of the Old Testament in the New (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1978). 11 D. A. Carson claims that the typology employed by John serves a “replacement motif.” D. A. Carson, “John and the Johannine Epistles,” in It is Written: Scripture Citing Scripture (ed. D. A. Carson and H. G. M. Williamson; Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988), 245–64. Regarding the function of the citations, Carson writes (p. 246): “The citations in one way or another point to Jesus, identifying him, justifying the responses he elicits, grounding the details of his life and death in the Scriptures.” The fulfillment theme looms large in Bruce G. Schuchard’s investigation, as indicated by his conclusion (Scripture, 156): “Jesus, therefore, has fulfilled all of Scripture and is himself its ultimate significance.” 12 Borgen, Bread from Heaven: An Exegetical Study of the Concept of Manna in the Gospel of John and the Writings of Philo (Leiden: Brill, 1981), 55.
3
The homily in John 6, 31–58 . . . is a polemic against a gnosticizing tendency to draw a sharp distinction between the spiritual sphere and the external sphere. John opposed and was influenced by a docetic Christology and an understanding of the vision of God which was so general that it played down the importance of the external Torah and the unique role of Jesus Christ of history.13
Borgen concludes the monograph with these words: The distinction between the sphere of man and the divine sphere of the spirit in 6, 63 leads to a docetic Christology. The homily of 6, 31–58 develops an anti-docetic Christology as the answer: the spiritual bread from heaven is identical with Jesus, the son of Joseph, a historical human being (“flesh and blood”), with whom the elected believers are united through the mediation of the eucharist and the words of Jesus. The docetic spiritualists, therefore, are like “Jewish” externalists, because they believe the bread from heaven to be found outside the Incarnate One. Furthermore, in the bodily resurrection at the last day (6, 39.40.44, 54) the anthropological and soteriological distinction between flesh and spirit (6, 63) will finally be removed, and the spiritual and external spheres will be one and the same.14
While Borgen explains important aspects of John 6, he uses a traditional approach that focuses on form and theological content with little attention to the social situation of the Johannine community.15 Literary critics of the Fourth Gospel not only show little interest in the first-century Johannine community, but also largely omit consideration of how the scriptural citations function in the narrative itself.16 Paul Duke’s work, Irony in the Fourth Gospel, does venture to move from a literary observation, namely, John’s use of irony, to the social situation of the Fourth Gospel; however, like all of the works cited here, he does not attend to John’s use of Scripture.17 13
Ibid., 148. Ibid., 192. 15 John 6 has garnered extensive scholarly attention. At the forefront have been questions regarding the sacramental language (e.g., Rudolf Bultmann, The Gospel of John [trans. G. R. Beasley-Murray; Philadelphia: Westminster, 1971], 218–37), the presentation of Jesus as “the Prophet” (Wayne A. Meeks, The Prophet-King: Moses Traditions and the Johannine Christology [Leiden: Brill, 1967]), the Christology, and the unity or disunity of the chapter (Paul N. Anderson, The Christology of the Fourth Gospel: Its Unity and Disunity in Light of John 6 [Tübingen: J. C. B. Mohr, 1996]). All are important topics, but the present investigation must be limited to the question of whether or not there are any hints of the Johannine community’s social situation present there. 16 See, for example, R. Alan Culpepper, Anatomy of the Fourth Gospel: A study in literary design (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1983), and Mark Stibbe, John (Sheffield: JSOT, 1993). Neither does Stephen D. Moore’s Literary Criticism and the Gospels (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1989) treat the appearance of Scripture. 17 Paul D. Duke, Irony in the Fourth Gospel (Atlanta: John Knox, 1985). 14
4
Useful Predecessors
A number of scholars have sought to incarnate the community implied by the text of the Fourth Gospel. Their work not only illuminates various details of the present investigation but also provides its very starting point. J. Louis Martyn In History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel, J. L. Martyn asks about the community behind the Fourth Gospel and infers much about its social situation by reading some of John’s narratives as self-allusive. Martyn argues for a “two-level drama” in John: one refers to the einmalig18 and the other to John’s contemporary situation. By plotting the story of the blind man in ch. 9 on a dramatic map, Martyn discovers that the story reflects the schism that occurred in the synagogue once a group of powerful Jews, whom John calls “Pharisees,” decreed that confession of Jesus as the Messiah would lead to expulsion from the synagogue. In Martyn’s analysis, Jesus represents the Christian preacher, the blind man a faithful convert. Not only ofl pollo¤, but also Jewish rulers decline to make a public Christian confession for fear of dismissal from the synagogue. Evidence of the likelihood that this depicts the historical period of John’s community rather than the time of Jesus may be gleaned from the repeated use of éposunãgvgow language, found in 9:22, 12:42, and 16:2.19 In his reconstruction of the origins of the community, Martyn, perhaps under the influence of Acts 17:22, visualizes a Christian missionary or preacher proclaiming Jesus as Messiah to those in the synagogue. Some Jews believe, so a sub-group forms in the synagogue comprised of those who still participate in regular synagogue worship but also celebrate the Eucharist and conduct catechesis. At some point synagogue authorities determine that belief in Jesus as Messiah constitutes apostasy and take action against Christians. As a result, “What had been an inner-synagogue group of Christian Jews now 18 By way of definition, Martyn writes: “By it I mean something like ‘back there’ as opposed to ‘now and here.’ . . . The reader will not go far wrong if he renders my use of einmalig by the expression ‘once upon a time.’ ” J. Louis Martyn, History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel (Nashville: Abingdon, 1979), 29 n. 22. 19 In specifying the passive sense, John uses the phrase éposunãgvgow gen°syai (9:22). In the active sense, “to expel from the synagogue,” John uses éposunãgvgon poie›n (12:42, 16:2). The word éposunãgvgow does not appear in the or secular literature.
5
became—against its will—a separated community of Jewish Christians.”20 Even with the threats at hand, there are still those who remain within the synagogue but consider themselves Christian. Moreover, Christian preachers are still trying to secure converts from the synagogue, “to lead people astray,” a fact reflected in the drama of chs. 5 and 7. According to Martyn, “leading astray” comprises a legal accusation. Specifically regarding John’s use of the , Martyn expresses interest in the figure of Moses and how John’s assumptions about Moses compared to those of other Jews of his era. John allows Jesus to be a Mosaic Prophet-Messiah, but Jesus is not the antitype of Moses. Referring to this conclusion he claims: “John provides us with data which make it possible to speak about the specific hermeneutic which he applies to the Old Testament.”21 Martyn does briefly acknowledge John’s use of earlier traditions. At the general level, he says, “Of course not everyone in the early church viewed alike the relationship between a concern for tradition and effective involvement in contemporary issues. One of the most pressing needs in study may be a careful analysis of the various ways in which authors viewed this relationship.”22 The present work aims to contribute to such an analysis. Martyn never defines “tradition”; presumably he means at least the traditions concerning Jesus, but Scripture would also fit well into his observation that no author simply repeats tradition, but “everyone shapes it, bends it, makes selections from among its riches, even adds to it. . . . Consequently, when we read the Fourth Gospel, we are listening both to tradition and to a new and unique interpretation of that tradition.”23 The only specific statement Martyn offers about John’s use of the is this: “From a quite special point of view he [ John] could even agree that Scripture (≤ grafÆ, not ı nÒmow) has about it an imperative quality (cf. 7:23 with, e.g., 20:9).”24 To be sure, the reader will easily detect my debt to Martyn’s scholarship as my presuppositions about the traumatic, antagonistic social situation in which the Fourth Gospel was forged become evident. But Martyn’s work does not treat the social function of John’s use of the . Hence, while Martyn’s work provides important background for my own, he does not address my question at all. 20 21 22 23 24
Martyn, History, 66. Ibid., 104 n. 154. Ibid., 19. Ibid. Ibid., 104.
6
Nils A. Dahl In his article, “The Johannine Church and History,”25 Nils A. Dahl notes that John adopts imagery (e.g., vine and branch) but changes the meaning; that is, the imagery comes to represent Christ’s relationship with the Johannine sectarians rather than the way God deals with God’s people throughout history. Like Martyn, Dahl asks about the relationship between tradition and contemporary life for John. Dahl contends, “What matters is the witness which the Scriptures in their totality bear to Christ (5:39, 46)” and “The Scriptures, as understood by John, bear witness to Christ in the present, rather than to a history of a salvation in the past with an importance of its own.”26 According to Dahl, John declares continuity between tradition and John’s contemporary time not through a salvation history scheme but by compelling the traditions to bear witness to Jesus. This applies both to John the Baptist and history, including the visions of Isaiah (Isa 6), Moses (Exod 33:17–34:9), and Abraham (based on Gen 15:7–21 and Jewish lore). Dahl insists that for John the “true greatness” of the figures lies solely in their function as witnesses to Jesus: “Whoever drinks of the well, which Jacob gave to his descendants, will thirst again (4:10–14). Moses did not give the true bread from heaven; the fathers ate manna in the wilderness, and they died (6:32, 49). Abraham died too, and so did the prophets (8:52).”27 Dahl argues that the Fourth Evangelist defines the church as the “true Israel” and speaks of its continuing mission to bear witness to Christ in a world hostile to him, a world that has already been defeated “legally” if not evidently. But Dahl remains on the level of ideas and theology and does not attend to the actual social situation in which John’s community finds itself. In comparing John with Gnosticism he says, “One example of this affinity may be seen in the conception of the church as the community of those who are of the truth and have heard the voice of the Savior”;28 Dahl fails to provide anything more concrete than this. Hence, while he does attempt to investigate John’s use of traditions, he never asks about
25 Nils A. Dahl, “The Johannine Church and History,” in Nils A. Dahl, Jesus in the Memory of the Early Church (Minneapolis: Augsburg, 1974), 99–119. 26 Ibid., 106. 27 Ibid., 107. 28 Ibid., 118.
7
the social function of Scripture in the Fourth Gospel; he never asks if and how John used Scripture to provide identity and social boundaries for a sectarian group born out of a Jewish community that first possessed that very Scripture. Wayne A. Meeks Wayne Meeks alone has tested the waters in which I wish to swim, particularly in his article “The Man from Heaven in Johannine Sectarianism.”29 The bulk of the article treats the descent/ascent motif in the Fourth Gospel, but Meeks asks about the motif for sociological rather than merely theological or ideological reasons. What social function does John’s symbolism serve, especially the above/below symbolism? Meeks concludes that John projects the experience of his community onto Jesus’ own so that the presentation of Jesus as alien, not of this world, and hated by the Jews parallels the experience of the sect. This not only provides an etiology of the group but also reminds and assures them that following Jesus necessarily implies “a change in social location,” namely, a separation from the world, especially the world of Judaism. The Fourth Gospel justifies the existence of the community, helps to shape its identity, and draws sharp boundaries around the sectarians: “One of the primary functions of the book, therefore, must have been to provide a reinforcement for the community’s social identity, which appears to have been largely negative. It provided a symbolic universe which gave religious legitimacy, a theodicy, to the group’s actual isolation from the larger society.”30 The Fourth Gospel is a book for insiders, much like some of the Qumran literature. Drawing upon the sociology of knowledge, Meeks suggests that John’s Gospel provided the group with a new symbolic world and therefore a new reality. It is surprising to find that, in the twenty-five years since the article was published, no one has gone on to ask where John’s use of Scripture fits into the “continual, harmonic reinforcement between social experience and ideology.”31 Surely a discussion of identity formation in a Jewish sectarian group is incomplete without a treatment 29 Wayne A. Meeks, “The Man from Heaven in Johannine Sectarianism,” JBL 91 (1972): 44–72. 30 Ibid., 70. 31 Ibid., 71.
8
of the role of Scripture in that formation. In this study, I exegete the parts of John that evidence a concern for Scripture to discover what it might indicate about John’s community of faith. Like Meeks, I draw upon the work of sociologists to aid my analysis.
Method of Inquiry The heuristic framework for this study derives from two branches of sociology: the sociology of religion and the production of culture. Chapter Two lays out that framework. Its overall construction is especially informed by the work of William Sims Bainbridge, Rodney Stark, and Bryan Wilson on sects and other religious movements; Nancy Ammerman on the culture of congregations; and Robert Wuthnow on the production of culture, including the production of the sacred. This study uses the comparative method of social history. It is useful to have both an ancient and a modern group with which to compare the community of the Fourth Gospel. The Qumran community and the Branch Davidians serve as those comparative communities. Chapter Three inquires after the social function of the use of Scripture in the Qumran community. The Qumran community has yielded much for archaeologists and biblical scholars alike. Like the Branch Davidians, the Essenes marked boundaries in a radically physical way, withdrawing to a separate space. They have bequeathed enough literary evidence to venture reasonable suggestions about their use of Scripture. From the extensive Qumran library, 4QMMT, Pesher Habakkuk, and CD have been selected as samples for study. Chapter Four focuses on the Branch Davidians, especially under the leadership of David Koresh. Scripture—memorization of it, study of it, and adherence to it—stood at the very center of the group’s communal existence. The Branch Davidians were nothing if not a people of “The Book.” Koresh typically taught through group Bible study, not through writing; therefore, in inquiring after the social function of the use of Scripture among the Branch Davidians, I will depend primarily on recorded Bible study sessions. This comparative method serves in two ways. First, it will tend to validate or invalidate claims made about the nature of the Fourth Gospel community. If I discover a feature of the Fourth Gospel community that would seem to make sense given its status as a “breakaway” group,
9
I can test my hypothesis by asking whether the feature appears in other “break-away” groups. If it does not, then I must account for the dissimilarity; if it does, then I must account for the similarity. Second, much more is known about the life of the Qumran and Branch Davidian communities than the Fourth Gospel community. The better known may shed light on the lesser known. Chapter Five uses all of the sociological and comparative material to inform the exegesis of the nineteen occurrences of direct scriptural citation in the Fourth Gospel. Before undertaking that exegesis, however, I consider the fact that the Fourth Gospel, unlike the texts used for comparison, appears in narrative form. Finally, because the Fourth Gospel itself emphasizes Jesus’ own words, I devote special attention to Jesus’ words, their authority, and their relationship to Scripture. Chapter Six concludes the project by venturing an informed hypothesis regarding what the author of John may have achieved for his first-century community through his artful, intentional invocation of Scripture.
CHAPTER TWO
SOCIOLOGICAL MODELS Culture has independent causal influence in unsettled cultural periods because it makes possible new strategies of action—constructing entities that can act (selves, families, corporations), shaping the styles and skills with which they act, and modeling forms of authority and cooperation. It is, however, the concrete situations in which these cultural models are enacted that determine which take root and thrive, and which wither and die. Ann Swidler, “Culture in Action”
This chapter offers a model for examining the use of Scripture in sectarian communities. It defines “sectarian,” it states what sects must do to form and maintain themselves successfully, and it contends that Scripture can aid those processes. The remainder of the study addresses the role Scripture plays in that formation and maintenance. Ideally, in launching an investigation into the social function served by Scripture in the communities of Qumran, the Branch Davidians, and the Fourth Gospel, I would immediately appeal to work done in the “sociology of Scripture,” which would present all the ways Scripture could be used by a given group. I might imagine that these “sociologists of Scripture” would have at least studied various kinds of modern Scripture-using groups and found enough correlations to enable them to draw conclusions about how Scripture functions both ostensibly and actually within the various groups. I might even expect to find sociologists who have studied the use of Scripture among pre-modern groups. I would run my eye down the list until I hit upon the sub-category “the use of Scripture among sectarians,” whence I would learn what I might expect of a sect and why. I would then locate the exegetical materials of the Branch Davidian, Johannine, and Qumran communities, keeping that chart close by to see if these groups manifest such tendencies. If so, I would have insight as to why those tendencies obtained given the fact that sects have to meet certain goals to perdure. Such a line of inquiry, how-
11
ever, has yet to be systematically undertaken by sociologists of religion. Occasionally a compelling isolated study appears, but it remains at the level of one sermon1 or one congregation.2 To date, then, sociologists have not tackled the subject.3 Students of Christianity have not helped to clarify the subject either. At least since the oft-quoted publication of Meeks’s “The Man from Heaven in Johannine Sectarianism,” the sectarian nature of the Johannine community has largely been granted. Likewise, scholars of both the Qumran community and the Branch Davidian community readily designate them as sects. But what exactly marks a community as a sect? One should not be lulled by the ease with which the term is bandied about into thinking that a shared definition of requisite features present to qualify a group as a sect has been used by these various scholars, or even that such a definition exists. With respect to scholarship as it relates to the present project, I noted previously
1 See Marsha Witten’s work described at the end of this chapter: “The Restriction of Meaning in Religious Discourse: Centripetal Devices in a Fundamentalist Christian Sermon,” in Robert Wuthnow, ed., Vocabularies of Public Life: Empirical Essays in Symbolic Structure (New York: Routledge, 1992), 19–38. 2 See Nancy Ammerman’s Congregation & Community (New Brunswick, N.J.: Rutgers University Press, 1997) and Bible Believers (New Brunswick, N.J.: Rutgers University Press, 1987). 3 Why have sociologists not tackled the subject? I suggest three reasons: a bias against texts, the disrepute of sociology of religion, and especially the disrepute of the sociology of sectarianism. Regarding the second, William Sims Bainbridge claims: In sociology, anthropology, and even psychology, religion was a prime topic for the pioneers of social science. But despite occasional upsurges like the extensive survey research of the 1960s, the sociology of religion has languished in a peripheral status since those pioneers departed. Today, however, this discipline is primed for a renaissance through which it takes its rightful place at the center of social science. . . . After decades of little respect from social scientists in other specialties, and even less support from grant-giving agencies, the sociology of religion is rapidly gaining stature within the intellectual community, because of a renewed recognition of the importance of its theme. Bainbridge, The Sociology of Religious Movements (New York: Routledge, 1997), 27. Bryan Wilson addresses the third: Despite the obvious social importance of movements that not only affect but actually encompass the lives of so many people throughout the world (for today perhaps no societies are sect-less) sectarian studies remain at the fringe of academic disciplines . . . sectarian studies—compared, say, to anthropology—have received neither encouragement nor endorsement: the subject matter is regarded as academically inconsequential, and the subject area is, within the sociology of religion, something of a pariah, whilst the sociology of religion itself has been called a Cinderella within sociology. Bryan R. Wilson, The Social Dimensions of Sectarianism (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1990), 5.
12
those who have contributed to the present study by their attention to the social realities of the Johannine community, especially J. Louis Martyn, Wayne A. Meeks, and Nils A. Dahl. Two lacunae remain in spite of their work. First, while they have recognized the sectarian nature of the Johannine community, they have not attempted to systematically study how the deployment of Scripture contributes to the maintenance of that sectarian character. Second, and this is a more general problem, scholars studying the and early Christianity have been less than precise in their use of sectarianism as a concept, and some have even argued that “cult” is a better category. A sampling of Wayne Meeks, Rodney Stark, and Shaye Cohen proves exemplary.
Wayne A. Meeks on Early Christianity Meeks has done us the invaluable service of, inter alia, drawing on sociology to discuss ancient Christian communities, usually with a functionalist approach. Much of his work regarding early Christianity uses the language of sectarianism to describe a community. None of his work on John omits reference to its sectarian nature. In addressing the development of Johannine Christology, for example, Meeks writes: “We have already affirmed with Martyn that the Gospel’s controversies press us to look for the context of its theologizing in the same disputes that constituted the Johannine groups as a separate religious community over against the Jewish communities to which they had belonged ” (my italics).4 Further, What drove the Johannine Christians to make just these connections, in the face of the social pain that it obviously cost them? We must remember that the social pain was but the negative side of the process by which they had become a distinctive community. . . . In this Gospel, “abiding” in the truth about Jesus has positive and negative social dimensions: It entails stalwart “love” for fellow disciples of Jesus and brave separation from those who reject him. The claim that constitutes the identity of this special group of former Jews is that in their abiding in the Son of Man they have been granted what the whole of Israel’s Scripture and tradition—both Jewish and Samaritan versions—pointed to. . . . They alone are Israel. . . . They are epitomized in one of the first of those “given by God” to 4 Wayne A. Meeks, “Equal to God,” in The Conversation Continues: Studies in Paul and John in Honor of J. Louis Martyn (ed. Robert T. Fortna and Beverly R. Gaventa; Nashville: Abingdon, 1990), 309–21, here 316.
13
Jesus, Nathanael the élhy«w ÉIsrahl¤thw. Here we have the very model of a sectarian consciousness. To “Pharisees” and to ordinary Jews of all kinds, as the narrative makes clear, these claims did not fulfill but rather subverted the classical Scripture and traditions. These [christological] claims broke the community with other Jews by their audacity, their exclusiveness, and their persistence; they constituted blasphemy. Smarting from the forced separation, the circle of the Beloved Disciple exulted in this subversion, which became the principle literary strategy of the Fourth Evangelist (my italics).5
In addition to using sectarian categories to understand the Fourth Gospel, Meeks also recognizes the importance that Scripture had in that sectarian consciousness when he claims: “While in Philo’s writings we see the Moses traditions being used in a broad Kulturkampf, here in John they are employed in a sectarian controversy. And both sides in this controversy have used the same scripture and similar traditions.”6 The present study seeks to carry Meeks’s work forward by systematically addressing the ways in which Scripture contributes to the maintenance of that sectarian nature. It also attempts to speak more precisely about the sectarian nature of the Fourth Gospel. As Meeks himself acknowledges, “We have now become accustomed to say that earliest Christianity was a sect of Judaism. This is useful language. . . . However, there are some problems with the phrase.”7 For example, one must always remember that Luke and Josephus, who both use the term a·resiw, have apologetic purposes which may color their usage of the term. Furthermore, a·resiw may not be considered synonymous with a modern sociologist’s usage. Finally, modern sociologists do not always agree on the meaning of the term “sect.” In some ways, however, one might wish that Meeks himself had done more to clarify the usage with regard to ancient Christianity. For instance, in his article “Breaking Away: Three New Testament Pictures of Christianity’s Separation from the Jewish Communities,” Meeks claims of the Fourth Gospel, Matthew, and Paul’s letters: “Each of them gives 5
Ibid., 318–19. Wayne Meeks, “The Divine Agent and His Counterfeit in Philo and the Fourth Gospel,” in Aspects of Religious Propaganda in Judaism and Early Christianity (ed. Elizabeth Schussler-Fiorenza; Notre Dame, Ind.: University of Notre Dame Press, 1976), 43–67, here 54. 7 Wayne A. Meeks, “Breaking Away: Three New Testament Pictures of Christianity’s Separation from the Jewish Communities,” in “To See Ourselves as Others See Us”: Christians, Jews, “Others” in Late Antiquity (ed. Jacob Neusner and Ernest S. Frerichs; Chico, Calif.: Scholars Press, 1985), 93–115, here 93. 6
14
some reason for affirming that Christianity had been a sect of Judaism, but we shall find that each looks back at that connection [i.e., the connection between Christianity and Israel] from a point just after a decisive break has occurred.”8 This use of the term “sect” is somewhat problematic. First, it implies that “a decisive break,” such as having been expelled from synagogues, moves the group to the position of having been a sect, whereas schism with the parent tradition is one feature of sectarianism upon which almost all sociologists of sectarianism agree. Second, the Fourth Gospel and Matthew were clearly forged in communities that identified primarily with some form of Judaism; Paul’s communities, on the other hand, emerged in a world dominated by pluralistic paganism. According to Stark and Bainbridge, those are two very different social phenomena, and they recognize the distinction by designating the first type “sect” and the second “cult.” A sect is a schismatic group that “breaks away” from an existing “parent body,” to use Bainbridge’s language, while a “cult” is a non-schismatic, innovative group that arises in a society or is imported to it from an alien culture.9 The method of emergence, the social composition, and the dynamics of the two kinds of groups generally differ, so that such labels serve as a shorthand for expressing what one should expect from a group. To call both Pauline Christianity and Johannine Christianity sectarian blurs important distinctions between the two, distinctions that Meeks himself highlights: Theologically it is correct to say that the scriptures and traditions of Judaism are a central and ineffaceable part of the Pauline Christians’ identity. Socially, however, the Pauline groups were never a sect of Judaism. They organized their lives independently from the Jewish associations of the cities where they were founded, and apparently, so far as the evidence reveals, they had little or no interaction with the Jews. . . . There is thus a certain paradox about Pauline Christianity. The apostle himself was deeply concerned about the relations between Christianity and “the Israel of God.” Yet he and his associates had created an organized movement that was entirely independent of the Jewish communities in the cities of the northeastern Mediterranean basin. The scriptures and traditions from Judaism played a major part in the beliefs and practices of Pauline Christianity, yet the identity of the Pauline groups was not shaped by having once been within a Jewish context. However much Paul’s own identity may have been 8 9
Ibid., 94. Bainbridge, Sociology, 107.
15
formed by the trauma of what we call his conversion, there was no comparable trauma for the communities which he founded. Unlike the Johannine groups, the Pauline congregations were not composed of people who had become aposynagogoi.10
In “A Hermeneutics of Social Embodiment,” Meeks makes an uncharacteristically general proclamation: “It is time that we took seriously the well-known fact that most of the New Testament documents, including the Pauline Epistles . . . were immediately addressed to . . . what a sociologist could only call the institutionalization of the new sect” (my italics).11 By “the new sect” it would appear that Meeks uses the term so broadly as to include Christianity as a whole and, if not, at least broadly enough to include all of Pauline Christianity. But “the Pauline Epistles,” as he himself has spent a lifetime proving, certainly do not attest to a uniformity among the communities that would warrant speaking of “the” new sect. Since “sects,” as social communities rather than an esoteric set of ideas, can only be designated as such vis-à-vis their own environs, to label all Pauline Epistles as evidence of the institutionalization of a single sect obliterates the differences evident in different Pauline groups vis-à-vis their social surroundings. What is wanted, then, is a way of speaking about the various communities that takes their social location into account but allows for nuanced distinctions among the various forms of Christianity reflected in the . If successful, the present project will add to what Meeks has begun by attending more systematically both to the function of Scripture in a social group and to the way sects operate, in hopes of discovering how the text and the group shape one another.
Rodney Stark on Early Christianity As a direct result of reading Meeks’s The First Urban Christians, Rodney Stark was inspired to undertake a sociological analysis to explain the apparently explosive rise of Christianity using “hard science,” or as close to it as one can come in the social sciences. While it has much to recommend it, the study lacks nuance. Where Meeks sees a sect, Stark sees a cult. He combines all of “early Christianity” as reflected 10
Meeks, “Breaking Away,” 106–8. Wayne A. Meeks, “A Hermeneutics of Social Embodiment,” in Christians Among Jews and Gentiles (ed. George W. E. Nickelsburg and George W. MacRae; Philadelphia: Fortress, 1986), 176–186, here 185. 11
16
in the and identifies it as a “cult” in contrast to a “sect,” offering the following definitions of each: sect movements “occur by schism within a conventional religious body when persons desiring a more otherworldly version of the faith break away to ‘restore’ the religion to a higher level of tension with its environment. . . . Cult movements, on the other hand, are not simply new organizations of an old faith; they are new faiths, at least new in the society being examined.”12 In identifying what he calls “early Christianity” as a cult, he writes: During his ministry, Jesus seems to have been the leader of a sect movement within Judaism. Indeed, even in the immediate aftermath of the Crucifixion, there was little to separate the disciples from their fellow Jews. However, on the morning of the third day something happened that turned the Christian sect into a cult movement. Christians believe that on that day Jesus arose from the dead and during the next forty days appeared repeatedly to various groups of his followers. It is unnecessary to believe in the Resurrection to see that because the apostles believed in it, they were no longer just another Jewish sect. Although it took time for the fact to be recognized fully (in part because of the immense diversity of Judaism in this era), beginning with the Resurrection Christians were participants in a new religion, one that added far too much new culture to Judaism to be any longer an internal sect movement.13
There are a number of problems with Stark’s argument. First, the resurrection serves as his dividing line between sect and cult. On what basis does he make this decision? Notions of resurrection are not alien to Judaism,14 and the Fourth Gospel points to the claim of Jesus’ being “equal to God” as the primary problem rather than resurrection. Second, if Stark were to attend to the primary evidence of the early Christian groups, he would find that many, if not most, certainly do not see themselves as something “other” than a true, purified, restored, “fulfilled” Judaism. According to emic categories, Christianity would, then, constitute a sect. Stark, however, operates from an etic position whose conclusions contradict those of the groups themselves.15 12 Rodney Stark, The Rise of Christianity (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1996), 33. 13 Ibid., 44. 14 See George W. E. Nickelsburg’s work: Resurrection, Immortality and Eternal Life in Intertestamental Judaism (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1972). 15 In contrast with the approach evidenced by Weber (as quoted in Bainbridge, Sociology, 71) when he notes, “Methodism, which first arose in the middle of the eighteenth century within the Established Church of England, was not, in the minds of its founders, intended to form a new Church, but only a new awakening of the
17
And what counts as “culture” for Stark? To argue effectively that Christianity added “far too much new culture to Judaism to be any longer an internal sect movement” would require Stark to identify what constituted essential Jewish culture, what constituted essential Christian culture, and to show that Christianities shared little with Judaisms. At present, his essential Judaism seems to consist of a “nonresurrectionist” theology and Christianity seems to consist primarily of a doctrine of “resurrection.” All of the various communities depict their groups as aligned with Scripture, a primary cultural element shared by all Jewish groups and all Christian groups.16 Third, Stark eliminates all but Pauline Christianity from his characterization of the early church as a cult movement: “Moreover, whatever the relationship between Christianity and Judaism, when historians speak of the early church, they do not mean the church in Jerusalem but the Pauline church—for this is the church that triumphed and changed history.”17 In his effort to perform a sweeping study of four centuries of Christianity in two hundred pages, he has sacrificed the specifics manifested in the other (i.e., non-Pauline) texts, such as the one under study in this investigation.18 ascetic spirit within the old. Only in the course of its development, especially in its extension to America, did it become separate from the Anglican Church” (my italics). As we will see when addressing the Qumran community, the Fourth Gospel, and the evidence provided by the Johannine Epistles, such an emic description pertains there as well. 16 Wuthnow’s observation more closely approximates the situation found in the Fourth Gospel: “Congregations . . . are in business not to invent the sacred but to encourage people to discover it. . . . The God that people in most congregations attempt to discover is assumed to be a being described in the books these congregations provide in their pews, a being who likes to hear people sing certain songs that have been part of traditional worship services for years and years, and one who tolerates (perhaps even appreciates) people trying to address him or her (usually him) with certain formulaic prayers. What earns other groups the designation of cult is that they are not content to abide by these norms; instead of discovering the sacred, they many even try to invent it.” Wuthnow, Producing the Sacred: An Essay on Public Religion (Urbana, Ill.: University of Illinois Press, 1994), 53. As we will see in the Fourth Gospel, John does not imagine that he is inventing something new; rather he argues that if one understood the Scriptures, one would see and discover the truth as promulgated by his Jesus. 17 Stark, The Rise, 45. 18 As he admits, Stark has a vested interest in defining this so-called “early Christianity” as a cult: “Finally, what difference does it make whether early Christianity was a movement of the relatively privileged [i.e. “cult”] or of the down-trodden [i.e. “sect”]? In my judgment it matters a great deal.” The Rise, 46. His reasoning goes as follows: sects overrecruit from the less privileged, whereas cults overrecruit from the more privileged. If early Christianity had been a sectarian movement, it would have constituted what Stark designates anachronistically a “proletarian move-
18
Meeks designates Pauline Christianity “what a sociologist could only call the institutionalization of the new sect”;19 Stark designates it a cult.20 Meeks designates Johannine Christianity a sect; Stark ignores it.
Shaye Cohen on Second Temple Judaism Scholars of ancient Judaism also invoke the sociological language of sects, as does Shaye Cohen when he devotes considerable attention to what he calls “Sectarian and Normative” in a book on Second Temple Judaism.21 At the outset of the chapter he aims to define “sect,” “orthodoxy,” “heresy,” and “normative.” He defines a sect as “a small, organized group that separates itself from a larger religious body and asserts that it alone embodies the ideals of the larger group because it alone understands God’s will.”22 He then makes at least two claims regarding his definition: (1) he has derived the definition from the sociology of medieval and modern Christianity, and (2) his is a minimalist definition with which all students of sectarianism would agree. But the very fact that he has used constructs derived from medieval and modern Christianity precludes any sophisticated student of sectarianism from agreeing with his minimal definition. He still operates under Troeltschian and Niebuhrian assumptions (such as, “If a sect grows to the extent that it is a large body in its own right, it is no longer a sect but a ‘religion’ or ‘church’ ”),23 assumptions which are outdated (see “history of church and sect” section of this chapter) and anachronistic24 insofar as he applies notions of modern Christian “church” to ancient Judaism. While it is not within the scope of this presentation to relate all of the details of his schema, ment,” and would have been rooted out by mighty Rome as a political threat. Since Rome largely seems to have ignored the movement it makes sense that the movement must have had friends in high places, which protected it from destruction, thus contributing to his interest in explaining “the rise of Christianity.” 19 Meeks, “A Hermeneutics,” 185. 20 For another (early) attempt to apply the sociology of sectarianism to early Christianity, see Robin Scroggs, “The Earliest Christian Communities as Sectarian Movement,” in Christianity, Judaism, and Other Greco-Roman Cults: Studies for Morton Smith at Sixty (ed. Jacob Neusner; Leiden: Brill, 1975), 2:1–23. 21 Shaye Cohen, From the Maccabees to the Mishnah (Philadelphia: Westminster, 1987), 124–73. 22 Ibid., 125. 23 Ibid. 24 Indeed, all “church-sect” discussions are anachronistic insofar as there was no institution quite like a “church” before Constantine.
19
its lack of nuance is exemplified by a statement such as this: “In the period under review in this book two Jewish sects (or sect-like groups) outgrew their sectarian origins to become independent religions.25 Out of the Christian sect came Christianity, and out of the Pharisaic sect came rabbinic Judaism, also known simply as ‘Judaism.’ ”26 Using these modern Christian models he describes the nature of Jewish sectarianism in the Second Temple period. At the outset of the chapter he identifies four Jewish sects: the Pharisees, the Christians, the Samaritans, and the Qumranians. He makes a point of differentiating his definition of “sect” (a modern sociological construct) from Josephus’ a·resiw (“schools of thought” rather than sociological groups). He identifies three focal points of Jewish sects: the Law, the temple, Scripture. A number of problems arise in Cohen’s presentation. First, though he originally distinguishes his use of sect from Josephus’, he goes on to consider all of those groups presented by Josephus, sometimes deciding they are sects, sometimes not, sometimes indicating paucity of sources. Second, he is inconsistent in his analyses of the groups he initially identifies as sectarian. He confidently denotes the Pharisees as a sect, though later in the chapter he admits, “None of the ancient sources views the Pharisees as a sect, and there is no sign that the Pharisees of the first century had that exclusivistic ideology, strict organization, and group-oriented eschatology which characterize sects.”27 His treatment of Christianity is problematic. First, when he makes a statement such as “Those Jews who do not accept Christ are sinners. If this is not a sectarian perspective, it certainly is very close to it,”28 he clearly moves away from his own definition of what constitutes a sect. Second, in the end, even based on his own “minimal definition” of Christianity, he cannot decide whether or not it 25 His notions regarding religion may also be overdetermined by modern institutions. One way we should not think about sects is as a group “separating from the parent religion” as such a notion might imply anachronistic features such as established, normative traditions, creeds, states, and a pluralism quite unlike that of modern American society, not to mention that even “religion” as construed in modern academic theories is a notion that would have been foreign to antiquity. Furthermore, though we are accustomed to think of sects as “breaking away” we should be careful to recognize that often the groups studied in this work understand (or least posture) themselves as reformers of the parent tradition or even as the legitimate representation of the “purified” or “true” tradition and do not, in fact, see themselves as “breaking away.” 26 Cohen, Maccabees to Mishnah, 126. 27 Ibid., 162. 28 Ibid., 168.
20
constitutes a sect: “These distinctive and peculiar practices [baptism, Eucharist, speaking in tongues], more than the distinctive and peculiar theology on which the practices were based, made Christianity a ‘sect’ or, at least, a separate group within Jewish society.”29 When addressing the Therapeutae, Cohen proclaims that Jewish sectarianism was a phenomenon restricted to the mother country. Alienation from the temple and the priests was required if sectarianism was to have a focus, and outside the land of Israel that focus did not exist, because all Jews were equally distant from the holy land and from contact with the sacred. All the sources that speak about the Pharisees, Sadducees, Essenes, and other sects, place them exclusively (except for occasional refugees from war or persecution) in the land of Israel, for the most part in Judea.30
Cohen limits his discussion of sectarianism to Jewish sects of the first century, so there are no “controls” in his study regarding the behavior of sects in general. If, for example, when I study the Branch Davidians I find that the sect was established or maintained at a geographical distance from the parent tradition, I will have to conclude either that Cohen is wrong from a sociological point of view in insisting that Jewish sectarianism could only have existed in Palestine or that Cohen is correct but only because Judaism itself was structured such that it provides an exception to the general rule.31 That is to say, first-century Jewish sects may be exceptional because, unlike the Branch Davidian sect, for example, Jews in the first century defined the sacred in terms of a temple and a Holy Land. Had he used a comparative approach Cohen’s arguments might be more persuasive.
A New Proposal A fresh approach is needed. This chapter will present a theoretical framework for the investigation. There is some consensus among social scientists that a group like the three I am examining, in empir29
Ibid. Ibid., 171. 31 Cohen’s insistence that Jewish sectarianism required alienation from the temple and the priests, coupled with his claim that such a requirement did not obtain “outside the land of Israel,” implies that he negates the possibility of a sect outside of Israel. The implication is further corroborated by his statement that, though the Therapeutae may look like an exception to his rule, there is “no hint in Philo of any sectarian self-definition.” Ibid. 30
21
ically verified instances, tends to employ a certain range of strategies for establishing and maintaining its identity as a group. This project heavily employs William Bainbridge’s approach to sects and cults. Bainbridge recognizes some basic tendencies that inhere in groups one might call sectarian. First, sects tend to arise from a schism between an established parent tradition and the smaller group. Second, sects tend to represent “an intense form of a standard religious tradition.”32 Bainbridge is quick to note that while these tendencies appear, they do not always inhere together. Rather than attempting to define the essential characteristics of a “sect,” Bainbridge operates with a model that estimates “degrees of tension” between a group and its environment.33 Those considered “sectarian” are on the high-tension end of the continuum. Bainbridge places his own work in the context of the history of scholarship as follows: Traditional church-sect theory postulates a system of religious institutions and movements, in which an ecclesia (or established church) has formed an alliance with the powerful members of a society, and small dissenting sects break away in social opposition and religious fervor. These sectarian movements tend to attract poor and uneducated converts, in contrast to the ecclesia which comprises the rich and educated. Throughout the first half of the twentieth century, sociologists tended to construct complex descriptions of an ecclesia and of sects that listed a number of attributes of each. But many examples did not fit these typologies at all well. Following the ideas of sociologist Benton Johnson, expressed early in the second half of the century, it is useful to arrange religious groups along a dimension of their degree of tension with the surrounding sociocultural environment.34
Whether or not a group will maintain its original level of tension, increase it, or decrease it depends on a number of factors. Bainbridge suggests the following as those that decrease tension: 1. Birth of a new generation of members who must be raised in the religion rather than converted to it. 2. Improvement in the economic level of members due to the ascetic values or other features of the sect. 3. Sociocultural assimilation of the ethnic group to which members belong.
32
Bainbridge, Sociology, 24. For a brief history of the “church-sect” and “cult-sect” debates, see the Excursus at the conclusion of the chapter. 34 Bainbridge, Sociology, 59. 33
22
4. Increase in the number of members, bringing the sect out of minority status. 5. Development of a stable leadership structure, which builds a bureaucracy and emphasizes the needs of the bureaucratic leaders. 6. Random processes, including regression toward the mean, that tend to reduce the deviance of individuals or groups.
As parallels, Bainbridge offers the following as factors that maintain or increase tension: 1. A high level of recruitment of new members, which emphasizes their needs rather than those of members born into the group. 2. Failure of members to rise in the surrounding socioeconomic system, perhaps due to widespread economic depression and social chaos. 3. Rejection of members by powerful groups in society because they belong to a suppressed ethnic group. 4. Failure of a conversionist group to grow causes members to stress specific compensators in lieu of worldly evidence of success. 5. A sequence of charismatic leaders stages numerous revivals that pump up the tension. 6. Holy scriptures or other well-established traditions that anchor the group near a particular level of tension.35
In all of my research, this is the only place in which a sociologist of religion noted that the use of Scripture may serve a significant social function for sects. Bainbridge’s explanation for inclusion of this category is worth quoting in full: It may not be immediately obvious why holy scriptures, the last of the factors preventing tension reduction, has anything to do with random processes, the last of the factors promoting reduction. The link is found in the mathematical theory of random processes, specifically in the concept of absorbing state. In random processes, an absorbing state is a situation that it is easy to get into but difficult to get out of. This is a very useful concept, but unfortunately is not a very familiar one. Therefore, we need a humble example. Imagine a marble rolling around in the bottom of a bathtub. Almost any place on the bottom of the tub, a slight push makes the marble move a considerable distance. However, if the marble falls into the drain, it is stuck there forever. The drain is an absorbing state. There are several absorbing states in the sociology of religion. A religious seeker sets out on a quest to find a suitable religion to join; when he or she actually joins one, it is an absorbing state for the quest, and the person may stay in it forever. The afterlife is another 35
Ibid., 79.
23
absorbing state, from which few if any people return. A successful religious movement typically goes through a formative period, when it develops its distinctive doctrine and practices. If it writes these down into sacred books, or enshrines them in inflexible structures of social roles, then it will be unlikely to change them, short of a major internal revolution. Thus, fixed scriptures are an absorbing state that can prevent random movement away from high tension. The most prominent example, of course is the great power of the New Testament to serve as the launch pad for an endless barrage of high-tension religious movements that seek to fulfill its world-transcending promise.36
Apart from this, Bainbridge ignores the function of Scripture within sectarian groups. It is important to highlight that, in contending for dominance, sects often war on two fronts: one with the parent tradition and the other with the larger secular culture. In the Qumran texts, one finds opposition both to the dominant religious tradition (i.e., temple-based, priestly Judaism) and to the larger non-Jewish culture designated “gentiles,” especially Romans. The Branch Davidian texts depict opposition both to the dominant religious tradition from which the sect separated, Seventh-Day Adventism, and to the larger secular culture designated as “the world.” The Fourth Gospel vehemently opposes its parent tradition; the degree to which it opposes the larger non-Jewish culture will be treated later. It is now appropriate to present from the start a summary of the factors involved in the formation and maintenance of a sectarian group. Sects are engaged in the production of culture, a production in which Scripture plays a key role and which is fundamentally shaped by the need to distinguish the sectarian culture from various external cultures, especially a parent tradition. The following is a general outline of what the creation and maintenance of a sectarian culture entails, but the present project concentrates throughout on the role of Scripture in the process. Thus, the outline provides a taxonomy for understanding how scripture could function in each of the three examined groups. The remainder of this chapter will explain the inclusion of the various categories by drawing upon the work of sociologists. At the broadest level, this investigation inquires after what sociologists call “the production of culture.”
36
Ibid., 82–83.
24
Charting Results How Scripture Can Function Within Sects A. BREAKING AWAY: CREATING AND DEGRADING “THEM” B. FORMATION OF SECT 1. Etiology: celebrate origins of the community; ground community in the past 2. Show sect’s founder to have special insight regarding Scripture 3. Defining and elevating “us” C. CREATING A DISTINCT WAY OF LIFE 1. 2. 3. 4.
Ethical behavior Ritual practice Language and rhetoric Use of sacred texts a. The sectarian community as Scripture’s telos b. Scripture is authoritative and validates sect’s views 5. Roles of authoritative leaders Leader is righteous, chosen, or otherwise admirable; leader is unjustly persecuted; leader is privy to special insight; leader warrants fidelity and belief—salvation depends on one’s stance vis-à-vis him or her 6. Definition of the future D. OPPOSITION TO AND FROM THE PARENT TRADITION 1. Named opponents 2. Those who break Scripture E. OPPOSITION FROM WITHIN THE SECT: DEALING WITH DEFECTION 1. Reward adherence to the sect 2. Castigate potential and actual deserters F. OPPOSITION TO AND FROM WITHOUT G. JUDGMENT AGAINST OPPONENTS H. GROWING THE SECT 1. Proselytizing 2. The next generation
The Production of Culture As a subfield in the discipline of sociology, cultural analysis has not experienced smooth development. Scholars have not agreed on the definition of culture, the methods appropriate for studying culture,
25
or even whether the subfield belongs to sociology rather than history or political science. In spite of the disparities, it is possible to detect four basic approaches to cultural analysis, according to sociologist Robert Wuthnow.37 The subjective approach views culture in terms of beliefs, attitudes, opinions, and values. The focus remains on the individual, her ideas, moods, motivations, and goals, and depends largely on participant observation and personal interview. This approach prevails in the social sciences.38 The structural approach attends to patterns and relationships among cultural elements. The focus is less on the subjective states of the individual and more on culture as an objectified phenomenon. “Its task is conceived of as identifying orderly relations and rules—structures—that give culture coherence and identity,”39 and the approach typically appears in the work of structuralists and post-structuralists. The institutional approach is marked by interest in how culture is related to actors, resources, and institutions which distribute those resources. This approach recognizes that culture “is produced by actors who have special competencies and is perpetuated by organizations that in a sense process resources for the purpose of ritualizing, codifying, and transmitting cultural products. These organizations in turn are likely to develop relations with the state and other sources of power and may also be challenged by movements with access to other pools of social resources.”40 The final approach, and the one into which the present study best fits, is the dramaturgic approach. 37 Robert Wuthnow delineates these four in Meaning and Moral Order: Explorations in Cultural Analysis (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1987), 10–17. He devotes the remaining chapters of the work to an application of each of the approaches and concludes by noting the strengths and weaknesses of each. 38 The traditional view of how culture shapes action championed most prominently by Max Weber and Talcott Parsons places “values” at the center of the equation. Simply put, culture imparts values to an individual and the individual then chooses actions that will achieve the end dictated by that value. So, in his work, The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, Weber argues that the Calvinist doctrine of predestination engendered a drive to prove that one enjoyed a place among the elect which manifested itself in the mundane context of worldly affairs, especially in the forms of asceticism, rigorous self-examination, and discipline. A second example of the “values” approach is provided by the studies and debates on the “culture of poverty,” which seek to explain why the poor do not take advantage of opportunities to get out of the culture of poverty; briefly stated, they conclude that the poor do not have the same values as the middle or upper classes. Ann Swidler, “Culture in Action: Symbols and Strategies,” American Sociological Review 51 (1986): 275. 39 Wuthnow, Meaning, 12. 40 Ibid., 15.
26
The dramaturgic approach focuses on the expressive or communicative properties of culture. Rather than being conceived of as a purely (or largely) autonomous entity, culture is now approached in interaction with social structure. Unlike in the subjective approach, culture is said to interact with social structure not as a feature of individual feeling and experience but as an expressive dimension of social relations. Ideology, for example, is pictured as a set of symbols that articulates how social relations should be arranged. More generally, culture becomes identifiable as the symbolic-expressive dimension of social structure. It communicates information about morally binding obligations and is in turn influenced by the structure of these obligations. This approach is like the structural approach in that culture is defined in a way that makes it more observable than in the subjective approach. Rather than consisting of subjective beliefs and attitudes, it consists of utterances, acts, objects and events—all of which are observable, even behavioral in a sense. The relations or patterns among these elements remain important, as in the structural approach. But these relations are no longer examined strictly by themselves; they are now examined in conjunction with ideas about the ordering of social life. Of particular importance is the idea that social life requires a dimension of moral order, that is, a set of definitions about what is proper to do and what is reasonable to expect. The term “dramaturgic” is used to describe this approach because of its emphasis on the capacity of rituals, ideologies, and other symbolic acts to dramatize the nature of social relations [cf. Garfinkel below]. It is in these dramatizations that definitions of the situations are communicated. In saying that culture is symbolic-expressive, therefore, this approach tends to focus less on information that is simply and straightforwardly transmitted than on messages that may be implicit in the ways in which social life is arranged, in rituals, and in the choice of words in discourse. Put simply, what is “given off ” may be as important as what is “given.”41
In the Fourth Gospel, one is dealing with culture in at least two forms: both the narrative and its use of Scripture manifest the “expressive or communicative properties of culture” and both lend themselves to inquiry concerning the interaction between culture and social structure. Ideology in the Fourth Gospel serves not simply to supply an individual with a set of esoteric ideas (as in the subjective approach), but to symbolize and articulate how social relations should be arranged. When Wayne A. Meeks discovers that the motif of Jesus as a stranger to this world both calls the community to persevere under persecu41
Ibid., 13–14.
27
tion and comforts the community by showing its identity with Jesus,42 he approximates Wuthnow’s observation that the idea that “social life requires a dimension of moral order, that is, a set of definitions about what is proper to do and what is reasonable to expect,” is extremely important. It is also the case that when Meeks looks beyond the explicit to the implicit messages in the Fourth Gospel, when he looks beyond what the text says about the Man from Heaven to how the text functions, he approximates Wuthnow’s observation that, “In saying that culture is symbolic-expressive, therefore, this approach tends to focus less on information that is simply and straightforwardly transmitted than on messages that may be implicit in the ways in which social life is arranged, in rituals, and in the choice of words in discourse. Put simply, what is ‘given off ’ may be as important as what is ‘given.’ ”43 The insistence upon the importance of the interaction between culture and social structure requires more attention. The present study defines culture in a Geertzian fashion, as “the publicly available symbolic forms through which people experience and express meaning.”44 Geertz’s definition may be augmented by denoting such various symbolic transmitters of meaning as “beliefs, ritual practices, art forms, and ceremonies, as well as informal cultural practices such as language, gossip, stories and rituals of daily life.”45 “Scripture” comprises an egregious omission and, of course, must be added. Ann Swidler’s understanding of how culture functions, namely, as “a repertoire or ‘tool kit’ of habits, skills, and styles from which people construct ‘strategies of action,’ ”46 is quite useful and allows for the complexity of the relationship among social conditions, ideas, and ethos. People are born into a culture not of their own choosing which shapes their identity and behavior. But what happens when a group rejects or is rejected by that community and decides to construct a counterculture, as we see in the groups selected for this study? How do they overcome the separation and invent an identity? They can solve the first problem by building a myth in which the opponents 42
Meeks, “Man from Heaven.” Wuthnow, Meaning, 14. 44 As quoted by Swidler, “Culture,” 273. Wuthnow (Meaning, 4) offers a similar definition of culture as “the symbolic-expressive aspect of social behavior.” 45 Swidler, “Culture,” 273. 46 Ibid. 43
28
become “totally other.” The second task demands much more. Now they have to adopt and invent culture, actions, habits; they must imbue them with meaning and instruct others accordingly until they reach a point where people act upon a shared set of assumptions. They must once again set boundaries, markers that indicate whether one is in or out. In order to comprehend the process of breaking away, one must understand how groups form in the first place. To understand a group’s boundaries, one must analyze its culture. In order for a group to function, its members must generally share the same habits and customs without constantly defining them. For example, in America all drivers know that a red light means stop and a green light means go—drivers do not think about why this is so each time they must negotiate a traffic light, nor do they inquire of the other drivers whether or not they too understand that red means stop and green means go. Each assumes that the other will act within the established limits of their culture. Shared assumptions mark a group. In crafting his message for a group of Christians, John intends to shape at least their beliefs and probably their practices as well. Scripture serves John as one tool in constructing his Gospel. In the end, John uses the sacred to produce the sacred; he uses a cultural tool to create a cultural tool. To make such a statement is to draw attention to the fact that culture is produced. It involves producers (e.g., artists, preachers, and authors), products (e.g., works of art and sermons), and consumers (e.g., viewers, readers, or listeners). Other factors involved in the production of culture include: the immediate audience, whether an individual or a community;47 the larger audience, defined as those to whom the immediate audience might relate the contents of the work as well as those who might take an interest in the work for some reason or another;48 the resources available to the preacher; and the host environment. Furthermore, the production of culture is a process. 47 The Gospels highlight the role played by individuals and communities in producing the sacred. First, we have the Gospels because individuals or communities saw fit to preserve Jesus’ traditions, which allowed the Gospel writers to compose narratives and thereby pass on those traditions. Second, we continue to have the Gospels because individuals or communities saw fit to preserve them. 48 “The sermon is likely to have the assembled audience in mind as its primary public, yet it is also likely to treat this audience not as a unitary entity but as a series of subgroups whose boundaries may spill over to a much wider public: those of you who are educated, those of you who are feeling depressed, those of you who are uncertain what to believe.” Wuthnow, Producing, 55.
29
The history of sociological analysis regarding the production of culture can be traced from the time when culture was largely viewed as “a set of preexisting assumptions, widely shared and long enduring, that provided tacit explanations for why societies prospered or failed and that guided behavior into various channels”49 to a more recent period in which sociologists have proven that culture, at least in the form of music, art, and museums, is produced rather than inevitable. By Wuthnow’s own admission, “the cultural production perspective has thus progressed far more in studies of other kinds of culture, such as art, literature, and political ideology, than in applications to the understanding of religion.”50 Scripture has enjoyed no attention in this regard. It is not the case, then, that inculcators of culture transmit a systematic set of values whereby each member of the community then chooses each action she undertakes in order to achieve a certain end; the picture is much more complex than that.51 Cultures are not monolithic systems but admit diverse, even conflicting elements from which members are free to choose in undertaking an action. Most useful for our inquiry into the interaction between culture and social structures is Ann Swidler’s analysis of cultural influences
49
Ibid., 23. Ibid., 24. 51 Bainbridge critiques traditional views of values in a chapter entitled “Morality” in Sociology, 269–99. Having presented one of the traditional views in which “values” comprise “the legitimate goals of human action, enshrined as the central axioms of a culture and inculcated into the society’s members through socialization,” he goes on to variously dispute such a notion. First, such a view assumes a highly unified society; second, it favors abstraction over concreteness, and empirical sociologists tend toward the latter, looking to a person’s socioeconomic status or “location in a social network.” Finally, it assumes that people “practice what they preach,” so to speak, but sociologists are not convinced that such is the case. “Once upon a time, sociologists used to explain behavior as the natural expression of an individual’s attitudes, but then researchers found many instances in which words and deeds diverge, and verbally expressed attitudes no longer seemed so sociologically relevant. Attitudes and values may be important, but it was no longer appropriate for sociologists to assume so without direct evidence in the particular situation under study, and it often proved difficult to measure their influence in particular studies” (282). Unlike Swidler’s, however, his constructive work regarding culture, norms, and values is less nuanced and compelling. In short, culture comprises “the accumulated set of explanations a society possesses on how to obtain particular rewards and avoid costs. . . . Norms are simply specific explanations having to do with social situations, and values are general explanations having to do with social situations” (284). He goes on to say that in seeking to formulate these so-called “explanations,” most arose first in the area of religion simply because they did not depend on empirical proof, which leads him to this proclamation: “Thus, values, to the extent that this concept means anything at all, are likely to be religious in nature” (285). 50
30
in two different situations, which she refers to as “settled lives” and “unsettled lives.” In settled lives, culture and action reinforce one another, whereas in unsettled lives culture serves to create new strategies of action.52 In “settled lives,” culture and action are not so tightly bound because there is no heightened need for intentionality. The culture in which settled people live is “given” and requires little thought, though it does require some choice because established cultures can tolerate diversity in a way that ideological movements cannot. Hence, in settled lives, there are “gaps between the explicit norms, world-views, and rules of conduct individuals espouse and the ways they habitually act.”53 This does not generally constitute a problem, however, because people “know” how to act within the culture. Unlike unsettled cultures, it is more difficult to analyze the relationship between culture and social structure in settled lives because the two are so intertwined. In settled cultures, “ideology . . . has gone underground, so pervading ordinary experience as to blend imperceptibly into common-sense assumptions about what is true.”54 Nevertheless, Swidler distinguishes how culture influences settled lives: [S]ettled cultures constrain action by providing a limited set of resources out of which individuals and groups construct strategies of action. There is nonetheless a distinctive kind of cultural explanation appropriate to settled cultures. First, while such cultures provide a “tool kit” of resources from which people can construct diverse strategies of action, to construct such a strategy means selecting certain structural elements (both such tacit culture as attitudes and styles and, sometimes, such explicit cultural materials as rituals and beliefs) and investing them with particular meanings in concrete life circumstances.55
She gives as an example young adults who attend church once they are married and have children and, in turn, find religious feelings Two points must be made here: first, “unsettled lives” may refer to individuals or groups; second, the distinction between culture’s role in maintaining strategies of action or creating new ones should not be seen in completely dichotomous terms because, admittedly, “even the most fanatical ideological movement, which seeks to remake completely the cultural capacities of its members, will inevitably draw on many tacit assumptions from the existing culture” (Swidler, “Culture,” 278), a point worth remembering as we undertake an investigation of the use of Scripture among groups who stand against a dominant cultural form (so, the Qumranians deny the validity of other Jewish groups; the Fourth Gospel community denies the validity of “the Jews,” and the Branch Davidians deny the validity of any groups outside the BD who call themselves “Christian”). 53 Swidler, “Culture” 280. 54 Ibid., 281. 55 Ibid. 52
31
re-evoked. In such a case, culture does not cause their choice to attend in that both the cultural elements and the life strategy are chosen simultaneously. But culture does serve an influential role insofar as the “ability to put together such a strategy depends on the available set of cultural resources. Furthermore, as certain cultural resources become more central in a given life and become more fully invested with meaning, they anchor the strategies of action people have developed.”56 In unsettled periods, “ideologies—explicit, articulated, highly organized meaning systems (both political and religious)—establish new styles or strategies of action. When people are learning new ways of organizing individual and collective action, practicing unfamiliar habits until they become familiar, then doctrine, symbol, and ritual directly shape action.”57 These groups do not tolerate the ambiguities, multiplicities and even profound inconsistencies which “settled lives” do; rather, they provide an overarching, coherent answer to the question of “how human beings should live. In conflict with other cultural models, these cultures are coherent because they must battle to dominate the world-views, assumptions, and habits of their members.”58 Sects seek to dominate the worldview of their members, and those studied here rely heavily on the invocation and interpretation of Scripture to effect it. Indeed, I propose that the function of every direct quotation from or allusion to Scripture is the production of a worldview. While these cultures do exert a causal power, it is not complete at least at their origins because “much of their taken-forgranted understanding of the world and many of their daily practices still depend on traditional patterns.”59 This is true for all of the groups studied here, the traditional patterns emanating from Judaism in the cases of Qumran and the Fourth Gospel, and from SeventhDay Adventism for the Branch Davidians. The position and influence of Scripture comprises part of those “traditional patterns.” The notion of “unsettled lives” plays a central role in understanding the groups under scrutiny in this work, so it is worth citing Swidler’s brief summary of the discussion of “unsettled lives”: Culture has independent causal influence in unsettled cultural periods because it makes possible new strategies of action—constructing entities 56 57 58 59
Ibid. Ibid., 278. Ibid., 279. Ibid.
32
that can act (selves, families, corporations), shaping the styles and skills with which they act, and modeling forms of authority and cooperation. It is, however, the concrete situations in which these cultural models are enacted that determine which take root and thrive, and which wither and die.60
Sects represent an unsettled period; therefore, one should expect Scripture, as a vehicle of culture, to play a prominent role in the establishment of new strategies of action. Additionally, if we assume that sects exemplify “unsettled lives,” perhaps we can reasonably speculate that they actually practice what they preach, that their actions correlate with their beliefs. The construction of new systems generally moves from ideology to tradition to common sense, with ideology constituting an articulated, deliberate belief system, tradition referring to beliefs and practices which are simply taken for granted, and common sense comprising beliefs so assumed that they seem natural and inevitable enough that they evoke little, if any, conscious reflection.61 Groups struggling to establish themselves, especially when vying for a position of dominance, tend toward the ideological; the expectations concerning belief and action are usually explicit, demanding, and rigid. The new ideology often conflicts with tradition and common sense in its effort to construct a new cultural model, which will provide the tools for new “strategies of action.” Such is the case with sects, which, by definition, conflict with tradition and attempt to compose a new cultural model. The ways in which the Qumran, Fourth Gospel, and Branch Davidian communities conflict with the tradition and common sense of their larger culture are manifold and are discussed in the individual chapters devoted to each, but they include at least the interpretation of Scripture, ritual practices, and ethics. A group’s acute ideological phase can be described as follows: Bursts of ideological activism occur in periods when competing ways of organizing action are developing or contending for dominance. People formulate, flesh out, and put into practice new habits of action. In such situations, culture may indeed be said to directly shape action. Members of a religious cult wear orange, or share their property . . . because their beliefs tell them to. . . . During such periods, differences in ritual practice or doctrine may become highly charged, so that stat60 61
Ibid., 280. Ibid., 279.
33
uary in churches . . ., the clothing and preaching style of ministers . . . are fraught with significance. Ritual acquires such significance in unsettled lives because ritual changes reorganize taken-for-granted habits and modes of experience.62
To understand how culture works in a high-ideology period one must attend to the larger context. While such groups offer new strategies of action and patterns of organizing people, they “are in active competition with other cultural frameworks—at the least in competition with common sense and usually with alternative traditions and ideologies as well.”63 To explain why one ideology is victorious requires analysis of “the structural constraints and historical circumstances within which ideological movements struggle for dominance.”64 Attention to the placement of a community within a host environment is essential. Wuthnow contends that we should think of religious groups as competing with one another and he identifies three probable dynamics among them. First is the phenomenon of “selective adaptation,” defined as “the process whereby organizations in competition with one another succeed in extracting resources from their host environment, with the result that over time some organizations cease to exist, while others take over a disproportionate share of the available resources.”65 This largely has to do with the notion of “fit” between the host environment and the group. Isomorphism, the second feature, involves the competing organizations coming to resemble one another at least enough to ensure their securing some part of the available resources. Finally, specialization allows each group to assert its distinctiveness. I present these three features not to suggest that one can impose a modern market economy model onto the first century, but to enunciate the fact that the social environment in which a group resides and functions and in which a preacher or artist produces his or her work must be considered as crucial to understanding the dynamics at work between the lone producer, the 62
Ibid., 279. Ibid., 280. Similarly, John A. Hostetler notes: “A sectarian movement must establish an ideology different from that of the parent group in order to break off relations with it. A sect must establish cultural separatism, involving symbolic and often material as well as ideological differences, from those of the parent group.” John A. Hostetler, Amish Society (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press, 1968), 35–36; quoted in Bainbridge, Sociology, 264. 64 Swidler, “Culture,” 280. 65 Wuthnow, Producing, 30. 63
34
group that she seeks to affect, and the wider community. In words similar to those expressed by Swidler at the heading of this chapter, Wuthnow writes: In combination these three processes—selective adaptation, isomorphism, and specialization—help us see that the products generated by any particular organization are not merely the result of random efforts by talented leaders or exceptionally clever committees; these products are part of a larger system, and which ones find the light of day depends very much on whether their organizations are successful in coping with the exigencies of their social environments.66
If Swidler is correct in her proposals about high-ideology periods, we should expect stark opposition between the sects and the dominant culture, or, more appropriately, dominant cultures, since dissident sectarian religious oppose both the dominant religious tradition from which they have emerged as well as the larger “secular” culture. For example, the Fourth Gospel opposes the dominant religious tradition, which the author indicates with the term “Jews,” as well as the larger culture designated as “the world.” These designations are not as tidy as they might first appear because (a) the categories “Jews” and “world” overlap and (b) by “secular” I do not mean a-religious or non-religious since it would be difficult to find a person in antiquity not involved in some religious cult. Rather, I mean to indicate that part of the larger culture that does not participate in the sect’s parent tradition, which, for the Qumran and Fourth Gospel communities consists of pagans. Likewise, those in the larger culture outside of Seventh-Day Adventism who are designated as “the world” might actually be part of a religious tradition and not define themselves in “secular” terms. The sects, however, do differentiate between the parent tradition from which they separated and to which they are opposed, and the larger culture that is not part of either the sect or the parent tradition, to which they are also opposed. To summarize the differences between the two models of culture, settled culture (tradition and common sense) is characterized by low coherence and low consistency and serves an encapsulating function. In the short term, it exerts “weak direct control over action” and “refines and reinforces skills, habits, and modes of experience.” In the long term, it “provides resources for constructing strategies of 66 Wuthnow, Producing, 32. The existence of the Johannine epistles indicates that at least two (opposing) parts of the Johannine community did, in fact, survive.
35
action” and “creates continuities in style or ethos, and especially in organization of strategies of action.” On the other hand, unsettled culture (ideology) is characterized by high coherence and consistency, and, rather than encapsulating, “competes with other cultural views.” In the short term it exerts “strong control over action” and “teaches new modes of action.” In the long term it “creates new strategies of action, but long-term influence depends on structural opportunities for survival of competing ideologies.”67 Finally, a brief word about the direction of influence between ideology and ethos: debate continues about the relationship between the two, and most use Weber as a starting point.68 Weber is often interpreted as a determinist and criticized for placing too much emphasis on the causal power of ideology to dictate ethics. Regarding Calvinism, for example, Weber suggests that asceticism was borne of the predestinarian doctrine of salvation. Asceticism was not any more the inexorable outcome of predestinarian doctrine than hedonism might have been. Instead, one might argue for a relationship between ideology and ethos that gives priority to the latter as the more causal. Michael Walzer does so when he argues that Calvin had a certain discipline in mind, which he sought to effect in his listeners: He opportunistically revised and reworked his doctrine in order to achieve a particular psychological effect. Calvin needed potent theological imagery to inscribe within his congregants the rigorous control of thought and action he sought. Indeed, tightly argued doctrine, austere ritual, and potent imagery were the weapons Calvin crafted to teach a new ethos.
67 This paragraph summarizes the chart presented by Swidler as “Figure 1. Two Models of Culture.” Swidler, “Culture,” 282. 68 Weber’s concept of “elective affinity” appears in “Social Psychology of the World Religions,” in H. H. Gerth and C. Wright Mills, trans. and eds., From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology (London: Routledge, 1960), 267–301. By it, Weber attempts to articulate the complex relationship between ideas and ethics. Using six world religions, he shows that ethics do not flow directly and inevitably from particular ideas; rather, certain ethics depend upon the “psychological and pragmatic contexts of religions” (267). “Not ideas, but material and ideal interests, directly govern men’s conduct. Yet very frequently the ‘world images’ that have been created by ‘ideas’ have, like switchmen, determined the tracks along which action has been pushed by the dynamic of interest. ‘From what’ and ‘for what’ one wished to be redeemed and, let us not forget, ‘could be’ redeemed, depended upon one’s image of the world” (280). Nancy Ammerman explains that “Weber was arguing with Marx on this score. So unlike Marx (for whom the material conditions were both necessary and sufficient), Weber posits that both material conditions and ideas are necessary (the train and the switchmen). Conditions + ideas = new conditions; not simply: ideas = new conditions.” Personal correspondence, February 9, 2000.
36
But doctrine “caused” ethos only in an immediate sense. In a larger explanatory perspective, commitment to a specific ethos, a style of regulating action, shaped the selection and development of doctrine.69
The fundamental recognition that there is a dialectic between ideology and ethos, and the articulation of how a leader may persuade her listeners, serves our study and will be referred to in the following chapters when I analyze how the authors deploy Scripture. If Walzer is correct, then we should expect Scripture to be used by leaders in such a way as to influence an ethos or ethics. A perduring question in Johannine studies concerns the chronological development of the Christology (ideology), the chronological development of the sect (ethos) itself, and the relationship between the christological development and the social group development. One might argue that the high Christology of the group developed first and caused the group to break off into a sect; or, one might argue that the high Christology was the result of having been displaced from the synagogue. The best arguments, however, allow for a nuanced dialectic between the two.70 In closing this section, which has oriented the reader to the assumptions made about culture in this work, I echo the sentiments of Swidler when she presents the implications of the approach to culture which she champions: This perspective could reorient research on culture in a second way, by directing attention to a set of historical questions about the interaction of culture and social structure. Distinguishing culture’s role in settled and unsettled periods, we can focus on those historical junctures where new cultural complexes make possible new or reorganized strategies of action. We can then ask how concrete structural circumstances affect the relative success of competing cultural systems. We could also ask how the capacity of particular ideas, rituals, and symbols to organize given kinds of action affects the historical opportunities actors are able to seize. Such questions might finally begin to give us a systematic view of the dynamic interactions between culture and social structure.71
My study lies in the trajectory of this implication.
69
Swidler, “Culture,” 280 (describing Walzer’s argument). See, e.g., Jerome Neyrey, An Ideology of Revolt: John’s Christology in Social-Science Perspective (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1988). 71 Swidler, “Culture,” 283. 70
37
Relationship Between Sect and Parent Tradition Establishing Distance Having presented the view of culture assumed in this study, I now attend to the details of group formation and maintenance. Sects, by definition, form in opposition to a parent tradition and, as long as they maintain their sectarian stance, they maintain opposition to and from that parent tradition. The sect inhabits an unclear land with regard to its identity: on the one hand, because it shares much of the same heritage and operates under many of the same presuppositions regarding worldview, in many ways it remains indistinct from the parent tradition; on the other hand, there is enough discontinuity with the parent tradition to warrant the formation of a separate group. How does a group distinguish itself from the parent tradition? First and foremost, the group accentuates the differences between itself and the parent tradition and creates a clear sense of “us” against “them.” The group is characterized in elevated terms and the opponents in degrading terms. Harold Garfinkel’s work on status degradation elucidates the process whereby this may be achieved. By definition, sects stand in opposition to at least one other group, the dominant tradition. The process of developing an identity, group boundaries, and a worldview involves distancing the community from other groups, defining the community over against authentic or constructed opponents. In creating a “we,” leaders capitalize on the benefits of creating a “not-we,” the “other.” None of our authors shies away from the polemic required for this process. In his article, “Conditions of Successful Degradation Ceremonies,” Garfinkel explains, “Communicative work directed to transforming an individual’s total identity into an identity lower in the group’s scheme of social types is called a ‘status degradation ceremony.’ ”72 By “total 72 Harold Garfinkel, “Conditions of Successful Degradation Ceremonies,” AJS 61 (1956): 420. The denunciation can occur through a variety of media including writing or personal presence. Whether or not it is successful depends on a number of factors, which Garfinkel addresses on p. 424; for example, “Whether the denunciation must be accomplished on a single occasion or is to be carried out over a sequence of ‘tries,’ factors like the territorial arrangements and movements of persons at the scene of the denunciation, the numbers of persons involved as accused, degraders, and witnesses, status claims of the contenders, prestige and power allocations among participants, all should influence the outcome.” I am not interested in deciding whether or not the degradation “worked” in the historical sense but rather in providing a framework that defines how one undertakes the work of degradation.
38
identity,” Garfinkel signifies not just the actions of the denounced, but the grounds upon which the actions are based. This combination of behavior and grounds “constitutes the other as a social object.”73 Wherever one finds a society, one finds the structural conditions necessary for status degradation, though the tactics may be different from group to group.74 Where Garfinkel starts with specific ritualized occasions, the student of the Fourth Gospel deals with rhetoric in a text. Ritual and rhetoric have in common the power to enunciate a group’s ultimate values and draw lines indicating who shares those values and who does not. Because of this similarity, Garfinkel’s work can usefully be applied to the text of the Fourth Gospel. There are at least three dramatis personae in this performance: the denouncer, the denounced, and the group that the denouncer is trying to persuade (which Garfinkel designates “witnesses”). The denouncer must present himself or herself as an authentic representative of the group. The primary task of the denouncer consists of proving not that the denounced has somehow changed but rather that the character presently described is the essential character which may previously have escaped notice. The rhetoric of denunciation typically employs irony to highlight the disparity between what the denounced seemed to be and what he or she is now proved to be in reality. The reconsideration and “redefinition of origins of the denounced”75 also figures largely in that rhetoric. A successful degradation ceremony requires that the following conditions be met. First, the denounced and that which is being blamed on the denounced (for ease of discussion, Garfinkel chooses to call this the “event”) must be “removed from the realm of their everyday character and be made to stand as ‘out of the ordinary.’ ”76 Second, the denounced and the event must be seen in terms of types rather than unique occurrences so that a certain uniformity regard73
Ibid. One might appropriately assign Garfinkel’s work to the genre of shame and honor studies, which has recently garnered much attention in various disciplines. See, for example, Jerome H. Neyrey, Honor and Shame in the Gospel of Matthew (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1998); David Arthur DeSilva, Despising Shame: Honor Discourse and Community Maintenance in the Epistle to the Hebrews (Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1995); Douglas L. Cairns, Aidos: The Psychology and Ethics of Honour and Shame in Ancient Greek Literature (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1993); and N. R. E. Fisher, Hybris: A Study in the Values of Honour and Shame in Ancient Greece (Warminster: Aris & Phillips, 1992). 75 Garfinkel, “Conditions,” 422. 76 Ibid. 74
39
ing both is engendered: “[A]ny sense of accident, coincidence, indeterminism, chance, or monetary [sic] occurrence must not merely be minimized. Ideally, such measures should be inconceivable. . . .”77 Having been convinced of the typed nature of the denounced, the group must then think in dialectical terms such that they “should not be able to contemplate the features of the denounced person without reference to the counterconception”;78 character traits are further clarified when held to the light of their opposites. Having set the situation up this way, the denouncer aims to have the group (“witnesses”) in such a position that no real choice is involved when regarding the denounced; rather, morality constrains the group to believe that the need for denunciation is obvious, if not commonsensical. The denouncer must enjoy some sort of authority and must show that he shares the same essence as the witnesses and that he speaks for the whole group when he speaks. “What the denouncer says must be regarded by the witnesses as true on the grounds of a socially employed metaphysics whereby witnesses assume that witnesses and denouncer are alike in essence. . . . For bona fide members it is not that these are the grounds upon which we are agreed but upon which we are alike, consubstantial, in origin the same.”79 The denouncer must draw attention to the group’s “ultimate values,” speak on behalf of those values, and be viewed as one who maintains those values. The last requirement involves drawing boundaries, separating the denounced from the denouncer and the group. The denouncer must establish distance between the witnesses and the denounced so much so that “the denounced person must be ritually separated from a place in the legitimate order, i.e., he must be defined as standing at a place opposed to it. He must be placed ‘outside,’ he must be made ‘strange.’ ”80 Applied Theory It is useful to illustrate briefly using examples from the Fourth Gospel. That John vehemently denounces a group known as “the Jews” stands uncontested. How does he effect this? In the narrative, Jesus stands as the denouncer, “the Jews” as the denounced, and the disciples as the witnesses, or group to be persuaded. Assuming the literary text 77 78 79 80
Ibid. Ibid., 422–23. Ibid., 423 and n. 12. Ibid., 423.
40
to represent the contemporary reality of the author, the author is the denouncer, non-sectarian Jews are the denounced, and the sect is the witnesses. John 8:31–47 is instructive for this discussion: 8.31 ÖElegen oÔn ı ÉIhsoËw prÚw toÁw pepisteukÒtaw aÈt“ ÉIouda¤ouw, ÉEån Íme›w me¤nhte §n t“ lÒgƒ t“ §m“, élhy«w mayhta¤ moÊ §ste 8.32 ka‹ gn≈sesye tØn élÆyeian, ka‹ ≤ élÆyeia §leuyer≈sei Ímçw. 8.33 épekr¤yhsan prÚw aÈtÒn, Sp°rma ÉAbraãm §smen ka‹ oÈden‹ dedouleÊkamen p≈pote: p«w sÁ l°geiw ˜ti ÉEleÊyeroi genÆsesye; 8.34 épekr¤yh aÈto›w ı ÉIhsoËw, ÉAmØn émØn l°gv Ím›n ˜ti pçw ı poi«n tØn èmart¤an doËlÒw §stin t∞w èmart¤aw. 8.35 ı d¢ doËlow oÈ m°nei §n tª ofik¤& efiw tÚn afi«na, ı uflÚw m°nei efiw tÚn afi«na. 8.36 §ån oÔn ı uflÚw Ímçw §leuyer≈s˙, ˆntvw §leÊyeroi ¶sesye. 8.37 o‰da ˜ti sp°rma ÉAbraãm §ste: éllå zhte›t° me épokte›nai, ˜ti ı lÒgow ı §mÚw oÈ xvre› §n Ím›n. 8.38 ì §g∆ •≈raka parå t“ patr‹ lal«: ka‹ Íme›w oÔn ì ±koÊsate parå toË patrÚw poie›te. 8.39 ÉApekr¤yhsan ka‹ e‰pan aÈt“, ÑO patØr ≤m«n ÉAbraãm §stin. l°gei aÈto›w ı ÉIhsoËw, Efi t°kna toË ÉAbraãm §ste, tå ¶rga toË ÉAbraåm §poie›te: 8.40 nËn d¢ zhte›t° me épokte›nai ênyrvpon ˘w tØn élÆyeian Ím›n lelãlhka ∂n ≥kousa parå toË yeoË: toËto ÉAbraåm oÈk §po¤hsen. 8.41 Íme›w poie›te tå ¶rga toË patrÚw Ím«n. e‰pan [oÔn] aÈt“, ÑHme›w §k porne¤aw oÈ gegennÆmeya: ßna pat°ra ¶xomen tÚn yeÒn. 8.42 e‰pen aÈto›w ı ÉIhsoËw, Efi ı yeÚw patØr Ím«n ∑n ±gapçte ín §m°, §g∆ går §k toË yeoË §j∞lyon ka‹ ¥kv: oÈd¢ går épÉ §mautoË §lÆluya, éllÉ §ke›nÒw me ép°steilen. 8.43 diå t¤ tØn laliån tØn §mØn oÈ gin≈skete; ˜ti oÈ dÊnasye ékoÊein tÚn lÒgon tÚn §mÒn. 8.44 Íme›w §k toË patrÚw toË diabÒlou §st¢ ka‹ tåw §piyum¤aw toË patrÚw Ím«n y°lete poie›n. §ke›now ényrvpoktÒnow ∑n épÉ érx∞w ka‹ §n tª élhye¤& oÈk ¶sthken, ˜ti oÈk ¶stin élÆyeia §n aÈt“. ˜tan lalª tÚ ceËdow, §k t«n fid¤vn lale›, ˜ti ceÊsthw §st‹n ka‹ ı patØr aÈtoË. 8.45 §g∆ d¢ ˜ti tØn élÆyeian l°gv, oÈ pisteÊet° moi. 8.46 t¤w §j Ím«n §l°gxei me per‹ èmart¤aw; efi élÆyeian l°gv, diå t¤ Íme›w oÈ pisteÊet° moi; 8.47 ı Ãn §k toË yeoË tå =Æmata toË yeoË ékoÊei: diå toËto Íme›w oÈk ékoÊete, ˜ti §k toË yeoË oÈk §st°. 8.48 ÉApekr¤yhsan ofl ÉIouda›oi ka‹ e‰pan aÈt“, OÈ kal«w l°gomen ≤me›w ˜ti Samar¤thw e‰ sÁ ka‹ daimÒnion ¶xeiw;
That Jesus speaks as an authentic representative of the group and its ultimate values requires no comment. The passage begins with a presentation of “Jews who had believed” (pepisteukÒtaw), though by the end of the passage a reversal occurs. Jesus immediately establishes abiding in his own Word as the criterion for identifying one who is “truly” (élhy«w)81 a disciple. The reward will be knowledge of the truth (élÆyeia), which indicates that truth stands as a central value. ÉAlÆyeia and its cognates, which appear fifty-five times in the Fourth Gospel, occur eight times in 8:31–47 alone. When Jesus 81 Few aspects are more typically Johannine than the use of élÆyeia and its cognates.
41
announces that the truth that comes from keeping his word will bring liberation, the “Jews who had believed” start defining themselves in relation to someone other than Jesus by appealing to their origins: “We are descendants of Abraham” (my emphasis). Ironically, they not only reject the values presented by Jesus, that is, truth and freedom, but do so with the claim “we have never been in bondage to anyone,” which implies an ignorance or forgetting of the exodus. Rather than engage that omission, Jesus indicates their bondage to sin and furthers the distancing process by declaring that there are two kinds of people, the slave and the son; the former does not continue in the house forever but the latter does. Since the author has designated them as slaves, the reader has no choice but to see them as opposed to the Son, whom the readers know is Jesus. Jesus next takes up their claim to be sp°rma ÉAbraãm; he grants them that claim, but indicates that the seed of Abraham should not desire to kill Jesus. Presenting them as potential murderers serves the denunciation process, as does Jesus’ explanation of their impulse. To be “insiders” (or, in John’s words, “truly [ Jesus’] disciples”) requires continuing in Jesus’ word, which they patently do not do: “my word finds no place in you”; hence, they are “outsiders.” In addition to the paired opposites already presented—slave vs. son; slavery vs. freedom; abiding in Jesus’ word vs. having no place for Jesus’ word— Jesus now indicates another: speaking what he has seen with his Father/ doing what they have heard from their father. This leads into a vehement argument regarding the true origins and essence of the opponents. In vv. 31–37, the debate is conducted in terms of “children,” with the Jews claiming and Jesus granting that they are sp°rma ÉAbraãm and Jesus claiming to be a son (uflÒw). Since Jesus has raised the issue of paternity, the Jews respond by citing Abraham as their father, an unremarkable ascription for a Jew. Given that in v. 37 Jesus granted their claim to be sp°rma ÉAbraãm, Jesus’ declaration in v. 39 may seem contradictory until one notices the switch from sp°rma to t°kna: “If you were Abraham’s children (t°kna), you would do what Abraham did, but now you seek to kill me, a man who has told you the truth (élÆyeia) which I heard from God.” The switch from sp°rma to t°kna is not accidental; t°kna occurs four times in John and it always refers to insiders, believers. Securing a position as a child of God is a central concern from the beginning of this Gospel: “But to all who received him, who believed (pisteÊv) in his name, he gave power to become children (t°kna) of God” ( John 1:12). At 11:52 we learn
42
that the boundaries signifying insiders are drawn more largely than we might have first suspected, so that Christ died not only for the nation but also “to gather into one the children of God who are scattered abroad.” At 13:33 Christ calls the insiders, his disciples, “My children.” Thus, the “outsiderness” of these “Jews” is highlighted insofar as they are only sp°rma of Abraham and not t°kna. Having established that they are not t°kna ÉAbraãm because what they do in no way relates to what Abraham did, Jesus declares that what they do relates to what their real father did. Having lost the battle regarding Abraham as their father, the Jews now change their claim to “God is our Father.” Jesus addresses this claim in much the same way, starting with the conditional sentence, “If God were your Father (rather than “If you were Abraham’s children”), you would love me (rather than, “you would do what Abraham did”).” He then explains why they have failed to love him, just as in vv. 37–38 he explains why they seek to kill him, and he arrives at the same two related reasons: they are not able to hear his word and their father is the devil.82 Just as he said in v. 38, “you do what you have heard from your father,” so now he says, “your will is to do 82 Nils Dahl treats this passage at length in “Der Erstgeborene Satans und der Vater des Teufels (Polyk. 7,1 und Joh 8.44),” in Apophoreta: Festschrift für Ernst Haenchen (ed. Walther Eltester; BZNW 30; Berlin: Töpelmann, 1964), 70–84. He notices that Polycarp denounces his opponents using a triad of slander which comprises “Anti-Christ,” “from the devil,” and “firstborn of Satan.” The phrase “firstborn of Satan” appears in both Christian polemic against heretics and Talmudic anecdotes. Dahl suspects that they share a common root. He eventually traces the usage back to a startling targumic legend about Cain in which the story of Cain’s birth in Gen 4:1 is interpreted in such a way that the devil, not Adam, is Cain’s father. His explanation begins: Die Frage: ,,Wer war nach jüdischer Haggada der Erstgeborene Satans?“ zu erheben, heißt sie zu beantworten. Der Erstgeborene Satans war Kain. Darüber kann kein Zweifel bestehen, denn Kain war nach verbreiteter Überlieferung Sohn Satans, und es gab niemand, der ihm den Rang der Erstgeburt strittig machen könnte (72). Dahl argues that John 8:44 alludes to this tradition as well. When Jesus accuses the Jews of murderous desires, he indirectly indicates that they are the “geistige Nachkommen Kains,” who murdered his brother. Dahl admits that the texts of both Gen 4:1 and John 8:44 are problematic and open to various interpretations and reconstructions. He is certain that the §ke›now of 8:44 refers to Cain. Indeed, his reconstruction and interpretation of John 8:31–47 makes sense out of myriad problems in the passage, including text critical (the variant readings of 8:44), grammatical (how does one explain what exactly is meant by Íme›w §k toË patrÚw toË diabÒlou §st°), and hermeneutical questions. Regarding the last, Dahl’s argument best explains the presence of disparate elements which seem odd in their context, such as particularly identifying the father of the Jews as a “murderer” or focusing on sin at 8:34 (which Dahl considers to be an allusion to Gen 4:7). Dahl corroborates his hypothesis with evidence from various sources, including the Johannine epistles.
43
your father’s desires.” Again, Jesus has set up a strict boundary line, a strict either/or: God as father vs. devil (diãbolow) as father. If the language was in any way neutral previously, Jesus now presents these Jews in such a way that the reader must consider them “outsiders,” completely opposed to the group’s ultimate values and not accidentally, but because of their very origins and essence.83 Their desire and attempt to murder him, their hatred of the truth and inability to hear Jesus’ word are inevitable given the devil as their source of being (Íme›w §k toË patrÚw toË diabÒlou), a figure whom Jesus describes as “a murderer from the beginning,” one who “has nothing to do with the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he lies, he speaks according to his own nature (§k t«n fid¤vn), for he is a liar and the father of lies” (8:44). The passage concludes with a clear distinction between insiders and outsiders, those who are “of God” (§k toË yeoË) and those who are not of God, respectively. Lest any doubt remain for the “Jews” with whom he is speaking (and presumably the reader), Jesus clearly categorizes them: §k toË yeoË oÈk §st°” (8:47). 8:48–59 continues in much the same vein and narrates the progression of the debate to the point that they try to kill him, thus proving Jesus’ insight about their very nature as murderers just like their father the devil and unlike their ancestor Abraham. Recall Garfinkel’s proposition: “Communicative work directed to transforming an individual’s total identity [defined as both the actions of the denounced and the grounds upon which the actions are based, the combination of which comprises the other as a social object] into an identity lower in the group’s scheme of social types is called a ‘status degradation ceremony.’ ” In my example, the goal is the denunciation of a “group” on a literal level, though one might argue that “the Jews” constitute a single character on the practical level. Jesus has accomplished the primary task of the denouncer, which is to prove not that these “Jews” had somehow changed, but rather that their character, as described in the passage as murderers, liars, and opponents of Jesus and God, is their essential character though it had apparently previously escaped notice. The author deploys rhetoric typical of denunciation when he uses irony to highlight the disparity between what the denounced seemed to be (those who were truly disciples who had received Jesus’ word) and what they are now 83 See Dahl, “Johannine Church,” 110–11, where Dahl treats 8:30–59 under the heading “Witnesses Before Christ.”
44
proved to be in reality (liars in whom Jesus’ word finds no place). Secondly, one sees the “redefinition of origins of the denounced” insofar as the Jews are depicted as those who have the devil as their father rather than Abraham or God. Regarding the conditions which generally must be met for a successful degradation ceremony, it is clear that the “Jews” have been “removed from the realm of their everyday character and [have been] made to stand as ‘out of the ordinary.’ ”84 Second, “the Jews” and their opposition to Jesus in the form of attempted murder and rejection of his word are presented in terms of types rather than accidents. Third, having been convinced of the typed nature of the Jews, the witnesses now think of the Jews in dialectical terms such that they cannot consider the characteristics of the Jews apart from the counter-characteristics, so that the former are further clarified in light of the latter. The Jews belong to the categories of slave (as opposed to son), slavery (as opposed to freedom), having no place for Jesus’ word (as opposed to abiding in Jesus’ word), having the devil as father (as opposed to God as father), “not of God” (as opposed to “of God,” §k yeoË), and those who have “nothing to do with the truth” (as opposed to those who “know the truth”). As the denouncer, Jesus draws attention to the witnesses’ “ultimate values,” speaks on behalf of those values, and is viewed as one who maintains those values. The presentation has been conducted in such a way that the witness, disciple, or reader has no choice but to be against “the Jews” and to identify with Jesus: “What the denouncer [ Jesus] says must be regarded by the witnesses [disciples] as true on the grounds of a socially employed metaphysics whereby witnesses assume that witnesses and denouncer are alike in essence. . . . For bona fide members it is not that these are the grounds upon which we are agreed but upon which we are alike, consubstantial, in origin the same.”85 Finally, clear boundaries have been drawn in this denunciation passage such that “the Jews” have been construed as standing opposed to the group’s “legitimate order”; they have been placed “outside” and have been made “strange.” While I have conducted the study at the narrative level, that is, the story presented of Jesus and “the Jews” ostensibly occurring ca. 30 84 85
Garfinkel, “Conditions,” 422. Ibid., 423.
45
.., my primary interest is the social context of the sectarian community for whom this Gospel was written near the end of the first century.86 If Meeks and Martyn are correct, the narrative may be seen, at least in part, as expressing the concerns of the Johannine community. In terms of the analysis above, that would lead us to replace Jesus as the denouncer with the author/leader of the community who speaks authoritatively through the text; the denounced would be the opponents from the sect’s parent community, and the “event” would be the opponents’ refusal to join the sect or, perhaps, their threat to kill sectarians. The sectarians would, of course, identify with Jesus, but it is the author, qua influential member, who occupies Jesus’ role as denouncer in the construction of the sect’s opponents as “other.” Because the passage begins by identifying the denounced not simply as “the Jews” but as “the Jews who had believed,” a case might be made that the author specifically has in mind here the denunciation of sect-defectors rather than the opponents from the parent community who had never been part of the sect. In response to that possibility I have two comments. First, there is no compelling reason to assume that the author could not achieve two purposes with one passage, and it is probable that such is the case here. Second, if one were to analyze the whole of the Fourth Gospel, one could easily make the case that a larger group of Jews is targeted than just apostates. To what pragmatic end is this status degradation enacted? Garfinkel argues that it reinforces “group solidarity” and “binds persons to the
86 Leander Keck has discussed ch. 8 in “Derivation as Destiny: ‘Of-ness’ in Johannine Christology, Anthropology, and Soteriology,” in Exploring the Gospel of John (ed. R. Alan Culpepper and C. Clifton Black; Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1996), 274–88. Keck contends that the author of the Fourth Gospel uses the preposition §k to indicate the essential “nature” of given characters in the Gospel. Of this passage he writes: This analysis of “of-ness” is confirmed in the latter half of chapter 8, which contains Jesus’ most drastic polemic against the very Jews who, despite believing in him (vv. 30, 31), nonetheless reject his promise of freedom, claiming that as Abraham’s descendants they have never been enslaved. . . . Jesus’ brutal attack (doubtless reflecting the invective of Jewish-Christian polemic against non-Christian Jews) is based on the previously noted principle that like produces like, here expressed as “like father, like son”. Consequently, of-ness implies not only the point of origin (derivation) but also the reproduction of its character. In other words, by construing of-ness as paternity, one can argue in both directions: One can infer the identity and character of the father from the behavior of the children, and one can attribute the character of the father to the children (p. 282).
46
collectivity.”87 One might add other intentions or effects: to further define boundaries for the group; to establish or maintain an “orthodoxy” so that to be a member of this group means to be unlike the denounced; to cause the group to consider the person an “outsider” so that they will eschew that person’s behavior and worldview; to motivate the denounced to leave so that the group may be purified, rid of the denounced’s influence, and brought into closer harmony and unity. Garfinkel’s work makes it reasonable to expect the sect to elevate the status of the sectarians and degrade that of the group’s opponents.88 Capitalizing on Closeness While sects are involved in the creation of something distinct from the parent tradition, they nevertheless continue to be tied to it. In Swidler’s terms, even those in unsettled lives marked by a high ideology period tacitly draw on existing cultural assumptions from the larger culture: “[A]t least at their origins, such ideological movements are not complete cultures, in the sense that much of their taken-forgranted understanding of the world and many of their daily practices still depend on traditional patterns.”89 The ongoing connection between a sect and the parent tradition need not be eschewed by the group but can serve it well. In analyzing how congregations produce the sacred, Wuthnow suggests that congregations can claim that what they do is tied to the sacred because people are culturally conditioned to expect congregations to deal with the sacred. Given a society that has traditionally associated the sacred with certain religious institutions, a congregation can take advantage of that situation by tying itself to such institutions. Historians of early Christianities readily recognize this, especially when discussing what has come to be called “The Parting of the Ways,” that is, the process by which 87
Garfinkel, “Conditions,” 421. In various ways, Garfinkel’s work is corroborated by others who have conducted analyses concerning the dynamics involved in creating an “other” and the concomitant fulmination which results. See, e.g., Sean Freyne, “Vilifying the Other and Defining the Self,” in “To See Ourselves as Others See Us: Christians, Jews, ‘Others’ in Late Antiquity” (ed. Jacob Neusner and Ernest S. Frerichs; Chico, Calif.: Scholars Press, 1985), 117–43; and Susan Harding, “Epilogue: Observing the Observers,” in Southern Baptists Observed (ed. Nancy Tatom Ammerman; Knoxville: The University of Tennessee Press, 1993), 318–37. 89 Swidler, “Culture,” 279. 88
47
Christianity became distinct from Judaism. In an unpublished paper,90 I argue that determining the date at which they could be distinguished depends upon whose perspective is presented, the pagan neighbors’, the Roman government’s, the Jews’ or the Christians’. From the perspective of the government, for instance, for some time in some places, Christians could enjoy some of the governmental benefits reserved for Jews by hanging on to the coattails of the Jews, so to speak. Viewing the Fourth Gospel as one Christian perspective, I will argue that John’s community did just what Wuthnow suggests, that is, capitalized on linking itself to Israel’s heritage, at least by its appropriation of its Scripture. Simultaneously then, the sect remains connected to the parent tradition but also tries to demonstrate its distinctiveness. One way to mark the group off is to narrate or construct an etiology of the group, celebrating its origins and grounding the community in the hoary past. Another important and consistent feature exhibited by the Qumran, Branch Davidian, and Fourth Gospel communities in their attempts to distinguish themselves from the parent traditions is the portrayal of the founders and leaders of the sects as having special insight regarding Scripture.
Creating a Distinct Way of Life Ethics and Ritual Practices A number of factors are involved in the successful invention and maintenance of a sectarian culture. Foremost is the influence that a group may exert upon its individual members. Wuthnow ascribes proper significance to the power and role of the community in shaping the individual member’s worldview: The congregation provides a crucible in which a new identity, a person undergoing change, can be molded. It also provides a manifestation of the collective journey of the sacred. This is why church leaders know the importance of corporate identity, why congregations write their histories and commemorate their anniversaries, and why they also sometimes deliberately develop conceptions of themselves as mission churches, pilgrim churches, or churches oriented toward new beginnings, 90 Jaime Clark-Soles, “Christians in Rome: Four Perspectives,” Unpublished essay, December 17, 1993.
48
rebirth, and revival. These, like our individual stories, are perhaps myths that reconstruct the past and have minimal connections to actual history, yet they play a powerful role in making the sacred concrete. They do so by making it public, visible, so it can be internalized into the consciousness of individual members.91
If these observations hold true regarding congregations, they are even more likely to apply to sectarian groups that bother intensely with such matters as marking off boundaries, shaping individual and group identity, and expressing the sacred. If it is to enjoy significance and success, a congregation must do at least the following: (a) draw individuals into “an intimate community”; (b) encourage them to worship; and (c) “provid[e] them and their children with instruction.”92 Congregations draw boundaries that mark off the sacred from the profane. I have already noted this feature in reviewing Swidler’s work, and the observation is as old as Durkheim. The boundaries may be drawn in many ways, including rituals (such as fasting or purifying oneself ), architecture (such as a discrete meeting place, stained glass), and dress (formal attire, robes). Finally, there is distinctive behavior. Wuthnow notes: “There is, however, one additional way in which the content of what is said in and by congregations is fundamentally important to their capacity to express the sacred. Congregations do not set themselves apart from everyday life simply by hiding out in strange-looking buildings; they do so even more basically by saying strange things and doing strange things.”93 This saying and doing strange things comprises “ethics” and “ritual practice.” A group distinguishes itself by the principles that are preached and practiced. In a high-ideology period of a group, this group might be expected to delineate clearly the rules by which the members should abide, Swidler’s example of “wearing orange,” as it were. Often these rules address purity issues and, indeed, all three groups studied in this work express some interest in purity or cleanliness. As representatives of “unsettled lives,” sects might also be expected to focus attention on ritual practice. Of course, “ethics” and “ritual practice” overlap and they are to be separated only for heuristic purposes. Under “ritual” we might reasonably expect to find concern for worship, study and instruction, special meals, and methods of purification. 91 92 93
Wuthnow, Producing, 61. Ibid., 40. Ibid., 58.
49
Language and Rhetoric Boundary formation takes place in numerous ways, one of which Wuthnow labels “cultural exclusion.” This refers to the process whereby the group rids itself of individuals who do not conform to the group by making them feel uncomfortable or unwelcome (so, as we shall see, John deals harshly with the so-called “crypto-Christians”). For religious groups “to have any distinct identity you have to have boundaries, buttressing the scarcity of their valued goods by limiting access to them.”94 I will ask what those goods would have been in the Branch Davidian, Qumran, and Johannine communities (presumably, “salvation” at the very least). An Ivy League degree is valuable not only because it has been defined as “good” but especially because access to it has been limited. How can a religious group weed out those who make the community less desirable? It takes the cooperation of the group around the preacher to effect boundary formation; the preacher cannot achieve that alone. One element of boundary construction has to do with the presentation of beliefs wherein boundaries are set by making the belief system one that is not accessible to everyone. This may be done by the group’s claim to maintain unique beliefs while simultaneously not definitively delineating those beliefs. Additionally, the group may pepper its presentation “with references to esoteric, historical, philosophical, and theological sources of wisdom.”95 Esoterica and irony would fit well here.96 At the more detailed level, Wuthnow only very occasionally signals the significance of the language by which a group communicates. He makes the following important comment only in passing: “The special advantage of congregations, especially in the high church or liturgical traditions (and at the extreme fundamentalist end of the theological spectrum), is that they can speak largely in the distinctive language of their own subculture and do so with the authority of specialists who know this language well.”97 Relevant to a consideration of the power of language, Wuthnow suggests that any effective religion must use what he calls a “language” based on tradition, narrative, and conviction, a weighty triumvirate. As noted above, the Fourth Gospel concerns itself with tradition, both that of Israel and 94 95 96 97
Ibid., 38. Ibid., 37. See Duke, Irony. Wuthnow, Producing, 101.
50
that of the earliest Jesus movement. That the Fourth Gospel worries about conviction will become readily apparent when I treat the problem of sect-defectors. Of tradition, conviction, and narrative, Wuthnow’s presentation of the essentialness and almost inevitability of narrative commands attention: [Narrative’s] fundamental characteristic is the unfolding of events according to a temporal sequence. Narrative is thus especially well suited for connecting moral prescriptions with tradition. Narrative also tends to be self contained; it employs a high degree of intratextuality or selfreferencing. As such it is not easily disconfirmed by outside events or alternative stories. Understanding the narrative requires the listener to enter into its own internal logic. Narrative also invites this sort of identification between the listener and characters in the story. Whether there is true intersubjectivity between the subject and the text or not, the text suggests there is.98
During this investigation of the Fourth Gospel it is important to remember that the use of Scripture appears in the context of a narrative; in a sense it is a language within a language, a code within a code. When Wuthnow grants narrative, stories, and myth “a powerful role in making the sacred concrete,”99 he reminds us that the “literary” and the “social” are not discrete realms. In analyzing a Christian fundamentalist sermon preached in 1986 entitled “The Meaning of Life,” Marsha Witten has made a brief foray into ways by which narrative may be used in religious discourse. She seeks to “discover the conditions that make behaviors meaningful,”100 rather than trying to determine the meaning itself of worship practices and religious talk for participants, convinced that the latter remains impossible. Studying the “context and form of the practices and discourse,”101 however, does yield results, whether one works at the level of institutional contexts or at what she calls the “microscopic level,” studying the “internal structure or the practice of discourse itself.”102 Witten envisions her project thus: My concern here is not with what the sermon means, but with the way in which the structure of the information it presents makes its messages meaningful, delimiting and disambiguating the messages it communicates. In other words, I explore how the text exploits what 98 99 100 101 102
Ibid., 164. Ibid., 61. Witten, “Restriction,” 19. Ibid. Ibid.
51
Northrop Frye (1982) would term its ‘centripetal tendency’: structures of information that turn in on themselves, close meaning down, license or authorize a particular set of messages, discourage plural readings. To do so, I examine features in and among the narratives in the text that create a tight structural coherence, a relatively ‘airless’ textual space, that present the sermon as a hermetic entity, a self-reinforcing utterance. Although this paper is devoted to the analysis of one sermon in depth, the method I display here would seem to offer much promise for the systematic, comparative study of the degree of disambiguation in religious texts in general.103
Witten argues that three mechanisms in the story form provide interpretive closure: compactness, coherence, and redundancy of communicative structures. The particular sermon she analyzes contains thirteen narratives. She isolates the following narrative, the “Seneca” story, as an example of a high degree of compactness: (1) Maybe it’s knowledge [that is the answer to the question of life]. (2) Maybe that [sic] why we go to college is because we need more answers. (3) We go to seminars in our jobs all the time to gain more knowledge because that’s going to fulfill life. (4) Seneca, a great philosopher and scholar, believed that. (5) He believed that if you gained enough knowledge that all the immoral things of life would go away, that peace would be attained on earth, that fulfillment would be found. (6) And he quested for knowledge and he gained knowledge and he found that his life became more immoral, that there became more violence, and he ended up committing suicide because he didn’t have any answers. (7) Because knowledge does not contain answers to the real life questions.
The story itself, which comprises sentences 4–6, exhibits an almost completely non-digressive character. There is only one character in the story and his character is summarized by two attributes: he is a scholar and a philosopher. The entirety of his search for truth occupies only three sentences. No setting is given. The narrative essentially races to the story’s outcome, Seneca’s demise. In narrating the story with such compactness, the preacher prohibits digressive gaps that might allow for alternative interpretations. The story also shows the power of coherence to delimit meaning. Here Witten is concerned to show the degree of “connectedness” exhibited by the stories, including both lexical and grammatical connections. Synonyms, word repetitions, or collocations (“words related either by membership in the same class or through opposition”) come under lexical connections, whereas grammatical connections include 103
Ibid., 19–20.
52
such phenomena as pronouns, comparative references, conjunctions, or ellipses. Using a system that involves calculating the ratio of the possible number of linkages to the actual number, she finds that the stories in the sermon, including the “Seneca” story, enjoy an unusually high degree of connectedness which, combined with compactness, contributes to tight restriction of meaning. Witten then explores the element of redundancy in the sermon. Within this discussion, she attends to redundancy at the level of story (so the stories in the sermon tend to have the same elements), narrative discourse (often the commentary itself has a redundant structure), and, finally, at the meta-level (where the commentary on the story either always affirms, negates, or remains neutral with respect to the story). I will attend more closely to Witten’s discussion of redundancy when I analyze the Fourth Gospel. Sacred Texts Sacred texts provide a ready tool for cultivating a sense of group cohesion because by definition they form an unquestioned authoritative center for all groups which use them. Certainly this principle obtains in the Qumran, Branch Davidian, and Johannine communities. Although sociologists have studied sects and their opponents, sacred texts and authors have traditionally remained outside the purview of sociology, which tends to deal with groups, not individuals, and people, not texts, certainly unfortunate bifurcations. Occasional observations regarding authors or preachers appear, as when Weber or Bainbridge speaks of charismatic leaders, but remain largely absent. The same is true of Scripture. Bainbridge offers the one observation discussed above, but the fact that he lists the charismatic leaders and holy Scripture separately indicates that he does not consider the use of holy Scripture by the charismatic leader. If even this basic question has not been addressed, we can be sure that more nuanced distinctions have not been pondered. The influence and interplay of Scripture and interpreter for the sake of a community will occupy the remainder of this work, and it is hoped that upon its completion some useful conclusions might be rendered.104 104 Swidler writes the following not about cultures as unified wholes but about what she calls “chunks of culture” and their history: Particular cultural resources can be integrated, however, into quite different strategies of action. A crucial task for research is to understand how cultural
53
My interest in Scripture’s role in maintaining a sect responds, in part, to Swidler’s call: “[S]ociologists should search for new analytic perspectives that will allow more effective concrete analyses of how culture is used by actors, how cultural elements constrain or facilitate patterns of action, what aspects of a cultural heritage have enduring effects on action, and what specific historical changes undermine the vitality of some cultural patterns and give rise to others.”105 Role of Authoritative Leaders Sociologists of cultural production remind us to consider the producer. In the case of the artist, the sociologist asks what kind of training the artist had; who funded the training; who provided the program of training; what kind of materials were at the artist’s disposal; who commissioned the piece; how the artist came to the attention of the commissioner; and how these social factors influence the content of the work. The artist and preacher can be distinguished from one another insofar as the former is expected to be original and inventive whereas the latter is expected to enact the sacred rather than produce it. Nonetheless, both the artist and preacher are intentional and deliberate, striving to achieve a particular goal in their production. Where the author is innovative, it is appropriate to ask what factors precipitated innovation, how various innovations may have competed with one another, why some appealed more than others, and, finally, how what was once innovative becomes the norm. One of Wuthnow’s important observations that I keep in mind in my analysis is the fact that “cultural production results in products and by-products, that is, intended results and unintended results.106 . . . In both cases capacities created in one historical context are reappropriated and altered in new circumstances. . . . The significance of specific cultural symbols can be understood only in relation to the strategies of action they sustain. Culture does not influence how groups organize action via enduring psychological proclivities implanted in individuals by their socialization. Instead, publicly available meanings facilitate certain patterns of action, making them readily available, while discouraging others (p. 283). My analysis of the reappropriation of the “chunk of culture” known as Scripture relates its significance to the strategies of action which it sustains, such as the formation and maintenance of a sectarian lifestyle and worldview. 105 Ibid. 106 This phenomenon is readily recognized by reader-response critics, not to mention by preachers who find that parishioners sometimes “hear” something in a sermon that (a) was not actually there or (b) was there, to the complete surprise of the preacher.
54
resources are expended and social circumstances influence what happens.”107 All of this leads us to make the following two suggestions about the communities studied in the present work. First, whether or not the audience realizes it or cares, John, David Koresh, and the Qumran authors worked intentionally to achieve certain ends for certain audiences. Second, any serious study of the use of Scripture in the texts of these communities must take social circumstances into account. Definition of the Future Sects require great sacrifice from their members by asking them to abandon the comfort of “settled lives” and join the group. Because they demand much, they must promise much. Why should people enlist? What do they gain? What is the telos toward which the sacrifice is directed? Groups may respond variously, one with a vision for a better present world, another with a vision of an end to an earthly world. Many promise “salvation” and some variety of future glory for adherents of the sect. Whether the three communities under study do so will be addressed when each is taken up in turn. To summarize, I expect successful maintenance of sects to involve attention to ethical norms; ritual practice; the use of language and rhetoric to effect inclusion or exclusion; the authoritative roles played by the leader and by Scripture; and eschatology.
Opposition from within the Sect Because sects demand so much, they often experience a high rate of attrition. Leaders address this problem by: (1) rewarding adherence to the sect and (2) castigating potential and actual deserters.
Opposition from Without By definition, a sect stands in opposition to its larger social environment. Opposition between the sect and the parent tradition from which it stems was treated earlier, but often the sect will find itself 107
Wuthnow, Producing, 27.
55
opposed to the larger culture which stands outside the parent tradition. The Qumran community, for example, reveals tensions not only with the parent tradition, temple-based Judaism, but also the Romans. The Branch Davidian group opposes the Seventh-Day Adventist Church as well as the rest of Christianity and secular American culture, including the government. Sects will sometimes label these non-parent, non-sectarian opponents “the world.”
Judgment against Opponents Once the group has exactly defined its opponents, pronouncing judgment upon them solidifies group cohesion. It serves as the corollary to rewarding faithful sectarians. Rewards and judgments can take both concrete and intangible forms; a leader might insist that faithful members will enjoy earthly material prosperity and the opponents scarcity of some sort, or that faithful members will enjoy a beatific heavenly eternal afterlife and the opponents a ghastly, agonizing eternal afterlife. Apocalyptic sects are particularly drawn to this technique.
Growing the Sect To ensure its ongoing vitality, one would expect a leader to worry about enlisting new members through proselytizing. Yet another way in which Swidler’s argument about culture and action is useful for studying the Fourth Gospel has to do with the apparent hesitance of some, represented by Nicodemus and the blind man’s parents, to join John’s community. Swidler observes that those in settled lives “do not readily take advantage of new structural opportunities which would require them to abandon established ways of life. This is not because they cling to cultural values [as the traditional Weberian argument contends], but because they are reluctant to abandon familiar strategies of action for which they have the cultural equipment.”108 Further:
108
Swidler, “Culture,” 281.
56
Within established modes of life, culture provides a repertoire of capacities from which varying strategies of action may be constructed. Thus culture appears to shape action only in that the cultural repertoire limits the available range of strategies of action. Such “settled cultures” are nonetheless constraining. Although internally diverse and often contradictory, they provide the ritual traditions that regulate ordinary patterns of authority and cooperation, and they so define common sense that alternative ways of organizing action seem unimaginable, or at least implausible. Settled cultures constrain action over time because of the high costs of cultural retooling to adopt new patterns of action.109
These observations of Swidler’s generate questions about both potential recruitment to the sect and the ability to retain devotees. In addition to growing the sect through proselytes, I would expect the leaders to express concern for raising up the next generation of sectarians through special instruction for the children of the sect.
Excursus: A History of Church and Sect Anyone undertaking a study of sectarianism must contend with some of the older typologies, which still haunt and hinder students of sectarianism, especially the “sect-church” and “sect-cult” debates. Indeed, one scholar goes so far as to say: “Perhaps the cornerstone of the sociology of religion is church-sect theory. . . .”110 Because the history and legacy of the church-sect typology is usually rehearsed by any serious scholar undertaking a discussion of the sociology of sectarianism and is therefore readily available to the especially interested reader, the recapitulation of the subject here is brief. The scholarly debate over church and sect began with Max Weber and Ernst Troeltsch, and has been continued at least by Niebuhr, Benton Johnson, Bryan Wilson, Laurence Iannaccone, and William Sims Bainbridge. Weber contrasted church and sect, describing the former as inclusive and the latter as exclusive. Troeltsch expanded this characterization, noting that the church is bureaucratic, conforms to society, and appeals to the upper classes whereas sects are small, ascetic, countercultural, non-bureaucratic, and consist of members who are devoted, close, and primarily lower class. While aware of the culturally conditioned nature of Troeltsch’s proposed typology, 109 110
Ibid., 284. Bainbridge, Sociology, 38.
57
some scholars consider it still generally relevant. Accordingly, Wilson characterizes Christian sects as follows: (1) They tend to be exclusive, in the sense that they do not admit of dual allegiances: a sectarian is committed to only one body of religious teaching, and has only one membership. (2) Sects tend to claim that they have a monopoly of the complete religious truth, which others do not enjoy. This truth provides the framework for all aspects of belief, religious worship, social practice, ethics, politics, and all areas of human affairs; it may also embrace an understanding of the natural world, and the purposes and order that are thought to underlie the universe. (3) Sects also tend to be lay organizations. They may develop a body of professional functionaries and organizers, but they are generally anti-sacerdotal. This is implicit in the assumption that is made by sectarians that all men have some equal possibility of access to the truth. That such an assumption should so often be apparent in the operations of sects arises from the need of the inspirators of these movements to legitimize their own departure from prevailing orthodoxy—an orthodoxy warranted and sustained by the claims of a priestly class. (4) As far as specifically religious practice goes, sects tend to reject the religious division of labour, and to deny special religious virtuosity to anyone, except, in some cases, to their own founders and leaders. Religious obligations are equal obligations for all “those who accept the truth” (as sects frequently define their own members). (5) It is thus implicit that sects are marked by voluntarism. An individual chooses to be a sectarian, and he is normally required to show some mark of merit (by knowledge of doctrine; quality of life; the recommendation of members in good standing; initiations or ritual performances; and so on) in order to be accepted as a member. (6) In conformity with this last requirement, sects exercise concern for sustained standards among their members, and it is usually the case that they exercise sanctions against the inadequate or wayward, to the point of expelling such individuals from the sect. (7) Sects tend to demand total allegiance. The member of any of the conventional churches in western countries may not appear in his everyday life to be very different from other religiously-uncommitted, or completely secular, men in his life-style, morals, interest, and leisure-time pursuits. This is not true of the sectarian—he is marked emphatically by his religious allegiance, which is expected to be evident in its influence on all areas of his life. The fact that a man is a member of such-and-such a group— a Mormon, a Seventh-day Adventist, or one of Jehovah’s Witnesses— is in itself the single most important fact about him, telling one more of what to expect of him than any other piece of information pertaining to him. (8) Finally, the sect is a protest group.111 111 Bryan R. Wilson, Religion in Sociological Perspective (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1982), 91–92.
58
H. Richard Niebuhr argued that sects naturally evolve into denominations after one generation, implying that the former, in effect, compromise or “sell out.” Like Troeltsch’s, Niebuhr’s model was overly conditioned by a particular era (turn of the century), location (United States), and religion (Christianity). Additionally, instead of recognizing that there may be more than one type of sect and, therefore, that one evolutionary model is insufficient, he assumed that all sects develop in the same way. Benton Johnson criticized the judgmental attitudes of Niebuhr and Wilson regarding sects that assimilate and exhorted sociologists to leave their own “baggage” out of the discussion, to “keep their sociology in isolation from their other passions.”112 Positively, Johnson attempted to improve upon the typologies of Troeltsch and Weber so that they might enjoy a wider applicability, indeed one that could account for Jewish, Christian, and Islamic traditions.113 Probably the most influential and prolific sociologist of sectarianism, Bryan Wilson has covered a lengthy period in his work. Precisely because he resists dogmatic confidence in typologies or models of sectarianism and, for that matter, the sociology of religion itself, Wilson provides some of the most useful material. He himself intended to construct a typology less determined by post-Reformation Christian sects, one broad enough to include non-Christian, non-western, nonindustrialized contexts. That fact, combined with his use of a comparative approach, makes him particularly interesting and important for the present project. He avoids the earlier theorists’ tendency to define a group based on either organization or doctrine since both of those categories were unduly dictated by Christianity; instead, he suggests and outlines various “responses to the world” evinced by sectarian groups. His own particular interests lie in how groups address and propose to overcome the problem of evil through some scheme of “salvation.” Over the years he has unabashedly revised the typology that he first presented in 1959. In one of its later recensions it comprised the following seven “responses to the world”:114 1. The conversionist response to the world holds that the world is corrupt because people are corrupt and seeks a “supernaturally 112
Benton Johnson, “Church and Sect Revisited,” JSSR 10 (1971): 137. Benton Johnson, “On Church and Sect,” American Sociological Review 28 (1963): 539. 114 For a fuller presentation, see Bryan R. Wilson, Magic and the Millennium (New York: Harper & Row, 1973), 22–30. 113
59
wrought transformation of the self ” which allows a “new subjective orientation,” a transcendence over the evil apparent in the world.115 This new posture vis-à-vis the world constitutes salvation and, while it may include a future element, the focus is on salvation now. 2. The revolutionist response insists that the only cure for the evil that exists is the destruction of the contemporary natural and social world; while the faithful may be called to play some small role, it is primarily a divine endeavor, to be executed imminently. Salvation is in the immediate future. 3. The introversionist response views the world as entirely evil and teaches withdrawal from and renunciation of the world as the only means of salvation. The community separates itself from the larger society and worries intently about maintaining holiness. Though ideologically the attainment of salvation is located in the future, “salvation is sociologically a present endeavour”116 and is reserved only for members of the group. 4. The manipulationist response contends that salvation depends upon the mastery of religious precepts that allow one to see the world differently. Salvation comprises health, wealth, happiness, and high status. “Whilst it is the subjective orientation which must be changed, the objective world will be brought into harmony with this new perception and manipulated by it.”117 5. The thaumaturgical response focuses on the cure of very specific afflictions, such as illness, grief, fear, and death. Escape from them constitutes salvation and that salvation is wrought through miracles and oracles. 6. The reformist response seeks to reform the world under the guidance and direction of the divine as revealed to those “whose hearts and minds are open to supernatural influence.”118 According to Wilson, this response may externally resemble rational secular approaches using the same techniques toward similar ends. It maintains that people will be responsible for changing the world, but only at the behest and demand of the divine. Because the position accommodates the world to a significant degree, its convictions about salvation are less gripping and, therefore, it experiences less intense allegiance than the other responses. 115 116 117 118
Ibid., 22. Ibid., 24. Ibid. Ibid., 25.
60
7. The utopian response seeks to remodel the world in accordance with the divine economy and reconstitute society in a way that eradicates evil. It does not imagine an apocalyptic cataclysmic event on the part of the divine, but rather envisages human energy accomplishing the divinely assigned task.119 Wilson is careful to warn that his typology (or anyone else’s) should not be treated as a final, complete, thoroughly accomplished scheme that may be universally applied and expected to render a full characterization of any given group. It is unfortunate that Wilson himself has never applied his expertise to ancient groups. One shortcoming of Wilson’s work lies in the fact that, while earlier scholars of the Fourth Gospel may have focused too narrowly on ideology (in the form of theology, Christology, soteriology) and assumed too close a connection between that ideology and the probable social realities related to the group, Wilson himself may leave too little room for any causal connection between ideology and social reality.120 Typology finally gave way to theory in the work of Laurence Iannaccone, who attempted to base his analysis of church and sect on empirical evidence and has employed an economic model, thus lending to the subject the status associated with theory and mathematical analysis. After reviewing charts, graphs, and statistics largely impenetrable to the nonspecialist, one arrives at Iannaccone’s conclusions about church and sect. Churches are moderate with respect to social norms whereas sects are extreme. Sects create two classes, “members (or ‘true believers’), who fully embrace the sect norms while rejecting the society’s, and nonmembers (both ‘heathen’ and 119
This model replaces that presented in “An Analysis of Sect Development,” American Sociological Review 24 (1959): 3–15, where Wilson posited four types of sects: conversionist, gnostic, introversionist, and adventist. Explaining his decision, he writes: “In that endeavor [i.e., that undertaken in Magic and the Millennium], I found it necessary to abandon the rigorous application of sub-types of sect in favour of ‘responses to the world,’ since this type construct did not carry with it the demand for, for example, either exclusivity or the particular assumptions about organization that are built into the concept of the sect as such.” Wilson, Religion, 103. 120 Indeed, he admits having had such criticism lodged against him, but offers only the following rather unrepentant reply: “Obviously response is affected by teachings and doctrine (where something answering to that designation exists), but it is recognizable in groups in which formal teaching is inchoate or incoherent. . . . Ideology, as formally expressed in sect teachings, can become ossified and insensitive to social realities that are expressed by other media and at other levels within a movement. While by no means ignoring the importance of conscious ideologies, this specific item by which ideal types of sect may be distinguished is not confined to ideological concerns.” Wilson, Magic, 20.
61
‘heretics’), who reject the sect and are in turn rejected by it.”121 In contrast to churches, where mobility is not a noteworthy feature, the sect’s grasp on new converts is tentative and apostasy is common. Sect membership is more homogenous than church membership, and sects exhibit a stability in the event of social change that the church does not, given its tendency to accommodate to changing society.122 Because they demand more from their members than do churches, sects have to offer more to their members. Furthermore, because the sect requires rejection of the secular society, it must provide an alternative society. “It cannot merely exhort its members to sell all they have; it must also provide them with everything they need.”123 The sect provides not only such mundane necessities as food and shelter, but also intangible rewards such as friendship and status. Sects tend to attract those who do not have much to lose by forfeiting ties with traditional society (unlike, say, a Nicodemus), so they often appeal to the poor, the uneducated, and those who have limited secular opportunities, such as women and minorities. Bainbridge renders the most cogent presentation of past typologies of sects and a newer, perhaps more sophisticated argument that seeks to operate at the level of theory.124 He begins by presenting three hallowed notions maintained by sociologists of sectarianism: first, the group’s religious beliefs and practices largely stand in continuity with the mainstream groups of its society but tend to be more intense; second, sects overrecruit from the poor and uneducated; and third, sects emerge from denominational schism. The problem with the third notion is that it envisions a rather abrupt, definitive break as the only way a sect might form. But not all groups conform to such a scheme. For example, according to Bainbridge: “Adventist movements seem generally to begin not in the schism of a denomination into two or more parts, although that did occur in the recent history of the Branch Davidians, but in rather more subtle processes that take place within a diffuse Adventist cultural system.”125 121 Laurence R. Iannaccone, “A Formal Model of Church and Sect,” American Journal of Sociology 94 (1988): S257. 122 Thus, Iannaccone’s findings contradict Niebuhr’s claim that sects evolve into denominations. Ibid., S258. 123 Ibid., S259. 124 Bainbridge, Sociology. Bainbridge has worked closely and prolifically with Rodney Stark for many years, and this most recent work draws heavily upon that previous work, especially their well-known A Theory of Religion (New York: Lang, 1987) and The Future of Religion (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1985), inter alia. 125 Bainbridge, Sociology, 117.
62
Like Wilson, Bainbridge notes a number of problems with the church-sect typology as initially defined by Ernst Troeltsch. First, by “church” what is meant is an established church, a church recognized by the society and the state as “the” church. Such a model applies neither to modern industrial nations, which by and large have no national church; nor to first-century Palestinian Judaism, which operated under occupation; nor to Diaspora Judaism, which lived under pagan rule; nor to first-century Christianity as reflected in the . The concept denoted by “sect” in this scheme fares no better because many sects do not evidence all of the features described by the ideal type. Recall that Benton Johnson sought to modify Troelstch’s typology to achieve wider application. Rather than attempting to reform the typology, Bainbridge prefers to discard that model and focus instead on Johnson’s observation about “degrees of tension” that exist between a religious group and its social environment, with low-tension denominations on the one end and high-tension sects on the other. “A religious group might be found at any point along this dimension, and over time it may move a significant distance, either increasing or decreasing its relative tension with the surrounding sociocultural environment.”126 The church-sect typology has run its course of usefulness. Sociology of sectarianism has become more sophisticated, trying to move away from the level of impression and sheer particularism toward the level of theory. Instead of defining “sect” as merely a deviant form of “church,” scholars are focusing on sects in the absolute. Bainbridge’s work, though somewhat reductionistic and overdetermined by economic theories, serves as a guide for us as we approach sects in terms of levels of tension rather than a rigid checklist of necessary features. Sect-Cult Distinctions Sect-church typology is no longer compelling. As indicated early in this chapter, however, if used cautiously the sect-cult distinction can help us to differentiate between those schismatic groups that break away from a parent tradition and non-schismatic innovative groups that arise in a society or are imported to it from an alien culture. 126 Ibid., 41. This proposition accounts both for the Johannine community’s moving relatively quickly from the high-tension position vis-à-vis its social environs to the lower-tension position reflected in the Johannine epistles and for the fact that the Branch Davidians and Qumran community did not, though all evidence sectarian characteristics.
63
The former comprise “sects” and the latter, “cults” (or “NRMs—new religious movements”127 as specialists now commonly refer to them in an attempt to avoid the pejorative sense associated with the word “cult”). It is the case that the method of emergence, the social composition, and the dynamics of the two kinds of group generally differ so that such labels serve as a shorthand for expressing what one should expect from a group. The problem lies in the paradigm’s inability to account for the many groups that do not fit neatly into the paradigm, those that are marked by both schism and innovation, as we shall see at least when we study the Branch Davidians, an Adventist group. Like Bainbridge, I want “to get beyond sectcult thinking,”128 and rely instead on his “levels of tension” approach, which is more broad and more specific than either traditional “sectchurch” or “sect-cult” typologies. Why Label the Group? What is the benefit of trying to understand what kind of social group the Fourth Gospel represents? Why not stick merely to defining what kind of theology (including soteriology, Christology, ecclesiology) the group represents? In a sense, to ask what kind of social group the Fourth Gospel represents using the insights of the sociology of religion is to take the Fourth Gospel’s own incarnational theology more seriously than theologians themselves have in rendering disembodied analyses. My objective is no more ambitious than to know and understand this first-century community more accurately, and, perhaps as a by-product, to know and understand those of Qumran and the Branch Davidians better. If it is the case that any or all of the groups are “sects,” then I should be able to make some predictions about what I expect to find. As I have noted, the dynamics involved in the formation and maintenance of a sect differ greatly from those of a “novel religious movement,” a “denomination,” or, if Wilson is correct, even another sect. Using the scholars discussed above, especially Swidler, Wuthnow, Wilson, Bainbridge, and Garfinkel as a springboard, our constructive task lies in positing a taxonomy that might help both scholars and sociologists of religion analyze 127 Rodney Stark prefers to call them “novel” rather than “new” religious movements because sects are also “new” in some sense while not being “novel.” See Bainbridge, Sociology, 24. 128 Ibid., 107.
64
the social function(s) served by an author’s or community’s deployment of Scripture, a task that has been undertaken by neither group of scholars. If it is possible to theorize about the nature of various religious groups (sects, NRMs, denominations), apply the theory to actual groups, modify the theory based on particular studies, and use the more refined theory to undertake a new particular study, why should it not be possible to do the same thing for the ways in which various religious groups use their sacred texts to achieve their goals? Should one place exceeding confidence in the theories, typologies, and taxonomies composed by the above scholars or by the present author? Should one envision them as ends in themselves, definitive, solidified categories that exist in order to force elements into them and, having done so, consider oneself to have “explained” something? Indeed not. All of Wilson’s insights regarding the purpose, advantages, and limitations of constructing ideal types should be assumed by the reader: The point of type construction is to delineate a probable and expectable constellation of related features and logical relationships and sequences, and, by comparing the type with actual phenomena, to become aware of the issues that stand in need of explanation. All actual empirical cases diverge from the ideal type, but there must clearly be a limit to such divergence, a point beyond which the cases cannot usefully be analysed by using the type as the appropriate measuring rod, simply because the case is too discrepant. One might say, a point at which the case concerned cannot be appropriately called a ‘sect’, and thus cannot be usefully analysed in the terms we have carefully devised as being specifically appropriate for the analysis of sects. . . . The question of whether a particular movement may or may not properly be called a ‘sect’ is in itself of relatively little interest; the question that matters is the appropriate tools for analysis. . . . [Ideal types] are essential tools, and their purpose is not one of classification. Typeconstructs are not intended simply to allow us to designate classes of phenomena: they are to indicate, as we have said, the expectable logic of the social arrangements of a given genus of phenomena. It is a futile occupation to spend time on deciding whether a particular movement should be called a ‘sect’ or not. Ideal types are not empty boxes into which the sociologist drops appropriate cases; they are, rather, to be used to make us aware of the specific historical, organizational, compositional, or other features of a sect that depart from our hypothetical system of logical relationships. The type should always turn us back to historical or empirical data so that we can explain those features of a case that contradict our hypothesized common-sense assumptions.129 129
Wilson, Religion, 104–5.
65
Conclusion Having elaborated on its various elements, I refer again to the chart on page 24, which will provide a taxonomy for presenting the research into the uses of Scripture by each of the three examined groups. When Swidler writes: “Strategies of action are cultural products; the symbolic experiences, mythic lore, and ritual practices of a group or society create moods and motivations, ways of organizing experience and evaluating reality, modes of regulating conduct, and ways of forming social bonds, which provide resources for constructing strategies of action,”130 she approximates my interest in what social effect John’s use of one element of culture, Scripture, has on his community.
130
Swidler, “Culture,” 284.
CHAPTER THREE
THE QUMRAN COMMUNITY Cultural history requires us to take seriously the forms by which a culture transmits its knowledge, and thereby shapes its members’ competencies and self-conceptions. As Roger Chartier asks: “How are we to understand the ways in which the form that transmits a text to its readers or hearers constrains the production of its meaning? The appropriation of discourse is not something that happens without rules or limits. Writing deploys strategies that are meant to produce effects, dictate a posture, and oblige the reader. . . . If we want to understand the appropriations and interpretations of a text in their full historicity, we need to identify the effects in terms of meaning that its material forms produced.” Stephen Fraade, “Looking for Legal Midrash at Qumran”
Why Qumran? Like that of the Fourth Gospel, the community of the Dead Sea Scrolls has come to be regarded as a sect in the sociological sense.1 That is to say, both developed out of conflict with a parent tradition, both represent “an intense form of a standard religious tradition,”2 and both engaged certain strategies of action that maintained or increased tension with the parent tradition. Unlike the Johannine community, which left behind only meager proof of its existence in the form of the Fourth Gospel and the Johannine Epistles, the Qumran community has bequeathed to its students a veritable literary goldmine in addition to archaeological evidence. The present task involves understanding how the use of Scripture at Qumran may have contributed to the formation and maintenance of the sect. Because much more is known 1 2
For an introduction to Jewish sectarianism, see Cohen, Maccabees to Mishnah, 124–73. Bainbridge, Sociology, 24.
67
about the sect at Qumran, the study of its scriptural use may by analogy and comparison yield insight into the community of the Fourth Gospel.3
The Origins of the Sect In his article, “The Prehistory of the Qumran Community,”4 Philip R. Davies depicts the history of research regarding the origins of the Qumran community as a drama in three scenes. The first scene finds scholars suggesting that the Qumran community emerged in the midsecond century ... as a result of opposition between a pro-Zadokite group and the Hasmonean high priest. According to the theory, the pro-Zadokite group consisted of so-called Hasidim who had been antiAntiochus Epiphanes. As a result of the conflict with the “wicked” high priest, the Teacher of Righteousness, who was the leader of the Hasidim, withdrew to Qumran with his disciples and formed a sect, the Essenes. From there, Essenism spread throughout Palestine, with Qumran serving as locus of authority for the movement.5 Those Hasidim who spurned the Teacher of Righteousness became the Pharisees. Such a reconstruction equates the Essenes (attested to by Josephus) with the Qumran community. It depends primarily upon Pesher Habakkuk for corroboration, takes what is found there at face value, and fills in the gaps with a harmonizing approach to CD and archaeology.6 The second scene, according to Davies, features scholars who both pay more attention to the prehistory of the Qumran sect and employ a more sophisticated methodology than earlier scholars, a methodology grounded in literary criticism. Acting in this second scene are 3 Richard Hays indicates the appropriateness of such comparison when he writes: “Rabbinic Judaism, no less than early Christianity, represents (along with the Qumran community and Philo’s scholastic Alexandrian Judaism, inter alia), one of several different adaptations of the religious and cultural heritage represented by Israel’s Scriptures.” Richard B. Hays, Echoes of Scripture in the Letters of Paul (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1989), 11. The same could be said of the Qumran and Branch Davidian communities, though the latter does not have the advantage of prestige bestowed upon the hoary. Comparative analysis reveals what the possibilities were and are for treating the . 4 Philip R. Davies, “The Prehistory of the Qumran Community,” in The Dead Sea Scrolls: Forty Years of Research (ed. Devorah Dimant and Uriel Rappaport; Leiden: Brill, 1992), 116–25. 5 Ibid., 116. 6 Ibid., 117.
68
scholars such as G. Jeremias, H. Stegemann, and J. Murphy-O’Connor, who have noticed discrepancies concerning the history of the sect not only within CD itself but also between CD and other Qumran literature. CD reveals no “wicked priest,” reflects a different ideology and community formation than 1QS reflects, and a different history of sect formation than the pesharim. This has led them to argue that CD reflects the stage of the community before the arrival of the Teacher of Righteousness, whether that pre-Qumran phase might be described as Hasidic (Stegemann) or Essenic (MurphyO’Connor).7 In this construal, the Teacher of Righteousness arrived after the group or movement was established and caused division that resulted in the withdrawal of his followers to the Dead Sea while the rest of the Essenes remained throughout Palestine. This school attributes the origin of the Essenes to sometime between the exile and the first half of the second-century ... Davies critiques the first two scenes and suggests a way forward to the third scene: The third alternative, which of course is the only alternative, is to take the conclusions generated by such literary-critical studies as we have (of the Community Rule, the Damascus Document and the War Scroll in particular) which raise important questions about the ideology and history of Qumran literature—and try to verify or falsify them by looking at other texts from Qumran, looking again at the other ancient sources, and at the archeological data from Qumran—and, most of all, testing the implication.8
Having done so, Davies himself finds at least two communities reflected in the scrolls. The first and earliest community was a group of Essenes, and the second he designates as the yahad depicted in 1QS. He considers the Essenes the “parent movement”9 and the yahad one of its offspring. The earlier community may have developed at any time from the exile on, and its interests and nature are reflected in 11QT, CD, Jubilees, and perhaps 4QMMT and parts of 1 Enoch. The later yahad of Qumran adopted CD and these other texts much in the same way as Christians did the .10 Anyone who undertakes a brief sketch of the origins of the Qumran community or commu7
Ibid., 118. Ibid., 119. 9 Ibid., 121. 10 Ibid. Davies’ statement, of course, is a bit too simplistic, but the analogy serves its purpose. 8
69
nities must agree with Davies’ observation: “I suggest that few scholars—even including Qumran specialists—realize the extent to which the whole question of origins is now without consensus.”11 A perennial problem when dealing with the extant texts as evidence for the community at Qumran lies in designating which texts discovered in the caves were composed by the community and which were merely brought there or brought and edited. Regardless of the group’s origins or whether the texts studied in this chapter originated from the group with which it has become associated, this study will presume that the so-called “sectarian documents,” including the pesharim, 1QS, CD, and 4QMMT, discovered at the Dead Sea reflect the nature of the sectarian community that dwelled there and preserved the manuscripts.
The Evidence from Qumran In an investigation concerning the social history of the community, students of Qumran fare better than do their Fourth Gospel counterparts, for not only do they have archaeological remains, but also a vast library upon which to draw.12 Customarily scholars divide the Qumran literature into biblical and non-biblical, the former denoting actual biblical texts and the latter comprising all else. Many of the non-biblical texts are saturated with Scripture, albeit in different ways. The present analysis will attend to the use of Scripture in Pesher Habakkuk (1QpHab),13 4QMMT,14 and the Damascus Document (CD) 1–8 and 19–20.15 11
Ibid., 119. Florentino García Martínez’s The Dead Sea Scrolls Translated: The Qumran Texts in English (Leiden: Brill, 1994), offers the advantage of a complete compilation of all texts published as of 1994, not to mention an introduction to each text. Often scholars possess numerous fragments of a work which they use to reconstruct the original text (as is the case for The Halakic Letter, e.g.). Martínez includes not only the hypothetically reconstructed text, but also all of the fragments. 13 For the Hebrew text, see Miller Burrows, The Isaiah Manuscript and the Habakkuk Commentary, vol. 1 of The Dead Sea Scrolls of St. Mark’s Monastery (New Haven: The American Schools of Oriental Research, 1950), plates LV–LXI. 14 For the Hebrew text, see Elisha Qimron and John Strugnell, Qumran Cave 4.V: Miqsat Ma’ase ha-Torah (DJD X; Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1994). 15 For the Hebrew text, I use Florentino García Martínez and Eibert J. C. Tigchelaar, The Dead Sea Scrolls Study Edition: Volume One IQI–4Q273 (Leiden: Brill, 1997). CD 1–8, 19–20 is known as the Admonition or Exhortation while CD 9–16 is called the Laws or Statutes. Jonathan G. Campbell’s The Use of Scripture in the 12
70
Why these texts? Ideally, one would employ texts of the same genre in doing comparative work; however, the Qumran library contains nothing analogous to a Gospel. Like scholars, Qumran scholars debate issues of genre. One text can fit more than one genre. For example, the Damascus Document contains rules for the community, much like the text known as Rule of the Community, but it also contains halakah, much like 4QMMT or even Jubilees, the latter of which is classified under “rewritten Bible”; it also contains biblical interpretation. And while there are some commonalities between Qumran literature and Johannine literature, there is no continuous narrative recounting the deeds and teachings of the founder of the group. 4QMMT displays mostly halakic interests but it also sheds light on the sectarian understanding of the group’s separatism primarily due to halakic differences. I have chosen CD because it represents the genre of “Rules,” which has been designated “the most typical of all the documents from the Qumran library.”16 One might question its inclusion, leveling criticisms such as the fact that its contents reflect an Essenism at odds with other Qumran literature. CD represents an Essenism that could be lived out in town rather than desert, in marriage rather than celibacy, in conjunction with frequenting the Temple for worship rather than complete withdrawal from it, with some different hierarchical structuring and even some different regulations.17 In defense of its inclusion, the fact that so many copies of CD were discovered at Qumran corroborates the assumption that the sect considered the text an important and authoritative document. CD most likely represents an earlier phase of the sect than does 1QpHab and as such it gives us a wider purview of evidence related to scriptural interpretation of the Qumran community. Pesher Habakkuk is included because it offers an example of another genre typical of that community, the pesharim, and, though prima facie the use of Scripture is fairly straightforward, a closer analysis reveals various intentions of the commentator that survive, which Damascus Document 1–8, 19–20 (Berlin: Walter de Gruyter, 1995), provides a useful examination of The Admonition. 16 García Martínez, Dead Sea Scrolls Translated, 2. 17 For a summary of similarities and differences between the two types of Essenism, see Geza Vermes, The Dead Sea Scrolls in English (3d ed.; New York: Penguin, 1987), 9–16.
71
accounts for its preeminent position among Qumran scholars. The other fifteen pesharim are much more fragmentary.18 By way of introduction I will present some commonly held views about “exegesis at Qumran,” the “character of the Qumran community,” and “pesherite exegesis” before moving to a perusal of the texts.19
Exegesis at Qumran Numerous scholars have contributed to the discussion of exegesis at Qumran, and some have even sought to compare it with that of various authors.20 The literary evidence depicts a community for whom study of Scripture is definitive: “[T]he Qumran Community, in recounting its origins and continuing practices, in describing how a person gains admission to the community and advances through its ranks, places intensive study of Mosaic scriptures and the communal laws deriving from those scriptures at the center of its elite self-understanding and differentiation from the rest of Israel.”21 But the relationship between Scripture and the sect at Qumran is symbiotic; while the sect submits to Scripture’s authority it is also the case that the community provides Scripture’s telos. Scripture was partially intended for and useful to preceding generations, but its complete actualization had to await the generation in which the sect found itself. Habakkuk wrote, for example, about things that would happen to the “last generation” (i.e., the sect) and, in fact, he claims that God did not even fully disclose the timing to the prophet himself. 18 In terms of pesherite authorship, it is assumed that all sixteen were composed by different authors. See Timothy H. Lim, Holy Scripture in the Qumran Commentaries and Pauline Letters (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1997), 11. 19 I enclose each topic in quotes because I have reservations about them insofar as I recognize the dangers of positing generalizations from texts, which can evince marked particularities and discrepancies. Since, however, this investigation’s primary concern is the Fourth Gospel and not a thorough study of Qumran, I seek merely to set the context of discussion for the reader. 20 Among those who consider the in general, see Fitzmeyer, “Quotations,” 297–333. For Paul, see Timothy H. Lim, Holy Scripture; for the Johannine writings see James H. Charlesworth, ed., John and the Dead Sea Scrolls (New York: Crossroad, 1990). 21 Steven D. Fraade “Looking for Legal Midrash at Qumran,” in Biblical Perspectives: Early Use and Interpretation of the Bible in Light of the Dead Sea Scrolls (ed. Michael E. Stone and Esther G. Chazon; Volume XXVIII of Studies on the Texts of the Desert of Judah, ed. F. García Martínez and A. S. Van der Woude; Leiden: Brill, 1998), 62–63.
72
“Thus, what differentiates the covenanteers and necessitates their separation from the rest of Israel is precisely their adherence to and active engagement with God’s will (laws), as manifest to all Israel in the Torah (hrwt) and as revealed to the community alone from the Torah (hrwt).”22 The Qumranians fervently believed that they enjoyed an exclusive claim on truth as revealed by the interpretations of Scripture performed by the community’s teachers. They admitted no other legitimate interpretations.23 The same phenomenon occurs in the Fourth Gospel and Branch Davidian sects. The community believed that Torah was twofold; there were revealed things (tlgn) and hidden things (trtsn), and while all of Israel was privy to the former, the latter were reserved for the sectarians alone.24 Fishbane detects three stages with respect to the authority of Mikra at Qumran: (1) God’s revelation of the Torah to all Israel, which turned out to be less than compelling; (2) the revelation of hidden things to the sectarians through the Instructor in Torah; and the Teacher of Righteousness, thereby establishing a New Covenant, and (3) a period of New Instruction.25 The salient texts for deeming the community Torah-centered include:26 1QS 1:3, 8, 12: “[D]o what is right and proper before [God], in accordance with what He commanded through Moses and all His servants, the prophets . . . to perform the statutes of God . . . [and] to clarify their knowledge in the truth of the statutes of God.” 1QS 6:6–8: “And in the place in which the Ten assemble there should not be missing a man to interpret the law day and night, 22
Ibid., 65. “The inspired interpretations at Qumran are also authoritative insofar as it is only these interpretations, which carry the true divine intent of the Torah of Moses and the words of the prophets; i.e., it is only on the basis of the law as interpreted by the Teacher and Interpreter (and their inheritors), and only on the basis of the prophecies as interpreted by the Teacher, that God’s will can be fulfilled and known. The sectarians believed that only they were the bearers of the esoteric sense of the ancient revelations.” Michael Fishbane, “Use, Authority and Interpretation of Mikra at Qumran,” in Mikra: Text, Translation, Reading, and Interpretation of the Hebrew Bible in Ancient Judaism and Early Christianity (ed. M. J. Mulder, with H. Sysling; Assen: Van Gorcum, 1988), 364. 24 Ibid. 25 Ibid., 365–66. 26 Fraade discusses 1QS 8:12–16; 1QS 5:7–10; 1QS 6:6–8; and 4QMMT C7–11 in “Looking,” 63–68. Fishbane addresses 1QS 1:3, 8, 12; 1QS 6:6–8; and CD 12:2–3 in “Use,” 345–46. 23
73
always, one relieving another. And the Many shall be on watch together for a third of each night of the year in order to read the book, explain the regulation, and bless together.” CD 12:2–3: “[I]n any settlement where there obtains a [communal quorum of ] ten let there not be lacking a priest versed in the book of wghy.” 1QS 8:12–16: “When these become a Community in Israel in accordance with these rules, they shall separate themselves from the session of the men of deceit in order to depart into the wilderness to prepare there the Way of the Lord; as it is written: ‘In the wilderness prepare the way of the Lord, make level in the desert a highway for our God’ (Isa 40:3). This (alludes to) the study of the Torah which he commanded through Moses to do, according to everything which he has revealed from time to time, and according to that which the prophets have revealed by his Holy Spirit.” 1QS 5:7–10: “according to everything which has been revealed from it (= the Torah) to the Sons of Zadok, the priests, who keep the covenant and seek his will, and according to the multitude of the men of their covenant, who devote themselves together to his truth and to walking in his will.” 4QMMT C7–11: “[And you know that] we have separated ourselves from the multitude of the people [and from all their impurity] and from being involved with these matters and from participating with [them] in these things. And you [know that no] treachery or deceit or evil can be found in our hand (i.e., in us), since for [these things] we give. [. . . And] we have [written] to you so that you may study (carefully) the book of Moses and the books of the Prophets and (the writings of ) David [and the events of ] ages past.” In short, “at most, we can say that the community’s collective life of regular çrdm, in the root sense of searching for and inquiring after God’s will through revealed scriptures and laws, was the social and soteriological context in which they experienced or expected such revelation to continue. . . . The Qumran community viewed itself as being doubly privileged: to be engaged in the search for God’s will and to have had it divinely revealed to them.”27 A number of people are presented as authoritative interpreters at Qumran, but the figure known as the “Teacher of Righteousness” 27
Fraade, “Looking,” 76.
74
held particular sway over the group. Davies describes the community as follows: “[T]he Qumran group accepted some figure as this eschatological teacher and thus anticipated the end of days, accepted his ruling and isolated themselves from those others of their group who rejected the person’s claims. . . . I regard the yahad as a messianic sect, rather like the Nazarenes.”28 The sentence could just as appropriately describe the Branch Davidians. Whoever the “historical” interpreters of Scripture were at Qumran, I am interested in the authors as interpreters. There is tension between application and preservation when one interprets law codes or sacred texts. How can an author simultaneously be “relevant” to her community and faithful to the text? The task of the modern expositor is to elucidate with varying degrees of help from tradition.29 The Qumran texts show a range of exegetical artfulness and variety. Fraade finds sophisticated exegesis at Qumran “involving continuous commentary (pesharim) and complex interpretation of verses through the citation and interpretation of other verses.”30 Fraade has investigated the extent of evidence at Qumran for the method of midrash halakah, defined as “the explicit citation and interpretation of scripture as a source of or justification for law.”31 His conclusion is at least twofold: (1) there is very little evidence of that process whereby laws are derived from scriptural explication32 and (2) this should not surprise us, given the social construction (either actualized or ideal) of the community as evidenced by the scrolls. This is a sectarian group that depends on revelation first and foremost as its locus of authority, bequeathed through the Teacher of Righteousness or his successors. The community starts with revelation and then turns to Scripture.33 This is true of the Fourth Gospel community as well. As Bultmann noticed with perspicacity, Jesus is nothing in the Fourth Gospel if not the Revealed Revealer. In fact, the content of his revelation is simply that he himself is the revealer. And, as we will see later, the Branch Davidians operated in a similar fashion—its primary focus was on revelation as filtered through David Koresh and others before him. 28
Davies, “Prehistory,” 120. Lim, Holy Scripture, 33. 30 Fraade, “Looking,” 63. 31 Ibid., 60. 32 Fraade writes: “[L]egal midrash involving explicit biblical quotation is mainly limited to the Damascus Document, where it is the exception.” Ibid., 61. 33 According to Fraade, the Qumran community “formulated its rules in keeping with its particular socio-religious self-understanding as the elect recipient and bearer of continued divine revelation.” Ibid., 79. 29
75
Pesherite Exegesis 34 Because the pesharim reflect a number of peculiar features, they have generated among scholars a (questionable) assumption that we can speak of an exegetical approach to Scripture known as “pesherite exegesis.” When the discussion turns to defining the essence of pesherite exegesis, quot homines, tot sententiae. While I cannot engage the details of that debate here, I do think it necessary to apprise the reader of some of its basic elements before presenting the analysis of Pesher Habakkuk. Any responsible use of the pesharim for purposes such as mine requires a word on the issue of genre as it relates to the pesharim, especially because the term “pesher” has been subjected to abuses of arbitrary usage.35 At the very least, the word may signify either the body of literature discovered at Qumran or the method of interpretation evinced therein. The pesharim adopt a particular biblical book as their focus and proceed to offer a continuous commentary or interpretation. So, a verse or verses will be introduced followed by the statement: “The interpretation (rçp) is . . .” and a contemporizing explanation. However, many other significances attach to the word as a result of the history of scholarship.36 Debate primarily centers on whether one should appeal to content or form when defining the genre.37 Those directing their attention to content designate the 34 Fraade warns against extrapolating too much from the pesharim to general comments on scriptural exegesis at Qumran: “Because the pesharim were among the first of the DSS discovered and published, because of their allusions to events and persons in the sect’s history, and because of their significance for the history of biblical interpretation, they have gained a prominence that has led some to regard them as defining Qumran scriptural exegesis overall. However, given the fact that they all exist in single copies and display a specific type of actualized prophetic exegesis, it would be a mistake to exaggerate their importance or to assume that they characterize the broad range of Qumran use of Scripture.” Ibid., 76 n. 57. 35 Any reader who has essayed to define “apocalyptic” or “midrash” will feel a familiar frustration when engaging the subject of “pesher.” A brief foray into the subject yields suggestions that a separate genre for pesharim is redundant. George Brooke, for example, advises scholars to consider them “Qumran midrash” (“Qumran Pesher: Towards the Redefinition of a Genre,” Revue de Qumran 10 [1979–81]: 502), while Moshe Bernstein wonders if the Isaiah pesher should actually be denominated as “florilegia from Isaiah.” (“Introductory Formulas for Citation and Recitation of Biblical Verses in the Qumran Pesharim: Observations on a Pesher Technique,” DSD 1 [1994]: 66). 36 For a brief overview of that history, see Brooke’s article “Qumran Pesher,” 483–503. 37 The relationship between pesher and midrash generates dispute as well. Brooke advocates considering pesher a sub-genre of midrash, indeed, eliminating the term entirely and assigning the appellation “Qumran midrash” rather than “Pesharim” to the texts traditionally known as such. “Qumran Pesher,” 503.
76
prophetic materials, the Teacher of Righteousness’ knowledge of God’s economy of salvation, and eschatological concerns as determinative generic factors. The fact, however, that evidence for the last two features appears in other literature besides the pesharim opens the content approach to criticism. Regarding prophetic materials, the pesharim do not cover all of the prophets (which, to be sure, may be an accident of preservation) and the pesharim are not confined exclusively to the prophets when conducting exegesis. J. Carmignac distinguished two types of pesharim, continu and thematique; the former refers to those that interpret one biblical book sequentially, whereas the latter finds the author drawing from a number of biblical books concerning a particular theme.38 The first type is reflected in the collection of materials known as the pesharim while the second is merely a technique that can appear in any text, even non-Qumran texts (e.g., Paul). Pesher Habakkuk falls under the rubric of pesher continu since it provides a running commentary on Habakkuk. As noted above, generally speaking the pesharim present one or more biblical verses, signify the disjuncture between biblical citation and interpretation with the word rçp, identify the figures in the biblical text in a contemporizing fashion and, finally, provide an explanation. They proceed sequentially through the biblical book. At times, however, the author will re-quote part of the initially quoted text and elaborate. The pesherist will often focus on a particular word and assign it special significance. For instance, we learn from 1QpHab 12.3–4 that “Lebanon” and “beasts” refer to contemporary persons, namely, “the council of the community,” and “the simple of Judah,” respectively. “Lebanon” frequently signifies the Jerusalem temple due to the fact that cedars of Lebanon were used for the construction of Solomon’s Temple (1 Kgs 5:15–26). It is often purported that the Qumran community viewed itself as a “restored temple.” So, “Lebanon” refers to the community. “The simple ones of Judah” refers to the whole or a part of the community.39 Those who like to see parallels in texts cite Paul’s treatment of sp°rma in Gal 3. 38 Though these tidy distinctions have suffered criticism, they continue to appear in most treatments of pesharim. Moshe Bernstein (“Introductory Formulas,” 63) complains about this classification system (inter alia): “. . . too much weight is placed on 1QpHab as a model, on the existence of exactly two kinds of pesharim, and on the need for pesharim to behave rather monolithically.” 39 Lim, Holy Scripture, 49.
77
Timothy Lim has explored pesherite exegesis and Pauline literature. Lim addresses textual variants, original texts, Vorlagen, etc., all of which are relevant for an analysis of scriptural authority. In order to fully understand the relationship of the author to the biblical text we want to know whether the author attempted to completely preserve the original wording of the text or whether she felt free to alter wording or even paraphrase. The issue quickly becomes complicated, of course, since we do not have access to any biblical autographs, so that where differences occur it is difficult to decide whether to attribute the variance to authorial license or simply to the fact that the author uses a different text type. Lim wants to know whether or not the pesherists and Paul modified the biblical text for their own interpretive agenda. He concludes that ancient exegetes, including the pesherists and Paul, did concern themselves with “the preservation of the Word of God.”40 In analyzing their modifications of the text, Lim correctly observes that “there existed a tension between a multiplicity of interpretative forces,”41 but he does not take social factors into consideration. Lim’s concerns differ from my own in a number of ways. He focuses more on the relationship between the interpreter and his text rather than that between the interpreter and his community. In his study the biblical text is an end; in the present study it is a means. Explicit Citations Given the interest in the citation formulae of John’s Gospel (as well as Matthew’s), the introductory formulae in the pesharim warrant some attention. In addressing the use of Scripture in John I will attend to the language used in reference to both Scripture and the words of Jesus in order to better understand the authoritative nature of each. It is necessary to do the same for the Qumran texts. Scripture is referred to as that which (1) is “written” (bwtk), (2) is written in a particular book, (3) God, Moses, or a prophet has “said” (rma), “spoken” (rbd), “told” (dygh), “taught” (dml), or “announced” ([ymçh). rma, rbd, and dygh occur most often. In the pesharim, there are at least two types of formulae, those that introduce the biblical lemmas and those that introduce interpretations of the text. Within the first type, one might ask if there 40 41
Ibid., 33. Ibid., 95.
78
are different formulae for introducing the lemma for the first time versus the repetition of a citation. The answer is a qualified “yes”; given the nature of the genre, i.e., a running commentary, the initial lemma is not usually introduced by a formula42 but a re-citation in the interpretive section that follows often is. With respect to 1QpHab, the latter comprises rma rça awh awk and rma rçaw. To introduce interpretations, the pesharim characteristically employ the term “pesher.” Common formulae include rbdh rçp, wrçp, and l µymyh tyrjal µgtph rçp (“the interpretation of the matter with regard to the end of days concerns”), though the last formula does not appear in 1QpHab. After turning a critical eye upon the work of Horton, Brooke, Fitzmeyer, and Divant, Moshe Bernstein arrives at the following conclusions regarding both continuous and thematic pesharim: 1) Scriptural citations in “continuous” pesharim are generally not introduced by a formula. 2) Requotation within “continuous” pesharim is a comparatively rare phenomenon, and perhaps 1QpHab, the touchstone for pesharim, is the exception rather than the rule. 3) The terminology rma rça awh ayk, rma rçaw, bwtk rçaw, and rçak bwtk is also not common in the “continuous” pesharim, with 1QpHab again misleading us regarding its frequency. 4) rma rçaw clearly has two functions in Qumran “continuous” pesharim: the introduction of previously cited text and the introduction of text not quoted before. At times, rma rçaw seems to have a resumptive effect when a text is not strictly continuous. 5) bwtk rçaw/k occur only in non-continuous pesher material of both “continuous” text and thematic types (and CD), and are usually employed to introduce previously unquoted text. This usage in continuous pesher does not seem limited to the introduction of subordinate prooftexts. 6) There are differences in significant features and qualities in citation technique and citation terminology among the “continuous” pesharim as currently defined. 7) Some of the 4QpIsa material (not only 4QpIsac) shares common phenomena with the so-called thematic pesharim, against the other socalled continuous pesharim.43
Regarding thematic pesharim, Bernstein concludes that: (1) they manifest a wider variety of formulae than the continuous pesharim; (2)
42
For possible exceptions, see Maurya P. Horgan, Pesharim: Qumran Interpretations of Biblical Books (Washington, D.C.: Catholic Biblical Association, 1979), 243 n. 53. 43 Bernstein, “Introductory Formulas,” 67–68.
79
they do not always identify the source of their citation (cf. the Fourth Gospel), though usually they do; (3) rma rçaw serves a resumptive function; (4) citations from other biblical books are not always introduced with a formula; (5) some “quotations” do not match any known biblical lemma and may actually represent paraphrases (as is the case in Fourth Gospel); and (6) “Thematic persharim’s structure of citations from a central text or texts surrounded by support from other ones demands heavy usage of the subordinated prooftext formulas like _b bwtk rça awh or _rpsb bwtk rçak.”44 In 4QMMT, the form bwtk occurs eleven times but is never followed by a direct scriptural citation (B27, 38, 66, 70, 76, 77, C6, 11, 12 [twice], 21). Explicit citations often serve to substantiate a claim already made or a regulation commanded; this is otherwise known as a prooftext. Alternatively, Scripture can be cited first, followed by a comment or interpretation. A crucial feature of the explicit citations is the fact that the interpretation ascribed to the text by or for the community differs from the original meaning of the text, but the interpreter acts as though his interpretation is the “plain-sense of the Mikra.”45 Using CD 3:18–4:4, Fishbane shows how the author employs Ezek 44:15 and concludes: “[T]his passage is then explicated in terms of the sect, so that the special nature of sectarian triumphalism is justified through the Mikra. . . . Through these boldly reinterpretated [sic] citations, the communal sense of history and destiny is justified and vindicated.”46 Allusions Like the Fourth Gospel and Branch Davidian material, Qumran literature is replete with biblical phraseology and allusions. The authors of 4QMMT, CD, and 1QpHab were steeped in the biblical tradition and sought to conform their listeners to the biblical mold. Fishbane presents CD 8:7–9 as a prime example: “And they did each one what was right in his eyes and preferred each one the stubbornness of his heart, and did not withdraw from the people [of the land and their sin], but rebelled highhandedly by walking in the ways of the wicked.”47 Various phrases are reminiscent of biblical language. For 44 45 46 47
Ibid., 68. Fishbane, “Use,” 348. Ibid., 350. Ibid., 357.
80
instance, “doing what is right in one’s own eyes” constantly breeds demise in Judges; “stubbornness of heart” occurs often and can be found in Deut 29:18; “the way of the wicked” recalls Ps 1; and so on.48 Wuthnow’s observation: “The special advantage of congregations, especially in the high church or liturgical traditions (and at the extreme fundamentalist end of the theological spectrum), is that they can speak largely in the distinctive language of their own subculture and do so with the authority of specialists who know this language well,”49 applies to the power of allusion in shaping these groups, a power which should not be underestimated; it is no less than supplying them a language with the concomitant power that we all know language wields in the formation of a person’s worldview.50 In addition to biblical language, Fishbane proves that authors also used biblical models as a basis for compositional forms. So, the structure of the Aaronic blessing is imitated in 1QS 2:2–10. He also refers to practices reflected in the Bible, appropriated and adapted for the community. His example is that of 1QS 2, which takes up the covenant ceremony of Deut 27:9–26.51
Analysis of Primary Sources Pesher Habakkuk 52 Col. 1 1 [Hab 1:1–2 Oracle received by the prophet Habakkuk in a vision. For how long, YHWH] do I ask for help without 2 [you hearing me; shout: Violence! to you without you saving me? The interpretation of this concerns the beg]inning of the generation 3 [. . . which will com]e upon them 4 [. . . they] will [sh]out against 5 [. . . Hab 1:3a Why do you show me misdeeds and] do you behold [to]il? Blank 6 [The interpretation of this . . . of ] God with persecution and betrayal. 7 [Hab 1:3b You set destruction and violence in front of me and brawls occur and quarrel arise]. Blank 8 [ The interpretation of this . . .] ro[bbe]ry of [. . .] and brawls 9 [. . . ar]gument and they th[ink] destruc-
48
Ibid. Wuthnow, Producing, 101. 50 In Wittgenstein’s words, “The limits of my language mean the limits of my world.” 51 Fishbane, “Use,” 357–59. 52 English translation taken from Martínez and Tigchelaar, The Dead Sea Scrolls Study Edition, 1:11–21. 49
81
tion 10 [. . .] Hab 1:4a For the Law falls into abeyance. 11 [The interpretation of this . . .] that they have rejected the Law of God. 12 [Hab 1:4bc And justice does not emerge as the winner, for the evildoer accos]ts the upright man. Blank 13 [Its interpretation: the evildoer is the Wicked Priest and the upright man] is the Teacher of Righteousness.53
This passage directs the reader to one of the loci of authority for the sect, namely, the Teacher of Righteousness (1QpHab 1:13) who is defined as the “upright man” referred to in Hab 1:4. He is contrasted with one of the sect’s preeminent enemies, the Wicked Priest (1QpHab 1:13), whom the author of the pesher confidently identifies with the “evildoer” of Hab 1:4. The Wicked Priest has been variously designated as Jonathan Maccabee, Simon Maccabee, Alexander Jannaeus, or perhaps even more than one person. The passage also reveals the sect’s assumption that Scripture finds its telos in the Qumran community itself. In 1QpHab 1:2–3, the author claims that Habakkuk prophesied “concerning the expectation of the generation of the visitation in the last days all the things that are going to come upon them.”54 One contemporizing technique used by the author of the pesher is to move facilely and unapologetically from the original prophet’s first-person statement to an interpretation which imputes a third-person significance to the prophet’s words, as he does in 1QpHab1:4–5. Col. I 14 [. . . Hab 1:4d This] is why justice emerges 15 [distorted. The interpretation of this . . .] and not [. . .] 16 [. . . Hab 1:5 Look, traitors, and behold,] 17 [be astonished, shocked, for in your time a work is done which you would not believe if ] Col. II 1 it was reported. Blank [. . . The interpretation of the word concerns] the traitors with the Man of 2 the Lie, since they do not [believe in the words of ] the Teacher of Righteousness from the mouth of 3 God; and (it concerns) the traito[rs of the] new [covenant] si[n]ce they did not 4 believe in the covenant of God [and dishonoured] his holy na[me]. 5 Likewise: Blank The interpretation of the word [concerns the trai]tors in the last 6 days. They are violator[s of the coven]ant who will not believe 7 when they hear all that is going [to happen t]o the final generation, from the mouth of 8 the Priest whom God has placed wi[thin the Commun]ity, to foretell the fulfillment of all 9 the words of his servants, the prophets, [by] means of whom God has declared 10 all that is going to happen to his people Is[rael]. 53 54
Ibid., 11. Horgan, Pesharim, 12.
82
In this passage the author provides a triple interpretation and degradation of the “traitors” mentioned in Hab 1:5. First, the sobriquet points to the initial period of breaking away from the parent tradition by indicating those in the past who allied themselves with the Man of the Lie against the Teacher of Righteousness. The specific charge against the Man of the Lie and his cohort is the failure to believe the words of the Teacher of Righteousness; those who fail to believe (pisteÊv) the words of Jesus will bear serious condemnation in the Fourth Gospel. Second, the passage expresses concern for present troublemakers, namely, those who had once belonged to the sect (i.e., members of the “new covenant”) but have now defected. They are characterized as “not believing” and as “profaning the holy name.” Finally, “traitors in the last days” are potential proselytes who refuse to join the sect. Since the author labels three different groups “traitors” in 1:16–2:10, I presume that the third group listed refers to potential Jewish converts (“those of the covenant”) as opposed to the second group, which refers to defectors from the sect, those of the “new covenant” who deserted. In addition to implying the opposition faced by the sect, the passage also reveals attitudes about leaders of the group. It presents the Teacher of Righteousness as one who both warrants fidelity and belief and is privy to special insight insofar as his words are “from the mouth of God.” Furthermore, the sect’s priest emerges as a locus of authority. In this passage we learn that, just as in an earlier phase of the sect’s testimony the “traitors” referred to in Hab 1:5 were those who did not listen to the words of the Teacher of Righteousness, so also in the final days of the sect there will be traitors who do not listen to the words of the group’s ordained interpreter, the priest. In studying 1QpHab one enters an interpretive world that lends itself to Wuthnow’s dramaturgic approach to the study of culture. The whole of 1QpHab corroborates Wuthnow’s claim: In saying that culture is symbolic-expressive, therefore, this approach tends to focus less on information that is simply and straightforwardly transmitted than on messages that may be implicit in the ways in which social life is arranged, in rituals, and in the choice of words in discourse. Put simply, what is “given off ” may be as important as what is “given.”55
55
Wuthnow, Meaning, 13–14.
83
The author of 1QpHab is not simply trying to inculcate a set of esoteric or philosophical ideas in his community, but to express how social relations should be arranged for God’s covenant community. 1QpHab 2:8–10 reiterates the sect’s conviction, which appears already at 1QpHab 1:2–3, that Scripture finds its telos in the Qumran community itself. Here one discovers that other prophets besides Habakkuk spoke of the community’s era. All three sects under study hold this conviction as part of their self-understanding that they alone represent the pure and true covenant community of God as indicated in Scripture. As Meeks writes of the Fourth Gospel: The claim that constitutes the identity of this special group of former Jews is that in their abiding in the Son of Man they have been granted what the whole of Israel’s scripture and tradition—both Jewish and Samaritan versions—pointed to. . . . They alone are Israel. . . . They are epitomized in one of the first of those “given by God” to Jesus, Nathanael the élhy«w ÉIsrahl¤thw. Here we have the very model of a sectarian consciousness (my italics).”56 Col. II 10b Hab 1:6 For see, I will mobilize 11 the Chaldaeans, a cruel [and deter]mined people. Blank 12 Its interpretation concerns the Kittim, wh[o ar]e swift and powerful 13 in battle, to slay many [. . .] in the kingdom of 14 the Kittim; they will take possession [of many countries] and will not believe 15 in the precepts of [Go]d [. . . Hab 1:6 They go across the earth] 16 to [take possession of dwelling not theirs. Its interpretation . . .] 17 [. . .] Col. III 1 and they will advance over the plain, to destroy and pillage the cities of the country. 2 For this is what he has said: Hab 1:6 <
>. Hab 1:7 It is dreadful 3 and terrible; his judgment and his exaltation arise from himself. Blank 4 Its interpretation concerns the Kittim, the fear and dread of whom are on all 5 /the peoples;/ all their thoughts are premeditated to do evil, and with cunning and treachery 6 they behave towards all the nations. Hab 1:8 Their horses are swifter than panthers; they are keener 7 than wolves at night. Blank Their war-horses paw the ground, galop [sic], from afar 8 they come flying like an eagle, hastening to eat. Hab 1:9 All of them come to use violence; the breath of 9 their faces is like the East wind. Blank Its inter[pretation] concerns the Kittim, who 10 trample the land with [their] horse[s] and their animals 11 and come from far off, from the islands of the sea, to devour all the nations, like an eagle, 12 insatiable. With fury they are he[ated, and with] burning wrath and livid 13 faces they will speak to all [the nations. Fo]r this is what 14 he has said: Hab 1:9 The brea[th of their
56
Meeks, “Divine Agent,” 54.
84
faces is like the East wind. And he gathers] captives [like sa]nd. 15 Its [interpreta]tion [. . .] 16 [. . .] 17 [. . . Hab 1:10a At kings] Col. IV 1 it sneers and leaders it mocks. Blank Its interpretation: 2 they deride the powerful and despise the honoured men; at kings 3 and princes they jeer, and sneer at a huge army. Hab 1:10b And he 4 laughs at every strong fortress, piles up earth and captures it. 5 The interpretation of this concerns the leaders of the Kittim, who despise the 6 fortresses of the peoples and with derision laugh at them, 7 they surround them with a huge army to capture them. And through dread and fear 8 they surrender to their hands, and they demolish them because of the wickedness of those who dwell 9 in them. Hab 1:11 Then the wind changes and goes on; and this one has made his might 10 his God. Blank Its interpretation [con]cerns the leaders of the Kittim, 11 who on the advice of a house of guilty [people] go by, one 12 before the other. [Their] leaders, [o]ne after another, will come 13 to raze the ea[rth. Hab 1:11 And] this one [has made] his might his God. 14 Its interpretation [. . . al]l the nations 15 [. . .]
The author interprets Habakkuk’s “Chaldeans” as Kittim who are “swift and vigorous in battle” (1QpHab 2:12–14). The author of Pesher Habakkuk spends considerable time on the Romans. The fact that they occupy more than one quarter of the commentary’s space indicates that their influence and power were immediate, imminent, ubiquitous, and produced an exigency that surely fueled the sect’s apocalyptic tendencies. Their military might is formidable (3:10–11); they are universally feared (3:4–5); they confiscate land (3:1); they unscrupulously plot evil, guided only by guile and deception; their megalomania respects no bounds. All of this they execute with burning rage and flagrant violence (3:11–12; cf. 6:10–12). Supercilious and cavalier, the Romans are identified as those who “scoff at kings, laugh at princes,” in Habakkuk’s words. We also learn a bit of history, that the Romans have ruled for some duration, when the author interprets “Then they changed, a wind, and they passed by” (Hab. 1:11), as referring to successive Roman rulers. This lengthy excoriation certifies for the sect that the Romans are vehement foes. The author never specifically identifies the Kittim as “Romans”; rather, this is an example of insider language. As we learned from Wuthnow, religious groups may effect boundary formation through “cultural exclusion,” “buttressing the scarcity of their valued goods by limiting access to them.”57 Unless one is initiated into the linguistic code of the group, she will remain an outsider. 57
Wuthnow, Producing, 38.
85
Among those who suffer the derision of the Romans the author includes Israel as a whole, “a great people,” thereby indicating that he not only continues to define the sect within the parameters of the parent tradition but also still worries over the welfare of his nonsectarian fellow countrymen. The author castigates those who “betray the covenant.” By this phrase does he signify non-Qumran Jews or the Qumran sectarians? Logic suggests the latter because the author speaks in future terms. Since he has already indicated that the parent tradition patently does not keep God’s statutes and that the sect alone obeys the statutes of God, it most likely refers to defectors from the sect. Col. IV 16 [. . . Hab 1:12–13a Are you not] 17 [from of old, YHWH my holy God. We will not die. YHWH,] Col. V 1 you have appointed him to judge; Rock, you have installed him to rebuke him. Your eyes are too pure 2 to look at evil, you can not stare at calamity. Blank 3 Interpretation of the word: God is not to destroy his nation at the hand of the peoples, 4 but in the hand of his chosen ones God will place the judgment over all the peoples; and by their reproof 5 all the evildoers of his people will be pronounced guilty, (by the reproof ) of those who kept his commandments 6 in their hardship. For this is what he has said: Hab 1:13a <>. Blank Its interpretation: they have not run after the desire of their eyes in the era of 8 wickedness.
This passage defines and elevates the sect. The author is so bold as to transfer the “eyes too pure to look on evil” from God to the sectarians. The sectarians are God’s “chosen ones” (cf. 1QpHab 9:12) who are “not unfaithful.” They persevere, obeying God’s commandments (wtwwxm ta rmç) even in a time of “distress” and “wickedness.” This adherence to God’s commandments plays a central role in creating a distinct way of life for the sectarians; conversely, a chief complaint which the author has against opponents of the sect is their failure to obey God’s commandments. The sectarians are further elevated by their judicial position; they will enact judgment in a twofold capacity: they will judge both Gentiles and Jews outside the sect. Col. V 8b Hab 1:13b Why do you stare, traitors, and remain silent when 9 a wicked person consumes someone more upright than himself ? Blank Its interpretation concerns the House of Absalom 10 and the members of their council, who kept silent when the Teacher of Righteousness was rebuked, 11 and did not help him against the Man of the Lie, Blank who rejected 12 the Law in the midst of their whole Council.
86
1QpHab 5:8–12 contributes to an understanding of the origins and history of the sect. The original context of this passage finds Habakkuk pondering Yahweh’s employment of the Chaldeans to punish the wicked of Israel.58 Our author, however, has interpreted the prophecy as referring to the betrayal of the founder59 and authoritative leader of the Qumran community, the Teacher of Righteousness, by those who should have defended him against the Liar (who may be the Wicked Priest, one or more of the Hasmoneans, or a rival of the Teacher of Righteousness within the community).60 The author’s interpretation of Scripture achieves a number of effects for the sect. It categorizes those of the parent tradition at the time of the sect’s break as “them,” speaking of those who “did not help” the sect’s leader, the Teacher of Righteousness. It further degrades “them” by associating them with the “Man of the Lie” and “house of Absalom,” which is defined in treacherous terms. The interpretation creates “us” through etiological means: the Teacher of Righteousness was “rebuked” by the Liar and betrayed by the men of the council. It positions the Teacher of Righteousness as one of the loci of authority and portrays him as unjustly persecuted. It reiterates the lawlessness of the Man of the Lie and his opposition to the Teacher of Righteousness.
58
Lim, Holy Scripture, 98–104. Or simply “key figure,” depending on the theory to which one subscribes concerning the Teacher of Righteousness. 60 Geza Vermes, The Complete Dead Sea Scrolls in English (New York: Allen Lane/Penguin Press, 1997), 54: “The Teacher did not meet with unanimous approval within the congregation, and a faction described as ‘seekers of smooth things,’ ‘removers of the bounds,’ and ‘builders of the wall,’ all metaphors seeming to point to religious laxity and infidelity, turned against him and his followers. The leader of the breakaway party, though accorded a number of unflattering sobriquets, such as ‘Scoffer,’ ‘Liar,’ or ‘Spouter of Lies,’ seems to be one and the same person.” On p. 60, however, Vermes appears to identify the Liar with the Wicked Priest. Michael Knibb, The Qumran Community (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1987), identifies the Liar as the leader of a breakaway group, distinct from the Wicked Priest: 7, 10, 23, 42, 71, 223, 243. Lawrence Schiffman, Reclaiming the Dead Sea Scrolls: The History of Judaism, the Background of Christianity, the Lost Library of Qumran (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1994), 232: “The traitors, apparently led by the Man of Lies, were most probably straying members of the group or a competing group. In any case, this passage [1QpHab 2:1–3] shows that the teacher faced opposition from the official priesthood, but from others as well.” James VanderKam, The Dead Sea Scrolls Today (London: SPCK, 1994), 47: “The Liar seems to have been a member of the community who refused to accept what the Teacher of Righteousness claimed.” 59
87
Not only here but throughout his work the author of 1QpHab exhibits an understanding of the importance of providing the group with a history of itself. This is in keeping with Wuthnow’s observations regarding the power inherent in a group’s rehearsal of its history.61 Col. V 12 Hab 1:14–16 You made man like fish of the sea, 13 like a reptile, to rule over it. All of [them] he hauls up [with a fish]-hook, catches in his net 14 and gathers in [his] tr[awl. This is why he offers sacri]fices to his net; this is why he rejoices 15 [and is hap]py [and burns incense to his trawl; since by them] his portion is fat 16 [and his food rich . . .] 17 [. . .] Col. VI 1 of the Kittim, and they gather their wealth with all their loot 2 like fish of the sea. And what it says: Hab 1:16a This is why he offers sacrifices to his net 3 and burns incense to his trawl. Blank Its interpretation: they 4 offer sacrifices to their standards and their weapons are 5 the object of their worship. Hab 1:16b Since by them his portion is fat and his food rich. 6 Its interpretation: they distribute their yoke and 7 their burden, which is their food, among all the peoples, year after year, 8 ravaging many countries. Hab 1:17 For this he continually unsheathes his sword 9 to kill peoples without pity. Blank 10 Its interpretation concerns the Kittim who will cause many to die by the edge of the sword, 11 youths, adults and old people, women and children; not even 12 children at the breast will they pity.
1QpHab 6:1–12 depicts the Romans as idolatrous insofar as they sacrifice to their military weapons and are capriciously violent. Note the interpretive move of changing the “He” of the original passage to the plural Kittim. The passage establishes the Romans as opponents. Col. VI 12 Hab 2:1–2 I will stand firm in my sentry-post, 13 I will position myself in my fortress, and I will look out to see what he says 14 to me, and what [he answers t]o my reproof. YHWH answered me 15 [and said: Write the vision; inscr]ibe it on tablets so that may run 16 [the one who reads it . . .] . . . [. . .] 17 [. . .] Col. VII 1 And God told Habakkuk to write what was going to happen 2 to the last generation, but he did not let him know the consummation of the era. 3 Blank And as for what he says: Hab 2:2 <<So that /may run/the one who reads it>>. 4 Its interpretation concerns the Teacher of Righteousness, to whom God has made known 5 all the mysteries of the words of his servants, the prophets.
This passage evinces the sect’s view of the Teacher of Righteousness as privy to special insight. Further, it once again reveals the sect’s 61
Wuthnow, Producing, 61.
88
assumption that Scripture finds its telos in the Qumran community itself. The author contends that Habakkuk wrote about the community’s own era and that they are “the last generation.” Such apocalyptic eschatological notions might have encouraged the sectarians to persevere through difficulties and assured them that the apparent chaos (or “tribulation” as 1QpHab 8:2 names it) around them caused by both the parent religion and the destructive Romans was actually all subject to God’s prudence. David Koresh relied upon this technique for the Branch Davidians. Col. VII 5 Hab 2:3 For the vision has an appointed 6 time, it will have an end and not fail. Blank 7 Its interpretation: the final age will be extended and go beyond all that 8 the prophets say, because the mysteries of God are wonderful.
The notion of a “last” end time implies that the author interprets God’s action in salvation history to involve a number of end times, an idea corroborated by 1QpHab 7:12–13. In addition to successive end times, the author states that the ultimate end time, that which his own community inhabits, is prolonged according to God’s providence. Drawing upon the book of Revelation, David Koresh makes the same declaration. Such a proclamation encourages the sectarians to persevere, to understand that the long wait is not a sign of God’s abandonment, but rather God’s economy. In Koresh’s rhetoric, the prolonged period is viewed in positive, proselytizing terms so that the eschaton is protracted in order that more might be drawn into the sect. The author of 1QpHab may have the same vision. Col. VII 9 Hab 2:3b Though it might tarry, wait for it; it definitely has to come and will not 10 delay. Blank Its interpretation concerns the men of truth, 11 those who observe the Law, whose hands will not desert the service 12 of truth when the final age is extended beyond them, because 13 all the ages of God will come at the right time, as he established 14 for them in the mysteries of his prudence. Hab 2:4 See, it is conceited and does not give way 15 [his soul within him.] Blank Its interpretation: they will double upon them 16 [. . . and] find [no] mercy at being judged. [. . .] 17 [. . . Hab 2:4b But the righteous man will live because of their loyalty to him.] Col. VIII 1 Its interpretation concerns all observing the Law in the House of Judah, whom 2 God will free from the house of judgment on account of their toil and of their loyalty 3 to the Teacher of Righteousness.
89
The sectarians are elevated as “men of truth” who “observe the Law” (-hrwth yçw[; 1QpHab 7:11; 8:1) and are destined for salvation62 from the “house of judgment” (fpçmh tyb; 1QpHab 8:2).63 In contrast, the opponents will endure judgment (1QpHab 7:16). The passage presents the Teacher of Righteousness as one who warrants fidelity and belief. The eschatological material serves as a thinly veiled implied exhortation to perseverance for the sectarians who are in danger of becoming deserters or have already deserted “the service of truth when the final age is extended beyond them” (1QpHab 7:11–12). As is typical of the Qumran, Branch Davidian, and Johannine communities, the chief stated reward is salvation. Col. VIII 3 Hab 2:5–6 Surely wealth will corrupt the boaster, and not 4 will he last, he who widens his throat like the abyss, and he, like death can not be satisfied. 5 All the peoples ally against him, all the nations come together against him. 6 Are they not all going to chant verses against him, explaining riddles at his expense? 7 They shall say: Ah, one who amasses the wealth of others! How long will he load himself 8 with debts? Blank Its interpretation concerns the Wicked Priest, who 9 was called loyal at the start of his office. However, when he ruled 10 over Israel his heart became proud, he deserted God and betrayed the laws for the sake of 11 riches. And he robbed and hoarded wealth from the violent men who had rebelled against God. 12 And he seized public money, incurring additional serious sin. 13 And he performed re[pul]sive acts by every type of defiling impurity. Hab 2:7–8 Will not suddenly 14 your cre[di]tors get up, and those who shake you wake up? You will be their prey. 15 Since you pillaged many peoples all the rest of the nations will pillage you. 16 Blank The in[terpretation of the word] concerns the Priest who rebelled 17 [. . .] the precepts of [God . . .] . . . [. . .] Col. IX 1 afflicting him with the punishment of sin; the horrors of 2 terrifying maladies they have acted upon him, as well as vengeful acts on his fleshly body. And what 3 it says: Hab 2:8a <<Since you pillaged many peoples all the 4 rest of the nations will pillage you>>. Blank Its interpretation concerns the last priests of Jerusalem, 5 who will accumulate riches and loot from plundering the nations. 6 However, in the last days their riches and their loot will be given into the hands 7 of the army of the Kittim. Blank For they are Hab 2:8a <>. 8 Hab 2:8b For the human blood (spilt) and the violence (done) to the country, the city and all/who dwell/in it. Blank 9 62 63
lxn appears also at 9:13 and 12:14 in 1QpHab, though negatively. tyb appears elsewhere in 1QpHab at 4:11; 5:9; 8:1; 9:12, 14; 10:3; 11:6; note
similar house language in the Fourth Gospel (ofik¤a; 14:2).
90
Its interpretation concerns the [Wi]cked Priest, whom, for the wickedness against the Teacher of 10 Righteousness and the members of his council, God delivered into the hands of his enemies to disgrace him 11 with a punishment, to destroy him with bitterness of soul having acted wickedly 12 against his elect. Woe to anyone putting ill-gotten gains in his house, placing 13 his perch high up to escape the power of evil! You have planned things that will bring disgrace 14 to your house, destroying many nations and sinning against your [so]ul. For 15 the sto[ne] will shout from the wall, the wooden beam will an[swer . . .] 16 [The interpretation of the word concerns the priest who [. . .] 17 [. . .] Col. X 1 for its stone to be by oppression and the beam of its wood by pillage. And what 2 it says: Hab 2:10 <>. Blank 3 Its interpretation: it is the house of judgment, for God will give 4 his judgment among many nations and from there will lead him to punishment. 5 And in their midst he will proclaim him guilty and will punish him with sulphurous fire. Hab 2:12–13 Woe 6 to him who builds a city with blood and founds a town on wickedness! Does 7 this not stem from YHWH of Hosts that the nations wear themselves out for fire 8 and the peoples are exhausted for nothing? Blank 9 The interpretation of the word concerns the Spreader of the Lie, who has misdirected many, 10 building a useless city with blood and erecting a community with deceit 11 for his own glory, wearing out many by useless work and teaching them 12 a[c]ts of deceit, so that their labours are for nothing; so that 13 those who derided and insulted God’s chosen will go to the punishment of fire.
This passage elevates both the sect and the Teacher of Righteousness. The author refers to the sect as God’s “elect” (1QpHab 9:12; 10:13) and announces that its maltreatment will result in divine judgment for those who persecute them.64 The Teacher of Righteousness is once again portrayed as unjustly persecuted (1QpHab 9:10).65 Maltreatment of the Teacher of Righteousness carries with it the same heavy penalty as mistreatment of the sect, that is, divine judgment (1QpHab 9:10–12). Additionally, the passage indicates opponents of the group and judgment against them. The Wicked Priest is a Ruler of Israel who previously was not an opponent of the group (he was “called by the true name at the beginning of his course”); however, he became “arrogant,” apostatized, “betrayed the statutes,” and stole on account 64 Just as fidelity to the Teacher of Righteousness brings salvation and rejection brings divine judgment. 65 Cf. 1QpHab 5:9–12; 11:4–6.
91
of greed (cf. 1QpHab 12:10). The author identifies him with “the one who multiplies what is not his own” in Hab 2:6. All of these characteristics remind the sectarians that the Priest is indeed an opponent. The Jerusalem priests comprise another opponent (1QpHab 9:4). Hab 2:8a says, “For you have plundered many nations, but all the rest of the peoples will plunder you.” In the author’s estimation, “you” refers to the last priests of Jerusalem who, like the Wicked Priest, have amassed ill-gotten wealth; like the Wicked Priest, they will be punished for it particularly by the Romans, who are indicated as “the rest of the peoples.” The Wicked Priest receives punishment (1QpHab 9:1–2, 9–12); the last priests of Jerusalem likewise (1QpHab 9:4–7). The former appears to have already occurred while the latter awaits fruition from the author’s perspective. Notice that 1QpHab 9:4–6 presents the Romans as instruments of God wielded to punish Jerusalem priests. This is the only reference to the Kittim that does not revile them. Finally, named among the opponents of the sect is the Spreader of the Lie and his followers (1QpHab 10:9), who traffic in deceit, violence, and paths of error, lead to judgment. Col. X 14 Hab 2:14 For the earth will become full of the knowledge of YHWH’s glory just as water 15 fills the sea. Blank Interpretation of the word: 16 in his return [. . .] 17 [. . .] Col. XI 1 the Lie. Afterwards, knowledge will be revealed to them, as plentiful as the water 2 in the sea. Hab 2:15 Woe to anyone making his companion drunk, spilling out 3 his anger, or even making him drunk to look at their festivals! 4 Blank Its interpretation concerns the Wicked Priest who 5 pursued the Teacher of Righteousness to consume him with the heat 6 of his anger in the place of his banishment. In festival time, during the rest 7 of the day of Atonement, he appeared to them, to consume them 8 and make them fall on the day of fasting, the sabbath of their rest. Hab 2:16 Your are more glutted 9 with disgrace than with glory. Drink up also and stagger! 10 The cup of YHWH’s right hand will turn against you and disgrace come 11 upon your glory. Blank 12 Its interpretation concerns the Priest whose disgrace exceeded his glory 13 because he did not circumcise the foreskin of his heart and has walked on paths of 14 excessiveness to slake his thirst; but the cup of 15 [Go]d’s anger will consume him, increasing [. . .]his [dis]grace. And the pain 16 [. . .]
The passage portrays the Teacher of Righteousness as unjustly persecuted. In castigating the Wicked Priest, the author reminds the sect of the abominability of its opponent’s deeds.
92
This passage also depicts the sect as privileged to receive “revealed knowledge,” a feature which all of the three groups under study share. It also indicates some of the liturgical/ritual practices, namely, the observance of the Day of Atonement, the sabbath, and fasting. That juxtaposition of “new” (i.e., “revelation”) and “old” (i.e., observance of traditional Jewish rituals) depicts well the “in-between” nature of a sect. At one and the same time, it both defines itself over against the parent tradition and capitalizes on its connection to that tradition. As previously presented, both Wuthnow and Swidler have discussed the naturalness and advantages enjoyed by a group which ties itself to a culture or institution which is traditionally associated with the sacred. Col. XI 17 [Hab 2:17 For the violation of Lebanon will cover you, and the destruction of animals] Col. XII 1 will appal [sic] you, owing to the human blood and the violence (done to) the country, the city and all who dwell there. 2 The interpretation of the word concerns the Wicked Priest, to pay him the 3 reward for what he did to the poor. Because Lebanon is 4 the Council of the Community and the animals are the simple folk of Judah, those who observe 5 the Law. God will sentence him to destruction, Blank 6 exactly as he intended to destroy the poor. And as for what he says: Hab 2:27 <>. Its interpretation: the city is Jerusalem 8 in which the/Wicked/Priest performed repulsive acts and defiled 9 the Sanctuary of God. The violence (done to) the country are the cities of Judah which 10 he plundered of the possessions of the poor.
This passage exemplifies a number of aspects of the author’s exegetical technique. First, the author contemporizes overtly and unabashedly, applying Habakkuk’s references to his own community so that “Lebanon” is the community’s council and the “beasts” are the simple ones of Judah. Second, while on the one hand the author demystifies the text by providing such explicit equations, on the other hand he remystifies by speaking in his own “code,” which draws upon biblical idiom. So, rather than simply stating, “Alexander Jannaeus66 treated the members of our sect poorly,” he says, “The Wicked Priest persecuted ‘the poor ones’ ”; Habakkuk’s “beasts” are not described as “our Qumran community,” but rather in other cryptic terms, namely “the simple ones of Judah.” However the author chooses to denote
66
To whom the title refers remains uncertain.
93
his group, he clearly defines and elevates them both as obedient to the Law and as persecuted. Through incisive invective, the author reminds the sect of the heinousness of its opponent’s, the Wicked Priest’s, deeds. In addition, the passage assures the sectarians that, despite present appearances, God exacts judgment justly; the author accomplishes this by prophesying that God will mete out the same punishment upon the Wicked Priest as the latter attempted to inflict upon the sectarians, namely, “complete destruction.” Finally, the author claims that the Wicked Priest’s sphere of influence extends from Jerusalem to the cities of Judah. Col. XII 10 . . . Hab 2:18 What use is the sculpture which the craftsman carves, 11 (or) the cast effigy and sham oracle, in whom their craftsman trusts, 12 to make dumb idols? The interpretation of the word concerns all the 13 idols of the peoples which they made, to serve them and bow down 14 for them. But they will not save them on the day of Judgment. Hab 2:19–20 Woe, 15 wo[e, to anyone saying] to wood: Wake up! and to a silent [st]one: G[et up!] 16 [Can it instruct? It is covered with gold and silver, but no] 17 [spirit at all is therein. But YHWH is in his holy Temple.] Col. XIII 1 Silence in his presence, all the world! Its interpretation concerns all the peoples 2 which serve stone and wood. However, on the day 3 of judgment God will destroy all the worshippers of idols, 4 and the wicked, from the earth. Blank 5–15 Blank
The author presents “the nations” as enemies of the sect at 1QpHab 12:10–13:4. They cannot destroy God’s people; rather, they are to be judged by the Qumran community. They are idolatrous and as such they will be judged by God on the “day of judgment.” 1QpHab as we have it ends on a note of judgment. Previously the author has assured the sectarians that God would deal harshly with their opponents within the parent tradition; now he turns his attention to Gentile enemies and, finally, casting his net widely to include them all, he predicts judgment on “all evil ones.” The Damascus Document The year 1896 marked Solomon Schechter’s discovery of the Damascus Document (CD) in a Cairo genizah. Two manuscripts, A and B, comprise that document, the former containing sixteen columns (CD 1–16) and the latter two columns (CD 19–20). Typically scholars divide CD into the Admonition (1–8; 19–20) and the Laws (9–16). With the discovery of the Qumran cache, new evidence of the
94
document appeared primarily in the form of eight incomplete (4Qda–h or 4Q266–273).67 Of these eight, 4Q266 and 4Q270 contain the most material. After reconstructing 4QD it appears that it contained not only all of the Cairo material but additional material as well. I have chosen to use the Admonition as a sounding into the text, canvassing CD 1–8 and 19:33b–20:34 for evidence.68 Johnathan Campbell’s monograph on the use of Scripture in CD serves as my primary guide.69 With respect to CD, Campbell’s introduction implies that he has made similar observations, discovered similar gaps in scholarship, and asks some of the same questions I do with respect to the Fourth Gospel. For example, he notes the near impossibility of determining which came first, a consideration of Scripture followed by a particular interpretation or a group’s ideas projected onto Scripture. As the premise of my investigation should reveal, while I think the two work in tandem, common sense should prevent us from underestimating the latter. He also makes an astute sociological observation about scriptural interpretation in Second Temple Judaism: What does it mean for a religious group in the second century ..., or perhaps earlier, to consider its message as stemming from the Bible? In one way or another, such would be the case for almost any group of observant Jews of the time, for it is arguable that, from at least the second century onwards, the inner tensions and conflicts within Second Temple Judaism centered largely on competing claims to represent a valid interpretation of the one commonly received corpus of revelation.70
When he actually commences analysis of texts, however, our aims diverge, his being the identification of scriptural texts alluded to in seven sections of CD. Beyond indicating that the author was intentional about his usage of Scripture and identifying certain scriptural passages which exert a widespread influence on the document, Campbell rarely ventures into questions of social history. When he 67
Caves 5 and 6 yielded a few fragments as well. CD 19:1–33a, found in B, presents multifarious difficulties. For the most part, it duplicates 7:5b–8:21 of A, but there are perplexing difficulties, the explanation of which has prompted much scholarly discussion but no indubitable conclusions. For a concise introduction to the subject, see Campbell, Use, 152–60. Since I have included an investigation of 7:5b–8:21, I will not attend to 19:1–33a, as it adds nothing to my conclusions. 69 The text of CD itself, however, will be quoted from Martínez and Tigchelaar, The Dead Sea Scrolls Study Edition, 1:551–81. 70 Campbell, Use, 9. 68
95
does, he simply makes a provocative comment here or there but fails to pursue a social-historical line of questioning.71 Much scholarly attention has been devoted to the redactional history of the text, especially given the irreconcilable or contradictory elements apparent in the triple-presentation of the sect’s history in the Admonition at 1:1–2:1; 2:14–4:12a; and 5:15b–6:11a. My investigation does not depend significantly upon the proper designation of each stratum. As I have noted regarding the Fourth Gospel, the final form commands attention for two reasons. First, mine is a quest for the social function of the use of Scripture embodied in the text rather than a strictly literary inquiry into issues of form, structure, etc. The second point results from the first, namely, the ancient community used and preserved these texts, with all of the seams and discrepancies that discomfit the modern reader, so I do not presume that the discrepancies are a “problem to be solved”; at most they are an inroad to further insight about how the texts functioned for ancient groups. Because my question is one step removed from the “narrative level” of the text, I am under no compunction to harmonize the various details, but only to suggest what the author (or authors if the text represents various phases of the sect’s existence) is trying to accomplish as a shaper of this sect’s imagination, Weltanschauung, and practices.72 To be sure, it is necessary to have a general understanding of what the author intends at the “narrative level” in order to determine what he is trying to achieve for his group. So, when the author refers to someone as “the scoffer” it is important to recognize that he refers to a leader of Israel, but whether the leader is Jannaeus or Simon or represents both at the same time does not affect my project significantly.
71
I recommend the book as a compendium of citations and allusions in the seven sections of CD that he treats. By analogy it serves a purpose similar to NestleAland’s Appendix III: Loci Citati Vel Allegati. Campbell’s presentation also provides excellent bibliography and touches briefly on some textual problems in light of the discovery of the relevant to CD. The lack of a concordance renders a quick comparison of terminology in the document difficult. 72 That at least one other scholar deems the enterprise worthy or possible is indicated by Campbell’s comment as he turns from an analysis of sources behind the so-called “historical” sections to what he calls the “midrashic” sections: “Indeed, the remainder of the Admonition can be characterized by its immediate, practical interest, expressed very largely through the direct quotation and interpretation of Scripture.” Campbell, Use, 105.
96
What does matter relative to the historical sections of CD and the origins of the sect is this: “[P]art-way through the story there is a shift from ancient Israel to the formation and development of the group behind the Admonition. Thus, the story of the [sic] God’s involvement with biblical Israel culminates in the establishment of the community commended in CD 1–8 and 19–20. . . .”73 As with the Fourth Gospel and 4QMMT, I deal primarily with direct citations introduced by a formula not because loud allusions and soft echoes do not matter, but simply to avoid undertaking the unfeasible task of discussing every citation, allusion, and echo in the texts.74 Col. I (= 4Q266 2 I–II) 10b And God appraised their deeds, because they sought him with an undivided heart, 11 and raised up for them a Teacher of Righteousness, in order to direct them in the path of his heart. Blank. And he made known 12 to the last generations what he had done for the last generation, the congregation of traitors. 13 These are the ones who stray from the path. This is the time about which it has been written: Hos 4:16 <>, when <> (ˆwxlh çya) arose, who poured out over Israel 15 waters of lies and made them stray into a wilderness without path, causing the everlasting heights to sink down, diverging 16 from tracks of justice and removing the boundary with which the forefathers had marked their inheritance, so that 17 the curses of his covenant would adhere to them, to deliver them up to the sword carrying out the vengeance 18 of the covenant. For they sought easy interpretations (twqljb wçrd), chose illusions, scrutinised 19 loopholes, chose the handsome neck, acquitted the guilty and sentenced the just, 20 violated the covenant, broke the precept, banded together against the life of the just man, their soul abominated all those who walk 21 in perfection, they hunted them down with the sword and provoked the dispute of the people. And kindled was the wrath of Col. II (= 4Q266 2 II) God against their congregation, laying waste all its great number, for their deeds were unclean in front of him.75
73
Ibid., 202. Nevertheless, Campbell’s warning is prudent: “[W]e should avoid overemphasizing the role of quotations, since no consistent criteria can be detected which determined whether a reference to the Bible should be overt or subtle. Thus, for example, while no text from Jer is cited, our survey shows clearly that it would be wrong to suggest that Jer 23, 25, 27 are any less important in the Admonition than, say, Hos 3–4, from which verses are quoted. On the other hand, some passages that appear peripheral, when set against the entire body of influential texts, are cited by the author, as in the case of Mal 1:10 in CD 6:12. An acknowledgement of overt Bible usage only, therefore, could lead the student of CD in the wrong direction.” Ibid., 178. 75 CD speaks of a shoot of the planting (t[fm çrwç); the Fourth Gospel speaks 74
97
CD 1:1–2:1 has spawned much debate in which scholars take turns supplying referents for the author’s cryptic designations and propose various theories for the historical development of the group. Campbell has identified no less than fifty biblical allusions in CD 1:1–2:1, most of which are related to the exile. He barely mentions the direct citation in his discussion, however, which remains at an abstract level and does not venture into the social. He does little more than present his case justifying why he detects an allusion here or there. All of his discussion leads only to this conclusion: “Such data lead us to different conclusions than those of some scholars. Indeed, it may be conjectured that considerable care went into forming the narrative of CD 1:1–2:1, whatever is to be made of the historical problems outlined above. Further analysis of the rest of CD . . . is now in order to determine whether the same applies to the remainder of the Admonition.”76 It is clear that the author inveighs against a leader of Israel, the scoffer, who is described in terms which contrast with the Teacher of Righteousness in 1:11. This person had considerable power inasmuch as he successfully led “Israel” astray into “a wilderness without path” (˚rd al whwtb µ[ty) as compared with the Teacher of Righteousness who was sent “to direct them in the path of his heart” (wbl ˚rdb µkyrdhl). As in 1QpHab, the opponents are here characterized as breaking the precepts of the Torah (CD 1:20), and the author confidently predicts that divine judgment awaits them (CD 1:16–17; 1:21–2:1). Furthermore, like his 1QpHab counterpart, the author of CD expresses certainty that the biblical texts were written about the author’s own time and predicted that those of the parent tradition would be led astray. As I observed in our other texts, when the author lambastes those of the parent tradition, he bestows his greatest calumny upon the leaders of Israel who cause Israel to stray. Col. III (= 4Q269 2) 7 to them in Qadesh: Deut 9:23 <. But they preferred the desire>> of their spirit, and did not listen to 8 the voice of their creator, the precepts he had taught them, and murmured in their tents. of Jesus as the vine and the Christians as the branch; such language is adopted by the Adventist sectarians, the Branch Davidians. It would be worthwhile to see if this kind of language is typical for sectarians or whether it is ubiquitous in JudeoChristian history at large. 76 Campbell, Use, 66.
98
Through this retrospective historical recounting, the author uses Scripture to create “them,” to explain the nature of the opponents now by looking to the past where the sectarians can see the inexorability of the present situation. The opponents, like God’s opponents of old, opposed God’s precepts and “murmured.”77 Col. III 20 . . . Those who remained steadfast in it will acquire eternal life, and all the glory of Adam is for them. As 21 God swore to them by means of Ezekiel the prophet, saying: Ez 44:15 <>.
In the immediate context the author recounts Israelite history for exemplary purposes so that his readers may despise evil and choose rightly.78 As with Pesher Habakkuk and the Fourth Gospel, revelation plays a central role for the small group of the faithful. CD 3:10–12 indicates that salvation depends on adherence to the sect, a group characterized as “holding fast to the law.” The author of CD presents the biblical text in an altered form by adding a waw before µywlh and qwdx ynb thereby creating three groups where there had been one; he then identifies them. The MT of Ezek 44:15 reads:
yl'[+ y; îq, la,rc: y] AI yneB] twº[to B] i y!vDi q ; m] i tr,mº v, m] Ai ta, Wr⁄mv] ; rv! a, } qwdøfix; yneB] µYwI⁄i lh] ' µyn!hI K} hø w' “ 79 hwhy ynda µan µd+w: : bl, j¢e y!li byràq i h] l' ] yn" p;fi l] Wd¢m][;w“ ynI t- er]vâ;lø] yl`'ae Wbàr“q]yI hM; I hì e The three groups are described in the following terms: “The priests are converts of Israel, who left the land of Judah; and the levites are those who joined them; and the sons of Zadok are the chosen of Israel, the men of renown, who stand (to serve) at the end of days” (CD 4:2–4). Though the exact determination of these groups and which historical phase they allude to remains elusive, the author 77 The student of the Fourth Gospel notes a similar accusation on the part of the Johannine sectarian author against the parent tradition in John 6. 78 “Thus, by knowing what went wrong with previous generations, as far back as the Watchers, as well as why and to what effect, the reader can choose aright so as to avoid the same fate.” Campbell, Use, 68. 79 “But the levitical priests, the descendants of Zadok, who kept the charge of my sanctuary when the people of Israel went astray from me, shall come near to me to minister to me; and they shall attend me to offer me the fat and the blood, says the Lord GOD” (NRSV).
99
intends to signify the sect and reveal something of its establishment, the fact that it broke away or withdrew from the parent tradition. As Campbell notes, “The biblical verse, featuring the qwdx ynb once more, is used to prove that the community was raised up to inherit the covenantal promises.”80 The sectarians are elevated as “men of renown,” an elect group, and they operate within a history which is drawing to a close. The eschatological note may serve a two-fold purpose. If we were to assume that the author wrote in part for potential proselytes, we might cite this as an example of the use of Scripture for persuading them to join the sect, since at CD 3:10–12 we learn that anyone outside the sect (house of Judah),81 “when the period corresponding to the number of these years is complete,” will fare poorly. At this point the author only expresses concern for Israelites who do not join the sect, ignoring Gentiles. The author displays an overt interest in boundaries, here depicted as a “wall” which divides insiders and outsiders (CD 4:12). If we assume that the author expects only the sectarians to read the text, we must assume that the ostensible interest in proselytizing is a backhanded way of encouraging present members to continue to adhere to the sect. Of course, it does not have to be an either/or; the author could have more than one group in mind, though I suspect that the sect is the main audience. Certainly that is how the rhetoric works for David Koresh. Col. IV 12 . . . And during all these years 13 Belial will be set loose against Israel, as God has said by means of the prophet Isaiah, son of 14 Amoz, saying: Isa 24:17 <<Panic, pit and net against you, earthdweller>>.
In the previous verses the author has warned that the time for joining the sect, “the house of Judah,” is growing short and those who remain outside should expect divine judgment. In this passage the author declares God’s judgment and punishment upon Jewish nonsectarians and acts as though the claim that God will enact it by means of Belial is a natural interpretation of the Isaiah text and that the time frame implied is the sect’s own. The author degrades the Jewish opponents by interpreting Isaiah’s “net” as three nets: fornication, wealth, and defilement of the temple. 80
Campbell, Use, 83. Once again, we see evidence of the importance of belonging to the right “house.” Cf. n. 63 above. 81
100
Col. IV 19b The builders of the wall who go after Zaw—Zaw is the preacher 20 of whom he said: Mic 2:6 <>— are caught twice in fornication: by taking 21 two wives in their lives, even though the principle of creation is Gen 1:27 <<male and female he created them>>. Col. V (= 4Q266 3 II; 4Q267 2) 1 And the ones who went into the ark Gen 7:9 <<went in two by two into the ark>>. Blank And about the prince it is written: 2 Deut 17:17 <>.82
This passage actually contains three direct quotations but as they are so closely related it seems best to present them together. The author applies Micah’s words, indicating a plural subject, to an individual, Zaw,83 who must be an influential leader among the non-sectarian Jews who teaches his followers to break the law through polygyny.84 The author amasses scriptural evidence to support his stated view. Col. V 8b But Moses said: Lev 18:13 <>. The law of incest, 10 written for males, applies equally to females. . . .85
Here the author deploys Scripture to degrade his Jewish opponents by once again accusing them of violating the law, this time through incest. In so doing, he implies ethical regulations for his own group. Given the perennial claim about the absence of women at Qumran, CD contains surprising material, such as this concern to apply the 82
Because they do not contain an introductory formula, Campbell (Use, 125) considers Gen 1:27 and 7:9 “virtual quotations.” 83 Regarding the identity of this figure Campbell writes: “Another possibility is to identify the wx with the ˆwxlh çya of CD 1:14, because both contexts utilize the epithet πyfm. He may then be equated with one of the Maccabee brothers, so that the ≈yth ynwb are then literally ‘builders’ of Jerusalem in the mid-second century ..., working under his command. Numerous other theories of identification have, of course, been put forward,” Ibid., 122. Perhaps this figure is synonymous with that of 1QpHab 10:9, since both opponents are designated as πyfm. If so, we may add this as evidence for the Man of Lies. 84 The brevity and, to the modern reader uninitiated in the sect, obscurity in the invocation of the Micah passage reminds us that a thorough study of the biblical texts in their original context would shed even greater light on how the author deploys Scripture. For instance, Campbell, who treats allusions as well as direct citations, lists Mic 2 as a text which considerably influences at least the three historical sections in the Admonition. 85 Were the text of CD presented here extended to include vv. 13ff., we would note the “virtual quotation” of Isa 59:5: “They hatch adders’ eggs, and weave the spider’s web; whoever eats their eggs dies, and the crushed egg hatches out a viper,” and Isa 50:11a: “But all of you are kindlers of fire, lighters of firebrands.” This serves, quite obviously, to degrade the Jewish opponents.
101
law of incest to females though the original text clearly does not take that step.86 Col. VI 2b And he raised from Aaron men of knowledge and from Israel 3 wise men, and made them listen. And they dug the well: Num 21:18 <>. The well is the law. And those who dug it Blank are 5 the converts of Israel, who left the land of Judah and lived in the land of Damascus, 6 all of whom God called princes, for they sought him, and their renown has not been repudiated 7 in anyone’s mouth.
The original text finds God miraculously providing water to the Israelites as they travel to Moab and Ammon and it follows closely upon the heels of the bronze serpent stories.87 The author interprets and applies this to his own community. He elevates the sectarians as princes of renown who are above repudiation. It bespeaks the sect’s history, withdrawal, and separation from the parent tradition apparently due to issues concerning the law. The boldness of the author’s language implies a profound disagreement as he claims that the sectarians actually dug the well, which is the law. It is not the case that the sectarians and the parent tradition agree on the fundamentals of the law and differ on a few minor points; rather, so drastic is the disparity that the author uses language of something “new” (çdj; v. 19) being inaugurated. The author’s use of “land of Damascus” reminds the reader that, like the Branch Davidians, the Qumran community resided in a location physically separate from any other community. This is one overt way to draw boundaries and mark off the sacred from the profane. Indeed, in addition to rituals, dress, and distinctive behavior, “architecture” is one feature of congregational life to which sociologists of religion point when studying how religious groups draw boundaries. Col. VI 7b And the staff ( qqwjmh) is the interpreter of the law (hrwth çwrd), of whom 8 Isaiah said: Isa 54:16 <>. Blank And the nobles of the people are 9 those who came to dig the well with the staves that the sceptre decreed, 10 to walk in them throughout the whole age of wickedness, and without which they will not obtain it, until there arises 11 he who teaches justice (qdxh hrwy) at the end of days. 86
Cf. CD 3:6–9. Both the divinely supplied water and the bronze serpent incident pique the interest of the student of the Fourth Gospel. 87
102
Now the author uses Scripture to interpret Scripture. Isaiah illuminates Numbers to the effect of describing a leader of the sectarians, here called hrwth çwrd.88 How the qqwjmh, hrwth çwrd, and hrwy qdxh are related and whether or not they represent the same historical figure is debatable,89 but for our present purposes it is clear that the Teacher of Righteousness is an eschatological figure upon whom correct observance of the law depends. The leader (or leaders) described here is divinely ordained and privy to special insight by which he leads the sectarians.90 Col. VI 11b But all those who have been brought into the covenant 12 shall not enter the temple to kindle his altar in vain. They will be the ones who close 13 the door, as God said (la rma rça): Mal 1:10 <<Whoever amongst you will close my door Blank so that you do not kindle my altar 14 in vain!>>. They should take care to act in accordance with the exact interpretation of the law for the age of wickedness: to keep apart 15 from the sons of the pit; to abstain from wicked wealth which defiles, either by promise or by vow, 16 and from the wealth of the temple and from stealing from the poor of the people, making widows their spoils 17 and murdering orphans; to separate unclean from clean and differentiate between 18 the holy and the common; to keep the sabbath day according to its exact interpretation, and the festivals 19 and the day of fasting, according to what was discovered (axm) by those who entered the new covenant (hçdjh tyrbh) in the land of Damascus (qçmd).
The author applies the words of Malachi to the sect, once again indicating that it is the sectarians who are alluded to in the text; that they should strictly observe the law and maintain clear boundaries. There is concern for ritual practices such as sabbath observance, fasting, and festival days. The opponents are degraded as “sons of the pit” and are presumably Jewish, given the implication that they are associated with the ill-gotten wealth of the temple. The 88 Whether or not this figure is synonymous with the Teacher of Righteousness is debatable. 89 As is the relationship between the citation of Num 21:18 at 6:3–4 and the citation of Isa 54 here. Campbell (Use, 97) suggests that “the significance of the citation in CD 6:8 probably relates to mention of the qqwjm, for it would appear that the ylk in Isa 54:16 has been taken as a parallel to qqjm in Nu 21:18.” 90 It is unlikely that the interpreter of the law and the Teacher of Righteousness are identical in the author’s scheme, as the former refers to a former stage of the sect and the latter to a later figure. It may even be that one or both are functional terms rather than titles or personal code names. The point, however, lies in the fact that this use of Scripture tells us something about the loci of authority in the group and the ordained nature of the leaders.
103
passage further substantiates the observation above that opponents, Jew or Gentile, are generally defamed as greedy, law-breaking, violent people. The clichéd nature of the accusation detracts somewhat from the likelihood of its historical accuracy, but accuracy of the degradation is irrelevant for my purposes. The passage elevates the sectarians as those who have “discovered” something of God’s plan and belong to a “new” covenant with God. They define themselves as those who have withdrawn to the “land of Damascus,” a phrase that constitutes insider language. Col. VII 6b And if they reside in camps in accordance with the rule of the land, and take 7 women and beget children, they shall walk in accordance with the law Blank and according to the regulation 8 of the teachings, according to the rule of the law, as he said: Num 30:17 <>.
The author appears to use Scripture here either to justify a practice among the sectarians or to command it. Col. VII 9b But (for) all those who despise: when God visits the earth in order to empty over them the punishment of the wicked, 10 when there comes the word which is written in the words of Isaiah, son of Amoz, the prophet, 11 who said: Isa 7:17 < come since the day Ephraim departed from Judah>>. When the two houses of Israel separated, 13 Ephraim detached itself from Judah, and all the renegades were delivered up to the sword; but those who remained steadfast 14 escaped to the land of the north. Blank As he said Am 5:26–27 <>. Blank The books of the law are the Sukkat 16 of the King, as he said Am 9:11 <>. Blank The King 17 is the assembly; and the Kiyyune of the images are the books of the prophets, 18 whose words Israel despised. Blank And the star is the Interpreter of the law, 19 who will come to Damascus, as is written: Num 24:13[sic], 24:17 <>. The sceptre is the prince of the whole congregation and when he rises he will destroy 21 all the sons of Seth. Blank These escaped at the time of the first visitation Col. VIII 1 while the renegades were delivered up to the sword. Thus will be the judgment of all those entering his covenant but who 2 do not remain steadfast in them; they shall be visited for destruction at the hand of Belial. This is the day 3 when God will make a visitation.91 91
Campbell, Use, 132 n. 77: “There are marked differences between Mss A and
104
Because these three instances of direct citation are so interrelated, it is best to treat them together. While a thorough exegesis of this rather complicated passage cannot be undertaken here, some information relevant to our task can be gleaned. The author uses the first scriptural citation to predict judgment, though without the following text it is not quite clear upon whom that judgment will fall. The first three scriptural citations yield the following contention on the author’s part: at an earlier phase the sect, Ephraim, broke away from the parent tradition, Judah, and God’s favor was upon the former (and wrath upon the latter), so much so that God chose to entrust the books of the Law and the prophets to the small but “steadfast” sect. In escaping to the “north” the sect allegedly went to Damascus (a term used numerous times in this document to designate the sect). The opponents, Israel, are defamed as “despisers of the law.” God did not leave the sect bereft of leadership but supplied an Interpreter of the Law as well as a “prince of the whole congregation”92 whose main purpose lies in the destruction of those who have apostatized from the sect, the sons of Seth. Garfinkel’s work concerning degradation ceremonies resurfaces here as the author wants to show that it is not simply the case that these apostates were firm believers who somehow fell away, but rather that they never really were what they appeared to be. They never were essentially “one of us” but imposters who somehow were fortunate enough not to be discovered during the first visitation. Their luck, however, has run out, and the author assures the group that these apostates will suffer greatly.93 Col. VIII 8b They did not keep apart from the people and have rebelled with insolence, 9 walking on the path of the wicked ones, about whom God says: Deut 32:33 <>. Blank The serpents are the kings of the peoples Blank and the wine is 11 their paths, and the asps’ poison is the head of the kings of Greece, who comes to carry out vengeance against them.
B in CD 7:9b–8:2a and 19:5b–14, respectively. This chiefly concerns the biblical texts chosen for proof and illustration. Ms A uses Is 7:17; Am 5:27a; and Nu 24:17, whereas Ms B employs Zec 13:7 and Ez 9:4.” Ms A is followed in this study. 92 I do not include this figure under leaders of the group because I suspect he is a supernatural eschatological figure. 93 I do not exclude the possibility that the author also uses Scripture to predict judgment on non-sectarian Jews as well, since he presumably addresses “all despisers” (µysawmh); however, a closer reading of the text implies greater concern with apostates.
105
Col. VIII 14 And what Moses said: Deut 9:5 <>. 16 Blank And thus is the judgment of the converts of Israel, who turned aside from the path of the people: on account of God’s love for 17 the forefathers, who following him, he loves those who come after them, because to them belongs 18 the fathers’ covenant.
This appears to announce judgment for apostates from the sect. Campbell claims that it signifies election of the sect and reassures the sectarians that “as God loved the µynçar, so too does he love µhyrja µyabh.”94 Col. XX 13b And from the day 14 of the gathering in of the unique teacher, until the end of all the men of war who turned back 15 with the man of lies, there shall be about forty years. Blank And in this age the wrath 16 of God will be kindled against Israel, as he said: Hos 3:4 <>.
The author denounces one of the leaders of Israel as the Man of Lies and foretells God’s judgment upon those who follow him, especially apostates. This wrathful judgment contrasts with the abundant blessings to be enjoyed by the sectarians themselves (CD 20:17ff.). The citation substantiates the author’s own view that the sect is the proper recipient of God’s love and covenant. 4QMMT 4QMMT’s fragmentary condition necessitates a considerable amount of reconstruction, which leaves ample room for debate and circumspection and little room for claims of certainty. The editors often depend on other Qumran texts, especially the Temple Scroll, in their reconstruction. The reconstructed nature of the text does not jeopardize my undertaking, however, because enough is certain to make general claims about how Scripture functioned socially for the people related to this text. The author alludes both directly and indirectly to Scripture and does so intentionally. Just as the entirety of 1QpHab purports to be merely an interpretation of the biblical text, so also 4QMMT claims that it contains “some 94
Campbell, Use, 148.
106
of the rulings according to the precepts of the Torah.” Conceivably, then, one might chart the whole text on the table, since the author presents the text as an explication of part of the Bible. Unlike 1QpHab, however, this text does not systematically quote Scripture and then explicate it. It is best, therefore, to stick to explicit references to Scripture either in the form of citations introduced by a formula or in the form of more general reference to Scripture such as “the books of Moses, the precepts of Torah,” etc.95 Those references appear at: B 9–11 (GM 12–14); B 27–35 (GM 30b–38); B37–38 (GM 40–41); B 66–67 (GM 69B–73a); B 70 (GM 73b); B 75–76 (GM 78–79a); B 76–77 (GM 79b–80a); B 77–78 (GM 80b); C 6–7 (GM 91b); C 12 (GM 97a), C 12 (GM 97b–102); C 17 (GM 103–106a); C 20 (GM 106b–107a).96 At the “narrative level,” so to speak, the author ostensibly composes the letter in order to persuade the recipient to adopt the precepts and practices of the author’s community. The fact that numerous copies of the letter were found among the texts preserved at Qumran implies that it secondarily (or even primarily if the letter form was a rhetorical rather than actual device) may have served to inculcate or validate certain beliefs and practices at Qumran. How does the use of Scripture achieve the ostensible purposes of the author and how might it have reinforced the community’s own practices and beliefs? Before those questions are answered, attention to a number of points regarding the overall nature of the letter vis-à-vis Scripture is in order. First, the High Priest issue. If the letter was, in fact, penned for the eyes of the High Priest (and I remain skeptical about this), then one could say that the entire letter reveals opposition from the parent religion, especially the High Priest/Wicked Priest, but also all Jews who break Torah precepts as defined by the sect’s leaders. Second, because the author wants to prove that the sectarians observe Scripture’s precepts while the opponents patently do not, all of the scriptural references degrade the enemy while elevating the sectarians.
95
In addition to the scriptural materials, the text contains evidence relevant to the various categories on the chart, but I remind the reader that my concern lies primarily with the social function of Scripture as used by the author. 96 The references are drawn from the Qimron-Strugnell DJD edition of 4QMMT. To facilitate the reader’s ability to refer to the text, references to the lines of the composite manuscript are provided in parentheses, as given by Martínez in Dead Sea Scrolls Translated, 76–85.
107
Third, because the author bothers to write the letter to persuade the addressee of his position, all of the references show a residual concern for the parent tradition and seek to proselytize. Finally, whether the halakot derived from and/or validated by Scripture imply provision of ethical imperatives remains somewhat problematic in the text insofar as some of the halakot address temple rituals. I have circumspectly decided not to infer sectarian ethical regulations and practices from those instances but only suggest such where the regulation could be practiced within the sect itself. 4QMMT expresses concern not only for what the sectarians believe, but also for what they do.97 We can identify at least three parties in 4QMMT by the appearance of first, second, and third person pronouns: the author’s group (the sect), the addressee’s group (followers of the Wicked Priest?), and a third group (Pharisees?). B 9–11 (GM 12–14): [And concerning the cereal offering] of the sacrifice of well-being which they (the opponents) leave over from one day to the following one: but [it is written] that the cereal offer[ing is to be ea]ten after the suet and the flesh (are sacrificed), on the day when they are sacri[ficed (i.e. before sunset).
B 9–11 concerns the proper time to eat a cereal offering, but since Scripture does not specifically address cereal offerings, the author turns by way of analogy to such texts as Lev 7:15 or Lev 22:29. The author apparently interprets sunset as the beginning of a new day, whereas the opponents count the new day with the dawn. The passage provides an ethical imperative for the members of the sect and it demonstrates the sect’s presupposition that Scripture is a major locus of authority. As was the case in both 1QpHab and CD, opponents are degraded in terms of their unwillingness to keep the law. B 27–35 (GM 30b–38): [And concerning] that it is written: [if a person slaughters inside the camp, or slaughters] outside the camp cattle or sheep or goat: for [ . . . in] the northern part of the camp. And we are of the opinion that [-ç µybçwj wnjnaw] the sanctuary [is the ‘tent of meeting’] and that Jerusalem is the ‘camp’, and that ‘outside the 97 In noting the biblical allusion to Gen 15:6 at 4QMMT C31–32, Moshe Bernstein “wonder[s] whether the employment of Gen 15:6 in 4QMMT is not meant to convey an overtone of proper belief or of taking something on trust ( ˆmahw), as well as proper practice” (my italics). Moshe Bernstein, “The Employment and Interpretation of Scripture” in Reading 4QMMT: New Perspectives on Qumran Law and History (ed. John Kampen and Moshe Bernstein; Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1996), 36.
108
camp’ [is outside Jerusalem], that is, the encampment of their settlements. It is ‘outside the c[amp’ where one should . . . the purification-offering and] take out the ashes of ]the altar and bu[rn the purification-offering. For Jerusalem] is the place which [He has chosen] from among all the tribes [of Israel . . .] they do [not] slaughter in the sanctuary.
B 27–35 appears in the context of proper slaughtering practices. The author quotes and interprets part of Lev 17:2–5, which in its entirety reads: “Speak to Aaron and his sons and to all the people of Israel and say to them: This is what the L has commanded. If anyone of the house of Israel slaughters an ox or a lamb or a goat in the camp, or slaughters it outside the camp, and does not bring it to the entrance of the tent of meeting, to present it as an offering to the L before the tabernacle of the L, he shall be held guilty of bloodshed; he has shed blood, and he shall be cut off from the people.” The author applies the ancient text to contemporary concerns by interpreting the ancient “tent of meeting” as the contemporary Jerusalem temple sanctuary and the “camp” to mean the city Jerusalem, so that “outside the camp” signifies outside Jerusalem.98 In consulting the Temple Scroll, which also treats this Leviticus passage, it would appear that the opponents do not slaughter in the sanctuary, whereas the author believes that they should. For the sect this passage serves a number of purposes. It upholds the authority of Scripture. It degrades “them,” in this case as those who transgress Torah because “they do not slaughter in the sanctuary.” Furthermore, the phrase -ç µybçwj wnjnaw locates authority in the sectarian leader(s) and appears throughout the Halakic Letter (4QMMT B 36, 37, 42, 55, 64, 73). The authority of the letter’s “we” is further demonstrated in the hortatory section which concludes the letter: “[And] we have [written] to you so that you may study (carefully) the book of Moses and the books of the Prophets and (the writings of ) David [and the events of ] ages past” (4QMMT C 10); and “We have indeed sent you some of the precepts of the Torah according to our decision, for your welfare and the welfare of your people” (4QMMT C 26–27). The latter passage may indicate that the letter was written to the Hasmonean High Priest; if that is the case, it further evinces opposition from the parent tradi98 Cf. B 59–62: “For Jerusalem is the camp of holiness and is the place which He has chosen from among all the places of the tribes of Israel. For Jerusalem is the chief of the camps of Israel.”
109
tion, particularly the High Priest. The sectarian leaders know God’s economy (4QMMT C 20) which elevates them and, presumably, the sect which follows them. Finally, the fact that the leader(s) composed the letter and sent it to the High Priest reveals a residual concern for the parent tradition. While the authors do concern themselves with providing ritual imperatives here, I do not include it because, unlike other halakot in 4QMMT, I am unsure that this one would apply to the sect’s own community since it treats a temple matter. B 37–38 (GM 40–41): [. . . And concerning] eating (a fetus): we are of the opinion that the fetus [found in its (dead) mother’s womb may be eaten (only) after it has been ritually slaughtered. And you know that it is] so, namely that the ruling refers (to) (bwtk) a pregnant animal.
Qimron’s translation obscures the occurrence of bwtk in this passage, which refers to Lev 22:28; 4QMMT makes the unusual move of applying Lev 22:28 to pregnant animals, a move that places it in opposition to rabbinic law.99 The passage serves the following functions for the sect: it upholds the authority of Scripture, provides a ritual imperative, and ascribes authority to the sectarian leader(s) through the phrase -ç µybçwj wn jnaw, which is then connected with what is “written.” The authors’ reminding the reader of what the reader “knows” regarding Scripture paraenetically brings the reader into the sect. B 66–70a (GM 69b–73a): And it is (indeed) written that after he (i.e. the leper) shaves and washes he should dwell outside [his tent seven] days; but now while their impurity is (still) with them le[pers enter] into a house containing sacred food. And you know [that if someone violates a prohibitive commandment unintentionally], and the fact escapes him, he should bring a purification offering.
Both Lev 13:46 and 14:1–32 are evidenced here. The former reads: “He shall remain unclean as long as he has the disease; he is unclean. He shall live alone; his dwelling shall be outside the camp.” Lev 14:1–32 addresses the healing of a leper and demarcates a threephase process. The particular citation above draws from Lev 14:8, which describes the first phase: “The one who is to be cleansed shall wash his clothes, and shave off all his hair, and bathe himself in
99
Qimron and Strugnell, DJD X, 157.
110
water, and he shall be clean. After that he shall come into the camp, but shall live outside his tent seven days.”100 It appears in a section about the purity of lepers at different stages of their healing. The author eschews the opponents’ more liberal view,101 which allows the leper to enter a house containing sacred food during the first phase, and espouses a more stringent view, which would bar entrance. The author manifests tolerance for those who violate commands accidentally.102 For the sect, the scriptural citation once again upholds the authority of Scripture and provides an ethical imperative. It is important to draw attention to the author’s penchant for clemency toward ofl pollo¤ in sharp contrast with B 70–71 below, where he impugns the leaders who should know better but instead “allow” the lepers to eat the sacred food. This is a characteristic evident in all of our sectarian texts, namely, while the sectarian leaders consider all those of the parent tradition who are not for them to be against them, a peculiar vehemence is reserved for and directed against the leaders. Students of the Fourth Gospel usually wonder at John’s ambiguous use of the term ÉIouda›oi to mean all Jews at times but only the scribes, Pharisees, and chief priests at other times. Something similar to 4QMMT’s attitude toward the “enemies” occurs in the Fourth Gospel. This passage also displays 4QMMT’s typical concern for purity, boundaries, and proper social relations. Drawing clear boundaries is an effective and concrete way to develop sectarian cohesion. Recall Swidler’s observation that during high ideology periods, in which a sect tries to establish an identity and a culture for its members, such issues assume great importance. Sectarian ideology does not tolerate ambiguities or multiple interpretations; rather, it seeks to clearly enunciate an overarching worldview for its members. The same phenomenon is seen when 4QMMT deals with issues of marriage. 100
Lev 14:9 and 14:20 provide the second and third phases, respectively. The rabbis’ views reflect a stance closer to the opponents’ than the sectarians’, according to the evidence in m. Neg. All agree, however, that a leper cannot partake of the sacred food until sunset on the eighth day. For the full discussion, see Qimron and Strugnell, DJD X, 166–70. 102 Bernstein restores the text to read as follows: “They shall be alone [outside the city. And] it is also written that from the time that he shaves and washes [h]e shall remain outside [his house for seven d]ays,” with the result that the author insists on two points: (1) lepers be kept out of cities and (2) during the purification period they be excluded from their homes. Bernstein, “Employment,” 43–44. 101
111
B 70–72 (GM 73b): [and concerning him who purposely transgresses the precepts it is writ]ten that he ‘despises and blasphemes’. [Moreover, since they have the] impurity of leprosy, one should not let them (the lepers) eat of the sacred food until sunset on the eighth day.
The author’s complaint seems to be lodged against those who “let them (the lepers) eat of the sacred food,” thereby implying that the debate exists at the level of leadership. The whole section begins with the words, “And concerning (healed) lepers we are [of the opinion that they . . .],” the phrase “we are of the opinion” occurring throughout the text. The author views himself as influential and argues with opponents who enjoy similar influence. In accusing the opponents of despising and blaspheming, the author may draw from Num 15:30–31.103 This passage presents Scripture and the sect’s leaders as loci of authority. It degrades “them,” in this case as those who “despise and blaspheme” because they transgress Torah. B 75–76 (GM 78–79a): And concerning104 the practice of illegal marriage that exists among the people: (this practice exists) despite their being so[ns] of holy [seed], as is written, Israel is holy.
Scholars debate whether this refers to marriage between priests and laity or between Israelites and non-Israelites. Qimron and Strugnell prefer the former.105 They also contend that the author has in mind here not Jer 2:3, “Israel was holy to the L,” but rather “that Israel is holy according to the scripture.”106 What, if anything, does this passage imply for the Qumran sect? It would appear that it does not forbid marriage in general but only 103 Num 15:27–31: “An individual who sins unintentionally shall present a female goat a year old for a sin offering. And the priest shall make atonement before the L for the one who commits an error, when it is unintentional, to make atonement for the person, who then shall be forgiven. For both the native among the Israelites and the alien residing among them—you shall have the same law for anyone who acts in error. But whoever acts high-handedly, whether a native or an alien, affronts the L, and shall be cut off from among the people. Because of having despised the word of the L and broken his commandment, such a person shall be utterly cut off and bear the guilt.” 104 The author introduces each topic with the phrase lx πaw. This approximates Paul’s epistolary technique using per‹ d° and must be factored into a decision about the genre of 4QMMT. For such a discussion, see Qimron and Strugnell, DJD X, 113–14. 105 See Ibid., 171–75, for their argument. 106 Ibid., 55.
1