This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
hM;v: Úyh`, Ola‘ hwì :hy“ .Úvâ,p]n"Alk;b]W Ú`b]b;l“Alk;B] Úyn< +b;W hT∞ ;a' µw Y–ho ' Ú¡ù W“x'm] yk∆InOa;Arv,a} r ví ,a} µyM+i['h¢;AlK;mi Ú!x]B,qiw“ bc;wO“ Úm-<j}riw“ Ú¡t]Wbv]Ata, Úyhi à,fila‘ hwí :hy“ bv;! w“ 30:3 >hM;vâ; Úyt™l, øa‘ hw :hy“ IÚàx]ypâih‘ ⁄ 112
Ibid., 59.
115
The author adds “at the end of days,” creating an eschatological significance for the text which is to be realized contemporarily113 and omits the phrase “which I have set before you.” The omission of >hM;vâ; Úyh™ l, øa‘ hwì :hy“ Úài j}yDihi r ví ,a} µy+wOi Gh'Alk;B] constitutes a more important move because, if intentional, it finds the author erasing the allusion to the historical dispersion of Israel. This achieves the following for the sect: it sets its experience in an eschatological context, and, while ostensibly seeking to convert the addressee to the sectarian worldview, it implicitly exhorts those already “in” to remain faithful and so achieve salvation. Furthermore, it implies that the scriptural text finds its telos in the sect’s own generation, degrades the opponents as those who stray from Torah, and espouses a clear notion of judgment for non-sectarians. C 17–20 (GM 103–106a): [It is written in the book] of Moses [and in the books of the Prophets] that there will come [. . .] [the blessings have (already) befallen in . . .] in the days of Solomon the son of David. And the curses [that] have (already) befallen from the days of Jeroboam the son of Nebat and up to when Jerusalem and Zedekiah King of Judah went into captivity that He will bring them [. . .].
The author exhorts the addressee to turn to Scripture, especially the history of the kings, in order to learn from them. The passage achieves the following for the sect: it sets their experience in an eschatological context, implies that the scriptural text finds its telos in the sect’s own generation, and espouses a clear notion of divine judgment. C 20 (GM 106b–107a): And we know that some of the blessings and the curses have (already) been fulfilled as it is written in the bo[ok of Mo]ses.
This passage echoes C 17 and as such achieves the same for the sect: it sets their experience in an eschatological context, especially with the “fulfillment” language, implies that the scriptural text finds its telos in the sect’s own generation, espouses a clear notion of divine judgment, and shows the sect’s special knowledge.
113 Where Qimron and Strugnell see “an addition,” Bernstein suggests another biblical allusion rising from Deut 31:29 or even Deut 4:30: lKø¡ ÚWaÈx;m]W Ú+l] rX¢'B' >wløâqøB] T™[; ]m'v;w“ Úyh+,loa‘ hw∞:hy“ Ad[' T!;b]v'w“ µym+iY:h' t!yrIj}a'B] hL,aeh; µyr¢ib;D]h.' Qimron and Strugnell, DJD X, 59; Bernstein, “Employment,” 48 and n. 43.
116
Indirect Use of Scripture in 4QMMT As with the Fourth Gospel, while space does not allow extensive comment on biblical allusions, indirect references, or the mere use of biblical phraseology, a few words are certainly in order. Like most Qumran texts, 4QMMT is suffused with biblical language.114 For example, at C 24 the author observes that kings who followed Torah were “delivered from troubles” (twrxm lxn), a common phrase which is used of King David at 1 Sam 26:24 and Ps 34:18.115 References to “Torah” (hrwt) abound (C 24 [twice], 27, 28) and function in the important capacity of canon for setting boundaries and determining whom to include or exclude. So the opponents are those who do not “fear” or “do” Torah, whereas the sectarians are defined as “seekers of the Torah” (hrwt yçqbm). Knowing Torah is not as important as fearing or doing Torah, since the (unknown) addressee proves that knowledge of Torah certainly does not necessitate observance of it (C 28). Other indirect references to Scripture appear in the form of “the book” (rps) C 10 (twice), 11; Moses (hçm) C 10, 17, 21; David (dwd) C 10, 18, 25; prophets (aybn) C 10; and “former events,” C11, 12. These last five congregate in 4QMMT C 7–11, so it bears closer attention. C 7–11:116 [And you know that] we have separated ourselves from the multitude of the people [and from all their impurity] and from being involved with these matters and from participating with [them] in these things. And you [know that no] treachery or deceit or evil can be found in our hand (i.e. in us), since for [these things] we give [. . . And] we have [written] to you so that you may study (carefully) the book of Moses and the books of the Prophets and (the writings of ) David [and the] [events of ] ages past.
At the “narrative level,” the author writes to the addressee to explain why his group has separated and to invite the addressee to scrutinize Scripture more seriously so that he might at least concede the authors’ points and at most convert to the sect. 114 Though Qimron’s claim (DJD X, 136) seems a bit exaggerated: “In most of the halakhot there are allusions to the biblical passages on which the particular halakha is based. Some words from each biblical parallel occur in the halakha of MMT (sometimes in a grammatical form different from that of the source).” 115 Ibid., 62 n. 24. 116 Ibid., 56–57.
117
For the sect that preserved the letter, the appeal to “the book of Moses,” “the books of the Prophets,” “the writings of David,” and “the events of ages past” degrades “them” as “the people and all their impurity.” It helps to create “us” through etiological propositions—both the claim that the sectarians deliberately separated at some point and the claim that “events of ages past” as recorded in Scripture validate that withdrawal. It elevates “us” as an honest, faithful group in whom there is “no treachery or deceit.” As always, it reflects the authority of Scripture for the group. Cases where the author refers to the biblical text, but does not indicate he is doing so by using a citation formula (bwtk), occur at B 69, 70. There the lack of citation formula serves an intentional function since the author’s goal at those points is paraenetic; he acts as though the addressee does not need to be directed to the scriptural passage because the addressee should “know” already that the author is alluding to Scripture. So the author says, “And you know [that if someone violates a prohibitive commandment unintentionally], and the fact escapes him, he should bring a purification offering.” In referring to Lev 5:2 the author assumes (whether actually or rhetorically)117 that this addressee who has “wisdom and knowledge of the Torah” (C 28) knows the reference. Put that way, the addressee would be ashamed to admit he does not. The technique compels the reader to assume the author’s position.118 A similar pattern of indirect reference usage appears in the following places, but detailed analysis of them would add little to what we have already seen: B 11–13 (Lev 22:16); B 14 (Num 19:8, 10, 21); B 39–41 (Deut 23:2–4); B 40 (Gen 2:23–24); B 49 (Lev 19:30); B 62–64 (Lev 19:23–24 and Lev 27:32); B 72–74 (Num 19:16 or 19:18); C 25 (2 Sam 7:15, Ps 89:25, 29, 34, 50; 2 Chr 6:42); C 31–32 (Gen 15:6; Deut 6:18, 24–25; 12:28; Ps 106:3).119
117
Cf. Rom 7:1. David Koresh was fond of this technique. 119 Moshe Bernstein distinguishes between biblical imitation for “purely stylistic” purposes and “theological” purposes. I disagree with such a categorization because what Bernstein designates “mere stylistics,” I would place on our chart under the rubric of “shaping worldview” or “production of culture,” noting the power of language in a way he apparently does not. If we ignore his categories, his identifications of biblical allusions are useful. For a discussion of how Bernstein arrives at these scriptural echoes, see “Employment,” 36–38. 118
118
Charting Results How Scripture Functions in the Qumran Sect A. BREAKING AWAY: CREATING AND DEGRADING “THEM” 1QpHab 2:1–3; 5:8–12 4QMMT B 9–11, 27–35, 70, 75–76, 77–78; C 6–7, 12 CD 3:7–8; 4:12–14; 5:8ff.; 6:11–19; 7:9–8:3 B. FORMATION OF SECT 1. Etiology: celebrate origins of the community; ground community in the past 1QpHab 5:8–12 4QMMT C 6–8; 11 CD 3:20ff.; 6:2–7; 6:11–19; 7:9–8:3 2. Show sect’s founder to have special insight regarding Scripture 1QpHab 2:2; 7:4–5 CD 6:7–11 3. Defining and elevating “us” a. An elect group 1QpHab 5:4–5, 6–8; 9:12; 10:13 CD 8:14–18 b. An honest, faithful group 4QMMT B 8–9 1QpHab 5:7; 7:10 c. A persevering group 1QpHab 5:6–8; 7:10–11; 8:1 CD 7:12–14 d. A privileged group 1QpHab 11:1 4QMMT C 20 CD 3:18–4:4; 6:2–7; 6:11–19 e. A group affording access to salvation 1QpHab 8:2 f. A group that observes the Law 1QpHab 5:5–6; 12:2–5
119
C. CREATING A DISTINCT WAY OF LIFE 1. Ethical behavior a. Setting boundaries: purity/defilement 4QMMT B 66–67, 75–76, 76–77, 77–78; C 6–7 CD 3:20ff.; 6:11–19 b. Providing ethical imperatives 1QpHab 5:5; 7:10–11; 8:1 4QMMT B 9–11, 37–38, 66–67, 75–76, 76–77, 77–78 CD 6:11–19; 7:6–9; 7:9–8:3 2. Ritual practice 1QpHab 11:7–8 4QMMT B 27 CD 6:11–19 3. Language and rhetoric All of 1QpHab, which clothes contemporary experience in biblical terms CD 6:2–7; 7:9–8:3 4. Use of sacred texts a. The sectarian community as Scripture’s telos 1QpHab 1:2–3; 2:8–10; 7:2 CD 1:13ff.; 4:12–14; 6:11–19 b. Scripture validates the sect’s views 4QMMT B 9–11, 27–35, 37–38, 66–67, 70, 75–76, 77–78; C 6–7, 12 CD 4:19ff.; 7:6–9; 20:13–17 5. Roles of authoritative leaders a. Teacher of Righteousness 1. The leader is righteous, chosen by God or otherwise admirable 1QpHab 1:13 CD 6:7–11; 7:18ff. 2. Unjustly persecuted 1QpHab 5:9–12; 9:9–10; 11:4–6 3. Privy to special insight 1QpHab 2:2; 7:4–5 CD 6:7–11 4. Warrants fidelity and belief; salvation and judgment depend upon one’s stance vis-à-vis him 1QpHab 2:2; 8:2–3; 9:9–12
120
b. Priest 1QpHab 2:8–10 c. “We” of 4QMMT who pronounce rulings (dabar) according to their opinion 4QMMT B 1–2, 29, 36, 37, 42, 55, 64, 73; C 10, 11–12, 20, 26–27 6. Definition of the future 1QpHab 7:1–2, 7, 9–14 CD 3:20ff. D. OPPOSITION TO AND FROM THE PARENT TRADITION 1. Named opponents a. High Priest/Wicked Priest ([çrh ˆhkh) 1QpHab 1:13; 8:8–13; 11:13–14 4QMMT as a whole; 4QMMT C 26–27(?) b. Man of the Lie 1QpHab 2:1–2; 5:11; 10:9(?) CD 1:14(?) c. Seekers-After-Smooth-Things CD 1:18 d. House of Absalom and its partisans 1QpHab 5:9–12 e. Other priests of Jerusalem 1QpHab 9:4 2. Those who break Scripture 1QpHab 5:11–12 4QMMT B 9–11, 27–35, 70, 75–76, 77–78; C 6–7, C 12 CD 1:20; 3:7–8; 4:19ff.; 5:8ff. E. OPPOSITION FROM WITHIN THE SECT: DEALING WITH DEFECTION 1. Reward adherence to the sect 1QpHab 8:2 4QMMT C12 2. Castigate potential and actual deserters 1QpHab 2:3–4, 14–15 CD 7:20–8:3; 8:14–18
121
F. OPPOSITION TO AND FROM WITHOUT 1. Romans 1QpHab. 2:12–14; 3–4; 6:1–12; 9:4–6 2. The nations 1QpHab 12:10–13:4 G. JUDGMENT AGAINST OPPONENTS 1. Against Parent Religion 1QpHab 5:4–5; 9:1–2, 4–7, 12; 10:3–5, 12–13; 12:2–5 CD 1:16–17; 1:21–2:1; 3:20ff. 4QMMT C 12, 17, 20 2. Against Sect-Defectors 1QpHab 2:3–4, 14–15120 CD 7:20–8:3; 8:14–18; 20:13–17 3. Against the “World” (the nations, the Romans) 1QpHab 5:4; 12:12–13:4 H. GROWING THE SECT 1. Proselytizing 1QpHab 2:6 4QMMT B 37–38 CD 3:20ff. 2. The next generation
Conclusions Formation of the Sect A sect, by definition, forms in opposition to a parent tradition, and as long as its members remain sectarian they maintain opposition to and from that tradition. The process of developing an identity, group
120 Protest might be raised against the inclusion of the 1QpHab passages here insofar as they do not overtly announce judgment on the sect defectors at this particular point, but merely mention them with disgust. Other passages, however, make it clear that, in addition to drawing attention to them, the author implies judgment on them as well (cf. e.g., 13:4).
122
boundaries, and a worldview requires distinguishing the group from other groups, defining the community over against actual or constructed opponents. Regardless of which, if any, of the scenarios presented at the beginning of the chapter actually inhered in the birth of the sect, the author of 1QpHab envisions a schism centered on the acceptance or rejection of the Teacher of Righteousness (1QpHab 5:8–12). The sectarian insiders, the “we,” identify with those who accepted the Teacher of Righteousness, while the opponents, the “they,” are those who are identified with the rejecters. The latter are not only identified, but also clearly degraded; they are “traitors” who are associated with the Man of the Lie (1QpHab 2:1–3). The author of 4QMMT ascribes the break to issues of purity and draws the dividing line between the “we” who maintained the purity laws and the “they” who patently transgressed them. 1QpHab also identifies “them” as those who rejected the law (1QpHab 5:8–12). The distinctions and characterizations made by the Qumran authors in recounting the emergence of the sect remain consistent for opponents as described in the sect’s contemporary situation. Just as the original opponents to the Teacher of Righteousness rejected him, so also the contemporary opponents reject the sectarians; just as the original opponents were treacherous, deceitful, and willing to sacrifice their integrity to save themselves, so also the contemporary opponents are treacherous, greedy, and deceitful; just as the original opponents broke Torah, so also the contemporary opponents do the same. By the same token, the contemporary sectarians resemble their founding counterparts. They accept the words of the Teacher of Righteousness, that is, the word of God. They remain faithful to Torah (1QpHab 5:5–6); they are honest and persevere in the truth no matter what the cost to them. These consistent characterizations are in keeping with Garfinkel’s observations regarding degradation techniques. It is not enough simply to denounce the actions of the opponents; the grounds of their actions must be identified. In the Fourth Gospel the essence of the opponents is defined primarily by whether one’s father is the devil or God. In the Qumran literature, the opponents, in their very essence, are opposed to God’s desires and seek to fulfill their own desires (CD 3:7); the exact opposite can be said of the sectarians. The Qumran authors (i.e., the denouncers) use Scripture deftly to accomplish what Garfinkel describes thus: “any sense of accident, coincidence, indeterminism, chance, or monetary [sic] occurrence must not merely be
123
minimized. Ideally, such measures should be inconceivable. . . .”121 This is accomplished in part by the authors’ indication that the sect’s contemporary situation was already inscribed in Scripture long ago and that Scripture finds its telos in the group. There are no surprises for the sect: their experiences are simply the unfolding of what was already foretold in Scripture. The opponents are made to be totally “other”; they are ritually separated from a place in the legitimate order and are instead doomed to divine destruction. As it turns out, although the Qumran group separated from its parent tradition, each text manifests a residual concern for the parent tradition and its affairs; theirs was not “a clean break.” The people of the Qumran community, in typical sectarian fashion, never considered themselves anything but Jews. Their distinction lay in their understanding themselves as the true, purified, fulfilled Israel, the faithful inheritors of the covenant indicated in Scripture. Their etiology is grounded in the hoary past; to one initiated into the sect’s special jargon, they can be seen in the pages of Scripture, the “we” of Hab 1:12ff., the “princes” of Num 21:18. The fact that the sect simultaneously envisioned itself both as a “new” phenomenon (members of a “new” covenant, e.g.) and an “old” phenomenon (rightful claimants to the original covenant, faithful remnant) results in tension that may explain in part why the authors give more attention and vehement castigation to Jews than to Gentiles. Though adamantly defining themselves as radically different from those in the parent tradition, they are not so different as to be defined apart from that tradition. So, the person who expects the Qumran sect to wash its hands of the Jews who opposed it and whom it opposed, and to turn its sights upon Samaritans or Gentiles, will find little supporting evidence. It is not the case that the authors’ interest in the parent tradition terminates with their having narrated the original break; rather, it continues to express tension with the tradition. Recall Swidler’s characterization of unsettled periods which, in the process of forming new strategies of action, nevertheless maintain a basic connection with the parent tradition insofar as “much of their taken-for-granted understanding of the world and many of their daily practices still depend on traditional patterns.”122 Scripture itself may be counted among those “traditional patterns,” as Wayne Meeks indicates when he writes with 121 122
Garfinkel, “Conditions,” 42. Swidler, “Culture,” 279.
124
regard to the Fourth Gospel: “While in Philo’s writings we see the Moses traditions being used in a broad Kulturkampf, here in John they are employed in a sectarian controversy. And both sides in this controversy have used the same scripture and similar traditions.”123 Creating a Distinct Way of Life Like the Branch Davidians, the Qumran community evinced its break with its parent tradition in a rather literal way by physically residing together in a separate community whose boundaries were drawn clearly. As Bainbridge notes: “A successful religious movement typically goes through a formative period, when it develops its distinctive doctrine and practices.”124 Those forging a sectarian community must provide the group a sense of identity, which involves adopting or inventing culture, actions, habits, ascribing to them particular meaning, and assimilating members into that culture so that everyone in the group operates with a set of shared assumptions and strategies of action. Residents of Qumran were expected to abide by uniform ethical and ritual practices. Recall Swidler’s argument: Bursts of ideological activism occur in periods when competing ways of organizing action are developing or contending for dominance. People formulate, flesh out, and put into practice new habits of action. In such situations, culture may indeed be said to directly shape action. Members of a religious cult wear orange, or share their property . . . because their beliefs tell them to. . . . During such periods, differences in ritual practice or doctrine may become highly charged, so that statuary in churches . . ., the clothing and preaching style of ministers . . . are fraught with significance. Ritual acquires such significance in unsettled lives because ritual changes reorganize taken-for-granted habits and modes of experience.125
She argues, “In unsettled periods, ideologies—explicit, articulated, highly organized meaning systems (both political and religious)—establish new styles or strategies of action. When people are learning new ways of organizing individual and collective action, practicing unfamiliar habits until they become familiar, then doctrine, symbol, and ritual directly shape action.”126 Sects, as representatives of unsettled lives, are impa123 124 125 126
Meeks, “Divine Agent,” 54. Bainbridge, Sociology, 82–83. Swidler, “Culture,” 279. Ibid., 278.
125
tient of the ambiguities, varieties, and even profound inconsistencies which “settled lives” tolerate; rather, they provide a comprehensive answer to the question of “how human beings should live. In conflict with other cultural models, these cultures are coherent because they must battle to dominate the worldviews, assumptions, and habits of their members.”127 Sects seek to dominate the worldview of their members, and the sects studied here rely heavily on the invocation and interpretation of Scripture to effect it. The reader should not be surprised, then, to find an emphasis on ethical and ritual practice at Qumran or to discover Scripture as a vehicle of culture which plays a prominent role in designing the new strategies of action. In the most general terms, the sectarians are consistently exhorted to “observe the Law” (1QpHab 8:1) or “keep the commandments” (1QpHab 5:5), but more specific practices are enjoined as well, such as those related to consuming a cereal offering (4QMMT B 9–11), eating a fetus (4QMMT B 37–38), lepers (4QMMT B 66–67), marriage (4QMMT B 75–76), and others. Rituals related to slaughtering (4QMMT B 27) and keeping the sabbath and festival days (CD 6:11–19; 1QpHab 11:7–8) appear as well. Issues of purity and defilement loom large in the deployment of Scripture in the chosen Qumran texts. This is a community that appears to have concerned itself seriously with setting boundaries between insiders and outsiders. The same applies to the Branch Davidians under Koresh, who expected his people to abide by particular dietary laws, marriage boundaries, codes of dress, and observance of the sabbath. In addition to ethical and ritual means, creating and using a special insider language is effective in developing a sense of group identity among sectarians. Recall the discussion concerning language and rhetoric as a means to cultural inclusion or exclusion. Leaders and members may insist that their belief system is unique but deliberately not present those beliefs thoroughly or transparently. They may appeal to esoteric, historical, philosophical, and theological sources of wisdom to keep the belief system somewhat inaccessible to outsiders. They may also use special language.128 This type of move is made often in the Qumran literature where the authors speak in a code, even a double code. For example, 1QpHab12ff. quotes Hab. 1:4 and then “explains” that the “evildoer” of Hab 1:4 is the “Wicked 127 128
Ibid., 279. Wuthnow, Producing, 101.
126
Priest” and Habakkuk’s “upright man” is the Teacher of Righteousness. The biblical code is thus cracked for the sectarians who, as insiders, know the Wicked Priest and the Teacher of Righteousness, but the “interpretation” remains opaque to the outsider whose only hope of discovery rests upon extensively searching all of the Qumran literature to make an educated guess as to the identity of these figures. Other examples of special language include: “traitors,” the “poor ones,” the “simple ones of Judah,” “the last generation,” “those who live in the land of Damascus,” “Ephraim,” “the House of Judah,” “the House of Absalom,” “Man of the Lie,” “seekers-after-smooththings,” and “Kittim.” In observing how these authors wield Scripture to establish boundaries and place various people and groups of people into orderly categories, it is useful to visit part of Wuthnow’s explanation of the dramaturgic approach to culture: The term “dramaturgic” is used to describe this approach because of its emphasis on the capacity of rituals, ideologies, and other symbolic acts to dramatize the nature of social relations. It is in these dramatizations that definitions of the situations are communicated. In saying that culture is symbolic-expressive, therefore, this approach tends to focus less on information that is simply and straightforwardly transmitted than on messages that may be implicit in the ways in which social life is arranged, in rituals, and in the choice of words in discourse. Put simply, what is “given off ” may be as important as what is “given.”129
Loci of Authority Scripture The authors of our texts plied Scripture extensively and variously to maintain the sect. In addition to setting boundaries, providing ethical imperatives,130 and insisting on ritual/devotional practices, much scriptural interpretation focused on the loci of authority, specifically the leaders of the group and Scripture. In the establishment of new strategies of actions for the Qumran sectarians, Scripture and the 129
Wuthnow, Meaning, 13–14. “Keep,” “learn,” and “practice” are all words used often in the Qumran texts with regard to the keeping of God’s “statutes,” “ordinance,” “commands,” and “words”; the Fourth Gospel uses strikingly similar language. 130
127
authoritative leaders play a special role. Clearly, the group considered itself subject to Scripture, called variously the word of God, the Law, the commandments, the words of his servants the prophets, or “that which is written.” In its break with the parent tradition, the Qumran sect did not attempt to downplay the role of Scripture; rather it viewed itself as those who take Scripture most seriously and adhere to what is communicated therein. Indeed, the group patently distinguishes itself as those who take Scripture seriously as opposed to the parent tradition, which is definitively characterized by its “rejection” of Scripture. Recall Wuthnow’s identification of the three dynamics at work when religious groups compete with one another: selective adaptation, isomorphism, and specialization. Selective adaptation concerns the “fit” between the group and its host environment; the Qumran community’s fit and the parent tradition’s fit in Roman Palestine appears to have been equal and requires no attention. Isomorphism has to do with the organizations having enough resemblance to one another to ensure a certain part of the available resources. The Qumran sect appears to have been a strictly Jewish phenomenon; its members came from a worldview previously shaped by the parent tradition. “Specialization” was achieved, at least in part, by the Qumran community’s commitment to reforming, purifying, and revitalizing the covenant community as indicated in Scripture. Hence, in presenting its views, the community readily argued that those views emerged from and were validated by Scripture. The authors all resolutely indicate that the sectarian community is Scripture’s telos. They typically “prove” that their views are in keeping with Scripture.131 Davies addresses the role of Scripture in the Qumran community: This state of affairs is misconceived if CD is dismissed as a mere ‘mosaic’ of quotations to which no evidential value may be attached. There are certainly numerous examples of biblical phraseology which must be regarded as unconsidered and even as only part of the author’s own biblically saturated vocabulary. But the cumulative force of the numerous quotations and allusions amounts to a statement that the ‘plot’ of CD can be read in the Bible: the community, the time in which it lives, its laws, everything is anticipated, described, regulated in 131 This aspect of scriptural usage has been commented on by myriad scholars usually under the rubric of “proof-texting.” See, e.g., Geza Vermes, “Biblical ProofTexts in Qumran Literature,” Journal of Semitic Studies 34/2 (1989): 493–508.
128
the Bible. The conclusion is forced upon one that not only is the Bible used by the community to present its appeal, but also that it was in the Bible in the first place that the community found its identity.132
The authors use Scripture to denote the centrality of Scripture. As noted previously, the relationship between the community and Scripture was symbiotic (a point which applies to any community, ancient or modern, which espouses a notion of scriptural authority). The community rests under the authority of Scripture but certainly influences how Scripture is interpreted by “closing down” possible meanings so that the “proper interpretation” becomes “evident and inevitable.” Leaders The “specialization” of the group does not end with Scripture, however. As will be seen in the cases of both the Branch Davidians and the Johannine community, it is Scripture as mediated through the authoritative leader or leaders of the group. 1QpHab uses Scripture to elevate especially the figure known as the Teacher of Righteousness, who makes only a slight appearance in CD’s scriptural interests and is absent from 4QMMT’s. Some may find this surprising given the febrile attempt to place him as the founder and primary leader of the sect and to compare his to the role of Jesus of Nazareth for Christianity. To be sure, we have included only evidence pertaining to the use of direct citations, so the inclusion of entire texts in our analysis might have secured him a more central role. Because he has engendered so much debate, a few words are in order regarding the Teacher of Righteousness. While the exact date, identification, and function of the Teacher of Righteousness continues to befuddle students of Qumran, no one would contest his significant role in the community and especially the authority wielded by him regarding biblical interpretation. Jesus enjoyed a similar authority in the community of the Fourth Gospel, as did David Koresh in the Branch Davidian community. Unlike the latter two groups, however, the Qumranians did not impute divinity to their teacher. In speaking of the authority of Mikra, Fishbane proposes a “twofold chain of authority: God and His authoritative spokesmen.”133 Mikra is 132 133
Philip R. Davies, “Eschatology at Qumran,” JBL 104 (1985): 55. Fishbane, “Use,” 360.
129
the revelation of God to which Moses and the Prophets attest. Next in line are the community’s teachers.134 The role of the teacher is highlighted in CD 6:10–11: “Without [the Staff of Instruction] they will not grasp [the meaning of the revelations of God] until there arises one who teaches righteousness in the end of days.” And in 1QpHab 2:1–9 we learn that “the true meaning of the ancient prophecies were not even known to the authoritative spokesman of God who revealed them in past times. Only through the interpretations of the Teacher will the community know of the final day and their ultimate vindication.”135 The same point is made in 1QpHab 7:1–2. 1QpHab attests to the special interpretive authority imputed to the Teacher of Righteousness. His words are to be believed because it has been given to him to unravel the mysteries set forth in Scripture; indeed, his interpretation is presented as coming from the “mouth of God.” His special revelatory relationship vis-à-vis Scripture is the cynosure of his authority. Because of this, not only should his words command belief, but he himself should be the object of fidelity. As is the case with the Branch Davidian and Fourth Gospel groups, the leader is shown to be especially righteous or chosen by God to fulfill his role. He is unjustly persecuted; he is privy to special insight regarding Scripture and other matters. In all three cases, that is, with the Teacher of Righteousness, Jesus, and David Koresh, the authors insist that to reject the leader is to reject the word of God or Godself and thereby to lose one’s salvation. While the three leaders mentioned occupy the central leadership roles for the groups studied, both the Qumran and Branch Davidian sects admit other, if lesser, authorities as well. So, 4QMMT never mentions the Teacher of Righteousness; rather, the halakic exhortations and rulings are handed down from the “we” who are indicated in the text. 1QpHab also allows room for a “priest” mentioned in 1QpHab 2:8–10. The Branch Davidians reserve an authoritative position for a number of previous leaders in the group’s history, but Koresh is the ultimate authority. The Fourth Gospel strictly eschews Jesus’ sharing authority with anyone, even John the Baptist.
134 135
Ibid. Ibid., 361.
130
Definition of the Future As noted already by Meeks and sociologists of sectarianism, sects require great sacrifice from their members. As a result, they must compensate by providing rewards and by providing a deep sense of belonging. Rewards can be envisioned as a present or a future phenomenon. One common reward among all of the groups under study here is that of salvation from God’s judgment. Both 1QpHab and CD concern themselves with the future, or, as 1QpHab denotes it, “the end time.” At that time, divine justice will be meted out and the sectarians will receive God’s favor, eternal life, all the glory of Adam (CD 3:20ff.), while the opponents of the group will not (1QpHab 7:9–14). One stands either with the sect or against the sect; one receives either God’s favor or disfavor; the Qumran authors envision no “middle ground.” Of course, eschatology and judgment go hand in hand. By proclaiming judgment the author exhorts the sectarians to continued faithfulness despite tribulation, retrieves those in danger of defecting, and insists that the apparent chaos and violence surrounding them from the parent religion and the Romans is not ultimate; rather, God’s sovereignty is to be trusted. The author takes the opportunity to inspire the faithful sectarians to endure by assuring them that salvation inheres only in the sect, whereas those outside will reap divine wrath. Scripture is used to portend this fate variously for non-sectarian Jews, sect-defectors, and pagans. Opponents Attention to the sect’s enemies is in order. First, because the sect seems to have developed over time, we must allow that the enemies in each era and/or each text might be somewhat different. In other words, the particularities of each text must be honored rather than harmonized under the rubric of a principal text which one has chosen as “the key text.” Having said that, one generalization supported by this study is that the most often and most vociferously denounced enemies of the Jewish sect are always other Jews, with the pagan world lagging behind substantially. Even when pagan opponents do appear, more often than not they are presented as agents of God’s divine wrath due to the treatment of the sectarians by the rest of Judaism. Campbell makes an observation which will apply to the Fourth Gospel as well:
131
With regard to the significance of the use of scripture in CD 1–8 and 19–20, we may go one stage further in view of the polemical air of much of the document. This adversarial tone, as already implied in our consideration of the sect’s supposed exilic origins, may profitably be related to conflicting claims in the second half of the Second Temple period truly to represent and continue ancient Israel’s traditions. Indeed, rival interpretations of revelation held in common among the various Jewish groups at this time have been highlighted by Vermes, whose own words we may borrow once more: “From the one body of sacred writings . . . and employing the same methods of interpretation, each evolved a distinct religious outlook and way of life in conflict, very often, with those of the others.”136
Numerous named enemies surface in the texts we have chosen. Realizing that various sobriquets may apply to an individual or a group, and that some of these may designate the same historical figure(s), we list the following: Wicked Priest, traitors, Man of Lies, SeekersAfter-Smooth-Things, Man of Scorn, Spouter of Lies, House of Absalom and its partisans, other Jerusalem priests, and all those who do not keep Torah precepts. The Romans and “the nations” occasionally appear as well. Recurring characteristics of the enemies include trafficking in deceit, violence, profanation of God’s name, disbelief, and apostasy. Notably, our Qumran authors (like the Fourth Gospel) can distinguish between “the people” and “rulers of the people” when speaking of both Jewish and Roman opponents.137 Parent Tradition By definition, sects stand in opposition to at least one other group, the parent tradition. Those of the parent tradition are most generally and often referred to as those who do not keep Torah precepts. Specific figures are also named. The Wicked Priest is an evildoer, proud, a deserter of God, a betrayer of the Law, greedy, inebriate, a robber, and the performer of acts of defiling impurity. The Man of Lies is primarily charged with rejecting the Law and not believing the words of the Teacher of Righteousness which were from the mouth of God, two of the most egregious offenses the author can imagine. He leads others astray (the same charge made against Jesus 136
Campbell, Use, 207. Campbell’s n. 79 refers us to 4QMMT as well. So, e.g., 1QpHab 3:9 speaks of “the Kittim,” whereas 4:5 refers to “the rulers of the Kittim.” 137
132
in the Fourth Gospel; John 7:12 and 7:47) subjecting them to deceit and falsehood and causing them to persecute the sectarians. CD 1:18ff. speaks of “the scoffer” who arose in Israel and caused people to stray so that the people became unjust, broke the covenant, and sought easy interpretations (also translated “seekers-after-smooththings”). The “House of Absalom and their partisans” are castigated primarily for their inaction rather than action insofar as they remained silent when the Teacher of Righteousness underwent persecution by the Man of the Lie in their midst. The author of the Fourth Gospel exhibits the same impatience with “fence-sitters” and indicates that one belongs to the sect and receives all due reward or one does not belong to the sect and receives all due punishment. Neither he nor the Qumran authors shows sympathy to those who try to occupy neutral ground. The last priests of Jerusalem, like other opponents, are characterized by their greed and injustice. Sect-Defectors Sects demand much of their adherents and they often lose members. Not only do many sects expect material, physical, and social sacrifices, all of them ask the new member to adopt a new worldview, to learn new strategies of action. In the case of Qumran, the authors indicate that they draw members from the parent Judaism. As such, the Qumran community would afford some common traditions and assumptions that would feel comfortable to the potential convert but at the same time would require a shift from the old worldview. In studying how culture functions in a high-ideology period, Swidler suggests that the group that is offering new strategies of action and patterns of organizing people is “in active competition with other cultural frameworks—at least in competition with common sense and usually with alternative traditions and ideologies as well.”138 That is to say, the Qumran community certainly competed with temple-based Jerusalem Judaism, which would have represented common sense, and it may also have found itself competing with other forms of Judaism as well.139 That the group did experi138
Swidler, “Culture,” 280. That Second Temple Judaism was marked by variety has become axiomatic, against the older view of a “normative Judaism.” How various the forms were depends in part on the angle one takes when investigating the groups. Regarding political 139
133
ence defection from the sect is indicated in the chosen texts. The authors castigate the defectors as “traitors” and those who did “not remain steadfast.” The authors clearly announce divine reward (life, blessings, salvation from the house of judgment) at some future day of judgment for those who remain faithful to the sect and condemnation (destruction, curses) for the defectors. The Fourth Gospel, through its particular concern for “abiding” in Jesus (of the one hundred twelve occurrences of m°nv in the , thirty-eight appear in the Fourth Gospel, twenty-three in 1 John, and three in 2 John), reflects a similar problem of sect-defection. Like Qumran, it offers “life” (zvÆ) and not a place in the house of judgment, but a room in God’s house ( John 14:2) as a reward for those who remain faithful despite suffering much tribulation on account of their membership in the group. The Branch Davidian materials exhibit the same problem and a similar solution. The “World” Of the Qumran texts chosen for scrutiny, only 1QpHab evinces any interest in what David Koresh and, perhaps, the Fourth Gospel call “the world”; i.e., those who belong to neither the sect, its defectors, or the parent tradition. 1QpHab, in its typical “double-code,” interprets Habakkuk’s Chaldeans as “Kittim,” which signifies the Romans. The reader may refer to the analysis at 1QpHab 2:12–14 for a full description of their vices, but the Romans are primarily defined in terms similar to those used against the other opponents: they are violent, greedy, proud, unjust, and deceitful. Like all of the other opponents, the author confidently consigns them to divine destruction on the day of visitation. Because of their identical (degraded) natures, it is only fitting then that God will use the Romans to destroy the Jewish opponents of the sect. The Romans are presented as a violent force in the land of Israel, annihilating everything in
attitudes, there were Jews who were avidly nationalistic as opposed to those who embraced a more cosmopolitan stance. Regarding issues of personal piety, Pharisees may have adopted temple piety into their own and advocated that others do the same. Regarding particular doctrinal considerations, there was some variety among different groups of Jews. We might categorize varieties of Judaism by taking class issues into account. At any rate, Second Temple Judaism was a complex phenomenon, and the Qumran community would have found itself having to take that into consideration when seeking members.
134
their path, but the author never indicates that the mighty forces had any particular cognizance of the small Qumran community. In this way the Romans differ from the opponents in Jerusalem who persecute the group qua sect. 1QpHab also mentions “the nations” but in a very stock way. They are idolaters who will receive destruction along with everyone else who does not belong to the Qumran community. Growing the Sect Like the Branch Davidian and Johannine communities, the authors of the Qumran texts looked to the parent tradition for new members. After all, all three saw themselves as the rightful and true incarnation of the parent tradition as indicated by Scripture. They all used Scripture to convince those who already lent Scripture authority that their group was the purified form of God’s covenant community. None of the Qumran texts chosen for study addresses the next generation. The same is true of the Fourth Gospel. The Branch Davidian materials show only very occasional and brief interest in the subject. Conclusion Sects are engaged in the production of culture, a production in which Scripture plays a key role and which is fundamentally shaped by the need to distinguish the sectarian culture from various external cultures, especially a parent tradition. That the sectarian Qumranians successfully created and maintained a community cannot be doubted given the fact that it seems to have perdured over time and created enough distinction for itself to be noticed by Josephus. Wuthnow suggests three requirements for the success of a religious group. It must: a) draw individuals into an intimate community; b) encourage them to worship; and c) provide them and their children with instruction. While none of the texts chosen for this study reveals concern for the instruction of children, they do demonstrate concern for the instruction of members and meet the other two criteria as well. All of the sociologists of religion cited in this study have called us to attend to the concrete social and historical circumstances in which a religious group functions to better understand the group. Swidler urges us to analyze “the structural constraints and historical cir-
135
cumstances within which ideological movements struggle for dominance.”140 She contends: Culture has independent causal influence in unsettled cultural periods because it makes possible new strategies of action—constructing entities that can act (selves, families, corporations), shaping the styles and skills with which they act, and modeling forms of authority and cooperation. It is, however, the concrete situations in which these cultural models are enacted that determine which take root and thrive, and which wither and die.141
For both Qumran and its parent tradition, those “historical circumstances” included operating under Roman rule and, finally, suffering destruction by the Romans. Jerusalem fell to the Romans and the temple was destroyed, but the tradition arose from the ashes, perhaps in the form of Rabbinic Judaism. On the other hand, the Qumran community appears to have been destroyed. Thus, it “lost” its competition with the parent tradition.
140 141
Swidler, “Culture,” 280. Ibid.
CHAPTER FOUR
THE BRANCH DAVIDIAN COMMUNITY
We are entering into a period of time where the Bible is gonna be understood by somebody. David Koresh Ezekiel 21:31: ‘I will pour out my indignation upon you, with the fire of my wrath I will blow upon you. I will deliver you into brutish hands, those skillful to destroy.’ The Lord destroys with fire these days. David Koresh People like dead religions. David Koresh
Introduction On April 19, 1993, the group known as the “Branch Davidians” was catapulted to momentary notoriety when the United States government smashed through the walls of the citizens’ residence1 with military tanks and released CS gas into the home, which was housing some eight-five children, men, and women, all the while shouting over a loudspeaker: “This is not an assault. This is not an assault.” Within minutes the so-called “compound” and seventy-four of its residents were consumed by flames. Twenty-one of the eighty were children, not including the two fetuses, one seven months and one full-term, which appear to have been born “as the result of an evolutionary reflex, instants after their mothers . . . expired.”2 Before the
1 This act alone killed six mothers and children who, according to Coroner Rodney Crow, were crushed and suffocated “from the falling concrete in the bunker that fell on them.” Among those crushed was one of the two pregnant women. Dick J. Reavis, The Ashes of Waco (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1995), 275. 2 Ibid., 277.
137
fire was fully extinguished, the Mt. Carmel flag was replaced with an ATF flag. For the most part, interest in the group lingers only in the occasional TV episode devoted to “cults”3 and among a small group of scholars. The main question posed by James D. Tabor and Eugene V. Gallagher appears in the title of their monograph: Why Waco? As one of the few scholarly accounts of the group known as the Branch Davidians and its conflict with the American government, the work attempts to set the sect in its historical, religious, and social contexts.4 Tabor asks, “Who were the 130 Branch Davidians living at Mt. Carmel in the spring of 1993, how had they come there, and why did they choose to stay, even if remaining there might lead to death?”5 Contrary to popular sentiment, the Branch Davidians were not a cult; that is, they were neither a “new” religious movement nor did they hail from some exotic land. They were strictly a homegrown phenomenon sown in the Millerite movement, watered in the SeventhDay Adventist church, blossoming under the leadership of Victor Houteff. Historically speaking, scholars trace the heritage of Koresh’s group to 1818 when a Baptist named William Miller concluded that the Second Coming would occur in 1844. It did not. Disciples responded variously to this “Great Disappointment,” and one group, under the leadership of Ellen G. White, who had heard Miller himself on more than one occasion, formed the Seventh-Day Adventist church (hereafter, SDA). White was privy to numerous divine visions and revelations upon which she based her teachings. Among those teachings were Saturday Sabbath keeping; abstinence from meat, alcohol, tobacco, and caffeine; and a belief in the imminence of Christ’s return. She proclaimed that, though 1844 did not see Christ’s return to earth, it was the occasion of Christ’s entering the Holy of
3 April 1999 saw the airing of an episode of “First Wave,” which featured an alien taking human form, attracting followers, imprisoning them within a compound, killing those who crossed the leader, and treating the women as a personal harem. The episode used the words “cult” and “deprogramming” and presented both Jim Jones and David Koresh as analogues. Such is the influence the anti-cult network has had on the media and, in turn, on the American mind. 4 See also Stuart A. Wright, ed., Armageddon in Waco: Critical Perspectives on the Branch Davidian Conflict (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1995). 5 James Tabor and Eugene Gallagher, Why Waco? Cults and the Battle for Religious Freedom in America (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1995), 23.
138
Holies in heaven where he cleansed the sanctuary in preparation for his second advent to earth, at which time only Adventists would receive salvation. White died in 1915, and her writings remain authoritative for Adventists. The General Conference has never validated a new prophet.6 In the late 1920s one devoted SDA by the name of Victor Houteff set about to reform the church which had become, in his estimation, too lax.7 William Pitts makes this astute comment: “As has been the case with the leaders of countless other sectarian movements in the history of the church, Houteff did not initially want to start a new denomination. Rather, he wanted to reform an old one; but the old one did not welcome his reform.”8 By 1935 the schism could not be bridged; Houteff had been excised from the church roll, and the group broke away under the name Shepherd’s Rod. During WWII it changed its name to the Davidian Seventh-Day Adventists in order to enjoy the rights afforded to the SDA church regarding conscientious objection. Tabor, echoing the sentiments of Pitts, summarizes the break this way: “Although Houteff had never intended to separate from the mother church, after he was forced out, his movement officially took the name Davidian Seventh-Day Adventists. . . . As time went on and opposition from the main body stiffened, Houteff began to view the Seventh-Day Adventists as a ‘heathen’ apostate group, in contrast to his own small band of followers, whom he identified as the ‘remnant’ true church.”9 Certain characteristics of Houteff ’s teaching and leadership style perdured throughout the group’s history, many of them especially prominent in Koresh’s reign. First, Houteff never considered himself or his group as anything other than Seventh-Day Adventists. He continually attempted to influence the denomination and drew his adherents from it. Second, he declared himself a prophet and insisted upon the notion of “present truth,”
6 For a brief history of the Adventist movement, see Bainbridge, Sociology, 89–118. Pp. 110–17 are devoted to the Branch Davidians. 7 Indeed, Victor Houteff would not have been surprised to find a prominent sociologist of religion say this in 1997: “Despite holding Sabbath services on Saturday and stemming from the same millenarian tradition as the Witnesses, the SeventhDay Adventists fit right into the standard Protestant tradition.” Bainbridge, Sociology, 110. 8 William L. Pitts, Jr., “Davidians and Branch Davidians: 1929–1987,” in Armageddon (ed. Stuart A. Wright; Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1995), 23. 9 Tabor and Gallagher, Waco, 35.
139
a continual unfolding and further revelation of the truth as presented in Revelation and Daniel, the two most central books of Adventism. His treatment of all of Scripture as an enclosed universe allowed him to ignore any borders between individual books of the Bible and freely to illuminate any verse of Scripture by drawing on innumerable other biblical texts. This constant blending of literal and symbolic readings left room for an infinite amount of “play” and adjustment of interpretation as events unfolded. This method allowed every line, every word, every symbol in the entire Bible to serve, on some level, as a coded indicator for the contemporary situation, often directly addressing Houteff and his group. Even in cases where a text had an obvious historical fulfillment or point of reference, it could always have a “double” hidden meaning, revealed only through the “spirit of prophecy.” Koresh employed precisely the same methods in his own exposition of the Scriptures, often to the utter bafflement of the FBI negotiators.10
The King James Version served as the authoritative biblical text for the group. Houteff continued Ellen G. White’s ethical requirements regarding vegetarianism, alcohol, and caffeine. He settled his group at a site they named Mt. Carmel, where they lived together, studied together, sent out missionaries and tracts, attempted to gather the 144,000 (as indicated in Revelation), and awaited the second advent of Christ. Upon his death in 1955 Houteff was succeeded by his wife, Florence. Notably, she does not figure in Koresh’s own version of the group’s history. Her tenure was quite brief and she made no lasting contributions to the group. She did set a particular date for the second Advent, April 22, 1959, which inspired about nine hundred people to sell all of their possessions and convene at Mt. Carmel to await the Parousia. The day comprised yet another disappointment, which sparked a number of splinter groups, one of which fell under the leadership of Ben Roden who added the “Branch” to the Davidian SDA name based on Isa 11:1, Zech 6:2, and a revelation that Roden received that he himself was the branch referred to therein. In addition, he claimed other branches would be associated with him, basing such a claim on John 15:1–3. For the most part, Roden simply built upon Houteff ’s work, though he emphasized more heavily the
10
Ibid., 36.
140
observance of Levitical feasts and the need to relocate the center of Adventism to Israel. He also injected new life into the anti-Catholic sentiments born in early Adventism. Ben Roden died in 1978 and was succeeded by his wife, Lois, only after she prevailed over her son George Roden in a battle for authority over the group. She continued the group in the same vein as earlier Branch Davidian prophets but provided the innovative teaching that the Holy Spirit is feminine. She died in 1986. Roden groomed as her successor Vernon Howell, a young Adventist who had joined the group in 1981 after being removed from the church rolls of his Seventh-Day Adventist church for causing dissension regarding his belief that the Adventist church had become corrupt and lax. Howell, too, had to contend with George Roden to assume leadership of the group.11 By 1988 Howell had ascended to unrivaled primacy, though he held de facto power as early as 1985. In 1990 Howell changed his name to David Koresh, the first name after King David and the cognomen after Cyrus, the Persian king and “christ” discussed in Second Isaiah. Koresh continued in the same vein as his predecessors, considering himself a prophet appointed by God, the recipient of divine revelations, and the final authority on scriptural interpretation. He inherited his exegetical technique from the former leaders, though his interpretation differed on a number of points, as we will see when we review his own teachings. His innovation lay in an unprecedented focus and concentration on unraveling the mysteries of the seven seals. He “corrected” the earlier leaders by showing that, though they thought they were about the business of gathering the 144,000, in actuality their responsibilities lay in different areas. This “correction” presents no problem for a group which embraces the notion of “present truth” and progressive revelation. His other innovation lay in his understanding of his role in building the House of David, which would rule in the millennium. On the basis of this, Koresh had sexual relations not only with his wife, Rachel, but also with many of the other women at Mt. Carmel, some married, some under legal age, and all with the consent of parents and husbands.
11 The details of the power struggle are unusual and interesting insofar as they include both a small gun battle between Roden and Koresh’s followers and a challenge from Roden to Koresh involving raising a corpse that Roden had illegally exhumed.
141
In 1993 the group came under attack, ostensibly because of weapons violations and accusations of child abuse. The latter charge has never been substantiated though investigated more than once. Popular sentiment assumes that the conflict regarding weapons centered on stockpiling them; in fact, it is not illegal in Texas to stockpile weapons, and the charge had to do with a technicality regarding the assembling of the weapons. The group was partially in the business of selling the weaponry at gun shows. This is not the place to provide details about the legality or the wisdom of the ATF raid, though I urge the reader to familiarize herself with the scholarly analysis of the facts. That consensus exists as to the catastrophic actions sanctioned by the government is obvious throughout the literature, the less restrained providing titles to their work such as “Killed by Semantics: Or Was it a Keystone Kop Kaleidoscope Kaper?” or “Did the G-men Sleep Through Soc 100?” and the more restrained entitling their works “Misguided Tactics Contributed to Apocalypse in Waco” and “Cult Label Made Waco Violence Inevitable.”12 Everyone, however, agrees with Nancy T. Ammerman’s judicious observations: After the disastrous BATF raid on the home of the Branch Davidians, as the FBI settled into their long siege and the world’s news organizations created a small village outside the perimeter, scholars of religion—with near unanimity—shook their head in collective disbelief at the strategies being adopted by federal law enforcement. Did they not know that a group was more likely to rally behind its charismatic leader than to surrender to his enemies? Did they not know that apocalyptic beliefs should be taken seriously, that they were playing the role of the enemies of Christ? Did they not know that any course of action that did not seem to come from the Bible would be unacceptable to these students of Scripture? Did they really believe they were dealing with hostages? I have yet to encounter a single sociologist or religious studies scholar who has the slightest doubt that the strategies adopted by the FBI were destined for tragic failure.13
In March 1993 Philip Arnold of the Reunion Institute in Houston went on the air (radio) and discussed the relevance of Revelation, Koresh’s primary text, for the Branch Davidians’ self-understanding. 12 All four articles are found in James R. Lewis, ed., From the Ashes: Making Sense of Waco (Lanham, Maryland: Rowman & Littlefield, 1994). The authors and page numbers are as follows: Moorman Oliver, Jr., 71–86; William H. Swatos, Jr., 201–4; Stuart A. Wright, 95–98; and Robert C. Hicks, 63–66. 13 Nancy T. Ammerman, “Waco, Law Enforcement, and Scholars of Religion,” in Armageddon, ed. Stuart A. Wright, 282–83.
142
Koresh heard the show on his transistor radio and requested that he be allowed to discuss Scripture with Arnold. The FBI denied the request but sent tapes of the broadcasts to the group. This prompted Arnold and James Tabor to develop a plan for communicating with Koresh. On April 1, 1993, they went on the radio and discussed the “prophetic technicalities of the Waco situation as it might be viewed by the Branch Davidians.”14 Koresh expressed pleasure that he had finally found biblical scholars who understood what he was trying to say, or at least spoke his language. The government did not capitalize upon this whatsoever. The night before the April 19, 1993 fire, Koresh began to write his document on the Seven Seals, after which he intended to come out. He did not, quite obviously, have the chance to finish it; however, he did make sure that what he had written made it to Tabor through one of his followers, Ruth Riddle. In keeping with Koresh’s wishes, Tabor has provided that material to the public.15 The conflagration ended the Koresh era of the movement. Eleven of the survivors have been incarcerated on conspiracy charges; others manage The Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, which distributes Koresh’s materials free of charge. To date, no new leader has arisen. This brief history has situated the group in its historical context, for, in one scholar’s words: “Only through an understanding of Adventist history can one ever hope to accurately comprehend Koresh within a meaningful context. The media and the federal government were satisfied with the generic label ‘cult’ leader, as if Koresh somehow existed outside time and place.”16 Tabor answers his own question, “Why Waco?” thus: scriptural interpretation and an apocalyptic worldview were central to this group and its leader, and this fact was never recognized or taken seriously by the negotiators, one of whom thought that Koresh meant aquatic animals when he referred to the Seven Seals. While some rely primarily on disaffected apostates from the group, Tabor interviews faithful Branch Davidians who survived the fire to discover why they followed Koresh and
14
Tabor and Gallagher, Waco, 14. For a more detailed history of the Branch Davidians, see Pitts, “Davidians”; see also David Bromley and Edward D. Silver, “The Davidian Tradition: From Patronal Clan to Prophetic Movement,” both in Stuart A. Wright, ed., Armageddon. See also Tabor and Gallagher, Waco, 23–51. 16 Tabor and Gallagher, Waco, 43. 15
143
lived in that community. Both the faithful and the apostates cite Koresh’s exegetical skills as the primary draw to the group. Scripture functioned as the central core of the Branch Davidians, whose quotidian Bible studies could occasionally last fifteen hours. These were people to whom Scripture mattered, for whom Scripture provided a symbolic worldview that approximated their experience. Initially, the group’s proselytizers attempted to interest these people in hearing Koresh, who was said to have great wisdom and skill in expounding the entire Bible, particularly the prophets and the book of Revelation, in a way that none could equal. Koresh’s entire efforts rested on the fundamental presupposition, sacrosanct through 150 years of Adventist history, that humankind was living in the last days, and that God’s true people would be guided by the voice of a living prophet. The crux of the Davidian claim was that no one could have the wisdom and skill that Koresh had in the Scriptures unless God had inspired him or her. Koresh viewed the parent body of Seventh-Day Adventists as apostate and corrupt. . . . The absolute center of life at Mount Carmel was the Bible studies that Koresh conducted for the group. He claimed that those who lived at Mount Carmel were exposed to his deeper teachings, which had never been revealed before. Within the group there was a sense that God was beginning to reveal more and more truth and understanding, and Koresh and his followers spoke of this with joy and exhilaration. The Davidians thought themselves to be on the absolute edge of God’s latest revelation regarding all the matters that would pertain to the final events of history and their own vital participation therein—and it was all being expounded to them through the mouth of David Koresh.17
Already the reader might notice some similarities with the Johannine community, and there are legion others. For instance, just as Jesus is the center of the message and the center of Scripture, so too is Koresh for this group: “You reject Cyrus, you reject God.”18 More than once in the Fourth Gospel John has Jesus claim that to know him is to know the Father and to reject him is to reject the Father. John’s community was rejected by its parent tradition though the community saw itself as the true and pure form of that tradition. It saw itself as standing against the “world”; likewise, the Branch Davidians, accused of brainwashing people, claim, “No, the truth is,
17
Ibid., 26–31. David Koresh, Ancient of Days, audiocassette transcript, June 14, 1986, as quoted in Tabor and Gallagher, Waco, 32. 18
144
it is the world that is brainwashed.”19 An analysis of the group at Waco promises to provoke interesting questions concerning John’s community.
Primary Sources The primary evidence for the role of Scripture in the life of the Branch Davidians comes from the cassette tapes of Koresh’s exegesis and the final written transcript given to James Tabor. I will analyze such data to ask how Scripture functioned in that group, providing identity and boundaries for the group, legitimating the authority of its leader, and prescribing particular ethics. Tabor prefaces his own attempt to do so with words somehow appropriate to the Fourth Gospel: “Koresh and his followers lived within a coded world of biblical language that created for them a sacred context they perceived to be concrete, systematic, and reliable. Those ‘outside’ had few, if any, clues to comprehending this world, so that the most technical and vital aspects of the group’s understanding of Scripture simply became ‘mumbo jumbo’ and ‘Bible babble.’”20 Most of the cassettes that feature Koresh undertaking scriptural exegesis are simply recordings of group Bible study or worship.21 A few find Koresh alone elucidating Scripture for the sake of those about to receive the tape, whether it be a group in Australia (see Letter to Australia) or Wisconsin (Letter to Steve Schneider and the Wisconsin Brethren). These electronic epistles serve as do Paul’s letters to the early Christian communities. They are composed not for the sake of a general audience but seek to shape a community with whom there is already a connection and a certain amount of shared knowledge and worldview. As the common saying among Pauline scholars goes, then, “It is like listening to one side of a telephone conversation.” The tapes have been entitled, though it is unclear who has chosen the titles.22 It should also be noted that of the twenty-four I
19
Ibid., 33. Ibid., 52. 21 At the time of my inquiry, The Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund offered twentyfour cassettes through its catalogue. Those are the twenty-four alluded to above. 22 Because the Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund maintains a catalogue from which anyone can order the materials, it may be that the titles were assigned for the sake 20
145
own, two are from 1984, three from 1985, four from 1986, eleven from 1987, none from 1988, and one from 1989. There is a gap from 1989 to 1993, and the only recording from 1993 is the March 2 radio broadcast conducted just after the February raid and just before the April destruction. Two are undated. The literary evidence consulted comprises The Decoded Message of the Seven Seals of the Book of Revelation, Daughters of Zion, Get Ready! The Message, Letter to Sister Smith, Letter to the Seventh-Day-Adventist Church, and Blow Ye the Trumpet in Zion, all downloaded from Mark Swett’s website. Though I have personally listened to them, I have relied upon Mark Swett’s transcriptions of Jonah, Judge What I Say, and Enter Into Rest—the Seventh Seal.23 Where I rely upon a transcript, I have indicated the name of the transcriber and the online location of the transcript; when I refer to the content of a sound recording, I indicate that by “audiocassette.” While I do not want to prematurely announce or provide a detailed summary of the similarities between the Branch Davidian and the Johannine evidence, it is useful to indicate some broad similarities and dissimilarities at the start. I suggest the following as points of similarity: 1) both express a concern for proper interpretation of Scripture; 2) both insist that only a privileged leader can execute such an interpretation; and 3) both are composed for a specific, already committed (albeit to various degrees) audience. But there are also points of dissimilarity. The Branch Davidian materials are abundant, they cover a period of nine years, they consist of both oral and written materials, and they contain materials directed to a variety of audiences. I distinguish four types of evidence and present them in descending order of priority: 1) that whose primary audience was the group residing at Waco; 2) that directed to Davidians residing elsewhere: Letter to Australia, Letter to Steve Schneider and the Wisconsin Brethren; 3) that directed to Adventists and lapsed Branches: Judge What I Say; and 4) that directed to complete outsiders including other denominations and “the world”: Radio Sermon and The Decoded Message of the Seven Seals of the Book of Revelation. I weight the materials composed
of ordering ease. The titles in the catalogue and those on the cassettes themselves do not always exactly agree. 23 Mark Swett maintains a website regarding Koresh and the Branch Davidians which is located at http://home.maine.rr.com/waco.
146
for the sake of the community most heavily because I consider the Fourth Gospel and the Johannine Epistles to be materials of that order. My interest in the Branch Davidian material lies in its potential for illuminating understanding of the Fourth Gospel.
Analysis of Primary Sources I now lay aside what outside observers suggest about the Branch Davidians and turn instead to the Davidians’ own understanding of themselves, always with a view to what function Scripture plays in encouraging particular self-understandings and discouraging others. I report on the salient concerns, themes, and techniques that repeatedly occur in Koresh’s exegesis and use of Scripture. Does Scripture function for this sect as I have hypothesized it might for sects in general? Formation of the Sect All scholars who provide a history of the sect’s emergence record its birth date as 1929, under the leadership of V. Houteff. Every comprehensive historical account begins with William Miller ca. 1818. The Davidians themselves, however, trace their history to a much earlier date. Koresh finds in the biblical texts, especially Revelation, clear reference to the group’s continually unfolding history. Rev 7 figures prominently in this and appears in most of the study sessions. I commence my explication of how Scripture is used to highlight and make certain claims regarding the group’s emergence with an interpretive example that showcases other aspects of Koresh’s techniques as well: “And after these things ( John says) I saw four angels standing on the four corners of the earth” (Rev 7:1a). These are the mysteries, these four angels here. “. . . holding the four winds of the earth, that the wind should not blow on the earth, nor on the sea, nor on any tree” (Rev 7:1b). Now inspiration revealed through the seventh angel’s message that seeing that 144,000 have not been sealed yet, and seeing that there must be four prophetic messages holding the strife from the world against the church, we have to look today for a present interpretation of who these four angels are. Now we know that all the messages from Enoch
147
all the way down to our day . . . well, let me back up. From Enoch all the way down to 1844, the judgment of the dead, all those messages are contained in Ellen G. White. Ellen G. White brought us the modern Israel of the day. Israel, Sabbath keeping people. That’s the third angel’s message. Now seeing that the Sabbath is still present truth, still present truth, and that the world is held accountable for knowing this true Sabbath, Saturday, that is one of the angels. But there is also another angel that joined the third angel that is important for the people to know about today, and that was Victor Houteff. His message was about the New Jerusalem. And then we had another message about the Branch name, the Branch He. That’s the other angel. But then to our surprise we have a sixth angel, Lois I. Roden, who brought us the Branch She message, who started revealing the mystery of Christ, the fullness of the Godhead bodily. Now these four angels Branches, use your senses, common sense, are the main four prophetic messages which the world is held responsible for today of knowing. Now remember, this is a revelation. And these messages hold, or keep the persecution of the world away from the church. And we also know something else, that another angel is ascending from the east. [The] east represents the old country but it also represents dry wind. Now notice, this angel comes and tells the four angels, “Do not hurt the wicked until we have sealed.” So right there people have always wanted to know when the 144,000 were going to be sealed. They’ve always . . . now wait a minute . . . Sister White was the first one who saw the vision of the 144,000. Her first vision was of the 144,000, so we know one of those four angels is Ellen White. Brother Houteff came teaching he was to seal them. And Brother Roden the same, and Sister Roden point blank says that her message is mainly for wave sheaf. So here’s another point. Wave sheaf is barley. We also know that Sister White, Brother Houteff, Brother Roden, Sister Roden, they never gathered the 144,000 to seal them. They’ve been gathering barley. Now, how do we know this? Remember, according to Ezekiel four, six grains, from Luther all the way to Ellen White, were to be combined into what? One barley cake. In other words, barley . . . Ellen G. White said that when all those who died under the third angel’s message would be resurrected in the special resurrection. So the third angel’s message gathered barley. And Victor Houteff came in Leviticus declaring to be the Vanguard, the first of the first fruits. So that right there, everyone who joined the Shepherd’s Rod became what? Not 144,000, they became wave sheaf, Vanguard. Then Brother Roden came declaring that all those who joined the Branch He message become what? Wave sheaf. And then Sister Roden comes along and point blank and teaches her message is to gather wave sheaf. So here we have four angels holding the winds, that the winds should not blow until the servants of God, the 144,000, the antitypical disciples of the day, are going to be sealed. So now it’s not until the angel ascends from the east, which would be the seventh angel. Let me
148
repeat now, Sister White’s the third, Brother Houteff is the fourth, Brother Roden is the fifth, Sister Roden is the sixth, and the angel ascending from the east is the seventh angel, the seventh angel saying, “Hurt not till we have sealed the servants of our God in their foreheads with the seal of the living God.” Who’s the living God? The Sabbath seal, the Sabbath seal. Now the question is, we have been taught the Branches may say, that Brother Houteff was the seal with the New Jerusalem and Brother Roden sealed with the Kingdom seal but now someone here now is teaching that they don’t have these seals and [that is] true. Let’s see what the Bible says. We turn to Revelation, chapter 14, where again this same subject is being brought to view.24
A number of points should be noted. First, Koresh’s interpretation, what he calls “common sense,” is comprehensible only within a specific privileged context, that is, the Branch Davidians under Koresh. In-group jargon abounds, including “inspiration,” “revelation,” “the 144,000,” “1844,” “present truth,” “Ellen G. White, V. Houteff, B. Roden, L. Roden,” “Branch He,” “Branch She,” “wave sheaf,” “antitypical,” and “the special resurrection.” This reflects the use of rhetorical techniques to effect inclusion or exclusion. Second, the Davidians are an elect, elevated group, “wave sheaf,” “first fruits,” “modern Israel.” Third, Koresh uses Scripture to interpret Scripture. In elaborating upon the four angels holding the four winds, he declares: “So the third angel’s message gathered barley,” drawing upon Ezek 4. Through the quotation and interpretation of a single verse, Rev 7:1, Koresh has managed to achieve a number of necessary ends. He has helped to create a sense of “us” by appealing to the group’s history and grounding it not only in the more recent past, but tracing it all the way back to Enoch. As a part of that history, he indicates that the founder of the sect (and most of its subsequent leaders) enjoyed special insight regarding Scripture. He also elevates “us” in at least two ways, one overtly and one covertly, the former via such laudatory sobriquets as “first fruits” and “wave-sheaf ” and the latter by adopting Ellen G. White, a figure who belongs to the Seventh-Day Adventist Church, as the sect’s own and connecting her with three of the sectarian leaders, Houteff, Roden, and Roden when presenting an interpretation of Rev 7:1. Unlike the scholarly
24 David Koresh, Judge What I Say, audiocassette recorded April 2, 1985. Transcribed by David Bunds. Online: http://home.maine.rr.com/waco.
149
presentations, the move from White to Houteff is seamless and smooth in Koresh’s own. The interpretation does more, though, than simply rehearse the group’s past, as indicated by the scriptural verse; it sets boundaries, establishes the loci of authority for the group, and encourages perseverance. In this single passage we find Koresh using Scripture, here Rev 7:1, to establish boundaries in two ways. First, he declares that one of the four angels is Ellen G. White, whose primary message had to do with keeping the Sabbath on Saturday. He thereby enjoins his followers to observe a Saturday Sabbath, expressing concern for ritual practice. Second, by using jargon he draws a line between insiders, for example, those who understand what is meant by the mere mention of 1844 or Branch She, and outsiders, who do not. This reflects the use of rhetorical techniques to effect inclusion or exclusion. By means of Rev 7:1 Koresh insists that Scripture stands at the center of the group. When a question arises, which here regards Koresh’s teaching that some of the former leaders were mistaken about their role in the ingathering of the 144,000, Koresh says, “Let’s see what the Bible says.” While Scripture certainly does enjoy elevated status, Koresh’s interpretation makes it clear that Scripture’s authority for the group depends upon “inspiration revealed through the seventh angel’s message,” which, as the sect knows, refers to Koresh’s own message. His authority prevails. Koresh begins his interpretation of the passage by indicating an imminent period of trial: “There must be four prophetic messages holding the strife from the world against the church.” Later he says, “And these messages hold, or keep the persecution of the world away from the church.” By this he means to say that each of the four angels named, White, Houteff, Roden, and Roden, was about the business of gathering the 144,000, after which the consummation of the eschaton would arrive. None of them achieved it, so the Final Judgment, the wind, has been held back so that the seventh angel’s message could accomplish the ingathering.25 The former leaders would 25 For the tyro, some confusion inheres in the numbering of the angels. There are seven angels with messages in Revelation. The four angels who appear in Rev 7:1 are the third, fourth, fifth and sixth angels, and they divulged their messages to White, Houteff, Roden, and Roden, respectively. The first two angels are both connected with William Miller; the first angel’s message was that preached by him prior to 1844 and the second was that preached after 1844.
150
not have seen themselves as the four angels of Rev 7:1 and clearly thought that they were, in fact, to gather the 144,000; it is only in hindsight, or with the aid of “inspiration,” “present truth,” and “new light,” that all of the group’s history up to Koresh has been placed in its proper perspective. Koresh’s message is the clarion call, and those who persevere will be “sealed.” By reviewing all of the primary sources one can compose a brief outline of the group’s self-presentation of its history. Note that Koresh clearly and unwaveringly identifies with Christianity in general and Adventism in particular. In the course of amply listening to and reading Koresh’s interpretation of Scripture, one pieces together Koresh’s view concerning how his group came to be. As he exegetes Jonah, we learn that it is a story of “movements who failed to progress into the ever unfolding ray of truth, the spirit of prophecy, God’s purpose on earth.”26 He quotes the first half of Amos 3:7: “ ‘the Lord God will do-’” and the group finishes it: “-nothing, but he revealeth his secret unto his servants the prophets.”27 It is a story of figures, prophets, arising in a denomination, insisting on reform among their brethren, having their message largely fall on deaf ears and, consequently, a new group developing.28 So, after centuries of “darkness”, which comprises the hegemony of the Catholic Church, Martin Luther appears and leads the Protestant Reformation. “They reformed in that they chose not to follow the heresies and the traditions of Rome, but to follow only the ‘thus saith the Lord’ as recorded in the word of God. Luther brought this out to them ‘the just shall live by faith as it is written,’ not as it is prelated through
26
David Koresh, Jonah, audiocassette recorded April 25, 1989. Transcribed by Mark Swett. Online: http://home.maine.rr.com/waco. Though Houteff might not have conceded Koresh’s point, Koresh declares that Houteff ’s movement “failed,” at least in part, and explains why that happened: “They did the same thing they’d been preaching against the Adventists were doing—consulting with flesh.” David Koresh, Ezekiel 21, audiocassette recorded October 19, 1984. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. 27 Amos 3:7 and Rev 10:7 comprise the most frequently completed Bible verses by the group. 28 This type of reasoning is evident in the following excerpt: “In 1929, the fourth angel came according to Rev 14:15. This message came to join the third angel of the dead—Ellen G. White’s message. This message came to announce the imminent judgement of the living. This movement was called The Shepherd’s Rod. It was given the greatest amount of light we’ve had heretofore. But folks were proud and arrogant so God took another route—the Branch Davidians. To begin the judgment at the house of God was to begin with the Davidians” Koresh, Ezekiel 21.
151
the prelates, huh?”29 Though Luther “didn’t have all the light,”30 he “faithfully gave his message to the Nineveh of that time.” The Catholic Church rejects Luther’s message and the Lutheran church is born. Luther dies and the next prophet to arise is John Knox. As the “new ray of light” he attempts to reform his Lutheran brethren teaching that one must be born again by the agency of the Holy Spirit as testified to in Scripture. The Lutherans reject Knox and Presbyterianism is born. Wesley arises and exhorts the Presbyterians. “The Methodists had to finally become the Baptists, and the Baptists become the Adventists, and the Adventists become the Seventh-Day-Adventists.”31 The Adventists grew out of the Baptists insofar as William Miller, the founder of Adventism, was a Baptist. Often Koresh alludes to what “we as Adventists” know, believe, or do. For example: “We as Seventh-Day Adventists we might be more blind than we think. We might be more judgmentive [sic] of others and we need to judge ourselves a bit more”;32 or, “We know as Adventists we have the judgment message;” or, “What is truth? What is this message to the Laodicean church of which I, being a Seventh-Day Adventist, I know I’m a part because our denomination proclaimed the judgment according to Daniel’s prophecies?”33 Koresh sees the Branch Davidians as the continuation and perfection of the Reformation.34 In keeping with the observation made by sociologists of sectarianism, Koresh sees his group not as outside Christianity or Seventh Day Adventism but as a purified form of them, the genuine expression of what they call for. At the same time, he does recognize that his group constitutes a small, contentious part of these larger bodies. Koresh prefaces his explication of “the marriage feast” by saying
29
Koresh, Jonah. His dietary habits indicate that Luther still lacked some light. Koresh asks the group how Luther died and they answer, “Overeating.” He confirms that Luther “didn’t know how to regulate his mouth, did he? That had not yet been given to him yet, huh? Back in those days when you used to be sick, do you know what they prescribed to you? Food! You got a bellyache you need to eat some food. Any kind of pain in the stomach was you were hungry. Dark days in those days.” Koresh, Jonah. The Davidians, as Adventists, consider dietary habits an important part of the religious life, as we shall see further when discussing the group’s ethics. 31 Koresh, Jonah. 32 David Koresh, What is Truth?, undated audiocassette. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. 33 Tabor and Gallagher, Waco, 48. 34 David Koresh, Ezekiel 47, audiocassette recorded November 11, 1984. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. 30
152
that when people hear the explanation, “you’ll know why our little group is in so much trouble all the time.”35 Regarding his “little group,” Koresh originally taught that the group was living during the sixth seal and within that seal are four angels, White, Houteff, Roden, and Roden. In the latter part of his tenure, Koresh would claim that the seventh seal was being revealed via himself. For example: In other words, we want to know who the Lord’s feet are according to Zechariah 14. So therefore, if Uzziah represents Victor Houteff then Jotham must represent Brother Roden and Ahaz Sister Roden and then Hezekiah must also represent the seventh angel’s message. In other words we’re taking from Brother Roden’s writings and showing that Victor Houteff was Uzziah, then Jotham would be Brother Roden. Sister Roden would be Ahaz and Vernon Howell, the seventh angel’s message, would be Hezekiah.36
Though he traces the group’s history ultimately back to creation down through the Reformation, the period from White to Koresh commands the majority of discussion regarding the group’s history. As noted above, Koresh often chooses Rev 7 for study and rehearses the group’s history by interpreting Rev 7:3. Now remember these four angels here are standing on the four corners of the earth and they have power to hurt don’t they? That means their message has come, has been rejected, and now they have power to hurt. Now this angel who is ascending from the east has the seal of the living God. Who are these four messages—these four angels? It should be very simple. The only message that we’ve ever had as pertaining to judgment that deals with the 144,000—the first message that is, was contained in the third angel’s message, the Sabbath. The Sabbath seal, or the third angel of 1844, contains all the truth from creation to the time of Christ. And the third angel’s message was a review of that history, so that all the world would realize that the judgment for the dead had begun. The first vision that Ellen G. White had was of the 144,000. That’s simple isn’t it? Now if that interpretation is true then we should easily be able to see that as far as the world is concerned today; what four messages is all the earth responsible for? Well, the message of the Sabbath, the message of the Kingdom, the message of the new name both he and she. In other words, we
35 David Koresh, Voice of Fire, audiocassette undated. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. 36 Koresh, Judge.
153
see these four angels as Sister White, Brother Houteff, Brother Roden, and Sister Roden.37
In Koresh’s scheme, as in all Adventist interpretations, William Miller conveyed the first two angels’ messages, the first in 1833 and the second prior to 1844.38 On October 22, 1844, Christ entered the celestial Holy of Holies and at that time the judgment of the dead occurred. Also in keeping with Adventism, Ellen G. White represents the third angel’s message, which largely teaches the observance of a Saturday Sabbath. Koresh presents White as simply the next step in the unfolding Christian, meaning Adventist, meaning Branch Davidian, history: “Ezekiel 4 tells us that the third angel’s message consisted of six grains—six grains: Luther, Knox, Wesley, Campbell, Miller, White. But they were combined into what kind of cake? A barley cake. Branches, what is barley? Wave sheaf.”39 Victor Houteff offered the fourth angel’s message, which Koresh often refers to as the New Jerusalem. While all secondary sources trace the emergence of the Branch Davidian movement to V. Houteff in 1930 and indicate it in terms of a crucial disjuncture, Koresh once again moves immediately and smoothly from Ellen White to V. Houteff in his rehearsal of the group’s “myth of origins”: “Only those who joined the third angel’s message, who died when Sister White was alive, will be resurrected as wave sheaf. But when Brother Houteff came in 1930, he came to seal with the Sabbath seal . . . . Those who were Adventists, who joined the Shepherd’s Rod, became true Sabbath keepers and they received the Sabbath seal.”40 In fact, Koresh depicts a seamless history from the to the present. Each successive stage represents further progress and “light” so that no earlier phase of Christianity enjoys a privileged status. Take, for example, his attitude toward Miller’s message in relation to Paul’s: “So William Miller’s message was just as much a part of the gospel as Paul’s message, wasn’t it? Those who rejected William Miller couldn’t be saved.”41 37
David Koresh, The Seventh Angel—Enter Into Rest, audiocassette recorded on January 31, 1985 in Jerusalem. Transcribed by Mark Swett. Online: http://home. maine.rr.com/waco. 38 David Koresh, Confusion, Part I, audiocassette recorded July 18, 1987. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. 39 Koresh, The Seventh. 40 Koresh, Judge. 41 Koresh, Confusion, Pt. 1.
154
Florence Houteff, who succeeded Victor Houteff, does not factor into Koresh’s version of the group’s history. Rather, he skips to Ben Roden as the bearer of the fifth angel’s message, which he usually refers to as the Branch He message. Lois Roden related the sixth angel’s message “revealing the mystery of Christ, the fullness of the Godhead bodily.” Branch She42 is the shorthand for Lois Roden’s addition of the feminine to teachings on God. While occasional reference is made to George Roden’s unjustified attempt to seize leadership of the group, he is never depicted as anything but an imposter. The group history moves from Lois Roden to Koresh’s own era of leadership, at which time the seventh, and last, angel’s message is revealed. That message primarily concerns the opening and interpretation of the seven seals, which reveals the final and ultimate truth about all matters, especially history, the restoration of the House of David, the meaning of Scripture, the solution to scriptural puzzles, and the nature and imminence of the apocalyptic eschaton. David Koresh’s ministry represents the time when the 144,000 would be gathered: “1985, the ministry begins and the sealing of the 144,000 is to start.”43 Thus, Scripture functions prominently in the retelling of the group’s history in at least three related ways. First, in the Davidians’ estimation, Scripture itself points forward to and adumbrates the group’s history. Second, the twentieth-century group looks back to Scripture and views itself in light of it. Finally, Scripture is used as an excuse to rehearse the group’s history. In other words, while the ostensible goal of a Bible study is simply to interpret correctly whatever Scripture is at hand that day, the choice of Scripture to interpret as well as its fittingness for presenting the group’s history is no accident. In this way, Koresh uses Scripture to build an identity for his group and the individuals who comprise it. He instills a bold confidence
42 The Branch “He” and the Branch “She” stem from a twofold observation. First, Ezek 36:8 refers to the mountains of Israel shooting forth their branches. Second, the Gospels contain the parable of the fig tree, a judgment parable in which “Matthew says the branch he, Mark says the branch she, and Luke tells us, learn the parable of the fig tree and all the trees” [italics mine]. Koresh, Judge. It is true that the KJV translates ı klãdow aÈt∞w “his” branch at Matt 24:32 and “her” branch at Mark 13:28, but why it ascribes a masculine translation to a feminine possessive remains a mystery. At any rate, like Rabbi Akiba and others, Koresh finds significance in such details. 43 Koresh, Judge.
155
in this afflicted minority community so that, equipped with the certain knowledge that they are a privileged, elect group, they might persevere and abide with the group. Like the Qumran sect, the Branch Davidian situation corroborates Wuthnow’s claims about the importance of constructing and relating a group’s collective history: “These, like our individual stories, are perhaps myths that reconstruct the past and have minimal connections to actual history, yet they play a powerful role in making the sacred concrete. They do so by making it public, visible, so it can be internalized into the consciousness of individual members.44 Former Leaders and Their Works Koresh does more than list former leaders in his recounting of the group’s history; he also refers to their teachings as authoritative. For instance, while interpreting Ezek 21 Koresh claims, “And the only plan of salvation there is is contained in the everlasting gospel presented by William Miller. . . . You’ll also find that same gospel continued on by Ellen G. White, picked up again by Brother Houteff, also found through Brother Roden’s message. Sister Roden’s. And there is a seventh angel too.”45 Like all Adventists, Koresh often invokes the teachings of “Sister Ellen G. White.” At least as often he quotes the sect’s founder, “Brother Houteff ” who, like White, produced numerous writings. For example, “Our study aim—in the message of The Loud Cry—is to find out who are the foolish virgins. As we learn in 2nd Shepherd’s Rod 185, Brother Houteff says they’re the ones who had confidence in men. They saw no necessity for more light, more prophets, truth, or a message.”46 Elsewhere he narrates the group’s history as shown in Revelation and says this of Houteff: “In 1929, the fourth angel came according to Rev 14:15. This message came to join the third angel’s message of the dead— Ellen G. White’s message. The message came to announce the imminent judgment of the living. This movement was called The Shepherd’s Rod. It was given the greatest amount of light we’ve had heretofore.”47 It is clear from the cassettes that the group uses charts composed
44 45 46 47
Wuthnow, Producing, 61. Koresh, Ezekiel 21. Koresh, The Seventh. Koresh, Ezekiel 21.
156
by Houteff and successive Davidian prophets. The following quote, whose context is an interpretation of Ezek 47, indicates both the use of such charts and the fact that Koresh views the leaders as Christ figures: Brother Roden hasn’t reaped the 144,000, though he will. Because he as Christ and Brother Houteff as Christ and all those from the third angel’s message on will be resurrected as Christ was resurrected to finish the work, to gather the 144,000. To prove it, Brother Houteff shows on the ceremonial chart he shows from 31 .. on the wave sheaf offering. And in 1844 the door was opened and he shows, what’s the symbol up there? Barley. Proves it to the tee doesn’t it?48
He alludes to the Rodens’ work rather than quoting them verbatim. For instance, “Sister Roden used to tell us that the days of creation was a compacted prophecy.”49 All of these examples attest to the group’s leaders as loci of authority and those that showcase Houteff show the sect’s founder to have special insight regarding Scripture. As important as they are, none of these writings enjoys the same level of authority as Scripture, and each is considered enlightened only insofar as possible given the limitations and constraints imposed upon it by virtue of its place in the progressive revelation of truth. So, in referring to White’s work, “The Great Controversy,” he cautions his listeners: “Sure, take ‘Great Controversy,’ read it through, but Ellen G. White will tell you point blank that she didn’t have all the light.” Loci of Authority Scripture Studying Scripture’s function within a group from a sociological perspective always involves a twofold task: (1) to understand how the group itself describes the role of Scripture in its midst and (2) to understand how an outsider might view the role of Scripture in the group. Anthropologists designate the former the “emic” function of Scripture and the latter the “etic” function of Scripture, but only with certain qualifications. First, the emic and the etic may coincide; second, the etic may be considered an addition to the emic rather
48 49
Koresh, Ezekiel 47. Koresh, The Seventh.
157
than a denial of it; finally, where the emic treads on holy or supernatural ground, the etic cannot follow insofar as sociology and empirical analysis are inherently limited to natural ground. The overwhelming conviction presented in the exegetical tapes is that Scripture is the inviolable source of all truth. Quoting John 10, Koresh announces: “The law [by which Koresh means to indicate “Scripture”] cannot be broken.”50 Without question, Scripture stands at the center of the group’s activity and identity. Koresh conducted lengthy quotidian Bible studies, and the most common reason given by converted Davidians for why they chose to join the group was Koresh’s command, understanding, and ability to elucidate the Scriptures. Koresh continually emphasizes the centrality of Scripture: “How did Christ overcome? Well, I know one thing—Christ overcame through scripture. It is written. It is written. It is written. Christ also overcame through prophecy which was written.”51 And again, “Christ is quite well-versed in the scriptures . . . always referring, ‘It is written, it is written, it is written’ when he comes up against the devil.”52 He says, “God will have a people who will uphold the Bible and the Bible only.”53 After recapitulating Rev 8:1ff., Koresh warns his listeners: “You better start looking for the angel from the east who’s coming to gather.” The angel is going to seal 144,000 then a “great multitude.” The seventh seal opens and one finds “an angel at the altar only for those who know the truth. He has a censer for the saints. Saints believe in God’s word. They know what truth is. They believe God’s word.”54 By this statement, Koresh implies that Scripture and truth are coextensive so that what is said about one applies to the other. “What is truth? Well, let me tell you, the Lord is truth. He’s the Word. Look at this book—is it truth?” Truth saves: “Truth that doesn’t save you is gonna hurt you. The truth you don’t listen to is gonna 50 David Koresh, Radio Sermon, audiocassette recorded March 2, 1993. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. Koresh quotes John 10:34–35 very quickly. In 10:34 Jesus says, “Is it not written in your law, I said, Ye are gods?” The quote is actually not from the Pentateuch but from Ps 83, indicating that the fourth evangelist used the word “law” rather loosely. I believe Koresh simply misquoted 10:35 which says, “scripture cannot be broken” accidentally because of the presence of “the law” in 10:34. At any rate, he clearly intends to quote the verse and clearly means “Scripture.” 51 Koresh, What is Truth? 52 Koresh, Radio Sermon. 53 Koresh, What is Truth? 54 Ibid.
158
hurt you. No ostrich games in God’s kingdom. . . . People today are not really concerned about truth.”55 In Koresh’s teaching, truth is closely bound to judgment and exists in unexpected form: “The prophecies teach something contrary to any human planning.”56 Scripture is the basis for all that the community says and does. “Being Christian, our foundation is supposed to be the Bible. . . . I’m building up to this point: we’re supposed to be Christians who are founded upon a sacred parchment known as the Bible which is a record of men who have gone before.”57 There is a war being waged and Scripture is a weapon, a sword: “The sword is a message that comes not to the world to destroy the wicked but to destroy or save the wicked in the church.”58 Who is the slayer of Ezek 21:11? Koresh asks. He answers: “Paul tells us that the word of God is a two-edged sword. The word of God given to a messenger is the same as giving a man a sword in a battle to obtain a victory.”59 When he refers to Paul’s words about the sword, Koresh must have Heb 4:12 in mind, implying that he assumes Paul wrote it. We should not be surprised to find Koresh picking up the sword theme in Ezekiel and Paul because, of the thirty-seven times the word appears, eleven are found in Revelation, Koresh’s favorite book. Of those eleven, six refer to the words that come from Jesus’ mouth (1:16, 2:12, 2:16, 19:15, 19:21, 19:21). Revelation is the Alpha and Omega of all of Koresh’s exegesis; it is the preeminent, ultimate canon within the canon. Next in respective order of importance stand Daniel, other prophetic texts, and then the remaining texts, but they hold significance only insofar as they illuminate Revelation. “You need to understand the full meaning of each passage of scripture, of the prophecies, and its relationship to the book of Revelation. This is the only way that we can have a complete understanding of prophecy and revelation and the way that they both work together. I’m sure we can all agree on this.”60 Koresh inherited this rating of the various texts directly from his predecessors, who received the tradition from Adventism itself.
55 56 57 58 59 60
Koresh, Koresh, Koresh, Koresh, Ibid. Koresh,
What is Truth? What is Truth? Voice of Fire. Ezekiel 21. The Seventh.
159
He admits that people often ask him why he does not “talk about the gospel. How come you always want to talk about prophecy?” His response: Well, you see, prophecy, Peter tells us, is a light that shines in a dark place. Now, how would you have liked to have been Cyrus the King of Persia who came according to prophecy, and understood the prophecies, and demanded that Gath be returned to the land, and yet they did not because they did not fully understand the prophecies? How would you like to have been Alexander the Great who died a death because simply he was fulfilling prophecy, and knew not the day of his visitation? How would you like to be the Jews, who did not fully understand the significance of Daniel chapter nine so that when the Messiah came, he found them unprepared for his gospel, and yet today, we ourselves are in a period of time where we don’t even understand the prophecies?”61
Because one’s salvation depends upon it, knowledge or ignorance of prophecy is no trivial matter. In exegeting Rev 10:7, Koresh turns to Dan 12:1 for illumination: “And at that time shall Michael stand up, the great prince which standeth for the children of thy people: and there shall be a time of trouble, such as never was since there was a nation [even] to that same time: and at that time thy people shall be delivered, every one that shall be found written in the book.” Koresh then warns: Now brethren, honestly before God. If we do not know the events that are foretold by Christ’s own testimony, which Revelation 19 tells us—“the testimony of Jesus Christ is the spirit of prophecy”—then we can be assured that our name is not in that book, because how can we fulfill that which we know not? The Pharisees fulfilled prophecy. They killed the Son of God, did they not? They did, because they knew not the truth pertaining to the events of their day.62
He also turns to Joel to elucidate Rev 10:7 and reiterates the importance of understanding biblical prophecy: Let’s look into the book of Joel and see what wisdom God has placed there that we might understand these things; as God has given each messenger a portion of the truth we must harmonize each prophecy
61 David Koresh, Letter to Steve Schneider and the Wisconsin Brethren, audiocassette recorded in 1987. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. 62 Ibid.
160
of the Bible that we may know the whole truth and be prepared to be delivered, because we are written in the book. If we are the ones who fulfill prophecy in these days then it is God who has spoken of us long ago that through the writings of the prophets God may foreknow us by the spirit of prophecy. If we do not fulfill God’s word we are not written in this book, but if we fulfill that which is written we are in God’s book as a surety, we are children of light.63
He himself indicates that the preoccupation with Daniel and Revelation stems from the Adventist movement. In other words, he did not invent the focus on those texts. One cassette opens with a song entitled “Understand,” which exhorts: I got a secret that I’d like you to understand; see the Book there in the angel’s hand; the book of Daniel’s got a message, a message for you. See the angel with a book in his hand, the book of Daniel, it contains the eternal plan, seven thunders won’t you see, won’t you listen to me, we’ve got the key.64
He claims that “Daniel fits hand in hand with Revelation because Daniel also includes all the other prophecies.”65 If we imagine a set of concentric circles with Revelation at the very center, the next circle would consist of Daniel, followed by the prophetic texts in general and, finally, parts of non-prophetic books which contain prophecy. The following statement is not atypical for Koresh: “Now look at ya. You mean to tell me you don’t know what the prophecies teach in the Old Testament? You don’t know what Isaiah 2 or Micah 4 teaches? Or Jeremiah 36 or Jeremiah 30? You don’t know what Ezekiel 36 or Zechariah 2 teaches? You mean to tell me you don’t know who that mighty army of Joel 2 is? Or of Isaiah 5? Who’s that bird in Ecclesiastes 12? What is the fall of Babylon according to Isaiah 13? . . . You don’t know what happens in Daniel 11 or 12?”66 Elsewhere he prods, “What does Isaiah say about it? What does Malachi? What does Ezekiel? What does Amos? Hosea [which he pronounces Ho-she-a]? Zechariah?” Or, “Do the prophets have
63 64 65 66
Ibid. Koresh, Voice of Fire. Koresh, What is Truth? Ibid.
161
the mystery written within their pages? Isaiah 2; Micah 4; Ezekiel 36; Zechariah 2? Do they relate to Revelation 11?”67 At times Koresh invokes less prophetic books, but uses them only to pull out material related to prophecy. So, he turns to 2 Peter, but the only aspect that interests him is the prophetic one. After reading 2 Pet 1:15, he explains that Peter is “fixin’ to die.” He then reads vv. 16–21. Commenting on v. 19, he says, “Prophecy is like a light that shines in darkness.” In an interpretive move that downplays the authority of apostolic witness and moves the spotlight to biblical prophecy, Koresh interprets Peter’s words, “So we have the prophetic message more fully confirmed,” this way: “Prophecy is an even more sure word than Peter’s own eyewitness.” He draws attention to the mention of “daystar,” which points to the future coming of Christ. He concludes his interpretation of the section with this assertion: “Since God can’t lie, all the prophecies must harmonize.”68 Koresh has an unwavering conviction that “prophecy relates to the future.”69 Early in his teaching he placed his community in the period of Revelation’s sixth seal, though later he would locate them at the beginning of the seventh. “You know the first cases to be judged are those who died in the flood. You know that as well as I do. And you know the seals represent judgments or truth that God has sent to the world since the beginning of the world, since Adam’s time. The sixth seal is our period of time. You know that. Doesn’t take a nit-wit to know those kinda things. But the key is, what do the symbols actually teach? Well, there’s an answer and it’s very clear.”70 Before leaving the topic of Scripture’s role as attested to by Koresh himself, it is important to note that only the King James Version suffices as the authoritative text for interpretation: “[S]tay with the King James and the original renderings but not these modern ones, you know, go with the original King James.”71 Again, Koresh inherited this contention from his predecessors. According to their self-presentation, the Davidians were a scriptural people. They spent a vast amount of time studying it, seeking to 67
Ibid. Koresh, Voice of Fire. 69 Ibid. 70 Koresh, What is Truth? 71 David Koresh, Root of Jesse, audiocassette recorded August 27, 1987. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. 68
162
understand it, and conforming to it. If Geertz is right that culture comprises “the publicly available symbolic forms through which people experience and express meaning,” then Scripture is the most potent cultural element for the group. These were not people who accommodated themselves to the host environment six days a week and made room for the rather odd world of Scripture once a week. For the Davidians, a group whose high degree of tension with its surrounding culture persisted for the course of its existence, Scripture was an absorbing state. The numerous examples given in this section attest to the primacy of Scripture’s authority for the Branch Davidians. Leader Koresh’s Authority To say that Scripture enjoys an authoritative position for the Branch Davidians is correct as far as it goes, but it lacks nuance. Repeatedly the centrality of Scripture is asserted, but nowhere is blind, unquestioning acceptance of it counseled. Quite the contrary. Koresh says: “See why we’re supposed to read the Bible? To see if these things really happened. That’s why the book was written—to judge these men. To see if they be of God or not.”72 Scripture stands under judgment by the group (“we’re supposed to read the Bible”). That is the first note of nuance. Such a proclamation may lead the listener to the assumption that this degrades the authority of Koresh himself as interpreter, that what we have here is the notion that any faithful believer (i.e., member of Koresh’s group at Mt. Carmel) is capable of exacting such judgments, but such is not the case. An extended exchange between Koresh and a potential Branch Davidian reveals, inter alia, that Koresh alone owns the right “to judge these men.” Our second note of nuance, then, is that, much like the Fourth Gospel, it is not Scripture itself which is authoritative, but Scripture as interpreted by the divinely inspired leader of the community. As a corollary, the “we” who are advised to read the Bible and see if it approximates history is not a group of individuals who have undertaken personal studies and then convened to discuss their insights in hopes of arriving at a consensus, but rather a “we” with Koresh at the head leading the group 72 David Koresh, The Assyrians, audiocassette recorded January 10, 1987. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX.
163
qua group into “light,” as he often calls it. Conformity to Koresh’s own interpretation constitutes attainment of truth. So, while Scripture indeed enjoyed a central role at Mt. Carmel, it did so only as interpreted by David Koresh. He alone retained absolute authority over every aspect of life at Mt. Carmel, including the proper understanding of Scripture. Koresh exerts control, elevates his own authority, and puts members in their place all the while doing so in the context of scriptural interpretation. While interpreting Zephaniah, for example, Koresh is teaching about Assyria. A man raises his hand and Koresh says, “Yes, David?” and the exchange proceeds as follows: David: “Manasseh paid tribute to the king of Assyria.” Koresh: “Yes, he did.” David: “He was taken captive and taken to Babylon . . .” (at this point, Koresh talks over the top of him) Koresh: “But again, that title, the scholars have put that title of Assyria. He was taken where again David? You already answered your question. He was taken to Babylon. What was he taken to Babylon for?” David: “Babylon had not conquered Assyria at that time.” Koresh: “Yes they had. Yes they had.” David: “Assyria fell in 612 ..” Koresh: “Yes, that’s what the historians tell us, but there’s somethin’ I know that y’all don’t know yet.” At this point, Koresh turns to an amalgamation of Chronicles, Daniel, and Revelation, commencing with this comment: “Now, inspiration recently revealed—now, I don’t mean to throw our understanding of history away, but I’m just saying we have to understand something more clearly than any scholar has ever understood.” He goes on to ask whether Dan 7:8–9 concerning the little horn head has occurred yet. The group answers in the negative and Koresh confirms it, saying: “No, but Zephaniah is telling us about this event. See what I’m saying, David?” Apparently David remains unabashed because later in the study Koresh asks, “Now, you still with us David? Huh? Are you understanding this or are you having a problem over there?” To which David responds, “I don’t agree with that.” At this point Koresh assails him: “I know you don’t, but I don’t agree with the way you’ve been doin’ your past few weeks here either. I mean,
164
you know, we’ve been talking in the past few years about inheritance and things like that. I’m here to warn ya. We’ve had this experience over and over again. God’s a little bit wiser than what we are and our human wisdom is gonna end up as ashes one of these days.”73 Again, David persists; this time he requests further clarification of Koresh’s assertion that “The Assyrians were the ancient Americans,” asking whether Koresh means that literally or symbolically. Koresh interrupts him and charges: “You’re not listening. I’ve been explaining it here for the past five minutes,” and goes on to exegete a passage of Daniel for him after which he declares, “You see, we’ve been having studies every day some of us here, right? So David and the Bonds are at a disadvantage because this is a very unique subject we’ve been opening up.” Strict boundaries are drawn between those who “understand” and “know” (language used by the Fourth Gospel for the same purpose) and those who do not. Elsewhere Koresh phrases it this way: “Not all of us here have the same knowledge of the truth.”74 Another lengthy exchange between Koresh and a visitor to the group whose sister appears to be a member provides a further example. Troubled by Koresh’s suggestion that he alone can interpret Scripture, she asks if it is not the case that God, by the power of the Holy Spirit, reveals things to the individual who earnestly studies. He responds negatively. At that point, a man asks, “Only you can give it?” to which Koresh replies with his own question: “Does that offend you?” The woman persists and Koresh peremptorily declares: “You may not, by asking God, understand the mysteries of God. God will do nothing but reveal his secret to his servants the prophets. Should you, should you receive an enlightened message from God then you’ll be sittin’ here and I’ll be sittin’ out there.”75 The woman chooses to leave, which Koresh says, “happens all the time.” Like his predecessors, Koresh claimed exclusive authority on the basis of his prophetic office, an office won not by human election but by divine designation. In this role, Koresh was privy to various genuine revelations.76 “But by the mercy of God, God allowed me
73
Ibid. Ibid. 75 Koresh, Confusion, Pt. 1. 76 As opposed to those that are invalid. For instance, referring to a book esteemed by some Adventists, Daniel and Revelation by Uriah Smith, Koresh assures his listeners that the information contained therein “never was a real revelation.” 74
165
to have such a wonderful vision and a wonderful understanding of the seventh angel’s message.”77 In The Assyrians, dated to 1987, Koresh speaks of “The vision in Australia that I had.”78 Elsewhere he claims, “The Lord revealed a very special thing to me here recently”79 and “You see we’re in Jerusalem right now and the Lord revealed something to me here a year and a half ago. . . .”;80 given that he made this statement in April, 1985, this particular revelation must have occurred in 1983. Because he is an anointed messenger, a christ, there is no true knowledge and understanding apart from his teaching. Regarding the interpretation of Ezek 36, Koresh says, “Let each of the Branches read this at their own leisure, and then we’ll be sending out some studies on it because only inspiration can bring it to light.”81 He invites them to admit his privileged status: “Branches, judge in your own hearts. Everything that I’ve spoken, you know is true. Everything. Judge what I say. ‘And when this cometh to pass (lo, it will come), then shall they know that a prophet hath been among them’ (Ezek 33:33).”82 During a study of Hebrews, he quotes Heb 3:12 and then explains its meaning: “How do you depart from the living God, Branches? Well you depart from the living voice, don’t you? The living mouthpiece, right? No Prophet—no truth. That’s the rule.”83 In traditional prophetic style, the leader of the Branch Davidians is to be about the business of reformation. “Where there is any true reform in the Word of God there is a living prophet directing that truth. Otherwise, the church is as it is now.”84 Like the Fourth Gospel, so key is the leader that to reject him is to reject Scripture and, therefore, truth; like the Fourth Gospel, Koresh makes this point explicitly to the listeners: I myself, I been watchin’ people here for quite a while, observing, seeing how they respond to me, seeing how they respond to—well, some of you know how it is in the world when somebody gets mad, who do they get mad at usually? Me. That lady acted like she was [indiscernible word] yesterday, the lady we saw at the store. Right? I’m the devil and Paul’s the good guy, right? He’s the angel there with the 77
Koresh, Judge. Koresh, The Assyrians. 79 David Koresh, A Letter to Australia, audiocassette recorded June 14, 1986. Provided by Mt. Carmel Survivors Fund, Axtell, TX. 80 Koresh, Judge. 81 Ibid. 82 Ibid. 83 Koresh, The Seventh. 84 Koresh, The Bird. 78
166
halo on his head. You see? Why does that stuff happen all the time for? Because they don’t have to accept Paul. You see, they can accept everything Paul says and have the light in their heads and still be lost. But the test is God has given them a person as a covenant to the people. That’s what Isaiah tells us, right? That’s the people who don’t like me from the day go when they just see me for some reason. ’Cause actually in their hearts they don’t like truth, you see?85
Compare Koresh’s presentation of himself here with John 3:19–21 and 8:31–59, in which Jesus indicates that rejection of him signifies rejection of truth and Scripture.86 All of this material corroborates the leader as a locus of authority. Given the elevated status of Scripture and its ostensible authority, it is surprising that Koresh frequently calls attention to discrepancies in the Bible rather than ignoring or denying that contradictions exist. He deals with this “problem” in three different ways. Sometimes he presents the disharmony as a mere fact to be accepted. For example, in his lengthy study on The Assyrians,87 he raises a number questions. For example, when exegeting Zephaniah, Koresh points out that “the destruction of the Land” prophesied has never happened. How does Koresh address the problem? We can’t worship Zephaniah just because he claims to be a prophet, can we? No. That would be stupid, wouldn’t it? We have to prove Zephaniah gibes with history. . . . Always there’s been people in Jerusalem. . . . I’m not gonna worship a dead prophet. . . . The prophet must have been stretching the story a little bit. If that’s the case, the prophet’s a liar. . . . What if the Bible’s a false book? And those of us who are traditional Christians accept it because everybody else does. And that’s tradition too, isn’t it? That’s no different than being a Jew accepting God because your fathers accepted him. And not knowing anything about God.88
85
Koresh, The Assyrians. The parallel is not exact insofar as Koresh speaks in own name, whereas the “leader” in the Fourth Gospel, that is, the author, speaks through the mouth of Jesus. The difference in strategy can be imputed both to the genre difference of the materials (the Fourth Gospel is a narrative, Koresh’s material is an exposition of Scripture) as well as the nature of authority in each group. The Branch Davidians had a tradition of successive authoritative leaders who were elected by God; the evidences various techniques designed to lend authority to the text, from Paul’s insistence on his “apostleship,” to the practice of pseudepigraphy, to the use of characters in a narrative who promulgate the author’s own agenda. The Fourth Gospel falls into the last category. 87 Koresh, The Assyrians. 88 Ibid. 86
167
He provides no immediate resolution but proceeds to the next verse of interest in Zephaniah.89 Finally, at other times he actually accounts for the discrepancies by appealing to “mystery,” which, along with other special jargon such as “revelation,” “present truth,” and “inspiration,” comprises an insider vocabulary, which simultaneously binds group members together more intimately and helps to identify “outsiders.” Discrepancies are only apparent, not actual: “The Bible does contradict itself, bite my tongue, according to man. With inspiration, we can find out why there’s a he tree and a she tree. . . .”90 Unlike, say, a Paul, Koresh is not content to shepherd from afar. His program for the ingathering of the elect seeks to draw all Branch Davidians to Mt. Carmel. In the context of interpreting the eschatological marriage supper on the basis of Zephaniah, Matthew, and Revelation, Koresh indicates this concern: Well, isn’t a marriage supper a sacrifice? Right? You’re blessed just ’cause you’re invited to it. Now you’re tenfold cursed if you don’t accept the response, you see, if you don’t give a response to the call. We had a letter from one of our professed Branches from Canada recently. And you know what they wrote to us? I’m telling this for the benefit of those who haven’t seen this yet. [He goes on to talk about a woman who has given various excuses for not migrating to Waco]. Now she can’t come because some guy proposed though he’s not an Adventist or a Branch or anything but yet he knows what she believes and doesn’t say anything about it. So she’s gonna go ahead and marry him. She hopes to see me in Israel in 1989 for the resurrection. Now that’s deception isn’t it?
He tells the group that his response is: “Well, you’re not gonna see nobody resurrected. You see? What is the test of this message? Come to Texas! Right? God didn’t say come to Texas meaning to stay where you’re at and get the truth ’cause you can’t get it. It’s impossible.”91 To have the group physically reside together, of course, draws clear boundaries between insiders and outsiders and serves as a crucible for inculcating the desired worldview and ethical regulations.
89 Koresh never seriously entertains the notion that the Bible could be a false book but aims rather to present the case as an uninitiated reader might see it. The point is, here he freely raises the problem and does not provide a solution. 90 Koresh, Confusion, Pt. 1. 91 Koresh, The Assyrians.
168
Koresh’s Technique Koresh adopts a number of techniqu