2WWR%RQKRII+HUEHUW6FKDXHU6LHEHQ$XJHQKDWGHU3IDX 9LHUWHU%DQGDXVGHU6HULH Ä'DVXQVLFKWEDUH9LVLHU 0LOLWl...
219 downloads
1045 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
2WWR%RQKRII+HUEHUW6FKDXHU6LHEHQ$XJHQKDWGHU3IDX 9LHUWHU%DQGDXVGHU6HULH Ä'DVXQVLFKWEDUH9LVLHU 0LOLWlUYHUODJGHU'HXWVFKHQ'HPRNUDWLVFKHQ5HSXEOLN9(% %HUOLQ 'UXFNHUHL1HXHV'HXWVFKODQG%HUOLQ 'UXFNXQG:HLWHUYHUDUEHLWXQJ'UXFNHUHLGHV0LQLVWHULXPV IU1DWLRQDOH9HUWHLGLJXQJ9(% %HVWHOOQXPPHU ''50
:LHIULVFKJHZDVFKHQVLHKWGLH6WUDHDXV'HQ$VSKDOWKDW GLH6RQQHVFKRQJHWURFNQHW1XUGHUHUGLJH5DQGVWUHLIHQ EHZDKUWQRFKGLH)HXFKWLJNHLW(UWUlJW3IW]HQ'HU)LFK WHQZDOGEHLGHUVHLWVGHU&KDXVVHHZLUNWKHXWHEHVRQGHUVJUQ 'HUKHIWLJH5HJHQGHUOHW]WHQ1DFKWKDWGHQ6WDXEHLQHUODQJHQ 7URFNHQSHULRGHKLQZHJJHVSOWGLHbVWHJOHLFKVDPQHXJH ODFNWXQGVLHJOlQ]HQGJHPDFKW'LH0RRVSROVWHUVLQGJH VFKZROOHQ,P6WUDHQJUDEHQVWHKW:DVVHU(VLVWNXU]QDFK HOI8KUNHLQH:RONHDP+LPPHOHLQVFK|QHU6RQQWDJ $XIGHP%HLIDKUHUVLW]OLHJWHLQDXIJHIDOWHWHV0HWLVFKEODWW $FKLP'HWMHQQLPPWHV]XU+DQGQDFKGHPHUDQGHQ6WUDHQ UDQGJHIDKUHQLVWXQGJHKDOWHQKDW9DUQGRUIOLHJWKLQWHULKP HUPXVLFKVFKRQLP-DJHQEHILQGHQ'HU=HLJHILQJHU JOHLWHWEHUGLH.DUWH'LH&KDXVVHHGLHJURH.UHX]XQJ ]ZHLQHLQGUHL$E]ZHLJXQJHQGLHLQGHQ:DOGIKUHQ8QG EHLGHUYLHUWHQPVVHHUQDFKUHFKWVDEELHJHQKDW*HQHUDOYRQ :LHVHQHFNEHLGHU(UNOlUXQJGHV:HJHVJHVDJW (UIlKUWMHW]WODQJVDPZHLWHU8PGLHVH6WXQGHKDW'HWMHQ GLH&KDXVVHHVRJXWZLHIUVLFKDOOHLQ=ZHL0RWRUUlGHU NQDWWHUQYRUEHU'LH6R]LXVIDKUHUKDEHQ$QJHOQJHVFKXOWHUW 'LH5XFNVlFNHVLQGDXVJHEHXOWXQGVHKHQDXVDOVKlWWHQLKUH %HVLW]HUDQGLHVHP0RUJHQHLQHQJXWHQ)DQJJHWDQ $FKLPVHXI]W'LHGDN|QQHQEHULKUH)UHL]HLWYHUIJHQ XQGWXQZDVLKQHQ9HUJQJHQPDFKW1DVFK|QLKPZUGH
$QJHOQVLFKHUNHLQHQ6SDEHUHLWHQ6WXQGHQODQJDP:DVVHU VLW]HQXQGGDUDXIZDUWHQGDHWZDVJHVFKLHKWQHLQGDVLVW QLFKWVHLQH6DFKH(U]LHKWHVYRUGDV*HVHW]GHV+DQGHOQV VHOEVW]XEHVWLPPHQ:HQLJVWHQVVRZHLWHVLQVHLQHU0DFKW VWHKW 1DFKUHFKWV,PVHOEHQ$XJHQEOLFNWULWWHUYROODXIGLH %UHPVHZHLOGHU9:.lIHUGHUHEHQVRUXKLJODJ]X VFKDXNHOQEHJLQQWZLHHLQ.XWWHUEHLVFKZHUHU6HH'XOLHEHU +LPPHO'HU:DOGZHJJOHLFKWHLQHP)OXGHOWD'LH5HLIHQ VFKZHUHU)DKU]HXJHKDEHQHLQH8QPHQJHYRQ6SXUHQLQGHQ %RGHQJHJUDEHQ'LHVWHKHQMHW]WYROO:DVVHU(LQH9LHO]DKO YRQ5LQQHQGXUFK'lPPHJHWUHQQWEUHLWHWVLFKDXVXQGHV LVWVFKZHUDE]XVFKlW]HQZLHWLHIGLHHLQ]HOQHQ3IW]HQVLQG 1XQPLWGHP&KDVVLVDXI]XVHW]HQXQGVWHFNHQ]XEOHLEHQGDV N|QQWHLKPJHUDGHQRFKSDVVHQ2KQHIUHPGH+LOIHNlPHHU VFKZHUOLFKIUHLXQGGLH)RUVWIDKU]HXJHGLHGHQ:HJYHU ZVWHWKDEHQZlUHQZHQQEHUKDXSWIUKHVWHQVPRUJHQ ZLHGHU]XHUZDUWHQ$FKLP'HWMHQVLHKWDXIGDV:DVVHUOD E\ULQWKXQGVHLQH+DOEVFKXKHQLHGHU]LHKWGLH7U]XXQG PDQ|YULHUWGHQ:DJHQDQGHQ5DQG'RUWLVWGHU%RGHQKDOE ZHJVIHVWGDOlWVLFKREZRKOPLWEHWUlFKWOLFKHU6FKUlJODJH YRUDQNRPPHQ'DGDV1LHGHUKRO]UDVFKHOQGDQGHU.DURV VHULHHQWODQJVFKOHLIWVW|UWLKQQLFKW(ULVWNHLQHUGHU6RQQ WDJVIDKUHUGLHGHUNOHLQVWH.UDW]HU]X7UlQHQUKUWGDV$XWR LVWIULKQDXVVFKOLHOLFKHLQ%HI|UGHUXQJVPLWWHO /DQJVDPH)DKUWYRUDXV+ROSHUQGXQGVWRHQGTXlOWVLFK GHU:DJHQLPNOHLQHQ*DQJLQGLH7LHIHGHV:DOGHV+LQWHQ JLEWHVHLQHQ%XPV'DVIUGHQ+HUUQ2EHUVWEHVWLPPWH %FKHUSDNHWLVWYRP5FNVLW]DXIGHQ%RGHQJHIDOOHQ$FKLP OlWHVGRUWOLHJHQ (UWUlJWMDVHOEVW6FKXOGDQGLHVHU*HOlQGHIDKUW+lWWHHU VLFKQLFKWGHQNHQN|QQHQGDGHU*HQHUDOHWZDVLP6FKLOGH IKUWHDOVHULKQIUDJWHª0RUJHQLVW6RQQWDJKDEHQ6LHHWZDV YRU"© ª1HLQ©KDWWHHUJHUDGH]XJHDQWZRUWHWª)DXOHQ]HQ VFKZLPPHQJHKHQQLFKWV*HQDXHV©8QGGDPLWIRUGHUWHHU
GLH(UNXQGLJXQJKHUDXVª:ROOHQ6LHPLUHLQHQ*HIDOOHQ WXQ"© :HOFKHU2IIL]LHUNDQQHVVLFKOHLVWHQHLQHP*HQHUDONHLQHQ *HIDOOHQWXQ]XZROOHQ8PVRPHKUZHQQGLHVHU%ULJDGHJH QHUDOEHLHEHQMHQHP0LOLWlULVFKHQ$EVFKLUPGLHQVW0$' GHU %XQGHVZHKUHLQHEHKHUUVFKHQGH5ROOHVSLHOWGHU.XQGVFKDI WHUQGHV0LQLVWHULXPVIU6WDDWVVLFKHUKHLWGHU'HXWVFKHQ 'HPRNUDWLVFKHQ5HSXEOLNYRQ$PWVZHJHQZHQLJJHZRJHQ VHLQGDUI'HU/XIWZDIIHQPDMRULP%RQQHU9HUWHLGLJXQJV PLQLVWHULXP$FKLP'HWMHQKDWDOOHQ*UXQGVLFKGDVDKQXQJV ORVH:RKOZROOHQGHVPlFKWLJHQ0DQQHV]XEHZDKUHQ'DHU HVJHQLHWLVWLQVHLQHU'LHQVWVWHOOHDXIGHU+DUGWK|KHEH NDQQWXQGZHQQGRUWDXFKQLHPDQGGDUEHUVSULFKWGLH XQWHUVWHOOWHª)UHXQGVFKDIW©GHV0DMRUVXQGGHV$EZHKU JHQHUDOVEULQJW9RUWHLOH0DQFKH+UGHKDWHUGDGXUFK QHKPHQN|QQHQXQGZHQQHUJHOHJHQWOLFK=XJDQJ]Xª6WUHQJ JHKHLP©0DWHULDOHUKLHOWGDVLKPHLJHQWOLFKKlWWHYHUVFKORV VHQEOHLEHQPVVHQVRGDQNWHHUGDVGHPLKPDXI*UXQGVHLQHU %H]LHKXQJHQ]XP0$'DQJHKlQJWHQ6LHJHOY|OOLJHU=XYHU OlVVLJNHLW(UWXWJXWGDUDQ*HUWYRQ:LHVHQHFNGHQHUEHWHQHQ 'LHQVW]XHUZHLVHQ *HVWHUQZDUGHU*HQHUDOJDQ]XQHUZDUWHWLQ'HWMHQV'LHQVW ]LPPHUHUVFKLHQHQXQGKDWWHDEJHZLQNWDOV$FKLPVLFKYRU VFKULIWVPlLJDOV9HUWUHWHUGHVDEZHVHQGHQ$EWHLOXQJVOHLWHUV 2EHUVW%ULQNPDQQPHOGHWH(UZROOWHJOHLFKZLVVHQZDVGHU 0DMRUYRUVLFKDXIGHP6FKUHLEWLVFKKDEH1DWUOLFKILHOHU QLFKWPLWGHU7ULQV+DXVHLJHQWOLFKJLQJLKQGLHVH$UEHLWGHU /XIWZDIIHJDUQLFKWVDQDEHUGLH)RUPXOLHUXQJª,FKVHKH6LH PVVHQIU%ULQNPDQQDXIDUEHLWHQ©YHUULHWVHLQH1HXJLHU 'XUFKHLQ6HQNHQGHU6WLPPH9HUWUDXOLFKNHLWHU]HXJHQG KDWWH'HWMHQPLWJHWHLOWHUVLW]HDQHLQHU3URMHNWYRUODJHIUGHQ 9HUWHLGLJXQJVDXVVFKXGHV%XQGHVWDJHV'HU*HQHUDOJDE VLFKGHQ$QVFKHLQY|OOLJHU,QIRUPLHUWKHLWXQGPHLQWHGLHVH XQWHUVWUHLFKHQ]XPVVHQPLW$OOJHPHLQSOlW]HQZLHª'LH +HUUHQYRQGHU6R]LDOGHPRNUDWLHKDEHQHVHLOLJGDPLW© 3Ul]LVHUZDUGDQQGDVª:HOFKH'LUHNWLYHKDW%ULQNPDQQ
,KQHQKLQWHUODVVHQ"2GHUP|FKWHQ6LHGDUEHUQLFKWVSUH FKHQ"© ª3KDQWRPDFKWXQGDFKW]LJQXUhEHUJDQJVO|VXQJ'LHGHXW VFKH05&$LVW1XPPHUHLQV©KDWWHGHU0DMRUJHDQWZRUWHW ZLHDXVGHU3LVWROHJHVFKRVVHQ2ELKPYRQ:LHVHQHFNGLH (UZLGHUXQJDQKHLPVWHOOWHRGHUQLFKWHUHUZDUWHWHVLHXQG VFKRQHLQEORHV=|JHUQKlWWHGHU$FKVHLKUHV9HUKlOWQLVVHV HLQHQ.QLFNJHEHQN|QQHQ'HUJOHLFKHQXQHQWZHJWLP$XJH ]X KDEHQXQGHV]XEHGHQNHQLVWGHP.XQGVFKDIWHU:HUQHU %UHGHEXVFKLQGHU0DVNHGHVHKHPDOLJHQIDVFKLVWLVFKHQ-DJG IOLHJHUV$FKLP'HWMHQLQ)OHLVFKXQG%OXWEHUJHJDQJHQ+LHU GDUILKPNHLQ)HKOHUXQWHUODXIHQHLQHLQ]LJHV9HUVDJHQ N|QQWHGDV(QGHVHLQHU$UEHLWQDFKVLFK]LHKHQ1LFKWGD HUVLFKYRUHLQHU(QWGHFNXQJVHLQHUZDKUHQ,GHQWLWlWIUFKWHWH GLH*HIDKUEHVWHKWLPPHUEHLGHU$UW$UEHLWGLHHUOHLVWHW DEHUZUGHQLFKWVHLQ$XVIDOOGHQ9HUOXVWHLQHUZLFKWLJHQ ,QIRUPDWLRQVTXHOOHIUGLH*HQRVVHQLQ%HUOLQEHGHXWHQHLQHU ,QIRUPDWLRQVTXHOOHGLHLQODQJHQ-DKUHQPLWJU|WHU6RUJIDOW XQGXQVlJOLFKHU0KHDXIJHEDXWZRUGHQLVW" ª'LHHLHUOHJHQGH:ROO0LOFKXQG)OHLVFKVDX©KDWWHGHU *HQHUDOGLH(UZlKQXQJGHV0HKU]ZHFNIOXJ]HXJV05&$ XQHUQVWPLWGHP7HUPLQXVHLQHVEHNDQQWHQ1DFKULFKWHQ PDJD]LQVNRPPHQWLHUWª,FKYHUVWHKHMDQLFKWVGDYRQDEHU PXGHQQGLHVH(QWZLFNOXQJVRODQJHGDXHUQ"© 'HWMHQQDKPGHQOHLFKWHQ7RQDXIXQGZDUIKLQHLQH 0DVFKLQHGLHSUDNWLVFKDOOHVN|QQHQVROOHHUIlQGHQGLH .RQVWUXNWHXUHKDOWQLFKW]ZLVFKHQ)UKVWFNXQG$EHQGEURW OHLGHU 9RQ:LHVHQHFNGHXWHWHDXIGLH3URMHNWYRUODJHXQGVDJWH XQYHUPLWWHOWHUZUGHVLFKGDV$UEHLWVSDSLHUJHUQHLQPDO DQVHKHQHKHHVGDV5HIHUDWYHUODVVH ª$XIGHP'LHQVWZHJ"©IUDJWH$FKLP]XUFN 'LH$QWZRUWNDQQWHHULPYRUDXVª%HLP$PWIU6LFKHUKHLW SIOHJWPDQLQVROFKHQ)lOOHQLPPHU]XVDJHQ/LHEHUSUL YDW!© (LQH6HNXQGHODQJEHJHJQHWHQVLFKLKUH%OLFNH6LHOlFKHOWHQ EHLGH$XIGLHVHP*HELHWYHUVWDQGHQVLHVLFK
'DVODVVHVLFKPDFKHQKDWWH'HWMHQEHVWlWLJWXQGHUNOlUW 2EHUVW%ULQNPDQQNRPPHLQHLQHU:RFKHDXVGHP8UODXE ]XUFNXQGZQVFKHGLH9RUODJHGDQQDXIVHLQHP6FKUHLEWLVFK ]XILQGHQ*HQJHQG=HLWDOVR 0LWHLQHP6FKODJZLUGGHU:DOGZHJEHIDKUEDU'LH VFKZHUHQ%XOOGR]]HUGHU)RUVWYHUZDOWXQJKDEHQLKQKLHU YHUODVVHQXQGVLQGQDFKOLQNVLQ5LFKWXQJ.DKOVFKODJDE JHERJHQ$FKLPDWPHWHUOHLFKHUWDXIXQGVFKDOWHWKRFK-HW]W EOHLEWLKPDXFK=HLWIUHLQHQ%OLFNDXIGLH6FK|QKHLWGHV :DOGHVGHULKQKRFKVWlPPLJXPJLEW6FKZHUH=ZHLJHUHL FKHQELVDXIGHQ%RGHQKHUDEXQGHU]HXJHQWLHIHQ6FKDWWHQ 0lUFKHQJHVWDOWHQN|QQWHQGD]X+DXVHVHLQGHUE|VH:ROI KLQWHUHLQHP%DXPKHUYRUOXJHQ(LQ(LFKK|UQFKHQLVW]X VHKHQGDVEHUGHQ:HJKXVFKW'HWMHQOlFKHOW(UGUHKWGDV )HQVWHUJDQ]KHUXQWHU:DOGOXIWWDQNHQ (LQH%LHJXQJXQGHLQ6WFNKLQWXWVLFKHLQH/LFKWXQJDXI GLHHLQ-DJGKDXVWUlJW ª.HQQHQ6LH%ULQNPDQQV%ORFNKDXV"©KDWWHYRQ :LHVHQHFNJHVWHUQJHIUDJW$OVGHU0DMRUYHUQHLQWHEHWHXHUWH HUª6LHVROOWHQHVDEHUNHQQHQ:XQGHUVFK|QJHOHJHQ*H UDGH]XGDV3DUDGLHVIUHLQHQVROHLGHQVFKDIWOLFKHQ-lJHUZLH HUHLQHULVW0RUJHQLVW6RQQWDJKDEHQ6LHHWZDVYRU"© ª)DXOHQ]HQVFKZLPPHQJHKHQQLFKWV*HQDXHV© ª:ROOHQ6LHPLUGHQ*HIDOOHQWXQ"© (VZDUGDQQGLH5HGHGDYRQJHZHVHQ%ULQNPDQQKDEHYRQ :LHVHQHFNDQJHUXIHQXQGLKQJHEHWHQLKPHLQLJHVHLQHU]HLW JHKHLPJHZHVHQHXQGZlKUHQGGHV]ZHLWHQ:HOWNULHJHVXQWHU 9HUVFKOXJHKDOWHQH0DWHULDOLHQGHV2EHUNRPPDQGRVGHU /XIWZDIIH]XEHUODVVHQGLHYRQ:LHVHQHFNDOVMXQJHU2I IL]LHUGHU$EZHKUDEWHLOXQJª)UHPGH+HHUH2VW©LQGLH+lQGH EHNRPPHQXQGEHL.ULHJVHQGHQLFKWDEJHJHEHQKDWWH2EHUVW %ULQNPDQQKlWWHGLHGDULQHQWKDOWHQHQ$QJDEHQUHFKWJHUQLQ VHLQHQ0HPRLUHQYHUZDQGW(UGHU*HQHUDOZlUHJHUQVHOEVW KLQDXVJHIDKUHQZLHYLHOHJHPHLQVDPH(UOHEQLVVHN|QQHPDQ DXIIULVFKHQGRFKQXQVHLGDVXQP|JOLFKXQGHUZUGHHV EHJUHQZHQQ'HWMHQ8QGHLQ$XVIOXJLQV*UQHZlUH LPPHU]XHPSIHKOHQ
9LHOOHLFKWKDWWHGHU.XQGVFKDIWHU:HUQHU%UHGHEXVFK JHGDFKWN|QQHHVQW]OLFKVHLQPHKUYRQGHU3ULYDWVSKlUHGHV HLJHQWOLFKVHKU]XUFNKDOWHQGHQ$EWHLOXQJVOHLWHUV]XHUIDKUHQ 'HUZDUHUVWYRUNXU]HPDXVGHP1$72+DXSWTXDUWLHULQ %UVVHOQDFK%RQQ]XUFNYHUVHW]WZRUGHQXQG]XQHXLP$PW DOVGDGDVJHJHQVHLWLJH9HUKlOWQLVPHKUDOVI|UPOLFKKlWWH VHLQN|QQHQ-HW]WJHKWHVLP5HIHUDWVHKUNRUUHNW]XXQG PDQFKHUGHQNWZHKPWLJDQGLH=HLWHQ]XUFNLQGHQHQGHU DOWH*QWHU.U|VLQJELV]XVHLQHU3HQVLRQLHUXQJ&KHIZDU .U|VLQJNHKUWHXQHQWZHJWGDVHKHPDOLJHª)URQWVFKZHLQ© KHUDXVª1HXH0DVFKLQHQQHXH0RQWXUDEHUGHU*HLVWGHU 7UXSSHVR©XQGHQWVSUHFKHQGIRUVFKXQGXQEHNPPHUW ZDUDXFKVHLQ/HLWXQJVVWLO0DQFKHPHLQ'RUQLP$XJH 'HU0RRVWHSSLFKUHLFKWELVDQGDV%ORFNKDXVKHUDQ'DV VWHKWGDZLHHLQH,OOXVWUDWLRQDXVGHPª/HGHUVWUXPSI©NORELJH %DONHQIHVWLQHLQDQGHUJHIJWQLHGULJDEHUZHLWUlXPLJHLQ DXVODGHQGHV6WURKGDFKGDVYRUGHP(LQJDQJHLQH6LW]IOlFKH EHUVSDQQW6RVHOWVDPNQRUULJZLHGDV+DXVVHOEVWVLQGDXFK GLH%lQNHXQGLVWGHU7LVFKGDYRU 'HWMHQIlKUWGLFKWKHUDQVWHLJWDXVQLPPWGDV3DNHWXQWHU GHQ$UPXQGJHKWDXIGHQ(LQJDQJ]X8QZLOONUOLFKVLHKWHU DXIVHLQH$UPEDQGXKU(VLVWLQ]ZLVFKHQKDOE]Z|OIJHZRU GHQDEHUDOOH)HQVWHUOlGHQVLQGJHVFKORVVHQ'DV+DXVPDFKW GHQ(LQGUXFNDOVEHILQGHHVVLFKLQWLHIHP6FKODI'LH6WLOOH GHU8PJHEXQJZLUGQXUYRQ9RJHOVWLPPHQGXUFKEURFKHQ *DQ]OHLVH]ZLWVFKHUQ0HLVHQ $FKLPWULWWQlKHU'HU0RRVWHSSLFKVFKOXFNWGDV*HUlXVFK GHU6FKULWWH'HUHLVHUQH.ORSIHUOlUPW,PVHOEHQ$XJHQEOLFN VFKOlJWLP%ORFNKDXVHLQ+XQGDQDEHUGDVDQIlQJOLFKH *HNOlIIYHUZDQGHOWVLFKXPJHKHQGLQHLQODQJJH]RJHQHV NODJHQGHV+HXOHQ'DV7LHUKlOWVLFKQLFKWXQPLWWHOEDUKLQWHU GHU7UDXI 6RQVWUHJWVLFKQLFKWV ª*XWHQ0RUJHQ+HUU2EHUVW©UXIW'HWMHQXQGQHQQWVHLQHQ 1DPHQ(UHUZDUWHWHLQH$QWZRUW(VJLEWNHLQH1XUGHU+XQG NOlIIWZLHGHUDOVHUGLHIUHPGH6WLPPHK|UW
'HU0DQQPLWGHP3DNHWXQWHUP$UP]|JHUW0|JOLFKZlUH MDQRFKGD%ULQNPDQQVFKRQYRU7DJVHLQ*HZHKUJH VFKXOWHUWKDWXQGKLQDXVLQV5HYLHUJHJDQJHQLVW$EHUKlWWH HUGDQQGHQ+XQG]X+DXVHJHODVVHQ" 8QHQWVFKORVVHQVWUHFNW$FKLPGLH+DQGQDFKGHU.OLQNH DXVXQGGUFNWVLHQLHGHU'LH7UJLEWQDFK'DV7DJHVOLFKW HUKHOOWHLQHQUHFKWHFNLJHQ9RUUDXP'HU%ORFNKDXVFKDUDNWHU LVWDXFKKLHUJHZDKUWZRUGHQQDWXUIDUEHQHV+RO]EHZXW JUREJHIXJW(LQH.OHLGHUDEODJHEHILQGHWVLFKKLHU2EHQDXI OLHJWHLQYHUEHXOWHU-lJHUKXWPLW*DPVEDUW(LQ/RGHQPDQWHO XQGHLQH5HJHQSHOHULQHKlQJHQGDXQGDXIGHP5RVWVWHKHQ 3LUVFKVWLHIHO'HWMHQQLPPWGDVDOOHVZDKUXQGHUHUEOLFNW DXFKHLQ)HUQJODVDP+DNHQ1HLQHVVLHKWQLFKWVRDXVDOV KDEHGHU+DXVKHUUGLH%ORFNKWWHYHUODVVHQ :WHQGHUNOlIIWMHW]WGHU+XQG'HWMHQODXVFKW5HFKWVYRQ LKPEHILQGHWVLFKHLQH7UJHUDGHDXVLVWHLQHXQGOLQNVVLQG ]ZHL+LQWHUHLQHUGHUEHLGHQVWHFNWGDV7LHU ª+HUU2EHUVW©UXIW$FKLPQRFKHLQPDOª0DMRU'HWMHQ +HXWHDOV3ULYDWNXULHUYRQ+HUUQYRQ:LHVHQHFN*HVWDWWHQ 6LHHLQ]XWUHWHQ"© -HW]WEHNRPPWHUHLQJDQ]XQJXWHV*HIKO8QGDOVZLHGHU NHLQH$QWZRUWJHJHEHQZLUGUHLWHUGLHPLWWOHUH7UDXI 'DEHLVWHKWHUQHEHQGHP5DKPHQXQEHZXWLQVWLQNWLY DOVGURKHLKPDXVGHP5DXP*HIDKU 'DVPXGDVJU|WH=LPPHULP%ORFNKDXVVHLQXQGHVHWZD ]XU+lOIWHHLQQHKPHQ'LH'XQNHOKHLWJlKQW'HWMHQDQXQG HVLVWVWLOOGDULQhEHUKDXSWVFKHLQWDXIHLQPDODOOHVLP+DXV GHQ$WHPDQ]XKDOWHQELVDXIGHQ+XQG9RQGHU7UOLQNV NRPPWHLQNUDW]HQGHV*HUlXVFK .DXPPHUNOLFKLVWLQGHU'XQNHOKHLWGHU8PULGHU)HQVWHU ]XHUNHQQHQGQQHUHFKWHFNLJH/LFKWOHLVWHQ$FKLPOHJWGDV 3DNHWDEQLPPWVHLQ)HXHU]HXJKHUDXVXQGOlWHVDXI IODPPHQ'LHVFKZDFKH)ODPPHUHLFKWQLFKWDXVGDV=LPPHU DXV]XOHXFKWHQDEHUVLHJLEWJHQXJ+HOOLJNHLWXPGHQ:HJ]XP )HQVWHURKQHDQ]XVWRHQ]XILQGHQ .OHLQH6FKHLEHQPHKUIDFK]XVDPPHQJHVHW]WEOHLJHIDW
DXFKGDVHLQH(ULQQHUXQJDQª/HGHUVWUXPSI©'HWMHQ|IIQHW GLH)OJHOKDNWGLH)HQVWHUOlGHQDXVXQGVW|WVLHDXI)U HLQHQ0RPHQWEOHQGHWGHU7DJ $OVHUVLFKXPZHQGHWVWRFNWLKPGHU$WHP1HLQ2EHUVW %ULQNPDQQKDWVHLQ%ORFNKDXVKHXWHQLFKWYHUODVVHQ(UOLHJW VHOWVDP]XVDPPHQJHNUPPWYRUVHLQHP6FKUHLEWLVFKXQG QHEHQLKPLVWDXIGHP7HSSLFKHLQGXQNOHU)OHFN%OLFNORVH ZHLWJH|IIQHWH$XJHQVWDUUHQDQ$FKLPYRUEHU(LQHQKDOEHQ 6FKULWWYRQGHP7RWHQHQWIHUQWOLHJWHLQ-DJGJHZHKU 'HWMHQVWHKWZLHHUVWDUUWGLFKWDQGHU)HQVWHUZDQGEH WURIIHQXQGUDWORV'UDXHQ]ZLWVFKHUQLPPHUQRFKGLH 0HLVHQ1HEHQDQWREWGHU+XQG8QGGDOLHJW%ULQNPDQQLP -lJHUKHPGPLWHLQHU/HGHUZHVWHXQGJUQHQ%UHHFKHVEHU GHUHQ:DGHQWHLOHJUDXH:ROOVWUPSIHJH]RJHQVLQG :LHYHUlQGHUW%ULQNPDQQZLUNW$FKLPKDWLKQQLHDQGHUV JHVHKHQDOVVWUDIIDXIJHULFKWHWSHGDQWLVFKDXI+DOWXQJEH GDFKWLQSHQLEHONRUUHNWHU8QLIRUP.U|VLQJQDQQWHLKQ DEZHFKVHOQGHLQHQ/DFNDIIHQXQGHLQHQ8QLIRUPVWlQGHUGHP QLFKWVZLFKWLJHUZlUHDOVGLH8QLIRUPXQGGLH6FKXOWHUVWFNH $QLKQHQEHLGHQKDWWH.U|VLQJZHLWHUJHVDJWN|QQWH'HWMHQ GHQ8QWHUVFKLHG]ZLVFKHQHLQHP)URQWRIIL]LHUXQGHLQHP 6FKUHLEWLVFKVWUDWHJHQVWXGLHUHQ:lKUHQGHU.U|VLQJDOV *HVFKZDGHUNRPPRGRUHPLWVHLQHQ0lQQHUQDXI)HOGIOXJ SOlW]HQWLHILP/DQGGHV*HJQHUVLP'UHFNODJWUXJ%ULQN PDQQLP5HLFKVOXIWIDKUWPLQLVWHULXPLQGHU%HUOLQHU:LOKHOP VWUDH$NWHQWDVFKHQYRQ=LPPHU]X=LPPHU:HQLJVWHQV ZlUHLKPHUVSDUWJHEOLHEHQ%ULQNPDQQDOVVHLQHQ1DFKIROJHU HLQ]XDUEHLWHQ2EHUVWYRQ%RFNGHULKQDOV5HIHUDWVOHLWHU DEO|VWHVHL]ZDUDXFKHLQ%URKHQJVWJHZHVHQDEHUZHQLJ VWHQVQLFKWVRXQV\PSDWKLVFKZLH%ULQNPDQQ9LHOOHLFKWODJ HVGDUDQGDPDQVRZHQLJYRQ%ULQNPDQQZXWH1LFKW HLQPDOGDVGDHUHLQSDVVLRQLHUWHU:HLGPDQQZDUKDWWHVLFK KHUXPJHVSURFKHQ $FKLPUlXVSHUWVLFK6HNXQGHQODQJIKOWHUVLFKYHUVXFKW GDVJDQ]H%ORFNKDXVJUQGOLFKLQ$XJHQVFKHLQ]XQHKPHQ(U XQWHUOlWHV1LFKWVEHUKUHQQLFKWVYHUlQGHUQ'LH8QWHU
VXFKXQJLQ*DQJVHW]HQ'DVQlFKVWH7HOHIRQEHILQGHWVLFK LQ9DUQGRUI'RUWKLQPXHUMHW]WIDKUHQ 6FKRQDQGHU7UEOHLEWHUQRFKHLQPDOVWHKHQ'DOLHJW %ULQNPDQQGDLVWGDV*HZHKU(LQ8QIDOO"(LQ6FKXGHU ORVJLQJDOVGHU2EHUVWGLH:DIIHUHLQLJHQZROOWH"'HWMHQ VFKWWHOWGHQ.RSI(LQ0DQQGHUVHLQ/HEHQODQJ8PJDQJ PLW:DIIHQKDWWHXQGHQNEDU(LQVRSHGDQWLVFKHU0DQQ GD]XQHLQGHUUHLQLJWHNHLQ*HZHKURKQHHV]XYRUYRU VFKULIWVPlLJHQWODGHQ]XKDEHQ 0RUG" 'DVIHVW]XVWHOOHQLVW6DFKHGHU3ROL]HL $EHUDOVHULQ9DUQGRUILQGHU7HOHIRQ]HOOHVWHKWZlKOWHU GLH1XPPHUGHV*HQHUDOVYRQ:LHVHQHFNXQGXQWHUULFKWHW GLHVHQEHUGHQ6DFKYHUKDOW,PPHUKLQ'HU0DMRULVWLP $XIWUDJYRQ:LHVHQHFNV]X%ULQNPDQQJHIDKUHQHVJDELU JHQGZHOFKH9HUELQGXQJHQ]ZLVFKHQGHQEHLGHQ(UPHUNW VRIRUWGDHUULFKWLJJHKDQGHOWKDW'DV9RUNRPPQLVQLFKWDOV HUVWHU]XHUIDKUHQKlWWHGHU*HQHUDOEHOJHQRPPHQ6FKOLH OLFKLVWHUHLQ6LFKHUKHLWVRIIL]LHUEHIDWPLW9RUJlQJHQLQ QHUKDOEGHU%XQGHVZHKUXQGGHU7RWHZDU$EWHLOXQJVOHLWHU DXIGHU+DUGWK|KH (UZHUGHDOOHV:HLWHUHYHUDQODVVHQVFKOLHWYRQ:LHVHQHHN GDV*HVSUlFK
:LHGHUIODPPW%OLW]OLFKWDXI)U6HNXQGHQEUXFKWHLOHWDXFKW HVGHQ%OXWIOHFNLP7HSSLFKXQGGDV*HZHKUDP%RGHQLQ JOHLHQGH+HOOLJNHLW'HU7RWHOLHJWQLFKWPHKUGD/HGLJOLFK HLQHPLW.UHLGHJH]HLFKQHWH8PULOLQLHPDFKWGHXWOLFKZLH HUJHIXQGHQZRUGHQLVW9RP6FKUHLEWLVFKZHUGHQ)LQJHU VSXUHQDEJHQRPPHQ(LQHLQ]HOQHU.RJQDNVFKZHQNHUVRZLH HLQHGD]XJHK|ULJH)ODVFKHYHUVFKZLQGHQQXUPLW*XP PLKDQGVFKXKHQDQJHIDWLQ)ROLHQWWHQ(LQ0DQQNQLHWDP
%RGHQXQGNUDW]WPLWHLQHP6FKDEHUGDVJHURQQHQH%OXWLQ HLQ5HDJHQ]JODV(LQEDWWHULHJHWULHEHQHU6SH]LDOVWDXEVDXJHU VXUUWXPGLH0|EHOKHUXPHVN|QQWHGRFKVHLQGDHLQ )UHPGHUDQVHLQHQ6FKXKVRKOHQ(UGNUPHOKHUHLQEUDFKWHGLH QLFKWDXVGLHVHU*HJHQGVWDPPHQHLQH:ROOIDVHURGHUHLQ +DDUKLQWHUOLH'DVLVWGHUPKVHOLJHXQGZHQLJVSHNWDNXOlUH $OOWDJGHU.ULPLQDOWHFKQLN8QGRIWNRPPWJDUQLFKWVGDEHL KHUDXV $OVEORHU%HREDFKWHUOHKQW$FKLP'HWMHQDP7UUDKPHQ XQGVLHKW]X-HW]WKDWHU0XHGDV=LPPHUPLW5XKH]X EHWUDFKWHQ6RZLHGDV+DXVYRQDXHQDXVVLHKWLVWHVDXFK LQQHQHLQJHULFKWHW'HUDXV)HOGVWHLQHQJHPDXHUWH.DPLQGLH VFKZHUHQ%DXHUQP|EHOGLHLKUHJDQ]H6FK|QKHLWDXVGHU XQYHUKOOWHQ6WUXNWXUGHV+RO]HVEH]LHKHQDEHUVRQVWVFKOLFKW ZLUNHQ'HU6FKUHLEWLVFKLVWHLQDOWHUWPOLFKHV6WFNPLW EUHLWHP8QWHUEDXXQGVFKPDOHP2EHUWHLODXIGHUKHUXQWHU JHNODSSWHQ6FKUHLESODWWHVWHKWHLQH5HLVHVFKUHLEPDVFKLQH (LQH9LHO]DKOYRQ)lFKHUQRIIHQHXQGYHUVFKOLHEDUHLVW YRUKDQGHQXQGDOOHZHUGHQJH|IIQHWJHOHHUWXQGXQWHUVXFKW 1DFK)lFKHUQJHRUGQHWHUIlKUWGHU,QKDOWHLQHJUQGOLFKH 3UIXQJ'LH0lQQHUGLHGDVWXQPHVVHQGLH7LHIHGHU6FKEH XQGYHUJOHLFKHQVLHPLWGHQ0DHQGHV6FKUDQNHV6LHUFNHQ GDV0|EHOVWFNVRJDUYRQGHU:DQGZHJEHWUDFKWHQGLH 5FNVHLWHXQGQHKPHQGLH9HUELQGXQJVVWHOOHQXQWHUGLH /XSH(UQVWWXQVLHGDVZRUWORVPLWJHVDPPHOWHQPHUN ZUGLJDXVGUXFNVORVHQ*HVLFKWHUQ-HGHUZHLZDVHU]X PDFKHQKDWNHLQHUVWHKWGHPDQGHUHQLP:HJHGDVDOOHVOlXIW DEZLHDP6FKQUFKHQ 0HUNZUGLJHUZHLVHHULQQHUWGLH8QWHUVXFKXQJVJUXSSH 'HWMHQDQHLQHQ5DEHQVFKZDUP'LH0lQQHUWUDJHQDOOH=LYLO XQGPXWHQGHQQRFKZLHXQLIRUPLHUWDQ'DVPDFKHQGLH EODXHQ1\ORQPlQWHOGLHVLHQLFKWDEJHOHJWKDEHQXQGGLHVLH HLQDQGHUlKQOLFKZHUGHQODVVHQ ,QHLQHPDOWHQ6WDKOVFKUDQNLVWHLQVHKUPRGHUQHUYHU ERUJHQ*H|IIQHW]HLJWHUGLH*HZHKUHGHV-lJHUV%ULQNPDQQ =ZHLVWHKHQQRFKGULQ'DVHLQHLVWHLQ'ULOOLQJGDVDQGHUH
PLWGHQEHLGHQVWDUNHQ/lXIHQHLQH6FKURWIOLQWH'DV*HZHKU DXIGHP7HSSLFKKDW]ZHLXQWHUVFKLHGOLFKH/lXIHEHUHLQDQ GHUHLQHQVFKODQNHQIU.XJHOQXQGHLQHQEDXFKLJHUHQIU 6FKURWSDWURQHQ$FKLPGHQNWVRHWZDVQHQQHPDQZRKOHLQH %RFNEFKVIOLQWH(ULVW]XZHQLJPLWMDJGOLFKHP%UDXFKWXP XQG*HUlWYHUWUDXWXPHVJHQDX]XZLVVHQ 'LH.DPLQZDQG'LHVHGLHHLQ]LJHDXV6LFKHUKHLWV JUQGHQJHPDXHUWH:DQGLVWHLQHU6DPPOXQJDOWHU:DIIHQ YRUEHKDOWHQ6WHLQVFKORJHZHKUHKlQJHQGDHLQNXU]HU 6DXVWXW]HLQH3UVFKEFKVHHLQHODQJH)OXQGHXQGGD]X 3XOYHUK|UQHUXQGIODVFKHQ+LUVFKIlQJHUXQG6DXIHGHUQ 'D]ZLVFKHQWUDJHQ%RUGH=LQQJHVFKLUUHLQSDDU/HXFKWHUXQG HLQH%LHGHUPHLHUXKU =X'HWMHQWULWWGHU/HLWHUGHU8QWHUVXFKXQJVJUXSSHGHV 0LOLWlULVFKHQ$EVFKLUPGLHQVWHVGHQDOOHLQ*HQHUDOYRQ :LHVHQHFNDOVNRPSHWHQWIUGLHVHQ)DOOEHWUDFKWHWKDW'HU 0DQQLVWYHUJOHLFKVZHLVHMXQJHLQHVFKODQNH(UVFKHLQXQJPLW HLQHPVFKPDOHQ*HVLFKWYRQNDOWHU,QWHOOLJHQ]ª6FKHXOLFKH *HVFKLFKWH©ZLUIWHUKLQª(LQ*OFNGD6LH%ULQNPDQQ JHIXQGHQKDEHQ+HUU0DMRU(LQ0DQQLQVHLQHU3RVLWLRQGD JLEWHVLPPHUJOHLFKGLHZLOGHVWHQ*HUFKWH©(UGHXWHWDXI GLH.UHLGH]HLFKQXQJDP%RGHQª6LHKDEHQPLWLKP]XVDP PHQJHDUEHLWHW/LWWHUDQ'HSUHVVLRQHQ":LUNWHHUZLHHLQ 6HOEVWPRUGNDQGLGDW"© $FKLPV*HVLFKWEOHLEWJlQ]OLFKXQEHZHJWª8QVHU9HUKlOW QLVZDUHLQUHLQGLHQVWOLFKHV©VDJWHUREHQKLQª,FKZXWHQLFKW HLQPDOGDHU-lJHUZDU+DOWHQ6LHGDVIUHLQHQ6HOEVWPRUG" 2GHUIUHLQHQ8QIDOO"© (UHUKlOWNHLQH$QWZRUWZHLOMXVWLQGLHVHP0RPHQWMHPDQG KHUHLQNRPPWXQGPHOGHW*HQHUDOYRQ:LHVHQHFNIDKUH VRHEHQYRU'HU*HQHUDOIROJWLKPDXIGHP)XH 'HU0$'2IIL]LHU]HLJWGLH$QGHXWXQJHLQHV+DFNHQNODS SHQVª+HUU*HQHUDO+DXSWPDQQ(EHUVEDFKPLWGHU8QWHU VXFKXQJVJUXSSH%RQQHLQVEHL7DWRUWVLFKHUXQJ© 9RQ:LHVHQHFNZLQNWDEXQGUHLFKW'HWMHQGLH+DQG ª/DVVHQ6LHVLFKQLFKWVW|UHQ0DFKHQ6LHZHLWHU©
'HU*UXSSHQOHLWHUNHKUW]XVHLQHQ/HXWHQ]XUFN(UJHVHOOW VLFK]X]ZHLHQGLHQDKHGHP)HQVWHUOHLVHPLWHLQDQGHUVSUH FKHQ(LQHUGHUEHLGHQKDWMHW]WGLH%RFNEFKVIOLQWHLQGHU +DQG $QGHU)HQVWHUZDQGKlQJWHLQ*HPlOGH'LH'DUVWHOOXQJ HLQHU0DUNWV]HQHLVWGDVVLH]HLJWHLQHQ9HUNDXIVVWDQGGHU :LOGEUHWIHLOELHWHW ª'DVLVWMDXQIDEDU©OlWVLFKGHU*HQHUDOVRIRUWYHU QHKPHQª%ULQNPDQQ%HLXQVHUHP7HOHIRQDWZHJHQGLHVHV 3DNHWVZDUHUQRFKJDQ]GHUDOWH,FKYHUVWHKHGDVQLFKW© ª,FKDXFKQLFKW+HUU*HQHUDO© 6LHVWHKHQEHLGHXQGVHKHQ]XU8PUL]HLFKQXQJ1HEHQDQ LQGHU.DPPHUQHEHQGHU.FKHZLQVHOWNOlJOLFKGHU+XQG (VLVWHLQEUDXQHU6HWWHU$FKLPKDWLKQYRUKLQJHVHKHQDOV HLQHUGHU0$'/HXWHHLQ+XQGHNHQQHURIIHQEDUGLH7U |IIQHWH'HU0DQQQDKPGHQ6HWWHUDP+DOVEDQGXQGJLQJPLW LKPYRUV+DXV1DFKKHUJDEHULKP]XIUHVVHQ6HLWGHPLVW GDV7LHUHWZDVUXKLJHU 9RQ:LHVHQHFN]LHKWIDKULJVHLQH7DEDNVSIHLIHDXVGHU 7DVFKHXQGVFKLHEWVLH]XUFNRKQHJHUDXFKW]XKDEHQ(UUXIW GHQ+DXSWPDQQGHQHUJHUDGHZHJJHVFKLFNWKDWZLHGHU]X VLFKXQGIUDJWLKQQDFKVHLQHQ(UNHQQWQLVVHQ ª(LQH(LQZLUNXQJGXUFK'ULWWHVFKHLGHWDXV©HUNOlUW(EHUV EDFKª([WUHPVWDUNH6FKPDXFKVSXUHQODVVHQHUNHQQHQGD GHU6FKXDXVDOOHUQlFKVWHU1lKHDEJHJHEHQZXUGH8Q PLWWHOEDUQHEHQGHP7RWHQODJGLHVH%RFNEFKVIOLQWHGHUHQ .XJHOODXIGHUXQWHUHDEJHVFKRVVHQZXUGH,FKELQVLFKHUGD GLH2EGXNWLRQGDV]XJHK|ULJH3URMHNWLO]XWDJHI|UGHUQZLUG $XIGHU:DIIHIDQGHQZLUDXVVFKOLHOLFKGLH)LQJHUDEGUFNH %ULQNPDQQV© ª:HUVROOWHGHP2EHUVWDXFKQDFKGHP/HEHQWUDFKWHQ"© NRPPHQWLHUWGHU*HQHUDOª:LHLFKVFKRQJHVDJWKDEH(VLVW XQIDEDU© 'LH8QWHUVXFKXQJGHU:DIIHLVWDEJHVFKORVVHQ'HU+DXSW PDQQKDWQLFKWVGDJHJHQGD'HWMHQVLHQLPPW:lKUHQGHU VLHDXIGHQ+lQGHQZLHJWIUDJWHUEHLOlXILJZLHGLH6FKXEDKQ JHZHVHQVHL
ª'DV3URMHNWLOWUDWYRQXQWHQQDFKREHQLQGHQ.|USHUHLQ© HUOlXWHUW(EHUVEDFKEHUHLWZLOOLJª'LH(LQVFKXVWHOOHEHILQGHW VLFKXQWHUKDOEGHV.LQQV© $FKLPNODSSWGDV*HZHKUDEXQGEHU]HXJWVLFKGDGLH :DIIHWDWVlFKOLFKQLFKWPHKUJHODGHQLVW'DQQOlWHUGLH /lXIHZLHGHUHLQUDVWHQXQGVHW]WVLFKGLH0QGXQJHQXQWHUV .LQQ(VLVWLKPVRJXWZLHXQP|JOLFKLQGLHVHU6WHOOXQJPLW GHU+DQGGHQ$E]XJ]XHUUHLFKHQ ª*DUQLFKWVRHLQIDFKVLFKDXIGLHVH:HLVHLQGLHHZLJHQ -DJGJUQGH]XEHI|UGHUQ©JLEWHU]XEHGHQNHQXQGlUJHUWVLFK GDHUVLFKGHUQDIRUVFKHQ)RUPXOLHUXQJDXV:LOGZHVWILOPHQ EHGLHQWª%ULQNPDQQKDWWHHWZDPHLQH)LJXUXQGPLUIlOOWHV VFKZHUGHQ$E]XJ]XEHWlWLJHQ© $XIHLQPDOVHKHQDOOH]X'HWMHQKLQPLW]XUFNKDOWHQGHU 1HXJLHUHLQZHQLJEHUUDVFKW 9RQ:LHVHQHFNXQGGHU*UXSSHQOHLWHUYRQª%RQQHLQV© WDXVFKHQHLQHQNXU]HQ%OLFN'DQQVDJWGHU+DXSWPDQQNKO HUN|QQHVLFKQLFKWHULQQHUQHLQHQ6HOEVWPRUGEHKDXSWHW]X KDEHQ ª'LH6FKXEDKQVFKOLHWGLH0|JOLFKNHLWHLQHV8QIDOOVHLQ© IlKUWHUIRUWª6LHN|QQHQVLFKPKHORVEHU]HXJHQGDGLH $E]JHGHV*HZHKUVDXHURUGHQWOLFKOHLFKWJHKHQ,FKZHUGH GXUFKHLQHEDOOLVWLVFKH8QWHUVXFKXQJIHVWVWHOOHQODVVHQREHLQ KDUWHV$XIVHW]HQGHV.ROEHQVEHLHQWVLFKHUWHP*HZHKUJH QJWGHQ6FKXDXV]XO|VHQ© ª7XQ6LHGDV©'HU*HQHUDOEHNUlIWLJWª%ULQNPDQQXQG 6HOEVWPRUGQHLQGDVSDWQLFKW]XVDPPHQ© 'HWMHQZLOOZLVVHQZDQQHWZDHVJHVFKHKHQVHL (VPVVHXP0LWWHUQDFKW$XIHLQHSUl]LVHUH=HLWDQJDEH KDEHVLFKGHU$U]WQLFKWIHVWOHJHQZROOHQHUNOlUWGHU+DXSW PDQQ 1XQIlQJWYRQ:LHVHQHFNGRFKDQGLH3IHLIH]XVWRSIHQ (UZQVFKHODXIHQGEHUGHQ)RUWJDQJGHU8QWHUVXFKXQJ XQWHUULFKWHW]XZHUGHQVDJWHUXQGYHUODQJWDEVROXWHV 6FKZHLJHQJHJHQEHUGHQ0HGLHQ'HU3UHVVHVWHOOHGHV0LQL VWHULXPVZHUGHHUVHOEVWHQWVSUHFKHQGH$QZHLVXQJHQHUWHLOHQ
$FKLPJLEWVLFKEHIOLVVHQXQGUHLFKW)HXHU'HU*HQHUDO SDIIWHLQSDDU=JHXQGGHXWHWPLWGHP3IHLIHQVWLHODXIGDV *HPlOGH ª)UDQV6Q\GHUV'HU:LOGEUHWKlQGOHU!'DVKLHULVWQDWU OLFKHLQH.RSLHDEHUHLQHJXWH©9RQ:LHVHQHFNOLHEWHVPLW VHLQHU%LOGXQJ]XSURW]HQª6Q\GHUVZDUHLQ%UXHJHO6FKOHU XQG6SH]LDOLVWIU-DJGWLHUH.DW]HQ+XQGH*HIOJHO)LVFKH )UFKWHXQG*HPVH(LQ0DQQGHULQGHQ6SHLVHNDPPHUQ GHUJURHQ:HOW]X+DXVHZDU0DQVDJWVRJDU5XEHQVKDEH LKQJHKROWZHQQHUDXIVHLQHQ*HPlOGHQ7LHUHEUDXFKWH'HU $GOHUDXIGHP3URPHWKHXV!%LOG]XP%HLVSLHO©(UEULFKW DEXQGOlFKHOWª,FKELQXQWU|VWOLFK'HWMHQGDLFK,KQHQDXI GLHVH:HLVHGHQ6RQQWDJYHUGRUEHQKDEHQ'DQNHGD6LH PLFKLQIRUPLHUWKDEHQ:HQQ6LHGLH/DQGHVSROL]HLJHUXIHQ KlWWHQ6RJHKHQZLUHLQHU8QPHQJHYRQ6SHNXODWLRQHQDXV GHP:HJHGLHQXU8QUXKHVWLIWHQ*OFNLP8QJOFN© 'LH0lQQHUYRQª%RQQHLQV©VLQGLPPHUQRFKDP:HUN =ZHLKRFNHQYRUGHP.DPLQXQGIHJHQEHKXWVDP$VFKHUHVWH LQ3ODVWLNWWHQ'DXQGGRUWLVWGLH$VFKHJDQ]ZHLDOVVHL 3DSLHUYHUEUDQQWZRUGHQ$QGHUHKDEHQGLH7UJHJHQEHUGHU .FKHJH|IIQHW'HWMHQVLHKWLP9RUEHUJHKHQHLQNOHLQHV 6FKODI]LPPHU$XFKKLHUZHUGHQGLH6FKUlQNHJHOHHUWYRQ GHQ:lQGHQJHUFNWXQGJHQDXXQWHUVXFKW'DVEHIUHPGHW $FKLP(VVFKHLQWLKPQLFKWUHFKW]XU6XFKHQDFK6SXUHQ HLQHVP|JOLFKHQ9HUEUHFKHQV]XSDVVHQHUYHUPXWHWGDGLH 0lQQHUHWZDV%HVWLPPWHV]XHQWGHFNHQKRIIHQHWZDVZRYRQ VLHHLQHNODUH9RUVWHOOXQJKDEHQ(UP|FKWHQDFKGHP6LQQ GLHVHU$NWLYLWlWHQIUDJHQDEHUHUXQWHUOlWHV,QGHQ-DKUHQ VHLQHU.XQGVFKDIWHUWlWLJNHLWKDWHUJHOHUQWVHLQH1HXJLHUVR ]XGRVLHUHQGDVLHXQDXIIlOOLJEOHLEW :lKUHQGHUVRGDVWHKWHLQXQEHWHLOLJWHU$XHQVHLWHULQ PLWWHQGHUJHVFKlIWLJHQ*UXSSHQLPPWYRQ:LHVHQHFN +DXSWPDQQ(EHUVEDFKEHLVHLWHXQGVSULFKWOHLVHPLWLKP 'HWMHQYHUVWHKWQLFKWZDVJHUHGHWZLUGGRFKDQGHU5HDNWLRQ GHV*UXSSHQOHLWHUVHUNHQQWHUGDGHU*HQHUDO,QVWUXNWLRQHQ JLEW'HU+DXSWPDQQQLFNWZLHGHUKROWXQGGHXWHWZLHGHUGDV
+DFNHQNODSSHQDQ:DUXPGDVDOOHVZHQQPDQGRFKJHUDGH ZHJVDXIGLH)HVWVWHOOXQJHLQHV8QIDOOV]XPDUVFKLHUW" )UVLHEHLGHJHEHHVKLHUGUDXHQQLFKWVPHKU]XWXQ ZHQGHWVLFKYRQ:LHVHQHFNDQVFKOLHHQG'HWMHQ]XVLH VWQGHQQXULP:HJHXQGWlWHQJXWGDUDQGDV)HOG]XUlXPHQ ª/DVVHQ6LHPLFKJXWPDFKHQGDLFK,KQHQGHQ7DJYHU GRUEHQKDEH,FKODGH6LH]XP0LWWDJHVVHQHLQ5HQDWHZLUG VLFKIUHXHQXQG1HLQGDVZLUGHLQHhEHUUDVFKXQJ .RPPHQ6LH© $FKLPYHUEHXJWVLFKXQGGHQNWLURQLVFKGHQ7DJPVVHPDQ LP.DOHQGHUDQVWUHLFKHQ'HQQHEHQKDWHLQ*HQHUDOVLFKHU OLFKXQJHZROOWHLQJHUlXPWGDHUJHOHJHQWOLFKLP:HJH VWHKW'HQNZUGLJ 6LHQHKPHQHLQHQDQGHUHQ:HJ'HU)HOGZHEHOLQ=LYLOGHU GHQVFKZDU]HQ0HUFHGHVGHV0$'*HQHUDOVIlKUWXPJHKW GLHDXIJHZKOWH:DOGVWUHFNHLQZHLWHP%RJHQXQGHUUHLFKWVR HUVWKLQWHU9DUQGRUIGLH&KDXVVHH'HU:DJHQGHV0DMRUV ]XFNHOWKLQWHUKHU 1DWUOLFKGHQNW$FKLPDQ%ULQNPDQQ'LH(ULQQHUXQJDQ HLQ*HVSUlFKLVWGD'HU2EHUVWKDWWH'HWMHQ]XVLFKJHUXIHQ XPLKP5LFKWOLQLHQIUGDV]XHUDUEHLWHQGH3URMHNWJXWDFKWHQ ]XHUWHLOHQ(UVLHKWJHUDGH]XSODVWLVFKGDVLPPHUVRXQ JODXEOLFKDXIJHUlXPWH%URYRUVLFKGDVEDUMHGHUSHUV|Q OLFKHQ1RWHLVWXQGGLHY|OOLJOHHUH6FKUHLEWLVFKSODWWHDXIGHU GLHEHLGHQ7HOHIRQHXQGGHU6WlQGHUPLWGUHLYHUVFKLHGHQ IDUELJHQ.XJHOVFKUHLEHUQHLQVDPZLUNHQ(VZDUJDQ]XQ JHZ|KQOLFKGD%ULQNPDQQSO|W]OLFK.DIIHHEULQJHQOLH'HU NDPVRIRUW)UDX0DUVFKQHULP9RU]LPPHUVFKLHQHLQHQ EHVRQGHUHQ6LQQIUGLH%HGUIQLVVHLKUHV&KHIV]XKDEHQ :DQQLPPHUHU.DIIHHZQVFKWHNRFKWHJHUDGHGDV:DVVHU ª,FKP|FKWH©KDWWHGHU2EHUVWJHVDJWªGD6LHGDV3UR MHNWJXWDFKWHQIUGHQ9HUWHLGLJXQJVDXVVFKX EHUDUEHLWHQ,Q GLHVHU0DSSHILQGHQ6LHDOOHVGHQPRGLIL]LHUWHQ6WDU ILJKWHU!GLHEULWLVFKH+DZNHU3HOIVLHEHQXQG]ZDQ]LJ!GDV IUDQ]|VLVFKH3URMHNW0LUDJH!XQGGHQ05&$(QWZXUI )DVVHQ6LHGDV]XVDPPHQ7HFKQLVFKH'HWDLOVVRZHQLJZLH
P|JOLFKVRQVWYHUVWHKHQGLH+HUUHQ$EJHRUGQHWHQQXU%DKQ KRI'HUHLQ]LJH)DFKPDQQIU/XIWZDIIHGHQVLHGRUWKDEHQ LVWHLQHKHPDOLJHU/DVWHQVHJOHUNXWVFKHULFKELWWH6LH 7HQGHQ]$OOH0DVFKLQHQVLQGJXWDEHU05&$LVWEHVVHU© 'LHHUZlKQWH0DSSHEUDFKWHHUZLHDXVGHP1LFKWVXQWHU GHU6FKUHLEWLVFKSODWWHKHUYRU'HU0DMRUQDKPVLHHQWJHJHQ XQGEHVWlWLJWHª-DZRKO+HUU2EHUVW$OOH0DVFKLQHQJXW DEHU05&$EHVVHU©(UPDFKWH$QVWDOWHQDXI]XVWHKHQ 0LWHLQHU+DQGEHZHJXQJKDWWHLKP%ULQNPDQQEHGHXWHWHU P|JHVLW]HQEOHLEHQ$XIHLQPDOORFNHUWHGHU$EWHLOXQJVOHLWHU VHLQH+DOWXQJOHKQWHVLFKEHTXHP]XUFNXQGYHUVFKUlQNWH GLH$UPHYRUGHU%UXVW0LWVHLQHQKHOOHQIDVWIDUEORVHQ $XJHQEOLFNWHHU'HWMHQIUHXQGOLFKDQ'HU2EHUVWVDKQRFK JXWDXVPLWVHLQHPVRQQHQJHEUlXQWHQ*HVLFKWGHVVHQ)DUEH PLWGHPHUJUDXWHQDEHUYROOJHEOLHEHQHQ+DDUNRQWUDVWLHUWH ª6LHVLQGGRFKHLQDOWHU+DVH+HUU'HWMHQ©VHW]WHHUQHX DQXQGVFKRQGLHVHV]LYLOHª+HUU'HWMHQ©OLH$FKLP DXIPHUNHQ'DVZDUEHL%ULQNPDQQQLFKWEOLFKª7HLOHQ6LH HLJHQWOLFKGLH$XIIDVVXQJGDXQVHUH/XIWZDIIHLQLKUHP MHW]LJHQ=XVWDQGHLQHP(UQVWIDOOJHZDFKVHQLVW"© ª'DVLVWGLHDOOJHPHLQH$QVLFKWLP)KUXQJVVWDE/XIW ZDIIH©HUZLGHUWHGHU0DMRUVRIRUW:DVVROOWHGDV":ROOWHLKQ %ULQNPDQQDXIV*ODWWHLVIKUHQ"(LQH6WXQGHGHU*HVLQQXQJV SUIXQJ" ª,FKKDWWHXP,KUHSHUV|QOLFKH0HLQXQJJHEHWHQ©EHKDUUWH VHLQ*HJHQEHU 8QEHZHJWHQ*HVLFKWVHQWJHJQHWH'HWMHQª,FKKDEHNHLQHQ *UXQGGLH$QVLFKWGHU([SHUWHQLQ)UDJH]XVWHOOHQ© ª-DMD©PXUPHOWH%ULQNPDQQXQGVFKDXWH]XP)HQVWHU KLQEHU'DYRUVSLHOWHGHU:LQGLQGHQ%LUNHQ$P+LPPHO ]RJHQHLOLJH:RONHQIHW]HQYRUEHUª,VW,KQHQVFKRQHLQPDO DXIJHIDOOHQGDXQVHUH([SHUWHQYRUZLHJHQG0lQQHULQ PHLQHP$OWHUVLQG"6LHKDEHQQLFKWPHKUYLHO=HLWZHQQVLH DQGHQ6LHJHQGHU/XIWZDIIHQRFKWHLOKDEHQZROOHQ©(U ZDQGWHVLFKZLHGHUGHP0DMRU]XXQGOlFKHOWHDOVREHU 9HUVWlQGQLVKHLVFKH
ª,FKNDQQPLUQLFKWYRUVWHOOHQGD+HUU2EHUVWGDVQLFKW ZROOHQ©(UOHKQWHVLFKQLFKWDQVDNHU]HQJHUDGHXQGZDUGDV 0XVWHUELOGHLQHVYRQ=ZHLIHOQDQGHU9ROONRPPHQKHLWGHU HLJHQHQ7UXSSHIUHLHQ6WDEVRIIL]LHUV'DEHLZXUGHLKPKHL :RKLQOLHIGHQQGDV" ª8QVHUHGHU]HLWLJH/XIWZDIIHLVWHLQHhEHUJDQJVO|VXQJ© EUDXVWHGHU2EHUVWMlKDXIVWW]WHGLH+lQGHYRUVLFKDXIGHQ 7LVFKXQGEHXJWHVLFK]XGHPDQGHUHQª0LWHLQHUhEHU JDQJVO|VXQJNDQQPDQQLFKWDXIV*DQ]HJHKHQ,FKZHKUH PLFKHQWVFKLHGHQGDJHJHQ+DVDUG]XVSLHOHQ:HQQORV JHVFKODJHQZLUGXQGLFKELQLPPHUVFKRQLQ3DUDJXD\XQG VSlWHULP1$72+HDGTXDUWHUVNRPSURPLORVGDIUHLQ JHWUHWHQGDPDQGLHXQHUWUlJOLFKHQ=XVWlQGHLQ0LWWHOHXURSD lQGHUQPXZHQQDOVRORVJHVFKODJHQZLUGGDQQPXDE VROXWH*HZLKHLWEHVWHKHQGDYRQXQVQLFKWQXUGHUHUVWH VRQGHUQDXFKGHUOHW]WH6FKXLQGLHVHU$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJ PLWGHP.RPPXQLVPXVDEJHJHEHQZLUG8QGGDIUVLQG QHXQ]HKQKXQGHUWHLQXQGVHFK]LJGLH9RUDXVVHW]XQJHQQLFKW JHJHEHQ© (LQH3DXVHHQWVWDQG%ULQNPDQQZDUWHWHDXIHLQH6WHO OXQJQDKPH'LHEOLHEDXV$FKLPEHVFKUlQNWHVLFKDXIV=X K|UHQ:LHKHOOK|ULJHUEHLGHU6DFKHZDUYHUEDUJHU=ZHL IHOORVKDWWHGHU2EHUVWHLQHVROFKH3UREOHPVWHOOXQJQLFKWDXV KHLWHUHP+LPPHODXIJHZRUIHQ'DIUPXWHHVHLQHQ$QOD JHEHQ'HWMHQZHUWHWHGLH$XVODVVXQJHQVHLQHV9RUJHVHW]WHQ DOVQHXHUOLFKH%HVWlWLJXQJGDIUGDLQGHU%XQGHVUHSXEOLN GDVJHVDPWHSROLWLVFKHZLUWVFKDIWOLFKHXQGJHVHOOVFKDIWOLFKH /HEHQ]XQHKPHQGPLOLWDULVLHUWZXUGHQLFKWQXUDXIGHU +DUGWK|KHZDUPHKUXQGPHKUGLH5HGHYRP$XVEDX:HVW EHUOLQVDOV%UFNHQNRSIGHU1$72XQGWlJOLFKEHULFKWHWHQ GLH0DVVHQPHGLHQYRQJHIlKUOLFKHQ=ZLVFKHQIlOOHQDQGHU 6WDDWVJUHQ]HGHU'HXWVFKHQ'HPRNUDWLVFKHQ5HSXEOLNYRQ GHUVLHHLQ%LOGGHV&KDRVXQGGHV6FKUHFNHQV]HLFKQHWHQ 1RFKQLHLVWGHUNDOWH.ULHJJHJHQGHQDQGHUHQGHXWVFKHQ 6WDDWVRKHLXQGXPIDVVHQGJHIKUWZRUGHQZLH]X%HJLQQ GLHVHV-DKUHV'HU=XVDPPHQKDQJPLW%ULQNPDQQV hEHUOHJXQJHQZDUXQYHUNHQQEDU
'DGHU0DMRUVFKZLHJVSUDFKGHU2EHUVWZHLWHUª:DVLFK ,KQHQHEHQJHVDJWKDEH+HUU'HWMHQWULIIWOHLGHUDXIWDXEH 2KUHQ+LHU]XODQGH=XP*OFNJLEWHVQRFKDQGHUH0|JOLFK NHLWHQ8QGLFKZHUGHVLHQXW]HQ(LQHGHXWVFKH$UPHHGDUI QLFKW]XPGULWWHQPDOLQGLHVHP-DKUKXQGHUWJHVFKODJHQLQGLH +HLPDW]XUFNNHKUHQ:HQQVLHPDUVFKLHUWPXVLHHVGLHV PDOPLWGHUDEVROXWHQ*HZLKHLWGHV6LHJHVWXQ© 'HU)HOGZHEHODP6WHXHUGHVVFKZDU]HQ0HUFHGHVKlOWVLFK DQGLHYRUJHVFKULHEHQH*HVFKZLQGLJNHLWXQGHUP|JOLFKWHV 'HWMHQVRPKHORV]XIROJHQ'DEHLLVWGLH6WUDHOHHU6LH VLHKWDXVDOVHUKROHVLHVLFKYRPZRFKHQWlJOLFKHQ)DKU]HXJ VWURP %HLGHP*HVSUlFKPLW%ULQNPDQQKDWWH$FKLPEHZXW GDUDXIYHU]LFKWHWGHQ2EHUVWGXUFKHLQSDDUJHVFKLFNWH )UDJHQDQGHU=XQJH]X]LHKHQRGHUJDU]XYHUVXFKHQVLFK ]XVHLQHP9HUWUDXWHQ]XPDFKHQ'DEHLIROJWHHUHLQHU :HLVXQJ:LQQLH:LQNHOPDQQVGLHVFKRQYRUJHUDXPHU=HLW JHVDJWKDWWHª,FKVROOGLUPLWWHLOHQNHLQH$QQlKHUXQJDQ %ULQNPDQQhEHUGHLQHP&KHIEUDXWVLFKRIIHQEDUHWZDV ]XVDPPHQ9RUVLFKW©(UKDWWHGHPHQWJHJHQJHKDOWHQ%ULQN PDQQJHK|UHDEHUGRFK]XGHQJDQ]DOWHQ.DPHUDGHQXQGVHL 9HUELQGXQJVRIIL]LHUGHV2EHUNRPPDQGRVGHU/XIWZDIIH]XP 5HLFKVIKUHU66JHZHVHQ+LPPOHUSHUV|QOLFKKDEHLKPVRJDU HLQHQ(KUHQULQJYHUOLHKHQXQGHVGHXWHGRFKZRKOGDUDXIKLQ GDHUVLFKQRFKGHUJOHLFKHQ:HUWVFKlW]XQJHUIUHXHGDLKQ GHU*HQHUDOLQVSHNWHXUGHU/XIWZDIIHVHOEVWIUVHLQHQMHW]LJHQ 3RVWHQYRUJHVFKODJHQKDWWH.DXPYRUVWHOOEDUGDVROFKHLQ 0DQQLQV6FKXIHOGJHUDWHQVHLQVROO :LQQLH:LQNHOPDQQXQGHUZDUHQGDPDOVDXIGHU7UDEUHQQ EDKQLQ.|OQJHZHVHQXQWHUJHWDXFKWLQGHU0HQJHGHU7XUI IUHXQGHXQJHVW|UWLPDOOJHPHLQHQ*HGUlQJH :LQQLHZXWHHVEHVVHU'LH*HQRVVHQLQ%HUOLQKDWWHQVLH LQIRUPLHUWª(VJLEWHLQHVWUHQJJHKHLPHPLOLWlULVFKH6WXGLH GLHGLH)KUXQJVVWlEHGHU7HLOVWUHLWNUlIWHHUDUEHLWHWKDEHQ $OVGLHVH6WXGLHYRP9HUWHLGLJXQJVPLQLVWHU6WUDXDQ%XQ GHVNDQ]OHU$GHQDXHUEHUJHEHQZXUGHIHKOWHQGDULQYLHU]HKQ
6HLWHQ'DVZDUH[DNWGHUYROOVWlQGLJH%HLWUDJYRQ2EHUVW %ULQNPDQQ]XGLHVHU9RUODJH© 'HWMHQZDUYRQGHU9RUODJHLQIRUPLHUWJHZHVHQ1DWUOLFK KDWWHGDVJDQ]H5HIHUDWGHP&KHI]XDUEHLWHQPVVHQRKQH GDGLHHLQ]HOQHQMHGRFKGDV(QGHUJHEQLV]X*HVLFKWEH NDPHQ1XUVRYLHOVWDQGIHVW'DV3DSLHUZDUZHLWHUJHJHEHQ ZRUGHQDOVRPXWHHVDXIGHP:HJH]XP%XQGHVNDQ]OHU IHVWJHKDOWHQZRUGHQVHLQ 'HUVFKZDU]H0HUFHGHVYRUQYHUPLQGHUWGLH*HVFKZLQGLJ NHLW$FKLPQLPPWJOHLFKIDOOVGHQ)XYRP*DV3O|W]OLFK VW|WLKPDXIGDPDQGHQªWUDJLVFKHQ8QIDOOWRG©GHV2EHU VWHQGHU/XIWZDIIH%ULQNPDQQDXFKDQGHUVEHWUDFKWHQNDQQ 'HU$EWHLOXQJVOHLWHULVWDXVGHU5HLKHJHWDQ]WHUKDWVLFK RIIHQEDUHUODXEWHLQHDQGHUH0HLQXQJ]XKDEHQDOVGLHUH YDQFKHOVWHUQHQ6FKDUIPDFKHUXP0LQLVWHU6WUDXXQGDXI GLHVHP6WDQGSXQNW]XEHKDUUHQ'HXWHWHQLFKWGLHEHLP*H VSUlFKLP%URJHPDFKWHbXHUXQJGDUDXIKLQGDHUVLFK LQMHGHP)DOOH*HK|UYHUVFKDIIHQZROOWHDXFKZHQQHUGDPLW ZLGHUGHQ6WDFKHOVHLQHVªREHUVWHQ.ULHJVKHUUQ©ORFNWH" =ZHLIHOORVEHVDHU0|JOLFKNHLWHQGD]XHUPXWHGRFK ZlKUHQGVHLQHU7l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lQJWPLW%ULQNPDQQV%HLWUDJ]XGHU 9RUODJH]XVDPPHQXQGPLW%ULQNPDQQV%HPHUNXQJHUZHUGH QRWIDOOVDQGHUVZRHLQRIIHQHV2KUILQGHQ:DUHUVFKRQGDEHL VHLQH%HGHQNHQVFKULIWOLFK]XIRUPXOLHUHQ"$FKLPGHQNWDQ GLHRIIHQH6FKUHLEPDVFKLQHLP%ORFNKDXV
(UKlOWXQPLWWHOEDUKLQWHUGHP0HUFHGHVGHVVHQ)DKUHU KHUDXVVSULQJWXQGVHLQHP*HQHUDOGLH7U|IIQHW ª.RPPHQ6LH'HWMHQ©OlGWYRQ:LHVHQHFNHLQª,FKKDEH JURHQ+XQJHU©
'LHYHUVSURFKHQHhEHUUDVFKXQJKHLW*QWHU.U|VLQJ'HU HKHPDOLJH&KHIGHVIDVFKLVWLVFKHQ-DJGJHVFKZDGHUVª,P PHOPDQQ©QDFKPDOLJHU&RURQHOXQG9RUJHVHW]WHUGHVYHU PHLQWOLFKHQ)OLHJHUDVVHV'HWMHQLQ$UJHQWLQLHQXQGVHLQ VSlWHUHU$EWHLOXQJVOHLWHUDXIGHU+DUGWK|KHGHUKHXWLJH /REE\LVWHLQHVEHNDQQWHQVGGHXWVFKHQ/XIWIDKUWNRQ]HUQV JLEWVLFKWURW]VHLQHVNDKOHQ.RSIHVQRFKHEHQVRMXJHQGOLFK IRUVFKZLHIUKHU$XFKVHLQWUDJHQGHV2UJDQKDWQLFKWVDQ /DXWVWlUNHHLQJHEWXQGHUEHJUW$FKLPPLWOlUPHQGHU hEHUVFKZHQJOLFKNHLW0HLQH+HUUHQVLQGGDQLFKWJOHLFKGLH DOWHQ=HLWHQZLHGHUOHEHQGLJGLH/XIWNlPSIHEHUGHU 8NUDLQHGLH)OJHEHUGHQDUJHQWLQLVFKHQ8UZDOG]XMHQHU +D]LHQGDLQGHUGHU*UXQGVWRFNIUªHLQHZHKUKDIWH%XQGHV UHSXEOLN©JHVFKQLW]WZXUGHGLH5FNNHKUVFKOLHOLFKXQGGLH JHPHLQVDPH0LWZLUNXQJDP$XIEDXHLQHUQHXHQVFKODJ NUlIWLJHQ/XIWZDIIH"6RZDVYHUELQGHWIUDOOH=HLWHQª1HXH 0DVFKLQHQQHXH0RQWXUDEHUGHU*HLVWGHU7UXSSHVR© 8QGEHLGH]HLJHQVLHVLFKGLHHUKREHQH)DXVWPLWDXIUHFKW JHVWHOOWHP'DXPHQ(VLVWDOOHVLQ2UGQXQJ]ZLVFKHQLKQHQ 'HWMHQVLHKW.U|VLQJQDFKDOVHU]XVHLQHU7RFKWHUKLQ EHUJHKWZHLOHULUJHQGZHOFKH6RQGHUZQVFKHKLQVLFKWOLFK GHU*HWUlQNH]XP0LWWDJHVVHQDQPHOGHQZLOO(LQHQ$XJHQ EOLFNLVW$FKLPDOOHLQLQGHPJDQ]DXI,PDJHSIOHJHXQG5H SUlVHQWDWLRQJHVWHOOWHQ6SHLVH]LPPHU(UKDWHLQVFK|QHV +DXVGHU%ULJDGHJHQHUDOYRQ:LHVHQHFNXQGHLQJHULFKWHWLVW HVPLWGHP7HXHUVWHQXQG.RPIRUWDEHOVWHQZDVGHU0DUNW ELHWHW6LHNDQQVLFKVHKHQODVVHQGLHªEHVFKHLGHQH+WWH©GHV
0$'*HZDOWLJHQGHUVLFKVHLQH6SRUHQLQGHU$EWHLOXQJ ª)UHPGH+HHUH2VW©GHV*HQHUDOV*HKOHQYHUGLHQWKDW 6HNXQGHQODQJJLEWVLFKDXFK:HUQHU%UHGHEXVFK(ULQQH UXQJHQKLQ:HQQHUMHW]W]XUFNGHQNWDQVHLQH(QWVFKHLGXQJ DOV.XQGVFKDIWHUGHV0LQLVWHULXPVIU6WDDWVVLFKHUKHLWGLH ª6SXUGHU:|OIH©]XYHUIROJHQGHUQDFKGHU=HUVFKODJXQJGHV )DVFKLVPXVXQWHUJHWDXFKWHQVLFKLP9HUERUJHQHQVDPPHOQ GHQXQGQXQLP5XGHOZLHGHUKHUYRUJHWUHWHQHQ0HXWHGLH GDUDXIEUHQQWGLH(UJHEQLVVHGHV]ZHLWHQ:HOWNULHJHVXP ]XNHKUHQXQG]XªNRUULJLHUHQ©GDQQZHLHUGDGDVHLQHJXWH XQGQRWZHQGLJH(QWVFKHLGXQJZDU1DWUOLFKKDWHVLQGHQ -DKUHQYLHOH6LWXDWLRQHQJHJHEHQLQGHQHQVHLQH)UHLKHLWXQG VRJDUVHLQ/HEHQDXIGHV0HVVHUV6FKQHLGHVWDQGHQXQG PDQFKPDOKDWWHHU$QJVWIXUFKWEDUH$QJVW:XWHHUZLHHV DXVJHKHQZUGHDOVHUGHU)OXJ]HXJIKUHU8QWHURIIL]LHU %UHGHEXVFKPLWGHP6FKODFKWIOXJ]HXJ+VHLQHPEXOOLJHQ 'RSSHOGHFNHUYRP7\S+HQVFKHOKLQWHUGHQVRZMHWLVFKHQ /LQLHQODQGHWHXPQLFKWDQGHQ9HUEUHFKHQGHU+LWOHUFOLTXH PLWVFKXOGLJ]XZHUGHQ":XWHHUZLHHVDXVJHKHQZUGHDOV HUQDFKGHQJHIDKUYROOHQ6WDWLRQHQDXIGHPªU|PLVFKHQ:HJ© GHU66+LOIVRUJDQLVDWLRQª.DPHUDGHQZHUN©LQ&RUGREDPLW GHQ3DSLHUHQGHVJHIDOOHQHQ-DJGIOLHJHUV'HWMHQXQGHLQ JHSDXNWHP:LVVHQEHUGLHVHQ0DQQHEHQMHQHP.RPPRGRUH .U|VLQJJHJHQEHUWUDWLQGHVVHQ*HVFKZDGHUGLHVHU'HWMHQ JHIORJHQZDU"'LH7lXVFKXQJJHODQJXQGHVZDU.U|VLQJGHU LKQ%UHGHEXVFKLQVHLQHP*HIROJHPLWLQGLH=HQWUDOHGHU ZHVWGHXWVFKHQ5HPLOLWDULVLHUXQJQDKP9LHO0KHKDWHV JHNRVWHW.U|VLQJLPPHUGRUWKLQ]XGLULJLHUHQZRHULKQ EUDXFKWH$EHUHVLVWJHOXQJHQXQGWUlJW)UFKWH(LQJXWHV *HIKOZHQQHUVLFKGDVPDQFKPDOYRU$XJHQKlOW $XIGHP7LVFKEUHQQWHLQGUHLDUPLJHUVLOEHUQHU.HU]HQ OHXFKWHU6HOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKZLUGYRQ%ULQNPDQQJHVSURFKHQ 5HQDWHYRQ:LHVHQHFNVFKZHLJWGD]X6LHEHVFKUlQNWVLFK GDUDXIHLQHDXIPHUNVDPH*DVWJHEHULQ]XVHLQXQGGDVVHU YLHUHQGH0lGFKHQDQ]XZHLVHQ'DVLVWHLQHYRPª:LUW VFKDIWVZXQGHU©DQJHORFNWH,WDOLHQHULQ6LHYHUVWHKWNDXPHLQ
:RUWXQGVFKHLQWYRUZLHJHQG$QJVW]XKDEHQHWZDVIDOVFK ]XPDFKHQ ª(LQ-lJHUYRUGHP+HUUQ©.U|VLQJVFKWWHOWGHQ.RSI ª8QGVHLQHHLJHQH-DJGZDIIHZLUGLKP]XP9HUKlQJQLV:HQQ GDVQLFKWWUDJLVFKLVW© ª6HKUWUDJLVFK©EHVWlWLJW$FKLP2KQHGLH=HUOHJXQJHLQHU )RUHOOH]XXQWHUEUHFKHQVLHKWHU]XP*HQHUDOKLQGHUDQV 7HOHIRQJHUXIHQZRUGHQLVWXQGJHUDGHZLHGHUKHUHLQNRPPW 9RQ:LHVHQHFNVHW]WVLFKXQGQLPPWGLH6HUYLHWWHDXI(U ZLUNWYHUlUJHUWª:HQQPDQVLFKQLFKWXPDOOHVVHOEVWNP PHUW©ZLUIWHUKLQª,FKP|FKWHQLFKWZLVVHQDXIZHOFK XQEHKROIHQH$UWPDQGHUDOWHQ)UDXGHQ8QIDOOLKUHV0DQQHV PLWJHWHLOWKDW+DEHQDOOHNHLQ+HU]GLHVHMXQJHQ/HXWH8QG GDQQEHUOlWPDQ)UDX%ULQNPDQQHLQIDFKVRLKUHP/HLG,FK KDEHHEHQYHUDQODWGDVLHHLQ:DJHQYRQXQV]XLKUHP6RKQ QDFK5HJHQVEXUJEULQJW(VZHUGHQVRYLHOHXQQ|WLJH)DKUWHQ DXI6WDDWVNRVWHQJHPDFKWDEHUDXIGDV1lFKVWOLHJHQGH NRPPWNHLQHU© 2EHUVWD'.U|VLQJWULQNWHLQHQ6FKOXFN3IlO]HUXQGWXSIW VLFKGLH/LSSHQª'DHVLKQDXIVROFKH$UWHUZLVFKHQPXWH© VHXI]WHUQRFKHLQPDOª(UODJPLUQLFKWQDVFK|QMHGRFKVR HLQ(QGHZQVFKHLFKNHLQHP© 'HU0RNNDZLUGLP+HUUHQ]LPPHUJHUHLFKW0DQUDXFKW QRFKHLQH=LJDUUH'DQQKlOWHV'HWMHQIUDQJHPHVVHQVLFK ]XHQWIHUQHQ1LHPDQGYHUVXFKWLKQ]XKDOWHQ$FKLPGHQNW ZLHGHUDQGHQª=XIDOO©GHULKQGHQ7RWHQILQGHQOLH'HU 0RKUKDWVHLQH6FKXOGLJNHLWJHWDQGHU0RKUNDQQJHKHQ 9RQ:LHVHQHFNXQGVHLQ6FKZLHJHUYDWHUWUHWHQDXIGLH 9HUDQGDKHUDXV9RQKLHUDXVIKUHQHLQSDDU6WXIHQKLQDE LQGHQ*DUWHQ'LHEHLGHQ0lQQHUEOHLEHQMHGRFKXQWHUGHP *ODVGDFKLQPLWWHQGHV5HFKWHFNVGDVVLFK]XP*DUWHQKLQ |IIQHW%HTXHPHZHLH+RO]VWKOHPLWOHXFKWHQGURWHQ.LVVHQ VWHKHQYRUGHP$XHQNDPLQ(LQHDXVIDUELJHQ*ODVVWHLQHQ JHIJWH:DQGEHJUHQ]WGLH9HUDQGDQDFKGHUHLQHQHLQH %UXFKVWHLQPDXHUQDFKGHUDQGHUHQ6HLWH ª8QGZHUZLUG%ULQNPDQQV1DFKIROJHU"©HUNXQGLJWVLFK
GHUHKHPDOLJH.RPPRGRUHXQGVFKOlJWEHKDJOLFKHLQ%HLQ EHUVDQGHUH$OVGHUDQGHUHEORGLH6FKXOWHUQKHEWIlKUWHU IRUWª:HQQPLFKMHPDQGIUDJHQZUGHDEHUPLFKIUDJWMD QLHPDQGZUGHLFKPHLQHQGDGLH$EWHLOXQJJXWEHUDWHQ ZlUHDOVQHXHQ&KHIXQVHUHQDOWHQ6SH]L'HWMHQHLQ]XVHW]HQ HLQHQ0DQQPLWGHUULFKWLJHQ0DUVFKULFKWXQJ'HUNHQQWLQ GLHVHP+DXIHQMHGH%URNODPPHU© ª0LWGHUULFKWLJHQ0DUVFKULFKWXQJ©ZLHGHUKROWYRQ :LHVHQHFNXQGOlWGLH:RUWHGDEHLLQGHU6FKZHEHª%LVWGX GDJDQ]VLFKHU"$XFK%ULQNPDQQZDUPDOHLQHUYRQXQV© .U|VLQJZlKOWPLW%HGDFKWHLQHQHXH=LJDUUHDXVGHU.LVWH GLHDXIGHP7LVFKVWHKW(UIKUWVLHXQWHUGHU1DVHYRUEHLXQG ILQJHUWLQGHU:HVWHQWDVFKHQDFKGHU6FKHUHª(VJLEWVHKU ZHQLJH)OLHJHULQGHU2UJDQLVDWLRQGHUHKHPDOLJHQ66$QJH K|ULJHQ© 8QZLOONUOLFKVHQNWGHU*HQHUDOGLH6WLPPHª'HU(KUHQ ULQJGHV5HLFKVIKUHUV+DVWGXVFKRQYHUJHVVHQGDPDQ EHUGLH2'(66$QLFKWVSULFKW"©8QGEHWRQWª.HLQH)UDJHQ GD]XELWWH©(UVHW]WVLFKQLFKWJHKWHLQSDDU6FKULWWHXQG OHKQWVLFKGDQQGHQ$UPDXIGHQ6LPVJHVWW]WDQGHQ.DPLQ ª'HU9RUIDOO]ZLQJWXQVMHGHQHLQ]HOQHQDXVGHU8PJHEXQJ %ULQNPDQQV]XGXUFKOHXFKWHQ$XFK'HWMHQ6FKRQGDVIRU GHUW9RUVLFKW,FKN|QQWHPLUDEHUYRUVWHOOHQGDHUGLH $EWHLOXQJELVDXIZHLWHUHVNRPPLVVDULVFKOHLWHW© .U|VLQJGUFNWGLH=LJDUUHEHKXWVDP]ZLVFKHQ'DXPHQXQG =HLJHILQJHUª$OOHV4XDWVFK©VDJWHUª9RUVLFKWPXVHLQ DEHUZDV'HWMHQDQJHKW:HQQLFKPLFKUHFKWHULQQHUHKDW HUIUGLFKHLQHJDQ]H5HLKHJOKHQGHU.RKOHQDXVGHP)HXHU JHKROW$OOHVYHUJHVVHQ"© 9RQ:LHVHQHFNVLHKW]XHLQHU*UXSSHVLFKMDJHQGHU6SDW]HQ KLQEHUª2KQH$QVHKHQGHU3HUVRQ©HUZLGHUWHUEUVN ª%HJUHLIGRFKHQGOLFKGDHVQLFKWQXUXP$FKLP'HWMHQJHKW 'DLVWQRFKHLQJXWHV'XW]HQGDQGHUHUDXFKYHUGLHQWHU/HXWH KLQWHUGHQHQ%RUQXQG.DLVHUPLWGHP6LFKHUKHLWVGLHQVWGHU EHZXWHQ2UJDQLVDWLRQHEHQVRKHUVLQGZLHKLQWHUGHLQHP /LHEOLQJVVFKOHU:LHGLH'LQJHOLHJHQPVVHQZLUDQQHKPHQ
GDHLQHURGHUPHKUHUHGDYRQIDXOVLQG:HU"'DVPVVHQZLU VFKQHOOVWHQVKHUDXVNULHJHQ(VJHKWXP.RSIXQG.UDJHQ© -HW]WEUHQQWGLH=LJDUUH'HUbOWHUHEOlVWJHQOLFKHLQHQ 5DXFKULQJLQGLH/XIWª*XWJXW©OHQNWHUYHUV|KQOLFKHLQ :DVKDWHUGDYRQZHQQHUVLFKYRU$FKLPVWHOOW"ª,FKP|FKWH QXUQLFKWJHUQPHLQH.UHLVHJHVW|UWVHKHQ)UPLFKJHKWHV XPGLH)UDJHGDLFKDXFKDXIPHLQHU6WUHFNHHLQHQ1DFK IROJHUIU%ULQNPDQQEUDXFKH$OVLFKGHPGDPDOV]XGLHVHU ,QGXVWULHYHUELQGXQJYHUKDOIZDUQLFKWDE]XVHKHQGDHUVR VFKQHOODXVIDOOHQZUGH© ª8QG"© .U|VLQJ]XSIWDQGHU%JHOIDOWH'DYRQDXVJHKHQGGDVHLQ 6FKZLHJHUVRKQZHLWZHQLJHU$KQXQJYRQPRGHUQHP0DQD JHPHQWXQGGHVVHQYHUVFKOXQJHQHQ3IDGHQEHVLW]WDOVHU VHOEVWEHLP/XIWIDKUWNRQ]HUQ:HJHQHU 0RVVHUZRUEHQKDW HUNOlUWHUZLHGDV]XVDPPHQKlQJW(UVHW]HYRUDXVEHJLQQW HUGDVHOEVWHLQ6LFKHUKHLWVRIIL]LHUKHXWHZLVVHZLHYROO JHVWRSIWPRGHUQH.DPSIIOXJ]HXJHPLWNRPSOL]LHUWHU(OHN WURQLNVLQGVRYROOJHVWRSIWGDGLHVH7HFKQLNJHOHJHQWOLFK VRJDUHUIDKUHQH3LORWHQEHUIRUGHUWXQG]XEHGDXHUOLFKHP PHQVFKOLFKHP9HUVDJHQIKUW$EHUGDVVHLHLQDQGHUHV .DSLWHO 9RQ:LHVHQHFNOHKQWLPPHUQRFKDP.DPLQXQGOlFKHOW EHOXVWLJW1DWUOLFKZHLHUGDV'RFKHUVDJWQLFKWV(U VFKZHLJWXQGK|UW]X 'HUHKHPDOLJH*HVFKZDGHUFKHIGHUª,PPHOPlQQHU©IlKUW IRUW:HJHQHU 0RVVEH]LHKHHLQHQ7HLOGHUEHQ|WLJWHQ HOHNWURQLVFKHQ$XVVWDWWXQJYRQHLQHU)LUPDQDPHQV(*$GHU (OHNWURQLN*HUlWHXQG$QODJHQEDXPLW6LW]LQ.|OQ6HOEVW YHUVWlQGOLFKKDEHPDQGLH(*$PLW%HGDFKWDOV/LHIHUDQWHQ JHZlKOW'LHVH)LUPDQlPOLFKVHLWURW]LKUHVGHXWVFKHQ$XV KlQJHVFKLOGHVGDV7RFKWHUXQWHUQHKPHQHLQHVHLQVFKOlJLJHQ 3DULVHU.RQ]HUQV'DVHU|IIQHJHZLVVH0|JOLFKNHLWHQ ª,P.ODUWH[W"© ª:HQQZLUHUKHEOLFKH$XIWUlJHDQGLH.|OQHU(*$YHU JHEHQGDQQKDEHQZLUQDWUOLFKGHQ:XQVFKXQVHUHUVHLWV
DXFKPLWEHVWLPPWHQHLJHQHQ(U]HXJQLVVHQEHLGHUIUDQ]| VLVFKHQ0XWWHUILUPDHLQ]XVWHLJHQ1XQLVWGDVDQVLFKHLQH 6DFKHGLH9HUWUHWHUGHUEHLGHQ)LUPHQJDQ]JHPWOLFKEHL HLQHP$UEHLWVHVVHQEHUGLH%KQHVFKLHEHQN|QQHQ$EHU 'D]XPVVHQVLHZLVVHQZHOFKHVWUDWHJLVFKHQ,QWHUHVVHQGHU )KUXQJVVWDE/XIWZDIIHYHUIROJWXQGZHOFKHWDNWLVFKHQ 0LWWHOHUDQZHQGHQZLOOVLH]XHUUHLFKHQ'DUEHULP%LOGH ]XVHLQXQGGHU)LUPDHQWVSUHFKHQGH]LHOJHULFKWHWH+LQZHLVH ]XJHEHQGDPLWLKUH(QWZLFNOXQJVDUEHLWHQXQGLKU$QJHERW GHQWDWVlFKOLFKHQ%HGUIQLVVHQHQWVSUHFKHQLVWGLH$XIJDEH VROFKHU9HUELQGXQJVPlQQHU,KUHUVHLWVZHUGHQVLHJOHLFKVDP LQGHU5FNNRSSOXQJLQGLH/DJHYHUVHW]WGLHXQWHULKUHP (LQIOXHQWVWDQGHQHQ*HUlWH]XPJHHLJQHWHQ=HLWSXQNW]XU %HVFKDIIXQJ]XHPSIHKOHQ6ROlXIWGDVEHL:HJHQHU 0RVV 6RDUEHLWHWH%ULQNPDQQGHU(*$LQGLH+DQG'DVJOHLFKH HUZDUWHQZLUYRQVHLQHP1DFKIROJHU,Q]ZLVFKHQZHUGHQZLU GLH.|OQHUPLWEHGLHQHQDEHUDXIGLH'DXHUWDXJWGDVQLFKW -HPHKU4XHUYHUELQGXQJHQGHVWREHVVHU$XHUGHP]DKOWHV VLFKLPPHUDXVEHLGHUDQGHUHQ)LUPDDXVJHUHFKQHWHLQHQ 0DQQ]XZLVVHQPLWGHPPDQJXWHQ.RQWDNWKDW0DQHUIlKUW VRDXFKYRQGHQ6SSFKHQGLHGLHOLHEHQ)UHXQGH!DOOHLQ]X NRFKHQJHGHQNHQ8QGMHK|KHUGHU'LHQVWJUDGGHVWRJU|HU GLH:LUNXQJVZHLVH©(UVWUHLFKWHLQHQODQJHQ6WUHLIHQ$VFKH LQGLH7RQVFKDOHª'HWMHQLVW]ZDUQXU0DMRUGRFKHLQ([ SHUWH8QG.XJHOQKDWHUKLQOlQJOLFKSIHLIHQK|UHQ(VJHKW QLFKWVEHUSUDNWLVFKH(UIDKUXQJ0WHHUQLFKWEDOG2EHUVW OHXWQDQWZHUGHQ",FKZUGHLKQJDQ]JHUQDQ%ULQNPDQQV 6WHOOHVHKHQ© :HQQHVQXUGDUXPJHKHHUZLGHUWGHU*HQHUDOGDJHJHQ KlWWHHUQLFKWVHLQ]XZHQGHQ'DVWDQJLHUHGLH,QWHUHVVHQGHU EHZXWHQ2UJDQLVDWLRQVHLQHV(UDFKWHQVEHUKDXSWQLFKW 8QGZDVGLH%HI|UGHUXQJGHVª/LHEOLQJVVFKOHUV©DQEHWUHIIH QXQGDODVVHVLFKMDHLQZHQLJQDFKKHOIHQ
'HUDOWH%DXPEHVWDQGLVWEHVRQGHUVUHL]YROO+RKH3ODWDQHQ Z|OEHQVLFKEHUGHPJHSIOHJWHQ:HJ8QWHUGHP%OlWWHUGDFK LVWGHU$EHQGVFKRQQDK'RFKGDQQHQGHWGLH$OOHH(LQ NOHLQHU6HHEUHLWHWVLFKDXVYRQGHUXQWHUJHKHQGHQ6RQQH U|WOLFKDQJHKDXFKW$PMHQVHLWLJHQ8IHUHUKHEWVLFKGLH .XSSHOGHV.XUKDXVHVPLWGHPVlXOHQEHJUHQ]WHQ(LQJDQJ :HUQHU%UHGHEXVFKLVWQLFKWDOOHLQ'HUIUHXQGOLFKH)UK VRPPHUWDJKDWDXHU.XUJlVWHQDXFKYLHOH(LQZRKQHUGHU ª3HQVLRQlUVWDGW©:LHVEDGHQ]XP6SD]LHUHQJHKHQJHORFNW $QVlVVLJHWUHIIHQKLHU%HNDQQWHMXQJH3DDUHILQGHQLPPHU QRFKHLQHYHUVFKZLHJHQH(FNHXQGZHQQPDQ)UHPGHQ EHJHJQHWZLUGPDQQLFKWQHXJLHULJGLH.XUJlVWHZHFKVHOQ MDVWlQGLJ'DVPDFKWGHQ.XUSDUNGHU6WDGWDP5KHLQ]X HLQHPLGHDOHQ7UHIISXQNW'DIlOOWPDQQLFKWDXIGDLVWPDQ JDQ]HLQIDFK7HLOHLQHVJHZRKQWHQ%LOGHV (UIUHXWVLFKDOVHU:LQQLH:LQNHOPDQQVLHKW6LHVLW]WDXI HLQHUGHU3DUNElQNHLQPLWWHQEOKHQGHU5KRGRGHQGURQEVFKH XQGKDWHLQ%XFKLQGHU+DQG'DVVFKPDOH*ROGVFKQLWWElQG FKHQVLHKWQDFK5LONHDXV(VEHZDKUW:LQQLHPLW6LFKHUKHLW GDYRUDQJHVSURFKHQ]XZHUGHQ:HU5LONHOLHVWQXQMD 6HKUJOFNOLFKPXWHWGLH)RWRJUDILQDXV)UDQNIXUWDP0DLQ QLFKWDQ'DIUKDW:HUQHU9HUVWlQGQLV*DQ]JHZLZDU :LQQLHYRQVHLQHP$QUXIQLFKWHUEDXWZDKUVFKHLQOLFKKDWWH VLH3OlQHIUGLHVHQ6RQQWDJ9HUDEUHGXQJHQYLHOOHLFKWGLHVLH PLWYRUJHVFKREHQHQ%HJUQGXQJHQUFNJlQJLJPDFKHQ PXWHXPQDFK:LHVEDGHQIDKUHQ]XN|QQHQ 'DV=XVDPPHQWUHIIHQHUIROJWDXHUSODQPlLJ1DFKUHLI OLFKHUhEHUOHJXQJKDWWHGHU.XQGVFKDIWHULP$QVFKOXDQGDV 0LWWDJHVVHQEHLYRQ:LHVHQHFN]XP7HOHIRQJHJULIIHQ :LQQLHV1XPPHUJHZlKOWXQGDOVVLHVLFKPHOGHWHJHEHWHQ )UlXOHLQ7KLHUVFKDQGHQ$SSDUDW]XUXIHQ:HGHUHUQRFKGLH )RWRJUDILQNHQQHQHLQ)UlXOHLQ7KLHUVFK+lWWHHLQ'ULWWHUGDV *HVSUlFKPLWJHK|UWGDQQZUGHHUEHVWHQIDOOVJHGDFKWKDEHQ
GHU$QUXIHUKDEHHLQHQIDOVFKHQ$QVFKOXJHZlKOW9LHOOHLFKW ZUGHHUVRJDU0LWOHLGPLWGHP0DQQHPSIXQGHQKDEHQGHU YHUVLFKHUWHGLHJHZlKOWH1XPPHUVHLLKPYRQ)UlXOHLQ 7KLHUVFKJHQDQQWZRUGHQRGHU6FKDGHQIUHXGHZHLOEHVDJWHV )UlXOHLQRIIHQEDUHLQHQOlVWLJHQ9HUHKUHULQGLH,UUHJHIKUW KDWWH6RHWZDVVROOHVMDJHEHQ 0LWGHP)UlXOHLQ7KLHUVFKKDWHVHLQHEHVRQGHUH%HZDQGW QLV'LHVHU1DPHLVWGDV&RGHZRUWIUHLQGULQJHQGQRW ZHQGLJHV=XVDPPHQWUHIIHQ(UQHQQW]XJOHLFKGHQ2UWDQ GHPGLH%HJHJQXQJVWDWWILQGHQVROOª7KLHUVFK©VWHKWIU :LHVEDGHQZHLOHVHLQ3URIHVVRU)ULHGULFKYRQ7KLHUVFKZDU GHUGLH3OlQHIUGDVGRUWLJH.XUKDXVVFKXIGLHVHVMHQVHLWV GHV7HLFKHVJHOHJHQH.XUKDXVGHVVHQLRQLVFKH6lXOHQMHW]W ODQJH6FKDWWHQZHUIHQ :HUQHUKlOWVLFKDXIGHUDQGHUHQ6HLWHGHUEUHLWHQ3URPH QDGHXQGJHKWYRUEHU(UELHJWLQHLQHQ6HLWHQZHJHLQXQG EOHLEWDQHLQHP5RQGHOOVWHKHQEHLGHP:LQQLH]XLKPVW|W )U$XHQVWHKHQGHLVWGDVHLQH]XIlOOLJH%HJHJQXQJZLHPDQ VLHLP.XUSDUNMHGHQ$XJHQEOLFNHUOHEW ª$OOHVLQ2UGQXQJ©VDJW:LQQLHXQGOlW:HUQHUGDPLW ZLVVHQGDLKPQLHPDQGJHIROJWLVWª,FKELQQLFKWIUKHU ZHJJHNRPPHQ:REUHQQWHVGHQQ"© ª2EHUVW%ULQNPDQQLVWWRW©(UYHUEHVVHUWVLFKªLVW HUPRUGHWZRUGHQ8QGLFKKDEHGLH/HLFKHJHIXQGHQLP $XIWUDJ:LHVHQHFNV© 6LHOlFKHOWLKQDQXQGKDNWVLFKORFNHUEHLLKPHLQ'HU 5LONHEDQGLVWLQLKUHU8PKlQJHWDVFKHYHUVFKZXQGHQ,Q HLQHPVDQGIDUEHQHQ6WUDHQNRVWPYRQGHPVLFKLKUNXS IHUURWHV+DDUDWWUDNWLYDEKHEWVLHKWVLHVHKUHOHJDQWXQG IUDXOLFKDXV:RKOJHIlOOLJEHWUDFKWHQ]ZHLDOWH'DPHQDP :HJHGLHEHLGHQXQGVLQGVLFKHLQLJGDGDVHLQVFK|QHV3DDU VHL*HQDXGLHVHU(LQGUXFNVROOHUZHFNWZHUGHQ ª'LHVSDQLVFKHQ6WFNH©YRQ)LVFKHUWU|SIHOWHQVFKRQ XQDXVJHVHW]WDXVGHQ/DXWVSUHFKHUQGHVª5HLFKVUXQGIXQNV© DOV:HUQHU%UHGHEXVFKQRFKHLQ-XQJHZDUXQGPHLQWH6FKXO DUEHLWHQQLFKWRKQH5DGLRPXVLNPDFKHQ]XN|QQHQ-HW]W
VSLHOWVLHGDV.XURUFKHVWHUEHLVHLQHUDEHQGOLFKHQ6HUHQDGH DEHUGLH0HORGLHQNOLQJHQQXUOHLVHKHUEHUXQGVW|UHQQLFKW :HUQHU%UHGHEXVFKEHULFKWHW:LQQLHXQWHUEULFKWLKQQLFKW 6LHKlOWDXFKGDV/lFKHOQIHVWGDVVLHWUlJWVHLWVLH$UPLQ $UPPLWLKPJHKW'LHEHLGHQ.XQGVFKDIWHUN|QQHQVLFKRIIHQ PLWHLQDQGHUVHKHQODVVHQVHLWVLHVLFKHLQPDOEHLHLQHP RIIL]LHOOHQ(PSIDQJGHU3XEOLF5HODWLRQV$EWHLOXQJYRQ :HJHQHU 0RVVEHJHJQHWXQGHLQDQGHUYRUJHVWHOOWZRUGHQ VLQG'DIUJLEWHVHLQH0HQJH=HXJHQ2EHUVWD'.U|VLQJ HLQJHVFKORVVHQXQGQLHPDQGNDQQHWZDVGDEHLILQGHQGDGHU JXWDXVVHKHQGH/XIWZDIIHQRIIL]LHUPLWGHQHUJUDXHQGHQ 6FKOlIHQ-XQJJHVHOOHREHQGUHLQGLHVRHQWVWDQGHQH%H NDQQWVFKDIWPLWGHUFKDUPDQWHQ)RWRJUDILQJHOHJHQWOLFK SIOHJW*HOHJHQWOLFKVLHPDFKHQQXUVSDUVDPYRQGHU 0|JOLFKNHLW]X%HJHJQXQJHQLQGHUgIIHQWOLFKNHLW*HEUDXFK $XFKGDVJHK|UW]XUNRQVSLUDWLYHQ$UEHLW(VPXYHUKLQGHUW ZHUGHQGDHLQHUGHQDQGHUHQP|JOLFKHUZHLVHJHIlKUGHW :HGHUGHU0LOLWlULVFKH$EVFKLUPGLHQVWQRFKGDV%XQGHVDPW IU9HUIDVVXQJVVFKXW]VFKODIHQXQGJLEWHVEHLLKQHQHUVW HLQPDOGHQ$QIOXJHLQHV9HUGDFKWVGDQQIDQJHQVLHLQVJHKHLP XQGXQEHPHUNWVRIRUWDQGDV8PIHOGGHUDXIV.RUQJH QRPPHQHQ3HUVRQV\VWHPDWLVFK]XGXUFKOHXFKWHQ)OFKWLJH %HNDQQWVFKDIWHQQDVFK|QGLHKDWMHGHU$EHUEHLPHKU 8QG:LQQLH:LQNHOPDQQLVWIUGLH9HUELQGXQJ:HUQHU %UHGHEXVFKVPLWGHQ*HQRVVHQLQ%HUOLQYHUDQWZRUWOLFKLVW VR]XVDJHQVHLQJXWHU*HLVWGDV%LQGHJOLHG]ZLVFKHQLKPXQG GHUVR]LDOLVWLVFKHQ+HLPDWDXFKHLQELFKHQ6FKXW]HQJHO =XJHJHEHQPDQFKPDOIlOOWLKPVHLQH=XUFNKDOWXQJJDUQLFKW OHLFKW (LQH3DXVHHQWVWHKW6LHVFKOHQGHUQXPGHQ7HLFKKHUXP XQGJHKHQDQGHP6HLWHQIOJHOGHV7KLHUVFKHQ.XUKDXVHV HQWODQJLQGHPGLH6SLHOEDQNLKUH5RXOHWWHWLVFKHKDWª)DLWH YRWUHMHX[5LHQQHYDSOXV0DFKHQ6LH,KU6SLHO1LFKWV JHKWPHKU©(LQKQHQKDIWHU3I|UWQHULQHLQHU2SHUHWWHQOLYUHH JUHLIWVFKRQQDFKGHU7UNOLQNHDEHU:LQQLHXQG:HUQHU JHKHQYRUEHU'HU6SLHOEDQNEHVXFKHUPXHLQH.DUWHHU
ZHUEHQXQGVLFKOHJLWLPLHUHQHUZLUGUHJLVWULHUW'LHEHLGHQ ZROOHQLKUHQ%HVXFKLQ:LHVEDGHQQLFKWDNWHQNXQGLJJHPDFKW VHKHQ ª1DWUOLFKJLEWHVPDQFKPDO8QIlOOHPLW-DJGZDIIHQ©VDJW :LQQLH:LQNHOPDQQVFKOLHOLFKJHGHKQWª$XFKHUIDKUHQH :HLGPlQQHUVLQGGDYRUQLFKWVLFKHU'DVZHLMHGHU,QVRIHUQ LVWGLH*HVFKLFKWHUHFKWJHVFKLFNWHLQJHIlGHOW:HQQPDQ QLFKWVEHU%ULQNPDQQZWHGRFKVR(LQ0DQQVWHOOWVLFK TXHU6LFKHUOLFKKDWPDQYHUVXFKWLKQ]XP(LQVFKZHQNHQ]X EHZHJHQ9HUJHEOLFK(UEOLHEGHU6WHLQLP:HJ8QGGLHVHQ :HJZROOWHPDQIUHLKDEHQ© :HUQHUQLFNWª$OVRYHUIXKUPDQQDFKNODVVLVFKHP9RUELOG 'LH*HVFKLFKWHNHQQWYLHOH%HLVSLHOHlKQOLFKHU$UW'HQNQXU DQ%DUWKRX'HUIUDQ]|VLVFKH$XHQPLQLVWHUZXUGHYLHU XQGGUHLLJYRQ$JHQWHQ+LWOHUVHUPRUGHWZHLOHUIUHLQ %QGQLVVHLQHV/DQGHVPLWGHU6RZMHWXQLRQHLQWUDW,Q 0DUVHLOOH© 6LHVWUDKOWLKQDQ9RQZHLWHPZLUNWGDVDOVZROOHGLH)UDX LKUHP3DUWQHUJHUDGHHWZDVEHVRQGHUV/LHEHVVDJHQ6WDWW GHVVHQEHVWlWLJWVLHPLWGHU(UZlKQXQJGHV$WWHQWDWVYRQ 0DUVHLOOHKDEH:HUQHUEHUHLWVGLH*U|HQRUGQXQJDQJHGHX WHWXQGGHQ6WHOOHQZHUWGHQVLHGHPª)DOO%ULQNPDQQ©]X PHVVHQPWHQ1DWUOLFKJHKHQGLH/HXWHGHQHQGHU2EHUVW LP:HJHZDUEHU/HLFKHQ'RFKHVOLHJWDXFKLQLKUHP ,QWHUHVVHQLFKWEHUPlLJDXIVLFKDXIPHUNVDP]XPDFKHQ -HGRFKLVW0RUGGDVOHW]WH0LWWHOXQGLPPHUHLQ5LVLNRVR ODQJHHVKHOOK|ULJH/HXWHJLEWGLHQDFKGHQ+LQWHUJUQGHQ VXFKHQ:lUHGDVGXUFK%ULQNPDQQHQWVWDQGHQH3UREOHP GXUFKHLQHHKUHQYROOH3HQVLRQLHUXQJGHV2EHUVWHQDXVGHU :HOW]XVFKDIIHQJHZHVHQKlWWHPDQHVDXIGLHVH:HLVH EHUHLQLJW ª'DPLWZlUH%ULQNPDQQQLFKWDEJHKDOWHQZRUGHQVHLQH 7KHVHYRPhEHUJDQJVFKDUDNWHUGHUJHJHQZlUWLJHQ/XIWZDIIH ZHLWHU]XYHUWUHWHQ(UZROOWHHLQH/XIWZDIIHGLHVLHJWZHQQ VLHDQJUHLIW9RQVHLQHP6WDQGSXQNWDXVZDUGDVGXUFKDXV ORJLVFKHUKDWWHMDVHLQH(UIDKUXQJHQ2EZRKO©
ª-D"©HUPXQWHUW:LQQLH ª,FKNHQQHVHLQH%HZHJJUQGHQLFKWXQQDKEDUZLHHUVLFK JDEDEHUhEHUJDQJVFKDUDNWHUKLQRGHUKHUQDWUOLFKLVW GLHVH/XIWZDIIHHLQJHIlKUOLFKHV,QVWUXPHQWXQGGXUFKDXVLQ GHU/DJHLQQHUKDOEGHU1$72JHZLVVH$XIJDEHQ]XHUIOOHQ 'DVKDWHUPLQGHVWHQVVRJXWJHZXWZLHZLU:DVZROOWHHU GHQQPHKU"© 6LHEOHLEHQDQHLQHP6SULQJEUXQQHQVWHKHQ,QGHVVHQ %HFNHQJLEWHV*ROGILVFKHGLHEHKlELJEHUIWWHUWXQGIHWW LKUH.UHLVH]LHKHQ$OVGLH6FKDWWHQGHUEHLGHQ0HQVFKHQDXIV :DVVHUIDOOHQNRPPHQVLHJOHLFKQlKHUª'LH1LHGHUODJHQGHU EHLGHQ:HOWNULHJHDXV]XPHU]HQXQGLKUH(UJHEQLVVH]X NRUULJLHUHQGDUDXI]LHOWHHUZRKO©ZLUIWGLH)RWRJUDILQKLQ ª8QGHUZROOWHHVYHUPXWOLFKHQWVFKHLGHQGYRQGHQHLJHQHQ /HXWHQJHWDQVHKHQ$PGHXWVFKHQ:HVHQVROOGLH:HOW JHQHVHQ© :HUQHUVWW]WVLFKDXIGLH6DQGVWHLQIDVVXQJGHV%HFNHQV ª'DVLVWGLHHLQH6HLWH©VDJWHUª(UVWHKWPLWVHLQHU7KHRULH QLFKWHLQPDODOOHLQ'DVKDWGHQ0RUGQLFKWDXVJHO|VWZHQQ GXPLFKIUDJVW,FKHULQQHUHPLFKJHQDXDQVHLQH:RUWHGD HVQRFKDQGHUH0LWWHOJlEHVHLQHLQGHUEHZXWHQ9RUODJH QLHGHUJHOHJWHQ(UNHQQWQLVVH]XYHUWUHWHQXQGGDVPXGHU +DNHQVHLQ©(UZHQGHWVLFK:LQQLH]Xª'LH%ULVDQ]GHU 6LWXDWLRQLVWEHNDQQW'LHXQYHUEHVVHUOLFKHQ2VWODQGUHLWHUXQG LKUH(SLJRQHQEHUVFKODJHQVLFK'LH9HUWHXIHOXQJGHVVR ]LDOLVWLVFKHQ/DJHUVKDWHLQQLHJHNDQQWHV$XVPDHUUHLFKW .HLQH=HLWXQJXQGNHLQH5DGLRVHQGXQJPHKURKQHGLH3KUDVH YRQGHU%HIUHLXQJGHU%UGHUXQG6FKZHVWHUQLQGHU2VW ]RQH!'HU)ULHGHKlQJWDQHLQHPVHLGHQHQ)DGHQ,QGLHVHU /DJHNDQQPDQQLFKW]XODVVHQGDGDV%LOGYRQGHU6FKODJ NUDIWGHU%XQGHVZHKUXQGLKUHU)OLHJHUYHUElQGHLQLUJHQG HLQHU:HLVHDXFKQXUDQJHNUDW]WZLUGLQDOOHUgIIHQWOLFKNHLW ZRP|JOLFK© ª+DWHUGLH.RQVHTXHQ]VHLQHV9HUKDOWHQVQLFKWYRUDXV VHKHQN|QQHQ"© ª1DWUOLFKKDWHU©HUZLGHUW:HUQHUWURFNHQª$EHUVROFKH
/HXWHZLHGHU2EHUVWKDEHQHLQHQEHVRQGHUHQ(KUHQNRGH[ 'HQNHDQGHQ.DSLWlQGHUHEHQPLWVHLQHP6FKLIIXQWHUJHKHQ PXZHQQHUQLFKWGDV*HVLFKWYHUOLHUHQZLOO%ULQNPDQQKDW ]XPLQGHVWJHDKQWZDVDXILKQ]XNRPPHQZUGH7URW]GHP (UKDWVHLQHQ7RGHLQNDONXOLHUWMDYLHOOHLFKWVRJDULQ5HFK QXQJJHVWHOOWGDHUVHLQHP&UHGR]XVlW]OLFK*HZLFKWYHU OHLKHQZHUGH© :LQQLHZLUIWHLQ6WHLQFKHQLQV:DVVHU6ROFKH%HKDQGOXQJ P|JHQGLH*ROGILVFKHQLFKW6LH]LHKHQVLFK]XUFNª8QGZR EHILQGHWVLFK%ULQNPDQQV9HUPlFKWQLV"© ª'DVLVWKLHUGLH)UDJH©EHVWlWLJW:HUQHUª=ZHLIHOORV ZXWHGHU2EHUVWPHKUDOVZLUDOOH]XVDPPHQ(UKDWWH=XJDQJ ]X*HKHLPGRVVLHUVXQG]X3ODQXQJVXQWHUODJHQGLHHLQHUZLH LFKEHVWHQIDOOVLPYHUVLHJHOWHQ8PVFKODJYRQ=LPPHU]X =LPPHUWUDJHQGDUI$XHU+DXVHEHI|UGHUWVLHQXUGHU .XULHUGLHQVWXQGGDVP|JOLFKVWQRFKPLW)HOGMlJHUHVNRUWH 'XUFKDXVZDKUVFKHLQOLFKGDHVLQVHLQHP&UHGR%H]JHDXI VROFKH3OlQHJLEWPLW$QJDEHYRQ6WUDH+DXVQXPPHUXQG SUl]LVHQ'DWHQ'HVKDOEKDWGHU0LOLWlULVFKH$EVFKLUPGLHQVW LP%ORFNKDXVGDQDFKJHVXFKW© :LQQLH:LQNHOPDQQV%OLFNIROJWGHU:DVVHUIRQWlQHELV KLQDXI]XLKUHU6SLW]H'LHJOLW]HUWVLOEULJLQGHU$EHQGVRQQH XQGVWHKWKHOOJHJHQGHQEODXHQ+LPPHOª2KQHHV]XILQ GHQ© ª:HQLJVWHQVVRODQJHLFKGRUWZDU8QGDXFKEHL:LHVHQHFN NDPZlKUHQGGHV(VVHQVNHLQHHQWVSUHFKHQGH%HQDFKULFKWL JXQJ+lWWHGHU*HQHUDOHLQH(UIROJVPHOGXQJHUKDOWHQVR ZlUHHVLKPDQ]XVHKHQJHZHVHQ© 'LH)RWRJUDILQVFKDXWQRFKLPPHUQDFKREHQª'DV'RNX PHQWZUGHXQVQW]HQ©VDJWVLHJDQ]OHLFKWKLQª(VZUGH XQVVRJDUVHKUKHOIHQJODXEHLFK© 'HU.XQGVFKDIWHUKROWWLHI/XIW6HKUJOFNOLFKZLUNWHU QLFKWLQGLHVHP$XJHQEOLFN:LQQLHV6FKOXIROJHUXQJLVWOR JLVFKDEHU0LWGHU8QWHUVXFKXQJVJUXSSHª%RQQHLQV©KDW YRQ:LHVHQHFNVLFKHUGLHEHVWHQ/HXWH]XP%ORFNKDXVLQ 0DUVFKJHVHW]WEHUGLHGHU0$'LQGHUª+DXSWVWDGW©YHU
IJW8QGZRVLHELVKHUPLWLKUHQ6SH]LDONHQQWQLVVHQXQGLQ YROOHU/HJDOLWlWQLFKWVDXVJHULFKWHWKDEHQVROO:HUQHU%UH GHEXVFKLQVJHKHLPXQGLOOHJDOHUIROJUHLFKVHLQ"$EHUGD]XLVW HUMDKLHUª+DOOHOXMD©VDJWHUVHXI]HQGXQGVLHKWHLQHP VFKZDU]KDDULJHQ0lGFKHQQDFKGDVPLWZLHJHQGHQ+IWHQ ]XU6SLHOEDQNKLQEHUJHKWª/LDQHDXVGHP8UZDOG]XUFN© ODXWHWHKHXWHIUKHLQH=HLWXQJVDQQRQFHª+DWQRFK7HUPLQH IUHL©1DMD'LHGDGUEHQVLHKWMHGHQIDOOVVHKUKEVFKDXV ª,FKZHUGHHVYHUVXFKHQ:LQQLH9LHO+RIIQXQJKDEHLFK QLFKW6LFKHUOLFKELHWHWGDV%ULQNPDQQ3DSLHUHLQSDDUJXWH =XVDW]LQIRUPDWLRQHQYLHOOHLFKWVRJDUZHUWYROOHEOR© 'LH)RWRJUDILQQLPPWZLHGHUVHLQHQ$UPXQGIKUWLKQYRP 6SULQJEUXQQHQIRUW'HU.XUSDUNLVWLPPHUQRFKEHOHEWDEHU GLH6FKDUGHU6SD]LHUJlQJHUOLFKWHWVLFKDOOPlKOLFK(VZLUG VWLOOHU'LHDEHQGOLFKH6HUHQDGHYHUNODQJ'LH0XVLNHUKDEHQ GHQ0XVLNSDYLOORQYHUODVVHQ%HVFKDXOLFKNHLWEUHLWHWVLFKDXV 'LH0HKU]DKOGHU%HVXFKHUJHKWQDFK+DXVHPLWGHUhEHU ]HXJXQJHLQHQVFK|QHQXQGIULHGYROOHQ1DFKPLWWDJYHUEUDFKW ]XKDEHQ$KQHQGLH/HXWHZLHWUJHULVFKGLHEUHLWH%H KlELJNHLWLKUHV6RQQWDJVLVW":ROOHQVLHGDVEHUKDXSWZLVVHQ" 'LHPHLVWHQZDKUVFKHLQOLFKQLFKW6LHVLQGJDQ]EHVFKlIWLJW PLWGHP.DPSIXPHLQHQ/RJHQSODW]LQGHU:RKOVWDQGV JHVHOOVFKDIWDXVJHEXFKWPLWGHU*LHUQDFK%HVLW]XQG6HOEVW EHKDXSWXQJXQGEHVWUHEWGXUFKKHIWLJHQ*HEUDXFKGHU(OOHQ ERJHQLQGLH&KHIHWDJHXQGGDPLW]XP3ODW]DQGHU6RQQH DXI]XVWHLJHQ'HQQDXI]XVWHLJHQLVWDOOHV]XEHVLW]HQLVWDOOHV QXUZHULP:RKOVWDQGOHEWOHEWDQJHQHKP'LHVHV.RQVXP GHQNHQEULQJWHLQHHUVFKUHFNHQGH2EHUIOlFKOLFKNHLWLQSROL WLVFKHQ'LQJHQPLWVLFK0LWGHUHLJHQHQ3HUVRQXQGGHP HLJHQHQ-REKDWPDQJHQXJ]XWXQXP3ROLWLNVROOHQVLFKGRFK ELWWHGLHNPPHUQGLHGDIUEH]DKOWZHUGHQ8QGGDVWXQVLH GHQQDXFKXQGGLH9HUJHOLFKNHLWGHU/HXWHNRPPWLKQHQVHKU HQWJHJHQ:HUGHQNWVFKRQLQGHU%OWH]HLWGHV:LUWVFKDIWV ZXQGHUVQRFKGDUDQGDHUVLFKHLQPDOJHVFKZRUHQKDWOLHEHU VHLQ/HEHQODQJWURFNHQHV%URW]XHVVHQDOVQRFKHLQPDOGLH 6FKUHFNHQGHU%RPEHQQlFKWH]XHUOHEHQ"0DQLVWMDZLHGHU
ZHUXQGIKOWVLFKJURXQGPlFKWLJPLWGHQ$PHULNDQHUQLP 5FNHQ :HUQHU%UHGHEXVFKKDWGLHVHV/DQGKLHUJUQGOLFKVDWW(U LVWODQJHJHQXJKLHUXPYRP&KURPJODQ]GHU/X[XVOLPRXVL QHQXQGGHQJUHOOHQ)DUEHQGHU1HRQOLFKWHUQLFKWPHKU JHEOHQGHW]XZHUGHQ'D]XZDUHQLKP]XWLHIH%OLFNHKLQWHU GLH)DVVDGHP|JOLFKGD]XKDWHUGLH5HVWDXUDWLRQYHUGHUE OLFKHQDOWHQ8QJHLVWHVFKDXYLQLVWLVFKHUXQGUHYDQFKLVWLVFKHU 3UlJXQJ]XKDXWQDKPLWHUOHEW8QGGDVVROODXIGLH'DXHUHLQH 3HUVSHNWLYHKDEHQ" 6LHJHKHQQRFKHLQ6WFN:HJHVJHPHLQVDPGDQQWUHQQHQ VLHVLFK(LQH]XIlOOLJH%HJHJQXQJXQGHLQH6WXQGHIUHXQG OLFKHQ*HGDQNHQDXVWDXVFKHV]ZLVFKHQDOWHQ%HNDQQWHQVLQG ]X(QGHJHJDQJHQ:HUVROOWHGDUDQHWZDVYHUGlFKWLJILQ GHQ" :LQQLHZHQGHWVLFKDOOHLQGHP$XVJDQJGHV.XUSDUNV]X XQGOlXIW]XGHPHQWIHUQWHQ3DUNSODW]DXIGHPLKU$XWRVWHKW 'HU0RWRULVWQRFKZDUPHVZDUHLQNXU]HU$XIHQWKDOWLQ :LHVEDGHQ9RUKLQZDUHQGLH6WUDHQOHHU-HW]WTXlOWVLFKGHU JURH%0:LQPLWWHQGHU%OHFKODZLQHYRQ6RQQWDJVDXVIOJ OHUQGDKLQGLHDXIGHP+HLPZHJVLQG'LH)RWRJUDILQZlKOW VFKRQ1HEHQVWUDHQXPEHVVHUYRUDQ]XNRPPHQDEHUVR VFKODXVLQGDQGHUHDXFK6LHIJWVLFKLQV8QYHUPHLGOLFKH,KUH hEHUOHJXQJHQNUHLVHQXP:HUQHUV%HULFKW(LQZHLWHUHU6WHLQ IUGDV0RVDLNELOGGDVGLH$XINOlUXQJ]XVDPPHQVHW]WXQG IRUWZlKUHQGDXIGHQQHXHVWHQ6WDQGEULQJWLVWGDV1LFKW PHKU"$XIMHGHQ)DOOZLFKWLJJHQXJGHU6DFKHQDFK ]XJHKHQ :HUQHU%UHGHEXVFKEHWULWWGDV.XUKDXVUHVWDXUDQWEHVWHOOW HLQ$EHQGHVVHQXQGEOlWWHUWVFKHLQEDUGXUFKDXVPLWGHU:HOW ]XIULHGHQlXHUOLFKHLQEHWXFKWHU%UJHUPLWXQJHEURFKHQHP 6HOEVWZHUWJHIKOJHODVVHQLP:LHVEDGHQHUª.XULHU©8QG ZLHGHUHLQPDOHLQ5HJLHUXQJVOFRPPXQLTXHPLWGHU)RUGHUXQJ DQGLH.DXIOHXWHGLHª2VW]RQH©]XER\NRWWLHUHQ)RWRVYRQ .RQUDG$GHQDXHUXQG9L]HNDQ]OHU(UKDUG:HUQHUVFKLHEW GDV%ODWWYRQVLFK
(UEOHLEWELVGHU5FNVWURPDXIGHQ6WUDHQDENOLQJW'DQQ HUVWIlKUWHUXQGGLH/LFKWNHJHOGHU6FKHLQZHUIHUKHEHQ QXQPHKUGDV*UDXGHV$VSKDOWVDXVGHU'XQNHOKHLW(UOlW VLFK=HLW1XQHUVWVSUWHUZLHDEJHVSDQQWXQGPGHHULVW $OVHULQGHU7LHIJDUDJHGHV1HXEDXVDXVVWHLJWLQGHPHUHLQH =ZHL]LPPHU.RPIRUWZRKQXQJJHPLHWHWKDWUHFNWHUVLFKXQG JlKQW'DVZDUHLQ6RQQWDJPLWYROOHP3URJUDPP 'HQ)DKUVWXKOGHULKQLQGHQVLHEHQWHQ6WRFNEULQJWEH QXW]HQDXFKDQGHUH0LHWHU0DQJUWVLFKXQGVFKZHLJWVLFK DQPDQNHQQWVLFKQLFKWMHGHUKDWJHQXJPLWVLFKVHOEVW]X WXQ 'LH:RKQXQJVWUNODSSW]X/LFKW$OOH7UHQVLQGJH|II QHWELVDXIGDV7LFNHQHLQHU8KULVWDOOHVVWLOO7URW]GHP VFKDOWHW:HUQHUEHUDOOGLH%HOHXFKWXQJHLQXQGJHKWHUVW HLQPDOGXUFKGLHJHVDPWH%HKDXVXQJ'DVPXWHWDQZLHHLQ 5LWXDO(VLVWDXFKHLQV6FKOLHOLFKLVW$FKLP'HWMHQQLFKWQXU HLQEHOLHELJHU0DMRUGHU%XQGHVOXIWZDIIHHULVWHEHQVRJXWGHU ''5.XQGVFKDIWHU:HUQHU%UHGHEXVFKGHUVLFK8QDXI PHUNVDPNHLWXQG/HLFKWVLQQQLFKWOHLVWHQNDQQ'DHUQRFK QLFKWHQWWDUQWZRUGHQLVWXQGLQDOOGHQ-DKUHQVHLQHUJHIDKU YROOHQ$UEHLWNHLQHQ9HUGDFKWDXIVLFKJH]RJHQKDWGDQNWHU QLFKW]XOHW]WVHLQHU6HOEVWGLV]LSOLQVRYLHO.UDIWXQGhEHU ZLQGXQJVLHJHOHJHQWOLFKDXFKNRVWHW :HUQHU%UHGHEXVFKHUEODW(UVLHKWHLQ]ZHLWHVPDOKLQ 1HLQHLQ,UUWXPLVWDXVJHVFKORVVHQ'LH+DDUVLFKHUXQJDQGHU PLWWOHUHQ6FKUHLEWLVFKVFKXEODGHLVW]HUVW|UW'DV+DDUKlQJW KHUDE:HULPPHULQVHLQHU$EZHVHQKHLWGHQ6FKUHLEWLVFK JH|IIQHWKDWDFKWHWHQLFKWDXIGDVZLH]XIlOOLJ]ZLVFKHQ)K UXQJVVFKLHQHXQG/DGHHLQJHNOHPPWH+DDU 'DV)DFKLVWRUGQXQJVJHPlYHUVFKORVVHQ'HU0HFKDQLV PXVVFKOLHWVLFKZLHLPPHUQLFKWVGHXWHWDXIHLQHQIUHPGHQ RGHUJDUJHZDOWVDPHQ(LQJULIIKLQ8QGGULQLVWDXFKDOOHV XQYHUlQGHUWDOOHVOLHJWDQVHLQHP3ODW]1LFKWHLQPDOGHU 8PVFKODJPLWGHQGUHLKXQGHUWIQI]LJ0DUNIHKOW+LHUZDUHQ GHPQDFK3URILVDP:HUNDEHUQLFKWYRQGHUNULPLQHOOHQ 6RUWH'LHVHª)LOLJUDQWHFKQLNHU©KDEHQHWZDVDQGHUHVJH VXFKW:DV"
%UHGHEXVFKJLHWVLFKHLQHQ0DJHQELWWHUHLQXQGWULQNWLKQ LQNOHLQHQ6FKOXFNHQ,QGHU7DWGLHhEHUUDVFKXQJLVWLKPDXI GHQ0DJHQJHVFKODJHQ'DQXW]WHVQLFKWVGLHDEVROXWH*H ZLKHLW]XKDEHQGDHVLQGLHVHU:RKQXQJQLFKWVJLEWZDV LKQEHODVWHQN|QQWH'DUDXIDFKWHWHUVRUJVDP 6RVWHKWHUODQJHHLQ)UHPGHULQGHQHLJHQHQYLHU:lQGHQ XQGODXVFKWGHP7LFNHQGHU8KU :DUXP"$XIGLHVH)UDJHEOHLEWHUVLFKGLH$QWZRUWVFKXOGLJ (LQª:HU"©LVWOHLFKWHU]XHUNOlUHQ3ROL]LVWHQNRPPHQRIIL ]LHOOXQGPLW+DXVVXFKXQJVEHIHKOHQ'DVGDLVW*HKHLPGLHQVW DUEHLW8QGGHU$QOD" (UVHW]WVLFKKLQ(UVFKUDXEWPHFKDQLVFKGLH0XVFKHOYRP 7HOHIRQK|UHU1HLQHLQHª:DQ]H©LVWKLHUQLFKWHLQJHEDXW ZRUGHQ,KPLVWJDUQLFKWZRKOLQVHLQHU+DXW:DVLVWGDLP *DQJH"$XIHLQPDOKDWHUGDV*HIKOGDLKQGLH:lQGH EHODXHUQ%XFKUFNHQLKQDEVFKlW]HQGPXVWHUQGLHZHLH DXJHQORVH*HVLFKWVPDVNHGLHHUGDPDOVDXV3RUWXJDOPLW JHEUDFKWKDWLKQKlPLVFKDQJULQVW %ORNHLQH3DQLN6LFKQLFKWGXUFK1HUYRVLWlWYHUUDWHQ 1LFKW]XHUNHQQHQJHEHQGDHUHLQH6SXUGHU/HXWHHQWGHFNW KDWGLH:HUWGDUDXIOHJWHQXQEHPHUNW]XEOHLEHQ(UKDWVLH QLFKWZDKUJHQRPPHQHULVWJDQ]XQEHIDQJHQ (UJHKW]XP)HUQVHKHUXQGVFKDOWHWLKQHLQ(LQJHZ|KQ OLFKHU6RQQWDJDEHQG $EHUGLH)UDJHQEOHLEHQ
'LHVH0KOHVWHKW]ZDUDQHLQHPUDXVFKHQGHQ%DFKDEHUVLH NODSSHUWQLFKW'DV0KOUDGLVWWURFNHQXQGKDWLP$XJHQEOLFN OHGLJOLFKGHNRUDWLYHQ&KDUDNWHU'DV:DVVHUZLUGHUVWZLHGHU GDUDXIJHOHLWHWZHUGHQZHQQGLH5HQRYLHUXQJGHV$XVIOXJV KRWHOVª=XU0KOH©DEJHVFKORVVHQLVWXQGGDV+DXVQHXHU |IIQHWVHLQZLUG-HW]WVLQGQRFK/HLWHUQXQG%DXJHUVWHGD
%DONHQOLHJHQDXIHLQHP6WDSHOXQGGHU*HVDPWHLQGUXFNLVW ]LHPOLFKZVW (LQOHLVHU1DFKWZLQGKDWVLFKDXIJHPDFKW'DV0KOHQKRWHO OLHJWJDQ]GXQNHOGDXQGPXWHWYHUODVVHQDQPLWVHLQHQJH VFKORVVHQHQ)HQVWHUOlGHQ'HU(LQGUXFNWlXVFKW:HQQHLQHU JHQDXKLQVLHKWHQWGHFNWHUGDXQGGRUW/LFKWLQ5LW]HQGHU /lGHQXQGEHUGHP6FKRUQVWHLQ5DXFKGHQGHU1DFKWZLQG VFKQHOO]HUWHLOW5DVFKHU]LHKHQGLH:RONHQDP+LPPHOXQG JHEHQIU6HNXQGHQGLHVFKPDOH6LFKHOGHV0RQGHVIUHL'LH 7DQQHQULQJVXPEHXJHQGLH:LSIHO'DVbFK]HQGHVDUEHLWHQ GHQ+RO]HVLVWGDHLQ:DOGNDX]PHOGHWVLFKXQGGLHRIIHQHQ 7RUIOJHOGHUOHHUHQ*DUDJHVFKODJHQLQLKUHQ+DOWHUXQJHQ (LQHJXWH3ULYDWVWUDHGLHYRQGHU&KDXVVHH]ZLVFKHQ $VFKDIIHQEXUJXQG:U]EXUJLQGHQ6SHVVDUWKLQHLQDE]ZHLJW IKUWELVKLHUKHU'HU)DKUHUGHV:DJHQVGHVVHQ6FKHLQ ZHUIHU/LFKWEDKQHQLQGLH'XQNHOKHLWVFKLHEHQNHQQWVLFK DXV2KQH]X]|JHUQVWHXHUWHUEHUGHQOHHUHQ3DUNSODW] KLQZHJXQGJHQDXLQGLH*DUDJHKLQHLQ,PVHOEHQ0RPHQW YHUO|VFKHQGLH/LFKWHUXQGHLQKHPGVlUPOLJHU0DQQLVWGD GLH7RUIOJHO]XVFKOLHHQª,PNOHLQHQ6DDO+HUU%RUQ©VDJW HUQXU 9RQGHU*DUDJHDXVIKUWHLQH(LVHQWULQV+DXV'HU&KHI GHU5+(,10$,1'(7(.7(,LQ)UDQNIXUWJHKWHLQHQ PlLJHUKHOOWHQ*DQJKLQXQWHUXQG|IIQHWHLQH7URKQH DQ]XNORSIHQRGHUHLQª+HUHLQ©DE]XZDUWHQ'DQQEOHLEWHU VWHKHQ+LHULVWNHLQH/DPSHDQ1XUGDV.DPLQIHXHUEUHQQW LP5DXFKIDQJKHXOWGHU:LQGXQGGLHXQUXKLJHQ)ODPPHQ ZHUIHQ]XFNHQGHQ)HXHUVFKHLQEHUVFKZHUH(LFKHQP|EHO XQGVWHLQHUQH:lQGHª6LHKDEHQVLFKGUHLLJ6HNXQGHQYHU VSlWHW©VDJWHLQH6WLPPHKLQWHUGHUKRKHQ/HKQHHLQHVYRU GHQ.DPLQJHUFNWHQ6HVVHOVKHUYRUGLHEUFKLJH6WLPPH HLQHVDOWHQ0DQQHVGHUHVQLFKWJHZRKQWLVW]XZDUWHQ %RUQVHW]W]XHLQHUZRUWUHLFKHQ(QWVFKXOGLJXQJPLWZLGUL JHQ8PVWlQGHQDQGRFKGHUDQGHUHXQWHUEULFKWLKQJOHLFK ª*HVFKHQNW.DPHUDG%RUQ+LHUKHU1XQ"© 'HUVSlWH*DVWJHKWXPGHQ/HKQVHVVHOKHUXPª3ODQPlLJ
JHODXIHQ+HUU)ULWVFK©PHOGHWHUª'DV8UWHLOLVWYROOVWUHFNW© 'HU$OWHQLFNWJHODVVHQ'DVKDWHUHUZDUWHW(UEHXJWVLFK HLQZHQLJYRUXQGVWUHFNWVHLQHNQRFKLJHQ+lQGHQlKHUDQV )HXHU6HLQVFKPDOHVKDJHUHV*HVLFKWLVWXQEHZHJWDOVHULQ GLH)ODPPHQKLQHLQIUDJWª6LHKDEHQGDV3DSLHU":DVVWHKW GULQ"© ª(VZDUQLFKWLP%ORFNKDXV:LUKDEHQKLQWHUKHUHLQH JHQDXH'XUFKVXFKXQJJHPDFKW%ULQNPDQQPXHVDQ GHUVZR©%RUQEULFKWDE9RUGLHVHP$XJHQEOLFNKDWHUVLFK JHIUFKWHW)ULWVFKPDJ0LHUIROJHQLFKWGLHHPSILQGHWGHU &KHIGHU2'(66$DOVSHUV|QOLFKH%HOHLGLJXQJ(UZLUGGLH HUWHLOWH$XVNXQIWQLFKWKLQQHKPHQ8QZLOONUOLFKVWUDIIWVLFK GHU/HLWHUGHU5+(,10$,1'(7(.7(, )ULWVFKPXVWHUWLKQYRQREHQELVXQWHQ0HKUXQGPHKU GHQNWHUHUIOOWGLHVHU0HQVFKZHQLJHUGLH(UZDUWXQJHQGLH GLH2'(66$LQGHQ'LUHNWRULKUHV6LFKHUKHLWVGLHQVWHVVHW]W -HlOWHU%RUQZLUGGHVWREHTXHPHUZLUGHUDXFK=HLWVLFK QDFKHLQHP1DFKIROJHUXP]XVHKHQ0DQKDW%RUQGLH 5+(,10$,1'(7(.7(,QLFKWDQYHUWUDXWGDPLWHUVLHDOV DQJHQHKPH3IUQGHEHWUDFKWHWDXVGHUHU0LWWHOXQG=HLW IUVHLQH]DKOUHLFKHQ'DPHQEHNDQQWVFKDIWHQ]LHKW'DVLVWMD VFKRQHLQ.RPSOH[EHLLKP8QGKDWHUQLFKWHLQZHQLJ]XYLHOH )HKOVFKOlJHDXIVHLQHP.RQWR"6LFKHUGLHELOGHQGLH$XV QDKPHJHPHLQKLQLVWGLH2UJDQLVDWLRQPLWGHP$SSDUDW]X IULHGHQDEHUVFKRQHLQHLQ]LJHU)HKOVFKODJLVWLP3ULQ]LSHLQHU ]XYLHO8QGHVN|QQWHQPHKUZHUGHQZHQQPDQHVVFKOHSSHQ OlW(U)ULWVFKKDWLPPHUHLQHQVHFKVWHQ6LQQGDIUJHKDEW GHQ=HLWSXQNW]XHUNHQQHQDQGHPHLQ:HFKVHO:XQGHU ZLUNW'DV0DLVWYROO$OOHUGLQJVZRKHUQLPPWHUJOHLFK HLQHQ0DQQGHQHUVRIHVWLQGHU+DQGKDWXQGGHUVRVHKU VHLQ:HUN]HXJLVW"1LFKWVEHUVWU]HQ 'HU$OWHZHQGHWVLFK]XUFN]XP)HXHUXQGVWDUUWLQGLH *OXW(UVFKLHEWGLH5HFKWHXQWHUGDV6DNNRXQGPDVVLHUW EHKXWVDPGLH+HU]JHJHQG'LHVH6WLFKH6REDOGHUVLFKDXI UHJWVLQGVLHGDª,KUH6FKOXIROJHUXQJHQ"©IUDJWHUXQYHU PLWWHOW
%RUQZLUGVHKUHLIULJ=XQlFKVWXQWHUVWUHLFKWHUGLHHLJHQH 7FKWLJNHLWPLWGHU0LWWHLOXQJGDDXFKGLH8QWHUVXFKXQJV JUXSSHª%RQQHLQV©LP%ORFNKDXVQLFKWVJHIXQGHQKDEH'DV ZLVVHHUYRQ*HQHUDOYRQ:LHVHQHFN6LHVHLHQGDQQVRYHU EOLHEHQGDGHU*HQHUDOHVEHUQDKPGLH:RKQXQJ%ULQN PDQQV]XUlXPHQLQGHPHUGLH:LWZH]XLKUHP6RKQQDFK 5HJHQVEXUJEULQJHQOLH(UVLFKHUWHDXFK]XGDGHU0$' HUVWPRUJHQLQGHU:RKQXQJ1DFKVFKDXKDOWHQZHUGHGDPLW GLH5+(,10$,1'(7(.7(,9RUODXIKDEH,QGLHVHP $XJHQEOLFNXQGKLHUVFKDXW%RUQDXIGLH8KUVHLHQ +HU]RJ6FKZHGOHUXQG6SH]LDOLVWHQDQGHU$UEHLW9RQGHP (UJHEQLVZHUGH2'(66$VRIRUWXQWHUULFKWHW )ULWVFKQLPPWGDV]XU.HQQWQLV(UOlWGHQ%OLFNQLFKWYRQ GHQ)ODPPHQ,PPHUQRFKPDVVLHUWHUVHLQ+HU]ª:LHZDU HVPLW%ULQNPDQQ"©ZLOOHUZLVVHQ 6WDWWHLQHU$QWZRUW]LHKW%RUQDXVGHU,QQHQWDVFKHVHLQHV :LOGOHGHUMDFNHWWVHLQH6WHQRUHWWHHLQNOHLQHV7RQEDQGJHUlW (VLVWQLFKWJU|HUDOVHLQHOHNWULVFKHU5DVLHUDSSDUDWXQGKDOE VRKRFK(LQOHLVWXQJVIlKLJHV0LNURIRQZXUGHHLQJHEDXWGDV DXFKDOV/DXWVSUHFKHUIXQJLHUWZHQQPDQZLH%RUQMHW]WGHQ 3ODVWLNGHFNHOEHUGHQ6SXOHQ|IIQHW(LQH'DXPHQEHZHJXQJ GHU6FKDOWHUUFNWDXIª2Q©GDV*HUlWVSLHOW (VUHJQHWLQ6WU|PHQ6FKPDW]HQGH6FKULWWHDXIQDVVHP 0RRV(LQ0HWDOONORSIHUGU|KQW%RUQV6WLPPHUXIWª.DPH UDG%ULQNPDQQ©1RFKHLQPDOGHU.ORSIHU$XIHLQPDOJDQ] LQGHU1lKHHLQHDQGHUH6WLPPHª:ROOHQ6LH]XPLU"©'LH $QWZRUWª.DPHUDG%ULQNPDQQ,FKGDFKWHVFKRQLFKKDEH GLH)DKUWXPVRQVWJHPDFKW6DXZHWWHU©(LQ+XQGEHOOW ª.HLQH%DQJH%HOODLVWHLQ]lUWOLFKHV0lGFKHQXQGQXUDXI 1LHGHUZLOGVFKDUI© (LQH7UZLUGJH|IIQHWXQGZLHGHUJHVFKORVVHQ(LQHDQGHUH JHKWDXI%ULQNPDQQVDJWIUHXQGOLFKª*DQ]VFK|QQDELVWGX %HOOD%OHLEVWJOHLFKKLHU1DORVUHLQPLWGLU©(LQHZHLWHUH 7UGLHJH|IIQHWZLUGª%LWWH© ª'DUILFKUDXFKHQ"©HUNXQGLJWVLFK%RUQLP$XVIOXJVKRWHO ª=XU0KOH©QHUY|V:HLGHU7HXIHOVRDEJHEUKWNDQQ
NHLQHUVHLQGDHVLKQEHLGHUSUl]LVHQDNXVWLVFKHQ:LHGHU KROXQJHLQHUVROFKHQ6WXQGHQLFKWEHUPDQQW(UKDWHLQHQ 0DQQHUVFKRVVHQXQGZHQQHUDXFKPDQFKHVDXIVHLQHP .HUEKRO]KDWHLQEHUXIVPlLJHU.LOOHULVWHUQLFKW:HL*RWW HVLVWLKPQLFKWOHLFKWJHIDOOHQ$EHUZDVVROOWHHUPDFKHQ"(V ZDUHLQ%HIHKOYRQ)ULWVFK(UPXWHJHKRUFKHQHUPX LPPHUJHKRUFKHQ,KPEOHLEWNHLQHDQGHUH:DKOPHKU ª5DXFKHQ6LH©PXUPHOW)ULWVFKXQGOHKQWVLFK]XUFN(U OHJW]XHUVWGLH)LQJHUVSLW]HQXQGGDQQDXFKQRFKGLH+DQG IOlFKHQDQHLQDQGHU:HQQHUQXQQRFKGLH$XJHQVFKOLHWKDW HUGDV%LOGXQGGLH6]HQHGHXWOLFKYRUVLFK (UVFKOLHWGLH$XJHQ'DV%DQGOlXIW ª+EVFKKLHU:LUNOLFKKEVFK© (LQH)ODVFKHZLUGHQWNRUNW*OlVHUNOLUUHQDXIGHP7LVFK ª6LHVLQGGRFKQLFKWKLHUKHUJHNRPPHQXPPHLQ%ORFNKDXV ]XEHVLFKWLJHQ.DPHUDG%RUQ© ª1DWUOLFKQLFKW2EHUJUXSSHQIKUHU)ULWVFKKDWPLFKJH EHWHQ© 6HKUWURFNHQHQWJHJQHW%ULQNPDQQª'DVKHLW6LHEULQJHQ PLUGLH(LQODGXQJ]XU2'(66$7DJXQJ,FKKDEHPLFKVFKRQ JHZXQGHUW6LHLVWOlQJVWEHUIlOOLJ7ULQNHQ6LH%HLVROFKHP :HWWHUKlOWHLQJXWHU.RJQDN/HLEXQG6HHOH]XVDPPHQ© 1DFKHLQHUZLQ]LJHQ3DXVHVDJW%RUQª(LQVDPH*HJHQG KLHU© %ULQNPDQQKXVWHWª0LUJHIlOOWVLH1LUJHQGZROlWHVVLFK VRJXWQDFKGHQNHQZLHLQGHU(LQVDPNHLW,FKDUEHLWHDQ PHLQHQ.ULHJVHULQQHUXQJHQZLVVHQ6LH"'HU/XIWNULHJDXV GHU6LFKWGHV*HQHUDOVWDEHV©(VJLEWHLQVFKDUUHQGHV *HUlXVFKDOVREHLQ6WXKOJHUFNWZUGHª$OVR":RLVWGLH (LQODGXQJ"© 'DUDXIJHKW%RUQQLFKWHLQ0LWHLQHPQHXHQ$QVDW] JOHLFKVDPJHVFKlIWVPlLJHUNOlUWHUª.DPHUDG)ULWVFKLVW]X 2KUHQJHNRPPHQGD6LH6RUJHQKDEHQ:LUZUGHQ,KQHQ JHUQKHOIHQ'HVKDOEELQLFKKLHU© 1HXHUOLFKUFNWHLQ6WXKO6FKULWWHJHKHQKLQXQGKHU ª'DVLVWHV":HQQLFK6LHUHFKWYHUVWHKH%RUQVLQG6LH
YHUJDWWHUWPLFK]XU2UGQXQJ]XUXIHQ"/DVVHQ6LHPLFK DXVUHGHQ6LHVROOHQPLFKGDUDQHULQQHUQGDLFKGHU 2'(66$DXI*HGHLKXQG9HUGHUEYHUVFKZRUHQELQXQGGD %HVFKOVVHGHU2UJDQLVDWLRQIUPLFKELQGHQGVLQG,VWHVVR"© ª-DGDVLVWVR© 'LH6FKULWWHK|UHQDXI%ULQNPDQQLVWVWHKHQJHEOLHEHQ ª$XIGHXWVFKJHVDJW,FKKDEHGDV0DXO]XKDOWHQ© ª$XIJXWGHXWVFKJHVDJW-D© $EHUPDOVUFNWHLQ6WXKO,QGLHODXIHQGH7RQEDQGZLHGHU JDEHKLQHLQHUNOlUW%RUQ)ULWVFKª,FKKDWWHGDV*HIKOGD HUHWZDVDKQWH(UVDKPHKUIDFK]XVHLQHP-DJGJHZHKUKLQ EHUGDVDP6FKUHLEVHNUHWlUOHKQWH,FKGDFKWHMHGHVPDOHU ZUGHJHKHQXQGGDV*HZHKU]XVHLQHQDQGHUHQLQGHQ*H ZHKUVFKUDQNVWHOOHQ1LFKWVGDYRQ'DKDEHLFKEHJULIIHQGD HUVLFKQXUEHU]HXJWHGDGLH:DIIHQRFKGDVWDQG,FKVDK GDGHU6LFKHUXQJVEJHOXPJHOHJWZDU,FKVFKORGDUDXVGD LFKHLQHJHODGHQH%FKVHYRUPLUKDWWH$OVKDEHHUPHLQHQ %HVXFKHUZDUWHW© %RUQV6WLPPHLVWZLHGHULP/DXWVSUHFKHUª'HU6RPPHU HLQXQGVHFK]LJLVWSURJUDPPLHUWXQGGDUlVRQLHUHQ6LHPLW ,KUHQ9RUEHKDOWHQPLW,KUHU7KHRULHYRQXQJHQJHQGHU 9RUEHUHLWXQJPLW,KUHU)RUGHUXQJQDFK9HUVFKLHEXQJGHU (QWVFKHLGXQJ6LHEULQJHQXQVHUHVWUDWHJLVFKH.RQ]HSWLRQLQ *HIDKU'LH2UJDQLVDWLRQVHW]W+LPPHOXQG+|OOHLQ%H ZHJXQJXQG6LH":LUEHJUHLIHQ,KUH(LQVWHOOXQJQLFKW© 'LH6FKULWWH%ULQNPDQQVDXIURKHQ+RO]ERKOHQVFKQHOOHU DOVYRUKLQHUUHJWHU(LQKLQJHZRUIHQHVª,FKKDEHGLHJU|WH +RFKDFKWXQJYRUGHP%HPKHQGHU2UJDQLVDWLRQXPEDOG P|JOLFKVWH%HIUHLXQJ0LWWHOGHXWVFKODQGVYRP.RPPXQLV PXV$EHU©6HLQH6WLPPHZLUGHLQGULQJOLFKIDVWEH VFKZ|UHQGª6LHDOOHHUOLHJHQHLQHP:XQVFKGHQNHQ,FKIU PHLQHQ7HLOP|FKWHYHUPHLGHQGDHLQGHXWVFKHU*HQHUDOVWDE LP$XJXVWHLQXQGVHFK]LJ]XPGULWWHQPDOLQGLHVHP-DKU KXQGHUWHLQHYHUQLFKWHQGH1LHGHUODJHKLQQHKPHQPX© ª'DVLVWVHLQHDOWH/HLHU©EHPHUNW)ULWVFKNDOW ª1DWUOLFK©IlKUWGHU2EHUVWDXIGHP7RQEDQGIRUW
ªZHUGHQZLUHLQHV7DJHVPDUVFKLHUHQ'RFKHVMHW]W]XWXQ ZlUH6HOEVWPRUG© ª0LWGLHVHU0HLQXQJVWHKHQ6LHDOOHLQ© 6WLOOH%ULQNPDQQVWHKWZLHGHU'DQQVDJWHUIHVWª,FKZHL PLFKLP5HFKW7HLOHQ6LH.DPHUDG)ULWVFKPLWGDLFKPLFK GDLFKNHLQHDQGHUH7ULEQHPHKUKDEHDQGDV1$72 +HDGTXDUWHUVZHQGHQZHUGH,QGHU+RIIQXQJGDVLFK ZHQLJVWHQVGRUWQRFKHLQLJH/HXWHHLQHQNODUHQ.RSIEHZDKUW KDEHQ,FKJODXEHQLFKWGDGLH9HUHLQLJWHQ6WDDWHQRGHUDXFK GDV8QLWHG.LQJGRPRGHU)UDQNUHLFKYRQGHU$XVVLFKWEH JHLVWHUWZlUHQLQHLQHZHOWZHLWH$XVHLQDQGHUVHW]XQJKLQ HLQJH]RJHQ]XZHUGHQGXUFKHLQH$NWLRQGLHYRQHLQHU +DQGYROO/HXWHQRUJDQLVLHUWZLUG8QGDOOHLQ",FKEHWRQH QRFKHLQPDOZLUVLQGQLFKWVRZHLW0HLQ(QWVFKOXLVWHQG JOWLJ© ª,KUOHW]WHV:RUW.DPHUDG%ULQNPDQQ"© ª0HLQOHW]WHV:RUW+HUU%RUQ© 3ROWHUQGIlOOWHLQ6WXKOXP*DQ]VFKQHOOH6FKULWWHLQJOHLFK EOHLEHQGHU1lKHYRP0LNURIRQ'DVKHLWHVLVWGHU&KHIGHU 5+(,10$,1'(7(.7(,GHUUHQQW(LQPHWDOOLVFKHV .OLFNHQ %ULQNPDQQVHKUODXWª:RKOZDKQVLQQLJJHZRUGHQ":DIIH ZHJ%RUQ©1lKHUNRPPHQGH6FKULWWHKDVWLJXQGXQJOHLFK PlLJ.HXFKHQ(LQ]ZHLWHU6WXKONLSSW9RP0LNURIRQ JHUDGHQRFKDXIJHIDQJHQLVWGDVUDVHQGH%HOOHQGHVHLQ JHVSHUUWHQ+XQGHVPHKU]XDKQHQDOV]XK|UHQ (LQ6FKX %RUQVFKDOWHWGDV*HUlWDXV(ULVWEOD6HLQH6WLPPHLVW UDXKXQGEHOHJWXQGHUPXVLFKHUVWUlXVSHUQHKHHUEHWRQW VDFKOLFKHUNOlUHQNDQQª,FKKDWWHQDWUOLFKHLQHVFKDOO JHGlPSIWH3LVWROHPLWJHEUDFKW)UHPGIDEULNDWEHLXQVQLFKW UHJLVWULHUW'DQQVDKLFKGDV-DJGJHZHKU'DVZUGHYLHO QDWUOLFKHUZLUNHQGDFKWHLFK,FKKDWWHGLH%FKVHYRULKP LQGHU+DQGDEHUHUEHNDPVLHQRFK]XIDVVHQ*HQXW]WKDW HVLKPQLFKWV© )ULWVFKOHJWEHWXOLFKGLH:ROOGHFNHEHLVHLWHXQGHUKHEWVLFK
DXVGHP6HVVHO6HLQ*HVLFKWEOHLEWY|OOLJDXVGUXFNVORV2KQH GLHJHULQJVWH5HJXQJEHPHUNWHUª:DUXPVRYLHO=HLWYHU VFKZHQGXQJ"6ROFKH/HXWHQHKPHQNHLQH9HUQXQIWDQ$EHU GHU(LQIDOOPLWGHP-DJGJHZHKUZDUJXW*HEHQ6LHPLUGDV %DQG© %RUQJHKRUFKW(UWXWHVXQJHUQGRFKHUYHUVWHKWGD )ULWVFKGLH$XIQDKPHKDEHQZLOOZHLOHUPHKUIDFKHUZlKQW ZLUGXQGZHLOGLH7RQEDQGDXI]HLFKQXQJVROOWHVLHLQIDOVFKH +lQGHJHUDWHQ(KHGHU$OWHGLH6SXOHHLQVWHFNWYHU JHZLVVHUWHUVLFKVRJDUGDHVNHLQH.RSLHJLEW%RUQNHQQW GLH6SLHOUHJHOQGHU2UJDQLVDWLRQ]XJHQDXXPDQHLQHVROFKH 0|JOLFKNHLWDXFKEORJHGDFKW]XKDEHQ ª1DFKGHP6FKXNDPHQPHLQH/HXWH:LUVLQGXQEHPHUNW LQGHU1lKHGHV%ORFNKDXVHVJHEOLHEHQELVGHU0$'HUVFKLHQ (VZDUXQVEHNDQQWGD0DMRU'HWMHQGHQ7RWHQILQGHQ ZUGH+HUUYRQ:LHVHQHFNKDWWHPLUJHJHQEHUHUZlKQWHV VHLGHQNEDUGDGHU2EHUVWVHLQHQ6WHOOYHUWUHWHU]XEHHLQIOXV VHQYHUVXFKWKDEHMDGD0DMRU'HWMHQHYHQWXHOOYRQ1LHGHU VFKULIWHQ%ULQNPDQQVZLVVHXQGVLFKEHPLJWIKOHQN|QQH VROFKH1LHGHUVFKULIWHQDQGLH%UVVHOHU)UHXQGHGHV2EHUVWHQ ZHLWHU]XOHLWHQLQY|OOLJHU8QNHQQWQLVGHU=XVDPPHQKlQJH QDWUOLFK'HU0DMRUZDUVRIUHXQGOLFKVRIRUWGLH)HQVWHU OlGHQ]X|IIQHQQDFKGHPHULP+DXVZDU© )ULWVFKVFKDXWLKQQXUDQXQGGDQLPPWHUHLQHQ%ULHIXP VFKODJPLW)RWRJUDILHQKHUDXV0LWHLQHU7HOHNDPHUDDXI JHQRPPHQGRNXPHQWLHUHQVLHOFNHQORV'HWMHQV$XIHQWKDOW LQGHU-DJGKWWH'LHVH%LOGHUVHKHQDXVDOVKlWWHGHU$XI QHKPHQGHVHOEVWPLWLP=LPPHUJHVWDQGHQ ª'HU0DMRUKDWVLFKZHQLJHUDOVHLQH0LQXWHLP%ORFNKDXV DXIJHKDOWHQSUl]LVVHFKVXQGYLHU]LJ6HNXQGHQ(UKDWQLFKWV EHUKUWXQGQLFKWVJHVXFKW6HLQ9HUKDOWHQLVWLQMHGHU3KDVH GXUFKDXVNRUUHNWJHZHVHQ© )ULWVFKYHU]LHKWHLQZHQLJGHQ0XQGª6LHP|JHQGHQ0DQQ MD"© ª:DVKHLWP|JHQ!©ZHLFKWGHU&KHIGHU5+(,10$,1 '(7(.7(,DXVª*HOHJHQWOLFKH=XVDPPHQDUEHLWPLWLKPKDW
VLFKDOVQW]OLFKHUZLHVHQ,FKGDUIGDUDQHULQQHUQGD'HWMHQ VHLQHU]HLWDXIGHPU|PLVFKHQ:HJ!QDFK6GDPHULNDJH VFKOHXVWZXUGH'LH)UDQ]RVHQKDWWHQLKQDOV.ULHJVYHUEUH FKHUJHVXFKW© 'HU0DQQLP2KUHQVHVVHOQLFNWXQGUFNWGDV3ODLGDXI VHLQHQ.QLHQ]XUHFKW'DVLVWLKPEHNDQQW:HUDXIGHP ªU|PLVFKHQ:HJ©DXHU/DQGHVJHEUDFKWZXUGHLVWLQGHQ $XJHQGHU2UJDQLVDWLRQGHUHKHPDOLJHQ66$QJHK|ULJHQHLQH YHUOlOLFKH3HUV|QOLFKNHLW'DMHQHU)OLHJHUXQGLQIROJHGHV VHQORJLVFKHUZHLVHNHLQ$QJHK|ULJHUGHU66ZDUVSLHOWNHLQH 5ROOHGLH2'(66$KDWVLFKLPPHUIUGDV*DQ]HYHUDQW ZRUWOLFKJHIKOWXQGGHQ:HUWHLQHV0DQQHVPHKUDQVHLQHU +DOWXQJDOVDP%HVLW]HLQHV0LWJOLHGVEXFKHVJHPHVVHQ 'HWMHQV$XIWUHWHQKDWQLHPDOV$QOD]XU.ULWLNJHJHEHQ 'LH)ODPPHQLP.DPLQ]XFNHQ,KUU|WOLFKHV/LFKWVSLHOW DXI%RUQV*HVLFKW'HU'XIWYRQ%LUNHQKRO]IOOWGHQ5DXP %LUNHQKRO]'RSSHOWVRGLFNXQGKDOEPHWHUODQJVLQG VHLQHU]HLWGLH6FKHLWHJHZHVHQPLWGHQHQGDPDOVLPUXV VLVFKHQ/DJHUZHLWKLQWHU0RVNDXJHKHL]WZXUGH'LHVHELWWHUH .lOWHYLHU]LJ*UDGPLQXVZRFKHQODQJGDQQVRJDUIQI]LJ *UDG8QGGLHJHPDXHUWHQgIHQIUDHQ6REDOGVLHGXUFK JHEUDQQWZDUHQZHQQGDV+RO]QXUQRFKHLQHGXUFKJOKWH 0DVVHELOGHWHZXUGHREHQLP2IHQHLQH.ODSSHJH|IIQHWXQG GHU=XJGXUFKHLQHQHLVHUQHQ'HFNHOJHVWRSSW'HU6FKQHHODJ PHWHUKRFKXQGEHXJWHGLH%lXPHWLHI6LHVWDQGHQUHJORVHV ZHKWHQLFKWGHUOHLVHVWH:LQGXQGEHUGHPJDQ]HQ.ULHJV JHIDQJHQHQODJHUODJGLHVHU'XIWYRQEUHQQHQGHP%LUNHQKRO] ,QMHQHP/DJHUKDEHQVLHVLFKNHQQHQJHOHUQW$FKLP'HWMHQ XQGHU%RUQ'HU=XIDOONHWWHWHVLHDQHLQDQGHUXQGLPPHUZLH GHUKDEHQVLFKLKUH:HJHJHNUHX]W%RUQLVWRKQH$UJZRKQ JHJHQEHUGHPHKHPDOLJHQ-DJGIOLHJHUHUIKOWVRJDUHLQH JHZLVVH=XQHLJXQJIULKQDEHUIU(PRWLRQHQLVWLQGHU 2UJDQLVDWLRQNHLQ3ODW],PPHUKLQKDWVLH%ULQNPDQQ]XP 7RGHYHUXUWHLOWXQG%ULQNPDQQEHVDHLQHQ(KUHQULQJGHV 5HLFKVIKUHUV668QGZDVZlUHPLWLKPVHOEVW%RUQJH VFKHKHQZHQQHUVLFKGHP%HIHKOZLHGHUVHW]WKlWWH"7URW]
GHV.DPLQIHXHUVIU|VWHOWHVGHQ&KHIGHU5+(,10$,1 '(7(.7(, ,QGDV6FKZHLJHQKLQHLQNORSIWHVXQGGHUVHOEH0DQQHU VFKHLQWGHU%RUQLQGHU*DUDJHLQ(PSIDQJJHQRPPHQKDW (UKlOWHLQ7HOHIRQLQGHU+DQGXQGIKUWGDV.DEHOLQGHQ $QVFKOXVWHFNHUHLQª)U6LH©VDJWHUQXUXQGUHLFKW%RUQ GHQ+|UHU ,QGLHVHP$XJHQEOLFNZQVFKWGHUYRQJDQ]HP+HU]HQ VHLQH/HXWHP|FKWHQHLQH6LHJHVIDQIDUHEODVHQXQGPHOGHQ GDVYHUIOXFKWH%ULQNPDQQSDSLHUVHLVLFKHUJHVWHOOWZRUGHQ :LHLKQGDVEHLGHP$OWHQDXIZHUWHQZUGH$EHUDPDQGHUHQ (QGHGHU/HLWXQJVDJWH:ROI'LHWHU6FKZHGOHUEORª1HJD WLY&KHI:DVVROOHQZLUWXQ"© %RUQKDWLKQGHVZHJHQhEHUKDXSWUHL]WLKQGLHJDQ]H VIILVDQWDUURJDQWH$UWGLHVHV'LSORPNULPLQDOLVWHQVHLQ PRNDQWHV/lFKHOQVHLQ9RQREHQ+HUDE6SHNXOLHUWHUQLFKW VFKRQDXIVHLQHQ%RUQV6FKUHLEWLVFKVHVVHOXQGIUHXWVLFK ZHQQGHU&KHIDXIV.UHX]IlOOW"(UZHLNHLQH$QWZRUWDXI GLHDXIJHZRUIHQH)UDJHHUOHJWHLQIDFKDXI )ULWVFKVLHKWLKQDQXQGZHLDOOHVª:DVPDFKHQ6LH QXQ"©
bXHUOLFKLVW0DMRU'HWMHQY|OOLJXQYHUlQGHUWDOVHUDP 0RQWDJPRUJHQ]XP'LHQVWDXIGHU+DUGWK|KHHUVFKHLQW(V LVWDOOHVLQ2UGQXQJHVPXDOOHVLQ2UGQXQJVHLQ3QNWOLFK ]HKQ0LQXWHQYRUGHU=HLWEHWULWWHUGDV+DXVXPDXIGLH 6HNXQGHJHQDXGHQ6WXKODQVHLQHQ6FKUHLEWLVFKKHUDQ]XUN NHQ:LHHVVLFKJHK|UWHUVFKHLQHQUDQJJOHLFKH2IIL]LHUHPLW LKPZlKUHQGUDQJQLHGHUHEHUHLWV]ZHL0LQXWHQDQZHVHQG VLQG'LHDEJHVWXIWH=HLWHQIROJHZLUGELV]XP2EHUVWSUl]LVH HLQJHKDOWHQ2EHUVWHEHWUHWHQGDV+DXVPLWGHP*ORFNHQ VFKODJDFKWXQGQXUEHL*HQHUDOHQLVWHVHLQELFKHQDQGHUV
(LQSDDU:RUWHKLQXQGKHU$OOJHPHLQHVEHUGDV:RFKHQ HQGH0DMRU6FKPLWWHU]lKOWVFKRQLP3DWHUQRVWHUYRQGHP ª*HQHUDODQJULII©PLWGHPVHLQH(QNHOGHQ9RUVDW]]XQLFKWH PDFKWHQVLFKPDOULFKWLJDXV]XVFKODIHQGHU6RQQWDJZDUVR DQVWUHQJHQGGDHUVLFKHUVWHLQPDOGDYRQHUKROHQPXª0DQ VROOWHVLFKDXFKVR QH-DJGKWWHDQ/DQG]LHKHQZLHGHU&KHI 8QHUUHLFKEDUVHLQ© ª$XFK%ULQNPDQQKDWWHVHLQH6RUJHQ1DMHW]WQLFKWPHKU© 6LHVLQGDOOHLQLP3DWHUQRVWHU'HWMHQWULWWGLFKWHUDQGHQ DQGHUHQKHUDQXQGIlKUWOHLVHIRUWª(ULVWWRW6HOEVWPRUG,Q GHU1DFKWYRP6DPVWDJ]XP6RQQWDJ$EHUEHKDOWHQ6LH VIU VLFKELVHVRIIL]LHOOEHNDQQWJHJHEHQZLUG© 6FKPLWWV%HWURIIHQKHLWLVWYRQVHLQHP*HVLFKWDEOHVEDU 2EHQJHKWHUJOHLFKLQVHLQ=LPPHUXQGKDWEHL)UDX0DUVFKQHU QXUHLQIOFKWLJHV.RSIQLFNHQIU+DXSWPDQQ5RWKH'HUZDU JHVWHUQPLWVHLQHU)DPLOLHLQ6W*RDU(UKDWVLFKGRUWUHFKW ]HLWLJEHLGHP:LQ]HULQ(ULQQHUXQJJHEUDFKWEHLGHPHU VHLQHQ:HLQNDXIWLP'LUHNWEH]XJGHQQGDVLVWELOOLJHUª8QG HLQ:HLQLVWGDV© ª,QWHUHVVLHUWPLFK©ZLUIW$FKLPKLQª%ULQJHQ6LHGRFKPDO HLQH.RVWSUREHGDYRQPLW©6RDOOWlJOLFKZLHP|JOLFK *HQDX]ZHL0LQXWHQQDFKDFKW8KUNOLQJHOWGDV7HOHIRQDXI 'HWMHQV6FKUHLEWLVFK$FKLPQLPPWGHQ+|UHUDEXQGVWHKW DXIZLHVLFK VVFKLFNWZHQQPDQPLWHLQHP9RUJHVHW]WHQ VSULFKW'HU0DMRUHUKlOW$QZHLVXQJDXV%ULQNPDQQV$U EHLWV]LPPHUHLQH$NWHPLWGHU1XPPHU-]XHQWQHK PHQXQGVLHXPJHKHQGGHP$QUXIHU]XEHUEULQJHQ'LH$NWH EHILQGHVLFKLP3DQ]HUVFKUDQNGLH6LFKHUKHLWVDEWHLOXQJVHL DQJHZLHVHQ'HWMHQGHQ6FKOVVHODXV]XKlQGLJHQ1DFK(QW QDKPHKDEHGHU0DMRU3DQ]HUVFKUDQNXQG$UEHLWV]LPPHU]X YHUVFKOLHHQXQGGLH6FKOVVHOPLWVDPWGHQ8QWHUODJHQDE ]XJHEHQ.HLQ:RUWZHVKDOEXQGZDUXP $FKLPEHJLEWVLFK]XP6LFKHUKHLWVEURTXLWWLHUWXQGNHKUW PLWGHP6FKOVVHO]XUFN)UDX0DUVFKQHUEOLFNWLKQIUDJHQG DQGRFKHUKHEWQXUGLH6FKXOWHUQXQGYHUVFKZLQGHWLQ%ULQN PDQQV5DXP3DQ]HUVFKUDQNDXIGDOLHJWGLH$NWH'HWMHQ
NHQQWVLHVLHLVWDXFKEHUVHLQHQ7LVFKJHJDQJHQ,PEULJHQ LVWGHU6DIHVRJXWZLHOHHU%ULQNPDQQKDWWHLKQYRUVHLQHP 8UODXEDXIJHUlXPW'LH'LHQVWSLVWROHGHV2EHUVWHQXQGHLQH 6FKDFKWHO0XQLWLRQKDEHQHLQJDQ]HV)DFKIUVLFKDOOHLQ $FKLPQLPPWGHQ2UGQHUKHUDXVGDVLVWGDV:HUNYRQ6H NXQGHQVFKOLHWGHQOHHUHQ3DQ]HUVFKUDQN]XXQGZHQGHWVLFK ]XUFN]XU7U 'D]|JHUWHUEHLWVLFKDXIGLH/LSSHQXQGLVWJOHLFKPLW ]ZHLGUHL6FKULWWHQDQ%ULQNPDQQV6FKUHLEWLVFK(UJHKWHLQ 5LVLNRHLQGDVZHLHUDEHUGLH*HOHJHQKHLWLVWVRXQJODXEOLFK JQVWLJXQGYHUORFNHQG+LQ]XNRPPWGDDOOH6FKUHLEWLVFKH LP5HIHUDWDXVGHUVHOEHQ3URGXNWLRQVVHULHVWDPPHQXQGPLW EHUHLQVWLPPHQGHQ6FKO|VVHUQYHUVHKHQVLQG0KHORVOlW VLFK%ULQNPDQQV6FKUHLEWLVFK|IIQHQ'HWMHQPDFKWQXUGLH 6FKXEODGHREHQOLQNVDXI'RUWOLHJWGLHSULYDWH6FKUHLEPDSSH GHV2EHUVWHQHUKDWVLHRIWJHQXJJHVHKHQ(KHHUVLHKHU DXVQLPPWZLUGHUVLFKEHZXWGDHUNHLQH)LQJHUDEGUFNH KLQWHUODVVHQGDUI0LWHLQHP3DSLHUWDVFKHQWXFKEHKLOIWHUVLFK 8PVFKOlJHXQG%ULHIERJHQPLWYRUJHGUXFNWHU$QVFKULIW9LHU YHUVFKLHGHQIDUELJH.XJHOVFKUHLEHUHLQ5HFKHQVFKLHEHU'LH 6HLWHQIlFKHU)RWRV)UDX%ULQNPDQQGHU6HWWHU*UXSSHQELOG HLQHU.ODVVHPLWLKUHP/HKUHU'HU6RKQGLHbKQOLFKNHLWLVW XQYHUNHQQEDU0HKUHUH%ULHIH%HODQJORVYRQIUHPGHU+DQG (LQHUGHQ%ULQNPDQQJHVFKULHEHQKDW1XUDQJHIDQJHQQLFKW ]X(QGHJHIKUW'LH$QUHGHODXWHWª0HLQ/LHEHU©8QGGDQQ VWHKWGDQRFKª$OVLFKJHVWHUQZLHGHUGUDXHQZDUXQGYRU GHP%LOGVWDQGKDEHLFKPHLQHP+HU]HQHLQHQ6WRJHJHEHQ 'XKDVW]ZDUQLHHWZDVJHVDJWDEHUPHLQHPZHLGPlQQLVFKHQ 6FKDUIEOLFNLVWWURW]GHPQLFKWHQWJDQJHQZLHEHJHLVWHUW'X YRUGHP:LOGEUHWKlQGOHU!JHVWDQGHQKDVW,FKP|FKWH'LU HLQH)UHXGHPDFKHQ'LH.RSLHJHK|UW'LU,FKELQVLFKHUGD 'XHLQHQJXWHQ3ODW]GDIUILQGHQZLUVWXQGEHLLKUHU%H WUDFKWXQJPDQFKPDODQXQVHUHJHPHLQVDPHQ3LUVFKJlQJH GHQNVW'XKDVWHLQPDOJHVDJWGDGDV%LOGVHLQHYROOH :LUNXQJHUVWEHLULFKWLJHU%HOHXFKWXQJHU]LHOHQXQ'XKDVW VLFKHU©0LWWHQLP6DW]DEJHEURFKHQDOVVHL%ULQNPDQQDQ
GLHVHU6WHOOHJHVW|UWZRUGHQXQGKDEHGHQ%ULHIHLQVWZHLOHQ LQGLH0DSSHJHJHEHQ $FKLP]|JHUW(ULVWVFKRQYHUVXFKWGHQ%ULHIDQVHLQHQ 3ODW]]XUFN]XVFKLHEHQXQG]XYHUJHVVHQ:LHGHU]|JHUWHU ,Q6HNXQGHQEUXFKWHLOHQ]LHKHQGLH9RUJlQJHLQGHU-DJGKWWH QRFKHLQPDODQLKPYRUEHUGLHILHEHUKDIWH6XFKHGHU %HDPWHQYRQª%RQQHLQV©GHUHLJHQH9HUGDFKWHVJHKHXP %ULQNPDQQV3DSLHUH0DQKDWWHDXFKGDV%LOGYRQGHU:DQG JHQRPPHQXQGGDKLQWHUJHVHKHQ0HKUQLFKW*DEHVGDYLHO OHLFKWHLQHQ+RKOUDXPLP5DKPHQHLQ9HUVWHFN]ZLVFKHQ 0DOJUXQGXQG5FNSODWWH"$EHUGDVZlUHGRFKGLHVHQ3URILV QLFKWHQWJDQJHQ'DNDQQQLFKWVVHLQ 7URW]GHP(LQHUMlKHQ(LQJHEXQJIROJHQGVWHFNW'HWMHQ GHQXQYROOHQGHWHQ%ULHIHLQ'HULVWVRPHUNZUGLJDEJHIDW GHUPXWHWDQDOVZROOHHUGHQ(PSIlQJHUPLWGHU1DVHDXI HWZDVVWRHQ(UNDQQVLFKKLHUQLFKWHZLJDXIKDOWHQ'HVKDOE YHUVHW]WHUGHQ6FKUHLEWLVFKLQVHLQHQDOWHQ=XVWDQG]XUFN XQGJHKW$NWHXQG6FKOVVHODE]XJHEHQZLHEHIRKOHQ $OVHUZLHGHUDQVHLQHP3ODW]VLW]WOlWLKQGHU%ULHIQLFKW ORV-HOlQJHUHUGDUEHUQDFKGHQNWGHVWRPHUNZUGLJHUHU VFKHLQHQLKPGLH)RUPXOLHUXQJHQ%HVLW]HQVLHQLFKWHWZDV 6XJJHVWLYHV":ROOHQVLHQLFKWMHPDQGHPHLQ,QWHUHVVHHLQ UHGHQGDVGHU%HWUHIIHQGHJDUQLFKWEHNXQGHWKDW"8QG ZDUXPOHJWH%ULQNPDQQVRYLHO:HUWDXIGLH%HWRQXQJGHU %HOHXFKWXQJ":DVN|QQWHVLHGHQQ]X7DJHI|UGHUQZDVQLFKW DXFKEHLJHZ|KQOLFKHP7DJHVOLFKW]XVHKHQJHZHVHQZlUH" (LQKHOOHVIUHXQGOLFKHV%LOG(LQHEORH.RSLHQRFKGD]X 0DOHULVFKH%HVRQGHUKHLWHQNDQQGHU2EHUVWQLFKWLP$XJHQ JHKDEWKDEHQ:DVDEHUGDQQ" $XIGHU7RLOHWWHOLHVW$FKLPGLHZHQLJHQ=HLOHQQRFKHLQPDO XQGSUlJWVLHVLFKHLQVRJXWHVJHKW'DQQ]HUUHLWHUGHQ %RJHQLQZLQ]LJH)HW]HQXQGVSOWLKQZHJ)UDOOH)lOOH 'LH=HLJHUGHUHOHNWULVFKHQ7LVFKXKUVWHKHQDXIQHXQDOV )UDX0DUVFKQHUGHQ0DMRULQV9RU]LPPHUELWWHW'DEHLJLEW VLHLKPPLWWRQORVEHZHJWHQ/LSSHQ]XYHUVWHKHQZHUGUDXHQ LVWª'HU0$'©
9RQ:LHVHQHFNSHUV|QOLFKVWHKWGDXQGPLWLKPJHNRPPHQ VLQGZLHGHUXPGLH/HXWHGHU8QWHUVXFKXQJVJUXSSHª%RQQ HLQV©'HWMHQEDXWVLFKDXIXQGNODSSWGLH+DFNHQ]XVDPPHQ ª+HUU0DMRU©VDJWGHU*HQHUDOVHKUGLHQVWOLFKªNRPPHQ 6LHPLW6LHZHUGHQIUGDV3URWRNROOJHEUDXFKW© (LQHUGHU0$'/HXWHKDWGLHYRUKLQYRQ$FKLPEHQXW]WHQ 6FKOVVHO|IIQHW%ULQNPDQQV=LPPHUXQGOlWGHP*HQHUDO GHQ9RUWULWW'HUOHKQWVLFKPLWGHP5FNHQDQV)HQVWHU ZlKUHQGGLH6SH]LDOLVWHQEHJLQQHQGHQ5DXP]XGXUFK VXFKHQ'HWMHQVWHKWGDEHLXQGDFKWHWGDUDXIQLFKWDOO]XVHKU LP:HJH]XVHLQ$EHUPDOVEHPHUNWHUGLHDXHURUGHQWOLFKH 3HUIHNWLRQPLWGHUª%RQQHLQV©DUEHLWHWHLQLQHLQDQ GHUJUHLIHQGHV5lGHUZHUNGHPQLFKWVHQWULQQW'DVLVWVR HLQJHVSLHOWGDHVNHLQHU9HUVWlQGLJXQJ]ZLVFKHQGHQ 0lQQHUQEHGDUI-HGHUNHQQWVHLQH$XIJDEHXQGMHGHULVWHLQ 0HLVWHUVHLQHV)DFKHV -HW]WKDEHQVLHGHQ6FKUHLEWLVFKHUUHLFKW2IIHQVLFKWOLFKLVW LKQHQQLFKWEHNDQQWGDVLFKDOOH6FKUHLEWLVFKHGHV5HIHUDWV PLWGHPJOHLFKHQ6FKOVVHO|IIQHQODVVHQVLHEHGLHQHQVLFK HLQHVNRPSOL]LHUWHQ9HUVWHOOVFKOVVHOV'HWMHQYHU]LHKWNHLQH 0LHQH'LH6FKXEODGHREHQOLQNVGLH6FKUHLEPDSSH1DFK )LQJHUDEGUFNHQVXFKWPDQQLFKW ª=XOHW]WZDUHQ6LHLP=LPPHU+HUU0DMRU"©IUDJW+DXSW PDQQ(EHUVEDFKVDFKOLFK ª9RUHLQHU6WXQGHHWZD©EHVWlWLJW$FKLPLPJOHLFKHQ 7RQIDOOª,P3DQ]HUVFKUDQNEHIDQGVLFK© ª,FKZHL'DQNH©XQWHUEULFKWLKQGHU+DXSWPDQQ 8PVFKOlJHXQG%RJHQPLWDXIJHGUXFNWHU$GUHVVH)RWRV )UDX%ULQNPDQQGHU6HWWHU*UXSSHQELOGHLQHU.ODVVHPLW LKUHP/HKUHU0HKUHUH%ULHIHYRQIUHPGHU+DQG6LHYHU VFKZLQGHQLQHLQHU3ODVWLNWWH'D]XGLHREHQDXIOLHJHQGHQ %RJHQXQGGDV/|VFKEODWW ª/DERUXQWHUVXFKXQJ©EHVWLPPW(EHUVEDFKZRUWNDUJ ª'XUFKJHGUFNWH6FKULIW/|VFKDEGUFNH6LHZLVVHQVFKRQ %LWWH+HUU0DMRUKDW+HUU%ULQNPDQQRIW.XJHOVFKUHLEHU EHQXW]W"©
ª6RYLHOPLUEHNDQQWLVWQXUVHOWHQ©VWHOOW$FKLPULFKWLJ ª,FKJODXEHHU]RJGLHJXWHDOWH)OOIHGHUYRU© 1DWUOLFKNDQQGHU%ULHIGHQHUYHUVFKZLQGHQOLHJDQ] RGHU]X7HLOHQLQ6SLHJHOVFKULIWDXIGHP/|VFKEODWWZLHGHU ]XILQGHQVHLQ)ULKQHUZlFKVWGDUDXVNHLQH*HIDKU%ULHIH ZHUGHQJHVFKULHEHQGDPLWPDQVLHDEVFKLFNW +DXSWPDQQ(EHUVEDFKJHKWKLQDXVXQGOlWVLFKYRQ)UDX 0DUVFKQHUGLH7DJHVNODGGH%ULQNPDQQVJHEHQGDV+HIWLQ GHP(PSIDQJXQG:HLWHUJDEHYRQ$NWHQHEHQVRIHVWJHKDOWHQ ZHUGHQZLH%HVSUHFKXQJHQ'LHQVWUHLVHQXQG%HVXFKH'DULQ VWHKWDXFKZRDEZHVHQGH0LWDUEHLWHUZDQQXQGZLH]XHU UHLFKHQVLQG ª*HEHQ6LHPDOKHU©VDJWYRQ:LHVHQHFNª)UDX0DUVFKQHU VROOHLQHQHXHDQOHJHQ'LHVH.ODGGH]XGHQ$VVHUYDWHQ© ª%RQQHLQV©VXFKWZHLWHU:lKUHQGHUEHREDFKWHWZLHGLH 0lQQHUGDVPDFKHQGDGHQNW'HWMHQDQGHQKHLPOLFKHQ %HVXFKLQVHLQHU:RKQXQJ(ULVWYHUVXFKWLKQGLHVHU0DQQ VFKDIWKLHUDQ]XODVWHQ'DVLHDOOHUGLQJVGLH+DDUVLFKHUXQJ DQVHLQHP6FKUHLEWLVFKEHUVHKHQKDW :DVVLH]XILQGHQJHKRIIWKDEHQHQWGHFNHQ+DXSWPDQQ (EHUVEDFKXQGVHLQH0lQQHULQ%ULQNPDQQV$UEHLWV]LPPHU QLFKW$FKLPEHPHUNWGDGHU/HLWHUGHU*UXSSHGLH6FKXOWHUQ KHEWDOVHU]XYRQ:LHVHQHFNDQV)HQVWHUWULWW*OHLFKGDUDXI ]LHKWª%RQQHLQV©DE,P9RUEHLJHKHQOlW(EHUVEDFK$FKLP ZLVVHQPDQZHUGHLKPDP1DFKPLWWDJGDV'XUFKVXFKXQJV SURWRNROO]XU8QWHUVFKULIWYRUOHJHQHVPVVHMDDOOHVVHLQH 2UGQXQJKDEHQ 'HU*HQHUDOEOHLEW0LWHLQHUOlVVLJHQ+DQGEHZHJXQJ IRUGHUWHU'HWMHQDXILQHLQHPGHU6HVVHO3ODW]]XQHKPHQ 'DQQVWRSIWHUEHWXOLFKVHLQH3IHLIHXQGIUDJWZLHQHEHQKHU XQGVHKUIUHXQGOLFKª:DVKDEHQ6LHHLJHQWOLFK]XYHUEHUJHQ 'HWMHQ"© ª9RU,KQHQQLFKWV+HUU*HQHUDO©DQWZRUWHW$FKLPZLHDXV GHU3LVWROHJHVFKRVVHQ(UEULQJWHVVRJDUIHUWLJ]XODFKHQDOV KDOWHHUGLH)UDJHIUHLQHQJXWHQ:LW],Q:DKUKHLWEHUOHJW HUILHEHUKDIWZDVVHLQ*HJHQEHUPHLQHQN|QQWH0LWVHLQHP
DQGHUHQ,FKKDWWHHVJHZLQLFKWV]XWXQ:lUHPDQGHP .XQGVFKDIWHUGHV0LQLVWHULXPVIU6WDDWVVLFKHUKHLWDXIGLH 6SXUJHNRPPHQVRZUGHGDVQLFKWXQWHUYLHU$XJHQDEJHWDQ ZHUGHQ 'LH3IHLIHEUHQQW:HLJUDXH5DXFKVFKZDGHQ]LHKHQ GXUFKV=LPPHUª6R"©IUDJWYRQ:LHVHQHFNª0DFKHQZLU GRFKPDOGLH3UREHDXIV([HPSHO:RZDUHQ6LHJHVWHUQ QDFKPLWWDJ"© (UKlWWHGRFKLQGLH6SLHOEDQNJHKHQVROOHQ'DQQN|QQWH HUMHW]WPLWUXKLJHP*HZLVVHQVDJHQ5XIHQ6LHGDV&DVLQR LQ:LHVEDGHQDQ'RUWKDEHQVLHPHLQHQJHVWULJHQ%HVXFKLQ GHU.DUWHL$EHUGDVJHKWQLFKW(UVFKOlJWHQWVSDQQWHLQ%HLQ EHUVDQGHUHª*XWJHJHVVHQJXWJHODXQW©VDJWHUOlFKHOQG ª6FK|QHV:HWWHUKDWIUPLFKZDV/RFNHQGHV(UVWZROOWHLFK LQGHQ)OLHJHUNOXEGRFKGD]XZDUHVHLJHQWOLFKVFKRQ]XVSlW ,FKELQDXIV*HUDWHZRKODP5KHLQHQWODQJJHIDKUHQHLQIDFK VR8PGLHVH=HLWVLQGGLH6WUDHQOHHUNHLQ0HQVFKKXSW ZHQQPDQHLQELFKHQWU|GHOWDXIGHUHLQHQ6HLWHGHU)OX DXIGHUDQGHUHQ:HLQEHUJH]DXEHUKDIW(LJHQWOLFKZROOWHLFK PLUPDOGLH)HVWH(KUHQEUHLWVWHLQDQVHKHQLFKZDUQRFKQLH GRUWHLQH6FKDQGH'DLFKDEHUGLH$EIDKUWYHUSDWKDEHELQ LFKQDFK:LHVEDGHQJHNRPPHQ-DGRUWKDEHLFKHLQHQ +DSSHQJHJHVVHQLP.XUKDXVEULJHQVXQGPLWGHP&DVLQR JHOLHElXJHOW5HFKW]HLWLJILHOPLUGDV:HKUHWGHQ$QIlQJHUQ HLQ'HVKDOEEOLHEHVEHLHLQHPNOHLQHQ6SD]LHUJDQJ© (UZLUGGDVXQJXWH*HIKOQLFKWORVGDHU]XYLHOUHGHW :LHVEDGHQPXWHHUQHQQHQGDVZDUQLFKW]XXPJHKHQ0DQ N|QQWHLKQEHREDFKWHWKDEHQ$EHUZDUXPLQGUHL7HXIHOV 1DPHQ"8QGGDQQPWHMHW]WGLH)UDJHQDFKGHU'DPH :LQQLHNRPPHQGLHHUª]XIlOOLJ©LP.XUSDUNJHWURIIHQKDW 'LH)UDJHIlOOWQLFKW9RQ:LHVHQHFNZLQNWVRJDUDE1HLQ YRQ:LQQLH:LQNHOPDQQZHLHUDQVFKHLQHQGQLFKWVHUKDW ZRKOQXUDXIGHQ%XVFKJHNORSIW'DJHKW'HWMHQVHLQHUVHLWV ]XP$QJULIIEHUª6RVFK|QGLH)DKUWZDULFKEHUHXHVLH 0HLQH:RKQXQJLVWGXUFKVXFKWZRUGHQZlKUHQGLFKDE ZHVHQGZDU=XP*OFNIHKOWQLFKWV6RQVWKlWWHLFKQDWUOLFK GLH.ULSRYHUVWlQGLJW©
'HU*HQHUDOSDIIWª$FK":LHKDEHQ6LHGDVIHVWJHVWHOOW"© $FKLPJULQVWª'UEHQLQ$UJHQWLQLHQJDEHVHLQH0HQJH HUIDKUHQHU6LFKHUKHLWVOHXWH+HUU*HQHUDO'LHHUZlKQWHQ JHOHJHQWOLFKPDOHLQSDDUHLQIDFKH.QLIIHGHUHQ$QZHQGXQJ GDYRUEHZDKUHQNDQQGXPP]XVWHUEHQ0LUKDWGDVJHIDOOHQ 8QGGLHVFKOLFKWH+DDUVLFKHUXQJDQPHLQHP6FKUHLEWLVFKLVW JHVWHUQDXFKSURPSWEHUVHKHQZRUGHQ© 9RQ:LHVHQHFNQLFNWª,QGHU7DW,FKGDQNH,KQHQIU,KUH (KUOLFKNHLW'HWMHQ:LHLFKLPPHUJHVDJWKDEH'LHDOWHQ $UJHQWLQLHUVLQGHLQEHVRQGHUHV9|ONFKHQ1D,KUHIDPRVH +DDUVLFKHUXQJNULHJWGHU(EHUVEDFKSRVWZHQGHQGDXIV%XW WHUEURW© 'DVLVWHLQ(LQJHVWlQGQLV ª:DUXP+HUU*HQHUDO"© 9RQ:LHVHQHFNKDQWLHUWPLWGHP3IHLIHQEHVWHFNª(VZlUH PLUOLHEHU6LHKlWWHQHVQLFKWEHPHUNW6RZLHZLUPLWHLQDQGHU VWHKHQXQVYHUELQGHWYLHOHV:HQQLFKGDQXUDQ,KUHQ(LQVDW] DOV9HUVLFKHUXQJVGHWHNWLYLQ3RUWXJDOGHQNH$QGHUHUVHLWV(V JLEW'LQJHGLHHLQIDFKJHWDQZHUGHQPVVHQRKQH$QVHKHQ GHU3HUVRQRKQH5FNVLFKWDXILQGLYLGXHOOH6\PSDWKLHQRGHU $QWLSDWKLHQ:HQQHLQVR KRKHU2IIL]LHUZLH%ULQNPDQQDXI VROFKH:HLVHDXVGHP/HEHQVFKHLGHWELQLFKJH]ZXQJHQLQ VHLQHP8PIHOG]XUHFKHUFKLHUHQ© ª'DIUKDEHLFKYROOHV9HUVWlQGQLV+HUU*HQHUDO©HUZLGHUW $FKLP(ULVWLQ%RQQLPPHUDOVYRUELOGOLFKHU6ROGDWDXI JHWUHWHQGDVPXDXFKVREOHLEHQ8QGGLH%HNDQQWVFKDIWPLW GHP0$'*HQHUDOKDWLKPJHQXW]WHUNDQQXQGGDUIVLHVLFK QLFKWGXUFK(PSILQGOLFKNHLWHQYHUVFKHU]HQ'HWMHQVSULQJW DXIDOVVLFKYRQ:LHVHQHFNHUKHEW ª,FKKDEHQLFKWVDQGHUHVHUZDUWHW©(UWULWWZLHGHUDQV )HQVWHUª(VLVWGRFKPHUNZUGLJ(LQ0DQQOHJW+DQGDQVLFK ZHLOHURIIHQVLFKWOLFKQLFKWPLW'LIIHUHQ]HQIHUWLJJHZRUGHQ LVWGLHHV]ZLVFKHQLKPXQGYRUJHVHW]WHQbPWHUQJHJHEHQKDW )KOWVLFKYHUNDQQWPLDFKWHWYLHOOHLFKWVRJDUYHUODFKW 1DWUOLFKLVWHUVLFKEHZXWGDHUPLWVHLQHP)UHLWRGZH QLJVWHQVLQGHQXQWHUULFKWHWHQ.UHLVHQ$XIVHKHQHUUHJW
:DUXPKDWHUGLHVHV$XIVHKHQQLFKWJHQXW]WXPQRFKHLQPDO DXIVHLQH3UREOHPHDXIPHUNVDP]XPDFKHQ":LUJHKHQGDYRQ DXVGDGHU0DQQHWZDVKLQWHUODVVHQKDEHQPX'DVHUNOlUW XQVHUH$NWLYLWlWHQGHQQGHU3RVWHQGHQ%ULQNPDQQLQQH KDWWHXQGGLH,QIRUPDWLRQHQGLHLKP]XJlQJOLFKZDUHQOHJHQ GLH9HUPXWXQJQDKHGDVHLQ1DFKODLQXQULFKWLJH+lQGH JHODQJW6LHYHUVWHKHQ"© ª,FKYHUVWHKH+HUU*HQHUDO© (UYHUVWHKWYRUDOOHPGDGHU0$'2IIL]LHUGLH6HOEVW PRUGYDULDQWHDXIUHFKWHUKlOWXPVHLQH1DFKIRUVFKXQJHQ]X PRWLYLHUHQ%HL-DJGXQIlOOHQJLEWHVNHLQHHQWVSUHFKHQGH +LQWHUODVVHQVFKDIWZHLOVLHXQYRUKHUJHVHKHQXQGEHU UDVFKHQGHLQWUHWHQ'HU9HUGDFKWGHQ:HUQHUXQG:LQQLH EHVSURFKHQKDEHQJHZLQQWQHXH1DKUXQJ 9RQ:LHVHQHFNNORSIWGLHOHHUJHEUDQQWH3IHLIHDXV(U UHFKQHVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKGDPLWVDJWHUGD'HWMHQKLHULP $PW$XJHQXQG2KUHQRIIHQKDOWHXQGLKQYHUVWlQGLJHZHQQ LUJHQGZHOFKHQHXHQ*HVLFKWVSXQNWH(UVHLMDKLHU]X +DXVHXQGLKPJHJHQEHUZUGHQGLH+HUUHQ.DPHUDGHQ JHZLNHLQ%ODWWYRUGHQ0XQGQHKPHQ9LHOOHLFKWJHEHHV %H]LHKXQJHQ%ULQNPDQQV]X'ULWWHQYRQGHQHQQRFKQLHPDQG ZLVVH0|JOLFKHUZHLVHVWRHHUDXIVRHWZDVGDHUMDQXQZRKO DPWLHUHQGHU5HIHUDWVOHLWHUVHL ª=ZDQJVOlXILJ©UlXPW$FKLPHLQªELVHLQ1DFKIROJHUIU GHQ+HUUQ2EHUVWJHIXQGHQLVW© ª:HQQLFKKLHUZDV]XVDJHQKlWWH'HWMHQ6RODQJHZLH6LH VFKRQEHLP%XQGVLQG'D]X,KUH.ULHJVHUIDKUXQJ8QGHLQ DOWHU$UJHQWLQLHUVLQG6LHDXFK© $FKLPJLEWVLFKJHVFKPHLFKHOW$EHUHUGHQNWGHU+LPPHO P|JHLKQGDYRUEHZDKUHQGLH7UHSSHKLQDXIXQGDXI%ULQN PDQQV6WXKO]XIDOOHQ-HK|KHUHULQGHU0LOLWlUKLHUDUFKLH VWHLJWXQGGDHUVWHLJWLVWXQYHUPHLGOLFKXQWHUGHQRE ZDOWHQGHQ8PVWlQGHQXQGGDQNGHUª9HUGLHQVWH©GHVHKH PDOLJHQ-DJGIOLHJHUDV $FKLP'HWMHQGHVWRPHKUZLUGDXFK VHLQH%HZHJXQJVIUHLKHLWHLQJHHQJW$OVHUDOV.U|VLQJV$G MXWDQWDXV6GDPHULNDLQGLH%5'NDPZDUVHLQ$NWLRQV
UDGLXVSUDNWLVFKXQEHJUHQ]W(UVFKUXPSIWHPHKUXQGPHKU MHJU|HUGDV5HIHUDWZXUGHXQGMHZLFKWLJHUH$XIJDEHQLKP EHUWUDJHQZXUGHQ8PVRPHKU/HXWHLKQNDQQWHQXPVR PHKUVWDQGHULP%OLFNIHOG8QGZHQQPDQLKQQXQJDUDXI %ULQNPDQQV6HVVHONDWDSXOWLHUWGDQQLVWHVY|OOLJDXVGHQQ HLQ5HIHUDWVOHLWHUWXWZHQLJªYRU2UW©GRUWKLQEHILHKOWHU DQGHUHXQGOlWVLFK%HULFKWHUVWDWWHQ,QGHU1DWXUGHU6DFKH OLHJWGDVROFKH%HULFKWHUVWDWWXQJDQGHUH6FKZHUSXQNWH KDEHQPXDOVVLHVLFKHLQ.XQGVFKDIWHUVWHOOHQZUGH 6ROOHUVLFKNQIWLJJDQ]DXIGLH$XVZHUWXQJGHU0DWHULDOLHQ EHVFKUlQNHQGLHEHUVHLQHQ6FKUHLEWLVFKJHKHQ"'DVLVW QDWUOLFKXQJHKHXHUZLFKWLJEORGDVDOOHLQPDFKWLKQQLFKW JOFNOLFK(UKDWUHFKWJHUQHLQELFKHQ:LQGXPGLH1DVH ,P9RU]LPPHUOlWYRQ:LHVHQHFNGLH0LWDUEHLWHUGHV 5HIHUDWV]XVDPPHQUXIHQHLQ'XW]HQG0lQQHULQ8QLIRUPHQ )UDX0DUVFKQHUXQGGUHLZHLWHUH=LYLODQJHVWHOOWH6FKUHLE NUlIWH ª,FKELQEHDXIWUDJW©HUNOlUW'HWMHQVSU|GHª6LHYRQIRO JHQGHPLQ.HQQWQLV]XVHW]HQ8QVHUKRFKYHUHKUWHU&KHI +HUU2EHUVW%ULQNPDQQKDWLQGHU1DFKWYRP6DPVWDJ]XP 6RQQWDJLQVHLQHP-DJGKDXV6HOEVWPRUGEHJDQJHQ$QGLHVHP 6DFKYHUKDOWEHVWHKWQDFKGHQ(UNHQQWQLVVHQGHV0LOLWlULVFKHQ $EVFKLUPGLHQVWHVNHLQ=ZHLIHO:LUZHUGHQGHP7RWHQHLQ HKUHQGHV$QGHQNHQEHZDKUHQ,FKELWWH6LH*HUFKWHQHQW JHJHQ]XWUHWHQGLHLP=XVDPPHQKDQJPLWGHP7RGDXI NRPPHQN|QQWHQ0LWGHU:DKUQHKPXQJGHU*HVFKlIWHGHV 5HIHUDWVELQLFKEHDXIWUDJW*LEWHVGD]X)UDJHQ",FKGDQNH ,KQHQ© $OVHUZLHGHUDQVHLQHP6FKUHLEWLVFKVLW]WEULQJWLKP)UDX 0DUVFKQHU.DIIHH%HWURIIHQZDUHQDOOHDEHUVLHKDWJHZHLQW )UDX0DUVFKQHULVWYRQ$QIDQJDQGDEHLVLHKDWGLH&KHIV NRPPHQXQGJHKHQVHKHQXQGLVWLKQHQDOOHQXQHQWEHKUOLFK JHZHVHQ ª6RZLH%ULQNPDQQKDWXQVQRFKNHLQHUYHUODVVHQ©VDJWVLH OHLVHª'DVSDWJDUQLFKW]XLKPDEHUZHQQHVGHU0$' IHVWJHVWHOOWKDWZLUGHVZRKOVWLPPHQ©
$FKLPQLFNWQXU'DQQZLHGHUDOOHLQNHKUWHUPLWVHLQHQ *HGDQNHQ]XGHP%ULHI]XUFN(UNRPPWQLFKWGDYRQORV YRQ:LHVHQHFNV%HKDXSWXQJ%ULQNPDQQPVVHHWZDVKLQWHU ODVVHQKDEHQXQGGLHLPPHUQRFKYHUJHEOLFKH6XFKHYRQ ª%RQQHLQV©]ZLQJHQLKQI|UPOLFKVHLQH3KDQWDVLHVSLHOHQ]X ODVVHQ:HVKDOEGUlQJWHGHU2EHUVWGHQ(PSIlQJHUGHVXQ YROOHQGHWHQ%ULHIHVVRGDV%LOGGHVª:LOGEUHWKlQGOHUV©JH ZLVVHUPDHQPLW(IIHNWEHOHXFKWXQJ]XEHWUDFKWHQ":DV VROOWHGHQQGDEHL]XWDJHWUHWHQ" (U WURPPHOWQHUY|VPLWGHQ)LQJHUVSLW]HQDXIVHLQH*ODV SODWWHXQGVWDUUWDXIGDV)RWRGDVGDUXQWHUOLHJW*URIRU PDWLJXQGKRFKJOlQ]HQG]HLJWHVHLQH0HPLWEXQW VFKHFNLJHP7DUQDQVWULFKMHQHQ)OXJ]HXJW\SGHQGHUHFKWH $FKLP'HWMHQELV]XVHLQHP$EVFKX EHUGHU6RZMHW XQLRQIORJ0LWVHLQHQ6WXQGHQNLORPHWHUQHLQPDODOVGDV ªVFKQHOOVWH/DQGIOXJ]HXJGHU:HOW©JHIHLHUWZDUGLHVHU 6WDQGDUGMlJHUGHUIDVFKLVWLVFKHQGHXWVFKHQ/XIWZDIIHYRQ DQGHQDOOLLHUWHQ-DJGIOXJ]HXJHQEHUHLWVXQWHUOHJHQ 'HQQRFKZXUGHHUELV]XP.ULHJVHQGHZHLWHUJHEDXW'DV)RWR KLHUJHK|UW]XU/HJHQGH:HUQHU%UHGHEXVFKVDOVHLQ6WFN ªOLHEH©(ULQQHUXQJ 9RP)HQVWHUKHUIlOOW/LFKWDXIGLH*ODVSODWWHXQGHU]HXJW 5HIOH[H(VOHJWDXFK*ODQ]SXQNWHDXIGDV)RWRDXIGDV %DONHQNUHX]XQGGHQGUHLIOJOLJHQ3URSHOOHU:UGHPDQGHQ ª:LOGEUHWKlQGOHU©VREHOHXFKWHQZDVZUGHHVGD]XVHKHQ JHEHQ" (UNRPPWQLFKWGDUDXIHUPXVLFKGDV%LOGQRFKHLQPDO DQVFKDXHQ
$ORLV0HQ]HOLVWHLQ=HLWXQJVOHVHUEHVRQGHUHU$UW(UKDWEHLP /HVHQLPPHUHLQHQ%OHLVWLIWLQGHU+DQGXQGPDFKWJHOHJHQW OLFKKLHUXQGGDHLQHQGQQHQ6WULFK0HLVWVLQGHV7RGHV
DQ]HLJHQGLHLKQEHVFKlIWLJHQRGHUDXFK0HOGXQJHQYRP $EOHEHQPHKURGHUZHQLJHUEHGHXWHQGHU3HUV|QOLFKNHLWHQ6R HLQHKDWHUMHW]WYRUVLFKª9DUQGRUI(LIHO8QWHUQRFKQLFKW QlKHUJHNOlUWHQ8PVWlQGHQNDPDP:RFKHQHQGHLQVHLQHU -DJGKWWHQDKHEHL9DUQGRUIGHU-DJGSlFKWHU%ULQNPDQQXPV /HEHQ%ULQNPDQQGHULP5DQJHHLQHV2EHUVWHQGHU/XIW ZDIIHVWDQGXQGGDV+DXVYRU-DKUHQYRQGHPDOOVHLWV JHDFKWHWHQ%DXXQWHUQHKPHU/XFLXV%RFNEHUQRPPHQKDWWH JHQRLQGHQ-lJHUNUHLVHQGHU8PJHEXQJKRKHV$QVHKHQYRU DOOHPGDQNGHUEHPKWHQ3IOHJHGHV1LHGHUZLOGHVGDVLKP EHVRQGHUVDP+HU]HQODJ,QVEHVRQGHUHKDWVLFK2EHUVW%ULQN PDQQXPGLH(LQIXKUXQG$QVLHGOXQJGHVLQGHU9HUJDQJHQKHLW JlQ]OLFKDXVJHURWWHWHQ)DVDQVYHUGLHQWJHPDFKW:LHGLH 5HGDNWLRQHUIlKUWZXUGHGHU/HLFKQDPGHVEHJHLVWHUWHQ :HLGPDQQHVLQ]ZLVFKHQLQVHLQHQ+HLPDWRUWEHUJHIKUW© $ORLV0HQ]HOOHJWGHQª(LIHO.XULHU©EHLVHLWHUFNWVHLQH 1LFNHOEULOOHK|KHUDXIGLH1DVHXQGGHQNWQDFK(LQ-DJG SlFKWHUDOVRGD]XHLQ2EHUVWHLQJXWVLWXLHUWHU0DQQ8QG HUKDWGLH-DJGKWWHODQJHJHKDEW'DVKHLWHUKDWHVVLFKGDULQ DQJHQHKPXQGEHKDJOLFKJHPDFKW9LHOOHLFKW9LHOOHLFKW DXFKQLFKW(UNDQQMDPLWHLQHP)HOGEHWWDXVJHNRPPHQ VHLQ'DVZlUHDEHUVHKUlUJHUOLFK 'HU0DQQVWHKWDXINUDPWLP6FKUDQNXQGOHJWDXIGHQ 7LVFKHLQHQJDQ]HQ6WR/DQGNDUWHQYRQGHU$UWGLH7DQN VWHOOHQDOV:HUEHJHVFKHQNHGHU0LQHUDO|OILUPHQYHUWHLOHQ ZHQQHLQHUPHKUDOVGUHLLJ/LWHUWDQNW0HQ]HOVXFKWXQG ILQGHWGDVULFKWLJH%ODWWXQGIlKUWQDFK9DUQGRUIYRUHUVWQXU PLWGHP)LQJHUDXIGHU.DUWH(UEHUUHFKQHWGLH(QWIHUQXQJ YRQ)UDQNIXUWXQGZLHJWGHQ.RSI$QV)HQVWHUVWHOOWHUVLFK XQGVFKDXWKLQDXVDXIGHQ6GEDKQKRIGXUFKGHQIDVWODXWORV GLHHOHNWULVFKHQ=JHIDKUHQ,QGHU1DFKPLWWDJVVRQQHJOlQ ]HQGLHDOXPLQLXPEHSODQNWHQ:DJHQ 0HQ]HOVLHKWDXIGLH8KU(UOLHJWJXWLQGHU=HLW:HQQVLH JOHLFKORVIKUHQZlUHQVLHQRFKYRU$QEUXFKGHU'XQNHOKHLW LQ9DUQGRUIN|QQWHQVLFKRULHQWLHUHQXQGGDV'LQJLQDOOHU 5XKHDXVEDOGRZHUQ6ROOHURGHUVROOHUQLFKW"(UILQJHUWHLQ
*HOGVWFNDXVGHU+RVHQWDVFKHZLUIWHVKRFKXQGIlQJWHVDXI (VLVWHLQ*URVFKHQXQGGLH5FNVHLWHVLHKWLKQDQ)QI (LFKHQEOlWWHUKDEHQIU$ORLVHWZDV6ROLGHVLQLKUHP=HLFKHQ KDWHUELVKHULPPHU*OFNJHKDEWVRRIWHUGLH0Q]HDXFK ZDUI (UJHKWDQV7HOHIRQGDVLP)OXUVWHKWZlKOWHLQH1XPPHU XQGELWWHWGLH)UDXGLHVLFKPHOGHW)UDQ]DQGHQ$SSDUDW]X UXIHQ(UKlWWHGDZDVVDJWHUGDQQXQGZHQQ)UDQ]KHXWH DEHQG=HLWKDEHXQGPLWLKPDUEHLWHQZROOH )UDQ]VDJW]X ª,FKIDKUHQRFKPDOZHJ/\GLD©ZHQGHWVLFK0HQ]HODQ VHLQH)UDXGLHXQWHUGHVVHQLQGHQ)OXUJHNRPPHQLVWª,FK ELQQDWUOLFK]XP'LHQVW© ª0LW P)UDQ]MD"©IUDJWVLH]XUFNª1LPPGHQZDUPHQ 3XOORYHU$ORLVXQGGHQNDQGHLQH1LHUHQ,QGHU(LIHOLVWHV QDFKWVNDOW© (U]LHKWK|UEDUGLH/XIWGXUFKGLH1DVHª+DVWGXZLHGHU VSLRQLHUWZDV",FKKDVVHGDV/\GLD8QGGXZHLWGDVJDQ] JHQDX© 6LHPXGDVOHW]WH:RUWKDEHQª:HQQLFKGHLQH=HLWXQJHQ QLFKWLPPHUYHUEUHQQHQZUGHGLH%XOOHQZlUHQGLUVFKRQ OlQJVWDXIGLH6FKOLFKHJHNRPPHQ,FKPHLQHHVQXUJXW© ª,VWMDJHULW]W©HUZLGHUWHUEUXPPHQGXQGNORSIWLKUDXIGHQ +LQWHUQª9HUJLGHQbSSHOZRLQLFKW,FKEUDXFKHLKQGD QDFK© ª'HQKDEHLFKMDZRKOQRFKQLHYHUJHVVHQ© .XU]GDUDXIYHUOlW0HQ]HOGDV+DXV(UKDWGLH-RSSH RIIHQXQGXQWHUP$UPGLHDEJHZHW]WH$NWHQWDVFKHDXVGHU GLH7KHUPRVIODVFKHUDJW-HGHQ7DJJHKWHUVRVHLQHQ'LHQVW DOV1DFKWZlFKWHUHLQHUVWLOOJHOHJWHQ)DEULNLQ3UDXQKHLP DQ]XWUHWHQHLQHQLFKWVVDJHQGH(UVFKHLQXQJIQI]LJMlKULJ XQGNDKON|SILJHLQEHVFKHLGHQHU$OOWDJVPHQVFKGHUQXUQRFK JHULQJH$QVSUFKHDQGDV/HEHQVWHOOWIUHXQGOLFKKLOIVEHUHLW LPPHUJHZLOOWHLQHQWURSIHQGHQ:DVVHUKDKQ]XUHSDULHUHQ RGHUHLQHQYHUVWRSIWHQ$XVJX]XUHLQLJHQ(ULVWLQGHP+DXV PLWGHQ]ZHLXQG]ZDQ]LJ0LHWVSDUWHVHQHLQHJHDFKWHWHMD
XQHQWEHKUOLFKH3HUV|QOLFKNHLW1LHPDQGZHLGD$ORLV 0HQ]HOHKHHUKLHUKHU]RJXP+DDUHVEUHLWHHLQHUJHSIHIIHU WHQ*HIlQJQLVVWUDIHZHJHQIRUWJHVHW]WHQHLQIDFKHQXQG VFKZHUHQ'LHEVWDKOVQXUGDGXUFKHQWJLQJGDLKPVHLQH MHW]LJH)UDXHLQKDQGIHVWHV$OLELYHUVFKDIIWH'HQQVHLWKHULVW $ORLV0HQ]HOLQGHQ$NWHQGHU)UDQNIXUWHU3ROL]HLQLFKW ZLHGHUDQKlQJLJJHZRUGHQ :lKUHQGHUPLWGHU6WUDHQEDKQHUVW]XP*RHWKHSODWH IlKUWGRUWXPVWHLJWXQGPLWHLQHUDQGHUHQ/LQLHGLH)DKUWQDFK 3UDXQKHLPIRUWVHW]WGHQNW0HQ]HODQMHQHDOWHQ=HLWHQ'LH IDOOHQLKPLPPHUHLQZHQQHUHLQQHXHV8QWHUQHKPHQDQIlQJW 'DVZDUHQ*HVFKlIWH'DPDOVKDWHULQGHU9ROWDVWUDHJH ZRKQWJDQ]QDKHDP*WHUEDKQKRIXQGPDQFKH:DJJRQV JLQJHQZLHYRQDOOHLQDXI9RUDOOHPPLWQXUHLQHPELFKHQ 1DFKKLOIHGLHGLHLQ%UHPHUKDYHQGHQ.RQVHUYHQQDFKVFKXE IUGLH86$UP\DXIJHQRPPHQKDWWHQXQGHVZDUNXU]QDFK GHP=XVDPPHQEUXFKGHU6FKZDU]PDUNWSUHLVHQRUPKRFK (LQH6WDQJHª&DPHO©VWHOOWHHLQ9HUP|JHQGDU1DMD $ORLV0HQ]HOZLUGEHKHQGHVREDOGHUGLH)DEULNEHWUHWHQ KDW'DIlOOWDOOH*HPlFKOLFKNHLWYRQLKPDE'LH$NWHQWDVFKH PLWGHU7KHUPRVIODVFKHVWHOOWHUDFKWORVEHLVHLWH8QWHU0D VFKLQHQWHLOHQ]LHKWHUHLQHIODFKH:HUN]HXJNLVWHPLW7UD JHULHPHQKHUYRUZLHVLH0RQWHXUHEHQXW]HQ+LQHLQ]XVHKHQ LVWEHUIOVVLJDOOHVLVWDQVHLQHP3ODW]VDXEHUJHRUGQHW IXQNWLRQVWFKWLJ0HQ]HOWUlJWGLH.LVWHLQHLQHOHHUH+DOOH KLQXQWHUXQG]LHKWHLQH3ODQHZHJ'DVWHKWVHLQ.OHLQWUDQV SRUWHUIDKUEHUHLWHLQ:DJHQXQEHVWLPPEDUHQ7\SV,QGHU JDQ]HQ6WUDHLQGHU0HQ]HOZRKQWZHLQLHPDQGGDHU EHUKDXSWHLQ)DKU]HXJEHVLW]W(UEHU]HXJWVLFKGD%H OHXFKWXQJXQG%UHPVOLFKWHUHLQZDQGIUHLIXQNWLRQLHUHQ 1XQQRFKHLQ.OHLGXQJVZHFKVHO,QHLQHYHUZDVFKHQH 0RQWHXUNRPELQDWLRQVFKOSIWHURKQH]XYHUJHVVHQGHQYRQ /\GLDLQGLH$NWHQWDVFKHJHVWRSIWHQ3XOORYHUXQWHU]X]LHKHQ VWHLJWLQVHLQ$XWRXQGYHUOlWGLHHKHPDOLJH0DVFKLQHQIDEULN /DQJZLW] 6|KQHGXUFKHLQHKLQWHUH$XVIDKUW'HUDOWH *HElXGHNRPSOH[GHUGHPQlFKVWDEJHULVVHQZHUGHQXQGDQ
GHVVHQ6WHOOHHLQHQDJHOQHXH3URGXNWLRQVVWlWWHHQWVWHKHQVROO EOHLEWGVWHUXQGGXQNHO]XUFNXQGZHQLJVSlWHUQLPPW 0HQ]HODP2UWVDXVJDQJYRQ2EHUXUVHO)UDQ]DQ%RUG'HU KRFNWGDDOVKDEHHUHLQH3DQQHQHEHQVHLQHP0RSHG6LH VFKLHEHQGDV.UDGKLQWHQDXIGLH/DGHIOlFKHXQGEHIHVWLJHQ HVPLW5LHPHQDQGHU6HLWHQZDQG'LH6FKQHOOLJNHLWPLWGHU GDVYRUVLFKJHKWYHUUlWhEXQJ'DQQJHKWGLH)DKUWZHLWHU ,UJHQGZRXQWHUZHJVKDOWHQVLHEHVWHOOHQLQHLQHU/DQGJDVW VWlWWHHLQSDDU:UVWHXQG&RODXQGNDXIHQHLQH=HKQHU SDFNXQJ$O&DSRQH=LJDUUHQ 6SlWHUKDOWHQVLHLP:DOG]LHPOLFKZHLWHQWIHUQWQRFKYRQ %ULQNPDQQV-DJGKWWH'DV0RSHGZLUGZLHGHUDEJHODGHQ XQG0HQ]HOVFKZLQJWVLFKKLQWHU)UDQ]DXIGLH6LW]EDQN'HU 0DQQLQGHU0RQWHXUNRPELQDWLRQKlOWMHW]WHLQHQ%HQ]LQ NDQLVWHULQGHU+DQG(VN|QQWHLKQHQMDMHPDQGEHJHJQHQXQG GHUVROOGDQQGHQNHQGHUbOWHUHVHLPLWVHLQHP:DJHQOLHJHQ JHEOLHEHQXQGKDEHGHQ-QJHUHQGD]XEHZHJHQLKQ]XUQlFK VWHQ7DQNVWHOOHXQG]XUFN]XEULQJHQ'LH.OHLQLJNHLWHQKD EHQHV0HQ]HODQJHWDQ 1HLQVLHVLQGQLFKW]XHLQHUODQJZLHULJHQ6XFKDNWLRQJH ]ZXQJHQ9RQGHU/DQGJDVWVWlWWHDXVKDW$ORLVQlPOLFKGHQ 9DUQGRUIHU%UJHUPHLVWHUDQJHUXIHQª%LOG]HLWXQJ+DPEXUJ 6FKU|GHU©KDWHUJHVDJWXQGVLFKEHPKWVHLQHU6WLPPHHLQ ZHQLJ6FKQHLG]XJHEHQ'DVKDWHUVFKRQ|IWHUJHPDFKWXQG GLH0DVFKH]LHKWLPPHUª:LUKDEHQGDHLQH6WRU\EHU%ULQN PDQQ6LHPVVHQLKQJHNDQQWKDEHQ6DJHQ6LHGRFKPDOGUHL 6lW]HEHULKQ,KUJDQ]SHUV|QOLFKHU(LQGUXFN",PPHU]X,FK QRWLHUHVFKRQ1DWUOLFKEHNRPPHQ6LHHLQ+RQRUDU:XQ GHUEDU:ROLHJWGHQQHLJHQWOLFKGLHVHV-DJGKDXV":LHNRPPW GHU)RWRJUDIGDKLQ"© 0LWVROFKHP:LVVHQDXVJHVWDWWHWIDKUHQVLHJHQDXDXILKU =LHO]X *HQHUDOYRQ:LHVHQHFNOHJWGHQ%ULHIODQJVDPDXIGHQ7LVFK ]XUFNXQGQLFNW+DXSWPDQQ(EHUVEDFKDQHUNHQQHQG]X ª6HKUJXW©EHPHUNWHUª,FKGDQNH,KQHQGD6LHPLFKVRIRUW YHUVWlQGLJWKDEHQ©
'HU+DXSWPDQQYHU]LHKWNHLQH0LHQH9RQ:LHVHQHFNVLHKW LKQNDXP,PSULYDWHQ$UEHLWV]LPPHUGHV*HQHUDOVEUHQQWQXU GLH6FKUHLEWLVFKODPSHXQGLKU/LFKWJHQJWQLFKWGHQJURHQ 5DXPDXV]XOHXFKWHQ(UYHUVLQNWLP'XQNHOQXQGLQGLHVHU 'XQNHOKHLWYHUVFKZLQGHW(EHUVEDFKLQVHLQHPEODXHQ1\ORQ PDQWHOXQGPLWGHP+XWLQGHU+DQGª$OOHVDQGHUHZDU XQLQWHUHVVDQWIQIXQGYLHU]LJ%HLOHLGVWHOHJUDPPHHLQKXQ GHUWIQI]LJJHGUXFNWH.RQGXODWLRQHQVLHEHQXQG]ZDQ]LJ +DQGVFKUHLEHQGLHVHVQLFKWPLWJH]lKOW© ª%LVMHW]W©VFKUlQNWGHU*HQHUDOHLQª'LH3RVWEHU ZDFKXQJZLUGELVDXIZHLWHUHVDXIUHFKWHUKDOWHQ© ª=X%HIHKO+HUU*HQHUDO© ª:DVPHOGHW5HJHQVEXUJ"© ª.HLQHEHVRQGHUHQ9RUNRPPQLVVH+HUU*HQHUDO1LFKWV ZDV$QODJHEHQN|QQWH5HFKHUFKHQDQ]XVWHOOHQ©'HU +DXSWPDQQUlXVSHUWVLFKª:DVEHIHKOHQ6LH]XYHUDQODVVHQ"© ª,FKEHKDOWHGHQ%ULHIKLHU©HQWJHJQHWYRQ:LHVHQHFNXQG VWHKWDXI ª*XWH1DFKW+HUU*HQHUDO© 'HU*HQHUDOJUHLIW]XP+|UHUZlKOW,QVHLQHU'LHQVWVWHOOH PHOGHWVLFKGHUGLHQVWKDEHQGH2IIL]LHUQXUPLWGHU7HOH IRQQXPPHURKQH'LHQVWJUDG1DPHQXQG$PW]XQHQQHQ ª9RQ:LHVHQHFN,FKEUDXFKHVRIRUWDOOH$QJDEHQEHU HLQHQ1RWLHUHQ6LHPDO6LU5HJLQDOG'RXJODV%UVVHO5XH GH6XLVVHRGHU6ZLW]HUODQG6WUDDW1XPPHUDFKWXQGYLHU]LJ 9HUPXWOLFKEHLP1$72+HDGTXDUWHUV5XIHQ6LH]XUFN JOHLFKJOWLJZLHODQJHHVGDXHUW© (UQLPPWZLHGHU3ODW]XQGJUHLIWQHXHUOLFK]XP7HOHIRQ'LH 5+(,10$,1'(7(.7(,DQ]XZlKOHQKlOWHUIU]ZHFNORV HUUXIWJOHLFKEHL%RUQ]X+DXVHDQª,FKP|FKWH6LHPRUJHQ IUKXPKDOEDFKW8KUEHLPLUVHKHQ©VDJWHUNQDSSª%HLPLU LQ%DG*RGHVEHUJ(QGH© 'HU*HQHUDOOHJWDXIUDXFKWEOLFNWDXIGHQ$SSDUDW'HU VFKZHLJW9RQ:LHVHQHFNZDUWHW,PJHOEOLFKHQ/LFKWNUHLVGHU 6FKUHLEWLVFKODPSHOLHJWGHU%ULHI (QGOLFK'LH7HOHIRQNOLQJHO
ª-D"© ª'LHDQJHIUDJWH3HUVRQ+HUU*HQHUDO6LU5HJLQDOG'RX JODVJHERUHQHUVWHQ]Z|OIWHQ]HKQ&RORQHOGHU5R\DO$LU )RUFH:lKUHQGGHV.ULHJHV&KHIGHV6WDEHVEHLP%H IHKOVKDEHUGHUHOIWHQ*URXS5$)/XIWPDUVFKDOO.HLWK3DUN )U9HUGLHQVWHXPGLH9HUWHLGLJXQJGHV/RQGRQHU/XIWUDXPV KRFKGHNRULHUW,KPZLUGZHVHQWOLFKHU$QWHLODQGHU(QWZLFN OXQJGHU6SH]LIL]LHUXQJYRQ.DPSIDXIWUlJHQIUGLH-DJG VWDIIHOQGHV)LJKWHU&RPPDQG]XJHVFKULHEHQQDFKGHUYRQ LKPPLWJHVFKDIIHQHQ7DNWLNJULIIHQGLHVFKQHOOHUVWHLJHQGHQ 6SLWILUHHLQIOLHJHQGHGHXWVFKH-DJGXQGGLHODQJVDPVWHLJHQ GHQ+XUULFDQH%RPEHUYHUElQGHDQ'XUFKGLHVH7DNWLNGHU %ULWHQVWLHJHQGDPDOVGLHGHXWVFKHQ9HUOXVWHVHKU6LU5H JLQDOGJHK|UWVHLWGUHL-DKUHQGHP/XIWZDIIHQVWDEEHLP 1$72+HDGTXDUWHUVDQ(ULVWYHUKHLUDWHWPLW© ª'DQNH©XQWHUEULFKWYRQ:LHVHQHFNª+DEHQZLUHWZDV EHUSHUV|QOLFKH9HUELQGXQJHQ]XHLJHQHQ2IIL]LHUHQ"© ª,FKEHGDXUH+HUU*HQHUDO%HIHKOHQ6LHEHLP%I9QDFK ]XIDVVHQ"© ª1HLQ© $XFKQRFKGDV%XQGHVDPWIU9HUIDVVXQJVVFKXW]DXI PHUNVDP]XPDFKHQZLGHUVWUHEWLKP'DIULVWLKPGLH6DFKH GRFK]XGHOLNDWMHZHQLJHU/HXWHYRQLKUZLVVHQGHVWREHVVHU 8QGZDVHUHUIDKUHQZROOWHZHLHU%HVRQGHUVKHLWHUVWLPPW HVLKQQLFKW%HXQUXKLJHQGHU*HGDQNH%ULQNPDQQV1DFKOD N|QQWHDXVJHUHFKQHWLQGLH+lQGHMHQHVDGOLJHQ/XIWZDI IHQREHUVWHQ,KUHUEULWLVFKHQ0DMHVWlWJHUDWHQVHLQ'HUKDWLQ GHU©/XIWVFKODFKWXP(QJODQGªKLQOlQJOLFK%HNDQQWVFKDIWPLW +LWOHUV.ULHJVPDVFKLQHJHPDFKWWRWHXQG YHUZXQGHWH=LYLOLVWHQDOOHLQLP]ZHLWHQ+DOEMDKUZHQQ VLFKYRQ:LHVHQHFNULFKWLJHULQQHUW8QYHUVWlQGOLFKGDPDQ HLQHQVROFKHQ0DQQEHUKDXSWLQV1$72+DXSWTXDUWLHU VFKLFNW'HUPXGRFKYROOJHVWRSIWVHLQPLW9RUEHKDOWHQXQG 0LWUDXHQJHJHQEHUGHP3DUWQHU%XQGHVUHSXEOLNLPDWODQ WLVFKHQ9HUWHLGLJXQJVV\VWHPGHUPXGRFKGLH)UDJHDXIGHU =XQJHKDEHQVRRIWLKP%RQQHU2IIL]LHUHLQ%ULQNPDQQV$OWHU
JHJHQEHUVWHKHQREGLHQLFKWGLH%RPEHUNRPPDQGLHUW KDEHQGLHHUXQGVHLQH/HXWHDEIDQJHQPXWHQ.DQQHLQ VROFKHU0DQQGLHQHXHVWUDWHJLVFKH/DJHLQ0LWWHOHXURSD REMHNWLYEHXUWHLOHQ")KOWHUVLFKLQVHLQHUKHXWLJHQ3RVLWLRQ QLFKWYLHOPHKUDOVHLQH$UW:DFKKXQGGHUDXISDVVHQPXGD GLHQHXHQ)UHXQGHDQ5KHLQXQG5XKUQLFKW]XPlFKWLJQLFKW ]XDNWLRQVIlKLJZHUGHQXQGGDHVNHLQHXQOLHEVDPHQhEHU UDVFKXQJHQJLEW" 6LU5HJLQDOG'RXJODVXQG2EHUVW%ULQNPDQQNDQQWHQHLQ DQGHU'HU%ULHIOlWGHQ6FKOX]XGDVLHVLFKVRJDUUHFKW JXWNDQQWHQ'DEHLEOHLEWRIIHQRE6LU5HJLQDOGGLHVH9HU ELQGXQJQLFKWYRUZLHJHQGJHSIOHJWKDWXPJHZLVVH,QIRUPD WLRQHQ]XHUKDOWHQ'DV%ULQNPDQQSDSLHULQVHLQHQ+lQGHQ ZlUHGDVQLFKWGDV(QGHGHU&KDQFHLQGLHVHP6RPPHU GLH=XVWlQGHMHQVHLWVGHU(OEHJUXQGVlW]OLFK]XlQGHUQ" 8QYHUVHKHQVKDWGHU*HQHUDO6FKZHLSHUOHQDXIGHU6WLUQ :HQQPDQQXUZWHZDVHVPLWGLHVHPYHUIOXFKWHQ%LOG DXIVLFKKDW(EHUVEDFKXQGVHLQH0lQQHUKDEHQGRFKDOOHV XQWHUVXFKWHUVHOEVWKDWVLFK'HWMHQJHJHQEHU]XPª:LOG EUHWKlQGOHU©JHlXHUWXQGQLFKWPHKUJHVHKHQDOVHLQHJXWH .RSLH:DUXPKDWVLH%ULQNPDQQ6LU5HJLQDOG'RXJODVVR ZDUPDQV+HU]JHOHJW"'DVLVWGRFKVHKUPHUNZUGLJ
=XVSlW$FKLP'HWMHQVWHKWPLWWHQLQGHU-DJGKWWH'HU JUHOOZHLH/LFKWVWUDKOVHLQHU7DVFKHQODPSHWDVWHWEHUGLH =LPPHUZlQGH6LHVLQGOHHUYHUVFKZXQGHQGDV=LQQJHVFKLUU YHUVFKZXQGHQGLHDOWHQ-DJGZDIIHQZHJDXFKª'HU:LOG EUHWKlQGOHU©'LH/HHUHJlKQW (UPDFKWGLH/DPSHDXVVWHKWVFKLHEWJHGDQNHQORVGLH 3LVWROHLQGLH7DVFKH+HUDXVJHQRPPHQKDWHUVLHZHLOGLH7U RIIHQZDUDOVHUHLQWUDI6LH]HLJWHGHXWOLFKH6SXUHQJHZDOW VDPHU(LQZLUNXQJPLWHLQHP%UHFKHLVHQHVKDWWHZRKOVFKQHOO JHKHQVROOHQJHVSOLWWHUWHV+RO]KHOOHUDQGHQ%UXFKVWHOOHQ 6HOWVDPKLOIORVNRPPWHUVLFKYRU$XVHLQHUJUQGOLFKHQ 8QWHUVXFKXQJGHV%LOGHVZLUGQLFKWV(UNDQQVLFKQXUQRFK DXVGHP6WDXEHPDFKHQXQGGHP+LPPHOGDQNHQGDHU
YRUVLFKWVKDOEHUGHQª.lIHU©HLQHQKDOEHQ.LORPHWHUHQWIHUQW DEJHVWHOOWKDW'LH6SXUHQVLFKHUXQJYROOEULQJWPDQFKPDO ZDKUH:XQGHUXQGVLFKHUOLFKZLUGPDQGLHQlKHUH8PJHEXQJ GHV-DJGKDXVHVQDFK5HLIHQDEGUFNHQDEVXFKHQ'HUZHLFKH :DOGERGHQ'HWMHQDWPHWDXIDOVHUZLHGHU$VSKDOWXQWHU GHQ5HLIHQVSUW2EZRKOHUHLJHQWOLFKQLFKWV]XIUFKWHQ EUDXFKWIlKUWHUHLQHQZHLWHQ8PZHJ(UWDQNWXQWHUZHJVXQG OlWGHQ:DJHQVRJDUGXUFKGLH:DVFKDQODJHUROOHQ$OOH 6SXUHQGHU:DOGIDKUWEHVHLWLJHQ(LQ*OFNGDMHGHJU|HUH 7DQNVWHOOHHLQHVROFKH:DVFKDQODJHKDW =ZHL)UDJHQVLQGGD:HULVWLQGLH+WWHHLQJHEURFKHQ" 6LQG.ULPLQHOOHDP:HUNJHZHVHQRGHUZXUGHHLQHNULPLQHOOH +DQGOXQJQXUYRUJHWlXVFKWXP6SXUHQ]XYHUZLVFKHQ":HQQ MDYRQZHP" 9RP0$'QLFKW'HUKlWWHMHGHU]HLWGLH0|JOLFKNHLWJH KDEWGDV%LOGLP5DKPHQVHLQHU1DFKIRUVFKXQJHQ]XGHQ $VVHUYDWHQ]XQHKPHQ9RQZHPGDQQ"'RFK.ULPLQHOOH" $EHUJHUDGH]XGLHVHP=HLWSXQNW":lUHGDQLFKWGHU.D PHUDG=XIDOO!]XYRUGHUJUQGLJLP6SLHO":HUDXHUGHP 0$'"$EHUHVIKUW]XQLFKWVVLFKLQ6SHNXODWLRQHQ]X YHUOLHUHQ9LHOOHLFKWGHU0DQQDQGHQGHUDQJHIDQJHQH%ULHI JHULFKWHWZDU"%ULQNPDQQNDQQLKQQRFKHLQPDOJHVFKULHEHQ NDQQLKQDXFKHLQGHXWLJHUIRUPXOLHUWKDEHQ$EHUGHVKDOE" 'DVLVW8QVLQQ (UZLVFKWGHQ*HGDQNHQZHJXQGHUHUWDSSWVLFKEHLGHU )HVWVWHOOXQJGDHUGDV%LOGQRFKQLHIUVRZLFKWLJJHKDOWHQ KDWZLHMHW]WGDHVLKPQLFKWPHKU]XJlQJOLFKLVW %RUQHUZDUWHW6FKZHGOHUXQG5RORIILQGHU*DVWVWlWWHª=XGHQ GUHL(LFKHQ©'DVLVWGLHVHOEHLQGHUJHVWHUQHLQXQVFKHLQEDUHU NDKON|SILJHU)QI]LJHULPYHUZDVFKHQHQ0RQWHXUDQ]XJ :UVWFKHQJHJHVVHQXQGGHP%UJHUPHLVWHUYRQ9DUQGRUI WHOHIRQLVFKHLQ+RQRUDUGHUª%LOG]HLWXQJ©YHUVSURFKHQKDW 6FKZHGOHUEHVWHOOWVFKRQEHLP%HWUHWHQGHUUXVWLNDOHLQ JHULFKWHWHQ6FKDQNVWXEHPLWGHQEODQNJHVFKHXHUWHQ(LFKHQ WLVFKHQHLQ)UKVWFN5RORII]LHKWPLW'DVZHOWPlQQLVFKH
*HEDUHQVHLQHV.ROOHJHQEHHLQGUXFNWLKQLPPHU(UNRSLHUW HVVRJXWHUNDQQ ª0XGDVVHLQ"©VDJW%RUQNQXUUHQG(UVLHKWDXIGLH8KU ª(VHLOWHLQZHQLJ© :ROI'LHWHU6FKZHGOHUUFNWDP*ROGJHVWHOOVHLQHU%ULOOH XQGHUZLGHUWLQPRNDQWHU:HLVHª%OLQGHU(LIHUVFKDGHWQXU &KHIZLHGDVDOWH6SULFKZRUWVRULFKWLJVDJW©8QGGHU.HOO QHULQGLHMXVWGDV5KUHLPLW6SHFNDXIJHVFKQLWWHQHQ/DQG VFKLQNHQ.UlXWHUEXWWHUQDKH]XXQWHUDUPODQJH%URWVFKHLEHQ YRQHLQHPUXQGHQ/DLEXQGHLQHQ]ZLHEHOJDUQLHUWHQ+DQGNlV VHUYLHUWEHILHKOWHUª$FKOHJHQ6LHIUGHQ+HUUQGRFKDXFK QRFKHLQ*HGHFNDXI©,QGHQ$XJHQGHUMXQJHQ)UDXLVW GDUDXIKLQHUGHU&KHI 'HU.DIIHHLVWDXVJH]HLFKQHW%RUQQLPPWHLQHQ6FKOXFN XQG]LHKWDQVFKOLHHQGVHLQHQ1RWL]EORFNDXVGHU7DVFKH'D VHLQH0LWDUEHLWHUJHQOLFKHVVHQXQGYRUHUVWJDQ]DXIGLHVH VLQQYROOH%HVFKlIWLJXQJNRQ]HQWULHUWVLQGEHUGHQNWHUQRFK HLQPDOGDVNXU]HPRUJHQGOLFKH*HVSUlFKLP+DXVYRQ :LHVHQHFNV$XFKGRUWZXUGHJHUDGHJHIUKVWFNW ª6LHPVVHQZLHGHUQDFK9DUQGRUIIDKUHQ©KDWWHGHU *HQHUDOJHVDJWXQGHLQ(LJHN|SIWª6LFKHUOLFKLVW,KQHQGDV XQDQJHQHKPDEHUHVJHKWQLFKWDQGHUV'LHVHU%ULHIGD /HVHQ6LH© %RUQODVª6HKUYHUHKUWHJQlGLJH)UDX(UODXEHQ6LHPLU ,KQHQPHLQWLHIHPSIXQGHQHV%HLOHLG]XGHPVFKZHUHQ9HUOXVW DXV]XVSUHFKHQYRQGHPLFKVRHEHQPLW(UVFKWWHUXQJHU IDKUHQKDEH'LHVLVWPLUXPVRPHKUHLQ%HGUIQLVGDLFKLQ PHKUMlKULJHU=XVDPPHQDUEHLW*HOHJHQKHLWKDWWH+HUUQ 2EHUVW%ULQNPDQQDOVHLQHQDXIUHFKWHQXQGYHUDQWZRUWXQJV YROOHQ.DPHUDGHQVFKlW]HQ]XOHUQHQ,FKGDUIVDJHQGDLFK HVQLFKW]XOHW]W,KUHP*DWWHQGDQNHZHQQLFKJHOHUQWKDEH GHQ*HJQHUYRQHLQVWPLWDQGHUHQ$XJHQ]XVHKHQ(VZDUIU PLFKEHUXKLJHQG]XZLVVHQGDHVLQGHU)KUXQJVVSLW]HGHU %XQGHVZHKU3HUV|QOLFKNHLWHQPLWVRNODUHP%OLFNIU5HDOL WlWHQXQGDQDO\WLVFKHP9HUVWHKHQIU0|JOLFKHVXQG8Q P|JOLFKHVJLEWDEKROGMHJOLFKHP9DEDQTXHVSLHO6HLHQ6LH
YHUVLFKHUWYHUHKUWHJQlGLJH)UDXGDLFK,KUHP*DWWHQHLQ EOHLEHQGHV$QGHQNHQEHZDKUHQZHUGH 1RFKYRUZHQLJHQ7DJHQVFKULHEHUPLUDXV9DUQGRUIXQG KDWWHGLH/LHEHQVZUGLJNHLWVLFKPHLQHU%HJHLVWHUXQJIUHLQ %LOGLQVHLQHU-DJGKWWH]XHULQQHUQGDV'HU:LOGEUHWKlQG OHU!KHLWXQGGDVHUPLU]XHLJQHWH9RUDXVJHVHW]WLPPHUGD 6LHYHUHKUWHJQlGLJH)UDXQLFKWDQGHUZHLWLJEHUGDV*H PlOGHGLVSRQLHUHQP|FKWHQZUGHLFKLKPJHUQHLQHQ(KUHQ SODW]DXI'RXJODV&DVWOHJHEHQ=XJOHLFKHUODXEHLFKPLU6LH LQPHLQHPHLJHQHQXQGLP1DPHQYRQ/DG\$PHO\KHU]OLFK ]XELWWHQHLQLJH:RFKHQEHLXQV]XYHUEULQJHQ 6HKUYHUHKUWHJQlGLJH)UDX,FKZHUGHGLH(KUHKDEHQDQ GHU*UDEOHJXQJ,KUHV*DWWHQWHLO]XQHKPHQDOVGHVVHQHU JHEHQHQ)UHXQGLFKPLFK]XEHWUDFKWHQELWWH ,Q9HUEXQGHQKHLW 6LU5HJLQDOG'RXJODV&RORQHO5$)© %RUQKDWWHGHQ%ULHIVWXGLHUWXQGGHQ*HQHUDOIUDJHQG DQJHVHKHQ9RQ:LHVHQHFNEHVWULFKHLQH6FKHLEH7RDVWPLW .RQILWUH:lKUHQGHUHLQHQZLQ]LJHQ%LVVHQNDXWHZDUIHU KLQª,FKKDEHEHUHLWVHLQSDDU1DFKIRUVFKXQJHQDQJHVWHOOW (VVWLPPWGD'RXJODVPHKUPDOVEHLXQVZDU8QWHUDQGHUHP LP=XVDPPHQKDQJPLWGHU%HUOLQHU/XIWEUFNH$EHULQ 9DUQGRUIOLHEHU%RUQLVWHUQLHJHZHVHQ(UJR(UNDQQGDV %LOGYRP:LOGEUHWKlQGOHU!QLHJHVHKHQKDEHQZHQLJVWHQV QLFKWGLHVH.RSLHLQGHU-DJGKWWH$EHUDXIGLHLVWHUJDQ] VFKDUIXQGGDVLVW%ULQNPDQQV*HVFKR,FKIXUFKWHXQVLVW GDHWZDVGXUFKGLH/DSSHQJHJDQJHQ,KUH$XIJDEH%H PlFKWLJHQ6LHVLFKGHV%LOGHV9HUVWHKHQ6LH"(VPXHLQIDFK MHGHP=XJULIIHQW]RJHQZHUGHQPXYHUVFKZXQGHQVHLQ'DV EHZHUNVWHOOLJHQ6LHOHLFKWHUDOVLFKPLWPHLQHPEURNUDWLVFKHQ $SSDUDWEHLGHP$VVHUYDWHGDVHZLJH/HEHQKDEHQ+HUU )ULWVFKLVWGHUJOHLFKHQ0HLQXQJ© 'DUDXIKLQKDWWH%RUQ6FKZHGOHUXQG5RORIILQGLHVH*DVW VWlWWHEHVWHOOW (UQHQQWLKQHQQXUGLH$XIJDEHQLFKWDEHUGHQ*UXQG'DQQ OlW%RUQVHLQHQ0HUFHGHVVWHKHQXQGVWHLJW]XVHLQHQ/HXWHQ
LQGHQKRFKEHLQLJHQ/DQGURYHUGHUIUGLH)DKUWDXIXQ EHIHVWLJWHQ6WUDHQEHVVHUJHHLJQHWLVW 6LHNRPPHQJDUQLFKWDQGDV/DQGKDXVKHUDQ'DVWHKHQ QlPOLFKPHKUHUHJUQZHLH)DKU]HXJHGHU/DQGSROL]HL8QWHU GLHVHQ8PVWlQGHQKlOWHV%RUQIUDQJHPHVVHQLQHLQH :HJDE]ZHLJXQJHLQELHJHQ]XODVVHQ5RORIIZLUGDOV$XI NOlUHUKLQEHUJHVFKLFNWXQGPLVFKWVLFKXQWHUGLH1HXJLHUL JHQ)RUVWDUEHLWHUXQG'RUIEHZRKQHU ª'DV-DJGKDXVLVWOHW]WH1DFKWJHSOQGHUWZRUGHQ©PHOGHW HUVFKOLHOLFKª)RUVWDUEHLWHUKDEHQLQDOOHU+HUUJRWWVIUKHGLH RIIHQH7UJHVHKHQ,FKELQDQV)HQVWHUJHJDQJHQ$OOHVZHJ $XFKGDV%LOG6LHVXFKHQQRFK6SXUHQ© )ULWVFKGHQNW%RUQXQGZLUGJDQ]EOD1DWUOLFKODVWHWHU PLUGDVDQ,FKELQHLQIDFKYLHO]XVSlWYHUVWlQGLJWZRUGHQ 6FKZHGOHUHQWJHKWQLFKWGDGHU&KHIGHQ+HPGNUDJHQ |IIQHWXQGVFKZHUDWPHWª*XWGDZLUJHIUKVWFNWKDEHQ© VDJWHU]XIULHGHQª'LHVHU6FKUHFNDXIQFKWHUQHQ0DJHQ 1LFKW]XYHUNUDIWHQ© ª6FKQDX]H0HQVFK©IDXFKWLKQ%RUQDQª,FKKDEHHLQHQ LQWHUHVVDQWHQ-RE6LHN|QQHQHQGOLFKPDO]HLJHQZDV6LH JHOHUQWKDEHQ6FKDIIHQ6LHGDV%LOGKHU'DVNDQQGRFKIU 6LHNHLQ3UREOHPVHLQ© 6FKZHGOHULVWQLFKWDXVGHU)DVVXQJ]XEULQJHQª%LVZDQQ &KHI"©IUDJWHUQRQFKDODQW]XUFN ª7HUPLQJHVWHUQ©HUZLGHUW%RUQNDOW
ª'HUJDQ]H$XIULGHQGHU0$'GHVZHJHQYHUDQVWDOWHWOlW PLFKDQQHKPHQGDHVVLFKEHLGHQRPLQ|VHQ%ULQNPDQQ SDSLHUHQXPVREULVDQWHV0DWHULDOKDQGHOW©VFKOLHW:HUQHU %UHGHEXVFKVHLQH]XVDPPHQIDVVHQGH6FKLOGHUXQJGHUOHW]WHQ (UHLJQLVVHLP=XVDPPHQKDQJPLWGHP7RGH%ULQNPDQQV ª,FKJODXEHVLH]XNHQQHQZUGHPHKUEHGHXWHQDOVHLQHEORH
=XVDW]LQIRUPDWLRQ$EHUQDFKGLHVHPGXPPHQ(LQEUXFKLQ GLH-DJGKWWH,FKZHLQLFKWZHLWHU© :LQQLH:LQNHOPDQQQLFNWª'LHVHU%ULHIDQIDQJDXVVHLQHU 0DSSHJLEWPLUDXFK]XGHQNHQ'DVLVWGRFKHLQGHXWOLFKHU +LQZHLV$EHUZRUDXI"© +HXWHGLHQWLKQHQGHU.|OQHU=RRORJLVFKH*DUWHQDOV7UHII SXQNW6LHJHKHQLP%HVXFKHUVWURPGHUDQGLHVHPVFK|QHQ )UKOLQJVQDFKPLWWDJJURLVWODVVHQVLFKWUHLEHQXQGYHU ZHLOHQGDXQGGRUWYRUGHQ*HKHJHQ:HUQHUVFKPXQ]HOWDOV JDQ]LQVHLQHU1lKHHLQNOHLQHU-XQJHVHLQH0XWWLYRU=HEUDV YHUZXQGHUWIUDJWZDUXPGHQQGLHVH3IHUGHDOOHHLQHQ6FKODI DQ]XJDQKDEHQ1DMXQJH)UDXGHQNWGHU.XQGVFKDIWHUQXQ ILQGHQ6LHPDOGDUDXIHLQH$QWZRUW :DVVLHHUZLGHUWK|UWHUQLFKWPHKU:LQQLHLVWZHLWHU JHJDQJHQXQGHUVFKOLHW]XLKUDXI 8QYHUPLWWHOWVHW]WVLHQHXDQª:DVLVWPLW&KHFNPDWH!"© ª,FKKDEHNHLQHQHXHQ,QIRUPDWLRQHQ'HU7HUPLQIUGDV 0DQ|YHUEOHLEWXQYHUlQGHUW$XJXVW6HSWHPEHU'LHELVKHU JU|WH.RQ]HQWUDWLRQYRQ1$72.DPSIYHUElQGHQLQHLQHP 0DQ|YHU=DKOHQKDVWGXMDVFKRQ©:HUQHUQLPPWVLHDP $UPª(QGJOWLJLVWGDVDOOHVQLFKW6REDOGLFKHWZDVKDEH© ª-D©VDJWVLHHLQIDFKXQGZlKUHQGLKUH*HGDQNHQEHL ª&KHFNPDWH©VLQGIlOOWLKUMHQHU$UWLNHOLQGHUª%RQQHU 5XQGVFKDX©HLQLQGHPGHU$GHQDXHU,QWLPXV5REHUW,QJULP HUNOlUWKDWGLH1$720lFKWHPWHQ]XGLHVHP=HLWSXQNW LQGHU/DJHVHLQªDOOH0LWWHOGHV.ULHJHVGHV1HUYHQNULHJHV XQGGHV6FKLHNULHJHVDQ]XZHQGHQ'D]XJHK|UHQQLFKWQXU KHUN|PPOLFKH6WUHLWNUlIWHXQG5VWXQJHQVRQGHUQDXFKGLH 8QWHUZKOXQJGDV$QKHL]HQGHVLQQHUHQ:LGHUVWDQGVGLH $UEHLWLP8QWHUJUXQGGLH=HUVHW]XQJGHU2UGQXQJGLH6DER WDJHGLH6W|UXQJYRQ9HUNHKUXQG:LUWVFKDIWGHU8QJHKRU VDPGHU$XIUXKU©6ROOGHUNDOWH.ULHJJHJHQGLH'HXWVFKH 'HPRNUDWLVFKH5HSXEOLNVHLQHQ*LSIHOSXQNWHUUHLFKWKDEHQ ZHQQGLH1$72.DPSIYHUElQGH]XVDPPHQJH]RJHQVLQGXQG *HZHKUEHL)XVWHKHQ"ª'HV1HUYHQNULHJHVXQGGHV6FKLH NULHJHV©'HU1HUYHQNULHJZLUGMDZRKOVFKRQDXIGLH6SLW]H JHWULHEHQ
:LQQLHIUDJW:HUQHUREHUGDVDXFKJHOHVHQKDEH (UQLFNWª-DXQGLFKEHZXQGHUHGLH/DQJPXWGHU*HQRVVHQ LQ%HUOLQ©
'DV3HUVRQDOEURGHU(OHNWURQLN*HUlWHXQG$QODJHQEDX GDVHLQ'LUHNWRUQDPHQV'RQQHUOHLWHWOLHJWLPIQI]HKQWHQ 6WRFNZHUNHLQHVPRGHUQHQ+RFKKDXVHVXQGKDWVRJXWZLH NHLQHQ%HVXFKHUYHUNHKU'HU)DKUVWXKOHQGHWLPYLHU]HKQWHQ 6WRFN1XUZHQLJH(LQJHZHLKWHKDEHQHLQHQ6FKOVVHO]XGHP VHSDUDWHQ$XI]XJGHUQRFKHLQH(WDJHK|KHUIlKUW*lVWHIU 'LUHNWRU'RQQHUZHUGHQQDFKYRUKHULJHU$QPHOGXQJYRQ HLQHPVHLQHU0LWDUEHLWHUXQWHQLQ(PSIDQJJHQRPPHQXQG QDFKREHQJHOHLWHW,PIQI]HKQWHQ6WRFNVHKHQVLHOHGLJOLFK GDV'RPL]LO'RQQHUVGHVVHQEUHLWH)HQVWHUHLQHQUHL]YROOHQ %OLFNDXIGDV3DQRUDPDYRQ.|OQJHVWDWWHQ'DVDQJUHQ]HQGH *URUDXPEURPLWGHUNKOHQ6DFKOLFKNHLWVHLQHU]X:DEHQ ]XVDPPHQJHVWHOOWHQ9DULR0|EHOXQGVFKDOOVFKOXFNHQGHQ :DQGYHUNOHLGXQJHQEOHLEWLKQHQYHUERUJHQ 2EHUVWD'*QWHU.U|VLQJVWHKWDXI(ULVWUHFKW]XIULHGHQ PLWGHP*HVSUlFKLQGHVVHQ9HUODXIHUDXFKVHLQH9RUVFKOlJH KLQVLFKWOLFK'HWMHQVDXIGHQ7LVFKJHOHJWKDW,KPLVWQLFKW HQWJDQJHQGD'LUHNWRU'RQQHUEHUUDVFKWGLH6WLUQLQ)DOWHQ JH]RJHQKDWDOVGHU'LHQVWJUDG$FKLPV]XU6SUDFKHJH NRPPHQLVW(LQ0DMRUVFKHLQWLKPGHQQZRKOGRFKHLQZHQLJ ]XNOHLQIUGLH$XIJDEH]XVHLQ(UVDJWGDVDXFKDEHU.U|VLQJ ZLVFKWGHQ(LQZDQGPLWGHULP%UXVWWRQGHUhEHU]HXJXQJ YRUJHEUDFKWHQ(UNOlUXQJZHJPDQKDEHHVPLWHLQHP0DQQ YRQ=XNXQIW]XWXQGHULQ.U]HDYDQFLHUHQZHUGH-HHKHU PDQVLFKVHLQHUYHUVLFKHUHGHVWREHVVHUKDEHPDQLKQLQGHU +DQGXQGGHVWR]LHOJHULFKWHWHUN|QQHPDQLKQDXIEDXHQ'DV VHLHLQH,QYHVWLWLRQDXIODQJH6LFKWVR]XVDJHQ'LHEHLGHQVLQG EHUHLQJHNRPPHQGDGHU2EHUVW]XQlFKVWHLQPDOLQXQ YHUELQGOLFKHU:HLVH'HWMHQVJUXQGVlW]OLFKH%HUHLWVFKDIWDXV IRUVFKHQZHUGH.U|VLQJYHUVSUDFK'RQQHUYRP(UJHEQLVLQ .HQQWQLV]XVHW]HQ 'RQQHUOlWHVVLFKQLFKWQHKPHQVHLQHQ%HVXFKHUSHU
V|QOLFKELV]XP+DXSWIDKUVWXKOHLQ6WRFNZHUNWLHIHU]XJH OHLWHQ*DQ]EHLOlXILJHUNXQGLJWHUVLFKXQWHUZHJVQDFKGHP 6WDQGGHU$UEHLWHQDQGHUªEHUKPWHQ©05&$$OO]XYLHOZHL .U|VLQJGD]XQLFKW]XVDJHQ'LH(QWVFKHLGXQJGHV9HU WHLGLJXQJVDXVVFKXVVHVGHV%XQGHVWDJHVVWHKHQRFKDXVHU ZLGHUWHUXQGQXW]WJOHLFKGLH*HOHJHQKHLW]XHUZlKQHQGLH JHVDPWHQ9RUODJHQVHLHQEHUGLH6FKUHLEWLVFKHGHV5HIHUDWHV JHJDQJHQLQGHP0DMRU'HWMHQDUEHLWH ª$KD©VDJW'RQQHUª1XQMDGLH$EWHLOXQJ%ULQNPDQQ 6DJHQ6LH+HUU.U|VLQJPXPDQGDQRFKPLW:HLWHUXQJHQ UHFKQHQ"© ª.DXP©HUZLGHUWGHU%HVXFKHUª'HU6DFKYHUKDOWLVWGRFK ZLHLFKDXVVLFKHUHU4XHOOHHUIDKUHQKDEHHLQGHXWLJJHNOlUW (LQEHGDXHUOLFKHU8QIDOOGHUZLHHLQ6HOEVWPRUGDXVVLHKW 6FKDGHXPGHQ0DQQ© ª-DVFKDGH©VFKOLHWVLFK'RQQHUGHP1HNURORJIUGHQ SDVVLRQLHUWHQ-lJHUDQ'DQQ|IIQHWHUGHP2EHUVW]XYRUNRP PHQGGLH)DKUVWXKOWU (UVHOEVWNHKUWLQGHQIQI]HKQWHQ6WRFN]XUFNGRFK EHWULWWHUVWDWWVHLQHV=LPPHUVPLWGHUVFK|QHQ0DKDJRQLWl IHOXQJGHQ*URUDXP+LHUVLQGDOOH*HUlXVFKHPHUNZUGLJ JHGlPSIW'RQQHUJHKW]ZLVFKHQ5DXPWHLOHUQXQGLQVLFK JHVFKORVVHQHQ$UEHLWVEHUHLFKHQKLQGXUFK(UZHFKVHOWKLHU XQGGDHLQSDDU:RUWHPLWKHPGVlUPHOLJHQ6DFKEHDUEHL WHUQXQGOlWVLFKGDXQGGRUWEHU(UJHEQLVVHXQWHUULFKWHQ ,QMHGHU$EWHLOXQJVWHKWGHU6FKUHLEWLVFKGHV*UXSSHQOHLWHUV IUHLZlKUHQGGLH$UEHLWVSOlW]HVHLQHU0LWDUEHLWHUQDFKHLQHP DXVJHNOJHOWHQ6\VWHPNRPSOH[ZHLVHDQHLQDQGHUJHUFNWXQG ]XJHRUGQHWVLQG.DUWHLXQG$NWHQVFKUlQNHWUHQQHQVLHYRQ HLQDQGHUEHUIUHLVWHKHQGHQ3DQ]HUWUHVRUHQLVWDQGHU'HFNH HLQH9LGHRNDPHUDLQ%HWULHEXQGDXI$NWHQZDJHQZHUGHQ 6W|HYRQ+HIWHUQKLQXQGKHUJHIDKUHQ2EZRKOVWlQGLJ 0HQVFKHQLQ%HZHJXQJVLQGLVWNHLQ6FKULWW]XK|UHQ 'HU*UXSSHQOHLWHUEHLGHPGHU'LUHNWRU]XHUVWVWHKHQ EOHLEWVLHKWQXUDXIXQGEHJLQQWRKQH8PVFKZHLIHVDFKOLFK ]XUHIHULHUHQ'DHUZHGHUDXIVWHKWQRFKHLQHQ6WXKODQELHWHW
EHGHXWHWNHLQH8QK|IOLFKNHLWJHJHQEHUGHP&KHI(VLVWQXU UDWLRQHOOXQGGHVKDOEXQJHVFKULHEHQHV*HVHW](LQ6WXKOLVWMD GDZHQQVLFKGHU&KHIVHW]HQZLOOZLUGHUGDVWXQ)ORVNHOQ VLQGKLHUXQHUZQVFKWPDQOHJW:HUWDXIYHUVDFKOLFKWH$U EHLWVEH]LHKXQJHQXQGKDWGDGXUFKHLQH0HQJHXQQ|WLJHQ /HHUODXIDXVJHVFKDOWHW:HULQGLHVHP*URUDXPDUEHLWHW ZLUGQLFKWQDFKGHU7LHIHVHLQHU9HUEHXJXQJHQJHZHUWHW VRQGHUQDOOHLQQDFKVHLQHU/HLVWXQJ1DWUOLFKHU]HXJWGHU (UIROJV]ZDQJXQWHUGHPMHGHUVWHKWLQEHVRQGHUVKRKHP 0DH6WUHDEHUVLFKGHPDXV]XVHW]HQLVWGHU3UHLVIUEHU GXUFKVFKQLWWOLFKH*HKlOWHU1HLQ/HHUODXIJLEWHVKLHUQLFKW XQGHUZLUGDXFKQLFKWYHUPLW 'LH$EZHUEXQJTXDOLIL]LHUWHU)DFKNUlIWHDXVGHUª=RQH© OlXIWDXIYROOHQ7RXUHQ0DQZLUGLQGHU/DJHVHLQXQGGDV HQWVSULFKWGHU$XIJDEHQVWHOOXQJGDVJHSODQWHQHXH=ZHLJ ZHUNLP6DXHUODQGZHLWJHKHQGPLWVROFKHP3HUVRQDO]XYHU VRUJHQ'LH9HUIDKUHQVZHLVHQHUVWHQVGDV$QVSUHFKHQDXV JHVXFKWHU/HXWHGXUFKEHUHLWVLQGHU%XQGHVUHSXEOLNOHEHQGH HKHPDOLJH.ROOHJHQXQG)UHXQGHHLQH$UWª3DWHQVFKDIWV V\VWHP©]ZHLWHQVGHU(LQVDW]YRQª6FKOHSSHUQ©GLHªGU EHQ©JH]LHOWPLWHLQHPLQ)UDJHNRPPHQGHQ3HUVRQHQNUHLV .RQWDNWDXIQHKPHQXQGZHLWHUH9HUELQGXQJVPlQQHUJH ZLQQHQXQGGULWWHQVGLH$UEHLWPLWHUKDOWHQJHEOLHEHQHQ 3HUVRQDONDUWHLHQYRQ%HWULHEHQGHUHQIUKHUH=ZHLJZHUNHLP 2VWHQHQWHLJQHWZXUGHQ'LHGULWWH9DULDQWHKDWVLFKEHVRQGHUV EHZlKUWGDHVGHQ$QJHVFKULHEHQHQRIIHQEDU)UHXGHPDFKW VLFKXQYHUJHVVHQXQGZLHGHUJHEUDXFKW]XVHKHQ'LHVXPVR PHKUDQJHVLFKWVGHUYHUVSURFKHQHQXQGPLW$NULELHDXFK JHZlKUWHQ5HJHOXQJVR]LDOHU%HODQJHLP)DOOHGHV$EVHW]HQV DXV2VWGHXWVFKODQGDOVGDVLQG:RKQXQJVEHVFKDIIXQJhEHU EUFNXQJVJHOGHU(QWVFKlGLJXQJIU9HUORUHQHV%OHQGHQGH =XVDPPHQDUEHLWPLWGHQVWDDWOLFKHQ6WHOOHQ:DVGLH*UXSSH VHOEVWQDWUOLFKQLFKWGHU$XIJDEHHQWKHEWªGUEHQ©LPPHU QHXH6FKZDFKSXQNWH]XILQGHQXQGLQVLHKLQHLQ]XVWRHQ 'DVYHUVWHKWVLFKIU'RQQHUGDUEHUYHUOLHUWHUNHLQ:RUW (UZUGHHVVRJDUEHOQHKPHQZHQQGHU*UXSSHQOHLWHUGLH
3V\FKRORJHQHUZlKQHQZUGHGLH]XP$EIDVVHQGHUª(U LQQHUXQJVEULHIH©KLQ]XJH]RJHQZHUGHQ6HOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFK NHLWHQ ª:DQQ©IUDJWHUWURFNHQªN|QQHQZLUEHUGLH3URIHVVRUHQ =DHUUXKQ0DW]XQG%ODQNHQEXUJYHUIJHQ"© 'HU*UXSSHQOHLWHUYHU]LHKWNHLQH0LHQHª3URIHVVRU =DHUUXKQXQGVHLQH)DPLOLHVLQGKHXWHPRUJHQYLD:HVWEHUOLQ LQ.|OQJHODQGHW,FKKDEHLKQLP+RWHO6FKZHL]HU+RI! XQWHUJHEUDFKW8QVHU+HUU%HUJQHUEHWUHXWLKQ'DV/DJHU )ULHGODQGLVWLQIRUPLHUWGLH)RUPDOLWlWHQHUOHGLJHQZLU3UR IHVVRU0DW]KDWVHLQH=XVDJHIUXQV]XDUEHLWHQZLGHUUXIHQ (UWUHQQWVLFKQLFKWYRQ'UHVGHQ:LUEOHLEHQGUDQ3URIHVVRU %ODQNHQEXUJKDW3HFKJHKDEW'LH)RUVFKXQJVXQWHUODJHQGLH HUPLWEULQJHQVROOWH,KU)HKOHQLVWHQWGHFNWZRUGHQGLH 6WDDWVVLFKHUKHLWKDWLKQLQ.|QLJV:XVWHUKDXVHQDEJHIDQJHQ DOVHULQGLH6%DKQVWHLJHQZROOWH8QVHU0DQQZDUVFKRQLQ VHLQHU1lKHYRUHLQHUKDOEHQ6WXQGHNDPVHLQ$QUXIDXV :HVWEHUOLQ(LQ]HOKHLWHQLP7DJHVEHULFKW© 'RQQHUQLFNWXQGJHKWZHLWHU5DXPWHLOHU6WHOOZlQGH1XQ .RSLHUPDVFKLQHQ8QG%HUJHYRQ)DFK]HLWVFKULIWHQDXVDOOHU :HOW9RQGLHVHU*UXSSHZHUGHQ3XEOLNDWLRQHQQDFK9HU |IIHQWOLFKXQJHQGXUFKIRUVFKWGLHGLH$UEHLWGHU(*$WDQ JLHUHQ7KHPDWLVFKVRUWLHUWJHKHQGLH.RSLHQGHU,QJHQLHXU DEWHLOXQJ]XGLHVLHQDFKVSH]LHOOHQ*HVLFKWVSXQNWHQDQDO\ VLHUWXQGLKUHUVHLWVZHLWHUJHKHQGH8QWHUVXFKXQJHQYHUDQODW VRIHUQGDVQW]OLFKHUVFKHLQW $OV'RQQHUQlKHUWULWWZLUGJHUDGHGLHDPHULNDQLVFKH=HLW VFKULIWª$YLDWLRQ:HHN©DEJHOLFKWHWGLHVLFKLQ)DFKNUHLVHQ GXUFKLKUHH[WHQVLYHQ5HFKHUFKHQ]XDNWXHOOHQ/XIWIDKUW WKHPHQHLQHQ1DPHQJHPDFKWKDW'HU$UWLNHOGHUNRSLHUW ZLUGEHUKUWGDV$UEHLWVJHELHWGHUHLJHQHQ(OHNWURQLNHU =XGLHVHP0DWHULDOZLUGNHLQHGHXWVFKVSUDFKLJH,QKDOWV DQJDEHDQJHIHUWLJW'RQQHUHUZDUWHWYRQVHLQHQ0LWDUEHLWHUQ GDVLH(QJOLVFKXQG)UDQ]|VLVFKEHKHUUVFKHQ%HLWUlJHDXV VRZMHWLVFKHQ4XHOOHQHEHQVRZLHDXVMDSDQLVFKHQHUKDOWHQ ([]HUSWH:HUVSULFKWVFKRQMDSDQLVFKRGHUUXVVLVFK"'HU
MXQJH0DQQGHUIU5XVVLVFK]XVWlQGLJLVWKDWHLQHJXWH1DVH EHZLHVHQDOVHU6ODZLVWLNVWXGLHUWHQRFKLVWGLH1DFKIUDJH JU|HUDOVGDV$QJHERW)U-DSDQLVFKKDWPDQVLFKHLQH'DPH DXVGHP/DQGHGHUDXIJHKHQGHQ6RQQHKROHQPVVHQ6LHKDW LQ
'LUHNWRUVDXIVHLQHP%ORFN]XXQWHUVWUHLFKHQ(LQ0DQQ GLHVHQ$OWHUVLQJXWHUMDJHKREHQHU3RVLWLRQPLWJHGLHJHQHP 3HQVLRQVDQVSUXFKXQGXQYHUKHLUDWHW"'DVLVW]XPLQGHVWQLFKW DOOWlJOLFKGHPPXPDQDXIGHQ*UXQGJHKHQª1RWLHUW© EHVWlWLJWHU ª'DQQZlUHGDQRFKGLH6DFKH/HPQLW]$XVJHUHFKQHWEHL GHU(*$GLHVHQREVNXUHQ)ULHGHQVDSSHOO]XYHUWHLOHQGDV JHKWGRFKZRKO]XZHLW© ª,P7DJHVEHULFKW©HUZLGHUW6HQQHZDOGNQDSSª'HU9HU IDVVXQJVVFKXW]LVWHLQJHVFKDOWHW:LUVLQGEHU]HXJWGDGLH +HUUHQEHL:HUNPHLVWHU/HPQLW]DXFKQRFKJDQ]DQGHUH 0DWHULDOLHQILQGHQZHUGHQ©'DVQLPPWHUQLFKWQXUDQGDV ZHLHULPYRUDXV
)UHPGDUWLJXQGXQJHZRKQWLVWGLHVH:HOW(LQHQ+DQJ]XP *LJDQWLVFKHQKDWVLHXQGDOOHVEHUVWHLJWGDVQRUPDOH0D +DXVKRKH6FKDFKWHOKDOPHPRQXPHQWDOH%lXPHXQGHLQH 7LHUZHOWGLHDXV'U)UDQNHQVWHLQV*UXVHONDELQHWW]XNRP PHQVFKHLQWWUHWHQ:HUQHU%UHGHEXVFKHQWJHJHQ:HQQHU QLFKWKLQXQGZLHGHUGLHVHKUZHLWUlXPLJH6WHUHREULOOHK|KHU DXIGLH1DVHVFKLHEHQPWHZHLOVLHUXWVFKWN|QQWHHU JODXEHQYHUORUHQXQGNOHLQLQGLHVHU6]HQHULH]XVWHKHQGLH LKPHLQ9RUWUDJPLW')RWRVYRQPHLVWHUKDIWJHVWDOWHWHQ 'LDUDPHQXQG6FKDXELOGHUQLP9RUWUDJV]HQWUXPUlXPOLFK QDKHEULQJW :HUQHUOlWGDVDOOHVPLWJURDUWLJHU*HODVVHQKHLWEHUVLFK HUJHKHQ1HLQGLH(QWZLFNOXQJVJHVFKLFKWHGHU)DXQDXQG )ORUDGHVKHLPLVFKHQ/HEHQVUDXPHVUHLWLKQQLFKWYRP6WXKO +|FKVWJOHLFKJOWLJVLQGLKPGLH6WDPPElXPHGHU'LQRVDX ULHUY|OOLJHJDOLVWLKPVRJDUGLH0LWWHLOXQJGDHVYRUGHP 8UYRJHO$UFKlRSWHU\[EHUHLWV*OHLWIOLHJHUJDEGLHPLWVR JHQDQQWHQ)OXJKlXWHQNXU]H)OJHDXVIKUWHQXQGQLFKWHLQ PDOGLHEHUKPWHQHLQVFKOlJLJHQ)XQGHLQGHQ3ODWWHQNDONHQ GHVREHUHQ-XUDEHL6ROQKRIHQLQ%D\HUQIDV]LQLHUHQLKQ(U IKOWVLFKDXVVFKOLHOLFKGHU*HJHQZDUWYHUEXQGHQ 1DFKGHP:LQQLH:LQNHOPDQQXQGHUVLFKJHWUHQQWKDEHQ
KDW:HUQHU%UHGHEXVFKVLFKXQYHUPLWWHOWGLH)UDJHJHVWHOOW ZDVHUDQWZRUWHWZHQQLKQZLHGHUMHPDQGIUDJWZRHUZDU -HW]WNDQQHUPLWJXWHP*HZLVVHQVDJHQHUKDEHGHQ.DW]HQ VSUXQJQDFK.|OQJHPDFKWLP=RRORJLVFKHQ*DUWHQPDOWLHI GXUFK]XDWPHQXQGGLHNOHLQVWlGWLVFKH(QJHYRQ%RQQIUHLQ SDDU6WXQGHQ]XYHUJHVVHQ-DXQGLP=RRKDEHHU*HOHJHQKHLW JHQRPPHQHLQSXUHU=XIDOOHLQHQXQJHPHLQIHVVHOQGHQ 9RUWUDJ]XHUOHEHQ6HLWKHUZLVVHHUGDHVLQGHU9HUJDQJHQ KHLWQRFKªJU|HUH7LHUH©JHJHEHQKDEHDOVLQGHU*HJHQZDUW )UDOOH)lOOHKDWHUGLH(LQWULWWVNDUWHVRªDFKWORV©LQGLH -DFNHQWDVFKHJHNQOOWGDVLHGDULQIUGLHQlFKVWH=HLW DXIILQGEDUEOHLEW=XVlW]OLFKHUZLUEWHUVRJDUHLQH%URVFKUH PLWGHU$EVLFKWVLHHEHQVRªDFKWORV©LQVHLQHU:RKQXQJ KHUXPOLHJHQ]XODVVHQ(LJHQWOLFKLVWHVJDQ]JXWJHOHJHQWOLFK PLWGHU1DVHGDUDXIJHVWRHQ]XZHUGHQGDPDQQLFKW YRUVLFKWLJJHQXJVHLQNDQQ(ULVWJDQ]]XIULHGHQPLWVLFK 1LFKWV%|VHVDKQHQGVWHLJWHUDXIGHP=RR3DUNSODW]LQ VHLQHQ:DJHQXQGGUFNWLKQUFNZlUWVDXVHLQHUVHKUHQJHQ 3DUNOFNH'HUPlFKWLJDXVODGHQGH%XLFNOLQNVQHEHQLKP QLPPWVHLQH$XIPHUNVDPNHLWVRLQ$QVSUXFKGDHUDXIGHQ NOHLQHQ)LDWDXIGHUDQGHUHQ6HLWHNDXPDFKWHW8QGVRJH VFKLHKWHVHLQKlOLFKHVPHWDOOLVFKHV.QLUVFKHQ6WRXQG 6SOLWWHUQ 1DWUOLFKVWHLJWHUDXVXQGEHVLHKWGHQ6FKDGHQ'HU6WR VWDQJHVHLQHV:DJHQVLVWQLFKWVSDVVLHUWVLHWUlJWMHW]WQXUHLQ ZHQLJJUQH)DUEHDEHUGHP)LDWIHKOWHLQ5FNOLFKWXQGHU KDWHLQHQKlOLFKHQ.UDW]HULP/DFN,QGHU1lKHYHUVDPPHOQ VLFKQXQ1HXQPDONOXJHXQGPDFKHQGLHEOLFKHQJHLVWUHLFKHQ %HPHUNXQJHQ:HUQHU%UHGHEXVFKOlWGDVNDOW0LWHLQHP $QIOXJYRQ,URQLHGHQNWHUVHLQ=RRDXIHQWKDOWZlUHGDPLW HLQGHXWLJQDFKJHZLHVHQXQGHUKlWWHVLFKGHQ%HVXFKGHV 9HUWUDJVEHUGLH(QWZLFNOXQJVJHVFKLFKWHGHU)DXQDXQG )ORUDGHVKHLPLVFKHQ/HEHQVUDXPHVHLJHQWOLFKVFKHQNHQN|Q QHQ2GHULVWGDVGLH5DFKHGHU'LQRVDXULHUIUVHLQHPDQ JHOQGH$XIPHUNVDPNHLW" (UWXWZDVJHWDQZHUGHQPXHUHQWQLPPWVHLQHU
%ULHIWDVFKHHLQH9LVLWHQNDUWHXQGYHUPHUNWPLWGHP.XJHO VFKUHLEHUDXILKUHU5FNVHLWHª9HU]HLKHQ6LHPHLQH8Q DFKWVDPNHLW,FKELWWH6LHVLFKZHJHQGHU6FKDGHQVUHJXOLH UXQJPLWPLULQ9HUELQGXQJ]XVHW]HQ$'©:LHVLFK VJHK|UW IJWHUQRFKGLH8KU]HLWKLQ]XHKHHUGLH.DUWHGXUFKHLQHQ )HQVWHUVSDOWLQGHQ)LDWZLUIW6LHODQGHWJHQDXLQGHU0LWWH GHV)DKUHUVLW]HV (UQRWLHUWVLFKGDV.HQQ]HLFKHQGHVNOHLQHQ:DJHQVGDV .|OQHU.HQQ]HLFKHQª./0©XQGIlKUWDE'LH 6FKDXOXVWLJHQKDEHQVLFKVFKRQYHUODXIHQGHU0DQQKDWVLFK QLFKWHLQIDFKDXVGHP6WDXEJHPDFKWHULVWXQLQWHUHVVDQW :HUQHU%UHGHEXVFKLVWQLFKWPHKUJDQ]VR]XIULHGHQPLW VLFKZLHYRUKLQ
%HLGHU9RUVSHLVH*lQVHOHEHUVFKQLWWFKHQUXQGDXVJHVWRH QHVJHWRDVWHWHV:HLEURWPLW%XWWHUXQG3DVWHWHEHOHJWXQG PLW7UIIHOQJDUQLHUWEOHLEWGDV*HVSUlFKDOOJHPHLQ0DQ PXHUVWHLQZHQLJZDUPZHUGHQPLWHLQDQGHUXQGVLFKNHQ QHQOHUQHQ9RP:HWWHULQ)UDQNIXUWLVWGLH5HGHXQGQDWUOLFK YRQGHU]XQHKPHQGHQ.ULPLQDOLWlW'LHVWHLJHQGH8QVLFKHU KHLWYRUDOOHPGHU*HJHQGXPGHQ%DKQKRIPLWGHU .DLVHUVWUDHGHU:HVHUGHU0RVHOXQGGHU0QFK QHUVWUDHZLUGKHUYRUJHKREHQXQGHVZLUGEHNODJWGDGLH 0DLQPHWURSROHPHKUXQGPHKU]XP'RUDGRGHULQWHUQDWLR QDOHQ9HUEUHFKHUZHOWZLUG'DPLWLVWPDQEHUHLWVEHLPHLJHQW OLFKHQ7KHPD$OVGDV+DXSWJHULFKWVHUYLHUWZLUGJH EDFNHQH)ULVFKOLQJVEUXVWHQWEHLQWLQ6FKHLEHQJHVFKQLWWHQ PLW(LXQG5HLEHEURWJDUQLHUWJUQHU6SDUJHODOV%HLODJHH[WUD JHUHLFKW&XUU\VDKQHQVRHXQG3HWHUVLOLHQNDUWRIIHOQVRZLHHLQ 6DODWWHOOHUNDQQPDQ]XU6DFKHNRPPHQª%ODXHU6SlW EXUJXQGHU©UXELQURWLP*ODVIHLQLP$URPDKHUELP*H VFKPDFNXQGGHQQRFKYRQDQJHQHKPHP)HXHUKlOWGDEHLGLH .HKOHQIHXFKW
:ROI'LHWHU6FKZHGOHUGHXWHWPLWHLQHU.RSIEHZHJXQJDXI VHLQ*ODVª:HLQYRP7DWRUWJHZLVVHUPDHQ6LHZLVVHQ GRFKGDGDV$KUWDOGDVJU|WH5RWZHLQJHELHWXQVHUHV /DQGHVLVW"-DXQGGLH$KUIOLHWDXFKGXUFKGLH(LIHOHKH VLHEHL6LQ]LJLQGHQ5KHLQPQGHW,FKELQ,KQHQDXHURUGHQW OLFKGDQNEDUGD6LHPLUPLWHLQHUNOHLQHQ,QIRUPDWLRQXQWHU GLH$UPHJUHLIHQZROOHQ+HUU)ULHEHO© /XGZLJ)ULHEHOGHXWHWHLQH9HUEHXJXQJDQ(UPXQLFKW VDJHQGDHUPLWEHLGHQ+lQGHQ]XJHJULIIHQKDWDOVGHU .ULPLQDOUDW0RQNVHLQ9RUJHVHW]WHULP(LQEUXFK'LHEVWDKO 'H]HUQDWGHU)UDQNIXUWHU.ULSRLKPGLHVH%HJHJQXQJYHU PLWWHOWKDW2EHUQLFKW/XVWKDEHIUDJWH0RQNEHLGHUUH QRPPLHUWHQ5+(,10$,1'(7(.7(,LQHLQHU6DFKHEH UDWHQGWlWLJ]XZHUGHQ'LH5+(,10$,1'(7(.7(,IXKU GHU.ULPLQDOUDWIRUWVHLLP$XIWUDJHLQHU9HUVLFKHUXQJV JHVHOOVFKDIWPLWGHU:LHGHUEHVFKDIIXQJHLQHU5HLKHJHVWRK OHQHU.XQVWJHJHQVWlQGHEHIDWXQGHUKDOWHHVGXUFKDXVIU DQJHPHVVHQXQGYRPSROL]HLOLFKHQ6WDQGSXQNWDXVYHUWUHWEDU LKUGDEHLEHKLOIOLFK]XVHLQ)URSSRUWXQHUDFKWHHUDXFKGHU 'HWHNWHL(LQEOLFNLQJHZLVVH8QWHUODJHQ]XJHEHQ8QGLP EULJHQN|QQH2EHUNRPPLVVDU)ULHEHOVHLQHPHKHPDOLJHQ .RPPLOLWRQHQ6FKZHGOHUHLQHQVHKUKHU]OLFKHQ*UXLQDOWHU 9HUEXQGHQKHLWEHVWHOOHQ %H]LHKXQJHQVLQGGDVKDOEH/HEHQ )ULHEHOKDWVLFKDXIGLHVHV*HVSUlFKLP+RWHOª)UDQNIXUWHU +RI©LQGHU:LOKHOP/HXVFKQHU6WUDHHQWVSUHFKHQGYRU EHUHLWHW0LWVLFKIKUWHU6DFKIDKQGXQJVPDWHULDOLHQGLH SUl]LVH%HVFKUHLEXQJHQXQGDXFK)RWRV$XVVFKQLWWUHSUR GXNWLRQHQYRQ3ULYDWIRWRVGHU)DPLOLH%ULQNPDQQHQWKDOWHQ EHLVLFKKDWHUDXFKGLHDXI$QIRUGHUXQJIHUQVFKULIWOLFKEHU PLWWHOWHQ(UNHQQWQLVVHGHU/DQGHVSROL]HLGLHGDV-DJGKDXV GXUFKVXFKWH=XGHUHQ3UHLVJDEHLVWHUYRQVHLQHP9RU JHVHW]WHQHUPlFKWLJW:DVZLOOHUPHKU" ,PJHIlOOLJHQ3ODXGHUWRQXQGZLHEHLOlXILJEHPHUNWHU ZlKUHQGVLHHVVHQGDGLHOLHEHQ.ROOHJHQLQGHU(LIHOQLFKW IQGLJJHZRUGHQVLQG'DVKDEHZRKOGDUDQJHOHJHQGDHV
DP(UHLJQLVRUWNHLQH$Q]HLFKHQGDIUJDEGDGRUW3URILVPLW HLQHUHLJHQHQXQYHUZHFKVHOEDUHQ+DQGVFKULIWDP:HUNH JHZHVHQZlUHQ9LHOPHKUGHXWHWHQGLH7DWXPVWlQGHDXIHLQHQ =XJULIIYRQ$PDWHXUHQKLQGLHQDFKGHP0RWWRKDQGHOWHQ ª'LH*HOHJHQKHLWLVWJQVWLJ©$OOHLQGDVgIIQHQGHU7UPLW GHP%UHFKHLVHQGDVMHGHQ9RUEHUNRPPHQGHQJHUDGH]XPLW GHU1DVHGDUDXIVWRHKLHUPVVHHWZDVQLFKWLQ2UGQXQJVHLQ VSUHFKHIUVLFK3URILVKlWWHQVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFK:HUWGDUDXI JHOHJWGDLKU7XQP|JOLFKVWODQJHXQHQWGHFNWEOHLEW ª$XHUGHP+HUU6FKZHGOHU:HQQ6LHGLH/LVWHGHUJH VWRKOHQHQ*HJHQVWlQGHGXUFKVHKHQZHUGHQ6LHQXU]ZHLWUDQ JLJH:DUHILQGHQ$OWH-DJGZDIIHQJLEWHV]X7DXVHQGHQXQG GDV%LOGZDUEORHLQH.RSLH:DVGDV=LQQJHVFKLUUDQJHKW QHXQ]HKQWHV-DKUKXQGHUWLFKELWWH6LH-DZHQQHVVLFKXP 6WFNHDXVGHPIQI]HKQWHQRGHUVHFK]HKQWHQ-DKUKXQGHUW JHKDQGHOWKlWWHVlKHHVVFKRQDQGHUVDXVDEHUVR©'HU 2EHUNRPPLVVDUWXSIWVLFKGHQ0XQGPLWGHU6HUYLHWWHª:LV VHQ6LHZDVPLFKZXQGHUW",FKYHUVWHKHQLFKWZDUXPGLH 9HUVLFKHUXQJVJHVHOOVFKDIWVROFKHU%DJDWHOOHQZHJHQ,KUH 'LHQVWHLQ$QVSUXFKQLPPW'LHVLQGGRFKQLFKWELOOLJXQGGHU $XIZDQGVWHKWLQNHLQHP9HUKlOWQLV]XP(UJHEQLV© 6FKZHGOHUOlFKHOWXQGOHHUWVHLQ*ODV6RIRUWLVWGHUEH IUDFNWH.HOOQHU]XU6WHOOHXQGVFKHQNWQDFK ª0HLQOLHEHU+HUU)ULHEHO©VHW]WGHU.ULPLQDOLVWOlVVLJDQ ªGDNRPPHQPHKUHUH'LQJH]XVDPPHQ(UVWHQVKDWXQVHUH 'HWHNWHLHLQHQ3DXVFKDOYHUWUDJPLWGHU9HUVLFKHUXQJXQG ]ZHLWHQVGLHVH6DPPOHUVLQGGRFKIDVWDOOH9HUUFNWH,FK KDEHOlXWHQK|UHQ%ULQNPDQQKDEHVHKUDQVHLQHQ6FKlW]HQ JHKDQJHQXQGVLH]XHLQHPKRUUHQGHQ/LHEKDEHUSUHLVYHU VLFKHUW© )ULHEHOOHKQWVLFK]XUFNXQG]LHKWVHLQH:HVWHVWUDII ª(LQHQ9HUVLFKHUXQJVEHWUXJKDEHQ6LHGRFKZRKOLQV$XJH JHIDW"5HLFKWPHUZLUGGHU+HUU2EHUVWNDXPJHVDPPHOW KDEHQXQGZHQQGDMHPDQGPLWGHP*HOGGHU9HUVLFKHUXQJ GDV(UEHHLQELFKHQDXIVWRFNHQZLOOVRZDVKDEHQZLUDOOH 7DJH©
ª6FKHLGHWDXV'DVLQGZLUJDQ]VLFKHU©ELHJW6FKZHGOHU HLQH*HVSUlFKVULFKWXQJDEGLHYRQVHLQHP$QOLHJHQZHJIKUW ª'DVLVWPLWDOOHU6RUJIDOWEHUSUIWZRUGHQ+HUU)ULHEHO:DV LFKYRQ,KQHQZLVVHQP|FKWH©(UXQWHUEULFKWVLFKZHLO XQWHUGHU$XIVLFKWGHV2EHUNHOOQHUVGHUQlFKVWH*DQJVHUYLHUW ZLUG6HH]XQJHQILOHWDXI%XWWHUUHLVPLWJHUDVSHOWHU$QDQDV XQG&KRURQVRHGDVLVWHLQHKROOlQGLVFKH6RHPLW:HLZHLQ XQGDQJHVFKZLW]WHQ:UIHOQYRQDEJH]RJHQHQ7RPDWHQYHU PHQJW8QGVWDWW5RWNRPPWQXQ:HLZHLQDXIGHQ7LVFK HLQ*UQHU9HOWOLQHUDXV8QJDUQIHLQZU]LJDEHUNUlIWLJXQG DXVJHJOLFKHQª:DVLFKYRQ,KQHQZLVVHQP|FKWHLVWGLHV'D HVVLFKEHLGHQJHVWRKOHQHQ*HJHQVWlQGHQZLH6LHVRULFKWLJ VDJHQXPPLQGHUZHUWLJH:DUHKDQGHOWNDQQVLHVFKZHUOLFK EHUGHQQRUPDOHQ$QWLTXLWlWHQKDQGHODEJHVHW]WZHUGHQ :HQQMHQHURGHUZHQQGHUDQJHVHKHQH.XQVWKDQGHOLQ)UDJH NlPHGDZWHQZLUVFKRQZDV]XWXQZlUHGDVGUIHQ6LH PLUJODXEHQDEHULQHLQHPVROFKHQ)DOO:RZUGHQ6LHGD DQVHW]HQ"© ª([]HOOHQWJDQ]H[]HOOHQW©OREWGHU2EHUNRPPLVVDUGDV 6HH]XQJHQILOHWª:LH6LHGLHVHV0HQ]XVDPPHQJHVWHOOW KDEHQJURHV.RPSOLPHQW© ª:HQLJVWHQVYRP(VVHQYHUVWHKHLFKHWZDV©HUZLGHUW 6FKZHGOHUVFKPXQ]HOQGXQGIJWJOHLFKKLQ]Xª$EHU]XP YROOHQ'UXFKEUXFKNRPPWGLHVHV7DOHQWLPPHUQXUGDQQ ZHQQGLH)LUPD]DKOW© )ULHEHOODFKWPLW,QGLHVHP$XJHQEOLFNYHUVWHKHQVLHVLFK VHKUJXWª:LUZROOHQPDOGDYRQDXVJHKHQ©VSULFKWGHU 2EHUNRPPLVVDUGDQQ]XU6DFKHªGDHLQ'LHEVWDKOLP $XIWUDJSRWHQWHU6DPPOHUYRQYRUQKHUHLQDXVVFKHLGHW.HLQ 5XEHQVNHLQYDQ*RJKNHLQ/LHEHUPDQQ$OOGDV=HXJDXV GHU-DJGKWWHLVWYLHOPHKUYRQGHU$UWGLHVLFKGHUNOHLQH 0DQQLQGLH%XGHKlQJWVRIHUQHUGHP1RVWDOJLHWUHQGIROJW RGHUHLQHQ+DXFKHUHUEWHU.XOWXUYRUWlXVFKHQZLOO:RNDXIW GLHVHUNOHLQH0DQQ"(UJHKWQLFKWLQ*HVFKlIWHGLHLKPIU WHXUHV*HOG(FKWKHLWGHU:DUHJDUDQWLHUHQHVVROOMDQXUVR DXVVHKHQ([SHUWLVHQVLQGQLFKWJHIUDJW$OVR+LHULQ)UDQN
IXUWJLEW VGHQ)ORKPDUNWLQ6DFKVHQKDXVHQGLH$QWLNHQE|UVH DQGHU(VFKHQKHLPHU:DUWHGHQ.XQVWNHOOHUDP(QGHGHU=HLO RGHUZDVGDV%LOGDQJHKWGLH/lGHQGLH%LOGHUHLQUDKPHQ XQGLPPHUDXFKJHUDKPWH.RSLHQYHUNDXIHQLQGHU%HUOLQHU 6WUDH]XP%HLVSLHORGHUGDV=HXJZLUGLQLUJHQGHLQHP 6HFRQGKDQG*HVFKlIWDOVJQVWLJH*HOHJHQKHLW!DQJHERWHQ 3URIHVVLRQHOOH+HKOHUJHEHQVLFKGDPLWJDUQLFKWHUVWDE$XFK GDVLVWHLQHUGHU*UQGHGDIUGD$PDWHXUHDOV7lWHUYHU PXWHWZHUGHQ© ª,QWHUHVVDQW©VDJW6FKZHGOHUª'LHJOHLFKHQ$EVDW]P|J OLFKNHLWHQKlWWHQGLH.HUOHMDDXFKLQDOOHQDQGHUHQ6WlGWHQ© ª-D©EHVWlWLJW)ULHEHO 8QGGDQQNRPPWVFKRQGDV'HVVHUW0DQJRFUHPH NRQVHUYLHUWH)UFKWHSULHUWPLW=XFNHUXQG-RJKXUWYHU PHQJWXQGPLWJHKDFNWHQ1VVHQEHVWUHXW1DWUOLFK 0RNND
6SlWHUOHKQWVLFK:ROI'LHWHU6FKZHGOHUEHTXHPLQVHLQHP 6FKUHLEWLVFKVHVVHO]XUFNXQGVWUHFNWGLH%HLQHODQJ2EZRKO HUQDFKGHPUHLFKOLFKHQ0DKOPLWGHP.ULPLQDOEHDPWHQ]X )XYRPª)UDQNIXUWHU+RI©LQGLH2SSHQKHLPHU6WUDH]X UFNJHNHKUWLVWKDWHULPPHUQRFKHLQ9|OOHJHIKO(UEH VFKOLHWKHXWHDXIGDV$EHQGEURW]XYHU]LFKWHQ 9RULKPOLHJHQGLHYRQ)ULHEHOHPSIDQJHQHQ0DWHULDOLHQ XQGDOVHUQXQGLHEHUODVVHQH'XUFKVFKULIWGHV)HUQVFKUHL EHQVGXUFKJHKWILQGHWHUGDHLQHQ3XQNWGHULKQVWXW]LJPDFKW VRGDHUGLHIUDJOLFKH6WHOOHURWDQVWUHLFKW(LQHEHLOlXILJH $XVVDJHGHV9DUQGRUIHU%UJHUPHLVWHUV$P$EHQGGHU 7DWQDFKWZXUGHHUYRQGHU+DPEXUJHUª%LOG=HLWXQJ©DQ JHUXIHQXQGXPHLQH%HVFKUHLEXQJGHU/DJHGHU-DJGKWWH JHEHWHQ'HU$QUXIHUQDQQWHVLFK6FKU|GHU:HLOVLFKGHU DQJHNQGLJWH)RWRJUDILP2UWQLFKWVHKHQOLHXQGGHU%UJHU PHLVWHUGDV]XJHVDJWH,QIRUPDWLRQVKRQRUDUDXFKQLFKWHUKLHOW HUVFKLHQHVGHU/DQGHVSROL]HLDQJHEUDFKWLQ+DPEXUJ5FN IUDJH]XQHKPHQ-DHUZLGHUWHPDQEHLGHUª%LOG=HLWXQJ© PDQKDEHHLQHQ+HUUQ6FKU|GHULQGHU+DXSWUHGDNWLRQDEHU
GHU5HGDNWHXUZHLOHLQ:HVWEHUOLQXQGHLQ6XMHW%ULQNPDQQ 9DUQGRUIZlUHLQGHU5HGDNWLRQJlQ]OLFKXQEHNDQQW0DQVHL DEHUGDQNEDUIUGHQ+LQZHLV'DEHLOLHHVGLH/DQGHVSROL]HL EHZHQGHQ 1LFKWVR6FKZHGOHU,QGHP$XJHQEOLFNGDHUGDVOLHVWVWHKW IULKQIHVWGDGLHª$PDWHXU©7KHRULHZRKOGRFKQLFKW VWLPPHQNDQQ'HU$QUXIEHVDJWQlPOLFKGDGLH7lWHU2UWV IUHPGHZDUHQGLHVLFKHUVWHLQPDOEHUGLH/DJHGHV-DJG KDXVHVLQIRUPLHUHQPXWHQ:RKHUDEHUZXWHQ2UWVIUHPGH YRP7RGH%ULQNPDQQV"(LQH/RNDO]HLWXQJXQGDXIMHGHP JU|HUHQ%DKQKRIVLQGDXFKVlPWOLFKH/RNDO]HLWXQJHQ]X EHNRPPHQ'HURGHUGLH(LQEUHFKHUKDEHQGHQ$UWLNHOJHOH VHQXQGVLFKGDUDXIKLQLQ0DUVFKJHVHW]W(LQHHLQVDPH+WWH LP:DOGXQJHIlKUGHWHUNDQQPDQNDXP%HXWHPDFKHQ1HLQ GLHVH9HUIDKUHQVZHLVHLVWGLHYRQ3URILVQLFKWGLHYRQGHQ *URHQGHU%UDQFKHDEHULPPHUKLQ2EGDV(UJHEQLVGHQ (UZDUWXQJHQHQWVSUDFKRGHUQLFKWVWHKWDXIHLQHPDQGHUHQ %ODWW6REHWUDFKWHWLVWVRJDUGDV(LQGULQJHQPLWWHOVHLQHU %UHFKVWDQJHZDKUVFKHLQOLFKJHQDXEHUOHJWJHZHVHQ6ROOWHGD HLQHIDOVFKH6SXUJHOHJWZHUGHQ"6FKZHGOHULVWEHU]HXJWGD GD/HXWHWlWLJZDUHQGLHGXUFKDXVLQGHU/DJHJHZHVHQZlUHQ HLQ6FKORDXIHOHJDQWHUH:HLVH]X|IIQHQ 'HU0LWDUEHLWHUGHU5+(,10$,1'(7(.7(,JUHLIW]XP 7HOHIRQUXIWGLH$QWLNHQE|UVHDQXQGOlWVLFKHLQLJH3UHLVH IUKLVWRULVFKH-DJGZDIIHQQHQQHQ'LH$QWZRUWHQGLHHUDXI VHLQHQ%ORFNNULW]HOWEHUUDVFKHQLKQ'LH1DFKIUDJHLVWVR JURGDVHOEVWIUEUDQGQHXH1DFKELOGXQJHQIXQNWLRQVWFK WLJQDWUOLFKXQGYRQ%FKVHQPDFKHUQRULJLQDOJHWUHXLQ+DQG ZHUNVDUEHLWKHUJHVWHOOWHLQHJDQ]H0HQJHEODXHU6FKHLQH KLQJHEOlWWHUWZHUGHQPX(EHQVRKRFKVWHKHQP|JOLFKVW DXVJHIDOOHQH-DJGWURSKlHQLP.XUVXQGGDVJOHLFKHJLOWIU =LQQJHVFKLUU'HU+HUUZROOHELWWHDOOHJHPDFKWHQ:HUW DQJDEHQLQGHU5HODWLRQVHKHQQHLQH[TXLVLWH6WFNHIKUH GLH$QWLNHQE|UVHQLFKWZHGHU-DJGZDIIHQPLWEHUKPWHQ 0HLVWHUPDUNHQQRFK2ULJLQDOJHPlOGHZHOWEHNDQQWHU0DOHU $EHUPLWVHKUVFK|QHQ.RSLHQN|QQHPDQDXIZDUWHQ
6FKDGHHLQH.RSLHGHVª:LOGEUHWKlQGOHUV©YRQ6Q\GHUVVHL QLFKWGDDEHUGHU+HUUN|QQHJHUQVHLQH7HOHIRQQXPPHU KLQWHUODVVHQXQGVLFKHUVHLQGDHUYHUVWlQGLJWZHUGHVR EDOG8QGPDQZHUGHGLH$XJHQRIIHQKDOWHQ'DUXPELWWHW 6FKZHGOHU *DQ]VLFKHULVWGLH%HXWHDXVGHP-DJGKDXVQRFKQLFKWLP +DQGHOXQGZLUGDXFKLQGHQQlFKVWHQ:RFKHQQLFKWDQ JHERWHQZHUGHQ1LFKWVRODQJHGLHHQWVSUHFKHQGHQ(LQOHJH EOlWWHULP6DFKIDKQGXQJVEXFKQRFKGUXFNIULVFKVLQG/HXWH GHQHQGLH=HLWXQJVOHNWUHGHUILQJLHUWH$QUXIEHLP%UJHU PHLVWHUXQGGDV%UHFKHLVHQHLQILHOHQEHGHQNHQDXFKGDV *DQ]VWLOOZHUGHQVLHVLFKIUVHUVWHYHUKDOWHQXQGDEZDUWHQ ª'DVLVWXQVHUH&KDQFH©VDJW6FKZHGOHUODXWLQGHQOHHUHQ 5DXPª,FKPXVLHGD]XEULQJHQPLUGHQ:LOGEUHWKlQGOHU! DQ]XELHWHQ© (UVWHKWDXIVFKOLHWGHQ+RVHQEXQGXQGJHKWGLH+lQGH LQGHQ-DFNHQWDVFKHQLP=LPPHUDXIXQGDE-HGHVPDODP 6FKUHLEWLVFKEOHLEWHUVWHKHQXQGZLUIWHLQHQ%OLFNDXIGDV 6XFKIDKQGXQJVEODWWPLWGHU$EELOGXQJGHV*HPlOGHV8QGDXI HLQPDOODFKWHUODXWDXI :ROI'LHWHU6FKZHGOHUKDWGDHLQH,GHH
$P$EHQGNOLQJHOWHV$OV'HWMHQGLH:RKQXQJVWU|IIQHW VWHKWGUDXHQVHLQDOWHU%HNDQQWHU-DPHV':LOVRQXQGKDW HLQHQ%OXPHQVWUDXXQWHUP$UPXQGHLQH)ODVFKHLQGHU 0DQWHOWDVFKH ª+DOOR©VDJWGHU6SH]LDODJHQWGHU&HQWUDO,QWHOOLJHQFH $JHQF\LQGHUJHZRKQWHQVDORSSHQ$UWª:HQQ6LHFKDUPDQ WHQ%HVXFKKDEHQJHKHLFKJOHLFKZLHGHU,FKZLOOQLFKW VW|UHQ© ª.RPPHQ6LHUHLQ©ELWWHW$FKLPª8QGZDVGHQFKDU PDQWHQ%HVXFKDQJHKW,FKNRPPHODQJVDPLQGLH-DKUHZR PDQJDQ]JHUQPDOHLQHQ$EHQG]XP$XVUXKHQKDW©
ª:HPVDJHQ6LHGDV©HUZLGHUW:LOVRQVHXI]HQGZLFNHOW GLH%OXPHQDXVZLUIWGDVJHNQOOWH3DSLHUDXIGLH+XWDEODJH XQGUHLFKW'HWMHQGHQ6WUDXª(KUHZHP(KUHJHEKUW" +HU]OLFKHQ*OFNZXQVFK© ª:R]X"© ª6LQG6LH%ULQNWQDQQV1DFKIROJHURGHUQLFKW"5HIHUDWVOHLWHU RGHUQLFKW"©(UZLQNWJOHLFKDEª6LHVLQG VXQGZHQQ6LHGDV QRFKQLFKWZLVVHQ]HLJWGDVQXUZLHODQJVDP,KU$PWDUEHLWHW© ª0HLQ1DPHLVW+DVH©'HWMHQVFKPXQ]HOWXQGJLEWVLFK 0KHIUHXGLJEHUUDVFKW]XZLUNHQª,FKJODXEHGDUDXI PVVHQZLUHLQHQWULQNHQ© ª*OlVHU©IRUGHUW:LOVRQXQGJHKWQDFKGHPHUDEJHOHJWKDW YRUDQLQV:RKQ]LPPHU(UNHQQWVLFKDXVHULVWMDEHUHLWV IUKHUKLHUJHZHVHQ=LHOVWUHELJPDUVFKLHUWHUDXIGHQ6HVVHO ]XGHPHUEHUHLWVEHLDQGHUHU*HOHJHQKHLWGHQ9RU]XJJH JHEHQKDW $FKLPIROJWLKP:lKUHQGHU*Ol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lUHUWlWLJNHLWLQQHUKDOEGHU%XQGHV OXIWZDIIH'DVHLQHHUJlQ]WGDVDQGHUH(UZLUGDXFKIUGHUKLQ PLWVSLHOHQ ª7KUHHFKHHUVRGHUZLHPDQKLHUZRKOVDJW+RFKVROOHU
OHEHQ©UXIW:LOVRQUHLFKW$FKLPHLQJHIOOWHV*ODVXQGVW|W PLWLKPDQ'HUREOLJDWH:KLVN\PLW(LVDXV'HWMHQV.KO VFKUDQN:LOVRQXQG:KLVN\EHLGHVIlQJWPLW:DQXQGGHU 0DQQKDWZRKODXFK]XYLHOH$JHQWHQILOPHJHVHKHQGHUHQ +HOGHQGDV=HXJOLWHUZHLVHKLQXQWHUJLHHQ ª:DVVDJHQGHQQHLJHQWOLFK,KUHDOWHQ.DPHUDGHQ]XP7RGH %ULQNWQDQQV"©NRPPWHUGDQQPKHORV]XU6DFKH ª0DQEHWUDXHUWLKQ© ª4XDWVFK©NRQWHUWGHU6SH]LDODJHQWWURFNHQª0DQYHUPLW LKQHEHQVRZHQLJZLHGLHVHQ$GPLUDODXVGHP%HVFKDIIXQJV DPWGHUVLFKGLH3LVWROHDQGLH6FKOlIHJHVHW]WKDWGL OHWWDQWLVFKHUZHLVHDQGLHUHFKWHREZRKOHUHLQJHVWDQGHQHU /LQNVKlQGHUZDUXQGPLWGHU5HFKWHQQLFKWHLQPDOHLQHQ %OHLVWLIWKDOWHQNRQQWHRGHUGHQ5HJLHUXQJVUDWDXVGHP $XVZlUWLJHQ$PWGHUVRXQJHVFKLFNWDXVGHP)HQVWHUVDK GDHUDXVGHPIQIWHQ6WRFNZHUNDXIGHQ$VSKDOWILHO'UHL DOWH.DPHUDGHQXQGVLHKRFNWHQ]LHPOLFKRIW]XVDPPHQZLH ZLUOHLGHUHUVWKLQWHUKHUHUIDKUHQKDEHQ:DVVDJWGHQQ,KU )UHXQG:LHVHQHFNGD]X"© ª1LFKWV©HUZLGHUW'HWMHQª$XHUGHPLVWHUQLFKWPHLQ )UHXQG© :LOVRQEHXJWVLFKEHUGLH=LJDUHWWHQGRVHDXIGHP7LVFK XQGEHGLHQWVLFKª6HLWZDQQVLQG6LHVR]XUFNKDOWHQGPLU JHJHQEHU",FKGDFKWHLPPHU:LHVHQHFNKDEH6LHLQGLH -DJGKWWHJHVFKLFNWGDPLWHLQ]XYHUOlVVLJHU0DQQGHQ7RWHQ ILQGHW© $FKLPVFKZHQNWGDV*ODVXQGOlWGLH(LVZUIHOGDULQ NOLUUHQª6RZHLWGDFKWHQ6LHULFKWLJ©UlXPWHUJHODVVHQHLQ ª$EHUDOOHVDQGHUH©'HWMHQVFKWWHOWGHQ.RSIª.HLQ :RUW9RP$GPLUDOKDEHLFKLQGHU=HLWXQJJHOHVHQXQGGD KLHHVHUVHL2SIHUHLQHV9HUNHKUVXQIDOOVJHZRUGHQ'LH 6DFKHPLWGHP5HJLHUXQJVUDWDXVGHP$XVZlUWLJHQ$PW NHQQHLFKEHUKDXSWQLFKW© 'HUDQGHUHOlWVHLQ)HXHU]HXJDXIIODPPHQª'DVJHVFKDK LQ0DGULGXQGHVZDUHLQ+RWHOIHQVWHU1XQ,KUH5HJLHUXQJ DUEHLWHWMDZRKOLQRIIL]LHOOUHFKWJXWPLW)UDQFR]XVDPPHQ©
ª=XIlOOHJLEW V©'HU0DMRUZXQGHUWVLFKXQGIOOWGLH*OlVHU QHXªhEULJHQVZXUGHEHLPLUDXFKLQDOOHU+HLPOLFKNHLW +DXVVXFKXQJJHKDOWHQ9RQ:LHVHQHFNXQGVHLQH0DQQHQ VLQGJUQGOLFKXQGGDLFK%ULQNPDQQV6WHOOYHUWUHWHUZDU© ª$KD©HUZLGHUW:LOVRQJHGHKQW(UQLFNWYRUVLFKKLQDOV ZROOHHUVLFKHLQHQ*HGDQNHQEHVWlWLJHQª6LHGUHKHQGXUFK ZHLOLKQHQHLQH3DQQHSDVVLHUWLVW© ª,FKP|FKWHQLFKWXQEHGLQJWGXPPVWHUEHQ©SURYR]LHUW 'HWMHQª:HQQHV,KQHQQLFKWVDXVPDFKW0LVWHU:LOVRQ© ª6LHPVVHQHVVRJDUZLVVHQZHLOLFKHWZDVPLW,KQHQ YRUKDEH'LH6LWXDWLRQLQ0LWWHOHXURSD'LHDOWHQ.DPHUDGHQ XQGGLHMXQJHQ/HXWHGLHLQLKUH)XVWDSIHQJHWUHWHQVLQG VFKUHQVLHGRFKPLWGHUHUNOlUWHQ$EVLFKWGDVSROLWLVFKH .DUWHQELOGGHVDOWHQ.RQWLQHQWV]XYHUlQGHUQ(VLVWLKQHQ ]XYLHO5RWGUDXI:R]XGHQQVRQVWDOOGLHVH$QVWUHQJXQJHQ XQGGLHJDQ]H+HNWLN"1DWUOLFKVLQGVLHVLFKGDUEHULP NODUHQGDVLHDOOHLQQLFKWVPHKUDXVULFKWHQN|QQHQ'DHV JHUDGHQRFKGD]XUHLFKWGHQ6WDUWVFKXDE]XIHXHUQDEHU GDQQ© 'HU6SH]LDODJHQWVWHKWDXIXQGEHJLQQWLP=LPPHUKLQXQG KHU]XODXIHQZlKUHQGHUIRUWIlKUWª'D]LHKHQVLHLQV.DONO GDGLH1$72LP)DOOHHLQHVEHZDIIQHWHQ.RQIOLNWVDQGHU (OEHQLFKWXPKLQNRPPHQZLUGLKUH%QGQLVYHUSIOLFKWXQJHQ ]XHUIOOHQ:DVZLOOVLHPDFKHQVRIHUQPDQVLHQXUYRU YROOHQGHWH7DWVDFKHQVWHOOW"(LQ]HOQH0LWJOLHGHUN|QQHQPLW GHQ=lKQHQNQLUVFKHQXQGJDUNHLQH/XVWKDEHQLKUH6ROGDWHQ LQ5LFKWXQJ8UDOPDUVFKLHUHQ]XODVVHQHVEOHLEWLKQHQNHLQH :DKO,FKELQEHU]HXJWGDLQGLHVHU5HFKQXQJGDV0DQ|YHU HLQHHQWVFKHLGHQGH5ROOHVSLHOWGDVGHQ'HXWVFKHQLQV+DXV VWHKW&KHFNPDWH6LHZLVVHQDOVDOWHU6ROGDWGDHVEHLVR ZDVPLWGHP=XVDPPHQ]LHKHQQRFKVRJURHU.DPSIYHU ElQGHQLFKWJHWDQLVW'LH6WlEHSUREHQGHQ(UQVWIDOOPLWDOOHQ 1DFKVFKXEXQG7UDQVSRUWIUDJHQGLHLQGHQ+HLPDWOlQGHUQ YHUEOHLEHQGHQ7UXSSHQVLQGLQ$ODUP]XVWDQGYHUVHW]WGDPLW VLHDXFKHWZDVGDYRQKDEHQPDQNDQQSUDNWLVFKYRQHLQHU 6WXQGHDXIGLHDQGHUHPRELOPDFKHQXQGHLQHQ7DJVSlWHU
VHOEVWEHU7HLOHGHV(UVDW]KHHUHVYHUIJHQ8QGZHQQGLH 'DPSIZDO]HHLQPDOLQ%HZHJXQJLVWYHUPDJVLHQDFKGHU K|KHUHQ0DWKHPDWLNGHU.ULHJVNXQVWNHLQHUPHKUDXI]XKDO WHQ© :HUQHU%UHGHEXVFKKDW0KHUXKLJXQGEHKHUUVFKW]X EOHLEHQ:LQQLH:LQNHOPDQQVXQGVHLQH9HUPXWXQJHQILQGHQ LKUH%HVWlWLJXQJ0HUNZUGLJHUZHLVHKDWHULQGLHVHP$XJHQ EOLFNHLQHLQ]LJHV%LOGEHUGHXWOLFKXQGPLWTXlOHQGHU*H QDXLJNHLWYRUVLFK(UVLHKWVLFKGHQMXQJHQ)OXJ]HXJIKUHU LQHLQHP6FKODFKWIOLHJHUYHUEDQGGHU1D]L/XIWZDIIHPLW HLQHU+HQVFKHO+V(QGH-XOLDXIHLQHQ(LVHQEDKQ NQRWHQSXQNWLQGHU1lKHYRQ0LQVNQLHGHUVWRHQHUEH REDFKWHWZLHGHU(LQVFKOlJHK|UWQRFKHLQPDOGDV5DWWHUQYRQ %RUGZDIIHQXQGQLPPWEHUGHXWOLFKZDKUGDGRUWXQWHQ NDXP0lQQHULQGHQHUGEUDXQHQ)HOGEOXVHQGHU5RWHQ$UPHH VLQGZRKODEHU)UDXHQPLWEXQWHQ.RSIWFKHUQ.LQGHUDXI GHP$UP.LQGHUDQGHQ5RFNVFK|HQ8QGXPVLHKHUXP EULFKWGLH+|OOHORVEHUVWHQ:DJJRQVZHUGHQ(UGH*OHLVH =JHXQG*HElXGHXPJHSIOJWYRQ'HWRQDWLRQHQ(U:HUQHU %UHGHEXVFKKDWGDPDOVGLHYLHU.LOR%RPEHQXQWHUGHQ 6FKZLQJHQGHV'RSSHOGHFNHUVQLFKWDXVJHO|VWXQGNHLQ 6FKXLVWDXVGHQEHLGHQ0*JHIDOOHQDEHU'DVZDUGDV *HVLFKWGHV.ULHJHVGHUYHUIOXFKWHQªDOWHQ.DPHUDGHQ© ª-DMD©JHKW'HWMHQDXI:LOVRQV:RUWHPLWHLQHPVDFK OLFKHQ,QWHUHVVHHLQGDVLKQEHUPHQVFKOLFKH$QVWUHQJXQJHQ NRVWHWª8QGZHQQLFK6LHULFKWLJYHUVWHKHKDWHVGXUFK %ULQNPDQQXQGVHLQHQ$QKDQJHLQH3DQQHJHJHEHQ$EHUZLH GHQQ",FKEHJUHLIHGDVQLFKW© (UPXVLFKXQZLVVHQGHUVWHOOHQDOVHULVW'DV*HVSUlFKPLW %ULQNPDQQLQGHPLKQGHU2EHUVWEHUVHLQH9RUEHKDOWH LQIRUPLHUWHGHQJHJHQZlUWLJHQ=HLWSXQNWDOVXQJHHLJQHWIU HLQH5HYLVLRQGHU(UJHEQLVVHGHV]ZHLWHQ:HOWNULHJHVEH WUDFKWHWHXQGPLW6FKULWWHQ]XU9HUKLQGHUXQJHLQHVULVNDQWHQ $EHQWHXHUVGURKWHGDUIHLQIDFKQLFKWVWDWWJHIXQGHQKDEHQ (EHQVRZHQLJGDUIHUHWZDVYRQ%ULQNPDQQV1DFKODDKQHQ XQGHUVWUHFKWQLFKWNDQQLKPGLHILHEHUKDIWH6XFKHGDQDFK DXIJHIDOOHQVHLQ
'HU6SH]LDODJHQWJHKW]XP.KOVFKUDQNXPQHXH(LVZUIHO ]XKROHQª.HQQHQ6LHHLQHQ6LU5HJLQDOG'RXJODV"©IUDJWHU EHUGLH6FKXOWHU$OV$FKLPYHUQHLQWHUZLGHUWHUNXU]ª$XFK HLQ%ULQNPDQQ,QWLPXV5R\DO$LU)RUFH1$726WDE*ODX EHQ6LHGD(QJODQG.ULHJIKUHQZLOO"(VZLUGQRFKODQJH EUDXFKHQPLWGHQ$XVZLUNXQJHQGHVOHW]WHQ.ULHJHVIHUWLJ]X ZHUGHQ:HQQPDQGDQXUGDV*HULQJVWHYRQGHU6XSSHDKQHQ ZUGHGLHGLHDOWHQ.DPHUDGHQ!DQNRFKHQPDQZUGHVLH YRP)HXHUUHLHQHKHVLH]XZDOOHQEHJLQQW2GHUGLH)UDQ ]RVHQPLWLKUHPRKQHKLQGLVWDQ]LHUWHQ9HUKlOWQLV]XP1RUG DWODQWLNSDNWGXOLHEH*WH-DXQG%ULQNPDQQHLQJHZHLKW LQDOOHVKDWHUVWNU]OLFKDQHEHQMHQHQ6LU5HJLQDOGHLQHQ IUHXQGOLFKHQ%ULHIJHVFKULHEHQ©:LOVRQNHKUWDQGHQ7LVFK ]XUFNª$OV6LHLQ%ULQNPDQQV+WWHJHZHVHQVLQGKDEHQ 6LHGDHLQ%LOGJHVHKHQ"6RHLQHQ6FKLQNHQLQ(VVLJXQGgO"© ª-DKLQJDQGHU:DQG© ª'HU:LOGEUHWKlQGOHU!© ª(VVWDQGNHLQ1DPHGUDQ$EHU9LHK]HXJZDUGUDXI:DV LVWGDPLW"©'DEHLGHQNWHUGD%ULQNPDQQGHQLP'LHQVW ]LPPHU]XUFNJHODVVHQHQ%ULHIQRFKHLQPDOJHVFKULHEHQKDW XQGGDGHUªOLHEH)UHXQG©GHU$QUHGH]ZHLIHOORVPLW6LU 5HJLQDOG'RXJODVLGHQWLVFKLVW6FKRQZLHGHUGDV*HPlOGH 2IIHQEDUKDWGHUEULWLVFKH)OLHJHUVRIRUWJHDQWZRUWHWGHU%ULHI LVWQDWUOLFKLQYRQ:LHVHQHHNV+lQGHJHODQJWXQGGLH&,$KDW GXUFKHLQHQ6SLW]HOLP0$'SRVWZHQGHQGGDYRQHUIDKUHQ ª:DVVROOGDPLWVHLQ"(VZDUQXUHLQH)UDJHDP5DQGH© EDJDWHOOLVLHUW:LOVRQª:DUXPWULQNHQ6LHGHQQQLFKW"6FKOLH OLFKVLQG6LH VGHUJHIHLHUWZLUG© 3IOLFKWVFKXOGLJVHW]W$FKLPGDV*ODVDQGLH/LSSHQª(LQ GLFNHU+XQGZHQQGDVDOOHVVWLPPW*XWGD6LHZLVVHQZDV DXIGHU3IDQQHLVW'DNDQQMDQLFKWVPHKUVFKLHIJHKHQ,FK OHVHMHGHQ7DJLQGHQ=HLWXQJHQZLHVHKUVLFK5HJLHUXQJXQG .RQJUHLQ:DVKLQJWRQXPGLH(UKDOWXQJGHV)ULHGHQV PKHQ© 'LHJH]LHOWH3URYRNDWLRQWULIIWYROOLQV6FKZDU]H:LOVRQ OLHJWPHKULP6HVVHODOVHUVLW]WKDWHLQ%HLQEHUGDVDQGHUH
JHVFKODJHQXQGEHWUDFKWHWDQJHOHJHQWOLFKVHLQHZLSSHQGH 6FKXKVSLW]Hª:DVKLQJWRQXQGGHU.RQJUH©DQWZRUWHWGHU 6SH]LDODJHQWª'DVLVWGLHHLQH6HLWH,FKVWHOOHQLFKWHLQPDO LQ)UDJHGDXQVHUH)ULHGHQVDSRVWHOHKUOLFKPHLQHQZDVVLH VDJHQXQGVDJHQPVVHQXPGLH6WLPPHQLKUHU:lKOHU]X EHKDOWHQ$EJHRUGQHWHXQG3UlVLGHQWHQNRPPHQXQGJHKHQ GLH&,$EOHLEW'DVLVWGLHDQGHUH6HLWH:LUPVVHQLQ JU|HUHQ'LPHQVLRQHQGHQNHQZHLWUlXPLJXQGDXIODQJH 6LFKW0DFKHQZLUXQVGRFKQLFKWVYRU'HWMHQ'LH=HLWDU EHLWHWJHJHQXQV-HOlQJHUGHU(LQIOXEHUHLFKGHU.RPPX QLVWHQEHVWHKWGHVWRPHKUZLUGHUVLFKIHVWLJHQGHVWRJU|HU ZLUGVHLQH$Q]LHKXQJVNUDIW'DUDQNDQQXQVQLFKWOLHJHQ6R EHWUDFKWHWLVWGHU=HLWSXQNWWDWVlFKOLFKJQVWLJ,FKZHUGHGHQ 7HXIHOWXQXQGGHP5DGGHV6FKLFNVDOVLQGLH6SHLFKHQIDOOHQ NHLQ*HGDQNH:RUDQPLUOLHJWLVW]XMHGHU=HLWLP%LOGH ]XVHLQXPLPULFKWLJHQ0RPHQWGLHULFKWLJHQ:HLFKHQVWHOOHQ ]XN|QQHQ8QWHUDQGHUHPELQLFKGHVZHJHQKLHU© 'HWMHQJULQVWLKPLQV*HVLFKWª1DSULPD©VDJWHUª-HW]W HQGOLFKZHLLFKZHUHLQ]LJXQGDOOHLQGLH*HVFKLFNHGHU 9HUHLQLJWHQ6WDDWHQYRQ$PHULNDOHQNW-DPHV':LOVRQ :HUKlWWHGDVJHGDFKW© :LOVRQILQGHWGDVJDUQLFKWNRPLVFKª$FK"©IUDJWHUª+DW HVVLFKVRDQJHK|UW"7XWPLUOHLG(VJLEW QH0HQJHHLQIOX UHLFKHU:LOVRQVLQ$PHULNDVLHKHLHQQXUDQGHUV© ª.RPPHQZLUGRFKPDO]XU6DFKH/DVVHQ6LHGLH.DW]H DXVGHP6DFN:HOFKH,QIRUPDWLRQHUZDUWHQ6LHYRQPLU"© 'HU6SH]LDODJHQWUHNHOWVLFKKRFKª.RQNUHWH)UDJHNRQ NUHWH$QWZRUW,FKP|FKWHJHQDXZLVVHQZRUXPHVEHLGHU 6WDEVEXQJLQGHU/QHEXUJHU+HLGHJHKW© ª,FKDXFK©'DVPHLQWHUJDQ]HKUOLFK ª:DVVROOGDVKHLHQ"© ª0LULVWQLFKWEHIRKOHQZRUGHQGDUDQWHLO]XQHKPHQQLH PDQGHPDXVGHP5HIHUDW'LHPLWWHOIULVWLJH3ODQXQJ!LVWGRUW QLFKWJHIUDJW© ª+HOODQGGDPQDWLRQ'DVKDWPLUJHIHKOW©:LOVRQVSULQJW DXIUXQ]HOWGLH6WLUQJUEHOWXQGVDJWGDQQª6LHQHKPHQWHLO©
(UOHHUWGDV*ODVDXIHLQHQ=XJª6ROFKH*HVFKLFKWHQNDQQ PDQGRFKQLFKWRKQHPLWWHOIULVWLJH3ODQXQJ!PDFKHQ9RU VWHOOXQJHQKDEHQPDQFKH/HXWH© ª(VLVWQLFKW]XIDVVHQ©EHVWlWLJW$FKLPXQGQLPPWGHQ7RQ GHVDQGHUHQDXI 1DFKGHPGLH)ODVFKHOHHUXQGGHU6SH]LDODJHQWDXVhEHUVHH JHJDQJHQLVW]LHKW:HUQHU%UHGHEXVFKGLH5ROORVKHUXQWHU EUDXWVLFKHLQHQ.DIIHHGHU7RWHHUZHFNHQN|QQWHXQGPDFKW VLFKDQGLH$UEHLW(UIDWGHQ,QKDOWGHV*HVSUlFKVPLW:LOVRQ DXIGDV:HVHQWOLFKH]XVDPPHQIRUPXOLHUWVWUHLFKWDXV VFKUHLEWQHX'LHXQPLYHUVWlQGOLFKDEJHIDWHQ.HUQVlW]H YHUVFKOVVHOWHU'LHEHVFKULHEHQHQ%RJHQYHUEUHQQWHUXQG VSOWGLH$VFKHLP$XVJXKLQXQWHUhEULJEOHLEWHLQ6WFN FKHQGQQHV/XIWSRVWSDSLHUEHGHFNWPLW=DKOHQNRORQQHQLQ ZLQ]LJHU6FKULIW'DVVWHFNWHULQGLHOHHUH3ODVWLNKOOHHLQHU .XJHOVFKUHLEHUPLQHGHUJOHLFKHQNDQQEHUDOOKHUXPOLHJHQ RKQH9HUGDFKW]XHUZHFNHQGHU9HUVFKOXNRPPWZLHGHU GDUDXIXQGDQVFKOLHHQGKDW:HUQHUGDVGULQJHQGH%HGUIQLV HLQH6WXQGH/XIW]XVFKQDSSHQ 1LHPDQGDFKWHWDXIGHQHLQVDPHQ6SD]LHUJlQJHUGHUGXUFK GHQ+RIJDUWHQEXPPHOWXQGGLH)lKUJDVVHKLQXQWHU]XP 5KHLQVFKOHQGHUW$P5DWKHQDXXIHUKHUUVFKWNDXPQRFK 9HUNHKUHLQ)XQNZDJHQWU|GHOWYRUEHUXQGDQHLQHUGHU $QOHJHVWHOOHQVFKDXNHOWHLQ$XVIOXJVGDPSIHU'LH3DVVDJLHUH KDEHQLKQOlQJVWYHUODVVHQ1XULP8QWHUGHFNEUHQQWQRFK /LFKWXQGDXVHLQHPZHLHQ.KOZDJHQZHUGHQ%HKlOWHU DXVJHODGHQDXIV6FKLIIJHWUDJHQXQGGXUFKHLQH/DGHOXNH KLQDEJHJHEHQ(LQZRUWORVHV*HVFKlIW*HZRKQKHLWQlFKW OLFKHU$OOWDJIU0DQQVFKDIWXQG6FKLIIVYHUVRUJHU :HUQHU%UHGHEXVFKJHKWZHLWHUDP)OXHQWODQJZHFKVHOW GLH6WUDHQVHLWHXQGKDWMHW]WQHEHQVLFKGLHKRKHVFKPXW ]LJURWH3RUSK\UPDXHUGLHGDVDQVWHLJHQGH(UGUHLFKYRUGHP +LQXQWHUUXWVFKHQDXIGLH6WUDHEHZDKUHQVROO'LH6WHOOHDQ GHUHUVWHKHQEOHLEWOLHJWJHQDXLQGHU0LWWH]ZLVFKHQ]ZHL /DWHUQHQXQGGDPLWYHUJOHLFKVZHLVHLP'XQNHOQ6FKRQDXI GHP:HJH]LHKW:HUQHUDXVGHU%UXVWWDVFKHHLQHNOHLQH1D
JHOIHLOH(UKDWVLHLQGHU+DQGDOVHUDP=LHOLVW'DOHKQWHU VLFKDQGLH0DXHUZLHMHPDQGGHUYHUVFKQDXIHQZLOOVLHKWVLFK QRFKHLQPDOXPXQGDOVHUZHLWHUJHKWLVWGDV5|KUFKHQLQ MHQHU:DQGIXJHYHUVFKZXQGHQGLHQXUVFKHLQEDUGXUFK 0|UWHOIHVWYHUVFKORVVHQLVW'HUHLQJHZHLKWH.XULHUILQGHW GHQ7RWHQ%ULHINDVWHQPKHORV(UOLHJWIQI4XDGHUUKHLQDXI ZlUWVQHEHQGHUJXHLVHUQHQDOWHQ:DVVHUVWDQGVPDUNHGLHDQ HLQOlQJVWYHUJHVVHQHV+RFKZDVVHUHULQQHUWXQGJHQDXLQGHU +|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ª$OWHQ=ROOKRI©QRFKHLQ %LHUXQGHLQHQ0DJHQELWWHU:HLOLKP:LOVRQV:KLVN\LP 1DFKKLQHLQ8QEHKDJHQEHUHLWHWOlWHUVLFKYRP2EHUHLQ 7D[LUXIHQXQGIlKUWQDFK+DXVH ,QGLHVHU1DFKWEOHLEWHUODQJHZDFK)lOOWHVQLFKWVFKZHU IUP|JOLFK]XKDOWHQZDVGDLQDOOHU+HLPOLFKNHLWHPVLJ YRUEHUHLWHWZLUG",VWGDVDOOHVQLFKWQXUHLQZVWHU7UDXPDXV GHPPDQHUOHLFKWHUWHUZDFKW"1HLQ'DVLVWGLHQDFNWH:LUN OLFKNHLWGLHNODU]XVHKHQXQGGHU]XEHJHJQHQJLOWHKHHV]X VSlWLVW
ªXQGVRPDFKHLFKPLFK]XP6SUHFKHUDOOHUZHQQLFK+HUUQ 'HWMHQVRZRKO]XVHLQHU%HI|UGHUXQJDOVDXFK]XU(UQHQQXQJ ]XP5HIHUDWVOHLWHUVHKUKHU]OLFKXQVHUH*OFNZQVFKHDXV VSUHFKH,FKVDJHQDFKDOWHU)OLHJHUVLWWHNXU]XQGEQGLJ +DOVXQG%HLQEUXFK+HUU2EHUVWOHXWQDQW© 0DMRU6FKPLWWGHUDOVGLHQVWlOWHVWHU2IIL]LHUGHU$EWHLOXQJ GLHNOHLQH$QVSUDFKHJHKDOWHQKDWKHEWGDV6HNWJODVXQGVW|W DOVHUVWHUPLW$FKLPDQ'LHDQGHUHQIROJHQLQGHUJHQDXHQ 5HLKHQIROJHGHU'LHQVWJUDGH=XOHW]WVLQGGLH=LYLODQJHVWHOOWHQ GUDQ)UDX0DUVFKQHUOlWHVVLFKQLFKWQHKPHQIUGLHVH JHVRQGHUWHLQSDDU:RUWH]XVDJHQXQGDOVVLHLKUHJHIKOV EHWRQWH5HGHKlOWZHUGHQLKUVRJDUHLQELFKHQGLH$XJHQ IHXFKW6LHPDJ'HWMHQXQGGHVKDOEKDWVLHDXFKGLHNOHLQH *UDWXODWLRQVFRXULQ%HZHJXQJJHEUDFKWXQGGDIUJHVRUJW GD6HNWJHKROWZXUGHDOVGLH=LYLODQJHVWHOOWHQEHLP&KHIVLH PLWJH]LHOWHU,QGLVNUHWLRQZLVVHQOLHHQZDUXP0DMRU'HWMHQ ]XP*HQHUDOEHIRKOHQZXUGHª(UZLUG2EHUVWOHXWQDQWXQG 5HIHUDWVFKHI©GDVJHQJWH $FKLP]HLJWVLFKEHUUDVFKW)UHXGHXQGHLQH6SXUPlQQ OLFKHU5KUXQJVLQGLKPDQ]XVHKHQ9RQZHLWHUHUNDPHUDG VFKDIWOLFKHU=XVDPPHQDUEHLWEHLGHU/|VXQJGHUDQVWHKHQGHQ $XIJDEHQVSULFKWHUYRQGHU)RUWVHW]XQJGHUEHZlKUWHQ 7HDPDUEHLWLP*HLVWHYRQJHJHQVHLWLJHU$FKWXQJXQGZHFKVHO VHLWLJHP9HUWUDXHQXQGHUYHUVlXPWDXFKQLFKWLQZRKO JHVHW]WHQ:RUWHQ%ULQNPDQQDOV9RUELOG]XHUZlKQHQZDV PDQVRVDJWEHLVROFKHP$QOD1DWUOLFKHUZDUWHQDOOHGD HU]XHLQHP8PWUXQNHLQOlGWDXHUKDOEGHV'LHQVWEHUHLFKV QDWUOLFK(UZLUGGHPJHUHFKWXQGNQGLJWDQPDQZHUGHDQ HLQHPGHUQlFKVWHQ7DJHLP)OLHJHUNOXEGDV(UHLJQLVHLQZHQLJ EHJLHHQ'DQQGDQNWHUQRFKHLQPDOXQGEHGDXHUWGDPDQ QXQOHLGHUJOHLFK]XU7DJHVRUGQXQJEHUJHKHQPVVH 'LHNXU]H=HLWVHLQHU$EZHVHQKHLWKDW)UDX0DUVFKQHU JHQJWVHLQHSHUV|QOLFKHQ6DFKHQLQ%ULQNPDQQV=LPPHU
KLQEHU]XUlXPHQ8QG.DIIHHEULQJWVLHLKPDXFKJOHLFKVR QDFKGHP0RWWRª'HU.|QLJLVWWRWHVOHEHGHU.|QLJ© 'DVLW]WHUQXQXQGMHW]WOLHJWKLHUXQWHUGHU*ODVSODWWHGDV JURIRUPDWLJHXQGKRFKJOlQ]HQGH)RWRMHQHUEXQWVFKHFNLJHQ 0HGLHHLQVWGHUHFKWH'HWMHQVWHXHUWH9|OOLJXQVROGDWLVFK NQ|SIWHUGLH8QLIRUPMDFNHDXIYHUVFKUlQNWGLH$UPHYRUGHU %UXVWXQGVWUHFNWGLH%HLQHXQWHUGHQ7LVFK-DGHU''5 .XQGVFKDIWHU:HUQHU%UHGHEXVFKKDWHVZHLWJHEUDFKWLQGHU %RQQHU/XIWZDIIH'LHVQLFKW]XOHW]WGXUFKGHQ8PVWDQGGD HUHVJHVFKDIIWKDWDXFKGLHDOOPlFKWLJH&HQWUDO,QWHOOLJHQFH $JHQF\LQ*HVWDOWLKUHV6SH]LDODJHQWHQ-DPHV':LOVRQ]X WlXVFKHQXQGIUVLFKHLQ]XQHKPHQ(LQNRUUXSWHU+DXIHQLVW GDVKLHU'HQ6WHUQPHKUXQGGLHK|KHUH'LHQVWVWHOOXQJGDQNW HUDXVVFKOLHOLFKGHP8PVWDQGGDHUGLHULFKWLJHQ/HXWH NHQQW6HLQ:HJZDULQGHP$XJHQEOLFNJHPDFKWLQGHPHV LKPJHODQJGHQHKHPDOLJHQª.RPPRGRUH©XQGMHW]LJHQ 2EHUVWD'.U|VLQJKLQWHUV/LFKW]XIKUHQ.U|VLQJV7RFK WHUKHLUDWHWHGHQ0$'*HQHUDOYRQ:LHVHQHFNYRQ :LHVHQHFNKDWJXWH%H]LHKXQJHQ]X:LOVRQHLQHUJDEVHLQ :RKOZROOHQIUGHQDQJHEOLFKHQ-DJGIOLHJHUDQGHQQlFKVWHQ ZHLWHUXQGVRLQ:RKOZROOHQYHUSDFNWVWLHJHUNUDIWGHV (LQIOXVVHVGHU0HLQXQJVELOGQHULQGLHVHP6WDDWYRQ6WXIH]X 6WXIH'LHVH0HFKDQLNIXQNWLRQLHUWDXWRPDWLVFKXQGKDWLKQ PLW]ZLQJHQGHU)ROJHULFKWLJNHLWDXIVHLQHQQHXHQ6WXKOJH VHW]W(UNDQQI|UPOLFKGDUDXIZDUWHQGDHUYRQGHP.UHLV GHULKQ]XPHLJHQHQ1XW]HQGLH7UHSSHKLQDXIVFKLHEWLQ .U]HPLWZHLWHUHQ$XIJDEHQEHWUDXWZHUGHQZLUG0DQHU ZDUWHWYRQLKPGDHUVLFKHUNHQQWOLFK]HLJWXPVRQVWLVWGHU 7RGXQGZHUZHLZDVVLHVLFKQXQZLHGHUDXVGHQNHQ)U GHQ0$'*HQHUDOKDWHUGHQWRWHQ%ULQNPDQQJHIXQGHQ :LOVRQZLOOLKQEHLGHU6WDEVEXQJLQGHU/QHEXUJHU+HLGH KDEHQXQG.U|VLQJ'HUVWHKWQRFKDXVDEHUYRQLKP NRPPWVLFKHUOLFKDXFKQRFKZDV 0DQFKPDOLVWHUGHVDOOHQHQWVHW]OLFKPGH0DQFKPDO ZQVFKWHUVLFKLQGLH+HLPDWMHQVHLWVGHU(OEH]XUFNLQ VDXEHUH9HUKlOWQLVVHXQGLQGLH*HERUJHQKHLW/HEHQZLHHLQ
0HQVFK$EHUHUZLUGDXIVHLQHP3RVWHQDXVKDOWHQVRODQJH %HUOLQLKQKLHUEHOlW (UJLEWVLFKHLQHQ5XFNXQGQLPPWGHQREHQDXIOLHJHQGHQ %DQGYRQGHP$NWHQSDNHWGDV)UDX0DUVFKQHUDXIGHQ 6FKUHLEWLVFKJHWUPWKDWVHW]WGLH%ULOOHDXIRKQHGLHHU LQ]ZLVFKHQEHLP/HVHQNDXPQRFKDXVNRPPWXQGZLGPHW VLFKGHQGLHQVWOLFKHQ2EOLHJHQKHLWHQ
$FKLP'HWMHQVWHKWLP%DGH]LPPHUXQGKlQJWQDFKHLQDQGHU GUHLWURSIQDVVH1\ORQKHPGHQDXIGLH/HLQH'HU+HPGHQ ZHJHQQLPPWHUGLH=XJHKIUDXQLFKWLQ$QVSUXFKGLHZlVFKW HULPPHUVHOEVW:LHHUVLHGDVRKlQJHQXQGWURSIHQVLHKW GHQNWHU6RJHKWGHU7DJ]X(QGHDQGHPPDQ2EHUVWOHXWQDQW JHZRUGHQXQGGHP0DUVFKDOOVWDEZLHGHUHLQ6WFNQlKHU JHUFNWLVW8QGGDEHLVFKPXQ]HOWHU 'DV7HOHIRQUXIWLKQKLQEHULQV:RKQ]LPPHUXQGDOVHU DEJHKREHQXQGVLFKJHPHOGHWKDWVDJWHLQHVHKUMXQJH )UDXHQVWLPPHª+HUGHJHQ'HUJUQH)LDWDXIGHP3DUNSODW] YRP.|OQHU=RR+HUU'HWMHQ"© ª-D*XWHQ$EHQGJQlGLJH)UDX,FKELQGHUhEHOWlWHU *ODXEHQ6LHPLUELWWHGDHVPLUVFKUHFNOLFKXQDQJHQHKPLVW :DVNDQQLFKIU6LHWXQ"© 'LH$QUXIHULQODFKWXQGGDNRPPWLKUH6WLPPH$FKLPQRFK MQJHUYRUDOVYRUKLQª$FKLFKELQVFKRQJDQ]EHUXKLJW (LJHQWOLFKZROOWHLFKPLFKQXUYHUJHZLVVHUQGDGHU1DPH DXIGHU9LVLWHQNDUWHVWLPPW'DVJHKWMDGDQQZRKOLQ2UG QXQJ© 'LHVH6WLPPHJHIlOOWLKP$XIHLQPDOKDWHU/XVWVLHQRFK HLQELFKHQIHVW]XKDOWHQª6HOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFK©EHVWlWLJWHU ª1DWUOLFKEHUQHKPHLFKGLH.RVWHQ6LHZHUGHQMDQLFKW JOHLFKHLQH*DQ]ODFNLHUXQJLQ$XIWUDJJHJHEHQKDEHQ© 6LHODFKWZLHGHUª:RGHQNHQ6LHKLQ,FKKDEHQXUGHQ .UDW]HUXQGGDV5FNOLFKWUHSDULHUHQODVVHQ+XQGHUWYLHU XQGDFKW]LJIQI]LJJDQ]JHQDX8QGHVLVWEHUKDXSWQLFKWV PHKU]XVHKHQ© (QGH]ZDQ]LJK|FKVWHQVGHQNW$FKLP,QVHLQHU9RU
6WHOOXQJLVWVLHEORQGKDWOXVWLJHEODXH$XJHQXQGHLQH6WXSV QDVHª)HLQ©JHKWHUDXILKUHQ7RQHLQª-HW]WPVVHQ6LHPLU QXUQRFKVDJHQZLHLFK,KQHQGDV*HOG]XNRPPHQODVVHQ NDQQ© ª,VWHV,KQHQUHFKWZHQQLFKGLH5HFKQXQJVFKLFNHXQG PHLQH.RQWRQXPPHUGUDXIVFKUHLEH"© 'HWMHQJLEWGHQ+|UHUYRQHLQHU+DQGLQGLHDQGHUH ª(LJHQWOLFKQLFKW©HUZLGHUWHUª$POLHEVWHQZUGHLFK,KQHQ GDV*HOGSHUV|QOLFKJHEHQJOHLFK,FKNDQQLQHLQHUKDOEHQ 6WXQGHLQ.|OQVHLQXQGGDQQKDEHQZLUHVKLQWHUXQV2ELFK PRUJHQ]XU%DQNNRPPHLFKKDEHHLQHQYROOHQ7HU PLQNDOHQGHUZHLLFKQLFKW8QG]XP6FKOXGHQNHQ6LH QRFKLFKZROOWHPLFKGUFNHQ:RNDQQLFK6LHHUUHLFKHQ"© :DKUVFKHLQOLFKLVWVLHVHKUEHUUDVFKW'LHDQJHQHKPH MXQJH6WLPPHDPDQGHUHQ(QGHVFKZHLJW$OWHU-XQJHGDELVW GX]XZHLWJHJDQJHQGHQNW$FKLP0XWGXVLHJOHLFKVHKHQ ZROOHQEORZHLOGLUGLH6WLPPHJHIlOOW"%O|G8QGZDV NRPPWGDEHLKHUDXV"6LHQHQQWHLQH$GUHVVH:HQQGXDQ NRPPVWPDFKWLKU0DQQDXIXQGLP+LQWHUJUXQGVWHKHQGUHL .LQGHUXQGZROOHQGHQE|VHQ2QNHOVHKHQGHUGHQ=ZHLW ZDJHQGHU)DPLOLHGHPROLHUWKDW6FK|QGXPP'LHJDQ]H 6DFKHZLUG]ZHL0LQXWHQGDXHUQ $EHUGLH6WLPPHVDJWEHUUDVFKHQGHUZHLVHPLWEHWRQWHU 6HOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKNHLWª,QHLQHU6WXQGHLP&DIHJHJHQEHU GHU'RPEDXKWWH*LQJHGDV"© ª*HKW©EHVWlWLJWHUª,FKIUHXHPLFKJQlGLJH)UDXLFKELQ DOVRLQHLQHU6WXQGHGD© ©8QGZLHHUNHQQHLFK6LH"© (UVLHKWGXUFKGLHRIIHQH7U]XU)OXUJDUGHUREHª,FKELQ EHLGHU/XIWZDIIHEODXH8QLIRUPJHOEH6SLHJHO.DQQPDQ JDUQLFKWYHUZHFKVHOQ8QGVRIHUQ]ZHL)OLHJHUGRUWVLQGLFK ELQGHUPLWGHP2EHUOLSSHQEDUW© 'DLVWZLHGHULKU/DFKHQHLQELFKHQNRNHWWHUDOVYRUKLQ ª*XW+HUU'HWMHQ%LVGDQQDOVR© ª%LVGDQQ©$OVGHUª.lIHU©LKQQDFK.|OQEULQJWEHUHXW HUVHLQH,QLWLDWLYHEHUHLWV0XHUVRZDVYHUDQVWDOWHQVRLQV
%ODXHKLQHLQXQGDXIVHLQHDOWHQ7DJH"hEHUGLH-DKUHLVWPDQ GRFKHLJHQWOLFKKLQDXVXQGQXQOLHJHQVLFK8QWHUQHKPXQJV JHLVWXQG%HTXHPOLFKNHLWLQGHQ+DDUHQ:lUHLKPPHKU=HLW JHEOLHEHQGDQQKlWWHGLH%HTXHPOLFKNHLWREVLHJW$EHUQXQ KDWHUVLFKGLH6XSSHHLQJHUKUWQXQZLUGHUVLHDXVO|IIHOQ %HVRQGHUVDXIZHQGLJH%H]DKOXQJHLQHU5HFKQXQJPHKUZLUG QLFKWVHLQ (VLVWHLQVWLOOHV&DIHKDOEOHHUXPGLHVH=HLW(LQH'DPHQ UXQGHGLHWURW]YRUJHUFNWHU6WXQGH8QPHQJHQ.XFKHQ YHU]HKUWXQGYRQ=HLW]X=HLWODXWDXIMXFK]WHLQSDDUlOWHUH /HXWHGLHDXVGHU(LQVDPNHLWLKUHUYLHU:lQGHKLHUKHUJH IORKHQVLQGHLQLJHMXQJH3DDUHGLHVLFKYLHO]XHU]lKOHQKDEHQ PHKUHUHHLQVDPH=HLWXQJVOHVHU(VLVWHLQ:LHQHU&DIH(LQH 8QPHQJH=HLWXQJHQXQG=HLWVFKULIWHQOLHJWDXVXQGRKQH EHVRQGHUH$XIIRUGHUXQJZHFKVHOQGLH.HOOQHUGDQQXQGZDQQ GDV*ODV:DVVHUDXVGDVKLHU]XPª%UDXQHQ©JHUHLFKWZLUG 'HWMHQILQGHWDQHLQHPNOHLQHQ0DUPRUWLVFK3ODW]YRQGHP DXVHUGLH7ULP$XJHKDWEHVWHOOWHLQHQª7UNLVFKHQ©]LHKW VLFKHLQH=HLWXQJKHUDQXQGZDUWHW8PGLHVH=HLWZHFKVHOQ GLH*lVWHVHOWHQHUDOVLQGHQ0LWWDJVXQG1DFKPLWWDJVVWXQ GHQ1RFKHLQMXQJHV3DDUNRPPWXQGVHW]WVLFKDQVJHJHQ EHUOLHJHQGH(QGHGHVODQJJHVWUHFNWHQ5DXPHVJDQ]PLWVLFK VHOEVWEHVFKlIWLJWZLHHVVFKHLQWXQGGDQQEHWULWWHLQHMXQJH )UDXGDV&DIH'DVLVWGLH$QUXIHULQGHQQVLHVWHXHUWVRIRUW DXIGHQHLQ]LJHQ8QLIRUPLHUWHQLP5DXP]X$FKLPVWHKWDXI JHKWLKU]ZHLGUHL6FKULWWHHQWJHJHQOlFKHOW1HLQEORQGLVW VLHQLFKWVLHKDWGXQNOHVNDVWDQLHQEUDXQHV+DDUXQGLKUH $XJHQVLQGGXQNHOVWDWWEODX6LHWUlJWHLQHQ6WDXEPDQWHOGHU YRPJOHLFKHQ*UQLVWZLHGHU/DFNLKUHVNOHLQHQ:DJHQV ª)UDX+HUGHJHQ"©IUDJWHUª,FKELQGHU8QJOFNVUDEH 'HWMHQ*XWHQ$EHQG© )UHLQHQ$XJHQEOLFNOLHJWLKUH+DQGLQGHUVHLQHQVFKPDO XQGNKOª*XWHQ$EHQG+HUU'HWMHQ,VROGH+HUGHJHQ$EHU 6LHKlWWHQVLFKZLUNOLFKQLFKWVHOEVWEHPKHQPVVHQ© $FKLPKLOIWLKUDXVGHP0DQWHOHLQHQlUPHOORVHQZHLHQ 6RPPHUSXOORYHUXQGHLQHQVFKZDU]HQ5RFNKDWVLHGDUXQ
WHUUFNWLKUHLQHQ6WXKO]XUHFKWXQGZLQNWGHP.HOOQHU,KQ EHUKUWHVV\PSDWKLVFKGD,VROGH+HUGHJHQZLGHUHLJHQHV :ROOHQEHIDQJHQZLUNW*HZLOLHJWGDVDQVHLQHQJUDXHQ 6FKOlIHQHEHQVRZLHDQGHU8QLIRUP6LFKHUOLFKKDWVLHHLQHQ )HOGZHEHOHUZDUWHWRGHUHLQHQMXQJHQ/HXWQDQWEHVWLPPW DEHUQLFKWHLQHQZHQQDXFKIULVFKJHEDFNHQHQ2EHUVWOHXW QDQWLQMHQHQ-DKUHQGLHPDQªGLHEHVWHQ©QHQQWZHLOGLH ZLUNOLFKJXWHQVFKRQYRUEHUVLQG,KU$OWHULVWVFKZHU]X VFKlW]HQGRFKGUHLLJLVWVLHQRFKQLFKW6LHVLHKWVHKUMXQJ DXVVFKODQNXQGKRFKEHLQLJZLHVLHLVWPLWLKUHPVFKPDOHQ NODUHQ*HVLFKWXQGGHPODFKOXVWLJHQZHLFKJH]HLFKQHWHQ 0XQG.HLQH6WXSVQDVH8QGKHUUOLFKXQYHUEUDXFKWVLHKWVLH DXV'LHVDOOHVVWHOOW'HWMHQIHVWXQGLVWVLFKQLFKWPHKUVR VLFKHUGDQDFK%H]DKOXQJGHU5HFKQXQJDOOHVYRUEHUVHLQ ZLUG,VROGH+HUGHJHQV(LQYHUVWlQGQLVYRUDXVJHVHW]W 'LH5HFKQXQJNRPPWDXIGHQ7LVFKXQGGDEOHLEWVLHDXFK IUVHUVWH,VROGHGUlQJWQLFKWVLHKDW=HLWPLWJHEUDFKW'DV ZHUWHW$FKLPVFKRQDOVJXWHV=HLFKHQ6LHLVWDOVRQHXJLHULJ JHQDXVRZLHHU 1DFKHLQHUKDOEHQ6WXQGHZHLHU]LHPOLFKYLHOYRQLKUXQG GDEHLKDWVLHQLFKWGDV*HIKO]LHOVWUHELJXQGJHNRQQWDXV JHIRUVFKWZRUGHQ]XVHLQ6LHLVWVLHEHQXQG]ZDQ]LJ-DKUHDOW XQYHUKHLUDWHWXQGWHFKQLVFKH=HLFKQHULQGHU]HLWGDPLWEH VFKlIWLJWDXIGHPVRJHQDQQWHQ]ZHLWHQ%LOGXQJVZHJ,QJH QLHXU]XZHUGHQ'DVNRVWHWQDWUOLFKYLHO=HLWXQG.UDIWXQG OlWZHQLJ5DXPIUDQGHUHVXQGGDV+HLUDWHQOlXIWMDQLFKW ZHJ6LHLVWVLFKGDUEHUNODUGDGLH&KDQFHQIUZHLEOLFKH ,QJHQLHXUHVRJXWQLFKWVLQGGLHPHLVWHQ)LUPHQEHODVWHQVLFK XQJHUQPLW0LWDUEHLWHULQQHQGLHLQOHLWHQGHQ6WHOOHQLPPHU $XWRULWlWVVFKZLHULJNHLWHQKDEHQXQGLUJHQGZDQQLPPHU]XU XQJHOHJHQVWHQ=HLW.LQGHUEHNRPPHQDEHUGDV/HUQHQ PDFKWLKU6SD-DXQGVLHDUEHLWHWKLHULQ.|OQEHLP(OHN WURQLN*HUlWHXQG$QODJHQEDX6LHIlKUWOHLGHQVFKDIWOLFKJHUQ $XWRXQGKDWPLWGHPNOHLQHQ)LDWYLHOH(QWGHFNXQJVUHLVH GXUFKGLHVNDQGLQDYLVFKHQ/lQGHUQXQWHUQRPPHQ6LHNDQQ XQEHIDQJHQXQGOHEKDIWGDYRQHU]lKOHQQDFKGHPVLHGLH
HUVWHQ+HPPXQJHQEHUZXQGHQKDW6HOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKLVWVLH PHLVWQLFKWDOOHLQJHIDKUHQDEHUWLHIHUH%LQGXQJHQVLQGQLFKW HQWVWDQGHQHVO|VWHVLFKDOOHVZLHGHUDXIXQGZDUGHQQZRKO QLFKWGDV5LFKWLJH $FKLP'HWMHQLVWHUVWDXQWEHULKUHIUHLPWLJH2IIHQKHLW 6LHKDWGDV6HOEVWYHUWUDXHQYRQMXQJHQ)UDXHQGLHJHZRKQW VLQGDXIGHQHLJHQHQ)HQ]XVWHKHQXQGHLJHQH(QWVFKHL GXQJHQ]XIlOOHQ'DVKDWVLH]ZDUQLFKWUHFKWKDEHULVFKJH PDFKWVLHLVWVLFKDEHULKUHU3HUV|QOLFKNHLWEHZXW'RFKVLH JHIlOOWLKPVHKUXQGHUVFKLHEWGHQ*HGDQNHQZHLWYRQVLFK GDVLHLKPVHLQHUJUDXHQ6FKOlIHQZHJHQYHUWUDXWXQGLKP EHVWHQIDOOVHLQH$UWª9DWHUUROOH©]XELOOLJHQN|QQWH ,VROGHKDWQLFKWVGDJHJHQGDV/RNDO]XZHFKVHOQXQGPLW $FKLPHVVHQ]XJHKHQ'DHUGLH.|OQHU*HJHEHQKHLWHQQLFKW VRNHQQWHPSILHKOWVLHGHQª:DOILVFK©XQGLQGLHVHPJH PWOLFKHQ:HLQUHVWDXUDQWLQGHU6DO]JDVVHªHVLVWDXFKJDU QLFKWVRWHXHUGD©KDWVLHJHVDJWVLW]HQVLHQRFKODQJH'HWMHQ NDQQQLFKWXPKLQHLQELFKHQDXFKYRQVLFK]XHU]lKOHQGDV HUZDUWHWVLHHLQIDFK:LHODXWHWGHU:HUEHVORJDQGHU9HU VLFKHUXQJVJHVHOOVFKDIWPLWGHUHQ'HWHNWLYDXVZHLVLQGHU 7DVFKHHUGDPDOVQDFK3RUWXJDOUHLVWHXPGDV*HKHLPQLVGHU 0DVNHQDXI]XNOlUHQ"ª9HUWUDXHQJHJHQ9HUWUDXHQ©(UNDQQ QLFKWQXU]XK|UHQRKQHVLHYRUGHQ.RSI]XVWRHQVRQGHUQ HU]lKOWDXFKYRQVLFK(UP|FKWHVLHJHUQZLHGHUVHKHQ$OVR EHULFKWHWHHUYRQMHQHP$FKLP'HWMHQLQGHVVHQ+DXWHUQXQ VFKRQVHLW-DKUHQVWHFNWXQGGHUDXV+DPEXUJVWDPPWHDXV GHU*U|QLQJHU6WUDHYLHU(LQHLQJHSDXNWHU/HEHQVODXIPLW HLQJHSDXNWHQ'DWHQ(UKlOWLKQVRNXU]ZLHP|JOLFKILQGHWHV EHUXKLJHQGGD,VROGHGLH)UHLH+DQVHVWDGWQLFKWNHQQWXQG VLFKHEHQVRZHQLJ]XGLHVHP6WDGWVWDDWGHU%XQGHVUHSXEOLN KLQJH]RJHQIKOW$XIHLQHVHKUIUDXOLFKH:HLVHQLPPWVLH MHGRFK$QWHLODP6FKLFNVDOGHV)OLHJHUV'HWMHQXQGIUDJWGLHV XQGGDVHUVWUHFKWQDFKGHPHLQEHIOLVVHQHU.HOOQHULKQ VDFKNXQGLJPLWª+HUU2EHUVWOHXWQDQW©DQJHUHGHWKDW0XHU QLFKWHLQH0HQJHHUOHEWYLHOJHVHKHQXQGPDQFKH*HIDKU EHVWDQGHQKDEHQ"8QGEHLDOOHGHPPHKU*OFNJHKDEWKDEHQ
DOVLKQ9DWHUGHUQRFKLQGHQOHW]WHQ.ULHJVWDJHQLQGHU 6FKODFKWXP%HUOLQILHO"$XIHLQHP6ROGDWHQIULHGKRILQ+DOEH VHLHUEHJUDEHQVDJWVLH 6HKUVSU|GHHUZLGHUWHUMDHUKDEH*OFNJHKDEWXQGVHL QDFKHLQHP$EVFKXLQ5XODQG0DLKDOEZHJV LQWDNWLQ*HIDQJHQVFKDIWJHUDWHQ(UPHUNWJOHLFKGDVLH VHLQH=XUFNKDOWXQJLQGLHVHP=XVDPPHQKDQJEHVRQGHUV EHHLQGUXFNWORJLVFKHUZHLVHGHXWHWVLHVLHIDOVFKDOVEHVFKHL GHQHV+HUXQWHUVSLHOHQXQGJHQDXGDVKDWHUQLFKWEH DEVLFKWLJW)UHLOLFKNDPHUDXFKLQGHU9HUJDQJHQKHLWQLFKW XPKLQJHOHJHQWOLFK'HWDLOVªVHLQHV©/HEHQVSUHL]XJHEHQ QLHJODXEWHUKDWHUGDVVRXQJHUQXQGZLGHUZLOOLJJHWDQZLH KHXWH6RVFKOLHWHUHWZDVJHZDOWVDPXQGEXUVFKLNRVPLWGHU LURQLVFKHQ%HPHUNXQJGDV/HEHQKDEHLKQZRKOHLQELFKHQ DXVGHU%DKQJHZRUIHQXQGHUKDEHGHQ$QVFKOXYHUSDW VRVHKUGDHUQXQKLHUDOVDOWHU-XQJJHVHOOHKHUXPVLW]HXQG VHLQH=HLWGDPLWYHUEULQJHEH]DXEHUQGHMXQJH)UDXHQ]X ODQJZHLOHQ ª1HLQ©VDJWVLHOHLVHXQGVHKUHQGJOWLJª:ROOHQZLU WDQW]HQ"© ª6HKUJHUQ© ,P1HEHQUDXPVSLHOWHLQ7ULROHLVH%DUPXVLNRKQH0LNUR IRQXQG9HUVWlUNHUDXIHLQHDQJHQHKPHXQDXIGULQJOLFKH$UW $FKLPIKUW,VROGHDP$UPKLQEHUDXIGLH7DQ]IOlFKH6LH JHKWJDQ]ORFNHUQHEHQLKPPLWHLQHUYHUEOIIHQGHQ6HOEVW YHUVWlQGOLFKNHLW(EHQVRVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKOHKQWVLHVLFK VDQIWDQLKQDOVVLHWDQ]HQ,Pª:DOILVFK©LVW5RFNQ 5ROO QLFKWJHIUDJWGDV7ULREHYRU]XJWODQJVDPH:DO]HU7DQJRXQG 6WRZIR[(LJHQWOLFKHUVWDXQOLFKZLHYLHOHMXQJH/HXWHVFKRQ ZLHGHUGDUDQ*HIDOOHQILQGHQ 1XQLVWHVGRFKHLQZXQGHUVFK|QHU$EHQGJHZRUGHQ$OV KDEHHU)XUFKWLKQ]X]HUVW|UHQYHUPHLGHW'HWMHQDOOHVZDV DXIGULQJOLFKZLUNHQN|QQWH(UIKUW,VROGHEHKXWVDPOHLFKW XQGORFNHUEHUKUWVHLQH+DQGLKUH6FKXOWHUEOlWWHU6LHUHGHQ QLFKWVDEHUZHQQVLFKLKUH%OLFNHEHJHJQHQOlFKHOQVLHVLFK ]X
ª6FKDGH©VDJW,VROGHOHLVHDOVGHUOHW]WH7DQJRYHU NOXQJHQLVW (UOlWHLQ7D[LUXIHQIlKUWVLH]XLKUHU:RKQXQJLQHLQHU GHU1HXEDXWHQDP6WDGWUDQGOlWGDV7D[LZDUWHQXQGEH JOHLWHWVLHELV]XU+DXVWUª,FKPX6LHZLHGHUVHKHQ©VDJW HUHLQIDFKª8QGGLH5HFKQXQJLVWDXFKQRFKQLFKWEH]DKOW© 6LHODFKW'LHVHV/DFKHQKDWLKPYRQ$QIDQJDQJHIDOOHQ ª8QGEORGHVZHJHQVLQG6LHGRFKQDFK.|OQJHNRPPHQ,FK EHKDOWHVLHHLQVWZHLOHQDOV3IDQG-DXQGZDQQ"© (UZHUGHVLHDQUXIHQEDOGDQWZRUWHWHUXQGGDHUVLFK GDUDXIIUHXH6LHJHEHQVLFKGLH+lQGHVLH]|JHUQEHLGH VHNXQGHQODQJVLQGEHLGHHLQELFKHQYHUOHJHQXQGGDQQVDJW VLHªJXWH1DFKW©XQGZHQGHWVLFKGHP+DXV]X$FKLPZDUWHW ELVVLHGLH7UYRQLQQHQJHVFKORVVHQKDWXQGNHKUW]XP7D[L ]XUFN'DVEULQJWLKQ]XP3DUNSODW]DXIGHPVHLQ9: ZDUWHW
ª/LFKWELWWH©UXIW:LQQLH:LQNHOPDQQª8QG$NWLRQ© ,PJUHOOHQ/LFKWGHU)RWRODPSHQEOKWGLHJHODQJZHLOWH *HVHOOVFKDIWMlKDXI*OHLFKJOWLJH*HVLFKWHUEHOHEHQVLFKXQG VWUDKOHQVRJDUHLQ/DFKHQLVW]XK|UHQ:HLQJOlVHUZHUGHQ JHKREHQPDQWULQNWVLFK]XXQGLP+LQWHUJUXQGWULWWGHU .IHUPLWHLQHU%DWWHULH)ODVFKHQXQWHUP$UPGXUFKGLH QLHGULJH7ULQV*HZ|OEHHLQ ª'DQNH©VDJW:LQQLHXQGULFKWHWVLFKYRQGHU0DWWVFKHLEH GHUJURIRUPDWLJHQ.DPHUDDXIª6RJHKWHVQLFKW'DV :DSSHQPX]ZDQ]LJ=HQWLPHWHUWLHIHUVRQVWUXWVFKWHVREHQ UDXV8QGGDQQJHEHQZLUHLQHQ6SRWGDUDXI© 'LH/HXWHDP7LVFKEH]DKOWH)RWRPRGHOOHIDOOHQEXFK VWlEOLFKLQVLFK]XVDPPHQKlQJHQGXUFKVLQGHQWVSDQQW'DV :DUWHQLVWLKUKDOEHV/HEHQVLHKDEHQhEXQJGDULQ1LHPDQG YHUOlWVHLQHQ3ODW]'LV]LSOLQLVWDOOHVLQGLHVHP*HZHUEH(V
JHK|UWDXFKGD]XQLFKWXQJHGXOGLJ]XZHUGHQXQGDXI .RPPDQGRHLQHJHZQVFKWH6WLPPXQJVRRIWUHSURGX]LHUHQ ]XN|QQHQZLHVLHYHUODQJWZLUG'DV7LHIHUKlQJHQGHV :DSSHQVGHU:HLQEDXJHQRVVHQVFKDIWHLJHQWOLFKLVWHVPHKU HLQ0DUNHQ]HLFKHQNPPHUWVLHQLFKWGDIUZHUGHQVLH QLFKWKRQRULHUW :lKUHQG/HLWHUQDXIJHVWHOOWXQGGLH+DOWHVHLOHGHV:DS SHQVYHUOlQJHUWZHUGHQXQGGLHIUGLHVHQ7DJDQJHPLHWHWHQ %HOHXFKWHUHLQHU$WHOLHUEHWULHEVJHVHOOVFKDIWLKUH/DPSHQQHX HLQULFKWHQVSULFKWGLH)RWRJUDILQPLWGHP.IHU(UVROOH ZHQLJHU)ODVFKHQQHKPHQVDJWVLHXQGDOOHPLWGHPJOHLFKHQ (WLNHWWGDPLWHVLQV$XJHVSULQJH 'HU.IHUEOLFNWIUDJHQG]XP9HUNDXIVPDQDJHUGHU*H QRVVHQVFKDIW(ULVWYHUDQWZRUWOLFKIUGLH:HUEHDNWLRQPLW GHUGLH:LQ]HUGHVNOHLQVWHQ:HLQEDXJHELHWVGHU%XQGHV UHSXEOLNQHXH$EVDW]PlUNWH]XHUVFKOLHHQKRIIHQ(VZlUH GRFKHLQ-DPPHUZHQQPDQDXVVHLQHQKRFKZHUWLJHQ4XDOL WlWVXQG3UlGLNDWVZHLQHQQLFKWPHKUKHUDXVVFKODJHQN|QQWH DOVELVKHU ª6WUDWDPRQWDQD©EHVWLPPWGHU0DQDJHUXQGQLFNWGHP .IHU]X:LQQLHHUNOlUWHUª'LHVHU5LHVOLQJLVWXQVHU3DUD GHSIHUG'HVKDOEKDEHQZLULKPHLQHQQHXHQDWWUDNWLYHQ 1DPHQJHJHEHQ8QGGDZLUDQGHU%HUJVWUDHOHEHQ6WUDWD PRQWDQD!0HLQH,GHH:LHILQGHQ6LHGLH"© ª*URDUWLJZLUNOLFKJURDUWLJ©HUZLGHUWVLHLP%UXVWWRQ GHUhEHU]HXJXQJ'DVJHK|UWVLFKHLQIDFK6FKOLHOLFKKDW GLHVHU0DQQDXVGHUJURHQ$Q]DKOGHU:HUEHIRWRJUDIHQ JHUDGHVLHDXVJHVXFKWGLHKRFKEH]DKOWHQ%LOGHUIUVHLQHQ EXQWHQ3URVSHNWDQ]XIHUWLJHQGDPXPDQLKPVFKRQHLQ ELFKHQQDFKGHP0XQGHUHGHQª8QGDXIGLH)QIKXQGHUWHU OLQNVHLQHQ7OO© ª/LQNV7OORND\©ZLHGHUKROWGHU(UVWH%HOHXFKWHU URXWLQLHUWXQGVHW]WVFKRQGHQEHVSDQQWHQ5DKPHQYRUGHU GDV/LFKWZHLFKHUPDFKW :LQQLHKDQWLHUWPLWGHP&G6%HOLFKWXQJVPHVVHU 'HU0DQDJHUKlOWVLFKQHEHQLKUª,FKKDEHGHQODWHLQLVFKHQ
1DPHQJHZlKOWXQGDXIGDV(WLNHWWHLQHQ5|PHUZDJHQ]HLFK QHQODVVHQZHLOQDFKZHLVOLFKVFKRQGLH)HOGKHUUHQGHU/H JLRQHQGLHHLQVWSHUSDJRVJHUPDQRUXP]RJHQ:HLQHYRQGHU %HUJVWUDHDOVN|VWOLFKH%HXWHKHLPDQGHQ7LEHUEUDFKWHQ© HU]lKOWHUVHOEVWJHIlOOLJ :LQQLHVWHOOWGLH%OHQGHHLQXQGYHUWDXVFKWGLH0DWWVFKHLEH JHJHQGLH)LOPSDFNNDVVHWWHª6FKDGH©VDJWVLHQHEHQEHLªGD PDQGDVQLFKWPHKUIRWRJUDILHUHQNDQQHLQHQGDKLQUDVHQGHQ .DPSIZDJHQLQGHPGHU)HOGKHUUPLWIODWWHUQGHP0DQWHO VWHKWXQGHLQH)ODVFKH6WUDWDPRQWDQD!DQGLH/LSSHQVHW]W© 'LH%HPHUNXQJlUJHUWVLHJOHLFKGHU0DQQPXVLFKGRFKDXI GHQ$UPJHQRPPHQIKOHQ $EHUGHU0DQDJHUNODWVFKWYRU%HJHLVWHUXQJLQGLH+lQGH ª:DUXPHLJHQWOLFKQLFKW"©IUDJWHU]XUFNª'HUJH]LHOWH $QDFKURQLVPXVLVWLQGHU:HUEXQJGXUFKDXVOHJLWLP,P 9RUGHUJUXQGHLQRIIHQHUVXSHUPRGHUQHU6SRUWZDJHQYROO GLHVHUKEVFKHQ&RYHUJLUOVGDGHUYRQGHU4XDGULJDEHUKROW ZLUG:DVEHIOJHOWGHQDOWHQ5|PHUVR"© ª6WUDWDPRQWDQD©VDJHQVLHEHLGHZLHDXVHLQHQ0XQGH ª$FKWXQJ©UXIW:LQQLHGDQQª,P$WHOLHUKHUUVFKW5XKH MHGHUVWHKWDXIVHLQHP3ODW]8QG$NWLRQ© :LHDXVGHP%RGHQJHVWDPSIWLVWGLHIU|KOLFKH:HLQ VWLPPXQJZLHGHUGDXQGVFKlXPWEHUELVQDFKGHP6XPPHQ GHV.DPHUDYHUVFKOXVVHVªDXV©JHUXIHQZLUG6LHHUOLVFKW DXJHQEOLFNOLFKXQGOHEWVRRIWZLHGHUDXIZLHGLH)RWRJUDILQ GLH$XIQDKPHZLHGHUKROW ª,FKUXIH6LHDQVREDOGLFKDOOHV]XVDPPHQKDEH©YHU VSULFKWGHU0DQDJHUHLQEHZHJOLFKHU0DQQ0LWWH'UHLLJLP EODWWJUQHQ0DDQ]XJXQGPLWHLQHUURVLQHQIDUEHQHQ.UD ZDWWHDXIGHUHLQH:HLQUHEHDEJHELOGHWLVWª(LQHEOHQGHQGH ,GHHOLHEH)UDX:LQNHOPDQQGLHN|QQWHYRQPLUVHLQ© 6LHKDWQRFKHLQHJDQ]H0HQJH]XIRWRJUDILHUHQIUGLHVHQ 3URVSHNWDEHUDOVVLH]X+DXVHLQ)UDQNIXUWLVWOHJWVLHGLH .DPHUDHUVWHLQPDOZHLWZHJ-HW]WQRFKPLW'HWDLODXIQDKPHQ DQ]XIDQJHQPLW6WLOOHEHQYRQ)ODVFKHQXQGEHVRQGHUVVFK|
QHQ*OlVHUQLQGHQHQGHU:HLQJHKHLPQLVYROOYHUORFNHQGHQ *ODQ]KDWXQGGHP%HWUDFKWHUGDV:DVVHULP0XQGH]XVDP PHQODXIHQOlWGD]XKDWVLHQXQZHGHU/XVWQRFK1HUYHQ'HU 7DJZDUDQVWUHQJHQGWURW]JXWHU2UJDQLVDWLRQGXUFKGHQ $XIWUDJJHEHUXQGLPPHUVSLHOWDXFKPLWGDLKUH7lWLJNHLW DOV:HUEHIRWRJUDILQQXUHLQH6HLWHGHU$UEHLWGDUVWHOOW6LHLVW LKUH/HJLWLPDWLRQLKUJXWEUJHUOLFKHV$XVKlQJHVFKLOGLQGHU +DQGHOVPHWURSROHDP0DLQPHKUQLFKW'LHVHVª$XV KlQJHVFKLOG©VWLPPLJXQGXQDQWDVWEDU]XKDOWHQNRVWHWDXHU IRWRJUDILVFKHP.|QQHQGLHJHGLHJHQH$XVELOGXQJDXIHLQHU UHQRPPLHUWHQ)DFKVFKXOHLQ'RUWPXQGKDWLKUHLQHVROLGH *UXQGODJHPLWDXIGHQ:HJJHJHEHQDXFKVHKUYLHO=HLW .UDIWXQG(QHUJLH'LH6WHXHUHUNOlUXQJPXVRDXVIDOOHQGD VLHQLHPDQGHQVWXW]LJPDFKWPXLP(LQNODQJVHLQPLWGHQ 0|JOLFKNHLWHQXQGGHP/HEHQVVWDQGDUGHLQHUDOOHLQDUEHLWHQ GHQ:HUEHIRWRJUDILQ:HGHUGLH6WHXHUIDKQGXQJGDUIHLQ +DDULQLKUHU6XSSHILQGHQQRFKGDUIGHU9HUIDVVXQJVVFKXW] DXIPHUNVDPZHUGHQZHQQZLHHVGXUFKDXVYRUNRPPHQ NDQQHLQ.XQGHEHLLKPUFNIUDJWREDQGHU,QWHJULWlWGHULQV $XJHJHIDWHQ'DPHDXFKMDNHLQ=ZHLIHOEHVWHKH%HLLKU VWLPPWDOOHVGDUDXIDFKWHWVLHPLWHLVHUQHU'LV]LSOLQ8P JHQJHQG6SLHOUDXPIULKUH.XQGVFKDIWHUDUEHLW]XEHKDOWHQ XQGGDPLWDXFK]XU$QOHLWXQJXQG8QWHUVWW]XQJ:HUQHU %UHGHEXVFKVKDWVLHVLFKLQGHU%UDQFKHGHQ5XIDXIJHEDXW HLQHEHVFKHLGHQH.ROOHJLQ]XVHLQGLHVLFKGHQ/X[XVOHLVWHW QXU$XIWUlJH]XEHUQHKPHQGLHLKUZLUNOLFK6SDPDFKHQ XQGLQGLHVLHGDQQYLHO/LHEH=HLWXQG6RUJIDOWLQYHVWLHUW .HLQHGUlQJHQGHQ7HUPLQHNHLQH+DXUXFN(LQVlW]H'D VLHJHUDGHGHVZHJHQLQ]XQHKPHQGHP0DH$QJHERWHHUKlOW LVWGLH.HKUVHLWHGHU0HGDLOOH 6LHHUIULVFKWVLFKXQWHUGHU'XVFKHKROWVLFKHLQHQ6DIWDXV GHP.KOVFKUDQNHU]lKOWDP7HOHIRQGHP0DQQPLWGHPVLH VHLW-DKUHQLQWLPEHIUHXQGHWLVWXQGGHUQLFKWVYRQGHUJH IDKUYROOHQ6HLWHLKUHV/HEHQVZHLYRQGHU$UEHLWDXIGHU %HUJVWUDHXQGGDVLHHLQHDQVWlQGLJH:HLQSUREHPLW JHEUDFKWKDEHOHJWGLH%HLQHKRFKXQGOLHVW=HLWXQJ/RNDO
QDFKULFKWHQXQGVHOEVWGLH$Q]HLJHQELHWHQPDQFKPDO+LQ ZHLVHXQG$QUHJXQJHQGHQHQHVQDFK]XJHKHQORKQW (UVWDOVVLH]XPGULWWHQPDODXIGLHVHOEH$Q]HLJHVW|W VWXW]WVLHª=XU$XVVWDWWXQJHLQHU:DOGJDVWVWlWWHVXFKHQZLU DOWH-DJGJHUlWHVRZLH6WLFKHXQGgOELOGHUGLHGHQ&KDUDNWHU XQVHUHU:LOGEUHWJDVWVWlWWHXQWHUVWUHLFKHQ=XVFKULIWHQHUELW WHQZLUP|JOLFKVWXQWHU%HLIJXQJYRQ)RWRVJDUDQWLHUW ]XUFNDQGLH$QQRQFHQH[SHGLWLRQ$GRPHLW)UDQN IXUW0DLQ .URQHQJDVVH.HQQZRUW+DODOL!© .HLQHVHKUDXIIlOOLJH$Q]HLJH(LQVSDOWLJQXUGXUFKHLQH GQQH5DQGOLQLHKHUYRUJHKREHQ(LQHYRQYLHOHQ(LQPDOLQ GHQDP$XIQDKPHRUWJHNDXIWHQª+HSSHQKHLPHU1DFKULFK WHQ©HLQPDOLPª:LHVEDGHQHU(FKR©XQGHLQPDOLQGHU ª)UDQNIXUWHU1HXHQ3UHVVH©$Q]XQHKPHQGDVLHDXFKQRFK LQDQGHUHQ/RNDO]HLWXQJHQHUVFKLHQHQLVW :LQQLHJlKQWXQG]QGHWVLFKHLQH=LJDUHWWHDQ(LQH :DOGJDVWVWlWWHKPHLQELFKHQYLHO$XIZDQGGDIU'LH ZROOHQGRFKNHLQ0XVHXPHLQULFKWHQ:DVVLHEUDXFKHQ KlWWHQVLHDXIGHP)ORKPDUNWVFKQHOOHUXQGELOOLJHUEHNRPPHQ N|QQHQ:HVHQWOLFKELOOLJHU$OOHLQZDVGLH$Q]HLJHQNR VWHQ'DVWLPPWZDVQLFKW :GEUHWJDVWVWlWWHNHLQHJHOlXILJH:RUWELOGXQJ:HUVDJW GHQQQRFKª:LOGEUHW©"'DV-DJGVWLO5HVWDXUDQWª6DQNW+X EHUWXV©LQGHU*DUWHQVWUDHPDFKW5HNODPHIUVHLQH:LOG *ULOOJHULFKWH6FKQHFNHQ6FKU|GHUDQGHU%DEHQKlXVHU /DQGVWUDHIU:LOGVSH]LDOLWlWHQ$EHU:LOGEUHW"2GHUVWHFNW HLQ$QWLTXLWlWHQKlQGOHUDXI'XPPHQIDQJGDKLQWHUGHUGDUDXI DXVJHKWYHUVWDXEWH)DPLOLHQHUEVWFNHDQ/DQG]X]LHKHQYRQ GHUHQ:HUWGLH%HVLW]HUNHLQH$KQXQJKDEHQ"'DVZlUH GXUFKDXVP|JOLFK 0GHXQGXQNRQ]HQWULHUWZLHVLHLVWVSLQQW:LQQLHGHQ )DGHQZHLWHU$OWH-DJGJHUlWHVRZLH6WLFKHXQGgOELOGHUGLH GHQ&KDUDNWHUHLQHU:LOGEUHWJDVWVWlWWHXQWHUVWUHLFKHQ2EGDV DXFKGHU0DQQOLHVWGHU%ULQNPDQQV+WWHDXVJHUlXPWKDW" *HZLWXWHU V:lUHHUNHLQDXIPHUNVDPHU=HLWXQJVOHVHUVR KlWWHHUQLFKWVYRQGHPOHHUVWHKHQGHQ-DJGKDXVZLVVHQ
N|QQHQ8QGKLHUZLUGLKPHLQHJHUDGH]XLGHDOH*HOHJHQKHLW JHERWHQVHLQH%HXWHDQGHQ0DQQ]XEULQJHQDXV3ULYDWKDQG LQ3ULYDWKDQG8QGHUPXVHLQH:DUHQLFKWHLQPDODQELHWHQ VLHZLUGMDJHVXFKW(UNDQQVLFKXQWHUHLQHPEHOLHELJHQ 1DPHQPHOGHQSRVWODJHUQG$QWZRUWHUELWWHQXQGJHJHQ %DUJHOGYHUNDXIHQ8QGVHLQ$QJHERWZLUGHLQHVXQWHUDQGH UHQXQGJDUQLFKWDXIIlOOLJVHLQ 1DWUOLFKGHQNWVLHMHW]WDQGHQª:LOGEUHWKlQGOHU©YRQ 6Q\GHUV-DXQGZHQQGHUGHQYHUPXWHWHQ:HJJHKWGUIWH JDUQLFKWPHKUDQGDV%LOGKHUDQ]XNRPPHQVHLQ:HUZHL LQZHOFKHUJXWHQ6WXEHGDVª7UDQVSRUWPLWWHO©YRQ%ULQNPDQQV *HKHLPQLVGDQQXQEHDFKWHWYRUVLFKKLQJLOEW ª'DV©VDJWGLH)RWRJUDILQOHLVHªLVWQLFKWLP6LQQHGHV (UILQGHUV© (LQ/RWWHULHVSLHOXQGGLH&KDQFHGHQ+DXSWJHZLQQ]X ]LHKHQLVWHLQV]XHLQHU0LOOLRQRSWLPLVWLVFKEHWUDFKWHW$EHU HVN|QQWHHLQH&KDQFHVHLQHLQHJDQ]YDJH8QGª'HU:LOG EUHWKlQGOHU©LVWZLFKWLJ6LHPXHWZDVXQWHUQHKPHQ0RU JHQKHXWHLVWHV]XVSlW ª'XVSLQQVW©HUNOlUWDQGLHVHP$EHQGLQGHUOHHUHQGHU DEULUHLIHQ)DEULN$ORLV0HQ]HOVHLQHP6SH]L)UDQ]PLWUX KLJHU*HODVVHQKHLW'DEHLVFKQHLGHWHUPXQGOLFKH.HUEHQLQ VHLQ)ULLKVWFNVEURWXPHVVRKlSSFKHQZHLVHEHTXHPHU YHU]HKUHQ]XN|QQHQ'D]XWULQNWHU7HHDXVGHU7KHUPRV IODVFKHXQGELHWHWDXFK)UDQ]HLQHQ6FKOXFNDQGRFKHUOHKQW DEª'DLKUMXQJHQ/HXWHLPPHUVRKHNWLVFKVHLQPW :DUXPVROOGDV=HXJJOHLFKZHJ"'DREHQILQGHWHVNHLQ 6FKZHLQXQGMHOlQJHUHVOLHJWGHVWRZHUWYROOHUZLUGHV 9HUODGLFKGUDXI© )UDQ]VW|KQWª(VLVW QHHLQPDOLJH*HOHJHQKHLW$ORLV:LU ZHUGHQGHQ.UHPSHOPLWHLQHP6FKODJHORVXQGLFKZLOO 0lXVHVHKHQ© ª,FKNDQQGLU QHQ+XQGHUWHUSXPSHQZHQQHVQXUGDVLVW© ª'DUXPJHKWHVQLFKW© ª(VLVW]XIUKDOOHVQRFK]XIULVFKLQGHU6DFKIDKQGXQJ
8QGGLHVHU%ULQNPDQQZDUQLFKWLUJHQGHLQHUGDUHLHQVLHVLFK DP5LHPHQ$XHUGHPPHLQ-XQJH$OOHVDXIHLQPDONRPPW VRZLHVRQLFKWLQ)UDJH'DVLVWPLU]XJHIlKUOLFK© )UDQ]]LHKWK|UEDUGLH/XIWGXUFKGLH1DVHª-HlOWHUGXELVW GHVWRNRPLVFKHUZLUVWGX© ª1XUYRUVLFKWLJHU©HUZLGHUW$ORLVNDXHQGª8QGGDVLVW HLQKLPPHOZHLWHU8QWHUVFKLHG:DVGHQNVWGXGHQQZRGX ZlUVWZHQQGHU$OWHQLFKWLPPHUKLHU"©(UEHVFKUHLEWPLW GHP=HLJHILQJHUNUHLVHQGH%HZHJXQJHQDQGHU6FKOlIHª'LH JHVLHEWH/XIW)UDQ]KDE LFKGLUHUVSDUW1LFKWGDLFKGLUZDV YRUKDOWHQZLOODEHUZHQQGXPLFKQLFKWKlWWHVW1LPPEOR PDOGLH%UHFKVWDQJH:HULVWGDJHJHQJHZHVHQ"'X© ª:HLOHVJOHLFKMHGHUVLHKW© ª1DXQG":DVPHLQVWGXZLHIHLQLFKGLH7UPLW QHP 'LHWULFKDXIJHNULHJWKlWWH"$EHUQLVFKWKlWW VWHJHVHKHQUHLQ JDUQLVFKW%OR1XKDP VHEHUDOOVR QH&RPSXWHUXQG ZDVGDHLQPDOGULQVWHFNWGDVEOHLEW)UDQ]'DGUFNWHLQHU HLQSDDUPDODXI QSDDU.Q|SSHXQGORVJHKW V'LH/LVWHYRQ DOOHQGLHVFKRQPDOLUJHQGZDQQ6SH]LDOVFKO|VVHUPLW QHP 'LHWULFKDXIJHPDFKWKDEHQ'XKDVW,FKKDEH8QGVLHZLV VHQ V(KHGXGLFKYHUVLHKVWNOLQJHOW VXQGGXNULHJVW QH )UHLIDKUWLP%XOOHQWD[L'DVLVWHV'DZLUPLW QHPSRSOLJHQ %UHFKHLVHQDUEHLWHQQHH)UDQ]IUVRWLHIJHVXQNHQKlOW XQVNHLQHU0DQPXPLWGHU=HLWJHKHQYDULDEHOVHLQYLJLODQW 'HQNDQGLH.QHLSHDQGHU(FNH,PHUVWHQ-DKUKDEHQGLH /HXWH%UDWKHQGOJHIUHVVHQZLHGLH:LOGHQ,P]ZHLWHQJLQJ GDV*HVFKlIWQRFKJXW,PGULWWHQZDUGLH%XGHSOHLWHZHLO GHQ/HXWHQGLH%UDWKHQGO]XP+DOVHKHUDXVKLQJHQ:DVKDEHQ VLHJHPDFKW"1HXP|EOLHUW.XKVFKZDQ]EHUGLH7UJH KlQJW6WHDNKRXVH!GUDQJHVFKULHEHQJH|IIQHWYRQPLWWDJV XP]Z|OIELV]ZHL8KUQDFKWVXQGGLH.QHLSHLVWZLHGHU SURSSHQYROO/lWGDVDXFKQDFKZLUGGHU%XGLNHUGLHVPDO UHFKW]HLWLJ QHQ3RUQRVFKXSSHQGUDXVPDFKHQ6H[ILOPHXQG %LHU8QGJHKWGDVZLHGHUQLFKWPHKUIlQJWHUYRQYRUQDQ +HXW]XWDJHPXWGXDXIGHP4XLYLYHVHLQZLHPDQVRVDJW ,FKKDEHHVEHJULIIHQ)UDQ]XQGZHQQGXGLFKDQPLFKKlOWVW
ZLUGGLUQLVFKWSDVVLHUHQ)DOOVGXXQEHGLQJWDXIGLH)UHVVH IDOOHQZLOOVWRKQHPLFK$EHUGDQQQXUPLW QHU6DFKHLQ GHULFKQLFKWGULQKlQJH© 'DVLVWHLQHGHUOlQJVWHQ5HGHQGLH$ORLV0HQ]HOLQOHW]WHU =HLWJHKDOWHQKDWXQGVLHYHUIHKOWLKUH:LUNXQJDXI)UDQ] QLFKW'HUVDJWHUVWHLQPDOQLFKWVXQGSDFNWVRJDUZRUWORVGLH ELOOLJH6RIRUWELOGNDPHUDHLQGLHHUPLWJHEUDFKWKDWXPGLH XQWHUGHP6WLFKZRUWª+DODOL©HUEHWHQHQ)RWRV]XPDFKHQ 'DQQVFKRQDQGHU7U IUDJWHUXQGHVNOLQJWEHLQDKH VFKFKWHUQª:DQQPHLQVWGXGHQQ"© $ORLVEUHLWHWGLH$UPHDXVLQGHUHLQHQ+DQGGHQ5HVWGHV %URWHVLQGHUDQGHUHQGDV0HVVHUª)UKHVWHQVLQYLHU:R FKHQYRUKHUVFKLHEWVLFKGDQLFKWV]XVDPPHQ8QGGDQQDXFK QXUHLQ]HOQRGHULQJDQ]NOHLQHQ3RVWHQ1LHPDOVGDVYROOH 6RUWLPHQW/DGLUGDVHLQH/HKUHIUV/HEHQVHLQ)UDQ]:LH RIWPXLFKGLUGDVQRFKVDJHQ"©
:LQQLH:LQNHOPDQQN|QQWHJHQDXYRUGHP+DXVKDOWHQ6LH WXWHVQLFKW6LHIlKUWGLH.URQHQJDVVHKLQXQWHUELHJWLQHLQH 1HEHQVWUDHHLQSDUNWXQGOlXIW]XUFN'LH$QQRQFHQH[ SHGLWLRQ$GRPHLWLVWHLQUHVSHNWDEOHV8QWHUQHKPHQGDVGDV JDQ]HIQIVW|FNLJH+DXVLQ$QVSUXFK]XQHKPHQVFKHLQWHLQ 1HXEDXDXV$OXPLQLXPXQG*ODVHLQJHIDWLQQHRNODVVL]L VWLVFKH0LHWVKlXVHUGHU*UQGHU]HLW'LH6FKDOWHUKDOOHXPIDW GDVJHVDPWH(UGJHVFKR 'LH)RWRJUDILQWULWWHLQXQGRULHQWLHUWVLFKDPªVWXPPHQ 3RUWLHU©8PGLHVHIUKH6WXQGHKHUUVFKWPlLJHU3XEOLNXPV YHUNHKUKLQWHU*ODVZlQGHQUDWWHUQOHLVHXQGPRQRWRQ)HUQ VFKUHLEHUXQHQWZHJWNOLQJHOQ7HOHIRQH,QGHU0LWWHGHU+DOOH ELOGHQLQJOHLFKPlLJHQ$EVWlQGHQVWHKHQGH7LVFKHXPGLH .XQVWOHGHUVHVVHOJUXSSLHUWVLQGHLQHJHUDGH/LQLH$Q ]HLJHQPXVWHUOLHJHQDXV3UHLVOLVWHQ*HVWDOWXQJVYRUVFKOlJH :LQQLHVHW]WVLFKHUVWHLQPDOXQGEOlWWHUW'DEHLPXVWHUWVLH GLH6]HQHULH )UGLHVRJHQDQQWHQª.OHLQDQ]HLJHQ©VLQGIQI6FKDOWHU ]XVWlQGLJ6LFKHLQHU.OHLQDQ]HLJH]XEHGLHQHQZDUEHUKDXSW
HLQSV\FKRORJLVFKJHVFKLFNWHU6FKDFK]XJ.OHLQH$Q]HLJHQ VSUHFKHQNOHLQH/HXWHDQGLHJURHQVLQGLKQHQ]XUHSUlVHQ WDWLYXQGPDKQHQ]XU9RUVLFKWYRQLKQHQIKOWPDQVLFKEH UHLWVEHUV2KUJHKDXHQZHQQPDQVLHOLHVW )QI6FKDOWHU:UGH:LQQLHV9RUKDEHQOHJLWLPVHLQ N|QQWHVLHDXIMHGHQEHOLHELJHQ]XJHKHQ$EHU]XPEOLFKHQ *HVFKlIWVJHEDUHQYRQ$QQRQFHQH[SHGLWLRQHQJHK|UWGDVLH GLH'LVNUHWLRQGHV$XIWUDJJHEHUVZDKUHQXQGNHLQH$XVNXQIW EHULKQHUWHLOHQ8QGJHUDGHHLQHVROFKHP|FKWH:LQQLH :LQNHOPDQQHLQKROHQ$QZHQZHQGHWVLHVLFK" $PHUVWHQ6FKDOWHUHLQH)UDXYRUJHVFKULWWHQHQ$OWHUV VWUHQJHU7\SXQQDKEDUXQGVLFKHUOLFKNRUUHNWELVDXIGLH .QRFKHQ1HLQ$P]ZHLWHQ6FKDOWHUHLQMXQJHV0lGFKHQ $QIDQJ]ZDQ]LJVHKUVFKLFNXQGVHKUEHGHXWVDP1HLQ'LH NDQQGHQ0XQGQLFKWKDOWHQ$PGULWWHQ6FKDOWHUHLQMXQJHU 0DQQZLHDXVGHP(LJHSHOOWHLQ'DQG\(UVSLHOWGHQª0DQQ YRQ:HOW©+P$PYLHUWHQ6FKDOWHUHLQVGOlQGLVFKHU 7\SPLWJHZHOOWHP+DDUNOHLQXQWHUVHW]WXQGEHZHJOLFK0DQ VSULFKWDQGLHVHP6FKDOWHULWDOLHQLVFKVSDQLVFKXQGIUDQ]| VLVFK1HLQ$PIQIWHQ6FKDOWHUDXFKGHU]LHOWDXIGHQ .XQGHQNUHLVGHU0LOOLRQHQ*DVWDUEHLWHUWUNLVFKVHUELVFK XQGNURDWLVFKYHUPXWOLFKHLQ6WXGHQW1HLQ :LQQLHV%OLFNNHKUW]XPGULWWHQ6FKDOWHU]XUFN'DGUIWH VLHGLHJU|WHQ&KDQFHQKDEHQ'HURIIHQNXQGLJH:LGHU VSUXFK]ZLVFKHQGHP+DQJ]XPJURHQ]XPVHQ/HEHQ XQGGHQILQDQ]LHOOHQ0|JOLFKNHLWHQGD]X6LHJHKWDXIGHQ MXQJHQ0DQQ]X 'LH9HUWUDXOLFKNHLWGHV*HVSUlFKV]ZLVFKHQ$GRPHLW 0LWDUEHLWHUQXQG.XQGHZLUGGXUFK0LOFKJODVVFKHLEHQ]ZL VFKHQGHQ6FKDOWHUQJHZlKUOHLVWHWQLHPDQGNDQQGHPDQGH UHQDXIGLH)LQJHUVHKHQ'DVNRPPWGHU$EVLFKWGHU)R WRJUDILQVHKUHQWJHJHQ ª,FKKDEHHLQJDQ]SHUV|QOLFKHV$QOLHJHQ+HUU%DFK© EHJLQQW:LQQLH:LQNHOPDQQXQGEHGLHQWVLFKGHV1DPHQVDXI GHU.DUWHLP5DKPHQGHV6FKLOGFKHQV $OOH.XQGHQKDEHQKLHUHLQJDQ]SHUV|QOLFKHV$QOLHJHQ
GHQNWGHUMXQJH0DQQXQGVHW]WHLQURXWLQLHUWHVXQGYHU WUDXHQHUZHFNHQGHV/lFKHOQDXIª:DVNDQQLFKIU6LHWXQ JQlGLJH)UDX"©8QGJHVFKlIWLJ]LHKWHUVLFKEHUHLWV%ORFNXQG .XJHOVFKUHLEHUKHUDQ ª,FKEHQ|WLJHHLQH$XVNXQIW© ª%LWWH©1DWUOLFKHUZDUWHWHUHLQH(UNXQGLJXQJQDFKGHP IUHLQHEHVWLPPWH6DFKHHUIROJYHUVSUHFKHQGVWHQ:HUEHWUl JHUGHPJQVWLJVWHQ(UVFKHLQXQJVWDJXQGGHQHQWVSUHFKHQ GHQ.RVWHQ :LQQLHOHJWGLHª)UDQNIXUWHU1HXH3UHVVH©YRULKQKLQVR JHIDOWHWGDGLHURWDQJHVWULFKHQHª+DODOL©$Q]HLJHVRIRUWLQV $XJHVSULQJW$XVGHU]XVDPPHQJHOHJWHQ=HLWXQJOXJWGH]HQW HLQEODXHU+XQGHUWPDUNVFKHLQQLFKWVHKUDXIGULQJOLFKDEHU XQEHUVHKEDU ª:HUKDWGLHVH$Q]HLJHDXIJHJHEHQ"© 6HOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFKZHLHUGDHUGLH)UDJHQLFKWEHDQW ZRUWHQGDUI(LJHQWOLFKPWHHUGDVVDJHQ6FK|EHHUHLQIDFK GLH=HLWXQJ]XUFNXQGQlKPHNHLQH1RWL]YRQGHP*HOGZlUH GDVIULKQDPHLQIDFKVWHQDEHUHU]|JHUW(UVLHKWGHQEODXHQ 5DQGXQGVFKOXFNWHUUHJW'DQQVLHKWHU:LQQLHDQGLHHOH JDQWH(UVFKHLQXQJGLHWHXUH*DUGHUREH:DKUVFKHLQOLFK EHUOHJWHUILHEHUKDIWREGDVHLQ9HUWUDXHQVWHVWGHU'LUHNWLRQ LVW1DGDQDFKVLHKWVLHZRKOQLFKWDXV8QGVLHKlOWDXFK VHLQHP%OLFNVWDQGXQGOlFKHOWDXIPXQWHUQG 'HUMXQJH0DQQ]LHKWXQEHZHJWHQ*HVLFKWVGLH=HLWXQJDQ VLFKKHUDQª(LQHQ$XJHQEOLFNJQlGLJH)UDX©VDJWHU(UWULWW DQGHQ6FKUHLEHUKHUDQGHUPLWGHP&RPSXWHUYHUEXQGHQ MHGHP6FKDOWHU]XJHRUGQHWLVW(UWLSSWGLH&KLIIUHHLQGUFNW HLQHQ.QRSIXQGNRPPWJOHLFKGDUDXIPLWHLQHPVFKPDOHQ EHGUXFNWHQ6WUHLIHQ]XUFN'HQKDWHULQGHUHLQHQ+DQG,Q GHUDQGHUHQZLHJWHUGLH=HLWXQJPLWGHP+XQGHUWPDUNVFKHLQ ª-DJQlGLJH)UDX©EHJLQQWHUIDUEORVªLFKVHKHJHUDGHGD GLHVH$QQRQFHLQGUHLXQG]ZDQ]LJ=HLWXQJHQHUVFKHLQWPHKU PDOV(LQ6LHEHQWDXVHQGPDUNREMHNW© 6LHQLFNW6LHKPDODQGHUMXQJH0HQVFKKDWGDV=HXJGD]X LQGLHVHP/DQGHHWZDV]XZHUGHQ1DWUOLFKVLQGKXQGHUW
0DUNIUGLH3UHLVJDEHHLQHV6LHEHQWDXVHQGPDUNREMHNWVYLHO ]XZHQLJ:LQQLHOHJWJHODVVHQ]ZHLZHLWHUH%ODXHGD]X,P %UXFKWHLOYRQ6HNXQGHQYHUVFKZLQGHQGLHGUHL6FKHLQH'HU &RPSXWHUDXVGUXFNWULWWQXQGHQ:HJLQGLH*HJHQULFKWXQJDQ :LQQLHV+DQGWDVFKHQLPPWLKQDXI 'HUMXQJH0DQQNULW]HOWHWZDVDXIGHQ5DQGGHUJHIDOWHWHQ =HLWXQJXQGUHLFKWVLHGHU.XQGLQ]XUFNª6ROOWHQJQlGLJH )UDXQRFKZHLWHUH)UDJHQKDEHQLFKVWHKH,KQHQLPPHUJHUQ ]XU9HUIJXQJ© (LQH7HOHIRQQXPPHU ª'DQNH+HUU%DFK,FKZHUGHGDUDXI]XUFNNRPPHQ© HUZLGHUWGLH)RWRJUDILQIUHXQGOLFKXQGJHKW $OVVLHLQLKUHP%0:VLW]WQLPPWVLHVLFKGHQ&RP SXWHUVWUHLIHQYRU2EHQDXIGDV.HQQZRUWª+DODOL©XQGGLH 5HFKQXQJVQXPPHUQRFKHLQSDDU$QJDEHQLQGHU=DKOHQVSUD FKHGHV&RPSXWHUVZDKUVFKHLQOLFKGLHFRGLHUWHQ1DPHQGHU EHDXIWUDJWHQ3UHVVHHU]HXJQLVVHXQGYROODXVJHVFKULHEHQ GHU$XIWUDJJHEHUª,QQRFHQWLD0RRVDFKHU)UDQN IXUW0DLQ %RFNHQKHLPHU/DQGVWUDH© :LQQLH:LQNHOPDQQGUHKWGHQ=QGVFKOVVHO
=XUFNJHVHW]WPLWHLQHPNOHLQHQ*DUWHQGDYRUVLHKWGDV ]ZHLVW|FNLJH(LQ]HOKDXVPLWGHPDXVJHEDXWHQ'DFKJHVFKR JHSIOHJWXQGRKQH3URW]LJNHLWJHGLHJHQDXV(VKDWVRJDUHWZDV $QKHLPHOQGHVPLWGHQIULVFKJHVWULFKHQHQZHLHQ%DONRQJLW WHUQXQGGHP$WHOLHUIHQVWHUDXIGHP'DFK'DKLQWHUZLUGHLQ VFKDUODFKURWHU9RUKDQJVLFKWEDU1LUJHQGZRVWHKWHLQH 6FKHLEHRIIHQ :LQQLH:LQNHOPDQQJHKWODQJVDPYRUEHLXQGEHWULWWGDQQ HLQ6WFNZHLWHUGDV/DGHQJHVFKlIWHLQHUFKHPLVFKHQ5HLQL JXQJ(LQHIUHXQGOLFKHlOWHUH)UDXLQZHLHP.LWWHOHPSIlQJW VLHXQGIUDJWQDFKLKUHQ:QVFKHQ ª9LHOOHLFKWN|QQHQ6LHPLUKHOIHQ©VDJWGLH)RWRJUDILQ YHUELQGOLFKª:DQQNDQQPDQGHQQ)UDX0RRVDFKHULQGHU 1XPPHUKXQGHUWVLHEHQXQGYLHU]LJHUUHLFKHQ"$QV7HOHIRQ JHKWVLHQLFKWXQGQXQ,FKKDEHXPVRQVWJHNOLQJHOW©
ª.HQQHQ6LH)UDX0RRVDFKHU"© ª6RQVWZlUHLFKGRFKQLFKWKLHU©HQWJHJQHW:LQQLHHLQ ZHQLJYRQREHQKHUDEXQG]HLJWHLQYHUZXQGHUWHV/lFKHOQGDV DXVGUFNHQZLOOVLHYHUVWHKHGHQ6LQQGHU)UDJHQLFKW1DWU OLFKEHJUHLIWVLHVHKUJXWGDGLH)UDXHLQIDFKYRUVLFKWLJLVW XQGGLH1DFKEDULQYRUDXIGULQJOLFKHQ9HUWUHWHUQEHZDKUHQ P|FKWH'LH$QWZRUWEHU]HXJWYLHOOHLFKWJHUDGHZHLOVLHVR XQEHIDQJHQXQORJLVFKLVW ª(QWVFKXOGLJHQ6LH)UDX0RRVDFKHULVWZLHGHUEHLLKUHU 7RFKWHUDXIGHP/DQGH,UJHQGZRGDXQWHQLQ%D\HUQJODXEH LFK© ª$FK"©EHGDXHUWGLH%HVXFKHULQª'DVLVWVFKDGH'LH $QVFKULIWKDEHQ6LHZRKOQLFKW"6RQVWZUGHLFKLKUVFKUHL EHQ© $XFKGDVZLUNWYHUWUDXHQHUZHFNHQG ª/HLGHUDEHUGDNDQQ,KQHQVLFKHUOLFK+HUU6FKZHGOHU KHOIHQ'DVLVWGHU+HUUGHUGLH$WHOLHUZRKQXQJJHPLHWHWKDW© ª+HUU6FKZHGOHU© ª'DVLVWHLQVHKUIHLQHU0HQVFK,PPHUIUHXQGOLFKXQG VRKLOIVEHUHLW(LQ$NDGHPLNHU'DKDW)UDX0RRVDFKHUULFKWLJ *OFNJHKDEW6LHZROOWHMDHUVWJDUQLFKWYHUPLHWHQXQGQ|WLJ KlWWHVLHHVDXFKQLFKWJHKDEW© ª-DLFKZHL©EHVWlWLJW:LQQLHª,FKZHUGHHVGDQQHLQPDO VRYHUVXFKHQ,FKGDQNH,KQHQMHGHQIDOOVVHKU©6FKRQDQGHU 7UZHQGHWVLHVLFKQRFKHLQPDOXPª.DQQLFK+HUUQ 6FKZHGOHUWDJVEHUHUUHLFKHQ"© ª'DVZHLLFKOHLGHUQLFKW© (LQSDDU6WUDHQZHLWHUSDUNWGLH)RWRJUDILQLQGHU1lKH HLQHV3RVWDPWVXQGEOlWWHUWLP7HOHIRQEXFK-DGHU1DPHZLUG DXVJHZLHVHQª6FKZHGOHU:ROI'LHWHU'LSORPNULPLQDOLVW )IP%RFNHQKHLPHU/DQGVWUDH© :LQQLHNODSSWGDV%XFK]XEHVWHOOWVLFKLQGHUNOHLQHQ .RQGLWRUHLHLQHQ.DIIHHXQGEHUOHJW'LH'DPH0RRVDFKHU VFKHLQWRIWQLFKWGD]XVHLQ'HU'LSORPNULPLQDOLVW:ROI'LHWHU 6FKZHGOHUVHLHLQIUHXQGOLFKHUXQGKLOIVEHUHLWHU0HQVFKPLW GHPGLH+DXVEHVLW]HULQ*OFNJHKDEWKDEHVDJWHGLH)UDXYRQ
GHU5HLQLJXQJ:DKUVFKHLQOLFKKDWWH)UDX0RRVDFKHUDXFK QLFKWVGDJHJHQGDHUXQWHULKUHP1DPHQHLQH$QQRQFH DXIJDEXQGQDWUOLFKKROWHUDXFKGLHHLQJHKHQGHQ=XVFKULIWHQ LQGHU.URQHQJDVVHDE2GHUZHLVLHJDUQLFKWVGDYRQZRVLH GRFKRIWDEZHVHQGLVW"'DVHUVFKHLQWQDKHOLHJHQG /DQJVDPNULHJWGLH6DFKH)DUEHGHQNW:LQQLH(LQHUSO|W] OLFKHQ(LQJHEXQJIROJHQGJHKWVLHDQV7HOHIRQVXFKWGLH1XP PHUHLQHV$QVFKOXVVHVXQGZlKOW ª5KHLQ0DLQ'HWHNWHLJXWHQ7DJ©PHOGHWVLFKHLQH7HOH IRQLVWLQPLWJHVFKlIWVPlLJHU9HUELQGOLFKNHLW ª*HEHQ6LHPLU+HUUQ6FKZHGOHU© ª,FKEHGDXUH+HUU6FKZHGOHULVWQLFKWLP+DXVH%LWWH KLQWHUODVVHQ6LH,KUHQ1DPHQXQG,KUH5XIQXPPHU+HUU 6FKZHGOHUUXIW]XUFN© ª1LFKWQ|WLJ,FKPHOGHPLFKZLHGHU'DQNH© :LQQLHWULQNWHLQHQ]ZHLWHQ.DIIHH$OOHVNODU6LHGHQNW DQGDV*HVSUlFKGDVVLHPLW:HUQHULP:LHVEDGHQHU.XUSDUN JHIKUWKDWXQGLQGHPVLHIHVWVWHOOWHQ%ULQNPDQQKDEHZRKO GLH.UHLVHGHUªDOWHQ.DPHUDGHQ©JHVW|UW6LHEOHLEHQJHVW|UW VRODQJHGDV%ULQNPDQQSDSLHUDOV'DPRNOHVVFKZHUWEHUGHU 6]HQHKlQJW'HU0$'KDWHVWURW]JURDQJHOHJWHU6XFKDNWLRQ QLFKWJHIXQGHQ$XIGDV%LOGYRPª:LOGEUHWKlQGOHU©LVWHUHUVW VSlWHUDXIPHUNVDPJHZRUGHQ$OVHUHVVLFKHUVWHOOHQZROOWH KDWHUGLHJOHLFKH(UIDKUXQJPDFKHQPVVHQZLH:HUQHU(V ZDUZHJ8QGQXQVXFKHQVLHDOOHGDQDFKVHOEVWYHUVWlQGOLFK DXFKGLHªDOWHQ.DPHUDGHQ©'LHKDEHQPLWGHU5+(,1 0$,1'(7(.7(,LKU9ROO]XJVRUJDQHLQJHVFKDOWHWXQGZHLO %RUQXQGVHLQH/HXWHDXHUKDOEGHU/HJDOLWlWDUEHLWHQVLQG LKQHQZHQLJHUGLH+lQGHJHEXQGHQXQGVLHN|QQHQVLFKPHKU HUODXEHQDOVEHLVSLHOVZHLVHYRQ:LHVHQHFN0DQPXLKQHQ ]XJHVWHKHQGDVLHPLWGHU6LHEHQWDXVHQGPDUN$Q]HLJHQ NDPSDJQHGLHJHVFKLFNWDXIGLHYHUPXWHWHQNOHLQHQ'LHEHDXV GHU-DJGKWWH]LHOWGXUFKDXVHLQIDOOVUHLFKXQGHUIROJYHU VSUHFKHQGYRUJHKHQ6HOEVWVLH:LQQLH:LQNHOPDQQYHU PXWHWHMD]XHUVWOHGLJOLFKHLQH$XINDXIDNWLRQLQEORHP *HVFKlIWVLQWHUHVVH'DGDVGDKLQWHUVWHFNWDEHUQXQZHL VLHHV
'LHJHZRQQHQHQHXH(UNHQQWQLVYHUDQODWVLHVLFKZLHGHU XPJHKHQGPLWGHP$Q]HLJHQPHQVFKHQLQ9HUELQGXQJ]X VHW]HQ'DVLHVFKRQHLQPDOKDQGHOVHLQLJJHZRUGHQVLQG NRPPWHVVFKQHOO]X HLQHU9HUHLQEDUXQJ1DFKNXU]HP )HLOVFKHQXPGHQ3UHLVHUZLUGVLFKQDFKGHU$Q]DKOGHU =XVFKULIWHQULFKWHQYHUDEUHGHQVLHGD:LQQLHGLH0|JOLFK NHLWHUKlOWDOOH(LQJlQJH]Xª+DODOL©]XVLFKWHQ
:LHGHUPDFKW'LUHNWRU'RQQHUVHLQHQEOLFKHQ5XQGJDQJLP *URUDXPEUREOHLEWGDXQGGRUWVWHKHQOlWVLFKEHULFKWHQ XQGODQGHWVFKOLHOLFKEHL6HQQHZDOGª%OLW]©XQG'RQQHUVLQG ZLHGHUEHLVDPPHQ'LH6DFKHPLWGHP:HUNPHLVWHULVWVFKRQ HUOHGLJWbUJHUKDWHVLQGHU9HUVDQGDEWHLOXQJJHJHEHQGDKDW GLH)UHPGHQSROL]HLHLQSDDU7UNHQDXIJHVW|EHUWGLHYRQ FOHYHUHQ/DQGVOHXWHQLOOHJDOLQGLH%XQGHVUHSXEOLNJHVFKOHXVW ZRUGHQVLQGXQGGHUHQ$XIHQWKDOWVXQG$UEHLWVHUODXEQLV JHIlOVFKWZDUHQ'LHHQWVWDQGHQHQ/FNHQVLQGPLW/HXWHQ DXVGHUª=RQH©JHVFKORVVHQZRUGHQ ª6WLFKZRUW=RQH©QLPPW'RQQHUDXIª,FKKDEHGDHLQH ,QIRUPDWLRQYRP%I9'LH9HUIDVVXQJVVFKW]HUHPSIHKOHQ HLQHJHZLVVH6RUJIDOWEHLGHU(LQVWHOOXQJYRQ)DFKNUlIWHQGLH YRQGUEHQNRPPHQ%HLP+DQGZHUNVPHLVWHU1XEHOQXVFK NLQJHVFKHQNW$EHUEHLXQV)UGLH/HXWHGUEHQLVWHV QDWUOLFKDXFKLQWHUHVVDQW]XZLVVHQZDVZLUPDFKHQXQGLQ GHU6LWXDWLRQMHW]WGDVFKLHEHQVLHGHU)OFKWOLQJVKHUGHUDVFK HLQVFKZDU]HV6FKDIXQWHU)lOOWJDUQLFKWDXI© ª1RWLHUW©YHUVLFKHUW6HQQHZDOGªhEULJHQV'HWMHQ $FKLP8QYHUKHLUDWHW6LHZLVVHQ"©1DFKGHPGHU'LUHNWRU JHQLFNWKDWIKUWHUIRUWª$OOHVQRUPDO$EZHJLJH1HLJXQJHQ 0lQQHUEHNDQQWVFKDIWHQXQGVRNHLQH$XFKNHLQ+DJHVWRO] PLWXQGXUFKVLFKWLJHP3ULYDWOHEHQ)UDXHQEHNDQQWVFKDIWHQ VLQG%LVMHW]WQDFKJHZLHVHQGDV7HFKWHOPHFKWHOPLWHLQHU
JHZLVVHQ%HDWH*UXQGPDQQHLQHUNKOHQ%ORQGHQDXVGHP )OLHJHUNOXE'DVLVWYRUEHL1HXHVWH(UREHUXQJ,VROGH +HUGHJHQKLHULQ.|OQ© ª$XFKEORQG"© ª.DVWDQLHQEUDXQ8QGGHU:LW]GDEHL,VROGH+HUGHJHQ VWHKWIQI6WRFNZHUNHXQWHUXQVDQHLQHU=HLFKHQPDVFKLQH© ª$FKQHH"©'RQQHUVFKPXQ]HOWª:HQQGDVNHLQ=XIDOO LVW© ª(VLVWHLQHU©YHUVLFKHUW6HQQHZDOGª,FKKDEHPLULKUH 3HUVRQDODNWHNRPPHQODVVHQ+LHU© 'HU'LUHNWRUVFKOlJWGHQ'HFNHODXIXQGEHWUDFKWHWGDV 3DELOGª1DMD©VDJWHUª6LHKWMDJDQ]QLHGOLFKDXV© )QI6WRFNZHUNHWLHIHUVWHKW,VROGH+HUGHJHQDQLKUHU =HLFKHQPDVFKLQHKDWGLHbUPHOGHV.LWWHOVKDOEDXIJHVWUHLIW XQGIHUWLJWQDFKHLQHUYRP.RQVWUXNWLRQVEURYRUJHJHEHQHQ +DQGVNL]]HHLQH5HLQ]HLFKQXQJDQ'LH$UEHLWJHKWLKUJXWYRQ GHU+DQGXQGEHVFKZHUWVLHQLFKW'DVLVWGLHJHZRKQWH7lWLJ NHLWGLHVLHVLFKHUEHKHUUVFKWXQGGLHDXV]XIKUHQLKUDXFK )UHXGHPDFKWVLHOLHEWHVIOFKWLJKLQJHZRUIHQH8PULVVHDXI GHP=HLFKHQSHUJDPHQWNODUHVFKDUIXPULVVHQH.RQWXUHQ DQQHKPHQ]XVHKHQ,VROGHLVWJXWHU'LQJH %ULJLWWH.RHSSHQWULWW]XLKUXQG]HLJWDXIGLH$UPEDQGXKU ª.DIIHHSDXVH©YHUNQGHWVLHª.RPPZLUJHKHQ UDXV© 'UHLLJ=HLFKQHULQQHQVWHKHQLQGLHVHP6DDODQLKUHQ VFKDWWHQORVEHOHXFKWHWHQ0DVFKLQHQDEHUQXU]XGHU.ROOHJLQ DP1DFKEDUJHUlWKDW,VROGHHLQHQJHUHV9HUKlOWQLV%ULJLWWH .RHSSHQLVW$QIDQJ9LHU]LJVLHKWMHGRFKMQJHUDXVXQGKDW 9HUVWlQGQLVIUGLH3UREOHPHXQG3UREOHPFKHQGHUDQGHUHQ JLEWPDOHLQHQJXWHQ5DWXQGYHUVWHKWVLFKYRUDOOHPGDUDXI ]X]XK|UHQ,QIROJHGHVVHQVLW]HQVLHEHLP0LWWDJHVVHQLQGHU .DQWLQH]XVDPPHQXQGULFKWHQHVVRHLQGDVLHLKUH3DXVHQ JHPHLQVDPLQGHU.DIIHHVWXEHDP(QGHGHV*DQJHVYHU EULQJHQ,KUH9HUEXQGHQKHLWEHJLQQWEHLP%HWUHWHQXQGHQGHW EHLP9HUODVVHQGHV(*$*HOlQGHV'DUEHUKLQDXVJLEWHV NHLQH%HJHJQXQJHQ $XHULKQHQLVWMHW]WLQGHU.DIIHHVWXEHQXUHLQMXQJHU0DQQ
LPJHOEHQ2YHUDOOGHU$XWRPDWHQJHVHOOVFKDIWHLQMREEHQGHU 6WXGHQWYHUPXWOLFKGHUVHLQHQ/HEHQVXQWHUKDOWPLW*HOHJHQ KHLWVDUEHLWHQVROFKHU$UWDXIEHVVHUW(UEHVFKLFNWGLH$XWR PDWHQPLW6WDQJHQYRQ3ODVWLNEHFKHUQIOOWGLH.DIIHHEHKlO WHUDXIXQGUHLQLJWGLH$XVJDEHVFKlFKWH'DVJHKWIOLQNHU YHUULFKWHWGLHVH$UEHLWZRKOGRFKVFKRQOlQJHU$UEHLWVJlQJH ZLHGLHVHZHUGHQLPPHUYRQ+LOIVNUlIWHQDXVJHIKUW$QJH VWHOOWHGHU)LUPDHUVFKHLQHQQXU]XP$XVZHFKVHOQGHU*HOG NDVVHWWHQ 'LHEHLGHQ)UDXHQZHUIHQLKUH0Q]HQHLQXQGHQWQHKPHQ QDFK.QRSIGUXFNGDPSIHQGH.DIIHHEHFKHUPLWGHQHQVLH VLFKLQHLQH(FNH]XUFN]LHKHQ'LH7LVFKHVLQGNOHLQXQGGLH 6WKOHQLFKWEHTXHPODQJHDXIKDOWHQVROOVLFKKLHUQLHPDQG $EHUPDQNDQQZHQLJVWHQVGLH%HLQHYRQVLFKVWUHFNHQXQG HLQ SDDU=JHUDXFKHQZDVLP=HLFKHQVDDOYHUERWHQLVWª:HP ZLOOVWGXGHQQJHIDOOHQ"'HLQ.OHLGLVWYLHO]XVFKLFNIUGLH $UEHLW© 8QZLOONUOLFKUDIIW,VROGHGHQRIIHQHQ.LWWHOHLQZHQLJ ]XVDPPHQ(LJHQWOLFKZROOWHVLHJDUQLFKWVYRQLKUHUQHXHQ %HNDQQWVFKDIWHU]lKOHQDEHUQXQWXWHVLKUGRFKJDQ]JXWGDU EHUUHGHQ]XN|QQHQ6LHVSULFKWJHUQEHUGDVZDVLKU )UHXGHPDFKWª$FK©EDJDWHOOLVLHUWVLHªZLUWUHIIHQXQVHUVW ]XP]ZHLWHQPDOXQGLFKNRPPHYRUKHUQLFKWPHKUQDFK +DXVH'HVKDOE© %ULJLWWH.RHSSHQOlFKHOWXQGEOlVWEHKXWVDPLQGHQEUlXQ OLFKHQ6FKDXPLP%HFKHUª:LHLVWHUGHQQ"6DJGRFKZDV© ª:DVVROOLFKGDVDJHQ"1HWWLVWHUHEHQ© 'LH1DFKEDULQDXVGHP=HLFKHQVDDOOlWQLFKWORFNHUª8QG HLQELFKHQlOWHUKP"© ª:LHNRPPVWGXGDUDXI"© ª,VROGH'XKDVWHLQULFKWLJHV&RFNWDLONOHLGDQ)UGLH IUKHUHQ5HLVHEHNDQQWVFKDIWHQELVWGXPHLVWLQ-HDQVKHU XPJHVSUXQJHQ$EHUGDVGDVWHKWGLUYLHOEHVVHU9HUNOHLGXQJ DOV'DPHGDVOlWGRFK5FNVFKOVVH]X© ,VROGHODFKWPLWª'DV*HVLFKWZHQQLFKLQ-HDQVNlPH,FK VWHOOHHVPLUOLHEHUQLFKWYRU:DKUVFKHLQOLFKZlUHHUPDORV
HQWWlXVFKW(UKDWVRZDV*HGLHJHQHVDQVLFKZDV.RUUHNWHV ,FKJODXEHDXIGHQN|QQWHPDQVLFKYHUODVVHQ© %ULJLWWHWULQNWLQNOHLQHQ6FKOXFNHQXQGKlOW,VROGHLKUH =LJDUHWWHQKLQª8QGGDVJHIlOOWGLU"© ª1DXQGRE'XGHULVWJDQ]DQGHUVDOVGLHMXQJHQ %XUVFKHQGLHLPPHUJOHLFK.OLPP]JHDP%+PDFKHQ8QG GDQQLVWQLFKWVPHKU%HLGHPKDEHLFKGDV*HIKOGHUPDJ PLFKULFKWLJ'HUOlWVLFK=HLWXQGPLUDXFK+DOWHPLFKUXKLJ IUYHUUFNWDEHULFKELQDXIHLQHLUUHDOWPRGLVFKH$UWYHU OLHEW©6RQXQLVWHVKHUDXV6LHUDXFKW 'LH.ROOHJLQVLHKWVLHVRUJHQYROODQª0lGFKHQ0lGFKHQ 'DVNOLQJWMDIDVW]XVFK|QXPZDKU]XVHLQ© ª:DUXPVROOLFKQLFKWDXFKPDO*OFNKDEHQ"© %ULJLWWH.RHSSHQVFKQLSSW$VFKHLQGLH6FKDOHª'RUW PXQGHU8QLRQ©VWHKWGUDXI5HNODPHª+RIIHQWOLFKLVWGDV QLFKWHLQJDQ]$XVJHNRFKWHUGHUGLFKJHQDXGXUFKVFKDXWXQG DXIGHLQHQ-DKUJDQJVSH]LDOLVLHUWLVW0DQOLHVWGDYRQVRYLHOLQ GHQ=HLWXQJHQ+HLUDWVVFKZLQGOHUNRPPHQDXIGLHNRPLVFK VWHQ7ULFNV©6LHVHXI]Wª:HLWGXREHUEHUKDXSWVRKHLW ZLHHUEHKDXSWHW"© ,VROGHKHEWGDV.LQQXQGEOLFNWGLH.ROOHJLQVHKUEHUOHJHQ DQª:HLLFK©YHUNQGHWVLHª,FKELQGRFKQLFKWYRQJHVWHUQ ,FKKDEHVHLQ$XWRJHVHKHQ© ª0HUFHGHVUHQWDFDU©ZLQNWGLH.RHSSHQDE ª1HLQHLQ.lIHU!XQGQLFKWPDOQHX©WUXPSIW,VROGHDXI ª(UVWDQGXQWHUHLQHU/DWHUQHXQGGDV/LFKWILHOYROODXIV .HQQ]HLFKHQ$OVRKDEHLFKPLFKHUNXQGLJWDXIZHQGHU :DJHQ]XJHODVVHQLVW6WLPPWDOOHV'DPLWQLFKWJHQXJ$OV HUPLFKJHVWHUQDEHQGDQULHIKDEHLFKJHVDJWLFKZLVVHQLFKW JHQDXREZLUQLFKWhEHUVWXQGHQPDFKHQPVVHQ8QGVRKDEH LFKLKQKHXWHLP'LHQVWDQJHUXIHQXQGGDVNODSSWHDXFK 7HOHIRQ]HQWUDOH6HNUHWlULQHUZLHVLFK VJHK|UW+LQWHUKHU KDEHLFKHLQVFKOHFKWHV*HZLVVHQJHKDEW,FKJODXEHLFKZHUGH LKPGDVVDJHQ© %ULJLWWH.RHSSHQKDWHLQHNOHLQH6WUHLFKHOJHVWHIUGLH -QJHUHª0lGFKHQ©VDJWVLHª'LFKKDW VMDHUZLVFKWELV
EHUEHLGH2KUHQ$EHUPLWGHP*HVWlQGQLVZUGHLFKHLQ ELFKHQZDUWHQ0lQQHUEUDXFKHQQLFKWDOOHV]XZLVVHQ© 'DQQGUFNHQVLHGLH=LJDUHWWHQDXVXQGNHKUHQLQGHQ =HLFKHQVDDO]XUFN