abul-fm.qxd
2/28/02
9:11 AM
Page iii
SLURRY SYSTEMS HANDBOOK BAHA E. ABULNAGA, P.E. Mazdak International, Inc.
McG...
729 downloads
1344 Views
11MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
abul-fm.qxd
2/28/02
9:11 AM
Page iii
SLURRY SYSTEMS HANDBOOK BAHA E. ABULNAGA, P.E. Mazdak International, Inc.
McGRAW-HILL New York Chicago San Francisco Lisbon London Madrid Mexico City Milan New Delhi San Juan Seoul Singapore Sydney Toronto
abul-fm.qxd
2/28/02
9:11 AM
Page iv
Cataloging-in-Publication Data is on file with the Library of Congress.
Copyright © 2002 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of America. Except as permitted under the United States Copyright Act of 1976, no part of this publication may be reproduced or distributed in any form or by any means, or stored in a data base or retrieval system, without the prior written permission of the publisher. 1 2 3 4 5 7 8 9 0
DOC/DOC
0 7 6 5 4 3 2
ISBN 0-07-137508-2 The sponsoring editor for this book was Larry S. Hager and the production supervisor was Sherri Souffrance. It was set in Times Roman by Ampersand Graphics, Ltd. Printed and bound by R. R. Donnelley and Sons, Co.
This book was printed on recycled, acid-free paper containing a minimum of 50% recycled de-inked fiber.
McGraw-Hill books are available at special quantity discounts to use as premiums and sales promotions, or for use in corporate training programs. For more information, please write to the Director of Special Sales, McGraw-Hill Professional Publishing, Two Penn Plaza, New York, NY 10121-2298. Or contact your local bookstore. Information contained in this work has been obtained by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. (“McGraw-Hill”) from sources believed to be reliable. However, neither McGraw-Hill nor its authors guarantee the accuracy or completeness of any information published herein, and neither McGraw-Hill nor its authors shall be responsible for any errors, omissions, or damages arising out of use of this information. This work is published with the understanding that McGraw-Hill and its authors are supplying information but are not attempting to render engineering or other professional services. If such services are required, the assistance of an appropriate professional should be sought.
abul-fm.qxd
2/28/02
9:11 AM
Page v
In memory of my father, Dr. Sayed Abul Naga, and in dedication to my mother, Dr. Hiam Aboul Hussein, who devoted their lives to comparative literature as authors and translators. May their efforts contribute to a better understanding among mankind. And to my children Sayed and Alexander for filling my life with joy and happiness.
index.qxd
2/28/02
9:28 AM
Page I.11
BAHA ABULNAGA, P.E., obtained his Bachelor of Aeronautical Engineering in 1980 from the University of London and his Masters in Materials Engineering in 1986 from the American University of Cairo, Egypt. The first years of his professional career were devoted to the adaptation of air cushion platforms to desert environments, as well as the development of renewable energy systems. In 1988, he joined CSIRO (Australia) as a scientist. There he conducted research on complex multiphase flow for the design of smelting furnaces. Since 1990, he has been active in design of rotating equipment, pumps, and slurry pipelines and processing plants. His career has been a balanced mixture of design of equipment and consulting engineering. He has been employed as a design engineer for a number of manufacturers such as Warman Pumps (now part of Weir Pumps), Svedala Pumps and Process (now part of Metso Mineral Systems), Sulzer Pumps North America, and Mazdak Pumps and Mixers. He has also contracted as a slurry and hydraulics specialist for major consulting engineering firms such as ERM, SNC-Lavalin, Fluor, Bateman, Rescan, and Hatch and Associates. His involvement in the design, expansion, and commissioning of projects has included ASARCO Ray Tailings (USA), LTV Steel (USA), Zaldivar Pipeline (Chile), Southern Peru Expansion (Peru), Lomas Bayes (Chile), Escondida (Chile), BHP Diamets (Canada), Muskeg River Oil Sands (Canada), Bajo Alumbrera (Argentina), Homestake Eskay Creek (Canada), and many other engineering projects, feasibility studies, and audits.
abul-fm.qxd
2/28/02
9:11 AM
Page xvii
PREFACE
The science of slurry hydraulics started to flourish in the 1950s with simple tests on pumping sand and coal at moderate concentrations. It has evolved gradually to encompass the pumping of pastes in the food and process industries, mixtures of coal and oil as a new fuel, and numerous mixtures of minerals and water. Because of the diversity of minerals pumped, the wide range in sizes [43 m (mesh 325) to 51 mm (2 in)], and the various physical and chemical properties of the materials, the engineering of slurry systems requires various empirical and mathematical models. The engineering of slurry systems and the design of pipelines is therefore fairly complex. This handbook targets the practicing consultant engineer, the maintenance superintendent, and the economist. Numerous solved problems and simplified computer programs have been included to guide the reader. The structure of the book is essentially in two parts. The first six chapters form the first part of the book and focus on the hydraulics of slurry systems. Chapter 1 is a general introduction on the preparation of slurry, the classification of soils, the siltation of dams, and the history of slurry pipelines. Chapter 2 focuses on water as a carrier of solids. Chapter 3 progresses with the mechanics of mixing solids and liquids and the principles of rheology. Chapter 4 presents the various models of heterogeneous flows of settling slurries, whereas Chapter 5 concentrates on non-Newtonian flows. Due to the importance of open channel flows in the design of long-distance tailings systems or slurry plants, Chapter 6 was dedicated to a better understanding of these complex flows, which are seldom mentioned in books on slurry. In Part II, the book focuses on components of slurry systems and their economic aspects. In Chapter 7, the important equipment of slurry processing plants is presented, including grinding circuits, flotation cells, agitators, mixers, and thickeners. Chapter 8 presents the guidelines for the design of centrifugal slurry pumps, and methods of correction of their performance. Chapter 9 reviews the continuous improvements of positive displacement slurry pumps in their different forms, such as plunger, diaphragm, or lockhopper pumps. As slurry causes wear and corrosion, aspects of the selection of metals and rubbers is presented in Chapter 10. To guide the reader to the various aspects of the design of slurry pipelines, Chapter 11 presents practical cases such as coal, phosphate, limestone, and copper concentrate pipelines. This review of historical data is followed by a review of standards of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers and the American Petroleum Institute, as they are extremely useful tools for the design and monitoring of pipelines. Finally, as the big unknown is too often cost, Chapter 12 closes the book by offering guidelines for a complete feasibility study for a tailings disposal system or a slurry pipeline. The author wishes to thank the staff of Mazdak International Inc, particularly Ms. Mary Edwards for providing typing services with great dedication over a period of two years. The author particularly wishes to thank Fluor Daniel Wright Engineers for allowing him to use their excellent library in Vancouver, Canada. The author wishes to thank his former colleagues in a colorful career, particularly Mr. K. Burgess, C.P.Eng. of Warman International; Mr. A. Majorkwiecz, K. Major, and Mr. Peter Wells of Hatch & Associates; Mr. I. Hanks, P.Eng. and W. McRae of Bateman Engineering; Mr. R. Burmeister
xvii
abul-fm.qxd
xviii
2/28/02
9:11 AM
Page xviii
PREFACE
H. Basmajian, and Dr. C. Shook, consultants; Mr. C. Hunker, P.Eng, V. Bryant, D. Bartlett, and W. Li, P.Eng. of Fluor Daniel; and Mr. A. Oak, P.Eng. of AMEC for allowing him to work on very challenging assignments in Australia and South and North America. The author wishes to thank the following firms for their contributions in the form of figures and data to this handbook: The Metso Group (formerly the companies Nordberg and Svedala), Red Valves, Geho Pumps (Weir Pumps), Mobile Pulley and Machine Works, Inc., Wirth Pumps, Hayward Gordon, Mazdak International Inc., the BHR Group, and GIW/KSB Pumps. The author is grateful to the various publishers and associations who allowed him to reproduce valuable materials in the book.
abul-fm.qxd
2/28/02
9:11 AM
Page vii
CONTENTS
Preface
xvii
PART ONE HYDRAULICS OF SLURRY FLOWS 1 General Concepts of Slurry Flows 1-0 1-1
1-2
1-3 1-4 1-5
1-6 1-7 1-8
1-9 1-10
Introduction Properties of Soils for Slurry Mixtures 1-1-1 Classifications of Soils for Slurry Mixtures 1-1-2 Testing of Soils 1-1-3 Textures of Soils 1-1-4 Plasticity of Soils Slurry Flows 1-2-1 Homogeneous Flows 1-2-2 Heterogeneous Flows 1-2-3 Intermediate Flow Regimes 1-2-4 Flows of Emulsions 1-2-5 Flows of Emulsions - Slurry Mixtures Sinking Velocity of Particles, and Critical Velocity of Flow 1-3-1 Sinking or Terminal Velocity of Particles 1-3-2 Critical Velocity of Flows Density of a Slurry Mixture Dynamic Viscosity of a Newtonian Slurry Mixture 1-5-1 Absolute (or Dynamic) Viscosity of Mixtures with Volume Concentration Smaller Than 1% 1-5-2 Absolute (or Dynamic) Viscosity of Mixtures with Solids with Volume Concentration Smaller Than 20% 1-5-3 Absolute (or Dynamic) Viscosity of Mixtures with High Volume Concentration of Solids Specific Heat Thermal Conductivity and Heat Transfer Slurry Circuits in Extractive Metallurgy 1-8-1 Crushing 1-8-2 Milling and Primary Grinding 1-8-3 Classification 1-8-4 Concentration and Separation Circuits 1-8-5 Piping the Concentrate 1-8-6 Disposal of the Tailings Closed and Open Channel Flows, Pipelines Versus Launders Historical Development of Slurry Pipelines
vii
1.3 1.4 1.5 1.5 1.8 1.13 1.13 1.15 1.16 1.16 1.16 1.16 1.17 1.17 1.17 1.17 1.19 1.21 1.21 1.21 1.22 1.22 1.22 1.24 1.24 1.25 1.26 1.26 1.30 1.30 1.31 1.32
abul-fm.qxd
2/28/02
viii
9:11 AM
Page viii
CONTENTS
1-11 1-12 1-13 1-14
Sedimentation of Dams—A role for the Slurry Engineer Conclusion Nomenclature References
1.33 1.37 1.37 1.38
2 Fundamentals of Water Flows in Pipes
2.1
2-0 2-1 2-2 2-3
2.4 2-5 2-6 2-7 2-8 2-9 2-10 2-11
2-12 2-13 2-14
Introduction Shear Stress of Liquid Flows Reynolds Number and Flow Regimes Friction Factors 2-3-1 Laminar Friction Factors 2-3-2 Transition Flow Friction Factor 2-3-3 Friction Factor in Turbulent Flow 2-3-4 Hazen–Williams Formula The Hydraulic Friction Gradient of Water in Rubber-Lined Steel Pipes Dynamics of the Boundary Layer 2-5-1 Entrance Length 2-5-2 Friction Velocity Pressure Losses Due to Conduits and Fittings Orifice Plates, Nozzles and Valves Head Losses Pressure Losses Through Fittings at Low Reynolds Number The Bernoulli Equation Energy and Hydraulic Grade Lines with Friction Fundamental Heat Transfer in Pipes 2-11-1 Conduction 2-11-2 Thermal Resistance 2-11-3 The R Value 2-11-4 The Specific Heat or Heat Capacity Cp 2-11-5 Characteristic Length 2-11-6 Thermal Diffusivity 2-11-7 Heat Transfer Conclusion Nomenclature References
3 Mechanics of Suspension of Solids in Liquids 3-0 3-1
Introduction Drag Coefficient and Terminal Velocity of Suspended Spheres in a Fluid 3-1-1 The Airplane Analogy 3-1-2 Buoyancy of Floating Objects 3-1-3 Terminal Velocity of Spherical Particles 3-1-3-1 Terminal Velocity of a Sphere Falling in a Vertical Tube 3-1-3-2 Very Fine Spheres 3-1-3-3 Intermediate Spheres 3-1-3-4 Large spheres 3-1-4 Effects of Cylindrical Walls on Terminal Velocity
2.1 2.1 2.3 2.4 2.6 2.8 2.9 2.18 2.19 2.33 2.33 2.35 2.44 2.49 2.54 2.58 2.58 2.58 2.60 2.60 2.60 2.61 2.61 2.61 2.61 2.62 2.62 2.64
3.1 3.1 3.1 3.1 3.3 3.3 3.3 3.5 3.6 3.7 3.8
abul-fm.qxd
2/28/02
9:11 AM
Page ix
CONTENTS
3-1-5 Effects of the Volumetric Concentration on the Terminal Velocity 3-2 Generalized Drag Coefficient—The Concept of Shape Factor 3-3 Non-Newtonian Slurries 3-4 Time-Independent Non-Newtonian Mixtures 3-4-1 Bingham Plastics 3-4-2 Pseudoplastic Slurries 3-4-2-1 Homogeneous Pseudoplastics 3-4-2-2 Pseudohomogeneous Pseudoplastics 3-4-3 Dilatant Slurries 3-4-4 Yield Pseudoplastic Slurries 3-5 Time-Dependent Non-Newtonian Mixtures 3-5-1 Thixotropic Mixtures 3-6 Drag Coefficient of Solids Suspended in Non-Newtonian Flows 3-7 Measurement of Rheology 3-7-1 The Capillary-Tube Viscometer 3-7-2 The Coaxial Cylinder Rotary Viscometer 3-8 Conclusion 3-9 Nomenclature 3-10 References
4 Heterogeneous Flows of Settling Slurries 4-0 4-1
4-2 4-3
4-4
4-5 4-6 4-7 4-8 4-9 4-10
Introduction Regimes of Flow of a Heterogeneous Mixture in Horizontal Pipe 4-1-1 Flow with a Stationary Bed 4-1-2 Flow with a Moving Bed 4-1-3 Suspension Maintained by Turbulence 4-1-4 Symmetric Flow at High Speed Hold Up Transitional Velocities 4-3-1 Transitional Velocities V1 and V2 4-3-2 The Transitional Velocity V3 or Speed for Minimum Pressure Gradient 4-3-3 V4: Transition Speed between Heterogeneous and Pseudohomogeneous Flow Hydraulic Friction Gradient of Horizontal Heterogeneous Flows 4-4-1 Methods Based on the Drag Coefficient of Particles 4-4-2 Effect of Lift Forces 4-4-3 Russian Work on Coarse Coal 4-4-4 Equations for Nickel–Water Suspensions 4-4-5 Models Based on Terminal Velocity Distribution of Particle Concentration in Compound Systems Friction Losses for Compound Mixtures in Horizontal Heterogeneous Flows Saltation and Blockage 4-7-1 Pressure Drop Due to Saltation Flows 4-7-2 Restarting Pipelines after Shut-Down or Blockage Pseudohomogeneous or Symmetric Flows Stratified Flows Two-Layer Models
ix
3.10 3.12 3.17 3.18 3.18 3.25 3.25 3.27 3.28 3.28 3.30 3.30 3.32 3.32 3.33 3.36 3.38 3.38 3.41
4.1 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.3 4.4 4.4 4.5 4.5 4.7 4.8 4.18 4.19 4.21 4.25 4.26 4.28 4.28 4.30 4.33 4.43 4.43 4.45 4.47 4.48 4.50
abul-fm.qxd
2/28/02
x
9:11 AM
Page x
CONTENTS
4-11 Vertical Flow of Coarse Particles 4-12 Inclined Heterogeneous Flows 4-12-1 Critical Slope of Inclined Pipes 4-12-2 Two-Layer Model for Inclined Flows 4-13 Conclusion 4-14 Nomenclature 4-15 References
5 Homogeneous Flows of Nonsettling Slurries 5-0 5-1
4.57 4.58 4.59 4.61 4.62 4.63 4.66
5.1
Introduction Friction Losses for Bingham Plastics 5-1-1 Start-up Pressure 5-1-2 Friction Factor in Laminar Regime 5-1-3 Transition to Turbulent Flow Regime 5-1-4 Friction Factor in the Turbulent Flow Regime 5-2 Friction Losses for Pseudoplastics 5-2-1 Laminar Flow 5-2-1-1 The Rabinowitsch–Mooney Relations 5-2-1-2 The Metzner and Reed Approach 5-2-1-3 The Tomita Method 5-2-1-3 Heywood Method 5-2-2 Transition Flow Regime 5-2-3 Turbulent Flow 5.3 Friction Losses for Yield Pseudoplastics 5-3-1 The Hanks and Ricks Method 5-3-2 The Heywood Method 5-3-3 The Torrance Method 5-4 Generalized Methods 5-4-1 The Hershel–Bulkley Model 5-4-2 The Chilton and Stainsby Method 5-4-3 The Wilson–Thomas Method 5-4-4 The Darby Method: Taking into Account Particle Distribution 5-5 Time-Dependent Non-Newtonian Slurries 5-6 Emulsions 5-7 Roughness Effects on Friction Coefficients 5-8 Wall Slippage 5-9 Pressure Loss through Pipe Fittings 5-10 Scaling up From Small to Large Pipes 5-11 Practical Cases of Non-Newtonian Slurries 5-11-1 Bauxite Residue 5-11-2 Kaolin Slurries 5-12 Drag Reduction 5-13 Pulp and Paper 5-14 Conclusion 5-15 Nomenclature 5-16 References
5.1 5.2 5.2 5.5 5.8 5.9 5.11 5.11 5.11 5.11 5.13 5.14 5.14 5.14 5.17 5.17 5.18 5.18 5.19 5.19 5.19 5.22 5.24 5.28 5.29 5.29 5.33 5.34 5.35 5.35 5.35 5.38 5.39 5.40 5.41 5.42 5.44
6 Slurry Flow In Open Channels and Drop Boxes
6.1
6-0 6-1
Introduction Friction for Single-Phase Flows in Open Channels
6.1 6.2
abul-fm.qxd
2/28/02
9:11 AM
Page xi
CONTENTS
6-2
6-3 6-4 6-5
6-6 6-7 6-8 6-9 6-10 6-11 6-12 6-13 6-14 6-15
Transportation of Sediments in an Open Channel 6-2-1 Measurements of the Concentration of Sediments 6-2-2 Mean Concentrations for Dilute Mixtures (Cv < 0.1) 6-2-3 Magnitude of  Critical Velocity and Critical Shear Stress Deposition Velocity Flow Resistance and Friction Factor for Heterogeneous Slurry Flows 6-5-1 Flow Resistances in Terms of Friction Velocity 6-5-2 Friction Factors 6-5-2-1 Effect of Roughness 6-5-2-2 Effect of Particle Concentration on Slurry Viscosity 6-5-2-3 Effects of Particle Sizes on the Chezy Coefficient 6-5-2-4 Effect of Bed Form on the Friction 6-5-3 The Graf–Acaroglu Relation 6-5-4 Slip of Coarse Materials 6-5-5 Comparison between Different Models Friction Losses and Slope for Homogeneous Slurry Flows 6-6-1 Bingham Plastics Flocculation Launders Froude Number and Stability of Slurry Flows Methodology of Design Slurry Flow in Cascades Hydraulics of the Drop Box and the Plunge Pool Plunge Pools and Drops Followed by Weirs Conclusion Nomenclature References
xi
6.9 6.12 6.18 6.22 6.23 6.27 6.29 6.30 6.31 6.31 6.31 6.32 6.33 6.33 6.35 6.36 6.39 6.40 6.44 6.45 6.45 6.54 6.56 6.67 6.71 6.71 6.74
PART TWO EQUIPMENT AND PIPELINES 7 Components of Slurry Plants 7-0 7-1
7-2 7-3 7-4
7-5
Introduction Rock Crushing 7-1-1 Primary Crushers 7-1-1-1 Jaw Crushers 7-1-1-2 Gyratory Crushers 7-1-1-3 Impact Crushers Secondary and Tertiary Crushers 7-2-1 Cone Crushers 7-2-2 Roll Crushers Grinding Circuits 7-3-1 Single-Stage Circuits 7-3-2 Double-Stage Circuits Horizontal Tumbling Mills 7-4-1 Rod Mills 7-4-2 Ball Mills 7-4-3 Autogeneous and Semiautogeneous Mills Agitated Grinding 7-5-1 Vertical Tower Mills
7.3 7.3 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.7 7.8 7.9 7.9 7.11 7.11 7.21 7.23 7.23 7.26 7.26 7.26 7.27 7.28
abul-fm.qxd
2/28/02
xii
9:11 AM
Page xii
CONTENTS
7-6
7-7
7-8 7-9 7-10 7-11 7-12 7-13
7-5-2 Vertical Spindle Mills 7-5-3 Roller Mills 7.5.4 Vibrating Ball Mills 7.5.5 Hammer Mills Screening Devices 7-6-1 Trommel Screens 7-6-2 Shaking Screens 7-6-3 Vibrating Screens 7-6-4 Banana Screens Slurry Classifiers 7-7-1 Hydraulic Classifiers 7-7-2 Mechanical Classifiers 7-7-3 Hydrocyclones 7-7-4 Magnetic Separators Flotation Circuits Mixers and Agitators Sedimentation 7-10-1 Gravity Sedimentation 7-10-2 Centrifuges Conclusion Nomenclature References
8 The Design of Centrifugal Slurry Pumps 8.0 8.1 8.2
8-3 8-4 8-5
8-6 8-7 8-8 8-9 8-10
Introduction The Centrifugal Slurry Pump Elementary Hydraulics of the Slurry Pump 8.2.1 Vortex Flow 8-2-2 The Ideal Euler Head 8-2-3 Slip of Flow Through Impeller Channels 8-2-4 The Specific Speed 8-2-5 Net Positive Suction Head and Cavitation The Pump Casing The Impeller, the Expeller and the Dynamic Seal Design of the Drive End 8-5-1 The Radial Thrust Due To Total Dynamic Head 8-5-2 The Axial Thrust Due to Pressure 8-5-3 Thread Pull Force 8-5-4 Radial Force on the Drive End 8-5-5 Total Forces from the Wet End 8-5-6 Flange Loads Adjustment of the Wet End Vertical Slurry Pumps Gravel and Dredge Pumps Affinity Laws Performance Corrections for Slurry Pumps 8-10-1 Corrections for Viscosity and Slip 8-10-2 Concepts of Head Ratio and Efficiency Ratio Due to Pumping Solids
7.28 7.28 7.28 7.31 7.31 7.32 7.32 7.32 7.32 7.32 7.32 7.33 7.33 7.38 7.38 7.40 7.59 7.60 7.62 7.64 7.64 7.66
8.1 8.1 8.2 8.6 8.7 8.8 8.11 8.14 8.18 8.25 8.34 8.42 8.43 8.43 8.48 8.51 8.51 8.52 8.53 8.53 8.59 8.60 8.61 8.61 8.64
abul-fm.qxd
2/28/02
9:11 AM
Page xiii
CONTENTS
8-10-3 Concepts of Head Ratio and Efficiency Ratio Due to Pumping Froth 8-11 Conclusion 8-12 Nomenclature 8-13 References
9 Positive Displacement Pumps 9-0 9-1 9-2 9-3 9-4 9-5 9-6 9-7 9-8 9-9
Introduction Solid Piston Pumps Plunger Pumps Diaphragm Piston Pumps Accessories for Piston and Plunger Pumps Peristaltic Pumps Rotary Lobe Slurry Pumps The Lockhopper Pump Conclusion References
10 Materials Science for Slurry Systems 10.0 Introduction 10-1 The Stress- Strain Relationship of Metals 10-2 Iron and Its Alloys for the Slurry Industry 10-2-1 Grey Iron 10-2-2 Ductile Iron 10.3 White Iron 10-3-1 Malleable Iron 10-3-2 Low-Alloy White Irons 10-3-3 Ni-Hard 10-3-4 High-Chrome–Molybdenum Alloys 10.4 Natural Rubbers 10-4-1 Natural Aashto 10-4-2 Pure Tan Gum 10-4-3 White Food-Grade Natural Rubber 10-4-4 Carbon-Black-Filled Natural Rubber 10-4-5 Carbon-Black- and Silicon-Filled Natural Rubber 10-4-6 Hard Natural Rubber/ Butadiene Styrene Compound Filled with Graphite 10-5 Synthetic Rubbers 10-5-1 Polychlorene (Neoprene) 10-5-2 Ethylene Propylene Terpolymer (EPDM) 10-5-3 Jade Green Armabond 10-5-4 Armadillo 10-5-5 Nitrile 10-5-6 Carboxylic Nitrile 10-5-7 Hypalon 10-5-8 Fluoro-elastomer (Viton) 10-5-9 Polyurethane 10-6 Wear Due to Slurries 10-7 Conclusion 10-8 References
xiii
8.68 8.72 8.72 8.75
9.1 9.1 9.1 9.6 9.8 9.13 9.13 9.14 9.15 9.16 9.17
10.1 10.1 10.1 10.3 10.3 10.4 10.4 10.4 10.5 10.5 10.6 10.11 10.12 10.12 10.12 10.13 10.13 10.13 10.13 10.14 10.15 10.15 10.15 10.15 10.17 10.17 10.18 10.18 10.18 10.21 10.22
abul-fm.qxd
2/28/02
9:11 AM
Page xiv
xiv
CONTENTS
11 Slurry Pipelines 11.0 11-1 11-2 11-3
11-4 11-5 11-6
11-7 11-8 11-9 11-10 11-11 11-12 11-13 11-14
Introduction Bauxite Pumping Gold Tailings Coal Slurries 11-3-1 Size of Coal Particles 11-3-2 Degradation of Coal During Hydraulic Transport 11-3-3 Coal–Magnetite Mixtures 11-3-4 Chemical Additions to Coal–Water Mixtures. 11-3-5 Coal–Oil Mixtures 11-3-6 Dewatering Coal Slurry 11-3-7 Ship Loading Coarse Coal 11-3-8 Combustion of Coal–Water Mixtures (CWM) 11-3-9 Pumping Coal Slurry Mixtures Limestone Pipelines Iron Ore Slurry Pipelines Phosphate and Phosphoric Acid Slurries 11-6-1 Rheology 11-6-2 Materials Selection for Phosphate 11-6-3 The Chevron Pipeline 11-6-4 The Goiasfertil Phosphate Pipeline 11-6-5 The Hindustan Zinc Phosphate Pipeline Copper Slurry and Concentrate Pipelines Clay and Drilling Muds Oil Sands Backfill Pipelines Uranium Tailings Codes and Standards for Slurry Pipelines Conclusion References
12 Feasibility Study for A Slurry Pipeline and Tailings Disposal System 12-0 12-1 12-2 12-3 12-4 12-5
12-6 12-7 12-8
Introduction Project Definition Rheology, Thickeners Performance, Pipeline Sizing Reclaim Water Pipeline Emergency Pond Tailings Dams 12-5-1 Wall Building by Spigotting 12-5-2 Deposition by Cycloning 12-5-2-1 Mobile Cycloning by the Upstream Method 12-5-2-2 Mobile Cycloning by the Downstream Method 12-5-2-3 Deposition by Centerline 12-5-2-4 Multicellular Construction Submerged Disposal 12-6-1 Subsea Deposition Techniques Tailings Dam Design Seepage Analysis of Tailings Dams
11.1 11.1 11.1 11.2 11.2 11.2 11.3 11.4 11.5 11.5 11.6 11.8 11.8 11.10 11.10 11.12 11.16 11.17 11.18 11.19 11.20 11.21 11.21 11.22 11.23 11.24 11.27 11.27 11.30 11.31
12.1 12.1 12.2 12.5 12.8 12.9 12.11 12.11 12.12 12.14 12.14 12.15 12.15 12.15 12.17 12.17 12.18
abul-fm.qxd
2/28/02
9:11 AM
Page xv
CONTENTS
12-9 12-10 12-11 12-12 12-13 12-14 12-15 12-16 12-17 12-18 12-19 12-20
Stability Analysis for Tailings Dams Erosion and Corrosion Hydraulics Pump Station Design Electric Power System Telecommunications Tailings Dam Monitoring Choke Stations and Impactors Establishing an Approach for Start-up and Shutdown Closure and Reclamation Plan Access and Service Roads Cost Estimates 12-20-1 Capital Costs 12-20-2 Operation Cost Estimates 12-21 Project Implementation Plan 12-22 Conclusion 12-23 References
xv
12.18 12.19 12.19 12.19 12.20 12.21 12.21 12.22 12.22 12.23 12.24 12.24 12.24 12.25 12.27 12.27 12.28
Appendix A Specific Gravity and Hardness of Minerals
A.1
Appendix B Units of Measurement
B.1
Index
I.1
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.1
PART ONE
HYDRAULICS OF SLURRY FLOWS
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.3
CHAPTER 1
GENERAL CONCEPTS OF SLURRY FLOWS
1-0 INTRODUCTION Slurry is essentially a mixture of solids and liquids. Its physical characteristics are dependent on many factors such as size and distribution of particles, concentration of solids in the liquid phase, size of the conduit, level of turbulence, temperature, and absolute (or dynamic) viscosity of the carrier. Nature offers examples of slurry flows such as seasonal floods that carry silt and gravel. Every year during the flood season, the Nile transports massive amounts of silt over thousands of miles to the Saharan desert. To rephrase Herodotus, who once said “Egypt is the gift of the Nile,” one may consider that one of the most ancient civilizations was dependent on natural slurry flows for its survival. Dredging is one of the most common and ancient processes involving slurry flows; the dredged materials contain a wide range of particles, tree debris, rocks, etc. Mining has employed the concept of slurry flows in pipelines since the mid-nineteenth century, when the technique was used to reclaim gold from placers in California. Long-distance slurry pipelines have evolved in all continents since the mid 1950s. Some slurry mixtures consist of very fine solids at high concentration, such as those in the copper concentrate pipelines of Escondida, Chile, and Bajo Alumbrera, Argentina. Other mixtures are based on coarse particles up to a size of 150 mm (6⬙), such as those pumped from fields of phosphate matrix. This chapter introduces some of the basic principles of slurry mixtures and flows. The slurry engineer has to appreciate the properties of the soil to be mined, dredged, or mixed with water. Original rock sizes, hardness, and plasticity play a major role in the selection of the equipment for crushing, milling, flotation, tailings disposal, or soil reclamation. Understanding sinking and critical speeds are essential when sizing the pipeline. A brief introduction to slurry flows in extractive metallurgy serves the purpose of focusing on the essentials of the application of slurry flows to engineering. Natural slurry flows, even in very dilute forms, can have negative effects on the environment if not properly managed. Some of the great dams of the world built in the twentieth century are starting to suffer from siltation. Behind such dams, large lakes are often man-made. The river flow is brought to a sufficiently slow speed for the silt to deposit at the bottom. Engineers in the twenty-first century will have to learn to manage the siltation of large man-made lakes using the science of dredging and piping slurry flows.
1.3
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
1.4
Page 1.4
CHAPTER ONE
1-1 PROPERTIES OF SOILS FOR SLURRY MIXTURES Slurry flows occur in nature in different ways. They are often associated with the transportation of silt from one region to another. Strong rains lead to soil erosion, mud slides, and the eventual drainage of slurries toward rivers. These are dilute slurries, in the sense that the soils mix naturally at a weight ratio of solids to liquids smaller than 15%. One very interesting river is the Nile. It may be said that during two months of the year it becomes a massive slurry flow. Torrential tropical rains over Lake Victoria in Uganda and Kenya are the source of the White Nile. Torrential tropical rains over the Ethiopian plateau are the source of the Blue Nile. On their way to the Sudan, both branches of this longest river in the world transport silt and soils. The White Nile seems to lose a lot of its water as it enters the swamps of the Bahr El Ghazal in Sudan. What is left of the White Nile joins the Blue Nile near Khartoum in Sudan. The Nile pursues its trip to the north and gradually enters the Saharan desert through Nubia and Egypt. As the flood season terminates, the silt transported by the Nile sediments by gravity. The silt has deposited for thousands of years, creating a narrow strip of rich farmland. Out of this silt grew the towns and states in Nubia and Egypt. The Pharaohs built an advanced civilization on the silt brought to them by the Nile’s natural slurry flows. The “gift of the Nile” was silt that would not have been deposited without a form of natural slurry flow. A simplified flow sheet (Figure 1-1) of the Nile illustrates this natural slurry flow. The steps in the process are: 앫 Water from the rains is the carrier liquid. 앫 The flow of water from the mountains of Uganda and Kenya moves fast enough during the flood season to scour the ground of silt and transport it in the form of a dilute slurry. (This is a step of slurry formation.)
torential rains
Uganda/Kenya
Sedimentation at Bahr El Ghazal
floods
rains
Ethiopia
The Saharan Desert
silt transported by the White Nile
floods
Nubia Sudan
Egypt
sedimentation by gravity of the silt after the flood (Egypt is the Gift of the Nile)
silt transported by the Blue Nile
FIGURE 1-1 There is no better example of the importance of slurry to civilization than the land of Egypt. For thousands of years, the Nile has transported massive quantities of silt over thousands of kilometers to cover by its floods a narrow stretch of land. From these silt layers, a civilization grew.
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.5
GENERAL CONCEPTS OF SLURRY FLOWS
1.5
앫 As the waters from the rains over the mountains of Uganda and Kenya join, they form the White Nile. (This step is natural hydrotransport.) 앫 As the White Nile enters the Bahr El Ghazal in Sudan, it spreads and stagnates, forming swamps. A nomadic life has long flourished around these swamps. (This step involves partial sedimentation by stagnation in the swamps.) 앫 In another region (in Ethiopia), rains form the Blue Nile. The flow of water from the mountains of Ethiopia move fast enough during the flood season to scour the ground of silt and transport it in the form of a dilute slurry. (This is another step of slurry formation.) 앫 The Blue and White Nile merge near Khartoum, Sudan, and continue their flow to the north. 앫 As the floods enter Nubia and Egypt, they overflow the banks of the Nile and transport speed of the slurry mixture drops. 앫 Sedimentation of silt occurs, with Egypt acting as a massive clarifier for the waters of the Nile, particularly at its delta with the Mediterranean Sea. (This step is natural gravity sedimentation.) For thousands of years the Pyramids and the Sphinx have stared at this immense natural slurry clarifier that is the Valley of the Nile in the middle of the Saharan Desert (Figure 12). Dredging is an important engineering activity in which gravel is moved in the form of slurry into a hopper on a specially constructed boat (Figure 1-4). A special pump is often used in a drag arm (Figure 1-3), and a special suction mouthpiece (Figure 1-5) is used at the tip of the drag arm. To complete dredging and form the slurry, it is essential to cut through the sand layers, rocks, and debris, using special cutters for sand (Figure 1-6a) and for rocks (Figure 1-6b) with very hard, replaceable blades. The composition of a slurry mixture depends on many factors such as particle size and distribution. Particles may be found in nature as soils or may be created by the processes of crushing, milling, and grinding. For applications such as dredging, natural soils are pumped without any crushing or grinding. For mining processes, an understanding of the physical properties of soils is essential for sizing equipment, crushing and milling, slurry preparation, mixing, and pumping (see Figure 1-7).
1-1-1 Classifications of Soils for Slurry Mixtures There are a variety of methods used to classify soils. Two main classes are: 1. Cohesive soils such as certain silts and clays with a median particle diameter smaller than 0.0625 mm (less than 0.0025 in, or mesh 250) 2. Noncohesive soils such as certain silts and clays with a median particle diameter larger than 0.0625 mm (larger than 0.0025 in, or mesh 250) For underwater dredging, the rock’s strength is determined by its core, and this property has a very important effect on the efficiency of dredging. Herbrich (1991) proposed a classification of soils in terms of unconfined compressive strength (see Table 1-1). The Permanent International Association of Navigation Congresses (1972) adopted a system of classification of soils, reviewed by Sargent (1984) and summarized in Tables
abul-1.qxd
1.6
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.6
CHAPTER ONE
FIGURE 1-2 For five thousand years, the Sphinx and the Pyramids have stared from the Gizeh plateau in the desert at history and at the Nile, which transforms itself every summer into a natural slurry transporter, bringing silt and life to the desert.
1-2, 1-3, and 1-4, that is recommended for use in dredging. In these tables, visual inspection is mentioned as a quick way to determine the nature of soils. This method does not relieve the engineer from the responsibility of conducting a proper size distribution test and rheology test before any design. The Standard D2488 of the American Society for Testing of Materials (ASTM) (1993) also offers a classification of soils, with a range of particle sizes as presented in Table 1-5. This standard is widely used in North America.
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.7
GENERAL CONCEPTS OF SLURRY FLOWS
hopper for solids
bottom of lake discharge pipe
pump
electric cable
drag arm column
FIGURE 1-3 Dredging boat and dredge arm.
FIGURE 1-4 Special dredger boat.
1.7
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.8
1.8
FIGURE 1-5 Works.
CHAPTER ONE
Suction mouthpiece for boat dredger. Courtesy of Mobile Pulley and Machine
1-1-2 Testing of Soils Various soil tests are recommended before mixing the soil with water in the early stages of designing a dredging or slurry transportation system. Particle size distribution should be established. Table 1-6 presents conversion factors between the three most common scales for measuring particle size. A number of tests are recommended to determine the dredgeability of soils and their behavior in placer mining or slurry mixing (Table 1-7). In nature, silts may be found in association with clays; thus, the parameters for both silts and clays should be assessed. The following testing parameters are accepted by the industry. Composition Tests 앫 Visual inspection: For the purpose of assessment of the rock mass. Such a test indicates the in situ state of the rock mass. Tests may be conducted in situ or under lab conditions in accordance with British Standard Institute Standard BS 5930 (1999). 앫 Section thickness test: A lab test conducted for the purpose of geotechnical identification and as a tool to determine mineral composition of the rock mass. 앫 Bulk density: Wet and dry tests are conducted under laboratory conditions to assess the weight and volume relationship. (International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mineral Sciences, 1979). 앫 Porosity: This is a calculation of voids as a percentage of total volume and is based on lab tests on bulk density. 앫 Carbonate content: This lab test should be conducted in accordance with American Society for Testing Materials (ASTM) Standard D3155 (1983) to measure lime content, particularly in limestone and chalks.
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.9
(a)
(b) FIGURE 1-6 (a) Special dredging sand cutter. The blades are replaceable. Courtesy of Mobile Pulley and Machine Works. (b) Special dredging rock cutter. Courtesy of Mobile Pulley and Machine Works. 1.9
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
1.10
Page 1.10
CHAPTER ONE
FIGURE 1-7 Mineral process plants can reject fairly coarse material that is left after crushing and milling mineral rocks. In this case, the coarse material is transported by piping in the form of a tailings slurry and used to build a tailings dam.
Strength, Hardness, and Stratification Tests 앫 Surface hardness: This lab test should be conducted to determine hardness in terms of the Mohr’s scale (from 0 for talc to 10 for diamonds). Appendix I presents a tabulation of density and Mohr hardness of minerals. The hardness of minerals is critical to the wear life of equipment associated with slurry flows. 앫 Uniaxial compression: This lab test measures ultimate strength under uniaxial stress. These tests should be done on fully saturated samples. The dimensions of the test sample and the directions of stratification influence stress direction. Cylinder samples
TABLE 1-1 Classification of Soils in Terms of Unconfined Compressive Strength. (After Herbrich, 1991) Unconfined compressive strength Characteristic Very weak Weak Moderately weak Moderately strong Strong Very strong Extremely strong
MPa
103 psi
< 1.25 1.25–5.0 5.0–12.5 12.5–50.0 50–100 100–200 > 200
< 0.145 0.15–0.73 0.73–1.8 1.8–7.3 7.3–14.6 14.6–29.2 > 29.2
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.11
1.11
GENERAL CONCEPTS OF SLURRY FLOWS
TABLE 1-2 Classification of Noncohesive Dredged Soils after the Permanent International Association of Navigation Congresses (1972, 1984) Type of soils
Identification of particle sizes mm
BS sieve units
Identification
Boulders and cobbles
> 200 60–200
6
Visual examination and measurement
Gravel
Fine 2–6 mm Medium 6–20 mm Coarse 20–80 mm
Fine No. 7—1–4 in Medium 1–4–3–4 in Coarse 3–4–3 in
Visual examination
Sands
Fine 0.06–0.2 mm Medium 0.2–0.6 mm Coarse 0.6–2 mm
Fine mesh 72–200 Visual Medium mesh 25–72 examination. No Coarse mesh 7–25 cohesion when dry
앫
앫 앫 앫 앫 앫 앫
Strength and structural properties
May be found loose in some fields, or in cemented beds, or may appear as weak conglomerate beds or hard packed gravel intermixed with sand Strength varies between compacted, loose and cemented. Homogeneous or stratified structures. Intermixture with silt or clay may produce hardpacked sands
should have a length-to-diameter ratio of 2:1, as per The International Society for Rock Mechanics (1978). Brazilian split: This is a lab test to measure strength as derived from uniaxial testing. This procedure is similar to the uniaxial compression test but with a different lengthto-diameter ratio. For further details, consult The International Society for Rock Mechanics (1977). Point load test: This is a quick lab test to measure strength. It should be conducted with the uniaxial compression test as described by Broch and Franklin (1972). Seismic velocity test: This field in situ test is conducted to check on the stratigraphy and fracturing of rock masses. It is useful for extrapolating field and lab measurements to rock mass behavior. Ultrasonic velocity test: This lab test is conducted on cores in the longitudinal direction. Static modulus of elasticity: This lab test measures stress/strain rate and gives an indication of the brittleness of rock. Drillability: This in situ test measures penetration rate, torque, feed force, fluid pressure, depth of layers, etc., and is used to establish the drill techniques and specification for placer mining or dredging. Angularity: This lab test is conducted to assess the shape of particles by visual inspection in accordance with British Standard Institute BS 812 (1999).
The expertise of a geologist is essential for mining or dredging large areas.
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.12
TABLE 1-3 Classification of Cohesive Natural Soils after the Permanent International Association of Navigation Congresses (1972, 1984) Identification of particle sizes
Type of soils
mm
BS sieve
Identification
Silts
Fine 0.002–0.006 Medium 0.006–0.02 Coarse 0.02–0.06
Passing No. 200
Individual particles are invisible. Wet lumps or coarse are visible. Determination by testing for dilatancy*. Silt can be dusted off fingers after drying and dry lumps are powdered by finger pressure
Clays
Finer than 0.002
N/A
Clays are very cohesive and are plastic without dilatancy. Moist samples stick to fingers with smooth, greasy touch. Dry lumps do not powder.
Strength and structural properties Coarse and sandy particles are nonplastic but similar characteristics to sands. Fine silts are plastic and similar to clays. They are often found in nature intermixed with sand and clay. They may be homogeneous or stratified and their consistency may vary from fluid silt to stiff silt or siltstone Strength
Shear strength
Very soft: may < 20kN/m2 be squeezed < 2.9 psi easily between fingers Soft: easily molded by fingers
20–40 kN/m2 2.9–5.8 psi
Clays shrink and crack by drying and develop high strength
Firm: requires 40–75 kN/m2 strong pressure 5.8–10.9 psi to mold by fingers
Structure of clays may be fissured, intact, homogeneous, stratified, or weathered.
Stiff: can not be molded by fingers, dent by thumbnail
75–150 kN/m2 10.9–21.8 psi
Hard: tough, intended with difficulty by thumbnail
Above 150 kN/m2 21.8 psi
*Dilatancy is a property exhibited by silt when shaken, and is due to high permeability of silt. When a moistened sample is shaken in the open hand, water appears on the surface, giving it a glossy appearance.
TABLE 1-4 Classification of Organic Soils after the Permanent International Association of Navigation Congresses (1972, 1984) Type of soils Peat and organic soils
Identification of particle sizes mm
BS sieve
Identification
N/A
N/A
It is generally identified as brown or black with a strong organic smell and contains wood and fibers.
1.12
Strength and structural properties It may be firm or spongy in nature and its strength is different in horizontal and vertical directions.
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.13
1.13
GENERAL CONCEPTS OF SLURRY FLOWS
1-1-3 Textures of Soils Granular soils are found in nature as a mixture of particles of different sizes. Two coefficients are used to express such texture: 1. The coefficient of curvature, Cc (equation 1-1) 2. The coefficient of uniformity, Cu (equation 1-2) D230 Cc = ᎏ (D60D10)
(1-1)
D60 Cu = ᎏ D10
(1-2)
Where D10, D30, and D60 are defined as the grain size at which 10%, 30%, and 60% of the soil is finer. According to Herbrich (1991) If 1 < Cc < 3, the grain size distribution will be smooth If Cu > 4 for gravels then there is a wide range of sizes If Cu > 6 for sands then there is a wide range of sizes Alternatively, the soil is said to contain very little fines and is well graded.
1-1-4 Plasticity of Soils For clays and silts, an additional test for the liquid limit (LL) and the plastic limit (PL) are recommended. The liquid limit is defined as the moisture content in soil above which it starts to act as a liquid and below which it acts as a plastic. To conduct a test, a sample of clay is thoroughly mixed with water in a brass cup. The number of bumps required to close a groove cut in the pot of clay in the cup is then measured. This test is called the Atterberg test. The plastic limit is defined as the limit below which the clay will stop behaving as a plastic and will start to crumble. To measure such a limit, a sample of the soil is formed into a tubular shape with a diameter of 3.2 mm (0.125 in) and the water content is measured when the cylinder ceases to roll and becomes friable.
TABLE 1-5 Range of Particle Sizes of Soils According to ASTM D2488 (1993) Material Boulders Cobbles Coarse gravel Fine gravel Coarse sand Medium sand Fine sand Silts and clays
Range of sizes in mm > 300 75–300 19–75 4.75–19 2.00–4.75 0.43–2.00 0.08–0.43 < 0.075
Range of sizes in inches > 12 3–12 0.75–3 0.019–0.75 0.08–0.0188 0.017–0.08 0.003–0.017 < 0.003
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.14
TABLE 1-6 Conversion between Scales of Particle Size U.S. no.
2.5 3 3.5 4 5 6 7
Tyler mesh
2.5 3 3.5 4 5 6 7
Sieve opening (micrometers)
Sieve opening (inches)
Grade of soils Screen shingle gravel
26670 22430 18850 15850 13330 11200 9423 7925 6680 5613 4699 3962 3327 2794
3 2 1.50 1.050 0.883 0.742 0.624 0.525 0.441 0.371 0.321 0.263 0.221 0.185 0.156 0.131 0.110
8 9 10 12
8 9 10 12
2362 1981 1651 1397
0.093 0.078 0.065 0.055
Very coarse sand
14 16 20 24
14 16 20 24
1168 991 833 701
0.046 0.039 0.0328 0.0276
Coarse sand
28 32 35 42 50
28 32 35 42 50
589 495 417 351 297
0.0232 0.0195 0.0164 0.0138 0.0117
Medium sand
60 70 80 100 120 140
60 70 80 100 120 140
250 210 177 149 125 105
0.01 0.0823 0.07 0.06 0.05 0.041
Fine sand
170 200 230
170 200 250 270
88 74 63 53
0.034 0.029 0.025 0.02
Silt
325 400 500 625 1250 2500 12500
43 38 25 20 10 5 1
0.017 0.015 0.01 0.008 0.004 0.002 0.0004
Pulverized silt
<12500
<1
<0.0004 1.14
Mud
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.15
GENERAL CONCEPTS OF SLURRY FLOWS
1.15
TABLE 1-7 Testing Parameters on Soils to Determine Dredgeability, Suitability for Placer Mining, or Slurry Preparation Type of soil
Testing parameters
Sand
Density Water content Specific gravity of grains Grain size Water permeability Frictional properties Lime content Organic content
Silt
Density Water content Water permeability Shear strength or sliding resistance Plasticity Lime content Organic content
Clay
Density Water content Sliding resistance Consistency ranges (plasticity) Organic content
Peat
Same parameters as clay
Gravel
Same parameters as sand
The difference between the liquid and plastic limits is defined as the plasticity index: PI = LL – PL
(1-3)
1-2 SLURRY FLOWS A slurry mixture is essentially a mixture of a carrying fluid and solid particles held in suspension. The most commonly used fluid is water, but over the years, attempts have been made to use crude oils with milled coal, and even air in pneumatic conveying. The flow of slurry in a pipeline is much different from the flow of a single-phase liquid. Theoretically, a single-phase liquid of low absolute (or dynamic) viscosity can be allowed to flow at slow speeds from a laminar flow to a turbulent flow. However, a twophase mixture, such as slurry, must overcome a deposition critical velocity or a viscous transition critical velocity. The analogy can be made here in terms of an airplane: if the speed drops excessively, the airplane stalls and stops flying. If the slurry’s speed of flow is not sufficiently high, the particles will not be maintained in suspension. On the other hand, in the case of highly viscous mixtures, if the shear rate in the pipeline is excessively low, the mixture will be too viscous and will resist flow. Sections 1-2-1 and 1-2-2 define the two basic slurry flows.
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.16
1.16
CHAPTER ONE
1-2-1 Homogeneous Flows Solids are uniformly distributed throughout the liquid carrier. An example of homogeneous flows is copper concentrate slurry after undergoing a process of grinding and thickening. Particles are then very fine and the mixture is at a high concentration (50–60% by weight). As the concentration of particles is increased (beyond 40% by weight for many slurries), the mixture becomes more viscous and develops non-Newtonian properties. Apart from rich concentrate slurries, drilling mud, sewage sludge, and fine limestone (cement kiln feed slurry) behave as homogeneous flows. Typical particle sizes for homogeneous mixtures are smaller than 40 m to 70 m (325–200 mesh), depending on the density of the solids. The presence of clays in certain circuits must not be ignored. If clay is not separated, the slurry can be quite viscous. Pumps and pipes must be sized properly to handle the resultant absolute (or dynamic) viscosity. Certain mines in Peru contain material called soft high clay, which can increase the absolute (or dynamic) viscosity of the slurry up to 400 mPa at weight concentrations in excess of 45%. Dilution to lower concentration and changes to recycling load are solutions to such a problem.
1-2-2 Heterogeneous Flows In a heterogeneous flow, solids are not uniformly mixed in the horizontal plane. A gradient of concentration exists in the vertical plane. Dunes or a sliding bed may form in the pipe, with the heavier particles at the bottom and the lighter ones in suspension, particularly at the critical deposition velocity. The different phases retain their properties and the largest particles do not necessarily cause the biggest problems; it really depends on the ratio that they are mixed with finer particles. Heterogeneous slurries are encountered in many placer mining, phosphate rock mining, and dredging applications. Concentration of particles remains low, typically less than 25% by weight in many dredging applications and below 35% by weight in many tailing disposal applications. Heterogeneous flows require a minimum carrier velocity. In some tailing applications of the Taconite mines of Minnesota, the typical deposition velocity is in excess of 3.4–4 m/s (11–13 ft/s). Nature being complex, flows are encountered that have the characteristics of heterogeneous or homogeneous flows. The concept of pseudohomogeneous flows is also used when a large fraction of particles are fine but there remain a sufficient fraction of coarse particles that may deposit as the flow speed is reduced below a minimum value.
1-2-3 Intermediate Flow Regimes Intermediate regimes occur when some of the particles are homogeneously distributed and others are heterogeneously distributed. Intermediate regime flows include tailings from mineral processing plants and a wide range of industrial slurries.
1-2-4 Flows of Emulsions Strictly speaking, an emulsion is not slurry. An emulsion is a mixture of two phases at certain temperatures resulting in an essentially homogeneous flow. An example of an emulsion is a mixture of bitumen at 70% by volume with water at 30% by volume. If sur-
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.17
GENERAL CONCEPTS OF SLURRY FLOWS
1.17
factants are used, the bitumen remains well mixed with water in a certain temperature range. Emulsions can become unstable under certain high shear rates or through very tight clearances of pumps according to Nunez et al. (1996). In the 1990s, PDVSA-BITOR constructed a 300 km (188 mi) pipeline in Venezuela with a diameter of 660–915 mm (26–36 in) for transporting their ORIMULSION fuel, a mixture of highly concentrated bitumen and water. The fuel is a substitute for coal in thermal plants. Emulsions do not encounter the deposition velocity of slurries, but as flows become unstable, fine droplets of heavy oils or bitumen may coalesce into larger ones, causing changes of flow.
1-2-5 Flows of Emulsions—Slurry Mixtures A mixture of an emulsion and solids such as fine coal could be used to produce a fluid with a high calorific value. Coal must be very fine to burn readily in combustion furnaces. The flow is similar to a homogeneous flow with a high absolute (or dynamic) viscosity component.
1-3 SINKING VELOCITY OF PARTICLES AND CRITICAL VELOCITY OF FLOW Various parameters of speed determine whether a mixture may separate or continue to flow. In fact, the designer of a thickener or a mixer is often more interested in the sinking velocity of particles. On the other hand, the designer of a pipeline has to pay attention to the critical velocity of flow, settling speed, and whether the flow is vertical or horizontal, particularly in the case of heterogeneous flows.
1-3-1 Sinking or Terminal Velocity of Particles This is the minimum speed needed to maintain particles in suspension, particularly in a process of mixing or thickening. This velocity is not identical with the critical velocity of flow, and should not be confused with it. Table 1-8 presents examples of sinking velocity of various soils. The designer of a mixing system or a thickener is encouraged to conduct lab tests, since clays may be mixed with sands in some areas, or the soil may be stratified, with layers of different materials.
1-3-2 Critical Velocity of Flows In Chapters 3, 4, and 5 the mechanics of solid suspensions are described in detail. An important parameter to introduce in this chapter is the critical velocity of a slurry flow. Figure 1-8 plots the pressure loss per unit length on the y-axis, versus the velocity V of a slurry flow on the x-axis. Five points are shown for flow at a constant volume concentration. For this slurry of moderate viscosity, the flow is stationary and the solids clog the pipeline below point 1. There is insufficient speed to move the particles. As the flow is accelerated, the speed reaches point 1, which is called the deposition critical velocity VD, or minimum speed to start the flow. Between points 1 and 2, the bed builds up, dunes form, and the different phases are well separated. Between points 2 and 3 the flow is streaking but
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.18
1.18
CHAPTER ONE
TABLE 1-8 Sinking Velocity of Soil Particles (after Sulzer Pumps, 1998, with permission of Elsevier) Particle diameter, Mesh size, micrometers US fine
Pressure drop per unit of length
0.2 0.6 1 2 5 6 20 50 60 100 200 250 300 500 600 1000 2000
Soil grain size identification Sinking velocity, m/s
Sinking velocity, ft/s
3 × 10–8 2.8 × 10–7 7 × 10–6 9.2 × 10–6 17 × 10–6 25 × 10–6 28 × 10–5 17 × 10–4 25 × 10–4 0.07 0.021 0.026 0.032 0.053 0.063 0.10 0.17
270 230 150 70 60 35 30 18 10
Grain size by ASTM
Fine clay Coarse clay
Silt
Fine silt
Fine sand
Coarse silt Intermediate silt to sand Fine sand Medium coarse sand
Coarse sand Coarse sand Very coarse sand
slurry
4-5 Pseudohomogeneous
5
3-4 Jumping and rolling
4
2-3 Streaking
3 1
1-2 Bedding
2
wa
Grain size, international
Clay
ter
y/D concentration
Below 1 Stationary and clogging
Speed of flow FIGURE 1-8 Pressure drop versus velocity for water and for a slurry mixture. (After Sulzer Pumps, 1998, with permission of Elsevier.)
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.19
GENERAL CONCEPTS OF SLURRY FLOWS
1.19
momentum is building up. Between points 3 and 4, there is sufficient speed to cause jumping and rolling of the coarse particles. Above point 4, the speed is sufficiently high to allow a pseudohomogeneous flow in which the fine particles act as a carrier for the coarse particles. These stages are extensively reviewed in Chapter 4. When absolute (or dynamic) viscosity is an important factor, such as in clayish slurries or homogeneous flows, another parameter, the viscous transition critical velocity VT must be determined. There are two regimes for flow of homogeneous mixtures. Flow at speeds less than VT is associated with laminar flows, whereas flows above VT are characteristic of turbulent flows. Flow in the laminar regime is often characterized by a friction loss factor, which is 64/Re for the Darcy factor or 16/Re for the Fanning factor (this topic will be discussed in more details in Chapter 2). As a result, the losses in the laminar regime appear to be a linear function of speed, whereas in the turbulent regime they are proportional to the square of the speed. As we will see in Chapter 5, researchers have struggled with special definitions of a modified Reynolds number for non-Newtonian flows. Emulsions have been pumped over long distances in laminar flow. Nunez et al. (1996) demonstrates the existence of certain effects similar to comminution, i.e., breakup of large droplets into finer ones, as well as coalescence of small particles into larger ones under different flow regimes, shear rates, and constraints. A question often asked is what the relationship between the sinking speed (as per Table 1-8) and the deposition of critical velocity VD? This question comes up when the rheology laboratory produces the results of thickening tests, and when there is not enough money or time to conduct proper slurry loop tests. This point will be examined in Chapter 4 and various approaches have been adopted over the years, from the simplest assumption that the critical deposition velocity is 17 times as large as the terminal or sinking velocity, to more complex mathematical formulae. Often in a lab test, the coarse particles deposit rapidly while the fine particles are still in suspension. Proper pump tests are often recommended, particularly when a multimillion dollar pipeline is being designed. Tests can be conducted at a number of universities, provincial and state research centers, or with the help of manufacturers of slurry pumps. Examples include the Saskatchewan Science Research Center in Canada; the GIW research lab of KSB Pumps (USA), described by Wilson et al. (1992); the Slurry Research Lab of Mazdak International Inc. (U.S.A.); Texas A&M University (U.S.A.); and Melbourne University (Australia), among others.
1-4 DENSITY OF A SLURRY MIXTURE The density of a slurry mixture is a function of 앫 The density of the carrier fluid 앫 The density of the solid particles 앫 The concentration by volume of the solid phase The density of the solid particles is determined carefully by various experimental methods. Fine particles tend to entrap air, which the lab technician must remove by proper agitation or by adding a small quantity of wetting agent. Some materials exhibit a change of packing abilities and therefore density as a function of particle size. If the solids are to be passed through a comminution process, a SAG (semiautogeneous), or ball mill, they can occupy more volume per unit mass as they be-
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.20
1.20
CHAPTER ONE
come finer. The slurry engineer is therefore encouraged to measure the solid’s density at the proposed size of particles to be transported in slurry form. Certain errors can occur in evaluating the density of solids with heterogeneous mixtures. If the heavier slurry particles settle out and a sample is taken, it may reflect a greater density of finer particles. Due to these possible sources of error, the engineer is encouraged to measure the density of the slurry mixture after proper mixing, and to use the data on concentration by weight or by volume to work back to the density of the solids. The density of a slurry mixture is expressed as 100 m = ᎏᎏᎏ Cw/s + (100 – Cw)/L
(1-4)
where Cw = concentration by weight m = density of the mixture phase l = density of the liquid phase s = density of the solid phase Engineers use the term concentration by weight, as it is easier to convert back into the total tonnage of solids to be transported through a pipeline or across an extractive metallurgy plant. However, the characteristics of the mixture, the mechanics of flow, and the resultant physical properties are more related to the concentration by volume. The concentration by volume of solids in a mixture is expressed as Cwm 100 Cw/s Cv = ᎏ = ᎏᎏᎏ s Cw/s + (100 – Cw)/L
(1-5)
The concentration by weight of solids in a mixture is expressed as Cvs Cvs Cv = ᎏ = ᎏᎏ m Cvs + (100 – Cv)
(1-6)
Example 1-A A pipeline is designed to transport 140 metric ton (308,000 lb) of sand per hour. The specific gravity of the sand particles is 2.65 (or the density is 2650 kg/m3). The concentration by weight is 30%. Determine the density of the mixture if the carrier fluid is water and determine the resultant flow rate. 앫 Weight of sand in the mixture over a period of 1 hr is 140 metric ton (308,000 lb) 앫 Weight of equivalent volume of water equivalent to the sand content is 140,000 kg/2,650 kg/m3 = 52,800 앫 Weight of water in the slurry mixture at a concentration of 30% by weight = 140,000 kg (100 – 30)/30 or 326,600 kg 앫 Total weight of slurry mixture transported in 1 hr is the sum of the weight of water and sand or 140,000 + 326,600 = 466,600 kg/hr 앫 Total weight of equivalent volume of water is 326,000 + 52,800 = 378,800 kg or 378 m3 of liquid, since density of water is 1000 kg/m3 The density of the slurry mixture is therefore 466,600 kg/378 m3 = 1,230 kg/m3. Alternatively, the specific gravity of the slurry compared to water is 1.23. The flow rate, being the volume per unit of time, is equivalent to 378 m3/hr.
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.21
GENERAL CONCEPTS OF SLURRY FLOWS
1.21
1-5 DYNAMIC VISCOSITY OF A NEWTONIAN SLURRY MIXTURE Although density is essentially a static property, absolute (or dynamic) viscosity is a dynamic property and tends to reduce in magnitude as the shear rate in a pipeline increases. Thus, engineers have had to define different forms of viscosity over the years, everything from dynamic viscosity, to kinematic viscosity, to effective pipeline viscosity. The effective pipeline viscosity will be discussed in detail in Chapters 3, 4, and 5. In this chapter, the reader is introduced to basic concepts of the mixture of slurry in a stationary state. This is effectively what the pump, or a mixer, might see at the start-up of a plant. As is often the case, when the driver cannot deliver enough torque to overcome the absolute (or dynamic) viscosity, the operator is forced to dilute the slurry mixture. Plasticity as defined in Section 1-1-4 is an important parameter in determining overall absolute (or dynamic) viscosity of a mixture of clay and water. There are, however, numerous soils in nature, such as sand and water or gravel and water, in which the solids contribute little to the overall absolute (or dynamic) viscosity, except in terms of their concentration by volume.
1-5-1 Absolute (or Dynamic) Viscosity of Mixtures with Volume Concentration Smaller Than 1% For such solid–liquid mixtures in diluted form, Einstein developed the following formula for a linear relationship between absolute (or dynamic) viscosity and volume concentration:
m ᎏ = 1 + 2.5 L
(1-7)
where m = absolute (or dynamic) viscosity of the slurry mixture L = absolute (or dynamic) viscosity of the carrying liquid This is a very simple equation that is based on the following assumptions: 앫 Particles are fairly rigid 앫 The mixture is fairly dilute and there is no interaction between the particles Such a flow is not encountered, except in laminar regimes of very dilute concentrations (below a volume concentration of 1%).
1-5-2 Absolute (or Dynamic) Viscosity of Mixtures with Solids with Volume Concentration Smaller than 20% Thomas (1965) took the equation of Einstein further by calculating for higher volumetric concentrations of Newtonian mixtures:
m ᎏ = 1 + K1 + K22 + K33 + K44 + . . . L where K1, K2, K3, and K4 are constants
(1-8)
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.22
1.22
CHAPTER ONE
K1 is the Einstein constant of 2.5 (from Equation 1-7), and K2 has been found to be in the range of 10.05–14.1 according to Guth and Simha (1936). It is difficult to extrapolate the higher terms K3 and K4 in Equation 1-8. They are ignored with volumetric concentrations smaller than 20%.
1-5-3 Absolute (or Dynamic) Viscosity of Mixtures with High Volume Concentration of Solids For higher concentrations, Thomas (1965) proposed the following equation with an exponential function:
m ᎏ = 1 + K1 + K22 + A exp(B) L
(1-9)
where K2 = 10.05 A = 0.00273 B = 16.6 Figure 1-9 is based on Equation 1-9 and is widely accepted in the slurry industry for heterogeneous mixtures of a Newtonian rheology.
1-6 SPECIFIC HEAT Thomas (1960) derived an equation for the specific heat of a mixture as a function of the specific heat of the liquid and solid phases: CpmCws + CpmCwL Cpm= ᎏᎏ 100
(1-10)
1-7 THERMAL CONDUCTIVITY AND HEAT TRANSFER Thermal conductivity is difficult to measure, as solids may settle during the test. Sometimes it is recommended to apply a small quantity of gel to maintain the solids in suspension. Orr and Dalla Valle (1954) derived the following equation for the thermal conductivity of slurry mixtures: 2kl + ks – 2(kl – ks) km = kl ᎏᎏᎏ 2kl + ks – 2(kl + ks)
冢
where k = thermal conductivity and subscripts l = liquid m = mixture s = solids.
冣
(1-11)
L m 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
CV Volumetric concentration of solids
10 12 14 16 18 20 22 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39 42 43 44
CV [%] 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65
m
L
8.950 9.932 11.07 12.40 13.94 15.75 17.86 20.33 23.22 26.62 30.61 35.29 40.80 47.28 54.91 63.89 74.47 86.94 101.63 118.95 139.4
FIGURE 1-9 Ratio of viscosity of mixture versus viscosity of carrier in accordance with the Thomas equation for coarse slurries.
Page 1.23
viscosity of carrier liquid
80
L
9:12 AM
3 5 7
90
m 1.029 1.089 1.156 1.233 1.365 1.465 1.575 1.696 1.83 1.978 2.142 2.426 2.649 2.907 3.210 3.573 4.017 4.570 5.273 6.734 7.37 8.103
2/28/02
Ratio of viscosity of slurry mixture vs.
abul-1.qxd
CV[%] 1
100
1.23
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
1.24
Page 1.24
CHAPTER ONE
Metzner et al. (1959, 1960) published articles on heat transfer for slurries. The applications for heat transfer problems have been confined to the nuclear industry, the processing of tar sands, feeding slurry to autoclaves for thermal processing, or certain emulsionbased slurries.
1-8 SLURRY CIRCUITS IN EXTRACTIVE METALLURGY It would be beyond this book to discuss the principles of extractive metallurgy. Slurry is a very important component in the processing of ores to the final disposal of tailings and shipping of concentrate. Chapter 7 is dedicated to equipment for slurry processing. There are three main processes used for extractive metallurgy: 1. Hydrometallurgy, which implies processing the ore using a liquid medium 2. Electrometallurgy, which involves the application of electric and electro-chemical processes to extract the ore 3. Pyrometallurgy, which involves the use of heat (roasting, smelting, etc.) for processing the ore The most common minerals of high metric tonnage (iron, aluminum, copper, titanium, nickel, chromium, magnesium, zinc, etc.) are found in nature as oxides and sulfides and as a combination of both. Ores are sometimes a mixture of rich metal composition and poorer compositions called gangue. The gangue can be acidic or alkaline, and determines the type of flux used for pyrometallurgy. Since ores come in all levels of complexity, various methods of processing have been developed over the years. The first process ore undergoes is called classification or ore dressing. The purpose here is to separate the richer components of a mixture from the unuseful soils. Mineral processing may be used to produce a single stream, as is the case with taconite circuits, where iron extraction is the main activity. It may also create two streams, such as copper concentrate and gold concentrate, when both minerals are found in the same ore body . Mineral processing is usually undertaken at the mine. Its purpose is to separate some of the gangue before shipment of a concentrate. The concentrate is richer in the desired mineral than the original soil.
1-8-1 Crushing In Figure 1-10, a block diagram for crushing and grinding is presented. These are two of the fundamental steps taken to start a slurry circuit. Large rocks are first crushed to an acceptable size. Depending on the type of equipment used, crushing may be done in a single step to feed a semiautogeneous mill, or in three steps (primary, secondary, and tertiary crushing). Rocks are transported from one crusher to another by conveying in a dry form. Their initial size of 300–600 mm (1–2 ft) is reduced to 100–150 mm (4–6 in). Jaw, gyrator, and cone crushers are commonly used during these stages. The crushed material is transported by conveyors to a storage area called the stockpile. From the stockpile, crushed rocks are transported to the grinding and milling circuit.
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.25
1.25
GENERAL CONCEPTS OF SLURRY FLOWS
stockpile
Primary Crusher
Secondary Crusher
Tertiary Crusher
Crushing
Ore <2% metal
stockpile solids
slurry
een scr cyclones
tank
Lake
Tailings Dam
FIGURE 1-10
fines
Flotation Cells
Electrostatic Separators
Water Ball Mill
Ball Mill
Tailings pipes 30-40% solids
Reclaim Water
cyclones Ball or Pebble Mill
Rod Mill
fines
Magnetic Separators
slurry
Gravity Separators
Milling and Grinding
Autogeneous Mill
Classification
water
wells
Ri ve r
abul-1.qxd
Crushing and milling are the starting points of a slurry system.
1-8-2 Milling and Primary Grinding Milling and primary grinding serve the purpose of reducing the size of particles from 100–150 mm (⬇ 4–6 in) down to less than 6 mm (⬇ 1–4 in). This is done by using steel or ceramic balls and rods in rotating cylindrical and conical mills. If the process has undergone primary, secondary, and tertiary crushing, a process of screening is undertaken to separate the very coarse from finer particles. The particles are then further reduced in size by milling in rod mills with the addition of water. The still dilute slurry is transported to a ball mill where steel balls achieve further reduction in size. The mixture of slurry and steel balls undergoes a separation at the exit from the ball mill (by using the difference in momentum between the two materials). Slurry is then diverted into a pump box, which is connected to slurry pumps. The slurry is pumped to cyclones, where the coarse particles are further separated from the fine particles. In the last 20 years, efforts have been made to eliminate secondary and tertiary crushing, by feeding the material directly to an autogenous or a semiautogenous mill (SAG mill). The technology has evolved in size. Today, a single line featuring a SAG mill and two ball mills can handle 65,000 metric tons (short tons) per day. An example of a single line plant is the concentrator of ASARCO in Ray, Arizona (USA). In the 1990s, SIEMENS and ABB introduced the concept of the wrap-around motor,
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
1.26
Page 1.26
CHAPTER ONE
which helped eliminate complicated gearboxes for SAG mills. Some of the largest SAG mills are now built with a diameter of 12.2 m (40 ft). The process of crushing is essentially a dry process but the process of milling is a wet process in which slurry comes to play an important role. The use of water eliminates the dangerous generation of dust associated with dry grinding. It is not possible to undertake milling or wet grinding in a single step. The slurry is recirculated as follows. Initially, the coarse and fine particles are separated through a coarse screen or a special cyclone. Then the coarse particles are returned to the SAG mill and the intermediate sized particles are sent to the ball mill. The fine sized particles are taken from the cyclone overflow to a magnetic separation, electrostatic separation, or flotation plant. It is therefore not uncommon to recirculate 250–350% of the feedstock through the circuit of grinding and milling. Attention should be paid to the presence of clays in the ore, and associated dynamic viscosity. Flow from the ball mills can reach a concentration of 40–50% by weight and certain non-Newtonian rheology may manifest itself. Over the years, a plant that started in rocky ground may encounter more clay as it proceeds into deeper depths.
1-8-3 Classification This is essentially a process to separate the particles according to their sinking rates in water. Wet classifiers are used with grinding and may include rubber-lined or ceramic cyclones (called hydrocyclones) and spiral mechanical classifiers. The principle of the cyclone is to feed the slurry tangentially and force it to rotate. By centrifugal forces, the coarser particles sink to the bottom of the cone while the finer particles float to the top. Both streams separate. The underflow, which consists of coarse material, and the overflow, which consists of fines, are then directed to other circuits. The underflow is fed back to the ball mills and the overflow is directed to the flotation circuit or other types of separators. The spiral mechanical classifier is used in pools. The heavier particles are allowed to settle in the pool while the finer particles float and flow out of the pool. The heavier particles are then removed from the bottom of the pool with a spiral or mechanical device. From cyclones or from the grinding circuit, the slurry may pass through different types of separators such as flotation circuits, electrostatic separators, and magnetic separators. Their purpose is to separate by chemical, electrical, or magnetic forces the minerals from the gangue. These steps occur before further thickening prior to feeding the pipeline. The gangue is diverted to tailings circuits (see Figure 1-11).
1-8-4 Concentration and Separation Circuits After a considerable effort to reduce the sizes of particles, it is important to separate the richer soils from the slimes or gangue. This step is achieved by using the properties of the ore itself. Gravity devices work on the principle that the ore (such as gold or diamonds) is heavier than the gangue. These devices include shaking units, the classic miner’s pan, rocking cradle devices, or more sophisticated gold concentrators or mineral sand concentrators. The drawback of these systems is that they may not necessarily be able to treat the fine particles produced by grinding and milling. In diamond extraction plants, X-ray machines are used in conjunction with gravity separation to detect the diamonds. Gravity devices are also used in a number of dry processes as well as slurry processes
abul-1.qxd 2/28/02
Crushing, grinding, milling (see fig 1- 10)
Electrostatic Separators
Ma gnetic Separators
9:12 AM
Flotation Cells
Gravity Separators
wells
Lake
Ri ve
r
Tailings Dam
Tailings pipes 30-40% solids
tailings thickener Reclaim Water
Page 1.27
minerals
gangue
tank
concentrate thickener
tailings sump
concentrate at about 20% mineral slurry pipeline
reclaim water
filtering drying smelting burning
1.27
FIGURE 1-11 Block for thickening and disposal of tailings, used as the basis for the design of slurry concentrate and fi 1diagram 11 tailings pipelines.
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
1.28
Page 1.28
CHAPTER ONE
for mineral sand and placer mining. In the case of mineral sands, the presence of a wide range of heavy oxides allows the miner to separate the various components by using gravity in conjunction with the magnetic or electrostatic properties. Magnetic devices are especially useful, since iron is one of the most common minerals and it is possible to separate iron oxides from gangue by applying a magnet. This is usually done by introducing the slurry over a rotating drum, as shown in Figure 1-12; the drum picks up the magnetic concentrate while the remaining soils are diverted away by the flow of the remaining slurry. Magnetic devices are common in taconite processing plants, iron ore plants, as well as in mineral sand plants. Electrostatic devices were developed in Australia to process beach and mineral sands. The sand ore is fed to a conducting and grounding rotor and is exposed to ionization. The particles, which have certain electrostatic properties, are attracted by the electric charge and are separated from the other particles. The nonconducting particles drop on the rotor and are brushed away into a separate container (Figure 1-13). Flotation devices use the principle of flotation to separate particles that are wettable from other particles. This is a very common process with sulfides but is less efficient with oxides. The cyclone overflow or the fine particles in the slurry after undergoing milling and grinding are fed to a series of flotation tanks (or a flotation machine). An agitator provides vigorous mixing. Air is introduced from a separate compressor line and chemical reagents are added to create froth. The nonwettable minerals float on top of the froth and are pumped away by froth-handling pumps or scraped away by mechanical devices. The wettable particles, such as the gangue, do not float on top of the froth and sink to the bottom of the tank. Special tailing pumps may then pump away the gangue, sometimes for further grinding and processing (particularly gangue from the first flotation tank) and sometimes to the final tailing box (see Figure 1.14). The process of froth generation and flotation is more efficient when carried out in steps. A series of up to six tanks may be constructed to drop gradually, with launders in between. Without reagents, only graphite or molybdenum would be nonwettable. Reagents have been produced by the industry for different grades of sulfides, to depress or activate the extraction of certain minerals, to control pH, etc.
rotating magnet
Feed
Magnetic concentrate
Other soils
FIGURE 1-12 A drum-type magnetic separator. The drum is sometimes replaced by a magnetic belt on a special table.
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.29
1.29
GENERAL CONCEPTS OF SLURRY FLOWS
Feed Nonionizing electrode fine-wire electrode ionizing Conductors concentrate
Nonconductor soils FIGURE 1-13
An electrostatic separator.
The secondary grinding that is applied to the underflow of the circuits from flotation is useful for extracting secondary ores, and has been applied successfully in copper–gold ores for further extraction of the gold. A mineral process plant includes gravity flows from hydrocyclones to ball mills and pumped flows from SAG mills to hydrocyclones. A good plant layout must allow space for repairs and long bends, and provide the ability to join and split flows. The use of three dimensional computer modeling is a very useful tool for the design engineer to determine the slope of launders and physical constraints to the layout of the plant (Figure 1-15)
froth bubbles with mineral concentrate
aeration agitator pump
secondary grinding FIGURE 1-14 A flotation circuit.
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
1.30
9:12 AM
Page 1.30
CHAPTER ONE
1-8-5 Piping the Concentrate From these processes of classification, a concentrate is obtained. The slurry can be further thickened or dewatered using thickeners to a concentration of 50–60% by weight. The concentrate can then be pumped for hundreds of kilometers to a port from which it can be shipped to a pyrometallurgy plant. At the port, a filtering plant can provide further dewatering. Long pipelines are used to transport concentrate. At Cuajone, in Peru, an open launder is used to transport tailings from an altitude of 3000 m (10,000 ft) down to sea level. The potential energy drop is used to overcome the friction losses of the launder. In Escondida, Chile, copper concentrate flows by gravity from an altitude in excess of 2500 m (8200 ft) above sea level over a distance in excess of 200 km (125 mi) to a port at sea level. Thus, in a typical copper extraction process the rocks are reduced to very fine particles through vertimills, semiautogeneous mills, and ball mills. Further separation occurs through flotation circuits and grinding.
1-8-6 Disposal of the Tailings Once the concentrated ore has been extracted, the plant is left with the sands and slimes. These are dewatered to an acceptable concentration by weight of 35–45%. Using thicken-
FIGURE 1-15 Three-dimensional computer representation of a grinding circuit with one central SAG mill, a ball mill on each side, hydrocyclones at the top left, and pumps (at the floor level). Courtesy of Hatch & Associates, Vancouver, Canada.
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:12 AM
Page 1.31
GENERAL CONCEPTS OF SLURRY FLOWS
1.31
ers, the flow separates into clarified water that is returned to the plant for use in the milling and grinding circuits, and into an underflow of concentrated tailings. The underflow from the tailings is then pumped away to a large disposal pond, called a tailings dam. The sand sinks to the bottom of the tailings pond and the water from the top is returned back to the plant for further use. During the process of disposing of the tailings, spigots and other devices are used to separate coarse from fine particles at the discharge point; the coarse particles are used to build the beaches or the wall of the dam. Dams have been built up to a height of 200 m (656 ft). The environmental engineer must make sure that no dangerous chemicals seep through the ground. If the tailings contain dangerous substances, a plastic or clay (which tends to create a seal) lining for the pond may be recommended to prevent seepage. Some dangerous collapses of tailing dams have been reported over the years, with detrimental consequences when they contained cyanide products, as in the case of certain gold mines. The technology used in tailing pumps has improved. The casings can be designed to withstand 6.9 MPa (1000 psi) of pressure. However, these are essentially single-stage centrifugal pumps installed in series. Up to seven pumps have been installed in series in mines such as National Steel in Minnesota and Kelian Gold in Indonesia.
1-9 CLOSED AND OPEN CHANNEL FLOWS, PIPELINES VERSUS LAUNDERS The reader will find that over the years the majority of references on slurry flows have focused on pipelines because the interest in the field has concentrated on the ability to haul coal, sand, and phosphate hydraulically. Many mines, particularly in Chile and Peru, are located at very high altitudes. This demand has increased interest in gravity flows. In the early 1970s, Southern Peru Copper installed one of the first long, open launders to dispose of tailings to the sea. The launder was of a concrete and fiberglass design, with a U-shaped cross section. Another example of a long gravity pipeline for copper concentrate is the Escondida concentrate pipeline in Chile, which is longer than 200 km (125 mi). Despite the increasing importance of long gravity pipelines, equipment has not kept up with the expanding need. Cave (1980) described tests on slurry turbines. A 350 mm × 300 mm (14⬙ × 12⬙) was reported by Burgess and Abulnaga (1991). Launders play a very important role in slurry flows of plants. Cyclone underflow is directed to ball mills then to SAG mills by gravity. Flows in these circuits can cause tremendous wear if provision is not made to control speeds. Launders in plants are typically rubber lined. Long-distance pipelines are manufactured of rubber-lined steel or extra-thick, high-density polyethylene (HDPE). Because of the importance of open launders, gravity flows, and drop boxes, Chapter 6 is dedicated to these complex flows. Obviously, not all mines are located on mountaintops, and slurry pipeline flow will continue to be the main emphasis of researchers. In long pipelines, centrifugal pumps can be installed at regular intervals; these require power to be brought in. For long-distance pumping, positive displacement pumps compete well with centrifugal pumps. The positive displacement pumps are of a diaphragm or hose design. They are extremely expensive. A 17.3 MPa (2500 psi) pump may range in price between U.S. $600,000 and $1,200,000 in year 2000 dollars. The higher capital investment required for positive displacement pumps is offset by their higher efficiency. These pumps are built to much smaller flow capacity than are large centrifugal pumps.
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
1.32
9:12 AM
Page 1.32
CHAPTER ONE
1-10 HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT OF SLURRY PIPELINES One of the first large engineering projects that involved transportation of solids by liquid was the dredging for the Suez Canal in the 1860s in Egypt. It was reported to have used conduits to dispose of the sand–water mixture. Nora Blatch in 1906 was probably the first person to conduct a systematic investigation of the flow of solid–water mixtures. She used a 25 mm (1 in) horizontal pipe and measured the pressure gradients as a function of flow, density, and solid concentration. As a result, between 1918 and 1924, a 200 mm (8 in) pipeline was installed in the Hammersmith power station, in London, England to transport coal slurry over a distance of 660 yd. In 1948, in France, the Institute of Research SOGREAH began a series of tests on transporting sand and gravel in pipes with a diameter from 38–250 mm (1.5–10 in). These extensive tests were the basis for the formulation by Durand of a number of equations that will be reviewed in Chapter 4. These equations have been subject to further refinements over the last 50 years. In 1952, in the United Kingdom, the British Hydromechanic Research Association (BHRA) started to study the hydraulic transport of lump coal, sand, gravel, and limestone. Limestone pipelines were constructed in Trinidad and England in 1960. The Trinidad pipeline had a diameter of 204 mm (8 in), a length of 9.6 km (6 mi), and was designed to operate in a laminar flow regime. The limestone pipeline in England had a diameter of 250 mm (10 in) and was 112 km (70 mi) long. In 1950, the Consolidated Coal Co. in the United States started to conduct research on the hydrotransport of fine “nonsettling” slurries. Concentrated coal with a weight concentration of 60% and particle size between minus 1168 m (14 mesh) and minus 43 m (325 mesh) was transported. The pipeline transported 1.5 million tons of coal each year between 1957 and 1964. The pipeline stretched 176 km (110 mi) from Cadiz, Ohio to Eastlake in Cleveland, Ohio. In 1957, the Colorado School of Mines collaborated with the American Gilsonite Company and designed a pipeline with a diameter of 200 mm (8 in) to transport crushed gilsonite. The pipeline was constructed between Bonanza, Utah and Grand Junction, Colorado. The particle size was minus 4.7 mm (4 mesh) and solids were pumped at a weight concentration of 48%. Two other pipelines were built in Georgia to transport kaolin in the 1960s. In 1967, an iron ore concentrate slurry pipeline started to operate in Tasmania, Australia. The pipeline had a diameter of 245 mm (95–8 in). Concentrate was transported at a weight concentration of 60% with an average particle size of minus 149 m (100 mesh) over a distance of 85 km (53 mi) through extremely rugged terrain (see Figure 1-16). In 1970, the Black Mesa Pipeline, one of the longest pipelines ever built up to that time, started operation between the Black Mesa Coal fields in Arizona and the Mohave Power Plant in Nevada. Coal was ground to a particle size of minus 1168 m (14 mesh), and transported in a pipe with a diameter of 457 mm (18 in) over a distance of 437 km (273 mi). Coal was dewatered at the end of the line through a mill before combustion with preheated air. Since the 1970s, a number of short and long slurry pipelines have been constructed. Table 1-9 lists a number of such achievements. Now, at the beginning of the 21st century, new complex, multiphase tar–sand pipelines are planned for northern Alberta, Canada.
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:13 AM
Page 1.33
GENERAL CONCEPTS OF SLURRY FLOWS
1.33
FIGURE 1-16 Long slurry pipelines must travel through isolated areas over long distances and may involve pressures up to 2500 psi that require special positive displacement pumps. Courtesy of Wirth Pumps, Germany.
1.11 SEDIMENTATION OF DAMS— THE ROLE OF THE SLURRY ENGINEER In the last 150 years, world population has grown fast and our modern standards of living depend on the production of electricity, and production of food for at least two seasons a year. In an effort to meet these demands, engineers have built small as well as very large dams. In certain areas, very large man-made lakes have been dug in the earth, such as behind the Aswan High Dam in Egypt, the Ataturk Dam in Turkey, and new dams on the Yellow River in China. Some large rivers transport silt that tends to separate from water when the speed of the flow is interrupted by a dam. This phenomenon is called siltation of dams. The problem
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:13 AM
Page 1.34
1.34
CHAPTER ONE
TABLE 1-9 Examples of Slurry Pipelines Built Since 1957
Ore
Site of pipeline, or name of pipeline
Solids Pipe transported, Pipeline length diameter million short inch Mile km tons/yr
Start-up date
Coal
Consolidation, USA Black Mesa ETSI ALTON Belonovo–Novosibirsk, Siberia, Russia
10 18 38 24
108 273 1036 180 158
175 440 1675 112 256
1.3 4.8 25 10 3.4
1957 1970 1979 1981 1985
Iron concentrate
Savage River Waipipi (Iron Sands) Pena, Colorado Las Truchas, Mexico Sierra Grande, Argentina Samarco, Brazil Chongin, North Korea New Zealand Sands, NZ Jian Shan, China La Parla–Hercules, Mexico
9 8,12 8 10 8 20 ? 12 10 8/14
53 6 28 16 20 244 61 5 62 52/182
86 9.7 45 27 32 395 98 8 100 85/295
2.25 1.0 1.8 1.5 2.1 12 4.5
1967 1971 1974 1976 1976 1977 1975
4.5
1982
Copper ore
Los Bronces
24
35
56
Copper concentrate
Bougainville, PNG West Irian, Indonesia Pinto Valley OK Tedi, Papua New Guinea Escondida, Chile (gravity line) Collahausi, Chile Freeport, Indonesia Batu Hijau, Indonesia Alumbrera, Argentina
6 4 4 6 9 7 5 6 6
20 69 11 96 102 125 71 11 194
32 111 17 155 165 203 115 18 314
1.0 0.3 0.4 ? 1.0
1972 1972 1974 1987 1994 1999
0.8
1999 1998
Copper tailings
Bougainville, Papua NG Southern Peru Copper (gravity)
34
31
50 150
Limestone
Rugby Calaveras Michigan Limestone Tailings
10 7 20
57 17 1.2
92 27 2
1.7 1.5
1964 1971
Phosphate Chevron, Vernal, Wyoming ore concentrate Simplot Wenglu
10 8 8
94 89 28
152 145 45
1.3–2.5
1986
Dredging
24
33
21
11,000 gpm 1998
Dallas White Rock Lake, USA
1972
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:13 AM
Page 1.35
GENERAL CONCEPTS OF SLURRY FLOWS
1.35
of siltation of dams has not been well documented or studied. Chanson (1998) and Chanson and James (1999) examined the siltation of Australian dams. Certain dams in Australia became gradually fully silted between 1890 and 1960. They reported that the Koorawatha dam in New South Wales (Figure 1-17) became fully silted with bed-load material. The Cunningham Creek Dam in New South Wales, Australia was well studied by Hellstrom (1941) according to Chanson. Sedimentation problems are more acute with small dams than with medium-size and large reservoirs (Chanson and James,1999). Siltation at Eildon in the State of Victoria occurred in 1940 after torrential rainfalls following bushfires that had destroyed 50% of the catchment forest. The siltation at Eppalock in Victoria followed extensive gold mining, tree clearing, and hydraulic mining between 1851 and 1890. There were some extreme siltation cases. The Quipolly Reservoir No. 1, in Australia underwent very rapid sedimentation between 1941 and 1943 at a rate in excess of 1143m3/km2/year (9600 ft3/mi2/y). The Korrumbyn Creek Dam sedimented in less than 7 years. Since the 1950s, improvements in land management practices and a better understanding of the problems of soil erosion have resulted in better approaches to the protection of dams.
FIGURE 1-17 The Koorawatha Dam in Australia—fully silted. [From Chanson (1999). Reprinted by permission of Butterworth-Heinemann.]
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:13 AM
Page 1.36
1.36
CHAPTER ONE
Chanson and James (1998) discussed the hazards of fully silted dams. The weight of silt pressing against the concrete structure introduces a medium with a specific gravity larger than the water for which the dam was designed. It is important in these cases to monitor the structure. In the 1970s and 1980s, the drought in Ethiopia and the Sudan reduced the flow of the waters to the Nile to dramatically low levels. Egypt avoided famine by using its massive man-made lake behind the Aswan High Dam (Lake Nasser). On the other hand, any specialist who visits Egypt can feel that the fellahin (farmers) are speaking with nostalgia of the “Tamye” or silt that used to come with the annual flood and enrich the land. This raw material was the basis of natural nutrients, as well as mud for the construction of houses and manufacture of bricks. The Egyptian case is not unique. Certain dams in the United States are now the subject of discussions on decommissioning and some were removed in the 1990s. The slurry engineer can offer some much needed solutions. The twenty-first century will see slurry engineers providing adequate solutions in terms of dredging the lakes that are sedimenting and transporting the dredged silt to traditional lands, or to arid lands via special slurry pipelines. A simple concept for such a solution is presented in Figure 1-18. It is proposed that in certain areas, particularly where the accumulation of silt is likely to apply pressure on the dam structure, submersible slurry pumps be installed on a permanent basis. Dredging boats with dredging arms or submersible pumps and cutters would be used on the rest of the lake. Where the capital investment does not justify it, small dredgers with submersible pumps should be used. The slurry from these operations will be dilute, it would be pumped to the shore through a floating plastic pipe. It may be pumped in pipelines and diverted to canals for agricultural purposes. It may also be pumped to brick plants, where it would be dewatered and the silt used as a raw material.
Agriculture dredger
Brick manufacture Dam
Submersible pump silt
FIGURE 1-18 Simplified flow sheet to remove silt behind dams. Silt would be dredged using submersible Fi pumps 1 18at predetermined locations or in association with boat dredgers. The silt would be pumped in slurry form to agricultural farmlands or to special plants for the manufacture of bricks.
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:13 AM
Page 1.37
GENERAL CONCEPTS OF SLURRY FLOWS
1.37
Slurry engineers can provide economic solutions to the siltation of dams. This effort should be made in conjunction with environmental engineers, as new ecosystems often form around large dams. The author hopes that this handbook will be useful to the decision makers who have to deal with siltation of dams, while satisfying the concerns of environmental engineers, as decommissioning is not always the solution.
1-12 CONCLUSION In this first chapter, some of the basic properties of solids, which are important to the composition of slurries, were reviewed. Their importance will be emphasized in the next few chapters. They may lead to Newtonian as well as more complex non-Newtonian flows that require special equations to determine the friction factors, velocity of flow, pipe sizes, head, and efficiency losses in pumps. Wear is an important cost to be paid for transporting solids by liquids. This will be discussed later in the book when exploring slurry pumps and pipelines. The modern slurry engineer can serve the mining and power industries by making possible the transportation of minerals, coal, coal–crude oil mixtures over very long distances, and also play a major role in dredging sediments behind dams to avoid dam failure and to provide arid lands with much needed silt.
1-13 NOMENCLATURE A B Cc Cu Cv Cw Cp d10 d30 d50 d60 d80 K1, K2, K3, K4 k LL PI PL Re VD VT
Constant Constant Coefficient of curvature Coefficient of uniformity Concentration by volume of the solid particles in percent Concentration by weight of the solid particles in percent Heat capacity Grain size at which 10% of the soil is finer Grain size at which 30% of the soil is finer Grain size at which 50% of the soil is finer Grain size at which 60% of the soil is finer Grain size at which 80% of the soil is finer polynomial coefficients in Einstein’s equation for dynamic viscosity Thermal conductivity Liquid limit of clay and silt soils Plastic index of clay and silt soils Plastic limit of clay and silt soils Reynolds number Deposition critical velocity Viscous transition critical velocity Concentration by volume in decimal points Absolute (or dynamic) viscosity Density
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:13 AM
1.38
Subscripts l m s
Page 1.38
CHAPTER ONE
Liquid Mixture Solids
1-14 REFERENCES The American Society for Testing of Materials. 1993. Practice for Description and Identification of Soils (Visual–Manual Aggregate Mixtures). Standard D2488. Philadelphia: The American Society for Testing of Materials. The American Society for Testing of Materials. 1983. Test Method for Lime Content of Uncured Soil–Lime Mixtures. Standard D3155. Philadelphia: The American Society for Testing of Materials. The British Standard Institute. 1999. Code for Practice of Site Investigation. Standard BS 5930. London: The British Standard Institute. The British Standard Institute. 1999. Aggregate Abrasion Value. Standard BS 812. Pt 113. London: The British Standard Institute. Broch, E., and J. A. Franklin. 1972. The Point-Load Strength Test. International Journal for Rock Mechanics and Mineral Sciences, 9, 669–697. Burgess K. E, and B. E. Abulnaga.1991.The Application of Finite Element Methods to Warman Pumps and Process Equipment. Paper presented to the Fifth International Conference on Finite Element Analysis in Australia, University of Sydney, Australia (July). Cave I. 1980. Slurry Turbines for Energy Recovery. In Seventh International Conference on the Hydraulic Transport of Solids in Pipelines, Sendai, Japan, pp. 9–15, Cranfield, United Kingdom: BHRA Group. Chanson H. 1998. Extreme Reservoir Sedimentation in Australia: A Review. International Journal of Sediment Research, UNESCO-IRTCES, 13, 3, 55–63. Chanson H. 1999. The Hydraulics of Open Channel Flows—An Introduction. Oxford, UK: Butterworth-Heinemann. Chanson H., and D. P. James.1999. Siltation in Australian Reservoirs: Some Observations and Dam Safety Implications.” In Proceedings 28th IAHR Congress, Graz, Austria, Paper B5. Guth, E., and A. R. Simha. 1936. Viscosity of suspensions and solutions. Kolloid-Z, 74, 266. Quoted in Wasp, E. J., J. P. Kenny, and R. L. Gandhi. 1977. Solid–Liquid Flow—Slurry Pipeline Transportation. Aedermannsdorf, Switzerland: Trans. Tech. Publications. Hellstrom B. (1941) Nagra Lakttagelser over Vittring Erosion och Slambidning i Malaya och Australien.” Geografiska Annaler (Stockholm, Sweden), Nos. 1–2, pp. 102–124 (in Swedish). Herbrich, J. 1991. Handbook of Dredging Engineering. New York: McGraw-Hill Inc. The International Journal for Rock Mechanics and Mineral Sciences, 1979, 16, 141–156. The International Society for Rock Mechanics. 1977. Suggested Methods for Determining the Strength of Rock Materials in Triaxial Compression. Lisbon, Portugal: The International Society for Rock Mechanics. The International Society for Rock Mechanics. 1978. Suggested Methods for Determining the Deformability of Rock. Lisbon, Portugal: The International Society for Rock Mechanics. Metzner, A. B., and P. S. Friend. 1959. Heat Transfer to Turbulent Non-Newtonian Fluids. Ind. & Eng. Chem., 51, 7 (July), 879–882. Metzner, A. B., and D. F. Gluck. 1960. Heat Transfer to Non-Newtonian Fluids Under Laminar Flow Conditions. Chem. Eng. Science, 12, 3 (June), 185–190. Nunez, G. A., M. Briceno, C. Mata, and H. Rivas. 1996. Flow Characteristics of Concentrated Emulsions of Very Viscous Oil in Water. Journal of Rheology, 40, 3 (May/June), 405–423. Orr, C., and J. M. Dalla Valle. 1954. Heat-Transfer Properties of Liquid–Solid Suspensions. Chem. Eng. Prog., Symp. Series No. 9, 50, 29–45. The Permanent International Association of Navigation Congresses. 1972. Classification of Soils to be Dredged. In Bulletin No. 11, Vol. I. The Permanent International Association of Navigational Congresses.
abul-1.qxd
2/28/02
9:13 AM
Page 1.39
GENERAL CONCEPTS OF SLURRY FLOWS
1.39
Sargent, J. H. 1984. Classification of Soils to be Dredged. In Supplement to Bulletin No 47. The Permanent International Association of Navigation Congresses. Sulzer Pumps. 1998. Centrifugal Pump Handbook. New York: Elsevier. Thomas, D. G. 1960. Heat and Momentum Transport Characteristics of Non-Newtonian Aqueous Thorium Oxide Suspensions. AIChE Journal, 6 (December), 631–639. Thomas D. G. 1965. Transient Characteristics of Suspensions: Part VIII. A Note on the Viscosity of Newtonian Suspensions of Uniform Spherical Particles. Journal Colloid Science, 20, 267. Wasp, E. J., J. P. Kenny, and R. L. Gandhi. 1977. Solid–Liquid Flow—Slurry Pipeline Transportation. Aedermannsdorf, Switzerland: Trans Tech Publications. Wilson, K. C., G. R. Addie, and R. Clift. 1992. Slurry Transport Using Centrifugal Pumps. New York: Elsevier Applied Sciences. Further Reading: Wilson, G. 1976. Construction of Solids-Handling Centrifugal Pumps. In Pump Handbook. Edited by J. Karassik et al. New York: McGraw-Hill.
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.1
CHAPTER 2
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
2-0 INTRODUCTION The mechanics of pipe flow is a topic well dealt with in the scientific literature. In this chapter, some of the concepts are reviewed in a simplified manner as they relate to slurry flows. The friction factor for single phase flows is presented in terms of boundary layer theory. Losses in pipes are summarized in terms of fittings and conduits commonly used on large engineering projects. Numerous books have been written for single-phase flows. This chapter limits itself to a brief introduction. The equations in this chapter are based on SI units for consistency. They can be readily used in USCS (United States Customary System) units if the reader assumes the use of slugs and not pounds for mass units. There is considerable confusion about the use of slugs, which are units of mass, and pounds, which are units of force. The conversion factor between these is often called gc and is equal to 32.2 ft/sec. Many other references input gc in their equations to achieve such a conversion, but it was not deemed necessary in this book. The worked examples show how slugs should be used as a unit of mass. Certain models of Newtonian slurry flows are attempts to apply correction factors to the friction losses of the carrier liquid on the basis of the volumetric concentration of solids. The reader is encouraged to examine this chapter before proceeding with more complex themes.
2-1 SHEAR STRESS OF LIQUID FLOWS Modern fluid mechanics is based on the concept of a controlled volume. Mass momentum and energy must be conserved when a particle enters and leaves the volume. Considering flow through a section of pipe of a constant diameter between two locations 1 and 2 as in Figure 2-1, the hydraulics force associated with the drop of pressure is
F12 = ᎏ D i2(P1 – P2) 4
2.1
(2-1)
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
2.2
Page 2.2
CHAPTER TWO
w
P
P
2
1
L
FIGURE 2-1 Shear stress and pressure for flow in a pipe.
This force is balanced by the friction force Fr Fr = wDiL
(2-2)
where L is the distance between points 1 and 2 and w is the wall shear stress
ᎏ D 2i (P1 – P2) – wDL = 0 4 or Ri(P1 – P2) Di(P1 – P2) w = ᎏᎏ = ᎏᎏ 4L 2L
(2-3)
The shear stress at any radius and from the center of the pipe is r Ri⌬P = ᎏ = w ᎏ 2L R where L = length Ri = the pipe inner radius (at the inside wall of the pipe) r = local radius The shear stress is calculated. At the center of the pipe there is no shear stress. Example 2-1 Homogeneous slurry is tested in a pipe with an inner diameter of 53 mm (2.086 in). The pressure drop due to friction is measured between two points (A and B), which are separated by a distance of 1.8 m (5.9 ft). The pressure drop is recorded as 3000 Pa (0.435 psi). To appreciate the shear stress distribution from the wall to the center of the pipe, determine the shear stress distribution at the wall and at three points: at a radius of 20 mm (0.787⬙), at a radius of 12 mm (0.472⬙), and at the center of the pipe. Solution This problem will be solved in SI units [Système International (metric)] and in USCS units.
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.3
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
2.3
Solution in SI Units Using Equation 2-3, the shear stress at the wall is 0.053(3000) w = ᎏᎏ = 22 Pa 4 × 1.8 since the inner radius of the pipe is 26.5 mm. At a radius of 20 mm the shear stress is
冢 冣
冢
冣
20 r = w ᎏ = 22 ᎏ = 16.6 Pa Ri 26.5 At a radius of 12 mm the shear stress is
冢 冣
冢
冣
12 r = w ᎏ = 22 ᎏ = 10 Pa Ri 26.5 At the center of the pipe the shear stress is
冢 冣
冢
冣
0 r = w ᎏ = 22 ᎏ = 0 Pa Ri 26.5 Solution in USCS Units Using Equation 2-3, the shear stress at the wall is 2.086 in (0.435 psi) w = ᎏᎏᎏ = 0.0032 psi 4 × 5.9 × 12 since the inner radius of the pipe is 1.043 in. At a radius of 20 mm (0.787 in) the shear stress is
冢 冣
冢
冣
r 0.787 = w ᎏ = 0.0032 ᎏ = 0.0024 psi Ri 1.043 At a radius of 12 mm (0.472 in) the shear stress is
冢
冣
0.472 = 0.0032 ᎏ = 0.00145 psi 1.043 At the center of the pipe = 0
2-2 REYNOLDS NUMBER AND FLOW REGIMES Determining the magnitude of friction was historically a controversial topic until the end of the 19th century. The great disagreement was between the practical engineers and the theory of hydrodynamics. Hager (in 1839) and Poiseville (in 1840) demonstrated that under certain conditions friction was a linear function of the speed of flow. In 1858, Darcy demonstrated that under other conditions friction was in fact proportional to the square of the mean speed of the flow. By 1883, Reynolds had demonstrated that both Poiseville and Darcy were correct, as the mechanics of flows were fundamentally different at very low speeds and at high speeds.
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.4
2.4
CHAPTER TWO
Through nondimensional analysis, Reynolds demonstrated that under certain fixed conditions, the transition from a laminar Poiseville flow to a turbulent Darcy flow was based on the ratio of the inertia forces to the viscous forces. In his honor, such a ratio is now called the Reynolds number: UDi Inertia forces UDi Re = ᎏᎏ = ᎏ = ᎏ Viscous forces
(2-4)
where = density of the fluid = absolute or “dynamic” viscosity = kinematic viscosity (defined as the absolute viscosity divided by the density of the liquid) U = average velocity of the flow The kinematic viscosity is the absolute (or dynamic viscosity) divided by the density. Its unit of measurement are, strictly speaking, m2/s or ft2/sec. Another unit used is the centistokes, which is obtained by dividing the absolute viscosity in centipoises by the specific gravity of the fluid. A centipoise is equivalent to one milli-Pascal-second. One unit for kinematic viscosity used in the oil industry (but of limit use in the mining industry) is the seconds Saybolt universal (or SSU). For values of kinematic viscosity larger than 70 centistokes (cst), the following formula is recommended by the Hydraulic Institute (1990): SSU = centistokes × 4.635 In simplified terms, it may be said that two geometrically similar bodies immersed in a fluid will develop inertia and viscous forces in a constant ratio when body forces are negligible. Since Reynolds developed his theory, his approach has been has been extended to other fluids. Modern aerodynamics uses the chord of the wing aerofoil instead of the pipe diameter as the distance parameter for Equation 2-4. In Chapter 3, the concept of the particle Reynolds number based on a characteristic particle diameter shall be introduced. Figure 2.2 presents the equations of the Reynolds number for different shapes and flows. For pipe flows, the critical Reynolds number is considered to be between 2300 and 2800. In many pipes, flow becomes unstable above a Reynolds number of 2300 and slides into a transition regime before converting into turbulent motion.
2-3 FRICTION FACTORS The Fanning friction factor is a nondimensional number defined as the ratio of the wall shear stress to the dynamic pressure of the flow:
w fN = ᎏ U 2/2
(2-5)
Users of USCS units should use slugs/ft3 for density and not the more commonly used units of pounds per cubic feet. The conversion between these two is gc or 32.2 ft/sec2. Substituting Equation 2-3 into Equation 2-5
U 2 ⌬PDI fN = ᎏ / ᎏ 4L 2
冢
冣冢
冣
(2-6)
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.5
2.5
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
c h
Airfoil chord "c" Re = U c /
Close parallel plates Re = [U h/2 ] 32/3
DI dp Annular flow
Re= ( U/
)*2 r 20 + r2i - r 2m 2
2
where rm = (r 0 - r i )/2.3 log10 (r0 /rI )
Use inner diameter for pipe flow Re= U D i /
for sphere use diameter Re= U d p /
FIGURE 2-2 Definition of Reynolds number for various shapes.
Equation 2-6 clearly indicates that the friction factor is dependent on the flow. It will be demonstrated that there is a relationship between the friction factor and the Reynolds number of the flow. In USCS units, density is expressed in slugs/ft3. Example 2-2 The slurry in Example 2-1 has a specific gravity of 1.2 , or a density of 1200 kg/m3. If the speed of the flow is 2 m/s (6.56 ft/s), determine the Fanning friction factor. Solution in SI Units Using the shear stress calculated in Example 2-1 as 22 Pa and inserting it into Equation 25, the Fanning friction factor can be calculated as 22 = 0.0092 fN = ᎏᎏ 1200 × 22 × 0.5 Solutions in USCS Units Assume the density of water to be 62.3 lbm/ft3. Since specific gravity equals 1.2, the density of the slurry is 1.2 × 62.3 = 74.76 lbs/ft3. To convert lbs/ft3, into slugs/ft3 complete the following equation: 74.76 ᎏ = 2.32 slugs/ft3 32.2 In Example 2-1, the wall shear stress was determined to be 0.0032 psi. Using equation 2.5 0.0032 × 144 = 0.0092 fN = ᎏᎏ 2.32 × 6.562 × 0.5
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.6
2.6
CHAPTER TWO
2-3-1 Laminar Friction Factors The friction or resistance of a body to motion is confined to a viscous layer at the wall or surface of the body. This layer is called the boundary layer. Understanding this phenomenon remained illusive until the end of the 19th century. At the turn of the 20th century, Prandtl developed the principles of boundary layer theory. To understand the basic principles of the boundary layer, let us start by examining the flow between closely related plates at low speed. With one plate stationary and the other moving at a speed U, a linear velocity profile is established. The wall shear stress w is established as
U w = ᎏ h by Newton’s law, where h is the spacing between plates and
冢 冣
U u=y ᎏ h
(2-7)
With y as the vertical ordinate from the stationary plate, the velocity gradient is defined as du U ᎏ = ᎏ = rate of shearing strain or shear rate d␥ H
(2-8)
Thus, the dynamic viscosity is Shear Stress = ᎏ = ᎏᎏᎏ du/d␥ Rate of Shear Strain
(2-9)
Equation 2-8 is the basis for boundary layer theory. Instead of a moving plate at a velocity U, the velocity of the flow outside the boundary layer is studied (see Figure 2-3). The shear rate is not necessarily linear. For example flow around an aircraft airfoil can be attached, stagnant at a point, or can even reverse flow after separation. Laminar flow in a pipe is described by the Hagen–Poiseville equation: ⌬P 32U ᎏ=ᎏ D i2 L
(2-10)
Upper plate moves at speed U
h y FIGURE 2-3 ary plate.
y u=U h
w
Linear velocity distribution due to a plate moving at a speed U above a station-
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.7
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
2.7
which can be rearranged as ⌬P = ᎏ L
Di⌬P
= ᎏ ᎏ 冢 冣冢 ᎏ 32U 冣 冢 4L 冣冢 8U 冣 D 2i
Di
w = ᎏ 8U/Di
(2-11)
(2-12)
or the ratio of the wall shear stress and the mean velocity gradient. The term (8U/Di) is often called the pipe (or pipeline) shear rate in laminar flow. From Equation 2-12 8U w = ᎏ Di
(2-13a)
Substituting Equation 2-12 into Equation 2-5, the Fanning friction factor for a laminar flow can be expressed as 8U fN = ᎏ Di
冢
U 2
冣 冢ᎏ 2 冣
/
16 16 fN = ᎏ = ᎏ VDi Re
(2-14)
(2-15)
The Fanning friction factor is more commonly found in reference publications on chemical engineering. Another friction factor used by mechanical engineers is the Darcy friction factor: fDarcy = 4 × fFanning To avoid confusion, in the book the symbols fD will be used for Darcy friction factor and fN will be used for Fanning friction factor. Flow in a laminar regime is considered to be independent of pipe roughness. Example 2-3 A viscous fluid is flowing in a laminar flow at a speed of 1m/s (or 3.28 ft/s) in a pipe with an inner diameter of 336.6 mm (13.25 in). The measured pressure drop over a distance of 200 m (656 ft) is 8400 Pa (1.22 psi). The density of the fluid is 855 kg/m3 (SG = 0.855). Determine an equivalent viscosity for the pipeline fluid, the Reynolds number, and the friction factor. Solution in SI Units From Equation 2-3, the shear stress at the wall is 0.3366 × 8400 w = ᎏᎏ = 3.53 Pa 4 × 200 The Fanning Friction Factor from Equation 2.5 is 2w 2 × 3.53 fN = ᎏ2 = ᎏ2 = 0.0083 V 855 × 1
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
2.8
Page 2.8
CHAPTER TWO
The equivalent pipeline viscosity from Equation 2-12 is
w 3.53 × 0.3366 = ᎏ = ᎏᎏ = 0.148 Pa-s 8U/D 8×1 The Reynolds Number from Equation 2-4
UD 855 × 1 × 0.3366 Re = ᎏ = ᎏᎏ = 1938 0.148 Check on friction factor: 16 fN = ᎏ = 0.00823 1938 Solution in USCS Units 0.8555 × 62.3 density = ᎏᎏ = 1.654 slugs/ft3 32.2 Since it was stated that the pressure drop = 1.215 psi, over a distance of 656.2 ft the shear stress is: 13.25 × 1.2 w = ᎏᎏ = 0.0005 psi 4 × 656.2 × 12 The Fanning Friction Factor from Equation 2.5 is 2w 2 × 0.0005 × 144 fN = ᎏ2 = ᎏᎏ = 0.0081 V 1.654 × 3.282 The equivalent pipeline viscosity converting the shear stress from psi to lbf/ft2, 0.0005 × 144 = 0.072 lbf/ft2, is (13.25/12) × 0.072 Diw = ᎏ = ᎏᎏ = 0.003 lbf-sec/ft2 8V 8 × 3.28 The Reynolds number is 1.654 × 3.28 × 13.25/12 Re = ᎏᎏᎏ = 1997 0.003 Check on friction factor: 16 fN = ᎏ = 0.008 1997
2-3-2 Transition Flow Friction Factor The transition from a laminar to a turbulent flow is difficult to describe. For Reynolds numbers up to 3 × 106, Wasp et al. (1977) recommended the use of Nikuradse equation for the Fanning coefficient: 0.0553 fN = 0.0008 + ᎏ Re0.237
(2-16)
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.9
2.9
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
2-3-3 Friction Factor in Turbulent Flow In turbulent flow, the roughness of the pipe becomes an important factor in determining the friction factor. The roughness is measured in units of length. Up to a certain limiting Reynolds number Re, the friction factor can be expressed by the following Colebrook equation:
冢 冣
冢
Di Di 1 ᎏ = 4 loge ᎏ + 3.48 – 4 loge 1 + 9.35 ᎏᎏ 2 兹f苶N 2 Re兹f苶N
冣
(2-17)
A more simplified equation for the Darcy factor is called the Prandtl–Colebrook equation: 2.51 1 ᎏ = –2 log10 ᎏ + ᎏ 兹f苶 3.7 Di Re兹f 苶 D N
冢
冣
(2-18)
A popular equation used by mechanical engineers (Lindeburg, 1997) as it is explicit and does not require tedious iterations is the Swamee–Jain equation. It is suitable for the range of Reynolds numbers between 5000 and 100,000,000: fD =
冢冦
冥冧 冣
0.25 ᎏᎏᎏ 2 /D log10 ᎏᎏ + (5.74/Re0.9) 3.7
冤
(2-19)
Because the slurry flows occur at Reynolds Numbers smaller than 100,000,000, Equation 2.19 is satisfactory in the context of this handbook. Example 2-4 Using the Swamee–Jain equation, determine the friction factor for a flow of 3500 US gpm in an 18⬙ OD pipe with a wall thickness of 0.375 in. The fluid has a specific gravity of 1.02 and a dynamic viscosity of 2.7 × 10–5 lbf-sec/ft2. Solutions in SI Units (For conversion factors refer to the Appendix at the end of this book.) 3500 × 3.785 Q = ᎏᎏ = 0.221 m3/s 60000 ID of pipe = (18 – 2 × 0.375) = 17.25 in (0.438 m) Area of flow = × 0.25 × 0.4382 = 0.1506 m2 0.221 Average velocity of flow = ᎏ = 1.467m/s 0.1506 Density = 1.02 × 1000 = 1020 kg/m3
= 2.7 × 10–5 × 47.88 = 0.00129 Pa.s 1020 × 1.467 × 0.438 Re = ᎏᎏᎏ = 506975 0.00129
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
2.10
Page 2.10
CHAPTER TWO
The absolute roughness of steel pipes is 6 × 10–5 m. Relative roughness is 6 × 10–5 /Di = ᎏ = 0.000137 0.438 0.25 fD = ᎏᎏᎏᎏᎏ = 0.01486 [log10(0.000137/3.7 + 5.74/5069750.9)]2 Solutions in USCS Units Q = 3500 × 0.1337 = 467.95 ft3/min ID of pipe = (18 – 2 × 0.375) = 17.25 in or 1.4375 ft Area of flow = × 0.25 × 1.43752 = 1.623 ft2 467.95 Velocity of flow = ᎏ = 255.3 ft/min or 4.80 ft/s 1.623 1.02 × 62.3 Density = ᎏᎏ = 1.973 slugs/ft3 32.2 1.973 × 4.80 × 1.4375 Re = ᎏᎏᎏ = 504,779 2.7 × 10–5 The absolute roughness of steel is 0.0002 ft. Relative roughness is 0.0002 ᎏ = 0.000139 1.4375 fD = 0.25/[log10(0.000139/3.7 + 5.74/5047790.9)]2 = 0.0149 The Colebrook and Prandtl–Colebrook formulas are limited to a certain range of Reynolds number magnitude. At high Reynolds numbers, the friction factor becomes independent of the Reynolds number. The value of the Reynolds number beyond which the friction factor is independent is calculated using the following equation: Di Re = 70 ᎏ
ᎏ 冪莦ᎏf = 70 ᎏ 冪莦 f 2
N
Di
8
D
The region for which equation 2-19 applies is shown on the Moody diagram to be to the right of the the dashed curve (Figure 2-4). The equations established so far have been developed for clear water and do not apply for plastic fluids or liquids carrying coarse particles. They can apply for any other singlephase Newtonian liquids. (These terms will be explained in Chapter 3). Most fluid dynamics books publish data for linear roughness based on Moody’s work. Such values are applicable to water. However, tests conduced on slurry pipelines can yield different values, due to the erosion of pipe, wear and tear of rubber linings, etc. The Moody diagram is a general graph for the Darcy factor versus the Reynolds number. It is applicable to a very large number of different pipe materials. There are four principal pipe materials associated with slurry flows: plastic pipes [high-density polyethylene (HDPE)], plain steel pipes, rubber-lined steel pipes, and concrete pipes. The absolute
abul-2.qxd 2/28/02 9:14 AM Page 2.11
2.11
FIGURE 2-4 Moody diagram for the friction factor versus the Reynolds number for pipe flow (Reproduced from V. L. Streeter, Fluid Mechanics, McGraw-Hill, 1971. Reproduced by permission of McGraw-Hill, Inc.)
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
2.12
Page 2.12
CHAPTER TWO
roughness of these materials is presented in Table 2-1. Plain steel pipes and rubber-lined steel pipes are the most common, but HDPE and HDPE-lined steel pipes have gained in importance in the last quarter of the 20th century. One of the concentrate pipelines used in Escondida, Chile featured a long section of gravity flow in HDPE pipe. Certain reference books show a roughness of steel of 0.045–0.05 mm. This is difficult to maintain in steel pipes carrying slurries as they are often subject to erosion and corrosion. For this reason, the author recommends the use of a slightly higher roughness of the order of 0.06 mm in friction calculations. The dimensions of plain steel pipes, their pressure ratings, and relative roughness are presented in Table 2-2. It is obvious that steel pipes are limited in pressure rating to 3000 psi. This criterion is essential when considering location of booster pump stations or chokes. In the case of slurry pipelines, the thickness of the pipes is selected on the basis of 앫 Pressure 앫 Corrosion allowance 앫 Wear allowance Because of the wear allowance, erosion, and corrosion, the rating of slurry pipes is lower than presented in Table 2-2. Steel pipes may be hardened for carrying coarse slurry particles (larger than 6.5 mm or 1–4⬙), or sacrificial thickness is used to resist abrasion. The pressure rating as presented in Table 2-2 should be used as a starting point for the design calculations, and the appropriate allowance should be made for wear. Reclaimed water pipelines use the pressure ratings as in Table 2-2. The roughness and inner diameter of reclaimed water pipes may change due to scaling and deposition of lime. Steel pipes are rubber lined to a typical thickness of 6 mm (or 0.25⬙) for small sizes of pipes [< 150 mm (6⬙), 9.5 mm (3–8⬙)], and 13 mm (1–2⬙) for pipe sizes up to 24⬙. Larger pipes may be custom lined. Lining is done in an autoclave and the rubber is cured under steam. Rubber lining is limited to pumping coarse material up to a size of 6 mm (⬇ 1–4⬙). Rubber does not contribute to the pressure rating of steel pipes. Table 2-3 presents the dimensions and relative roughness of rubber-lined steel pipes. The dimensions of plain HDPE pipes (not HDPE-lined steel) for pressures up to 110 psi (760 kPa) are listed in Table 2-4. The dimensions of HDPE pipes for pressures in the range of 125 to 300 psi (863–2070 kPa) are presented in Table 2-5. These dimensions are slightly different than metric pipes. HDPE is not a magic material but can withstand the abrasion of taconite and some coarse laterites. As with rubber, there must be a cut-off size of particle size beyond which the use of HDPE is not acceptable. Very little has been published on this subject. The use of concrete pipes is often associated with gravity flows.
TABLE 2-1 Absolute Roughness of New Materials Used in Slurry Pipes Description Plastic pipes, PVC, ABS, HDPE Steel pipes Rubber-lined pipes Concrete pipes
Roughness (m)
Roughness (ft)
1.5 × 10–6 6.0 × 10–5 0.00015 0.0012
0.000004921 0.000197 0.000492 0.00394
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.13
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
2.13
TABLE 2-2 Size, Rating, and Relative Roughness of Plain Steel Pipes to U.S. Dimensions* Outside diameter (inch)
Wall thickness (inch)
Pipe internal diameter (inch)
Allowed working pressure (psi) to 650 °F
Relative roughness for new pipe
2⬙ Sch 40 2⬙ Sch 80 2⬙ Sch 160 XX
2.375
0.154 0.218 0.344 0.436
2.067 1.939 1.687 1.503
1159 2038 3890 5356
0.001143 0.001212 0.001400 0.001572
3⬙ Sch 40 3⬙ Sch 80 3⬙ Sch 160 XX
3.500
0.216 0.300 0.438 0.600
3.068 2.900 2.624 2.300
1341 2129 3495 5252
0.000770 0.000815 0.000900 0.001027
4⬙ Sch 40 4⬙ Sch 80 4⬙ Sch 120 4⬙ Sch 160 XX
4.500
0.237 0.337 0.438 0.531 0.674
4.026 3.826 3.624 3.438 3.152
1191 1905 2663 3387 4553
0.000587 0.000617 0.000652 0.000687 0.000749
5⬙ Sch 40 5⬙ Sch 80 5⬙ Sch 120 5⬙ Sch 160 XX
5.633
0.257 0.375 0.500 0.625 0.750
5.117 4.883 4.633 4.383 4.133
1071 1950 2502 3284 4098
0.000461 0.000484 0.000510 0.000539 0.000572
6⬙ Sch 40 6⬙ Sch 80 6⬙ Sch 120 6⬙ Sch 160 XX
6.625
0.280 0.432 0.562 0.719 0.864
6.065 5.761 5.501 5.187 4.897
1000 1739 2394 3215 4004
0.000389 0.000410 0.000429 0.000455 0.000482
8⬙ Sch 20 8⬙ Sch 30 8⬙ Sch 40 8⬙ Sch 60 8⬙ Sch 80 8⬙ Sch 100 8⬙ Sch 120 8⬙ Sch 140 XX 8⬙ Sch 160
8.625
0.250 0.277 0.322 0.406 0.500 0.594 0.719 0.812 0.875 0.906
8.125 8.071 7.981 7.813 7.625 7.437 7.187 7.001 6.875 6.813
655 752 916 1225 1577 1935 2422 2792 3046 3173
0.000291 0.000293 0.000296 0.000302 0.000310 0.000318 0.000329 0.000337 0.000344 0.000347
0.250 0.307 0.365 0.500 0.594 0.719 0.844 1.000 1.125
10.250 10.136 10.020 9.750 9.562 9.312 9.062 8.750 8.500
523 688 856 1255 1537 1918 2308 2804 3211
0.000230 0.000233 0.000236 0.000243 0.000247 0.000254 0.000261 0.000270 0.000278 (continued)
Denomination (inch)
10⬙ Sch 20 10⬙ Sch 30 10⬙ Sch 40 S 10⬙ Sch 60 X 10⬙ Sch 80 10⬙ Sch 100 10⬙ Sch 120 10⬙ Sch 140 XX 10⬙ Sch 160
10.75
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
2.14
Page 2.14
CHAPTER TWO
TABLE 2-2 Continued Outside diameter (inch)
Wall thickness (inch)
Pipe internal diameter (inch)
Allowed working pressure (psi) to 650 °F
Relative roughness for new pipe
12⬙ S 12⬙ Sch 40 12⬙ X 12⬙ Sch 60 X 12⬙ Sch 80 12⬙ Sch 100 12⬙ Sch 120 XX 12⬙ Sch 140 12⬙ Sch 160
12.750
0.250 0.330 0.375 0.406 0.500 0.562 0.688 0.844 1.00 1.125 1.312
12.250 12.090 12.000 11.938 11.750 11.626 11.374 11.062 10.750 10.500 10.126
440 634 744 820 1052 1207 1526 1927 2337 2672 3183
0.000193 0.000195 0.000197 0.000198 0.000201 0.000203 0.000208 0.000214 0.000220 0.000225 0.000233
14⬙ Sch 10 14⬙ Sch 20 14⬙ Sch 30 S 14⬙ Sch 40 14⬙ X 14⬙ Sch 60 14⬙ Sch 80 14⬙ Sch 100 14⬙ Sch 120 14⬙ Sch 140 14⬙ Sch 160
14.000
0.250 0.330 0.375 0.400 0.500 0.594 0.750 0.938 1.062 1.250 1.406
13.500 13.376 13.250 13.124 13.000 12.812 12.500 12.124 11.876 11.500 11.188
401 537 676 817 956 1169 1528 1969 2265 2724 3112
0.000175 0.000177 0.000178 0.00180 0.000182 0.000184 0.000189 0.000195 0.000199 0.000205 0.000211
16⬙ Sch 10 16⬙ Sch 20 16⬙ Sch 30 S 16⬙ Sch 40 X 16⬙ Sch 60 16⬙ Sch 80 16⬙ Sch 100 16⬙ Sch 120XX 16⬙ Sch 140 16⬙ Sch 160
16.000
0.250 0.312 0.375 0.500 0.656 0.844 1.031 1.219 1.438 1.594
15.500 15.376 15.250 15.000 14.688 14.312 13.938 13.562 13.124 12.812
350 469 590 834 1142 1520 1903 2296 2764 3104
0.000152 0.000154 0.000155 0.000157 0.000161 0.000165 0.000169 0.000176 0.000180 0.000184
18⬙ Sch 10 18⬙ Sch 20 18⬙ S 18⬙ Sch 30 18⬙ X 18⬙ Sch 40 18⬙ Sch 60 18⬙ Sch 80 18⬙ Sch 100 18⬙ Sch 120 18⬙ Sch 140 18⬙ Sch 160
18.000
0.250 0.312 0.375 0.438 0.500 0.562 0.750 0.938 1.156 1.375 1.562 1.781
17.500 17.376 17.250 17.124 17.000 16.876 16.500 16.124 15.688 15.225 14.876 14.438
312 416 524 632 739 847 1178 1514 1911 2318 2673 3096
0.000135 0.000136 0.000137 0.000138 0.000139 0.000140 0.000143 0.000147 0.000151 0.000155 0.000159 0.000164
Denomination (inch)
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.15
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
2.15
TABLE 2-2 Continued
Denomination (inch)
Outside diameter (inch)
Wall thickness (inch)
Pipe internal diameter (inch)
Allowed working pressure (psi) to 650 °F
Relative roughness for new pipe
20.000
0.250 0.375 0.500 0.594 0.812 1.031 1.281 1.500 1.750 1.969 0.250 0.375 0.500 0.562 0.688 0.969 1.219 1.513 1.812 2.062 2.344 0.312 0.375 0.500 0.625 0.312 0.375 0.500 0.625 0.750 0.375 0.500 0.375 0.500
19.500 19.250 19.000 18.812 18.376 17.938 17.438 17.000 16.500 16.082 23.500 23.250 23.000 22.876 22.624 22.062 21.562 20.938 20.376 19.875 19.312 29.376 29.250 29.00 28.750 35.376 35.250 35.000 34.750 34.500 41.250 41.000 47.250 47.000
280 471 664 811 1155 1507 1917 2284 2710 3091 233 392 552 635 795 1165 1500 1927 2319 2674 3083 254 313 440 568 207 260 366 473 580 223 313 195 274
0.000121 0.000123 0.000124 0.000126 0.000129 0.000132 0.000135 0.000139 0.000143 0.000147 0.0001005 0.0001016 0.0001027 0.000103 0.000104 0.000107 0.000109 0.000113 0.000116 0.000119 0.000122 0.0000804 0.0000807 0.0000814 0.0000822 0.0000668 0.0000670 0.0000675 0.0000679 0.0000685 0.0000573 0.0000576 0.0000499 0.0000503
20⬙ Sch 10 20⬙ Sch 20 S 20⬙ Sch 30 X 20⬙ Sch 40 20⬙ Sch 60 20⬙ Sch 80 20⬙ Sch 100 20⬙ Sch 120 20⬙ Sch 140 20⬙ Sch 160 24⬙ Sch 10 24⬙ Sch 20 S 24⬙ X 24⬙ Sch 30 24⬙ Sch 40 24⬙ Sch 60 24⬙ Sch 80 24⬙ Sch 100 24⬙ Sch 120 24⬙ Sch 140 24⬙ Sch 160 30⬙ Sch 10 30⬙ S 30⬙ Sch 20 X 30⬙ Sch 30 36⬙ Sch 10 36⬙ S 36⬙ Sch 20 X 36⬙ Sch 30 36⬙ Sch 40 42 S
42.000
48 S
48.000
24.000
30.000
36.000
*Dimensions are based on ANSI B36.1 and B31.1. Absolute roughness of steel is taken as 60 m.
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
2.16
Page 2.16
CHAPTER TWO
TABLE 2-3 Size and Relative Roughness of Rubber-Lined Steel Pipes to U.S. Dimensions*
Denomination (inch)
Outside diameter (inch)
Wall thickness (inch)
Rubber thickness (inch)
Pipe internal diameter (inch)
Relative roughness for rubber-lined pipe
2⬙ Sch 40 2⬙ Sch 80 2⬙ Sch 160 XX
2.375
0.154 0.218 0.344 0.436
0.25
1.559 1.431 1.179 0.995
0.003788 0.004127 0.005009 0.005935
3⬙ Sch 40 3⬙ Sch 80 3⬙ Sch 160 XX
3.500
0.216 0.300 0.438 0.600
0.25
2.560 2.392 2.116 1.792
0.002307 0.002469 0.002790 0.003295
4⬙ Sch 40 4⬙ Sch 80 4⬙ Sch 120 4⬙ Sch 160 XX
4.500
0.237 0.337 0.438 0.531 0.674
0.25
3.518 3.138 3.116 2.930 2.664
0.001679 0.00178 0.001895 0.002015 0.002233
5⬙ Sch 40 5⬙ Sch 80 5⬙ Sch 120 5⬙ Sch 160 XX
5.633
0.257 0.375 0.500 0.625 0.750
0.25
4.609 4.375 4.125 3.875 3.625
0.001281 0.00135 0.001431 0.001524 0.001629
6⬙ Sch 40 6⬙ Sch 80 6⬙ Sch 120 6⬙ Sch 160 XX
6.625
0.280 0.432 0.562 0.719 0.864
0.25
5.557 5.253 4.993 4.679 4.389
0.001063 0.001124 0.001183 0.001262 0.001345
8⬙ Sch 20 8⬙ Sch 30 8⬙ Sch 40 8⬙ Sch 60 8⬙ Sch 80 8⬙ Sch 100 8⬙ Sch 120 8⬙ Sch 140 XX 8⬙ Sch 160
8.625
0.250 0.277 0.322 0.406 0.500 0.594 0.719 0.812 0.875 0.906
0.375
7.375 7.732 7.231 7.063 6.875 6.687 6.437 6.251 6.125 6.063
0.000801 0.000807 0.000817 0.000836 0.000859 0.000883 0.000917 0.000945 0.000964 0.000974
0.250 0.307 0.365 0.500 0.594 0.719 0.844 1.000 1.125
0.375
9.500 9.386 9.27 9.00 8.812 8.562 8.312 8.000 7.750
0.000621 0.000629 0.000637 0.000656 0.000670 0.000689 0.000710 0.000738 0.000762
10⬙ Sch 20 10⬙ Sch 30 10⬙ Sch 40 S 10⬙ Sch 60 X 10⬙ Sch 80 10⬙ Sch 100 10⬙ Sch 120 10⬙ Sch 140 XX 10⬙ Sch 16
10.75
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.17
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
2.17
TABLE 2-3 Continued Outside diameter (inch)
Wall thickness (inch)
Rubber thickness (inch)
Pipe internal diameter (inch)
Relative roughness for rubber-lined pipe
12⬙ S 12⬙ Sch 40 12⬙ X 12⬙ Sch 60 X 12⬙ Sch 80 12⬙ Sch 100 12⬙ Sch 120 XX 12⬙ Sch 140 12⬙ Sch 160
12.750
0.250 0.330 0.375 0.406 0.500 0.562 0.688 0.844 1.00 1.125 1.312
0.375
11.500 11.340 11.250 11.188 11.000 10.870 10.624 10.312 10.000 9.750 9.376
0.000513 0.000521 0.000525 0.000528 0.000537 0.000543 0.000556 0.000572 0.000591 0.000606 0.000629
14⬙ Sch 10 14⬙ Sch 20 14⬙ Sch 30 S 14⬙ Sch 40 14⬙ X 14⬙ Sch 60 14⬙ Sch 80 14⬙ Sch 100 14⬙ Sch 120 14⬙ Sch 140 14⬙ Sch 160
14.000
0.250 0.330 0.375 0.400 0.500 0.594 0.750 0.938 1.062 1.250 1.406
0.375
12.750 12.626 12.500 12.374 12.250 12.062 11.750 11.374 11.126 10.750 10.438
0.000463 0.000468 0.000472 0.000477 0.000482 0.000489 0.000503 0.000519 0.000531 0.000549 0.000566
16⬙ Sch 10 16⬙ Sch 20 16⬙ Sch 30 S 16⬙ Sch 40 X 16⬙ Sch 60 16⬙ Sch 80 16⬙ Sch 100 16⬙ Sch 120XX 16⬙ Sch 140 16⬙ Sch 160
16.000
0.250 0.312 0.375 0.500 0.656 0.844 1.031 1.219 1.438 1.594
0.375
14.750 14.626 14.500 14.250 13.938 13.562 13.188 12.668 12.374 12.062
0.000400 0.000404 0.000407 0.000414 0.000424 0.000435 0.000448 0.000466 0.000477 0.000489
18⬙ Sch 10 18⬙ Sch 20 18⬙ S 18⬙ Sch 30 18⬙ X 18⬙ Sch 40 18⬙ Sch 60 18⬙ Sch 80 18⬙ Sch 100 18⬙ Sch 120 18⬙ Sch 140 18⬙ Sch 160
18.000
0.250 0.312 0.375 0.438 0.500 0.562 0.750 0.938 1.156 1.375 1.562 1.781
0.375
16.750 16.626 16.500 16.374 16.250 16.126 15.750 15.374 14.938 14.500 14.126 13.688
0.000353 0.000355 0.000358 0.000361 0.000363 0.000366 0.000375 0.000384 0.000395 0.000407 0.000418 0.000431 (continued)
Denomination (inch)
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
2.18
Page 2.18
CHAPTER TWO
TABLE 2-3 Continued Outside diameter (inch)
Wall thickness (inch)
Rubber thickness (inch)
Pipe internal diameter (inch)
Relative roughness for rubber-lined pipe
20⬙ Sch 10 20⬙ Sch 20 S 20⬙ Sch 30 X 20⬙ Sch 40 20⬙ Sch 60 20⬙ Sch 80 20⬙ Sch 100 20⬙ Sch 120 20⬙ Sch 140 20⬙ Sch 160
20.000
0.250 0.375 0.500 0.594 0.812 1.031 1.281 1.500 1.750 1.969
0.375
18.750 18.500 18.250 18.062 17.626 17.188 16.688 16.250 15.750 15.312
0.000315 0.000319 0.000324 0.000327 0.000335 0.000344 0.000354 0.000363 0.000375 0.000386
24⬙ Sch 10 24⬙ Sch 20 S 24⬙ X 24⬙ Sch 30 24⬙ Sch 40 24⬙ Sch 60 24⬙ Sch 80 24⬙ Sch 100 24⬙ Sch 120 24⬙ Sch 140 24⬙ Sch 160
24.000
0.250 0.375 0.500 0.562 0.688 0.969 1.219 1.513 1.812 2.062 2.344
0.375
22.750 22.500 22.250 22.126 21.874 21.312 20.812 20.224 19.626 19.126 18.562
0.000259 0.000260 0.000263 0.000265 0.000267 0.000270 0.000277 0.000284 0.000292 0.000309 0.000318
Denomination (inch)
*Dimensions for steel are based on ANSI B36.1 and B31.1. Absolute roughness of rubber is taken as 150 m.
2-3-4 Hazen–Williams Formula In the United States, the Hazen–Williams formula is often used by civil engineers because it is independent of the Reynolds number. Speed is calculated as: U = 1.319 CRH0.63S 0.54 in ft/s
(2-20)
1.85 Qgpm S = Hv /L = ᎏᎏᎏ 1.67 × C 1.85 × RH1.17
(2-21)
where Qgpm is expressed in US gallons per minute, and S = slope or head loss per unit length U = average velocity of fluid in ft/sec RH = hydraulic radius = area of pipe/perimeter of pipe C = Surface roughness coefficient (refer to Table 2-6) In SI units:
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.19
2.19
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
TABLE 2-4 Dimensions of North American HDPE Pipes for Pressure Ratings 50 psi to 110 psi at a Temperature of 23°C (73.4 °F) Pressure rating
DR 32.5 50 psi
DR 26 64 psi
DR 21 80 psi
DR 17 100 psi
DR 15.5 110 psi
Pipe size (inch)
Average outside diameter (inch)
Average inside diameter (inch)
Average inside diameter (inch)
Average inside diameter (inch)
Average inside diameter (inch)
Average inside diameter (inch)
3 4 5 6 7 8 10 12 13 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32M 36 40M 42 48M
3.500 4.500 5.563 6.625 7.125 8.625 10.750 12.750 13.375 14.000 16.000 18.000 20.000 22.000 24.000 26.000 28.000 30.000 31.594 36.000 39.469 42.000 47.382
3.214 4.133 5.109 6.084 6.544 7.921 9.874 11.711 12.285 12.859 14.696 16.533 18.370 20.206 22.043 23.880 25.717 27.554 29.054 33.054 36.225 38.576 43.526
3.147 4.046 5.001 5.957 6.406 7.754 9.665 11.463 12.025 12.586 14.385 16.183 17.982 19.778 21.577 23.375 25.174 26.971 28.414 32.366 35.469 37.760 42.616
3.063 3.938 4.870 5.798 6.237 7.550 9.410 11.160 11.707 12.253 14.005 15.755 17.507 19.257 21.007 22.759 24.508 26.258 27.663 31.510 34.561 36.761 41.489
3.021 3.885 4.802 5.720 6.150 7.446 9.279 11.005 11.545 12.086 13.812 15.539 17.265 18.992 20.718 22.445 24.171 25.898 27.288 31.075
6.193 6.661 8.063 10.048 11.919 12.502 13.086 14.967 16.826 18.696 20.565 22.435 24.304 26.173 28.043 29.541 33.651 35.898 39.261 44.302
U = 0.8492 CRH0.63S 0.54 in m/s
(2-22)
All parameters in Equation 2-22 must be in SI units. There is no consistency in using the Hazen–Williams formula from small to large pipes. Despite the fact that commercial publications from pipe suppliers sometimes use Hazen–Williams equations to determine pressure loss of slurries, this method is highly discouraged for long pipelines.
2.4 THE HYDRAULIC FRICTION GRADIENT OF WATER IN RUBBER-LINED STEEL PIPES Equations 2-15 to 2-19 have established a relationship between the friction factor and the Reynolds number. To compute the latter, the properties of water as a carrier fluid are presented in Tables 2-7 and 2-8.
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.20
2.20
CHAPTER TWO
TABLE 2-5 Dimensions of North American HDPE Pipes for Pressure Ratings 128 psi to 300 psi at a Temperature of 23°C (73.4 °F) Pressure rating
DR 13.5 128 psi
DR11 160 psi
DR 9 200 psi
DR 7.3 254 psi
DR6.3 300 psi
Pipe size (inch)
Average outside diameter (inch)
Average inside diameter (inch)
Average inside diameter (inch)
Average inside diameter (inch)
Average inside diameter (inch)
Average inside diameter (inch)
3 4 5 6 7 8 10 12 13 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32M
3.500 4.500 5.563 6.625 7.125 8.625 10.750 12.750 13.375 14.000 16.000 18.000 20.000 22.000 24.000 26.000 28.000 30.000 31.594
2.951 3.795 4.690 5.584 6.006 7.270 9.062 10.749 11.274 11.802 13.488 15.174 16.880 18.544 20.231 21.917 23.603 25.289 26.645
2.826 3.633 4.490 5.349 5.751 6.693 8.679 10.293 10.797 11.301 12.915 14.532 16.145 17.780 19.374 20.988 22.606 24.219 25.527
2.675 3.440 4.253 5.065 5.446 6.594 8.219 9.745 10.225 10.701 12.231 13.760 15.289 16.819 18.346 19.875 21.405 22.934
2.485 3.194 3.948 4.700 5.056 6.119 7.627 9.046 9.491 9.934 11.853 12.772 14.191 —
2.321 2.986 3.690 4.395 4.727 5.723 7.133 8.459 8.674 9.289 10.615 — — —
TABLE 2-6 Hazen–Williams Roughness Coefficients Description Extremely smooth pipe Very smooth pipe Concrete pipe Riveted new pipes and tiled channels Normal cast pipes, 10 year old steel pipes, masonry channels Very rough pipes
Roughness coefficient 140 130 120 110 100 60
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.21
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
2.21
TABLE 2-7 Physical Properties of Water in SI Units
Temperature T (°C) 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Density L (kg/m3)
Dynamic viscosity, kinematic viscosity (mPa·s)
Kinematic viscosity, dynamic viscosity (km2/s)
Surface tension in contact with air (N/m)
Vapor pressure at atmospheric pressure (kN/m2)
999.8 1000 999.7 999.1 998.2 997.0 995.7 992.2 988.0 983.2 977.8 971.8 965.3 958.4
1.781 1.518 1.307 1.139 1.002 0.890 0.798 0.653 0.547 0.466 0.404 0.354 0.315 0.282
1.785 1.519 1.306 1.139 1.003 0.893 0.800 0.658 0.553 0.474 0.413 0.364 0.326 0.294
0.0756 0.0749 0.0742 0.0735 0.0728 0.0720 0.0712 0.0696 0.0679 0.0662 0.0644 0.0626 0.0608 0.0589
0.61 0.87 1.23 1.70 2.34 3.17 4.24 7.38 12.33 19.92 31.16 47.34 70.10 101.33
TABLE 2-8 Physical Properties of Water in USCS Units Temperature T
Density L
Kinematic viscosity
Dynamic viscosity
Surface tension in contact with air
Vapor pressure at atmospheric pressure
(°F)
(slug/ft3)
(lbf-sec/ft2)
(ft2/sec)
(lbf/ft)
(psia)
32 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 180 190 200 212
1.940 1.940 1.940 1.938 1.936 1.934 1.931 1.927 1.923 1.918 1.913 1.908 1.902 1.896 1.890 1.883 1.876 1.868 1.860
0.00003746 0.00003229 0.00002735 0.00002359 0.0000205 0.00001799 0.00001595 0.00001424 0.00001284 0.00001168 0.00001069 0.00000981 0.00000905 0.00000838 0.0000078 0.00000726 0.00000678 0.00000637 0.00000593
0.00001931 0.00001664 0.00001410 0.00001217 0.00001059 0.00009300 0.00008260 0.00007390 0.00006670 0.00006090 0.00005580 0.00005140 0.00004760 0.00004420 0.00004130 0.00003850 0.00003620 0.00003410 0.00003190
0.00518 0.00614 0.00509 0.00504 0.00498 0.00492 0.00486 0.00480 0.00473 0.00467 0.00460 0.00454 0.00447 0.00441 0.00434 0.00427 0.00420 0.00413 0.00404
0.09 0.12 0.18 0.26 0.36 0.51 0.70 0.95 1.27 1.69 2.22 2.89 3.72 4.74 5.99 7.51 9.34 11.52 14.70
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
2.22
9:14 AM
Page 2.22
CHAPTER TWO
The friction losses are expressed by the following equation: fDV 2L H= ᎏ 2gDI
(2-23)
where H = head due to losses (in meters for SI units, in ft for USCS units) L = length of the pipe (in meters for SI units, in ft for USCS units) fD = Darcy friction factor DI = pipe inner diameter V = speed of flow in the pipe (m/s or ft/s) g = acceleration due to gravity (9.81 m/s or 32.2 ft/s) The hydraulic friction gradient is defined as the head loss per unit length. It is defined as fDV 2 H iw = ᎏ = ᎏ 2gDI L
(2-24)
This is a very important parameter that will be used in Chapter 4 to evaluate the friction loss of Newtonian flows. Calculations of the friction factor by Equation 2-18 require iterations. The Moody diagram is a logarithmic scale that is rather difficult to use and prone to reading errors. With modern computers, a simple program will give more accurate numbers for the Darcy friction factor than from reading the Moody curve on a difficult logarithmic scale. The following program was written for plain steel and rubber-lined steel pipes. It uses standard US pipe sizes and applies the Swamee–Jain equation (2-19). DIM PIP(300), t(300), a(300), q(300), ep(300) pi = 4 * ATN(1) DEF fnlog10 (X) = LOG(X) * .4342944 ‘ p refers to nominal size ‘ outside diameter is stated p2 = 2.375 p3 = 3.5 p4 = 4.5 p5 = 5.633 p6 = 6.625 p8 = 8.625 p10 = 10.75 p12 = 12.75 p14 = 14 p16 = 16 p18 = 18 p20 = 20 p24 = 24 p30 = 30 p36 = 36 p42 = 42 p48 = 48 INPUT “choose between steel (1) and rubber (2)”, ch IF ch = 1 THEN tr1 = 0 IF ch = 1 THEN tr2 = 0
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.23
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
IF IF IF IF ef IF IF
ch = 2 THEN ch = 2 THEN ch = 1 THEN ch = 2 THEN = e / .0254 ch = 1 THEN ch = 2 THEN
tr1 tr2 e = e =
2.23
= .254 = .375 .00006 .00015
LPRINT “steel pipe” LPRINT “rubber lined pipe”
‘2 FOR I = 1 TO 4 t(1) = .154 t(2) = .218 t(3) = .344 t(4) = .436 PIP(I) = p2 - 2 * t(I) - 2 * tr1 ep(I) = ef / PIP(I) LPRINT USING “ppe od = ##.### in pip id = ##.#### in thick = #.### in k/d = #.########”; p2; PIP(I); t(I); ep(I) GOSUB swamee NEXT I LPRINT LPRINT The program is repeated for all US sizes of pipes (not shown here) swamee: d1 = PIP(I) * .0254 a = .25 * pi * d1 ^ 2 FOR K = 1 TO 5 q = a * K * 1000 qus = (q * 60 / 3.7854) fd = .4 em = ep(I) Re = 1000 * K * d1 / .001 110 z = (em / 3.7) + (5.74 / Re ^ .9) y = fnlog10(z) fd = .25 / y ^ 2 1111 hl = fd * K ^ 2 / (2 * 9.81 * d1) PRINT “revised swamee factor “; fd LPRINT USING “veloc = ##.### m/s; flow q = ####.#### L/s; flow = ######.## gpm “; K; q; qus LPRINT USING “RE = #########; fd = #.#####; hL = #####.####”; Re; fd; hl LPRINT PRINT “iteration error in swamee friction factor “; dg
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.24
2.24
CHAPTER TWO
TABLE 2-9 Flow and Hydraulic Friction Gradient for Steel Pipes at a Speed of 1 m/s to 5m/s (3.28 to 16.4 ft/sec) for Water at a Density of 1000 kg/m3 (62.3 lbs/ft3) and a Kinematic Viscosity of 1 cP (2.09 × 10–5 lbf-sec/ft2) Using the Swamee–Jain Equation* Relative Wall roughness Speed Speed Denomination thickness for new of flow Flow of flow (inch) (inch) pipe (m/s) L/s (ft/s)
Flow Darcy US Reynolds friction gpm number factor
Friction gradient (m/m) or (ft/ft)
2⬙ Sch 40
0.154
0.001143
1 2 3 4 5
2.2 4.3 6.5 8.6 10.8
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
34.3 69 103 137 172
52,502 105,004 157505 210007 262509
0.0244 0.0227 0.0221 0.0217 0.0214
0.0237 0.0883 0.1927 0.3367 0.5204
2⬙ Sch 80
0.218
0.00121
1 2 3 4 5
1.9 3.8 5.7 7.6 9.5
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
30.2 60.4 90.6 121 151
49,251 98,501 147,752 197002 246253
0.0248 0.0231 0.0224 0.0220 0.0218
0.0257 0.0956 0.2087 0.3648 0.5637
2⬙ Sch 160
0.344
0.001400
1 2 3 4 5
1.4 2.9 4.3 5.8 7.2
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
22.9 45.7 68.6 91.4 114
42,850 85,700 128,549 171,399 214249
0.0258 0.0239 0.0232 0.0228 0.023
0.0306 0.114 0.249 0.434 0.671
3⬙ Sch 40
0.216
0.000770
1 2 3 4 5
4.77 9.5 14.3 19.08 23.8
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
75.6 151 227 303 378
77,927 155,854 233,782 311709 389636
0.02213 0.0206 0.0200 0.0197 0.0195
0.0145 0.054 0.118 0.206 0.319
3⬙ Sch 80
0.300
0.000815
1 2 3 4 5
4.3 8.5 12.8 17.1 21.3
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
67.5 135 203 270 337
73,660 147,320 202,980 294,640 368,300
0.0224 0.0209 0.0203 0.0199 0.0197
0.0155 0.0579 0.1264 0.2209 0.3415
3⬙ Sch 160
0.438
0.000900
1 2 3 4 5
3.5 7 10.5 13.9 17.5
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
55.3 111 166 221 277
66,650 133,299 199,949 266,598 332,248
0.0230 0.0214 0.0208 0.0204 0.0202
0.0176 0.0655 0.1431 0.2501 0.3866
4⬙ Sch 40
0.237
0.000587
1 2 3 4 5
8.21 16.4 24.6 32.8 41.1
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
130.2 260.4 391 521 651
102,260 204,521 306,781 409,042 511,302
0.0207 0.0193 0.0188 0.0185 0.0183
0.0103 0.0386 0.0843 0.1473 0.2278
4⬙ Sch 80
0.337
0.000617
1 2 3 4 5
7.4 14.8 22.3 29.7 37.1
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
117 253 353 470 588
97,180 194,361 291,541 388,722 485,902
0.021 0.01957 0.019 0.0187 0.0185
0.011 0.041 0.09 0.157 0.243
4⬙ Sch 160
0.531
0.000687
1 2
6 12
3.3 6.6
95 190
87,325 0.0215 174,650 0.0201
0.0126 0.047
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.25
2.25
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
TABLE 2-9 Continued Relative Wall roughness Speed Speed Denomination thickness for new of flow Flow of flow (inch) (inch) pipe (m/s) L/s (ft/s) 4⬙ Sch 160
Flow Darcy US Reynolds friction gpm number factor
3 4 5
18 24 30
9.9 13.2 16.5
285 380 475
261,976 0.0195 349,301 0.0192 436,626 0.019
Friction gradient (m/m) or (ft/ft) 0.102 0.179 0.277
5⬙ Sch 40
0.257
0.000461
1 2 3 4 5
13.3 26.5 39.8 53 66.3
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
210 421 631 841 1052
129,972 259,944 389,915 519,887 649,859
0.0196 0.0183 0.0178 0.0175 0.0173
0.0077 0.0287 0.0628 0.1098 0.1697
5⬙ Sch 80
0.375
0.000484
1 2 3 4 5
12.1 24.1 36.2 48.4 60.4
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
192 383 575 766 958
124,028 248,056 372,085 496,113 620,141
0.1981 0.0185 0.018 0.0177 0.0175
0.0081 0.0304 0.0665 0.1163 0.1797
5⬙ Sch 160
0.625
0.000539
1 2 3 4 5
9.7 19.5 29.2 38.9 48.7
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
154.3 308.6 463 617 772
111,328 222,656 333,985 445,313 556,641
0.0203 0.0189 0.0184 0.0181 0.0179
0.0093 0.0347 0.0759 0.1327 0.2052
6⬙ Sch 40
0.280
0.000389
1 2 3 4 5
18.7 37.3 55.9 74.6 93.2
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
295.4 591 886 1182 1477
154,051 308,102 462,153 616,204 770,255
0.0189 0.0176 0.0171 0.0169 0.0167
0.0062 0.233 0.051 0.0892 0.138
6⬙ Sch 80
0.432
0.000410
1 2 3 4 5
16.8 33.6 50.5 67.3 84
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
267 533 800 1066 1333
146,329 292,659 438,988 585,318 731,647
0.0191 0.0178 0.0173 0.0170 0.0169
0.0066 0.0248 0.0543 0.095 0.147
6⬙ Sch 160
0.719
0.000455
1 2 3 4 5
13.6 27.3 40.9 54.5 68.2
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
216 432 648 864 1,080
131,750 263,500 395,249 526,999 658,749
0.0195 0.0183 0.0177 0.0174 0.0173
0.0076 0.0282 0.0617 0.108 0.167
8⬙ Sch 40
0.322
0.000296
1 2 3 4 5
32.3 65.6 96.8 129.1 161.4
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
512 202,717 1,023 405,435 1,535 608,152 2,046 810,870 2,558 1,013,587
0.0177 0.0166 0.0161 0.0159 0.0157
0.0045 0.0167 0.0365 0.0639 0.0988
8⬙ Sch 80
0.500
0.000310
1 2 3 4 5
29.4 58.9 88.4 117.8 147.3
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
467 934 1,401 1,868 2335
0.0179 0.0047 0.0168 0.0176 0.0163 0.0386 0.0160 0.0675 0.0158 0.1044 (continued)
193,675 387,350 581,025 774,700 968,375
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.26
2.26
CHAPTER TWO
TABLE 2-9 Continued Relative Wall roughness Speed Speed Denomination thickness for new of flow Flow of flow (inch) (inch) pipe (m/s) L/s (ft/s)
Flow Darcy US Reynolds friction gpm number factor
Friction gradient (m/m) or (ft/ft)
8⬙ Sch 160
0.906
0.00347
1 2 3 4 5
23.5 47 70.6 94.1 117.6
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
373 746 1,118 1,491 1,864
0.0184 0.0172 0.0167 0.0164 0.0163
0.0054 0.0202 0.0443 0.0774 0.1197
10⬙ Sch 40 S
0.365
0.000236
1 2 3 4 5
51 102 153 204 254
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
806 254,508 0.0169 1,613 509,106 0.0158 2,419 763,524 0.0154 3,226 1,018,032 0.0151 4,032 1,272,540 0.0150
0.0034 0.0127 0.0277 0.0485 0.0750
10⬙ Sch 60 X
0.500
0.000243
1 2 3 4 5
48 96 145 193 241
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
764 247,650 1,527 495,300 2,291 742,950 3,054 990,600 3,818 1,238,250
0.017 0.0159 0.0155 0.0152 0.0151
0.0035 0.0131 0.0286 0.0501 0.0775
10⬙ Sch 120 XX 1.000
0.000269
1 2 3 4 5
39 78 116 155 194
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
615 222,250 1,230 444,500 1,845 666,750 2,460 889,000 3,075 1,111,250
0.0174 0.0163 0.0158 0.0156 0.0154
0.004 0.0149 0.0327 0.0571 0.0883
12⬙ S
0.375
.000197
1 2 3 4 5
73 146 219 292 365
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
1,157 304,800 0.0163 2,313 609,600 0.0152 3,470 914,400 0.0148 4,626 1,219,200 0.0146 5,783 1,524,000 0.0144
0.0027 0.0102 0.0223 0.0390 0.0603
12⬙ X
0.500
0.000201
1 2 3 4 5
59 117 177 235 293
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
928 273,050 0.0166 1,856 546,100 0.0156 2,784 819,150 0.0152 3,713 1,099,000 0.0149 4,641 1,365,250 0.0148
0.0031 0.0116 0.0255 0.0445 0.0689
12⬙ Sch 120 XX 1.000
0.00022
1 2 3 4 5
59 117 177 235 293
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
928 273,050 0.0166 1856 546,100 0.0156 2784 819,150 0.0152 3713 1,099,000 0.0149 4641 1,365,250 0.0148
0.0031 0.0116 0.0255 0.0445 0.0689
14⬙ S
0.375
0.000178
1 2 3 4 5
89 178 267 356 445
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
1,410 336,550 0.0159 2,820 673,100 0.0149 4,231 1,009,650 0.0145 5,640 1,346,200 0.0143 7,050 1,682,750 0.0141
0.0024 0.0090 0.0198 0.0346 0.0536
14⬙ X
0.500
0.000182
1 2 3
86 171 257
3.3 6.6 9.9
1,357 2,175 4,072
0.0025 0.0093 0.0202
173,050 346,100 519,151 692,201 865,251
330,200 0.016 660,400 0.015 990,600 0.0146
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.27
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
2.27
TABLE 2-9 Continued Relative Wall roughness Speed Speed Denomination thickness for new of flow Flow of flow (inch) (inch) pipe (m/s) L/s (ft/s) 14⬙ X
Flow Darcy US Reynolds friction gpm number factor
Friction gradient (m/m) or (ft/ft)
4 5
343 428
13.2 16.5
5,429 1,320,800 0.0144 6,787 1,651,000 0.0142
0.0354 0.0548
14⬙ Sch 120
1.062
0.000531
1 2 3 4 5
72 143 214 286 357
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
1,133 301,650 0.0163 2,266 603,301 0.0153 3398 904,951 0.01485 4531 1,206,602 0.0146 5664 1,508,251 0.0145
0.0028 0.0103 0.0226 0.0395 0.0611
16⬙ Sch 30 S
0.375
0.000155
1 2 3 4 5
118 236 354 471 589
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
1,868 387,350 0.0155 3,736 774,700 0.0145 5,604 1,162,050 0.0141 7,471 1,549,400 0.0139 9,339 1,936,750 0.0138
0.002 0.0076 0.0167 0.0292 0.0452
16⬙ X
0.500
0.0001575
1 2 3 4 5
114 228 342 456 570
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
1,807 381,000 0.0155 3,614 762,000 0.0146 5,421 1,143,000 0.0142 7,228 1,524,000 0.0139 9,035 1,905,000 0.0138
0.0021 0.0078 0.0170 0.0298 0.0461
16⬙ Sch 120
1.291
0.000176
1 2 3 4 5
91 182 274 365 456
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
1,446 340,817 0.0159 2,892 681,634 0.0149 4,338 1,022,452 0.0145 5784 1,363,269 0.0143 7230 1,704,086 0.0141
0.0024 0.0089 0.0195 0.0341 0.0527
18⬙ S
0.375
0.000137
1 2 3 4 5
151 302 452 603 754
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
2,390 438,150 0.0151 4,780 876,300 0.0142 7,170 1,314,450 0.0138 9,560 1,752,600 0.0136 11,949 2,190,750 0.0134
0.0018 0.0066 0.0144 0.0252 0.0390
18⬙ X
0.500
0.000139
1 2 3 4 5
146 293 439 586 732
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
2,321 431,800 0.0151 4,642 863,600 0.0142 6,963 1,295,400 0.0138 9,284 1,727,200 0.0136 11,605 2,159,000 0.0135
0.0018 0.0067 0.0147 0.0257 0.0397
18⬙ Sch 120
1.375
0.000155
1 2 3 4 5
118 236 354 471 589
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
1,868 387,350 0.0155 3,734 774,700 0.0145 5,604 1,162,050 0.0141 7,471 1,549,000 0.0139 9340 1,966,750 0.0138
0.0020 0.0076 0.0167 0.0292 0.0452
20⬙ Sch 20S
0.375
0.000123
1 2 3 4 5
188 375 563 751 939
3.3 2,976 488,950 0.0148 0.0015 6.6 5,952 977,900 0.0139 0.0058 9.9 8,929 1,466,850 0.0135 0.0126 13.2 11,905 1,955,800 0.0133 0.0221 16.5 14,881 2,444,750 0.0131 0.0342 (continued)
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.28
2.28
CHAPTER TWO
TABLE 2-9 Continued Relative Wall roughness Speed Denomination thickness for new of flow (inch) (inch) pipe (m/s)
Speed Flow Flow of flow US L/s (ft/s) gpm
Darcy Reynolds friction number factor
Friction gradient (m/m) or (ft/ft)
20⬙ Sch 30 X
0.500
0.000124
1 2 3 4 5
183 366 549 732 915
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
2,899 5,799 8,698 11,598 14,497
482,600 965,200 1,447,800 1,930,400 2,413,000
0.0148 0.0139 0.0135 0.0133 0.0132
0.0016 0.0059 0.0128 0.0225 0.0348
24⬙ Sch 20 S
0.375
0.000102
1 2 3 4 5
274 548 822 1096 1370
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
4,341 8,683 13,025 17,366 21,707
590,550 1,181,100 1,771,650 2,362,200 2,952,750
0.0142 0.0134 0.013 0.0128 0.01267
0.0012 0.0046 0.0101 0.0177 0.0273
24⬙ Sch S
0.500
0.000102
1 2 3 4 5
268 536 804 1072 1340
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
4,249 584,200 0.01425 0.0012 8,497 1,1684,000 0.01338 0.0047 12,746 1,752,600 0.01302 0.0102 16,995 2,336,800 0.01282 0.0179 21,243 2,921,000 0.01269 0.0277
*Dimensions are based on ANSI B36.1 and B31.1. Absolute roughness of steel is taken as 60 m.
‘INPUT “hit any key to continue”; m$ CLS NEXT K RETURN The range of speeds used to carry solids in Newtonian flows is typically between 1.5 m/s and 5m/s. Tables 2-9 and 2-10 present friction factor and head losses for water as a carrier fluid for plain and rubber-lined steel pipes. There is no point in tabulating other fluids here as they are rarely used for slurry mixtures. The hydraulic friction gradient of water in rubber-lined pipes in the range of 2⬙ to 18⬙ is presented in Figures 2-5 to 2-13. Rubber thickness of 6.4 mm (0.25⬙) was assumed for 2⬙, 3⬙, 4⬙, and 6⬙ (up to 150 mm) pipes. Rubber thickness of 9.5 mm (0.375⬙) was assumed for 8⬙ to 24⬙ (200 to 610 mm NB) pipes. HDPE friction head was plotted for similar sizes at SDR11 (suitable for 100 psi pressure), to mark the advantages of reduced friction at these sizes using HDPE instead of rubber-lined pipes, wherever it may be appropriate. The design engineer must take in account the pressure limitations of HDPE pipes versus rubber-lined steel pipes. The hydraulic friction gradient for HDPE pipes up to a size of 20⬙ (508 mm), and for speeds in the range of 1 to 5 m/s (3.3 to 16.5 ft/sec) is presented in Table 2-11 These curves and tables allow an easier and accurate determination of the hydraulic friction gradient of water than the Moody diagram.
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.29
2.29
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
TABLE 2-10 Flow and Hydraulic Friction Gradients for Rubber-Lined Steel Pipes at a Speed of 1 m/s to 5 m/s (3.28 to 16.4 ft/sec) for Water at a Density of 1000 kg/m3 (62.3 lbs/ft3) and a Kinematic Viscosity of 1 cP (2.09 × 10–5 lbf-sec/ft2) Using the Swamee–Jain Equation*
Pipe size (inch)
Wall thickness (inch)
Relative roughness Speed Speed Flow for new of flow Flow of flow US pipe (m/s) L/s (ft/s) gpm
Reynolds number
Darcy friction factor
Energy gradient (m/m) or (ft/ft)
39,599 79,197 118,796 158,394 197,993
0.0309 0.0297 0.289 0.0287 0.0287
0.0399 0.153 0.338 0.595 0.925
2⬙ Sch 40
Steel 0.154 0.003788 Rubber 0.250
1 2 3 4 5
1.2 2.5 3.7 4.9 6.2
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
2⬙ Sch 80
Steel 0.218 0.004123 Rubber 0.250
1 2 3 4 5
1 2.1 3.1 4.2 5.2
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
16.5 33 49.4 65.8 82.2
36,347 72,695 109,042 145,390 181,737
0.0317 0.0299 0.0296 0.0295 0.0337
0.045 0.171 0.377 0.665 1.033
2⬙ Sch 160
Steel 0.344 0.005008 Rubber 0.250
1 2 3 4 5
0.7 1.4 2.1 2.8 3.5
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
11.2 22.3 33.5 44.7 55.8
29,947 59,893 89,840 119,786 149,733
0.0337 0.0322 0.0317 0.0314 0.0312
0.0574 0.2195 0.4854 0.8551 1.3284
3⬙ Sch 40
Steel 0.216 Rubber 0.250
1 2 3 4 5
3.3 6.6 10 13.3 16.6
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
53 105 158 211 263
65,024 130,048 195,072 260,096 325,120
0.0269 0.0257 0.0253 0.0251 0.0250
0.0211 0.0808 0.1788 0.3150 0.4895
3⬙ Sch 80
Steel 0.300 0.002487 Rubber 0.250
1 2 3 4 5
2.9 5.8 8.7 11.6 14.5
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
46 92 138 184 230
60,757 121,514 182,270 243,027 303,784
0.0274 0.0262 0.0258 0.0256 0.0255
0.0230 0.088 0.1949 0.3435 0.5337
0.002791 3⬙ Sch 160 Steel 0.438 Rubber 0.250
1 2 3 4 5
2.3 4.5 6.8 9.1 11.3
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
36 72 108 144 180
53,746 107,493 161,239 214,986 268,732
0.0283 0.0272 0.0267 0.0265 0.0263
0.0269 0.103 0.228 0.402 0.624
4⬙ Sch 40
Steel 0.237 0.001679 Rubber 0.250
1 2 3 4 5
6.3 12.5 18.8 25.1 31.4
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
99 199 298 398 497
89,357 178,714 268,072 357,429 446,786
0.0247 0.0237 0.0233 0.0231 0.0229
0.0141 0.054 0.1195 0.2106 0.3273
4⬙ Sch 80
Steel 0.337 0.00178 Rubber 0.250
1 2 3 4 5
5.6 11.2 16.7 23.3 27.8
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
88.4 177 265 354 442
84,277 168,554 252,832 337,109 421,386
0.0251 0.0151 0.0240 0.0581 0.0236 0.1287 0.0234 0.2268 0.0233 0.352 (continued)
19.5 39 58.6 78 97.6
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.30
2.30
CHAPTER TWO
TABLE 2-10 Continued
Pipe size (inch)
Wall thickness (inch)
Relative roughness Speed Speed Flow for new of flow Flow of flow US pipe (m/s) L/s (ft/s) gpm
Reynolds number
Darcy friction factor
Energy gradient (m/m) or (ft/ft)
4⬙ Sch 160
Steel 0.531 0.002015 Rubber 0.250
1 2 3 4 5
04.4 8.7 13.1 17.4 21.8
03.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
069 138 207 276 345
074,422 148,844 223,266 297,688 372,110
0.0259 0.0248 0.0244 0.0242 0.0241
0.0178 0.068 0.151 0.265 0.412
5⬙ Sch 40
Steel 0.257 0.001281 Rubber 0.250
1 2 3 4 5
10.8 21.5 32.3 43.1 53.8
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
171 341 512 683 853
117,069 234,137 351,206 468,274 585,343
0.023 0.0221 0.0217 0.0215 0.0214
0.01 0.038 0.085 0.150 0.233
5⬙ Sch 80
Steel 0.375 0.001349 Rubber 0.250
1 2 3 4 5
9.7 19.4 29.1 38.8 48.5
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
154 308 461 615 769
111,125 222,250 333,375 444,500 555,625
0.0233 0.0224 0.022 0.0218 0.0217
0.0107 0.0410 0.0901 0.160 0.249
5⬙ Sch 160
Steel 0.625 0.00152 Rubber 0.250
1 2 3 4 5
7.61 3.3 15.2 6.6 22.8 9.9 30.4 13.2 38.0 16.5
121 241 362 482 603
98,425 196,850 295,275 393,700 492,125
0.024 0.0231 0.0227 0.0225 0.0224
0.0124 0.0478 0.1058 0.1865 0.2898
6⬙ Sch 40
Steel 0.280 0.001063 Rubber 0.250
1 2 3 4 5
15.6 31.3 47 62.5 78.2
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
248 496 744 992 1240
141,148 282,296 423,443 564,591 705,739
0.0219 0.0211 0.0207 0.0206 0.0204
248 496 744 992 1240
6⬙ Sch 80
Steel 0.432 0.001124 Rubber 0.250
1 2 3 4 5
14 28 42 56 70
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
222 443 665 886 1108
133,426 266,852 400,279 533,705 667,131
0.0222 0.0214 0.0210 0.0208 0.0207
0.0085 0.0326 0.0723 0.1274 0.198
6⬙ Sch 160
Steel 0.719 0.001262 Rubber 0.250
1 2 3 4 5
11.1 22.2 33.3 44.4 55.5
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
176 352 528 703 879
118.847 237,693 356,540 475,386 594,233
0.0229 0.0219 0.0215 0.0215 0.0213
0.0098 0.0377 0.0835 0.1472 0.2288
8⬙ Sch 40
Steel 0.322 0.000817 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
26.5 53 79.5 106 132
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
420 840 1,260 1,680 2,100
183,667 367,335 551,002 734,670 918,337
0.0205 0.0198 0.0195 0.0193 0.0192
0.0057 0.0219 0.0486 0.0856 0.1331
8⬙ Sch 80
Steel 0.500 0.000859 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3
24 48 72
3.3 6.6 9.9
380 760 1,139
174,625 349,250 523,875
0.0208 0.0199 0.0197
0.006 0.0233 0.0517
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.31
2.31
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
TABLE 2-10 Continued
Pipe size (inch)
Wall thickness (inch)
Relative roughness Speed Speed Flow for new of flow Flow of flow US pipe (m/s) L/s (ft/s) gpm
8⬙ Sch 80
Reynolds number
Darcy friction factor
Energy gradient (m/m) or (ft/ft)
4 5
96 120
13.2 16.5
1,519 1898
698,500 0.0195 873,125 0.0194
0.0912 0.142
19 37 6 75 93
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
295 590 886 1,181 1,476
154,000 308,000 462,001 616,001 770,001
0.0215 0.0206 0.0203 0.0201 0.020
0.0071 0.0273 0.0604 0.1065 0.1656
8⬙ Sch 160
Steel 0.906 0.000974 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
10⬙ Sch 40 S
Steel 0.365 0.000637 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
43.5 3.3 87 6.6 131 9.9 174 13.2 218 16.5
690 235,458 1,380 470,916 2,071 706,374 2,761 941,832 3,451 1,177,290
0.0194 0.0186 0.0183 0.0182 0.0181
0.0042 0.0161 0.0357 0.063 0.098
10⬙ Sch 60 X
Steel 0.500 0.000656 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
41 82 123 164 205
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
651 228,600 1,301 457,200 1,952 658,800 2,602 914,400 3,253 1,143,000
0.0195 0.0188 0.0185 0.0183 0.0182
0.0044 0.0167 0.0371 0.0653 0.1016
10⬙ Sch 120 XX
Steel 1.000 0.000738 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
32 65 97 130 162
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
514 203,200 1,028 406,400 1,542 609,600 2,056 812,800 2,570 1,016,000
0.0201 0.0198 0.0189 0.0188 0.0187
0.0050 0.0193 0.0429 0.0756 0.1174
12⬙ S
Steel 0.375 0.000525 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
64.1 3.3 128.3 6.6 192.4 9.9 256.5 13.2 320.7 16.5
1,017 285,750 0.01853 2,033 571,500 0.0178 3,049 857,250 0.01755 4,066 1,143,000 0.0174 5,082 1,428,750 0.0173
0.0033 0.0127 0.0282 0.0497 0.0722
12⬙ X
Steel 0.500 0.000537 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
61 123 184 245 307
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
972 279,400 0.0186 1,943 558,800 0.0179 2,915 838,200 0.0176 3,887 1,117,600 0.0175 4,859 1,397,000 0.0174
0.0034 0.0131 0.029 0.051 0.079
12⬙ Sch 120 XX
Steel 1.000 0.000591 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
51 101 152 203 253
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
803 254,000 0.0190 1606 508,000 0.0183 2409 762,000 0.0180 3212 1,016,000 0.0179 4015 1,270,000 0.0179
0.038 0.0147 0.0326 0.0574 0.0892
14⬙ S
Steel 0.375 0.000472 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
79 158 238 317 396
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
1,255 317,500 0.0181 2,510 635,000 0.0174 3,765 952,500 0.0171 5,020 1,270,000 0.0170 6,275 1,587,500 0.0169
0.0029 0.0112 0.0248 0.0437 0.0679
(continued)
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.32
2.32
CHAPTER TWO
TABLE 2-10 Continued
Pipe size (inch)
Wall thickness (inch)
Relative roughness Speed Speed Flow for new of flow Flow of flow US pipe (m/s) L/s (ft/s) gpm
Reynolds number
Darcy friction factor
Energy gradient (m/m) or (ft/ft)
14⬙ X
Steel 0.500 0.000482 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
76 152 228 304 380
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
1,205 311,150 2,410 622,300 3,616 933,450 4,820 1,244,600 6,026 1,555,750
0.0182 0.0175 0.0172 0.0171 0.0170
0.003 0.0115 0.0254 0.0447 0.0695
14⬙ Sch 120
Steel 1.062 0.000531 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
63 125 188 251 314
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
997 282,600 1988 565,201 2983 847,801 3977 1,130,402 4971 1,413,002
0.0186 0.0179 0.0176 0.0175 0.0174
0.0034 0.0129 0.0286 0.0503 0.0783
16⬙ Sch 30 S
Steel 0.375 0.000407 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
107 213 319 426 532
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
1,689 368,300 3,377 736,600 5,066 1,104,900 6,755 1,473,200 8,443 1,841,500
0.0175 0.0168 0.0166 0.0165 0.0164
0.0024 0.0093 0.0207 0.0364 0.0566
16⬙ X
Steel 0.500 0.000414 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
103 206 309 412 515
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
1,631 361,950 3,262 713,900 4,893 1,085,850 6,524 1,447,800 8,155 1,809,750
0.0176 0.0169 0.0167 0.0165 0.0164
0.0025 0.0095 0.0211 0.0372 0.0578
16⬙ Sch 120
Steel 1.291 0.000466 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
81 162 243 324 405
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
1,289 321,767 2,578 643,534 3867 965,302 5155 1,287,069 6444 1,608,836
0.0180 0.0174 0.0171 0.0169 0.0169
0.0029 0.011 0.0244 0.0429 0.0668
18⬙ S
Steel 0.375 0.000358 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
138 276 414 552 690
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
2,187 419,100 4,373 838,200 6,560 1,257,300 8,746 1,676,400 10,933 2,095,500
0.0170 0.0164 0.0161 0.0160 0.0159
0.002 0.008 0.0176 0.0311 0.0484
18⬙ X
Steel 0.500 0.000363 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
134 268 401 535 669
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
2,121 412,750 4,241 825,500 6,362 1,238,250 8,483 1,651,000 10,604 2,063,750
0.0171 0.0164 0.0162 0.0160 0.0159
0.0021 0.0081 0.0180 0.0317 0.0493
18⬙ Sch 120
Steel 1.375 0.000407 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
107 213 320 426 533
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
1,689 368,300 3,377 736,600 5,066 1,104,900 6,755 1,473,200 8,443 1,841,500
0.0175 0.0168 0.0166 0.0165 0.0164
0.0024 0.0093 0.0207 0.0364 0.0566
20⬙ Sch 20S
Steel 0.375 0.000319 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3
173 346 520
3.3 6.6 9.9
2,7495 469,900 497 939,800 8,246 1,409,700
0.0166 0.0159 0.0157
0.0018 0.0069 0.0154
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.33
2.33
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
TABLE 2-10 Continued
Pipe size (inch)
Wall thickness (inch)
Relative roughness Speed Speed Flow for new of flow Flow of flow US pipe (m/s) L/s (ft/s) gpm
20⬙ Sch 20S
Reynolds number
Darcy friction factor
Energy gradient (m/m) or (ft/ft)
4 5
694 867
13.2 16.5
10,995 1,879,600 0.0156 13,744 2,349,500 0.0155
0.0271 0.0421
20⬙ Sch 30 X
Steel 0.500 0.000324 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
169 338 506 675 844
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
2,675 463,550 0.0166 5,350 927,100 0.0160 8,025 1,390,650 0.0158 10,670 1,854,200 0.0156 13,375 2,317,750 0.0155
0.0018 0.0070 0.0156 0.0275 0.0428
24⬙ Sch 20 S
Steel 0.375 0.000262 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
257 513 780 1,026 1,283
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
4,066 8,132 12,198 16,284 20,330
571,500 1,143,000 1,714,500 2,286,000 2,857,500
0.0159 0.0153 0.0151 0.0150 0.0149
0.0014 0.0055 0.0121 0.0214 0.0332
0.000265 24⬙ Sch S Steel 0.500 Rubber 0.375
1 2 3 4 5
251 502 753 1,003 1,254
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
3,976 7,952 11,930 15,904 19,880
565,150 1,130,300 1,695,450 2,260,600 2,825,700
0.0159 0.0154 0.0151 0.0150 0.0149
0.0014 0.0055 0.0123 0.0216 0.0336
*Dimensions are based on ANSI B36.1 and B31.1. Absolute roughness of rubber is input as 150 m (0.000492 ft).
2-5 DYNAMICS OF THE BOUNDARY LAYER Boundary layer theory has been extensively covered by a number of authors. A book by Schlichting (1968) is considered one of the classical references on this subject. When a uniform flow approaches a plate, the particles at the wall of the plate are slowed down by the dynamic viscosity of the fluid. A layer called the boundary layer develops. When the flow enters a pipe, effects develop at the entrance until the flow is uniform.
2-5-1 Entrance Length Flow in a pipe at relatively low speed when the Reynolds number is smaller than 2500 is characterized by a certain distance called “entrance length,” over which the velocity profile takes the final parabolic shape shown in Figure 2-14. The length Le is expressed as Le = 0.028 DiRe For turbulent flows, the entrance length is equivalent to 50 times the inner diameter.
9:14 AM
Page 2.34
2.34
0
40
5 m/s
sch
0.8 0.7
4 m/s
0.6 0.5 0.4 3 m/s
0.3 0.2
2.0 4.0 6.0 Flow Rate (L/s)
rometers (0.000492 ft)
0.8
16.5 ft/sec 40
1.0 0.9
8.0
0
0.0
1 m/s
sch 8
0.0
2 m/s
sch
0.1
Hydraulic friction gradient (ft/ft)
sch 8
0.9
60
1.0
sch 1
Hydraulic friction gradient (m/m)
CHAPTER TWO
60
2/28/02
sch 1
abul-2.qxd
0.7 13.2 ft/sec
0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3
9.9ft/sec
0.2 0.1 0.0
6.6 ft/sec 3.3 ft/sec
0.0 20 40 60 80 100 120 Flow Rate (US gallons/min) FIGURE 2-5 Hydraulic friction gradient for water in a rubber-lined 2⬙ pipe, Sch 40, Sch 80 and Sch 160. Caculations for 2⬙ steel pipe. Rubber thickness = 0.250⬙ (6.4 mm). Rubber roughness = 150 m (0.000492 ft).
rometers (0.000492 ft)
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.35
2.35
Hydraulic friction gradient (m/m) (m/m)
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
0.7 5 m/s
0.6 0.5
h sc 4 m/s
0.4
h sc
Rubber Lined Steel Pipes
80
40 sch
0.3
4 m/s
3 m/s
2 m/s
0.1
HDPE SDR 11 5 m/s
3 m/s
0.2
2 m/s
1 m/s
0.0 0.0
Hydraulic friction (ft/ft)gradient (ft/ft)
0 16
2.0
4.0
6.0
8.0
10.0
12.0
14.0
16.0 18.0 20.0 Flow Rate (L/s)
0.7 0.6 0.5 13.2 ft/sec
0.4 0.3
16.5 ft/sec 0 16 h sc
Rubber Lined Steel Pipes 0 h8 sc
40 sch
9.9ft/sec
0.2 0.0 0
16.5 ft/sec
9.9 ft/sec
6.6 ft/sec
0.1
HDPE SDR 11 13.2 ft/sec
6.6 ft/sec
3.3 ft/sec
20
40
60
80
100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 220 240 260 Flow Rate (US gallons/min)
FIGURE 2-6 Hydraulic friction gradient for water in a rubber-lined 3⬙ pipe, Sch 40, Sch 80, and Sch 160. Rubber thickness = 0.25⬙ (6.4 mm). Rubber roughness = 150 m (0.000492 ft). 2-HDPE line 3⬙ SDR11 roughness 1.5 m (0.00000492 ft).
2-5-2 Friction Velocity Prandtl proposed a concept of friction velocity: Uf =
w
ᎏ =U ᎏ 冪莦 冪莦2 fN
(2-25)
Blasius conducted tests on turbulent flows in pipes and developed an equation for the shear wall stress in terms of the maximum velocity outside the boundary layer.
冢 冣
r w = 0.0225 (Umax)7/4 ᎏ R
1/4
(2-26)
The local magnitude of the velocity in a boundary layer at a height y above the wall is u ᎏ = 8.73(y+)n Uf
(2-27)
where n = 1/7 to 1/9 and where the nondimensional height parameter y+ is defined as the relative distance from the wall:
abul-2.qxd 2/28/02
5 m/s 4 m/s
0.1
2 m/s 3 m/s 1 m/s
0.0 0.0
2 m/s
10
20
30
Flow Rate (L/s)
40
HDPE SDR 11
sc h 80 40
13.2 ft/sec
16.5 ft/sec
sch
0.3
sch
Energy gradient (ft/ft)
5 m/s
0.2 3 m/s
160
0.4
sc h
sch 80 40
160 4 m/s
sch
0.3
Rubber Lined Steel Pipes
Page 2.36
2.36
Energy gradient (m/m)
0.4
9:14 AM
Rubber Lined Steel Pipes
0.2 16.5 ft/sec
9.9 ft/sec
0.1
13.2 ft/sec
6.6 ft/sec
9.9 ft/sec
0.0
6.6 ft/sec 3.3 ft/sec
0.0 100 200 300 400 500
HDPE SDR 11
Flow Rate (US gallons/min)
FIGURE 2-7 Hydraulic friction gradient for water in a rubber-lined 4⬙ pipe, Sch 40, Sch 80, and Sch 160. Rubber thickness = 0.25⬙ (6.4 mm). Rubber roughness = 150 m (0.000492 ft). 2-HDPE line 3⬙ SDR11 roughness 1.5 m (0.00000492 ft).
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.37
2.37
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
Energygradient (m/m)
0.30 Rubber Lined Steel
0.25 0.20
ch 4 m/s s
0.15 0.10
5 m/s 0 16
40 sch
80 sch
3 m/s
0.05
1 m/s
0.0
2 m/s
HDPE SDR11 0.0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Flow Rate (L/s) 0.30 0.25 Energy gr adient (ft/ft)
abul-2.qxd
16.5 ft/sec 60 1 ch s 13.2 ft/sec 80 sch
0.20 0.15
40 sch
0.10 0.05 0.0
9.9 ft/sec 6.6 ft/sec 3.3 ft/sec
HDPE SDR11 0.0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
Flow Rate ( US gallons/sec) FIGURE 2-8 Hydraulic friction gradient for water in a rubber-lined 6⬙ pipe, Sch 40, Sch 80, and Sch 160. Rubber thickness = 0.25⬙ (6.4 mm). Rubber roughness = 150 m (0.000492 ft). 2-HDPE line 3⬙ SDR11 roughness 1.5 m (0.00000492 ft).
Uf␥ y+ = ᎏ
(2-28)
and where u = velocity of the flow at distance y. The boundary layer can be divided into a number of sections. At small values of y+ up to 5, the velocity profile is linear in a sublayer (see Figure 2-15). The flow is considered to be laminar in the sublayer. Above y+ = 5, a buffer zone develops up to y+ = 50 and turbulence develops. The thickness of the boundary viscous sublayer ␦ is usually expressed as 11.6 11.6 ␦= ᎏ = ᎏ 兹苶 (苶 w苶) U
ᎏ 冪莦 8 fD
(2-29)
In the turbulent region, the velocity profile is established as Uf y u ᎏ = 5.75 log10 ᎏ + 5.5 Uf
冢 冣
(2-30)
abul-2.qxd 2/28/02
0.08 3 m/s
0.06 0.04 0.02
HDPE SDR11 2 m/s 1 m/s
0.0
20
40
60
80
100 120 140 Flow Rate (L/s)
h
40
sc
0.08 9.9 ft/sec
0.06 0.04 0.02
HDPE SDR11 6.6 ft/sec 3.3 ft/sec
0.0
0.0
h
13.2 ft/sec
0.10
sc
0.12
80
160
0.14
sch
Hydraulic friction gradient (ft/ft)
80 h
sc
4 m/s
0.10
40
sc
0.12
h
sch
160
0.14
16.5 ft/sec
0.16
Page 2.38
2.38
Hydraulic friction gradient (m/m)
5 m/s
0.16
Rubber Lined Steel 0.18
0
400
800 1200 1600 Flow Rate (US gallons/min)
9:14 AM
Rubber Lined Steel 0.18
2000
FIGURE 2-9 Hydraulic friction gradient for water in a rubber-lined 8⬙ pipe, Sch 40, Sch 80, and Sch 160. Rubber thickness = 0.375⬙ (9.5 mm). Rubber roughness = 150 m (0.000492 ft). 2-HDPE roughness 1.5 m (0.00000492 ft).
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.39
2.39
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
Hydrau lic friction gradient (m/m)
0.12 0.10
5 m/s
0.08
5 m/s
0.06
h sc " 10 3 m/s
0.04 0.02 0.0
2 m/s 1 m/s
0.0 40
80
40
4 m/s 4 m/s
40 ch s " 12 3 m/s
2 m/s 1 m/s
120 160 200 240 280 320 Flow Rate (L/s)
0.12 16.5 ft/sec
Hydrau lic friction gradient (ft/ft)
abul-2.qxd
0.10 0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02
9.9 ft/sec 6.6 ft/sec
16.5 ft/sec
13.2 ft/sec 13.2 ft/sec
" 12
40 sch
9.9 ft/sec
0.0 0.0
3.3 ft/sec
ch "s 0 1
40
800
1600 2400 3200 4000 4800 Flow Rate ( US gallons/sec) 6.6 ft/sec
FIGURE 2-10 Hydraulic friction gradient for water in a rubber-lined 10⬙ pipe, Sch 40 and 12⬙, Sch 40 pipes. Rubber thickness = 0.375⬙ (9.5 mm). Rubber roughness = 150 m (0.000492 ft). 2-HDPE roughness 1.5 m (0.00000492 ft).
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.40
2.40
CHAPTER TWO
Hydraulic friction gradient (m/m)
0.08 5 m/s
0.06 DR "S
0.04
11
5 m/s
10
0.02
DR "S
11
12
0.0 0.0 40
80
120 160 200 240 280 320 Flow Rate (L/s)
Hydraulic friction gradient (ft/ft)
0.08 0.06 0.04
" 10
0.02
R SD
16.5 ft/sec 16.5 ft/sec
11
DR "S
11
12
0.0 0.0
800
1600 2400 3200 4000 4800 Flow Rate ( US gallons/sec)
FIGURE 2-11 Hydraulic friction gradient of water in 10⬙ and 12⬙ SDR11 HDPE pipes. Roughness 1.5 m (0.00000492 ft).
The reader is encouraged to review the work of Schlichling (1968) for details of boundary layer theory. Example 2-5 Determine the boundary viscous sublayer thickness and friction velocity of Example 2-4. Solution in SI Units In Example 2-4, the Darcy friction factor was determined to be 0.0178. In Section 2.31 it was stated that fD = 4fN, therefore 0.0178 fN = ᎏ = 0.00445 4 Since the velocity of the flow is 1.467 m/s,
冪莦
冪莦
ff 0.00445 Uf = U ᎏ = 1.467 ᎏ = 0.0692 m/s 2 2 From Equation 2.28 the thickness of the viscous sublayer is calculated as 11.6 ␦= ᎏ U
ᎏ 冪莦 8 fD
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.41
2.41
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
30 ) (S ch
0.08
16 "S
S
0.07
14 "
0.06
" 18 5 m/s
4 m/s
0.05 0.04
S
3 m/s
0.03 0.02 2 m/s
0.01
1 m/s
0.0 0.0
100 200 300 Flow Rate (L/s)
0 09
400
500
600
Flow Rate (L/s) 30 )
0.09
(S ch
0.08 14 "
S
0.07 0.06 0.05
" 18
13.2 ft/sec
0.04
S
16.5 ft/sec
0.03
9.9 ft/sec
0.02 0.01
700
16 "S
Hydraulic friction gradient (m/m)
0.09
Hydraulic friction gradient (ft/ft)
abul-2.qxd
6.6 ft/sec 3.3 ft/sec
0.0 0.0
2000
4000 6000 8000 Flow Rate (US gallons/min)
10000
FIGURE 2-12 Hydraulic friction gradient for water in rubber-lined 14⬙ pipe, Sch 40 and 16⬙ S and 18⬙ S pipes. Wall thickness = 0.375⬙ (9.5 mm). Rubber thickness = 0.375⬙ (9.5 mm). Rubber roughness = 150 m (0.000492 ft).
11.6 (0.00129) ␦ = ᎏᎏ 1020 (1.467)
ᎏ = (4.72) 10 冪莦 8 0.0178
Solution in USCS Units 0.0178 fN = ᎏ = 0.00445 4 Since the average velocity flow in 4.8 ft/s,
冪莦
0.00445 Uf = 4.8 ᎏ 0.2264 ft/s 2
–7
m
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.42
2.42
CHAPTER TWO
0.08 11
0.07
0.05
5 m/s
18
R
11
0.04
16
"S
D
R
0.06
SD
5 m/s
11
5 m/s
"
0.03
"
R SD
14
Hydraulic friction gradient (m/m)
0.09
0.02 0.01 0.0 0.0
100
200
300
400
500
600 700 Flow Rate (L/s)
0.08 0.07 D
R
11
0.06 "S
0.05
16
18
"
R
11
SD
R
11
0.04
SD
16.5 ft/sec
"
0.03 14
Hydraulic friction gradient (ft/ft)
0.09
0.02 0.01 0.0 0.0
2000
4000 6000 8000 Flow Rate (US gallons/min)
10000
FIGURE 2-13 Hydraulic friction gradient of water in 14⬙, 16⬙ and 18⬙ SDR 11 HDPE pipes. Absolute roughness 1.5 m (0.00000492 ft).
g 2-
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.43
2.43
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
TABLE 2-11 Flow and Hydraulic Friction Gradient for HDPE Pipes SDR11 at a Speed of 1 m/s to 5 m/s (3.28 to 16.4 ft/sec) for Water at a Density of 1000 kg/m3 (62.3 lbs/ft3) and a Kinematic Viscosity of 1 cP (2.09 × 10–5 lbf-sec/ft2) Using the Swamee–Jain Equation Pipe inner Speed Pipe size diameter Relative of flow Flow (in) (in) roughness (m/s) L/s
Speed of flow (ft/s)
Flow US gpm
Reynolds number
Darcy friction factor
Friction gradient (m/m) or (ft/ft)
3
2.826
0.0000053
1 2 3 4 5
4.0 8.0 12.1 16.2 20.2
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
64 128 192 257 321
71,780 143,561 215,341 287,122 358,902
0.01917 0.01659 0.01532 0.0145 0.01391
0.0136 0.0471 0.0979 0.167 0.247
4
3.633
00000041
1 2 3 4 5
6.7 13.4 20.1 26.8 33.4
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
106 212 318 424 530
92,278 184,556 276,835 369,113 461,391
0.0182 0.0158 0.0146 0.0138 0.01329
0.01 0.035 0.0726 0.1223 0.1835
5
4.49
0.0000033
1 2 3 4 5
10.2 204 306 408 510
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
162 324 486 648 810
114,046 228,092 342,138 456,184 570,230
0.01738 0.01514 0.01403 0.01331 0.01279
0.0078 0.0271 0.0564 0.0592 0.1429
6
5.349
0.0000028
1 2 3 4 5
15 29 44 58 73
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
230 460 689 919 1,150
135,865 271,729 407,594 543,458 679,323
0.01677 0.01465 0.01359 0.01290 0.01241
0.0063 0.0220 0.0459 0.0774 0.1164
7⬙
5.7510
0.0000026
1 2 3 4 5
17 34 51 67 84
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
266 531 797 1,063 1,328
146,075 292,151 438,226 584,302 730,377
0.01653 0.01445 0.01341 0.01274 0.01225
0.0058 0.0202 0.0421 0.0711 0.1069
8⬙
7.270⬙
0.0000022
1 2 3 4 5
25 49 74 98 123
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
389 779 1,168 1,558 1,947
176,860 353,720 530,581 707,441 884,301
0.0159 0.0139 0.01296 0.01232 0.01186
0.0046 0.0161 0.0336 0.0568 0.0854
10⬙
8.675⬙
0.0000017
1 2 3 4 5
38 76 114 153 191
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
605 1,210 1,815 2,420 3,025
220,447 440,893 661,340 881,786 1,102,233
0.0152 0.0134 0.0125 0.0119 0.0114
0.0035 0.0124 0.0259 0.0439 0.0660
12⬙
10.293⬙ 0.0000015
1 2 3 4 5
54 107 161 215 268
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
851 1,702 2,552 3,404 4,254
261,442 522,884 784,327 1,045,769 1,307,211
0.01475 0.0130 0.0121 0.0115 0.0111
0.0029 0.0101 0.0212 0.0359 0.0541 (continued)
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.44
2.44
CHAPTER TWO
TABLE 2-11 Continued Pipe inner Speed Pipe size diameter Relative of flow Flow (in) (in) roughness (m/s) L/s
Speed of flow (ft/s)
Flow US gpm
Reynolds number
Darcy friction factor
Friction gradient (m/m) or (ft/ft)
13⬙
10.797⬙ 0.0000014
1 2 3 4 5
59 118 177 236 295
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
936 1,872 2,808 3,745 4,681
274,244 548,488 822,731 1,096,975 1,371,219
0.0146 0.0129 0.0120 0.0114 0.0110
0.0027 0.0096 0.0201 0.0340 0.0512
14⬙
11.301⬙ 0.0000013
1 2 3 4 5
65 129 194 259 324
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
1,026 2,051 3,077 4,103 5,129
287,045 574,091 861,136 1,148,182 1,435,227
0.0145 0.0128 0.0119 0.0113 0.0109
0.0026 0.0091 0.0190 0.0322 0.0485
16⬙
12.915⬙ 0.0000012
1 2 3 4 5
85 169 253 338 423
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
1,340 2,679 4,020 5,359 6,698
328,041 656,082 984,123 1,312,164 1,640,205
0.0141 0.0125 0.0116 0.0110 0.0107
0.0022 0.0078 0.0163 0.0276 0.0416
18⬙
14.532⬙ 0.000001
1 2 3 4 5
107 214 321 428 535
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
1,696 3,392 5,088 6,784 8,480
369,113 738,226 1,107,338 1,476,451 1,845,564
0.0138 0.0122 0.0114 0.0109 0.0105
0.0019 0.0068 0.0142 0.0240 0.0362
20⬙
16.146⬙ 0.0000009
1 2 3 4 5
132 264 396 528 660
3.3 6.6 9.9 13.2 16.5
2,094 4,187 6,281 8,375 10,469
410,108 820,217 1,230,325 1,640,434 2,050,542
0.0136 0.0120 0.0112 0.0107 0.0103
0.0017 0.0060 0.0125 0.0213 0.0321
From the Equation 2.28, the thickness of the viscous sub-layer is 11.6 × 2.7 × 10–5 ␦ = ᎏᎏ 1.973 × 4.8
ᎏ = 1.56 × 10 冪莦 8 0.0178
–6
ft
2-6 PRESSURE LOSSES DUE TO CONDUITS AND FITTINGS The sizing of pumps is based on determining pressure losses between the starting point (A) and the final delivery point (B) (Figure 2-16). It is important to know that the static pressure at (A) includes atmospheric pressure or the pressure of any pressurizing gas, and
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.45
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
2.45
Le
V
Di
FIGURE 2-14
Entrance length for flows in pipes.
the pressure due to the height of liquid above the centerline of the first impeller or impeller at suction. It is also important to know that static pressure at (B) includes any pressurizing gas at (B) and the height of liquid at (B) above the centerline of the pump’s impeller. The additional pressure losses between (A) and (B) include the friction losses and pressure losses in all the pipe fittings such as valves, elbows, expansions, contraction branches, and bypasses. Pressure is also lost at entry and exit as well. Such pressure losses are expressed in terms of the Darcy–Weisbach equation and in terms of pressure loss factors for each fitting. Total pressure loss due to friction:
U 2 Lj U 2 Hf = fD ᎏ ᎏ + ⌺Kf ᎏ 2 Dij 2 where Lj = length of the conduit j Kf = pressure loss of the fitting f
Turbulent layer
V + +
Buffer layer Viscous sublayer FIGURE 2-15 Boundary layer of flow over a plate.
(2-31)
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.46
2.46
g
CHAPTER TWO
6
H 2
5 Pipe Diameters H 1
FIGURE 2-16
Simplified pumping system between two tanks.
TABLE 2-12 Equivalent Length of Valves for Friction Loss of Calculations for Single-Phase Turbulent Flow
Fitting Gate valves Globe valves Angle valves Ball valves Butterfly valves Plug valves—straightway Plug valves—3 way through flow Plug valve—branch flow Stop check valve—straight through Stop check valve—angular 90 deg Swing check valve Lift check valve Tilting disc check valve Foot valve with strainer—poppet disc Foot valve with strainer—hinged disc
Equivalent length/diameter ratio 8 340 55 3 16 18 30 90 400 200 300 55 5–15 420 75
Minimum recommended speed for full disc lift m/s
Ft/s
2.12 2.89 2.32 5.4 1.16–3.08 0.58 1.35
6.96 9.49 7.59 17.7 3.80 to 10.13 1.90 4.43
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.47
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
2.47
0.5 0.4
Loss Factor K
abul-2.qxd
0.3 0.2 0.1 0.0 0 2 4 6 8 10 Ratio R/D (bend radius/pipe diam)
FIGURE 2-17 Loss Factors for rough wall bends for pipes 1–7⬙ (after Crane Technical Bulletin No 410).
The differential head that a pump must deliver to pump a liquid between (A) and (B) is therefore TDH = (PB – PA)/g + (ZB – ZA) + HfOB + HfOA where HfOA = the pressure losses due to conduits and fittings between the tank (A) and the pump, including entry loss HfOB = the losses due to conduits and fittings between the pump and tank (B), including exit losses Table 2-12 presents examples of loss coefficients for fittings. Some practical considerations limit the use of fittings in slurry circuits. For example, elbows should have a minimum radius of three pipe diameters to avoid short turns (see Figure 2-17). Such an approach minimizes wear. Example 2-6 The fluid of Example 2-4 is pumped at a flow rate of 3500 gpm through a 16 × 14 pump. The steel fittings include 14⬙ × 18⬙ reducer, an 18⬙ knife gate valve, three long radius 90° elbows with a diameter to radius ratio of 3. The length of the pipe is 355 ft. Determine the total dynamic head if the liquid level in the suction tank is 10 ft and the level in the discharge tank is 50 ft above the centerline of the impeller. Ignore the length of the suction pipe as negligible. Solution in SI Units Net static head: (50 ft – 10 ft) 0.3048 = 12.2 m Dynamic head at the entry of the pump: Di = 15.25 in or 0.387 m Suction Area = 0.1178 m2
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.48
2.48
CHAPTER TWO
0.221 Speed = ᎏ = 1.875 m/s 0.1178 Dynamic head at suction: 1.8752 U2 ᎏ = ᎏ = 0.18 m 2g 2 × 9.81 For a sharp entrance pipe, the recommended K factor is 0.5. Friction losses at the entry to the pump are calculated as follows: 0.5 × 0.18 = 0.09 m On the discharge of the pump for a 14 × 18 reducer, the loss factor is calculated from the area ratio as
冢
d 21 K = 1 – ᎏ2 d2
= 0.1681 冣 = 冢1 – ᎏ 17.25 冣 2
13.252
2
2
앫 For an18 ft full-bore gate valve, the loss factor K = 0.10 앫 For the elbow r/D = 3, the loss factor K = 0.14 앫 For the reentry pipe L/D = 65 Total friction losses:
冤
冥
355 × 0.3048 + 65 × 0.438 0.09 m + ᎏᎏᎏ × 0.0178 + (0.1681 + 0.10 + 3 × 0.14) 0.438 1.4672 × ᎏ = 0.774 m 2 × 9.81 TDH = 0.774 m + 12.2 m = 12.97 m Solution in USCS Units Net static head = 50 ft – 10 ft = 40 ft Speed in suction pipe is calculated as follows: ID = 15.25⬙ = 1.27 ft Flow Rate = 7.79 ft3/s Area = 1.267 ft2 7.79 Velocity = ᎏ = 6.15 ft/s 1.267 Dynamic head at suction: 6.152 ᎏ = 0.587 ft 2 × 32.2
The K factor for sharp entrance in 0.5. Loss during suction is 0.5 × 0.587 = 0.293 ft. On the discharge of the pump the K factor is determined as in the SI unit solution. Total friction losses are:
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.49
2.49
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
冤
冢
冣
冥
355 + 65 × 1.27 4.82 0.293 ft + 0.0178 ᎏᎏ + 0.1681 + 0.10 + 0.42 ᎏ = 2.44 ft 1.27 2 × 32.2 TDH = 40 + 2.44 = 42.44 ft
2-7 ORIFICE PLATES, NOZZLES, AND VALVE HEAD LOSSES The flow through an orifice plate, a nozzle, or a valve is reduced from the ideal theoretical value by a discharge coefficient: Q = Cd Qideal
(2-32)
The ideal theoretical flow is considered the product of speed and area at the opening of the orifice, valve, or nozzle. The theoretical velocity through the orifice is calculated as Vth = 兹2苶g苶h苶 =
ᎏ 冪莦 R 2⌬P
(2-33)
However, the velocity is typically smaller than the theoretical velocity: Vo = CveVth where Cve = velocity coefficient. The flow through an opening contracts from the full area. This is known as the vena contracta effect.
Reentrant tube
Sharp Edged
Square Edged
Reentrant tube
Length = 1/2 to
Stream clears
Length = 2-1/2
1 diameter
sides
diameters
V
V
C =0.52 d
C =0.61 d
V
C =0.61 d
C =0.73 d
FIGURE 2-18 Discharge coefficients of orifice plates and nozzles.
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
2.50
9:14 AM
Page 2.50
CHAPTER TWO
For a thin plate or sharp-edged orifice, the vena contracta is assumed to be one half of an orifice diameter d1 downstream from the orifice, but in reality the distance may be from 30% to 80% of d1. For flow of water at a high Reynolds number through a small orifice diameter, Lindeburg (1998) reported that the contracted area is approximately 61% to 63%. The coefficient of contraction is defined as area of vena contracta Cc = ᎏᎏᎏ orifice area
(2-34).
The total discharge is the product of the reduced velocity and the contracted area: Q = CveVth(Cc A1) The product of the velocity coefficient by the area contraction coefficient is called the discharge coefficient: Cd = CveCc
(2-35)
Q = Cd A1兹(2 苶g 苶h 苶)苶
(2-36a)
Q = Cd A1兹(2 苶⌬ 苶P 苶苶 /)苶
(2-36b)
actual discharge Cd = ᎏᎏᎏ theoretical discharge Typical values for discharge coefficients from nozzles and orifices are shown in Figure 2-18. The Cameron Hydraulic Handbook (1977) recommends a further correction for large openings when d2/d1 > 0.30:
冪莦
2gh Q = Cd A ᎏᎏ4 1 – (d1/d2)
(2-37)
This equation works for liquids with a dynamic viscosity similar to the viscosity of water. The discharge vena contracta and velocity coefficient presented in Figure 2-18 are based on controlled flow conditions upstream. Flow disturbances can affect the magnitude of these coefficients. Manufacturers of valves in North America have developed a valve coefficient to relate flow rate to pressure drop as Cv, which is defined as: ⌬Ppsi Qgpm = Cv ᎏ S.G.
冪莦
(2-38)
This coefficient is not dimensionally homogeneous and is not equal to the discharge coefficient from orifices and nozzles. Although the flow coefficient Cv was developed for control valves, a relationship is often established for other fittings in terms of the K factor: (29.9)(din)2 Cv = ᎏᎏ 兹苶 K
(2-39)
The reader should be very careful not to confuse Cv (the flow coefficient commonly used in North America) with the discharge coefficient Cd more commonly used in the rest of the world. Such a mix-up can lead to serious errors. Cv is not used outside North America and has no relationship to the terms defined in Equations 2-34 to 2-37. The reader should avoid the common confusion that it sometimes creates.
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.51
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
2.51
FIGURE 2-19 Cross-section of a Series 39 slurry check valve. (Courtesy of Red Valve Company, Carnegie, PA, U.S.A.)
FIGURE 2-20 Front view of a Series 39 slurry check valve. (Courtesy of Red Valve Company, Carnegie, PA, U.S.A.)
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
2.52
9:14 AM
Page 2.52
CHAPTER TWO
FIGURE 2-21 Slurry knife-gate valve cross-sectional drawing. (Courtesy of Red Valve Company, Carnegie, PA, U.S.A.)
FIGURE 2-22 U.S.A.)
Slurry knife-gate valve. (Courtesy of Red Valve Company, Carnegie, PA,
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.53
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
2.53
FIGURE 2-23 Slurry pinch valve, showing cut through the rubber sleeve. (Courtesy of Red Valve Company, Carnegie, PA, U.S.A.)
Manufacturers of slurry valves have developed very specific designs to meet the requirements of wear and operation without plugging. These include: 앫 앫 앫 앫 앫
Rubber-lined check valves Rubber-lined knife-gate valves Rubber-lined pinch valves Ceramic ball valves Plug valves
Special check valves are available for sewage and slurry flows. The Red Valve Company Series 39 valves (Figures 2-19 and 2-20) feature a special reinforced elastomer check sleeve. The valve check sleeve seals under reverse flow or back-pressure and opens under pressure from the pump. It does not incorporate any discs that may wear on contact with slurry. This type of valve is therefore different in design than the type shown in books on water flows. The consultant engineer should therefore request from the manufacturer of the slurry check valves the estimated K factor for pressure losses. The Red Valve Company Series 39 slurry check valves are available in sizes up to 48⬙ (1220 mm), with a choice of elastomers such as pure gum rubber, neoprene, Hypalon, chlorobutyl, Buna-N, EPDM, and Viton. Knife-gate valves for slurry flows (Figures 2-21 and 2-22) feature a metal gate sand-
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
2.54
9:14 AM
Page 2.54
CHAPTER TWO
FIGURE 2-24 Principles of operation of a pinch valve, pinched by a roller. (Courtesy of Red Valve Company, Carnegie, PA, U.S.A.)
wiched between two rubber linings (or cartridges). They are often installed on the suction side of slurry pumps to provide a method of isolating them during repairs and maintenance. Most knife-gate valves are rated to a maximum of 1 MPa (150 psi), but some manufacturers offer valves rated at 2 MPa (300 psi). Globe valves are not suitable for slurry applications because they wear rather rapidly. To control slurry flows, a rubber pinch valve is recommended (Figure 2-23). The valve features a special reinforced sleeve. The sleeve is closed by pinching using a special roller (mechanical pressure) (Figure 2-24) or by the use of air pressure (Figure 2-25). Ceramic ball valves are used as shut-off valves for pipelines, particularly to close under high pressure.
2-8 PRESSURE LOSSES THROUGH FITTINGS AT LOW REYNOLDS NUMBERS Certain slurry flows, particularly those of a non-Newtonian regime, do occur at relatively moderate Reynolds numbers and in laminar conditions (Tables 2-13 to 2-14). For many years, the method using the K factor and the equivalent length has been the most widely
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.55
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
2.55
FIGURE 2-25 Principles of operation of a pneumatically actuated pinch valve. (Courtesy of Red Valve Company, Carnegie, PA, U.S.A.)
accepted method. It is based on experimental data obtained usually in steel pipes at very high Reynolds numbers. As the Reynolds number is reduced closer to laminar flow, the K factor becomes inversely proportional to it. Since certain homogeneous slurries are sometimes pumped at relatively low Reynolds numbers, even quite close to the critical value, it is important to emphasize an alternative approach. Hooper (1992) emphasized the limitations of this method and proposed a two-K method: K1 K⬁ K = ᎏ + ᎏᎏ 1 + 1/D1-in Re
(2-40)
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.56
2.56
CHAPTER TWO
TABLE 2-13 Equivalent Length of Fittings for Friction Loss of Calculations for Single-Phase Turbulent Flow* Fitting Standard threaded elbow Standard threaded elbow Standard threaded elbow Mitre bend
Standard tee
Type
Length/Diameter Ratio
90 degree 45 degree Long radius 90 degree—5 diameter bend as used in slurry plants 15 degree bend 30 degree bend 45 degree bend 60 degree bend 75 degree bend 90 degree bend Through flow Through branch
30 16 16 4 8 15 25 40 60 20 60
*Data from Ingersoll Rand (1977).
where K1 = value of K at a Reynolds number of 1 K⬁ = value of K at high Reynolds numbers DI-in = internal pipe diameter in inches. Values of these two constants are presented in Table 2-15. Regarding the equivalent length method, Hooper (1992) wrote:
TABLE 2-14 Dynamic Loss Factor K for Expansions and Contractions, where Loss = KV2/2g* Fitting Pipe exit Pipe entrance Pipe entrance (flush)
Reentry pipe Sudden enlargements in pipes Sudden contractions in pipes Gradual enlargements in pipes Gradual contractions in pipes
Description Projecting sharp edged, rounded Inward projecting Sharp edged Bellmouth fillet/diameter = 0.02 Bellmouth fillet/diameter = 0.04 Bellmouth fillet/diameter = 0.06 Bellmouth fillet/diameter = 0.10 Bellmouth fillet/diameter = 0.15 and up
Less than 45 degrees Larger than 45 degrees Less than 45 degrees Larger than 45 degrees
*Data from Ingersoll Rand (1977).
Loss factor K 1.0 0.78 0.5 0.28 0.24 0.15 0.09 0.04 L/D = 65 K = (1 – d 21/d 22) K = 0.5(1 – d 21/d 22) K = 2.6 sin (/2)(1 – d 21/d 22)2 K = (1 – d 21/d 22)2 K = 0.8 sin (1 – d 21/d 22) K = 0.5(1 – d 21/d 22)兹(s 苶in 苶苶/2 苶)苶
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.57
2.57
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
TABLE 2-15 Constants for the Two-K Method* (after Hooper 1992) Fitting Elbows
Description 90°
45°
180°
Tees
Used as elbows
Run-through tee
Valves
Gate, ball, plug
Globe Globe Diaphragm Butterfly Check
Type Standard R/D = 1, screwed Standard R/D = 1, flanged/welded Long radius (R/D = 1.5), all types Mitered Elbow R/D = 1.5 1 weld 90° 2 welds 45° 3 welds 30° 4 welds 22.5° 5 welds 18° Standard (R/D = 1.0), all types Long radius (R/D = 1.5), all types Mitered, 1 weld, 45° angle Mitered, 2 welds, 22.5° angle Standard R/D = 1, screwed Standard R/D = 1, flanged/welded Long radius (R/D = 1.5), all types Standard, screwed Long radius, screwed standard, flanged/welded Stub-in-type branch Screwed Flanged or welded Stub-in-type branch Full line size,  = 1 Reduced trim,  = 0.9 Reduced trim,  = 0.85 Standard Angle or Y-type Dam type Lift Swing Tilting check
K1 at Re = 1
K⬁ at very high Re
800 800 800 1000 800 800 800 800 500 500 500 500 1000 1000 1000 500 800 800 1000 200 150 100 300 500 1000 1500 1000 1000 800 2000 1500 1000
0.40 0.25 0.20 1.15 0.35 0.30 0.27 0.25 0.20 0.15 0.25 0.15 0.60 0.35 0.30 0.70 0.40 0.80 1.00 0.10 0.05 0.00 0.10 0.15 0.25 4.00 2.00 2.00 0.25 10.0 1.50 0.50
*Use R/D = 1.5 values for R/D = 5 pipe bends, 45° to 180°. Use appropriate tee values for flowthrough crosses.
The equivalent-length method concept contains a booby trap for the unwary. Every equivalent length method has a specific friction factor ( f ) associated with it, because the equivalent lengths were originally developed from the K factor in the formula Le = KD/f. This is why the latest version of the equivalent length method (the 1976 edition of the Crane Technical Paper 410 . . . properly requires the use of two friction factors. The first is the actual friction factor for the pipe ( f ), and the second is a “standard” friction factor for the particular fitting ( fT). Thus the two-K method is as easy to use and as accurate as the updated equivalent-length method. The two-K method will be explored further in Chapter 5.
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
2.58
Page 2.58
CHAPTER TWO
2-9 THE BERNOULLI EQUATION The last few sections of this chapter examined the concept of friction and pressure losses. The presence of friction forces, changes in elevation between one point and another along the piping, the presence of a pump to add energy to the fluid, or a turbine to extract energy can all be expressed in terms of the extended Bernoulli’s equation: (Ep + Ev + Ez)1 + EA = (Ep + Ev + Ez)2 + EE + Ef + Em
(2-41)
U 22 P1 U 21 P2 ᎏ + ᎏ + Z2g + EA = ᎏ + ᎏ + Z2g + EE + Ef + Em 2 2 where subscripts 1 and 2 refer to points 1 and 2. Ep = P1/ = energy due to static pressure per unit mass U 21/2 = energy due to dynamic pressure per unit mass Z = location of point above a reference datum EA = energy added (e.g., by a pump) per unit mass EE = energy extracted (e.g., by a turbine) per unit mass Ef = Energy per unit mass due to friction losses Em = Energy lost due to fittings, per unit mass In USCS units.
2-10 ENERGY AND HYDRAULIC GRADE LINES WITH FRICTION When the total energy for flow in a pipeline is plotted against distance, a profile called the energy gradient line is obtained. The energy drops with friction or extraction through a turbine, and increases by absorption from a pump. The hydraulic gradient is the sum of the pressure and the potential energies. The hydraulic gradient is therefore smaller than the energy gradient by the dynamic head (Figure 2-26).
2-11 FUNDAMENTAL HEAT TRANSFER IN PIPES In many areas of the world, mining is done in cold climates (Figure 2-27). Long tailing pipelines are exposed to wind, snow, and freezing conditions. In some oil–sand processes, temperature is used to facilitate the pumping or separation of tar from sand. In other processes, hot slurries are fed to autoclave furnaces. The field of heat transfer is immense, but in the following paragraphs, some fundamentals will be reviewed. There are three main phenomena of heat transfer: 1. Conduction 2. Convection 3. Radiation
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.59
2.59
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
EGL EGL
2
V1 /2 HGL
EA
HGL
2
V2 /2
2
E v= V /2 Energy and Hydraulic Gradients
Energy and Hydraulic Gradients
For a pump
For an expansion
FIGURE 2-26 Energy and hydraulic gradients.
FIGURE 2-27 The construction of mines may require pipelines that operate in extremely cold environments. This water pipeline was insulated and heat-traced for an Arctic environment.
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.60
2.60
CHAPTER TWO
TABLE 2-16 Examples of Conductivity Range Material
Range of conductivity K, W/m °K
Range of conductivity K, Btu-ft/hr-ft2 °F
0.03–0.21 0.09–0.70 0.03–2.6 8.7–78 14–120 52–420
0.02–0.12 0.05–0.40 0.02–1.5 5.0–45 8.0–70 30–240
Insulators Nonmetallic Liquids Nonmetallic Solids Liquid metals Metallic alloys Pure metals
2-11-1 Conduction Heat transfer by conduction occurs essentially by molecular vibration and movement of free electrons. As metals have more free electrons than nonmetals, they are better conductors of heat. Thermal conductivity, also known as thermal conductance, is a measure of the rate of heat transfer per unit thickness. Examples of conductivity range are presented in Table 2-16 Thermal conductivity is a function of temperature. For metals it decreases with temperature, whereas for insulators it increases with temperature. To simplify matters, it is common to assume the thermal conductivity at the average temperature of 1–2(T1 + T2). 2-11-2 Thermal Resistance Defining heat transfer power as Qt, thermal resistance is defined as T1 – T2 Rth = ᎏ Qt
(2-42)
where Qt is expressed in watts or Btu/hr. For a flat plate with a thickness path length L and an area A, and if heat transfer occurs by conduction and kth is the thermal conductivity of the material, the resistance factor Rth is: L Rth = ᎏ kthA
(2-43)
For a layer of insulation around a pipe, this equation is expressed in terms of the inner and outer radius of the insulation layer: ln(RO/RI) Rth = ᎏ 2kthL
(2-44)
2-11-3 The R Value One term commonly used by the industry is the thermal resistance per unit area or R value.
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.61
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
T1 – T2 R Value = ᎏ Rth A Qt /A
2.61
(2-45)
2-11-4 The Specific Heat or Heat Capacity C The specific heat capacity is defined as the energy required to increase the temperature of a unit mass by a unit degree and is calculated as Qt = C m⌬T
(2-46).
2-11-5 Characteristic Length Characteristic length is defined as the ratio of the volume to its surface area and is calculated as V Lc = ᎏ As
(2-47)
2-11-6 Thermal Diffusivity Thermal diffusivity is a measure of the speed of propagation of a specific temperature into a solid. The higher the diffusivity, the faster the material will reach a certain temperature. Thermal diffusivity is calculated as kth ⬀= ᎏ eC
(2-48)
where e = thermal resistivity (⍀-cm or ⍀-in) ⬀ = diffusivity (m2/s or ft2/hr) Kth = conductivity (W/m-°K or Btu-ft/hr-ft2-°F) C = specific heat capacity (J/kg°K – Btu/lbm-°F) 2-11-7 Heat Transfer Heat transfer is essentially a transmission of energy from one body to another in a period of time. For this reason, it has the same unit as power in SI units, i.e., the watt. In USCS units Btu/hr is used. However, many equations ignore the time factor. Heat transfer per unit area qta is often used so that the total heat transfer Qt over an area A is calculated as Qt = qta A Qt = mC⌬T where m = the mass of the body ⌬T = the temperature change or power or rate of heat transfer The rate of heat transfer or power associated with the flow is expressed as Pwt = QC⌬T
(2-49)
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.62
2.62
CHAPTER TWO
Heat transfer can take different forms when slurry is stored in tanks, varies in thickness, or flows in pipes. In the northern climates, loss of heat can lead to frozen pipelines. In the hot climates, the heat absorbed from the sun leads to expansion of plastic lines and significant pipe stresses.
2-12 CONCLUSION In this chapter, some very important principles regarding water flows were introduced. Since water is the principal carrier of slurry mixtures, the tools developed in this chapter such as hydraulic friction gradients and methods to correlate the friction velocity with the friction factor will be extensively used for pipe flow and open channel flow of heterogeneous mixtures (Chapters 4 and 6). This chapter discussed some specific valve types such pinch, rubber sleeve, and check valves. These valves have their own experimental loss coefficients, which need to be obtained from manufacturers. This chapter presented the conventional K and the new two-K loss factors. The two-K factor as developed by Hooper is of particular importance for slurry flows at low Reynolds numbers. The engineer should therefore avoid the common pitfall of using published data on turbulent water flows for conventional waterworks valves when estimating the losses in a slurry system.
2-13 NOMENCLATURE A As C Cc Cd C Cv Cve din DH Di Dij E EA EE Ef Em Ep Ev Ez fD fN Fr F12 g
Cross-sectional area of the flow Surface area Hazen–Williams roughness factor Coefficient of contraction Discharge coefficient Specific heat or heat capacity Valve coefficient Velocity coefficient Pipe diameter expressed in inches Hydraulic diameter = 4A/P Conduit inner diameter (m) Inner diameter of the pipe j Energy per unit mass Energy added per unit mass Energy extracted per unit mass Energy due to friction loss per unit mass Energy lost due to fittings per unit mass Energy due to static pressure per unit mass Energy due to dynamic pressure per unit mass Potential energy per unit mass due to elevation above a reference point Darcy friction factor Fanning friction factor Friction force Force between points 1 and 2 Acceleration due to gravity (9.8 m/s2)
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 2.63
FUNDAMENTALS OF WATER FLOWS IN PIPES
gc h Hf Hv kth Kf L Lc Le Lj m P Ppsi Pwt Q Qgpm Qideal qth r RI RH R Ri RO Rth Re S S.G. T TDH u U Uf Umax VO Vth W y+ ZA ␥ d␥/dt ⬀ ␦
e
2.63
Conversion factor between slugs and lbm or 32.2 ft/sec2 Spacing between plates Head loss due to friction Head loss in the Hazen–Williams formula Conductivity Pressure loss of the fitting f Length of conduit or pipe Characteristic length Entrance length Length of the conduit j The mass of the body Pressure Pressure in psi Rate of heat power transfer Flow rate (m3/s) Flow rate expressed in US gallons per minute Ideal flow rate through an orifice as product of area and velocity Heat transfer per unit area local radius Radius at the inner wall of the pipe, or inner radius in an annular flow Hydraulic radius = area/perimeter Resistance factor for thermal insulation is the pipe inner radius (at the inside wall of the pipe) Outer radius in an anuular flow thermal factor Reynolds number Slope or head per unit length Specific gravity Average temperature Total dynamic head that a pump is required to develop Velocity of the flow at distance y Average speed of a flow outside the boundary layer Friction velocity Maximum speed in the boundary layer Practical velocity across an orifice due to vena contracta Theoretical velocity across an orifice weight The relative distance from the wall in the boundary layer Elevation of a point above a reference grade Shear strain Wall shear rate or rate of shear strain with respect to time Diffusivity The thickness of the boundary layer ␦ Linear roughness (m) Carrier liquid absolute or dynamic viscosity (usually expressed in Pascal-seconds or poise) Pythagoras number (ratio of circumference of a circle to its diameter) Duration of the shear for a time-dependent fluid Density in kg/m3 or slug/ft3 Thermal resistivity Shear stress at a height y or at a radius r
abul-2.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
2.64
w
Page 2.64
CHAPTER TWO
Wall shear stress kinematic viscosity (defined as absolute viscosity divided by density)
2-14 REFERENCES Hooper W. B. 1992. Fittings, Number and Types. pp. 391–397 of The Piping Design Handbook, Edited by J. J. McKetta. New York: Marcel Dekker. Ingersoll Rand. 1977. The Cameron Hydraulic Handbook. Ner Jersey: The Ingersoll Rand Company. Johnson, M. 1982. Non-Newtonian Fluid System Design. Some Problems and Their Solutions. Paper read at the 8th International Conference on the Hydraulic Transport of Solids in Pipe, Johannesburg, South Africa. Lindeburg, M. R. 1997. Mechanical Engineering Reference Manual. Belmont, CA: Professional Publications Inc. Schlichting, H. 1968. Boundary Layer Theory, 6th ed. New York: McGraw-Hill. The Hydraulic Institute.1990. Engineering Data Book. Cleveland, OH: The Hydraulic Institute. Wasp E., J. Penny, and R. Handy. 1977. Solid–Liquid Flow Slurry Pipeline Transportation. Aedermannsdorf, Switzerland: Trans Tech Publications.
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.1
CHAPTER 3
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
3-0 INTRODUCTION The physical principles of flow of complex mixtures are based on the interaction between the different phases, which may mix well or move in superimposed layers. In this chapter, the basic concepts of motion of particles in a carrying fluid will be presented, as well as the effect of their concentrations and boundaries. In the previous two chapters, we reviewed the physical properties of solids, single-phase flows, and some aspects of mixtures of both. Concepts of non-Newtonian mixtures are reviewed so the reader can understand the principles used to analyze complex homogeneous flows of very fine particles at high volumetric concentration. The physics of solid–liquid mixtures have been the subject of many publications, particularly by chemical and nuclear engineers. In this chapter, an effort is made to focus on the practical equations that a slurry engineer may use to accomplish his/her tasks. The engineer may have to use more than one equation when assessing a mixture to make an engineering judgment.
3-1 DRAG COEFFICIENT AND TERMINAL VELOCITY OF SUSPENDED SPHERES IN A FLUID One fundamental aspect to the transportation of solids by a liquid is the resistance, called the drag force, that such solids will exert, and the ability of the liquid to lift such solids, called the lift force. Both are complex functions of the speed of the flow, the shape of the solid particles, the degree of turbulence, and the interaction between particles and the pipe. One approach is to look at a vehicle that we have all come to know—the airplane. This distraction from the complex world of slurry flows is justifiable. 3-1-1 The Airplane Analogy When an airplane flies in a horizontal plane, it is subject to the forces of downward gravity, upward lift, and drag opposite to its flight path. To maintain steady flight, its engines 3.1
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.2
3.2
CHAPTER THREE
must develop sufficient thrust to overcome drag. The airplane must also fly above its stalling speed. The lift and drag are aerodynamic forces (Figure 3-1). They are proportional to the surface area, the density of air, the inclination of the airplane body with respect to speed, and the square of the speed. For the airplane wing, these forces are expressed as L = 0.5 CLV 2Sw
(3-1)
D = 0.5 CDV Sw
(3-2)
2
where = density of the fluid V = cruising speed of airplane CL = lift coefficient of wing airfoil CD = drag coefficient of wing airfoil The aerodynamic drag consists of two components: the profile drag and induced drag. The induced drag is proportional to the square of the lift. Airfoils are designed to maximize the lift-to-drag ratio, or to develop the most lift at the least drag penalty: CD = CD0 + kwC L2
(3-3)
where CD0 = the profile drag kw = a function of the shape of the wing (minimum for an elliptical wing and for a wing flying in ground effect) The value of the drag and lift coefficients are determined by the shape of the flying ob-
Thrust
Buoyancy Drag
Wing lift Drag Stabilizer lift
Weight
Thrust Weight
Weight
Forces on an aircraft in steady horizontal flight
Drag
Forces on a rocket in vertical flight
Forces on a free-falling particle immersed in a fluid
FIGURE 3-1 Lift and drag forces on moving objects.
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.3
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
3.3
ject, but also by the physical properties of a fluid, particularly the density, viscosity, and speed of motion. Nondimensional analysis, an important branch of fluid dynamics, allows the expression of these relationships by characteristic numbers. The Reynolds Number has already introduced in Chapter 2. For an airplane in a steady horizontal linear flight, the lift must overcome weight and the thrust drag. A rocket flying in a vertical plane must develop sufficient thrust to overcome drag forces as well as weight: L = W and T = D T=W+D
For an Airplane For a rocket in vertical flight
3-1-2 Buoyancy of Floating Objects The principle of Archimedes is well known. It states that the buoyancy force developed by an object static in a fluid is equal to the weight of liquid of equivalent volume occupied by the object. When the density of the object is less than the density of the liquid, the object floats, and in the inverse situation, the object sinks. For a sphere immersed in a fluid of density L, the buoyancy force is calculated from the weight of fluid the particle displaces: FBF = (/6)d g3L g
(3-4)
where FBF = buoyancy force dg = sphere diameter g = acceleration due to gravity (9.78–9.81 m/s2)
3-1-3 Terminal Velocity of Spherical Particles Although most solids are not spherical in shape, the sphere is the point of reference for the analysis of irregularly shaped solids. 3-1-3-1 Terminal Velocity of a Sphere Falling in a Vertical Tube When a sphere is allowed to fall freely in a tube, the buoyancy and the drag forces act vertically upward, whereas the weight force acts downward. At the terminal or free settling velocity, in the absence of any centrifugal, electrostatic, or magnetic forces W = D + FBF
(3-5)
d 2g
冢 6 冣d g = 冢 6 冣d g + 0.5 C V 冢 4 冣 3 g S
3 g L
D L
2 t
(3-6)
The drag coefficient corresponding to free fall of the particle is calculated as 4(S – L)gdg CD = 3LV t2 where dg = sphere diameter g = acceleration due to gravity, typically 9.8 m/s2 or 32.2 ft/sec2
(3-7)
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
3.4
Page 3.4
CHAPTER THREE
Vt = the terminal (or free settling) speed s = the density of the solid sphere in kg/m3 or slugs/ft3 L = the density of the liquid The terminal (or sinking) velocity is measured using a visual accumulation tube with a recording drum. Various mathematical models have been derived for the drag coefficient. Turton and Levenspiel (1986) proposed the following equation: 0.413 24 ) CD = (1 + 0.173Re 0.657 p Rep 1 + 1.163 × 104Re –1.09 p
(3-8)
Example 3-1 Using the Turton and Levenspiel equation, write a small computer program in quickbasic to tabulate the drag coefficient of a sphere. LPRINT “ Drag coefficient vs. Reynolds Number based on Turton, R., and O. Levenspiel” RE0= 1 15 FOR I=1 TO 10 RE=I*RE0 CD= (24/RE) * (1+0.173*RE^0.657)*(0.413/(1+11630*RE^-1.09) PRINT USING “RE= ###### ; Cd = ##.#### “; RE,CD NEXT I IF RE>1E6 THEN GOTO 30 RE0=RE
TABLE 3-1 Particle Reynolds Number and Corresponding Drag Coefficient for a Sphere Based on the Equation of Turton and Levenspiel (1986) as per Example 3-1 Particle Reynolds number, Rep 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Drag coefficient, CD
Particle Reynolds number, Rep
Drag coefficient, CD
Particle Reynolds number, Rep
Drag coefficient, CD
28.1520 15.2735 10.8485 8.5809 7.1908 6.2459 5.5588 5.0349 4.6211 4.2851 2.6866 2.0940 1.7729 1.5670 1.4216 1.3124
80 90 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000
1.2266 1.1571 1.0994 0.5025 0.6793 0.6085 0.5617 0.5281 0.5029 0.4832 0.4675 0.4547 0.3990 0.3878 0.3883 0.3927
6000 7000 8,000 9,000 10,000 20,000 30,000 40,000 50,000 60,000 70,000 80,000 90,000 100,000 200,000 300,000
0.3983 0.4042 0.4151 0.4151 0.4200 0.4497 0.4617 0.4671 0.4697 0.4709 0.4713 0.4713 0.4711 0.4707 0.4653 0.4609
Page 3.5
3.5
0.6
4
0.4
2
0.2
8000
2000
80
100
60
40
20
6000
0
0
4000
30
6
CD
CD
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
Rep
25
4
9:14 AM
10
2/28/02
Rep 0.6 0.4 0.2
0.6
0.2
Rep
Rep
3X10
1X10
5
0 2 4 6 8 10
0.4 5
Rep
CD
3
10
800
600
400
200
0
0
5
Rep
0.2
5
1X10
8X10
0.4
6X10
2X10
10
4
0
0.6
4
0.8
4X10
1.0
4
15
CD
1.2
4
20
CD
Drag Coefficient CD
abul-3.qxd
FIGURE 3-2 Drag coefficient of a sphere for Reynolds number smaller than 300,000.
GOTO 15 30 END Results are tabulated in Table 3-1 and presented in Figure 3-2 in a linear scale rather than a logarithmic scale. Linear scales are sometimes more useful to the mine operator who is in a remote area and has little time to waste on difficult logarithmic graphs 3-1-3-2 Very Fine Spheres For small particles in the range of a diameter d50 < 0.15 mm (0.0059 in), the most common equation was created by Stokes and reported by Herbich (1991) and Wasp et al. (1977), who indicate that the main forces are due to the viscosity effect in the laminar flow regime: D = 3dg
(3-9)
In the laminar regime, the drag coefficient is inversely proportional to the Reynolds number, i.e., CD = 24/Rep. The terminal velocity is expressed by Stoke’s equation: (S – L)d g2g Vt = 18L
(3-10)
Stokes’s equation is limited to particle Reynolds numbers smaller than 0.1, but has often been used for particle Reynolds Numbers as large as 1 (based on sphere diameter dg).
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.6
3.6
CHAPTER THREE
From Equation 3-10, Herbich (1968) pointed out that the radius of particles for which the validity of the equation is in doubt is expressed as 4.52L R= (S – L)
冤
冥
3/2
This equation is not set in stone for all situations. Rubey (1933) demonstrated one example by showing that Stoke’s law does not apply to spherical quartz suspended in water when the particle diameter exceeds 0.014 mm (0.00055 in, mesh 105). 3-1-3-3 Intermediate Spheres For the range of particle Reynolds numbers between 1 and 1000, i.e., when dpV0 1 < < 1000 Govier and Aziz (1972) reported that Allen (1900) derived the following equation: ( – L)g Vt = 0.2 L
冤
冥
0.72
d 1.18 p (/)0.45
(3-11)
Example 3-2 A slurry mixture consists of fine rocks at an average particle diameter of 140 m, with a particle density of 2800 kg/m3. The carrier liquid is water with a dynamic viscosity of 1.5 × 10–3 Pa · s. The volumetric concentration of the solids is 12%. Determine the terminal velocity of the particles. Solution Using Equation 1-9, the dynamic viscosity of the mixture is
m = L[1 + 2.5C + 10.05C 2 + 0.00273 exp(16.6C)] = 1.5 × 10–3[1 + 2.5 × 0.12 + 10.05(0.12)2 + 0.00273 exp (16.6 × 0.12)]
m = 2.197 × 10–3 Pa · s. Let us check the magnitude of the Reynolds number: dV0 140 × 10–6 × 0.02504 × 2800 = = 4.468 2.197 × 10–3 The Allen law applies in a transition regime: (140 × 10–6)1.18 Vt = 0.2 [9.81 × 1.8]0.72 (2.197 × 10–3/2800)0.45 2.83 × 10–5 Vt = 0.2 × 7.903 0.001789 Vt = 0.02504 m/s
Richards (1908) demonstrated that Stokes’s equation is inaccurate for particles with a diameter larger than 0.2 mm (0.00787 in, mesh 70) and conducted extensive tests for
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.7
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
3.7
quartz particles (with a specific gravity of 2.65) in laminar, transitional, and turbulent regimes. He derived the following equation for terminal velocity in mm/s: 8.925 Vt = dg{[1 + 95(S/L – 1)d g3]1/2 – 1}
(3-12)
Where dg, the diameter of the sphere, is expressed in mm. This equation covers the range of particles between 0.15–1.5 mm (0.0059–0.059 in) at particle Reynolds numbers between 10 and 1000. 3-1-3-4 Large Spheres For particles with a diameter in excess of 1.5 mm, Herbrich (1991) expressed the terminal velocity by the following equation: Vt = Kt 兹[d 苶苶 苶苶 苶L苶–苶苶)] 1苶 g( S/
(3-13)
where Kt = an experimental constant = 5.45 for Rep > 800, according to Govier and Aziz (1972). Equation 3-13 is often called Newton’s law. In the regime of Newton’s law, the drag coefficient of a sphere is approximately 0.44, as shown in Figure 3-2. Newton’s law applies to turbulent flow regimes. Other equations for terminal velocity of particles have been developed by various authors. Four different equations are presented in Table 3-2. Example 3-3 Using the Budyruck equation from Table 3-3, determine the terminal velocity of spheres from 0.1 to1 mm. A simple computer program is written in quickbasic as follows: LPRINT LPRINT “BUDRYCK AND RITTINGER EQUATION FOR TERMINAL VELOCITY OF SPHERES IN WATER” LPRINT LPRINT DP0 = .1 FOR I=1 to 11 DP = I*DP0 VS= (8.925/DP)*(SQR(1+157*DP^30-1) LPRINT USING “PARTICLE DIAMETER = ##.### mm TERMINAL VELOCITY Vs = ##.### mm/s”;DP,VS NEXT I FOR J=12 TO 20 DP = J*DP0
TABLE 3-2 Equations for Terminal Speed of Large Spheres Name
Equation*
Application
Budryck Rittinger
Vt = 8.925[(1 + 157d g3)1/2 – 1]/dg Vt = 87(1.65dg)1/2
For dg < 1.1 mm For 1.2 < dg < 2 mm
*Where Vt is expressed in mm/s and dg in mm.
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.8
3.8
CHAPTER THREE
TABLE 3-3 Calculation of Terminal Velocity of Spheres in Accordance with Budryck’s Equation Particle diameter dp in mm
Terminal velocity Vs in mm/s
Particle diameter dp in mm
Terminal velocity Vs in mm/s
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6
6.75 22.4 38.34 51.85 63.21 73.02
0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 1.1
81.63 89.49 96.64 103.26 109.45
VS= 87*SQR(1.65*DP) LPRINT USING “PARTICLE DIAMETER = ##.### mm TERMINAL VELOCITY Vs = ##.### mm/s”;DP,VS NEXT J END The results are shown in Tables 3-3, 3-4, and Figure 3-3 Herbich (1968) measured drag coefficients for ocean nodules to be as high as 0.6 at particle Reynolds numbers of 200. This high value is reached with spheres at a particle Reynolds number of 1000. 3-1-4 Effects of Cylindrical Walls on Terminal Velocity The previous paragraphs focused on the settling velocity of a single particle or widely separated particles. The presence of a vessel or cylindrical walls tends to multiply the interaction between particles and cause some collisions. Extensive tests have been conducted on flows in vertical tubes. Brown and associates (1950) recommended multiplying the terminal speed of a single particle by a wall correction factor Fw. For laminar flows they proposed to use the Francis equation: Fw = 1 – (d/Di)9/4
(3-14a)
They proposed to use the Munroe equation for a turbulent flow regime: Fw = 1 – (d/Di)1.5
(3-14b)
where Di = the inner diameter of the tube
TABLE 3-4 Calculation of Terminal Velocity of Spheres in Accordance with Rittinger’s Equation Particle diameter dp in mm
Terminal velocity Vt in mm/s
Particle diameter dp in mm
Terminal velocity Vt in mm/s
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5
117.21 122.42 127.42 132.23 136.87
1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 2.0
141.36 145.71 149.93 154.04 158.04
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.9
3.9
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
Sphere diameter d p in inches
120
5
4
100 80
3
60 2 40 1 20 0
0 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
Te rminal velocity Vt in inch/sec
Terminal velocity Vt in mm/s
0
1.2
Sphere diameter d p in mm (a)
0.04
0.05
0.06
0.07
0.08
160
6
140 5 120 100
4
80
3
60 2 40 1.0
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
2.0
1
Terminal velocity Vt in inch /sec
Sphere diameter d p in inches Terminal velocity Vt in mm/s
abul-3.qxd
Sphere diameter d p in mm (b) FIGURE 3-3 Terminal velocity of spheres (a) in accordance with Budryck’s equation, (b) in accordance with Rittinger’s equation.
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.10
3.10
CHAPTER THREE
Example 3-4 The flow described in Example 3-2 occurs in a 63 mm ID pipe. Determine the corrected terminal velocity due to the wall effects. Solution The terminal velocity was determined to be 0.02504 m/s. The flow is in transition. Equation 3-14a for laminar flow is Fw = 1 – (d/DI)9/4 Fw = 1 – (0.140/63)9/4 Fw = 0.999 Equation 3-14b for turbulent flow is Fw = 1 – (0.14/63)1.5 = 0.999. More recently, Prokunin (1998) extended the analysis of the interaction of the wall with the motion of a single particle by considering the angle of inclination and any rotation that the particle may incur. His investigation included immersion in non-Newtonian flows by testing with glycerin and silicone. He noticed from his tests that when the particle approaches the wall, it develops a lift force. The lift force seems to increase with a reduction of the gap that separates the particle from the wall. However, Prokunin could not explain this lift force and recommended further research. 3-1-5 Effects of the Volumetric Concentration on the Terminal Velocity As the volumetric concentration of particles increases, it causes interactions and collisions, and transfers momentum between the different (finer and coarser) units. The distance between particles decreases. For spheres at 1% concentration by volume, the interparticle distance is only 4 diameters. It shrinks to 2.5 diameters at 5% and to 2 diameters at 10% concentration by volume. In an ideal laminar flow, the interaction is much simpler than in a turbulent flow. Worster and Denny (1955) published data on the terminal velocity of coal and gravel particles, as shown in Table 3-5. The effect of the concentration is clearly marked by a difference in terminal velocity between a single particle and a volumetric concentration of 30%. Kearsey and Gill (1963) applied the Carman–Kozeney equation of flow through a porous medium to determine the terminal velocity as
TABLE 3-5 Terminal Velocity for Coal and Gravel after Worster and Denny (1955) Coal with a specific gravity of 1.5 ________________________________ Particle size Single particle 30% Concentration ____________ ______________ ________________ mm Inches (cm/s) (ft/s) (cm/s) (ft/s) 1.59 6.4 12.7 25.4
1/16 1– 4 1– 2
1
4.6 15.2 30.5 51.8
0.15 1.50 1.00 1.70
3.0 10.7 21.3 36.6
0.10 0.35 0.70 1.20
Gravel with a specific gravity of 2.67 ________________________________ Single particle 30% Concentration ______________ ________________ (cm/s) (ft/s) (cm/s) (ft/s) 9.1 30.5 61.0 106.7
0.30 1.00 2.00 3.50
3.0 10.7 21.3 36.6
0.10 0.35 0.70 1.20
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.11
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
冤
(1 – Cv)3 Vc = KzC v2
P
冥冤 s 冥冤 L 冥 1
2 p
3.11
(3-15)
where sp = the specific surface expressed for as sphere as the surface area to volume ratio:
d 2g = 6/dg sp = (d 3g/6) Kz = the Kozney constant, which is a function of particle shape, porosity, particle orientation, and size distribution. The magnitude of Kz is between 3 and 6, but is commonly assumed to be 5 P/Li = the pressure gradient in the pipe due to the flow of the mixture In the process of sedimentation, the pressure gradient is essentially due to the volumetric concentration of the particles and is expressed as P = Cv(s – L)g Li
(3-16)
In addition, the settling velocity due to a volumetric concentration is expressed as
冤
(1 – Cv)3g Vc = KzCv
(s – L)
冥冤 冥 s 2 p
(3-17)
For spheres with sp = 6/dg, the equation reduces to
冤
(1 – Cv)3gd 2g Vc = 36KzCv
(s – L)
冥冤 冥
(3-18)
As the volumetric concentration increases from 3% to 30%, the velocity drops drastically. Assuming Kz to be equal to 5.0, the settling velocity for spheres reduces to a simple equation: (1 – Cv)3 Vc = V0 10Cv
(3-19)
where V0 = the terminal velocity at very low volumetric concentration Equation 3-19 does not apply to volumetric concentrations smaller than 8%. Equation 3-18 would apply to smaller concentrations. Example 3-5 Assuming that the terminal velocity at a volumetric concentration of 8% is 100 mm/s, apply Equation 3-18 from a volumetric concentration of 8–30%. Plot the results in Figure 3-4. Thomas (1963) proposed the following empirical equation in the range of Vc/V0 of 0.08–1.0: 2.303 log10(Vc/V0) = –5.9CV
(3-20)
Example 3-6 The free settling speed of solid particles is 22 mm/s at a volumetric concentration of 1%. Using the Thomas equation 3-20, determine the settling speed at 25% volumetric concentration.
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.12
3.12
Vc / Vo
CHAPTER THREE
1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0
0
0.2 0.1 Volumetric concentration
0.3
FIGURE 3-4 Effect of the volumetric concentration on the terminal velocity of spheres in accordance with Equation 3-18.
Solution 2.303 log10(Vc/V0) = -5.9 × 0.25 Vc/V0 = 10–0.64 Vc/V0 = 0.2288 Vc = 0.2288 × 22 mm/s = 5.03 mm/s The Kozney-based approach is limited to concentrations where the particles come into contact with each other in a vertical flow. Beyond this point, the pressure gradient is smaller than expressed by Equation 3-16. In the case of hard spheres, the settling process completes when the particles come into contact with each other. In the case of flocculated particles or clusters of flocculated fluid, stress may cause deformation and further settling may occur by compaction. Irregularly shaped particles and flocculates cause the development of a structure with its own yield stress level. As the particles move closer, the yield stress increases until equilibrium is reached. The weight of the overburden is then supported by the saturated fluid and the compacted sediment.
3-2 GENERALIZED DRAG COEFFICIENT— THE CONCEPT OF SHAPE FACTOR Every day the slurry engineer has to deal with particles of all shapes and sizes. Although the sphere represents a shape for reference, it is in the minority in the world of crushed or naturally worn rocks. Albertson (1953) conducted an extensive study on the effect of the shape of gravel particles on the fall velocity in a vertical flow (Figure 3-5). He proposed a definition for a shape factor: c A = 兹(a 苶b苶)苶 where a = the longest of three mutually perpendicular axes b = the third axis c = the shortest of three mutually perpendicular axes
(3-21)
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.13
3.13
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
a
l fal f no tio c e dir
c
b
FIGURE 3-5 The axes of an irregularly shaped particle, according to Albertson.
Particles in a free fall tend to align themselves to expose the largest surface to the flow. In other words, they act as free-falling leaves from a tree on an autumn day, where c is taken as the dimension opposite to the direction of the fall. The projected area of the particle is a function of the dimensions “a” and “b” but is often not equaled to such a product as (ab) because particles are usually not rectangular in shape (see Table 3-6). In a different approach, Clift et al. (1978) decided to compare the projected area of a free-falling, irregularly shaped particle, with a sphere of equal projected area in order to define a diameter: da = 兹(4 苶S 苶苶 苶)苶 f /
(3-22)
where Sf = the projected area of the free-falling particle However, Albertson (1953) preferred to define a different diameter base, dp, on the fact that the actual volume of the free-falling particle could be equated to a sphere of the
TABLE 3-6 Clift Shape Factor of Various Particles Isometric ____________________________________ Particle c Sphere Cube Tetrahedron Irregular Rounded Cubic angular Tetrahedral
From Wilson et al. (1992).
0.524 0.694 0.328 0.54 0.47 0.38
Typical mineral particles _______________________________________ Particle c Sand Sillimanite Bituminous Coal Blast Furnace Slag Limestone Talc Plumbago Gypsum Flake Graphite Mica
0.26 0.23 0.23 0.19 0.16 0.16 0.16 0.13 0.023 0.003
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.14
3.14
CHAPTER THREE
same volume but with a diameter of dn. Albertson (1953) therefore proposed a Reynolds number based on dn: dnVt Ren =
(3-23)
There may be a marked difference between naturally worn gravel and crushed gravel. This is a fact that a slurry engineer should bear in mind when extrapolating data from lab results. Because Clift chose an equivalent diameter da based on the projected area, he proposed a different shape factor:
c = particle volume/d a3
(3-24)
Typical values are shown in Table 3-6. The Albertson and Clift shape factors are about 40 years apart in definition but can be related by a factor E:
c = EA
(3-25)
The logarithmic curves as shown in Figure 3-6 are sometimes difficult to read. Table 3-7 presents values of drag coefficient versus Reynolds number rounded off to the first decimal point. The work of Albertson was developed further by the Inter-Agency Committee on Water Resources (1958), who developed the following two non-dimensional coefficients (Figure 3-7): CN = (s/L – 1)g/V t3
(3-26a)
CN = 0.75CD /Ren
(3-26b)
CS = (s/L – 1)gd 3p/(62)
(3-27a)
CS = 0.125CD Re2n
(3-27b)
and
ALBERTSON SHAPE FACTOR = a/ cb
Drag coefficient CD
10.0 0.3 0.5 0.7
1.0
1.0
0.1
00
10 10
100 100
33
10 10
4
10 10
4
55
10 10
6
10 10
6
Particle Reynolds number Rep
FIGURE 3-6 The drag coefficient versus Reynolds number and shape factor. (After Albertson, 1953.)
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.15
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
3.15
TABLE 3-7 Drag Coefficient versus Reynolds Number for Different Albertson Shape Factors Drag coefficient Reynolds number 7 8 9 10 15 20 32 40 50 60 70 80 100 150 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000
Shape factor = 0.3 7.0 6.5 6.1 5.8 4.64 3.95 3.0 2.7 2.5 2.3 2.25 2.2 2.08 1.87 1.75 1.74 1.8 1.9 1.94 1.988 2.0 2.07 2.1 2.3 2.28 2.48 2.21 2.2 2.19 2.183 2.18
Shape factor = 0.5 Shape factor = 0.7 Shape factor = 1.0 6.0 5.5 5.1 4.74 3.7 3.2 2.6 2.28 2.08 1.94 1.74 1.67 1.62 1.44 1.36 1.33 1.34 1.38 1.42 1.47 1.51 1.54 1.58 1.72 1.73 1.69 1.66 1.62 1.58 1.55 1.53
4.7 4.3 4.0 3.75 3.0 2.55 2.1 1.84 1.67 1.56 1.4 1.35 1.3 1.16 1.11 1.08 1.09 1.1 1.12 1.14 1.15 1.16 1.17 1.22 1.19 1.16 1.14 1.13 1.13 1.14 1.14
4.0 3.7 3.4 3.15 2.4 2.0 1.55 1.3 1.12 1.0 0.94 0.844 0.8 0.68 0.6 0.5 0.44 0.4 0.38 0.36 0.34 0.334 0.33 0.3 0.29 0.294 0.3 0.31 0.31 0.32 0.32
The drag coefficient CD is then plotted against the equivalent Reynolds number Ren to determine the terminal velocity. On a logarithmic scale, CN and CS are superposed as straight lines for reference (Figure 3-7). In order to measure the Albertson shape factor, Wasp et al. (1977) developed a correlation between the sieve diameter and the fall diameter dn (Figure 3-8). The approach proposed by Albertson and Clift is limited to free fall of particles in a fluid. However, turbulence can develop new forces. Whenever an engineering contract requires the drag of particles to be measured, the engineer is well advised to conduct tests in a fluid of similar dynamic viscosity as the one that will be used in the project. In addition to the shape factor and drag coefficient, the slurry engineer must also determine the fluid density, dynamic viscosity at the temperature of pumping, particle density (or specific gravity of solids), nominal (or statistical average) diameter, and fall velocity.
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.16
3.16
CHAPTER THREE
0.8
S. F
6 5 4 3
sp
he
2
he
0.4
re
re
s
s
0.6
0.2 0
= 0.9
S .F = 0.3 S. F = 0. 5 S. F = 0.7
Sieve diameter (mm)
S. F S . F = 0.3 =0 .5 S. F= S. F 0.7 =0 .9
1.0
7
sp
Sieve diameter (mm)
FIGURE 3-7 CD and CW versus particle Reynolds number for different shape factors. Adapted from the Inter-Agency Committee on Water Resources (1958).
1 0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
Fall diameter (mm)
1.0
0
1
2
3
4
Fall diameter (mm)
FIGURE 3-8 Relationship between sieve and fall diameter after Wasp et al. (1977).
5
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.17
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
3.17
Example 3-7 A naturally worn particle has an Albertson shape factor of 0.7. It has a nominal diameter of 250 m. Its density is 3000 kg/m3. It is allowed to free-fall in water at a temperature of 25° C. Calculate the fall velocity for the single particle and the fall velocity if the volumetric concentration of particles is increased to 20%. Solution Referring to Table 2-7 (or Table 2-8 for USCS units), the kinematic viscosity of water is 0.89 × 10–6 m2/s. We need to determine the coefficient CS = 0.125CD/Ren2. The curves published by Inter-Agency Committee on Water Resources indicate that CS = 0.125CD/Ren2 = 0.167(s/L – 1)gd p3/2 = 203. From Figure 3-6, at a shape factor of 0.7 and CS of 203, the Reynolds number would be 7.2Vt = Re/(dp) = 7.2/(890,000 × 0.00025) = 0.0324 m/s for a single particle. Applying Equation 3-18 for a concentration of 20%, the velocity would be 0.256 × 0.0324 = 0.0083 m/s.
3-3 NON-NEWTONIAN SLURRIES Various models have been developed over the years to classify complex two- and threephase mixtures (Table 3-8). In the case of mining, the following mixtures are often encountered: 앫 A fine dispersion containing small particles of a solid, which are uniformly distributed in a continuous fluid and are found in copper concentrate pipelines and in slurry from grinding after classification, etc.
TABLE 3-8 Regimes of Flows for Newtonian and Non-Newtonian Mixtures after Govier and Aziz (1972) Multiphase flows (gas–liquid, liquid–liquid, Single-phase flows gas–solid, liquid–liquid) ___________________________ ___________________________________________________ Single-phase behavior _____________________________________________________ Multiphase behavior ___________________________ Pseudohomogeneous Heterogeneous _______________________________ __________________ True homogeneous Laminar, transition, and Turbulent flow regime only turbulent flow regime Purely viscous
Newtonian flows
Purely viscous, non-Newtonian, and time-independent
Bingham plastic Dilatant Pseudoplastic Yield pseudoplastic
Purely viscous, non-Newtonian and time-dependent
Thixotropic Rheopectic
Viscoelastic
Many forms
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.18
3.18
CHAPTER THREE
앫 A coarse dispersion containing large particles distributed in a continuous fluid and encountered in SAG mills, cyclone underflows, and in certain tailings lines, etc. 앫 A macro-mixed flow pattern containing either a frothy or highly turbulent mixture of gas and liquid, or two immiscible liquids under conditions in which neither is continuous. Such patterns are found in flotation circuits in which froth is used to separate concentrate from gangue. 앫 A stratified flow pattern containing a gas, liquid, two slurries of different particle sizes, or two immiscible liquids under conditions in which both phases are continuous. Designing a pipeline to operate in a non-Newtonian flow regime must be based on reliable test data about the rheology and particle sizing (see Table 3-9). The engineer must be cautious before venturing into generalizations about rheological properties. In Figure 1-4 of Chapter 1, the relationship between dynamic viscosity and volumetric concentration was presented. In fact, the industry has accepted the criterion that friction losses are highly dependent on slurry viscosity in cases where the average particle diameter is finer than 40–60 microns, and (depending on the specific gravity) at volumetric concentrations in excess of 30%. Fibrous slurries such as fermentation broths, fruit pulps, crushed meal animal feed, tomato puree, sewage sludge, and paper pulp may not contain a high percentage of solids, but may flow as non-Newtonian regimes. With these materials, the long fibers are flexible and intertwine into a close-packed configuration and entrap the suspending medium. The fibers may be flocculated or may form flocs with an open structure. Based on the volume content of the flocs, the mixture may develop high dynamic viscosity. However, because the flocs are compressible, they may deform with the flow. Flocculated slurries are encountered in flotation cells circuits, thickeners, and various processes in mineral extraction plants. With the formation of flocs, the slurry may develop an internal structure. This structure may develop properties leading to a non-Newtonian flow, shear thinning behavior (pseudoplastic), and sometimes thixotropic time-dependent behavior. When shear stresses are applied to the slurry, the floc sizes may shrink and become less capable of entrapping the carrier slurry. At higher shear stresses, the flocs may shrink to the size of particles, and the flow may lose its non-Newtonian behavior.
3-4 TIME-INDEPENDENT NON-NEWTONIAN MIXTURES Certain slurries require a minimum level of stress before they can flow. An example is fresh concrete that does not flow unless the angle of the chute exceeds a certain minimum. Such a mixture is said to posses a yield stress magnitude that must be exceeded before that flow can commence. A number of flows such as Bingham plastics, pseudoplastics, yield pseudoplastics, and dilatant are classified as time-independent non-Newtonian fluids. The relationship of wall shear stress versus shear rate is of the type shown in Figure 3-9 (a), and the relationship between the apparent viscosity and the shear rate is shown in Figure 3-9 (b). The apparent viscosity is defined as
a = Cw/(d/dt)
(3.28)
3-4-1 Bingham Plastics For a Bingham plastics it is essential to overcome a yield stress 0 before the fluid is set in motion. The shear stress versus shear rate is then expressed as
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.19
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
3.19
TABLE 3-9 Examples of Bingham Slurries Yield Stress, Pa
Coefficient of rigidity,
mPa · s (cP)
Particle size, d50
Density, kg/m3
92% under 74 m
1520
80% under 1 m
1280
59
13.1
80% under 1 m
1207
25
6.7
80% under 1 m
1149
7.8
4.0
1520
34.5
44.7
Aqueous clay suspension III
1440
20
32.8
Aqueous clay suspension V
1360
Slurry 54.3% Aqueous suspension of cement, rock Flocculated aqueous China clay suspension No. 1 Flocculated aqueous China clay suspension No. 4 Flocculated aqueous China clay suspension No. 6 Aqueous clay suspension I
3.8
6.65
6.86
19.4
Fine coal @ 49% CW Fine coal @ 68% CW Coal tails @ 31% CW Copper concentrate @ 48% CW 21.4% Bauxite
50% under 40 m 50% under 40 m 50% under 70 m 50% under 35 m < 200m
1163
8.5
4.1
Gold tails @ 31% CW 18% Iron oxide
50% under 50 m < 50 m
1170
5 0.78
87 4.5
7.5 % Kaolin clay Kaolin @ 32% CW Kaolin @ 53% CW with sodium silicate Kimbelite tails @ 37% CW 58% Limestone
Colloidal 50% under 0.8 m 50% under 0.8 m
52.4% Fine liminite Mineral sands tails @ 58% Cw 13.9% Milicz clay 16.8% Milicz clay 19.6% Milicz clay Phosphate tails @ 37% CW 14% Sewage sludge
< 50 m 50% under 160 m
Red mud @ 39% CW Zinc concentrate @ 75% CW Uranium tails @ 58% CW
50% under 15 m < 160 m
1 8.3 2 19
1103
1530 2435
< 70 m < 70 m < 70 m 85% under 10 m 1060 5% under 150 m 50% under 20 m 50% under 38 m
5 40 60 18
7.5 20 6
5 30 15
11.6 2.5
6 15
30 30
16 250
2.3 5.3 13 28.5 3.1
8.7 13.6 25 14 24.5
23 12 4
30 31 15
Reference Hedstrom (1952) Valentik & Whitmore (1965) Valentik & Whitmore (1965) Valentik & Whitmore (1965) Caldwell & Babitt (1941) Caldwell & Babitt (1941) Caldwell & Babitt (1941) Wells (1991) Wells (1991) Wells (1991) Wells (1991) Boger & Nguyen (1987) Wells (1991) Cheng & Whittaker (1972) Thomas (1981) Wells (1991) Wells (1991) Wells (1991) Cheng & Whittaker (1972) Mun (1988) Wells (1991) Parzonka (1964) Parzonka (1964) Parzonka (1964) Wells (1991) Caldwell & Babitt (1941) Wells (1991) Wells (1991) Wells (1991)
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.20
3.20
m ha ng i B
stic pla o d seu ld P Yie
c sti Pla
ian on t w stic Ne opla d u Pse
Di lat an t
Shear Stress
CHAPTER THREE
tic as Pl
Apparent viscosity a
m ha ng Bi
Di lat an t
Rate of shear ( = du/dy)
Newtonian
Pse udo plas tic
Rate of shear ( = du/dy) (b) FIGURE 3-9 (a) Shear stress versus shear rate; (b) viscosity versus shear rate of time-independent non-Newtonian fluids.
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.21
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
w – 0 = d/dt
3.21
(3-29)
where w = shear stress at the wall 0 = yield stress
= the coefficient of rigidity or non-Newtonian viscosity It is also related to a Bingham plastic limiting viscosity at infinite shear rate by the following equation:
0
= + (d/dt)
(3-30)
The magnitude of the yield stress 0 may be as low as 0.01 Pascal for sewage sludge (Dick and Ewing, 1967) or as high as 1000 MPa for asphalts and Bitumen (Pilpel, 1965). The coefficient of rigidity may be as low as the viscosity of water or as high as 1000 poise (100 Pa · s) for some paints and much higher for asphalts and bitumen. In the case of tarbased emulsions or certain tar sands, it is customary to add certain chemicals to reduce the dynamic viscosity of the emulsion or the coefficient of rigidity of the slurry. Tables 3-9 presents examples of Bingham slurries, magnitudes of yield stress, and coefficients of rigidity values. Example 3-8 Samples of a mineral slurry with Cw = 45% are examined in a lab. From the measurements of the rate of shear () and shear stress ( ), determine the yield stress and viscosity. Rate of Shear [s–1] 100 150 200 300 Shear Stress (Pa) 10.93 12.27 13.49 15.68 – 0 (Pa) 4.11 5.45 6.67 8.87
400 17.66 10.85
500 19.49 12.67
600 700 800 21.2 22.84 24.43 14.39 16.03 17.61
The data is plotted in Figure 3-10. At a low shear rate < 100s – 1, the slope is
= 4.426/100 = 0.0443 Pa · s At high shear rate 4.426 = = 0.0164 Pa · s 270
w – 0
= du/dy Take a point at high shear rate (700 s–1): 16.03
= 700
= 0.0229 Pa · s Check at du/dy = 600 14.394
= = 0.02399 600 at du/dy = 800
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.22
3.22
CHAPTER THREE
17.61
= 0.022 800 An average = 0.023 Pa · s is taken. Alternative = 0/(du/dy) + a
= 6.82/700 + 0.0164 = 0.026 Pa · s This example shows that at zero rate of shear the shear stress is 6.82 Pa. The yield stress is therefore 6.82 Pa. The yield stress increases as the concentration of solids augments. Thomas (1961) proposed the following relationships between yield stress 0, coefficient of rigidity , concentration by volume Cv, and viscosity of the suspending medium :
0 = K1C v3
(3-31)
/ = exp(K2Cv)
(3-32)
where K1 and K2 = constants and are characteristics of the particle size, shape, and concentration of the electrolyte concentration. These equations were derived from the work of Thomas (1961) on suspensions of titanium dioxide, graphite, kaolin, and thorium oxide in a range of particle sizes from 0.35–13 micrometers and in volume concentration of 2–23%. Thomas (1961) defined a shape factor T1 for nonspherical particles as
T1 = exp[0.7(sp/s0 – 1)]
(3-33)
where sp = the surface area per unit volume of the actual particles s0 = the surface area per unit volume of a sphere of equivalent dimensions or 6/dg
(Pa)
He indicated that the coefficient K1 might then be expressed as
30
Shear stress
28 24 20 16 12 8 4
0
0 0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
Rate of shear FIGURE 3-10 Plot of data for Example 3-8.
900 -1
(sec )
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.23
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
uT1 K1 = d 2p
3.23
(3-34)
Where K1 is expressed in Pa (or lbf/ft2 with u = 210 in), and the particle diameter dp is expressed in microns. Thomas defined a second shape factor T2 = (sp/s0)1/2 to derive the equation: 苶苶p K2 = 2.5 + 14T 2/兹d
when 0.4 < dp < 20 microns
(3-35)
Thomas (1963) extended his work to flocculated mixtures with dispersed fine and ultrafine particles with overall dimensions up to 115 microns. He derived the following equations:
/ = exp[(2.5 + )Cv]
(3-36)
= 兹[( 苶d苶f苶 /dap 苶苶 –苶] 1苶 p)苶
(3-37)
where where = the ratio of immobilized dispersing fluid to the volume of solids related approximately to the particle and floc apparent diameter df = the apparent floc diameter dapp = the apparent particle diameter This particle diameter is shown by the following: dapp = dp(s0/sp) exp(–1–2 ln2 )
(3-38)
where
= the logarithmic standard deviation In general, and at a constant temperature, the following equations are applied to Bingham plastic slurries:
/ = A exp(BCv)
(3-39)
0 = E exp(FCv)
(3-40)
The constants A, B, E, and F are derived from tests measuring particle size, shape, and the nature of their surface. Gay et al. (1969) proposed the following correlation for high concentrations of solids:
/ = exp{[2.5 + [Cv/(Cv – Cv)]0.48](Cv/Cv)}
(3-41)
where Cv = the maximum packing concentration of solids For a change in temperature in the order of 27°C (50°F). Parzonka (1964) developed the following power law equation:
= K3T a–n
(3-42a)
where n = an exponent K3 = an exponent Ta = absolute temperature Govier and Aziz (1972) proposed an equation based on an exponential drop of Bingham plastic viscosity with temperature:
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
3.24
9:14 AM
Page 3.24
CHAPTER THREE
= A exp(B/T)
(3-42b)
To obtain the viscosity, plot the curve of the shear stress ( – 0) in Pascals against the shear rate (s–1). 3-4-2 Pseudoplastic Slurries Pseudoplastic fluids are time-independent non-Newtonian fluids that are characterized by the following: 앫 An infinitesimal shear stress, which is sufficient to initiate motion 앫 The rate of increase of shear stress with respect to the velocity gradient decreases as the velocity gradient increases This type of flow is encountered when fine particles form loosely bound aggregates that are aligned, stable, and reproducible at a given magnitude of shear rate. The behavior of pseudoplastic fluids is difficult to define accurately. Various empirical equations have been developed over the years and involve at least two empirical factors, one of which is an exponent. For these reasons, pseudoplastic slurries are often called power-law slurries. The shear stress is defined in terms of the shear rate by the following equation:
w = K[(d/dt)n]
(3-43)
where K = the power law consistency factor, expressed in Pa · sn n = the power law behavior index, and is smaller than unity Examples of pseudoplastic slurries are shown in Table 3-10. The apparent viscosity of a pseudoplastic is defined in terms of the ratio of the shear stress to the shear rate:
a = [ w/(d/dt)]
(3-44)
3-4-2-1 Homogeneous Pseudoplastics Pseudoplastic slurries are another category of non-Newtonian slurries. Pseudoplastics are divided into homogeneous and pseudohomogeneous mixtures. Whereas in the case of a Bingham slurry, it was pointed out that the coefficient of rigidity was a linear function of the shear rate, in the case of a pseudoplastic, the coefficient of rigidity is expressed by the following power law:
= K(d/dt)n–1
(3-45)
The shear stress is plotted against the shear rate on a logarithmic scale at various volume fractions. From the slope of such a plot, “K,” the power law consistency factor, and “n,” the power law behavior index (smaller than unity) are derived as plotted in Figure 311. As indicated in Figure 3-12 the magnitude “K,” the power law consistency factor, and the power law factor index n are dependent on the volumetric concentration of solids. Example 3-9 A phosphate slurry mixture is tested using a rheogram. The following data describe the relationship between the wall shear stress and the shear rate:
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.25
3.25
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
d/dt w(Pa)
0 25
50 32
100 43
150 51
200 53
300 56
400 58
500 60
600 62
700 63.2
800 64.3
The mixture is non-Newtonian. If it is considered a power law slurry, derive the power law exponent “n” and the power law coefficient K. Solution The first step is to plot the data on a logarithmic scale. In the equation for a pseudoplastic, the coefficient of rigidity is expressed by equations (3.43) and (3.45), the values of “K” and “n.” By using the logarithmic scale: log w = log K + n log (d/dt) log(d/dt) log( w) n
1.699 1.505 —
2 1.633 0.425
2.176 1.707 0.592
2.301 1.724 0.136
2.477 1.748 0.136
2.602 1.763 0.12
2.669 1.778 0.154
2.778 1.792 0.112
2.845 1.8 0.13
2.903 1.808 0.14
log(d/dt)2 – log(d/dt)1 n = (log w)2 – (log w)1 n ⬇ 0.132 1.8 = log K = 0.132 × 2.843 log K = 1.424 K = 26.5 TABLE 3-10 Examples of Power Law Pseudoplastics
Slurry Cellulose acetate Drilling mud—barite Sand in drilling mud
Particle size, d50
Range of weight concentration, %
Graphite Graphite and magnesium hydroxide
16.1 m 5 m
Flocculated kaolin Deflocculated kaolin Magnesium hydroxide Pulverized fuel ash (PFA-P) Pulverized fuel ash (PFA-P)
0.75 m 0.75 m 5 m 38 m
1.5–7.4 1.0–40.0 1.0–15% sand using drilling mud with 18% barite 0.5–5.0 32.2 total (4.1 graphite and 28.1 magnesium hydroxide) 8.9–36.3 31.3–63.7 8.4–45.3 63–71.8
20 m
70–74.4
14.7 m 180 m
Range of consistency coefficient K, Nsn/m2
Angle of flow behavior index, n
Reference
1.4–34.0 0.8–1.3 0.72–1.21
0.38–0.43 0.43–0.62 0.48–0.57
Heywood (1996) Heywood (1996) Heywood (1996)
Unknown
Probably 1
Heywood (1996)
5.22
0.16
Heywood (1996)
0.3–39 0.011–0.6 0.5–68 3.3–9.3
0.117–0.285 0.82–1.56 0.12–0.16 0.44–0.46
Heywood (1996) Heywood (1996) Heywood (1996) Heywood (1996)
2.12–9.02
0.48–0.57
Heywood (1996)
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.26
3.26
CHAPTER THREE
Shear stress (in units of pressure)
1 0.1 0.01
pe
=
x y/
slo
0
y
K
n
n = y/x
x
0.001 0.0001 0
1
10
100
Shear rate
1000
10,000
(1/sec)
FIGURE 3-11 Plotting the rheology on a logarithmic scale to obtain the consistency factor “K” and the flow behavior index “n” of Pseudoplastics.
Consider d/dt = 700. Check w = K(d/dt)n. 62.9 = 26.5 × 7000.132 This is close to the measured stress of 63.2 Pa. Therefore, the equation of this phosphate slurry is:
w = 26.5(d/dt)0.132 The coefficient of rigidity is obtained as:
1.0
6
ma gne tite
4 2
Flow Behavior Index "n"
clays
8
tite gne ma
Power Law Consistency Factor K Pa.sn/cm 2
10
0.8 0.6 0.4
clays
0.2 0
0 0
20 40 Volume Fraction of solids, CV
0
20 40 Volume Fraction of solids, CV
FIGURE 3-12 Effect of volumetric concentration on the consistency factor “K” and the flow behavior index “n” of Pseudoplastics (after Aziz and Govier, 1972).
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.27
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
3.27
= K(d/dt)n–1
= 26.5(d/dt)–0.878 at d/dt = 700
= 26.5 × (700)–0.878
= 0.084 Pa · s at d/dt = 600.
= 26.5 × 600 = 0.096 Pa · s 3-4-2-2 Pseudohomogeneous Pseudoplastics Pseudohomogeneous pseudoplastics behave similarly to their homogeneous counterparts. Clay suspensions and magnetite-based slurries demonstrate an exponential relationship between n and Cv as shown in Figure 3-12. The power law factor K has a more complex relationship with Cv, as shown in Figure 3-12. Various equations have been derived to solve the power law factor of pseudoplastics. These equations are presented to help the reader appreciate the rheological constants that must be determined by testing, as will be described in Section 3-6. The Prandtl–Eyring equation is based on Dahlgreen’s (1958) discussion of the study conducted by Eyring and Prandtl on the kinetic theory of liquids:
= A sinh–1[(d/dt)/B]
(3-46)
where A and B = the rheological constants sinh = the hyperbolic function From Equation 3-44, the apparent viscosity is derived as
a = {A/(d/dt)}{sinh–1[(d/dt)/B]}
(3-47)
The Ellis equation is more flexible but is an empirical equation and uses three rheological constants. Skelland (1967) demonstrates how the equation is based on the work of Ellis and Round and is explicit with respect to the velocity gradient rather than the shear rate: (d/dt) = (A0 + A1 ( –1)) w
(3-48)
where A0, A1, and are the rheological coefficients of the slurry material. The apparent viscosity is expressed as
a = 1/(A0 + A1 w( –1))
(3-49)
When A1 = 0, the equation takes on a Newtonian form where A0 = 1/. The equation reduces to the conventional power law equation with = 1/n and A1 = (1/k)1/n. When > 1, the equation approaches a Newtonian flow at low shear stresses, and when < 1, it tends to approach a Newtonian flow at high shear stress. The Cross equation (Cross, 1965) is a versatile equation that is based on measurements of viscosity, 0 at zero shear rate and at infinite shear rates.
– 0 a = 0 + 1 + (d/dt)2/3
(3-50)
where is a coefficient used to express to the shear stability of the mixture. This equation has been tested and has successfully predicted the behavior of a wide
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.28
3.28
CHAPTER THREE
variety of pseudoplastic mixtures, such as suspensions of limestone, non-aqueous polymer solutions, and nonaqueous pigment paste.
3-4-3 Dilatant Slurries Dilatant fluids are time-independent non-Newtonian fluids and are characterized by the following: 앫 An infinitesimal shear stress is sufficient to initiate motion. 앫 The rate of increase of shear stress with respect to the velocity gradient increases as the velocity gradient increases. Dilatant fluids, therefore, use similar equations as pseudoplastic fluids. They are much less common than pseudoplastics. Dilatancy is observed under specific conditions such as certain concentrations of solids, shear rates, and the shape of particles. Dilatancy is due to the shift, under shear action, of a close packing of particles to a more open distribution in the liquid. Govier et al. (1957) observed the phenomena of dilatancy in suspensions of magnetite, galena, and ferrosilicon in a range of particle sizes from 5 microns to 70 microns. It is observed that the slope of the shear stress versus the shear rate increases, particularly in the range of shear rates from 80 to 120 sec–1. Metzener and Whitlock (1958) explained the phenomenon of dilatancy as follows. Two mechanisms account for the inflection and subsequent increase in the slope of the curve. Initially, the shear stress approaches a magnitude at which the size of flowing particles and aggregates is at a minimum and a Newtonian behavior develops (at the inflection of the curve). As the level of stress rises, the mixture expands volumetrically, and entire layers of particles start to slide or glide over each other. In the interim, the slurry acts as a pseudoplastic until the shear stress is high enough to cause dilatancy. The phenomenon of dilatancy is not easy to model. According to Metzener and Whitlock (1958), it is observed at volumetric concentration in excess of 27–30% and at shear rates in excess of 100 s–1.
3-4-4 Yield Pseudoplastic Slurries Yield pseudoplastic fluids are time-independent non-Newtonian fluids and are characterized by the following: 앫 An infinitesimal shear stress is sufficient to initiate motion. 앫 The rate of increase of shear stress, with respect to the velocity gradient, decreases as the velocity gradient increases. 앫 A yield stress must be overcome at zero shear rate for motion to occur. Examples of yield pseudoplastics are shown in Table 3-11. Equation 3-44 is then modified to account for the yield stress as follows:
w – 0 = K[(d/dt)n]
(3-51)
Equation 3-51 is known as the Herschel–Buckley equation of yield pseudoplastics and is accepted by most slurry experts to describe the rheology of yield pseudoplastics with
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:14 AM
Page 3.29
3.29
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
TABLE 3-11 Examples of Yield Pseudoplastics
Slurry Sewage sludge Sewage sludge Sewage sludge Sewage sludge Kaolin slurry Kaolin slurry Kaolin slurry
Density, kg/m3
Yield stress 0, Pa
Range of consistency coefficient K, Nsn/m2
1024 1011 1013 1016 1071 1061 1105
1.268 0.727 2.827 1.273 1.880 1.040 4.180
0.214 0.069 0.047 0.189 0.010 0.014 0.035
Angle of flow behavior index, n
Reference
0.613 0.664 0.806 0.594 0.843 0.803 0.719
Chilton and Stainsby (1998) Chilton and Stainsby (1998) Chilton and Stainsby (1998) Chilton and Stainsby (1998) Chilton and Stainsby (1998) Chilton and Stainsby (1998) Chilton and Stainsby (1998)
low to moderate concentration of solids. At high shear rates, certain complex phenomena such as dilatancy may develop. Certain bentonite clays develop a yield pseudoplastic rheology at 20% concentration by volume. Krusteva (1998) investigated the rheology of a number of inorganic waste slurries such as drilling fluids in petroleum output, residue mineral materials in tailing ponds, filling of abandoned mine galleries, etc. In the case of clay containing industrial wastes, he indicated that colloidal forces of attraction or repulsion are ever present with Brownian forces and may cause thermodynamic instability. Waste materials such as blast furnace slag, fly ash, and material from mine filling exhibited various forms of a yield pseudoplastic rheology. The behavior of yield pseudoplastics can be expressed by the Carson model as described by Lapasin et al. (1998):
n = n0 +n (d/dt)
(3-52)
By binary system, Lapasin meant a mixture of two sizes of particles above the colloidal range and by ternary, three sizes. Alumina powders with average d50 diameters of 0.9 m, 1.4 m, and 3.9 m, and different specific surface areas (8.23 m2/cm3, 5.74 m2/cm3, and 2.65 m2/cm3) were investigated. A dispersing agent was used. Appreciable time-dependent effects were only noticed at a concentration of the dispersing agent below a critical value. Multicomponent suspensions were found to have a viscosity that was dependent on the total volume concentration of solids Cv and on the composition of the dispersed phase expressed as a volume fraction. It was also dependent on the shear rate of the mixture. Vlasak et al. (1998) investigated the addition of peptizing agents to kaolin–water mixtures. These mixtures were described as yield pseudoplastics that follow the Bulkley–Herschel rheological model (these will be discussed in Chapter 5). The addition of peptizing agents initially achieved a rapid drop of viscosity down to 8–10% of the original value up to an optimum concentration. As the concentration of the peptizing agent is increased beyond an optimum value, its effects are neutralized and the viscosity of the slurry increases again. Soda Water-GlassTM as a peptizing agent seemed to achieve the best reduction in viscosity when added at a concentration of 0.4%. The effect was a drastic drop of viscosity by 92% of its original value (without the peptizing agent). The optimum concentration of sodium carbonate, another peptizing agent, was 0.1%. The viscosity was reduced by 90%. These narrow bands of concentration of peptizing agents can effectively reduce the cost of hydro-transporting kaolin–water mixtures by reducing viscosity and therefore the coefficient of friction.
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:15 AM
Page 3.30
3.30
CHAPTER THREE
3-5 TIME-DEPENDENT NON-NEWTONIAN MIXTURES Because crude oils and slurries of tar sands from certain Canadian mining projects develop a time-dependent non-Newtonian behavior in cold temperatures, a section of this chapter will pay attention to these complex thixotropic properties. In time-dependent non-Newtonian flows, the structure of the mixture and the orientation of particles are sensitive to the shear rates. Due to structural changes and reorientation of particles at a given shear rate, the shear stress becomes time-dependent as the particles realign themselves to the flow. In other words, the shear stress takes time to readjust to the prevailing shear rate. Some of these changes may be reversible when the rate of reformation is the same as the rate of decay. However, in the case of flows in which the deformation is extremely slow, the structural changes or particle reorientation may be irreversible (see Figure 3-13).
3-5-1 Thixotropic Mixtures
Shear Stress (
)
When the shear stress of a fluid decreases with the duration of shear strain, the fluid is called thixotropic. The change is then classified as reversible and structural decay is observed with time under constant shear rate. Certain thixotropic mixtures exhibit aspects of permanent deformation and are called false thixotropic. When the rate of structural reformation exceeds the rate of decay under a constant sustained shear rate, the behavior is classified as rheopexy (or negative thixotropy). One typical example of a thixotropic mixture is a water suspension of bentonitic clays. These difficult slurries are produced by mud drilling associated with the use of positive displacement diaphragm or hose pumps. The reader may find throughout literature considerable discussion about “hysterisis.” This function is used to measure the behavior of the mixture by gradually increasing the shear rate and then by decreasing it back in steps. These curves are interesting but are of limited help to the designer of a pumping system.
Th
ix
ro ot
pi
c
R
p heo
ect
ic
Rate of shear ( = du/dy) FIGURE 3-13 Rheology of time-dependent fluids.
2/28/02
9:15 AM
Page 3.31
3.31
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
Moore (1959) proposed expressing the complex behavior of a thixotropic fluid that does not possess a yield stress value in terms of six parameters:
= (0 + c)(d/dt) d/d = a – (a + bd/dt) where
= duration of the shear for a time-dependent fluid a, b, c, and 0 = materials constants = a structural parameter that has two values (0 and 1) at the limits where the material is fully broken down or fully developed
Fredrickson (1970) discussed the modeling of thixotropic mixtures of suspensions of solids in viscous liquids and proposed that rheological tests be conducted to measure four constants to understand the qualitative nature of the mixture. Ritter and Govier (1970) proposed representing the behavior of thixotropic fluids as follows: 앫 The formation of structures, networks, or agglomerates is similar to a second-order chemical reaction. 앫 The breakdown of the structure is similar to a series of consecutive first-order chemical reactions where formation is meant by behavior that is time-dependent, whereas the breakdown occurs when the viscosity of the fluid acts as a Newtonian mixture that is independent of both the shear rate and the duration of shear (Figure 3-14).
4 Duration of shear, min
2
Shear stress, +0.01, lb /ft
abul-3.qxd
0
10 -1
1
8 6
10 100
4 2
10 -2 10
100 Rate of Shear, d /dt + 10 in sec
1000 -1
FIGURE 3-14 Rheology of Pembina crude oil at 44.5°F at constant duration of shear. (After Govier and Aziz, 1972.)
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:15 AM
Page 3.32
3.32
CHAPTER THREE
Ritter and Govier (1970) therefore proposed to express the shear stress of the fluid in terms of structural stress s and , a component of shearing stress due to the Newtonian component of the fluid:
= s +
(3-53)
s0 + s s – s log = –KD log – log KDR ( 2s0/ s) – s s0 – s
冤
冥
冤
冥
(3-54)
where s0, s = structural stresses at a given shear rate after zero and infinite duration of shear s0 = 0 – (d/dt) s = – (d/dt) KD = a constant that is independent of shear rate but is related to the first-order structural decay process and is expressed in the minutes–1. KDR = a dimensionless measure of the interaction between the network or structure decay and the reestablishment processes The coefficient KDR is evaluated as
2s0 – s1 s KDR = s1 s – 2s
(3-55)
where s1 is measured after a lapse of 1 minute. In Equations 3-54 and 3-55, KDR, KD, s0, s1, and s are determined from rheology tests. Kherfellah and Bekkour (1998) examined the thixotropy of suspensions of montmorillonite and bentonite clays. Montmorillonite clays are used as thickening agents for drilling fluids, paints, pesticides, cosmetics, pharmaceuticals, etc. Commercial bentonite suspensions exhibited thixotropic properties for concentrations higher than 6% by weight. Rheopectic or negative thixotropic mixtures are not common in mining and will not be examined in this chapter.
3-6 DRAG COEFFICIENT OF SOLIDS SUSPENDED IN NON-NEWTONIAN FLOWS Some solids may be transported by highly viscous fluids in a non-Newtonian flow regime. One such example includes solids transported in the process of drilling a tunnel in a sandy soil rich with clay or bentonite. Other examples of solids suspended in non-Newtonian flows are energy slurries, which are mixtures of fine coal and crude oils. In such circumstances, the drag coefficient of the coarse components is of interest. Brown (1991) reviewed the literature for settling of solids in non-Newtonian flows, but cautioned that the studies have been limited to single particles. Considerably more research is needed in this field.
3-7 MEASUREMENT OF RHEOLOGY In the proceeding sections of this chapter, the concepts of Newtonian and non-Newtonian fluids were explored. Measuring the viscosity of a slurry mixture is recommended for ho-
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:15 AM
Page 3.33
3.33
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
mogeneous flows, mixtures with a high concentration of particles, and for fibrous and flocculated slurries. Subsieve particles are defined as particles with an average diameter smaller than 35–70 m (depending on whose reference book you consult). Slurry flows with subsieve particles at a relatively high concentration by volume (Cv 30%) are strongly rheologydependent. Heterogeneous flows, flows without subsieve particles, or flows with subsieve particles at a very low concentrations, are not governed by the rheology of the slurry. Flocculation or the addition of flocculates in the process of mixing slurries tends to result in non-Newtonian rheology. Rheology in simple layman’s terms is the relationship between the shear stress and the shear rate of the slurry under laminar flow conditions. Although this relationship extends to transitional and turbulent flows, most tests are conducted in a laminar regime, often in tubes or between parallel plates. 3-7-1 The Capillary-Tube Viscometer The purpose of the capillary tube viscometer is to measure the rheology of a laminar flow under controlled velocity conditions. Tubes are used in a range of diameters from 0.8–12 mm (1/32–1/2 in). The length of the tube is accurately cut to account for entrance effects and end effects. Typically, the length may be as much as 1000 times the inner diameter. The capillary tube viscometer is used to plot the average rate versus the shear stress at the wall of the tube. This is called the pseudoshear diagram, as defined by the Mooney–Rabinovitch equation:
冦
d[ln(8V/Di)] 8 (du/dr)w = 0.75 + 0.2 Di d[ln(P/4Li)]
冧
(3-56)
where (du/dr)w = rate of shear at the wall P = pressure drop due to friction over a length Li of pipe of inner diameter Di V = average velocity of the flow d = derivative The data is then plotted on a logarithmic scale as per Figure 3-15. The use of capillary-like viscometers is complicated by the “effective slip” of nonNewtonian fluid-suspended material, which tends to move away from the wall, leaving an attached layer of liquid. The result is a reduction in the measurements of effective viscosity. Therefore, it is often recommended to conduct such tests in a number of tubes of different diameters. Measuring the pressure loss between two points well away from the entrance and end effects gives the shear stress at the wall as:
w = RiP/(2Li)
(3-57)
By considering that the velocity profile at a height y above the wall is a function of the shear stress we obtain – (du/dy)w = f ( ) It may be possible to establish a relationship between the flow rate Q and the shear stress as Q 1 3 = 3 w R
冕
w
0
2f ( )d
(3-58)
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:15 AM
Page 3.34
3.34
CHAPTER THREE
100
D4
increasing tube diameter
shear rate
8V D
ter wa 10
1.0
D3 D2 D1
0 0
1.0
Shear Stress FIGURE 3-15 rheometer.
D P 4L
10
Pseudoshear diagram of a non-Newtonian mixture tested in a capillary tube
For a Newtonian flow: 2V Q w 3 = = Di R 4
(3-59)
or = w/(8V/Di). For a Bingham flow:
= (du/dr)w + 0 for > 0, where 0 is the yield stress. The velocity profile is expressed as 2V
Q 3 = = 3 Di w R
冕 ( – )d w
2
0
(3-60)
0
By integration of this equation and by multiplying by 4, the shear rate is derived as 8V w 4 0 1 40 = 1 – + 4 DI
3 w 3 w
冤
冢 冣
冢 冣冥
(3-61)
Equation 3-61 is called the Buckingham equation. This equation cannot be solved without long iterations. Many engineers prefer to simplify the Buckingham equation by ignoring the term ( 0/ w)4, as this term is of negligible magnitude compared with the other terms:
2/28/02
9:15 AM
Page 3.35
3.35
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
w ⬇ 8V /Di + 4/3 0
(3-62)
The modified equation is plotted in Figure 3-16. For a pseudoplastic slurry or power law fluid, the shear stress is expressed by Equation 3-43. By analogy with the method developed for a Bingham flow in a tube, the following equation is expressed: Q 2V 1 3 = = 3 R Di w
冕 ( /K) 2
1/n
d
(3-63)
0
or Q 3 = R
冕
w
0
(3+1/n) (3 + 1/n)K1/n
(3-64)
which once integrated is expressed as 2V n w1/n = Di 3n + 1 K1/n
冢
冣
(3-65)
The effective viscosity is expressed as
e = w/(8V/Di) = K(8V/Di)(n–1)[4n/(3n + 1)]n
(3-66)
w
Unfortunately, Equation 3-66 is of no value when n < 1.0, which is the case for many power law slurries. It would mean that as the shear rate increases, the effective viscosity decreases to zero. This is contradictory to nature. For power law exponents smaller than 1.0, alternative equipment should be used to measure rheology. It is tricky to avoid errors with the use of capillary effect viscometers. A particular source of errors is the end effect. At the entrance exit of the tube, contraction and expansion of the flow cause additional pressure losses.
Shear Stress
abul-3.qxd
w 2 r0 Velocity profile
shear rate FIGURE 3-16 Pseudoshear diagram for a Bingham plastic.
dV dU dy dy
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
3.36
9:15 AM
Page 3.36
CHAPTER THREE
3-7-2 The Coaxial Cylinder Rotary Viscometer A more practical instrument to use when measuring rheology is the coaxial cylinder viscometer. In basic terms, it is a device used to measure the resistance or torque when rotating a cylinder in a viscous fluid (Figure 13-17). The moment of inertia in the cylinder is established by the manufacturer. The torque is due to the force the fluid exerts tangentially to the outside surface of the cylinder: T = 2R0h w R0
(3.67)
where T = (surface area) (shear stress) (radius) R0 = outside radius of the rotating cylinder h = height of the cylinder w = shear stress at the wall The shear stress at any radius r in the fluid can be expressed as du T w = = 2r 2h dy
(3.68)
If the liquid is rotating at an angular velocity , then (du/dy)w = –rd/dr
scale to measure torque
rotation of bob at speed
R0 r Rc
FIGURE 3-17 The rotating concentric viscometer.
slurry
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:15 AM
Page 3.37
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
3.37
and
= –rd/dr –T d = dr 2hr
冕
0
d =
冕
Rc
R0
–T 3 dr 2hr
or
冢
1 1 T = 2 – 2 Rc 4h R 0
冣
(3.69)
where Rc is the radius of the outside cylinder. This is known as the Margulus equation. It is obvious that R 20 can be related to the moment of inertia Ik of the rotating bob cup. Since for a Bingham slurry, the rate of shear is expressed as du/dr = ( – 0); the Margulus equation can be demonstrated as Rc 1 1 T 0 = 2 – 2 – ln Rc R0 4h R 0
冢
冣
冢 冣
(3.70)
= n[T/(2R 20hK)]1/n [1 – (R0/Rc)2/n]
(3.71)
w = T/(2R 2b h)
(3.72)
This equation is known as the Reiner–Rivlin equation. For a Pseudoplastic: At the wall: A plot of log w versus log can be constructed. The slope gives the flow index n and, by substituting Equation 3-45, the value of K can be calculated. Heywood (1991) discussed errors with the use of rotating viscometers. Particular sources of errors are the end effects from both cylinders and the possible deformation of the laminar layer under the effect of high rotational speed. Heywood recommended the use of cylinders with a long length to diameter ratio. Wall slip effects can be detected by using cylinders of different radius but same length. The vendors of rheometers publish equations to correct for wall slip and end effects. One important problem about the use of rheometers is that they do not distinguish between Bingham and Carson slurries. This can lead to grave mistakes in the design of a pipeline. Certain slurries have a course of fractions that could also precipitate during a rheometer test. Unfortunately, this would give false readings. When there is doubt, the safest approach is to conduct a proper pump test in a loop. Whorlow (1992) published a book on rheological techniques that includes dynamic tests and wave propagation tests. In the appendix, he listed a number of rheological investigation equipment manufacturers. Some of the techniques apply more to polymers and are not relevant to our discussion. Dynamic vibration tests have been extended to fresh concrete (Teixera et al., 1998). Concord and Tassin (1998) described a method to use rheo-optics for the study of thixotropy in synthetic clay suspensions. A rheometer optical analyzer was used on laponite, a synthetic hectorite clay. Laponite was mixed with water and tests were conducted at various intervals for up to 100 days. Rheo-optics seems to be
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:15 AM
Page 3.38
3.38
CHAPTER THREE
FIGURE 3-18 Stresstech rheometer, courtesy of ATS Rehosystems. The rheometer was developed for the pharmaceutical and cosmetics industries, where materials consistency may vary from fluid to solid.
a new technique based on the ability of solids to reorient themselves by applying to them a negative electrical charge.
3-8 CONCLUSION In this chapter, it was demonstrated that mixtures of solids and liquids are complex systems. The size of the particles, the diameter of the pipe, the interaction with other particles, the viscosity of the carrier, and the temperature of the flow all interact to yield Newtonian or non-Newtonian flows. In the next three chapters, the principles discussed in the present chapter will be applied to calculate the velocity of deposition, the critical velocity, the stratification ratio, and the friction loss in closed and open conduits for heterogeneous and homogeneous mixtures.
3-9 NOMENCLATURE a A
The longest axis of a particle in Albertson’s model Parameter used to express viscosity of non-Newtonian flows
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:15 AM
Page 3.39
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
A0 A1 b B c C CD CDo CL CN CS Cv Cv Cw da dapp df dg dn d D Di E f( ) FBF Fw g gc h Ik K KD KDR Kt Kz K1, K2, K3 ln L Lc LI n P Q r R Rc Re
3.39
Coefficient Coefficient Axis of a particle in Albertson’s model Parameter used to express viscosity of non-Newtonian flows The shortest axis of a particle in Albertson’s model Parameter used to express viscosity of non-Newtonian flows Drag coefficient of an object moving in a fluid Profile drag coefficient of an object moving in a fluid Lift coefficient of an object moving in a fluid Coefficient based on equivalent Ren Coefficient based on equivalent Ren Concentration by volume of the solid particles in percent Maximum packing concentration of solids Concentration by weight of the solid particles in percent Diameter of a sphere with a surface area equal to the surface area of the irregularly shaped particle Apparent particle diameter Apparent flocculant diameter Sphere diameter Diameter of a sphere with a volume equal to the volume of the irregularly shaped particle in Albertson’s model Particle diameter Drag force Tube or pipe inner diameter Factor between Albertson and Clift shape factors Function of Buoyancy force Wall effect correction factor for free-fall speed of a particle Acceleration due to gravity (9.78–9.81 m/s2) Conversion factor, 32.2ft/s2 if U.S. units between lbms and slugs Height of the cylinder Moment of inertia Consistency index or power law coefficient for a pseudoplastic A constant that is independent of shear rate but is related to the first-order structural decay process and is express in minutes–1 A dimensionless measure of the interaction between the network or structure decay and the reestablishment processes Coefficient for terminal velocity Kozney constant Coefficients natural logarithm Lift force Characteristic length Length of pipe or tube Flow behavior index, or exponent for a pseudoplastic (<1.0) Pressure drop Flow rate Radius Radius Radius of the container in the coaxial cylinder rotary viscometer Reynolds number
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:15 AM
Page 3.40
3.40
Ren Rep Ri R0 sp
CHAPTER THREE
0 s w
A c T
Reynolds Number of a particle based on dn Reynolds Number of a sphere particle based on its diameter Inner radius of a pipe or tube Radius of the bob in the coaxial cylinder rotary viscometer The surface area per unit volume of a sphere of equivalent dimensions or 6/dg, also called specific surface of a particle Front area of a particle orthogonal to the direction of flow Surface area of a wing along the direction of flight Applied torque for the cylinder rotary viscometer Absolute temperature Average velocity of the flow Terminal velocity at very low volume concentration of solids Terminal velocity at given volume concentration of solids The terminal (or free settling) speed Weight the ratio of immobilized dispersing fluid to the volume of solids related approximately to the particle and floc apparent diameter A coefficient used to express to the shear stability of a pseudoplastic mixture Concentration by volume in decimal points Shear strain Wall shear rate or rate of shear strain with respect to time Coefficient of rigidity of a non-Newtonian fluid, also called Bingham viscosity A structural parameter for thixotropic fluids, which do not possess a yield stress value Carrier liquid absolute viscosity Apparent viscosity of a pseudoplastic fluid Effective viscosity Apparent viscosity of a pseudoplastic fluid at zero shear rate Bingham plastic limiting viscosity, or apparent viscosity of a pseudoplastic fluid at very high shear rate Pythagoras number (ratio of circumference of a circle to its diameter) Duration of the shear for a time-dependent fluid Density Shear stress at a height y or at a radius r Yield stress for a Bingham plastic or yield pseudoplastic Structural stress of a thixotropic fluid Wall shear stress Kinematic viscosity Angular velocity of particle Angular velocity of complete system The logarithmic standard deviation Albertson shape factor Clift shape factor Thomas shape factor
Subscripts g L m p s
Equivalent sphere Liquid Mixture Particle Solids
Sf Sw T Ta V V0 Vc Vt W
d/dt
a e 0
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:15 AM
Page 3.41
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
3.41
3–10 REFERENCES Albertson, M. L. 1953. Effects of shape on the fall velocity of gravel particles. Paper read at the 5th Iowa Hydraulic Conference, Iowa University, Iowa City, Iowa. Allen, H. S. 1900. The motion of a sphere in a viscous fluid. Phil. Mag., 50, 323–338, 519–534. Boger, D. V., and Q. D. Nguyen. 1987. The Flow Properties of Weipa #3 and #4 Plant Tailings. Internal study conducted by Comalco Aluminium Ltd, Weipa, Australia, quoted in Darby, R., R. Mun, and D. V. Boger. 1992. Predict Friction Loss in Slurry Pipes. Chem. Engineering, 99, 9 (September), 117–211. Brown, G. G. 1950. Unit Operations. New York: Wiley. Brown, N. P. 1991. The settling behavior of particles in fluids. In Slurry Handling, Edited by N. P. Brown and N. I. Heywood. New York: Elsevier Applied Sciences. Caldwell, D. H., and H. E. Babitt. 1941. Flow of muds, sludge and suspensions in circular pipe. Am. Inst. Chem. Engrs. Trans., 37, 2 (April 25), 237–266. Caldwell, D. H., and H. E. Babitt. 1942. Pipeline flow of solids in suspension. Symp. Am. Soc. of Civ. Eng. Proc., 68, 3 (March), 480–482. Cheng, D. C. H., and W. Whitaker. 1972. Applications of the Warren Spring Laboratory pipeline design method to settling suspension. Paper read at the 2nd Annual Hydrotransport Conference, Bedford, England. Chilton, R. A., and R. Stainsby. 1998. Pressure loss equations for laminar and turbulent non-Newtonian pipe flow. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, 124, 5 (May), 522–529. Clift, R., J. R. Grace, and M. E. Weber. 1978. Bubbles, Drops and Particles. New York: Academic Press. Concord, S., and J. F. Tassin. 1998. Rheoptical study of thixotropy in synthetic clay suspensions. In Proceedings of the Fifth European Rheology Conference. Ljubljana, Slovenia: University of Ljubljana. Cross, M. M. 1965. Rheology of non-Newtonian fluids—New flow equation for pseudoplastic systems. Journal of Colloid Science, 20, 417. Dahlgreen, S. E. 1958. Eyring model of flow applied to thixotropic equilibrium. Journal of Colloid Science, 13 (April), 151–158. Dedegil, M. Y. 1987. Drag coefficient and settling velocity of particles in non-Newtonian suspensions. Journal of Fluids Engineering, 109 (September), 319–323. Dick, R. I., and B. B. Ewing. 1967. Rheology of activated sludge. Journal of Water Pollution Control Federation, 39, 543. Dahlgreen, S. E. 1958. Eyring model of flow applied to thixotropic equilibrium. Journal of Colloid Science, 13 (April), 151–158. Fredrickson, A. G. 1970. A model for the thixotropy of suspensions. American Inst. of Chem. Eng. Journal, 16, 436. Gay E. D., P. A. Nelson, and W. P. Armstrong. 1969. Flow properties of suspensions with high solids concentration. American Inst. of Chem. Eng. Journal, 15, 6, 815–822. Goodrich and Porter. 1967. Govier, G. W., C. A. Shook, and E. O. Lilge. 1957. Rheological Properties of water suspensions of finely subdivided magnetite, galena, and ferrosilicon. Trans. Can. Inst. Mining Met., 60, 157. Govier, G. W., and K. Aziz. 1972. The Flow of Complex Mixtures in Pipes. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold. Hedstrom, B. O. A. 1952. Flow of plastic materials in pipes. Ind. Eng. Chem., 33, 651–656. Herbrich, J. 1968. Deep ocean mineral recovery. Paper read at the World Dredging Conference II, Rotterdam, the Netherlands. Herbrich, J. 1991. Handbook of Dredging Engineering. New York: McGraw-Hill. Heywood, N. I. 1991. Rheological characterisation of non-settling slurries. In Slurry Handling, Edited by N. P. Brown and N. I. Heywood. New York: Elsevier Applied Sciences. Heywood, N. I. 1996. The performance of commercially available Coriolis mass flowmeters applied to industrial slurries. Paper read at the 13th International Hydrotransport Symposium on Slurry Handling and Pipeline Transport. Johannesburg, South Africa. Cranfield, UK: BHRA Group. Inter-Agency Committee on Water Resources. 1958. Report 12. Internal report by the Subcommittee on Sedimentation, Minneapolis, Minnesota.
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
3.42
9:15 AM
Page 3.42
CHAPTER THREE
Kearsey, H. A., and L. E. Gill. 1963. Study of sedimentation of flocculated thorium slurries using gamma ray technique. Trans. Inst. Chem. Engrs., 41, 296. Kherfellah, N., and K. Bekkour. 1998. Rheological characteristics of clay suspensions. In Proceedings of the Fifth European Rheology Conference. Ljubljana, Slovenia: University of Ljubljana. Krusteva, E. 1998. Viscosmetric and pipe flow of inorganic waste slurries. In Proceedings of the Fifth European Rheology Conference. Ljubljana, Slovenia: University of Ljubljana. Lapassin, R., S. Pricl, and M. Stoffa. 1998. Viscosity of aqueous suspensions of binary and ternary alumina mixtures. In Proceedings of the Fifth European Rheology Conference. Ljubljana, Slovenia: University of Ljubljana. Metzner, A. B., and M. Whitlock. 1958. Flow behavior of concentrated (dilatant) suspensions. Trans. Soc. Rheology, 2, 239–254. Moore, F. 1959. Rheology of Ceramic Slips and Bodies. British Ceramic Society Transactions, 58, 470. Mun, R. 1988. The Pipeline Transportation of Suspensions with a Yield Stress. Master’s Thesis, University of Melbourne, Australia. Parzonka, W. 1964. Determination of the maximum concentration of homogeneous mixtures (in French). Journal of the French Academy of Science, 259, 2073. Pilpel, N. 1965. Flow properties of non-cohesive powders. Chemical Process Eng. 46, 4, 167–179. Prokunin, A. N. 1998. Particle-wall interaction in liquids with different rheology. In Proceedings of the Fifth European Rheology Conference. Ljubljana, Slovenia: University of Ljubljana. Richards, R. H. 1908. Velocity of Galena and Quartz Falling in Water. Trans AIME, 38, 230–234. Ritter, R. A., and G. W. Govier. 1970. The development and evaluation of a theory of thixotropic behavior. Can. Journal Chem. Eng., 48, 505. Rubey, W. W. 1933. Settling velocities of gravel, sand and silt particles. Amer. Journal of Science, 25, 148, 325–338. Skelland, A. H. P. 1967. Non-Newtonian Flow and Heat Transfer. New York: Wiley. Teixeira, M. A. O. M., R. J. M. Craik, and P. F. G. Banfill. 1998. The effect of wave forms on the vibrational processing of fresh concrete. In Proceedings of the Fifth European Rheology Conference. Ljubljana, Slovenia: University of Ljubljana. Thomas, D. G. 1961. Transport characteristics of suspensions: Part II. Minimum transport velocity for flocculated suspensions in horizontal pipes. AIChE Journal, 7 (September), 423–430. Thomas, D. G. 1963. Transport characteristics of suspensions. Ch. E. Journal, 9, 310. Thomas, A. D. 1981. Slurry pipeline rheology. Paper presented at the National Conference on Rheology. Second Annual Conference of the British Society of Rheology, Australian Branch, University of Sydney, Australia. Turton, R., and O. Levenspiel. 1986. A short note on drag correlation for spheres. Powder Technology Journal, 47, 83. Valentik, L., and R. L. Whitemore. 1965. Terminal velocity of spheres in Bingham plastics. British Journal of Applied Phys., 16, 1197. Vlasak, P., Z. Chara, and P. Stern. 1998. The effect of additives on flow behaviour of kaolin–water mixtures. In Proceedings of the Fifth European Rheology Conference. Ljubljana, Slovenia: University of Ljubljana. Wasp, E. J., J. P. Kenny, and R. L. Gandhi. 1977. Solid-Liquid Flow—Slurry Pipeline Transportation. Trans-Tech Publications. Wells, P. J. 1991. Pumping non-Newtonian slurries. Technical Bulletin 14. Sydney, Australia: Warman International. Whorlow, R. W. 1992. Rheological Techniques, 2d. ed. New York: Ellis Horwood. Wilson, K. C., G. R. Addie, and R. Clift. 1992. Slurry Transport Using Centrifugal Pumps. New York: Elsevier Applied Sciences. Worster, R. C., and D. E. Denny. 1955. Hydraulic transport of solid materials in pipes. Proceedings of the Institute of Mechanical Engineers (UK), 38, 230–234. Further Reading: Caldwell, D. H., and H. E. Babitt. 1942. Pipeline flow of solids in suspension. Symp. Am. Soc. of Civ. Eng. Proc., 68, 3 (March), 480–482. Goodrich, J. E., and R. S. Porter. 1967. Rheological interpretation of torque—Rheometer data. Polymer Eng & Science, 7 (January), 45–51.
abul-3.qxd
2/28/02
9:15 AM
Page 3.43
MECHANICS OF SUSPENSION OF SOLIDS IN LIQUIDS
3.43
Lazerus, J. H., and P. T. Slatter. 1988. A method for the rheological characterization of tube viscometer data. Journal of Pipelines, 7, 165–176. Thomas, D. G. 1960. Heat and momentum transport characteristics of non-Newtonian aqueous thorium oxide. AIChE Journal, 7, 431. Wilson, K. C. 1991. Pipeline design for settling slurries. In Slurry Handling. Edited by N. P. Brown, and N. I. Heywood. New York: Elsevier Applied Sciences. Wilson, K. C. 1991. Slurry transport in flumes. In Slurry Handling. Edited by N. P. Brown, and N. I. Heywood. New York: Elsevier Applied Sciences.
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.1
CHAPTER 4
HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS OF SETTLING SLURRIES
4-0 INTRODUCTION A practical engineer sifting through the literature on slurry flows would be astonished by the number of different equations. Since the work of the French scientists Durand and Condolios in 1952, and British scientists Newitt et al. in 1955, engineers and scientists have continued to develop new equations for deposition velocity and friction losses. This chapter reviews the evolution of models of Newtonian slurry flows from wellgraded and uniform particle sizes to complex mixtures of coarse and fine particles. For this purpose, some equations are listed in a historical context, to demonstrate their evolution to the reader. The sheer number of equations demonstrates how complicated heterogeneous flows are. A number of factors interact in a horizontal pipe. The flow takes the form of different regimes, and includes everything from a simple stationary bed at low speed to a pseudohomogeneous flow at high speeds. For each regime, equations have been developed over the years to account for the mean particle diameter, the diameter of the conduit, the density of the particles, their drag coefficient, the speed of flow, etc. As a result, there are many angles from which a heterogeneous flow of settling solids can be examined. The followers of Durand and Condolios put great emphasis on the drag coefficient of the solid particles, whereas the followers of Newitt prefer to focus on the terminal velocity. As we have clearly demonstrated in Chapter 3, the drag coefficient and the terminal velocity are interrelated. Examining a flow of slurry is often an exercise of playing with a murky liquid in which very little can be seen. Sand does not behave like coal and there is not a single universal law that may apply to the transportation of solids by liquids. It is therefore important to rely on database, historical information, and empirical data. In the past, engineers have tried to simplify the complexity of slurry flows by defining certain transition velocities. With the use of modern research tools, there is an emerging approach of rejecting the concept of an abrupt change from one state of flow to another, and a tendency to consider such a change over a band of the speed. Different approaches have been developed to examine the mixture of coarse and fine particles from superimposed layers to two-layer models. This book is intended for engineers, and various examples are included in the text. The purpose of such examples is to simplify the use of complex equations. With modern personal computers, which use simple languages such as quick basic, an engineer can efficiently calculate friction losses for a heterogeneous slurry flow. 4.1
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.2
4.2
CHAPTER FOUR
4-1 REGIMES OF FLOW OF A HETEROGENEOUS MIXTURE IN HORIZONTAL PIPE The history of slurry pipelines was briefly presented in Section 1-10 of Chapter 1. Two schools are credited for laying the foundations of modern hydro-transport engineering; SOGREAH in France, and the British Hydro-mechanic Research Association of the United Kingdom. Starting in 1952, Durand and Condolios of SOGREAH published a number of studies on the flow of sand and gravel in pipes up to 900 mm (35.5 in) in diameter. Based on the specific gravity of particles with a magnitude of 2.65, they proposed to divide the flows of nonsettling slurries in horizontal pipes into four categories based on average particle size as follows: 앫 Homogeneous suspensions for particles smaller than 40 m (mesh 325) 앫 Suspensions maintained by turbulence for particle sizes from 40 m (mesh 325) to 0.15 mm (mesh 100) 앫 Suspension with saltation for particle sizes between 0.15 mm (mesh 100) and 1.5 mm (mesh 11) 앫 Saltation for particles greater than 1.5 mm (mesh 11) This initial classification was refined over the next 18 years by Newitt et al. (1955), Ellis and Round (1963), Thomas (1964), Shen (1970), and Wicks (1971). Due to the interrelation between particle sizes and terminal and deposition velocities, the original classification proposed by Durand has been modified to four flow regimes based on the actual flow of particles and their size. Referring to Figures 4-1 and 4-2, there are four main regimes of flow in a horizontal pipe 1. 2. 3. 4.
Flow with a stationary bed Flow with a moving bed and saltation (with or without suspension) Heterogeneous mixture with all solids in suspension Pseudohomogeneous or homogeneous mixtures with all solids in suspension
velocity
d nde spe u s ly Ful
suspended with moving bed
suspended with saltation
lenticular deposits
stationary deposits with ripples
blocked pipe
FIGURE 4-1 Flow regimes of heterogeneous flows in terms of speed versus volumetric concentration (after Newitt et al., 1955).
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.3
Flow
with
a sta tion ary be
F d wi low w th or ith a wi tho mov ut sus ing b pen ed sio ns
HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS OF SETTLING SLURRIES
particle size
abul-4.qxd
th
wi
4.3
all
low sf n u o ne sio ege en ter susp e H s in id sol Flow as a homogeneous or
pseudohomogeneous suspension
Mean velocity
FIGURE 4-2 Flow regimes of heterogeneous flows in terms of particle size versus mean velocity (after Shen, 1970).
Two special cases shown in Figure 4-1 are not considered to be at the limits of these regimes of flows. They are lenticular deposits at very low speeds but low solid concentration, and blocked pipes at high solid concentration. Slurry flows that have some form of segregation or separation of solids in layers are called “heterogeneous” flows, whereas the slurries themselves are called “settling” slurries. 4-1-1 Flow With a Stationary Bed When the slurry flow speed is low, the bed thickens. As the fluid above the bed tries to move the solids by entrainment, they tend to roll and tumble. The particles with the lowest settling speed move as an asymmetric suspension, whereas the coarser particles build up the bed. As the speed drops even further, the pressure to maintain the flow becomes quite high and eventually the pipe blocks up. Flow with saltation and asymmetric suspension occurs above the speed of blockage. This means that the coarser particles “sand up,” whereas the finer particles continue to move. Certain tailing lines have exhibited this phenomenon. In fact, when a process plant is built with a tailing line too large to handle the initial flow, the operator may choose to let the bottom of the pipe sand up to reduce the effective cross-sectional area of the pipe. This principle has been successfully applied to pipelines in a variety of countries. Saltation can eventually lead to blockage of a pipe. It may result in a number of problems, such as water hammer, wear, and freezing in cold climates. Most engineering specifications require that the pipeline be designed to operate at speeds higher than those associated with saltation. 4-1-2 Flow With a Moving Bed When the speed of the flow is low and there are a large number of coarse particles, the bed moves like desert sand dunes. The top particles are entrained in the moving fluid
abul-4.qxd
4.4
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.4
CHAPTER FOUR
above the bed. Consequently, the upper layers of the bed move faster than the lower layers in a horizontal pipe. If the mixture were composed of a wide range of particles with different sizes and settling velocities, the bed would be composed of the particles with the highest settling speed. Particles with a moderate settling speed are maintained in an asymmetric suspension, with most particles concentrated in the lower half of the pipe, whereas the particles with the lowest settling speed move as a symmetric suspension
4-1-3 Suspension Maintained by Turbulence As the flow speed increases, turbulence is sufficient to lift more solids. All particles move in an asymmetric pattern with the coarsest at the bottom of a horizontal pipe covered with superimposed layers of medium- and fine-sized particles. Many particles may strike the bottom of the pipe and rebound. Wear on the bottom of the pipe must be taken into account in maintenance schedules and the pipes must be rotated at intervals suggested by the slurry engineer in order to maintain an even wear pattern of the internal wall of the pipe. Although the flow is not symmetric, from the point of view of power consumption, this regime may be the most economical for transporting a certain mass of solids. Wilson (1991) calls all flows below V3 fully stratified flows and all flows above V3 fully suspended flows. The transition from fully stratified to fully suspended flows is considered by this author to be fairly complex and should be represented by sigmoid or ogee curves. It is a transition over a range of the speed and not an abrupt transition at a single value of the speed. The work of Wilson and colleagues will be examined in Section 4-4-5.
4-1-4 Symmetric Flow at High Speed At speeds in excess of 3.3 m/s (10 ft/s), all solids may move in a symmetric pattern (but not necessarily uniformly). Sometimes this flow is called pseudohomogeneous because of its symmetry around the pipe axis. Power consumption is a linear relationship of the static head multiplied by the velocity, but is proportional to the cube of velocity needed to overcome friction losses. Power consumption in pseudohomogeneous mixtures of coarse and fine particles may be excessive for long pipelines. Pseudohomogeneous mixtures of fine or ultrafine particles may occur at speeds as low as 1.52 m/s (5 ft/s). One definition of fine and coarse particles was explained Govier and Aziz (1972), who proposed the following: 앫 Ultrafine particles: dp < 10 m (mesh 1250), where gravitational forces are negligible. 앫 Fine particles: 10 m < dp < 100 m (mesh 1250 < dp < mesh 140), usually carried fully suspended but subject to concentration gradients and gravitational forces. 앫 Medium sized particles: 100 m < dp < 1000 m (mesh 240 < dp < mesh 15), will move with a deposit at the bottom of the pipe and with a concentration gradient. 앫 Coarse particles: 1000 m < dp < 10,000 m (0.039 in < dp < 0.394 in). These are seldom fully suspended and form deposits on the bottom of the pipe. 앫 Ultracoarse particles are larger than 10 mm (0.4 in). These particles are transported as a moving bed on the bottom of the pipe. Considering particle sizes while ignoring their density is meaningless. Practical engineers do shift the boundaries between different sizes based on the density of the particles. There is no question that beads of high-density polyethylene will behave differently than
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.5
HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS OF SETTLING SLURRIES
4.5
sand particles with the same average diameter because the former is lighter than water while the latter is 2.65 times heavier than water.
4-2 HOLD-UP The previous section describes how different layers of solids move with different speeds, from the bottom, coarser particles, to the finer particles at the top of the horizontal pipe. The theory of hold-ups complicates this process, however. Hold-ups are due to velocity slip of layers of particles of larger sizes, particularly in the moving bed flow pattern. Newitt et al. (1962) conducted speed measurements of a slurry mixture in a horizontal pipe. In the case of light Plexiglas pipe, zircon or fine sand did not result in local slip; particles and water moved at the same speed. However, for coarse sand and gravel, they observed asymmetric suspension and a sliding bed. They also observed that in the upper layers of the horizontal pipe, the concentrations of larger particles were the same as for finer solids, but were marked by differences in the magnitude of the discharge rate of the lower layers.
4.3 TRANSITIONAL VELOCITIES The four regimes of flow described in Section 4-1 can be represented by a plot of the pressure gradient versus the average speed of the mixture (Figure 4-5). The transitional velocities are defined as 앫 V1: velocity at or above which the bed in the lower half of the pipe is stationary. In the upper half of the pipe, some solids may move by saltation or suspension.
1.0
Ratio distanc e from bottom of pipe to the inner diameter (y/D) I
0.8 0.6 0.4
C
0.0 3
abul-4.qxd
0.2
v 7 0.0
0.10
4 0.1
0 0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.20
Discharge solids concentration C y FIGURE 4-3 Distribution of concentration of solids in a pipe versus average volumetric concentration.
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.6
4.6
CHAPTER FOUR
앫 V2: velocity at or above which the mixture flows as an asymmetric mixture with the coarser particles forming a moving bed. 앫 V3 or VD: velocity at or above which all particles move as an asymmetric suspension and below which the solids start to settle and form a moving bed. 앫 V4: velocity at or above which all solids move as a symmetric suspension.
Velocity (ft/se c)
Volumetric Concentration (%)
0
5
10
15
20
direction of flow 30 20 10 0 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Velocity (m/s ) FIGURE 4-4 Simplified concept of particle distribution in a pipe as a function of volumetric concentration and speed.
1
at w asymmetric flow
V2 V 3
stationary bed
V1
3
V4
symmetric flow
2
er
4
moving bed
Pressure drop per unit of length
slurry
Speed of flow
FIGURE 4-5 Velocity regimes for heterogeneous slurry flows.
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.7
4.7
HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS OF SETTLING SLURRIES
V3 is effectively the deposition velocity, often called in the past the Durand velocity for uniformly sized coarse particles. It is no longer recommended that it be called the Durand velocity, as tests in the last 20 years have led to new equations that include the effects of particle size and composition of the slurry. The magnitude of the velocity depends on the volumetric concentration (Figure 4-7).
4-3-1 Transitional Velocities V1 and V2 The transitional velocity V1 is obviously not used for the operation of slurry lines. It may be of interest in lab research, instrumentation, and monitor of start-up. The transitional velocity V2 is determined individually from pressure measurements of the pressure gradient. The main focus of the tests is to determine the height of the bed and to derive a stratification ratio. Wilson (1970) developed a model for the incipient motion of granular solids at V2. He assumed a hydrostatic pressure exerted by the solids on the wall and proposed the following equation: 1 ⌬P ᎏ ᎏ L L
– sin cos
s
+ ᎏ 冢sin – ᎏ 冣冥 冢 冣冤 ᎏᎏ D tan 4 Rw i
r
s(S – 1) Cvb(sin – cos )g = ᎏᎏᎏ 2
(4-1)
where (⌬P/L)2 = pressure gradient at 2 = half the angle subtended at the pipe center due to the upper surface of the bed, in radians s = coefficient of static friction of the solid particles against the wall of the pipe Rw = cross-sectional area of the bed divided by the bed width r = angle of repose of the solid particles
100
10
0
0
10
100
d 50
Cumulative passing (%)
abul-4.qxd
1000
Particle mesh diameter ( m) FIGURE 4-6 Concept of d50 by cumulative passing percentage versus particle size.
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.8
4.8
CHAPTER FOUR
S = ratio of density of solids to density of liquid Cvb = volume fraction solids in the bed (When USCS units are used, express density in slugs/ft3 rather than lbm/ft3). For 0.7 mm (mesh 24) sand with water in a 90 mm (3.5 in) pipe, Wilson measured = 0.35 and concluded that the assumptions of hydrostatic distribution of the granular pressure were correct.
4-3-2 The Transitional Velocity V3 or Speed for Minimum Pressure Gradient The transitional velocity V3 is extremely important because it is the speed at which the pressure gradient is at a minimum. Although there is evidence that solids start to settle at slower speeds in complex mixtures, operators and engineers often referred to transitional velocity as the speed of deposition. Durand and Condolios (1952) derived the following equation for uniformly sized sand and gravel: VD = V3 = FL{2 · g · Di[(s – L)/L]}1/2
(4-2)
where FL = is the Durand factor based on grain size and volume concentration V3 = the critical transition velocity between flow with a stationary bed and a heterogeneous flow Di = pipe inner diameter (in m) g = acceleration due to gravity (9.81 m/s) s = density of solids in a mixture (kg/m3) L = density of liquid carrier The Durand factor FL is typically represented in a graph for single or narrow graded particles, as in Figure 4-7 after the work of Durand (1953). However, since most slurries
Durand Velocity Factor FD
2.0
1.0
For single or narrow graded slurries
CV = 15% CV = 10%
CV = 5%
C = 2% V
Based on Schiller equation using d50
CV = 15% CV = 5%
0 0
1.0
2.0
3.0
Particle diameter (mm)
FIGURE 4-7 Durand velocity factor versus particle size—comparison between the conventional values for single graded slurries and Schiller’s equation using d50 for wide graded slurry.
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.9
4.9
HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS OF SETTLING SLURRIES
are mixtures of particles of different sizes, this plot is considered too conservative. The Durand velocity factor has been refined by a number of authors. In an effort to represent more diluted concentrations, Wasp et al. (1970) proposed including a ratio between the particle diameter and the pipeline diameter. Wasp proposed the use of a modified factor F⬘ L so that
S – L VD = V3 = FL⬘ 2gDi ᎏ L
冤
冥 冤ᎏ D 冥 1/2
dp
1/6
(4-3)
i
Schiller and Herbich (1991) proposed the following equation for the Durand velocity factor based on the d50 of the particles: )[1 – exp (–6.9 d50)]} FL = {(1.3 × C 0.125 v
(4-4)
where d50 is expressed in mm. Some reference books define a Froude number as Fr = FL · 兹2苶. The particle size d50 is the statistically determined particle size below which half (or 50%) would be equal or smaller to that set size. The following example illustrates the concept of d50. Example 4-1 A sample of slurry is sieved for particle size. The data is collected in the laboratory (see Table 4-1). Plot the data on a logarithmic graph and determine the d50. Solution The data is plotted in Figure 4-6; the d50 is determined to be 145 m. Example 4-2 A slurry mixture has a d50 of 300 m. The slurry is pumped in a 30 in pipe with an ID of 28.28⬙. The volumetric concentration is 0.27. Using Equations 4-4 and 4-2, determine the speed of deposition for a sand–water mixture if the specific gravity of sand is 2.65. Solution in SI Units From Equation 4-4: FL = (1.3 × 0.270.125)(1-exp (–6.9 × 0.3)) FL = 1.1 × 0.8738 FL = 0.964 From Equation 4-2 the deposition velocity is V3 = 0.964 (2 × 9.81 × 28.25 × 0.0254 × 1.65)1/2 V3 = 4.64 m/s
TABLE 4-1 Data for Example 4-1 Particle size (m)
425
300
212
150
106
75
53
45
38
–38
Cumulative passing (%)
97.2
87.1
68.3
51.3
35.9
20.5
14.5
11.8
10.8
—
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.10
4.10
CHAPTER FOUR
Solution in USCS Units From Equation 4-4: FL = (1.3 × 0.270.125)(1 – exp (–6.9 × 0.3)) FL = 1.1 × 0.8738 FL = 0.964 From Equation 4-2 the deposition velocity is V3 = 0.964 (2 × 32.2 × 28.25/12 × 1.65)1/2 V3 = 15.25 ft/sec Various curves have been published for the magnitude of FL. They are often plotted for a single graded size and use difficult to read logarithmic scales. For the sake of accuracy, Table 4-2 tabulates the magnitude of FL between 0.08 mm < d50 < 5mm on the basis
TABLE 4-2 The Coefficient FL Based on Schiller’s Equation Using the d50 of the Particles for Particles Between 0.080 and 5 mm for Volumetric Concentration up to 30%. FL = {(1.3 × C v0.125)[1 – exp(–6.9 d50)]} d50 (mm)
CV = 0.05
CV = 0.10
CV = 0.15
CV = 0.20
CV = 0.25
CV = 0.30
0.08 0.10 0.12 0.14 0.16 0.18 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 0.50 0.55 0.60 0.65 0.70 0.75 0.80 0.85 0.90 1.00 1.5 2 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 5.0
0.379 0.446 0.503 0.554 0.598 0.636 0.669 0.735 0.781 0.814 0.837 0.854 0.866 0.874 0.880 0.884 0.887 0.889 0.890 0.891 0.892 0.893 0.8939 0.8940 0.8940 0.8940 0.8940 0.8940 0.8940
0.414 0.486 0.549 0.604 0.652 0.693 0.730 0.801 0.852 0.888 0.913 0.931 0.944 0.953 0.959 0.964 0.967 0.969 0.971 0.972 0.973 0.974 0.9748 0.9749 0.9749 0.9749 0.9749 0.9749 0.9749
0.435 0.511 0.577 0.635 0.686 0.729 0.768 0.843 0.896 0.934 0.961 0.980 0.993 1.002 1.009 1.014 1.017 1.020 1.021 1.023 1.023 1.0245 1.0255 1.0255 1.0255 1.0255 1.0255 1.0255 1.0255
0.451 0.530 0.599 0.658 0.711 0.756 0.796 0.874 0.929 0.968 0.996 1.015 1.029 1.039 1.046 1.051 1.055 1.057 1.059 1.060 1.061 1.062 1.063 1.063 1.063 1.063 1.063 1.063 1.063
0.464 0.545 0.616 0.677 0.731 0.777 0.818 0.898 0.955 0.995 1.024 1.044 1.058 1.069 1.076 1.081 1.084 1.087 1.089 1.090 1.091 1.092 1.0931 1.0932 1.0932 1.0932 1.0932 1.0932 1.0932
0.474 0.557 0.630 0.693 0.748 0.795 0.837 0.919 0.977 1.018 1.048 1.068 1.083 1.093 1.101 1.106 1.109 1.112 1.114 1.115 1.116 1.1172 1.1183 1.1184 1.1184 1.1184 1.1184 1.1184 1.1184
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.11
HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS OF SETTLING SLURRIES
4.11
of Schiller’s equation. The magnitude of FL based on d50 is smaller than values published in the literature for single graded slurry mixtures (lab mixtures using a uniform size of particles). A number of authors have confirmed that this is the case (Warman International Inc., 1990). In order to compare the conventional magnitude of FL based on single and narrow graded particles to the Schiller equation, both ranges of FL are plotted in Figure 4-7. With a more complex approach that takes into account the actual viscosity of the slurry mixture and the density of the particles, Gillies et al. (1999) developed an equation for the Froude number F in terms of the Archimedean number (which we will discuss in Section 4-4-5 for stratified coarse flows): 4 Ar = ᎏ d 3 ( – )g 3L2 p L s L
(4-5)
To estimate the deposition velocity V3, Gilles et al. (1999) developed an equation for the Froude number based on the Archimedean number: Fr = aArb
(4-6)
where Fr = FL · 兹2苶 For Ar > 540, a = 1.78, b = –0.019 For 160 < Ar < 540, a = 1.19, b = 0.045 For 80 < Ar < 60, a = 0.197, b = 0.4 For Ar < 80, the Wilson and Judge (1976) equation can be used, which expressed the Froude number as
冦
冢
dp Fr = (兹2 苶) 2.0 + 0.30 log10 ᎏ DiCD
冣冧
(4-7)
This correlation is useful in the range of 10–5 < (dp /DiCD) < 10–3. To determine the drag coefficient, the actual density of the liquid should be used, whereas the viscosity should be corrected for the presence of fines. Example 4-3 Water at a viscosity of 0.0015 Pa · s (0.0000313 slugs/ft-sec) is used to transport sand with an average particle diameter of 300 m (0.0118 inch). The volumetric concentration is 0.27. The pipe’s inner diameter is 717 mm (28.35⬙). Using the Gilles equation (Equation 4-6), determine the deposition velocity if the specific gravity of sand is 2.65. Assume CD = 0.45. Solution in SI Units d50 0.3 ᎏ = ᎏ = 0.4 × 10–3 Di 717 Iteration 1 Assuming CD > 10–3, by the Wilson and Judge correlation (Equation 4-7):
冦
冢
0.003 Fr = (兹2苶) 2.0 + 0.30 log10 ᎏᎏ 0.717 × 0.45 Fr = 1.54 FL = Fr/兹2苶 = 1.54/兹2苶 = 1.09
冣冧
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.12
4.12
CHAPTER FOUR
The specific gravity of the mixture is determined as: Sm = Cv(Ss – SL) + SL = 0.27 (2.65 – 1) + 1 = 1.446 苶g苶D 苶苶 苶苶 苶苶– 1苶 = 4.82 m/s VD = FL兹[2 i( s/ L 苶苶] Iteration 2 4 × 9.81 (3 × 10–4)3 × 1000 (1650) Ar = ᎏᎏᎏᎏ = 258.98 3(1.5 × 10–3)2 for 160 < Ar < 540, a = 1.19, b = 0.045. From equation 4.6: Fr = aArb = 1.19 · 258.980.045 = 1.53 FL = F/兹苶2 = 1.53/兹苶2 = 1.082 VD = FL[2gDi(s/L – 1)]0.5 VD = 1.082[2 · 9.81 · 0.717 · (1.65)]0.5 = 5.21m/s Solution in USCS Units d50 0.00118 ᎏ = ᎏ = 0.4 × 10–3 Di 28.23 Iteration 1 Assuming CD > 10–3, by the Wilson and Judge correlation (Equation 4-7):
冦
冢
0.00118 Fr = (兹苶2) 2.0 + 0.30 log10 ᎏᎏ 28.23 × 0.45
冣冧
Fr = 1.54 FL = 1.54/2 = 1.09 The specific gravity of the mixture is determined as: Sm = Cv(Ss – SL) +SL = 0.27(2.65 – 1) + 1 = 1.446 VD = 1.09[2 · 32.2 · (28.23/12) (2.65 – 1)]0.5 VD = 17.23 ft/sec Iteration 2 The particles’ diameter is 0.984 · 10–3 ft The density of water is 1.93 slugs/ft3 The density of sand is 5.114 slugs/ft3 Water dynamic viscosity is 0.0000313 slugs/ft-sec 4(0.984 · 10–3)3 × 1.93(5.114 – 1.93) · 32.2 Ar = ᎏᎏᎏᎏᎏᎏ = 259 3(0.0000313)2 for 160 < Ar < 540, a = 1.19, b = 0.045. From equation 4.6, Fr = aArb = 1.19 · 258.980.045 = 1.53 FL = 1.53/兹2苶 = 1.082 VD = FL[2gDi(s/L – 1)]0.5 VD = 1.082[2 · 32.2 · 2.35 · (1.65)]0.5 = 17.1 ft/s
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.13
HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS OF SETTLING SLURRIES
4.13
The solution by the Gilles equation is within the limits set by Schiller in Example 4-2. In these two different examples, we applied two different formulae but obtained consistent results. This demonstrates the sensitivity of approaches to equations derived from empirical equations. It may be necessary sometimes try to solve a problem using two different equations, and to use common sense when similar results are obtained. Table 4-3 presents values of the Archimedean number, the resultant magnitude of the factor FL for particles d50 in the range of 0.08 to 50 mm for a specific gravity of 1.5, which is typical of coal-based mixtures. Most coals may be pumped with different sizes of particles as discussed in Chapter 11. The viscosity may be due to the presence of cer-
TABLE 4-3 The Coefficient FL Based on Gilles Equation for Particles Between 0.080 and 50 mm of Specific Gravity of 1.500 (e.g., Coal) as a Function of Viscosity
d50 (mm) 0.08 0.10 0.12 0.14 0.16 0.18 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 0.50 0.55 0.60 0.65 0.70 0.75 0.80 0.85 0.90 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 20.00 30.00 40.00 50.00
= 1 cP = 5 cP = 10 cP _____________________ _______________________ _______________________ Archimedean Archimedean Archimedean number Ar FL number Ar FL number Ar FL 3.35 6.54 11.3 17.9 26.8 38.1 52.3 102 177 280 419 596 818 1088 1413 1796 2243 2579 3348 4016 4768 6540 52320 176580 418560 817500 1415640 3348480 6540000 5.23 × 107 17.7 × 108 41.86 × 108 81.75 × 108
Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 0.89 1.062 1.084 1.104 1.420 1.43 1.437 1.445 1.451 2.457 1.463 1.469 1.474 1.478 1.487 1.547 1.583 1.610 1.63 1.647 1.674 1.696 1.764 1.805 1.835 1.859
0.13 0.26 0.45 0.72 1.07 1.53 2.1 4.1 7.1 11.2 16.75 23.8 32.7 43.5 56.51 72 89.7 110.4 134 161 191 262 2093 7063 16742 32700 56505 133939 261600 2092800 7063202 16742404 32700008
Eqn 4-7 0.033 Eqn 4-7 0.065 Eqn 4-7 0.113 Eqn 4-7 0.18 Eqn 4-7 0.27 Eqn 4-7 0.38 Eqn 4-7 0.52 Eqn 4-7 1.02 Eqn 4-7 1.77 Eqn 4-7 2.80 Eqn 4-7 4.19 Eqn 4-7 5.96 Eqn 4-7 8.18 Eqn 4-7 10.9 Eqn 4-7 14.1 Eqn 4-7 18 0.84 22.4 0.914 27.6 0.99 33.5 1.058 40 1.066 48 1.081 65 1.455 523 1.489 1765 1.514 4185 1.533 8175 1.55 14126 1.575 33485 1.595 65400 1.66 523200 1.698 1765800 1.726 4185601 1.749 81750020
Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-17 1.12 1.45 1.475 1.494 1.51 1.534 1.554 1.616 1.654 1.682 1.703
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
4.14
9:16 AM
Page 4.14
CHAPTER FOUR
tain fines, as with peat coals or degradation of the coal during pumping over long distances, or the use of a heavy medium such as magnetite at high concentration as a carrier for coal in a water mixture. Table 4-4 presents values of the factor FL for particles d50 in the range of 0.08 to 50 mm for a specific gravity of 2.65, which is typical of sand and tar-sand-based mixtures. The largest particles are often found in tar sand applications, with some contribution of the tar or oil to viscosity. In this table, there was no need to present the Archimedean number, as this was demonstrated in the previous table. Newitt et al. (1955) preferred to express the speed of transition between “saltation” flow and heterogeneous flow in terms of the terminal velocity of particles (previously discussed in Chapter 3): V3 = 17 Vt
(4.8)
The reader should refer to Equation 3-18, which corrects the terminal velocity of a single particle to a mass of particles at higher volumetric concentration. Although Equation 4-8 has served as the basis of many models, we will later discuss the recent corrections proposed by Wilson et al. (1992). The approach to obtain the magnitude of V3 is basically to conduct a test and measure pressure drop per unit length of pipe. V3 is considered to occur at the minima, or the point of minimum pressure drop. W. E. Wilson (1942) expressed the pressure gradient of noncolloidal solids by referring to clean water and by proposing a correction to the Darcy–Weisbach equation (discussed in Chapter 2). He expressed the consumed power due to friction by the following equation:
FIGURE 4-8 These taconite tailings must be pumped above a deposit velocity of 13 ft/s in 14⬙ pipe due to the size of the particles.
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.15
4.15
HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS OF SETTLING SLURRIES
TABLE 4-4 The Coefficient FL Based on Gilles Equation for Particles Between 0.080 and 50 mm of Specific Gravity of 2.65 (e.g., Sands and Oil Sands) as a Function of Viscosity d50 (mm) 0.08 0.10 0.12 0.14 0.16 0.18 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40 0.45 0.50 0.55 0.60 0.65 0.70 0.75 0.80 0.85 0.90 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 8.00 10.00 20.00 30.00 40.00 50.00
= 1 cP, FL
= 5 cP, FL
= 10 cP, FL
Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 0.837 0.964 1.061 1.093 1.421 1.433 1.444 1.454 1.462 1.470 1.478 1.485 1.491 1.497 1.502 1.507 1.512 1.521 1.583 1.620 1.647 1.668 1.685 1.713 1.735 1.805 1.847 1.877 1.901
Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 0.8 0.906 1.016 1.065 1.076 1.087 1.097 1.107 1.116 1.423 1.431 1.489 1.524 1.549 1.569 1.585 1.611 1.632 1.698 1.737 1.766 1.789
Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-7 Eqn 4-17 0.847 0.915 0.984 1.054 1.072 1.450 1.484 1.509 1.528 1.544 1.569 1.589 1.654 1.692 1.720 1.742
冢
冣
(4-9)
⌬Hf g fDV 2 C1CwVt g ᎏ=ᎏ+ᎏ L 2Di V
(4-10)
CwVt fDV ⌬Hf = L ᎏ + C1 ᎏ 2gDi V where ⌬Hf = head loss due to friction (in units of length) fD = Darcy–Weisbach friction factor C1 = constant Equation 4-9 may also be reexpressed as
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.16
4.16
CHAPTER FOUR
By differentiating this equation with respect to V, we obtain for the minimal value –C1CwVt g 2 fDV ᎏ = ᎏᎏ 2Di V2 or fDV C1CwVt g ᎏ=ᎏ Di V2 C1CwVt gDi V 3 = ᎏᎏ fD at constant friction factor fD, or [C1CwVt gDi]1/3 Vmin = ᎏᎏ f D1/3
(4-11)
The magnitude of the Darcy friction factor for water flow in rubber lined and HDPE pipe was computed for pipes from 2⬙ to 18⬙ and results presented in Chapter 2. Wilson (1942) defined a factor C3 to determine whether the particles will settle to form a bed: 2Vt C3 = ᎏᎏ (⌬Hf fD gDi/L)1/2
(4-12)
If C3 > 1 most particles with a terminal velocity Vt will stay in suspension. If C3 ⱕ 1 most particles with a terminal velocity Vt will settle out. Whereas the equations of Newitt et al. (1955) and Wilson (1942) focused on the terminal velocity, the work of Durand and Condolios (1952) focused on the drag coefficient for sand and gravel. Zandi and Govatos (1967) and Zandi (1971) extended the work of Durand to other solids and to different mixtures. They defined an index number as V 2CD1/2 Ne = ᎏᎏ CvDi g(s/w – 1)
(4-13)
At the critical value when Ne = 40, the flow transition between saltation and heterogeneous regimes occurs. This statement infers that when Ne < 40 saltation occurs, and when Ne ⱖ 40 heterogeneous flow develops. These results, based on a mixture of different particle sizes, did not apply to the work of Blatch (1906), who concentrated on particles of a uniform size (sand 20–30 mesh in water). Babcock (1967) reinterpreted this work and demonstrated that for finely graded particles the transition occurred at an index number of 10. It is obvious that a complex mixture of particles of different sizes can increase the magnitude of the transition index number. Example 4-4 Tailings from a mine consist of solids at a volumetric concentration of 20%. The specific weight of the solids is 4.2. The pipe diameter is 8⬙ with a wall thickness of 0.375⬙ and rubber lining of 0.5⬙. The particle Albertson shape factor is 0.7. The dynamic viscosity is 3 cP. The average d50 = 0.4 mm. Determine the speed of transition from saltation using the Zandi approach as expressed by Equation 4-13. Solution in SI Units Pipe inner diameter Di = 8⬙ – 2 · (0.5 + 0.375) = 6.25⬙ = 158.75 mm
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.17
HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS OF SETTLING SLURRIES
4.17
Iteration 1 Let us first assume a transition from saltation at 3 m/s and let us determine the drag coefficient of the particles in water at the stated dynamic viscosity: Rep = 1000 · 0.0004 · 3/0.003 = 400 From Table 3.7, CD = 1.09. The transition from saltation occurs when Ne = 40. From Equation 4-13, using SI units: 9 · 兹1 苶.0 苶9苶 Ne = ᎏᎏᎏᎏ 0.2 · 0.15875 · 9.81 · (4.2/1 – 1) Ne = 9.43. Iteration 2 Let us first assume a transition from saltation at 6 m/s and let us determine the drag coefficient of the particles in water at the stated dynamic viscosity: Rep = 1000 · 0.0004 · 6/0.003 = 800 From Table 3.7, CD = 1.15. 苶5苶 36 · 兹1苶.1 Ne = ᎏᎏᎏᎏ 0.2 · 0.15875 · 9.81 · (4.2/1 – 1) Ne = 39. The transition from saltation therefore occurs at a speed of 6.1 m/s. Solution in USCS Units Iteration 1 Pipe diameter = 8⬙ – 2 · (0.375 + 0.5) = 6.25⬙ = 0.521 ft Let us first assume a transition from saltation at 10 ft/s and let us determine the drag coefficient of the particles in water at the stated dynamic viscosity. Particle size = 0.4 mm/304.7 mm = 1.3128 × 10–3 ft
= 0.003/47.88 = 6.265 × 10–5 lbf-sec/ft2 Density of water = 62.3 lbm/ft3/32.2 ft/sec = 1.935 slugs/ft3 1.935 slugs/ft3 × 1.3128 × 10–3 ft × 10 ft/sec Re = ᎏᎏᎏᎏᎏ 6.265 × 10–5 lbf-sec/ft2 = 406 From Table 3.7, CD = 1.09. 苶9苶 100 · 兹1苶.0 Ne = ᎏᎏᎏᎏ 0.2 · 0.5208 ft · 32.2 ft/sec · (4.2/1 – 1) Ne = 9.73. Iteration 2 Let us first assume a transition from saltation at 20 ft/s and let us determine the drag coefficient of the particles in water at the stated dynamic viscosity: Rep = 406 · (20/10) = 804
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.18
4.18
CHAPTER FOUR
From Table 3.7, CD = 1.15. 202 · 兹1苶.1 苶5苶 Ne = ᎏᎏᎏᎏ 0.2 · 0.5208 ft · 32.2 ft/sec · (4.2/1 – 1) Ne = 39.97. The transition from saltation therefore occurs at a speed of 20 ft/sec. 4-3-3 V4: Transition Speed Between Heterogeneous and Pseudohomogeneous Flow For the transition to pseudohomogeneous flows, Newitt et al. (1955) expressed the speed in terms of the terminal velocity of particles as V4 = (1800 gDiVt)1/3
(4-14)
Refer to Chapter 3 and Equation 3-18 to calculate terminal velocity. Govier and Aziz (1972) applied Newton’s law (i.e., CD = 0.44) for particles immersed in a fluid to Equation 4-14 to yield 4gdp 1/6 V4 = 38.7D 1/3 i ᎏ (S – 1) 3CD
(4-15)
Govier and Aziz (1972) analyzed the work of Spells (1955) on solid particles with a diameter 80 m < dp < 800 m (mesh 180 < dp < 20) and derived the following equation: V 1.63 V4 = 134CD0.816D 0.633 i t
(4-16)
This equation was derived in USCS units with the diameter expressed in feet and the velocity in feet per seconds. Example 4-5 An ore with a specific gravity of 4.1 is to be pumped in a pseudohomogeneous regime in a 24 in pipe with an ID of 22.23 in. The drag coefficient of the particles is assumed to be 0.44. The estimated flow rate is 12,000 US gpm. The particles have a sphericity of 0.72 and a diameter of 250 m. Solve for V4. Solution in SI Units 12,000 × 3.785 Q = ᎏᎏ = 0.757 m3/s 60,000 Pipe ID = 22.25 × 0.0254 = 0.565 m Cross-sectional area = 0.251 m2 Average speed of flow = 3.02 m/s Sphericity = Asp/Ap = 0.72 苶2 苶苶 ×苶25苶0苶 = 218 m dsp = 兹0苶.7
Vt =
ᎏᎏᎏᎏ 冣 冪冢莦莦莦莦 莦 3 × 0.44 × 1000 4 × 0.218 × 10–3 × 9.81 (4100 – 1000)
Vt = 0.142 m/s
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.19
HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS OF SETTLING SLURRIES
4.19
By Newitt’s equation (Equation 4.14): V4 = (1800 × 9.81 × 0.565 × 0.142)1/3 V4 = 11.22 m/s Alternatively using Equation 4.16: Di = 1.854 ft Vt = 0.466 ft/sec V 1.63 V4 = 134C D0.816D 0.633 i t V4 = 134 × 0.440.816 × 1.8540.633 × 0.4661.63 = 29.19 ft/sec or 8.9 m/s Solution in USCS Units Q = 12,000 · 0.002228 = 26.736 ft3/sec Pipe ID = 22.25/12 = 1.854 ft Cross-sectional area = 2.7 ft2 Average speed of flow = 9.9 ft/sec Sphericity = Asp/Ap = 0.72 苶2 苶苶 ×苶25苶0苶 = 218 m = 0.000715 ft dsp = 兹0苶.7
The density of water is 1.93 slugs/ft3 The density of solids is 7.913 slugs/ft3 Vt =
冪冢莦莦莦冣莦 4 × 0.000715 × 32.2 (7.913 – 1.93) ᎏᎏᎏᎏ 3 × 0.44 × 1.93 Vt = 0.465 ft/s
By Newitt’s equation (Equation 4.14): V4 = (1800 × 32.2 × 1.854 × 0.465)1/3 V4 = 36.83 ft/sec Alternatively, using Equation 4.16: V 1.63 V4 = 134C D0.816D 0.633 i t V4 = 134 × 0.440.816 × 1.8540.633 × 0.4661.63 = 29.19 ft/sec
4-4 HYDRAULIC FRICTION GRADIENT OF HORIZONTAL HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS Having been able to determine the speed for transition from one regime to another, the slurry engineer must determine the loss of head per unit length due to friction, called the hydraulic friction gradient (Equation 2-24). The hydraulic friction gradient for the slurry (im) is higher than the hydraulic friction gradient for an equivalent volume of water. Since the first slurry pipelines were built, engineers and scientists have tried to correlate the losses with slurry to those of an equivalent volume of water. It was initially assumed that the friction losses would increase in proportion to the vol-
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
4.20
Page 4.20
CHAPTER FOUR
umetric concentration of solids. A term im was then defined as the friction head of the mixture in equivalent meters (or feet) of the carrier fluid (e.g., water) per unit of pipe length. In Chapter 2, the friction hydraulic gradient was introduced by Equation 2-24 and is defined as: fDV 2 i= ᎏ 2gDi There are a number of models to predict friction losses and they are essentially based on the interaction forces between solids and liquid carrier. Some use the drag coefficient, others use the terminal velocity of the solids, and some consider the solids to be moving as a bed with a layer of liquid and suspended fines above it. To reflect the increase in friction head due to the volumetric concentration of solids, Durand and Condolios (1952) proposed a nondimensional ratio im – iL Z= ᎏ CviL
(4-17)
where Cv = the volumetric concentration of solids im = pressure gradient for the slurry mixture in meters of water iL = pressure gradient for an equivalent volume of water or carrier fluid in meters of water
C V3 C V2 C V1
im iL
w at er
in equivalent (m/m) or (ft/ft)
Head loss per pipe length
The reader should not confuse head of slurry in meters or feet of slurry with meters or feet of water. This is not a barometer or some instrument measuring pressure; for this reason everything is kept consistent by using meters or feet of water. By itself, the term i relates only to clear water having the same velocity as the slurry flow. It is convenient to use water as a reference benchmark. (See Figure 4-9.)
Average velocity of flow FIGURE 4-9 Concepts of the hydraulic friction gradients im and iL for slurry mixture and for water.
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.21
HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS OF SETTLING SLURRIES
4.21
4.4.1 Methods Based on the Drag Coefficient of Particles Based on their analysis of test data from 11 references for sand in particle sizes ranging up to 1 inch (25.4 mm), in pipes with a diameter range from 1.5 inch to 22 inch, and in volumetric concentration up to 22%, Zandi and Govatos (1967) derived an equation for the index number Ne (equation 4-13) in terms of the volumetric concentration, and some empirical parameters: V 2C D1/2 = ᎏᎏ Dig(s/w – 1)
(4-18)
Ne = ᎏ Cv
(4-19)
Or from equation 4-13:
or = CvNe. They plotted this function against a parameter to express head loss as im – iL = ᎏ = K()m CviL
(4-20)
where iL = hydraulic gradient in terms of water density for a flow of clean water with a mean velocity V im = hydraulic gradient in terms of water density for a slurry flow with a mean velocity V K, m = constants On a logarithmic scale they obtained: For > 10, K = 6.3 and m = –0.354 For < 10, K = 280 and m = –1.93 The data is presented in Figure 4-10. The dramatic change in values of K and m at = 10 has encouraged researchers to develop more sophisticated models that we shall review in the rest of this chapter. Substituting for the value of 40 of the index coefficient, V3 may be expressed as [40 CvDi g(s – w)/w]1/2 V3 = ᎏᎏᎏ C D1/4
(4-21)
Equation 4-21 is therefore a modified version of Equation 4-2. Equation 4-4 is a different approach, as it accounts for particle size, which is often easier to measure than the drag coefficient. Example 4-4 has shown that some iteration is necessary to obtain the velocity at which the transition from saltation to asymmetric flow occurs. Despite its simplicity, this method continues to be used by dredging engineers who usually deal with sand and gravel mixtures of less than 20% concentration by volume. The personal experience of the author is that often mines and dredging systems have to be designed in very remote areas where there are no slurry labs to conduct tests. This is an unfortunate fact, and sometimes an “overconservative” approach based on Durand, Zandi, and other authors is the only alternative. However, the author does encourage engineers of slurry systems to plan well ahead and test data to avoid very expensive field corrections.
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.22
4.22
CHAPTER FOUR 10000
RANGE OF 1 NUMBER Zandi & Govtes
1000 Durand & Condolios
쐌 0–40 쐌 40–310 왌 310–1550 왖 1550–3100
iL = ᎏ Cv iL
100
10
1
.1
.01 .01
0.1
1.0
10 V 2兹C 苶苶D = ᎏᎏ Di g( s /L – 1)
100
1000
FIGURE 4-10 The Zandi–Govatos factors for heterogeneous slurry flows. (From Zandi and Govatos, 1967, reprinted with permission from ASCE.)
Shook et al. (1981) modified Zandi’s equation by proposing “in-situ concentration of particles” Ct rather than volumetric concentration:
t = Km im – iL t = ᎏ iLCt They measured a magnitude of m = –1 for one single type of coal in different pipe sizes. They measured different values of K for different coals. The in-situ concentration Ct remained constant with speed, but the volumetric concentration of solids Cv that could be moved increased with V. This concept will be reexamined in Section 4.10 as part of the two-layer models. Example 4-6 Using Equations 4-19 to 4-20, consider the pumping of solids in a 305 mm (12 in) ID pipe at a speed of 3.045 m/s (10 ft/s) and a volumetric concentration of 18%. Assume a drag coefficient of 0.45 for the solid particles and a specific gravity of 2.65. Determine the increase in the pressure gradient for flow in the pipe due to the presence of solids.
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.23
HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS OF SETTLING SLURRIES
4.23
Solution in SI Units V = 3.045 m/s pipe Di = 0.305 m (12 in) 3.0452 × 兹苶 0苶 .4苶5 Ne = ᎏᎏᎏ = 68.67 0.18 × 0.305 × (2.65 – 1) 68.67 Ne = ᎏ = ᎏ = 381.5 Cv 0.18
> 10 then K = 6.3 and m = –0.345 =
= K –0.345 = 0.81
im – iL ᎏ = 0.81 × 0.18 = 0.145 iL im ᎏ = 1.145 iL The slurry causes an increase of pressure gradient of 14.5% by comparison with water at the same velocity. Using the approach developed by Durand and Condolios, the fanning friction factor for the slurry is correlated with the friction factor for an equivalent volume of water by the following equation: gDi(s – L) fDm = fDL 1 + Kf Cv ᎏᎏ 苶 V2L兹苶 CD
冦
冤
冥 冧 3/2
(4-22)
Wasp et al. (1977) deducted that the coefficient Kf is between 80 and 150, depending on the slurry. The most common value is actually 81 for most sands according to Govier and Aziz (1972) (see Table 4-5). Example 4-7 Using Equation 4-22, determine the correction for the friction factor for the portion of solids in a slurry mixture of uniform size distribution. The slurry is pumped at the rate of 16,000 gpm in a rubber-lined 22.75⬙ ID pipe. The volumetric concentration is 22%. Assume Kf = 85 and CD = 0.45. Use the Swain–Jaime equation to determine fL. The specific gravity of the solids is 2.65. The dynamic viscosity of water is 2.7 × 10–5 lbf-sec/ft2. Solution in SI Units 16,000 (3.785) Q = ᎏᎏ = 1.009 m3/s 60,000 Pipe ID = 22.75 (0.0254) = 0.5778 m Area of pipe = 0.262 m2 Velocity = 3.85 m/s Dynamic viscosity = 0.00129 mPa · s
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.24
4.24
CHAPTER FOUR
TABLE 4-5 Correction of Friction Factor Due to Volumetric Concentration of Solids Based on Equation 4-22 Assuming K = 81 gDi (s – L) ᎏᎏ V 2L兹苶 C苶 D
fDm – fDL ᎏ CV fDL
gDi (s – L) ᎏᎏ V 2L兹苶 C苶 D
fDm – fDL ᎏ CV fDL
0.01 0.02 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.08 0.09 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.35 0.40
0.081 0.229 0.421 0.648 0.906 1.190 1.500 1.833 2.187 2.561 4.706 7.245 10.125 13.31 16.77 20.49
0.45 0.50 0.55 0.60 0.65 0.70 0.75 0.80 0.85 0.90 0.95 1.00
24.451 28.638 33.039 37.645 42.448 48.024 52.611 57.959 63.477 69.159 75.002 81.000
For the water: 1,000 (3.85) 0.5778 Re = ᎏᎏᎏ = 1,723,292 0.00129 Absolute roughness of rubber = 0.00015 m. Relative roughness 0.00015 ᎏ = ᎏ = 0.0002596 DI 0.5778 0.25 = 0.0151 fD = ᎏᎏᎏᎏᎏ [log10{(0.0002596/3.7) + (5.74/1,723,2920.9)}2]
冤
冢
9.81 · 0.578 · 1.65 fm = fL 1 + 85 · 0.22 ᎏᎏ 3.852兹苶0苶 .4苶4苶5 fm = fL · 18.067 = 0.273 Solution in USCS Units Q = 35.63 ft3/sec 22.75 Pipe ID = ᎏ = 1.896 ft 12 Area = 2.823 ft2
冣 冥 1.5
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.25
HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS OF SETTLING SLURRIES
4.25
Velocity = 12.62 ft/s Dynamic viscosity = 1.29 cP = 0.0129 · 0.002089 lbf-sec/ft2 = 0.00002695 lbf-sec/ft2
冢
冣
62.3 12.62 (1.896) Re = ᎏ ᎏᎏ = 1.7 × 106 32.2 2.695 × 10–4 Absolute roughness of rubber = 0.00049 ft Relative roughness of rubber = 0.0002596 fD = 0.0151
冤
冢
32.2 × 1.896 × 1.65 ᎏ fm = 0.0151 1 + 85 × 0.22 ᎏᎏᎏ 12.622 兹苶0苶 .4苶5
冣 冥 = 0.27 1/5
An increase of the friction factor by 18-fold appears to be very high. The engineer in charge of such a problem should seriously consider redesigning the system. At this stage, the reader is encouraged to become familiar with the basic equations before applying them to compound systems. Equation 4-17 can be expressed in terms of the drag coefficients of the solid particles, the pipe inner diameter, the density of the solid and liquid phases, the speed, and an experimental factor Ke: im – iL Dig(s/L – 1) 1 ᎏ Z = ᎏ = Ke ᎏᎏ 兹C 苶D 苶 CviL V2
冤
冢
冣冥
3/2
(4-23)
Babcock (1968) was very critical of all equations using pressure gradients based on the work of Durand and Condolios or their followers. Geller and Gray (1986) did not agree with Babock’s criticisms and spelled out some of the misgivings. Govier and Aziz (1972) did confirm that errors of the order on 40% have occurred in predicted values of Z, but for all intents and purposes, these equations were the best available till the early 1970s. Herbich (1991) agreed with the value of 81 for most dredged sands and gravel. Sand and gravel are typically dredged, then pumped at a volumetric concentration smaller than 20%.
4.4.2 Effect of Lift Forces It may be considered that the magnitude of the constant m is based on a very large magnitude of data. In an innovative study at the Canada Center for Mineral and Energy Technology (CANMET), Geller and Gray (1986) conducted an extended analysis that demonstrated that lift forces had an effect on the pressure gradient. This study, rather than dismissing the ideas of Durand, supported the previous work and gave it more importance. Reviewing the work of Babock (1971), Geller and Gray (1986) indicated that for fine to intermediate sizes (80/100 quartz sand with d = 0.16 mm) the value of m was –0.25. In addition, they concluded that lift forces are at a maximum when the volumetric concentration Cv is less than 0.23. For intermediate sands at higher volumetric concentration, the lift forces seem to be minimal. This is an important factor to consider (for an understanding of lift forces review Chapter 3, Section 3.1). Furthermore, there is an important coefficient of mechanical friction p, which results from the sliding displacement between solids in contact, which is distinct from the viscous friction.
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.26
4.26
CHAPTER FOUR
4-4-3 Russian Work on Coarse Coal There are no universally accepted models for coarse coal. Work in the former Soviet Union on coarse coal was reported by Traynis (1970) and reviewed by Faddick (1982). From Russian data, the following two equations were reported. For deposition velocity: [(c – hm)/c]1/3 ᎏ V3 = [Dig]1/2 ᎏᎏ [ fDLk CD]1/3
(4-24)
For the hydraulic gradient for coal: 兹g苶D 苶苶i Cvc(s – hm) s – L im = iL 1 + Cv ᎏ + ᎏ · ᎏᎏ L k CdVL
冦
冢
冣 冤
冥冧
(4-25)
where Cv = total volumetric concentration of solids Cvc = volumetric concentration of coarse solids K = constant for coarse coal = 1.9 CD = drag coefficient considered to be 0.75 for the coarse coal fraction hm = density of heavy medium produced by the fines For the other terms, see Section 4-14. Example 4-8 Coarse coal is to be pumped in a rubber-lined 18 in pipe steel with an inner diameter of 17 in. A screen analysis of the coal indicates that it has a distribution of 20% passing 200 microns. The velocity of pumping is 4.5 m/s and the total weight concentration is 52%. The specific gravity of the coal is 1.35. Determine the hydraulic gradient due to wall friction in the horizontal pipeline. Assume a water dynamic viscosity of 1.2 cP, but correct for viscosity due to solids using Einstein’s equation. Assume a drag coefficient of 0.75 for the coarse coal. Solution Since the weight concentration is 52%, the specific gravity of the mixture is Sm = SL/(1 – (CW (Ss– SL)/Ss) = 1/(1 – 0.52(1.35 – 1)/1.35) = 1.156 The volumetric concentration is Cv = Cw Sm/Ss = 0.52 · 1.156/1.35 = 0.445 The weight concentration of the fines is 20%. Density of the heavy medium carrying the fines is Smf = SL/(1 – (CWf(Ss– SL)/Ss) = 1/(1 – 0.104(1.35 – 1)/1.35) = 1.028 Volumetric concentration of the fines = 0.2 · 0.445 = 0.089. Calculations in SI Units Pipe ID = 17 (0.0254) = 0.432 m Area of pipe = 0.146 m2 Velocity = 4.5 m/s The dynamic viscosity is corrected to take in account the presence of fines at a volumetric concentration of 0.089. The dynamic viscosity of water is 1.2 cP, the Einstein–Thomas equation is applied:
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.27
4.27
HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS OF SETTLING SLURRIES
= L(1 + (2.5 · 0.089) + (10.05 · 0.0892) + 0.00273 exp (16.6 · 0.089)] = 1.314 L = 1.577cP 1,000(4.5) 0.432 Re = ᎏᎏ = 1,232,720 0.001577 Absolute roughness of rubber = 0.00015 m. Relative roughness:
0.00015 ᎏ = ᎏ = 0.000368 DI 0.432 0.25 = 0.0162 fDL = ᎏᎏᎏᎏᎏ [log10{(0.000368/3.7) + (5.74/1,232,7200.9)}2] iL = fDV 2/(2gDi) = 0.0162 · 4.52/(2 · 9.81 · 0.432) = 0.0387 m/m Using Equation 4.25:
冦
冢
冣 冤
兹(9 苶.8 苶1 苶苶·苶 0.4 苶3 苶2 苶)苶 0.8 · 0.445 · (1350 – 1028) 1350 – 1000 im = 1 + 0.445 ᎏᎏ + ᎏᎏ · ᎏᎏᎏ 1000 1.9 · 0.75 · 4.5 1000
冥冧
im = 0.0387[1 + 0.445(0.35)] + [0.0368)] = 0.0815m/m The presence of coal effectively doubles the head losses. The deposition velocity is expressed from Equation 4-24: [(1350 – 1028)/1350]1/3 V3 = [0.432 · 9.81]1/2 ᎏᎏᎏ [0.0162 · 1.9 · 0.75]1/3 V3 = 4.48 m/s Calculations in USCS Units Pipe ID = 17⬙ = 1.417 ft Area of pipe = 1.576 ft2 Velocity = 4.5 m/s = 14.76 ft/sec The dynamic viscosity is corrected to take in account the presence of fines at a volumetric concentration of 0.089. For the water, dynamic viscosity = 1.2 cP = 0.012 · 0.002089 lbfsec/ft2 = 2.507 × 10–5 lbf-sec/ft2. The Einstein–Thomas equation is applied:
= L(1 + (2.5 · 0.089) + (10.05 · 0.0892) + 0.00273 exp (16.6 · 0.089)] = 1.314 L = 3.294 × 10–5lbf-sec/ft2 . For the water, the density is 1.934 slugs/ft3. 1.934 · 14.76 · 1.417 Re = ᎏᎏᎏ = 1.23 × 106 3.294 × 10–5 Absolute roughness of rubber = 0.000492 ft. Relative roughness: 0.000492 ᎏ = ᎏ = 0.000368 DI 1.417
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.28
4.28
CHAPTER FOUR
0.25 fDL = ᎏᎏᎏᎏᎏ = 0.0162 [log10{(0.000368/3.7) + (5.74/(1.23 × 106)0.9)}2] iL = fDV 2/(2gDi) = 0.0162 · 14.762/(2 · 32.2 · 1.417) = 0.0387 ft/ft Using Equation 4.25, and substituting density with specific gravity
冦
冢
冣 冤
兹苶 (3苶2.2 苶苶·苶 1.4 苶1 苶7 苶)苶 0.8 · 0.445 · (1.350 – 1.028) 1.350 – 1 im = 1 + 0.44 ᎏ + ᎏᎏ · ᎏᎏᎏ 1 1.9 · 0.75 · 14.76 1.0
冥冧
im = 0.0387[1 + 0.445(0.35)] + [0.0368)] = 0.0815ft/ft The presence of coal effectively doubles the head losses. The deposition velocity is expressed from Equation 4-24: [(1.350-1.028)/1.350]1/3 V3 = [1.417 · 32.2]1/2 ᎏᎏᎏ [0.0162 · 1.9 · 0.75]1/3 V3 = 14.71 ft/sec The coal slurry is therefore being pumped just above the deposition speed, and therefore at the minimum pressure gradient for horizontal pipelines.
4-4-4 Equations for Nickel–Water Suspensions Ellis and Round (1963) conducted tests on a mixture of nickel particles and water and derived the following equation: im – iL = ᎏ = K()m = 385 –1.5 CviL
(4-26)
The constants K and m are therefore different from those reported by Zandi and Govatos (1967) for sand particles, as expressed by Equation 4-20.
4-4-5 Models Based on Terminal Velocity Newitt et al. (1955) conducted tests in pipes smaller than 150 mm (6 in) and proposed to express Z in terms of the terminal velocity (instead of the drag coefficient).
s – L gDiVt im – i Z = ᎏ = K2 ᎏ ᎏ Cvi L V m3
冤
冥
(4-27)
where K2 = an experimentally determined constant. For small pipes, K2 = 1100. Vm = mean velocity of mixture For solids of different sizes, Newitt suggested a weighted mean diameter as n
dpm = 冱 dpimi/mt i=1
where mi = the mass of solids with particle diameter of dp mt = total mass of solids
(4.28)
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.29
HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS OF SETTLING SLURRIES
4.29
Hayden and Stelson (1968) proposed a modification of the Durand–Condolios equation using the terminal velocity instead of the drag coefficient: gDi[(m – L)/L]Vt im – iL ᎏ = 100 ᎏᎏᎏ Cv iL V 2 兹g苶d苶苶 苶苶)/ 苶L苶–苶苶) 1苶 p( m苶
冤
冥
1.3
(4-29)
Geller and Gray (1986) pointed out that the equations of Durand, Newitt, and Babcock converged when m = –1. Newitt et al. (1955) minimized the importance of lift forces when a bed cannot form because of lift forces on particles. However, the work of Bagnold (1954, 1955, 1957) indicated that the submerged weight of particles separated from the bed was transmitted to the bed or the pipe wall under the same conditions. Thus, mechanical friction can contribute to head loss. It may be argued that sometimes it is easier to measure the terminal velocity rather than the drag coefficient, particularly with oddly shaped particles. As Chapter 3 clearly demonstrated, both parameters are interrelated. Example 4-9 The tailings from a small mine are pumped at a weight concentration of 40%. They consist of crushed rock at a specific gravity of 3.2. The d85 of the particles is 1mm. For a flow rate of 280 m3/hr, a smooth high-density polyethylene pipe with an internal diameter of 138 mm is selected. Using Newitt’s method as expressed By equations 4.27 and 4.29, determine the head loss due to the presence of solids, assuming a dynamic viscosity of 1.8 cP. Solution in SI Units Pipe flow area = 0.25 · · 0.1382 = 0.01496 m2 Average velocity of flow = Q/A = (280/3600)/0.01496 = 5.2 m/s Particle Reynolds number using the density of water = Rep = 0.001 · 3.71 · 1000/0.0018 = 2063 Since Rep > 800, the flow is turbulent and Newton’s law is used to calculate the terminal velocity: Vt = 1.74(dp · g · (p – L)/L)1/2 = 1.74(0.001 · 9.81 · 2.1)1/2 = 0.25 m/s By Newitt’s method, the transition between saltation and motion occurs at 17Vt or V3 = 17 · 0.25 = 4.25 m/s Since the weight concentration is 40%, the specific gravity of the mixture is Sm = SL/(1 – (CW (Ss– SL)/Ss) = 1/(1 – 0.4(3.1 – 1)/3.1) = 1.372 The volumetric concentration is Cv = (1.372 – 1)/2.1 = 0.177 Using equation 4.27, and assuming K2 = 1100, Z = 1100 · (2.1) · (9.81 · 0.138 · 0.25/5.23) = 5.563 im/i = 1 + 0.177 · 5.563 = 1.985 Using equation 4.29:
冢
9.81 · 0.138 · 2.1 · 0.25 im – iL ᎏ = 100 ᎏᎏᎏ CviL 5.22[9.81 · 0.001 · 2.2)1/2 im/iL = 1 + 0.177 · 11 = 2.95
冣
1.3
= 11
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
4.30
9:16 AM
Page 4.30
CHAPTER FOUR
This example and the use of these two equations indicates that the empirical coefficients of 1100 in the Newitt method for fine coal and sand, or the empirical coefficient of 100 for sand from the Hayden and Stelson equation, do not converge for similar results. Testing would be recommended to confirm the magnitude of these coefficients.
4.5 DISTRIBUTION OF PARTICLE CONCENTRATION IN COMPOUND SYSTEMS The reader may be familiar with the concepts developed in the 1950s and 1960s on uniformly graded solid particles. In reality, slurries often consist of a wide distribution of particles. The coarser ones tend to move at the bottom of the horizontal pipe, and the finer ones move above these bottom layers. Understanding the distribution of these particles in layers above layers is essential for a correct estimation of the friction losses. Initially, the work was done in the 1930s and 1940s on open channel flows and is discussed in Chapter 6, Section 6-2-3. The distribution of volumetric concentration is shown to be a function of depth of the liquid in an open channel flow, raised to a exponent. The exponent is a function of the relation of the terminal velocity to the friction velocity. Ismail (1952) was the first to extend the approach of Vanoni to closed conduits. He focused initially on rectangular closed conduits. This test work demonstrated that the concentration was an exponential function:
冢 冣
C Vt Log10 ᎏ = ᎏ (y – a) CA Es
(4-30)
where Es = the mass transfer coefficient a = height of layer A above bottom of the conduit y = distance from the lower boundary C = volumetric concentration of the particle diameter under consideration CA = volumetric concentration of height “A” For many pipes, C/CA is considered by Wasp et al. (1977) to be 0.08 DI from the top of the pipe. Wasp et al. (1977) examined the distribution of concentration of The Consolidation Coal Company’s Ohio coal pipeline at a height of 8% from the bottom of the conduit and at 8% from the top of the conduit; they reinterpreted the work of Ismail (1951) and devised the following equation:
冢
1.8 Vt C log10 ᎏ = – ᎏ CA KxUf
冣
(4-31)
where Uf is the friction velocity (discussed in Chapter 2) Kx is the Von Karman constant  = constant of proportionality Hsu et al. (1971) reexamined the work of Ismail by proposing a polar coordinate system (r, ) for the analysis of the distribution of concentration in a pipe: Vt r cos ␣ cos C(r, ) ᎏ = exp ᎏ ᎏ ᎏᎏ Uf RI me C(0, 0)
冤 冢
冣冥
(4-32)
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.31
HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS OF SETTLING SLURRIES
4.31
where ␣ = the angle from the horizontal = angle from the vertical starting at the lowest quadrant point RI = inner diameter of pipe r = local radius for a point in the flow Equation 4-30 can be reduced to
冤 冥
Vt C log10 ᎏ = ᎏ (constant) CA Uf
(4-33)
The extent by which the Von Karman constant Kx is suppressed by turbulence is difficult to assess. Ippen (1971) conducted an analysis of turbulent suspensions in open channel flows. This work showed that the concentration close to the lower boundary was the most important factor suppressing the Von Karman constant. This may not be astonishing when we consider that beds of coarse particles form in this region at low speeds. Hunt (1969) developed an equation for diffusion of heterogeneous flows: d(Cv) ES ᎏ + (1 – Cv)CvVt = 0 d(y)
(4-34)
where Cv is the volumetric concentration of solids. This equation shows that when coarse and fine particles are pumped together under certain conditions, the flows may exhibit an increase in concentration of fine particles with increasing height. Example 4-10 Using Hunt’s equation, prove that the ratio of concentration at 0.08 DI from the top is the concentration at pipe center expressed by
冤
冥
VR log10 ᎏ = –1.8 Z VRa where VR = Cv/1 – Cv a = the reference plane at 0.08 DI It has already been shown in Equation (4-31) that
冤 冥
C Vt log10 ᎏ = –1.8 ᎏ CA KxUf Let us confirm that Hunt’s approach applies: dCv Es ᎏ + (1 – Cv)CvVt = 0 dy Cv VR = ᎏ 1 – Cv DCv ᎏ = (1 – Cv)2 dVR
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
4.32
9:16 AM
Page 4.32
CHAPTER FOUR
冢
冣
dC dC dVR dVR ᎏ = ᎏ ᎏ (1 – Cv)2 ᎏ dy dVR dy dy But some of Hunt’s equation shows that –Vt(1 – Cv)Cv dC ᎏ = ᎏᎏ Es dy Then dV –Vt dC dVR ᎏ (1 – Cv) Cv = ᎏ · ᎏ = (1 – Cv)2 ᎏ Es dVR dy dy dVR –Vt ᎏ Cv = ᎏ (1 – Cv) Es dy dVR Es ᎏ (1 – Cv) + VtCv = 0 dy Or Cv dVR Es ᎏ + Vt ᎏ = 0 dy (1 – Cv) This is the same as the Equation 4-34. The approach discussed in the previous paragraph is sometimes classified as the distributed concentration approach. The analysis is based on establishing the plane for reference CA, usually at 0.08 diameter. It has been demonstrated that
冤 冥
C Vt log10 ᎏ = – 1.8 ᎏ CA KxUf If  is assumed to be unity and there is no suppression for the Von Karman constant, i.e., Kx = 0.4, then
冤 冥
冤 冥
C Vt log10 ᎏ = –4.5 ᎏ CA Uf
(4-35)
Thomas (1962) commented that the Durand–Condolios approach was limited to sand and similar solids and proposed a more general criterion of evaluating flow of slurries in terms of the ratio Vt/Uf or ratio of free-fall velocity to friction velocity. He indicated that when Vt ᎏ > 0.2 Uf
(4-36)
the solids would be transported as a heterogeneous slurry. Charles and Stevens (1972) suggested that Equation 4.32 should be modified to correspond to C/CA < 0.13, whereas Charles and Stevens’ criterion corresponds to C/CA < 0.27. The Thomas criterion as expressed by Equation 4-31, corresponds to C/CA < 0.13, whereas the Charles and Stevens’ criterion corresponds to C/CA < 0.27.
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.33
HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS OF SETTLING SLURRIES
4.33
Thomas (1962) indicated that the minimum transport condition for particles depends on a number of factors, and derived the following equation for glass beads:
冢
Vt dpUf 0 ᎏ = 4.90 ᎏ Uf
S – L
ᎏ冥 冣冢 ᎏ DU 冣 冤 i
0.60
f0
0.23
(4-37)
L
where = kinematic viscosity of water Uf 0 = friction velocity at deposition for limiting case of infinite dilution Thomas (1962) defined a critical friction velocity at which the slurry starts to deposit for a given concentration as
冦
冤 冥 冧
Vt 苶V苶) ᎏ Uf C = Uf 0 1 + 2.8 (兹C Uf 0
1/3
(4-38)
The approach of Thomas is implicit. It means that to predict Uf, it is important to measure friction loss as a function of velocity. It is then necessary to establish the deposition velocity using Equations 4-34, 4-35, and 4-36.
4-6 FRICTION LOSSES FOR COMPOUND MIXTURES IN HORIZONTAL HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS Many slurries resulting from dredging, cyclone underflow, and tailings disposal are not pumped with single-sized particles. Some authors such as Newitt et al. (1955) proposed the use of a weighted average particle diameter but Hill et al. (1986) proposed that the particles should be divided. The finer particles would move as a heterogeneous flow, while the coarser particles would move as a bed by saltation. The equations of friction loss for each fraction or size of solids should be calculated as in Sections 4-4-1 and 4-4-3. Hill et al. (1986), Wasp et al. (1977), and Gaesler (1967) demonstrated that this approach worked well when applied to pumping water–coal mixtures. The compound or heterogeneous–homogeneous system is the most important and most common in slurry transportation. It involves coarse and fine particles. The fines move as a homogeneous mixture while the remainder move as a heterogeneous mixture. To conduct this analysis, the rheological and physical properties of the solids must be known. This method was pioneered by Wasp et al. (1977) and in some respects was further developed by the “stratification model” described later on. The heterogeneous mixture or bed motion is based on the method of concentration in relation to a reference layer, as described by Equation 4-30. The method proposed by Wasp et al. (1977) can be summarized as follows: 1. Divide the total size fraction into a homogeneous fraction using Durand’s equation. 2. Calculate the friction losses of the homogeneous fraction based on the rheology of the slurry, assuming Newtonian flow. 3. Calculate the friction losses of the heterogeneous fraction using Durand’s equation. 4. Define a ratio C/CA for the size fraction of solids based on friction losses estimated in steps 2 and 3.
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.34
4.34
CHAPTER FOUR
5. Based on the value of C/CA, determine the fraction size of solids in homogeneous and heterogeneous flows. Re-iterate steps 2 to 5 until convergence of the friction loss. Example 4-11 A nickel ore slurry needs to flow by gravity at a weight concentration of 28%. The design flow rate is 1631 m3/hr. The slurry was tested in a 159 mm pipeline with a roughness coefficient of 0.016 mm at a weight concentration of 26.3%. The results of the pressure drop versus speed are presented in Table 4-2. No data was made available on the drag coefficients or terminal velocity of the solids. The particle size distribution of the originally milled ore is presented in Table 4-3. Special screens would be installed to screen away the coarsest particles (larger than 0.850 mm). Conducting a friction loss for a rubber lined steel pipe would be a better option. (See Tables 4-6 and 4-7.) The solids density was measured as 4074 kg/m3. At a weight concentration of 26.3%, this corresponds to a slurry density of 1244 kg/m3. Volumetric concentration is
m CV = CW ᎏ = 0.08% s Using the Thomas–Einstein equation for dynamic viscosity correction:
= L(1 + (2.5 · 0.08) + (10.05 · 0.082) + 0.00273 exp(16.6 · 0.08)] = 1.274 · L Analysis of Test Results Water at a temperature of 20° Celsius has a dynamic viscosity of 1 mPa · s. Slurry viscosity is therefore 1.274 mPa · s, and the Reynolds number is 1244(V)DI Re = ᎏᎏ = 155,256(V) = 294,986 1.274 × 10–3 where V = 1.9 m/s The slurry was tested in a pumping test loop. The lab tests indicated a pressure drop of 270 Pa/m at this velocity. The +0.850 mm solids were screened away prior to pump tests.
TABLE 4-6 Pressure Drop versus Speed in a 159 mm ID Steel Pipe at a Weight Concentration of 26.3% (Example 4-11) Temperature 20°C ______________________________________ Velocity (m/s) Pressure drop (kPa) 1.00 1.5 1.9 2.3 2.7 3.1 3.5 4.0
0.085 0.175 0.270 0.360 0.525 0.688 0.847 1.046
Temperature 35°C ______________________________________ Velocity (m/s) Pressure drop (kPa) 0.61 1.00 1.51 1.91 2.30 2.70 3.11 3.50 4.00
0.063 0.079 0.169 0.259 0.358 0.487 0.628 0.793 0.988
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.35
4.35
HETEROGENEOUS FLOWS OF SETTLING SLURRIES
TABLE 4-7 Particle Size Distribution Prior to Screening the Coarsest Solids (Example 4-11) Size (mm)
Volumetric concentration
+ 0.850 –0.850 to +0.400 –0.400 to +0.200 –0.200 to +0.105 –1.05 to +0.044 –0.044
14.3% 1.61% 1.91% 1.41% 1% 79.8%
Table 4-8 indicates the new volumetric concentration of the solids in the slurry after screening the +0.850 mm solids. The method developed by Wasp et al. (1977) has been used very successfully over the last 25 years for Newtonian slurries and will be used in the present calculations. The roughness of a steel pipe is 0.046 mm. Assuming that the –0.044 mm particles were transported by turbulence above the moving bed of coarser particles, the Swain–Jain equation may be used in the range of 5000 < Re < 100,000,000 to determine the friction coefficient of the homogeneous part of the mixture: 0.25 fD = ᎏᎏᎏᎏ = 0.017 {log10 [(/Di)/3.7 + 5.74/Re0.9]}2 where fD = the Darcy friction factor For the density of 1244 kg/m3, the pressure losses of the carrier fluid (including the –0.044 mm) at a first iteration is therefore 0.017(1.92) 1244 Loss = ᎏᎏ = 240 Pa/m (2) 0.159 The lab test measured 270 Pa/m; the losses due to the moving bed are therefore 31 Pa/m. Using Table 4-8, apply the Wasp method for calculating the pressure losses of the moving bed. It will be assumed initially that the –0.044 mm particles are part of the homogeneous liquid layer above the bed. It is essential first to determine the drag coefficient and the particle Reynolds number.
TABLE 4-8 Particle Size versus Volume Concentration in the Slurry (Example 4-11)
Particle size (mm)
Original volumetric concentration CV in the solids
New volumetric concentration CV in the solids (after screening)
Volumetric concentration in the slurry (at overall solids CV of mixture at 8%)
+0.850 –0.850 to + 0.400 –0.400 to + 0.200 –0.200 to +0.105 –1.05 to +0.044 –0.044
14.3% 1.61% 1.91% 1.41% 1% 79.8%
— 1.88% 2.23% 1.65% 1.17% 93.1%
— 0.15% 0.178% 0.132% 0.093% 7.45%
abul-4.qxd
2/28/02
9:16 AM
Page 4.36
4.36
CHAPTER FOUR
Two cases will be considered: spheres and particles with an Albertson shape factor of 1.0 for the sake of simplicity. To calculate the particle Reynolds number, the density of 1244 kg/m3, viscosity of 1.3 mPas, and the speed of 1.9 m/s of the carrier fluid are used: Rep = 1,818,154 dp where dp = the average particle size. To calculate the drag coefficient of a sphere, the Turton equation (Equation 3.8a) is used. Results are summarized in Table 4-9. Wasp et al. (1977) recommend using Durand’s equation for each fraction of solids to determine the increase in pressure losses due to the moving bed: gDi(s – L)/L ⌬Pbed = 82 ⌬PLCvbed ᎏᎏ V 2兹苶 C苶 D
冤
冥
1.5
After determining the Darcy friction factor at the pipe diameter of 0.159 m and the speed of 1.9 m/s at a liquid loss of 219 Pa/m, the loss due to each fraction becomes
冤
1 ⌬Pbed = 17,490 Cvbed ᎏ 兹苶 苶 CD
冥
1.5
Results of calculations are presented in Table 4-10. The total friction loss is therefore 240 Pa/m + 151.4 = 391.4. By comparison with the measured 270Pa/m, the calculations for the bed are higher and can be refined by the method of concentration using Equation 4-30:
冤 冥
C Vt log10 ᎏ = –1.8 ᎏ CA KxUf At 391.4 Pa/m, the equivalent fanning factor is
391.4 = 2 ff V 2 ᎏ Di 391.4(0.159) fN = ᎏᎏ = 0.0069 2(1.92)1,244 To calculate Uf, use Equation 2-25 from Chapter 2: /苶)苶 = 1.9兹(0 苶.0 苶0苶6苶/2 苶)苶 = 0.1116 m/s U = Um兹(苶fN苶2 Assuming Kx = 0.4 and  = 1, we can iterate the results.
TABLE 4-9 Drag Coefficient for Particles in Example 4-11, Assuming Spherical Shape Particle size distribution (m