SOLAR CELLS AND THEIR APPLICATIONS Second Edition Edited by LEWIS FRAAS LARRY PARTAIN
A JOHN WILEY & SONS, INC., PUBLICATION
SOLAR CELLS AND THEIR APPLICATIONS
WILEY SERIES IN MICROWAVE AND OPTICAL ENGINEERING KAI CHANG, Editor Texas A&M University A complete list of the titles in this series appears at the end of this volume.
SOLAR CELLS AND THEIR APPLICATIONS Second Edition Edited by LEWIS FRAAS LARRY PARTAIN
A JOHN WILEY & SONS, INC., PUBLICATION
Copyright © 2010 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. All rights reserved Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey Published simultaneously in Canada No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning, or otherwise, except as permitted under Section 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or authorization through payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, (978) 750-8400, fax (978) 750-4470, or on the web at www.copyright.com. Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, (201) 748-6011, fax (201) 748-6008, or online at http://www.wiley.com/go/permission. Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty: While the publisher and author have used their best efforts in preparing this book, they make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy or completeness of the contents of this book and specifically disclaim any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. No warranty may be created or extended by sales representatives or written sales materials. The advice and strategies contained herein may not be suitable for your situation. You should consult with a professional where appropriate. Neither the publisher nor author shall be liable for any loss of profit or any other commercial damages, including but not limited to special, incidental, consequential, or other damages. For general information on our other products and services or for technical support, please contact our Customer Care Department within the United States at (800) 762-2974, outside the United States at (317) 572-3993 or fax (317) 572-4002. Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic formats. For more information about Wiley products, visit our web site at www.wiley.com. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data: Solar cells and their applications / [edited by] Lewis Fraas, Larry Partain.—2nd ed. p. cm.—(Wiley series in microwave and optical engineering) ISBN 978-0-470-44633-1 (cloth) 1. Solar cells. I. Partain, L. D. II. Fraas, Lewis M. TK2960.S652 2010 621.31'244—dc22 2010000196 Printed in Singapore 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Contents Preface
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
ix
Contributors .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
xiii
INTRODUCTION TO SOLAR CELLS
.
.
.
.
.
1
.
3
.
17
Solar Cells, Single-Crystal Semiconductors, and High Efficiency . . . . . . . . . . Lewis Fraas
43
PART I
.
Chapter
1
Solar Cells: A Brief History and Introduction . Lewis Fraas and Larry Partain
Chapter
2
Solar Cell Electricity Market History, Public Policy, Projected Future, and Estimated Costs . Larry Partain and Lewis Fraas
Chapter
Chapter
3
.
.
.
67
PART II TERRESTRIAL SOLAR CELL ELECTRICITY
.
.
111
Chapter
5
Crystalline Silicon Solar Cells and Modules Leonid Rubin
.
.
113
Chapter
6
Thin-Film Solar Cells and Modules . Robert Birkmire
Chapter
7
Terrestrial Module Fabrication and Assembly Technologies . . . . Christopher Bunner
Chapter
4
8
Solar Cell Device Physics . Larry Partain
Chinese Solar Cell Status. Wang Sicheng
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
137
.
.
.
.
159
.
.
.
.
171 v
vi
Chapter
CONTENTS
Tracking the Sun for More Kilowatt Hour and Lower-Cost Solar Electricity . . . . . . Ron Corio, Michael Reed, and Lewis Fraas
.
207
Solar Cell Systems: Definition, Performance, and Reliability. . . . . . . . . . Jason Strauch, Larry Moore, and Elmer Collins
.
219
Levelized Cost of Energy for Utility-Scale Photovoltaics . . . . . . . . . Matthew Campbell
.
.
251
.
.
271
Chapter 12
Low-Concentration Crystalline Silicon Systems . Lewis Fraas
.
273
Chapter
High-Concentration, III–V Multijunction Solar Cells . . . . . . . . . . Geoffrey Kinsey
.
.
293
High-Concentration Fresnel Lens Assemblies and Systems . . . . . . . . . . Gerhard Peharz and Andreas Bett
.
313
High-Concentration Cassegrainian Solar Cell Modules and Arrays . . . . . . . . Michael Ludowise and Lewis Fraas
.
337
Concentrator Solar Cell Installations at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas . . . . Suresh Sadineni and Robert Boehm
.
.
361
Concentrator Photovoltaic Field Installations . Francisca Rubio, María Martínez, and Pedro Banda
.
377
Chapter
Chapter
9
10
11
PART III TERRESTRIAL CONCENTRATOR SOLAR CELL SYSTEMS . . . . . . . . .
Chapter
Chapter
Chapter
Chapter
PART IV Chapter
13
14
15
16
17
SOLAR CELLS IN SPACE . 18
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
395
Space Solar Cells and Applications . Sheila Bailey and Ryne Raffaelle
.
.
.
.
397
CONTENTS
vii
PART V
OTHER ASPECTS AND CONSIDERATIONS .
Chapter
19
Solar Resource for Space and Terrestrial Applications . . . . Christian A. Gueymard and Daryl Myers
.
.
.
.
425
.
.
427
.
463
Chapter
20
Solar Energy Costs: The Solar Advisor Model . Paul Gilman, Nathan Blair, and Christopher Cameron
Chapter
21
Challenges of Large-Scale Solar Cell Electricity Production . . . . David Faiman
.
.
.
.
483
.
.
.
.
497
Market Overview of Flat Panel Detectors for X-Ray Imaging . . . . . . . . . Carl LaCasce, Larry Partain, and Chuck Blouir
.
499
Amorphous Silicon Transistors and Photodiodes . . . . . Robert Street
PART VI THIN FILMS AND X-RAY IMAGER TECHNOLOGIES . . . . . . Chapter
22
Chapter
23
.
.
.
.
.
.
511
Chapter
24
Amorphous Silicon Digital X-Ray Imaging . Richard Colbeth
.
.
533
Chapter
25
Photoconductor Digital X-Ray Imaging. George Zentai
.
.
.
559
PART VII Chapter
Index .
SUMMARY 26
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
581
Summary, Conclusions, and Recommendations. . . . Lewis Fraas and Larry Partain
.
.
.
.
.
.
583
.
.
.
.
.
.
613
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Preface This Second Edition is intended to be a comprehensive survey, review, and analysis of all the major factors related to the continuing technical development of solar cell electricity and its market development into a major worldwide source of electric power in response to powerful political and economic influences. It is divided into six major sections plus a Summary section including conclusions and recommendations. In contrast to the First Edition, Part I contains three initial chapters written so that nonspecialists and the more general readers and investors and policy makers can follow their contents without the need for specialized training or understanding. The goal is to allow a broad spectrum of readers to at least comprehend the market history, the influence of public policy, the likely costs of solar cell-generated electricity, and the special role that near-perfect, single-crystal semiconductor fabrication materials can have on overall performance. Chapter 4 in this part, on Solar Cell Device Physics (like the First Edition), is again aimed at advanced undergraduate and graduate college courses and other technical professionals involved in teaching, research, and commercial development. It not only covers the traditional abrupt p/n junction configuration of the First Edition but also expands into the very non-abrupt p-i-n geometries that characterize a whole new class of high-performance solar cells including interdigitated back-contact cells, point-contact cells, and heterojunction-with-intrisinsic-thin-layer (HIT) cells. It further addresses the special resistive restrictions that can limit p-i-n-type device performance as well as proposed paths to performance levels well beyond 50% efficiency levels. However, to maintain a reasonable length, this physics chapter does use the First Edition as a reference. Part II addresses the current state of terrestrial solar cell electricity technology and development programs. This includes the dominant crystalline silicon abrupt p/n junction devices and their large-scale fabrication and the emerging thin-film amorphous and polycrystalline semiconductor cells and modules. The amazing recent growth of the Chinese terrestrial solar cell program is presented in some detail. The potential advantages of tracking the sun are explored along with a detailed description of 3 years of field experience with fixed-axis crystalline silicon modules of 12% efficiency (under standard test conditions) in the Arizona desert. The emerging utility-scale installations are summarized along with their important cost-determining characteristics. Part III attempts to present a comprehensive overview of the terrestrial concentrator approach to solar cell electricity production and its special advantages ix
x
PREFACE
and challenges. This includes both low and high sunlight concentration levels with various system approaches as well as early results of small field tests at the University of Nevada and of substantial utility-scale field tests of multiple and varied concentrator systems in Spain. Part IV takes a broad look at space systems and all of the unique approaches, needs, accomplishments, plans, and future needs for space. Part V contains a chapter giving precise descriptions of the solar resource both terrestrially and in space. It also contains a chapter describing a sophisticated and detailed cost and performance model from the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL). This Solar Advisor Model is reviewed and summarized. Finally, the special challenges of large-scale solar electricity production are explored. Part VI is a special four-chapter addition of the Second Edition that discusses how thin-film solar cells can be transformed into X-ray imaging devices when devices are reduced to submillimeter sizes and are aligned in columns and rows that are covered by a scintillator film that converts X-ray photons into visible light photons. If these are then attached to an array of the thin-film transistor switches, a flat-plate X-ray imager is produced. The market analysis of this whole X-ray imager field shows that its current market size of $2 billion per year should continuously evolve into a $15 billion per year wholesale market over the next 10 years or so as these devices continually improve in performance and drop in price. The final chapter summarizes the amazing growth of this solar cell electricity technology and market over the 15 years since the publication of the First Edition. It provides recommendations for how major countries and unions can play major roles from both technology and public policy perspectives and how continuing cost reduction and improved performance demands should be met under both near- and medium-term time frames. In summary, this book describes today’s baseline planar solar cell power systems as well as innovations in high-efficiency solar cells and concentrated sunlight systems that have occurred in the last 15 years, which now promise lower cost electricity competitive with other mainstream electric power sources. In addition to describing these technical breakthroughs in clear and simple terms, this book also describes the path from research breakthrough to high-volume production, emphasizing the cooperation required between government and private enterprise. Given this cooperation, solar cells can be a major contributor to the electric power production mix within the next 10 years. This book has been written for a large audience, not just a technical audience. It is hoped that any educated reader will find this book interesting, especially any reader who seeks to understand how the world’s energy supply problems can be increasingly addressed by exploiting direct solar energy resources available within a country’s borders. It further describes how most countries can start moving away from increasingly intense competition for decreasing depletable energy supplies and how they can continue moving toward a long-term, sustainable solution with inherently positive attributes.
PREFACE
xi
The thesis of this book is that solar energy can be cost competitive with other forms of electric power production and that the technical innovations required for this have already been made. Incentives for investment are needed to bring these innovations into high-volume production. It is hoped that this book will help educate the public, possible investors, as well as policy makers worldwide about the potential for a bright sunny energy future. Lewis Fraas Issaquah, WA Larry Partain Mountain View, CA
Contributors Sheila Bailey, NASA Glenn Research Center at Lewis Field, Space Environments and Experiments Branch, Cleveland, OH; email:
[email protected] Pedro Banda, Instituto de Sistemas Fotovoltaicos de Concentración (ISFOC) S.A., Puertollano (Ciudad Real), Spain; email:
[email protected] Andreas Bett, Fraunhofer Institut für Solare Energiesysteme (ISE), Freiburg, Germany; email:
[email protected] Robert Birkmire, Institute of Energy Conversion, University of Delaware, Newark, DE; email:
[email protected] Nathan Blair, National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Golden, CO; email: Nate_
[email protected] Chuck Blouir, Varian Medical Systems, Cleveland, OH; email: chuck.blouir@ varian.com Robert Boehm, Center for Energy Research, Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, NV; email: rboehm@unlv. nevada.edu Christopher Bunner, Spire Corporation, Bedford, MA; email: cbunner@spirecorp. com Christopher Cameron, Sandia National Laboratories, Albuquerque, NM; email:
[email protected] Matthew Campbell, Utility Power Plant Products, SunPower Corporation, Richmond, CA; email:
[email protected] Richard Colbeth, Varian Medical Systems, Mountain View, CA; email: richard.
[email protected] Elmer Collins, Sandia National Laboratories, Microsystems Science & Technology, Albuquerque, NM; email:
[email protected] Ron Corio, Array Technologies, Inc., Albuquerque, NM; email: rcorio@wattsun. com David Faiman, Department of Solar Energy and Environmental Physics, Jacob Blaustein Institutes for Desert Research, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Israel; email:
[email protected] Lewis Fraas, President, JX Crystals Inc., Issaquah, WA; email: lfraas@jxcrystals. com Paul Gilman, Consultant, Chicago, IL; email:
[email protected] Christian A. Gueymard, Solar Consulting Services, Colebrook, NH; email:
[email protected] xiii
xiv
CONTRIBUTORS
Geoffrey Kinsey, Amonix, Inc., Seal Beach, CA; email:
[email protected] Carl LaCasce, Varian Medical Systems, Salt Lake City, UT; email: carl.lacasce@ varian.com Michael Ludowise, SolFocus, Inc., Mountain View, CA; email: mike_ludowise@ solfocus.com María Martínez, Instituto de Sistemas Fotovoltaicos de Concentración (ISFOC) S.A., Puertollano (Ciudad Real), Spain; email:
[email protected] Larry Moore, Sandia National Laboratories, Microsystems Science & Technology, Albuquerque, NM Daryl Myers, National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Golden, CO; email: Daryl.
[email protected] Larry Partain, Varian Medical Systems, Mountain View, CA; email: larry.
[email protected] Gerhard Peharz, Fraunhofer Institut für Solare Energiesysteme (ISE), Freiburg, Germany; email:
[email protected] Ryne Raffaelle, U.S. Department of Energy, National Center for Photovoltaics, National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Golden, CO; email: Ryne.Raffaelle@ nrel.gov Michael Reed, Array Technologies, Inc., Albuquerque, NM; email: mreed@ arraytechinc.com Leonid Rubin, Day4 Energy Inc., Burnaby, BC, Canada; email: lrubin@day4 energy.com Francisca Rubio, Instituto de Sistemas Fotovoltaicos de Concentración (ISFOC) S.A., Puertollano (Ciudad Real), Spain; email:
[email protected] Suresh Sadineni, Center for Energy Research, Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Nevada, Las Vegas, Las Vegas, NV; email:
[email protected] Wang Sicheng, Energy Research Institute, National Development and Reform Commision, Beijing, China; email:
[email protected] Jason Strauch, Sandia National Laboratories, Integrated Microdevice Systems, Microsystems Science & Technology, Albuquerque, NM; email: jestrau@ sandia.gov Robert Street, Palo Alto Research Center, Palo Alto, CA; email:
[email protected] George Zentai, Ginzton Technology Center, Varian Medical Systems, Mountain View, CA; email:
[email protected]
PART I INTRODUCTION TO SOLAR CELLS
1 SOLAR CELLS: A BRIEF HISTORY AND INTRODUCTION LEWIS FRAAS1 AND LARRY PARTAIN2 1 JX Crystals Inc., 2Varian Medical Systems
1.1
BRIEF HISTORY
The history of the solar cell is really quite interesting [1]. In 1839, Edmond Becquerel found that two different brass plates immersed in a liquid produced a continuous current when illuminated with sunlight. We now believe that he had made a coppercuprous oxide thin-film solar cell. Later in the 1870s, Willoughby Smith, W. G. Adams, and R. E. Day discovered a PV effect in selenium. A few years later, an American named C. E. Fritts placed a sheet of amorphous selenium on a metal backing and covered the selenium with a transparent gold leaf film. He reported that this selenium array produced a current “that is continuous, constant, and of considerable force—with exposure to sunlight.” At the time, there was no quantum theory and there was considerable skepticism about his claim of converting sunlight into electricity. So he sent a sample to Werner Siemens in Germany, who was one of the most respected experts in electricity at the time. Siemens’s observation verified Fritts’s claims. However, the conversion efficiencies of both the thin-film cuprous oxide and the amorphous selenium solar cells were less than 1%. Around 75 years passed while quantum mechanics was discovered, the importance of single-crystal semiconductors was recognized, and p/n junction behavior was explained (see Chapter 3). By 1954, Chapin et al. [2] at Bell Labs had discovered, invented, and demonstrated the silicon single-crystal solar cell with 6% efficiency. Over the few following years, researchers brought the silicon solar cell efficiency up to 15%. The timing was fortunate because Sputnik was launched in 1957 and solar cells were the perfect lightweight low-maintenance remote electric power source. Today, silicon solar cells are being used to power the space station. Solar Cells and Their Applications, Second Edition, Edited by Lewis Fraas and Larry Partain Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
3
4
A BRIEF HISTORY AND INTRODUCTION
The solar cell industry remained small until the first Arab oil embargo in 1973. Up until that time, the solar cell industry established a firm foothold with low-level but consistent cell and array production and performance. During those first 20 years, reliability was the driver and cost was not as important. After 1973, the flat-plate silicon module was brought down to earth and modified for weather resistance. This transition also included major improvements in cell and module fabrication that brought down costs dramatically (Fig. 2.3, chapter 2). Flat-plate “champion” silicon cell efficiencies (defined in Section 2.1, Chapter 2) have improved to values as high as 25%. Production module efficiencies have improved from around 10% for early modules to as high as 19% today (SunPower Corporation). Most important, annual production quantities have grown dramatically. Worldwide production exceeded 1 GW/year in 2002 and rose to over 3.8 GW/ year by 2006 (Fig. 2.1, Chapter 2). In the late 1970s, it was discovered that good cells could be made with multicrystalline wafers as long as the crystal size is at least 20 times larger than the optical absorption length [3]. Only those carriers within an optical absorption length from the crystal boundaries are lost. This is less than 5% of the carriers. Typical production quantity multicrystalline cell efficiencies are around 14%, whereas comparable single-crystal cells have efficiencies around 15%. By 2007, modules with multicrystalline cells accounted for about 45% of sales and modules with single-crystal cells accounted for about 40% of sales. Planar silicon cell modules dominated the market in 2007 because of their early well-funded foundation years for space satellites and their huge learning curve support (Fig. 2.3, Chapter 2) from single-crystal silicon and integrated circuit technology development. While silicon-based cells still dominate the solar cell electricity market today, several other cell types have now entered the market. (Solar cells are also known as PV cells.) These newer cell types have added diversity in potential applications as well as offered alternate paths to lower-cost solar electric power. These alternate cell types include hydrogenated amorphous silicon, cadmium teluride and CIGS thin-film cells (Chapter 6), as well as concentrator cells with efficiencies as high as 41% (Chapters 13–17).
1.2
APPLICATIONS AND MARKETS
In the late 1970s and early 1980s, the traditional solar cell electricity applications [4] were at remote locations where utility power was unavailable, for example, campers and boats, temporary power needs for disaster situations, and power for remote communication station repeaters. In the late 1980s and early 1990s, solar cells began to be routinely used to provide site-specific energy for urban and suburban homes, office buildings, and a multitude of other mainstream grid-connected applications. Also, solar cell electricity systems have become very important sources of energy in the developing world. Today, for an increasing number of power needs, solar cell electricity is the cheapest and best way to generate electricity.
APPLICATIONS AND MARKETS
5
In addition to the solar power arrays on space satellites, there are now many different types of PV systems used here on Earth including 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
remote stand-alone without battery storage, remote stand-alone with battery storage, small modules for calculators and toys, residential grid connected with DC to AC inverter, commercial grid connected with inverters, and PV fields for utility power generation.
Remote solar water pumping is a nice example of stand-alone solar cell electricity where batteries are not needed. Solar water pumping is very desirable for crop irrigation, livestock watering, and clean water for remote villages. Solar water pumping systems are now installed around the world. The nice thing about this application is that underground water is pumped when the sun is shining. It can be immediately used for crop irrigation. In other areas, it can be pumped into tanks for livestock to drink. In third world countries, pumping underground water for people to drink provides cleaner water than surface water thereby limiting disease. This application is quite economical because the system is simple. Battery storage or DC to AC conversion is not necessary. Simple solar trackers are used to maximize pumping time. The electric motors driving the pumps have a threshold current that must be provided before they will operate. By tracking the sun, this power is provided from dawn to dusk, not just at around noon as would be the case without tracking. Another application where there is a good match with demand is for air conditioning in developed countries like the United States. For many remote applications, storage is needed to store electric energy for when it is needed. Examples of these applications include off-grid cabins and remote communication repeater stations. For most solar cell applications where storage is needed, secondary or storage batteries are the best alternative. Generally, batteries should be deep discharge batteries such as marine batteries or motive power batteries. Forklift trucks and golf carts use large-capacity deep discharge batteries that are designed for long life and many discharge cycles. In addition to batteries, combination systems can be used to compensate for the fact that the sun does not always shine. A solar/wind combination is particularly good since quite often, either one or the other is available. Another combination system can be a solar–thermal cell electricity system. In this case, solar cells are located on your roof for generating electricity in the summer and infrared-sensitive PV cells (also known as TPV cells) are integrated into your heating furnace to generate electricity when it is cold and dark outside and you need heat to keep warm. In a TPV cell electricity system, a ceramic element is heated in the furnace flame and its glow in the infrared is converted to electricity by infraredsensitive TPV cells [5]. Solar-powered calculators are another familiar application for solar cells. While the efficiencies of amorphous silicon solar cells are much lower than either single or multicrystalline cells, an advantage for thin-film cells is that they can be made with cell interconnections built into the process. This means that for applica-
6
A BRIEF HISTORY AND INTRODUCTION
tions like powering calculators where voltage but little current is required to run the calculator, amorphous silicon circuits are preferred to save on the cost of interconnecting multiple cells to provide voltage. Credit is due to the Japanese for recognizing this advantage and to the inventors of the amorphous silicon solar cell for making solar cells a common household item [6]. Today, more and more homes on the grid are using solar cell arrays to generate electricity to save on costs of peak electric power. The passage of the PURPA by the U.S. Congress made it possible for a small producer to install generating systems and to sell the power to the utility at a favorable price without the enormous amount of red tape usually required of a new electric power producer. Most states have now also passed net metering laws that allow the electric meter at a home to run both directions. However, at least in California, the utility charge can at most be reduced to zero and they never pay any net money to their customers who produce more electricity than they consume. This allows homeowners generating solar cell electricity to send energy to the grid if they are producing excess electricity with a credit from the utility so that they can use electric power from the grid on days without sufficient sunlight. An example of real cost savings with a solar cell electricity installation for a homeowner in San Jose, California, is shown in Figure 1.1 [7]. Current Monthly KWH 2,500 2,000
Over 300% $0.26 300% Baseline $0.24
1,500
200% Baseline $0.19
1,000
130% Baseline $0.14
500
100% Baseline $0.13
e
Ju ly Au g Se u pt st em be r O ct ob N ov er em b D ec er em be r
ay
ril
Ju n
M
Ap
Ja nu a Fe ry br ua ry M ar ch
–
Monthly KWH With PV System 2,500 2,000
Over 300% $0.26 300% Baseline $0.24
1,500
200% Baseline $0.19
1,000
130% Baseline $0.14
500
100% Baseline $0.13
e
Ju ly Au g Se u pt st em be r O ct ob N ov er em be D r ec em be r
ay
Ju n
M
Ap ril
Ja nu a Fe ry br ua ry M ar ch
–
Figure 1.1. When electric utility rates are staged, a homeowner with solar can displace electricity at the peak power rate as illustrated here. This example was originally presented by Akeena Solar on their web site in 2003 and then published in reference [7].
APPLICATIONS AND MARKETS
7
Figure 1.1 is for an actual case in 2003. Note in this figure that the utility electric rates are staged. While the homeowner pays a base rate of 13¢ per kilowatt hour that in itself is well above the national average. More importantly, the homeowner is paying twice that or 26¢ per kilowatt hour for his peak power. So his solar electric system is saving him money at the 26¢ per kilowatt hour rate. While the grid-connected solar cell electricity market started with residential customers, commercial customers are now starting to use solar arrays on their flat building rooftops. Figure 1.2 shows a photograph of two 1-kW solar cell arrays on a flat rooftop in Spokane, Washington. These arrays are mounted on carousel solar trackers (Chapter 9). People have been dreaming of the potential of solar cell electricity systems as a major electric power source for over 100 years. Now with the existence of solar power fields such as the one in China shown in Figure 1.3, this dream is becoming reality.
Figure 1.2. Two-kilowatt PV array from JX Crystals Inc on a commercial building flat rooftop.
Figure 1.3. Solar cell electricity generating field in Shanghai, China. System designed by JX Crystals Inc.
8
1.3
A BRIEF HISTORY AND INTRODUCTION
TYPES OF SOLAR CELLS AND MODULES
Unfortunately, solar cell electricity is still too expensive for widespread economical use (Section 2.4, Chapter 2). While it is hoped that traditional crystalline silicon module prices will continue to fall, there are other alternatives under development as shown in Figure 1.4. Figure 1.4 shows the three types of solar modules in use today [8]. The upper section (Figure 1.4a) of this figure shows the planar single-crystal silicon modules and fabrication procedure. This approach dominates the solar market today with over 85% of solar modules sold. As shown in Figure 1.5, retail module prices have
(a) Standard Silicon Single Crystal Module Fabrication Crystal to Ingot to Wafer to Module
(b) Concentrator Module Fabrication Smaller Single Crystal Cells With Mirrors (shown) or Lens Array
(c) Thin Film Module - Spray-on Successive Non-Crystalline Films
Figure 1.4. Alternate PV module types: (a) standard silicon single-crystal module fabrication, crystal to ingot to wafer to module; (b) concentrator module fabrication, smaller single-crystal cells with mirrors (shown) or lens array; and (c) thin-film module, spray-on successive noncrystalline films.
TYPES OF SOLAR CELLS AND MODULES
9
8
Module cost (US$/W)
7 6 5 4 3
Small Medium Large
2 1 0 1980
1985
1990
1995
2000
2005
2010
2015
2020
Year
Figure 1.5. Solar module prices for small, medium, and large volumes from 1985 through 2009. All values in then current dollars without inflation adjustments (from Photovoltaics World, September 2009).
been falling dramatically recently. Wholesale module prices are substantially lower than retail prices. The silicon cell cost accounts for about 75% of the module cost with the cost of the glass, frame, junction box, and labor accounting for the remaining approximately 25%. The lower section of Figure 1.4c shows a thin-film module. This concept is attractive because thin films require up to 100× less semiconductor material and offer a promise of lower costs per watt. Since single-crystal material is expensive, why not replace it with inexpensive thin films? The challenge is accommodating their lack of crystallinity. The latter degrades conversion efficiency, which, if too severe, limits their abilities to compete economically in the marketplace (Figs. 2.8 and 2.9 and accompanying text, Chapter 2). An appeal of multicrystalline silicon solar cells is that they offer lower manufacturing costs while still maintaining a conversion efficiency at least two-thirds that of the single-crystal ones [9] of similar Jet Propulsion Laboratory-like configurations (see Chapter 2). However, there are other useful thin-film applications, particularly for amorphous silicon, where its unique properties offer particular advantages and where high quantum efficiency but not high light conversion efficiency is a dominant factor. An example of this is use of amorphous silicon cells in medical imaging (Chapters 22–25) as shown in Figure 1.6. Here, the complete absence of crystallinity in amorphous silicon provides strong radiation damage resistance, and its higher bandgap (than crystalline silicon) gives lower dark currents. These are two strong advantages in the field of flat-plate, digital X-ray imagers that have almost totally replaced analog X-ray film. Recently, amorphous silicon imagers have also begun to displace many of the vacuum tube-based image intensifiers traditionally used in X-ray fluoroscopy. Both X-ray film and intensifier fluoroscopy replacements typically use a thin scin-
10
A BRIEF HISTORY AND INTRODUCTION Kilovoltage X-Ray Source Megavoltage X-ray Source
a-Si Kilovoltage Flat Plate X-ray Imager a-Si Megavoltage Flat Plate X-ray Imager (retracted)
Figure 1.6. Medical imaging system using amorphous silicon solar cell modules.
tillator film to convert the incident X-ray photons into visible light that the underlying amorphous silicon cells efficiently convert into electronic signals that are readily digitized. Frequently, the amorphous silicon solar cells (or pixels) measure a few hundred microns on a side, and millions of them form the rows and columns of a single X-ray imager plate. Such plates provide the digitized X-ray images at up to 30 frames/s and higher. The difficulty with module approaches (a) and (c) in Figure 1.4 is that one tries to obtain both low cost and high efficiency with the same element. In the approach shown in Figure 1.4b, one separates the two requirements of low cost and high performance into two separate elements. The single-crystal cells are the high-efficiency converters used sparingly, while mirrors or lenses are used to concentrate the sunlight onto the cells. The aluminum mirrors (or alternately glass or plastic lenses) are relativley inexpensive. For the case shown in Figure 1.4b, the cell cost is halved. The aluminum mirrors cost at least 10 times less than the singlecrystal cells. In this approach, the sunlight is concentrated onto the expensive high-efficiency single-crystal cells diluting their cost. This approach is now termed CPV. In Figure 1.4b, the sunlight intensity on the cell is doubled; that is, the concentration ratio is 2. Chapter 12 describes a configuation similar to the mirror configuration in Figure 1.4b with a concentration ratio of 3. Various concentration ratios are possible up to as high as 1000. A negative for this approach is that the modules must be aimed at the sun using solar trackers. Trackers by themselves are not a negative as the additional kilowatt per hour per installed kilowatt pays for the trackers. However, when high-concentration optical elements are used, only the direct sunlight is collected. This limits CPV to very sunny locations. However, in any case, solar cell electricity in general will be most economical first in very sunny locations such as the Southwestern United States.
ARGUMENTS FOR SOLAR CELL ELECTRIC POWER
1.4
11
ARGUMENTS FOR SOLAR CELL ELECTRIC POWER
While solar cell electricity is still expensive today, there are three strong arguments for national programs to accelerate its transition into a mainstream power source. The first argument is that there is a logical path for future lower costs for solar electricity. There are three simple steps that will lead to lower cost given development and manufacturing scale-up. These steps are based on technical breakthroughs that have now been made. In step 1, given that the cost of solar electricity today (August 2009) is about 20¢ per kilowatt hour (Solarbuzz) for commercial-sized systems for fixed flat-plate systems in the sunny Southwestern United States, by implementing solar trackers where the modules continuously point at the sun, one can gain 1.3 times more kilowatt hour per installed kilowatt, reducing the cost of solar electricity to about 16¢ per kilowatt hour. This is already being done as evidenced in Figures 1.2 and 1.3 [10]. Step 2 is then to decrease the module cost while maintaining its performance by using lower-cost optical elements as shown in Figure 1.4b. This CPV approach by itself can potentially reduce the system cost for solar electricity to under 10¢ per kilowatt hour (see Chapter 12) [10]. In step 3, one then increases the module efficiency in the CPV approach to well over 20%. As described in Chapter 3, this should reduce the cost of solar electricity still further. “Champion” CPV module efficiencies as high as 31% [11] have now been demonstrated including the one shown in Figure 1.7. While logic suggests these lower costs, this will depend on funding for manufacturing scale-up and government top-down commitment. Actually, there are multiple approaches for CPV ranging from LCPV systems using linear mirrors with silicon cells as shown in Figure 1.4b to HCPV systems
Table III: Performance Summary Packaged Projected Measure Measure Cells at STC with at Module STC 90% Operate at STC Optical Temp (April 28) Effic (April 28) DJ Cell 17.4 W 15.7 W 14.4 W 15.1 W Power DJ Cell 31.5% 28.4% 26.1% 27.3% Effic. IR Cell 3.64 W 3.28 W 2.6 W 3.1 W Power IR Cell 6.6% 5.9% 4.7% 5.6% Effic. Sum 21 W 19 W 17 W 18.7 W Power Sum 38.1% 34.3% 30.8% 32.9% Effic. NIP DNI = 0.92; Area = 600 cm2; Input Power = 55.2 W
Figure 1.7. Prototype CPV module with demonstrated outdoor module efficiency of 31%.
12
A BRIEF HISTORY AND INTRODUCTION
with newer semiconductor materials [12] such as the one shown in Figure 1.7. These LCPV and HCPV systems will be described in more detail in Chapters 12–17. Of course, while the above three steps can be implemented, this still requires investment and political commitment. This leads us to our next two arguments in favor of national programs to accelerate the penetration of solar cell electricity into the mainstream energy mix. The second reason relates to the fact that oil and natural gas resources are being depleted. Quoting from Kenneth Deffeyes’s [13] book titled Hubbert’s Peak: The Impending World Oil Shortage, “In 1956, the geologist M. King Hubbert predicted that U. S. oil production would peak in the early 1970s. Almost everyone inside and outside the oil industry rejected Hubbert’s analysis. The controversy raged until 1970 when the U.S. production of crude oil started to fall. Around 1995, several analysts began applying Hubbert’s method to world oil production, and most of them estimated that the peak year for world oil will be between 2004 and 2008. These analyses were reported in some of the most widely circulated sources: Nature, Science, and Scientific American” [14]. The 2008 peaking of world oil prices to record levels above $140 per barrel seems to support these predictions. The war in Iraq that began in 2003 was likely influenced, at least in part by the shortage of proven U.S. oil and natural gas reserves that could only last 3.0 and 7.5 years, respectively, should the United States have to depend only on its own reserves [15]. The consequence of this “impending world oil shortage” is that electricity prices are going to be rising probably abruptly within the next 5–10 years. This affects the economics of solar cell electricity as solar modules based on semiconductor devices will last for 25 years or longer. Today’s cost competition calculations for solar cell electricity usually assume a short-term payback and nonescalating energy prices. The third argument in favor of bringing solar cell electricity into the mainstream is the environmental and moral argument. It is desirable to avoid global warming as well as oil related war. When one thinks about conventional electric power production, one thinks about oil, natural gas, nuclear, and coal as fuel sources. Solar cell electricity is not on this list because it is currently too expensive. However, these conventional fuel sources have hidden unintentional costs. For example, nuclear fuels are coupled with nuclear waste management and nuclear weapons. Then nuclear waste and nuclear weapons are coupled with the cost of homeland security and our fear of weapons of mass destruction. There are hidden costs involved in attempting to guarantee that nuclear materials do not find their way into the hands of terrorists. Another example of hidden costs is the world’s dependence on oil from the Middle East that is linked unavoidably, particularly in the United States and in other developed countries, with terrorists from the Middle East. It can arguably be claimed that wars have now been fought in the Middle East to secure oil supplies.
ABOUT THIS BOOK
13
In contrast to the unintended costs just enumerated, consider solar energy. Solar energy is inevitable on the larger scale of time. Solar energy is really already a primary energy source through wind and hydroelectricity. Solar energy generated our coal, oil, and natural gas via photosynthesis a hundred million years ago. Solar cells are very much more efficient than plants at converting sunlight to useful energy. Finally, solar energy is benign and will benefit the whole world.
1.5
ABOUT THIS BOOK
The first edition of this book [16] was published in 1995 and can serve as a reference for this second edition. This second edition is divided into four main parts. Part I is an introduction to the current markets, cell and module types, and the physics of solar cell operation. The solar cell electricity market has grown appreciably over the last 14 years as described in Chapter 2. The basics of solar cell operation are presented for single-crystal cells and for thin-film cells in Chapters 3 and 4. Part II of this book focuses on the status of solar cell systems today. Single and multicrystalline silicon and thin-film cells and modules are described in Chapters 5 and 6. Over the last 3 years, silicon module automated manufacturing is coming online with the promising major cost reductions. The traditional and currently dominant silicon module manufacturing, now with automation, is described in Chapter 7. Also, over the last 3 years, China has made a major commitment to solar module manufacturing, and the status of solar electricity in China is described in Chapter 8. A major cost reduction for solar cell electricity comes through the use of solar trackers as described in Chapter 9. Large multi-MW solar cell field installations are then described in Chapters 10 and 11. Part III of this book then describes newer concentrated solar cell and system developments. Chapters 12–17 describe various concentrator solar cell electricity (also known as CPV) modules and system types and installations. Major developments have been taking place here over the last 3 years and that potentially could lead to major cost reductions over the next 5 years. While it remains to be seen if thin-film solar modules can produce electricity at rates competitive with other mainstream electricity generating technologies, nevertheless, amorphous silicon thin-film panels have found a place in other applications and in major markets like flat panel displays and medical imagers. The fourth part of this book describes successful applications of thin film technology as a spin-off from solar cell electricity. Chapters 22–25 then discuss the newest and rapidly growing applications of amorphous silicon thin films in X-ray imaging. The issue of the cost of solar cell electricity, solar modules, and solar systems is a very important subject addressed from various points of view in Chapters 2, 3, 10, 11, 20, and 26. Many believe that solar electricity prices will drop as a result of the recent investments in thin-film module manufacturing, and it is true that thin-film module prices have fallen. However, conversion efficiencies for these commercially available thin-film modules are still under 10%, and this means that
14
A BRIEF HISTORY AND INTRODUCTION
2.5–3.0 times more module area needs to be deployed relative to modules with over 19% conversion efficiencies. So, costs need to be compared at the system level, not just at the module level. Furthermore, the focus needs to be on the cost of the electricity produced in cents per kilowatt hour, not just the hardware cost. A summary and conclusions are presented in Chapter 26. Features that distinguish this second edition from the first edition are the much larger number of solar field installations and the major advances in the concentrator arena using very high-efficiency cells as well as the advances in other novel uses of thin-film modules. The current magnitude and momentum of the solar cell electricity market development (as summarized in Chapter 2) makes its eventual success both inevitable and unstoppable. This is due to the certainty of its future development path with its inherent, major advantages along with the worldwide spread of the scientific knowledge and the manufacturing and engineering know-how (covered in Chapters 3–18), plus the national commitments (alluded to in the Public Policy section of Chapter 2) that will turn promise into reality. World fossil fuel energy production rates will decline in the near to medium time frames, and the current lifestyles of the developed world cannot continue without appropriate replacements. Thus, it is no longer a question of whether this solar cell electricity power transition will occur but one of who will lead this process, who will reap the most benefits, and on what time scale it will occur. ABBREVIATIONS AC—alternating current CIGS—copper indium gallium deselenide CPV—concentrating photovoltaic DC—direct current HCPV—high-concentration photovoltaic LCPV—low-concentration photovoltaic MW—megawatt PURPA—Public Utilities Regulatory Power Act PV—photovoltaic TPV—thermophotovoltaic
REFERENCES [1] [2] [3] [4]
J. Perlin. From Space to Earth, the Story of Solar Electricity. Ann Arbor, MI, AATEC Publications (1999). D. M. Chapin, C. S. Fuller, and G. L. Pearson. A new silicon p-n junction photocell for converting solar radiation into electrical power. J. Appl. Phys. 25, 676 (1954). H. C. Card, and E. S. Yang. IEEE-TED 24, 397 (1977). R. J. Komp. Practical Photovoltaics, 3rd edition, revised. Ann Arbor, MI, AATEC Publications (2001).
REFERENCES [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12]
[13] [14] [15] [16]
15
L. M. Fraas, J. E. Avery, and H. X. Huang. Thermophotovoltaic furnace-generator for the home using low bandgap GaSb cells. Semicond. Sci. Technol. 18, S247 (2003). D. E. Carlson and C. R. Wronski. Appl. Phys. Lett. 28, 671 (1976). L. M. Fraas. Akeena Solar example cited in Chapter 2, p. 15, in Path to Affordable Solar Electric Power and the 35% Efficient Solar Cell, Issaquah, WA, JX Crystals Inc. (2004). L. M. Fraas. Path to Affordable Solar Electric Power & The 35% Efficient Solar Cell. Available at http://www.jxcrystals.com/ (2004). M. A. Green. Solar cell efficiency tables (version 29), Prog. Photovolt. Res. Appl. 15, 15–40 (2007). L. M. Fraas, J. Avery, L. Minkin, H. X. Huang, A. Gehl, and C. Maxey. Carousel trackers with 1-Sun or 3-Sun modules for commercial building rooftops. Presented at the Solar 2008 Conference, May 6, 2008, San Diego, CA (2008). L. M. Fraas, J. Avery, H. Huang, L. Minkin, and E. Shifman. Demonstration of a 33% efficient Cassegrainian solar module. Presented at 4th World Conference on PV, May 7–12, Hawaii (2006). L. M. Fraas and R. C. Knechtli. Design of high efficiency monolithic stacked multijunction solar cells. In IEEE Photovoltaic Specialists Conference, 13th, Washington, D.C., June 5–8, 1978, Conference Record (A79-40881 17-44). New York, Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc., pp. 886–891 (1978). K. S. Deffeyes. Hubbert’s Peak: The Impending World Oil Shortage. Princeton, NJ, Princeton University Press (2001). C. A. Campbell and J. H. Laherrere. The end of cheap oil. Sci. Am. March, 78 (1998). www.BP.com web site has a section entitled “BP Statistical Review of World Energy 2003.” This site has country and regional proven reserves and consumption data for both oil and natural gas. L. D. Partain, ed. Solar Cells and Their Applications, 1st edition. New York, John Wiley & Sons (1995).
2 SOLAR CELL ELECTRICITY MARKET HISTORY, PUBLIC POLICY, PROJECTED FUTURE, AND ESTIMATED COSTS LARRY PARTAIN1 AND LEWIS FRAAS2 1 Varian Medical Systems, 2JX Crystals Inc.
2.1
MARKET HISTORY
The worldwide solar cell (or photovoltaic) electricity generation market has grown dramatically over the past 30 years, both in terms of gigawatts per year (Fig. 2.1) (1 GW = 1 billion watts) and in billions of U.S. dollars per year sales (Fig. 2.2) [1]. Worldwide production exceeded 1 GW/year in 2002 and rose to over 3.8 GW/ year by 2006, and worldwide sales increased from US$(2007)1.5 to 9.7 billion over this same time period. The US$(2007)390 billion sales of the world’s largest oil company, Exxon Mobile, are shown in Figure 2.2 for reference [2]. Since 1975, this progress has provided a 1000-fold increase in gigawatts per year produced and almost a 100-fold increase in billions of U.S. dollars per year in sales. From 1975 to about 1985, the gigawatt per year growth rate was about a factor of 2 every 2 years. From about 1985 to 1995, it dropped to about half that rate before returning to approximately doubling every 2 years from about 1995 through 2006. Another 1000-fold increase in gigawatts per year production would place the solar cell electricity generation capacity in the range of both the total 2006 U.S. installed electricity generation capacity of 1075 GW [3] and the installed 2005 world electricity generation capacity of 3889 GW [4] even after allowing for the “capacity factor” of terrestrial sunlight being available only about 15–22% of the time [5, 6], neglecting storage issues. Since most commercial solar cells for terrestrial use
Solar Cells and Their Applications, Second Edition, Edited by Lewis Fraas and Larry Partain Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
17
18
SOLAR CELL ELECTRICITY
World Solar Cell Production (gigawatts)
10000
US PURPA
1000
Net Metering
JPL FSA
100
06 US Generating 05 World Capacity Generating Capacity
10 1
Rate To Double Every 2 Years
Cumulative
0.1 Annual
0.01 0.001 1970
1980
1990
2000
2010
2020
2030
2040
Year
Figure 2.1. The world solar cell production levels, on both an annual and cumulative basis, since 1975, with comparisons to the U.S. and world total electricity generating capacities in 2006 and 2005, respectively, and with support and public policy program time intervals for the JPL FSA, the U.S. PURPA, and the net metering programs. 1000 Exxon
World Solar Cell Market Size (billions 2007 US$/yr)
US PURPA
100
Net Metering
JPL FSA
Rate To Double Every 2 Years
10
1
0.1 1970
1980
1990
2000 2010 Year
2020
2030
2040
Figure 2.2. The world annual solar cell market size since 1975 with a comparison to the annual sales of the world’s largest oil company, Exxon Mobile, in 2007.
are designed for 20 years or greater lifetimes, the actual solar cell generation capacity lies between the annual and cumulative curves of Figure 2.1. The reason for the difference in the gigawatt and dollar growth rates is the constantly falling cost of terrestrial solar cells over the past 30 years as plotted in Figure 2.3. The 1975 technology was essentially slightly modified space satellite technology that cost about a hundred U.S. dollars per watt in 2007. By 2006, this had steadily dropped 25-fold to about four 2007 US$/watt. Like many high-technology and electronic products, this cost reduction roughly followed a learning
MARKET HISTORY
19
Solar Cell Module Cost (2007 US$/watt)
100 2X Cost Drop For Every 10X Increase In Cumulative Production Growth
10
8.6 gigawatts by 2006 1 0.001
0.01
0.1
1
10
100
1000
Cumulative Solar Cell Production (gigawatts)
Solar Cell Production (megawatts/yr)
Figure 2.3. The decrease in solar cell module costs since 1975 as a function of the cumulative solar cell production power through 2007. The dotted line indicates a learning curve decrease in cost by a factor of 2 with every 10× increase in cumulative production. 10000
Japan Europe China
1000 Total
Taiwan
100
Others
US
India
10
1 1994
1996
1998
2000
2002
2004
2006
2008
Year
Figure 2.4. The solar cell annual production rate from 1995 through 2006, broken down by the United States, Japan, Europe, China, Taiwan, India, and all others.
curve of dropping about a factor of 2 for every 10-fold increase in cumulative market production [7]. However, this price reduction has pretty much stalled during the last 10-fold increase in cumulative market. Many analysts attribute this cost plateau to a shortage of feedstock silicon required to manufacture the vast majority of current terrestrial solar cells [8]. The United States led in the production of solar cells from 1975 until the late 1990s. As shown in Figure 2.4, the Japanese production rate exceeded that of the United States in 1999, followed by Europe in 2003 and by China in 2006. In 2006,
20
SOLAR CELL ELECTRICITY
the United States’ fourth place position was essentially shared with Taiwan, whose rate of growth was higher. As shown in Figure 2.5 the United States held the third position in the yearly installation of solar cells in 2007, barely ahead of the rest of Europe (i.e., all but Germany) and with the rest of Asia (all but Japan) quite close behind. By 2004, Germany’s installation rate surpassed that of Japan. There are three major options to try and resume the module cost reduction process plotted in Figure 2.3. The first is to fundamentally improve crystalline cell technology and performance well beyond that of the original 1970s “modified space cell” configuration. Two potential candidates for this are the commercial SunPower interdigitated back contact cell and the SANYO HIT cell (see Chapters 3 and 4) both with prototype modules of independently confirmed “champion” efficiencies over 20% [9]. The second is thin film technologies that require much less (typically 100X) material than crystalline silicon solar cells (see Chapter 6). By 2006, the thin film annual production rate had grown to within a factor of a 1000 of the mainly silicon, total solar cell production rate, led by the United States and Japan as shown in Figure 2.6. In 2007, thin films’ growth rate was greater that that of the total market for the first time (compare with Fig. 2.1). This latest growth was mainly due to thinfilm CdTe cells that have taken the thin film lead from amorphous silicon. The decreased thin film production in Japan was mainly due to reduced activity in amorphous silicon. The third major option, for continued cost per watt reduction, is concentrator solar cell systems where the sunlight is focused down to a small area so that much smaller amounts of expensive solar cell material are also required for electricity 10000 World Solar Cell Installations (megawatts per year)
Europe Feed-In Tariffs
1000
Germany 100,000 Roofs
Germany Total
Japan
US
100
Rest of Asia
10 Rest Of Europe
1 1998
2000
2002
2004
2006
2008
Year
Figure 2.5. The annual solar cell installation rate from 2000 through 2007, broken down by the United States, Germany, Japan, the rest of Europe, and the rest of Asia, with time interval comparisons to Germany’s 100,000 Roofs Program and Europe’s Feed-In Tariff Program.
MARKET HISTORY
21
World Thin Film Solar Cell Production (gigawatts/yr)
10000 1000 100 10 Rate To Double Every 2 Years
1 0.1
Europe Japan
Total US
0.01
Rest Of World
0.001 1994
1996
1998
2000
2002
2004
2006
2008
Year
Figure 2.6. The annual world production of thin-film solar cells from 2003 through 2006, broken down by the United States, Europe, Japan, and the rest of world, and with the world total extended through 2007. The dashed line indicates a growth rate to double every 2 years.
Cumulative World Solar Cell Sales (billions 2007 US$)
1000 Rate To Double Every 2 Years
100
$36 billion by 2006
10 Germany 100,000 Roofs
1 JPL FSA
0.1 1970
1980
1990
2000
2010
2020
Year
Figure 2.7. The world cumulative solar cell sales from 1975 through 2006, with comparisons to the total expenditures of the JPL FSA Program through 1985 and Germany’s 100,000 Roofs Program through 2003.
generation (see Chapters 12–17). The latter are in their earliest, larger-scale testing phases, with most installation efforts currently centered in Spain ([10]; Banda and Rubio, Chapter 17). Figure 2.7 shows the cumulative sales totals of solar cells that have grown to US$(2007)36 billion by 2006. This is a classic learning curve-type response to a total integrated investment, which has overwhelmingly been into crystalline silicon solar cells, over this 1975–2006 time period. This total magnitude serves
22
SOLAR CELL ELECTRICITY
as a significant and growing barrier to any new technology that essentially has to become competitive at a greatly accelerated growth rate (comparatively) but with much less total integrated investment. Until recently, the thin-film growth rate had not been able to duplicate that of crystalline silicon (Figs. 2.1 and 2.6). Compounding any new solar cell approach’s problems is crystalline silicon’s constantly improving efficiency, reliability, ruggedness, acceptance, and costs as it continues down its learning curve, with ever-growing totals of integrated sales investment. The classic response strategy for this situation is a disruptive one where the new technology enters a niche market where the dominant technology does not participate and proceeds independently down its own learning curve largely unchallenged until its new concepts suddenly become competitive [11]. A potential example of the latter is the very high-efficiency, but also very high-cost, triplejunction space solar cells, based on III–V compounds (e.g., GaAs) that now dominate the space solar cell market (see Chapters 13–17).
2.2
PUBLIC POLICY
Over the past 30 years, there have been multiple significant public policy decisions, which have directly driven and strongly influenced the rate of development and the geographical location of major segments in the world total solar cell electricity marketplace. Here, five primary ones are highlighted that can be readily correlated with major market responses evident in the historical statistical market data. The earliest is the JPL FSA from 1975 through 1985 [12]. It corresponds to the initial rapid rate of market growth as indicated in Figure 2.1. It transformed delicate and expensive space silicon cells into rugged, reliable, and affordable terrestrial ones through five increasingly large (hundreds of kilowatts) and rigorously competitive block purchases of silicon cell modules whose properties were monitored and meticulously tested and reported [13]. The last two of these blocks produced the two early peaks in market growth shown on the left side of Figure 2.2. Its US$(1985)235 million (US$[2007]403 million) [14] total program size was equivalent to about 30% of the total integrated total market sales between 1975 and 1983 as is evident from Figure 2.7. Both its magnitude and sharp focus (on transforming fragile, expensive space silicon cell technology into robust and affordable terrestrial products) made it the primary driver of this early market development period. At each stage, these modules had to pass increasing stiff environmental reliability, stability, and performance standards. By the end, the project had met all of its major goals except for the price of the modules. The emerging results of singlecrystal, sawed silicon wafers, screen printed with a top metal grid contact, sandwiched between a plastic back plane and a top glass plate with polyvinyl butyral adhesive or EVA, set the standard for the next 20 years of solar cell market leadership by the United States. Following World War II, the U.S. economy was the world’s largest and it could best afford such a market generating and leading investment into this new breakthrough renewable energy technology. According to Figure 2.7, the growth
PUBLIC POLICY
23
in the world market equaled the total US$(2007)403 million JPL investment by 1988, with geometrical larger annual revenues the following years into the 1990s when U.S. companies still led in the world marketplace. For the next 10 years (about 1985–1995), the growth rate dropped by about a factor of 2, supported but only rather weakly by the PURPA that had passed in 1978. PURPA allowed “independent” electricity producers to be paid utility wholesale “avoided costs” under long-term (15–30 years), fixed-price contracts at least early on [15]. This was strongly led by California Public Utility Commission’s interpretation and requirements that ordered utilities to offer standardized contracts, most notably Standard Offer No. 4, with fixed prices. In the 1980s, PURPA was estimated to have produced up to 12 GW in non-hydro renewable energy system installations in the United States. Over half (6.1 GW) were in California, but most (over 90%) were for wind, geothermal, and biomass. Unfortunately, PURPA was not restricted just to renewables. By the early 1990s, its support of renewables stagnated with most new contracts going for nonrenewable natural gas “cogeneration” plants (producing both electric and steam) due to changing conditions including relatively low natural gas costs. Nevertheless, a significant aspect of PURPA was its first demonstration of a “feed-in”-type tariff, where renewable energy sources received “above-market” prices for their power output under longterm, fixed-price contracts, resulting in a large market response and many installations, although the majority of these were not for solar cell electricity. The next big positive stimulus for solar cell electricity was net metering, which started in the early 1990s [15]. It became prevalent enough in the United States to restore the rapid growth of solar cell production by about 1995 (as indicated on Fig. 2.1). Net metering allows independent producers, such as rooftop systems on residences and commercial buildings, to be credited by their utility for the retail avoided cost of utility-delivered electricity to their site (as opposed to wholesale avoided costs of PURPA). Typically, the utility only credits for the siteproduced power, up to the net power delivered to the site from the utility each year. Thus, any excess site electricity production is not accrued and no actual payment goes from the utility to the customer. The benefit is that the utility customer, producing local power, can offset up to 100% of the retail value of the power delivered to his or her site each year. From Figure 2.4, it can be seen that the Japanese solar cell production exceeded that of the United States by 1999 and it has maintained this world leadership production position since that time. The cost of Japanese solar cell modules decreased by over a factor of 4 from 1994 to 2003 (from ¥1733 per watt to ¥583 per watt or from US$[2007]23.62 to 4.32 per watt [8, 14, 16]) and went from being not cost competitive to being very competitive. During this same period, the efficiency of their modules increased from 12% to the 15–17% range, while the thickness of the silicon wafers used decreased from 380 to 180 microns. The performance increase came from continuous incremental improvements in light trapping (textured surfaces, double antireflection coating, reduced contact shadow). It also came from lower losses (good-quality substrates, passivation, heterojunctions) and from lower resistance (thicker electrodes, fine contact pattern). Cost reductions came
24
SOLAR CELL ELECTRICITY
from thinner substrates, larger cell sizes, simpler and lower-temperature processes, non-vacuum technology, and from making substrates directly from molten silicon. This was all largely developed directly at large commercial Japanese companies, but in close coordination with Japanese universities and with the Japanese government agencies with a clear mandate and a government resources commitment sufficient for success. The latter program was essentially that of the NEDO as part of the New Sunshine Program under the MITI [8] and its successor organizations. Approximately 8% of Japanese corporate funding (including NEDO support) goes to basic research, and this has been enough to provide the high-performance crystalline silicon HIT cell from SANYO (see Chapters 4 and 5). Since the late 1980s, the Japanese economy has been one of the world’s largest. In 2007, it was the world’s second largest economy, exceeded only by that of the United States [17]. With its comparatively small commitment to military expenditures, Japan has been particularly free to focus heavily on its internal hightechnology industrial development. “… It was in the middle of that decade [the 1990s] that the country [Japan] realized the importance of innovation and redesigned its whole strategy” [18]. “The size of NEDO’s budget illustrates this point. Japan’s corporations spend a combined 111 billion [2008] US$ on research and development every year, but more than 90% of that actually goes to incremental improvements of existing products, with 7 billion [2008] US$ going to basic research. That makes the more than 1 billion [2008] US$ that NEDO pours into its 140 research projects equal to 16% of the total corporate [Japanese] investment into basic research … Take NEDO’s long-term commitment to solar cell research. On the one hand, Japanese manufacturers like Sharp and Kyocera have won a significant share of the global market using technologies developed through NEDO projects. … With … sinister place names like ‘Devil River’, ‘Valley of Death’ and ‘Darwinian Sea’, … the illustration on the table [of the] … director general of … NEDO looks like some kind of map … It’s a vivid visual metaphor created by the U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology to express the pitfalls that lie waiting for inventors trying to turn their research into commercial products … In Japan … [the NEDO director general] is the man charged with helping the scientific community to catapult technology and know-how past these obstacles and into the marketplace. … Since being reorganized in 2003 … [NEDO has] complete control of the national projects … [to] cancel projects that aren’t going well and direct more money into promising-looking research.” There are no details of the amounts of NEDO funding of solar cell R & D programs over the 2000–2005 time period, but when combined with Japanese corporate R & D expenditures, these combined totals are plausibly on the order of 30% of the integrated cumulative sales of solar cells of ∼10 billion (US$[2007]) by that time (see Fig. 2.7). Such NEDO-coordinated and well-supported programs in Japan, centered in large commercial operations, are reminiscent of the scale and methods of the U.S. technology development efforts termed the military–industrial complex by U.S. President Eisenhower [19]. The latter evolved dramatically from the cauldron of pressures leading up to and into World War II [20], and their implementations can be reasonably credited with keeping the U.S. military technology more than com-
PUBLIC POLICY
25
petitive with Germany’s and Japan’s early on in the World War II years and later on with the former Soviet Union’s. Its time-tested and hard-proven U.S. Department of Defense’s Science and Technology program (of US$[2007]10.8 billion) is split with 13% to basic research, 41% to applied research, and 46% to advanced technology development [21]. The latter two guide new military technology through “the Valley of Death”-type obstacles, identified by the former Advanced Technology Program of the U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology and as highlighted and accommodated in current NEDO programs. Survivors are then ready for standard procurement or sales processes. U.S. public policy since the 1980s has largely blocked comparable programs in the United States for any technologies and industrial developments other than those focused or directed at U.S. military applications. The U.S. military–industrial complex approach was a dramatic change and improvement in the R & D process and in the rapid translation of research success into large-scale production and availability [20]. Its only major missing part, relevant to the widespread commercial introduction of solar cell-based energy, is the economic viability and market evaluations like those of the former Advanced Technology Program of the U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology. By the mid-1990s, the EU countries and their increasingly integrated industries and markets began to build an expanding and major role for themselves in the world economy, not only for the EU in general but for Germany in particular, which was the world’s sixth largest economy by 2007 [17]. By 2007, the combined economies of the EU actually exceeded that of the United States. From 1999 until 2003, the German government instituted the 100,000 Roofs Program, targeted only at solar cell electricity, with 1.7 billion euros (US$[2007]2.2 billion) [14, 16] in favorable loans and feed-in law tariffs of up to 0.574 euros per kilowatt hour (US$[2007]∼0.75 per kilowatt hour) for up to 20 years [22]. This US$(2007)2.2 billion level investment again represents about 30% of the total world integrated sales of solar cells up to 2003 as shown in Figure 2.7. This program generated 145 GW of installed solar cell panels in Germany in 2003 to make it the leading installer since that time (see Fig. 2.5). It is estimated that the Roofs Program generated 10,000 German jobs and created 800 million euros (US$[2007]1.0 billion) in German industry revenues in 2003 alone. With this rate of revenue growth, this total loan investment was duplicated in German sales revenues within about the three following years. In comparison, the size of the California economy ranks eighth in the world [23]. Its and Germany’s (ranked sixth) have both the ability and track record of early demonstration of breakthrough technology and market trends including ones in renewable energy. Expanding on the PURPA concept, Germany introduced its version of feed-in tariffs in 1990, which was refined into its successful form by 2000 when it became a federally managed program [24, 25]. With such feed-in tariff law programs instituted in multiple European Community nations, Germany, Spain, and Denmark each provide significant portions of their countries’ electricity totaling 5%, 9%, and 20%, respectively, in 2007 from renewable sources, which were under long-term (20 year) contracts in Germany and in Spain [26]. The 2007 solar cell
26
SOLAR CELL ELECTRICITY
electricity installation totals for Germany and Spain were 47% and 23% (for a combined 70%) of the world market. These latest feed-in tariffs are justified by rationale that can include the following [24]. Long-term contracts (up to 20 years) pay solar cell electricity “tariffs” up to five times the going commercial rate (e.g., US$[2007]0.75 per kilowatt hour) [22], as opposed to representative rates (of US$[2007]0.16 per kilowatt hour typical of Italy in 2006 [27]). When 3% of a country’s electric power is produced under such agreements and the costs are spread among all the users, the 500% premium becomes a ∼15% increase in each user’s electricity bill. The integrated production that supplies these countries’ installations drives down the cost of solar cell modules, according to its learning curve (see Fig. 2.3). For a learning curve of 2X cost reduction for every 10X increase in cumulative production, the cost premium would be reduced by a factor of 2 when the cumulative production grows 10-fold, and a factor of 4 for 100-fold. After that, the cost to the customers for the next 3% of a country’s solar cell electricity installation reduces the price premium by a factor of 2–4 down to 7.5–3.75%, respectively (compared to the initial 15%). With integrated solar cell production growth doubling every 2 years (see Fig. 2.1), these 10- and 100-fold increases would occur in about 3.3 and 13.0 years, respectively. Three percent of a large user market can be quite significant particularly in the early penetration stages of solar cells into the total electricity market. For instance, 3% of the 2007 U.S. installed electricity capacity would be over 32 GW, more than eight times the total size of the world solar cell production total in 2006. The benefits that could accrue from such a program are a nation’s electricity energy supply becoming substantially less dependent on imported oil and gas, from a domestic source of sunlight that never decreases and that is delivered on-site free of charge, where the electricity conversion process itself (excluding the feedstock refining, manufacturing, installation, recycling, and disposal of solar cells) produces no pollution and generates no greenhouse gases. As a widely distributed source, it would be less subject to disruption by terrorist or military acts or by natural disasters. An orderly transition into this major new energy resource could be made steadily over many years, before world oil and gas production peak and begin to decline, which otherwise could generate sharp price fluctuations and major delivery disruptions with little or no time for orderly change. The resulting industries generated within countries could earn sales revenues equal to such subsidies within about three or four following years (if historical trends repeat) while at the same time creating large numbers of new jobs and major positive contributions to each country’s international balance of trade. Early participation in the process could well lead to world economic market leadership positions and geographic shifts of the centers of activity that historical evidence suggests can last for many years. It is the opinion of many economists [28, 29] that China is well on its way to becoming the world’s largest economy within the next few years or decades, with India likely to vie with the United States for second place perhaps 10–20 years even further out. From indications like the very high rate of expansion of its solar cell production capacity (Fig. 2.4), China may well be in the best position to invest
PUBLIC POLICY
27
the tens to hundreds of billions of 2007 U.S. dollars that historical data indicate could thrust it into the world’s leading position, at least in the area of solar cell production. And if history repeats itself, China would rapidly equal this total investment amount within 3 or 4 years of sales from its industries while also benefiting from the jobs generated and national sales revenue as well as from further increases to its international balance of payments surplus. There have been many other government-sponsored programs, some involving even larger monetary investments at their time, than the five cited above, but none with the comparably large and demonstrable effects on the world’s solar cell electricity market development history. Hence, it is not only the magnitude of a government program’s investments that provides the impetus for whole new technology applications and for relocating the geographical centers of leading activity, but it also takes wise selection of program focus and strong program execution. It is instructive to note that only the first (the JPL FSA) and the third (the Japanese NEDO development of crystalline silicon) of the five government programs covered above was directly focused on a single technology approach. Most, if not all of the other three, were essentially solar cell technology area neutral and were economic and technology stimulus programs. To a large degree, these all have mainly made use of the original JPL crystalline silicon design, with only this technology’s steady and incremental improvements, developed mostly by the manufacturers themselves (with large government subsidies at least in Japan) in response to the growing market. Over the last 30 years, the U.S. government’s (and many other countries’) renewable energy programs have had their major focus on the development of new breakthrough technology. Unfortunately, to date, the results have had little measureable impact on the solar cell electricity market and its development trajectory. However, this may be about to change; as Figure 2.3 indicates, the last 10X increase in cumulative solar cell production has produced little or no decrease in module costs, essential to the strategies covered above, for making solar cell electricity into a major alternative to depletable oil, natural gas, and coal energy supplies. A relevant public policy success example for technology implementation is the U.S. Interstate Highway System that was initiated in the Eisenhower administration beginning in 1956 [30]. It was justified as a defense-related program and was ∼90% federally funded by highway user taxes because it was considered “vitally important to national goals.” The Interstate Highway segments cost many times that of the then typical highways, and most of the highway users taxed had no direct Interstate Highway access in the early years of the program. The eventual positive impact of this system on the employment and housing opportunities of a large fraction of the U.S. population and on the U.S. economy as a whole has arguably been even greater than that of the federally funded U.S. National Aeronautics and Space Administration and its space programs. An analogue for this in solar cell electricity would be a federal tax on the users of depletable energy, namely, oil, natural gas, and coal. For example, this could pay a fraction of the initial capital costs (starting at, say, 75%) of installed solar cell electricity generating systems until approximately 30% of the then current cumulative world solar cell electricity
28
SOLAR CELL ELECTRICITY
market has been subsidized. These depletable energy users would then be directly paying for the development and deployment of renewable energy systems “vitally important to national goals” to the point that the latter becomes self-sustaining. For scale and reasonableness comparisons to the above past and potential future government programs, the following historical cost numbers may be useful. The cost of petroleum and petroleum products imported into the United States was US$327 billion in 2007, an increase of US$27 billion from the 2006 costs [31]. The U.S. 3-month balance of payment (current account) deficit increased by US$(2007)10.2 billion largely due to petroleum and petroleum product imports, which brought the total U.S. deficit to US$(2007)176 billion by the end of March 2008 [32]. Should military actions be needed at some future time to avoid major disruptions in imported gas and oil to any country, the ongoing Iraq war could provide a rough order-of-magnitude cost estimate from its 5 year costs to the United States of US$450 billion through the end of September 2007 [33]. The total final estimated cost in 1991 of the 42,795 miles of the U.S. Interstate Highway System at that point in time was $128.9 billion with $114.3 billion (or 88.7%) paid for from U.S. government funds at an average cost of $3 million per mile [34].
2.3
PROJECTED FUTURE
The historical market data above allow analysis of known quantitative results and comparatively objective evaluations of probable causes of, and contributions to, major past events and developments. Future projections require extrapolations beyond what is presently known and require a greater degree of speculation and unavoidably involve more subjective judgments and opinions. Nevertheless, important and accurate parallels can often be drawn between past history and future results, when past lessons learned are well applied, using well-accepted scientific principles and limitations combined with sound mathematical engineering and market analyses as attempted below. A continued growth rate of doubling every 2 years of production (and appropriately lower sales growth due to learning curve price reductions in Fig. 2.3) for solar cell electricity products and systems could lead to a sizeable fraction of the total U.S. and world electricity generating capacity and energy sales being provided by solar cell electricity in the decade between 2020 and 2030, as seen from Figure 2.1. One risk that could impede this progress is continuing stagnation of the Figure 2.3 solar cell module cost reduction with cumulative production. Another risk is that reasonable approaches may not be readily found to match the production of solar cell electricity to the demand schedule of electricity customers (e.g., night use of electricity when the sun is not shining). An accelerating factor for an even faster rate of growth is the rise in the real cost of energy (after correction for inflation) derived from depletable fossil fuel sources (i.e., oil, natural gas, and coal). The growing fossil fuel energy demands of the rapidly growing economies of China and India, plus the steady growth from the other leading world economies, strongly suggest that this real price increase will continue inexorably
PROJECTED FUTURE
29
for the medium term and precipitously over the longer term when the world production rates of oil and natural gas energy supplies eventually peak and begin to fall. A parallel case of a similar solid-state electronic technology growth is the approximate doubling of the calculating capacity on computer-integrated circuit chips every 2 years, which is termed Moore’s law [35]. Although all agree that this computing power growth rate cannot continue indefinitely due to fundamental and mathematical limitations, this empirical Moore’s law progress rate has essentially remained on track for more than 40 years. In comparison to solar cell electricity’s potential, 2030 is less than 25 years away. The terrestrial solar resource available is not a fundamental limitation to producing solar cell electricity each year at the level of the world generation capacity in 2005 (shown in Fig. 2.1) or even higher. The intensity of sunlight striking the outer boundary of the earth’s atmosphere is 1367 W/m2 (±4%) 24 h/day and 365 days/year as shown in the First Edition, Append B [36]. The diameter of the earth (at the equator) is 12,756 km [37] and the intensity of sunlight striking the earth’s surface (through an average atmospheric path length—i.e., AM1.5G) is 0.704 of its intensity at the atmosphere edge as given in the First Edition, Append A [36]. If one combines these with the conservative assumptions that (1) only land-based systems will be used; (2) one-third of the earth’s surface is land; (3) the availability of sunlight only matches demand 20% of the time (i.e., the capacity factor = 0.2); (4) 1% of the land is appropriate for solar cell electricity generation; and(5) the average system conversion efficiency is 10%, then the worldwide solar cell electricity resource size is 8193 GW or more than twice the 2005 world electricity generation capacity of 3889 GW shown in Figure 2.1. As the world’s dominant energy sources have evolved over time, from wood to coal and then to oil and gas, the total energy market size has increased substantially with each transition due to inherent advantages following each step. The solar input resource is large, so that the major challenge is to match solar cell electricity supply with demand. With natural hydro capacities at 121 and 923 GW for the United States and the world, respectively, in 2005 [38], this renewable storage resource can only cover demand mismatches of up to these same orders of magnitude. At Figure 2.1 extrapolated growth rates, such world levels could be reached as early as 2025. Unless battery or some other storage alternatives become practical, available and cost-effective in the meantime, solar cell electricity could be limited to supplying a fraction of the total world electric energy demand. To become the major electric energy resource, some fundamental change would likely be needed in electric energy use patterns. One of the most important and valuable U.S. exports is agricultural crops. This crop production essentially occurs only in the daytime, peaks in the summer months, with a virtual shutdown for most of the winter. Time of day and time of year utility rates could start to encourage business and personal lifestyles to take full advantage of such time availability of solar cell-generated electricity. Electric energy intense industries, such as aluminum refining and others, might well be induced to shift major fractions of their yearly
30
SOLAR CELL ELECTRICITY
production toward the daylight hours of the summer, if there were financial incentives like lower electricity rates.
2.4
COST ESTIMATES
The levelized cost of energy, L, is a detailed calculation of the effective cost of energy provided, such as 2007 U.S. dollar per kilowatt hour, considering all of the life cycle factors and expenses that contribute to such effective costs [39]. The intent of this chapter is to be as free of involved mathematical expressions and derivations as possible. Hence, Table 2.1 is used to separately summarize simple and approximate expressions that can be readily used to estimate L values and what effects them most based on parameter input values in the range of those listed in Table 2.2. This starts with baseline estimates taken from recent field experience and then proceeds to projected future cost reductions in the near- and medium-term time frames. The less mathematically inclined can thus skip the next two paragraphs and proceed directly to the results that follow. A more sophisticated and rigorous cost analysis is the complete topic of Chapter 20 (Solar Advisor Model) of this book. As listed in Table 2.1, the levelized cost of energy (L) is obtained by taking all the capital costs incurred for installing a solar cell electricity system, converting these initial capital costs into an annualized charge using fixed charge rates, and then dividing the results by the electric energy produced by such a system in a year. The result is an L value in dollar per kilowatt hour. Here, the simple approach developed by the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) was used [39]. The annual energy produced per unit area is just the solar energy density SEY (in kilowatt hour per square meter) that strikes the surface of the system per year, which is then adjusted for all of the relevant conversion efficiencies. The derating efficiency accounts for the mismatch and interconnect losses inevitably encountered in system assembly. A major component of fixed charge rates is the loan amortization rate, which is the per dollar cost per year of obtaining a loan at a given rate for a given period of time. This is easily obtained from loan amortization tables or from use of the Microsoft Excel PMT function. In locations where there are tax write-offs for the interest particularly on home loans, this reduces the fixed cost rate, proportionally to the tax bracket B and the fraction f of the loan payment that is interest. Additional annual financing costs are covered in the factor Δ. In a residential home loan, this Δ includes the annual taxes and insurance cost (per total loan dollar value) that adds to the amortized “interest and principal” payment (i.e., the principal, interest, taxes, and insurance [PITI] payments). The L value is conveniently expressed in terms of area-related capital costs per unit area and power-related capital cost per unit power (including the DC to AC inverter costs for the latter). One just multiplies these by the area A and the peak power P needed to generate 1 kWh in 1 year, and this gives the expression for L. For the power part, one needs to realize that module efficiency values are based on the assumption of a standard peak value of solar energy striking a system
COST ESTIMATES
31
TABLE 2.1. Levelized Cost of Energy (L) L ($ kWh ) =
TS FS + Ti Fi Annual AC energy production
Annual AC Energy Production per unit area = ηDηiηmSEY
L = (1 + r )
(Cm + Cb ) Fs A ηD ηi ηmSE Y
+ (1 + r ) Ci Fi P
AC kWh produced per year = ηDηiηmSEYA so A = 1/(ηDηiηmS) Peak output power P of inverter in kW needed for array of area A with a module efficiency ηm where the nominal peak solar input power is 1000 W/m2 = 1 kW/m2 P = ηDηiηm 1 kW/m2 A = ηDηiηm/(ηDηiηm) = 1/SEY and Cm($/m2) = Cw($/W)ηm1000(W/m2) so that (1000ηm [Cw − I ] + Cb ) FS + Ci Fi / SE Y L = (1 + r ) ηD ηi ηmSE Y where I—government incentives in $/W and η η C b FS Cw = D i {L SE Y (1 + r ) − Ci Fi } + I − 1000 1000ηm
T—total capital investment F—fixed charge rate (converts initial investment into annualized charge) Subcript S—total system except for DC to AC power inverter Subscript i—DC to AC power inverter ηi—DC to AC inverter power conversion efficiency ηm—module efficiency of converting sunlight into DC power ηD—system derating efficiency SEY—sunlight energy density striking module surface over year in kWh/m2 where FS = mS – BfSmS + Δ and Fi = mi – Bf imi + Δ r—indirect cost rate (including yearly operations and maintenance costs) Cm—module cost in $/m2 Cb—area-related balance of systems costs in $/m2 (including installation) m—loan amortization rate per year f—fraction of m that is interest B—tax bracket Δ—additional fixed charge rate A—area required to produce 1 kWh/ year in m2 Ci—DC to AC inverter cost in $/kW P—peak inverter power output rating in kW required to produce 1 kWh/year
TABLE 2.2. Parameter Values for Baseline, Near-Term, and Medium-Term Time Frames Parameter
Symbol
Value
Units
Baseline
Near Term
Medium Term
Module efficiency
ηm
0.135 (13.5%)
0.16 (16%)
0.20 (20%)
— (%)
Module cost
CW
4
2.2
1.25
$/W
Sunlight energy density/year
SEY
2435
2435
2435
kWh/m2/year (Phoenix)
Area-related BOS
Cb
307
155
150
$/m2
DC to AC inverter cost
Ci
900
690
300
$/kW
Inverter efficiency
ηi
0.95 (95%)
0.96 (96%)
0.97 (97%)
System lifetime
LTS
30
35
35
Years
Inverter lifetime
LTi
5
10
20
Years
System derating efficiency
ηD
0.95 (95%)
0.95 (95%)
0.95 (95%)
— (%)
I
2.50
1.21
0.55
$/W
0.06 (6%)
0.06 (6%)
0.06 (6%)
1/year (%/year)
Government incentive Loan rate
— (%)
Loan amortization rate system
mS
0.0726 (7.26%)
0.069 (6.90%)
0.069 (6.90%)
1/year (%/year)
Loan amortization rate inverter
mi
0.237 (23.7%)
0.136 (13.6%)
0.0872 (8.72%)
1/year (%/year)
Interest fraction of amortization system
fS
0.826 (82.6%)
0.870 (87.0%)
0.870 (87.0%)
— (%)
Interest fraction of amortization inverter
fi
0.253 (25.3%)
0.442 (44.2%)
0.688 (68.8%)
— (%)
Tax bracket
B
0.28 (28%)
0.28 (28%)
0.28 (28%)
— (%)
Additional fixed charge rate
Δ
0.0442 (4.24%)
0.0442 (4.24%)
0.0442 (4.24%)
1/year (%/year)
Fixed charge rate system
FS
0.100 (9.82%)
0.0964 (9.64%)
0.0964 (10%)
1/year (%/year)
Fixed charge rate inverter
Fi
0.265 (26.3%)
0.163 (13.7%)
0.115 (11.8%)
1/year (%/year)
Indirect cost rate
r
0.225 (22.5%)
0.225 (22.5%)
0.225 (22.5%)
— (%)
Levelized cost of energy
L
0.32
0.15
0.09
$/kWh
COST ESTIMATES
33
is 1000 W/m2. It is a standard accounting technique to multiply direct costs by an indirect rate, r, to include overhead and general and administrative costs including yearly operations and maintenance costs. For the expressions used here, it was assumed that the majority of the balance-of-systems (BOS) costs (including installation costs but excluding inverter costs) were area related. Hence, any BOS given in power-related form was converted into area-related form using the conversion relationship that is four lines from the bottom of Table 2.1. It is noted that any first-year government incentives I offered in terms of dollar per watt rebates simply subtract directly from the capital cost of the modules CW in dollar per watt. The final L expression is given three lines from the bottom of Table 2.1. The module cost CW expression on the bottom line came just from solving the L expression for CW in terms of all the other parameters. The baseline calculated costs for residential solar cell system electricity of $0.32 per kilowatt hour in Phoenix, Arizona, are given on the third column bottom line of Table 2.2. The baseline input parameter values for module efficiency, module costs, BOS costs, inverter costs, inverter efficiency, system derating efficiency, system lifetime, and inverter lifetime came from the U.S Solar Energy Technology Multiyear Program Plan 2007–2011’s [40] 2005 benchmark numbers obtained from 200 residential installations between 2000 and 2005. The loan rate and tax bracket were taken from the 2008–2012 plan [41]. The indirect cost rate and the system fixed charge rate were taken from the EPRI values [39] and its 22.5% value includes the 0.5% operations and maintenance charge used in the Solar Advisor Model. The Δ value (adding to indirect charge rate) was chosen so that the calculated FS value equaled the EPRI value of 10%. The Phoenix annual solar energy density SEY was taken from Riordan’s Chapter 20 of the First Edition [36]. As a reality check, the fixed charge rate for a 2007 home loan in Mountain View, California, was calculated as shown in Table 2.3, and its value of 9.13% (for PITI) is in this general range. The government incentive of $2.50 per watt was chosen to give the same $0.32 per kilowatt hour L value as reported in the SETP 2007–2011 plan [40]. It is in the approximate range of the most beneficial rebates offered by the state of California.
TABLE 2.3. Fixed Charge Rate F for the Purchase of a $400,000 Home with 20% Down and a $320,000 30-Year Mortgage at a 6.375% Loan Rate in Mountain View, California, in 2007 Parameter
Monthly Cost ($)
Yearly Cost ($)
Normalized Yearly Cost per Loan ($)
1995.0
23,935.0
0.0748 (7.48%)
375.0
4500.0
0.0141 (1.41%)
766.0
0.0024 (0.24%)
Principal and interest Taxes Insurance Fixed charge rate F (total)
63.85
0.0913 (9.13%)
34
SOLAR CELL ELECTRICITY
Levelized Cost of Energy L ($/kW-hr)
One of the advantages of the simple Table 2.1 expressions is the ease with which they can be used for sensitivity analyses. Figure 2.8 shows such a sensitivity plot of the levelized cost L to different module efficiency values. For the baseline case with a module efficiency of 13.5% and an L value of $0.32 per kilowatt hour (shown by a vertical line), one can see the beneficial effects of greatly increased module efficiency rapidly saturate with a sharper increase in L costs with decreased module efficiency. Similarly, Figure 2.9 shows the sensitivity of allowed module 0.5
0.4
0.3 Base Line
0.2 Near Term
0.1 Medium Term
0 0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Module Efficiency ηm (%)
Figure 2.8. The levelized cost of energy L as a function of module efficiency ηm for the baseline, near term, and the medium term obtained from the expressions of Table 2.1 using the input parameter values of Table 2.2. 6
Base Line $0.32/kW-hr
Module Cost CW ($/W)
5 4 Near Term $0.15/kW-hr
3 2
Medium Term $0.9/kW-hr
1 0 -1 -2 0
10
20
30
40
50
Module Efficiency ηm (%)
Figure 2.9. The allowed module cost CW obtained by holding all the parameters constant, except for module efficiency ηm and module cost CW, using the other parameter values of Table 2.2 for the baseline, near term, and the medium term calculated with the expression at the bottom of Table 2.1.
COST ESTIMATES
35
costs in dollar per watt (around the baseline $4 per watt value indicated by the vertical line) with module efficiency but with all the other baseline parameters held constant including L at $0.32 per kilowatt hour. Here, higher module costs can be supported with higher module efficiencies, but again this rapidly saturates. At lower module efficiencies, the module cost that can be justified drops sharply. For module efficiencies below 5%, the constant energy cost value L cannot be supported even if the module costs went to zero. This effect is due to the BOS cost described by the Cb parameter in the Cw expression at the bottom of Table 2.1. One conclusion from these sensitivity analyses is that there is no one parameter whose improvement can make the cost of solar cell electricity competitive with current electricity rates. Hence, two more cases were considered and they are the “near-term” and “medium-term” cases shown in Table 2.2 and in Figures 2.7 and 2.8 that respectively correspond to L values of $0.15 per kilowatt hour and $0.09 per kilowatt hour, module efficiency values of 16% and 20%, and module costs of $2.20 per watt and $1.25 per watt plus all the other optimistic parameter values listed in Table 2.2. These parameter values were taken from the “2011” and “2020” projections of the SETP 2007–2011 tables [40] plus similar listed adjustments to the remaining parameters. It should be noted that the SETP 2008–2012 table and plans [41] accelerated such improvements in to the “2010” and “2015” time frames. In this context, “near term” corresponds to the 2010–2011 time frame and “medium term” corresponds to the 2015–2020 time frame. Again, the corresponding curves of Figure 2.8 illustrate the positive but saturating benefits of increased module efficiencies and the sharper penalties for lower module efficiencies. Here, Figure 2.9 shows the even stronger penalties for reduced module efficiencies with the L costs held constant at increasingly competitive values. For the specific $0.09 per kilowatt hour case considered here, module efficiencies below 8% could not be justified even if their costs were zero. Further, at a module price of $2 per watt, the calculated minimum module efficiency required to be competitive is 6% for the baseline case and 14% for the near-term cases but is not achievable for the medium-term case. Similarly, at a module price of $1 per watt, the calculated minimum efficiencies required to be competitive are 5%, 6%, and 15%, respectively, for the baseline, near-term, and medium-term cases. A bottom line here is that decreased module costs are essential for achieving competitive system performance but that lower-cost modules still have to have efficiencies relatively near the more expensive modules of higher performance to provide competitive, levelized cost values. All of these emphasize the importance of resuming the Figure 2.3 module cost learning curve reductions that most recently have become quite flat. The breakdown of the three major system components and their contributions to the levelized costs L are shown in Table 2.4 for the baseline, near-term, and medium-term cases. For all three, the module costs contribute in the 70s percent range; the area-related BOS contributions are in the mid-30s to low 40s percent range, with the inverter contributions in the 30s–40s percent range. The resulting L values are only possible due to government incentives that pick up 30–40% of the total component contributions. This is the case even though the Table 2.2
36
SOLAR CELL ELECTRICITY
TABLE 2.4. Individual Parameter Contributions to the Levelized Cost of Energy L Parameter
Symbol
Contribution to L ($/kWh and %) Baseline
Near Term
Medium Term
Module cost ($/W)
CW
0.235 (73.6%)
0.117 (77.8%)
0.066 (72.7%)
Area-related BOS ($/m2)
Cb
0.134 (41.8%)
0.052 (34.2%)
0.039 (43.6%)
DC to AC inverter cost ($/kW)
CI
0.098 (30.6%)
0.046 (30.8%)
0.014 (15.6%)
Government incentive ($/W)
I
–0.147 (−46.0%)
–0.064 (−42.8%)
–0.029 (−32.0%)
Levelized cost of energy
L
0.320 (100%)
0.150 (100%)
0.090 (100%)
parameter assumptions show the actual government contributions in dollar per watt falling by more than a factor of 3 over this period. The SETP 2008–2012 Plan [41] and its Solar Advisor Model actually have the government incentive going to zero by the medium term. If these government incentives were all zero, the respective L values would be $0.467 per kilowatt hour, $0.214 per kilowatt hour, and $0.119 per kilowatt hour for the baseline, near-term, and medium-term cases (from the addition of the top three contribution rows of Table 2.4). It is such amounts that would be appropriate for “feed-in tariff ” situations. A reality check of this zero-incentive “2005” baseline value is that it is on the order of the $0.75 per kilowatt hour long-term contracts that Germany’s programs signed in the early 2000s to make their “feedin” programs financially attractive. Indeed, it is such feed-in tariff scenarios that market history indicates have been the most effective in stimulating rapid adoption and in promptly moving new geographic regions into higher world market ranking positions. The above near- and medium-term “zero-incentive” L values seem particularly reasonable for this latter type of public policy support strategy.
2.5
CONCLUSIONS
The 1000-fold growth of the world’s production of solar cell electricity in the 30 years since 1975 resulted from a growth rate that doubled output every 2 years for the first and last 10 years of this period. The middle 10 years had a growth rate reduced by about a half. Another 1000-fold growth in production would provide an electricity production level equivalent to the world’s total installed generation capacity of 3889 GW in 2005. Should a growth rate of doubling every 2 years be maintained, the latter capacity levels would be reached in the decade between 2020 and 2030.
CONCLUSIONS
37
The technical and manufacturing expertise required to support such developments is now spread throughout the world. The challenges to achieving these results are likely on the same order as those faced by the Manhattan Project that produced the first nuclear weapons or by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration’s program that placed the first men on the moon. These challenges include matching the availability of solar cell electric power with demand, continued reductions in the costs of producing electricity from solar cell systems (probably by another factor of 4 from baseline values) in ways that do not deplete basic resources needed for their construction and deployment, that does not seriously degrade the environment, and in a time frame that meets the inevitable peaking and decline of energy provided from fossil fuels. The leadership position in this technology originated in the United States but has largely shifted to the European Community and to Japan and to China over the last 10–15 years. Although the remaining challenges are daunting, the expertise to overcome them is now developing throughout the world. Changes in the rankings of dominating regions leading this technology will get increasingly expensive as the cumulative world market continues to expand. Those with the wisest and boldest strategies will likely be the major benefactors. The political entities with the highest capabilities for playing major roles in the rapidly evolving world market for solar cell electricity are those backed by the largest economies. In current order of size, these economies are those of (1) the EU, (2) the United States, (3) China, (4) Japan, and (5) India [17]. The market history-demonstrated and the best-estimated public policy approaches for promptly changing rankings among the leaders in the world market, in descending order of effectiveness, are (1) feed-in tariffs; (2) depletable energy user taxes applied to renewable energy development and deployment; (3) government-funded incentives that pay a substantial portion of the capital costs in the first year of installation; (4) long-term (30 years), low-interest rate loans often funded with tax-free bonds; (5) net metering particularly when extended to total metering so that the electricity excess delivered to a utility is paid for at least at 30–40% of the retail delivered costs; and (6) other tax incentives that include loan interest write-offs at constant interest rates over 30-year time periods. Several of these six listed approaches contain features that overlap. Of the three major options for resuming module cost reductions with market growth, key to the large-scale adoption strategy described in this chapter, is the concentrator option that has been the least explored so far and that needs the greatest assistance in making the transition from research into large-scale commercial availability and into clear feasibility demonstrations. Concentrator technology’s failure so far to transition into commercial availability is likely due in part to the “Valley of Death” syndrome described above in the Public Policy section, and that is endemic to all new technologies trying to break into large established markets. The EU is beginning to demonstrate that different countries with adjacent borders, speaking various languages, and with a spectrum of individual cultures, economic development levels, and technology competencies can join into cooperative trade, economic, consumer, and political arrangements that thrust such unions
38
SOLAR CELL ELECTRICITY
into a world leadership position, as ranked by economic metrics in general and by renewable energy implementations and deployments in particular. At its peak, the British Empire demonstrated that a dominant economic power base and trading entity could be assembled from widely spread countries whose participations were established and maintained through military “support.” A key challenge of the twenty-first century may be whether other “adjacent” and “nonadjacent” but diverse countries can cooperate through similar unions motivated primarily by economic self-interest and mutual well-being. For the latter unions to remain competitive with the large and rapidly growing economies like China’s and India’s, the involved “union” populations likely need similar sizes and mobilities and similar lack of restrictions. This latter likely includes ready access to nearly “comparable” education and training for the involved populations plus the latter’s ability to promptly relocate to job and professional opportunities unfettered by overly restrictive or artificial constraints such as those based on nationality, class, race, religion, or sex. As a nation composed essentially of diverse immigrant populations, the United States may have some advantages in the latter areas but with a remaining question of how much immigration is needed, desirable, and politically acceptable. A key to competitive solar cells and systems manufacturing in more developed countries like the EU, the United States, and Japan is automation. The fabrication equipment will likely cost about the same no matter where it is located. A Pacific Rim advantage is lower-cost labor that automation can offset to a large degree. Competitive plant construction costs including land in developed countries can likely be accommodated by appropriate tax breaks and incentives. This would offer reduced employment opportunities in manufacturing, but it would retain the product sales and factory construction revenues so that the involved country could avoid balance of payment deficits that would otherwise develop. “Champion” cells and modules are very important demonstrations of what is possible with current technology, but their performance numbers must be used with caution. When a fabricator has made and tested 10,000 devices, the very “best” by definition occurs with a yield of one in 10,000. Such a performance extreme does not necessarily provide accurate estimates of what can actually be achieved on a large scale in the near term at reasonable costs. In the past, such differences between the average achieved in large installations and in solitary “champion” devices have been as high as a factor of 4X to 5X with the differences exacerbated with attempts to provide low costs using less understood or developed materials systems (see Chapter 1 in Reference 36). When the price paid for solar cells is high using very well understood and developed materials systems, such as with space solar cells that can range in price from $300 per watt to $1800 per watt, the difference between “champion” and average cell performance can drop into the 30% or even lower range (see Chapters 4 and 23 in Reference 36). The terrestrial challenge is to simultaneously provide relatively low costs and high performance. Concentrators are an approach to using “expensive” and well-developed cell materials technologies with potentially low-cost optics to provide such a simultaneous result. However, this approach has not yet been well developed or tested
ABBREVIATIONS
39
experimentally. Early data show that the output of a two-axis tracking module of a high 17% efficiency produces 99% more kilowatt hour per square meter per year in a sunny Palo Alto, California environment in a side-by-side comparison with a near horizontal (5 ° fixed tilt) 12% efficient module (Fraas and Partain, Chapter 26). Recent tests of a 3X concentrator, two-axis tracking module of crystalline silicon interdigitated back contact cells showed that side by side, it had comparable output in kilowatt hour per square meter to a fixed axis module of similar cells in Shanghai, China, but only in measurements for a single day (L. Fraas, pers. comm.). Unfortunately, most of the current concentrator demonstration sites do not include non-concentrator modules, for direct side-by-side comparisons in terms of kilowatt hour per square meter per year outputs. Theoretical calculations of the differences are beginning to become available (Gueymard, Chapter 19). However, such calculations have not yet been carefully validated with experimental data. Their accuracy is unlikely to be trusted until such validations have been completed. Sensitivity analysis illustrates that there is no one parameter whose improvement will lead to the widespread practical implementation of solar cell electricity. However, module cost reductions (in dollar per watt) and efficiency improvements (in percent) will play dominant roles. However, major reductions in inverter costs and improvements in their lifetimes (by factors of 3X to 4X according to the Table 2.2 estimates) will also be needed. Among the other major challenges are economical means for energy storage in combination with time-of-use schemes that will be required for large-scale penetration into the traditional electricity energy market over the longer term. Most of the basic scientific understanding and principles needed to accomplish this are essentially already known. It is the engineering applications and their optimizations and scale-up that remain Herculean in scope and in magnitudes. This a situation largely shared with that of the U.S. Manhattan Project and the U.S. Man-on-the Moon Program in their early days. However, with sufficient forethought, the extremely short time frames and major diversion of resources of the Manhattan Project should not be required. While never predictable, research breakthroughs will accelerate at least some small parts of this effort. It is no longer a question whether this new energy source transition will occur. It is only a question of who will lead the process and who will reap the most benefits.
ABBREVIATIONS AC—alternating electric current CdTe—cadmium telluride DC—direct electric current EIA—U.S. Energy Information Administration EU—European Union EVA—ethylene vinyl acetate FSA—Flat-Plate Solar Array Project
40
SOLAR CELL ELECTRICITY
GaAs—gallium arsenide HIT—heterojunction with intrisic thin-layer solar cell JPL—U.S. Jet Propulsion Laboratory MITI—Ministry of International Trade and Industry (Japan) NEDO—New Energy and Industrial Technology Development Organization (Japan) PMT—name of the Microsoft Excel function that calculates mortgage payments as a function of interest rates and mortgage periods for given loan amounts PURPA—U.S. Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act R & D—research and development SETP—U.S. Solar Energy Technology Mulityear Program X—multiplier REFERENCES [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14]
J. G. Dorn. Solar Cell Production Jumps 50 Percent in 2007, Earth Policy Institute. Available at http://www.earth-policy.org/indicatiors/solar/2007.htm. Accessed March 9, 2008 (2007). Exxon Mobile Corporation. Annual Report. Available at http://thomson.mobular. net/thomson/7/2677/3201/. Accessed September 6, 2008 (2007). Energy Information Administration, U.S. Government, Existing Generating Units in the United States. Available at http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/electricity/epa/ epat2p2.html. Accessed September 6, 2008 (2007). Energy Information Administration, U.S. Government, Table H1, World Total Installed Generating Capacity. Available at http://www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/ieo/ieoecg. html. Accessed September 6, 2008 (2008). L. Stoddord and R. Pletka. CEC Workshop on Renewable Energy. Available at http://www.energy.ca.gov/2004_policy_update/documents/2004_06_08_BLACK_ VEATCH.pdf. Accessed September 6, 2008 (2004). R. Wiser and M. Bolinger. Projecting the Impact of State Portfolio Standards on Solar Installaltions, slide 4. Available at http://www.cleanenergystates.org/library/ ca/CEC_wiser_estimates.0205.pdf. Accessed September 6, 2008 (2005). W. Wallace. Government terrestrial acceleration programs. In Solar Cells and Their Applications, L. Partain, ed., p. 495. New York, Wiley (1995). T. Tomita. Prog. Phototovolt Res. Appl. 13, 471–479 (2005). M. A. Green, K. Emery, and D. L. King. Solar cell efficiency tables (version 29). Prog. Photovolt. Res. Appl. 15, 15–40 (2007). V. Salas and E. Olias. Overview of the photovoltaic technology status and perspective in Spain. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. Elsevier, London. doi:10.1016/j.rser.2008.03.011 (2008). C. Christensen. The Innovator’s Dilemma. Boston, Harvard Business School (1997). E. Christensen. Flat plate solar array project. US Department of Energy Report, Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Pasadena, CA (1985). W. Callahan and R. McDonald. Flat-Plate Solar Array Project Final Report, JPL Publication 86-31, 5101-289, DOE/JPL 1012-125, Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Pasadena, CA (1986). Bureau of Economic Analysis, U.S. Government, Table 1.19 Implicit Price Deflators for Gross Domestic Product. Available at http://www.bea.gov/national/nlpaweb/ TableView.asp#Mld. Accessed September 8, 2008 (2008).
REFERENCES [15] [16] [17]
[18]
[19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33]
41
E. Martinot, R. Wiser, and R. Hamrin. Renewable Energy Policies and Markets in the United States. Available at http://www.resource-solutions.org/lib/librarypdfs/ IntPolicy-RE.policies.markets.US.pdf. Accessed September 13, 2008 (2005). New York Federal Reserve Bank, US$ Foreign Exchange Rates. Available at http:// www.ny.frb.org/markets/fxrates/historical/fx.cfm. Accessed September 10, 2008 (2008). Central Intelligence Agency, U.S. Government, The World Fact Book, Rank Order—GDP (purchasing power parity). Available at http://www.cia.gov/library/ publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2001rank.html. Accessed September 18, 2008 (2008). Fortune magazine. A catalyst for change, the Japan of the future, pp. S10-S11, Special Advertising Section, July 21. Available at http://www.timeinc.net/fortune/ services/sections/customprojects/sections/071126_Japan2.pdf. Accessed September 16, 2008 (2008). Military-Industrial Complex Speech, Public Papers of the Presidents, Dwight D. Eisenhower, 1960, pp. 1035–1040. Available at http://coursesa.matrix.msu. edu/∼hst306/documents/indust.html. Accessed September 27, 2008 (1961). D. E. Kash. Perpetual Innovation, Chapter 6. New York, Basic Books (1989). FY 2008 Budget Request for Defense S&T, FYI. AIP Bulletin of Science Policy News, February 13, 2007, No. 23, pp. 1–2 (2007). SolarBuzz. German PV Market. Available at http://www.solarbuzz.com/fastfactsgermany.htm. Accessed September 6, 2008 (2007). A brief history of the California economy. Available at http://www.dof.ca.gov/ HTML/FS_DATA/HistoryCAEconomy/index.htm. Accessed November 22, 2008 (2008). World Future Council, Feed-in Tariffs. Available at http://worldfuturecouncil.org/ fileadmin/user_upload/Maja/Feed-in_Tariffs_WFC.pdf. Accessed September 16, 2008 (2008). Wikipedia. Feed-in tariff. Available at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feed_in_Tariff. Accessed November 22, 2008 (2008). SolarBuzz. 2007 World PV Industry Report Highlights. Available at http://www. solarbuzz.com/Marketbuzz2008-Intro.htm. Accessed September 7, 2008 (2008). NEI Nuclear Notes, Italy Nuclear Update. Available at http://www.neinuclearnotes. blogspot.com/2006/02/italy-nuclear-update.html. Accessed September 15, 2008 (2006). China to become world’s largest economy by 2010, Finance Daily. Available at http://financedialy.co.uk/News/Chinatobe WorldsLargestEconomyby2010_448. html. Accessed September 27, 2008 (2008). The World’s Largest Economies in 2050, University of Phoenix, based on 2003 Goldman Sachs study. Available at http://www.everthing2.com/index.pl?node_ id=1756826. Accessed September 27, 2008 (2005). 50th Anniversary of the Interstate Highway System. Available at http://www.fhwa. dot.gov/interstate.history.htm. Accessed August 22, 2008 (2006). US oil import bill to top $400 billion this year. Available at http://www.reuters.com/ article/pressRelease/idUS236508+07-Mar-2008+BW20080307. Accessed September 7, 2008 (2008). Bureau of Economic Analysis, U.S. Government, U.S. International Transactions: First Quarter 2008. Available at http://www.bea.gov/newreleases/rels.htm. Accessed September 7, 2008 (2008). The Cost of Iraq, Afghanistan, and Other Global War. Available at http://zfacts.com/ metaPage/lib/CRS-Belasco-2006-09-Iraq-Costs-RP33110.pdf. Accessed September 7, 2008 (2008).
42 [34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40]
[41]
SOLAR CELL ELECTRICITY Interstate Cost. 50th Anniversary of the Interstate Highway System Frequently Asked Questons. Available at http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/interstate/faq.htm# question6. Accessed November 20, 2008 (2006). S. Thompson and S. Pathasarathy. Materials Today 9, 20–25 (2006). L. D. Partain, ed. Solar Cells and Their Applications. New York, Wiley (1995). Earth radius. Available at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth-radius. Accessed November 22, 2008 (2008). Energy Information Administration, U.S. Government, Table H6, World Installed Hydroelectric and Other Renewable Generating Capacity. Available at http://www. eia.doe.gov/oiaf/ieo/ieoecg.htm. Accessed September 6, 2008 (2008). F. R. Goodman, J. C. Schaefer, and E. A. DeMeo. Terrestrial, grid connected systems. In Solar Cells and Their Applications, Chapter 16, L. D. Partain, ed. New York,Wiley (1995). US Department of Energy, Solar Energy Technologies Program, Multi Year Program Plan 2007-2011. Available at http://www.pv-era.net/doc_upload/documents/218_0 084aSolarEnergyTechnologiesProgram2007-2011_proof.pdf. Accessed October 12, 2008 (2007). US Department of Energy, Solar Energy Technologies Program, Multi Year Program Plan 2008-2012. Available at http://www1.eere.energy.gov/solar/pdfs/ solar_program_mypp_2008-2012.pdf. Accessed October 26, 2008 (2008).
3 SOLAR CELLS, SINGLE-CRYSTAL SEMICONDUCTORS, AND HIGH EFFICIENCY LEWIS FRAAS JX Crystals Inc.
3.1
INTRODUCTION
How efficient can a solar cell be and how much power and energy can it produce and at what cost? These are the fundamental questions addressed in this chapter. In order to address these questions, it will be necessary to first describe the nature of sunlight and then the nature of semiconductors. It will be shown that singlecrystal semiconductors are necessary for high sunlight conversion efficiency and that high conversion efficiency is important for lower-cost solar electricity. In addition to silicon solar cells, a new class of semiconductors based on LED materials will also be discussed. The reader is familiar with LEDs and the fact that they come in different colors. It is noted herein that LEDs are just solar cells running in reverse. In other words, in a LED, electricity goes in and light comes out. In a solar cell, light goes in and electricity comes out. It will be shown that the LED class of semiconductors can be used to make multicolor or multijunction solar cells where the multicolor feature is critical for making solar cells with energy conversion efficiencies as high as 40%. While it is true that high-efficiency single-crystal solar cells are more expensive to make than amorphous or small grain size polycrystalline thin-film cells, fortunately, it is possible to use inexpensive mirror or lens materials to collect the sunlight and to focus the solar energy on these single-crystal converters thereby diluting their cost. This is the concentrated sunlight PV or CPV approach. The newer 40% cells are even more complex and expensive than single-crystal silicon Solar Cells and Their Applications, Second Edition, Edited by Lewis Fraas and Larry Partain Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
43
44
SOLAR CELLS, SINGLE-CRYSTAL SEMICONDUCTORS
cells requiring higher-concentration HCPV systems, whereas the silicon singlecrystal cells can use lower concentration LCPV simpler systems. This chapter will then conclude with a discussion of the future cost potential for the various solar PV options comparing the potential future system-level cost for the conventional planar silicon cell and thin-film cell approaches with the concentrated sunlight approaches.
3.2
SUNLIGHT, RAINBOWS, AND PHOTONS
How much energy is in sunlight? The answer to this question requires a definition of some terms. The three terms are power, solar intensity, and energy. Power is in watts and solar intensity is in watts per unit area. Energy is in kilowatt hours. Homeowners pay for energy in kilowatt hours. Solar modules and arrays produce power in watts. The relevant measure of solar radiation is solar intensity. On a nice, sunny day at noon, the solar intensity is usually around 1 kW/m2. One square meter is close to 11 ft2. How does a scientist describe sunlight? The observation of rainbows proves that sunlight can be divided into different colors. Also, when a group of very fine parallel lines are scribed close to each other to make a grating, it is observed that the colors can be correlated with line spacing. This means that there is a wavelength connected to each color. So, light is an electromagnetic wave as shown in Figure 3.1, just like radio waves and microwaves with a wavelength, λ, and electric field, E. The history of the study of light is interesting. Actually, Newton thought of light as particles. However, with grating experiments in the 1800s, it was decided that light was an electromagnetic wave. Then, in about 1905, Einstein looked at the photoelectric effect and said that light comes in small energy packets called
E
Wave length
Figure 3.1. Electromagnetic wave.
SUNLIGHT, RAINBOWS, AND PHOTONS
45
quanta, which behave somewhat like particles. Einstein won the Nobel Prize for this work [1], not for his theory of relativity. Einstein noted that when the light of a certain color hits a metal, all of the electrons that escape the metal have the same peak energy and that when the light intensity is increased, the number of electrons increases, not the energy of each electron. It is like the energy in wave theory is E2, but the energy also equals nλ × eλ, where nλ is the number of photons and eλ is the energy of each photon. So, one can think of the electromagnetic wave intensity as getting smaller and smaller until one discovers that it is coming in discrete particles. It occurs in very fine steps. So now, the sun’s intensity spectrum can be divided into color or wavelength intervals as in Figure 3.2. To understand how solar cells work, first note that a photon’s energy is inversely proportional to its wavelength. This just means that shorter wavelength photons at the left in this curve have more energy than the longer wavelength photons at the right. Electric power is the product of voltage and current. In a solar cell, the power results when electrons pass through a voltage. It is the nature of semiconductors that each semiconductor material has a threshold absorption energy that then controls the voltage the electrons see. It is convenient then to talk in units called electron volts. An electron volt is the energy that an electron produces when it moves through a potential of 1 V. Photon energies and material threshold absorption energies are measured in electronvolt. For example in Figure 3.2, a red photon with an energy of 2 eV has a wavelength of about 0.6 microns, and the absorption threshold energy for silicon, called its bandgap energy, is at 1.1 eV, which equates to 1.1 microns (1 micron = 1 micrometer = 1 millionth of a meter = 1 μm). Now the efficiency limits can be seen. First, in Figure 3.2, all photons with energies less than 1.1 eV are lost; that is, all solar energy with wavelengths greater 1600
Watts/m2/micron
1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
Wavelength (microns)
Figure 3.2. Sun’s spectrum at AM1.5. The gray region is the usable photon energy for a silicon solar cell.
46
SOLAR CELLS, SINGLE-CRYSTAL SEMICONDUCTORS
than 1.1 microns is lost because these photons are not absorbed. Next, for photons with energies large enough to be absorbed (left side of figure), each photon absorbed must create an electron that can move to generate voltage. The yield here should be one electron per photon, but the actual number is less and is called the quantum efficiency or QE. QEs of 90% occur in pure single-crystal materials. QEs in non-single-crystal materials are lower. So, single-crystal semiconductors are important for high efficiency as will be discussed in the next sections of this chapter. For now, high QEs in single-crystal materials are assumed. These moving electrons create the current. To calculate the current, the photons absorbed are simply counted. However, note that while a photon might have 2 eV of energy, it can only create an electron moving through a voltage of no more than the bandgap energy. For silicon, this is 1.1 eV. So, 2-eV photons loose at least 2.0 – 1.1 = 0.9 eV. The gray region in Figure 3.2 shows the energy that can be captured from the higher-energy photons. This now leads to a way to make higher-efficiency solar cells using multiple materials. Two stacked materials can absorb the lower-energy photons in one material generating a lower voltage and the higher-energy photons in a second material generating a higher voltage. The result is more photons better used. This concept is shown in Figure 3.3. The gray regions in Figure 3.3 show that more photon energy can now be captured. To implement this two-junction or two-color cell concept, one must choose materials wisely. The GaAs/GaSb two-color cell (2) demonstrated in 1989 uses two simple materials with bandgap energies of 1.4 eV (0.9 micron) and 0.7 eV (1.8 micron). Theoretically, the efficiency for this pair can be as high as 41%. Thirtyfive percent has been demonstrated [2].
1600
Watts/m2/micron
1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 200 0
0
0.5
1 1.5 Wavelength (microns)
2
2.5
Figure 3.3. GaAs/GaSb and solar spectrum. The GaAs absorbs higher-energy photons at the left, generating higher voltage. The GaSb absorbs lower-energy photons at the right (1 micron = 1 micrometer = 1 millionth of meter).
ELECTRONS IN ATOMS AS WAVES AND THE PERIODIC TABLE
47
For the more general reader who may not care about the chemical names, note that the top GaAs cell actually looks blue and the bottom GaSb cell actually looks red. So, one can also refer to the cells in multicolor cell stacks as blue cells glued on top of red cells. The chemical terms will be used through most of this book for the benefit of technical readers because the chemical names are more precise. More information on multijunction concentrator cells will be presented later in this chapter and in Chapter 13.
3.3 ELECTRONS IN ATOMS AS WAVES AND THE PERIODIC TABLE OF THE ELEMENTS There are several different types of solar cells made from materials ranging from single crystals to amorphous silicon. The goal here is to describe the different types of solar cells and their advantages and limitations. A fundamental description of the nature of semiconductors is presented, beginning with electrons in atoms as waves. The discussion of electrons as waves then leads to a description of semiconductors as single crystals. The theory of single-crystal semiconductors is then used to describe how diodes and solar cells work. A discussion of the effects of various defects in semiconductor materials on solar cell performance follows. The reader will see that the performances enumerated are consistent with the simple concepts presented. This chapter explains why high-efficiency cells require good single-crystal materials. In the last section, it was noted that the sun’s rays are really electromagnetic waves with varying wavelengths. Electromagnetic radiation includes radio waves, microwaves, and infrared, visible, and ultraviolet waves. When one thinks about longer wavelength radiation like radio waves, one always thinks about waves. However, for the shorter wavelengths associated with infrared and visible light, physicists start to talk about photons. A photon is like a particle or wavelet having a specific wavelength and energy. A photon is a quantum of energy or discrete packet of energy. Now, is radiation a wave or a particle? The answer is both! This is the wave–particle duality, a subject called quantum mechanics [3], a subject normally taught in graduate school physics classes along with a lot of mathematics. However, the key ideas can actually be described in simple nonmathematical terms, and these ideas are important to the understanding of solar cells. While electromagnetic radiation is normally thought of as waves, one generally thinks of electrons as particles circling an atomic nucleus just as planets circle the sun. However, an atom is really extremely small, so small that in crossing a human hair, one will pass by 200,000 atoms. Intuition based on everyday experience fails at this small size. It turns out that electrons around atomic nuclei are described by wave functions. Here is the wave–particle duality again. However, the rules that govern electrons in atoms and solids can be described in fairly simple terms. In Figure 3.4, start with the simple hydrogen atom [4, 5] with a single negatively charged electron and a single positively
48
SOLAR CELLS, SINGLE-CRYSTAL SEMICONDUCTORS
Nucleus
D Px, Py, Pz
4103 A 4342 A 4563 A
S
E X
6565 A
Figure 3.4. Left: potential well for an electron around the nucleus in an atom with energy level S, P, and D wave functions. Right: a spectral line sequence for hydrogen.
charged proton. The oppositely charged proton and electron attract each other and as they get closer and closer to each other, it is harder and harder to pull them apart. The electron is said to be in an energy well or a potential well as shown on the left of Figure 3.4. The question then is can the electron collapse down and sit on the proton? The answer is no. Why not? Scientists have observed the electromagnetic spectra emitted by atoms and find discrete wavelengths and energies as shown on the right in Figure 3.4. Not all energies are possible. How is this explained? Scientists hypothesize that the electron position is described by a wave function that then gives its probable position. Since one knows that the electron cannot be outside the potential well, one knows the wave functions have to be zero outside the well. Now, observe that the waves will have to have one, two, and three nodes as is shown in the wells at the left in Figure 3.4. For historical reasons, the state with one peak node is labeled S, and the states with two nodes are labeled Px, Py, and Pz. (x, y, and z are the three directions in three-dimensional space.) The next rule is that electrons can have positive and negative spins, and only one electron can occupy each state. So there will be two S states with opposite spins and two Px, two Py, and two Pz states for a total of eight state configurations possible. This wave hypothesis has proven to be very successful as it explains atomic spectra and the periodic table of the elements [6] and all of chemistry. The rule of eight including S and P orbits explains the second and third rows of the periodic table. Table 3.1 summarizes important features of the periodic table including the common commercial semiconductor materials. The D level transition metals are not shown since they are not relevant here. Compounds are formed from the elements in the periodic table. For example, table salt is a compound containing Na (sodium) and Cl (chlorine) and is written as NaCl. The two semiconductor
SEMICONDUCTORS AS CRYSTALS AND THE WAVE THEORY
49
TABLE 3.1. Periodic Table of the Elements I
II
III
IV
V
VI
VII
H Hydrogen
VIII He Helium
Li Lithium
Be Berilium
B Boron
C Carbon
N Nitrogen
O Oxygen
F Fluorine
Ne Neon
Na Sodium
Mg Magnesium
Al Aluminum
Si Silicon
P Phosphorus
S Sulfur
Cl Chlorine
Ar Argon
Ga Gallium
Ge Germanium
As Arsenic
In Indium
Sb Antimony
compounds making up the two color solar cell stack described in Figure 3.3 are gallium arsenide (GaAs) and gallium antimonide (GaSb).
3.4 SEMICONDUCTORS AS CRYSTALS AND THE WAVE THEORY Why is it important to know about electrons as waves? The answer is that waves are intrinsically periodic as are the atom locations in single crystals. It is this periodicity that makes semiconductors special. Historically, the semiconductor revolution started 80 years ago with the discovery of the importance of high-purity single crystals and the wave theory of solids. The first application of the electron wave theory was by A. Sommerfeld in 1928 [7]. As shown in Figure 3.5a, he described the motion of electrons in metals by assuming the electrons moved in a flat-bottom energy well bounded by the metal surfaces. Any wavelength would be possible, leading to a set of conduction band energy levels. The real breakthrough came in 1928 with F. Bloch [8], who then modeled a periodic single crystal with a set of periodic energy wells representing the atom positions within the larger energy well as shown in Figure 3.5b. He showed that there are then two or more energy bands separated by energy gaps. The states with wave functions centered on the atomic wells represent valence electrons, and the states with wave functions centered between the atomic wells represent conduction band electrons. A key point is that any electron can be near any atom in the crystal. A. H. Wilson [9] in 1931 then provided the elementary theory of semiconductors by noting that if the material is pure enough and if the valence band is completely full and the conduction band is completely empty, then one has a semiconductor. An intrinsic semiconductor is defined as having zero conductivity at zero temperature with increasing conductivity as the temperature increases. The increasing conductivity comes about as electrons are thermally excited into the conduction band. This is opposite from metals where the number of conduction
50
SOLAR CELLS, SINGLE-CRYSTAL SEMICONDUCTORS
Ec (a) Metal
Ec Ev (b) Semlconductor
Figure 3.5. Solid potential energy and energy band models for metal and semiconductor.
band electrons is fixed and collision frequency increases with temperature decreasing electrical conductivity as the temperature increases. A key point here is that there is an energy gap between the valence band and the conduction band and that this energy gap derives from the periodicity, which derives from the single crystal. This history is fascinating. However, the goal here is to explain the reasons why single crystals are important to solar cells and to probe the question of how pure and how perfect solar cell materials need to be. Most importantly, how can solar cells be integrated into systems to generate electricity on a large scale at a competitive price? Before describing semiconductors in more detail, let us return to the periodic table and contrast the semiconductors with metals and insulators to see why semiconductors are special and why they are needed to make solar cells. To preview the answer, note that in order to deliver electric power, a solar cell needs to generate both current and voltage. Generating current requires electron mobility and generating voltage requires a gap between electron energy states. Metals have electron mobility and insulators have gaps between energy states, but only semiconductors have both. The metals like sodium and magnesium are on the left in the periodic table. These atoms have only a few loosely bound electrons each, and they can be tightly packed with up to 12 nearest neighbors. Because the atoms are closely packed, the potential energy well for a metal looks like a flat-bottom well with the well extending to its surfaces. As shown in Figure 3.5a, the metal surfaces form the energy barriers confining the electrons. Because this well is so large compared to one atom, all electron wave function wavelengths and energies are possible. Electrons are then free to move around in the metal, but there are no energy gaps between energy states. Since the electrons hardly feel the metal atom core positions with the flat-bottom potential well, crystallinity is not important to metallic properties.
SEMICONDUCTORS AS CRYSTALS AND THE WAVE THEORY
51
The elements at the right of the periodic table like oxygen and chlorine have tightly bound electrons and are hungry to grab more. They readily form ionic compounds like salt (sodium chloride) and glass (silicon dioxide). The energy levels in these compounds are much like those of atoms in that the electrons only are excited between atomic energy states. There are gaps in energy, but the electrons are not mobile. Crystallinity is not very important since electrons are localized on ions. This brings us to the group IV elements like silicon. The structure of silicon in a silicon crystal is shown in Figure 3.6. Silicon has four electrons and forms four tetrahedral bonds as shown. Looking at a row of silicon atoms along the diagonal in a silicon crystal, note the alternating bonded and nonbonded spaces between silicon atoms. The energy potential well profile for this row is shown in the middle of this figure along with two wave patterns, one drawn as a solid line and one drawn as a dashed line. The peaks in the solid line wave pattern localize the electrons in the bonded regions with lower-average energy potential. Meanwhile, the peaks in the dashed line wave pattern are localized in the nonbonded regions with higher-average energy. However, both waves allow the electrons to be near any silicon pair in the crystal, implying electron mobility throughout the crystal. Because of the periodic nature of the atomic positions in a single crystal, the wave functions allowed describing the electrons in a single crystal must have a
E
Eg
c v
Eg
c v
E x Si
Si
Si
Si
Si
Si
Si
E
E x As
Ga
As
Ga
As
Ga
As
Ga
Figure 3.6. Top: tetrahedrally bonded silicon atoms in groups along cube diagonal in silicon crystal showing alternate bonded and nonbonded pairs. Middle: energy potential for top atom sequence with valence band bonding wave function as solid line and conduction band antibonding wave function as dashed line. Bottom: the potential and wave functions for a GaAs crystal.
52
SOLAR CELLS, SINGLE-CRYSTAL SEMICONDUCTORS
corresponding wavelength. Thus, the two types of states with bonding and antibonding electron locations between nearest silicon pairs or farthest silicon pairs are the only states allowed. There is an energy gap between these states because no other electron wave functions are allowed. The states representing the bonding states form what is called the valence band and the states representing the antibonding states form what is called the conduction band. Figure 3.6 also shows the energy potential and wave functions for a group III–V semiconductor. The III–V semiconductors are the materials used to make LEDs. In this case, a group III element like gallium can form tetrahedral bonds with a group V element like arsenic where the result is the sharing of four electrons per atom as in silicon. Group III–V is a rich class of semiconductors. It turns out that because of the crystal periodicity, there is both energy gap and electron mobility in semiconductors. Figure 3.7 allows one to visualize this more easily. In this figure, both connected bonded regions and open channels in between can be seen. One can imagine electrons traveling in the bonded regions or separately in more energetic states in the open channels. Propagating electrons in the bonded region have energies in a valence band, and propagating electrons in the open channels have energies in a conduction band. The separation between these regions provides the energy gap. Looking at Figure 3.7, one can also imagine a large foreign atom or a crystal boundary or defect interfering with flow in the channels or a total disruption of the channels smearing the two sets of energy states into each other.
Figure 3.7. A view of a channel open for conduction electron movement in a GaAs single crystal. Small sphere: gallium atom; large sphere: arsenic atom; white cylinders: valence bonds.
JUNCTIONS AND DIODES
53
Figure 3.7 suggests intuitively that electrons will have higher mobility in single crystals than in amorphous or small crystal size thin films. This is in fact true quantitatively. Electron mobility is easily and routinely measured. The electron mobility in single-crystal silicon is typically 1500 cm2/Vs, and in single-crystal GaAs, it is 4500 cm2/Vs. However, in amorphous silicon and copper indium diselenide (CIS), two common thin-film solar cell materials, it is only 4 cm2/Vs. This is a difference by a factor of 1000 consistent with our intuitive expectations based on Figure 3.7.
3.5
JUNCTIONS AND DIODES
It has now been established that carriers are mobile, allowing current to flow in solar cells. How does one use an energy gap to create voltage? A P/N junction (P = positive, N = negative) is needed. In the above description of electron movement in semiconductors, one now needs to note that it is important to count electrons. If the semiconductor is very pure (a state called intrinsic), then all of the bonding states will be occupied by electrons and there will be no electrons to move in the conduction band. Electrons cannot move in the valence band either because there are no empty spaces to move to. Substituting a small number of phosphorus atoms for silicon atoms can rectify this problem (one in a million). Since phosphorus is from group V, it has one more electron than silicon. The resultant material is labeled N-type because the extra electrons are negatively charged. Alternately, as a complement to the N-type material, one can substitute an aluminum atom for a silicon atom leaving the bonding or valence band one electron deficient because aluminum from group III has one less electron than a silicon atom. Now instead of thinking about a million electrons in the valence band, we talk about the missing electrons in the valence band. We call this a hole. It is like watching a bubble move in water. The hole has a positive charge and we call this material P-type. Now what happens when N- and P-type materials are brought together? The result is a P/N junction diode [10–12] as shown in Figure 3.8. The band edge diagrams at the bottom of this figure describe how a diode works. When the P and N regions first come together, the electrons and holes from each side diffuse together, eliminating each other, leaving an electric field region in the junction. This happens until the valence band edge (v) in the P material almost lines up with the conduction band edge (c) in the N material as shown on the left in this figure. At this point, the free electrons and holes on both sides of the junction have the same energy as shown by the dashed horizontal line. This is the zero voltage band diagram (Fig. 3.8A). Now notice that there is an energy hill for electrons to climb in order to move from the N to the P side of the junction. An applied voltage can either decrease this hill or energy barrier for forward bias (Fig. 3.8B) or increase it in reverse bias (Fig. 3.8C). If the hill is made small enough by a forward voltage about equal to two-thirds (67%) of the bandgap energy, Eg, then current starts to
SOLAR CELLS, SINGLE-CRYSTAL SEMICONDUCTORS
Current (Amps)
54
Current PN y
z
x
c Eg v E
c
P v
x (a) Zero voltage
c Eg v
(A)
(C)
Voltage (V)
Forward current
c Eg v
Metal Contacts
N
(B)
P
Electron c Applied N voltage v
P
N
c v
(b) Forward voltage
(c) Reverse voltage
Figure 3.8. Upper left: P/N junction diode; upper right: current versus voltage for P/N diode; lower left (A): conduction band minimum and valence band maximum positions through P/N junction at zero applied voltage. Lower middle (B): forward voltage band diagram—reduced barrier for high current flow. Lower right (C): reverse voltage—barrier blocks current flow.
flow. This corresponds to the knee in the diode current versus voltage curve shown at the top right in this figure. In reverse bias, no current flows because the barrier just gets bigger. Thus, a diode is a rectifier allowing current flow in only one direction.
3.6
SOLAR CELL BAND DIAGRAMS AND POWER CURVES
Referring now to Figure 3.9, a solar cell is just a large P/N junction diode with a metal grid on its front side facing the sun. A solar cell converts the energy in sunrays to electric power. Now we shall refer to the sunrays as photons. In Figure 3.9, the now familiar band edge diagrams are shown at the bottom. These band edge diagrams show how a solar cell works. First, a photon is absorbed exciting an electron from the ground state or valence band in the P material to an excited conduction band state. It is mobile in the conduction band and if it lives long enough in this excited state, it can diffuse to the junction and fall down the potential barrier. Another way of thinking about this potential barrier is simply that it represents an electric field region created by the initial separation of electron and holes when the junction was formed. Anyway, when an electron enters a field region, it gains electrical energy. This can be converted to a voltage and current to do work.
HIGH-EFFICIENCY AND MULTIJUNCTION SOLAR CELLS
Sun ray Current (Amps)
Voltage (V)
P N
x
N
c c
P
E x
Max power point
Light generated current Forward dark current
c
v
Voc
Isc
Light generated current Eg
55
Eg
N
Voc
v v
Short circuit current (Isc) at zero voltage
P Open circuit voltage (Voc) at zero current
Figure 3.9. Upper left: P/N junction solar cell with metal grid on top. Lower left: photon absorption excites electron into conduction band. Electron then falls through junction potential. Upper and lower right: current versus voltage curve for solar cell is diode I versus V curve moved down by light-generated current.
3.7
HIGH-EFFICIENCY AND MULTIJUNCTION SOLAR CELLS
How efficient can a solar cell be and how do we achieve these high efficiencies? Theoretically, a solar cell efficiency of 70% is possible. However, no one believes that, in practice, this can be achieved. Still, a 35% efficient solar cell has been demonstrated and 45% is probably an achievable target. What needs to be done to achieve high efficiencies is a more interesting question. In fundamental terms, three things need to be done. First, for each photon absorbed, the excited state carrier generated needs to last long enough to be collected at the junction. Second, while the sun’s spectrum contains photons of different energies, the energy available in each photon must be used as wisely as possible. And third, the voltage a cell generates should be as close as possible to the bandgap energy. We will discuss each of these requirements in succession in the following paragraphs. The first requirement of one electron collected for every photon absorbed implies single-crystal material and high-purity material. The measure of electrons collected per photon absorbed is called quantum efficiency. Figure 3.10 provides a semiquantitative answer to the semiconductor purity question. To understand Figure 3.10, let us go back to the crystal channels shown in Figure 3.7. First, how far will an electron move through one of these crystal channels? The answer is about 100 atomic spaces. This is because the atoms are not really stationary but
56
SOLAR CELLS, SINGLE-CRYSTAL SEMICONDUCTORS
Random walk
Light absorption
Junction
Figure 3.10. A light-generated carrier diffuses to the junction in a random walk sequence.
are vibrating small distances around their home positions because they have thermal (heat) energy. This vibration energy is small, however, so that the excited electron does not return to the valence band but just gets deflected into another channel. We think of this deflection as a step in a random walk diffusion problem. This brings us back to Figure 3.10. The next question is how far is the excited-state electron away from the junction? This depends on the photon absorption distance. This absorption distance depends on the material and on the rules for photon absorption. Now we shall divert for a minute to the rules for photon absorption. This will be important because, as we will see, silicon is fundamentally different from the III–V semiconductors in its photoelectric properties. Looking back to the hydrogen atom in Figure 3.4, a rule for photon absorption is that the wave functions involved have to have different symmetries. For example, note that the S and D wave functions are symmetric around the position of the nucleus, while the P functions are antisymmetric. Thus, absorption between S to P and P to D are allowed, but S to D is not allowed. Now let us look at the wave functions for silicon and GaAs in Figure 3.6. Note that both wave functions for silicon are symmetric around the point between two silicon atoms. This means that photon absorption in silicon is not allowed to first order. In GaAs, however, photon absorption is allowed. So the photon absorption length in GaAs is about 10,000 atomic spaces. In reality, photons are also absorbed in silicon but in about 100,000 atomic spaces. This second-order absorption in silicon results because of atomic thermal vibrations. Now, returning to the purity question and the random walk diffusion problem, remember that a step length is about 100 atomic spaces. So a carrier in GaAs will
HIGH-EFFICIENCY AND MULTIJUNCTION SOLAR CELLS
57
be about 100 steps away from the junction, and a carrier in silicon will be about 1000 steps away. However, in a random walk problem, the number of steps required to move N steps away from the start is N × N steps. So, the distance an excited electron must travel to the junction in GaAs will be 10,000 steps or one million atomic spaces. If it were to see a large impurity in a channel on this path, it could return to the valence band and be lost. So the purity requirement for GaAs is about 1 ppm. The analogous argument for silicon suggests a purity requirement of 10 ppb. This is 1/100,000,000. In fact, silicon solar cells lose performance given transition metal impurities in the range of several parts per billion. The above argument has been a little tedious, but the goal is to impress the reader with this purity requirement. By analogy, it should also be clear that good single-crystal quality without defects is as important as purity. The above purity specification is routinely met in commercial single-crystal silicon solar cells today as well as in various other single-crystal silicon-based devices that have revolutionized our lives over the last 50 years. While the reader is probably not aware of it, various single-crystal III–V devices have penetrated our everyday lives as well in the last 10 years. As the above argument about the difference in photon absorption for GaAs versus silicon suggests, III–V are often a better choice for photoelectric and optical-electronic applications. Referring to the periodic table, there are a large number of III–V materials available including GaAs, InP, InSb, and GaSb. Additionally, alloys of these materials are available including AlGaAs, GaAsP, GaInAs, InGaP, and InGaAsP. This makes a large set of bandgaps and electron mobilities available. Single-crystal III–V devices can now be found in cell phones, satellite receivers, CD music players, CD-ROMs in personal computers, taillights in cars, traffic stoplights, and military weapon systems. Single-crystal III–V devices are also key components in fiber optic phone communication and the Internet. In fact, the most efficient solar cells are made using III–V materials. This brings us back to our second requirement for making high-efficiency solar cells. We need to use the energy in the sun’s varied colored rays as efficiently as possible. A problem with sunlight is that the photons come in different colors with different associated energies. If we wanted to maximize the efficiency of a photodiode, we would illuminate it with only photons with a single energy with an energy equal to the bandgap energy Eg. Then, if the crystal quality and purity were sufficient, all of the excited carriers would be collected at the junction with 67% of the photon energy being delivered as a voltage. The energy conversion efficiency would be roughly 67%. However, referring to Figure 3.2, photons from the sun come with different energies. Some of the photons have too little energy to be absorbed, and some of the photons have energy considerable in excess of the bandgap energy. For the sun’s spectrum, this limits the single-junction solar cell efficiency to less than 30%. Fortunately, group III–V offers a solution because various materials with various bandgap energies are available. Specifically, one can stack a visible light-sensitive GaAs solar cell with metal grids on its front and back on an infrared-sensitive GaSb solar cell to arrive at the two-color or two-junction solar cell shown at the right in
58
SOLAR CELLS, SINGLE-CRYSTAL SEMICONDUCTORS
Figure 3.11. In this way, one absorbs the high-energy photons first in the top material generating a high voltage, while the low-energy photons pass through the top cell to be converted in the bottom cell. More photons are used and they are used more wisely. This then is the 35% efficient GaAs/GaSb two-color or two-junction solar cell demonstrated by L. Fraas et al. in 1989 [2].
Silicon Eg=1.1 eV
Ga Sb Eg=0.7 eV
Ga As Eg=1.4 eV
Figure 3.11. Left: for single-junction solar cell, sunlight contains high-energy photons with excess energy and low-energy photons with too little energy. Right: solar spectrum can be more efficiently utilized by stacking two different junctions together. Three junction cell
First Second Third
n+ n p p++ n n p+ p+ n n
Window InGaP GaInAs
Ge
p
From p. 888 (at 300 suns AM1.5) 13.3 mA/cm2 x Vop η = --------------------------------84 mW/ cm2 Vop= 2.55 V Efficiency = 40%
Active solar cell junction Shorting tunnel interconnect
Figure 3.12. Monolithic triple-junction InGaP/GaInAs/Ge CPV cell as first described by L. Fraas and R. Kinechtli in the 13th IEEE PV Specialist Conference, predicting 40% at 300 suns AM1.5 [13].
PV MODULE AND SYSTEM COST TRADES
59
Concentrating lens
Solar Cell Heat spreader back plane
Light Generated Current (Amps)
Sun light Sunlight concentrated
Sunlight not concentrated
Voltage (V)
Figure 3.13. Solar cells are more efficient with concentrated sunlight because both current and voltage increase.
As first predicted in 1978 [13], an efficiency of 40% has recently been demonstrated [14] for the monolithic three-junction InGaP/GaInAs/Ge CPV cell as shown in Figure 3.12. This brings us to the third way of increasing solar cell efficiency. For a given bandgap energy, we want to generate more voltage. Concentrating the sunlight onto the cell can do this. This is shown in Figure 3.13. Sunlight can be concentrated using a lens as is shown at the left in this figure. The resulting currents versus voltage curves with and without a lens are shown at the right. As is customary for solar cells, the diode curves here have been flipped over. Note that the higher current concentrator cell has a higher efficiency. This is because the diode is being driven harder to a higher current and voltage. In other words, if the light level goes up by 10, the current also goes up by 10 but at the same time, the voltage also goes up. In practice, the open-circuit voltage can go up from about two-thirds of Eg to about three-quarters of Eg under concentrated sunlight.
3.8
PV MODULE AND SYSTEM COST TRADES
So it is clear that single-crystal cells have higher efficiencies than amorphous or small grain size thin-film cells and that multijunction cells have still higher efficiencies. However, single-crystal cells are more expensive than thin-film cells and multijunction cells are very complex. It is also clear that CPV systems see only direct sunlight, which is less than global sunlight. So, it is necessary to look at the cost of complete PV systems. This is shown in Table 3.2. Note that the attached table has five columns comparing system-level costs measured in terms of simple payback times. The columns summarize future (ca.
60
TABLE 3.2. Comparison of Future Economics for Planar PV and Concentrated Solar PV Module Type
Thin Film
SC Silicon
LCPV
HCPV
HCPV JXC
Cell Efficiency @ temperature
9%
19%
22%
35%
44%
Annual available irradiancea
2336 kWh/m2 (fixed tilt)
2905 kWh/m2 (tracking 1-axis)
2382 kWh/m2 (1-axis; 87% global; 94% optical efficiency)
2178 kWh/m2 (2-axis; DNI = 78% global; 85% optical efficiency)
2178 kWh/m2 (2-axis; DNI = 78% global; 85% optical efficiency)
Annual kWh/m2 electricity
210 kWh/m2
552 kWh/m2
524 kWh/m2
762 kWh/m2
936 kWh/m2
Dirt penalty
–5% = >200 kWh/m2 –5% = >525 kWh/m2
–7% = >488 kWh/m2
–9% = >695 kWh/m2
–9% = >852 kWh/m2
Annual revenue at 10¢/kWh
$20/m2
$52.5/m2
$48.8/m2
$69.5/m2
$82/m2
Cell cost per m2 module
$50/m2
$300/m2
$100/m2
$100/m2
$137/m2
Module materialb
$50/m2
$60/m2
$67/m2
$67/m2
$67/m2
Optics
0
0
$57/m2
$65/m2
$65/m2
Module cost
$100/m2 ($1.11/W)
$224/m2 ($1.20/W)
$232/m2 ($0.92/W)
$360/m2 ($1.89/W)
$75/m (1-axis)
$150/m (2-axis rigid)
$150/m2 (2-axis rigid)
$25/m2
$25/m2
$25/m2
$40/m2
$40/m2
$160/m2
$460/m2
$324/m2
$422/m2
$459/m2
$35/m
Installation Total module area cost
2
2
2
$269/m2 ($0.85/W)
$75/m (1-axis)
Array support structure
2
Module Type
Thin Film
SC Silicon
LCPV
HCPV
HCPV JXC
Module system costc
$1.78/W
$2.42/W
$1.74/W
$1.67/W
$1.44/W
System with inverter at $0.3/Wd
$27/m2 $2.08/W
$57/m2 $2.72/W
$56/m2 $2.04/W
$76/m2 $1.97/W
$96/m2 $1.74/W
System payback time at $0.1/kWhd
9.4 years
9.8 years
7.8 years
7.2 years
6.8 years
a
Las Vegas. Glass, frame, Wire, J-box, etc. Without inverter cost. An explanation of the assumed peak power rating is required. For the two planar cases, this is straightforward. The efficiencies listed should be interpreted as future projected module efficiency at operating temperature. In this case, the Wp rating assumes 1 kW/m2 global illumination. So, the module peak W power ratings are 90 W/m2 for the thin-film case and 190 W/m2 for the single-crystal silicon case. For the HCPV cases, the efficiencies listed should be interpreted as future projected cell efficiency at operating temperature. However, the Wp rating now assumes 850 W/m2 of direct illumination (DNI) and 85% optical efficiency. So, for the 35% HCPV column, the module peak W power rating is 253 W/m2 and for the 44% column, the module peak W power rating is 318 W/m2. For the LCPV case, there is no standard. However, since the 3-sun sees DNI plus one-third of diffuse, the logical standard to be consistent with the other two would be to assume 90% of global illumination or 900 W/m2. In the table, a 3-sun module rating of 220 × 0.9 × 0.94 = 186 W/m2 is assumed. d Including inverter cost. From above, given that the inverter size for the system is set by the system peak power rating, one can calculate inverter cost per square meter. For the thin-film column, this is $27 per square meter; for the Si column, this is $57 per square meter; for 35%, this is $76 per square meter; for 44%, this is $96 per square meter; for LCPV, this is $56 per square meter. b c
61
62
SOLAR CELLS, SINGLE-CRYSTAL SEMICONDUCTORS
2015) projected system costs for thin-film PV systems, single-crystal silicon flatplate systems, a JX Crystals 3-sun LCPV evolutionary system, an HCPV system using today’s 35% multijunction cells, and a JX Crystals HCPV Dual-Focus Cassegrainian system using a 44% efficient cell combination. These systems will be described in more technical detail in Chapters 12–17. Each column lists projected module outputs in annual kilowatt hour per square meter for Las Vegas, and each column summarizes projected system-level area-related costs in dollar per square meter. These costs include not just module cost but also support structure and installation costs. Given annual projected energy outputs and total area-related costs, it is then possible to calculate a simple system payback time given an assumed energy value of 10 ¢ per kilowatt hour. The good news is that all five columns for all PV technologies promise a simple payback time of less than 10 years. These systems should last for over 20 years. The first column is for the thin-film PV case. This case suffers from a low cell efficiency of 9%. Module costs are assumed to be those stated by First Solar and other thin-film PV companies of only $1.11 per watt. However, even given these low module level costs, because of the low cell efficiencies and lower-energy production per square meter, it takes a long time to pay off the cost of the array support structures and system installation. The projected simple payback time is 9.4 years. The second column is for the conventional single-crystal silicon planar module case. Here, the good news is the 19% cell efficiency, which then leads to 2.5 times more annual energy production per square meter of module area compared to the thin-film case. Simple one-axis tracking is one of the benefits here, giving more kilowatt hour per kilowatt installed. Trackers, unfortunately, are not affordable for the thin-film PV case. However, the cell cost is much higher than the thin-film case. Note that the cell cost assumed here is a future projection of $1.58 per watt. Given a higher-energy output, the field-related area costs are paid off faster than for the thin-film PV case, and the simple payback time works out to be 9.8 years. The third column is for an evolutionary LCPV case as will be described in Chapter 12. This case assumes the same 1-sun single-crystal cells and module manufacturing process as for the second column case. The three changes are the cut-up of the 1-sun single-crystal cells into thirds, the addition of low-cost linear mirrors, and the addition of a thin aluminum sheet heat spreader at the back of the laminated standard module. This approach has already been demonstrated in the field. The immediate benefit here is low risk, straightforward manufacturing, and a reduction of the cell cost by a factor of 3. Additional benefits are the ability to utilize more than just direct sunlight on less than perfect sunny days and higher optical throughput. The same simple one-axis trackers can be used as for the planar silicon module case. The reduction of the cell cost relative to column 2 with no additional penalties leads to a lower simple payback time of 7.8 years. The fourth column is for the HCPV case using today’s 35% multijunction cells. Here, of course, the 35% cell efficiency is spectacular. However, there are some negatives. One negative is that these HCPV systems only see direct sunlight
THE IMPORTANCE OF SINGLE CRYSTALS
63
(DNI) and not global illumination. While DNI can be as high as 90% of global illumination on the best blue-sky day, on an annual average even in Las Vegas or in Phoenix, it is only 78% of global illumination. A typical optical throughput of 85% for HCPV is also a negative. These two negatives make a 0.85 × 0.78 × 35% = 23% silicon planar cell competitive. However, the hoped-for good news for the HCPV approach is a lower module cost because of the cheaper optical materials relative to the high-efficiency single-crystal solar cells. If the low-cost modules ($0.92 per watt assumed here) and if the low-cost precision tracking ($150 per square meter assumed here) can be demonstrated in high-volume production, then this system will beat the planar system in sunny locations with a simple payback time of 7.2 years. However, this approach is more risky and will take longer to build up the manufacturing infrastructure than for the LCPV case. In the still longer term, column 5 presents an even higher-efficiency HCPV approach as will be described in Chapter 15. This approach uses a recently announced improved triple-junction monolithic cell (39% efficient) at the focus in the center of a Cassegrain optical configuration. A second infrared cell is also used behind a secondary mirror with a dichroic coating allowing the infrared to get to the second cell. The second GaSb infrared cell adds an addition 5% to give a cell combination efficiency of 44%. The GaSb cell, which is a diffused junction cell [16], is relatively inexpensive to make. Even with the cost of this second cell, its added efficiency leverages down all of the system cost to give an even more attractive payback time of 6.8 years. This approach, while all of the separate components have already been demonstrated, will require a lot of time and money to bring into high-volume production.
3.9
THE IMPORTANCE OF SINGLE CRYSTALS
From the above discussion of system-level cost trades, why have CPV systems not received more attention and why have thin film systems received so much attention? One answer is that searching for a 20% efficient low-cost thin-film solar cell is a very attractive dream. However, in this chapter, we have talked about electrons as waves and semiconductors as crystals to convey the message that this dream is not well founded on scientific principles. In fact, in graduate school solid-state physics classes, the bandgap in semiconductors is rigorously derived based on the assumption of the perfect periodic single-crystal lattice. However, the importance of single crystals to semiconductor devices is not generally conveyed in a simple understandable way. It is certainly not knowledge available to funding sources or the financial community. Figure 3.14 is an attempt to rectify this situation by making an analogy between an electron traveling in a solid and a car traveling through a forest. Organizing the atoms in single crystals is like removing the trees to make a road through a forest. Atoms out of place or atomic impurities are obstacles for the electron just like trees are obstacles for a car. Collisions with these obstacles force the electron (or the car) to lose energy. Efficiency is dramatically reduced.
64
SOLAR CELLS, SINGLE-CRYSTAL SEMICONDUCTORS
Figure 3.14. Single-crystal versus thin-film solar cells. Organizing the atoms in single crystals is like removing the trees to make a road through a forest. Atoms out of place or atomic impurities are obstacles for the electron just like trees are obstacles for a car. Collisions with these obstacles force the electron (or the car) to lose energy. If you were a car driving through the national forest, or an electron passing through a solar cell, which path would you rather take?
In any case, after 25 years of effort on thin-film solar cells, their module efficiencies are still low and they have not penetrated the mainstream electric power marketplace. Concentrator solar cells have not entered the marketplace yet in high volume either. There are several reasons for this, but it is not for lack of performance. The technology for solar concentrators is well founded on established scientific and engineering principles. One of the problems for concentrators is that a larger investment is required for hardware like lenses and trackers as well as for new solar cell manufacturing facilities. It is time for a serious top-level funding commitment. The technology is ready.
REFERENCES
65
ABBREVIATIONS AM1.5—1 and ½ Air-Mass (see Chapter 19) CPV—concentration photovoltaic DNI—direct normal incident sunlight E—electric field Eg—bandgap energy GaAs—gallium arsenide GaSb—gallium antimonide Group III–V—compounds consisting of group III and group V elements from the periodic table (LED semiconductor compounds) HCPV—high-concentration photovoltaic LCPV—low-concentration photovoltaic LED—light-emitting diode P/N junction—positive/negative junction PV—photovoltaic or solar cell QE—quantum efficiency (the number of electrons collected per incident photon) λ—wavelength
REFERENCES [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13]
A. Einstein. On the quantum theory of radiation. Phyikalische Zeitschrift 18, 121 (1917). L. M. Fraas, J. Avery, J. Gee, et al. Over 35% efficient GaAs/GaSb stacked concentrator cell assemblies for terrestrial applications. In 21st IEEE PV Specialist Conference, p. 190. Kissimmee, Florida, 1990. IEEE, New York (1990). R. P. Feynman, R. B. Leighton, and M. Sands. The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Volume III—Quantum Mechanics. Reading, MA, Addison Wesley (1965). N. Bohr. Radiation Spectra and the Hydrogen Atom. Philos. Mag. 25, 10 (1913). N. Bohr. The Theory of Spectra and Atomic Constitution. Fys. Tidsskr. 19, 153 (1921); 9, 1 (1922). R. P. Feynman, R. B. Leighton, and M. Sands. The Feynman Lectures on physics. In The Hydrogen Atom and the Periodic Table, Vol. 3, Chapter 19, Reading, MA, Addison Wesley (1965). A. Sommerfeld. Z. Phys. 47, 1 (1928). F. Bloch. Z. Phys. 52, 555 (1928). A. H. Wilson. Proc. R. Soc. A 133(458), 134, 277 (1931). J. M. Ziman. Principles of the theory of solids. In Electron States, pp. 72–74. Cambridge and London, Cambridge University Press (1964). C. Kittel. Introduction to Solid State Physics. 3rd Edition. New York, John Wiley & Sons (1967). S. M. Sze. Physics of Semiconductor Devices. New York, Wiley-Interscience (1969). L. M. Fraas and R. C. Knechtli. Design of high efficiency monolithic stacked multijunction solar cells. In 13th IEEE Photovoltaic Specialist Conference, Conference Record (A79-40881 17–44), Washington, D.C., June 5–8, pp. 886–891. Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Inc., New York (1978).
66 [14] [15]
SOLAR CELLS, SINGLE-CRYSTAL SEMICONDUCTORS R. R. King, D. C. Law, K. M. Edmondson, et al. 40% efficient metamorphic GaInP/ GaInAs/Ge multijunction solar cells. Appl. Phys. Lett. 90 (18), p. 3516 (2007). L. M. Fraas, H. X. Huang, and J. E. Avery. Low cost high power GaSb photovoltaic cells. Thermophotovoltaic generation of electricity. In 3rd NREL Conference, T. Coutts, C. Allman, J. Benner, eds, p. 33. Woodbury, N.Y., AIP (1997).
4 SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS LARRY PARTAIN Varian Medical Systems
4.1 DEVELOPMENT OF QUANTUM MECHANICS AND SOLID-STATE ELECTRONICS Solar cells are likely the ultimate quantum mechanical and solid-state electronic devices. Although their behavior (photovoltaics) was observed in the early 1830s, their optimization and rapid advancement awaited the development of both these fields starting at the turn of the twentieth century. Many of these discoveries are summarized by the set of equations immediately below. The person most associated with each discovery is shown in parentheses along with the year of the discovery. Asterisks identify those advances that were awarded Nobel Prizes in physics [1, 2]. (Planck, 1900)*
E N = Nh f
(4.1)
(Einstein, 1905)*
E = hf
(4.2)
(Compton,1923)*
p = hf c
(4.3)
(De Broglie, 1923)
λ=h p
(4.4)
f ( ε ) = 1 [1 + exp {( ε − ε F kT )}]
(4.5)
(Fermi and Dirac, 1926) (Schrodinger, 1928)* (Shockley et al., 1947)*
[ − (h
2
8π m ) ∇ + V ( r )] FK ( r ) = EK FK ( r ) 2
2
ε*Fe − ε*Fh = qV and J n = qnμ n dε*Fe /dx.
(4.6) (4.7)
Equation 4.1 explained the shape of the black body light emission spectrum from hot objects including the sun. The energy at any emitted light frequency f consists Solar Cells and Their Applications, Second Edition, Edited by Lewis Fraas and Larry Partain Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
67
68
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS
of N discrete (quantized) energy packets each with a small energy content proportional to f with a proportionality constant (Planck’s constant) value of h. Equation 4.2 more definitively established that the wave phenomena of light is actually made up of discrete photons each with a quantized energy value hf that explained the experimentally observed photoelectric effect of electron emission from metal surfaces in a vacuum illuminated with monochromatic light. Equation 4.3 established that each such photon possesses a quantized momentum value, p, which accurately explains the trajectories of photon “collisions” with electrons. Strangely enough, Equation 4.4 indicates that rest mass particles like electrons also behave like waves with wavelengths λ that are inversely proportional to their momentum value, p. This is one description of the wave–particle duality. In 1913, Neil Bohr’s [3] Nobel Prize-winning work (when combined with the De Broglie result of Eq. 4.4) explained the discrete electron energy levels of hydrogen atoms have just the right sizes to accommodate integer multiples of each electron’s wavelength, λ. Thus, the hydrogen atom has allowed electronic energy states with unoccupied energy gaps between each allowed state or energy “band.” It is reasonable to expect that when atoms are brought together to form solids, their atomic discrete levels are perturbed and broadened into allowed electronic energy state bands. Equation 4.5 describes the probability that any of a material’s allowed electronic states is actually occupied by an electron, in terms of an energy variable expression containing Boltzmann’s constant k and referenced to a special energy value εF (the Fermi energy). The latter has ultimately been found to be the electron’s potential energy value [4, 5]. 4.2 FUNDAMENTALS OF SOLAR CELL OPEN-CIRCUIT VOLTAGE The density of available quantum states to “free” electrons in a semiconductor can be approximated by solving Schrodinger’s wave equation for the case of a cube of semiconductor material where the states’ potential energy, V, is zero everywhere inside the cube and is infinite everywhere outside this cube [6]. All of the allowed solutions to the wave equation are sine waves whose wave numbers K (i.e., in the x direction Φ(x) ∼ sin(Kx)) are integer multiples of π/a where a is the dimension of one side of the cube equal to the atomic spacing of the semiconductor. If one then integrates such quantized K values in three-dimensional space, using a differential volume that is normalized by the volume (π3/a3) occupied by one individual quantum state and applying the Fermi–Dirac expression for the probability that any available state is actually occupied, then one obtains the well-known expressions for the volume density of electrons n in the conduction band (and similarly the volume density of holes p in the valence band) with the respective conduction and valence energy band edges specified by εC and εV [7, 8]: n = N c e −(εC − ε F ) kT
(4.8)
p = N v e −( ε F − ε V ) kT .
(4.9)
FUNDAMENTALS OF SOLAR CELL OPEN-CIRCUIT VOLTAGE
69
Here, NC = 2Mc(2πmdekT/h2)3/2 and Nv = 2(2πmdhkT/h2)3/2. mde and mdh are the density-of-states effective masses for “free” electrons and holes, respectively, and Mc is the number of equivalent minima at the conduction band edge [8, 9]. Each hole denotes the absence of an electron in the valence band. Note that the product of n × p gives np = N C N V exp[− ( ε C − ε V ) kT = N C N V exp ( − ε G kT ) = ni2 ,
(4.10)
which only varies with the bandgap and temperature regardless of the doping levels to make the semiconductor either n or p type or alternatively to characterize its intrinsic or “i” properties if undoped. Then ni is the electron and hole density in such “i” materials. While the density states derivation is based on the periodic atomic spacing a, any dependence on this a disappears in the total mathematical calculation process. The results, at least to the first order, appear to accurately describe the properties of even amorphous semiconductor materials with distributions of atomic spacings and not just a well-defined and single constant a as long as there is an approximately defined bandgap. Equations 4.8 and 4.9 are equilibrium expressions for materials in the dark. With light exposure, both conduction band electron and valence band hole concentrations increase above their equilibrium values. Absorbed photons with enough energy “pump” valence band electrons into the conduction band, leaving behind the valence band holes. The standard assumption is that Equations 4.8 and 4.9 still apply but with two different quasi-Fermi energy values, ε*Fe for the electrons and ε*Fh for the holes instead of the single-equilibrium Fermi energy εF0. For the latter, subscript “0” is added to denote its equilibrium position. These expressions clearly show that for n to increase, ε*Fe must move away from εF0 toward the conduction band edge εC. Similarly, ε*Fh must also move away from ε*F0 for p to increase but toward the opposite valence band edge εV. Since quasi-Fermi energies correspond to potential energies, the light-exposed semiconductor populations of electrons and holes actually possess measurably different potential energy values that, according to the first Shockely expression in Equation 4.7, is a measureable voltage, V. The magnitude of this voltage is expressed as V = [ Δε LFe + Δε LFh ] q ,
(4.11)
where Δε LFe = ε*Fe − ε F0 and Δε LFh = ε*F0 − ε Fh with the superscript “L” added to denote the nonequilibrium light exposure. It is this splitting of quasi-Fermi and potential energy values of electrons and holes that is the first fundamental step in the quantum mechanical conversion of the microscopic photon energy (typically expressed in electron volts per photon) into a macroscopic DC voltage, V, which can be physically measured and used to do work. The challenge is to include properly configured semiconductor materials into a device that allows such a macroscopic physical V measurement with a standard voltmeter.
70
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS
A simple explanation of the underlying physics was presented in the First Edition (pp. 2–4 [5]). It details how concentration gradients (normalized by the total concentration value) produce forces per unit charge that are just as real as the forces that electric fields exert on such charges. Moving quantized particles through such concentration gradient force fields involves work that changes potential energies. This derivation is not repeated here.
4.3
SHOCKLEY DIODE MODEL OF SOLAR CELLS
In 1947, Shockley et al. [10] produced the Nobel Prize-winning discovery and demonstration of solid-state electronic transistors fabricated from single-crystal semiconductors with energy bandgap properties. Shockley’s breakthrough devices incorporated characteristics well summarized by the two expressions of Equation 4.7 (pp. 305–310, 463 [9]) that he used extensively in his work. The second Equation 4.7 expression also clearly implies quasi-Fermi level connections to potential energy because the gradient of the former provides a force that translates into velocity (and then to a current density, J) with a proportionality constant that is the electron mobility μn, where n is the density of conduction electrons in the semiconductor material. The energy gradient and resulting velocity prescribe how much of the starting potential energy and thus the efficiency is lost in establishing a DC terminal voltage, V, and a current flow as detailed below. Interesting enough, Shockley never clearly identified quasi-Fermi levels as measures of potential energy. However, there had long been hints of such a relationship, not the least being the Einstein relation that the ratio of diffusion coefficient to mobility is a known and calculable constant [8, 9]. In their bipolar forms, transistors consist of two back-to-back Shockley diodes. All of these quantum mechanics and solid-state electronic discoveries led directly to the detailed description of the Shockley diode solar cell behaviors and their controlling parameters needed for reproducible progress in this field. These preceding advances received a significant share of the Nobel Prizes in physics in the first half of the twentieth century, and their exploitation in the second half of the twentieth century, along with one more Noble Prize-winning discovery, has resulted in major increases in solar cell performance from ∼1% efficiency level in ∼1900 to over 40% currently. One wonders what the next century of Nobel Prizewinning discoveries may provide. In 1954, Chapin et al. [11] reported a 6% efficiency for an abrupt p/n junction diode single-crystal silicon solar cell conversion device. Seven years later, the derivation and treatment of the classic Shockley model was published by Shockley and Queisser [12] for the current–voltage properties and the efficiencies of this particular configuration. The corresponding geometry and nonequilibrium energy band structure for this type of solar cell exposed to light is shown schematically in Figure 4.1. This contact metallization partially covers its emitter to allow light entrance. A macroscopic and measureable voltage, V, is clearly indicated as being equal to
SHOCKLEY DIODE MODEL OF SOLAR CELLS Emitter
71
Base Depletion region
Light n
p tE tE'
Grid metal
tB xE
tB'
xB
Back metal x
Metal fermi level V ~ 0.6 Voc
0
xn
xP
εc
Loss δεn
Light ε ε
qV
* Fe
q(V-JR)
Dark ε
* Fh
XW
Light Loss
* Fe
ε
Dark
Metal fermi level
* Fh
δεp
εv
Figure 4.1. The Shockley diode configuration (top) and its energy band diagram (bottom) in the light.
the different majority carrier Fermi levels at opposite sides of the solar cell. A significant difference in Figure 4.1 from most earlier models is its clear identification of the Fermi energy in the metal contacts and their alignment with the majority carrier Fermi levels in the p/n junction solar cell. The assumption here as that the metal contacts do not significantly respond to the incident light so that their nonequilibrium behavior is well described just by their single-equilibrium Fermi energy values. At best, the band diagrams in Shockley’s 1950 book (fig. 12-3, p. 310 [9]) only hint at such a diagram, and his classic model publication contains no energy band diagrams [12]. However, it is metal conductors that deliver electric power to loads, and any potential energy conversion in a solar cell can only be utilized if such potential energy differences are efficiency transferred to the metal contacts. Hovel’s often quoted text only weakly relates voltage to differing Fermi levels and with no connection to metal Fermi energy levels (fig. 3, p. 9 [13]). Even though Sze’s (fig. 4, p. 794 [8]) textbook does relate the open-circuit voltage to the Fermi level split, there is no connection made to Fermi levels in the metal contacts. It is such latter levels and their alignments (or misalignments) with conduction and valence band edges that form the basis for projected significant increases (or losses) in solar cell efficiencies that is the major point of this chapter.
72
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS
The quasi-Fermi level splitting in Figure 4.1 between ε*Fe and ε*Fh gives the highest potential energy difference available from the solar cell conversion process as characterized by setting the open-circuit voltage Voc to the voltage V of Equation 4.11. For low injection conditions, where the concentrations of the light-generated carriers ΔnL = n – n0 and ΔpL = p – p0 are much greater than that of the minority carriers but are much less than that of the majority carrier concentrations, the opencircuit expression simplifies to Voc = ε G q + ( kT q ) ln [ Δ nL po ( N C N V )]
(4.12)
for the p-type side of the solar cell and to Voc = ε G q + ( kT q ) ln [ Δ pL no ( N C N V )]
(4.13)
for the n-type side of the solar cell. For high injection where ΔnL and ΔpL become larger than the majority carrier concentration, these expressions respectively become 12 Voc = ε G q + ( 2 kT q ) ln ⎡⎣ Δ nL ( N C N V ) ⎤⎦ and
(4.14)
12 Voc = ε G q + ( 2 kT q ) ln ⎡⎣ Δ pL ( N C N V ) ⎤⎦ .
(4.15)
Only significant voltages are generated if ΔnL or ΔpL >> no or po, respectively (low injection), or is greater than both (high injection). In abrupt p/n junctions with significant doping levels and low injection, this means that voltage is only really generated by minority carriers. Note the twice higher temperature coefficient of the second term in the Voc expressions for high injection versus low injection. Also note that Voc approaches the εG/q bandgap value (in all four expressions) when the temperature T approaches absolute zero [12] or when the light-generated carrier concentrations approach 1018–1019 cm−3 concentrations (depending on the density-of-states effective mass values) where the arguments in the ln functions approach values of one. It is this latter case of high light-generated carrier concentrations giving bandgap Voc values that is another major point of this chapter for significantly increasing solar cell efficiencies. Given the absorption of a photon that produces an electron–hole pair, this specific optimization minimizes the loss of energy below the bandgap. This contrasts to minimizing the losses above bandgap in the multiple bandgap devices that have recently provided efficiencies exceeding 40% (Perharz and Bett, Chapter 14; [14]). The fundamental Shockley transistor assumption implies that any minority carrier that enters the depletion region exits the other side with relatively little change in the potential energy it had on entrance. To the degree that this assumption is accurate, it provides an efficient, low-loss process for transforming minority carriers into majority ones. This conversion process from minority to majority
SHOCKLEY DIODE MODEL OF SOLAR CELLS
73
carriers is the second major step of the abrupt p/n junction solar cell energy conversion process. It is instructive to note here the most efficient step theoretically possible for converting an absorbed photon’s energy in electron volts into a DC voltage, V. This occurs when all absorbed photons’ energies hf (i.e., monochromatic photons all of a single frequency f) just exceed the bandgap energy εG, and the open-circuit voltage Voc equals the bandgap value εG/q. This would only be possible if the quasi-Fermi levels ε*Fe and ε*Fh split all the way to the band edges εC and εV. It would be a perfect quantum mechanical conversion step with no direct loss. When the energy of an absorbed photon is greater than the bandgap, its energy excess greater than the bandgap creates “hot” electrons (and/or holes) whose energies are rapidly thermalized to steady-state values near the band edge by inelastic collisions with other charged carriers and/or with semiconductor lattice vibratrions (phonons). The latter quickly convert such extra energy into heat that no longer can contribute to steady-state carrier potential energy but only to the semiconductor’s temperature increase. The third major step in the energy conversion process is the extraction of the majority carriers’ light added energy from the semiconductor and the deposition of this energy into the metal contacts whose average electron potential energy values are also specified by their respective metal Fermi energy levels indicated by the arrows in Figure 4.1. Because of semiconductor band structure, mobile electrons can only occupy electronic states whose total energy is at or above the conduction band edge εC. They thus enter the metal with offset energy δεn as a kinetic energy (hot electron) that is again quickly thermalized by scattering down to the metal’s Fermi energy level. Since only the potential energy is available at the external metal contacts, the typical way to reduce this δεn loss is to raise the electron quasi-Fermi level by moderate to heavy doping at the semiconductor’s boundary. An analogous δεp loss process also occurs for majority carrier holes at the p-type interface with its metal contact. This is likewise typically reduced by moderate to heavy doping at the semiconductor’s boundary. For the highest conversion efficiencies, both these δεn and δεp need to be simultaneously reduced to as close to zero values as possible. The second expression of Equation 4.7 indicates that a loss of potential energy is required to transport charge from one part of a device to another as described by a current density, J. The latter is a fundamental and unavoidable potential energy loss even if the conversion step to open-circuit voltage is perfect and loss free. Despite the lack of band diagram clarity, it is the one-dimensional Shockley and Queisser [12] equations, as extended by Hovel [13], and only slightly extended more in the First Edition (chapter 1 [5]), that have formed the basis for most of the successful analysis and performance improvements that have eventually and recently led to cell efficiencies exceeding 40% ([14]; Perharz and Bett, Chapter 14). These well-known derivations will not be repeated here but will only be summarized by the resulting expressions that identify key parameters. In the Shockley abrupt p/n junction model of Figure 4.1, an electrostatically charged depletion region penetrates a depth, xE, into the emitter of thickness tE and
74
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS
also penetrates a depth, xB, into the base of thickness tB. Outside the depletion region, there is no net charge, so any potential energy change, for the mobile electrons and holes there, cannot be due to an accumulation of net electrostatic charge. The majority carrier transport is simply described by the linear Ohm’s law, current–voltage relationships, specified by a single series resistance. The more important physics is contained in the nonlinear expressions (Eqs. 4.8 and 4.9) and relationships that describe the minority carrier transport, where the effects of concentration gradients are dominant. Combining the transport equations with the one-dimensional continuity equations and the standard boundary conditions, and the assumption of current dominated by minority carrier diffusion current at each edge of the depletion region [12, 13], one obtains the standard Shockley diode equations for current density J versus voltage V in an abrupt n/p junction solar cell as J = J 0 {exp [ q (V − JR ) kT ] − 1} − J L ,
(4.16)
V = ( kT q ) ln [( J J 0 ) + ( J L J 0 ) + 1] + JR,
(4.17)
or solving for V,
where Jo = (Joh + Joe) and J oh = q ( ni2 N D ) vdh f h and J oe = q ( ni2 N A ) vde f e and the light-generated current JL is ∞
J L = ∫0 qF ( λ ) [1 − r ( λ )] QE ( λ ) dλ.
(4.18)
Here, fh and fe are hyperbolic functions of the surface or interface recombination velocities, the diffusion velocities, the diffusion lengths, and the undepleted n and p layer thicknesses specified in the First Edition [5]. The R = RA is the specific series resistance, where R is the actual series resistance in ohms describing majority carrier transport and A is the cross-sectional area of the device. The ND and NA are the respective donor and acceptor doping concentrations of the emitter and base. The F(λ) is the photon flux density of light of wavelength λ, r(λ) is the light reflectivity of the emitter surface at λ, and QE(λ) is the quantum efficiency of the solar cell at the indicated wavelength. The open-circuit voltage Voc comes from setting J = 0 in Equation 4.17 to give Voc = ( kT q ) ln [( J L J 0 ) + 1] ,
(4.19)
which is equivalent to Equations 4.12 and 4.13’s low injection expressions applied to the boundaries of the depletion region. The short-circuit current density Jsc (where V = 0) is given from Equation 4.16 by the transcendental expression J sc − J 0 [ exp ( − qRJ sc kT ) − 1] = − J L .
(4.20)
SHOCKLEY DIODE MODEL OF SOLAR CELLS
75
If R is known, the light J–V characteristics are uniquely determined when any two of the three coefficients JL(∼ –Jsc), Jo, or Voc are known. Equation 4.19 gives the third when the other two are specified. The power density is the JV product (=J{[KT/q] In[(J/Jo) + (J/JL) + 1] + JR}) from Equation 4.17 that is maximum when the d(JV)/dJ = 0, at a maximum power current density Jm and voltage Vm. This Jm is negative, with a magnitude slightly less than JL (as shown in Fig. 4.2), and it is specified by the transcendental expression ln [( J L + J m + J 0 ) J 0 ] = − J m ( J L + J m + J 0 ) − 2qRJ m kT .
(4.21)
Substituting this Jm back into Equation 4.17 then gives Vm. The efficiency of the cell η is given by 2
1
0
Voc
J (A/cm2)
–1
–2 JL –3
R = 0.3 Ω-cm2 0.22
–4 0.0091
Jsc
0.15
–5
–6 –1
–0.5
0
0
0.06
0.5
1
1.5
2
V (V)
Figure 4.2. The light and dark J–V characteristics calculated with Equation 4.16 for Jo = 9.23 (10−20) A/cm2, JL = 5.17 A/cm2. The open-circuit voltage Voc and short-circuit current density Jsc are shown as a function of the specific series resistant R in ohm-square centimeter.
76
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS
η = − Vm J m A Pin = − Voc J sc FF ( Pin A) = − [( ε G q ) VF][ J scmax JF] FF ( Pin A) ,
(4.22)
where Pin is the optical input power to the solar cell and A is the cell’s crosssectional area. The negative signs come from Jm and Jsc being negative. The fill factor FF is conveniently defined as the ratio FF = Vm J m Voc J sc = ( J m J L )(Vm Voc )( J L J sc ) ,
(4.23)
which specifies the “squareness” of the light J–V characteristics (see Fig. 4.2), and it has a maximum value of one and accounts for the unavoidable potential energy loss in transporting the charge to the solar cell boundaries for maximum power and the unavoidable “dark” current losses of forward biased diodes as well as losses due to high series resistance values. The (qVoc/εG) = VF loss fraction is the loss when the Voc is less than the bandgap. The loss fraction JF = J sc J scmax describes when all the incident photons with energies greater than the bandgap εG do not contribute to the Jsc (i.e., the external quantum efficiency is <1). A loss factor not included in the above is the energy that absorbed photons have that exceed the bandgap value εG. The latter is decreased using multi-bandgap cells and whose loss minimizations with three differing bandgaps have recently resulted in cell efficiencies exceeding 40% ([14]; Perharz and Bett, Chapter 14). These expressions inherently include the Equation 4.7 relations because the latter were the basic underlying assumptions used to derive the Shockley abrupt p/n junction model. When sunlight is concentrated through some optical means, a concentration ratio, X, can be defined as the concentrated optical input power Pinc divided by the unconcentrated one sun value Pin1 X . If the spectral distribution is not changed too much by the concentrating optics, the light-generated J Lc is just X times its one sun value J L1X since Equation 4.18 is linear in photon flux intensity F(λ). Hence, concentrator efficiency ηc is given as ηc = − Voc J sc1 X FF ( Pin1 X A) .
(4.24)
In high-performance devices with a low R so that Jsc/JL = –1 and with Jo/JL << 1 so that In(Jo/JL) is well approximated in Equation 4.19 by qVoc/kT, the FF of Equation 4.23 is totally specified by the factor qVoc/kT independent of the value of JL [12, 13], since the transcendental Equation 4.21 then simplifies to ln [(1 − J m J sc ) exp ( qVoc kT )] = ( J m J sc ) (1 − J m J sc )
(4.25)
and Equation 4.17 similarly simplifies to Vm Voc = ( kT qVoc ) ln [( − qVoc kT ) (1 − J m J sc )] .
(4.26)
p-i-n SOLAR CELLS
77
1.0 CIGS
0.9 0.8
Ge
Si (4 data points) GaAs 1050X GaAs 240X
Fill factor
0.7 0.6
GaAs 1X
0.5
CdTe
0.4
Photochemical
0.3 0.2
Theoretical maximum
Organic polymer
a-Si (stabilized)
0.1 0.0 0.00
20.00
40.00
60.00
80.00
100.00
120.00
qVoc/kT
Figure 4.3. The variation of the fill factor FF with the qVoc/kT values. The solid line curve is the maximum values predicted by the Shockley diode model with measured data points for comparisons.
The resulting relationship is plotted as the solid line theoretical curve in Figure 4.3 for qVoc/kT values between 0 and 105. For qVoc/kT between 50 and 105, the FF rises from 0.90 to 0.95. This theoretical FF asymptotically approaches 1 for Voc >> kT/q [12] and 0 for Voc << kT/q. The measured FFs of all the Green et al. [15] champion single-junction solar cells are plotted on this figure for reference along with the high-performance Ge and 1050X GaAs cells from the First Edition [5]. Note that all these experimental values fall beneath this curve, although a few of the highest performance ones approach the theoretical limit curve.
4.4
p-i-n SOLAR CELLS
By 1969, non-abrupt p/n junctions were proposed, first for Ge cells intended for thermophotovoltaic applications with high light intensities and high short-circuit current densities [16]. This involved inserting an undoped or intrinsic (i) layer between the p- and n-doped regions. These workers noted the increased carrier lifetimes in the undoped regions and the significance of open-circuit voltage as a fraction of the bandgap. They proposed and demonstrated the advantages of interdigitated back surface contacts. By 1975, p-i-n crystalline silicon solar cells were proposed with IBCs to better meet the needs of concentrated sunlight applications including higher doping concentrations in the p and n layers for higher open-circuit voltages [17, 18]. By 1976, the first a-Si p-i-n cells were reported with thin and heavily doped n+ and p+ regions between the metal contacts and on each side of the “i” layer [19]. Some of these, at least initially, were analyzed with the Shockley-like abrupt p/n junctions expressions with various modifications to account for their non-abrupt “i” regions.
78
4.5
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS
OHMIC CONTACTS AND HETEROJUNCTION INTERFACES
Metal contacts whose Fermi levels well align (see Fig. 4.1) with semiconductor band edges are needed to keep energy losses at these interfaces to a minimum as the majority carriers flow from the semiconductor materials and deliver power to external electrical loads. Typically, any energy losses (other than the δεn and δεp offset losses discussed above) at such interfaces are described by a contact resistance for each interface. When the voltage loss across such an interface is negligible compared to other major voltage drops in the circuit, such contacts are referred to as ohmic contacts. The latter does not necessarily mean that there is a linear relationship between the voltage drop and the current flowing through the contact but that this voltage drop increases monotonically with the current. It further means that whatever voltage drop that does develop is negligible in comparison to the major voltage drops in other parts of the solar cell circuit. Many workers have concluded that ohmic contacts correspond to interface boundaries to semiconductors with high minority carrier recombination rates, typically described by high surface recombination velocities [20–23]. The development history of high-efficiency solar cells as well as the implications of another Nobel Prize support this conclusion as discussed below. The seemingly mutually exclusive solar cell requirements (1) for ohmic contacts with low contact resistance unavoidably accompanied by high surface recombination velocities and (2) for cell interface boundaries with low surface recombination velocities were solved by the double heterostructure work pioneered by Kroemer and Alferov that began in 1957 [24]. Their work was crucial to the development of semiconductor light-emitting diodes (LEDs) and lasers that require very high current density flows between metal contact surfaces with doped semiconductors in a manner that does not limit the lifetimes of nearby excited carriers. Their breakthrough contributions were recognized with a Nobel Prize in 2000. They separated the problem into two solvable parts. Ohmic contacts were made to a higher bandgap material whose abrupt transition to a lower bandgap material keeps the latter’s minority carriers separated from the ohmic contact by the barrier height discontinuities at the conduction or valence band edges of heterojunctions. The low contact resistance is produced by a combination of high semiconductor doping of the regions adjacent to the contact metals to provide tunnel junction behavior and by microscopic roughness at the interface where pointed boundary regions provide electric field enhancement and field emission due to the differing dielectric constants of the metals and the semiconductors [23, 25–28]. Both provide higher average current densities at lower voltage drops across the contact regions. 4.6 CHAMPION 28.2% EFFICIENT GaAs AND OTHER SOLAR CELLS A “champion” cell means the highest record efficiency measured in a solar cell of some specific configuration. By definition, it is irreproducible since it is the highest value ever measured in a single device up to some specified date according to some
CHAMPION 28.2% EFFICIENT GaAs AND OTHER SOLAR CELLS
79
“validated” procedures preferably by “certified” laboratories independent of the organization that fabricated it. On a yield basis, the one-of-kind cost of a champion cell is enormous for any significantly sized development or manufacturing program. High-performance abrupt p/n junction solar cells demonstrate properties near those predicted by the ideal Shockley diode theory developed above. Analysis of the champion 28.2% efficient GaAs abrupt p/n junction concentrator cell illustrates this agreement and the relation of quasi-Fermi level splitting to fundamental performance limits. The correlations of this section help justify the predictions of solar cell performance limits developed later. The 28.2% efficiency is a corrected value calculated by multiplying the originally published 29.2% [29] by a correction factor of 0.952 to a value of 27.8%. In January 1991, Sandia National Laboratories implemented a recalibration of their primary reference cell [30] to agree with the National Renewable Energy Laboratory results, which resulted in the original 0.952 adjustment. Then recently, it was adjusted back up to 28.2% using the new reference solar spectrum ASTM G173-03 [31]. A GaAs alloy-based double-heterostructure configuration facilitated this high champion cell performance. Herbert Kroemer’s first conception of this type of structure was in 1963 for solid-state laser applications while he was at Varian in Palo Alto, California [32]. Even though Kroemer departed for academia in 1968, his remaining legacy and influence at Varian can be seen in the double heterostructure of this champion GaAs solar cell diagrammed in Figure 4.4 (and detailed in
Anti-reflection coating
3.5 μm front metallization 0.6 μm p-GaAs Cap Layer 0.04 μm p-(Al,Ga)As Window 0.5 μm p-GaAs Emitter
3.5 μm n-GaAs Base
0.2 μm n-(Al,Ga)As Mirror 0.6 μm n-GaAs Buffer
350 μm n-GaAs Substrate
Back metalization
Figure 4.4. The double heterostructure p-on-n configuration of efficient GaAs solar cells.
80
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS
TABLE 4.1. Dimensions and Doping Levels of Optimized [33] p-on-n and n-on-p GaAs Solar Cells p-on-n Cell
n-on-p Cell
μm
cm
μm
cm−3
GaAs cap layer
0.6
p = 5(1019)
0.6
n = 2(1018)
(Al0.9Ga0.1)As window
0.04
p ∼ 1019
0.04
n ∼ 1018
GaAs emitter
0.5
p = 2(1018)
0.2
n = 1(1018)
GaAs base
3.5
n = 2(10 )
3.8
p = 5(1017)
(Al0.2Ga0.8)As barrier
0.2
n = 1(1018)
0.2
p = 2(1018)
GaAs buffer
0.6
n = 1(1018)
0.6
p = 2(1018)
−3
17
The champion 28.2% efficient solar cell was of n-on-p construction.
Table 4.1) as first reported by Varian in 1988 20 years later [29, 34]. Note that the top GaAs heterojunction was to an Al0.9Ga0.1As layer that provided a wide enough bandgap window near 3 eV for blue light to readily pass into the GaAs active light absorption region. It also confined the GaAs’s minority carriers to stay near the collecting diode junction region and away from the adjacent front surface ohmic contact with its very high surface recombination velocity for minority carriers. The lower heterojunction was to a Al0.2Ga0.8As layer for a band edge offset of only a few kT beyond that of GaAs to confine the minority carriers to also stay near the junction from the back side. A sulfuric acid–peroxide etch [35] was used to passivate its edges. Contemporary, parallel, continuing, and similar GaAs alloy solar cell development work in Russia has been well summarized recently [24]. A detailed analysis of this champion cell was presented in chapter 1 of the First Edition and is not repeated here [5]. Up to 2009, this champion cell still held the record for efficiency of a single-junction device as tabulated by Green et al. [31] even though it was fabricated and reported 21 years earlier in 1988. Here, only summary descriptions and discussions are given. Its high open-circuit voltage of 1.155 V under 240X sunlight concentration was essentially set by the minority carrier concentrations approaching the 1014 cm−3 range calculated from Equations 4.12 and 4.13. This level is much less than the majority carrier concentrations of 1018 and 5 (1017) cm−3, respectively, for the n emitter and p base in this device whose quasi-Fermi levels’ spacing from their nearest band edges were hardly changed from their equilibrium values in the dark. Assuming this is all still satisfied at minority carrier concentration values of 1017 cm−3, then such devices at 1000 times higher light concentrations would still be in the “low injection” range if the higher heat load and current densities could be managed. The reasonable Shockley diode model parameter values that well fit this device’s behavior were summarized in tables 1.3 and 1.4 of the First Edition [5].
CHAMPION 28.2% EFFICIENT GaAs AND OTHER SOLAR CELLS
81
A companion Varian p-on-n cell (listed in Table 4.1) to the champion n on p one described above had a conversion efficiency that was still increasing at a concentration ratio of 1260x where its efficiency was 26.2% (see fig. 1.8 in [5]). Note that its 0.6-μm GaAs cap layer was heavily doped at 5 (1019) cm−3. Alferov summarized Russian measurements of similar GaAs technology single-junction cells whose efficiencies were 26.2% at 1000x, 25% at 2000x and 23% at 5800x concentration values (fig. 8.4 [24]). At the 5800x concentration, the Voc had risen to 1.195 V, but the fill factor had fallen to 0.79 due to apparent series resistance problems. This open-circuit voltage indicates the minority carrier concentrations still remained in the 1014 cm−3 low injection range. For further reference at the 1680x maximum efficiency conditions for the latter device, its Voc was lower at 1.18 V but with a higher FF of 0.87 [36]. When triple junction cells were exposed to concentrations over 14,000X (fig. 8.16 [24]), rather modest increases in opencircuit voltages were observed but with kinks in their I–V curves indicative of their tunnel junctions being driven beyond low loss limits. Combined, these illustrate the difficulties of trying to make Voc approach bandgap values using high concentration ratios alone based on abrupt p/n junction low injection designs. The potential performance improvement of the low injection, abrupt n-on-p GaAs concentrator cell design can be assessed by using best reported, materials limited parameter values. The results were in 30–32% efficiency range for such single junctions without increasing the concentration ratio X beyond 240X [5]. The theoretical open-circuit voltage values Voc are specified in Equations 4.12 and 4.13 as a function of the low injection minority carrier electron and hole concentrations are shown in Figure 4.5a as the continuous curves assuming a densityof-states effective mass ratio of md/mo = 0.5. The solid line curves indicate the operational range of current champion devices with actual experimental results shown as data points, while the dashed curves indicate expected values at substantially higher and lower minority carrier concentrations. The GaAs data points appear at higher concentrations than the reported 1014 cm−3 levels reported immediately above. However, this difference is due to GaAs’s density-of-states effective masses being lower than the assumed 0.5 value used for the curves [8]. The solid lines indicate the approximate range of the best current champion cells and the upper dashed line indicates the 1019 cm−3 minority carrier concentrations that would be required to make VF approach one and the open-circuit voltages approach bandgap value (for a density-of-states effective mass ratio of 0.5). Note that this direct efficiency loss factor for voltage VF is well below 80% for data points other than the GaAs concentrator devices. Surprisingly, the champion CIGS VF is among the highest of the one sun cells with a minority carrier concentration exceeding 1013 cm−3, and CdTe is among the lowest, corresponding to a minority carrier concentration of ∼1010 cm−3. The dominant intrinsic or “i” region of p-i-n cells has such low-equilibrium carrier concentrations that almost any low light intensity provides light-generated carrier concentrations exceeding that of both the electrons and holes. This is the high injection case described by Equations 4.14 and 4.15 and plotted in Figure 4.5b. Similar contour curves are shown for constant light-generated carrier
82
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS
Figure 4.5. The open-circuit voltage Voc as a fraction VF of the bandgap. The solid and broken line curves are theoretical values for constant light-generated concentrations from 104 to 1016 cm−3. (a) Low injection case. (b) High injection case.
concentrations (in undoped intrinsic materials, there is no well-defined “minority carrier”), again with solid curves used to emphasize the range of current champion devices indicated by data points. The low VF value of stabilized a-Si corresponds to low light-generated carrier concentrations of ∼1011 cm−3 about three orders of magnitude below that of the best GaAs concentrator cells. The IBC crystalline silicon champion cell achieved a VF value of 0.61 that corresponds to a carrier concentration of almost 1016 cm−3 if it is a high injection device but to less than 1013 cm−3 if it operates as a low injection device. Its i-like region was actually n-type and low doped to ∼1015 cm−3. Thus, it is an intermediate device whose VF = 0.61 value is plotted in both the (a) and (b) parts of Figure 4.5 due to this uncertainty. The crystalline silicon HIT cell has an
ADVANCED CONCEPT p/n AND p-i-n CRYSTALLINE SILICON CELLS
83
even higher VF =0.65 as plotted in Figure 4.5b. Its low n-type doping level has not been disclosed but is likely in the same 1015 cm−3 level range. The point contact crystalline silicon solar cell definitely has an undoped “i” layer and an even higher Voc = 0.80 V and VF = 0.73 corresponding to a light-generated concentration exceeding 1016 cm−3. This p-i-n point contact light-generated carrier concentration is over three orders of magnitude above the best GaAs concentrator cells plotted in Figure 4.5a. Direct comparison to Figure 4.5a immediately shows that same lightgenerated carrier concentrations produce much lower VF values under high injection conditions compared to low injection. This is due to the “majority” carrier Fermi level being essentially pinned close to its neighboring band edge in low injection devices due to rather heavy majority carrier doping levels (of abrupt p/n junction Shockley devices) that contribute almost half the bandgap to the observed Voc even at very low light-generated carrier concentrations. Superficially, this would seem to indicate a major advantage for low injection device designs. However, an attempt is made to argue the opposite point in Section 4.9; that is, that “high injection” devices actually provide the highest-efficiency potential when all interacting parameter trade-offs are considered.
4.7 ADVANCED CONCEPT p/n AND p-i-n CRYSTALLINE SILICON CELLS Three high-performance and innovative departures from the simple Shockley model discussed above are covered in this section, namely, the IBC cell, the point contact cell, and the HIT cell. Prior to the HIT discussion, the p/n Shockley-type PERL cell is also covered. All four are based on crystalline silicon.
4.7.1
Interdigitated and Point Contact Crystalline Silicon Cells
An innovative adaptation of the Shockley diode solar cell (of Fig. 4.1) is the IBC cell [16, 37, 38]. Its conceptual evolution can be seen by starting with a drawing in Figure 4.6 (top) of a one-dimensional symmetry cell with the light coming in from the top. All the surfaces are passivated with SiO except for narrow openings centered under each plated Cu grid line. To make ohmic contacts, a thin layer of Al is deposited, whose interface roughening reactions [26] with the underlying Si and its metallic nature provides for unimpeded majority carrier flow between the semiconductor and the exterior circuit. The Al on top of the SiO provides mirror reflection of any sunlight that strikes the sides. The small ohmic contact regions reduce the portion of the cell surface with high surface recombination velocities inherent to ohmic contacts. Heavily doped but thin p+ and n+ layers are diffused in from the right- and left-hand sides, respectively, into a low (∼1015 cm−3) n-type Czochralski silicon wafer of approximately 5-Ω-cm resistivity and ∼1-ms minority carrier lifetime. The p/n junction is at the left side at the p+–n− interface. If
84
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS Light
p+
n+
n–
SiO Al reflector/barrier Plated Cu
εc ε*FeL q(V - JR*)
δεn ΔεFeL εFo
ΔεFhL ε*FhL
qV
δεp εv
Figure 4.6. One-dimensional conceptual representation of the interdigitated back contact cell (top) and its corresponding energy band diagram approximation (bottom).
conceptually this is folded about its center into a upside down “U” shape until the p+ and n+ regions touch, the actual IBC geometry is produced as shown schematically in Figure 4.7. As described by Mulligan et al. [39], the wafers are p+ layer diffused on both sides about 1.8 μm deep to give 16 Ω per square resistivity layers (p ∼ 5 (1018) cm−3). This is followed by a thermal oxide growth of ∼0.25-μm thickness on all surfaces. Next, a screen printed resist mask is used on the back-side oxide surface to provide ∼0.7-mm-wide strip openings (∼2-mm repetitive spacing) for etching ∼3 μm down through both the oxide and the p+-doped layer while at the same time the top side p+ layer is removed. The resist is cured thermally or with UV light. Next, an n+ diffusion is done to provide n+ layers in the 3-μm deep trenches about 0.9 μm deep with ∼40 Ω per square resistivity (n ∼ 1 (1019) cm−3). This is followed by a thermal oxide growth over all the n+ surfaces ∼0.095 μm thick. With a resist covering the back side, the textured top surface (∼1- to 10-μm-high square pyramids corresponding to the 100 wafer orientations) is etched into the wafer after the top oxide has been removed. Next, the wafers are n diffused and oxidized on both sides. The latter provides the n+ FSF under the oxide essentially for the production of a very
ADVANCED CONCEPT p/n AND p-i-n CRYSTALLINE SILICON CELLS
n+ Front surface field
85
TiO2 SiO
n– Wafer of Si
i-aSi
p+ aSi n+ aSi
Reflector/barrier
Metallization
Figure 4.7. Two-dimensional cross-sectional schematic of an interdigitated back contact solar cell.
low front surface recombination velocity [40]. The electric field of the FSF is in the direction to repel minority carrier holes from the wafer’s top or front surface. Finally, a SiN or TiO2 antireflection coating is applied to the top pyramid surface, which, in combination with the underlying SiO, provides a two-layer structure with a very low reflection coefficient over the active sunlight wavelengths of this solar cell. A screen printed resist is used to etch narrow openings in the oxide centered over the p+ and n+ strips in the back but configured as separate and disconnected “islands” to keep such exposed open areas to less than 5% the back surface. A three-layer metallization is then applied to the whole back side of ∼0.4-μm total thickness, starting with Al, followed by a titanium 10%–tungsten 90% diffusion barrier, and finally by a thin Cu layer, followed by annealing in forming gas at ∼300°C. The latter Cu outer coating provides the base for subsequent grid finger plating, but it does not exhibit strong lateral conductivity. Another screen printed resist is again used to define the grid lines over the p+ and n+ back-side regions and then Cu electroplated to ∼20-μm thickness and capped with ∼7 μm of tin plating to improve solderability. A final screen printed resist is applied so the ∼0.4-μmthick tri-layer metallization can be removed between all the grid lines that would otherwise partially short the n+ and p+ terminal contacts together. A perspective drawing of the overall structure is shown in Figure 4.8 including the 145-μm-thick Czochralski wafer thickness currently used in manufacturing [38]. The Al mirror coating of the oxides at the bottom reflects back any light at the longer wavelengths that penetrate that far, for repeat passes through the wafer. When p-type wafers were used instead of n-type, comparable performance could be achieved, but the p-type ones evidenced a few percent degradations under
86
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS
Textured front surface n– 145 μm thick Czochralski silicon wafer SiO Passivation n+
–
p
+
+
Limited Contact Area
Cu Grid Lines
Figure 4.8. Perspective drawing of the interdigitated back contact solar cell.
Figure 4.9. Photograph of the back and front surface of an interdigitated back contact solar cell formed on a 6-in. Czochralski wafer.
sunlight due to a boron dopant and residual oxygen interaction. Fortunately, float zone silicon wafers are no longer needed to provide wafers with the desired 1-ms minority carrier lifetimes. A photo of the front and back surfaces of an interdigitated cell is shown in Figure 4.9. It shows the very black front surface and the back surface with all the alternating metal strips connected by top and bottom bus bar tabs that provide the plus and minus terminals for convenient solder attachment. Two-dimensional energy band diagrams are difficult to draw. Hence, Figure 4.6 (bottom) shows a one-dimensional approximation. The high near 1019 cm−3 doping of both the thin n+ and p+ layers makes the equilibrium (zero voltage, in the dark) Fermi level εFo penetrate both their conduction and valence band edges
ADVANCED CONCEPT p/n AND p-i-n CRYSTALLINE SILICON CELLS
87
plus provide good alignment with the metal Fermi levels with essentially negative δεn and δεp offset values for efficient conversion of the excited majority carrier concentrations into metal contact electrons with matched Fermi levels and negligible energy losses. Here, it is assumed this high doping significantly reduces the minority carrier lifetimes so the thin n+ and p+ regions do not contribute to lightgenerated current nor support high minority carrier concentration values. Very importantly, these heavily doped regions strongly define which carriers are the majority ones at the collection boundaries. Thus, when the “quasi-minority” quasi-Fermi levels collapse together to essentially a single Fermi level at the boundaries, the majority carrier Fermi levels stay aligned with the metal contact Fermi levels and at opposite band edges. The present band diagram is similar to that of Swanson (fig. 5 [37]). It is this asymmetric Fermi level merging process that coverts the quasi-Fermi level splitting in the bulk of the device into a physical, assessable, and useable voltage in the metal contacts. It plays the comparable role to the second major step of depletion-region-minority-to-majority-carrier conversion in Shockley abrupt p/n junctions. However, there are substantial and major differences in its operational mode that opens new opportunities for optimizations. In sunlight intensities low enough to produce increases in electron–hole pair concentrations below the ∼1015 cm−3 doping of the wafer, this specific resistance R is just the corresponding bulk resistances encountered in standard Shockley diode solar cells. However, at high light intensities where the photogenerated concentrations exceed the background doping level, the resistance contribution to the total R value is reduced. Once generated, the electrons (and holes) have no memory whether produced from thermally ionized doping levels or from light absorption and thus provide the same reduction in resistance regardless. The Figure 4.6 (bottom) plot is for this “high injection” case. However, one immediate disadvantage of this configuration is immediately seen. The equilibrium spacing of the Fermi level from the conduction band edge is much larger here than in standard Shockley devices. Hence, the open-circuit voltage is limited by the high injection restrictions of Equations 4.14 and 4.15 versus the low injection ones of Equations 4.12 and 4.13. One of the major cost reductions came from the replacement of all photoresist photolithography fabrication processes with screen printed resists steps. This was accommodated by widening the widths of the n+ and p+ strips shown in Figures 4.7 and 4.8 to accommodate the design rule constraints of screen printing. These wide features imposed a very flat aspect ratio for the resulting cells as illustrated schematically in Figure 4.10 (not to scale). These current trajectories are not unlike those of majority carriers in the emitters of standard Shockley diodes collected at top metal grid lines except here the “grid lines” can be very wide without any light shadowing loss. The amount of energy it takes to collect charge carriers over a given distance with a specified force is proportional to the time that force has to be applied, where that time is inversely proportional to the carrier velocity. Hence, the collection energy lost for both electrons and holes can be made similar by scaling these lateral collection lengths (approximately Wn and Wp) inversely with
88
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS
n+
Electron trajectories p+
Hole trajectories 145 μm
+
n
p+
W Wn ~ 0.7 mm
Wp ~ 1.4 mm
Wn
Figure 4.10. The electron and hole trajectories in a flat-profile interdigitated back contact solar cell with wide 0.7- and 1.4-mm metal grid metals for the n+ and p+ regions, respectively.
their mobilities (of μn = 1350 cm2/Vs and 480 cm2/Vs for crystalline Si) in approximate agreement with the widths shown. As can be seen by the trajectories, the photoelectrons cannot be collected at the p+ region and the holes cannot be collected by the n+ region. Essentially, diffusion drives this whole process and as electrons are blocked at the p+ regions, their charge accumulation builds up to just the right distribution to generate an electrostatic field that deflects any new electrons transversely over to their proper collection region. The analogous process occurs for the photogenerated holes. The net effect is that these transverse currents can accurately be described just by doubling the diffusion coefficient value along all of the transverse paths. This is a phenomenon called the Webster effect [38], which has been well known since the early days of high-current transistor development [41]. The effect reduces the potential energy loss from the charge diversion process. Under “high injection” conditions, the 21.8% champion IBC cell with a Voc of 0.677 V, a voltage loss factor VF = 0.62, and a fill factor of 0.806 at a Jsc of 40 mA/cm2 at 25°C [15], the light-generated ΔpL and ΔnL concentrations were on the order of 4.7 (1015) cm−3. It is of interest to note that the n− doping concentration selected to reduce series resistance R problems for the interdigitated cell is in this same general concentration range. With its high measured fill factor, essentially at the limit of Shockley diode theory for this open-circuit value, there are certainly no trap-controlled SCLI limitations that are covered in the following section. However, a minority carrier concentration of 4.7 (1015) cm−3 would have produced an even higher Voc in a standard Shockley diode cell with a majority carrier doping concentration in the mid (1017) cm−3 range. For comparison, the 24.7% efficient champion Shockley diode PERL cell had a higher Voc of 0.706 V, a voltage loss factor VF = 0.64, and a higher fill factor of 0.828 at a higher Jsc of 42.2 mA/cm2 at 25°C [15]. According to
ADVANCED CONCEPT p/n AND p-i-n CRYSTALLINE SILICON CELLS
89
TABLE 4.2. Summary Properties of Exemplary Single-Junction Solar Cells Description
εG (eV)
η (%)
Voc (V)
Champion GaAs
1.41
28.2
PERL Si
1.1
IBC Si
FF
J sc1X (mA/cm2)
VF
Light-Generated Carriers (cm−3)
1.16
0.857
22.6
0.823
1.0 (1013)
24.7
0.706
0.828
42.2
0.642
4.9 (1012)
1.1
21.8
0.677
0.806
40.0
0.615
1.8 (1015)
HIT Si/a-Si
1.1
21.8
0.718
0.790
38.4
0.718
4.1 (1015)
Das Si/a-Si
1.1
18.8
0.694
0.744
36.4
0.676
2.3 (1015)
a-Si (unstabilized)
1.8
12.0
0.891
0.701
18.4
0.495
5.2 (1011)
a-Si (stabilized)
1.8
9.5
0.859
0.630
17.5
0.478
2.8 (1011)
Equations 4.12 and 4.13, it accomplished this with a lower minority carrier concentration of 4.9 (1012) cm−3. For comparisons, all these numbers are summarized in Table 4.2 as calculated from the known density-of-states effective mass values except for a-Si where md/mo was taken as 1.0 for lack of a better value. Thus, these table concentrations differ from those of Figure 4.5 calculated for md/mo = 0.5. At one sun concentrations, the interdigitated cell configurations certainly do have inherently lower open-circuit voltage potential than the champion versions of regular Shockley diode devices. As will be discussed below, the PERL fabrication requires photolithograpy fabrication steps that make it not economically competitive with alternate designs for one sun applications. Other standard Shockley diode one sun silicon cells, fabricated without photolithography, presently do not match the performance levels of the interdigitated type. Given the constraints of high production volumes at competitive costs, the IBC cells currently provide one of the best trade-offs of performance and costs.
4.7.2
Concentrator Point Contact and IBC Cells
Under concentrated sunlight, the higher costs of photolithography fabrication can be justified. For the latter, the interdigitated design uses about 10X thinner widths for the n+ and p+ regions (i.e., the Wn and Wp values) to reduce tranverse current problems. A champion version of this has demonstrated a conversion efficiency of 26.1% at a concentration value of 105X (Item 9, Table 1.5 [5]). The point contact cell has a larger fraction percentage of its back surface contacting the metal contacts than the one sun IBC one to be able to handle the higher currents encountered with concentration (see Fig. 4.11). Apparently, this design under ∼100X sun light intensities produces high enough photo carrier concentrations in the “i” region so
90
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS n+ busbar
p+ busbar
n+ n+
n+ Undoped czochralski wafer
Oxide
Sunlight
Figure 4.11. The point contact solar cell configuration.
that little or no doping is needed in the wafers to avoid series resistance problems from the bulk of the wafer itself. 4.7.3
PERL Cell
The PERL cell, to date, is one of the closest approximations to an ultimate Shockley diode, single-junction cell design for low injection conditions, with fine light trapping features, extensive oxide passivations, reduced ohmic contact regions, and an Al reflecting back contact. The only major features it is missing are heterojunction barriers to its ohmic contact regions and possibly back surface texturing. Chapter 2 of the First Edition [5] discussed this device in detail with its picture even featured on this book’s cover fly sheet. A champion version has demonstrated the highest crystalline silicon efficiency so far, even approaching the 25.2% efficiency of the even more expensive GaAs single junction, one sun solar cell also of standard, low injection, Shockley diode design. However, the latter also had the additional Nobel Prize-winning double heterostructure barriers to it ohmic contact regions. Neither the Si point contact nor the PERL cell design (requiring photolithography) is cost competitive for one sun applications. The lower open-circuit voltages of the IBC and HIT cell compared to the PERL support the former being high injection devices described by Figure 4.5b where the PERL is a low injection device described by Figure 4.5a.
ADVANCED CONCEPT p/n AND p-i-n CRYSTALLINE SILICON CELLS
4.7.4
91
HIT Cell
The distinctly different structure of the HIT cell is shown in Figure 4.12 [42]. Its evolution from an a-Si cell design is evident by its similar configuration except that the middle section is replaced by a thin and low-doped n-type crystalline silicon wafer, and the top and bottom surfaces are almost identical, starting with a TCO under the top and bottom grid lines [43, 44]. These are followed by highly doped a-Si layers with p doping on the top and n doping on the bottom, and finally by undoped a-Si on each side of the crystalline silicon wafer. The textured nature of its top and bottom surfaces assists in reducing reflection losses and causes longer photon path lengths inside the device, particularly for the photons that exit the back of the cell and are directed back by reflection off a diffuse white bottom substrate. Since the bandgap of a-Si is 1.8 eV compared to crystalline silicon’s of 1.2 eV, this is the double heterostructure for which Alferov and Kroemer shared the 2000 Nobel Prize in physics, except that the latter was all in GaAs-related III–V compounds. For the III–Vs, the lattice constants of all the components usually need to match to give good performance. However, a-Si has no well-defined lattice constant and surprisingly appears to perform well as a heterostructure barrier that confines excited carriers to the crystalline silicon and away from ohmic contacts. This HIT cell has matched the IBC cell to have the highest “notable” module efficiency for a mass produced device of 21.8% but with a higher open-circuit voltage of 0.718 V, a voltage loss factor VF = 0.65, a slightly lower fill factor of 0.79, and a lower short-circuit current density of 36.9 mA/cm2 at 25°C compared with the IBC cell module [15]. Its lower current is due to the 1.8-eV bandgap a-Si p+ (minority carrier killer) layer’s and the top ITO layer’s absorption of blue wavelengths plus the light shading from it wide, screen printed resin contact grids on
Metal
Front TCO p+ (a-Si) i (a-Si)
n-type c-Si
n+ (a-Si) Back TCO
Metal
Figure 4.12. The heterojunction with intrinsic thin-layer (HIT) cell.
92
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS
top of the cell [43]. Its relatively high fill factor is evidence of no strong trapcontrolled SCLI losses discussed below. The upper region current losses of HIT could be avoided by applying this a-Si/crystalline Si heterojunction to the IBC cell, all of whose contacts are on the rear of the cell where little light goes. At the same time, the protection it provides from ohmic contact high surface recombination velocities would be expected to be seen in higher minority carrier concentrations and thus higher opencircuit voltages. Encouraging preliminary data with increased Voc (compared to IBC) was found in preliminary experiments on similar structures [45] (see Table 4.2 entry Das Si/a-Si), but higher overall performance has not yet been demonstrated because it did not contain all the other efficiency-enhancing elements of the IBC described above. HIT’s one-dimensional symmetry band diagram is qualitatively the same as that shown in Figure 4.6 (but with heterojunction band edge offsets next to each doped region), and its Fermi level splitting corresponds to an excited carrier concentration of 4.1 (1015) cm−3 (from Eq. 4.15) that is about three orders of magnitude higher than the corresponding number for the champion PERL cell. However, its open-circuit voltage is only slightly higher because it operates as a high injection device (vs. a low injection one as illustrated in Fig. 4.5). This means that the HIT cell is better at absorbing, confining, and preserving photogenerated excited carriers than any other one sun, crystalline silicon-based solar cell device so far. One potential reason is the dual heterojunction that keeps the crystalline silicon photoexcited carriers from the high surface recombination velocity of ohmic contacts. Another possible reason is that the textured top and bottom is superior to single-sided texturing, particularly when it is placed onto a module’s white backing surface that reflects any light lost from the bottom back up into the cell. In reality, the high open-circuit voltage is likely due to a combination of these effects. The early versions of the HIT cells were formed on undoped crystalline silicon wafers over 200 μm thick. Recent reports have quoted thicknesses for HIT cells as low as 70 μm without wafer bowing problems but with monotonically falling short-circuit current densities with thickness below 200 μm [43]. These seem to imply that the champion-level performance occurs at the larger wafer thickness (i.e., ∼200 μm). With the same qualitative structure as an amorphous Si cell with a thick and undoped central core, the question arises as why the HIT and the IBC cells do not enter the regime of trap-controlled SCLI operation covered in the following section. The main reason is that high-quality, 1-ms-lifetime Czochralski Si wafers do not have the significant density of deep traps needed for trap-controlled behavior. However, the need to have 1015 cm−3 level doping for one sun operation free of notable resistive losses in interdigitated cells and the disappearance of this need when it and the point contact cells are under concentrated light then begs the question of whether a-Si cells might recover some of their lost fill factors if exposed to appropriate minimum levels of sunlight concentration, similar to select GaAs concentrator cells [27].
SCLI MODEL OF SOLAR CELLS
4.8
93
SCLI MODEL OF SOLAR CELLS
In the same year that Chapin et al. [11] reported a 6% efficiency for a Shockley diode single-crystal silicon solar cell, Reynolds et al. [46] reported the same 6% efficiency for what they then described as CdS solar with a Cu contact. However, the subsequent development of this type of cell showed that its higher performance configurations have a quantum efficiency that starts at ∼1-μm wavelength that corresponds to the 1.2-eV bandgap of CuxS, sharply different from the 2.4-eV bandgap (at 0.5-μm wavelength) of the CdS other part of this heterojunction device [47]. What is most distinctive about this cell is the crossover of its measured dark and light J–V curves as shown by the data points in Figure 4.13 for a device with a 6% efficiency [48]. This is in sharp contrast to the vertical only dark-light shift of high-performance Shockley solar cells as shown for the champion GaAs cell in figure 1.2 of the First Edition [5] and as specified by this model’s Equation 4.16. There are no physically realistic parameters values that one can use in Shockley diode solar cell equations to fit these measured crossover data. However, these data were well fit with a trap-controlled SCLI model as shown by the theoretical solid line curves in Figure 4.13 using reasonable parameter values that are in the range of independently measured values obtained from 20 Theory Experimental Data
15 10
Dark
J (mA/cm2)
5 0 –5 –10
Light
–15 –20 0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
V (V)
Figure 4.13. The dark and light J–V crossover properties of a 6% efficient, thin-film polycrystalline CuxS/CdS solar cell [48, 49].
94
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS
other component materials using nonsolar cell characterization techniques [48, 49]. Like a-Si, CuxS/CdS solar cells degrade with sunlight exposure in the terrestrial atmosphere and can recover with heat treatment [47]. Unfortunately, their degradation continues unabated and is not limited to a small percentage like a-Si. Furthermore, the CuxS/CdS recovery heat treatment requires a hydrogen-reducing atmosphere (and possibly oxygen also), while a-Si requires only heat. Eventually, a CuxS/Cd(Zn)S version of this cell provided the first polycrystalline thin-film solar cell with an efficiency over 10% [50] with an open-circuit voltage of 0.84 V, a voltage loss factor VF = 0.7, a fill factor of 0.68, and a short-circuit current density of 17.8 mA/cm2. From today’s perspective, the greatest value of the CuxS/CdS solar cells is not from their ability to provide better device solutions but their validation of a theoretical model, different from Shockley’s, for a distinctly different physical mechanism for directly converting light into DC electricity. At high enough current densities, no matter how well designed and fabricated the contact and grid metalizations are in a Shockley diode type solar cell, one reaches a level where the ohmic voltage losses internal to the cell dominate over the exponential current–voltage characteristics of the abrupt p/n junction itself. This is easily seen for in-the-dark log current density versus terminal voltage plots that remain in a straight line (that is exponential) until an outward curvature appears, when the internal ohmic voltages start to dominate. Such a dark log current density versus voltage curve for an a-Si solar cell (or photodiode as termed in X-ray imagers) is shown in Figure 23.11 of Chapter 23. Here, this ohmic dominance appears at a terminal voltage of about 0.9 V and at a dark current density of about 1 mA/cm2 for this specific device. Also note that the one sun short-circuit current densities Jsc are on the order of 18 mA/cm2 in a 12% (unstablized) efficiency singlejunction a-Si device (see table 1.5 in Reference 5) and of 17.5 mA/cm2 in a 9.5% (stabilized) champion device [15]. One can work to reduce the internal series resistance by varying the thickness and properties of the ITO transparent top contact typically used for a-Si and by adding additional conducting grid lines on top of the ITO. However, as noted earlier, a-Si cells have a fundamental structural difference from the abrupt p/n junction configuration shown for the simplest Shockley diode in Figure 4.1. As shown in Figure 23.9 of Chapter 23, the a-Si solar cell structure is dominated by a ∼0.3-μm-thick intrinsic or undoped region with only thin ∼10-nm-thick n+- and p+-type doped regions, essentially the diametric opposite of an abrupt p/n junction. The most developed, trap-controlled SCLI diode model for a-Si solar cells was summarized previously [51]. A key simplifying assumption was made to keep the mathematics tractable. This is that one can find a region (the 0.3-μm-thick undoped high-resistance region) where current transport is dominated by a singlecarrier type (electrons) and where their transport is well described by drift current alone (i.e., diffusion current is negligible). This current dominance is justified in general when the mobility of conduction band electrons is quite different from that of holes, so that the higher-mobility carrier dominates. This is particularly justified in a-Si where the electron mobility is about 100 times that of its holes (Street, Chapter 23). Note that the key Shockley diode assumption, to make that mathemat-
SCLI MODEL OF SOLAR CELLS
95
ics tractable, was just the opposite. It was that a region can be found at the edges of the depletion regions where current is well described just by diffusion currents with a negligible drift current. Space charge begins to build up in this undoped amorphous layer when the velocity of electrons being injected by a negative voltage on the thin, heavily n+doped cathode exceeds the velocity with which they can be transported across the undoped region to the thin heavily p+-doped anode, as specified by its dielectric relaxation time ρε where ρ is the resistivity and epsilon ε is its dielectric constant. The threshold current density JTH where the dielectric relaxation time just equals the transit time through a resistive region of thickness L with a concentration of mobile carriers n, a mobility μ, and a dielectric constant ε is given by J TH = n2 q 2 μL ε .
(4.27)
Gauss’s law is used to describe the spatial changes in the electric field E(x) across the region. The drift-current-only expression specifies the electron concentration as n(x) = J/[qμE(x)]. In combination, these two relations define the primary differential equation that can be solved analytically for the current–voltage relationships for the case of a single trapping layer in the bandgap or solved numerically for a distribution of traps in the bandgap. To obtain rectification (and later solar cell) behavior, the n(x) boundary condition must be asymmetric with n(0) = nα (at the n-type contact), which is greater than nβ = n(L) (at the p-type contact), where L is the length of the undoped highresistance region. With a negative voltage applied to the n-type contact side of the high-resistance region, the electric field boundary condition is E(0) = J/(qμnα). The voltage injected electron concentration n(x) at each incremental position builds up so that the nonequilibrium but steady-state dielectric relaxation time through each such incremental slab exactly equals the drift velocity of the conduction electrons moving through that slab. As the current densities J (and also the terminal voltages V) continually increase, so do the trapped and mobile charge values at each and every x position under SCLI conditions. The typical transition point, for trap-controlled SCLI devices, is at a terminal voltage where pure ohmic to SCLI change begins, called the trapped-filled limit VTFL. The latter title is intended to approximately define the forward bias voltage just large enough to have the quasi-Fermi level just pass through the initial deepest trap level and to change its trapped charge probability from almost zero to almost one. This essentially is the knee where the current density begins to rise abruptly above the straight-line ohmic current density. A rough phenomenological estimate for this transition voltage is given as [52] VTFL = q L2 ptio ε ,
(4.28)
where ptio is the hole concentration in the ith trap level at equilibrium. Above this transition voltage, the resistive and trapping effects cause the current to increase nonlinearly with voltage.
96
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS
So far, only SCLI diodes operating in the dark have been considered. For abrupt p/n junction Shockley diodes, all light absorbed in the junction “depletion” region, to produce electron–hole pairs, is assumed to be collected with 100% efficiency. Such a near-perfect collection of all photocarriers from the “i” layer of the a-Si p-i-n structure to produce a constant light-generated current apparently continues to apply relatively well. The first light exposure assumption is that if one stays at low enough voltage in general, and at zero terminal bias voltage in particular, the light-generated shortcircuit current density is well described by the Shockley diode expressions for Jsc even at high current densities. For a-Si, this means collection of all electron–hole pairs produced by light absorption in the “i” layer, but not in the n+ and p+ contact regions that are essentially dead to photocurrent generation. The second major light exposure assumption is that the charge distribution can be split into two parts, ρo(x, Φ) and ρI(x, Φ, V), where Φ is the light intensity and the “o” subscript designates the zero terminal voltage charge distribution that leads to the generation of Jsc and the “I” subscript denotes the positional change in this charge density with a voltage that controls the “injection” of charge through the device contacts. The final light exposure assumption is that the voltage-induced changes in ρI(x, Φ, V) are well approximated in the SCLI current expressions by replacing the equilibrium trap densities with their steady-state light-exposed values. Then, the dark SCLI J–V expressions become the light-exposed ones just with the addition of the constant short-circuit current density, which only varies with Φ, and the replacement of equilibrium trap densities with their steady-state light-exposed values. This SCLI model fit of the nonexponential shape of the light J–V curves for the (unstablized) 10% efficient a-Si solar cell is shown in Figure 4.14. The bandgap
0 Catalano et al. Data
J (mA/cm2)
–4
εc – εt = 0.5 eV = 0.4-0.5 eV = 0.3-0.5 eV = 0.2-0.5 eV
–8 –12 –16 –20
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4 0.5 V (V)
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
Figure 4.14. The fit of the J–V data measured data points of a 10% efficient a-Si solar cell using the trap-controlled SCLI model and the trap densities values (round data points) of Figure 4.15 for the labeled bandgap energy ranges.
SCLI MODEL OF SOLAR CELLS
97
trap distribution densities that provide this fit are shown by the circular data points and dashed line curve in Figure 4.15. For reference, the solid line curves of the latter are the known electronic state densities inside this band or “mobility” gap from Street’s Figure 23.2 in Chapter 23. Figure 4.14 Illustrates how the lowest trap level provides the starting base to the J–V characteristic’s shape (with the highest fill factor) that then progressively fills in with each shallower trap level at higher voltage points that soften the curve and further lower the fill factor. The quasi-Fermi level essentially moves through each shallower level in approaching closer to the conduction band edge with increasing forward bias. For reference, the light J–V curve fit values for the density of states of a 9.2% efficient, polycrystalline thin-film CuxS/CdS solar cell are also shown in Figure 4.15 [53]. Both cells have a relatively high peak in the mid 1017 cm−3eV−1 trap densities 0.3–0.4 V deep below the conduction band edge that fall sharply at shallower adjacent trap energies. However, the a-Si curve intersects its band tail states and then bends back up. This softens the J–V curvature and lowers its fill factor. Apparently, the CuxS/CdS heterojuction is free of such band tails states (at least of the indicated magnitudes), and its higher fill factor of 0.71 (compared to the a-Si fill factor of 0.68) is consistent with this conclusion. The highest fill factors predicted by this SCLI model have values of approximately 0.76. They occur when there is a single deep trap in the bandgap with the equilibrium Fermi energy εFeo positioned just a few KT above it (see fig. 2.2 [52]). This implies fundamental, lower values for the achievable fill factors in solar cell devices well described by a trap-controlled SCLI model (vs. Shockley diodes ones).
Figure 4.15. The solid line curves are the density of states for amorphous silicon (from Fig. 23.2, Street, Chapter 23) as a function of energy position relative to the conduction band edge εC. The broken line curves are the trap-controlled SCLI model trap values that fit the light J–V curves of a 10% efficient a-Si cell (triangle data points) and a 9.2% CuxS/ CdS (round data points) cell.
98
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS
For trap-controlled SCLI diodes, the theoretical values for Voc remain the same quasi-Fermi level splitting ones specified by Equations 4.12–4.15 for low or high injection and their Jsc values versus bandgap are also the same as for Shockley diodes. The only major difference is in the FF values. Fundamentally, the current density with trap-controlled SCLI cannot rise as quickly with voltage as in devices with J rising exponentially with V. This makes its shape less square and it theoretical FF lower. What is obvious for the a-Si data points in Figure 4.5b is that they have only been able to achieve rather low light-generated carrier densities up to ∼1011 cm−3 (compared to 1013 to 1015 cm−3 levels in the other champion devices). This imposes sharp relative efficiency penalties on high injection devices like a-Si despite a-Si’s higher rate of light-generated carriers in comparatively much thinner optically active layers. This low carrier concentration results from its comparatively very low minority carrier lifetimes caused by all of its bandgap states and defects and by its poorer surface passivation and its lack of heterojunction barriers to ohmic contact regions of very high surface recombination velocities. These deficiencies are present in various degrees in other defect-filled thin-film devices. One additional important implication of the SCLI solar cell model is that any bandgap material can be made to perform as a solar cell, at least to some degree, by placing it between two asymmetric contacts.
4.9 BANDGAP VOLTAGE, UNDOPED QUANTUM WELL SOLAR CELLS Shockley and Queisser [12] used a detailed balance calculation to estimate the maximum efficiency of a crystalline silicon, abrupt p/n junction solar cell described by their model equations. They took the black body radiation from the sun (appropriately represented geometrically) minus reverse black body radiation from a silicon cell surface near room temperature and used the net flux of photons above the silicon bandgap to come up with a short-circuit current density, an open-circuit voltage, and a corresponding fill factor to determine a maximum efficiency of 30% essentially for a cell located above the earth’s atmosphere. Since terrestrial cells are typically a relative 10% higher efficiency than space cells (due to less blue light photons), this corresponds to a maximum terrestrial efficiency on the order of 33%. They readily conceded that concentrated sunlight could be used to produce larger net photon fluxes from the sun and even higher efficiencies. Henry [54] extended the detailed balance modeling to the case of 1000X sunlight concentration levels. For a single junction, they found a maximum efficiency of 37% that increased to 50% with 2 junctions and to 72% with 36 junctions (and no interconnect losses) (p. 798 [8]). Henry noted that the ultimate maximum of 72% was less than the Carnot thermodynamic limit of ∼93% due to the light emission losses of high-efficiency solar cells. Such losses are readily evident in the highest efficiency direct bandgap solar cells with negligible nonradiative recombination losses but strong radiative light emission (LED behavior) when
BANDGAP VOLTAGE, UNDOPED QUANTUM WELL SOLAR CELLS
99
placed in forward bias with no sunlight exposure. This band edge emission definitely does not have the spectral distribution shape of black body radiation. The maximum low injection efficiencies were calculated and presented in figures 1.12 and 1.13 of the First Edition [5] for abrupt single p/n junction devices as a function of bandgap. For both unconcentrated and concentrated sunlight spectra, these maxima were in the 35–37% range for bandgaps between ∼1.1 and 1.4 eV in approximate agreement with Henry [54]. Such efficiency values apparently require sunlight concentration at least at 1.1-eV bandgaps. To stay in the low injection regime, the light-generated carrier concentrations would need to stay below the ∼1017 cm−3 range because the majority carrier doping in realistic devices are typically in the mid ∼1017 cm−3 levels. However, Figure 4.5a indicates that light-generated minority carrier concentrations would need to get the 1018 to 1019 cm−3 range for open-circuit voltages to approach bandgap level values. Unfortunately, low injection restrictions would then require 1019 to 1020 cm−3 majority carrier concentrations that essentially kills minority carrier lifetimes. In essence, low injection, abrupt p/n junctions are fundamentally blocked from achieving open-circuit voltages of bandgap magnitudes. In a typical 1017 to 1018 cm−3 doped abrupt p/n junction solar cell, one can attempt to shine enough light on it for high injection operation with light-generated carrier concentrations exceeding the doping levels and splitting the quasi-Fermi levels to near the band edges. However, such heavy doping decreases excited carrier lifetimes in semiconductors in general and in direct bandgap semiconductors in particular. For the latter, radiative recombination lifetime is determined by the Einstein coefficient and is inversely proportional to the doping level ([55]; Table 1.3 [5]). Hence, this radiative component of recombination lifetime can be decreased by many orders of magnitude when little or no doping is used. Combining this with excellent surface passivation and with heterojunctions that keep quantum well excited carriers away from high surface recombination velocity ohmic contacts, much higher carrier concentrations and levels of Fermi splitting to band edges become possible. In this case, the heterojunction n+ and p+ regions provide the collapse of the quasi-Fermi levels into single levels at opposite band edges so that the metal contacts provide actual open-circuit voltages at the band edge, equal to the splitting values of the quasi-Fermi levels in the quantum well (see Figs. 4.6 and 4.17b). An exemplary example is the same Figure 4.4 structure except that the 0.5-μm p emitter and the 3.5-μm n base are replaced by a 4.0-micron thick undoped GaAs layer of very high quality. Dividing the champion GaAs concentrator cell of 28.2% efficiency by its voltage loss factor VF = 0.823, the undoped quantum well design should be able to support efficiencies approaching 34% if its ohmic contacts can be made to accommodate the high current densities that would correspond to the sunlight concentration ratios that can provide band edge quasi-Fermi level splitting. An alternate quantum well structure is intrinsic amorphous Si surrounded by thin a-Si carbide (or silicon nitride) heterojuctions of higher bandgap that are heavily doped n and p types except for the 10–20 Å adjacent to the well as needed to keep the “minority” carriers in the well from tunneling into the very high
100
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS
density of majority carriers in the barrier materials. To date, such heterojuction barriers to amorphous Si have only been applied to its top surface, and this does not provide a quantum well. Additionally, these could be capped by thin, heavily doped n and p a-Si to provide the final transition between the barrier layers and the metal contacts for better alignment of band edges in the well with the metal Fermi levels. The projected efficiencies of such high injection, undoped quantum well devices in tandem two-junction structures are plotted in Figure 4.16 as a function of the top cell bandgap with constant light-generated carrier concentration shown as contours. The bandgap pairs that provide matched junction–maximum power– current densities are (1.3 eV, 0.55 eV), (1.4 eV, 0.62 eV), (1.5 eV, 0.83 eV), (1.6 eV, 1.0 eV), and (1.7 eV, 1.2 eV) for efficiencies over 50%, slightly exceeding the values calculated by Henry [54]. The equilibrium and light-exposed energy band diagram is shown schematically in Figure 4.17 for a 1.7- and 1.2-eV tandem device interconnected via a p+/n+ tunnel junction with the actual structural layout shown as the box diagram at the bottom of Figure 4.17a for reference. For comparisons, 60 cm–3
1019 50
Efficiency η (%)
40 GaAa/GaSb 100X
1016 30
InP/GaInAs 50X
1013
20
1010 10 107
104
0 1.0
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
2.0
2.2
2.4
2.6
2.8
Top Junction Bandgap Energy εG (eV)
Figure 4.16. The theoretical efficiency for current matched, two-junction solar cells under high injection AM1.5D sunlight for constant light-generated carrier concentration values plus experimental data points. The solid line curve corresponds to the highest achieved concentration levels listed in Figure 4.5 and Table 4.2.
BANDGAP VOLTAGE, UNDOPED QUANTUM WELL SOLAR CELLS
101
Figure 4.17. Two-quantum well, high injection solar cell diodes of two different well bandgaps, interconnected by a tunnel junction for the production of open-circuit voltages that are a larger fraction of the bandgap values to provide higher conversion efficiencies. In (b), the bandgap voltage condition is shown with the split of the quasi-Fermi levels just beyond the band edges for an open-circuit voltage just greater than the sum of the two-well bandgaps equaling 2.9 V. Diagrams are proportioned for clear labeling of features and are not to scale.
performance data points for two champion tandem dual junction cells are shown to indicate the current state of the art (for low injection, abrupt p/n junction devices). As one indication of the practicality of such band edge quasi-Fermi splitting operation is comparison to high-efficiency LEDs with conversion efficiencies of
102
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS
over 50% (narrow band light ouput power divided by DC input power) [56]. They achieve such bandgap splitting both with DC voltages applied to the LED contacts and also by optical pumping [57]. LEDs operate in just the opposite way from solar cells—DC electricity goes in and visible light comes out [58]. The most efficient LED conversion one can imagine is the application of a voltage just greater than the quantum well bandgap so that every electron that enters a LED quantum well combines with a valence band hole to produce a photon with the same magnitude electron volt energy as the applied voltage. This is the reverse analogue for the most efficient conversion of fixed electron volt photons into electrons flowing into the solar cell contacts at the corresponding voltage V described earlier in this chapter. Even though high-efficiency LEDs typically have many more quantum wells of much lower thickness than solar cells, all of the same bandgap, with no tunnel junction electrical interconnects, and various narrow bandwidth features like quantum dots and distributed Bragg structures [59, 60], they still provide existence proof that bandgap quasi-Fermi splitting is possible optically in quantum well structures. The 50% solar cell efficiency challenge will be to see how high the light-generated carrier concentrations can be raised as wells are made with no doping, with extremely low defect levels, and with nearly perfect boundaries to heterojunctions and to surface passivation layers. One limit will be the maximum current densities and light concentration ratios that can be tolerated by the interconnect tunnel junctions even when they are fabricated by highly precise techniques like molecular beam epitaxy. An estimate of the maximum theoretical conversion efficiencies of solar cells with many junctions all operating with open-circuit voltages of bandgap magnitudes is obtained by taking the thermodynamic limit (Carnot efficiency maximum ∼93%) and subtracting the unavoidable losses loss due to re-emmision of (LED) light (as recommended by Henry [54]). Considering undoped direct band p-i-n gap quantum well solar cells whose dark currents are dominated by radiative recombination, the worst case loss corresponds to an open-circuit voltage where all (100%) of the absorbed optical energy is lost due to radiative recombination. This “ideal” device is then operated at a maximum power voltage, Vm, which lowers its “dark current” and its corresponding radiative recombination losses by more than 95% (see such >95% reduction in dark current in the champion cell with a fill factor of 85% of figure 1.2 of the First Edition [5]). This indicates that theoretical maximum efficiencies are in the 85–90% range that falls to the ∼80–85% levels after downward adjustments for realistic material parameter values versus “ideal” ones (see [5]).
4.10
CONCLUSIONS
Fifty years of quantum mechanics theory development followed by 50 years of its application to solid-state electronic device problems have led to solar cell efficiency performance increasing from ∼1% to over 40% currently. Solar cell theory
CONCLUSIONS
103
continues to predict substantially higher efficiencies when high excited carrier concentrations are considered. As existence proofs, LEDs have achieved excited carrier concentrations at the high levels (that penetrate band edges at ∼1019 cm−3) where greatly improved performance is projected for solar cells. These high carrier concentrations correspond to diode operation where the quasi-Fermi levels split to the bandgap edges. They also correspond to terminal voltages that approximately equal the bandgaps of the photoactive regions. In retrospect, it is intuitive that such operation corresponds to the highest possible conversion efficiency. However, no current champion solar cells have come close to demonstrating open-circuit voltages at bandgap levels. The associated deficit is directly described by the voltage fraction VF shown in Figure 4.5 and identifies a promising area for substantial future device performance improvements. Prior modeling has projected 50% terrestrial efficiencies for two-junction cells at 1000X sunlight concentration that rise to 72% for 36 tandem junctions, ignoring the losses in the interconnect tunnel junctions [8, 54]. Bandgap open-circuit voltage values should assist with the challenges of exceeding 50% efficiency levels. The last 15 years has provided wide technical and market experience with solar cell configurations that depart dramatically from the traditional Shockley diode abrupt p/n junction geometry with one-dimensional symmetry. These include the a-Si, the point contact, the IBC, and the HIT solar cells. All of these except the point contact one are currently commercially successful products. And all but the first use crystalline silicon as the primary photo active component. All use textured surfaces to enhance light absorbance and trapping, and all use high doping of the regions next to the metal contacts to assure good ohmic contact formation and Fermi level alignments with the nearest band edges. Except for the HIT cell, none have applied the Nobel Prize-winning concept of a quantum well heterojunction barrier to shield excited carriers in a photoactive region from the high recombination properties of ohmic contacts. Combining the lessons learned from analyzing their behavior with the insights gained from LEDs, it appears that abrupt p/n junctions are not required for the highest efficiency performance. Indeed, under low injection limits, one is fundamentally blocked from achieving such Fermi levels bandgap splitting performance. So far, the non-abrupt configuration has not been applied to the multijunction III–V devices that currently provide the 40% efficiency levels of performance. They achieved their improvements mainly by reducing the losses of absorbed photon energy that lie above the bandgap of the absorbing material. The opportunities for improvement in improved voltage fraction VF arise from reducing the photon energy losses below the bandgap. The latter involves two components. One is the quasi-Fermi level bandgap splitting from high excited carrier concentrations. Direct bandgap materials are likely preferred due to their comparatively higher absorption coefficients to provide high light absorption in thinner layers and their absence of significant non-radiative recombination losses. The other is using heavily doped semiconductor regions next to the metal contacts to align the metal Fermi level to the associated band edge in the solar cell. The latter becomes particularly effective when implemented with the quantum well
104
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS
heterojunction barriers. In addition, suggested options are recommended improvements to the crystalline silicon configurations for higher performance, mainly by implementing the quantum well and heterojunction barrier configuration pioneered with HIT solar cells. Summarizing the rationale for p-i-n quantum well concentrator solar cells, if the light-generated carrier concentrations can be made to equal or to exceed the standard doped semiconductor concentration levels, there is no longer any need for doping. Once generated, carriers have no memory of coming from either thermal ionization of dopants or from optical absorption of photons and thus reduce the resistive effects by equivalent amounts. However, elimination of doping can greatly increase the excited carrier lifetimes and the associated lightgenerated carrier concentrations, particularly when all cell boundaries are passivated or have heterojunction barriers shielding excited carriers from ohmic contacts’ high surface recombination. The highest possible efficiency conversion occurs by the absorption of photons with energies just above the quantum well bandgap that produce carriers that exit the solar cell with a voltage equal to the well bandgap value. Such voltage generation in the metal contact requires the metal Fermi levels to align with the well band edges, which only occurs at high doping levels and when the high light-generated carrier concentration splits the quasi-Fermi levels all the way to the band edges. Such highly doped semiconductor layers are typically optically dead and should thus be kept as thin as possible to reduce their light absorption losses. Carrier transport parameters fundamentally reduce the power delivered out of the cell by the fill factor FF ratio. However, much higher conversion efficiencies should be made possible than any current champion devices exhibit, as open-circuit voltages are made to approach quantum well bandgap values.
ABBREVIATIONS A—solar cell junction area a—atomic spacing of a semiconductor Al—aluminum AlGaAs—aluminum gallium arsenide AM1.5D—1.5 air mass direct component of sunlight a-Si—amorphous silicon ASTM—American Society of Testing and Materials c—speed of light in free space CdS—cadium sulfide CdTe—cadmium telluride CIGS—copper indium gallium diselenide Cu—copper CuxS—copper sulfide DC—direct current
ABBREVIATIONS
105
EN—black body radiation energy of N photons of frequency f E(x)—electric field as a function of position x exp—exponential f—frequency of a light photons fe—hyperbolic function describing effects of minority carrier electron surface recombination FF—fill factor fh—hyperbolic function describing effects of minority carrier hole surface recombination FSF—front surface field F(λ)—light flux intensity of wavelength λ f(ε)—probability that a quantum state of energy ε is occupied by an electron GaAs—gallium arsenide Ge—germanium h—Planck’s constant HIT—heterojunction with intrinsic thin layer i—intrinsic I—current IBC—interdigitated back contact ITO—indium tin oxide J—current density of electrons and holes J0—Shockely diode reverse saturation current density of electrons and holes J0e—electron contribution to the Shockely diode reverse saturation current density J0h—hole contribution to the Shockely diode reverse saturation current density J L1X —one sunlight-generated current density J Lc—concentrator light-generated current density JF—current density factor of J sc J scmax JL—light-generated current density from electrons and holes Jm—maximum power current density Jn—current density of electrons Jsc—short-circuit current density J scmax—light-generated current density when external quantum efficiency equals one JTH—threshold current density in SCLI devices k—Boltzmann’s constant K—quantum wave number from Schrodinger’s equation solutions L—width of the intrinsic or low-doped region ln—natural logarithm Mc—number of equivalent minima at the conduction band edge mde—electron density-of-states effective mass mdh—hole density-of-states effective mass md/mo—density-of-states effective mass ratio n—density of electrons n0—equilibrium electron carrier density ni—intrinsic carrier density nα—electron concentration boundary condition at the forward bias electron injecting contact
106
SOLAR CELL DEVICE PHYSICS
nβ—electron concentration boundary condition opposite the forward-bias electron injecting contact N—number of photons of frequency f emitted from a black body NA—hole (or acceptor) doping density NC—effective density of conduction band states ND—electron (or donor) doping density Nv—effective density of valence band states p—density of holes p—momentum of a photon p0—equilibrium hole carrier density Pin1 X —unconcentrated one sun optical input power to the solar cell Pinc —concentrated optical input power to the solar cell PERL—passive emitter, rear locally diffused p-i-n—p-type-intrinsic-n-type structure Pin—optical input power to the solar cell p/n—abrupt junction from p-type to n-type structure Pt.—point ptio—hole concentration in ith trap at equilibrium in a SCLI device QE(λ)—quantum efficiency of the solar cell at wavelength λ q—charge of an electron R—solar cell series resistance R—specific solar cell series resistance equal to series resistance R times junction area A r(λ)—the light reflectivity of the emitter surface at wavelength λ SCLI—space charge-limited current Si—silicon SiO—silicon oxide T—absolute temperature tB—solar cell base width t B′ —undepleted solar cell base width TCO—transparent conducting oxide tE—solar cell emitter width t E′ —undepleted solar cell emitter width TiO2—titanium dioxide UV—ultraviolet vde—diffusion velocity of electrons vdh—diffusion velocity of holes VF—voltage factor of qVoc/εG Vm—maximum power voltage Voc—open-circuit voltage VTFL—trapped-filled limit voltage in SCLI devices X—sunlight concentration ratio xB—base depletion region width xE—emitter depletion region width V(r)—potential energy function value at a space vector position r
REFERENCES
107
Wn—width of n contact region of IBC solar cell Wp—width of p contact region of IBC solar cell xn—x position of emitter depletion region edge xp—x position of base depletion region edge xw—x position of base boundary next to its metal contact Zn—zinc ΔnL—light-generated change in electron concentration ΔpL—light-generated change in hole concentration ε—dielectric constant εC—energy level of conduction band edge εF—Fermi energy Δε LFe—light-induced change in electron quasi-Fermi energy Δε LFh —light-induced change in hole quasi-Fermi energy δεn—electron energy loss moving from conduction band edge to metal Fermi level δεp—hole energy loss moving from valence band edge to metal Fermi level η—efficiency ηC—concentrator efficiency ε∗Fe—quasi-Fermi energy of electrons εF0—equilibrium Fermi energy ε*Fh—quasi-Fermi energy holes εG—bandgap energy εV—energy level of valence band edge λ—wavelength of a photon of frequency f ρo(x, Φ)—charge distribution as a function of position x in a SCLI device exposed to a light intensity Φ at zero bias voltage ρI(x, Φ, V)—the change in charge distribution as a function of position x in a SCLI device exposed to a light intensity Φ due to the application of a charge injecting voltage V μn—electron mobility π—the universal mathematical constant “pi” ΦK(r)—electronic wave function of quantum number K is a vector position in space r