Solaris

6WDQLVãDZ/HP 6RODULV

)RUGtWRWWD 0XUiQ\L%HDWUL[

6WDQLVODZ/HP 6RODULV 5HJpQ\ .ULWHULRQ.|Q\YNLDGy %XNDUHVW

11&/Y

6WDQLVODZ/HP6RODULV :\GDZQLFWZR021:DUV]DYD $ODSNLDGiV6WDQLVODZ/HP6RODULV (XUySD.|Q\YNLDGy%XGDSHVW

%HQFVLN-iQRVUDM]DLYDO

0HJpUNH]pV

)HGpO]HWLLG V]HULQWWL]HQNLOHQFyUDNRUE~FV~WLQWHWWHP D] DNQD N|UO iOOyNQDN pV OHPiV]WDP D IpPOpWUiQ D IONpEHeSSHQDQQ\LKHO\YROWEHQQHKRJ\DN|Q\|N|PHW I|OHPHOKHVVHP +UUXKiP FVDWODNR]yMiW D IDOEyO NLiOOy YH]HWpNEH LOOHV]WHWWHP D V]NDIDQGHU IHOI~YyGRWW pV PRF FDQQLVHPHQJHGHWWW|EEp$IpPEXURNNDOHJ\WHVWWpYiOYD iOOWDP²YDJ\LVLQNiEEOyJWDP²DOHYHJiJ\EDQ )HOSLOODQWRWWDP D GRPERU~ DEODNRQ iW D] DNQD IDOD OiWV]RWW PpJ IHOMHEE SHGLJ D] DNQD I|Op KDMOy 0RGGDUG DUFD'HU|JW|QHOLVW,QWpVV|WpWOHWWPHUWOHHUHV]WHWWpN DV~O\RVYpGNXSROiW1\ROFV]RUHJ\PiVXWiQIHOE~JWDND FVDYDURNDWPHJK~]yYLOODQ\PRWRURN$]WiQV]LV]HJ KDQJ MHOH]WH KRJ\ OHYHJW ERFViWDQDN D UH]JpVFVLOODStWyNED 6]HPHPODVVDQKR]]iV]RNRWWDV|WpWVpJKH]0iUOiWWDPD] HJ\HWOHQPpUyUDKDOYiQ\]|OGN|UYRQDOiW ².pV]HQYDJ\.HOYLQ"²KDQJ]RWWDIOKDOOJDWyEyO ².pV]HQ0RGGDUG²IHOHOWHP ² 1H OHJ\HQ JRQGRG VHPPLUH $] ÉOORPiV IRJDG ²EL]WDWRWW²6]HUHQFVpVXWDW 0LHOWW YiODV]ROKDWWDP YROQD IHQW YDODPL FVLNRUJiV WiPDGW pV D IONH PHJUi]NyGRWW $NDUDWODQXO LV PLQGHQ L]PRPDWPHJIHV]tWHWWHPGHD]WiQQHPW|UWpQWVHPPL ² 0LNRU LQGXORN" ² NpUGH]WHP ]L]HJpV KDOODWV]RWW PLQWKDILQRPKRPRNSHUHJQHDPHPEUiQUD ² 0iULV UHSOV] .HOYLQ 0LQGHQ MyW ² IHOHOW 0RGGDUG N|]HOL KDQJMD 0pJ IHO VHP RFV~GWDP DPLNRU V]pOHV UpV Q\tOW D] DUFRP HOWW pV D]RQ iW PHJOiWWDP D FVLOODJRNDW +LiED LJ\HNH]WHP I|OIHGH]QL N|]WN D 9t]|QW $OIiMiW DPHUUH D 3URPpWKHXV] UHSO 1HP LVPHUWHP D 7HM~W UHQGV]HUQHN H]W D UpV]pW HJ\HWOHQ FVLOODJNpSHW VHP WXG WDP D]RQRVtWDQL V]LNUi]y SRU YLOORJRWW D NHVNHQ\ DEODN HOWW 9iUWDP PLNRU NH]G KXQ\RURJQL D] HOV FVLOODJ 'H QHP YHWWHP pV]UH &VDN KDOYiQ\RGWDN pV HOWQHGH]WHN EHOHPRVyGWDNDY|U|VHVVpIDNXOyKiWWpUEH5iM|WWHPKRJ\ PiU D OpJN|U IHOV UpWHJHLEHQ MiURN 0HUHYHQ iOOWDP D 

OpJSiUQiN N|]W FVDN PDJDP HOp Qp]KHWWHP $ KRUL]RQW PpJ PRVW VHP OiWV]RWW 5HSOWHP pV UHSOWHP DQpONO KRJ\ pUH]WHP YROQD GH ODVVDQ DODWWRPRVDQ HO|QW|WW D IRUUyViJ 2GDNLQW KDON pOHV FVLNRUJiV NH]GG|WW PLQWKD IpPPHO NDUFROQiQDN QHGYHV YHJHW $ PpUyUD NLV DEOD NiEDQ XJUiQGR]y V]iPRN QpONO IRJDOPDP VHP OHWW YROQDPLO\HQVHEHVHQ]XKDQRN$FVLOODJRNPiUHOW,QWHN 9|U|VHV IpQ\ W|OW|WWH EH D NpPOHOQ\tOiVW )OHPEHQ GREROW D YpU pJHWW D] DUFRP WDUNyPUD KLGHJHW I~MW D KV]DEiO\R]y VDMQiOWDP KRJ\ QHP YHWKHWWHP E~FV~SLOODQWiVW D 3URPpWKHXV]UD ² Q\LOYiQ PiU OiWyWiYROViJRQNtYOYROWDPLNRUD]DXWRPDWDEHUHQGH]pV NLQ\LWRWWDDNpPOHODEODNRW )ONpP HJ\HWNHWWW Ui]NyGRWW pV HOYLVHOKHWHWOHQO UH ]HJQL NH]GHWW D YLEUiOiV iWKDWROW D V]LJHWHOUpWHJHNHQ pV OpJSiUQiNRQH]HUQ\LW,YHOI~UyGRWWDYHOPEHDPpUyUD ]|OGN|UYRQDODHOPRVyGRWW+LGHJYpUUHOQp]WHP1HPD]pUW M|Y|NLO\HQPHVV]LUOKRJ\DFpOQiOHOSXV]WXOMDN ² 6RODULV ÉOORPiV ² PRQGWDP ² 6RODULV ÉOORPiV 6RODULVÉOORPiV&VLQiOMDWRNPiUYDODPLWÔJ\pU]HPEDM YDQDVWDELOL]iFLyYDO6RODULVÉOORPiVLWWD]pUNH]9pWHO eV PHJLQW HOV]DODV]WRWWDP HJ\ IRQWRV SLOODQDWRW D ERO\JyIHOW,QpVpW+DWDOPDVDQODSRVDQWHUOWHODODWWDP FVDNDIHOV]tQpQK~]yGyViYRNPpUHWHPXWDWWDKRJ\PpJ PHVV]H YDJ\RN 9DJ\LV LQNiEE ² PDJDVDQ PHUW PiU iWOpSWHP D]W D PHJIRJKDWDWODQ KDWiUW DPLNRU HJ\ pJLWHVW WiYROViJDPDJDVViJJiYiOLN=XKDQWDP(J\UH]XKDQWDP 0RVW PiU pUH]WHP PpJ DNNRU LV KD EHKXQ\WDP D V]H PHP'HU|JW|QNLQ\LWRWWDPKRJ\PLQpOW|EEHWOiVVDN 9iUWDP YDJ\ HJ\ IpO SHUFHW D]WiQ PHJLVPpWHOWHP D KtYiVW 0RVW VHP NDSWDP YiODV]W $ OpJN|UL NLVOpVHN VRUW,]V]HU, G|UGOpVHLN|]|WWFVDNKDONPRUDMKDOODWV]RWW D IOKDOOJDWyEyO RO\DQ PpO\ pV |EO|V PLQWKD D ERO\Jy KDQJMD OHQQH $ NpPOHOQ\tOiVW KiO\RJ IXWRWWD EH pV HOWDNDUWD D QDUDQFVY|U|V HJHW $] DEODN HOV|WpWOW DND UDWODQXO |VV]HUiQGXOWDP DPHQQ\LUH D OpJSiUQD HQJHGWH GH D N|YHWNH] SLOODQDWEDQ UiM|WWHP KRJ\ IHOKEHQ YDJ\RN $ IHOKUpWHJ IHOU|SSHQW PLQWKD HOI~MWiN YROQD +RO IpQ\EHQ KRO iUQ\pNEDQ VLNORWWDP WRYiEE D IONH IRUJRWW D KRVV]WHQJHO\H N|UO pV D KDWDOPDV SXIIDGW



QDSWiQ\pU PpOWyViJRVDQ HO~V]RWW D] DUFRP HOWW EDOUyO EXNNDQW IHO pV MREEUD W,QW HO $ G|UJpVHQ pV D PRUDMRQ NHUHV]WOWiYROLKDQJNH]GHWWDIOHPEHGXUX]VROQL ² 6RODULV ÉOORPiV KtYMD D] pUNH]W 6RODULV ÉOORPiV KtYMD D] pUNH]W 0LQGHQ UHQGEHQ $] pUNH] D] ÉOORPiV HOOHQU]pVHDODWWYDQ6RODULVÉOORPiV]HQLD]pUNH]QHN NpV]OM|Q IHO D QXOOD PiVRGSHUFNRU W|UWpQ OHV]iOOiVUD ILJ\HOHP NH]GHP .HWWV]i]|WYHQ NHWWV]i]QHJ\YHQ NLOHQFNHWWV]i]QHJ\YHQQ\ROF   $ V]DYDNDW HOYiODV]Wy U|YLG VtSROiVRN HOiUXOWiN KRJ\ QHP pO HPEHU EHV]pO (] HQ\KpQ V]yOYD IXUFVD YROW 5HQGV]HULQWD]HJpV]WiUVDViJNLURKDQDUHSOWpUUHD]~M HPEHU HOp NLYiOW KD HJ\HQHVHQ D )|OGUO M|Q 'H QHP VRNiLJ W|SUHQJKHWWHPH]HQ PHUW D] yULiVL NDULND DPLW D QDS UDM]ROW N|UpP KLUWHOHQ WyWiJDVW iOOW D VtNViJJDO HJ\WW DPHO\ IHOp UHSOWHP D]WiQ iWELOOHQW HOOHQNH] LUiQ\EDKLQWi]WDPPLQWDV~O\HJ\KDWDOPDVLQJiQpVD V]pGOpVVHO NV]N|GYH PHJSLOODQWRWWDP D ERO\Jy IDONpQW IHOPHUHG SLV]NRVOLOD pV IHNHWpV ViYRNNDO EDUi]GiOW YpJWHOHQVtNMiQHJ\ ]|OGIHKpUQpJ\]HWHVSLFL VDNNWiEOiW D] ÉOORPiV LUiQ\tWyMHOpW (EEHQ D SHUFEHQ QDJ\RW FVDWWDQYD HOYiOW YDODPL D IONH WHWHMpWO ² D KRV] V]~ Q\DN~ J\,U,V HMWHUQ\EH YDGXO EHOHNDSRWW D V]pO HOPRQGKDWDWODQXO I|OGL t]H YROW HQQHN D KDQJQDN KRV] V]~KyQDSRNyWDD]HOV LJD]LV]pO]~JiV $] HVHPpQ\HN J\RUVXOy LUDPEDQ N|YHWWpN HJ\PiVW (GGLJ FVDN WXGWDP KRJ\ ]XKDQRN 0RVW OiWWDP $ ]|OG IHKpUVDNNWiEODURKDPRVDQQWWIHOLVPHUWHPDKRVV]~NiV WHVWHW DPHO\UH UiIHVWHWWpN H]VW|VHQ IpQ\O FHWKDO ROGDOiEyO UDGDUDQWHQQiN Q\~OWDN NL IDOiQ DEODNVRURN V|WpWOHWWHN PiUD] LV OiWV]RWW KRJ\ D IpPNRORVV]XV QHP DERO\JyIHOV]tQpQQ\XJV]LNKDQHPI|O|WWHOHEHJ²DWLQWD IHNHWHKiWWpUHQRWW~V]LNiUQ\pNiQDNPpJV|WpWHEEWRMiV GDG IROWMD 8J\DQDNNRU PHJSLOODQWRWWDP D] yFHiQ OXVWiQ PR]Jy OLOD KiW~ EDUi]GiLW D IHOKN KLUWHOHQ D PDJDVED V]|NWHN SHUHPN EtERUY|U|VHQ OiQJROW N|]WN V]UNpVQDUDQFFViIDNXOWDODSRVWiYROLpJD]WiQPLQGHQ |VV]HIRO\W GXJyK~]yED NHUOWHP 0LHOWW PHJV]yODOKDW WDP YROQD HJ\ J\RUV WpV YLVV]DSRIR]WD D IONpW IJJ OHJHV KHO\]HWpEH D NpPOHODEODNEDQ KLJDQ\RV IpQQ\HO FVLOODQW IHO D N|G|V OiWyKDWiULJ KXOOiP]y yFHiQ D] 

HMWHUQ\ FVDWWRJy KX]DODL pV J\,U,L KLUWHOHQ OHYiOWDN D V]pOPHVV]H VRGRUWD NHW D KXOOiPRNI|O|WW D IONHSHGLJ D PHVWHUVpJHV HUWpUUH MHOOHP] VDMiWRV ODVVtWRWW PR]JiVVDO V]HOtGHQ KLQWi]RWW OHIHOp 8WROMiUD QpKiQ\ QpJ\]HWHV UHSONDWDSXOW pV NpW DOLJKDQHP W|EE HPHOHW PDJDV FVLSNpVUiGLyWHOHV]NySHUQ\ YLOODQW IHO D V]HPHP HOWWeOHVUXJDOPDVDFpOFVDWWDQiVVDOPHJiOOWDIONHYD ODPL NLQ\tOW DODWWDP pV D IpPGRER] KDSWiNEDQ iOOy XWDViYDO QDJ\RW V]XVV]DQYD EHIHMH]WH V]i]Q\ROFYDQ NLOR PpWHUHVXWD]iViW ² 6RODULV ÉOORPiV 1XOOD PiVRGSHUF $ OHV]iOOiV EHIH MH]G|WW9pJH²GDUiOWDJpSLHVHQD]HOOHQU] EHUHQGH]pV 0HJUDJDGWDP D NpWROGDOW YiOOPDJDVViJEDQ NLiOOy IRJDQW\~NDWIXUFVDQ\RPiVQHKH]HGHWWDPHOOHPUHEHOV V]HUYHLPPLQWKDyORPEyOOHWWHNYROQD pVV]pWNDSFVROWDP DN|OG|N]VLQyUW=|OGEHW,V)g/'IHOLUDWJ\XOODGWNLpVD IONH IDOD PHJQ\tOW D OHYHJiJ\ HQ\KpQ KiWED WDV]tWRWW HOUHNHOOHWWOpSQHPKRJ\HOQHHVVHN 6]NDIDQGHUHP PpOD VyKDMKR] KDVRQOy KDON V]LV]HJpV VHOHUHV]WHWWHNLDOHYHJW6]DEDGYROWDP (]VW W|OFVpU PDJDV NXSROiMD DODWW iOOWDP )DOiQ V]tQHV FV|YHN N|WHJHL iJD]WDN V]pW pV W,QWHN HO NHUHN Q\tOiVRNEDQ +iWUDQp]WHP $ V]HOO]DEODNRN ]~JYD V]tY WiN NL D OHV]iOOiVQiO EHKDWROW PpUJH] ERO\JyOpJ PDUDG YiQ\DLW 6]LYDU DODN~ IONpP HJ\ DFpOSDG FVpV]HIRUPD PpO\HGpVpEHQ iOOW UHVHQ PLQW D I|OUHSHGW VHO\HPJXEy %RUtWyOHPH]HL SLV]NRVEDUQiUD S|UN|OGWHN /HPHQWHP D NLV OHMWQ ,QQHQ pUGHV P,DQ\DJ UpWHJ IHGWH D IpPSDGOyW $ UDNpWDV]iOOtWy NRFVLN ² N|]|QVpJHV NHUHNHV NRUGpN ² KHO\HQNpQW HJpV]HQ D] DFpOLJ NLNRSWDWWiN $ V]HOO]WHW V]LYDWW\~N KLUWHOHQ HOKDOOJDWWDN pV QpPD FV|QG WiPDGW .LVVp WDQiFVWDODQXO Qp]HOGWHP YiUWDP KRJ\ YDODNL HOM|Q GH HJ\ OpOHN VHP PXWDWNR]RWW &VDN HJ\ YLOiJtWy QHRQQ\tO WHVVpNHOW D KDQJWDODQXO VLNOy PR]JyMiUGD IHOp 5iOpSWHP $ FVDUQRN PHQQ\H]HWH V]pSHQ OHMW SDUD ERODtYYHO ROYDGW EHOH D FVV]HU, IRO\RVyED $ IDOPp O\HGpVHNEHQ KDORPED GREiOW Ji]SDODFNRN J\,U,V HMW HUQ\N WDUWiO\RN OiGiN KHYHUWHN HJ\PiV KHJ\pQKiWiQ (]W LV IXUFViOORWWDP $ PR]JyMiUGD RGiLJ YLWW DKRO D IRO\RVy NHUHN KHO\LVpJEH WRUNROOLN 2WW PpJ QDJ\REE YROW



D UHQGHWOHQVpJ 2ODMRV WyFVD N~V]RWW HO D JDUPDGiED KiQ\W EiGRJNDQQiN DOyO .HOOHPHWOHQ E,]W iUDV]WRWW $ UDJDFVRV IRO\DGpNEDQ MyO OiWV]RWWDN D NO|QE|] LUiQ\ED LQGXOy OiEQ\RPRN $ EiGRJNDQQiN N|]|WW IHKpU WiYtUyV]DODJNtJ\yNSDStUFDIDWRNpV KXOODGpNRNKHYHUWHN PLQWKD LGH V|S|UQpN D V]HPHWHW D NDELQRNEyO 0HJLQW NLJ\XOODGW HJ\ ]|OG Q\tO D N|]pSV DMWy IHOp LUiQ\tWRWW 6],NIRO\RVyED MXWRWWDPDPHO\EHQ NpW HPEHU DOLJ PHKH WHWW YROQD HO HJ\PiV PHOOHWW eJUH Qp] OHQFVpV YHJ, WHWDEODNRN YLOiJtWRWWiN PHJ ÔMDEE ]|OGIHKpU QpJ\]HWHV DMWy)pOLJQ\LWYDiOOW%HOpSWHPÌYHOWIDO~NDELQHJ\HWOHQ QDJ\SDQRUiPDDEODNP|J|WWHDN|GIiW\RORVY|U|VpJEROW /HQW D QpPiQ YRQXOy KXOOiPRN IHNHWpV GRPEMDL $ IDODN PHQWpQ FVXSD Q\LWRWW V]HNUpQ\ EHQQN P,V]HUHN N|Q\YHN PRVDWODQ SRKDUDN SRURV WHUPRV]RN $ SLV]NRV SDGOyQ |WKDW PDJDMiUy JpSDV]WDOND N|]WN QpKiQ\ OHODSSDGW IRWHO DPHO\HNEO NLHUHV]WHWWpN D OHYHJW &VDN D] HJ\LN KiWUDG|QW|WW WiPOiM~ V]pN YROW IHOI~MYD (EEHQ QDSpJHWWH DUF~ FLQJiU HPEHUNH OW 2UUiUyO DUFFVRQWMDLUyO FDIDWRNEDQ KiPORWW D EU 0HJLVPHUWHP H] 6QDXW *LEDULDQ KHO\HWWHVH D NLEHUQHWLNXV $QQDN LGHMpQ QpKiQ\ LJHQ HUHGHWL FLNNHW WHWW N|]]p D V]RODULV]WL NDL pYN|Q\YEHQ 6]HPpO\HVHQ PpJ QHP WDOiONR]WDP YHOH /\XNDFVRV LQJHW YLVHOW DPLEO LWWRWW NLWN|]WHN ODSRV PHOONDViQDNV]V]UV]iODLPHJ SHFVpWHV WpUG, YHJ\V]H UHNNHO NLpJHWHWW KDMGDQ IHKpU YiV]RQQDGUiJRW DQQ\L ]VHEEHO PLQW HJ\ V]HUHOQHN .H]pEHQ P,DQ\DJ N|UWpW V]RURQJDWRWW ² LO\HQEO LV]QDN D PHVWHUVpJHV JUDYLWiFLy QpONOL ,UKDMyNRQ .iSUi]y V]HPPHO PHUHGW UiP (U Q\HGW XMMDL N|]O NLKXOORWW D] HGpQ\ pV NHWWWKiUPDW XJURWW D SDGOyQ PLQW HJ\ OpJJ|PE 3iU FVHSS iWOiWV]y IRO\DGpN |PO|WW NL EHOOH 6QDXW ODVVDQ KDOiOViSDGW OHWW 6]yOQLVHPEtUWDPDPHJG|EEHQpVWOpVH]DQpPDMHOHQHW RO\DQ VRNi WDUWRWW KRJ\ UpPOHWH YDODPL PHJIRJKDWDWODQ PyGRQ UiP LV iWUDJDGW (OLQGXOWDP IHOp gVV]HNXQ NRURGRWWDIRWHOEDQ ² 6QDXW   ² VXWWRJWDP 0HJUiQGXOW PLQWKD DUFXO W|WWHP YROQD +LGHJOHOV LV]RQ\DWWDO PHUHGW UiP pV UHNHGWHQK|U|JWH ²eQQHPLVPHUOHNpQQHPLVPHUOHNPLWDNDUV]   " 

$ NL|PO|WW IRO\DGpN J\RUVDQ SiUROJRWW $ONRKROV]DJRW pUH]WHP ,YRWW" 5pV]HJ" 'H PLWO LMHGW PHJ HQQ\LUH" )|OGEH J\|NHUH]YH iOOWDP D V]RED N|]HSpQ 7pUGHP UH PHJHWW IOHPEH PLQWKD YDWWiW GXJWDN YROQD eUH]WHP WDOSDP DODWW D SDGOyW GH ~J\ UpPOHWW KRJ\ PpJ H] VHP HJpV]HQEL]WRV$GRPERU~DEODNYHJP|J|WWODVVDQPR] JRWW D] yFHiQ 6QDXW PDNDFVXO EiPXOW YpUHV V]HPpYHO $UFiQ I|OHQJHGHWWD IpOHOHP GH D OHtUKDWDWODQ XQGRU QHP W,QWHOUyOD ² 0L YDQ YHOHG"    ² NpUGH]WHP KDONDQ ² %HWHJ YDJ\" ²+RJ\DJJyGV]pUWHP  ²V]yODOWPHJIRMWRWWKDQJRQ ² 1DJ\V]HU, 7H PDMG YLJ\i]RO UiP PL" 'H PLpUW pQUiP"eQQHPLVPHUOHN ²+ROYDQ*LEDULDQ" ² IDJJDWWDP(J\ SLOODQDWUD HOiOOW D OpOHJ]HWH V]HPH ~MEyO YHJHVVp YiOW YDODPL IHOOREEDQW pVNLDOXGWEHQQH ²*L  JLED²KHEHJWH²QHPQHP +DQJWDODQ HV]HOV YLKRJiV Ui]WD PHJ PHO\ KLUWHOHQ DEEDPDUDGW ² *LEDULDQKR] M|WWpO   " ² ILUWDWWD FVDNQHP Q\X JRGWDQ²*LEDULDQKR]"eVPLWDNDUV]YHOHFVLQiOQL" ÔJ\ PpUHJHWHWW PLQWKD PRVW HJ\V]HUUH iUWDOPDWODQQi YiOWDPYROQDJ\LONRVPHJYHWpV iUDGWD V]DYDLEyOpV PpJ LQNiEEDKDQJMiEyO ²0LNHWEHV]pOV]  ²GDGRJWDPNiEXOWDQ²+ROYDQ" (OK,OYHPHUHGWUiP ²1HPWXGRG   " 5pV]HJ JRQGROWDP +ROWUpV]HJ )HOIRUUW D] HSpP (J\V]HU,HQ RWW NHOOHWW YROQD KDJ\QRP GH NLIRJ\WDP D EpNHW,UpVEO ² 7pUM PiU pV]KH] ² I|UPHGWHP Ui ² +RQQDQ WXGKDWQiPKRJ\KROYDQPLNRUPRVWpUNH]WHP0LYDQ YHOHG6QDXW" /HHVHWWD]iOOD0HJLQWHODNDGWDOpOHJ]HWHGHYDODKRJ\ PiVNpSS pV HJ\V]HUUH YLOiJRVViJ J\~OW NL D V]HPpEHQ 5HV]NHW NH]pYHO PHJUDJDGWD D IRWHO NDUIiMiW pV QDJ\ QHKH]HQWDOSUDiOOWFVDN~J\URSRJWDND]t]OHWHL ²+RJ\"²NpUGH]WHPDMGQHPNLMy]DQRGYD²eUNH]WpO" +RQQDQpUNH]WpO" 

² $ )|OG QHYH]HW, ERO\JyUyO ² GK|QJWHP ² +DOORWWiO PiUUyOD"ÔJ\OiWV]LNQHP ²$)|  8UDPLVWHQ  DNNRUWHYDJ\  .HOYLQ" ²3HUV]H0LWQp]HO~J\"0LYDQH]HQFVRGiONR]QLYDOy" ²6HPPL²IHOHOWHV,U,QKXQ\RURJYD²6HPPL 0HJW|U|OWHDKRPORNiW ² 1H KDUDJXGM .HOYLQ LJD]iQ VHPPL FVDN WXGRG D PHJOHSHWpV1HPV]iPtWRWWDPUiG ²+RJ\KRJ\QHPV]iPtWRWWiO"+LV]HQPiUKyQDSRNNDO H]HOWW PHJNDSWiWRN D] pUWHVtWpVW pV 0RGGDUG PD LV WiYLUDWR]RWWD3URPpWKHXV]UyO   ² ,JHQ ,JHQ   SHUV]H FVDN WXGRG LWW PRVW HJ\ NLV  IHOIRUGXOiVYDQ ²$]WOiWRP²MHJ\H]WHPPHJPRJRUYiQ²(OpJN|QQ\, pV]UHYHQQL 6QDXW N|UOMiUW PLQWKD ,UUXKiPDW YL]VJiOJDWQi SH GLJDYLOiJOHJN|]|QVpJHVHEEV]NDIDQGHUHYROWYH]HWpNpV NiEHON|WHJJHODPHOOpQ.|KLQWHWWQpKiQ\DW0HJG|U]V|OWH FVRQWRVRUUiW ² 1HP DNDUV] HVHWOHJ PHJIU|GQL   " %L]WRVDQ MyW WHQQH.pNDMWyDW~OVyROGDORQ ².|V]|Q|P,VPHUHPD]ÉOORPiVEHRV]WiViW ²1HPHQQpOYDODPLW   " ²1HP+ROYDQ*LEDULDQ" $] DEODNKR] VpWiOW PLQWKD QHP KDOODQi +iWXOUyO VRNNDO |UHJHEEQHN OiWV]RWW 5|YLGUH Q\tUW KDMD V] YROW QDSpJHWWH WDUNyMiW PpO\ UiQFRN EDUi]GiOWiN 2GDNLQW FVLOORJYD HPHONHGWHN pV VOO\HGWHN D URSSDQW KXOOiPRN iP RO\DQ ODVVDQ PLQWKD D] yFHiQ PHJGHUPHGW YROQD .LWHNLQWYH ~J\ UpPOHWW KRJ\ D] ÉOORPiV ODVVDQ ROGDOW FV~V]LNPLQWKD OHVLNODQD HJ\ OiWKDWDWODQWDODS]DWUyO $] WiQ I|OHPHONHGLN pV XJ\DQRO\DQ OXVWiQ D PiVLN ROGDOiUD GO 'H H] DOLJKDQHP RSWLNDL FVDOyGiV YROW $ KXOOiPRN N|]WLNDWODQRNEDQQ\iONiVYpUSLURVWDMWpNV]LJHWHNJ\,OWHN |VV]H )XWy pPHO\JpV IRJRWW HO $ 3URPpWKHXV] NLPpUW UHQGMH|U|NUHHOYHV]WHWWSDUDGLFVRPQDNW,QW ² +iW Qp]G   ² V]yODOW PHJ YiUDWODQXO 6QDXW ² D] D KHO\]HW KRJ\ SLOODQDWQ\LODJ FVDN pQ   ² )HOpP IRUGXOW ,GHJHVHQ W|UGHOWH D NH]pW ² %H NHOO pUQHG D] pQ WiUVDViJRPPDO(J\HOUH6]yOtWV3DWNiQ\QDN&VDNIpQ\ 

NpSUO LVPHUV] GH QHP EDM PLQGHQNL tJ\ KtY $WWyO WDU WRNVHPPLVHPRVVDOHUyODP.O|QEHQLVKDD]HPEHU V]OHLQHN RO\DQ NR]PLNXV DPEtFLyL YROWDN PLQW D] HQ\pLPQHNDNNRUHJpV]MyNLVQpYQHNpU]LD3DWNiQ\W   ² +RO YDQ *LEDULDQ" ² LVPpWHOWHP NRQRNXO 0HJUHE EHQWDV]HPH ²6DMQiORPKRJ\tJ\IRJDGWDODN'H  QHPFVDND]pQ KLEiP (JpV]HQ NLPHQW D IHMHPEO WXGRG LWW DQQ\L PLQGHQW|UWpQW   ²6HPPLEDM²PRQGWDP²+DJ\MXNH]W6]yYDOPLYDQ *LEDULDQQDO" 1LQFV LWW D] ÉOORPiVRQ" (OUHSOW YDODKRYi" ² 1HP ² IHOHOW $ VDURNEDQ KHYHU NiEHOWHNHUFVHNHW Qp]WH ² 1HP UHSOW VHKRYi eV QHP LV IRJ eSSHQ H]pUW  W|EEHNN|]|WW   ² +RJ\DQ" ² PDNDFVNRGWDP 0pJ PRVW LV D IOHPEHQ pUH]WHP D YDWWiW pV ~J\ UpPOHWW  PLQWKD URVV]XO KDOODQpN²+RJ\pUWHGH]W"+iWKROYDQ" ² +LV]HQ PiU WXGRG ² FVDWWDQW IHO HJpV]HQ PiV KDQJRQ 2O\DQ KLGHJHQ Qp]HWW D V]HPHPEH KRJ\ EHOH ERU]RQJWDP+DUpV]HJLVEL]RQ\iUDWXGMDPLWEHV]pO ²&VDNQHPW|UWpQW   " ²'HW|UWpQW ²%DOHVHW" %yOLQWRWW 1HPFVDN LJHQW LQWHWW KDQHP KHO\HVHOWH LV UHDJiOiVRPDW ²0LNRU" ²0DKDMQDOEDQ .O|Q|V GH QHP pUH]WHP PHJUHQGOpVW $ NXUWiQ SDWWRJyNpUGpVHNpVIHOHOHWHNLQNiEEPHJQ\XJWDWWDNMy]DQ WiUJ\LODJRVViJXNNDO $]W KLWWHP PiU pUWHP HGGLJ PHJIRJKDWDWODQYLVHONHGpVpW ²eVKRJ\DQ" ² gOW|]] iW UHQGH]NHGM HO pV J\HUH YLVV]D   PRQG MXN  HJ\yUDP~OYD .LFVLWKDER]WDP ²1RMy ² 9iUM FVDN ² KtYRWW YLVV]D DPLNRU PiU D] DMWy IHOp LQGXOWDP 6DMiWRV SLOODQWiVW YHWHWW UiP /iWWDP KRJ\ NV]N|GLN 

>NpS@

>UHV@

² +iUPDQ YROWXQN LWW pV PRVW YHOHG PHJLQW KiUPDQ YDJ\XQN,VPHUHG6DUWRULXVW" ²)pQ\NpSUOPLQWWpJHG ² )HQW YDQ D ODERUDWyULXPEDQ pV QHP KLQQpP KRJ\ pMV]DNDHOWWOHM|Q GH   V]yYDO W PLQGHQHVHWUH PHJLV PHUHG +D YDODNL PiVW OiWQiO pUWHG QHP HQJHP pV QHP 6DUWRULXVWpUWHGDNNRU   ²$NNRU" 7DOiQ iORP D] HJpV] $ NpVHL QDS IpQ\pEHQ YpUHVHQ FVLOORJyIHNHWHKXOOiPRNpVHOWWNH]D]HPEHUDNLPRVW YLVV]DODNDURVV]pNpEHOHKDMWMDDIHMpWPLQWD]HOEEpV PHJLQWDNiEHOWHNHUFVHNHWQp]L ²$NNRU  QHFVLQiOMVHPPLW ².LWOiWKDWQpN".tVpUWHWHW"²UREEDQWDPNL ² eUWHOHN $]W KLV]HG PHJUOWHP 7pYHGV] 1HP YDJ\RN UOW 1HP WXGRP PiVNpSS HOPRQGDQL   HJ\H OUH .O|QEHQ OHKHW KRJ\   QHP W|UWpQLN VHPPL 0LQGHQHVHWUHWXGMUyOD$]pUWILJ\HOPH]WHWOHN ²0LUH"0LUOEHV]pOV]" ² 1H YHV]tWVG HO D IHMHG ² IRO\WDWWD FV|N|Q\|VHQ D PDJipW ² 9LVHONHGM ~J\ PLQWKD   OpJ\ PLQGHQUH HONpV]OYH /HKHWHWOHQ WXGRP 'H D]pUW SUyEiOG PHJ (] D]HJ\HWOHQPHQWVpJ1HPWXGRNMREEDW ² 'H PLW IRJRN OiWQL" ² V]LQWH RUGtWRWWDP 1HKH]HQ WUW]WHWWHPPDJDPKRJ\YiOORQQHUDJDGMDPpVMyOPHJ QH Ui]]DP DPLQW RWW O QDSpJHWWH HOJ\|W|UW NpSpYHO D VDURNED EiPXO pV V]HPOiWRPiVW HUON|GYH SUpVHO NL PLQGHQHJ\HVV]yW ²1HPWXGRP(]EL]RQ\RVpUWHOHPEHQWOHGIJJ ²+DOOXFLQiFLyN" ² 1HP (]   YDOyViJRV &VDN HJ\UH YLJ\i]]   PHJ QHWiPDGG ²0LWEHV]pOV]"²IDNDGWDPNLHOYiOWR]RWWKDQJRQ ²1HPD)|OG|QYDJ\XQN ² 3RO\WKHULXPRN" 'H KiW D]RN LJD]iQ QHP KDVRQOt WDQDN HPEHUUH ² NLiOWRWWDP 1HP WXGWDP KRJ\DQ Ui]KDWQiP IHO UpYOHWpEO PHO\ H]HNHW D YpUIDJ\DV]Wy UOWVpJHNHWVXJDOOMD ²eSSHQD]pUWRO\DQUpPHV²PRQGWDKDONDQ²6]yYDO YLJ\i]] 

²0LW|UWpQW*LEDULDQQDO" 1HPYiODV]ROW ²0LWFVLQiO6DUWRULXV" ²*\HUHHJ\yUDP~OYD 6DUNRQ IRUGXOWDP pV RWWKDJ\WDP $] DMWyEyO PpJ HJ\ V]HU YLVV]DQp]WHP $UFiW NH]pEH WHPHWYH OW DSUyQ J|U Q\HGWHQ SHFVpWHV QDGUiJEDQ &VDN PRVW YHWWHP pV]UH KRJ\NpWNH]pQHNEW\NHLWDOYDGWYpUERUtWMD

$V]RODULVWiN

$ FVV]HU, IRO\RVy UHV YROW 0HJiOOWDP HJ\ SHUFUH D FVXNRWW DMWy HOWW pV IOHOWHP 9pNRQ\ OHKHWHWW D IDO EH KDOODWV]RWW D V]pO G~GROiVD 1pJ\V]|JOHWHV UDJWDSDV]FtP NpW IHGH]WHP IHO D] DMWyQ KDQ\DJXO NLVVp IHUGpQ RGDUD JDV]WYD HJ\HWOHQ V]yW ILUNiOWDN Ui FHUX]iYDO (PEHU 1p]WHP D NXV]D EHW,NHW HJ\ SLOODQDWLJ YLVV]D DNDUWDP PHQQL6QDXWKR]GHPHJpUWHWWHPKRJ\QHPOHKHW $] HV]HOV ILJ\HOPH]WHWpV PpJ D IOHPEHQ FVHQJHWW (OLQGXOWDP D] ,UUXKD yORPV~OO\DO K~]WD D YiOODPDW &V|QGEHQ PLQWKD |QNpQWHOHQO LV EXMNiOQpN HJ\ OiWKD WDWODQ V]HPSiU HOO YLVV]DORSDNRGWDP D] |WDMWyV NHUHN KHO\LVpJEH $] DMWyNRQ WiEOiN 'U *LEDULDQ 'U 6QDXW 'U 6DUWRULXV $ QHJ\HGLN UHV 5|YLG KDER]iV XWiQ yYDWRVDQ OHQ\RPWDP D NLOLQFVHW /DVVDQ Q\LWRWWDP D] DMWyW ² pUH]WHP V]LQWH WXGWDP KRJ\ YDQ YDODNL RGDEHQW %HOpSWHP 6HQNLVHPYROWRWW8J\DQRO\DQFVDNYDODPLYHONLVHEE GRPERU~ DEODN Qp]HWW D] yFHiQUD DPHO\ LWW ² D QDSSDO V]HPEHQ²]VtURVDQIpQ\OHWWPLQWKDY|U|VRODMFVXURJQDD KXOOiPRNUyO %tERU YLVV]IpQ\NEHW|OW|WWH D KDMyNDELQKR] KDVRQOy V]REiW $] HJ\LN ROGDORQ N|Q\YHVSROFRN PHJ D IDOKR] V]tMD]RWW FVXNOyV iJ\ D PiVLNRQ IDOLV]HNUpQ\HN N|]WN HJ\PiV DOi UDJDV]WRWW OpJL IHOYpWHOHN QLNNHOUiPiNEDQ D IpPiOOYiQ\RNRQ YDWWDGXJyV ORPELNRN pVNpPFV|YHN$]DEODNHOWWNpWVRUIHKpU]RPiQFRVOiGD WRUODV]ROWD HO D] XWDW QpPHO\LN Q\LWYD YROW EHQQN KDORPED GREiOW V]HUV]iPRN pV P,DQ\DJ FV|YHN D NpW VDURNEDQ FVDS IVWHOV]tYy K,WJpSHN D PLNURV]NyS D SDGOyQiOOWD]DEODNDODWWLQDJ\DV]WDORQPiUQHPIpUWHO 0HJIRUGXOWDP ² D] DMWy PHOOHWW D PHQQ\H]HWLJ pU V]HNUpQ\ WiUYDQ\LWYD WHOH NH]HVOiEDVRNNDO YpG pV PXQNDN|WpQ\HNNHO D SROFRNRQ IHKpUQHP, OHQW D VXJiU YpG FVL]PiN N|]O NLFVLOODQWDN D KRUGR]KDWy R[LJpQ NpV]OpNHNDOXPtQLXPSDODFNMDL$NpWNpV]OpNiODUFFDO HJ\WW D IHOFVDWROW iJ\ NDUIiMiQ OyJRWW 0LQGHQWW H] D ]VLEYiViUDNDSNRGyWHVVpNOiVVpNUHQGFVLQiOiVQ\RPDL 

YDO .|UOV]LPDWROWDP HQ\KH YHJ\V]HUV]DJRW pV YDODPL FVtSV E,] PDUDGYiQ\iW pUH]WHP ² WDOiQ NOyU" gV]W| Q|VHQ D IHOV VDURNED SLOODQWRWWDP D UiFVRV V]HOO] Q\tOiVRNSHUHPpQV]HOtGHQOLEHJWHNDSDStUV]DODJRNMHOH] YH KRJ\ D V]LYDWW\~N P,N|GQHN D OpJiUDPOiVVDO QLQFV EDM.pWV]pNUOOHUiPROWDPDN|Q\YHNNpV]OpNHNpVP, V]HUHN WRUQ\iW ~J\DKRJ\ D VDURNED KDOPR]WDP NHW PDMG DGGLJ UDNRGWDP PtJ D] iJ\ N|UO D V]HNUpQ\ pV D SROFRNN|]|WWYLV]RQ\ODJUHVV]LJHWWiPDGW2GDK~]WDPD IRJDVW KRJ\ UiDNDVV]DP ,UUXKiPDW PHJIRJWDP D YLO OiP]iU K~]yMiW GH U|JW|Q HO LV HQJHGWHP 9DODKRJ\ QHP DNDUy]RWW NLE~MQL D V]NDIDQGHUEO ² PLQWKD DNNRU YpG WHOHQQp YiOQpN 0pJ HJ\V]HU MyO N|UOQp]WHP D V]REiEDQ HOOHQUL]WHPJRQGRVDQEHFVXNWDPHD]DMWyWpVPLYHO]iU QHP YROW UDMWD QpPL KDER]iV XWiQ HOp WROWDP D NpW OHJQHKH]HEE OiGiW $ KHYHQ\pV]HWW EDULNiG YpGHOPpEHQ D]WiQ KiURP UiQWiVVDO PHJV]DEDGXOWDP QHKp] Q\LNRUJy J~Q\iPWyO$V]HNUpQ\DMWyEHOVHMpQIJJ NHVNHQ\WN|UD V]RED HJ\ UpV]pW PXWDWWD 9DODPL PR]JiVW NDSWDP HO D V]HPHP VDUNiEyO KiWUDXJURWWDP GH D VDMiW WN|UNpSHP YROW 7ULNyP WHOMHVHQ iWL]]DGW D V]NDIDQGHU DODWW $]W LV OHGREWDP PDMG PHJWDV]tWRWWDP D V]HNUpQ\W 2GpEE FV~V]RWWP|J|WWHPHJFVLOODQWDWHQ\pUQ\LIUGV]REDIDOD $ ]XKDQ\ DODWW MyNRUD ODSRV GRER] IHNGW ÉWFLSHOWHP D V]REiED pV D I|OGUH UDNWDP 1\RPEDQ IHOFVDSyGRWW D I|GHOH PLQWKD UXJyUD MiUQD pV UHNHV]HLEHQ IXUFVD KROPLNDW SLOODQWRWWDP PHJ PLQGHQIpOH V]HUV]iP NDULNDW~UiLWYDJ\HOQDJ\ROWPiVRODWDLWV|WpWV]tQ, IpPEO HJ\ UpV]N D IDOLV]HNUpQ\HNEHQ KHYHU WiUJ\DNUD KDVRQOtWRWW'HPLQGKDV]QiOKDWDWODQYROWWRU]HOJ|UEOW PHJROYDGW PLQWKD W,]YpV]EO NHUOW YROQD HO $ OHJN O|Q|VHEE D] YROW KRJ\ D J\DNRUODWLODJ W,]iOOy NHUDPLW IRJDQW\~N LV tJ\ HOIRUPiWODQRGWDN /DERUDWyULXPL NH PHQFpN KIRNiQ D NHUDPLW QHP ROYDG ² OHJIHOMHEE HJ\ DWRPPiJO\DEHOVHMpEHQ(OUiQWRWWDPDIRJDVUDDNDV]WRWW V]NDIDQGHU ]VHEpEO D VXJiU]iVPpUW GH D NLV IHNHWH My V]iJQpPDPDUDGWPLNRUDURQFVRNI|OpWDUWRWWDP 0iU FVDN HJ\ V]iO DOVyQDGUiJ pV O\XNDFVRV DWOpWDWULNy YROW UDMWDP (]HNHW LV D SDGOyUD GREWDP PLQW D URQJ\RW pV PH]WHOHQO EHXJURWWDP D ]XKDQ\ DOi 0HJN|QQ\HEE OpVQHN pUH]WHP D ]iSRUR]y YL]HW 7HNHUHJWHP D IRUUy 

]XKDWDJ DODWW G|J|Q\|]WHP PDJDP SUV]N|OWHP GH YDODKRJ\ HOW~OR]YD PLQWKD tJ\ DNDUQiP OHUi]QL NLYHWQL PDJDPEyOD]HJpV]]DYDURVEL]RQ\WDODQViJRWDPLD]ÉOOR PiVW EHW|OWL pV HQJHP LV PHJIHUW]|WW H]]HO D] RVWRED J\DQDNYiVVDO .LNHUHVWHP D V]HNUpQ\EO HJ\ V]NDIDQGHU DOi LV YLVHO KHW N|QQ\, PHOHJtWW iWUDNWDP D ]VHEHLEH FVHNpO\ YDJ\RQRPDW QRWHV]RP ODSMDL N|]|WW NHPpQ\ WiUJ\UD WD SLQWRWWD]XMMDPI|OGLODNiVRPNXOFVDYROWD My pJ WXGMD KRJ\DQ NHYHUHGHWW RGD 7DQiFVWDODQXO IRUJDWWDP QHP WXGWDP PLW NH]GMHN YHOH YpJO OHWHWWHP D] DV]WDOUD (V]HPEHMXWRWWKRJ\YDODPLIHJ\YHUUHLVV]NVpJHPOHKHW $V]HUV]iPRNNDONRPELQiOW]VHENpVQHPLJHQIHOHOWPHJD FpOQDNGHPiVQHPDNDGWQiODPVHJ\HOUHQHPYROWDP RO\DQ OHONLiOODSRWEDQ KRJ\ QHNLiOOMDN YDODPL VXJiUV]yUyW YDJ\ HIIpOpW NHUHVQL /HOWHP D NLV IpPV]pNUH D] UHV WpUVpJ N|]HSpQ PLQGHQ KROPLWyO WiYRO (J\HGO DNDUWDP OHQQLgU|PPHOOiWWDPKRJ\PpJW|EEPLQWIpOyUiPYDQ PHJiOODSRGiVDLPDW PLQGLJ SRQWRVDQ EHWDUWRP DNiU OpQ\HJHVHNDNiUQHPH]PiUDWHUPpV]HWHPKH]WDUWR]LN $] yUDPXWDWy D KHWHVKH] pUW D KXV]RQQpJ\ yUiV V]iPODSRQ /HQ\XJRGRWW D QDS +pW yUD D] LWWHQL LG V]HULQW ² DNNRU D 3URPpWKHXV]RQ PRVW K~V] yUD YDQ $ 6RODULV PiU EL]WRVDQ NLV V]LNUiYi ]VXJRURGRWW 0RGGDUG NpSHUQ\MpQ VHPPL VHP NO|QE|]WHWL PHJ D FVLOODJRNWyO 'H KiW pQ PiU QHP D 3URPpWKHXV]RQ YDJ\RN %H KXQ\WDP D V]HPHP 7HOMHV FV|QG YROW FVDN D FV|YHN V]RUW\RJWDN HJ\HQOHWHV LGN|]|NEHQ $ IUGV]RED SRUFH OiQSDGOyMiUDKDONDQFV|S|J|WWDYt] *LEDULDQ PHJKDOW $OLJ IpO QDSSDO H]HOWW KD MyO pUWHW WHP 6QDXW V]DYDLW 0LW FVLQiOWDN D KROWWHVWWHO" (OWHPHW WpN" ,JD] LV ² H]HQ D ERO\JyQ QHP OHKHW WHPHWQL *\D NRUODWLDVDQ PHJKiQ\WDPYHWHWWHP D GROJRW PLQWKD D KDORWW VRUVD YROQD D OHJIRQWRVDEE D]WiQ UiM|WWHP PHN NRUDRVWREDViJH]HQW|SUHQJHQLIHOiOOWDPpViWOyVDQUyQL NH]GWHPDV]REiWPHJPHJERWROYDV]pWV]yUWN|Q\YHNEHQ PDMG HJ\ UHV NLV ROGDO]ViNEDQ OHKDMROWDP pUWH I|OHPHOWHP /iP QHP LV UHV 6|WpW YHJSDODFN YROW EHQQHRO\DQN|QQ\,PLQWDIHOI~MWSDStU]DFVNy$]DEODN IHOpWDUWRWWDPpViWQp]WHPUDMWDRGDNLQWV]HQQ\HVN|G|N WRPStWRWWiN D QDSQ\XJWD ]RUGDQ Y|U|VO XWROVy 

VXJDUDLW 0L YDQ YHOHP" 0LpUW IRJODONR]RP PLQGHQ V]D PiUViJJDOPLQGHQNH]HPEHDNDGyYDFDNNDO" gVV]HUH]]HQWHP PHUW PHJJ\XOODGW D YLOODQ\ +iW SHUV]HDV|WpWHGpVUHpU]pNHQ\IRWRFHOOD&VXSDYiUDNR]iV YROWDP LGHJHLP DQQ\LUD PHJIHV]OWHN KRJ\ YpJO PiU QHP DNDUy]RWW KiWWDO iOOQL D] UHV V]REiQDN (OKDWiUR] WDP KRJ\ |VV]HV]HGHP PDJDP 6]pNHW K~]WDP D N|Q\ YHVSROF HOp 2WW YROW $ 6RODULV W|UWpQHWH +XJKHV pV (XJHO XQWLJ LVPHUW UpJL PRQRJUiILiMD ² OHYHWWHP D PiVRGLN N|WHWHW pV PHUHY YDVWDJ WiEOiMiW |OHPEH IHNWHWYH ODSR] JDWQLNH]GWHP $ 6RODULVW PDMGQHP V]i] pYYHO V]OHWpVHP HOWW IHGH] WpNIHO.pWQDSN|UONHULQJ ERO\JyHJ\LNQDSMDY|U|VD PiVLN NpN 7|EE PLQW QHJ\YHQ pYLJ HJ\HWOHQ ,UKDMy VHP N|]HOtWHWWH PHJ $QQDN LGHMpQ V]HQWO KLWWHN D *DPRZ 6KDSOH\HOPpOHWEHQ NHWWV FVLOODJRN ERO\JyLQ QHP NHOHWNH]KHW pOHW $] HJ\PiV N|U O NHULQJ NpW QDS JUD YLWiFLyV MiWpND PLDWW D] LO\HQ ERO\JyN SiO\iMD VRKDVHP iOODQGy $ NHOHWNH] SHUWXUEiFLyN KRO PHJU|YLGtWLN KRO PHJ Q\~MWMiN D ERO\JySiO\iW pV D] pOHW FVtUiL KD HJ\iOWDOiQ OpWUHM|QQHN HOEEXWyEE HOSXV]WXOQDN D SHU]VHO KVpJ EHQ YDJ\ D J\LONRV IDJ\EDQ $ YiOWR]iVRN XJ\DQLV pYPLO OLyNDODWWPHQQHNYpJEHWHKiWFVLOODJiV]DWLYDJ\ELROyJLDL YRQDWNR]iVEDQ QDJ\RQ U|YLG LG DODWW KLV]HQ D IHMOGpV W|EEV]i]PLOOLyKDQHPPLOOLiUGpYHWLJpQ\HO $] HUHGHWL V]iPtWiVRNEyO NLGHUOW KRJ\ D 6RODULV |WV]i]H]HU pY DODWW IpO FVLOODJiV]DWL HJ\VpJUH PHJN|]HOtWL Y|U|VQDSMiWWRYiEELHJ\PLOOLypYP~OYDSHGLJDQQDNL]]y WRUNiED]XKDQ 'HPiUWt]WL]HQ|WpYP~OYDPHJJ\]GWHNUyODKRJ\D 6RODULVSiO\iMDNRUiQWVHPPXWDWMDDYiUWPyGRVXOiVRNDW VW HJpV]HQ ~J\ YLVHONHGLN PLQWKD iOODQGy OHQQH pSSRO\DQ iOODQGy DNiU D PL QDSUHQGV]HUQN ERO\ JySiO\iL ÔMUD HOYpJH]WpN D PHJILJ\HOpVHNHW pV V]iPtWiVRNDW PRVWPiUDOHJQDJ\REESRQWRVViJJDOGHPHJLQWFVDND]W D]HUHGPpQ\WNDSWiNKRJ\D6RODULVSiO\iMDQHPiOODQGy (NNRU OpSHWW HO D 6RODULV D] pYHQWH V]i]V]iP I|OIH GH]HWW pV PR]JiVHOHPHLN SiU VRUQ\L DGDWiYDO ODMVWURPR 

]RWW ERO\JyN HJ\LNpEO NO|Q|V ILJ\HOPHW pUGHPO pJL WHVWWp $OLJ QpJ\ pYYHO H I|OIHGH]pV XWiQ D /DRNRRQ HJ\LN ERO\JyMiQ MiUW 2WWHQVNM|OGH[SHGtFLy NpW NtVpU UDNWiU KDMyMiYDO HJ\WW PHJNHUOWH D 6RODULVW 9iOODONR]iVXN FVXSiQ LGHLJOHQHV U|JW|Q]|WW IHOGHUtWpV YROW DQQiO LV LQ NiEE PLYHO QHP WXGWDN OHV]iOOQL (J\HQOtWL pV VDUNL SiO\iUD KHO\H]WHN W|EE DXWRPDWD PHJILJ\HOKROGDW H]HN HOVVRUEDQDJUDYLWiFLyVHUWHUHWPpUWpN0HJiOODStWRWWiN KRJ\DERO\JyW W~OQ\RPyUpV]W yFHiQERUtWMD FVDNQpKiQ\ IHQQVtN HPHONHGLN NL EHOOH gVV]WHUOHWN NLVHEE (XUy SiQiOSHGLJD6RODULViWPpUMHK~V]V]i]DOpNNDOQDJ\REE PLQW D )|OGp (]HN D UHQGV]HUWHOHQO V]pWV]yUW NRSiU V]LNOiV V]iUD]I|OGHN IOHJ D GpOL IpOWHNpQ WHUOQHN HO (OHPH]WpNDOpJN|U|VV]HWpWHOpWLV²R[LJpQWQHPWDUWDOPD] ² YpJO LJHQ SRQWRVDQ PHJPpUWpN D ERO\Jy V,U,VpJpW DOEHGyMiW pV PiV FVLOODJiV]DWL DGDWDLW $ YiUDNR]iVQDN PHJIHOHOHQD]pOHWVHPPLIpOHQ\RPiUDQHPDNDGWDNVHP DV]iUD]I|OGHNHQVHPD]yFHiQEDQ $ N|YHWNH] Wt] pY IRO\DPiQ D 6RODULV PRVW PiU YDOD PHQQ\L LOOHWpNHV FVLOODJYL]VJiOy WiYFV|YHLQHN NHUHV]WW ]pEHQ IRO\WDWWD HONpSHV]W YLVHONHGpVpW SiO\iMD iOODQGy PDUDGW KRORWW D JUDYLWiFLy W|UYpQ\HL V]HULQW PLQGHQ NpW VpJHW NL]iUyODJ YiOWR]QLD NHOOHWW YROQD(J\ LGHLJ ERWUiQ\ V]DJDYROWD]J\QHNPLYHOD]pV]OHOpVL HUHGPpQ\H NpUW V]LJRU~DQ D WXGRPiQ\ pUGHNpEHQ  KRO EL]RQ\RV V]HPpO\HNUHKRODV]iPtWyJpSHNUHSUyEiOWiNNHQQLDIHOH OVVpJHW $Q\DJL IHGH]HW KtMiQ D YROWDNpSSHQL 6RODULVH[SHGtFLy HOLQGtWiVD WRYiEEL KiURP pYHW NpVHWW PtJ YpJO 6KDQQD KDQJiUGiMiQDNNLHJpV]tWpVHXWiQKiURP&WRQQiVNR] PRGUyPLDRV]WiO\~ HJ\VpJHW V]HU]HWW D] ,QWp]HWWO 0iVIpO pYYHO D 9t]|QW $OIiMiQDN WpUVpJpEO UDMWROy H[SHGtFLy pUNH]pVH HOWW D PiVRGLN IHOGHUtW IORWWD D] ,QWp]HW XWDVt WiViUD 6RODULV N|UOL SiO\iUD KHO\H]WH D /XQD |QP, N|G 6]DWHOORLGRW (] D 6]DWHOORLG D] pYWL]HGHN VRUiQ KiURPV]RUIHO~MtWYDPiLJLVP,N|GLN0pUpVLHUHGPpQ\HL YpJOHJ PHJHUVtWHWWpN D] 2WWHQVNM|OGH[SHGtFLy pV]OHOpVpW KRJ\D]yFHiQPR]JiVDLDNWtYMHOOHJ,HN 6KDQQDKDQ HJ\LN KDMyMD PDJDVDQ NHULQJHWW NHWW SH GLJ PHJIHOHO HONpV]OHWHN XWiQ OHV]iOOW D 6RODULV GpOL 

VDUNiQ K~]yGy PLQWHJ\ KDWV]i] QpJ\]HWPpUI|OGHV V]LN OiVI|OGGDUDEUD$]H[SHGtFLyWL]HQQ\ROFKyQDSLPXQNiMiW V]HUHQFVH NtVpUWH PLQG|VV]H HJ\HWOHQ EDOHVHWN YROW YDODPLNpV]OpNKLEDN|YHWNH]WpEHQÉPDWXGyVJiUGDNpW V]HPEHQ iOOy WiERUUD V]DNDGW $] yFHiQ PLDWW NDSWDN KDMED $] HOHP]pVHN DODSMiQ V]HUYHV NpSOHWQHN PLQVt WHWWpN pOQHN DNNRULEDQ PpJ VHQNL VHP PHUWH QHYH]QL  'H PtJ D ELROyJXVRN V]HPpEHQ SULPLWtY DODNXODW YROW YDODPL LUGDWODQ YpJOpQ\ N ÅSUHELRORJLNXV IRUPiFLyQDNµ NHUHV]WHOWpN  PLQWKD HJ\HWOHQHJ\ JLJiV]LYi IDMXOW IRO\p NRQ\ VHMW EXUNROQi D] HJpV] ERO\JyW KHO\HQNpQW W|EE PpUI|OG PpO\ NRFVRQ\iV N|SHQ\EH DGGLJ D FVLOODJiV]RN pV D IL]LNXVRN DPHOOHWW NDUGRVNRGWDN KRJ\ UHQGNtYO PDJDVV]HUYH]HWWVpJ,WDOiQPpJ D I|OGLV]HUYH]HWHNQpO LV ERQ\ROXOWDEE VWUXNW~UiQDN NHOO OHQQLH KLV]HQ DNWtYDQ EHIRO\iVROQL NpSHV D ERO\JySiO\D DODNXOiViW 6HPPL PiV RNiW pV PDJ\DUi]DWiW QHP WDOiOWiN XJ\DQLV D 6RODULV YLVHONHGpVpQHN VW D ERO\JyIL]LNXVRN |VV]HIJJpVW IHGH] WHN IHO D SOD]PDyFHiQ EL]RQ\RV IRO\DPDWDL pV D KHO\LOHJ PpUW JUDYLWiFLyV HU N|]|WW DPHO\ D] yFHiQ ÅDQ\DJFVHUp MpWOµIJJ YiOWR]iVRNDWPXWDWRWW ÌJ\D]WiQDIL]LNXVRNpVQHPDELROyJXVRNiOOWDNHO D SDUDGR[ÅSOD]PDJpSµHOQHYH]pVVHOH]RO\DQNpS]GPpQ\W DNDUWMHOHQWHQLDPHO\DPL IRJDOPDLQN V]HULQW WDOiQ QHP pOOpQ\ GH FpOV]HU, WHYpNHQ\VpJUH NpSHV PpJSHGLJ ² WHJ\N PLQGMiUW KR]]i ² FVLOODJiV]DWL DUiQ\~ WHYpNHQ\VpJUH (EEHQDYLWiEDQDPHO\KHWHNDODWW|UYpQ\NpQWUiQWRWW PDJiED PLQGHQ MHOHV V]DNWHNLQWpO\W Q\ROFYDQ pY yWD HOV]|ULQJRWWPHJD*DPRZ6KDSOH\HOPpOHW (J\LGHLJPpJYpGHOPH]QLSUyEiOWiNPRQGYiQKRJ\D] yFHiQQDNVHPPLN|]HD]pOHWKH]PpJFVDNQHPLVÅSDUDµ YDJ\ ÅSUHELRORJLNXV IRUPiFLyµ KDQHP JHROyJLDL NpSOHW YDOyEDQ UHQGNtYOL GH D 6RODULV SiO\iMiQDN VWD ELOL]iOiViUD FVDN D JUDYLWiFLyV HUN YiOWR]iVDL WHV]LN Np SHVVpLWWD/H&KDWHOLHUV]DEiO\UDKLYDWNR]WDN (]]HO D NRQ]HUYDWLYL]PXVVDO V]HPEHQ I|OPHUOWHN RO\DQKLSRWp]LVHN²SpOGiXOD]LJHQUpV]OHWHVHQNLGROJR]RWW &LYLWD²9LWW\IpOH HOPpOHW ² KRJ\ D] yFHiQ GLDOHNWLNXV IHMOGpV HUHGPpQ\H VDODNMiEyO D SUHyFHiQEyO 

DPHO\ ORPKiQ UHDJiOy YHJ\L HOHPHN ROGDWD YROW D N| UOPpQ\HN PiUPLQW D OpWpW IHQ\HJHW SiO\DYiOWR]iVRN KDWiViUD D I|OGL OpSFVIRNRN N|]YHWtWpVH QpONO WHKiW PHOO]YHD]HJ\pVW|EEVHMW,HNNLDODNXOiViWDQ|YpQ\pV iOODWYLOiJ HYRO~FLyMiW LGHJUHQGV]HU pV DJ\ NLIHMOHV]WpVH QpONO D]RQQDO D ÅKRPHRV]WDWLNXV yFHiQµ iOODSRWiED Op SHWW 0iV V]yYDO QHP VRN V]i] PLOOLy pYHQ iW DONDOPD] NRGRWW D N|UQ\H] YLOiJKR] PLQW D I|OGL V]HUYH]HWHN DPHO\HNN|]OFVDNLO\HQKRVV]~LG HOWHOWpYHOHPHONHGHWW NLJRQGRONRGyIDMKDQHPD]RQQDO~UUiOHWWN|UQ\H]HWpQ ,JHQHUHGHWLJRQGRODWYROWFVDNpSSHQD]QHPGHUOWNL EHOOH KRJ\DQ VWDELOL]iOKDWMD D V]LUXSRV NRFVRQ\D HJ\ pJLWHVW SiO\iMiW 0DMGQHP HJ\ pYV]i]DGD LVPHUWpN D JUD YLWRUW D PHVWHUVpJHV HUWHUHNpV JUDYLWiFLyV WHUHN HOiOOt WiViUD V]ROJiOy EHUHQGH]pVW GH HO VHP WXGWiN NpS]HOQL KRJ\DJUDYLWRURNyULiVLKIRNRQ ERQ\ROXOW PDJUHDNFLyN NDO HOLGp]HWW WHOMHVtWPpQ\pW PL PyGRQ XWiQR]]D HJ\ DODNWDODQ SHPS $] ~MViJRN WFVN|WERJDUDW |VV]HKRUG WDN D Å6RODULVUHMWpO\UOµ D OHJYDGDEE VOHWOHQVpJHNNHO FVLJi]WiN IHO D] ROYDVyN NtYiQFVLViJiW pV RNR]WDN GKUR KDPRNDW D WXGyVRNQDN ² PpJ RO\DQ Qp]HW LV KDQJRW ND SRWW KRJ\ D] yFHiQ V]HJUOYpJUO D I|OGL YLOODPRV DQJRO QiNURNRQD   0LNRU D]WiQ VLNHUOW OHJDOiEE YDODPHO\HVW WLV]Wi]QL D GROJRW NLW,QW KRJ\ D PDJ\DUi]DW ² NpVEE LV VRNV]RU ,]|WW YHOQN LO\HQ WUpIiW D 6RODULV ² ~MDEE pV WDOiQ PpJ WLWRN]DWRVDEENpUGpVHNHWYHWIHO $ NXWDWiVRN NLPXWDWWiN KRJ\ D] yFHiQ NRUiQWVHP D PLJUDYLWRUDLQNHOYHDODSMiQP,N|GLNDPLNO|QEHQVHP YROQD OHKHWVpJHV  KDQHP N|]YHWOHQO PRGHOOiOQL WXGMD D WpULG PHWULNiMiW HQQHN WXODMGRQtWKDWy W|EEHN N|]|WW KRJ\ D 6RODULV HJ\ pV XJ\DQD]RQ GpON|UpQ HOWpUpVHN PX WDWNR]QDN D] LGPpUpVEHQ 7HKiW D] yFHiQ QHPFVDN ² KRJ\ ~J\ PRQGMXN ² LVPHUL KDQHP DPLYHO PL QHP GLFVHNHGKHWQN  NL LV WXGMD KDV]QiOQL D] (LQVWHLQ%RHYL HOPpOHWEL]RQ\RVN|YHWNH]PpQ\HLW (]DPHJiOODStWiVV]i]DGXQNHJ\LNOHJKHYHVHEEYLKDUiW UREEDQWRWWD NLD WXGRPiQ\RV YLOiJEDQ +DORPUD GOWHN D OHJWHNLQWpO\HVHEE RV]WDWODQXO HOLVPHUW WHyULiN D V]DNLURGDORPEDQ V]HQWVpJW|U FLNNHN OiWWDN QDSYLOiJRW 

PLQGHQ HOPpW Oi]ED KR]RWW D QDJ\ NpUGpV Å]VHQLiOLV yFHiQµYDJ\ÅJUDYLWiFLyVNRFVRQ\Dµ" 0LQGH] PDMG K~V] pYYHO V]OHWpVHP HOWW W|UWpQW $PLNRU pQ LVNROiED MiUWDP D] LGN|]EHQ PHJLVPHUW Wp Q\HNDODSMiQPiUN|]KHO\QHNV]iPtWRWWKRJ\D6RODULVRQ YDQpOHW²GHD]WHJ\HWOHQHJ\ODNRVNpSYLVHOL   *pSLHVHQ ODSR]JDWWDP D +XJKHV(XJHO PiVRGLN N| WHWpW PLQGMiUW D] HOHMpQ OHJDOiEE DQQ\LUD |WOHWHV PLQW DPLO\HQ PXODWViJRV UHQGV]HUWDQL EHVRUROiV WDOiOKDWy $ WiEOi]DWEDQ LO\HQ NDWHJyULiN V]HUHSHOQHN 7tSXV ² 3RO\ WKHULD5HQG²6\QF\WLDOLD2V]WiO\²0HWDPRUSKD 0LQWKD LVWHQ WXGMD KiQ\ HJ\HGHW LVPHUQpQN HEEO D IDMEyO SHGLJ KiW FVDN H] D] HJ\ iUYiONRGLN LWW 1R GH H] OHJDOiEE WHNLQWpO\HV SpOGiQ\ NHUHNHQ WL]HQKpW ELOOLy WRQQiWQ\RP 8MMDLP DODWW SHUHJWHN D] iOODSRWYiOWR]iVRN MHOOHJpW WHPpW YHJ\L IRO\DPDWiW LVPHUWHW V]tQHV iEUiN GLDJUD PRN HOHP]pVHN pV V]tQNpSHN 0LQpO WRYiEE KDODGWDP D YDVNRV N|WHWEHQ DQQiO MREEDQ HOKDUDSy]RWW D KyIHKpU ODSRNRQ D PDWHPDWLND D]W KLQQp D] HPEHU W|EEHW PiU QHP LV OHKHWQH WXGQL D 0HWDPRUSKD RV]WiO\ H NpSYLVHO MpUO DPHO\ LWW KHYHU D QpJ\yUiV pMV]DND V|WpWVpJpEH EXUNROYDSiUV]i]PpWHUUHOD]ÉOORPiVDFpOWHVWHDODWW 3HGLJKiWPpJD]WVHPG|QW|WWpNHOÅOpQ\µHD]yFHiQ DUUyOPiUQHPLVEHV]pOYHKRJ\pUWHOPHVQHNQHYH]KHWH 9LVV]DO|NWHP D V~O\RV N|Q\YHW D SROFUD V OHYHWWHP D N|YHWNH]W (] NpW UpV]UH RV]ORWW (OV IHOH NtVpUOHWL MHJ\]N|Q\YHNNLYRQDWDLDUUyOD V]iPWDODQYiOODONR]iVUyO DPHO\HNQHN D] YROW D FpOMD KRJ\ NDSFVRODWRW OpWHVtWVHQHN D] yFHiQQDO (] D NDSFVRODWWHUHPWpV QDJ\RQ MyO HPOpNV]HP D KXPRURV W|UWpQHWHN YLFFHN pV FVLSNHO GpVHNNLPHUtWKHWHWOHQIRUUiVDYROWHJ\HWHPLVWDNRURPEDQ RO\DQ G]VXQJHOOp EXUMiQ]RWW KRJ\ DKKR] NpSHVW D N|]pSNRUL VNRODV]WLND PDJD D] iWWHWV] UHQG pV YLOiJRV ViJ $ N|WHW PiVRGLN UpV]H PDMGQHP H]HUKiURPV]i] ROGDOFVXSiQDWpPDELEOLRJUiILiMD0DJDD V]DNLURGDORP HOVHPIpUQHHEEHQDV]REiEDQ (OV]|U RO\DQ NO|QOHJHV HOHNWURQLNXV NpV]OpNHNNHO SUyEiONR]WDN NDSFVRODWRW OpWHVtWHQL PHO\HN NpSHVHN YRO WDN WUDQV]IRUPiOQL D] DGRWW pV D YHWW LQIRUPiFLyNDW $] yFHiQ PDJD LV N|]UHP,N|G|WW H]HNQHN D NpV]OpNHNQHN 

D NLDODNtWiViEDQ 'H D] HJpV]EO VHPPLW VHP WXGWDN NLKiPR]QL 0HUW PLEHQ LV iOOW D ÅN|]UHP,N|GpVHµ" 0y GRVtWRWWD D EHOpPHUtWHWW P,V]HUHN HJ\HV HOHPHLW DPLQHN N|YHWNH]WpEHQ D NLVOpVHN ULWPXVJ|UEpMH PHJYiOWR]RWW D UHJLV]WUiOy NpV]OpNHN V]DODJMiQ KHP]VHJWHN D MHOHN JL JiV]L IHOVEE PDWHPDWLNDL P,YHOHWHN IRV]OiQ\DLQDN WHWV]HWWHN GH PLW MHOHQWHWW PLQGH]" 7DOiQ D] yFHiQ SLOODQDWQ\L JHUMHV]WHWWVpJL iOODSRWiQDN DGDWDL YROWDN" 9DJ\H]HNEOD]LPSXO]XVRNEyOV]OHWWHND]yFHiQJLJiV]L NpS]GPpQ\HLYDODKROW|EEH]HUPpUI|OGUHDNXWDWyNWyO" 7DOiQ D] yFHiQ |U|N LJD]ViJDLQDN D YLVV]IpQ\H ² YDODPL pUWKHWHWOHQHOHNWURQLNXVQ\HOYHQ" 9DJ\WDOiQP,YpV]HWp QHNUHPHNHL".LWXGKDWWDYROQDPLNRUVRKDVHPVLNHUOW NpWV]HUXJ\DQD]WDUHDNFLyWNLYiOWDQL"0LNRUDYiODV]KRO RO\DQ LPSXO]XVNLW|UpV YROW KRJ\ PDMG V]pWYLWWH D P,V]HUW KRO SHGLJ VNHW KDOOJDWiV" 0LNRU HJ\HWOHQ Nt VpUOHWHW VHP OHKHWHWW UHSURGXNiOQL" 0LQGXQWDODQ ~J\ UpPOHWW KRJ\ HJ\ OpSpVUH YDJ\XQN D V]QWHOHQO GDJDGy IHOMHJ\]pVWHQJHU PHJIHMWpVpWO  KLV]HQ NO|Q HOHNWURQLNXV DJ\DNDW pStWHWWQN HUUH D FpOUD RO\DQ LQIRUPiFLyIHO GROJR]yNDSDFLWiVVDODPLO\HWPpJHJ\HWOHQSUREOpPDVHP LJpQ\HOW 9DOyEDQ DGyGWDN LV EL]RQ\RV HUHGPpQ\HN 0LQWKDD]yFHiQ²D]HOHNWURPRVPiJQHVHVpVJUDYLWiFLyV LPSXO]XVRNIRUUiVD²PDWHPDWLNDLQ\HOYHQEHV]pOWYROQD YLOODPRV NLVOpVHLQHN EL]RQ\RV V]HNYHQFLiLW D I|OGL DQDOt]LV OHJHOYRQWDEE iJDL IOHJ D KDOPD]HOPpOHW VHJtWVpJpYHORV]WiO\R]QLWXGWiNRO\DQKRPROyJVWUXNW~UiN MHOHQWNH]WHNDPHO\HNHWD]HQHUJLDpVD]DQ\DJDYpJHVpV YpJWHOHQ PHQQ\LVpJHN D] HOHPL UpV]HFVNpN pV WHUHLN N|OFV|QKDWiViQDN IL]LNiMiEyO LVPHUQN ² PLQGH] DUUD D PHJJ\]GpVUH NpV]WHWWH D WXGyVRNDW KRJ\ D] yFHiQ YDODPL JRQGRONRGy PRQVWUXP D] HJpV] ERO\JyW HOERUtWy PLOOLyV]RURVUD GX]]DGW SURWRSOD]PDV]HU, DJ\YHOWHQJHU PHO\ D YLOiJPLQGHQVpJ OpQ\HJpQ W|SUHQJYH LV]RQ\DWRV DUiQ\~ HOPpOHWL IHMWHJHWpVHNNHO W|OWL LGHMpW V DPLW P,V]HUHLQN HEEO NLUDJDGQDN FVXSiQ D PpO\VpJEHQ |U|NN|Q|U|NNp IRO\y V]iPXQNUD IHOIRJKDWDWODQ JLJiV]L PRQROyJYpOHWOHQOHOOHVHWWW|UHGpNH ÌJ\ D PDWHPDWLNXVRN +LSRWp]LVHLNUO HJ\HVHN D]W PRQGWiN KRJ\ H] D] HPEHUL OHKHWVpJHN OHEHFVOpVH KDVUD HVpV YDODPL HOWW DPLW PpJ QHP pUWQN GH PHJ 

pUWKHWQN D] ÅLJQRUDPXV HW LJQRUDELPXVµ yVGL IHOIRJi ViQDN IHOWiPDV]WiVD PiVRN ~J\ YpOWpN PHGG pV NiURV PHVpN NRUXQN PLWROyJLiMiW WNU|]LN DPHO\ D] yULiVL DJ\YHOEHQ ² HOHNWURQLNXV YDJ\ SOD]PDV]HU, PLQGHJ\ ² D]pOHWOHJIEEFpOMiWDOpWVXPPiMiWOiWMD 0HJLQWPiVRN  GHKiWNXWDWyNpVQp]HWHNOpJLyV]iP YROWDN 1R pV PL YROW D ÅNDSFVRODWWHUHPWpVLµ NtVpUOHWHN HJpV]WHUOHWHDV]RODULV]WLNDW|EELiJiKR]NpSHVWPHO\HN IOHJ D] HOP~OW QHJ\HGV]i]DGEDQ DQQ\LUD V]DNRVRGWDN KRJ\ D NLEHUQHWLNXVV]RODULVWD PiU DOLJ WXG V]yW pUWHQL D V]LPPHWULiGNXWDWyV]RODULVWiYDOÅ7LDNDUWRND]yFHiQQDO V]yW pUWHQL PLNRU HJ\PiVW VHP pUWLWHN"µ ² WUpIiONR]RWW HJ\V]HU 9HXEHNH D] ,QWp]HW DNNRUL LJD]JDWyMD PpJ HJ\HWHPLVWDNRURPEDQpVPLO\HQLJD]DYROW 0HUWLWWYDQPpJD]LVDPLpUWD]yFHiQWD0HWDPRUSKD RV]WiO\ED VRUROWiN +XOOiP]y IHOOHWpEO D OHJ NO|QE|]EE VHPPL I|OGLKH] QHP KDVRQOy IRUPiM~ SOD]PDNpS]GPpQ\HN W|UQHN HO pV D QHPHJ\V]HU KHYHV ÅDONRWy WHYpNHQ\VpJµ FpOMiW ² DONDOPD]NRGy PHJLVPHU YDJ\EiUPLPiVUHQGHOWHWpVpW²PpJFVDNQHPLVVHMWMN .pW Np]]HO WHWWHP KHO\UH D N|WHWHW RO\DQ QHKp] YROW V DUUDJRQGROWDPKRJ\N|Q\YWiUDNUDPHQ DGDWKDOPD]XQN D 6RODULVUyO PLQG FVDN I|O|VOHJHV NRORQF KDV]RQWDODQ WpQ\HN ~WYHV]WMH ² SRQWRVDQ XJ\DQRWW WDUWXQN PLQW DPLNRU KHWYHQQ\ROF pYYHO H]HOWW HONH]GWpN D] DGDWJ\,M WpVW VW OpQ\HJpEHQ PpJ VRNNDO URVV]DEE D KHO\]HW KLV]HQD]HJpV]HGGLJLPXQNDPHGGQHNEL]RQ\XOW $PLWSRQWRVDQWXGXQND]FVXSDQHJDWtYXP$]yFHiQ QHPKDV]QiOJpSHNHWpVQHPLVNpV]tWLO\HVPLWEiUEL]R Q\RV N|UOPpQ\HN N|]|WW NpSHVQHN OiWV]LN Ui KLV]HQ OHXWiQR]WD QpPHO\LN EHOpPHUtWHWW P,V]HU DONDWUpV]HLW GH H]W FVDN D NXWDWiVRN HOV pV PiVRGLN pYpEHQ FVLQiOWD D]WiQ QHP YHWW W|EEp WXGRPiVW D V]HU]HWHVL WUHOHPPHO LVPpWHOJHWHWW NtVpUOHWHNUO PLQWKD YpJNpSS PHJXQWD YROQD JpSHLQNHW V WHUPpNHLQNHW V DOLJKDQHP EHQQQNHW LV    1LQFV LGHJUHQGV]HUH QLQFVHQHN VHMWMHL QLQFV IHKpUMHV]HU, VWUXNW~UiMD²IRO\WDWRPÅQHJDWtYLVPHUHWHLQNµ IHOVRUROiViW ² QHP PLQGLJ UHDJiO D EHKDWiVRNUD EiU PLO\HQHUVHNJ\HWVHPYHWHWWSpOGiXODPiVRGLN*LHVH H[SHGtFLy UDNWiUKDMyMiQDN NDWDV]WUyIiMiUD SHGLJ D JpS KiURPV]i]NLORPpWHUPDJDVUyO]XKDQWUiVDWRPPiJO\iL 

QDN QXNOHiULV UREEDQiVD PiVIpO PpUI|OGHV N|U]HWEHQ HOSXV]WtWRWWDDSOD]PiW  7XGyVN|U|NEHQNH]GWpNODVVDQHOSDUHQWiOQLDÅ6RODULV J\HWµ IOHJ D] ,QWp]HW WXGRPiQ\RV IKDWyViJiQDN EHU NHLEHQDKROD]XWyEELpYHNEHQIHOPHUOWDJRQGRODWKRJ\ PHJQ\LUEiOMiN D WRYiEEL NXWDWiV GRWiFLyMiW $] ÉOORPiV WHOMHVIHOV]iPROiViUyOHGGLJPpJVHQNLVHPPHUWEHV]pOQL H] W~OViJRVDQ Q\tOW NDSLWXOiFLy YROQD 'H EDUiWL N|UEHQ QpPHO\HN PiU SHG]HWWpN KRJ\ QLQFV PiV KiWUD PLQW YDODPL My VWUDWpJLiYDO OHKHWOHJ ÅWHUYV]HU,HQµ YLVV]DYRQXOQLDÅ6RODULVJ\EOµ &VDNKRJ\ H] D] ŁJ\µ ODVVDFVNiQ VRNDN IOHJ D ILDWD ORN V]HPpEHQDIIpOHSUyEDN OHWW VDMiW pUWpNNPpUFpMH ÅOpQ\HJpEHQ ² PRQGWiN ² QDJ\REE WpWUH PHJ\ D MiWpN PLQWKRJ\IHOGHUtWMNHD6RODULVFLYLOL]iFLyMiWUyOXQNYDQ LWWV]yD]HPEHULPHJLVPHUpVKDWiUDLUyOµ (J\LGHLJQpSV]HU, YROWD]D Qp]HWD QDSLVDMWy LV EX] JyQWHUMHV]WHWWH KRJ\DJRQGRONRGyyFHiQD]HJpV]6ROD ULVW HOERUtWy JLJiV]L DJ\ VRN PLOOLy pYL IHMOGpVVHO HOEEUH WDUW D PL FLYLOL]iFLyQNQiO ² ÅFVLOODJMyJLµ NR]PLNXV E|OFV HOHYHQPLQGHQWXGiVPHO\UpJiWOiWWDPLQGHQWHYpNHQ\VpJ KLiEDYDOyViJiW pV H]pUW KDOOJDW RO\DQ PHJiWDONRGRWWDQ +RORWW H] HJ\V]HU,HQ QHP LJD] KLV]HQ D] pO yFHiQ QDJ\RQ LV WHYpNHQ\NHGLN FVDN pSSHQ QHP HPEHUL HONpS ]HOpVHNV]HULQWWHKiWQHPpStWYiURVRNDWKLGDNDWUHSO JpSH]HWHNHW QHP SUyEiOMD OHJ\]QL YDJ\ iWOpSQL D WHUHW DNLN PLQGHQiURQ PHJ DNDUWiN YpGHQL D] HPEHU IHOVEE UHQG,VpJpW UHQGNtYO pUWpNHV WNiUW\iW OiWWDN HEEHQ  YLV]RQW H]HUIpOH iWYiOWR]iVW ÅRQWROyJLNXV DXWRPHWDPRUIy ]LVWµ PtYHO WXGyV WHUPLQXVRNEDQ D]WiQ QLQFV KLiQ\ D V]RODULV]WLNDL P,YHN ROGDODLQ 0LYHO SHGLJ D 6RODULV DGDWRN NiVDKHJ\pQHN PDNDFV RVWURPOyMiEDQ yKDWDWODQXO D] D] pU]pV WiPDG KRJ\ D] pUWHOPHV VW WDOiQ ]VHQLiOLV NRQVWUXNFLyN IRV]OiQ\DL YDODPL KLEEDQW DJ\ HV]HOV GD GRJiViYDO NHYHUHGQHN D ÅFVLOODJMyJLµJRQGRODW HOOHQOiED VDNpQWPHJMHOHQWDÅKO\HyFHiQµHOPpOHW (]HN D KLSRWp]LVHN NLUiQJDWWiN VtUMiEyO pV ~M pOHWUH NHOWHWWpND]HJ\LNOHJVLEEILOR]yILDLWpPiWD]DQ\DJpVD V]HOOHP D WXGDW YLV]RQ\iQDN SUREOpPiMiW -yNRUD DGDJ EiWRUViJ NHOOHWW DKKR] KRJ\ YDODNL ² GX +DDUW YROW 

D] ² HOVNpQW WXODMGRQtWVRQ WXGDWRW D] yFHiQQDN &VDN QHPPLQGHQYLWDpVHOOHQWpWPpO\pQH]DNpUGpVL]]RWWEiU D PHWRGROyJXVRN VLHWYH PHWDIL]LNXVQDN EpO\HJH]WpN /HKHWVpJHVHJRQGRONRGiVWXGDWQpONO"'HJRQGRONRGiV QDNQHYH]KHWMNHD]yFHiQEDQOHMiWV]yGyIRO\DPDWRNDW" ,JD]H KRJ\ D KHJ\ FVDN HJ\ QDJ\RQ QDJ\ N " $ ERO\Jy SHGLJ yULiVL KHJ\" 1HYH]KHWMN tJ\ LV GH D] ~M QDJ\ ViJUHQGGHO ~M W|UYpQ\V]HU,VpJHN pV ~M MHOHQVpJHN OpSQHN V]tQUH 2O\DQ OHWW H] D SUREOpPD NRUXQNEDQ PLQW KDMGDQ D N|U QpJ\V]|JHVtWpVH 0LQGHQ HUHGHWL HOPH LJ\HNH]HWW OH WHQQL D JDUDVW D 6RODULVJ\EHQ V]DSRURGWDN D] RO\DQ HOPpOHWHN KRJ\ D] yFHiQ ÅD] pUWHOHP YLUiJNRUiQDNµ UpJ P~OWV]DNDV]iWN|YHW KDQ\DWOiVpVHOIDMXOiVWHUPpNHVW KRJ\ QHP PiV PLQW HJ\ NRFVRQ\iV GDJDQDW PHO\ D ERO\Jy HJ\NRUL ODNRVDLQDN WHVWpEHQ NHOHWNH]HWW PDMG PLQGDQQ\LXNDW I|OIDOWD pV HOQ\HOWH |U|N pOHW, PDJiWyO PHJLIMXOyVHMWIHOHWWLNpSOHWWpROYDV]WYDDPDUDGYiQ\RNDW $ IpQ\FV|YHN I|OGL QDSSDOUD HPOpNH]WHW IHKpU YLOiJi QiO OHUiPROWDP D] DV]WDOUyO D P,V]HUHNHW pV N|Q\YHNHW P,DQ\DJ ODSMiQ V]pWWHUtWHWWHP D 6RODULV WpUNpSpW pV IpPNHUHWpUH WiPDV]NRGYD W]HWHVHQ V]HPJ\UH YHWWHP $] pO yFHiQ VHNpO\HEE PHGHQFpL PpO\ NDWODQRNNDO YiO WDNR]QDN V]LJHWHLW PiOOy N]HWHN OHGpNH ERUtWMD WHKiW YDODPLNRU D IHQHNpQ YROWDN ²  V]DEiO\R]Qi D EHOpPHUOW V]LNODW|PE|N IHOEXNNDQiViW pV HOVOO\HGpVpW LV" 6HM WHOPQN VLQFV UyOD 1p]WHP D VRNIpOH NpNUH pV OLOiUD IHVWHWW yULiVL IpOWHNpNHW D WpUNpSHQ pV NL WXGMD KiQ\DG V]RU PiU pOHWHPEHQ PHJLQW pSS~J\ HOiPXOWDP PLQW DNNRU UpJHQ LVNROiVNRURPEDQ DPLNRU HOV]|U WDQXOWXQN D6RODULVUyO 1HPWXGRPKRJ\DQW|UWpQW²HJ\V]HUUHOpQ\HJWHOHQQHN UpPOHWWN|UO|WWHPPLQGHQ*LEDULDQKDOiOiQDNOHVHONHG WLWNiYDO V D UiP YiUy LVPHUHWOHQ M|YYHO HJ\WW QHP JRQGROWDP VHPPLUH WHOMHVHQ HOPHUOWHP D PLQGHQ HPEHUWPHJG|EEHQW WpUNpSV]HPOpOpVpEHQ $]pO NpS]GPpQ\HJ\HVWpUVpJHLWD]RNUyODWXGyVRNUyO QHYH]WpN HO DNLN D] LOOHW WiMpN NXWDWiViQDN V]HQWHOWpN pOHWNHW eSSHQ D] HJ\HQOtWL V]LJHWFVRSRUW N|UO 

HOWHUO 7KH[DOONRFVRQ\XODWRW WDQXOPiQ\R]WDP DPLNRU PHJpUH]WHPKRJ\YDODNLQp] ÉOOWDP D WpUNpS I|O|WW GH PiU VHPPLW VHP OiWWDP EHOOHPLQWKDFVDNPHJEpQXOWDPYROQD$]DMWyV]HPEHQ YROWYHOHPHOWWHDOiGiNPHJHJ\ V]HNUpQ\NHLV9DODPL DXWRPDWD ² JRQGROWDP EiU HO]OHJ HJ\ VHP YROW D V]REiEDQ QHP LV M|KHWHWW EH pV]UHYpWOHQO 7DUNyPRQ KiWDPRQ pJQL NH]GHWW D EU HOYLVHOKHWHWOHQQp YiOW D UiP QHKH]HG PHUHY WHNLQWHW eV]UH VHP YHWWHP KRJ\ EHK~ ]RP D Q\DNDP V HJ\UH V~O\RVDEEDQ WiPDV]NRGRP D] DV]WDOUDODVVDQFV~V]QLNH]GHWWDSDGOyQpVH]DPR]JiV YDODKRJ\IHOV]DEDGtWRWW+LUWHOHQPHJIRUGXOWDP $ V]RED UHV YROW &VDN D] DEODN QDJ\ IHNHWH IpON|UH iVtWRWW IHOpP 6]RURQJiVRP QHP P~OW HO $ V|WpWVpJ HQ JHPQp]HWW²D]DODNWDODQV]HPQpONOLYpJWHOHQURSSDQW V|WpWVpJ(J\HWOHQFVLOODJVHPOiWV]RWWD]pJHQ /HK~]WDP D UHGQ\W (J\ yUiMD VH YROWDP D] ÉOORPiVRQ pV PiULV NH]GWHP pUWHQL PLpUW WiPDG LWW D] HPEHUHNEHQ OG|]pVL PiQLD gQNpQWHOHQO NDSFVRODWED KR]WDP H]W *LEDULDQ KDOiOiYDO ,VPHUWHP W V HGGLJ ~J\ JRQGROWDP VHPPL PHJ QHP ]DYDUKDWQi D] HOPpMpW 'H PRVW PiU QHP YROWDPHEEHQEL]WRV ÉOOWDP D V]RED N|]HSpQ D] DV]WDOQiO 1\XJRGWDEEDQ OpOHJH]WHP pUH]WHP DPLQW KRPORNRPRQ PHJK,O D] L]JD ORP YHUtWpNH 0LUH LV JRQGROWDP D] LPpQW" 3HUV]H D] DXWRPDWiNUD 1DJ\RQ IXUFVD KRJ\ HJ\HW VH OiWQL VHP D IRO\RVyQVHPDV]REiNEDQ+RYiW,QKHWWHN"$]HJ\HWOHQ DPHO\LNNHO ² PHVV]LUO ² WDOiONR]WDP D UHSOWpU JpSL V]HPpO\]HWpKH]WDUWR]RWW'HKRODW|EEL" ÐUiPUD Qp]WHP ,QGXOQRP LV NHOOHQH 6QDXWKR] .LOpSWHP D IRO\RVyUD $ PHQQ\H]HW DODWW IXWy IpQ\FV|YHN HOpJ J\|QJpQ YLOiJtWRWWDN (OPHQWHP NpW DMWy HOWW V DKKR] pUNH]WHP DPHO\LNUH *LEDULDQ QHYH YROW NLtUYD 6RNiLJ WpWRYi]WDP HOWWH $] ÉOORPiV QpPD YROW $ NLOLQFVUH WHWWHP D NH]HP 9ROWDNpSSHQ HJ\iOWDOiQ QHP DNDUWDP EHPHQQL /DVVDQ KDMORWW D NLOLQFV XMMQ\L UpV Q\tOW D] DMWyQ HJ\ SLOODQDWLJ IHNHWHVpJ YROW EHOO D]WiQ NLJ\XOODGW D YLOODQ\ +D PRVW M|QQH YDODNL D IRO\RVyQ U|JW|Q PHJOiWQD *\RUVDQ EHOpSWHP pV ]DMWDODQXO GH HUVHQEHFVXNWDPD]DMWyW$]WiQPHJIRUGXOWDP 

/HJ\|NHUH]YH iOOWDP D] DMWy HOWW KiWDPPDO PDMGQHP KR]]iVLPXOYD $ V]RED QDJ\REE YROW D] HQ\pPQpO LWW LV SDQRUiPDDEODN KiURPQHJ\HG UpV]pW DSUy NpN pV Uy]VDV]tQ YLUiJRV IJJ|Q\ WDNDUWD Q\LOYiQ D )|OGUO KR]WiN QHP WDUWR]LN D] ÉOORPiV IHOV]HUHOpVpKH] $ IDO PHQWpQ QDJ\RQ KDOYiQ\ ]|OGUH ]RPiQFR]RWW H]VW IpQ\, N|Q\YHVSROFRN pV V]HNUpQ\HN VRUDNR]WDN 7DUWDOPXN KDORPED GREiOYD KHYHUW D] DV]WDORN pV NDURVV]pNHN N|]|WW/iEDPHOWWNpWIHOERUXOWJpSDV]WDONDWRUODV]ROWDHO D] XWDW IpOLJ EHWHPHWWpN NHW D V]pWKDVtWRWW WDUWyNEyO NLKXOOW IRO\yLUDWRN 1\LWRWW N|Q\YHN KiQ\yGWDN ORPELNRN pVSDODFNRNFVHUHSHLN|]WOLEHJ ODSMDLNRQYpJLJ|PO|WWHN D YHJ\V]HUHN ² SHGLJ D OHJW|EE YHJ RO\DQ YDVWDJ IDO~ KRJ\ KD HJ\V]HU,HQ OHHVLN DNiU My PDJDVUyO DWWyO PpJ QHP W|ULN |VV]H $] DEODNQiO IHOGOW tUyDV]WDO NLQ\~Oy NDUMiQROYDVyOiPSDURQFVDD]HOWWHKHYHU V]pNNpWOiED IpOLJ NLK~]RWW ILyNRNED PpO\HG &pGXOiN Np]tUiVVDO WHOHUyWW tYHN SDStURN iUDGDWD ERUtWRWWD D SDGOyW 0HJLVPHUWHP *LEDULDQ tUiViW pV D MHJ\]HWHN I|Op KDMROWDP0LNRUI|OHPHOWHPDV]pWV]yUWtYHNHWDUUDOHWWHP ILJ\HOPHV KRJ\ D NH]HP PiU QHP HJ\ iUQ\pNRW YHW KDQHPNHWWW 0HJIRUGXOWDP )HQW pOHV KDWiU~ YDNtWy NpN W,]FVtN OiQJROW D IJJ|Q\|Q HJ\UH V]pOHVHGYH PLQWKD NLJ\XOODGW YROQD D Uy]ViV NDUWRQ )pOUHUiQWRWWDP ² LMHV]W IpQ\|]|Q NiSUi]WDWRWW HO %HW|OW|WWH D KRUL]RQW KDUPDGUpV]pW $ KXOOiPY|OJ\HNEHQ NtVpUWHWLHVHQ PHJQ\~OW KRVV]~ iUQ\p NRNKDGDURQWRWWD]ÉOORPiVIHOp(]YROWDQDSIHONHOWH,WW D]ÉOORPiVMHOHQOHJLI|OGUDM]LV]pOHVVpJpQHJ\yUiVpMV]DND XWiQ NHO IHO D ERO\Jy PiVRGLN NpN QDSMD $] |QP,N|G NLNDSFVROy PiU HOROWRWWD D PHQQ\H]HWYLOiJtWiVW PLNRU YLVV]DWpUWHP D SDStUKDORPKR] (J\ KiURP KpWWHO H]HOWW WHUYH]HWW NtVpUOHW U|YLG OHtUiViUD EXNNDQWDP *LEDULDQ QDJ\RQ NHPpQ\ U|QWJHQVXJiU]iVW DNDUW D SOD]PiUD LUiQ\tWDQL $ V]|YHJEO NLYLOiJORWW KRJ\ D NtVpUOHWHW OHERQ\ROtWy 6DUWRULXV V]iPiUD NpV]OW H] FVDN Pi VRGSpOGiQ\ $ IHKpU ODSRN YDNtWDQL NH]GWHN 0LQGHQ HJpV]HQ PiV YROW PLQW D] pMV]DND EHiOOWD HOWW $NNRU W|EEQ\LUH SLV]NRVUy]VDV]tQ N|G JRPRO\JRWW D K,O QDS IpQ\pEHQ YpUY|U|VHQ pV WLQWDIHNHWpQ FVLOORJy yFHiQ I|O|WW HJ\EHPRVYD D QDUDQFVV]tQ, pJEROWRW D IHOKNHW pV D KXOOiPRNDW 0RVW PLQGH] HOW,QW $ Uy]ViV IJJ|Q\|Q iW 

HQ\pPPpO

LV ~J\ pJHWW D IpQ\ DNiU HJ\ HUV NYDUFOiPSD L]]yMD /HEDUQXOWNH]HPPDMGQHPKDPXV]UNpQHNOiWV]RWW0HJ YiOWR]RWWD]HJpV]V]REDPLQGHQY|U|VHViUQ\DODW~KROPL EDUQD OHWW YDJ\ PiMV]tQ,UH IDNXOW D IHKpU ]|OG pV ViUJD WiUJ\DN V]tQH YLV]RQW ~J\ IHOUDJ\RJRWW KRJ\ V]LQWH YLOi JtWRWWDN +XQ\RURJYD Qp]WHP NL D IJJ|Q\ UpVpQ ROYDGW IpP UHPHJHWW pV YRQDJORWW D] pJ IHKpU W,]WHQJHUH DODWW %HKXQ\WDP D V]HPHP WiJXOy W,]NDULNiNDW OiWWDP $ PRVGy SROFiQ D NDJ\Oy LV W|U|WW YROW  iODUFQDN EHLOO yULiVL QDSV]HPYHJ KHYHUW J\RUVDQ I|OWHWWHP $ IJJ|Q\ PRVW~J\L]]RWWPLQWDQiWULXPOiQJgVV]HV]HGWHPDSD StURNDW D] HJ\HWOHQ IHO QHP ERUXOW DV]WDOUD UDNWDP pV WRYiEEROYDVWDP$V]|YHJHJ\UpV]HKLiQ\]RWW ÉWIXWRWWDP D] HOYpJ]HWW NtVpUOHWHN MHJ\]N|Q\YpW .L GHUOW KRJ\ QpJ\ QDSRQ NHUHV]WO EHVXJiUR]WiN D] yFHiQW D MHOHQOHJL KHO\WO H]HUQpJ\V]i] PpUI|OGGHO pV]DN NHOHWUH 0LQGH] QDJ\RQ PHJOHSHWW KLV]HQ D U|QWJHQVX JDUDN DONDOPD]iViW SXV]WtWy KDWiVXN PLDWW (16=HJ\H] PpQ\ WLOWMD pV EL]WRVDQ WXGWDP KRJ\ QHP NpUWHN HQJH GpO\W D )|OGWO H]HNUH D NtVpUOHWHNUH 2OYDViV N|]EHQ HJ\V]HUIHOQp]WHP V D Q\LWRWW V]HNUpQ\DMWy WN|UODSMiEDQ PHJSLOODQWRWWDP PDJDPDW KXOODIHKpU DUF D QDJ\ IHNHWH V]HPYHJJHO +iWERU]RQJDWy YROW D NpNHVIHKpU IpQ\EHQ pJ V]RED GH SiU SHUF P~OYD FVLNRUJiV KDOODWV]RWW pV W|NpOHWHVHQ ]iUy SiQFpOODS HUHV]NHGHWW D] DEODNUD V|WpW OHWW D]WiQ NLJ\~OW D PRVW IXUFViQ ViSDGWQDN WHWV] PHVWHUVpJHV YLOiJtWiV (]XWiQ PiU FVDN D PHOHJ IRNR]yGRWW D KV]DEiO\R]y YH]HWpNHN V]HOtG ]PP|JpVH pOHV VLYtWiVED PHQW iW WHOMHV HUYHO GROJR]RWW D] ÉOORPiV K,WEHUHQGH]pVH0pJLVWRYiEEQWWDIRMWyKVpJ /pSWHNHW KDOORWWDP 9DODNL M|WW D IRO\RVyQ .pW QHV]WH OHQXJUiVVDOD]DMWyQiOWHUPHWWHP$OpSWHNWpWRYi]WDNpV HOQpPXOWDN $] D YDODNL RWW iOOW D] DMWy HOWW /DVVDQ PR]GXOW D NLOLQFV JRQGRONRGiV QpONO |V]W|Q|VHQ PHJ UDJDGWDPpVYLVV]DWDUWRWWDP$Q\RPiVQHPHUV|G|WWGH QHP LV J\HQJOW $ YDODNL D] DMWy W~OVy ROGDOiQ pSSRO\DQ FV|QGEHQ YROW PLQW pQ WDOiQ PHJOHSG|WW -y GDUDELJ IRJWXNDNLOLQFVHW$]WiQKLUWHOHQIHOV]|N|WWDNH]HPEHQ² HOHQJHGWpN pV KDON QHV] WDQ~VtWRWWD KRJ\ D PiVLN HOPHJ\0pJVRNiLJIOHOWHPGHFV|QGYROW 

9HQGpJHN

+DPDUMiEDQ QpJ\UpW KDMWRWWDP pV ]VHEUH YiJWDP *L EDULDQ MHJ\]HWHLW /DVVDQ D V]HNUpQ\KH] OpSWHP EHOHSLO ODQWRWWDP ² D NH]HVOiEDVRN pV |OW|Q\|N D] HJ\LN ROGDOUD ]V~IROyGWDNPLQWKDQHPUpJYDODNLRWWiOOWYROQDN|]WN$ SDGOyQ KHYHU SDStUKDORPEyO ERUtWpN FVFVNH NDQGLNiOW NL)|OYHWWHP1HNHPV]yOW(OV]RUXOyV]tYYHOWpSWHPIHOpV NpQ\V]HUtWHWWHPPDJDPKRJ\V]pWQ\LVVDPDEHQQHODSXOy SDStUV]HOHWNpW (] YROW UDMWD *LEDULDQ V]DEiO\RV PiNV]HP EHW,V GH N|QQ\HQROYDVKDWytUiViYDO $QQ 6RODU 9RO , $QQH[ pV 0HVVHQJHU 9RW 6HSDU ) J\EHQ5DYLQW]HU.LV$SRNULI

(QQ\L pV HJ\ V]yYDO VH W|EE 1DJ\RQ VLHWKHWHWW H]]HO D OHYpOOHO 7DOiQ YDODPL IRQWRV ]HQHW" 0LNRU tUKDWWD" 6UJVHQ IHO NHOO PHQQHP D N|Q\YWiUED JRQGROWDP $ V]RODULV]WLNDL pYN|Q\YHN HOV N|WHWpQHN IJJHOpNpW LVPHU WHP LOOHWYH WXGWDP D OpWH]pVpUO GH VRKDVHP YROW D NH ]HPEHQKLV]HQSXV]WiQW|UWpQHWLpUWpNHYDQ5DYLQW]HUUO pV.LV$SRNULIMpUOPpJFVDNQHPLVKDOORWWDP 0LWWHJ\HN" 0iULV NpVWHP HJ\ QHJ\HGyUiW $] DMWyEyO PpJ HJ\V]HU N|UOQp]WHP &VDN PRVW OiWWDP PHJ D IDOKR] VLPXOy OHKDMWKDWyiJ\DWPHUWHOWDNDUWDD6RODULVQ\LWRWWWpUNpSH 0|J|WWH IJJ|WW YDODPL =VHEPDJQHWRIRQ WRNEDQ .LYHW WHP EHOOH WRNMiW YLVV]DDNDV]WRWWDP D PDJQyW SHGLJ ]VHEUHYiJWDP/iWWDPDV]iPOiOyMiQKRJ\PDMGQHPWHOH YDQDWHNHUFV ,VPpWPHJiOOWDPHJ\SLOODQDWUDD]DMWyEDQpVEHKXQ\W V]HPPHO IHV]OWHQ ILJ\HOWHP D NLQWL FV|QGHW 6HPPL .LOpSWHPDIRO\RVyIHNHWHDNQiQDNUpPOHWW²PpJPRVWLV UDMWDP YROW D V|WpW V]HPYHJ OHYHWWHP tJ\ PiU OiWWDP D ViSDGWPHQQ\H]HWYLOiJtWiVW%HFVXNWDPPDJDPP|J|WWD] DMWyWVHOLQGXOWDPEDOUDDUiGLyN|]SRQWIHOp 

1HP PHVV]H D NHUHN FVDUQRNWyO DPHO\EO NOONNpQW iJD]QDN V]pW D IRO\RVyN V],N iWMiUy Q\tOW DOLJKDQHP D IUGV]REiN IHOp V PpO\pQ EL]RQ\WDODQ N|UYRQDO~ FVDN QHPWHOMHVHQ D IpOKRPiO\ED YHV] yULiVL DODNRW SLOODQWRW WDPPHJ )|OGEH J\|NHUH]HWW D OiEDP .pQ\HOPHV NDFVi]y OpS WHNNHO WDJEDV]DNDGW QpJHU Q M|WW IHOpP D] iWMiUyEDQ /iWWDP YLOORJy V]HPH IHKpUMpW pV V]LQWH XJ\DQDEEDQ D SLOODQDWEDQ PiU FVXSDV] WDOSiQDN SXKD FVRVV]DQiVDLW LV KDOORWWDP1HP YROWUDMWD VHPPL FVDNHJ\ ViUJiVDQFVLO ORJyWDOiQV]DOPiEyOIRQWV]RNQ\DOyJyPHOOH KDWDOPDV IHNHWH NDUMDL FRPEYDVWDJViJ~DN IHOpP VH Qp]YH K|P S|O\J|WW HO PHOOHWWHP ² HJ\ PpWHUUH KD YROW ² pV WRYiEE ULQJDWWD HOHIiQWIDUiW PHOO\HO VW|UWpQHWL P~]HXPRN W~OWHQJ FVtSHM, SDOHROLWNRUL V]REUDLUD KDVRQOtWRWW $ IRO\RVy VDUNiQ EHIRUGXOW pV HOW,QW *LEDULDQ NDELQMiEDQ $ V]REiEyO NLFVDSy IpQ\ HJ\ SLOODQDWLJ pOHVHQ PHJYLOi JtWRWWD $]WiQ KDONDQ EHFVXNyGRWW D] DMWy pV HJ\HGO PDUDGWDP -REE NH]HPPHO iWIRJWDP D EDO FVXNOyPDW pV WHOMHV HUPEO PHJV]RUtWRWWDP KRJ\FVDN~J\ URSRJWDN D FVRQWMDLP .iEiQ Qp]WHP N|UO 0L W|UWpQW" 0L YROW H]" +LUWHOHQ PLQWKD IEH NyOLQWRWWDN YROQD HV]HPEH MXWRWW 6QDXW ILJ\HOPH]WHWpVH 'H KiW PLW MHOHQW H]" .L H] D I|UWHOPHV $SKURGLWp" +RJ\ NHUO LGH" (J\ FVDN HJ\HWOHQHJ\ OpSpVW WHWWHP *LEDULDQ NDELQMD IHOp pV PiULV PHJWRUSDQWDP 1DJ\RQ MyO WXGWDP KRJ\ QHP OpSHN EH RGD 7iJXOy RUUO\XNNDO V]LPDWROWDP 9DODPL QLQFV UHQG MpQ YDODPL KLiQ\]LN ² SHUV]H gV]W|Q|VHQ YiUWDP D] XQGRUtWyHUVL]]DGViJV]DJRWGHPpJDNNRUVHPpUH]WHP VHPPLWDPLNRUHJ\OpSpVUHYROWWOHP 1HP WXGRP PHGGLJ iOOWDP RWW D K,Y|V IpPIDOQDN WiPDV]NRGYD$]ÉOORPiVQpPDYROWFVDNDKV]DEiO\R]y V]LYDWW\~NE~JWDNYDODKROHJ\KDQJ~DQ 1\LWRWW WHQ\pUUHO PHJSDVNROWDP D] DUFRP pV HOWi PRO\RJWDP D UiGLyN|]SRQWLJ 0LNRU OHQ\RPWDP D NLOLQ FVHWpOHVKDQJFVDWWDQWIHO ².LD]" ²eQYDJ\RN.HOYLQ 6QDXW D NLVDV]WDOQiO OW HJ\ UDNiV NRQ]HUY PHJ D UiGLyDGy N|]|WW pV K~VNLYRQDWRW HYHWW FVDN ~J\ D GR ER]EyO 1HP WXGRP PLpUW N|OW|]|WW pSSHQ D UiGLyN|] 

SRQWED %iUJ\~Q iOOWDP D] DMWyEDQ Qp]WHP HJ\HQOHWHVHQ UiJy iOONDSFViW pV KLUWHOHQ PHJpUH]WHP PLO\HQ pKHV YDJ\RN$ SROFKR] OpSWHP NLYiODV]WRWWDP D WiQ\pURV]ORS EyO D OHJNHYpVEp SRURVDW pV OHOWHP 6QDXWWDO V]HPEHQ (J\ GDUDELJ V]yWODQXO HWWQN  D]XWiQ IHOiOOW WHUPRV]W YHWW HO D IDOLV]HNUpQ\EO pV IRUUy HUOHYHVW W|OW|WW PLQG NHWWQNQHN /HWHWWH D WHUPRV]W D SDGOyUD PHUW D] DV]WD ORQPiUQHPYROWKHO\pVPHJNpUGH]WH ²/iWWDG6DUWRULXVW" ²1HP+ROYDQ" ²)HQW 6]yYDO D ODERUDWyULXPEDQ 1pPiQ HWWQN WRYiEE PtJ D GRER] IHQHNpQ PHJ QHP FVLNRUGXOW D NDQiO $ UiGLyVV]REiEDQpMV]DNDKRQROW$]DEODNRWHO]iUWDDNOV SiQFpOODS D PHQQ\H]HWHQ QpJ\ NHUHN IpQ\WHVW pJHWW 9LVV]IpQ\N UHPHJVHQ YLEUiOW D] DGySXOW P,DQ\DJ ODSMiQ 6QDXWMiURPFVRQWMDIHOHWWY|U|VHUHFVNpNKiOy]WiNEHD IHV]O EUW 0RVW HOQ\,WW O|W\|J IHNHWH SXOyYHU YROW UDMWD ²5RVV]XOpU]HGPDJDG"²NpUGH]WH ²1HP0LpUW" ²0HJL]]DGWiO 9pJLJVLPtWRWWDP D KRPORNRPRQ &VDNXJ\DQ SDWDN]RWW UyODP D YHUtWpN Q\LOYiQ D] HOEEL UpPOHWWO 6QDXW pOH VHQIUNpV]WHDUFRP(OPRQGMDPQHNL")HGMHLQNiEE IHO D NiUW\iLW .L MiWV]LN LWW NL HOOHQ pV PLIpOH UHMWpO\HV PyGRQ" ²0HOHJYDQ²PRQGWDP²$]WKLWWHPMREEDQP,N|GLN QiODWRNDKV]DEiO\R]iV ² (J\ yUD DODWW OHK,O %L]WRV KRJ\ FVDN D PHOHJWO" ² VDQGtWRWW UiP 6]RUJDOPDVDQ IDOWDP PLQWKD QHP LV KDOORWWDPYROQDNpUGpVpW ²0LNDWHUYHLG"²NpUGH]WHPLNRUYpJUHEHIHMH]WND] HYpVW$PRVGyEDUDNWDD]HGpQ\WPHJD]UHVGRER]RNDW pVYLVV]DOWDNDURVV]pNpEH ² $ONDOPD]NRGRP KR]]iWRN ² IHOHOWHP N|]|Q\|V KDQJRQ ² 9DQ YDODPL NXWDWiVL WHUYHWHN QHP" ÉOOtWyODJ YDODPL~MPyGV]HUU|QWJHQYDJ\PLXJ\H" ² 5|QWJHQ" ² YRQWDIHOD V]HP|OG|NpW ² +RO KDOORWWDG H]W" 

² 1HP LV WXGRP 9DODNL HPOtWHWWH 7DOiQ D 3URPp WKHXV]RQ1RpV" &VLQiOMiWRNPiU" ² eQ QHP LVPHUHP D UpV]OHWHNHW *LEDULDQ |WOHWH YROW 6DUWRULXVV]DONH]GWpNHO'HWHKRQQDQWXGKDWV]HUUO " 9iOODWYRQWDP ²1HPLVPHUHGDUpV]OHWHNHW"3HGLJRWWNHOOHWW OHQQHG KLV]HQ D V]DNPiGED YiJ ² HOKDUDSWDP D PRQGDWRW 1HP V]yOW VHPPLW $ KV]DEiO\R]y VLYtWiVD HOFVHQGHVOW D PHOHJ HOYLVHOKHW V]LQWHQ PDUDGW &VDN HJ\ IRO\WRQRV PDJDV KDQJ IJJ|WW D OHYHJEHQ PLQW HJ\ KDOGRNOy OpJ\ ]PP|JpVH 6QDXW IHOiOOW D] LUiQ\tWySXOWKR] OpSHWW pV NDWWRJWDWQL NH]GWH D NDSFVROyNDW WHOMHVHQ pUWHOPHWOHQO KLV]HQD JpSEHQ QHP LV YROWiUDP (J\ GDUDELJ MiWV]DGR ]RWWD]WiQKiWUDVHQp]YHPHJV]yODOW ² (O NHOO PDMG LQWp]QL D IRUPDViJRNDW HN|UO D    WXGRG ²,JHQ" 6DUNRQ IRUGXOW pV PDMG iWG|I|WW D V]HPpYHO 1HP PRQGKDWQiP KRJ\ V]iQGpNRVDQ KR]WDP NL D VRGUiEyO GH PLYHO VHMWHOPHP VHP YROW PLIpOH MiWV]PD IRO\LN LWW MREEQDN OiWWDP KD WDUWy]NRGyDQ YLVHONHGHP &VRQWRV iGiPFVXWNiMD IHOIHOEXNNDQW D IHNHWH SXOyYHU PDJDV Q\DNDI|O|WW ²7HEHQWYROWiO*LEDULDQQiO²V]|JH]WHOHKLUWHOHQ1HP NpUGpVQHN V]iQWD )HOYRQWDP D V]HP|OG|N|P pV KLJ JDGWDQD]DUFiEDQp]WHP ²7HYROWiODV]REiMiEDQ²LVPpWHOWH 7DOiQ\RVDQ ELFFHQWHWWHP ÅQR pV D]WiQµ YDJ\ ÅWHJ\N IHOµPyGUD $]WDNDUWDPKRJ\IRO\WDVVD ².LYROWRWW"²IDJJDWRWW 6]yYDOWXGDUUyODQUO  ²6HQNL²UDYDV]NRGWDP².LOHWWYROQD" ²$NNRUPLpUWQHPHQJHGWpOEH" (OYLJ\RURGWDP ² ,MHGWHPEHQ 0LXWiQ ILJ\HOPH]WHWWpO   DPLNRU PHJ PR]GXOW D NLOLQFV |V]W|Q|VHQ HONDSWDP 'H PLpUW QHP PRQGWDGKRJ\WHYDJ\"%HHQJHGWHOHNYROQD ²$]WKLWWHP6DUWRULXV²PRUPROWDEL]RQ\WDODQXO ²1RpVKD OHWWYROQD" 

²6]HULQWHG  PLW|UWpQWRWW"²ILUWDWWDYiODV]KHO\HWW 7pWRYi]WDP ²1HNHGMREEDQNHOOWXGQRG+ROYDQ" ² $ K,WKi]EDQ ² IHOHOW D]RQQDO ² 0LQGMiUW UHJJHO OHYLWWN  DPHOHJPLDWW ²+ROWDOiOWiOUi" ²$V]HNUpQ\EHQ ²$V]HNUpQ\EHQ"+ROWDQ" ²$V]tYHPpJP,N|G|WWGHQHPOpOHJ]HWW$JRQL]iOW ²1HPSUyEiOWDGPHJPHQWHQL" ²1HP ²0LpUW" +DER]RWW ²0iUNpV YROW0LUHOHIHNWHWWHPPHJKDOW ²2WWiOOWDV]HNUpQ\EHQ"$NH]HVOiEDVRNN|]|WW" ²,JHQ $ VDURNEDQ iOOy NLV tUyDV]WDOKR] PHQW pV I|OYHWW UyOD HJ\SDStUODSRW(OpPWHWWH ²ÌUWDPHJ\LGHLJOHQHVMHJ\]N|Q\YHW²PRQGWD²-yLV KRJ\N|UOQp]WpO D V]REiMiEDQ $] H[LWXV RND   KDOiORV DGDJSHUQRV]WiOLQMHNFLy,WWYDQROYDVG   ÉWIXWRWWDPDU|YLGV]|YHJHW ² gQJ\LONRVViJ   ² LVPpWHOWHP KDONDQ ² 'H KiW PLpUW   " ² ,GHJ|VV]HRPOiV   GHSUHVV]Ly   YDJ\ PLQHN KtY MiN(KKH]WHMREEDQpUWHV] ²eQFVDNDKKR]pUWHNDPLWPDJDPOiWRN²IHOHOWHPpV OW|PEODOXOUyODV]HPpEHQp]WHP ²(]]HOPLWDNDUV]PRQGDQL"²NpUGH]WHQ\XJRGWDQ ²%HDGWDPDJiQDNDSHUQRV]WiOWpVDV]HNUpQ\EHE~MW LJD]" +iW KD tJ\ YROW DNNRU H] QHP GHSUHVV]Ly H] QHP KROPL LGHJ|VV]HURSSDQiV KDQHP V~O\RV SV]LFKy]LV 3DUDQRLD   %L]RQ\iUD D]W KLWWH KRJ\ OiW YDODPLW   ² IRO\WDWWDP HJ\UH ODVVDEEDQ D V]HPpEH PHUHV]WYH V]HPHP $ UiGLySXOWKR] PHQW V PHJLQW D NDSFVROyNDW NDWWRJ WDWWD ²7HtUWDGDOi²V]yOWDPHJ\LG P~OYD²eV6DUWRULXV" ² )HQW YDQ D ODERUEDQ 0RQGWDP PiU 1HP PXWDWNR ]LND]WKLV]HP   ²0LWKLV]HO" 

²+RJ\EH]iUNy]RWW ² %H]iUNy]RWW" $Ki %H]iUNy]RWW 1R WHVVpN 7DOiQ HO LVEDULNiGR]WDPDJiW" ²/HKHW ²6QDXW  ²PRQGWDP²D]ÉOORPiVRQYDQYDODNL ²/iWWDG" (OUHKDMROYDPHUHGWUiP ²+iWPLUHILJ\HOPH]WHWWpO"+DOOXFLQiFLyNUD" ²0LWOiWWiO" ²(PEHUYDQLWWLJD]" +DOOJDWRWW$IDOQDNIRUGXOWPLQWKDQHPDNDUQiKRJ\ OiVVDP D] DUFiW 8MMDLYDO GREROW D IpPODSRQ .H]pUH Qp] WHP 0iU QHP YROW UDMWD YpUQ\RP +LUWHOHQ YLOiJRVViJ J\~OWD]DJ\DPEDQ ² 9DOyViJRV HPEHU ² IRO\WDWWDP KDONDQ V]LQWH VXW WRJYD PLQWKD WLWNRW iUXOQpN HO pV NLKDOOJDWKDWQiQDN ² ,JD]"0HJOHKHW  pULQWHQL0HJOHKHW  VHEHVtWHQL   pVWHPDLVOiWWDG ²+RQQDQWXGRG" 1HPIRUGXOWIHOpPÉOOWDIDOKR]ODSXOYDDKRJ\V]DYDLP RGDV]|JH]WpN ² eSSHQ PLHOWW pQ PHJpUNH]WHP   1HP VRNNDO D] HOWW   gVV]HUiQGXOW PLQWKD YpJLJYHUWHN YROQD UDMWD 7pER O\XOWV]HPSiUPHUHGWUiP ²7H"²K|U|JWH²+iWWHNLYDJ\" ÔJ\ OiWV]RWW PLQGMiUW UiP YHWL PDJiW (UUH QHP V]i PtWRWWDP )HMH WHWHMpUH iOOW D KHO\]HW 1HP KLV]L KRJ\ D] YDJ\RN DNLQHN PRQGRP PDJDP" 0LW MHOHQW H]" $UFD HOWRU]XOW D UpPOHWWO (OPHEDM" 0pUJH]pV" 0LQGHQ OH KHWVpJHV 'H D]W D ² V]|UQ\HWHJHW pQ PDJDP OiWWDP KiW DNNRUpQ  pQLV   " ² .L YROW D]" ² W|UW NL EHOOHP (] D NpUGpV PHJ Q\XJWDWWD (J\ GDUDELJ YL]VJiOJDWRWW PLQWKD PpJ QHP YROQDEL]WRV D GROJiEDQ 'H PiU PLHOWW PHJV]yODOW WXG WDPKRJ\URVV]DWOpSWHPpVQHPIRJYiODV]ROQL /DVVDQ OHOW D NDURVV]pNEH pV IHMpUH V]RUtWRWWD NpW NH]pW ² 0LN W|UWpQQHN LWW   ² PRUPROWD ² /LGpUFQ\R PiV   ².LYROWD]"²NpUGH]WHP~MUD 

²+DQHPWXGRG  ²GQQ\|JWH ²$NNRUPLYDQ" ²$NNRUVHPPL ² 6QDXW ² PRQGWDP ² HOpJ PHVV]H YDJ\XQN KD]XOUyO -iWVV]XQN Q\tOW NiUW\iNNDO ÔJ\LV RO\DQ ]DYDURV LWW PLQGHQ ²+iWPLWDNDUV]" ²0RQGGPHJNLWOiWWiO ²eVWH   "²YiJWDUiJ\DQDNRGYD ²ÌJ\QHPMXWXQNVHPPLUHeQPHJPRQGRPGHPRQGG PHJ WH LV 1\XJRGW OHKHWV] QHP WDUWDODN UOWQHN PHUW WXGRP   ² UOWQHN 8UDPLVWHQ ² SUyEiOW QHYHWQL ² (PEHU KLV]HQ WH VHPPLW GH VHPPLW   KLV]HQ D] PHJYiOWiV OHQQH+D HJ\SHUFLJLVD]W KLWWH YROQDKRJ\PHJERORQ GXOWDNNRUQHPWHV]LH]WDNNRUpOQH   ² 6]yYDO DPLW D MHJ\]N|Q\YEHQ D] LGHJ|VV]HRPOiVUyO tUWiOD]KD]XJViJ" ²+iWSHUV]H ²eVPLpUWQHPtURGD]LJD]DW" ²0LpUW   "²VyKDMWRWW +DOOJDWWXQNHJ\VRUW0HJLQWNRURPV|WpWEHQWDSRJDWy] WDPQHPpUWHWWHPVHPPLWSHGLJPiUPiUD]WKLWWHPVL NHUO PHJJ\]Q|P pV N|]|V HUYHO URKDPR]]XN PHJ D UHMWpO\W'HKiWPLpUWPLpUWQHPDNDUEHV]pOQL" ²+ROYDQQDND]DXWRPDWiN"²NH]GWHP~MUD ²$UDNWiUEDQ%H]iUWXNNHWNLYpYHDUHSOWpULHNHW ²0LpUW" (UUHVHPYiODV]ROW ²1HPPRQGRGPHJ" ²1HPPRQGKDWRP 6HKRJ\ VH WXGWDP D KHO\]HW Q\LWMiKR] IpUN]QL )|O PHQMHN 6DUWRULXVKR]" +LUWHOHQ HV]HPEH MXWRWW D FpGXOD pVH]WOiWWDPPRVWDOHJIRQWRVDEEQDN ² +RJ\ NpS]HOHG LO\HQ N|UOPpQ\HN N|]|WW D WRYiEEL PXQNiW"²WiPDGWDPUi 0HJYHWHQYiOODWYRQW ².LWpUGHNHODPXQND" ²$]WPRQGRG"+iWDNNRUPLWDNDUV]FVLQiOQL" 

1HP IHOHOW $ FV|QGEHQ PH]tWOiEDV OpSWHN WiYROL QHV]H KDOODWV]RWW$QLNNHOpVP,DQ\DJNpV]OpNHNPHQQ\H]HWLJ pU HOHNWURQLNXVDJ\DNPLNURV]NySRNpVSUHFt]LyVP,V]H UHN N|]|WW ~J\ KDWRWW H] D ORPKD FVRV]RJy MiUiV PLQW YDODPL IpONHJ\HOP, ERKyF PXWDWYiQ\D $ OpSpVHN N|]H OHGWHN )HOiOOWDP pV L]JDWRWWDQ OHVWHP 6QDXWRW 5pVUH KXQ\RUtWRWW V]HPPHO IOHOW GH HJ\ FV|SS LMHGHOHP VH OiW V]RWWUDMWD+iWPpJVHPWOHIpO"" ²+RJ\NHUOWH]LGH"²NpUGH]WHPeVDPLNRUNpVHWWD YiODV]²1HPDNDURGPHJPRQGDQL" ²1HPWXGRP ²1RMy $OpSWHNWiYRORGWDNpVHOKDOWDN ² 1HP KLV]HG HO" ² Qp]HWW UiP ² %HFVOHWV]DYDPUD QHPWXGRP 6]yWODQXONLQ\LWRWWDPDV]NDIDQGHUHVV]HNUpQ\WpVIpO UHWROWDP D QHKp] UHV J~Q\iNDW 0LQW YiUWDP EHOO D NDPSyNRQ OyJWDN D V~O\WDODQViJ iOODSRWiEDQ YpJ]HQG ,UVpWiNKR] YDOy Ji]SLV]WRO\RN 6RNDW QHP pU GH PpJLVFVDNIHJ\YHU-REEPLQWDVHPPL0HJYL]VJiOWDPD WDUWiO\W V YiOODPUD DNDV]WRWWDP D WRNRW 6QDXW pEHUHQ ILJ\HOW 0LNRU LJD]tWRWWDP D V]tM KRVV]iQ J~Q\RVDQ UiP YLJ\RUJRWWViUJDIRJDLYDO ²6]HUHQFVpVYDGiV]DWRW²KXKRJWD ² .|V]|Q|N PLQGHQW ² IHOHOWHP D] DMWy IHOp WDUWYD )HOXJURWWDNDURVV]pNEO ².HOYLQ 5iQp]WHP 0iU QHP YLJ\RUJRWW 1HP WXGRP OiWWDPH YDODKDLO\HQHONtQ]RWWDUFRW ² .HOYLQ H] QHP   pQ   pQ LJD]iQ QHP   ² GD GRJWD 9iUWDP IRO\WDWMDH GH FVDN D V]iMiW PR]JDWWD PLQWKDYDODPLWNLDNDUQDN|SQL 6DUNRQIRUGXOWDPpVV]yQpONONLPHQWHP

6DUWRULXV

$ IRO\RVy UHV YROW (OV]|U HJ\HQHV D]WiQ MREEUD IRU GXO 6RKDVHP YROWDPPpJ D]ÉOORPiVRQ GH D] HONpV]tW HG]pVNHUHWpEHQKDW KpWLJ ODNWDPSRQWRV PiViEDQD )|O G|QD],QWp]HWEHQ7XGWDPKiWKRYiYH]HWD]DOXPtQLXP OpSFV $ N|Q\YWiUEDQ V|WpW YROW .LWDSRJDWWDP D YLOODQ\ NDSFVROyW 0HJNHUHVWHP D NDWDOyJXVEDQ $ V]RODULV]WLNDL pYN|Q\YHN HOV N|WHWpW D IJJHOpNNHO pV OHQ\RPWDP D ELOOHQW\,W3LURV IpQ\ J\XOODGW NL $ N|OFV|Q]JpSN|]|OWH KRJ\ D N|Q\Y *LEDULDQQiO YDQ D PiVLNNDO D]]DO D .LV $SRNULIIDO HJ\WW (OROWRWWDP D YLOODQ\W pV OHNRFRJWDP 1DJ\RQ IpOWHP *LEDULDQ NDELQMiWyO EiU D] HOEE D IRO\R VyUyOKDOODWV]RWWDND]RNDEL]RQ\RVOpSWHN'HKiWKDYLV] V]DPHQW" (J\ GDUDELJ RWW WRSRJWDP D] DMWy HOWW D]WiQ HUW YHWWHP   PDJDPRQ   pV  |VV]HV]RUtWRWW  IRJJDO EHQ\LWRWWDP .LJ\~OW D IpQ\ ² D V]RED UHV YROW $] DEODN HOWWL N|Q\YKDORPPDO NH]GWHP HJ\HQNpQW GREiOWDP IpOUH D SDGOyQ KHYHU N|WHWHNHW HJ\V]HU FVDN D V]HNUpQ\KH] XJURWWDP pV EH]iUWDP 1HP EtUWDP Qp]QL D]W D] UHV KHO\HW D NH]HVOiEDVRN N|]|WW $] DEODNQiO QHP WDOiOWDP PHJDIJJHOpNHW0yGV]HUHVHQKDODGWDPWRYiEEGDUDEUyO GDUDEUD YpJO HOpUWHP D] XWROVy KDORPKR] D] iJ\ pV D V]HNUpQ\N|]|WWpVHEEHQODSXOWDNHUHVHWWN|Q\Y 5HPpOWHP KRJ\ WDOiORN EHQQH YDODPL ~WPXWDWiVW pV FVDNXJ\DQDQpYPXWDWyQiORWWYROWHJ\SDStUGDUDENDD SLURV FHUX]iYDO EHNDULNi]RWW QpY ² $QGUp %HUWRQ ² QHP PRQGRWW QHNHP VHPPLW .pW ROGDOV]iP iOOW PHOOHWWH )HO ODSR]WDPHOV]|UD]HOVWVPHJWXGWDPKRJ\%HUWRQWDU WDOpNSLOyWD YROW 6KDQQDKDQ ,UKDMyMiQ -y V]i] ROGDOODO KiWUiEE V]HUHSHO ~MUD $] H[SHGtFLy D OHV]iOOiV XWiQ HOHLQWH URSSDQW yYDWRV YROW GH PLXWiQ WL]HQKDW QDS DODWW NLWDSDV]WDOWiN KRJ\ D SOD]PDyFHiQ QHPFVDN VHPPL WiPDGy NHGYHW QHP PXWDW KDQHP YLVV]D LV K~]yGLN PLQGHQIHOV]tQpKH]N|]HOHG WiUJ\HOOpVOHKHWOHJNHUOL D N|]YHWOHQ NDSFVRODWRW D P,V]HUHNNHO PHJ D] HPEHUHNNHO 6KDQQDKDQ pV KHO\HWWHVH 7LPROLV HQ\KtWHWW D V]LJRU~ yYDWRV 

ViJLUHQGV]DEiO\RNRQPLYHOD]RNQDJ\RQPHJQHKH]tWHWWpN pVKiWUiOWDWWiNDPXQNiW (NNRUD]H[SHGtFLyNpWpVKiURPWDJ~FVRSRUWRNUDRV] ORWWpVH]HNRO\NRUW|EEV]i]PpUI|OGHVXWDNDWLVWHWWHND] yFHiQ I|O|WW D VXJiUV]yUyNDW DPHO\HNNHO D PXQNDWH UOHWHW DGGLJ N|UO]iUWiN D %i]LVRQ KHO\H]WpN HO $] ~M PyGV]HU HOV QpJ\ QDSMiQ VHPPL EDOHVHW QHP W|UWpQW FVDN D V]NDIDQGHUHN R[LJpQNpV]OpNH URPORWW HO QpKD PHUWDNLI~YyV]HOHSHNpU]pNHQ\QHNEL]RQ\XOWDNDPpUJH] OpJN|U NRUUy]LyV KDWiViUD (]pUW PDMGQHP QDSRQWD FVHUpOQLNHOOHWWNHW $]|W|GLNQDSRQDOHV]iOOiVWyOV]iPtWYDDKXV]RQHJ\H GLNHQ  NpW NXWDWy &DUXFFL pV )HFKQHU ² D] HOEEL VXJiU ELROyJXV D PiVLN IL]LNXV ² IHOIHGH] UHSOpVW YpJ]HWW D] yFHiQ I|O|WW HJ\ NpWV]HPpO\HV NLV VLNOyNRFVLEDQ (] QHP UHSO MiUP,KDQHPOpJSiUQiQVLNOLN 0LYHO KDW yUD P~OYD VHP WpUWHN YLVV]D 7LPROLV ² D %i]LV SDUDQFVQRND6KDQQDKDQWiYROOpWpEHQ ² ULDGyWUHQ GHOW HO V PLQGHQ UHQGHONH]pVUH iOOy HPEHUpW NHUHVpVNUH NOGWH $ N|UOPpQ\HN YpJ]HWHV |VV]HMiWV]iVD YROW KRJ\ D] QDS DOLJ HJ\ yUiYDO D NXWDWyFVRSRUWRN LQGXOiVD XWiQ PHJV]DNDGW D UiGLy|VV]HN|WWHWpV PHUW D Y|U|V QDSRQ yULiVL IROW NHOHWNH]HWW pV HUV UpV]HFVNHVXJiU]iV ERPEi]WD D OpJN|U IHOV UpWHJHLW &VDN D] XOWUDU|YLG KXOOiP~NpV]OpNHNP,N|GWHN GH D]RNPLQG|VV]H K~V] KDUPLQF PpUI|OGHV N|U]HWEHQ EL]WRVtWRWWiN D NDSFVRODWRW 5iDGiVXO QDSQ\XJWD HOWW V,U, N|G WiPDGW ~J\KRJ\ IHO NHOOHWWKDJ\QLDNHUHVpVVHO $PHQWFVRSRUWRNPiUKD]DWpUEHQYROWDNPLNRUHJ\L NN I|OIHGH]WH D VLNOyNRFVLW DOLJ Q\ROFYDQ PpUI|OGQ\LUH D SDUWWyO 0,N|G PRWRUUDO WHOMHV pSVpJEHQ VXKDQW D KXO OiPRNI|O|WW 'H iWOiWV]y NDELQMiEDQ FVDNHJ\ HPEHU YROW ²D]HV]PpOHWOHQOKHYHU &DUXFFL $ VLNOyNRFVLW D %i]LVUD YLWWpN &DUXFFLW D] RUYRVRN JRQGMDLUD Et]WiN PpJ D]QDS HVWH PDJiKR] WpUW )HFKQHU VRUViUyOVHPPLW VHP WXGRWW PRQGDQL &VDN DUUD HPOpNH ]HWW KRJ\ DPLNRU PiU YLVV]DIHOp NpV]OGWHN  HJ\V]HU FVDN IXOGRNROQL NH]GHWW .pV]OpNpQHN NLI~YyV]HOHSH EH V]RUXOW pV PLQGHQ EHOpJ]pVQpO HJ\ NHYpV PpUJHV Ji] NH UOWV]NDIDQGHUHEHOVHMpEH 

)HFKQHU PHJ DNDUWD MDYtWDQL WiUVD OpJ]NpV]OpNpW H]pUW NLNDSFVROWD |YpW pV IHOiOOW (] D] XWROVy PR]]DQDW DPLUH&DUXFFLHPOpNH]HWW$V]DNpUWNtJ\UHNRQVWUXiOWiN D]HVHPpQ\HNYDOyV]tQ, OHIRO\iViW&DUXFFLNpV]OpNpQHN MDYtWiVD N|]EHQ )HFKQHU NLQ\LWRWWD D IONH WHWHMpW IHOWH KHWOHJ D]pUW PHUW D] DODFVRQ\ IHGpO DNDGiO\R]WD D PR] JiVEDQ (] QHP YROW WLORV KLV]HQ D] LO\HQ JpSHN WHWHMH DP~J\ VHP ]iU OpJPHQWHVHQ FVDN D] LGMiUiV YLV]RQWDJ ViJDL pV D V]pO HOOHQ YpG 6]HUHOpV N|]EHQ EL]RQ\iUD D]  R[LJpQNpV]OpNHLVHOURPORWW)HFKQHUHON|G|VOWWXGDWWDO IHOIHOpNDSDV]NRGRWWNLPiV]RWWDQ\tOiVRQDNRFVLWHWHMpUH pVD]yFHiQED]XKDQW (] D] yFHiQ HOV iOGR]DWiQDN W|UWpQHWH $ KROWWHVWHW KLiED NHUHVWpN SHGLJ D V]NDIDQGHUEHQ IHOV]tQHQ NHOOHWW YROQD PDUDGQLD 'H KD RWW OHEHJHWW LV ² D VRN H]HU QpJ\ ]HWPpUI|OGHV W|EEQ\LUH N|GIRV]OiQ\RNED EXUNROW KXOOiP]y UHQJHWHJ W]HWHV iWNXWDWiVD PHJKDODGWD D] H[SHGtFLyOHKHWVpJHLW 9LVV]DWpUHND NRUiEELHVHPpQ\HNKH] $ONRQ\DWUD YDOD PHQQ\LPHQWJpSKD]DpUWNLYpYHDQDJ\WHKHUKHOLNRSWHUW DPHO\HQ%HUWRQLQGXOWHO 6|WpWHGpVXWiQPDMGQHPHJ\yUiYDOMHOHQWPHJD%i]LV I|O|WWPiUNRPRO\DQDJJyGWDNpUWH,GHJVRNNRQPHKHWHWW NHUHV]WO²FVDND]pUWV]iOOWNLVDMiWOiEiQDJpSEOKRJ\ HV]HYHV]HWWHQ PHQHNOQL NH]GMHQ VtUW pV NLDEiOW DPLNRU IHOWDUWy]WDWWiN PHJG|EEHQW OiWYiQ\ YROW KLV]HQ H] D SLOyWDWL]HQKpWpYHUHSOWD],UEHQVRNV]RUDOHJQHKH]HEE N|UOPpQ\HNN|]|WW $] RUYRVRN QiOD LV PpUJH]pVUH J\DQDNRGWDN .pW QDS P~OYD %HUWRQ ² DNL OiWV]yODJ KHO\UH]|NNHQW GH HJ\ SLO ODQDWUDVHPYROWKDMODQGyHOKDJ\QLD]H[SHGtFLyIUDNpWi MiW VW D] yFHiQUD Qp] DEODNRNDW LV PHVV]H HONHUOWH ² D]]DO iOOW HO KRJ\ MHOHQWpVW NtYiQ WHQQL UHSOpVpUO 5D JDV]NRGRWW HKKH] D]W PRQGWD UHQGNtYO IRQWRV J\UO YDQV]y-HOHQWpVpWD]H[SHGtFLyPHJYL]VJiOWDGHDOpJN|UL Ji]RNNDO PpUJH]HWW HOPH NyURV WHUPpNpQHN PLQVtWHWWpN V PLQW LO\HW QHP D] H[SHGtFLy W|UWpQHWpKH] KDQHP %HUWRQ NyUW|UWpQHWpKH] FVDWROWiN DPLYHO D] J\ EH LV IHMH]G|WW (QQ\LWN|]|OWD IJJHOpN1\LOYiQ%HUWRQMHOHQWpVH WDU WDOPD]WDDOpQ\HJHW²D]WDPLWOH]DKRVV]~MiUDW~SLOyWD |VV]HURSSDQW ÔMUD W,Yp WHWWHP D V]REiW GH D .LV 

$SRNULIRW QHP WDOiOWDP 0LQG MREEDQ HUW YHWW UDMWDP D IiUDGWViJPiVQDSUDKDODV]WRWWDPKiWDWRYiEELNXWDWiVW pV HOKDJ\WDP D NDELQW $] DOXPtQLXP OpSFV PHOOHWW HO KDODGYD pV]UHYHWWHP KRJ\ IRNDLUD YLOiJRVViJ KXOO 6DU WRULXV PpJ LO\HQNRU LV GROJR]LN" 7DOiONR]QRP NHOO YHOH JRQGROWDP )HQW HJ\ NLFVLW PHOHJHEE YROW $ V]pOHV DODFVRQ\ IR O\RVyQ HQ\KH KX]DW FVDSRWW PHJ $ SDStUV]DODJRN YDGXO ORERJWDN D V]HOO]Q\tOiVRNRQ $ N|]SRQWL ODERUDWyULXP DMWDMD YDVWDJ UHFpV YHJODS IpPNHUHWEHQ 6|WpW IJJ|Q\ IpOH WDNDUWD EHOOUO  FVDN D PHQQ\H]HW DODWWL NHVNHQ\ DEODNRNRQ YHWG|WW NL D IpQ\ 0HJQ\RPWDP D NHUHV]WUX GDW 0LQW YiUWDP D] DMWy QHP HQJHGHWW 2GDEHQW FV|QG YROW RO\NRU KDON V]LV]HJpV KDOODWV]RWW PLQWKD Ji]OiQJ pJQH%HNRSRJWDP²VHPPLYiODV] ² 6DUWRULXV ² NLiOWRWWDP ² 6DUWRULXV GRNWRU eQ YDJ\RN .HOYLQ D] ~M NROOpJD %HV]pOQHP NHOO |QQHO HQ JHGMHQEHNpUHP 0LQWKD J\,U|WW SDStURN ]L]]HQQpQHN YDODNLQHN D OiED DODWW²D]WiQ~MUDFV|QGOHWW ² eQ YDJ\RN D] .HOYLQ +LV]HQ KDOORWW UyODP 3iU yUiMD pUNH]WHP D 3URPpWKHXVV]DO ² NLDEiOWDP EH D] DM WyIpOID pV D IpPNHUHW UpVpQ ² 6DUWRULXV GRNWRU 1LQFV LWW VHQNLPiVFVDNpQ(QJHGMHQEH &V|QG$]XWiQKDONQHV]1pKiQ\pOHVFV|UUHQpVWDOiQ IpPHV]N|]|NHW UDNQDN IpPWiOFiUD eV KLUWHOHQ VyEiOYiQQ\iGHUPHGWHP6]DSRUDNLV OpSWHNNRSSDQWDN ² PLQWKD HJ\ J\HUPHN V]HGHJHWQp NXUWD OiEDFVNiLW 7DOiQ  WDOiQURSSDQWJ\HVHQXWiQR]]DH]WDWLSHJpVW XMMDLYDOGREROHJ\MyOUH]RQiOyUHVOiGiQ ² 6DUWRULXV GRNWRU ² KDUVRJWDP ² .LQ\LWMD YDJ\ QHPQ\LWMDNL" 9iODV] KHO\HWW PHJLQW D J\HUHNWLSHJpVW KDOORWWDP pV N|]EHQ QpKiQ\ DOLJ NLYHKHW J\RUV HUpO\HV OpSpVW PLQWKD D] D] HPEHU OiEXMMKHJ\HQ MiUQD 'H KD MiUNiO KRJ\ XWiQR]KDWMD N|]EHQ D J\HUHNHW" %iQRP LV pQ  ² IRUW\DQWDP IHO pV Q|YHNY GK|PHW V]DEDGMiUD HQJHGYH RUGtWDQLNH]GWHP ² 6DUWRULXV GRNWRU 1HP D]pUW UHSOWHP WL]HQKDW KyQDSLJ KRJ\ PHJiOOtWVDQDN D NRPpGLiL 7t]LJ V]iPR ORND]WiQEHW|U|PD]DMWyW 

1HPLJHQKLWWHPKRJ\VLNHUOQH $ Ji]SLV]WRO\ O|NpVH QHP QDJ\RQ HUV GH HOKDWiUR] WDP KRJ\ YDODPL PyGRQ EHYiOWRP D IHQ\HJHWpVHPHW KD NHOOUREEDQyDQ\DJRW NHUtWHNEL]WRVDQ DNDGD UDNWiUEDQ 1HP V]DEDG HQJHGQHP EX]GtWRWWDP PDJDP QHP MiWV]KDWRP |U|N|VHQ D]RNNDO D NiUW\iNNDO DPLNHW D KHO\]HWDNH]HPEHQ\RPKLV]HQDWpERO\YLJ\RURJUyOXN 2O\DQ]DMKDOODWV]RWWPLQWKDELUNy]QiQDNYDJ\E~WRUW WRORJDWQiQDN D IJJ|Q\ IpOUHFV~V]RWW D IpO PpWHUQ\L UpVHQ YpNRQ\ iUQ\pN W,QW IHO D MpJYLUiJRV DEODNKR] KD VRQOy KRPiO\RV YHJWiEOD P|J|WW pV PHJV]yODOW HJ\ NLVVpUHNHGWHVIHMKDQJ ².LQ\LWRPGHtJpUMHPHJKRJ\QHPM|QEH ²$NNRUPLQHNQ\LWMD"²I|UPHGWHPUi ².LPHJ\HNPDJiKR] ²-y0HJtJpUHP $NXOFVKDONDQQ\LNRUGXOWD]iUEDQD]XWiQD]DMWyIH OpW HOWDNDUy V|WpW iUQ\pN JRQGRVDQ YLVV]DK~]WD D IJJ|Q\W PDMG ERQ\ROXOW P,YHOHWHN N|YHWNH]WHN UHFVHJ IDDV]WDO WRORJDWiViW YpOWHP KDOODQL D]WiQ YpJUH PHJQ\tOW D] YHJDMWy pSS FVDN DQQ\LUD KRJ\ 6DUWRULXV NLFV~V]KDVVRQ  UDMWD 0HJiOOW HOWWHP WHVWpYHO IHGH]YH D EHMiUDWRW 6RYiQ\ pJLPHV]HO YROW FVRQW pV EU D NUpPV]tQ, WULNy DODWW )HNHWH NHQGW YLVHOW D Q\DNiEDQ YiOOiQ NHWWpKDMWRWW VDYPDUWD ODERUDWyULXPL YpGN|SHQ\ OyJRWW .HVNHQ\ OyIHMpW IHUGpQ WDUWRWWD 0DMGQHP IpO DUFiW HOI|GWHDGRPERU~IHNHWHV]HPYHJ~J\KRJ\V]HPpWQHP OiWKDWWDP FVDN KRVV]~ iOONDSFViW NpNHV V]iMiW pV V]LQWpQ V]HGHUMHV IDJ\RWWQDN OiWV]y yULiVL IOpW %RURWYiODWODQ YROW 3LURV VXJiUYpG JXPLNHV]W\, IJJ|WW ]VLQyURQ D FVXNOyMiUyO (J\ GDUDELJ OHSOH]HWOHQ HOOHQV]HQYYHO V]HPOpOWN HJ\PiVW )HMpQ yORPV]tQ, V|UWH PHUHGH]HWW PDJD Q\tUKDWWD OH JpSSHO  iOOiQ HJpV]HQ V] ERURVWD+RPORNDOHVOWPLQW6QDXWpGHFVDNN|UOEHOO D IHOpLJ D OHEDUQXOW UpV]W Yt]V]LQWHV YRQDO KDWiUROWD %L]WRVDQPLQGLJVDSNiWYLVHODQDSRQ ² 0LW yKDMW" ² V]yODOW PHJ YpJUH ÔJ\ UpPOHWW QHP DQQ\LUDD]pQPRQGDQLYDOyPDWYiUMDLQNiEEKiWUDIHOpIL J\HO PLQGHQ LGHJV]iOiYDO J|UFV|VHQ D] YHJDMWyKR] WD SDGYD -y GDUDELJ QHP WXGWDP PLYHO NH]GMHP QHKRJ\ YDODPLEXWDViJVOM|QNLEHOOH 

².HOYLQYDJ\RN  EL]RQ\iUDKDOORWWUyODP²NH]GWHP ²*LEDULDQPXQNDWiUVDYDJ\RN  D]D]YROWDP   6RYiQ\ DUFD ² FVXSD IJJOHJHV YRQDO LO\HQ OHKHWHWW 'RQ 4XLMRWH ² NLIHMH]pVWHOHQ PDUDGW $ UiP V]HJH]HWW GRPERU~IHNHWHV]HPYHJYDODKRJ\WRUNRPUDIRUUDV]WRWWD DV]yW ²0RVWpUWHVOWHPKRJ\*LEDULDQ  PHJKDOW 0HJLQWHODNDGWDP ²,JHQeVPLWyKDMW"    7UHOPHWOHQYROWDKDQJMD ² gQJ\LONRV OHWW"    .L WDOiOWD PHJ D KROWWHVWHW |Q YDJ\6QDXW" ² 0LpUW NpUGH]L H]W WOHP" 1HP WiMpNR]WDWWD 6QDXW GRNWRU   " ²$]WV]HUHWQpPKDOODQLKRJ\|QQHNPLDYpOHPpQ\HD] J\UO    ²gQSV]LFKROyJXV.HOYLQGRNWRU" ²,JHQ0LpUW" ²7XGyV" ²1RLJHQ  'HKRJ\M|QH]   ² $]W JRQGROWDP WDOiQ Q\RPR]y YDJ\ UHQGU +DMQDOL NpW yUD QHJ\YHQ SHUF YDQ pV |Q DKHO\HWW KRJ\ LJ\HNH]QH EHNDSFVROyGQL D] ÉOORPiVRQ IRO\y PXQNiED DPL YpJHUHGPpQ\EHQPpJpUWKHW OHQQHEiUPLO\HQEUXWiOLVDQ SUyEiOW LV EHKDWROQL D ODERUDWyULXPED ~J\ IDJJDW LWW HQ JHPPLQWKDOHJDOiEELVJ\DQ~VtWRWWYROQpN 2O\DQ HUIHV]tWpVVHO IpNH]WHP PDJDP KRJ\ KRPORNR PRQNLW|WWDYHUtWpN ² gQ LJHQLV J\DQ~V 6DUWRULXV ² YiJWDP RGD IRMWRWW KDQJRQ 0LQGHQiURQYpULJDNDUWDPVpUWHQLH]pUWiGi]XOKR]]i WHWWHP ²eVH]WPDJDLVQDJ\RQMyOWXGMD ² +D H]W YLVV]D QHP YRQMD pV ERFViQDWRW QHP NpU SDQDV]WWHV]HNPDJDHOOHQDUiGLyMHOHQWpVEHQ.HOYLQ ² 0LpUW NpUMHN ERFViQDWRW" 0HUW DKHO\HWW KRJ\ WLV] WHVVpJHVHQIRJDGQDpVHOPRQGDQiPLW|UWpQLNLWWEH]iU Ny]LN D ODERUED pV HOEDULNiGR]]D PDJiW" +iW HOPHQW D My]DQ HV]H" 7XGyV PDJD YDJ\ J\iYD SDWNiQ\" +DOOMD" 9iODV]ROQD YpJUH" ² 0DJDP VHP WXGRP PLNHW RUGtWRW 

WDP GH PHJ VH UH]]HQW 6iSDGW OLNDFVRV EUpQ N|YpU L] ]DGViJFVHSSHN J\|QJ\|]WHN 0RVW NDSWDP pV]EH KLV]HQ QHP LV ILJ\HO UiP .pW NH]pW D KiWD P|Jp GXJYD WHOMHV HUYHOQ\RPWDD]DMWyWDPHO\NLVVpPHJUHPHJHWW PLQWKD EHOOUOQHNLIHV]OQHYDODNL ² 0HQMHQ   ² Q\|J|WW IHO KLUWHOHQ IXUFVD VLStWy KDQJRQ²0HQMHQ  PiU  D]LVWHQV]HUHOPpUH0HQ MHQOHPDMGPHJ\HNpQLVPHJWHV]HNPLQGHQWDPLWDNDU FVDNPHQMHQ +DQJMiEDQ HOPRQGKDWDWODQ V]HQYHGpV YROW ² WHOMHVHQ HOK,OYH |QNpQWHOHQO D] DMWy IHOp Q\~OWDP KRJ\ VHJtWVHN WDUWDQL KLV]HQ V]HPOiWRPiVW H]HQ HUON|G|WW GH RO\DQ ERU]DOPDVDW Y|OW|WW PLQWKD NpVW IRJWDP YROQD Ui tJ\ D]WiQ KiWUiOQL NH]GWHP  SHGLJ V]QHW QpONO ULNiFVROW pOHVIHMKDQJMiQKROD]WÅ0HQMPHQMµKROD]W Å0HJ\HN PiUPHJ\HN1HQHµ )HOUiQWRWWD D] DMWyW pV EHXJURWW ~J\ UpPOHWW KRJ\ PHOOH PDJDVViJiEDQ DUDQ\RV KROPL FVLOODQ PHJ YDODPL IpQ\HV NRURQJ WRPSD ]DM KDOODWV]RWW D ODERUDWyULXPEyO IpOUHFV~V]RWWDIJJ|Q\PDJDViUQ\pNVXKDQWHOD]YHJ ODSP|J|WWDIJJ|Q\DKHO\pUHNHUOWpVD]WiQPiUQHP OiWWDPVHPPLW0LW|UWpQLNRWWEHQW"/pSpVHNGRERJWDND YDG KDMV]D pOHV YHJFV|U|PS|OpVEH WRUNROORWW pV FVHQJ J\HUHNNDFDJiVYROWUiDYiODV]   5HPHJHWW D OiEDP ULDGWDQ Qp]WHP N|UO &V|QG Wi PDGW /HURVNDGWDP D] DODFVRQ\ P,DQ\DJ ODSRV DEODNSiUNiQ\UD 7DOiQ HJ\ QHJ\HGyUiW LV OKHWWHP tJ\ QHP WXGRP YiUWDPH YDODPLW YDJ\ FVDN DQQ\LUD NLERUXOWDP KRJ\ QHP YROW OHONLHUP IHOiOOQL 0DMG V]pWUHSHGW D IHMHP +RVV]~ FVLNRUJiVW KDOORWWDP YDODKRQQDQIHQWUOpVHJ\V]HUUHYLOiJRVOHWW hOW|PEO FVDN D ODERUDWyULXPRW PHJNHUO N|UIRO\RVy HJ\V]DNDV]iWOiWWDP(]D]ÉOORPiVOHJIHOV HPHOHWHN|] YHWOHQO D SiQFpOWHW DODWW H]pUW D EHOV IDODN KRPRU~DN pVIHUGpNQpKiQ\PpWHUHQNpQWOUpVV]HU, DEODNRNNDOIH GODSMXNpSSHQPRVWHPHONHGHWWIHON|]HOHGHWWDNpNQDS OHPHQWH 9DNtWy IpQ\ FVDSRWW EH D YDVWDJ YHJ, DEODNRQ 0LQGHQ QLNNHOV]HJpO\ PLQGHQ NLOLQFV IHOUDJ\RJRWW PLQW HJ\HJ\ NLV QDS $ ODERUDMWy pUGHV YHJWiEOiMD NHPHQFH Q\tOiVNpQW L]]RWW 5iQp]WHPD NtVpUWHWLHV IpQ\EHQ V]UNp QHN WHWV] |OEH WHWW NH]HPUH MREERPEDQ D Ji]SLV]WRO\W 

V]RURQJDWWDP )RJDOPDP VHP YROW PLNRU pV KRJ\DQ YHW WHPHO DWRNMiEyO9LVV]DUDNWDP7XGWDPPiUKRJ\LWWD VXJiUV]yUy VHP KDV]QiO XJ\DQ PLW LV NH]GKHWQpN YHOH" 6]pWYHVVHPD]DMWyW"%HW|UMHNDODERUDWyULXPED" )HOWiSiV]NRGWDP$]yFHiQEDVOO\HG QDSNRURQJKLG URJpQUREEDQiVNpQWOiQJROWpVV]LQWHPHJIRJKDWyYt]V]LQ WHV VXJiUQ\DOiERW O|YHOOW XWiQDP PLNRU DUFRPDW pUWH PiU OHIHOp PHQWHP D OpSFVQ  ~J\ pJHWHWW PLQW D IRUUy SHFVpWYLDV] $ OpSFV N|]HSpQ PHJJRQGROWDP PDJDP pV YLVV]DIRU GXOWDP .|UOMiUWDP D ODERUDWyULXPRW 0LQW PRQGWDP D IRO\RVy N|UEHYLV] YDJ\ V]i] OpSpV XWiQ D W~OVy ROGDORQ XJ\DQRO\DQ YHJDMWyKR] pUNH]WHP 1HP LV SUyEiOWDP NL Q\LWQLWXGWDPKRJ\]iUYDYDQ 1p]HOGWHP QLQFVH YDODPL DEODN YDJ\ OHJDOiEE UpV D P,DQ\DJ IDOEDQ HJ\iOWDOiQ QHP pUH]WHP PpOWDWODQ GR ORJQDNKRJ\PHJOHVVHP6DUWRULXVW(OpJYROWDWDOiOJDWiV EyO WXGQL DNDUWDP D] LJD]ViJRW EiU VHMWHWWHP KRJ\ DOLJKDIRJRPPHJpUWHQL (V]HPEHMXWRWWKRJ\DODERUWHUPHNHWPHQQ\H]HWLDEOD NRNYLOiJtWMiNPHJ YDJ\LV D SiQFpOWHW DEODNDL pV KD NL PiV]QpNWDOiQEHWXGQpNNXNXFVNiOQL(KKH]D]RQEDQOH NHOO PHQQHP V]NDIDQGHUpUW pV R[LJpQNpV]OpNpUW ÉOOGRJiOWDP D OpSFVQpO WDQDNRGWDP pUGHPHVH QHNLYiJQRP1DJ\RQYDOyV]tQ,KRJ\DWHWDEODNRNYHJH KRPiO\RV GH PL PiVW WHKHWQpN" /HPHQWHP D N|]pSV V]LQWUH (O NHOOHWW KDODGQRP D UiGLyN|]SRQW HOWW $MWDMD IpOLJ Q\LWYD YROW 6QDXW XJ\DQ~J\ OW DKRJ\ RWWKDJ\WDP $OXGW/pSWHLPUH|VV]HUH]]HQWpVNLQ\LWRWWDDV]HPpW ²+DOOy.HOYLQ²GY|]|OWUHNHGWHQ1HPYiODV]ROWDP ²1RPLYDQPHJWXGWiOYDODPLW"²pUGHNOG|WW ²0HJ²IHOHOWHPODVVDQ²1LQFVHJ\HGO (OK~]WDDV]iMiW ² 1R WHVVpN 0LN NL QHP GHUOQHN 9HQGpJHNHW IRJDG D]WPRQGRG" ² ,JD]iQ QHP pUWHP PLpUW QHP DNDUMiWRN HOiUXOQL KRJ\PLH]²YHWHWWHPRGDV]tQOHOWN|]|QQ\HO²+LV]HQLWW PDUDGRNpV~J\LVPHJWXGRPHOEEXWyEE+iWPLUHMyH] DWLWRN]DWRVNRGiV" 

² 0DMG PHJpUWHG KD QHNHG LV OHV]QHN YHQGpJHLG ² PRQGWD ÔJ\ UpPOHWW YiU YDODPLUH pV QLQFV VRN NHGYH EHV]pOJHWQL ² +RYi PpV]" ² V]yOW XWiQDP DPLNRU KiWDW IRUGt WRWWDP 1HP IHOHOWHP $ UHSOWpUL FVDUQRN XJ\DQDEEDQ D]iOODSRWEDQYROWDKRJ\KDJ\WDP$]HPHOYpQ\HQRWWiOOW IpOLJ Q\LWYD D] pQ |VV]HpJHWW IONpP $ V]NDIDQGHUHV IRJDVRNIHOpLQGXOWDP GH KLUWHOHQ HOPHQW D NHGYHP D WH WVpWiWyO6DUNRQIRUGXOWDPpVOHVLHWWHPDFVLJDOpSFVQD UDNWiUDNKR] $ V],N IRO\RVy WHOH YROW SDODFNRNNDO pV IHOWRUQ\R]RWW OiGiNNDO $ PH]WHOHQ IpPIDO NpNHVHQ FVLOOR JRWWDIpQ\EHQ0pJK~V]KDUPLQFOpSpVpVDI|GpPDODWW PHJMHOHQW D GpUOHSWH K,WYH]HWpN .|YHWQL NH]GWHP 9DV WDJP,DQ\DJNDUPDQW\~EDQW,QWHOEHYH]HWHWWDOpJPHQ WHVHQ ]iUW K,WKi]ED )HOUiQWRWWDP D NpW WHQ\pUQ\L YDVWDJ JXPLSHUHP, DMWyW GHUPHV]W KLGHJ FVDSRWW NL UDMWD 0HJERU]RQJWDP -pJFVDSRN FVQJWHN OH D KDYDV VSLUiOFV|YHNODELULQWXViUyO,WWLVYpNRQ\KyUpWHJJHOOHSHWW OiGiNpVWDUWiO\RNVRUDNR]WDNDIDOPHQWLSROFRNRQSHGLJ IpPGRER]RN pV YDODPL ]VLUDGpN iWOiWV]y P,DQ\DJED FVRPDJROW ViUJiV W|PEMHL +iWXO DODFVRQ\DEE YROW D IpON|UtYHVI|GpP-pJW,NWOV]LNUi]yYDVWDJIJJ|Q\OyJRWW UDMWD )pOUHKDMWRWWDP $] DOXPtQLXP UiFVRNEyO |VV]HUDNRWW SULFFVHQ YDODPL QDJ\ KRVV]~NiV WiUJ\ IHNGW V]UNH SRQ\YiYDO OHWDNDUYD 0HJHPHOWHP D SRQ\YiW pV *LEDULDQ pOHV PHWV]pV, DUFiED SLOODQWRWWDP )HNHWH KDMD KRPORND I|O|WW D] V] FVtNNDO UiVLPXOW NRSRQ\iMiUD *pJpMH pOHVHQ NLGXGRURGRWW PHJW|UYH D Q\DNiW %HVSSHGW V]HPH I|OIHOp PHUHGW VDUNiEDQ ]DYDURV MpJFVHSS J\,OW PHJ &VRQWLJ iWMiUW D KLGHJ |VV]HV]RUtWRWWDP D] iOONDSFVRPDW KRJ\ QH YDFRJMDN )RJWDP D SRQ\YiW pV PiVLN NH]HPPHO DUFiKR] pUWHP (JpV]HQ RO\DQ YROW PLQWKD IDJ\RV IiW pULQWHWWHP YROQD %UpWpUGHVVpWHWWHDIHNHWHSRQWRNNpQWNLW ERURVWD$M NiUD D KDWiUWDODQ PHJYHW WUHOHP NLIHMH]pVH IDJ\RWW Ui 9LVV]DHQJHGWHP D WDNDUy V]pOpW V HNNRU pV]UHYHWWHP KRJ\ D WHVW PiVLN ROGDOiQ KRVV]~NiV IHNHWH J\|QJ\|N YDJ\ EDEV]HPHN OiWV]DQDN NL D SRQ\YD UiQFDL DOyO QDJ\ViJ V]HULQW VRUED I,]YH +LUWHOHQ PHJK,OW EHQQHP D YpU 0H]WHOHQ OiEXMMDN YROWDN D]RN D WDOS IHOO Qp]YH D QDJ\XMMDNWRMiVGDGEHJ\HNLVVpHOiOOWDKDORWWLOHSHOJ\, U|WWV]pOHDODWWDQpJHUQ VLPXOWDSULFFVKH] 

+DVRQ IHNGW PLQWKD PpO\HQ DOXGQD /DVVDQ ODVVDQ IHOKDMWRWWDPDYDVWDJSRQ\YiW)HMHDSUyNpNHVIHNHWHFVL JiNED J|QG|U|G KDMiYDO pSSRO\DQ IHNHWH YDVNRV NDUMD KDMODWiEDQSLKHQW+iWiQDNFVLOORJyEUHPHJIHV]OWDJH ULQFRV]ORS GXGRUDLQ $ KDWDOPDV WHVW PHJ VHP PRFFDQW ,VPpWPH]WHOHQOiEiUDSLOODQWRWWDPpVHNNRUNO|Q|VGR ORJ K|NNHQWHWW PHJ WDOSD QHP YROW ODSRV pV NHPpQ\ D UiQHKH]HG V~O\WyO QHP V]DUXVtWRWWD HO D PH]tWOiEMiUiV pSSRO\DQYpNRQ\EUIHGWHPLQWDKiWiWYDJ\DNH]pW 1HP KLWWHP D V]HPHPQHN H]pUW PHJWDSLQWRWWDP EiU VRNNDOURVV]DEEYROWKR]]ipUQLPLQWDKROWWHVWKH](NNRU KLKHWHWOHQ GRORJ W|UWpQW D K~V]IRNRV IDJ\EDQ IHNY WHVW pOW pV PHJPR]GXOW )HOK~]WD D OiEiW PLQW D] DOYy NXW\D KDDPDQFViKR]Q\~OQDN 0HJIDJ\ LWW ² JRQGROWDP GH WHVWH Q\XJRGW YROW pV pSSHQ FVDN K,Y|V SXKD pULQWpVH PpJ RWW EL]VHUJHWW XMMDPKHJ\pEHQ.LKiWUiOWDPOHHUHV]WHWWHPDIJJ|Q\WpV YLV]V]DWpUWHP D IRO\RVyUD $]W KLWWHP PHJIXOODGRN D KVpJWO $ OpSFV IHOYLWW D UHSOWpUL FVDUQRNKR] /HURVNDGWDP HJ\ |VV]HWHNHUW J\,U,V HMWHUQ\UH pV NH]HPEHWHPHWWHPD]DUFRPÔJ\pUH]WHPPLQWKDDJ\ED IEH YHUWHNYROQD1HP WXGWDPPL YDQYHOHP +DOiORVDQ NLPHUOW YROWDP JRQGRODWDLP V]DNDGpN SHUHPpQ WiQWRURJWDN ² D] |QWXGDWODQViJ D PHJVHPPLVOpV EROGRJViJRVHOpUKHWHWOHQPHQHGpNQHNWHWV]HWW 1HP YROW PLpUW 6QDXWKR] YDJ\ 6DUWRULXVKR] PHQQHP QHP WXGWDP HONpS]HOQL KRJ\ EiUNL LV pUWHOPHV HJpVV]p NRYiFVROKDWQi D]W DPLW HGGLJ iWpOWHP DPLW OiWWDP DPLW VDMiW NH]HPPHO WDSLQWRWWDP $] HJ\HWOHQ PHQWVpJ ² V]D EDGXOiV ² PDJ\DUi]DW D WpERO\ GLDJQy]LVD YROW ,JHQ ² EL]WRVDQ PHJUOWHP PLQGMiUW DKRJ\ OHV]iOOWDP $] yFHiQ tJ\ KDW D] DJ\DPUD ² HJ\PiVW N|YHWLN D KDOOXFLQiFLyLP KD SHGLJ tJ\ YDQ I|O|VOHJHVHQ J\|WU|P PDJDPKRJ\PHJIHMWVHPDQHPOpWH] UHMWpO\HNHWLQNiEE RUYRVL VHJtWVpJ XWiQ NHOOHQH Qp]QHP IHOKtYQL D UiGLyN|]SRQWEyO D 3URPpWKHXV]W YDJ\ HJ\ PiVLN ,UKDMyW OHDGQLD]626MHO]pVW 2O\DVPL W|UWpQW HNNRU DPLW VRKDVHP KLWWHP YROQD PHJQ\XJWDWRWWDJRQGRODWKRJ\QHPYDJ\RNpSHOPpM, 0RVWPiUQDJ\RQLVMyOPHJpUWHWWHP6QDXWV]DYDLW²KD XJ\DQ 6QDXW HJ\iOWDOiQ OpWH]LN pV pQ YDODKD LV EHV]pO 

WHP YHOH KLV]HQ OHKHW KRJ\ PiU MyYDO HOEE KDOOXFLQiOQL NH]GWHP ² OHKHW KRJ\ PpJ D 3URPpWKHXV]RQ YDJ\RN RWW W|UW NL UDMWDP KLUWHOHQ D] HOPHEDM pV PLQGD] DPLW iWpO WHP FVDN ERPORWW DJ\DP WHUPpNH" 'H KD EHWHJ YDJ\RN DNNRUPHJLVJ\yJ\XOKDWRN²VH]OHJDOiEEIHOFVLOODQWRWWDD V]DEDGXOiV UHPpQ\pW DPHO\HW DOLJ SiUyUiV VRODULVL WD SDV]WDODWDLP NXV]D UpPUHJpQ\pEHQ VHKRJ\ VHP EtUWDP IHOIHGH]QL 0RVW WHKiW PLQGHQHNHOWW YDODPL ORJLNXVDQ HOJRQGROW NtVpUOHWHW ² H[SHULPHQWXP FUXFLVW ² NHOO PDJDPRQ Yp JH]QHP KRJ\ EL]RQ\RVViJRW V]HUH]]HN LJD]iQ PHJUO WHP pV VDMiW NpS]HOHWHP V]OHPpQ\HLYHO YLDVNRGRPH YDJ\ pOPpQ\HLP EiUPLO\HQ DEV]XUGDN pV KLKHWHWOHQHN PpJLVFVDNYDOyViJRVDN" ÌJ\ W|SUHQJWHP D FVDUQRN WDUWyV]HUNH]HWpQHN HJ\LN DFpORV]ORSiW EiPXOYD $ IDOEyO NLiOOy OHQW GRPERU~ EiGRJOHPH]]HO ERUtWRWW KDOYiQ\]|OGUH Pi]ROW RV]ORSUyO SiU KHO\HQ N|UOEHOO HJ\ PpWHU PDJDVViJEDQ OHSDW WRJ]RWW D IHVWpN Q\LOYiQ D] HUUH J|UGO UDNpWDV]iOOtWy NRFVLN NRSWDWWiN OH 0HJWDSRJDWWDP D] DFpOW NLFVLW I|O PHOHJtWHWWHP D WHQ\HUHPPHO PHJNRFRJWDWWDP D EiGRJ YpGOHPH] NLKDMOy SHUHPpW ² OHKHW D] DJ\UpP HQQ\LUH YDOyViJRV"/HKHW² YiODV]ROWDPPDJDPQDN HOYpJUH H] D V]DNPiPpUWHNKR]]i 'H NLWDOiOKDWRNH LO\HQ PLQGHQW HOG|QW NtVpUOHWHW" (OHLQWH ~J\ UpPOHWW KRJ\ QHP PHUW EiUPLO\HQ IHODGDWRW W,]|N PDJDP HOp D] LV EHWHJ DJ\DP FVDOyGiVD OHV] KD YDOyEDQ EHWHJ  +LV]HQ QHPFVDN NyURV HVHWHNEHQ KDQHP D OHJQRUPiOLVDEE iORPEDQ LV HOIRUGXO KRJ\ pEUHQ QHP LVPHUWV]HPpO\HNNHOEHV]pOJHWQNNpUGpVHNHWWHV]QNIHO D]iORPDODNRNQDNV KDOOMXND YiODV]XNDW pV EiU H]HN D V]HPpO\HN FVDN VDMiW SV]LFKLNXPXQN V]O|WWHL LGHLJOHQH VHQ HONO|QOW SV]HXGRDXWRQyP UpV]HL PpJVHP WXGMXN PLW IRJQDNIHOHOQL DPtJ iOPXQNEDQ  PHJ QHPV]yODOWDN 3HGLJ YiODV]XNDW VDMiW HOPpQNQHN H] D] HONO|QOW UpV]H IRJDOPD]]D PHJ WHKiW PiU DNNRU LVPHUQQN NHOOHQH PLNRUNLJRQGROWXN KRJ\D]WiQD NpS]HOW V]HPpO\ V]iMiED DGKDVVXN %iUPLW WHUYH]HN KiW pV EiUPLW KDMWRN YpJUH PLQGLJ UiIRJKDWRP KRJ\ ~J\ FVHOHNHGWHP DKRJ\DQ iO PXQNEDQ FVHOHNV]QN (J\iOWDOiQ QHP EL]WRV KRJ\ 6QDXW 

>NpS@

>UHV@

pV 6DUWRULXVYDOyEDQ OpWH]LN WHKiW QHNLN LV KLiED WHQQpN IHODNiUPLO\HQNpUGpVW *RQGROWDP Ui KRJ\ EHYHKHWQpN YDODPL RUYRVViJRW YDODPL HUV KDWiV~ V]HUW SpOGiXO SH\ROW YDJ\ PiV RO\DQ NpV]tWPpQ\W DPHO\ pU]pNL FVDOyGiVRNDW pV V]tQHV OiWR PiVRNDW LGp] HO +D LO\HQ MHOHQVpJHNHW WDSDV]WDOQpN H] D]WEL]RQ\tWDQiKRJ\DEHYHWW RUYRVViJ LJD]iQOpWH]LNpV DN|UQ\H] DQ\DJLYDOyViJUpV]H&VDNKRJ\²HOPpONHGWHP WRYiEE ² H] VHP YROQD D NtYiQW G|QW NtVpUOHW PLYHO WXGRP KRJ\DQ NHOO KDWQLD D V]HUQHN KLV]HQ V]NVpJNpSSHQ PDJDP YiODV]WRWWDP NL  WHKiW PHJW|UWpQKHW KRJ\ D] RUYRVViJ EHYpWHOH pV KDWiVD HJ\DUiQWFVDNNpS]HOHWHPWHUPpNHOHV] 0iUD]WKLWWHPQHPVLNHUONLW|UQ|P D]UOHWE,Y|V N|UpEO²KLV]HQQHPJRQGRONRGKDWRPPiVNpSSPLQW D] DJ\DPPDO QHP OpSKHWHN NL PDJDPEyO KRJ\ HOOHQUL]]HP QRUPiOLVDNH D WHVWHPEHQ OHMiWV]yGy IRO\DPDWRN(NNRUKLUWHOHQIHMpQWDOiOWDPDV]|JHW )HOXJURWWDP D] HMWHUQ\WHNHUFVUO pV HJ\HQHVHQ D UiGLyN|]SRQWED URKDQWDP 1HP YROW RWW VHQNL )XWy SLOODQWiVW YHWHWWHP D IDOL YLOODQ\yUiUD eMMHO QpJ\ yUD IHOp MiUW²D]ÉOORPiVHJ\H]PpQ\HVpMV]DNiMDRGDNLQWXJ\DQLV PiU SLUNDGW D Y|U|V KDMQDO *\RUVDQ EHNDSFVROWDP D WiYROViJLUiGLyNpV]OpNHWpVPtJDOiPSiNEHPHOHJHGWHN PpJHJ\V]HUYpJLJJRQGROWDPDNtVpUOHWV]DNDV]DLW 1HP HPOpNH]WHP D 6RODULV N|UO NHULQJ 6]DWHOORLG DXWRPDWD iOORPiViQDN KtYyMHOpUH GH D ISXOW IHOHWW OyJy WiEOiFVNiQPHJWDOiOWDP.RSRJWDNDPRUVHMHOHNpVQ\ROF PiVRGSHUF P~OYD PHJM|WW D YiODV] $ 6]DWHOORLG LOOHWYH DQQDN HOHNWURQLNXV DJ\D ULWPLNXVDQ LVPpWOG V]LJQiOODO MHOHQWNH]HWW (NNRU IHOV]yOtWRWWDP DGMD PHJ |W WL]HGHVMHJ\ SRQWRV ViJJDO KRJ\ D 6RODULV N|UO NHULQJYH D 7HM~WUHQGV]HU FVLOODJNRURQJMiQDN PHO\ GpON|UHLW PHWV]L KXV]RQNpW PiVRGSHUFHQNpQW $]XWiQ OHOWHP pV YiUWDP D YiODV]W 7t] SHUF P~OYD PHJM|WW /HWpSWHP D] HUHGPpQ\W N|]O SDStUFVtNRW pV D ILyNED GXJWDP YLJ\i]YD QHKRJ\ N|]EHQ UiSLOODQWVDN  /HFLSHOWHP D N|Q\YWiUEyO D QDJ\ pJWpUNpSHNHW D ORJD



SH\ROW>V]HULQWHPQHPMyGHtJ\PDUDG@

ULWPXVWiEOiNDW D 6]DWHOORLG QDSL PR]JiViQDN pYN|Q\YpW PHJ QpKiQ\ VHJpGN|Q\YHW pV QHNLYHVHONHGWHP XJ\DQHQ QHN D IHODGDWQDN $] HJ\HQOHWHN IHOiOOtWiVD PDMGQHP HJ\ yUiLJWDUWRWWQHPLVHPOpNV]HPPLNRUV]iPROWDPHQQ\LW XWROMiUD WDOiQ PpJ D] HJ\HWHPHQ J\DNRUODWL FVLOODJiV]DW YL]VJiQ $ V]iPtWiVRNDW D] ÉOORPiV QDJ\ V]iPtWyJpSpQ Yp JH]WHP HO *RQGRODWPHQHWHP D N|YHWNH] YROW D ]pJ WpUNpSHNUO RO\DQ DGDWRNDW NHOO NDSQRP DPHO\HN QHP IHGLN WHOMHVHQ D 6]DWHOORLG iOWDO N|]|OW PpUpVL HUHGPpQ\H NHW $]pUW QHP PHUW D 6]DWHOORLG SiO\iMiUD UHQGNtYO ERQ\ROXOW ]DYDUy HUN KDWQDN ² QHPFVDN D 6RODULV pV D] HJ\PiV N|UO NHULQJ NpW QDS YRQ]iVD EHIRO\iVROMD KDQHP D] yFHiQ iOWDO HOLGp]HWW KHO\L JUDYLWiFLyV YiOWR]iVRN LV +D PHJOHV] D NpW V]iPVRURP D 6]DWHOORLG DGDWDLpV D]pJWpUNpSHN DODSMiQ YpJ]HWW HOPpOHWL V]iPtWiV HUHGPpQ\HL EHYH]HWHP V]iPtWiVDLPED D V]NVpJHV KHO\HVEtWpVHNHW DNNRU D NpW HUHGPpQ\FVRSRUWQDN D QHJ\HGLN WL]HGHVMHJ\LJ IHGQLH NHOO HJ\PiVW HOWpUpV FVDN D] |W|GLN WL]HGHVMHJ\QpO PXWDWNR]KDW D] yFHiQ NLV]iPtWKDWDWODQWHYpNHQ\VpJpQHNKDWiViUD 1RV PpJ KD D 6]DWHOORLG iOWDO N|]|OW V]iPVRU QHP LV YDOyViJ KDQHP ]DYDUW HOPpP V]OHPpQ\H DNNRU VHP HJ\H]KHW D PiVRGLN DGDWVRUUDO $J\DP PHJERPROKDWRWW GH VHPPLO\HQ N|UOPpQ\HN N|]|WW VHP OHKHWHWW NpSHV PDJDHOYpJH]QLDV]iPtWiVWDPLWD]ÉOORPiVQDJ\V]iPt WyJpSH YpJ]HWW PLYHO HKKH] W|EE KyQDSUD OHWW YROQD V]NVpJH ÌJ\ KiW ² KD D] DGDWRN HJ\H]QHN ² D] ÉOORPiV QDJ\ V]iPtWyJpSH YDOyEDQ OpWH]LN pV QHP Oi]iOPRPEDQ KDQHPDYDOyViJEDQGROJR]WDPYHOH 5HPHJHWW D NH]HP PLNRU HOYHWWHP D ILyNEyO D WiY tUyJpS SDStUFVtNMiW pV D V]iPtWyJpS V]pOHVHEE HUHG PpQ\V]DODJMD PHOOp IHNWHWWHP $ NpW V]iPVRU PLQW JRQ GROWDP D QHJ\HGLN WL]HGHVMHJ\LJ HJ\H]HWW (OWpUpVHN FVDN D]|W|GLNQpOMHOHQWNH]WHN $ ILyNED GREWDP D SDStURNDW $ V]iPtWyJpS WHKiW OpWH]LN WOHP IJJHWOHQO DNNRU D] ÉOORPiV LV YDOyViJ PLQGD]]DOHJ\WWDPLUDMWDYDQ eSSHQ EH DNDUWDP FVXNQL D ILyNRW DPLNRU pV]UHYHW WHP KRJ\ HJpV] N|WHJ SDStUODS YDQ EHQQH WHOH LGHJHVHQ 

UyWWV]iPtWiVRNNDO.|]HOHEEK~]WDP HJ\HWOHQSLOODQWiV EyO PHJpUWHWWHP KRJ\ YDODNL PiU HOYpJH]WH D NtVpUOHWH PHW LOOHWYH HJ\ KDVRQOyW D]]DO D NO|QEVpJJHO KRJ\ D FVLOODJNRURQJ DGDWDL KHO\HWW D 6RODULV DOEHGyMiQDN QHJ\YHQ PiVRGSHUFHQNpQWL pUWpNpW DGDWWD PHJ D 6]DWHOORLGGDO 1HP YDJ\RN UOW 2GD D YpJV UHPpQ\VXJiU .L NDSFVROWDP D] DGyW PHJLWWDP D WHUPRV]EyO D PDUDGpN HUOHYHVWpVDOXGQLPHQWHP

+DUH\

0tJV]iPROWDPYDODPLGK|VQpPDHOV]iQWViJWDUWRWW OiERQ0RVWD]WiQDQQ\LUD HOWRPSXOWDP D NLPHUOWVpJWO KRJ\ NpSWHOHQ YROWDP PHJiJ\D]QL D NDELQRPEDQ DKHO\HWW KRJ\ D IHOV V]tMDNDW NDSFVROWDP YROQD NL D NDUIiW UiQJDWWDP ~J\KRJ\ D] HJpV] PLQGHQVpJ D Q\DNDPED V]DNDGW PLNRU YpJUH OHQW YROW D] iJ\ D SDGOyUD GREiOWDP D UXKiPDW PHJ D IHKpUQHP,PHW pV IpOLJHV]PpOHWOHQO]XKDQWDPDSiUQiUDPpJFVDNIHOVHP I~MWDP UHQGHVHQ 9LOiJRVEDQ DOXGWDP HO QHP LV WXGRP PLNRU $]]DO D] pU]pVVHO Q\LWRWWDP NL D V]HPHPHW KRJ\ FVDN SiU SHUFLJ DOXGWDP 6iSDGW Y|U|V IpQ\ W|OW|WWH EH D V]REiW .LFVLW Ii]WDP GH MyO pUH]WHP PDJDP 0H]WHOHQO IHNGWHP WDNDUy QpONO ÉJ\DPPDO V]HPN|]W D IpOLJ HOIJJ|Q\]|WWDEODNQiODY|U|VKDMQDOIpQ\pEHQYDODNLOW D V]pNHQ +DUH\ YROW D] IHKpU VWUDQGUXKiEDQ PH]WHOHQ OiEiW NHUHV]WEH YHWYH V|WpW KDMD KiWUDIpVOYH D N|QQ\, YiV]RQ PHJIHV]OW D PHOOpQ N|Q\|NLJ OHVOW NDUMiW OD]iQ OyJDWWD pV PR]GXODWODQXO Qp]HWW IHNHWH SLOOiL DOyO 6RNiLJ J\|Q\|UN|GWHP EHQQH HJpV]HQ Q\XJRGWDQ (OV JRQGRODWRP D] YROW PLO\HQ My YpJUH HJ\ iORP DPLNRU WXGRP KRJ\ iOPRGRP 'H D]pUW MREEDQ V]HUHWWHP YROQD KD HOW,QLN %HFVXNWDP D V]HPHP pV QDJ\RQ HUVHQ NtYiQWDP KRJ\ PRVW PiU QH OiVVDP GH DPLNRU NLQ\LWRWWDP XJ\DQ~J\ OW RWW PLQW D] HOEE $MNiQ MHOOHJ]HWHV NLV PRVRO\D PLQWKD IW\OQL NpV]OQH GH D V]HPpEHQ QHP YROW VHPPL YLGiPViJ (V]HPEH MXWRWW PLQGD] DPLW D] HVWH OHIHNYpV HOWW D] iOPRNUyO JRQGROWDP eSSHQ RO\DQ PLQW DPLNRU XWROMiUD OiWWDP pOYH DNNRU WL]HQNLOHQF pYHV YROW PRVW KXV]RQNLOHQFQHN NHOOHQH OHQQLH GH SHUV]H VHPPLW VHP YiOWR]RWW ² D KDORWWDN QHP YpQOQHN 8J\DQD]]DO D PLQGHQHQ FVRGiONR]y V]HPPHO Qp] UiP +R]]iYiJRN YDODPLW ² JRQGROWDP GH EiU FVDN iORP YROW YDODKRJ\ PpJVHP WXGWDP UiV]iQQL PDJDP KRJ\ HJ\ KDORWWKR] ² DNiU iOPRPEDQLVWiUJ\DNDWYDJGRVVDN ²6]HJpQ\NLFVLP²PRQGWDP²HOM|WWpOOiWRJDWyED" 

.LVVpPHJLMHGWHPPHUWDKDQJRPQDJ\RQYDOyViJRVDQ FVHQJHWW V D] HJpV] V]RED pV +DUH\ ² PLQGHQ D] HONpS]HOKHW OHJUHiOLVDEEQDNUpPOHWW 0LFVRGD SODV]WLNXV iORP QHPFVDN KRJ\ V]tQHV GH HJpV]FVRPyKROPLWOiWRNLWWDSDGOyQDPLWHVWHOHIHNYpV NRU pV]UH VH YHWWHP +D PDMG IHOpEUHGHN ² JRQGROWDP ² PHJNHOOQp]QHPYDOyEDQLWWYDQQDNHYDJ\NHWLVFVDN iOPRGRPPLQW+DUH\W   ² 0HGGLJ DNDUV] PpJ tJ\ OQL   " ² NpUGH]WHP pV UDMWDNDSWDP PDJDP KRJ\ KDONDQ EHV]pOHN PLQWKD FVDN IpOQpNKRJ\YDODNLPHJKDOOMDSHGLJNLKDOOKDWQiD]WDPLW iOPRPEDQPRQGRN" .|]EHQDQDSNLVVpI|OMHEEHPHONHGHWW1RJRQGROWDP H] My 9|U|V QDSSDO YROW DPLNRU OHIHNGWHP XWiQD NpNQHN NHOO M|QQLH pV FVDN D]WiQ N|YHWNH]KHW ~MDEE Y|U|V 0LYHO QHP DOKDWWDP WL]HQ|W yUiW HJ\KX]DPEDQ EL]WRVKRJ\iOPRGRP ÌJ\ PHJQ\XJRGYD MREEDQ V]HPJ\UH YHWWHP +DUH\W +iWXOUyO pUWH D IpQ\ D IJJ|Q\ UpVpQ EHKDWROy QDSVXJiU PHJDUDQ\R]WD EDO RUFiMiQ D EiUVRQ\RV SLKpNHW V]HPSLOOiMDKRVV]~iUQ\pNRWYHWHWWD]DUFiUD1DJ\RQV]pS YROW /iP JRQGROWDP PLO\HQ DNNXUiWXV YDJ\RN PpJ iOPRPEDQLVILJ\HOHPDQDSMiUiViWJ\HOHNKRJ\ D]D J|GU|FVNH SRQWRVDQ RWW OHJ\HQ DKRO VHQNL PiVQDN FVXGiONR]y V]iMD VDUND DODWW GH PpJLVFVDN |UOWHP YROQD KD PiU YpJHW pU D] HJpV] (OYpJUH PXQNiKR] NHOO OiWQRP *|UFV|VHQ EHKXQ\W V]HPPHO LJ\HNH]WHP I|OpEUHGQL GH KLUWHOHQ Q\LNRUJiVW KDOORWWDP 5|JW|Q NLQ\LWRWWDP D V]HPHP $] iJ\ V]pOpQ OW pV NRPRO\DQ Qp]HWW UiP 5iPRVRO\RJWDP HUUH  LV HOPRVRO\RGRWW pV I|OpP KDMROW D] HOV FVyN SLKHN|QQ\, YROW PLQW D J\HUHNHNp 6RNiLJFVyNROJDWWDP,OOLNtJ\NLKDV]QiOQLHJ\iOPRW"² W,QGWHP N|]EHQ 'H KLV]HQ QHP LV FVDORP PHJ D] HPOpNpW YHOH iOPRGRP pV QHP PiVVDO eUGHNHV HGGLJ VRKDVHPiOPRGWDPUyOD  0pJPRVWVHPV]yOWXQNVHP PLW +DQ\DWW IHNGWHP PLNRU I|OHPHOWH D] DUFiW DOXOUyO OiWKDWWDPDSUyRUUO\XNDLWpU]HOPHLQHNiOODQGyEDURPpWH UpWDPLQWD]DEODNIHOOiWVW|WWUDMWXNDQDSXMMDPKH J\pYHOYpJLJVLPtWRWWDPDIONDJ\OyMiWFLPSiL EHOHSLUXOWDN D FVyNROy]iVED 1HP WXGRP HWWO OHWWHPH DQQ\LUD 

Q\XJWDODQ HJ\UH KDMWRJDWWDP PDJDPEDQ KRJ\ FVDN iORPGHHOV]RUXOWDV]tYHP (UW J\,MW|WWHP KRJ\ NLXJRUMDN D] iJ\EyO HO YROWDP Ui NpV]OYH KRJ\ QHP VLNHUO iOPiEDQ D] HPEHU J\DNUDQ QHP XUD D WDJMDLQDN ~J\ pU]L PLQWKD D WHVWH WiYRO OHQQH YDJ\ PHJEpQXOW YROQD LQNiEE D]W UHPpOWHP KRJ\ HWWO D V]iQGpNWyO IHOpEUHGHN 'H QHP pEUHGWHP KDQHP V]pSHQ IHOOWHP pV OHWHWWHP D OiEDP D I|OGUH +LiED H]W PiU YpJLJ NHOO iOPRGQRP JRQGROWDP GH My KDQJXODWRPQ\RPWDODQXOHOV]iOOW)pOWHP ² 0LW DNDUV]" ² NpUGH]WHP 5HNHGW YROW D KDQJRP NUiNRJQRPNHOOHWW 0H]WHOHQ OiEDPPDO |V]W|Q|VHQ D SDSXFVRP XWiQ ND SLUJiOWDP pV PLHOWW UiM|WWHP YROQD KRJ\ LWW QLQFV VHP PLIpOH SDSXFV ~J\ EHYHUWHP D OiEXMMDPDW KRJ\ IHOV]LV] V]HQWHP 1R PRVW OHJDOiEE YpJH OHV] ² JRQGROWDP HOpJHGHWWHQ 'H PpJ HNNRU VHP W|UWpQW VHPPL +DUH\ YLVV]DK~]y GRWW PLNRU IHOOWHP $] iJ\WiPOiQDN WiPDV]NRGRWW %DO PHOOpQHN FV~FVD DODWW D V]tYYHUpV WHPpUH ILQRPDQ UH PHJHWW D UXKD 1\XJRGW pUGHNOGpVVHO V]HPOpOW )HO|WO|WW EHQQHP KRJ\ MyOHVQH HJ\ KLGHJ ]XKDQ\ GH pV]EH NDSWDPiORPEHOL]XKDQ\WyOQHPOHKHWI|OpEUHGQL ²+RJ\NHUOV]LGH"²NpUGH]WHP 0HJIRJWD D NH]HPHW pV DKRJ\ UpJHQ V]RNWD ÅPHUUH V]DODGDQ\XODFVNiWµMiWV]RWWYHOH ²1HPWXGRP²PRQGWD²EDM" +DQJMD LV XJ\DQD] D PpO\ KDQJ YROW V]yUDNR]RWW KDQJOHMWpVH LV D UpJL 0LQGLJ ~J\ EHV]pOW PLQWKD QHP QDJ\RQILJ\HOQHDUUDDPLWPRQGPLQWKDPiUYDODPLPiV IRJODONR]WDWQi H]pUW KRO iEUiQGRVQDN WHWV]HWW KRO SHGLJ V]HPpUPHWOHQQHN PHUW PLQGHQW H]]HO D FVDN V]HPpEHQ WNU|]GiOPRVFVRGiONR]iVVDOQp]HWW ²0RQGG  OiWRWWYDODNL" ² 1HP WXGRP &VDN M|WWHP pV NpV] )RQWRV H] .ULV" 7RYiEEMiWV]RWWDNH]HPPHOGHDUFDPiUQHPYHWWUpV]WD NHGYHVNHGpVEHQ(ONRPRURGRWW ²+DUH\   " ²7HVVpNV]tYHP" ²+RQQDQWXGWDGKRJ\KROYDJ\RN" 

(] JRQGRONRGyED HMWHWWH $]WiQ HOPRVRO\RGRWW NLYLO ODQWYD IRJDL pOpW RO\DQ V|WpWSLURV DMND YROW KRJ\ PHJ VHPOiWV]RWWUDMWDKDPHJJ\HWHYHWW ² )RJDOPDP VLQFV +iW QHP YLFFHV" $OXGWiO PLNRU EHM|WWHP GH QHP NHOWHWWHOHN I|O 1HP PHUWHOHN I|OUi]QL PHUW RO\DQ PpUHJ]ViN YDJ\ 0pUHJ]ViN pV PRUFRV PHGYH ²PLQGHJ\LNV]yQiOIHOGREWDpVHONDSWDDNH]HPHW ²/HQWLVYROWiO" ² 9ROWDP 'H U|JW|Q IHOM|WWHP QDJ\RQ KLGHJ YDQ RWW (OHQJHGWHDNH]HPHW.|Q\|NpUHGOYHKiWUDYHWHWWHDIHMpW KRJ\KDMDV]pSHQOHRPROMRQpVD]]DODIpOPRVROO\DOQp]HWW UiP PHO\ FVDN DNNRU QHP LGHJHVtWHWW W|EEp PLNRU EHOHV]HUHWWHP ²'HKiW  +DUH\  GHKiW  ²PDNRJWDP )|Op KDMROWDP pV PHJHPHOWHP UXKiMD U|YLG XMMiW $ KLPOROWiV YLUiJIRUPD KHJH I|O|WW DSUy V]~UiV SLURVORWW %iU V]iPtWRWWDP Ui PHUW DNDUDWODQXO LV IRO\WRQ D ORJLND IRV]OiQ\DLW NHUHVWHP D NpSWHOHQVpJEHQ  ² pPHO\JpV IRJRWW HO 0HJpULQWHWWHP D]LQMHNFLy Q\RPiW DPHO\ pYHNLJ HJ\UH NtVpUWHWW iOPDLPEDQ KRJ\ NLDEiOYD ULDGWDP IHO D J\,U|WW iJ\RQ PLQGLJ XJ\DQDEEDQ D Sy]EDQ V]LQWH NDULNiED J|UQ\HGYH DKRJ\  IHNGW PiU PDMGQHP KLGHJHQ DPLNRUUiWDOiOWDP²PHUWiOPRPEDQXWiQR]QLLJ\HNH]WHP PLQWKD tJ\ DNDUWDP YROQD NLHQJHV]WHOQL D] HPOpNpW YDJ\ YHOH OHQQL D]RNEDQ D] XWROVy SHUFHNEHQ DPLNRU PiU pUH]WH D] LQMHNFLy KDWiViW pV EL]WRVDQ IpOW +LV]HQ SiQLNED HVHWW KD PHJYiJWD D] XMMiW QHP EtUWD D IiMGDOPDW LV]RQ\RGRWW D YpUWO pV HJ\V]HU FVDN LO\HQ V]|UQ\,VpJHW N|YHWHWW HO |W V]yW KDJ\YD KiWUD D QHNHP FtP]HWW FpGXOiQ ,WW YDQ D SDStUMDLP N|]|WW PLQGLJ PDJDPPDO KRUGRP PiU HOIDNXOW pV V]pWHVLN D KDMWiVRN PHQWpQ GH VRKDVHP YROW EiWRUViJRP PHJYiOQL WOH ² H]HUV]HU YLVV]DWpUWHP DKKR] D SHUFKH] DPLNRU tUWD H]HUV]HU WpSHOGWHP PLW pUH]KHWHWW DNNRU 0DJ\DUi]WDP PDJDPQDN KRJ\ QHP JRQGROKDWWD NRPRO\DQ FVDN PHJ DNDUW LMHV]WHQL pV YpOHWOHQOPpUHWH]WH W~OD]DGDJRW tJ\ W|UWpQW HUVN|G|WW PLQGHQNL YDJ\ SHGLJ GHSUHVV]LyV URKDPEDQ IRJDQW KLUWHOHQ HOKDWiUR]iV YROW 'H N QHP WXGWiNPLWPRQGWDPQHNL|WQDSSDOD]HOWW~J\KRJ\D OHJMREEDQ IiMMRQ PtJ D KROPLPDW FVRPDJROWDP QDJ\RQ Q\XJRGWDQPHJMHJ\H]WHÅ7XGRGPLWMHOHQWH]   " µ²pQ SHGLJ ~J\ WHWWHP 

PLQWKD QHP pUWHQpP KRORWW QDJ\RQ MyO pUWHWWHP GH D]W KLWWHPJ\iYD OHV] KR]]i  pV H]W LV V]HPpEH PRQGWDP ² pVPRVWLWWIHNV]LNNHUHV]WEHQ D]iJ\RQ pV UiPIJJHV]WL DV]HPpWPLQWKDQHPWXGQiKRJ\PHJ|OWHP ² 6HPPL PiV QHP MXW HV]HGEH" ² GRURPEROWD +DMiQ SDUi]VORWW D QDSIpQ\ Y|U|V YROW D] HJpV] V]RED NDUMiUD Qp]HWW DPHO\ HJ\V]HUUH IRQWRV OHWW PHUW pQ RO\DQ VRNiLJ YL]VJiOJDWWDP pV PLNRU OHHQJHGWHP D NH]HP UiIHNWHWWH K,Y|VVLPDDUFiW ²+DUH\²GDGRJWDPUHNHGWHQ²H]QHPOHKHW   ²+DOOJDVVPiU /HKXQ\W V]HPH UHPHJHWW D] LGHJHV V]HPKpMDN DODWW IHNHWHSLOOiLDUFiUDVLPXOWDN ²+ROYDJ\XQN+DUH\" ²2WWKRQ ²+ROYDQD]" 6]HPH HJ\ SLOODQDWUD NLQ\tOW PDMG U|JW|Q OHFVXNyGRWW 3LOOiLPHJFVLNODQGR]WiNDNH]HPHW ².ULV ²1R" ²2O\DQMytJ\ 0R]GXODWODQXO OWHP I|O|WWH +iWUDV]HJWHP D IHMHP pV PHJOiWWDP D] iJ\ HJ\ GDUDEMiW +DUH\ NyFRV KDMiW pV PH]WHOHQ WpUGHPHW D PRVGy WNUpEHQ /iEDPPDO N|]HOHEE K~]WDP HJ\HW D SDGOyQ KHYHU IpOLJ PHJROYDGW V]HUV]iPRN N|]O pV V]DEDG NH]HPPHO I|OHPHOWHP $ YpJHKHJ\HVYROW%U|PUHLOOHV]WHWWHPDV]DEiO\RVIpON|U DODN~VHEKHO\I|OpVDK~VRPEDG|IWHP%HOpPKDVtWRWWD IiMGDORP 1p]WHP D NLEXJJ\DQy YpUW DPHO\ QDJ\ FVHSSHNEHQ YpJLJFVXUJRWW FRPERP EHOV ROGDOiQ pV KDONDQOHFV|S|J|WWDSDGOyUD )|O|VOHJHV YROW $] DJ\DPEDQ NDYDUJy UpPHV JRQGR ODWRN HJ\UH KDWiUR]RWWDEE IRUPiW |OW|WWHN QHP iOWDWWDP PDJDPW|EEpKRJ\FVDNiOPRGRPHEEHQPiUHJ\GDUDE LGHMHQHPKLWWHPPRVWDUUDJRQGROWDPYpGHNH]QHPNHOO )LJ\HOWHPKiWiQDNpVFVtSKDMODWiQDNtYpWDIHKpUYiV]RQ DODWW PH]WHOHQ OiEiW OHOyJDWWD D] iJ\UyO 2GDQ\~OWDP yYDWRVDQ PHJIRJWDP Uy]VDV]tQ, VDUNiW pV YpJLJK~]WDP XMMDPDWDWDOSiQ 3XKDYROWPLQWHJ\~MV]O|WWp 

9ROWDNpSSHQPiUEL]WRVDQWXGWDPKRJ\H]QHP+DUH\ pVPDMGQHPEL]WRVDQKRJ\ H]WQHPWXGMD $ FVXSDV] OiE PHJPR]GXOW D WHQ\HUHPEHQ +DUH\ V|WpWSLURVDMNDKDQJWDODQQHYHWpVUHK~]yGRWW ²1H  ²J|F|JWH 6]HOtGHQ NLV]DEDGtWRWWDP D NH]HP pV IHOiOOWDP 0pJ PLQGLJPH]WHOHQYROWDP*\RUVDQ|OW|]QLNH]GWHPN|]EHQ OiWWDPKRJ\IHOOD]iJ\RQpVQp] ²+ROPDUDGWDKROPLG"²NpUGH]WHPGHU|JW|QPHJLV EiQWDP ²$KROPLP" ²&VDNH]D]HJ\UXKiGYDQ" 0RVW PiU V]tQpV]NHGWHP +DQ\DJXO WHUPpV]HWHVHQ LJ\HNH]WHP YLVHONHGQL PLQWKD WHJQDS YiOWXQN YROQD HO QHP²PLQWKDHJ\iOWDOiQHO VHP YiOWXQNYROQD)HOiOOW pV LVPHUV N|QQ\, GH HUWHOMHV PR]GXODWiYDO OHVLPtWRWWD D V]RNQ\iMiW.pUGpVHPV]|JHWW|WWDIHMpEHEiUQHPV]yOW VHPPLW 0RVW HOV]|U Qp]HWW N|UO My]DQ NXWDWy SLOODQWiVVDO pV V]HPOiWRPiVW FVRGiONR]YD IRUGXOW ~MUD IHOpP ² 1HP WXGRP   ² WpWRYi]RWW ² WDOiQ D V]HNUpQ\ EHQ"    ²WHWWHKR]]ipVNLQ\LWRWWDDV]HNUpQ\DMWyW ² 1HP RWW FVDN NH]HVOiEDVRN YDQQDN ² IHOHOWHP $ PRVGy PHOOHWW PHJWDOiOWDP D YLOODQ\ERURWYiW pV ERURW YiONR]QLNH]GWHPYLJ\i]YDKRJ\DOiQ\DNiUNLOHJ\HQLV DKiWDPP|JpQHNHUOM|Q -iUNiOW D NDELQEDQ YL]VJiOyGRWW NLQp]HWW D] DEODNRQ YpJORGDM|WWKR]]iPpVD]WPRQGWD ².ULVD]D]pU]pVHPKRJ\YDODPLW|UWpQW   " (ODNDGW 9iUDNR]WDP NH]HPEHQ D NLNDSFVROW YLOODQ\ ERURWYiYDO ² 0LQWKD YDODPLW HOIHOHMWHWWHP YROQD   VRN PLQGHQW &VDN   FVDN WHUiG HPOpNV]HP   pV   pV VHPPL PiVUD ,J\HNH]WHPQ\XJRGWDUFFDOYpJLJKDOOJDWQL ²0RQGGpQ  EHWHJYROWDP" ²+iW  N|UOEHOO,JHQHJ\LGHLJNLFVLWEHWHJYROWiO ²-D~J\$NNRUEL]WRVDQDWWyOYDQ 0iULV IHOYLGXOW 1HP WXGRP HOPRQGDQL PLW pOWHP iW $PLNRU KDOOJDWRWW MiUWNHOW OHOW UiP PRVRO\JRWW pPHO\tW IpOHOPHPHW HOQ\RPWD D PHJJ\]GpV KRJ\ YD 

OyEDQ +DUH\W OiWRP GH D N|YHWNH] SHUFEHQ PLQW PRVW LV PHJLQW ~J\ pUH]WHP KRJ\ H] HJ\ OHHJ\V]HU,VtWHWW +D UH\ PLQG|VV]H QpKiQ\ MHOOHJ]HWHV V]y PR]GXODW pV JHV]WXV (JpV]HQ N|]HO M|WW NpW |NOpW PHOOHPQHN WiPDV]WRWWDpVPHJNpUGH]WH ²0LKRJ\YDJ\XQN"-yOYDJ\URVV]XO" ²$OHKHW OHJMREEDQ²IHOHOWHP 3LFLWHOPRVRO\RGRWW ²0LNRUtJ\PRQGRGDNNRULQNiEEURVV]XO ² 6]y VLQFV UyOD +DUH\ GUiJiP GH PRVW HO NHOO PHQQHP ² KDGDUWDP ² 0HJYiUV] My" ,OOHWYH   QHP YDJ\ pKHV" ² WHWWHP KR]]i PHUW UDMWDP KLUWHOHQ IDU NDVpKVpJW|UWNL ²eKHV"1HP 0HJUi]WDDIHMpWKDMDFVDN~J\U|SN|G|WW ²,WWYiUMDODN"6RNiLJ" ²(J\yUiFVNiW²NH]GWHPGHN|]EHYiJRWW ²9HOHGPHJ\HN ²1HPM|KHWV]YHOHPPHUWGROJR]QRPNHOO ²$NNRULVYHOHGPHJ\HN 1R OiP H] HJ\ HJpV]HQ PiV +DUH\ D] LJD]L QHP HUV]DNRVNRGRWW6RKD ².LFVLNpPH]OHKHWHWOHQ   )HOQp]HWW UiP V KLUWHOHQ PHJIRJWD D NH]HPHW 9p JLJVLPtWRWWDPDNDUMiWFVXNOyMiWyODYiOOiLJWHOWpVPHOHJ YROWLJD]iQQHPEHFp]JHWpVQHNV]iQWDPPpJLVPDMGQHP D] OHWW EHOOH $ WHVWHP IHOLVPHUWH DNDUWD IHOp YRQW PLW VHPW|UGYHDMy]DQpVV]HOD]pUYHNNHOpVDIpOHOHPPHO 1\XJDOPDWHUOWHWYHPDJDPUDPHJLVPpWHOWHP ²1HPM|KHWV]+DUH\PDUDGMLWWV]pSHQ ²1HP )pOHOPHWHVHQKDQJ]RWW ²0LpUW" ²1   QHPWXGRP .|UOQp]HWWpVPHJLQWUiPHPHOWHDV]HPpW ²1HPEtURN  ²WHWWHKR]]iHJpV]HQKDONDQ ²'HPLpUW"  ² 1HP WXGRP 1HP EtURN $]W KLV]HP   D]W KLV]HP   /iWKDWyODJ NHUHVWH PDJiEDQ D YiODV]W pV DPLNRU UiWDOiOWWLVPHJOHSWH 

²$]WKLV]HPPXV]iMKRJ\PLQGLJ  OiVVDODN 7iUJ\LODJRV KDQJMD NpWVpJWHOHQQp WHWWH KRJ\ QHP V]HUHOPLYDOORPiVUyOYDQV]yKDQHPHJpV]HQPiVUyO(]D YDODPL KLUWHOHQ iWIRUPiOWD |OHOpVHPHW EiU NOVOHJ PLW VHP YiOWR]RWW ² DPLQW RWW iOOW HOWWHP V]HPpEH Qp]YH HONH]GWHP KiWUDFVDYDUQL D NDUMiW HOHLQWH EL]RQ\WDODQ PR]GXODWRP KLUWHOHQ pUWHOPHW NDSRWW FpOMiUD WDOiOW 0iU V]pWLVQp]WHPPLYHON|W|]KHWQpPPHJ +iWUDFVDYDUW NpW N|Q\|NH HQ\KpQ |VV]HWG|WW pV XJ\DQDEEDQ D SLOODQDWEDQ RO\ KLKHWHWOHQ HUYHO IHV]OW PHJ KRJ\ KLiED V]RUtWRWWDP YLVV]D 7DOiQ HJ\ PiVRG SHUFLJN]G|WWHPÌJ\KiWUDKDMROYDpSSFVDNOiEXMMKHJJ\HO pULQWYHDSDGOyWPpJHJ\ELUNy]yEDMQRNVHPOHQQHNpSHV NLV]DEDGtWDQL PDJiW GH +DUH\ EL]RQ\WDODQ NLV PRVROO\DO D] HJpV]UO PLW VHP WXGy DUFiQ V]pWW|UWH D NDSFVRW NLHJ\HQHVHGHWWpVOHHQJHGWHDNDUMiW 6]HPH XJ\DQD]]DO D Q\XJRGW pUGHNOGpVVHO SLKHQW UDMWDPPLQWOHJHOV]|UDPLNRUI|OpEUHGWHP~J\ OiWV]LN pV]UH VH YHWWH NpWVpJEHHVHWW HUIHV]tWpVHPHW DPLW D SiQL UpPOHW VXJDOOW 0R]GXODWODQXO iOOW PLQWKD YiUQD YDOD PLUH ² N|]|Q\|V ILJ\HOHPPHO pV PLQGH]HQ NLVVp FVRGiO NR]YD /HKXOORWW D NDURP 2WWKDJ\WDP D OiQ\W D V]RED N| ]HSpQ pV D PRVGy SROFiKR] ERWRUNiOWDP eUH]WHP KRJ\ IDQWDV]WLNXV FVDSGiED HVWHP pV NHUHVWHP D PHQHNOpV ~WMiW HJ\UH NtPpOHWOHQHEE PyGV]HUHN MiUWDN D] HV]HPEHQ +D YDODNL PHJNpUGH]L PL W|UWpQLN YHOHP pV PLW MHOHQW PLQGH] HJ\ iUYD V]yW VHP EtUWDP YROQD NLQ\|JQL DQQ\LWPiUWXGWDPKRJ\DPL LWW D] ÉOORPiVRQ PLQGDQQ\LXQNNDO W|UWpQLN D] YDODPL ERU]DOPDV pV pUWKHWHWOHQ |VV]HIJJ HJpV] GH PRVW QHP H]HQ JRQGRONR]WDP KDQHP YDODPL IRUWpO\RQ D V]|NpV J\HV PyGMiQ W|UWHP D IHMHP 1HP Qp]WHP +DUH\ IHOp GH pUH]WHP PDJDPRQ D WHNLQWHWpW $ SROF I|O|WW YROW D IDOED pStWHWW J\yJ\V]HUV]HNUpQ\ )XWy V]HPOpW WDUWRWWDP EHQQH 7DOiOWDPHJ\DOWDWyVYHJFVpWpVEHGREWDPQpJ\WDEOHWWiW ² D PD[LPiOLV DGDJRW ² HJ\ SRKiUED 0HVWHUNHGpVHPHW QHP LV LJHQ WLWNROWDP +DUH\ HOWW %DMRVDQ WXGQiP PHJPRQGDQL PLpUW 1HP W,QGWHP UDMWD )RUUy YL]HW W|OW|WWHPDSRKiUEDYiUWDPPtJDWDEOHWWiNIHOROGyGQDN pV+DUH\KR]OpSWHPDNLPpJPRVWLVDV]REDN|]HSpQiOOW 

²+DUDJV]RO"²NpUGH]WHKDONDQ ²'HKRJ\,GGPHJ 1HP WXGRP PLpUW GH V]iPtWRWWDP Ui KRJ\ HQJHGHO PHVNHGLN 9DOyEDQ V]y QpONO HOYHWWH D SRKDUDW pV IHOKDMWRWWD$]DV]WDOUDWHWWHPD]UHVSRKDUDWpVOHOWHP D VDURNED D V]HNUpQ\ pV D N|Q\YHVSROF N|]|WW +DUH\ XWiQDP VRPSRO\JRWW D SDGOyUD WHOHSHGHWW NDURVV]pNHP HOp OiEiW PDJD DOi K~]YD DKRJ\ V]RNWD V pSSLO\HQ LVPHUV PR]GXODWWDO KiWUDYHWHWWH D KDMiW 1RKD PiU HJ\ iOWDOiQ QHP KLWWHP KRJ\  D] YDODKiQ\V]RU UiLVPHUWHP DSUy V]RNiVDLUD HOV]RUXOW D WRUNRP )HOIRJKDWDWODQ pV V]|UQ\, YROWD]HJpV]VDOHJUpPHVHEEKRJ\pQPDJDPLV iOQRN V]HUHSUH NpQ\V]HUOWHP KLV]HQ FVDN V]tQOHOHP KRJ\ +DUH\QDN WDUWRP PtJ  LJD]iQ +DUH\QDN KLV]L PDJiW pV QHP FVDS EH WXGDWRVDQ 1HP WXGRP PLEO N|YHWNH]WHWWHP HUUH GH H]W D] HJ\HW EL]WRVUD YHWWHP KD XJ\DQEiUPLLVEL]WRVOHKHWHWWPpJH]HQDYLOiJRQ hOG|JpOWHP D OiQ\ D WpUGHPQHN WiPDV]NRGRWW KDMD PR]GXODWODQ NH]HPHW FVLNODQGR]WD DOLJ PRFFDQWXQN 1p KiQ\V]RUORSYDyUiPUDQp]WHP)pOyUDHOWHOWD]DOWDWyQDN PiUKDWQLDNHOOHQH+DUH\KDONDQGQQ\|J|WWYDODPLW ²6]yOWiO"²NpUGH]WHPGHQHPYiODV]ROW(OiOPRVRGLN JRQGROWDP EiU KD V]LQWH DNDURN OHQQL V]tYHP PpO\pQ HJ\SHUFLJVHPKLWWHPKRJ\D]RUYRVViJKDWQLIRJ0LpUW" (UUH VHP WDOiORN YiODV]W DOLJKDQHP D]pUW PHUW FVHOHP W~OHJ\V]HU, YROW )HMHODVVDQD]|OHPEHFV~V]RWWV|WpWKDMDHOERUtWRWWDD WpUGHPHW HJ\HQOHWHVHQ OpOHJ]HWW PLQW D] DOYyN /HKDMRO WDPKRJ\D]iJ\EDYLJ\HPQHPQ\LWRWWDNLDV]HPpWGH HJ\V]HUUH FVDN J\HQJpGHQ EHOHPDUNROW D KDMDPED pV KDQJRVDQIHONDFDJRWW 0HJGHUPHGWHP+DUH\FVDN~J\Ui]NyGRWWDQHYHWpVWO 6]HPpW|VV]HKXQ\RUtWYDiUWDWODQpVHJ\EHQUDYDV]NpSSHO VDQGtWRWW UiP .tQRVPHUHYHQ RVWREiQ pV WDQiFVWDODQXO OWHP +DUH\ NXQFRJRWW PpJ HJ\ NLFVLW NH]HPUH IHNWHWWH DUFiWpVHOFV|QGHVHGHWW ² 0LW QHYHWV]" ² NpUGH]WHP WRPSiQ $UFiUD PHJLQW NLOW D] D NLVVp DJJRGDOPDV W|SUHQJpV /iWWDP KRJ\ OHONLLVPHUHWHVHQ DNDU YiODV]ROQL 2UURFVNiMiUD WHWWH D] XMMiWYpJOIHOVyKDMWRWW 

²1HPWXGRP V]LQWHPHJU|N|Q\|GpVFVHQGOWNLDKDQJMiEyO ² ,UWy KO\pQ YLVHONHGHP XJ\H" ² V]DEDGNR]RWW ² +LUWHOHQ YDODKRJ\   GH WH LV MySRID YDJ\ RO\DQ QQHSpO\HVHQOV]LWWPLQW  3HOYLV   ²0LQWNLFVRGD"²NDSWDPIHODIHMHPPHUWD]WKLWWHP URVV]XOKDOORN ²0LQW3HOYLVKLV]HPWXGRGD]DN|YpU   1RV+DUH\VHPPLV]tQDODWWQHPLVPHUKHWWH3HOYLVWpV WOHP VHP KDOOKDWRWW UyOD DEEyO D] HJ\V]HU, RNEyO NLIRO\yODJKRJ\3HOYLV OHJDOiEEKiURPpYYHO+DUH\ KDOiOD XWiQ pUNH]HWW YLVV]D H[SHGtFLyMiYDO $]HOWW pQ VHP LVPHUWHPpVDUUyODNLiOOKDWDWODQV]RNiViUyOVHPWXGWDP KRJ\D]HOQ|NLV]pNEHQWUyQROYDYpJWHOHQKRVV]~UDQ\~MWMD D] LQWp]HWL OpVHNHW .O|QEHQ 3HOOH 9LOOLV D EHFVOHWHV QHYH pV YLVV]DWpUpVH HOWW D]W VHP WXGWXN KRJ\ EDUiWDL 3HOYLVQHNV]yOtWMiN +DUH\ D WpUGHPUH N|Q\|N|OW pV DUFRPDW IUNpV]WH .DUMiUDWHWWHPDNH]HPpVODVVDQYiOODIHOpFV~V]WDWWDP PtJ PDMGQHP |VV]HNXOFVROyGRWW ONWHW PH]WHOHQ Q\DND N|UO9pJV VRURQVLPRJDWiVLVOHKHWHWWYROQDSLOODQWiVi EyOtWpOYH VHPpUWHOPH]WHPiVNpQW3HGLJYDOyMiEDQDUUyO SUyEiOWDP PHJJ\]GQL KRJ\ V]DEiO\RV PHOHJ HPEHUL WHVWHW WDSLQWRNV L]PDLDODWW FVRQWRNpV t]OHWHN YDQQDN 1\XJRGW V]HPpEH Qp]YH LV]RQ\~ NHGYHP WiPDGW KRJ\ HJ\HUWHOMHVPR]GXODWWDO|VV]HV]RUtWVDPD]XMMDLPDW 0iU PDMGQHP |VV]H]iUXOWDN DPLNRU KLUWHOHQ HV]HPEH MXWRWW6QDXWYpUHVNH]HpVHOHQJHGWHPDOiQ\W ²0LO\HQIXUFViQQp]HO  ²MHJ\H]WHPHJQ\XJRGWDQ ÔJ\ ]DNDWROW D V]tYHP KRJ\ PHJ VHP EtUWDP V]yODOQL (J\SHUFUHOHKXQ\WDPDV]HPHP +LUWHOHQNLUDM]ROyGRWWHOWWHPD]HJpV]KDGLWHUYHOHMpWO YpJLJ PLQGHQ UpV]OHWpYHO HJ\WW 3LOODQDWQ\L WpWRYi]iV QpONOIHOiOOWDP ²0RVWPiULJD]iQPHQQHPNHOO+DUH\²MHOHQWHWWHPNL ²pVKDPLQGHQiURQDNDURGKiWJ\HUHYHOHP ²-y )HOXJURWW 

² 0LpUW YDJ\ PH]tWOiE" ² NpUGH]WHP PtJ D V]HN UpQ\KH] PHQWHP pV NLYiODV]WRWWDP NpW V]tQHV NH]HV OiEDVWQHNLpVPDJDPQDN ² 1HP WXGRP   ~J\ OiWV]LN HOKDJ\WDP YDODKRO D V]DQGiORPDW   ² YpOWH EL]RQ\WDODQXO 1HP V]yOWDP Ui VHPPLW ² 9HVG OH D UXKiGDW PHUW H]W QHP K~]KDWRG I|Op ² .H]HVOiEDV   " 0LpUW" ² pUGHNOG|WW pV PiULV YHWN]QL NH]GHWW GH IXUFVD GRORJ GHUOW NL UXKiMiW QHP OHKHW OHYHWQL PHUW VHKRO VHP Q\tOLN $ SLURV JRPERN D] HOHMpQ FVDN GtV]HN 6HKRO HJ\ NDSRFV YLOOiP]iU YDJ\ LO\HVPL +DUH\ ]DYDUWDQ PRVRO\JRWW )|OHPHOWHP D SDGOyUyO HJ\ V]LNpKH] KDVRQOy V]HUV]iPRW pV KiWXO D NLYiJiVQiO IHOKDVtWRWWDPDUXKiWRO\DQIDSRIiYDOPLQWKDH]OHQQHD YHWN]pVOHJWHUPpV]HWHVHEEPyGMD0RVWPiUOHK~]KDWWDD IHMpQNHUHV]WO$NH]HVOiEDVNLFVLWO|W\|J|WWUDMWD ² 5HSOQN"    'H WH LV M|VV]" ² IDJJDWRWW PLXWiQ PLQGNHWWHQ IHO|OW|]WQN pV NLPHQWQN D V]REiEyO &VDN EyOLQWRWWDP 6]|UQ\HQ IpOWHP KRJ\ |VV]HWDOiONR]XQN 6QDXWWDOGHDUHSWpUUHYH]HW IRO\RVyUHV YROWD UiGLyV V]REDSHGLJDPHO\HOWWHONHOOHWWPHQQQNFVXNYD 0RVW LV KDORWWL FV|QG XUDONRGRWW D] ÉOORPiVRQ +DUH\ Qp]WHDPLQWDNLVYLOODQ\WDUJRQFiQNLK~]WDPHJ\UDNpWiW D N|]pSV iOOiVEyO pV V]DEDG YiJiQ\UD WROWDP 6RUUD PHJYL]VJiOWDP D PLNURUHDNWRUW D WiYLUiQ\tWiVRV NRUPiQ\RNDW D I~YyNiNDW D]XWiQ D UDMWNRFVLYDO HJ\WW iWWROWDP D UDNpWiW D NXSROD N|]SRQWL W|OFVpUH DOi D KHQJHUHV UDMWNRURQJUD PLXWiQ D] UHV IONpW HOWiYROtWRWWDPRQQDQ $ NLV ,UKDMy WHKHUV]iOOtWiVUD V]ROJiOW D] ÉOORPiV pV D 6]DWHOORLG N|]|WW HPEHU OHJIHOMHEE NLYpWHOHV HVHWEHQ XWD]RWW YHOH PHUW EHOOUO QHP OHKHWHWW NLQ\LWQL 7HUYHP pSSHQ HUUH D NHGYH] N|UOPpQ\UH pSOW 3HUV]H QHP DNDUWDP NLOQL D UDNpWiW GH PLQGHQW ~J\ FVLQiOWDP PLQWKD LJD]L UDMWKR] NpV]OGQpN +DUH\ XJ\DQLV NRQ\t WRWW D GRORJKR] KLV]HQ VRNV]RU XWD]WXQN HJ\WW %HOOUO LV HOOHQUL]WHP D KV]DEiO\R]yW pV D] R[LJpQEHUHQGH]pVW PLQGNHWWW EHLQGtWRWWDP EHNDSFVROWDP D IiUDPN|UW D MHO]OiPSiNIHOYLOODQWDNHNNRUNLPiV]WDPDV],NRG~EyO VLQWHWWHPDOpWUiQiOiOOy+DUH\QDN ²6]iOOMEH 

²eVWH" ²0DMGXWiQDG%HNHOO]iUQRPDFVDSyDMWyW 6HPPL MHOpW QHP OiWWDP KRJ\ LG HOWW J\DQ~W IRJRWW YROQD 0LKHO\W I|OPHQW D OpWUiQ pV D KHO\pUH PiV]RWW EHGXJWDP D IHMHP PHJNpUGH]WHP NpQ\HOPHVHQ OH V DOLJ KDQJ]RWW HO D V],N IDODN N|]W WRPSiQ NRQJy ÅLJHQµ KiWUDOpSWHP pV EHFVDSWDP D] DMWyW 9LOOiPJ\RUVDQ UiWRO WDPDNpWUHWHV]WpVQHNLOiWWDPKRJ\DNpV]HQOpWEHQWDU WRWW NXOFFVDO PHJK~]]DP D] |W V]RUtWyFVDYDUW D SiQFpO YiMDWDLEDQ $ KHJ\HV V]LYDU IJJOHJHVHQ PHUHGH]HWW PLQWKD YD OyEDQ D] ,UEH NpV]OGQH )RJO\RPQDN VHPPL EDMD VHP OHV]D]WWXGWDP²R[LJpQEYHQYDQDUDNpWiEDQPpJHJ\ NLVpOHOHPLVNO|QEHQVHP DNDUWDPtWpOHWQDSLJ EH]iUYD WDUWDQL 0LQGHQiURQ V]HUW NHOOHWW WHQQHP OHJDOiEE QpKiQ\ V]DEDG yUiUD KRJ\ HOWHUYH]KHVVHP D WRYiEEL WHHQGNHW pVPRVWPiUHJ\HQMRJ~IpONpQWPHJWDQiFVNR]]DPDGROJRW 6QDXWWDO $] XWROVy HOWWL FVDYDU PHJK~]iVD N|]EHQ pUH]WHP KRJ\ D UDNpWD IpPiOOYiQ\D DPHO\UH FVDN KiURP FVDSSDO YROW IHOIJJHV]WYH NLVVp UHPHJ D]W KLWWHP pQ PDJDP OHQGtWHWWHP PR]JiVED D] DFpOWHVWHW DPLQW HUWHOMHVHQ GROJR]RPDMyNRUDNXOFFVDO 'H PLNRU KiWUiOWDP QpKiQ\ OpSpVW RO\DVPLW OiWWDP KRJ\iOPRPEDQVHWpUMHQYLVV]D $] HJpV] UDNpWD YLWXVWiQFRW MiUW +DUH\ VRUR]DWRV |N|OFVDSiVDLWyO GH PLFVRGD FVDSiVRN YROWDN +D D Yp NRQ\ IHNHWH KDM~ OiQ\ KHO\HWW DFpODXWRPDWD iOO D] ,U KDMyEDQ QHP EtUWD YROQD tJ\ PHJUi]QL D Q\ROFWRQQiV W|PHJHW $ UHSOWpU OiPSiLQDN YLVV]IpQ\H RWW XJUiQGR]RWW pV YLEUiOW D FVLOORJy SiQFpORQ +DOODQL HJ\pENpQW QHP KDO ORWWDP VHPPLW WHOMHV FV|QG YROW GH D UDNpWiW WDUWy iOOYiQ\]DW V]pWYHWHWW OiEiQDN N|UYRQDOD HOYHV]WHWWH pOHV VpJpW pV UH]JHWW PLQW D K~U $ UH]JpV ~J\ IHOJ\RUVXOW KRJ\ DJJyGQL NH]GWHP D SiQFpO]DW pSVpJppUW 5HV]NHW Np]]HOK~]WDPPHJD]XWROVyFVDYDUWHOGREWDPDNXOFVRW pV OHXJURWWDP D OpWUiUyO /DVVDQ KiWUiOYD OiWWDP KRJ\ D FVDN iOODQGy Q\RPiVUD PpUHWH]HWW DPRUWL]iWRURN FVDS 

V]HJHL WiQFROQDN IRJODODWXNEDQ ÔJ\ UpPOHWW D SiQFpO N|SHQ\ W|P|U FVLOORJiVD PHJW|ULN 0LQW D] UOW XJURW WDP D WiYLUiQ\tWy SXOWKR] NpW Np]]HO Q\RPWDP IHOIHOp D UHDNWRULQGtWyNDUMiWpVDUiGLyNDSFVROyWHNNRUIOVLNHWtW Y|OWpV YDJ\ YRQtWiV W|UW HO D NDELQ EHOVHMpYHO |VV]HNDSFVROW KDQJV]yUyEyO VHPPLIpOH HPEHUL KDQJKR] QHP KDVRQOtWRWW pV PpJLV NLYHWWHP EHOOH HJ\ LVPpWOG HOQ\~MWRWWNLiOWiVWÅ.ULV.ULV.ULVµ (J\pENpQW QHP LV EL]WRV KRJ\ MyO KDOORWWDP gNO|PHW YpUHVUH]~]YDHV]HYHV]HWWHQHUON|GWHPKRJ\EHLQGtWVDP DUDNpWiW.pNHVIpQ\YLOODQWPHJDIDORQSRUIHOOHJ O|YHOOW HO D UDMWNRURQJ I~YyNiL DOyO PpUJHV V]LNUDRV]ORSSi YiOW pV PLQGHQ KDQJRW HOQ\HOW YDODPLO\HQ IRO\DPDWRV pOHV VYtWpV $ UDNpWD I|OHPHONHGHWW D KiURP OiQJVXJiURQ DPHO\HNU|JW|QHJ\HWOHQW,]RV]ORSEDROYDGWDNpVUHV]NHW IRUUyViJRW KDJ\YD PDJD P|J|WW NLUHSOW D Q\LWRWW NLO| YFVDWRUQiQ $ Q\tOiV U|JW|Q EH]iUXOW D OpJV]LYDWW\~N DXWRPDWLNXVDQP,N|GpVEHOpSWHNVPHJNH]GWpNDFVtSV IVWEHQ ~V]y FVDUQRN NLV]HOO]WHWpVpW 0LQGHEEO VHPPLW VHP YHWWHP pV]UH /iQJEDQ pJ DUFFDO D KVpJWO OH SHU]VHOW NXQNRUL KDMMDO D SXOWQDN GOYH J|UFV|VHQ NDS NRGWDP D OHYHJW DPHO\ WHOH YROW pJpVV]DJJDO PHJ D] LRQL]iFLy MHOOHJ]HWHV y]RQV]DJiYDO %iU D VWDUW SLOODQDWi EDQ |V]W|Q|VHQ EHKXQ\WDP D V]HPHP D WRUNRODWW,] PpJLV HOYDNtWRWW 6RNiLJ FVDN IHNHWH Y|U|V pV DUDQ\ NDULNiNDW OiWWDP /DVVDQ HORV]ORWWDN $ IVW D SRU pV D N|G HOW,QW NLV]tYWiN D VLYtWy V]HOO]WHWNpV]OpNHN (OV YLOiJRV SLOODQWiVRP D ]|OGHVHQ IpQ\O UDGDUHUQ\UH HVHWW $] LUiQ\UHIOHNWRUUDO PDQYHUH]YH NHUHVQL NH]GWHP D] ,UKDMyW 0LNRU YpJUH HONDSWDP PiU D OpJN|U IHOHWW MiUW eOHWHPEHQ QHP OWWHP NL UDNpWiW LO\HQ YDNWiEDQ pV UOWHQ D]W VHP WXGYD PHNNRUD J\RUVXOiVW DGMDN QHNL pV HJ\iOWDOiQ KRYi LUiQ\tWVDP /HJHJ\V]HU,EE OHV] JRQGROWDPKDN|USiO\iUDiOOtWRPD6RODULVN|UOPLQWHJ\ H]HU NLORPpWHU PDJDVViJEDQ DNNRU NLNDSFVROKDWRP D PRWRURNDW PHUW DPtJ P,N|GQHN VRVHP OHKHWHN EHQQH EL]WRV QHP W|UWpQLNH YDODPL NLV]iPtWKDWDWODQ KDWiV~ NDWDV]WUyID $] H]HU NLORPpWHUHV SiO\D ² PLQW D WiEOi]DWEyOOiWWDP²VWDFLRQiULXVV]LQWpQV]yOYDH]VHP FV|NNHQWHWWH D YHV]pO\W HJ\V]HU,HQ QHP MXWRWW HV]HPEH MREEPHJROGiV 

$KDQJV]yUyWU|JW|QDVWDUWXWiQHOQpPtWRWWDPpVQHP LV PHUWHP W|EEp EHNDSFVROQL %iUPLW LQNiEE FVDN QH NHOOMHQ ~MUD KDOODQRP D]W D] LV]RQ\~ KDQJRW DPHO\EHQ PiU VHPPL HPEHUL QHP YROW 0LQGHQ OiWV]DW ² H]W OHJDOiEE HOPRQGKDWWDP ² V]pWIRV]ORWW pV +DUH\ PDV]NMD P|JOHJ\PiVLNDUFVHMOHWWHOD]LJD]LDPHO\KH]NpSHVW D]UOHWYDOyEDQV]DEDGXOiVOHQQH (J\yUDYROWDPLNRUHOKDJ\WDPDUHSOWHUHW

$Ä.LV$SRNULI´

$UFRPRQ NH]HPHQ |VV]HpJHWW D EU (V]HPEH MXWRWW KRJ\PLNRUD]DOWDWyWNHUHVWHP+DUH\V]iPiUDNDFDJWDP YROQDDQDLYLWiVRPRQKDQHPIiMDNpSHP pJpVLVHEHNUH YDOy NHQFVUH LV DNDGWDP D J\yJ\V]HUHV SROFRQ tJ\ KiW YLVV]DPHQWHP D V]REiPED %HQ\LWRWWDP pV D QDSQ\XJWD Y|U|V IpQ\pEHQ OiWWDP KRJ\ D IRWHOEDQ DPHO\ HOWW D] LPpQW+DUH\WpUGHOWOYDODNL$UpPOHWWRUNRQUDJDGRWW YDNRQ KN|OWHP YLVV]D KRJ\ HOPHQHNOMHN YLOODQiVQ\L LGHLJ WDUWRWW D] HJpV] $] O DODN IHOQp]HWW 6QDXW YROW +iWWDO IHOpP OiEiW NHUHV]WEH YHWYH PpJ PRVW LV XJ\DQ DEEDQ D YHJ\V]HUIROWRV YiV]RQQDGUiJEDQ  YDODPL SDStU FVRPyWWDQXOPiQ\R]RWW0HOOHWWHD]DV]WDORQMyNRUDLUDW N|WHJ KHYHUW $PLNRU PHJOiWRWW PLQGHQW IpOUHWHWW pV HONRPRURGYD KRVV]DVDQ YL]VJiOJDWRWW RUUD KHJ\pQ O SiSDV]HPHI|O|WW 6]y QpONO D PRVGyKR] PHQWHP NLYHWWHP D J\yJ\ V]HUWiUEyO D IpOIRO\pNRQ\ NHQFV|W pV NHQHJHWQL NH]GWHP DUFRPRQ pV KRPORNRPRQ D OHJFV~Q\iEE pJpVHNHW 6]H UHQFVpUH DUFRP QHP GX]]DGW PHJ QDJ\RQ D V]HPHPQHN SHGLJ QHP HVHWW EDMD PHUW HUVHQ EHKXQ\WDP 1pKiQ\ QDJ\REE KyO\DJRW D KDOiQWpNRPRQ PHJ D MiURPFVRQWRN I|O|WW IHOV]~UWDP HJ\ VWHULO LQMHNFLyVW,YHO pV NLQ\RPWDP EHOON D VDYyV YiODGpNRW $]WiQ NpW QHGYHV Jp]ODSRW WHUtWHWWHP D] DUFRPUD 6QDXW HJpV] LG DODWW ILJ\HOPHVHQ V]HPOpOW 1HP YHWWHP UyOD WXGRPiVW 0LNRU YpJH]WHP VHEHLP iSROJDWiViYDO DUFRP HJ\UH MREEDQ pJHWW  KHO\HW IRJODOWDP D PiVLN NDURVV]pNEHQ (OEE OH NHOOHWW UyOD GREQRP +DUH\ UXKiMiW (JpV]HQ N|]|QVpJHV UXKD YROW HOWHNLQWYHDWWyOKRJ\QHPOHKHWHWWOHYHWQL 6QDXW FVRQWRV WpUGpUH NXOFVROW Np]]HO NULWLNXVDQ ILJ\HOWHWpQ\NHGpVHPHW ² 0LW V]yOQiO HJ\ NLV EDUiWL FVHYHJpVKH]" ² NH]GWH PLXWiQOHOWHP 0HJLJD]tWRWWDP D OHFV~V]QL NpV]O Jp]GDUDERNDW pV QHPYiODV]ROWDP ²9HQGpJHLQNYROWDNLJD]"



² ,JD] ² IHOHOWHP V]iUD]RQ 6HPPL NHGYHP VHP YROW HKKH]DJXQ\RURVKDQJKR] ²eVNLIVW|OWNNHW"/iWRPIRUUyYROWDE~FV~ 9pJLJVLPtWRWWD|U|N|VHQKiPOyKRPORNiW,WWRWWDIULVV EU Uy]VDV]tQ IROWMDL PXWDWNR]WDN 1p]WHP PLQW ERUM~ D] ~MNDSXUD+RJ\KRJ\HGGLJQHPMXWRWWHV]HPEHYDMRQKRO LV ÅVO OHµ 6QDXW pV 6DUWRULXV" 0LQGLJ FVDN D QDSUD JRQGROWDP²SHGLJD6RODULVRQQHPV]RNiVQDSR]QL   ² 3HUV]H ILQRPDEEDQ NH]GWHG" ² IRO\WDWWD J\HW VHP YHWYHUiKRJ\KLUWHOHQiWOiWWDPDV]LWiQ².LVDOWDWyFVND PpUJHFVNHUHVUHGQ\|VV]HNUpQ\NHLJD]" ²0LWDNDUV]"%HV]pOJHWKHWQNPLQWHJ\HQO IHOHN+D ERKyFNRGQLYDQNHGYHGDNNRULQNiEEPHQMHO ² 1pKD ERKyF D] HPEHU KD QLQFV LV KR]]i NHGYH ² GQQ\|JWH gVV]HKXQ\RUtWRWW V]HPPHO IUNpV]HWW ² &VDN QHP DNDURG D]W PRQGDQL KRJ\ ]VLQyUUDO YDJ\ EDOWiYDO QHPLVNtVpUOHWH]WpO"   (VHWOHJWLQWDWDUWyWYiJWiOKR]]i PLQW /XWKHU" $]W VHP" 1R OiP ² K~]WD HO D V]iMiW ² H] D]WiQ D YLWp] 0pJ D PRVGy LV pS HJ\iOWDOiQ QHP SUyEiOWDGV]pWYHUQLDIHMpWVHPPLDYLOiJRQDEHUHQGH]pV PDUDG FVDN ~J\ ULSV]URSV] EHUiPROWDG NLOWWHG pV DJ\ " ÐUiMiUDQp]HWW ² (V]HULQW KD PLQGHQ MyO PHJ\ YDQ NpW yUiQN WDOiQ PpJKiURPLV²IHMH]WHEH1p]HWWQp]HWWIHUGHPRVRO\iYDO D]WiQEHOHYiJRWW ²6]yYDOD]WPRQGRGKRJ\JD]HPEHUQHNWDUWDV]" ²8WROVyJD]HPEHUQHN²V]|JH]WHPOHQ\RPDWpNRVDQ ² ,JHQ" eV KD PHJPRQGRP HOKLWWHG YROQD" (OKLWWpO YROQDHJ\iUYDV]yWLV" +DOOJDWWDP ² *LEDULDQQDO W|UWpQW HOV]|U ² IRO\WDWWD XJ\DQD]]DO D NHOOHPHWOHQ NLV PRVROO\DO ² %H]iUNy]RWW D V]REiMiED pV FVDN D] DMWyQ NHUHV]WO EHV]pOW YHOQN 1\LOYiQ NLWDOiORG PLWJRQGROWXQN   7XGWDPGHLQNiEEQHPV]yOWDPVHPPLW ² 9LOiJRV 0HJiOODStWRWWXN KRJ\ UOW 0HVpOW QHNQN HJ\HWPiVW D] DMWy P|JO GH QHP PLQGHQW 7DOiQ D]W LV VHMWHG PLpUW WLWNROWD KRJ\ NL YDQ QiOD" 1R KLV]HQ 

WXGRG PiU VXXP FXLTXH 'H  LJD]L WXGyV YROW $GMXQN QHNLOHKHWVpJHWD]WN|YHWHOWH ²/HKHWVpJHW"0LUH" ² +iW D]W KLV]HP PHJSUyEiOW YDODPL PDJ\DUi]DWRW NHUHVQL D] HJpV]UH HOUHQGH]QL PHJIHMWHQL pMV]DNiQNpQW GROJR]RWW7XGRGPLWFVLQiOW"3HUV]HKRJ\WXGRG ² $ V]iPtWiVRN ² PRQGWDP ² $ ILyNEDQ $ UiGLy N|]SRQEDQ YROW" ²'HpQDNNRUPpJVHPPLWVHPWXGWDP ²0HGGLJWDUWRWWH]" ² $ YHQGpJMiUiV" 7DOiQ HJ\ KpWLJ $ EHV]pOJHWpVHN D] DMWyQNHUHV]WO 0HJ   V]yYDO DPL RGDEHQW W|UWpQW $]W JRQGROWXN KDOOXFLQiFLyN pV PRWRULNXV L]JDORP 6]NR SRODPLQWDGWDPQHNL ²+RJ\KRJ\  QHNL" ²1RLJHQÉWYHWWHGH QHPPDJiQDN.tVpUOHWH]HWW ÌJ\ PHQWH] ²eVWL   " ² 0L" +DUPDGQDS HOKDWiUR]WXN KRJ\ EHPHJ\QN KR]]i KD PiVNpSS QHP PHJ\ UiW|UMN D DMWyW NL DNDU WXNJ\yJ\tWDQLPLQWHPEHUVpJHVNROOpJiNKR]LOOLN ²eV  D]pUW²W|UWNLEHOOHP ²$]pUW ²eVRWW  DEEDQDV]HNUpQ\EHQ   ²%L]RQ\GUiJDILDP%L]RQ\1HPWXGWDKRJ\N|]EHQ KR]]iQN LV PHJM|WWHN D YHQGpJHN eV PiU QHP YROW PyGXQN YHOH IRJODONR]QL 'H  H]W QHP WXGWD 0RVW PiU  PRVWPiUNLFVLW  EHOHM|WWQN 2O\DQ KDONDQ PRQGWD KRJ\ D] XWROVy V]yW DOLJ KDOORW WDPLQNiEENLWDOiOWDP ²9iUMQHPpUWHP²V]yOWDPN|]EH²+RJ\OHKHWD]   KLV]HQ KDOODQRWRN NHOOHWW $]W PRQGRG KDOOJDWy]WDWRN +DOODQRWRNNHOOHWWDNpWKDQJRWpVDNNRU   ² 1HP &VDN D]  KDQJMiW KDOORWWXN pV KD YROWDN LV pUWKHWHWOHQ ]DMRN YLOiJRV XJ\H KRJ\ D]RNDW LV QHNL WXODMGRQtWRWWXN   ²&VDND]    "'HKiW  PLpUW" ² 1HP WXGRP ,JD] YDQ HUUO HJ\ HOPpOHWHP 'H D]W KLV]HP NiU VLHWQL YHOH VHJtWHQL ~J\VHP VHJtW PpJ KD PHJ LV PDJ\DUi] HJ\HWPiVW +iW tJ\ iOOXQN 'H WH 

Q\LOYiQ PiU WHJQDS OiWWiO YDODPLW NO|QEHQ UOWQHN WDUWRWWiOYROQDEHQQQNHW" ²$]WJRQGROWDPKRJ\pQUOWHPPHJ ²,JHQ"eVQHPOiWWiOVHQNLW" ²'HOiWWDP ².LW" )LQWRUD PiU QHP YROW PRVRO\ +RVV]DQ IUNpV]WHP D] DUFiWPLHOWWNLE|NWHP ²$]WD   IHNHWpW   1HPV]yOWVHPPLWGHJ|UFV|VHQHOUHKDMOyWHVWHpV]UH YpWOHQOPHJOD]XOW ² $]pUW ILJ\HOPH]WHWKHWWpO YROQD ² NH]GWHP PiU FVHNpO\HEEPHJJ\]GpVVHO ²+LV]HQILJ\HOPH]WHWWHOHN ²'HKRJ\DQ ² 1HP OHKHWHWW PiVNpSS eUWVG PHJ QHP WXGWDP NL OHV]D]"6HQNLVHPWXGWDH]WQHPOHKHWWXGQL   ²+DOOJDVVLGH6QDXW OHQQH HJ\SiUNpUGpVHP 7H PiU UpJHEEHQ   EHQQH YDJ\ (] D    V]yYDO   PL OHV] YHOH" ²ÔJ\pUWHGYLVV]DM|QH" ²ÔJ\ ²9LVV]DLVPHJQHPLV ²+RJ\KRJ\" ² ÔJ\ M|Q YLVV]D DPLO\HQ HOV]|U YROW   D] HOV OiWRJDWiVNRU (J\V]HU,HQ QHP WXG VHPPLW YDJ\ SRQWR VDEEDQ V]yOYD ~J\ YLVHONHGLN PLQWKD PLQGD] DPLW FVL QiOWiOKRJ\PHJV]DEDGXOMWOHPHJVHPW|UWpQWYROQD+D DKHO\]HWWHOUiQHPNpQ\V]HUtWHGQHPOHV]DJUHVV]tY ²0LO\HQKHO\]HWWHO" ²$]DN|UOPpQ\HNWOIJJ ²6QDXW ²0LWDNDUV]" ²1HPHQJHGKHWMNPHJPDJXQNQDNDIpQ\,]pVWKRJ\ WLWNROy]]XQN ²(]QHPIpQ\,]pV²V]DNtWRWWIpOEHV]iUD]RQ².HOYLQ WH~J\OiWV]LNPpJPLQGLJQHPpUWHG  GHWXGRGPLW" )HOYLOODQWDV]HPH ²0HJPRQGKDWQiGNLYROWD]" 

1\HOWHP HJ\HW /HKDMWRWWDP D IHMHP 1HP DNDUWDP UiQp]QL-REEDQV]HUHWWHPYROQDKDPiVOLWWpVQHP 'HKiWQHPYiORJDWKDWWDP$Jp]FVtNOHYiOWpVDNH]HPUH SRWW\DQWgVV]HUH]]HQWHPDVtNRVpULQWpVUH ²(J\QDNL   (ODNDGWDP ²0HJKDOW,QMHNFLyW  DGRWWEHPDJiQDN   9iUW ² gQJ\LONRV OHWW   " ² NpUGH]WH OiWYD KRJ\ HOD NDGWDP ²,JHQ ²eVH]PLQGHQ" +DOOJDWWDP ²(]QHPOHKHWPLQGHQ   )HONDSWDPDIHMHP1HPQp]HWWUiP ²+RQQDQWXGRG" 1HPYiODV]ROW ² +iW My ² YiJWDP EHOH 0HJQHGYHVtWHWWHP D] DMNDP ² gVV]HYHV]WQN $]D] QHP LV &VDN pQ PRQGWDP QHNL   WXGRG PLNHW KRUG |VV]H GKpEHQ D] HPEHU )RJWDP D FyNPyNRPDW pV HON|OW|]WHP  PHJ pUWpVHPUH DGWD   QHP PRQGWD NL GH KD D] HPEHU pYHNLJ HJ\WW pOW YDODNLYHO IpOV]DYDNEyO LV pUWL   %L]WRV YROWDP EHQQH KRJ\FVDNIHQ\HJHW]LNKRJ\QHPPHUQpPHJWHQQLpV   pV H]W LV EHROYDVWDP QHNL 0iVQDS HV]HPEH MXWRWW KRJ\ RWWKDJ\WDP D ILyNEDQ D]RNDW D]   LQMHNFLyNDW WXGWD KRJ\ RWW YDQ KD]DYLWWHP D OiERUDWyULXPEyO PHUW V]N VpJHP YROW Ui PpJ D KDWiViUyO LV EHV]pOWHP DNNRU 0HJ LMHGWHP HO DNDUWDP KR]QL RQQpW GH JRQGROWDP PpJ D]W KLKHWQp KRJ\ NRPRO\DQ YHWWHP DPLW PRQGRWW pV   QHP KR]WDP HO D]WiQ KDUPDGQDS PpJLV RGDPHQWHP PHUWQHPYROWQ\XJWRP'H  PLUHRGDpUWHPPiUQHP pOW ²ÐWHiUWDWODQNLVIL~   )HMHPEHV]iOOWDYpU'HDPLQWUiQp]WHPPHJpUWHWWHP KRJ\ QHP J~Q\ROyGLN 0LQWKD PRVW OiWQiP HOV]|U 6]UNH DUFiQDN PpO\ UiQFDLQ YpJWHOHQ IiUDGWViJ OW V~O\RVEHWHJQHNOiWV]RWW ² 0LpUW PRQGRG H]W" ² NpUGH]WHP IXUFViQ HOEiWRU WDODQRGYD 

² 0HUW H] D W|UWpQHW WUDJLNXV 1HP QHP ² WHWWH KR]]i J\RUVDQDPLNRUIpV]NHOGQLNH]GWHP²WHPpJPRVWVHP pUWHG (OKLV]HP KRJ\ VRNDW V]HQYHGV] HPLDWW WDOiQ J\LONRVQDNLVpU]HGPDJDGGH  KLGGHOH] PpJ QHPD OHJURVV]DEE ²,JD]iQ"²IDNDGWDPNLJ~Q\RVDQ ² gUO|N KRJ\ QHP KLV]HG HO NRPRO\DQ |UO|N $PL PHJW|UWpQW D] ERU]DV]Wy OHKHW GH D OHJV]|UQ\,EE D] DPL  QHPW|UWpQWPHJ6RKD ²1HPpUWHP  ²PDNRJWDP&VDNXJ\DQHJ\V]yWVHP pUWHWWHP%yOLQWRWW ² $]W PRQGMXN UHQGHV HPEHU ² PDJ\DUi]WD ² .L D UHQGHVHPEHU"$NLVRKDVHPN|YHWHWWHOJ\DOi]DWRVViJRW" 1RMyGHQHPLVJRQGROWUiVRKD"7DOiQQHPLVJRQGROW FVDN pSSHQ IHO|WO|WW EHQQH iWYLOODQW D] DJ\iQ Wt] pYH YDJ\KDUPLQFpYHWDOiQYpGHNH]HWWHOOHQHD]WiQQ\XJRGW OpOHNNHOHOIHOHMWHWWHKLV]HQWXGWDKRJ\~J\VHPWHQQpPHJ VRKD eV PRVW NpS]HOG HO KRJ\ HJ\V]HUUH FVDN IpQ\HV QDSSDOD]HPEHUHNV]HPHOiWWiUDHOpEHiOO$=DJRQGRODW WHVWHW |OWYH OHUi]KDWDWODQXO PHJ|OKHWHWOHQO (O WXGRG NpS]HOQL" +DOOJDWWDP ²+iWH]PHJ\D6RODULVÉOORPiVRQ²PRUPROWD ² 'H KiW   PL OHKHW RO\DQ ERU]DV]Wy" ² NpUGH]WHP KDER]YD ² (OYpJUH QHP YDJ\WRN JRQRV]WHYN WH PHJ 6DUWRULXV   ² 'H KLV]HQ WH SV]LFKROyJXV YDJ\ .HOYLQ ² V]DNtWRWW IpOEH WUHOPHWOHQO ² +iW NL D] DNLQHN VRKDVHP YROW YDODPL V]pJ\HOOQL YDOy iOPD" )DQWi]LDNpSH" *RQGROM HJ\   HJ\ IpWLVLPiGyUD DNL V]HUHOPHV PLW WXGRP pQ YDODPLV]HQQ\HVIHKpUQHP,EHpVDOHJQDJ\REEYHV]pO\HN iUiQW,]]HOYDVVDOPHJV]HU]LD]WD]LPiGRWWJXV]WXVWDODQ URQJ\RW PXODWViJRV OHKHW LJD]" $NL XQGRURGLN YiJ\DL WiUJ\iWyO GH N|]EHQ PHJUO pUWH D] pOHWpW NRFNi]WDWMD pUWH RO\DQ V]HQYHGpOO\HO KRJ\ 5yPHy HOE~MKDW PHOOHWWH   9DQQDN LO\HQ HVHWHN 1HP pUWHG KRJ\ Op WH]KHWQHN RO\DQ GROJRN   RO\DQ KHO\]HWHN   DPLNHW VHQNLVHPPHUPHJYDOyVtWDQLFVDNJRQGRODWEDQFVDNHJ\ UpV]HJ ]OO|WW UOW SHUFpEHQ QHYH]G DKRJ\ DNDURG   eVD]LJHWHVWWpOQ(]D]HJpV]



²(]D]HJpV]  ²V]DMNy]WDPWRPSiQ=~JRWWDIHMHP ² 1R GH   PL YDQ D] ÉOORPiVVDO" +RJ\ M|Q LGH D] ÉOORPiV" ² 1H WHGG PDJDG KO\pQHN ² G|UP|JWH pV pOHVHQ D V]HPHPEH Qp]HWW ² +LV]HQ iOODQGyDQ D 6RODULVUyO EH V]pOHN VHPPL PiVUyO FVDN D 6RODULVUyO 1HP D] pQ KL EiP KD WH YDODPL HJpV]HQ PiVW YiUWiO (J\pENpQW PiU HOHJHWiWpOWpODKKR]KRJ\OHJDOiEEYpJLJKDOOJDVV (OLQGXOXQN D .R]PRV]ED PLQGHQUH IHONpV]OYH ² PD JiQ\RVViJUD KDUFUDV]HQYHGpVUH KDOiOUD 6]HUpQ\VpJEO QHPPRQGMXNNLKDQJRVDQGHUHPHNIL~NQDNWDUWMXNPD JXQNDW $]WiQ EHXJULN YDODPL PHJOHSHWpV pV U|JW|Q NL GHUO KRJ\ D IHQH QDJ\ HOV]iQWViJ FVDN Sy] YROW 1HP D .R]PRV]WDNDUMXNPLPHJKyGtWDQL|UHJHPFVDND)|OGHW DNDUMXN NLWHUMHV]WHQL D PLQGHQVpJ KDWiUiLJ $] HJ\LN ERO\Jy OHJ\HQ VLYDWDJ PLQW D 6]DKDUD D PiVLN MHJHV PLQWDVDUNYLGpNYDJ\WUySXVLPLQWDEUD]tOLDLG]VXQJHO 1HPHV OHON,HN pV KXPiQXVDN YDJ\XQN QHP DNDUXQN PiVIDMRNDWOHLJi]QLFVDNiWDGQLQHNLND]pUWpNHLQNHWpV FVHUpEH iWYHQQL D] |YpLNHW 0HUW PL YDJ\XQN D V]HQW .DSFVRODWORYDJMDL+iWH]LVKD]XJViJ1HPNHUHVQNPL PiVW FVDN HPEHUHNHW 1\DYDO\iW NHOOHQHN QHNQN PiVIDMWD YLOiJRN 7NU|NHW DNDUXQN 0LKH] NH]GHQpQN PiVIDMWD YLOiJRNNDO" (OpJ QHNQN D PDJXQNp D] LV D WRUNXQNRQDNDGW6DMiWHV]PpQ\tWHWWNpSQNHWNHUHVVN D]HJ\LNERO\JyQOHJ\HQDPLpQNQpOIHMOHWWHEEFLYLOL]iFLyD PiVLNRQ D PL SULPLWtY P~OWXQN KDVRQPiVD &VDNKRJ\ D WN|UEO RO\DVPLQp]YLVV]DDPLW QHP IRJDGXQN HO DPLW NLNpUQN PDJXQNQDN 3HGLJ QHPFVDN KDPYDV HUpQ\HNHW KR]WXQN PDJXQNNDO D )|OGUO QHP D] (PEHU KVL V]REUiW SDNROWXN ,UKDMyED ÔJ\ M|WWQN V]U|VWOE U|VWO DPLO\HQHN YDJ\XQN pV PLNRU D PiVLN IpO HOpQN WiUMD D] LJD]ViJRW D]W D UpV]pW DPLUO QHP V]RNWXQN EHV]pOQLDNNRUNDSiOy]XQN ² 7HKiW PL H] D] HJpV]" ² NpUGH]WHP PLXWiQ WUHO PHVHQYpJLJKDOOJDWWDP ² $] DPLW NHUHVWQN NDSFVRODW HJ\ PiVLN FLYLOL ]iFLyYDO 0RVW PHJNDSWXN $ VDMiW I|UWHOPHV URQGDVi JXQNH]HUV]HUHVQDJ\tWiVEDQPLQWKDPLNURV]NySRQQp] QpQNDVDMiWV]pJ\HQQNpVJ\DOi]DWXQN +DQJMDUHPHJHWWDGKWO 

² 6]yYDO D]W PRQGRG KRJ\   D] yFHiQ" +RJ\  FVLQiOMD"'HPLQHN"$UUyOPiUQHPLVEHV]pOHNKRJ\DQ GH D] LVWHQ V]HUHOPpUH PLQHN" &VDN QHP JRQGRORG NR PRO\DQ KRJ\ V]yUDNR]QL DNDU YHOQN" 9DJ\ PHJ DNDU EQWHWQL" +LV]HQ H] D OHJSULPLWtYHEE GpPRQROyJLD $ ERO\JyW PHJV]iOOWD HJ\ QDJ\RQ QDJ\ |UG|J DNL ViWiQL KXPRUpU]pNH VXJDOODWiUD V]XNXEXVRNDW NOG|]JHW HJ\ WXGRPiQ\RV H[SHGtFLy WDJMDLQDN &VDN QHP KLV]HO LO\HQ HJHWYHU PDUKDViJRNEDQ" ² $] D] |UG|J QHP LV RO\DQ EXWD ² GQQ\|JWH D IRJD N|]|WW 0HJK|NNHQYH SLOODQWRWWDP Ui (V]HPEH MXWRWW KRJ\KDD]ÉOORPiVRQW|UWpQWHNHWQHPLVOHKHWHOPHEDMMDO PDJ\DUi]QL H] PpJ QHP ]iUMD NL D] LGHJ|VV]HRPOiVW 5HDNWtYSV]LFKy]LV   "²|WO|WWIHOEHQQHPPLNRUV]LQWH KDQJWDODQXONXQFRJQLNH]GHWW ² .pV]tWHG D GLDJQy]LVW" &VDN HO QH KDPDUNRGG +LV]HQWHRO\DQHQ\KHNLDGiVEDQWDSDV]WDOWDGD]HJpV]HW KRJ\PpJPRVWVLQFVIRJDOPDGUyOD ² 9DJ\ ~J\ (QJHP PHJVDMQiOW D] |UG|J ² pOFHOGWHP .LVVpPiUXQWDWRWWH]DEHV]pOJHWpV ² 0LW DNDUV] WXODMGRQNpSSHQ" 0RQGMDP PHJ PLO\HQ WHUYHNHWV] HOOHQQN[ELOOLyWRQQiQ\LPHWDPRUISOD]PD" 7DOiQVHPPLO\HW ² +RJ\KRJ\ VHPPLO\HW" ² FVRGiONR]WDP 6QDXW FVDN YLJ\RUJRWW ² 0LQW EL]RQ\iUD WDQXOWDG D] LVNROiEDQ D WXGRPiQ\ D]]DOIRJODONR]LNKRJ\DQW|UWpQLNYDODPLQHPD]]DOKRJ\ PLpUW $]W NpUGH]HG KRJ\DQ" 1RV KiW Q\ROF YDJ\ NLOHQF QDSSDO D]XWiQ D U|QWJHQNtVpUOHW XWiQ NH]GG|WW /HKHW KRJ\ D] yFHiQ YDODPL PiV VXJiU]iVVDO YiODV]ROW D EHVXJiU]iVUD WDOiQ OHWDSRJDWWD YHOH D] DJ\XQNDW pV EL ]RQ\RVSV]LFKLNDLHOWRNRVRGiVRNUDEXNNDQW ²(OWRNRVRGiVRN" (]NH]GHWWpUGHNHOQL ² 1R LJHQ D W|EELWO HOV]DNDGW N|UO]iUW HOIRMWRWW EHIDOD]RWW IRO\DPDWRN D] HPOpNH]HW J\XOODGiVRV JyFDL (]HNHW  UHFHSWQHN Qp]WH NRQVWUXNFLyV WHUYQHN   KLV]HQ WXGRG PHQQ\LUH KDVRQOtWDQDN D] DV]LPPHWULNXV NURPRV]yPDNULVWiO\RN D QXNOHLQVDYDV FHUEUR]LGYHJ\OHWHN NULVWiO\DLKR] DPHO\HNEHQ D] HPOpNNpSHN U|J]GQHN   +LV]HQ D] |U|NOGpVW KRUGR]y SOD]PD LV ÅHPOpNH]µ SOD] 

PD 6]yYDO PHJWDOiOWD EHQQQN D UHFHSWHW NLMHJ\H]WH D]WiQ D W|EELW PiU WXGRG 'H KRJ\ PLpUW FVLQiOWD   " (J\ EL]WRV QHP D]pUW KRJ\ NLQ\tUMRQ EHQQQNHW $]W VRNNDOHJ\V]HU,EEHQHOLQWp]KHWQp(J\iOWDOiQLO\HQWHFK QLNDLDGRWWViJRNNDO OpQ\HJpEHQDNiUPLW PHJWHKHWQH SpO GiXOKDVRQPiVRNDWLVNOGKHWQHDQ\DNXQNUD ² Ð  ² NLiOWRWWDP IHO² KiWH]pUW J\XOODGWiOEH DQQ\LUD HOV HVWHDPLNRUPHJOiWWiO ² (]pUW .O|QEHQ ² VDQGtWRWW UiP ² KiWKD PHJ LV FVLQiOWD" +RQQDQ WXGRG KRJ\ pQ XJ\DQD] D GHUpN |UHJ 3DWNiQ\YDJ\RNDNLNpWpYYHOH]HOWWLGHpUNH]HWW   " +DONDQ IHONDFDJRWW PLQWKD PHJU|N|Q\|GpVHP NL WXGMDPLO\HQQDJ\HOpJWpWHOpUHV]ROJiOQDGHPLQGMiUWHOLV NRPRUXOW ² 1R QHP ² G|UP|JWH ² PpJ FVDN H] KLiQ\R]QD   /HKHW KRJ\ PiV NO|QEVpJ LV YDQ GH pQ FVDN HJ\UO WXGRNWpJHGpVHQJHPPHJOHKHW|OQL ²eVNHWQHP" ²1HPDMiQORPKRJ\PHJSUyEiOG6]|UQ\, OiWYiQ\ ²6HKRJ\DQ" ² 1HP WXGRP 0pUHJJHO NpVVHO N|WpOOHO QHP D] EL] WRV   ²$WRPSLV]WROO\DO" ²0HJSUyEiOQiG" ²1HPWXGRP+DHJ\V]HUQHPHPEHUHN   ² 'H EL]RQ\RV V]HPSRQWEyO PpJLVFVDN D]RN (PEHU QHNKLV]LNPDJXNDW)RJDOPXNVLQFVD   V]iUPD]iVXN UyO(]WFVDNpV]UHYHWWHGPiU" ²3HUV]H6]yYDO  KRJ\YDQH]" ² 3LOODQDWRN DODWW UHJHQHUiOyGQDN 9LOOiPJ\RUVDQ pUWHG D V]HPQN OiWWiUD pV PHJLQW ~J\ NH]GHQHN YLVHO NHGQLPLQW  PLQW   ²+RJ\DQ" ² 0LQW D PL NpS]HOHWQNEHQ   PLQW D]RN D] HPOpN NpSHNDPLNEO    ² ,JHQ (] LJD] ² EyORJDWWDP hJ\HW VH YHWHWWHP Ui KRJ\|VV]HpJHWWDUFRPUyONH]HPUHFV|S|JDNHQFV ² *LEDULDQ WXGWD   " ² NpUGH]WHP KLUWHOHQ .XWDWy SLOODQWiVWYHWHWWUiP ²+RJ\WXGWDHD]WDPLWPL" 

²,JHQ ²0DMGQHPEL]WRVYDJ\RNEHQQH ²0LpUW"0RQGWD" ²1HP'HWDOiOWDPQiODHJ\N|Q\YHW   ²$.LV$SRNULI"²XJURWWDPIHO ²$]'HKRQQDQWXGV]WHUyOD"²IRJWDHOD]LGHJHVVpJ pVPDMGiWI~UWDWHNLQWHWpYHO ² 1\XJL ² FVyYiOWDP D IHMHP ² /iWKDWRG KRJ\ |VV]HpJWHP pV HJ\iOWDOiQ QHP UHJHQHUiOyGRP /HYHOHW KDJ\RWWQHNHPDNDELQMiEDQ ²+RJ\PRQGRG"/HYHOHW"eVPLYDQEHQQH" ²1HPVRN9DOyMiEDQQHPLVOHYpOFVDNHJ\IHOMHJ\]pV %LEOLRJUiILDL XWDOiV D 6RODULVpYN|Q\Y IJJHOpNpUH PHJ DUUDD]$SRNULIUD0LD]HJ\iOWDOiQ" ²(J\UpJLKLVWyULD7DOiQYDQYDODPLN|]HDPLpQNKH] 1HV]H %UN|WpVHV NRSRWW VDUN~ YpNRQ\ N|Q\YHFVNpW K~]RWW HO D]VHEpEOViWQ\~MWRWWD ² eV 6DUWRULXV   " ² NRFNi]WDWWDP PHJ J\RUVDQ PLN|]EHQHOWHWWHPDN|Q\YHW ² 0L YDQ YHOH" 0LQGHQNL ~J\ YLVHONHGLN HEEHQ D KHO\]HWEHQDKRJ\WXG QRUPiOLVSUyEiOOHQQLDPLQiOD KLYDWDORVDWMHOHQW ²)XUDHJ\SyN ² +iW LJHQ (J\V]HU RO\DQ KHO\]HWEHQ YROWXQN D UpV] OHWHN PHOOpNHVHN HOpJ D] KR]]i KRJ\ |WV]i] NLOy R[LJp QQN PDUDGW Q\ROF HPEHUQHN 6RUUD OHV]RNWXQN D PLQ GHQQDSLWHHQGNUODYpJpQPLQGERURVWiVDQMiUWXQNGH  QDSRQWDERURWYiONR]RWWNLSXFROWDDFLSMpW PiULO\HQ 3HUV]H PRVW DNiUPLW FVLQiO PLQGHQ FVDN WHWWHWpV NR PpGLDYDJ\J\LONRVViJ ²*\LONRVViJ" ² +iW QH OHJ\HQ J\LONRVViJ 9DODPL ~M V]yW NHOO Ui NLWDOiOQL3pOGiXOÅUDNpWDYiOiVµ-REEDQKDQJ]LN" ²5RSSDQWV]HOOHPHVYDJ\²PRURJWDP ²,QNiEEVtUMDN"-DYDVROMYDODPLW ²0HQMDIHQpEH ² 1HP NRPRO\DQ EHV]pOHN 1DJ\MiEyO HOPRQGWDP PLQGHQWDPLWWXGRN0LDWHUYHG" 

² 7HUYHP" -y YLFF )RJDOPDP VLQFV PLW FVLQiOMDN KD  YLVV]DM|Q%L]WRVKRJ\YLVV]DM|Q" ²0DMGQHP ² 'H YROWDNpSSHQ KRJ\ MXWQDN EH KLV]HQ D] ÉOORPiV OpJPHQWHVHQ]iUYDYDQ"7DOiQDSiQFpO   0HJUi]WDDIHMpW ² $ SiQFpOQDN VHPPL EDMD 6HMWHOPHP VLQFV KRJ\DQ M|QQHN EH D YHQGpJHN W|EEQ\LUH pEUHGpV XWiQ MHOHQW NH]QHNDOXGQLSHGLJPpJLVFVDNNHOOQpKD ²eVKDEH]iURPD]DMWyW" ² 3HUFHN DODWW iWMXW UDMWD &VDN HJ\HWOHQ PyGV]HU YDQ  WXGRGPiUPHO\LN )HOiOOWeQLVIHOiOOWDP ² ,GH ILJ\HOM 6QDXW   $UUD DNDUV] NLO\XNDGQL KRJ\ KDJ\MXNLWW D]ÉOORPiVW FVDN D]W YiURGKRJ\ pQ MDYDVRO MDP" )HMpWFVyYiOWD ² (] QHP RO\DQ HJ\V]HU, 3HUV]H DNiUPLNRU HOPHQH NOKHWQNOHJDOiEELVD6]DWHOORLGUDpVRQQDQOHDGKDWMXN D] 626MHO]pVW 7HUPpV]HWHVHQ UOWQHN WDUWDQDN PDMG EHGXJQDN YDODPL I|OGL V]DQDWyULXPED pV RWW PDUDGXQN PtJ V]pSHQ YLVV]D QHP YRQXQN PLQGHQW PHJHVLN LO\HQ NROOHNWtYHOPH]DYDUD]LVWHQKiWDP|J|WWLiOORPiVRNRQ   7DOiQQHPLVOHQQHURVV]6]pSQDJ\NHUWEpNHVVpJIHKpU V]REiFVNDVpWiND]iSROyYDO   (JpV]HQ NRPRO\DQ EHV]pOW ]VHEUH GXJRWW Np]]HO UHV WHNLQWHWH D V]RED VDUNiED UpYHGW $ Y|U|V QDS PiU OHEX NRWWDOiWKDWiUP|JpDWDUDMRVKXOOiPRNWLQWDIHNHWHVLYD WDJJiROYDGWDN|VV]H$]pJY|U|VHQOiQJROW/LODV]HJpO\, IHOKN ~V]WDN D] HOPRQGKDWDWODQXO NRPRU NpW V]tQ, WiM I|O|WW ²6]yYDOPHQHNOQLDNDUV]"9DJ\QHP"0pJQHP" (OPRVRO\RGRWW ² Ð WH RURV]OiQV]tY, KV    PpJ QHP NyVWROWiO EHOH NO|QEHQ NLVHEE OHJpQ\ OHQQpO 1HP DUUyO YDQ V]y KRJ\ pQPLWDNDURNFVDNDUUyOPLWOHKHWFVLQiOQL ²1RpVPLW" ²eSSHQH]D]DPLWQHPWXGRN ² $NNRU LWW PDUDGXQN" *RQGRORG KRJ\ WDOiOXQN YD ODPLPyGRW   

)HOpP IRUGtWRWWD PpO\ UiQFRNNDO EDUi]GiOW |V]W|YpU KiPOyDUFiW ² .L WXGMD +iWKD pUGHPHV ² PRQGWD ² 5yOD QHPLJHQ WXGXQNPHJW|EEHWGHWDOiQPDJXQNUyO   6DUNRQ IRUGXOW IRJWD D SDStUMDLW pV NLPHQW 9LVV]D DNDUWDPWDUWDQLGHQ\LWRWWV]iPRQQHPM|WWNLKDQJ1HP PDUDGW PiV WHQQLYDOyP PLQW D YiUDNR]iV $] DEODNKR] OpSWHP Qp]WHP D YpUHVIHNHWH yFHiQW GH DOLJ OiWWDP (V]HPEH MXWRWW KRJ\ EH]iUNy]KDWQpN HJ\ UDNpWiED D UHSOWpUHQ GH QHP JRQGROWDP NRPRO\DQ RVWRED |WOHW YROW HOEEXWyEE ~J\LV NL NHOO M|QQ|P /HOWHP D] DEODNKR]VHOYHWWHPD6QDXWWyONDSRWWN|Q\YHW0pJHOpJ YLOiJRV YROW Uy]VDV]tQ, IpQ\ YHWG|WW D ODSRNUD Y|U|VHQ L]]RWW D V]RED $ N|WHWHL HJ\ 2WWR 5DYLQW]HU QHY, E|OFVpV]GRNWRUiOOtWRWWD|VV]HW|EEQ\LUHPiUQHPLVNpWHV pUWpN, FLNNHNEO pV WDQXOPiQ\RNEyO 0LQGHQ WXGRPiQ\W NtVpU YDODPL iOWXGRPiQ\ NLVLNORWW HOPpNEHQ WHUPHOG FViPSiV WRU]NpS D FVLOODJiV]DW NDULNDW~UiMD D FVLOODJ MyVOiVDNpPLipD]DONtPLDYROWKDMGDQpUWKHW KiWKRJ\ D J\HUPHNFLSEHQ MiUy V]RODULV]WLND N|UO FVDN ~J\ UDM ]RWWDNDV]HOOHPLFVXGDERJDUDNLO\HQVOHWOHQVpJHNW|OWLN PHJ 5DYLQW]HU N|Q\YpW GH D] LJD]ViJ NHGYppUW OH NHOO V]|JH]QL KRJ\ D] HOV]yEDQ YLOiJRVDQ HOKDWiUROMD PDJiW HWWO D SDQRSWLNWXPWyO 0LQG|VV]H ~J\ YpOWH pV YROW LV QpPL LJD]D KRJ\ J\,MWHPpQ\H pUWpNHV NRUGRNXPHQWXP OHKHW PDMG D W|UWpQpV]HN pV D WXGRPiQ\SV]LFKROyJXVRN V]iPiUD %HUWRQ MHOHQWpVH HONHO KHO\HW IRJODOW HO D N|Q\YEHQ 7|EEUpV]EOiOOW$]HOV D]LJHQW|P|UKHOLNRSWHUQDSOy 7L]HQQpJ\ yUiWyO WL]HQKDW QHJ\YHQLJ D] HJ\H]PpQ\HV H[SHGtFLyLG V]HULQW  D IHOMHJ\]pVHN V],NV]DY~DN pV QH JDWtYDN Å0DJDVViJ ²YDJ\ ²YDJ\PpWHU²QHP pV]OHOWHP VHPPLW ² D] yFHiQ UHVµ (] W|EEV]|U PHJLVPpWOGLN $]XWiQ NRU Å9|U|V N|G V]iOO IHO /iWyWiYROViJ PpWHU$]yFHiQUHVµ  yUDNRU Å$ N|G V,U,V|GLN FVHQG OiWyWiYROViJ PpWHUQpKDIHOWLV]WXO/HV]iOORNUDµ  Å.|GEHQ YDJ\RN 0DJDVViJ  /iWyWiYROViJ PpWHU&VHQG)HOV]iOORNUDµ 

Å0DJDVViJ.|GUpWHJDOiWyKDWiULJ $ N|G EHQW|OFVpUV]HU, Q\tOiVRNDPHO\HNHQiWD]yFHiQIHOV]tQpW OiWRP9DODPLW|UWpQLNEHQQN0HJSUyEiORNEHKDWROQLD] HJ\LNW|OFVpUEHµ  ÅgUYpQ\IpOpW OiWRN ² ViUJD KDERW YHW NL .|GIDO YHV]LN|UO0DJDVViJ/HPHJ\HNUDµ (]]HO YpJ]GLN %HUWRQ KHOLNRSWHUQDSOyMD $] ~J\QH YH]HWW MHOHQWpV WRYiEEL UpV]H NLYRQDW %HUWRQ NyUW|UWp QHWpEO SRQWRVDEEDQ %HUWRQ WROOED PRQGRWW YDOORPiVi QDN V]|YHJH D EL]RWWViJ WDJMDLQDN N|]EHYHWHWW NpUGpVHL YHO Å%HUWRQ0LNRUOHPHQWHPKDUPLQFPpWHUUHQHKp]OHWW WDUWDQLDPDJDVViJRWPHUWDEEDQD W|OFVpU IRUPiM~N|G PHQWHV WpUEHQ YLKDURV V]pO I~MW 1HNL NHOOHWW IHNGQ|P D NRUPiQ\]iVQDN H]pUW HJ\ LGHLJ WDOiQ Wt]WL]HQ|W SHUFLJ QHP Qp]WHP NL D JpSEO .|]EHQ HJ\ HUV V]pOURKDP EH OHVRGRUWDN|GEH1HPN|]|QVpJHVN|GYROWKDQHPYDODPL HPXO]LyIpOH D]W KLV]HP NROORLGRV PHUW PLQGHQ DEOD NRPDW EHOHSWH $OLJ EtUWDP OHWLV]WRJDWQL RO\DQ UDJDGyV YROW $ IRUGXODWV]iPRP W|EE PLQW KDUPLQF V]i]DOpNNDO FV|NNHQW PHUW HEEHQ D N|GIpOpEHQ QDJ\REE YROW D OpJ HOOHQiOOiV~J\KRJ\YHV]tWHQLNH]GWHPDPDJDVViJRW0LYHO QDJ\RQDODFVRQ\DQMiUWDPpVIpOWHPKRJ\EHOHWN|]|PD KXOOiPRNED WHOMHV Ji]W DGWDP $ JpS WDUWRWWD D PDJDV ViJRW GH I|OMHEE QHP PHQW 9ROW PpJ QpJ\ J\RUVtWy UD NpWDW|OWpQ\HP 1HP KDV]QiOWDP IHO NHW PHUW DUUD JRQ GROWDPURVV]DEERGKDWDKHO\]HWpVDNNRUV]NVpJHPOHV] UiMXN $ PD[LPiOLV IRUGXODWV]iPQiO URSSDQW HUV EHUH] JpVWiPDGWVHMWHWWHPKRJ\D]DIXUFVDHPXO]LyOHSLEHD OpJFVDYDUW D WHKHUEtUiVPXWDWy iOODQGyDQ D QXOOiQ iOOW tJ\ VHPPLW VHP WHKHWWHP $ QDSRW QHP OiWWDP PLyWD N|GEHNHUOWHPGHDUUDIHOpD N|GY|U|VHQ IRV]IRUHV]NiOW )RO\WRQ N|U|]WHP UHPpOYH KRJ\ HOEEXWyEE YDODPHO\LN N|GPHQWHV W|OFVpUEH NHUO|N pV PLQWHJ\ IpOyUD P~OYD VLNHUOW LV &VDNQHP V]DEiO\RV KHQJHU DODN~ SiU V]i] PpWHU iWPpUM, V]DEDG WpUVpJEH MXWRWWDP .|U|VN|UO KHYHVHQ NDYDUJRWW D N|G PLQWKD HUV NRQYHNFLyV iUDP OiVRN VRGRUQiN ,J\HNH]WHP D ÅO\XNµ N|]HSpQ PDUDGQL PHUW RWW YROW D OHYHJ D OHJQ\XJRGWDEE (NNRU pV]UHYHW WHP KRJ\ D] yFHiQ IHOV]tQH PHJYiOWR]RWW $ KXOOiPRN FVDNQHP WHOMHVHQ HOW,QWHN D IRO\DGpN IHOV UpWHJH PiU 

PLQW D]p D] DQ\DJp DPLEO D] yFHiQ YDQ IpOLJ iWOiWV]y OHWW HOHOW,Q KRPiO\RV IROWRNNDO D]WiQ QHPVRNiUD WHO MHVHQ NLWLV]WXOW pV H]HQ D W|EE PpWHU YDVWDJQDN YpOW Up WHJHQ iW EHOiWKDWWDP D PpO\EH 2WW YDODPL ViUJiV LV]DS IpOH J\,OW |VV]H YpNRQ\ IJJOHJHV HUHNEHQ I|OIHOp V]L YiUJRWW NLIRO\W D IHOV]tQUH DKRO YHJHVHQ FVLOORJy OHWW PDMG IRUW\RJQL pV KDE]DQL NH]GHWW N|]EHQ EHV,U,V|G|WW HNNRU RO\DQ YROW PLQW D QDJ\RQ W|PpQ\ RGDpJHWW FX NRUV]LUXS (] D] LV]DS YDJ\ Q\iOND PHJFVRPyVRGRWW IHO J\,UG|WW NDUILROV]HU, NLWUHPOpVHNHW DONRWRWW pV ODVVDQ NO|QIpOH IRUPiNDW |OW|WW $ N|GIDO IHOp VRGUyGWDP SiU SHUFLJ PDQYHUH]QHP NHOOHWW D NRUPiQQ\DO PHJ D IRUGX ODWV]iPPDO pV PLUH ~MUD NLQp]KHWWHP RGDOHQW DODWWDP RO\DVPLW SLOODQWRWWDP PHJ DPL HJ\ NHUWUH KDVRQOtWRWW ,JHQ NHUWUH 7|USH IiFVNiNDW V|YpQ\HNHW NHUWL XWDNDW OiWWDP ² QHP LJD]LDNDW PLQG DEEyO D ViUJiV DQ\DJEyO YROWDPLN|]EHQWHOMHVHQPHJV]LOiUGXOWPLQWDJLSV]GHD IHOV]tQH HUVHQ FVLOORJRWW /HV]iOOWDP DPHQQ\LUH FVDN WXGWDPKRJ\MyOPHJQp]KHVVHP ² .pUGpV $ IiNQDN pV PiV Q|YpQ\HNQHN DPHO\HNHW OiWWiOOHYHOHLNLVYROWDN" %HUWRQYiODV]D1HP&VDNDIRUPiMXNYROWPHJ²PLQW HJ\NHUW PDNHWWMpQ(]D]0DNHWW,O\HQYROW0DNHWW GH D]W KLV]HP WHUPpV]HWHV QDJ\ViJ~ 3iU SHUF P~OYD UHSHGH]QLW|UHGH]QLNH]GHWWDNRURPIHNHWHKDVDGpNRNEyO V,U, Q\iONDEXJ\RJRWWHOPHJNRFVRQ\iVRGRWWHJ\UpV]H OHFVXUJRWW D W|EEL UDMWD PDUDGW pV HJ\UH KHYHVHEEHQ KDE]RWW YpJO D] HJpV]HW HO|QW|WWH D WDMWpN PiU VHPPL PiVWQHPOiWWDP.|]EHQPLQGHQIHOOV]RURQJDWQLNH]GHWW DN|GH]pUWPHJQ|YHOWHPDIRUGXODWV]iPRWpVI|OPHQWHP KiURPV]i]PpWHUUH .pUGpV (JpV]HQ EL]WRV KRJ\ DPLW OiWWiO NHUWUH KD VRQOtWRWWpVVHPPLPiVUD" %HUWRQ YiODV]D %L]WRV %L]WRV PHUW W|EEIpOH UpV]OHWHW LV PHJILJ\HOWHP HPOpNV]HP SpOGiXO KRJ\ HJ\ KHO\WW QpJ\V]|JOHWHV OiGDIpOpN iOOWDN VRUEDQ .pVEE HV]HPEH MXWRWWKRJ\NDSWiUDNOHKHWWHN .pUGpV .pVEE MXWRWW HV]HGEH" 1HP DNNRU DPLNRU OiWWDG" %HUWRQYiODV]D1HPPHUWPLQGHQRO\DQYROWPLQWKD JLSV]EOOHQQH$]WiQPpJPiVWiUJ\DNDWLVOiWWDP 

.pUGpV0LNHW" %HUWRQYiODV]D1HPWXGRPPHJPRQGDQLPLNYROWDN PHUW QHP Qp]KHWWHP PHJ DODSRVDEEDQ ÔJ\ UpPOHWW Qp PHO\LN ERNRU DODWW KRVV]~NiV IRJD]RWW V]HUV]iPIpOpN IH NV]QHN PLQWKD NLV NHUWLJpSHN JLSV]|QWYpQ\HL OHWWHN YROQD 'H HEEHQ QHP YDJ\RN HJpV]HQ EL]WRV $PLW D] HOEEPRQGWDPDEEDQLJHQ .pUGpV1HPJRQGROWiODUUDKRJ\H]KDOOXFLQiFLy" %HUWRQ YiODV]D 1HP $]W JRQGROWDP GpOLEiE +DOOX FLQiFLyUD QHP JRQGROWDP PHUW WHOMHVHQ MyO pUH]WHP PD JDP PHJ D]pUW VHP PHUW VRKD pOHWHPEHQ QHP OiWWDP LO\HVPLW $PLNRU I|OPHQWHP KiURPV]i] PpWHUUH DODWWDP FVXSDO\XNYROWD N|G PLQW HJ\ VDMW 1pPHO\LN O\XNUHV YROW H]HNHQ iW D] yFHiQ KXOOiP]iViW OiWWDP D W|EELEHQ IRUW\RJRWW YDODPL /HHUHV]NHGWHP D] HJ\LNEH pV QHJ\YHQ PpWHUHQ OiWWDP KRJ\ QHP VRNNDO D] yFHiQ IHOV]tQH DODWW HJ\ IDO IHNV]LN RO\DQ PLQW YDODPL QDJ\RQ QDJ\ pSOHW IDOD YLOiJRVDQ iWWHWV]HWW D KXOOiPRNRQ QpJ\V]|JOHWHV Q\tOiVRN YROWDN UDMWD V]DEiO\RV VRURNEDQ PLQWKD FVDN DEODNRNOHWWHNYROQDVW~J\UpPOHWWQpPHO\LNDEODNEDQ PR]RJ YDODPL (EEHQ PiU QHP YDJ\RN HJpV]HQ EL]WRV $ IDO HPHONHGQL NH]GHWW pV ODVVDQ IHOEXNNDQW D] yFHiQEyO 0LQWDYt]HVpV~J\|PO|WWUyODDQ\iONDQ\~OyVFDIDWRNLV YROWDN EHQQH Q\iONDFVRPyN YDJ\ PLN +LUWHOHQ NHWWpW|UW D] HJpV] YLOOiPJ\RUVDQ OHPHUOW pV U|JW|Q HOW,QW ÔMUD IHOUiQWRWWDPDJpSHWpVN|]YHWOHQODN|GI|O|WWUHSOWHP DIXWyP, PDMGQHPpULQWHWWH0HJSLOODQWRWWDPDN|YHWNH] UHV W|OFVpUW ² D]W KLV]HP QpJ\V]HU|WV]|U DNNRUD YROW PLQWD]HOV 0iU PHVV]LUO PHJOiWWDP KRJ\ OHQW YDODPL ~V]LN )HFKQHU V]NDIDQGHUpQHN Qp]WHP PHUW YLOiJRV V]tQ, YROW PDMGQHP IHKpU pV D] DODNMD LV HPEHUUH KDVRQOtWRWW eOHV V]|JEHQ YLVV]DIRUGXOWDP PHUW DWWyO IpOWHP W~OUHSO|N UDMWDpVQHPWDOiORPPHJW|EEpD]DYDODPLHNNRUNLVVp I|OHPHONHGHWW ~J\ UpPOHWW PLQWKD ~V]QD D]WiQ PLQWKD GHUpNLJ Ji]ROQD D] yFHiQEDQ *\RUVDQ OHHUHV]NHGWHP RO\DQ PpO\UH KRJ\ pUH]WHP DPLQW D IXWyP, YDODPL SXKiEDWN|]LNKXOOiPWDUDMOHKHWHWWYROWLVRWWHJ\QDJ\ KXOOiP$]DYDODPLHPEHUYROWGHV]NDIDQGHUQpONOeV PpJLVPR]JRWW .pUGpV/iWWDGD]DUFiW"



%HUWRQYiODV]D/iWWDP .pUGpV.LYROWD]" %HUWRQYiODV]D(J\J\HUHN .pUGpV0LIpOHJ\HUHN"/iWWDGPiUYDODKROpOHWHGEHQ" %HUWRQ YiODV]D 1HP 6RKD /HJDOiEELV QHP HPOpN V]HP Ui 'H PLKHO\W D N|]HOpEH pUWHP QHJ\YHQ PpWHU OHKHWHWWN|]|WWQNWDOiQHJ\NLFVLYHOW|EEUiM|WWHPKRJ\ YDODPLURVV]YDQEHQQH .pUGpV+RJ\pUWHGH]W" %HUWRQ YiODV]D 0LQGMiUW PHJPDJ\DUi]RP (OV]|U QHP WXGWDP PL D] &VDN HJ\ LG P~OYD YHWWHP pV]UH ERU]DV]WyDQQDJ\YROWÐULiVL²D]QHPNLIHMH]pV/HKHWHWW QpJ\ PpWHU 3RQWRVDQ HPOpNV]HP PLNRU D IXWyP, D KXOOiPQDN WN|]|WW D] DUFD YDODPLYHO PDJDVDEEDQ YROW D] HQ\pPQpO SHGLJ KD OWHP LV D IONpEHQ OHJDOiEE KiURPPpWHUUHOD]yFHiQIHOV]tQHI|O|WWYROWDP .pUGpV +D LO\HQ QDJ\ YROW KRQQDQ WXGWDG KRJ\ J\HUHN" %HUWRQYiODV]D0HUWHJpV]HQNLFVLJ\HUHNYROW .pUGpV 1HP JRQGRORG %HUWRQ KRJ\ D YiODV]RG OR JLNiWODQ" %HUWRQ YiODV]D 1HP (J\iOWDOiQ QHP +LV]HQ OiWWDP D] DUFiW 0HJ D WHVWDONDWD LV J\HUHNHV YROW 2O\DQ   FVHFVHPIRUPiQDN Qp]WHP 1R QHP H] W~O]iV /HKHWHWW NpWKiURP pYHV )HNHWH KDMD YROW pV yULiVL NpN V]HPH $Q\DV]OW PH]WHOHQ YROW $ EUH QHGYHV YDJ\ LQNiEE VtNRVPHUWQDJ\RQFVLOORJRWW (] D OiWYiQ\ V]|UQ\, KDWiVVDO YROW UiP 0iU QHP KLWWHP KRJ\ GpOLEiE 1DJ\RQ LV WLV]WiQ OiWWDP (PHO NHGHWW pV VOO\HGW D KXOOiPRNNDO GH HWWO IJJHWOHQO LV PR]JRWWpVH]YROWD]XQGRUtWy .pUGpV0LpUW"0LWFVLQiOW" %HUWRQYiODV]D2O\DQYROWQRPLQWYDODPLP~]HXP EDQ  PLQWHJ\YLDV]EiE²GHpO YLDV]EiE7iWRJRWW pV PLQGHQIpOH XQGRUtWy PR]GXODWRW WHWW 0HUW   PHUW D]RN QHPD] PR]GXODWDLYROWDN .pUGpV+RJ\pUWHGH]W" %HUWRQ YiODV]D 1HP PHQWHP KR]]i N|]HOHEE WL]HQ|W K~V] PpWHUQpO OHJLQNiEE WDOiQ K~V]UD EHFVOQpP 'H 

PRQGWDP PiU PLO\HQ LUGDWODQ QDJ\ YROW ~J\KRJ\ HJp V]HQ SRQWRVDQ OiWWDP &VLOORJRWW D V]HPH pV HJ\iOWDOiQ PLQGHQHVWO RO\DQ YROW PLQW HJ\ pO J\HUHN GH D]RN D PR]GXODWRN PLQWKD YDODNL SUyEiOJDWQi   NLSUyEiOQi   .pUGpV0DJ\DUi]GPHJSRQWRVDEEDQ %HUWRQ YiODV]D 1HP WXGRP VLNHUOH (] YROW D EHQ\RPiVRP eUH]WHP 1HP JRQGRONR]WDP UDMWD $]RN D PR]GXODWRN  WHUPpV]HWHOOHQHVHNYROWDN .pUGpV $]W DNDURG PRQGDQL KRJ\ SpOGiXO ~J\ PR] JDWWD D NDUMiW DKRJ\HPEHUL NDU QHP PR]RJKDW PHUW D] t]OHWHNQHPHQJHGLN" %HUWRQ YiODV]D 1HP 'HKRJ\ &VDN   pUWHOPHWOHQ PR]GXODWRN YROWDN ÉOWDOiEDQ PLQGHQ PR]GXODW MHOHQW YDODPLWV]ROJiOYDODPLUH   .pUGpV *RQGRORG" (J\ FVHFVHP PR]JiViQDN QLQFV IHOWpWOHQOpUWHOPH %HUWRQ YiODV]D 7XGRP 'H D FVHFVHP |VV]HYLVV]D NDOLPSiO FVDN ~J\ EHOH D YLOiJED (] SHGLJ   WXGRP PiU (QQHN D PR]GXODWDL PyGV]HUHVHN YROWDN (J\PiV XWiQN|YHWNH]WHNFVRSRUWRNEDQpV VRUR]DWRNEDQ 0LQWKD YDODNLPHJDNDUQiYL]VJiOQLPLWWXGFVLQiOQLH]DJ\HUHN D NDUMiYDO D W|U]VpYHO D V]iMiYDO   D] DUFD YROW D OHJ V]|UQ\,EE JRQGRORP D]pUW PHUW D] DUF D OHJNLIHMH]EE pVH]RO\DQYROW  1HPWXGRPKRJ\PDJ\DUi]]DPPHJ eO YROW LJHQ GH PpJVHP HPEHUL ,OOHWYH D YRQiVDL QD J\RQ LV D V]HPH EUH PLQGHQH GH D] DUFNLIHMH]pVH D PLPLNiMDD]QHP .pUGpV )LQWRURNDW YiJRWW" 7XGRG PLO\HQ D] HPEHU DUFDHSLOHSV]LiVURKDPEDQ" %HUWRQ YiODV]D 7XGRP /iWWDP HSLOHSV]LiV URKDPRW eUWHP 1HP   H] PiV YROW $] HSLOHSV]LiV J|UFV|VHQ UiQJDWy]LNH]PHJVLPiQpVHJ\HQOHWHVHQPR]JRWWNHFVH VHQ YDJ\ KRJ\ LV PRQGMDP   GDOODPRVDQ 1HP WDOiORN PiV V]yW eV D] DUFD LJHQ D]]DO LV tJ\ YROW (PEHUL DUF QHP OHKHW RO\DQ KRJ\ D] HJ\LN IHOH YLGiP D PiVLN V]RPRU~ D] HJ\LN UpV]H IHQ\HJHW]LN YDJ\ IpO D PiVLN PHJGLDGDOPDVNRGLNYDJ\PLWFVLQiOGH DQQiOD J\HUHN QpO tJ\ PHQW eV PpJ HJ\ D] HJpV] PR]JiV pV DUFMiWpN OHKHWHWOHQO J\RUV YROW eQ QDJ\RQ U|YLG LGHLJ Qp]WHP 7DOiQWt]PiVRGSHUFLJ9DJ\DGGLJVHP 

.pUGpV eV D]W DNDURG PRQGDQL KRJ\ PLQGH]W LO\HQ U|YLGLG DODWWOiWWDG"(J\pENpQW KRQQDQWXGRG PHQQ\L LGHLJWDUWRWWPHJQp]WHGD]yUiW" %HUWRQ YiODV]D 1HP 1HP Qp]WHP PHJ D] yUiW GH WL]HQKDW pYH UHSO|N $] pQ V]DNPiPEDQ PiVRGSHUFUH pUH]QL NHOO D] LGW H] EHLGHJ]GLN 6]NVpJ YDQ Ui D ODQGROiVQiO 6RKDVHP OHV] YpUEHOL SLOyWD DNL EiUPLO\HQ N|UOPpQ\HN N|]|WW PHJ QHP WXGMD PRQGDQL KRJ\ HJ\ MHOHQVpJ |W PiVRGSHUFLJ WDUWRWW YDJ\ Wt]LJ 8J\DQH] iOO D PHJILJ\HONpSHVVpJUH $] pYHN VRUiQ PHJWDQXOMD D] HP EHUKRJ\PLQpOU|YLGHEELG DODWWpV]OHOMHQPLQGHQW .pUGpV/iWWiOPpJPiVWLV" %HUWRQYiODV]D/iWWDP 'H D W|EELUH QHPHPOpNV]HP LO\HQSRQWRVDQ6RNYROWH]QHNHP~J\OiWV]LN/HEORNNROW D] DJ\DP (UHV]NHGQL NH]GHWW D N|G PDJDVDEEUD NHOOHWW V]iOOQRP .HOOHWW GH KRJ\ PLNRU pV KRJ\DQ FVLQiOWDP DUUD QHP HPOpNV]HP eOHWHPEHQ HOV]|U NLV KtMiQ OH]XKDQWDP$QQ\LUDUHPHJHWWDNH]HPKRJ\QHPEtUWDP UHQGHVHQ WDUWDQL D NRUPiQ\W ÔJ\ UpPOLN NLDEiOWDP YDODPLWpVD%i]LVWKtYRJDWWDPSHGLJWXGWDPKRJ\QLQFV |VV]HN|WWHWpV .pUGpV0HJSUyEiOWiOYLVV]DIRUGXOQL" %HUWRQ YiODV]D 1HP 0HUW DPLNRU YpJUH D N|G I|Op YHUJGWHP HV]HPEH MXWRWW KRJ\ KiWKD RWW YDQ )HFKQHU YDODPHO\LN W|OFVpU PpO\pQ 7XGRP EXWDViJQDN KDQJ]LN 0pJLV H] MiUW D IHMHPEHQ +D LO\HVPLN W|UWpQQHN JRQGRO WDP DNNRU WDOiQ )HFKQHUW LV VLNHUO PHJWDOiOQRP (]pUW HOKDWiUR]WDP KRJ\ DQQ\L W|OFVpUEH V]iOORN OH DKiQ\ED FVDN EtURN 'H DPLNRU I|OHPHONHGWHP D KDUPDGLNEyO D]XWiQDPLWRWWOiWWDPPHJpUWHWWHPKRJ\QLQFVWRYiEE .LNpV]OWHP (]W PHJ NHOO PRQGDQRP HJ\pENpQW ~J\LV WXGMiN 5RVV]XO OHWWHP pV KiQ\WDP D JpSEHQ $GGLJ D]W VHP WXGWDP PL IiQ WHUHP D URVV]XOOpW 6RKD QHP YROW KiQ\LQJHUHP .pUGpV(]DPpUJH]pVWQHWHYROW%HUWRQ %HUWRQ YiODV]D /HKHW 1HP WXGRP 'H D]W DPLW KDUPDGV]RUUD OiWWDP QHP pQ WDOiOWDP NL $]W QHP D PpUJH]pVRNR]WD .pUGpV+RQQDQWXGKDWRG" %HUWRQYiODV]D$]QHPYROWKDOOXFLQiFLy+DOOXFLQiFLy D]DPLWDVDMiWDJ\DPWHUPHOYDJ\QHP" 

.pUGpV'HLJHQ %HUWRQ YiODV]D 1R XJ\H (]W SHGLJ QHP WHUPHOKHWWH 6RKDQHPKLV]HPHO1HPYROQDUiNpSHV .pUGpV0RQGGHOLQNiEEPLYROWD]My" %HUWRQ YiODV]D (OEE PHJ NHOO WXGQRP KRJ\DQ NH]HOLND]WDPLWHGGLJPRQGWDP .pUGpV0LpUWIRQWRVH] " %HUWRQYiODV]D6]iPRPUDQDJ\RQLVIRQWRV0RQGRP KRJ\ RO\DVPLW OiWWDP DPLW VRKDVHP IHOHMWHN HO +D D EL]RWWViJ ~J\ YpOL KRJ\ D EHV]iPROyPQDN YDQ OHJDOiEE HJ\HWOHQ V]i]DOpNQ\L YDOyV]tQ,VpJH WHKiW PHJ NHOO YL]V JiOQL D] yFHiQW HEEO D V]HPSRQWEyO ~J\ pUWHP NXWDWi VRNDW NHOO LQGtWDQL HEEHQ D] LUiQ\EDQ DNNRU PLQGHQW HOPRQGRN'HKDDEL]RWWViJDJ\UpPQHNWDUWMDD]HJpV]HW DNNRUQHPPRQGRNVHPPLW .pUGpV0LpUW" %HUWRQ YiODV]D 0HUW KRJ\ PLO\HQ ERU]DOPDNDW KDO OXFLQiORND]D]pQPDJiQJ\HP'HKRJ\PLWpV]OHOWHPD 6RODULVRQD]QHPPDJiQJ\ .pUGpV (] D]W MHOHQWL KRJ\ D] H[SHGtFLy LOOHWpNHV V]HUYHLQHN G|QWpVpLJ PHJWDJDGV] PLQGHQ WRYiEEL YiODV]W" 0HUW D]W EL]RQ\iUD PHJpUWHG KRJ\ D EL]RWWViJ QLQFVD]RQQDOLG|QWpVUHIHOKDWDOPD]YD %HUWRQYiODV]D,JHQµ ÌJ\ YpJ]GLN D] HOV MHJ\]N|Q\Y 8WiQD UpV]OHW N| YHWNH]LN D PiVRGLNEyO DPLW WL]HQHJ\ QDSSDO NpVEE YHW WHNIHO Å(OQ|N    PLQGH]W ILJ\HOHPEH YpYH D KiURP RUYRV EyOKiURPELROyJXVEyOHJ\IL]LNXVEyOHJ\JpSpV]PpUQ|N EOpVD]H[SHGtFLyKHO\HWWHVYH]HWMpEOiOOyEL]RWWViJDUUD D PHJJ\]GpVUH MXWRWW KRJ\ D %HUWRQ iOWDO HODGRWW HVHPpQ\HN D]RQ KDOOXFLQiFLyVRUR]DW WDUWDOPiW NpSH]LN DPHO\ D ERO\JyOpJN|U RNR]WD PpUJH]pV KDWiViQDN D YHOH MiUy N|G|V WXGDWiOODSRWQDN pV D] DJ\NpUHJ DVV]RFLiFLyV PH]LEHQ OpWUHM|WW L]JDORPQDN WXODMGRQtWKDWy V D IHQW HPOtWHWWHVHPpQ\VRUQDNVHPPLYDJ\PDMGQHPVHPPLYD OyViJDODSMDQHPYROW %HUWRQ %RFViQDW 0LW MHOHQW D] KRJ\ ªVHPPL YDJ\ PDMGQHP VHPPL©" 0L D] D ªPDMGQHP VHPPL©" 0HNNRUD D]" 

(OQ|N 0pJ QHP IHMH]WHP EH -HJ\]N|Q\YEH YpWHWHWW GU $UFKLEDOG 0HVVHQJHU IL]LNXV YRWXP VHSDUDWXPD QH YH]HWW NLMHOHQWHWWH KRJ\ D %HUWRQ iOWDO HOPRQGRWWDN V]H ULQWHYDOyEDQPHJW|UWpQKHWWHNpVDODSRVYL]VJiODWRWpUGH PHOQHN(]PLQGHQ %HUWRQ0HJLVPpWOHPD]HOEELNpUGpVW (OQ|N (J\V]HU, D GRORJ $ ªPDMGQHP VHPPL© D]W MHOHQWL KRJ\ KDOOXFLQiFLyLG EL]RQ\RV UHiOLV MHOHQVpJHNEO LQGXOKDWWDN NL %HUWRQ $ OHJQRUPiOLVDEE HPEHUUHO LV HOIRUGXO KRJ\ pMV]DND V]pOYLKDUEDQ HPEHUDODNQDN Qp]L DKDMODGR]yERNURW +iWPpJHJ\LGHJHQERO\JyQ PLNRUD PHJILJ\HO HOPpMH PpUHJ KDWiVD DODWW iOO (] HJ\iOWDOiQ QHPVpUW UiGQp]YH%HUWRQ+RJ\DQG|QWHV]H]HNXWiQ" %HUWRQ(OV]|UD]WV]HUHWQpPPHJWXGQL N|YHWNH]LNH YDODPL0HVVHQJHUGRNWRUYRWXPVHSDUDWXPiEyO" (OQ|N *\DNRUODWLODJ VHPPL ÔJ\ pUWHP QHP LQGXO NXWDWiVHEEHQD]LUiQ\EDQ %HUWRQ$PLLWWHOKDQJ]LNMHJ\]N|Q\YEHNHUO" (OQ|N,JHQ %HUWRQ $NNRU N|]|OQL V]HUHWQpP KRJ\ PHJJ\]Gp VHP V]HULQW D EL]RWWViJ QHP HQJHP VpUWHWW PHJ pQ LWW QHP V]iPtWRN KDQHP D] H[SHGtFLy V]HOOHPpW $QQDN pUWHOPpEHQDPLWDP~OWNRUPRQGWDPWRYiEELNpUGpVHNUH QHPYiODV]RORN (OQ|N(]PLQGHQ" %HUWRQ (] 9LV]RQW EHV]pOQL V]HUHWQpN 0HVVHQJHU GRNWRUUDO/HKHWVpJHV" (OQ|N7HUPpV]HWHVHQµ (]]HO YpJHW pU D PiVRGLN MHJ\]N|Q\Y $] DSUy EHW,V OiEMHJ\]HW V]HULQW GU 0HVVHQJHU PiVQDS PDMGQHP KiURPyUiV EL]DOPDV EHV]pOJHWpVW IRO\WDWRWW %HUWRQQDO PDMG D] ([SHGtFLy 7DQiFViKR] IRUGXOW pV LVPpWHOWHQ N|YHWHOWHKRJ\LQGtWVDQDNNXWDWiVRNDWDSLOyWDYDOORPiVD DODSMiQ .LMHOHQWHWWH KRJ\ HPHOOHWW V]yOQDN %HUWRQ ~MDEE N|]OpVHL DPHO\HNHW D]RQEDQ FVDN D 7DQiFV NHGYH] KDWiUR]DWD HVHWpQ KR]KDW Q\LOYiQRVViJUD $ 7DQiFV ² V]HPpO\ V]HULQW 6KDQQDKDQ 7LPROLV pV 7UDKLHU ² HOXWDVtWRWWDDMDYDVODWRWpVH]]HOD]J\HWOH]iUWiN $ N|Q\Y YpJO HJ\ OHYpOUpV]OHW IpQ\NpSPiVRODWiW N|]OL 0HVVHQJHU tUiVDL N|]|WW WDOiOWiN KDOiOD XWiQ $OLJ 

KDQHP IRJDOPD]YiQ\ YROW 5DYLQW]HU QHP WXGWD PHJiO ODStWDQLHOPHQWHDOHYpOpVPLO\HQHUHGPpQQ\HO

   EGOHWHVNRUOiWROWViJDPLDWW²NH]GGLNDV]|YHJ² )pOWLN D WHNLQWpO\NHW D]pUW GREWD YLVV]D N|YHWHOpVHPHW D 7DQiFV NRQNUpWDQ 6KDQQDKDQ pV 7LPROLV PHUW 7UDKLHU V]DYD QHP V]iPtW  0RVW N|]YHWOHQO D] ,QWp]HWKH] IRUGXORNGH7HLVWXGRGKRJ\H]IDOUDKiQ\WERUVy6DMQRV N|W D V]DYDP pV QHP tUKDWRP PHJ QHNHG DPLW %HUWRQWyO KDOORWWDP $ 7DQiFV SHUV]H D]pUW G|QW|WW tJ\ PHUW D V]HQ]iFLyVIHOIHGH]pVVHOHJ\ªODLNXV© iOOW HODNLQHN QLQFV VHPPLIpOH WXGRPiQ\RV FtPH 3HGLJ VRN NXWDWy PHJLULJ\HOKHWQp HQQHN D SLOyWiQDN D OpOHNMHOHQOpWpW pV PHJILJ\HONpSHVVpJpW .pUOHN NOGG HO QHNHP SRV WDIRUGXOWiYDODN|YHWNH] DGDWRNDW )HFKQHUpOHWW|UWpQHWHJ\HUPHNNRUipLV  DPLW FVDN WXGV] D FVDOiGMiUyO pV D FVDOiGL J\HLUO  iOOtWyODJNLVJ\HUHNHPDUDGWiUYiQ UpV]OHWHVOHtUiVDUUyODKHO\UODKROQHYHONHGHWW 6]HUHWQpP PpJ HOPRQGDQL QHNHG PL D YpOHPpQ\HP D] HJpV]UO 0LQW WXGRG QHP VRNNDO )HFKQHU pV &DUXFFL LQGXOiVDXWiQIROWNHOHWNH]HWWDY|U|VQDSFHQWUXPiEDQpV HQQHN UpV]HFVNHVXJiU]iVD D 6]DWHOORLG DGDWDL V]HULQW D GpOL IpOWHNpQ YROW D OHJHUVHEE D PL %i]LVXQN N|UQ\pNpQ H]pUW QHP YROW UiGLy|VV]HN|WWHWpV  9DODPHQQ\L NXWD WyFVRSRUW N|]O )HFKQHU pV &DUXFFL WiYRORGRWW OHJPHV] V]HEEUHD%i]LVWyO ,O\HQ V,U, pV WDUWyV N|G|W WHOMHV V]pOFVHQG PHOOHWW D NDWDV]WUyIDQDSMiLJHJ\V]HUVHPpV]OHOWQNDERO\JyQ $PLW %HUWRQ OiWRWW V]HULQWHP UpV]H YROW D] ªHPEHUDN FLyQDN© PHO\EH D] D UDJDFVRV V]|UQ\HWHJ EHOHYiJRWW $ %HUWRQ iOWDO pV]OHOW NpS]GPpQ\HN LJD]L IRUUiVD )HFKQHU YROW ² D]  DJ\D NHUOW YDODPL V]iPXQNUD IHOIRJKDWDWODQ ªSV]LFKLNDL ERQFROiV© DOi DPHO\HW HJ\HV Q\LOYiQ D OHJ PDUDGDQGyEE  HPOpNNpSHN NtVpUOHWL ~MUDWHUHPWpVH UH NRQVWUXNFLyMDN|YHWHWW 7XGRP KRJ\ H] IDQWDV]WLNXVDQ KDQJ]LN WXGRP KRJ\ WpYHGKHWHN (]pUW NpUHP D VHJtWVpJHGHW PRVW D] $ODULNRQ YDJ\RNLWWYiURPDYiODV]W 

0iUDOLJOiWWDPDEHW,NHW~J\UiPV|WpWHGHWWDN|Q\Y PHJV]UNOW D NH]HPEHQ D VRURN|VV]HIRO\WDN GH D IpOLJ UHV ROGDO D]W PXWDWWD KRJ\ ~J\LV YpJpKH] pUWHP D W|UWpQHWQHN DPHO\HW VDMiW pOPpQ\HLPUH JRQGROYD QD J\RQ YDOyV]tQ,QHN YpOWHP .LQp]WHP D] DEODNRQ $ V| WpWOLOD pJEROW SHUHPpQ PpJ L]]RWW QpKiQ\ IHOK PLQW D NLDOYy V]pQSDUi]V $ V|WpWVpJEH EXUNROW yFHiQEyO PiU VHPPL VHP OiWV]RWW +DONDQ VXVWRURJWDN D SDStUV]DODJRN D V]HOO]Q\tOiV N|UO $] HQ\KpQ y]RQLOODW~ IHOKHYOW OHYHJ PHJVHPUH]]HQW1pPDFVHQGERUXOWD]ÉOORPiVUD $]RQW,QGWHPHOKDWiUR]iVXQNEDQ²KRJ\LWWPDUDGXQN ² VHPPL KVLHV QLQFV 5pJHQ OH]iUXOW D KHURLNXV ,UNDODQGRN KDOiOW PHJYHW YiOODONR]iVRN NRUD QHPLJHQ IRUGXOQDN HO RO\DQ V]|UQ\, EDOHVHWHN VHP DPLO\HQ )HFKQHUp YROW D] yFHiQ HOV iOGR]DWip 6]LQWH QHP LV pUGHNHOW PiU PLO\HQ ÅYHQGpJHµ YDQ 6QDXWQDN YDJ\ 6DU WRULXVQDN (J\ LG P~OYD JRQGROWDP DEEDKDJ\MXN D V]pJ\HQNH]pVW pV QHP NHUOMN W|EEp HJ\PiVW +D QHP WXGXQN PHJV]DEDGXOQL D ÅYHQGpJHNWOµ DNNRU PHJV]RN MXN NHW pV HJ\WW pOQN YHON KD SHGLJ 7HUHPWMN IRUGtWDMiWpNV]DEiO\RNRQDNNRUDONDOPD]NRGXQND]~MDN KR]LVEiUHJ\GDUDELJPDMGU~JNDSiOXQNpVGK|QJQN VW HJ\LNQN YDJ\ PiVLNXQN WDOiQ |QJ\LONRV OHV] GH YpJOD]~MiOODSRWLVHJ\HQV~O\ED]|NNHQ2WWKRQRVI|OGL V|WpWVpJ V]iOOW D V]REiUD PiU FVDN D PRVGy pV D WN|U IHKpUIROWMDOiWV]RWW)HOiOOWDPWDSRJDWy]YDPHJWDOiOWDPD YDWWDFVRPyW D SROFRQ QHGYHV YDWWiYDO OHPRVWDP D] DU FRPDW pV D] iJ\UD KHYHUHGWHP 9DODKRO I|O|WWHP KRO HUVHEEHQKROJ\HQJpEEHQ]L]HJWHNDSDStUV]DODJRNPLQW D] pML ERJDUDN 0iU D] DEODNRW VHP OiWWDP IHNHWH YROW PLQGHQ FVDN HJ\ QHP WXGRP KRQQDQ HUHG YpNRQ\ND IpQ\FVtNIJJ|WWHOWWHPWDOiQD IDORQWDOiQPHVV]H NLQW DVHPPLEHQ(V]HPEHMXWRWWPHQQ\LUHPHJUpPOWHPWHJ QDS HVWH D VRODULVL pJ UHV WHNLQWHWpWO pV PDMGQHP HOPRVRO\RGWDP 0iU QHP IpOWHP WOH 6HPPLWO VHP IpOWHP )|OHPHOWHP D FVXNOyPDW ]|OGHQ YLOiJtWRWW UDMWD D IRV]IRURV V]iPNRV]RU~ (J\ yUD P~OYD NHO IHO D NpN QDS eOYH]WHP D V|WpWVpJHW My PpO\HNHW OpOHJH]WHP JRQG WDODQXOpVIHOV]DEDGXOWDQ 

.pVEE IRUGXOWDP HJ\HW pV Q\RPQL NH]GHWW D IDU ]VHEHPEHQ ODSXOy PDJQy 3HUV]H *LEDULDQ  EHV]pO D V]DODJRQ1HPWiPDV]WRPIHOQHPKDOOJDWRPNLDWLWNDLW (] D] HJ\HWOHQ DPLW WHKHWHN pUWH (OK~]WDP D PDJQyW KRJ\D]iJ\DOiUHMWVHP6XUUDQyQHV]W|WWH PHJ D IOH PHW+DONDQQ\LNRUGXOWD]DMWy ² .ULV   " ² KDQJ]RWW VXWWRJYD IRMWRWWDQ ² ,WW YDJ\ .ULV"2O\DQV|WpWYDQ ²1HPEDM²PRQGWDP²1HIpOM*\HUHLGH

7DQiFVNR]iV

+DQ\DWW IHNGWHP VHPPLUH VHP JRQGROWDP IHMH D YiOODPRQ $ V]RED V|WpWVpJH PHJERO\GXOW /pSWHNHW KDO ORWWDP(OW,QWHND IDODN 9DODPL UiP QHKH]HGHWW pV QW W|QQWW IHO D] pJLJ ÉWMiUWD PLQGHQ SRUFLNiPDW N|UO IRJRWW DQpONO KRJ\ KR]]iP pUW YROQD PHJGHUPHGWHP D V|WpWEHQ pUH]WHP DPLQW iWOiWV]y pOHV W|PHJH IRMWRJDWQL NH]G 1DJ\RQ PHVV]LUO KDOORWWDP D V]tYYHUpVHPHW (JpV] ILJ\HOPHPPHO PDUDGpN HUPPHO IHV]OWHQ YiUWDP D] DJyQLiW1HPM|WW&VDN]VXJRURGWDPpVDOiWKDWDWODQpJ D OiWKDWDWODQ KRUL]RQW D IHOKWOHQ FVLOODJWDODQ Q\~OyV VHPPL HJ\UH WiJXOW GDJDGW pV pQ OHWWHP D N|]pSSRQWMD LJ\HNH]WHP EHOHI~UQL PDJDP D IHNYKHO\HPEH GH PiU QHP YROW DODWWDP VHPPL D V|WpWVpJ UHVHQ WiWRQJRWW gN|OEHV]RUtWRWWNp]]HOIHGH]WHPD]DUFRPDW0iUQHPYROW DUFRP 8MMDLP D VHPPLEH PDUNROWDN NLiOWDQL Y|OWHQL DNDUWDP   .pNHVV]UNH V]RED $ E~WRURN SROFRN IDOV]|JOHWHN V]pOHV WRPSD YRQiVRNNDO RGDYHWYH QLQFV VDMiW V]tQN FVDN N|UYRQDOXN )pQ\HV J\|QJ\IHKpU FVHQG D] DEODN P|J|WW 7HVWHP FVXSD YHUtWpN ROGDOW SLOODQWRN HQJHP Qp] ²(O]VLEEDGWDNDURG" ²0LYDQ   " )|OHPHOL D IHMpW 6]HPH XJ\DQRO\DQ V]tQ, PLQW D V]RED V]UNpQ YLOiJtW D IHNHWH SLOOiN DODWW (OEE VXWWR JiVDPHOHJpWpU]HPFVDND]XWiQpUWHPPHJPLWPRQG ²1HP,OOHWYHLJHQ 9iOOiUD WHV]HP D NH]HP &VDNXJ\DQ HO]VLEEDGW 0iVLN NDURPPDOODVVDQPDJDPKR]K~]RP ²5RVV]DWiOPRGWiO ²ÉOPRGWDP",JHQSHUV]HeVWHQHPDOXGWiO" ²1HPLVWXGRP$]WKLV]HPQHP1HPYDJ\RNiOPRV 'HWHFVDNDOXGM0LpUWQp]HORO\DQIXUFViQ" %HKXQ\WDP D V]HPHP eUH]WHP V]DSRUD HJ\HQOHWHV V]tYYHUpVpWDPDJDPODVV~EEV]tYGRERJiVDI|O|WW.HOOpN² JRQGROWDP 'H QHP FVRGiONR]WDP VHPPLQ PpJ D]RQ 

VHP PLO\HQ HJ\NHGY, YDJ\RN 7~OMXWRWWDP PiU D UpP OHWHQ pV D NpWVpJEHHVpVHQ 2O\DQ PHVV]LUH pUWHP PLQW PpJ VHQNL $MNDP D Q\DNiW V~UROWD OHMMHEE VLNORWWDP D NDJ\OyVLPDNLVPpO\HGpVEHD]LQDNN|]|WW ,WW LV ONWHWHWW D]pU )HON|Q\|N|OWHP $UDQ\Oy QDSIHONHOWH OiJ\ SLUNDGDW KHO\HWWYLOODPRVNpNW,]WHQJHU|QW|WWHHODKRUL]RQWRWHOV VXJDUD V]LQWH EHUREEDQW D V]REiED OiQJED ERUXOW PLQ GHQ V]LYiUYiQ\RV YLVV]IpQ\HN WiQFROWDN D WNU|Q D NL OLQFVHNHQ D QLNNHOFV|YHNHQ D IpQ\|]|Q ~J\ URQWRWW QHNL PLQGHQ IHOOHWQHN PLQWKD V]DEDGXOQL DNDUQD PLQWKD V]pWDNDUQiYHWQLDV],NKHO\LVpJHW0iUQHPEtUWDPEHOH Qp]QL 0HJIRUGXOWDP +DUH\ V]HPERJDUD |VV]HV],NOW 1DJ\V]UNHV]LYiUYiQ\KiUW\iNUDJ\RJWDNUiP ²0iUUHJJHOYDQ"²NpUGH]WH IiW\RORVKDQJRQ0LQWKD iORPpVYDOyViJN|]|WWV]pGHOHJQH ²,WWPLQGLJLO\HQU|YLGD]pMV]DNDV]tYHP ²eVPL" ²0LYDQYHOQN" ²6RNiPDUDGXQNLWW" 1HYHWQHP NHOOHWW 'H FVDN YDODPL UHNHGW KRUNDQWiV V]DNDGWNLEHOOHP²QHPLJHQKDVRQOtWRWWDQHYHWpVKH] ²$WWyOIpOHNHOpJVRNi1LQFVKR]]iNHGYHG" 6]HPUHEEHQpVQpONOILJ\HOPHVHQQp]HWW9DJ\NDFVLQ WRWW"1HPWXGRP0DJiUDK~]WDDWDNDUyWNDUMiQHOW,QW DNLVSLURVKiURPV]|J ²0LpUWQp]HOtJ\ " ²0HUWV]pSYDJ\ (OPRVRO\RGRWW 'H H] FVDN XGYDULDVViJ YROW YiODV] D EyNUD ²,JD]iQ"0HUW~J\Qp]HOPLQWKD  PLQWKD   ²1R" ²0LQWKDNHUHVQpOYDODPLW ²1HEXWiVNRGM ² 5RVV]XO PRQGRP LQNiEE PLQWKD D]W JRQGROQiG KRJ\YDODPLEDMRPYDQYDJ\HOWLWNRORNYDODPLWHOWWHG ²8J\DQPiU ² +D HQQ\LUH WDJDGRG DNNRU EL]WRV 1R PLQGHJ\ *\LONRVNpNKVpJiUDGWEHDNLJ\~OWDEODNRQ.H]HPHWD V]HPHP HOp WDUWYD N|UOQp]WHP KRO D QDSV]HPYHJ $] DV]WDORQ KHYHUW )|OWpUGHOWHP pUWH $ V]HPYHJHQ iW



>NpS@

>UHV@

PHJSLOODQWRWWDP +DUH\W D WN|UEHQ 9iUW YDODPLW 0LNRU ~MUDPHOOpKHYHUHGWHPUiPPRVRO\JRWW ²eQQHPNDSRN" 1HPpUWHWWHPPHJU|JW|Q ²-DV]HPYHJHW" )HOWiSiV]NRGWDP pV NHUHVJpOQL NH]GWHP D ILyNEDQ PHJD]DEODNHOWWLNLVDV]WDORQ7DOiOWDPNpWV]HPYHJHW PLQGHJ\LN W~O QDJ\ YROW 2GDDGWDP QHNL 0LQG D NHWWW IHOSUyEiOWD/HHVWHND]RUUDN|]HSpLJ &VLNRURJYD HUHV]NHGQL NH]GHWW D] DEODNSiQFpO $] ÉO ORPiV HOE~MW PLQW WHNQVEpND D Ki]iED (J\ SHUF DODWW pMV]DNDOHWW7DSRJDWy]YDOHYHWWHP+DUH\V]HPYHJpWpVD PDJDPpYDOHJ\WWD]iJ\DOiGREWDP ²0RVWPLWFVLQiOXQN"²NpUGH]WH ²$PLWpMMHOV]RNiVDOV]XQN ².ULV ²7HVVpN ²1HWHJ\HNUiG~MERURJDWiVW" ²1HPNHOO1HPNHOO  V]tYHP 0DJDP VHP pUWHWWHP PLpUW V]yOtWRP tJ\ GH HJ\V]HU FVDN IHOp Q\~OWDP D V|WpWEHQ iW|OHOWHP NDUFV~ YiOOiW V DPLQW PHJUHPHJHWW HOKLWWHP KRJ\  D] ÉPEiU QHP LV WXGRP+LUWHOHQ~J\pUH]WHPpQFVDSRPEHW pV QHP HQJHPPHUW HJ\V]HU,HQFVDN|QPDJD $]WiQ HOHOQ\RPRWW D] iORP PLQGLJ J|UFV|V UiQGXOiV VDO ULDGWDP IHO KHYHV V]tYGRERJiVRP FVDN ODVVDQ FVLOODSRGRWW KDOiORVDQ NLPHUOYH V]RUtWRWWDP PDJDPKR] +DUH\W  SHGLJ QDJ\RQ yYDWRVDQ PHJWDSLQWRWWD D] DUFRPDW D KRPORNRPDW KRJ\ QLQFVH Oi]DP +DUH\ YROW ,JD]LEEPiUQHPLVOHKHWHWWYROQD (WWO D JRQGRODWWyO YDODPL PHJYiOWR]RWW EHQQHP 1HP KDUFROWDPWRYiEE6]LQWHD]RQQDOHODOXGWDP .|QQ\, pULQWpVUH pEUHGWHP -yOHV K,Y|VVpJ D KRP ORNRPRQ $UFRPDW QHGYHV YDODPL ERUtWRWWD ODVVDQ OHYiOW UyODpV+DUH\DUFDMHOHQWPHJI|O|WWHP.LFVDYDUWDDJp]W SRUFHOiQ WiOED FVXUJDWWD EHOOH D I|O|VOHJHV IRO\DGpNRW 0HOOHWWH HJ\ YHJEHQ ERURJDWyYt] pJpVL VHEHNUH 5iP PRVRO\JRWW ² -y UHJJHOW PRUPRWD ² GY|]|OW pV YLVV]DWHWWH D ERURJDWiVW²)iM" ²1HP



0HJPR]JDWWDP D] DUFL]PDLPDW &VDNXJ\DQ PHJV],QW D IiMGDORP +DUH\ D] iJ\ V]pOpQ OW IHKpUQDUDQFVViUJD FVtNRV IpUIL IUGN|SHQ\EHQ IHNHWH KDMD V]pWWHUOW D N|SHQ\ JDOOpUMiQ .|Q\|NLJ IHOJ\UN]|WW KRJ\ NpQ\HOPHVHQ GROJR]KDVVRQ 5HWWHQWHQ pKHV YROWDP OHJDOiEE K~V] yUiMD HJ\ IDODWRW VHP HWWHP 0LNRU +DUH\ EHIHMH]WH VHEHLP iSROJDWiViW I|ONHOWHP +LUWHOHQ NpW HJ\PiV PHOOHWW KHYHU WHOMHVHQ HJ\IRUPD SLURV JRPERV IHKpUUXKiUDHVHWWDSLOODQWiVRPD]HOVDPHO\LNQHNpQ KDVtWRWWDP IHO D NLYiJiViW KRJ\ OHYHWKHVVH pV D PiVLN DPLEHQ WHJQDS M|WW (]W PiU  IHMWHWWH V]pW ROOyYDO $]W PRQGWDEL]WRVDQHOURPORWWDYLOOiP]iU (]DNpWHJ\IRUPDUXKDYROWDOHJLV]RQ\~EEPLQGDEEyO DPLW DGGLJ iWpOWHP +DUH\ D J\yJ\V]HUV]HNUpQ\EHQ UHQ GH]NHGHWW eV]UHYpWOHQO KiWDW IRUGtWRWWDP QHNL pV YpUHVUHKDUDSWDPD]|NO|P$NpWUXKiUDPHUHGYH²YDJ\ WDOiQ LQNiEE XJ\DQD] NpW SpOGiQ\EDQ ² D] DMWy IHOp NH]GWHP KiWUiOQL $ FVDSEyO My KDQJRVDQ ]XKRJRWW D Yt] /HQ\RPWDP D NLOLQFVHW NLVXUUDQWDP D IRO\RVyUD pV yYDWRVDQ EHFVXNWDP D] DMWyW .LV],UG|WW D Yt]FVRERJiV pV D] YHJFV|U|PS|OpV PDMG KLUWHOHQ PHJV]DNDGW $ IRO\RVy WpJODODS DODN~ PHQQ\H]HWOiPSiL HOPRVyGy IpQ\IROWRW YHWHWWHN D] DMWyUD gVV]HV]RUtWRWW IRJJDO YiUDNR]WDP NH]HP D NLOLQFVHQ EiU QHP LV UHPpOWHP KRJ\WDUWDQLEtURP(J\HUVUiQGtWiVPDMGQHPNLWpSWH D NH]HPEO GH D] DMWy QHP Q\tOW NL FVDN PHJUHPHJHWW pV LMHV]WHQ UHFVHJQLURSRJQL NH]GHWW 0HJG|EEHQYH HQJHGWHP HO D NLOLQFVHW KiWUDK~]yGWDP D] DMWyYDO KLKHWHWOHQ GROJRN W|UWpQWHN VLPD P,DQ\DJ ODSMD EHKRUSDGWPLQWKDDV]REDIHOpQ\RPQiN$]HJ\UHMREEDQ PHJIHV]O DMWyNHUHWUO DSUiQNpQW SDWWRJ]DQL NH]GHWW D ]RPiQF HOEXNNDQW P|JOH D FVXSDV] DFpO 0RVW pUWHWWHP PHJ DKHO\HWW KRJ\ NLIHOp Q\RPQi D IRO\RVyUD Q\tOy DMWyW PDJD IHOp K~]]D pV ~J\ DNDUMD NLQ\LWQL $ IHKpU P,DQ\DJ WiEOiQ HOJ|UEOW D IpQ\IROW PLQW HJ\ KRPRU~ WN|UEHQ yULiVL UHFFVHQpV ² D YpJVNLJ IHV]tWHWW W|P|UDMWyV]iUQ\PHJUHSHGW$NLOLQFVLVNLV]DNDGWEHOOH pV D V]REiED ]XKDQW $ Q\tOiVEDQ U|JW|Q PHJMHOHQW NpW YpUHV Np] pV SLURV Q\RPRNDW KDJ\YD D IHKpU ODNNRQ WRYiEE UiQJDWWD D] DMWyV]iUQ\DW ² D P,DQ\DJ ODS NHWWp W|UWIHUGpQOyJRWWDVDURNYDVDNRQpVHJ\PHUHYHONpNOW 

DUF~ IHKpUQDUDQFVViUJD WHUHPWpV ]RNRJYD D Q\DNDPED YHWHWWHPDJiW +D PHJ QHP EpQtW D OiWYiQ\ D]W KLV]HP PHQHNOQL SUyEiOWDP YROQD +DUH\ J|UFV|VHQ ]LKiOW IHMpW D YiOODP KR] YHUWH NyFRV KDMD FVDN ~J\ U|SN|G|WW $PLQW iW|OHO WHP pUH]WHP KRJ\ D I|OGUH FV~V]LN %HFLSHOWHP D V]REiED iWQ\RPDNRGYD D W|U|WW DMWyQ V D] iJ\UD IHNWHWWHP .|UPH EHKDVDGR]RWW pV FVXSD YpU YROW 0LNRU PHJIRUGtWRWWD D NH]pW OiWWDP KRJ\ D WHQ\HUH PHU VHE $UFiUDSLOODQWRWWDPUHVV]HPHDVHPPLEHUpYHGW ²+DUH\ 5HNHGWK|UJpVYROWDYiODV] 8MMDPDW D V]HPpKH] N|]HOtWHWWHP /HFVXNyGRWW $ J\yJ\V]HUV]HNUpQ\ IHOp VLHWWHP 1HV] KDOODWV]RWW D] iJ\ IHOO0HJIRUGXOWDP(J\HQHVHQOWpVUpPOWHQQp]WHYp UHVNH]pW ².ULV²Q\|V]|UJ|WW²pQ  pQ  PLW|UWpQWYHOHP" ² )|OVpUWHWWHG D NH]HG PLNRU NLW|UWHG D] DMWyW ² IH OHOWHP V]iUD]RQ $MNDP IXUFViQ HO]VLEEDGW NO|Q|VHQ D] DOVyPLQWKDKDQJ\iNPiV]NiOQiQDNUDMWD5iKDUDSWDP +DUH\ KRVV]DQ EiPXOWD D VDUNiEyO NLIRUGXOW I,UpV]HV V]pO,UHW|UWP,DQ\DJWiEOiWD]WiQPHJLQWUiPQp]HWW5H PHJHWWD]iOODOiWWDPPHNNRUDHUIHV]tWpVpEHNHUOKRJ\ OHJ\,UMHIpOHOPpW *p]ODSRNDW YiJWDP HOYHWWHP D V]HNUpQ\EO D VHENHQFV|W pV YLVV]DPHQWHP D] iJ\KR] +LUWHOHQ OHKXOORWW D NDURP HOHMWHWWHP PLQGHQW D ]VHODWLQV]HU, SpSSHO WHOL YHJWpJHO\ PHJUHSHGW OH VHP KDMROWDP pUWH 0iUQHPYROWUiV]NVpJ )|OHPHOWHPDNH]pW.|UPHLWPpJD]DOYDGWYpUNHVNHQ\ FVtNMD V]HJpO\H]WH GH D ]~]yGiVRN HOW,QWHN WHQ\HUpW SHGLJDN|UQ\H]HWQpOpOpQNHEEUy]VDV]tQ,]VHQJHEUER UtWRWWD(]LVV]LQWHV]HPOiWRPiVWKDOYiQ\RGRWW /HOWHP PHJVLPRJDWWDP D] DUFiW LJ\HNH]WHP UiPR VRO\RJQLGHQHPQDJ\RQVLNHUOW ²0LpUWFVLQiOWDGH]W+DUH\" ²eQQHP(]W  pQ" 6]HPpYHOD]DMWyIHOpLQWHWW ²7HKiW1HPHPOpNV]HO" 

² 1HP ,OOHWYH   OiWWDP KRJ\ QHP YDJ\ LWW ERU]DV] WyDQPHJLMHGWHPpV   ²eV" ².HUHVQLNH]GWHOHND]WKLWWHPWDOiQDIUGV]REiEDQ YDJ\   &VDN PRVW YHWWHP pV]UH KRJ\ D V]HNUpQ\W HOWROWD D IUGV]REDEHMiUDWDHOO ²eVD]WiQ" ²$]DMWyKR]V]DODGWDP ²eV" ²1HPHPOpNV]HP3HGLJW|UWpQWYDODPLXJ\H" ²'HPL" ²1HPWXGRP ²+iWPLUHHPOpNV]HO"0LWFVLQiOWiOD]WiQ" ²,WWOWHPD]iJ\RQ ²eVDKRJ\EHKR]WDODNDUUDQHPHPOpNV]HO" +DER]RWW6]iMDOHJ|UEOWDUFiQIHV]OWLJ\HNH]HW ²9DODPLUpPOLN7DOiQ1HPLVWXGRP /HWHWWH OiEiW D SDGOyUD pV IHOiOOW 2GDPHQW D W|U|WW DMWyKR] ².ULV 0|Jp OpSWHP iWIRJWDP D YiOOiW 5HPHJHWW +LUWHOHQ IHOpPIRUGXOWpVDV]HPHPHWNHUHVWH ².ULV²VXWWRJWD².ULV ²1\XJRGMPHJ ².ULVKiWKD  .ULVQHPYDJ\RNpQHSLOHSV]LiV"  pV D] HSLOHSV]LD 8UDPLVWHQ 0DMGQHP HOQHYHWWHP PDJDP ² 'HKRJ\ V]tYHP &VDN H] D]DMWyWXGRG LWW LO\HQ   LO\HQHND]DMWyN   $PLNRU NLPHQWQN D V]REiEyO pSSHQ I|OHPHONHGHWW D FVLNRUJyDEODNSiQFpOpVHOpQNWiUXOWD]yFHiQEDVOO\HG QDSNRURQJ $ IRO\RVy PiVLN YpJpQ OHY NLV NRQ\KiED WDUWRWWDP (J\WW Ki]LDVV]RQ\NRGWXQN VRUUD Q\LWRJDWYD D V]HNUpQ\HNHW pV K,WJpSHNHW 0LQGMiUW pV]UHYHWWHP KRJ\ +DUH\QHPYDODPLMHOHVV]DNiFVQDOLJpUWHJ\pEKH]PLQW D NRQ]HUYGRER]RN IHOQ\LWiViKR] ² DNiUFVDN pQ )HOIDOWDP NpW GRER] WDUWDOPiW pV PHJLWWDP My SiU FVpV]H NiYpW +DUH\ LV HYHWW GH ~J\ DKRJ\ D J\HUHNHN V]RNWDN QpKD PLNRU D 

IHOQWWHNNHGYppUWHV]QHN²QHPLVNpQ\V]HUHGHWWHQFVDN JpSLHVHQpVILJ\HOPHWOHQO $]WiQ iWPHQWQN D UiGLyVV]RED PHOOHWWL NLV P,WEH YROW HJ\ WHUYHP .LMHOHQWHWWHP KRJ\ PLQGHQHVHWUH PHJ DNDURP YL]VJiOQL OHIHNWHWWHP D KiWUDKDMWRWW WiPOiM~ ND URVV]pNEH IHFVNHQGW pV W,W YHWWHP HO D VWHULOL]iOyEyO 6]LQWH JRQGRONRGiV QpONO WXGWDP PLW KRO WDOiORN ~J\ EHOpQN VXO\NROWiN D] ÉOORPiV I|OGL HG]PRGHOOMpEHQ (J\ FVHSS YpUW YHWWHP D] XMMiEyO YHJODSRFVNiNUD NHQWHP NLV]iUtWRWWDPNHW D]H[KDXV]WRUEDQ PDMG QDJ\YiNXXP EDQH]VWLRQRNDWJ]|OWHPUiMXN (]DMy]DQWHYpNHQ\VpJPHJQ\XJWDWRWW+DUH\DSiUQiV YL]VJiOyV]pNHQ KHYHUYH V]HPOpOG|WW D JpSHNNHO ]V~IROW P,WKHO\LVpJEHQ $ Ki]LWHOHIRQ FV|UUHQW EHOH D FVHQGEH )|OYHWWHP D NDJ\OyW ² .HOYLQ ² MHOHQWNH]WHP .|]EHQ +DUH\W ILJ\HOWHP HJ\ LGHMH DSDWLNXVQDN OiWV]RWW PLQWKD NLPHUtWHWWpN YROQD D] HOP~OWyUiNpOPpQ\HL ² $ P,WEHQ YDJ\" 1R YpJUH ² NLiOWRWW HJ\ PHJ N|QQ\HEEOWKDQJDYRQDOW~OVyYpJpQ 6QDXWYROW)OHPKH]V]RUtWRWWDPDNDJ\OyWpVYiUWDP ²Å9HQGpJHGµYDQPL" ²$] ²eVGROJR]RO" ²,JHQ ²(J\NLVNLYL]VJiOiV" ²0LpUW"(J\SDUWLVDNNRWDNDUWiOMDYDVROQL" ² 1H KO\pVNHGM .HOYLQ 6DUWRULXV DNDU WDOiONR]QL YHOHG$]D]YHOQN ²0LDIHQH²OHSGWHPPHJ²eVD   ²HOKDUDSWDPD V]yW²(J\HGOYDQ"²NpUGH]WHPD]WiQ ² 1HP 5RVV]XO IHMH]WHP NL PDJDP %HV]pOQL DNDU YHOQN 0LQG D KiUPDQ EHNDSFVROMXN D YL]RIRQW GH D NpSHUQ\WOHWDNDUMXN ²eUWHPeVPLpUWQHPKtYRWWIHO "6]pJ\HOOLPDJiW" ²2O\DVPL²PRURJWD6QDXW²6]yYDO" ² $] LGSRQWUD JRQGROV]" 0RQGMXN HJ\ yUD P~OYD 0HJIHOHO" ²0HJ 

$WHQ\pUQ\LNpSHUQ\QFVDND]DUFiWOiWWDP(J\KRV] V]~SHUFLJiUJXVWHNLQWHWWHODV]HPHPEHQp]HWWDNDJ\Oy EDQKDONDQ]PP|J|WWD]iUDP 9pJUHPHJV]yODOWNLVVpEL]RQ\WDODQXO ²+RJ\YDJ\" ²7,UKHWHQeVWH" ² $]W KLV]HP HJ\ IRNNDO URVV]DEEXO PLQW WH 0RQGG FVDNPLWV]yOQiOKD   ² %H DNDUV] Qp]QL KR]]iP" ² WDOiOWDP NL D IRO\WDWiVW 9iOODPRQ iW +DUH\ IHOp OHVWHP )HMH KiWUDKDQ\DWORWW D SiUQiQ NHUHV]WEH YHWHWW OiEEDO IHNGW pV XQDOPiEDQ JpSLHVHQ KLQWi]WDWWD D NDUID OiQFiQ FVQJ H]VW JR O\yFVNiW ² +DJ\G D]W KDOORG" +DJ\G D]W WH ² KDUVDQW D IOHPEH 6QDXW KDQJMD 0RVW D SURILOMiW PXWDWWD D NpSHU Q\ 7|EEHW QHP KDOORWWDP PHUW EHIRJWD D NDJ\OyW GH OiWWDPKRJ\PR]RJDV]iMD ² 0RVW QHP PHKHWHN 7DOiQ PDMG NpVEE 6]yYDO HJ\ yUD P~OYD ² KDGDUWD YpJO pV D NpSHUQ\ NLDOXGW 9LV] V]DDNDV]WRWWDPDKDOOJDWyW ².LYROWD]"²NpUGH]WHN|]|PE|VHQ+DUH\ ²(J\WDJ6QDXW.LEHUQHWLNXV1HPLVPHUHG ²6RNiWDUWPpJ" ²0LpUWXQDWNR]RO"²%HWHWWHPD]HOV SUHSDUiWXPRWD QHXWULQRPLNURV]NyS ND]HWWiMiED pV VRUUD EHQ\RPWDP D V]tQHVNDSFVROyJRPERNDW7RPSiQIHOE~JWDND]HUWHUHN ²6RNV]yUDNR]iVLWWQLQFVpV KDV]HUpQ\ WiUVDViJRP PDO EH QHP pUHG DNNRU UpJHQ URVV] ² IRO\WDWWDP V]yUD NR]RWWDQ HJ\UH ULWNiEEDQ S|WW\HQWYH D V]DYDNDW PLN|] EHQ NpW Np]]HO PDJDP IHOp K~]WDP D QDJ\ IHNHWH IHMHW DPHO\EHQ D PLNURV]NyS NHWWV V]HPOHQFVpMH IpQ\OHWW pV V]HPHPHW D SXKD JXPLNDJ\OyNKR] LOOHV]WHWWHP +DUH\ PRQGRWW YDODPLW GH QHP ILJ\HOWHP RGD (]VW|VHQ FVLOORJy KDWDOPDV VLYDWDJRW OiWWDP IHOOUO PHUHGHN V]|JEHQ /DSRV V]LNODNRURQJRN IHNGWHN UDMWD HOPRVyGy N|GIHOKEH EXUNROYD PLQWKD W|UHGH]QpQHN pV PiOODQiQDN (]HN D Y|U|V YpUVHMWHNeOHVUH iOOtWRWWDP D NpSHW pV D V]HPNDJ\OyNKR] WDSDGYD HJ\UH PpO\HEEHQ EH~V]WDPD]H]VW|VIpQ\, OiWyPH]EH.|]EHQEDONp]]HO D] iOOYiQ\ V]DEiO\R]yNDUMiW IRUJDWWDP pV DPLNRU HJ\ YiQGRUNNpQW PDJiQ\R 

VDQ KHYHU YpUVHMW D IHNHWH YRQDODN PHWV]pVSRQWMiED NH UOW I|OHUVtWHWWHP D QDJ\tWiVW $] REMHNWtY OiWV]yODJ Ui HUHV]NHGHWW D]HOWRU]XOW EHKRUSDGW Y|U|VYpUVHMWUH DPHO\ PRVW PiU V]LNODNUiWHUQHN OiWV]RWW J\,U, DODN~ SHUHPH KDVDGpNDLEDQ pOHV IHNHWH iUQ\pNRNNDO $ NULVWiO\RV H]VWLRQEHYRQDWWyO WVNpV SHUHP PRVW NL~V]RWW D PLNURV]NyS OiWyPH]HMpEO )HOW,QW D IpOLJ PHJROYDGW |VV]HNXQNRURGRWW IHKpUMHOiQFRN KRPiO\RV N|UYRQDOD PLQWKDRSDOL]iOyYt]HQiWQp]QpP0LNRUDIHKpUMHURQFVRN HJ\LN FVRPyMD D IHNHWH NHUHV]W DOi NHUOW ODVVDQ WRYiEE Q\RPWDP D QDJ\tWyNDUW HJ\UH WRYiEE PRVW PiU DNiUPHO\LN SLOODQDWEDQ PHJMHOHQKHW D] DQ\DJ PpO\pEH YH]HW XWD]iV YpJiOORPiVD PiU HJ\HWOHQ PROHNXOD HOODSRVRGRWW iUQ\pND W|OWL EH D] HJpV] NpSHW PRVW HON|G|V|GLN 'H QHP W|UWpQW VHPPL $] DWRPRN UH]J IHOKFVNpLW NHOOHWWYROQDOiWQRPDPRO\DQKLGHJOHOVNRFVRQ\DFVHSSH NHWGHQ\RPXNVHPYROWDOiWyPH] PDNXOiWODQH]VWMpQ hWN|]pVLJQ\RPWDPDNDUW$JpSKDUDJRVDQIHOEJ|WWGH PRVW VHP OiWWDP VHPPLW 6]DJJDWRWW VtSROiV MHOH]WH D NpV]OpN W~OWHUKHOpVpW 0pJ HJ\ SLOODQWiVW YHWHWWHP D] H]VWVLYDWDJUDpVNLNDSFVROWDPD]iUDPRW +DUH\UD Qp]WHP eSSHQ iVtWRWW GH J\HVHQ PRVRO\ED IRMWRWWD ²1RPL~MViJ"²pUGHNOG|WW ² 0LQGHQ D OHJQDJ\REE UHQGEHQ ² PRQGWDP ² $]W KLV]HP  HJpV]VpJHVHEEPiUQHPLVOHKHWQpO 1p]WHP Qp]WHP pV PHJLQW HONH]GG|WW D] D IXUFVD ]VLEEDGiVD]DOVy DMNDPEDQ +RJ\ LV YDQH]" 0LW OiWWDP pQ" (] D OiWV]yODJ RO\ J\|QJpG pV W|UpNHQ\ ² YDOyMiEDQ HOSXV]WtWKDWDWODQ²WHVWYpJV VRURQDVHPPLEOpSOIHO" gN|OOHO UiYiJWDP D PLNURV]NyS ]|P|N KHQJHUpUH 7DOiQ KLEiV" 7DOiQ QHP HVLN HJ\EH D] HUWHUHN IyNXV]D   " 1HP 7XGWDP KRJ\ D NpV]OpN My 9pJLJPHQWHP PLQGHQ OpSFVIRNRQ VHMWHN IHKpUMHNRQJORPHUiWXP PROHNXOD PLQG SRQWRVDQ XJ\DQRO\DQ YROW PLQW D VRN H]HU SUHSD UiWXPRQDPLWPiUOiWWDP'HD]XWROVyOpSpVDVHPPLEH YH]HWHWW 9pQiVYpUWYHWWHPpVDPpUKHQJHUEHW|OW|WWHP6]pW DGDJROWDP KR]]iOiWWDP D] HOHP]pVKH] 7RYiEE WDUWRWW PLQWJRQGROWDPNLFVLWNLM|WWHPDJ\DNRUODWEyO$UHDNFLyN UHQGEHQYROWDN0LQGHJ\LN+DFVDN   

7|PpQ\ VDYDW FVHSSHQWHWWHP D NLV SLURV J\|QJ\UH 3H]VHJQLNH]GHWWHOV]UNOWSLV]NRVKDEOHSWHHO%RPOiV 'HQDWXUiFLy 7RYiEE WRYiEE .pPFVpUW Q\~OWDP $PL NRU YLVV]DIRUGXOWDP D YpUFV|SSHPKH] D YpNRQ\ YHJFV PDMGQHPNLHVHWWDNH]HPEO $ V]HQQ\HV WDMWpN DODWW D NpPFV IHQHNpQ ~MUD V|WpW SLURVUpWHJNHOHWNH]HWW$VDYpJHWWHYpUUHJHQHUiOyGLN"(] NpSWHOHQVpJ(]OHKHWHWOHQ ² .ULV ² PLQWKD QDJ\RQ PHVV]LUO V]yOtWDQiQDN ² .ULVWHOHIRQ ²0L"-DN|V]|Q|P $WHOHIRQPiUUpJyWDFVHQJHWWGHFVDNPRVW KDOORWWDP PHJ ².HOYLQ²V]yOWDPEHOH ²6QDXWÉWNDSFVROWDPDYRQDODWPRVWPLQGDKiUPDQ KDOOMXNHJ\PiVW ² hGY|]O|P .HOYLQ GRNWRU ² Q\HNHUJHWW 6DUWRULXV PDJDV RUUKDQJMD 2O\DQ V]tQH]HWH YROW PLQWKD WXODMGRQRVD YHV]pO\HVHQ GOHGH] SyGLXPRQ iOOQD J\DQDNRGYDpEHUHQGHOiWV]DWUDKLJJDGWNpSSHO ² 7LV]WHOHWHP GRNWRU ~U ² IHOHOWHP 1HYHWpV FVLNODQ GR]WD D WRUNRPDW GH NpWVpJHLP WiPDGWDN KRJ\ HOpJJp WLV]WiEDQ YDJ\RNH MyNHGYHP RNDLYDO 9ROWDNpSSHQ NLQ DNDURN QHYHWQL" .H]HPEHQ V]RURQJDWWDP YDODPLW D NpPFV YROW D YpUUHO 0HJUi]WDP 0iU PHJDOYDGW 7DOiQ FVDN D V]HPHP NiSUi]RWW D] HOEE" 7DOiQ URVV]XO OiWWDP" ²%L]RQ\RVNpUGpVHNHWV]HUHWQpNIHOYHWQLDNROOpJDXUDN HOWW D    DDD   D IDQWRPRNNDO NDSFVRODWEDQ ² KDOORWWDP LV 6DUWRULXVW PHJ QHP LV 0LQWKD HUV]DNNDO W|UQH EH D WXGDWRPED 9pGHNH]WHP D KDQJMD HOOHQ 0pJ HJ\UHD]DOYDGWYpUWEiPXOWDPDNpPFV IHQHNpQ ² 1HYH]]N NHW ) NpS]GPpQ\HNQHN ² MDYDVROWD J\RUVDQ6QDXW ².LW,Q $NpSHUQ\ N|]HSpQIJJOHJHVYRQDOK~]yGRWWMHOH]YH KRJ\ D YpWHO NpW FVDWRUQiQ IRO\LN ² NpWROGDOW D EHV]pON DUFiW NHOOHQH OiWQRP 'H D] YHJ V|WpW YROW FVDN D SHUHPpQ IHKpUO NHVNHQ\ FVtN PXWDWWD KRJ\ D NpV]OpN P,N|GLNiPDNpSHUQ\NHWYDODPLYHOOHWDNDUWiN ²0LQGHJ\LNQNYpJ]HWWNO|QIpOHYL]VJiODWRNDW  ² 6QDXW RUUKDQJMiEDQ PHJLQW IHOiJDVNRGRWW D] yYDWRVViJ 

(J\ SHUF V]QHW ² (OV]|U WDOiQ |VV]HYHWKHWQpQN HUHG PpQ\HLQNHW D]WiQHOPRQGDQiP PLUH MXWRWWDPD PDJDP UpV]pUO   .H]GMHWDOiQ|Q.HOYLQGRNWRU   ² eQ" ² IRUW\DQWDP IHO +LUWHOHQ PDJDPRQ pUH]WHP +DUH\ WHNLQWHWpW $ NpPFV|YHW D] DV]WDOUD WHWWHP EHJX UXOWD]iOOYiQ\RNDOi pQ SHGLJ IHOOWHPD PDJDV KiURP OiE~ V]pNUH PHO\HW D OiEDPPDO K~]WDP RGD (OV SLOOD QDWEDQ YDODPL NLIRJiVW DNDUWDP NHUHVQL GH D]WiQ PD JDPQDNLVYiUDWODQXOUiNH]GWHP ²1RMygVV]HOWDWDQXOyN|U"1RMyeQXJ\DQV]LQWH VHPPLW VHP FVLQiOWDP GH D]pUW EHV]pOKHWHN (J\ V]|YHWWDQL SUHSDUiWXP pV QpKiQ\ UHDNFLy 0LNURUHDNFLy $]DEHQ\RPiVRPKRJ\   (GGLJ D SLOODQDWLJ IRJDOPDP VHP YROW PLW PRQGMDN +LUWHOHQPHJQ\tOWEHQQHPYDODPL]VLOLS ² 0LQGHQ QRUPiOLV GH H] FVDN iOFi]iV &VDN iODUF %L]RQ\RV pUWHOHPEHQ V]XSHUNySLD PiVRODW PHO\ W|NpOH WHVHEE D] HUHGHWLQpO 0HUW DKRO D] HPEHUQpO D V]HPFVpV VpJ D VWUXNWXUiOLV RV]WKDWyViJ KDWiUiKR] pUQN LWW WR YiEEYH]HW D] ~W   PHUW H]HN V]XEDWRPiOLV DQ\DJEyO YDQQDN ² (J\ SLOODQDW (J\ SLOODQDW +RJ\ pUWL H]W" ² iOOtWRWW PHJ 6DUWRULXV 6QDXW QHP V]yOW VHPPLW 9DJ\ WDOiQ WOH HUHGH]D]LKiOiVDKDOOJDWyEDQ"+DUH\UiPQp]HWW&VDN PRVW pEUHGWHP WXGDWiUD KRJ\ D] XWROVy V]DYDNDW V]LQWH NLDEiOWDP L]JDOPDPEDQ gVV]HV]HGWHP PDJDP HO UHGOWHP D NpQ\HOPHWOHQ V]pNHQ OHKXQ\WDP D V]HPHP +RJ\LVPDJ\DUi]]DP" ² $ PL WHVWQN YpJV V]HUNH]HWL HOHPHL D] DWRPRN )HOWpWHOH]HPKRJ\D]) NpS]GPpQ\HND N|]|QVpJHV DWR PRNQiONLVHEEHJ\VpJHNEOpSOQHNIHO6RNNDONLVHEEHN EO ² 0H]RQRNEyO   " ² NpUGH]WH 6DUWRULXV (J\iOWDOiQ QHPYROWPHJOHSGYH ² 1HP QHP PH]RQRNEyO   $ PH]RQRNDW pV]OHOWHP YROQD$JpSIHOERQWyNpSHVVpJHPiUPLQWH]pLWWOHQQQi ODP Wt] D PtQXV] KXV]DGLNRQ $QJVWU|P 'H VHPPL VHP OiWV]LN EHQQH PLQGYpJLJ VHPPL 7HKiW QHP PH]RQRN 7DOiQLQNiEEQHXWULQRN ² +RJ\DQ NpS]HOL H]W" +LV]HQ D QHXWULQRV]HUNH]HWHN QHPVWDELODN  



²1HPWXGRP1HPYDJ\RNIL]LNXV7DOiQYDODPLHUWpU VWDELOL]iOMD NHW (KKH] QHP pUWHN 6]yYDO KD ~J\ YDQ DKRJ\ PRQGRP D] pStWHOHP D] DWRPQiO Wt]H]HUV]HUWH NLVHEEUpV]HFVNH1RPRVWPHQMQNWRYiEE+DDIHKpU MHPROHNXOiN pV D VHMWHN N|]YHWOHQO H]HNEO D ÅPLNURDWR PRNEyOµ pSOQpQHN IHO DNNRU H]]HO DUiQ\RVDQ NLVHEEQHN NHOOHQHOHQQLN$YpUVHMWHNQHNLVD]HQ]LPHNQHNPLQG HQQHN'HQHPtJ\YDQ(EEON|YHWNH]LNKRJ\DIHKpUMH D VHMW pV D VHMWPDJ FVDN iODUF $ YDOyViJRV VWUXNW~UD PHO\ D YHQGpJ pOHWP,N|GpVpW EL]WRVtWMD YDODKRO PpO\HEEHQUHMOLN ² .HOYLQ ² KRUNDQW IHO 6QDXW ,MHGWHQ KDJ\WDP DEED Å9HQGpJHWµ PRQGWDP" ,JHQ GH +DUH\ QHP KDOORWWD eV NO|QEHQ VHP pUWHQp .LEiPXO D] DEODNRQ iOOiW NH]pEH WiPDV]WYD WLV]WD NLV SURILOMD NDUPD]VLQY|U|V pJUH UDM]ROyGLN $ KDOOJDWyEDQ FV|QG 6HPPL QHV] FVDN NpW HPEHUWiYROLOpOHJ]pVH ²9DQEHQQHYDODPL²GQQ\|JWHYpJUH6QDXW ² ,JHQ OHKHWVpJHV ² WHWWH KR]]i 6DUWRULXV ² FVDN D] D E|NNHQ KRJ\ D] yFHiQ QHP H]HNEO D .HOYLQ iOWDO IHOWpWHOH]HWW UpV]HFVNpNEO pSO IHO KDQHP N|]|QVpJHVHN EO ²7DOiQPiVPLO\HQHNHWLVWXGV]LQWHWL]iOQL²MHJ\H]WHP PHJ+LUWHOHQN|]|Q\IRJRWWHO(]DEHV]pOJHWpVPpJFVDN QHPLVQHYHWVpJHV(J\V]HU,HQIHOHVOHJHV ²(]PHJPDJ\DUi]QiDUHQGNtYOLHOOHQiOOyNpSHVVpJHW² PRUPRJWD6QDXW²eVDJ\RUVUHJHQHUiOyGiVW$]LVOHKHW KRJ\ D] HQHUJLDIRUUiV RGDOHQW YDQ KLV]HQ pOHOHPUH VLQFV V]NVpJN   ² 6]yWNpUHN ² MHOHQWNH]HWW6DUWRULXV1DJ\RQ XWiOWDP /HJDOiEEQHHVQHNLIRO\WRQDV]HUHSpEO  ² $] LQGtWpNRN NpUGpVpW V]HUHWQpP IHOYHWQL $] ) NpS]GPpQ\HN PHJMHOHQpVpQHN PRWLYiFLyMiUD JRQGRORN ÌJ\ RV]WDQiP IHO D NpUGpVW PLN D] ) NpS]GPpQ\HN" 1HP V]HPpO\HN pV QHP LV PHJKDWiUR]RWW V]HPpO\HN PiVRODWDL KDQHP DQ\DJL YHWOHWHL DQQDN DPLW D PL DJ\XQND]LOOHW V]HPpO\HNUHYRQDWNR]yODJWDUWDOPD] 7DOiOy PHJKDWiUR]iVD IHOYLOODQ\R]RWW $NiUPLO\HQ HOOHQV]HQYHVH]D6DUWRULXVEXWiQDNQHPEXWD ² ,JD]D YDQ ² V]yOWDP N|]EH ² eV H] D]W LV PHJ PDJ\DUi]]D KRJ\ PLpUW pSSHQ LO\HQ V]H   LO\HQ NpS 

]GPpQ\HN MHOHQWHN PHJ pV QHP PiVRN $ OHJPDUDGDQ GyEEOHJHOV]LJHWHOWHEEHPOpNNpSHN PDWHULDOL]iOyGWDNEiU WHUPpV]HWHVHQ HJ\LN HPOpNNpS VLQFV N|UOIDOD]YD pV D ÅPiVROiVµ N|]EHQ tJ\ RGDNHYHUHGWHN   RGDNHYHUHGKHW WHN PiV HPOpNIRV]OiQ\RN LV DPLN YpOHWOHQO D N|]HOEHQ YROWDNHQQHNWXODMGRQtWKDWyKRJ\DYHQGpJRO\DVPLUOLV WXG DPLUO D] HUHGHWL V]HPpO\ D PLQWiMD QHP WXGKDWRWW   ² .HOYLQ ² ILJ\HOPH]WHWHWW ~MUD 6QDXW &VRGiONR]WDP KRJ\ FVDN  LGHJHVNHGLN PLNRU HOMiU D V]iP 6DUWRULXVW ~J\ OiWV]LN QHP ]DYDUMD $]W MHOHQWHQp H] KRJ\ D]  ÅYHQGpJHµ ODVV~EE pV]MiUiV~ PLQW D 6QDXWp" (J\ SLOODQDWUD IHOUpPOHWW HOWWHP KROPL IpONHJ\HOP, W|USH D WXGyV6DUWRULXVGRNWRUPHOOHWW   ² ÔJ\ YDQ H]W LV WDSDV]WDOWXN ² IHOHOWH pSSHQ ² 0iUPRVW DPL D] ) NpS]GPpQ\HN PHJMHOHQpVpQHN LQ GtWpNDLW LOOHWL   $ OHJHOV V]LQWH WHUPpV]HWHV JRQGRODW D]KRJ\NtVpUOHWHWYpJH]QHNUDMWXQN&VDNKRJ\H]HOpJ   VLOiQ\ NtVpUOHW YROQD 0LQGHQ NtVpUOHWQpO D] HUHGPpQ\HN EOIOHJSHGLJDKLEiNEyOWDQXOXQNpVMDYtWRWWIRUPiEDQ LVPpWHOMNPHJ  (UUOSHGLJV]yVLQFV8J\DQD]RND]) NpS]GPpQ\HN MHOHQQHN PHJ ~MUD   PLQGHQ NRUUHNFLy QpONO   QLQFVHQHN SpOGiXO ~MDEE HV]N|]|NNHO IHOIHJ\ YHUH]YHD]  HOWiYROtWiVXNDWFpO]yOpSpVHNHOOHQ   ² (J\V]yYDO KLiQ\]LN D FVHOHNYpVOiQF NRUULJiOy YLV] V]DFVDWROiVVDO DKRJ\DQ 6QDXW GRNWRU IRJDOPD]Qi ² MH J\H]WHPPHJ²eVPLN|YHWNH]LNHEEO " ² &VDN DQQ\L KRJ\ NtVpUOHWQHN H]   NRQWiUPXQND YROQDDPLHOpJJpYDOyV]tQ,WOHQ$]yFHiQ  SUHFt](UUH PXWDW D] ) NpS]GPpQ\HN NpWUpWHJ, NRQVWUXNFLyMD LV %L]RQ\RVKDWiULJ~J\YLVHONHGQHNPLQWHJ\LJD]L  PLQW D]LJD]L   %HOH]DYDURGRWW ²0LQWD]HUHGHWLHN²VHJtWHWWHNLJ\RUVDQ6QDXW ²,JHQD]HUHGHWLHN'HPLNRUDKHO\]HWPHJKDODGMDHJ\ iWODJRV  L]p  HUHGHWLQRUPiOLVNpSHVVpJHLWDNNRUD] ) NpS]GPpQ\QpO YDODPL ÅWXGDWNLNDSFVROiVµ OpS IHO pV N|]YHWOHQO MHOHQWNH]LN HJ\ PiVLN QHP HPEHUL WHYp NHQ\VpJ   ²,JD]²PRQGWDP²GHtJ\FVDND   DNpS]GPpQ\HN YLVHONHGpVpW UHJLV]WUiOMXN pV QHP MXWXQN WRYiEE eV tJ\ PHGG YLWD 

² (]W QHP iOOtWDQiP LO\HQ KDWiUR]RWWDQ ² WLOWDNR]RWW 6DUWRULXV+LUWHOHQUiM|WWHPPLWQHPEtURNEHQQHRO\DQ NDFLIiQWRVDQ V]yQRNRO PLQW HJ\ LQWp]HWL OpVHQ ÔJ\ OiWV]LNQHPWXGPiVNpSS ² ,WW D] HJ\pQLVpJ NpUGpVpUH NHOO JRQGROQXQN (] D IRJDORP WHOMHVHQ LVPHUHWOHQ D] yFHiQ V]iPiUD 0LQGHQ EL]RQQ\DO tJ\ YDQ eQ ~J\ OiWRP NROOpJD XUDN KRJ\ D NtVpUOHWUpV]QNUH  |||  OHJNtQRVDEEDNDURPPRQ GDQL OHJIiMGDOPDVDEE DVSHNWXViUyO HJ\iOWDOiQ QLQFV WX GRPiVDPLYHONtYOHVLNIHOIRJyNpSHVVpJHKDWiUDLQ ² 6]yYDO D]W JRQGROMD KRJ\ H] QHP V]iQGpNRV   " ² NpUGH]WHP .LFVLW PHJK|NNHQWHWW D JRQGRODW GH QpPL W|SUHQJpVXWiQEHOiWWDPKRJ\QHPLVRO\DQNpSWHOHQ ² $]W 1HP KLV]HP KRJ\ LWW EiUPLIpOH DOMDVViJ URVV] LQGXODW HOHYHQEH G|IpVL V]iQGpN MiWV]DQD V]HUHSHW   DKRJ\6QDXWNROOpJDYpOL ² eQ QHP WXODMGRQtWRN QHNL pU]HOPHNHW ² V]yODOW PHJ YpJUH 6QDXW LV ² GH KiW PLYHO PDJ\DUi]RG KRJ\ IRO\WRQ YLVV]DWpUQHN" ²0HJQ\RPRWWHJ\JRPERWpVPRVWIRURJDJpSPLQWD JUDPRIRQOHPH]²HOPpVNHGWHPD]]DODWLWNRVV]iQGpNNDO KRJ\HJ\NLFVLWIHOERVV]DQWRP6DUWRULXVW ² 1H WpUMQN HO D WiUJ\WyO NROOpJD XUDN ² XWDVtWRWW UHQGUH RUUKDQJMiQ D GRNWRU ² 0pJ QHP IHMH]WHP EH D PRQGDQLYDOyPDW 5HQGHV N|UOPpQ\HN N|]|WW NRUDLQDN WDUWDQiPKRJ\DNiUHO]HWHVEHV]iPROyWLVWDUWVDNPXQ NiP iOOiViUyO GH D NO|QOHJHV KHO\]HWUH YDOy WHNLQWHWWHO NLYpWHOWWHV]HN+DMORNDUUDDQp]HWUHEiUHJ\HOUHLQNiEE VHMWpVQHNQHYH]QpPKRJ\.HOYLQNROOpJD IHOWHYpVH KHO\HV $QHXWULQRV]HUNH]HWKLSRWp]LVpUHJRQGRORN  ,O\HQUHQG V]HUHNHW FVDN HOPpOHWEHQ LVPHUQN QHP WXGWXN KRJ\ VWDELOL]iOKDWyN(QQHNNDSFViQIHOPHUOEL]RQ\RV OHKHW VpJ DPHQQ\LEHQ D UHQGV]HUW VWDELOL]iOy HUWpU PHJVHP PLVtWpVH   0iU HJ\ LGHMH pV]UHYHWWHP KRJ\ 6DUWRULXV ROGDOiQ ODVVDQ OHFV~V]LN D NpSHUQ\W WDNDUy V|WpW KROPL IHOO YLOiJRV UpV WiPDGW pV YDODPL Uy]VDV]tQ, UpPOHWW EHQQH DPLODVVDQPR]RJ$V|WpWOHSHOPRVWKLUWHOHQOHKXOORWW ²0HQMRQQpW0HQMRQQpW²6DUWRULXVNpWVpJEHHVHWW ULNiFVROiVD PDMG V]pWYHWHWWH D NDJ\OyW $ KLUWHOHQ NLYLOiJRVRGRWWNpSHUQ\QDGRNWRUYDODPLYHOELUNy]y 

NH]HLN|]|WW²EXJJ\RVODERUDWyULXPLN|Q\|NYpGWYLVHOW² DUDQ\ViUJDWiUJ\FVLOODQWPHJYDODPLQDJ\NRURQJD]WiQ V|WpW OHWW PpJ PLHOWW UiM|WWHP KRJ\ D] D] DUDQ\ViUJD NRURQJHJ\V]DOPDNDODS   ²6QDXW"²V]yODOWDPPHJPpO\OpOHJ]HWHWYpYH ² ,JHQ .HOYLQ ² IHOHOW D NLEHUQHWLNXV IiUDGW KDQJMD 0RVWpUH]WHPFVDNPHQQ\LUHURNRQV]HQYHV1HPLVDNDU WDPPiUWXGQLNLYDQYHOH²0iUDHOpJLJD]" ²,JD]7HQp]]PDMGEHKR]]iPKDWXGV]LWWOHQWYDJ\ DV]REiPEDQMy"²I,]WHPKR]]iJ\RUVDQQHKRJ\OHWHJ\H DNDJ\OyW ²-y²PRQGWD²'HQHPWXGRPPLNRU eVH]]HOEHLVIHMH]G|WWDPXQNDpUWHNH]OHW

$PRQVWUXPRN

eMMHO YLOiJRVViJUD pEUHGWHP )HON|Q\|N|OWHP PiVLN NH]HPHW D V]HPHP HOp WDUWRWWDP +DUH\ D] iJ\ YpJpEHQ NXSRUJRWW OHSHGEH EXUNROy]YD NyFRVDQ DUFiED KXOOy KDMMDO5HPHJHWWDYiOOD+DQJWDODQXOVtUW ²+DUH\ 0pJMREEDQ|VV]HNXFRURGRWW ²0LEDMRGYDQ"   +DUH\   )HOOWHP D] iJ\RQ PpJ HJpV]HQ NiED YROWDP ODVVDQ RFV~GWDPIHOOLGpUFHViOPRPEyO$OiQ\UHV]NHWHWWÉW|OHO WHP(OWDV]tWRWWDN|Q\|NpYHO$UFiWHOUHMWHWWH ²'UiJiP ²+DJ\MiO ²'H+DUH\KiWPLEDM" )|OHPHOWH YRQDJOy QHGYHV DUFiW .|YpU J\HUHNHV N|QQ\FVHSSHN IRO\WDN YpJLJ UDMWD PHJFVLOODQWDN iOOD J|GU|FVNpMpEHQOHFV|S|JWHNDOHSHGUH ²1HPDNDUV]WHHQJHP ²+RJ\JRQGROKDWV]LO\HW" ²+DOORWWDP eUH]WHPKRJ\NH]GD]DUFRPPHUHYHGQL ²0LWKDOORWWiO"5RVV]XOpUWHWWHGpQFVDN   ²1HP1HP$]WPRQGWDGKRJ\QHPpQYDJ\RN+RJ\ PHQMHN HO eQ HO LV PHQQpN ,VWHQHP eQ HOPHQQpN GH KDQHPEtURN1HPWXGRPPLH]$NDUWDPpVQHPEtURN 2O\DQ  RO\DQKLWYiQ\YDJ\RN ².LFVLNpP .DURPED NDSWDP WHOMHV HUPEO PDJDPKR] V]RUtWRW WDP PLQGHQ V]pWKXOORWW FVyNROJDWWDP D NH]pW QHGYHV VyV XMMDLW HVNG|]WHP IRJDGNR]WDP HQJHV]WHOWHP KRJ\ FVDNXQGRN RVWRED iORPYROW/DVVDQOHFVLOODSRGRWW 0iU QHP VtUW 5iP IJJHV]WHWWH WiJUD Q\tOW DOYDMiUy V]HPpW .|Q\Q\HLIHOV]iUDGWDN(OIRUGXOW ² 1HP ² PRQGWD ² QH EHV]pOM tJ\ 1HP NHOO 7H PiU QHPYDJ\XJ\DQD]   ²eQ"²W|UWNLEHOOHPDNDUDWODQXO 

²,JHQ.ULV1HPDNDURGKRJ\YHOHGOHJ\HNeU]HPpQ PiU UpJHQ ÔJ\ WHWWHP PLQWKD QHP OiWQiP *RQGROWDP KiWKD FVDN NpS]HOG|P YDJ\ PL 'H QHP 7H   PiVNpSS YLVHONHGV] 1HP YHV]HO NRPRO\DQ ÉORP YROW D] LJD] GH UyODP iOPRGWiO $ QHYHPHW LV PRQGWDG eV XQ GRURGWiOWOHP0LpUW"0LpUW" (OpEHWpUGHOWHPiW|OHOWHP ².LFVLN|O\|N   ² 1HP DNDURP KRJ\ tJ\ EHV]pOM 1HP DNDURP pUWHG" eQQHPYDJ\RNN|O\|NeQ   )HO]RNRJRWW pV D] iJ\UD ERUXOW )|ONHOWHP $ V]HO O]Q\tOiVRN KDON ]~JiVVDO iUDV]WRWWiN D K,Y|V OHYHJW )i]WDP0DJDPUDNDSWDPDIUGN|SHQ\WOHOWHPD]iJ\ V]pOpUHpVPHJpULQWHWWHPDOiQ\YiOOiW ² ,GH ILJ\HOM +DUH\ 0RQGRN YDODPLW 0HJPRQGRP D] LJD]DW /DVVDQD NH]pUH WiPDV]NRGYD IHOOW /iWWDPD]WpU ONWHWpVpW Q\DNiQDN OiJ\ EUH DODWW 0HJLQW PHJPH UHYHGHWWD]DUFRPpVYDFRJWDPPLQWKDIDJ\RVV]pOI~MQD .pSWHOHQYROWDPJRQGRONR]QL ²$]LJD]DW"²NpUGH]WH²ÔJ\pOMQN" 1HP YiODV]ROWDP U|JW|Q PHUW HOV]RUXOW D WRUNRP (] YROWD PL UpJL YDUi]VLJpQN +D NLPRQGWXN HJ\LNQN VHP PHUW W|EEp KD]XGQL YDJ\ DNiU FVDN HOKDOOJDWQL YDODPLW (J\ LGEHQ W~O]RWW V]LQWHVpJJHO J\|W|UWN HJ\PiVW QDLYDQKLWWNKRJ\H]VHJtW ²ÔJ\pOMQN²IHOHOWHPUiNRPRO\DQ²+DUH\   9iUDNR]RWW ² 7H LV PHJYiOWR]WiO 0LQGDQQ\LDQ YiOWR]XQN 'H QHP H]W DNDUWDP PRQGDQL &VDNXJ\DQ ~J\ OiWV]LN KRJ\   EL]RQ\RV RNEyO DPLW HJ\LNQN VHP LVPHU SRQWRVDQ   QHP WXGV] HOKDJ\QL 9LV]RQW H] MyO YDQ tJ\ PHUW pQ VHP WXGQiODNWpJHG   ².ULV )HONDSWDPDOHSHGYHOHJ\WW.|QQ\i]WDWWDIHMHFVNpMpW YiOODPUD IHNWHWWH )HODOi KRUGR]WDP D V]REiEDQ pV ULQJDWWDP0HJVLPRJDWWDD]DUFRPDW ²1HP7HQHPYiOWR]WiOPHJ²V~JWDDIOHPEH²'H pQ9HOHPYDQYDODPL7DOiQH]" $ W|U|WW DMWyV]iUQ\ KHO\pQ WiWRQJy UHV IHNHWH QpJ\V]|JUHPHUHGWD]DMWyURQFVRNDWPpJD]HVWHOHYLWWHP 

D UDNWiUED ÔM DMWyODSRW NHOO KR]QRP ² JRQGROWDP 9LV] V]DOWHWWHP +DUH\W D] iJ\UD pV OHHUHV]WHWW Np]]HO PHJ iOOWDPHOWWH ²0RQGGDOV]ROWHHJ\iOWDOiQ"²NpUGH]WHP ²1HPWXGRP ²+RJ\KRJ\QHPWXGRG*RQGRONR]]GUiJiP ² $]W KLV]HP D] QHP RO\DQ LJD]L DOYiV 7DOiQ EHWHJ YDJ\RN&VDNIHNV]HPpVJRQGRONRGRPpVWXGRG   0HJUi]NyGRWW ² eV" ² NpUGH]WHP VXWWRJYD PHUW IpOWHP KRJ\ HOFVXNOLNDKDQJRP ²1DJ\RQIXUFVDJRQGRODWRND]RN1HPLVWXGRPKRJ\ MXWQDNHV]HPEH ²3pOGiXO" 1\XJRGWQDN NHOO PDUDGQRP JRQGROWDP DNiUPLW KDO ORNIHONpV]OWHPDV]DYDLUDPLQWDEXQNyFVDSiVUD 7DQiFVWDODQXOUi]WDDIHMpW ²9DODPLYDQ  N|U|VN|UO   ²1HPpUWHP   ² 0LQWKD QHPFVDN EHQQHP YROQD KDQHP YDODKRJ\ WRYiEE LV QHP WXGRP PHJPDJ\DUi]QL (UUH QLQFVHQHN V]DYDN   ²5RVV]DNDWiOPRGWiO²W|WWHPHODGROJRWIHOOpOHJH]YH ² 0RVW V]pSHQ HOROWMXN D YLOODQ\W UHJJHOLJ QLQFV VHPPL JRQGXQN UHJJHO SHGLJ PDMG NHUHVQN ~MDEEDNDW KD NHGYQNOHV]KR]]i-y" $ NDSFVROy IHOp Q\~OW V|WpW OHWW YLVV]DIHNGWHP D NLK,OWiJ\EDpUH]WHPN|]HOHG OHKHOHWHPHOHJpW ÉW|OHOWHP ²6]RUtWVMREEDQ²V~JWDeVHJ\KRVV]~SHUFP~OYD ².ULV ²7HVVpN" ²6]HUHWOHN 2UGtWDQLWXGWDPYROQD 9|U|VKDMQDOYROW$]yULiVLQDSWiQ\pUDODFVRQ\DQiOOWD OiWKDWiU IHOHWW $ NV]|E|Q HJ\ OHYpO KHYHUW )|OWpSWHP D ERUtWpNRW +DUH\ D IUGV]REiEDQ YROW KDOORWWDP D G~GROJDWiViW 1pKD NLNXNNDQWRWW YL]HV KDMD D YiOOiUD WDSDGW²$]DEODNKR]OpSWHPpVROYDVQLNH]GWHP 

.HOYLQ 0HJDNDGWXQN 6DUWRULXV HUpO\HV OpSpVW DNDU WHQQL %t]LN EHQQH KRJ\ VLNHUO D QHXWULQRV]HUNH]HWHN GHVWDELOL]iOiVD .tVpUOHWHLKH] V]NVpJH OHQQH QpPL SOD] PiUD PLQW D] )HN DODSDQ\DJiUD $]W MDYDVROMD V]iOOM NL pV KR]] HJ\ WDUWiO\EDQ SOD]PiW 7pJ\ DKRJ\ MyQDN OiWRG GH pUWHVtWV PLW KDWiUR]WiO 1HNHP QLQFV YpOHPpQ\HP $]W KLV]HPPiUVHPPLPVLQFVHQ&VDND]pUWV]HUHWQpPPpJLV KD PHJWHQQpG KRJ\ NLPR]GXOMXQN D KROWSRQWUyO OHJDOiEE OiWV]yODJ 0iVNO|QEHQ FVDN D] PDUDG KiWUD KRJ\ LULJ\HOMN*W 3DWNiQ\ 8L 1H J\HUH EH D UiGLyVV]REiED (] D] HJ\ DPLW PHJWHKHWV]pUWHP,QNiEEWHOHIRQiOM

gVV]HV]RUXOW D V]tYHP HWWO D OHYpOWO 0pJ HJ\V]HU ILJ\HOPHVHQ YpJLJROYDVWDP PDMG HOWpSWHP pV GDUDEMDLW D OHIRO\yED GREWDP $]WiQ QHNLiOOWDP NH]HVOiEDVW NHUHVQL +DUH\QDN 0iU H] LV ERU]DOPDV YROW eSSHQ ~J\ PLQW DNNRU 'H  VHPPLUO VHP WXGRWW NO|QEHQ QHP |UOKH WHWW YROQD DQQ\LUD PLNRU PHJPRQGWDP KRJ\ HJ\ NLV NXWDWyXWDWWHUYH]HND]ÉOORPiVRQNtYOpVV]HUHWQpPKD YHOHP M|QQH 0HJUHJJHOL]WQN D WHDNRQ\KiEDQ +DUH\ PHJLQW FVDN SiU IDODWRW HYHWW  pV IHOPHQWQN D N|Q\Y WiUED ÉWDNDUWDPQp]QLDQHXWULQRWHUHNUOpVV]HUNH]HWHNUO V]yOy LURGDOPDW PLHOWW PHJWHQQpP DPLW 6DUWRULXV Nt YiQ 0pJ QHP WXGWDP KRJ\DQ NH]GHN KR]]i GH HOKD WiUR]WDP V]HPPHO WDUWRP D PXQNiMiW (V]HPEH MXWRWW KRJ\ D] D OHHQG QHXWULQRDQQLKLOiWRU PHJV]DEDGtWKDWQi 6QDXWRWpV 6DUWRULXVW pQ SHGLJ YDODKRONtYO YiUQpN +D UH\YDO SpOGiXO HJ\ UHSOJpSEHQ PtJ D] ÅDNFLyµ OH]DMOLN -y LGHLJ Q\DJJDWWDP D QDJ\ HOHNWURQLNXV NDWDOyJXVW GH NpUGpVHLPUH YDJ\ FpGXOiW GRERWW NL D ODNRQLNXV Å1HP V]HUHSHO D MHJ\]pNEHQµ IHOLUDWWDO YDJ\ D IL]LNDL V]DNPXQ NiN UHPpQ\WHOHQO V,U, G]VXQJHOpEH XWDVtWRWW 3HGLJ VHKRJ\ VHP YROW NHGYHP RWWKDJ\QL H]W D QDJ\ NHUHN KHO\LVpJHWPHO\QHN VLPD IDOiWYpJHVYpJLJ EHNRFNi]]iN D PLNURILOPHNNHO pV HOHNWURQLNXV IHOMHJ\]pVHNNHO W|P|WW ILyNRN$]ÉOORPiVNHOOVN|]HSpQOHYDEODNWDODQN|Q\Y



WiUDOHJHOV]LJHWHOWHEEKHO\D]HJpV]DFpONRURQJEDQ7DOiQ H]pUWpUH]WHPRO\DQMyOPDJDP LWW EiU IL]LNXVLDPEtFLyLP N~WED HVWHN )HODOi OyIUiOWDP D WiJDV WHUHPEHQ YpJO NLN|W|WWHP D PHQQ\H]HWLJ pU KDWDOPDV N|Q\Y V]HNUpQ\QpO 1HP DQQ\LUD IpQ\,]pVQHN V]iQWiN ² DQQDN NO|QEHQ LV NpWVpJHV OHWW YROQD ² LQNiEE WLV]WHOJpVQHN D 6RODULVNXWDWiV ~WW|UL HOWW $ SROFRNRQ VRUDNR]RWW PLQWHJ\ KDWV]i] N|WHWEHQ D WiUJ\ HJpV] NODVV]LNXV LUR GDOPD *LHVH PRQXPHQWiOLV QRKD PiU MDYDUpV]W HODYXOW Wt]N|WHWHV PRQRJUiILiMiWyO NH]GYH .LYHWWHP D *LHVH N|WHWHNHW V~O\XNWyO Q\RPEDQ OHKDQ\DWORWW D NDURP pV HJ\IRWHONDUIiMiUDWHOHSHGYHWDOOy]JDWQLNH]GWHPEHQQN +DUH\ LV WDOiOW PDJiQDN YDODPL N|Q\YHW ² YiOOD I|O|WW EHOHROYDVWDP 5pJL N|Q\Y PpJ D] HOV H[SHGtFLy V]HUpQ\ N|Q\YWiUiEyO WDOiQ pSSHQ *LHVH WXODMGRQD YROW YDODKD &VLOODJN|]L 6]DNiFVPHVWHU   1HP V]yOWDP VHPPLW OiWYDPLO\HQILJ\HOPHVHQWDQXOPiQ\R]]D DV]LJRU~ ,UKD My]iVLYLV]RQ\RNKR]DONDOPD]RWWUHFHSWHNHWYLVV]DIRUGXO WDP D] |OHPEHQ WDUWRWW WHNLQWpO\HV IyOLiQVKR] $ 6RODULV NXWDWiV Wt] pYH D 6RODULDQD VRUR]DW ,9;,,, N|WHWHNpQW MHOHQW PHJ D PRVWDQiEDQ NLDGRWW N|WHWHN PiU QpJ\ V]iPMHJ\,HN *LHVpEHQ QHP YROW VRN IDQWi]LD GH D] ~J\LV FVDN iUW HJ\6RODULVNXWDWyQDN7DOiQVHKROVHPRNR]HQQ\LEDMWD NpS]HOHU pV D J\RUV KLSRWp]LVJ\iUWiV DGRWWViJD (]HQ D ERO\JyQ YpJO LV PLQGHQ OHKHWVpJHV %iUPLO\HQ KLKH WHWOHQO KDQJ]LN QHP HJ\ OHtUiV D SOD]PD NpS]GPpQ\HL UO YDOyV]tQ,OHJ PLQG KLWHOHV FVDN pSSHQ HOOHQUL]KHWHW OHQ PLYHO D] yFHiQ ULWNiQ LVPpWOL PDJiW (]HN D PRQVWUXPRN HOV OiWiVUD IOHJ LGHJHQV]HU,VpJNNHO pV URSSDQW W|PHJNNHO G|EEHQWLN PHJ D V]HPOpOW  KD NLVHEE PpUHWEHQ MHOHQWNH]QpQHN YDODPL PRFViU IHOHWW DOLJKDQHP VLPiQ HON|Q\YHOQpN NHW PLQW D WHUPpV]HW ~MDEEYpOHWOHQV]HV]pO\pWD]HUNYDNMiWpNiQDNP,YpW$ N|]pSV]HU,VpJ pV D OiQJpV] HJ\DUiQW WDQiFVWDODQXO iOO D VRODULVLIRUPiN],U]DYDURVYiOWR]DWRVViJDHOWWHJ\LNVHP WXG PLKH] IRJQL D] pO yFHiQ WQHPpQ\HLYHO *LHVH HJ\LN VHP YROW ²  D SHGiQV UHQGV]HUH]N IDMWiMiKR] WDUWR]RWW DNLNQpOKLJJDGWNOV OHSOH]LD]HJpV]pOHWNHWIHOHPpV]W iGi] PXQNDGK|W $PtJ WHKHWWH PHJPDUDGW D OHtUiV PyGV]HUpQpO KD SHGLJ NLIRJ\RWW D V]DYDNEyO ~MDNDW ID 

UDJRWWOHOHPpQ\HLQHPPLQGLJV]HUHQFVpVHNQHPLVPLQ GLJLOOHQHNDOHtUWMHOHQVpJUHGHKiWYpJV VRURQVHPPLIpOH WHUPLQXV QHP DGMD YLVV]D D]W DPL D 6RODULVRQ W|UWpQLN *LHVH V]DYDL D ÅPDPPXWIDµ PHJ D ÅKRVV]DQ\µ D ÅJRPEDKHJ\µ D ÅPLPRLGµ D ÅV]LPPHWULiGµ pV D] ÅDV]LP PHWULiGµ D ÅEiEHOµ PHJ D ÅOHQJHWHJµ IXUD FVLQiOPiQ\RN GH PpJLVFVDN DGQDN YDODPL NpSHW D 6RODULVUyO DQQDN LV DNLFVXSiQpOHWWHOHQIpQ\NpSHNHQpVJ\DWUDILOPHNHQOiWWD 3HUV]H PpJ H] D] DJJiO\RV UHQGV]HUH] LV HOYHWHWWH RO\NRU DVXO\NRW)RO\WRQKLSRWp]LVHNHWJ\iUWD]HPEHUDNNRULV KD yYDNRGLN WOH VW PpJ DNNRU LV KD QHP WXG UyOD *LHVH D ÅKRVV]DQ\Wµ DODSIRUPiQDN YpOWH VRNV]RURV Pp UHW, IHOWRUQ\RVXOy I|OGL GDJiO\KXOOiPRNKR] KDVRQOtWRWWD VWD]HOV NLDGiVWDQ~ViJDV]HULQWHUHGHWLOHJpSSHQVpJJHO ÅGDJiO\QDNµ NHUHV]WHOWH QHYHWQpQN H]HQ D JHRFHQWUL] PXVRQ KD D GHUpN WXGyV WDQiFVWDODQViJD pUWKHW QHP YROQD +LV]HQ H]HN D NpS]GPpQ\HN ² KD PiU I|OGL KDVRQODWRW NHUHVQN ² QDJ\REE PpUHW,HN D &RORUDGR *UDQG &DQ\RQMiQiO DQ\DJXN SHGLJ D IHOV]tQHQ NRFVRQ\iVKDERV H] D KDE JLJiV]L PiOOpNRQ\ I]pUHNNp YDJ\ yULiV V]HP, FVLSNpYp GHUPHG VW HJ\HV NXWDWyN ÅFVRQWYi]V]HU, NLQ|YpVWµ LV OiWWDN  PpO\HEEHQ YLV]RQW HJ\UH UXJDQ\RVDEEi YiOLN RO\DQQi PLQW D PHJIHV]OW L]RP Wt]K~V] PpWHU PpO\VpJEHQ PiU V]LNOiQiO NHPpQ\HEE GH UXJDOPDVViJiW PHJU]L .pWROGDOW IDO PDJDVRGLN ViUNiQ\EUV]HU, IHV]HV KiUW\D ERUtWMD HEEH NDSDV]NRGQDN D]RN D EL]RQ\RV ÅFVRQWYi]V]HU,VpJHNµ  D NpW IDO N|]|WW Q\~OLN HO W|EE NLORPpWHU KRVV]~ViJEDQ D WXODMGRQNpSSHQL ÅKRV]V]DQ\µ OiWV]yODJ |QiOOy NpS]GPpQ\PLQWYDODPLLUGDWODQyULiVNtJ\yDPHO\HJpV] KHJ\HNHW ]DEiOW IHO pV PRVW QpPiQ HPpV]WL NHW RO\NRU ODVV~ UHPHJ PR]JiVED OHQGtWYH KDOV]HU,HQ ODStWRWW WHVWpW 'H D ÅKRVV]DQ\µ FVDN IHQWUO LO\HQ UHSOJpSUO +D N|]HOUO Qp]LN~J\KRJ\D ÅNDQ\RQµ NpW IDOD W|EE V]i] PpWHU PDJDVDQ WRUQ\RVXO D JpS I|Op D ÅNtJ\yWHVWµ FVXSD V]pGOHWHV NDYDUJiV DPHGGLJ D V]HP HOOiW PLQWKD EHOOUO IHV]HJHWQp YDODPL D] yULiV KHQJHUW (OV]|U FVDN |UYpQ\OHQL OiWV]LN D VtNRV V]UNpV]|OG PDVV]D NLWUHPOpVHLFVLOORJYDYHULNYLVV]DDQDSIpQ\WGHPLNRUD JpS HJpV]HQ D IHOV]tQ I|Op V]iOO D ÅV]XUGRNµ NpW SDUWMD DPHO\HNN|]|WWDÅKRVV]DQ\µK~]yGLNLO\HQNRUKHJ\YRQX ODWQDN OiWV]LN YDODPL JHROyJLDL W|UpV PHQWpQ  pV]UHYHV] 

V]N KRJ\ D PR]JiV VRNNDO ERQ\ROXOWDEE ,WWRWW NRQ FHQWULNXV NHULQJpV ILJ\HOKHW PHJ V|WpWHEE V]tQ, iUDP ODWRN NHUHV]WH]LN HJ\PiVW D NOV ÅN|SHQ\µ RO\NRU WN U|] IHOOHWWp YiOLN YLVV]DYHUL D] pJ pV D IHOKN NpSpW PDMG iJ\~G|UJpVV]HU, UREDMMDO V]pWUHSHV]WLN D Ji]]DO HOHJ\ IpOIRO\pNRQ\ DQ\DJ NLW|UpVHL /DVVDQ PHJpUWMN KRJ\LWW|VV]SRQWRVXOQDND]RND]HUNDPHO\HND]pJQHN PHUHG ORPKiQ NULVWiO\RVRGy NRFVRQ\iV KHJ\IDODNDW IHQQWDUWMiN GH EiUPLO\HQ Q\LOYiQYDOy H] D V]HPQHN D NXWDWy QHP YHKHWL LO\HQ HJ\V]HU,HQ WXGRPiVXO +iQ\ pYHQiWIRO\WD]iGi]YLWDKRJ\PLLVW|UWpQLNYROWDNpSSHQ D ÅKRVV]DQ\RNEDQµ DPHO\HN PLOOLyV]iP EDUi]GiOMiN D] pO yFHiQ URSSDQW WpUVpJHLW $ V]|UQ\HWHJ V]HUYHLQHN YpOWpN NHW P,N|GpVNHW KRO DQ\DJFVHUpQHN PDJ\DUi]WiN KRO OpOHJ]pVQHN KRO WiSDQ\DJV]iOOtWiVQDN ² FVDNDSRURVN|Q\YWiUDNDPHJPRQGKDWyLPLPLQGHQQHN PpJ 9pJO PLQGHJ\LN KLSRWp]LVW VLNHUOW PHJG|QWHQL IiUDGViJRV VW QHPHJ\V]HU YHV]pO\HV NtVpUOHWHN H]UHL iUiQ eV H] PpJ FVDN D ÅKRVV]DQ\µ D OHJHJ\V]HU,EE pV OHJWDUWyVDEE IRUPD KLV]HQ KHWHNLJ IHQQPDUDG DPL VRODULVLYLV]RQ\ODWEDQPDWX]ViOHPLNRU   %RQ\ROXOWDEE V]HV]pO\HVHEE V D V]HPOpOEHQ WDOiQ D OHJKHYHVHEE YLV]RO\JiVW NHOW DODN]DW D ÅPLPRLGµ SHUV]H FVDN |V]W|Q|V HOOHQpU]pVUH JRQGRORN  *LHVH QHP W~O]RN HJpV]HQEHOpMNV]HUHWHWWpVKDOiOiLJNXWDWiVXNQDNOHtUi VXNQDN PLEHQOpWN WDOiOJDWiViQDN V]HQWHOWH PDJiW (OQHYH]pVNNHO D]W DNDUWD NLIHMH]QL DPL D] HPEHU V]iPiUDDOHJVDMiWRVDEEEHQQNKDMODPXNDWDN|UQ\H] IRUPiNXWiQ]iViUDDNiUN|]HOLHNDNiUWiYROLDN (J\ QDSRQ PpO\HQ D] yFHiQ IHOV]tQH DODWW WHUMHGHOPHV ODSRVV]DNDGR]RWWSHUHP,V]XURNIHNHWHNRURQJW,QLNIHO 7t]WL]HQNpW yUD P~OYD OHEHQ\HVVp YiOLN V]HPOiWRPiVW WDJROyGLN pV N|]EHQ D IHOV]tQ IHOp W|U $ V]HPOpO PHJ HVNGQH KRJ\ RGDOHQW KHYHV N]GHOHP IRO\LN PHUW D] HJpV] N|UQ\pN PHJPR]GXO NRQFHQWULNXV KXOOiPJ\,U,N YpJWHOHQ VRUD RVWURPROMD H]W D SRQWRW PLQW J|UFVEH K~]yGy V]iMDN YDJ\ L]PRVDQ |VV]H]iUXOy HOHYHQ NUiWHUHN WRURQQ\i QQHN D PpO\EHQ WHUMHQJ KLPEiOy]y IHNHWH UpP I|O|WW IHOiJDVNRGQDN pV YLVV]D]XKDQQDN $ W|EE V]i]H]HU WRQQiV DQ\DJW|PHJ OH]~GXOiViW PiVRGSHUFHNLJ WDUWy Q\iO 

NiVFXSSDQiV NtVpUL EiU LQNiEEPHQQ\G|UJpVQHN QHYH] QpP PHUW LWW PLQGHQ JLJiV]L DUiQ\~ (]HN D S|U|O\FVD SiVRN YLVV]DQ\RPMiN D V|WpW NpS]GPpQ\W VW ~J\ OiWV]LN PLQWKD V]pWODStWDQiN pV GDUDERNUD WpSQpN D FVDS]RWW V]iUQ\DNNpQW FVQJ OHEHQ\HN QpPHO\LNpUO WRMiVGDG IUW|N YiOQDN OH KRVV]~ OiQFFi Q\~OQDN |VV]HIRJy]QDN pV I|OIHOp ~V]QDN PDJXN XWiQ K~]YD D PLQWHJ\ KR]]iMXN QWW V]DNDGR]y DQ\DNRURQJRW DPHO\QHN HJ\UH KRUSDGWDEE WiQ\pUMiUD WRYiEE ]~GXOQDN KXOOiPJ\,U,N eV H] D MiWpN KRO HJ\ QDSLJ KRO HJ\ KyQDSLJ WDUW 1pKD HQQ\LEHQ LV PDUDG $ OHONLLVPHUHWHV *LHVH H]W D YiOWR]DWRW ÅHOYHWpOW PLPRLGQDNµ QHYH]WH PLQWKD ² QH NpUGH]]N KRQQpW ² EL]WRVDQ WXGQi KRJ\ PLQGHQ LO\HQ NDWDNOL]PD YpJV FpOMD D] ÅpUHWW PLPRLGµ YLOiJRV KpM~ SROLSV]HU, Q\~OYiQ\RN WHOHSH W|EEQ\LUH QDJ\REE HJ\ I|OGL YiURVQiO  DPHO\QHN ÅIHODGDWDµ D NOV IRUPiN PDMPROiVD   7HUPpV]HWHVHQ DNDGW HJ\ PiVLN V]RODULVWD 8\YHQV QHY, DNL H]W D YpJVy V]DNDV]W pSSHQ ÅGHJHQHUiFLyQDNµ WDUWRWWD HOIDM]iVQDN HOKDOiVQDN D OpWUHM|Y IRUPiN HUGHMpW SHGLJ pNHVV]yOy EL]RQ\tWpNQDN DUUD KRJ\ H NL]iUyGRWW NpS]GPpQ\HN QHP iOOQDN W|EEp D]DQ\DWHVWXUDOPDDODWW *LHVH D]RQEDQ ² DNL PLQGHQ HJ\pE VRODULVL DODN]DW OHtUiViQiO ~J\ YLVHONHGLN PLQW D PHJIDJ\RWW Yt]HVpVHQ PiV]NiOyKDQJ\DVHPPLVHP]|NNHQWLNLWHPSyVV]iUD] VWtOXViEyO ² H]~WWDO RO\DQ EL]WRV YROW D GROJiEDQ KRJ\ D PLPRLG V]OHWpVpQHN Ii]LVDLW D ÅW|NpOHWHVVpJµ HJ\UH PD JDVDEEIRNDLV]HULQWUDQJVRUROWD 0DJDVEyO Qp]YH ~J\ UpPOLN D PLPRLG YiURVKR] KD VRQOtW GH H]W D FVDOyGiVW FVDN D] RNR]]D KRJ\ PLQGHQ iURQ YDODPL LVPHUW GRORJKR] DNDUMXN KDVRQOtWDQL 7LV]WD LGEHQDVRNHPHOHWHVQ\~OYiQ\RNDWpVWHWHMN|QDF|O|S HUGW L]]y OHYHJUpWHJ YHV]L N|UO HWWO D] DP~J\ LV QHKH]HQIHOLVPHUKHW IRUPiNOHQJHQLpVKDMODGR]QLOiWV]D QDN 0LKHO\W IHOK MHOHQLN PHJ D] pJEROWRQ DPHO\ SHUV]H QHP NpN KDQHP D Y|U|V QDS IpQ\pEHQ UWHV D NpN QD SpEDQ YDNtWy IHKpU  D PLPRLG D]RQQDO UHDJiO +HYHV VDUMDG]iV LQGXO PHJ DODSMiWyO PDMGQHP HOV]DNDGy NDU ILROV]HU,HQ SXIIDGR]y Q\~OyV EXURN O|NGLN D PDJDVED N|]EHQ HJ\UH IHKpUHGLN pV QpKiQ\ SHUF P~OYD PHJWp YHV]WpVLJ KDVRQOtW D IHOKJRPRO\UD (] D KDWDOPDV W QHPpQ\ Y|U|VHV iUQ\pNRW YHWYH KDODG HOUH ~J\ WHWV]LN 

PLQWKDDPLPRLGFV~FVDLDGRJDWQiNiWHJ\PiVQDNPR] JiVD PLQGLJ HOOHQNH] LUiQ\~ PLQW D YDOyViJRV IHOKp $]WKLV]HP*LHVHV]tYHVHQOHYiJDWWDYROQDDIpONDUMiWKD OHJDOiEE HUUH D] HJ\ WDOiQ\UD IpQ\W GHUtWKHW 3HGLJ D PLPRLG LO\HQ ÅHJ\HGLµ WHUPpNHL PpJ VHPPLN DKKR] D] HOHPL HUHM, WHYpNHQ\VpJKH] NpSHVW DPLUH D I|OGL M|YH YpQ\HNKR]WDWiUJ\DNpVIRUPiNÅLQJHUOLNµ $ IRUPDXWiQ]iV OpQ\HJpEHQ PLQGHQUH NLWHUMHG DPL QLQFV PHVV]HEE Q\ROFNLOHQF PpUI|OGQpO $ PLPRLG W|EEQ\LUHQDJ\tWRWWPiVRODWRWSURGXNiOQpKDWRU]tWNDUL NtUR] YDJ\ JURWHV]NO HJ\V]HU,VtW NO|Q|VHQ D JpSHNHW 1\HUVDQ\DJD SHUV]H PLQGLJ XJ\DQD] D J\RUVDQ IHKpUHG PDVV]D DPHO\ D OHYHJEH O|NGYH QHP HVLN OH KDQHP IJJYH PDUDG N|QQ\HQ V]DNDGy N|OG|N]VLQyURN N|WLN |VV]H D] DODSSDO H]HNHQ DUDV]ROJDW HOUH V N|]EHQ KRO ]VXJRURGYD KRO IHOSXIIDGYD IRO\DPDWRVDQ D OHJERQ\ROXO WDEE IRUPiNDW |OWL $ UHSOJpSHW D UiFVRW YDJ\ D UXGDW HJ\IRUPDJ\RUVDQUHSURGXNiOMDFVDNPDJiUDD]HPEHUUH QHP UHDJiO D PLPRLG SRQWRVDEEDQ VHPPLIpOH pOOpQ\UH Q|YpQ\HNUHVHPPHUWD]RNDWLVYLWWHNNtVpUOHWLFpORNEyOD 6RODULVUD D IiUDGKDWDWODQ NXWDWyN  (]]HO V]HPEHQ D] HPEHU IRUPiM~ EiEXW NXW\D YDJ\ ID EiUPLO\HQ DQ\DJEyO NpV]OWV]REUiWU|JW|QOHPiVROMD 6DMQRV LWW LV PHJ NHOO MHJ\H]QQN KRJ\ D PLPRLGQDN H] D ÅNpV]VpJHVµ YLVHONHGpVH ² DPHO\ HJ\HGOiOOy MHOHQVpJ D6RODULVRQ²J\DNUDQV]QHWHO $ OHJpUHWWHEE PLPRLGQDN LV YDQQDN ÅOXVWD QDSMDLµ PLNRU VHPPL PiVW QHP FVLQiO FVDN QDJ\RQ ODVVDQ ONWHW (] D ONWHWpV HJ\pENpQW OiW KDWDWODQ W|EE PLQW NpWyUiV V]DNDV]iW FVDN VSHFLiOLV ILOPIHOYpWHOHNNHOVLNHUOWNLPXWDWQL ,O\HQNRU D PLPRLG INpSS D] |UHJ EiWUDQ EHMiUKDWy D] yFHiQED PHUOW WDUWyNRURQJMDLQ pV Q\~OYiQ\DLQ HJ\ DUiQW~J\OHKHWVpWiOQLPLQWDWiQFWHUHPEHQ Å'ROJRVµQDSMDLQLVOHKHWD]pUWDPLPRLGRQWDUWy]NRGQL GH D OiWiVL YLV]RQ\RN LO\HQNRU QDJ\RQ URVV]DN PHUW D IRUPiNDWXWiQ]y JRPRO\DJ GX]]DGy Q\~OYiQ\DLUyO IRO\WRQ V]LWiODSRUKyKR]KDVRQOySLV]NRVIHKpUSHO\KHVNROORLGH PXO]Ly $ IRUPiN HJ\pENpQW N|]HOUO ~J\VHP LVPHUKHWN IHO KLV]HQ yULiVL QDJ\RN KHJ\PpUHW,HN 5iDGiVXO D ÅP,N|GµPLPRLGDODSMDVSSHGVVpYiOLNDK~VRVHVWO DPHO\ FVDN Wt]WL]HQNpW yUD P~OYD iOO |VV]H D WDMWpNNQpO



VRNNDO N|QQ\HEE V]LOiUG NpUHJJp 9pJO PHJIHOHO IHOV]H UHOpV KtMiQ N|QQ\HQ HO LV WpYHGKHW D] HPEHU D J|FV|UW|V RV]ORSRNKR] pV DOYDGW JHM]tUHNKH] KDVRQOy GX]]DGW WRU Q\RNODELULQWXViEDQPpJIpQ\HVQDSSDOLVPHUWDV,U,Q IHOOG|]|WWÅPtPHO JRPRO\DJRNµV|WpWEHERUtWMiN +D D PLPRLGQDN KHO\HVHEEHQ D I|O|WWH WDQ\i]y NXWDWyQDN  My QDSMD YDQ D PHJILJ\HOpV SiUDWODQ pOPp Q\HNHW NtQiO Å,KOHWHWW NHGYpEHQµ IDQWDV]WLNXV PXWDW YiQ\RNUDNpSHVDPRQVWUXP(J\pQLPRGRUEDQYDULiOMDD NOYLOiJ IRUPDNLQFVpW FLIUi]]D VW ÅWRYiEEN|OWLµ yUiNLJ HOV]yUDNR]LN H]]HO D] DEV]WUDNW IHVWN LPiGMiN H]W D OiWYiQ\W D WXGyVRN SHGLJ D KDMXNDW WpSLN PHUW HJ\ NXNNRW VHP pUWHQHN H]HNEO D IRO\DPDWRNEyO 1pKD J\HU PHWHJ QHRSULPLWtY VWtOXV MHOOHP]L D PLPRLG DONRWiVDLW PiVNRU PHJ ÅEDURNN FLUiGiNµ V]OHWQHN V LO\HQNRU PLQ GHQ DONRWiViQ RWW D SXIIDGW HOHSKDQWLDVLV EpO\HJH .LYiOW D]|UHJPLPRLGRNIDEULNiOQDNNDFDJWDWyLGRPRNDWEiUpQ VRKDVHP WXGWDP QHYHWQL UDMWXN W~OViJRVDQ OHQ\,J|] D OiWYiQ\WLWRN]DWRVViJD eUWKHWKRJ\DNXWDWyND]HOV pYHNEHQOi]DVDQUiYH WHWWpNPDJXNDWDPLPRLGRNUDtPHD6RODULVyFHiQLGH iOLVN|]SRQWMDLDKROYpJUHPHJYDOyVXONpWFLYLOL]iFLyYiUYD YiUW Np]IRJiVD ÉPGH KDPDURVDQ NLGHUOW KRJ\ Np]IRJiVUyO V]y VLQFV PHUW D FpOWDODQ PDMPROiVRQ W~O D PLPRLGQHPPXWDWVHPPLIpOHEDUiWNR]yNHGYHW $ WXGyVRN HONHVHUHGHWWHQ J\|W|UWpN D] DJ\XNDW GH VH KRJ\ VHP EtUWDN PHJV]DEDGXOQL D DQWURSR YDJ\ ]RR PRUIL]PXVWyO D] pO yFHiQ KRO HJ\LN KRO PiVLN NpS]G PpQ\pWQHYH]WpNNLÅpU]pNV]HUYHNQHNµVWÅYpJWDJRNQDNµ DKRJ\ QpKiQ\ WXGyV N|]WN 0DDUWHQV pV (NNRQDL  HJ\ LGEHQ *LHVH ÅEiEHOHLWµ pV ÅOHQJHWHJHLWµ pUWHOPH]WH 3HGLJ D] pO yFHiQ SURWXEHUDQFLiL PHO\HNHW RO\NRU NpW PpUI|OG PDJDVViJED O|YHOO N|UOEHOO DQQ\LUD ÅYpJWDJRNµ DPHQQ\LUHDI|OGUHQJpVDI|OGNpUHJÅUHJJHOLWRUQiMDµ $ YLV]RQ\ODJ iOODQGyDQ LVPpWOG IRUPiN NDWDOyJXVD PLQWHJ\KiURPV]i]FtPV]yWWDUWDOPD](]HNHWDPRQVWUX PRNDW RO\DQ J\DNUDQ V]OL D] yFHiQ KRJ\ QDSRQWD OHJ DOiEEQpKiQ\ WXFDWRW VW HVHWOHJ W|EE V]i]DW LV pV]OHOWHN EHOON$OHJLGHJHQV]HU,EEHNDPHQQ\LEHQYpJNpSSQHP KDVRQOtWKDWyN VHPPL I|OGL MHOHQVpJKH]  *LHVH LVNR 

DDEV]WUDNW

OiMD V]HULQW D V]LPPHWULiGRN .XWDWiVXNKR] FVDN DNNRU IRJWDN KR]]i PLNRU PiU EL]WRVDQ WXGWiN KRJ\ D] yFHiQ VRKDVHPWiPDGMDPHJD]HPEHUWpVNO|Q|VYDNPHUVpJ YDJ\ N|QQ\HOP,VpJ NHOO DKKR] KRJ\ YDODNL D SOD]PD |UYpQ\EH]XKDQMRQPiVODSUDWDUWR]QDNWHUPpV]HWHVHQD] RO\DQ EDOHVHWHN DPHO\HNHW SpOGiXO D] R[LJpQNpV]OpN YDJ\ D KV]DEiO\R]y KLEiMD RNR]  D]W LV NLWDSDV]WDOWiN PiU KRJ\ D KRVV]DQ\RN KHQJHUHV IRO\DPDLQ pV D IHOKN N|]|WW KLQWi]y EiEHOHN LUGDWODQ WRUQ\DLQ PLQGHQ YHV]pO\ QpONO iW LV KDWROKDW D UHSOJpS YDJ\ PiV OpJLMiUP, PHUW D SOD]PD V]pWYiOLN HOWWH6RODULVOpJN|UEHOLKDQJVH EHVVpJJHOHQJHGXWDWD]LGHJHQWHVWQHNVWKDNpQ\V]HUt WLN PpJ D] yFHiQ IHOV]tQH DODWW LV PpO\ DODJXWDNDW Q\LW yULiVL HQHUJLiW PR]JyVtW LO\HQNRU 6]NUMDELQ V]iPtWiVD  V]HULQW HJ\HV HVHWHNEHQ  HUJHW  5HQGNtYO yYDWR VDQ OiWWDN PXQNiKR] IRO\WRQ YLVV]DNR]YD W|EEV]|U|V EL]WRVtWiVVDO ² DPL XJ\DQ MREEiUD ILNWtY YROW ² V D]RN QHYpWDNLNHOVQHNHUHV]NHGWHNOHDV]LPPHWULiGWRUNiED PDLVPLQGHQJ\HUHNLVPHULD)|OG|Q (]HN D PRQVWUXPRN QHP D NOVHMN PLDWW LO\HQ IpOHO PHWHVHN EiU DWWyO LV URVV]DNDW iOPRGKDW D] HPEHU ,Q NiEE D]pUW PHUW QLQFV UDMWXN VHPPL EL]WRV pV iOODQGy PpJ D IL]LND W|UYpQ\HL VHP pUYpQ\HVOQHN $ V]LPPHW ULiGNXWDWyNKDQJR]WDWWiNPLQGLJDOHJPDNDFVDEEXOKRJ\ D]pO yFHiQpUWHOPHV $ V]LPPHWULiGRN KLUWHOHQ V]OHWQHN .HOHWNH]pVN YXONiQNLW|UpVKH]KDVRQOtW.|UOEHOOHJ\yUiYDOHOWWHD] yFHiQ QHJ\YHQ|WYHQ QpJ\]HWNLORPpWHUHQ FVLOORJQLYLOORJQL NH]GPLQWKDPHJYHJHVHGHWWYROQDEiUIRO\pNRQ\PDUDG pVYiOWR]DWODQXOKXOOiP]LN1pKDHJ\OHQJHWHJHWV]tYEHV D] |UYpQ\ KHO\pQ NHOHWNH]LN D V]LPPHWULiG GH H] QHP V]DEiO\ (J\ My yUD P~OYD D] YHJHV KiUW\D yULiV EXERUpNNpQW D OHYHJEH UHSO WNUpEHQ D] pJ D QDS D IHOKN D OiWyKDWiU IRO\WRQ YiOWR]y W|UpNHQ\ NpSH UDJ\RJ 3iUDWODQ OiWYiQ\ D V]tQHN FLNi]y MiWpND DPLW UpV]EHQ D J|UEOHWUpV]EHQDIpQ\W|UpVLGp]HO .O|Q|VHQ V]tQSRPSiVDN D V]LPPHWULiGRN D NpN QDS IpQ\pEHQU|YLGGHOQDSOHPHQWHHOWW,O\HQNRU~J\WHWV]LN KRJ\ D ERO\Jy PiVLN ERO\JyW V]O DPHO\ SLOODQDWRQNpQW GXSOiMiUDQ 

$OLJ U|SSHQW IHO D PpO\EO D FVLOORJyYLOORJy J|PE PiULV KRVV]DQWL JHUH]GHNUH KDVDG DPHO\HN I|OO HOYiOQDN GH QHP KXOODQDN V]pW (] D QHP W~O V]HUHQFVpVHQ ÅYLUiJNHKHO\V]DNDV]QDNµ QHYH]HWW VWiGLXP FVDN PiVRGSHUFHNLJ WDUW $] pJUH PHUHG tYHOW KiUW\DFLNNHO\HN NLIRUGXOQDN OiWKDWDWODQ EHOVHMN |VV]HIRUU pV YLOOiPJ\RUVDQ iWDODNXOQDN YDODPL ]|P|N WHVWWp DPHO\EHQ VRN V]i] HVHPpQ\ ]DMOLN HJ\V]HUUH &HQWUXPiEDQ PHO\HW +DPDOHL KHWYHQ IQ\L FVRSRUWMD YL]VJiOW PHJ HOV]|U JLJDQWR pV SROLNULV]WDOOL]iFLy ~WMiQ WHQJHO\V]HU, WDUWyRV]ORSM|QOpWUHDPLWRO\NRUÅJHULQFQHNµ QHYH]QHN GH pQ QHP WDUWR]RP H WHUPLQXV KtYHL N|]p $ WHQJHO\ N|UOL PHUpV] V]HUNH]HWHW V]OHWpVH VWiGLXPiEDQ D] yFHiQ NLORPpWHUHV iUNDLEyO IJJOHJHVHQ IHOW|U KDWDOPDV JHM]tUHN WiPDV]WMiN DOi DQ\DJXN HJpV]HQ KtJ V]LQWH Yt]V]HU, NRFVRQ\D ( IRO\DPDW N|]EHQ D NRORVV]XV PpO\pEO WRPSD HOQ\~MWRWW E|PE|OpV KDOODWV]LN pV KHYHVHQEXJ\ERUpNROyKyIHKpUOD]DKDE|QWLHO$]WiQ²D N|]pSSRQWWyODNHUOHWIHOpKDODGYD²HONH]GGLNDPpO\EO IHOW|U Q\~OyV DQ\DJ UpWHJHLWO PHJYDVWDJRGRWW V]LQWHN UHQGNtYO ERQ\ROXOW IRUJiVD N|]EHQ D] HOEE HPOtWHWW JHM]tUHN PHJDOYDGQDN pV PR]JpNRQ\ FViSV]HU, RV]ORSRNNi YiOQDN Q\DOiEMDLN D] HJpV] V]HUNH]HW GLQDPLNiMD iOWDO V]LJRU~DQ PHJKDWiUR]RWW SRQWRNKR] KDMROQDN pV HJ\ H]HUV]HUHV J\RUVDViJJDO Q|Y PDJ]DW JLJiV]L NRSROW\~MiUD HPOpNH]WHWYH Uy]VDV]tQ YpU pV QDJ\RQ V|WpW ]|OG V]LQWH IHNHWH Yt] SDWDNMDL NH]GHQHN iWiUDPODQL UDMWXN (WWO IRJYD PiU MHOHQWNH]LN D V]LP PHWULiG OHJUHQGNtYOLEE WXODMGRQViJD ² PRGHOOiOQL WXG VW IHO LV WXG IJJHV]WHQL EL]RQ\RV IL]LNDL W|UYpQ\HNHW 0RQGMXN PHJ U|JW|Q KRJ\ QLQFV NpW HJ\IRUPD V]LPPHW ULiGpVPLQGHJ\LNNJHRPHWULiMDPLQWHJ\~MÅWDOiOPiQ\Dµ D] pO yFHiQQDN (]XWiQ D V]LPPHWULiG PpKpEHQ PHJV]OHWLN D] DPLW ÅJpSH]HWVWiGLXPQDNµ V]RNiV QH YH]QLEiUH]HNDNpS]GPpQ\HNNRUiQWVHPKDVRQOtWDQDN D] HPEHUHN iOWDO V]HUNHV]WHWW JpSHNUH D] HOQHYH]pV FVDN P,N|GpVN YLV]RQ\ODJ V]RURV pV H]iOWDO PLQWHJ\ ÅJpSLHVµ FpOV]HU,VpJpUHXWDO $PLNRU D PpO\EO IHOW|U JHM]tUHN PHJDOYDGQDN YDJ\ V]HUWHiJD]yYDVWDJIDO~JDOpULiNNipVIRO\RVyNNiGX]]DG QDN D ÅKiUW\iNEyOµ SHGLJ NLDODNXO D] HJ\PiVW PHWV] IDODN OHMWN pV I|GpPHN ODELULQWXVD D V]LPPHWULiG D]]DO 

LJD]ROMD QHYpW KRJ\ D] HJ\LN SyOXV PLQGHQ WHNHUYpQ\HV VLNiWRUiQDNIRO\RVyMiQDNpV DNQiMiQDNSRQWRVDQ XJ\DQ RO\DQPiVDMHOHQLNPHJD]HOOHQNH] SyOXVRQ +~V]KDUPLQF SHUF P~OYD D NRORVV]XV ODVVDQ PHUOQL NH]G IJJOHJHV WHQJHO\H LO\HQNRU QpKD Q\ROFWL]HQNpW IRNNDOPHJGO9DQQDNNLVHEEpVQDJ\REEV]LPPHWULiGRN GH PpJ D W|USpN LV My Q\ROFV]i] PpWHUUHO HPHONHGQHN HNNRUDKRUL]RQWI|OppVWt]WL]HQ|WPpUI|OGUOLVOiWKDWyN .|]YHWOHQO D] HJ\HQV~O\ EHiOOiVD XWiQ PLKHO\W D PHUOpV DEEDPDUDG pV D WHQJHO\ YLVV]DELOOHQ IJJOHJHV KHO\]HWpEH OHKHW D OHJEL]WRQViJRVDEEDQ EHOpMN KDWROQL D OHJDONDOPDVDEE KHO\ D EHKDWROiVUD D FV~FV DODWWL WHUOHW $ YLV]RQ\ODJ VLPD ÅVDUNL VDSNDµ DODWWL UpV]W V]LWiYi O\XJJDWMiN D EHOV NDPUiN pV IRO\RVyN NHUHN Q\t OiVDL $] HJpV] pStWPpQ\ SHGLJ YDODPL IHOVEE PDWHPD WLNDLHJ\HQOHWKiURPGLPHQ]LyVPHJROGiVD 0LQW WXGMXN PLQGHQ HJ\HQOHW NLIHMH]KHW D PDJDVDEE JHRPHWULD IRUPDQ\HOYpQ pV PHJIHOHO WpUEHOL LGRP V]HUNHV]WKHW KR]]i $ V]LPPHWULiG HV]HULQW /REDFVHYV] NLM N~SMDLQDN pV 5LHPDQQ QHJDWtY J|UEOHWHLQHN YDODPL IpOH URNRQD GH FVDN QDJ\RQ WiYROUyO PHUW HONpS]HO KHWHWOHQO ERQ\ROXOW (JpV] PDWHPDWLNDL UHQGV]HU W|EE N|EPpUI|OG WHUMHGHOP, OHYH]HWpVH PpJSHGLJ QpJ\GLPHQ ]LyV OHYH]HWpV PHUW D] HJ\HQOHWHN OpQ\HJHV HJ\WWKDWyL LGEHQLVNLIHMH]GQHND]DODN]DWLGEHOLYiOWR]iVDLEDQ $ OHJHJ\V]HU,EE JRQGRODW SHUV]H D] YROW KRJ\ PLQGH] QHP HJ\pE PLQW D] pO yFHiQ ÅPDWHPDWLNDL JpSHµ LVPH UHWOHQ FpO~ V]iPtWiVDLQDN D]  PpUHWHLKH] V]DERWW PR GHOOMHGHH]WD)HUPRQWIpOHKLSRWp]LVWPDPiUVHQNLVHP YDOOMD .pWVpJNtYO FViEtWy HONpS]HOpV YROW KRJ\ D] pO yFHiQ H]HNNHO D WLWiQL NLW|UpVHNNHO DPHO\HNQHN PLQGHQ PROHNXOiMD V]QWHOHQO ERQ\ROyGy IHOVEE PDWHPDWLNDL IRUPXOiN V]HULQW PR]RJ D] DQ\DJ D NR]PRV] D OpW SUREOpPiLW ERQFROJDWMD   GH KiW H] WDUWKDWDWODQQDN EL ]RQ\XOW 7~OVRNRO\DQMHOHQVpJUH EXNNDQKDWXQN D] yULiV EHOVHMpEHQ DPHO\ QHP HJ\H]WHWKHW |VV]H H]]HO D OpQ\H JpEHQ HJ\V]HU, PiVRN V]HULQW J\HUPHNHVHQ QDLY  IHO IRJiVVDO 6RNDQ SUyEiOWDN YDODPL N|]pUWKHW V]HPOpOWHW V]LP PHWULiGPRGHOOW NLJRQGROQL HOpJ QpSV]HU, OHWW $YHULDQ SpOGiMD QHYH]HWHVHQ NpS]HOMQN HO HJ\ %DELORQ YLUiJNR 

UiEyOYDOyI|OGLpSOHWHWDPHO\QHNDQ\DJDpOpU]pNHO pV IHMOG V]XEV]WDQFLD H] D] pSOHW IRO\DPDWRVDQ YpJLJKDODGYD D] iWPHQHWL V]DNDV]RNRQ V]HPQN OiWWiUD IHO|OWL D J|U|J PDMG D URPiQ pStWpV]HW IRUPiLW D]WiQ RV]ORSDLW|UpNHQQ\pNDUFV~VRGQDNDV~O\RVEROWR]DWPD JDVDEE N|QQ\HEE OHV] D IpON|UtYHN PHUpV] SDUDEROiED PHQQHN iW YpJO FV~FVtYYp KHJ\HVHGQHN $] tJ\ OpWUHM|WW JyWLNDpUQLpV|UHJHGQLNH]GPHJMHOHQQHNDNpVHLIRUPiN DPDJDVEDW|UV]iUQ\DOyiKtWDWKHO\pEHEXMDSRPSDOpS HOWWQN iOO D WRE]yGyQ JD]GDJ EDURNN pV KD tJ\ IRO\WDWMXN D VRUW YiOWR]y pSOHWQNEHQ PLQGLJ HJ\ pOHW IRO\DPDW HJ\HV V]DNDV]DLW OiWYD YpJO HOMXWXQN D] ,UKD My]iVNRUiQDN pStWpV]HWpKH] pV WDOiQD V]LPPHWULiGUyO LV OHV]YDODPLKDOYiQ\IRJDOPXQN 'H H] D KDVRQODW EiUPLO\HQ DODSRVDQ pV UpV]OHWHVHQ NLGROJR]]iN VW NO|QOHJHV PDNHWWHN VHJtWVpJpYHO ILOPUH YLWWpN  D OHJHQ\KpEEHQ V]yOYD LV HUWOHQ D V]LJRU~EE NULWLNXV SHGLJ D NpUGpV PHJNHUOpVpQHN YDJ\ HJ\V]HU,HQ KD]XJViJQDN LV QHYH]KHWL KLV]HQ D V]LPPHWULiG VHPPL I|OGLGRORJKR]QHPKDVRQOtW   $] HPEHU QDJ\RQ NHYHVHW WXG HJ\V]HUUH I|OIRJQL FVDN D]WOiWMXNDPLHOWWQNLWW pV PRVW W|UWpQLN D IRO\DPD WRNHJ\LGHM, VRNDViJiQDNV]HPOpOWHWpVHEiUPHQQ\LUH|V] V]HIJJHQHN VW NL LV HJpV]tWLN HJ\PiVW PHJKDODGMD OHKHWVpJHLQNHW (]W PpJ YLV]RQ\ODJ HJ\V]HU, MHOHQVp JHNQpO LV WDSDV]WDOMXN (J\ HPEHU VRUVD VRNDW MHOHQWKHW W|EE V]i]pW QHKp] iWWHNLQWHQL GH H]HU PLOOLy HPEHU W|U WpQHWH WXODMGRQNpSSHQ VHPPLW VHP MHOHQW $ V]LPPHWULiG KDWYiQ\R]RWWPLOOLyQHPPLOOLiUGD] HONpS]HOKHWHWOHQVpJ PDJD PLW pUQN KiW D]]DO KD PHJiOOXQN YDODPHO\LN FVDUQRNiEDQ DPHO\ QHP HJ\pE PLQW Wt]V]HUHV .URQHFNHUWpU RGDWDSDGXQN D OpOHJ] EROWR]DW UHGLKH] PLQW D KDQJ\iN EiPXOMXN D UHIOHNWRUDLQN IpQ\pEHQ V]UNpQRSDOL]iOyJLJiV]LIHOOHWHNHPHONHGpVpWHJ\PiVED KDWROiViW D OiJ\ pV WpYHGKHWHWOHQO W|NpOHWHV PHJROGiVW DPHO\SHGLJFVDNIXWySLOODQDWKLV]HQLWWPLQGHQYiOWR]LN ² HQQHN D] pStWP,YpV]HWQHN D WDUWDOPD D PR]JiV D] |VV]HIRJRWW pV FpOV]HU, PR]JiV $ IRO\DPDW SDUiQ\L W|UHGpNpW OiWMXN HJ\HWOHQ K~U UH]JpVpW D V]XSHUyULiVRN V]LPIRQLNXV ]HQHNDUiEDQ pV UiDGiVXO WXGMXN ² GH FVDN WXGMXN QHP IRJMXN IHO ² KRJ\ N|]EHQ I|O|WWQN pV DODWWXQN D V]pGtW 

PpO\VpJEHQOiWiVXQNpVNpS]HOHWQNKDWiUDLQW~OH]HUpV PLOOLy HJ\LGHM, iWDODNXOiV IRO\LN pV YDODPHQQ\LW V]LJRU~ PDWHPDWLNDL HOOHQSRQW NDSFVROMD |VV]H *HRPHWULDL V]LPIyQLiQDNLVQHYH]WpNPiUDV]LPPHWULiGRW²FVDNKRJ\ PLVNHWHNYDJ\XQNHUUHD]HQpUH $KKR] KRJ\ LJD]iQ OiWKDVVXQN YDODPLW QDJ\RQ QDJ\RQPHVV]LUH NHOOHQH WiYRORGQXQNGH KiWD V]LPPHW ULiGEDQPLQGHQEHOOMiWV]yGLNOHPLQGHQFVXSDV]DSRUR GiV V]OHWpVHN NLUREEDQy ODYLQiL V]QWHOHQ DODNXOiV PHO\HJ\EHQDODNtWLVpVDPLPy]DVHPRO\DQpU]pNHQ\D] pULQWpVUH PLQW D V]LPPHWULiG WOQN PpUI|OGHNUH OHY V]i] HPHOHWWHO I|OMHEE YDJ\ OHMMHEE OHY SRQWMD D]RNUD D YiOWR]iVRNUDDPHO\HNHQDPLWDUWy]NRGiVLKHO\QN PHJ\ NHUHV]WO 0LQGHQ SLOODQDWRNLJ pO DODN]DW V]iPXQNUD OiWKDWDWODQ J\|Q\|U, UHQGEHQ IRUPiOMD pV LUiQ\tWMD D] |VV]HV W|EELW HJ\WW YiOWR]QDN pV W LV DODNtWMD YDODPHQQ\L 6]LPIyQLD ² OHJ\HQ GH RO\DQ DPHO\ PDJD WHUHPWL |QPDJiW pV PDJD LV SXV]WtWMD HO %RU]DOPDV D V]LPPHWULiG YpJH (J\HWOHQ V]HPWDQ~MD VHP WXGRWW V]D EDGXOQL DWWyO D] pU]pVWO KRJ\ WUDJpGLiW VW WDOiQ J\LO NRVViJRW OiW .pW OHJIHOMHEE KiURP yUD P~OYD ² WRYiEE VRKDVHP WDUW H] D UREEDQiVV]HU, VDUMDG]iV V]DSRURGiV pV VQHP]pV ² D] pO yFHiQ WiPDGiVED OHQGO (] tJ\ IHVWDVLPDIHOV]tQUiQFRNDWYHWD]HOFVLWXOWFVDWDWpU~MUD IRUW\RJQL NH]G D V]RWW\DGW WDMWpN DODWW NRQFHQWULNXV KXOOiPJ\,U,NWiPDGQDND OiWKDWiURQ XJ\DQRO\DQL]PRV NUiWHUHN PLQW DPLO\HQHN D PLPRLG V]OHWpVpQpO EiEiV NRGWDN GH VRNNDO QDJ\REEDN .|UOIRJMiN D V]LPPHWULiG OHPHUOW UpV]pW D NRORVV]XV ODVVDQ I|OHPHONHGLN PLQWKD D ERO\Jy NL DNDUQi YHWQL PDJiEyO D] yFHiQ IHOV NR FVRQ\DUpWHJHRVWURPRWLQGtWHJ\UHI|OMHEEN~V]LNEHOHSLD V]LPPHWULiGIDOiWPHJDOYDGUDMWDHOIDOD]]DDQ\tOiVRNDW GHH]VHPPLDKKR]NpSHVWDPLN|]EHQRGDEHQW W|UWpQLN $ IRUPDWHUHPW IRO\DPDW ² D] pStWPpQ\ V]HUNH]HWpQHN V]QWHOHQ iWDODNXOiVD ² HJ\ SHUFUH PHJiOO PDMG Oi]DVDQ IHOJ\RUVXO D J\|Q\|U, |VV]KDQJ DODSRN pV EROWR]DWRN VLPD |VV]HROYDGiVD KDMOiVD V]pWiJD]iVD DPL RO\DQ HJ\HQOHWHVpVEL]WRVYROWPLQWKD|U|NNpWDUWDQDERPODQL NH]G 1\RPDV]Wy pU]pVQN WiPDG PLQWKD D NRORVV]XV D N|]HOJ YHV]pO\ WXGDWiEDQ UM|QJYH KDMV]ROQD YDODPL EHWHOMHVOpVW 'H PLQpO KHYHVHEEp YiOLN D IRO\DPDW 

DQQiO Q\LOYiQYDOyEE D] DQ\DJ pV D PR]JiV I|UWHOPHV XQGRUtWy V]tQHYiOWR]iVD $ FVRGiODWRVDQ KDMOpNRQ\ IDODN PLQGHQtYHSDFDOOiSXKXOHOQ\iNRVRGLNOHNRQ\XOFV|N|WW IRUPiNU~W Q\RPRUpNWRU]DODNRN MHOHQQHN PHJ D OiWKD WDWODQPpO\VpJEOEDOMyVPRUDMW|UIHOE|PE|OpVVpGDJDG DNLiUDPOyOHYHJPLQWYDODPLKDOiOK|UJpVVtSROYDW|UiW D EHV],NOW IRO\RVyNRQ V]RUW\RJYD pV JXUJXOi]YD UHNHG PHJ D MiUDWRNEDQ RFVPiQ\ KRUNDQiVRNUD NpV]WHWL D VOO\HG I|GpPHNHW PLQWKD HJ\ V]|UQ\, JpJH Q\iONDFVR PyNNDOERUtWRWWPHUHYKDQJV]iODLNUiNRJQiQDNVDQp]W D IpNHYHV]WHWW PR]JiV HOOHQpUH D] HQ\pV]HW GHUPHV]W KLGHJHFVDSMDPHJ²KLV]HQHJ\KDOGRNOyYRQDJOiViWOiWMD 0iU FVDN D] DNQiN H]UHLQ iW HOVYtW RUNiQ Q\RPiVD WDUWMD IHQQ D URSSDQW pStWPpQ\W PDMG ODVVDQ VOO\HGQL NH]G |VV]HHVLNPLQW D W,]EH GRERWW YLDV]OpS LWWRWW PpJ PHJUiQGXO |VV]HIJJpVWHOHQ J|UFV|V YDN YRQDJOiVDL HJ\UHJ\HQJpEEHNPtJYpJOJ\]DKXOOiPRNV]DNDGDWODQ RVWURPDD]DOiPRVRWWJLJiV]KHJ\ODVV~ViJJDO|VV]HRPOLN VHOW,QLNDNDYDUJyKDERNEDQDPHO\HNEOV]OHWHWW ,JHQPLWMHOHQWPLQGH]"0LD]pUWHOPH" (POpNV]HP HJ\V]HU HJ\ LVNROiVFVRSRUW OiWRJDWWD PHJ D] DGHQL 6RODULV ,QWp]HWHW DKRO *LEDULDQ WDQiUVHJpGMH YROWDPDN|Q\YWiUNLVWHUPpQiWEHYH]HWWpNDWDQXOyNDWD QDJ\WHUHPEHDPHO\HWW~OQ\RPyUpV]WPLNURILOPHNND]HWWiL W|OWHQHN PHJ 7HUPpV]HWHVHQ PiU UpJ QHP OpWH] V]LPPHWULiGRN EHOVHMpQHN DSUy UpV]OHWHLW iEUi]ROMiN YDQ RWWEHOONQHPIHOYpWHOEOKDQHPHJpV]WHNHUFVEOW|EE PLQWNLOHQFYHQH]HUeVDNNRUHJ\GXFLV]HPYHJHVWDOiQ WL]HQ|W HV]WHQGV KDWiUR]RWW pV pUWHOPHV WHNLQWHW, NLVOiQ\HJ\V]HUFVDNPHJNpUGH]WH ²eVPLUHMyPLQGH]"    .tQRV FVHQG iOOW EH FVDN D WDQiUQ YHWHWW PHJUyYy SLOODQWiVW QHYHOHWOHQ WDQtWYiQ\iUD D NtVpU V]RODULVWiN N|]O pQ LV RWW YROWDP  VHQNL VHP WXGRWW YiODV]ROQL +LV]HQD V]LPPHWULiGRNVRKDVHP LVPpWOGQHN D EHQQN PXWDWNR]yMHOHQVpJHNLVFVDNULWNiQ(OIRUGXOKRJ\DOH YHJ QHP YH]HWL EHQQN D KDQJRW 0iVNRU D IpQ\W|UpVL NRHIILFLHQV Q|YHNV]LN YDJ\ FV|NNHQ /NWHW ULWPLNXV KHO\L JUDYLWiFLyV LQJDGR]iVRN OpSQHN IHO PLQWKD D V]LP PHWULiGQDN GRERJy JUDYLWiFLyV V]tYH YROQD 1pKD PHJ 

ERORQGXO D NXWDWyN LUiQ\W,MH HUVHQ LRQL]iOW UpWHJHN NHOHWNH]QHN pV W,QQHN HO V PpJ VRNiLJ IRO\WDWKDWQiP D IHOVRUROiVW (J\pENpQW KD D V]LPPHWULiGRN WLWNiW PHJ LV ROGDQiQN YDODKD PpJ DNNRU LV RWW YDQQDN D] DV]LP PHWULiGRN   8J\DQ~J\ NHOHWNH]QHN FVDN PiVNpSS YpJ]LN QHP OiWKDWy EHOON HJ\pE PLQW UHPHJpV ORERJiV YLOOyG]iV FVDNDQQ\LW WXGXQN KRJ\ V]pGOHWHV IRO\DPDWRN MiWV]yG QDNOH EHQQN D IL]LNDLODJ OHKHWVpJHV VHEHVVpJ KDWiUiQ ÅyULiVL NYDQWXPMHOHQVpJHNQHNµ LV QHYH]LN NHW 'H EL ]RQ\RV DWRPPRGHOOHNKH] YDOy PDWHPDWLNDL KDVRQOyViJXN RO\ P~Oy pV WQpNHQ\ KRJ\ VRNDQ PHOOpNHV YRQiVQDN YDJ\ HJ\V]HU,HQ YpOHWOHQQHN WDUWMiN 6RNNDO U|YLGHEE pOHW,HN D V]LPPHWULiGRNQiO Wt]K~V] SHUFLJ pOQHN SXV]WXOiVXN SHGLJ WDOiQ PpJ ERU]DOPDVDEE PHUW D] RUNiQ Q\RPiEDQ DPHO\ Y|OW URPEROy OpJW|PHJHNNHO W|OWL PHJ pV UHSHV]WL V]pW NHW SRNROL J\RUVDViJJDO HPHONHGQL NH]G EHQQN D V]HQQ\HV KDEUpWHJ DODWW IRUW\RJy IRO\DGpN I|UWHOPHVHQ EXJ\ERUpNROYD HOiUDV]W PLQGHQW PDMG D] HJpV] PRQVWUXP IHOUREEDQ PLQWKD LV]DSYXONiQ W|UQH NL IRV]OiQ\DL PRVOpNV]HU, RV]ORSEDQ UHSOQHNDPDJDVEDpVDERPOyFDIDWRNHVMHPpJVRNiLJ KXOO D] yFHiQ Q\XJWDODQ IHOV]tQpUH 1pPHO\LNHW PHVV]LUH KRUGMD DV]pO PpJ D UREEDQiV N|]SRQWMiWyO |WYHQKDWYDQ NLORPpWHUQ\LUH LV ~V]LN D KXOOiPRNRQ HJ\HJ\ NLV]iUDGW ODSRVViUJiVSRUFRJyUDYDJ\KiUW\iVFVRQWUDHPOpNH]WHW PDUDGYiQ\ .O|Q FVRSRUWRW DONRWQDN D] pO yFHiQWyO KRVV]DEE U|YLGHEE LGUH WHOMHVHQ HOYiOy DODNXODWRN PHO\HN VRNNDO ULWNiEEDN D] HOEELHNQpO pV PHJILJ\HOpVN LV QHKH]HEE $PLNRU HOV]|U EXNNDQWDN Ui PDUDGYiQ\DLNUD D]W KLWWpND]yFHiQEDQpO OpQ\HNWHWHPHLWIHGH]WpNIHOFVDN MyYDO NpVEE GHUOW NL PHQQ\LUH WpYHGWHN  1pKD ~J\ UpPOLN PLQWKD IXUFVD VRN V]iUQ\~ PDGDUDNNpQW PHQHNOQpQHN D OHQJHWHJHN OG|] FViSMDL HOO ² OiP PHJLQW D )|OGUO KR]RWW NpS]HWHN YDVIDOiED WN|]QN 2O\NRU QDJ\RQ ULWNiQ KHYHUpV] IyNiNKR] YDJ\ SLQJYLQHNKH] KDVRQOy NO|Q|V YDODPLN OiWKDWyN D V]LJHWHN V]LNOiV SDUWMDLQ DPLQW D QDSRQ VWNpUH]QHN YDJ\OXVWiQDWHQJHUIHOpPiV]QDNKRJ\EHOHROYDGMDQDN ÌJ\ IRURJWXQN HJ\UH D I|OGL HPEHUL IRJDOPDN E,YN| UpEHQD]HOV NDSFVRODWSHGLJ   

$] H[SHGtFLyN VRN V]i] NLORPpWHUW WHWWHN PHJ D V]LP PHWULiGRN~WYHV]WLEHQWHOHUDNWiNNHWUHJLV]WUiOyNpV] OpNHNNHO |QP,N|G ILOPIHOYHYNNHO D P,KROGDN WpYp NDPHUiL PHJ|U|NtWHWWpN D PLPRLGRN PHJ D KRVV]DQ\RN VDUMDG]iViW pUpVpW pV SXV]WXOiViW 0HJWHOWHN D N|Q\YWiUDN Kt]WDN D] DUFKtYXPRN V H]pUW RO\NRU GUiJiQ NHOOHWW IL]HWQL +pWV]i]WL]HQQ\ROF HPEHU OHOWH KDOiOiW D NDWDNOL]PiNEDQ PHUW QHP KDJ\WiN HO LGHMHNRUiQ D SXV]WXOiVUD tWpOW PRQVWUXPRNDW V]i]KDWDQ YHV]WHN RGD FVDN DEEDQ D] HJ\HWOHQ HPOpNH]HWHV NDWDV]WUyIiEDQ ² N|]WN D] DNNRU PiU KHWYHQpYHV *LHVH ² DPLNRU HJ\ WVJ\|NHUHV V]LPPHWULiG YiUDWODQXO D] DV]LPPHWULiGRN MHOOHJ]HWHVVRUViUDMXWRWW+HWYHQNLOHQFHPEHUWQ\HOWHOHJ\ PiVRGSHUF DODWW D OHYHJEH UHSO ViURV PDVV]D JpSHLNNHO NpV]OpNHLNNHO SiQFpOV]NDIDQGHUHLNNHO HJ\WW VDNLW|UpVHOVRGRUWPpJKXV]RQKHWHWDNLNUHSOJpSHQpV KHOLNRSWHUHQ N|U|]WHN D YL]VJiOW DODNXODW I|O|WW (]W D KHO\HW D QHJ\YHQNHWWHGLN V]pOHVVpJL N|U pV D Q\ROFYDQNLOHQFHGLNGpON|UPHWV]pVSRQWMiQiO D 6]i]KDWRN 5REEDQiVD QpYHQ WQWHWLN IHO D WpUNpSHN 'H H] D SRQW FVDN D WpUNpSHQ OpWH]LN D] yFHiQ IHOOHWH RWW LV XJ\DQRO\DQPLQWDNiUKROPiVXWW (NNRU KDQJ]RWW HO D] HOV RO\DQ N|YHWHOpV D 6RODULV NXWDWiV W|UWpQHWpEHQ KRJ\ YHVVHQHN EH D] yFHiQ HOOHQ DWRPIHJ\YHUW $ ERVV]~QiO LV EDUEiUDEE OpSpV OHWW YROQD HOSXV]WtWDQL YDODPLW PHUW QHP WXGMXN PHJpUWHQL 7VDQ NHQ *LHVH WDUWDOpNFVRSRUWMiQDN KHO\HWWHV YH]HWMH DNL FVDN HJ\ WpYHGpVQHN N|V]|QKHWWH pOHWpW ² D N|]YHWtW DXWRPDWD KLEiVDQ MHO|OWH PHJ D KHO\HW DKRO DPD]RN D V]LPPHWULiGRWYL]VJiOWiNtJ\ D]yFHiQI|O|WWERO\RQJRWW JpSpYHO SiU SHUFFHO D UREEDQiV XWiQ pUNH]HWW D KHO\V]tQUH PpJ OiWWD D IHNHWH JRPEDIHOKW ² V]yYDO H] D 7VDQNHQ D MDYDVODW WiUJ\DOiVDNRU PHJ]HQWH KRJ\ KD D WHUYHW HOIRJDGMiN |QPDJiYDO pV WL]HQQ\ROF PHJPDUDGW HPEHUpYHO HJ\WW OHYHJEH U|StWL D] ÉOORPiVW pV EiU KLYDWDORVDQ VRKDVHP LVPHUWpN EH KRJ\ H] D] |QJ\LONRVViJJDO IHQ\HJHW XOWLPiWXP G|QW|WWH HO D V]DYD]iVHUHGPpQ\pWIHOWHKHWOHJPpJLVFVDNtJ\YROW 3HUV]H UpJHQ HOP~OW D] D] LG PLNRU D ERO\JyQ HJ\PiVW N|YHWWpN D] LO\HQ QpSHV H[SHGtFLyN 0DJD D] iOORPiV NpWV]i] PpWHU iWPpUM, NRURQJ N|]pSWW QpJ\ SHUHPpQ NpWV]LQWHV pStWpVpW P,KROGDNUyO LUiQ\tWRWWiN WLV]WHOHWUH 

PpOWy P,V]DNL YiOODONR]iV YROW LJD]iQ EV]NH LV OHKHWQH Ui D )|OG KD D] yFHiQ QHP O|NQH NL PDJiEyO PiVRGSHUFHN DODWW PLOOLyV]RU HNNRUD pStWPpQ\HNHW $] DQQLKLOiFLyV HQHUJLiYDO P,N|G JUDYLWRURN UpYpQ |WV]i] H]HU|WV]i]PpWHUPDJDVViJEDQOHEHJD]yFHiQI|O|WW0iV ERO\JyN V]RNiVRV ÉOORPiVDLQDN pV QDJ\ 6]DWHOORLGMDLQDN EHUHQGH]pVpQ NtYO NO|QOHJHV UDGDURNNDO LV I|OV]HUHOWpN PHO\HN D] yFHiQ IHOV]tQpQHN OHJNLVHEE YiOWR]iViUD SyW NDSDFLWiVW LQGtWDQDN EH tJ\ D] DFpONRURQJ D]RQQDO IHOUHSO D V]WUDWRV]IpUiED PLKHO\W ~MDEE NpS]GPpQ\ V]OHWpVpQHNMHOHLPXWDWNR]QDNDODWWD 0RVW V]LQWH UHV D] ÉOORPiV 0LyWD D] DXWRPDWiNDW ² PpJ PRVW VHP WXGRP PLpUW ² D] DODJVRUL UDNWiUDNED ]iUWiN RO\DQ NLKDOWDN D IRO\RVyN PLQW HJ\ KDMyURQFVRQ DPHO\ YDNWiEDQ ERO\RQJ PHUW D JpSHN W~OpOWpN D OH JpQ\VpJHW 0LNRU D *LHVHPRQRJUiILD NLOHQFHGLN N|WHWpW LV YLV] V]DWHWWHP D SROFUD ~J\ UpPOHWW D YDVWDJ KDEV]LYDFV Up WHJJHO EXUNROW DFpOSDGOy PHJUHPHJ D OiEDP DODWW 0R] GXODWODQXO ILJ\HOWHP GH D UHPHJpV QHP LVPpWOG|WW $ N|Q\YWiUpV D W|EEL KHO\LVpJN|]|WW W|NpOHWHV D V]LJHWHOpV WHKiWDUHPHJpVQHNFVDNHJ\ RNDOHKHW UDNpWiWOWWHNNL D] ÉOORPiVUyO (] D JRQGRODW YLVV]D]|NNHQWHWW D YDOyViJED 0pJ QHP G|QW|WWHP HO YpJOHJ NLUHSO|NH DKRJ\ 6DUWRULXV NtYiQMD +D ~J\ YLVHONHGHP PLQWKD WHOMHVHQHJ\HWpUWHQpNDWHUYHLYHOOHJIHOMHEENpVOHOWHWHP D] |V]V]HW,]pVWDPHO\HOEEXWyEEV]LQWHEL]WRVDQNLUREEDQ PHUW D]W HOKDWiUR]WDP KRJ\ W|ULNV]DNDG PHJPHQWHP +DUH\W $] D NpUGpV VLNHUOH 6DUWRULXV WHUYH ÐULiVL I|OpQ\EHQYDQYHOHPV]HPEHQ²PLQWIL]LNXVWt]V]HURO\DQ MyOLVPHULDSUREOpPiW QHNHPFVDND]D SDUDGR[UHPpQ\ PDUDGKRJ\D]yFHiQÅW|UKHWHWOHQMiWpNRNNDOµOHSHWWPHJ EHQQQNHW 1HNLGXUiOWDP PDJDP pV HJ\ yUD KRVV]DW NRWORWWDP D PLNURILOPHNHQ KRJ\ NLEiQ\iVV]DN YDODPL pUWKHWW D QHXWULQRIRO\DPDWRN IL]LNiMiQDN IpOHOPHWHV NpSOHWWHQJHUpEO (OHLQWH UHPpQ\WHOHQ YiOODONR]iVQDN UpPOHWW DQQiO LV LQNiEE PLYHO D QHXWULQRWpUQHN |W ERU]DV]WyDQQHKp]HOPpOHWHYDQPiUH]LVPXWDWMDKRJ\ HJ\LN VHP W|NpOHWHV 'H YpJO PpJLV WDOiOWDP YDODPL EL]WDWyWeSSHQDNpSOHWHNHWtURJDWWDPNLPLNRUNRSRJWDW WDN 

$] DMWyKR] VLHWWHP pV NLQ\LWRWWDP JRQGRVDQ HOiOOYD D UpVW 6QDXW L]]DGViJWyO IpQ\O DUFiW SLOODQWRWWDP PHJ 0|J|WWHDIRO\RVyUHVYROW ²7HYDJ\D]"²Q\LWRWWDPNLD]DMWyW²*\HUHEH ² eQ YDJ\RN ² IHOHOWH +DQJMD UHNHGW YROW J\XOODGW V]HPH DODWW WiVNiN V|WpWOHWWHN IpQ\HV VXJiUYpG JXPL N|WpQ\ OyJRWW D Q\DNiEDQ UXJDOPDV NDQWiURQ DOyOD PpJ PRVW LV XJ\DQD] D SLV]NRV YiV]RQQDGUiJ NDQGLNiOW NL 6]HPH N|UEHIXWRWW D] HJ\HQOHWHV YLOiJtWiV~ NHUHN KHO\L VpJHQ pV NLJXYDGW PLNRU pV]UHYHWWH +DUH\W DNL D W~OVy IDOQiO NDURVV]pNH PHOOHWW iOOW 7HNLQWHWQN |VV]HYLOODQW ILJ\HOPH]WHWHQ KXQ\RUtWRWWDP HUUH N|QQ\HQ PHJKDMROW pQSHGLJWiUVDViJLKDQJQHPEHFVDSWDPiW ² %HPXWDWRP 6QDXW GRNWRUW +DUH\ 6QDXW D    D IHOHVpJHP ²eQ  DFVRSRUWHOpJULWNiQOiWKDWyWDJMDYDJ\RNpV H]pUW   ² D V]QHW YHV]pO\HVHQ KRVV]~UD Q\~OW ² QHP YROWPpJV]HUHQFVpPPHJLVPHUQL  ²+DUH\PRVRO\RJYD NH]HW Q\~MWRWW 6QDXW ~J\ UpPOHWW NLVVp EDPEiQ IRJWD PHJ D NH]pW KXQ\RURJYD EiPXOWD PtJ YpJO NDURQ IRJWDP ² %RFViQDW ² PRQGWD HNNRU +DUH\QDN ² %HV]pOQL V]HUHWQpNYHOHG.HOYLQ   ² 3DUDQFVROM |UHJHP ² NpV]VpJHVNHGWHP IHV]WHOHQ QDJ\YLOiJL KDQJRQ YiViUL NRPpGLD YROW GH KiW PLW WHKHWWQN ² +DUH\ GUiJiP QH ]DYDUWDVG PDJDG $ PL XQDOPDVJ\HLQNUONHOOWiUJ\DOQXQN6QDXWGRNWRUUDO   *\RUVDQ D N|Q\YWiU W~OVy IHOpEHQ iOOy IRWHOHNKH] WH UHOWHP 6QDXWRW D N|Q\|NpQpO IRJYD +DUH\ DEED D NDURVV]pNEH WHOHSHGHWW DPHO\EHQ DGGLJ pQ OWHP GH pV]UHYpWOHQO~J\IRUGtWRWWDKRJ\N|Q\YH I|O|WWOiWKDVVRQ EHQQQNHW ²0LYDQ"²NpUGH]WHPKDONDQ ² (OYiOWDP ² IHOHOWH pSS~J\ VXWWRJYD GH VtSROyEE KDQJRQ9DODKDWDOiQQHYHWWHPYROQDKDPHJKDOORPH]WD W|UWpQHWHW YDJ\ H]W D EHV]pOJHWpVW GH D] ÉOORPiVRQ HODSDGW D KXPRUpU]pNHP ² eYHNHW pOWHP iW WHJQDS yWD .HOYLQ²IRO\WDWWD²6]pSNLVpYHNHWeVWH" ² 6HPPL   ² E|NWHP NL U|YLG KDER]iV XWiQ PHUW QHP WXGWDP PLW PRQGMDN .HGYHOWHP 6QDXWRW GH ~J\ 

pUH]WHP PRVW yYDNRGQRP NHOO WOH YDJ\LV LQNiEE DWWyO DPLLGHKR]WD ² 6HPPL" ² XWiQR]WD D KDQJRPDW ² 1RFVDN KiW HQQ\LUH   " ² 0L HQQ\LUH" ² DGWDP D] pUWHWOHQW +XQ\RUtWRWW J\XOODGW V]HPpYHO pV RO\DQ N|]HOUO KRJ\ DUFRPRQ pUH] WHPOHKHOHWHPHOHJpWVXWWRJQLNH]GHWW ² .iW\~ED MXWRWWXQN .HOYLQ 6DUWRULXVV]DO PiU QHP OHKHWpULQWNH]QLDQQ\LWWXGRNDPHQQ\LWPHJtUWDPQHNHG PHJ DPHQQ\LW J\|Q\|U, NLV pUWHNH]OHWQN XWiQ PRQ GRWW   ².LNDSFVROWDDYL]RIRQW"²NpUGH]WHP ² 1HP 5|YLG]iUODW YDQ QiOD $]W KLV]HP NpV]DNDUYD FVLQiOWDYDJ\  ²|NOpYHORO\DQPR]GXODWRWWHWWPLQWKD V]pWYHUQH YDODPLW 6]yWODQXO Qp]WHP 6]iMD EDO VDUND IHUGHPRVRO\UDUiQGXOW ².HOYLQD]pUWM|WWHP   (ODNDGW ²0LDV]iQGpNRG"²NpUGH]WHYpJO ² $ OHYpOUH JRQGROV]   " ² PRQGWDP ODVVDQ ² +iW PHJWHKHWHP pSSHQ QHP OiWRP RNiW KRJ\ QH WHJ\HP pSSHQH]pUWFV|UJ|NLWWXWiQDDNDUWDPQp]QL   ²1HP²V]DNtWRWWIpOEH²1HPHUUHJRQGRORN   ²1HP"   ²NpUGH]WHPFVRGiONR]iVWV]tQOHOYH²+iW DNNRUFVDNPRQGG ² 6DUWRULXV   ² PRUPROWD NLV V]QHW XWiQ ² $]W KLV]LPHJWDOiOWDDPyGMiW  WXGRG 6]HPH UiP WDSDGW 1\XJRGWDQ OWHP LJ\HNH]WHP N|]|PE|VDUFRWYiJQL ²(OV]|ULVLWWYDQD]DU|QWJHQGRORJ(POpNV]HODPLW *LEDULDQQDO FVLQiOWDN %L]RQ\RV PyGRVtWiVW OHKHWQH UDMWD HV]N|]|OQL   ²0pJSHGLJ" ² N HJ\V]HU,HQ VXJiUQ\DOiERW LUiQ\tWRWWDN D] yFHiQUDFVDNDIHV]OWVpJpWPRGXOiOWiNNO|QIpOHPLQWiN V]HULQW ² ,JHQ WXGRP (]W PiU 1LOLQ LV FVLQiOWD eV VRNDQ PiVRN ² 'H FVDN OiJ\ VXJiU]iVVDO (] PHJ NHPpQ\ YROW eV QHPVDMQiOWiNWOH5iQ\RPWiND]HJpV]NDSDFLWiVW 

²(EEOQDJ\EDMRNOHKHWQHN²MyVROWDP²0HJVpUWHWWpN D1pJ\HNpVD](16=HJ\H]PpQ\pW ² .HOYLQ   QH DGG D KO\pW 0LW V]iPtW H] PiU" *LEDULDQPHJKDOW ²eUWHPeV6DUWRULXVPRVWPLQGHQWUiDNDUNHQQL" ² 0LW WXGRP pQ (UUO QHP EHV]pOWQN 1HP pUGHNHV 6]yYDO 6DUWRULXV NLVW|WWH KRJ\ KD D ÅYHQGpJµ PLQGLJ FVDN pEUHGpVNRU MHOHQLN PHJ DNNRU Q\LOYiQ iOPXQNEDQ V]HGLNLEHOOQNDJ\iUWiVLUHFHSWHW$]WKLV]LD]DOYiVD OHJOpQ\HJHVHEE iOODSRWXQN (]pUW FVLQiOMD tJ\ 0iUPRVW 6DUWRULXVHODNDUMDNOGHQLQHNLD]pEUHQOpWQNHWD]pEHU JRQGRODWDLQNDWpUWHG" ²+RJ\DQ"3RVWiQ" ² 7DUWVG PHJ D YLFFHLGHW $ VXJiUQ\DOiERW HJ\LNQN DJ\iUDPDLIRJMiNPRGXOiOQL 9pJUHNDSFVROWDP ² -D ~J\ ² MHJ\H]WHP PHJ ² eV D] D] HJ\LNQN pQ YROQpN,JD]" ²,JHQ5iGJRQGROW ²1DJ\RQPHJWLV]WHO ²0LWV]yOV]KR]]i" +DOOJDWWDP 6]y QpONO ODVVDQ D N|Q\YpEH PHUOW +DUH\UD Qp]HWW D]XWiQ PHJLQW UiP eUH]WHP KRJ\ HOViSDGRN3HGLJN|]|Q\|VQHNDNDUWDPOiWV]DQL ²1RV"    ²NpUGH]WH 9iOODWYRQWDP ² 5|QWJHQSUpGLNiFLy D] HPEHU QDJ\V]HU,VpJpUO 6]HULQWHPWLV]WDFLUNXV]eVV]HULQWHGLV9DJ\QHP" ²$]WPRQGRG" ²$]WKiW ²$NNRUMy²pVHOYLJ\RURGRWWPLQWKDNHGYpUHWHWWHP YROQD²6]yYDOKO\HVpJQHNWDUWRG6DUWRULXVWLSSMpW" 0pJ QHP pUWHWWHP KRJ\DQ W|UWpQW GH D WHNLQWHWpEO NLROYDVKDWWDP KRJ\ RGD O\XNDGWXQN NL DKRYi  DNDUWD +DOOJDWWDPPHUWPLWLVWHKHWWHPYROQD ² 1DJ\V]HU, ² MHOHQWHWWH NL ² 0HUW YDQHJ\ PiVLN WHUY LVÉWDODNtWDQLD5RFKHNpV]OpNHW ²$]DQQLKLOiWRUW   " ² ,JHQ 6DUWRULXV PiU HOYpJH]WH D] HO]HWHV V]iPt WiVRNDW 5HiOLV D WHUYH 1LQFV LV V]NVpJ QDJ\ NDSDFLWiVUD 

eMMHOQDSSDO P,N|GKHW D NpV]OpN NRUOiWODQ LGHLJ $QWL WHUHWiOOtWHO ²9i  YiUM+RJ\YDQH]"  ² 1DJ\RQ HJ\V]HU, 1HXWULQRDQWLWpU OHV] $ UHQGHV DQ\DJRWQHPEHIRO\iVROMD&VDND   QHXWULQRV]HUNH]HWHN ERPODQDNIHOeUWHG" (OpJHGHWWHQPRVRO\JRWW7iWYDPDUDGWDV]iP0RVRO\D ODVVDQ OHKHUYDGW KRPORNiW UiQFROYD iUJXV V]HPPHO ILJ\HOW ² 6]yYDO HOYHWMN D] HOV WHUYHW D *RQGRODWDNFLyW ² NH]GWH KRVV]DEE YiUDNR]iV XWiQ ² ,JD]" -|KHW D PiVRGLN" 6DUWRULXV PiU MDYiEDQ NRWOLN UDMWD 1HYH]]N 6]DEDGViJDNFLyQDN (J\ SLOODQDWUD EHKXQ\WDP D V]HPHP +LUWHOHQ HOV]iQ WDP PDJDP 6QDXW QHP IL]LNXV 6DUWRULXV NLNDSFVROWD YDJ\|VV]HW|UWHDYL]RIRQMiW6RKDMREENRU ² eQ LQNiEE 0pV]iUV]pNDNFLyQDN QHYH]QpP   ² PRQGWDPODVVDQ ²7HLVPpV]iURVNRGWiOPiU9DJ\QHP"eVH]HJpV]HQ PiV1HPOHV]ÅYHQGpJµQHPOHV])NpS]GPpQ\VHPPL $ PDWHULDOL]iFLy SLOODQDWiEDQ D]RQQDO EHN|YHWNH]LN D IHOERPOiV ²)pOUHpUWHV]²FVyYiOWDPDIHMHP5HPpOWHPKRJ\HOpJ WHUPpV]HWHVHQ YLJ\RUJRN ² 1HP HUN|OFVL DJJiO\DLP YDQQDNFVDNIpOWHPDEU|PHW1LQFVNHGYHPHOSDWNROQL |UHJHP ²+RJ\KRJ\" /HHVHWW D] iOOD *\DQDNRGYD Qp]HJHWHWW =VHEHPEH Q\~OWDPVHOK~]WDPDJ\,U|WWSDSLURVWDNpSOHWHNNHO ² eQ LV W|UWHP D IHMHP H]HQ D GROJRQ 0LW EiPXOV]" +LV]HQ pQ GREWDP EH D] HJpV] QHXWULQRKLSRWp]LVW YDJ\ QHP" 1R Qp]G $QWLWHUHW OHKHW JHUMHV]WHQL 5HQGHV DQ\DJUD iUWDOPDWODQ (] LJD] &VDNKRJ\ D GHVWDELOL]iFLy SLOODQDWiEDQ PLNRU D QHXWULQRV]HUNH]HW HOERPOLN IHOV]D EDGXODN|WpVLHQHUJLD(J\NLORJUDPPQ\XJDOPLW|PHJUH Wt]D Q\ROFDGLNRQHUJHW V]iPtWYD HJ\HWOHQ ) NpS]GPpQ\ QpO |WV]|UKpWV]HU Wt] D NLOHQFHGLNHQ 7XGRG PLW MHOHQW H]" 0LQWKD HJ\ FVLQRV NLV XUiQW|OWHW UREEDQQD IHO D] ÉOORPiVRQ ² 8J\DQ 'H KiW   6DUWRULXV EL]WRVDQ JRQGROW HUUH   

²$]QHPRO\DQEL]WRV²PDJ\DUi]WDPNDMiQYLJ\RUUDO ²7XGRG6DUWRULXVD)UD]HU&DMROODLVNRODKtYH6]HULQWN D] HOERPOiV SLOODQDWiEDQ D] HJpV] N|WpVL HQHUJLD IpQ\VXJiU]iV DODNMiEDQ V]DEDGXO IHO (J\ YDNtWy YLOODQiV OHQQH D] HJpV] WDOiQ QHP pSSHQ YHV]pO\WHOHQ GH VHPPL HVHWUH VHP SXV]WtWy KDWiV~ &VDNKRJ\ PiVIpOH KLSR Wp]LVHN PiVIpOH HOPpOHWHN LV YDQQDN iP D QHXWULQR WpUUO  &D\HWWH V]HULQW $YDORY V]HULQW 6LRQD V]HULQW D] HPLVV]LyV WDUWRPiQ\ VRNNDO V]pOHVHEE pV PD[LPXPD pSSHQ D NHPpQ\ JDPPDVXJiUWDUWRPiQ\ED HVLN 1DJ\RQ V]pS KRJ\ 6DUWRULXV KLV] D PHVWHUHLQHN pV D] HOPpOHWNQHN GH PiV HOPpOHWHN LV YDQQDN 6QDXW eV WXGRG PLW PRQGRN" ² IRO\WDWWDP OiWYD KRJ\ ERJDUDW WHWWHPDIOpEH²$] yFHiQW LV V]iPtWiVEDNHOO YHQQL+D D]W PHJ WXGWD FVLQiOQL DPLW FVLQiOW DNNRU EL]WRVDQ D] RSWLPiOLV PyGV]HUW DONDOPD]WD eUWHG" 6]HULQWHP D] yFHiQ DNFLyMD RO\DQ pUY DPHO\ D PiVLN LVNROD PHOOHWW V]yO6DUWRULXVHOOHQ ²$GGLGHD]WDFpGXOiW.HOYLQ   2GDDGWDP )pOUHKDMWRWW IHMMHO SUyEiOWD LUNDILUNiPDW NLVLODEL]iOQL ²(]LWWPL"²PXWDWWDD]XMMiYDO 9LVV]DYHWWHPDFpGXOiW ²(]"(]DWpUWUDQV]PXWiFLyWHQ]RUD ²$GGFVDNLGH   ² 0LQHN" ² NpUGH]WHP EiU ~J\LV WXGWDP ² $KRJ\ DNDURG ² IHOHOWHP N|]|Q\|VHQ ² eQ RGDDGKDWRP &VDN WXGRGH]WNtVpUOHWLOHJPpJVHQNLVHPYL]VJiOWDHGGLJQHP LVPHUWQNLO\HQUHQGV]HUHNHW )UD]HUEHQKLV]pQ6LRQD V]HULQW V]iPtWRWWDP NL  $]W IRJMD Ui PRQGDQL KRJ\ pQ QHP YDJ\RN IL]LNXV pV 6LRQD VHP D] /HJDOiEELV D]  IHOIRJiVD V]HULQW (]HQ OHKHW YLWDWNR]QL 'H N|V]|Q|P V]pSHQD]RO\DQYLWiWDPLQHNDYpJpQHVHWOHJJ]]pYiORN 6DUWRULXVQDJ\REEGLFVVpJpUH 7pJHG PHJ WXGODN J\]QL WVRKD0HJVHSUyEiORP ² +iW PLW DNDUV] FVLQiOQL   "  H]HQ GROJR]LN ² PRUPROWD 6QDXW V]tQWHOHQ KDQJRQ gVV]HJ|UQ\HGW pOpQNVpJH Q\RPWDODQXO HOW,QW 1HP WXGWDP KLV]H QHNHPGHPiUPLQGHJ\YROW ² $PLW PLQGHQ HPEHU FVLQiO KD PHJ DNDUMiN |OQL ² IHOHOWHPKDONDQ 

² 0HJSUyEiORN EHV]pOQL YHOH +iWKD NLWDOiOW YDODPL EL]WRQViJLLQWp]NHGpVW²G|UP|JWH6QDXW5iPSLOODQWRWW ²,GHILJ\HOM pV KDPpJLV   " $] D]HOV WHUY 0LW V]yOV] KR]]i" 6DUWRULXV EHOHPHJ\ $] EL]WRV 9pJ HUHGPpQ\EHQ  H]LVHJ\OHKHWVpJ   ²7HEt]ROEHQQH" ²1HP²YiJWDUiU|JW|Q²'H  PLWiUWKDW" 1HP DNDUWDP W~O KDPDU EHOHHJ\H]QL KLV]HQ pSSHQ H] YROWDFpORP6]|YHWVpJHVHPOHWWD]LGQ\HUpVEHQ ²0HJJRQGRORP²MHOHQWHWWHPNL ² +iW DNNRU pQ PHJ\HN ² PRUPRJWD pV IHOiOOW 5RSRJWDN D FVRQWMDL DPLQW NLNiV]iOyGRWW D IRWHOEyO ² 6]yYDOFVLQiOKDWXQN UyODG HQNHIDORJUDPPRW" ² NpUGH]WH N|WpQ\pWG|U]V|OJHWYHPLQWKDYDODPLOiWKDWDWODQSHFVpWHW DNDUQDOHW|U|OQLUyOD ² 1HP EiQRP ² IHOHOWHP .LIHOp LQGXOW J\HW VH YHWYH +DUH\UDDNL|OpEHQDN|Q\YYHOQpPiQILJ\HOWHDMHOHQHWHW 0LNRU EHFVXNyGRWW XWiQD D] DMWy pQ LV IHOiOOWDP .LVLPtWRWWDP D WHQ\HUHPEH J\,UW FpGXOiW $ NpSOHWHN SRQWRVDN YROWDN 1HP KDPLVtWRWWDP PHJ NHW &VDN D]W QHP WXGRP PLW V]yOQD 6LRQD D] RNIHMWpVHPKH] $OLJKD YiOODOQigVV]HUH]]HQWHP +DUH\ VXKDQW P|JpP pV PHJ pULQWHWWHDNDURPDW ².ULV ²7HVVpNV]tYHP" ².LYROWH]" ²+LV]HQPRQGWDP6QDXWGRNWRU ²0LIpOHHPEHU" ²1HPQDJ\RQLVPHUHP0LpUWNpUGHG" ²$QQ\LUDQp]HWW   ²%L]WRVDQWHWV]HOQHNL ²1HP²Ui]WDPHJDIHMpW ²1HP~J\Qp]HWW,QNiEE~J\PLQWKD  PLQWKD   0HJERU]RQJRWW UiP HPHOWH D V]HPpW pV U|JW|Q OHV W|WWH ².ULVPHQMQNHOLQQHQ  

$FVHSSIRO\yVR[LJpQ

ÐUiP YLOiJtWy V]iPODSMiW EiPXOYD ]VLEEDGWDQ IHNG WHPDV|WpWV]REiEDQQHPWXGRPPLyWD6DMiWOpOHJ]HWH PHW KDOOJDWWDP pV FVRGiONR]WDP YDODPLQ GH PLQGH] D ]|OGHV V]iPNRV]RU~ D V]HPHP HOWW PHJ D FVRGiONR]iV WHOMHV N|]|Q\EHQ ~V]RWW DPLW D IiUDGWViJ KDWiViQDN YpO WHP 2OGDOW IRUGXOWDP D] iJ\ IXUFViQ V]pOHV YROW YDODPL KLiQ\]RWW 9LVV]DIRMWRWWDP D OpOHJ]HWHPHW 1pPD FV|QG 0HJGHUPHGWHP $ OHJFVHNpO\HEE QHV] VHP KDOODWV]RWW +DUH\" 0LpUW QHP KDOORP D OpOHJ]pVpW" 9pJLJVLPtWRWWDP D]iJ\DWHJ\HGOYROWDP ² +DUH\ ² DNDUWDP NLiOWDQL GH OpSWHNHW KDOORWWDP 1DJ\pVV~O\RVDODNN|]HOHGHWWPLQWKD   ²*LEDULDQ"²NpUGH]WHPQ\XJRGWDQ ²eQYDJ\RN1HJ\~MWVYLOODQ\W ²1HJ\~MWVDN   ²1HPNHOOÌJ\PLQGNHWWQNQHNMREEOHV] ²'HKiWWHPHJKDOWiO" ²1HPV]iPtW&VDNPHJLVPHUHGDKDQJRPDW" ²0HJ0LpUWWHWWHG" ² 0XV]iM YROW 1pJ\ QDSRW NpVWpO +D HOEE pUNH]HO WDOiQ QHP NHOOHWW YROQD GH QH WpJ\ PDJDGQDN V]HP UHKiQ\iVW1HPURVV]QHNHP ²7HLJD]iQLWWYDJ\" ²(QJHPLViORPQDNKLV]HOPLQW+DUH\W" ²+ROYDQ+DUH\" ²+RQQDQWXGRGKRJ\WXGRP" ²6HMWHP ² 7DUWVG PHJ D VHMWpVHLGHW 0RQGMXN KHO\HWWH YDJ\RN LWW ²'HpQD]WDNDURPKRJ\ LVLWWOHJ\HQ ²$]OHKHWHWOHQ ² 0LpUW" 0RQGG WXGRG WH KRJ\ LJD]iEyO QHP LV WH YDJ\KDQHPpQ" ² 7pYHGV] eQ LJD]iQ pQ YDJ\RN +D V]U|]QL DNDUV] ~J\ LV PRQGKDWRG KRJ\ PpJ HJ\V]HU pQ 'H QH YHV]WH JHVVNDV]yW 

²(OPpJ\" ²(O ²eVDNNRU YLVV]DM|Q" ²,O\HQIRQWRV"+iWPL QHNHG" ²$]D]pQGROJRP ²+LV]HQIpOV]WOH ²1HP ²8QGRURGV]WOH   ²0LWDNDUV]" ² 0DJDGDW V]iQG QH W  PLQGLJ K~V]pYHV OHV] 1H WpJ\~J\PLQWKDQHPWXGQiG +LUWHOHQIRJDOPDP VLQFV PLpUW OHFVLOODSRGWDP 7HOMHV Q\XJDORPPDO YiUWDP D IRO\WDWiVW 0LQWKD N|]HOHEE M|WW YROQDD]iJ\YpJpKH]GHRO\DQV|WpWYROWKRJ\PRVW VHP OiWWDPVHPPLW ² 0LW DNDUV]" ² NpUGH]WHP KDONDQ .LPpUW KDQJRP ~J\OiWV]LNPHJOHSWH6RNiUDYiODV]ROW ² 6DUWRULXV PHJPDJ\DUi]WD 6QDXWQDN KRJ\ EHFVDS WDG 0RVW N FVDSQDN EH WpJHG ÔJ\ WHV]QHN PLQWKD D U|QWJHQNpV]OpNHW V]HUHOQpN SHGLJ D WpUDQQLKLOiWRUW pStWLN ²+ROYDQ+DUH\"²V]|JH]WHPQHNLDNpUGpVW ² 1HP KDOORG PLW PRQGRN" 7|EEV]|U QHP ILJ\HO PH]WHWOHN ²+ROYDQ+DUH\" ² 1HP WXGRP 9LJ\i]] IHJ\YHUUH OHV] V]NVpJHG 6HQNLUHVHPV]iPtWKDWV] ²+DUH\UDV]iPtWKDWRN²PRQGWDP+DONFLNNDQiVYROW DYiODV]1HYHWHWW ² 1R LJHQ SHUV]H %L]RQ\RVKDWiULJ +LV]HQDNiUPLNRU N|YHWKHWHGDSpOGiPDW   ²7HQHPYDJ\*LEDULDQ ²0iUPHJLQWNH]GHG+iWNLYDJ\RN"$WHiOPRG" ²1HP$] EiEMXN'HWHQHPWXGV]UyOD ²eVKRQQDQWXGRGKRJ\WHNLYDJ\" (] V]|JHW W|WW D IHMHPEH )|O DNDUWDP NHOQL GH QHP EtUWDP *LEDULDQ PRQGRWW YDODPLW 1HP pUWHWWHP D V]D YDNDW FVDN D KDQJMiW KDOORWWDP HONHVHUHGHWWHQ KDUFROWDP WHVWHP J\|QJHVpJH HOOHQ PpJ HJ\V]HU WHOMHV HUPEOQHNLUXJDV]NRGWDP²pVI|OpEUHGWHP/HYHJ XWiQ NDSNRGWDPPLQWDSDUWUDYHWHWWKDO.RURPV|WpWYROW'H KLV]HQH]PpJPLQGLJiORP/LGpUFQ\RPiV0LWPRQG   

>NpS@

>UHV@

ÅRO\DQ GLOHPPD DPLW QHP YDJ\XQN NpSHVHN PHJROGDQL gQPDJXQNDW OG|]]N $ SRO\WKHULXPRN FVDN JRQGROD WDLQN V]HOHNWtY I|OHUVtWL $ MHOHQVpJ LQGtWpNDLQDN NHUH VpVH DQWURSRPRUIL]PXV $KRO QLQFVHQHN HPEHUHN RWW HPEHUL pVV]HO IHOIRJKDWy LQGtWpNRN VLQFVHQHN +RJ\ D NXWDWiVL WHUYHW IRO\WDWKDVVXN YDJ\ JRQGRODWDLQNDW NHOO PHJVHPPLVtWHQQN YDJ\ PDWHULDOL]iFLyMXNDW $] HOEEL QHP iOO PyGXQNEDQ $] XWyEEL W~OViJRVDQ KDVRQOtW D J\LONRVViJKR]µ +DOOJDWWDP D V|WpWEHQ D] HJ\HQOHWHV WiYROL KDQJRW DPHO\UOD]RQQDOWXGWDPKRJ\*LEDULDQp.LQ\~MWRWWDPD NH]HP$]iJ\UHVYROW 0HJLQWiOPRGRPJRQGROWDP ² *LEDULDQ   " ² PRQGWDP YROQD GH HOFVXNORWW D KDQJRP9DODPLNDWWDQWDUFRPDWJ\|QJHOpJiUDPFVDSWD PHJ ² 0L YDQ *LEDULDQ ² iVtWRWWDP ² ÌJ\ OG|]QL D] HPEHUWHJ\LNiORPEyODPiVLNED   6XKRJyQHV] ²*LEDULDQ²LVPpWHOWHPKDQJRVDEEDQ $]iJ\UXJyNPHJUHPHJWHN ² .ULV   pQ YDJ\RN   ² VXWWRJWD HJ\ KDQJ N|] YHWOHQODIOHPPHOOHWW ²7HYDJ\+DUH\  pV*LEDULDQ" ² .ULV   KLV]HQ     KLV]HQ WH PRQGWDG KRJ\ PHJ KDOW   ² ÉORPEDQ  D]pUW pOKHW ² GQQ\|JWHP  YRQWDWRWWDQ 0iUHJ\iOWDOiQQHPYROWDPEHQQHEL]WRVKRJ\iOPRGRP ² %HV]pOW LV ,WW YROW ² PRW\RJWDP /HUDJDGW D V]HPHP ÉOPRV YDJ\RN WHKiW DOV]RP JRQGROWDP EiYiQ DMNDP +DUH\ K,Y|VYiOOiWV~UROWD NpQ\HOPHVHQ RGDE~MWDP KR] ]i)HOHOWYDODPLWGHPiUEyGXOWiORPED]XKDQWDP 5HJJHO D Y|U|VO V]REiEDQ IHOUpPOHWWHN HOWWHP D] pMV]DNDL HVHPpQ\HN $ EHV]pOJHWpVW *LEDULDQQDO iO PRGWDP GH D]WiQ" +DOORWWDP D KDQJMiW HUUH PHJHV NGWHP YROQD FVDN QHPLJHQ HPOpNH]WHP PLW PRQGRWW 1HP LV EHV]pOJHWpVQHN UpPOHWW LQNiEE YDODPL HODGiV QDN(ODGiV   " +DUH\ PRVDNRGRWW +DOORWWDP D Yt]FVRERJiVW D IU GV]REiEyO $] iJ\ DOi Qp]WHP DKRYi QpKiQ\ QDSMD EHO|NWHPDPDJQHWRIRQW1HPYROWRWW 

²+DUH\²NLiOWRWWDP&VXURPYL]HVHQNXNNDQWRWWNLD V]HNUpQ\P|JO ² 1HP OiWWiO YpOHWOHQO D] iJ\ DODWW HJ\ PDJQHWRIRQW" 2O\DQNLV]VHEPDJQyW   ²9ROWRWWHJ\SiUYDFDN2GDWHWWHPPLQGHQW²E|N|WW D J\yJ\V]HUV]HNUpQ\ PHOOHWWL SROFUD pV HOW,QW D IUGV]REiEDQ .LXJURWWDP D] iJ\EyO GH KLiED NHUHV JpOWHP ²/iWQRGNHOOHWW²PRQGWDPPLNRUNLM|WW1HPIHOHOW )pVON|G|WWDWN|UHOWW&VDNPRVWYHWWHPpV]UHPLO\HQ ViSDGW pV DPLNRU V]HPQN WDOiONR]RWW D WN|UEHQ YDODKRJ\IUNpV] YROWDSLOODQWiVD ²+DUH\²]HQGtWHWWHPUiPHJLQWPLQWHJ\V]DPiU²D PDJQyQLQFVDSROFRQ ²(QQpOIRQWRVDEEWpPDQHPMXWHV]HGEH" ²%RFViVVPHJ²PRURJWDP²LJD]DGYDQ/pQ\HJWHOHQ 1R PpJ FVDND]KLiQ\]LNKRJ\ YHV]HNHGQL NH]GMQN $]WiQ HOPHQWQN UHJJHOL]QL +DUH\ PD PLQGHQW PiVNpSS FVLQiOW PLQW V]RNWD GH QHP WXGWDP PHJKDWiUR]QL D NO|QEVpJHW ,GHJHQO Qp]HOG|WW SiUV]RU QHP KDOORWWD PHJKRJ\V]yORNKR]]iPLQWKDHOHOUpYHGWYROQD(J\V]HU I|OQp]HWWpVOiWWDPKRJ\QHGYHVHQFVLOORJDV]HPH ²0LEDMRG"²VXWWRJWDP²6tUV]" ²ÉKDJ\MEpNpQÔJ\VHLJD]LN|QQ\HN²FVXNODGR]WD 7DOiQ QHP NHOOHWW YROQD HQQ\LEHQ KDJ\QRP GH VHPPLWO VHPUHWWHJWHPMREEDQPLQWDOHONL]pVWO.O|QEHQLVPiV JRQGRP YROW ² EiU WXGWDP KRJ\ 6QDXW pV 6DUWRULXV iUPiQ\NRGiViW FVDN iOPRGWDP PpJLV W|SUHQJHQL NH]GWHP YDQH HJ\iOWDOiQ YDODPL Np]LIHJ\YHU D] ÉOORPiVRQ 0HJ VHP IRUGXOW D IHMHPEHQ PLKH] NH]GHN YHOH²FVDNOHJ\HQ/HNHOOXJUDQRPDUDNWiUEDPRQGWDP +DUH\QDN 6]y QpONO M|WW XWiQDP ÉWNXWDWWDP D GRER]RNDW IHOW~UWDP D OiGiNDW OH HJpV]HQ D K,WKi]LJ 1HP WXGWDP HOOHQiOOQL D NpQ\V]HUQHN KRJ\ EH QH SLO ODQWVDN'HQHPDNDUWDPKRJ\+DUH\EHM|MM|QH]pUWFVDN UpVUH Q\LWRWWDP D] DMWyW pV N|UOQp]WHP $ V|WpW SRQ\YD GRPERUXODWDKRVV]~NiVYDODPLWWDNDUWGHD]DMWyEyOQHP WXGWDP PHJiOODStWDQL RWW IHNV]LNH D QpJHU Q DKRO DNNRUÔJ\UpPOHWWUHVDKHO\H 

6HPPL DONDOPDV IHJ\YHUUH QHP EXNNDQWDP HJ\UH ERVV]~VDEEDQWpQIHUHJWHPPtJHJ\V]HUFVDNIHOW,QWKRJ\ QHP OiWRP +DUH\W ,JD] U|JW|Q HONHUOW D IRO\RVyUyO GH D]pUW HOJRQGRONRGKDWWDP YROQD D]RQ PLpUW SUyEiO HOPDUDGQL WOHP DPLNRU HJ\ SHUFQ\L WiYROOpW LV RO\DQ QHKH]pUHHVLNeQD]RQEDQIRO\YiVW~J\YLVHONHGWHPPLQW DNLYDODPLPLDWWPHJVpUWG|WWYDJ\HJ\V]HU,HQPLQWDNL KO\H 0HJIiMGXOW D IHMHP FVLOODStWyW QHP WDOiOWDP GK|QJYH IRUJDWWDP IHO D J\yJ\V]HUV]HNUpQ\W $ P,WEH QHPDNDUy]RWWOHPHQQLULWNDSRFVpNKDQJXODWEDQYROWDP +DUH\ QHV]WHOHQO M|WWPHQW D NDELQEDQ QpKD HOW,QW HJ\ LGUH PDMG GpOXWiQ PLNRU PiU PHJHEpGHOWQN LOOHWYH  HJ\iOWDOiQ QHP HYHWW pQ PHJ pWYiJ\WDODQ YROWDP D KDVRJDWyIHMIiMiVWyOpVQHPLVNtQiOJDWWDP HJ\V]HUFVDN OHOWPHOOpPpVNDSLUJiOQLNH]GWHD]XEERQ\RPXMMiW ² 1R PL YDQ" ² PRUPRJWDP JpSLHVHQ )|O V]HUHWWHP YROQD PHQQL ~J\ UpPOHWW NRSiFVROiV KDON YLVV]KDQJMiW KR]]iN D FV|YHN 6DUWRULXV EL]WRVDQ D PDJDVIHV]OWVpJ, NpV]OpNHW EW\N|OL GH U|JW|Q HOPHQW D NHGYHP PHUW HV]HPEH MXWRWW KRJ\ +DUH\ XWiQDP M|QQH MHOHQOpWH D N|Q\YWiUEDQ PpJ ~J\DKRJ\ LQGRNROKDWy YROW GH RWW IHQW DJpSHNN|]|WW6QDXWLGpWOHQPHJMHJ\]pVHNHWWHKHW ².ULV²VXWWRJWD+DUH\²KRJ\iOODGRORJNHWWQNNHO" $NDUDWODQXOIHOVyKDMWRWWDP,JD]iQ QHP PRQGKDWQiP KRJ\V]HUHQFVpVQDSRPYROW ²$OHKHW OHJMREEDQ0LEDMRGYDQPiUPHJLQW" ²6]HUHWQpNHJ\NLFVLWEHV]pOJHWQLYHOHG ²7HVVpN)LJ\HOHN ²'HQHPtJ\ ²+iWKRJ\"7XGRGMyOPHQQ\LUHIiMDIHMHPUHQJHWHJ JRQGRPYDQ   ²(J\NLVMyDNDUDWRW.ULV 0RVRO\UDNpQ\V]HUtWHWWHPPDJDP6LUDOPDVOHKHWHWW ²-yOYDQGUiJiP%HV]pOM ²'HPHJPRQGRGD]LJD]DW" )HOYRQWDPDV]HP|OG|N|P1HPWHWV]HWWH]DEHYH]HW ²0LpUWKD]XGQpN" ²+iWKDRNRGYDQUi.RPRO\RNRG'HKDD]WDNDURG KRJ\  WXGRG  DNNRUQHKD]XGMQHNHP 

+DOOJDWWDP ² eQ PHJPRQGRN YDODPLW pV WH LV PHJPRQGDV] YD ODPLW-y"'HD]LJD]DW$NiUPLOHJ\HQLV 1HPQp]WHPDV]HPpEHSHGLJNHUHVWHDSLOODQWiVRPDW ÔJ\WHWWHPPLQWKDQHPYHQQpPpV]UH ² 0RQGWDP PiU QHNHG   pQ QHP WXGRP KRQQpW NHUOWHPLGH/HKHWKRJ\WHWXGRG9iUMPpJpQEHV]pOHN $]LVOHKHWKRJ\QHPWXGRG'HKDWXGRGFVDNPRVWQHP PRQGKDWRGPHJDNNRUWDOiQPDMGHJ\V]HUNpVEE" 0pJ tJ\LVMyOHQQH/HJDOiEEPDUDGQDYDODPLUHPpQ\HP -HJHVERU]RQJiVIXWRWWUDMWDPYpJLJ ² 0LNHW EHV]pOV] J\HUHN" 0LFVRGD UHPpQ\   " ² GDGRJWDP ² .ULV DNiUPL YDJ\RN J\HUHN EL]WRVDQ QHP 0HJt JpUWHG%HV]pOM (] D] ÅDNiUPL YDJ\RNµ HOV]RUtWRWWD D WRUNRPDW FVDN EiPXOWDP pV HV]HOVHQ Ui]WDP D IHMHP PLQWKD N|Q\| U|JQpNKRJ\QHNHOOMHQW|EEHWKDOODQRP ²+iWQHPpUWHGKDQHPOHKHWQHPRQGGPHJ &VDN DQQ\LWPRQGMKRJ\QHPOHKHW ²1HPWLWNRORNVHPPLW  ²Q\|JWHPNLUHNHGWHQ ²$NNRUMy²PRQGWDpVIHOiOOW6]yOQLDNDUWDPYDODPLW pUH]WHP KRJ\ QHP KDJ\KDWRP tJ\ GH NpSWHOHQ YROWDP EHV]pOQL ²+DUH\   +iWWDO iOOW QHNHP NLQp]HWWD]DEODNRQ 6|WpWNpN UHV yFHiQWHUOWHODPH]WHOHQpJDODWW ² +DUH\ KD D]W KLV]HG   +DUH\ KLV]HQ WXGRG KRJ\ V]HUHWOHN   ²(QJHP" 2GDPHQWHP pV iW DNDUWDP |OHOQL .LERQWDNR]RWW HOO|NWHDNH]HPHW ² 0LO\HQ MyViJRV YDJ\   ² YHWHWWH RGD ² 6]HUHWV]" %iULQNiEEYHUQpO ²+DUH\GUiJiP ²1H1H$NNRULQNiEEKDOOJDVV $] DV]WDOKR] PHQW HONH]GWH OHV]HGQL D] HGpQ\W .LEi PXOWDP D V|WpWNpN YpJWHOHQEH /HIHOp PHQW D QDS D] ÉOORPiVQDJ\iUQ\pNDHJ\HQOHWHVHQULQJRWWDKXOOiPRNRQ +DUH\ OHHMWHWW HJ\ WiQ\pUW $ PRVRJDWyEDQ ]XER 

JRWW D Yt] $] pJ DOMiQ D UW V]tQ DUDQ\FVtNRV SLV]NRVY| U|VEHPHQWiW&VDNWXGQiPPLWFVLQiOMDNÐFVDNWXG QiP+LUWHOHQFV|QGWiPDGW+DUH\P|J|WWHPiOOW ²1H  1HIRUGXOMPHJ²VXWWRJWD²7HVHPPLUOVHP WHKHWV].ULV7XGRP1HJ\|W|UGPDJDG 8WiQDQ\~OWDP $ V]RED VDUNiED PHQHNOW IHONDSRWW HJ\FVRPyWiQ\pUWpVNLMHOHQWHWWH ² 'H NiU KRJ\ W|UKHWHWOHQHN -XM GH I|OGK|] YiJQiP D]HJpV]HW (J\ SLOODQDWLJ D]W KLWWHP FVDNXJ\DQ D I|OGK|] YiJMD GHUiPYLOODQWDV]HPHpVHOPRVRO\RGRWW ²1HIpOMQHPFVLQiORNMHOHQHWHNHW $] pMV]DND NHOOV N|]HSpQ IHOpEUHGWHP WLV]WD IHMMHO pEHUHQILJ\HOYHOWHPI|OD]iJ\RQ D V]REDV|WpW YROWD] DMWyUpVHQ iW KDOYiQ\ IpQ\FVtN HVHWW EH D IRO\RVyUyO 0pUJHVHQ V]LV]HJHWW YDODPL HJ\UH KDQJRVDEEDQ N|]EHQ PpO\ WRPSD FVDWWDQiVRN KDOODWV]RWWDN PLQWKD HJ\ QDJ\ WHVW YiJyGQD D IDOKR] 0HWHRU ² KDVtWRWW EHOpP ² ÉWW|WWHDSiQFpOW9DODNLYDQRWW(OQ\~MWRWWK|UJpV 7HOMHVHQ NLMy]DQRGWDP (] D] ÉOORPiV QHP UDNpWD pV D]DV]|UQ\, KDQJ   .LURKDQWDP D IRO\RVyUD $ NLVODERU DMWDMD IpOLJ Q\LWYD YROWEHQWpJHWWDYLOODQ\2GDIXWRWWDP 'HUPHV]W KLGHJ FVDSRWW PHJ $ NDELQW EHW|OW SiUD KyYi IDJ\DV]WRWWD D OHKHOHWHW )HKpU SLKpN NHULQJWHN D SDGOyQYRQDJOyIUGN|SHQ\EHEXUNROWWHVWI|O|WW0LKHO\W PHJOiWWDPDMHJHVIHOKEHQRGDXJURWWDPIHOQ\DOiEROWDP K|UJ|WW N|SHQ\H pJHWWH D NH]HPHW NLERWODGR]WDP YHOH D IRO\RVyUDYpJLJD]DMWyNHOWWPiUQHPpUH]WHPDKLGHJHW FVDN OHKHOHWpQHN SiUDJRPRO\DL SHU]VHOWpN D YiOODPDW PLQWDOiQJ $] DV]WDOUD IHNWHWWHP I|OWpSWHP D N|SHQ\W HJ\ SLO ODQDWLJQp]WHPDUHPHJ DUFRWiOODNLKHJ\HVHGHWWQ\LWRWW V]iMiUD UiIDJ\RWW D YpU DMNiW IHNHWpV ]~]PDUD YRQWD EH Q\HOYpQMpJNULVWiO\RNFVLOORJWDN   &VHSSIRO\yVR[LJpQ$ODERUEDQFVHSSIRO\yVR[LJpQYROW 'HZDUHGpQ\HNEHQ  pUH]WHP D] YHJFVHUpS URSRJiViW D OiEDP DODWW PLNRU +DUH\W I|OHPHOWHP 0HQQ\LW LKDWRWW EHOOH"0LQGHJ\6]pWURQFVROWDDQ\HOFV|YpWDJpJpMpWD WGHMpW $ FVHSSIRO\yV R[LJpQ SXV]WtWyEE KDWiV~ PLQW D W|PpQ\ VDYDN (J\UH J\|QJpEE OpOHJ]HWYpWHOpW



SDStUV]DNtWiVKR] KDVRQOy V]iUD] ]|UHM NtVpUWH 6]HPH FVXNYDYROW$JyQLD 9pJLJSLOODQWRWWDP D P,V]HUHNNHO RUYRVViJRNNDO WHOL KDWDOPDV YHJV]HNUpQ\HNHQ *pJHPHWV]pV" /pJ]FV " 'H PiU QLQFV WGHMH 6]pWURQFVROyGRWW 2UYRVViJ" 0HQQ\L RUYRVViJ 6]tQHV YHJFVpNNHO pV GRER]RNNDO W|P|WW SROFRN +|UJpVH EHW|OW|WWH D WHUPHW Q\LWRWW V]iMiEyOWRYiEEUDLVSiUDJRPRO\RNW|UWHNHO 0HOHJtWSiUQiN   .HUHVJpOQL NH]GWHP D]WiQ DEEDKDJ\WDP D PiVLN V]HNUpQ\KH] XJURWWDP |VV]HYLVV]D GREiOWDP D] LQMHNFLyV GRER]RNDW KRODIHFVNHQGDVWHULOL]iOyEDQ JpPEHUHGHWW NH]HPPHO QHP EtUWDP |VV]HUDNQL XMMDLP QHP KDMORWWDN 'K|PEHQ |N|OOHO YHUWHP D VWHULOL]iOy I|GHOpW GH QHP LV pUH]WHP HQ\KH EL]VHUJpV YROW PLQGHQ HUHGPpQ\ $ KDOGRNOy HUVHEEHQ K|UJ|WW 2GDXJURWWDP 1\LWYD YROW D V]HPH ²+DUH\ 0pJ VXWWRJiV VHP M|WW NL D V]iPRQ 1HP EtUWDP PHJ V]yODOQL $UFRP LGHJHQ ]DYDUy JLSV]iODUF YROW %RUGiL HPHONHGWHNpVVOO\HGWHNIHKpUEUHDODWWD]ROYDGyKyWyO QHGYHVKDMDV]pWWHUOWDWiPOiQ(QJHPQp]HWW ²+DUH\ 7|EEHW QHP WXGWDP NLQ\|JQL 7XVNyNpQW iOOWDP GHU PHGWLGHJHQNH]HLPPHOOiEDPDMNDPV]HPKpMDPHJ\UH MREEDQ pJHWW GH DOLJ pUH]WHP D PHOHJEHQ IHOROYDGy YpU HJ\ FV|SSMH IHUGH YRQDODW UDM]ROYD OHIXWRWW D] DUFiQ 1\HOYHPHJUiQGXOWpVHOW,QW6]DNDGDWODQXOK|UJ|WW 0HJIRJWDPDFVXNOyMiWSXO]XVDQHPYROWV]pWWiUWDPD N|SHQ\W pV D GHUPHV]WHQ KLGHJ WHVWUH Q\RPWDP D I OHPHW D PHOOH DOi 0iJO\D URSRJiViKR] KDVRQOy KDQJRW KDOORWWDP GH D]RQ iW D V]iPROKDWDWODQXO J\RUV YiJWDWy V]tYYHUpVW LV ÉOOWDP I|Op KDMROYD FVXNRWW V]HPPHO HJ\ V]HUUH FVDN D IHMHPKH] pUW YDODPL +DMDPED PDUNROW 5iPHUHGWHP ² .ULV ² K|U|JWH 0HJIRJWDP D NH]pW V]RUtWiVD PDMGQHP V]pW]~]WD D] XMMDLPDW DUFD ERU]DOPDVDQ HOWRU ]XOW D] |QWXGDW HOW,QW UyOD NLIRUGXOW D V]HPH IHKpUMH WRUNiEyO EXJ\ERUpNROiV W|UW HO J|UFV|VHQ UiQJDWy]RWW $OLJ EtUWDP WDUWDQL IpOLJ OHFV~V]RWW D] DV]WDOUyO )HMpW D SRUFHOiQ W|OFVpU V]pOpEH YHUWH ÉWIRJWDP pV D] DV]WDOKR] 

V]RUtWRWWDP PLQGHQ ~MDEE URKDP NLWpSWH D NDURPEyO KLUWHOHQ HO|QW|WW D YHUtWpN WpUGHP PDMGQHP |VV]HFVXN ORWW0LNRUDJ|UFV|NHQ\KOWHNPHJSUyEiOWDPOHIHNWHWQL 6tSROYD NDSNRGRWW OHYHJ XWiQ $ V]|UQ\, YpUHV DUFEyO HJ\V]HUFVDNUiPQp]HWW+DUH\V]HPH ².ULV²K|U|JWH²PHGGLJ  PHGGLJPpJ.ULV" )XOGRNROQLNH]GHWWKDE]RWWDV]iMDPHJLQWJ|UFV|NEHQ YRQDJORWW 9pJV HUPPHO WDUWRWWDP +DQ\DWW ]XKDQW IRJDL|VV]HNRFFDQWDN]LKiOW ² 1HP QHP QHP ² O|NWH NL PLQGHQ OpOHJ]HWWHO pV PLQGHJ\LN D] XWROVyQDN UpPOHWW 'H D J|UFV|N PpJ HJ\ V]HU YLVV]DWpUWHN PHJLQW D NDURPEDQ KiQ\NROyGRWW V,U,Q NDSNRGYD D OHYHJW DNNRUD HUIHV]tWpVVHO KRJ\ ERUGiL NLXJURWWDN 1\LWRWW YDNV]HPH YpJUH IpOLJ OH]iUXOW 0HJGHUPHGW(]DYpJJRQGROWDP1HPLVSUyEiOWDPOHW| U|OQL V]iMiUyO D Uy]VDV]tQ KDERW I|Op KDMROWDP YDODPL WiYROL QDJ\ KDUDQJ ]~JRWW EHQQHP YiUWDP D] XWROVy OHKHOHWHW KRJ\ D]WiQ D I|OGUH ]XKDQMDN GH PpJ HJ\UH OpOHJ]HWW DOLJ K|U|JYH HJ\UH FV|QGHVHEEHQ pV PHOOpQ DPHO\PiUFVDNQHPPR]GXODWODQYROWHJ\V]HUFVDNPHJ OiWWDP D V]tYYHUpV VHEHV ONWHWpVpW *|UQ\HGWHQ iOOWDP I|O|WWH DUFD V]tQHVHGQL NH]GHWW 0pJ QHP IRJWDP IHO VHPPLW FVDN QHGYHV OHWW D WHQ\HUHP pV ~J\ UpPOHWW PHJVNHWOWHP YDODPL UXJDOPDV OiJ\ PDVV]D W|PL HO D IOHPHW GH D]pUW PRVW LV KDOORWWDP D KDUDQJ ]~JiViW WRPSiQNRQJRWWPLQWKDPHJUHSHGWYROQDDV]tYH .LQ\LWRWWDDV]HPpWpVSLOODQWiVXQNWDOiONR]RWW ² +DUH\ ² DNDUWDP PRQGDQL GH PLQWKD QHP YROQD V]iMDPDUFRPPHUHYQHKp]iODUFFVDNQp]QLWXGRN 7HNLQWHWH N|UEHIXWRWW D V]REiQ IHMH PHJPR]GXOW KDORWWL FV|QG YROW 0|J|WWHP YDODPL PiVLN WiYROL YLOiJ EDQHJ\HQOHWHVHQFV|S|J|WWDYt]DURVV]XOHO]iUWFVDSEyO .|Q\|NpUH WiPDV]NRGRWW )HOOW +iWUDKN|OWHP 5iP WDSDGWDV]HPH ² 0L D]   PL W|UWpQW   " ² NH]GWH ² 1HP   VLNHUOW"0LpUW   "0LpUWQp]HOtJ\UiP   " eVKLUWHOHQIHOVLNROWRWW ²0LpUWQp]HOtJ\UiP &V|QGOHWW$NH]pWEiPXOWD0HJPR]JDWWDD]XMMDLW ²(]pQYDJ\RN   "



² +DUH\ ² PRQGWDP KDQJ QpONO FVDN D] DMNDPPDO )|OHPHOWHDIHMpW ² +DUH\   " ² YLVV]KDQJR]WD /DVVDQ OHVLNORWW D] DV]WDOUyOpVWDOSUDiOOW0HJLQJRWWYLVV]DQ\HUWHD]HJ\HQ V~O\iW QpKiQ\ OpSpVW WHWW YDODPL NO|Q|V G|EEHQHWEHQ 5iPQp]HWWGHPLQWKDQHPLVOiWQD ² +DUH\" ² LVPpWHOWH ODVVDQ ² 'H   pQ   pQ QHP YDJ\RN +DUH\ +iW DNNRU   NL YDJ\RN"    +DUH\" eV WHWH" 6]HPHKLUWHOHQNLWiJXOWIHOUDJ\RJRWWEROGRJPRVRO\pV PpO\VpJHVFVRGiONR]iVVXKDQWiWD]DUFiQ ²9DJ\WHLV"7HLV" 1HP IHOHOWHP 9iOODP D V]HNUpQ\KH] WDSDGW ² HJpV]HQ RGiLJKiWUiOWDPUpPOHWHPEHQ /HKDQ\DWORWWDNDUMD ²1HP²PRQGWD²1HPKLV]HQIpOV]'HpUWVGPHJpQ PiUQHPEtURP 1HP PHJ\ eQ QHP WXGWDP VHPPLW eV PRVW   PRVW VHP pUWHN VHPPLW +LV]HQ H] OHKHWHWOHQVpJ   ²0HOOpKH]V]RUtWRWWDNLIHKpUHGHWW|NOpW ² eQ VHPPLW VH WXGRN VHPPL PiVW FVDN +DUH\W $]W KLV]HG KD]XGRN" 1HP KD]XGRN ~J\ pOMQN KRJ\ QHP KD]XGRN (OVtUWD PDJiW pV ]RNRJYD D I|OGUH RPORWW 0LQWKD EpNO\yW W|UW YROQD OH UyODP RGDXJURWWDP KR]]i YiOORQ UDJDGWDPYHUJGYHN|QQ\WHOHQO]LKiOYDSUyEiOWHOO|NQL ² +DJ\MiO ² NLiOWR]WD ² +DJ\MiO +LV]HQ XWiOV] 7XGRP ÌJ\ QHP NHOO 1HP NHOO +LV]HQ OiWRG OiWRG KRJ\H]QHPpQYDJ\RNQHPpQQHPpQ   ² +DOOJDVV ² RUGtWRWWDP pV PHJUi]WDP D YiOOiQiO IRJYD HJ\PiV HOWW WpUGHOWQN pV PLQGNHWWHQ |QNtYOHW EHQ NLDEiOWXQN )HMH PHJPHJUiQGXOW D YiOODPRQ WHOMHV HUPEO PDJDPKR] V]RUtWRWWDP +LUWHOHQ DEEDKDJ\WXN D YLDVNRGiVW=LKiOWXQN$FVDSEyOHJ\HQOHWHVHQFV|S|J|WWD Yt] ² .ULV   ² GDGRJWD YiOODPUD KDMWYD DUFiW ² PRQGG PHJPLWFVLQiOMDNKRJ\QHOHJ\HN.ULV   ²1HEHV]pOMtJ\ ²NLiOWRWWDP )|OHPHOWHDIHMpW+RVV]DQUiPQp]HWW ² +iW   WH VH WXGRG" 6HPPLW VH OHKHW FVLQiOQL" 6HPPLW" ²+DUH\  N|Q\|UOM   

²eQDNDUWDP  KLV]HQOiWWDG1H1H+DJ\MiOQHpUM KR]]iPQHPDNDURP8WiOV] ²1HPLJD] ²+D]XGV]+RJ\QHXWiOQiO0LNRUpQ  pQPDJDPLV ÐFVDNOHKHWQH  FVDNVLNHUOQH   ²0HJ|OQpGPDJDG ²0HJ ² 'H pQ QHP DNDURP pUWHG" 1HP DNDURP KRJ\ PHJ|OGPDJDG$]WDNDURPKRJ\LWWOpJ\YHOHPpVVHPPL PiVQHPNHOODYLOiJRQ $]yULiVLV]UNHV]HPHNPDJXNED|OHOWHN ²+RJ\KD]XGV]  ²V~JWDHJpV]HQKDONDQ (OHQJHGWHPpVI|OiOOWDP/HOWDSDGOyUD ² 0RQGG PLW FVLQiOMDN KRJ\ HOKLGG" $]W PRQGRP DPLWJRQGRORNeVH]D]LJD]ViJ6HPPLPiV ²1HPPRQGKDWV]LJD]DWeQQHPYDJ\RN+DUH\ ²$NNRUNLYDJ\" 6RNiLJ KDOOJDWRWW 1pKiQ\V]RU PHJUHPHJHWW D] iOOD PDMGOHKDMWRWWIHMMHOVXWWRJWD ² +iW +DUH\   GH   GH WXGRP KRJ\ H] QHP LJD] 1HPHQJHPV]HUHWWpO  DNNRUUpJHQ   ² 0LQGHJ\ ² IHOHOWHP ² $PL YROW HOP~OW $QQDN YpJH 'HLWWPRVWWpJHGV]HUHWOHNeUWHG" 0HJUi]WDDIHMpW ² -y YDJ\ KR]]iP 1H KLGG KRJ\ QHP WXGRP PLO\HQ UHQGHVHQ YLVHONHGWpO ,JD]iQ D OHKHW OHJUHQGHVHEEHQ 'H KiWLWWQLQFVPLWWHQQL0LNRUKiURPQDSMDKDMQDOEDQD] iJ\DGPHOOHWWOWHPpVYiUWDPKRJ\IHOpEUHGMDNNRUPpJ QHP WXGWDP VHPPLW ÔJ\ pU]HP ERU]DV]Wy UpJHQ YROW .HOHNyW\iQ YLVHONHGWHP XJ\H" 0LQWKD N|G OW YROQD D] DJ\DPRQ 1HP HPOpNH]WHP PL YROW HOEE PL NpVEE pV VHPPLQ VH FVRGiONR]WDP ~J\ YDODKRJ\ PLQW HJ\ WDUWyV DOWDWiV YDJ\ HJ\ KRVV]~ EHWHJVpJ XWiQ *RQGROWDP LV KRJ\ WDOiQ EHWHJ YROWDP FVDN QHP DNDURG PHJPRQGDQL 'H D]WiQ HJ\UH W|EE IXUFVDViJRW YHWWHP pV]UH 7XGRG PLNHW 2WW D N|Q\YWiUEDQ PLNRU D]]DO D KRJ\ KtYMiN 6QDXWWDO EHV]pOJHWWpO PiU GHUHQJHWW YDODPL 'H KLiED IDJJDWWDODN KiW I|ONHOWHP pMMHO pV EHNDSFVROWDP D]W D PDJQyW (EEHQ D] HJ\EHQ KD]XGWDP .ULV PHUW FVDNXJ\DQpQGXJWDPHO+RJ\LVKtYMiNDNLEHV]pOUDMWD" 

²*LEDULDQ ² ,JHQ *LEDULDQ $NNRU PLQGHQW PHJpUWHWWHP EiU YROWDNpSSHQ PRVW VHP pUWHN VHPPLW &VDN HJ\HW QHP WXGWDP KRJ\ pQ QHP OHKHWHN   QHP YDJ\RN   KRJ\ tJ\ YpJ]GLN   KRJ\ QLQFV YpJH (UUO QHP EHV]pOW ,OOHWYH WDOiQ EHV]pOW GH I|OpEUHGWpO pV NLNDSFVROWDP D PDJQyW $ OpQ\HJHW PiU ~J\LV KDOORWWDP D]W KRJ\ QHP YDJ\RNHPEHUFVDNHV]N|] ²0LFVRGD" ² ,JHQ $ UHDNFLyLG YL]VJiODWiKR] YDJ\ PLKH] 0LQG HJ\LNW|NQHN YDQ HJ\ LO\HQ   DPLO\HQ pQ YDJ\RN $] HPOpNHLDODSMiQD]HOIRMWRWWNpS]HWHLDODSMiQYDODKRJ\tJ\ PRQGWD .O|QEHQ ~J\LV WXGRG VRNNDO MREEDQ PLQW pQ 2O\DQERU]DV]WyYDOyV]tQ,WOHQGROJRNDWPRQGRWWKRJ\KD QHPHJ\H]LNPLQGHQWDOiQHOVHKLV]HP ²0LHJ\H]LN" ²+iWKRJ\QLQFVV]NVpJHPDOYiVUDPHJKRJ\IRO\WRQ D VDUNDGEDQ NHOO OHQQHP 7HJQDS UHJJHO PpJ D]W KLWWHP J\,O|OV]pVEROGRJWDODQYROWDP+RJ\OHKHWWHPLO\HQEXWD XUDPLVWHQ 'H KiW PRQGG VHMWKHWWHP pQ H]W" +LV]HQ  HJ\iOWDOiQ QHP J\,O|OWH D]W D]   |YpW GH KRJ\ EHV]pOW UyOD $NNRU pUWHWWHP PHJ KRJ\ WHOMHVHQ PLQGHJ\ DNiUPLW FVLQiORN QHNHG PLQGHQNpSSHQ NtQV]HQYHGpV 9DJ\ PpJ URVV]DEE PHUW D NtQ]yHV]N|] pOHWWHOHQ pV iUWDWODQPLQWDNDPLDIHMHGUHHVKHWpVDJ\RQWKHW'H KRJ\D NtQ]yHV]N|]FVXSDMy V]iQGpNpV V]HUHOHPOHJ\HQ D]W QHP WXGWDP HONpS]HOQL 6]HUHWQpP OHJDOiEE HOPRQGDQL QHNHG PLW pUH]WHP DPLNRU D]W D V]DODJRW KDOOJDWWDP pV YpJUH PHJpUWHWWHP 7DOiQ KDV]QiW YHKHWQpG/HLVSUyEiOWDPtUQL   ²$]pUWJ\~MWRWWiOYLOODQ\W"²VXWWRJWDPUHNHGWHQPHUW KLUWHOHQHOV]RUXOWDWRUNRP ² $]pUW 'H QHP VLNHUOW 7XGRG D]W NHUHVWHP PDJDPEDQ  NHWpUWHGD]WDPiVYDODPLWWLV]WDUOHW YROW (J\ GDUDELJ ~J\ UpPOHWW QLQFV LV WHVWHP D EU|P DODWW YDODPL PiV YDQ EHQQHP   FVDN IHOV]tQ YDJ\RN +RJ\WpJHGEHFVDSMDODNeUWHG" ²eUWHP ²0LNRUD]HPEHUpMV]DNDIHNV]LNyUiNKRVV]DWFVXGD PHVV]LUH NDODQGR]QDN D JRQGRODWDL QDJ\RQ IXUFVD YLGpNHNUHWXGRG   

²7XGRP   ² 'H KiW pUH]WHP D V]tYHP GRERJiViW PHJ DUUD LV HPOpNH]WHP KRJ\ YpUYL]VJiODWRW FVLQiOWiO 0LO\HQ D Yp UHP.ULVPRQGGPHJD]LJD]DW0RVWPiUHOPRQGKDWRG ²8J\DQRO\DQPLQWD]HQ\pP ²,JD]iQ" ²(VNV]|P ² +RJ\ OHKHW D]" -D pV PpJ DUUD LV JRQGROWDP KRJ\ D]DPiVYDODPLWDOiQHOYDQUHMWYHEHQQHPpUWHG  HJ\ SLFLNH VHMW YDJ\ PL &VDN D]W QHP WXGWDP KRO OHKHW (J\pENpQW D]W KLV]HP PLQGH] FVDN UJ\ YROW PHUW QDJ\RQ IpOWHP DWWyO DPLW WHQQL DNDUWDP pV WXODM GRQNpSSHQ YDODPL PiV NLYH]HW XWDW NHUHVWHP 'H .ULV KD XJ\DQRO\DQ D YpUHP   KD ~J\ YDQ DKRJ\ PRQ GRG   /HKHWHWOHQ +LV]HQ DNNRU PiU QHP pOQpN LJD]" 6]yYDOPpJLVYDQYDODPLGHKRO"$IHMHPEHQ"'HKiWpQ XJ\DQ~J\ JRQGRONR]RP   pV VHPPLW VHP WXGRN   +D D]]DOJRQGRONR]QpNDNNRUHOHMpWOIRJYDPLQGHQWWXGQRP NHOOHWW YROQD pV QHP V]HUHWQpOHN FVDN V]tQOHOQpP pV WXGQiPLVKRJ\V]tQOHOHP   .|Q\|UJ|N.ULVPRQGMHO PLQGHQWDPLWWXGV]KiWKDPpJLVOHKHWYDODPLWFVLQiOQL" ²&VLQiOQL"0LW" 1HPIHOHOW ²0HJDNDUV]KDOQL" ²$]WKLV]HPLJHQ (OKDOOJDWWXQNÉOOWDP D SDGOyQ NXSRUJy OiQ\ I|O|WW pV WpWRYiQ Qp]WHP D WHUHP UHV N|]HSpW D IHKpUUH ]R PiQFR]RWW JpSHNHW D V]DQDV]pW KHYHU IpQ\HV P,V]HUH NHWPLQWKDYDODPLQDJ\RQIRQWRVDWNHUHVQpNGHKLiED ²+DUH\HOPRQGKDWRNYDODPLWpQLV" 6]yWODQXOILJ\HOW ² ,JD] KRJ\ QHP YDJ\ HJpV]HQ RO\DQ PLQW pQ 'H D]W QH KLGG KRJ\ YDODPL URVV]DEE YDJ\ (OOHQNH]OHJ .O|QEHQ JRQGROKDWV] HUUO DPLW DNDUV] GH H]pUW   QHPKDOWiOPHJ 6]iQDOPDVJ\HUHNHVPRVRO\|PO|WWHOD]DUFiQ ²$]WPRQGRG  KDOKDWDWODQYDJ\RN" ² 1HP WXGRP 0LQGHQHVHWUH VRNNDO NHYpVEp YDJ\ KDODQGyPLQWpQ ²%RU]DV]Wy²VXWWRJWD 

²7DOiQQHPLVRO\DQERU]DV]WyPLQWKLV]HG ²1RD]pUWDOLJKDLULJ\HOV]   ² 1HP HUUO YDQ V]y +DUH\ ,QNiEE D    VRUVRGUyO WDOiQtJ\QHYH]QpP$]DKHO\]HWKRJ\LWWD]ÉOORPiVRQD WH VRUVRG OpQ\HJpEHQ pSSRO\DQ EL]RQ\WDODQ PLQW D] HQ\pP YDJ\ EiUPHO\LNQNp (]HN IRO\WDWQL DNDUMiN *L EDULDQNtVpUOHWpWpVEiUPLPHJW|UWpQKHW ²9DJ\VHPPL ² 9DJ\ VHPPL pV V]LQWpQ V]yOYD MREEDQ V]HUHWQpP KD VHPPL VH W|UWpQQH QHP LV DQQ\LUD IpOHOHPEO EiU DOLJKDQHP H] LV V]HUHSHW MiWV]LN QHP WXGRP  KDQHP D]pUW PHUW ~J\ VLQFV pUWHOPH (EEHQ D] HJ\EHQ EL]WRV YDJ\RN ² 0LQHN QLQFV pUWHOPH" ,WW HUUO D]   yFHiQUyO YDQ V]y" 0HJERU]RQJRWW ² ,JHQ $ NDSFVRODWUyO 6]HULQWHP OpQ\HJpEHQ URSSDQW HJ\V]HU, D NpUGpV $ NDSFVRODW EL]RQ\RV WDSDV]WDODWRN IRJDOPDN YDJ\ OHJDOiEE N|YHWNH]PpQ\HN iOODSRWRN FVHUpMpW MHOHQWL QR GH KD QLQFV PLW NLFVHUpOQL" +D D] HOHIiQW QHP HJ\ yULiVL EDNWpULXP DNNRU D] yFHiQ VHP OHKHWHJ\yULiVLDJ\3HUV]HPLQGNpWIpONLIHMWKHWEL]RQ\RV KDWiVRNDW (J\ LO\HQ KDWiV MyYROWiEyO Qp]OHN PRVW pV SUyEiORP PHJPDJ\DUi]QL KRJ\ GUiJiEE YDJ\ QHNHP PLQW D] D WL]HQNpW pY DPLW D 6RODULVQDN V]HQWHOWHP pV KRJ\ YHOHG DNDURN PDUDGQL 6]iQKDWWDN WpJHG NtQ]yHV] N|]QHN V]tYHV DMiQGpNQDN YDJ\ FVDN PLNURV]NRSLNXV Nt VpUOHWQHN /HKHWV] WH EDUiWL JHV]WXV DODWWRPRV G|IpV J~Q\ROyGiV   7DOiQ PLQG HJ\V]HUUH YDJ\ DPLW D OHJ YDOyV]tQ,EEQHN WDUWRN YDODPL HJpV]HQ PiV GH YpJHUHG PpQ\EHQ PLW pUGHNHO HQJHP pV WpJHG V]OHLQN V]iQGpND KD PpJRO\DQ NO|QE|] V]OHLQN YROWDN LV" $]W PRQG KDWRG HWWO D V]iQGpNWyO IJJ D M|YQN pV LJD]DG YDQ 1HP OiWKDWRP HOUH PL OHV] 7H VHP 0pJ D]W VH PRQG KDWRP KRJ\ PLQGLJ V]HUHWQL IRJODN +D PiU HQQ\L PLQ GHQW|UWpQWDNNRUEiUPLPHJW|UWpQKHW+ROQDSWDOiQ]|OG PHG~]DOHV]EHOOHP(]QHPWOQNIJJ'HDEEDQDPL WOQNIJJHJ\WWOHV]QN.HYpVH] " ² ,GH ILJ\HOM   ² NH]GWH ² PpJ YDODPLW   0RQGG pQ  QDJ\RQKDVRQOtWRN  KR]]i"



²1DJ\RQKDVRQOtWRWWiOGHPRVWPiUQHPWXGRP² IHOHOWHP ²+RJ\KRJ\   " )|ONHOWDSDGOyUyOpVUiPQ\LWRWWDQDJ\V]HPpW ²0iUHOWDNDUWDG ² eV EL]WRV YDJ\EHQQH KRJ\ QHP W KDQHP HQJHP" (QJHP   " ² %L]WRV 7pJHG 1HP WXGRP $WWyO IpOHN KD LJD]iQ  YROQiOQHPWXGQiODNV]HUHWQL ²0LpUW" ²0HUWYDODPLERU]DV]WyWN|YHWWHPHO ²(OOHQH" ²,JHQ$PLNRU   ²1HPRQGGHO ²0LpUW" ²0HUWD]WDNDURPWXGGKRJ\QHP YDJ\RN

%HV]pOJHWpV

0iVQDS HEpGUO YLVV]DM|YHW 6QDXW FpGXOiMD YiUW D] DEODN HOWWL DV]WDONiQ 6DUWRULXV HJ\HOUH DEEDKDJ\WD D] DQQLKLOiWRU pStWpVpW ² tUWD pV KDMODQGy HJ\ XWROVy SUyEiW WHQQLD]yFHiQNHPpQ\U|QWJHQEHVXJiU]iViYDO ² 6]tYHP ² PRQGWDP ² iW NHOO PHQQHP 6QDXWKR] $] DEODNEDQ OiQJROy Y|U|V QDSNHOWH NHWWpYiJWD D V]REiW 0L NpNHV iUQ\pNEDQ YROWXQN $ PiVLN ROGDO WLV]WD Y|U|VUp]QHN WHWV]HWW ~J\ UpPOHWW KD HJ\ N|Q\Y OHHVQH D SROFUyOFVHQJ KDQJRWDGQD ²$UUyODNtVpUOHWUOYDQV]y&VDNQHPWXGRPKRJ\DQ FVLQiOMXN -REE YROQD KD   XJ\H PHJpUWHG   ² HOKDOOJDWWDP ² 1H PHQWHJHW]] .ULV eQ LV DQQ\LUD V]HUHWQpP   7DOiQKDQHPWDUWVRNi   ² (OWDUW HJ\ LGHLJ ² PRQGWDP ² 0L OHQQH KD YHOHP M|QQpOpVNLQWYiUQiODIRO\RVyQ" ²-y'HKDQHPEtURPNL" ² +RJ\ YDQ H] YROWDNpSSHQ" ² NpUGH]WHP PDMG J\RUVDQ KR]]iWHWWHP ² 1HP NtYiQFVLViJEyO   GH KD UiM|QQpQNWDOiQXUDONRGQLWXGQiOUDMWD ² )pOHN ² PDJ\DUi]WD .LFVLW HOViSDGW ² 1HP WXGRP PHJPRQGDQL PLWO PHUW LJD]iEDQ QHP LV IpOHN FVDN FVDN   HOYHV]HN $] XWROVy SHUFEHQ PpJ YDODPL   V]pJ\HQW pU]HN QHP WXGRP MREEDQ NLIHMH]QL $]WiQ PiU VHPPLW(]pUWJRQGROWDPKRJ\EHWHJVpJ  ²WHWWHKR]]i KDONDEEDQpVPHJUi]NyGRWW ²+iWKDFVDNLWWYDQtJ\H]HQD]iWNR]RWWÉOORPiVRQ² PRQGWDP ² 0HJ LV WHV]HN PLQGHQW KRJ\ PLHOEE HONHUOMQNLQQpW 7iJUDQ\tOWDV]HPH ²*RQGRORGKRJ\HOPHKHWQNLQQHQ" ² 0LpUW QH" 9pJO LV QHP YDJ\RN LGHN|WYH   (J\pENpQWH]WLVPHJNHOOEHV]pOQHP6QDXWWDO.|UOEHOO PHGGLJEtUQiGNLHJ\HGO" 

²$]DWWyOIJJ  ²IHOHOWHODVVDQ/HKDMWRWWDDIHMpW² +D N|]EHQ KDOOKDWRP D KDQJRGDW   DNNRU WDOiQ PHJOHV]HNYDODKRJ\ ² -REEDQ |UOQpN KD QHP KDOODQiG DPLW EHV]pOQN 1HP PLQWKD EiUPLW LV WLWNROQpN HOWWHG GH QHP WXGRP QHPWXGKDWRPPLWIRJPRQGDQL6QDXW   ² 1H IRO\WDVG eUWHP -y 0DMG ~J\ iOORN KRJ\ pSSHQ FVDNDKDQJRGIRV]OiQ\DLWKDOOMDP$]QHNHPHOpJOHV] ² $NNRU PRVW IHOKtYRP D ODERUEyO 1\LWYD KDJ\RP D] DMWyW %yOLQWRWW .LPHQWHP D Y|U|V QDSVXJDUDN IDOiQ iW D IRO\RVyUD NiSUi]y V]HPHPPHO V]LQWH IHNHWpQHN OiWWDP EiU pJHWW D YLOODQ\ $ NLV ODERU DMWDMD Q\LWYD YROW (J\ 'HZDUWHUPRV]WNU|VFVHUHSHLKHYHUWHNDSDGOyQDQDJ\ FVHSSIRO\yVR[LJpQWDUWiO\RNDODWW²D]pMV]DNDLHVHPpQ\HN HJ\HWOHQ Q\RPD $ WHQ\pUQ\L NpSHUQ\ NLYLOiJRVRGRWW PLNRUI|OYHWWHPDKDOOJDWyWpVWiUFVi]WDPDUiGLyN|]SRQW V]iPiW 0LQWKD NpNHV IpQ\KiUW\D WDSDGQD D KRPiO\RV YHJEHOV ROGDOiUD$KiUW\DPRVWPHJKDVDGWpV6QDXW IpOROGDOW iWKDMROYD HJ\ PDJDV IRWHO NDUIiMiQ HJ\HQHVHQ D V]HPHPEHQp]HWW ²hGY²PRQGWD ² 0HJNDSWDP D FpGXOiGDW %HV]pOQL V]HUHWQpN YHOHG ÉWPHKHWHN" ²-|KHWV]0RVWU|JW|Q" ²0RVW ²3DUDQFVROM.HWWHFVNpQ   " ²1HP 7DOiQ\RV NLIHMH]pV MHOHQW PHJ D EDUi]GiOW KRPORN~ QDSpJHWWHVRYiQ\ DUFRQ DPHO\ IHUGpQ ~V]RWW D GRPERU~ YHJ P|J|WW PLQWKD YDODPL IXUFVD KDO Qp]QH NL HJ\ DN YiULXPDEODNiQ ²1RQR²PRQGWD²+iWDNNRUYiUODN ² 0HKHWQN V]tYHP ² OpSWHP EH D NDELQED NLVVp PHVWHUNpOW pOpQNVpJJHO iW D Y|U|V IpQ\IJJ|Q\|Q DPHO\ P|J|WWFVDNKRPiO\RVDQOiWWDP+DUH\W 7RUNRPRQ DNDGW D V]y N|Q\|NpW D NDUID DOi I,]YH J|UFV|VHQ WDSDGW D V]pNKH]7DOiQNpVQKDOORWWDPHJDOpSWHLPHWYDJ\QHP WXGWD HOpJ J\RUVDQ PHJOD]tWDQL H]W D] LMHV]W J|UFV|W pV QRUPiOLV WHVWWDUWiVW |OWHQL HJ\ PiVRGSHUFLJ OiWWDP KR J\DQ KDUFRO D EHQQH UHMO pUWKHWHWOHQ HUYHO 6]iQDORP 

pV UOW YDN GK V]RUtWRWWD HO D V]tYHPHW 1pPiQ PHQ WQN YpJLJ D KRVV]~ IRO\RVy PiVPiV V]tQ,UH ]RPiQFR ]RWW V]DNDV]DLQ ² D WHUYH]N tJ\ DNDUWiN YiOWR]DWRVVi WHQQL D SiQFpOEXURN ODNyLQDN pOHWpW 0iU PHVV]LUO OiW WDPKRJ\DUiGLyN|]SRQWDMWDMDQ\LWYDYDQ+RVV]~Y|U|V IpQ\SiV]PD KXOORWW D IRO\RVyUD PHUW 6QDXWKR] LV pSSHQ EHVW|WW D QDS +DUH\UD Qp]WHP QHP LV SUyEiOW PRVRO\RJQL HJpV] ~WRQ HOPpO\HGYH NpV]OG|WW D KDUFUD |QPDJiYDO 9RQiVDLUD NLOW D N|]HOJ HUIHV]tWpV HOVi SDGW pV YDODKRJ\ |VV]HW|SSHGW D] DUFD 7t]K~V] Op SpVQ\LUH D] DMWyWyO PHJiOOW RGDIRUGXOWDP XMMDL KHJ\pYHO SLFLW HOWDV]tWRWW KRJ\ PHQMHN pV WHUYHLP 6QDXW D NtVpUOHW D] HJpV] ÉOORPiV KLUWHOHQ PLQG VHPPLQHN UpP OHWWDKKR]DJ\|WUHOHPKH]NpSHVWDPHOO\HOPRVW PHJ NHOO ELUNy]QLD+yKpUQDNpUH]WHPPDJDPPiUYLVV]DDNDUWDP IRUGXOQL GH D IRO\RVy IDOiQ PHJW|U V]pOHV IpQ\ViYRW HPEHUDODNWDNDUWDHO6LHWYHEHPHQWHPDNDELQED6QDXW D]DMWyEDQiOOWWDOiQHOpPDNDUWM|QQL$Y|U|VQDSpSSHQ P|J|WWHYROW²PLQWKDV]KDMiEyOVXJiUR]QDDEtERUIpQ\ (J\ GDUDELJ V]yWODQXO Qp]WN HJ\PiVW $] DUFRPDW NpPOHOWH eQ QHP OiWWDP D YRQiVDLW PHUW YDNtWRWW D] DEODNYHJHQ YLVV]DYHUG IpQ\ (OPHQWHP PHOOHWWH pV PHJiOOWDP D PDJDV SXOWQiO DPHO\EO D PLNURIRQRN UXJDOPDV NRFViQ\DL QQHN NL /DVVDQ Q\XJRGWDQ PHJIRUGXOW pV WRYiEE ILJ\HOW V]RNiVRV NLV DMNELJJ\HV]Wp VpYHO DPHO\ V]LQWH YiOWR]DWODQXO PHJ\ iW KRO PRVRO\ED KRO IiUDGW ILQWRUED 6]HPpW iOODQGyDQ UiP IJJHV]WYH D PHQQ\H]HWLJ pU IpPV]HNUpQ\KH] VpWiOW PHO\QHN NpW RO GDOiQ OiWKDWyODJ VLHWYH NLGREiOW UiGLyDONDWUpV]HN KDN NXPXOiWRURNpVV]HUV]iPRNKHYHUWHNRGDK~]RWW HJ\ V]p NHW pV KiWiW D ]RPiQFR]RWW V]HNUpQ\DMWyQDN WiPDV]WYD OHOW (] D KRVV]~ QpPDViJ PiU OHJDOiEELV IXUFVD YROW +H J\H]WHP D IOHP NO|Q|VHQ D IRO\RVy IHOp DKRO +DUH\W KDJ\WDPGHDOHJFVHNpO\HEEQHV]VHPKDOODWV]RWW ²0LNRUNpV]OW|NHO"²NpUGH]WHP ² $NiU PD LV HONH]GKHWQpQN FVDN D IHOYpWHOKH] NHOO PpJHJ\NLVLG ²)HOYpWHOKH]"$]HQNHIDORJUDPPUDJRQGROV]" ²+iWSHUV]H+LV]HQEHOHHJ\H]WpO0LpUW   " ²1HPVHPPL 

² +DOOJDWODN ² PRQGWD 6QDXW PLNRU LVPpW QDJ\RQ KRVV]~UDQ\~OWDFV|QG ²0iUWXGMD  PDJiUyO²~MViJROWDPV]LQWHVXWWRJYD )HOYRQWDDV]HP|OG|NpW ²&VDNXJ\DQ" $] YROW D] pU]pVHP KRJ\ QHP OHSG|WW PHJ LJD]iQ $NNRU PLW DODNRVNRGLN" (O LV PHQW D NHGYHP D EHV]pO JHWpVWO GH HUW YHWWHP PDJDPRQ +D PiVpUW QHP KiW SXV]WDORMDOLWiVEyOLVIRO\WDWQRPNHOOJRQGROWDP ² $NNRU NH]GWH NDSLVNiOQL PLNRU D N|Q\YWiUEDQ EHV]pOJHWWQN $]WiQ ILJ\HOW HQJHP |VV]HUDNRVJDWWD D WDSDV]WDODWDLWYpJOPHJWDOiOWD*LEDULDQPDJQyMiWpVOH KDOOJDWWDDV]DODJRW   $ V]HNUpQ\QHN WiPDV]NRGYD PR]GXODWODQXO OW GH V]HPHSLFLWPHJYLOODQWeQDSXOWPHOOHWWiOOWDPDQ\LWRWW DMWyYDOV]HPEHQ0pJKDONDEEDQIRO\WDWWDP ² $]QDS pMMHO PtJ DOXGWDP |QJ\LONRV DNDUW OHQQL &VHSSIRO\yVR[LJpQQHO   =L]]HQpV KDOODWV]RWW PLQWKD SDStURNDW VRGRUQD D KX ]DW 'HUPHGWHQ IOHOWHP D IRO\RVy LUiQ\iED GH D QHV] IRUUiVDN|]HOHEEYROW0LQWKDHJpUPRWRV]NiOQD  (JpU 2VWREDViJ,WWQLQFVHQHNHJHUHN6QDXWUDVDQGtWRWWDP ²)LJ\HOHN²MHOHQWHWWHNLYiOWR]DWODQQ\XJDORPPDO ² 3HUV]H QHP VLNHUOW   GH PLQGHQHVHWUH WXGMD NL FVRGD ² 0LpUW PRQGRG H]W HO QHNHP" ² NpUGH]WH YiUDWODQXO =DYDUEDM|WWHP ²+iWKRJ\WHLVWXGG  PLDKHO\]HW  ²GDGRJWDP ²)LJ\HOPH]WHWWHOHN ² 6]yYDO WH WXGWDG   ² HPHOWHP IHO DNDUDWODQXO D KDQJRP ² 1HP $]W QHP WXGWDP 'H PRQGWDP PiU KRJ\ YDQ H] 0LNRU D ÅYHQGpJµ PHJMHOHQLN DOLJ W|EE PLQW IDQWRP $]   ÉGiPMiEyO PHUtWHWW HPOpNHN pV NpSHN ],U]DYDURV HJ\YHOHJpW QHP V]iPtWYD WXODMGRQNpSSHQ UHV 'H PLQpO WRYiEE YDQ YHOHG DQQiO HPEHULEE OHV] gQiOOyVXO LV SHUV]H FVDN EL]RQ\RV KDWiULJ (]pUW D]WiQ PLQpO WRYiEE WDUWDQQiOQHKH]HEE   

(OKDOOJDWRWW *|UEH SLOODQWiVVDO N|]|Q\|V KDQJRQ NpUGH]WH ²0LQGHQWWXG" ²+LV]HQPRQGWDP ²0LQGHQW"$]WLVKRJ\HJ\V]HUPiULWWYROWpVWH   ²1HP (OYLJ\RURGRWW ²0RQGGFVDN.HOYLQKDHQQ\LUH   YROWDNpSSHQ PLW DNDUV]FVLQiOQL"(OPHQQLD]ÉOORPiVUyO" ²,JHQ ²9HOH" ²9HOH +DOOJDWRWW PLQWKD D YiODV]RQ JRQGRONR]QD GH PpJ YDODPL YROW D KDOOJDWiViEDQ   PL OHKHW D]" $ UHMWpO\HV OpJKX]DW~MUDPHJ]L]]HQWHJpV]HQN|]HOWDOiQHJ\YpNRQ\ IDOP|J|WW6QDXWPHJPR]GXOWDV]pNHQ ²1DJ\RQKHO\HV²V]yOW²0LWQp]HO~J\"$]WKLWWHG XWDGED iOORN" &VLQiOM  DPLW DNDUV] pGHV ILDP -yO Qp]QpQNNL KD PLQGHQ EDMXQN WHWHMpEH PpJ NpQ\V]HUW LV DONDOPD]QiQN (V]HP iJiEDQ VLQFV KRJ\ OHEHV]pOMHOHN FVDNDQQ\LWPRQGRNWHHPEHUNpQWDNDUV]YLVHONHGQLHJ\ HPEHUWHOHQKHO\]HWEHQ6]pSV]pSGHKLiEDYDOy6WPpJ D]VHPEL]WRVKRJ\V]pSPHUWDOLJKDOHKHWV]pSDPLRV WREDViJ 1R GH QHP H] D OpQ\HJ 7H QHP NpUV] D WRYiEEL NtVpUOHWHNEOKDQHPYHOHHJ\WWPHQQLDNDUV]ÌJ\YDQ" ²ÌJ\ ²&VDNKRJ\H]LV  NtVpUOHW1HP" ²0LUHJRQGROV]"+RJ\   EtUMDHPDMG   "+DYHOHP OHV]DNNRU  D]WKLV]HP   (J\UH YRQWDWRWWDEEDQ EHV]pOWHP YpJO DEEDKDJ\WDP 6QDXWKDONDQIHOVyKDMWRWW ²0LQGDKiUPDQVWUXFFSROLWLNiWIRO\WDWXQN.HOYLQGH PL OHJDOiEE WXGMXN pV QHP YiJMXN PDJXQNDW QHPHV Sy]ED ²eQQHPSy]RORN ² -y QHP DNDUWDODN PHJVpUWHQL $ QHPHV Sy]W YLV] V]DYRQRP GH D VWUXFFSROLWLND PDUDG 7H NO|Q|VHQ YH V]pO\HV IRUPiEDQ ,]|G +D]XGV] PDJDGQDN QHNL D]WiQ ~MEyOPDJDGQDN,VPHUHGDQHXWULQRDQ\DJEyOpSOWUHQG V]HUVWDELOLWiViQDNIHOWpWHOHLW" ²1HP7HVHPLVPHUHG6HQNLVHPLVPHUL



² 1HP KiW 'H D]W D] HJ\HW WXGMXN KRJ\ QHP VWDELO UHQGV]HU WHKiW FVDN YDODPL iOODQGy HQHUJLDIRUUiV WDUWKDWMD IHQQ (]W 6DUWRULXVWyO WXGRP (] D] HQHUJLD WHUPHOL D] |UYpQ\O VWDELOL]iOy WHUHW 1R PiUPRVW NOV H] D WpU D ÅYHQGpJKH]µ YLV]RQ\tWYD" 9DJ\ D WHVWpQ EHOO YDQDWpUIRUUiVD"eUWHGDNO|QEVpJHW" ² eUWHP ² PRQGWDP ODVVDQ ² +D NOV DNNRU      DNNRUD]LO\HQ   ²$NNRUD6RODULVWyOHOWiYRORGYDD UHQGV]HUIHOERPOLN² IRO\WDWWD KHO\HWWHP ² (]W QHP OiWKDWMXN HOUH GH KiW D NtVpUOHWHWPiUHOLVYpJH]WHG$]DUDNpWDDPLWNLOWWpO   PRVW LV NHULQJ WXGRG 0iU D PR]JiVHOHPHLW LV NL V]iPtWRWWDP UHV yUiLPEDQ )|OUHSOKHWV] SiO\iUD iOO KDWV] PHJN|]HOtWKHWHG pV XWiQDQp]KHWV] PL OHWW D]   XWDVVDO   ²0HJUOWpO²ULSDNRGWDPUi ² $]W PRQGRG" 1R pV   KD YLVV]DV]LSNi]QiQN D]W D UDNpWiFVNiW" 0HJ OHKHW FVLQiOQL 7iYLUiQ\tWiVRV /HKR] ]XNDSiO\iMiUyOpV   ²+DJ\GDEED ² (] VH WHWV]LN" +iW DNNRU YDQ PpJ HJ\ PyGV]HU URSSDQW HJ\V]HU, 1HP LV NHOO OHV]iOOQLD D] ÉOORPiVUD +DGG NHULQJMHQ WRYiEE &VDN D UiGLyW NDSFVROMXN EH  KD pODNNRUYiODV]ROpV   ² 'H KiW   RWW PiU UpJ HOIRJ\RWW D] R[LJpQ ² Q\|JWHP ²+iWKDR[LJpQQpONOLVHOpO1RPHJSUyEiOMXN" ²6QDXW  6QDXW   ² .HOYLQ   .HOYLQ   ² J~Q\ROyGRWW GK|VHQ ² *RQGRONR]] HJ\ NLFVLW D]RQ D KtUHV HPEHUVpJHGHQ .LW DNDUV] EROGRJJi WHQQL" 0HJPHQWHQL" 0DJDGDW" W " 0HO\LNHW" (]W YDJ\DPD]W" .HWWUH PiUQHPIXWMD D K VLHVVpJHGEO " /iWKDWRG PLUH MXWV] 8WROMiUD PRQGRP H]LWWHUN|OFV|QNtYOLKHO\]HW +LUWHOHQ~MUD NH]GG|WW D]HOEELPRWRV]NiOiV PLQWKD YDODNLDIDODWNDSDUiV]Qi(UQ\HGWLV]DSRVQ\XJDORP|Q W|WW HO QHP WXGRP PLpUW 0LQWKD IRUGtWRWW OiWFV|Y|Q iW QDJ\RQPHVV]LUOQp]QpPD]HJpV]KHO\]HWHWVEHQQHPD JXQNDW DSUy OHWW PLQGHQ NLFVLW QHYHWVpJHV pV MHOHQWpN WHOHQ 

² 1R My ² KDJ\WDP Ui ² eV V]HULQWHG PLW NHOOHQH FVLQiOQRP" (OWiYROtWVDP" +ROQDS M|Q HJ\ XJ\DQLO\HQ LJD]"eVDNNRU~MUD"1DSRQWD" 0HGGLJ" 0LQHN"-y D] QHNHP"9DJ\QHNHG"6DUWRULXVQDN"$]ÉOORPiVQDN" ²9iUM(OEEWHIHOHOM(OLQGXOWRNpVWHJ\NIHOPiULV pV]OHOHGDYiOWR]iVW3iUSHUFP~OYDOiWRG   ² 1R PLW OiWRN" ² YiJWDP N|]EH KDUDSyVDQ ² 6]|UQ\HWHJHW"'pPRQW" ² 1HP 6]DEiO\RV UHQGHV DJyQLiW 7H PiU NRPRO\DQ D]W KLV]HG KRJ\ KDOKDWDWODQRN" %L]WRVtWODN KRJ\ QHP   $NNRU PLW FVLQiOV]" 9LVV]DM|VV]   HJ\ ~MDEE SpOGiQ\pUW" ² +DJ\G DEED ² RUGtWRWWDP |N|OEH V]RUtWRWW Np]]HO +XQ\RURJYD ILJ\HOW V]iQDNR]y J~Q\ FVLOORJRWW D V]H PpEHQ ² É V]yYDO pQ KDJ\MDP DEED" 7XGRG PLW D WH KH O\HGEHQ LJD]iQ QHP SD]DUROQiP D] LGPHW HUUH D] HV] PHFVHUpUH $NNRU PiU FVLQiOM YDODPL RNRVDEEDW SpOGiXO PHJYLUJiFVROKDWQiG ERVV]~EyO D] yFHiQW 0LW NpS]HOV]" +D ² J~Q\RVDQ LQWHJHWHWW D PHQQ\H]HW IHOp PLQWKD HJ\ WiYRORGy DODNRW NtVpUQH ² DNNRU JD]HPEHU YDJ\" eV tJ\ tJ\ QHP" +D YLJ\RURJV] PLNRU Y|OWHQL V]HUHWQpO YL GiPViJRWpVQ\XJDOPDWV]tQOHOV]PLNRUD]|NO|GHWKDUDS GiOQiG DNNRU QHP YDJ\ JD]HPEHU" eV KD LWW QHP OHKHW PiVQDNOHQQL"$NNRUPLYDQ"$NNRU6QDXWWDORUGtWR]RO PHUW PLQGHQQHN  D] RND" 1H OpJ\ UiDGiVXO KO\H LV |UHJHP   ² 7H PDJDGUyO EHV]pOV] ² PRUPROWDP OHKDMWRWW IHMMHO ² 'HpQ   V]HUHWHP ².LW"$]HPOpNHGHW ²1HPW0RQGWDPPLWDNDUWFVLQiOQL 1HP VRN   LJD]LHPEHUOHWWYROQDNpSHVHUUH ²0iULVEHLVPHUWHG   ²1HORYDJROMDV]DYDNRQ ² -y 6]yYDO V]HUHW 7H SHGLJ V]HUHWQL DNDURG 1DJ\ NO|QEVpJ ²7pYHGV] ² 6DMQiORP .HOYLQ GH WH KR]DNRGWiO HO D V]tY J\HLGGHO 6]HUHWHG1HP V]HUHWHG 0HJKDOQD pUWHG 7H LV pUWH,JD]iQJ\|Q\|U,pSOHWHVpVPHJKDWyKLVWyULD&VDN HOWpYHV]WHWWHGYHOHDKi]V]iPRW1HPLGHYDOyeUWHG"'H KRJ\ pUWHG QHP DNDURG PHJpUWHQL 1iOXQNQiO KDWDOPD 

VDEE HUN EHGREWDN HJ\ N|UIRO\DPDWED DPLQHN  HJ\ UpV]H6]DNDV]D,VPpWOG ULWPXVD+DWHJ\NIHO  KD HJ\ V]|UQ\HWHJ OG|]QH DNL PLQGHQUH NpV] pUWHG HJ\ SHUFLJVHKDER]QiOKRJ\PHJV]DEDGXOMWOH,JD]" ²,JD] ² 1R OiWRG +iWKD pSSHQ H]pUW QHP V]|UQ\HWHJ" (] PHJN|WL D NH]HGHW" eSSHQ D] D FpO KRJ\ PHJ OHJ\HQ N|WYH ²(]FVDNKLSRWp]LVPpJHJ\DW|EELV]i]H]HUPHOOpRWW D N|Q\YWiUEDQ eUWVG PHJ 6QDXW     QHP 1HP DNDURNYHOHGEHV]pOQLUyOD ² $KRJ\ yKDMWRG 7H NH]GWHG &VDN D]W QH IHOHMWVG HO KRJ\OpQ\HJpEHQHJ\WNU|WV]HUHWV]DPHO\DVDMiWDJ\DG EyO PXWDW HJ\ GDUDENiW +D QDJ\V]HU, OiQ\ KiW D]pUW PHUW QDJ\V]HU, HPOpNHNHW UL]WpO UyOD 7H DGWDG D UHFHS WHW.|UIRO\DPDW(]WMHJ\H]GPHJ ² +iW PLW DNDUV] WOHP" +RJ\   HOWiYROtWVDP" (J\ V]HUPiUNpUGH]WHPPLQHN"1HPIHOHOWpO ²$NNRU PRVW IHOHOHN1HP pQ KtYWDODNLGHEHV]pOJHWQL 1HP pQ KR]WDP HO D GROJDLGDW eQ QHP SDUDQFVRORN pV QHP WLOWRN PHJ QHNHG VHPPLW pV DNNRU VH WHQQpP KD PyGRPEDQiOOQD0DJDGWyOM|WWpOLGHPDJDGWyOWiODOWDGNL QHNHP D] HJpV] J\HW pV WXGRGH PLpUW" 1HP" +RJ\ OHUi]KDVG D WHUKpW pV D] pQ Q\DNDPED YDUUKDVG eQ LV LVPHUHP H]W EDUiWRP 9iUM PpJ QHP IHMH]WHP EH eQ VHPPLEHQ VHP DNDGiO\R]ODN SHGLJ pSSHQ D]W V]HUHWQpG +DXWDGEDiOOQpNV]pWYHUKHWQpGDIHMHPHWPHUWDNNRUYH OHP YROQD GROJRG XJ\DQRO\DQ K~VYpU HPEHUUHO PLQW WH YDJ\ pV PDJDGDW LV PLQGMiUW HPEHUQHN pUH]QpG 'H tJ\   QHP WXGV] D KHO\]HWWHO PHJELUNy]QL D]pUW YLWDW NR]RO LWW YHOHP   YDJ\LV LQNiEE |QPDJDGGDO 1R PRQGG HO PpJ D]W LV KRJ\ ERU]DV]WyDQ V]HQYHGQpO KD PRVWU|JW|QHOW,QQH  NO|QEHQLQNiEEQHPRQGMVHP PLW ² 0LNHW EHV]pOV] eQ FVDN D]pUW M|WWHP PHUW SXV]WD ORMDOLWiVEyO N|]|OQL DNDUWDP YHOHG KRJ\ HOKDJ\MXN D] iOORPiVW ² YiJWDP YLVV]D GH V]DYDLPDW PDJDP VHP pUH]WHPW~OViJRVDQPHJJ\]QHN6QDXWYiOODWYRQW ² 3HUV]H OHKHW KRJ\ QHP WHKHWV] PiVNpSS +D HJ\iO WDOiQKR]]iV]yOWDPD]J\K|]KiWFVDND]pUWPHUWHJ\UH 

IHOMHEEPiV]ROpVPDJDVUyOOHSRWW\DQQLpUWHGXJ\H"    *\HUHI|OKROQDSUHJJHONLOHQFN|UO6DUWRULXVKR]-y" ² 6DUWRULXVKR]" ² FVRGiONR]WDP ² +LV]HQ QHP HQJHG EHVHQNLW7HPRQGWDGPpJWHOHIRQiOQLVHPOHKHWKR]]i ²0RVWYDODKRJ\PHJROGRWWD7XGRGKRJ\PLHUUOQHP EHV]pOQN 7H HJpV]HQ PiV WpV]WD YDJ\   1R PLQGHJ\ )HOM|VV]UHJJHO" ² 0HKHWHN ² GQQ\|JWHP 6QDXWRW EiPXOWDP EDO NH]H PLQWHJ\ YpOHWOHQO HOW,QW D V]HNUpQ\ Q\LWRWW DMWD MiEDQ 0LNRU Q\tOW NL D V]HNUpQ\" 7DOiQ PiU HOpJ UpJHQ GH QHPILJ\HOWHPRGD ~J\ IHOL]JDWRWW H] D J\|WUHOPHV EH V]pOJHWpV 6QDXW PR]GXODWD WHUPpV]HWHOOHQHV YROW 0LQW KD  UHMWHJHWQHRWWYDODPLW9DJ\PLQWKDYDODNLIRJQiD NH]pW0HJQHGYHVtWHWWHPD]DMNDP ²6QDXWPLWFVLQiOV]   " ²0HQM0HQM²PRQGWDKDONDQpVQDJ\RQQ\XJRGWDQ $ Y|U|V QDS XWROVy VXJDUDLQDN IpQ\pEHQ PHQWHP NL D V]REiEyO %HFVXNWDP D]DMWyW +DUH\ YDJ\Wt]OpSpVVHO DU UpEEDIDOW|YpEHQNXSRUJRWW-|WW|PUHIHOXJURWW ²/iWRG   "²UDJ\RJRWWUiP² 6LNHUOW.ULV  ÔJ\ |UO|N+iWKD  KiWKDPDMGMREEOHV]   ² 3HUV]H ² KDJ\WDP Ui V]yUDNR]RWWDQ +D]DPHQWQN N|]EHQ IRO\WRQ D] D KO\H V]HNUpQ\ MiUW D] HV]HPEHQ 6]yYDO RWW UHMWHJHWL   " eV D] HJpV] EHV]pOJHWpVW   " ÔJ\ NLJ\~OW D] DUFRP KRJ\ DNDUDWODQXO YpJLJVLPtWRWWDP ,VWHQHPPLFVRGDUOHWeVWXODMGRQNpSSHQPLEHQLVPD UDGWXQN"6HPPLEHQ"-DSHUV]HKROQDSNLOHQFNRU   +LUWHOHQ PDMGQHP DNNRUD UpPOHW IRJRWW HO PLQW D] pMV]DND+ROQDSPHJFVLQiOMXND]HQNHIDORJUDPPRW$VX JiUQ\DOiE UH]JpVHLQHN Q\HOYpQ PLQGHQ DJ\IRO\DPDWRPDW OHNOGLN D PpO\EH NLV]ROJiOWDWMiN D IHOIRJKDWDWODQ SDUW WDODQ V]|UQ\HWHJQHN +RJ\ LV PRQGWD 6QDXW ÅERU]DV]WyDQ V]HQYHGQpO KD PRVW HOW,QQH PL   " µ$] HQNHIDORJUDPP PLQGHQW I|OMHJ\H] $ WXGDW DODWWL IRO\DPDWRNDW LV eV KD D]W DNDURP KRJ\ HOW,QM|Q HOSXV]WXOMRQ"1HPH]pUWUi]RWWPHJDQQ\LUDKRJ\W~OpOWH D]W D ERU]DOPDV |QJ\LONRVViJRW" )HOHOKHW D] HPEHU D WXGDWDODWWLMipUW" 'H KD pQ QHP IHOHOHN pUWH DNNRU NL PiV   "ÉWNR]RWWKO\HVpJ0LDIHQpQHNHJ\H]WHPEHOH KRJ\ SRQW D] pQ   3HUV]H PHJQp] 

KHWHP HOEE D]W D J|UEpW GH ~J\VHP LJD]RGRP NL UDMWD 6HQNL VHP WXGMD PHJIHMWHQL $ V]DNHPEHUHN QDJ\MiEyO NLROYDVViNEHOOHPLUHJRQGROWDYL]VJiOWV]HPpO\GHFVDN iOWDOiQRVViJRNEDQ ² SpOGiXO PDWHPDWLNDL IHODGYiQ\W RO GRWW PHJ GH KRJ\PLO\HW D]W PiU QHP NpSHVHN PHJiOOD StWDQL /HKHWHWOHQ PRQGMiN PHUW D] HQNHIDORJUDPP HJpV] VHUHJ HJ\LGHM, IRO\DPDW HUHGMH pV FVDN HJ\ UpV]NQHN YDQ SV]LFKLNDL WDUWDOPD   1R pV D WXGDWDODWWL  $UUyOQHPLVDNDUQDNEHV]pOQL+ROYDQQDN N DWWyO KRJ\ NLEiQ\iVV]iN D] HPEHU HOIRMWRWW YDJ\ HO QHP IRMWRWW HPOpNHLW   'H PLWO IpOHN HQQ\LUH" 1HP PDJDP PRQGWDP UHJJHO +DUH\QDN KRJ\ HEEO D NtVpUOHWEO ~J\VHP VO NL VHPPL" +D D I|OGL QHXURIL]LROyJXVRN QHP EROGRJXOQDN D J|UEpYHO KRJ\DQ IHMWKHWQp PHJ H] D YDGLGHJHQ IRO\pNRQ\ IHNHWH PRQVWUXP   'H KiW EHKDWROW D] DJ\DPED QHP LV VHMWHP KRJ\DQ iWNXWDWWDD]HJpV]HPOpNH]HWHPHWpVPHJWDOiOWDOHJIiMyEE DWRPMiW (EEHQ D]WiQ QHP NpWHONHGKHWHP 7HOMHVHQ PD JiWyO PLQGHQ ÅVXJiUN|]YHWtWpVµ QpONO iWW|UW D GXSOiQ OpJPHQWHV SiQFpORQ D] ÉOORPiV DFpOEXUNiQ PHJWDOiOWD EHQQHDWHVWHPHWpVHOYLWWHD]ViNPiQ\iW   ² .ULV   " ² V]yOtWRWW KDONDQ +DUH\ $] DEODNQiO iOOWDP pV YDNRQ EiPXOWDP D OHV]iOOy pMV]DNiED (]HQ D I|OGUDM]L V]pOHVVpJHQ DOLJ NLYHKHW ILQRP IiW\RO ERUXOW D FVLOODJRNUD HJ\HQOHWHV YpNRQ\ IHOKUpWHJ RO\DQ PDJDVDQ KRJ\ D QDS D OiWKDWiU DOyO H]VW|V Uy]VDV]tQ, GHUHQJpVWYHWtWHWWUi +D XWiQD HOW,QLN D] D]W MHOHQWL KRJ\ tJ\ DNDUWDP +RJ\ PHJ|OWHP 1H PHQMHN I|O" 1HP NpQ\V]HUtWKHWQHN 'HPLWPRQGRNQHNLN"²(]W²QHP(]WQHPPRQGKDWRP PHJ +LiED IRO\WRQ V]tQOHOQL KD]XGQL NHOO 0HUW KiWKD NHJ\HWOHQ QDJ\V]HU, J\LONRV JRQGRODWRN V]iQGpNRN UHPpQ\HN ODSSDQJDQDN EHQQHP pV pQ PLW VHP WXGRN UyOXN (OLQGXOW D] HPEHU PiV YLOiJRN PiV FLYLOL]iFLyN IHOp SHGLJ PpJ |QPDJiEDQ VHP LVPHU PLQGHQ ]XJRW ]ViNXWFiW DNQiW HOWRUODV]ROW V|WpW DMWyW .LDGMDP QH NLN  V]pJ\HQNH]pVEO ".LDGMDPFVDND]pUWPHUWJ\iYD YDJ\RN" ² .ULV   ² VXWWRJWD PpJ KDONDEEDQ,QNiEEpUH]WHP PLQW KDOORWWDP KRJ\ QHV]WHOHQO P|JpP VLNOLN ~J\ WHWWHPPLQWKDQHPYHQQpPpV]UH(J\HGODNDUWDPPRVW



OHQQL (J\HGO NHOOHWW OHQQHP 0pJ QHP V]iQWDP HO PD JDPPpJQHPG|QW|WWHP6HPPLW VHP KDWiUR]WDPPpJ HO %iPXOWDP D V|WpWHG HJHW D FVLOODJRNDW PHO\HN FVXSiQ NtVpUWHWLHV iUQ\DL D I|OGL FVLOODJRNQDN EpQiQ iOOWDP pV D] UHVVpJEHQ DPHO\ IHOYiOWRWWD JRQGRODWDLP FLNi]iViW NLPRQGKDWDWODQXO Q|YHNHGHWW D ULGHJ N|]|PE|V EL]RQ\RVViJ KRJ\ RWW DKRYi QHP pUKHWHN OH PiUYiODV]WRWWDP~J\WHWWHPPLQWKDVHPPLVHPW|UWpQW YROQD pV PpJ DQQ\L HUP VHP YROW KRJ\ PHJYHVVHP PDJDP

$JRQGRONRGyN

²$]DNtVpUOHWLGHJHVtW.ULV" gVV]HUiQGXOWDP D KDQJUD ÐUiN yWD EiPXOWDP iOPDWODQXO D V|WpWVpJHW PDJiQ\RVDQ PHUW D OpOHJ]pVpW VHPKDOORWWDPVDOi]iORPV]HU,IpOLJpUWHOPHVVH]pUW~M GLPHQ]LyW pV MHOHQWpVW |OW pMV]DNDL JRQGRODWRN NXV]D ODELULQWXViEDQPHJLVIHOHGNH]WHPUyOD ² 0L YDQ   " +RQQDQ WXGRG KRJ\ QHP DOV]RP   " ²NpUGH]WHP)pOHOHPUH]GOWDKDQJRPEDQ ²$EEyODKRJ\OpOHJ]HO  ²PDJ\DUi]WDKDONDQV]LQWH ERFViQDWNpUHQ ² 1HP DNDUWDODN ]DYDUQL   +D QHP OHKHWQHPRQGGPHJ   ²0LpUWQHPRQGKDWQiP",JHQDNtVpUOHW(OWDOiOWDG ²0LWYiUQDNWOH" ² N PDJXN VH WXGMiN 9DODPLW $NiUPLW 1HP *RQGRODWDNFLy H] KDQHP .pWVpJEHHVpV 0RVW PiU FVDN HJ\NHOOHJ\HPEHUDNLHOpJEiWRUKRJ\YiOODOMDDG|QWpV IHOHOVVpJpW GH H]W D IDMWD EiWRUViJRW D W|EEVpJ N| ]|QVpJHV J\iYDViJQDN WDUWMD PHUW H] YLVV]DNR]iV pUWHG PHJKiWUiOiVHPEHUKH]PpOWDWODQV]|NpV0LQWKDD]OHQQH HPEHUKH] PpOWyKDQ\DNLJ VOO\HGHOPHUO pV EHOHIXOODG YDODPLEHDPLWQHPpUWpVVRKDVHPIRJPHJpUWHQL (OKDOOJDWWDP GH ]LKiOiVRP PpJ OH VHP FVLOODSRGRWW PiULV~MUDHOIXWRWWDGK ² 3HUV]H PLQGLJ DNDGQDN J\DNRUODWLDV ILFNyN &VDN WDQXOPiQ\R]]XN D]W D SOD]PiW PRQGMiN D]RNDW D NpS WHOHQ pO YiURVRNDW DPLN HJ\ QDSUD NLQQHN D]WiQ HOW,QQHNPHUWKDDNDSFVRODWRWQHPLVVLNHUOOpWUHKR]QL OHJDOiEE D] DQ\DJ WLWNDLW PHJLVPHUMN 0LQWKD QHP WXG QiN KRJ\ |QFVDOiV D] HJpV] WpQIHUJpV HJ\ pUWKHWHWOHQ Q\HOYHQ tURWW N|Q\YWiUEDQ DKRO FVDN D N|Q\YHN V]tQpW Qp]HJHWMN  $IHQHHJ\HPHJ ²1LQFVW|EELO\HQERO\Jy" ² .L WXGMD   /HKHW W|EE LV GH PL FVDN H]W D] HJ\HW LVPHUMN 0LQGHQHVHWUH QDJ\RQ ULWND MyV]iJ QHP ~J\ PLQW D )|OG 0L EH]]HJ N|]|QVpJHVHN YDJ\XQN PL YD J\XQN D I, D YLOiJPLQGHQVpJEHQ URSSDQW EV]NpN YDJ\XQN 

UiKRJ\WL]HQNHWW YDQEHOOQNHJ\WXFDWEDQpVD]WKLW WN HEEH D QDJ\ iOWDOiQRVViJED PLQGHQW EHOH OHKHW J\| P|V]|OQL 0iV YLOiJRN ² HUUH D] LQGXOyUD PDVtUR]WXQN QHNLD.R]PRV]QDN1RpVPLOHV]D]RNNDODPiVYLOiJRN NDO" 0HJKyGtWMXN NHW YDJ\ N KyGtWDQDN PHJ HJ\pE PHJ VHP IRUGXOW D PL Q\DYDO\iV DJ\XQNEDQ É QH LV EHV]pOMQNUyOD )|ONHOWHPDJ\yJ\V]HUV]HNUpQ\KH]WDSRJDWy]WDPPHJ NHUHVWHPDODSRVDOWDWyVGRER]W ²0RVWDOXGQLIRJRNV]tYHP²PRQGWDPDV|WpWVpJQHN DPHO\EHQ FVDN D YHQWLOOiWRU E~JRWW RGDIHQW ² $OXGQRP NHOO.O|QEHQQHPWXGRPPLOHV]   /HOWHPD]iJ\UD0HJpULQWHWWHDNH]HPHW ÉW|OHOWHP D YDNV|WpWEHQpVPR]GXODWODQXOV]RUtWRWWDPPtJL]PDLPDW HOQHPOD]tWRWWDD]iORP 5HJJHO IULVVHQ pV NLSLKHQWHQ pEUHGWHP D NtVpUOHWHW MHOHQWpNWHOHQ DSUyViJQDN YpOWHP QHP LV pUWHWWHP KRJ\ FVLQiOKDWWDP LO\HQ QDJ\ J\HW EHOOH $]W VHP EiQWDP KRJ\+DUH\WLVPDJDPPDONHOOYLQQHPDODERUDWyULXPED 0LQGHQ HUIHV]tWpVH FVG|W PRQGRWW PLNRU SiU SHUFLJ HJ\HGOPDUDGWOHWHWWHPKiWD]~MDEENtVpUOHWHNUOSHGLJ NpV]VpJHVHQ YiOODONR]RWW PLQGHQUH PpJ D]W LV IHO DMiQORWWD KRJ\ ]iUMDP EH YDODKRYi  pV D]W WDQiFVROWDP KR]]RQPDJiYDOYDODPLROYDVQLYDOyW $] HJpV] FpFyQiO MREEDQ pUGHNHOW KRJ\ PLW WDOiORN D ODERUEDQ $ SROFRNRQ HOpJ Kp]DJRVDQ VRUDNR]WDN D] DQD OLWLNDL YHJHGpQ\HN QpPHO\LN V]HNUpQ\DMWyEyO KLiQ\]RWW D] YHJ D] HJ\LN DMWyV]iUQ\ FVLOODJ DODNEDQ PHJUHSHGW PLQWKD QHPUpJ YDODPL FVHWHSDWp IRO\W YROQD DPHO\QHN Q\RPDLWVLHWYHGHJRQGRVDQHOWQWHWWpNH]HQNtYOVHP PL NO|Q|VHW QHP IHGH]WHP IHO D QDJ\ IHKpU pV NpN WH UHPEHQ $ NpV]OpN N|UO PDWDWy 6QDXW UHQGNtYO IH J\HOPH]HWWHQ YLVHONHGHWW +DUH\ PHJMHOHQpVpW WHUPpV]H WHVQHN YHWWH ELFFHQWpVVHO GY|]|OWH PLN|]EHQ KRPORNR PDW pV KDOiQWpNRPDW PHJQHGYHVtWHWWH IL]LROyJLDL ROGDWWDO 6DUWRULXVLVHONHUOW$V|WpWNDPUiEDYH]HW NLVDMWyQM|WW EH)HKpUN|SHQ\WYLVHOW I|O|WWH ERNiLJ pU IHNHWH VXJiU YpG N|WpQ\W +LYDWDORVDQ NLPpUWHQ N|V]|QW PLQWKD D I|OGL LQWp]HW IRO\RVyMiQ WDOiONR]QiQN NpW GROJR]y D VRN V]i]N|]OpVWHJQDSYiOWXQNYROQDHO&VDNPRVWYHWWHP pV]UH KRJ\ PHUHY DUFNLIHMH]pVpW D V]HPYHJ KHO\HWW 

YLVHOWNRQWDNWOHQFVHRNR]]D.HUHV]WEHWHWWNp]]HOILJ\HOWH DPLQW 6QDXW IHKpU VDSNiW FVDYDU D IHMHPUH D] HOHNWUyGiNDW OHV]RUtWy V]DODJEyO (J\V]HUNpWV]HU N|UO Qp]HWW D WHUHPEHQ GH ~J\ WHWW PLQWKD HJ\iOWDOiQ QHP YHQQp pV]UH +DUH\W DNLEROGRJWDODQXO NXSRUJRWW HJ\ ]Vi PRO\RQ D IDOQiO pV ROYDViVW V]tQOHOW DPLNRU 6QDXW HO PHQWDIRWHOHPPHOOO IpPPHO pV YH]HWpNHNNHO PHJUDNRWW IHMHP XWiQD IRUGXOW OiWQL DNDUWDP DPLQW EHNDSFVROMD D JpSHW GH 6DUWRULXV YiUDWODQXO I|OHPHOWH D NH]pW pV NHQHWHVHQV]yQRNROQLNH]GHWW ² .HOYLQ GRNWRU (J\ SHUF ILJ\HOPHW pV NRQFHQWUiFLyW NpUHN 6HPPLW VHP V]iQGpNR]RP |QUH UiHUOWHWQL PHUW H] QHP YH]HWQH FpOKR] FVXSiQ DUUD KtYRP IHO KRJ\ QH JRQGROMRQ |QPDJiUD UiP 6QDXW NROOpJiUD YDJ\ EiUPHO\ PiV V]HPpO\UH HPHONHGMpN IHOO D] HJ\pQHNKH] I,]G HVHWOHJHVVpJHNHQ pV |VV]SRQWRVtWVD HOPpMpW D] J\UH DPHO\HW LWW NpSYLVHOQN $ )|OG pV D 6RODULV D NXWDWyN QHP]HGpNHL PHO\HN HJ\VpJHW DONRWQDN EiU D] HJ\HV HPEHU V]OHWLN pV PHJKDO iOOKDWDWRV W|UHNYpVQN D] LQWHOOHNWXiOLV NDSFVRODW OpWUHKR]iViUD D] HPEHULVpJ QDJ\V]HU, W|UWpQHOPL ~WMD M|YHQG IHMOGpVpQHN EL]WRV WiYODWDLNpV]VpJQNKRJ\EiUPLO\HQiOGR]DWpVQHKp]VpJ iUiQ PLQGHQ V]HPpO\HV pU]HOPQNHW IHOiOGR]YD WHOMHVtW VN NOGHWpVQNHW ² tPH H]HN D]RN D JRQGRODWRN DPH O\HNQHN PDUDGpNWDODQXO EH NHOO W|OWHQLN D] |Q WXGDWiW $] DVV]RFLiFLyN QHP IJJHQHN XJ\DQ WHOMHVHQ D] |Q DND UDWiWyO iP D] KRJ\ |Q LWW YDQ D] iOWDODP Yi]ROW JRQ GRODWPHQHW KLWHOHVVpJpW WDQ~VtWMD +D QHP OHV] EHQQH EL]WRV KRJ\ PHJIHOHOW IHODGDWiQDN NpUHP V]yOMRQ pV 6QDXW NROOpJD PHJLVPpWOL D IHOYpWHOW ,GQN HOYpJUH YDQ   8WROVyPHJMHJ\]pVpW IDNyV]iUD] PRVRO\ NtVpUWH GH H] VHP YiOWR]WDWRWW V]HPpQHN IUNpV] pV PHJU|N|Q\|G|WW NLIHMH]pVpQ )RUJRWW D J\RPURP HWWO D PpOWyViJRVDQ HOV]DYDOW QDJ\NpS, IUi]LVW|PHJWO 6]HUHQFVpUH 6QDXW PHJW|UWHDKRVV]~UDQ\~OyFV|QGHW ² /HKHW .ULV" ² NpUGH]WH D] HQNHIDORJUiI PDJDV SXOWMiUD N|Q\|N|OYH KDQ\DJ pV HJ\EHQ EL]DOPDV Sy]EDQ PLQWKD HJ\ IRWHOUD WiPDV]NRGQD +iOiV YROWDP KRJ\ D NHUHV]WQHYHPHQV]yOtWRWW 

² /HKHW ² PRQGWDP pV EHKXQ\WDP D V]HPHP $ OiPSDOi]DPHO\PLQGHQW NLI~MW D]DJ\DPEyO PLNRUEHIH MH]WH D] HOHNWUyGiN I|OHUVtWpVpW V D NDSFVROyUD WHWWH D] XMMiWKLUWHOHQHOP~OWV]HPKpMDPDOyOPHJSLOODQWRWWDPD] HOOHQU] OiPSiN Uy]VDV]tQ IpQ\pW D NpV]OpN IHNHWH ODSMiQ 8J\DQDNNRU PHJV],QW D IpPHOHNWUyGiN NHO OHPHWOHQQ\LUNRVK,Y|VVpJHLVD]D]pU]pVPLQWKDKLGHJ SpQ]GDUDERNWDSDGQiQDNDIHMHPKH]6]UNHV|WpWDUpQD YROWDP $] UHV SRURQGRW OiWKDWDWODQ Qp]VHUHJ EiPXOWD PLQGHQ ROGDOUyO DPILWHiWUXPV]HU,HQ YpYH N|UO D FV|Q GHW DPHO\EHQ ODVVDQ HORV]ORWW D J~Q\RV PHJYHWpV 6DUWR ULXV pV D .OGHWpV LUiQW $ U|JW|Q]|WW V]HUHS HOMiWV]iViW YiUy EHOV PHJILJ\HON IHV]OWVpJH HQ\KOW +DUH\" ² GREWDP IHO D V]yW SUyEDNpSSHQ V]RURQJDWy DJJRGDORP PDONpV]HQDUUDKRJ\U|JW|QYLVV]DV]tYMDP'HpEHUYDN Qp]WHUHP QHP WLOWDNR]RWW (J\ SHUFLJ FVXSD J\|QJpGVpJ YROWDP WUHOPHV pV KRVV]~ iOGR]DWRNUD NpV] V]LQWH UpV]YpW +DUH\ HJpV]HQ EHW|OW|WW YRQiVRN QpONO DODN WDODQXO DUF QpONO V NpWVpJEHHVHWW V]HUHOHPEHQ ONWHW V]HPpO\WHOHQ IRJDOPiQ NHUHV]WO SURIHVV]RUL NOOHPpQHN PLQGHQ NRPRO\ViJiYDO PHJMHOHQW HOWWHP D V]UNH V|WpW VpJEHQ *LHVH D V]RODULV]WLND pV D V]RODULVWiN DW\MD 'H QHPDUUDD]LV]DSRVUREEDQiVUDJRQGROWDPQHPDE,]|V PpO\VpJUH DPHO\ HOQ\HOWH DUDQ\NHUHWHV V]HPYHJpW pV JRQGRVDQNHIpOW V] EDMXV]iW FVDN D Up]PHWV]HWHW OiWWDP DPRQRJUiILDFtPODSMiUyODV,U,QEHYRQDONi]RWWKiWWHUHW PHOO\HODP,YpV]DIHMHW|YH]WH~J\KRJ\PLWVHPJ\DQtWYD V]LQWH GLFVIpQ\EH NHUOW PHQQ\LUH KDVRQOtW QHP D YRQiVDL KDQHP UpJLPyGL OHONLLVPHUHWHV NRPRO\ViJD DSiP DUFiKR] YpJO PiU QHP LV WXGWDP PHO\LNN Qp] UiP (J\LNQHN VLQFV VtUMD RO\DQ J\DNRUL pV PHJV]RNRWW GRORJ H] QDSMDLQNEDQ KRJ\ VHPPL NO|Q|V PHJLQGXOiVW QHPNHOW $ NpS HOW,QW V pQ HJ\ LGUH QHP WXGRP PHGGLJ WDU WRWW PHJIHOHGNH]WHP D] ÉOORPiVUyO D NtVpUOHWUO +DUH\ UyO D IHNHWH yFHiQUyO PLQGHQUO FVRUGXOWLJ EHW|OW|WW D IHOYLOOiPOy EL]RQ\RVViJ KRJ\ H] D NpW UpJ QHP pO YpJ WHOHQO NLFVLQ\ V]iUD] ViUUi YiOW HPEHU PLQGHQQHO PHJ ELUNy]RWW DPL FVDN pUWH pV HEEO D IHOIHGH]pVEO FVRGi ODWRV Q\XJDORP iUDGW HOVRGRUWD D] DODNWDODQ W|PHJHW DPHO\ QpPiQ ILJ\HOW D V]UNH DUpQD N|UO EXNiVRPUD 

>NpS@

>UHV@

YiUYD 'XSOD NDWWDQiVVDO NLNDSFVROWiN D JpSHW KLUWHOHQ V]HPHPEH VW|WW D PHVWHUVpJHV IpQ\+XQ\RURJWDP 6DU WRULXV YiOWR]DWODQ Sy]EDQ iWKDWy SLOODQWiVVDO NpPOHOW 6QDXW KiWDW IRUGtWRWW QHNL D NpV]OpN N|UO VUJ|OG|WW KDQJRVDQ FVDWWRJYD OHIIHJ VDUXMiYDO PLQWKD V]iQGpNR VDQWHQQp ²ÔJ\YpOLKRJ\VLNHUOW.HOYLQGRNWRU"²WiPDGWUiP 6DUWRULXVHOOHQV]HQYHVRUUKDQJMD ²,JHQ²IHOHOWHP ² %L]WRV HEEHQ" ² WDPiVNRGRWW FVRGiONR]y VW J\DQDNYyiUQ\DODWWDO ²,JHQ eOHV PDJDEL]WRV YiODV]RP HJ\ SHUFUH NL]|NNHQWHWWH PHUHYPpOWyViJiEyO ² $NNRU   My ² YDNNDQWRWWD pV N|UOQp]HWW PLQWKD QHP WXGQi PLKH] NH]GMHQ PRVW 6QDXW D IRWHORPKR] OpSHWWpVQHNLIRJRWWOHWHNHUQLDN|WpVW )HOiOOWDP pV MiUNiOWDP PtJ 6DUWRULXV HOW,QW D V|WpW NDPUiEDQ PDMG YLVV]DWpUW D] HOKtYRWW pV PHJV]iUtWRWW ILOPPHO3LV]NRVIHKpU]HJ]XJRVUH]J YRQDODNK~]yGWDND Wt]WL]HQ|WPpWHUHVV]DODJRQPLQWKDSHQpV]YDJ\SyNKiOy OHSQpEHDVtNRVIHNHWHFHOOXORLGRW 1HP YROW PiU LWW VHPPL GROJRP GH D]pUW PDUDGWDP %HYH]HWWpN D ILOPHW D] R[LGiOW PRGXOiWRUIHMEH 6DUWRULXV PpJHJ\V]HUPHJQp]WHDV]DODJYpJpWEL]DOPDWODQPpUJHV DUFFDO PLQWKD NL DNDUQi VLODEL]iOQL D ]HJ]XJRV YRQDODN WDUWDOPiW $ NtVpUOHW KiWUDOHY UpV]H PiU OiWKDWDWODQXO IRO\W OH 3HUV]H D]pUW WXGWDP PL W|UWpQLN PLNRU D IDO PHOOHWWL HORV]WySXOWQiOEHNDSFVROMiN D PHJIHOHO NpV]OpNHW +DON PpO\ ]PP|JpVVHO LQGXOW PHJ D] iUDP D SiQFpOSDGOy DODWWL WHNHUFVHNEHQ D]WiQ FVDN D IJJOHJHV YHJIDO~ MHO]FV|YHN IpQ\FVtNMD N~V]RWW OHIHOp PXWDWYD KRJ\ D U|QWJHQiJ\~ KDWDOPDV FV|YH D IJJOHJHV DNQiED HUHV] NHGLN pV Q\LWRWW WRUNiEDQ PHJiOO (NNRU D IpQ\HN LV PHJiOOWDN D VNiOD OHJDOVy IRNiQ pV 6QDXW Q|YHOQL NH]GWH D IHV]OWVpJHW PtJ D PXWDWyN PiUPLQW D IHKpU IpQ\FVt NRN  LGHRGD OHQJYH IpOIRUGXODWRW WHWWHN MREEUD $] iUDP ]PP|JpVH DOLJ KDOODWV]RWW VHPPL VHP W|UWpQW D ILOP GRERN D JpS I|GHOH DODWW IRURJWDN tJ\ PpJ H] VHP OiW 

V]RWW D PpWHUV]iPOiOy KDONDQ NHW\HJHWW PLQW YDODPL yUDP, +DUH\ D N|Q\YH I|O|WW KRO HQJHP ILJ\HOW KRO NHW 2GDVpWiOWDP KR]]i .pUGHQ Qp]HWW UiP $ NtVpUOHW PiU YpJHW pUW 6DUWRULXV ODVVDQ D NpV]OpN QDJ\ N~S DODN~ IHMpKH]OpSHWW ²0HJ\QN"   ²NpUGH]WHFVDNV]iMPR]JiVVDO+DUH\ %yOLQWRWWDP )HOiOOW 6]y QpONO HOPHQWHP 6DUWRULXV PHOOHWW²~J\pUH]WHPQHYHWVpJHVYROQDE~FV~]NRGQL $ IHOV IRO\RVy PDJDV DEODNDLQ NLYpWHOHVHQ V]pS QDS Q\XJWD UDJ\RJRWW EH 1HP D V]RNiVRV NRPRU SIIHGW Y|U|VVpJ KDQHP D IpQ\HV N|G|NEH EXUNROW Uy]VDSLURV PLQGHQ iUQ\DODWD PLQWKD D OHJILQRPDEE H]VWSRUUDO YROQD EHKLQWYH $] yFHiQ YpJWHOHQ VtNMiQDN ORPKiQ KXO OiP]yV~O\RVIHNHWHVpJpUH OiJ\ EDUQiVOLOD YLVV]IpQ\W KLQ WHWW H] D V]HOtG DONRQ\ &VDN D ]HQLWQpO YROW OiQJY|U|V D] pJ /HQW D PL IRO\RVyQN N|]HSH WiMiQ KLUWHOHQ PHJWRU SDQWDP (OYLVHOKHWHWOHQ JRQGRODW YROW KRJ\ PHJLQW UiQN ]iUXOD]yFHiQUDQp] NDELQPLQWHJ\E|UW|QFHOOD ² 7XGRG PLW +DUH\   ² PRQGWDP ² EHQp]HN D N|Q\YWiUED  1LQFVHOOHQHNLIRJiVRG"    ²1DJ\RQMyOHV]PDMGNHUHVHNYDODPLROYDVQLYDOyW² OHONHQGH]HWWNLVVpPHVWHUNpOWHQ eUH]WHPKRJ\WHJQDSyWDYDODPLWiWRQJyV]DNDGpNYDQ N|]|WWQNpVOHJDOiEEHJ\NLFVLWNHGYHVQHNNHOOHQHKR]]i OHQQHP GH WHOMHV DSiWLD OHWW ~UUi UDMWDP 1HP LV WXGRP PLQHN NHOOHWW YROQD W|UWpQQLH KRJ\ IHOUi]]RQ 9LVV]DIRUGXOWXQN D IRO\RVyQ pV HJ\ NLV HPHONHGQ I|O PHQWQN D KiURPDMWyV HOWpUEH DKRO D] DMWyN N|]|WW NULVWiO\YHJ P|Jp ]iUW YLUiJRN GtV]OHWWHN DNiUFVDN YD ODPLYLWULQEHQ $ N|Q\YWiUED YH]HW N|]pSV DMWy PLQGNpW ROGDOiW GRPERU~ P,EU ERUtWRWWD DMWyQ\LWiVQiO PLQGLJ YL J\i]WDPKRJ\KR]]iQHpUMHN%HQWDQDJ\NHUHNWHUHP EHQDVWLOL]iOWQDSRNNDOGtV]tWHWWViSDGWH]VWPHQQ\H]HW DODWWNLVVpK,Y|VHEEYROWPLQWDIRO\RVyQ 9pJLJK~]WDP D NH]HP D NODVV]LNXV V]RODULV]WLNDL J\,MWHPpQ\N|WHWHLQpVPiUNLDNDUWDPYHQQL*LHVH HOV N|WHWpW FHORIiQQDO YpGHWW HOODSMiQ D]]DO D Up]PHWV]HWWHO



PLNRU YiUDWODQXO I|OIHGH]WHP D YDVNRV Q\ROFDGUpW DODN~ *UDYLQVN\WDPHO\HWDP~OWNRUQHPYHWWHPpV]UH /HOWHP HJ\ NiUSLWR]RWW IRWHOED 0pO\ FVHQG YROW 3iU OpSpVVHO KiWUiEE +DUH\ ODSR]JDWRWW HJ\ N|Q\YHW KDOORW WDP XMMDL DODWW KRJ\DQ ]L]]HQQHN D ODSRN *UDYLQVN\ NRPSHQGLXPD DPLW D] HJ\HWHPHQ W|EEQ\LUH SXVNiQDN KDV]QiOWXQN D V]RODULV]WLNDL KLSRWp]LVHN iEpFpUHQGHV J\,MWHPpQ\H D] $ELROyJLDLWyO D =RRPRUILJ $] |VV]HiOOtWy DNL VRKD PpJ FVDN V]tQpW VH OiWWD D 6RODULVQDN iWUiJWD PDJiW PLQGHQ PRQRJUiILiQ H[SHGtFLyMHJ\]N|Q\Y|Q W|UHGpNHVPXQNiQpVLGHLJOHQHVMHOHQWpVHQPpJD]HJ\pE ERO\JyNDW WDQXOPiQ\R]y SODQHWROyJXVRN P,YHLEO LV NLEiQ\iV]WD D WpPiYDO NDSFVRODWRV XWDOiVRNDW V HONpV]tWHWWH D KLSRWp]LVHN NDWDOyJXViW LVPHUWHWpVHL NLVVp PHJK|NNHQWHQ YHOVHN J\DNUDQ N|]KHOO\p VHNpO\HVtWL D] ~M NRQFHSFLyKR] YH]HW NLILQRPXOWDQ V]|YHYpQ\HV JRQ GRODWRNDW $] HQFLNORSpGLNXV LJpQQ\HO NpV]OW P, HJ\pE NpQWPDPiULQNiEEFVDNNXULy]XPK~V]pYHMHOHQWPHJ D]yWD RO\DQ WHPpUGHN ~M KLSRWp]LV V]OHWHWW KRJ\ PiU HO VHP IpUQpQHN HJ\ N|WHWEHQ $ QpYPXWDWy D KVL KDORWWDN OLVWiMiUD HPOpNH]WHW ² DOLJ pO PiU YDODNL D V]HU]N N|]O DNWtY V]RODULV]WLNDL WHYpNHQ\VpJHW WDOiQ HJ\ VHP IRO\WDW (]DPLQGHQLUiQ\EDV]pWiUDPOyV]HOOHPLJD]GDJViJD]WD EHQ\RPiVW NHOWL KRJ\ YDODPHO\LN KLSRWp]LV EL]WRVDQ KHO\HV OHKHWHWOHQ KRJ\ D YDOyViJ HJpV]HQ PiV pV HJ\LNKH] VHP KDVRQOtW D WHOL PDURNNDO IHOpMH V]yUW |WOHWHN N|]O *UDYLQVN\ D P, HOV]DYiEDQ NRUV]DNRNUD RV]WRWWD D V]RODULV]WLND DGGLJL PDMGQHP KDWYDQ pYpW $ 6RODULV HO]HWHVIHOGHUtWpVpWOV]iPtWRWWHOV NRUV]DNEDQYDOyMiEDQ PpJ VHQNL VHP iOOtWRWW IHO WXGDWRV KLSRWp]LVHNHW )pOLJ PHGGLJ |V]W|Q|VHQ D ÅMy]DQ pV]µ DODSMiQ HON|Q\YHOWpN KRJ\ D] yFHiQ pOHWWHOHQ YHJ\L NRQJORPHUiWXP D ERO\JyW N|UOYHY URSSDQW NRFVRQ\DW|PHJ DPHO\ ÅNYi]LYXONiQLµ WHYpNHQ\VpJ VRUiQ KR]]D OpWUH D IXUFViEEQiO IXUFViEE NpS]GPpQ\HNHW V LPPDQHQV DXWRPDWLNXV YHJ\L IRO\DPDWRN UpYpQ VWDELOL]iOMD D YiOWR]pNRQ\ SiO\iW RO\DVIRUPiQ DKRJ\ D] LQJD PHJU]L OHQJpVVtNMiW ,JD] 0DJHQRQ PiU KiURP pY P~OYD D ÅNRFVRQ\DJpSµ pO YROWD PHOOHWWNDUGRVNRGRWW GH *UDYLQVN\NLOHQF pYYHONpVEEUH GDWiOMD D ELROyJLDL KLSRWp]LVHN NRUV]DNiQDN NH]GHWpW PLNRU 0DJHQRQ HOV]LJHWHOW YpOHPpQ\pQHN HJ\UH 

W|EEKtYHDNDGW$N|YHWNH] pYHNEHQWXFDWMiYDONpV]OWHN D] pO yFHiQ ELRPDWHPDWLNDL HOHP]pVVHO DOiWiPDV]WRWW LJHQ ERQ\ROXOW UpV]OHWHV HOPpOHWL PRGHOOMHL (NNRU PpJ FVDNQHP HJ\IRUPiQ YpOHNHGWHN D WXGyVRN D KDUPDGLN NRUV]DNEDQD]WiQIHOERPORWWD]HJ\VpJ *RPEDPyG V]DSRURGWDN D] LVNROiN pV J\DNUDQ iGi] KDUFRNDWYtYWDN(NNRUP,N|G|WW3DQPDOOHU6WUREO)UH\ KRXVH OH *UHXLOOH 2V]LSRYLFV *LHVH HJpV] KDJ\DWpNiW PHJVHPPLVtW NULWLNiQDN YHWHWWpN DOi $NNRULEDQ NpV]O WHN D] DGGLJ YL]VJiOKDWDWODQQDN WDUWRWW DV]LPPHWULiGRN HOV DWODV]DL NDWDOyJXVDL V]WHUHRIpQ\NpSHL D IRUGXODWRW D]~MWiYLUiQ\tWRWWP,V]HUHNWHWWpNOHKHWYpDPHO\HNHWD PLQGHQSLOODQDWEDQIHOUREEDQiVVDOIHQ\HJHW NRORVV]XVRN YLKDURV PpO\pEH NOGWHN 0tJ MDYiEDQ ]DMORWWDN D YLWiN FV|QGEHQ I|OPHUOW PiU HJ\HJ\ PHJYHWHQ DJ\RQ KDOOJDWRWW PLQLPDOLVWD KLSRWp]LV KD QHP LV VLNHUO OpW UHKR]QLD]WDKtUHVÅNDSFVRODWRWµ D]ÅpUWHOPHVPRQVWUXP PDOµ DNNRU VHP YL]VJiOMXN KLiED D FVRQWWi GHUPHG PL PRLGYiURVRNDW pV J|PE DODN~ KHJ\HNHW PHO\HNHW D] yFHiQ NLO|N PDJiEyO KRJ\ ~MUD HOQ\HOMH PLYHO D NXWDWiV UpYpQ pUWpNHV NpPLDL pV IL]LNRNpPLDL LVPHUHWHNUH D] yULiVPROHNXOiN V]HUNH]HWpYHO NDSFVRODWRV ~M WDSDV]WDOD WRNUD WHKHWQN V]HUW 'H D] LO\HQ WpWHOHN KLUGHWLW PpJ FVDN YLWiUD VHP pUGHPHVtWHWWpN +LV]HQ HNNRULEDQ NHOHW NH]WHNDWLSLNXViWDODNXOiVRNPiLJKDV]QiODWRVNDWDOyJX VDL HNNRU V]OHWHWW )UDQFN ELRSOD]PDHOPpOHWH D PL PRLGRNUyODPHO\²EiUWpYHVQHNEL]RQ\XOWpVHOYHWHWWpN² D V]iUQ\DOy JRQGRONRGiV pV D ORJLNXV NRQVWUXNFLy QDJ\V]HU, SpOGiMDPDUDGW (]HN D] |VV]HVHQ KDUPLQF pYLJ WDUWy Å*UDYLQVN\NRU V]DNRNµ D V]RODULV]WLND QDLY LIM~NRUiW |V]W|Q|VHQ RSWL PLVWDURPDQWLNiMiWYpJO²D]HOV V]NHSWLNXVKDQJRNNDO ² pUHWW NRUiW NpSYLVHOWpN 0iU D] HOV QHJ\HGV]i]DG YpJH IHOp MHOHQWNH]WHN D] HOV NROORLGiOLVPHFKDQLV]WLNXV KLSRWp]LVHN NpVHL XWyGDL D VRODULVL yFHiQ DSV]LFKLNXV YROWiW KLUGHW Qp]HWHN $] yFHiQ WXGDWRV DNDUDWiQDN MHOHLW IRO\DPDWDL FpOV]HU,VpJpW WHYpNHQ\VpJpQHN EHOV V]NVpJOHWHNEO IDNDGy LQGtWpNDLW NHUHV NXWDWiVRN FVDNQHP HJ\|QWHW,HQ HJ\ HJpV] WXGyVQHP]HGpN VDMiWRV HOWpYHO\HGpVpQHN PLQVOWHN $ UpJL WDQRNDW KDORPUD G|QW SXEOLFLV]WLNDL V]HQYHGpO\ NpV]tWHWWH HO D WDODMW +ROGHQ 

(RQLGpV]pV6WROLZDFVRSRUWMiQDNMy]DQHOHP] EHiOOtWRWW ViJ~ V]RUJRV WpQ\J\,MWpVUH |VV]SRQWRVtWy NXWDWiVDL V]i PiUD JRPEDPyG V]DSRURGWDN pV EYOWHN D] DUFKtYXPRNpVPLNURILOPWiUDNVRUUDLQGXOWDNDJD]GDJRQ I|OV]HUHOW H[SHGtFLyN DPHO\HN PDJXNNDO FLSHOWHN PLQGHQ OHKHWVpJHV NpV]OpNHW |QP,N|G UHJLV]WUiWRUW pU]pNHOW pVV]RQGiWDPLWD)|OGFVDNQ\~MWKDWRWW1pPHO\LNpYEHQ H]HUQpO LV W|EE HPEHU NXWDWWD HJ\V]HUUH D ERO\JyW GH KLiED J\,MW|WWpN IiUDGKDWDWODQXO D] DQ\DJRW KLiED GX] ]DGW HJ\UH J\RUVDEEDQ D] DGDWWHQJHU D WXGyVRN V]HOOHPpQHN IULVVHVVpJH PiU HODSDGW pV PHJNH]GG|WW D 6RODULVNXWDWiV PLQGHQHN HOOHQpUH PpJ RSWLPLVWD V]DNDV]iQDN SRQWRV GiWXPPDO QHKH]HQ HOKDWiUROKDWy KDQ\DWOyNRUV]DND $OHJMHOOHP]EEHNHUUHDNRUV]DNUDDQDJ\HJ\pQLVpJHN G~V IDQWi]LiM~ HOPpOHWDONRWyN YDJ\ PHUpV] WDJDGyN RO\DQRN PLQW *LHVH 6WUREO YDJ\ 6HYDGD D] XWROVy QDJ\ V]RODULVWDDNLWLWRN]DWRVN|UOPpQ\HNN|]|WWSXV]WXOWHOD ERO\Jy GpOL VDUND N|]HOpEHQ 9pJ]HWHV EDOHVHWH HJ\ ~MRQFFDO VHP IRUGXOKDWQD HO  DODFVRQ\DQ V]iOOy JpSpW W|EE V]i] HPEHU V]HPH OiWWiUD EHOHYLWWH HJ\ OHQJHWHJEH DPHO\ SHGLJ KDWiUR]RWWDQ HOKDMROW D] ~WMiEyO +LUWHOHQ URVV]XOOpWHWiMXOiVWYDJ\NRUPiQ\KLEiWHPOHJHWWHNGHpQ D]W KLV]HP YDOyMiEDQ H] YROW D] HOV |QJ\LONRVViJ D NpWVpJEHHVpVHOV YiUDWODQQ\LOYiQRVNLW|UpVH $] HOV GH QHP D] XWROVy $ *UDYLQVN\N|WHWEHQ D] LO\HQ DGDWRN QHP V]HUHSHOQHN PDJDP LGp]WHP IHO D Gi WXPRNDWWpQ\HNHWpVUpV]OHWHNHWPtJD]DSUyEHW,VPHJ ViUJXOWODSRNDWIRUJDWWDP ,O\HQSDWHWLNXV|QJ\LONRVViJHJ\pENpQWPiUQHPDNDGW W|EE GH KDVRQOy QDJ\ HJ\pQLVpJ VHP $ SODQHWROyJLD HJ\ EL]RQ\RViJiWP,YHO WXGyVJiUGD|VV]HWpWHOpWYROWDNpSSHQ PpJ VHQNL VHP WDQXOPiQ\R]WD $ QDJ\ WHKHWVpJHN pV NL YiOy MHOOHPHN V]OHWpVpQHN J\DNRULViJD N|UOEHOO iOODQ Gy SiO\DYiODV]WiVXN D]RQEDQ QHP HJ\HQOHWHV 0HJRV] OiVXN PDJ\DUi]DWD YDOyV]tQ,OHJ D] HJ\HV WXGRPiQ\iJDN SHUVSHNWtYiLEDQ UHMOLN $ V]RODULV]WLND NODVV]LNXVDLW VRN IpOHNpSSHQ pUWpNHOLN GH QDJ\ViJXNDW VW QHP HJ\ HVHW EHQ OiQJHOPpMNHW VHQNL VHP YRQMD NpWVpJEH $ OHJMREE PDWHPDWLNXVRNDW pV IL]LNXVRNDW D ELRIL]LND LQIRUPiFLy HOPpOHW HOHNWURIL]LROyJLD NLYiOyViJDLW YRQ]RWWD PDJiKR] 

IULVVHVpJH

pYWL]HGHNHQ iW D 6RODULV QpPD yULiVD $]XWiQ KLUWHOHQ HJ\LN pYUO D PiVLNUD YH]pUHN QpONO PDUDGW D NXWDWy VHUHJ $ WUHOPHV J\,MW|JHWN pV NRPSLOiWRURN QpYWHOHQ V]UNH FVDSDWD VRN HUHGHWL NtVpUOHWHW KDMWRWW XJ\DQ PpJ YpJUHGHD]HJpV]HPEHULVpJHWPHJPR]JDWyQDJ\V]DEiV~ H[SHGtFLyNpVDPHUpV]iWIRJyKLSRWp]LVHNNRUDOHMiUW 0HJNH]GG|WW D V]RODULV]WLND V]pWKXOOiVD pV ² PLQWKD FVDN H]W D KDQ\DWOiVW WNU|]QpN ² W|PHJpYHO V]OHWWHN D FVXSiQ PiVRGUHQG, UpV]OHWHNEHQ HOWpU KLSRWp]LVHN DPHO\HNV]HULQWDVRODULVLyFHiQGHJHQHUiOWHOIDM]RWWYLV] V]DIHMOG OpQ\1pKDIHOW,QWHJ\HJ\EiWUDEEpUGHNHVHEE NRQFHSFLy GH PLQGHJ\LN YDODKRJ\ HOPDUDV]WDOWD D] yFHiQW D IHMOGpV YpJWHUPpNpQHN WHNLQWHWWpN DPHO\ FVDN IL]LNDLODJ pOWH W~O D OHJPDJDVDEE IRN~ V]HUYH]HWWVpJ KDM GDQL VRNH]HU pYYHOH]HOWWL NRUV]DNiW V PD PiU FVXSiQ D] DJyQLD pUWHOPHWOHQ KDV]RQWDODQ WQHWHLQHN KDOPD]D eYV]i]DGRNLJ K~]yGy PRQXPHQWiOLV KDOGRNOiV ² tJ\ OiWWiND6RODULVWDKRVV]DQ\RNDWPHJDPLPRLGRNDWNyURV EXUMiQ]iVQDN PDJ\DUi]WiN D NRFVRQ\iV PRQVWUXP IRO\DPDWDLEDQ HJ\UH D ],U]DYDU pV D] DQDUFKLD MHOHLW NH UHVWpN H] D] LUiQ\]DW YDOyViJRV U|JHV]PpYp IDMXOW ~J\ KRJ\DN|YHWNH] KpWQ\ROFpYLURGDOPDKDDV]HU]NQHP LVPXWDWKDWWiNNL pU]HOPHLNHW Q\tOW V]LWNRNEDQ  YDOyViJRV UiJDORPKDGMiUDW ² tJ\ iOOW ERVV]~W D V]RODULVWiN YH]pU QpONO PDUDGW HOiUYXOW V]UNH VHUHJH D Oi]DV NXWDWiVRN PLQGLJ HJ\IRUPiQ N|]|PE|V MHOHQOpWNNHO PLW VHP W|UG WiUJ\iQ ,VPHUHN QpKiQ\ LJHQ HUHGHWL PXQNiW DPHO\HW DOLJKD QHP KLED YROW NLKDJ\QL D V]RODULV]WLND NODVV]LNXVDLQDN HEEO D VHUHJV]HPOpMpEO  Wt]WL]HQNpW HXUySDL SV]LFKR OyJXV P,YHL DNLNQHN FVDN DQQ\L N|]N YROW D V]RODULV] WLNiKR] KRJ\ KRVV]~ LGQ iW YL]VJiOWiN D N|]YpOHPpQ\ UHDNFLyLW IHOPpUpVHNHW YpJH]WHN D ODLNXV iWODJHPEHUHN N|UpEHQ V PHJOHSHQ V]RURV |VV]HIJJpVW PXWDWWDN NL D N|]YpOHPpQ\ DODNXOiVD YDODPLQW D WXGRPiQ\RV YLOiJEDQ OHMiWV]yGyIRO\DPDWRNN|]|WW $ YiOWR]iV V]HOH PHJOHJ\LQWHWWH D %RO\JyNXWDWy ,QWp]HW NRRUGLQiFLyV FVRSRUWMiW LV DPHO\ D NXWDWiVRN DQ\DJL IHGH]HWpUO G|QW (] DEEDQ Q\LOYiQXOW PHJ KRJ\ DSUiQ NpQW GH N|YHWNH]HWHVHQ OHIDUDJWiN D V]RODULV]WLNDL LQWp 

]HWHNpV iOORPiVRN N|OWVpJYHWpVpW PHJ D ERO\JyUD LQGXOy FVRSRUWRNGRWiFLyMiW $ NXWDWiV OHpStWpVpW VUJHW KDQJRN PHOOHWW RO\DQ MDYDVODWRN LV IHOPHUOWHN KRJ\ KDWpNRQ\DEE HV]N|]|NHW NHOOHQH DONDOPD]QL D] HIIpOH |WOHWHN WHUpQ DOLJKDQHP D .R]PROyJLDL 9LOiJLQWp]HW JD]GDViJL LJD]JDWyMD YLWWH HO D SiOPiW  XJ\DQLV FV|N|Q\|VHQ KDMWRJDWWD KRJ\ D] pO yFHiQNRUiQWVHPLJQRUiOEHQQQNHWFVDNpSSHQ~J\YDQ D] HPEHUHNNHO PLQW D] HOHIiQW D KiWiQ PiV]NiOy KDQ J\iNNDO QHP YHV]L NHW pV]UH WHKiW HUpO\HV LPSXO]XVRNUD ERO\JyPpUHW, yULiVJpSHNUH YDQ V]NVpJ KRJ\ ILJ\HOPpW IHONHOWVN pV PDJXQNUD LUiQ\tWVXN 0XODWViJRV N|UOPpQ\ YROW ² D URVV]PiM~ VDMWy NL LV ORYDJROWD ² KRJ\ QHP D 6RODULVNXWDWiVW IHGH] %RO\JyNXWDWy ,QWp]HW KDQHP D .R]PROyJLDL ,QWp]HW LJD]JDWyMD iOOW HO LO\HQ N|OWVpJHV |WOHWHNNHO ² QDJ\YRQDO~ViJDQHPDVDMiW]VHEpUHPHQW $]WiQ PHJNH]GG|WW D KLSRWp]LVHN N|UIRUJiVD IHOIULV VtWHWWpN D UpJLHNHW DSUyFVHSU PyGRVtWiVRNDW KDMWRWWDN YpJUH UDMWXN SRQWRVDEEi YDJ\ pSSHQ W|EEpUWHOP,Yp IR JDOPD]WiN NHW V D V]RODULV]WLND WHUMHGHOPHV GH YLOiJRV V]HUNH]HW, pStWPpQ\H HJ\UH NXV]iEE ]ViNXWFiNNDO WHOL ODELULQWXVViYiOW$] iOWDOiQRV N|]|Q\ SDQJiV pV NHGYHW OHQVpJ OpJN|UpEHQ ~J\ UpPOHWW KRJ\ D WHOHQ\RPWDWRWW SDStU yFHiQMD pSSRO\DQ PHGG pV pUWHOPHWOHQ PLQW D] D PiVLND6RODULVRQ 9DJ\ NpW pYYHO D]HOWW KRJ\ YpJH]WHP pV *LEDULDQ PHOOp NHUOWHP D] ,QWp]HWEHQ D 0HWW,UYLQJDODStWYiQ\ PDJDVMXWDOPDWW,]|WWNLDQQDNDNLHPEHULFpORNUDKDV] QRVtWMDDVRODULVLSOD]PDHQHUJLiMiW5pJHEEHQLVIHOPHUOW PiU H] D OHKHWVpJ D] ,UKDMyN VRN UDNRPiQ\ SOD] PDNRFVRQ\iW V]iOOtWRWWDN D )|OGUH +DQJ\DV]RUJDOP~ WX GyVRN IiUDGR]WDN D SOD]PD NRQ]HUYiOiViQ SUyEiONR]WDN PDJDV pV DODFVRQ\ KPpUVpNOHWWHO D VRODULVLKR] KDVRQOy PHVWHUVpJHV PLNURDWPRV]IpUiYDO pV PLNURNOtPiYDO WDUWy VtWy EHVXJiU]iVRNNDO YpJO H]HUIpOH YHJ\L HOMiUiVVDO GH VRKDVHP WXGWiN PHJJiWROQL D W|EEpNHYpVEp ODVV~ ERP OiVL IRO\DPDWRW DPHO\HW SHUV]H V]LQWpQ VRNV]RU OHtUWDN D OHJQDJ\REE SRQWRVViJJDO WDJODOYD PLQGHQ V]DNDV]iW |QHPpV]WpV SiOOiV HOVGOHJHV YDJ\ NRUDL pV PiVRGODJRV YDJ\ NpVHL IRO\yVRGiV 8J\DQLO\HQ VRUVUD MXWRWWDN D SOD] 

PDNO|QIpOHWHUPpNHLEOpVNpS]GPpQ\HLEOYHWWPLQWiN LV &VDN D ERPOiV ~WMD NO|QE|]|WW D YpJHUHGPpQ\ PLQGLJ HJ\ KDPXN|QQ\, IpPHVHQ FVLOORJy |QJHUMHGpVWO IHOKtJXOW Op YROW gVV]HWpWHOpW HOHPL V]HUNH]HWpW YHJ\L NpSOHWHLW PLQGHQ V]RODULVWD N|Q\Y QpONO I~MMD DNNRU LV KDiOPiEyOpEUHV]WLN 0LYHO D PRQVWUXP NLVHEEQDJ\REE UpV]HLQHN pOHWEHQ WDUWiViW YDJ\ OHJDOiEE IHOIJJHV]WHWW YHJHWiFLyMiW KROPL KLEHUQiOiViW D ERO\JyV]HUYH]HWHQ NtYO VHPPLNpSS VHP VLNHUOW HOpUQL NLDODNXOW D] D PHJJ\]GpV 0HXQLHU pV 3URURFK LVNROiMD WiPDV]WRWWD DOi  KRJ\ WXODMGRQNpSSHQ FVDN HJ\HWOHQ UHMWpO\KH] NHOO PHJWDOiOQXQN D KHO\HV PDJ\DUi]DWNXOFViWDNNRUHJ\FVDSiVUDYLOiJRVOHV]PLQ GHQ   (]W D NXOFVRW H]W D VRODULVL E|OFVHNN|YpW RO\DQ HP EHUHN LV KDMNXUiV]WiN LGW pV IiUDGViJRW QHP NtPpOYH DNLNQHN D] pJYLOiJRQ VHPPL N|]N VHP YROW D WXGR PiQ\KR] $ V]RODULV]WLND OpWH]pVpQHN QHJ\HGLN pYWL]HGp EHQMiUYiQ\V]HU,HQHOV]DSRURGWDNDODLNXVPHJV]iOORWWDN D U|JHV]PpV SUyIpWiN ² iGi] EX]JDOPXN PpJ D] |U|N PR]JyYDOpV D N|U QpJ\V]|JHVtWpVpYHO KDGDNR]y HOGHLNpQ LV W~OWHWW D MHOHQVpJ NRPRO\DQ DJJDV]WRWW QHP HJ\ SV]L FKROyJXVW 'H H] D V]HQYHGpO\ FVDN SiU pYLJ OiQJROW ² PLNRU pQ D 6RODULVUD NpV]OGWHP UpJHQ NLNRSRWW PiU D GLYDWRVWpPiNN|]OD]HJpV]yFHiQJJ\HOHJ\WW 9LVV]DWHWWHPD*UDYLQVN\WVPHOOHWWHPLYHODN|Q\YHN iEpFpUHQGEHQ iOOWDN *UDWWHQVWURP YpNRQ\ND I]HWpUH EXNNDQWDP D 6RODULVLURGDORP HJ\LN FVXGDERJDUiUD DPHO\ V]LQWH HOW,QW D YDVWDJ IyOLiQVRN N|]|WW (] D] tUiV D] (PEHUHQW~OL PHJpUWpVppUW YtYRWW KDUFEDQ D] HPEHU HOOHQ IRUGXOW NO|Q|V J~Q\LUDW HJpV] IDMWiQNUyO HJ\ DXWRGLGDNWD PDWHPDWLNDL V]iUD]ViJiEDQ LV PpUHJWO FV| S|J P,YH $ V]HU] PLXWiQ HJpV] VRU pUGHNHV FLNNHO JD]GDJtWRWWD D NYDQWXPIL]LND EL]RQ\RV HOpJJp PHOOpNHV UpV]WHUOHWHLW HEEHQ D OHJHUHGHWLEE EiU DOLJ K~V]ROGDODV IP,YpEHQ D]W LJ\HNH]HWW NLPXWDWQL KRJ\ PpJ D WXGR PiQ\ OiWV]yODJ OHJHOYRQWDEE V]tQWLV]WiQ HOPpOHWL pV PD WHPDWLNDL HUHGPpQ\HL LV FVXSiQ HJ\NpW OpSpVUH WiYRORG WDNHODN|UQ\H] YLOiJW|UWpQHOHPHOWWLSULPLWtYHQpU]pNL DQWURSRPRUI IHOIRJiViWyO %RQFNpV DOi YHWWH D UHOD WLYLWiVHOPpOHW IRUPXOiLW D] HUWHUHN WHRUpPiMiW D SDUD 

VWDWLNiWD]HJ\VpJHVNR]PLNXVWpUKLSRWp]LVHLWNLPXWDWWD EHQQND]WDPLWHVWQNQ\RPDpU]pNV]HUYHLQNQHNV]HU YH]HWQN IHOpStWpVpQHN iOODWL IL]LROyJLiQN NRUOiWDLQDN pV J\DUOyViJDLQDN HUHGMH pV N|YHWNH]PpQ\H V PLQGHEEO D]WV],UWHOHKRJ\D]HPEHUVRKDVHPPLIpOHÅNDSFVRODWRWµ QHP WHUHPWKHW QHP HPEHUV]DEiV~ DKXPDQRLG FLYL OL]iFLyNNDO$]HJpV]IDMWiQNEyOJ~Q\W,] SDV]NYLOOXVHJ\ V]yYDO VHP HPOtWL D] pUWHOPHV yFHiQW GH D 6RODULV PHJYHWHQ GLDGDOPDV QpPDViJD V]LQWH PLQGHQ PRQGDW EDQ MHOHQ YDQ /HJDOiEELV tJ\ pUH]WHP PLNRU HOV]|U RO YDVWDP *UDWWHQVWURP I]HWpW (J\pENpQW DOLJKD V]iPtW D V]RNiVRV pUWHOHPEHQ YHWW V]RODULV]WLNDL PXQNiN N|]p LQ NiEE NXULy]XP D NODVV]LNXV J\,MWHPpQ\EHQ FVDN D]pUW V]HUHSHO PHUW *LEDULDQ LGHWHWWH eQ LV WOH NDSWDP N|O FV|QDQQDNLGHMpQ 7LV]WHOHWKH]KDVRQOyIXUFVDpU]pVVHOLOOHV]WHWWHPyYDWR VDQ YLVV]D D N|Q\YHN N|]p D YpNRQ\ND EH VHP N|W|WW NO|QOHQ\RPDWRW 0HJpULQWHWWHP D 6RODULV$OPDQDFK EDU QiV]|OG N|WpVpW %iUPHNNRUD ],U]DYDU pV WHKHWHWOHQVpJ V]DNDGW UiQN PpJLVFVDN WpQ\ KRJ\ D] HOP~OW Wt]HJ\Qp KiQ\QDSpOPpQ\HLDODSMiQEL]RQ\RVViJRWV]HUH]WQNHJ\ SiU DODSYHW NpUGpVEHQ PHO\HNUH pYHNHQ iW WHQJHUQ\L WLQWiW YHV]WHJHWWHN D PHGG ² PHUW HOG|QWKHWHWOHQ ² YLWiNEDQ $]WKRJ\D]yFHiQpOOpQ\DSDUDGR[RQRNHOpJPDNDFV NHGYHOL WRYiEEUD LV NpWVpJEH YRQKDWMiN 'H D] PiU FiIROKDWDWODQKRJ\LJHQLVYDQSV]LFKLNXPDEiUPLWLVpUW VQN H]HQ D V]yQ $] VHP YLWDWKDWy W|EEp KRJ\ LJHQLV pV]UHYHV]L MHOHQOpWQNHW   0iU H] D] HJ\ PHJiOODStWiV NHUHV]WOK~]]D D V]RODULV]WLND HJ\LN VRN N|YHWUH WDOiOW LVNROiMiW DPHO\ V]HULQW D] yFHiQ ÅPDJiQYDOy YLOiJµ ÅPDJiQYDOy OpQ\µ HJ\NRUL pU]pNV]HUYHLW PiVRGODJRV YLV] V]DIHMOGpV VRUiQ HOYHV]WHWWH tJ\ NOV MHOHQVpJHN YDJ\ WiUJ\DN OpWH]pVpUO QHP WXG EH]iUNy]RWW D JLJiV]L JRQ GRODWiUDPRN N|UIRUJiViED DPHO\HNQHN V]pNKHO\H pV WHUHPWMHDNpWQDSIpQ\pEHQ|UYpQ\O WHQJHU %HEL]RQ\RVRGRWW WRYiEEi KRJ\ PHVWHUVpJHVHQ V]LQ WHWL]iOQL NpSHV D] HPEHUL WHVWHW PL H]W QHP WXGMXN PHJ WHQQL VW W|NpOHWHVtWL LV V]iPXQNUD pUWKHWHWOHQ GH Q\LO YiQ FpOMDLYDO |VV]HIJJ PyGRVtWiVW HV]N|]|OYH V]XEDWR PiOLVVWUXNW~UiMiQ 

7HKiW OpWH]LN pO JRQGRONRGLN FVHOHNV]LN HJ\V]HU V PLQGHQNRUUD PHJV],QW D OHKHWVpJ KRJ\ pUWHOPHWOHQQHN YDJ\ QHP OpWH]QHN Q\LOYiQtWVXN D Å6RODULVNpUGpVWµ WDODMiW YHV]WHWWH D] D Qp]HW KRJ\ QHP /pQQ\HO iOOXQN V]HPEHQ V tJ\ NXGDUFXQN QHP LV NXGDUF $] HPEHUHN PRVW PiU KD DNDUMiN KD QHP NpQ\WHOHQHN WXGRPiVXO YHQQLH]WDV]RPV]pGViJRWDPHO\ EiU W|EEIpQ\pYPHV] V]HVpJEHQ D YLOiJ,U VRN ELOOLy NLORPpWHUpQ W~O WHUMHV] NHGpVN ~WMiED iOO V DPHO\HW D .R]PRV] PLQGHQ PiV UpV]pQpOQHKH]HEEPHJKyGtWDQL 7DOiQ D] HJpV] W|UWpQHOHP IRUGXOySRQWMiKR] pUWQN ² JRQGROWDP)HOONHUHNHGKHW PRVW YDJ\D N|]HOM|YEHQ D YLVV]DYRQXOiV D PHJKiWUiOiV V]HOOHPH QHP OHKHWHWOHQ VW QHP YDOyV]tQ,WOHQ KRJ\ PpJ D] ÉOORPiVW LV IHOV]iPROMiN'HQHPKLV]HPKRJ\H]EiUPLWPHJROGDQD $ JRQGRONRGy NRORVV]XV SXV]WD OpWH]pVH QHP KDJ\ W|EEp Q\XJWRW D] HPEHUHNQHN ÉWV]HOKHWLN D 7HM~WUHQGV]HUW NDSFVRODWRW WHUHPWKHWQHN KR]]iQN KDVRQOy OpQ\HN FLYLOL ]iFLyLYDOD6RODULVDNNRULV|U|NNLKtYiVPDUDGD]HPEHU V]HPpEHQ 0pJ HJ\ DSUy EUN|WpVHV N|Q\Y NHYHUHGHWW D] $OPD QDFKN|WHWHN N|]p (OQp]WHP VRN Np] Q\RPiWyO PHJV|Wp WHGHWWWiEOiMiWPLHOWWNLQ\LWRWWDP0XQWLXV%HYH]HWpVD V]RODULV]WLNiED  0RVWLVHOWWHPYDQD]pMV]DNDPLNRU QHPWXGWDPOHWHQQLH]WDUpJLN|Q\YHW*LEDULDQPRVRO\D PLNRU NH]HPEH DGWD D VDMiW SpOGiQ\iW ² H] D] PHJLVPHUHP ² pV D I|OGL KDMQDO D] DEODNEDQ PLNRU D ÅYpJHµ V]yKR] pUWHP $ V]RODULV]WLND ² tUMD 0XQWLXV ² D NR]PLNXV NRU KLWSyWOpND WXGRPiQ\RV N|QW|VEH |OW|]|WW YDOOiV D NDSFVRODW D FpO DPHO\UH W|UHNV]LN pSSRO\ N| G|V pV KRPiO\RV PLQW D V]HQWHN N|]|VVpJH YDJ\ D 0HV VLiVHOM|YHWHOH$ NXWDWiV PyGV]HUWDQL IRUPXOiNOLWXUJLiMD V]HULQW IRO\y LVWHQWLV]WHOHW D NXWDWyN DOi]DWRV EX]JDOPD SHGLJ MiPERU YiUDNR]iV D EHWHOMHVOpVUH D] pJL ]HQHWUH KLV]HQ D 6RODULV pV D )|OG N|]|WW QLQFV pV QHP LV OHKHW KtG(]WDQ\LOYiQYDOyWpQ\WPHJDW|EELWSpOGiXODN|]|V WDSDV]WDODWRN pV N|]|OKHW IRJDOPDN WHOMHV KLiQ\iW  D V]RODULVWiN QHP YHV]LN WXGRPiVXO DKRJ\ D KLYN LV HOXWDVtWRWWiN D KLWN DODSMDLW PHJLQJDWy pUYHNHW (J\pE NpQWPLWYiUQDNPLWUHPpOQHND]HPEHUHND]ÅLQIRUPDWtY NDSFVRODW PHJWHUHPWpVpWOµ JRQGRONRGy WHQJHUHN 

SpGiQ\iW

NHO"eOPpQ\EHV]iPROyWHJ\LGEHQYpJWHOHQOpWUO DPHO\ RO\DQ UpJL KRJ\ DOLJKD HPOpNH]KHW VDMiW NH]GHWpUH" eO KHJ\HN IRUPiMiEDQ NLUREEDQy YiJ\DN V]HQYHGpO\HN UH PpQ\HN pV NtQRN OHtUiViW PHO\HNEHQ D PDWHPDWLND OpWH ]pVH D PDJiQ\ pV D OHPRQGiV WHOMHVVpJJp YiOLN" 'H KiW H] D WXGiV iWDGKDWDWODQ V KD PHJSUyEiOMiN EiUPHO\LN I|OGLQ\HOYUH OHIRUGtWDQL D W~OVy ROGDORQ PDUDGQDN ÉP D ÅKLYNµ QHP LV HIIpOH LQNiEE D N|OWpV]HWUH VHPPLQW D WXGRPiQ\UDWDUWR]yIHOIHGH]pVHNHWUHPpOQHN²EiUPDJXN VHP WXGQDN UyODN D .LQ\LODWNR]WDWiVW YiUMiNDPHO\ D] HPEHUL OpW pUWHOPpW YDQ KLYDWYD IHOWiUQL HOWWN $ V]RODULV]WLND WHKiW D UpJL HOKDOW PtWRV]RN XWyGD D PLV]WLNXVVyYiUJiVRNWHUPpNHPHO\HNHWD]HPEHULV]iMDN PiU QHP PHUQHN Q\tOWDQ pV KDQJRVDQ KLUGHWQL V D V]RODULV]WLND IXQGDPHQWXPiQDN PpO\pQ UHMO DODSN ² D 0HJYiOWiVUHPpQ\H   $ V]RODULVWiN SHUV]H NpSWHOHQHN EHLVPHUQL KRJ\ YD OyEDQ tJ\ YDQ LQNiEE JRQGRVDQ NHUOLN D .DSFVRODW OpQ\HJpQHN NLIHMWpVpW ~J\KRJ\ tUiVDLNEDQ H] D .DSFVRODW YDODPL YpJV GRORJJi YiOLN PtJ D] HUHGHWL PpJ My]DQ IHOIRJiVEDQ NH]GHW OHWW YROQD PHJQ\LWiV ~M ~WUD OpSpV ² HJ\UH D VRN N|]O ² N V]HQWVpJJp DYDWWiN V D] pYHN P~OWiYDO|U|NOpWNpVPHQQ\RUV]iJXNOHWW   6]yNLPRQGy pV NHVHU, HOHP]pVVHO V]ROJiO 0XQWLXV D ERO\JyNXWDWiV HUHWQHNH FVLOORJyDQ V]HGL t]HNUH D 6RODULV PtWRV]W YDJ\LV LQNiEE D] (PEHU .OGHWpVpQHN PtWRV]iW $ V]RODULV]WLND IHMOGpVpQHN DNNRUL EL]DNRGiVWyO pV UR PDQWLNiWyO GX]]DGy V]DNDV]iEDQ W|NpOHWHVHQ DJ\RQKDOO JDWWiN H]W D] HOV QQHSURQWy KDQJRW eUWKHW KLV]HQ 0XQWLXVV]DYDLQDNHOIRJDGiVDD]HJpV]DNNRULV]RODULV]WL NiW NHUHV]WOK~]WD YROQD $] ~MIDMWD My]DQ V]HUpQ\HEE LJpQ\, V]RODULV]WLND PpJ VRNiLJ YiUW PHJDODStWyMiUD gW pYYHO 0XQWLXV KDOiOD XWiQ DPLNRU P,YH PiU N|Q\YULW NDViJ YROW V]RODULV]WLNDL pV ILOR]yILDL J\,MWHPpQ\HNEHQ HJ\DUiQW I|OOHOKHWHWOHQ IHKpU KROOy DODNXOW PHJ D QHYpW YLVHO LVNROD D QRUYpJ N|U DPHO\EHQ 0XQWLXV KLJJDGW HODGiVPyGMiW D] |U|NpEH OpS ILOR]yIXVRN HJ\pQLVpJH V]HULQW (UOH (QQHQVVRQ PDUy KHYHV LUyQLiMD pV NLVVp HOVHNpO\HVtWHWW NLDGiVEDQ 3KDHODQJD J\DNRUODWL V]RODULV] WLNiMD YDJ\ ÅXWLOLWDULV]WLNiMDµ YiOWRWWD IHO XWyEEL D]W 

VUJHWWH KRJ\W|UGMHQHN PLQGHQHNHOWW D NXWDWiV NRQN UpWKDV]QiYDOVXWEDGREYDD]RO\DQFVDOyNDUHPpQ\ V]OWHGpOLEiERVW|UHNYpVHNHWPLQWDFLYLOL]iFLyNNDSFVR ODWDNpW FLYLOL]iFLy V]HOOHPL N|]|VVpJH 'H 0XQWLXV HOHP ]pVpQHN NtPpOHWOHQ YLOiJRVViJiKR] KDVRQOtWYD V]HOOHPL WDQtWYiQ\DLQDN PXQNiVViJD EL]RQ\ FVDN XWiQpU]pV KD QHP V]LPSOD QpSV]HU,VtWpV NLYpYH (QQHQVVRQ pV HVHWOHJ 7DNDWD P,YHLW9ROWDNpSSHQ PiU  PDJD HOPRQGRWW PLQ GHQW DPLNRU D V]RODULV]WLND HOV V]DNDV]iW D ÅSUyIpWiNµ NRUiQDN QHYH]WH H]HN N|]p VRUROYD *LHVpW +ROGHQW 6H YDGiWDPiVRGLNDWDÅQDJ\V]DNDGiVµ NRUiQDN PLNRUD] HJ\HWOHQ 6RODULVHJ\Ki]PDUDNRGyIHOHNH]HWHN FVRSRUWMiUD ERPOLN V PHJMyVROWD D KDUPDGLN V]DNDV]W D GRJ PDWL]iOiV pV VNRODV]WLNXV PHJFVRQWRVRGiV NRUiW PHO\ DNNRU NH]GGLN DPLNRU PiU PLQGHQ NXWDWKDWyW IHOGHUt WHWWHN(]D]RQEDQQHPYiOWEH*LEDULDQQDNYROWLJD]D ² JRQGROWDP  PRQXPHQWiOLV HJ\V]HU,VtWpVQHN WDUWRWWD 0XQWLXV RNIHMWpVpW KLV]HQ OLNYLGiOy KHYpEHQ PHJIHOHG NH]LN D V]RODULV]WLND PLQGHQ YDOOiVL V]tQH]HWWO PHQWHV NRQNUpW HYLOiJL PXQNiMiUyO DPHO\ D NpW QDS N|UO NH ULQJ DQ\DJJRO\yQ NtYO VHPPL PiVW QHP tJpU SHGLJ PpJLVFVDNH]DPXQNDDG|QW EHQQH 0XQWLXV N|Q\YpEHQ NHWWpKDMWRWW PHJViUJXOW I]HWNpUH EXNNDQWDP NO|QOHQ\RPDW D 3DUHUJD 6RODULDQD QHJ\HGpYL IRO\yLUDWEyO *LEDULDQ HJ\LN HOV PXQNiMD UpJHQ tUWD PLNRU PpJ QHP iOOW D] ,QWp]HW pOpQ &tPH 0LpUW OHWWHP V]RODULVWD 7|P|UHQ OHOWiUV]HU,HQ IHOVRUROMD EHQQHDNDSFVRODWUHiOLVOHKHWVpJpWLJD]ROyNRQNUpWMHOHQ VpJHNHW *LEDULDQ XJ\DQLV DKKR] D WXGyVQHP]HGpNKH] WDUWR]RWW DPHO\ ² D]W KLV]HP XWROVyNpQW ² D] RSWLPLVWD IHOW|U NRUDL pYHNKH] PHUW NDSFVROyGQL V QHP WDJDGWD KRJ\pOEHQQHHJ\VDMiWRVDWXGRPiQ\V]DEWDKDWiURNRQ W~OPHQ KLW H] D]RQEDQ W|NpOHWHVHQ DQ\DJHOY, KLV]HQ DEEDQ Et]LN KRJ\ HUIHV]tWpVHLQN KD HOpJ PDNDFVDN pV iOOKDWDWRVDNYpJOVLNHUUHYH]HWQHN .LLQGXOySRQWMiXO D] HXUi]LDL ELRHOHNWURQLNXVRN &VRX (QPLQ 1J\DOOL pV .DYDNDG]H MyO LVPHUW NODVV]LNXV NX WDWiVDL V]ROJiOWDN N PXWDWWiN NL D KDVRQOyViJ HOHPHLW D] DJ\iUDPRN pV D SOD]PiEDQ PpUW NLVOpVHN N|]|WW DPHO\HN EL]RQ\RV NpS]GPpQ\HN QHYH]HWHVHQ D NRUDL SROLPRUIRN pV D] LNHUV]RODULGiN V]OHWpVpW PHJHO]LN 

(OYHWHWWH D W~OViJRVDQ DQWURSRPRUI pUWHOPH]pVHNHW D SV]LFKRDQDOLWLNDL SV]LFKLiWULDL QHXURIL]LROyJLDL LVNROiN NO|QIpOH PLV]WLILNiOy Wp]LVHLW DPHO\HN HPEHUL EHWHJVpJHNHWSUyEiOQDNEHOHPDJ\DUi]QLDNRFVRQ\DyFHiQ ED SpOGiXO HSLOHSV]LiW D] DV]LPPHWULiGRN J|UFV|V NLW|UpVH OHWWYROQD DURKDPRNPHJIHOHOMH  PHUW *LEDULDQ D .DSFVRODW OHJMy]DQDEE OHJyYDWRVDEE KLUGHWL N|]p WDUWR]RWW pV VHPPLW VHP J\,O|OW MREEDQ PLQW PLNRU HJ\LNPiVLN IHOIHGH]pV N|UO QDJ\ K,KyW FVDSWDN ² DPL XJ\DQ PiU QDJ\RQ ULWNiQ IRUGXOW HO (IIpOH ROFVy pUGHNOGpVW NDYDUW HJ\pENpQW D] pQ GLSORPDPXQNiP $] LV PHJYDQ LWW SHUV]H QHP Q\RPWDWiVEDQ YDODPHO\LN PLNURILOPGRER] PpO\pQ ODSXO %HUJPDQQ pV 5H\QROGV ~MV]HU, NXWDWiVDL DODSMiQ DNLNQHN VLNHUOW D] DJ\NpUHJIRO\DPDWRN PR]DLNMiEyO HONO|QtWHQLN pV ÅNLV],UQLNµ D OHJHUVHEE HPyFLyN D NpWVpJEHHVpV D IiMGDORP D J\|Q\|U HOHPHLW |VV]HYHWHWWHP H]HNHW D] DJ\iUDPJ|UEpNHW D] yFHiQ YLOODPRV NLVOpVHLQHN J|UEpLYHO V D J|UEpN RV]FLOOiFLyMD pV SURILOMD HJ\HV HVHWHNEHQ D V]LPPHWULiGRN NHO\KpQHN EL]RQ\RV UpV]HLQ D] pUHWOHQ PLPRLGRN WDODS]DWiQ VWE  ILJ\HOHPUHPpOWy DQDOyJLiNDW PXWDWRWW (] HOpJ YROW DKKR] KRJ\ D EXOYiUVDMWy $ .pWVpJEHHVHWW .RFVRQ\D $ ERO\Jy RUJD]PXVD pV PiV HIIpOH V]HQ]iFLyKDMKiV] FtPHN DODWW tURJDVVRQ UyODP 'H MDYDPUD W|WW NL D GRORJ OHJDOiEELV QHPUpJHQPpJtJ\JRQGROWDP PLYHO*LEDULDQDNLSHUV]H QHP E|QJpV]L YpJLJ D] H]UpYHO PHJMHOHQ PXQNiNDW NO|Q|VHQ D] ~MRQFRNpW ² H]W HJ\HWOHQ V]RODULVWD VHP J\]Qp²IHOILJ\HOWUiPpVOHYHOHWNDSWDPWOH(] D OHYpO ]iUWDOHpOHWHPHJ\LNIHMH]HWpWpVQ\LWRWWDPHJD]~MDW

ÈOPRN

0LYHO KDW QDSLJ VHPPLIpOH UHDNFLyW QHP pV]OHOWQN PHJLVPpWHOWN D NtVpUOHWHW .|]EHQ D] ÉOORPiV DPHO\ HGGLJ PR]GXODWODQXO OHEHJHWW D QHJ\YHQKDUPDGLN V]p OHVVpJL N|U pV D V]i]WL]HQKDWRGLN GpON|U PHWV]pVSRQWMiQ QpJ\V]i]PpWHUHVyFHiQV]LQWI|O|WWLPDJDVViJiWPHJWDUWYD GpO IHOp~V]RWW PHUW D 6]DWHOORLG UDGDUMDL pV UDGLRJUDPMDL V]HULQW DUUDIHOp MHOHQWVHQ PHJpOpQNOW D SOD]PDWHYp NHQ\VpJ $] HQNHIDORJUDPPDO PRGXOiOW U|QWJHQVXJiUQ\DOiE NpW QDSRQ NHUHV]WO SiU yUiV LGN|]|NEHQ OiWKDWDWODQXO iW iWG|IWHD]yFHiQFVDNQHPWN|UVLPDIHOV]tQpW $ PiVRGLN KXV]RQQpJ\ yUD YpJH IHOp PiU RO\DQ N|]HO YROWXQNDVDUNKR]KRJ\PLNRUDNpNQDSNRURQJMDPpJHO VHP W,QW D OiWyKDWiU P|J|WW W~OROGDOW D IHOKN EtERU YLVV]IpQ\H PiU D Y|U|V QDSNHOWpW MHOH]WH $] yFHiQ YpJ WHOHQIHNHWHVtNMiQpVI|O|WWHD]UHVpJHQNiSUi]DWRVYDG N]GHOHP IRO\W LO\HQNRU D IpPHVHQ L]]y PpUHJ]|OGHQ YLOORJyNHPpQ\V]tQHNpVDWRPSDEtERUSDUi]VOiVN|]|WW D] HJ\PiVVDO V]HPEHQ iOOy KLJDQ\NpN pV VNDUOiWY|U|V W,]J|PE IpQ\HV EDUi]GiNNDO V]iQWRWWD YpJLJ D] yFHiQW V KD D ]HQLWHQ PHJMHOHQW HJ\ SDUiQ\L IHOK D KXOOiPRN IDOiQ IDQWDV]WLNXV V]LYiUYiQ\V]tQHNEHQ YLOOy]WDN D V~O\RV WDMWpNNDO HJ\WW OHFVXUJy IpQ\HN 1pKiQ\ SHUFFHO D NpN QDSOHPHQWHXWiQD]pV]DNQ\XJDWLOiWyKDWiURQIHOW,QWHJ\ V]LPPHWULiG²DP,V]HUHNPiUMHOH]WpN²DOLJERQWDNR]RWW NL D YpUY|U|V N|GEO FVDN LWWRWW FVLOODQW PHJ WN|U IpQ\HVHQ PLQW D] pJ pV D] yFHiQ KDWiUiQ NLERPORWW JLJiV]L YHJYLUiJ $] ÉOORPiV D]RQEDQ QHP YiOWR]WDWWD PHJ ~WLUiQ\iW V D NLDOYy UXELQOiPSDNpQW Y|U|VHQ KX Q\RUJyNRORVV]XVPLQWHJ\QHJ\HGyUDP~OYDHOW,QWDKRUL ]RQW P|J|WW 1pKiQ\ SHUFFHO NpVEE NDUFV~ RV]ORS V]|N|WWDOHYHJEHW|YpWDERO\JyJ|UEOHWHPiUHOWDNDUWD KDQJWDODQXOQWWQ|YHNHGHWW W|EENLORPpWHUPDJDVUD$] LPpQWpV]OHOWV]LPPHWULiGSXV]WXOiViQDNH]DQ\LOYiQYDOy MHOH GHUHNiLJ YpUY|U|VHQ L]]RWW I|OMHEE SHGLJ NpNHQ PLQW HJ\ KLJDQ\RV]ORS PDMG NpWV]tQ, IiYi WHUHEpO\HVHGHWW PLQG 

KHYHVHEEHQVDUMDG]yiJDLQDNFV~FVD|VV]HKDMROWVJRPED DODN~ IHOKYp ROYDGW D JRPEDNDODSMiW HOVRGRUWD D V]pO PpJ VRNi FVLOORJRWW D NpW QDS W]pEHQ W|YH SHGLJ D OiWyKDWiU HJ\KDUPDGiQ V]pWV]yUW ORPKD IUW|V URQFVRNNi V]DNDGR]YD LJHQ ODVVDQ D] yFHiQED KXOORWW (J\yUDP~OYDDV]tQMiWpNXWROVyQ\RPDLVHOW,QW 0HJLQW HOWHOW NpW QDS PpJ HJ\V]HU XWROMiUD PHJLVPp WHOWN D NtVpUOHWHW U|QWJHQVXJDUDLQN PiU D NRFVRQ\D yFHiQMyNRUDWHUOHWpWYpJLJV]XUNiOWiNGpOHQIHOW,QWHND] $UUKHQLGiN HEEO D PDJDVViJEyO PiU KiURPV]i] NLOR PpWHUUO LV MyO OiWV]RWW D KDWFV~FV~ V]LNOiV KHJ\OiQF RO\DQ PLQWKD MpJ pV Ky IHGQp SHGLJ V]HUYHV OHGpN ERUtWMD WDQ~VtWYD KRJ\ D] DODNXODW HJ\NRU D] yFHiQ IHQHNHYROW 'pONHOHWL LUiQ\UD iOOWXQN iW HJ\ LGHLJ D KHJ\YRQXODW PHQWpQKDODGWXQNFV~FVDLEHOHYHV]WHNDY|U|VQDSLGHMpQ PLQGLJV,U,EEIHOK]HWEHPDMGHOW,QWHN7t]QDSWHOWPiU HODNtVpUOHWPHJNH]GpVHyWD $] ÉOORPiVRQ H]DODWW OpQ\HJpEHQ VHPPL VHP W|UWpQW PLXWiQ 6DUWRULXV EHSURJUDPR]WD D NtVpUOHWHW DXWRPDWDJpSLVPpWHOJHWWHWRYiEEPpJDEEDQVHPYDJ\RN EL]WRV HOOHQUL]WpNH D P,N|GpVpW eV PpJLV VRN PLQGHQ W|UWpQWD]ÉOORPiVRQVRNNDOW|EEPLQWyKDMWRWWDPYROQD 'H QHP D] HPEHUHN N|]|WW $JJyGWDP KRJ\ 6DUWRULXV VUJHWQL IRJMD D] DQQLKLOiWRU pStWpVpQHN IRO\WDWiViW YiUWDP PLW V]yO 6QDXW KD PHJWXGMD 6DUWRULXVWyO KRJ\ W|EEpNHYpVEp EHFVDSWDP D QHXWULQRDQ\DJ ERPOiViQDN XMMDPEyO V]RSRWW YHV]pO\HLYHO ÉP HJ\LNN VHP V]yOW VHPPLW +DOOJDWiVXN RNiW HOHLQWH QHP LV VHMWHWWHP SHUV]H JRQGROWDP Ui KRJ\ HVHWOHJ IRUUDOQDN YDODPLW WLWRNEDQ GROJR]QDN H]pUW QDSRQWD EHNXNNDQWRWWDP D QDJ\ODERU DODWWL DEODNWDODQ KHO\LVpJEH DKRO D] DQQLKLOiWRUW WDUWMiN 6RKDVHP WDOiOWDP RWW VHQNLW D NpV]OpN SiQFpOMiW pV NiEHOHLW ERUtWy SRUUpWHJ DUUyO WDQ~VNRGRWWKRJ\KHWHNyWDKR]]iVHQ\~OWDN 6QDXWHN|]EHQ pSSRO\DQ OiWKDWDWODQQi YiOW PLQW 6DU WRULXV VW PpJ QHKH]HEE YROW HOpUQL PHUW PiU D UiGLyV V]REDYL]RIRQMDVHPYiODV]ROW$]ÉOORPiV~WMiWYDODNLQHN LUiQ\tWDQLDNHOOHWWGHQHPWXGRPPHJPRQGDQLPHO\LNN YROW D] PHUW ² EiUPLO\HQ IXUFViQ KDQJ]LN ² HJ\V]HU,HQ QHP pUGHNHOW $] yFHiQ UHDNFLyMiQDN HOPDUDGiVD LV 

DQQ\LUDKLGHJHQKDJ\RWWKRJ\NpWKiURPQDSP~OYDPiU QHPFVDN KRJ\ QHP UHPpOWHP YDJ\ QHP IpOWHP WOH GH PHJ LV IHOHGNH]WHP UyOD pV D] HJpV] NtVpUOHWUO 1DSKRVV]DW D N|Q\YWiUEDQ YDJ\ D NDELQEDQ OG|JpOWHP +DUH\YDO DNL iUQ\pNNpQW NHUOJHWHWW 7XGWDP KRJ\ D NHWWQN GROJD URVV]XO iOO pV KRJ\ H] D] DSDWLNXV WXQ\D KDOOJDWiV QHP WDUWKDW D YpJWHOHQVpJLJ 9DODKRJ\ PHJ NHOOHQH W|UQ|P D QpPDViJRW YiOWR]WDWQRP NHOOHQH D YLV]RQ\XQNRQGHPpJDJRQGRODWiWLVHOKHVVHJHWWHPPLQ GHQ YiOWR]iVQDN PHUW NpSWHOHQ YROWDP EiUPLIpOH G|Q WpVUH ~J\ pUH]WHP QHP WXGRP MREEDQ PHJPDJ\DUi]QL KRJ\D]ÉOORPiVRQPLQGHQNLYiOWDPLGROJXQN+DUH\YDO UHQGNtYO LQJDWDJ Q\DNW|U HJ\HQV~O\EDQ YDQ V HJ\ PRFFDQiVWyO |VV]HRPROKDW 0LpUW" 1HP WXGRP $ OHJ IXUFViEEKRJ\ LVYDODPLW|EEpNHYpVEpKDVRQOyWpU]HWW $KRJ\ PRVW YLVV]DJRQGRORN ~J\ UpPOLN H]W D EL]RQ\WD ODQViJRW H]W D IHJ\YHUV]QHWpU]pVW D N|]HOJ I|OGUHQJpV VHMWHOPpW HJ\ VHPPL PiV PyGRQ QHP pU]pNHOKHW GH D] ÉOORPiV PLQGHQ V]LQWMpW pV V]REiMiW EHW|OW MHOHQOpW RNR]WD %iU WDOiQ PpJ YDODPL iUXONRGRWW UyOD D] iOPRN 0LYHO VHP D]HOWW VHP D]yWD QHP YROWDN LO\HQ iOPDLP HOKDWiUR]WDP KRJ\ OHtURP NHW H]pUW WXGRN OHJDOiEE QpKiQ\ V]yW GDGRJQL UyOXN GH H]HN D IRV]OiQ\RN DOLJ pUH]WHWQHNYDODPLWD]iORPNpSHNG|EEHQHWHV JD]GDJViJi EyO 6]yYDO NL QHP IHMH]KHW KHO\]HWHNEHQ YROWDP RO\DQ WpUEHQ DKRO QLQFV pJ pV I|OG QLQFV PHQQ\H]HW IDO pV SDGOy PLQWKD YDODPL LGHJHQ NOV DQ\DJED YROQpN EHOHSUpVHOYH EHOH]VXJRUtWYD PLQWKD HJpV] WHVWHP EHOHQWW YROQD HJ\ IpOLJ KDORWW PR]GXODWODQ DODNWDODQ W|PEEHYDJ\LQNiEEpQPDJDPOHQQpND]KLV]HQWHVWHP PiUQLQFVLVKLUWHOHQViSDGWUy]VDV]tQHOPRVyGRWWIROWRN YHV]QHN N|UO RO\DQ N|]HJEHQ ~V]QDN DPLQHN PiV D] RSWLNiMD PLQW D OHYHJp ~J\KRJ\ FVDN HJpV]HQ N|]HOUO OHKHW WLV]WiQ OiWQL NHW GH DNNRU UHQGNtYO WHUPpV]HWHOOHQHVHQ WLV]WiQ PHUW H]HNEHQ D] iOPRNEDQ D N|]HOL N|UQ\H]HWDQ\DJV]HU,EE pV Np]]HOIRJKDWyEE YROW D] pEUHQLVPHUW WiUJ\DNQiO 0LQGLJ D]]DOD SDUDGR[pU]pVVHO pEUHGWHP KRJ\ D YDOyViJ D] LJD]L YDOyViJ DPD] YROW V DPLW Q\LWRWWV]HPPHO OiWRNFVDN DQQDN YDODPL NLV]iUDGW iUQ\pND ,O\HQYROWD]HOV NpSDNH]GHWDPLEOD]iORPNLERQ WDNR]RWW .|UO|WWHP HQJHGpO\UH YiUW YDODPL EHOHHJ\H]p 

VHPUHHJ\OiWKDWDWODQEyOLQWiVUDVpQWXGWDPLOOHWYHYD ODPL WXGWD EHQQHP KRJ\ QHP V]DEDG HQJHGQHP PHUW PLQpO tJpUHWHVHEE D] pUWKHWHWOHQ QpPD FViEtWiV DQQiO LV]RQ\~EE OHV] D YpJ 'H QHP PpJVHP WXGWDP KLV]HQ DNNRU EL]RQ\iUD IpOWHP YROQD PiUSHGLJ IpOHOPHW QHP pUH]WHPVRKD9iUWDP$N|UO|WWHPOHQJ Uy]VDV]tQN|G EO NLYiOW D] HOV pULQWpV V pQ WHKHWHWOHQ WXVNyNpQW PpO\HQ HOPHUOYH DEEDQ D N|]HJEHQ DPHO\ PLQWHJ\ N|UO]iUW VHP KiWUiOQL VHP PR]GXOQL QHP EtUWDP D] SHGLJ YDN pV PpJLV OiWy pULQWpVHNNHO N|UOWDSRJDWWD E|U W|Q|PHWpVRO\DQOHWWPLQWHJ\Np]DPHO\HQJHPDONRW HGGLJ V]HPHP VHP YROW PRVW HJ\V]HUUH OiWWDP D] DUFR PRQ ERO\RQJy XMMDN DODWW NLIRUPiOyGRWW D VHPPLEO D] DMNDP D KRPORNRP V DPLQW H] D YpJWHOHQO SLFL pULQWp VHNUH V]DNDGy WDSRJDWiV WRYiEE VLNORWW DUFRP pV OpOHJ] W|U]VHP WiPDGW HEEHQ D V]LPPHWULNXV WHUHPW IRO\DPDW EDQ ² PHUW pQ DNLW WHUHPWHWWHN PDJDP LV DONRWWDP V PHJMHOHQW HJ\ VRKDVHP OiWRWW DUF LGHJHQ pV LVPHUV V]HPpEHDNDUWDPQp]QLGHQHPWXGWDPPHUWD]DUiQ\RN IRO\WRQYiOWR]WDNQHPYROWWpUpVLUiQ\FVDNV]OHWWQND VHPPLEO pV IHOIHGH]WN HJ\PiVW YDODPL LPiGViJRV FV|QGEHQ D]WiQ PiU pQ PDJDP YROWDP RWW GH PLQWHJ\ YpJWHOHQQp KDWYiQ\R]YD pV D] D PiVLN OpQ\ ² HJ\ Q " ² PR]GXODWODQXO |VV]HIRUUW YHOHP ÉWMiUW EHQQQNHW D] pOHW ONWHWpVHHJ\pVXJ\DQD]YROWXQNGHDNNRUHEEHDODVV~ MHOHQHWEH DPHO\HQ NtYO VHPPL VHP OpWH]HWW pV PLQWKD QHP LV OpWH]KHWHWW YROQD KLUWHOHQ EHORSDNRGRWW YDODPL HOPRQGKDWDWODQXO NHJ\HWOHQ NpSWHOHQ pV OiWKDWDWODQ DUDQ\N|SHQ\NpQW VLPXOW WHVWQNK|] ]VLEEDV]WDQL NH]GHWW &VXSDV] IHKpU WHVWQN PHJIHNHWHGHWW pV WHNHUJ IpUJHNNpIRO\WV]pW ~J\ M|WWHN NL EHOOQN PLQW D OHYHJ YpJ QpONO HJ\PiVED IRQyGy pV V]pWERPOy JLOLV]WiN FVLOORJyOi]DVFVRPyMDYROWDP²YROWXQN²YROWDPVHEEHQ D SDUWWDODQViJEDQ ² QHP ² pQ D SDUWWDODQViJ KDQJ QpONO Y|OW|WWHP D NLDOYiVpUW D YpJpUW GH PpJ FVDN HNNRU|PO|WWHPV]pWHJ\V]HUUHPLQGHQLUiQ\EDVQWW|Q QWW EHQQHP D IHNHWH pV Y|U|V PHVV]HVpJ IyNXV]DLED YHWtWHWW KRO V]LNOiYi GHUPHG KRO HJ\ PiV QDS YDJ\ HJ\ PiVLN YLOiJ IpQ\pEHQ WHW] PLQGHQ YDOyViJQiO pOHVHEE V]i]V]RURVV]HQYHGpV 

(] YROW D OHJHJ\V]HU,EE iORP D W|EELW QHP OHKHW HOPRQGDQLPHUWLV]RQ\DWXNQDNQLQFVPHJIHOHOMHD]pEHU WXGDWEDQ+DUH\OpWH]pVpUOQHPWXGWDPEHQQNGHPiV QDSSDOLHPOpNYDJ\WDSDV]WDODWVHPV]HUHSHOWVRKD 9ROWDNPiVIDMWDiOPRNLV~J\pUH]WHPV]RUJRVODVV~ NXWDWiV IRO\LN EHQQHP D GHUPHGW V|WpWVpJEHQ PLQGHQ pU]pNHOKHW HV]N|] QpONO YDODPL iWKDWROW UDMWDP IHOGD UDEROWPHJVHPPLVtWHWWPtJFVDNDWHOMHVUHVVpJPDUDGW EHOOHP H QpPD pOYHERQFROiV XWROVy IRND RO\DQ V],NO UHWWHQHWYROWKRJ\KDQDSSDOHV]HPEHMXWRWWPHJJ\RUVXOW DV]tYYHUpVHP $QDSSDORNSHGLJIDNyQHJ\IRUPiQiOPRVDQFDPPRJ WDN XQRWW URVV]NHGYEHQ pV WHOMHV N|]|Q\EHQ FVDN D] pMV]DNiNWyO IpOWHP QHP WXGWDP KRJ\DQ PHQHNOMHN HOON YLUUDV]WRWWDP +DUH\YDO DNLQHN HJ\iOWDOiQ QHP YROWV]NVpJH DOYiVUD FVyNROWDP pV EHFp]JHWWHP GH WXG WDPKRJ\QHPpUGHNHOVHPVHPVDMiWPDJDPFVDND] HODOYiVWyO UHWWHJHN V H]W  LV PHJVHMWKHWWH EiU VRKDVHP EHV]pOWHP QHNL OLGpUFiOPDLPUyO RGDDGiViEDQ PLQGLJ D PHJDOi]WDWiV WXGDWiW pUH]WHP pV H]HQ QHP WXGWDP YiO WR]WDWQL 6QDXW pV 6DUWRULXV PRQGRP HJpV] LG DODWW QHP PXWDWNR]RWW 6QDXW QpKiQ\ QDSRQNpQW KDOODWRWW PDJiUyO RO\NRU FpGXOiW tUW GH W|EEQ\LUH WHOHIRQiOW 0HJNpUGH]WH QHP WDSDV]WDOWDPH YDODPL ~M MHOHQVpJHW YDODPL YiOWR]iVW EiUPLW DPLW UHDNFLyQDN WHNLQWKHWQpQN D]DQQ\LV]RUPHJLVPpWHOWNtVpUOHWUH$]WIHOHOWHPVHPPLW pVI|OWHWWHPXJ\DQH]WDNpUGpVW6QDXWFVDNDIHMpWLQJDWWD DNpSHUQ\Q $ NtVpUOHWHN EHV]QWHWpVpW N|YHW WL]HQ|W|GLN QDSRQ NRUiEEDQ pEUHGWHP IHO PLQW V]RNWDP $ OLGpUFQ\RPiV WHOMHVHQNLPHUtWHWW]VLEEDGWDQWpUWHPPDJDPKR]PLQWKD PpO\ QDUNy]LVEDQ IHNGWHP YROQD 2GDNLQW pSSHQ IHONHOW DY|U|VQDSD]yFHiQRQEtERUW,]IRO\DPK~]yGRWWYpJLJ OiWWDP KRJ\ D Q\XJRGW IHOV]tQ DOLJ pV]UHYHKHWHQ ]DYD URVRGQLNH]G)HNHWHVpJHPHJKRPiO\RVRGRWWPLQWKDN|G IiW\RO OHEHJQH I|O|WWH GH H] D N|GIiW\RO QDJ\RQ LV DQ\DJ V]HU, YROW ,WWRWW EX]RJQL NH]GHWW PDMG D] HJpV] OiWKDWy IHOV]tQPHJERO\GXOW$IHNHWHVpJHOW,QWD]yFHiQWNO|Q|V KiUW\DERUtWRWWDDKXOOiPKHJ\HNHQKDOYiQ\Uy]VDV]tQ,D KXOOiPY|OJ\HNEHQ J\|QJ\EDUQD WDNDUy $] HJ\HQOHWHVHQ YiOWDNR]y V]tQHN SODV]WLNXVDQ GRPERUtWRWWiN 

>NpS@

>UHV@

NLDPLQWHJ\YDUi]VWpVUHPHJGHUPHGWKXOOiPRNYpJWHOHQ VRUDLW $]XWiQ D V]tQHN |VV]HNHYHUHGWHN OD]D WDMWpN NH OHWNH]HWW D] yFHiQRQ V D] ÉOORPiV DODWW pV N|U|VN|UO yULiVL KDEIHOKN HPHONHGWHN D OHYHJEH 9t]V]LQWHVHQ OH EHJYH V]iOOWDN D WLV]WD UW pJ IHOp HJ\iOWDOiQ QHP KD VRQOtWRWWDN LJD]L IHOKNUH HJpV]HQ ODSRVDN YROWDN FVDN D SHUHPN GX]]DGW IHO OpJJ|PEV]HU,HQ 1pPHO\LN D] DODFVRQ\DQ MiUy QDS NRURQJMD HOp ~V]RWW V D NRQWUDV]W N|YHWNH]WpEHQV]pQIHNHWHYt]V]LQWHVViYNpQWPHWV]HWWHiW D] L]]y WiQ\pUW D W|EEL D QDS N|]HOpEHQ DV]HULQW KRJ\ PLO\HQV]|JEOpUWpNDVXJDUDNW,]Y|U|VEHQPHJJ\SLURV EDQ PiOQDV]tQEHQ pJHWW pV H] tJ\ PHQW PLQWKD YpUHV SLNNHO\HN V]DNDGR]QiQDN OH D] yFHiQ KiPOy IHOV]tQpUO RO\NRU IHNHWH K~VD LV NLEXNNDQW DOyOXN PDMG ~MDEE KDEUpWHJ DOi UHMW]N|G|WW (J\LNPiVLN KDEOHSHG N|]YHWOHQO D] DEODN HOWW YLWRUOi]RWW HO DOLJ HJ\ PpWHUUH VW D] HJ\LN KR]]i LV pUW D] YHJKH] VHO\PHVQHN WHWV] IHOV]tQpYHO$]HOV UDMRNPiUDOLJOiWV]RWWDNDPDJDVEDQ WpWRYD PDGDUDNNpQW OHEHJWHN PDMG iWWHWV] N|GGp IRV]ORWWDND]pJHQ $] ÉOORPiV PR]GXODWODQ YROW YDODNL PHJiOOtWRWWD YDJ\ KiURP yUiW YHV]WHJHOW V N|UO|WWH V]DNDGDWODQXO IRO\W D V]tQMiWpN 9pJO PLNRU D QDS D OiWyKDWiU DOi VOO\HGW V D] yFHiQUD IpOKRPiO\ ERUXOW H]UpYHO V]iOOWDN D] pJEH D NDUFV~Y|U|VO V]LOXHWWHNYpJWHOHQVRURNEDQ~V]WDNHJ\UH I|OMHEE PLQWKD OiWKDWDWODQ K~URNRQ HPHONHGQpQHN PHUHYHQ pV V~O\WDODQXO V D WpSHWW V]iUQ\DNQDN H] D] QQHSpO\HV PHQQ\EHPHQHWHOH PLQGDGGLJ WDUWRWW PtJ HO QHPQ\HOWHNHWDWHOMHVV|WpWVpJ +DUH\WPHJUpPtWHWWHDIHQVpJHVpVG|EEHQHWHVOiWYiQ\ DPHO\KH] V]RODULVWD OpWHPUH VHP WXGWDP PDJ\DUi]DWRW I,]QL ² QHNHP LV pSSRO\DQ ~M pV pUWKHWHWOHQ YROW PLQW QHNL 'H KiW D 6RODULVRQ pYHQWH OHJDOiEE NpWV]HUKi URPV]RU pV]OHOQHN HJ\HWOHQ NDWDOyJXVEDQ VHP V]HUHSO YDGRQDW~M IRUPiNDW pV NpS]GPpQ\HNHW VW HJ\ NLV V]H UHQFVpYHOPpJJ\DNUDEEDQLV .|YHWNH] pMMHON|UOEHOOHJ\yUiYDODNpNQDSIHONHOWH HOWW ~MDEE ULWND WQHPpQ\ WDQ~L YROWXQN D] yFHiQ IRV]IRUHV]NiOW (OV]|U IpQ\IROWRN MHOHQWHN PHJ D V|WpWEHQ OiWKDWDWODQ yFHiQRQ V]UNpVIHKpUHQ GHUHQJ HOPRVyGRWW IROWRN DPHO\HN HJ\WW ULQJDWy]WDN D KXOOiPRN 

NDO PDMG |VV]HIRO\WDN V]pWWHUMHGWHN PtJ D NtVpUWHWLHV GHUHQJpV N|U|VN|UO HO QHP pUWH D KRUL]RQWRW )pQ\HUHMH N|UOEHOO WL]HQ|W SHUFLJ QWW D]WiQ D MHOHQVpJ PHJOHS YpJHW pUW Q\XJDW IHOO NLKXQ\W D GHUHQJpV D V|WpWVpJ W|EEV]i]PpUI|OGHVIURQWMDODVVDQHOUHQ\RPXOWVDPLNRU HOpUWH pV HOKDJ\WD D] ÉOORPiVW D] yFHiQ PpJ IRV]IRUHV] NiOyUpV]HRO\DQYROWPLQWKDW,]YpV]IpQ\HK~]yGQDNHOHW IHOpPDJDVDQD]pJUHYHWGYH0LNRUDOiWyKDWiULJV]RUXOW yULiVL VDUNL IpQ\KH] KDVRQOtWRWW PDMG KLUWHOHQ HOW,QW 1HPVRNiUDIHONHOWDQDSPHJLQWUHVKDORWWVtNViJWHUOW HODODWWXQNFVDNDKXOOiPRNUHGLNOG|]JHWWHNKLJDQ\RV YLOODQiVRNDW D] ÉOORPiV DEODNDL IHOp $] yFHiQ IRV]IR UHV]NiOiVD PiU OHtUW MHOHQVpJ D] HVHWHN EL]RQ\RV V]i]D OpNiEDQ DV]LPPHWULiGRN NLW|UpVH HOWW ILJ\HOWpN PHJ H]HQNtYO D IRNR]RWW KHO\L SOD]PDWHYpNHQ\VpJ HOpJJp WL SLNXV MHOH$ N|YHWNH] NpW KpW IRO\DPiQ D]RQEDQ VHPPL QHP W|UWpQW VHP RGDNLQW VHP D] ÉOORPiVRQ &VDN HJ\ V]HU KDOORWWDP D] pMV]DND NHOOV N|]HSpQ WiYROL MDMV]yW PLQWKD VHKRQQpW pV PLQGHQKRQQpW M|QQH UHQGNtYO PD JDV pOHV HOQ\~MWRWW KDQJ YROW YDODPL IHOIRNR]RWW HPEHU IHOHWWL Q\|V]|UJpV OLGpUFHV iOPRPEyO IHOULDGYD KRVV]DQ KDOOJDWy]WDP QHP YROWDP EHQQH EL]WRV pEUHQ YDJ\RNH YDJ\H]LVFVDNiORP(O] QDSWRPSD]DMRNKDOODWV]RWWDN D ODERUDWyULXPEyO DPHO\ UpV]EHQ D PL NDELQXQN I|O|WW YDQPLQWKDV~O\RVE~WRURNDWYDJ\JpSHNHWWRORJDWQiQDN ~J\ UpPOHWW H] D YLQQ\RJiV LV IHOOUO M|Q EiU QHP pUWHWWHP KRJ\DQ KLV]HQ D NpW V]LQWHW KDQJV]LJHWHO I|GpPYiODV]WMDHO$]LGHJWpS Q\|V]|UJpVFVDNQHPIpOyUD KRVV]DW WDUWRWW RO\DQ YROW PLQW HJ\ KDOGRNOy MDMJDWiVD PiU IHO DNDUWDP URKDQQL YHUtWpNEHQ i]YD IpOUOWHQ GH YpJO HOKDOOJDWRWW pV PHJLQW FVDN D E~WRUWRORJDWiVW KDOORWWDP .pW QDS P~OYD HVWH PLNRU +DUH\YDO D WHDNRQ\KiEDQ OG|JpOWQN YiUDWODQXO EHUREEDQW 6QDXW gOW|Q\ YROW UDMWDLJD]LI|OGL|OW|Q\H]PHJYiOWR]WDWWD0DJDVDEEQDN OiWV]RWWpVPHJ|UHJHGHWW$OLJSLOODQWRWWUiQND]DV]WDOKR] OpSHWW I|Op KDMROW pV OH VHP OYH QHNLHVHWW D KLGHJ K~VQDNHJ\HQHVHQDGRER]EyOHWWHNHQ\HUHWLVIDOWKR]]i NDEiWXMMDEHOHpUWDNRQ]HUYGRER]EDpV]VtUIROWRVOHWW ²9LJ\i]]EHSLV]NtWRGDUXKiGDW²PRQGWDP 

² +P" ² U|IIHQWHWW WHOL V]iMMDO ÔJ\ KDE]VROW PLQW DNL QDSRNyWD QHPOiWRWWpWHOWW|OW|WWPDJiQDNHJ\ IpOSRKiU ERUW IHOKDMWRWWD PHJW|U|OWH D V]iMiW pV QDJ\RW OpOHJH]YH N|UEHYL]VODWRWW J\XOODGW V]HPpYHO 5iP Qp]HWW pV IHOPRUGXOW ²6]DNiOOWHUHV]WHWWpO"   1RQR   +DUH\ QDJ\ FV|U|PS|OpVVHO D PRVRJDWyED GREiOWD D] HGpQ\W 6QDXW D VDUNiQ KLPEiOy]RWW SRIiNDW YiJRWW pV KDQJRVDQ FViPFVRJRWW Q\HOYpYHO WLV]WRJDWYD D IRJiW $] YROWD]pU]pVHPV]iQGpNRVDQFVLQiOMD ² 1LQFV NHGYHG ERURWYiONR]QL PL" ² WiPDGW UiP pV PHUHQQp]HWW1HPYiODV]ROWDP ²9LJ\i]]²FVDWWDQWIHOHJ\LG P~OYD²-yWPRQGRN  LVD]]DONH]GWHKRJ\QHPERURWYiONR]RWW ²(UHGMDOXGQL²GQQ\|JWHP ²0LFVRGD"2O\DQQLQFV0LpUW QHEHV]pOJHWKHWQpQN" ,GH ILJ\HOM .HOYLQ KiWKD FVDN MyW DNDU QHNQN" +iWKD EROGRJJi DNDU WHQQL FVDN PpJ QHP WXGMD D PyGMiW" .LROYDVVD D] DJ\XQNEyO D NtYiQViJDLQNDW   'H D] LGHJIRO\DPDWRNQDN FVDN NpW V]i]DOpND WXGDWRV WHKiW  MREEDQ LVPHU EHQQQNHW PLQW PL PDJXQN 7HKiW KDOOJDWQL NHOO Ui %HOH NHOO HJ\H]QL 1HP LJD]" 9DJ\ QHP DNDURG" 0LpUW   ² VtUyVDQ HOFVXNORWW D KDQJMD ² PLpUW QHPERURWYiONR]RO" ²+DJ\GPiUDEED²PRUGXOWDPUi²5pV]HJYDJ\ ² 0L" 5pV]HJ" eQ" 1D pV" +iW HJ\ HPEHU DNL D *DODNWLND HJ\LN YpJpEO D PiVLNED KXUFROWD D WUiJ\iMiW KRJ\ PHJWXGMD PLW pU PpJ OH VH LKDWMD PDJiW" $]WiQ PLpUW" 7H KLV]HO D] HPEHU NOGHWpVpEHQ KH .HOYLQ" *LEDULDQ PHVpOW iP UyODG PLHOWW V]DNiOOW HUHV]WHWW   3RQWRViQRO\DQYDJ\DKRJ\PRQGWD  &VDNI|OQHPHQM D ODERUED PpJ HO WDOiOQiG YHV]tWHQL D KLWHGHW   RWW YD MiNRO6DUWRULXVDPLIRUGtWRWW)DXVWXQNNHUHVLD]HOL[tUWD KDOKDWDWODQViJ HOOHQ WXGRG"  D V]HQW .DSFVRODW XWROVy ORYDJMDSHUV]HRO\DQDPLO\HQWOQNWHOLN  DOHJXWyEEL |WOHWH VH YROW URVV] SURORQJiOW DJyQLD -y PL" $JRQLD SHUSHWXD   V]DOPD   V]DOPDNDODS   KRJ\ OHKHW D] KRJ\WHQHPLV]RO.HOYLQ" 'X]]DGW V]HPKpMD P|J|WW PDMGQHP HOW,Q V]HPH +D UH\UDWpYHGWDNLPR]GXODWODQXOiOOWDIDOQiO 

² ÐFHiQ V]O|WWH $SKURGLWp V]pSVpJHV WQHPpQ\ WH KDOKDWDWODQ   ² NH]GWH V]DYDOQL GH KDQJMD YLKRJiVED IXOODGW ² 0DMGQHP   VWLPPHO   PL .HO   YLQ"    ²FVXNODGR]WDN|K|JYH 0pJ Q\XJRGW YROWDP GH Q\XJDOPDP MHJHV GKYp NH]GHWWV,U,V|GQL ² +DJ\G DEED ² LQWHWWHP OH ² +DJ\G DEED pV PHQM LQQHQ ².LGREV]"7HLV"6]DNiOOWHUHV]WHV]pVNLGREV]"1HP DNDURG PiU KRJ\ yYMDODN KRJ\ WDQiFVRW DGMDN PLQW My ,UKDYHUKR] LOOLN" .HOYLQ Q\LVVXN NL D] DOVy FVDSyDMWyW NLDEiOMXQNOHQHNLKiWKDPHJKDOOMD'HKRJ\KtYMiN",GH ILJ\HOM PL QHYHW DJJDWWXQN PLQGHQ FVLOODJUD pV ERO\JyUD SHGLJ KiWKD PiU YROW QHYN" +RJ\ M|YQN PL HKKH]"  7XGRGPLWJ\HUQNOH.LDEiOMXQNQHNL  PHJPRQGMXN PLW FVLQiOW YHOQN EL]WRVDQ PHJUpPO   pStW QHNQN H]VW V]LPPHWULiGRNDW LPiGNR]LN pUWQN D]  PDWHPDWLNDQ\HOYpQPHJGREiOEHQQQNHWYpUHVDQJ\DORN NDO EHOpQN N|OW|]WHWL D NtQV]HQYHGpVpW D UHWWHJpVpW pV N|Q\|U|J QHNQN KRJ\ OHJ\HQ YpJH 0HUW H] D] HJpV] ERO\Jy PHJ PLQGD] DPLW FVLQiO VHPPL PiV FVDN N|Q\|UJpVDYpJpUW 1R PLpUW QHPQHYHWV]" +LV]HQFVDN WUpIiORN +D W|EE KXPRUpU]pNH OHQQH D IDMWiQNQDN WDOiQ QHP MXWXQN LGH 7XGRG PLW DNDU FVLQiOQL" 0HJ DNDUMD EQWHWQL D] yFHiQW DJ\RQNtQR]QL KRJ\ PLQGHQ KHJ\H Y|OWV|Q   D]W PRQGRG ~J\VHP PHU H]]HO HOiOOQL MyYiKDJ\iVWNpUQLDWWyOD]DJ\pUHOPHV]HVHGHWWJ\OHNH]HW WO DPHO\LN LGHNOG|WW PLQNHW PHJE,QKGQL PiVRN E, QHLpUW" ,JD]DG YDQ QHP PHUL   GH FVDN D NDODSRFVND PLDWW$NDODSRFVNiWD]WQHPiUXOMDHOVHQNLQHNDQQ\LUD QHPEiWRUDPL)DXVWXQN   +DOOJDWWDP 6QDXW HJ\UH MREEDQ WiQWRUJRWW .|QQ\HN FVXURJWDND]DUFiQpVDUXKiMiUDFV|S|JWHN ² .L D] RND" .L WHWWH H]W YHOQN" *LEDULDQ" *LHVH" (LQVWHLQ" 3ODWyQ" 0LQG J\LONRVRN YROWDN WXGRG" *RQ GROG HO D UDNpWiEDQ V]pWSXNNDQKDW D] HPEHU PLQW HJ\ EXERUpN YDJ\ PHJI YDJ\ W~UyYi PHJ\ |VV]H YDJ\ PLHOWW PHJQ\LNNDQKDWQD NLIU|FFVHQ PLQGHQ YpUH D]WiQ PiU FVDN D FVRQWLNiN NRFRJWDWMiN D EiGRJRW 1HZWRQ SiO\iQ NHULQJYH (LQVWHLQPyGRVtWiVVDO PLQW D KDODGiV FV|UJL  eV PL |QNpQW QHNLYiJWXQN HQQHN D J\|Q\|U, 

~WQDN pV LWW H]HNEHQ D FHOOiNEDQ KDOKDWDWODQ WiQ\pURN pV PRVRJDWyGp]ViN N|]|WW K, V]HNUpQ\HN RGDDGy YpFpN FVDSDWD N|UpEHQ OHVVN D EHWHOMHVOpVW   Qp]] FVDN N|UO .HOYLQ +D QHP YROQpN UpV]HJ QHP SRIi]QpN LO\HQHNHW GH YDODNLQHN YpJO LV NL NHOO PRQGDQLD 9DJ\ QHP NHOO   " ,WW OV] J\HUHN D YiJyKtGRQ pV Q D V]DNiOODG  .LDKLEiV"9iODV]ROMWHPDJDGQDN   /DVVDQPHJIRUGXOWpVNLPHQWDNV]|E|QPHJNDSDV] NRGRWW D] DMWyEDQ KRJ\ HO QH HVVHQ OpSWHL PpJ VRNiLJ YLVV]KDQJ]RWWDNDIRO\RVyQ.HUOWHP+DUH\WHNLQWHWpWGH V]HPQN KLUWHOHQ |VV]HWDOiONR]RWW 2GD DNDUWDP PHQQL KR]]i iW|OHOQL PHJVLPRJDWQL D KDMiW GH QHP EtUWDP 1HPEtUWDP

6LNHU

$ N|YHWNH] KiURP KpW RO\DQ YROW PLQWKD HJ\ pV XJ\DQD] D QDS LVPpWOGQH |U|NNp HJ\IRUPiQ D] DEODN IHGNNLQ\tOWDNpV~MUD EHFVXNyGWDNpMMHOHJ\LNUpPiORP EyO D PiVLNED YRQV]ROWDP PDJDP UHJJHO I|ONHOWQN pV NH]GG|WWDV]tQMiWpNGHYDOyEDQV]tQMiWpNYROW"1\XJDO PDW V]tQOHOWHP pV +DUH\ LV tJ\ WHWW H] D KDOOJDWyODJRV PHJiOODSRGiV D WXGDW KRJ\ N|OFV|Q|VHQ EHFVDSMXN HJ\PiVW H] OHWW D YpJV PHQHGpNQN 6RNDW EHV]pOWQN DUUyOKRJ\DQpOQNPDMGD)|OG|QOHWHOHSV]QNYDODKROD QDJ\YiURV N|UQ\pNpQ pV VRKD W|EEp QHP KDJ\MXN HO D NpNHJHWPHJD]|OGIiNDWHOWHUYH]WNKRJ\DQUHQGH]]N EH D Ki]XQNDW PLO\HQ OHV] D NHUWQN PpJ |VV]H LV NDSWXQN D UpV]OHWHNHQ   HJ\ V|YpQ\HQ HJ\ SDGRQ   KLWWHP pQ HEEHQ HJ\ PiVRGSHUFLJ LV" 1HP -yO WXGWDP KRJ\ OHKHWHWOHQ +RJ\QH WXGWDP YROQD +LV]HQ PpJ KD HO LV KDJ\KDWQi D] ÉOORPiVW pOYH D )|OGUH FVDN HPEHU pUNH]KHW PHJ D] HPEHU SHGLJ D SDStUMDL $ OHJHOV HOOHQU]pV YpJHW YHWQH D V]|NpVQHN 0HJ DNDUQiN iOODSt WDQLD V]HPpO\D]RQRVViJiW WHKiW PLQGHQHNHOWW HOYiODV] WDQiNWOHPpVH]U|JW|QHOiUXOQi$]ÉOORPiVD]HJ\HWOHQ KHO\ DKRO HJ\WW pOKHWQN 7XGWD H]W +DUH\" %L]WRVDQ 0HJPRQGWDQHNLYDODNL"$W|UWpQWHNV]HULQW~J\OiWV]LN LJHQ (J\LN pMMHO IpOiOPRPEDQ KDOORWWDP KRJ\ +DUH\ FV|Q GHVHQI|ONHO0DJDPKR]DNDUWDPYRQQL0iUFVDNV]DYDN QpONOV|WpWEHQWXGWXQNHJ\SHUFUHV]DEDGGiYiOQLFVDN D]|QNtYOHWSLOODQDWDLEDQHQJHGHWWIHODV]QWHOHQJ\|WU NpWVpJEHHVpV ÔJ\ OiWV]LN QHP YHWWH pV]UH KRJ\ IHOULDG WDP 0LUH NLQ\~MWRWWDP D NH]HP OHV]iOOW D] iJ\UyO 0H]tWOiEDV OpSWHNHW KDOORWWDP PpJ HJ\UH IpOiORPEDQ +RPiO\RVV]RURQJiVIRJRWWHO ² +DUH\" ² VXWWRJWDP .LDEiOQL DNDUWDP GH QHP PHUWHP)HOOWHPD]iJ\RQ$IRO\RVyUDQ\tOyDMWyFVDNEH YROW KDMWYD .HVNHQ\ IpQ\FVtN V]HOWH iW Up]V~WRVDQ D V]REiW ÔJ\ UpPOHWW IRMWRWW KDQJRNDW KDOORN %HV]pO YD ODNLYHO".LYHO" 

.LXJURWWDPD]iJ\EyOGHRO\DQV]|UQ\, IpOHOHPURKDQW PHJ KRJ\ OiEDP QHP HQJHGHOPHVNHGHWW (J\ GDUDELJ KDOOJDWy]WDP ² FV|QG YROW /DVVDQ YLVV]DERWRUNiOWDP D] iJ\KR])HMHPEHQGREROWDYpU6]iPROQLNH]GWHP(]HULJ MXWRWWDP DNNRU KDONDQ NLQ\tOW D] DMWy +DUH\ EHVXUUDQW pVPR]GXODWODQXOPHJiOOWPLQWKDDOpOHJ]HWHPHWILJ\HOQp ,J\HNH]WHP HJ\HQOHWHVHQ V]XV]RJQL ² .ULV   " ² VXWWRJWD 1HP IHOHOWHP *\RUVDQ YLVV]DE~MW D] iJ\ED eUH]WHP KRJ\ PHUHYHQ IHNV]LN pV EpQiQ ODSXOWDP PHOOHWWH QHP LV WXGRP PHGGLJ .pUGpVHNHW SUyEiOWDP IRJDOPD]QLGHDPLQWP~OWDNDSHUFHNHJ\UHYLOiJRVDEEDQ pUH]WHP KRJ\ ~J\VHP V]yODORN PHJ HOVQHN .pVEE WDOiQHJ\yUDP~OYDHODOXGWDP $ GpOHOWW XJ\DQ~J\ WHOW PLQW D W|EEL &VDN RO\DQNRU OHVWHP J\DQDNRGYD +DUH\W DPLNRU QHP YHKHWWH pV]UH (EpGXWiQHJ\PiVPHOOHWWOG|JpOWQNDGRPERU~ DEODN QiO 2GDNLQW DODFVRQ\ UW IHOKN ~V]WDN D] ÉOORPiV ~J\ VLNORWWN|]|WWNPLQWHJ\KDMy+DUH\ROYDVRWWYDODPLWpQ FVDN EiPXOWDP PDJDP HOp ² ~MDEEDQ HJ\UH W|EEHW UpYHGH]WHP tJ\ H] YROW D] HJ\HWOHQ SLKHQpVHP eV]UHYHWWHP KRJ\ KD EL]RQ\RV V]|JEHQ IpOUHKDMWRP D IHMHP PLQGNHWWQNHW OiWRP D] DEODNYHJEHQ iWWHWV]HQ GHWLV]WiQ/HYHWWHPDNH]HPDNDUIiUyO+DUH\²PXWDWWD D] DEODNYHJ ² HJ\ J\RUV SLOODQWiVVDO PHJJ\]G|WW UyOD KRJ\ D] yFHiQW Qp]HP D]WiQ D NDUIiUD KDMROW pV DMNiYDO PHJpULQWHWWHRWWDKROD]LPpQWDNH]HPYROW&VDNOWHP WRYiEE WHUPpV]HWHOOHQHV PHUHY Sy]EDQ  SHGLJ OHFVJJHV]WHWWHIHMpWDN|Q\YHI|O|WW ² +DUH\ ² V]yODOWDP PHJ KDONDQ ² KRYi PHQWpO D] pMMHO" ²$]pMMHO" ²,JHQ ²eQ  iOPRGKDWWiO.ULVeQVHKRYDVHPHQWHP ²1HPPHQWpONLDV]REiEyO" ²1HP%L]WRVDQiOPRGWDG ²/HKHW²KDJ\WDPUi²,JHQOHKHWKRJ\iOPRGWDP   (VWH OHIHNYpVNRU PHJLQW HPOHJHWQL NH]GWHP D] XWD ]iVXQNDWYLVV]DWpUpVQNHWD)|OGUH ² -DM KDJ\MXN PiU H]W ² IDNDGW NL ² 1H EHV]pOM HUUO .ULV+LV]HQWXGRG  



²0LW" ²6HPPLW6HPPLW 0LNRUPiUOHIHNGWQND]WPRQGWDV]RPMDV ² 9DQ RWW D] DV]WDORQ HJ\ SRKiU J\P|OFVOp DGG LGH OpJ\V]tYHV 0HJLWWDDIHOpWD]WiQQHNHPQ\~MWRWWD1HPNtYiQWDP ²1RD]pQHJpV]VpJHPUH²PRVRO\JRWW)HOKDMWRWWDPD V]|US|WNLFVLWVyVQDNpUH]WHPGHQHPIRJWDPJ\DQ~W ²+iWPLUOEHV]pOMQNKDD)|OGUO QHPDNDUV]" ²NpUGH]WHPDPLNRUHOROWRWWDDYLOODQ\W ²0RQGGKDpQQHPOHQQpNPHJQVOQpO" ²1HP ²6RKD" ²6RKD ²0LpUW" ² 1HP WXGRP 7t] pYLJ HJ\HGO YROWDP pV QHP QVOWHPPHJ1HEHV]pOMQNHUUOV]tYHP   6]pGOWHP  PLQWKD  OHJDOiEE HJ\ YHJ ERUW LWWDP YROQD ² 'H EHV]pOMQN LJHQLV EHV]pOMQN  eV KD  pQ NpU QpOHNUi" ² +RJ\ PHJQVOMHN" UOWVpJ +DUH\ 1HP NHOO QH NHPVHQNLFVDNWH )|OpPKDMROW6]iPRQpUH]WHPDOHKHOHWpWRO\DQHUVHQ iW|OHOWKRJ\yOPRViOPRVViJRPHJ\SLOODQDWUDHOP~OW ²0iVNpSSPRQGG ²6]HUHWOHN )HMH D YiOODPUD ]XKDQW pUH]WHP J|UFV|VHQ OH]iUW SLO OiLQDNUHPHJpVpWpVDN|QQ\HNQHGYHVVpJpW ²0LEDMRG+DUH\" ² 6HPPL 6HPPL 6HPPL ² KDMWRJDWWD HJ\UH FV|Q GHVHEEHQ,J\HNH]WHPQ\LWYDWDUWDQLDV]HPHPGHIRO\WRQ OHFVXNyGRWW1HPLVWXGRPPLNRUDOXGWDPHO 9|U|V KDMQDOUD pEUHGWHP ÐORPQHKp] YROW D IHMHP WDUNyPSHGLJRO\DQPHUHYPLQWKDFVLJRO\iLP|VV]HQWWHN YROQD eUGHV GDJDGW Q\HOYHPHW PR]GtWDQL VHP EtUWDP 9DODPL PpUJH]pV OHKHW ² JRQGROWDP PtJ HUON|GYH I|OHPHOWHP D IHMHP +DUH\ IHOp Q\~OWDP .H]HP D KLGHJ OHSHGK|]pUW 9LOOiPJ\RUVDQIHOOWHP 

$] iJ\UHV YROWD NDELQEDQ VHQNL $] DEODNYHJHNHQ Y|U|V NRURQJRN WNU|]WpN YLVV]D D QDSRW /HXJURWWDP D] iJ\UyO 1HYHWVpJHV OiWYiQ\ OHKHWHWW WiQWRURJWDP PLQW D UpV]HJ %~WRURNED NDSDV]NRGWDP QHNLHVWHP D V]HNUpQ\ QHN ² D IUGV]RED UHV YROW $ IRO\RVy LV $ NLVODERUEDQ VHPWDOiOWDPVHQNLW ² +DUH\ ² RUGtWRWWDP D IRO\RVy N|]HSpQ NiEXOWDQ KDGRQiV]YD ² +DUH\   ² Q\|JWHP PpJ HJ\V]HU GH DNNRUPiUWXGWDP 1HPHPOpNV]HPSRQWRVDQPLW|UWpQWD]WiQÔJ\ UpP OLN NHUHV]WONDVXO YiJWDWWDP D] ÉOORPiVRQ HJ\ V]iO LQJEHQHPOpNV]HPPpJDK,WKi]EDLVOHURKDQWDPPHJ D OHJDOVy UDNWiUED pV |N|OOHO YHUWHP D] HOUHWHV]HOW DMWyW 7DOiQW|EEV]|ULVYROWDPRWW'E|UJ|WWDOpSFVHOYiJyG WDP IHOXJURWWDP PHJLQW URKDQWDP YDODKRYi YpJO D] iWWHWV] YpGIDOKR]MXWRWWDPDPHO\P|J|WWDNLMiUDWYDQD GXSOD SiQFpODMWy 7HOMHV HUPEO G|QJHWWHP pV RUGtWRW WDP KRJ\ OHJ\HQ H] FVDN iORP 9DODNL PiU HJ\ LGHMH PHOOHWWHP YROW UiQJDWRWW pV K~]RWW YDODPHUUH $]WiQ D NLVODERUEDQ YROWDPMpJKLGHJYt]WO OXFVNRV LQJEHQ FVDS ]RWWKDMMDORUUO\XNDLPDWpVQ\HOYHPHWV]HV]pJHWWHPDMG QHP KDQ\DWW KHYHUWHP YDODPL KLGHJ IpPHQ ]LKiOWDP 6QDXWDSHFVpWHVYiV]RQQDGUiJMiEDQD J\yJ\V]HUHV V]HN UpQ\N|UOVUJ|OG|WW YDODPLWIHOG|QW|WW D P,V]HUHNpV YHJHNIOVLNHWtWHQFV|U|PS|OWHN (J\V]HU FVDN RWW iOOW I|OpP KDMROYD pV ILJ\HOPHVHQ D V]HPHPEHQp]HWW ²+ROYDQ" ²1LQFV ²'HGH+DUH\   ²1LQFVPiU+DUH\²WDJROWDODVVDQDUFiWD]HQ\pPKH] N|]HOtWYH PLQWKD FVDSiVW PpUQH UiP pV PRVW D KDWiVW ILJ\HOQp ² 9LVV]DM|Q   ² VXWWRJWDP EHKXQ\W V]HPPHO eV PRVWHOV]|UpUH]WHPKRJ\LJD]iQQHPIpOHNDNtVpUWHWLHV YLVV]DWpUpVWO 1HP pUWHWWHP KRJ\ LV IpOKHWWHP WOH YDODKD ²,GGPHJ 3RKDUDW Q\~MWRWW IHOpP YDODPL PHOHJ IRO\DGpNNDO 0HJQp]WHP D]WiQ KLUWHOHQ D] DUFiED ORFFVDQWRWWDP D] 

HJpV]HW 6]HPpW W|U|OJHWYH KiWUiOW 0LUH NLQ\LWRWWD RWW iOOWDPI|O|WWH(JpV]HQNLFVLQHNOiWV]RWW ²7HYROWiO" ²0LUOEHV]pOV]" ² 1H KD]XGM WXGRG WH KRJ\ PLUO 7H EHV]pOWpO YHOH DNNRU pMMHO" eV WH PRQGWDG KRJ\ PD pMMHOUH DOWDWyW DG MRQ   "0LWFVLQiOWiOYHOH"%HV]pOM $ ]VHEpEHQ NHUHVJpOW (OK~]RWW HJ\ J\,U|WW ERUtWpNRW .LNDSWDP D NH]pEO /H YROW UDJDV]WYD .tYO VHPPL )HOWpSWHP 1pJ\UpW KDMWRWW SDStU HVHWW NL EHOOH 1DJ\ EHW,V NLFVLW J\HUHNHV tUiV JLUEHJXUED VRURNEDQ 0HJLV PHUWHP 'UiJiP pQ NpUWHP Ui  My HPEHU %RU]DV]Wy KRJ\ KD]XGQRP NHOOHWW QHNHG GH PXV]iM YROW &VDN HJ\HW WHKHWV] pUWHP KDOOJDVV UiP pV QH WpJ\ NiUW PDJDGEDQ 1DJ\V]HU, YROWiO $ODWWD HJ\ iWK~]RWW V]y NLEHW,]WHP Å+DUH\µ tUWD D]WiQ |VV]HILUNiOWD PpJ HJ\ EHW, YROW RWW + YDJ\ 6 SDFiYi NHQGYH ÔMUD HOROYDVWDP D]WiQ PHJLQW eV PpJ HJ\V]HU 0iU My]DQDEE YROWDP DQQiO KRJ\ UM|QJHQL NH]GMHN PpJ IHOMDMGXOQL VHP EtUWDP QHP M|WW NL KDQJ D WRUNRPRQ ²+RJ\DQ"²VXWWRJWDP²+RJ\DQ" ²0DMGNpVEE.HOYLQ6]HGG|VV]HPDJDG ²6]HGHP%HV]pOM+RJ\DQ" ²$QQLKLOiFLy ² +RJ\KRJ\" +LV]HQ D NpV]OpN   " ² UREEDQW NL EHOOHP ² $ 5RFKHNpV]OpN QHP YROW DONDOPDV 6DUWRULXV PiVLNDW pStWHWW VSHFLiOLV GHVWDELOL]iWRUW .LFVLW 1pKiQ\ PpWHUHVKDWyVXJDU~W ²0LOHWW  YHOH" ²(OW,QW(J\YLOODQiVpVHJ\IXYDOODW*\HQJHIXYDOODW 0iVVHPPL ².LVKDWyVXJDU~D]WPRQGWDG" ²,JHQ1DJ\REEKR]QHPYROWDQ\DJ $ IDODN KLUWHOHQ IHOpP NH]GWHN GOQL %HKXQ\WDP D V]HPHP ²8UDPLVWHQ  GHKiW  KLV]HQ~J\LVYLVV]DM|Q   ²1HPM|Q ²+RJ\KRJ\   " 

² 1HP M|Q .HOYLQ (POpNV]HO D]RNUD D IHOV]iOOy KDEIHOKNUH"$]yWDQHPM|QQHNYLVV]D ²1HPM|QQHN" ²1HP ²0HJ|OWHG²PRQGWDPKDONDQ ²0HJ7HPiVWWHWWpOYROQD"$]pQKHO\HPEHQ" )HOXJURWWDPpVMiUNiOQLNH]GWHPHJ\UHJ\RUVDEEDQD IDOWyO D VDURNLJ pV YLVV]D .LOHQF OpSpV )RUGXOM .LOHQF OpSpV 0HJiOOWDPHOWWH ²,GHKDOOJDVVMHOHQWpVWtUXQN.|]YHWOHQ|VV]HN|WWHWpVW NpUQN D 7DQiFFVDO 0HJ OHKHW FVLQiOQL %HOHPHQQHN 0XV]iM .LYRQMiN D ERO\JyW D 1pJ\HN HJ\H]PpQ\H DOyO 0LQGHQ HV]N|] PHJHQJHGYH $QWLDQ\DJJHQHUiWRURNDW KR]XQN $] DQWLDQ\DJQDN VHPPL VHP iOO HOOHQ 6HPPL 6HPPL²YLFVRURJWDPGLDGDOPDVDQN|QQ\HNWOYDNRQ ²0HJDNDURGVHPPLVtWHQL"²NpUGH]WH²0LpUW" ²0HQMLQQHQ+DJ\MHQJHP ²1HPPHJ\HN ²6QDXW )DUNDVV]HPHWQp]WQN1HPHWLQWHWW ²0LWDNDUV]"0LWDNDUV]WOHP" $]DV]WDOKR]KiWUiOW ²-y0HJtUMXNDMHOHQWpVW (OIRUGXOWDPpVMiUNiOQLNH]GWHP ²hOMOH ²+DJ\MEpNpQ ² .pWGRORJUyO YDQV]y$] HOV  D WpQ\HN $ PiVLN D PLN|YHWHOpVHLQN ²eSSHQPRVWNHOOHUUOEHV]pOQQN" ²eSSHQPRVW ²+iWQHPeUWHG")W\O|ND]HJpV]UH ² $] XWROVy MHOHQWpVW *LEDULDQ KDOiOD HOWW NOGWN -y NpW KyQDSMD 3RQWRVDQ UHNRQVWUXiOQXQN NHOO D] HVH PpQ\HNHWKRJ\DQMHOHQWHNPHJD    ²+DJ\RGDEED"²UDJDGWDPPHJDYiOOiW ² 0HJYHUKHWV] DNNRU LV IRO\WDWRP ² MHOHQWHWWH NL (OHQJHGWHP ²&VLQiOMDPLWDNDUV] 

² $] D KHO\]HW KRJ\ 6DUWRULXV PHJSUyEiO PDMG HJ\HV WpQ\HNHWHOWLWNROQL(EEHQPDMGQHPEL]WRVYDJ\RN ²eVWHQHP" ² 1HP 0RVW PiUQHP(] QHP FVDN D PL J\QN ,WW DUUyO YDQ V]y   WXGRG PLUO  eUWHOPHV WHYpNHQ\VpJHW WDQ~VtWRWW 6RKDVHP WDSDV]WDOW PDJDVUHQG, V]HUYHV V]LQWp]LVUH NpSHV ,VPHUL D WHVWQN IHOpStWpVpW PLNUR VWUXNW~UiMiWDQ\DJFVHUpMpW   ²5HQGEHQYDQ²PRQGWDP²eVD]WiQ"0LpUWKDJ\RG DEED" (OYpJ]HWW YHOQN HJ\   NtVpUOHWVRUR]DWRW 3V]LFKLNDL pOYHERQFROiVW $ IHMQNEO NLORSRWW DGDWRN DODSMiQ  FVHSSHW VHP W|UGYH D]]DO  KRJ\  PL PLW DND UXQN ² (]HN PiU QHP WpQ\HN .HOYLQ PpJ FVDN QHP LV N|YHWNH]WHWpVHN 3XV]WiQ KLSRWp]LVHN %L]RQ\RV pUWHOHP EHQpSSHQD]]DOV]iPROWDPLWD]DJ\XQNHJ\]iUWUHMWHWW UpV]HDNDU/HKHWWHNH]HN²DMiQGpNRNLV   ²$MiQGpNRN-yViJRV,VWHQ +DKRWi]QLNH]GWHP ² +DJ\G DEED ² ULYDOOW UiP pV HONDSWD D NH]HPHW 6]RUtWDQL NH]GWHP D] XMMDLW $GGLJ V]RUtWRWWDP PtJ EH OHURSSDQWDNDFVRQWMDL0HJVHUH]]HQWFVDNQp]HWW|VV]H K~]RWWV]HPPHO(OHQJHGWHPpVDVDURNEDNXOORJWDP ² ,J\HNV]HP EHV]QWHWQL D K]|QJpVW ² PRQGWDP D IDOQDNIRUGXOYD ²1HPpUGHNHV6]yYDOPLWN|YHWHOMQN" ² $PLW DNDUV] eQ PRVW QHP WXGRN JRQGRONR]QL 0RQGRWWYDODPLWPLHOWW   "  ²1HP6HPPLWeQDPDJDPUpV]pUO~J\OiWRPKRJ\ PRVWLWWDOHKHWVpJ ² /HKHWVpJ" 0LUH" -D   ² IRO\WDWWDP FV|QGHVHE EHQ D V]HPpEH Qp]YH PHUW DNNRU pUWHWWHP PHJ ² $ .DSFVRODW" 0HJLQW D .DSFVRODW" 1HP YROWHOpJ DPLW   WH LV PHJ H] D] HJpV] UOWHNKi]D   .DSFVRODW" 1R QHPQHPeQHEEONLV]iOORN ²0LpUW" ² NpUGH]WH Q\XJRGWDQ ² .HOYLQ WH PpJ PRVW LV VW PRVW PpJ LQNiEE PLQW HGGLJ |V]W|Q|VHQ HPEHUQHNWHNLQWHG*\,O|O|G ²eVWHQHP"    ²YHWHWWHPRGD ²1HP+LV]HQ YDN.HOYLQ   

² 9DN" ² LVPpWHOWHP 1HP YROWDP EHQQH EL]WRV MyO KDOORWWDPH ² 3HUV]H D PL IHOIRJiVXQN V]HULQW 6]iPiUD QHP ~J\ OpWH]QN DKRJ\DQ HJ\PiVQDN 0L DUUyO LVPHUMN PpJ HJ\PiVW PLQW HJ\pQHNHW DPLW OiWXQN D] DUFUyO D WHVW NOOHPpUO1HNLD]FVDNiWOiWV]yYHJ+LV]HQD]DJ\XQN EHOVHMpEHKDWROW ²1RMyeVDNNRU"0LN|YHWNH]LNHEEO "+DIHOWXGRWW WiPDV]WDQLPHJWXGRWWWHUHPWHQLHJ\HPEHUWDNLFVDND] pQ HPOpNHLPEHQ OpWH]LN GH ~J\ KRJ\ D V]HPH D PR]JiVDDKDQJMD  DKDQJMD   ²)RO\WDVG)RO\WDVGKDOORG" ² -y   My   ,JHQ 6]yYDO   D KDQJMD   HEEO D] N|YHWNH]LN KRJ\ ~J\ ROYDV EHQQQN PLQW D Q\LWRWW N|Q\YEHQeUWHGPLWDNDURNPRQGDQL" ² eUWHP +RJ\ KD DNDUQi NDSFVRODWED OpSKHWQH YH OQN" ²3HUV]H+iWQHPQ\LOYiQYDOy" ² 1HP (J\iOWDOiQ QHP +LV]HQ FVDN D J\iUWiVL UH FHSWHW YHWWH HO DPL QHP V]DYDNEyO iOO )HKpUMHVWUXNW~UD PLQW PLQGHQ HPOpNNpS 0LQW D] RQGyV]iO IHMH YDJ\ D SHWHVHMW 2WW D] DJ\EDQ QLQFVHQHN V]DYDN pU]pVHN HJ\ HPEHU HPOpNH FVDN NpS DPL D QXNOHLQVDYDN Q\HOYpQ tUyGRWWDQDJ\PROHNXOiVDV]LQNURQNULVWiO\RNUD+iWYHWWH DOHJPpO\HEEHQEHOpQNPDUyGRWWOHJ]iUWDEEOHJWHOMHVHEE OHJYLOiJRVDEEHPOpNNpSHWpUWHG"'HDONDOPDVLQWIRJDOPD VHP YROW KRJ\ PL D] V]iPXQNUD PL D MHOHQWpVH 0LQWKD IDEULNiOQL WXGQiQN HJ\ V]LPPHWULiGRW pV EHGREQiQN D] yFHiQED LVPHUYH D V]HUNH]HWpW WHFKQROyJLiMiW pStWDQ\DJiWFVDNpSSHQD]WQHPpUWHQpQNPLUHYDOyPL DFpOMDPLWMHOHQWQHNL   ²/HKHWVpJHV²W,QGWHP²,JHQOHKHWVpJHVeVKDtJ\ YDQ DNNRU WDOiQ QHP LV   WDOiQ QHP LV DNDUW tJ\ PHJWLSRUQL pV |VV]HPRU]VROQL PLQNHW /HKHW eV SXV]WiQ DNDUDWODQXO   5HPHJQLNH]GHWWDV]iP ².HOYLQ ²7XGRPWXGRP,JHQ6HPPLEDM7HMyIL~YDJ\ LV My 0LQGHQNL My 'H PLpUW" (]W PDJ\DUi]G PHJ 0LpUW" 0LpUWFVLQiOWDGH]W"0LWPRQGWiOQHNL" 

²$]LJD]DW ²,JD]DWLJD]DW'HPLW" ² ÔJ\LV WXGRG *\HUH PRVW EH KR]]iP 0HJtUMXN D MHOHQWpVW*\HUH ² 9iUM 0LW DNDUV] WH YROWDNpSSHQ" &VDN QHP DNDUV] LWWPDUDGQLD]ÉOORPiVRQ"    ²'HLJHQ,WWPDUDGRN

$]|UHJPLPRLG

hOWHPDQDJ\DEODNQiOpVQp]WHPD]yFHiQW1HPYROW VHPPL GROJRP $ MHOHQWpV DPLW |W QDSLJ tUWXQN PiU KXOOiPN|WHJNpQW V]iJXOGRWW D] ,UEHQ YDODKRO D] 2ULRQ FVLOODJNpSWiMiQ0LNRUHOpULDV|WpWSRUN|G|WDPHO\Q\ROF WULOOLyN|EPpUI|OGHWW|OW EH V PLQGHQ MHOHWpV IpQ\VXJDUDW HOQ\HO UiWDOiO D N|]YHWtWOiQF HOV iOORPiViUD 2QQDQ HJ\LN UiGLyEyMiUyO D PiVLNLJ V]|NYH VRN PLOOLiUG NLORPpWHUHVXJUiVRNNDOEHIXWHJ\yULiVLtYHWPtJD]XWROVy iOORPiVDSUHFt]LyVP,V]HUHNNHO]V~IROWIpPW|PEHONDSMD KRVV]~ SRIiM~ LUiQ\DQWHQQiMiYDO PpJ HJ\V]HU |VV]SRQWRVtWMD pV ~MUD NLGREMD D] ,UEH D )|OG LUiQ\iED $]WiQ WHOQHN D KyQDSRN D )|OGUO NLOWW KDVRQOy HQHU JLDQ\DOiE WRU]XOiVEDUi]GiW K~]YD PDJD XWiQ D 7HM~W UHQGV]HU JUDYLWiFLyV WHUpEHQ NR]PLNXV IHOKQHN WN|]LN iWVLNOLNUDMWDIHOIHOHUV|GLNDODVVDQKLQWi]yEyMiNOiQFD PHQWpQ V YiOWR]DWODQ VHEHVVpJJHO V]iJXOG WRYiEE D 6R ODULVNHWWVQDSMDIHOp $]yFHiQDPDJDVDQMiUyY|U|VQDSDODWWIHNHWpEEYROW PLQWYDODKD$V]HPKDWiUUR]VGDV]tQ, N|GEHEXUNROy]RWW NO|Q|VHQ SiUiV QDS YROW PLQWKD D] LJHQ ULWND pV HONpS]HOKHWHWOHQO KHYHV YLKDURN HJ\LNH N|]HOHJQH DPHO\HN pYHQWH FVDN QpKiQ\V]RU pV]OHOKHWN D ERO\JyQ 1HP DODSWDODQ D IHOWHYpV KRJ\ HJ\HWOHQ ODNyMD PDJD LUiQ\tWMDD]LGMiUiVWpVPDJDNHOWLH]HNHWDYLKDURNDW +yQDSRNLJ NHOO PpJ NLEiPXOQL H]HQ D] DEODNRQ Qp]QL D PDJDVEyO D IHKpU DUDQ\ pV D IiUDGW EtERU YiOWDNR]iViW DPHO\ RO\NRU HJ\HJ\ NLW|U JHM]tUEHQ HJ\HJ\ V]LPPHW ULiG H]VW|V EXERUpNiEDQ WNU|]GLN Q\RPRQ N|YHWQL D V]pOEHQ KDMODGR]y NDUFV~ OHQJHWHJHN YiQGRUOiViW IpOLJ HOPiOORWWSRUODGyPLPRLGRNUDEXNNDQQL(J\V]pSQDSRQ PLQGHQ YL]RIRQ NpSHUQ\MH YLOORJQL NH]G pOHWUH NHO D UpJyWD PR]GXODWODQ HOHNWURQLNXV MHO]EHUHQGH]pV W|EE V]i]H]HUNLORPpWHUUOpUNH] LPSXO]XVKR]]DP,N|GpVEH D IpPNRORVV]XV N|]HOHGpVpW MHO]L DPHO\ IOVLNHWtW JUDYLWRUE~JiVVDO OHV]iOO D] yFHiQ I|Op $] 8O\VVHV OHV] D] YDJ\ D 3URPpWKHXV] YDJ\ YDODPHO\LN PiVLN QDJ\ KRVV]~Mi 

HOHWURQLNXV

UDW~ FLUNiOy 0LNRU D] ÉOORPiV ODSRV WHWHMpUO IHOPiV]RP D] DNQD OpWUiMiQ PHJSLOODQWRP PDMG D IHGpO]HWHQ VRUD NR]y ]|P|N IHKpUSiQFpORV DXWRPDWiNDW DPHO\HN PHQ WHVHN D] HUHGHQG E,QWO pV RO\DQ iUWDWODQRN KRJ\ WHO MHVtWHQHN PLQGHQ SDUDQFVRW DNiU HO LV SXV]WtWMiN |QPD JXNDW YDJ\ D] ~WMXNEDQ iOOy DNDGiO\W KD H]W SURJUDPR] WiNEHNULVWiO\RNEDQUH]J PHPyULiMXNED$]WiQHOLQGXOD KDMy ]DMWDODQXO PHUW J\RUVDEE D KDQJQiO EDVV]XV RNWiYRNUD W|UW G|UGOpVHNQHN D] yFHiQLJ WHUMHG N~SMiW KDJ\YD PDJD P|J|WW pV HJ\ SHUFLJ PLQGHQ HPEHU DUFiW IHOGHUtWLDJRQGRODWKRJ\KD]DWpUQHN 'H QHNHP QLQFV KRYi KD]DWpUQHP $ )|OG" (ONpS ]HOWHP D ]V~IROW OiUPiV QDJ\YiURVRNDW DPHO\HNEHQ HOYHV]HN HOVRGUyGRP PDMGQHP ~J\ PLQWKD PHJWHWWHP YROQD DPLW PiVRGLN YDJ\ KDUPDGLN pMMHO DNDUWDP ² EHOHYHWQL PDJDP D YDNV|WpWEHQ ORPKiQ KXOOiP]y yFHiQ ED(OPHUO|ND]HPEHUHNW|PHJpEHQ+DOOJDWDJpVILJ\HO PHV OHV]HN WHKiW PHJEHFVOW SDUWQHU OHV] VRN LVPHUV|PVWEDUiWRPPHJQNWDOiQPpJHJ\HWOHQQ LV (J\ LGHLJ NpQ\V]HUtWHP PDJDP KRJ\ PRVRO\RJMDN N|V]|QMHN I|ONHOMHN HOYpJH]]HP D]W D] H]HUQ\L DSUy WHHQGW DPLEO D I|OGL pOHW iOO D]WiQ PiU QHP LV pU]HP NHW7DOiORN~MpUGHNOGpVLWHUOHWHNHW~MIRJODODWRVViJR NDWGHQHPDGRPiWPDJDPQHNLNHJpV]HQ6HPPLQHNpV VHQNLQHN VRKD W|EEp eV pMV]DND WDOiQ PDMG DUUDIHOp EiPXORN DKRO D V|WpW SRUIHOK IHNHWH IJJ|Q\NpQW HOWDNDUMDDNpWQDSIpQ\pWIHOLGp]HNPLQGHQWD]WLVDPLQ PRVW W|SUHQJHN pV SLFLW IiMGDOPDV GH LQNiEE I|OpQ\HV HOQp] PRVROO\DO JRQGRORN YLVV]D UOWVpJHPUH pV UHPpQ\HLPUH (J\iOWDOiQ QHP WDUWRP URVV]DEEQDN H]W D M|YHQG PDJDPDW DQQiO D .HOYLQQpO DNL PLQGHQUH NpV] YROWD.DSFVRODWQDNQHYH]HWWJ\pUWeVVHQNLQHNVHPOHV] MRJDKRJ\HOtWpOMHQ 6QDXW OpSHWW EH D NDELQED .|UOQp]HWW D]WiQ UiP SLOODQWRWWIHOiOOWDPpVD]DV]WDOKR]PHQWHP ²$NDUV]YDODPLW" ² 1LQFV VHPPL GROJRG LJD]"    ² NpUGH]WH KXQ\R URJYD ² $GKDWQpN YDODPLW WXGRG YDQ HJ\NpW V]iPtWiV EiUQHPpSSHQDOHJVUJVHEEHN   ².|V]|Q|P²PRVRO\RJWDP²GHI|O|VOHJHV 

²%L]WRVYDJ\HEEHQ"²ILUWDWWDD]DEODNRQNLQp]YH ²%L]WRV0LQGHQIpOpQJRQGRONR]WDPpV   ²-REEDQV]HUHWQpPKDQHPJRQGRONR]QiODQQ\LW ² 8J\DQ KLV]HQ QHP LV WXGRG PLUO YDQ V]y 0RQGG FVDN  KLV]HOWH,VWHQEHQ" *\RUVSLOODQWiVWYHWHWWUiP ²0HQMPiU.LKLV]PDQDSViJ   1\XJWDODQYROWDWHNLQWHWH ² 9iUM QHP LO\HQ HJ\V]HU, D GRORJ ² PDJ\DUi]WDP V]iQGpNRVDQN|QQ\HGKDQJRQ² eQ QHP D I|OGLYDOOiVRN KDJ\RPiQ\RV ,VWHQpUO EHV]pOHN 3HUV]H QHP YDJ\RN YDO OiVNXWDWy OHKHW KRJ\ VHPPL ~MDW QHP VW|WWHP NL GH QHP WXGRG YpOHWOHQO KLWWHNH YDODKD HJ\   J\DUOy LVWHQEHQ" ² *\DUOyEDQ" ² YRQWD IHO D V]HP|OG|NpW ² +RJ\ pUWHG H]W" %L]RQ\RV V]HPSRQWEyO PLQGHQ YDOOiV LVWHQH J\DUOy YROW PHUW HPEHUL WXODMGRQViJRNDW DJJDWWDN Ui FVDN IHOQDJ\tWYD $] ÐWHVWDPHQWXP ,VWHQH SpOGiXO KDMEy NROiVUD pV iOGR]DWRNUD VyYiUJy PiV LVWHQHNUH IpOWpNHQ\ ]VDUQRN   D J|U|J LVWHQHN LV WHOH YROWDN HPEHUL J\DUOy ViJRNNDOFLYDNRGiVRNFVDOiGLSHUSDWYDURN   ²1HP²V]DNtWRWWDPIpOEH²pQRO\DQLVWHQUHJRQGRORN DNL QHP D]pUW W|NpOHWOHQ PHUW HJ\J\, HPEHUHN WDOiOWiN NL KDQHP OHJOpQ\HJHVHEE LPPDQHQV WXODMGRQViJD D W|NpOHWOHQVpJ 2O\DQ LVWHQ DNLQHN PLQGHQWXGiVD pV PLQGHQKDWyViJD NRUOiWROW WpYHVHQ OiWMD HOUH P,YHLQHN M|YMpW D] iOWDOD HOLQGtWRWW HVHPpQ\HN RO\DQ LUiQ\ED IRUGXOKDWQDN DPHO\ W PDJiW LV PHJUpPtWL (] HJ\   Q\RPRUpN LVWHQ DNL PLQGLJ W~OViJRVDQ VRNDW PDUNRO pV HUUH PLQGLJ NpVQ M|Q Ui $NL FVDN D] yUiNDW V]HUNHV]WHWWH QHP D] LGW DPLW PpUQHN 5HQGV]HUHNHW YDJ\JpSH]HWHNHWIDEULNiOWPHJKDWiUR]RWWFpORNUDGHD]RN W~OQWWHNDFpORNRQpVHOiUXOWiNNHWeVPHJWHUHPWHWWHD YpJWHOHQVpJHW GH D] QHP KDWDOPiQDN PpUFpMH OHWW DPLQHNV]iQWDFVDNKDWiUWDODQYHUHVpJpQHNPpUWpNH ² 9DODPLNRU UpJHQ D PDQLFKHL]PXV   ² NH]GWH KDER]YD6QDXW*\DQDNYyWDUWy]NRGiVDPHOO\HOD]XWyEEL LGEHQNH]HOWPRVWIHOROGyGRWW ²'HHQQHNVHPPLN|]HDMypVDURVV]SULQFtSLXPiKR] ² V]DNtWRWWDP U|JW|Q IpOEH ² (] D] ,VWHQ QHP 

OpWH]LND]DQ\DJRQNtYOpVQHPWXGWOHV]DEDGXOQLFVDN V]HUHWQH   ² ,O\HQ YDOOiVW QHP LVPHUHN ² PRQGWD U|YLG KDOOJDWiV XWiQ ² ,O\HQUH VRKDVHP YROW V]NVpJ +D MyO pUWHOHN pV DWWyO WDUWRN tJ\ YDQ WH YDODPL IHMOG LVWHQUH JRQGROV] DNL D] LGEHQ pULN pV Q|YHNV]LN D KDWDORP HJ\UH PDJDVDEE IRNDLUD KiJ pV UiG|EEHQ KDWDOPD WHKHWHW OHQVpJpUH"(]DWHLVWHQHGRO\DQOpQ\DNLQHNV]iPiUDD] LVWHQVpJ NL~WWDODQ KHO\]HW pV PLNRU H]W PHJpUWL NpW VpJEHHVLN1RMyGHDNpWVpJEHHV LVWHQQHPPiVPLQWD] HPEHULJD]"6]yYDOD]HPEHUUHJRQGROV]   gUHJHP H] QHPFVDNILOR]yILiQDNGHPpJPLV]WLNiQDNLVJ\HQJH ² 1HP D] HPEHUUH JRQGRORN ² PDNDFVNRGWDP ² 1pKiQ\YRQiVDWDOiQPHJIHOHODWHDONDOPL GHILQtFLyGQDN GH FVDN D]pUW PHUW RO\DQ Kp]DJRV $] HPEHU D OiWV]DW HOOHQpUH QHP DONRW PDJiQDN FpORNDW %HOHV]OHWLN HJ\ NRUEDDPHO\NpV]FpORNHOpiOOtWMDV]ROJiOKDWMDNHWYDJ\ IHOOi]DGKDW HOOHQN GH D V]ROJiODW YDJ\ D Oi]DGiV WiUJ\D NtYOUO DGRWW +RJ\ PHJLVPHUKHVVH D FpORN NHUHVpVpQHN WHOMHV V]DEDGViJiW HJ\HGO NHOOHQH OHQQLH H] SHGLJ QHP VLNHUOKHWPHUWKDQHPHPEHUHNN|]|WWQHYHONHGLNQHP YiOKDW HPEHUUp (] D] pQ   YDODNLP FVDN RO\DQ OpQ\ OHKHWDNLQHNQLQFVW|EEHVV]iPDpUWHG" ²Ð²PRQGWD²KRJ\U|JW|QUiQHPM|WWHP   eVNLPXWDWRWWD]DEODNRQ ²1HP²WLOWDNR]WDP² VHPD]/HJIHOMHEEPLQWRO\DQ OpQ\ DNL IHMOGpVH VRUiQ HOPXODV]WRWWD D] LVWHQQp YiOiV OHKHWVpJpW PHUW W~O KDPDU PDJiED ]iUNy]RWW  FVDN UHPHWH D .R]PRV] UHPHWpMH QHP LVWHQH    LVPpWOL PDJiW 6QDXW GH D] DNLUH pQ JRQGRORN H]W VRKDVHP WHQQp7DOiQpSSHQPRVW NHOHWNH]LN YDODKROD 7HM~WUHQG V]HUYDODPHO\LN]XJiEDQpVLIMRQWLMyNHGYpEHQKDPDURVDQ HONH]G FVLOODJRNDW ROWRJDWQL pV ~MDNDW NLJ\~MWDQL HJ\ LG P~OYDPDMGpV]UHYHVV]N   ²0iULVpV]UHYHWWN²MHJ\H]WHPHJIDQ\DUXO6QDXW² $ QRYiN pV V]XSHUQRYiN   V]HULQWHG D]  ROWiUiQDN J\HUW\iL" ² +D WH LO\HQ V]y V]HULQW DNDURG YHQQL DPLW PRQ GRN   ² 1R pV KiWKD pSSHQ  D 6RODULV  D WH LVWHQEpELG E|OFVMH²IRO\WDWWD6QDXW6]HPHN|UODYpNRQ\UiQFRN 

EDQHJ\UHKDWiUR]RWWDEEPRVRO\EXMNiOW²+iWKDpSSHQD WH NpWVpJEHHV LVWHQHG FVtUiMD YDJ\ SDOiQWiMD *\HUPHNL |V]W|QHL PpJ MyFVNiQ IHOOP~OMiN pUWHOPpW pV PLQGD] DPLW V]RODULV]WLNDL N|Q\YWiUDLQN WDUWDOPD]QDN HJ\ FVHFVHP U~JNDSiOiVDLQDNKRVV]~ODMVWURPD   ² 0L PHJ HJ\ GDUDELJ D MiWpNV]HUHL YROWXQN ² WHWWHP KR]]i ² +iW LJHQ OHKHW eV WXGRG PLO\HQ QDJ\ HUHGPpQ\W pUWpO HO" 9DGRQDW~M KLSRWp]LVW DONRWWiO D 6R ODULVUyO H] SHGLJ QDJ\ V]y 5iDGiVXO RO\DW PHO\ U|JW|Q PHJPDJ\DUi]]DPLpUWQHPVLNHUONDSFVRODWRWWHUHPWHQL PLpUW QHP pUNH]LN YiODV] PLpUW EiQW HO YHOQN LO\HQ HQ\KpQ V]yOYD VDMiWRV PyGRQ HJ\ NLVJ\HUHN SV]LFKL NXPD   ² /HPRQGRN D V]HU]L MRJUyO ² G|UP|JWH D] DEODNQiO iOOYD 6RNiLJ EiPXOWXN D IHNHWH KXOOiPRNDW $ NHOHWL KRUL]RQWRQ ViSDGW KRVV]~NiV IROWRFVND ERQWDNR]RWW NL D N|GEO ²+RQQDQV]HGWHGH]WDJ\DUOyLVWHQGROJRW"²NpUGH]WH KLUWHOHQ1HPYHWWHOHV]HPpWDFVLOORJyYpJWHOHQUO ² 1HP WXGRP 'H QDJ\RQ QDJ\RQ LJD]QDN WDOiOWDP pUWHG" (] D] HJ\HWOHQ LVWHQ DNLEHQ KDMODQGy YROQpN KLQQL $NLQHN D V]HQYHGpVH QHP PHJYiOWiV QHP GY|]tW VHQNLWQHPV]ROJiOVHPPLUHFVDNYDQ ² (J\ PLPRLG   ² MHJ\H]WH PHJ KDONDQ PiV KDQJRQ 6QDXW ² 0LW PRQGDV]" -D LJHQ 0iU D] HOEE pV]UHYHWWHP 1DJ\RQ|UHJ 0LQGNHWWHQDY|U|VN|GEHQ~V]yKRUL]RQWRWQp]WN ²/HPHJ\HN²V]yOWDPKLUWHOHQ²ÔJ\VHYROWDPPpJD] ÉOORPiVRQ NtYO PRVW LWW D] DONDORP (J\ IpOyUD P~OYD YLVV]DM|Y|N   ² 0LFVRGD" ² PHUHV]WHWW QDJ\ V]HPHNHW 6QDXW ² /H DNDUV]PHQQL"+RYi" ² 2GD ² PXWDWWDP D N|GEO HOUpPO WHVWHV IROWUD ² 0LpUW QH" $ NLV KHOLNRSWHUUHO 0pJLVFVDN QHYHWVpJHV YROQD KD PDMG HJ\V]HU D )|OG|Q EH NHOOHQH YDOODQRP KRJ\ V]RODULVWD OpWHPUH VRKDVHP WHWWHP D OiEDP D 6R ODULVUD   $V]HNUpQ\KH]VpWiOWDPpVYiORJDWQLNH]GWHPDNH]HV OiEDVRNN|]|WW6QDXWQpPiQILJ\HOWD]WiQNLE|NWH ²1HPWHWV]LNH]QHNHP 

² 0L" ² IRUGXOWDP PHJ D] RYHUDOODO D NH]HPEHQ 5pJ QHP pU]HWW L]JDORP IRJRWW HO ² 0L QHP WHWV]LN" .L YHOH $WWyO IpOV] KRJ\   KO\HVpJ 6]DYDPDW DGRP KRJ\ QHP(V]HPiJiEDQVLQFV.RPRO\DQ ²(ONtVpUOHN ².|V]|Q|PGHLQNiEEPDJDPPHJ\HN7XGRGQHNHP H] ~MGRQViJ OHV] HJpV]HQ ~M pOPpQ\ ² KDGDUWDP PLDODWW EHE~MWDPDNH]HVOiEDVED6QDXWPRQGRWWPpJYDODPLWGH QHP QDJ\RQ ILJ\HOWHP RGD PHUW D V]NVpJHV KROPLNDW NHUHVJpOWHP 9HOHP M|WW D UHSOWpUUH 6HJtWHWW NLK~]QL D JpSHW D] iOOiVEyOpVDUDMWNRURQJN|]HSpUHWROQL0LNRUI|OYHWWHPD V]NDIDQGHUWNLW|UW ²-HOHQWPpJQHNHGYDODPLWDEHFVOHWV]y" ² 8UDPLVWHQ 6QDXW WH PpJ PRVW LV   " -HOHQW eV PiUV]DYDPDWDGWDP+ROYDQQDNDWDUWDOpNSDODFNRN" 1HP V]yOW W|EEHW 0LNRU PDJDPUD ]iUWDP D] iWOiWV]y NXSROiWLQWHWWHPQHNL%HNDSFVROWDDOLIWHWDPHO\ODVVDQ IHOYLWW D] ÉOORPiV WHWHMpUH $ PRWRU EHUUHJQL NH]GHWW D KiUPDV OpJFVDYDU PHJS|UGOW V D JpS YDOyV]tQ,WOHQO N|QQ\HGpQ I|OHPHONHGHWW RGDOHQW KDJ\YD D] ÉOORPiV HJ\UHNLVHEEH]VWNRURQJMiW (OV]|U YROWDP HJ\HGO D] yFHiQ I|O|WW HJpV]HQ PiV OiWYiQ\W Q\~MWRWW tJ\ PLQW D] DEODNEyO 7DOiQ D]pUW LV PHUW DODFVRQ\DQ UHSOWHPDOLJ QHJ\YHQ|WYHQ PpWHUUHO D KXOOiPRNI|O|WW(GGLJFVDNWXGWDPPRVWHOV]|UpUH]WHP LV KRJ\ D ]VtURVDQ IpQ\O GRPERN pV PpO\HGpVHN YiOWDNR]y VRUD QHP ~J\ PR]RJ PLQW D WHQJHU KXOOiPDL YDJ\ D IHOKN KDQHP PLQW HJ\ iOODW 2O\DQ YROW H] D PR]JiV PLQW HJ\ FVXSDV] WHVW L]PDLQDN QDJ\RQ ODVV~ IRO\DPDWRV |VV]HK~]yGiVD pV HOHUQ\HGpVH $ ORPKiQ iW IRUGXOy KXOOiPRN WHWHMpQ Y|U|V KDE FVLOORJRWW PLNRU YLVV]DNDQ\DURGWDP KRJ\ SRQWRVDQ EHiOOMDN D UHQGNtYO ODVVDQ VRGUyGy PLPRLGV]LJHW LUiQ\iED pSSHQ V]HPEHV W|WW D QDS YpUHV YLOOiPRNDW V]yUW D GRPERU~ YHJUH PDJDD]yFHiQSHGLJWLQWDNpNOHWWV|WpWW,]SHWW\HNNHO .|UW tUWDP OH GH QHP HOpJ J\DNRUORWWDQ ~J\KRJ\ D OpJiUDPOiV PHVV]LUH VRGRUW V D PLPRLG P|JpP NHUOW V]DEiO\WDODQ N|UYRQDO~ MyNRUD YLOiJRV IROW D] yFHiQRQ (OYHV]tWHWWH D N|GWO NDSRWW Uy]ViV V]tQpW ViUJiV OHWW PLQWDV]iUD] FVRQW HJ\ SLOODQDWUD HOW,QW D V]HPHP HOO KH 

O\HWWH PHJSLOODQWRWWDPD WiYROEDQD]ÉOORPiVW KDWDOPDV UpJLPyGL ]HSSHOLQNpQW OHEHJHWW OiWV]yODJ HJpV] DODFVR Q\DQ (UVHQ ILJ\HOYH PHJLVPpWHOWHP D PDQYHUW D JURWHV]N IRUPiM~ PHUHGHN DODN]DW YLOOiPJ\RUVDQ QWW ÔJ\UpPOHWWQHNLPHJ\HNOHJPDJDVDEEJXPyVQ\~OYiQ\i QDNRO\DQKLUWHOHQUiQWRWWDPIHODJpSHWKRJ\DKLUWHOHQ ODVVXOiVWyO PHJLQJRWW NiU YROW L]JXOQL D IXUFVD WRUQ\RN J|PE|O\, FV~FVDL PpO\HQ DODWWDP VLNORWWDN HO %HiOOWDP D] ~V]y V]LJHW I|Op V ODVVDQ PpWHUUO PpWHUUH FV|NNHQ WHWWHP D PDJDVViJRW PtJ D SRUODGR]y FV~FVRN D NDELQ I|Op QHP HPHONHGWHN $ PLPRLG QHP YROW QDJ\ +RVV]D WDOiQ KiURPQHJ\HG PpUI|OG V]pOHVVpJH DOLJ SiU V]i] Pp WHUKHO\HQNpQWHONHVNHQ\HGHWWRWWQHPVRNiUDPHJUHSHG 1\LOYiQ HJ\ VRNNDO QDJ\REE NpS]GPpQ\ W|UHGpNH VR ODULVL PpUWpNNHO PpUYH FVDN UHSHV]GDUDE LVWHQ WXGMD KiQ\KHWHVYDJ\KyQDSRVDSUyPDUDGYiQ\ $] HUH]HWW PDJDVODWRN N|]|WW HJpV]HQ D] yFHiQQiO I|OIHGH]WHP YDODPL SDUWIpOpW K~V]KDUPLQF QpJ\]HWPpWH UHV HOpJJp OHMWV GH PDMGQHP VLPD IHOOHWHW V RGD WDU WRWWDPDJpSSHO $ OHV]iOOiVQHKH]HEEQHNEL]RQ\XOW PLQW YiUWDP D OpJFVDYDU NLV KtMiQ QHNLWN|]|WW HJ\ V]HPHP OiWWiUD IHOPDJDVRGy IDOQDN GH D]pUW VLNHUOW 5|JW|Q OHiOOtWRWWDP D PRWRUW pV KiWUDO|NWHP D] YHJWHWW $ V]iUQ\RQ iOOYD HOOHQUL]WHP QHP FV~V]KDWH EH D JpS D] yFHiQED² DOLJ K~V]OpSpVQ\LUH PiU KXOOiPRN Q\DOGRVWiN D ]HJ]XJRV SDUWYRQDODW ² GH D KHOLNRSWHU EL]WRVDQ iOOW V]pWYHWHWW WDOSDLQ /HXJURWWDP D    ÅI|OGUHµ $PLW D] HOEE PLNRU D OpJFVDYDU PDMGQHP EHOHWN|]|WW IDOQDN Qp]WHP pOpUH iOOtWRWW yULiVL KiUW\DYpNRQ\ FVRQWOHPH] YROW QDJ\ O\XNDNNDO pV JDOpULDV]HU, UHFpNNHO $ QpJ\|W HPHOHW PDJDV VtNRW W|EE PpWHU V]pOHV Up]V~WRV UHSHGpV RV]WRWWD NHWWp iW OHKHWHWW UDMWD OiWQL pSS~J\ PLQW D V]DEiO\WDODQXO HOV]yUW QDJ\ O\XNDNRQ )HOPiV]WDP D IDO OHJN|]HOHEELIHUGHKDVDGpNiKR]PHJiOODStWRWWDPKRJ\D V]NDIDQGHU FLSMH MyO WDSDG V D] |OW|]pN HJ\iOWDOiQ QHP QHKH]tWL PHJ D PR]JiVW YDJ\ QpJ\ HPHOHW PDJDVEyO D] yFHiQ I|O|WW D FVRQWYi]V]HU, WiM IHOp IRUGXOYD YpJUH MyO iWWHNLQWKHWWHPD]HJpV]V]LJHWHW %iPXODWRVDQ KDVRQOtWRWW HJ\ IpOLJ URPED GOW VL YiURVKR] YDODPL VRN V]i] pYHV HJ]RWLNXV PDURNNyL WHOH SOpVKH] DPHO\ I|OGUHQJpV YDJ\ HJ\pE NDWDV]WUyID iOGR 

]DWD OHWW 9LOiJRVDQ OiWWDP D] XWFiN UpV]EHQ EHWHPHWHWW RPODGpNNDO HOWRUODV]ROW J|UEH V]XUGRNDLW NDQ\DUJyVDQ PHUHGHNHQ IXWRWWDN OH D SDUWKR] DPHO\UH NLNLFVDSRWW D V,U, WDMWpN I|OMHEE pSHQ PDUDGW EiVW\iN RYiOLV YiUIDODN PDJDVRGWDN D GRPERU~ pV KRPRU~ IDODN IHNHWH Q\tOiVDL URPRV DEODNRNQDN YDJ\ OUpVHNQHN UpPOHWWHN $] HJpV] V]LJHWYiURV QHKp]NHVHQ IpOROGDOUD GOW PLQW HJ\ VOO\HG KDMy pV YDNRQ pUWHOPHWOHQO ~V]RWW D] yFHiQRQ QDJ\RQ ODVVDQ IRURJYD DPLUO D QDS OiWV]yODJRV PR]JiVD WDQ~V NRGRWW D] iUQ\pNRN OXVWiQ N~V]WDN D URPRN ~WYHV]WMp EHQ QpKD HOEXNNDQW HJ\ QDSVXJiU pV RGDVW|WW DKRO pQ iOOWDP 0pJ IHOMHEE NDSDV]NRGWDP EiU H] PiU HOpJ NRFNi]DWRV YROW D IHMHP I|Op NLKDMOy PiOODGR]y Q\~OYiQ\RNUyO YDVWDJ VXJiUEDQ SHUHJQL NH]GHWW D NDYLFVRV W|UPHOpN OH]~GXOW pV JRPRO\Jy SRUIHOKEH EXUNROWD D WHNHUYpQ\HV VLNiWRURNDW pV V]XUGRNRNDW SHUV]H D PLPRLG QHP V]LNOD V D PpV]NK|] YDOy KDVRQODWRVViJD Q\RPEDQ HOW,QLN KD HJ\ GDUDERW Np]EH YHV]QN VRNNDO N|QQ\HEE D KDENQpO UHJHV V]HUNH]HW,H]pUWURSSDQWOHYHJV 0iU RO\DQ PDJDVDQ YROWDP KRJ\ pUH]WHP D V]LJHW PR]JiViWQHPFVDN~V]RWWDPHUUHD]yFHiQIHNHWHL]PDL QDNO|NpVHLWDV]tWRWWiNNLWXGMDKRQQDQpVKRYiKDQHP MREEUDEDOUD KLPEiOy]RWW LV QDJ\RQ ODVV~ ULQJiViW FXS SRJy QHV]NtVpUWH DPLQW D V]UNH pV ViUJD WDMWpN OHFVXU JRWW D V]LJHW NLEXNNDQy SHUHPpUO ,QJDPR]JiVD UpJHQ NH]GG|WW DOLJKDQHP D V]OHWpVHNRU pV D]pUW PDUDGW PHJ PHUW D PLPRLG W|PHJH yULiVL 0LNRU NLEiPpV]NRGWDP PDJDP V]pOMiUWD NLOiWyPEyO yYDWRVDQ OHPiV]WDPpV²IXUFVDGRORJ²FVDNHNNRUM|WWHPUiKRJ\ D PLPRLG HJ\iOWDOiQ QHP pUGHNHO QHP YHOH DNDUWDP WDOiONR]QLKDQHPD]yFHiQQDO /HOWHP D] pUGHV UHSHGH]HWW SDUWRQ Wt] OpSpVQ\LUH D KHOLNRSWHUWO$IHNHWHKXOOiPORPKiQIHOPiV]RWWDSDUWUD V]pWWHUOW V XJ\DQDNNRU V]tQWHOHQQp IDNXOW DPLNRU YLVV]DK~]yGRWWUHPHJ Q\iONDV]iODNFVXURJWDNOHDV]LJHW SHUHPpUO 0pJ OHMMHEE FV~V]WDP pV EHOHQ\~OWDP D N| YHWNH] KXOOiPED +tYHQ PHJLVPpWHOWH D]W D MHOHQVpJHW DPLWD]HPEHUHNPDMGQHPV]i]pYH WDSDV]WDOWDNHOV]|U PHJWRUSDQW YLVV]DK~]yGRWW N|UOIRO\WD D NH]HPHW GH VHKRO VHP pUW KR]]i ~J\KRJ\ NHV]W\,P pV D KXOOiP N| ]|WW YpNRQ\ OHYHJUpWHJ PDUDGW NRQ]LV]WHQFLiMD LV U|J 

>NpS@

>UHV@

W|Q PHJYiOWR]RWW D NH]HP N|UO IRO\pNRQ\EyO V]LQWH K~ VRVViYiOW/DVVDQI|OHPHOWHPDNH]HPHWDKXOOiPLOOHWYH DQQDN YpNRQ\ Q\~OYiQ\D N|YHWWH V HJ\UH iWWHWV]EE SLV]NRV]|OG NDUPDQW\~YDO IRJWD N|UO )HOiOOWDP PHUW OYH PiU QHP WXGWDP PDJDVDEEUD Q\~MWy]NRGQL D NR FVRQ\iVV]iUPHJIHV]OWPLQWDK~UGHQHPV]DNDGWHO PDJDDKXOOiPODSRVDQV]pWWHUOWDSDUWRQDOiEDPN|UO GH QHP pULQWHWWH  PLQW YDODPL IXUFVD OpQ\ DPHO\ WUHO PHVHQYiUMDDNtVpUOHWYpJpW0LQWKDHJ\Q\~OyVYLUiJQWW YROQD NL D] yFHiQEyO pV NHO\KH N|UOYHQQp D] XMMDLPDW SRQWRV GH VHKRO KR]]i QHP pU YLDV]OHQ\RPDWNpQW +iWUDOpSWHP $ UXJDOPDV NRFViQ\ PHJUHPHJHWW pV EL]RQ\WDODQXO KLPEiOy]YD V]LQWH NHOOHWOHQO HUHV]NHGHWW YLVV]D D KXOOiP IHOGX]]DGW PDJiED IRJDGWD V HOW,QW D SDUW V]pOH P|J|WW $GGLJ LVPpWHOJHWWHP H]W D MiWpNRW PtJ D]HJ\LNKXOOiP²SRQWRVDQ~J\PLQWV]i]pYYHOH]HOWW² N|]|Q\|VHQ HOK~]yGRWW PLQWKD EHWHOW YROQD D] ~M WDSDV]WDODWWDO 7XGWDP KRJ\ yUiNLJ NHOOHQH YiUQRP PtJ ~MUD ÅNtYiQFVL OHV] UiPµ /HOWHP DNiU D] LPpQW GH D] HOPpOHWEO MyO LVPHUW MHOHQVpJ DPHO\HW PRVW PDJDP LGp]WHP HO HJpV]HQ NLFVHUpOW $ YDOyViJRV pOPpQ\W D] HOPpOHWQHPWXGWDN|]YHWtWHQL (QQHN D] pOOpQ\QHN VDUMDG]iViEDQ Q|YHNHGpVpEHQ WHUMHV]NHGpVpEHQ PLQGHQ PR]GXODWiEDQ NO|QNO|Q pV HJ\WWYpYH ~J\ pU]L D] HPEHU YDODPL yYDWRV GH QHP LMHGVQDLYLWiVQ\LOYiQXOPHJV]HQYHGpO\HVHQpVJ\RUVDQ PHJ DNDU LVPHUQL PLQGHQW N|UO DNDUMD IRJQL D YiUDWODQXO HOpEH NHUOW ~M IRUPiW GH IpO~WUyO PHJ NHOO KiWUiOQLD QHP OpSKHW W~O UHMWpO\HV W|UYpQ\HN V]DEWD KD WiUDLQ 0LO\HQ IDQWDV]WLNXV NRQWUDV]W H] D IUJH NtYiQ FVLViJD]HJpV]KRUL]RQWRWEHW|OW yULiVEDQ0pJVRKDVHP pUH]WHPHQQ\LUHURSSDQWMHOHQOpWpWHUVpVUHQGtWKHWHWOHQ QpPDViJiW HJ\HQOHWHV KXOOiPOpOHJ]pVpW 0HJUHQGOWHQ Qp]WHP VRKD QHP LVPHUW UpYOHWEH PHUOYH V HEEHQ D PLQG LQWHQ]tYHEE PHJVHPPLVOpVEHQ HJJ\p YiOWDP D IRO\pNRQ\ YDN yULiVVDO PLQWKD D OHJFVHNpO\HEE HUIHV]tWpVQpONOV]DYDNQpONOHJ\HWOHQJRQGRODWQpONO PLQGHQWPHJERFViWDQpNQHNL $]HOP~OWKpWHQRO\DQMy]DQXOYLVHONHGWHPKRJ\6QDXW EL]DOPDWODQ SLOODQWiVDL YpJO LV PHJV],QWHN .LIHOp Q\XJRGW YROWDP GH ² EiU H]W PDJDP VHP OiWWDP 

WLV]WiQ²WLWRNEDQ YiUWDPYDODPLW 0LW" +RJ\ YLVV]DM|Q" 9iUKDWWDP H]W" 0LQGHJ\LNQN WXGMD KRJ\ K~VYpU HPEHUDQ\DJLOpQ\DOiYDQYHWYHDIL]LROyJLDPHJDIL]LND W|UYpQ\HLQHN pV PLQGHQ pU]pVQN HJ\WWHV HUHMH VHP KDUFROKDWH]HNNHO D W|UYpQ\HNNHO FVDN J\,O|OKHWL NHW $ V]HUHOPHVHN pV D N|OWN |U|N KLWH D KDOiOW LV OHJ\] V]HUHOHP KDWDOPiEDQ D] pYV]i]DGRNRQ iW Q\RPXQNEDQ MiUy ÅILQLV YLWDH VHG QRQ DPRULVµ ² KD]XJViJ ÉP H] D KD]XJViJ FVDN KLiEDYDOy GH QHP QHYHWVpJHV 9DJ\ OHJ\QN D] LG P~OiViW PpU yUD DPHO\HW KRO V]pWV]HGQHN KRO ~MUD |VV]HUDNQDN V DPHO\QHN JpSH]HWp EHQ PLNRU D] yUiV PHJLQGtWMD D IRJDVNHUHNHNHW HOV NHWW\HQpVNNHOMiUQLNH]GDV]HQYHGpVpVDV]HUHOHPWXG YDKRJ\DNtQyUDP,YHLYDJ\XQNpVH]DNtQDQQiOJ\|W UEE PLQpO NRPLNXVDEEi WHV]L D VRN LVPpWOGpV" ,VPp WHOQL D] HPEHUL OpWHW MyO YDQ GH ~J\ PLQW D UpV]HJ D] HOFVpSHOW QyWiW PLQGLJ ~MDEE JDUDVW GREYD D ]HQHV]HN UpQ\EH" (J\ SLOODQDWLJ VHP KLWWHP KRJ\ D IRO\pNRQ\ NRORVV]XV DPHO\ PiUHPEHUHN V]i]DLW Q\HOWH HO DPHOO\HO HJpV]IDMWiPpYWL]HGHNyWD KLiEDSUyEiOMDDOHJFVHNpO\HEE NDSFVRODWRW LV OpWUHKR]QL DPHO\ WXGWiQ NtYO ULQJDW LWW PLQW HJ\ SRUV]HPHW PHJLQGXOQD NpW HPEHU WUDJpGLiMiQ 'HWHWWHLQHNPpJLVFVDNYROWYDODPLFpOMD,JD]HEEHQVHP YDJ\RN HJpV]HQ EL]WRV ÉP KD HOPHJ\HN LQQpW YpJNpSS OHPRQGRNDUUyOD WDOiQFVHNpO\ WDOiQFVDND NpS]HOHWEHQ OpWH] OHKHWVpJUO DPLW D M|Y UHMWHJHW 6]yYDO ² pYHNHW W|OWVHND]RNN|]|WWDE~WRURNpVKROPLNN|]|WWDPHO\HNHW HJ\WW pULQWHWWQN DEEDQ D OHYHJEHQ DPHO\ PpJ D]  OpOHJ]HWpW U]L" 0LpUW" $]W UHPpOHP WDOiQ KRJ\ YLVV]DM|Q" 1HP 'H pO EHQQHP D YiUDNR]iV FVXSiQ H] PDUDGW XWiQD 0LO\HQ EHWHOMHVOpVW PHJFV~IROWDWiVW PLO\HQ J\|WUHOPHNHW YiURN PpJ" 1HP WXGRN VHPPLW GH UHQGtWKHWHWOHQO KLV]HP KRJ\ D NHJ\HWOHQ FVRGiN LGHMH QHPP~OWHO