Lecture Notes in Mathematics Editors: J.-M. Morel, Cachan F. Takens, Groningen B. Teissier, Paris
1992
Alberto Parmeggiani
Spectral Theory of Non-Commutative Harmonic Oscillators: An Introduction
123
Alberto Parmeggiani Department of Mathematics University of Bologna Piazza di Porta San Donato, 5 40126 Bologna Italy
[email protected]
ISBN: 978-3-642-11921-7 e-ISBN: 978-3-642-11922-4 DOI: 10.1007/978-3-642-11922-4 Springer Heidelberg Dordrecht London New York Lecture Notes in Mathematics ISSN print edition: 0075-8434 ISSN electronic edition: 1617-9692 Library of Congress Control Number: 2010924182 Mathematics Subject Classification (2000): 35P20, 35J45, 35P15, 35S05, 47A10, 47G30, 47N50, 58J52, 81Q20 c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2010 This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer. Violations are liable to prosecution under the German Copyright Law. The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Cover design: SPi Publisher Services Printed on acid-free paper springer.com
To Serena & Lorenzo, Luisa & Pier Luigi
Preface
This book grew out of a series of lectures given at the Mathematics Department of Kyushu University in the Fall 2006, within the support of the 21st Century COE Program (2003–2007) “Development of Dynamical Mathematics with High Functionality” (Program Leader: prof. Mitsuhiro Nakao). It was initially published as the Kyushu University COE Lecture Note number 8 (COE Lecture Note, 8. Kyushu University, The 21st Century COE Program “DMHF”, Fukuoka, 2008. vi+234 pp.), and in the present form is an extended version of it (in particular, I have added a section dedicated to the Maslov index). The book is intended as a rapid (though not so straightforward) pseudodifferential introduction to the spectral theory of certain systems, mainly of the form a2 + a0 where the entries of a2 are homogeneous polynomials of degree 2 in the (x, ξ )-variables, (x, ξ ) ∈ Rn × Rn , and a0 is a constant matrix, the so-called noncommutative harmonic oscillators, with particular emphasis on a class of systems introduced by M. Wakayama and myself about ten years ago. The class of noncommutative harmonic oscillators is very rich, and many problems are still open, and worth of being pursued. I wish to thank Masato Wakayama, dearest friend and collaborator, and my friends and colleagues Nicola Arcozzi, Sandro Coriasco, Sandro Graffi, Fr´ed´eric H´erau, Takashi Ichinose, Miyuki Kuze, Lidia Maniccia, Luca Migliorini, Cesare Parenti and Cosimo Senni for their invaluable help in giving these notes a (hopefully) decent shape. Bologna December 2009
Alberto Parmeggiani
vii
Contents
1
Introduction .. . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .
1
2
The Harmonic Oscillator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 7 2.1 From the Hamiltonian to the Operator Acting on L2 . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 7 2.2 The Spectrum of the Harmonic Oscillator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 10
3
The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 3.1 Review of the Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 3.2 Global Metrics and Global Pseudodifferential Operators .. . . . . . . . . . . 3.3 Spectral Properties of Globally Elliptic Pseudodifferential Operators.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 3.4 Notes . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .
15 15 25 41 53
The Spectral Counting Function N(λ ) and the Behavior of the Eigenvalues: Part 1 .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 4.1 The Minimax Principle.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 4.2 The Spectral Counting Function .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 4.3 The Spectral Counting Function of the (Scalar) Harmonic Oscillator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 4.4 Consequences on the Spectral Counting Function of an Elliptic Global ψ do . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .
65
5
The Heat-Semigroup, Functional Calculus and Kernels . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 5.1 Elementary Properties of the Heat-Semigroup.. . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 5.2 Direct Definition of Tr e−tA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 5.3 Abstract Functional Calculus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 5.4 Kernels . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 5.5 f (A) as a Pseudodifferential Operator.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 5.6 Notes . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .
67 67 69 71 73 77 77
6
The Spectral Counting Function N(λ ) and the Behavior of the Eigenvalues: Part 2 .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 79 6.1 A Parametrix Approximation of e−tA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 79 6.2 The Karamata Theorem .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 83
4
55 55 58 61
ix
x
Contents
6.3 6.4 6.5
Use of the Parametrix Approximation of e−tA for Obtaining the Weyl Asymptotics of N(λ ) . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 86 Remarks on the Heuristics on N(λ ) and ζA (s) . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 91 Notes . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 92
7
The Spectral Zeta Function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 93 7.1 Robert’s Construction of ζA by Complex Powers . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 93 7.2 The Meromorphic Continuation of ζA via the Parametrix Approximation of e−tA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 96 7.3 The Ichinose–Wakayama Theorem .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .106 7.4 Notes . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .110
8
Some Properties of the Eigenvalues of Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .111 8.1 The Ichinose and Wakayama Bounds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .112 8.2 A Better Upper-Bound for the Lowest Eigenvalue . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .115 8.3 Notes . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .120
9
Some Tools from the Semiclassical Calculus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .121 9.1 The Semiclassical Calculus .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .121 9.2 Decoupling a System .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .129 9.3 Some Estimates for Semiclassical Operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .140 9.4 Some Spectral Properties of Semiclassical GPDOs . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .143
10 On Operators Induced by General Finite-Rank Orthogonal Projections . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .149 10.1 Reductions by a Finite-Rank Orthogonal Projection . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .149 10.2 Semiclassical Reduction by a Finite-Rank Orthogonal Projection.. .155 11 Energy-Levels, Dynamics, and the Maslov Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .161 11.1 Introducing the Dynamics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .161 11.2 The Maslov Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .173 11.3 Notes . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .189 12 Localization and Multiplicity of a Self-Adjoint Elliptic 2×2 Positive NCHO in Rn . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .191 12.1 The Set Q2 and Its Semiclassical Deformation .. . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .192 12.2 Localization and Multiplicity of the Spectrum in the Scalar Case . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .206 12.3 Localization and Multiplicity of Spec(Aw 2 (x, D)), with A2 ∈Q2s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .227 12.4 Localization and Multiplicity of Spec(Qw (α ,β ) (x, D)) . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .234 12.5 Localization and Multiplicity of Spec(Aw 2 (x, D)), with A2 ∈ Q2 \ Q2s . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .237 12.6 Notes . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .238
Contents
xi
Appendix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .239 A.1 Almost-Analytic Extension and the Dyn’kin–Helffer– Sj¨ostrand Formula .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .239 Main Notation . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .245 B.1 General Notation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .245 B.2 Symbol, Function and Operator Spaces .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .246 B.3 The Spectral Counting Function and the Spectral ζ -Function . . . . . . .247 B.4 Dynamical Quantities and Assumptions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .247 B.5 Classes of Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .247 References .. . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .249 Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .253
Chapter 1
Introduction
A non-commutative harmonic oscillator (NCHO for short) is the Weyl-quantization aw (x, D) of an N × N system of the form a(x, ξ ) = a2 (x, ξ ) + a0 , (x, ξ ) ∈ Rn × Rn = T ∗ Rn , where a2 (x, ξ ) is an N × N matrix whose entries are homogeneous polynomials of degree 2 in the (x, ξ ) variables, and a0 is a constant N × N matrix. In other words, a NCHO is the Weyl-quantization of a matrix-valued quadratic form in (x, ξ ), plus a constant matrix term. The name NCHO (which was given by M. Wakayama and myself) originates on the one hand from the fact that a scalar harmonic oscillator is a single quadratic form in (x, ξ ), and on the other from the two levels of non-commutativity that one has to deal with when studying these systems: the level due to the matrix-valued nature of the symbol of the system, and the level due to the Weyl-quantization rule xk ξ j ↔ (xk Dx j + Dx j xk )/2 (where D = −i∂ , as usual), reflected through symplectic geometry by the Poisson-bracket relations {ξ j , xk } = δ jk , 1 ≤ j, k ≤ n. I shall say that a NCHO aw (x, D) is elliptic when det a2 (x, ξ ) behaves exactly like (|x|2 + |ξ |2 )N when |(x, ξ )| is large. When a2 and a0 are Hermitian matrices, the operator aw (x, D) is “formally self-adjoint” (that is, symmetric on S (Rn ; CN )), and when in addition it is positive elliptic (that is, the matrix a2 (x, ξ ) is positive definite for (x, ξ ) = (0, 0)), then it is self-adjoint as an unbounded operator in L2 (Rn ; CN ) with a discrete real spectrum. It is particularly striking to realize that, while (almost) everything is known for scalar harmonic oscillators, very little is known about the spectral properties of selfadjoint elliptic systems, even in the basic (and seemingly simple) case of NCHOs. This book is mainly intended as a pseudodifferential introduction to the spectral theory of elliptic NCHOs, although it contains also results for more general elliptic differential systems with polynomial coefficients, and is a first account of the properties of such systems. A particularly important example of NCHO, is given by the system ⎡ ⎤ ∂x2 x2 1 + − x − α ∂ + x ⎢ 2 2 2 ⎥ ⎢ ⎥, Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) = ⎣ 2 ∂x x2 ⎦ 1 x∂x + β − + 2 2 2
x ∈ R, α , β ∈ C,
A. Parmeggiani, Spectral Theory of Non-Commutative Harmonic Oscillators: An Introduction, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1992, c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2010 DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-11922-4 1,
1
2
1 Introduction
which is the Weyl-quantization of the matrix ⎡ 2 ⎤ ξ + x2 −ixξ ⎢α ⎥ 2 ⎥ Q(α ,β ) (x, ξ ) = ⎢ ξ 2 + x2 ⎦ , ⎣ ixξ β 2
(x, ξ ) ∈ R × R,
that was introduced by M. Wakayama and myself in a series of papers (see Parmeggiani-Wakayama [58, 59]). When α , β > 0 with αβ > 1, the system is positive elliptic, self-adjoint, and so it has a discrete spectrum in L2 (R; C2 ), and a very rich and remarkable structure. It is worth remarking that in [59] (see also [58]) the eigenvalues are described in terms of a scalar three-term recurrence, and hence in terms of a continued fraction (however, it is very difficult to have a direct and explicit expression of them). It is also worth mentioning that when α = β > 1, one has (see Parmeggiani-Wakayama [58, 59]) that Qw (α ,α ) (x, D) is unitarily equivalent to a scalar harmonic oscillator times the identity 2 × 2 matrix, so that its spectral properties are governed by the tensor product of the oscillator representation and the 2-dimensional trivial representation of sl2 (R) (see e.g. Howe-Tan [25]), i.e. one has matrix-valued creation/annihilation operators that can be used to “construct” the spectrum (see Parmeggiani-Wakayama [60] for further examples of NCHOs whose spectrum can be studied through the tensor product of the oscillator representation and the finite dimensional representation of sl2 (R) and its perturbations). Hence, when α , β > 0 and αβ > 1, Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) can be thought of as a matrix-valued deformation of the scalar harmonic oscillator (it is not yet known whether Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) when α = β admits creation/annihilation operators or not). System Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) for α , β > 0 and αβ > 1, will be the main example to bear in mind in this exploration of the basic spectral properties of elliptic NCHOs. Of course, it is a natural and important problem to understand the spectral behavior of Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) as α and β vary in C \ {αβ = 0}. I won’t be dealing with this aspect here, and concentrate mainly only on the theory of self-adjoint elliptic and positive NCHOs. My motivation for considering systems like Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) comes from PDEs, namely from the study of a-priori lower bound estimates, such as Melin’s or H¨ormander’s or Fefferman-Phong’s , in the case of pseudodifferential systems (see Parenti-Parmeggiani [49], and also Parmeggiani [53, 54], and references therein). A basic tool for studying such inequalities is the use of the localized operator, introduced by L. Boutet de Monvel (and further developed by L. Boutet de Monvel, A. Grigis and B. Helffer in their study of the hypoellipticity with loss of derivatives; see [49] and the references therein). The localized operator is, loosely speaking, the Weyl quantization of the “meaningful” part of the Taylor-expansion of the symbol at characteristic points, whose spectral properties become relevant to the existence of the lower-bound estimate. In the case of systems, the localized operator is a differential system with polynomial coefficients, an example of which is given by Qw (α ,β ) (x, D). Another motivation comes from the search of vector-valued
1 Introduction
3
deformations of the scalar, fundamental, harmonic oscillator. In some sense, as the reader will see, the class of polynomial differential systems studied here is by all means a remarkable vector-valued deformation of the harmonic oscillator which inherits many beautiful spectral properties. From the point of view of Mathematical Physics, it is interesting to mention here the recent results of Hirokawa [22] on the Dicke-type crossings among the eigenvalues (of basic importance in many physical problems) for certain NCHOs. It is also conceivable that NCHOs (and more general differental systems with polynomial coefficients) appear naturally in questions related to the BornOppenheimer approximation or to Solid State Physics. For instance,1 when dealing with the Flux 1/2 problem relative to the spectral analysis of the Harper model, B. Helffer and J. Sj¨ostrand [21] are led to work with a semiclassical pseudodcos ξ cos x ifferental system whose symbol is , and one is concerned with cos x − cos ξ the analysis for energies near 0 and phase-space points (x, ξ ) near (π /2, π /2). After a phase-space translation, one is therefore forced to consider system
the sin ξ sin x ξ x , whose harmonic approximation is the system . The sin x − sin ξ x −ξ
2 D + x2 [D, x] square of the latter is the NCHO . −[D, x] D2 + x2 It is interesting to remark that the three-term recurrence equations I have mentioned above, appearing in the study of the spectrum of Qw (α ,β ) (x, D), are similar to certain ones appearing in Lay and Slavyanov’s book [39] about special functions. It is thus plausible that some physical applications of NCHOs may also be found by considering, in analogy, those given in [39]. The main results contained in this book are: • the meromorphic continuation of the spectral zeta function ζA of a general N × N
elliptic NCHO A in Rn , and the very elegant (and precise) result by Ichinose and Wakayama on the spectral zeta function of an elliptic Qw (α ,β ) (x, D); • some precise upper and lower bounds on the lowest eigenvalue of Qw (x, D) (α ,β ) (due to Ichinose and Wakayama, and to myself); • the “clustering” and “multiplicity” phenomena of eigenvalues in dependence on dynamical quantities, such as period and action (and Maslov index), related to the closed integral trajectories of the Hamilton vector-fields associated with the eigenvalues of the symbol of the system for a class of n-dimensional 2 × 2 positive elliptic NCHOs of order 2, that generalizes the class of positive elliptic Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) (these results are due to myself). In the course of achieving the afore-mentioned results, I have also developed some general tools, used here, that I hope will also prove useful to attack further spectral problems, beyond those treated in these notes.
1
I am indebted with B. Helffer for explaining this to me.
4
1 Introduction
Of some basic material I have not given a thoroughly self-contained presentation, at times preferring instead a kind of overall survey with the aim of giving a “userguide” of it, my choice being due to the existence of beautiful (and important) books and papers to which I address the reader. Here is now an account on the content of this book. In Chapter 2, I introduce the Weyl-quantization of the Hamiltonian of the harmonic oscillator and describe its spectral properties. This is the basic scalar model which will serve as a guide throughout this study. In Chapter 3, I give a rapid introduction to the general Weyl-H¨ormander calculus, to be then specialized to the case of the “global metric”. This is the setting where I shall develop the spectral theory of NCHOs. In Chapter 4, I introduce the function that “counts” the eigenvalues of an operator with discrete spectrum (the spectral counting function), and give some of its elementary properties. I also describe the spectral counting function associated with a general harmonic oscillator, which is then used to derive a first crude information about the behavior of the spectral counting function associated with a general NCHO (information that, however, is already sufficient to obtain a first convergence region of the associated spectral zeta function). In Chapter 5, I give an account of the functional calculus of the operators I am interested in, and introduce the notion of “trace” of an operator. In Chapter 6, I decribe the construction of an approximation to e−tA , based on the parametrix construction for d/dt + A, where A is a positive elliptic global polynomial differential system. This is then used to compute the leading coefficient of the asymptotics of the spectral counting function for large eigenvalues, in terms of the symbol of the system. To achieve this, I use (as is classical) the Karamata Tauberian theorem, of which I give a complete proof. In Chapter 7, I recall Robert’s theorem on the meromorphic continuation of the spectral zeta function, and then give a proof of it for a positive elliptic N × N NCHO in Rn by using the approximation to e−tA constructed in Chapter 6, and finally recall (and sketch the proof of) the Ichinose-Wakayama theorem about the spectral zeta function associated with a positive elliptic Qw (α ,β ) (x, D). (The Ichinose-Wakayama result is a consequence of the more general result I give for an elliptic N × N NCHO, except for their very precise description of the “trivial zeros”. That is why I have decided to sketch their proof.) In Chapter 8, I recall Ichinose-Wakayama’s lower and upper bounds to the lowest eigenvalue of a positive elliptic Qw (α ,β ) (x, D), and then show a refinement (which is new) of the upper bound, whose proof uses only some elementary symplectic linear algebra. In Chapter 9, I review and construct some tools from the calculus of Semiclassical Pseudodifferential Operators (i.e. the Weyl-quantization of symbols of the kind p(x, hξ ; h), where h ∈ (0, 1] is the semiclassical parameter), proving in particular the decoupling construction (modulo operators that have a norm which is O(hN ) for every N ∈ Z+ ) of a given system whose principal symbol can be blockwise diagonalized.
1 Introduction
5
Then in Chapter 10, I introduce a useful approach to study large eigenvalues of self-adjoint (unbounded) operators (in the usual and in the semiclassical setting), consisting of a “reduction” of the operator by “cutting off low energies”. In Chapter 11, I recall some basic facts about the dynamics of the integral trajectories of the Hamilton vector-field associated with the symbol of a pseudodifferential operator (the bicharacteristics), with special interest in the periodic trajectories. I will then introduce the Maslov index of such trajectories, and give an effective way of computing it, following the approach and results of RobbinSalamon [62] (see also McDuff-Salamon [43]). In the notes to this chapter I rapidly recall some motivations for the introduction of the Maslov index, and give the appropriate references. In the final Chapter 12, I describe in the first place the clustering and multiplicity properties of the large eigenvalues of a scalar semiclassical pseudodifferential operator, which are described through the dynamical quantities introduced in Chapter 11. This is afterwards used to study, through the decoupling seen in Chapter 9 and the methods developed in Chapter 10, the large eigenvalues of an elliptic 2 × 2 NCHO in Rn whose symbol has distinct eigenvalues. Since the eigenvalues of a semiclassiw cal NCHO aw 2 (x, hD) (i.e. with a0 = 0) are h times the eigenvalues of a2 (x, D), this gives us precise clustering and multiplicity properties of the large eigenvalues of a NCHO, with no lower-order part a0 , in terms of the dynamical quantities associated with the eigenvalues of the symbol a2 (x, ξ ). This part is new, and generalizes the results obtained in Parmeggiani [55] for an elliptic Qw (x, D) to n-dimensional (α ,β ) 2 × 2 NCHOs. In the Appendix, I show a few properties of the almost-analytic extension to the complex domain of compactly supported functions in R, and (following DimassiSj¨ostrand [7]) recall a proof of the Dyn’kin-Helffer-Sj¨ostrand formula. Finally, a list of the main notation used throughout the book is given right before the Bibliography. I end this Introduction by saying that in this book there was no space for including other issues related to an elliptic Qw (α ,β ) (x, D), such as: • the representation-theoretic approach, due to H. Ochiai, which establishes the
• •
• •
deep relation of the spectral theory of these systems to the existence of particular holomorphic solutions of Heun differential operators in the complex domain (see Ochiai [46, 47]); the numerical study of the spectrum started by K. Nagatou, M.T. Nakao and M. Wakayama (see Nagatou-Nakao-Wakayama [45]); the number-theoretic investigation of the special values of the spectral zeta function associated with the spectrum initiated by T. Ichinose and M. Wakayama (see Ichinose-Wakayama [32, 33], Kimoto-Wakayama [36, 37], Kimoto-Yamasaki [38], and Ochiai [48]); the Poisson-like formulas on the spectral density of eigenvalues (see Parmeggiani [52]); the properties of the lowest eigenvalue and some perturbation theory in the parameters (α , β ) (see Ichinose-Wakayama [33], Parmeggiani [51, 52]).
They will be part of a wider book, that M. Wakayama and I are planning to write.
Chapter 2
The Harmonic Oscillator
In this chapter we shall review the spectral properties of the harmonic oscillator, i.e. of the operator given by the Weyl-quantization of the Hamiltonian (|ξ |2 + |x|2 )/2.
2.1 From the Hamiltonian to the Operator Acting on L2 Consider the phase-space Rn × Rn = T ∗ Rn = R2n (the cotangent bundle of Rn ), that we shall always consider endowed with the canonical symplectic form
σ=
n
∑ d ξ j ∧ dx j ,
(2.1)
j=1
where (x, ξ ) are symplectic coordinates in Rnx × Rnξ . Equivalently, for any given
δx δx , v = ∈ Rn × Rn one has tangent vector v = δξ δξ
σ (v, v ) = δ ξ , δ x − δ ξ , δ x ,
(2.2)
where ·, · denotes the usual inner-product in Rn . Remark that σ = d(∑nj=1 ξ j dx j ), where ∑nj=1 ξ j dx j is called the canonical 1-form. Next, consider in R2n the Hamiltonian 1 p0,n (x, ξ ) = (|ξ |2 + |x|2 ) = 2
n
∑ p0(x j , ξ j ),
j=1
where 1 p0 (x j , ξ j ) = p0,1 (x j , ξ j ) = (ξ j2 + x2j ), 2
A. Parmeggiani, Spectral Theory of Non-Commutative Harmonic Oscillators: An Introduction, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1992, c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2010 DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-11922-4 2,
7
8
2 The Harmonic Oscillator
is the one-dimensional harmonic oscillator in the variables (x j , ξ j ) ∈ R2 . Its Weyl-quantization is the operator (we shall throughout use Dx j or D j for −i∂x j or −i∂ j , respectively) 1 1 2 pw 0,n (x, D) = (−Δ x + |x| ) = 2 2
n
n
j=1
j=1
∑ (−∂x2j + x2j ) = ∑ pw0 (x j , Dx j ).
It is readily seen that pw 0,n (x, D) is continuous when thought of as an operaw n n tor p0,n (x, D) : S (R ) −→ S (Rn ) and as an operator pw 0,n (x, D) : S (R ) −→ n n n S (R ), where S (R ) and S (R ) are, respectively, the space of Schwartz functions and temperate distributions on Rn . The operator pw 0,n (x, D) is obtained from p0,n (x, ξ ) by replacing ξ j by D j , x j by x j and x j ξk by (x j Dk + xk D j )/2, that is to say, it is obtained as
−n pw 0,n (x, D)u(x) = (2π )
ei x−y,ξ p0,n (
x+y , ξ )u(y)dyd ξ , u ∈ S (Rn ), (2.3) 2
where it is understood that the integration with respect to y is effected first and the one with respect to ξ last. Exercise 2.1.1. Show the formula (2.3) indeed holds.
When studying the spectral properties of pw 0,n (x, D) it is also convenient to realize it as an unbounded operator in L2 (Rn ), that we will denote by H regardless the dimension n, H : D(H) ⊂ L2 (Rn ) −→ L2 (Rn ), with domain 2 n 2 n D(H) = {u ∈ L2 (Rn ); Hu = pw 0,n (x, D)u ∈ L (R )} =: B (R )
(2.4)
(the so-called maximal operator; we shall come back to this later on), where pw 0,n (x, D)u is understood in the sense of distributions. Note that one clearly has S (Rn ) ⊂ D(H), whence H is densely defined. It is also a closed operator. To see this, we have to show that ⎫ L2 ⎪ D(H) u j −→ u, as j → +∞ ⎪ ⎬ =⇒ u ∈ D(H) and Hu = v. ⎪ ⎪ L2 ⎭ Hu −→ v, as j → +∞ j
Since L2
S
u j −→ u =⇒ u j −→ u, we have on the one hand S
w pw 0,n (x, D)u j −→ p0,n (x, D)u, as j → +∞,
2.1 From the Hamiltonian to the Operator Acting on L2
9
and on the other, L2
pw 0,n (x, D)u j = Hu j −→ v, as j → +∞, whence 2 n pw 0,n (x, D)u = v ∈ L (R ),
i.e. u ∈ D(H) and Hu = v, which is what we wanted to prove. Let us restrict our attention, for the time being, to the 1-dimensional case n = 1. We have x2 + ξ 2 x + iξ x − iξ √ , (x, ξ ) ∈ R × R. p0 (x, ξ ) = = √ 2 2 2 Set hence x ∓ iξ ψ± (x, ξ ) := √ . 2 Note that |ψ± (x, ξ )| ≈ p0 (x, ξ )1/2 , where, for positive A and B, A ≈ B means that there are universal constants C1 ,C2 > 0 such that C1 A ≤ B ≤ C2 A. Notation. Let A, B > 0. We shall always write A B (or B A) when there is a universal constant C > 0 such that A ≤ CB. We hence have A ≈ B whenever A B and B A. Define next the Poisson bracket of two C1 functions f and g by { f , g} =
∂ f ∂g ∂ f ∂g . − ∂xj ∂ξj j=1 ∂ ξ j ∂ x j n
∑
Then, on the one hand p0 (x, ξ ) = ∏ ψ± (x, ξ )ψ∓ (x, ξ ), and {ψ+ , ψ− } = −i, ±
and on the other hand, upon setting x ∓ ∂x Ψ± := ψ±w (x, D) = √ , 2 we have, by a direct computation, 1 Ψ+Ψ− = H − , 2
1 Ψ−Ψ+ = H + , 2
[Ψ+ , Ψ− ] = −1.
(2.5)
The operators Ψ± are the celebrated creation (Ψ+ ) and annihilation (Ψ− ) operators. We now define, for a, b : R2 −→ C affine functions in x, ξ , the operation ab by i ab = ab − {a, b}, 2
10
2 The Harmonic Oscillator
so that
i 1 ψ+ ψ− = ψ+ ψ− − (−i) = p0 − , 2 2
and
i 1 ψ− ψ+ = ψ− ψ+ − i = p0 + . 2 2 We have therefore discovered the correspondence
Ψ±Ψ∓ = (ψ± ψ∓ )w (x, D). Notice, moreover, that on S (R) and S (R)
Ψ±∗ = Ψ∓ , Ψ±∗ = (ψ± )w (x, D), and 1 [Ψ+ , Ψ− ] = (ψ+ ψ− )w (x, D) − (ψ− ψ+ )w (x, D) = {ψ+ , ψ− }w (x, D). i
(2.6)
Hence the fact that the operators Ψ+ and Ψ− do not commute may be explained by the fact that {ψ+ , ψ− } = 0, which is hence a first level of non-commutativity when dealing with operators, due to the non-vanishing of the Poisson brackets {ξ j , x j } = 1. Moreover, the fact that a commutator is a “lower order” operator will no longer hold true in general for matrix-valued symbols (see Remark 3.1.9 below). This is the second level at which non-commutativity manifests itself when considering systems of operators.
2.2 The Spectrum of the Harmonic Oscillator We have now the following fundamental theorem about the spectrum of the harmonic oscillator when n = 1. The higher dimensional case will easily follow. Theorem 2.2.1. Let H : D(H) ⊂ L2 (R) −→ L2 (R), i.e. we think of H as an unbounded operator on L2 with dense domain D(H) given in (2.4), Hu = pw 0 (x, D)u in the sense of distributions. Then we have the following facts. 1. Self-adjointness: H = H ∗ , that is, D(H) = D(H ∗ ) and H ∗ u = pw 0 (x, D)u for all u ∈ D(H). 2. Spec(H) = {n + 1/2; n ∈ Z+ } (where Z+ = {0, 1, 2, . . .}), with multiplicity 1. 2 3. Define v0 = e−x /2 and vn = Ψ+n v0 , n ∈ Z+ . Then Ψ− v0 = 0, all the functions vn 2 belong to S and are of the form vn = fn e−x /2 , where fn ∈ R[x] is a polynomial of degree n (i.e., of the form an xn + an−1xn−1 + . . . + a0, with non-zero leading coefficient an ). Moreover, the vn form a complete orthogonal system of L2 .
2.2 The Spectrum of the Harmonic Oscillator
11
Hence, upon defining un = vn /||vn ||, the system {un }n∈Z+ is an orthonormal basis of L2 . The functions vn are called Hermite functions. This theorem is well-known. However, we give the proof for the sake of completeness. Proof. We shall denote throughout by (·, ·) the canonical inner product in L2 , and by || · ||0 the induced L2 -norm. Note, in the first place, that for any given u1 , u2 ∈ S we have (Hu1 , u2 ) = (u1 , Hu2 ) (i.e. H is symmetric, or, equivalently, pw 0 (x, D) is formally self-adjoint), and 1 1 1 (Hu, u) = (Ψ+Ψ− + )u, u = ||Ψ− u||20 + ||u||20 ≥ ||u||20 , ∀u ∈ S . 2 2 2 On the other hand, since Ψ− v0 = 0 and v0 ∈ S , we indeed have that (Hu, u) 1 = . 2 u∈S \{0} ||u||20 min
Next, it is clear that the functions vn = Ψ+n v0 ∈ S , for all n ∈ Z+ . Hence we may compute by induction 1 1 Hvn = (Ψ+Ψ− + )vn = (Ψ+Ψ− + )Ψ+ vn−1 2 2 1 = Ψ+ (Ψ−Ψ+ − )vn−1 + Ψ+vn−1 2 (using (2.5) and the induction hypothesis Hvn−1 = (n − 1 + 1/2)vn−1) 1 = Ψ+ Hvn−1 + Ψ+vn−1 = Ψ+ (n − 1 + )vn−1 + Ψ+vn−1 2 1 1 = (n + )Ψ+ vn−1 = (n + )vn . 2 2 Of course, we have to make sure that vn ≡ 0 for all n. Hence, we compute by induction ||vn ||20 = (vn , vn ) = (Ψ+n v0 , Ψ+n v0 ) = (Ψ−nΨ+n v0 , v0 ) = Ψ−n−1 (Ψ+Ψ− + [Ψ− , Ψ+ ])Ψ+n−1 v0 , v0 = Ψ−n−1 (Ψ+Ψ− + 1)Ψ+n−1 v0 , v0 = n(Ψ−n−1Ψ+n−1 v0 , v0 ) = n!||v0||20 > 0, whence vn ≡ 0 for all n ∈ Z+ . Now, since Ψ− v0 = 0, a similar computation also shows that m > n =⇒ (vn , vm ) = 0,
12
2 The Harmonic Oscillator
that yields the orthogonality of the system {vn }n∈Z+ . To prove its completeness, we note in the first place that it is clear that vn = fn v0 , for a real polynomial fn of degree n (i.e., fn = an xn + an−1 xn−1 + . . . + a0 , with the a j ∈ R and non-zero leading coefficient an ). Hence, let g ∈ L2 (R) be such that +∞ −∞
g(x)vn (x)dx = 0, ∀n ∈ Z+ .
It then follows that, since any polynomial f ∈ R[x] can be written as a linear combination of the fn (by virtue of the fact that their leading coefficients are not zero), we have +∞ −∞
Using e−ixξ =
g(x) f (x)e−x
2 /2
dx = 0, ∀ f ∈ R[x].
(2.7)
(−ixξ ) j and (2.7) yields j! j≥0
∑
+∞ −∞
e−ixξ g(x)e−x
2 /2
dx = Fx→ξ (ge−x
2 /2
)(ξ ) = 0, ∀ξ ∈ R.
But an L2 -function which has zero Fourier-transform must be zero, that is ge−x
2 /2
≡ 0 =⇒ g ≡ 0 in L2 (R).
Hence {vn }n∈Z+ is an orthogonal basis of L2 (R) and {un }n∈Z+ , where un := vn /||vn ||0 , is an orthonormal basis of L2 (R). Using this, one then sees that Im(H ± i) = L2 (R), whence, by general arguments (see, for instance, Dunford-Schwartz [13] or Kato [35]), H = H ∗ . This therefore shows that 1 Spec(H) = {n + ; n ∈ Z+ }, 2 with multiplicity 1, and concludes the proof.
It is worth noting that the non-commutativity of the operators Ψ± allowed the operator H to be positive (i.e. the quadratic form (H·, ·) in L2 is bounded from below by a positive constant) although its symbol, the function p0 (x, ξ ), is merely ≥ 0. We have this by virtue of the uncertainty principle, or equivalently, putting things geometrically, by virtue of the presence of symplectic variables (the pair (x, ξ ) ∈ R2 satisfies {ξ , x} = 1) in the symbol, that makes p−1 0 (0)(= {0} in this case) too small to support an eigenfunction.
2.2 The Spectrum of the Harmonic Oscillator
13
How about higher dimensions? We start by putting ( j)
( j)w
( j)
Ψ± := ψ± (x, D), where ψ± (x, ξ ) =
x j ∓ iξ j √ , 1≤ j≤n 2
( j)
(note that when n > 1 we only have |ψ± (x, ξ )| ≈ p0 (x j , ξ j )1/2 and no longer that ( j) |ψ± (x, ξ )| ≈ p0,n (x, ξ )1/2 ). Then, on S (Rn ) or S (Rn ), H=
n
1 ( j) Ψ− + ) = 2
∑ (Ψ+
( j)
j=1 ( j)
( j )
( j)
n
∑ (Ψ−
1 ( j) Ψ+ − ), 2
( j)
j=1
( j )
( j)
( j )
[Ψ+ , Ψ+ ] = [Ψ− , Ψ− ] = 0, and [Ψ+ , Ψ− ] = −δ j j . Hence, if we define for α ∈ Zn+ n
uα (x) := ∏ uα j (x j ), j=1
where uα j is given by Theorem 2.2.1, we have the following theorem. Theorem 2.2.2. 1. As an unbounded operator in L2 (Rn ) with domain B2 (Rn ) the operator H, the (maximal) realization of pw 0,n (x, D), is self-adjoint; 2. {uα }α ∈Zn+ is a complete orthonormal system of L2 (Rn ), made of eigenfunctions of H; 3. Spec(H) = {|α | + n/2; α ∈ Zn+ } (no longer with multiplicity 1 for n > 1; we shall examine the multiplicity later on, see Section 4.3).
Chapter 3
The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
In this chapter we shall review the Weyl-H¨ormander pseudodifferential calculus (see H¨ormander [29]; see also H¨ormander [27]), in which we shall “embed” the “global” one (see Helffer [17] and Shubin [67]), to be recalled in Section 3.2. In section 3.3 we shall describe a few spectral properties of globally elliptic pseudodifferential operators.
3.1 Review of the Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus We shall denote by X = (x, ξ ), Y = (y, η ) and Z = (z, ζ ) the points of R2n = Rn ×Rn . Definition 3.1.1. An admissible metric in R2n is a function R2n X −→ gX where gX is a positive-definite quadratic form on R2n such that: • Slowness: There exists C0 > 0 (the constant of slowness) such that for any given
X , Y ∈ R2n one has
gX (Y − X) ≤ C0−1 =⇒ C0−1 gY ≤ gX ≤ C0 gY ; • Uncertainty: For any given X ∈ R2n one has
gX ≤ gσX , where gσX is the dual metric (with respect to the symplectic form σ , see (2.1)) defined by
σ (Y, Z)2 ; Z=0 gX (Z)
gσX (Y ) = sup
• Temperateness: There exists C1 > 0 and N0 ∈ Z+ such that for all X , Y ∈ R2n
one has
N0 gX ≤ C1 gY 1 + gσX (X − Y ) .
A. Parmeggiani, Spectral Theory of Non-Commutative Harmonic Oscillators: An Introduction, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1992, c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2010 DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-11922-4 3,
15
16
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
The Planck function associated with g is by definition gX (Z) . σ Z=0 gX (Z)
h(X)2 = sup
It is important to note that the uncertainty of g yields that h(X ) ≤ 1 for all X ∈ R2n . Remark 3.1.2. One easily sees (exercise for the reader) that the metric |d ξ |2 , (x, ξ ) ∈ R2n , 1 + |ξ |2
gx,ξ = |dx|2 +
is an admissible metric. In this case one has h(x, ξ )−1 = (1 + |ξ |2 )1/2 , which is the usual pseudodifferential weight (which is then g-admissible; see Definition 3.1.4 below). Remark 3.1.3. The dual metric gσ appears naturally to keep into account localization of Fourier transforms when dealing with the composition of symbols (see (3.5) below). Notice that the uncertainty principle may also be rephrased as the basic observation that for the function uA (x) = e− Ax,x , with A symmetric n × n and positive, the −1 Fourier transform is uˆA (ξ ) = c(detA)−1/2 e− A ξ ,ξ , whence uA is as much “concentrated” within the ellipsoid {x; Ax, x ≤ 1}, as uˆA (ξ ) is “concentrated” within the ellipsoid {ξ ; A−1 ξ , ξ ≤ 1}. As an example of computation of gσ and h, consider the constant metric g=
n
∑ (λ j dx2j + μ j d ξ j2 ),
λ j , μ j > 0, 1 ≤ j ≤ n.
j=1
Then (exercise for the reader) gσ =
n
dx2j
∑( μj
j=1
+
d ξ j2
λj
),
and h(X ) = max (λ j μ j )1/2 , ∀X ∈ R2n . 1≤ j≤n
3.1 Review of the Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
17
Definition 3.1.4. Given an admissible metric g, a g-admissible weight is a positive function m on R2n (i.e. m(X ) > 0 for all X ∈ R2n ) for which there exist constants c,C,C > 0 and N1 ∈ Z+ such that for all X,Y ∈ R2n , gX (X − Y ) ≤ c =⇒ C−1 ≤ and
m(X ) ≤ C, m(Y )
N1 m(X) ≤ C 1 + gσX (Y − X ) . m(Y )
Remark 3.1.5. It is then seen (exercise for the reader) that the Planck function h is a g-admissible weight. Definition 3.1.6. Let g be an admissible metric and m be a g-admissible weight. Let a ∈ C∞ (R2n ). Denote by a(k) (X; v1 , . . . , vk ) the k-th differential of a at X in the directions v1 , . . . , vk of R2n (thought of as tangential directions in TX R2n , the tangent space of R2n at the point X ). Define |a|gk (X ) :=
|a(k) (X ; v1 , . . . , vk )| . k 1/2 0=v1 ,...,vk ∈R2n ∏ j=1 gX (v j ) sup
We say that a ∈ S(m, g) if for any given integer k ∈ Z+ the following seminorms are finite: ||a||k;S(m,g) :=
|a|g (X ) < +∞. ≤k, X∈R2n m(X ) sup
(3.1)
Given μ ∈ R, we shall say that a ∈ S μ (g) if a ∈ S(h−μ , g) (that is, we use the Planck function h as a weight for measuring the growth of the symbols). With BgX0 ,r = {X ; gX0 (X − X0 ) < r2 }, following Bony and Lerner [3] we say that a ∈ C∞ (R2n ) is a symbol (of weight m) confined to the ball BgX0 ,r , and write a ∈ Conf(m, g, X0 , r), if for all k ∈ Z+ gX
||a||k,Conf(m,g,X0 ,r) :=
|a| 0 (X) 1 + gσX0 (X − BX0,r ))k/2 < +∞, m(X ) 2n 0 ≤k, X∈R sup
(3.2)
where gYσ (X − B) = inf gYσ (X − Z). Hence the space of symbols confined to the Z∈B
ball BgX0 ,r coincides with S (R2n ) endowed with the seminorms (3.2). Any given ϕ ∈ C0∞ (BgX0 ,r ) is automatically confined (of weight 1) to the ball BgX0 ,r . Remark 3.1.7. For the standard pseudodifferential metric gx,ξ = |dx|2 +
|d ξ |2 , (x, ξ ) ∈ R2n , 1 + |ξ |2 μ
with h(x, ξ )−1 = (1 + |ξ |2 )1/2 , one has S μ (g) = S1,0 (Rn × Rn ), the familiar class of symbols of order μ .
18
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
Given a symbol a ∈ S(m, g) one then defines its Weyl-quantization by the formula aw (x, D)u(x) = (2π )−n
ei x−y,ξ a(
x+y , ξ )u(y)dyd ξ , u ∈ S (Rn ). 2
It is then seen (H¨ormander [29]) that the expression makes sense, and that A = aw (x, D) : S (Rn ) −→ S (Rn ) and A = aw (x, D) : S (Rn ) −→ S (Rn ) is continuous, with Schwartz kernel given by the tempered distribution KA (x, y) = (2π )−n
ei x−y,ξ a(
that is, KA (x + t/2, x − t/2) = (2π )−n
x+y , ξ )d ξ , 2
ei t,ξ a(x, ξ )d ξ
is the inverse Fourier transform of a with respect to ξ , whence a(x, ξ ) =
e−i t,ξ KA (x + t/2, x − t/2)dt.
For example, in the case of a ∈ S μ (g), gx,ξ = |dx|2 + |d ξ |2 /(1 + |ξ |2), the kernel KA is interpreted as an oscillatory integral, that is KA (x, y) = S - lim (2π )−n ε →0+
ei x−y,ξ a(
x+y , ξ )χ (εξ )d ξ , 2
where χ is any given Schwartz function with χ (0) = 1, the limit being independent of χ . Recall that the expression for the Schwartz kernel comes from considering the “weak” form
x+y , ξ )u(y)v(x)dyd ξ dx 2 = KA |v¯ ⊗ u S ,S , ∀u, v ∈ S (Rn ),
(aw (x, D)u, v) = (2π )−n
ei x−y,ξ a(
where (v ⊗ u)(x, y) = v(x)u(y) and ·|· S ,S denotes the S -S duality. One has the following composition theorem (see H¨ormander [29] or [27]). Theorem 3.1.8. Given a ∈ S(m1 , g), b ∈ S(m2 , g) then aw (x, D) bw (x, D) = (ab)w (x, D),
3.1 Review of the Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
19
where for any given N ∈ Z+ (ab)(X) =
N
∑
j=0
j 1i σ (DX ; DY ) a(X )b(Y )X=Y +rN+1 (X ), j! 2
(3.3)
with rN+1 ∈ S(hN+1 m1 m2 , g). In particular, for any given N ∈ Z+ , σ (DX ; DY )N a(X)b(Y )X=Y ∈ S(hN m1 m2 , g).
(3.4)
Here we write, by (2.2) with X = (x, ξ ) and Y = (y, η ),
σ (DX ; DY ) := σ (Dx , Dξ ; Dy , Dη ) := Dξ , Dy − Dη , Dx . cw
This formula comes from considering in the first place the composition aw bw = for symbols a, b ∈ S (R2n ) and, by using the relation
f (x, y)e2ixy dxdy =
1 4π
fˆ(ξ , η )e−iξ η /2 d ξ d η , f ∈ S (R2 ),
through the formula c(X) = π −2n
e−2iσ (X−Y,X−Z) a(Y )b(Z)dY dZ
e−2iσ (T,Z) a(X + T )b(X + Z)dT dZ = eiσ (DX ;DY )/2 (a(X)b(Y ))X=Y , = π −2n
(3.5)
where (recall) X = (x, ξ ), Y = (y, η ), Z = (z, ζ ). This is then extended to general symbols a and b of the kind considered in the theorem. Remark 3.1.9. It follows from (3.3) that i aw (x, D)bw (x, D) = (ab)w (x, D) − {a, b}w (x, D) + . . . 2 Hence, for scalar symbols we have for the commutator 1 [aw (x, D), bw (x, D)] = {a, b}w (x, D) + . . . . i This is no longer true for matrix-valued symbols, simply because matrices do not commute. What one can say in this case is just that [aw (x, D), bw (x, D)] = [a, b]w (x, D) −
w i {a, b} − {b, a} (x, D) + . . ., 2
where [a, b] = ab − ba denotes the usual matrix-commutator.
20
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
The next important result is the existence of a partition of unity associated with the metric g (see H¨ormander [29] and Bony-Lerner [3]). Notice that no smoothness assumption on either the metric g or the g-admissible weights m was made. The existence of the partition of unity makes it possible to regularize the metric and the g-admissible weights. Lemma 3.1.10. Let g be an admissible metric, and let r2 < C0−1 . Then there exists a sequence of centers {Xν }ν ∈Z+ , a covering of R2n made of g-balls Bgν ,r = {X; gXν (X − Xν ) < r2 } centered at Xν and radius r, and a sequence of functions {ϕν } uniformly in S(1, g), with supp ϕν ⊂ Bgν ,r , such that ∑ν ∈Z+ ϕν2 = 1. Moreover, for any given r∗ such that r2 ≤ r∗2 < C0−1 , there exists an integer Nr∗ such that no more than Nr∗ balls Bgν ,r∗ can intersect at each time, i.e. one has an a-priori finite number of overlappings of the dilates by r∗ /r of the Bgν ,r ; hence ∀E ⊂ N, E > Nr∗ =⇒
ν ∈E
Bgν ,r∗ = 0. /
In addition, with gσX (B − B) := and
inf
Y ∈B,Y ∈B
gσX (Y − Y ), B, B ⊂ R2n ,
1/2 Δ μν (r∗ ) := max 1, gσXμ (Bgμ ,r∗ − Bgν ,r∗ ), gσXν (Bgμ ,r∗ − Bgν ,r∗ ) ,
there exist constants N˜ and C˜ such that ˜ ˜ sup ∑ Δ μν (r∗ )−N < C.
μ
ν
Moreover, for all k ∈ Z+ there exist C > 0 and ∈ Z+ such that for any given a ∈ S(m, g) and b ∈ Conf(1, g, X, r) one has ||ab||k,Conf(1,g,X,r) ≤ Cm(X )||a||,S(m,g) ||b||,Conf(1,g,X,r) .
(3.6)
Finally, for all k, N ∈ Z+ there exist C = Ck,N > 0 and ∈ Z+ such that for every μ , ν ∈ N and every a ∈ Conf(1, g, Xμ , r) and b ∈ Conf(1, g, Xν , r) one has ||ab||k,Conf(1,g,Xμ ,r) + ||ab||k,Conf(1,g,Xν ,r) ≤ C||a||,Conf(1,g,Xμ ,r) ||b||,Conf(1,g,Xν ,r) Δ μν (r)−N .
(3.7)
One has also the following useful lemma, due to Bony and Lerner [3]. Lemma 3.1.11. Let g be an admissible metric, and let m be a g-admissible weight. Let Bν be a g-ball as in Lemma 3.1.10. Let gν = gXν and mν = m(Xν ). Let {aν }ν ∈Z+ be a sequence of symbols with aν ∈ S(mν , gν ), such that for any given integer k ∈ Z+
3.1 Review of the Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
21
sup ||aν ||k,Conf(mν ,gν ,Xν ,r) < +∞.
ν ∈Z+
Then a := ∑ν ∈Z+ aν belongs to S(m, g). The sequence {aν }ν ∈Z+ is said to be uniformly confined in S(m, g). When m = 1 we have from the Cotlar-Stein Lemma (see H¨ormander [29], Lemma 18.6.5; see also Lemma 3.1.14 below) that aw = 2 ∑ν aw ν is a bounded operator in L . We next come to the action of the affine symplectic group. We have the following theorem (see H¨ormander [29]). Theorem 3.1.12 (Symplectic invariance). For every affine symplectic transformation χ : Rn × Rn −→ Rn × Rn (i.e. χ ∗ σ = σ , where χ ∗ σ is the pull-back of the 2-form σ by χ , defined by (χ ∗ σ )(v, w) = σ (χ v, χ w) where χ : R2n −→ R2n is the tangent map associated with χ ) there exists a unitary Uχ : L2 (Rn ) −→ L2 (Rn ), uniquely determined apart from a complex constant factor of modulus 1, such that for all a ∈ S(m, g) one has Uχ−1 aw (x, D)Uχ = (a ◦ χ )w(x, D). One has that Uχ is also an automorphism of S (Rn ) and S (Rn ). The proof of the theorem is obtained by considering the generators of the affine symplectic group of Rn × Rn and the associated metaplectic operator Uχ . One has that • when χ : (x, ξ ) −→ (x + x0 , ξ ), then (Uχ f )(x) = f (x − x0 );
• when χ : (x, ξ ) −→ (x, ξ + ξ0 ), then (Uχ f )(x) = ei x,ξ0 f (x); • when χ maps (x j , ξ j ) −→ (ξ j , −x j ) (for some j) keeping the other variables
fixed, then Uχ is the normalized partial Fourier transform in the x j variable Uχ f = (2π )−1/2Fx j →ξ j f ; • when χ : (x, ξ ) −→ (T x, t T −1 ξ ), where T : Rn −→ Rn is a linear isomorphism, then (Uχ f )(x) = |detT |−1/2 f (T −1 x); • when χ : (x, ξ ) −→ (x, ξ −Ax), for some A = tA, then (Uχ f )(x) = e−i Ax,x /2 f (x). We close this section by recalling the following fundamental result about the L2 -continuity. Theorem 3.1.13. Let a ∈ S(m, g). Then aw (x, D) : L2 (Rn ) −→ L2 (Rn ) is bounded iff m is bounded. Moreover, the operator aw (x, D) is compact in L2 (Rn ) iff m → 0 at ∞. Finally, there exist constants C > 0 and k ∈ Z+ (depending only on the dimension and the “structural” constants relative to g and m) such that ||aw ||L2 →L2 ≤ C||a||k;S(m,g) . When a ∈ S (R2n ) we have ||aw ||L2 →L2 ≤ (2π )−2n ||a|| ˆ L1 .
22
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
The proof of this theorem uses Lemma 3.1.10 and the very important Cotlar-Stein Lemma (see [29]), of which we give a proof for the sake of completeness. Lemma 3.1.14. Let H1 , H2 be Hilbert spaces. Let {A j } j=1,...,+∞ be linear bounded operators from H1 to H2 (i.e. they belong to L (H1 , H2 )). Suppose that there exists a constant M > 0 such that +∞
+∞
j∈N k=1
j∈N k=1
sup ∑ ||A∗j Ak ||1/2 ≤ M, sup ∑ ||A j A∗k ||1/2 ≤ M.
(3.8)
+∞
Then Au :=
∑ (Ak u) exists for any given u ∈ H1 , with strong convergence in H2 ,
k=1
and for the norm of A we have ||A|| ≤ M. Proof. We remark in the first place that if T ∈ L (H1 , H2 ), then ||T ∗ || = ||T ||, and ||T ∗ T || = ||T ||2 , so that, when T = T ∗ ,
(3.9)
||T 2 || = ||T ||2 .
In order to prove (3.9), one first notices that (with obvious notation) ||T || :=
sup || f ||H1 =||g||H2 =1
|(T f , g)H2 |,
(3.10)
for on the one hand, for any given f˜ ∈ H1 and g˜ ∈ H2 with || f˜||H1 = ||g|| ˜ H2 = 1, one has |(T f˜, g) ˜ H2 | ≤ sup |(T f , g)H2 |, || f ||H1 =||g||H2 =1
whence ||T || ≤
sup || f ||H1 =||g||H2 =1
|(T f , g)H2 |,
because ||T f˜||H2 = sup |(T f˜, g)H2 | ≤ ||g||H2 =1
sup || f ||H1 =||g||H2 =1
|(T f , g)H2 |,
and on the other sup || f ||H1 =||g||H2 =1
|(T f , g)H2 | ≤ ||T ||.
Now, from (3.10) it follows that ||T || :=
sup || f ||H1 =||g||H2 =1
|(T f , g)H2 | =
sup || f ||H1 =||g||H2 =1
||T ∗ T || ≤ ||T ∗ ||||T || = ||T ||2 ,
|( f , T ∗ g)H1 | = ||T ∗ ||,
3.1 Review of the Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
23
and ||T ||2 = sup (T f , T f )H2 = sup |(T ∗ T f , f )H1 | ≤ ||T ∗ T || || f ||H1 =1
|| f ||H1 =1
which proves (3.9). The above remark yields ||T ||2m = ||(T ∗ T )m ||. Define now, for N ∈ N, AN :=
N
∑ Ak .
k=1
For the general term in (A∗N AN )m we have
||A∗j1 A j2 . . . A∗j2m−1 A j2m || ≤ min{||A∗j1 A j2 || . . . ||A∗j2m−1 A j2m ||, ||A∗j1 ||||A j2 A∗j3 || . . . ||A j2m−2 A∗j2m−1 ||||A j2m ||}. Since ||A∗j1 ||, ||A j2m || ≤ M by hypothesis, taking the geometric mean of the above bounds gives N
∑
||AN ||2m = ||(A∗N AN )m || ≤
j1 , j2 ,..., j2m =1
||A∗j1 A j2 . . . A∗j2m−1 A j2m ||
N
≤M
∑
≤M
∑ M2m−1 = NM2m ,
||A∗j1 A j2 ||1/2 ||A j2 A∗j3 ||1/2 . . . ||A∗j2m−1 A j2m ||1/2 j1 , j2 ,..., j2m =1 N
j1 =1
where in the last inequality we have used (3.8). Thus ||AN || ≤ N 1/(2m) M −→ M as m → +∞, ∀N ∈ N. We now show that the linear operator A : H1 u −→ Au :=
(3.11)
+∞
∑ (Ak u) ∈ H2 is well-
k=1
defined and bounded. Suppose that u = A∗j v for some j and some v ∈ H2 . Then, since ||Ak A∗j || = ||A j A∗k || ≤ M||A j A∗k ||1/2 , we get that for N1 + 1 ≤ N2 ||AN2 u − AN1 u||H2 = ||
as N1 , N2 → +∞, whence also defined when u ∈
N2
∑
k=N1 +1
Ak A∗j v||H2 ≤ M
N2
∑
k=N1 +1
||Ak A∗j ||1/2 ||v||H2 −→ 0
+∞
∑ (Ak u) exists in this case. It thus also follows that Au is
k=1
∑ Im(A∗j ). Define now
finite +∞
W :=
∑ Im(A∗j ) := {u ∈ H1 ; ∃{v j } j∈N ⊂ H2 , u = lim
j=1
N→+∞
N
∑ A∗j v j }.
j=1
24
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus N
Define uN :=
∑ A∗j v j . Then {uN }N is a Cauchy-sequence in H1. Moreover, from
j=1
(3.11) one obtains that for any given m ≥ 1, m
|| ∑ Ak (uN1 − uN2 )||H2 ≤ M||uN1 − uN2 ||H1 k=1
uniformly in m, whence since AuN1 and AuN2 are defined (all N1 , N2 ) one gets ||AuN1 − AuN2 ||H2 ≤ M||uN1 − uN2 ||H1 −→ 0 as N1 , N2 → +∞. Hence there exists +∞
∑ (Ak uN ), N→+∞
Au = lim
k=1
+∞
and || ∑ Ak u||H2 ≤ M||u||H1 , ∀u ∈ W. k=1
It follows that A is a bounded operator in W, whence it is also bounded in W . Since ⊥
W⊥ = W =
Ker(Ak ), one has u ∈ W ⊥ =⇒ Au = 0,
k∈N
whence, as H1 = W ⊕ W ⊥ , we get A ∈ L (H1 , H2 ), with ||A|| ≤ M.
In the case of matrix-valued and vector-valued symbols, Definitions 3.1.4 and 3.1.6, the composition formula (3.3) (keeping track, where necessary, of the order of the terms), Theorem 3.1.12 and the continuity theorem Theorem 3.1.13 all hold true. Upon denoting by MN the set of N × N complex matrices, we shall write S(m, g; MN ) = S(m, g) ⊗ MN , and S μ (g; MN ) = S μ (g) ⊗ MN , for the matrix-valued analogue of the symbol spaces S(m, g) and S μ (g) considered above. In general, analogous notation will be used for the spaces S(m, g; V) = S(m, g) ⊗ V (where V is some real or complex finite-dimensional vector space) etc. Remark 3.1.15. Note that for a ∈ S(m, g) (or in general a ∈ S(m, g; V)), the formal adjoint (i.e. on S and S ) of aw (x, D) is aw (x, D)∗ = (a∗ )w (x, D), a∗ being the complex conjugate a¯ of a when a is scalar, or the linear form t a¯ ∈ V∗ when a is a vector in V, or the adjoint matrix a∗ = t a¯ in case V = MN . It is also useful to have the rule for passing from the Weyl-quantization to the ordinary quantization “to the right” (the so-called left-quantization: “taking derivatives before taking multiplications”). Theorem 3.1.16. Let g be an admissible metric, and suppose that gx,ξ (y, η ) = gx,ξ (y, −η ), for all (x, ξ ), (y, η ) ∈ R2n . Let m be a g-admissible weight. Then exp iκ Dx , Dξ is a weakly continuous isomorphism of S(m, g) for every κ ∈ R,
3.2 Global Metrics and Global Pseudodifferential Operators
25
iκ Dx , Dξ j a(x, ξ ) ∈ S(hN+1 m, g), j! j=0 N
eiκ Dx ,Dξ a(x, ξ ) − ∑
for all N ∈ Z+ . Hence, given a, b ∈ S(m, g) we have aw (x, D) = b(x, D), with b(x, D)u(x) = (2π )−n
ei x−y,ξ b(x, ξ )u(y)dyd ξ , u ∈ S ,
where b(x, ξ ) = ei Dx ,Dξ /2 a(x, ξ ), a(x, ξ ) = e−i Dx ,Dξ /2 b(x, ξ ).
(3.12)
Equalities (3.12) follow in a way similar to that of the composition formula (3.3). Remark 3.1.17. In H¨ormander [29, p. 159], Theorem 3.1.16 is stated in a more general form, and takes care also of the relation of the Weyl-quantization to the so-called right-quantization (“taking derivatives after taking multiplications”).
3.2 Global Metrics and Global Pseudodifferential Operators We now consider the Weyl-H¨ormander pseudodifferential calculus modelled after the harmonic oscillator. Let us hence consider, for X ∈ R2n , m(X ) := (1 + |X|2)1/2 , gX = so that
|dX|2 , m(X )2
(3.13)
gσX = m(X )2 |dX|2 , h(X ) = m(X )−2 .
The metric g is called the global metric. Let us check that g is indeed admissible, and that m and m−1 are g-admissible. • The metric g is slowly varying. Let c0 ∈ (0, 1/2) to be picked, and suppose
gX (Y − X ) ≤ c0 , that is, |Y − X|2 ≤ c0 m(X)2 . Then, on the one hand
m(Y )2 = 1 + |Y |2 ≤ 1 + (|X | + |X − Y |)2 ≤ 1 + 2|X |2 + 2|X − Y |2 ≤ 2(c0 + 1)m(X )2, and on the other m(X)2 = 1 + |X |2 ≤ 1 + 2|Y|2 + 2|X − Y |2 ≤ 2m(Y )2 + 2c0m(X )2 ,
26
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
that is, in the end, 1 − 2c0 m(X )2 ≤ m(Y )2 ≤ 2(c0 + 1)m(X )2 , 2 or, equivalently, 1 − 2c0 gY ≤ gX ≤ 2(c0 + 1)gY . 2 We may hence pick c0 = 1/4 (say), and get that g is slowly varying with slowness constant C0−1 = 1/10. • Uncertainty. It is trivial: gX =
|dX|2 ≤ m(X )2 |dX|2 = gσX . m(X)2
• Temperateness. We must find universal constants C1 > 0 and N0 ∈ Z+ such that
N0 gX (Z) ≤ C1 gY (Z) 1 + gσX (X − Y ) , ∀X ,Y, Z ∈ R2n , that is to say, N0 |Z|2 |Z|2 2 2 1 + m(X ) ≤ C |X − Y | . 1 m(X )2 m(Y )2 We hence consider m(Y )2 /m(X)2 . Since m(Y )2 1 + 2|X |2 + 2|X − Y |2 m(X )2 + |X − Y |2 ≤ ≤ 2 m(X )2 m(X)2 m(X )2 ≤ 2 1 + m(X)2|X − Y |2 ,
(3.14)
as m(X ) ≥ 1 for all X, the temperateness follows. Hence g is admissible. • To prove that m and m−1 are g-admissible, note that the first part of the above argument shows also that gX (Y − X) ≤ C0−1 =⇒ m(X ) ≈ m(Y ), that m(Y ) 1 + gσX (X − Y ), m(X) and that m(X)2 1 + 2|Y|2 + 2|X − Y |2 |X − Y |2 ≤ ≤ 2 1+ 2 2 m(Y ) m(Y ) m(Y )2 ≤ 2 1 + m(X)2|X − Y |2 ,
(3.15)
3.2 Global Metrics and Global Pseudodifferential Operators
27
for one has m(Y )−1 ≤ m(X) for all X,Y. Inequalities (3.14) and (3.15) prove that m and m−1 are g-admissible weights. The weight m is called the global weight. This shows that we may consider the class S(mμ , g), μ ∈ R. Hence a ∈ S(mμ , g) if for all α ∈ Z2n + there exists Cα > 0 such that |∂Xα a(X )| ≤ Cα m(X)μ −|α | , ∀X ∈ R2n . Definition 3.2.1. When a ∈ S(mμ , g) we shall say that a has order μ . Next, we introduce the basic notion of elliptic elements. Definition 3.2.2. A symbol a ∈ S(mμ , g) is said to be globally elliptic when there exist constants c,C > 0 such that |X | ≥ C =⇒ |a(X )| ≥ c m(X )μ . Hence, we may say that not only does the symbol a(X ) grow at most like m(X )μ , but that for large X it is equivalent to the weight m(X )μ . The next definition is introduced for keeping track of the important class of differential operators with polynomial coefficients, that are Weyl-quantizations of polynomials of the kind d
∑
∑
j=0 |α |+|β |=2d−2 j
aαβ xα ξ β , aαβ ∈ C.
The grading 2d − 2 j, in place of the more general one 2d − j, is natural, when considering spectral properties of Weyl-quantizations of degree 2 polynomials in (x, ξ ) ∈ R2n . Definition 3.2.3. We say that a symbol a ∈ S(mμ , g) is classical, and write a ∈ Scl (mμ , g), if there exists a sequence {a μ −2 j } j≥0 ⊂ C∞ (R2n \ {0}) such that for all j ≥ 0 aμ −2 j (tX) = t μ −2 j aμ −2 j (X), ∀t > 0, ∀X = 0 (that is, the a μ −2 j are positively homogeneous of degree μ − 2 j), and for any given N ∈ Z+ N
a(X ) − χ (X) ∑ aμ −2 j (X) ∈ S(mμ −2(N+1) , g), j=0
χ being some excision function, that is a function 0 ≤ χ ≤ 1 that is supported away from 0, for instance χ ≡ 0 for |X| ≤ 1/2, and χ ≡ 1 for |X | ≥ 1. We shall write a∼
∑ aμ −2 j .
j≥0
28
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
Remark 3.2.4. More generally, one may consider also semi-regular classical symbols a ∈ S(mμ , g), that is symbols for which there exists a sequence {a μ − j } j≥0 ⊂ C∞ (R2n \ {0}) such that for all j ≥ 0 a μ − j (tX) = t μ − j aμ − j (X), ∀t > 0, ∀X = 0, and a∼
∑ aμ − j .
j≥0
We shall write a ∈ Ssrcl (mμ , g). However, our interest will rest mainly on classical symbols. Remark 3.2.5. One may also define classical symbols by requiring the sequence {a μ −2 j } j≥0 to be smooth on the whole R2n , but with the positive homogeneity property holding for all t > 1 and |X| > 1 only. This does not make any difference in the theory (it merely avoids the use of excision functions) and it is just a matter of taste. Note hence that, with d ∈ Z+ , d
∑
∑
aαβ xα ξ β ∈ Scl (m2d , g),
∑
aαβ xα ξ β ∈ Ssrcl (m2d , g).
j=0 |α |+|β |=2d−2 j
whereas
d
∑
j=0 |α |+|β |=2d− j
Definition 3.2.6. Let μ ∈ Z+ . A classical symbol a ∈ Scl (mμ , g) is a global polynomial differential (GPD for short) symbol of order μ if a=
[ μ /2]
∑ aμ −2 j
j=0
(with [μ /2] denoting, as usual, the integer part of μ /2), where the entries of the a μ −2 j are homogeneous polynomials in X ∈ R2n of degree μ − 2 j. A global polynomial differential operator (GPDO for short) of order μ is the Weyl-quantization of a GPD symbol of order μ . To recognize globally elliptic classical symbols, it is very useful to have the following lemma. Lemma 3.2.7. Let a ∈ Scl (mμ , g). Then min |a μ (X)| > 0,
|X|=1
iff a is globally elliptic.
(3.16)
3.2 Global Metrics and Global Pseudodifferential Operators
29
Proof. Let χ be an excision function as in Definition 3.2.3. Then a(X ) = χ (X)a μ (X) + O(m(X )μ −2). We may hence take |X | ≥ 1, so that in the above identity χ = 1. Now, for |X | ≥ 1 we also have m(X) ≈ |X |, whence, using the homogeneity of aμ we get a(X) = m(X )μ Hence
|X |μ −2 a (X/|X|) + O(m(X ) ) , |X | ≥ 1. μ m(X)μ
a(X) ≈ m(X)μ , ∀X with |X | 1,
iff (3.16) holds. Lemma 3.2.7 then induces the following definition.
Definition 3.2.8. We say that a ∈ Scl (mμ , g) is globally elliptic when (3.16) holds. In the vector-valued case, we will use the following definition of globally elliptic symbols. Definition 3.2.9. Let V be a finite-dimensional vector space (complex or real). We denote by S(mμ , g; V), resp. Scl (mμ , g; V), the class of vector-valued symbols, resp. vector-valued classical symbols. In other words, we have S(mμ , g; V) = S(mμ , g) ⊗ V, and likewise for Scl (mμ , g; V). In particular, when V = MN , having that a ∈ S(mμ , g; MN ), resp. Scl (mμ , g; MN ), means that each entry a jk of the matrix a belongs to S(mμ , g), resp. Scl (mμ , g), and having an N × N global polynomial differential system of order μ means having a symbol a ∈ Scl (mμ , g; MN ) such that each entry is a GPD symbol of order μ (see Definition 3.2.6). We shall say that a symbol a ∈ S(mμ , g; MN ) is globally elliptic if there exist constants c,C > 0 such that |det a(X )| ≥ c m(X)μ N , whenever |X | ≥ C. Equivalently, when a ∈ S(mμ , g; L (V, W)), where W is another finite-dimensional vector space, we require (for some norms | · |V in V and | · |W in W) |a(X)v|W ≈ m(X )μ |v|V , ∀v ∈ V, ∀X with |X | 1, and when a = a∗ ∈ S(mμ , g; MN ) is positive-definite or negative-definite as an Hermitian matrix, we may equivalently require | a(X )v, v CN | ≈ m(X)μ |v|2CN , ∀v ∈ CN , ∀X with |X | 1. When a ∈ Scl (mμ , g; MN ) is classical, we shall then require min |det a μ (X)| > 0,
|X|=1
30
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
or, equivalently, |a μ (X )v|CN ≈ |v|CN , ∀v ∈ CN , ∀X with |X | = 1, and when aμ = a∗μ is positive/negative-definite as an Hermitian matrix, | a μ (X )v, v CN | ≈ |v|2CN , ∀v ∈ CN , ∀X with |X | = 1. Analogous requirements for classical symbols are possible in the case one has V = L (CN1 , CN2 ) etc. (of course det can be used only where meaningful). We shall say that a symbol a = a∗ ∈ S(mμ , g; MN ) is globally positive elliptic if a(X )v, v CN ≈ m(X)μ |v|2CN , ∀v ∈ CN , ∀X with |X | 1. When a = a∗ ∈ Scl (mμ , g; MN ), we shall say that a is globally positive elliptic if aμ (X )v, v CN ≈ |v|2CN , ∀v ∈ CN , ∀X with |X | = 1.
(3.17)
We shall say that a matrix-valued GPDO of order μ is elliptic (resp. positive elliptic) if its principal symbol aμ is globally elliptic (resp. positive elliptic). Remark 3.2.10. Recall that a(X)−1 =
1 co a(X ), deta(X)
where coa ∈ S(m(N−1)μ , g; MN ) is the cofactor matrix (i.e. the transpose of the the matrix whose i j-entry is the algebraic cofactor of the i j-entry of a) associated with a(X). One then sees that, equivalently: • a ∈ S(mμ , g; MN ) is globally elliptic if a(X)−1 exists for all X ∈ R2n with |X | 1
and χ a−1 ∈ S(m−μ , g; MN ), where χ is some excision function; • a ∈ Scl (mμ , g; MN ) is globally elliptic if a μ (X )−1 exists for all X ∈ R2n with |X| = 1. Definition 3.2.11. A non-commutative harmonic oscillator (NCHO for short) is the Weyl-quantization of any given 2nd-order N × N GPD system a ∈ Scl (m2 , g; MN ). Hence a = a2 + a0 , where a2 is a matrix whose entries are homogeneous quadratic forms in X = (x, ξ ) ∈ R2n , and a0 is a constant matrix. We shall be particularly interested in the following two-parameter family of 0 −1 NCHOs. Let α , β ∈ C, J = , and 1 0 α 0 x2 + ξ 2 + iJxξ , x, ξ ∈ R. Q(α ,β ) (x, ξ ) = 2 0 β
(3.18)
3.2 Global Metrics and Global Pseudodifferential Operators
31
Hence, Q(α ,β ) ∈ Scl (m2 , g; M2 ) and the NCHO Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) is then the system of GPDOs of order 2
1 α 0 ∂x2 x2 + + J x . (3.19) − (x, D) = ∂ + Qw x (α ,β ) 2 2 2 0 β A NCHO is elliptic (resp. positive elliptic) when it is elliptic (resp. positive elliptic) as a GPDO. Remark 3.2.12. The NCHO Q(α ,β ) (x, ξ ), for α , β > 0 and αβ > 1 is positive elliptic. (We leave it to the reader to check this claim.) It is important to make the following observation on formally self-adjoint positive elliptic N × N systems of GPDOs. Lemma 3.2.13. Let a = a∗ ∈ Scl (mμ , g; MN ) be a globally positive elliptic GPD system. Then μ ∈ Z+ is even. Hence a = a μ + aμ −2 + . . . + a0 , where a0 is an N × N constant Hermitian matrix, and all the a μ −2 j , 0 ≤ j ≤ (μ − 2)/2, are N × N Hermitian matrices. Proof. By (3.17), taking v = e1 (the first vector of the canonical basis of CN ), we have for the 11-entry of a μ aμ ,11 (X) ≈ |X |μ , ∀X ∈ R2n . Hence a μ ,11 is a nonnegative homogeneous polynomial in X ∈ R2n of degree μ , which is positive when X = 0. Hence μ must be an even (nonnegative) integer. It is also important to define the smoothing elements. Definition 3.2.14. A symbol a∈
S(mμ , g) =: S(m−∞ , g) = S (Rn × Rn )
μ ∈R
is said to be a smoothing symbol. In fact, in this case aw (x, D) : S (Rn ) −→ S (Rn ) is continuous, and for its Schwartz kernel Kaw one has Kaw ∈ S (Rn × Rn ). Analogously in the matrix-valued case. In general, any continuous map R : S (Rn ; CN ) −→ S (Rn ; CN ) is called a smoothing operator. Equivalently, for the Schwartz kernel KR of a smoothing operator R we have KR ∈ S (Rn × Rn ; MN ). We next have the following useful result (of basic importance when constructing a parametrix of an elliptic operator in these global classes).
32
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
Proposition 3.2.15. Let μ j −∞, μ j > μ j+1 , j ∈ N, be a monotone strictly decreasing sequence of real numbers. Let a j ∈ S(mμ j , g), j ∈ N. Then there exists a ∈ S(mμ1 , g) such that a ∼ ∑ a j, j≥1
that is, for all r ∈ N we have r
a − ∑ a j ∈ S(mμr+1 , g). j=1
If another a has the same property, then a − a ∈ S (R2n ). Proof. Let χ be an excision function, with 0 ≤ χ ≤ 1, such that χ (X ) = 0 if |X| ≤ 1/2 and χ (X ) = 1 if |X | ≥ 1. In the first place we show that we can choose a monotone strictly increasing sequence of positive R j → +∞, increasing so quickly as j → +∞ that for any given j ≥ 2 and for all α ∈ Z2n + with |α | ≤ j, α ∂X χ (X /R j )a j (X) ≤ 2− j m(X )μ j +1−|α | .
(3.20)
To see this, note that |∂Xα (χ (X /R))| ≤ Cα m(X)−|α | , for R ≥ 1. In fact,
(3.21)
∂Xα (χ (X/R)) = R−|α | (∂Xα χ )(X/R),
and |α | ≥ 1, X ∈ supp(∂Xα χ )(·/R) =⇒ R/2 ≤ |X | ≤ R, from which (3.21) follows, and shows that χ (·/R) ∈ S(1, g) uniformly in R ≥ 1. Then for all α ∈ Z2n + α ∂X χ (X/R)a j (X) ≤ C j,α m(X )μ j −|α | , if R ≥ 1, whence
(3.22)
χ (·/R)a j ∈ S(mμ j , g), j ∈ N, R ≥ 1.
Of course, this is seen also by noting that χ (X/R)a j (X ) = a j (X ) for X large, for supp χ (·/R)a j ⊂ {X ∈ R2n ; |X| ≥ R/2}, ∀ j ∈ N.
(3.23)
Now, given any j ≥ 1, if R ≥ 1 and |α | ≤ j we have α ∂X χ (X /R)a j (X ) ≤ max {C j,α } m(X )μ j −|α | =: C j m(X )μ j −|α | . |α |≤ j
(3.24)
3.2 Global Metrics and Global Pseudodifferential Operators
33
On the other hand, m(X )μ j −|α | ≤ ε m(X)μ j +1−|α | , when X is such that
1 m(X) = (1 + |X|2)1/2 ≥ . ε
So, to satisfy (3.20), it suffices to choose ε = 1/(2 jC j ), and take (1 + R2j /4)1/2 ≥ 2 jC j , j ≥ 2. That is, it suffices to take R j ≥ 2 j+1C j , j ≥ 2. Hence we may choose R1 = 1, R j = 2 j+1 (C j + 1) + R j−1, j ≥ 2. Now, (3.23) and R j +∞ yield that the sum a(X ) :=
∑ χ (X/R j )a j (X )
j≥1
is locally finite, hence a ∈ C∞ . On the other hand, given any r ∈ N and any α ∈ Z2n +, we may find N ∈ N so large that |α | ≤ N + 1 and μN+1 + 1 ≤ μr . Hence N α ∂X a(X ) − ∑ χ (X /R j )a j (X) =
α ∂X
j=1
≤
χ (X /R j )a j (X )
∞
∑
j=N+1 ∞
1 m(X )μ j +1−|α | j 2 j=N+1
∑
≤ 2−N m(X )μr −|α |
(3.25)
(recall that μ j > μ j+1 ). Therefore, by choosing r = 1 we obtain that for any given α ∈ Z2n + (with N large depending on α as above) N N ∂Xα a(X ) = ∂Xα a(X ) − ∑ χ (X/R j )a j (X) + ∂Xα ∑ χ (X /R j )a j (X ) , j=1
j=1
whence, by (3.22) and (3.25), |∂Xα a(X )| ≤
N 1 μ1 −|α | m(X ) + ∑ C j,α m(X)μ j −|α | ≤ Cα m(X )μ1 −|α |, 2N j=1
that is a ∈ S(mμ1 , g).
34
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
On the other hand, we also obtain from (3.25) that for any given r ∈ N and any given α ∈ Z2n + with N ≥ r + 1 so large depending on α and r that |α | ≤ N + 1 and μN+1 + 1 ≤ μr+1 , r N α ∂X a(X ) − ∑ a j (X ) ≤ ∂Xα a(X) − ∑ χ (X /R j )a j (X ) j=1
j=1
+ ∑ ∂Xα (1 − χ (X /R j ))a j (X ) r
j=1
+
N
∑
α ∂X χ (X /R j )a j (X )
j=r+1
≤ Cα ,r m(X)μr+1 −|α | , for we have (1 − χ (·/R j ))a j ∈ S(m−∞ , g), ∀ j ∈ N, and
χ (·/R j )a j ∈ S(mμr+1 , g), ∀ j ≥ r + 1. This shows that a ∼ ∑ j≥1 a j . Finally, if a ∈ S(mμ1 , g) has this last property, then for all r ∈ N, r r a − a = a − ∑ a j − a − ∑ a j ∈ S(mμr+1 , g), j=1
j=1
that is a − a ∈ S(m−∞ , g) = S (R2n ), which concludes the proof.
The following proposition (that we state without proof, for which we address the reader to Helffer [17] or Shubin [67]) is also useful. Proposition 3.2.16. Let a j ∈ S(mμ j , g), j ∈ N, where μ j is monotone strictly decreasing to −∞ as j → +∞. Let a ∈ C∞ (R2n ) be such that for any given α ∈ Z2n + there are constants να and Cα such that |∂Xα a(X)| ≤ Cα m(X)να . Finally, let there exist j and C j with j monotone strictly decreasing to −∞ as j → +∞, and suppose the following estimate holds r−1
|a(X ) − ∑ a j (X)| ≤ Cr m(X )r , j=1
for any given r ∈ N. Then a ∼ ∑ j≥1 a j .
3.2 Global Metrics and Global Pseudodifferential Operators
35
In these global classes we have that for any given Au(x) := aw (x, D)u(x) = lim (2π )−n
ε →0+
ei x−y,ξ a(
x+y , ξ )χ (ε x, ε y, εξ )u(y)dyd ξ , 2
the limit being independent of χ ∈ S (R3n ) such that χ (0) = 1. In this case we have, using the relations (1 + |x − y|2)−M (1 − Δξ )M ei x−y,ξ = ei x−y,ξ , (1 + |ξ |2)−N (1 − Δy)N ei x−y,ξ = ei x−y,ξ , and integrating by parts, that −n
Au(x) = (2π )
ei x−y,ξ (1 + |x − y|2)−M
×(1 − Δξ )M (1 − Δy )N
1 x+y , a( ξ )u(y) dyd ξ . (1 + |ξ |2)N 2
In fact, for large M and N the integral becomes absolutely convergent, for if a ∈ S(mμ , g) then (see e.g. Shubin [67]), for b(x, y, ξ ) = a((x + y)/2, ξ ) we have γ
|∂xα ∂yβ ∂ξ b(x, y, ξ )| ≤ Cαβ γ (1 + |x| + |y| + |ξ |)μ −|α |−|β |−|γ |(1 + |x − y|)|μ |+|α |+|β |+|γ |, for all (x, y, ξ ) ∈ R3n , which allows us to conclude the convergence. In this case the Schwartz kernel KA ∈ S (Rn × Rn ) is given by KA |ψ S ,S = lim (2π )−n ε →0+
ei x−y,ξ a(
x+y , ξ )χ (ε x, ε y, εξ )ψ (x, y)dydxd ξ , 2
for all ψ ∈ S (R2n ). Also in the case of these global classes we may pass from the Weyl-quantization to the ordinary quantization (left-quantization). Theorem 3.1.16 is thus stated in the following form. Theorem 3.2.17. Given a ∈ S(mμ , g) we have aw (x, D) = b(x, D), where b(x, ξ ) = ei Dx ,Dξ /2 a(x, ξ ), a(x, ξ ) = e−i Dx ,Dξ /2 b(x, ξ ). We next summarize some properties of aw (x, D).
(3.26)
36
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
Theorem 3.2.18. 1. Given any a ∈ S(mμ , g) we have: • aw (x, D) : S (Rn ) −→ S (Rn ) and aw (x, D) : S (Rn ) −→ S (Rn ) is
continuous; • When a is real-valued, then aw (x, D) is formally self-adjoint.
The same holds true for a ∈ S(mμ , g; MN ). 2. If a ∈ S(1, g) then aw (x, D) : L2 (Rn ) −→ L2 (Rn ) is continuous. The same holds true for a ∈ S(1, g; MN ). 3. If a ∈ S(m−s , g), with s > 0, then aw (x, D) : L2 (Rn ) −→ L2 (Rn ) is compact. The same holds true for a ∈ S(m−s , g; MN ), s > 0. We next define general global pseudodifferential operators. Definition 3.2.19. 1. We say that A ∈ OPS(mμ , g) (i.e., that A is a global pseudodifferential operator of order μ ) if there exists a ∈ S(mμ , g) such that A = aw (x, D) + R, with KR ∈ S (Rn × Rn). 2. We say that A ∈ OPScl (mμ , g) if a ∈ Scl (mμ , g). 3. We say that A ∈ OPS(mμ , g) is elliptic when a is globally elliptic. 4. If A ∈ OPScl (mμ , g), a ∼ ∑ j≥0 aμ −2 j , we call aμ the principal symbol of A and aμ −2 the subprincipal symbol of A. Analogously for N × N systems. Example 3.2.20. For example, for the “translated” harmonic oscillator p0,n (x, ξ)+C (C a real constant), which is a classical symbol of order 2 (and also a GPD symbol of order 2), we have that p0,n (x, ξ ) is the principal symbol and the constant C is the subprincipal one. As another example, consider the symbol of the NCHO
0 −i α 0 x2 + ξ 2 Q(α ,β ) (x, ξ ) = + xξ . 2 i 0 0 β
The principal part is Q(α ,β ) (x, ξ ) itself, and there is no subprincipal part here. Observe hence that in the corresponding Weyl-quantization
Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) =
the part
1 2
1 0 −1 α 0 −∂x2 + x2 + (x∂x + ), 2 1 0 2 0 β
0 −1 is not the subprincipal term. 1 0
3.2 Global Metrics and Global Pseudodifferential Operators
37
Theorem 3.2.21. Let a ∈ Scl (mμ1 , g) and b ∈ Scl (mμ2 , g). Then aw (x, D)bw (x, D) ∈ OPScl (mμ1 +μ2 , g), and for the symbol composition ab we have (using the fact that the derivative of a function which is homogeneous of degree μ is a function homogeneous of degree μ − 1) ab ∼ ∑ (ab)μ1 +μ2 −2 j , (3.27) j≥0
so that the principal symbol of the composition is (ab)μ1 +μ2 = aμ1 bμ2 ,
(3.28)
i (ab)μ1 +μ2 −2 = aμ1 bμ2 −2 + a μ1 −2 bμ2 − {a μ1 , b μ2 }. 2
(3.29)
and the subprincipal symbol is
Exercise 3.2.22. Write down the composition formula for semiregular classical symbols. We now come to a central construction in the theory of elliptic global pseudodifferential operators: the existence of a (two-sided) parametrix. Theorem 3.2.23. Let A ∈ OPS(mμ , g) be elliptic. Then there exists B ∈ OPS(m−μ , g) such that BA = I + R, AB = I + R , (3.30) where R, R are smoothing operators. Furthermore, if A ∈ OPScl (mμ , g) then B ∈ OPScl (m−μ , g). One calls B a two-sided parametrix. Proof. We shall give the proof when A is “classical”. ˜ for some B In the first place, it suffices to see that BA = I + R and AB = I + R, and B . In fact, we then have ˜ = (I + R)B, BAB = B(I + R) that is
˜ . B = B + (RB − BR) smoothing
We hence prove that we may find B as in the statement, such that BA = I + R (i.e. B is a left-parametrix). The construction of a right-parametrix is completely analogous. Let χ be an excision function. Let b− μ =
χ ∈ Scl (m−μ , g). aμ
38
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
Then
B1 = (b−μ )w (x, D) ∈ OPScl (m−μ , g),
and
B1 A = I + R1, R1 ∈ OPScl (m−1 , g),
and actually R1 ∈ OPScl (m−2 , g), because we are working with classical symbols. We hence “Neumann-invert” I + R1 as follows: for any given N ∈ Z+ we have
N
∑ (−1) j R1j
B1 A = I − (−1)N+1 R1N+1 .
j=0 ( j)
(0)
j
( j)
If r1 is the symbol of R1 (which is classical), that is r1 = 1 and r1 = r1 . . . r1 , then by Proposition 3.2.15 we may find a symbol s ∈ Scl (1, g) such that s∼
∞
∑ (−1) j r1
( j)
j times
.
j=0
Hence S = sw (x, D) satisfies SB1 A = I + R, with R smoothing. We thus set B := SB1 . This concludes the proof of the theorem.
Remark 3.2.24. 1. Theorem 3.2.21 also holds for matrix-valued operators. 2. Theorem 3.2.23 also holds for matrix-valued elliptic global pseudodifferential operators. 3. An equivalent proof may be given by using the composition formula (3.3) and by considering, at each degree of homogeneity, the equation ba = 1 + r, and finally by using an excision function to “re-sum” the homogeneous terms. Hence, for instance, we have the equations i b−μ aμ = 1, b−μ aμ −2 + b−μ −2aμ − {b−μ , a μ } = 0, . . . , 2 so that we take b−μ = a−1 μ , b− μ −2 =
i 2
−1 −1 {a−1 μ , a μ } − a μ a μ −2 a μ , . . . .
Of course, in the matrix-valued case we must be careful in keeping the right order of the factors.
3.2 Global Metrics and Global Pseudodifferential Operators
39
We are now ready to define the natural spaces on which global operators act. Let Λ 2 = 1 + |x|2 + |D|2 (where |D|2 is a pseudodifferential notation for −Δx ) be the harmonic oscillator in n-dimensions, translated by 1. Let s ∈ R. By virtue of our knowledge of the spectrum of the harmonic oscillator (see Theorem 2.2.1 and its n-dimensional extension Theorem 2.2.2) we may define the s/2-power Λ s = (1 + |x|2 + |D|2 )s/2 (see also Section 5.3 of Chapter 5 below, where a few facts of the functional calculus are recalled). Using the proof of Theorem 5.5.1 below (see Helffer [17, pp. 46–52]) in the special case of Λ 2 , one has that Λ s = w s (x, D) ∈ OPScl (ms , g) is globally elliptic, with principal symbol (|x|2 + |ξ |2 )s/2 . Hence for all s, s ∈ R, one has that on S (Rn ) (and S (Rn ))
Λ s Λ s = Λ s+s , Λ −s = (Λ s )−1 , and Λ s = (Λ s )∗ also as global pseudodifferential operators. Definition 3.2.25. Let s ∈ R. Define the spaces Bs (Rn ) = {u ∈ S (Rn ); Λ s u ∈ L2 (Rn )}, endowed with the norm and inner-product respectively given by ||u||Bs = ||Λ s u||0 , (u, v)s := (Λ s u, Λ s v)0 , u, v ∈ Bs (Rn ). We define the CN -valued case as follows: Bs (Rn ; CN ) := Bs (Rn ) ⊗ CN , endowed with the natural norms and inner-products induced by the norm and innerproduct of Bs and CN . Here are some important properties of the Bs , that are derived by the continuity properties and the existence of a parametrix of the operators Λ s (see Helffer [17]). Proposition 3.2.26. 1. For each s ∈ R, Bs (Rn ) is a Hilbert space, and S (Rn ) ⊂ Bs (Rn ) is densely embedded. 2. For s ∈ Z+ , Bs (Rn ) = {u ∈ L2 (Rn ); and
∑
|α |+|β |≤s
∑
|α |+|β |≤s
||xα ∂xβ u||20 < ∞},
||xα ∂xβ u||20 ≈ ||u||2Bs ,
that is, the two norms are equivalent.
40
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
3. For any given s ∈ R, the L2 inner-product defined for u, v ∈ S extends to a sesquilinear form which is continuous on Bs (Rn ) × B−s (Rn ), and one has that B−s (Rn ) is identified with (Bs (Rn ))∗ (the dual of Bs (Rn )). 4. For any given s < s we have that Bs (Rn ) ⊂ Bs (Rn ) with compact and dense range. 5. We have S (Rn ) =
Bs (Rn ), S (Rn ) =
s∈R
Bs (Rn ).
s∈R
Hence, given any p, q, ∈ Z+ , if |u| p,q = sup sup (1 + |x|) p|∂xα u(x)| |α |≤q x∈Rn
denotes a seminorm in S , there is s0 = s0 (p, q, n) such that for all s ≥ s0 there exists Cs > 0 for which we have |u| p,q ≤ Cs ||u||Bs , ∀u ∈ S (Rn ).
(3.31)
6. For any given s ∈ R, any given A ∈ OPS(mμ , g) is bounded as an operator A : Bs (Rn ) −→ Bs−μ (Rn ). 7. The spaces Bs (Rn ) do not depend on Λ s , that is, for any given globally elliptic A ∈ OPScl (ms , g) one has Bs (Rn ) = {u ∈ S (Rn ); Au ∈ L2 (Rn )}. 8. Properties 1–7 above hold true also in the vector-valued and matrix-valued cases. It is worth noting that Property 5 of Proposition 3.2.26 does not hold for the more usual Sobolev spaces H s (Rn ), for in this case we have, upon setting H +∞ (Rn ) :=
H s (Rn ), H −∞ (Rn ) :=
s∈R
H s (Rn ),
s∈R
that S (Rn ) H +∞ (Rn ) H −∞ (Rn ) S (Rn ). Notice also that S (Rn ) =
k∈Z
Bk (Rn ).
3.3 Spectral Properties of Globally Elliptic Pseudodifferential Operators
41
3.3 Spectral Properties of Globally Elliptic Pseudodifferential Operators We now want to study how the spectrum of an elliptic global psedudodifferential operator depends on the spaces Bs . Remark that all the results stated in this section hold true also for matrix-valued operators. We have the following very important lemma, which shows that the kernel of an elliptic global pseudodifferential operator does not depend on the spaces Bs in which the operator is realized (in fact, it consists exclusively of Schwartz functions). Lemma 3.3.1. Let A ∈ OPS(mμ , g) be elliptic. Then Ker(A : Bs+μ → Bs ) = Ker(A : S → S ) = Ker(A : S → S ), ∀s ∈ R. Proof. Take ψ ∈ S such that Aψ = 0. Then, by the existence of a parametrix Q, 0 = QAψ = ψ + Rψ , i.e. ψ = −Rψ ∈ S , since R is smoothing. Hence Ker(A : S → S ) ⊂ Ker(A : S → S ) ⊂ Ker(A : S → S ). Since it is trivial that Ker(A : S → S ) ⊂ Ker(A : Bs+μ → Bs ) ⊂ Ker(A : S → S ),
we obtain the claim.
Next we show that the kernel of an elliptic global pseudodifferential operator has a finite dimension. Lemma 3.3.2. Let A ∈ OPS(mμ , g) be elliptic. Then dim Ker A < +∞. Proof. Let Q be a two-sided parametrix of A, with QA = I + R, R smoothing. Since Ker(A : Bμ → L2 ) ⊂ Ker(QA : Bμ → Bμ ) = Ker(I + R : Bμ → Bμ ), and since R : Bμ −→ S → Bμ +1 →→ Bμ , where →→ denotes compact embedding, we get that R : Bμ −→ Bμ is compact, whence the claim.
42
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
The range of an elliptic global pseudodifferential operator enjoys some nice properties as well. They are stated in the following results. Lemma 3.3.3. Let A ∈ OPS(mμ , g) be elliptic. For all s ∈ R one has: (i) Im(A : Bμ +s → Bs ) is closed, with finite codimension; (ii) codimIm(A : Bμ +s → Bs ) = dim Ker A∗ (hence independent of s). Proof. Let Q be a two-sided parametrix of A, with AQ = I + R , R smoothing. One has Im(A : Bμ +s → Bs ) ⊃ Im(AQ : Bs → Bs ) = Im(I + R : Bs → Bs ), and since R : Bs → Bs is compact, Im(I + R : Bs → Bs ) is closed, with finite codimension. This proves (i). We prove (ii). By the Closed Range Theorem we have dim(Bs /A(Bμ +s )) = dim Ker(A+ : Bs → Bμ +s ), where the operator A+ is defined by (Au, g)s = (u, A+ g)μ +s , u ∈ Bμ +s , g ∈ Bs . (Recall that (Au, g)s = (Λ s Au, Λ s g)0 .) Taking sequences {u j } j , {g j } j ⊂ S with Bμ +s
Bs
u j → u and g j → g, as j → +∞, yields (Λ s Au, Λ s g)0 = lim (Λ s Au j , Λ s g j )0 = lim (u j , A∗Λ 2s g j )0 j→+∞
j→+∞
= lim (Λ
μ +s
j→+∞
u j, Λ
−( μ +s) ∗
A Λ 2s g j )0 = (Λ μ +s u, Λ −(μ +s) A∗Λ 2s g)0 .
We thus have (Λ μ +s u, Λ −(μ +s) A∗Λ 2s g)0 = (u, A+ g)μ +s = (Λ μ +s u, Λ μ +s A+ g)0 . Then, by comparison, Λ μ +s A+ g = Λ −(μ +s) A∗Λ 2s g, whence A+ g = Λ −2(μ +s) A∗Λ 2s g, ∀g ∈ Bs , and, finally,
dim Ker(A+ : Bs → Bμ +s ) = dim Ker A∗ ,
which concludes the proof. Lemma 3.3.4. Let A ∈ OPS(mμ , g) be elliptic. One has: (i) Im(A : S → S ) is closed, with finite codimension equal to dim Ker A∗ ; (ii) Im(A : S → S ) is closed, with finite codimension equal to dim Ker A∗ .
3.3 Spectral Properties of Globally Elliptic Pseudodifferential Operators
43
S
Proof. To see (i), take {u j } j ⊂ S such that Au j → g ∈ S , as j → +∞. Then, in L2
particular, Au j → g, whence g ∈ Im(A : Bμ −→ L2 ). Therefore there exists u ∈ Bμ such that Au = g and, by the existence of a parametrix, we have that u ∈ S , since g ∈ S . This proves that Im(A : S → S ) is closed. We now claim that Im(A : S → S ) = {u ∈ S ; (u, g)0 = 0, ∀g ∈ Ker A∗ } =: V. (Recall that KerA∗ ⊂ S .) To prove the claim, observe that the inclusion ⊂ is trivial. To prove ⊃, suppose in the first place that μ = 0. Then, since L2 = Im A ⊕ Ker A∗ (A : L2 → L2 is now continuous), we have that if u ∈ S , then u = Au +g, with g ∈ S and u ∈ L2 , whence Au ∈ S . Thus, by the existence of a parametrix, u ∈ S . When u ∈ V , then u = Au and u ∈ A(S ), which proves the claim for μ = 0. When μ = 0, the assertion follows by observing that Im(A : S → S ) = Im(AΛ −μ : S → S ), and that Ker A∗ = Ker (Λ −μ A∗ ). This reduces matters to the case μ = 0 and proves (i). To prove (ii), we put, for ψ ∈ S and ϕ ∈ S , (ψ , ϕ )S ,S := ψ |ϕ¯ S ,S , so that
(Aψ , ϕ )S ,S = (ψ , A∗ ϕ )S ,S , ∀ψ ∈ S , ∀ϕ ∈ S .
We claim that Im(A : S → S ) = {ψ ∈ S ; (ψ , g)S ,S = 0, ∀g ∈ Ker A∗ } =: V . The inclusion ⊂ is trivial. To prove ⊃, take ψ ∈ V . Since ψ ∈ Bs0 for some s0 ∈ R, we get (recalling that the dual of Bs is B−s ) (ψ , g)S ,S = (ψ , g)Bs0 ,B−s0 . Suppose at first that μ = 0. Then A : Bs0 → Bs0 , A∗ : B−s0 → B−s0 , and, by construction, (Aψ , g)Bs0 ,B−s0 = (ψ , A∗ g)Bs0 ,B−s0 . Since A∗ has closed range, the Closed Range Theorem yields that if (ψ , g)Bs0 ,B−s0 = 0, ∀g ∈ Ker A∗ ,
44
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
then ψ ∈ Im(A : Bs0 → Bs0 ), whence ψ ∈ Im(A : S → S ). This proves the claim and also that Im(A : S → S ) is closed with codimension equal to dim KerA∗ , when μ = 0. When μ = 0, we reduce matters to the case μ = 0, by observing that Im(A : S → S ) = Im(AΛ −μ : S → S ), and that Ker A∗ = Ker (Λ −μ A∗ ).
This concludes the proof. We next have the following useful proposition.
Proposition 3.3.5. Let A ∈ OPS(mμ , g) be elliptic. The following assertions are equivalent: (i) (ii) (iii) (iv) (v)
Ker A = {0}; A∗ : S → S is onto; A∗ : S → S is onto; A∗ : Bμ +s → Bs is onto, for all s ∈ R; A∗ : Bμ +s → Bs is onto, for some s ∈ R.
Proof. We start by observing that (iv)⇒(iii), and that, in turn, by the existence of a parametrix, (iii)⇒(ii). Of course, (iv) implies (v). We now prove that (i) implies any of the (ii) to (v). Since dim(Bs /A∗ (Bμ +s )) = dim Ker A∗∗ = dim Ker A = 0, we immediately get that A∗ : Bμ +s → Bs is onto, for any given s ∈ R (since we already know that Im(A∗ : Bμ +s → Bs ) is closed). It follows that for any given u ∈ S ⊂ L2 there exists g ∈ Bμ such that A∗ g = u, whence, as Q∗ A∗ = I + R with R smoothing, S Q∗ u = Q∗ A∗ g = g + R g =⇒ g ∈ S . ∈S
A∗ (S )
=S. Thus That A∗ (S ) = S is trivial. In fact, u ∈ S implies u ∈ Bs0 for some s0 ∈ R, whence the existence of g ∈ Bμ +s0 ⊂ S (as we already know that (i)⇒(iv)) such that A∗ g = u. This concludes the proof that (i)⇒(ii), (iii), (iv) and (v). We finally prove that (v)⇒(i). If A∗ : Bμ +s → Bs is onto for some s, it follows that dim Ker A = codim A∗ (Bμ +s ) = 0. This concludes the proof.
Corollary 3.3.6. Let A ∈ OPS(mμ , g) be elliptic. If A = A∗ then the injectivity of A is equivalent to the surjectivity of A, which is in turn equivalent to the invertibility of A (on any of the spaces S , S , or Bs ). Recall that (see Helffer [17], or H¨ormander [29], or Shubin [67]) a linear continuous operator T : B1 → B2 , B1 and B2 Banach spaces, is a Fredholm operator if
3.3 Spectral Properties of Globally Elliptic Pseudodifferential Operators
45
• dim Ker T < +∞, • dim Coker T < +∞, where Coker T = B2 /T (B1 ) ,
so that one may define the index of T as ind T = dim Ker T − dim Coker T. Recall that in this situation T (B1 ) is then closed. From the preceding results one has the following Fredholm property of a globally elliptic psedudodifferential operator (see [17] or [67]). Theorem 3.3.7. Let A ∈ OPS(mμ , g) be elliptic. Then: • A : B μ +s → Bs is a Fredholm operator, for any given s ∈ R; • ind A is independent of s and is expressed by the formula
ind A = dim Ker A − dimKer A∗ . In particular, if A = A∗ , that is, if A is formally self-adjoint, then ind A = 0. Here is another important consequence of global ellipticity, and of the previous results. Theorem 3.3.8. Let A ∈ OPScl (mμ , g) be elliptic and suppose there exists s0 ∈ R such that A Bs0 : Bs0 (Rn ) −→ Bs0 −μ (Rn ) is an isomorphism (that is, it is invertible with linear and continuous inverse). Then A−1 : Bs (Rn ) −→ Bs+μ (Rn ) is continuous ∀s ∈ R, and (ABs )−1 is the restriction to Bs−μ (Rn ) of an operator in OPScl (m−μ , g). The same holds true in the case of N × N systems. Proof. We give a proof in the scalar case. From Lemma 3.3.1 and Lemma 3.3.3 we have that ABs : Bs (Rn ) −→ Bs−μ (Rn ) is an isomorphism for all s ∈ R. By the global ellipticity, we know that there is Q ∈ OPScl (m−μ , g) such that QA = I + R, AQ = I + R , R, R smoothing. By hypothesis, upon setting A0 := ABs0 , we have −1 s A0 A−1 0 = IBs0 −μ , A0 A0 = IB 0 .
Then
−1 QBs0 −μ = A−1 0 A0 Q Bs0 −μ = A0 (IBs0 −μ + R Bs0 −μ ),
whence it follows that −1 A−1 0 = Q Bs0 −μ −A0 R Bs0 −μ .
(3.32)
46
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
On the other hand, we also have −1 −1 −1 s QBs0 −μ = QBs0 −μ A0 A−1 0 = (IB 0 + R Bs0 )A0 = A0 + R Bs0 A0 , whence it follows, using (3.32), that −1 −1 A−1 0 = Q Bs0 −μ −R Bs0 A0 = Q Bs0 −μ −R Bs0 Q Bs0 −μ +R Bs0 A0 R Bs0 −μ .
(3.33)
But RQ is smoothing, as well as RA−1 0 R , for A−1
R
0 Bs0 (Rn ) −→ S (Rn ) S (Rn ) −→ S (Rn ) → Bs0 −μ (Rn ) −→
R
is continuous. Hence from (3.33) it follows that A−1 ∈ OPScl (m−μ , g) and this concludes the proof. Let us now suppose that μ > 0 (the case μ = 0 is trivial). Consider PA : D(PA ) ⊂ L2 (Rn ) −→ L2 (Rn ), D(PA ) = {u ∈ L2 ; PA u = Au ∈ L2 }, where Au is understood in the sense of distributions. The unbounded operator PA is called the maximal operator (associated with A). When A is an elliptic global pseudodifferential operator, it is straightforward to see that PA is a closed operator, that is (see also Chapter 2) ⎫ ⎪ D(PA ) u j → u, as j → +∞ ⎪ ⎬ L2
L2
PA u j → v, as j → +∞
⎪ ⎪ ⎭
=⇒ u ∈ D(PA ) and PA u = v.
S
In fact, from the hypothesis we have Au j → Au, so that Au = v ∈ L2 whence u ∈ D(PA ), which proves that PA is a closed operator. Moreover,we have the following lemma (see also point 7 of Proposition 3.2.26). Lemma 3.3.9. One has D(PA ) = Bμ . Proof. To see this, just note that we obviously have Bμ ⊂ D(PA ). If now u ∈ L2 with Au ∈ L2 , by the existence of a parametrix we get Bμ QAu = u + Ru =⇒ u ∈ Bμ , which gives D(PA ) ⊂ Bμ .
This immediately gives back the fact that D(H) (see (2.4)), where H is the har2 2 2 n monic oscillator pw 0,n (x, D) = (|D| + |x| )/2, is exactly the Hilbert space B (R ). w Hence, in the case of the NCHO Q(α ,β ) (x, D), for α , β > 0 and αβ > 1, we have
3.3 Spectral Properties of Globally Elliptic Pseudodifferential Operators
47
2 2 D(Qw (α ,β ) (x, D)) = B (R; C ).
The next proposition gives that when A = A∗ , i.e. when A is formally self-adjoint, then PA = PA∗ , i.e. PA is self-adjoint. Proposition 3.3.10. One has PA∗ = PA∗ . Hence if A is formally self-adjoint then PA is self-adjoint. Proof. Let g ∈ D(PA∗ ), that is g ∈ L2 and there exists h ∈ L2 such that (Au, g)0 = (u, h)0 , ∀u ∈ D(PA ) = Bμ .
(3.34)
Hence (3.34) holds in particular for all u ∈ S . Now, from t ¯ S ,S , ∀u ∈ S , ¯ ¯ S ,S = A∗ g|u S ,S = h|u
(Au, g)0 = g|Au
S ,S = Ag|u
S
we obtain A∗ g = h ∈ L2 . The existence of a parametrix then yields g ∈ Bμ . Thus D(PA∗ ) ⊂ Bμ , and PA∗ g = A∗ g when g ∈ D(PA∗ ). On the other hand, Bμ ⊂ D(PA∗ ). In fact, if g ∈ Bμ take u ∈ Bμ and sequences {u j } j , {g j } j ⊂ S such that Bμ
Bμ
u j −→ u, g j −→ g, as j → +∞. L2
Since A∗ ∈ OPS(mμ , g), we thus have that A∗ g j −→ A∗ g, as j → +∞, and (Au, g)0 = lim (Au j , g j )0 = lim (u j , A∗ g j )0 = (u, A∗ g)0 , j→+∞
j→+∞
whence g ∈ D(PA∗ ), and this concludes the proof.
One defines the minimal operator PA by PA : D(PA ) = S (Rn ) ⊂ L2 (Rn ) −→ L2 (Rn ), PA u = Au, ∀u ∈ D(PA ). By the same method used in the case of the maximal operator, one sees (exercise for the reader!) that PA is closable, i.e. that D(PA )
⎫ ⎪
u j −→ 0, as j → +∞ ⎪ ⎬
L2 PA u j −→ v,
L2
as j → +∞
Moreover, we have the following proposition.
⎪ ⎪ ⎭
=⇒ v = 0.
48
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
Proposition 3.3.11. One has (PA )∗ = PA∗ Proof. As before, D((PA )∗ ) ⊂ Bμ , and (PA )∗ g = A∗ g, for all g ∈ D((PA )∗ ). Take Bμ
now g ∈ Bμ and u ∈ S , and consider a sequence {g j } j ⊂ S such that g j −→ g, as j → +∞. Then, as before, (Au, g)0 = lim (Au, g j )0 = lim (u, A∗ g j )0 = (u, A∗ g)0 , j→+∞
j→+∞
whence g ∈ D((PA )∗ ) and (PA )∗ g = A∗ g.
Corollary 3.3.12. A = A∗ implies PA = PA∗ = (PA )∗ . We may now give the following theorem about the spectrum of a formally self-adjoint positive elliptic global pseudodifferential operator (or system) of order μ ≥ 1. Theorem 3.3.13. Let A ∈ OPScl (mμ , g), μ ≥ 1, be elliptic, with real symbol and positive principal symbol aμ . Then A : D(A) = Bμ ⊂ L2 −→ L2 , thought of as an unbounded operator, is self-adjoint, with a discrete spectrum, made of an increasing to +∞ and bounded from below sequence {λ j } j∈N of eigenvalues with finite multiplicities, −∞ < λ1 ≤ λ2 ≤ . . . −→ +∞, with repetitions according to the multiplicity. The corresponding eigenfunctions belong to S and, possibly after an orthonormalization procedure, form a basis of L2 . Proof. The fact that A is a self-adjoint unbounded operator with a discrete spectrum and Schwartz eigenfunctions follows from the arguments above (Bμ is compactly embedded in L2 , and if λ ∈ Spec(A) then Ker(A − λ ) ⊂ S with finite dimension). We have to prove that the spectrum is bounded from below. Since aμ > 0, using the calculus of global operators we may find Q ∈ OPScl (mμ /2 , g) such that A = Q∗ Q + R, R ∈ OPScl (mμ −2 , g).
(3.35)
Then (Au, u) = ||Qu||20 + (Ru, u), ∀u ∈ S . 1/2
Since Q is elliptic, with principal symbol q μ /2 = aμ , we have, by the existence of a parametrix M for Q, that for some c > 0 ||Qu||20 + ||u||20 ≥ c||u||2Bμ /2 , ∀u ∈ S .
(3.36)
˜ so that In fact, from MQ = I + R˜ (R˜ smoothing) it follows u = MQu − Ru, ˜ 20 ||Qu||20 + ||u||20, ∀u ∈ S , ||u||2Bμ /2 = ||Λ μ /2 u||20 = ||Λ μ /2 MQu − Λ μ /2 Ru||
3.3 Spectral Properties of Globally Elliptic Pseudodifferential Operators
49
since, M : L2 −→ Bμ /2 being continuous, the operator Λ μ /2 M has order zero and Λ μ /2 R˜ is smoothing, and hence they are both L2 → L2 bounded. This proves (3.36). Now, as the inverse (Λ μ /2 )−1 of Λ μ /2 belongs to S(m−μ /2 , g), we have |(Ru, u)| = (((Λ
μ −1 2
)−1 )∗ R(Λ
μ −1 2
)−1Λ
μ −1 2
u, Λ
μ −1 2
u)| ≤ C||u||2B(μ −1)/2 , ∀u ∈ S , (3.37)
for ((Λ (μ −1)/2 )−1 )∗ R(Λ (μ −1)/2 )−1 has order −1 and hence, in particular, is L2 → L2 bounded. On the other hand, for any given ε > 0 (to be picked later) there exists Cε > 0 such that (note that μ − 1 ≥ 0) ||u||2B(μ −1)/2 ≤ ε ||u||2Bμ /2 + Cε ||u||20 , ∀u ∈ S .
(3.38)
From (3.36), (3.37) and (3.38) we finally get (Au, u) ≥ (c − ε C)||u||2Bμ /2 + O(||u||20) ≥ −C0 ||u||20 , ∀u ∈ S , by choosing 0 < ε < c/C.
Exercise 3.3.14. Let μ ≥ 1. Prove inequality (3.38).
Corollary 3.3.15. In the hypotheses of Theorem 3.3.13 we have that Spec(A) does not depend on s ∈ R. More precisely, if we think of A as an unbounded operator As : D(As ) = Bμ +s ⊂ Bs −→ Bs , As u = Au, u ∈ D(As ), then it follows that A∗s = As = A∗ = A and, by Lemma 3.3.1, Spec(As ) = Spec(A0 ) =: Spec(A). Remark 3.3.16. Theorem 3.3.13 and Corollary 3.3.15 hold true also in the matrixvalued case. The only delicate point is to obtain (3.35) in the case of systems, by constructing the expansion of the symbol of Q. One can actually find Q = Q∗ ∈ OPScl (mμ /2 , g; MN ) such that A = Q2 + R, R ∈ OPS(m−∞ , g; MN ), for at the level of the principal symbol one has to find a matrix qμ /2 = q∗μ /2 > 0 such that q2μ /2 = aμ , X = 0, and at the level of lower degrees of homogeneity one has to solve j − th term of (q∗μ /2 q μ /2 ) = a μ −2 j , X = 0, ∀ j ∈ Z+ .
(3.39)
50
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
In particular, the subprincipal part is the solution of i qμ /2 qμ /2−2 + q μ /2−2qμ /2 = aμ −2 + {q μ /2, q μ /2 }, X = 0, 2
(3.40)
with q∗μ /2−2 = qμ /2−2. Lemma 3.3.17 below takes care of (3.39) and Lemma 3.3.19 below takes care of (3.40). Lemma 3.3.17. Let 0 < a μ = a∗μ ∈ C∞ (R2n \ {0}; MN ) be positively homogenous of degree μ , and let 0 < c1 < c2 be such that c1 |v|2CN ≤ a μ (ω )v, v CN ≤ c2 |v|2 , ∀v ∈ CN , ∀ω ∈ S2n−1 . Then there exists a unique 0 < qμ /2 = q∗μ /2 ∈ C∞ (R2n \ {0}; MN ) positively homogeneous of degree μ /2 such that qμ /2 (X)∗ qμ /2 (X) = a μ (X ) for all X = 0. Proof. We construct q μ /2 on S2n−1 , for then it suffices to put q μ /2 (X ) = |X |μ /2 qμ /2 (
X ), ∀X = 0. |X |
From the hypothesis we have that Spec(a μ (ω )) ⊂ [c1 , c2 ] ⊂ R+ , for all ω ∈ S2n−1 . Let hence γ ⊂ C be a closed, counter-clockwise oriented curve contained in Re ζ > 0 enclosing [c1 , c2 ] such that γ¯ = γ , and define q μ /2 (ω ) =
1 2π i
γ
ζ 1/2 (ζ − a μ (ω ))−1 d ζ ,
where ζ 1/2 is the branch of the square-root that is positive when ζ is positive. It is then clear that q μ /2 is smooth and that q∗μ /2 = qμ /2 . Let γ be another curve (closed, counter-clockwise oriented) contained in Re ζ > 0 which encloses γ , with γ ∩ γ = 0. / It follows from the Cauchy formula that qμ /2 (ω ) =
1 2π i
γ
ζ 1/2 (ζ − a μ (ω ))−1 d ζ ,
so that, using the resolvent identity (ζ − ζ )(ζ − a μ (ω ))−1 (ζ − a μ (ω ))−1 = (ζ − a μ (ω ))−1 − (ζ − a μ (ω ))−1 , we get
1 ζ 1/2 (ζ )1/2 (ζ − a μ (ω ))−1 (ζ − a μ (ω ))−1 d ζ d ζ (2π i)2 γ γ (ζ )1/2 1/2 1 1 = d ζ ζ (ζ − a μ (ω ))−1 d ζ 2π i γ 2π i γ ζ − ζ
qμ /2 (ω )2 =
3.3 Spectral Properties of Globally Elliptic Pseudodifferential Operators
51
ζ 1/2 1 1 (ζ )1/2 (ζ − a μ (ω ))−1 d ζ d ζ 2π i γ 2π i γ ζ − ζ 1 = ζ (ζ − a μ (ω ))−1 d ζ = aμ (ω ), 2π i γ
−
for 1 2π i since
ζ
∈
γ
γ
ζ 1/2 d ζ = 0, ζ −ζ
is “outside” γ . This concludes the proof.
Remark 3.3.18. When working with a symbol 0 < a = a∗ ∈ S(mμ , g; MM ) such that for 0 < c1 < c2 c1 |v|2CN ≤
a(X )v, v CN ≤ c2 |v|2CN , ∀v ∈ CN , ∀X ∈ R2n |X | ≥ c > 0, m(X )μ
one has the analogue of Lemma 3.3.17, by working with
a(X ) , |X | ≥ c. m(X )μ
Lemma 3.3.19. The equation i qμ /2 qμ /2−2 + q μ /2−2qμ /2 = aμ −2 + {q μ /2, q μ /2 }, X = 0, 2
(3.41)
has a unique smooth solution q μ /2−2 = q∗μ /2−2 defined for X = 0, positively homogeneous of degree μ /2 − 2. Proof. Call cμ −2 the right-hand side of (3.41). Notice that c∗μ −2 = cμ −2 . Again, we work on S2n−1 and then extend the result by homogeneity of degree μ /2 − 2 as before. Since by Lemma 3.3.17 Spec(qμ /2 (ω )) ⊂ [c1 , c2 ] ⊂ R+ , we have inf
ζ ∈Spec(qμ /2 (ω )) ζ ∈Spec(−qμ /2 (ω ))
|ζ − ζ | ≥ c0 > 0, ∀ω ∈ S2n−1 .
We therefore readily see that, with γ ⊂ {Re ζ > 0} a closed, counter-clockwise oriented curve encircling [c1 , c2 ] with γ = γ¯, q μ /2−2(ω ) =
1 2π i
γ
(ζ − q μ /2(ω ))−1 cμ −2 (ω )(ζ + q μ /2 (ω ))−1 d ζ .
Hence q μ /2−2 is smooth, with q μ /2−2(ω )∗ = qμ /2−2(ω ) for all ω ∈ S2n−1 , and defining qμ /2−2(X ) = |X|μ /2−2qμ /2−2 (X/|X|) for X = 0 proves the lemma.
52
3 The Weyl–H¨ormander Calculus
Remark 3.3.20. Given an operator A as in Theorem 3.3.13, it is useful to introduce a calculus with parameters tailored to A, for understanding, for example, the resolvent (A − λ )−1 . For X = (x, ξ ) ∈ R2n , λ ∈ C, consider (for reasons of homogeneity, as suggested by the example |x|2 + |ξ |2 − λ ) the weight mλ and the metric gλ defined by mλ (X ) := (1 + |X |2 + |λ |2/μ )1/2 , gλ ,X :=
|dX|2 . mλ (X)2
Then one sees that the metric gλ is admissible (with structural constants independent of λ ) and that mλ (X )±1 is a g-admissible function for all λ ∈ C (uniformly μ in λ ). One may then work with the class of symbol S(mλ , gλ ; λ ∈ Ω ) of functions a ∈ C∞ (R2n × Ω ) satisfying the following estimates: For any given α ∈ Z2n + there is Cα > 0 such that |∂Xα a(X , λ )| ≤ Cα mλ (X)μ −|α | , ∀X ∈ R2n , ∀λ ∈ Ω . In this framework, the classical symbols are defined to be those symbols a ∈ μ S(mλ , gλ ; λ ∈ Ω ), Ω now a cone of C, for which there exists {aμ −2 j } j≥0 ⊂ C∞ (R2n × Ω \ {(0, 0)}) such that a(X, λ ) ∼
∑ aμ −2 j (X, λ ),
j≥0
where
aμ −2 j (tX,t μ λ ) = t μ −2 j aμ −2 j (X, λ ), ∀t > 0, |X | + |λ | = 0.
In this case the excision function χ to be used is a function constructed by taking ω ∈ C∞ (Rt ), with 0 ≤ ω ≤ 1, ω ≡ 0 for |t| ≤ 1/2 and ω ≡ 1 for |t| ≥ 1, and then by putting χ (X , λ ) := ω (|X |2 + |λ |2/μ ). (See Helffer [17] and Shubin [67] for more on this.) Remark 3.3.21. It is interesting to note that, when μ = 2, in Theorem 3.3.13 above it is not necessary to assume that a2 > 0 for deducing the semi-boundedness from below of the operator A. It suffices that a2 ≥ 0. One has in fact the following result of H¨ormander’s, his celebrated Sharp-G˚arding inequality, which is valid even for infinite-size systems (see H¨ormander [29, Theorem 18.6.14]). Theorem 3.3.22 (H¨ormander’s Sharp-G˚arding inequality). Let g be admissible (hence with uncertainty Planck’s function h ≤ 1 everywhere). Suppose that 0 ≤ a = a∗ ∈ S(h−1, g; L (H, H)), where H is a Hilbert space. Then there exists C > 0 such that (aw (x, D)u, u) ≥ −C||u||20, ∀u ∈ S (Rn ; H). Since, in the case of the global metric, saying that a ∈ S(h−1 , g) is equivalent to saying that a ∈ S(m2 , g), we conclude from this theorem that any given “second
3.4 Notes
53
order” (in the sense of the growth measured by m) global system, even infinitedimensional, is semi-bounded from below in L2 . The “fourth order” case (that is, the case S(h−2, g) = S(m4 , g)) for nonnegative global symbols is completely different, and is the celebrated Fefferman-Phong inequality. It is known that in general this inequality does not hold for systems (see the references to Brummelhuis, H¨ormander and Parmeggiani in [53]). However, we have recently proved that it is indeed valid for large classes of systems of PDEs (see Parmeggiani [53, 54, 56, 57]).
3.4 Notes For the Weyl-H¨ormander calculus, the reader is addressed to the original paper by H¨ormander [27] and H¨ormander’s book [29]. For the global calculus, the reader is addressed to Helffer’s book [17] and to Shubin’s book [67]. m The L2 -continuity theorem was first proved in the class S1/2,1/2 by Calder´on and Vaillancourt and then generalized by many people (Beals and Fefferman, Cotlar and Stein, Unterberger and others; see the references in H¨ormander [27] or [29]) to more general pseudodifferential calculi.
Chapter 4
The Spectral Counting Function N(λ ) and the Behavior of the Eigenvalues: Part 1
To understand the eigenvalues of an elliptic global operator, a very useful, basic and general tool is the Minimax Principle. After recalling it, we shall use the Minimax Principle to study the first properties of the spectral counting function, and of the behavior of the large eigenvalues, of an elliptic global operator. Remark that everything we say in this section holds also for matrix-valued operators.
4.1 The Minimax Principle In the first place, it is very useful to recall the Minimax Principle in the abstract setting. Theorem 4.1.1 (Minimax Principle). Let A : D(A) ⊂ H −→ H be an unbounded, densely defined and closed self-adjoint operator in the (infinite-dimensional) Hilbert space H, semi-bounded from below (that is, A ≥ −CI on D(A) for some constant C > 0), and with compact resolvent. Then, with Spec(A) given by the sequence −∞ < λ1 ≤ λ2 ≤ . . . → +∞, where the eigenvalues are repeated according to multiplicity, for the j-th eigenvalue one has ⎤ ⎡
λj =
sup
u1 ,...,u j−1 lin.ind.
⎢ ⎣
inf
u∈Span{u1 ,...,u j−1 ||u||=1
}⊥ ∩D(A)
⎥ (Au, u)⎦ ,
(4.1)
or, in other words, ⎤
⎡
λj =
sup
codimV = j−1 V closed
⎢ ⎣
inf
⎥ (Au, u)⎦ .
u∈V ∩D(A) ||u||=1
Proof. (We follow Dimassi-Sj¨ostrand’s book [7].) The first step is to see that D(A) ∩ E is always dense in E, where E = Span{u1 , . . . , u j−1 }⊥ and where A. Parmeggiani, Spectral Theory of Non-Commutative Harmonic Oscillators: An Introduction, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1992, c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2010 DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-11922-4 4,
55
56
4 The Spectral Counting Function N(λ ) and the Behavior of the Eigenvalues: Part 1
u1 , . . . , u j−1 are linearly independent. Let v1 , . . . , v j−1 ∈ D(A) be close to u1 , . . . , u j−1 in norm. Then the space F := Span{v1 , . . . , v j−1 } ⊂ D(A) has dimension j − 1 and is transversal to E, whence it follows that there exists a unique bounded projection πE : H −→ H with Im πE = E, Ker πE = F. Then u = u +πE (u) =⇒ πE (u) = u − u ∈ D(A). D(A) u = u + ∈F
∈E
∈D(A)
Thus πE D(A) : D(A) −→ D(A), and we also have that πE (D(A)) = D(A)∩E is dense in E. The next step is to prove that
Λ j (u1 , . . . , u j−1 ) :=
inf
(Au, u) ≤ λ j .
u∈E∩D(A) ||u||=1
(4.2)
Let in fact e1 , . . . , e j ∈ D(A) be an orthonormal (ON) system of eigenfunctions of A corresponding to the eigenvalues λ1 ≤ . . . ≤ λ j . Then Span{e1 , . . . , e j } ∩ E = {0} (notice that the first space has dimension j and the second one has codimension j − 1). We then let u := ∑1j ck ek be a normalized vector in the intersection, so that j ∑1 |ck |2 = 1. It is clear that u ∈ D(A) ∩ E, and that (Au, u) =
j
j
k=1
k=1
∑ λk |ck |2 ≤ λ j ∑ |ck |2 = λ j ,
from which we deduce (4.2). We finally prove (4.1). We have just seen that the right-hand side is ≤ λ j . But if we take uk = ek , 1 ≤ k ≤ j − 1, and consider the sequence {e j } j≥1 ⊂ D(A) of the ON eigenvectors of A, we may then take u ∈ Span{e1 , . . . , e j−1 }⊥ ∩ D(A) of the form u = ∑k≥ j ck ek with
∑ |λk ck |2 < +∞,
and
k≥ j
so that (Au, u) =
k≥ j
∑ λ j |ck |2 ≥ λ j ∑ |ck |2 = λ j ,
k≥ j
which yields inf
u∈Span{e1 ,...,e j−1 }⊥ ∩D(A) ||u||=1
This concludes the proof.
∑ |ck |2 = 1,
k≥ j
(Au, u) = λ j .
4.1 The Minimax Principle
57
Corollary 4.1.2. Formula (4.1) is equivalent to ⎤
⎡
λj =
sup
u1 ,...,u j−1
⎢ ⎣
inf
⎥ (Au, u)⎦ ,
u∈Span{u1 ,...,u j−1 }⊥ ∩D(A) ||u||=1
(4.3)
where it is important to notice that the u1 , . . . , u j−1 may be taken not necessarily linearly independent. Proof. Denote by λ j the right-hand side of (4.3). Then it is clear that λ j ≤ λ j . Suppose that λ j > λ j , that is, λ j is obtained by using vectors u1 , . . . , u j−1 which are not linearly independent. Hence for any given ε > 0 there exist uε1 , . . . , uεj−1 with dim Span{uε1 , . . . , uεj−1 } ≤ j − 2, such that (with the notation of (4.2), where E = Span{uε1 , . . . , uεj−1 }⊥ )
λ j − ε < Λ j (uε1 , . . . , uεj−1 ) ≤ λ j−1 ≤ λ j , by Theorem 4.1.1, whence a contradiction.
Remark 4.1.3. Formula (4.3) also follows by observing that the suprema of the Λ j (u1 , . . . , u j−1 ) in (4.1) and (4.3) are equal, because j − 1 vectors can be always ε -approximated by j − 1 linearly independent vectors (in other words, systems of j − 1 vectors that are linearly independent are always dense in systems of j − 1 vectors). To prove this claim, it suffices to show that given j vectors u1 , . . . , u j and given any ε > 0 we may always find vectors v1 , . . . , v j that are linearly independent and such that ||vk − uk || < ε , 1 ≤ k ≤ j. To see this we first consider Span{u1 , . . . , u j } =: V = Span{ui1 , . . . , ui }, where I := {i1 , . . . , i } ⊂ {1, . . . , j} =: J and ui1 , . . . , ui are linearly independent. We order the elements in J \I = I (that we suppose non-empty, for otherwise there is nothing to prove) in increasing order, so that I = {i1 , . . . , ij− }, with i1 < . . . < ij− . Recall that uk ∈ V for all k ∈ I . Consider then V ⊥ , so that H = V ⊕V ⊥ , with orthogonal sum. Let {ek }k≥1 ⊂ V ⊥ be an ON basis of V ⊥ . Define
ε vi = ui + ek , k = 1, . . . , j − , k k j and vik = uik , 1 ≤ k ≤ . It is then clear that the v1 , . . . , v j are now linearly independent and that j
∑ ||ui − vi|| < ε .
i=1
This gives the claim of the remark.
58
4 The Spectral Counting Function N(λ ) and the Behavior of the Eigenvalues: Part 1
We conclude this section with the following important application (called “the Rayleigh-Ritz technique”) of Corollary 4.1.2 (see Reed-Simon [61, p. 82]). Theorem 4.1.4. Let A be as in Theorem 4.1.1. Let V ⊂ D(A) be a j-dimensional subspace, and let ΠV : H −→ H be the orthogonal projection of H onto V . Write AV := ΠV AΠV , and denote by λˆ 1 ≤ . . . ≤ λˆ j the eigenvalues of the j × j matrix AV V . Then λk ≤ λˆ k , 1 ≤ k ≤ j. Proof. By the Minimax Principle (in the form (4.3)), AV V has eigenvalues given by ⎤
⎡
λˆ k =
sup
u1 ,...,uk−1 ∈V
⎢ ⎣
inf
u∈V ∩Span{u1 ,...,uk−1 }⊥ ||u||=1
⎥ (Au, u)⎦ ⎤
⎡ =
sup
u1 ,...,uk−1 ∈H
⎢ ⎣
inf
u∈V ∩Span{ΠV (u1 ),...,ΠV (uk−1 )}⊥ ||u||=1
⎥ (Au, u)⎦
(using the fact that for u ∈ V one has (u, ΠV (u )) = (u, u )) ⎤ ⎡ =
sup
u1 ,...,uk−1 ∈H
⎡ ≥
sup
u1 ,...,uk−1 ∈H
⎢ ⎣
⎢ ⎣
inf
u∈V ∩Span{u1 ,...,uk−1 }⊥ ||u||=1
inf
u∈D(A)∩Span{u1 ,...,uk−1 }⊥ ||u||=1
⎥ (Au, u)⎦ ⎤ ⎥ (Au, u)⎦ = λk ,
which concludes the proof.
4.2 The Spectral Counting Function Fix an elliptic A ∈ OPScl (mμ , g) (possibly matrix-valued), μ ≥ 1, with real-valued symbol and principal symbol aμ > 0. Then we know that A = A∗ . It is no restriction, by Theorem 3.3.13 and Remark 3.3.16, to assume that A > 0, for it suffices to consider A + c for a suitable constant c ∈ R. Then the spectrum Spec(A) of A is made by a sequence of eigenvalues 0 < λ1 ≤ λ2 ≤ . . . −→ +∞, where the eigenvalues are repeated according to their multiplicities. Remark 4.2.1. Notice that if A ∈ OPScl (mμ , g), μ > 0, and c is a constant, then A + c ∈ OPS(mμ , g), and it is classical only when μ ∈ 2N. However, since c times
4.2 The Spectral Counting Function
59
the identity operator commutes with everything and is continuous on any desired space and, in case A = A∗ has a discrete spectrum, adding c amounts to shifting each eigenvalue of A by the same constant c, this won’t be causing any problems throughout these notes, and we shall keep thinking of A + c as a classical operator. Let λ ∈ [0, +∞) =: R+ (recall also that R+ = (0, +∞)), and define the spectral counting functions (associated with A) N(λ ) = { j ∈ N; λ j < λ }, and N0 (λ ) = { j ∈ N; λ j ≤ λ }.
(4.4)
When comparing two elliptic global pseudodifferential operators A and B, we shall at times write NA and NB to denote the respective counting functions N(λ ). We shall study in this chapter the first basic properties of the function N. The function N0 is also introduced (some authors prefer using it in place of N). As far as the asymptotic properties of N and N0 are concerned, there is no difference, and it is just a matter of taste. We next list a few immediate properties of the spectral counting functions: • N(λ ) and N0 (λ ) are non-decreasing functions, with limit +∞ at +∞; • One has
N(λ j ) < N0 (λ j ), ∀λ j ∈ Spec(A),
and
N(λ ) = N0 (λ ), ∀λ ∈ Spec(A);
• N(λ j ) ≤ j, for all λ j ∈ Spec(A).
Notice that this might not be true for N0 (λ ). One may just think of a case in which λ j = λ j+1 = . . . = λ j+k j , for some j and k j , so as to have N0 (λ j ) = j + k j .
The next proposition (see Helffer [17]) shows how a-priori inequalities are used to compare the behavior of eigenvalues related to different elliptic global pseudodifferential operators (this also holds for elliptic operators on a compact boundaryless manifold). This will then be used (see Theorem 4.3.4, Theorem 4.4.1, and Corollary 4.4.3 below) to obtain a first information on the behavior of the eigenvalues λ j (A) as j → +∞ of an elliptic global pseudodifferential operator, by using the harmonic oscillator as a reference operator B. Proposition 4.2.2. Suppose that A, B : D ⊂ L2 (Rn ; CN ) −→ L2 (Rn ; CN ) be positive, self-adjoint operators with compact resolvent, with same domain D such that S (Rn ; CN ) ⊂ D. Suppose there exist C1 ,C2 > 0 with ||Au||2 ≤ C1 ||Bu||2 + ||u||2 , ∀u ∈ S (Rn ; CN ), ||Bu||2 ≤ C2 ||Au||2 + ||u||2 , ∀u ∈ S (Rn ; CN ).
4 The Spectral Counting Function N(λ ) and the Behavior of the Eigenvalues: Part 1
60
Then
λ j (A) ≈ λ j (B), as j → +∞,
that is, one can find c1 , c2 > 0 and j0 ∈ N such that c1 λ j (A) ≤ λ j (B) ≤ c2 λ j (A), ∀ j ≥ j0 . Hence, by possibly changing the constants, we may always suppose that c1 λ j (A) ≤ λ j (B) ≤ c2 λ j (A), ∀ j ∈ N. Proof. One rewrites the above inequalities as (A2 u, u) ≤ C1 (B2 + I)u, u , (B2 u, u) ≤ C2 (A2 + I)u, u , ∀u ∈ S (Rn ; CN ), whence from the Minimax Principle (see (4.1))
λ j (A)2 ≤ C1 (λ j (B)2 + 1), and λ j (B)2 ≤ C2 (λ j (A)2 + 1), for all j ∈ N. Since λ j (A), λ j (B) → +∞ as j → +∞, there exists j0 ∈ N such that λ j (A), λ j (B) ≥ 1 for all j ≥ j0 , whence the desired conclusion. To see how this preliminary information influences the behavior of the function N(λ ) we show the following corollary. Corollary 4.2.3. Let A, B be as in Proposition 4.2.2. Suppose there exist C1 ,C2 > 0 such that C1 λ j (A) ≤ λ j (B) ≤ C2 λ j (A), ∀ j ∈ N. (4.5) Then, upon writing NA (resp. NB ) for the counting-fuction associated with A (resp. B), we have NA (C2−1 λ ) ≤ NB (λ ) ≤ NA (C1−1 λ ), ∀λ ∈ [0, +∞).
(4.6)
Proof. Let τ ≥ 0 and let JA (τ ) := { j ∈ N; λ j (A) < τ }, JB (τ ) := { j ∈ N; λ j (B) < τ }. Then from (4.5) we have that JA (τ ) ⊂ JB (C2 τ ) ⊂ JA (
C2 τ ), C1
whence NA (τ ) ≤ NB (C2 τ ) ≤ NA ( for all τ ≥ 0. Setting τ = λ /C2 gives (4.6).
C2 τ ), C1
4.3 The Spectral Counting Function of the (Scalar) Harmonic Oscillator
61
Remark 4.2.4. From Corollary 4.2.3 we have that if we know that (say) NA (λ ) = cA λ m (1 + o(1)) as λ → +∞, then we may conclude only that NB (λ ) ≈ λ m as λ → +∞, that is, there are constants C1 ,C2 , λ0 > 0 such that C1 λ m ≤ NB (λ ) ≤ C2 λ m , ∀λ ≥ λ0 . We now prepare the ground for exploiting Proposition 4.2.2 in the case in which A is an elliptic global pseudodifferential system (with positive-definite principal symbol) in Rn and B = pw 0 (x, D)I, where I is the 2 × 2, or N × N, identity matrix, and where p0 (x, ξ ) = (|x|2 + |ξ |2 )/2 (for simplicity, we shall drop the dependence on n in the notation for the harmonic oscillator). In particular, the results of the next section apply to the case in which A is our elliptic NCHO Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) (for α , β > 0, αβ > 1). In order to deduce the growth-rate of the eigenvalues λ j (A) of A, we have to understand NB (λ ) for B and deduce the growth of the eigenvalues λ j (B) as jpower . This is done in the next section.
4.3 The Spectral Counting Function of the (Scalar) Harmonic Oscillator We have the following well-known lemmas. Lemma 4.3.1. Let p(x, ξ ) = |x|2 + |ξ |2 . For the spectral counting function N(λ ) associated with pw (x, D) we have N(λ ) ∼ (2π )−n
p(x,ξ )≤1
dxd ξ λ n , λ → +∞.
Proof. It is well-known that the eigenvalues of pw (x, D) are
λ=
n
n
j=1
j=1
∑ (2α j + 1) = n + 2 ∑ α j ,
α = (α1 , . . . , αn ) ∈ Zn+ .
Hence, if μ = α1 + . . . + αn (= |α |), one has λ = n + 2 μ . Now, {α ∈ Zn+ ; |α | < μ + 1} = {α ∈ Zn+ ; |α | ≤ μ } =
μ
∑ {α ∈
j=0
=
Zn+ ; |α |
= j} =
μ
∑
j=0
μ +n j+n−1 = n n−1
(μ + n)(μ + n − 1) . . .(μ + 1) μ n ∼ , n! n!
(4.7)
62
4 The Spectral Counting Function N(λ ) and the Behavior of the Eigenvalues: Part 1
as μ → +∞, so that, for λ = n + 2 + 2 μ , N(n + 2 + 2 μ ) ∼
μn , as μ → +∞. n!
On the other hand, (2π )−n
p(x,ξ )≤λ
dxd ξ = λ n (2π )−n
|x|2 +|ξ |2 ≤1
dxd ξ =
λn , 2n n!
and when λ = n + 2 + 2 μ ,
λn μn ∼ , as μ → +∞, n 2 n! n!
which proves the claim. For the sake of completeness we prove formula (4.7), that is, we show that
j+n = {α ∈ Zn+ ; |α | ≤ j}. n
(4.8)
Proof (of (4.8)). We proceed by induction on the dimension n. The case n = 1 is obviously true. Now, we have {α ∈ Zn+ ; |α | ≤ j} =
j
∑ {α ∈ Zn+ ; |α | = k},
k=0
and, writing α = (α , αn ) ∈ Zn−1 + × Z+ , {α ∈ Zn+ ; |α | = k} =
k
∑
αn =0
{α ∈ Zn−1 + ; |α | = k − αn }
= {α ∈ Zn−1 + ; |α | ≤ k} =
by the induction hypothesis. We must thus prove that k+n−1 j+n ∑ n−1 = n . k=0 j
But this follows from the formula n n−1 n−1 = + , k k k−1
k+n−1 , n−1
4.3 The Spectral Counting Function of the (Scalar) Harmonic Oscillator
for (with the convention that
n−1 n
63
= 0)
j k+n−1 k+n k+n−1 j+n n−1 − = − , ∑ n−1 = ∑ n n n n k=0 k=0 j
which proves the claim.
We may hence prove the following lemma, which gives the behavior of the eigenvalues of pw 0 (x, D) as j → +∞. Note that having the asymptotic behavior of N(λ ) given by Lemma 4.3.1 would suffice in case the eigenvalues of pw 0 (x, D) were all simple, for N(λ j+1 ) = j then, but this is not the case for pw (x, D) when n ≥ 2. 0 Note that a harmonic oscillator with simple eigenvalues is given, for example, by the Weyl-quantization of n
∑ μ j (x2j + ξ j2),
where μ1 , . . . , μn > 0 are Q-independent.
j=1
Lemma 4.3.2. For the eigenvalues λ j (repeated according to the multiplicity) of pw 0 (x, D) we have
λ j ≈ j1/n , as j → +∞.
(4.9)
Proof. The case n = 1 is trivial, for the eigenvalues of pw 0 (x, D) are then all simple and, by Lemma 4.3.1, we have j = N(λ j+1 ) ≈ λ j , as j → +∞, where λ j = j − 1/2, j ≥ 1. Therefore we consider the case n > 1. Let mk+1 be the multiplicity of the eigenvalues λ j = |α | + n/2, when α ∈ Zn+ and |α | = k. Then mk+1 =
k+n−1 , n−1
and, for k ≥ 0, k k k+n +n−1 = ∑ m+1 = ∑ =: Mk+1 . n n−1 =0 =0 We now consider the intervals of integers Ik := N ∩ (Mk , Mk+1 ], k ≥ 1, and write N = {M1 } ∪
k≥1
Ik , M1 = m1 = 1,
4 The Spectral Counting Function N(λ ) and the Behavior of the Eigenvalues: Part 1
64
the union being disjoint. Since λ1 ≤ λ2 ≤ . . . are the eigenvalues of pw 0 (x, D), we have that for every j > 1 there exists k = k j ∈ N such that j ∈ Ik and λ j = λMk+1 , and that
N(λMk+1 ) = Mk ≈ (λMk+1 )n , as k → +∞,
by Lemma 4.3.1. As Mk =
k
k−1
k−1
=1
=0
=0
∑ m = ∑ m+1 = ∑
+n−1 k−1+n = , n−1 n
we have that
(k − 1)n kn ∼ , k → +∞. n! n! Since Mk < j ≤ Mk+1 , we get that j → +∞ iff k → +∞ and Mk ∼
(k − 1)n j kn , as j → +∞, whence j ≈ kn and finally
λ j = λMk+1 ≈ k ≈ j1/n , as j → +∞.
This concludes the proof of the lemma.
Remark 4.3.3. The above argument applies also in the case of pw 0 (x, D)IN . In this case we have an increase of multiplicity due to the presence of the N × N identity matrix IN . μ /2
Theorem 4.3.4. Let μ > 0, and let P0
μ /2
pw 0 (x, D). By Theorem 5.5.1 below, P0
be the μ /2-functional power of P0 = μ /2
∈ OPScl (mμ , g), that is P0
is an elliptic μ /2
classical global pseudodifferential operator of order μ . Denoting by {λ j (P0 )} j≥1 μ /2 the non-decreasing sequence of the eigenvalues of P0 , repeated according to multiplicity, we have μ /2 λ j (P0 ) ≈ j μ /2n , as j → +∞. It is important to note the power of j: it is the order of the operator divided by twice the dimension. Proof. Since
μ /2 2/ μ
λ j (P0
)
= λ j , j ∈ N,
the proof follows immediately from (4.9).
Remark 4.3.5. Of course, when μ ∈ 2N Theorem 4.3.4 holds without making use of Theorem 5.5.1.
4.4 Consequences on the Spectral Counting Function of an Elliptic Global ψ do
65
4.4 Consequences on the Spectral Counting Function of an Elliptic Global ψ do Using Proposition 4.2.2 we may now obtain the following behavior of the large eigenvalues of an elliptic global pseudodifferential operator, and in particular of our NCHO Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) when α , β > 0 and αβ > 1. The first result we state is the following. Theorem 4.4.1. Let 0 < A = A∗ ∈ OPScl (mμ , g; MN ), μ > 0, be an elliptic, selfadjoint and positive global pseudodifferential operator. Then, upon denoting by λ j (A), j ≥ 1, the sequence of the repeated eigenvalues of A we have
λ j (A) ≈ j μ /2n , as j → +∞. Proof. We start by remarking that, by virtue of the results of Section 3.3, A has a discrete spectrum, made of eigenvalues with finite multiplicities which, due to the positivity of A, diverge to +∞. μ /2 Now, by Theorem 5.5.1 below, the μ /2-power P0 of P0 = pw 0 (x, D) is an elliptic μ /2
classical global pseudodifferential operator of order μ . Put, for short, B = P0 IN , where IN is the N × N identity matrix. Let therefore QA and QB be two-sided parametrices (of order −μ ) for A and B, respectively, so that Q A A = I + R A , QB B = I + R B , where RA and RB are smoothing operators. Then, for all u ∈ S (Rn ; CN ), Au = A(QB B − RB)u = (AQB )Bu − ARBu, Bu = B(QA A − RA)u = (BQA )Au − BRAu, so that, by the
L2 -boundedness of
AQB , ARB , BQA and of BRA , we get
||Au||20 ||Bu||20 + ||u||20, ∀u ∈ S (Rn ; CN ), and, analogously, ||Bu||20 ||Au||20 + ||u||20, ∀u ∈ S (Rn ; CN ). The result therefore follows from Proposition 4.2.2 and Theorem 4.3.4.
Remark 4.4.2. Of course, when μ ∈ 2N Theorem 4.4.1 holds without making use of Theorem 5.5.1. In particular, for our elliptic NCHO Qw (α ,β ) (x, D), α , β > 0 and αβ > 1, we therefore have the following result.
66
4 The Spectral Counting Function N(λ ) and the Behavior of the Eigenvalues: Part 1
Corollary 4.4.3. Let A = Qw (α ,β ) (x, D), with α , β > 0 and αβ > 1. Hence A is a positive elliptic system of GPDOs of order two, to which we may apply our results. Then λ j (A) ≈ j, as j → +∞. Recall that, given a self-adjoint operator A > 0 with a discrete spectrum {λ j } j≥1 , the spectral zeta function associated with A is by definition the series
ζA (s) =
1
∑ λs,
j≥1
s ∈ C with Re s sufficiently large.
(4.10)
j
From Theorem 4.4.1 and Corollary 4.4.3 we get the following immediate information about a first region of convergence of the spectral zeta functions ζA and ζQ associated with an elliptic A and an elliptic Qw (α ,β ) (x, D), respectively. We have in fact the following corollary. Corollary 4.4.4. The spectral zeta function ζA is holomorphic for Re s > 2n/μ . In particular, for α , β > 0 and αβ > 1 the spectral zeta function ζQ is holomorphic for Re s > 1. Proof. The proof follows immediately from the behaviors
λ j (A) ≈ j μ /2n , and λ j (Q) ≈ j, as j → +∞, and the fact that the harmonic series ∑ j≥1 j−s converges for Re s > 1.
Remark 4.4.5. It is well-known that for the spectral zeta function of the harmonic oscillator H = pw 0 (x, D) (n = 1) one has (exercise for the reader)
ζH (s) =
1
∑ ( j + 1/2)s = (2s − 1)ζ (s),
(4.11)
j≥0
where ζ (s) is the Riemann zeta function.
Chapter 5
The Heat-Semigroup, Functional Calculus and Kernels
We shall review in this chapter some elementary properties of the heat-semigroup associated with a globally elliptic operator, along with its functional calculus and some properties of the Schwartz kernels involved that give rise to the definition of the “trace” of the operator.
5.1 Elementary Properties of the Heat-Semigroup Let a ∈ Scl (mμ , g; MN ) be globally elliptic with μ ∈ N and principal symbol a μ = a∗μ > 0 (as an Hermitian matrix), and suppose that A∗ = A = aw (x, D) be positive on S (Rn ; CN ), that is there exists c > 0 such that (Au, u) ≥ c||u||20, ∀u ∈ S (Rn ; CN ). Let s ∈ R and let also As : D(As ) = Bs+μ (Rn ; CN ) ⊂ Bs (Rn ; CN ) −→ Bs (Rn ; CN ), As := ABs , be a realization of A as an unbounded operator in Bs (Rn ; CN ). Then we know that As = A∗s , Spec(As ) = Spec(A0 ) =: Spec(A), that the eigenfunctions of As are the eigenfunctions of A, and that they belong to S , by the elliptic regularity (i.e., the existence of the parametrix). We have that the resolvent Rs (λ ) = (As − λ )−1 : Bs (Rn ; CN ) −→ Bs (Rn ; CN ) is defined, bounded and holomorphic for all λ ∈ C \ Spec(A). It is important to note that s ≤ s =⇒ Rs (λ )Bs = Rs (λ ), ∀λ ∈ C \ Spec(A), (5.1)
for if λ ∈ Spec(A), then (As − λ )u = f ∈ Bs is solvable in Bs +μ and, by the elliptic regularity, for the solution u we have u ∈ Bs+μ ⊂ Bs +μ .
A. Parmeggiani, Spectral Theory of Non-Commutative Harmonic Oscillators: An Introduction, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1992, c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2010 DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-11922-4 5,
67
68
5 The Heat-Semigroup, Functional Calculus and Kernels
By virtue of (5.1), since
Bs = S and
s∈R
Bs = S , we may hence define, as a
s∈R
continuous map, R(λ ) : S (Rn ; CN ) −→ S (Rn ; CN ), R(λ )Bs := Rs (λ ), ∀λ ∈ C\ Spec(A). (5.2) Note that R(λ ) : S (Rn ; CN ) −→ S (Rn ; CN ) is also continuous. We may then simply write R(λ ) for the resolvent of A, regardless the domain used to realize A as an unbounded operator. It is hence well-known that for any given s ∈ R there is Cs > 0 such that Cs ||R(λ )||Bs →Bs ≤ . dist(λ , Spec(A)) Let δA := min Spec(A). We may therefore choose δ ∈ (0, δA ) such that Dδ := {λ ∈ C; Re λ ≤ δ } ∪ {λ = ρ eiφ ; ρ ≥
δ π 7 , φ ∈ [ , π ]} ⊂ C \ Spec(A). 2 4 4
Hence there exists Cs > 0 such that
λ ∈ Dδ =⇒ ||R(λ )||Bs →Bs ≤
Cs . 1 + |λ |
Let ∂ Dδ be oriented in such a way that Dδ is kept to the right-hand side. Then (see Kato’s book [35]) we may define ⎧ 1 ⎪ e−λ t R(λ )d λ , t > 0, ⎨ e−tA = 2π i ∂ Dδ ⎪ ⎩ −tA = I. e t=0
Hence, for any fixed s ∈ R, {e−tA }t≥0 is a strongly continuous semigroup in Bs with generator −As . Furthermore, for every δ ∈ (0, δA ), we have sup eδ t ||e−tA ||Bs →Bs < +∞. t≥1
Using the same arguments as in Chazarain-Piriou [6], one can prove the following lemma. (Recall that R+ = [0, +∞).) Lemma 5.1.1. Let f ∈ Bs (Rn ; CN ). Put F(t) = e−tA f . Then for every p, j ∈ Z+ , t p(
d j ) F ∈ C0 (R+ ; Bs+(p− j)μ (Rn ; CN )), dt
and sup ||t p ( t≥0
d j ) F||Bs+(p− j)μ ≤ C p, j || f ||Bs . dt
5.2 Direct Definition of Tr e−tA
69
From the lemma we may therefore think of e−tA as a map e−tA : S (Rn ; CN ) −→ S (R+ ; S (Rn ; CN )), and as a map e−tA : S (Rn ; CN ) −→ S (R+ ; S (Rn ; CN )). We also have the following fact about the heat-equation associated with −A. Lemma 5.1.2. For any given f ∈ S (Rn ; CN ) and g ∈ S (R+ ; S (Rn ; CN )), there exists a unique u(t) = u ∈ S (R+ ; S (Rn ; CN )) such that ⎧ du ⎪ ⎪ + Au(t) = g(t), t > 0, ⎨ dt ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ u(0) = f , with u(t) = e−tA f +
t 0
e−(t−t )A g(t )dt .
Moreover, f ∈ S (Rn ; CN ), g ∈ S (R+ ; S (Rn ; CN )) =⇒ u ∈ S (R+ ; S (Rn ; CN )).
5.2 Direct Definition of Tr e−tA In this section we give a direct proof that the kernel e−tA (x, y), t > 0, of e−tA (the heat-kernel of A) is a rapidly decreasing function of (x, y), and that Tr e−tA =
∑ e−t λ j ,
t > 0.
j≥1
Let {ϕ j } ⊂ S (Rn ; CN ) be an ON systems of L2 (Rn ; CN ) made of eigenfunctions of A. To start with, note that if u =
∞
∞
j=1
j=1
∑ u j ϕ j ∈ L2 , i.e. ∑ |u j |2 < +∞, then
e−tA u =
∞
∑ e−t λ j (u, ϕ j )ϕ j ,
j=1
so that, e−tA : S −→ S → S being continuous (and recalling that (v∗ ⊗ w)ζ = v∗ (ζ )w), we have by the Schwartz-kernel Theorem that e−tA (x, y) =
∑ e−t λ j ϕ j (y)∗ ⊗ ϕ j (x) ∈ S ,
j≥1
t > 0.
70
5 The Heat-Semigroup, Functional Calculus and Kernels
If we proceed formally, we have Tr e−tA =
Rn
Tr e−tA (x, x)dx =
∑ e−t λ j
j≥1
Rn
|ϕ j (x)|2CN dx =
∑ e−t λ j ,
j≥1
=1
where Tr denotes the matrix-trace. We next show that the formal procedure is actually correct. Since Aϕ j = λ j ϕ j , we get Ar ϕ j = λ jr ϕ j , for all r ∈ N, and ||ϕ j ||2Bμ r ||ϕ j ||20 + ||Ar ϕ j ||20 = (1 + λ j2r )||ϕ j ||20 .
(5.3)
(The reader may prove (5.3) as an exercise by using a parametrix of A, or else look at Lemma 5.3.1 below.) From (5.3) and (3.31) we thus get that given any S -seminorm | · | p,q, p, q ∈ Z+ , there exists r so large that |ϕ j | p,q ≤ C pq (1 + λ j2r )||ϕ j ||20 = C pq (1 + λ j2r ).
(5.4)
We now notice that (t λ j )k e−t λ j ≤ Ce−t λ j /2 , t > 0,
(5.5)
where C = (2k/e)k . Indeed, it is easy to see that
τ a e− τ ≤
a a e
, ∀τ , a > 0,
(5.6)
so that
τ a e−τ = τ a e−τ /2 e−τ /2 =
τ a 2
e−τ /2 2a e−τ /2 ≤
a a e
2a e−τ /2 =
2a a e
e−τ /2 .
Hence we obtain from (5.4) and (5.5), recalling that λ j +∞ as j → +∞, |e−tA (·, ·)| p,q ≤ Cpqt −k ∑ e−t λ j /2 < +∞, ∀t > 0, j≥1
for we already know that λ j ≈ j μ /2n as j → +∞. Hence, t → e−tA (·, ·) ∈ C∞ (R+ ; S (Rn × Rn ; MN )), and
Tr e−tA =
∑ e−t λ j ,
j≥1
as we wanted.
t > 0,
5.3 Abstract Functional Calculus
71
The next step, to be carried out in Chapter 6, will be to study the singularity as t → 0+ of the trace of the heat-kernel. We shall accomplish this by constructing a parametrix approximation of e−tA (the parametrix we are referring to is a parametrix for d/dt + A), that will give the sought information. After that, we shall relate the singularity of Tr e−tA as t → 0+ to the counting function N(λ ) through the Karamata theorem. But before doing that, we continue with a section about the abstract functional calculus of an elliptic global system, a section about kernels, and finally close the chapter with a section about f (A) as a global pseudodifferential operator.
5.3 Abstract Functional Calculus We recall in this section how to obtain an abstract functional calculus for an elliptic 0 < A = A∗ ∈ OPScl (mμ , g; MN ), μ > 0, with a discrete spectrum, Spec(A), made of a sequence 0 < λ1 ≤ λ2 ≤ . . . → +∞ of eigenvalues repeated according to multiplicity, and with eigenfunctions {ϕ j } j∈N ⊂ S (Rn ; CN ) that form an orthonormal basis of L2 (Rn ; CN ). Let f : Spec(A) −→ C. Define the unbounded operator f (A) : D( f (A)) ⊂ L2 (Rn ; CN ) −→ L2 (Rn ; CN ) by ! D( f (A)) := u =
∑ u j ϕ j ∈ L2 (Rn ; CN );
j≥1
D( f (A)) u =
" 2 2 | f ( λ )| |u | < +∞ , j j ∑
j≥1
∑ u j ϕ j −→ f (A)u := ∑ f (λ j )u j ϕ j .
j≥1
j≥1
Then f (A) is a closed operator with dense domain, since the ϕ j ∈ D( f (A)). If f is real-valued, then f (A) = f (A)∗ . Now we want to have conditions on f which ensure that f (A) : S (Rn ; CN ) −→ S (Rn ; CN ) be continuous. The first step is to understand D(A p ), for p ∈ N. Lemma 5.3.1. Define, for p ∈ N, the unbounded operator A p : D(A p ) ⊂ L2 −→ L2 , by D(A p ) = {u ∈ D(A p−1 ); A p−1 u ∈ D(A)}, and A p u = A(A p−1u). Remark that the domain is dense in L2 since S ⊂ D(A p ). Using the eigenfunctions {ϕ j } j∈N , we then have ! " D(A p ) = u = ∑ u j ϕ j ∈ L2 ; ∑ λ j2p |u j |2 < +∞ = B pμ (Rn ; CN ), j≥1
j≥1
and Au =
∑ λ ju jϕ j.
j≥1
Proof. Note in the first place that ϕ j ∈ S (Rn ; CN ) ⊂ Bs (Rn ; CN ), for all s ∈ R. If u ∈ D(A p ) we want then to prove that Λ pμ u ∈ L2 , where, recall, Λ pμ u is taken in the sense of distributions. Using a parametrix Q of A p such that QA p = I + R gives
72
5 The Heat-Semigroup, Functional Calculus and Kernels pμ 2 u ∈ D(A p ) =⇒ Λ pμ u = Λ pμ (QA p − R)u = (Λ pμ Q) A pu − Λ Ru ∈ L . order 0
∈L2
∈L2
And conversely, supposing u ∈ B pμ , and using a parametrix E of Λ pμ such that ˜ yields E Λ pμ = I + R, ˜ = (A p E) Λ pμ u − A pRu ˜ ∈ L2 , S A p u = A p (E Λ pμ − R)u order 0
∈L2
∈L2
and this concludes the proof. Remark 5.3.2. Note hence that for p ∈ N, ||u||2B pμ ≈ ||u||2D(A p ) := ||u||20 + ||A pu||20 ≈ ||A p u||20 ,
(5.7)
for, by our assumption, Spec(A) ⊂ (0, +∞).
When f is slowly increasing on the spectrum of A one has that f (A) is continuous from S into itself. One has in fact the following lemma. Lemma 5.3.3. Suppose f is slowly increasing on Spec(A), i.e. there exists C > 0 and p ∈ Z+ such that | f (λ j )| ≤ C(1 + λ j ) p , ∀ j ∈ N.
(5.8)
Then f (A) : S (Rn ; CN ) −→ S (Rn ; CN ) is continuous. Proof. For all r ∈ Z+ we have |(1 + λ j )r f (λ j )u j | ≤ C(1 + λ j )r+p |u j |, ∀ j ∈ N.
(5.9)
By Lemma 5.3.1 we have D(A p ) = B pμ , whence (5.9) implies the continuity of f (A)B(r+p)μ : D(Ar+p ) = B(r+p)μ −→ D(Ar ) = Br μ , ∀r ∈ Z+ , the spaces being endowed with the respective Hilbert-space structures (and making use of (5.7)). This proves the lemma. Remark 5.3.4. One has the following immediate consequences. 1. If f is bounded on Spec(A) (e.g. p = 0 in (5.8)) then f (A) : L2 −→ L2 is continuous. 2. Since A > 0, we may consider f (A) when f (λ ) = λ s , λ > 0, s ∈ R. 3. If f ∈ C0∞ (R) then f (A) is smoothing and compact (and actually of finite rank). 4. If f (λ ) = eit λ , t ∈ R, then unitary
eitA : L2 −→ L2 , (eitA )∗ = e−itA .
5.4 Kernels
73
5. If f ∈ S ([0, +∞)), then f (A) is smoothing. This is in particular the case when f (λ ) = e−t λ , for t, λ > 0. It is useful to have also the following proposition about the Schr¨odinger group. Proposition 5.3.5. The function t −→ e−itA ∈ C∞ (Rt ; L (S , S )). Moreover, with Dt = −i∂t , it solves the Cauchy problem ⎧ ⎨ (Dt + A)e−itA = 0, in C∞ (Rt ; L (S , S )), ⎩
e−itA t=0 = I.
Proof. One directly sees, from the very definition, that for all m, p ∈ N t −→ e−itA ∈ Cm−1 (Rt ; L (D(Am+p ), D(A p ))),
and that the equation is satisfied.
5.4 Kernels We now come to the study of the Schwartz kernel of f (A). Let hence f be slowly increasing on Spec(A). Then, by Lemma 5.3.3 f (A) : S −→ S is continuous so that, using the embedding S → S , f (A) : S −→ S is also continuous. Hence, by the Schwartz-kernel theorem, f (A) has a distribution kernel: for any given u, v ∈ S we have ( f (A)u, v) = K|v¯ ⊗ u S ,S . We have the following proposition. Proposition 5.4.1. If f is slowly increasing on Spec(A), then the distribution kernel K of f (A) belongs to S (Rn × Rn ; MN ), and one has K = S - lim Km , where Km (x, y) = m→+∞
m
∑ f (λ j )ϕ j (y)∗ ⊗ ϕ j (x),
j=1
where ϕ j (y)∗ ⊗ ϕ j (x)v = v, ϕ j (y) CN ϕ j (x), for all v ∈ CN (that is, ϕ j (y)∗ ⊗ ϕ j (x) = ϕ j (x) t ϕ j (y), colum-times-row).
74
5 The Heat-Semigroup, Functional Calculus and Kernels
Proof. Let k0 ∈ N be such that f (λ j ) −→ 0, as j → +∞. (1 + λ j )2k0
(5.10)
Let Pm be the L2 -orthogonal projection onto Span{ϕ j }1≤ j≤m . Then Rm := f (A)Pm is the operator whose kernel is Km . In addition, Rm can be extended as an operator belonging to L (D(Ak0 ), D(Ak0 )∗ ), where, recall, D(Ak0 )∗ is the dual space of D(Ak0 ). By (5.10), {Rm }m∈N is a Cauchy sequence in L (D(Ak0 ), D(Ak0 )∗ ). Hence there exists lim Rm = R ∈ L (D(Ak0 ), D(Ak0 )∗ ). m→+∞
But for all j ≥ 1 Rϕ j = lim Rm ϕ j = lim f (A)ϕ j = f (A)ϕ j . m→+∞
m→+∞
Since S → D(Ak0 ), and D(Ak0 )∗ → S , we have R ∈ L (S , S ), with
Rϕ j = f (A)ϕ j , ∀ j ≥ 1.
Hence R = f (A) in L (S , S ), so that f (A) = lim Rm .
m→+∞
Proposition 5.4.2. If f is rapidly decreasing on Spec(A) then S
Km −→ K, as m → +∞. L2
Proof. From Proposition 5.4.1 with k0 = 0 we obtain that Km −→ K as m → +∞. Let Ax be the operator A acting on x-functions (or distributions). Then, with (A∗y ⊗ Ax )(v∗ ⊗ u) = (Ay v)∗ ⊗ (Ax u), we have, for r ∈ N, ((A∗y )r ⊗ Arx )Km (x, y) =
m
∑ λ j2r f (λ j )ϕ j (y)∗ ⊗ ϕ j (x).
j=1
Hence, on the one hand, by Proposition 5.4.1, ((A∗y )r ⊗ Arx )Km −→ ((A∗y )r ⊗ Arx )K, as m → +∞, in the topology of S (Rn × Rn ; MN ), and on the other hand λ j2r f (λ j ) is rapidly decreasing for j → +∞, whence it also follows that ((A∗y )r ⊗ Arx )Km −→ ((A∗y )r ⊗ Arx )K, as m → +∞,
5.4 Kernels
75
in the topology of L2 (Rn × Rn ; MN ), for all r ∈ Z+ . Since A∗y and Ax are elliptic we obtain, by a natural vector-valued regularity theorem for Ax or A∗y starting from L2x,y , that Km −→ K, as m → +∞, ˆ ry , for all r ∈ Z+ . Since Brx ⊗B ˆ ry ⊂ Brx,y and in the topology of Brx ⊗B
r∈Z+
the claim follows.
Brx,y = Sx,y ,
Corollary 5.4.3. If f is rapidly decreasing on Spec(A) then Tr f (A) :=
∑
f (λ j ) =
j≥1
Rn
Tr K(x, x) dx,
where, recall, Tr denotes the matrix-trace. To make this section self-contained, we prove the following “rough” information on the behavior of the eigenvalues of A. Proposition 5.4.4. There exists k0 ∈ N such that ∞
1
∑ λ 2k0
j=1
< +∞.
j
Proof. For simplicity we consider the scalar case. We know that the operator A−k ∈ OPScl (m−k μ , g), k ∈ N. Using Theorem 3.1.16 (or Theorem 3.2.17), write A−k = b(x, D) + R, where R is smoothing. Then for the Schwartz-kernel K of A−k we have K(x, y) = K0 (x, y) + K1 (x, y), where K1 ∈ S (Rn × Rn ) is the Schwartz-kernel of R, and K0 is the Schwartz-kernel of b(x, D), given by K0 (x, y) = (2π )−n
ei x−y,ξ b(x, ξ )d ξ ∈ S (Rn × Rn )
(in the sense of oscillatory integrals, see Helffer [17] or Shubin [67]). Let us choose in the first place the integer k so that k μ > n. Then K0 ∈ C(Rn × Rn ) ∩ L∞ (Rn × Rn ). If k is picked so that k μ > n + 1, we have in addition that y j K0 (x, y) = (2π )−n
y j ei x−y,ξ b(x, ξ )d ξ
Dξ j (ei x−y,ξ )b(x, ξ )d ξ + x j (2π )−n ei x−y,ξ b(x, ξ )d ξ = (2π )−n ei x−y,ξ (Dξ j b)(x, ξ ) + x j b(x, ξ ) d ξ , = −(2π )−n
76
5 The Heat-Semigroup, Functional Calculus and Kernels
from which we deduce that y j K0 ∈ L∞ (Rn × Rn ). By the same token, we may finally conclude that there is k0 = k0 (n) such that picking k = k0 gives xα yβ K0 ∈ C(Rn × Rn ) ∩ L∞ (Rn × Rn), ∀α , β ∈ Zn+ , |α | + |β | ≤ 2(n + 1), whence K0 ∈ L2 (Rn × Rn ), and therefore also K ∈ L2 (Rn × Rn ). Since {ϕ j } j≥1 and {ϕ¯ j } j≥1 are orthonormal systems in L2x and L2y , respectively, we get that ϕ j (y)∗ ⊗ ϕ j (x)(= ϕ j (x)ϕ j (y) in the scalar case) is an orthonormal system in L2x,y . The Fourier coefficients of K with respect to this basis are given by
a j j :=
K(x, y)ϕ j (y)ϕ j (x)dxdy = (A−k0 ϕ j , ϕ j )
= λ j−k0 (ϕ j , ϕ j ) = λ j−k0 δ j j . Hence
|K(x, y)|2 dxdy =
∞
∑
|a j j |2 =
j, j =1
∞
1
∑ λ 2k0
j=1
< +∞,
j
and this concludes the proof.
It is useful to define also the trace of t −→ e−itA , that is the trace of the Schr¨odinger group (which is clearly important in its own right, and basic when studying Poisson-like relations). We have the following proposition. Proposition 5.4.5. The map S (R) φ − → Tr φˆ (A), φˆ (t) =
e−itx φ (x)dx,
defines a distribution in S (R), denoted by Tr e−itA . Proof. The map φ −→ φˆ is continuous in S . It suffices therefore to prove that for some C > 0 we have |Tr φˆ (A)| ≤ C|φˆ | p,q , (5.11) where |φˆ | p,q is some suitable S -seminorm of φˆ . By Proposition 5.4.4 (alternatively, in case μ = 2ν by Theorem 4.3.4, Remark 4.3.5, Theorem 4.4.1 and Remark 4.4.2, we may also use the behavior λ j ≈ jν /n as j → +∞), there exists r ∈ N sufficiently large such that ∑ (1 + λ j2)−r < +∞. Hence j≥1
∑ φˆ (λ j ) = ∑ (1 + λ j2)−r (1 + λ j2)r φˆ (λ j ) j≥1
j≥1
≤
∑ (1 + λ j2)−r
j≥1
which proves (5.11) and the proposition.
sup |(1 + t 2)r φˆ (t)|, t∈R
5.6 Notes
77
5.5 f (A) as a Pseudodifferential Operator The following theorem, which concludes the chapter, is also useful (see Helffer [17] and Robert [63–65]). It is obtained through the calculus with parameters. Theorem 5.5.1. Let 0 < A = A∗ ∈ OPScl (mμ , g), μ ∈ N, be a scalar elliptic GPDO of order μ . Let f : (−c, +∞) −→ C satisfy, for some r ∈ R, the inequalities ∀k ∈ Z+ , ∃Ck > 0, such that | f (k) (λ )| ≤ Ck (1 + |λ |)r−k . Then the operator-function f (A) = F w (x, D) ∈ OPS(mr μ , g), with F∼
μ
∑ Frμ − j ,
Fr μ − j ∈ S(mr μ − j , g),
j=0
and • Fr μ = f (a μ ); • Fr μ −1 = a μ −1 f (a μ ) (and hence it is equal to 0, for in our case a μ −1 = 0);
d jk (a) (k) f (a μ ), j ≥ 2, where the d jk ∈ S(mk μ − j , g) and depend only k=1 k! on the symbol a. j
• Fr μ − j =
∑
Furthermore, if f is classic, that is f (λ ) ∼ ∑ j≥0 c j λ r− j , λ > 0, then f (A) ∈ OPScl (mr μ , g). Remark 5.5.2. In the matrix-valued case we shall need the result of Theorem 5.5.1 only for the complex power Az , z ∈ C, of an elliptic system of GPDOs 0 < A = A∗ ∈ OPScl (mμ , g; MN ). By a result due to Robert [63], one has that Az belongs to the class OPScl (mμ Re z , g; MN ). Corollary 5.5.3. In particular, for Q(α ,β ) ∈ Scl (m2 , g; M2 ), which is globally positive elliptic for α , β > 0 and αβ > 1, Remark 5.5.2 holds true.
5.6 Notes The reader is addressed to Helffer’s book [17] for the functional calculus of global pseudodifferential operators (see also the paper by Helffer and Robert [19]).
Chapter 6
The Spectral Counting Function N(λ ) and the Behavior of the Eigenvalues: Part 2
In this chapter we shall describe the parametrix approximation of e−tA , A a positive elliptic global polynomial differential system, which will then be used, through Karamata’s Tauberian theorem (proved in Section 6.2), to compute the leading coefficient of the asymptotic behavior for large eigenvalues of the spectral counting function, in terms of the symbol of the system.
6.1 A Parametrix Approximation of e–tA In this section, following Parenti-Parmeggiani [50], we consider an N × N elliptic system of GPDOs 0 < A = A∗ ∈ OPScl (mμ , g; MN ), μ ∈ N, and introduce a class of symbols which is suitable for constructing a pseudodifferential approximation of e−tA . Recall that R+ = [0, +∞). Definition 6.1.1. Let r ∈ R. By S(μ , r) we denote the set of all smooth maps b: R+ × Rn × Rn −→ MN satisfying the following estimates: For any given α ∈ Z2n + and any given p, j ∈ Z+ there exists C > 0 such that d sup t p ( ) j ∂Xα b(t, X ) ≤ Cm(X )r−|α |+( j−p)μ . dt t∈R+
(6.1)
For b ∈ S(μ , r) we then consider the pseudodifferential operator bw (t, x, D)u(x) = (2π )−n
ei x−y,ξ b(t,
x+y , ξ )u(y)dyd ξ , u ∈ S (Rn ; CN ), 2
and we shall say that B ∈ OPS(μ , r) if B = bw (t, x, D) + R, where R is smoothing. In this setting, a smoothing operator R is any continuous map R : S (Rn ; CN ) −→ S (R+ ; S (Rn ; CN )).
A. Parmeggiani, Spectral Theory of Non-Commutative Harmonic Oscillators: An Introduction, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1992, c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2010 DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-11922-4 6,
(6.2)
79
80
6 The Spectral Counting Function N(λ ) and the Behavior of the Eigenvalues: Part 2
Notice in particular that for the time-dependent seminorms of b ∈ S(μ , r) we have m(X)|α | |∂t j ∂Xα b(t, X)| ≤ Cα , j,p m(X)r+( j−p)μ t −p , ∀X ∈ R2n , ∀t ≥ 1, that is, for any given k, j, p ∈ Z+ there exists C = Ck, j,p > 0 such that (see (3.1)) ||∂t j b(t, ·)||k,S(mr+( j−p)μ ,g) ≤ Ct −p , ∀t ≥ 1.
(6.3)
We now introduce the “classical operators”. The key point here is to consider the correct homogeneity properties. The basic example to bear in mind is the matrix e−taμ (x,ξ ) . For instance, the bound for t p e−taμ (X) appearing in (6.1) follows from writing t p e−taμ (X) = aμ (X)−p (ta μ (X)) p e−taμ (X) , and from the inequality τ p e−τ ≤ (p/e) p , all τ > 0 (see (5.6)). The other bounds follow by the same considerations. Definition 6.1.2. We say that the operator B ∈ OPS(μ , r), B = bw + R is classical, and write B ∈ OPScl (μ , r), if there exists a sequence of functions br−2 j = br−2 j (t, X), j ≥ 0, t ≥ 0 and X = 0, such that: (i) One has the homogeneity br−2 j (t, τ X ) = τ r−2 j br−2 j (τ μ t, X), ∀τ > 0, ∀ j ≥ 0;
(6.4)
(ii) The function R2n \ {0} X −→ br−2 j (·, X) ∈ S (R+ ; MN ) is smooth for all j ≥ 0; (iii) For all ν ≥ 1 b(t, X ) −
ν −1
∑ χ (X)br−2 j (t, X ) ∈ S(μ , r − 2ν ),
j=0
where χ is an excision function. We call br = σr (B) the principal symbol of B. Of course, semi-regular classical symbols are defined accordingly (see Remark 3.2.4). Note that
σr (B) ≡ 0 =⇒ B ∈ OPScl (μ , r − 2),
6.1 A Parametrix Approximation of e−tA
81
and that given any smooth map b : R2n \ {0} −→ S (R+ ; MN ), with the homogeneity property b(t, τ X) = τ r b(τ μ t, X), ∀τ > 0, then there exists B ∈ OPScl (μ , r) such that σr (B) = b. One has the following results (whose proofs are left as an exercise to the reader) that are useful to the parametrix construction. Lemma 6.1.3. • One has
B ∈ OPScl (μ , r), C ∈ OPScl (μ , r ) =⇒ BC ∈ OPScl (μ , r + r ), with
σr+r (BC)(t, X ) = σr (B)(t, X )σr (C)(t, X ).
• One has
B ∈ OPScl (μ , r), P ∈ OPScl (m , g; MN ) =⇒ PB, BP ∈ OPScl (μ , r + ), with
σr+ (PB)(t, X) = p (X)σr (B)(t, X ),
and likewise for σr+ (BP).
• For B ∈ OPScl (μ , r) consider
d d B : S (Rn ; CN ) −→ S (R+ ; S (Rn ; CN )), u −→ (Bu). dt dt Then d d d B ∈ OPScl (μ , μ + r), with σμ +r ( B)(t, X ) = σr (B) (t, X ). dt dt dt • For B ∈ OPScl (μ , r) consider
∞ 0
Bdt : S (Rn ; CN ) −→ S (Rn ; CN ), u −→
Then
∞ 0
∞ 0
(Bu)dt.
Bdt ∈ OPScl (mr−μ , g; MN ),
with principal symbol X −→
∞ 0
σr (B)(t, X )dt.
We are now in a position to prove the following theorem about the existence of a parametrix approximation of e−tA . The parametrix we are interested in is that of the operator d/dt + A.
82
6 The Spectral Counting Function N(λ ) and the Behavior of the Eigenvalues: Part 2
Theorem 6.1.4. There exists UA ∈ OPScl (μ , 0) such that (i)
d UA + AUA : S (Rn ; CN ) −→ S (R+ ; S (Rn ; CN )) dt
is smoothing, and (ii)
UA t=0 −I : S (Rn ; CN ) −→ S (Rn ; CN )
is smoothing. One has
σ0 (UA )(t, X ) = e−taμ (X) .
Proof. Let b0 (t, X) = e−taμ (X) , and let B0 ∈ OPScl (μ , 0) with σ0 (B0 ) = b0 . By Lemma 6.1.3 we have d B0 + AB0 ∈ OPScl (μ , μ − 2), dt with principal symbol rμ −2 (t, X ), and B0 t=0 −I ∈ OPScl (m−2 , g; MN ), with principal symbol p−2 (X ). We next look for a symbol b−2 (t, X ), positively homogeneous of degree −2 (in the sense of (6.4)), such that ⎧ d ⎪ ⎪ ⎨ b−2 + a μ b−2 = −rμ −2 , dt ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ b = −p . −2 t=0 −2
(6.5)
The solution of (6.5), b−2 (t, X) = −e−taμ (X) p−2 (X) −
t 0
e−(t−t )aμ (X) rμ −2 (t , X )dt ,
(6.6)
is easily seen to be smooth and have the required homogeneity properties. Taking B−2 ∈ OPScl (μ , −2) with σ−2 (B−2 ) = b−2 , gives d (B0 + B−2) + A(B0 + B−2 ) ∈ OPScl (μ , μ − 4), dt and
(B0 + B−2)t=0 −I ∈ OPScl (m−4 , g; MN ).
Iterating the above procedure gives a formal series
∑ B−2k ,
k≥0
B−2k ∈ OPScl (μ , −2k).
6.2 The Karamata Theorem
83
We may hence take, by an adaptation of Proposition 3.2.15, an operator UA ∈ OPScl (μ , 0) for which UA −
ν −1
∑ B−2k ∈ OPS(μ , −2ν ),
∀ν ≥ 1,
k=0
and therefore obtain the required parametrix. Hence, from Lemma 5.1.1 and Theorem 6.1.4 we have that
R(t) := e−tA − UA(t) : S (Rn ; CN ) −→ S (R+ ; S (Rn ; CN )) is continuous (6.7) (i.e., it is a smoothing operator), and
e−tA − UA (t)
t=0
: S (Rn ; CN ) −→ S (Rn ; CN ) is smoothing.
(6.8)
Remark 6.1.5. In the applications of Theorem 6.1.4 we shall always consider a parametrix approximation of e−tA where b−2 j t=0 = 0 for j ≥ 1, B−2 j (t) = (χ b−2 j )w (t, x, D), where χ is our usual excision function, and hence consider the symbol cA (t, X ) of UA (t), i.e. UA (t) = cw A (t, x, D), given by cA (t, X ) =
∑ χ j (X)b−2 j (t, X ),
j≥0
where χ0 (X ) = χ (X ) and χ j (X) = χ (X/R j ), j ≥ 1, with R j +∞, as j → +∞, sufficiently fast (in analogy with the R j constructed in Proposition 3.2.15). We shall write UA (t) ∼ ∑ B−2 j (t). (6.9) j≥0
In order to exploit the parametrix approximation UA (t) of e−tA to study NA (λ ) as λ → +∞, we have to recall the Karamata theorem.
6.2 The Karamata Theorem Recall that the Euler Gamma function Γ (x) =
∞ 0
e−t t x−1 dt, x > 0, fulfills the rela-
tion Γ (x + 1) = xΓ (x). Also, following Halmos’ book on Measure Theory [16], given a Borel measure μ over a measure space X , a measurable space Y and a measurable transformation
84
6 The Spectral Counting Function N(λ ) and the Behavior of the Eigenvalues: Part 2
T : X −→ Y , the T -image measure μT of Y is defined for any Borel subset F ⊂ Y by
μT (F) = μ (T −1 F). Hence, for any given μT -measurable function f : Y −→ [0, +∞]
f (y)d μT (y) =
F
T −1 F
f (T x)d μ (x).
(6.10)
Theorem 6.2.1 (Karamata). Let μ be a positive (locally finite) Borel measure on [0, +∞), and let α > 0. Then ∞
e−t λ d μ (λ ) ∼ at −α , as t → 0+,
0
implies
x 0
d μ (λ ) ∼
a xα , as x → +∞. Γ (α + 1)
(6.11)
(6.12)
Proof. For t > 0 define the measure d μt (λ ) by μt (A) = t α μ (t −1 A). Let d ν (λ ) = αλ α −1 d λ , λ > 0. Then νt = ν . In fact, in general we have by definition that, given any Borel set A ⊂ [0, +∞),
μt (A) =
A
d μt (λ ) = t α μ (t −1 A) = t α
t −1 A
d μ (λ ),
and that, by (6.10), for any given measurable function f : [0, +∞) −→ [0, +∞] A
f (λ )d μt (λ ) = t α
t −1 A
f (t σ )d μ (σ ).
(6.13)
Hence, specializing to the case of νt gives
νt (A) =
A
d νt (λ ) = t α ν (t −1 A) = α t α
t −1 A
λ α −1 d λ = ν (A).
With b = a/Γ (α + 1), we have that, by virtue of (6.13), hypothesis (6.11) can be rewritten as ∞ ∞ lim e−λ d μt (λ ) = b e−λ d ν (λ ), (6.14) t→0+ 0
and also, since tα
0
1/t 0
d μ (λ ) =
1 0
d μt (λ ),
that the desired conclusion can be rewritten (just by putting x = 1/t) as 1
lim
t→0+ 0
d μt (λ ) = b
1 0
d ν (λ ).
(6.15)
6.2 The Karamata Theorem
85
Suppose we know that ∞
lim
t→0+ 0
f (λ )d μt (λ ) = b
∞ 0
f (λ )d ν (λ ), ∀ f ∈ C0 ([0, +∞)),
(6.16)
where C0 ([0, +∞)) denotes the space of continuous functions compactly supported in [0, +∞). Since ν and the μt , t ∈ (0, 1], are regular measures, we have that for any given open subset V of [0, +∞), ! ν (V ) = sup
[0,+∞)
" f (λ )d ν (λ ); f ∈ C0 ([0, +∞)), 0 ≤ f ≤ 1V ,
(6.17)
where 1V is the characteristic function of V (hence in particular supp f ⊂ V ), and for any given compact K ⊂ [0, +∞), ! ν (K) = inf
[0,+∞)
" f (λ )d ν (λ ); f ∈ C0 ([0, +∞)), 1K ≤ f ≤ 1 ,
(6.18)
hence f K ≡ 1, and likewise for the measures μt . Since (6.16) says that μt → ν weakly as measures on [0, +∞) as t → 0+, we have from (6.17) that ! b ν ((0, 1)) = sup b
[0,+∞)
! ≤ lim inf sup t→0+
f d ν ; f ∈ C0 ([0, +∞)), 0 ≤ f ≤ 1(0,1)
[0,+∞)
"
f d μt ; f ∈ C0 ([0, +∞)), 0 ≤ f ≤ 1(0,1)
"
= lim inf μt ((0, 1)) ≤ lim inf μt ([0, 1]), t→0+
t→0+
and likewise, from (6.18), that b ν ([0, 1]) ≥ lim sup μt ([0, 1]). t→0+
Since ν ((0, 1)) = ν ([0, 1]) (for ν ({0}) = ν ({1}) = 0) we have (a particular case of Prohorov’s theorem) lim μt ([0, 1]) = b ν ([0, 1]), t→0+
and this proves that (6.16) implies (6.15). Next, by (6.14) the measures e−λ d μt (λ ) are uniformly bounded, for t ∈ (0, 1], so that (6.16) follows from ∞
lim
t→0+ 0
g(λ )e−λ d μt (λ ) = b
∞ 0
g(λ )e−λ d ν (λ ),
(6.19)
for a dense (in the sup-norm) subset of g in C∞ ([0, +∞)), the space of continuous functions that vanish at infinity. But (6.19) holds for g(λ ) = e−nλ by hypothesis (6.11). Since polynomials in e−λ are dense in C∞ ([0, +∞)) by the Stone-Weierstrass Theorem, (6.19) holds and the theorem is proven.
6 The Spectral Counting Function N(λ ) and the Behavior of the Eigenvalues: Part 2
86
6.3 Use of the Parametrix Approximation of e–tA for Obtaining the Weyl Asymptotics of N(λ ) We may now exploit the existence of the parametrix approximation of e−tA to study, through Karamata’s theorem, the Weyl-asymptotics of N(λ ) as λ → +∞. Hence, let Spec(A) = {λ j } j≥1 , 0 < λ1 ≤ λ2 ≤ . . . → +∞, repeated according to multiplicity, and let N(λ ) = { j ∈ N; λ j < λ }. Then
∑ e−t λ j =
j≥1
∞ 0
e−t λ dN(λ ) = Tr e−tA .
Actually, from Theorem 6.1.4, (6.7) and Remark 6.1.5 we have Tr e−tA = TrUA (t) + TrR(t), t > 0, where TrUA (t) =
∑ Tr B−2 j (t)
(6.20)
(6.21)
j≥0
(we shall specify in a moment in what sense the = sign holds). Note that since the operator R(t) is smoothing (see (6.2)), we have 0 ≤ t −→ Tr R(t) ∈ S (R+ ; C). Now, Tr B−2 j (t) = (2π )−n
R2n
(6.22)
χ (X)Tr b−2 j (t, X )dX.
Hence, upon denoting by S2n−1 the unit sphere in R2n , using polar coordinates 0 = X = ρω , where ρ ∈ R+ and ω ∈ S2n−1 , gives X = |X| |X| Tr B−2 j (t) = (2π )−n
+∞ 0
S2n−1
χ (ρω )Tr b−2 j (t, ρω )ρ 2n−1d ρ d ω ,
(6.23)
where d ω is the induced Riemannian measure on S2n−1 . In general, if b ∈ S(μ , −2ν ), with ν > n, then by the estimates (6.1) we have that uniformly in t ≥ 0, (2π )−n
+∞ 0
S2n−1
b(t, ρω )ρ 2n−1d ρ d ω
0
+∞
ρ 2n−1 d ρ < +∞, (1 + ρ )2ν
from which it follows that 0 ≤ t −→ fb (t) := (2π )−n
+∞ 0
S2n−1
b(t, ρω )ρ 2n−1d ρ d ω
(6.24)
6.3 Use of the Parametrix Approximation of e−tA for Obtaining the Weyl Asymptotics
87
is continuous and bounded on R+ . Hence ν
0 ≤ t −→ TrUA (t) − ∑ Tr B−2 j (t) ∈ C(R+ ) ∩ L∞ (R+ ), ∀ν > n.
(6.25)
j=0
More generally, given any p, k ∈ Z+ , we have |t p ∂tk fb (t)| < +∞, ∀t ≥ 0, provided b ∈ S(μ , −2ν ) with 2ν > 2n − (p − k)μ . Hence, on defining S p,k (R+ ) := { f ∈ Ck (R+ ); t p f (r) ∈ L∞ (R+ ), r = 0, 1, . . . , k},
(6.26)
for any given p, k ∈ Z+ there exists ν with 2ν > 2n − (p − k)μ such that ν
0 ≤ t −→ TrUA (t) − ∑ Tr B−2 j (t) ∈ S p,k (R+ ),
(6.27)
j=0
and this is the meaning of the = sign in (6.21). Next, by the homogeneity of the b−2 j we may write (supp χ ⊂ {|X | ≥ 1/2}, say) Tr B−2 j (t) = (2π )−n
+∞ 1/2
S2n−1
χ (ρω )Tr b−2 j (ρ μ t, ω )ρ 2(n− j)−1d ρ d ω .
(6.28)
Since Tr b−2 j (·, ω ) ∈ S (R+ , C) (which is also the case for the remainder in the asymptotic expansion of σ0 (UA ), by virtue of (6.1)), the integral in ρ converges for all t > 0, and hence the whole integral in d ρ d ω converges absolutely. Thus |Tr B−2 j (t)| < +∞, ∀t > 0, j ≥ 0, and (2π )−n
+∞ 0
S2n−1
Tr b−2 j (ρ μ t, ω )ρ 2(n− j)−1d ρ d ω < +∞, ∀t > 0, 0 ≤ j < n.
Furthermore, it follows from (6.23) and (6.24) that if j ≥ n + 1 in Tr B−2 j (t) the whole integral in d ρ d ω converges also for t = 0. We therefore have from (6.22), (6.25) and the fact (that we have just seen) that for j ≥ n + 1 the terms Tr B−2 j (t) are non-singular at t = 0, that the singularity of Tr e−tA at t = 0, which of course must be present, is necessarily contained in n
∑ Tr B−2 j (t).
j=0
(6.29)
6 The Spectral Counting Function N(λ ) and the Behavior of the Eigenvalues: Part 2
88
Hence, to study the singularity at t = 0 of Tr e−tA , let us at first consider a term Tr B−2 j (t) of (6.29) with 0 ≤ j < n. Write for t > 0 Tr B−2 j (t) = β−2 j (t) − β−2 j (t), where −n β−2 j (t) := (2π )
+∞ S2n−1
0
Tr b−2 j (ρ μ t, ω )ρ 2(n− j)−1d ρ d ω
and −n β−2 j (t) := (2π )
+∞ S2n−1
0
1 − χ (ρω ) Tr b−2 j (ρ μ t, ω )ρ 2(n− j)−1d ρ d ω .
Since ρω ∈ supp(1 − χ ) =⇒ ρ ∈ [0, 1], it follows that we may rewrite −n β−2 j (t) = (2π )
1 0
S2n−1
whence it follows that
1 − χ (ρω ) Tr b−2 j (ρ μ t, ω )ρ 2(n− j)−1d ρ d ω ,
∞ ∞ β−2 j ∈ C (R+ ) ∩ L (R+ ),
with the derivatives of all orders bounded on R+ . , switching to the variable s = t 1/ μ ρ gives As regards β−2 j β−2 j (t)
=t
−2(n− j)/ μ
−n
(2π )
= c−2 j,n (μ )t
+∞
0 −2(n− j)/ μ
S2n−1
Tr b−2 j (sμ , ω )s2(n− j)−1 dsd ω
,
where c−2 j,n (μ ) := (2π )−n
+∞ 0
S2n−1
Tr b−2 j (sμ , ω )s2(n− j)−1 dsd ω
(6.30)
is such that |c−2 j,n (μ )| < +∞, because of the fact that Tr b−2 j (·, ω ) ∈ S (R+ ) and 0 ≤ j ≤ n − 1. Notice that, by the homogeneity, we may also write c−2 j,n (μ ) = (2π )−n
+∞ 0
S2n−1
Tr b−2 j (1, sω )s2n−1 dsd ω , 0 ≤ j ≤ n − 1. (6.31)
It therefore follows that Tr B−2 j (t) = t −2(n− j)/μ c−2 j,n (μ ) + o(1) , as t → 0+, 0 ≤ j ≤ n − 1.
6.3 Use of the Parametrix Approximation of e−tA for Obtaining the Weyl Asymptotics
89
As regards the term Tr B−2n (t), again by virtue of the fact that Tr b−2 j (·, ω ) ∈ S (R+ ), we have that for any given ε > 0 we may find Cε > 0 such that for all t > 0 |Tr B−2n (t)| = (2π )−n
+∞
1/2
= t −ε (2π )−n
S2n−1 +∞
χ (ρω )Tr b−2n (ρ μ t, ω )ρ −1 d ρ d ω
S2n−1
1/2
ε
χ (ρω )ρ ε μ t ε Tr b−2n (ρ μ t, ω )ρ −1−ε μ d ρ d ω
≤ Cε /t .
(6.32)
It follows that as t → 0+ n
# n−1
j=0
j=0
∑ Tr B−2 j (t) = t −2n/μ ∑
$ c−2 j,n (μ )t 2 j/μ + o(t 2 j/μ ) + t 2n/μ Tr B−2n (t) ,
so that, by (6.32), n
∑ Tr B−2 j (t) = t −2n/μ
c0,n (μ ) + o(1) , as t → 0 + .
j=0
This shows (using (6.24) to control the remainder term) that the leading singularity at t = 0 of Tr e−tA is exactly given by the term t −2n/μ with coefficient c0,n (μ ) = (2π )−n
+∞ S2n−1
0
Tr b0 (sμ , ω )s2n−1 dsd ω .
Since Tr b0 (sμ , ω ) = Tr e−s
μa
μ (ω )
=
N
∑ e−s
μ
j (ω )
(6.33)
,
j=1
where 0 < 1 (ω ), . . . , N (ω ), ω ∈ S2n−1 , are the (possibly repeated) eigenvalues of the N × N Hermitian matrix aμ (ω ), labelled in such a way to be represented by continuous functions on S2n−1 . Therefore N
c0,n (μ ) = (2π )−n ∑
+∞ S2n−1
j=1 0
= (2π )−n where we have used
+∞ 0
Γ ( 2n μ) μ
N
∑
j=1
e−s
S2n−1
μ
e−s s2n−1 ds = Γ (
We have thus proved the following theorem.
μ
j (ω )
s2n−1 dsd ω
1 dω , j (ω )2n/μ 2n )/ μ . μ
6 The Spectral Counting Function N(λ ) and the Behavior of the Eigenvalues: Part 2
90
Theorem 6.3.1. Let 0 < A = A∗ ∈ OPScl (mμ , g; MN ) be an elliptic N × N system of GPDOs of order μ ∈ N in Rn . Then Tr e−tA ∼
Γ ( 2n μ )/ μ (2π )n
t −2n/μ
N
∑
S2n−1
j=1
1 d ω , as t → 0+, j (ω )2n/μ
where 0 < 1 (ω ), . . . , N (ω ), ω ∈ S2n−1 , are the (possibly repeated) eigenvalues of the N × N Hermitian matrix a μ (ω ), labelled in such a way to be represented by continuous functions on S2n−1 . Hence, Karamata’s theorem gives for the spectral counting function N(λ ) ∼
%
Γ ( 2n μ )/ μ
N
∑
(2π )nΓ ( 2n μ + 1)
2n−1 j=1 S
& 1 d ω λ 2n/μ , as λ → +∞. (6.34) j (ω )2n/μ
In particular, when A is an elliptic NCHO, we have N(λ ) ∼
1 2n(2π )n
S2n−1
Tr a2 (ω )−n d ω λ n , as λ → +∞.
(6.35)
Corollary 6.3.2. For the NCHO Qw (x, D), α , β > 0 and αβ > 1, we have (α ,β ) 1 N(λ ) ∼ 4π
α +β −1 Tr Q(α ,β ) (ω ) d ω λ = ' λ , as λ → +∞. 1 S αβ (αβ − 1) (6.36)
Remark 6.3.3. Given a positive function aμ , positively homogeneous of degree μ > 0 in R2n \ {0}, we have aμ (x,ξ )≤1
dxd ξ =
(2π )−n 2n
S2n−1
1 dω . aμ (ω )2n/μ
Hence, using the homogeneity of degree μ of the eigenvalues j , the main term in (6.34) (i.e. the coefficient of λ 2n/μ ) may also be written as 2n 2n Γ ( μ ) μ Γ ( 2n μ + 1)
N
∑
j=1
j (x,ξ )≤1
dxd ξ ,
(6.37)
and the one in (6.36) as ! " detQ(α ,β ) (x, ξ ) Vol (x, ξ ) ∈ R × R; ≤1 . Tr Q(α ,β ) (x, ξ )
(6.38)
6.4 Remarks on the Heuristics on N(λ ) and ζA (s)
91
6.4 Remarks on the Heuristics on N(λ ) and ζ A (s) It is worth noting that information on N(λ ) can be obtained from information on ζA (s) through Ikehara’s theorem. Here we follow Shubin [67, p. 120]. Theorem 6.4.1. Let N(λ ) be non-decreasing and equal to 0 for λ < λ1 . Suppose that
ζA (s) =
+∞
λ1
λ −s dN(λ )
converges for Re s > k0 , for some k0 > 0, and that
ζA (s) −
A s − k0
can be extended as a continuous function to the closed half-plane Re s ≥ k0 . Then N(λ ) ∼
A k0 λ , as λ → +∞. k0
What we have behind scenes is the following. Since the spectrum of A is made of eigenvalues 0 < λ1 ≤ λ2 ≤ . . . → +∞, considering the Stiltjes integral
ζA (s) =
+∞ 0
λ −s dN(λ )
gives the spectral zeta function ζA (s) = ∑ j≥1 λ j−s , which we already know to be holomorphic for Re s > 2n/μ . Suppose now that N(λ ) = c1 λ α1 + c2 λ α2 + . . . + ck λ αk + O(λ αk+1 ), as λ → +∞, where Re α1 > Re α2 > . . . > Re αk > Re αk+1 . Then
ζA (s) =
k
+∞
j=1
λ1
∑ cj
λ −s dN(λ ) + fk (s),
where fk is holomorphic for Re s > Re αk+1 . Since for Re s > Re α j +∞ λ1
λ
−s
αj
d(λ ) = α j
+∞ λ1
λ α j −s−1 d λ =
αj αj α j −s [λ α j −s ]+∞ , λ1 = s − α λ 1 αj − s j
we obtain, for Re s > Re αk+1 ,
ζA (s) =
k
∑ cj
j=1
α −s
λ1 j α j + fk (s), s − αj
92
6 The Spectral Counting Function N(λ ) and the Behavior of the Eigenvalues: Part 2
so that for s = α j we have simple poles with residue c j α j , 1 ≤ j ≤ k. Conversely, knowing the poles of ζA gives information on the aymptotic behavior of N(λ ), as λ → +∞. However, things are very delicate and difficult even in the scalar case (be it on a compact boundaryless Riemannian manifold or the whole Rn × Rn ; see Ivrii [34] and references therein).
6.5 Notes The proof of Karamata’s Theorem 6.2.1 follows an unpublished idea of M. Aizenman. Corollary 6.3.2 was obtained by Ichinose and Wakayama in [31] as a consequence, through Ikehara’s theorem, of their result about the meromorphic continuation of the spectral ζ -function associated with Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) (where α , β > 0, αβ > 1), and later also by Parmeggiani in [53] (by Fourier integral operator methods) as a consequence of a theorem about the singularity at t = 0 of the Fourier transform of the spectral density ∑ j≥1 δ (λ − λ j ). Formula (6.38) for the main coefficient in the asymptotics for N(λ ) was observed by Parmeggiani in [53], where the relation between that coefficient and the periods of the bicharacteristics curves associated with the eigenvalues of Q(α ,β ) (x, ξ ) (they are all periodic, as it will be seen below) was also shown. It is worth mentioning also that Taniguchi in [68] approaches the construction of the heat-semigroup associated with Qw (α ,β ) (x, D), for α , β > 0, αβ > 1, by probabilistic methods. This method is deep and powerful, and should be extended to general NCHOs, to provide further geometrical understanding of the behavior of the eigenvalues of a NCHO in terms of “classical” quantities (i.e. related to the classical dynamics associated with the bicharacteristics).
Chapter 7
The Spectral Zeta Function
In the first section of this chapter we will briefly recall, addressing the reader to Robert’s paper [63] (see also Aramaki [1]), the construction of the spectral zeta function ζA (s) = Tr A−s , where 0 < A = A∗ ∈ OPScl (mμ , g; MN ) is an elliptic N × N system of GPDOs in Rn of order μ ∈ N. We will then prove a theorem about the meromorphic continuation of the spectral zeta function of an elliptic NCHO A = A∗ > 0 in Rn (Theorem 7.2.1) by using the parametrix approximation of the heat-semigroup e−tA constructed in Chapter 6, Section 6.1, from which we immediately deduce a corollary (Corollary 7.2.8) for our NCHO Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) (α , β > 0 and αβ > 1) which gives part of the result of Ichinose and Wakayama (Theorem 7.3.1 below; see [31]), whose proof we will sketch in the final section.
7.1 Robert’s Construction of ζ A by Complex Powers Let 0 < A = A∗ ∈ OPScl (mμ , g; MN ) be an elliptic N × N system of GPDOs in Rn of order μ ∈ N. Recall from Remark 3.3.20 that the construction of the complex powers of A may be cast in the Weyl-H¨ormander calculus with parameters. So, suppose the principal symbol aμ of A be positive as an Hermitian matrix, that is a μ = a∗μ > 0, and let Λ = {z ∈ C; arg z ∈ [θ , 2π − θ ]}, for some θ ∈ (0, π /4). Recalling the weight mλ (X ) = (1 + |X |2 + |λ |2/μ )1/2 and the metric gλ ,X = mλ (X )−2 |dX|2 , we have that μ
A − λ ∈ OPScl (mλ , gλ ; λ ∈ Λ ; MN ), and A − λ is elliptic for λ ∈ Λ : |a μ (X ) − λ | ≥ Cmλ (X)μ , |X|2 + |λ |2/μ 1, λ ∈ Λ , X ∈ R2n . Note that
aμ (tX) − (t μ λ ) = t μ (a μ (X) − λ ).
A. Parmeggiani, Spectral Theory of Non-Commutative Harmonic Oscillators: An Introduction, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1992, c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2010 DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-11922-4 7,
93
94
7 The Spectral Zeta Function
Hence it suffices to check ellipticity only when |X|2 + |λ |2/μ = 1 (recall that we are dealing with systems of GPDOs in Rn ). −μ One next constructs a parametrix Bλ ∈ OPScl (mλ , gλ ; λ ∈ Λ ; MN ) of Aλ = A − λ , such that Bλ Aλ = I + Rλ , Aλ Bλ = I + Rλ , Rλ , Rλ ∈ OPS(m−∞ λ , gλ ; λ ∈ Λ ; MN ). Starting from the symbol b(X; λ ) ∼
∑ b−μ −2 j (X ; λ )
j≥0
of Bλ one then takes az (X ) ∼
1 2π i
γ
λ z b(X; λ )d λ ,
where γ ⊂ C is the curve {z ∈ C; |z| = c, |argz| ∈ [θ , 2π − θ ]} ∪ {z ∈ C; argz = θ , |z| ≥ c} ∪{z ∈ C; arg z = 2π − θ , |z| ≥ c}, for some fixed θ ∈ (θ , π /4) and c > 0, oriented in such a way that the circle-part is clockwise oriented. If az,N is any truncation of the asymptotics of az , with remainder rz,N , one defines w Az = a w z,N (x, D) + rz,N (x, D), when Re z < 0,
and for Re z < , ∈ Z+ , Az = Az− A . It follows that Az ∈ OPScl (mμ Re z , g; MN ). Robert then proved the following result (later generalized by Aramaki to some infinite-dimensional situations), that we state for classical symbols (Robert’s statement holds for more general polyhomogenous classes). Theorem 7.1.1. Let K(z) be the Schwartz kernel of Az . Then
ζA (s) = Tr A−s =
Rn
Tr K(−s) (x, x)dx,
is holomorphic in {s ∈ C; Re s > 2n/ μ }, and can be extended as a meromorphic 2n 2 j function in C, with at most simple poles belonging to the sequence s j = − , μ μ j ∈ Z+ , with residue
7.1 Robert’s Construction of ζA by Complex Powers
Res(ζA , s j ) =
μ i(2π )n+1
S2n−1 γ
95
λ −s j Tr b−μ −2 j (ω , λ )d λ d ω .
The function ζA is holomorphic in 0 with value
ζA (0) =
1 μ (2π )n
+∞ S2n−1 0
Tr b−μ −2n (ω , −λ )d λ d ω ,
and since in our case A is a system of GPDOs, we have that ζA is holomorphic in − j, j ∈ N, with value
ζA (− j) =
(−1) j μ (2π )n
+∞
S2n−1 0
λ j Tr b−μ −2n− j μ (ω , −λ )d λ d ω ,
hence it is surely 0 when j μ is not even, for in this case b−μ −2n− j μ = 0. Note that ζA (− j) = Tr A j , so that, since in our case A is a system of GPDOs, the value ζA (− j) is the trace of a local operator. In the case A = Qw (α ,β ) (x, D), we have μ = 2 and n = 1, so that ζQ is meromorphic in C, with at most simple poles that belong to the sequence s j = 1 − j, j ∈ Z+ . But, as we shall see below, by the theorem of Ichinose and Wakayama, or Corollary 7.2.8 to Theorem 7.2.1, we have that ζQ has only one simple pole at s = 1. Moreover, Ichinose and Wakayama prove in addition the remarkable result that ζQ (−2 j) = 0, j ∈ Z+ , i.e. that ζQ has, beyond the zero at s = 0, the same “trivial zeros” of the Riemann zeta function (the negative even integers −2k, k ∈ N). The method of Robert to construct the complex powers of a NCHO (i.e. through a parametrix of the resolvent operator) seems to be not well-suited if one is willing to keep the expressions of the terms of the parametrix Bλ as much explicit as possible, as one can see already in the basic case of Qw (α ,β ) (x, D). Since in a NCHO many symmetries are present (some of them are hidden because of the non-commutativity of the variables x and ξ , and because of the matrix-nature of the system), one should find the way to exploit them to simplify computations (we made some computations, and we could only prove that ζQ (0) = 0). Exercise 7.1.2. Upon computing a few terms in the symbol of the parametrix for H − λ , H = pw 0 (x, D), n = 1, calculate the residues of ζH and its value at − j, j ∈ Z+ , using Robert’s theorem. (See Remark 4.4.5.) In the next section we shall give a proof of the meromorphic continuation of the spectral zeta function ζA of an elliptic N × N NCHO 0 < A = A∗ ∈ OPScl (m2 , g; MN ), with positive principal symbol a2 = a∗2 > 0, by using the parametrix approximation of e−tA constructed in Section 6.1, which will yield Robert’s result in the special, yet meaningful, case of a second order system of GPDOs.
96
7 The Spectral Zeta Function
7.2 The Meromorphic Continuation of ζ A via the Parametrix Approximation of e–tA Let 0 < A = A∗ ∈ OPScl (m2 , g; MN ) be an elliptic N × N NCHO (i.e. an elliptic N × N second order GPD system) with positive principal symbol a2 = a∗2 > 0. Let ζA (s) be the corresponding spectral zeta function. We have the following theorem. Theorem 7.2.1. There exist constants c−2 j,n , 0 ≤ j ≤ n − 1, and constants C j , j ≥ n, such that, for any given integer ν ∈ Z+ with ν ≥ n,
ζA (s) =
$ ν Cj 1 #n−1 c−2 j,n + + H (s) , ν ∑ s−n+ j ∑ s−n+ j Γ (s) j=0 j=n
(7.1)
where Γ (s) is the Euler gamma function, and Hν is holomorphic in the region Re s > −(ν − n) − 1. Consequently, the spectral zeta function ζA (s) is meromorphic in the whole complex plane C with at most simple poles at s = n, n − 1, n − 2, . . . , 1. In particular, when n = 1, ζA has only one simple pole at s = 1. One has (recall (6.31)) −n
c−2 j,n = (2π )
+∞ 0
S2n−1
Tr b−2 j (1, ρω )ρ 2n−1d ρ d ω , 0 ≤ j ≤ n − 1,
(7.2)
where the b−2 j are the terms in the symbol of the parametrix UA ∈ OPScl (2, 0) of Theorem 6.1.4, Remark 6.1.5 and (6.9), UA ∼
∑ B−2 j .
j≥0
Moreover, c0,n = (2π )−n
+∞ 0
S2n−1
Tr(e−a2 (ρω ) )ρ 2n−1 d ρ d ω
is the leading coefficient in the Weyl asymptotics for NA (λ ) (see (6.33) and Theorem 6.3.1). Proof. By the properties of the semigroup 0 ≤ t → e−tA we may use the Mellin transform and write (recall Corollary 4.4.4 with μ = 2) A−s =
1 Γ (s)
+∞ 0
t s−1 e−tA dt, Re s > 2n/2 = n,
so that
ζA (s) = Tr A−s = Let hence UA ∼
1 Γ (s)
+∞
t s−1 Tr e−tA dt.
(7.3)
(7.4)
0
∑ B−2 j ∈ OPScl (2, 0) be the parametrix approximation of e−tA
j≥0
constructed in Theorem 6.1.4 and Remark 6.1.5.
7.2 The Meromorphic Continuation of ζA via the Parametrix Approximation of e−tA
97
Next write
ζA (s) =
1
1 Γ (s)
0
+
+∞
t s−1 Tr e−tA dt =: Z0 (s) + Z∞ (s).
1
(7.5)
In the first place we claim that Z∞ (s) is holomorphic in C. In fact, on the one hand, since t → Tr R(t) is rapidly decreasing for t → +∞ (where R(t) = e−tA − UA(t), see (6.7)), we have that for all p ∈ N and for all t ≥ 1 |Tr R(t)| t −p . On the other, given any ν ≥ 0 and any symbol b ∈ S(2, −2ν ), we have by (6.1) that for all t ≥ 1 and all p ∈ N −n π ) (2
+∞ S2n−1
0
Tr b(t, ρω )ρ 2n−1d ρ d ω
= t −p (2π )−n
t −p
+∞ 0
+∞
S2n−1 2n−1 ρ
t p Tr b(t, ρω )ρ 2n−1d ρ d ω
0
(1 + ρ )2ν +2p
d ρ t −p .
It thus follows that for all p ∈ N and for all t ≥ 1 |TrUA (t)| t −p . In conclusion, since
Tr e−tA = TrUA (t) + TrR(t),
for every p ≥ 1 there exists C p > 0 such that |Tr e−tA | ≤ C pt −p , ∀t ≥ 1, which proves the claim, since the term 1/Γ (s) is already holomorphic in C. Therefore the crux of the matter lies in the study of the function Z0 (s). It is important to be a little more precise on the form of the b−2 j . First of all, let us rewrite the composition formula (3.3) as (ab)(X) ∼ a(X )b(X ) + ∑
j≥1
1 −i j {a, b}( j)(X ), j! 2
where {·, ·}(1) = {·, ·} is the Poisson bracket. Then, from the construction of the parametrix approximation of e−tA , and using the fact that the term a0 in the symbol of A is a constant N × N Hermitian matrix, we have r−2 j = a0 b−2 j + (where we set b2 ≡ 0).
1 −i 2 i {a2 , b−2( j−1)}(2) − {a2 , b−2 j }, j ≥ 0 2 2 2
(7.6)
98
7 The Spectral Zeta Function
Recall hence, by (6.6), that ⎧ −ta (X) ⎪ ⎨ b0 (t, X) = e 2 , ⎪ ⎩ b−2( j+1)(t, X) = −
t 0
e−(t−t )a2 (X) r−2 j (t , X )dt , j ≥ 0.
(7.7)
To have a better understanding of the terms (6.28), j ≥ 0, we need to control the behavior of the b−2 j as t → 0 + . This is provided by the following technical proposition, whose proof is postponed to the end of the section. Proposition 7.2.2. For any given j ≥ 0 we have b−2 j (t, ω ) = O(t j ), t → 0+, and for all α , β ∈ Zn+ , with |α | = 2k + 1, k ≥ 0, and |β | ≤ 1 we have
∂Xα +β b−2 j (t, ω ) = O(t j+k+1 ), t → 0+, where the constants in O(·) do not depend on ω ∈ S2n−1 . Now, taking the proposition for granted, recall that by the homogeneity of the b−2 j (see (6.28)), for t > 0 Tr B−2 j (t) = (2π )−n −n
= (2π )
+∞ S2n−1
0
+∞
1/2 S2n−1
χ (ρω )Tr b−2 j (t, ρω )ρ 2n−1d ρ d ω χ (ρω )Tr b−2 j (ρ 2t, ω )ρ 2(n− j)−1d ρ d ω .
Consider c−2 j,n = (2π )−n
+∞ 0
S2n−1
Tr b−2 j (ρ 2 , ω )ρ 2(n− j)−1d ρ d ω .
We claim that |c−2 j,n | < +∞, ∀ j ∈ Z+ . In fact, the integral is convergent at ρ = +∞ for all j since Tr b−2 j (·, ω ) is a Schwartz function, it is clearly convergent at ρ = 0 for 0 ≤ j ≤ n − 1, and finally it is convergent at ρ = 0 also when j ≥ n, for the singularity at 0 of the factor ρ 2(n− j)−1 is compensated by Tr b−2 j (t, ω ) = O(t j ) as t → 0 + . Define now the functions f j (t) := −(2π )−n
1 0
S2n−1
(1 − χ (ρω ))Trb−2 j (t, ρω )ρ 2n−1d ρ d ω , j ∈ Z+ . (7.8)
7.2 The Meromorphic Continuation of ζA via the Parametrix Approximation of e−tA
99
Then f j ∈ C∞ ([0, +∞); C), for all j ∈ Z+ , and by Proposition 7.2.2 f j (t) = O(t j ), t → 0 + .
(7.9)
It follows that Tr B−2 j (t) = c−2 j,nt −(n− j) + f j (t) = c−2 j,nt −(n− j) + O(t j ), t → 0+,
(7.10)
for all j ≥ 0, and that (by the proof of Proposition 3.2.15 adapted to the present setting), ν
TrUA (t) − ∑ Tr B−2 j (t) =: Tr Rν +1 (t) = O(t ν +1 ), t → 0+, ∀ν ∈ Z+ .
(7.11)
j=0
However, the information contained in (7.10) alone is not yet sufficient to obtain the meromorphic continuation of ζA , and we need a better control of f j . Notice that for (k) all j, k ∈ Z+ , writing ∂tk f j (t) = f j (t), (k)
f j (t) = −(2π )−n
1 0
S2n−1
(1 − χ (ρω ))Tr ∂tk b−2 j (t, ρω )ρ 2n−1d ρ d ω ,
(k)
so that f j (0) is finite and can be computed through (7.6), and through the differential equations (7.20) and (7.24) below used to construct the b−2 j . Note, in particular, that (k)
f0 (0) = (−1)k+1 (2π )−n
1 S2n−1
0
(1 − χ (ρω ))Tra2 (ρω )k ρ 2n−1d ρ d ω .
It is useful now to have the following elementary result. Lemma 7.2.3. Let f ∈ C∞ ([0, 1]; C). Define, for s ∈ C, Re s > 0, F(s) =
1 0
t s−1 f (t)dt.
Then, for any given ν ∈ Z+ , F(s) =
ν
∑
k=0
f (k) (0) 1 + Fν (s), k! s + k
(7.12)
where Fν (s) =
1 ν!
1 0
t s+ν
1 0
(1 − τ )ν f (ν +1) (t τ )d τ dt
(7.13)
100
7 The Spectral Zeta Function
is holomorphic for Re s > −ν − 1. Hence F can be meromorphically continued to the whole complex plane, with at most simple poles at the non-positive integers s = −k, k ∈ Z+ , and f (k) (0) . (7.14) Res(F, −k) = k! In particular, if f (t) = O(t j ) as t → 0+ for some j ∈ Z+ , then F(s) is meromorphic on C with at most simple poles at s = − j − k, k ∈ Z+ . Proof (of Lemma 7.2.3). By Taylor’s formula, for any given ν ∈ Z+ , f (t) =
ν
∑
k=0
1
f (k) (0) k t ν +1 t + k! ν!
0
(1 − τ )ν f (ν +1) (t τ )d τ .
Hence, if ν = 0 and Re s > 0 we write f (t) = f (0) + t F(s) = where
f (0) + s
1 1
ts
0
1 1
ts
0
0
0
1 0
f (t τ )d τ and have
f (t τ )d τ dt,
f (t τ )d τ dt
is holomorphic for Re s > −1. This shows that F can be meromorphically extended for Re s > −1, with possibly a simple pole at s = 0 with residue f (0). Iterating the process using Taylor’s formula gives (7.12) to (7.14). If now f (t) = O(t j ) as t → 0+ for some j ∈ Z+ , we have that F(s) is holomorphic for Re s > − j, and meromorphic on C with at most simple poles at s = − j − k, k ∈ Z+ . This completes the proof of the lemma. We next apply Lemma 7.2.3 to the functions f j , so that for any given ν ∈ Z+ we may write, by (7.9), Fj (s) :=
1
t 0
s−1
f j (t)dt =
ν
∑
k=0
( j+k)
(0) 1 + Fj,ν (s), ( j + k)! s + j + k
fj
where Fj,ν is holomorphic for Re s > − j − ν − 1. Using this in (7.10) gives the following lemma. Lemma 7.2.4. For each j ≥ 0, for any given ν ∈ Z+ , s −→
1
( j+k)
t 0
s−1
ν f (0) c−2 j,n 1 j +∑ + Fj,ν (s), Tr B−2 j (t)dt = s − (n − j) k=0 ( j + k)! s + j + k
where Fj,k is holomorphic for Re s > − j − ν − 1.
7.2 The Meromorphic Continuation of ζA via the Parametrix Approximation of e−tA
101
Analogously, from (6.22) and Lemma 7.2.3 we also have, with fR (t) := Tr R(t), that for any given ν ∈ Z+ 1 0
t s−1 fR (t)dt =
ν
∑
k=0
(k)
fR (0) 1 + FR,ν (s), k! s + k
where FR,ν is holomorphic for Re s > −ν − 1. We therefore obtain that for any given ν ∈ Z+ Z0 (s) =
$ 1 1 1 # ν 1s−1 s−1 s−1 t Tr B (t)dt + t Tr R (t)dt + t Tr R(t)dt . −2 j ν +1 ∑ 0 Γ (s) j=0 0 0
Since the function s →
1 0
t s−1 Tr Rν +1 (t)dt =: Fν +1 (s) is holomorphic for Re s >
−ν − 1, we thus obtain that, for any given ν ∈ Z+ with ν ≥ n, ( j+k)
ν fj (0) 1 1 # ν c−2 j,n + ∑ Z0 (s) = ∑ Γ (s) j=0 s − n + j j,k=0 ( j + k)! s + j + k ν
+∑
k=0
(k) $ ν fR (0) 1 + ∑ Fj,ν (s) + FR,ν (s) + Fν +1 (s) k! s + k j=0
$ ν Cj 1 #n−1 c−2 j,n +∑ + H˜ ν (s) , = ∑ Γ (s) j=0 s − n + j j=n s − n + j
(7.15)
with H˜ ν (s) holomorphic for Re s > −(ν − n) − 1. Since the function 1/Γ (s) is holomorphic in C and has zeros at the non-positive integers −k, k ∈ Z+ , this proves the theorem. As a corollary of the proof of Theorem 7.2.1 one has the following expression of the coefficients C j appearing in (7.15). Corollary 7.2.5. With the notation of the proof of Theorem 7.2.1 one has, for all ≥ 0, C+n = c−2(+n),n +
1 () () f j (0) + fR (0) . ∑ ! j=0
(7.16)
As another corollary of the proof of Theorem 7.2.1, we have the following result on ζA (0). Corollary 7.2.6. We have
ζA (0) = c−2n,n = (2π )−n
+∞ 0
S2n−1
Tr b−2n(ρ 2 , ω )ρ −1 d ρ d ω .
102
7 The Spectral Zeta Function
Proof. In the first place, due to the (simple) pole at s = 0 of Γ (s), we have from (7.5), (7.15) and (7.16) that
ζA (0) = Res(Γ ζA , 0) = c−2n,n + f0 (0) + fR (0). Now, recalling that (see Remark 6.1.5) cA t=0 = χ ICN , we have R(0) = (e−tA − UA(t))
t=0
= (1 − χ )w (x, D) ICN .
Hence fR (0) = Tr R(0) = (2π )−n
+∞ S2n−1
0
(1 − χ (ρω ))Tr(ICN )ρ 2n−1d ρ d ω .
But we also have f0 (0) = −(2π )−n
+∞ 0
S2n−1
(1 − χ (ρω ))Tr(ICN )ρ 2n−1 d ρ d ω ,
whence c−2n,n + f0 (0) + fR (0) = c−2n,n,
which proves the corollary.
Analogously, by looking into the proof of Theorem 7.2.1, one may also compute the values ζA (−k), k ∈ Z+ , by using
ζA (−k) = Res(Γ ζA , −k), (k)
and formulas (7.15) and (7.16). One needs to control fR (0). This may be achieved as follows. For any given ν ∈ Z+ , write again UA (t) =
ν
∑ B−2 j (t) + Rν +1(t).
j=0
Then (
d d + A)R(t) = −( + A)Rν +1(t), dt dt
whence R(t) = e−tA R(0) −
t 0
e−(t−t )A (
d + A)Rν +1(t )dt , dt
(7.17)
7.2 The Meromorphic Continuation of ζA via the Parametrix Approximation of e−tA
103
and for any given k ≥ 1 one may compute from (7.17) by successive differentiations a formula for (k)
fR (0) =
dk Tr R . t=0 dt k
Remark 7.2.7. To obtain explicitly the terms {a2 , b−2 j }() in order to compute the coefficients c−2 j,n , it is covenient to make use of the following formula (see, e.g., Rossmann’s book [66, p. 15]): for α ∈ Zn+ with |α | = 1,
∂Xα ea2 (X) = ea2 (X)
1 − exp(−ad a2 (X )) α ∂X a2 (X ), ad a2 (X)
(7.18)
where ∞ 1 − exp(−ad a2 (X )) (−1)k := ∑ (ad a2 (X))k , ad a2 (X )b = [a2 (X ), b]. ad a2 (X ) (k + 1)! k=0
Recently, M. Hitrik and I. Polterovich have given in [24] (see also [23]), nice formulas for resolvent expansions and trace regularizations for Schr¨odinger operators. A nice problem is that of using these formulas to compute the coefficients c−2 j,n and therefore re-obtain the full result by Wakayama and Ichinose, Theorem 7.3.1 below. When the order of the system is μ , which then must be an even integer by Lemma 3.2.13, one can prove the analog of Theorem 7.2.1, that is, that ζA has a meromorphic continuation to the whole complex plane with at most simple poles at s = 2(n − j)/ μ , j ∈ Z+ . However, in this case the analog of Proposition 7.2.2 is much more involved, and we leave the (non trivial) details to the interested reader. We just give the following formula for the terms rμ −2ν , ν ≥ 1: rμ −2ν =
ν −1
∑
j=max(ν − μ2 ,0)
+
μ 2 −1
∑
k=0
aμ −2(ν − j)b−2 j
−i ν −k− j 1 {aμ −2k , b−2 j }(ν −k− j) . (ν − k − j)! 2 j=max(ν − μ +k,0) ν −1−k
∑
(7.19) Notice that ζA is still continuous at s = 0, and that the zero of the factor 1/Γ (s) at s = −2k now cancels the pole at s = 2(n − j)/ μ of Γ ζA only when j is such that 2n − 2 j = −2 μ k, i.e. j = n + μ k. We hence expect, for μ > 2, a sequence of simple poles also for Re s < 0. Specializing to the case A = Qw (α ,β ) (x, D), we have the following corollary of Theorem 7.2.1.
104
7 The Spectral Zeta Function
Corollary 7.2.8. Consider an elliptic NCHO Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) (α , β > 0 and αβ > 1). Then the associated spectral zeta function ζQ can be meromorphically continued to the whole complex place C with only one simple pole at s = 1. We close this section by providing the proof of Proposition 7.2.2. Proof (of Proposition 7.2.2). We won’t be writing the dependence on ω , and we () will write b−2 j for a generic ∂Xα b−2 j with |α | = . (2)
(2)
(1)
(1)
Denote by E(a2 , b−2 j ), resp. E(a2 , b−2 j ), a generic expression obtained by taking the (matrix) product of derivatives of order 2, resp. order 1, of a2 with derivatives of order 2, resp. order 1, of b−2 j . Hence for all j ≥ 0 we may generically write (1)
(1)
(2)
(2)
{a2 , b−2 j } = E(a2 , b−2 j ), and {a2 , b−2 j }(2) = E(a2 , b−2 j ). Notice, therefore, that in {a2, b−2 j }(2) we have a constant-coefficient matrix (given by partial derivatives of order 2 of a2 ) times partial derivatives of order 2 of b−2 j . We proceed by induction. We start with the case j = 0. In this case b0 is the solution of ⎧ ⎨ ∂t b0 + a2 b0 = 0, (7.20) ⎩ b0 t=0 = I, whence b0 (t) = O(1) as t → 0 + . () Next, by induction on we show that b0 has the claimed property. For = 1 we take a 1st-order partial derivative with respect to X of (7.20) and have ⎧ (1) (1) (1) ⎪ ⎨ ∂t b0 + a2b0 = −a2 b0 , (7.21) ⎪ ⎩ (1) b0 t=0 = 0, whence (1)
b0 (t) = −
t 0
(1)
e−(t−t )a2 a2 b0 (t )dt = O(t), t → 0 + .
(7.22)
For = 2 we take a 1st-order partial derivative with respect to X of (7.22) (of course, we may equivalently use again (7.20) by taking an extra derivative of (7.21)) and have (2)
b0 (t) = − −
t 0
t 0
(1)
(e−(t−t )a2 )(1) a2 b0 (t )dt −
t 0
(2)
e−(t−t )a2 a2 b0 (t )dt
(1) (1)
e−(t−t )a2 a2 b0 (t )dt
= O(t 2 ) + O(t) + O(t 2) = O(t), t → 0 + . (2k−1+)
Next, suppose b0
(t) = O(t k ) as t → 0+, for = 0, 1 and all k ≥ 0 We want to
(2k+1+) (t) = O(t k+1 ), as t prove that b0
→ 0+, for = 0, 1. Using (7.20) and taking a
7.2 The Meromorphic Continuation of ζA via the Parametrix Approximation of e−tA
105
()
2k + 1-st partial derivative with respect to X we get (recall that a2 = 0 for all ≥ 3, as a2 is a polynomial in X of degree 2) ⎧ (2k+1) (2k+1) (1) (2k) (2) (2k−1) ⎪ + a2 b0 = −a2 b0 − a2 b0 = O(t k ) + O(t k ) = O(t k ), ⎨ ∂t b0 ⎪ ⎩
(2k+1) = t=0
b0
(2k+1)
whence b0
(2k+2)
b0
0,
(t) = O(t k+1 ) as t → 0 + . Then, as before,
(t) = − −
t 0
t
= O(t
(1) (2k)
(2) (2k−1)
(∂X (e−(t−t )a2 )) (a2 b0 (t ) + a2 b0
(t ))dt
(1) (2k) (2) (2k−1) e−(t−t )a2 ∂X a2 b0 (t ) + a2 b0 (t ) dt
0 k+2
) + O(t k+1 ) = O(t k+1 ), t → 0 + .
Hence the result is proved for b0 . So suppose, by induction, that (2k+1+)
b−2 j (t) = O(t j ), b−2 j
(t) = O(t j+k+1 ), t → 0+, = 0, 1.
We prove the result for b−2( j+1). To do so, we have to examine r−2 j (see (7.7)). In the first place we have from (7.6) r−2 j (t) = O(t j ) + O(t j−1+1) + O(t j+1) = O(t j ), t → 0 + . Consider next, keeping into account the fact that a0 is a constant matrix, (2k+1)
r−2 j
(2k+1)
= a0 b−2 j
(2)
(2+2k+1)
(2)
(2k+1)
+ E(a2 , b−2( j−1) ) + E(a2 , b−2 j
(1)
(2k+2)
) + E(a2 , b−2 j
)
= O(t j+k+1 ) + O(t j−1+k+2) + O(t j+k+1) + O(t j+k+1) = O(t j+k+1 ), t → 0 + . Taking an extra derivative, one immediately sees also that (2k+2)
r−2 j
= O(t j+k+1 ), t → 0 + .
Hence (2k+1+)
r−2 j
= O(t j+k+1 ), t → 0+, = 0, 1, ∀k ≥ −1
(7.23)
(when k = −1 we take = 1). Since ⎧ ⎨ ∂t b−2( j+1) + a2b−2( j+1) = −r−2 j , ⎩
b−2( j+1)t=0 = 0,
(7.24)
106
7 The Spectral Zeta Function
we obtain b−2( j+1)(t) = O(t j+1 ) as t → 0 + . As before, taking one partial derivative with respect to X yields ⎧ (1) (1) (1) (1) (1) j+1 j+1 ⎪ ⎨ ∂t b−2( j+1) + a2 b−2( j+1) = −E(a2 , b−2( j+1)) − r−2 j = O(t ) + O(t ), ⎪ ⎩
(1) b−2( j+1)t=0 = 0, (1)
whence it follows that b−2( j+1)(t) = O(t j+2 ), and, taking an extra derivative, also that, as t → 0+, (2)
b−2( j+1)(t) = −∂X
t 0
(1) (1) (1) e−(t−t )a2 E(a2 , b−2( j+1)) + r−2 j dt = O(t j+2 ).
Supposing then by induction the estimates up to order 2k − 1, using ⎧ (2k+1) (2k+1) (1) (2k) (2) (2k−1) (2k+1) ∂t b−2( j+1) + a2b−2( j+1) = −E(a2 , b−2( j+1) ) − E(a2 , b−2( j+1)) − r−2 j ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨ = O(t j+1+k ) + O(t j+1+k ) + O(t j+1+k ), ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ (2k+1) b−2( j+1) t=0 = 0, (2k+1)
we get b−2( j+1)(t) = O(t j+1+k+1 ), as t → 0+, and using (2k+2)
b−2( j+1)(t) t (1) (2k) (2) (2k−1) (2k+1) dt , e−(t−t )a2 E(a2 , b−2( j+1)) + E(a2 , b−2( j+1)) + r−2 j = −∂X 0
also that (2k+2)
b−2( j+1)(t) = O(t j+1+k+1 ), t → 0+, which proves the proposition.
7.3 The Ichinose–Wakayama Theorem In this section we want to outline the proof of Ichinose-Wakayama’s theorem on the spectral zeta function ζQ of our elliptic NCHO Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) (for α , β > 0 and αβ > 1). It is worth noting that, by Corollary 4.1 of Parmeggiani-Wakayama [59, p. 555], when α = β > 1 one has that Qw (x, D) is unitarily equivalent to the (α ,α ) scalar harmonic oscillator ∂ 2 x2
' 1 0 x 2 , α −1 − + 2 2 0 1
7.3 The Ichinose–Wakayama Theorem
107
√ which has eigenvalues α 2 − 1( j + 1/2), j ≥ 0, all of multiplicity 2. We therefore have that when α = β > 1
ζQ (s) = 2
2s − 1 ζ (s), (α 2 − 1)s/2
(7.25)
where ζ is the Riemann zeta function. Hence, when α = β > 1, ζQ has a meromorphic extension to the whole complex plane C with one single simple pole at s = 1 and it is zero at the non-positive integers −2k, k ∈ Z+ . Notice that the negative integers −2k, k ∈ N, are the so-called “trivial zeros” of ζ . We may hence say that ζQ has trivial zeros at the non-positive even integers. The fact that all this holds true also when α = β is a remarkable and elegant theorem due to Ichinose and Wakayama [31]. Theorem 7.3.1. There exist constants CQ, j , j ∈ N, such that ζQ (s) is represented, for every integer ν ∈ N, as
ζQ (s) =
$ ν CQ, j 1 α +β 1 # ' +∑ + HQ,ν (s) , Γ (s) αβ (αβ − 1) s − 1 j=1 s + 2 j − 1
(7.26)
where Γ (s) is the Euler gamma function, and HQ,ν is holomorphic in Re s > −2ν . Consequently, the spectral zeta function ζQ (s) is meromorphic in the whole complex plane C with a simple pole at s = 1, and has zeros (the so-called “trivial zeros”) for 0, −2, −4, . . . (the non-positive even integers 2Z− ). The non-positive even integers 2Z− , the “trivial zeros” of ζQ (s), are due to the presence of the function 1/Γ (s), which is holomorphic in C with zeros at the non-positive integers Z− = {0, −1, −2, . . .}, in the expression of ζQ (s). As already observed above, the negative trivial zeros are the same as those of Riemann’s ζ . As already mentioned in Chapter 6, Section 6.4, the use of Ikehara’s theorem gives the following corollary of Theorem 7.3.1 (Weyl’s law of the asymptotics of large eigenvalues; see Theorem 6.3.1, Corollary 6.3.2 and Remark 6.3.3; see also Theorem 5.2 in Parmeggiani [52]).
Corollary 7.3.2. N(λ ) =
α +β 1∼ ' λ , as λ → +∞. αβ (αβ − 1) λ j <λ
∑
Remark 7.3.3. Notice that the fact that ζQ has only one simple pole at s = 1 is a consequence of Theorem 7.2.1. But (7.26) gives a much more precise result, for it also states that ζQ (−2k) = 0 for k ∈ Z+ . As already remarked, obtaining this information from Theorem 7.2.1 is in principle also possible. We leave it to the reader to explore this direction.
108
7 The Spectral Zeta Function
Proof (sketch of proof of Theorem 7.3.1). Write for short Q in place of Qw (α ,β ) (x, D).
Because of the properties of the semigroup 0 ≤ t → e−tQ we may use Mellin’s transform and write +∞ 1 Q−s = t s−1 e−tQ dt, Re s > 1, (7.27) Γ (s) 0 so that
ζQ (s) = Tr Q Write
ζQ (s) =
1 Γ (s)
−s
1 = Γ (s)
1 0
+
+∞ 0
t s−1 Tr e−tQ dt, Re s > 1.
(7.28)
+∞
t s−1 Tr e−tQ dt =: Z0 (s) + Z∞ (s).
1
One then readily sees (as before) that Z∞ (s) is holomorphic in C, so that the crux of the matter lies, as before, in the study of the function Z0 (s), and for this, Ichinose and Wakayama need an asymptotic expansion for t > 0 of the kind Tr e−tQ ∼ c−1t −1 + c0 + c1t + c2t 2 + . . . , 0 < t → 0 + .
α 0 Put A = , and define the pseudodifferential operator P1 (t) (a quantization 0 β “to the right”) by P1 (t, x, D)u(x) = (2π )−1
ei(x−y)ξ e−t
A(y2 +ξ 2 )/2+iJyξ
u(y)dyd ξ , u ∈ S (R; C2 ).
Next put R2 (t) = e−tQ − P1(t). Ichinose and Wakayama then prove that 1 α +β 1 1 + Z0 (s) = ' αβ (αβ − 1) Γ (s) s − 1 Γ (s)
1 0
t s−1 Tr R2 (t) dt,
(7.29)
whence it follows that it suffices to treat the second term on the right-hand side of (7.29). We now use the heat-equation: 0 = (∂t + Q)e−tQ = (∂t + Q)P1(t) + (∂t + Q)R2(t), so that (∂t + Q)R2 (t) = −(∂t + Q)P1 (t) =: S(t).
(7.30)
By the Duhamel principle we may solve (7.30) obtaining R2 (t) = whence
t 0
e−(t−t )Q S(t )dt =
t 0
P1 (t − t ) + R2 (t − t ) S(t )dt =: P2 (t) + R3(t),
e−tQ = P1 (t) + P2(t) + R3 (t),
7.3 The Ichinose–Wakayama Theorem
109
and by repeating the process e−tQ = P1 (t) + P2(t) + . . . + Pν (t) + Rν +1(t). One has therefore to study Tr Pk (t) and Tr Rν +1 (t) for 0 < t → 0 + . One has that for any given (sufficiently small) ε > 0 there exist positive constants Cε (independent of t) and C (independent of t and ν ) such that |Tr R2 (t)| ≤ Cε t −ε , and |Tr Rν +1 (t)| ≤ Cν
Γ (1/2)ν ν /2 t , ν ≥ 1. Γ (1 + ν /2)
(7.31)
This yields that the Mellin transform of Tr R2 (t) is holomorphic in Re s > ε , and hence in Re s > 0, for ε is arbitrary, and that the Mellin tranform of TrRν +1 (t) (ν ≥ 1) is holomorphic in the region Re s > −ν /2. As for the Pk (t) terms, Ichinose and Wakayama then prove, by highly non-trivial computations, that Tr Pk (t) ∼
∑ ck, j t j ,
for k = 2, 3, . . . , and for t → 0+,
(7.32)
j≥0
with ck, j = 0 for 2 ≤ j < k − 2 and j ∈ 2N. It follows that
α +β Tr P1 (t) = ' t −1 , αβ (αβ − 1) and that Tr P2 (t) Tr P3 (t) Tr P4 (t) Tr P5 (t) Tr P6 (t) ... Tr Rν +1 (t)
∼ ∼ ∼ ∼ ∼
c2,1t + c2,3t 3 + c2,5t 5 + c2,7t 7 + c2,9t 9 + . . . c3,1t + c3,3t 3 + c3,5t 5 + c3,7t 7 + c3,9t 9 + . . . c4,3t 3 + c4,5t 5 + c4,7t 7 + c4,9t 9 + . . . c5,3t 3 + c5,5t 5 + c5,7t 7 + c5,9t 9 + . . . c6,5t 5 + c6,7t 7 + c6,9t 9 + . . .
= O(t ν /2 ).
Via the Mellin transform we thus obtain
ζQ (s) =
1 α +β 1 1 1 ' + (c2,1 + c3,1) Γ (s) αβ (αβ − 1) s − 1 Γ (s) s + 1 1 1 +(c2,3 + c3,3 + c4,3 + c5,3) Γ (s) s + 3 1 1 1 + ...+ HQ,ν (s), +(c2,5 + c3,5 + c4,5 + c5,5 + c6,5) Γ (s) s + 5 Γ (s)
which concludes the proof.
110
7 The Spectral Zeta Function
Problem 7.3.4. Compute the constants CQ, j appearing in the statement of Theorem 7.3.1 by using the parametrix approximation of e−tA , as in the proof of Theorem 7.2.1 (see also Corollary 7.2.5).
7.4 Notes In the outline of the proof Theorem 7.3.1 and its consequences we followed Ichinose and Wakayama’s paper [33]. We address the reader to the papers by Ichinose and Wakayama [32], by Kimoto and Wakayama [36] (see also the references therein), and by Ochiai [48] for important work on the special values of the spectral ζQ . This direction of problems is very deep, interesting and promising.
Chapter 8
Some Properties of the Eigenvalues of Qw (α ,β ) (x, D)
In this chapter we shall show some properties of the eigenvalues of a NCHO Q(α ,β ) (when αβ > 1 and α , β > 0), and in particular give some upper and lower bounds to the lowest eigenvalue. In the first place, we establish the following simple consequence of Theorem 3.1.12, which is useful when one is willing to study the behavior of the eigenvalues of the NCHO Q(α ,β ) with respect to α , β ∈ R. Lemma 8.0.1. We have that, for any given α , β ∈ R, the symbols Q(α ,β )(x, ξ ) and Q(β ,α ) (x, ξ ) have the same eigenvalues, for all (x, ξ ) ∈ R × R, and, at the operator w level, Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) is unitarily equivalent to Q(β ,α ) (x, D), that is, there exists a unitary transformation U : L2 (R; C2 ) −→ L2 (R; C2 ) such that w U ∗ Qw (α ,β ) (x, D)U = Q(β ,α ) (x, D).
Moreover, U is an automorphism of S (R; C2 ) and S (R; C2 ), so that the operators w Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) and Q(β ,α ) (x, D) are also equivalent in S and S .
0 −1 0 1 α 0 ,J= , and K = . Consider the system Proof. Let A = 1 0 1 0 0 β
KQ(α ,β ) (x, ξ )K = KAK p0 (x, ξ ) − iJxξ . β 0 , by considering the symplectic transformation κ : R × R 0 α (x, ξ ) −→ (ξ , −x) ∈ R × R, we have that
As KAK =
Q(β ,α ) (x, ξ ) = KQ(α ,β ) K ◦ κ (x, ξ ). It thus follows, since Tr Q(α ,β ) (x, ξ ) = Tr Q(α ,β ) (ξ , −x),
A. Parmeggiani, Spectral Theory of Non-Commutative Harmonic Oscillators: An Introduction, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1992, c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2010 DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-11922-4 8,
111
8 Some Properties of the Eigenvalues of Qw (α ,β ) (x, D)
112
and
detQ(α ,β ) (x, ξ ) = det Q(α ,β )(ξ , −x),
that Q(α ,β ) (x, ξ ) and Q(β ,α )(x, ξ ) have exactly the same eigenvalues, and that by Theorem 3.1.12, with Uκ the metaplectic operator (the normalized Fourier transform) associated with κ , −1 w w Qw (β ,α ) (x, D) = Uκ KQ(α ,β ) (x, D)KUκ = (KQ(α ,β ) K ◦ κ ) (x, D)
are unitarily equivalent, for U := KUκ : L2 (R; C2 ) −→ L2 (R; C2 ) is unitary. Since clearly U is also an automorphism of S (R; C2 ) and S (R; C2 ), this concludes the proof of the lemma. From now on, unless otherwise specified, we shall assume α , β > 0 and αβ > 1, so that Q = Qw (α ,β ) is elliptic and positive (as a differential operator), and hence has a discrete spectrum contained in R+ .
8.1 The Ichinose and Wakayama Bounds In [33] Ichinose and Wakayama proved the following theorem about estimates on upper and lower bounds for the eigenvalues of Q. Theorem 8.1.1. Let λ2 j−1 , λ2 j , j = 1, 2, . . . , be the (2 j − 1)-st and 2 j-th eigenvalues of Q. Then ( 1 ( j − ) min{α , β } 2
αβ − 1 1 ≤ λ2 j−1 ≤ λ2 j ≤ ( j − ) max{α , β } αβ 2
(
αβ − 1 . αβ (8.1)
Proof. Put K(t) = K(t, x, y) = e−tQ (x, y), t > 0. Then (∂t + Q)K(t) = 0, K t=0 = δ (x − y). Now, following Parmeggiani-Wakayama [58, 59], define −∂x2 + x2 1 ) + γ J(x∂x + ) 2 2 1 1 − γ2 2 x , = (−i∂x + iγ Jx)2 + 2 2
Q := A−1/2 QA−1/2 = I(
' where γ := 1/ αβ . One then has that K (t) = e−tQ (x, y) solves (∂t + Q )K (t) = 0, K t=0 = δ (x − y),
8.1 The Ichinose and Wakayama Bounds
113
and K (t, x, y) = (1 − γ 2)1/4 eγ (x
2 −y2 )J/2
where
' ' ' pH ( 1 − γ 2 t, 1 − γ 2 x, 1 − γ 2 y),
pH (t, x, y) = e−tH (x, y)
is the heat-kernel of the harmonic oscillator H = pw 0 . This follows from [58] (see also [59]), for Q is unitarily equivalent to 1 1 Q0 := γ I −∂x2 + ( 2 − 1)x2 , 2 γ so that
" 1 1 − γ 2( j − ); j ≥ 1 , 2 with each eigenvalue of multiplicity 2. Therefore, it also follows that Spec(Q ) =
ζQ (s) = Tr Q
−s
!'
= (1 − γ 2)−s/2 ζQ0 (s) = 2
2s − 1 ζ (s). (1 − γ 2)s/2
Now, since each eigenvalue λ j of Q has multiplicity 2, we have that the (2 j − 1)-st eigenvalue λ2 j−1 and the 2 j-th eigenvalue λ2 j coincide and ( ' αβ − 1 1 1 λ2 j−1 = λ2 j = ( j − ) 1 − γ 2 = ( j − ) . 2 2 αβ We now use the fact that
Q = A1/2 Q A1/2 ,
and the Minimax Principle (4.1). For n = 2 j − 1 or n = 2 j, with [u1 , . . . , un−1 ]⊥ := Span(u1 , . . . , un−1 )⊥ ∩ D(Q), D(Q) being the domain of Q, we thus have that %
λn = =
sup
u1 ,...,un−1 lin. ind.
sup
u1 ,...,un−1 lin. ind.
%
(Qu, u) inf 2 0=u∈[u1 ,...,un−1 ]⊥ ||u||0
&
(Q A1/2 u, A1/2 u) inf ||u||20 0=u∈[u1 ,...,un−1 ]⊥
&
(note that the vectors u1 , . . . , un−1 are linearly independent if and only if the vectors A−1/2 u1 , . . . , A−1/2 un−1 are linearly independent, for A1/2 : L2 (R; C2 ) −→ L2 (R; C2 ) is an isomorphism, i.e. bounded with bounded inverse, and that u ∈ D(Q) or u ∈ D(Q ) if and only if A−1/2 u does)
8 Some Properties of the Eigenvalues of Qw (α ,β ) (x, D)
114
%
(Q A1/2 u, A1/2 u) inf = sup ||u||20 u1 ,...,un−1 lin. ind. 0=u∈[A−1/2 u1 ,...,A−1/2 un−1 ]⊥ % & (Q A1/2 u, A1/2 u) inf = sup ||u||20 u1 ,...,un−1 lin. ind. 0=A1/2 u∈[u1 ,...,un−1 ]⊥
&
(putting v = A1/2 u) % = =
sup
u1 ,...,un−1 lin. ind.
%
sup
u1 ,...,un−1 lin. ind.
(Q v, v) inf 2 0=v∈[u1 ,...,un−1 ]⊥ ||A−1/2 v||0
&
(Q v, v) ||v||20 inf 2 2 0=v∈[u1 ,...,un−1 ]⊥ ||v||0 ||A−1/2 v||0
& .
Put m = min{α , β } and M = max{α , β }. Then M −1 ||v||20 ≤ (A−1 v, v) = ||A−1/2 v||20 ≤ m−1 ||v||20 , ∀v ∈ L2 (R; C2 ), and m≤
||v||20 ≤ M, ∀v = 0. ||A−1/2 v||20
We thus have %
λ2 j−1 ≤ λ2 j ≤ M
sup
u1 ,...,u2 j−1 lin.ind.
(Q v, v) inf 2 0=v∈[u1 ,...,u2 j−1 ]⊥ ||v||0
&
= M λ2 j = M λ2 j−1 , and %
λ2 j ≥ λ2 j−1 ≥ m
sup
u1 ,...,u2 j−2 lin. ind.
(Q v, v) inf 2 0=v∈[u1 ,...,u2 j−2 ]⊥ ||v||0
& = mλ2 j−1 ,
which concludes the proof. The bounds in (8.1) make up an interval #
(
1 I j := ( j − ) min{α , β } 2
αβ − 1 1 , ( j − ) max{α , β } αβ 2
When j < k we have I j ∩ Ik = 0/ ⇐⇒
2k − 1 max{α , β } > . 2j−1 min{α , β }
(
αβ − 1 $ . αβ
8.2 A Better Upper-Bound for the Lowest Eigenvalue
115
It follows that the eigenvalue λ2 j−1 or λ2 j has a multiplicity less than or equal to 2 if j<
|α + β | max{α , β } + min{α , β } = . 2(max{α , β } − min{α , β }) 2|α − β |
Otherwise, the eigenvalue will possibly happen to have a multiplicity greater than 2. However, we will see in Chapter 12, Section 12.4, that, as a consequence of a more general argument (see Section 12.3), under certain assumptions on the periods of the Hamilton-trajectories associated with the eigenvalues of the symbol, the spectrum of Qw (x, D) “clusters” and is simple (see also Parmeggiani [52, 55]). (α ,β ) As regards the lowest eigenvalue, it was shown by Nakao, Nagatou and Wakayama in [45], and by Parmeggiani in [51], that it is always simple for αβ large. Moreover, in [51], using perturbation theory in the limit αβ → +∞ and α /β a fixed constant = 1, it is seen that the lowest eigenvalue is always smaller, for αβ sufficiently large (α /β =constant= 1), than the lowest eigenvalue of the operator
α 0 −∂x2 x2 + ). ( 2 2 0 β
Perturbation theory may be used, for one writes Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) =
'
⎤ & %⎡ ) α − ∂ 2 + x2 0 1 1 β x ⎦ ⎣ ) +' . αβ J x∂x + β 2 2 αβ 0 α
' ' Put then ε = 1/ αβ → 0+ and ω0 = α /β with ω0 fixed with ω0 = 1. Since
Qw ω0 (x, D) =
ω0 0 −∂x2 + x2 , 2 0 ω0−1
is an elliptic system of GPDOs, it therefore possesses a parametrix. It is then 1 w easy to see that E (x, D) = J x∂x + 2 is bounded with respect to Qw ω0 (x, D) (see Kato’s book [35]). Hence Rellich’s theory can be applied as ε → 0+ to study the spectrum of w w ε Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) = Qω0 (x, D) + ε E (x, D), in terms of the spectrum of Qw ω0 (x, D). See Parmeggiani [51] for more on this.
8.2 A Better Upper-Bound for the Lowest Eigenvalue We now show, by using some elementary symplectic linear algebra, how to obtain an upper bound for the lowest eigenvalue of Q which is more accurate than that of Theorem 8.1.1.
8 Some Properties of the Eigenvalues of Qw (α ,β ) (x, D)
116
Theorem 8.2.1. For the lowest eigenvalue λ1 of Q we have ( 1 min{α , β } 2
' ' αβ αβ − 1 αβ − 1 ≤ λ1 ≤ , 1/4 αβ α + β + |α − β | (αβ√−1) Re ω
(8.2)
αβ
where ω ∈ C is the solution of ω 2 =
' αβ − 1 − i with Re ω > 0.
Remark 8.2.2. Since, as is readily seen, ' αβ − 1 1 ≤ max{α , β } ' , (αβ −1)1/4 2 αβ α + β + |α − β | √ Re ω ' ' αβ αβ − 1 αβ
the upper bound in (8.2) is better then the one by Ichinose and Wakayama given in (8.1). √ When α = β all the bounds reduce to the actual value of λ1 = α 2 − 1/2. Proof (of Theorem 8.2.1). The lower bound in (8.2) has already been proved in Theorem 8.1.1. ' Let e(x, ξ ) := xξ , and δ := αβ . We may therefore write 1 1/2 w A δ p0 (x, D)I + iJew (x, D) A1/2 . δ
1 1 Let next v± = √ be the normalized eigenvectors of J, so that Jv± = ±iv± . 2 ∓i Notice that KJv± = v∓ . Set 1 Lδ (x, ξ ) := ξ 2 + (δ 2 − 1)x2 ). 2 Consider the following symplectic transformations of R × R, and the corresponding metaplectic operators, Q=
κδ (x, ξ ) = (δ 1/2 x,
1
δ 1/2
ξ ), (Uδ f )(x) =
1
δ 1/4
κ± (x, ξ ) = (x, ξ ± x), (U± f )(x) = e±ix
2 /2
Define also
w w aw ± (x, D) := δ p0 (x, D) ∓ e (x, D).
' √ With μ± := ( α ± β )/2, we may write A−1/2 =
1 μ+ I − μ− KJ . δ
f(
x
δ 1/2
f (x).
),
8.2 A Better Upper-Bound for the Lowest Eigenvalue
117
We also write f = f+ v+ + f− v− , ∀ f ∈ S (R; C2 ). Let hence
λ1 =
=
inf
0= f ∈S (R;C2 )
(Q f , f ) || f ||20 % & w w δ p0 (x, D)I + iJe (x, D) ( f+ v+ + f− v− ), f+ v+ + f− v−
inf
δ ||A−1/2 ( f+ v+ + f− v− )||20
0= f + v+ + f − v− ∈S (R;C2 )
.
In the basis {v+ , v− } of C2 , w δ pw 0 (x, D)I + iJe (x, D) ( f + v+ + f − v− ) is represented by
0 aw + (x, D) (x, D) 0 aw −
f+ , f−
for we have that w w w δ pw 0 (x, D)I + iJe (x, D) ( f + v+ + f − v− ) = (δ p0 (x, D) − e (x, D)) f + v+ w v− + (δ pw (x, D) + e (x, D)) f − 0 w = (aw + (x, D) f + )v+ + (a− (x, D) f − )v− .
Hence, {v+ , v− } being a unitary basis of C2 ,
λ1 =
w (aw 1 + (x, D) f + , f + ) + (a− (x, D) f − , f − ) inf . δ 0= f+ v+ + f− v− ∈S (R;C2 ) ||A−1/2 ( f+ v+ + f− v− )||20
Now, it is readily seen that
δ p0 (x, ξ ) ∓ xξ = (Lδ ◦ κ∓ ◦ κδ−1)(x, ξ ). Hence, by Theorem 3.1.12, we have −1 w w −1 aw ± (x, D) = (Lδ ◦ κ∓ ◦ κδ ) (x, D) = Uδ (Lδ ◦ κ∓ ) (x, D)Uδ −1 = Uδ U∓−1 Lw δ (x, D)U∓Uδ .
One next computes A−1/2 ( f+ v+ + f− v− ) =
1 (μ+ f+ − μ− f− )v+ + (μ+ f− − μ− f+ )v− , δ
8 Some Properties of the Eigenvalues of Qw (α ,β ) (x, D)
118
whence ||A−1/2 ( f+ v+ + f− v− )||20 =
1 2 2 || μ f − μ f || + || μ f − μ f || + + − − + − − + 0 0 . δ2
We thus have *
λ1 = δ
inf
(0,0)=( f+ , f − )∈S (R,C2 )
−1 −1 (Lw δ (x, D)U−Uδ f + ,U−Uδ f + ) ||μ+ f+ − μ− f− ||20 + ||μ+ f− − μ− f+ ||20
+ −1 −1 (Lw δ (x, D)U+Uδ f − ,U+Uδ f − ) . + ||μ+ f+ − μ− f− ||20 + ||μ+ f− − μ− f+ ||20 Let ϕ0 = ϕ0 (x) = ce−(αβ −1) that ||ϕ0 ||0 = 1. Thus
1/2 x2 /2
be the ground state of Lw δ (x, D), with c so chosen
&1/2 % ' 1/4 αβ − 1 αβ − 1) ( √ Lw ϕ0 , and c = . δ (x, D)ϕ0 = 2 π We now choose f± to be f± = Uδ U∓−1 ϕ0 , that is 1
f± (x) =
δ 1/4
2 /2δ
e±ix
ϕ0 (
x
δ 1/2
).
It follows that 1' αβ − 1. 2
(aw ± (x, D) f ± , f ± ) = Now, for r, s ∈ R, 2 /2
||r f+ + s f− ||20 = ||(reix
+ se−ix
2 /2
)ϕ0 ||20
= (r2 + s2 )||ϕ0 ||20 + 2rs
cos(x2 )|ϕ0 (x)|2 dx,
so that
2 2 2 2 2 ( μ + μ ) − 2 μ μ cos(x )| ϕ (x)| dx + − 0 + − δ2 1 = 2 α + β − (α − β ) cos(x2 )|ϕ0 (x)|2 dx . δ
||A−1/2 f ||20 =
8.2 A Better Upper-Bound for the Lowest Eigenvalue
119
We next compute
cos(x2 )|ϕ0 (x)|2 dx = =
(αβ − 1)1/4 √ π
cos(x2 )e−
(αβ − 1)1/4 √ Re π
e−(
√
αβ −1x2
dx
√
αβ −1−i)x2
dx.
' Let ω ∈ C be the unique solution to ω 2 = αβ − 1 − i with Re ω > 0. Then, as is well-known, √ √ π −( αβ −1−i)x2 e dx = , ω whence
cos(x2 )|ϕ0 (x)|2 dx =
(αβ − 1)1/4 √ 1 (αβ − 1)1/4 √ ' π Re = Re ω , ω π αβ
and ||A−1/2 f ||20 =
1 (αβ − 1)1/4 α + β − (α − β ) ' Re ω > 0. αβ αβ
We therefore have that √ 1 λ1 ≤ ' αβ =
αβ −1 2
√
αβ −1 2 (αβ −1)1/4 − (α − β ) √ Re ω αβ
+
α +β ' ' αβ αβ − 1
1 αβ
α + β − (α − β ) (αβ√−1)
1/4
αβ
Re ω
.
w Since, by Lemma 8.0.1, Qw (α ,β ) (x, D) and Q(β ,α ) (x, D) are unitarily equivalent, they have the same lowest eigenvalue. Thus (with the same ω )
λ1 ≤ min
⎧ ⎪ ⎨
' ' αβ αβ − 1
' ' αβ αβ − 1
αβ
αβ
⎫ ⎪ ⎬
, , 1/4 1/4 ⎪ ⎩ α + β − (α − β ) (αβ√−1) Re ω α + β − (β − α ) (αβ√−1) Re ω ⎪ ⎭
that is
λ1 ≤
' ' αβ αβ − 1
α + β + |α − β | (αβ√−1)
1/4
αβ
Re ω
.
This shows that inequality (8.2) holds and concludes the proof of the theorem.
120
8 Some Properties of the Eigenvalues of Qw (α ,β ) (x, D)
8.3 Notes The problem of determining the lowest eigenvalue, and its multiplicity, of a generic elliptic positive NCHO is an open, and important, problem, which should be explored in depth.
Chapter 9
Some Tools from the Semiclassical Calculus
In this chapter we shall describe some tools from Semiclassical Analysis, that will be used in the subsequent chapters to obtain localization properties of the large eigenvalues of an elliptic positive NCHO Qw (α ,β ) (x, D), and more generally of an elliptic positive NCHO (with no sub-principal term), relating them to properties of the periods of the bicharacteristics of the (principal) symbol.
9.1 The Semiclassical Calculus We recall here some basic properties of semiclassical the Weyl-quantization and the semiclassical calculus. (In general, for Semiclassical Analysis, we address the reader to Dimassi-Sj¨ostrand [7], Evans-Zworski [15], Ivrii [34], Martinez [40], Robert [65], Shubin [67] and Voros [71].) Definition 9.1.1 (Semiclassical symbols). We shall say that a function a(X ; h) = a(·; h) ∈ C∞ (R2n X ), possibly depending on a parameter h ∈ (0, h0 ], h0 ∈ (0, 1], belongs to the symbol class Sδk (mμ , g), k, μ ∈ R and δ ∈ [0, 1/2], if for all α ∈ Z2n + there exists Cα > 0 such that |∂Xα a(X ; h)| ≤ Cα m(X)μ −|α | h−k−|α |δ , ∀X ∈ R2n , ∀h ∈ (0, h0 ].
(9.1)
As before, Sδk (mμ , g; MN ) = Sδk (mμ , g) ⊗ MN , and Sδk (mμ , g; V) = Sδk (mμ , g) ⊗ V, for any given finite-dimensional complex vector space V. Given a ∈ Sδk (mμ , g; V), we shall consider its h-Weyl quantization aw (x, hD)u(x) = (2π h)−n
eih
−1 x−y,ξ
a(
x+y , ξ ; h)u(y)dyd ξ , u ∈ S . 2
It is easy to see that aw (x, hD) is in fact the Weyl-quantization of the symbol a(x, hξ ; h). We shall also need more general classes, defined as follows (see DimassiSj¨ostrand [7]). We say that a smooth function a(·; h) ∈ C∞ (R2n X ), possibly depending
A. Parmeggiani, Spectral Theory of Non-Commutative Harmonic Oscillators: An Introduction, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1992, c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2010 DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-11922-4 9,
121
122
9 Some Tools from the Semiclassical Calculus
on a parameter h ∈ (0, h0 ], h0 ∈ (0, 1], belongs to the symbol class Sδk (mμ ), k, μ ∈ R and δ ∈ [0, 1/2], if for all α ∈ Zn+ there exists Cα > 0 such that |∂Xα a(X ; h)| ≤ Cα m(X)μ h−k−|α |δ , ∀X ∈ R2n , ∀h ∈ (0, h0 ].
(9.2)
Notice that, compared to (9.1), no further decay in m is obtained by taking derivatives of the symbol. The h-Weyl quantization of a symbol a ∈ Sδk (mμ ) is defined as before. The vector and matrix-valued symbol classes are defined as before. Notice that Sδk (mμ ) = Sδk (mμ , |dX|2 ), where |dX|2 is the Euclidean metric in R2n X , and that S(mμ , g) ⊂ S00 (mμ , g) ⊂ Sδk (mμ , g) ⊂ Sδk (mμ ).
(9.3)
Remark 9.1.2. Let E > 0. Define the L2 -isometry (also automorphism of S and S ), √ UE : u(x) −→ E −n/4u(x/ E). (9.4) Then, given any symbol a ∈ S0k (mμ ; MN ) one has from Theorem 3.1.12
In particular
√ √ h ˜ UE−1 aw (x, hD)UE = aw ( E x, E hD), where h˜ = . E
(9.5)
√ √ Uh−1 aw (x, hD)Uh = aw ( h x, h D).
(9.6)
Notice that since Uh corresponds to the symplectic transformation
κh : (x, ξ ) −→ (h1/2 x, h−1/2 ξ ), by using h1/2 m(X ) ≤ m(h1/2 X ) ≤ m(X), we have that if a ∈ S(mμ , g), then √ √ − min{ μ ,0}/2 (mμ , g). (a ◦ κh)(·, h·) = a( h ·, h ·) ∈ S0 By Proposition 3.2.15 we have the following result, that we shall frequently use k when dealing with “classical semiclassical symbols” in the class S0,cl (mμ , g) (see Definition 9.1.9 below). Proposition 9.1.3. Let μ ∈ R. Let a j ∈ S(mμ −2 j , g), j ∈ Z+ (in particular, the a j are independent of h). Then there exists a ∈ S00 (mμ , g) such that a∼
∑ h ja j,
j≥0
9.1 The Semiclassical Calculus
123
that is, for all r ∈ Z+ we have r
a − ∑ h j a j ∈ S0
−(r+1)
(mμ −2(r+1) , g).
j=0
If another symbol a has the same property, then
a − a ∈ S−∞ (m−∞ , g) :=
S0−k (mμ −2k , g).
(9.7)
k∈Z+
Proof. One takes an excision function χ ∈ C∞ (Rt ; [0, 1]), such that χ (t) = 0 for |t| ≤ 2 and χ (t) = 1 for |t| ≥ 4, and defines ∞
a(X; h) :=
∑ h jχ
j=0
m(X) a j (X ), hR j
where {R j } j∈Z+ ⊂ [1, +∞) is an increasing sequence with R j +∞ as j → +∞ sufficiently fast. Following the steps of the proof of Proposition 3.2.15, using the fact that h ∈ (0, 1] and that on the support of 1 − χ (m(X )/hR j ) we have |X | ≤ 4R j and 1 ≤ h−1 ≤ 4R j (so that we may divide and multiply by hr , for any given r ∈ N), one sees that the sequence R j can indeed be so chosen that a(X ; h) has the required properties. Using a Borel-summation argument one also has the following proposition (see Evans-Zworski [15]). Proposition 9.1.4. Let k j −∞, k j > k j+1 , j ∈ Z+ , be a monotone decreasing k
sequence of real numbers. Let a j ∈ Sδ j (mμ ). Then there exists a ∈ Sδ0 (mμ ) such that a ∼ ∑ j≥0 a j , that is, for all r ∈ Z+ r
k
a − ∑ a j ∈ Sδr+1 (mμ ). k
j=0
If another symbol a has the same property, then a − a ∈ S−∞ (mμ ) :=
Sδk (mμ ).
k∈R
Proof. One chooses χ ∈ C∞ ([0, +∞); R) such that 0 ≤ χ ≤ 1, χ [0,1] = 1, χ [2,+∞) ≡ 0, and then defines a(X) :=
∑ χ (λ j h)a j (X),
j≥0
X ∈ R2n ,
(9.8)
124
9 Some Tools from the Semiclassical Calculus
where the sequence 1 ≤ λ1 ≤ . . . ≤ λ j ≤ λ j+1 ≤ . . . → +∞ must be picked. The choice of the λ j is therefore made as follows: for each multiindex α with |α | ≤ j, we have |∂Xα χ (λ j h)a j (X ) | = |χ (λ j h)∂Xα a j (X)| ≤ C j,α h−k j −δ |α | χ (λ j h)m(X )μ λ jh = C j,α h−k j −δ |α | χ (λ j h)m(X )μ λ jh (since λ j h ≤ 2 in the support of χ ) 1 ≤ 2C j,α h−k j −1−δ |α | m(X )μ λj ≤ h−k j −1−δ |α | 2− j m(X)μ , ∀X ∈ R2n , if λ j is picked sufficiently large. Since we can accomplish this for all j and all α with |α | ≤ j, and trivially make it possible to have λ j+1 ≥ λ j , the sequence {λ j } j is therefore determined. One then concludes in a way similar to that used in the proof of Proposition 3.2.15. We leave it as an exercise for the reader to fill in the details of the proofs of Proposition 9.1.3 and of Proposition 9.1.4. From Evans-Zworski [15] (see also Dimassi-Sj¨ostrand [7]) we have the following important result. Theorem 9.1.5. We have that for a ∈ Sδ0 (mμ ; MN ), the operator aw (x, hD) as a linear map aw (x, hD) : S (Rn ; CN ) −→ S (Rn ; CN ) and as a linear map aw (x, hD) : S (Rn ; CN ) −→ S (Rn ; CN ) is continuous. In particular, by virtue of (9.3), this is the case also for a ∈ Sδ0 (mμ , g; MN ). As regards the L2 -continuity we have the following theorem. Theorem 9.1.6. Let a ∈ Sδ0 (1; MN ), 0 ≤ δ ≤ 1/2. Then aw (x, hD) : L2 (Rn ; CN ) −→ L2 (Rn ; CN ) is bounded and there is a constant C > 0, independent of h, such that ||aw (x, hD)||L2 →L2 ≤ C, ∀h ∈ (0, 1]. As regards the composition one has the following theorems. For the classes Sδk (mμ ; MN ) we have the following result (see Dimassi-Sj¨ostrand [7] and Evans-Zworski [15]).
9.1 The Semiclassical Calculus
125
Theorem 9.1.7. Given a ∈ Sδ0 (mμ1 ; MN ) and b ∈ Sδ0 (mμ2 ; MN ), one has aw (x, hD)bw (x, hD) = (ah b)w (x, hD), where
ah b = eihσ (DX ;DY )/2 (a(X)b(Y ))X=Y ∈ Sδ0 (mμ1 +μ2 ; MN ).
Here, recall, σ (DX ; DY ) = σ (Dx , Dξ ; Dy , Dη ). Furthermore, when δ ∈ [0, 1/2) one has k ∞ 1 ih ah b ∼ ∑ σ (DX ; DY ) a(X )b(Y )X=Y . (9.9) k=0 k! 2 0 (1; M ) with When δ = 1/2 one has (see [15]) that if a, b ∈ S1/2 N
supp a ⊂ K, and dist(supp a, supp b) ≥ γ > 0, where the compact K and the constant γ are independent of h, then ||aw (x, hD)bw (x, hD)||L2 →L2 = O(h∞ ).
(9.10)
Recall that f (h) = O(hN0 ) for some N0 ∈ Z+ if there exists CN0 > 0 such that | f (h)| ≤ CN0 hN0 . We say that f (h) = O(h∞ ) if for any given N0 ∈ Z+ one has f (h) = O(hN0 ). For the classes Sδk (mμ , g; MN ) we have the following result (see Shubin [67, p. 245]). Theorem 9.1.8. Let δ ∈ [0, 1/2). For any given symbols a ∈ Sδk1 (mμ1 , g; MN ) and b ∈ Sδk2 (mμ2 , g; MN ) we have aw (x, hD)bw (x, hD) = (ah b)w (x, hD) where ah b = eihσ (DX ;DY )/2 (a(X)b(Y ))X=Y ∈ Sδk1 +k2 (mμ1 +μ2 , g; MN ), and for all N0 ∈ Z+ (ah b) =
k 1 ih σ (D ; D ) a(X)b(Y )X=Y +hN0 +1 rN0 +1 , X Y ∑ k! 2 k=0 N0
k +k2 +2(N0 +1)δ
where rN0 +1 ∈ Sδ1
(mμ1 +μ2 −2(N0 +1) , g; MN ).
We next define the classical symbols in the semiclassical setting.
(9.11)
126
9 Some Tools from the Semiclassical Calculus
Definition 9.1.9 (Classical semiclassical symbols). 1. We shall say that a semiclassical symbol a ∈ S0k (mμ ; MN ) is classical and write k (m μ ; M ) if a ∈ Scl N a(X ; h) ∼ h−k ∑ h j a j (X) in S0k (mμ ; MN ), j≥0
where the a j ∈ S00 (mμ ; MN ) are independent of h, j ≥ 0. 2. We shall say that a semiclassical symbol a ∈ S0k (mμ , g; MN ) is classical and write k (m μ , g; M ) if there exists a sequence {a a ∈ S0,cl N μ −2 j } j≥0 of symbols a μ −2 j ∈ μ −2 j , g; M ), j ≥ 0, with the a S(m independent of h, such that for any given N μ −2 j N0 ∈ Z+ N0
a(X ; h) − h−k ∑ h j aμ −2 j (X) ∈ S0
k−(N0 +1)
(mμ −2(N0 +1) , g; MN ).
j=0
We shall write a(X; h) ∼ h−k ∑ h j aμ −2 j (X) in S0k (mμ , g; MN ). j≥0
For a classical semiclassical symbol a ∼ aμ + ha μ −2 + . . ., one calls a μ the principal symbol of a, and a μ −2 the subprincipal symbol of a. 0 (m μ , g; M ) is elliptic 3. We shall say that a classical semiclassical symbol a ∈ S0,cl N μ if its principal symbol a μ belongs to S(m , g; MN ) and aμ (X )−1 exists for all X ∈ R2n and belongs to S(m−μ , g; MN ). Equivalently, one requires that det a μ ∈ S(mN μ , g) be such that |det a μ (X)| m(X)N μ for all X ∈ R2n . 0 (m μ , g; M ) is 4. We shall say that a classical semiclassical symbol a = a∗ ∈ S0,cl N ∗ positive elliptic if its principal symbol aμ = aμ belongs to S(mμ , g; MN ) and there are 0 < c1 < c2 such that c1 m(X )μ |v|2CN ≤ a μ (X)v, v CN ≤ c2 m(X )μ |v|2CN , for all v ∈ CN and all X ∈ R2n . Remark 9.1.10. From Theorem 9.1.7 and Theorem 9.1.8, respectively, we have that k (m μ ; M ) and Sk (m μ , g; M ), respectively, are well-behaved also the classes Scl N N 0,cl under composition. We now wish to consider inverses in the semiclassical calculus. We need the following result, due to R. Beals, which characterizes pseudodifferential operators in the semiclassical setting (see Dimassi-Sj¨ostrand [7] or EvansZworski [15]; we give a statement in the scalar case for simplicity).
9.1 The Semiclassical Calculus
127
Theorem 9.1.11. Let A = Ah : S (Rn ) −→ S (Rn ) be a continuous linear operator, 0 < h ≤ 1. Then the following statements are equivalent: 1. A = aw (x, hD) for some a(x, ξ ; h) = a ∈ S00 (1); 2. For every N ∈ N and for every family 1 (x, ξ ), . . . , N (x, ξ ) of linear forms on R2n , the operator ad1 (x,hD) ◦ . . . ◦ adN (x,hD) Ah is continuous in L2 (Rn ), i.e. it belongs to L (L2 , L2 ), with norm O(hN ) in that space. (Recall that adA B = [A, B].) One may then prove the following proposition about “elliptic” elements in S00 (mμ ; MN ). Theorem 9.1.12. Let a(X ; h) = a ∈ S00 (mμ ; MN ) be elliptic, that is, by definition, a(X; h)−1 = a−1 ∈ S00 (m−μ ; MN ), for 0 < h ≤ h0 . Then, by possibly shrinking h0 , there exists a symbol b ∈ S00 (m−μ ; MN ) such that bw (x, hD)aw (x, hD) = I = aw (x, hD)bw (x, hD), 0 < h ≤ h0 , and, furthermore, bw (x, hD) possesses an asymptotic expansion, that is, b ∼ a−1 + h(a−1h r) + h2 (a−1 h rh r) + . . . , where r ∈ S00 (1; MN ) is such that (a−1 )w (x, hD)aw (x, hD) = I − hrw (x, hD). Proof. Let b˜ = a−1 ∈ S00 (m−μ ; MN ). Then b˜ w (x, hD)aw (x, hD) = I − hrLw (x, hD), rL ∈ S00 (1; MN ), and aw (x, hD)b˜ w (x, hD) = I − hrRw (x, hD), rR ∈ S00 (1; MN ). Then by Theorem 9.1.6 I − hrLw (x, hD) : L2 −→ L2 and I − hrRw (x, hD) : L2 −→ L2 are both invertible, provided h ∈ (0, h0 ], if h0 ∈ (0, 1] is taken sufficiently small. By the Beals Theorem 9.1.11 it follows that there exists cL , cR ∈ S00 (1; MN ) such that −1 −1 I − hrLw (x, hD) = cL (x, hD), I − hrRw (x, hD) = cR (x, hD), so that
and
−1 0 −μ ; MN ), b˜ w (x, hD) =: bw I − hrLw (x, hD) L (x, hD), bL ∈ S0 (m
−1 0 −μ =: bw ; MN ), b˜ w (x, hD) I − hrRw (x, hD) R (x, hD), bR ∈ S0 (m
128
9 Some Tools from the Semiclassical Calculus
whence we get the existence of a left-inverse bL (x, ξ ; h) = bL and of a right-inverse bR (x, ξ ; h) = bR , both belonging to the symbol class S00 (m−μ ; MN ), such that w w w bw L (x, hD)a (x, hD) = I = a (x, hD)bR (x, hD), 0 < h ≤ h0 ,
and, finally, w w w w bw L (x, hD) = bL (x, hD)a (x, hD)bR (x, hD) = bR (x, hD).
Put therefore b = bL = bR . In addition, we have that b possesses an asymptotic expansion. In fact, for any given N0 ∈ Z+ , let bw N0 (x, hD)
:= b˜ w (x, hD) I + hrRw (x, hD) + h2rRw (x, hD)2 + . . . + hN0 rRw (x, hD)N0 .
Then N0 +1 rR (x, hD)N0 +1 , aw (x, hD)bw N0 (x, hD) = I − h
and it follows that w w w bw N0 (x, hD) = b (x, hD)a (x, hD)bN0 (x, hD)
= bw (x, hD) − hN0 +1 bw (x, hD)rRw (x, hD)N0 +1 = bw (x, hD) + hN0 +1 rNw0 +1 (x, hD),
where we have put rNw0 +1 (x, hD) := −bw (x, hD)rRw (x, hD)N0 +1 . By Theorem 9.1.7 we have rN0 +1 ∈ S00 (m−μ ; MN ), and this concludes the proof. It will be also useful to have the following variation of Theorem 9.1.12 for 0 elliptic classical semiclassical symbols a ∈ S0,cl (mμ , g; MN ). The usual parametrix construction (using h as “parameter of homogeneity”) gives the following theorem. 0 Theorem 9.1.13. Let a ∈ S0,cl (mμ , g; MN ) be elliptic, that is, with a ∼ ∑ j≥0 h j aμ −2 j , −1 − μ let aμ ∈ S(m , g; MN ). Then there exists a classical semiclassical symbol 0 (m− μ , g; M ) such that b ∈ S0,cl N
bw (x, hD)aw (x, hD) = I + rLw (x, hD), aw (x, hD)bw (x, hD) = I + rRw (x, hD), where rL , rR ∈ S−∞ (m−∞ , g; MN ) (see (9.7)).
9.2 Decoupling a System
129
9.2 Decoupling a System In this section, using an adaptation taken from Parenti-Parmeggiani [49] of the classical decoupling argument of Taylor [69], we prove the following result. (See also Helffer-Sj¨ostrand [21].) 0 (m μ , g; M ). Theorem 9.2.1. Let μ > 0 and let a = a∗ ∼ ∑ j≥0 h j aμ −2 j ∈ S0,cl N ∗ ∗ Suppose there exists e0 ∈ S(1, g; MN ) such that e0 e0 = e0 e0 = I and
e∗0 aμ e0
λ1,μ 0 , = bμ = 0 λ2,μ
(9.12)
where λ j,μ = λ j,∗ μ ∈ S(mμ , g; MN j ), j = 1, 2, N1 + N2 = N, and dλ1 ,λ2 (X) m(X )μ , ∀X ∈ R2n ,
(9.13)
where, for each X ∈ R2n , ! " dλ1 ,λ2 (X ) = inf |μ1 − μ2|; μ1 ∈ Spec(λ1,μ (X)), μ2 ∈ Spec(λ2,μ (X )) .
(9.14)
0 (1, g; M ) with principal symbol e such that: Then there exists e ∈ S0,cl N 0
1. One has ew (x, hD)∗ ew (x, hD) − I, ew (x, hD)ew (x, hD)∗ − I ∈ S−∞ (m−∞ , g; MN ); 2. ew (x, hD)∗ aw (x, hD)ew (x, hD) − bw (x, hD) ∈ S−∞ (m−∞ , g; MN ), where the 0 (m μ , g; M ) is blockwise diagonal, with symbol b ∼ ∑ j≥0 h j bμ −2 j ∈ S0,cl N 0 b1,μ −2 j (X) , ∀X ∈ R2n , ∀ j ≥ 0, b μ −2 j (X ) = 0 b2,μ −2 j (X)
with blocks b j,μ of sizes N j , j = 1, 2, respectively, and with principal symbol
b μ (X ) =
λ1,μ (X) 0 , ∀X ∈ R2n . λ2,μ (X) 0
We shall call b an h∞ -(block)-diagonalization of a. Notice that b depends on a and e0 . Proof. We immediately observe that once ew (x, hD) has been found with the property that its principal symbol is e0 and ew (x, hD)ew (x, hD)∗ = I + rw (x, hD), with r ∈ S−∞ (m−∞ , g; MN ),
130
9 Some Tools from the Semiclassical Calculus
then by the ellipticity (using Theorem 9.1.13) we also get ew (x, hD)∗ ew (x, hD) = I + sw (x, hD), with s ∈ S−∞ (m−∞ , g; MN ). Hence it suffices to prove the existence of ew (x, hD) and b with the required properties. We show that for every integer k ∈ Z+ there exist e−2k ∈ S(m−2k , g; MN ),
(i) and
b j,μ −2k ∈ S(mμ −2k , g; MN j ), j = 1, 2,
(ii)
0 such that, with EN0 (X ) := ∑Nk=0 hk e−2k (X),
0 (m−2(N0 +1) , g; MN ), EN0 h EN∗0 = I + hN0 +1 S0,cl
and EN∗0 h ah EN0 =
N0
0 (mμ −2(N0 +1) , g; MN ), ∑ bμ −2k + hN0+1S0,cl
k=0
0 b1,μ −2k are in block-diagonal form. We shall then where the b μ −2k = 0 b2,μ −2k take e ∼ ∑k≥0 hk e−2k . Hence we proceed by induction. So, suppose we have already constructed symbols e0 , e−2 , . . . , e−2N0 , and bμ , b μ −2 , . . . , b μ −2N0 , independent of h, with the required properties. Put hence
SNw0 (x, hD) := ENw0 (x, hD)ENw0 (x, hD)∗ − I,
(9.15)
0 (m−2(N0 +1) , g; M ). We shall write, for short, E w , Sw and where SN0 ∈ hN0 +1 S0,cl N N0 N0 w w e−2k in place of EN0 (x, hD) etc. We look for a matrix-symbol e−2(N0 +1) ∈ S(m−2(N0 +1) , g; MN ) such that
∗ (ENw0 )∗ + hN0 +1 (ew − I = hN0 +2 rw (x, hD), ENw0 + hN0 +1 ew −2(N0 +1) −2(N0 +1) ) 0 (m−2(N0 +2) , g; M ), that is, we look for e where r ∈ S0,cl N −2(N0 +1) such that
w ∗ w w ∗ = hN0 +2 r˜w (x, hD), SNw0 + hN0 +1 ew (e ) + e (e ) 0 −2(N0 +1) −2(N0 +1) 0 0 (m−2(N0 +2) , g; M ). Using the composition formula (9.11) we thus look with r˜ ∈ S0,cl N at the coefficient of hN0 +1 and require that it be zero, obtaining the equation
s−2(N0 +1) + e0 (e−2(N0 +1) )∗ + e−2(N0 +1) e∗0 = 0.
(9.16)
9.2 Decoupling a System
131
Notice that s∗−2(N0 +1) = s−2(N0 +1) (this follows from (9.15)). Equation (9.16) has general solution 1 e−2(N0 +1) = − s−2(N0 +1) e0 + φ−2(N0 +1) , (9.17) 2 where φ−2(N0 +1) solves ∗ e0 φ−2(N + φ−2(N0 +1) e∗0 = 0, 0 +1)
which in turn gives that φ−2(N0 +1) has the form
φ−2(N0 +1) = α−2(N0 +1) e0 ,
(9.18)
where α−2(N0 +1) ∈ S(m−2(N0 +1) , g; MN ) and ∗ α−2(N + α−2(N0 +1) = 0. 0 +1)
We next perform a choice of α−2(N0 +1) for obtaining the blocks b j,μ −2(N0 +1) , j = 1, 2. Since on the one hand (ENw0 +1 )aw ENw0 +1 =
N0 +1
∑
k=0
N0 +2 w hk bw r1 , μ −2k + h
0 (mμ −2(N0 +2) , g; MN ), and on the other with r1 ∈ S0,cl
∗ w w (ENw0 +1 )aw ENw0 +1 = (ENw0 )∗ aw ENw0 + hN0 +1 (ew −2(N0 +1) ) a e0 ∗ w w N0 +2 w +(ew r2 0 ) a e−2(N0 +1) + h =: TNw0 + hN0 +2 r2w ,
(9.19)
0 (m μ −2(N0 +2) , g; M ), the conditions for the blocks b with r2 ∈ S0,cl N j, μ −2k are already satisfied for 0 ≤ k ≤ N0 , independently of e−2(N0 +1) . Let q μ −2(N0 +1) be the coefficient of hN0 +1 in EN∗0 h ah EN0 . Then the coefficient of hN0 +1 in TN0 is
qμ −2(N0 +1) + e∗−2(N0 +1) aμ e0 + e∗0 aμ e−2(N0 +1)
= qμ −2(N0 +1) + (e∗−2(N0 +1) e0 )e∗0 aμ e0 + e∗0 aμ e0 (e∗0 e−2(N0 +1) ).
(9.20)
Using (9.17) and (9.18), we write ⎧ 1 ∗ ⎪ ∗ ∗ ⎪ ⎨ e0 e−2(N0 +1) = − e0 s−2(N0 +1) e0 + e0 α−2(N0 +1) e0 =: τ + β , 2 ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ e∗ −2(N0 +1) e0 = τ − β ,
(9.21)
132
9 Some Tools from the Semiclassical Calculus
where 1 τ = − e∗0 s−2(N0 +1) e0 = τ ∗ , and β = e∗0 α−2(N0 +1) e0 = −β ∗ . 2 By (9.21), the term (9.20) goes over to qμ −2(N0 +1) + (e∗0 aμ e0 )τ + τ (e∗0 aμ e0 ) + (e∗0 aμ e0 )β − β (e∗0aμ e0 ).
(9.22)
We now show that β , hence in turn
α−2(N0 +1) = e0 β e∗0 ,
(9.23)
can be so chosen as to kill the off-diagonal terms in (9.22). In fact, upon writing qμ −2(N0 +1) + (e∗0 aμ e0 )τ + τ (e∗0 aμ e0 ) =
u1 γ , γ ∗ u2
where the u j = u∗j are N j × N j blocks, j = 1, 2, we look for β in the form
β=
0 δ , −δ ∗ 0
and, using (9.12), we are therefore led to the matrix equation
λ1,μ δ − δ λ2,μ = −γ .
(9.24)
By Lemma 9.2.2 below, hypothesis (9.13) yields that equation (9.24) has a unique smooth N1 × N2 matrix-valued solution δ ∈ S(m−2(N0 +1) , g; MatN1 ×N2 (C)). Since this fixes β , and hence α−2(N0 +1) , the terms b j,μ −2(N0 +1) are then the block-diagonal terms in (9.22). This concludes the inductive step and the proof of the theorem. Lemma 9.2.2. Let E = E ∗ ∈ S(mμ , g; MN1 ) and F = F ∗ ∈ S(mμ , g; MN2 ) be such that (recall (9.14)) dE,F (X) ≥ c0 m(X)μ , ∀X ∈ R2n . Then for each X ∈ R2n the map ⎧ ⎨ ΦE,F (X ) : MatN1 ×N2 (C) −→ MatN1 ×N2 (C), ⎩
(9.25)
ΦE,F (X )T = E(X)T − T F(X ),
is an isomorphism. Moreover, ||ΦE,F (X)−1 || ≤
C , ∀X ∈ R2n , m(X)μ
(9.26)
9.2 Decoupling a System
133
for a universal constant C > 0. Hence, if S ∈ S(mμ −2k , g; MatN1 ×N2 (C)), for some k ∈ Z+ , we have that X −→ T (X ) := ΦE,F (X)−1 S(X) ∈ S(m−2k , g; MatN1 ×N2 (C)).
(9.27)
Proof. For each fixed X ∈ R2n , let Spec(E(X )) = {e1 (X ), . . . , eνX (X )}. Hence e j (X ) = e j (X ) if j = j . Consider the contour in C
γ (X ) =
νX
γ j (X ), with γ j (X) ∩ γ j (X ) = 0/ for j = j ,
j=1
counter-clockwise oriented, where each γ j (X) = ∂ D j (X ) is a small circle that encloses only the eigenvalue e j (X ) of E(X ), 1 ≤ j ≤ νX , and Spec(F(X)) ⊂ C \
νX
D j (X ).
j=1
Then, on considering the equation E(X )T −T F(X) = S(X ) we have that the solution can be written as T = T (X ) = =
1 2π i νX
γ (X)
(ζ − E(X))−1 S(X )(ζ − F(X ))−1 d ζ −1 e j (X) − F(X ) ,
∑ PE, j (X)S(X)
(9.28)
j=1
where PE, j (X ) : CN1 → CN1 is the orthogonal projection associated with the eigenvalue e j (X ). This shows that for each fixed X the map ΦE,F (X ) is an isomorphism (for it is injective and linear). Moreover, using the fact that the norm of the resolvent of a normal operator equals the spectral radius, we also obtain from (9.28) that |T (X)| = |ΦE,F (X )−1 S(X) | ≤
C |S(X )|, ∀X ∈ R2n , m(X)μ
where C = N1 /c0 . This shows (9.26). Now, (9.26) gives that T (X ) is continuous and differentiable to all orders, for we have that for any given X1 , X2 ∈ R2n ΦE,F (X1 ) T (X1 ) − T (X2 ) = E(X2 ) − E(X1) T (X2 ) + T (X2 ) F(X1 ) − F(X2 ) + S(X1) − S(X2), (9.29) from which, since (9.26) yields |T (X2 )| |S(X2 )| for all X2 (recall that m(X ) ≥ 1 for all X), we obtain the continuity of T by considering the map ΦE,F (X1 )−1 , taking
134
9 Some Tools from the Semiclassical Calculus
the limit as X2 → X1 , and using the continuity of E, F and S. The differentiability claim follows from (9.29) by induction. It remains to control the growth of |∂Xα T (X)|. For any given α ∈ Z2n + , the matrix ∂Xα T is a solution to E ∂Xα T − ∂Xα T F + Sα = ∂Xα S, where, by the Leibniz rule, Sα :=
α α −β β β α −β ∂ E ∂ T − ∂ T ∂ F . ∑ β X X X X β ≤α
β =α
Hence
∂Xα T (X ) = ΦE,F (X)−1 ∂Xα S(X ) − Sα (X ) , β
so that assuming by induction on α that |∂X T | m−2k−|β | , gives by (9.26) |∂Xα T (X )| ≤ Cα m(X)−2k−|α | , ∀X ∈ R2n ,
which concludes the proof.
As a consequence of the proof of Theorem 9.2.1 we have the following analogue for classical symbols (which is used in Parmeggiani [52]). Theorem 9.2.3. Let μ > 0 and let a = a∗ ∼ ∑ j≥0 aμ −2 j ∈ Scl (mμ , g; MN ). Suppose there exists e0 ∈ C∞ (R2n \ {0}; MN ), positively homogeneous of degree 0, such that e∗0 e0
=
e0 e∗0
= I, and
e∗0 aμ e0
λ1,μ 0 , X = 0, = bμ = 0 λ2,μ
where λ j,μ = λ j,∗ μ ∈ C∞ (R2n \ {0}; MN j ) are positively homogeneous of degree μ , j = 1, 2, and Spec(λ1,μ (X )) ∩ Spec(λ2,μ (X)) = 0, / ∀X ∈ R2n , |X | = 1.
(9.30)
Then there exists e ∈ Scl (1, g; MN ) with principal symbol e0 such that 1. ew (x, D)∗ ew (x, D) − I, ew (x, D)ew (x, D)∗ − I ∈ S(m−∞ , g; MN ); 2. ew (x, D)∗ aw (x, D)ew (x, D) − bw (x, D) ∈ S(m−∞ , g; MN ), where the symbol b ∼ ∑ j≥0 bμ −2 j ∈ Scl (mμ , g; MN ) is blockwise diagonal, with
b μ −2 j (X ) =
0 b1,μ −2 j (X) , ∀X ∈ R2n \ {0}, ∀ j ≥ 0, 0 b2,μ −2 j (X)
9.2 Decoupling a System
135
with blocks b j,μ of sizes N j , j = 1, 2, respectively, and with principal symbol
b μ (X ) =
λ1,μ (X) 0 , ∀X ∈ R2n \ {0}. λ2,μ (X) 0
We shall call such a symbol b a (block)-diagonalization of a. Notice that b depends on a and e0 . Remark 9.2.4. Given N × N matrices a and b, a straightforward computation gives the following very useful formula: {a, b}∗ = −{b∗, a∗ }
(9.31)
which yields in particular that i i {a, a∗} and {a∗ , a} are Hermitian matrices. 2 2 It will be useful to compute the subprincipal part bμ −2 (that is, the coefficient of the h term) of the block-diagonal system obtained in Theorem 9.2.1. The same formula holds for the version given in Theorem 9.2.3 for classical operators. We have the following proposition. Proposition 9.2.5. For the subprincipal part bμ −2 of the h∞ -diagonalization given in Theorem 9.2.1 one has, by (9.20), the formula b μ −2 = e∗−2 e0 bμ + b μ e∗0 e−2 + e∗0 aμ −2 e0 −
i ∗ e0 {aμ , e0 } + {e∗0, a μ e0 } , 2
(9.32)
where
i e−2 = {e0 , e∗0 }e0 + α−2 e0 , 4 ∗ = −α ∗ with α−2 −2 determined by equation (9.24) through β−2 = e0 α−2 e0 . In the case N = 2, supposing that aμ = a∗μ > 0 and that there exist positive smooth functions λ1 , λ2 ∈ S(mμ , g) (where we now write λ j , j = 1, 2, for the eigenvalues of a μ ) such that (9.33) |λ1 (X ) − λ2(X)| m(X)μ , ∀X ∈ R2n , whence the existence of a smooth unitary matrix e0 such that e0 (X )∗ aμ (X )e0 (X) = we have the following corollary.
λ1 (X) 0 , ∀X ∈ R2n , λ2 (X ) 0
(9.34)
136
9 Some Tools from the Semiclassical Calculus
Corollary 9.2.6. Suppose a μ = a∗μ > 0 possesses smooth eigenvalues λ1 , λ2
1 0 2 satisfying (9.33). Let {w1 , w2 } be the canonical basis of C , w1 = , w2 = , 0 1 so that b μ (X )w j = λ j (X )w j , j = 1, 2, for all X ∈ R2n . Then the symbol of the h∞ -diagonalization b is a diagonal 2 × 2 matrix. Moreover, for the subprincipal + * (11) bμ −2 0 we have symbol bμ −2 = (22) 0 b μ −2 ( j j)
b μ −2 = b μ −2 w j , w j
1 = e∗0 aμ −2 e0 w j , w j + Im {e∗0 , λ j }e0 w j , w j
2 1 ∗ + Im e0 {aμ , e0 }w j , w j , j = 1, 2. 2
(9.35)
Proof. From the proof of Theorem 9.2.1 we have that the matrix β = β−2 is skewadjoint, whence ∗ β−2 bμ w j , w j + b μ β−2 w j , w j = −λ j β−2 w j , w j + λ j β−2 w j , w j = 0. (9.36)
Then, from (9.32), recalling that i e∗0 e−2 = e∗0 {e0 , e∗0 }e0 + β−2, 4 using aμ e0 = e0 bμ and (9.36), and since (∂ bμ )w j = (∂ λ j )w j , we obtain bμ −2 w j , w j = Re bμ −2 w j , w j
i = e∗0 aμ −2 e0 w j , w j + 2 Re e∗0 {e0 , e∗0 }e0 bμ w j , w j
4 i i ∗ −Re e0 {aμ , e0 }w j , w j − Re {e∗0 , e0 bμ }w j , w j
2 2 = e∗0 aμ −2 e0 w j , w j
1 1 − Im e∗0 {e0 , e∗0 }e0 bμ w j , w j + Im e∗0 {aμ , e0 }w j , w j
2 2 1 ∗ + Im {e0 , e0 }bμ w j , w j
2 ∂ e∗ ∂ λ ∂ e∗ ∂ λ j 1 n j − 0 e0 )w j , w j . + ∑ Im ( 0 e0 2 =1 ∂ ξ ∂ x ∂ x ∂ ξ
Now, since e0 e∗0 = I = e∗0 e0 , we have that (∂ e0 )e∗0 + e0 (∂ e∗0 ) = 0
(9.37)
9.2 Decoupling a System
137
whence ∂e
0 ∗ ∂ e0 e0 ∂ ξ ∂ x =1 n
{e0 , e∗0 e0 } = 0 = {e0 , e∗0 }e0 + ∑
−
∂ e0 ∗ ∂ e0 e ∂ x 0 ∂ ξ
(using (9.37)) = {e0 , e∗0 }e0 − e0{e∗0 , e0 }, that is
e∗0 {e0 , e∗0 }e0 = {e∗0 , e0 }.
(9.38)
Using (9.38) in the above expression for bμ −2 w j , w j and noting that
∂ e∗0 ∂ λ j ∂ e∗0 ∂ λ j ∂ e∗ ∂ λ j ∂ e∗ ∂ λ j e0 − e0 = 0 e0 − 0 e0 = {e∗0 , λ j }e0 ∂ ξ ∂ x ∂ x ∂ ξ ∂ ξ ∂ x ∂ x ∂ ξ (∂ λ j being a scalar), proves (9.35).
We must now study the “transformation properties” (we are interested just in the 2 × 2 case) of the subprincipal terms depending on the choice of e0 . More precisely, we have the following proposition. Proposition 9.2.7. Let 0 < aμ = a∗μ ∈ S(mμ , g; M2 ) satisfy (9.33). Let e0 and e˜0 be smooth, unitary 2 × 2 matrices in S(1, g; M2 ) such that e∗0 aμ e0 = e˜∗0 aμ e˜0 = bμ =
λ1 0 . 0 λ2
Denote by bμ −2 and b˜ μ −2 the subprincipal terms given in Corollary 9.2.6, associated respectively with e0 and e˜0 . Let hence f ∈ S(1, g; M2 ) be the unitary matrix
f=
f1 0 , such that f ∗ f = f f ∗ = I and e0 = e˜0 f , 0 f2
so that the f j ∈ C∞ (R2n ; C) belong to S(1, g) and | f j (X )| = 1, for all X ∈ R2n , j = 1, 2. Then, with {w1 , w2 } the canonical basis of C2 as before, ( j j) bμ −2 = b μ −2 w j , w j = b˜ μ −2 w j , w j + Im f j { f¯j , λ j } , j = 1, 2.
(9.39)
Proof. In the first place we have, since f w j = f j w j and | f j | = 1, j = 1, 2, e∗0 aμ −2 e0 w j , w j = f ∗ e˜∗0 aμ −2 e˜0 f w j , w j
= f j aμ −2 e˜0 w j , f j e˜0 w j = a μ −2 e˜0 w j , e˜0 w j .
(9.40)
138
9 Some Tools from the Semiclassical Calculus
Next, using (∂ f )w j = (∂ f j )w j , we compute {e∗0 , λ j }e0 w j , w j = { f ∗ e˜∗0 , λ j }e˜0 f j w j , w j
= f j {e˜∗0 , λ j }e˜0 w j , f j w j
n ∂ f∗ ∗ ∂λj ∂ f∗ ∗ ∂λj + f j ∑ e˜0 w j , w j
e˜0 − e˜ ∂ x ∂ x 0 ∂ ξ =1 ∂ ξ
= {e˜∗0 , λ j }e˜0 w j , w j
n ∂λj ∂ fj ∂λj ∂ fj + ∑ f j e˜∗0 e˜0 w j , w j − f j e˜∗0 e˜0 w j , w j
∂ x ∂ ξ ∂ ξ ∂ x =1 ∗ ¯ = {e˜0 , λ j }e˜0 w j , w j + f j { f j , λ j }w j , w j
= {e˜∗0 , λ j }e˜0 w j , w j + f j { f¯j , λ j }, j = 1, 2,
that is {e∗0 , λ j }e0 w j , w j = {e˜∗0 , λ j }e˜0 w j , w j + f j { f¯j , λ j }, j = 1, 2. Hence, for j = 1, 2, 1 1 1 ∗ Im {e0 , λ j }e0 w j , w j = Im {e˜∗0 , λ j }e˜0 w j , w j + Im f j { f¯j , λ j } . (9.41) 2 2 2 We now consider e∗0 {aμ , e0 }w j , w j = f¯j {a μ , e˜0 f }w j , e˜0 w j
= {a μ , e˜0 }w j , e˜0 w j + f¯j {a μ , f j }e˜0 w j , e˜0 w j
= e˜∗0 {aμ , e˜0 }w j , w j + f¯j {a μ , f j }e˜0 w j , e˜0 w j . Since (∂ aμ )e˜0 + a μ (∂ e˜0 ) = e˜0 (∂ bμ ) + (∂ e˜0 )b μ , we get
∂ (aμ − λ j )e˜0 w j = −(aμ − λ j )(∂ e˜0 )w j , j = 1, 2. It hence follows, with ∂ and
∂
(9.42)
generic first-order derivatives,
(∂ aμ )(∂ f j )e˜0 w j = (∂ f j )(∂ aμ )e˜0 w j = (∂ f j ) (∂ λ j )e˜0 w j − (a μ − λ j )(∂ e˜0 )w j , whence {a μ , f j }e˜0 w j = {λ j , f j }e˜0 w j − (a μ − λ j ){e˜0 , f j }w j , j = 1, 2,
9.2 Decoupling a System
139
so that, by using (a μ − λ j ){e˜0 , f j }w j , e˜0 w j = {e˜0 , f j }w j , (a μ − λ j )e˜0 w j = 0, we obtain f¯j {a μ , f j }e˜0 w j , e˜0 w j = f¯j {λ j , f j }e˜0 w j , e˜0 w j = f¯j {λ j , f j }, j = 1, 2. Hence e˜∗0 {aμ , e˜0 }w j , w j + f¯j {a μ , f j }e˜0 w j , e˜0 w j = e˜∗0 {aμ , e˜0 }w j , w j + f¯j {λ j , f j }, for j = 1, 2, and thus 1 1 1 ∗ Im e0 {aμ , e0 }w j , w j = Im e˜∗0 {aμ , e˜0 }w j , w j + Im f¯j {λ j , f j } , 2 2 2 (9.43) for j = 1, 2. We now observe that 0 = {1, λ j } = {| f j |2 , λ j } = f j { f¯j , λ j } + f¯j { f j , λ j }, so that
f¯j {λ j , f j } = f j { f¯j , λ j }, j = 1, 2.
(9.44)
Plugging (9.40), (9.41), (9.43) and (9.44) in (9.35) gives 1 1 bμ −2 w j , w j = b˜ μ −2 w j , w j + Im f j { f¯j , λ j } + Im f¯j {λ j , f j } 2 2 = b˜ μ −2 w j , w j + Im f j { f¯j , λ j } , j = 1, 2,
which proves the proposition.
Remark 9.2.8. It is useful to remark that Proposition 9.2.5, Corollary 9.2.6 and Proposition 9.2.7 all hold true in the case of classical symbols (with the usual Weylquantization). Remark 9.2.9. Notice that when a = a∗ is an N × N globally positive elliptic differential system of order μ (hence μ is even), by virtue of the homogeneity
λ j,μ (X ) = |X|μ λ j,μ (
X ), ∀X ∈ R2n \ {0}, j = 1, . . . , N, |X |
we have that condition (9.33) on the eigenvalues of aμ becomes |λ j,μ (ω ) − λ j,μ (ω )| 1, ∀ω ∈ S2n−1 , j = j .
(9.45)
140
9 Some Tools from the Semiclassical Calculus
9.3 Some Estimates for Semiclassical Operators Recall from Definition 3.2.25 and Proposition 3.2.26 that for s ∈ Z+ , Bs (Rn ) = {u ∈ L2 ; xα ∂xβ u ∈ L2 , |α | + |β | ≤ s}, and B−s = (Bs )∗ . It is also useful to recall that B2 (Rn ) = D(pw 0 (x, D)), 2 2 2 n where pw 0 is the usual harmonic oscillator (|x| + |D| )/2 = (|x| − Δ )/2 in R . Recall also that Bs (Rn ; CN ) = Bs (Rn ) ⊗ CN ,
and that, from (5.7), on B2s we have the equivalent norms ||u||2B2s ,1 :=
∑
|α |+|β |≤2s
s 2 ||xα ∂xβ u||20 , and ||u||2B2s := ||u||20 + ||pw 0 (x, D) u||0 .
We next wish to introduce the semiclassical parameter h ∈ (0, 1] into the game. Consider the L2 -isometry, also automorphism of S and S , √ Uh : u −→ (Uh u)(x) = h−n/4 u(x/ h). From (9.6) we have √ √ w w Uh−1 pw 0 (x, hD)Uh = p0 ( h x, h D) = h p0 (x, D).
(9.46)
Since √ ∂xβ (Uh−1 u)(x) = hn/4 h|β |/2 (∂xβ u)( h x) = h|β |/2 (Uh−1 (∂xβ u))(x), we get ||xα ∂xβ (Uh−1 u)||20 = h|β |−|α |||Uh−1 (xα ∂xβ u)||20 = h|β |−|α | ||xα ∂xβ u||20 , since Uh−1 is an L2 -isometry as well. Consider now the h-dependent norm ||u||2B2s ,h :=
∑
|α |+|β |≤2s
h2|β |||xα ∂xβ u||20 ,
which is an equivalent norm of B2s , for one readily has h4s ||u||2B2s ,1 ≤ ||u||2B2s ,h ≤ ||u||2B2s ,1 , ∀u ∈ B2s .
(9.47)
9.3 Some Estimates for Semiclassical Operators
141
Using (9.47) we get ||u||2B2s ,h =
∑
|α |+|β |≤2s
h2|β | ||Uh−1 (xα ∂xβ u)||20 =
∑
|α |+|β |≤2s
h|α |+|β | ||xα ∂xβ (Uh−1 u)||20 ,
from which it follows, with constants independent of h, that s −1 2 2 −1 2 w s −1 2 h2s ||Uh−1 u||20 + ||pw 0 (x, D) Uh u||0 ||u||B2s ,h ||Uh u||0 + ||p0 (x, D) Uh u||0 , and since s −1 2 −1 2 w s −1 2 ||Uh−1 u||20 + ||pw 0 (x, D) Uh u||0 = ||Uh u||0 + ||Uh p0 (x, D) Uh u||0 =
(by (9.46)) s 2 −2s s 2 h2s ||u||20 + ||pw = ||u||20 + h−2s||pw 0 (x, hD) u||0 = h 0 (x, hD) u||0 , we get, with constants independent of h, ⎧ 2s 2 w s 2 2 −2s ||u||2 + ||pw (x, hD)s u||2 , ⎪ ⎨ h ||u||0 + ||p0 (x, hD) u||0 ||u||B2s ,h h 0 0 0 ⎪ ⎩
h4s ||u||2B2s ,1 ≤ ||u||2B2s ,h ≤ ||u||2B2s ,1 ,
(9.48)
for all u ∈ B2s . We may hence prove the following useful fact. Proposition 9.3.1. Let r ∈ S00 (m−2N0 ; MN ), for some N0 ∈ N. Then, given any integer k0 with 0 ≤ k0 ≤ N0 , rw (x, hD) : L2 (Rn ; CN ) −→ B2k0 (Rn ; CN ) is continuous, satisfying the following estimates: there exists C > 0 (dependent on k0 but independent of h) such that ||rw (x, hD)u||B2k0 ,1 ≤ Ch−3k0 ||u||0 , ∀u ∈ L2 (Rn ; CN ), and ||rw (x, hD)u||B2k0 ,h ≤ Ch−k0 ||u||0 , ∀u ∈ L2 (Rn ; CN ), for all h ∈ (0, 1]. In particular, when 0 < k0 ≤ N0 , rw (x, hD) : L2 (Rn ; CN ) −→ B2k0 (Rn ; CN ) →→ L2 (Rn ; CN ) is compact, for all h ∈ (0, 1].
142
9 Some Tools from the Semiclassical Calculus
Proof. We want to estimate ||rw (x, hD)u||B2k0 ,h (of course, we may suppose k0 > 0, otherwise there is nothing to prove). Now, rw (x, hD) is also a bounded operator L2 −→ L2 with norm bounded independently of h ∈ (0, 1]. Take a sequence {u j } j∈Z+ ⊂ S (Rn ; CN ) such that u j → u in L2 as j → +∞. Since (p0 h . . . h p0 )h r ∈ S00 (1; MN ), we have, by the L2 -boundedness, with constants k0
independent of h, k0 w ||pw 0 (x, hD) r (x, hD)(u j − u j )||0 ||u j − u j ||0 −→ 0, as j, j → +∞.
Hence, by (9.48), with constants independent of h, h4k0 ||rw (x, hD)(u j − u j )||2B2k0 ,1 ≤ ||rw (x, hD)(u j − u j )||2B2k0 ,h k0 w 2 h−2k0 ||rw (x, hD)(u j − u j )||20 + ||pw 0 (x, hD) r (x, hD)(u j − u j )||0 h−2k0 ||u j − u j ||20 −→ 0, as j, j → +∞. B2k0
Hence rw (x, hD)u j −→ v ∈ B2k0 as j → +∞. But on the other hand we also have S
rw (x, hD)u j −→ rw (x, hD)u as j → +∞. It therefore follows that rw (x, hD)u ∈ B2k0 , ∀u ∈ L2 , and
||rw (x, hD)u||B2k0 ,1 ≤ Ch−3k0 ||u||0 , ∀u ∈ L2 , ||rw (x, hD)u||B2k0 ,h ≤ Ch−k0 ||u||0 , ∀u ∈ L2 ,
which concludes the proof.
Corollary 9.3.2. Let r ∈ S00 (m−2N0 ; MN ), for some N0 ∈ N. Then, given any integers k0 , k1 with 0 ≤ k0 ≤ k1 ≤ N0 , rw (x, hD) : B2k0 (Rn ; CN ) −→ B2k1 (Rn ; CN ) is continuous, satisfying the following estimates: there exists C > 0 (independent of h) such that ||rw (x, hD)u||B2k1 ,1 ≤ Ch−3k1 ||u||B2k0 ,1 , ∀u ∈ B2k0 (Rn ; CN ), and
||rw (x, hD)u||B2k1 ,h ≤ Ch−k1 ||u||B2k0 ,h , ∀u ∈ B2k0 (Rn ; CN ),
for all h ∈ (0, 1]. In particular, when 0 ≤ k0 < k1 ≤ N0 , rw (x, hD) : B2k0 (Rn ; CN ) −→ B2k1 (Rn ; CN ) →→ B2k0 (Rn ; CN ) is compact, for all h ∈ (0, 1].
9.4 Some Spectral Properties of Semiclassical GPDOs
143
Proof. Given any u ∈ S (Rn ; CN ), we have that rw (x, hD)u ∈ S (Rn ; CN ). Hence it suffices to prove the inequalities for Schwartz functions u, with constants independent of u and h. Since B2k0 (Rn ; CN ) ⊂ L2 (Rn ; CN ) with ||u||20 ≤ ||u||2B2k0 ,h ,
and
||u||20 ≤ ||u||2B2k0 ,1 ,
from Proposition 9.3.1 we have ||rw (x, hD)u||2B2k1 ,h ≤ Ch−2k1 ||u||20 ≤ Ch−2k1 ||u||2B2k0 ,h , and ||rw (x, hD)u||2B2k1 ,1 ≤ Ch−6k1 ||u||20 ≤ h−6k1 ||u||2B2k0 ,1 , for a constant C > 0 independent of u and of h, which concludes the proof.
9.4 Some Spectral Properties of Semiclassical GPDOs We establish in this section a few useful results about spectral properties of h-Weyl quantizations of N × N semiclassical GPD systems which are positive elliptic. We start by giving the definition of semiclassical global polynomial differential system. Definition 9.4.1 (Semiclassical GPD). We shall say that a classical semiclassical 0 (m μ , g; M ) is a semiclassical GPD system of order μ if μ ∈ N symbol a ∈ S0,cl N and a=
[ μ /2]
∑ h j aμ −2 j ,
a μ −2 j ∈ S(mμ −2 j , g; MN )
j=0
(with [μ /2] denoting, as usual, the integer part of μ /2), where the entries of the a μ −2 j are homogeneous polynomials in X ∈ R2n of degree μ − 2 j. 0 (m μ , g; M ) of order μ is ellipWe say that a semiclassical GPD system a ∈ S0,cl N ∗ tic (resp. positive elliptic, when a = a ) if the principal part aμ is a homogeneous globally elliptic (resp. globally positive elliptic) symbol. The h-Weyl quantization of a semiclassical GPD will be called an h-GPDO. Suppose a=
[ μ /2]
∑ h j aμ −2 j
j=0
is an N × N semiclassical GPD symbol of order μ ∈ N in Rn . Since (9.5) holds also on S (Rn ; CN ) and S (Rn ; CN ), we have the following lemma.
144
9 Some Tools from the Semiclassical Calculus
0 (m μ , g; M ) be an N × N semiclassical Lemma 9.4.2. Let E > 0 and let a ∈ S0,cl N GPD system of order μ ∈ N. Let UE be the isometry introduced in Remark 9.1.2. Then ˜ UE−1 aw (x, hD)UE = E μ /2 aw (x, hD), (9.49)
where h˜ = h/E and ˜ = aw (x, hD)
[ μ /2]
˜ ∑ h˜ j awμ −2 j (x, hD).
j=0
In particular, when E = h, we have Uh−1 aw (x, hD)Uh = hμ /2 aw (x, D),
(9.50)
where aw (x, D) =
[ μ /2]
∑ awμ −2 j (x, D).
j=0
Proof. The proof follows immediately from Remark 9.1.2. In fact, it suffices to observe that for h˜ = h/E we have √ √ ˜ = U −1 aw (x, hD)UE aw ( E x, E hD) E =
[ μ /2]
∑
h jUE−1 aw μ −2 j (x, hD)UE =
j=0
=
[ μ /2]
√ √ ˜ E x, E hD)
∑ h˜ j E j awμ −2 j (
j=0
[ μ /2]
˜ = E μ /2 aw (x, hD), ˜ ∑ h˜ j E j E μ /2− j awμ −2 j (x, hD)
(9.51)
j=0
in view of the fact that h = E h˜ and that the aμ −2 j have entries which are all homogeneous of degree μ − 2 j. We therefore get the following scaling properties of eigenvalues. 0 (m μ , g; M ) be an N × N semiclassical Lemma 9.4.3. Let E > 0 and let a ∈ S0,cl N GPD system of order μ ∈ N. Let UE be the isometry introduced in Remark 9.1.2. Then aw (x, hD)u(h) = λ (h)u(h), u(h) ∈ L2 (Rn ; CN ), u(h) = 0,
that is u(h) is an eigenfunction of aw (x, hD) belonging to the eigenvalue λ (h), iff, ˜ := U −1 u(h) ∈ L2 (Rn ; CN ), with u( ˜ h) E ˜ u( ˜ = ˜ h) aw (x, hD)
˜ λ (E h) ˜ where h˜ = h , u( ˜ h), μ /2 E E
9.4 Some Spectral Properties of Semiclassical GPDOs
145
˜ λ (E h) ˜ is an eigenfunction of aw (x, hD) ˜ that is, u( ˜ h) belonging to the eigenvalue μ /2 . E Hence,
λ (h) ∈ Spec(aw (x, hD)) ⇐⇒
˜ λ (E h) h ˜ ∈ Spec(aw (x, hD)), h˜ = . μ /2 E E
In particular, when E = h, one obtains that
λ (h) ∈ Spec(aw (x, hD)) ⇐⇒
λ (h) ∈ Spec(aw (x, D)). hμ /2
Proof. The proof follows immediately from Lemma 9.4.2.
As a (by now elementary) consequence of the results of Section 3.2, namely Remark 9.1.2, Lemma 9.4.2 and Theorem 3.3.13 we have the following fact concerning the spectrum of semiclassical GPD systems. 0 (m μ , g; M ) be an N × N positive elliptic semiProposition 9.4.4. Let A = A∗ ∈ S0,cl N classical GPD system of order μ ∈ 2N. Consider the unbounded operator A(h) defined by A(h) : Bμ (Rn ; CN ) ⊂ L2 (Rn ; CN ) −→ L2 (Rn ; CN ),
A(h)u = Aw (x, hD)u, ∀u ∈ Bμ (Rn ; CN ). Then A(h) is semi-bounded from below for all h ∈ (0, 1]. Hence, Spec(A(h)) is made of a sequence of eigenvalues {λ j (h)} j≥1 ⊂ R with finite multiplicities, such that −∞ < λ1 (h) ≤ λ2 (h) ≤ . . . ≤ λ j (h) ≤ . . . −→ +∞, with repetitions according to the multiplicity. As before, the eigenfunctions of A(h) all belong to the Schwartz space and form, possibly after an orthonormalization procedure, a basis of L2 (Rn ; CN ). Proof. In fact, by Lemma 9.4.2 we have Uh−1 A(h)Uh = hμ /2 A(1), so that (A(h)u, u) = (Uh−1 A(h)UhUh−1 u,Uh−1 u) = hμ /2 (A(1)Uh−1 u,Uh−1 u) ≥ −hμ /2C||Uh−1 u||20 = −hμ /2C||u||20 , ∀u ∈ S (Rn ; CN ). This concludes the proof of the lemma.
Hence, when A is an N × N positive elliptic semiclassical GPD system of order μ we immediately obtain from the Minimax Principle, Lemma 9.4.3 and Proposition 9.4.4 the following corollary.
146
9 Some Tools from the Semiclassical Calculus
0 (m μ , g; M ) be an N × N positive elliptic semiCorollary 9.4.5. Let A = A∗ ∈ S0,cl N classical GPD system of order μ ∈ 2N. Let φ j ∈ S (Rn ; CN ), j ∈ N, be an eigenfunction of Aw (x, D) (i.e. with h = 1) belonging to the eigenvalue λ j . Then
x ϕ j (h; x) := (Uh φ j )(x) = h−n/4φ j ( √ ) h
(9.52)
belongs to the eigenvalue λ j (h) := h μ /2 λ j of Aw (x, hD). In particular √ h ϕ j ( ; x) = E n/4 ϕ j (h; E x), j ≥ 1, E belongs to the eigenvalue λ j ( Eh ) = imax, for every j ∈ N
μ /2 h E
(9.53)
λ j of Aw (x, Eh D). Hence, using the Min-
λ j ∈ Spec(Aw (x, D)) ⇐⇒ hμ /2 λ j = λ j (h) ∈ Spec(Aw (x, hD)). We finally consider the following situation, that will be very useful later on. Let 0 (m μ , g; M ) be an N × N semiclassical positive elliptic GPD system. A = A∗ ∈ S0,cl N Let R = R∗ ∈ S00 (1, g; MN ) with supp(R) ⊂ K, where K is a compact set independent of h. Then Rw (x, hD) : S (Rn ; CN ) −→ S (Rn ; CN ) is continuous and, as an operator in L2 , ||Rw (x, hD)||L2 →L2 = O(1) for all h ∈ (0, 1] (see Dimassi-Sj¨ostrand [7]). We have the following important result. 0 (m μ , g; M ) be an N × N semiclassical posiProposition 9.4.6. Let A = A∗ ∈ S0,cl N ∗ 0 tive elliptic GPD system, and let R = R ∈ S0 (1, g; MN ) with supp(R) ⊂ K, where w K is a compact set independent of h. Let us consider Aw 0 (x, hD) = A (x, hD) + w R (x, hD). Then for all h ∈ (0, 1] the unbounded operator A0 (h) defined by
A0 (h) : Bμ (Rn ; CN ) ⊂ L2 (Rn ; CN ) −→ L2 (Rn ; CN ), μ n N A0 (h)u = Aw 0 (x, hD)u, ∀u ∈ B (R ; C ),
is self-adjoint with a discrete spectrum bounded from below, made of a sequence of eigenvalues {λ j (h)} j≥1 ⊂ R with finite multiplicities, such that −∞ < λ1 (h) ≤ λ2 (h) ≤ . . . ≤ λ j (h) ≤ . . . −→ +∞, with repetitions according to the multiplicity. Proof. That A0 (h) = A0 (h)∗ with the same domain Bμ of A(h) is trivial, for Rw (x, hD) is bounded in L2 and symmetric. By Theorem 10.1.1 below the resolvent set of A0 (h) is non-empty, and since Bμ is compactly embedded into L2 , A0 (h)
9.4 Some Spectral Properties of Semiclassical GPDOs
147
also has a discrete spectrum, that must be bounded from below, for the spectrum of A(h) is bounded from below and Rw (x, hD) is bounded in L2 . Remark 9.4.7. One may prove the discreteness of Spec(A0 (h)) also as follows. Since the Schwartz-kernel
x+y , hξ )d ξ 2 −1 x+y , ξ )d ξ = (2π h)−n eih x−y,ξ R( 2 x + y ,t) t=h−1 (x−y) = h−n (Fξ →t R)( 2
KR (x, y; h) = (2π )−n
ei x−y,ξ R(
of Rw (x, hD) belongs to S (Rn × Rn ; MN ), the operator Rw (x, hD) is actually Hilbert-Schmidt. Hence A0 (h) and A(h) have the same essential spectrum. Since the essential spectrum of A(h) is empty, the same is true for that of A0 (h). Remark 9.4.8. More generally, one may prove that if a classical semiclassical sym0 bol A = A∗ ∈ S0,cl (mμ , g; MN ), with μ ≥ 1, has globally positive elliptic principal symbol, then there exists h0 ∈ (0, 1] such that the unbounded operator A(h) defined by A(h) : Bμ (Rn ; CN ) ⊂ L2 (Rn ; CN ) −→ L2 (Rn ; CN ), A(h)u = Aw (x, hD)u, ∀u ∈ Bμ (Rn ; CN ), is self-adjoint, semi-bounded from below and with a discrete spectrum, for all h ∈ (0, h0 ]. In addition, from the elliptic regularity we have that its eigenfunctions are in S (Rn ; CN ), and, possibly after an orthonormalization procedure, they form a basis of L2 (Rn ; CN ). In fact, one uses (9.5) of Remark 9.1.2 (with E = h), namely √ √ Uh−1 Aw (x, hD)Uh = Aw ( h x, h D) to reduce matters to Theorem 3.3.13.
Chapter 10
On Operators Induced by General Finite-Rank Orthogonal Projections
In this chapter we further prepare the ground for the eigenvalue localization of elliptic global systems. Namely, in the following chapters we shall have to control the sandwitch (I − Π )B(I − Π ) of an operator B, semi-bounded from below, by the orthogonal projectors (I − Π ) relative to another operator A, semi-bounded from below. We present things in an abstract setting, for this is a useful machinery. Throughout this chapter H will always stand for a separable (infinite-dimensional) Hilbert space endowed with the scalar product (·, ·) = (·, ·)H .
10.1 Reductions by a Finite-Rank Orthogonal Projection The first result we need is the following theorem (see Kato’s book [35, Theorem 4.10, p. 291]). Theorem 10.1.1. Let T : D(T ) ⊂ H −→ H be self-adjoint (hence it is densely defined), and let B = B∗ ∈ L (H, H) (where, recall, L (H, H) denotes the space of bounded linear operators on H). Then S = T + B : D(T ) ⊂ H −→ H is self-adjoint and dist Spec(T ), Spec(S) ≤ ||B||, that is, sup
ζ ∈Spec(S)
dist(ζ , Spec(T )) ≤ ||B||,
sup
ζ ∈Spec(T )
dist(ζ , Spec(S)) ≤ ||B||,
(10.1)
where ||B|| = ||B||H→H . Let next T : D(T ) ⊂ H −→ H be a densely defined semi-bounded from below self-adjoint operator with compact resolvent. Hence T has a discrete spectrum made of a sequence {λ j } j≥1 of eigenvalues −∞ < λ1 ≤ λ2 ≤ . . . ≤ λ j ≤ . . . → +∞, repeated according to the multiplicity. Let {u j } j∈Z+ ⊂ D(T ) be any fixed orthonormal basis of H.
A. Parmeggiani, Spectral Theory of Non-Commutative Harmonic Oscillators: An Introduction, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1992, c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2010 DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-11922-4 10,
149
150
10 On Operators Induced by General Finite-Rank Orthogonal Projections
Remark 10.1.2. It is important to note that we do not assume that the u j be eigenfunctions of T (otherwise the result we wish to prove, namely Theorem 10.1.3 below, is a trivial consequence of the Spectral Theorem). Fix N0 ∈ N and let Π = ΠN0 : H −→ H be the finite-rank orthogonal projector onto Span{u1 , . . . , uN0 },
Π=
N0
∑ u∗j ⊗ u j : u −→
j=1
Note that
N0
∑ (u, u j )u j .
j=1
Π u ∈ D(T ), ∀u ∈ H,
and that (I − Π )u ∈ D(T ) ⇐⇒ u ∈ D(T ). We have the following consequence of Theorem 10.1.1. Theorem 10.1.3. The operator T+ := (I − Π )T (I − Π ) = T − Π T + T Π + Π T Π : D(T ) ⊂ H −→ H is self-adjoint, semi-bounded from below, with compact resolvent. Hence its spectrum is discrete and real. Proof. Consider the operators Π T, T Π , Π T Π : D(T ) ⊂ H −→ H. It is immediately seen that T− := Π T Π ∈ L (H, H) is symmetric and compact. Now, since the u j belong to D(T ) and T is self-adjoint, we have D(T ) u −→ Π Tu =
N0
N0
j=1
j=1
∑ (Tu, u j )u j = ∑ (u, Tu j )u j ,
which shows that Π T extends to a bounded operator T1 ∈ L (H, H) such that T1 D(T ) = Π T. Similarly, D(T ) u −→ T Π u =
N0
∑ (u, u j )Tu j ,
j=1
shows that T Π = T2 ∈ L (H, H). We now have that T1 + T2 is symmetric. In fact, (T1 u, v) = (Π Tu, v) = (u, T Π v) = (u, T2 v), ∀u, v ∈ D(T ), from which, T1 and T2 being bounded operators, the claim follows. Hence, the boundedness of T1 , T2 , T− and Theorem 10.1.1 give that T+ = T − (T1 + T2 ) + T− is self-adjoint and semi-bounded from below.
10.1 Reductions by a Finite-Rank Orthogonal Projection
151
Pick now ζ0 ∈ C such that dist(ζ0 , Spec(T )) > ||B||,
(10.2)
where B = −T1 − T2 + T− . Then, again by Theorem 10.1.1, ζ0 ∈ Spec(T+ ). Let R(ζ ) = (ζ − T )−1 be the resolvent operator of T and R+ (ζ ) the one of T+ . Then, since 1 ||R(ζ )|| = , dist(ζ , Spec(T )) (10.2) gives that the Neumann series relative to (I − BR(ζ0 ))−1 converges in L (H, H), whence −1 R+ (ζ0 ) = R(ζ0 ) I − BR(ζ0) . Since R(ζ0 ) is a compact operator, this completes the proof of the theorem.
Corollary 10.1.4. The operator T˜ := T− + T+ : D(T ) ⊂ H −→ H
(10.3)
is self-adjoint, semi-bounded from below, with compact resolvent. Hence its spectrum is discrete and real. Proof. It is immediate from Theorem 10.1.3 and Theorem 10.1.1.
Remark 10.1.5. It is important to notice that T− u ∈ D(T ) = D(T+ ) for all u ∈ H, so that it makes always sense to consider T+ T− , and that T+ T− u = 0, ∀u ∈ H, and T− T+ u = 0, ∀u ∈ D(T ).
(10.4)
[T+ , T− ] = 0 on D(T ).
(10.5)
In particular Define now the operators T+− := (I − Π )T Π : H −→ H, T+− ∈ L (H, H), T−+ := Π T (I − Π ) : D(T ) ⊂ H −→ H. It is readily seen that T−+ = Π T − T− can be extended to a bounded operator in H, that we keep denoting by T−+ , so that we also have ∗ T−+ = T+− .
Moreover, on setting H+ := (I − Π )H, H− := Π H,
152
10 On Operators Induced by General Finite-Rank Orthogonal Projections
we have that the H± are closed subspaces of H with H±⊥ = H∓ , so that H = H− ⊕ H+ with orthogonal direct-sum. Notice that, since H− ⊂ D(T ), it makes sense to con sider T+ H . Notice also that −
T+ H = 0, and T− H = 0. −
+
(10.6)
Take now an ON basis {e j } j≥1 ⊂ D(T ) of H which diagonalizes T+ , such that Span{e j }1≤ j≤N0 = H− , Span{e j } j≥N0 +1 = H+ . (This is possible, for [Π , T+ ] = 0 on D(T ).) Rotate next the basis {e j }1≤ j≤N0 into a basis that diagonalizes the N0 × N0 Hermitian matrix T− H . Call {e˜ j }1≤ j≤N0 the − resulting basis, and notice that T+ e˜ j = 0, j = 1, . . . , N0 . Set e˜ j = e j for j ≥ N0 + 1. We thus have that {e˜ j } j≥1 ⊂ D(T ) is an ON basis of H which diagonalizes T˜ (see (10.3)). This proves that Spec(T˜ ) = Spec(T− H− ) Spec(T+ H+ ),
where
T+ H+ : D(T ) ∩ H+ ⊂ H+ −→ H+
is the part of T+ in H+ (i.e. T+ is reduced by H+ ; see Kato [35, pp. 172, 178 and 278]). Notice that D(T ) ∩ H+ = (I − Π )D(T ), for on the one hand (I − Π )D(T ) ⊂ D(T ) and (I − Π )D(T ) ⊂ (I − Π )H = H+ , and on the other u ∈ D(T ) ∩ H+ =⇒ u = Π u + (I − Π )u = (I − Π )u ∈ (I − Π )D(T ). Since T = T˜ + T0, where T0 = T+− + T−+ = T0∗ ∈ L (H, H), once more from Theorem 10.1.1 we have dist Spec(T ), Spec(T˜ ) = dist Spec(T ), Spec(T± H± ) ≤ ||T0 ||. ±
(10.7)
10.1 Reductions by a Finite-Rank Orthogonal Projection
153
Since (T− being symmetric and compact) Spec(T− ) = Spec(T− H− ) ∪ {0} ⊂ [−||T− ||, ||T− ||], and since T+ has a discrete spectrum which is positively diverging to +∞ (T+ is semi-bounded from below, for T is so, and it has a discrete spectrum by Theorem 10.1.3) one obtains the following theorem. Theorem 10.1.6. In the hypotheses of Theorem 10.1.3, upon denoting δ := ||T0 || and choosing E > ||T− || + 3δ , we have that Spec(T ) ∩ (E, +∞) ⊂
[λ+ − δ , λ+ + δ ].
(10.8)
λ+ ∈Spec(T+ )∩(E−δ ,+∞)
Remark 10.1.7. Notice that when the u j are eigenfunctions of T, T+− = 0 and T−+ = 0 then, so that δ = ||T0 || = 0. Notice that one could have obtained (10.7) and the result of Theorem 10.1.6 by writing T as the (unbounded) system *
+ T− H− T−+ H+ : H− ⊕ (D(T ) ∩ H+ ) ⊂ H− ⊕ H+ −→ H− ⊕ H+, T+− H T+ H −
+
by using Proposition 10.1.8 below that shows that T+ H+ is self-adjoint in H+ (semi-bounded from below) with compact resolvent, and finally by using once more Theorem 10.1.1. Proposition 10.1.8. The operator T+ H+ : D(T ) ∩ H+ ⊂ H+ −→ H+ is self-adjoint in H+ with compact resolvent (and is obviously semi-bounded from below). Proof. Put, for short, T(+) = T+ H+ . Recall that (u, v)H+ := ((I − Π )u, (I − Π )v)H = (u, v)H , ∀u, v ∈ H+ . Then ∗ ) = {u ∈ H+ ; ∃v ∈ H+ , (T(+) u , u)H+ = (u , v)H+ , ∀u ∈ D(T(+) )}. D(T(+)
Since for all u, v ∈ D(T(+) ) = D(T ) ∩ H+ (T(+) u, v)H+ = (T+ u, v)H = (u, T+ v)H = (u, T(+) v)H+ , we always have
∗ D(T(+) ) ⊂ D(T(+) ).
154
10 On Operators Induced by General Finite-Rank Orthogonal Projections
∗ ). Then, for some v ∈ H , Take u ∈ D(T(+) +
(T(+) u , u)H+ = (u , v)H+ , ∀u ∈ D(T(+) ), that is, (T+ u , u)H = (u , v)H , ∀u ∈ D(T ) ∩ H+ .
Since T+ H− = 0 and H− is orthogonal to H+ , it also follows that (T+ u , u)H = (u , v)H , ∀u ∈ D(T ), for, given any u ∈ D(T ), (T+ u , u)H = (T+ [Π u + (I − Π )u ], u)H = (T+ (I − Π )u, u)H = ((I − Π )u , v)H = (Π u + (I − Π )u , v)H = (u , v)H . Hence u ∈ D(T ∗ ) = D(T ), and since u ∈ H+ , we thus obtain u ∈ D(T ) ∩ H+ = D(T(+) ). It follows that ∗ D(T(+) ) ⊂ D(T(+) ) and this proves the self-adjointness claim. To prove the compactness of the resolvent we observe, in the first place, that if ζ belongs to the resolvent set of T+ (which is non-empty by the semi-boundedness assumption) we have that the operator H+ u −→ (I − Π )(ζ − T+ )−1 (I − Π )u ∈ D(T ) ∩ H+ ⊂ H+ is continuous and compact, for (ζ − T+ )−1 is a compact operator and (I − Π ) is bounded. On the other hand, for all u ∈ H+ , (ζ − T(+))(I − Π )(ζ − T+ )−1 (I − Π )u = (ζ − T+ )(I − Π )(ζ − T+ )−1 (I − Π )u = (I − Π )(ζ − T+ )(ζ − T+ )−1 (I − Π )u = (I − Π )u = u, and for all u ∈ D(T ) ∩ H+ , (I − Π )(ζ − T+)−1 (I − Π )(ζ − T(+) )u = (I − Π )(ζ − T+ )−1 (I − Π )(ζ − T+ )u = (I − Π )(ζ − T+ )−1 (ζ − T+ )(I − Π )u = (I − Π )u = u. This proves that (ζ − T(+) )−1 = (I − Π )(ζ − T+ )−1 (I − Π ) for all ζ in the resolvent set of T+ , and concludes the proof.
10.2 Semiclassical Reduction by a Finite-Rank Orthogonal Projection
155
10.2 Semiclassical Reduction by a Finite-Rank Orthogonal Projection We now make things more precise, and introduce also the dependence on the semiclassical parameter h ∈ (0, 1]. Let D ⊂ H be independent of h, dense and compactly embedded in H, and let A = A(h) : D(A) = D ⊂ H −→ H, be a selfadjoint operator with A ≥ −CI on D. Let therefore {λ j (h)} j≥1 be the sequence −∞ < λ1 (h) ≤ λ2 (h) ≤ . . . ≤ λ j (h) ≤ . . . → +∞ of its eigenvalues, repeated according to their multiplicities. Let {u j (h)} j≥1 ⊂ D be a corresponding ON basis of eigenfunctions. Let E0 ≥ 10 be fixed (independent of h), and let us consider the orthogonal projector
Π = Π (h) = ∑ u j (h)∗ ⊗ u j (h) = λ j (h)≤E0
N0
∑ u∗j ⊗ u j : H −→ Span{u1, . . . , uN0 } ⊂ D,
j=1
where N0 = N0 (h) is the number of eigenvalues λ j (h) of A, repeated according to multiplicity, which satisfy λ j (h) ≤ E0 (in the sequel we will often drop the explicit dependence on h). Hence [Π , A] = 0 on D, and, by the Spectral Theorem, Spec((I − Π )A(I − Π )) ∩ (E0 , +∞) = Spec(A) ∩ (E0 , +∞), or, equivalently, Spec((I − Π )A(I − Π )) \ {0} = Spec(A) ∩ (E0 , +∞). Let R = R(h) = R∗ : H −→ H be in L (H, H) with ||R||H→H ≤ cR , ∀h ∈ (0, 1],
(10.9)
where cR > 0 is independent of h, and suppose that ||(I − Π )R||H→H = ||R(I − Π )||H→H = O(h∞ )
(10.10)
(we shall write (I − Π )R = O(h∞ ) and R(I − Π ) = O(h∞ ), respectively). Consider B = B(h) = A + R : D ⊂ H −→ H.
(10.11)
By Theorem 10.1.1 (and the proof of Theorem 10.1.3), we have that B = B∗ with compact resolvent for all h ∈ (0, 1]. Moreover, B ≥ −C I on D. Let hence { μ j (h)} j≥1 be the sequence −∞ < μ1 ≤ μ2 ≤ . . . → +∞ of its eigenvalues, repeated according to multiplicity. Define, as before, B− := Π BΠ , B+ = (I − Π )B(I − Π ), and B˜ = B− + B+.
156
10 On Operators Induced by General Finite-Rank Orthogonal Projections
The operator B− is bounded and symmetric (in fact, a finite-rank operator), and it follows from Theorems 10.1.1 and 10.1.3 that B+ and B˜ are self-adjoint with the same domain D, semi-bounded from below, with a discrete spectrum. Let ˜ = {μ˜ j } j≥1 , −∞ < μ˜ 1 ≤ μ˜ 2 ≤ . . . → +∞, Spec(B) + + Spec(B+ ) = { μ + j } j≥1 , −∞ < μ1 ≤ μ2 ≤ . . . → +∞,
with repetitions according to multiplicity. Notice, moreover, that since B− u ∈ D for all u ∈ H, it always makes sense to consider B+ B− . Let, as before, H− := Π H, H+ := (I − Π )H, so that H− ⊂ D, H+ = H−⊥ , and H = H− ⊕ H+ . We have B+ H− = 0, B− H+ = 0, and B+ B− = B− B+ = 0 on D
(10.12)
(hence, in particular, [B+ , B− ] = 0 on D). It is readily seen, by (10.10), that (I − Π )A(I − Π ) = B+ + R1 , where R1 = O(h∞ )
(10.13)
and that (since (I − Π )AΠ = Π A(I − Π ) = 0 by the Spectral Theorem) B = B˜ + R2 , where R2 = O(h∞ ).
(10.14)
Notice that there exists h0 ∈ (0, 1] such that for any given h ∈ (0, h0 ] we have B+ H+ > 0. (10.15) This follows from (10.13). In fact, let us fix an arbitrary integer N ≥ 1. Then we have from (10.13) that there exists CN+1 > 0 such that ||R j ||H→H ≤ CN+1 hN+1 , j = 1, 2, ∀h ∈ (0, 1]. We may therefore fix h0 ∈ (0, 1], such that CN+1 h < 1/102 for all h ∈ (0, h0 ], whence ||R j ||H→H < 10−2 hN , j = 1, 2, ∀h ∈ (0, h0 ]. Then, for all u ∈ D ∩ H+ , (B+ u, u) = ((I − Π )A(I − Π )u, u) − (R1u, u) ≥ ≥ (E0 − 10−2hN )||u||2 > (E0 − 1)||u||2, ∀h ∈ (0, h0 ], which proves the claim.
(10.16)
10.2 Semiclassical Reduction by a Finite-Rank Orthogonal Projection
157
Hence, from (10.15) we have that 0 ∈ Spec(B+ ) with multiplicity N0
(10.17)
(notice that N0 = dim H− ). From (10.13) and (10.16) we have that for all u ∈ D with ||u|| = 1 −10−2hN + (B+ u, u) ≤ ((I − Π )A(I − Π )u, u) ≤ (B+ u, u) + 10−2 hN , ∀h ∈ (0, h0 ]. (10.18) Since for each j ≥ N0 + 1 E0 < λ j = (Au j , u j ) = ((I − Π )A(I − Π )u j , u j ) ⎡ =
sup
v1 ,...,v j−1 lin. ind.
⎢ ⎣
inf
v∈Span{v1 ,...,v j−1 ||v||=1
and since
⎤
⎥ ((I − Π )A(I − Π )v, v)⎦ ,
}⊥ ∩D
⎤
⎡
μ+ j =
sup
v1 ,...,v j−1 lin.ind.
⎢ ⎣
inf
v∈Span{v1 ,...,v j−1 ||v||=1
⎥ (B+ v, v)⎦ ,
}⊥ ∩D
it thus follows from (10.18) and the Minimax Principle that for any given h ∈ (0, h0 ] −2 N + |λ j (h) − μ + j (h)| < 10 h , and 0 < E0 − 1 < μ j (h), ∀ j ≥ N0 (h) + 1. (10.19)
Hence (10.19) says that for any given h ∈ (0, h0 ], for j ≥ N0 (h) + 1 the j-th eigenvalue of A(h) is within distance 10−2 hN to the j-th eigenvalue of B+ (h). Therefore, for the eigenvalues of B+ we have
μ1+ = . . . = μN+0 = 0, 0 < μN+0 +1 ≤ μN+0 +2 ≤ . . . .
(10.20)
Notice also that B− H− is represented in the basis {u1, . . . , uN0 } by the N0 × N0 matrix acting on N0 -dimensional vectors ⎡ ⎤ (u, u1 ) N0 ⎢ ⎥ .. u = ∑ (u, u j )u j $ ⎣ ⎦, . j =1
(u, uN0 )
as B− H u = −
N0
∑
j, j =1
(u, u j )(Bu j , u j )u j ,
158
10 On Operators Induced by General Finite-Rank Orthogonal Projections
i.e. by the matrix whose j j -entry is given by
and that
B− H−
j j
= (Bu j , u j ), 1 ≤ j, j ≤ N0 ,
Spec(B− ) = Spec(B− H− ) ∪ {0} ⊂ [−c0 , c0 ],
(10.21)
where c0 := cR + E0 . In fact, B− is a compact self-adjoint operator, so that its spectrum is contained in the interval [−||B− ||H→H , ||B− ||H→H ]. Since ||B− ||H→H = ||Π (A + R)Π ||H→H ≤ E0 + ||Π RΠ ||H→H ≤ E0 + cR = c0 , (10.21) follows. Put Spec(B− H− ) = { μ1− , . . . , μN−0 }. We next consider an ON basis {e j } j≥1 ⊂ D of H, where Span{e1 , . . . , eN0 } = H− , and Span{e j } j≥N0 +1 = H+ , which diagonalizes B+ (this is possible, for [Π , B+ ] = 0 on D): B+ e j = 0, 1 ≤ j ≤ N0 , B+ e j = μ + j e j , j ≥ N0 + 1.
(10.22)
Notice then that, from (10.12), B− e j = 0, ∀ j ≥ N0 + 1. Let us then rotate the e1 , . . . , eN0 to obtain a new ON basis e˜1 , . . . , e˜N0 of H− which diagonalizes the Hermitian matrix B− H− . Defining e˜ j = e j for j ≥ N0 + 1 gives ˜ B− therefore an ON basis {e˜ j } j≥1 ⊂ D of H which simultaneously diagonalizes B, and B+ . Hence, in particular, + ˜ B˜ e˜ j = μ − j e˜ j , 1 ≤ j ≤ N0 , Be˜ j = μ j e˜ j , j ≥ N0 + 1.
Notice that a-priori we do not know whether or not μN−0 ≤ μN+0 +1 , so that we do not have, as yet, that the sequence {μ1− , . . . , μN−0 , μN+0 +1 , . . .} coincides with the ˜ We have therefore to non-decreasing sequence {μ˜ j } j≥1 of the eigenvalues of B. rearrange the μ ± in a non-decreasing order. Let j + S+ = { μ + j ; 0 < μ j ≤ c0 }.
Then { j ∈ Z+ ; μ + j ∈ S+ } = {N0 + 1, . . ., N0 + ν+ }, / Since for some ν+ = ν+ (h) ∈ Z+ (where ν+ = 0 if S+ = 0). {μ1− , . . . , μN−0 } ∪ S+
10.2 Semiclassical Reduction by a Finite-Rank Orthogonal Projection
159
is a finite set, we may arrange, in a non-decreasing order, with repetitions (according + − + to multiplicity among the μ − j , resp. the μ j , and equalities between the μ j and μ j ), the elements + μ− j , 1 ≤ j ≤ N0 , and μ j , N0 + 1 ≤ j ≤ N0 + ν+ ,
the resulting sequence being μ˜ j , 1 ≤ j ≤ N0 + ν+ , and call u˜ j the associated eigenvectors. Put finally u˜ j = e˜ j when j ≥ N0 + ν+ + 1. We therefore obtain the ON ˜ and have that sequence {u˜ j } j≥1 of eigenvectors of B, j ≥ N0 + ν+ + 1 ⇐⇒ μ + j > c0 . Hence, since for j ≥ N + 1 + ν+
μ+ j = (B+ u˜ j , u˜ j ) =
⎤
⎡ sup
v1 ,...,v j−1 lin. ind.
⎢ ⎣
inf
v∈Span{v1 ,...,v j−1 }⊥ ∩D ||v||=1
⎤
⎡
since
μj =
sup
v1 ,...,v j−1 lin. ind.
⎢ ⎣
˜ v)⎥ (Bv, ⎦,
inf
v∈Span{v1 ,...,v j−1 ||v||=1
⎥ (Bv, v)⎦ ,
}⊥ ∩D
and since by (10.14) and (10.16) we have that for all u ∈ D with ||u|| = 1 ˜ u) ≤ (Bu, u) ≤ (Bu, ˜ u) + 10−2hN , ∀h ∈ (0, h0 ], −10−2hN + (Bu, it therefore follows that for any given h ∈ (0, h0 ], for j ≥ N + 1 + ν+ −2 N |μ + j (h) − μ j (h)| < 10 h .
(10.23)
Hence (10.23) says that for any given h ∈ (0, h0 ], for j ≥ N0 (h) + ν+ (h) + 1 the j-th ˜ eigenvalue of B+ (h) is the j-th eigenvalue of B(h) and is within distance 10−2hN to the j-th eigenvalue of B(h). Therefore, combining (10.19) and (10.23) yields the following theorem. Theorem 10.2.1. Let E, E > 0 with E > E ≥ E0 + cR + 102 be fixed. Given any fixed N ≥ 1, there exists h0 ∈ (0, 1] such that for any given h ∈ (0, h0 ] the following holds: , Spec(A) ∩ (E, +∞) ⊂ (10.24) μ (h) − hN , μ (h) + hN , μ (h)∈Spec(B)∩(E ,+∞)
and, more precisely, given any j ≥ 1 so large that λ j (h) > E, then, with the same j, |λ j (h) − μ j (h)| ≤ hN ,
(10.25)
where, recall, Spec(A(h)) = {−∞ < λ1 (h) ≤ λ2 (h) ≤ . . . → +∞} and Spec(B(h)) = {−∞ < μ1 (h) ≤ μ2 (h) ≤ . . . → +∞}.
Chapter 11
Energy-Levels, Dynamics, and the Maslov Index
Our aim here is to study periodicity properties of the integral trajectories of the Hamilton vector field of a given pseudodifferential symbol p, lying in energy-level sets of the kind p−1 (E), E ∈ [E1 , E2 ], with which we shall associate the action integral. This will be done in the next section. In section 11.2 we shall then give a crash introduction to the Maslov index of a periodic trajectory, with the aim of enabling the reader to compute it in the cases of interest for us. In the notes to the chapter we shall also give a rapid overview of the reason why one needs this symplectic invariant, that will systematically appear in Chapter 12.
11.1 Introducing the Dynamics We now introduce the Dynamics into our considerations. Recall that, given a smooth real-valued function p defined on phase-space Rnx × Rnξ = R2n X , X = (x, ξ ), we may consider the associated Hamilton vector-field defined by Hp =
∂p ∂ ∂p ∂ . − ∂xj ∂ξj j=1 ∂ ξ j ∂ x j n
∑
Notice that, using the canonical symplectic 2-form σ on R2n and its non-degeneracy, one has that H p is uniquely defined, at (x, ξ ) ∈ R2n , by the relation d p(v) = σ (v, H p ), ∀v ∈ R2n ,
(11.1)
where v is thought of as a tangent vector to R2n at (x, ξ ). The integral trajectories γ of H p , called the bicharacteristic curves of p (or simply bicharacteristics of p), are the solutions of dγ (t) = H p (γ (t)). dt
A. Parmeggiani, Spectral Theory of Non-Commutative Harmonic Oscillators: An Introduction, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 1992, c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2010 DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-11922-4 11,
161
162
11 Energy-Levels, Dynamics, and the Maslov Index
We shall write
γX0 (t) = exp(tH p )(x0 , ξ0 ) = exp(tH p )(X0 ), γX0 (0) = (x0 , ξ0 ) = X0 , for the integral trajectory issued from X0 . It is easy to see that if X0 ∈ p−1 (E) then γX0 (t) ∈ p−1 (E) for all t in the interval of existence of γX0 . When p−1 (E) is compact, γX0 exists for all times. One calls p−1 (E) an energy surface (or energy level). Following Dimassi-Sj¨ostrand [7] and Helffer-Robert [20], we make the following assumptions on p. Assumption 11.1.1 (Dynamical assumptions (H1)-(H3)). Let E1 < E2 , and let 0 < ε be sufficiently small. We assume that: • (H1) d p = 0 for all X ∈ p−1 ([E1 − ε , E2 + ε ]); • (H2) p−1 (E) is connected for all E ∈ [E1 − ε , E2 + ε ]; • (H3) There exists a smooth function T =T (X) > 0 defined in p−1 ([E1 −ε , E2 +ε ])
such that exp(T (X)H p )(X) = X, ∀X ∈ p−1 ([E1 − ε , E2 + ε ]).
(11.2)
We have the following result. Lemma 11.1.2. Assume (H1), (H2) and (H3). Let X ∈ p−1 ([E1 − ε , E2 + ε ]) and let γX : [0, T (X)] t −→ exp(tH p )(X). Hence γX is a closed curve in p−1 ([E1 − ε , E2 + ε ]) (a periodic bicharacteristic of period T (X)). The functions X −→ T (X ), and X −→ J(X) :=
γX
ξ dx
are smooth and depend only on the value p(X ) : if X ∈ p−1 (E), for E ∈ [E1 −ε , E2 +ε ], we have T (X ) = Tp (E), J(X ) = J p (E), for some functions Tp and J p . Moreover, with J p = dJ p /dE, one has J p (E) = Tp (E). Recall that ξ dx = ∑nj=1 ξ j dx j is the canonical 1-form on R2n , such that d(ξ dx) = σ . Proof. Let [0, 1] s −→ X(s) ∈ p−1 ([E1 − ε , E2 + ε ]) be a C1 curve and put
ϕ (t, s) := exp(tH p )(X(s)), 0 ≤ s ≤ 1, 0 ≤ t ≤ T (X (s)),
11.1 Introducing the Dynamics
163
so that ϕ (T (X (s)), s) = ϕ (0, s) by (H3). Put γs := ϕ (t, s); t ∈ [0, T (X (s))] . Hence γs is a closed curve, for all s ∈ [0, 1]. We consider now the pull-back ϕ ∗ σ of the symplectic form σ by the map ϕ . Then
ϕ ∗ σ = α (t, s)dt ∧ ds, where, writing ϕ∗ for the tangent map associated with ϕ , ∂ ∂ ∂ (by (11.1)) α (t, s) = σ ϕ∗ ( ), ϕ∗ ( ) = σ H p , ϕ∗ ( ) ∂t ∂s ∂s ∂ ∂ = −d p(ϕ∗ ( )) = − p(ϕ (t, s)) . ∂s ∂s Since d(ξ dx) = σ , by the Stokes formula we have γs
ξ dx −
γ0
ξ dx =
s T (X(s )) ∂ 0
∂ s
0
p(ϕ (t, s )) dt ds .
(11.3)
But by the definition of ϕ (t, s) we have that p(ϕ (t, s)) = p(ϕ (0, s)) =: p(s), ¯ so that (11.3) reduces to γs
ξ dx −
γ0
ξ dx =
s 0
T (X(s ))
s ∂ p( ϕ (0, s )) ds = T (X (s ))d p(s ¯ ). (11.4) ∂ s 0
If all the γs are contained in the same energy surface p−1 (E), we get that γs
ξ dx −
γ0
ξ dx = 0,
that is, J(X (s)) is independent of s. Hence J(X) = J p (E) and (11.4) shows that J p (E) = Tp (E), where Tp (E) = T (X(0)).
We next show that assumptions (H1) and (H2) are fulfilled by smooth functions that are positively homogeneous of some positive degree (we will be interested in the case 2k, for some k ∈ N). This follows from Proposition 11.1.4 below. First of all, we have to recall Euler’s identity. Lemma 11.1.3. Let p ∈ C∞ (R2n \ {0}) be positively homogeneous of degree 0 = α ∈ R, that is p(τ X ) = τ α p(X), ∀τ > 0, ∀X = 0. (11.5) Then p(X) =
1 X, ∇X p(X) , ∀X = 0. α
(11.6)
164
11 Energy-Levels, Dynamics, and the Maslov Index
Proof. Given any X = 0, we have on the one hand d p(τ X) = X, ∇X p(X ) , dτ τ =1 and on the other d d α p(τ X ) = τ p(X) = α p(X ). dτ τ =1 dτ τ =1
This concludes the proof.
Proposition 11.1.4. Let p ∈ C∞ (R2n \ {0}; R+ ) be positively homogeneous of degree 2k, for some k ∈ N, that is p(τ X ) = τ 2k p(X), ∀τ > 0, ∀X = 0. Let I be any given closed interval of R, with I ⊂ (0, +∞). Then • p−1 (I) is a connected set, which is compact when I is bounded; • For all E > 0, the set p−1 (E) is a smooth compact and connected hypersurface
of R2n \ {0}.
Hence hypotheses (H1) and (H2) are always satisfied in this case, for every closed energy interval I ⊂ (0, +∞). Proof. Write any given X = 0 using polar coordinates as X = |X |
ρ > 0 and ω ∈ S2n−1 . Then
X = ρω , with |X |
p(X) = ρ 2k p(ω ), where 0 < c1 = min p(ω ) ≤ c2 = max p(ω ). ω ∈S2n−1
ω ∈S2n−1
Now, given any X ∈ p−1 (I), we have that p(X ) = ρ 2k p(ω ) = E for some E ∈ I, whence ρ = (E/p(ω ))1/2k . This shows that the map
γ : S2n−1 × I −→ p−1 (I), γ (ω , E) =
E 1 2k ω, p(ω )
is smooth and onto. Since S2n−1 × I is connected, this proves that p−1 (I) is also connected. When I is in addition also bounded, hence compact, then S2n−1 × I is compact, and therefore the same holds for p−1 (I). This proves the first claim in the statement. To prove the second claim, let E > 0 and take any X0 ∈ p−1 (E) (then, necessarily, X0 = 0). Hence X0 satisfies the equation p(X0 ) = E. By Euler’s relation (11.6) we have 1 0 < E = p(X0 ) = X0 , ∇X p(X0 ) , 2k which implies that ∇X p(X0 ) = 0, and concludes the proof.
11.1 Introducing the Dynamics
165
Let us now define the averaged action-integral associated with a trajectory [0, Tp (E)] t −→ γX (t) = exp(tH p )(X) contained in p−1 (E). Definition 11.1.5. In the dynamical assumptions (H1), (H2) and (H3) we define the averaged action-integral A p (E) = A p,γX (E) of an integral curve γX ⊂ p−1 (E), γX : [0, T (X) = Tp (E)] t −→ exp(tH p )(X), by A p (E) :=
1 T (X)
γX
ξ dx − E =
J p (E) − E. Tp (E)
(11.7)
Notice that, equivalently, since p(γX (t)) = E for all t ∈ [0, T (X )], A p (E) =
1 T (X)
γX
ξ dx −
1 T (X)
T (X) 0
p ◦ exp(tH p )(X)dt.
(11.8)
By Lemma 11.1.2 the definition of A p does not depend on γX , but only on E. When p satisfies (H1), (H2), (H3) and is such that the period Tp (E) is independent of E, for E belonging to some energy-interval I, then A p (E) is constant, as shown by the next lemma. Lemma 11.1.6. Assume (H1), (H2), (H3). Suppose that p is such that for some energy-interval I = [E1 , E2 ] the period Tp is independent of E. Then A p (E) is constant for all E ∈ I. Proof. Let Tp (E) = T0 for all E ∈ I. Since J p (E) = Tp (E) = T0 for all E ∈ [E1 , E2 ], we have that J p (E) = T0 E + J p (E1 ) on I. Hence A p (E) =
J p (E) J p (E1 ) J p (E1 ) T0 E −E = −E + = , ∀E ∈ I. Tp (E) T0 T0 T0
It will be useful also to have the following resut, about the behavior of the period Tp (E) and the action A p (E) when one changes the symbol p to α p, where α ∈ R+ is a constant. Lemma 11.1.7. Suppose p satisfies hypotheses (H1), (H2), (H3). Let α ∈ R+ be a constant. Put q=α p. Then q satisfies (H1), (H2), (H3) on the interval [α (E1 − ε ), α (E2 + ε )] with Tq (α E) = Furthermore,
Tp (E) , E ∈ [E1 − ε , E2 + ε ]. α
Aq (α E) = α A p (E), ∀E ∈ [E1 − ε , E2 + ε ].
(11.9)
166
11 Energy-Levels, Dynamics, and the Maslov Index
Proof. We have p−1 (E) = q−1 (α E), ∀E ∈ [E1 − ε , E2 + ε ].
Hq = α H p ,
Given any X ∈ p−1 (E) = q−1 (α E), E ∈ [E1 − ε , E2 + ε ], consider the curve
γ˜X : [0, Tp (E)/α ] t −→ exp(α tH p )(X) = exp(tHq )(X). Then, for all X ∈ q−1 (α E) = p−1 (E), with E ∈ [E1 − ε , E2 + ε ],
γ˜X (t) = (xq (t), ξq (t)) = exp(tHq )(X) = exp(t α H p )(X) = (x p (α t), ξ p (α t)) = γX (α t), ∀t ∈ [0, Tq (α E)], where γX : [0, Tp (E)] s −→ exp(sH p )(X). It follows that exp(
Tp (E) Hq )(X) = exp(Tp (E)H p )(X) = X , α
which shows that the function q−1 ([α (E1 − ε ), α (E2 + ε )] X −→ T (X) = Tq (q(X )) =
Tp (p(X )) >0 α
is smooth. Hence hypotheses (H1), (H2) and (H3) hold for q. Next, one has Jq (α E) = =
ξ dx =
γ˜X Tq (α E) 0
=α
Tq (α E) 0
ξq (t), x˙q (t) dt
ξq (t), (∂ξ q)(exp(tHq )(X)) dt
Tq (α E) 0
ξ p (α t), (∂ξ p)(exp(t α H p )(X)) dt
(setting α t = s) =
α Tq (α E) 0
ξ p (s), x˙p (s) ds =
γX
ξ dx = J p (E).
It thus follows that Aq (α E) =
Jq (α E) J p (E) − αE = − α E = α A p (E), Tq (α E) Tp (E)/α
for all E ∈ [E1 − ε , E2 + ε ], which concludes the proof.
11.1 Introducing the Dynamics
167
We next show that whenever there is T = Tp (E) for which hypothesis (H3) holds for a p positively homogeneous of degree 2, then T is independent of E, and A p (E) = 0. Lemma 11.1.8. Suppose p : R2n \ {0} −→ R+ is smooth, positively homogeneous of degree 2 and that (H3) is satisfied on [E1 − ε , E2 + ε ] ⊂ R+ . Then Tp does not depend on E ∈ [E1 − ε , E2 + ε ], and A p (E) = 0 for all E ∈ [E1 − ε , E2 + ε ]. Proof. Consider γX (t) = exp(tH p )(X), where X ∈ p−1 (E). In the first place, we notice that γX∗ (ξ dx) = ξ (t), x(t)
˙ dt. Now, on the one hand by virtue of the periodicity we have Tp (E) d
dt
0
ξ (t), x(t) dt = ξ (Tp (E)), x(Tp (E)) − ξ (0), x(0) = 0,
and on the other Tp (E) d
dt
0
ξ (t), x(t) dt =
Tp (E) 0
ξ˙ (t), x(t) + ξ (t), x(t)
˙ dt,
whence J p (E) =
γX
ξ dx =
Tp (E) 0
ξ (t), x(t) dt ˙ =−
Tp (E) 0
ξ˙ (t), x(t) dt.
Since, by Hamilton’s equations, Tp (E) 0
and
Tp (E) 0
ξ (t), x(t) dt ˙ =
Tp (E) .
ξ˙ (t), x(t) dt = −
it follows that
0
ξ (t),
Tp (E) . ∂p 0
∂x
/ ∂p (x(t), ξ (t)) dt ∂ξ
/ (x(t), ξ (t)), x(t) dt,
1 Tp (E) γX (t), (∇X p)(γX (t)) dt. 2 0 But Euler’s relation (11.6) says that J p (E) =
2p(X ) = X , (∇X p)(X) , so that, since p(γX (t)) = E for all t, J p (E) =
1 2
Tp (E) 0
γX (t), (∇X p)(γX (t)) dt =
Tp (E) 0
p(γX (t))dt = ETp (E). (11.10)
168
11 Energy-Levels, Dynamics, and the Maslov Index
Using Lemma 11.1.2 and Proposition 11.1.4, we therefore get J p (E) = Tp (E) = ETp (E) + Tp(E), ∀E ∈ [E1 − ε , E2 + ε ], whence
Tp (E) = 0, ∀E ∈ [E1 − ε , E2 + ε ].
On the other hand, from (11.10) we have A p (E) =
ETp (E) J p (E) −E = − E = 0, Tp (E) Tp (E)
which concludes the proof.
Remark 11.1.9. If p : R2n \ {0} −→ R+ is positively homogeneous of degree 2k, k ≥ 2, then we have J p (E) = kETp (E), ∀E > 0, whence, with Tp = dTp /dE, the equation Tp (E) = kETp (E) + kTp (E), i.e. ETp (E) =
1−k Tp (E), E > 0. k
Hence, fixing E0 ∈ [E1 − ε , E2 + ε ] ⊂ R+ (thus E0 > 0) gives E (1−k)/k Tp (E) = Tp (E0 ) , E ∈ [E1 − ε , E2 + ε ]. E0 When n = 1 and 0 < p is positively homogeneous of degree 2 we have that p−1 (E) is a periodic trajectory of H p of period T > 0, independent of E, for all E > 0. In fact, we have the following proposition. Proposition 11.1.10. Let n = 1, and let p : R2 \ {0} −→ R+ be smooth, positively homogenoeus of degree 2. Then all the integral trajectories of H p lying in p−1 (0, +∞) are periodic with least period Tp independent of the energy and given by the formula 2π dθ . (11.11) Tp = 2p(sin θ , cos θ ) 0 Proof. Let E > 0, and take X0 ∈ p−1 (E). We use polar coordinates
ϕ : (0, +∞) × [0, 2π ] −→ R2 \ {0}, ϕ (ρ , θ ) = (ρ sin θ , ρ cos θ ) = X . Then
ϕ ∗ σ = ρ d ρ ∧ d θ , ϕ ∗ { f , g} =
1 ∗ {ϕ f , ϕ ∗ g}ρ ,θ , ρ
11.1 Introducing the Dynamics
169
where ϕ ∗ f = f ◦ ϕ , { f , g} is the Poisson bracket of f and g, and, finally, { f˜, g} ˜ ρ ,θ := ∂ρ f˜∂θ g˜ − ∂θ f˜∂ρ g. ˜ Hence exp(tH p )(X0 ) = ϕ (ρ (t), θ (t)), X0 = ϕ (ρ0 , θ0 ), where, with θ˙ = d θ /dt and ρ˙ = d ρ /dt, ρ and θ satisfy the equations ⎧ 1 ⎪ ∗ ⎪ ⎨ θ˙ = ∂ρ (ϕ p) ρ 1 ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ ρ˙ = − ∂θ (ϕ ∗ p). ρ
(11.12)
(ϕ ∗ p)(ρ , θ ) = p(ρ sin θ , ρ cos θ ) = ρ 2 p(sin θ , cos θ ),
(11.13)
By the homogeneity
where for p(sin θ , cos θ ) = p(ω ) we have 0 < c1 = min p(ω ) ≤ c2 = max p(ω ). ω ∈S1
ω ∈S1
It follows from (11.13) and the first equation in (11.12) that the map t −→ θ (t) exists for all t ∈ R (the derivative being uniformly bounded), and that
θ˙ = 2p(sin θ , cos θ ) ≥ 2c1 , that is,
R t −→ θ (t) ∈ R is an increasing diffeomorphism,
(11.14)
and t −→ exp(tH p )(X0 ) is therefore the closed curve p−1 (E). By Lemma 11.1.8 we thus have that the least period, given by the relations exp(Tp (E)H p )(X0 ) = X0 , and exp(tH p )(X0 ) = X0 , ∀t ∈ (0, Tp (E)), i.e. given by the condition θ (Tp ) = θ0 + 2π , is independent of the energy. The formula for the least period Tp follows again from the homogeneity of p, for 1 ∂ θ˙ = (ϕ ∗ p) = 2p(sin θ , cos θ ), ρ ∂ρ whence (by the periodicity of p(sin θ , cos θ )) Tp =
θ0 +2π θ0
dθ = 2p(sin θ , cos θ )
2π 0
dθ . 2p(sin θ , cos θ )
170
11 Energy-Levels, Dynamics, and the Maslov Index
It is important to notice that from Proposition 11.1.10 it follows that the closed curve p−1 (E) is clockwise oriented. It will also be important, when considering the Maslov index of a curve in R × R, to be able to establish a-priori the orientation of a periodic trajectory p−1 (E) = γE = {exp(tH p )(X); 0 ≤ t ≤ T (E)} ⊂ R × R for p satisfying Assuption 11.1.1. In this case, one observes that
σ (∇X p(X ), H p (X )) = d p(X )(∇X p(X)) = |∇X p(X )|2 > 0, ∀X ∈ γE , so that
σ (∇X p, H p ) = − det[∇x p|H p ] > 0, ∀X ∈ γE ,
whence, in R × R, • whenever ∇x p(X ) points outwards from γE at X ∈ γE , then this is true at all
points of γE , and the couple {∇X p, H p } forms on γE a reference frame with the orientation opposite to the canonical one, that is, γE is clockwise oriented; • whereas, whenever ∇x p(X ) points inwards from γE at X ∈ γE , then this is true at all points of γE , and the couple {∇X p, H p } forms on γE a reference frame which is canonically oriented, that is, γE is counter-clockwise oriented.
Lemma 11.1.11. Let p : R2n \ {0} −→ R+ be smooth, positively homogeneous of degree 2k, k ∈ N. Let E > 0 be given, and consider the compact (connected) set p−1 (E) = γE . Then ∇X p(X ) points outwards from γE , for all X ∈ γE . Hence, in particular, when n = 1 and γE is a periodic trajectory of H p , it is clockwise oriented. Proof. We know that γE ⊂ R2n \ {0} is a smooth compact and connected hypersurface of R2n , whence it is orientable. The vector-field γE X −→ ∇X p(X ) is a nowhere-zero normal to γE , whence it either points outwards from γE at all points of γE , or else it points inwards from γE at all points of γE . Consider the compact set DE = {X = 0; p(X) ≤ E} ∪ {0}. Then ∂ DE = γE , and if E > E, by virtue of the homogeneity, we have DE DE . Hence γE is contained in the exterior of γE . Since moving from γE to γE increases the value of p from E to E , and since ∇X p gives the direction of maximal growth of p, we get that ∇X pγ points outwards from γE . E This concludes the proof. Of course, the above lemma also holds when the homogeneity degree of p is a real α