This page intentionally left blank
STATISTICAL PHYSICS OF LIQUIDS AT FREEZING AND BEYOND
Exploring important theorie...
26 downloads
1210 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
This page intentionally left blank
STATISTICAL PHYSICS OF LIQUIDS AT FREEZING AND BEYOND
Exploring important theories for understanding freezing and the liquid–glass transition, this book is useful for graduate students and researchers in soft-condensed-matter physics, chemical physics, and materials science. It details recent ideas and key developments, providing an up-to-date view of current understanding. The standard tools of statistical physics for the dense liquid state are covered. The freezing transition is described from the classical density-functional approach. Classical nucleation theory as well as applications of density-functional methods for nucleation of crystals from the melt are discussed, and compared with results from computer simulation of simple systems. Discussions of supercooled liquids form a major part of the book. Theories of slow dynamics and the dynamical heterogeneities of the glassy state are presented, as well as nonequilibrium dynamics and thermodynamic phase transitions at deep supercooling. Mathematical treatments are given in full detail so that readers can learn the basic techniques. SHANKAR PRASAD DAS is Professor of Physics at Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi. During the course of his career, he has made significant contributions to the field of slow dynamics in supercooled liquids and the glass transition.
STATISTICAL PHYSICS OF LIQUIDS AT FREEZING AND BEYOND
Shankar P. Das Jawaharlal Nehru University New Delhi, India
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, São Paulo, Delhi, Dubai, Tokyo, Mexico City Cambridge University Press The Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 8RU, UK Published in the United States of America by Cambridge University Press, New York www.cambridge.org Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521858397 c S. Das 2011 This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published 2011 Printed in the United Kingdom at the University Press, Cambridge A catalog record for this publication is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Das, Shankar P. (Shankar Prasad), 1959Statistical physics of liquids at freezing and beyond / Shankar P. Das. p. cm. ISBN 978-0-521-85839-7 (hardback) 1. Liquids–Thermal properties. 2. Crystallization–Mathematical models. 3. Nonequilibrium thermodynamics. 4. Statistical thermodynamics. I. Title. QC145.4.T5D37 2011 530.4 24–dc22 2010046159 ISBN 978-0-521-85839-7 Hardback Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of URLs for external or third-party internet websites referred to in this publication, and does not guarantee that any content on such websites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate.
I dedicate this book to my parents,
Sudhir Kumar Das and Gita Rani Das
Contents
Preface Acknowledgements 1
page xiii xvi
Statistical physics of liquids 1.1 Basic statistical mechanics 1.1.1 Thermodynamic functions 1.1.2 The classical N -particle system 1.1.3 The BBGKY hierarchy equations 1.1.4 The Boltzmann equation 1.2 Equilibrium properties 1.2.1 The Gibbs H-theorem 1.2.2 The equilibrium ensembles 1.2.3 The static structure factor 1.2.4 Integral equations for g(r) 1.3 Time correlation functions 1.3.1 The density correlation function 1.3.2 The self-correlation function 1.3.3 The linear response function 1.4 Brownian motion 1.4.1 The Langevin equation 1.4.2 The Stokes–Einstein relation
1 3 3 6 7 9 11 12 14 19 24 36 38 41 47 50 50 53
Appendix to Chapter 1 A1.1 The Gibbs inequality A1.2 The force–force correlation A1.3 Brownian motion A1.3.1 The noise correlation A1.3.2 Evaluation of the integrals
55 55 55 56 56 57
2
58 58 60
The freezing transition 2.1 The density-functional approach 2.1.1 A thermodynamic extremum principle
vii
viii
Contents
2.2
2.3
2.4
2.1.2 An approximate free-energy functional 2.1.3 The Ramakrishnan–Yussouff model Weighted density functionals 2.2.1 The modified weighted-density approximation 2.2.2 Gaussian density profiles 2.2.3 The hard-sphere system Fundamental measure theory 2.3.1 Density-independent weight functions 2.3.2 The free-energy functional Applications to other systems 2.4.1 Long-range interaction potentials 2.4.2 The solid–liquid interface
64 68 72 75 76 78 85 86 88 90 91 99
Appendix to Chapter 2 A2.1 Correlation functions for the inhomogeneous solid A2.2 The Ramakrishnan–Yussouff model A2.3 The weighted-density-functional approximation A2.4 The modified weighted-density-functional approximation A2.5 The Gaussian density profiles and phonon model
105 105 106 109 113 115
3
117 117 118 121 129 131 133 134 137 137 141 145 150 152 155
Crystal nucleation 3.1 Classical nucleation theory 3.1.1 The free-energy barrier 3.1.2 The nucleation rate 3.1.3 Heterogeneous nucleation 3.2 A simple nonclassical model 3.2.1 The critical nucleus 3.2.2 The free-energy barrier 3.3 The density-functional approach 3.3.1 The square-gradient approximation 3.3.2 The critical nucleus 3.3.3 The weighted-density-functional approach 3.4 Computer-simulation studies 3.4.1 Comparisons with CNT predictions 3.4.2 The structure of the nucleus
Appendix to Chapter 3 A3.1 The schematic model for nucleation A3.1.1 Critical nucleus A3.1.2 The free-energy barrier A3.2 The excess free energy in the DFT model
160 160 160 161 162
4
164 164 165
The supercooled liquid 4.1 The liquid–glass transition 4.1.1 Characteristic temperatures of the glassy state
Contents
4.2
4.3
4.4
5
4.1.2 The free-volume model 4.1.3 Self-diffusion and the Stokes–Einstein relation Glass formation vs. crystallization 4.2.1 The minimum cooling rate 4.2.2 The kinetic spinodal and the Kauzmann paradox The landscape paradigm 4.3.1 The potential-energy landscape 4.3.2 The free-energy landscape Dynamical heterogeneities 4.4.1 Computer-simulation results 4.4.2 Dynamic length scales
Dynamics of collective modes 5.1 Conservation laws and dissipation 5.1.1 The microscopic balance equations 5.1.2 Euler equations of hydrodynamics 5.1.3 Dissipative equations of hydrodynamics 5.1.4 Tagged-particle dynamics 5.1.5 Two-component systems 5.2 Hydrodynamic correlation functions 5.2.1 Self-diffusion 5.2.2 Transport coefficients 5.3 Linear fluctuating hydrodynamics 5.3.1 The generalized Langevin equation 5.3.2 The liquid-state dynamics 5.4 Hydrodynamics of a solid
ix
170 171 175 176 177 181 182 188 192 193 198 204 205 205 207 209 211 212 215 217 218 225 225 236 246
Appendix to Chapter 5 A5.1 The microscopic-balance equations A5.1.1 The Euler equations A5.1.2 The entropy-production rate A5.2 The second fluctuation–dissipation relation
260 260 263 264 269
6
271 271 271 274 287 287 293 295 300 303 303
Nonlinear fluctuating hydrodynamics 6.1 Nonlinear Langevin equations 6.1.1 Coupling of collective modes 6.1.2 Nonlinear Langevin equations 6.2 The compressible liquid 6.2.1 The one-component fluid 6.2.2 The nonlinear diffusion equation 6.2.3 A two-component fluid 6.2.4 The solid state 6.3 Stochastic balance equations 6.3.1 Smoluchowski dynamics
x
Contents
6.3.2
Fokker–Planck dynamics
308
Appendix to Chapter 6 A6.1 The coarse-grained free energy
310 310
7
318 319 320 327 328 330 334 335 339 343
Renormalization of the dynamics 7.1 The Martin–Siggia–Rose theory 7.1.1 The MSR action functional 7.2 The compressible liquid 7.2.1 MSR theory for a compressible liquid 7.2.2 Correlation and response functions 7.3 Renormalization 7.3.1 Fluctuation–dissipation relations 7.3.2 Nonperturbative results 7.3.3 One-loop renormalization
Appendix to Chapter 7 A7.1 The Jacobian of MSR fields A7.2 The MSR field theory A7.3 Invariance of the MSR action A7.4 The memory-function approach A7.4.1 The projection-operator method A7.4.2 The mode-coupling approximation
348 350 351 355 357 358 361
8
363 363 365 369 376 383 388 391 400 400 406 407 409 411 412 414 417 419 420 426
The ergodic–nonergodic transition 8.1 Mode-coupling theory 8.1.1 The schematic model 8.1.2 Effects of structure on dynamics 8.1.3 Tagged-particle dynamics 8.1.4 Dynamical heterogeneities and MCT 8.1.5 Linking DFT with MCT 8.1.6 Dynamic density-functional theory 8.2 Evidence from experiments 8.2.1 Testing with schematic MCT 8.2.2 Glass transition in colloids 8.2.3 Molecular-dynamics simulations 8.2.4 Discussion 8.3 Ergodicity-restoring mechanisms 8.3.1 Ergodic behavior in the NFH model 8.3.2 The hydrodynamic limit 8.3.3 Numerical solution of NFH equations 8.4 Spin-glass models 8.4.1 The p-spin interaction model 8.4.2 MCT and mean-field theories
Contents
xi
Appendix to Chapter 8 A8.1 Calculation of the spring constant A8.2 Field-theoretic treatment of the DDFT model A8.3 The one-loop result for vˆ vˆ (0, 0)
430 430 432 442
9
443 443 443 444 449 451 451 456 459 460 465 469 471 471 473
The nonequilibrium dynamics 9.1 The nonequilibrium state 9.1.1 A generalized fluctuation–dissipation relation 9.1.2 Computer-simulation studies 9.2 The effective temperature 9.2.1 The phenomenological approach 9.2.2 A simple thermometer 9.3 A mean-field model 9.3.1 The mode-coupling approximation 9.3.2 The FDT regime 9.3.3 The aging regime 9.3.4 Quasi-ergodic behavior 9.4 Glassy aging dynamics 9.4.1 Thermalization 9.4.2 Aging dynamics: experiments
Appendix to Chapter 9 A9.1 The energy of the oscillator A9.2 Evaluation of integrals A9.2.1 Integral IR for the FDT solution A9.2.2 Integrals for the aging solution
479 479 481 481 482
10
486 486 487 488 490 491 494 498 498 501 505 507 509 514 519 522
The thermodynamic transition scenario 10.1 The entropy crisis 10.1.1 The Adam–Gibbs theory 10.1.2 Dynamics near TK 10.2 First-order transitions 10.2.1 Metastable aperiodic structures 10.2.2 Random first-order transition theory 10.3 Self-generated disorder 10.3.1 Effective potential and overlap functions 10.3.2 A model calculation 10.4 Spontaneous breaking of ergodicity 10.4.1 The replica method for self-generated disorder 10.4.2 Free energy of the Replicated liquid 10.4.3 An example: The φ 4 model 10.5 The amorphous solid 10.5.1 The Mézard–Parisi model
xii
Contents
Appendix to Chapter 10 A10.1 Matrix identity A10.2 Matrix identity II A10.3 Computation of the vibrational contribution Iv A10.4 Computation of Tr ln M∗ References Index
531 531 532 533 536 540 558
Preface
This book is aimed at teaching the important concepts of the various theories of statistical physics of dense liquids, freezing, and the liquid–glass transition. Both thermodynamic and time-dependent phenomena relating to transport properties are discussed. The standard tools of statistical physics of the dense liquid state and the associated technicalities needed to learn them are included in the presentation. Details of some of the calculations have been included, whenever needed, in the appendices at the ends of chapters. I hope this will make the book more accessible to beginners in this very active field of research. The book is expected to be useful for graduate students and researchers working in the area of soft-condensed-matter physics, chemical physics, and the material sciences as well as for chemical engineers. We now give a brief description of what is in the book. The first chapter reviews the basics of statistical mechanics necessary for studying the physics of the liquid state. Key concepts of equilibrium and nonequilibrium statistical mechanics are presented. The topics covered here have been chosen keeping in mind the theories and concepts covered in the subsequent chapters of the book. Following this introductory chapter, we focus on the physics of liquids near freezing. In Chapter 2, we demonstrate how the disordered liquid state as well as the crystalline state of matter with long-range order can be understood in a unified manner using thermodynamic extremum principles. Our primary focus in discussing the freezing transition here is the classical density-functional approach using the density as the order parameter. The model is constructed from a basic statistical-mechanical description of the equilibrium liquid close to the freezing point. It predicts the location (in terms of thermodynamic parameters such as temperature and density) of the transformation into the crystalline states coming from the liquid side. This is in contrast to the traditional lattice-instability theories of melting of the solid state. The approach is termed microscopic since it uses the two-body interaction between the particles in the classical Hamiltonian as the starting point. After introducing the model for the broken symmetric state in terms of the inhomogeneous density function, we analyze the process of transformation from one phase to another. As the disordered liquid is quenched to a lower temperature at which the stable equilibrium state would be a crystal, the metastable liquid transforms into the state with long-range order through a nucleation process. A model for this transformation using a xiii
xiv
Preface
purely thermodynamic approach is given in terms of the classical nucleation theory. The latter is an important idea that is also applied in a somewhat different context in understanding the deeply supercooled state. Next, extensions of the density-functional theories introduced in the previous chapter are applied to identify the critical nucleus formation in the melt. Comparisons of the theories of freezing and nucleation with corresponding computer-simulation results are discussed at every step. Simulating nucleation of the crystalline phase from the melt has always been difficult. In recent years special techniques have been developed to study the formation and structure of the critical nucleus. We discuss these developments in Chapter 3. In Chapter 4, we begin considering the supercooled state, i.e., liquid kept at metastable equilibrium at temperatures beyond the freezing point. Competition between supercooling into a metastable state and the process of crystallization as well as the standard phenomenology of the glassy state are discussed here. The computer models of the liquid developed to study various aspects of the supercooled state are also described in this chapter. Concepts of dynamical heterogeneities and growing length scales associated with the supercooled liquid are introduced at this point. Next we turn to the discussion of the microscopic theories of the slow dynamics which develops in the supercooled liquid as it is increasingly supercooled. We present the theoretical developments in this field starting from the basics. Hence three chapters have been devoted to introducing the reader to the rather involved formalism necessary for treating this topics. The first, Chapter 5, presents the formulation of the basic equations of hydrodynamics for a set of slow modes in the many-body system. The dissipative equations are constructed using phenomenological arguments, and linear transport coefficients are defined. We introduce here the idea of generalizing hydrodynamic equations to short length scales in the dense liquid. In Chapter 6, we discuss the formulation of the nonlinear fluctuating hydrodynamics for several model systems. These equations control the dynamics of a set of slow modes in a manner that includes collective effects from semi-microscopic length scales. In Chapter 7, we present methods for formulating a renormalized theory of the dynamics. The effects of the nonlinear coupling of the slow modes are obtained in a systematic manner by using diagrammatic methods of quantum field theory. This Martin–Siggia–Rose (MSR) field-theoretic model obtains the dynamic density correlation function in terms of renormalized transport coefficients, which are themselves expressed self-consistently in terms of dynamic correlation functions. A new approach to studying the complex behavior of the supercooled liquid started with the idea of a nonlinear feedback mechanism on its transport properties from the coupling of slowly decaying correlation functions. That the renormalized dynamics for a compressible liquid obtains this model in a natural way is demonstrated in Chapter 7. The formalism also facilitates the analysis of the full implications of the nonlinearities in the equations of motion on the asymptotic dynamics. Chapters 5, 6, and 7 are technical and may be skipped by those not interested in understanding the construction of the mathematical models for the dynamics in full rigor. Some simpler deductions of the basic mode-coupling model are also presented in an appendix.
Preface
xv
The above renormalized model gives rise to the idea of an ergodic–nonergodic (ENE) transition in which the long-time limit of the density correlation function freezes. This ENE transition, its implications for the dynamics, and supporting evidence from experiments and simulation are discussed in full detail in Chapter 8. The possible role of ergodicity-restoring mechanisms and removal of the sharp ENE transitions follows thereafter. Finally, we make a critical evaluation of the mode-coupling theory for structural liquids and its link with models of dynamics for mean-field systems. Up to this point the discussion of the dynamics is only in terms of equilibrium correlations. In Chapter 9 we deal with the nonequilibrium aspects of the glassy state. We present the modification of the standard results of equilibrium statistical mechanics, such as the fluctuation–dissipation theorem and the concept of effective temperatures for the glassy state. Related computer-simulation studies are presented. Theoretical models of nonequilibrium dynamics in terms of mean-field spin models are also worked out. The relaxation time for the supercooled liquid increases drastically as it is supercooled and eventually vitrification occurs when the liquid behaves like a frozen solid. Apart from having a characteristic large viscosity, the supercooled liquid shows a discontinuity in specific heat due to freezing of the translational degrees of freedom in the liquid. The difference of the entropy of the supercooled liquid from that of the solid having only vibrational motion around a frozen structure represents the entropy due to large-scale motion and is called the configurational entropy Sc of the supercooled liquid. Theoretical analysis of the rapid disappearance of Sc with supercooling (the so-called “entropy crisis”) is essential for our understanding of the physics of the glass transition. The connections between structure and dynamics and the possibilities of an underlying thermodynamic phase transition in the deeply supercooled liquid are discussed in the last chapter of the book.
Acknowledgements
I gratefully acknowledge Kyozi Kawasaki for many helpful discussions, support and exchange of views on important concepts. His work and ideas appear in several chapters of this book and have been an inspiration for the author. Discussions and associations with various scientists at different stages of my career have been useful experience and helped me in writing this book. In particular I would like to mention A. Angell, B. Bagchi, J.L. Barrat, J.K. Bhattacharjee, C. Dasgupta, D. Dhar, J.W. Dufty, J.P. Dyre, M.H. Ernst, T.R. Kirkpatrick, R. Kühn, H. Löwen, F. Mezei, U. Mohanty, S.R. Nagel, T. Odagaki, T.V. Ramakrishnan, S. Ramaswamy, S. Sarkar, R. Schilling, Y. Singh, A. Solokov, A.K. Sood, J. Yeo, and S. Yip. During the course of writing this book I have benefited from discussions on various related topics with G. Biroli, C. Chakravarty, T. Engami, S. Franz, H. Hayakawa, B. Kim, V. Kumaran, A. Loidl, P. Lunkenheimer, K. Miyazaki, D. Reichman, S. Sastry, F. Sciortino, H. Tanaka, G. Tarajus, R. Yamamoto, and A. Yoshimori. I acknowledge my colleagues R. Ramaswamy, A.K. Rastogi, and S. Sarakar for their support. I acknowledge all my students for their research which has been very much needed in writing this book. In particular I acknowledge help from my students L. Premkumar, M. Priya, B. Sen Gupta, and S. P. Singh in preparing some of the figures and the manuscript. I thank Mr. R. N. Saini for his help with the reproduction of the figures. Big thanks are due to little Bodhisattva Das for helping me to prepare the figure presented on the front cover of the book. I am grateful to the authors and publishers who allowed figures from their publications to be used in the book. I am very thankful to Dr. Simon Capelin and Dr. Graham Hart from Cambridge University Press for allowing me time well beyond the initially agreed limit to finish writing this book. Lindsay Barnes, Laura Clark, S. Holt, M. Waddington, and Emma Walker of Cambridge University Press are acknowledged for their constant help, reminders, and patience – for keeping the project alive even though I kept missing deadlines repeatedly. Sehar Tahir is acknowledged for providing very useful help with LATEX and CUP style files. The UGC Capacity-Build-up grant of JNU, the PURSE grant from DST, and the CSIR research grant 03(1036)/05/EMRII are acknowledged for financial support. I acknowledge the Institute for Molecular Sciences (IMS) in Okazaki, Japan for support during my visit xvi
Acknowledgements
xvii
there in 2009–10. I am deeply grateful to Professor Hirata and his group there, in particular Dr. Yoshida, and others for their kind hospitality and help. The Physics Department of the University of Florida, Gainesville is acknowledged for hospitality and support during my visit there in summer 2009. The Joint Theory Institute of the University of Chicago is acknowledged for hospitality and support during my visits there in the summers of 2008 and 2010. Finishing this long project would not have been possible without the constant support and help of my wife Soma and my son Rhivu. It gave me the strength to carry on doing this work in the midst of the many other responsibilities of daily life. Finally, the acknowledgment which precedes all others is that to Professor Gene Mazenko, who introduced me to the statistical physics of liquids. I have greatly benefited from my association with him, and his teaching is reflected in the pages of this book. I gratefully acknowledge him for his kindness and support over all these years. Shankar Prasad Das, School of Physical Sciences, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi 110067.
1 Statistical physics of liquids
A liquid in thermodynamic equilibrium is described at the macroscopic level in terms of a few characteristic variables such as temperature T , pressure P, volume V , the (average) number of particles N , mass density ρ0 , etc. (Fermi, 1956). The thermodynamic properties listed above are not all independent and are related through a relation termed the equation of state. The equilibrium liquid transforms into a crystalline solid when its temperature T falls below a characteristic value Tm . The latter is termed the freezing point of the liquid at the corresponding pressure. The liquid state involves random motion of the constituent particles, each of which represents a basic microscopic unit for the system. The normal liquid is isotropic in a time-averaged sense. At freezing this isotropic symmetry of the normal liquid state is spontaneously broken. The crystalline state has a characteristic long-range order of the individual microscopic units. The transformation of the liquid into a crystalline solid involves the absorption of latent heat. This transformation is somewhat distinct from the condensation of the gaseous state into the liquid state. In the later case both the states are disordered. In Fig. 1.1 we display schematically a phase diagram showing the different equilibrium states for the corresponding values of the thermodynamic properties T and P. For example, the horizontal arrow in Fig. 1.1 indicates that as we cross the line separating the phases a transition from the liquid to the crystalline state occurs. This is accompanied by a discontinuous change of the thermodynamic properties (such as the volume V ) and is called a first-order transition. The coexistence line of the liquid and gaseous states terminates at the critical point. Beyond this point the transformation from one state to another occurs through a continuous, or second-order, phase transition. For the solid and the liquid states no such termination of the phase line occurs. The corresponding diagram showing the existence of the phases in the P–T plane is presented in Fig. 1.2. The part of the P–T plane which is not physically accessible to a single phase is marked as the coexistence region. Transformation from one state to another occurs here. The phase diagrams describe the equilibrium states as a function of the thermodynamic parameters. However, almost all liquids can, with varying degrees of ease, be supercooled below Tm without developing long-range order of the crystalline state. The supercooled liquid develops very slow dynamics. This slowing down is far more drastic than the decrease in the average speed of the liquid particles for the cooling to lower temperatures. The time taken for a characteristic fluctuation to relax to equilibrium increases by orders of magnitude as 1
2
Statistical physics of liquids
Fig. 1.1 The equilibrium phase diagram (schematic) of a simple fluid in the pressure (P) and temperature (T ) plane.
Fig. 1.2 The equilibrium phase diagram (schematic) of a simple fluid in the density n (equivalent to n 0 in the text) and temperature (T ) plane. The regions marked for coexistence are unavailable for a single phase and represent transformation.
the liquid is increasingly supercooled. The viscosity of the liquid increases below Tm until a situation in which the liquid stops flowing and transforms into an amorphous solid is reached. We will study in this book models for understanding the behavior of the liquid at the freezing point Tm and beyond. Our treatment involves primarily a coarse-grained picture of the microscopic-level description of the liquid.
1.1 Basic statistical mechanics
3
1.1 Basic statistical mechanics The microscopic description of the liquid is formulated here by treating the individual microscopic units in terms of the laws of classical physics. The justification of the classical approximation depends on the value of the thermal de Broglie wavelength 0 = √ h/ 2π mkB T corresponding to the average momentum of the liquid particles (of mass m) at a temperature T . kB = 1.38 × 10−16 erg/K is the Boltzmann constant. If the mean −1/3 is such that the ratio ξTr = nearest-neighbor separation of the liquid particles l0 ρ0 0 /l0 1 then the classical description is justified. For most liquids (Hansen and McDonald, 1986; Barrat and Hansen, 2003) barring hydrogen and neon, this ratio is small near the triple point. For molecular liquids another characteristic quantity, namely the ratio ξR = Rot /T between the characteristic rotational temperature Rot = 2 /(2I kB ) (I is the molecular moment of inertia of the molecule) and temperature T should also be small. However, as the temperature T falls and density ρ0 increases, ξTr increases. In the classical approximation the contributions to the thermodynamic properties from the kinetic and interaction parts of the Hamiltonian can be obtained separately. If Re represents the absolute value of the ratio of the kinetic and potential parts of the total energy of the system of particles then Re ∼ 1 corresponds to the liquid state. On the other hand, for the gaseous and solid states we have Re 1 and Re 1, respectively. The liquid state thus represents an intermediate between two extremes. Alternatively, this characterization of the liquid state can be done in terms of the interaction potential. Let a pair of particles in the system interact via a potential of depth ∼ and range ∼σ . The liquid state will correspond to the particles being cohesive, which requires that the total volume V ∼ N σ 3 and the average kinetic energy kB T ∼ . Indeed, the intermediate nature of the liquid state makes it particularly difficult to develop a quantitatively accurate model for its thermodynamic or dynamic properties at high densities. Both for dilute gases and for low-density solids the corresponding idealized model, namely the perfect gas and the harmonic solid, can be treated exactly. Such a reference state is lacking for a high-density liquid. In this book we will describe how the methods of classical statistical mechanics have been used to develop models for strongly interacting liquids and further extended to gain an understanding of the properties of deeply supercooled states.
1.1.1 Thermodynamic functions The first law of thermodynamics provides us with a definition of the internal energy U as a property of the equilibrium thermodynamic state. The second law of thermodynamics defines another state function S representing the thermodynamic entropy of the system. The first two laws are expressed in terms of the basic equation treating the variations of U and S as exact differentials, T d S = dU + P d V − μ d N¯ ,
(1.1.1)
where V is the volume and N¯ is the number of particles N in the system. Note that the number of particles N¯ is used here as a macroscopic (extensive) thermodynamic property
4
Statistical physics of liquids
of the system (similar to the volume V ). In order to distinguish it from the number of particles N in the system in a microscopic picture (to be used later) we denote it with a bar. μ is the chemical potential. The internal energy U can be treated as a function of T and V , giving the differential, ∂U d V, (1.1.2) dU = cv dT + ∂V T where cv = (∂U /∂ T )V is the specific heat at constant volume. Using eqn. (1.1.2) in eqn. (1.1.1) and the fact that d S is an exact differential, we obtain the thermodynamic relation
∂U ∂V
T
∂P =T ∂T
− P.
(1.1.3)
V
From the second law of thermodynamics follows the entropy function S of the thermodynamic state. As a direct consequence of the second law it follows that for an isolated system the entropy S never decreases. Equivalently, for a change from a state A to another state B (Fermi, 1936) B dQ S(B) − S(A) ≤ , (1.1.4) A T where the equality holds for a reversible change. Thus for an isolated system going through an infinitesimal change the heat supplied Q ≤ T S. Using the first law, this inequality leads to U + P V − T S ≤ 0.
(1.1.5)
For a constant-temperature and constant-volume process therefore we have (U −T S) ≤ 0. Hence for an isolated system the function F = U −T S always decreases and equilibrium is reached when the function F reaches a minimum. On the other hand, if the temperature T and pressure P remain constant, the inequality (1.1.5) tells us that (U − T S + P V ) ≤ 0. Therefore in constant-temperature, constant-pressure processes the thermodynamic function G = U − T S + P V ≤ 0 is minimized. F and G are called the Helmholtz and Gibbs free energies, respectively. Using the result (1.1.1), the differentials of F and G are obtained as d F = dU − T d S − S dT = −P d V + μ d N¯ − S dT
(1.1.6)
dG = dU − T d S − S dT + P d V + V d P = μ d N¯ + V d P − S dT.
(1.1.7)
From the above equations it follows that the thermodynamic potentials F and G can be treated as functions of the corresponding sets of thermodynamic variables, F ≡ F(T, V, N¯ )
1.1 Basic statistical mechanics
5
and G ≡ G(T, P, N¯ ). For the Gibbs free energy the situation is somewhat special since, apart from N¯ , the other two thermodynamic variables on which it depends are both intensive properties, i.e., independent of the size of the system. We can write the Gibbs free energy per particle as G(T, P, N¯ ) = N¯ g(T, P). We obtain, from eqn. (1.1.7), the chemical potential μ as G ∂G (1.1.8) = g(T, P) = , μ= ¯ N¯ ∂ N P,T which is the Gibbs free energy per particle. Using the relation G = μ N¯ in eqn. (1.1.7), we obtain the very useful Gibbs–Duhem relation, N¯ dμ − V d P + S dT = 0.
(1.1.9)
The above relation implies that, at the transition for the coexisting phases at equal temperature and pressure (d P = dT = 0 ), the chemical potentials of the two phases are also equal, μ1 = μ2 .
(1.1.10)
The Gibbs free energy per particle is continuous through the phase transition. However, from eqn. (1.1.9) it follows that ∂μ V − = = v, (1.1.11) ∂P T N¯ S ∂μ = s. (1.1.12) = ∂T P N¯ Thus the first derivative of the Gibbs free energy is discontinuous at the transition (hence the name first-order transition). The respective amounts of discontinuity are equal to the changes in specific volume and entropy for the two phases across the transition. We therefore obtain ∂μ s ∂μ − = . (1.1.13) ∂T P ∂P T v Since the change in Gibbs free energy (per particle) μ is a function of the intensive variables P and T , we can use the chain rule to write the LHS of eqn. (1.1.13) as (∂ P/∂ T )μ . At the transition μ is zero and hence the corresponding derivative is obtained as d P(T ) s ∂P = = . (1.1.14) dT ∂ T μ=0 v Using the fact that at the transition the temperature T remains constant, the difference between the specific entropies is s = L/T , where L is the latent heat of the transition. Hence, denoting the change of specific volume between the two phases as v = v2 − v1 ,
6
Statistical physics of liquids
the above equation for the rate of change of pressure P at coexistence with temperature T is obtained as d P(T ) L = . dT T (v2 − v1 )
(1.1.15)
The above equation is termed the Clapeyron equation.
1.1.2 The classical N-particle system We begin with a review of a few basic results concerning a fluid as a classical statistical mechanical system. We consider a fluid as a system of volume V containing N particles of mass m and following Newton’s laws of motion. The Hamiltonian for the system is given by the sum of a kinetic part K (p1 , . . . , p N ) and a potential part U (r1 , . . . , r N ), H= =
N pα2 + U (r1 , . . . , r N ) 2m
α=1 N α=1
pα2 1 u(rαβ ), + 2m 2
(1.1.16)
α,β
where rα and pα , respectively, denote the position and momentum of the αth particle and rαβ = |rα − rβ |. We assume that the particles of the fluid interact through a two-body potential u(rαβ ) dependent on the vector rαβ connecting the two interacting particles. In an isotropic system u is a function of only rαβ . We treat here the simplified case in which there is no external potential. The prime in the summation in the second term on the RHS of (1.1.16) indicates that the α = β term is excluded. The equations of motion of the particles are given by r˙ α ≡
drα ∂H , = dt ∂pα
p˙ α ≡
dpα ∂H , =− dt ∂rα
(1.1.17)
for α = 1, . . . , N . These equations with appropriate initial conditions determine the classical dynamics of the N -particle system. In the phase-space description the system is described in terms of a single phase point in the 6N -dimensional phase space involving the variables {rα , pα } for the N particles. The dynamics of the system is then represented by the trajectory of a single phase point in the phase space. The physically measured value of a dynamic variable is then given by an average on the phase-space trajectory. In equilibrium such an average is replaced, using the ergodic hypothesis (Dorfman, 1999), by an average over an appropriate ensemble representative of the system. Each member of the ensemble is an identical copy of the system evolving independently under the above equations of motion. The “fluid” constituted by these points in the phase space has a characteristic density termed the phase-space density f (N ) (r N , p N , t). This is the density of representative points corresponding to the members of the ensemble in any particular part of the phase space. Thus f (N ) dr1 dp1 · · · dr N dp N is the number of phase points in an
1.1 Basic statistical mechanics
7
elementary volume dr N dp N at time t. It also represents the probability that a particular member of the ensemble will be in a state in which the position and momentum coordinates of the ith particle (for i = 1, . . . , N ) lie in the ranges ri to ri + dri and pi to pi + dpi , respectively. Since the total number of ensemble members is fixed, we can maintain the normalization dr N dp N f (N ) (r N , p N , t) = 1,
(1.1.18)
where we have used the notation dr1 dp1 · · · dr N dp N ≡ dr N dp N . 1.1.3 The BBGKY hierarchy equations f (N )
The time evolution of is given by the Liouville equation, which is obtained by applying the continuity equation for the “incompressible fluid” formed by the phase points of the ensemble. Therefore N ∂ f (N ) ∂ f (N ) ∂ f (N ) · r˙ α + · p˙ α = 0. + (1.1.19) ∂t ∂rα ∂pα α=1
Using the equation of motion eqn. (1.1.17), we obtain from (1.1.19) ∂ f (N ) + {H, f (N ) } = 0, ∂t with the Poisson bracket between variables A and B being defined as
N ∂A ∂B ∂A ∂B { A, B} = · − · . ∂rα ∂pα ∂pα ∂rα
(1.1.20)
(1.1.21)
α=1
The above equation for the time evolution of f (n) is often written as
∂ + iL f (N ) = 0 ∂t
(1.1.22)
in terms of the Liouville operator L: L ≡ i{H, }.
(1.1.23)
The formal solution of the above equation for the N -particle distribution function is obtained as f (N ) (t) = exp[−iLt] f (N ) (0).
(1.1.24)
It is useful to compare the above result for the time evolution of f (N ) (t) with the time evolution of an operator A(r N , p N ). Since A is not explicitly dependent on t its change with time is controlled by that of {r N , p N }. Therefore the equation of motion for A is obtained as
N ∂A ∂A ∂A · r˙ α + · p˙ α ≡ iLA. = (1.1.25) ∂t ∂rα ∂pα α=1
8
Statistical physics of liquids
The solution of the above equation gives for the time dependence of A(t) the result A(t) = exp[+iLt] A(0).
(1.1.26)
The time dependence of f (N ) is therefore different from that of a dynamic variable. It represents the motion of the phase points in the phase space. The Liouville equation obtained for eqns. (1.1.17) makes this dynamics similar to that of an incompressible fluid. Let us consider the number of representative points present in a small elementary volume at t = 0. With the progress of time this elementary volume stretches out, changing its shape, but its total volume remains unchanged. In mathematical terms, in the Hamiltonian dynamics, the Jacobian of the corresponding transformation of the phase-space variables is unity, J [r N (0), p N (0) → r N (t), p N (t)] = 1.
(1.1.27)
This is termed the Liouville theorem. The phase-space trajectories of the different points never cross each other since the dynamics at this level is completely deterministic. Starting from an initial configuration the evolution is always unique. The Liouville equation describes the dynamics at the level of N particles. Using the definition (1.1.16) of the Hamiltonian for the N -particle system interacting through the two-body potential, the operator L in eqn. (1.1.23) is further simplified. The derivative of H with respect to the particle coordinates is given by
∂u(rαβ ) ∂H = ≡ −Fαβ , ∂rα ∂rα
(1.1.28)
β
Fαβ being the force on the αth particle due to interaction with the βth particle. The prime in the sum indicates that the α = β term is absent. Note that in the definition (1.1.16) for H we have dropped for simplicity the presence of any possible external potential and hence there is no external force on the particles here. This operator L is expressed as a sum of one-body and two-body terms: L=
N α=1
N 1 θα,β , 2
(1.1.29)
α,β=1
pα · ∇rα , m = Fαβ · (∇pα − ∇pβ ),
Sα ≡ θα,β
Sα +
(1.1.30) (1.1.31)
where the prime in the sum indicates that the terms for α = β are omitted. The above form of the Liouville operator is conveniently used to obtain a description of the dynamics at a reduced level. Starting from the level of N particles, the reduced distribution function giving the conditional probability of finding a reduced number of particles is defined. Thus the s-particle (s < N ) reduced distribution function f (s) is defined as N! f (N ) (x N , t)dxs+1 . . . dx N , (1.1.32) f (s) (xs , t) = (N − s)!
1.1 Basic statistical mechanics
9
where the position rα and momentum pα for the αth particle are jointly denoted by the single variable xα . The notation xn ≡ {x1 , . . . , xs } is used as the argument in eqn. (1.1.32). Starting from the Liouville equation (1.1.22) and integrating out the positions and momenta for the (N − s) particles, the dynamical equation for the reduced function f (s) is obtained as ⎫ ⎧ s s ⎬ ⎨∂ pi 1 θi, j f (s) (xs , t) + · ∇ri + ⎭ ⎩ ∂t m 2 i=1
=−
s
i, j=1
dxs+1 θi,s+1 f (s+1) (x(s+1) , t),
(1.1.33)
i=1
where the prime in the double sum indicates the absence of the i = j term. The distribution function f (N ) vanishes when the coordinate xα is at the limits of the integration, i.e., when rα is outside the volume of the system or pα → ∞. Hence the terms in which the integrand is a total derivative with respect to the integrated variable of position and momentum have been set equal to zero in deriving eqn. (1.1.33). With some further simplifications eqn. (1.1.33) for f (s) also reduces to the following form in terms of the force Fi j between the ith and jth particles: ⎧ ⎛ ⎡ ⎞ ⎤⎫ s s ⎬ ⎨∂ ⎣ pi · ∇ri + ⎝ Fi j ⎠ · ∇pi ⎦ f (s) (xs , t) + ⎭ ⎩ ∂t m i=1
=−
s
j=1
dxs+1 Fi,s+1 · ∇pi f (s+1) (x(s+1) , t).
(1.1.34)
i=1
Equations (1.1.33) and (1.1.34) relate the distribution function f (s) to its counterpart at the next level, i.e., f (s+1) , and thus for s = 1, . . . , N eqn. (1.1.33) gives rise to a hierarchy of N equations for the reduced distribution functions. This is known as the BBGKY hierarchy of equations for classical dynamics. At the simplest level, an approximate solution for the one-particle distribution function f (1) (r, p, t) is obtained from the first equation of the BBGKY hierarchy: p1 ∂ (1) (1.1.35) + · ∇r1 f (x1 , t) = − dr2 dp2 F12 · ∇p1 f (2) (x1 , x2 , t). ∂t m 1.1.4 The Boltzmann equation In order to reach a closed equation for the one-particle distribution function f (1) (x1 , t) from the above equation a relation linking the two-point function f (2) (x1 , x2 , t) to f (1) is needed. The simplest approximation in this regard is to ignore all correlation between the particles and use, in the mean-field approximation, f (2) (x1 , x2 , t) ≈ f (1) (x1 , t) f (1) (x2 , t).
(1.1.36)
10
Statistical physics of liquids
Using this closure relation in eqn. (1.1.35), we obtain what is termed the Vlasov equation, p1 ∂ ¯ (1.1.37) + · ∇r1 + F1 (r1 , p1 , t) · ∇p1 f (1) (r1 , p1 , t) = 0, ∂t m where we have defined the average force exerted on particle 1 by other particles as (1.1.38) F¯ 1 (r1 , p1 , t) = dr2 dp2 F¯ 12 f (1) (r1 , r2 , p1 , p2 , t). The term involving F12 in eqn. (1.1.38) is similar to the contribution which would appear in the presence of an external potential. Hence the Vlasov equation represents a collisionless approximation in the presence of an effective mean field. The above description of the dynamics is useful in plasma physics, in which long-range Coulomb forces are present. However, this is not a good approximation for studying a liquid with short-range interactions. In general, the RHS of eqn. (1.1.35) represents the contribution from the twobody interaction term to the dynamic evolution of f (1) (x1 , t) and is termed the collision contribution. The above equation is therefore written in the schematic form
(1) ∂ ∂ f p1 . (1.1.39) + · ∇r1 f (1) (r1 , p1 , t) = ∂t m ∂t coll
The RHS of the equation involving interaction of two particles is approximated through different schemes with a proper closing relation for the hierarchy in terms of the one-particle function. The most studied among the various approximations is the case of the Boltzmann equation in which the RHS (∂ f (1) /∂t)coll is approximated in terms of binary-collision contributions only. At low densities only two particles are likely to collide at a given point. The evaluation of the two-point functions before collision is done with the approximation of molecular chaos. Thus the factorization of eqn. (1.1.36) is applied. This again remains valid at low densities when successive binary collisions are completely uncorrelated. The collision of two particles at a point r is governed by the laws of classical mechanics. momenta of the particles before and that after collisions are denoted by {p1 , p2 } and The p1 , p2 , respectively. The RHS of eqn. (1.1.39) is approximated as (Dorfman, 1999) ∂ f (1) 1 dσ = dp2 d |p1 − p2 | ∂t m d coll × f (1) r, p1 , t f (1) r, p2 , t − f (1) (r, p1 , t) f (1) (r, p2 , t) . (1.1.40) where dσ /d denotes the differential scattering cross section in solid angle d defined around the (p1 −p2 ) vector of relative motion between the two particles before the collision. The approximation (1.1.40) gives rise to the Boltzmann H theorem which implies that the many-particle system evolves irreversibly to an equilibrium state. The time evolution
1.2 Equilibrium properties
11
of the HB function is defined as a functional of the one-particle distribution function f (r, p, t) as HB (t) = dp f (p, t) ln f (p, t). (1.1.41) Note that it is consistent to assume that the distribution function is independent of r since there is no external field present. On taking the time derivative of eqn. (1.1.41), we obtain " ∂ f (p, t) ! d HB (t) = dp 1 + ln f (p, t) . (1.1.42) dt ∂t It is straightforward to establish (Huang, 1987) using the Boltzmann equation that d HB (t) ≤ 0, dt
(1.1.43)
showing that the H function always decreases. This is known as the Boltzmann H theorem. For f (p, t) equal to the Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution function 3/2
β β p2 exp − (1.1.44) φMB ( p) = 2πm 2m the H function HB (t) is independent of time and is equal to zero. The function φMB ( p) is normalized and the constant β is determined from the average kinetic energy as p 2 /(2m) = 3/(2β). Hence β is identified with the temperature T of the equilibrium fluid β = 1/(kB T ). In general the nature of the interaction potential plays an important role in evaluating the collision integral on the RHS of eqn. (1.1.39). The irreversible kinetic equation obtained from closing the BBGKY hierarchy is used to compute the basic transport equations for fluid with dissipative dynamics. The most widely studied system in this regard is a system of hard spheres. We discuss this further in Section 5.2.2 below.
1.2 Equilibrium properties By definition for thermodynamic equilibrium, the distribution function f (N ) depends on the coordinates rα (t) and pα (t) but is independent of time t. The equilibrium state of a fluid corresponds to the stationary solutions of the distribution functions, ∂ (N ) N N f (r , p , t) = 0. ∂t
(1.2.1)
Therefore from eqn. (1.1.20) it follows # that the$ N -particle equilibrium distribution func(N ) (N ) (N ) tion f EQ must satisfy the condition f EQ , H = 0. Hence f EQ must be expressed as a functional of the Hamiltonian H or of function {Ai } (say), all of which have vanishing Poisson bracket with the Hamiltonian. These stationary distribution functions determine the Gibbsian ensembles. In this regard it is particularly useful to consider the following theorem for the equilibrium state.
12
Statistical physics of liquids
1.2.1 The Gibbs H-theorem The H function in terms of the N -particle distribution function f (N ) is defined as (1.2.2) HG = dr N dp N f (N ) (r N , p N ) ln f (N ) (r N , p N ). In some cases the ensemble may include variation of the total number of particles N or the total volume of the system. We denote by Tr an averaging over the whole phase space. If the different members of the ensemble have only energy as the variable with both the total number of particles N and the volume V fixed (a canonical ensemble) then Tr stands for Tr ≡
N 1 % drα dpα , N! h 3N
(1.2.3)
α=1
where the factor of h 3N is included to take into account the quantum-mechanical counting of possible states and the factor of N ! to account for the permutation among the N identical particles. If the ensemble is one in which, for example, variation of the total number of particles as well as of the energy is allowed (a grand-canonical ensemble) then we define ∞ 1 N dr dp N . (1.2.4) Tr ≡ h 3N N ! N =0
We now define the H function HG as HG = Tr f (N ) (r N , p N )ln f (N ) (r N , p N ) .
(1.2.5)
Let us consider the problem of minimizing the above H function subject to the following constraints in terms of a specific set of functions Ai (r N , p N ), i = 1, . . . , m, given by {A¯ i } such that A¯ i = Tr Ai f (N ) (r N , p N ) . (1.2.6) In equilibrium the time-independent f (N ) (r N , p N ) describes the probability for the different members of the corresponding ensemble. The condition (1.2.6) implies that the ensemble averages {A¯ i } characterize the thermodynamic equilibrium state. The H theorem at the N -particle level in this case states that, subject to the constraints (1.2.6), the (N ) normalized distribution function f 0 corresponding to which the value of HG reaches a minimum is given by (N ) N −1 N N N αi Ai (r , p ) . (1.2.7) f 0 (r , p ) = W0 exp − i
The set of parameters {αi } for i = 1, . . . , m defines the thermodynamic state characterized by optimum f (0) . W0 is the normalization constant N N W0 = Tr exp − αi Ai (r , p ) (1.2.8) i
1.2 Equilibrium properties
13
which ensures the condition Tr f 0(N ) (r N , p N ) = 1.
(1.2.9)
In order to prove the above theorem we first consider an arbitrary choice of the distri(N ) bution function f (N ) = f 0 . Since both the distribution functions represent probabilities, both of them are real positive numbers and x = f (N ) / f 0(N ) is also a positive number. Since both the distributions are normalized, we must have (N )
Tr f (N ) (r N , p N ) = Tr f 0
(r N , p N ) = 1.
(1.2.10)
Now let us consider the difference of the function HG as evaluated with the arbitrary functional f (N ) from that corresponding to f 0(N ) : HG [ f ] − H [ f 0 ] = Tr f 0 x ln{x f 0 (r N , p N , t)} − f 0 ln f 0 , (1.2.11) where we have dropped the superscript N on f to keep the notation simple. Using the normalization condition (1.2.10), the RHS of eqn. (1.2.11) reduces to " ! HG [ f ] − H [ f 0 ] = Tr f 0 {x ln x − x + 1} + ( f − f 0 )ln f 0 = I1 + I2 .
(1.2.12)
The first integral, I1 , on the RHS of eqn. (1.2.12) is always positive since, according to the Gibbs inequality (see Appendix A1.1), the quantity (x ln x − x + 1) is positive definite for positive x. The second integral, I2 , on the RHS of eqn. (1.2.12) vanishes. To demonstrate this we use the expression (1.2.7) for evaluating ln f 0 , & ' N N I2 = −Tr ( f − f 0 ) ln W0 + αi Ai (r , p ) i
= 0.
(1.2.13)
The above result for I2 follows easily from the normalization condition (1.2.10) and the constraints (1.2.6) for the ensemble averages of the set of observable {Ai }. Note that W0 and the parameters {αi } are not dependent on the phase-space variables. We have thus proved that HG for all arbitrary choices of f (N ) increases from its value corresponding to (N ) the function f 0 . The latter, as given by the RHS of eqn. (1.2.7), therefore minimizes the function HG . If we identify −kB HG with the thermodynamic entropy of the equilibrium state, the other parameters are also readily identified from the relation S = − ln W0 − αi A¯ i . (1.2.14) − kB i
Since for the equilibrium state the entropy is a maximum, we obtain, on taking the derivative of eqn. (1.2.14) with respect to αi , the following result for the thermodynamic average: ∂ ln W0 . A¯ i = − ∂αi
(1.2.15)
14
Statistical physics of liquids
On taking a second derivative we obtain ∂2 ∂ A¯ i = ln W0 . ∂αi ∂αi2
(1.2.16)
Using the expression (1.2.8) for ln W0 , the RHS of eqn. (1.2.16) is evaluated as the average of the mean-square fluctuation of Ai , ∂2 2 ln W = Tr Ai2 − {Tr[Ai ]}2 = Tr[{Ai − A¯ i } ] = Ai2 , (1.2.17) 0 2 ∂αi giving the relative fluctuation of Ai as Ai2 = −
∂ A¯ i . ∂αi
(1.2.18)
The result (1.2.18) implies that the relative fluctuation of Ai is of the order of the square root of the size S of the system, # $1/2 Ai2 1 ∼O . (1.2.19) ¯ S Ai The RHS approaches zero in the thermodynamic limit. Different representative statistical ensembles for the equilibrium state of the system are obtained with corresponding specific choices of the set of extensive variables {Ai }. The ensemble-averaged quantities {A¯ i } remain fixed at their experimentally measured values in the corresponding thermodynamic state which is characterized by the corresponding set of intensive thermodynamic variables {αi }. The above result (1.2.19) therefore demonstrates the equivalence of the different ensembles since the fluctuation of a specific property Ai around its average value is negligible in the thermodynamic limit of a large system, e.g., lim N → ∞, lim V → ∞ but N /V remaining finite. 1.2.2 The equilibrium ensembles Let us consider some of the specific ensembles in the following. For a completely isolated system we have the micro-canonical ensemble in which the assumption of equal a-priori probability for each state is applied. The canonical ensemble For the canonical ensemble the system is connected to an external heat bath allowing exchange of energy. The average energy is fixed and is determined by the equilibrium temperature T of the thermodynamic state. In the present case we have A ≡ H and the corresponding parameter is αi ≡ β. The number of particles N is fixed in this case. Evaluation of the H function gives HG = dr N dp N f 0 ln f 0 = −ln Z N − H¯ , (1.2.20)
1.2 Equilibrium properties
15
where Z N ≡ W0 . Upon identifying the average energy H¯ as the thermodynamic internal energy U , the above relation (1.2.14) reduces to −
S = −ln Z N − βU. kB
(1.2.21)
We identify β = 1/(kB T ) and the Helmholtz free energy of the system F as − kB T ln Z N = U − T S = F.
(1.2.22)
The equilibrium probability distribution is therefore given by (N ) N
f0
r , pN =
1 exp[−β H ] , ZN h 3N N !
with the partition function Z(N , V, T ) defined as 1 dr N dp N exp −β H (r N , p N ) . Z(N , V, T ) ≡ Z N = 3N h N!
(1.2.23)
(1.2.24)
The key relation connecting the thermodynamic property (the Helmholtz free energy F) with the statistical-mechanical quantity (the canonical partition function Z N ) is given by F = −kB T ln Z N .
(1.2.25)
For a noninteracting system (ideal gas) the Hamiltonian H has only a kinetic part and it is straightforward to obtain the partition function Z N by evaluating the Gaussian integrals involving the pα , α = 1, . . . , N : ZN =
VN N !30
,
(1.2.26)
√ with the thermal de Broglie wavelength 0 = h/ 2π mkB T . The free energy for the noninteracting system is obtained as ( ) Fid = N kB T ln n30 − 1 . (1.2.27) By using the relation P = −(∂ F/∂ V )T we obtain from eqn. (1.2.27) the ideal-gas equation of state P V = N kB T . The Gibbs free energy is given by ( ) G = F + P V = N kB T ln n30 , (1.2.28) and the chemical potential for the ideal gas is
( ) μid = kB T ln n30 .
(1.2.29)
The average energy, which is identified as the thermodynamic internal energy U , is obtained as * * ∂ ¯ (1.2.30) ln Z N ** . U=H=− ∂β V
16
Statistical physics of liquids
The mean-square fluctuation of the internal energy is obtained from the general formula (1.2.18) as ∂U 2 H = − = N kB T 2 cv , (1.2.31) ∂β V,N where cv is the specific heat per particle √ at constant volume. The relative root-mean-square fluctuation per particle is of O 1/ N , making it negligible in the thermodynamic limit. The grand-canonical ensemble The grand-canonical ensemble describes the system connected to an external bath allowing exchange of both energy and particles. The ensemble average of the total energy and the total particle numbers of the system are fixed. In this case we have A ≡ {H, N } and the corresponding αi is denoted by {β, −βμ}. Equation (1.2.14) reduces to the form −
S = −ln − H¯ + βμ N¯ , kB
(1.2.32)
where ≡ W0 in this case. The average energy H¯ and N¯ , respectively, correspond to the thermodynamic internal energy U and the average number of particles at temperature T . If we identify β = 1/(kB T ) and μ as the chemical potential, eqn. (1.2.32) reduces to the thermodynamic relation − kB T ln = U − T S − μ N¯ = F − G = −,
(1.2.33)
where G is the Gibbs free energy of the system and = − P V is the thermodynamic potential. The equilibrium probability distribution in the grand-canonical ensemble is therefore given by (N )
f0
(r N , p N ) =
1 exp[−β(H − μN )] , h 3N N !
(1.2.34)
where the grand-canonical partition function (μ, V, T ) is obtained as (μ, V, T ) =
∞ 1 dr N dp N exp −β(H (r N , p N ) − μN ) . (1.2.35) N!
N =0
The average energy and the average number of particles are respectively obtained as * * ∂ U = − ln ** , ∂β μ,V * * * * ∂ ∂ * = z ln ** . (1.2.36) ln * N¯ = ∂(βμ) ∂z T,V T,V where z = exp(βμ) is the fugacity. Note that the averaging in the grand-canonical ensemble can be interpreted as a weighted average with respect to the canonical-ensemble
1.2 Equilibrium properties
17
N -particle partition function Z N with all possible values of N . Thus we can express the grand-canonical partition function as (μ, V, T ) =
∞ zN ZN . N!
(1.2.37)
N =0
The average number of particles as given by eqn. (1.2.36) is expressed as N¯ =
∞
N P(N ),
(1.2.38)
N =0
where P(N ) is the probability for the N -particle state given by P(N ) =
z N ZN . N!
(1.2.39)
The key relation in the case of the grand-canonical ensemble connecting the thermodynamic property (the thermodynamic potential ≡ −P V ) with the statistical-mechanical quantity (the grand-canonical partition function ) is given by = −kB T ln .
(1.2.40)
The mean-square fluctuation of the number of particles is obtained from the general formula (1.2.18) as * ¯ ∂ N¯ ** ∂N 2 N = = kB T . (1.2.41) * ∂(βμ) T,V ∂μ T √ The relative root-mean-square fluctuation per particle is of O 1/ N , making it negligible in the thermodynamic limit. The RHS of eqn. (1.2.41) is further simplified by using the Gibbs–Duhem relation (McQuarie, 2000) N¯ dμ = V d P − S dT, and hence
∂μ ∂ N¯
= T
V N¯
∂P ∂ N¯
= T
1 N¯
(1.2.42)
∂P ∂n
,
since n = N¯ /V . However, (∂ P/∂n)T can also be written as ∂P V2 ∂P 1 ∂V ∂P = =− = , ¯ ∂n T ∂ V T ∂n T ∂ V nκ N T T where κT = −
1 V¯
¯ ∂V ∂P T
(1.2.43)
T
(1.2.44)
(1.2.45)
18
Statistical physics of liquids
is the isothermal compressibility of the system. Using the result (1.2.44) in eqn. (1.2.41), we obtain N 2 − N¯ 2 n (1.2.46) = κT . β N¯ √ The root-mean-square fluctuation N is therefore of O(1/ N ) and negligible in the thermodynamic limit – except near the critical point, where the compressibility is diverging and hence the role of fluctuations becomes important there. The isobaric–isothermal ensemble The isobaric ensemble describes the system connected to an external bath allowing both exchange of energy and variation of the volume V of the system. The number of particles remains constant in this case. The ensemble average of the total energy and the volume of the system are fixed. In this case we have Ai ≡ {H, V } and the corresponding αi is denoted by {β, βα}. Evaluation of the H function gives N dp N f 0 ln f 0 = −ln − βH − βαV , (1.2.47) HG = dr where ≡ W0 . Upon identifying the average energy H as the thermodynamic internal energy U the above relation (1.2.14) reduces to −
S = −ln − β(U + α V¯ ), kB
(1.2.48)
where V¯ is the volume in the thermodynamic equilibrium state at temperature T . We identify β = 1/(kB T ) and α as the thermodynamic pressure P so that eqn. (1.2.48) reduces to the thermodynamic relation − kB T ln = U − T S + α V¯ = U − T S + P V = G.
(1.2.49)
The equilibrium probability distribution in the isobaric ensemble is therefore given by (N ) (1.2.50) f 0 r N , p N = −1 exp[−β{H + P V }], where (N , P, T ) is the isobaric partition function. The latter is obtained as a Laplace transform (see eqn. (1.3.10) for its definition) at “frequency” β P with respect to the volume V , ∞ 0 N dp N exp[−β{H + P V }], (1.2.51) d V dr (N , P, T ) = 3N h N! 0 where 0 is a constant with the dimension of volume introduced so as to make the partition function dimensionless. The average volume and the mean square of the volume fluctuations are, respectively, obtained as * * ∂ , (1.2.52) ln ** V¯ = −kB T ∂P T,N
1.2 Equilibrium properties
19
Table 1.1 Different ensembles, the corresponding partition functions, and how they relate to the appropriate thermodynamic function. Ensemble type Canonical
Partition function
Thermodynamic function
Z N (N , V, T )
Helmholtz free energy, F F = −kB T ln Z N
Grand-canonical
(μ, V, T )
Thermodynamic potential, = −P V = −kB T ln
Isothermal–isobaric
(N , P, T )
Gibbs free energy, G G = −kB T ln
* (V )2 κT 1 ∂ V¯ ** = . =− * ¯ ¯ ∂(β P) β V V T,N
(1.2.53)
The above results for the different thermodynamic properties corresponding to the canonical, grand-canonical, and isobaric ensembles are shown in Table 1.1. 1.2.3 The static structure factor In the present section we discuss the correlation functions of fluctuations of dynamic variables at different spatial points but at the same time. These represent the static or the structural properties of the liquid. For a high-density liquid the most basic quantity characteristic of its structural or thermodynamic properties is the pair correlation function. The pair correlation function g(r ) For an N -particle system the equilibrium solution to the Liouville equation (1.1.22) is given by the Gibbsian distributions discussed in the previous section. Let us consider s (rs , ps ) of s particles as defined in eqn. (1.1.32), the reduced probability distributions f eq specifically for the equilibrium fluid. We use the short-hand notation rs ≡ {r1 , r2 , . . . , rs }, s in this case of a etc. here. The momentum dependence of the distribution function f eq thermodynamic equilibrium state is Maxwellian, &N ' % (s) s s f eq (r ) = φMB (ps ) n (s) (1.2.54) N (r ), s=1
where φMB (ps ) is the normalized Maxwell distribution function as defined in eqn. (1.1.44). The conditional probability of there being s particles simultaneously at {r1 , . . . , rs } irre(s) by integrating out the spective of their momenta is obtained from the corresponding f eq momentum variables { ps }, s (s) s n (s) (r ) = dps f eq (r , ps ). (1.2.55) N The simplest example of the above distribution function is the s = 2 case, i.e., g N (r1 , r2 ), which is termed the radial distribution function. It represents the conditional probability
20
Statistical physics of liquids
of a particle being at r2 while another is at r1 . In general a distribution function at the (s) s-particle level is defined from n N (rs ), g (s) N (r1 , r2 , . . . , rs ) =
(s)
n N (r1 , r2 , . . . , rs ) , (n N )s
(1.2.56)
where we define n N = N /V , the number of particles per unit volume in the N -particle system. In the grand-canonical-ensemble description, we average the reduced distribution s function n (s) N (r ) over the total number of particles N in the system to obtain the averaged quantity ∞ + , (s) s (s) s P(N )n N (rs ). (1.2.57) n (r ) ≡ n N (r ) = N =s
The simplest and most important is the s = 2 case. The thermodynamic quantity g(r1 , r2 ) termed the pair correlation function is defined as n (2) (r1 , r2 ) = n 2 g(r1 , r2 ),
(1.2.58)
where the factor n 2 on the LHS is for normalization of g(r ); n is the average number of particles per unit volume of the liquid, n = N¯ /V = n N . Some useful properties of this function follow directly from simple physical considerations. Thus, in the equilibrium state translational invariance holds and for an isotropic system g(r1 , r2 ) is a function only of the distance between the two points and can be denoted as g(r12 ). For a small separation r between two points g(r ) vanishes due to the repulsive core of the interaction potential, whereas, for large r , g(r ) → 1 so that the probability of two particles being at the two points goes to the trivial limit n 2 . The radial distribution function g(r ) is the most fundamental quantity in describing the thermodynamic properties of the equilibrium fluid. In this respect it is important to note two very basic relations linking the thermodynamic properties of a liquid to the pair correlation function. The virial equation For a liquid in which the interaction between the particles involves only two-body potentials as introduced in the expression (1.1.16) for the Hamiltonian, the thermodynamic pressure is obtained in terms of the pair correlation function only. To demonstrate this, we begin from the thermodynamic relation P = −(∂ F/∂ V )T with the free energy being given by F = −kB T ln Z N . The canonical partition function Z N is obtained for the interacting system as 1 dr N exp[−βU (r1 , . . . , r1 )], (1.2.59) ZN = N !3N 0 where 0 is the thermal de Broglie wavelength as defined with eqn. (1.2.26). The pressure is obtained as * * 1 1 ∂ * P= (1.2.60) Z N* . * Z ∂ V N !3N N 0 T
1.2 Equilibrium properties
21
The calculation of the thermodynamic pressure P involves computing the derivative of Z N with respect to the volume. The volume dependence of the partition function has two components. Let us first consider the 3N -dimensional integral over the spatial coordinates. Let us assume that the volume of the system is a box of size 2L for each dimension and that the spatial integral is done over the linear range −L to +L. The volume of the system V ∼ L 3 . A change of the integration variables from x to x = x/L reduces the configuration integral on the RHS of eqn. (1.2.59) to VN
+1 −1
dr1 . . .
+L −L
drN exp[−βU (r1 , . . . , r N )].
Using this form in eqn. (1.2.60), we obtain for the pressure +1 +L 1 P N −1 dr1 . . . drN e−βU (r1 ,...,r N ) = NV kB T N !Z N 3N −1 −L 0 −βU (r1 ,...,r N ) ∂U −β dr1 . . . dr N e ∂V β ∂U dr N e−βU (r1 ,...,r N ) =n− . 3N ∂V N !Z N 0
(1.2.61)
(1.2.62)
For systems in which the potential part U of the Hamiltonian involves only two-body interactions the integral Ivirial (say) in the second term on the RHS is simplified. In this case the spatial dependence of U comes through the two-body interaction potential u(r), N 1 U= u(ri j ). 2
(1.2.63)
i, j=1
Since the spatial dependence of U comes through that of the two-body potential, we write the derivative on the RHS in the form Ivirial =
N e−βU (r1 ,...,r N ) du(ri j ) dri j β · dr1 . . . dr N . 2 dri j dV N !Z N 3N 0 i, j=1
(1.2.64)
On changing the integration variable from x to x = x/L it follows that ri j → V 1/3ri j and hence the derivative dri j /d V = ri j /(3V ). For a system of identical particles all the different N (N − 1) choices for the pairs in the sum above give the same integral. For the spherically symmetric potential u(ri j ) we obtain
−βU (r1 ,...,r N ) e 1 N! du(r12 ) · r12 dr3 . . . dr N dr1 dr2 6V (N − 2)! dr12 N !Z N 3N 0 du(r ) 2πβ 2 dr r 3 = n g(r ). (1.2.65) 3 dr
Ivirial =
22
Statistical physics of liquids
We obtain the pressure in terms of the pair correlation functions as P 2πβ = n − n2 kB T 3
∞ o
du(r ) g(r )r 3 dr. dr
(1.2.66)
In the above equation we have dropped the subscript N from g in the thermodynamic limit. This is termed the virial equation. The compressibility condition The isothermal compressibility κT of the liquid defined in eqn. (1.2.45) is also related to the pair correlation function g(r ). In order to demonstrate this, we integrate with respect to (N ) all the variables {rs , ps } the definition (1.1.32) of the f (s) and obtain, in terms of f eq (r N ), N! (s) (N ) N dr N dp N f eq drs n N (rs ) = (r ). (1.2.67) (N − s)! On taking the s = 2 case, eqn. (1.2.67), and averaging over the number of particles N in terms of the probability P(N ) defined in eqn. (1.2.39), we obtain - . (2) dr1 dr2 n N (r1 , r2 ) = d N P(N )(N 2 − N ) = N 2 − N¯ , (1.2.68) where the angular brackets imply averaging over the number of particles N in the system. Using the definition (1.2.58) for the pair correlation function, the above relation gives us the mean-square fluctuation of N for an isotropic fluid, 2 2 2 ¯ ¯ dr1 dr2 g(r1 , r2 ) − N¯ 2 N − N = N +n = N¯ + n 2 V dr g(r ) − N¯ nV
¯ = N 1 + n dr{g(r ) − 1} . (1.2.69) Now, using the relation (1.2.46), we obtain the compressibility condition n κT = 1 + n (g(r ) − 1)dr. β
(1.2.70)
Note that the above relation (1.2.70) is obtained from consideration of the grand-canonical ensemble and, unlike eqn. (1.2.66), is not limited only to pairwise-additive interaction potentials. The static correlation function Starting from the level of N particles, the reduced distribution function giving the conditional probability of finding a smaller number of particles has been defined in eqn. (1.1.32).
1.2 Equilibrium properties
23
Thus the s-particle (s < N ) reduced distribution function f (s) is defined as N! f (N ) (r N , p N , t)drs+1 dps+1 . . . dr N dp N . f (s) (rs , ps , t) = (N − s)!
(1.2.71)
Furthermore, the conditional probability of there being s particles simultaneously at {r1 , . . . , rs } irrespective of their momenta is obtained from the corresponding f (s) by integrating out the momentum variables { ps }, N! (s) f (N ) (r N , p N , t)dp N drs+1 . . . dr N , n N (rs ) = dps f (s) (rs , ps ) = (N − s)! (1.2.72) where we have used the notation p N ≡ {p1 , . . . , p N }. Note that the above definition of n N can be rewritten in the form N! (s) d r˜ N d p˜ N f (N ) (r N , p N , t){δ(r1 − r˜ 1 ) . . . δ(rs − r˜ s )} n N (rs , t) = (N − s)! / N 0 = δ(r1 − r˜ α1 ) . . . δ(rs − r˜ αs ) , (1.2.73) α1 ,...,αs =1
where the prime in the summation in (1.2.73) indicates that none of the αi are equal. The simplest examples of the above distribution function are the s = 1, 2, . . . cases, / N 0 (1) δ(r − rα ) , (1.2.74) n (r) = α
n
(2)
(r, r ) =
/N
0
δ(r − rα )δ(r − rβ ) ,
(1.2.75)
α,β
and so on, where we have dropped the subscript N on n (s) for simplicity and {r1 , . . . , r N } are now the space coordinates of the particles labeled as α = 1, . . . , N respectively. Note that the above definitions for the average distribution functions are not restricted to systems in equilibrium. Let us focus on the simplest of these spatial distribution functions, namely the oneˆ particle quantity n (1) (r), simply written as the ensemble average of n(r), n(r) ˆ =
N
δ(r − rα ),
(1.2.76)
α
where we have put the hat on n to indicate that it depends on the phase-space variables. The integral of this one-particle density over the whole volume is N , the total number of particles. For an isotropic fluid in equilibrium 1in the2 absence of any external field the average density at every point is a constant so that n(r) ˆ = N /V = n 0 . The product of the density fluctuations δ nˆ = nˆ − n 0 at two different spatial points but at the same time, averaged over the equilibrium ensemble, is referred to as the equal-time correlation function. For the fluid
24
Statistical physics of liquids
in equilibrium translation invariance holds and the equal-time correlation function χnn is a function of (r − r ) only: / N N 0 1 2 ˆ n(r ˆ ) = δ(r − rα )δ(r − rβ ) − n 20 χnn (r − r ) = δ n(r)δ /
= δ(r − r )
α=1 β=1 N
0
δ(r − rα ) +
α=1
/
N
0
δ(r − rα )δ(r − rβ ) − n 20 ,
α,β=1
(1.2.77) where the prime indicates that the α = β term is dropped from the sum. However, using now eqns. (1.2.74) and (1.2.75), we obtain from the above equation the result ! " (1.2.78) χnn (r − r ) = n 0 δ(r − r ) + n 0 {g(r − r ) − 1} . Now, on taking the Fourier transform (see eqn. (1.3.9) for its definition) of the eqn. (1.2.78), we obtain the result
χnn (k) = n 0 1 + n 0 dr eik · r {g(r) − 1} ≡ n 0 S(k),
(1.2.79)
where the Fourier transform of the radial distribution function g(r ) is expressed in terms of the Fourier-transformed quantity S(k) for the isotropic liquid, (1.2.80) S(k) = 1 + n 0 eik · r h(r )dr, with h(r ) = g(r ) − 1. S(k) is termed the static structure factor for the liquid. This is a quantity directly measurable from the coherent part of elastic scattering intensities using a radiation source suitable for the length scale probed in the system. For experimental methodologies used in scattering experiments see Berne and Pecora (1976) and Hansen and McDonald (1986).
1.2.4 Integral equations for g(r) Both (1.2.66) and (1.2.70) give rise to the equation of state for the liquid, via two different routes, and in terms of the pair correlation function g(r ). Computation of the radial distribution function g(r ) for a liquid thus forms a major part of the study of its equilibrium thermodynamic properties. The determination of g(r ) is carried out by the solution of appropriate integral equations. We discuss below the broad outlines of some of the methods for computing g(r ) for a liquid. The Kirkwood approximation One of the earlier approaches to computing g(r ) comes from the stationary limit of the BBGKY hierarchy, from which one can obtain a set of equations for the static functions
1.2 Equilibrium properties
25
(s)
g N defined in eqn. (1.2.56) for the N -particle system. The hierarchy equation for the s-particle distribution function (in the absence of any external field) is obtained from eqn. (1.1.34) as ⎧ ⎫⎞ ⎤ ⎡⎛ s s ⎨ ⎬ pi ⎣⎝ (s) s ⎦ kB T ∇ri + Fi j ⎠ f eq (x ) · ⎩ ⎭ m i=1
=−
s pi i=1
m
j=1
dxs+1 Fi,s+1 ·
·
(s+1) (s+1) f eq (x )
.
(1.2.81)
Since eqn. (1.2.81) is independent of s and the value of the momentum ps , the equality must hold term by term and the space-dependent parts within the square brackets should (s) be equal. We write the equation now in terms of the spatial distribution functions n N (rs ) as follows: (s) s ˜ kB T ∇1 + F1 n N (r ) = − drs+1 F1,s+1 · n (s+1) (r(s+1) ), (1.2.82) N where we have used the notation F˜ 1 =
s l=1
F1l =
s
∇1 u(r1 , rl )
(1.2.83)
l=1
and ∇1 represents the derivative with respect to r1 . Now, using the definition (1.2.56) for (s) the s-particle distribution function g N (rs ), we obtain the hierarchy equations s −kB T ∇1 g (s) N (r ) =
s l=1
+n
s ∇1 u(r1 , rl )g (s) N (r )
(rs+1 )drs+1 . ∇1 u(r1 , rs+1 )g (s+1) N
(1.2.84)
The set of equations described by (1.2.84) is known as the Yvon–Born–Green (YBG) hierarchy. To solve this, a suitable closure scheme is needed. For an isotropic fluid the first equation of this set, i.e., the s = 2 case, reduces to an integral equation for g N (r1 , r2 ) of the form (we drop the superscript s for simplicity) kB T ∇1 g N (r1 , r2 ) + g N (r1 , r2 )∇1 u(r1 , r2 ) = −n ∇1 u(r1 , r3 )g N (r1 , r2 , r3 )dr3 . (1.2.85) (3)
The hierarchy is closed by writing the function g N , involving three particles, in the Kirkwood superposition approximation (Kirkwood, 1935) as (2) (2) (2) g (3) N (r1 , r2 , r3 ) = g N (r1 , r2 )g N (r2 , r3 )g N (r3 , r1 ).
(1.2.86)
26
Statistical physics of liquids
For the isotropic liquid the pair correlation function depends only on the distance between the two points, g N (r1 , r2 ) ≡ g N (r12 ). Using (1.2.86) in eqn. (1.2.85), we obtain the following equation: ∇1 {kB T ln[g N (r12 )] + u(r12 )} = −n dr3 ∇1 u(r13 ){g N (r23 ) − 1}g N (r13 ). (1.2.87) The last term added on the RHS gives a vanishing contribution since for the isotropic liquid every point is equivalent on average, and hence dr3 u(r1 , r3 )g N (r13 ) = 0. (1.2.88) The integral equation (1.2.87) known as the Yvon–Born–Green equation is good for computing the pair correlation functions in a low-density fluid. Once g(r ) is known, the other thermodynamic properties readily follow, as discussed above. For systems interacting with two-body potentials the integral-equation approach has been applied widely and the corresponding theoretical formulation of the problem is specific to the nature of the interaction. We discuss below the broad outlines of the calculation of the pair correlation function for two generic cases: (a) for a short-range repulsive potential like the hard-sphere interaction; and (b) for an interaction having an attractive part effective over a long distance. Hard-sphere interaction Subsequent to the Kirkwood approximation for closing the hierarchy, a new class of integral equations for g(r ) was obtained for fluids interacting through a pairwise additive potential by considering different methods of closing the hierarchy. This involved introducing a new type of correlation function, termed the direct correlation function c(r ), which was defined from the Ornstein–Zernike relation (Ornstein and Zernike, 1914), h(r ) = c(r ) + n c(|r − r |)h(r )dr . (1.2.89) Note that from eqn. (1.2.79) it follows that eqn. (1.2.89) also leads to the relation S(k) = [1 − n 0 c(k)]−1 .
(1.2.90)
To solve for g(r ) and c(r ), for a given pair potential u(r ), eqn. (1.2.89) is supplemented with a closure relation. Two standard prescriptions for this, namely the Percus–Yevick (PY) (Percus and Yevick, 1958) solution and hypernetted chain closure (HNC) (van Leeuwen et al., 1959), respectively, give y(r ) = 1 + h(r ) − c(r ) y(r ) = exp[h(r ) − c(r )]
(PY), (HNC),
(1.2.91) (1.2.92)
1.2 Equilibrium properties
27
where the function y on the LHS is defined as y(r ) = eβu(r ) g(r ). The motivation for both of the proposed closures can be reached through different approaches, for which we refer the reader to Percus (1962, 1964) and Stell (1963). Of the two proposed closures, the PY solution is most suitable for describing the correlations between particles when the interaction potential is harshly repulsive or of short range. The hard-sphere potential is a typical example of this. The HNC, on the other hand, is well suited for long-range potentials such as Coulombic systems. However, for strongly coupled systems like high-density or lowtemperature liquids, both these closures lead to severe thermodynamic inconsistency since the virial and compressibility equations given by (1.2.66) and (1.2.70), respectively, lead to different equations of state. For investigating equilibrium theories of simple liquids, the hard-sphere system has been the most widely studied system, both through computer simulations and using theoretical methods. For the hard-sphere system the integral equation for g(r ) can be solved exactly. The hard-sphere potential is given by & ∞ for r ≤ σ, (1.2.93) u HS (r ) = 0 for r > σ. Since the barrier height is infinite, with the hard-sphere potential g(r ) = 0 for r ≤ 0 and g(r ) = y(r ) for r ≥ 0. The PY closure eqn. (1.2.91) in this case takes the form & −y(r ) for r ≤ σ, c(r ) = (1.2.94) 0 for r ≥σ. With the above closure relation the Ornstein–Zernike equation (1.2.89) is solved using Laplace-transform methods and the direct correlation function is obtained as (Wertheim, 1963, 1964; Thiele 1963) & −α0 − α1 (r/σ ) − α2 (r/σ )3 for r ≤ σ, c(x) = (1.2.95) 0 for r > σ . The constants αi appearing in eqn. (1.2.95) are obtained in terms of the packing fraction ϕ = π nσ 3 /6 as follows: α0 =
(1 + 2ϕ)2
, (1 − ϕ)4 (1 + ϕ/2)2 α1 = −6ϕ , (1 − ϕ)4 ϕα0 α2 = . 2
(1.2.96) (1.2.97) (1.2.98)
Often it is more convenient to express the Fourier transform of the above expression in such a way as to obtain the static structure factor S(k) using the relation (1.2.90) (see Fig. 1.3).
28
Statistical physics of liquids
Fig. 1.3 The static structure factor from MD simulations of Lennard-Jones system at T = 0.723 and ρ = 0.844 (dots). The solid line corresponds to the hard-sphere mdoel.
Thus the Fourier transform of (1.2.95) gives the result (Ashcroft and Lekner, 1966)
sin(skσ ) ds s {α0 + α1 s + α2 s 3 } nc(kσ ) = −4πnσ skσ 0 24ϕ α1 = − 3 α0 (sin x − x cos x) + {2x sin x − (x 2 − 2)cosx − 2} x x α3 3 4 + 3 {(4x − 24x)sinx − (x − 12x 2 + 24)cosx + 24} (1.2.99) x
3
1
2
in terms of the dimensionless variable x = kσ . The above result is useful in obtaining the compressibility of the hard-sphere fluid using the relation nc(0) = −ϕ
(4 − ϕ)(2 + ϕ 2 )
(1.2.100)
(1 − ϕ)4
and hence, from eqn. (1.2.90) for the corresponding static structure factor, S(0) is obtained as S −1 (0) = 1 − nc(0) =
(1 + 2ϕ)2 (1 − ϕ)4
.
(1.2.101)
Since the compressibility is expressed as κT−1 = n(∂ P/∂n), we obtain from the compressibility condition, i.e., eqn. (1.2.70), the relation
∂P ∂n
= β −1
(1 + 2ϕ)2 (1 − ϕ)4
.
(1.2.102)
1.2 Equilibrium properties
29
By integrating the above expression we obtain the equation of state from the compressibility equation as P 1 + ϕ + ϕ2 . = nkB T (1 − ϕ)3
(1.2.103)
On the other hand, we obtain the equation of state directly from eqn. (1.2.66), giving that ∞ du(r ) 2 2πβ βP = n − n g(r )r 3 dr 3 0 dr ∞ 2 2π =n+n δ(r − σ ) g(r )r 3 dr 3 0 ! " = n 1 + 4ϕg(σ ) . (1.2.104) In reaching the above result we used the fact that the discontinuous hard-sphere potential u HS (r ) given by eqn. (1.2.93) decreases discontinuously from ∞ to 0 as r increases from σ − to σ + . Hence the derivative β du(r )/dr = −δ(r − σ ). The pair correlation function at contact g(σ ) directly follows from the PY closure. In the limit r → σ + , g(r ) = 0 while c(r ) = 0. On the other hand, for r → σ − , g(r ) = 0 while c(r ) = 0. Since the function y(r ) is continuous through r = σ , we obtain from eqn. (1.2.91) that g(σ + ) = −c(σ − ). It then follows from eqn. (1.2.95) that g(σ ) = α0 + α1 + α2 =
1 + ϕ/2 (1 − ϕ)2
(1.2.105)
and hence the corresponding equation of state is obtained from eqn. (1.2.104): P 1 + 2ϕ + 3ϕ 2 . = nkB T (1 − ϕ)2
(1.2.106)
The two different equations of state given by (1.2.103) and (1.2.106) match up to O(ϕ 2 ), beyond which the difference grows. An accurate equation of state for a hard-sphere system has been developed by studying the Mayer cluster expansion for such a system. The latter is generally defined as ∞
P Bi (T )n i−1 =1+ nkB T
(1.2.107)
i=2
in terms of virial coefficients Bi . These coefficients can be computed order by order using cluster diagrams. In fact, for the hard-sphere system B2 , B3 , and B4 are known analytically. However, the complexity of the calculation increases rapidly with the order. The numbers of diagrams entering the computation of Bi for i = 2, . . . , 6 are, respectively, 1, 3, 10, 56, and 468. Explicit calculations are therefore limited to low orders. For the hard-sphere
30
Statistical physics of liquids
system this calculation has been extended to B8 (van Rensburg, 1993; Vlasov et al., 2002) to obtain P = 1 + 4ϕ + 10ϕ 2 + 18.365ϕ 3 + 28.325ϕ 4 + 39.74ϕ 5 + 53.5ϕ 6 + 70.8ϕ 7 + · · · nkB T ∞ Cm ϕ m . (1.2.108) ≡1+ m=1
The above series has been summed by making the useful observation that the first seven terms on the RHS are well reproduced if the coefficient Cm is approximated with the formula Cm = 3m + m 2 .
(1.2.109)
The coefficients evaluated with this formula are C1 = 4 (4), C2 = 10 (10), C3 = 18 (18.365), C4 = 28 (28.325), C5 = 40 (39.74), C6 = 54 (53.5), and C7 = 70 (70.8), where the numbers in parentheses are the actual values of the coefficient in the series presented in eqn. (1.2.108). The formula (1.2.109) for Cm is therefore taken as a good approximation for the virial coefficient to all orders. We obtain the series in the form ∞
P (m 2 + 3m)ϕ m . =1+ nkB T
(1.2.110)
m=1
The sums can be easily evaluated using the results ∞
∞ d m ϕ ϕ = , dϕ (1 − ϕ)2 m=1 m=1 ∞ ∞ d 2 m ϕ(1 + ϕ) 2 m m ϕ = ϕ ϕ = . dϕ (1 − ϕ)3
m=1
mϕ m = ϕ
(1.2.111)
(1.2.112)
m=1
On evaluating the series on the RHS of eqn. (1.2.110) with the results (1.2.111) and (1.2.112), we obtain the equation of state as P 1 + ϕ + ϕ2 − ϕ3 . = nkB T (1 − ϕ)3
(1.2.113)
which is termed the Carnahan–Starling equation of state (Carnahan and Starling, 1969; Mansoori et al., 1971). Though it was obtained in an ad-hoc manner in the above simplified analysis, eqn. (1.2.113) presents a very accurate equation of state valid for a hard-sphere liquid up to high packing fractions close to freezing, having discrepancies from moleculardynamics simulation results of at most around 1%. The predictions from this equation of state lie in between those from the other two equations of state given by (1.2.103) and (1.2.106), respectively, following from the compressibility condition (1.2.70) and the virial equation (1.2.66). This is shown in Fig. 1.4. Several other equations of state have been devised (Mulero et al., 1999), though the form (1.2.113) is the simplest and most widely
1.2 Equilibrium properties
31
Fig. 1.4 The equation of state giving P/(nkB T ) − 1 vs. the packing fraction η for hard spheres according to the Percus–Yevick theory using the compressibility (PY-C) (eqn. (1.2.103)) and virial (PY-V) (eqn. (1.2.106)) routes. The result from the Carnahan–Starling equation is shown as a dashed line.
used. The Helmholtz free energy of the liquid is obtained by integrating the thermodynamic relation P = −(∂ F/∂ V )T , ϕ d ϕ¯ β P dn P = N kB T . (1.2.114) F = − P dV = N ϕ¯ n n2 0 The corresponding expression for the excess free energy of the hard-sphere liquid (in addition to the ideal-gas or noninteracting part) given in eqn. (1.2.114) is obtained by integrating the Carnahan–Starling equation of state,
ϕ βF d ϕ¯ β P ϕ(4 − 3ϕ) . (1.2.115) = −1 = N ϕ¯ n (1 − ϕ)2 0 On the other hand, on using either the PY or the HNC closure we will obtain two equations of state for the virial and compressibility conditions. This problem was addressed by proposing bridge functions to interpolate between the two schemes given in (1.2.91) and (1.2.92). The bridge function is adjusted to achieve full consistency between the two equations of state (Rogers and Young, 1984). Long-range interaction For interaction potentials that have a long-range attractive part in addition to the shortrange repulsive part, the closure schemes described above are not very useful. In this case the two-body interaction potential u(r ) is divided into a harshly repulsive short-range u 0 (r )
32
Statistical physics of liquids
part and a weak attractive part u 1 (r ) effective over long distances. In the conventional mean-spherical approximation (MSA) (Lebowitz and Penrose, 1966) this situation was initially treated by taking u 0 as a hard-sphere potential so that the resulting integral equation reduces to the PY equation with u 1 = 0. This approach was subsequently generalized to schemes in which u 0 is continuous though strongly repulsive (Chihara, 1973; Madden and Rice, 1980). This is referred to as “soft-core” MSA (SMSA). We consider here the scheme developed by Weeks, Chandler, and Andersen for systems with long-range attractive potentials (Chandler and Weeks, 1970; Weeks et al., 1971; Andersen et al., 1971). In the WCA theory the two-body interaction potential u(r) is divided into a short-range repulsive part u 0 (r) and a long-range attractive part u a (r), u(r) = u 0 (r) + u a (r).
(1.2.116)
A typical example is the spherically symmetric Lennard-Jones (LJ) interaction potential, for which such a division (Weeks et al., 1971) is made as follows. The LJ interaction potential u(r ) ≡ u LJ (r ) for two particles at a distance r is defined as 12 6 σ σ − ≡ w(r ), (1.2.117) u LJ (r ) = 40 r r where 0 is the depth of the potential at its minimum and σ is the scale associated with the potential. u LJ is written as a sum of two parts, a hard-core repulsive part u LJ R and an , respectively defined as attractive part u LJ P & w(r ) + 0 , for r < σ0 , LJ u 0 ≡ u R (r ) = (1.2.118) 0, for r > σ0 , and
& ua ≡
u LJ P (r )
=
−0 ,
for r < σ0 ,
w(r ),
for r > σ0 ,
(1.2.119)
where σ0 = 21/6 σ . For the homogeneous liquid state, its thermodynamic properties are obtained by treating the weak attraction u LJ P as a perturbation of a reference system having . an interaction potential u LJ R The thermodynamic property of the system with the given interaction potential u(r) is obtained as a sum of two contributions: first, that of a reference system having the purely repulsive interaction u 0 (12); and second, the contribution due to the attractive part of the interaction u a (12), which is obtained by treating the latter as a weak perturbation. In the first part, the properties of the reference system are usually known from independent models. The most commonly used reference system is the one with hard-sphere potential interaction potential u H d (r ), with diameter d characterizing the hard-sphere potential (for its definition see eqn. (1.2.93)). This choice of the hard-sphere system is motivated by the fact that there exist several models that accurately describe its thermodynamic properties
1.2 Equilibrium properties
33
for densities ranging from low to very high values. Some of these have already been discussed above. The diameter of the reference hard-sphere liquid system is chosen such that the corresponding thermodynamic free energy is equal to that of the original system with interaction potential u 0 (12). The dependence of the free energy F on the interaction potential u 0 (r) is treated in terms of the function e0 (r ) = exp(−βu 0 (r )), which changes sharply at the effective range of the harshly repulsive potential u 0 (r). The corresponding quantity for the hard-sphere potential ed (r) = exp(−βu H d (r )), on the other hand, changes discontinuously from 0 to 1 at r = d. The difference between the “e” functions corresponding to the reference and the hard-sphere systems defines the function e0 (r) = e0 (r) − ed (r).
(1.2.120)
The “blip function” e0 (r ) is nonzero only in a small range of O(d) (say) around r = d which is the diameter of the equivalent hard-sphere system. This is shown schematically in Fig. 1.5. Since the blip function is identically zero if u 0 (r) = u H d (r), the free energy of the reference system is expressed in a functional Taylor expansion in powers of e0 (r ) around the free energy of the equivalent hard-sphere system (EHS): * δ F ** e0 (r) δe0 (r) *e0 =ed * * 1 δ2 F * dr dr + e0 (r)e0 (r ) + · · ·. 2 δe0 (r)δe0 (r ) *e0 =ed
F[u 0 ] = F[u d ] +
dr
(1.2.121)
Fig. 1.5 The Boltzmann factors e0 (r ) for the potential u 0 (r ); ed (r ) for the hard-sphere potential uH d (r ); and the blip function e0 (r ) vs. r .
34
Statistical physics of liquids
We note first that the functional derivative in the second term on the RHS above is evaluated, noting that F = −kB T ln Z N , as δF δ F δu 0 (r ) = dr δe0 (r) δu 0 (r ) δe0 (r)
δu 0 (r ) 1 δZ N = kB T dr − . (1.2.122) Z N δu 0 (r ) δe0 (r) Since −βu 0 (r) = ln e0 (r) the functional derivative −β
δu 0 (r ) = eβu 0 (r) δ(r − r ). δe0 (r)
(1.2.123)
If the potential-energy part U of the Hamiltonian involves only two-body interactions as in the definition (1.2.63), the integral I˜ (say) in the square bracket on the RHS of eqn. (1.2.122) is further simplified. In this case the derivative of U with respect to the two-body potential u 0 (r) is simply a sum of delta functions, β δU −βU (r1 ,...,r N ) dr I˜ = . . . dr e 1 N δu 0 (r ) N !Z N 3N 0 N e−βU (r1 ,..., r N ) β = δ(r − ri j )dr1 . . . dr N . (1.2.124) 2 N !Z N 3N 0 i, j=1 For a system of identical particles all the different N (N − 1) choices for the pairs in the sum above give the same integral. For the translationally invariant system the integral dr1 dr2 ≡ V dr12 , giving −βU (r1 ,...,r N ) N! β e dr1 dr2 δ(r − r12 ) dr3 . . . dr N I˜ = 2 (N − 2)! N !Z N 3N 0 −βU (r12 =r ; r3 ,...,r N ) βV N! e = dr3 . . . dr N 2 (N − 2)! N !Z N 3N 0 V = β n 2 g(r ). (1.2.125) 2 Hence, using eqns. (1.2.123) and (1.2.125) in eqn. (1.2.122), we obtain the result 4 3 2 δF n V = −kB T dr g(r ) eβu 0 (r ) δ(r − r ) δe0 (r) 2 1 = − N nkB T y(r). (1.2.126) 2 Using this relation, the expansion (1.2.122) for the free energy is obtained as n dr yd (r )e0 (r) + · · ·. F[u 0 ] = F[u d ] − N kB T 2
(1.2.127)
The free energy of the reference system is made equal to that of the equivalent hard-sphere system by setting the first-order term in the RHS of eqn. (1.2.121) equal to zero. Thus the
1.2 Equilibrium properties
35
diameter d is determined from the condition dr yd (r )e0 (r) = 0.
(1.2.128)
The diameter d is obtained by numerically solving the above equation using the hardsphere pair correlation functions and the y function. Since the function e0 (r) is nonzero only in a small region around r = d, the above condition is evaluated to leading order by replacing yd with its value at this point. The integral on the LHS of eqn. (1.2.128) is then obtained (using the definition (1.2.120)) as ∞ ∞ dr{e0 (r) − ed (r)} = dr e−βu 0 (r) − dr. (1.2.129) 0
d
We have used the fact that ed (r ) equals 0 for r < d and 1 for r > d. From eqn. (1.2.129) one obtains for d the result (Barker and Henderson, 1967) ∞ ( ) dr 1 − e−βu 0 (r) . (1.2.130) d= 0
In fact, with the condition (1.2.128) satisfied, the free energy of the reference system is obtained in terms of that of the equivalent hard-sphere system (Chandler and Weeks, 1970; Weeks et al., 1971, Andersen et al., 1971; Barker and Henderson, 1971) F[u 0 ] = F[u d ] + O( 4 ),
(1.2.131)
where is the range around r = d over which the blip function is nonzero. Note that the value of d obtained from the solution of eqn. (1.2.128) depends both on the density n and on the temperature T , whereas the d obtained from the Barker–Henderson relation (1.2.130) depends only on the temperature. From eqns. (1.2.126) and (1.2.127) we obtain that to leading orders y(r) = yd (r), and hence the pair correlation function for the reference system is obtained as g0 (r ) = e−βu 0 (r ) yd (r ) + O( 2 ).
(1.2.132)
The pair correlation function g(r ) for the Lennard-Jones system is obtained in terms of that of the equivalent hard-sphere system of diameter d from eqn. (1.2.132). This is shown in Fig. 1.6. The corresponding g(r ) obtained from molecular-dynamics simulations as well as numerical solution of the Percus–Yevick equations for the LennardJones potential is also shown for comparison. In Section 2.4.1 we will discuss the application of the WCA approach to obtain the thermodynamic properties of the inhomogeneous solid state for a Lennard-Jones system. The contribution to the free energy from the attractive part of the potential is added as a mean-field term (see eqn. (2.4.9) in Chapter 2) in this theory. Further improvements for the thermodynamic properties (of the liquid) at higher densities are obtained by using the bridge functions mentioned above to interpolate between the SMSA and the HNC equations (Zerah and Hansen, 1986; Due and Haymet, 1995; Due and Henderson, 1996). These methods lead to values of the static structure factor for the liquid that are in agreement with simulations at high densities.
36
Statistical physics of liquids
Fig. 1.6 The radial distribution function g(r ) for the Lennard-Jones liquid at ρ ∗ = 0.85 and T ∗ = 0.88. MD simulations by Verlet (1968) (open circles); the Percus–Yevick solution for the pair function for the Lennard-Jones potential by Mandel et al. (1970) (dashed line); and the theory c American Institute of Physics. of Weeks et al. (1971) described in the text (solid line).
1.3 Time correlation functions The time correlation of the microscopic densities, averaged over the equilibrium ensemble, is an important ingredient in the study of the dynamics of a fluid. Essentially all experiments probing the dynamic properties of the fluid are also analyzed in terms of time correlation functions. Let ψˆ a be a dynamic variable dependent on the phase-space coordinates, denoted with the symbol {r N (t), p N (t)} ≡ N (t), defined as ψˆ a (t) = ψa [ N (t)].
(1.3.1)
For clarity we drop any possible spatial dependence of ψˆ a . The hat on the variable is used to denote that it is dependent on the phase-space variables. The time correlation function is defined as the correlation function of the fluctuation of ψa (t) and ψb (t ) (t > t ) around the corresponding equilibrium average, Cab (t, t ) = δ ψˆ a (t)δ ψˆ b (t ),
(1.3.2)
where the angular brackets denote the average in the equilibrium ensemble in the following way: ˆ ˆ δ ψa (t)δ ψb (t ) = d N (t )δ ψˆ a (t)δ ψˆ b (t ) f eqN [ N (t )] = d N (t )exp[iL(t − t )]δ ψˆ a (t )δ ψˆ b (t ) f eqN [ N (t )]. (1.3.3) The equilibrium distribution f eqN is independent of time and hence Cab is dependent only on the difference of the two times Cab (t, t ) = Cab (t − t ). Of particular interest for the
1.3 Time correlation functions
37
discussion of the dynamics of liquids is the equilibrium averaged autocorrelation function, which is defined as + , (1.3.4) Caa (t) = δ ψˆ a (t)δ ψˆ a∗ (0) . Since Caa (t) = Caa (−t) it follows from the above definition that Caa (t) is real for all times. Using Schwarz’s inequality (Dennery and Krzwicki, 1967) for the autocorrelation function, + , (1.3.5) |Caa (t)| ≤ ψˆ a ψˆ a∗ = Caa (0), i.e., the magnitude of the function is bound by its initial value. Indeed, in the long-time limit, t → ∞, the dynamic variables become uncorrelated and we have lim
(t−t )→∞
|Caa (t − t )| = δ ψˆ a (t)δ ψˆ a (t ) = 0.
(1.3.6)
An important property of the autocorrelation function is that its time derivative at t = 0 vanishes. In order to prove this, we note that, since ψa (t + s)ψb (s) is independent of s, d ψa (t + s)ψb (s) = 0, ds ψ˙ a (t + s)ψb (s) + ψa (t + s)ψ˙ b (s) = 0, where the dot implies a derivative with respect to s. On setting s = 0 we obtain the result ψ˙ a (t)ψb (0) = −ψa (t)ψ˙ b (0). For the autocorrelation at t = 0 we have the result * * d = C˙ aa (0) = 0. ψa (t)ψa (0)** dt
(1.3.7)
(1.3.8)
t=0
For our discussions in this book it will be particularly useful to define the two-sided Fourier transform +∞ Cab (t)eiωt dt (1.3.9) C˜ ab (ω) = −∞
and the one-sided Laplace transform +∞ Cab (t)ei zt dt, Cab (z) = −i
Im(z) > 0.
0
The two transforms are related in the following way: +∞ Cab (t)ei zt dt Cab (z) = −i 0
+∞ +∞ d ω¯ i(z−ω)t ¯ dt e dt C˜ ab (ω) ¯ −i = −∞ 2π 0 +∞ d ω¯ C˜ ab (ω) ¯ = . 2π z − ω ¯ −∞
(1.3.10)
38
Statistical physics of liquids
The above relation is further analyzed for the autocorrelation function using the standard identity 1 1 =P ∓ iπ δ(ω − ω), ¯ (1.3.11) lim →0 ω ± i − ω ¯ ω − ω¯ where P indicates the principal value. In this case, i.e., a ≡ b and the Fourier transform C˜ aa (ω) is real, we obtain the following useful relations between the Fourier and Laplace transforms of the correlation function: C˜ aa (ω) = −2Caa (ω + i),
(ω¯ + i) d ω¯ Caa Caa (ω + i) = − , π ω − ω¯
(1.3.12) (1.3.13)
for → 0. 1.3.1 The density correlation function For the fluid generally we define for a microscopic variable ψˆ a (r, t), corresponding to the microscopic property aα (t) for the αth particle at position rα (t), ψˆ a (r, t) =
N
aα δ(r − rα (t)).
(1.3.14)
α=1
In Table 1.2 we list examples of a few types of experiments with the corresponding dynamic variable aα whose time correlation is measured using the respective method. Our discussion here will primarily involve the microscopic variables of mass density and momentum density, defined, respectively, as mδ(r − rα (t)), (1.3.15) ρ(r, ˆ t) = α
gˆ (r, t) =
pα δ(r − rα (t)).
(1.3.16)
α
We put a hat on the slow variable to indicate the dependence on the phase-space coordinates of this variable. Note that the mass density ρ(r, ˆ t) is similar to the single-particle number density n(r, ˆ t). For the one-component system in fact we have ρˆ = m n. ˆ We show in Appendix A5.1 that the mass and momentum densities are related by the continuity equation ∂ ρˆ + ∇ · gˆ = 0. ∂t
(1.3.17)
The most important correlation function for our purpose is that of the density fluctuations, denoted by δ ρ(r, ˆ t) = ρ(r, ˆ t) − ρ0 ,
(1.3.18)
1.3 Time correlation functions
39
Table 1.2 Examples of correlation functions of a few dynamic variables and the corresponding experiments which measure them. implies a sum over the particle index α = 1, . . . , N while implies a sum over both particle indices α and β, with α = β. Dynamic variable
Correlation function
v: velocity of a tagged particle
v(t) · v(0)
5 + ik · (r (t)−r (0)) , α α e 5 + ik · (r (t)−r (0)) , α β e (1/N )
ij
Polarizability tensor να ii i να
Rotational diffusion
(1/N )
rα (t): position of the αth particle at t
5
Translational diffusion
i (t) j (0)
: angular velocity about the center of mass n(r, t): density
Trace ναT =
Experiment
(1/N ) (1/N )
Neutron scattering
, 5+ T να (0)ναT (t)eik · (rα (t)−rα (0))
, 5 + x y xy να (0)να (t)eik · (rα (t)−rβ (0))
Polarized Brillouin scattering Depolarized Brillouin scattering
with ρ0 = ρ ˆ being the average density. The average densities ρ0 = mn 0 are constants in the isotropic liquid state. The density–density correlation function involving fluctuations at two different space and time points is defined as ˆ t)δ n(r ˆ , 0). G nn (|r − r |, t) = V δ n(r,
(1.3.19)
It is often more convenient to describe the density–density correlation function of the Fourier component of the density variable, n(k, ˆ t) =
1 V
dr eik · r n(r, ˆ t) = V −1
eik · rα (t) .
(1.3.20)
α
The Fourier-transformed correlation function is then defined as F(k, t) =
1 δ n(k, ˆ t)δ n(−k, ˆ 0), N
(1.3.21)
where V is the volume. Using the above definition of the density fluctuations, we obtain that the correlation function F(k, t) can be written in two separate parts involving
40
Statistical physics of liquids
incoherent and coherent parts as follows: Fd (k, t) =
N 1 + ik · (rα (t)−rβ (0)) , e , N
(1.3.22)
α,β=1
N 1 ik · (rα (t)−rα (0)) e , Fs (k, t) = N
(1.3.23)
α=1
where the prime indicates that α = β in the sum. The first part is often called the distinct part of density correlation functions while the second part is referred to as the self part of the correlation function or the van Hove correlation function. The spectral quantity for the density–density correlation function S(k, ω), S(k, ω) =
1 2π
+∞
−∞
F(k, t)eiωt dt,
(1.3.24)
is called the dynamic structure factor and is measurable in inelastic light-, X-ray-, and neutron-scattering experiments (Mezei, 1991). The correlation function F(k, t = 0) for density fluctuations at the same time refers to the structural or thermodynamic property of the liquid. The static correlation function F(k, t = 0) = n 0 S(k), where S(k) is the static structure factor defined in eqn. (1.2.79). In the theories considered in the subsequent chapters in this book, the implicit effect of the interaction potential for the fluid particles on the dynamic properties will always be considered in terms of the corresponding static structure factor and higher-order static correlations. Another important correlation function for our discussion is the current–current correlation function. The current gˆ (x, t) is a vector field and hence, for an isotropic system, the corresponding correlation function is divided into a longitudinal part and a transverse part. The spatial Fourier transform of the correlation function G i j (q, t) between gi (x, t) and gi (x , 0) for the isotropic fluid is expressed as G i j (k, t) = kˆi kˆ j G L (k, t) + (δi j − kˆi kˆ j )G T (k, t),
(1.3.25)
with subscripts L and T referring to the longitudinal and transverse parts, respectively. If we choose both indices i and j of coordinates to be along the direction of the vector k then kˆi = kˆ j = 1 and G i j = G L . If both i and j are in a direction transverse to k then G i j = G T . On the other hand, if i( j) is along k and j (i) transverse to k, then G i j = 0. From the continuity equation (1.3.17) and the definitions (1.3.19) and (1.3.25) it follows directly that ω2 G nn (k, ω) = k 2 G L (k, ω),
(1.3.26)
linking the two-sided Fourier transforms of the density and (longitudinal) current autocorrelation functions.
1.3 Time correlation functions
41
1.3.2 The self-correlation function The dynamics of a single particle moving in a surrounding fluid can be described in terms of the density of the single particle nˆ s (r, t) defined as the tagged particle (α) density, nˆ s (r, t) = δ(r − rα (t)).
(1.3.27)
The average nˆ s of the tagged particle density is obtained as n s (r, t) =
1 V
(1.3.28)
and goes to zero in the thermodynamic limit V → ∞. The correlation of the taggedparticle density at two different times defines the van Hove correlation function, G s (|r − r |, t) = V δ nˆ s (r, t)δ nˆ s (r , 0) = V δ(r − rα (t))δ(r − rα (0)) − V −1 .
(1.3.29)
The tagged-particle density nˆ s (r, t) is δ(r − rα (t)), with rα (t) denoting the position of the tagged particle at time t. In an isotropic fluid G s (r, t) is a function of r only. The Fourier transform of G s is the self-part of the density correlation function defined above in eqn. (1.3.23). From eqn. (1.3.29) G s (r, t) can be interpreted as the probability per unit volume of finding a particle at a distance r at a given time t, given that it was at the origin r = 0 at t = 0. Note that, using eqn. (1.3.28), it follows from the definition of G s (r, t) that G s (r, 0) = δ(r )
and
dr G s (r, t) = 1.
(1.3.30)
Equation (1.3.30) is a statement of the conservation of probability. In an isotropic fluid G s is a function of r only and 4πr 2 G s (r, t) represents the probability of finding a particle at r at time t given that it was at the origin at time t = 0. In Fig. 1.7 we show schematically how this probability distribution spreads out with the passage of time. The frequency transform Ss (k, ω) of G s is defined, with Fs (k, t) = Ss (k, ω) =
+∞
−∞ +∞ −∞
dr eik · r G s (r, t),
(1.3.31)
dt eiωt Fs (k, t).
(1.3.32)
The tagged-particle correlation is obtained directly from the measurement of Ss (k, ω) in neutron-scattering experiments (Fig. 1.8). The coherent component of the scattered intensity is proportional to the self part of the correlation function and from it one directly obtains the information on the single-particle dynamics.
42
Statistical physics of liquids
Fig. 1.7 A schematic representation of how G s (r, t) spreads out with time.
¯ Fig. 1.8 Dependence of the correlation function S(Q, E) for coherent (solid) and incoherent (dashed) neutron-scattering analysis of argon at the frequency E (in meV) and the wave-number c American Physical Society. Q (in the Å−1 ) plane. From Sköld et al. (1972).
The free-particle limit It is straightforward to demonstrate that the function G s (r, t) and hence its Fourier transform Fs (k, t) have a Gaussian distribution in the t → 0 limit. In the very-short-time regime, the particle moves as a free one, and G s (r, t) varies spatially as a narrow Gaussian distribution function. In the free-particle limit it is straightforward to use the above definition in
1.3 Time correlation functions
43
terms of probability to compute
p dp φMB ( p)δ r − t m 1 1 r 2 = , 3/2 exp − 2 v t 0 2π v 2 t 2
G s (r, t) =
(1.3.33)
0
where φMB is the Maxwellian momentum distribution. For the free particle motion the particle with momentum p moves a distance r = pt/m. The corresponding Fourier transform Fs (k, t) and the frequency transform Ss (k, ω) are obtained as the following Gaussian functions:
1 Fs (k, t) = exp − (kv0 t)2 , 2 √ 2π 1 ω 2 Ss (k, ω) = exp − . (1.3.34) kv0 2 kv0 The behavior predicted by (1.3.34) is seen in Fig. 1.8. Therefore in the short-time or freeparticle limit the correlation functions remain Gaussian. The time correlation of the velocities of a tagged particle at two different times plays an important role in the description of the single-particle dynamics in a fluid. This is defined in three dimensions as 1 (1.3.35) ϕv (t) = v(t) · v(0). 3 For short times once again we can expand v(t) at t = 0 and compute the above correlation function. The first-order term goes to zero on using eqn. (1.3.7), and the leading-order contribution reads
t 2 20 2 + ··· , (1.3.36) ϕv (t) = v0 1 − 2 where v02 = kB T /m is the thermal velocity of a particle, 1 v(0) · v(0). 3 The quantity 0 has the dimension of frequency and is obtained as v02 =
20 =
1 1 {m v˙ } · {m v˙ } = F · F, 3mkB T 3mkB T
(1.3.37)
(1.3.38)
where F is the force exerted on the particle α by its neighbors. For a system in which the interactions between the particles are described by the pairwise additive potential v(12), we show in Appendix A1.2 by evaluating the force–force correlation function that 0 can be expressed in terms of the pair correlation function g(r ) by the following relation: n0 20 = (1.3.39) ∇ 2 v(r )g(r )dr. 3m
44
Statistical physics of liquids
0 is termed the Einstein frequency, since for short times it represents the frequency of vibration of the tagged particle undergoing small oscillations in the potential well produced by its neighbors. Note that the above analysis holds only for continuous potentials. For hard-sphere systems such an analysis does not hold. In this case the linear-order term contributes, and it has been shown (Lebowitz et al., 1969) that the autocorrelation function has the exponentially decaying form ϕv (t) = v02 [1 − 0 t + · · ·] ≈ e−0 t ,
(1.3.40)
where the frequency 0 = 2/(3ta ), with ta being the Boltzmann collision time, given by 4πn 0 σ 2 . ta−1 = √ βmπ
(1.3.41)
For higher densities the structure of ta is replaced by the corresponding Enskog time tE = ta /g(σ ). The decay of the tagged-particle correlation for a dense hard-sphere system is therefore exponential and is given by
2t 2 . (1.3.42) ϕv (t) = v0 exp − 3tE The exponential decay of ϕv (t) is a result of the completely random nature of uncorrelated binary collisions of the particles. Cooperative effects coming from longer length scales cause nonexponential or power-law decays in the correlation functions. We discuss such contributions to correlation functions in subsequent chapters. Long-time dynamics From the general definition (1.3.23) of the tagged-particle correlation (since all the particles are identical) we obtain + , 1 2 (1.3.43) Fs (k, t) = eik · (rα (t)−rα (0)) = eikd(t) , where d(t) = kˆ · (rα (t) − rα (0)), with kˆ being the unit vector in the direction of the wave vector. The terms with odd powers of k vanish in the above expansion, meaning that the equilibrium correlation function Fs (k, t) for the isotropic fluid is a function of |k| only, Fs (k, t) = 1 −
k2 2 k4 d (t) + d 4 (t) + · · ·. 2! 4!
(1.3.44)
In order to organize the Gaussian and non-Gaussian parts of Fs (k, t), we write the above expansion in terms of time-dependent functions n (t), for n = 1, 2, . . . (Rahman et al., 1962), (1.3.45) Fs (k, t) = exp −k 2 1 (t) + k 4 2 (t) − k 6 3 (t) + · · · .
1.3 Time correlation functions
45
On comparing coefficients of the different powers of k in eqns. (1.3.44) and (1.3.45), we obtain for the different n (t) 1 2 d (t), 2! 1 4 2 d (t) − 3d 2 (t) , 2 (t) = 4! 1 6 3 d (t) − 15d 4 (t)d 2 (t) + 30d 2 (t) . 3 (t) = 6! 1 (t) =
(1.3.46) (1.3.47) (1.3.48)
The Gaussian part of Fs (k, t) is determined by 1 (t), while the n for n ≥ 2 represent the non-Gaussian part. We demonstrate in the following that the function 1 (t) can be expressed in terms of the two-point current correlation function ϕv (t). In order to see the link between the tagged-particle correlations and the velocity correlations, we express the displacement of the tagged particle as an integral over its velocity. Thus, if we denote by u(t) the component of the velocity v of the tagged particle α in the direction of k, d(t) is obtained in terms of u as t d(t) = kˆ · (rα (t) − rα (0)) = d t¯ u(t). (1.3.49) 0
Since Fs (k, t) = exp(ikd(t)), we obtain the exponential on the RHS as a formal solution of the equation ∂ ikd(t) = iku(t)eikd(t) e ∂t
(1.3.50)
in the following form by iteration: t dt u(t )eikd(t ) eikd(t) = 1 + ik 0 t t = 1 + ik dt1 u(t1 ) + (ik)2 dt1 u(t1 ) 0
t1
dt2 u(t2 ) + · · ·.
(1.3.51)
0
0
On taking an average of the above equation, since in the isotropic fluid in equilibrium on average odd powers of u vanish, we obtain the tagged-particle correlation in terms of the expansion Fs (k, t) =
∞ n=0
(−k 2 )
n
t
dt1 0
0
t
dt2 . . .
t
dt2n u(t1 )u(t2 ) . . . u(t2n ). (1.3.52)
0
Now straightforward comparison of powers of k 2 with the definition (1.3.45) shows that t1 t dt1 dt2 u(t1 )u(t2 ), (1.3.53) 1 (t) = 0 0 t1 t2 t 1 dt1 dt2 dt3 u(t1 )u(t2 )u(t3 )u(t4 ) − 12 (t), (1.3.54) 2 (t) = 2 0 0 0
46
Statistical physics of liquids
and so on. Using the property of time translational invariance of the equilibrium correlation functions of u, the integral expression for 1 (t) is expressed in terms of the two-point velocity correlation functions ϕv (t1 − t2 ) as follows: t1 t1 t t 1 (t) = dt1 dt2 u(t1 )u(t2 ) = dt1 ds ϕv (s) 0 0 0 0 t t t t dt1 ds ϕv (s) − dt1 ds ϕv (s) = 0
0
t
=t 0
ds ϕv (s) −
0
0
t
t1
sϕv (s)ds,
(1.3.55)
where in reaching the final result we integrated the second term on the RHS by parts. Therefore, if the non-Gaussian effects are ignored, the tagged-particle correlation is entirely determined by ϕv (t). For an isotropic liquid d 2 (t) = 13 r 2 (t) in three dimensions, giving the result t r 2 (t) = 6t ϕv (s)ds, (1.3.56) 0
where we have ignored the contribution from the second term on the RHS of eqn. (1.3.55). The latter is a constant when the velocity correlation function decays in an exponential manner. However, it has been observed from the computer molecular-dynamic simulations (Alder and Wainwright, 1967, 1970) of fluids that the velocity autocorrelation ϕv (t) has a long-time tail decaying as t −3/2 in three dimensions. This long-time tail in ϕv (s) makes the second integral grow as t 1/2 . This makes the long-time (t → ∞), long-distance (k → 0) behavior of Fs (k, t) very different from the simple exponential prediction. However, the long-time decay of the tagged-particle correlation is still well behaved since we consider the limit k → 0 and t → ∞ such that k 2 t remains finite. The factor k 2 1 (t) on the RHS of eqn. (1.3.45) is finite in this limit. Therefore, for a system in which the dynamics is Gaussian, all the n (t) for n ≥ 2 in the exponent on the RHS of (1.3.45) vanish and the tagged-particle correlation is obtained in the form
t 2 2 Fs (k, t) = exp −k t1 (t) = exp −k t ϕv (s)ds . (1.3.57) 0
Hence in the Gaussian limit Fs (k, t) is determined in terms of the velocity correlation function ϕv (t) only. Non-Gaussian effects The non-Gaussian effect in the single-particle dynamics is related to higher (than-two-point) correlation functions in the fluid and was first studied for moleculardynamics simulations (Rahman, 1964) of argon. The expansion (1.3.45) is reorganized in terms of parameters αn (t) for n = 1, 2, 3, . . . for the isotropic system as (Nijboer and Rahman, 1966) 3k (t) 2k (t) −k (t) (1.3.58) α2 (t) − {α3 (t) − 3α2 (t)} . . . , 1+ Fs (k, t) = e 2! 3!
1.3 Time correlation functions
47
Fig. 1.9 Non-Gaussian parameters αn (t) for n = 2, 3, and 4 vs. time t (in units of 10−12 s) obtained from results of molecular-dynamic simulations of argon. From Rahman (1964).
where we have defined k (t) = k 2 1 (t). The αn are obtained as r 2n (t) n − 1, cn r 2 (t) 1 · 3 · 5 · · · · · (2n + 1) cn = . 3n
αn (t) =
(1.3.59) (1.3.60)
In particular, the above definition gives α1 (t) = 1 and the first non-Gaussian parameter α2 (t) as 1 2 3 r 4 (t) α2 (t) = 1 (1.3.61) 2 − 1. 5 r 2 (t) 2 In Fig. 1.9 the so-called non-Gaussian parameters αn (t) for n = 2, 3, and 4 are shown, with all quantities peaking at an intermediate time. The non-Gaussian parts are computed from molecular-dynamic simulation of argon (Rahman, 1964).
1.3.3 The linear response function An important application of the equilibrium correlation functions lies in the formulation of a linear response to an external perturbation. Let us consider the case in which
48
Statistical physics of liquids
a time-dependent external field h a (r, t) couples to the dynamic variable a(r). ˆ The Hamiltonian of the system in the presence of the external field is obtained as a sum of two parts, H = H0 + H (t), where H0 is the unperturbed system and H is the perturbation, H (t) = − a(r)h ˆ a (r, t)dr.
(1.3.62)
(1.3.63)
ˆ The fluctuation in the average value of a dynamic variable b(x) is obtained by taking a (N ) phase-space average with respect to the distribution function f (t). The time evolution of the phase-space probability density f (N ) (t) for the perturbed density is determined from the Liouville equation (1.1.22). In order to keep the notation simple, we drop the dependence of f (N ) on the phase-space variables. We define the fluctuation from the equilibrium f (N ) as (N ) f (N ) (t) = f eq + f (N ) (t),
(1.3.64)
(N ) where f eq is the equilibrium distribution which satisfies (N ) # $ ∂ f eq (N ) (N ) = H0 , f eq = −iL0 f eq = 0. (1.3.65) ∂t The symbol { } here denotes the Poisson brackets between the corresponding dynamic variables and L0 is the Liouville operator with the unperturbed Hamiltonian H0 . From the Liouville equation the time evolution of f (N ) is obtained as
∂ f (N ) = −iL f (N ) = {H, f (N ) } ∂t = {H0 , f (N ) } + {H , f (N ) } # $ (N ) (N ) = −iL0 f − dr a(r ˆ ), f eq h a (r , t).
(1.3.66)
(N ) The solution of the above equation with the boundary condition f (N ) (−∞) = f eq is t # $ (N ) f (N ) (t) = − dt dr e−i(t−t )L0 a(r (1.3.67) ˆ ), f eq h a (r , t ). −∞
ˆ The fluctuation in a dynamic variable b(r) at time t is obtained from the corresponding (N ) phase-space average with f (, t) by integrating over all the 6N phase-space variables, collectively denoted as , ˆ t) = d b(r) ˆ b(r, f (N ) (, t) t # $ (N ) ˆ dt dr d e−i(t−t )L0 a(r ˆ ), f eq b(r)h =− a (r , t ) ≡
−∞ +∞
−∞
dt
dr Rba (r − r , t − t )h a (r , t ),
(1.3.68)
1.3 Time correlation functions
49
where Rba (r − r , t − t ) is the linear response function in the liquid with time and spatial translational invariance. From the above expression the response function is obtained as # $ (N ) ˆ Rba (r − r , t − t ) = −(t − t ) d a(r ˆ , t ), f eq b(r, t), (1.3.69) where (t) is the Heaviside step function, which is equal to 1 and 0 for x < 0 and x > 0, respectively. An important result of equilibrium statistical mechanics is a relation between the linearresponse function and correlation functions that is termed the fluctuation–dissipation theorem (FDT). It follows directly then, using the definition of Poisson brackets, that the response function can be expressed in a more symmetric form in terms of the equilibrium average of the Poisson bracket, ˆ t), a(r ˆ , t )}0 , Rba (r − r , t − t ) = −(t − t ){b(r,
(1.3.70)
where the subscript 0 on the angular bracket implies averaging with respect to the unper(N ) turbed Hamiltonian H0 . Using the canonical distribution function f eq ∼ exp(−β H0 ), it can be shown directly from (1.3.69) that $ # ˆ , t ) (N ) (N ) ∂ a(r . (1.3.71) = −β f eq a(r ˆ , t ), f eq ∂t Using the above result in eqn. (1.3.69) gives the following relation between the correlation function and the corresponding response function: Rba (t − t ) = (t − t )
1 ∂Cba , kB T ∂t
(1.3.72)
where Cba is the correlation function averaged over the equilibrium distribution. In equilibrium we assume that time translational invariance holds for the correlation function, i.e., Cba (t, t ) ≡ Cba (t − t ). The relation (1.3.72) is the fluctuation–dissipation theorem (FDT). We have dropped the dependence on spatial coordinates in eqn. (1.3.72) for the sake of simplicity. The Laplace transform (Abramowitz and Stegun, 1965) of the R(z) response function is defined as ∞ dt ei zt Rba (t), Im(z) > 0. (1.3.73) Rba (z) = −i 0
Since aˆ and bˆ are both real functions, it follows directly that for the real and imaginary parts of the response function R(z), denoted by R and R , respectively, one has the following symmetry properties: (ω) = Rba (−ω), Rba
(1.3.74)
(ω) Rba
(1.3.75)
=
−Rba (−ω).
Equations (1.3.72)–(1.3.74) hold both for real space and for the corresponding Fouriertransformed quantities, and it is not explicitly mentioned which for simplicity.
50
Statistical physics of liquids
1.4 Brownian motion In the earlier sections our discussion of the dynamic correlation functions involved dealing with the phase-space variables in the 6N -dimensional space at the microscopic level. The kinetic theory of many-particle systems evolving under Liouville dynamics provides the basic tool for calculating the correlation functions in this case. Computer moleculardynamics simulations dealing with the microscopic coordinates of a small number of particles also constitute another useful tool for theoretically obtaining the correlation functions. An alternative approach to these methods is to study the dynamics in terms of a chosen set of dynamic variables. The basic criterion involved in this method is separating the dynamics into a slow part and a fast part. The choice of the set of variables is motivated in order to exploit the widely varying time scales in the dynamics. The correlations of the slow modes are then computed by treating the rest of the degrees of freedom as noise, this noise being completely random on the time scale of the slow modes. A classic example of the treatment of dynamics with stochastic noise is the Brownian motion which we will introduce in the following. The theory of Brownian motion discussed here was developed by Einstein (1905), Smoluchowski (1906), Planck (1917), and others (Chandrasekhar, 1943). It constitutes an approach to the dynamics of a many-particle system that is an alternative to the Liouvillian or Newtonian dynamics. In formulating the dynamics of a fluid we will largely follow a generalization of such a scheme in the subsequent chapters of this book.
1.4.1 The Langevin equation Small grains of pollen immersed in a fluid undergo a kind of perpetual irregular motion. This is termed Brownian motion after the name of the botanist Robert Brown, who first observed this phenomenon in 1827. The irregular motion is due to the incessant random collisions of the molecules of the surrounding fluid with the pollen grain or the so-called Brownian particle. The mass of this particle is much higher than that of a colliding particle of the surrounding fluid. The equation of motion of the Brownian particle is obtained in terms of a Langevin equation involving a stochastic part distinct from the completely deterministic Newtonian dynamics. This formulation of the problem is based on the assumption that the motion of the Brownian particle is controlled by forces varying on very different time scales and hence the equation of motion consists of a slow part and a fast part. The latter is termed noise, and calculation of the correlations of dynamic variables now implies treating different realizations of the noise. The equation of motion of a heavy Brownian particle of mass m moving in a sea of particles is written in the following form: dvi = −ζ vi (t) + f i (t), dt
(1.4.1)
1.4 Brownian motion
51
where we have chosen the mass m of the Brownian particle as unity to keep the algebra simple. Here i denotes the corresponding Cartesian component. The first term on the RHS represents a frictional drag term on the Brownian particle proportional to the velocity v. ζ is a controlling kinetic coefficient, which in this case is taken to be the same for all components i for simplicity. The second term f i (t), on the other hand, denotes the effect of all the random kicks the big particle gets from the smaller particles in the surrounding fluid. The above equation is the simplest form of the Langevin equation written in one dimension. To solve eqn. (1.4.1) we multiply it by the factor exp(ζ t), to write d [vi (t)eζ t ] = eζ t f i (t). dt It is straightforward to integrate from t0 to time t to obtain t dτ eζ τ f i (τ ), vi (t)eζ t = vi0 eζ t0 +
(1.4.2)
(1.4.3)
t0
where vi (t0 ) = vi0 . The ith component of the velocity of the heavy particle is therefore obtained as t 0 −ζ (t−t0 ) + dτ f i (τ )e−ζ (t−τ ) . (1.4.4) vi (t) = vi e t0
The first term on the RHS of eqn. (1.4.4) gives the contribution from the initial value of v0 decaying exponentially, while the second term gives the integrated effect from the force f i (τ ) acting over this time interval. To make further progress, we need to prescribe the nature of the random force f i (t). Since it keeps pushing the big particle at random from all directions, it is plausible to assume that, for all times t, f i (t) = 0.
(1.4.5)
Using this result, we obtain that the average velocity at time t simply follows from the exponential decay from the initial value, since the average noise is zero: + , vi (t) = vi0 e−ζ (t−t0 ) .
(1.4.6)
In thermal equilibrium vi0 = 0 and hence vi (t) remains zero at all times. To compute the correlation of the velocity at different times, we need to know how the noise values f i (t) at different times are correlated with each other. If the system is in equilibrium, the correlation between the random forces at times t and t depends only on the difference of the two times, i.e., time translational invariance holds. For the isotropic system we define this correlation in terms of the time-dependent function D¯ 0 (t − t ), f i (t) f j (t ) = δi j D¯ 0 (t − t ).
(1.4.7)
In Appendix A1.3 we consider some general properties of the function D¯ 0 (t), and show ¯ that it is symmetric around t = 0. It remains at all times bounded between limits + D(0) ¯ and − D(0), decaying to zero in the long-time limit. As pointed out above, in the Langevin
52
Statistical physics of liquids
description of the dynamics the velocity v of the massive Brownian particle is treated as a slow variable and the force f (t) changes randomly over time scales much shorter than the time scale of variation of v(t). As a simplification we will consider the extreme case in which the correlation of the noise is defined in terms of a delta function, f i (t) f j (t ) = δi j D¯ 0 δ(t − t ),
(1.4.8)
giving what is termed white noise. Furthermore, since the physical process of driving the Brownian particle with the noise must follow causality, i.e., f i (t) has no influence on vi (t ), where t > t , we have f i (t)v j (t ) = 0.
(1.4.9)
The correlation of the velocities at two different times t and t is obtained from the general solution given by (1.4.4), + , (1.4.10) Ci j (t, t ) = vi (t)v j (t ) = vi0 v 0j e−ζ (t+t −2t0 ) + Ii j , where the integral Ii j is obtained from the relation t t dτ dτ e−ζ (t−τ ) e−ζ (t −τ ) f i (τ ) f j (τ ). Ii j =
(1.4.11)
t0
t0
On the RHS of eqn. (1.4.10) a cross term is set equal to zero using the causality relation (1.4.9). Now, with the correlation of the noise as defined above in the diagonal form eqn. (1.4.8), the velocity correlation function at two different times is obtained. For an isotropic system both terms on the RHS of eqn. (1.4.11) are diagonal, reducing to Ci j (t, t ) ≡ δi j C(t, t ) and Ii j = δi j IB . We obtain for C(t, t ) the result
C(t, t ) = e−ζ (t+t −2t0 ) C(t0 , t0 ) + IB , where we define the integral IB as t ¯ IB = D 0 dτ t0
t
dτ e−ζ (t−τ ) e−ζ (t −τ ) δ(τ − τ ).
(1.4.12)
(1.4.13)
t0
The last integral is evaluated in Appendix A1.3 to obtain the following result for the velocity correlation function:
D¯ 0 −ζ |t−t | D¯ 0 C(t, t ) = + e−ζ (t+t −2t0 ) C(t0 , t0 ) − e . (1.4.14) 2ζ 2ζ The equal-time correlation C(t, t) is obtained by setting t = t :
D¯ 0 D¯ 0 C(t, t) = + e−2ζ (t−t0 ) C(t0 , t0 ) − . 2ζ 2ζ
(1.4.15)
The above relation implies that if the system reaches equilibrium it continues to remain at equilibrium for all times t unless disturbed. The equal-time correlation C(t, t) should then
1.4 Brownian motion
53
remain fixed for all t as given by eqn. (1.4.15) at C(t0 , t0 ) =
D¯ 0 . 2ζ
(1.4.16)
If the Brownian particle is in equilibrium in the liquid at temperature T at time t0 , then the initial distribution for the velocities is Maxwell–Boltzmann, giving the equal-time correlation as C(t0 , t0 ) = kB T,
(1.4.17)
where we have taken the mass m for the particle to be unity as above. The correlation C(t, t) is then obtained from eqn. (1.4.14) as
D¯ 0 D¯ 0 −2ζ (t−t0 ) +e . (1.4.18) kB T − C(t, t) = 2ζ 2ζ For the noise correlation (1.4.7), the corresponding velocity correlation function C(t, t ) for the Brownian particle follows from eqn. (1.4.14). In the equilibrium fluid at temperature T we obtain the correlation function C(t, t ) in the time translational invariant form,
C(t, t ) ≡ C(t − t ) = kB T e−ζ |t−t | .
(1.4.19)
Finally, according to the condition (1.4.17), we have, for the Brownian particle moving in the fluid in equilibrium at temperature T , D¯ 0 = 2ζ C(t0 , t0 ) = 2ζ kB T.
(1.4.20)
The noise correlation as defined in eqn. (1.4.7) is therefore given by f i (t) f j (t ) = 2kB T ζ δ(t − t )δi j .
(1.4.21)
1.4.2 The Stokes–Einstein relation Using the result for the velocity correlation function for the Brownian particles, straightforward integration gives the displacement xi (t) for a particle after time t. Since vi (t) = d xi /dt, we can integrate the above result to compute the root-mean-square displacement of the particle. We rewrite eqn. (1.4.19) as . d d (1.4.22) xi (t) xi (t ) = kB T e−ζ |t−t | . dt dt Note that in the above expression and in what follows below the repeated index i is not summed over. The above equation is integrated to obtain the following results for the correlation between the displacements at times t and t : t kB T t dτ dτ e−ζ (τ −τ ) ≡ IB , (1.4.23) xi (t)xi (t ) = ζ t0 t0
54
Statistical physics of liquids
where we have denoted the displacement at time t as xi (t) = xi (t) − xi (t0 ). We evaluate the integral IB in Appendix A1.3 to obtain xi (t)xi (t ) = kB T ζ −1 t + t − |t − t | − 2t0 $
# + ζ −1 e−ζ (t−t0 ) + e−ζ (t −t0 ) − e−ζ |t −t| − 1 . (1.4.24) For the case t = t the result for the mean-square displacement is xi2 (t) = 2kB T ζ −1 t − t0 + ζ −1 {e−ζ (t−t0 ) − 1} .
(1.4.25)
For short times relative to the characteristic time ζ −1 , i.e., ζ (t − t0 ) 1, we can expand the exponential on the RHS and obtain that the root-mean-square displacement is directly proportional to the time (t − t0 ), #+ ,$1/2 = v0 (t − t0 ), (1.4.26) [xi (t) − xi (t0 )]2 where v02 = kB T is the root-mean-square average velocity of the Brownian particle (its mass is taken as unity). This is free-particle behavior. On the other hand, for long times relative to the characteristic time ζ −1 , i.e., ζ (t − t0 ) 1, we obtain , + (1.4.27) [xi (t) − xi (t0 )]2 = 2kB T ζ −1 (t − t0 ) ≡ 2 D¯ 0 (t − t0 ), showing that the mean-square displacement grows linearly with time. This is termed the Einstein relation, and the constant of proportionality is defined as the diffusion coefficient D¯ 0 . From eqn. (1.4.27) we obtain a relation between the diffusion coefficient D¯ 0 and the friction coefficient ζ , namely D¯ 0 = kB T ζ −1 . In fact, the friction coefficient ζ is a property related to the resistance to the motion of the Brownian particle from the surrounding liquid. If the Brownian particle has a radius a and the surrounding fluid has shear viscosity η, then the frictional drag on the sphere is given by Stokes’ law, i.e., ζ = 0.6πaη. The diffusion coefficient D¯ 0 for the Brownian particle is then inversely proportional to the viscosity of the surrounding medium according to what is termed the Stokes–Einstein relation (Einstein, 1956): kB T . (1.4.28) D¯ 0 = 0.6πaη It is important to note at this point that the relation (1.4.28) is established here for the motion of a heavy Brownian particle in the surrounding fluid. However, it has also been found that even in the case of a liquid particle moving in a sea of identical particles the Stokes–Einstein relation of an inverse dependence of the diffusion coefficient on the viscosity seems to holds in liquids. We present a phenomenological argument for justifying the Stokes–Einstein relation with respect to the self-diffusion process in Chapter 4, Section 4.1.2, using the free-volume theory.
Appendix to Chapter 1
A1.1 The Gibbs inequality For any variable x we write the identity g ln g − g + 1 = =
g
dx 1 g
d [x ln x − x + 1] dx
d x ln x.
(A1.1.1)
1
If g > 1 then the integrand ln x is positive in the integration range and hence the integral on the RHS is positive definite. If, on the other hand, g < 1, then with a change of variable y = 1/x the integrand reduces to ln y/y 2 , with y as the integration variable changing from y = 1 to y = 1/g > 1. Over this range the integrand is positive and hence the integral is again positive definite. For g = 1 the RHS is zero. Thus we have proved that the quantity g ln g − g + 1 is always positive as long as g is positive.
A1.2 The force–force correlation We obtain here the expression for the force–force correlation function for the αth particle for a fluid interacting through a pairwise-additive continuous interaction potential. This is used in computing the Einstein frequency for a liquid particle as presented in eqn. (1.3.38). In general, if the Hamiltonian is H and the total potential energy is V , the derivatives with respect to the position coordinates rα of the αth particle are equal since the kinetic part of H is only momentum-dependent. We obtain for the force–force correlation for the αth particle F · F = ∇α V · ∇α V = ∇α V · ∇α H .
(A1.2.1)
In order to compute the above average, let us first obtain for the general dynamic variable A the following result: 55
56
Appendix to Chapter 1
∂H dp A · A · ∇α H = dr f eq ∂rα
∂ −1 N N dr dp A · = −β f eq ∂rα
∂ = β −1 dr N dp N · A f eq . ∂rα
N
N
(A1.2.2)
In reaching the last equality we ignored a surface term. In the present case, A ≡ ∇α V and we obtain from eqn. (A1.2.1) F · F = kB T dr N dp N f eq ∇α2 V. (A1.2.3) For a fluid in which the particles are interacting through a two-body potential only the total potential energy V is expressed as a pairwise sum of pair interactions u(r1 , r2 ) ≡ u(12) between particles 1 and 2 and the RHS of eqn. (A1.2.3) is obtained as N dp N f eq ∇α2 V F · F = kB T dr 3 4 exp[−β H ] 2 = kB T dr1 dr2 ∇1 u(12) (N − 1) dr3 . . . dr N ZN kB T dr1 dr2 ∇12 u(12)n 20 g(12) = N # $ (A1.2.4) = n 0 kB T dr ∇ 2 u(r ) g(r ).
A1.3 Brownian motion A1.3.1 The noise correlation In equilibrium the correlation between the noise values f (t) in the Langevin equation at two different times t and t depends only on the difference of the two times, i.e., time translational invariance holds. We define for the isotropic system f i (t) f j (t ) = δi j D¯ 0 (t − t ).
(A1.3.1)
Since the correlation matrix is diagonal, in this case D¯ 0 (t) = f i (t) f i (0) = f i (0) f i (−t) (A1.3.2) = f i (0) f i (−t) = D¯ 0 (−t). 1 2 2 Thus D¯ 0 is a symmetric function. Also D¯ 0 (0) = f i (t) is by definition a positive definite quantity. In fact, D¯ 0 (0) presents a limit for the function D¯ 0 (t): + , + , { f i (t) ± f i (0)}2 = f i2 (t) + f i2 (0) ± 2 f i (t) f i (0) = 2{ D¯ 0 (0) ± D¯ 0 (t)}.
(A1.3.3)
A1.3 Brownian motion
57
Since the LHS of (A1.3.3) is always greater than or equal to zero, we have that D¯ 0 (t) cannot go beyond the limits ± D¯ 0 (0). Finally, for times t large relative to the correlation time for the noise, lim f i (t) f i (0) = f i (t) f i (0) = 0.
(A1.3.4)
t→∞
The correlation of the noise represented by D¯ 0 (t) therefore is a symmetric function bounded between limits ±D(0) and decaying to zero in the long-time limit.
A1.3.2 Evaluation of the integrals We present here the evaluation of some of the integrals involved in the discussion of the Langevin dynamics. First we consider the integral IB defined in eqn. (1.4.13), t t ¯ dτ dτ e−ζ (t−τ ) e−ζ (t −τ ) δ(τ − τ ) IB = D0 t0 t 0 t t dτ e−ζ (t+t −2τ ) + θ (t − t) dτ e−ζ (t+t −2τ ) = D¯ 0 θ (t − t ) t0
= D¯ 0
e−ζ (t+t )
t0
θ (t − t ){e2t − e2t0 } + θ (t − t){e2t − e2t0 }
2ζ D¯ 0 −ζ |t−t | = − e−ζ (t+t −2t0 ) . e 2ζ
(A1.3.5)
Next we consider the integral IB defined in eqn. (1.4.23), t t τ −ζ (τ −τ ) −ζ (τ −τ ) IB = θ (t − t) dτ dτ e + dτ e t0
t0
t
τ
τ
−ζ (τ −τ )
t
−ζ (τ −τ )
+ θ (t − t ) dτ dτ e + dτ e t0 t0 τ ) ( = θ (t − t) 2(t − t0 ) + ζ −1 e−ζ (t−t0 ) + e−ζ (t −t0 ) − e−ζ |t −t| − 1 ) ( + θ (t − t ) 2(t − t0 ) + ζ −1 e−ζ (t−t0 ) + e−ζ (t −t0 ) − e−ζ |t−t | − 1 = 2tθ (t − t) + 2t θ (t − t ) − 2t0 + ζ −1 e−ζ (t−t0 ) + e−ζ (t −t0 ) − e−ζ |t −t| − 1 = t + t − |t − t | − 2t0 + ζ −1 e−ζ (t−t0 ) + e−ζ (t −t0 ) − e−ζ |t −t| − 1 .
(A1.3.6)
2 The freezing transition
In this chapter we discuss a theory for the freezing of an isotropic liquid into a crystalline solid state with long-range order. The transformation is a first-order phase transition with finite latent heat absorbed in the process. We focus on a first-principles orderparameter theory of freezing that originated from the pioneering work of Ramakrishnan and Yussouff (1979). The theory approaches the problem from the liquid side and views the crystal as a liquid with grossly inhomogeneous density characterized by a lower symmetry of the corresponding lattice. This is in contrast to description of the crystal in terms of phonons. The crucial quantity characterizing the physical state of the system in this non-phonon-based model is the average one-particle density function n(x). The thermodynamic description of either phase involves a corresponding extremum principle for a relevant potential. The latter, obtained as a functional of the one-particle density n(x) and the stable thermodynamic state of the system, is identified by the corresponding density required for invoking the extremum principle. This approach, which is generally referred to as the density-functional theory (DFT) of freezing (Haymet, 1987; Baus, 1987, 1990; Singh, 1991; Löwen, 1994; Ashcroft 1996), has been improved over the years and successfully applied for the study of liquid-to-crystal transitions in various simple liquids, the solid–liquid interface, two-dimensional systems, metastable glassy states, etc. For applications of density-functional methods in statistical mechanics there exist general reviews (Evans, 1979; Henderson, 1992). The theoretical formulation presented here also becomes the starting point of consideration of the dynamics of the dense liquid near freezing point and beyond that in the supercooled region. In the present chapter we focus on the treatment of the thermodynamic phase transition from the liquid to the crystalline state using DFT. 2.1 The density-functional approach In the liquid state of matter the constituent particles move randomly so that the timeaveraged density is the same at all points. As the temperature of the liquid is lowered (or equivalently the average density increased), the particles abandon the random spatial arrangement and form the crystalline state having a spatially varying density n(x) according to the symmetry of the corresponding lattice. At zero temperature, minimizing the 58
2.1 The density-functional approach
59
potential energy of the system corresponding to the optimum distribution of particles provides the choice of the relevant lattice structure. Understanding the transformation at finite temperature is more subtle. Here the phase transformation is a result of the competition between the energetic and entropic contributions. Predicting (in a quantitative manner) the thermodynamic condition under which such a transformation occurs in a many-particle system is the primary issue in the theory of freezing. This refers to the temperature of freezing as well as the volume change in the freezing process. Subsequent to some initial attempts (Lindemann, 1910; Born, 1939; Kirkwood and Monroe, 1941; Jancovici, 1965; Brout, 1963, 1966; Thouless and Kosterlitz, 1973) at understanding this very general phenomena of freezing, an order-parameter theory using the equilibrium density as the relevant variable was proposed by Ramakrishnan and Yussouff (1979). This theory adopts an approach that is intermediate between one of purely microscopic origin and a phenomenological description of the liquid near the transition. The thermodynamic properties of the inhomogeneous crystalline state are obtained in terms of the corresponding quantities for the homogeneous liquid state. The thermodynamics of the dense uniform liquid is well understood through integral-equation theories or simulations, which are used as an input in the theory described below. In the density-functional theory for the freezing transition the interaction potential between the liquid particles constitutes the microscopic-level description of the manyparticle system. The basic characteristics of the two-body potential for which a crystalline state appears (under appropriate conditions of density and temperature) include (a) a strongly repulsive part at short range and (b) an attractive part effective at long range. In such a condition the Hamiltonian can be written in a harmonic expansion around the equilibrium sites which correspond to the minimum-potential-energy configuration. The attractive part of the potential seemingly appears to play an important role in stabilizing the solid in a crystalline state in which each of the individual particles is localized around its mean position. However, even for the hard-sphere interaction, the liquid-tocrystal transition occurs, as was shown by computer simulations (Alder and Wainwright, 1962; Hoover and Ree, 1968). In this case the system must be stabilized externally by application of appropriate pressure. The hard-sphere liquid transforms into an f.c.c. solid at the reduced density n 0 σ 3 = 0.96 while the close-packed f.c.c. structure corresponds to a much higher value of n 0 σ 3 = 1.41. There are thus aspects of the freezing transition that go beyond the details of the interaction potential. Indeed, the geometric nature of the freezing transition is apparent in the structural similarity of classical liquids at high densities. Close to the freezing-transition point the static structure factor S(q) (see Chapter 1 for its definition) of many liquids near the first peak (wave vector q → qm ) has approximately the value S(qm ) = 2.85 (Verlet, 1974). This includes computer-simulation results for a Lennard-Jones liquid (Lennard-Jones and Devonshire, 1939) along the melting curve (Hansen and Verlet, 1969), a hard-sphere fluid (Verlet, 1968), and a one-component plasma (Hansen, 1973), and experimental results for materials such as Ar (Page et al., 1969), Na (Greenfield et al., 1971), and Pb (North et al., 1968). The value of S(qm ) lies in the range 2.8–3.1. This is the analogue of the corresponding result in the solid phase, namely the
60
The freezing transition
Lindemann (1910) criterion of melting, i.e., the mean-square displacement u 2 scaled by the square of the interatomic separation is 0.01 at melting (Ross and Alder, 1966). Let us briefly outline the classical density-functional scheme adopted in the following. In the order-parameter theory for the freezing transition presented here the free energy of an inhomogeneous system is uniquely determined from the properties of its homogeneous counterpart. The thermodynamic property is obtained as a functional of the one-particle density n(x). The latter is expressed in terms of a suitable set of parameters, treated as the order parameters of the transition. The liquid and the crystalline states correspond to orderparameter values from which one obtains the appropriate density functions representing the corresponding phase. The thermodynamic properties are computed assuming the system to be in a single phase (either liquid or crystal) and fluctuations of the order parameter are not taken into account. The density-functional approach is mean-field-like in this respect and it ignores the effects of fluctuations which make the crystalline state unstable in lower dimensions. In what follows, we first describe the formulation of an extremum principle for the appropriate thermodynamic potential. This is followed by the construction of the appropriate free-energy functional in terms of the inhomogeneous density function. Testing the optimization of the thermodynamic property then naturally leads to identification of the corresponding equilibrium phase. 2.1.1 A thermodynamic extremum principle The equilibrium state of the many-particle system is identified from the minimization of the appropriate thermodynamic free energy. For uniform systems the minimization is done with respect to the variation of the average density. For example, in the liquid-tovapor transformation both phases are characterized by their respective densities. In the grand-canonical-ensemble description of the uniform system the equilibrium state is characterized by the minimum value of the thermodynamic potential EQ = −P V , where P and V , respectively, denote the thermodynamic pressure and volume (McQuarie, 2000) of the fluid. In the case of the freezing transition, on the other hand, the crystalline state is characterized by a density function n(x) that is space-dependent and hence the corresponding free energy is treated as a functional of the density function. The appropriate free-energy functional required for the identification of the equilibrium state depends on the type of ensemble chosen in the statistical averaging. In the present case of solid–liquid transition it is appropriate to consider the grand-canonical ensemble so that the number of particles in a given volume can change abruptly. We present here, following Haymet and Oxtoby (1986) and Oxtoby (1991), the analysis for the proper extremum principle and the construction of the free-energy functional for the inhomogeneous state. Let us consider a system of N identical particles of mass m and the position and momentum coordinates {rα , pα }, for α = 1, . . . , N . The whole set of phase-space variables is to be denoted as {r N , p N }. Its Hamiltonian is given by HN =
N pα2 + U + Uext ≡ H N0 + Uext , 2m
α=1
(2.1.1)
2.1 The density-functional approach
61
where H N0 is the intrinsic part of the Hamiltonian in which U (r1 , . . . , r N ) is the interaction energy of the N -particle system – as has already been introduced in Chapter 1 in eqn. (1.1.16). Uext is the external field contribution and is expressed in terms of the 5 interaction with a local field obtained from a one-body potential φ, Uext = α φ(rα ). Following the example of equilibrium statistical mechanics, we define the functional [ f ] of f (r N , p N ) as [ f ] = Tr f (H N − μN + β −1 ln f ),
(2.1.2)
where μ is the chemical potential and β = 1/(kB T ) denotes the inverse temperature characterizing the grand-canonical ensemble. The symbol Tr in (2.1.2) refers to the classical trace defined in terms of the integration of the phase-space variables (r N , p N ) (defined in (1.2.3)) as ∞ 1 dr dp . . . dr . . . dp N . (2.1.3) Tr ≡ 1 N 1 h 3N N ! N =0
If we choose f (r N , p N ) to be a trial distribution function representing the probability of the system in the phase-space region (r N , p N ), then, according to the above definition, Tr f (r N , p N ) = 1.
(2.1.4)
The external field contribution Uext , which is a sum of single-particle contributions, is expressed as an integral, N Uext = φ(rα ) = dx n(x)φ(x), ˆ (2.1.5) α=1
in terms of the microscopic one-particle density n. ˆ At the microscopic level, the oneparticle density n(x) ˆ is formally defined as a function of the phase-space variables (r N , p N ), n(x) ˆ =
N
δ(x − rα ).
(2.1.6)
α=1
The average density function corresponding to the distribution function f is then obtained as n(x) = Tr n(x) ˆ f. The density-functional model uses the equilibrium averaged density as the order parameter. The statistical-mechanical formulation of the problem is often conveniently done in terms of the grand-canonical ensemble, implying that the volume of the system remains constant while the number of particles changes. The equilibrium (McQuarie, 2000) distribution function f 0 corresponding to this ensemble is obtained as f 0 = −1 exp[−β(H N − μN )],
(2.1.7)
where (β, μ) is the grand-canonical partition function. Using (2.1.7) for f 0 in the definitions (2.1.2) and (2.1.4) it follows that [ f 0 ] = −β −1 ln (β, μ) = EQ ,
(2.1.8)
62
The freezing transition
where EQ is the equilibrium grand potential for the system. EQ = −P V , where P and V , respectively, denote the pressure and volume of the system in equilibrium. The corresponding density n 0 (x) is obtained by averaging over the grand-canonical ensemble, n 0 (x) = Tr n(x) ˆ f0 =
δ ln , δβu(x)
(2.1.9)
where u(x) = μ − φ(x). For any arbitrary distribution function f satisfying the normalization (2.1.4) the corresponding functional [ f ] is obtained as [ f ] = Tr f (H N − μN + β −1 ln f ) = [ f 0 ] + β −1 Tr[ f ln( f / f 0 )] > [ f 0 ] = EQ .
(2.1.10)
Two points are to be noted with respect to the above results. (a) The second equality in (2.1.10) is obtained using the definition of the grand-canonical ensemble being restricted to those distribution functions f for which the ensemble average of the Hamiltonian H N and the number of particles N remain fixed. (b) The last inequality in (2.1.10) follows from the fact that Tr[ f ln( f / f 0 )] is always positive. To see this, we consider ∞ 1 d f 0 ()[x ln(x)] N! N =0 ∞ 1 d f 0 ()[x ln(x) − x + 1] , = N!
Tr[ f ln( f / f 0 )] =
(2.1.11)
N =0
where we define f ()/ f 0 () ≡ x (say) with d denoting the elementary volume in the 6N -dimensional phase space. The last equality in eqn. (2.1.11) follows since both f () and f 0 () are normalized (see eqn. (2.1.4)), canceling out the last two terms on the RHS. According to the Gibbs inequality (see Appendix A1.1) the quantity within the square brackets on the RHS of eqn. (2.1.11) is always positive and hence the integral is also positive definite. Therefore the functional [ f ] attains its minimum value for the choice f = f 0 . We now consider the following question: can two different external potentials φ and φ correspond to the same equilibrium density n 0 (x)? Let the equilibrium distribution functions with two such external potentials be f 0 and f 0 , respectively. The Hamiltonian corresponding to the external potential φ is denoted as , H N = H N0 + Uext
5
(2.1.12)
= where Uext α φ (rα ). The functional [ f ] now has its minimum value for the corresponding equilibrium distribution f = f 0 . By comparing the values of the functional
2.1 The density-functional approach
corresponding to f = f 0 and f 0 , respectively, we obtain the inequality ( ) EQ = Tr f 0 H N − μN + β −1 ln f 0 ( ) < Tr f 0 H N − μN + β −1 ln f 0 = EQ + dx n 0 (x)[φ (x) − φ(x].
63
(2.1.13)
The inequality in the second line of (2.1.13) follows from the fact that the choice f 0 minimizes the functional [ f ] in this case. To simplify the analysis we assume the chemical potentials both in the primed and in the unprimed cases to be the same μ. The above argument also applies in the reverse order on interchanging the primed and unprimed quantities, i.e., we evaluate the functional [ f ] first for f = f 0 corresponding to the Hamiltonian H N with external potential φ to obtain the inequality (2.1.14) EQ < EQ + dx n 0 (x)[φ(x) − φ (x)]. On adding (2.1.13) and (2.1.14) we obtain the contradictory result EQ + EQ < EQ + EQ . Therefore the original assumption linking φ(x) and φ (x) to the same n 0 (x) is not valid. We have thus proved the important result that the equilibrium density n 0 (x) is uniquely determined by the external potential φ(x). The inverse, i.e., a given n 0 (x) uniquely determining the corresponding field φ(x), also holds in the DFT description for the thermodynamic state. This is implied from the finite-temperature generalization (Mermin, 1965) of the ground-state theorem (Hohenberg and Kohn, 1964). On the other hand, from (2.1.8) it follows that for a given system characterized by H N0 , i.e., by the corresponding interaction U (as defined in (2.1.1), the equilibrium distribution function f 0 is entirely determined by the external potential φ(x). On combining these two results we obtain that the equilibrium distribution function f 0 is uniquely determined by the one-particle density n 0 (x). Using the unique correspondence between f 0 and n 0 , a functional φ of the one-particle density n(x) for the system in an external potential φ is obtained as φ [n] = [ f ] ≡ Tr f (H N − μN + β −1 ln f ).
(2.1.15)
In terms of φ [n] we further define a functional F[n(x)], φ [n] = F[n] + dx φ(x)n(x) − μ dx n(x) = F[n] − dx n(x)u(x),
(2.1.16)
where u(x) is as defined above with eqn. (2.1.9). It follows directly from the definition (2.1.2) for [ f ] that F[n] is obtained from the corresponding distribution function f as ) ( (2.1.17) F[n(x)] = Tr f HN0 + β −1 ln f .
64
The freezing transition
For the equilibrium distribution f = f 0 the corresponding one-particle density is n 0 (x), and we obtain for the value of φ [n 0 ] φ [n 0 ] ≡ [ f 0 ] = EQ .
(2.1.18)
For any other f = f 0 since [ f ] is higher, i.e., [ f ] > [ f 0 ]. If n(x) is the one-particle density corresponding to f , we must have then φ [n] > φ [n 0 ]. Thus we reach the important result that the equilibrium density n 0 (x) minimizes the functional φ [n] and its value at the minimum is equal to the equilibrium grand potential. This result is conveniently expressed in terms of the functional variational principle,
δφ [n] = 0. (2.1.19) δn(x) n(x)=n 0 (x) Note that, if we were considering the canonical ensemble, then it would follow in an exactly similar manner that the corresponding functional (of density) to be minimized would be the one involving the first two terms on the RHS of (2.1.16). Fφ [n] = F[n] + dx n(x)φ(x). (2.1.20) For the equilibrium density n 0 (x) the minimum value of this functional Fφ [n] is equal to the Helmholtz free energy of the system much in the same way as φ [n] is equal to the grand potential EQ for the grand-canonical ensemble considered above. The results (2.1.18) and (2.1.19) form the basis for calculation of the equilibrium densities in studying the freezing transition. This is described next.
2.1.2 An approximate free-energy functional Having identified the thermodynamic extremum principle we now construct the proper free-energy functional F[n] in terms of the density n(x). This functional is then used to determine the appropriate inhomogeneous density function n 0 (x) at equilibrium satisfying the extremum principle (2.1.21). Using the definition (2.1.16) and the extremum condition (2.1.19), we obtain the result
δ F[n] = μ − φ(x) ≡ u(x). (2.1.21) δn(x) n=n 0 The free-energy function F[n] has contributions from two different parts, F = Fid + Fex ,
(2.1.22)
to be defined as follows. (a) The ideal-gas part Fid is the free-energy functional for a noninteracting system of particles. (b) The excess part Fex is due to interaction between the particles.
2.1 The density-functional approach
65
The ideal-gas part Fid [n] as a functional of density n(x) is obtained by using the definition (2.1.20). This also involves obtaining the functional relation between the equilibrium density and the field u(x). For the ideal-gas case with the interaction potential U = 0 this can be done 5 exactly. In this case H N0 has only the kinetic-energy term K = α pα2 /(2m) and hence, on explicitly integrating out the 3N momentum variables, the grand-canonical partition function is obtained as & ' = Tr exp −β H0 − u(rα ) α
N ∞ 1 −3 βu(x) = dx e N! 0 N =0
−3 βu(x) dx e = exp 0 ,
(2.1.23)
√ where 0 = h/ 2πmkB T is the de Broglie or thermal de Broglie wavelength for the liquid particles. From eqns. (2.1.9) and (2.1.23) one obtains for the noninteracting case the equilibrium density for the inhomogeneous state in the presence of the field φ(x) as n 0 (x) =
exp[βu(x)] 30
,
(2.1.24)
" ! i.e., βu(x) = ln 30 n 0 (x) . We obtain the free-energy functional F[n 0 ] by evaluating the expression (2.1.16) at n = n 0 as # $ (2.1.25) β Fid [n 0 ] = dx n 0 (x) ln 30 n 0 (x) − 1 , where we have used for the ideal-gas equation of state −βEQ = β P V = N¯ ≡ dx n 0 (x)
(2.1.26)
for the average number of particles N¯ . We choose the ideal-gas part of the free energy Fid [n] as a functional of the density function n(x) such that for the equilibrium density n(x) = n 0 (x) it reduces to the expression (2.1.25) for Fid [n 0 ]. Fid [n] is thus obtained by generalizing the above result as ( ) −1 dx n(x) ln 30 n(x) − 1 . (2.1.27) Fid = β The equilibrium density for the noninteracting system is obtained as n 0 (x) = z exp[−βφ(x)], where the normalization constant z = exp(βμ)/30 .
(2.1.28)
66
The freezing transition
The ideal-gas part of the free energy is an entropic contribution. See also Appendix A1.1 for a deduction of Fid for a coarse-grained density function n(x) using an occupationnumber representation. It follows from the result (2.1.27) that an inhomogeneous density function implies a higher degree of mass localization and hence reduction of entropy. For a system of N particles the difference between the Fid values corresponding to a uniform state of density n 0 and one with an inhomogeneous density distribution n(x) is given by ˜ n(x)], ˜ (2.1.29) β Fid = n 0 dx n(x)[ln where we assume that n(x) ˜ = n(x)/n 0 . Since by definition n(x) ˜ is always positive, from the Gibbs inequality (see Appendix A1.1) it follows that ! " dx n(x)ln ˜ n(x) ˜ − n(x) ˜ +1 ≥0 (2.1.30) 6 for any density distribution n(x). For a fixed number of particles we have dx[n(x) ˜ − 1] = 0, we have from the relation (2.1.29) Fid ≥ 0. Entropy always drops upon localization of the particles in a state with inhomogeneous density profiles, as a result of the restriction of available phase space. The interaction part For the interacting system we include in F the contribution from the excess part of the free energy Fex . The functional-extremum principle (2.1.21) now reduces to the form (2.1.31) ln 30 n 0 (x) − c(1) (x; n 0 ) = β{μ − φ(x)} = βu(x), where we have used the definition β
−1 (1)
c
δ Fex (x; n 0 (x)) = δn(x)
n(x)=n 0 (x)
.
(2.1.32)
Using the result (2.1.31), we obtain for the equilibrium density n 0 (x) n 0 (x) = z exp[−βφ(x) + c(1) (x; n 0 (x))],
(2.1.33)
showing that c(1) (x; n 0 (x)) acts as a one-body potential due to the interaction between the fluid particles. The higher-order direct correlation functions are defined in terms of functional derivatives of c(1) with respect to n 0 (x). We demonstrate in Appendix A2.1 that the two-point function c(2) (x1 , x2 ) is related to the pair correlation function g (2) (x1 , x2 ) in the fluid by a relation that reduces to the Ornstein–Zernike relation for the uniform liquid discussed in Chapter 1. The expression for the one-body potential in (2.1.33) is simplified by expanding it around its value cl for the uniform liquid state of density n l = N¯ /V . For the uniform liquid in the absence of any external field we have from eqn. (2.1.33) for the uniform density n l = z exp(cl ). The inhomogeneous density function n 0 (x) is then obtained in terms
2.1 The density-functional approach
67
of the corresponding one-particle direct correlation function c(1) (r ), # $ n 0 (x) = n l exp c(1) (x; n 0 (x)) − cl − βφ(x) .
(2.1.34)
A simple Taylor expansion for c(1) (x; n 0 (x)) around the uniform liquid state gives (1) c [x1 ; n 0 (x)] = cl (n l ) + dx2 c(2) [x1 , x2 ; n l ]δn 0 (x2 ) 1 dx2 dx3 c(3) [x1 , x2 , x3 ; n l ]δn 0 (x2 )δn 0 (x3 ) + · · ·, (2.1.35) + 2 where δn 0 (x) = n 0 (x) − n l is the fluctuation of the equilibrium density in the inhomogeneous state from the uniform liquid-state density n l . In eqn. (2.1.35) we use the following definitions for the direct correlation functions c(i) as the successive functional derivatives of Fex evaluated at the liquid-state density n l ,
δ i Fex (i) c (x1 , . . . , xi ; n l ) = . (2.1.36) δn(x1 ) . . . δn(xi ) n=n l For practical calculations one usually adopts the simplest approximation, keeping terms only up to the second-order term (i = 2) in the expansion (2.1.35) to obtain the following expression for the inhomogeneous density in equilibrium: n 0 (x1 ) = n¯ l exp
dx2 c(2) (x1 , x2 ; n l )δn 0 (x2 ) ,
(2.1.37)
where we identify n¯ l = z exp[−βφ + cl ] ≡ n l exp[−βφ]. For eqn. (2.1.37) the trivial solution is then the uniform density n 0 (x1 ) = n l in the absence of any external field. The solution of eqn. (2.1.37) is the starting point for the subsequent analysis for testing the possibility of an inhomogeneous density state. The two-point kernel function c(2) (x1 , x2 ; n l ) which is defined in terms of the functional derivative of the one-body potential c(1) is required in order to completely specify eqn. (2.1.37) for the inhomogeneous density. The excess free energy in the solid state Fex is expressed as a functional Taylor expansion (Courant and John, 1965; Abramowitz and Stegun, 1970) in the density fluctuations δn 0 (x) = n 0 (x) − n l , Fex = F(n l ) − dx1 c(1) (x1 ; n l )δn 0 (x) 1 dx1 dx2 c(2) (x1 , x2 ; n l )δn 0 (x1 )δn 0 (x2 ) + · · ·. (2.1.38) − 2 The series involves the functions c(i) defined in (2.1.36) at the liquid-state density n 0 (x) = n l . In the present case we have only kept terms up to second order in the density difference.
68
The freezing transition
2.1.3 The Ramakrishnan–Yussouff model We now discuss the density-functional approach to the freezing transition of an isotropic liquid into a crystalline state, using an order-parameter description in terms of the density. We begin with the eqn. (2.1.37) for the inhomogeneous density function n(x) obtained from the functional extremum principle (2.1.19). This equation is solved using the kernel function c(x1 , x2 ) ≡ c(|x1 − x2 |) for the isotropic homogeneous liquid state with density n l . The stable solid state at freezing is identified from the solution of the implicit relation (2.1.37) obtained by using test density functions corresponding to a chosen lattice structure. The present theoretical approach therefore does not solve the problem of spontaneous breaking of the translational symmetry; rather it allows one to identify the crystal symmetry in the inhomogeneous state by picking up the appropriate density function n 0 (x) which satisfies the functional extremum principle (2.1.19). The density function defined with a suitable parametrization constitutes the order parameter of the transition. In this regard there are two main choices for the test density function that have been made in the literature and will be considered below. Before discussing specific details of the solution, we first outline the general scheme of locating the freezing-transition point. At low densities there is only one trivial solution, n(x) = n l , of eqn. (2.1.37) referring to the homogeneous liquid state. For densities n l above a certain value n ∗l (dependent on the temperature T and the chemical potential μ of the liquid), inhomogeneous solutions n(x) with spatially periodic densities corresponding to one or more crystalline states are possible. Such inhomogeneous solutions are obtained for a continuous range of densities above n ∗l above which for every n l there is a corresponding inhomogeneous state with density n 0 (x). The homogeneous state and the inhomogeneous state are at the same temperature and chemical potential. The particular pair which represents true phase coexistence is then chosen from the corresponding Maxwell construction (Huang, 1987) in the present case of a grand-canonical ensemble. In the context of liquid–vapor transition the total number of particles N remains fixed, and for the isobaric ensemble the corresponding Gibbs free energies of the two states are equal. In the grand-canonical ensemble for the density-functional theory considered here, the volume V is fixed and the corresponding thermodynamic potential which is minimized is the grand potential . The coexisting states with respective densities n l and n 0 (x) have the same temperature T and chemical potential μ. The location of the true transition point is inferred by equating the grand potentials in the two states. The difference between the grand potentials in the inhomogeneous crystalline state with density n 0 (x) and the homogeneous liquid state with density n l (in the absence of the external potential φ) is obtained as ≡ [n 0 (x)] − [n l ] = Fid [n 0 (x)] + Fex [n 0 (x)] − μ
dx[n 0 (x) − n l ].
(2.1.39)
The difference Fid = Fid [n 0 (x)] − Fid (n l ) in the ideal-gas part of the free energy is directly calculated from (2.1.27). The difference Fex = Fex [n 0 (x)] − Fex (n l ) between
2.1 The density-functional approach
69
the excess free energies of the liquid and solid states is expressed as a functional Taylor expansion in the density fluctuations δn 0 (x) = n 0 (x) − n l from (2.1.38) as Fex = − dx1 c(1) (x1 ; n l )δn 0 (x) 1 (2.1.40) dx1 dx2 c(2) (x1 , x2 ; n l )δn 0 (x1 )δn 0 (x2 ) + · · ·. − 2 On substituting (2.1.40) into (2.1.39) and using the relation (2.1.31) for the case in which the external field φ = 0, we obtain the following result for the grand potential difference between the crystalline and liquid states:
n 0 (x1 ) − dx1 (n 0 (x1 ) − n l ) = dx1 n 0 (x1 )ln nl 1 dx1 dx2 c(2) (x1 , x2 ; n l )δn 0 (x1 )δn 0 (x2 ) − · · ·. − (2.1.41) 2 Therefore, by equating in (2.1.41) to zero the the coexisting density at the freezingtransition point is obtained. Since the volume V is kept constant, the equality of the grand potential = −P V for the two states also implies the equality of pressure P. In summary, among all pairs of points with equal temperature and chemical potential, the one with equal pressure (up to the same order in perturbation theory) marks the phase-transition point. This identification is displayed schematically in Fig. 2.1 with a phase diagram. In the scheme described above for locating the freezing point of the liquid into a crystal, a crucial ingredient is the choice of the test density function which involves the order parameters of the associated thermodynamic phase transition. Two functional forms for
Fig. 2.1 The density-functional theory in the grand-canonical ensemble relates each of the liquid states to a corresponding solid state having the same chemical potential and temperature. (Schematic c American Institute of Physics. diagram from Haymet and Oxtoby (1986).)
70
The freezing transition
the density have been used extensively in the existing literature. The formulation originally adopted by Ramakrishnan and Yussouff (1979) as well as by Haymet and Oxtoby (1981) and Oxtoby and Haymet (1982) uses the expansion in the reciprocal-lattice-vector (RLV) space. The first choice for the density function in terms of RLVs is described in some detail below to clarify the dependence of the order parameter on the lattice symmetry of the crystal structure. It is also useful for the discussion on the nucleation process for the growth of the crystal phase, which will be described in the next chapter. The second choice for the density function in terms of the Gaussian profiles located at the lattice points is discussed in the next section together with the weighted-density-functional theories. In the Ramakrishnan–Yussouff theory the solid-state density with underlying crystal symmetry is expressed exactly in terms of an order-parameter expansion, ∞ Am eiKm · x . n 0 (x) = n l 1 + η + (2.1.42) m=1
The sum in (2.1.42) is over the RLVs {Km } of the corresponding crystal structure (Ashcroft and Mermin, 1976) being tested. The amplitudes Am represent the order parameters of the transition. If all of the Am and η are set to zero, the uniform liquid state is obtained. The average density of the solid state is defined as 1 (2.1.43) dx n 0 (x). ns = V η = (n s − n l )/n l denotes the fractional change in density at freezing. Using the expansion (2.1.42) for the density function, the integral in the exponent on the RHS in (2.1.37) is obtained as ∞ dx c(x − x )δn 0 (x ) = c˜0 η + c˜m Am eiKm · x . (2.1.44) m=1
We have simplified the notation above by defining the dimensionless quantity c˜m ≡ n l c(|Km |) (for m = 0, 1, . . .), where c(K m ) is the Fourier transform of the direct correlation function c(r ) of the uniform liquid evaluated at the RLV Km . For the isotropic liquid c˜m is a function only of the magnitude of the wave vector. At the phase-transition point the grand potentials for the two phases are equal. In Appendix A2.2, the expression (2.1.41) for the difference of the thermodynamic potential between the two phases is obtained in terms of the order parameters η and Am : ⎡ ⎤ 2 ξm ⎦ 1 1 = n l V ⎣(c˜0 − 1)η + c˜0 η2 + , (2.1.45) 2 2 c˜m m=0
where ξm denotes the rescaled amplitudes defined as ξm = c˜m Am . A nonzero set of solutions for the amplitude parameters in the inhomogeneous density function (2.1.42) from the above DFT equations marks a stable crystalline phase. The amplitudes η and Am corresponding to the crystalline state in which the liquid freezes are obtained with the following two inputs.
2.1 The density-functional approach
71
Table 2.1 Comparison of the freezing parameters for hard spheres as obtained in the Ramakrishnan–Yussouff theory, using the Percus–Yevick (PY) structure factor (with and without the Verlet–Weiss (VW) correction) for the uniform liquid state, and the simulation of Hoover and Ree (1968). From Haymet and Oxtoby (1986). Structure factor (PY with VW) Average liquid density n l Average solid density n s Fractional density change η Entropy change s/kB
0.9460 1.037 0.0907 −1.047
Structure factor (PY without VW) 0.9665 1.033 0.0690 −0.944
Simulation 0.939–0.948 1.036–1.045 0.0928–0.1129 −1.16
(a) A suitable set of RLVs Km representing the crystal lattice into which the isotropic liquid changes at the freezing point. Although the ansatz (2.1.42) for the inhomogeneous density can in principle involve an infinite number of wave vectors, for practical computations this series is terminated with a finite number of RLV values. (b) The structural information of the uniform liquid state in terms of the c j . These quantities are obtained as the Fourier transforms of the Ornstein–Zernike direct correlation function c(r ). In the present discussion we are restricting the computation to terms of up to second order in density fluctuations in the expression for the free energy and hence only two-point direct correlation functions are involved. The required input information of uniform liquid structure for obtaining the order parameters of the freezing transition is in terms of the direct correlation function c(r ). In principle any simple liquid with available structural information (from experiment, computer simulations or theoretical models) can therefore be studied with this model. In practice, however, the most widely investigated system is the hard-sphere fluid. In their seminal paper Ramakrishnan and Yussouff (1979) studied the hard-sphere system, restricting the set of RLVs to two shells only. Subsequently Haymet and Oxtoby (1986) included up to 20 sets of RLVs. We discuss this treatment in more detail in Appendix A2.2 and the results are listed in Table A2.4. The scaled direct correlation functions c j of the hard-sphere system are approximated with the Percus–Yevick (PY) (Percus and Yevick, 1958; Percus, 1962, 1964) structure factor with Verlet–Weiss (VW) corrections (described in Chapter 1). Following the scheme described above, this calculation tells us that the freezing transition occurs at n l σ 3 = 0.946 (σ is the hard-sphere diameter), to an f.c.c. solid with average density n s σ 3 = 1.03 and a fractional density change η = 0.09. These numbers are in good agreement with the corresponding computer-simulation results as indicated in Table 2.1. The entropy change (per particle) on freezing is obtained from the Clapeyron equation (McQuarie, 2000), s 1 dP −η = . (2.1.46) kB n l 1 + η dT
72
The freezing transition
The results with two different structural inputs of c j (with and without Verlet–Weiss corrections to the structure factor) are listed in Table 2.1. The derivative d P/dT at the transition point is directly computed from the corresponding equation of state, i.e., the empirical Carnahan–Starling and the PY equation of state, respectively (described in Chapter 1). The Ramakrishnan–Yussouff theory outlined above is a basic step towards our understanding of freezing phenomena. It provides a formulation of the first-order phase transition through identification of the proper order parameters of the transformation process. The density-functional formalism involved provides the thermodynamic properties of the inhomogeneous crystalline state in terms of those of the liquid state. However, in spite of the usefulness of this model mentioned above, some severe approximations are made. The most important is the truncation of the functional expansion of the excess free energy Fex in terms of the density difference δn 0 (x) = n 0 (x) − n l . The particles in the crystal are highly localized about the respective lattice sites and hence the average solid-state density is strongly inhomogeneous, implying that the density difference δn is not small. Attempts to include higher-order corrections in this series (Haymet, 1983) only make the situation worse and result in poor predictions for the crystal–liquid coexistence conditions for the hard-sphere system (Curtain, 1989). Furthermore, the density distributions in the crystal as obtained from the calculation outlined above are much sharper than those found in simulation studies. The improvement of the theory of the freezing transition comes from the weighted-density-functional theory for studying inhomogeneous fluids. This is discussed in the next section. 2.2 Weighted density functionals The DFT for freezing involves studying the stability of the inhomogeneous solid by comparing its thermodynamic properties with those of the homogeneous liquid. In the previous section we have discussed the calculation of the excess contribution to the free energy of the crystal (over the so-called ideal-gas contribution for a noninteracting system) by retaining low-order terms in a perturbation series. This excess part due to the interaction between the particles is computed using the basic interaction potential between the particles as an input. Improvement of the DFT has been achieved by making nonperturbative approximations for the excess free energy in terms of that of an equivalent system. The characteristics of the coarse-grained system are determined from a weighted average of the inhomogeneous density of the original system. The corresponding weighting function(s) therefore constitute a basic ingredient of this approach to studying inhomogeneous solids. It is either self-consistently dependent on the density itself or chosen to be density-independent, being determined from geometric considerations of the constituent particles. The densityfunctional formulation with weighting is termed the weighted-density-functional theory. The equivalent system is generally determined in terms of a local density, but schemes with a position-independent density have also been formulated. The theory also requires as an input a standard framework for computing the thermodynamic properties of the equivalent low-density system. This makes a hard-sphere fluid particularly suitable for
2.2 Weighted density functionals
73
developing such theories. In our treatment of the weighted-density-functional theories we follow closely the developments due to Ashcroft and coworkers (Curtain and Ashcroft, 1985, 1986; Curtain, 1987; Denton and Ashcroft 1989) and also the fundamental-measure theory (Rosenfeld, 1988, 1989; Rosenfeld et al., 1990) applicable to hard-sphere systems. In the following we also discuss applications for systems whose interaction potentials have a long-range attractive part in addition to the short-range repulsion. In this approach the thermodynamic properties of the crystal are approximated with a free-energy functional constructed using the following mapping. The free-energy density of the inhomogeneous system at a given point x1 is the same as that of a homogeneous system, but evaluated at an auxiliary density n¯ 0 (x). The excess free energy Fex is obtained as Fex =
dx n 0 (x) f WDA [n¯ 0 (x)].
(2.2.1)
The weighted density function n¯ 0 (x) is constructed by weighting the physical density n 0 (x ) over a relevant region around the point x with a suitable weighting function w. The dependence of n¯ on n should reflect the nature of the inhomogeneity present in a solid phase and yet be general enough to be applicable to the different phases of the system. For example, if the structured phase is a crystal, then the high degree of correlation in it should be reflected in the corresponding coarse-grained system. On the other hand, for a homogeneous liquid of constant density, the coarse-grained density should be the same as the original density. This is achieved by making the functional dependence of n¯ 0 (x) self-consistent and nonlocal: n¯ 0 (x) =
dx w(x − x , n¯ 0 (x))n 0 (x ).
(2.2.2)
To satisfy the constraint that for a uniform system with density n 0 the weighted density should also be n 0 , we have the normalization condition
dx w(x − x , n 0 ) = 1.
(2.2.3)
Equations (2.2.1) and (2.2.2), which form the basis of the weighted-density approximation (WDA), can in fact be justified from general considerations of the free-energy functionals. We demonstrate this in Appendix A2.3. The simplest functional dependence between the coarse-grained density n¯ 0 (x) and the physical n 0 (x) is that provided by Tarazona (1984, 1985). Here w is assumed to be independent of density. For a hard-sphere system, if the sphere of influence affecting the density at a point is taken to be the hard-sphere diameter σ , then w has the form w(r ) = 3/(4π σ 3 ) for r ≤ σ and is zero otherwise. Other forms have also been studied in the literature (Nordholm et al., 1980; Baus and Colot, 1985). As we will explain below, the weighting
74
The freezing transition
function can be computed in a self-consistent manner taking into account the correlations present in the inhomogeneous solid. The basic idea behind the WDA is to take into account how the short-ranged nonlocal effects in the interacting, inhomogeneous system (the crystal) influence its thermodynamic properties. In the WDA the excess free energy of the solid is interpreted as that of an effective liquid of much lower density than the average solid density. It follows then in a natural way that the low-density liquid is what is required to account for the correlations in the solid state. By choosing the weighting function in an optimal way, an approximate re-summation of functional expansion (in terms of density) of the exact excess free energy can be reached in the WDA. In general the weighting function serves to smooth out the sharp density variations over a spatial range by virtue of its being nonlocal in nature. Since the available information for the inhomogeneous liquid is minimal, the weighting function is fixed by using the known properties of the uniform liquid state. w is chosen such that the known relation between the two-point direct correlation function c(2) (x1 , x2 ; n 0 ) and the second functional derivative in density of the excess free energy Fex is strictly obeyed at the homogeneous limit of n 0 (x) → n 0 : 2 WDA
δ Fex [n] (2) . (2.2.4) c (x1 , x2 ; n 0 ) = −β δn(x1 )δn(x2 ) n(x)=n 0 By definition of the weighted density function n(x), ¯ the excess free energy is defined as WDA [n 0 (x)] = dx n 0 (x) f 0 (n¯ 0 (x)), (2.2.5) Fex where f ex (n 0 ) is the free-energy density for the homogeneous liquid of density n 0 . The knowledge of a suitable function for f ex (n 0 ) is a required input in formulating the weighteddensity-functional theory of the inhomogeneous liquid. Using the WDA form of the excess free energy and evaluating the RHS of (2.2.4), one obtains (for the proof see Appendix A2.3) the following relation between the direct correlation function c(2) (x, n 0 ) of the homogeneous liquid and the WDA weighting function w, −β −1 c(2) (x − x ; n 0 ) = 2 f ex (n 0 )w(x − x ) (n 0 ) dx1 w(x − x1 )w(x1 − x ) + n 0 f ex + n 0 f ex (n 0 ) dx1 w(x − x1 )w (x1 − x )
+ w (x − x1 )w(x1 − x ) .
(2.2.6)
Since the direct correlation function c(2) (x − x ; n 0 ) of the homogeneous liquid is known, the weighting function w is obtained from the solution of (2.2.6). Alternatively, the above equation is Fourier-transformed to obtain −β −1 c(2) (k; n 0 ) = 2 f ex (n 0 )w(k; n 0 ) + n 0 f ex (n 0 )w 2 (k; n 0 ) (n 0 )w(k; n 0 )w (k; n 0 ). + 2n 0 f ex
(2.2.7)
2.2 Weighted density functionals
75
In the zero-wave-number limit, since the normalization condition (2.2.3) implies w(0; n 0 ) → 1, the above relation reduces to the compressibility rule (Hansen and McDonald, 1986) β −1 c(2) (0; n 0 ) = −2 f ex (n 0 ) − n 0 f ex (n 0 ).
(2.2.8)
Using c(2) (k; n 0 ) as input, eqn. (2.2.7) is solved for w(k), which is then inverse Fouriertransformed to obtain w(r ). Hence the weighted density n¯ 0 (x) is also obtained from (2.2.2). Let us consider the main features of the weighted-density-functional approach for the thermodynamic description of the inhomogeneous crystalline state outlined above. With the weighting function w determined from the solution of (2.2.6), a functional expansion of WDA about a uniform reference state is guaranteed to be identical to the corresponding −Fex expansion of −Fex to second order in density differences. The higher-order terms in this functional expression can also be obtained within the WDA by taking further functional WDA , since the relation derivatives of −Fex c(m) (k, 0, . . . ; n 0 ) =
∂ m−2 ∂n n−2 0
c(2) (k; n 0 )
(2.2.9)
between c(2) (k; n 0 ) and c(n) (k, k , . . . ; n 0 ) is preserved for all m > 2. The WDA approximates the excess part of the free energy in a manner that is exact to lowest order in density variations with arbitrarily large spatial fluctuations typical of the crystalline state. It also includes terms to all higher orders in a density expansion, since it provides the approximate expressions for three-point and all higher-point direct correlation functions using the two-point functions of the homogeneous liquid.
2.2.1 The modified weighted-density approximation The weighted-density-functional approach for computing the free energy of the inhomogeneous liquid is simplified to a large extent by further refining the theory into a form that has been termed the modified weighted-density-functional approximation (MWDA) by Denton and Ashcroft (1989). In the MWDA the effective liquid in terms of which the correlations in the solid are expressed has a constant density nˆ 0 rather than the n¯ 0 (x) of the WDA. The excess free energy of the solid is now obtained in the form Fex = N f ex [nˆ 0 ]. The density nˆ 0 of the equivalent liquid is obtained from the global average 1 dx dx w(x ˜ − x , nˆ 0 ) nˆ 0 = N
(2.2.10)
(2.2.11)
in terms of a weighting function w˜ that is analogous to the corresponding quantity w of the WDA. Similarly to in the case of the WDA, the basic MWDA equations (2.2.10) and (2.2.11) can also be justified at a formal level. This is shown in Appendix A2.4. We also
76
The freezing transition
demonstrate in Appendix A2.4 that the weighting function w(x) ˜ of the MWDA is obtained in the form
1 nˆ 0 −1 (2) w(x, ˜ x , nˆ 0 ) = − β c (x, x ; n s ) + (2.2.12) f (nˆ 0 ) , 2 f ex V ex where f represents the second derivative of the free-energy density f (n 0 ) with respect to the density. Now, on substituting this equation into the defining relation for the basic MWDA equation (2.2.11), we obtain the following self-consistent expression for the density nˆ 0 :
1 nˆ 0 = − nˆ 0 n s f ex (nˆ 0 ) + β −1 dx n 0 (x) dx n 0 (x ) c(2) (x, x ; nˆ 0 ) . (2.2.13) 2 f ex The above self-consistent relation is solved for a chosen density function n 0 (x) to obtain nˆ 0 . The only input required is the two-point direct correlation function c(2) for the uniform liquid state. The free energy of the inhomogeneous solid is obtained in terms of the relation (2.2.10). The necessary steps required to compute the free energy of the inhomogeneous solid in the WDA and in the MWDA are similar. The following inputs are necessary in both cases. (a) A suitable prescription for the inhomogeneous density function n 0 (x) of the solid state. (b) The direct correlation function c(2) (r ) of the homogeneous liquid. (c) The free-energy function f ex (n 0 ) for the homogeneous liquid of density n 0 . Parametrization of the inhomogeneous density function constitutes the basic step in the DFT model. We consider in the next section a standard choice of the inhomogeneous density function n 0 (x) for the crystalline state. 2.2.2 Gaussian density profiles In the stable crystalline phase for standard materials the root-mean-square displacements of the atoms are only a small fraction of the nearest-neighbor separations. The Hamiltonian for the crystal reduces to a harmonic expansion in terms of displacement from the lattice sites. The corresponding excitations of the dynamic crystalline state are the phonons. The inhomogeneous density function is suitably approximated as a sum of Gaussians, 3/2 α 2 e−α(x−R) , (2.2.14) n 0 (x) = π R
where the parameter α is the inverse width of the Gaussian. The α = 0 limit corresponds to the uniform liquid with infinitely wide Gaussian profiles and increasing values of α correspond to more strongly localized density profiles. The Lindemann parameter L0 associated with the melting of a solid is defined as the ratio of the root-mean-square displacement of an atom of the solid from its lattice site to the nearest-neighbor distance in the crystal at coexistence. The width parameter α is inversely proportional to L0 = 3/(αa 2 ),
2.2 Weighted density functionals
77
Fig. 2.2 (a) The radial density function 4πr 2 n 0 (r)σ for the Lennard-Jones particles at the freezing point measured from a lattice site with r in the (100) and (111) directions (solid line) and in the (110) direction (dashed line). The deviations of n 0 (r) from the Gaussian form n G is shown in (b) by the c American Institute of Physics. corresponding curves. Adapted from Laird et al. (1987).
where a = (4/n s )1/3 is the lattice constant of the f.c.c. lattice. For the hard-sphere system the single-particle density function is also described quite accurately in terms of the above expression of the sum of Gaussian profiles. The suitability of the Gaussian density approximation is further clarified in Fig. 2.2, where the radial density function 4πr 2 n 0 (r)σ for a system of particles interacting through the Lennard-Jones (L-J) potential is shown (see eqn. (1.2.117) for the definition of the L-J potential). Figure 2.2 clearly shows that the density profile in the crystalline phase is well approximated in the Gaussian form. The single-parameter formulation (2.2.14) of the density function is simply related to the earlier expansion (2.1.42) in terms of RLVs. To see this, let us consider the Ramakrishnan– Yussouff parametrization of the inhomogeneous density function n 0 (x),1 1 Note that this expression is slightly different from that of (2.1.42).
78
The freezing transition
n 0 (x) = n s 1 +
∞
A˜ m eiKm · x .
(2.2.15)
m=1
By Fourier transforming the density function as given by both of the above two expressions, (2.2.14) and (2.2.15), we obtain for n 0 (Km ) Ns A˜ m = n 0 (Km ) 3/2 α 2 = dx e−α(x−R) −Km · x . π
(2.2.16)
R
On completing the square in the exponential and evaluating the Gaussian integral we obtain the result (2.2.17) A˜ m = exp −K m2 /(4α) , which links the order parameters A˜ m in terms of the width parameter α. The parametrization (2.2.14) for the density function is closely associated with the Debye model (McQuarie, 2000) of the crystal and is further discussed in Appendix A2.5. The parametrization of the density in terms of the Gaussian profiles has been particularly useful for describing the inhomogeneous solid, as we will demonstrate in a number of applications in this book.
2.2.3 The hard-sphere system In the weighted-density-functional theories (both WDA and MWDA) the free energy of the solid is obtained in terms of an effective liquid of much lower density. Accurate knowledge of the thermodynamic properties (equilibrium correlation functions) of the homogeneous liquid is therefore essential for computing those properties for the solid state. The hardsphere fluid satisfies the criteria very well since the various integral-equation theories provide a very good account of the correlations in a hard-sphere system at low densities. The self-consistent equations (2.2.7) and (2.2.13) of the WDA (Curtain and Ashcroft, 1985, 1986) and the MWDA (Denton and Ashcroft, 1989), respectively, are solved, using the direct correlation function c(r ) of the Percus–Yevick (PY) solution (see Chapter 1) for the hard-sphere fluid. The the excess-free-energy function f ex is obtained by computing the pressure P of the system from the corresponding equation of state which relates P to the density n 0 of the liquid. For the PY solution this is given by βP 1 + ϕ + ϕ2 = . n0 (1 − ϕ)3
(2.2.18)
ϕ = πn 0 σ 3 /6 is the packing fraction of the fluid and σ is the hard-sphere diameter. The excess free energy f ex is computed by integrating the equation
2.2 Weighted density functionals
β P/n 0 = 1 + ϕ
∂β f ex , ∂ϕ
79
(2.2.19)
leading to the result f ex
3 1 = − 1 − ln(1 − ϕ). 2 (1 − ϕ)2
(2.2.20)
The calculation of the thermodynamic properties of the inhomogeneous solid using the weighted-density-functional theory therefore involves the following basic steps. Calculation of the free energy of the solid For a chosen density function, determined by the width parameter α, the WDA (MWDA) free energy is calculated by obtaining the corresponding weight function w (w). ˜ Hence we obtain the density for the corresponding equivalent liquid n¯ 0 (nˆ 0 ) of the WDA (MWDA). The free energy thus computed is then minimized with respect to the parameter α of the test density function to obtain the density distribution for the thermodynamic state. By comparing the free energies of the liquid and solid states, the thermodynamic parameters for the freezing point are obtained. To determine the coexisting densities of the two phases, the respective grand potentials () are equated for two states having the same chemical potential (μ). The thermodynamically stable inhomogeneous structure for the crystalline state is identified from the minimum of the total free energy F = Fid + Fex . At a given density (below the freezing point) this free energy corresponds to a certain value of the width parameter α lying between the homogeneous-liquid limit of α → 0 and the strong-localization case of α → ∞. The key aspect of the weighted-density-functional approach for studying inhomogeneous solids can be understood as follows. For the very localized density profiles characteristic of the crystal, the expression (2.1.25) for the ideal-gas part Fid of the free energy reduces to the form ( )
5 α 3/2 β Fid (α)/N = − + ln 30 (2.2.21) 2 π corresponding to the large-α limit. It is monotonically increasing with α. On the other hand, the excess or interaction part of the free energy evaluated with the MWDA or the WDA approximation monotonically decreases, favoring strong localization of the particles around the lattice sites. Physically this implies that with increasing localization each particle feels the effects of its neighbor to a lesser extent. This is very different from the case of a high-density liquid in which the particles are strongly interacting. It is therefore possible to map the interaction contribution to the free energy of the solid to that of a uniform liquid of much lower density. The solid-state correlations are modeled by an effective liquid of much lower density.
80
The freezing transition
Let us now consider the explicit computation of the excess free energy of the hard-sphere crystal in the WDA and MWDA schemes. A. In the WDA the equation (2.2.7) is solved to obtain w(k), which is then Fouriertransformed to obtain w(r ). The density n¯ 0 (x) of the effective liquid is obtained for a given choice of the density function n 0 (x) (which is fixed by a corresponding value of α). The excess free energy of the liquid is obtained by computing locally the function f ex (n¯ 0 (x)). B. In the MWDA the density nˆ 0 for the equivalent liquid is obtained by solving selfconsistently the single equation (2.2.13) for a chosen value of the width parameter α. The excess free energy of the solid is then calculated as f ex (nˆ 0 ). Clearly the WDA calculation is computationally more cumbersome since calculation of the weight function w requires solving a differential equation. This is much simpler in the case of the MWDA, for which the density nˆ 0 is obtained at much less computational effort. Furthermore, unlike in the MWDA, in the WDA the excess free energy f ex has to be computed locally and then integrated over the system. In order to illustrate the weighted-density-functional approximation it will be useful to discuss the details of the calculation in the simplest case, i.e., the MWDA model for the freezing transition in a hard-sphere system. For the f.c.c. solid into which the liquid freezes, the lattice constant is given by a = (4/n s )1/3 . Self-consistent solution of (2.2.13) gives the equivalent liquid density nˆ 0 for a given value of α. The free-energy contributions corresponding to the ideal and excess parts are computed as functions of α, and the minimum of the total free energy at the optimum parameter value α ≈ 127 corresponds to the equilibrium density distribution. The corresponding weight function w˜ of the MWDA is obtained by using the self-consistent solution nˆ 0 on the RHS of (2.2.12). The curves for the liquidand solid-state free energies (see Fig. 2.3) cross at an intermediate density that marks the phase transition of the system from a homogeneous liquid state to a more localized density distribution with f.c.c. crystal structure. The free energy of the liquid state shown in Fig. 2.3 is computed from the Carnahan–Starling equation of state (see Chapter 1), which provides an accurate description of the thermodynamics near freezing point. A higher degree of mass localization (higher α values) occurs with increasing average density n s . Determination of the densities of the coexisting phases The densities of the coexisting phases in the MWDA are determined by a common-tangent construction to ensure that the appropriate thermodynamic conditions are satisfied. The chemical potential and the thermodynamic potential of the solid phase are computed using the relations ∂ f (n s ) , μ(n s ) = ∂n s (n s ) = F(n s ) − μ(n s )Ns . (2.2.22) The corresponding quantities for the uniform liquid state are obtained using the Carnahan– Starling equation of state. The coexisting solid and liquid densities satisfy simultaneously
2.2 Weighted density functionals
81
Table 2.2 Freezing parameters for the hard-sphere liquid–f.c.c.-solid transition: the average solid density n s , liquid density n l , change in density n 0 , latent heat per particle s, and Lindemann parameter L0 for the f.c.c. solid. RY, Ramakrishnan–Yussouf. Reproduced from Denton and Ashcroft (1989).
Simulation MWDA WDA RY
nsσ 3
nlσ 3
n 0 σ 3
s/kB
L0
1.04 1.036 1.045 1.147
0.94 0.910 0.916 0.967
0.10 0.13 0.13 0.18
1.16 1.35 1.41 2.24
0.126 0.097 0.093 0.055
7
f
6
5
4
3
0.9
1 n0
1.1
Fig. 2.3 Total free energies of the liquid (dashed curve) and f.c.c. solid (solid curve) phases of the hard-sphere system. The crossing point of the two curves indicates the freezing density above which c American the f.c.c. solid is the equilibrium state. Reproduced from Denton and Ashcroft (1989). Physical Society.
the conditions (see Fig. 2.1) μ(n s ) = μ(n l )
and
(n s ) = (n l )
(2.2.23)
giving the coexisting pairs of liquid and solid densities. Thermodynamic properties such as the Lindemann parameter for the f.c.c. solid and the change of entropy at the freezing point as obtained from the different density-functional models as well as the results from the computer simulation of the hard-sphere system are compared in Table 2.2. The corresponding results for the free energy of the hard-sphere fluid and the thermodynamic pressures are compared in Table 2.3. It is worth noting that the WDA and MWDA give almost comparable results, though the computational effort for determining the WDA density n¯ 0 (x) is considerably more than that for nˆ 0 in the MWDA.
82
The freezing transition
Table 2.3 A comparison of results from different density-functional models for the free energy per particle F/N (in units of kB T) and the ratio of pressure to solid density n s , P/(n s kB T ) for the hard-sphere f.c.c. solid over a range of solid densities. Reproduced from Denton and Ashcroft (1989). F/(N kB T )
P/(n s kB T )
nsσ 3
MWDA
WDA
Simulation
MWDA
WDA
Simulation
1.000 1.025 1.050 1.075 1.100
4.412 4.629 4.853 5.090 5.347
4.449 4.674 4.908 5.156 5.423
4.661 4.868 5.099 5.354 5.663
8.51 8.96 9.61 10.58 11.90
8.83 9.40 10.09 11.06
10.25 10.81 11.49 12.30 13.26
The one-particle direct correlation function The one-particle direct correlation function c(1) defined in eqn. (2.1.32) represents the potential seen by a single particle in the inhomogeneous state and is an important thermodynamic property worth considering. In the case of the hard-sphere solid this is obtained using the MWDA. On substituting the expression (2.2.15) for the inhomogeneous density function n 0 (x) into the basic equation of the MWDA, i.e., eqn. (2.2.11) for the density nˆ 0 , we obtain 1 ˜2 nˆ 0 = n s + Am w˜ m (nˆ 0 ). (2.2.24) ns Km =0
As already noted above, the amplitude A˜ m is related to the width parameter α of the Gaussian approximation in (2.2.17). In order to obtain a suitable expression for c(1) it is convenient to treat the weight function w(r ˜ ) in terms of its Fourier transform w˜ m (nˆ 0 ). The latter is obtained from eqn. (2.2.12) as 1 (2) w˜ m = − + nˆ 0 δ K ,0 f ex (nˆ 0 ) , (2.2.25) β −1 cm 2 f ex (n) ˆ (2) is the Fourier transform of the two-point direct correlation function for the where cm homogeneous liquid of density nˆ 0 and δ K ,0 denotes the Kronecker delta function. Starting from the basic definition of the one-particle direct correlation function, we obtain the result (1)
δ f ex (nˆ 0 ) δ Ns f ex (nˆ 0 ) = f ex (nˆ 0 ) + Ns δn 0 (x) δn 0 (x) δ n ˆ 0 (nˆ 0 ) , = f ex (nˆ 0 ) + Ns f ex δn 0 (x)
−β −1 cMWDA (x, [n 0 ]) =
(2.2.26)
where we have used the relation δ Ns /δn 0 (x) = 1. The functional derivative [δ nˆ 0 /δn 0 (x)] in the second term on the RHS is computed by taking a derivative with respect to n 0 (x) of
2.2 Weighted density functionals
83
the basic equation (2.2.11) of the MWDA. Thus we obtain δ nˆ 0 1 = δn 0 (x) Ns
6 2 dx1 w(x ˜ − x1 ; nˆ 0 )n 0 (x1 ) − nˆ 0 . 6 6 1 − Ns−1 dx1 dx2 w˜ (x1 − x2 ; nˆ 0 )n 0 (x1 )n 0 (x2 )
(2.2.27)
Using the Fourier transform of the two integrals appearing respectively in the numerator and the denominator of the RHS of the above expression, we obtain the following expression for c(1) in the MWDA: (1) (nˆ 0 ) −β −1 cMWDA (x, [n]) = f ex (nˆ 0 ) + n s f ex 5 2 n s + m A˜ m w˜ m (nˆ 0 )eiKm · x − nˆ 0 × . 5 (nˆ ) n s − m A˜ 2m w˜ m 0
(2.2.28)
5 We have simplified the notation in the above equation by denoting m as the sum over RLVs Km with the prime implying the exclusion of the Km = 0 case. The RHS of the above formula is easily computed once the density nˆ and the corresponding weight function w˜ are also known from the self-consistent solution of the basic MWDA equations. The result for the one-particle direct correlation function c(1) is displayed in Fig. 2.4 for the hard-sphere f.c.c. solid. The one-body potential represented by c(1) is lowest at the lattice sites (where the density is highest) and highest in the interstitial regions (where the density is lowest). This is also plausible according to relation (2.1.33), since the location of the minimum potential represents the equilibrium position for a particle.
(1)
Fig. 2.4 The one-particle direct correlation function cMWDA (r ) in the MWDA approximation of a hard-sphere solid vs. the separation between two points along the three symmetry directions of the c American Physical Society. cubic unit cell. Reproduced from Denton and Ashcroft (1989).
84
The freezing transition
An interesting application of the density-functional model for the hard-sphere solid is first-principles computation of the elastic constants starting from the basic interaction potential between the particles. The elastic properties of the equilibrium crystalline state are obtained from the second functional derivative of the free-energy functional with respect to the density function. When the free energy of the solid state was evaluated using perturbative expansions like the Ramakrishnan–Yussouff model described above, unphysical results of negative elastic constants (Jari´c and Mohanty, 1987; Jones, 1987) were obtained. Subsequently this was improved by performing nonperturbative calculations using weighted-density-functional approaches (Velasco and Tarazona, 1987; Xu and Baus, 1988). These results are in good agreement with simulation results (Frenkel and Ladd, 1987; Runge and Chester, 1987). The weighted-density-functional models WDA and MWDA that we employed above to describe the inhomogeneous state below freezing represent the primary development in this approach. They constitute the ingredients of the theoretical approach for dealing with the nonuniform state in terms of an equivalent uniform liquid. Another approach, which is somewhat similar to the MWDA, is the generalized effective-liquid approximation (GELA) (Lutsko and Baus, 1990). This model uses a different prescription for the positionindependent weighted density for the effective liquid in terms of which the crystalline state is described. The purely repulsive hard-core systems considered in this section have some specific characteristics peculiar to them. These can be attributed to the success of the weighteddensity approximation (keeping up to second order in density fluctuations) at describing accurately hard-core systems in terms of an equivalent low-density fluid. For the Hamiltonian with a purely hard-sphere interaction no expansion in terms of displacements from equilibrium sites exists. The hard-sphere crystal is therefore somewhat anomalous when viewed from the perspective of usual descriptions of lattice dynamics. The system is entirely controlled by collisions and the motion of the particles between collisions loses coherence very rapidly. This particular aspect of the hard-sphere crystal is reflected in its thermodynamic properties being successfully computed in terms of an equivalent liquid of much lower density. The ballistic motion of the freely moving hard spheres in the crystal between collisions is quite analogous to the corresponding motion of the particles in the low-density fluid. However, the above-described similarity in the case of the purely anharmonic hardsphere crystal is peculiar to itself. For the 1/r n -type potential (n → ∞ is the hard-sphere potential), as n approaches values more typical of short-range interactions in real systems, the coherence in the motion of the particles increases. In such cases, unlike for the hardsphere solid, the similarity between the correlations in the liquid and those in the solid is much less. As a result the success of the weighted-density-functional theories at providing understanding of freezing in systems with softer interactions has been limited. For the hard-sphere crystal the average domain of motion of a particular sphere is constrained in space over a scale determined largely by the range of the direct correlation function at the corresponding density. The range of the direct correlation function c(2) increases considerably with that of the interaction potential (n becoming smaller)
2.3 Fundamental measure theory
85
and hence the coarse-graining length scale for the corresponding weight function (over which the inhomogeneous density n 0 (x) should be averaged to obtain the weighted density n¯ 0 (x)) increases. This implies that it is appropriate include higher-order correlations like c(3) in the calculation of the weight function for the systems with softer potentials. For example, in the MWDA formulation for plasma (n = 1) inclusion of the three-particle correlation is required to obtain the freezing (Likos and Ashcroft, 1992). For hard-sphere systems (n → ∞), on the other hand, the third-order extension merely leads to additional improvement of already satisfactory results. 2.3 Fundamental measure theory A generalization of the scheme of describing the inhomogeneous state using the idea of weighted density has been formulated for the hard-sphere fluid and is termed the fundamental measure theory (FMT) (Rosenfeld 1988, 1989; Rosenfeld et al., 1990). In the fundamental measure theory the free energy of the inhomogeneous state is obtained in terms of not just one density but several weighted densities. The corresponding weight functions are independent of density, and are constructed by making use of the geometric properties of the constituent particles. Let us consider a one-component system of hard spheres of radius R (diameter σ = 2R). In the FMT the excess free energy Fex is expressed as (2.3.1) β Fex [n 0 (x)] = dx ex [{n¯ i (x)}]. The (excess) free-energy density ex is assumed to be a functional of several weighted densities n¯ i (for i = 1, 2, 3, . . .) respectively defined in terms of density-independent weight functions wi (x), n¯ i (x) = dx wi (x − x )n 0 (x). (2.3.2) The corresponding functional derivative of n¯ i with respect to the density n(x) is obtained as δ n¯ i (x ) (2.3.3) = wi (x − x ). δn 0 (x) Using (2.3.3) in the definition (2.1.36) for the two-point direct correlation function as the second functional derivative of the excess free energy, we obtain δ 2 ex δ 2 Fex c(x1 , x2 ) = −β dx wi (x1 − x)w j (x2 − x). (2.3.4) =− δn 0 (x1 )δn 0 (x2 ) δ n¯ i δ n¯ j i, j
In the uniform-fluid limit, the functional derivative reduces to the partial derivatives and we obtain for the direct correlation function ∂ 2 ex
c(x1 , x2 ) = (2.3.5) wi ⊗ w j , ∂ n¯ i ∂ n¯ j i, j
where ⊗ represents the convolution of the two weighting functions wi (x1 ) and w j (x2 ).
86
The freezing transition
A key observation in the formulation of the FMT is that the Percus–Yevick (PY) expression for the direct correlation function of the homogeneous hard-sphere fluid can be written in the form of the RHS of (2.3.5). For this a proper choice has to be made for the set of weight functions, which are defined in terms of the characteristic geometry of two overlapping hard spheres.
2.3.1 Density-independent weight functions The characteristic functions which relate to the geometry of a single hard sphere of radius R are identified as 4 R(3) = π R 3 , R(2) = 4π R 2 , 3 R(1) = R,
R(0) = 1.
(2.3.6)
Around the center of a sphere there is a sphere of radius σ = 2R that the center of another hard sphere cannot enter without producing an overlap. The overlap volume V and the overlap surface area S of two identical spheres with their centers at a distance r < 2R are obtained in terms of x = r/(2R) as V(r ) = (r − R)(|r − r | − R)dr = R3 (1 − 3x + 4x 3 )(r − 2R), S(r ) = 2 (r − R)δ(|r − r | − R)dr = R2 (1 − r/(2R))(r − 2R),
(2.3.7)
(2.3.8)
where (x) is the step function, which is equal to 1 and 0 for x < 0 and x > 0, respectively. The expression (1.2.95) for c(r ) presented in Chapter 1 is given in terms of the overlap volume V and overlap surface S as −c(r ) = χ (3) V(r ) + χ (2) S(r ) + χ (1) R(r ) + (r − 2R)χ0
(2.3.9)
by using the following two definitions. 1. The density-dependent coefficients χ (i) are expressed as χ (1) = 2 χ02 ,
χ (2) = 1 χ02 +
χ (3) = 0 χ02 + 21 2 χ03 +
23 4 χ , 4π 0
22 3 χ , 4π 0 (2.3.10)
where χ0 and i for i = 0, . . . , 3 are defined in terms of the fundamental measures R(i) of a sphere defined in (2.3.6) as χ0 = 1/(1 − 3 ), (i)
i = n 0 R .
(2.3.11) (2.3.12)
2.3 Fundamental measure theory
87
Note that 3 and 0 are equal to the packing fraction ϕ and the density n 0 of the uniform hard-sphere fluid, respectively. 2. The so-called overlap radius R(r ) of the two spheres with their centers at a distance r is defined as R = R − r/4 = R(1 − x/2). R is expressed in terms of S as r S(r ) R R(r ) = R − (r − 2R) = + (r − 2R). (2.3.13) 4 8π R 2 The expression (2.3.9) for the direct correlation function reduces to the form (2.3.5) with a proper choice for the wi . In this respect we define the functions w(3) and w (2) which are related to the volume and surface area, respectively, of a sphere of radius R, w (3) (r) = (|r| − R),
w(2) = δ(|r| − R).
(2.3.14)
The characteristic functions V and S for two overlapping spheres defined in eqns. (2.3.7) and (2.3.8) are obtained as simple convolutions of w(2) and w(3) as (3) (3) (2.3.15) V(r ) = w ⊗ w ≡ dr w (3) (r − r )w (3) (r ), (2.3.16) S(r ) = 2w (3) ⊗ w(2) ≡ 2 dr w (3) (r − r )w (2) (r ). In order to obtain the function R defined in (2.3.13) in terms of the characteristic functions of a sphere, we need to have a representation of the step function (r − 2R) using basic functions similar to those defined in (2.3.14). This requires extending the set of w(i) to include two more scalar functions defined as w (0) (r) , 4π R 2 and two more vector functions denoted by w (0) (r) =
w (1) (r) =
w (0) (r) 4π R
(2.3.17)
r w(2) (r) = ∇w (3) (r) ≡ δ(|r| − R), r w(2) (r) . (2.3.18) w(1) (r) = 4π R The step function is represented in terms of the basis functions which include the scalar functions w(i) , i = 0, 1, 2, 3, and the vector functions w(1) and w(2) , = 2 w(3) ⊗ w(0) + w (2) ⊗ w(1) + w(2) ⊗ w(1) . (2.3.19) The convolution involving w(1) and w(2) appearing in the last term on the RHS implies that of the scalar product of the two vectors. Using the relations (2.3.19) and (2.3.15), the expression (2.3.9) for the direct correlation function for the homogeneous hard-sphere fluid reduces to the form (2.3.5) with the weight functions wi and w j both running over the whole set {w (0) , w (1) , w (2) , w (3) , w(1) , w(2) } constructed from the characteristic volume and surface function of the hard sphere. The partial-derivative matrix [∂ 2 ex /∂ n¯ i ∂ n¯ j ] for the homogeneous fluid is obtained as a function of the density n 0 and the radius R of the hard sphere.
88
The freezing transition
2.3.2 The free-energy functional The free-energy density ex is constructed in terms of the linear combinations of the weighted densities and their products. The general form for ex in the spirit of a virial expansion is obtained as ex [{n¯ i (x)}] = 1 [n¯ i (x)] + 2 [n¯ i (x)n¯ j (x)] i
+
i, j
3 [n¯ i (x)n¯ j (x)n¯ k (x)] + · · ·.
(2.3.20)
i, j,k
The weighted densities n i for the inhomogeneous system are defined in terms of the corresponding (density-independent) weight functions as i = 0 to 3, (2.3.21) n¯ i (x) = dx wi (x − x )n 0 (x), n¯ i (x) = dx wi (x − x )n 0 (x), i = 1, 2. (2.3.22) The dimension of the scalar density n¯ i (x) is [L]i−3 (for i = 0 to 3) while the dimension of n¯ i is the same as that of n¯ i (for i = 1, 2). Since ex on the LHS of (2.3.20) has the dimension of the density L −3 (see the definition (2.3.1) for ex ), the free-energy density is expressed (from dimensional considerations) as a linear combination of n¯ 0 , n¯ 1 n¯ 2 , n¯ 32 , n¯ 1 · n¯ 2 , and n¯ 2 (n¯ 2 · n¯ 2 ), keeping terms of up to third order in the expansion (2.3.20), ex [{n¯ i (x)}] = γ (0) n¯ 0 (x) + γ (1) n¯ 1 (x)n¯ 2 (x) + γ (2) n¯ 32 (x) + γ (3) [n¯ 1 (x) · n¯ 2 (x)] + γ (4) n¯ 2 (x)[n¯ 2 (x) · n¯ 2 (x)],
(2.3.23)
where the coefficients γ (i) (i = 1, . . . , 5) in the expansion are functionals of the dimensionless density n¯ 3 (x). In the uniform-fluid limit, the expression (2.3.23) reduces to the form ex [{i }] = γ (0) 0 + γ (1) 1 2 + γ (2) 23 ,
(2.3.24)
since in this case the scalar density n¯ i (for i = 0 to 3) reduces to i and n¯ i = 0 (for i = 1, 2). Determining the coefficients γ (i) (i = 1, . . . , 5) in the expansion (2.3.23) requires the introduction of further approximations. Here once again the analogy with the uniformfluid state is used. By considering a single solute particle in a uniform hard-sphere fluid, the bulk pressure P is obtained. The bulk pressure is identified with the partial derivative of ex with respect to the packing fraction 3 , using the formulation of the scaled-particle theory (Reiss et al., 1959), ∂ex = β P ≡ 0 + β Pex , ∂3
(2.3.25)
2.3 Fundamental measure theory
89
where Pex denotes the contribution to the pressure from the excess part of the free energy. This relation is now assumed to be valid for the inhomogeneous fluid, in order to obtain the following differential equation: δex (x) = n¯ 0 (x) + β Pex [n 0 (x)]. δ n¯ 3 (x)
(2.3.26)
The functional Pex [n 0 (x)] is obtained from the definition of the thermodynamic potential functional 0 [n(x)] as δ Fex [n 0 (x)] ≡ − Pex [n 0 (x)]dx = Fex − n 0 (x) dx. (2.3.27) δn 0 (x) On computing the functional derivative of Fex with density in terms of the corresponding derivatives with respect to the weighted densities n¯ i (x) and using (2.3.3), the relation (2.3.27) gives the following result for Pex [n(x)]: β Pex [n 0 (x)] = −ex [n¯ i (x)] +
n¯ i (x)
i
δex (x) , δ n¯ i (x)
(2.3.28)
with i running over the whole set of weighted densities denoted in (2.3.21) and (2.3.22). On combining eqns. (2.3.26) and (2.3.28) we obtain the following equation for ex : ∂ex ∂ex = n¯ 0 − ex [n¯ i ] + n¯ i , ∂ n¯ 3 ∂ n¯ i
(2.3.29)
i
where we have replaced the functional derivatives appearing in the local relation by corresponding partial derivatives with respect to the weighted densities. Now, substituting the expression (2.3.23) for the excess free energy ex , and taking the terms involving the weighted densities and their products to be independent, we obtain the following five differential equations for the coefficients γ (i) for i = 0, . . . , 5: ∂γ (0) 1 = , ∂ n¯ 3 1 − n¯ 3 2γ (i) ∂γ (i) = ∂ n¯ 3 1 − n¯ 3
∂γ (i) γ (i) = ∂ n¯ 3 1 − n¯ 3
for i = 1, 3,
for i = 2, 4.
(2.3.30)
γ (0) = − ln(1 − n¯ 3 ) + c0 , c1 c2 , γ (2) = , γ (1) = 1 − n¯ 3 (1 − n¯ 3 )2 c3 c4 γ (3) = , γ (4) = . 1 − n¯ 3 (1 − n¯ 3 )2
(2.3.31)
The solutions of these equations are
(2.3.32)
The constants ci (for i = 1, . . . , 5) are determined by ensuring that for the uniform hardsphere fluid the two-point function c(r ) obtained from eqns. (2.3.5) and (2.3.24) matches with the corresponding Percus–Yevick expression, i.e., the RHS of eqn. (2.2.20). From this
90
The freezing transition
one obtains the constants as c0 = 0, c1 = 1, c2 = 1/(24π ), c3 = −1, and c4 = −1/(8π ). Using these results, the excess-free-energy functional is obtained as ex [{n¯ i (x)}] = −n¯ 0 ln(1 − n¯ 3 ) +
n¯ 3 − 3n¯ 2 (n¯ 2 · n¯ 2 ) n¯ 1 n¯ 2 − n¯ 1 · n¯ 2 + 2 . 1 − n¯ 3 24π (1 − n¯ 3 )2
(2.3.33)
The free-energy expression (2.3.24) can be changed in such a manner that in the uniformfluid limit the Carnahan–Starling (instead of the Percus–Yevick) expression of the free energy is obtained (Roth et al., 2002). The theory is easily generalized (Rosenfeld et al., 1990; Rosenfeld et al., 1997) to mixtures of hard spheres by defining a set of weight functions and hence weighted densities for each species. In formulating the FMT optimal use of the geometric considerations is made in obtaining the correlations in the uniform hard-sphere fluid in terms of the weight functions wi . The FMT by construction ensures that in the uniform-fluid limit the Percus–Yevick (PY) result for the direct correlation function is reproduced. An alternative approach by Kierlik and Rosinberg (1990) avoids use of the vector weight functions discussed above and obtains similar results with only four scalar weight functions and hence four weighted densities. Here the description of the inhomogeneous state in terms of density-independent weight functions replaces that with a density-dependent single weight function in the WDA (Curtain and Ashcroft, 1985). It is not clear a priori whether this is necessarily a better description of the inhomogeneous state. When applied to the freezing problem, the FMT indicates a very sharp decrease of the free energy, with the width of the Gaussian density profiles becoming unrealistically large. For large values of the width parameter α, i.e., for extremely localized density profiles, the local packing fraction given by the weighted density ϕ¯ 0 = n¯ 3 (x) is almost unity, the underlying reason being the short range (radius σ/2 of the hard sphere) of w3 in this case. In the WDA this problem is avoided since the corresponding weight function has a range σ and the local packing fraction π n¯ 0 σ 3 /6 is less than 0.5, implying that the inhomogeneous solid is mapped into a low-density uniform liquid. Thus application of the FMT is not very suitable for the freezing problem. In fact, here the free energy of the solid is never less than that of the liquid (which corresponds to the case α = 0). The more useful application of the FMT is to the calculation of the higher-order correlations in the uniform-liquid state (Kierlik and Rosinberg, 1990), for which good agreement with Monte Carlo results is obtained. The FMT has recently been applied in the study of systems beyond simple hard-core repulsion by Lutsko (2008).
2.4 Applications to other systems The basic idea of the density-functional theory outlined above has been applied for studying different systems including mixtures, liquid crystals, flux-lattice melting in superconductors, quasicrystals, glasses, fluids in confined geometries, wetting, adsorption and the nature of interfaces. It has also been applied to the study of liquid–solid phase transitions in systems having realistic nonsingular interactions. The inhomogeneous density function
2.4 Applications to other systems
91
used to describe the crystalline state has been modified to include the presence of vacancy defects in a crystal and obtains an estimation of the equilibrium density of vacancies. Here the basic interaction potential between the particles is the only input used in the theory. A general description of these extensions can be found in Henderson (1992). In the present section we discuss two important applications linked to the basic theme of this chapter, namely the study of systems with long-range attractive forces and the nature of liquid–solid interfaces.
2.4.1 Long-range interaction potentials So far we have discussed the density-functional theories of the freezing of a hard-sphere fluid. Geometric packing considerations play an important role in determining the thermodynamic properties of the condensed state. However, inclusion of only the hard-core form of the interaction potential in the Hamiltonian is inadequate for understanding the symmetry-breaking transition in real systems and hence consideration of more physical interactions is required. The crystalline phase is generally characterized by strong coherence, which is absent in the hard-sphere case. In the present section we discuss recent developments of models applicable to liquids having more realistic interaction potentials going beyond the simple hard-sphere type. For the Ramakrishnan and Yussouff model discussed in Section 2.1.3, of course, there is no specific limitation to the hard-sphere interaction potential. Only the structural properties of the homogeneous liquid state in terms of the direct correlation functions are required as input in solving the model equations and hence the theory can, in principle, be applied to systems with any interaction potential. However, the weighted-density-functional models described above require accurate knowledge of the equation of state of the homogeneous liquid in order to obtain the correlations corresponding to the inhomogeneous crystalline state. For the hard-sphere fluid such information is readily available from various standard integral-equation approaches. Extending the density-functional model to systems with attractive potentials, e.g., Lennard-Jones interaction, requires special treatment of the long-range attractive forces between the particles. The perturbation theory We now discuss formulation of the density-functional theory for a system with a realistic interaction potential that has a long-range attractive part. The treatment is analogous to the earlier perturbative treatment of Weeks et al. (1971) (referred to above as the WCA theory) for computing the thermodynamic properties of such systems in the homogeneous liquid state. Let us consider a system interacting through a two-body potential that is characterized in terms of a reference potential and a perturbation, involving a small parameter κ, as u(x12 ; κ) = u R (x12 ) + κu P (x12 ),
(2.4.1)
representing the reference and the perturbative components of the two-body potential, respectively. To formulate the density-functional theory of the inhomogeneous state of the system with a realistic interaction potential u(x12 ) as described above, we first construct
92
The freezing transition
the appropriate free-energy functional. A formal expression for the free energy is obtained by starting from the exact definition of the two-point distribution function f 2 (x1 , x2 ) as f 2 (x1 , x2 ) = n(x ˆ 1 )n(x ˆ 2 ),
(2.4.2)
where nˆ represents the microscopic one-particle density and the angular brackets refer to the average over the equilibrium distribution. The two-point distribution function represents the probability of particles 1 and 2, respectively, being simultaneously at x1 and x2 . The Boltzmann factor for obtaining the statistical average on the RHS of (2.4.2) is determined by the potential-energy part V of the Hamiltonian H. The dependence of the total potential energy V on spatial coordinates is expressed in terms of the two-body potential u(x12 ; κ) as follows: 1 dx1 dx2 n(x ˆ 1 )n(x ˆ 2 )u(x12 ; κ). (2.4.3) V(2) = 2 From eqn. (2.4.3) it follows that the functional derivative of the partition function Z= exp[−β H ] (2.4.4) with respect to the two-body potential u(x12 ) involves the product of two one-point density functions appearing between the angular brackets on the RHS of (2.4.2). Since the Helmholtz free energy is given by F = −kB T ln Z ,
(2.4.5)
the corresponding two-point function denoted by f 2 (x1 , x2 ; κ) is obtained formally in terms of a functional derivative with respect to the two-body potential, f 2 (x1 , x2 ; κ) =
δ F[n 0 (x)] . δu(x12 ; κ)
We integrate the relation (2.4.6) formally along κ = 0 to 1 to obtain the result 1 1 dκ dx1 dx2 f 2 (x1 , x2 ; κ)u P (x12 ) ≡ FP , F[n 0 (x)] − FR [n 0 (x)] = 2 0
(2.4.6)
(2.4.7)
where FR [n(x)] is the Helmholtz free energy of the reference system having the interaction potential u R . To lowest order in κ we obtain FP as 1 (2.4.8) dx1 dx2 f 2R (x1 , x2 )u P (x12 ), FP = 2 where f 2R (x1 , x2 ) denotes the two-particle distribution function for the system with interaction potential u R . Thus the free energy of the solid with interaction potential u(x12 ) is obtained as 1 (2.4.9) dx1 dx2 f 2R (x1 , x2 )u P (x12 ). F[n 0 (x)] = FR [n 0 (x)] + 2
2.4 Applications to other systems
93
In general an angularly averaged quantity 7 f 2R (x12 ) for the two-point function f 2R (x1 , x2 ) is defined as d dx1 R 2 7R n 0 f 2 (x) = (2.4.10) f (x1 , x1 + x), 4π V 2 d being the differential solid angle around x. Using the definition (2.4.10) for the angularly averaged correlation function 7 f we obtain from (2.4.9) the following expression for the free energy per particle of the inhomogeneous state for the system with interaction potential u: f [n 0 (x)] = f R [n 0 (x)] + 2π n 0 dr r 2 7 (2.4.11) f 2R (r )u P (r ). Thus both the free energy f R and the angularly averaged two-point distribution function 7 f 2R (r ) of the reference system are required in order to construct the free-energy functional for the system with interaction potential u(x 12 ). Since the thermodynamic properties of the hard-sphere system are well known, it becomes a natural choice for the reference system. The interaction potential for the liquid is divided into a harshly repulsive part (representing a hard core) and a long-range attractive part to be treated as a weak perturbation. The next step in this calculation is therefore to choose a suitable description for the reference system with interaction potential u R in terms of an equivalent hard-sphere system. The diameter of the hard-sphere system is determined by setting suitable conditions, to be described below. The reference system For a short-range repulsive u R (x12 ), the free-energy functional FR [n(x)] of the reference system is obtained in terms of an equivalent hard-sphere system. The diameter dE of this equivalent hard-sphere system is treated as an adjustable parameter in the theory and is determined by applying a suitable criterion obtained from thermodynamic considerations. To identify dE , the free energy of the reference system is written in terms of an expansion around that for the hard-sphere system in powers of a blip function e(x1 , x2 ), δ FHS [n 0 (x)] 1 FR = FHS + (2.4.12) dx1 dx2 e(x1 , x2 ) + · · ·, 2 δeHS (x1 , x2 ) where e(x1 , x2 ) = exp(−βu(x12 ))
(2.4.13)
is the Boltzmann factor for the interaction potential u(x12 ). The blip function is defined as e(x1 , x2 ) = eR (x1 , x2 ) − eHS (x1 , x2 ),
(2.4.14)
namely as the difference between the Boltzmann factors for the reference potential u R and a hard-sphere potential u HS . If the range of the reference potential is comparable to the hardsphere diameter then the function e is nonzero only over a range of ξ dHS with ξ < 1, whence the name blip function. Since the potential u is related to the Boltzmann factor e
94
The freezing transition
as −βu = ln e, it follows from (2.4.6) that the functional derivative of the Helmholtz free energy with respect to eHS (x1 , x2 ) is related to the two-point distribution function, −β
δ F[n 0 (x)] = f 2 (x1 , x2 )eβu HS (x12 ) ≡ yHS (x1 , x2 ). δe(x1 , x2 )
(2.4.15)
On using the relation (2.4.15) and evaluating the angular part of the integral on the RHS of (2.4.12) we obtain the result for the free energy as (2.4.16) FR [n 0 (r)] = FHS [n 0 (r)] + 2π V dr r 2 y˜HS (r )e(r ) + O((e)2 ), where y˜HS (r ) denotes the angular average of the hard-sphere function yHS (x1 , x2 ) and is obtained by averaging the latter over all orientations. The diameter dE of the equivalent hard-sphere system with potential u HS is adjusted so as to ensure that the first-order term in the expansion of eqn. (2.4.16) for the free energy vanishes. This is done by solving the relation ∞ ∞ dr r 2 y˜HS (r ) = dr r 2 y˜HS (r )e−βu R , (2.4.17) dE
0
where dE is the diameter of the equivalent hard-sphere system. The discussion so far is applicable to an equivalent hard-sphere system irrespective of whether the system is homogeneous or not. For the isotropic liquid state translational invariance holds and the angularly averaged quantity y˜HS (r ) → gHS (r ), the uniform liquid-state radial distribution function for the reference system. From the solution of eqn. (2.4.17) using the pair correlation function gHS we obtain the corresponding value of the diameter dE of the equivf 2R (r ) the alent (uniform) hard-sphere system. For the above two key quantities f R and 7 respective functional dependences on density are assumed to be the same as those of the corresponding quantities for an equivalent hard-sphere system of radius dE . The free energy The free energy of the system with interaction potential u in the inhomogeneous solid state is computed by making use of the above perturbation theory. We will discuss below two approaches along these lines. Model A The free energy f [n 0 (r)] per particle of the inhomogeneous system with interaction potential u is obtained as an expansion around the corresponding uniform liquid state (of density n 0 ) constructed in terms of direct correlation functions of the liquid, ∞ 1 f [n 0 (r)] = f [n 0 ] − dr . . . drn c(n) (r1 , . . . , rn )n 0 (r1 ) . . . n 0 (rn ), β N n! n=2
(2.4.18) where c(n) is the n-particle direct correlation function of the liquid of density n 0 . For the free energy f (n 0 ) of the uniform state we substitute the corresponding limit of the RHS of eqn. (2.4.11),
2.4 Applications to other systems
f [n 0 (r)] = f R [n 0 ] + 2πn 0
dr r 2 7 f 2R (r )u P (r ).
95
(2.4.19)
We now choose the uniform reference system of density n 0 , in terms of an equivalent hard-sphere system. The expansion (2.4.18) reduces in terms of the equivalent hard-sphere system (as 7 f 2R (r ) → gHS (r )) to f [n 0 (r)] = f HS [n 0 ] + 2πn 0 −
∞ n=2
1 β N n!
dr r 2 gHS (r ; n 0 )u P (r )
drn c(n) (r1 , . . . , rn )n 0 (r1 ) . . . n 0 (rn ), (2.4.20)
dr . . .
Next we write the direct correlation function of the system in terms of that of the hard(n) sphere system as c(n) = c(n) + cHS . Substituting this form of the direct correlation function into the above equation gives f [n(r )] = f HS [n 0 ] − + 2πn 0 −
∞ n=2
∞
1 β N n!
n=2
dr . . .
(n) drn cHS (r1 , . . . , rn )n 0 (r1 ) . . . n 0 (rn )
dr r 2 gHS (r )u P (r )
1 β N n!
dr . . .
drn c(n) (r1 , . . . , rn )n 0 (r1 ) . . . n 0 (rn ). (2.4.21)
The sum of the first two terms on the RHS of eqn. (2.4.21) is equal to the inhomogeneousstate free energy of the hard-sphere system, giving the result f [n(r)] = f HS [n 0 ] + 2πn 0 −
∞ n=2
1 β N n!
dr r 2 gHS (r )u P (r )
dr . . .
drn c(n) (r1 , . . . , rn )n 0 (r1 ) . . . n 0 (rn ). (2.4.22)
Let us now consider the example of the Lennard-Jones (LJ) interaction potential u(r ) ≡ u LJ (r ) which is defined for two particles at a separation r in eqn. (1.2.117). u LJ is divided LJ into two parts, namely a hard-core repulsive part, u LJ R , and an attractive potential, u P , respectively defined as & u LJ R
=
w(r ) + 0 ,
for r < σ0 ,
0,
for r > σ0 ,
(2.4.23)
96
The freezing transition
and
& u LJ P
=
−0 ,
for r < σ0 ,
w(r ), for r > σ0 ,
(2.4.24)
where σ0 = 21/6 σ and w(r ) is the RHS of eqn. (1.2.117). For the homogeneous liquid state, its thermodynamic properties are obtained by treating the weak attraction u LJ P as a . perturbation over a reference system having an interaction potential u LJ R The free energy of the solid is determined by evaluating the RHS of eqn. (2.4.22). As a typical case the first term on the RHS for the free energy of a hard-sphere system is computed using the MWDA method. The second term is a mean-field term (de Kuijper et al., 1990) that depends on the pair correlation function gHS (r ) of the uniform hard-sphere fluid of diameter dE . The third term depends on the density function of the inhomogeneous system and on the form of the c(n) . For simplicity we neglect the higher-order terms in c(n) (n > 2). Estimations of c(2) are made for large and small distances with simple approximations. For short distances both systems have a hard core and hence c(2) → 0. This ensures that the self-interaction does not influence the results. On the other hand, for large r , e.g., beyond the potential-well minimum at σ0 , the direct correlation functions are approximately equal to the potentials and hence the difference is simply w(r ). Over intermediate distances of the order of the diameter of the equivalent hard sphere, c(2) (r ) is different. The following approximation for c(2) has been used (Curtain and Ashcroft, 1986): ⎧ ⎪ 0 < r < rnn , ⎪ ⎨ 0, (2) (2.4.25) c = −β0 , rnn ≤ r < 21/6 , ⎪ ⎪ ⎩−βw(r ), 21/6 ≤ r, where rnn is a parameter related to the inter-particle spacing in the crystal and 0 is the depth of the potential well. The free energy of the stable solid is obtained by minimizing it with respect to the variations of the parameters of the density function n(r). In Fig. 2.5 the temperature–density phase diagram of the Lennard-Jones system as calculated by application of the present theory is shown. The Lindemann parameter L0 remains nearly constant at about 0.12–0.13 along the coexistence line. Model B A somewhat different scheme for computing the free energy of the inhomogeneous state for systems with interaction potentials having a long-range attractive part has been developed by Rascón et al. (1996). In this case the WCA approach is applied directly to the inhomogeneous solid state and the free energy is computed from eqn. (2.4.11) in terms of the reference state which itself is inhomogeneous. By using the hard-sphere 7 f 2 (r ) functional of the inhomogeneous solid state described above, a better estimation for the mean-field contribution to the free energy is obtained. The calculation of the corresponding two-particle distribution function f 2 requires some special steps. An approximate evaluation of the two-point distribution function f 2 (x1 , x2 ) for the hard-sphere system as a functional of the density n(x) for a Lennard-Jones interaction potential is done as follows.
2.4 Applications to other systems
97
Fig. 2.5 The phase diagram of a Lennard-Jones system obtained from model A is shown as a solid line. The corresponding computer-simulation results are shown as circles. Reproduced from Curtain c American Physical Society. and Ashcroft (1986).
The two-point distribution function f 2 . Since the individual particles in a crystal are sharply localized to their corresponding lattice sites, f 2 (x1 , x2 ) is approximated at the simplest level as the product of the individual average single-particle densities, f 2 (x1 , x2 ) = n 0 (x1 )n 0 (x2 ).
(2.4.26)
The above approximation for f 2 , which is defined in (2.4.2), amounts to neglecting the twopoint correlation in the crystal and is better applicable when the separation |x1 −x2 | is large. To proceed further we need the inhomogeneous density function for the solid state. The inhomogeneous density n 0 (x) for the hard-sphere system is expressed as a sum of Gaussian profiles as defined in (2.2.14) parametrized in terms of the WP αH (say). On substituting this ansatz for n 0 (x) into the expression (2.4.26), and taking an angular average as defined in (2.4.10), we obtain an approximate expression 7 f 20 (r ) for the two-point function: 7 f 2i0 (r ), (2.4.27) f 20 (r ) = i
where the functions f 2i0 (r ) =
n0 4π
f 2i0 (r ) 9
represent Gaussian peaks,
αH wi αH 2 (r − Ri ) , exp − 2π r Ri 2
i = 2, 3, . . .
(2.4.28)
Here Ri is the radius of the ith shell around a lattice site chosen as the origin and wi is the number of sites in the ith shell in the lattice. In deriving (2.4.28) we neglected contributions 2 involving exponential terms like e−αH (r +Ri ) /2 , since for large αH values (corresponding to the highly localized structures in the crystal) such factors are negligible at finite r
98
The freezing transition
values. Note that in (2.4.28) the angularly averaged two-point function is a function of the hard-sphere packing fraction ϕE for the equivalent hard-sphere system. The parameter αH in the expression for f 2 represents its functional dependence on the density function n 0 (x). In definition (2.4.28) above we have not included the case i = 1 corresponding to the peak at shortest r in 7 f 20 (r ). The approximation used in obtaining (2.4.27) is valid at large r but proves inadequate for including the correlations in the system at short length scales. For short distance 7 f 2 (r ) is parametrized using the known thermodynamic properties of the corresponding hard-sphere solid as follows: & " ! 2 , (A if r ≥ σc , /r ) exp −(α /2)(r − r ) 0 0 0 7 (2.4.29) f 21 (r ) = 0, otherwise. The three parameters A0 , α0 , and r0 are determined from the numerical solutions of three coupled nonlinear equations obtained by imposing the following three constraints on 7 f 21 (r ). 6 (a) The normalization of the angular-average two-point distribution function dr 7 f 2 (r ) over the first shell is equal to the coordination number of that shell in the corresponding crystal structure. (b) The virial equation relating the pressure P of the system to the 7 f 2 (σHS ) of the corresponding hard-sphere crystal (σHS is the hard-sphere diameter) at contact applies. f 210 . (c) The average r calculated with f˜(21) (r ) should be the same as that computed with 7 In the scheme for obtaining 7 f 2 (r ) for small r , outlined above, the pressure P at packing fraction ϕE of the equivalent hard-sphere system is required as an input. The pressure is obtained by computing the free energy of the solid with any of the standard densityfunctional methods discussed above for hard-core systems. For an optimum value of the width parameter αH = α¯ in the hard-sphere density function, the free-energy functional FHS [n] of the equivalent hard-sphere system is a minimum. This minimum value corresponds to the equilibrium free energy of the hard-sphere system of packing fraction ϕ. The corresponding pressure P is determined from the numerical derivative with respect to the density n 0 of the free energy FHS at the minimum. Using this value of the pressure P as well as the other constraints described above, the three constants in (2.4.29) are computed. The two formulas, given by (2.4.28) and (2.4.29), respectively, lead finally to the angularly averaged two-point distribution function, 7 7 f 21 (r ) + (2.4.30) f 2i0 (r ). f 2 (r ) = 7 i=2
In Fig. 2.6 the angularly averaged correlation function 7 f 2 (r ) of the hard-sphere f.c.c. solid at packing fraction ϕ = 0.537, is plotted against the distance r scaled with the corresponding hard-sphere radius. For the results presented here we have used the modified weighted-density-functional approximation (MWDA) for computing the hard-sphere free energy. It is important to note in this respect that the value of the equilibrium free energy FHS for the hard-sphere system considered above is different from FR of the reference system. The latter is just a part of the total free energy of the LJ system. The DFT treatment of the hard-sphere system (at packing fraction ϕE for the equivalent system) with
2.4 Applications to other systems
99
6 5
2
~f
4 3 2 1 0
2
r
4
6
Fig. 2.6 The angularly averaged correlation function 7 f 2 (r ) defined in eqn. (2.4.10) vs. the radial distance r/σ for a hard-sphere system at packing fraction 0.52. σ is the hard-sphere diameter.
density function characterized by Gaussian width αH as developed above is solely aimed at determining the functional dependence of the free energy FR and the two-point distribution function 7 f 2 (r ) of the reference system on the inhomogeneous density function n 0 (x). The total free energy for the inhomogeneous crystalline state is now obtained from (2.4.11) for a chosen density n 0 and temperature T of the LJ system. This involves comf 2R in terms of the equivalent hard-sphere functionals obtained puting the two parts f R and 7 above. The density function n 0 (x) is characterized by a width parameter denoted by α. The equilibrium state corresponds to the minimum of the free energy f per particle obtained for an optimum value of α. The hard-sphere system’s free energy for computing f R is obtained here using the MWDA. The free energy of the Lennard-Jones crystal obtained theoretically with the DFT approach described above is in very good agreement with corresponding computer-simulation results (van der Hoef, 2000).
2.4.2 The solid–liquid interface The density-functional theory of freezing outlined above has also been applied for modeling a number of related physical systems. Among those of particular interest to our present discussion is the study of the interface between coexisting solid and liquid phases (Evans, 1990, 1992). The structure of the interface between the crystal and the liquid is characterized by the sharp density peaks of the solid phase becoming gradually broader with a corresponding decrease in height as the homogeneous-liquid side is approached. The density peaks become more strongly overlapping, with the interface appearing like a perturbed liquid and gradually smoothing into the homogeneous-liquid state of uniform density. The nature of the density profiles determines the overall width of the interface. Following the general approach of the DFT of inhomogeneous solids, the density distribution for the interface is determined from the minimization of the corresponding excess grand potential ,
100
The freezing transition
= F[n(x)] − μ
dx n(x) + P V,
(2.4.31)
with the density n(x) approaching asymptotically the uniform-liquid density n l and the solid-state density n 0 (x) on the two sides of the interface. Both phases are at the coexistence values of the set of thermodynamic parameters (μ, P, T ). The first step in the formulation of a density-functional model for a theoretical description of the liquid–solid interface involves parametrization of the density n 0 (x) in the interface region. Following the prescription (2.1.42) for the inhomogeneous density in the bulk phase, we write down the density n 0 (x) in the interface region with the function A˜ m Bm (z)eiKm · x , (2.4.32) n 0 (x) = n l + (n s − n l )B0 (z) + m
with the z axis being chosen perpendicular to the interface. In (2.4.32) the functions B0 and Bm are introduced to take into account the variation of the density n 0 (x) across the interface. The criteria followed in constructing them are as follows. (i) Each of the Bm (for m = 0, 1, 2, . . .) is constructed so as to have values 0 and 1 corresponding to the bulk liquid and bulk solid phases, respectively. (ii) The Bm associated with the corresponding reciprocal wave vector Km must decay over a shorter distance as the magnitude of K m increases. To maintain positive density, it is necessary also that the larger K m is, the closer to the crystal the corresponding function Bm vanishes. We consider here the ansatz for the Bm as follows: ⎫ ⎧ 1, z 0 > |z|, ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎬ ⎨ 1 z − z0 1 + cos π Bm (z) = , m ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ 2 ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎭ ⎩ 0, z m < |z|.
z 0 < |z| < z m ,
(2.4.33)
The quantity m = |z m − z 0 | which represents the width of the density-variation range corresponding to wave vector K m is parametrized in the form K1 ν m = |z m − z 0 | = 0 , 0 ≤ ν ≤ 1, K m ≥ K 1 , (2.4.34) Km with K 1 denoting the smallest nonzero RLV. 0 is the width of the interface. Equations (2.4.33) and (2.4.34) represent an interface slab geometry with the bulk solid phase in |z| < z 0 , the bulk liquid phase in |z| > z 0 + 0 , and the interfacial region completely confined within the region z 0 < |z| < z m . This is shown schematically in Fig. 2.7. The quantities n l and {n s , A˜ m } for a suitably chosen set of RLVs Km correspond to the coexisting bulk liquid and solid phases, respectively. These are inputs for the test density function n 0 (x) to be used in the free-energy calculation of the interface. In the parametrization of
2.4 Applications to other systems
101
Fig. 2.7 A schematic diagram showing the spatial variations of Bm (z) order parameters describing the interfacial density profile given in eqn. (2.4.33) for an interface of width z. Adapted from c American Physical Society. Curtain (1989).
the interfacial density function n 0 (x) depicted above the order parameters all begin their decay from the point z = z 0 . The set of parameters for the optimum density distribution in the interface region is therefore reduced to 0 , and ν. In principle z 0 can also be treated as a free parameter in characterizing the density profile. The function B0 is another variational parameter representing the change of average density in the interfacial region on going from n s to n l . In the present context B0 is chosen to be the same as the order parameter corresponding to the shortest RLV K 1 , i.e., B0 ≡ B1 . With the above parametrization of the density function n 0 (x), the weight function w(x − x ) of the WDA is determined by finding the self-consistent solution of the basic equation of the WDA (2.2.6) or equivalently of (2.2.7) in the Fourier space. The weighted density n(x) ¯ is obtained using the relation (2.2.2) and the excess free energy Fex is computed from (2.2.5). Note that, instead of using the WDA approach described above, the excess free energy can be computed with a direct functional expansion (Oxtoby and Haymet, 1982). However, this requires one to adopt the square-gradient approximation. While this assumption of slow density variation allows an analytic solution of the problem, in the present context this can be avoided in the WDA formulation through the direct minimization of free energy as outlined above. The square-gradient approximation, which involves a different parametric function n 0 (x) for the interfacial density, will be discussed in the next chapter while we treat the nucleation of a spherical droplet of crystal in the liquid melt. The DFT discussed here is strictly at the mean-field level. Hence the role of fluctuations, the existence of long-wavelength capillary waves, and roughening transitions are ignored in the present treatment. The grand potential for the interface is minimized with respect to the parameters {0 , ν} of the density function. In Fig. 2.8 the results obtained for a hard-sphere system in terms
102
The freezing transition
Fig. 2.8 The equilibrium plane-averaged interfacial density ρ(z) defined in eqn. (2.4.35) for the (100) f.c.c.–liquid interface. Solid line, the theoretical result for the hard spheres showing four nonbulk layers; dashed line, simulation results for soft spheres showing six to seven non-bulk layers. The centers of the theoretical and simulated profiles have been approximately aligned. From Curtain c American Physical Society. (1989).
of the plane averaged density profiles at the interface are shown. The average density is defined as 1 d x dy n 0 (x), (2.4.35) n 0 (z) = A where A is the area of the interface. The interface considered here is a (100) plane of the crystal. The value of z 0 appearing in the definition of n 0 (x) is set by choosing it to be at the middle of the two layers of the crystal interfaces. The Percus–Yevick approximation is used throughout for the structure factor and equation of state. This also allows use of the coexistence conditions stated in Table 2.2. The surface energy is given by γsrf = /A, where A is the area of the interface. The numerical computation indicates that the situation of an interface with four atomic layers each of width a/2 (where a is the cubic-lattice spacing) and the exponent ν = 0.25 corresponds to the state of lowest free energy (Curtain, 1989). The surface free energy is
2.4 Applications to other systems
103
Fig. 2.9 Layer-by-layer contributions to the surface free energy βγ σ 2 of the equilibrium hard-sphere (111) f.c.c.–liquid interface. The interface spreads between layer 16 and layer 19. From Curtain c American Physical Society. (1989).
computed to be γsrf = 0.66 ± 0.02 in units of βσ 2 , where σ is the hard-sphere diameter. The (111)-plane-averaged interface is also found to have the lowest surface free energy corresponding to the same conditions, namely a width of four layers, each having width √ a/ 3, and an exponent ν = 0.25. The surface free energy γsrf = 0.63±0.02 is nearly equal to that of the (100) plane. An analysis of the layer-by-layer contribution to the surface free energy of the (111) interface is presented in Fig. 2.9. The largest contribution to the free energy occurs in the middle of the interface. There is also an asymmetry in the free-energy contributions, with the near-crystal region costing more free energy than that near the liquid side. The results of the density-functional model for the interfaces show very little anisotropy, with the surface free energies differing by less than 5%. However, it is useful to note that the two-parameter form of the density variation depicted above does not include anisotropy. The above results on the structure of the interfaces are comparable to those obtained from computer simulations of similar systems. For soft-sphere systems with an r −12 interaction potential the (100) (Cape and Woodcock, 1980) and (111) (Tallon, 1986) planes and for the Lennard-Jones system the (100) and (111) planes all obtain interfaces that consist of six or seven atomic layers of density variation. The surface free energy γsrf for the hard-sphere system computed above can be shown to be in reasonable agreement with simulation results for the soft-sphere systems by expressing the simulation results in terms of an equivalent hard-sphere system (Curtain, 1989). The above method of studying the interface is extended to the Lennard-Jones systems by computing the contribution due to the attractive part of the interaction in the mean-field approximation. Broughton and Gilmer (1986) obtained the surface tension from simulation of the Lennard-Jones system, which showed that the (111), (100), and (110) faces have the same surface free energies. The work mentioned is discussed in Chapter 3, in which we treat nucleation.
104
The freezing transition
The basic step in the weighted-density-functional theories involves a mapping of the inhomogeneous system (crystal) into a coarse-grained system that has inhomogeneity over a different scale (WDA) or has constant density (MWDA). This procedure represents a reduction in number of the associated degrees of freedom at the shortest length scales. The basic interaction in the original and coarse-grained system, however, remains the same here. The present treatment of the first-order freezing transition is in some way analogous to the renormalization-group (RG) approach (Wilson and Kogut, 1974; Wilson, 1975) which is applied to the theory of critical phenomena of second-order phase transitions. For first-order transitions application of the RG has not been common (Nienhuis and Nauenberg, 1975).
Appendix to Chapter 2
A2.1 Correlation functions for the inhomogeneous solid We demonstrate below that the two-point function c(2) (x1 , x2 ) for the inhomogeneous state is related to the pair correlation in the fluid. The one-body potential c(1) (x1 , n 0 (x)) defines the inhomogeneous density n(x1 ) through the relation (2.1.33) or equivalently through (2.1.31). By taking a functional derivative of (2.1.31) with respect to n 0 (x2 ) we obtain the following result for the two-point function c(2) (x1 , x2 ; n 0 (x)): c(2) (x1 , x2 ; n 0 (x)) ≡
δ δu(x1 ) δ(x1 − x2 ) c(1) (x1 ; n 0 (x)) = β − . δn 0 (x2 ) δn 0 (x2 ) n 0 (x1 )
(A2.1.1)
However, using the definition (2.1.9) of the equilibrium density n 0 (x1 ) and taking one more functional derivative of it with respect to the field u(x2 ), we obtain the following result for the average of the product of the microscopic densities nˆ at two points, β −1
δn 0 (x1 ) ˆ 2 )0 − n 0 (x1 )n 0 (x2 ), = n(x ˆ 1 )n(x δu(x2 )
(A2.1.2)
where the microscopic density n(x) ˆ is defined as in (2.1.6) and the subscript 0 on the angular bracket refers to the equilibrium average with the grand-canonical ensemble. The first term on the RHS of (A2.1.2) can be expressed in terms of one- and two-point contributions as follows: /
ˆ 2 )0 = n(x ˆ 1 )n(x / =
0 δ(x1 − xα )δ(x1 − xβ )
α,β
00 δ(x1 − xα )δ(x1 − xβ )
α=β
+ δ(x1 − x2 )n(x ˆ 1 )0 0
= n 0 (x1 )n 0 (x2 )g(x1 , x2 ) + n 0 (x1 )δ(x1 − x2 ), 105
(A2.1.3)
106
Appendix to Chapter 2
where we have used the definition (1.2.58) for the pair correlation function introduced in Chapter 1. Using (A2.1.3), the above relation (A2.1.2) reduces to the form β −1
δn 0 (x1 ) = h(x1 , x2 )n 0 (x1 )n 0 (x2 ) + n 0 (x1 )δ(x1 − x2 ). δu(x2 )
(A2.1.4)
We now use the two functional derivatives in eqns. (A2.1.1) and (A2.1.4) in the functional identity (u(x) and n 0 (x) being uniquely related to each other)
δu(x1 ) δu(x1 ) δn 0 (x3 ) dx3 (A2.1.5) = = δ(x1 − x2 ), δn 0 (x3 ) δu(x2 ) δu(x2 ) to obtain the following integral relation of the two-point kernel c(2) (x1 , x2 ) with h(x1 , x2 ) = g(x1 , x2 ) − 1: (2) h(x1 , x2 ) = c (x1 , x2 ) + dx3 {c(2) (x1 , x3 )}h(x3 , x2 )n 0 (x3 ). (A2.1.6) For the isotropic homogeneous liquid with constant density the relation (A2.1.6) reduces to the standard Ornstein–Zernike relation (1.2.89) presented in Chapter 1. The kernel function c(2) appearing in eqn. (2.1.37) is now evaluated in terms of the pair correlation function g(r ) or the static structure factor S(k) for the isotropic liquid. These structure functions are known from various integral-equation theories of the liquid state (discussed in Chapter 1), from experiments or from computer simulations, and form the starting point of the DFT for the freezing transition. Similarly, any one of the higher-order generalizations of the direct correlation function (as defined in eqn. (2.1.36)) (Barrat et al., 1987, 1988) is also related to the corresponding multi-particle correlations in the fluid.
A2.2 The Ramakrishnan–Yussouff model We consider here the deduction and solution scheme of the density-functional equations in the Ramakrishnan–Yussouff model. We begin with the form of the inhomogeneous density function given by ∞ iKm · x n 0 (x) = n l 1 + η + Am e (A2.2.1) m=1
defining the crystalline state in terms of the order parameters η and {Am }. By taking a Fourier transform of (2.1.37) the following set of equations for the order parameters η and Am is obtained: ∞ dx c˜0 η iKm · x 1+η =e c˜m Am e exp , (A2.2.2) V m=1 ∞ dx −iK j · x c˜0 η iKm · x exp c˜m Am e e . (A2.2.3) Aj = e V m=1
A2.2 The Ramakrishnan–Yussouff model
107
To simplify the discussion of the above equations, we define the integrals κm in terms of the rescaled amplitudes ξm = c˜m Am as ⎡ ⎤ dx −iK j · x (A2.2.4) exp ⎣ ξs eiKs · x ⎦ . e κj = V s=0
Equations (A2.2.2) and (A2.2.3) are now obtained in the simplified forms 1 + η = ec˜0 η κ0 , κj ξj = [1 + η] . c˜ j κ0
(A2.2.5) (A2.2.6)
Equations (A2.2.5) and (A2.2.6) together with the definition (A2.2.4) form a set of coupled equations for the order parameters η and Am of the freezing transition. At the phase-transition point the grand potentials for the two phases are equal. By substituting the ansatz (A2.2.2) into the RHS of (2.1.41), the difference of the thermodynamic potential between the two phases is obtained in terms of the order parameters η and Am . Using for the integral the result ⎡ ⎤ ξ2 ⎦ dx1 dx2 c(2) (x1 , x2 ; n l )δn 0 (x1 )δn 0 (x2 ) = n l V ⎣c˜0 η2 + (A2.2.7) c˜m m=0
and some trivial algebra, we obtain from (2.1.41) the following expression for : ⎡ ⎤ 2 ξm ⎦ 1 1 . (A2.2.8) = n l V ⎣(c˜0 − 1)η + c˜0 η2 + 2 2 c˜m m=0
It is useful to note here that the RLV |K j | is expressed in units of the inverse of the lattice constant a and the direct correlation function is expressed as a function of |K j |σ , hence the ratio σ/a enters the numerical computation. Since
1/3 σ (1 + η)n l σ 3 (A2.2.9) = a 3 the input structural entity c j on the RHS of (A2.2.8) is dependent on η. The next step in the calculation is to use a set of RLVs for the crystalline structure. The choice of a proper set of RLVs is related to the symmetry of the chosen crystal lattice whose stability is being tested. For an f.c.c. lattice, for example, the first set of eight nearestneighbor RLVs is given by K1 =
2π {±1, ±1, ±1}, a
(A2.2.10)
√ which is a set of eight vectors, each of length |K1 | = (2π/a) 3. In general the RLV Km is expressed in terms of its components, Km =
2π {±m x , ±m y , ±m z }, a
(A2.2.11)
108
Appendix to Chapter 2
where m x , m y , and m z are integers. The length of this vector is |Km | = (2π/a) : m 2x + m 2y + m 2z . We adopt a notation in which the RLV Km denotes a set of vectors Kmα , α = 1, 2, . . . , 2 p ( p is an integer), forming a shell of radius K m . For all the RLVs belonging to a particular shell s (say) the common amplitude is denoted by As . Hence all the ξi belonging to this shell are assumed to be the same and denoted by ξs . Using this symmetry of the different RLVs belonging to a particular shell s, we simplify the sum 5 iKs · x (appearing on the RHS of eqn. (A2.2.4)) and obtain the following result for s=0 ξs e κ0 corresponding to the case K 0 = 0: dx ωs (x)ξs , exp (A2.2.12) κ0 = V s where ωm (x) =
exp[iKmα · x] ≡
α
exp[−iKmα · x].
(A2.2.13)
α
Thus, for example, with {K1α } being the first set of eight lattice vectors denoted by eqn. (A2.2.10), we obtain that ω1 (x) = 8 cos(π x)cos(π y)cos(π z) and so on. We obtain κ0 using the result (A2.2.13), giving that 1 1 1 dx dy dz exp ωs (x)ξs , κ0 = 0
0
0
(A2.2.14)
(A2.2.15)
s
where the volume integral is performed over one primitive cell of the lattice and the index s in the sum denotes the different concentric shells in the RLV space. For computing κ j for j = 0, we make use of the relation κj =
∂ κ0 , ∂ξ j
(A2.2.16)
which follows from using the symmetry of the RHS of (A2.2.4) for all the RLVs {K j } belonging to a particular shell. With a suitably chosen set of RLVs extending to a certain number of shells, the corresponding amplitudes κ j and η are obtained from numerical solution of eqns. (A2.2.5) and (A2.2.6) together with the defining relations (A2.2.4) and (A2.2.16). The average solid-state density n s and hence the lattice constant (assuming the solid to be free of defects) is obtained in terms of the fractional density change, n s = n l (1 + η) =
4 a3
(A2.2.17)
(for the f.c.c. structure). The lattice constant thus follows self-consistently from the minimization of the free-energy functional. The results are listed in Table A2.4.
A2.3 The weighted-density-functional approximation
109
Table A2.4 Freezing parameters for hard spheres in the Ramakrishnan–Yussouff theory, using the Percus–Yevick structure factor (with Verlet–Weiss correction) for the uniform liquid state. From Haymet and Oxtoby (1986). Number of RLVs Nn 1 8 6 12 24 8 6 24 24 24 8 24 12 48 24 6 24 24 24 8
Lattice vectors (±i, ± j, ±k)
Order parameter As
Lindemann ratio L0
0 (1, 1, 1) (2, 0, 0) (2, 2, 0) (3, 1, 1) (2, 2, 2) (4, 0, 0) (3, 3, 1) (4, 2, 0) (4, 2, 2) (3, 3, 3) (5, 1, 1) (4, 4, 0) (5, 3, 1) (4, 4, 2) (6, 0, 0) (6, 2, 0) (5, 3, 3) (6, 2, 2) (4, 4, 4)
0.0907 1.0436 1.0299 0.9780 0.9427 0.9309 0.8857 0.8540 0.8444 0.8053 0.7767 0.7775 0.7324 0.7081 0.6995 0.7018 0.6701 0.6464 0.6398 0.6103
0.0668 0.0660 0.0644 0.0635 0.0633 0.0629 0.0626 0.0624 0.0620 0.0618 0.0617 0.0615 0.0612 0.0612 0.0610 0.0608 0.0608 0.0607 0.0606
A2.3 The weighted-density-functional approximation Equations (2.2.1) and (2.2.2), which form the basis of the WDA, can in fact be justified from general considerations (Ashcroft, 1996). In order to demonstrate this we start from the following definition of functional derivatives of the excess free energy: δ Fex [n] Fex [n λ+λ (x)] − Fex [n λ (x)] = dx (A2.3.1) n λ (x), δn λ (x) where we have used for the deviation n λ (x) ≡ n λ+λ (x) − n λ (x). The parameter λ associated with the density function n λ (x) specifies the nature or the “path” along which the density is being varied. It follows from the definition (2.1.36) that the functional derivative on the RHS of (A2.3.1) is the one-particle distribution function c(1) [x; n λ (x)]. A suitable expression for the excess free energy Fex is obtained by formally integrating the density along the “path” n λ (x) = λn 0 (x) from λ = 0 to 1. Along this “path” n λ (x) =
∂n λ dλ = n 0 (x)dλ. ∂λ
(A2.3.2)
110
Appendix to Chapter 2
The expression (A2.3.1) for the excess free energy reduces to the form Fex = −
1
dx
dλ c(1) [x; λn 0 (x)]n 0 (x).
(A2.3.3)
0
In obtaining the result (A2.3.3) we also used the fact that the excess free energy Fex is zero in the limit of zero density. In an exactly similar way, by applying the definition (2.1.36) for the case n = 2 at the appropriate density, the following formal expression for the one-particle function c(1) [x, n 0 (x)] is obtained: c(1) [x; n 0 (x)] = c(1) [x; n¯ 0 (x)] +
1
dλ
0
dx c(2) [x1 , x2 ; n λ (x)]n λ (x),
(A2.3.4)
where the functional integration in (A2.3.4) is performed along the “path” n λ (x) = n¯ 0 (x) + λ {n 0 (x) − n¯ 0 (x)}
(A2.3.5)
from λ = 0 to 1, n¯ 0 (x) being some suitable density function to be further specified below. Here c(1) [x; n¯ 0 (x)] is the one-particle direct correlation function of a homogeneous liquid of density n¯ 0 (x). On substituting the exact expression (A2.3.4) for the one-particle function c(1) into (A2.3.3) we obtain for the excess free energy Fex =
dx n 0 (x) f 0 [n¯ 0 (x)] −1 dx dx n 0 (x) dλ dλ c(2) [x1 , x2 ; λn λ (x)]n λ (x), −β
(A2.3.6)
where the function f 0 (n¯ 0 ) in the first term represents the excess free energy of the homogeneous liquid at density n¯ 0 . Using the definition for n λ along this chosen path (A2.3.5), Fex is obtained as Fex = dx n 0 (x) f 0 [n¯ 0 (x)] ! " (A2.3.7) − β −1 dx dx n 0 (x) n 0 (x ) − n¯ 0 (x) W[x, x ; n 0 (x), n¯ 0 (x)], where we have adopted the following definition for the function W: W[x, x ; n 0 (x), n¯ 0 (x)] ≡
1
dλ{λ} 0
0
1
dλ c(2) (x, x ; λn λ ).
(A2.3.8)
The density in the argument of c(2) is λn λ (x) = λ{n¯ 0 (x) + λ [n 0 (x) − n¯ 0 (x)]}. If we demand that the excess free energy is given by only the first term on the RHS of (A2.3.7) in a form similar to (2.2.1), then the second term must go to zero. Using this condition,
A2.3 The weighted-density-functional approximation
111
a defining relation for the density n¯ 0 (x) reduces to the form (2.2.2), with the corresponding weight function w(x1 − x2 ) obtained as w(x − x ; n¯ 0 (x)) = 6
W[x, x ; n 0 (x), n¯ 0 (x)] . dx W[x, x ; n 0 (x), n¯ 0 (x)]
(A2.3.9)
The weighting function w obtained above automatically satisfies the normalization condition (2.2.3). Equation (A2.3.9) also demonstrates the dependence of the weighting function on the direct correlation function of the liquid.
The homogeneous liquid Next, we obtain the relation (2.2.6) for the weighting function in the uniform-density limit. By virtue of the definition of the weighted density function n(x), ¯ the excess free energy is defined as WDA [n 0 (x)] = dx n 0 (x) f ex (n¯ 0 (x)), (A2.3.10) Fex where f ex (n 0 ) is the free-energy density for the homogeneous liquid of density n 0 . On taking a functional derivative of (A2.3.10) with respect to n 0 (x), we obtain WDA δ n¯ 0 (x1 ) δ Fex [n¯ 0 (x1 )]n 0 (x1 ) = f 0 [n¯ 0 (x)] + dx1 f ex , (A2.3.11) δn 0 (x) δn 0 (x) where the prime on f ex implies a partial derivative with respect to the corresponding density n 0 . On taking a second functional derivative we obtain WDA δ n¯ 0 (x) δ n¯ 0 (x ) δ 2 Fex [n¯ 0 (x)] [n¯ 0 (x )] = f ex + f ex δn 0 (x)δn 0 (x ) δn 0 (x ) δn 0 (x) δ n¯ 0 (x1 ) δ n¯ 0 (x1 ) + dx1 n 0 (x1 ) f ex [n¯ 0 (x1 )] δn 0 (x) δn 0 (x ) δ 2 n¯ 0 (x1 ) [n¯ 0 (x1 )]n 0 (x1 ) . + dx1 f ex δn 0 (x)δn 0 (x )
(A2.3.12)
Now, in order to simplify further the above equation, we need to evaluate the first and second functional derivatives of the weighted density n¯ 0 (x) with respect to the actual density n 0 (x). Starting from the defining relation (A2.3.13) n¯ 0 (x) = dx w(x − x , n¯ 0 (x))n 0 (x ), we obtain the following results for the functional derivatives: δ n¯ 0 (x ) = w(x − x; n¯ 0 (x)) δn 0 (x)
δ n¯ 0 (x ) + dx1 n 0 (x1 )w (x − x1 ; n¯ 0 (x )) . δn 0 (x)
(A2.3.14)
112
Appendix to Chapter 2
On taking a second derivative we obtain
δ 2 n¯ 0 (x1 ) δ n¯ 0 (x) = w (x1 − x; n¯ 0 (x)) δn 0 (x )δn 0 (x) δn 0 (x )
δ n¯ 0 (x1 ) + w (x1 − x; n¯ 0 (x1 )) δn 0 (x )
δ n¯ 0 (x1 ) δ n¯ 0 (x1 ) + dx2 n 0 (x2 )w (x1 − x2 ; n¯ 0 (x1 )) δn 0 (x) δn 0 (x )
δ 2 n¯ 0 (x1 ) . (A2.3.15) + dx2 n(x2 )w (x1 − x2 ; n¯ 0 (x1 )) δn 0 (x)δn 0 (x ) We now evaluate the above functional derivatives in the homogeneous-liquid limit n 0 (x) → n 0 and correspondingly the weighted density n¯ 0 (x) → n 0 (obtained using the normalization (2.2.3)). For the first derivative we obtain, from eqn. (A2.3.10), * δ n¯ 0 (x ) ** = w(x − x; n 0 ), (A2.3.16) δn 0 (x) *n 0 with the second term on the RHS going to zero, since * * * * δ * * dx1 w (x − x1 ; n¯ 0 (x ))* ≡ dx1 w(x − x1 ; n¯ 0 (x ))* = 0, ) δ n ¯ (x 0 n0 n0
(A2.3.17)
as a result of the normalization condition (2.2.3). Similarly, the second functional derivative is evaluated from (A2.3.15), giving the following result in the homogeneous-liquid limit: * δ 2 n¯ 0 (x1 ) ** = w (x1 − x ; n 0 )w(x1 − x; n 0 ) + w (x1 − x; n 0 )w(x1 − x ; n 0 ), δn 0 (x )δn 0 (x ) *n 0 (A2.3.18) since the last two terms on the RHS are equal to zero, using similar arguments regarding normalization of the weight function w to those used in (A2.3.17). We now evaluWDA in the homogeneous-liquid ate (A2.3.12) for the second functional derivative of Fex limit by substituting results (A2.3.17) and (A2.3.18) for the first and second derivatives, respectively, of the weighted density function and obtain * WDA * δ 2 Fex * = 2 f (n 0 )w(x − x ; n 0 ) ex δn 0 (x)δn 0 (x ) *n 0 + n 0 f ex dx1 w(x − x1 ; n 0 )w(x1 − x ; n 0 ) dx1 w(x − x1 ; n 0 )w (x1 − x ; n 0 ) + n 0 f ex + w (x − x1 ; n 0 )w(x1 − x ; n 0 ) . (A2.3.19)
A2.4 The modified weighted-density-functional approximation
113
In writing eqn. (A2.3.19) we assume that the weighting function w(x; n 0 ) in the homogeneous liquid depends only on |x|. Upon identifying the functional derivative on the RHS as a two-point direct correlation function we obtain for the homogeneous liquid the relation (n 0 )w(x − x ) −β −1 c(2) (x − x ; n 0 ) = 2 f ex + n 0 f ex (n 0 ) dx1 w(x − x1 )w(x1 − x ) (n 0 ) dx1 w(x − x1 )w (x1 − x ) + n 0 f ex
+ w (x − x1 )w(x1 − x ) ,
(A2.3.20)
where w(x) is the weighting function in the uniform liquid of density n 0 .
A2.4 The modified weighted-density-functional approximation The formulation of the MWDA approach in terms of eqns. (2.2.10) and (2.2.11) can be be justified at a formal level. The analysis is similar to what has been presented above for the basic equations of the WDA in Appendix A2.3. We take the reference density to be a constant, n¯ 0 (x) = nˆ 0 by setting the second term in eqn. (A2.3.7) equal to zero. This leads to the following expression for the effective liquid density nˆ 0 in the MWDA, nˆ 0 = dx dx n 0 (x)n 0 (x )w[x, ˜ x ; n 0 (x), nˆ 0 ], where the weighting function w˜ is now expressed in a form equivalent to (A2.3.9) for the WDA case, w(x ˜ − x ) = 6
˜ W[x, x ; n 0 (x), n¯ 0 (x)] , 6 ˜ x ; n 0 (x), n¯ 0 (x)] dx n 0 (x) dx n 0 (x )W[x,
(A2.4.1)
˜ being the corresponding function W ˜ W[x, x ; n 0 (x), nˆ 0 ] ≡
0
1
1
dλ λ
! " dλ c(2) x, x ; λ{nˆ 0 + λ [n 0 (x) − nˆ 0 ]} .
(A2.4.2)
0
Note that the weighting function w˜ in the present case of the MWDA is different from the weighting function w (see eqn. (A2.3.9)) for the WDA. However, it also satisfies a similar normalization condition to (2.2.3), namely dx w(x ˜ − x , nˆ 0 ) = 1 (A2.4.3) at all densities n 0 .
114
Appendix to Chapter 2
The homogeneous liquid As in the case of the WDA, the weighting function w˜ for the MWDA is determined by considering the limiting case of the homogeneous liquid. Starting from the basic eqn. (2.2.10) for the MWDA, we take the functional derivative with respect to n 0 (x) to obtain MWDA δ nˆ 0 δ Fex (nˆ 0 ) = f 0 (nˆ 0 ) + N f ex . δn 0 (x) δn 0 (x)
(A2.4.4)
On taking a second functional derivative, we obtain
MWDA δ nˆ 0 δ nˆ 0 δ nˆ 0 δ nˆ 0 δ 2 Fex ( n ˆ ) [nˆ 0 (x )] = f + + N f ex ex 0 δn 0 (x)δn 0 (x ) δn 0 (x) δn 0 (x ) δn 0 (x) δn 0 (x ) [nˆ 0 (x )] + N f ex
δ 2 nˆ 0 . δn 0 (x)δn 0 (x )
(A2.4.5)
The first and second functional derivatives of the weighted density nˆ 0 with respect to the actual density n 0 (x) are evaluated starting from the defining relation (2.2.11) as 1 2 δ nˆ 0 ˜ − x ; nˆ 0 ), (A2.4.6) = dx w(x − x ; nˆ 0 ) − 2 dx dx w(x δn 0 (x) N N 2 2 δ 2 nˆ 0 (A2.4.7) = w(x − x ; nˆ 0 ) − 2 dx w(x − x ; nˆ 0 ). δn 0 (x)δn 0 (x ) N N We now evaluate the above functional derivatives in the homogeneous-liquid limit n 0 (x) → n s ( the solid density) and correspondingly the weighted density nˆ 0 → n s (obtained using the normalization (A2.4.3)). For the first derivative we obtain from eqn. (A2.4.6) * 2n s ns ns δ nˆ 0 ** = 2 − = . (A2.4.8) * δn 0 (x) n s N N N Similarly, the second functional derivative is evaluated from (A2.4.5), giving the following result in the homogeneous-liquid limit: * * 2 δ 2 nˆ 0 * = 2 w(x ˜ − x ; n s ) − . (A2.4.9) δn 0 (x )δn 0 (x ) *n s N NV MWDA in the We now evaluate (A2.4.5) for the second functional derivative of Fex homogeneous-liquid limit by substituting results (A2.4.8) and (A2.4.9) for the first and second derivatives, respectively, of the weighted density function and obtain ns −β −1 c(2) (x, x ; n s ) = w(x, ˜ x ; n s ), (A2.4.10) + 2 f ex V giving the following result for the weighting function: 1 n s w(x, ˜ x ; n s ) = − β −1 c(2) (x, x ; n s ) + (A2.4.11) f (nˆ 0 ) . 2 f ex V ex
The self-consistent solution (for the appropriate nˆ 0 ) of (A2.4.11) provides the weighting function for the MWDA.
A2.5 The Gaussian density profiles and phonon model
115
A2.5 The Gaussian density profiles and phonon model Note that the Gaussian approximation (2.2.14) for the density of the inhomogeneous solid used in the liquid-based DFT here can be linked to a phonon description of the solid in a self-consistent Debye model, a one-parameter (TD ) theory for the dynamic crystal. In the Debye model (Huang, 1987) the phonon frequency ω = ck for wave number k < kD or, correspondingly, can be defined for the Debye temperature TD using kB TD = hωD = hckD . The speed of sound in the crystal, both for longitudinal and for transverse waves, is assumed here to be c. The density of states g(ω) in the Debye solid (the number of modes between ω and ω + dω is g(ω)dω) is proportional to ω2 and, in the normalized form, is expressed as 3 3 /ω2 , 9N ωD for ω ≤ ωD , (A2.5.1) g(ω) = 0, for ω > ωD , where ωD is the Debye frequency. For high temperatures, TD /T 1, so that quantum effects are negligible. The energy of the solid in terms of the 3N normal ) modes is obtained 5 ( 1 in terms of the occupation numbers {n i } as E{n i } = i n i + 2 ωi , ignoring any constant contribution to the energy. The partition function for the 3N phonon modes is obtained as % e−β ωi /2 Q= , (A2.5.2) 1 − e−β ωi i where the frequencies range from 0 up to a maximum of ωD . On taking the corresponding logarithm of the partition function, we obtain
βωi −β ωi }+ ln Q = − ln{1 − e 2 i
ωD βωi −β ωi }+ g(ω)dω. (A2.5.3) ln{1 − e =− 2 0 Using the standard thermodynamic identities, we obtain the entropy of the phonon gas in terms of the dimensionless parameter xD = TD /T as ! " ∂F −T S = −β = Nβ −1 3 ln(1 − e xD ) − 4I(xD ) , (A2.5.4) ∂β V where I is the Debye integral, I(x) =
3 x3
o
x
t3 dt. et − 1
(A2.5.5)
The energy of the phonons is obtained as U =−
3 ∂ ln Q = 3Nβ −1 I(xD ) + xD . ∂β 8
(A2.5.6)
116
Appendix to Chapter 2
In the high-temperature limit (xD 1), the integral I has the asymptotic behavior 3 I(xD ) ≈ 1 − xD + · · ·. (A2.5.7) 8 In the high-temperature limit the energy goes to the value 3N kB T . For the free energy of the noninteracting phonons we take only the kinetic-energy contribution E = 3N kB T /2. Using the result (A2.5.4) for the entropy in this high-temperature limit, we obtain for the scaled free energy per particle the result ( ) E −TS 5 β = β f = 3 ln xD − + O xD2 . (A2.5.8) N 2 This form reduces to the ideal-gas free-energy expression (2.2.21) if we identify 9 α 0 xD = π with the Gaussian model of eqn. (2.2.14), 0 being the thermal wavelength. At higher temperatures (hence smaller xD ), 0 ∼ T −1/2 becomes smaller and thus refers to smaller values of α, indicating a lower degree of mass localization in the crystalline state.
3 Crystal nucleation
If the liquid is cooled beyond the corresponding freezing point Tm at which the liquid and crystalline phases coexist in equilibrium, a thermodynamic driving force builds up towards forming the crystal. In this chapter we will discuss how the liquid transforms into a crystal, focusing on how the changes in the liquid are initiated and on the nature of the crystalline region that is formed. This process is referred to as nucleation. The thermodynamic force favoring the formation of the crystal seed in the supercooled liquid competes with the process of forming an interface between the solid and the liquid. The cost of the interfacial free energy therefore presents a barrier to the formation of the new phase. Only when the driving force is made large enough by moving deep into the supercooled state does crystallization occur on laboratory time scales. Thus pure water can be cooled to −20 ◦ C or below without freezing. Our focus here will be mainly on the process of crystallization of solid from the melt. The condensation of vapor into liquid is a very thoroughly studied process that has been discussed in various reviews (Stanley, 1971; Evans, 1979; ten Wolde et al., 1998). For condensation from a low-density gas or crystallization from dilute solution, it is easier to identify the nucleating bubbles since they differ widely in composition from the surrounding phase. In a crystal forming from a melt the nucleating droplet is far less distinct. It is somewhat problematic to define the cluster in the bulk of the melt in terms of a certain set of particles. One possible route is to identify the coordination numbers, which differ between the liquid and the crystalline phase. We will simplify our discussion here by limiting the discussion to one-component systems and also focus on what is termed homogeneous nucleation (Oxtoby, 1992a, 1992b; Gunton, 1999), which occurs in the bulk of the pure liquid phase. We also briefly explore here the issue of heterogeneous nucleation (Turnbull, 1969) started by impurities or occurring on the surfaces. 3.1 Classical nucleation theory In the classical nucleation theory we associate a number of particles with the nucleus of the new phase having a sharp interface with the bulk liquid. In this theory of the nucleation process the nucleus of the crystal, no matter how small, is treated using macroscopic thermodynamic principles. Let us first consider the formation of Ni clusters, each consisting of i monomers, and N single monomers (N Ni ). Assuming that clusters mix ideally 117
118
Crystal nucleation
with the monomers, the number of equivalent states is (N + Ni )!/(N !Ni !). Hence the total change in free energy on forming the clusters, at temperature T , is
Ni Ni Ni G i + kB T Ni ln + N ln , (3.1.1) G = Ni + N Ni + N i
where G i is the free energy of formation of a single cluster of i molecules from the bulk. On minimizing the free-energy cost G, we find that the equilibrium number of clusters of size i is given by ! " Ni = N exp −G i /(kB T ) . (3.1.2)
3.1.1 The free-energy barrier Next we compute the free-energy cost G i for a cluster of size i from the bulk liquid. We assume here that the clusters are spherical in shape and consist of i particles. The pressure difference between the two phases at the interface with principal radii of curvature R1 and R2 is given by 1 1 + , (3.1.3) P = γs R1 R2 where γs is the surface tension. For a spherical interface R1 = R2 = R, eqn. (3.1.3) becomes PrS − P L =
2γs , R
(3.1.4)
where PrS and P L , respectively, denote the pressures in the crystalline phase at the spherical interface of radius r and in the bulk liquid phase. By applying the Gibbs–Duhem relation (1.1.9) discussed in Chapter 1, dμS = vd P S for the crystalline phase, at a constant temperature, we obtain for the difference between the chemical potential on the interface at r and that of the bulk PrS ( ) S S v dP S = vm PrS − P S , (3.1.5) μr − μ = PS
assuming that the volume per particle vm for the crystal remains constant in the incompressible limit. In obtaining (3.1.5) we approximate the properties of the nucleus at the center as being same as those of the bulk solid and the surface tension of the small droplet with curved surface is taken to be the same as that of a plane interface. This is termed the capillary approximation. This applies better for large droplets and is a weak approximation in the case of small droplets. On combining (3.1.5) and (3.1.4) we obtain for the solid-phase chemical potential μrS at the interface 2γs μrS = μS + vm + PL − PS . (3.1.6) r
3.1 Classical nucleation theory
Since 2γs /r P L − P S , the above relation approximates to 2γs . μrS = μS + vm r
119
(3.1.7)
For a spherically shaped nucleating bubble of volume V and radius R containing a total number of molecules i, we have ivm ≡ V = (4π/3)R 3 . The total Gibbs free energy of the nucleating bubble is then given by 2γs S S dN G r = μ d N + vm r¯ 2γs . (3.1.8) = μS i + 4π r¯ 2 d r¯ r¯ Here we take the cluster to be stationary and ignore the rotational and vibrational contributions to the free energy. The difference of the Gibbs free energy from that of the surrounding bulk liquid is obtained as 4 S L 3 (3.1.9) π R G v + 4π R 2 γs , G i ≡ G r − G = 3 where G v is the difference of the bulk values for the Gibbs free energy per unit volume in the two phases, ( ) (3.1.10) G v = μS − μL /vm = μ/vm . Since the crystalline phase is more stable (i.e., μS < μL ), G v is negative. In terms of the number of particles i in the nucleus of volume V , we have vm i = (4π/3)R 3 . Using this relation, the surface contribution to the free energy represented by the second term on the RHS of (3.1.9) is expressed in terms of i, giving for the total free-energy difference of the nucleus of i molecules in the two phases ; 3
G i = vm G v i + aγs i 2/3 ,
(3.1.11)
2 i 2/3 is the surface area of the nucleus containing i monomers. where ai 2/3 = 36π vm If we do not assume a completely spherical shape of the interface, the free energy of the cluster can be argued to have the form (Turnbull and Fisher, 1949) (aϕ γϕs )i 2/3 , (3.1.12) G i = vm G v i + ϕ
where the summation in the second term on the RHS is carried out over all facets of the cluster with corresponding interfacial energy γϕs and aϕ is a geometric factor (which will reduce to a for a spherical nucleus). The expression (3.1.12) for the free energy is schematically written in the form G i = Ai 2/3 − Bi kB T
(3.1.13)
120
Crystal nucleation
Fig. 3.1 Schematic representations of the surface and bulk contributions to the free energy of the incompressible embryo in the classical nucleation theory (CNT). The sum of the two terms on the RHS of (3.1.11) reaches a maximum corresponding to the unstable critical nucleus.
5 using A = ϕ (aϕ γϕs )/(kB T ) and B = vm |G v |/(kB T ). Keeping the shape of the nucleus fixed, the free energy G i reaches a maximum for i = i ∗ , i.e., dG i /di = 0. We show this behavior of the free-energy difference G i (denoted as wmin ) with the number of particles i in the cluster schematically in Fig. 3.1. Using (3.1.13) we obtain 3 5
2 (aϕ γϕs ) 3 2A ∗ = , (3.1.14) i = 3B 3vm |G v | with the corresponding maximum value of the free energy as 5 4 (aϕ γϕs )3 . G ∗ = 27vm |G v |2
(3.1.15)
For the special case of the spherical nucleus we have, for all the facets, γϕs ≡ γs and 5 aϕ ≡ a. The result (3.1.12) for the barrier in terms of the radius R of the nucleus then reduces to the form given on the RHS of eqn. (3.1.9). For the critical nucleus the number of monomers and the barrier heights are respectively obtained as i∗ =
32π 3vm
γs |G v |
3 ,
(3.1.16)
3.1 Classical nucleation theory
G i ∗ =
16π γs3 3|G v |2
.
121
(3.1.17)
By equating the volume of i ∗ vm of the critical nucleus to the spherical volume of (4/3)π R ∗ 3 , we obtain for the radius of the critical nucleus R∗ =
2γs . |G v |
In this case the constants A and B in eqn. (3.1.13) are given by aγs A= , kB T vm |G v | . B= kB T
(3.1.18)
(3.1.19) (3.1.20)
The maximum at n = n ∗ in the free-energy barrier and the corresponding radius R ∗ of the cluster represent a limiting situation. Note that the above expression (3.1.17) for the free energy computed from thermodynamic consideration of reversible processes represents the minimum work needed to form the cluster of i monomers. Furthermore, it is also a maximum with respect to the variation of the number of monomers i. The critical nucleus is therefore in a state of unstable equilibrium. A cluster of radius less than R ∗ (having fewer than n ∗ monomers) is subcritical and shrinks spontaneously. On the other hand, clusters with radius greater than R ∗ (having more than n ∗ monomers) are supercritical and increasingly likely to grow. The classical nucleation theory (CNT) described above involves making approximations that are questionable. First, it assumes that even a cluster of molecular size has bulk-like properties at the center. Second, the clusters of monomers forming the nucleus are defined with a sharp interface between the two phases. More specifically, the CNT uses a surface free energy for the nuclei that is the same as that of the infinite planar interface, whereas the actual interface for the small nucleus is in fact sharply curved. Thus, while the basic ideas used in constructing the CNT capture the essential physics, there is a need for improvement.
3.1.2 The nucleation rate Since the supercooled liquid can be maintained in the metastable liquid state well below the freezing point, considerations of the dynamics become important in understanding the process of crystal formation from the melt. This dynamic process generally involves clusters of various sizes of the new phase gaining or losing more molecules from the bulk liquid. This process is idealized in terms of rate equations that are local in time, controlling the loss or gain of particles from the clusters of different sizes. At the simplest level, namely the description of the rate process of growth (of small clusters), the role of memory is ignored. This essentially amounts to ignoring the correlation in the events which
122
Crystal nucleation
cause the growth or decay of the clusters. The temperature is assumed to remain constant in the steady state as the cluster grows or decays. This implies that the clusters are in thermal equilibrium while the numbers of particles belonging to them change. The latent heat evolved in the process of phase change does not affect this condition. We also assume that the clusters grow or decay by attaching or losing single units or monomers. In the following we consider two cases of nucleation of the crystal: (a) transition from a fluid to a solid, i.e., crystallization from a low-concentration solution; and (b) crystallization from a high-density melt, whereby the growth of the nucleus takes place through an activated process. Nucleation from low monomer concentration Let the number of n-particle clusters of the crystalline phase present in the parent phase at n and n denote the rates of monomer addition and loss time t be denoted by Nn (t). If + − from the n-particle cluster, respectively, the net number of clusters changing per unit time from size n to size n + 1 at time t is given by n+1 n Nn (t) − − Nn+1 (t). Jn (t) = +
(3.1.21)
Equilibrium is reached when Nn (for all n) no longer changes with time. The equilibrium distribution is given by Jn (t) = 0, i.e., n+1 e n e N n = − Nn+1 . +
(3.1.22)
On the other hand, a steady state is reached when the rates of change of the numbers of differently sized clusters become constant, i.e., independent of time and size. This is characterized by Nn (t) ≡ Nns , giving for the steady-state nucleation rate n+1 s n s N n − − Nn+1 . J s ≡ Jn (t) = +
(3.1.23)
In the steady state the rate of change of the number of clusters of a particular size Nn is independent of time but not necessarily equal to zero. The latter is a particular case corresponding to the equilibrium state. Using the relation (3.1.22), the steady-state nucleation rate J s defined above satisfies the relation Nie s i s s J = + Ni − Ni+1 . (3.1.24) e Ni+1 Since the equilibrium density Nie of the clusters of size i is given by eqn. (3.1.2), we obtain from (3.1.24) the nucleation rate 3 4
G i+1 − G i i s exp . J s = + Nis − Ni+1 kB T
(3.1.25)
3.1 Classical nucleation theory
123
Using the Taylor expansions d Nis , di d = G i + i G i , di
s Ni+1 = Nis + i
G i+1
(3.1.26) (3.1.27)
and keeping terms up to lowest order, with i = 1, we obtain from (3.1.25) the following differential equation for Ni :
d d Ni i + + β Ni G i = −J, (3.1.28) di di where we drop from now on the superscript s for the steady state for simplification and i = use the notation β = 1/(kB T ). Now in general the nucleation rate is defined as + 2/3 ai λ+ , where λ+ is the dynamic factor denoting the number of monomers arriving at the nucleus per unit time per unit area and ai 2/3 is the surface area of the nucleus containing i i , we obtain monomers. Using this result for + d Ni d + β Ni G i = − J¯i −2/3 , di di
(3.1.29)
where J¯ = J/(aλ+ ). The formal solution of this equation is obtained by multiplying (3.1.29) by the factor exp(β G i ) and then integrating from an initial point i 0 up to i to obtain
i βG i 0 −βG i βG w −2/3 ¯ dw e w + Ni 0 e −J , (3.1.30) Ni = e i0
where we define the number of clusters Ni = Ni0 for i = i 0 . Now we can further simplify the above expression for Ni by choosing i 0 to be small enough relative to the critical nucleus (i = i ∗ ) that the number of critical nuclei can be expressed in terms of the number of monomers N per unit volume as given in eqn. (3.1.2), i.e., Ni0 = N exp(β G i0 ). Hence
i −βG i βG w −2/3 ¯ dw e w +N . (3.1.31) −J Ni = e i0
Now, for the number of clusters Ni with a very large number of particles we should have limi→∞ Ni = 0. On the other hand, since G i reaches a maximum at an intermediate i = i ∗ and falls to a negative value for large values of i, we must also have limi→∞ exp(−β G i ) = ∞. Therefore, in the large-i limit of eqn. (3.1.30), we obtain the result
i dw eβG w w −2/3 + N = 0. (3.1.32) lim − J¯ i→∞
i0
The nucleation rate J = J¯aλ+ is therefore given by J=
N aλ+ , I∗
(3.1.33)
124
Crystal nucleation
where the integral I∗ is obtained as I∗ =
∞
exp [β G n ] n −2/3 dn.
(3.1.34)
i0
The free energy G n is maximum at n = n ∗ and the dominant contribution of the integral I∗ in the denominator of the RHS of eqn. (3.1.34) comes from values of n close to n ∗ . We evaluate this integral by replacing G n with a Taylor expansion up to quadratic terms, G n = G n ∗ −
* 1 ** G n ∗ * (n − n ∗ )2 , 2
(3.1.35)
and take the limit over n from n = n ∗ to ∞ since the contribution from n = i 0 to n = i ∗ is negligible. This gives 1/2
G n ∗ ∗ −2/3 *2π kB T* I∗ = n exp . (3.1.36) *G ∗ * kB T n The steady-state nucleation rate J is obtained as * *
*G ∗ * 1/2 G n ∗ n n∗ J = N + exp − , 2πkB T kB T
(3.1.37)
∗
n = (an ∗ 2/3 )λ represents the number of monomers that hit the nucleus of surwhere + + face area A0 = an ∗ 2/3 per unit time. The nucleation rate is thus expressed in the form of the general expression ! " J = J0 exp −G n ∗ /(kB T ) . (3.1.38)
The prefactor J0 in the above expression for the nucleation rate is proportional to the number of monomers N per unit volume of the mother phase from which the nucleating cluster is formed. J0 also has the following two components. ∗
n represents the number of monomers attaching to the nucleus (i) The dynamic factor + per unit time. It is given by A0 λ+ , where A0 is the area of the cluster and λ+ denotes the rate of arrival of monomers on the cluster per unit area. (ii) The statistical prefactor Z , called the Zel’dovich factor (Zel’dovich, 1943), * * *G ∗ * 1/2 n Z= , (3.1.39) 2π kB T
is determined by the shape of the free-energy surface. Using the expression (3.1.13) * * for G n ∗ and taking the second derivative gives *G n ∗ * = |μ|/(3n ∗ ). Hence the Zel’dovich factor is expressed in terms of the chemical potential difference as
1/2 μ . (3.1.40) Z= 6πkB T n ∗
3.1 Classical nucleation theory
125
The expression for the nucleation rate J is now obtained in the form ∗
n J = N +
μ 6πkB T n ∗
1/2
G n ∗ exp − . kB T
(3.1.41)
Note that, in the above expression for the nucleation rate per unit volume per unit time, N denotes the number of monomers in unit volume. In order to further simplify the above expression, we need to estimate the dynamic prefactor present in the expression for the nucleation rate. In the case of transition from a dilute fluid to a solid, the dynamic prefactor is determined by taking the ideal-gas approximation for the monomers hitting the surface of the nucleus. The number of particles λ+ falling on the surface per unit time is obtained from the simple kinetic theory of ideal-gas particles in terms of the equilibrium pressure Pe as ∞ π/2 dv φ(v)(mv)(2π ) d(cos θ )cosθ Pe = λ+ 0 0 ; (3.1.42) = λ+ (2πmkB T ), where φ(v) denotes Maxwell’s velocity distribution for the ideal gas. Using the ideal-gas equation of state Pe = Ne kB T and the monomer concentration Ne at pressure Pe is reduced from its value N at the pressure P of nucleation by a factor S, where S = P/Pe . Thus we n ∗ for the nucleus of area A obtain for + 0 kB T 1/2 N n∗ + = (3.1.43) A0 . 2πm S For a spherically shaped critical nucleus the area is A0 = 4π R ∗ 2 with the radius R ∗ given by (3.1.18). Using (3.1.15), (3.1.16), and (3.1.10), we obtain for the nucleation rate J the result 9
2 γ3 2γs N 2 vm 16π vm s J= (3.1.44) exp − , πm S 3(kB T )3 (ln S)2 in which the chemical potential difference μ between the two phases is substituted in terms of the supersaturation as μ = ln S/(kB T ). Crystallization from the melt For nucleation from the condensed phase, the dynamic prefactor in the nucleation rate is approximated using the reaction-rate approach (Turnbull and Fisher, 1949). In this model the process of addition of the monomer to the nucleus is assumed to take place through transition into an intermediate activated state that represents an unstable maximum in the free energy as shown schematically in Fig. 3.2. This maximum at A corresponds to the nucleus in the activated state and is intermediate between the two minima corresponding to the nuclei with i and i + 1 particles, respectively. These two minima correspond to
126
Crystal nucleation
Fig. 3.2 A schematic representation of the free energy of activation corresponding to the process of adding a monomer to a nucleus.
the states of the nucleus before and after the monomer attachment. We assume that the free energies of formation of the nuclei corresponding to i, A, and i +1 are respectively denoted by G i , G A , and G i+1 . The free-energy difference between the states corresponding to A and i is given by 1 f i∗ ≡ G A − G i = f ∗ + (G i+1 − G i ) 2 i dG i ∗ , = f + 2 di
(3.1.45)
where we use the definition f ∗ = G A − (G i+1 + G i )/2. Similarly, the free-energy difference between the nuclei corresponding to A and i + 1 is 1 ∗ ≡ G A − G i+1 = f ∗ − (G i+1 − G i ) f i+1 2 i dG i ∗ . = f − 2 di
(3.1.46)
The steady-state rate of the nucleation J in this case is obtained in a manner similar to that used in formulating eqn. (3.1.23), as a sum of two opposite processes. These respectively ∗ and f ∗ . The correspond to rate processes (at temperature T ) of crossing barriers f i+1 i nucleation rate is obtained as ! " ∗ Ni+1 , (3.1.47) J = ai 2/3 ν0 exp −β f i∗ Ni − exp −β f i+1 where ν0 = kB T / h is the primary frequency corresponding to the thermal energy kB T and ai 2/3 is the surface area of the nucleus with i monomers. Using the Taylor expansions as
3.1 Classical nucleation theory
127
presented in eqn. (3.1.26) and keeping terms of up to lowest order in i, we obtain the following differential equation for the variation of Ni :
d d Ni (3.1.48) + β Ni G i = − J¯i −2/3 , di di where J¯ = J/{aν0 exp[− f ∗ /(kB T )] exp[− f ∗ /(kB T )]}. Note that (3.1.48) is identical to eqn. (3.1.29) in the earlier section except that now the rate of monomer attachment per unit area λ+ is replaced by ν0 exp[− f ∗ /(kB T )]. Hence the nucleation rate J in this case is obtained from (3.1.41) in the form
1/2 G n ∗ + f ∗ μ J = N ν0 n ∗ 2/3 exp − , (3.1.49) 6πkB T n ∗ kB T where N denotes the number of monomers per unit volume. In the above expression for the nucleation rate the exponent term involving the free-energy barrier G n ∗ is further simplified. Using (3.1.17), G n ∗ is expressed in terms of μ ≡ vm G v , where the chemical potential difference μ between the two phases is related to the molar enthalpy h and the molar entropy s through the thermodynamic relation μ = h − T s = s(Tm − T ).
(3.1.50)
We have used here the result that close to the melting temperature Tm , h = Tm s. Using (3.1.50) in (3.1.17) and the definition μ = vm G v , we obtain for the free-energy barrier G i ∗ =
2 γ3 16π vm s
3 s 2 (Tm − T )2
.
(3.1.51)
2 1/3 The exponential factor in (3.1.49) simplifies further with the definition a = 36π vm and the expression (3.1.16) for i ∗ . We obtain the following result for the nucleation rate:
2 (kB T γs )1/2 f ∗ −16π γs3 vm J = 2N vm exp − exp h kB T 3kB T s 2 (Tm − T )2
(3.1.52)
for the spherical nucleus. From eqn. (3.1.51) it follows that the free-energy barrier G v to be surmounted for the critical nucleus formation falls sharply as the undercooling of the liquid is increased, i.e., G v ∝ TR−2 , where the extent of undercooling is defined as Tm − T T =1− ≡ 1 − TR ≡ TR Tm Tm
(3.1.53)
in terms of the scaled temperature TR = T /Tm . At T = Tm the barrier G v is infinite, making the nucleation rate zero. To initiate the formation of the crystal seed the temperature of the liquid has to be well below the freezing point Tm , i.e., TR of the liquid has to be large. We now consider this dependence of the nucleation process on the extent of undercooling.
128
Crystal nucleation
Dependence on undercooling The temperature dependences of the two exponential factors in the above expression for the nucleation rate J result in opposite trends. The first factor, exp[− f ∗ /(kB T )] decreases with lowering of T . On the other hand, the second exponential factor increases as T decreases, since the difference T = Tm − T grows with lowering of the temperature. In fact, the latter factor in the exponent produces the dominant effect and for an increase of T by a few degrees the exponential factor in the nucleation rate J changes by orders of magnitude. To see this, we rewrite eqn. (3.1.52) in the form
G i ∗ a0 α 3 ζ ≡ J0 exp − (3.1.54) J = J0 exp − kB T TR (TR )2 using the definitions 2/3
α=
vm γs , h
ζ =
h . kB Tm
(3.1.55)
The constant a0 = 16π/3 for a spherical droplet. In order to obtain this value of J0 the energy barrier f ∗ has to be estimated. J0 is inversely related to the time τJ taken by a monomer to cross this barrier at the interface and become attached to the nucleus. Let us write J0 in the form CN /τJ , where CN is a constant, and hence the nucleation rate J is
CN G i ∗ J= exp − . (3.1.56) τJ kB T τJ is inversely proportional to the diffusion constant Ds and hence directly proportional to the viscosity if we assume that the Stokes–Einstein law holds. A lower value of the viscosity implies a shorter passage time and hence a lower barrier. We ignore the temperature dependence of the viscosity of the undercooled liquid at first to keep J0 within its upper bound. The prefactor J0 is estimated as 1032 (Turnbull and Fisher, 1949), taking the viscosity of the liquid as 10−2 P. The effect of undercooling on the crystallization is demonstrated through a plot of the nucleation rate with respect to the scaled temperature TR . This is shown in Fig. 3.3 (Turnbull, 1969). The curves are fixed by choosing constant values of the parameter αζ 1/3 (≡ 0 , say). Close to Tm , i.e., at low undercooling (TR ≈ 1), the curve for J corresponding to a fixed 0 rises steeply. The curve reaches a maximum at TR = 1/3 and falls off to zero as we approach T = 0. In order to be able to observe crystallization experimentally, the rate J must exceed some minimum practical value, say one nucleus per cubic meter per second (10−6 cm−3 s−1 ). This threshold value for J is shown by a horizontal line in Fig. 3.3. We notice in this plot of Fig. 3.3 that at low undercooling or close to Tm , corresponding to most values of the parameter 0 , the nucleation rate J falls much below the horizontal line and cannot be observed experimentally. In this case for 0 > 0.9 the crystallization practically never occurs through a homogeneous nucleation process. On the other hand, crystallization is almost impossible to suppress for 0 < 0.25. For intermediate values of 0 crystallization can remain suppressed only up to moderate undercooling.
3.1 Classical nucleation theory
129
Fig. 3.3 The logarithm of the rate J in cm−3 s−1 of homogeneous nucleation in the undercooled liquid given by (3.1.54) with reduced temperature TR for various values of 0 ≡ αζ 1/3 . The temperature dependence of the viscosity η present in the prefactor J0 in (3.1.54) is ignored here. From c Taylor & Francis Group, http://www.informaworld.com Turnbull (1969).
The above analysis is based on two assumptions: first, that the Stokes–Einstein relation holds; and second, that the temperature dependence of the viscosity can be ignored. Both are violated in the liquid deeply supercooled below Tm . A more realistic scenario for the crystallization process in the supercooled liquid emerges when we take into account (a) the sharp temperature dependence of the viscosity of the metastable liquid below the freezing point and (b) the violation of the Stokes–Einstein law. This is considered in the next chapter in our discussion of the glass transition. 3.1.3 Heterogeneous nucleation In our discussion of the crystallization process we have so far considered the phenomena to be taking place in the bulk of the liquid phase. This is generally termed homogeneous nucleation. In reality, however, the process occurs in a heterogeneous manner around foreign particles or impurities distributed in the sample. The surface of the liquid droplet is also often the source of heterogeneous nucleation. Turnbull (1950) extended the CNT for homogeneous nucleation to the heterogeneous process by considering the liquid and crystalline phases in contact with a solid substrate. The outcome of this is a modification of
130
Crystal nucleation
the free-energy barrier to the nucleation as obtained in the CNT in eqn. (3.1.17) in the following form: G i ∗ =
16π γs3 3|G v |2
f HN (θ ).
(3.1.57)
The factor f HN (θ ) is the heterogeneous nucleation factor given by f HN (θ ) =
1 (2 + cos θ )(1 − cos θ )2 , 4
(3.1.58)
where θ is the contact angle between the substrate and the crystal droplet nucleating from the liquid phase. This contact angle θ is determined in terms of the surface free energies of the different phases, cos θ =
γLS − γCS , γs
(3.1.59)
where γs denotes the surface free energy of the liquid–crystal interface while γLS and γCS , respectively, represent the surface free energies for the liquid–substrate interface and the crystal–substrate interface. If the substrate on which the nucleation is occurring is identical to the liquid phase we have (γLS − γCS ) → −γs and cos θ → 1, i.e., θ → π. In this limit we have homogeneous nucleation occurring in the liquid and f HN (θ ) = 1. The main implication of the heterogeneous nucleation is therefore represented in terms of a modification of the nucleation barrier. There is also a corresponding modification in the pre-exponential term J0 for the nucleation rate as given in (3.4.7) later. In a bulk heterogeneous process expectedly the factor modifying the nucleation rate signifies the fraction of the impurity sites which has been used up. Gránásy and Iglól (1997) assumed a modified nucleation rate in the following phenomenological form:
G ∗ J = {ϑ J0 } exp − f HN , (3.1.60) kB T where ϑ < 1 is the fraction of molecules active in nucleation. f HN < 1 is the factor representing the reduction of the potential barrier due to the presence of heterogeneities, as has ∗ already been discussed above. From (3.1.17) the exponential factor f HN [G /(kB T )] eqn. 3 3 in (3.1.60) is proportional to γT / T G v , where γT is the surface free energy at temperature T . In the CNT the quantity γT is usually taken to be independent of temperature and this is rectified in terms of the quantity χ (T ) = γT /γs , which is the ratio of the the two temperature-dependent surface tension γs to the bulk surface tension γs between phases. Therefore a plot of log[J/J0 ] against the quantity X ≡ χ (T )3 / T G 2v is a straight line with an intercept on the y axis equal to log ϑ. Using estimates of X from the different types of theories described above, Gránásy and Iglól (1997) computed the corresponding prediction for ϑ in each case. Since ϑ should be less than unity by definition, its values obtained for the various theoretical models are useful for judging the appropriateness of the corresponding theory.
3.2 A simple nonclassical model
131
3.2 A simple nonclassical model We now discuss the process of formation of the critical nucleus in terms of a simple schematic model (Bagdassarian and Oxtoby, 1994) in which the solid–liquid interface is described in terms of a single order parameter. The present model is treated analytically and also captures the important aspects of a more realistic density-functional approach to be described in subsequent sections. The theory involves choosing simple approximate forms for the free-energy profile of the undercooled liquid having minima corresponding to the stable and metastable bulk phases. The single order parameter ψ(r, t) used in the present model is assumed to have ψ(r, t) = 0 for the metastable bulk liquid phase and some characteristic constant value, say ψs , for the stable bulk solid phase. The relative depth of the deeper minima denotes the extent of supercooling of the system. The time evolution of this order parameter is written in the standard time-dependent Ginzburg–Landau (TDGL) (Ma, 1976) form δ[ψ] ∂ψ(r, t) = −0 , (3.2.1) ∂t δψ where [ψ] is the grand-canonical free energy expressed as a functional of the order parameter ψ(r, t) and 0 is the bare kinetic coefficient. The term δ/δψ on the RHS of (3.2.1) acts like a driving force (de Groot and Mazur, 1984) controlling the time variation of the order parameter. Hence the equation δ[ψ] =0 δψ
(3.2.2)
corresponds to a stationary nucleus. Now we write the grand potential functional of the inhomogeneous solid liquid in the square-gradient approximation (Cahn and Hilliard, 1958) of the order-parameter fluctuation in terms of the simple expression # $ 1 dr ω[ψ] + |∇ψ(r, t)|2 . [ψ] = (3.2.3) 2 Using this form of free energy in eqn. (3.2.1), the time evolution of ψ(r, t) becomes − 0−1
∂ψ(r, t) δω[ψ] = − ∇ 2 ψ(r, t). ∂t δψ
For the free-energy density ω(ψ) we choose the suggestive form 3 4 1 1 ω(ψ) = min λ0 ψ 2 , λs (ψ − ψs )2 + T 2 2
(3.2.4)
(3.2.5)
which represents two intersecting parabolas as shown in Fig. 3.4, with their respective minima at ψ = 0 and ψ = ψs . The depths of the two minima differ by an amount T , which is a measure of the undercooling of the system. T = 0 corresponds to the situation in which the two minima in ω are equal, signifying the coexistence of the liquid and crystalline phases. The curvatures of the two parabolas corresponding to the liquid
132
Crystal nucleation
Fig. 3.4 The schematic form of the potential energy taken as a combination of two parabolas as given by eqn. (3.2.5). The height T of the free-energy barrier between the two minima of the free energy represents the extent of supercooling of the system.
and crystalline states are denoted by λ0 and λs , respectively. The parabolas intersect at the order parameter value ψ = ψc , which can be related to the undercooling T by T =
1 1 λ0 ψc2 − λs (ψs − ψc )2 . 2 2
(3.2.6)
ψ(r, t) is the order parameter through the solid–liquid interface. The critical nucleus is represented by eqn. (3.2.2), which represents a saddle point for the free energy [ψ] (Bender and Orszag, 1978). Note that
δ[ψ] 2 δ[ψ] ∂ψ ∂ , (3.2.7) = dr = −0 dr ∂t δψ ∂t δψ so that always decreases while the optimum order-parameter profile is being determined by the condition (3.2.2). In solving this equation for ψ, we note that for the part ψ > ψc we need to use the solid part of the free-energy profile (the parabola with its minimum at ψc ), whereas for ψ < ψc the liquid part (the parabola with its minimum at 0) is to be used. In the above choice of the free energy in the double-parabola form there is automatically the limit in which the liquid loses its metastability with respect to the solid, i.e., ψc = 0. This limiting situation is characterized by the undercooling T obtained from (3.2.6) as sp ≡ T |ψc =0 = −
λs ψs2 2
(3.2.8)
and represents a spinodal in the present model. The basic equation describing the critical nucleus therefore follows from (3.2.4) in the form of a second-order differential equation for the order-parameter field in the steady state, δω[ψ] . (3.2.9) ∇ 2ψ = δψ
3.2 A simple nonclassical model
133
For representing the spherical nucleus we consider a spherically symmetric order-parameter profile. Using the corresponding spherically symmetric form of the ∇ 2 operator, we obtain the following differential equations for the order parameter from eqn. (3.2.2): d 2 ψ(r ) 2 dψ(r ) + − [ψ(r ) − ψs ] = 0, r dr dr 2 d 2 ψ(r ) 2 dψ(r ) + − ν¯ 2 ψ(r ) = 0, r dr dr 2
for ψ < ψc ,
(3.2.10)
for ψ > ψc .
(3.2.11) √ In writing the above two differential equations we express length r in units of 1 λs (i.e., √ √ λsr → r ) and define the parameter ν¯ = λ0 /λs . The two differential equations stated above are obtained by using in the equation (3.2.2) the respective parabolic form for the grand potential function as stated in eqn. (3.2.5). The parameter ν¯ denotes the relative curvatures of these two parabolas representing the order-parameter dependence of the free energy . The crossover value of the order parameter ψ = ψc marks the proximity to the stable liquid or the crystalline minimum. The crystalline nucleus is identified with the order-parameter value ψ > ψc , since in this case the system is closer to the free-energy minimum at ψ = ψs . The order-parameter values ψ < ψc , on the other hand, correspond to the liquid state, which is characterized by the minimum at ψ = 0. 3.2.1 The critical nucleus Equations (3.2.10) and (3.2.11) are solved to obtain the following relation among ψc , ψs , and rc for the critical nucleus: ψc = ψs
1 − rc−1 tanh rc . 1 + ν¯ tanh rc
(3.2.12)
The solution of eqns. (3.2.10) and (3.2.11) under appropriate boundary conditions to reach the above result (3.2.12) is given in Appendix A3.1. The boundary r = rc therefore is a marker for the crystalline phase in this case and is a natural identification of the radius of the critical nucleus corresponding to the condition (3.2.2). As we see in eqn. (A3.1.4) of Appendix A3.1.1, ψin (0) → ψs , i.e., the order parameter at the center of the nucleus approaches the bulk-solid value. The relation (3.2.12) between ψc and ψs is useful in determining how the critical radius changes with the undercooling T . Two limiting cases are of interest here. Near coexistence In this limit the undercooling T → 0 and it then follows from (3.2.6) that ψs → ψc (1+ ν¯ ). Identification of the same relation from (3.2.12) requires tanh rc → 1 and rc−1 → 0. This corresponds to rc → ∞. In order to find the leading-order relation between rc and T , we simplify the relation (3.2.6) to leading order in T as
T ψs − ψc = ν¯ ψc 1 − . (3.2.13) λ0 ψc2
134
Crystal nucleation
Upon inverting the above relation expressing ψc in terms of ψs with the approximation ψs ≈ (1 + ν¯ )ψc , we obtain ( ) ψs T + O 2T . + (3.2.14) ψc = 1 + ν¯ ν¯ λs ψs For large rc , to leading order (3.2.12) reduces to
r −1 1 − c . ψc = ψs 1 + ν¯ 1 + ν¯ On comparing (3.2.14) and (3.2.15) we obtain the relation
ν¯ rc T = − λs ψs2 . 1 + ν¯
(3.2.15)
(3.2.16)
In the above limit of coexistence T → 0 (rc → ∞) we have rc =
2 ˜T
ν¯ , 1 + ν¯
(3.2.17)
˜ T = T /sp is the undercooling of the system relative to that at the spinodal point. where The spinodal limit This is characterized by the situation ψc → 0, with the corresponding undercooling T being given by (3.2.8). In this case it follows from (3.2.12) that tanh rc → rc , i.e., rc → 0, implying that the liquid state is always unstable. In the limit rc → 0 the relation (3.2.12) reduces to the form ψc ≈ ψsrc2 /3. On using this in the definition (3.2.8) for the undercooling T we obtain
λs ψs2 2ψc 2 2 λs ψs2 1− 1 − rc . =− (3.2.18) T = − 2 ψs 2 3 The radius of the critical nucleus rc approaches zero with the supercooling sp corresponding to the spinodal point as, 1/2 ˜T . (3.2.19) rc ∼ 1 −
3.2.2 The free-energy barrier The free energy for the formation of the critical nucleus relative to the liquid is computed in the present schematic model as
∞ |∇ψ(r, t)|2 dr r 2 ω[ψ(r, t)] + , (3.2.20) NC = 4π 2 0 where the subscript NC refers to a nonclassical quantity to distinguish it from the corresponding quantity in classical nucleation theory. In Appendix A3.1.1 we demonstrate that
3.2 A simple nonclassical model
135
evaluating the RHS of eqn. (3.2.20) corresponding to the critical nucleus profile leads to
) 4πrc3 1 − rc−1 tanh rc ( 2 T − 4πrc sp (3.2.21) ν¯ + rc−1 . NC = 3 1 + ν¯ tanh rc The last equality above is reached by using the relation (3.2.12) for ψc /ψs . Using the leading-order expansion of tanh rc ≈ 1 − 2 exp(−2rc ) for large rc the second term on the RHS can be further simplified to obtain NC =
4πrc3 ν¯ T − 4πrc2 + rc−1 sp . 3 1 + ν¯
(3.2.22)
Upon identifying the RHS of (3.2.22) with the surface term in the classical expression (3.1.9) for the free energy of the critical nucleus, we obtain the following expression for the surface free energy: γs = −sp
ν¯ 1 + ν¯
≡
λs ψs2 2
ν¯ . 1 + ν¯
(3.2.23)
The free energy NC and radius rc of the optimum cluster in the present schematic model can be compared with the corresponding results of the CNT. To make such a comparison we need to identify the relevant quantities in the present model with their corresponding counterparts in the CNT. This is done primarily on the basis of the similarities between the expression (3.2.22) for the free energy in the schematic model and the classical expression for the same quantity as given by (3.1.17). Thus rc is taken as the radius of the critical nucleus and T as the free-energy difference G v in the CNT. The surface tension γs is chosen from (3.2.23). Using the expression for the (3.1.17) for G ∗ we obtain the free energy (in units of sp ) as 16π G˜ ∗ = ˜2 3 T
ν¯ 1 + ν¯
3 .
The radius of the critical nucleus in the CNT is obtained from (3.1.18) as
2γs 2 ν¯ ∗ R =− = , ˜ T 1 + ν¯ T
(3.2.24)
(3.2.25)
which agrees with the corresponding result (3.2.17) in the schematic model close to coexistence. For a chosen free-energy landscape (characterized by ν¯ ) and a given undercooling ˜ T ), the CNT expressions for the free energy and the radius of the critical (determined by nucleus are given by (3.2.24) and (3.2.25), respectively. In the nonclassical schematic model, on the other hand, estimates of the free energy and radius of the critical nucleus are obtained by directly solving eqns. (3.2.12) and (3.2.6). These two equations can be conveniently written as
136
Crystal nucleation
ϒ≡
ψc 1 − rc−1 tanh rc = , ψs 1 + ν¯ tanh rc
where ϒ is obtained from the solution of the equation ( ) ( ) ˜ T = 0. ϒ 2 1 − ν¯ 2 − 2ϒ + 1 −
(3.2.26)
(3.2.27)
For a given value of ν¯ the critical radius rc is obtained as a function of the relative under˜ T . The free-energy barrier ∗ (expressed in units of sp ) to formation of the cooling NC critical nucleus is obtained from (3.2.21) as ∗NC =
( ) 4πrc3 ˜ T − 4πrc2 ϒ ν¯ + rc−1 . 3
(3.2.28)
˜ T ) and ∗ (ν¯ , ˜ T ) are determined simultaneously. Therefore the critical radius rc (ν¯ , NC The radius rc of the critical nucleus in the present model can be either higher or lower than its counterpart R ∗ in the CNT depending on the value of the parameter ν¯ and the extent ˜ T . Results for the radius of the critical nucleus from these two theories of undercooling agree in the limit of zero supercooling, i.e., at coexistence, at which rc → ∞. The same behavior is observed with respect to the height of the free-energy barrier to critical-nucleus formation computed in the above two theories. The dependence of the critical radius rc ˜ T is shown in Fig. 3.5. We choose for the parameter on the degree of undercooling ν¯ = 0.5 here. In Fig. 3.5, we see that the predictions of the nonclassical theory can be higher and lower than the corresponding CNT predictions, depending on the undercooling. Both trends are also predicted within the different types of DFT models discussed in the next section. We have focused here primarily on the formation of the critical nucleus. The dynamics of its evolution is also obtained (Bagdassarian and Oxtoby, 1994) by solving the corresponding TDGL equations (3.2.1) for specific choices of the free-energy landscape defined in terms of ν¯ .
−1/2 ˜ T (see the text) Fig. 3.5 The critical radius rc in units of λs (see the text) vs. the undercooling for two values of the parameter ν¯ (see text): (a) 1.0 and (b) 0.6. The corresponding values of the critical radius obtained from the CNT in the respective cases are also shown for comparison. From c American Institute of Physics. Bagdassarian and Oxtoby (1994).
3.3 The density-functional approach
137
3.3 The density-functional approach The density-functional theory outlined in the previous chapter has been used for understanding the nucleation phenomena starting from basic principles of statistical mechanics. Compared with the model described in the previous section, here a more realistic description of the crystal and the liquid state is chosen. In this formulation the interaction potential between the constituent particles in the system is the primary input. As we have seen in Chapter 2 regarding studying the bulk crystalline phase or the interfaces, the grandcanonical potential is minimized with respect to the inhomogeneous density function in order to identify the critical nucleus. In the DFT formulation, unlike in the CNT described above, the effect of curvature of the interface in the computation of the free energy of the clusters is taken into account. The difference between the grand-canonical potentials of the inhomogeneous state (consisting of the nucleating bubble) and of the homogeneous liquid state is optimized with respect to the inhomogeneous density function. This automatically identifies the critical nucleus, i.e., corresponding to the optimum density function n 0 (x) representing the crystal nucleus in the melt, we have [n 0 (x)] = l + G ∗ ,
(3.3.1)
where G ∗ denotes the free energy required for the formation of the critical nucleus (see eqn. (3.1.15) in the discussion of the CNT above). In formulating the appropriate DFT for the present case it is important to notice that the critical nucleus is in fact dynamically unstable. However, this instability is with respect to the variation of the number of monomers in the critical nucleus, which can either grow or shrink as a result of fluctuations in the number of monomers. This is therefore relevant when the grand-canonical ensemble is used to describe the critical nucleus (with a fixed number of particles, on the other hand, the critical nucleus is the state of minimum free energy and hence corresponds to a thermodynamically stable state). The critical nucleus represents a saddle point in the function space of density, having one unstable direction with respect to the particle number. Hence the optimum density distribution of the critical nucleus is determined from the solution of the Euler–Lagrange equation
δ = 0. (3.3.2) δn(r) n(r)=n 0 (r) The identification of the critical nucleus and its size as depicted through the optimum density profile follows in a natural way from the optimization of the thermodynamic function in the DFT approach to this problem. However, it is still a mean-field approach and the treatment of the smallest clusters containing a few molecules can only be approximate.
3.3.1 The square-gradient approximation A crucial ingredient of the DFT is the choice of the test density function with respect to which the appropriate thermodynamic functional is minimized. We have discussed in
138
Crystal nucleation
the previous chapter (see, for example, eqn. (2.4.32)) how the density-functional model is extended to study the plane interface of the liquid and the crystal. The parametrization of the density function for the critical nucleus is done in a manner similar to that done in the DFT studies for the plane interface of the liquid and crystal. The spatial dependences of the parameters in the inhomogeneous density function characterizing the nucleus are chosen in such a manner that, away from the surface of the nucleus, near the center, the structure is crystalline, while at large radial distances the uniform liquid state of the melt is obtained. A typical example follows from the ansatz (2.1.42) for the density function generalized in the following manner for the spherical nucleus (Harrowell and Oxtoby, 1984): iKm · r Am (r )e , (3.3.3) n 0 (r) = n l 1 + η(r ) + m
in terms of a set of local order parameters, γ (r) ≡ {η(r ), Ai (r )}. The corresponding boundary conditions are η(r → ∞) = 0 for the liquid state and η(r → 0) = (n s − n l )/n l , which is the fractional change of density on solidification, n s being the average density of the solid state. In the discussion below we generalize this approach. We assume that the inhomogeneous density function n 0 (r; γ ) is parametrized in terms of locally varying amplitudes denoted by γ ≡ {γi (r)} for i = 1, . . . , m. The γi form a set of local order parameters. The grand potential function for the inhomogeneous state is computed within the square-gradient approximation. The latter is applied to evaluate the nonlocal contributions to the thermodynamic potential involving the densities at two different spatial points. To illustrate this approximation, we consider the local and nonlocal parts of [n(r)], [n] = Fid + Fex − μ n(r)dr. (3.3.4) The subscripts of the first and second terms on the RHS denote the ideal and the excess parts of the Helmholtz free energy, respectively. The ideal part Fid is represented in terms of a local functional of the density and the interaction or the excess part Fex involves nonlocal contributions. For the uniform state with constant order parameters these are given in Chapter 2 in eqns. (2.1.27) and (2.1.38), respectively. The grand potential of the inhomogeneous state corresponding to the density function n 0 (x, {γi }) is obtained in terms of a functional Taylor-series expansion around the uniform liquid state.
n 0 (x1 ; γ ) − dx1 (n 0 (x1 ; γ ) − n l ) β = dx1 n 0 (x1 ; γ )ln nl 1 + (3.3.5) dx1 dx2 c(x1 , x2 )δn 0 (x2 ; γ (x2 ))δn 0 (x1 ; γ (x1 )) + · · ·, 2 where the direct correlation function c(r ) (Ohnesorge et al., 1991) is defined as
δ 2 Fex [n 0 ] c(x1 , x2 ) = −β . δn 0 (x1 ; γ )δn 0 (x2 ; γ ) n l
(3.3.6)
The above expression is similar to the expansion around the uniform liquid state shown in eqn. (2.1.41) in Chapter 2. Note that the RHS of (3.3.5) involves the inhomogeneous
3.3 The density-functional approach
139
densities and hence the corresponding order parameters γi at two different spatial points x1 and x2 in the interaction part. This part is simplified by adding to the local contribution corrections evaluated within the square-gradient approximation. On expanding the amplitudes {γ } up to second order in spatial derivatives, we obtain for the ith member of the set 1 (3.3.7) γi (x2 ) = γi (x1 ) + {x21 · ∇}γi (x1 ) + {x21 · ∇}2 γi (x1 ), 2 where x2 − x1 = x21 and ∇ indicates the derivatives with respect to the spatial variation of the local order parameters. The density δn 0 (x2 ; γ (x2 )) is now expressed within the above square-gradient approximation as
∂n 0 (x2 ) 1 {x21 · ∇}γi + {x21 · ∇}2 γi n 0 (x2 ; γ (x2 )) = n 0 (x2 ; γ (x1 )) + ∂γi 2 i
+
1 ∂ 2 n 0 (x2 ) 2
∂γi ∂γ j
ij
{x21 · ∇}2 γi γ j ,
(3.3.8)
where ∂n 0 (x2 )/∂γi denotes the partial derivative of the density n 0 (x2 ; γ (x1 )) with respect to its dependence on the order parameter γi . We will assume here a linear dependence of the field γi on the density function (similar to the relation (2.4.32) stated above for the interface problem) and hence ignore contributions from the last term on the RHS of (3.3.8). Substituting (3.3.8) for the density fluctuation δn 0 (x2 ; γ (x2 )) reduces (3.3.5) to the form
n 0 (x1 ; γ ) − dx1 (n 0 (x1 ; γ ) − n l ) β = dx1 n 0 (x1 ; γ )ln nl 1 dx1 dx2 c(x1 , x2 )δn 0 (x2 ; γ (x1 ))δn 0 (x1 ; γ (x1 )) + 2 ∂n 0 (x2 ) 1 c(x1 , x2 )δn 0 (x1 ; γ (x1 )){x21 · ∇}2 γi . (3.3.9) dx1 dx2 + 4 ∂γi i
In obtaining the above result we have set the contribution from the linear term in the expansion (3.3.7) to zero using the fact that the spatial Fourier transform c(k) of the direct correlation function c(r ) at the RLV is c (K n ) = 0 since the Kn correspond to peaks of the structure factor. Let us consider the different terms on the RHS of (3.3.9). (a) The first three terms on the RHS of (3.3.9) constitute to leading orders a contribution that is expressed in terms of a grand potential density D(x) as 3
n 0 (x1 ; γ (x1 )) − δn 0 (x1 ; γ (x1 )) β u [γ ] = dx1 n 0 (x1 ; γ (x1 )) ln nl 4 1 dx2 c(x1 , x2 )δn 0 (x2 ; γ (x1 ))δn 0 (x1 ; γ (x1 )) + 2 ≡ dx D[γi (x)]. (3.3.10)
140
Crystal nucleation
D involves the order parameter γi (x) only locally. This part of the grand potential is denoted as u with the subscript u signifying the fact that the functional dependence of u is the same as that for the uniform system with constant order parameters. In (3.3.9) u is being evaluated with the Ramakrishnan–Yussouff functional Taylor-series expansion. Alternatively, this local contribution can be computed using the MWDA in the same manner as formulated for the bulk phases, for a more accurate evaluation of the grand potential. (b) The last term on the RHS of (3.3.9) is further simplified with a partial integration and using the substitution ∇α n 0 (x1 ; γ (x1 )) =
∂n 0 (x1 ) j
∂γ j
∇α γ j (x1 ),
(3.3.11)
where ∇α denotes the spatial derivative with respect to the corresponding spatial component xα . The coefficient of the square-gradient term, i.e., of ∇α γi ∇β γ j , is expressed αβ as a kernel #i j . The latter is evaluated to leading order in terms of the integral per6 formed with V −1 dx1 and is expressed in terms of the local order parameters γ (x), αβ #i j [γ (x)]
kB T =− 4V
β
α x21 x21
∂n 0 (x2 ) ∂n 0 (x1 ) c(x1 , x2 ; γ (x))dx1 dx2 . ∂γi ∂γ j
(3.3.12)
On combining the above terms we therefore obtain the following result for the difference between the grand potential of the inhomogeneous state and that of the uniform liquid: = kB T
⎧ ⎨
dx D[γi (x)] + ⎩
αβ i, j
αβ
⎫ ⎬
#i j [γ (x)]∇α γi (x)∇β γ j (x) . ⎭
(3.3.13)
Thus, in summary, the first term on the RHS of (3.3.13) represents the thermodynamic potential obtained as a local functional of the order parameter γ (x) while the second term represents the contribution (evaluated within the square-gradient approximation) due to the variation of the local amplitudes γi through the interface region. The critical nucleus is identified by optimizing the thermodynamic grand-canonical potential , i.e., solving the corresponding Euler–Lagrange equation (3.3.2). In the present context these equations simplify to ordinary differential equations,
δ = 0. δγi (r)
(3.3.14)
3.3 The density-functional approach
141
The corresponding choice for the set of order parameters represents a saddle point for [n] in the function space of density. The ordinary differential equations obtained for the order parameters are given by αβ ∂ ∂ αβ D[γ ] + # [γ ]{∇α γi (x)∇β γ j (x)} ∂γi ∂γ j i j j # $ αβ αβ − #i j [γ ]∇α ∇β γ j (x) − ∇α #i j [γ ] ∇β γ j (x) = 0
(3.3.15)
for the index i = 1, . . . , m running over the set. The above equations represent the spatial variation of the local amplitudes γi across the crystal–liquid interface in the critical nucleus. From what we have described above, the first step in the construction of the densityfunctional model of the nucleus in the melt therefore involves constructing (a) the density function parametrized in terms of a set of local order parameters that are chosen so as to represent a spherical nucleus in the melt and (b) the proper grand-canonical potential as a functional of the inhomogeneous density function. In the simplest approximation the first term in (3.3.13) is computed in terms of a low-order functional Taylor-series expansion of the Ramakrishnan and Yussouff (1979) model described in Chapter 2. However, this would imply an ad-hoc truncation of the density expansion for the crystalline state in which the density fluctuations are not small. Alternatively, u is computed using the more sophisticated weighted-density-functional methods described in Chapter 2. We consider both cases here.
3.3.2 The critical nucleus In the simplest approximation u is computed (Harrowell and Oxtoby, 1984) in terms of the expansion (3.3.10) around the uniform liquid state and keeping terms of up to second order in the density fluctuations around the uniform liquid state. The functional is to be optimized with respect to a suitably chosen density function, which represents the crystal nucleus. We consider for the density n 0 (r) representing the spherical nucleus the functional form (3.3.3) with the local amplitudes γ (r) ≡ {η(r), Ai (r)} being functions solely of the radial distance r . This implies spherical symmetry for the order parameters but not for the density function itself. Using the parametrization (3.3.3), we obtain for the density fluctuation δn 0 (x; γ ) = n 0 (x; γ ) − n l of the inhomogeneous state around the uniform liquid state density n l δn 0 (x2 ; γ (x1 )) = n l η(x1 ) +
i
Ai (x1 )e
iKi · x2
.
(3.3.16)
142
Crystal nucleation
On substituting (3.3.17) into (3.3.10), the grand potential function u is obtained as ⎤ & ' ⎡ ˜ + Ai (x)eiKi · x ln ⎣η(x) A j (x)eiK j · x ⎦ u = n l dx η(x) ˜ + − nl
i
&
dx η(x) +
' Ai (x)eiKi · x −
i
& × η(x) +
Ai (x)eiKi · x
'⎧ ⎨
i
⎩
η(x) +
n 2l 2
j
dx
dx c(x, x ; γ )
A j (x)eiK j · x
j
⎫ ⎬
,
⎭
(3.3.17)
where η˜ = 1 + η. Next, with the present choice of the density function, we obtain the following values for the partial derivatives: ∂n 0 (r) = nl, ∂η
and
∂n 0 (r) = n l eiKi · r . ∂Ai
(3.3.18)
αβ
Using the results (3.3.18) in the expression (3.3.12) the kernel #i j is obtained in a purely diagonal form, ⎧ ⎨ c0 δαβ , for γi , γ j ≡ η, 4 αβ (3.3.19) #i j = ⎩ cn δ δ , for γ ≡ A , γ ≡ A . i i j j 4 i j αβ We represent here c(k) as the spatial Fourier transform of the direct correlation c(r ), which is assumed to be translationally invariant for the uniform liquid state. We have used here the notation cn = n l c(K n ) for the liquid density n l and the double-primed quantity, i.e., cn , is the corresponding second derivative of cn with respect to the wave vector K n . It is useful to note the following relations in this respect: 2
d c(K ) n l dr c(r )rr = −n l I = −c0 I, (3.3.20) d K 2 K =0 2
ˆ nK ˆ nK ˆ n d c(K ) ˆ n cn , n l dr c(r )eiKn · r rr = −n l K = −K (3.3.21) d K 2 Kn ˆ n is the unit vector along Kn . The subscript 0 in c0 denotes the same quantity where K for zero wave vector. Note that with the present choice (3.3.3) for the density function the αβ kernel #i j is not only diagonal but also determined solely in terms of the static correlation of the uniform liquid state. The total difference of the grand potentials between the inhomogeneous and homogeneous states is obtained by evaluating the RHS of (3.3.13) in this case as nl 2 2 ˆ β = β u + ci {Ki · ∇Ai (r)} . dr c0 |∇η(r)| + (3.3.22) 4 i
3.3 The density-functional approach
143
Using the above expression for in (3.3.15), a set of ordinary differential equations for the order parameters {η, Ai } is obtained. Differentiating (3.3.22) with respect to η and Ai , respectively, gives −1 iKm · x1 dx1 ln 1 + η + Am e (3.3.23) V = c0 η − βU0 , V
−1
dx1 e
iKi · x1
ln η +
m
Am e
iKm · x1
= ci Ai − βUi .
(3.3.24)
m
Note that the LHS of each of the above equations follows from the corresponding results for the uniform system with local order parameters {η, Ai }. We have used for simplification in the RHS of (3.3.23) the following definitions for U0 and Ui : c0 2 c ˆ i · ∇)2 Ai (x). βUi (x) = i (K (3.3.25) ∇ η(x), 2 2 U0 and Ui are the Fourier components of an external field U (x) that maintains the density profile in a uniform system with the space-dependent order-parameter fields {η(x), Ai }, βUi eiKi · x (3.3.26) βU (x) = βU0 + βU0 (x) =
i
c c ˆ i · ∇)2 Ai (x). eiKi · x i (K = 0 ∇ 2 η(x) + 2 2
(3.3.27)
i
For the special case of the spherical nucleus considered here the order parameters η and Ai are merely radial functions and the defining relations for U0 and Ui in (3.3.25) are expressed with the following differential equations:
c0 d 2 2 d βU0 (r ) = + η(r ), (3.3.28) 2 dr 2 r dr
ci d 2 2 d + (3.3.29) Ai (r ). βUi (r ) = 6 dr 2 r dr In (3.3.28) we have averaged over the angular dependence present in (3.3.26) due to ˆ i · ∇)2 . These two equations are coupled to the two equations the directional operator (K (3.3.23) and (3.3.24) obtained above. In order to solve for the optimum density distribution in the critical nucleus corresponding to the saddle point in the space of the density function, the last two equations are expressed as a single relation, ' & Am eiKm · x1 = c0 η − βU0 + eiKi · x1 {ci Ai − βUi }. (3.3.30) ln 1 + η + m
i
Equivalently, we have, 1+η+
m
Am e
iKm · x1
=e
c0 η−βU0
iKi · x1 exp {ci Ai − βUi }e . i
(3.3.31)
144
Crystal nucleation
Hence the order parameters η and Ai are obtained in terms of the self-consistent equations ec0 η−βU0 dx1 exp {ci Ai − βUi }eiKi · x1 1+η = (3.3.32) V i
and ec0 η−βU0 Am = V
dx1 e
iKm · x1
exp
{ci Ai − βUi }e
iKi · x1
.
(3.3.33)
i
The coupled set of equations (3.3.26), (3.3.27), (3.3.32), and (3.3.33) constitutes the density distribution for the critical nucleus. To solve it the required input is the structure factor for the uniform liquid. The excess free energy per particle of the critical nucleus is then obtained from (3.3.1) by evaluating for the optimum density distribution. We show in Appendix A3.2 that is obtained as ∞ c0 dη 2 ci dAi 2 2 r D0 [η, Ai ] − − (3.3.34) = 4π dr. n l kB T 4 dr 12 dr 0 i
D0 [η(r ), Ai (r )] represents the local contribution to the excess free energy. The latter is obtained from the corresponding functional for a uniform system characterized by {η, Ai }. The last two terms on the RHS of (3.3.34) represent the nonlocal contribution due to the variation of the order-parameter field. In the first application of the density-functional method to the nucleation problem Harrowell and Oxtoby (1984) solved the model equations for a simplified case by setting c0 = 0 and considered only a single RLV, K m , corresponding to the peak of the liquid structure factor. It follows from eqns. (3.3.28) and (3.3.29), respectively, that βU0 = 0 and
d 2 cm 2 d βU1 (r ) = + (3.3.35) A1 (r ). 6 dr 2 r dr η is now an algebraic function of A1 as follows from (3.3.32). D0 exhibits two minima as a function of the order parameter A1 , corresponding to the crystalline and uniform liquid states, respectively. The liquid minimum exists down to the lowest supercooling temperature, indicating the absence of a spinodal point in the present model. From the r dependences on the order parameters η and A1 for the critical nucleus corresponding to various temperatures below the freezing point it follows that the crystal–liquid interface is a few atomic diameters thick and that this is essentially independent of supercooling. With lowering of the temperature the order parameter A1 remains essentially constant near r = 0, being equal to the corresponding value for the solid state. This indicates that the center of the nucleus has properties characteristic of the bulk solid. On the other hand, the order parameter η in the same region steadily decreases with supercooling. Thus for the critical nucleus the structure and average density, characterized by A1 and η, respectively, do not change at the same point in the interface. From the liquid side the crystalline
3.3 The density-functional approach
145
Fig. 3.6 The free-energy barrier A∗ (in units of kB T ) to nucleation vs. the extent of undercooling T , from the DFT (solid) and CNT (dashed) with the capillary approximation. From Harrowell and c American Institute of Physics. Oxtoby (1984).
structure appears first in the interface region and the density changes more inside the nucleus. It is energetically less favorable to compress a disordered liquid and once the order appears it is easier to compress. The free energy of the critical nucleus is computed from the formula (3.3.34) in the present calculation. The result is shown in Fig. 3.6. The corresponding result according to the CNT is estimated from the formula (3.1.17). Here G v (noted as A in Fig. 3.6) was computed using the DFT model. For the surface free energy γs the DFT results for the planar interface were used. Figure 3.6 shows that the dependence of the free energy on the supercooling as predicted in the CNT is qualitatively the same as that in the present DFT model, though the former somewhat underestimates the free energy of the critical nucleus. In the CNT the radius of the corresponding critical nucleus is estimated from (3.1.18). The DFT approach by construction does not assume any sharp interface. However, a radius for the critical nucleus can be defined (Harrowell and Oxtoby, 1984) as the distance at which A1 falls to half of its value at the center of the nucleus. Such an estimate indicates that the CNT somewhat underestimates the radius of the critical nucleus in comparison with that predicted from the DFT.
3.3.3 The weighted-density-functional approach The DFT model for the critical nucleus using a simple Ramakrishnan–Yussouff-type perturbation expansion for the free energy was subsequently improved using more advanced techniques like the modified weighted-density-functional approximation (MWDA) by Shen and Oxtoby (1996a, 1996b). We have already discussed the MWDA calculation of the bulk free energy in the previous chapter. Here we will consider its specific application for
146
Crystal nucleation
identifying the critical nucleus. This involves the identification of a set of order-parameter fields {γi (x)} characterizing the density function for the nucleus forming in the melt. Let us first identify a suitable set of parameter fields in defining the density function. The inhomogeneous density is expressed in terms of the usual RLV expansion in the following form: n 0 (x) = n¯ 0 + n s μm eiKm · x , (3.3.36) m
where n¯ 0 denotes the average density, n s is the average density of the solid and the μm denote the Fourier coefficients corresponding to the RLV Km . Note that the amplitude μm is dependent only on the magnitude of Km . The average density n¯ 0 changes from the density of the liquid (n l ) to that of the solid (n s ). The above expansion (3.3.36) in the RLVs can also be identified with a simple parametrization of the inhomogeneous density as a sum of the Gaussian density profiles centered at the lattice sites Ri , # $ ( α )3/2 2 n 0 (x) = 2a03 n¯ 0 e−α(x−Ri ) , π
(3.3.37)
{Ri }
where the inverse of α gives the width of the density profile. a0 is the lattice constant with the conventional unit cell being in the shape of a cube of side 2a0 and having four particles in each cell for the f.c.c. lattice structure. 2a03 is the volume of the primitive unit cell such that the factor 2a03 n¯ 0 on the RHS of (3.3.37) represents the dependence of the density function on the average density n¯ 0 . The two parametrizations (3.3.36) and (3.3.37) are equivalent to each other (see the discussion accompanying eqns. (2.2.15) and ! " 2 (2.2.16) in Chapter 2) with the choice μm = exp −K m /(4α) for the Fourier amplitudes. Therefore defining the density function in terms of Gaussian density profiles is equivalent to parametrizing all the RLV amplitudes μm (m > 1) in (3.3.36) in terms of the amplitude μ1 corresponding to the smallest nonzero K 1 , μm = (μ1 )(K m /K 1 ) . 2
(3.3.38)
Therefore the two order parameters n¯ 0 and μ1 completely define the inhomogeneous density function. The grand potential D for the bulk system is a functional of the inhomogeneous density function characterized by a pair of values for the parameters {n¯ 0 , μ1 }. For a Lennard-Jones system free energy is obtained as a sum of two different contributions. The Lennard-Jones interaction potential (see eqn. (1.2.117) for its definition) is divided into a short-range repulsive part and a long-range attractive part. The contribution to the free energy from the repulsive part of the interaction is computed in terms of an equivalent hard-sphere system using the MWDA as described in Chapter 2. (See eqns. (2.2.13) and (2.2.20).) The contribution to the free energy from the attractive part of the interaction is obtained in a mean-field approximation involving the pair correlation function for the uniform liquid state. For example, Shen and Oxtoby (1996a) obtained for a LennardJones system at T = 0.6 the stable bulk solid phase for n¯ 0 = 1.04 with the parameter
3.3 The density-functional approach
147
μ1 = 0.85 and the metastable bulk-liquid minimum for n¯ 0 = 0.89 and μ1 = 0. All densities and temperatures for the Lennard-Jones system were expressed in dimensionless units (see Chapter 1). Now let us consider the technique being applied to the critical nucleus. The spherically shaped critical nucleus nucleating from the melt is described in terms of the two order parameters {n¯ 0 , μ1 }, which are treated as functions of the radial distance r from the center. This form is similar to (2.4.32) used in the previous chapter for studying interfaces using the weighted-density-functional model. The spatial dependence of the order parameters fields {n¯ 0 , μ1 } is controlled by the corresponding Euler–Lagrange equations (3.3.14) obtained from the minimization of the grand potential. The optimum order-parameter functions therefore follow from the solution of the simple differential equations given by (3.3.15) as discussed above. The boundary conditions in this case are chosen in accord with the requirement that at the center of the nucleus (r = 0) and at large distance (r → ∞) the order parameters are equal to their characteristic values for the stable (crystalline) and metastable (liquid) phases, respectively. The order-parameter profiles for the critical nucleus obtained in the present case (Shen and Oxtoby, 1996a) are qualitatively similar to those obtained in the model described above, with the Ramakrishnan–Yussouff (Ramakrishnan and Yussouff, 1979) functional for the free energy. The results for the optimum density profile for the critical nucleus obtained with the MWDA are shown in Fig. 3.7. The density profile (n¯ 0 ) decays more rapidly across the interface than the structural order parameter (μ1 ). However, the results obtained from the Ramakrishnan–Yussouf (RY) free-energy functional and the MWDA approach follow opposite trends when compared
Fig. 3.7 The density (ρ) and structural order parameter (m), denoted by n s and μ1 , respectively, in the text, for the crystal nucleus at temperatures T = 75 K (solid), T = 70 K (long-dashed line), T = 60 K (short-dashed line), and T = 50 K (dotted line). Reproduced from Shen and Oxtoby c American Institute of Physics. (1996b).
148
Crystal nucleation
Fig. 3.8 An illustration of Bain’s distortion. Two f.c.c. cells (each of size a) outlined with thin black lines are shown. v, t, and u form an orthogonal triad of vectors. Along the t axis, the atoms are shown with open circles on the t = 0 plane, dot-filled circles on the t = a/2 plane, and solid circles on the t = a plane. With Bain’s distortion along the v axis, the cube outlined with thick dark lines becomes c American Physical Society. b.c.c. From Shen and Oxtoby (1996a).
with the corresponding CNT predictions. The free energy of the critical nucleus and its size obtained with the CNT are less than the corresponding results from the DFT formulated with the RY expansion. On the other hand, the CNT results are greater than the corresponding quantities obtained in the MWDA model. The nature of the critical nucleus is further analyzed by using the MWDA model (Shen and Oxtoby, 1996b) to study the free-energy landscape for the system corresponding to different possible crystalline structures. In this extension of the theory the parameter space for the inhomogeneous density function includes a new order parameter, χ , which refers to the symmetry of the crystal lattice. χ changes in a continuous manner monitoring Bain’s distortion (Bain, 1924) (see Fig. 3.8) in the lattice structure, which is defined in terms of the following set of real-space vectors: a0 a1 = 2
χ κˆ 1 + √ κˆ 2 , 2
a0 a2 = 2
χ κˆ 3 + √ κˆ 2 , 2
a3 =
a0 (κˆ 1 + κˆ 3 ), (3.3.39) 2
where κˆ 1 , κˆ 2 , and κˆ 3 represent an orthogonal triad of basic vectors (indicated in Fig. 3.8 as v, t, and u, respectively). The lattice symmetry corresponds to b.c.c. and f.c.c. for χ √ taking the values 1 and 2, respectively. The RLVs corresponding to (3.3.39) are obtained as linear combinations of the following set of basis vectors: 2π b1 = a0 2π b3 = a0
√ 2 κˆ 2 , −κˆ 3 + κˆ 1 + χ
2 κˆ 2 . κˆ 3 + κˆ 1 − χ
2π b2 = a0
√ 2 κˆ 2 , κˆ 3 − κˆ 1 + χ
√
(3.3.40)
3.3 The density-functional approach
149
Fig. 3.9 The landscape of the local grand-canonical free-energy density (ω) at coexistence temperature T = 83.1 K and n¯ 0 = 0.89. The symbol m denotes the parameter μ1 used in the text. The three minima shown correspond to (a) the stable liquid with m = 0, (b) the stable f.c.c. solid with χ = 1.414 and m = 0.818, and (c) the metastable b.c.c. solid with χ = 1.0 and m = 0.750. The metastable b.c.c. c American Physical solid creates a saddle point near χ = 1.0. From Shen and Oxtoby (1996a). Society.
At fixed values of the density n¯ 0 and temperature T , the landscape for the local grandcanonical free-energy density F in the parameter space of √ μ1 exhibits (Shen and χ and Oxtoby, 1996b) a minimum for a stable f.c.c. structure χ = 2 as well as one for a metastable b.c.c. structure (χ = 1). This landscape is displayed in Fig. 3.9 for n¯ 0 = 0.89 and coexistence temperature T = 83.1 K. In this extended description for studying the critical nucleus, the order parameters which characterize the nucleus are given by the set {n¯ 0 , χ, μ1 }. As the liquid is undercooled below the coexistence temperature, study of the MWDA model obtains the profile for χ (r ) corresponding to the critical nucleus. The spatial dependence of χ represents a substantial b.c.c. √ (χ = 1) of the nucleus character near the interface changing over to f.c.c. structure χ = 2 towards the center. With increased supercooling the b.c.c. character spreads further inside, until at temperature 50 K the nucleus is essentially all b.c.c. We note at this point that the computer studies of nucleation of the crystal from a melt (ten Wolde et al., 1996) discussed next also suggest that in the critical nucleus the interfacial region displays strong signatures of the b.c.c. symmetry while near the center there is f.c.c. symmetry. This changes the surface free energy of the nucleus. For a small-sized nucleus even the nature of the crystal symmetry near the center is changed and is more b.c.c. like. Such a metastable b.c.c. phase has also been seen (Löser et al., 1994) in experiments on rapidly cooled liquid metals whose stable crystalline phase is f.c.c. An earlier theoretical study by Klein and Leyvraz (1986) using a field-theoretic model of the phase transition also suggested the possibility of a metastable b.c.c. phase in the first-order phase transition.
150
Crystal nucleation
3.4 Computer-simulation studies The phenomenon of nucleation of a crystal from the melt has been studied using real experiments as well as computer simulations. There are some obvious problems in making an accurate study of the evolution of the nucleation process experimentally. It is difficult to study in an experiment the formation of the critical nucleus since the crystallite spends only a microscopic time in this stage of its evolution as the top of the potential barrier is approached. Computer simulation, which is a useful tool for studying the microscopic description of the fluid, has also been used for studying the nucleation process. In the present section we discuss some of the recent developments in the study of the nucleation process using such numerical methods. The straightforward approach of simulation for this problem is to supercool the liquid below the freezing point and watch the formation of the crystal nucleus. The free-energy barrier to the nucleation process falls as the inverse square of the supercooling (see eqn. (3.1.17) for the nucleation barrier in the CNT) so that at large supercooling the barrier is low. Mandell et al. (1976) simulated a small LennardJones system of 128 particles to study the nucleation process by monitoring the structure factor. Honeycutt and Andersen (1984) investigated the effect of system size on nucleation. Assuming the nucleation rate to be proportional to the volume, the observed nucleation rate in the simulation is expected to grow with the number of particles. The observed nucleation rate, however, decreased with the number of particles N , possibly indicating that the phenomenon being observed was not homogeneous nucleation. The simulations were strongly influenced by the periodic boundary conditions used in standard molecular-dynamic methods. Subsequent work by Swope and Andersen (1990) considered nucleation with one million Lennard-Jones particles. The study shows that, although b.c.c. and f.c.c. crystalline phases are formed in the early stage of nucleation, only the f.c.c. nuclei grow beyond the post-critical stage. In all these cases the nucleation is studied at deep supercooling (more than 40% below melting). The free-energy barrier to critical-nucleus formation is not small enough unless the system is deeply supercooled and as a consequence the rate of nucleation is too low to be observed. For example, at 20% supercooling in a typical simulation of 106 or so particles one has to wait up to 1030 simulation steps to observe one nucleation event (ten Wolde et al., 1996). Thus without deep supercooling the “brute-force” method for studying crystallization with computer simulations fails. At least 50% supercooling is needed in order to observe crystal formation over the time scale of a simulation. Studying the nucleation of the crystal from a melt using computer simulations at low undercooling (close to the freezing point) when the free-energy barrier is large requires the development of special techniques. In this regard it is useful to identify suitable reaction coordinates characterizing the crystallinity of the system. The free energy for the nucleus is obtained from the probability of occurrence of the corresponding value of the reaction coordinate, and this probability is computed through efficient sampling of the configuration space. By locating the maximum in the free-energy barrier against the reaction coordinate the critical nucleus is identified.
3.4 Computer-simulation studies
151
For characterization of the solid-like phase being formed in the liquid an unambiguous numerical criterion needs to be specified. For analyzing the nature of a crystal structure various methods have been developed (Mandell et al., 1976; Honeycutt and Andersen, 1984; Yang et al., 1990). A widely used approach is the analysis of the Voronoi polyhedron (VP) (Ashcroft and Mermin, 1976) associated with a given particle in the crystal. This polyhedron for a particle is the set of all points of space that are closer to it than to any other particle. It is customary to represent the VP for a given crystalline structure in terms of a set of numbers {n l } ≡ (n 3 , n 4 , n 5 , . . .) called signatures. nl represents the number of faces of the polyhedron with l sides. For a perfect crystal the VP is the corresponding Wigner–Seitz cell (Wigner and Seitz, 1933). Thus a perfect b.c.c. structure is represented by signatures (0, 6, 0, 8, 0, . . .)