Structural Investigation of Historic Buildings
Structural Investigation of Historic Buildings: A Case Study Guide to P...
763 downloads
6355 Views
11MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Structural Investigation of Historic Buildings
Structural Investigation of Historic Buildings: A Case Study Guide to Preservation Technology for Buildings, Bridges, Towers, and Mills. David. C. Fischetti © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
ffirs.indd i
12/18/08 10:26:01 PM
Structural Investigation of Historic Buildings A Case Study Guide to Preservation Technology for Buildings, Bridges, Towers, and Mills
David C. Fischetti
John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
ffirs.indd iii
12/18/08 10:26:02 PM
This book is printed on acid-free paper. ⬁ Copyright © 2009 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. All rights reserved. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey Published simultaneously in Canada No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning, or otherwise, except as permitted under Section 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or authorization through payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, (978) 750-8400, fax (978) 646-8600, or on the web at www.copyright.com. Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, (201) 748-6011, fax (201) 748-6008, or online at www.wiley.com/go/permissions. Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty: While the publisher and the author have used their best efforts in preparing this book, they make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy or completeness of the contents of this book and specifically disclaim any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. No warranty may be created or extended by sales representatives or written sales materials. The advice and strategies contained herein may not be suitable for your situation. You should consult with a professional where appropriate. Neither the publisher nor the author shall be liable for any loss of profit or any other commercial damages, including but not limited to special, incidental, consequential, or other damages. For general information about our other products and services, please contact our Customer Care Department within the United States at (800) 762-2974, outside the United States at (317) 572-3993 or fax (317) 572-4002. Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic books. For more information about Wiley products, visit our web site at www.wiley.com. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data: Fischetti, David C. Structural investigation of historic buildings : a case study guide to preservation technology for buildings, bridges, towers, and mills / David C. Fischetti. p. cm. Includes index. ISBN 978-0-470-18967-2 (cloth) 1. Building inspection. 2. Historic buildings—Conservation and restoration—Case studies. 3. Historic preservation—Conservation and restoration— Case studies. 4. Structural engineering—United States. I. Title. TH439.F55 2008 720.28'8—dc22 2008038581 Printed in the United States of America 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
ffirs.indd iv
12/18/08 10:26:03 PM
Contents Introduction
CHAPTER 1
CHAPTER 2
vii
Acknowledgments
x
Historic Structures: The Role of the Structural Engineer
1
Preservation and Public Safety: Structural Safety of Historic Timber Structures
15
CHAPTER 3
Simplified Engineering
21
CHAPTER 4
Conservation and the Specialty Contractor
41
CHAPTER 5
Historic Timber Structures
57
CHAPTER 6
Watauga Hall and the Montague Building
71
CHAPTER 7
The Restoration of St. Helena’s Church
91
CHAPTER 8
Market Hall Rehabilitation
115
CHAPTER 9
Differential Settlement at St. Philip’s Moravian Church at Old Salem
123
CHAPTER 10 James Madison’s Montpelier
139
CHAPTER 11 Timber, Glulam, and Conservation
149
v
ftoc.indd v
12/18/08 10:25:42 PM
vi
Contents
CHAPTER 12 Tabby: Engineering Characteristics of a Vernacular Construction Material 169
ftoc.indd vi
CHAPTER 13 Relocating the Cape Hatteras Lighthouse
181
CHAPTER 14 Crisis in American Covered Bridges
207
CHAPTER 15 The Timber Trusses of Burr, Town, and Haupt
211
CHAPTER 16 The Cornish-Windsor Covered Bridge
227
CHAPTER 17 A New Covered Bridge for Old Salem
241
CHAPTER 18 The Tohickon Aqueduct
253
CHAPTER 19 The Current State of Historic Preservation Engineering: One Engineer’s Point of View
263
Index
271
12/18/08 10:25:43 PM
Introduction n North America, our built environment of what is commonly referred to as historic structures typically includes everything 50 years of age or older. These structures are as diverse as Montezuma Castle, a cliff dwelling of mud and stone constructed in Arizona about 1150 A.D., to Dorton Arena, the world’s first cablesupported roof system, built in Raleigh, North Carolina, in 1952. The purpose of this book is to help prepare consulting structural engineers and others to deal with issues unique to historic structures. This book will also explore the reasons why engineering practitioners tend to shy away from these projects. Unfortunately, for liability concerns, and other reasons, few American structural engineers have embraced a preservation philosophy that allows for the continued use of our architectural and structural heritage. And yet, with the possible exception of the absence of timber design in some programs, civil engineering curricula in most North American universities should adequately equip the graduate engineer with sufficient skills to address the varied challenges posed by evaluation and condition assessment through observation, measurement, analysis, and testing. The case studies in this book are not totally representative of the full array of possible building types that may be encountered by the great majority of structural engineers. As case studies, they represent the particular experience encountered in one consulting structural engineer’s practice. The building types may be somewhat skewed by my experience in timber design and my geographic location, and specifically, the states where I am registered to practice engineering. This book can serve as a text in preservation courses for students of many disciplines. Whether the curriculum is history, architecture, art history, planning, engineering, construction management, or materials based, there is a need for the students who are anticipating a preservation career to know what to expect from their structural engineer team members or consultants. The seasoned structural engineer will find information useful to projects involving existing buildings to the extent that one may wish to obtain continuing education credits in the field to fulfill registration obligations, or obtain some certificate or advanced degree in historic preservation.
I
vii
flast.indd vii
12/18/08 10:25:25 PM
viii
Introduction
Conservation of our existing structures has obvious economic and social value. The success of various structural engineering solutions can be told through case studies to a wider audience, so that potential candidates for restoration, rehabilitation, or adaptive reuse, do not meet the wrecking ball without a second chance.
EVALUATING A TIMBER STRUCTURE Our procedure for evaluating an existing framed building or roof structure, historic or not, is to apply today’s code mandated snow, live, and wind and seismic loads to various component systems, assuming that no deterioration has occurred. In this way, the original structure can be tested with specific load criteria, against reasonable allowable design values so that the amount of stress in various elements can be tabulated and compared to allowables. By performing a computer analysis, the stiffness in various components, and the continuity, or lack of continuity, through joints, can be included, resulting in accurate theoretical deflections. The computed deflections can then be compared to today’s code mandated limits for structures. Once this process is completed, then a review of the amount of stress in particular elements can be compared against reasonable values that could be expected from the materials used at the time the building was constructed. After structural analysis is complete, then a condition analysis can be made on the basis of field observation, measurement, and testing. Ideally, it is best to have at least a preliminary analysis in hand prior to actually observing conditions in the field. In reality, we often are responding to the client’s wishes to inspect the structure as soon as possible, without benefit of measured drawings from the architect or prior information of any kind. Through analysis and engineering judgment, the capacity of various components can be tabulated to account for deterioration. The theoretical deflection can be compared to the actual deformation of the structure as measured in the field. Each study will be presented with emphasis on the structural evaluation and condition assessment. Each section will include a description of the project and its history, a condition assessment, structural analysis, discussion, recommendations and a description of the subsequent intervention as executed with drawings and photographs.
WHY THE BOOK IS NEEDED Tasks as simple as determining the grades and applicable design values for timber components and how to apply the effects of load duration to the evaluation of historic timber structures need to be included in a preservation engineering
flast.indd viii
12/18/08 10:25:26 PM
Introduction
ix
text. Reservations in the evaluation of wrought iron, and the unknowns associated with determining the capacity of unreinforced historic masonry or archaic concrete systems, are but a few of the issues leading to the wholesale destruction of potentially serviceable buildings and bridges. For example, not knowing the effects on strength of slag inclusions in wrought iron has caused structural engineers to automatically call for the replacement, with new steel, of all the possibly perfectly serviceable wrought iron tension rods in many building trusses and historic bridges. This book will also raise some questions that will be of interest to the research community. Historic structures provide an excellent laboratory to study aspects of structural engineering, materials science, forensic engineering, and building design. This book emphasizes a preservation philosophy that stresses achieving structural safety using traditional materials, based on modern analysis, measurement, and testing techniques. It is not a compilation of available ASTM tests or a documentation of various archaic structural systems. Lessons learned in historic preservation make us better designers of new structures.
flast.indd ix
12/18/08 10:25:27 PM
Acknowledgments y career has been influenced by many people who do not appear in these case histories who need to be acknowledged. Some, such as Wm. C. Vick and Tommy Vick of Wm. C. Vick Construction Co. in Raleigh, NC afforded me the opportunity to work on projects with some of these same design issues. Robert C. Browning, P.E. was an engineer interested, early on, on the work I was doing. My parents Rose and Constantine Fischetti, of course, encouraged me in my career. My grandfather Luigi Rinaldi, Master Brickmason, gave me my first job in construction. I graduated from Brooklyn Technical High School thirty years after my father. The teachers at Brooklyn Tech, most with industrial or construction experience, had a positive influence, particularly Angelo Amatelli, Head of the Structural Course of study. My timber design experience began at Koppers Company, Inc. in Pittsburgh in the Unit Structures Department of the Forest Products Division. I would like to thank Harry C. Smith, P.E. and Einar Orsett, P.E. for their guidance. Over the years many people have typed the various manuscripts which enabled this book to be published: Denise Bowles, Beckie Mitchem, Dolly Foster, Lynn McBride, Tami Wahl, and Connie Harrison. Most important is Gretchen Moog Tippett whose work was crucial in the final production of the manuscript. I want to also acknowledge Jim Harper, my editor, and Nancy Cintron, production editor, at Wiley. This book would not be possible without the work of my daughter Stephanie A. Fischetti who assembled the initial outline and proposal. Most of all I would like to thank my wife Joyce and our family for all of their love and support.
M
x
flast.indd x
12/18/08 10:25:27 PM
FIGURE 6-7 Floors were replaced in the Eagle Block (ca. 1835) in similar fashion to Watauga Hall. (See page 87 for discussion.)
FIGURE 7-10 Lateral bracing consisting of timber poles and framing was installed on both sidewalls. (See Chapter 7 for discussion of St. Helena’s Church.)
Structural Investigation of Historic Buildings: A Case Study Guide to Preservation Technology for Buildings, Bridges, Towers, and Mills. David. C. Fischetti © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
bins.indd 1
12/18/08 3:44:32 PM
FIGURE 7-19 All exterior surfaces were renewed, including the steeple. (See Chapter 7 for discussion of St. Helena’s Church.)
FIGURE 8-4 The technology used is common to the timber period of original construction. (See Chapter 8 for discussion of Market Hall.)
bins.indd 2
12/18/08 3:44:40 PM
FIGURE 8-5 The iron work was restored to its original configuration and color. (See Chapter 8 for discussion of Market Hall.)
FIGURE 8-6 This completed building again houses the Confederate Museum. (See Chapter 8 for discussion of Market Hall.)
bins.indd 3
12/18/08 3:44:48 PM
FIGURE 9-5 The log church has a false chimney and cupola. (See pages 131 to 134 for discussion of the St. Philip’s Log Church.)
FIGURE 9-16 The masonry wall was supported by the mini-piles. Steel bands were used to provide under-slung support to the wall. (See Chapter 9 for discussion of St. Philip’s Church.)
FIGURE 10-1 View of the surrounding property from the attic. (See Chapter 10 for discussion of James Madison’s Montpelier.)
bins.indd 4
12/18/08 3:44:54 PM
FIGURE 10-10 Arnold Graton (shown here) temporarily braced the chimney prior to removing soil and installing jacks. (See Chapter 10 for discussion of Montpelier.)
FIGURE 10-12 The chimney extension provided duct access into the vertical spaces within the chimney. (See Chapter 10 for discussion of Montpelier.)
FIGURE 12-7 The Horton-DuBignon House on Jekyll Island (ca. 1738) is one of the oldest tabby structures in Georgia. (See Chapter 12 for discussion on Tabby.)
bins.indd 5
12/18/08 3:45:09 PM
FIGURE 15-3 The deteriorated members in the Utica Road Covered Bridge were replaced in kind. (See page 213 for discussion.)
FIGURE 15-4 The Old Salem Covered Bridge is a modified Burr. A partial arch is shown here during construction. (See Chapter 17 for discussion.)
FIGURE 15-8 The Bunker Hill Covered Bridge with repairs almost completed. (See pages 219–225 for discussion.)
bins.indd 6
12/18/08 3:45:28 PM
FIGURE 16-3 The cable stayed system allowed for an orderly rehabilitation of the roof structure. (See Chapter 16 for discussion of the Cornish-Windsor Bridge.)
FIGURE 16-8 The governors of both New Hampshire and Vermont attended the dedication ceremony. (See Chapter 16 for discussion of the Cornish-Windsor Bridge.)
FIGURE 17-1 The acrylic panels provided a weathertight sidewall closure. (See Chapter 17 for discussion of the Old Salem Covered Bridge.)
bins.indd 7
12/18/08 3:45:38 PM
FIGURE 18-1 The aqueduct consists of three equal spans of 66 feet. (See Chapter 18 for discussion of the Tohickon Aqueduct.)
FIGURE 18-7 The completed aqueduct won a National Timber Bridge Award in 2002. (See Chapter 18 for discussion of the Tohickon Aqueduct.)
bins.indd 8
12/18/08 3:45:48 PM
CHAPTER
1
Historic Structures: The Role of the Structural Engineer
THE STRUCTURAL ENGINEER AS A PRESERVATIONIST ervices of the structural engineer may include planning, estimating, making structural evaluations, conducting feasibility studies, designing, and consulting. Adaptive use, the practice of renovating or rehabilitating a structure for a use other than that for which it was first designed, involves, for the structural engineer, several opportunities to be of service. Although the final construction cost may include as little as 5 to 12 percent of the total project cost for structural work, the structural engineer may play a pivotal role in determining whether a project will be economically feasible. A structural evaluation will indicate whether structural elements are reused, reinforced, or replaced. Often, adapting a building to a new use requires extensive structural changes to be made in order to make the building conform to current needs and code requirements. A common challenge for the structural engineer is how to construct, within a historic structure, an elevator shaft so that upper floors may be accessible. Seismic retrofit is an important concern facing historic structures in areas where retroactive seismic building code requirements are in force. The services provided by a structural engineer associated with moving a
S
Structural Investigation of Historic Buildings: A Case Study Guide to Preservation Technology for Buildings, Bridges, Towers, and Mills. David. C. Fischetti © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
c01.indd 1
1
12/18/08 10:06:12 PM
2
Historic Structures: The Role of the Structural Engineer
historic building might include a structural evaluation to determine whether the structure can be moved intact, partially disassembled, or relocated in sections. Structural reinforcement or the design of a new foundation might also be required. Registered land surveyors are the most qualified to provide accurate base measurements when the extensive documentation of a historic structure is required.
REHABILITATION GUIDELINES All structural engineers should obtain a copy of The Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation. Under these standards, rehabilitation means “the process of returning a property to a state of utility, through repair or alteration, which makes possible an efficient contemporary use while preserving those portions and features of the property that are significant to its historic, architectural, and cultural value.” Minimum alteration of the building, its environment, and its distinguishing architectural qualities is required for a project to qualify as a “certified rehabilitation” benefiting from the provisions of the tax act. Archeological resources must be protected, as well as significant historical, architectural, or cultural material. An understanding of the historical significance of a building must be obtained to enable the engineer to provide an acceptable solution to a particular design problem while following the “secretary’s standards.” The guidelines for applying The Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation recommend recognition of the “special problems inherent in the structural system of historic buildings, especially where there are visible signs of cracking, deflection, or failure.” In addition, “stabilization and repair of weakened structural members and systems when damaged or inadequate” are recommended. “Historically important structural members” are to be replaced “only when necessary.”1
BUILDING CODES AND HISTORIC STRUCTURES The structural engineer must make a realistic judgment when applying modern building code live-load requirements to a historic structure. For example, how much snow can adhere to a steeply pitched slate or tin roof? How does one rationalize the successful service of a hundred-year-old church roof structure when the forces obtained from the frame analysis appear too great for the
c01.indd 2
12/18/08 10:06:13 PM
The Structural Evaluation
3
connections involved? As in the review and evaluation of any structure, the engineer must make a judgment, based on available information, of the safety of such a structure. Should the engineer call for the reinforcing of a timber floor structure with steel beams when it is safe in bending and shear but exceeds deflection requirements when loaded with a required minimum live-load based on occupancy? The 2006 North Carolina State Building Code, which is the Standard Building Code with North Carolina amendments, includes several provisions for historic structures. In Section 1009, “Historic Buildings for Public Display or Exhibition” and Section 1010, “Historic Buildings for Adaptive Use,” the definition of historic buildings is as follows: General (a) Historic buildings means buildings designated as historic properties. (1) By the state historic preservation officer acting on behalf of the North Carolinian Historical Commission in accordance with the provisions of G.S. 121.8 and NCAC 46.0600. (2) Or by a local historic properties commission constituted in accordance with G.S. 160A.399.2 subject to review and approval by the Building Code Council.2
Included in the code are provisions regarding repairs, additions, sprinkler systems, means of egress, and the moving of historic buildings. In recent years several codes have adopted the innovations and principles of the New Jersey Rehabilitation Subcode commonly know as the New Jersey Rehab Code which was first published in 1997. Chapter 34, Existing Structures in the 2003 International Building Code also includes Section 3407 entitled Historic Buildings states that, “The provisions of this code relating to the construction, repair, alteration, addition, restoration, and movement of structures, and change of occupancy shall not be mandatory for historic buildings where such buildings are judged by the building official to not constitute a distinct life safety hazard.”2
THE STRUCTURAL EVALUATION Structural engineers have been reluctant to become involved with historic preservation projects, often because of the potential liability imposed on the engineer. By merely providing a structural evaluation of a historic structure, the engineer may become “the engineer of record” for a building constructed
c01.indd 3
12/18/08 10:06:14 PM
4
Historic Structures: The Role of the Structural Engineer
with “primitive” methods and materials. Many historic structures were not rigorously analyzed, but proportioned by the eye of an experienced builder or simply built as was the custom. If the engineer becomes involved in even a small portion of a historic preservation project, there must be adequate compensation for the assumed liability. The engineer must be completely satisfied that a structure meets the loading requirements for its intended occupancy, as well as all external forces. Structural evaluations usually include a determination of the ability of a floor or roof system to support these service loads. An existing structure might have to be monitored in order to obtain data for such an evaluation. Testing programs may have to be designed to aid in determining the strength of component materials or complete assemblies. Methods may consist of destructive or nondestructive testing of component materials or load tests of structural members such as beams or assemblies such as trusses. It will likely be necessary to adapt current testing methods for field use on historic structures. Accurate field measurements are essential in defining the structure and its condition. Surveying methods have been successfully utilized in determining the stiffness of deflected beams and trusses. A topographic plan of the floor surface of a historic structure will yield a useful visual representation of an irregular floor if the contour interval is small. Irregular floors in a historic structure could be caused by movement in the supporting soils, timber decay or shrinkage, or deflection of structural components. The ability to interpret the response of a structure to background vibrations and induced vibrations has made vibratory testing a valuable historic preservation tool. X-ray, liquid penetrant, nuclear particle density meters, and ultrasonic techniques are being used to evaluate various construction materials. The correct interpretation of masonry cracks may yield accurate information regarding the location and amounts of settlement or thermal movement. Monitoring such cracks is possible with “telltales” such as glass slides epoxied to the wall surface on each side of a fissure. Even slight movement can be detected by using such a strategy. Accurate monitoring of cracks is possible with calibrated telltales accurate to within one millimeter and electronic strain gauges. Load testing a historic structure may be the only reasonable way to justify conditions or materials that are difficult to analyze. In designing a load test, the engineer must call for the application of realistic loads carefully applied. Great care should be taken before applying twice the design live load, as required by many building codes, to a historic structure. For timber structures it may be unrealistic to apply full live load plus an increase for a period such as 24 or 48 hours, when the structure actually will never reach that service loading for
c01.indd 4
12/18/08 10:06:14 PM
Materials Research
5
FIGURE 1-1 This load test utilized water to determine the average stiffness of a series of recycled joists.
that length of time. Applying a known, safe load to a historic structure is an excellent method for determining the stiffness characteristics of various materials. This is of special value when evaluating timber structures. It is important to realize that because of the variation in the strength characteristics of timber, a load test of one member of a structure may not be indicative of the true capacity in other areas of the building. For any material, before a load test is undertaken, the engineer must be certain that all lateral bracing and slenderness requirements are satisfied. A preliminary analysis must be performed to ensure that the structure will not be loaded past the elastic limit or further to destruction. The application of strain gages and other instrumentation is highly desirable in monitoring a load test. Through the use of monitoring techniques, testing, measurements, observation, and structural calculations, an accurate interpretation of the structural capability of a historic structure can be presented in a carefully written report.
MATERIALS RESEARCH Research may yield information useful in the evaluation, rehabilitation, or renovation of the historic structure. Original plans, construction photographs, and written or oral accounts may provide clues to the original design or construction methodology. Old textbooks or materials handbooks may provide design methods and design strengths of various materials.
c01.indd 5
12/18/08 10:06:14 PM
6
Historic Structures: The Role of the Structural Engineer
The structural engineer must be familiar with the properties of materials such as timber, steel, cast iron, wrought iron, stone, brick masonry, terra cotta, and reinforced concrete. Patented floor or roof systems composed of various materials might appear only in manufacturer’s literature, with little or no design information available.
THE EVALUATION OF CONCRETE Reinforcing steel in older concrete buildings may be square, round, or hexagonal in cross-section with various types of deformations and exhibiting various physical properties. Early reinforcing steel was produced as plain and deformed steel in structural, intermediate, and hard grades. Structural grade was normally used unless specified otherwise. Structural engineers should obtain a copy of CRSI Engineering Data Report, no. 11, titled “Evaluation of Reinforcing Steel in Old Reinforced Concrete Structures.”3 The first specifications for reinforcing steel were developed in 1910 by the Association of American Steel Manufacturers. In 1911, the American Society for Testing and Materials adopted standard specification A15 for billet steel concrete reinforcing bars. Minimum working stresses and yield strengths for these and other early specifications are presented in the CRSI report. The most difficult problem in evaluating historic reinforced concrete structures is determining the size and location of the reinforcing steel. Various instruments now available may be used for such purposes, but should be verified by exposing the reinforcing steel in noncritical locations to visual inspection. Development lengths, bending and cutoff details, and effective depths must be determined. The material properties of both the steel and concrete should be determined by testing. Samples of reinforcing steel suitable for testing can usually be obtained without affecting the structural adequacy of an existing structure if the locations are carefully selected. A preliminary structural analysis aids in locating areas of low stress suitable for sampling. Nondestructive load testing of complete flexural members can be employed to verify calculated deflections. Accurate methods are still needed to aid engineers in evaluating the effects of voids, cracks, and deteriorated reinforcing.
BRICK MASONRY RESTORATION Lime-sand mortar, commonly used in structures located above water level, is of great importance in the repair and restoration of historic buildings. The structural engineer interested in historic preservation should be familiar with masonry restoration specifications.
c01.indd 6
12/18/08 10:06:15 PM
Brick Masonry Restoration
7
Mortar for face brick should match the original mortar in color, texture, density, and porosity. It should have strength equal or less than that of the original mortar. New mortar should have hardness equal to or less than that of the original brick, as determined by testing. The color of mortar used for repointing should be matched to the original by matching the color of original aggregates and mortar components as closely as possible. An archeological search may uncover ingredients of the original job mixed mortar, such as oyster shells, in the soil strata at the site in the builder’s trench, which contains other construction debris. The density and strength of historic brick units are a function of their position in the kiln and how well they were fired. Salmon brick, which are lightly burned, were typically reserved for the center of a wall and the harder, better burned, brick used as exterior face brick. Because of the extreme variations in their strength and durability, the use of salvaged brick should be discouraged. There are manufacturers who can match old brick very accurately and several manufacturers who are making bricks by the old methods. These bricks and a compatible lime mortar design mix are what is required to match the brick masonry of historic buildings. Repointing brick masonry is a waterproofing procedure and not a solution for structural problems. The repointing process is a critical procedure that should be done in carefully selected areas with great care.4 Materials engineers should become familiar with the components of historic mortars, and in that light review the methods for sampling and testing of masonry. The Brick Institute of America, Technical Notes on Brick Construction, no. 39A, reviews procedures for testing brick prisms.5 The standard ASTM methods of tests for masonry assemblages are especially applicable to the testing of historic masonry because of the possible variation in the mortar and brick strengths. The performance of historic mortar and brick can be evaluated in this way, not as individual components, but as they would perform together in the wall. Of course, obtaining suitable undisturbed samples for testing can be a problem with fragile materials. Once a replacement brick is selected and the original mortar approximated, prism testing of replacement masonry should yield information regarding allowable stresses that may be used in design. Mortar analysis and mix design should be accompanied by strength tests that can be evaluated by a materials testing engineer. There has been a tendency in the field of historic preservation to select brick and mortar so that they merely “look” right when placed alongside original masonry. The structural engineer can best determine that strength characteristics of replacement masonry materials are as compatible as the color and texture.
c01.indd 7
12/18/08 10:06:16 PM
8
Historic Structures: The Role of the Structural Engineer
FIGURE 1-2 The entrance gates for Camden (Railroad) Yards in Charleston, South Carolina, were restored and the stucco was renewed.
The use of grinders, sandblasting, sanding discs, or other abrasives normally are not permitted in the cleaning of brick. Irrevocable damage has been done to historic masonry by abrasive cleaning. For example, removal of the outer surface of old brick may expose the more porous inner portion of the brick, which may lead to spalling due to moisture penetration and subsequent freezing.
TIMBER DESIGN AND HISTORIC PRESERVATION Often, the proper analysis and evaluation of a historic structure requires that the structural engineer have extensive timber design experience. Many historic structures in the United States are timber framed. Masonry construction is generally used for foundations, exterior wall support, and building enclosure. A thorough knowledge of the physical and mechanical properties of wood is necessary. Many historic structures were constructed of green timber because of the considerable time required to air dry large timbers. In the seasoning process, timber gives off or takes on moisture from the surrounding atmosphere with changes in temperature and relative humidity until it attains a balance relative to the atmospheric conditions. Historic structures have had time to reach this point of balance, known as the equilibrium moisture content.
c01.indd 8
12/18/08 10:06:16 PM
Timber Design and Historic Preservation
9
Moisture content is the weight of the water contained in wood, expressed as a percentage of the weight of the oven-dried wood. As wood loses moisture, the water in the cell cavity evaporates first. The condition at which the water in the cell cavity has been evaporated but the cell wall is still saturated is known as the “fiber saturation point.” This point is usually assumed to be at approximately 30 percent. When the moisture content is reduced below this point, shrinkage will occur.6 Builders of heavy timber structures usually made allowances for shrinkage in the design of members and connections. The amount of shrinkage may be calculated using tables that give amounts of radial, tangential, and volumetric shrinkage from green to the oven oven-dried moisture content for various species. A moisture meter is an important tool for the structural engineer. What has been misinterpreted as deflection or settlement in historic structures may be due to the across-the-grain shrinkage of large timber girders that were installed in a green condition and subsequently dried to low moisture content. An increment borer can be used by the structural engineer to obtain core samples 0.2 of an inch in diameter, which can be used to determine the species, the number of growth rings per inch, the oven-dried weight, the moisture content, and the specific gravity of the wood sampled. Often, certain parts of a structure will indicate a moisture content that is considerably higher than the equilibrium moisture content determined by the dry bulb temperature and relative humidity. Usually, close contact of timber with moisture-containing masonry or earth will cause elevated moisture content at the bearing points of timber purlins, joists, beams, columns, or trusses. The moisture is most readily absorbed through end grain. Once the moisture content rises above 20 percent, decay will probably occur. Strength-reducing effects of decay and termite infestation commonly occur at support points. Repairing these areas of high shear is a challenge to the structural engineer involved in historic preservation. The structural engineer evaluating the heavy timber frame of a historic structure should be intimately familiar with the causes and significance of checking and the structural considerations. The structural engineer evaluating a timber structure should become familiar with the grading rules of the various species of wood that he may encounter. A familiarity with timber-grading rules and the strength reduction properties of various natural growth characteristics can be obtained from The Wood Handbook of the U.S. Forest Products Laboratory.7 Obviously, the purpose here is not to transform the engineer into a grading-rules expert, but to provide sufficient knowledge so that the engineer is comfortable in assigning a particular grade to the timber framing under consideration in order for the engineer
c01.indd 9
12/18/08 10:06:17 PM
10
Historic Structures: The Role of the Structural Engineer
to assume reasonable design values to be used in the analysis. Certainly, in historic structures, species and density play a most significant role in determining the strength of a particular timber. Of course, the timber’s history is critical also. Wood that appears to be of a superior grade may have been subjected to overstressing, cyclic loading, elevated temperatures, or other environmental conditions. The true capacity of a historic timber is often less than one would expect based on a visual inspection. The testing of representative samples to destruction is the surest way to determine reasonable design values. Results from such tests can be used to establish appropriate design values in a simplified manner or through statistical analysis of the results. Certainly, the old-growth, dense, clear timber found in many existing structures built before World War II, in North America, should be judged on the quality of the wood and not on published design values assigned for timber cut today. In spite of the insistence of the forest products industry that today’s timber is in every way equal to previously cut old-growth timber, I have observed a consistent difference in the density of today’s timber used for construction and that of the past. FIGURE 1-3 Cutting through the floor joists at Market Hall in Charleston, South Carolina, revealed the material to be dense southern pine.
The past practice of excessively notching floor or roof joists into carrying members must be reviewed by the structural engineer using the end-notched beam formulae presented in various timber design manuals and textbooks.8
c01.indd 10
12/18/08 10:06:17 PM
Historic Highway Bridges
11
A joist might be perfectly adequate in bending and deflection and be critical in horizontal shear at a notched support. This condition may be easily remedied by installing custom-sized nailed joist hangers to transfer vertical forces from the joist to the supporting member.
THE TIMBER TRUSS COMPUTER MODEL Slippage, rotation, shrinkage, or the lack of continuity in a timber joint is difficult to allow for in a computer analysis of a timber truss. Multiple-chord trusses will invariably appear stiffer when analyzed, even when all joints are free to rotate in the computer model. Structural engineers are aware that it is very difficult to produce a true hinge or a true fixed joint in the actual structure. Joints in timber trusses may act somewhere between the two, causing a very different distribution of forces than produced by the analysis. How does one model a half-lapped and notched joint in an indeterminate frame? What about the problem of describing the intersecting member of a multiple chord truss where half of the member section in each direction passes through a joint and all pieces nailed together with wrought iron nails?
HISTORIC HIGHWAY BRIDGES Highway bridge inspection, rehabilitation, and replacement programs have involved many structural engineers in the evaluation of older, sometimes historic, highway bridges. Many times these bridges are found deficient because of deterioration of structural elements, the increased magnitude of service loads, inadequate lane width, or a geometry or configuration of the highway or the bridge itself that makes the passage of vehicles unsafe at normal speeds. The structural engineer plays a pivotal role in the determination of possible methods to retain a historic bridge structure. Many two-lane bridges have been converted to one-lane bridges with addition of an adjacent span to carry traffic in the opposite direction. The lacing and cover plates of built-up members and the eyebolts and pinned connections of older steel truss spans provide the structural engineer with the opportunity to study design details that are uncommon today. Repairs and reinforcement can be made to deck, abutments, and superstructure. When this cannot be justified, truly historic spans may be removed from service by rerouting traffic to a replacement span. Many historic bridges have been successfully adapted for reuse for pedestrians in areas such as parks and downtown redevelopment projects.
c01.indd 11
12/18/08 10:06:18 PM
12
Historic Structures: The Role of the Structural Engineer
DISMANTLING HISTORIC RIVETED STEEL STRUCTURES There is a method for carefully dismantling a historic riveted steel structure. Rivets may be removed by drilling a pilot hole into the center of the rivet head, reaming the head to the same diameter of the rivet shank, and chipping the head off by means of a chisel or cutting tool held in a pneumatic hammer. The remaining portion of the rivet may then be driven from the hole with a drift pin and sledgehammer. Although this method is not as fast as torch cutting and resplicing by welding, it preserves the original configuration of connections, does not require splice plates, and does not subject the steel to excessively high temperatures. Field rivets can usually be identified by their heads, which may not be as well formed as shop rivets. Field splice locations can be determined so that a structure can be dismantled in much the same way it was first erected.
FIGURE 1-4 The presence of field bolts provide an opportunity to dismantle a historic bridge in the same way it was assembled.
Reassembly in the original manner of construction is possible, with rivets, if a source for rivets, rivet heaters, and other tools can be secured and if steel workers experienced in riveted construction are available.
c01.indd 12
12/18/08 10:06:19 PM
References
13
HISTORIC STRUCTURES PROVIDE RESEARCH OPPORTUNITIES Historic structures can provide a “laboratory” for engineering research. They provide an opportunity to evaluate the longevity of materials and the result of various construction practices. The causes of masonry deterioration and timber decay can be observed. The causes and consequences of masonry cracks can be determined. Failure modes of various materials may be observed, as well as the effects of moisture penetration and thermal movement. Creep deformations in materials such as timber or concrete can be studied, as well as other time-related properties such as fatigue strength. Someday, we may understand better the effects of load duration because of historic structures research. This research will provide useful information to designers of contemporary buildings.
CONCLUSION As the movement towards the preservation, restoration, rehabilitation, and adaptive reuse of historic structures expands, structural engineers will find themselves playing an ever-increasing role. To be successful, they must apply their engineering knowledge and skill in a sensitive manner providing a safe environment while preserving the significant historic, architectural, and cultural value of historic structures and places.
REFERENCES 1. U.S. Department of the Interior, The Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings (Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1979). 2. The North Carolina Building Code Council and the North Carolina Department of Insurance, North Carolina State Building Code, vol. I (Raleigh: The North Carolina Department of Insurance, 2006). 3. Concrete Reinforcing Steel Institute, Engineering Date Report, no.11, “Evaluation of Reinforcing Steel in Old Concrete Structures,” (Chicago: Concrete Reinforcing Steel Institute: 1981). 4. Harley J. McKee, F. A. I. A., Introduction to Early American Masonry: Stone, Brick, Mortar and Plaster, National Trust for Historic Preservation and Columbia University, Washington Preservation Press, 1973.
c01.indd 13
12/18/08 10:06:20 PM
14
Historic Structures: The Role of the Structural Engineer
5. Brick Institute of America, Technical Notes on Brick Construction, No. 39A (City: Publisher: 1975). 6. American Institute of Timber Construction, Timber Construction Manual 2nd ed. (New York: John Wiley and Sons, Inc.: 1974). 7. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service. Forest Products Laboratory, Handbook, no. 72, Wood Handbook (Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1974). 8. National Forest Products Association, National Design Specification for Wood Construction (Washington D.C.: National Forest Products Association: 1977).
c01.indd 14
12/18/08 10:06:20 PM
CHAPTER
2
Preservation and Public Safety: Structural Safety of Historic Timber Structures
eeting the requirements of the building code is not the same as assuring the public of a safe structure. Structural engineers have the training and experience to make the necessary judgments needed to keep a historic structure in service when parameters appear to fall short of minimum code requirements.
M
TIMBER MISUNDERSTOOD Timber is the primary structural component for most historic structures in the United States and Canada. Although the structures might also include brick and stone masonry, iron, steel, or concrete, timber is often the most misunderstood construction material of all. Part of the misunderstanding lies in our educational system. Many structural engineers earn degrees in structural engineering without ever taking a course in timber design. It is unfortunate that in North America, with our tremendous stock of timber-framed buildings and our strong forest products industry, more structural engineering curricula do not include at least introductory courses in timber design.
Structural Investigation of Historic Buildings: A Case Study Guide to Preservation Technology for Buildings, Bridges, Towers, and Mills. David. C. Fischetti © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
c02.indd 15
15
12/18/08 10:06:55 PM
16
Preservation and Public Safety: Structural Safety of Historic Timber Structures
In today’s residential market, timber is primarily of importance as dimension lumber. Most timber production consists of dimension framing, prefabricated trusses, stress-rated panels, and other components. The size of residential framing members is dictated by building codes for various spans and conditions. Manufacturers provide the design for prefabricated components such as wood trusses and joist substitutes. As a result, the glued laminated timber industry is one of the few areas where structural engineers are practicing the design of heavy timber structures on a daily basis.
PRESERVATION PHILOSOPHY It is hoped that by learning more about timber design, structural engineers will develop a preservation philosophy that demands rigorous analysis in order to justify “doing nothing” to a historic timber structure that has been performing satisfactorily for many years. Buildings that analysis (and observation) clearly indicate are unsafe would be reinforced in the most sensitive manner in an attempt to retain as much historic fabric as possible. Buildings that require extensive modification or reconstruction would be restored in a way that is in keeping with the original construction if possible, while fulfilling safety requirements. Often, engineers are asked to evaluate framing members to determine the capacity of an existing floor structure in a historic structure. This review process differs considerably from design.
STRUCTURAL REVIEW Members in the horizontal plane—such as floor sheathing, joists, purlins, and beams—are stressed principally in bending. The resisting bending moment is a measure of the strength of such an element. This measure, stiffness, and horizontal shear make up the three qualities that are normally checked during the process of selection that we call design. Because timber is available in certain standard lumber sizes, the designer selects from the available sizes, grades, and species those that most economically meet the predetermined standards for bending stress, deflection, and horizontal shear. When the engineer reviews the capacity of an existing member, many parameters complicate the process of selecting appropriate lumber. Size, span, and spacing of members are dictated by the structure. It is the engineer’s task to determine the size, orientation, species, grade, and end condition of all of the structural elements in a building that already exists. Between the factors of limited availability of types of lumber,
c02.indd 16
12/18/08 10:06:56 PM
Load Duration and Historic Structures
17
economic considerations, existing standards, and the structure of the building itself, freedom of choice is eliminated.
ENGINEERING JUDGMENT Often, the structural engineer must pass judgment on a structure that has endured far beyond what we consider to be a normal period of service. The timbers of such a structure were not selected on the basis of modern engineering analysis. They certainly do not bear inspection marks attesting to their grade and species. It should be obvious to the engineer that a safe floor structure should not fail in bending due to the actual loads imposed. But it is important to recognize that excessive deflection, excessive vibration, or a lack of stiffness, should not automatically categorize a floor structure as “unsafe”. Strict deflection limitations should be set for floors that support plaster ceilings in lieu of wood or tin ceilings, or no ceilings at all. But for comfort, the deflection limitation set in most building codes for floors, no matter what the ceiling, is 1/360th of the span. It must be said that overstressed structural members may also be perfectly safe. It is important for the engineer to evaluate the basis for his conclusion regarding the safety of the structure. When making such an evaluation, the loads assumed for design should be reconciled with the actual loads that will occur in service. The design values that we assume are critical to the computed capacity of some floor systems include factors of safety of 2.5 to 3.0. For structures such as mill buildings, average design values yield results that fall well above the minimum code requirements for adaptive reuse occupancy, such as residential, office, or retail. The actual distribution of loads in a structure, similar to live load reduction factors for tributary area, can account for the continued service for heavily loaded members such as stair and fireplace headers, and summer beams that may appear to the engineer to be grossly undersized. Many times, these members deflect more than is desirable for comfort.
LOAD DURATION AND HISTORIC STRUCTURES The concept of load factor design is currently making its way into the field of timber design. This concept is most appropriate for application to timber design because of the long history of the concept of live load duration. Early timber research found that timber reacts quite well to short applications of
c02.indd 17
12/18/08 10:06:56 PM
18
Preservation and Public Safety: Structural Safety of Historic Timber Structures
load. The duration of load was found to be as critical as the magnitude of the load. Presumably, this sensitivity to the duration of load is a result of the natural composition of timber, which consists of a tightly bound bundle of cells that tend to stretch or elongate with time. The larger and more constant the load, the more stretching of fibers occurs. The effects of this creep can be seen in many timber structures through excessive deflection. For short durations of load, allowable design values are increased substantially. Research into this time-versus-stress relationship is of paramount importance. Only through evaluating historic timber structures can we solve this puzzle, which is complicated by cyclic loading, original moisture content, member size, span, species, grade, temperature, humidity, and magnitude of stress.
REPLACEMENT-IN-KIND Often, replacement-in-kind is not economically feasible. More advances are being made in the field of timber design than in any other area of structural engineering. Recent products include laminated veneer lumber and numerous other beam and joist substitutes. The most important benefits of these reconstituted wood products is the availability of long lengths, higher design values, and greater stiffness. Preservationists and preservation engineers must determine the appropriateness of these materials to each case.
CASE HISTORIES Presented here are several projects that required us to determine the load capacity or safety of an existing floor structure. The Montague Building is discussed further in Chapter 6.
Chowan County Courthouse In a 1988 structural evaluation report, we concluded that the large second floor assembly hall of the Chowan County Courthouse in Edenton, North Carolina (c.1767), could be used for public occupancy if the area would be posted to limit the number of people to 200. A deflection limitation of 1/360th of a span governed the design, producing a bending stress as high as 2,292 psi in large, dense southern pine timber floor joists and beams.
Walker Building Sometime later, we reviewed the floor structure of the 1917 Walker Building at the State Hospital in Concord, New Hampshire. Assuming a reasonable set of
c02.indd 18
12/18/08 10:06:57 PM
Conclusion
19
design values equivalent to No. 1D SR southern pine, based on examination of a wood sample obtained from the building, and a visual inspection of the framing, we concluded that the existing 7½ ⫻ 11 timber beams were adequate to support a live load of 86 psf. This is well within the 50 psf required for office occupancy with fixed partitions. The live load deflection limitation of 1/360th of the span controlled the design. Of course, we concluded that this was a safe structure that met minimum code requirements. The calculations were based on reasonable assumptions of design values.
Montague Building In 1985, at my direction, six floor joists from the 1903 Montague Building in Raleigh, North Carolina, were tested to destruction. Of the five joists tested (of six joists selected; one was found not suitable for testing), the average bending stress at rupture was in excess of 5,000 psi. The average modulus of elasticity was 1,295,000 psi. These measures of strength and stiffness were used to evaluate the capacity of the floor structure. To meet tenant loads for possible retail occupancy in this speculative office building, I recommended that all of the existing floor joists be reinforced. (The Montague Building is also discussed in Chapter 6).
Moorfields At Moorfields, a 1792 house in Hillsborough, North Carolina, the excessive deflection of a summer beam was evaluated by measuring offsets in the floor surface above the beam. Based on field measurements and computer analysis, I was convinced that the summer beam had failed. Indeed, when exposed to view during construction by removing the ceiling plaster, the summer beam contained a severe fracture consistent with a typical bending failure. The only replacement beam available of sufficient stiffness and strength that would fit between in the space between the floor sheathing and the ceiling was a steel tube section approximately equal to the original timber beam in size.
CONCLUSION Only through specialized knowledge and experience can structural engineers make the necessary judgments needed to properly evaluate historic timber structures. The engineer must be convinced that the structural model in the computer is an accurate representation of actual conditions. Once that is clear, the application of rigorous analysis, testing, and engineering judgment may be necessary to explain why the historic timber structure in question has performed adequately for many years.
c02.indd 19
12/18/08 10:06:57 PM
CHAPTER
3
Simplified Engineering*
INTRODUCTION he field of structural engineering has grown more complex as we begin the twenty-first century. The profession of structural engineering evolved from principles first developed in the 1840s by American pioneers such as Squire Whipple (1804–1888) and Herman Haupt (1817–1905). These men were among the first to publish engineering pamphlets and textbooks based on rational mathematical or graphical analysis of simple structures. At that time, the unparalleled growth of the railroads required that reliable methods of analysis be invented for bridge construction. In the last few years, events and certain attitudes have combined to produce a highly complicated world for practicing engineers. Methods of analysis have grown more complex. For many years, the fundamental principles necessary for the design of simple structures did not change. Now, advances in computer technology, applications, and usage, stronger materials, composite and orthotropic materials, and plastic or load [resistance] factor design applications have changed the ways buildings and bridges are designed. Other requirements, such as continuing education, peer review, and changes in registration laws are thrust upon the engineer in an effort to obtain more accountability.
T
* This paper was originally written for the Fall 1995 Lecture Series, Sponsored by The Structural Group Boston Society of Civil Engineers, Section American Society of Civil Engineers. Structural Investigation of Historic Buildings: A Case Study Guide to Preservation Technology for Buildings, Bridges, Towers, and Mills. David. C. Fischetti © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
c03.indd 21
21
12/18/08 10:07:30 PM
22
Simplified Engineering
In order to be more productive and efficient in the areas that we can control, engineers might consider the concept of simplified engineering.
WHAT IS SIMPLIFIED ENGINEERING? Simplified engineering is a method of reducing the complexity of a problem by exercising the engineering judgment of an experienced designer in order to eliminate unnecessary procedures and methods not essential to arriving at a solution. When pressed, designers are tempted to take shortcuts in order to produce an acceptable set of plans and specifications in the shortest length of time. In recent years, consulting structural engineers have, during the design process, received fewer dimensions, details, wall sections, and building sections produced by architects. The consulting structural engineers are filling in some of the gaps, because we have no choice but to describe the complete structure. There are few shortcuts to producing a complete set of structural design documents. As a result, many engineers are practicing simplified engineering. Many in the engineering profession look toward the medical and legal professions as a gauge of our success. Unfortunately, engineers are rapidly losing ground in the one area that offers a quantitative comparison: monetary compensation. Unlike medical and legal fees, which are cumulative, engineering fees are usually based on fixed financial considerations and represent a slice of a pie. In most instances, owners, developers, financial institutions or architects decide what size the pie will be and how it will be divided among the consultants. In certain projects, the slice for the structural designer becomes even thinner when complexity dictates that additional consultants be added. A project may have building code, seismic, geotechnical, acoustical, lighting, roofing, landscape, waterproofing, theater, natatorium, security, curtain wall, sprinkler, and other specialty consultants. Not only can the limits of responsibility become ambiguous, but also, coordination between the various specialties is often difficult or nonexistent. For most ordinary buildings, analysis is a very small part of the effort. The production of a fully coordinated set of plans and specifications employs most of our time. Often, a project is drawn first, and then engineered. At a time of rising expectations and diminishing returns, engineers need methods of expediting their work without reducing quality. By rapidly advancing the production of plans and specifications through the initial stages of design, simplified engineering may be one method of reaching the goal of producing a design that
c03.indd 22
12/18/08 10:07:30 PM
What is Simplified Engineering?
23
meets all of the requirements of the project. This can be a shortcut to a solution based on sound engineering judgment, resulting in the appropriate effort applied to various tasks. Simplified engineering becomes a critical issue when it is practiced as a response to unwieldy or difficult computer software. To use most structural software, the designer requires a block of uninterrupted time. If this time is not available, the designer may abandon the software in favor of a less accurate hand calculation. In some cases simplification may actually yield more accurate final results. For example, a plane frame analysis of a three-dimensional steeple structure may afford the engineer an opportunity to “get the feel” of the structure when compared to a three-dimensional analysis with its complicated coordinate system, which results in reams of pages of output. The cost of increased accuracy in engineering calculations is a decreased sense and understanding, or feel for the numbers—particularly, the results. It is reasonable to expect that the design engineer will have a sense of an expected range of results prior to performing the calculations. The computer industry lags far behind in the production of efficient userfriendly software for structural engineers. Although great advances have been made in the development of faster general plane frame analysis programs with more capacity, design programs for individual beam and column members are often unwieldy. For example, some Composite Steel Beam Design programs require two pages of printout for each beam analyzed. Traditionally, structural engineers have “batched” tasks, analyzing all columns at one time, or all similarly loaded beams together. One 8½ ⫻ 11 sheet of printout should be sufficient to display the output for 12 to 24 beams or columns. Anton Tedesko pointed out in a recent issue of Civil Engineering magazine that computers have not “diminished the value of back-of-an-envelope calculations.”6 Computer analyses are of great help when used in the proper context, when modeling of the structure is correct, when the actual boundary conditions are taken into account and the output is examined and interpreted by an experienced engineer. It is a misconception, however, that sophisticated computer analyses through greater accuracy will lead to better designs. The quality of a design is not a function of the exactness of the calculations, and it is not necessary to strive for great accuracy in a numerical analysis when the accuracy of the assumption is not known. Many of the calculations made today are not necessary. Sometimes calculations are produced because the analyst is fascinated with the program or is taken in by the sheer beauty of the analysis. At other times, someone wants to show how many pages of calculations have been produced; sometimes this is done to impress a client.
c03.indd 23
12/18/08 10:07:31 PM
24
Simplified Engineering
A complicated analysis performed on a computer may not necessarily be an accurate model of the structure to be designed. The engineer must use judgment to decide what elements should be removed from the overall structure in order to simplify the problem. Computer analysis allows the designer to search for various solutions in a matter of seconds. Boundary conditions such as springs can be tried. The computer allows us to achieve a very reasonable model in a short period of time. Our best designs may still be simplified versions of parts of a structure with added opportunities to input nonprismatic sections and sophisticated boundary conditions. Antonio M. Garcia, P.E., described this state of affairs in an August 1993 issue of Civil Engineering magazine: With available structural design software, we can represent any structure on a screen, apply any load in any direction, and receive output on stresses at any or all nodes. We can also pictorially represent the deflected structure or, by use of color variations, picture the intensities of tensile and compressive stresses. In essence, much of what used to be intuition or “feel” based on experience has been replaced by highly sophisticated software and extremely fast hardware: Anyone with funds and little experience can achieve what once took years of training. The fallacy lies in believing that reams of output providing every bit of incredibly accurate information are enough to solve the problem. Experience cannot be purchased; it must be acquired. The fact that an answer is achieved does not necessarily mean that it is the right answer. No matter how sophisticated the computer, the engineer needs to understand the materials and construction methods used. The finished plans represent the designer’s intentions, and they must be realistic.1
The computer, used by an experienced designer, becomes a powerful tool. Carelessly used, it can result in a dangerous sense of well being and satisfaction in a design that may have serious shortcomings. As the computer reduces calculation time, it also reduces the time spent on a project, thereby reducing the time we spend thinking about the project with all of its intricacies and details. We thus lose the time spent “sleeping on it” that can give us a clearer picture of a project and its idiosyncrasies.
HOW CAN SIMPLIFIED ENGINEERING BE PRACTICED? Simplified engineering is practiced every day on thousands of projects when we choose what to analyze and how to approach the analysis. The more experienced an engineer is, the greater the latitude should be.
c03.indd 24
12/18/08 10:07:31 PM
When is Simplified Engineering a Valid Method?
25
Engineers have simplified their work for many years through the use of handbooks. Often the use of handbooks requires the engineer to interpolate between tabulated values. In many cases a code mandated requirement will govern the design. For example, in concrete, #4 reinforcing steel spaced 12 inches on center may be the minimum reinforcing recommended by the American Concrete Institute for a specific application. A designer might make the minimum steel beam size a W10x14 to allow sufficient depth for clip angle connections with space for a minimum of two rows of bolts. The Underwriters Laboratory might require a minimum composite beam size of W8x28 to obtain a certain fire resistance rating. With minimum requirements in place, the design effort is simplified by omitting the design of elements, which, by inspection, exceed the minimum requirements for stiffness and strength. The Hyatt-Regency walkway collapse in Kansas City and recent economic forces have changed the way structural engineers work. Previously, the engineer of record had more back-up. Steel companies were then staffed with complete engineering departments. The steel company’s engineers would review a project prior to bidding and construction, adding their input to the estimating and detailing efforts. Now, with steel companies employing minimal engineering staffs consisting of contract drafters located at remote sites, the engineer of record does not benefit from “another pair of eyes” looking at a project. The profession and the steel industry have redefined the roles of the various parties. From connection design to “standard details,” the steel fabricator assumes no responsibility. Many fabricators do not check shop drawings prior to submittal, thus shifting more of the burden onto the structural designer of record.
WHEN IS SIMPLIFIED ENGINEERING A VALID METHOD? Simplified engineering is a valid method to use when the result produces an adequate design. If the engineer is responsible when designing, there is not a problem with this method as it has been used traditionally. Our natural tendency has been to simplify everything into a model that is complex enough to accurately describe the structure to be designed, yet is simple enough to be analyzed. For example, truss analysis for many years assumed members to be prismatic sections with pinned joints. This facilitated analysis by such means as the method of joints. Now that we can create more complex models by computer, introducing some rigidity at joints and continuity in individual pieces, are we irresponsible when we abandon the computer and do a quick hand calculation?
c03.indd 25
12/18/08 10:07:31 PM
26
Simplified Engineering
WHO CAN PRACTICE SIMPLIFIED ENGINEERING? Any engineer can practice some form of simplified engineering. Even the newest EIT (Engineer-in-training) can be faced with a problem, for which his education did not prepare him, the first day on the job. Ideally, he would be working under the direct supervision of a more experienced engineer who would guide him toward a simplified approach. The more experience an engineer has, the more ability the engineer would obviously have for simplifying calculations based on knowledge of the subject and feel for the numbers and expected outcome.
ADVANTAGES, DISADVANTAGES AND POTENTIAL PROBLEMS Percival White wrote the following in the July 1920 issue of The Atlantic Monthly: Efficiency is fondly regarded in the American mind as the greatest contribution of this age to civilization. It is deemed an agency for good, a thing one cannot have too much of. Efficiency is a lightning calculator, by which you may convert time into anything you like, and read the answer in percentages, to the third decimal place. By its means, for example, you may change minutes into dollars, which is, after all, the thing most of us are trying to do. Yet there is danger in these glib conversions. Money is a tangible thing. The more you save, the more you have. But time is far more subtle stuff. Saving it does not imply having it. As soon as a man seriously starts saving time, make up your mind that he will no longer have a moment to spare.2
The greatest advantage of simplified engineering is the time it saves. The greatest disadvantage is that the solution may not be accurate. Potential problems may arise when drawings or calculations are reviewed at a later date. Simplified engineering may cause great difficulty to a peer reviewer unable to follow the thinking of the engineer of record or not in agreement with the methodology. Certainly, if the design has to be defended because of an observed problem in the field during construction or after completion, simplified engineering can result in lawsuits on the basis of negligence. Simplified engineering, practiced as a response to outside pressure such as fee or time constraints, does a great disservice to the project. Most clients are concerned with schedule. However, quality is infrequently discussed. It is assumed that any structural engineer will produce basically the same design.
c03.indd 26
12/18/08 10:07:32 PM
Historical Perspective: Rules of Thumb Versus Analysis
27
Does the client care whether the columns in a building frame are to be designed by computer considering bi-axial bending due to possible eccentricity, or merely selected from a handbook? Discussion of simplified engineering with owners, clients, and non-engineering professionals is risky. The decision of whether to simplify a portion of the analysis should be left to the engineer of record. Discussion with nonengineering professionals of simplified engineering may lead them to think that engineering design is simple or that it can be simplified. The client’s natural conclusion would be that they should expect a quick turnaround for a reduced fee.
HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE: RULES OF THUMB VERSUS ANALYSIS In American structural engineering, analysis as we know it today grew out of the work of many engineers practicing in the first half of the nineteenth century. They attempted to determine accurate methods of analysis to solve problems that had previously been solved using rules of thumb. Rigorous mathematical methods of analyzing the forces and stresses in framed structures, such as bridges, were unknown until the 1840s. Structural engineers Squire Whipple and Herman Haupt independently developed mathematical truss design methods. In 1842, Haupt produced a small pamphlet, Hints on Bridge Construction by an Engineer. Whipple is credited with developing the scientific basis of bridge design in the United States with his 1847 publication, “A Work on Bridge Building.” In 1851, Haupt produced his major work, General Theory of Bridge Construction. Earlier bridge builders such as Timothy Palmer, Theodore Burr, Lewis Wernwag, and Ithiel Town very likely used various methods to determine stresses and strains. It is not now known whether their methods of proportioning members were based on mathematics or rules of thumb. However, in 1820, Town advertised his patent for the plank lattice truss by inviting potential investors to “examine the model and the mathematics.”
Code of Design Often, mandated code requirements force engineers to design beyond the limits of good engineering judgment. For example, it may be obvious to the designer that certain loading conditions will not be necessary because of the configuration, construction type, location, or occupancy of a building. We have seen wind-, snow-, and seismic-mandated code requirements increase in complexity in recent years. Wind load factors, snowdrift coefficients,
c03.indd 27
12/18/08 10:07:32 PM
28
Simplified Engineering
and seismic analysis methods have greatly increased the complexity of structural design for the typical building. Supposedly, complicated and unwieldy loading conditions are a result of more accurate scientific or engineering research. But, at the same time, the coefficients provided in the current building codes often result in less snow, wind, or seismic force being applied to a structure compared to what the previous codes would have required. Most practicing engineers, if given the choice, would opt for the simpler series of loads, knowing full well that they might be conservative. From a structural engineer’s standpoint, there should be provisions in the code for alternate simple load provisions for wind, snow, and seismic design at this time when fees for architectural and engineering services are shrinking, and the expectations of our clients are rising. It is debatable whether the design community is designing safer structures today because of the complicated snowdrift, wind loads, and seismic requirements than we did with the earlier codes.
Timber Design Although wood is a very complicated building material, for 150 years it has been simple to design. The 1991 National Design Specification for Wood Construction (NDS) changed what was for many years a simple column formula into a more complex mathematical expression—an example of increased complexity in timber design. The previous design procedure shown in the 1985 edition of the Timber Construction Manual and earlier editions of the NDS was recently revised to include a column-stability factor based on a procedure proposed by A. Yline in 1956. This method permits estimation of the buckling stress and the required cross-sectional area for concentrically applied loads on straight columns in the elastic and inelastic ranges. The column stability factor is a complicated equation. Bruce Pooley, director of technical services for the American Institute of Timber Construction, admits, “Calculating Cp is lengthy when done by hand, but quickly computed with a programmable calculator, a computer spreadsheet, or any one of a number of software programs developed for wood design.” He indicated that the new design method was “equation based,” meaning that it was assumed that practicing engineers would program the equation into their computers, thus reducing the pain of dealing with such a complicated set of mathematical expressions.7
Load Resistance Factor Design For many applications, load factor design seems to be a design methodology that overly complicates the design process for the average engineer. Some proponents
c03.indd 28
12/18/08 10:07:32 PM
Historical Perspective: Rules of Thumb Versus Analysis
29
believe that now that we have computers, it does not matter how complicated the math is. Programs are viewed as a black box, a sort of mixing bowl, where the ingredients are placed without regard to the internal process but with complete confidence in the results. To the practicing engineer, LRFD is an unwieldy method of design promoted by the academic community and various large engineering firms. Allowable stress design gives the designer “real” numbers for use in a simple world where the design is either “OK” or “no good.” Working stress design is simple and commonly understood. Stress is proportional to strain below the elastic limit. Why would an engineer want to delve into that domain above which elastic materials begin to yield? Ultimate strength design, which originated for concrete in the 1956 and 1963 American Concrete Institute specifications, required nearly a quarter of a century to replace working stress design.
Vibratory Analysis Several years ago, the issue of floor vibration was considered by the North Carolina State Building Code Council for incorporation into the building code. This came at a time when the expectations of consumers were rising. In North Carolina, complaints regarding excessive floor vibration in residential structures caused the Structural Committee of the Building Code Council in 1991 to consider making vibratory analysis part of the building code at roughly the same time that the CABO code was being adopted. At the time, some argued that the Building Code Committee should not recommend that a vibratory analysis, by a professional engineer, be a required part of the code because the vibratory response of a floor is independent of its structural capacity. The vibratory response of a floor is difficult to quantify, and requiring a vibratory analysis in the building code would lead to increased litigation for real or imagined problems that are not a measure of safety. A suggestion was made to simplify the problem by placing in the code minimum depth-to-span recommendations that have been shown to minimize vibratory problems. That advice was not implemented, and code mandated vibratory analysis was avoided for the time being.
Seismic Design In light of the earthquakes in Northridge, California, and Kobe, Japan, engineering researchers are rethinking the current approach to seismic design. Research undertaken at the present time will result in almost immediate changes in the building codes. Seismic design is a market to exploit. Grant monies for studies and research is flowing from Washington in response to
c03.indd 29
12/18/08 10:07:33 PM
30
Simplified Engineering
major earthquake activity. Large design firms armed with grants can target areas of the country susceptible to seismic activity and market their specialized expertise, filling a void the local consultants may have discounted. Seismic damage makes great television press. Municipal, hospital, school, and other administrators cannot ignore the risks associated with a major earthquake. The more complicated the analysis needs to be, the more important it is to hire specialists to design seismic resistant foundations and buildings, and to determine how to modify the underlying soils or isolate the foundations of existing buildings. Will the academic community and code officials recommend simple methods of analysis that can be applied easily to new and existing buildings in order to reduce the risk of damage during a seismic event? Probably not. Several questions should be asked before we adopt complicated or excessive seismic requirements into our building codes. First, what is the risk of injury, death, or property damage in the United States due to a seismic event? Second, how much will seismic provisions add to the cost of rehabilitating or adding to existing structures? Third, how much will a seismic analysis add to the cost of engineering and architectural fees for new or existing structures? Fourth, how many clients will be willing to pay extra for a seismic analysis? History since 1750 indicates that in most of the United States, the risk of death or property damage from a seismic event is extremely small. There are many reasons for the low seismic mortality rate. Population density, construction methods and materials, geotechnical conditions, and climate are some of the factors that affect the number of deaths that may occur as a result of a seismic event. North American building codes and zoning ordinances limit population density in our cities. Cultural factors tend to limit the number of children living in single-family dwellings in North America. Construction methods in North America tend to limit the risk of earthquake-related deaths. One of the methods worth mentioning involves the use of mortar and unit masonry, which is far superior to the unit masonry used in many less-developed countries today or in any country in the past. Joint reinforcing is included in most commercial masonry walls built in North America. Many residential buildings in North America are framed with dimensional lumber, which is light and strong. Except in certain regions, North American builders tend to not roof buildings with heavy concrete or clay tile products. Buildings constructed in North America today are required by building codes to bear on properly proportioned footings resting on an adequate subgrade. In many overpopulated parts of the world, housing is constructed on steep slopes or filled in land not suited for agriculture or other activities. In American cities, such as Charleston, Boston, and San Francisco, which are underlaid with soft clays, pile, or caisson foundations are typically provided for large buildings.
c03.indd 30
12/18/08 10:07:33 PM
Historical Perspective: Rules of Thumb Versus Analysis
31
All of the existing buildings in North America are new when compared to many of the buildings found in other parts of the world. But the most important single factor pertaining to absence of property damaged or deaths during past seismic events is the absence of large seismic events. The East Coast has, no doubt, experienced many earthquakes, although the Appalachian mountain chain is one of the oldest, seismically inert ranges in the world. Records dating from 1750 indicate that although 2,750,000 people have died as a result of earthquakes worldwide, the record in the United States is very good and most states have not yet recorded a fatality.
Table 3-1 Major Earthquakes in the United States Since 1750
State
# of major earthquakes
Largest number of deaths in one event
Alaska
4
131
March 27, 1962
10
667
April 18, 1906
1049
Idaho
1
2
Oct. 28, 1983
2
Hawaii
2
173
April 01, 1946
234
California
Date
Total # of deaths 134
Massachusetts
1
0
Nov. 18, 1755
0
Missouri
3
10
Dec. 16, 1811
10
Montana
3
2
Oct. 11, 1936
30
Nevada
3
0
Dec. 16, 1954
0
Oregon
2
2
South Carolina
1
83
Dec. 4, 1993
Texas
1
0
August 16, 1931
0
Utah
1
0
March 12, 1934
0
Total
32
Aug. 31, 1886
2 83
1544
The total number of deaths from earthquakes since 1750 in the United States is 1544. The earthquake-related deaths in Hawaii were the result of tidal waves. The 1886 earthquake in Charleston, South Carolina, is the only major earthquake to be located on the East Coast. The deep layer of marl beneath Charleston is one reason for the heavy damage. St. Philip’s and St. Michael’s Churches in Charleston, South Carolina, were both badly damaged. Although the heavy steeples of both churches settled almost a foot, both buildings were repaired and have continued in service since 1886. Similarly, they were repaired after tornadoes and hurricanes such as Hugo in 1989. In the Winter 1990 issue
c03.indd 31
12/18/08 10:07:34 PM
32
Simplified Engineering
of Wood Design Focus, Ario Ceccotti presented an earthquake performance challenge to researchers, code writers, and designers: It is evident that thorough knowledge and planned balance of the positive and negative aspects will yield a proper design that guarantees structural safety at a reasonable cost. Researchers have the challenge of quantifying the factors that yield ductile behavior and energy dissipation in the structure. They can determine how to design and detail connections that lead to ductile systems, rather than brittle failures. Code writers have the challenge of combining the often-disparate results of research. They must present a few relatively simple and conservative design rules, which are easy to apply, for the most common structural forms (those with known ductility and dissipation levels). Yet, for less common structures, for which experience has demonstrated good structural performance, code writers must provide simple rules or guidelines based on the engineering judgment. Designers have the challenge of finding the best solution among the various ductility classes, creating the most convenient design from technical and economical points of view.3
The application of complicated seismic requirements, which are subject to wide interpretation, will only cause the demolition of many existing buildings. For example, to accurately determine the seismic resistance of an existing building, the unit weight and shear capacity of the existing masonry must be known. This requires expensive testing in the field to obtain design values to be used in the analysis, which owners are often not willing to pay for. Proposed seismic provisions for building additions will affect the historic preservation and the renovation and rehabilitation segments of the construction industry. Many owners faced with rehabilitating or adding to an older or historic structure will elect to demolish when faced with engineering fees for evaluation, or potentially unknown construction costs, required to bring a building into conformance with seismic provisions. For example, to construct a structurally independent stair and elevator tower addition is a difficult and expensive task. Usually, part of the new elevator lobby is supported by the existing structure at each floor level. Upcoming changes to the seismic provisions of the building code should exempt existing one-story buildings with wood framing or unit masonry loadbearing walls from the seismic provisions of the code and all other buildings in the Seismic Hazard Exposure Group I category. However, structures with precast concrete structural systems or unusually heavy roof systems should be included in a special hazard category. Certain elements such as architectural
c03.indd 32
12/18/08 10:07:35 PM
Historical Perspective: Rules of Thumb Versus Analysis
33
stone cladding, large chimneys, and masonry parapets above a certain height should be subject to seismic review in all cases. Based on the limited risk of a seismic event in most of the United States, it is in the best interest of the public, the construction industry, and architectural and engineering professions, to limit the complexity of the seismic code and its application to existing buildings. When California and Hawaii are excluded, we have suffered a total of 261 deaths from earthquakes in 245 years. More structural engineers in the United States will die from heart attacks due to stress—caused, in part, by an effort to implement a complicated seismic code—than all of the earthquake victims combined.
Code versus Creativity In the movie Brazil, Robert De Niro’s character, Harry Tuttle, is a heating engineer illegally providing mechanical repairs outside the government’s inept Central Services branch. When Sam Lowery questions why he chose to work outside the system, Harry Tuttle replies that he “couldn’t stand the paperwork . . . you can’t make a move without a form.” “Get in, get out, travel light . . . a man alone . . . ” is his philosophy as he provides much-needed emergency repair services, which are considered by the government to be sabotage. As we dictate methodologies in our building codes in an effort to ensure uniformity in approach, do we stifle creativity? Do we remove humanity from the design process as mandated design is implemented? Are mandated design methods an attempt by some in the design community to ensure that designers conform to a certain analysis-based ideal? In the future, will we have to depend on the Harry Tuttles, working outside of the system, to keep the system running?
Legal Implications The greatest legal implication of using simplified engineering methods is the potential needed to defend our designs should they be challenged for whatever reason. Unfortunately, modern-day structural engineering is so complex that it is very easy for a sharp attorney armed with the testimony of expert witnesses to prove negligence.
Engineering Judgment: Engineer of Record The engineer of record should have some leeway with regard to analysis methods used for a particular problem. At this time, we in the design professions are faced with the rising expectations of our clients, as well as a reluctance on their part to pay for professional engineering services. Schedules are often
c03.indd 33
12/18/08 10:07:35 PM
34
Simplified Engineering
compressed, leaving the designers very little time to produce documents, let alone time to cogitate and coordinate. The engineer of record has the ultimate responsibility for the design. Sufficient time must be provided in the schedule for a thorough final check and review of all the documents prior to bidding.
Third-Party Review Simplified engineering can result in real problems in a project with third-party review if the reviewer does not understand the methodology or does not agree that the simplified model is sufficiently accurate to produce a correct result. Simplified engineering can be a valuable tool for checking or verifying a design by others.
EXAMPLES OF SIMPLIFIED ENGINEERING: BUILDINGS Residential structures constructed in the United States today are an example of simplified engineering. The great majority of residential structures are not engineered, but built to minimum code standards that are based on standard tables developed for timber and masonry elements. The standard tables are often the results of empirical data derived from observing the behavior of structures over time. As a result of Hurricane Andrew, we have complicated our codes with various wind-load factors and unrealistic loading conditions in order to prevent future damage from a similar storm as if a deficiency in the code were the problem. Studies have shown that the code in South Florida was more than adequate, if followed, to produce buildings constructed well enough to resist wind forces generated by Hurricane Andrew. The obvious deficiency was in the execution of the design by the building contractors. Endwalls of gable-roofed buildings were pushed in by high wind forces because of the absence of endwall bracing required by code. Roof trusses lacked sufficient tiedowns in spite of code requirements. In many damaged buildings, plywood sheathing was insufficiently attached and blocked to resist uplift and shear forces due to wind. The conclusion of the 1992 American Plywood Association report, no. T92-21, is not that we need to change the design requirements, but that a more thorough inspection is required during the construction phase to ensure that fasteners are installed as specified: Within a week after Hurricane Andrew battered the southern Florida region on August 24, 1992, American Plywood Association technical and field promotion staff visited the region to inspect damaged and evaluate structural performance of residential and low-rise commercial structures.
c03.indd 34
12/18/08 10:07:35 PM
Bridges
35
The inspections were conducted in conjunction with inspections carried out under the auspices of a Damage Assessment Team, coordinated and arranged by the Florida Concrete and Concrete Products Association and endorsed by the state of Florida, Department of Community Affairs. The 45-member team consisted of structural engineers, government and university scientists, building code officials and technical representative of the building construction industry. Conventionally built residential structures constructed with wood systems performed satisfactorily when the structures were built to meet building code provisions. Residential structures constructed with masonry block walls also performed well, in general. Failures involving plywood or oriented strand board (OSB) roof sheathing or wood-framed roof or wall systems could be traced to improper or inadequate fastenings of connections to other components. Although extensive use of steel tension straps connecting roof-wall-floor framing was observed, the structural advantages offered by such connectors could not overcome deficiencies caused by omission of other code-required connections between building components.4
When, as a consulting structural engineer, have you walked a deck prior to roofing, to count the number of fasteners and verify their correct attachment to the structural system below? To reduce wind damage during a meteorological event, all buildings should be given a structural review to verify that the correct fasteners were properly installed in sufficient quantity. Is this task the responsibility of the building official, an independent consultant, the contractor, or the designer of record? It is obvious that code-mandated inspections that complicate the design or construction process for the engineer of record will not solve the problem. It is unlikely that fees for structural engineers will increase to cover additional code mandated assurances placed on the designer. An example of simplified engineering with which few would argue is the analysis of an unequal-sided suspended two-way flat concrete slab by assuming a square or rectangular shape with roughly the same proportions as the polygon. By setting a minimum thickness to ensure deflection control and obtaining reinforcing steel size and spacing to resist the bending forces, an adequate slab can be designed. At no time would the exact long-term deflection or exact maximum bending moment at any location be calculated. A serviceable design can thus be obtained without performing a sophisticated analysis.
BRIDGES Bridges are built using simplified engineering when components such as prestressed, precast concrete are selected from tables for short standard spans.
c03.indd 35
12/18/08 10:07:35 PM
36
Simplified Engineering
Of course, the tables are produced by the most rigorous analysis methods. This type of simplified engineering is often used at the Type Study Phase of bridge design as a tool for comparison of structure types and costs. Simplified engineering, however, is not likely to be used in the final design phase of a bridge. The standard code for bridges published by the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHO) has, like the building codes, increased in complexity. One example of the increased complexity can be found in the change of the distribution factor for wheel loadings on interior bridge girders. The spacing factor of S/11 will soon be changed to a much more complex expression. Fortunately for the designer, computer programs can be used for the calculation. However, the “feel” for the number becomes lost, if not nonexistent.
DESIGN PHILOSOPHY: DESIGN OF STRUCTURES As present-day designers, we often are so immersed in our day-to-day operations that we seldom have the opportunity to formulate a rigorous design philosophy. We know how to perform our services, but do not always think much about the process. If asked, most of us would describe the methods we use in order to illustrate our philosophy. Most of us design structures from the top to the bottom for vertical loads first. Then, after the horizontal and vertical members are selected, we determine which system to use to resist lateral forces. Although most engineers have three-dimensional design capability, we design buildings through analysis by separating orthogonal systems into components.
ENGINEERING EDUCATION In the 1960s, the computer became the modern tool for analysis, and many practical courses disappeared from the structural engineering curriculum. First, Surveying was eliminated. Then, Mechanical Drafting and Freehand Drawing were combined into Graphic Analysis. Some design and drafting courses were dropped from the curriculum in favor of basic computer programming. The Maxwell diagram, the string polygon, and Bow’s notation are unknown to the younger generation of engineers. Yet, what simple but beautiful methods of analysis these were! Graphical analysis was so simple and logical that many truss manufacturers employed drafters to do this work. Pier Luigi Nervi remarked, “I believe that graphical statics should play an important role in this last educational phase, since its procedures give a direct
c03.indd 36
12/18/08 10:07:36 PM
Analysis of Existing Structures
37
understanding—much better than that afforded by analytical methods—of force systems and their composition, decomposition, and equilibrium.”5 Nervi is well known for his ideas regarding mathematical analysis in building design. In the early 1950s, he wrote: It is highly regrettable that some of the highest qualities of the human mind, such as intuition and direct apprehension, have been banned from our schools and have been overwhelmed by abstract and impersonal mathematical formulas. We cannot forget that in the distant past intuition allowed the execution of works which cannot be analyzed today by the most modern theoretical methods, and before which we must bow in reverent and humble admiration. We cannot deny that the potentialities of mathematical methods are soon exhausted, even when their application is difficult and complex. Special, skinresistant, and highly indeterminate structures cannot be analyzed by mathematical theories, although they are extremely efficient from a technical, economical, and architectural viewpoint. Moreover, the most advanced chapters of theory of structures, which deal with the solution of statically indeterminate systems, can be used only to check the stability of a structure. They can be used only to analyze numerically a structure already designed, not only in its general outline, but in all its dimensional relations. The formative stage of a design, during which its main characteristics are defined and its quality and faults are determined once and for all (just as the characteristics of an organism are clearly defined in the embryo), cannot make use of structural theory and must resort to intuition and schematic simplifications.5
The essential part of the design of a building consists in conceiving and proportioning its structural system; in evaluating intuitively any dangerous thermal conditions and support settlements, in choosing materials and construction methods best adapted to the final purpose of the work and to its environment; and, finally, in seeking economy. When all these essential problems have been solved and the structure is thus completely defined, then and only then can we and should we apply the formulas of the mathematical theory of elasticity to specify with greater accuracy its resisting elements.
ANALYSIS OF EXISTING STRUCTURES The analysis of existing structures, such as in the field of historic preservation, requires that we have an appreciation for traditional methods of construction that may have been based on simplified engineering. It is only through testing, observation, and measurement that we can gather enough information to build an accurate model of the structure.
c03.indd 37
12/18/08 10:07:36 PM
38
Simplified Engineering
DESIGN OR MODIFICATION TO EXISTING STRUCTURES Most historic structures are constructed of timber and masonry. Simplified engineering is justified in dealing with these materials when accurate design values cannot be ascertained. The absence of construction documentation and quality control in the manufacture and construction of the component elements requires that analysis be based, at least in part, on judgment. Of course this being the case, one’s analysis can only be as good as one’s judgment, as well as the initial assumptions that are made. A thorough testing program can narrow the range of applicable design values, but engineering judgment must still be applied. Many historic structures will often times not stand close engineering scrutiny, yet they survive, providing adequate service for many years.
CONCLUSION It is now time to pause for a moment and study how structural engineering will be practiced in the twenty-first century. The engineers of record must be allowed some leeway to determine load criteria and methods of analysis, free from third-party interference. We should demand the freedom to simplify our work in order to satisfy our own requirements for structural safety while meeting increased client expectations of time, quality, and cost. If we are not careful, practicing structural engineers will become mere technicians designing structures with prepackaged software written by programmers, on the basis of methods and formulas developed by academics and prescribed by code officials, in accordance with criteria set by architects who have little to no knowledge of structure whatsoever. Now, it is not enough just to do the design and bear the responsibility; we must also perform the analysis in a prescribed manner to the satisfaction of others, all the while assuring them of our continued professional development.
REFERENCES 1. Antonio M. Garcia, “Computers, Creativity, and the Engineer,” Civil Engineering, 63 (8) (August 1993): 6. 2. Percival White, “The July Almanac,” The Atlantic Monthly, 276 (1) (July 1995). 3. Ario Ceccotti, “The Earthquake Performance Challenge,” Wood Design Focus, 1 (4) (Winter 1990).
c03.indd 38
12/18/08 10:07:36 PM
Bibliography
39
4. Edward L. Keith and John D. Rose, “Hurricane Andrew,” American Plywood Association (APA), APA Report T92-21, Tacoma, WA, September 1992 5. Pier Luigi Nervi, Structures Aesthetics & Technology in Building (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1956). 6. Anton Tedesko, “Computer Analysis No Substitute for Experience,” Civil Engineering, 64 (2) (February 1994). 7. Bruce D. Pooley, “Design of Glued Laminated Timber,” Wood Design Focus, 5(1) (Spring 1994): 3–8.
BIBLIOGRAPHY American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO), Standard Specifications for Highway Bridges, 15th ed. (Washington, D.C.: AASHTO, 1995). American Concrete Institute (ACI), Building Code Requirements for Reinforced Concrete (Detroit: ACI, 1956 and 1965). American Institute of Timber Construction (AITC), Timber Construction Manual, 3rd ed. (New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1985). American Society of Civil Engineers, “American Wooden Bridges,” ASCE Historical Publication no. 4, 1976. ASCE Standard: Minimum Design Loads for Buildings and Other Structures (ASCE 7-95). Public Ballot Draft Copy. ASCE Washington, D.C. Conrad P Roberge and Glenn R. Bell, “Regulated Structural Peer Review,” Civil Engineering Practice (Fall/Winter 1994). Gerry Gilliam, Brazil, Movie by Embassy International Pictures, starring Jonathan Pryce, Robert De Niro, Catherine Helmond, Terry Gilliam, MCA produced. 1985. Herman Haupt, Reminiscences of General Herman Haupt (July 1901). Wright, John W. ed. The Universal Almanac. Kansas City: Andrews & McMeel Publishing, 1995. pp. 566–567. National Forest Products Association (NFPA), National Design Specification for Wood Construction (Washington, D.C.: NFPA, 1991), pp. 103–104, and 125. National Forest Products Association, National Design Specifications for Wood Construction, (Washington, D.C.: National Forest Products Association, 1991). Squire Whipple, A Work on Bridge Building: Consisting of Two Essays (Utica, NY: H. H. Curtiss, Printer, Devereux Block, 1847).
c03.indd 39
12/18/08 10:07:37 PM
CHAPTER
4
Conservation and the Specialty Contractor
PRESERVATION PHILOSOPHY proper preservation philosophy requires that repairs to timberframe structures respect the work of the original framer. Through observation, measurement, testing, and analysis the structural engineer must select and design a repair that is appropriate to the task. It is often the structural engineer who makes the decision to repair or replace. Sometimes that decision is a response to the desires of the architect working in concert with the owner or a requirement of the contract, based on state or federal funds, or based on a particular grant, or the necessity to obtain tax credits for historic preservation. How the design is communicated to owner, architect, and general contractor often determines whether a project is successful. It is important to persuade stakeholders that craftpersons with specific skills are required, as well as materials that may not be readily available. Suggestions for temporary shoring and bracing, must be transmitted to those doing the work when such bracing has structural implications. Specific solutions involving traditional connections and materials must be thoroughly detailed and specified.
A
Structural Investigation of Historic Buildings: A Case Study Guide to Preservation Technology for Buildings, Bridges, Towers, and Mills. David. C. Fischetti © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
c04.indd 41
41
12/18/08 10:08:32 PM
42
Conservation and the Specialty Contractor
My preservation philosophy starts with structural safety and stability, with the realization that providing a structurally safe building may be independent of satisfying building code requirements. Second, repairs should be in the same fashion as the original construction as much as possible. If traditional methods will not provide adequate strength, then reinforcing may require other technologies in order to preserve the maximum amount of historic fabric. Timber structures should be rehabilitated as timber structures. Reinforcing and repairs should deal directly with the inadequacies in a way that would be easily understood by the original builder.
SPECIALTY CONTRACTORS We have caused various owners and general contractors to engage specialty contractors and conservation professionals to accomplish tasks that are not common in today’s construction market. We have recommended manufacturers of handmade brick, restoration masons, timber framers, structural movers, stone masons, specialty lumber suppliers, glued laminated timber manufacturers, foundries, preservation architects, testing laboratories, surveyors, historians, wood scientists, grant writers, marine contractors, specialists in ground modification and the installation of mini or pipe pile foundations, and other conservation professionals. These days, many general contractors are uncomfortable with aspects of projects that involve jacking, shoring, or underpinning. Often, the only answer is to engage a specialty contractor to undertake this work. For many projects, we have provided qualification-based specifications causing the general contractor to obtain the services of such contractors. Certainly, the standard specifications for shoring and bracing are applicable for projects involving patent scaffolding used in the typical applications. In these cases, engineers working for the scaffolding firms expect to receive from the engineer of record a tabulation of the loads to be supported by the patent scaffolding system. They are very uncomfortable when approached for a project that involves jacking as well as shoring, or the use of patent scaffolding in unusual ways, such as in a condition that will require the system to be braced to resist lateral loads. Although the engineer of record should not become responsible for means and methods at the construction site, enough information must be provided in the contract documents to describe the work in sufficient detail for it to be accomplished. We have received pressure from owners, who should know better, such as state departments of transportation, to provide shoring and bracing details in the structural drawings. In other cases, we decided to include “suggested” information regarding shoring and bracing in the plans, with a
c04.indd 42
12/18/08 10:08:33 PM
Specialty Contractors
43
disclaimer stating that “means and methods of construction, shoring and bracing shall remain the responsibility of the general contractor and that the details shown in the drawings are suggestions only.” In several cases, we have specified that the specialty contractor be a member of the International Association of Structural Movers. Members of IASM are well versed in shoring, bracing, jacking, and cribbing and the effects on buildings and their components.
Trinity United Methodist Church We saved several owners considerable expense by simply requiring the general contractor to either perform these tasks themselves or engage a structural mover. Trinity United Methodist Church in Darlington, South Carolina, originally contained a roll-up partition that separated a Sunday School annex from the main portion of the sanctuary. In this flexible scheme, the Sunday School annex could be opened to the main sanctuary for overflow seating. Unfortunately, the sight lines were not ideal, with many of the congregants unable to view the chancel platform, choir, or the pulpit. Since, the operation of the rollup partition had long ceased, the building committee was interested in expanding the main sanctuary into this area. Unfortunately, the floor of this ancillary space was flat with a step dividing it from the sanctuary, which had a sloped floor. This made a smooth transition between the two floor areas impossible without major reframing. As an alternate to demolition and reframing, we suggested that the flat floor be reorientated to match the main floor of the sanctuary. Inspection of the crawl space beneath this area revealed that the floor framing was supported by brick piers in the interior and a four inch brick ledge at the perimeter. After observing these conditions, we issued a brief report that included the following: In the sanctuary, a step separates the sloped floor from the flat floor. It is original to the building, and is required to form a closure for the pull down roll-up partition. The 2 12 framing of the flat floor can be sloped to match the main floor by removing the floor sheathing, removing the floor joists, cutting down brick piers and adjusting bearing conditions of beams and joists. The existing 2 12s can be reinstalled. The existing floor sheathing can be re-installed, supplementing the existing with new to replace the damaged. Care should be taken not to damage the sheathings and joists to be reused. Alternately, it should be possible to cut the boundary of the floor so that the flat floor can be dropped in one piece to match the slope of the main floor. Piers would need to be cut down, temporary support jacks added, and the mechanical ducts would need to be removed during construction. The crawl space height of 46 inches would be reduced by approximately 13 inches in the chancel area. This solution would require pier work to occur in the crawl space with its limited headroom.
c04.indd 43
12/18/08 10:08:34 PM
44
Conservation and the Specialty Contractor
Fortunately, we were able to convince the general contractor that the floor could be separated from its supports, and the supporting conditions modified in such a way, that with very little effort, the existing floor structure could be reused. It helped that the crawl space had sufficient headroom and that the perimeter-wall baseboards were easily removed prior to jacking the floor. Incorporating the Sunday School annex into the sanctuary increased the square footage by 75 percent. Existing floor joists that were embedded in the pockets in the exterior brick wall had to be cut along the face of the wall so that a double pressure-treated nailer could be inserted as support for the joists. Joist hangers were supplied to reattach the joists to the nailer, which was bolted to the brick masonry wall. The structural aspects of this project included plans and specifications to describe structural engineering requirements for the new chancel platform; to design solutions to eliminate the step at the existing roll-down and sloping the floor of the Sunday School annex; to design miscellaneous framing at a new pipe organ as well as engineering tasks related to creating an opening in the existing archway, to address raising the lintel above the arch and cutting the second floor of the education wing; and to revise walls and openings at the chancel wall/choir loft. To accommodate a new pipe organ, a Gothic archway had to be created and the chancel platform enlarged. For all of this to work, the discontinuity between the sanctuary and Sunday School annex had to be removed. At Trinity United Methodist Church, the local general contractor was able to adjust the slope of the flat floor to match the main floor, once we explained what we had in mind. Fortunately, very little input was required by us during construction of this portion of the project. With the church located approximately 120 miles from our office, extensive jobsite observation and consultation would have been difficult.
United Church of Chapel Hill The sanctuary of the United Church of Chapel Hill, North Carolina, had structural issues that caused the church leaders to make the decision to sell the property. The roof-framing system consisted of lightly framed, nail-connected, scissors trusses that, over time, had deflected horizontally, causing the top of the wood-framed east wall of the nave to translate toward the east five and one half inches. The wood-framed wall was actually an interior wall that supported a choir loft located between it and the exterior brick masonry wall. Obviously, scissors trusses, in similar fashion to all scissors trusses and pitched roof trusses with raised bottom chords, tend to deflect in the horizontal direction. In this case,
c04.indd 44
12/18/08 10:08:34 PM
Specialty Contractors
45
because the interior wood-framed wall was less stiff than the opposite brick masonry wall, all of the deflection occurred in the easterly direction. It was my understanding that the church leaders, rather than soliciting a condition assessment from an architect or structural engineer, responded to the building inspector, who was concerned that the deflection was an indication of great weakness in the superstructure that had to be repaired. The building inspector went so far as to say that the building was unsafe. Apparently, rather than obtaining second and third opinions, they decided to sell this fairly valuable property consisting of the church sanctuary, fellowship hall, parking lots, and educational and administrative spaces. Faced with unknown expenses associated with replacing of the roof system and reframing the choir wall, choir loft, and narthex, they felt justified in selling, at below market value, the property to a developer team consisting of several real estate investors. We became involved when the developer, upon the recommendation of a local architect, decided that we might be able to determine how to repair or replace the roof system. Our initial contact was a phone call from one of the investors. The following phone memo was in my “in” box: “Just bought a historic church in Chapel Hill wants you to look @ the extent of the roof damage.”
We met several of the investors at the church. After a brief inspection, we discussed the finer points of horizontal deflection in scissors trusses and how the roof could be fixed. I had no idea whether or not they understood a word I said. Almost two years had passed when they called again. By then, they had received their Zoning Compliance Permit and approval from the Historic District Commission and had selected an architect and contractor and construction work was underway. After measuring the trusses, we performed a plane frame analysis. The 29 scissors trusses that frame the roof were built with 2" 5¾" chords and 1¼" 8" collar ties. The pitch of the top chord was approximately 10 to 12 and the pitch of the bottom chord was approximately 7 to 12. The design span used for analysis was slightly less than 32 feet. The spacing between trusses averaged about 19 inches. We compared the calculated deflection against field measurements and reviewed the capacity of the nailed connections against the calculated member forces. Surprisingly, the analysis indicated that the member sizes and connections were adequate. The actual horizontal deflection was compared to the long-term calculated deflection. The total load deflection in the horizontal direction at the right support was calculated to be 7.47 inches, assuming the left support hinged and the
c04.indd 45
12/18/08 10:08:35 PM
46
Conservation and the Specialty Contractor
right support provided with a roller bearing in the x (horizontal) direction. Horizontal deflection due to dead load only was equal to 3.77 inches. This compared well to a measured deflection of 5.5 inches. When one considers that for a 30-foot span, the long-term dead load deflection of a timber structure is taken as 1.5 times the calculated dead load deflection. For trusses, the actual measured dead load deflection often exceeds the calculated deflection by a factor of three or four. With a small amount of resistance added to the roller in the horizontal direction, of 2 kips per inch, the total load horizontal deflection dropped to 0.41 inches. Obviously, the analysis indicated that the deflected shape of the roof truss was dependent on the boundary conditions, which in this case included support on a wood partition able to yield in the horizontal direction. The roof trusses were carefully modeled in the computer using section properties calculated for the actual dimensions of the truss components, and a modulus of elasticity of 1,600,000 psi. Lapped members were modeled as lapped members with a link connector to provide for continuity through the member intersection as well as rotation. Long-term deflection in timber scissors trusses is often magnified for a number of reasons. As in all wood-framed trusses in attics, the reduction in moisture content over timber affects the members and the joints. Normal creep is magnified if the roof structure was built from green timbers and high stresses were sustained over time due to dead loads only. Also, the types of connections have an effect on amount of deflection experienced. Shrinkage across the grain and the elongation of metal fasteners and the relaxation of wood fibers all contribute to movement in roof trusses. At the same time, the developer indicated that he was planning to demolish the sloped floor of the sanctuary because he was renovating the church as office space to be used for research. He had obtained as a tenant, a private scientific laboratory. They could only utilize the sanctuary as office space if the floor was not sloped. Again, we observed that the floor was simply framed and supported in the partial crawl space and basement on brick walls and piers. The floor joists of the sanctuary were 2" 9 ¾" southern pine joists spaced approximately 18 inches on center. This floor area was approximately 30 feet by 43 feet in size, with half of the floor sloping down to a 15-inch step at the chancel platform. At the time of our first visit we recommended that the developer obtain the services of one of two specialty contractors. We explained to the structural moving firm of Blake Moving Company of Greensboro, North Carolina, what we had in mind. The idea was to shore the roof trusses, separate them from their supports at the top of the wood partition, plumb up the partition and then reattach the trusses. We also explained what would be required to level the sloping
c04.indd 46
12/18/08 10:08:35 PM
Timber Framer Selection
47
floor of the sanctuary in one piece. Charlie Blake of Blake Moving Company understood exactly what to do, and accomplished the task in short order. So the adaptive reuse of this historic church facility into laboratory and administrative office space required very little new material, although 1,096 days passed from the first contact to completed project, most of the construction involved things other than the structural aspects of the work. We were able to certify the “adjusted” roof structure as structurally adequate and the building retained its historic floor structure. One interesting note occurred at the dedication of the new laboratory facility. The developer invited the church membership to attend the dedication. Several of them were less than happy to see their old sanctuary in like-new condition with the old millwork, flooring, and ceiling still intact. Apparently, one of the investors described to them how little was required to “fix” their former church sanctuary. At the United Church of Chapel Hill, it was fortunate that we were contacted early enough in the process to recommend a solution, and in particular, a specialty contractor capable of doing the job. In both of these cases, considerable historic fabric was retained, and money was saved for the owners by providing a unique solution to those capable of executing the design.
TIMBER FRAMER SELECTION Our most successful projects have been ones where we were able to select the timber framer in advance, or where we proposed several qualified bidders for consideration, or where we were able to insert prequalification language into a technical specification prior to bid. These have included new structures as well as the restoration and rehabilitation of existing buildings.
Tohickon Aqueduct For the rehabilitation of the Tohickon Aqueduct in Point Pleasant, Pennsylvania, we first designed the structure as a timber-frame Burr arch-truss system with mechanically laminated two-hinged arches. Bill Collins and I consulted with Jan Lewandowski to predetermine the constructability of the three span continuous timber system on site. As an aqueduct structure with an impervious liner, because of possible condensation and splash issues on the underside, we specified the material to be pressure treated. The original structure, which carried the Delaware Canal over Tohickon Creek, was a Town lattice truss. It was replaced with a riveted iron truss, which collapsed in 1931. The replacement steel and concrete aqueduct deteriorated to the point where it had to be
c04.indd 47
12/18/08 10:08:35 PM
48
Conservation and the Specialty Contractor
replaced to maintain the viability of the canal. Bill Collins proposed that the latest incarnation be built as a Town lattice structure, similar to the original. For several reasons, I determined that a Burr arch structure would be preferable. We courted several timber-frame companies as possible bidders, including Blue Ridge Timberwrights and Pocopson Industries. When the project bid, neither of the two firms that we were counting on turned in a price. Apparently, construction of the three-span structure in the field, within the right-ofway of the canal, was problematic. This was the single issue we had wrestled with during the initial stages of the design. In a value engineering process, we converted the timber-frame arches to glued laminated timber and deleted the saw-tooth splices resulting in three identical simple spans that could be shop fabricated, preassembled, and shipped to the site in sections. From a philosophical standpoint, we deviated from the original system to ensure a better structure and a longer service life. Although the Town lattice is a tough system because of its redundancy, we concluded that a wet environment would cause shrink swell problems in the tightly pinned lattice connections. If the chords and lattice were to be treated, moisture content would also be an issue for the pinned connections. From a maintenance standpoint, we concluded that the Burr arch would allow easier replacement of primary elements. (See Chapter 18 for additional discussion of the Tohickon Aqueduct.)
Market Hall The restoration of the 1841 Market Hall in Charleston, South Carolina, required that the general contractor hire craftsmen with timber-frame skills. MBM Construction of Charleston insisted that its carpenters were fully capable of executing the work described in the plans, in spite of its reluctance to submit qualifications as required by the specifications. Eventually, we prevailed. It was necessary for us to obtain a list of timber framers willing to travel to Charleston for the duration of the work. I played matchmaker between Mike Goldberg and Peter Bull and MBM Construction. Within a few days of the initiation of work, I received a phone call from the superintendent. He said, more or less the following: “Dave! You were right. These guys are fast. Our carpenters would have not been able to do this.” (See Chapter 8 for further description of the Restoration of Market Hall.) There is a tendency for general contractors to think that there is nothing special or difficult about timber-frame work. It is precisely what cannot be easily seen that is critical to the structural engineer. Square and tight joints with critical surfaces fully bearing are what the typical timber-frame demands. Trunnels and pins must be properly installed without damage to them or the
c04.indd 48
12/18/08 10:08:36 PM
Timber Framer Selection
49
members joined. Obviously, connections that rely on multiple surfaces being engaged at the same time, such as saw-tooth or bolt-o-lightning splices, require great precision. Of course, prior to scribing and cutting the first joint, the proper grade of timber must be obtained and properly seasoned. Often, it requires a timberframer’s eye to determine the actual quality of the timber in spite of the specified lumber grades, which may be quite stringent. In most cases, fees to the structural engineer fall quite short of allowing for the complete detailing of all the connections in a new structure or the repair details in a restoration project. Certainly, there are a few clients willing to pay an engineer’s fee to thoroughly study over a period of time, an existing building with problems.
Bunker Hill Covered Bridge For the repairs to the Bunker Hill Covered Bridge in Catawba County, North Carolina, we convinced the Catawba County Historical Society to allow us to obtain bids from two qualified timber framers or bridgewrights based on a site visit where we would all agree on the scope of work. I arranged to meet Arnold Graton and Jan Lewandowski at Douglas Airport in Charlotte and drove them to Catawba County. In that way, based on an analysis and a minimum set of plans, after and informal bid process, we were able to engage lower bidder Arnold Graton to restore the only remaining covered bridge built in accordance with Herman Haupt’s patent for the improved lattice. (See Chapter 15 for additional discussion of the Bunker Hill Covered Bridge.)
Yates Mill Both Jan Lewandowski and Arnold Graton worked on various stages of Yates Mill (ca. 1778) in Raleigh, North Carolina. As a member of the Yates Mill Associates, I did not have a contract for structural engineering plans and specifications. In an advisory role, I prevailed upon Yates Mill Associates to hire Jan and Arnold for various portions of the work. When Hurricane Fran destroyed the sawmill portion of Yates Mill, we were engaged by North Carolina State University to design the repairs. Again, we inserted prequalification language into the specifications. My preservation philosophy was enhanced while following Jan’s work around the mill as he cut out deteriorated wood and inserted all sizes and shapes of inserts and Dutchmen into posts and beams. At one, point I asked Jan about some notchedend cuts at some new floor joists that did not appear terribly good. He replied that those end cuts looked that way because his crew was mimicking the work of the original framer. I thought, of course! The original builder was a miller interested in grinding some corn as soon as possible. He was not a timberwright.
c04.indd 49
12/18/08 10:08:36 PM
50
Conservation and the Specialty Contractor
FIGURE 4-1 Yates Mill required the services of a timber framer.
A Tale of Two Plantations Two very different projects, involving two similar historic structures, illustrate the impact that a structural engineer can have on a project, only if the owner is willing to act on the advice of the engineer. For Burnside Plantation, in Henderson, North Carolina, at my recommendation, the owners agreed to hire Arnold Graton to replace a 26-foot-long portion of a white oak sill in the traditional manner, using a timber cut from a very large white oak tree on the property previously knocked down by Hurricane Fran. In contrast, in Wake County, North Carolina, the relocation of Midway Plantation (ca.1848), the house, and all of its dependencies, had sills replaced by “carpenters” using pressure-treated 2 8s scabbed and nailed together. For the Midway project, we were able to recommend Michael Blake as the structural mover but had no influence with the owners with regard to the timberframe aspects of the work. From a philosophical standpoint, total replacement of a badly deteriorated sill in a traditional manner or scabbing a piece onto a partially decayed sill is much more satisfying than merely nailing a bunch of boards together in place of missing sill material.
Connecticut Barn One of our most satisfying projects was the reconstruction and expansion of a barn in Connecticut. The client desired an indoor space sufficient in size to accommodate basketball. Our solution was to span the large space with two Town lattice trusses.
c04.indd 50
12/18/08 10:08:36 PM
Timber Framer Selection
51
FIGURE 4-2 The Barn was greatly expanded by adding two Town lattice trusses parallel to the ridge.
The architect selected me to assist with the design, and I recommended Arnold Graton as the best craftsman to undertake the project.
FIGURE 4-3 The 73-foot-long Town lattice trusses provided a clear span of almost 45 feet.
c04.indd 51
12/18/08 10:08:38 PM
52
Conservation and the Specialty Contractor
Miles Brewton House In spite of a lack of control, sometimes we have been pleasantly surprised by the skill that craftsmen previously unknown to us have brought to a project. I met Tommy Graham of McClellanville, South Carolina, at the Miles Brewton House (ca. 1769) in Charleston in 1988. The two-story portico of the Miles Brewton House features four columns of Oxford (England) limestone. It was thought that cracks in the columns were the result of the corrosion of the iron pins between drum sections. We determined by a review of historic photographs that the cracks more likely were caused by the 1886 earthquake. A survey of earthquake damage included a historic photograph of damage to the capital of one column. A subsequent historic photograph showed a newly installed iron band, most likely made by a blacksmith. There was considerable damage to the second level portico. A lack of bracing indicated that with movement in the north-south direction, during a seismic event, the portico could easily rack. Analysis indicated that the Oxford columns contained enough mass to produce a large lateral force when accelerated during an earthquake. Examination of nearby properties indicated that movement was in the northsouth direction. Damage to nearby parapets, chimneys, garden walls, storefronts and porticos indicated that this was true. Tommy Graham and his crew brought timber frame, carpentry, and painting skills to the Miles Brewton House.
St. Michael’s Episcopal Church In the steeple of St. Michael’s (ca. 1756–1761), Charleston, South Carolina, Tommy Graham provided the necessary craftsmen to rehabilitate a steeple constructed of cypress timbers. Initially, we proposed that several of the 6 8 framing timbers be replaced. Tommy pointed out that although he could mine large dense cypress timbers in nearby rivers, lakes, and swamps, acquisition of dry cypress timbers might be problematic. He instead proposed epoxy repairs to the steeple framework. In response, we instructed him to have his crew prepare a dozen lap joint samples under field conditions that could be tested in a laboratory. With segmental in-fill and the installation of Dutchmen we were able to rehabilitate the deteriorated timbers in a systematic way while maximizing the retention of historic fabric.
Darrah Hall After our experience at St. Michael’s, we recommended Tommy Graham to undertake the rehabilitation of Darrah Hall at Penn School (ca. 1882) on St. Helena Island, South Carolina. Darrah Hall had totally collapsed due to an unchecked long-term roof leak.
c04.indd 52
12/18/08 10:08:40 PM
Timber Framer Selection
53
FIGURE 4-4 Darrah Hall in St. Helena’s Island, South Carolina, had totally collapsed.
Again, using epoxy techniques, we restored the structural system of the building with a minimum loss of the original material.
FIGURE 4-5 Darrah Hall was restored using 90 percent of the original material.
c04.indd 53
12/18/08 10:08:40 PM
54
Conservation and the Specialty Contractor
Bloomsbury We also recommended Tommy Graham to rehabilitate a pair of two story porch columns at Bloomsbury in Camden, South Carolina. This home was the city home of Sarah Chesnut (1813–1889) during the Civil War. Tommy transported each column, in turn, to the shop where they were rehabilitated by segmental infill while controlling the moisture content of the pie shaped Dutchmen inserts and the solid timber cypress columns.
Montpelier Recently, we provided design to Mesick, Cohen, Wilson, and Baker, Architects of Albany, New York, for the restoration of James Madison’s Montpelier in Orange, Virginia. Although the array of craftsmen included several with timber-frame experience, most considered themselves furniture makers. Three tasks required special know-how that generated uncertainty among the assembled crew. Again, we recommended Arnold Graton to underpin the 1750s chimney, providing space for underground mechanical ducts to make a transition to the vertical space within the chimney. Also, leveling the floors required some expertise with shoring that the staff was not prepared to undertake. With a topographic map of the surface of the floors in hand, Arnold installed towers of 6 7, by 4 foot long, spruce cribbing. Floors were leveled starting at the attic floor, moving downward in stages, in one portion of the building at a time. Montpelier consists of a central portion with wings added on both sides. Between theses sections are masonry walls that served as the division between the phases in the floor leveling effort. We also asked Arnold to provide a price to rehabilitate a 12" 16" deteriorated first floor timber by routing out the decayed wood in its core and replacing it by segmental infill with laminated veneer lumber. The advantages of using laminated veneer lumber are similar to glued laminated timber in that the timber possesses considerable strength and the moisture content is strictly controlled. We also brought wood scientist Ron Anthony to the project to do some investigative resistance drilling. His work in the basement was critical in finding this deteriorated beam, which felt hard to the touch and appeared to be sound. (See Chapter 10 for additional discussion of James Madison’s Montpelier.)
PLAN STAMPING You would think that the ideal project for a structural engineer is one that the timber framer initiates. Unfortunately, most of timber framer work involves the requirement that the shop drawings for new timber-frame buildings bear
c04.indd 54
12/18/08 10:08:42 PM
Plan Stamping
55
the seal of a professional engineer attesting to the design. In those cases, the engineer is hired after the fact. In some cases, it is an afterthought, or seems to be, or it was simply a requirement of the project from the beginning, but the general contractor and timber-frame company chose to ignore it, hoping that it would go away. In these cases, it is important to provide the specialty structural engineer with all of the project requirements. It is not sufficient to provide only the shop drawings in the expectation that they will be sealed without much of a review. Besides live loads, the structural engineer should be informed of the grade and species of the wood and of any unusual conditions such as fragile finishes, deflection requirements at large openings such as above-glass partitions, or retractable folding doors, or unusually heavy roofing or flooring materials. Standard practice should involve providing a full set of plans and specifications to the specialty structural engineer. Without complete information, the structural engineer can review the design on the shop drawings based only on what is provided. It is then the timber framer who is responsible for transmitting the project requirements. Structural engineers and timber framers alike should be aware of stringent requirements place on specialty engineers by the building code and the engineer’s board of registration in such states as Florida. It is becoming increasingly more difficult to practice as a registered professional engineer in multiple states. Variations in the method of sealing a sheet of drawings and what information must be provided are becoming more complicated. Many states require the engineer’s corporation to be registered as a business entity and/or pay license. In Tennessee, it is not possible to hire an engineer to seal shop or submittal drawings after the initiation of the project. The board of registration has consistently interpreted this section of the law to mean that a registrant is prohibited from sealing or stamping any document for which the registrant was not responsible for the original design. To merely review and seal or stamp drawings is most commonly referred to as plan stamping; the board’s discipline for plan stamping ranges from a warning or reprimand, to the imposition of civil penalties, to the suspension or revocation of a certificate of registration. Ironically, it is often the large engineering firms that initiate specifications requiring the timberframe or glued laminated timber manufacturer to produce the final design, the design of connections, and an engineer’s seal on the shop drawings. In many cases, calculations must be submitted for approval. Of course, the board of registration members who are horrified at the thought of “plan stamping” are usually principals of these same large firms. So, in an era of globalization, the states are becoming more provincial in a rigorous effort to eliminate “plan stamping.” Unfortunately, they don’t recognize
c04.indd 55
12/18/08 10:08:43 PM
56
Conservation and the Specialty Contractor
the timber engineer as a rare individual willing to review drawings for timber structures serving the timber frame and glued laminated timber industries where other engineers are not. The best projects initiated by timber framers are the ones requiring the engineer to exercise his skills in developing a design solution in the initial stages. In the preliminary design effort, the engineer often can produce a unique solution. This is a valuable service that provides the engineering designer great satisfaction; it also may provide the timber framer with a competitive edge.
BLUE RIDGE TIMBERWRIGHTS AND AL ANDERSON We utilized the services of Blue Ridge Timberwrights and Al Anderson for several projects. Blue Ridge Timberwrights provided the superstructure for the New Covered Bridge at Old Salem and two, two-story replicated buildings at Somerset Place State Historic Site in Washington County, North Carolina. Blue Ridge Timberwrights were one of several firms that met the prequalification requirements of the specifications. Al Anderson also provided timber-frame services for Single Sisters House in Old Salem and White’s Mill in Abington, Virginia.
CONCLUSION To ensure success of many of our projects, we have had to prevail upon the owner, architect, contractor, and others in decision-making roles to engage subcontractors and craftsmen with specific skills. Structural engineers must take this proactive role to ensure that the work has the best chance to be completed in accordance with the engineer’s intent. In cases where this process was derailed for one reason or another, the results were less than satisfactory. For all concerned, it is best for the engineer to simply walk away from these projects if contractual relationships will permit him to do so.
c04.indd 56
12/18/08 10:08:43 PM
CHAPTER
5
Historic Timber Structures
INTRODUCTION hrough specialized knowledge and experience, engineers can make the judgments needed to properly evaluate historic timber structures. The structural engineer may also be called on to utilize his or her skills to reinforce, rehabilitate, or restore historic structures. This chapter will deal with timber as the primary structural component for most historic structures in the United States and Canada. Although timber is but one component of a historic structure, which may consist of brick and stone masonry, iron, steel, or concrete; it often is the most misunderstood construction material of all. The engineer must be convinced that the structural model is an accurate representation of actual conditions. Once that is clear, the application of rigorous analysis, testing, and engineering judgment may be necessary to explain why the historic structure in question has performed adequately for many years. Structural engineers must play an integral role in historic preservation efforts. Although architects, planners, art historians, city officials, real estate developers, investment bankers, politicians, and conservators have been in the forefront of the preservation movement, it is the structural engineer who
T
Structural Investigation of Historic Buildings: A Case Study Guide to Preservation Technology for Buildings, Bridges, Towers, and Mills. David. C. Fischetti © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
c05.indd 57
57
12/18/08 10:09:28 PM
58
Historic Timber Structures
FIGURE 5-1 Hurricane Fran destroyed the sawmill portion of Yates Mill in Raleigh, North Carolina.
possesses the knowledge and skills necessary to solve many of the problems associated with renovation, restoration, rehabilitation, and adaptive reuse of historic structures. The structural engineer is best qualified to measure, monitor, analyze, and evaluate historic structures. The Economic Recovery Tax Act of 1981 eliminated an economic bias in favor of new construction. Tax incentives for rehabilitating older buildings were simplified and substantially improved, especially in the case of historic buildings. The tax act gave impetus to the historic preservation movement. Structural engineers found themselves more involved in historic preservation projects as owners and developers discovered the benefits of the 1981 tax act.
TIMBER DESIGN AND HISTORIC PRESERVATION Often the proper analysis and evaluation of a historic structure requires that the structural engineer have extensive timber design experience. Many historic structures in the North America are timber framed. Masonry construction is generally utilized for foundations, exterior wall support, and building enclosure.
c05.indd 58
12/18/08 10:09:29 PM
Timber Design and Historic Preservation
59
A thorough knowledge of the physical and mechanical properties of wood is a necessity. Many historic structures were constructed of green timber because of the considerable time required to air dry large timbers. In the seasoning process timber gives off or takes on moisture from the surrounding atmosphere with changes in temperature and relative humidity until it attains a balance relative to the atmospheric conditions. Historic structures have had time to reach this point of balance known as the equilibrium moisture content. Moisture content is the weight of the water contained in wood, expressed as a percentage of the weight of the oven dry wood. As wood loses moisture, the water in the cell cavity is evaporated first. The condition at which the water in the cell cavity has been evaporated but the cell wall is still saturated is known as the fiber saturation point. This point is usually assumed to be at approximately 30 percent. When the moisture content is reduced below this point, shrinkage will occur. Builders of heavy timber structures usually make allowances for shrinkage in the design of members and connections. The amount of shrinkage may be calculated by utilizing tables that give amounts of radial, tangential, and volumetric shrinkage from green to oven-dry moisture content for various species. A moisture meter is an important tool for the structural engineer. What has been misinterpreted as deflection or settlement in historic structures may be due to the across-the-grain shrinkage of large timber girders that were installed in a green condition and subsequently dried to low moisture content. An increment borer can be utilized by the structural engineer to obtain core samples 0.2 of an inch in diameter, which can be used to determine the species, the number of growth rings per inch, the oven-dried weight, the moisture content, and the specific gravity of the wood sampled. Many times in old, dry buildings with dense wood, the increment borer is ineffective because the wood is too hard to penetrate or the sample crumbles upon extraction. In those cases, larger samples can be cut out that, upon testing, will yield more accurate test results. Many times, certain parts of a structure will indicate a moisture content that is considerably higher than the equilibrium moisture content determined by the dry bulb temperature and relative humidity. Usually, close contact of timber with moisture containing masonry or earth will cause elevated moisture content at the bearing points of timber purling, joists, beams, columns, or trusses. The moisture is most readily absorbed through end grain. Once the moisture content rises above 20 percent, decay may occur. Strength-reduction effects of decay and termite infestation many times occur at support points. Repairing these areas of high shear is a challenge to the structural engineer involved in historic preservation.
c05.indd 59
12/18/08 10:09:30 PM
60
Historic Timber Structures
The structural engineer evaluating the heavy timber frame of a historic structure should be intimately familiar with the causes and significance of checking and the structural considerations. A familiarity with timber-grading rules and the strength-reduction properties of various natural growth characteristics can be obtained from The Wood Handbook of the U.S. Forest Products Laboratory.1 The structural engineer must review the past practice of excessively notching floor or roof joists into carrying members using the end-notched beam formulae presented in various timber design manuals and textbooks. A joist might be perfectly adequate in bending and deflection and be critical in horizontal shear at a notched support. This condition may be easily remedied by installing custom-sized nailed joist hangers to transfer vertical forces from the joist to the supporting member. Checking is caused by the difference in the moisture content between the inner and outer wood fibers of timber members. As timber dries from the fiber saturations point (approximately 30 percent moisture content) to zero moisture content, it shrinks. As the outer wood fibers dry, large stresses form between the inner and outer wood fibers. Checking is merely the separation of the wood fibers that occur as shrinkage stresses are relieved. In general, shrinkage is greater in larger timbers than in small timbers of the same species and greater in hardwoods than in softwoods. Although season checks affect the horizontal shear strength in timber, the design values for various grades and species have to be set up anticipating season checking in excess of the grading limitations. Season checks at middepth of a beam near a support are important to shear strength. Compression or tension members are normally not affected. In Japan, a common practice is to cut a saw kerf, or artificial check, along the centerline of one face of a large timber half the depth of the timber (to the pith) in order to relieve stresses due to differential shrinkage before they cause checking.
TIMBER MISUNDERSTOOD AS A CONSTRUCTION MATERIAL Almost all buildings constructed during the first 300 years of settlement in the New World were of timber-frame construction. Even brick, stone, and log buildings had timber-framed roof and floor systems. This form of construction is characterized by the use of substantial pieces of timber, of square and rectangular sections, fabricated into a braced frame. The timbers in the frame are connected to each other by timber joints such as the mortise and tenon, half lap, dovetail, wedged half-dovetail, birdsmouth, and scarf. Joints may be pinned with wood pins, sometimes called pegs, treenails, or trunnels.
c05.indd 60
12/18/08 10:09:31 PM
Traditional Timber Joinery
61
Although timber is but one component of a historic structure, which may consist of brick and stone masonry, iron, steel, or concrete; it often is the most misunderstood construction material. Part of the misunderstanding lies in our educational system. Many structural engineers earn degrees in civil engineering without ever taking a course in timber design. It is unfortunate in North America, with our tremendous stock of timber-framed buildings and our strong forest products industry, that more civil engineering curricula do no include mandatory courses in timber design. In the 1990s, timber in most important to the residential market as dimension framing, prefabricated trusses, stress-rated panels, and other components. The size of residential framing members is dictated by building codes for various spans and conditions.
TRADITIONAL TIMBER JOINERY The key to timber frames and timber-framed trusses is the connections between members. The Achilles’ heel of timber joinery is tension connections. Early truss builders learned to provide iron straps at connections that were susceptible to failure. Consider the king post connection of a simple truss. Many postto-bottom-chord connections in king post trusses were furnished with iron straps and pins, especially where the bottom chord carried a suspended plaster ceiling or attic floor. Engineers evaluating timber frames and trusses should pay particular attention to tension joints. Sometimes the orientation of members is perpendicular, parallel, or of some angle in between. Usually, timber frames include braces that are oriented close to a 45-degree angle between posts and beams. It is important to consider the connection of the braces in the analysis of a frame. If a plane frame analysis results in high-tensile forces at brace end joints that appear inadequate, it may be appropriate to reanalyze without the tension braces included or provide a certain amount of slip in the joint. In many frames it can be assumed that only knee braces in compression are capable of resisting lateral loads. Joints may rely on pins (hardwood or iron), bearing surfaces, or side plates to transfer load. Tension splices of large timbers may be lapped or scarf joints with shear blocks, keys, shear pins, splice plates, fish plates, iron dogs, or a combination of two or more elements. The modern engineer can learn much from historic timber splice joints. Today’s shear plate, split ring, and spike grip timber connectors can maximize the capacity of a splice because a relatively small cross-section is removed in
c05.indd 61
12/18/08 10:09:31 PM
62
Historic Timber Structures
FIGURE 5-2 At James Madison’s Montpelier, a simple fork and loose tongue connection provided sufficient strength.
FIGURE 5-3 Simple scarf joints were provided to extend the ends of the ceiling joists at Montpelier.
order to install such connectors. Only in recent years has the design code recognized that long lines of connectors may result in unequal sharing of load due to drilling and punching tolerances.
c05.indd 62
12/18/08 10:09:31 PM
Structural Evaluation
63
Connection of posts and beams in many buildings may contain mortise and tenon joints of various configurations. Continuity in the frame may be accomplished with long tie beams with splines and pins. Rafters may be tenoned into a ridge member, a supporting plate, a tie beam, or a post. Joints, purlins, and beams may be connected to girders, rafters, beams, or trusses with mortise and tenon joists or housed or unhoused dovetail joints.
STRUCTURAL EVALUATION Engineers are most commonly asked to examine the timber frames of public structures, such as courthouses, churches, and bridges. Although wall posts, interior columns, sills, and plates are usually found adequate to their tasks according to modern engineering criteria, roof systems and trusses, bracing, joists, and tension joinery, when quantitatively analyzed, often appear barely able to carry their own dead load. Since most of the frames being examined have been successfully carrying dead and live loads for a hundred years or more, the conclusion that they will not work indicates that there may be something wrong with our analysis. Accurate field measurements are essential in defining the structure and its condition. Surveying methods have been successfully utilized in determining the stiffness of deflected beams and trusses. A topographic plan of the floor surface of a historic structure will yield a useful visual representation of an irregular floor if the contour interval is small. Irregular floors in a historic structure could be the result of movement in the supporting soils, timber decay or shrinkage, or deflection of structural components. Obtain accurate measurements. Apply some engineering judgment when standard procedures do not fit the situation. For example, you might assume that the original wood in use in a historic structure, unless inspection tells you otherwise, has design values that are as high as possible for the species. The straight-grained timber from the old-growth forest, with its small and scattered knots, was almost always much better material than the samples that modern design values are based on. Keep in mind that quality may be more important than species. Most of the great railroad bridges built in the northeast in the nineteenth century were of white pine, which is not favored for structural purposes today, but was favored then because it was available in great quantity as clear and dense growth. Structural evaluations usually include a determination of the ability of a floor or roof system to support service loads. Monitoring of an existing structure may be required in order to obtain data for such an evaluation. Testing programs
c05.indd 63
12/18/08 10:09:34 PM
64
Historic Timber Structures
may have to be designed to aid in determining the strength of component materials or complete assemblies. Methods may consist of destructive or nondestructive testing of component materials or load tests of structural members (such as beams) or assemblies (such as trusses). Adaptation of current testing methods for field use on historic structures will be necessary. Computer models used to analyze steel trusses may not be totally appropriate for analyzing wood trusses. A timber member is often moved away from its ideal point of bearing in order that there be room to construct the joint. The original builder was building a truss, and it probably functions like one. The problem for us today is to model it correctly. Obtain the advice of an engineer with experience evaluating timber structures, particularly in cases where maintaining the historic integrity of a frame was a parallel goal to ensuring structural stability. Ask your state Historic Preservation Office or the National Park Service, or a timber framer, for recommendations to locate an engineer qualified to undertake the structural evaluation.
LIVE LOAD DURATION AND HISTORIC STRUCTURES This is a most appreciated concept to apply to timber design because of the long history of the concept of live load duration. Early timber research found that timber reacts quite well to short applications of load. The duration of load was found to be as critical as the magnitude of the load. Presumably, the natural composition of timber consists of a tightly bound bundle of cells that tend to stretch or elongate with time. The larger and more constant the load, the more the stretching of fiber occurs. The effects of this creep can be seen in many timber structures through extensive deflection. For short durations of load, allowable design values will be increased substantially. This timber verses stress relationship is a most important research area. Only through evaluating historic timber structures can we solve this puzzle, which is complicated by cyclic loading, original moisture content, member size, span, species, grade, temperature, humidity and magnitude of stress.
ENGINEERING JUDGMENT Members in the horizontal plane such as floor sheathing, joists, purlins, and beams are stressed principally in bending. The resisting bending moment is a measure of the strength of such and element. This, together with stiffness and
c05.indd 64
12/18/08 10:09:34 PM
Load Tests
65
horizontal shear, are the three qualities that are normally determined during the process of selection we call design. Because timber is available in certain standard lumber sizes, the designer selects from those available, the size, grade, and species that most economically meets the preordained standards for bending stress, deflection, and horizontal shear. When the engineer reviews the capacity of an existing member, many parameters complicate this process. Size, span, and spacing of members are dictated by the existing structure. It is the engineer’s task to determine the size, orientation, species, grade, and end condition of all the structural elements in a building that already exists. The freedom of choice afforded by design is therefore reduced in the review process. Often, the structural engineer must pass judgment on a structure that has served far beyond what we consider to be a normal period of service. The timbers were not selected on the basis of modern engineering analysis. They certainly do not bear inspection marks attesting to their grade and specie. It should be obvious to the engineer that a safe floor structure should not fail in bending due to the actual loads imposed. But it is important to recognize that excessive deflection, excessive vibration, or lack of stiffness, should not automatically categorize a floor structure as “unsafe”. Strict deflection limitations should be set, however, for floors that support plaster ceilings in lieu of wood or tin ceilings, or no ceilings at all. But for comfort, the live load deflection limitation set in most building codes for floors, no matter what the ceiling, is 1/360th of the span. It must be said that overstressed structural members may also be perfectly safe. It is, however, important to evaluate the basis for the conclusion. The loads assumed for design should be reconciled with the actual loads that will occur in service. The design values that we assume are very critical to the computed capacity of some floor systems. For structures such as mill buildings, average design values yield results that fall well above the minimum code requirements for an adaptive reuse occupancy such as office or retail.
LOAD TESTS Load testing a historic structure may be the only reasonable way to justify conditions or materials that are difficult to analyze. In designing a load test, the engineer must call for the application of realistic loads carefully applied. Great care should be taken before applying twice the design live load, as required by many building codes, to a historic structure. For timber structures, it may be
c05.indd 65
12/18/08 10:09:35 PM
66
Historic Timber Structures
unrealistic to apply full live load plus an increase for a period such as 24 or 48 hours, when the structure actually will never reach that service loading for that length of time. Applying a known, safe load to a historic structure is an excellent method to determine the stiffness characteristics of various materials. This is of special value when evaluating timber structures. It is important to realize that because of the variation in the strength characteristics of timber, a load test of one member of a structure may not be indicative of the true capacity in other areas of the building. For any material, before a load test is undertaken, the engineer must be certain that all lateral bracing and slenderness requirements are satisfied. A preliminary analysis must be performed to ensure that the structure will not be loaded past the elastic limit or further to destruction. The application of strain gages and other instrumentation is highly desirable in monitoring a load test. Through the use of monitoring techniques, testing, measurements, observation, and structural calculations, an accurate interpretation of the structural capability of a historic structure can be presented in a carefully written report.
THE TIMBER TRUSS COMPUTER MODEL Slippage, rotation, shrinkage, or the lack of continuity in a timber joint is difficult to allow for in a chord-plane frame analysis of a timber truss. Multiple chord trusses will invariably appear stiffer when analyzed, even when all joints are free to rotate in the computer model. Structural engineers are aware that it is very difficult to produce a true hinge or a true fixed joint in the actual structure. Joints in timber trusses may act somewhere between the two causing a very different distribution of forces than produced by the analysis. How does one model a half-lapped and notched joint in an indeterminate frame? How about the problem of describing the intersecting member of a multiple chord truss where half of the member section in each direction passes through a joint and all pieces nailed together with wrought iron spikes? When analyzing a timber structure, the structural engineer must remember that wood is a orthotropic material with unique properties parallel and perpendicular to grain. Not only are properties in tension, compression, and shear unique for various species, but also the modulus of elasticity varies with grain direction. The moduli of elasticity along longitudinal, radial, and tangential axes of wood vary between species and with specific gravity and moisture content. A computer program for the analysis of wood structures should include the
c05.indd 66
12/18/08 10:09:35 PM
A Repair Philosophy
67
12 constants needed to describe the elastic behavior of wood. Three moduli of elasticity (E), three moduli of rigidity (G), and six Poisson’s ratios can be found in the Wood Handbook for some common species. For timber design and analysis, today’s computer programs should be using the relationships between stress and strain, which have been worked out for homogenous, orthotropic materials. The ideal timber analysis program would input species, specific gravity, and moisture content. Obviously, with such a tool we could vary the moisture content to reflect the drying out of a timber frame or truss during a long period of service. We could then better understand the effects of shrinkage in members and joints.
A REPAIR PHILOSOPHY When repairing timber trusses it is better to reinforce than replace members or connections. Epoxy has been used with success to fill and consolidate areas of decayed wood. If it is necessary to replace individual members, it is important to not modify the configuration of the existing truss unless the action of the truss is easily understood. In many timber structures it is not the members themselves which are critical elements but rather the connections. Connections made with cut or wrought nails are difficult to evaluate. Hardwood dowels, iron pins, cast iron seats or keys, saw-tooth splices, scarf joints, mortise and tenon joints, shear connectors, metal hangers, and anchors vary in capacity, depending on the direction of the load with respect to the angle of the grain. A review of the lateral bracing of historic roof trusses in many cases will indicate that although the members and connections can withstand very high forces, the mode of failure would be buckling of the truss at much lower stress levels. The addition of appropriate bracing may be the only required repair. Because of its availability, controlled moisture content, and known design values, glued laminated timber should not be overlooked as a replacement for large timber members. Pressure-treated wood should be specified as replacement material for timbers in contact with masonry or in an area susceptible to moisture. In reinforcing members or connections, the structural engineer must be very familiar with the National Design Specification for Wood Construction of the National Forest Products Association.2 Design values, edge distances, and installation procedures are specified for shear plates, split rings, nails, screws, lag screws, and bolts.
c05.indd 67
12/18/08 10:09:35 PM
68
Historic Timber Structures
The reinforcement or repair of a historic timber truss should be treated with sensitivity and care. The ideal reinforcement or repair would involve the fewest modern fasteners and utilize ring-shank nails and lag screws instead of bolts, if possible. In many cases, supplemental structural framing has to be introduced into a historic structure in order to relieve the original structural framework, which may be deficient. Not only must methods and locations of support for the new structure are determined, but also methods and locations for support of the existing structure, and the effects of the interaction of the two. The problem of erecting the new framework within the confines of the existing structure may present the most difficult challenge to the structural engineer.
REPLACEMENT-IN-KIND Of course “modern” timber products should not automatically replace traditional timber framing and joinery. Replacement-in-kind of members with mortise and tenon, dovetail, tongue and fork, slotted, or oak-pinned joint connection is a possibility that must be considered. In recent years many designs for new post-and-beam frames have been produced containing little or no metal connectors. Traditional technology is available through timber framers located in many areas of the United States and Canada. Often, replacement-in-kind is not economically feasible. More advances are being made in the field of timber design than any other area of structures. Recent products include laminated veneer lumber and numerous other beam and joist substitutes. The most important benefits of these reconstituted wood products is the availability of long lengths, higher design values, and greater stiffness. Preservationists and preservation engineers must determine the appropriateness of these materials to each case.
PRESERVATION PHILOSOPHY All structural engineers should obtain a copy of The Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings. Under these standards, rehabilitation means “the process of returning a property to a state of utility, through repair or alteration, which makes possible an efficient contemporary use while
c05.indd 68
12/18/08 10:09:36 PM
Summary
69
preserving those portions and features of the property which are significant to its historic, architectural, and cultural value.”3 Minimum alteration of the building, its environment, and its distinguishing architectural qualities are required for a project to qualify as a “certified rehabilitation” benefiting from the provisions of the tax act. Archeological resources must be protected, as well as significant historical, architectural, or cultural material. An understanding of the historical significance of a building must be obtained to enable the engineer to provide an acceptable solution to a particular design problem while following the “secretary’s standards.”3 The guidelines for applying the Interior Department’s standards for rehabilitation recommend that the “special problems inherent in the structural system of historic buildings, especially where there are visible signs of cracking, deflection, or failure” be recognized.3 “Stabilization and repair of weakened structural members and systems when damaged or inadequate” are also recommended. “Historically important structural members” are to be replaced “only when necessary.”3 The actual distribution of loads in a structure, similar to live load reduction factors for tributary area, can account for the continued service for heavily loaded members such as stair and fireplace headers, and summer beams, which may appear to the engineer to be grossly undersized. Many times, these members deflect beyond comfortable amounts. These excesses are often dismissed because “this house is old.” The failure rate of historic structures form sudden structural collapse is very small. Even when deterioration due to decay or termites is accounted for, the sudden collapse of an old timber structure is rarely reported. The reports usually involve accidents, such as collision of an automobile with a cast-iron column in the storefront of a commercial structure.
SUMMARY By learning more about timber design, engineers will develop a preservation philosophy that demands rigorous analysis in order to justify “doing nothing” to a historic timber structure that has been performing satisfactorily for many years. Buildings that analysis, testing, and observation clearly indicate are unsafe should be reinforced in the most sensitive manner in an attempt to retain as much historic fabric as possible. Buildings that require extensive modification or reconstruction should be treated in a way that is in keeping with the original construction if possible, while fulfilling safety requirements.
c05.indd 69
12/18/08 10:09:36 PM
70
Historic Timber Structures
FIGURE 5-4 The sawmill portion of Yates Mill was replaced in kind, except that positive anchorage of the timber frame was added.
REFERENCES 1. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service. Forest Products Laboratory Handbook, no. 72. Wood Handbook. Washington D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1974. 2. National Forest Products Association, National Design Specification for Wood Construction, Washington D.C.: National Forest Products Association, 1977). 3. U.S. Department of the Interior, The Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings. Washington D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office. 1979.
c05.indd 70
12/18/08 10:09:36 PM
CHAPTER
6
Watauga Hall and the Montague Building
ver the years I have noticed, or maybe simply imagined, that there appeared to be incredible leeway given by state preservation offices regarding the acceptability of certain architectural and structural decisions involving historic structures. As the structural consultant on many design teams, it often appeared that “the other guy,” usually a developer with minimal professional design input, was allowed to do certain things that our team was not. Was it because our team, headed by a competent and conscientious architect, was able to deal with various requirements while the developer could plead ignorance? Did the developer have more political pull, or was the success of his project more important for the community than ours? Most of the controversies seem to involve architectural decisions such as whether to replace or restore the windows. Although I cannot present a situation where a controversy regarding a similar issue occurred on two different projects, I can present two similar projects with very different outcomes. The Montague Building and Watauga Hall were both built in the early twentieth century with exterior load-bearing brick masonry walls and an interior load-bearing structure of wood. The floors of Watauga Hall consisted of 2 12 framing supported by load-bearing wood studs. The Montague Building was not much different, with floors consisting of 2 12 joists supported by a timber post and beam system.
O
Structural Investigation of Historic Buildings: A Case Study Guide to Preservation Technology for Buildings, Bridges, Towers, and Mills. David. C. Fischetti © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
c06.indd 71
71
12/18/08 10:11:27 PM
72
Watauga Hall and the Montague Building
The rehabilitations of the two buildings were different in that Watauga Hall was a university project administered in part by the North Carolina Department of Administration with no oversight by federal officials. The Montague Building was a privately owned building restored by a developer with oversight by the United States Department of the Interior acting through the state preservation office (SHPO).
OVERVIEW OF WATAUGA HALL AND THE MONTAGUE BUILDING Sometimes decisions regarding the existing structural system of a building are made of the basis of issues other than structural. Upgrades required to address fire safety concerns may be due to changes in occupancy or the need to separate tenants by a enhanced fire rated wall or floor system. The restorations for Watauga Hall and the Montague Building can be judged by The Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Guidelines for Historic Preservation, last amended in 1983, and the Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties, dated 1995. The Standards are not technical or prescriptive, but provide a philosophical basis for the decisions that structural engineers should make regarding historic properties. Whether or not Watauga Hall and the Montague Building are on the National Register of Historic Place is irrelevant. They both are certainly old enough to qualify, and important enough from a cultural standpoint. Deterioration, damage, and defects should, more often than not, be mitigated through reinforcing, or the replacing-in-kind critical elements, or by supplementing the original structure. The standards for preservation, rehabilitation, and restoration require that the historic character of a structure including, distinctive materials and examples of craftsmanship, be retained or preserved, repairing deteriorated features rather than replacing them. Although Watauga Hall and the Montague Building are similar in size, age, and type of construction, their histories are quite different. In 1985, the renovation of Watauga Hall was completed at a cost of $2.5 million. The renovation of the oldest dormitory on the campus of North Carolina State University, in Raleigh, North Carolina, has been judged a success. The project converted a 1903, three-story, wood framed, underutilized building into a noncombustible, four-story, steel and concrete dormitory for graduate students at a cost almost 8 percent below budget. The renovations to Watauga Hall may have been somewhat heavy handed with regard to the recommendations of The Secretary of the Interior’s Standards
c06.indd 72
12/18/08 10:11:28 PM
Overview of Watauga Hall and the Montague Building
73
FIGURE 6-1 The attic of Watauga Hall was converted into dormitory space by raising the elevation for the new roof structure.
for Guidelines for Historic Preservation. As a design team, we did what was necessary to stabilize the building and accommodate the needs of a modern graduate student dormitory. At Watauga Hall we demonstrated that historic timber-frame buildings can be renovated using a cast-in-place two-way flat plate concrete floor system. Historic timber-frame buildings can also be rehabilitated by reinforcing, with steel, every undersized joist and beam if testing and analysis require this. The service life of these two methods of construction can be vastly different, with the former proving more satisfactory in the long run, and the latter barely meeting current building codes in the short term. The challenge for structural engineers is to advise owners, architects, and developers about the aspects of each solution. Although the latter method will certainly not jeopardize the tax credits so necessary in converting a historic structure into a serviceable building, the resulting building may not be the best system for the building.
c06.indd 73
12/18/08 10:11:29 PM
74
Watauga Hall and the Montague Building
Obtaining historic certification from governmental agencies that administer the tax credit status of the project is crucial to the success of a project.
WATAUGA HALL Watauga Hall reflects much of the character and tradition of North Carolina State University, as it is named for the Watauga Club. The Watauga Club was a small but influential group of North Carolinians who were instrumental in the establishment of the land grant agricultural and mechanical arts college commonly known as “State College,” which is now North Carolina State University. Watauga Hall, originally constructed in 1896, was destroyed by fire during Thanksgiving weekend in 1901. The existing Romanesque Revival building was constructed in 1903 on the foundations of the original building. It is the only survivor of several dormitory structures built in 1896 to serve an expanding student body. Watauga Hall functioned, at various times, as the kitchen and dining hall, laundry, and office space for Campus Planning, Personnel, and Information Services. It functioned as a dormitory until 1968. For its last years of use as a dormitory, it provided the first housing on campus for women. Watauga Hall remained empty, between 1968 and 1983, when renovation began.
Watagua Hall Structural Evaluation Conditions inside of the long vacant Watauga Hall were discouraging. The interior was wood framed, including a monumental wood-framed stairway between the first and second levels. The room layout, governed by the location of load-bearing stud walls, was not ideally suited for a modern dormitory containing suites to house graduate students. The square footage was limited for the minimum number of beds that the university housing officials were requiring for efficiency. The architectural and structural response to the limitations of Watauga Hall included replacing the wood-framed floor system, raising the level of the roof to provide an additional floor in the former attic, and converting some of the crawl space to basement for ancillary functions. This was accomplished without underpinning and without extensive shoring and bracing. The original structure for Watauga Hall consisted of 3 12 floor joists spaced at 16 inches on center in some areas and 2 12 floor joists spaced at 18 inches apart in the great majority of the building.
c06.indd 74
12/18/08 10:11:30 PM
Watauga Hall
75
FIGURE 6-2 Watauga Hall was a wood-framed dormitory building.
The roof structure consisted of 2 12 rafters, 18 to 24 inches on center. Although the upper floors were supported by timber-stud corridor walls at interior locations, the basement and crawl space support consisted of 10 10 timber girders on iron pipe columns or brick masonry piers. A computer-aided analysis was used to evaluate floor joists in an area where the 10 10 timbers and iron columns supported the parallel corridor walls above. Opposing 3 12 floor joists lapped each other as they cantilevered over the central timber beam support below. Analysis indicated that the existing floor joists were capable of supporting a 40 psf live load in rooms and at least 100 psf live load in corridor areas. The 10 10 timber beams beneath the first floor were generally inadequately sized, supporting an average floor live load of no more than 20 psf on the floors above. Interestingly, the center of each portion of the building exhibited considerable settlement in the floor system. This settlement increased in amount from the first floor upwards. At the same time, the perimeter of the floor at each level varied by less than three one-hundredths of a foot in elevation on any one floor. I determined that the settlement in the center of each floor area was due to the cumulative vertical shrinkage across the grain of load-bearing beams, joists, headers, and plates. This contradicted a previous report from a geotechnical/structural engineer, who indicated that the depression in the floor system was due to subsurface settlement in the soils.
c06.indd 75
12/18/08 10:11:30 PM
76
Watauga Hall and the Montague Building
The moisture content of the existing timber framing was measured in the field with a Delmhorst J-1 moisture meter. The moisture content registered 5 percent or less in all areas. The total amount of shrinkage was calculated assuming average 19 percent initial moisture content for the 66.0 inches cumulative depth of joists, beams, and girders for the full height of the building. The total shrinkage across the grain for all these members computed to be 4.158 inches. A 19 percent initial moisture content was assumed because of the tendency of large timbers to retain moisture for a long period of time. In fact, the larger 10 10 timbers were probably installed close to a green state (30 percent moisture content). Obviously, the load-bearing timber structure shrank while the exterior brick masonry bearing walls did not. The computed value agreed closely with the 4.0 inches of settlement measured by a Registered Land Surveyor on the fourth floor. For Watauga Hall, samples of the timber framing were obtained with a 0.20-inch-diameter incremental boring tool. Laboratory tests consisting of moisture content, unit weight, and specific gravity were performed on each sample. The specific gravity values of the wood samples were somewhat erratic because of the variations to the size of the specimens, which often broke or crumbled when removed from the hollow auger of the incremental borer. The use of an incremental borer proved less acceptable than merely obtaining larger samples cut from the structure in noncritical locations. Typically, the incremental borer is a tool foresters use to obtain samples from living trees. Advancing such a tool into dry wood is much more difficult and is not recommended.
Brick Masonry Evaluation Several large cubes of brick masonry were obtained from Watauga Hall with a hammer drill from an abandoned masonry pier in the crawl space. Two prism sections were sawed from the cube sample in the laboratory and compressive strength tests were performed. Seven individual bricks were tested in accordance with ASTM C67-80a for compressive strength and modulus of rupture (flexure test). The compressive strength tests of the brick masonry from Watauga Hall indicated that the existing bricks complied with the compressive strength requirements set forth in ASTM C62-80, standard specifications for building brick, Grade SW brick. The compressive strength tests performed on the prism samples indicated that the masonry specimens exceeded the ASTM strength requirements for Type S mortar. In both Montague Building and Watauga Hall the pullout capacity of epoxy capsule bonded 3/4-inch diameter threaded rod anchors placed into the interior
c06.indd 76
12/18/08 10:11:32 PM
Watauga Hall
77
wythes of brick of the exterior wall was evaluated by testing in the field. A calibrated hydraulic jack, anchored to the floor surface, was utilized to apply incremental loads. The average pullout force of less than 600 pounds indicated that satisfactory anchorage to the walls would require that the ties extend through the walls to be fastened to large washers placed on the exterior face of the building.
The New Structural System for Watauga Hall The rehabilitation of Watauga Hall was bid on December 5, 1983, with eight general contractors participating. The low bid for general construction was $1,440,550, with all bid alternates taken. The general, plumbing, electrical and mechanical low bid total was $2,016,209, or approximately 8 percent below the architect’s estimate. The new structural system selected for Watauga Hall consisted of a twoway flat-plate cast-in-place reinforced concrete slab supported by steel tube section columns with shear heads. The concrete slab was placed on the existing timber floor surface to be used as a temporary form. FIGURE 6-3 Column splices and shear heads were positioned at the existing floor level.
The steel columns were threaded through openings cut into the existing floors and braced prior to placing reinforcing and concrete. The existing timber joists were also supported with additional shoring placed at mid-span locations. The steel columns were carried down to new isolated column footings in the basement or crawl space.
c06.indd 77
12/18/08 10:11:32 PM
78
Watauga Hall and the Montague Building
FIGURE 6-4 New steel columns were set on new isolated footings in the crawl space/basement.
Almost the entire suspended floor load for the renovated structure was supported by the steel columns, while the edge of the floor slab provided lateral bracing to the original exterior brick walls. Replacing the existing floor system with a two-way flat-plate structure had structural advantages in that a 6-inch-thick slab could easily support a 100 psf live load with the spans anticipated. An important advantage was the three-hour fire rating easily obtained between floors of the building to be used as a dormitory. The major construction advantage of this system is that once the columns, which are spliced with a simple connection at each floor level, are erected and braced, the other construction materials are easily fabricated and placed. Concrete placed for the floor slab can take any shape contained within the exterior walls without a lot of field measurements required to verify that fabricated components will actually fit into the space to be reframed. The typical reinforcing in the floor system consisted of straight #4 bars. Cast-in-place concrete was conveyed into the building by pumping. Construction was simple in the horizontal direction in that large prefabricated structural shapes, difficult to erect inside an existing building, were not required. Although accurate steel column placement was required for the new structural steel roof system to fit, perimeter dimensions between the columns and the periphery of the building were not critical. The most important advantage is that erection of a new structural system within the brick envelope did not require the complete “gutting” of the building,
c06.indd 78
12/18/08 10:11:33 PM
Montague Building
79
which would have required the introduction of extensive temporary bracing and shoring to protect fragile, laterally unbraced exterior brick masonry walls. This reduced the risk to the contractor during construction. The major disadvantage with the flat plate structural system utilizing the existing floor as a form is that the new floor surface is 6 inches higher than the original floor surface. This changed the relationship of the floor level to architectural details, door heads, and fenestration. Construction was unique in that concrete placement proceeded from the upper levels downward. After each concrete slab reached the required strength, the timber sheathing and joists for that floor were removed as well as the load-bearing studs from the floor below. FIGURE 6-5 The load-bearing stud walls were stripped from the floor below after the slab above cured sufficiently.
This provided an unobstructed floor surface to be used as a form for the next floor below. The only vertical structural elements remaining at each floor level were the exterior masonry walls and the new steel columns. The structural solution selected for Watauga Hall was unique because it involved the systematic removal of the existing timber structure as the steel and concrete structural system was retrofitted.
MONTAGUE BUILDING A few years later, and across town, the 1912, three-story Montague Building was undergoing a $1.8 million renovation, the goal of which was to bring new
c06.indd 79
12/18/08 10:11:34 PM
80
Watauga Hall and the Montague Building
life to a wood-framed office building that had been vacant for at least 15 years. The Montague Building is on the National Register of Historic Places. Located in the central business district of Raleigh, it had been the subject of several architectural and engineering analyses during prior years because of the potential value of leasible office space in the rapidly growing Sunbelt city. FIGURE 6-6 The south face of the Montague Building contained severely deteriorated brick masonry.
The three-story Montague Building was constructed in 1912. The first floor was divided into six retail bays with storefronts on the north side. The upper two floors were, for the most part, office space separated by a double-loaded central corridor. Architectural features included tin ceilings in all areas except the basement. Glass sidewalk prisms allowed natural light into the basement area on three sides of the building. The basement area extends to approximately 4 feet beyond the outside face of the building below the glass prism grates. The glass prisms on the north side had an unusual purple tint. The magnesium content of the glass prisms reacted with the ultraviolet rays in the sunlight to provide the purple color, according to information obtained from the Corning Glass Museum in Corning, New York. The builder of the Montague Building, Benjamin F. Montague, built in a developing section of downtown Raleigh, near the new City Sanitary Farmers Market and Tabernacle Baptist Church on Moore Square. It never reached its potential as an income producing property because Mr. Montague could not find enough satisfactory tenants.
c06.indd 80
12/18/08 10:11:36 PM
Montague Building Structural System Reinforced
81
The upper floors of the Montague Building were used as office space until the 1950s. The lower retail bays were in use until the mid-1960s. Insufficient egress and the absence of a sprinkler system and a fire-rated floor system prevented the upper floors of the Montague Building from being used in more recent times.
MONTAGUE BUILDING STRUCTURAL SYSTEM REINFORCED On February 14, 1986, we forwarded the following report to the developer of the Montague Building: Based upon our observation on January 25, 1985, February 4, 1986, and several other times, we have performed a design analysis of the existing floor joists which frame the floor structure of the Montague Building. The Montague Building structural system is a three-story timber post and beam structure consisting of 6 6 timber columns, 8 10 beams and 1 5⁄8” 11 5⁄8” timber joists, 12 inches on center, which span 19’-6” between frames. There is considerable deterioration of the structural system due to roof leaks. A fire damaged a portion of the floor system in the basement area in the east end of the building. Utilizing a dead load of 23 psf which includes the addition of one inch of Gypcrete topping, a sprinkler system, and a layer of sheetrock to the underside of the joists, it appears that the floor joists cannot safely support a live load of 50 psf in accordance with the 1978 edition of the NC State Building Code. Allowable live load for the floor joists was computed to be 36 psf. We utilized a modulus of elasticity of 1400 ksi and an allowable bending stress of 1400 psi for repetitive member use in accordance with the tabulated design values for Southern pine as found in the 1982 edition of the National Design Specification for Wood Construction. These values were modified by the test results of Froehling and Robertson, Inc. report number RM66-079 date February 1985. Froehling and Robertson’s geotechnical exploration and materials testing report indicates the following:
1. The basement floor slab is inadequate. The thickness of the basement floor slab is 3/4 to 1 ¼ inches. There is no vapor barrier beneath the slab. 2. The underlying soils are stiff, providing and allowable bearing capacity of 3,000 psf. The site is dry with the water table located probably at an elevation of 30 feet below grade.
c06.indd 81
12/18/08 10:11:37 PM
82
Watauga Hall and the Montague Building
3. Pull-out tests of masonry anchors indicate that the existing masonry is quite soft with a low bearing capacity. The condition of the south wall is critical. Masonry deterioration due to water damage and the number of large window openings combine to make the south wall a critical structural element. 4. The six timber joists tested indicate that the existing floor joists are equivalent to No. 2 southern pine except in deflection. Note that the following minimum uniformly distributed live loads will require reinforcement or replacement of the structure in certain areas: • Office (fixed partitions) 50 psf • Office (movable partitions) 80 psf • Retail, first floor, 100 psf • Lobbies, office buildings, 100 psf • Corridors, above first floor, 80 psf • Business machine equipment, 100 psf • Library stack rooms, 150 psf • File Room, 80 psf • Rest Rooms, 60 psf • Public Rooms, 100 psf Also note that the 36 psf allowable live load for the Montague Building is less than most of the uniformly distributed live loads tabulated above. As in many historic buildings, modification to this structure will be necessitated by fire code requirements as well as the inability of the structure to support minimum required design live loads in all floor areas. Joists, columns, and beams are all undersized for minimum office occupancy live loads. We have made a full exploration of options resulting from an in-depth investigation which, in the judgment of this engineer, justifies structurally reconstructing the interior of the building.
After providing a detailed description of the new interior structural concrete flat-plate system that we proposed, we concluded our report with the following: Reinforcement of the very deficient structural system, in a building which has been vacated for 15 to 20 years, is a difficult, risky and costly endeavor. With no question, the existing structural system of the Montague Building should be replaced.
c06.indd 82
12/18/08 10:11:37 PM
Montague Building Structural System Reinforced
83
It is hoped that the recommended structural solution will be seriously considered during the evaluation for integrity by the United State Department of Interior and that the 25% tax credit status will be maintained. We would not want the issue of the loss of tax credits to affect what we believe to be our best judgment as professional engineers when that decision affects the life, health, and safety of the public.
In the Montague Building, this same system of flat-plate concrete slabs and steel columns could have been used to an advantage in that the original noteworthy tin ceilings could have been reinstalled at their proper elevations, close to the existing window heads, while the space previously occupied by the flooring, subfloor, and joists could have accommodated mechanical ducts. In order to accomplish this, the tin ceiling would be taken down, cleaned, paint primed, stored, and then reinstalled on a ceiling framing system suspended from the completed concrete floor structure above. The original structural system for the Montague Building was a three-story post and beam structure consisting of 8 8 timber columns, 8 10 beams, and 2 12 timber joists, spaced at 12 inches on center. Considerable deterioration to the timber structural system was due to roof leaks and fire damage. Although I recommended the flat-plate concrete structure with steel columns for the Montague Building, the developer argued that the replacement of the existing structure would jeopardize the 25 percent tax credit incentive for a certified rehabilitation. The reinforcement of the existing structure of the Montague Building for minimum office occupancy live loads required the reinforcement of every joist and every floor beam. The floor beams were reinforced by applying steel side angles to the outside face of each member with hardened annular threaded, ring shank nails. Reinforcing the joists required the application of a composite metal cover plate to the underside of all joists. The design of this reinforcing was based on transformed section combining the wood joists with the steel cover plate acting in tension. To ensure composite action, the installation of the straps required the contractor to jack the joists above level and fasten the straps to the underside of the joists in a sequential and symmetrical manner starting from mid-span of the joists. The carpenters were less than happy, having to drive thousands of screws, overhead, into the underside of the joists using 1980s-era (very heavy) screw guns. Two types of screws were tested at the North Carolina State University Department of Wood and Paper Science Laboratory to obtain reliable design values in shear for the threaded fasteners. Thirteen assemblies were prepared using 14 gauge by 2-inch-long slotted hexhead screws. Twelve specimens were assembled with 14 gauge by 1 ¾-inch hexhead self-tapping screws. The specimens were fabricated by the general
c06.indd 83
12/18/08 10:11:38 PM
84
Watauga Hall and the Montague Building
contractor under jobsite conditions using wood samples from the Montague Building and then transported to the laboratory. The tapping screws were selected based on test results and ease of installation.
GEOTECHNICAL EVALUATIONS Testing of the existing building components prior to design was a part of the structural assessment for both the Montague Building and Watauga Hall. Subsurface evaluation at each building included test (or observation) pits dug by hand to establish footing depth and configuration, hand auger borings, and test borings drilled with a truck mounted drill rig. Geotechnical testing at Watauga Hall consisted of seven standard penetration test borings drilled to a depth of 25 feet, one hand-auger boring drilled in the crawl space to a depth of 10 feet, and five test pits dug around the perimeter of the building. With respect to underlying geology, both Watauga Hall and the Montague Building are located in the Piedmont physiographic province of Wake County, North Carolina. The in-place chemical weathering of the mica gneiss of the parent bedrock has produced an upper mantel of residual soils with clayey soils confined to the upper stratum. For the Montague Building, a total of six hand-auger borings with dynamic cone penetration tests ranging 2 to 8 feet in depth were made in the basement area. Eight test pits were hand excavated to determine footing configuration, elevation, dimensions, and soil consistence immediately below the footing base. To the exterior of the building, a truck-mounted drill rig was used to advance borings made in accordance with ASTM Specification D-1586 utilizing a hollow stem auger. Soil samples were obtained with a split-barrel sampler driven to a depth of 18 inches or to a blow count of 100 blows with a 100-pound hammer falling 30 inches. The standard penetration resistance N, denoting the number of blows per foot, is an indication of the in-place density strength and foundation support capacity. The soil samples were placed in glass jars, sealed, transported, and visually classified in accordance with ASTM D-2488. In the basement, where access was prohibited to the truck-mounted drilling machine, hand augers were utilized. Handheld penetration testing was performed through the augured holes with a portable dynamic cone electrometer which utilizes a 15-pound steel ring weight falling 20 inches on an “E” rod slide guide. The blows for 1 ¾-inch increments were recorded. These cone resistance values were correlated to the standard penetration values to
c06.indd 84
12/18/08 10:11:38 PM
Timber Materials Evaluation
85
determine the stiffness of the underlying soils. At the time, the use of the portable dynamic cone penetrometer had shown to be most reliable in four geologic regions, including the sandy or clayey sandy micaceous silts of the Piedmont geologic province of the southeastern United States. In addition, relatively undisturbed soil samples were obtained by hydraulically forcing sections of 3-inch diameter, 16-gauge steel, thin wall, or Shelby tube samplers into the soil at desired sampling levels. The samples were removed in the laboratory by a hydraulically operated extrusion press, measured, sampled in accordance with ASTM D-1587, “Standard Method for ThinWalled Tube Sampling of Soils.” The tabulated laboratory test data for the various soil samples included the percentage of natural moisture, Atterberg limits, grain size analysis, the unified soil classification, and a cyclic shear stress versus strain curve for one sample. I requested that the Raleigh office of Froehling & Robertson, Inc. provide materials testing and geotechnical exploration for both Watauga Hall and the Montague Building. Included were geotechnical exploration as well as wood and masonry materials testing. The geotechnical exploration consisted of borings, test pits, and laboratory analysis. The two geotechnical evaluations indicated that the Montague Building and Watauga Hall were both constructed on underlying soils that were stiff, providing a bearing capacity of 3,000 psf. Both sites were dry, with the water table located at an elevation of 30 feet or more below grade
TIMBER MATERIALS EVALUATION Evaluation of the timber joists in the Montague Building required the sampling of six full-length joists selected at random. Field-obtained moisture meter readings were compared with the oven-dried moisture content measurements made in the laboratory on 4-inch square samples in accordance with ASTM D-2016. Tabulated data included specific gravity measured in accordance with ASTM D-2395, annual timber growth rings per inch, of the slope of grain, unit weight of the timber samples, and cross-sectional dimensions of each sample. The 2 12 timber joists were tested to failure in a laboratory utilizing a calibrated hydraulic jack that applied a concentrated load at the midpoint of an 11-foot span. The load was applied in 500-pound increments and deflection was recorded to the nearest .001 of an inch utilizing an Ames Dial Deflectometer. Although the timber samples were visually classified as one of the seven species of southern pine with a grade equal to a high quality No. 2, the test results indicated that the actual stiffness of this material was less than expected.
c06.indd 85
12/18/08 10:11:39 PM
86
Watauga Hall and the Montague Building
The average modulus of elasticity of five samples tested was 1,395,600 psi or approximately 7 percent less than the published modulus of elasticity used for No. 2 southern pine at the time the tests were conducted.
TAX CREDITS The potential loss of historic integrity and the subsequent loss of tax credits in the latter stages of a project could prove disastrous to a developer. A structural engineer’s report should represent a full exploration of options for structurally reconstituting the building. In exercising professional judgment, the designers should consult with the reviewing agency to determine the acceptability of the various options as they relate to historically significant features. The tax status of the Montague Building was retained because the reinforcement option was selected. It appears that if the preferred structural solution for the Montague Building had been a suspended two-way concrete floor slab, the project would have been decertified and not eligible for preservation tax incentives. Although there is a need to develop methods of evaluating the probable service life of structural solutions, we must also be able to identify the other decision-making factors inherent in rehabilitating buildings. Designers must walk a narrow path with regard to renovation options so as to not cause the decertification of a historic property and the loss of tax credits. They must deal sensitively with the feeling of the building so as not to destroy the quality of the building that evokes an aesthetic or historic sense of a past period of time. This feeling may depend on the presence of surviving physical characteristics such as timber-framed floors or exposed roof trusses. Historic authenticity can be lost through extensive replacement of historic material and cannot be recaptured by reconstruction with new material in the rehabilitation. The U.S. Department of Interior has issued interim guidelines for evaluating deteriorated building in order to amplify previously published National Park Service requirements and guidance for the Preservation Tax Incentives Program. How will the serviceability of the reinforced Montague Building compare with the restructured Watauga Hall? The steel and concrete structure within Watauga Hall is a complete structural system supported by new column footings, while the three-story reinforced wood frame of the Montague Building is supported on its original corbelled brick and rubble stone fill column footings and exterior brick masonry walls. The Montague Building is an example of a project in which the original structural system was reinforced in order to meet minimum design load requirements.
c06.indd 86
12/18/08 10:11:39 PM
Subsequent Flat-Plate Applications
87
I proposed a solution similar to the successful flat-plate system used for Watauga Hall, but it was rejected by the owner. The State Historic Preservation officer did not render a clear judgment with regard to the acceptability of the proposed concrete floor system. Although the general contractor preferred the flat-plate approach, sufficiently accurate cost estimates of the two alternate systems were not generated prior to construction. Clearly, our preservation philosophies need to recognize the potential liability inherent in the difficult decisions made by design professionals such as structural engineers. Aesthetics weighs heavily in the decision-making process utilized by governmental agencies administering tax act preservation projects. A solution that requires the designer to reinforce a marginal timber structure, rather than replace the structure with a new system, involves additional risk to the owner, designer, and contractor. The structural engineer is responsible for the structural adequacy for the renovated building through its service life no matter the solution. Reinforcing a structure requires utilization of existing materials, which may not be reliable. The reinforcement of existing structures is more difficult, requiring innovative solutions. When the renovation of a building requires reinforcing of the existing structure, adequate testing of the existing materials is critical. Unfortunately, it is not always possible for the structural engineer to make the best decision with regard to future serviceability and building safety. Constraints imposed by owners and lenders, eager to obtain tax credits, may sway an engineer toward the solution of meeting minimum code requirements for the short term. Success of an historic preservation project depends on many related and unrelated factors. The engineering judgment of the structural engineer should be given considerable weight in making decisions that affect the desired result. Time will tell which solution was best. At the present time, Watauga Hall is fully occupied, limiting space to graduate-level students based on an application process. The Montague Building now houses Café Luna, several offices, and a branch office of a large consulting engineering firm.
SUBSEQUENT FLAT-PLATE APPLICATIONS I have recommended that use of the existing floor framing as a form to support a two-way cast-in-place flat-plate system on five occasions. We used it for the Garrett Hotel in Ahoskie, North Carolina, and more recently with great success at the Eagle Block Hotel in Newport, New Hampshire.
c06.indd 87
12/18/08 10:11:39 PM
88
Watauga Hall and the Montague Building
FIGURE 6-7 Floors were replaced in the Eagle Block (ca. 1835) in similar fashion to Watauga Hall. (See color insert.)
The structural system utilizes the existing wood-framed floor structure as a form for a flat-plate (two-way) concrete floor system. Steel-tube section columns on isolated spread footings support the concrete floor slabs. These are installed and braced prior to placement of concrete. Shear heads transfer the floor loads to the steel columns at each level. Cast-in-place perimeter angles connect the concrete floor slabs to the exterior masonry walls. There are many advantages to this structural system for a renovation such as this. The most important advantage is that the existing floor system can be used as formwork. It is not necessary to deal with tall, unbraced masonry walls during construction. The Concrete Reinforcing Steel Institute states the following advantages of a flat-plate structural system: The two-way flat plate is one of the most efficient structural systems for economy. Flat plates can be constructed in minimum time with minimum field labor because the flat plate utilizes the simplest possible formwork and reinforcing steel layout. Flat plates result in minimum story height for required clear headroom, and provide for most flexibility in layout of columns, partitions, small openings, etc. Where job requirements permit direct application of the ceiling finish to the flat plate soffit, elimination of ceiling construction permits additional substantial cost and construction time savings compared to other structural systems. Flat plates have become increasingly economical and widely used as the cost of field labor has increased relative to materials.
c06.indd 88
12/18/08 10:11:40 PM
Subsequent Flat-Plate Applications
89
They have been applied with particular advantage to multi-story motel, hotel, hospital, dormitory, and apartment buildings 1
As in many historic buildings, modification to the Eagle Block Hotel was necessitated by fire code requirements, as well as the inability by the structure to support minimum required design live loads in certain areas. There are many advantages of a solid two-way flat-plate concrete floor system for the renovation of historic structures. The use of a flat-plate system enables the contractor to utilize the existing floor framing and sheathing as formwork and existing load-bearing walls as shoring. Steps in this process would be as follows: 1. Remove of plaster and millwork from the interior stud walls and ceilings. 2. Construct interior column footings and erect new steel columns with shear heads through the existing floors. 3. Brace the steel columns and apply additional shoring and bracing to the formwork and original structure as needed. 4. Install continuous shelf angles with masonry and concrete tie systems between the perimeter of the flat slab and the existing exterior masonry wall. 5. Place reinforcing steel on the upper level floor structure. The process of setting reinforcing steel, and placing the slab, proceeds, by stages, downward until all levels are in place. At all times the structure is laterally braced by existing or new floor systems. Removal of original vertical supports proceeds from the top floor downward as each concrete slab above reaches sufficient strength. A flat-plate system works well in historic buildings because of the short spans involved. A flat-plate system gives considerable flexibility to the contractor with regard to actual field dimensions that can be a problem when utilizing a framing system of shop-fabricated components. Rectangular or odd bays of varying dimensions can be easily accommodated. The advantages of pumped concrete can also be utilized. This will minimize the amount of vertical floor load transferred by the floor system to the existing walls by providing for cantilevers wherever possible. Usually the use of a flat-plate system eliminates the need for a fire-rated ceiling or spray-on fireproofing. The south wall of the Eagle Block Hotel in Newport, New Hampshire, had a considerable bow in it that had been reinforced early in its history by bolting
c06.indd 89
12/18/08 10:11:41 PM
90
Watauga Hall and the Montague Building
two channels to the outside face of the wall. We described how the steel and concrete system could be used to pull the south wall into alignment so that the existing reinforcing channels could be removed. When the contractor priced this operation as an add alternate of $150,000, it was very quickly deleted from the project by the developer as too costly. In conclusion, the two-way flat-plate system provides a structural system to accommodate the requirements of a modern building without the risk of working within an open masonry shell requiring considerable temporary bracing. This structural system will satisfy all floor live-load and fire-separation requirements. The existing timber roof and attic framing systems can remain in place, as they did at the Eagle Block.
REFERENCE 1. Concrete Reinforcing Steel Institute (CRSI). CRSI Design Handbook, 9th ed. Schaumburg, IL: Concrete Reinforcing Steel Institute, 2002.
BIBLIOGRAPHY Froehling & Robertson, Inc., “Subsurface Exploration & Materials Testing of Watauga Hall,” Report #RJ66-179, July 9, 1982. Froehling & Robertson, Inc., “Supplementary Report, Watauga Hall Renovation,” July 23, 1982. Froehling & Robertson, Inc., “Geotechnical Exploration and Materials Testing of the Montague Building,” Report #RM66-079, February 11, 1985. Froehling & Robertson, Inc., “Tension Test, Restoration of the Montague Building,” Report #RN66-195, June 11, 1986. United States Department of the Interior, National Park Service, Interagency Resources and Reservation Assistance Divisions and Office of the Solicitor, “Interim Guidance on Evaluating Damaged/Deteriorated Buildings in Registered Historic Districts for Purposes of the Preservation Tax Incentives Program.” U.S. Forest Products Laboratory, Wood Handbook: Wood as an Engineering Material, (Washington, DC: USDA Agr. Handbk. 72, Rev. 1974).
c06.indd 90
12/18/08 10:11:42 PM
CHAPTER
7
The Restoration of St. Helena’s Church
he restoration of St. Helena’s Episcopal Church in Beaufort, South Carolina (1724), grew out of a preliminary structural evaluation we provided regarding the deterioration of one end of one queenpost roof truss. The deterioration occurred next to a sidewall chimney flue, which penetrated the roof. A leak in the vicinity of this roof penetration caused severe deterioration to the heel of one of the roof trusses where the top and bottom chords engage each other at the sidewall bearing point. Shortly after the completion of the structural report regarding the roof truss, George T. Fore, Materials Conservator of Raleigh, North Carolina, was engaged by the vestry to study the exterior of the church. Concerns raised in George Fore’s November 1994 “Conditions Analysis and Conservation Studies” report became the focus of additional study and debate.1 They included a question regarding settlement of the sidewalls due to the bearing capacity of the underlying soils. Planned repair of the roof trusses based on the 1993 study needed to be expanded to include repairs to individual truss connections in other locations and the lateral support of some individual truss members that had bowed out of alignment.
T
Structural Investigation of Historic Buildings: A Case Study Guide to Preservation Technology for Buildings, Bridges, Towers, and Mills. David. C. Fischetti © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
c07.indd 91
91
12/18/08 10:12:16 PM
92
The Restoration of St. Helena’s Church
FIGURE 7-1 The end of one queenpost truss was badly deteriorated.
Fore pointed out that tower work including repair of millwork, the bell support frame, and miscellaneous bracing of several elements was also required. Replacement of the Portland cement stucco at the base of exterior walls with a lime based stucco was identified in the Fore report as a task sensitive to seasonal changes in temperature. Stucco repairs required in areas affected by structural repairs to the truss would be a part of the stucco portion of a large construction contract anticipated by the vestry. In 1997, we provided a more thorough structural evaluation of the masonry and timber structure, including tabby foundations, balcony, framing, steeple, and roof structure, based on information obtained on April 7 and 8, 1997. We also included additional findings based on our inspection with George Fore in August 1994 and our previous work in 1993 with regard to the roof trusses. We described repairs that emphasized the use of traditional materials compatible with the original construction. In this way, the interaction of dissimilar materials would not be an issue. We pointed out that the use of reinforced concrete, structural steel, and epoxy-reinforcing methods have all been shown to result in less than perfect structural systems when combined with timber, brick masonry, and lime-based stuccos and mortars. By utilizing traditional materials, a certain sensitivity is achieved that is more in the spirit of The Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating
c07.indd 92
12/18/08 10:12:17 PM
Roof Trusses
93
Historic Buildings. We argued that building systems such as St. Helena’s Church can be made structurally sound by applying the usual engineering principles to those materials and the existing building geometry.
DESCRIPTION St. Helena’s Episcopal Church is a building with a timber-framed roof, balcony, and second-floor level supported on load-bearing brick masonry exterior walls and interior timber columns. The main floor is framed with joists that run across in the transverse direction. The major expansions to the original 1724 building was an 1817 reconstruction of the sanctuary in brick and a large side balcony expansion in 1842, which included sidewalls, balconies, and a new roof structure, resulting in a sanctuary plan approximately 66 feet square with projections at each end for a narthex and sacristy. The steeple was rebuilt in 1940. A steel structural system was added to the steeple at that time. The underframing and platforms of the side balconies were reworked in 1969 to accommodate air-conditioning ducts.
OBSERVATION In August 1994 we measured a relative humidity of 72.3 percent and a temperature of 76.3˚F inside the church at the balcony level. The principle balcony beams 8 by 11 inches in size had a moisture content of 10 percent. We observed the framing of the bell tower and revisited the attic to observe the condition of the queenpost trusses. We observed the condition of the steel beam above the choir loft.
ROOF TRUSSES The condition of the roof-framing system had not changed since our previous inspection. We concentrated our efforts in determining the condition of the exterior load-bearing walls that supported the balconies and roof trusses. We verified overall dimensions and wall thickness. It was determined that, based on marriage marks, the truss numbers ran from I to VI. Upon closer examination, it appeared that the roof trusses had suffered some recent wind damage. Besides the repairs to truss number IV, which had a deteriorated bottom chord, there were other members and connections that deserved attention.
c07.indd 93
12/18/08 10:12:19 PM
94
The Restoration of St. Helena’s Church
FIGURE 7-2 At this time the roof structure appeared unchanged from our previous visit.
BALCONIES In August 1994, with Mr. B.J. Pinckney of the church, George Fore and I opened the sidewall balcony framing for observation by removing some boards. We were able to observe the condition of the bearing seat at the upper end of the balcony framing beams. The principal framing of the balconies consisted of sloped 8-inch by 11-inch timbers that ran from the interior columns to the exterior wall where they rested on a 10 ¼- by 10 ½-inch sill plate supported and enveloped by the exterior wall. The exterior sidewalls had deformed outward over time. The maximum movement was at the balcony sill beam level. George Fore’s report showed that the maximum horizontal deformation of the wall was 2 5⁄8 inches on the north side and 3 9⁄16 inches on the south side. A horizontal crack had formed that ran along the full length of the sidewall, except at the ends where the masonry was tied back into the corners of the building. The great concern with regard to the adequacy of the balconies was based on the deformation shown in George Fore’s report. Two disturbing possibilities were put forward by others regarding this movement. First, the underlying soils might be overstressed, allowing the sidewalls to settle and rotate about the toe of the footing. This appeared to be a possibility because of the settlement observed in the floor joists and the door openings in endwalls, which had deformed into a
c07.indd 94
12/18/08 10:12:19 PM
Balconies
95
FIGURE 7-3 The balcony framing was exposed for additional examination.
FIGURE 7-4 The horizontal cracks in the sidewalls had been patched many times.
parallelogram shape indicating movement of the sides of the nave down in a vertical direction. The second explanation was that the sloping balconies themselves were exerting pressure on the exterior walls, causing them to crack at the balcony level and forcing the now-hinged wall to rotate outward. A sloped end condition would tend to push the exterior wall outward because
c07.indd 95
12/18/08 10:12:20 PM
96
The Restoration of St. Helena’s Church
FIGURE 7-5 The sidewalls appeared to have settled, although diagonal settlement cracks were not visible.
there would be a horizontal component of the beam reaction normal to the bearing surface. The masonry wall is 27 inches thick below the balcony sill beam. If the beam was installed green, shrinkage would have occurred across the grain as much as a quarter of an inch. A small amount of shrinkage at the sill could act as a notch, causing a hinged effect in the masonry wall. The eccentricity of the notch, combined with rotation at the top of the wall due to truss defection, would be sufficient to cause the amount of rotation that was observed in the wall. This, I determined, was the principal mechanism causing the balcony wings to rotate away from the building. It was significant that the horizontal crack is located at the thinnest portion of the masonry wall at the top of the sill beam.
c07.indd 96
12/18/08 10:12:23 PM
Balconies
97
FIGURE 7-6 The 10 10 sills embedded in the masonry sidewalls were somewhat decayed.
One of the two balcony beams observed had a sloped bearing surface at upper end rather than a horizontally cut seat. The stucco at the “hinge” in the exterior wall had been patched several times. This indicated that the movement of the wall had been progressive over time. In the computer, the north and south sidewalls were modeled as an integral part of the building cross-section. We utilized a low modulus of elasticity of 350,000 psi for the brick masonry. Assumed allowable design values for the masonry are as follows: • Compressive strength, 56 psi • Bearing, 100 psi • Shear, 9 psi The 12-foot spacing of the building cross-section modeled in the computer included one roof truss, a bay of balcony framing, and the masonry sidewalls with window openings. Overall building stability in the cross-section appeared tenuous, except for the balcony acting as a deep horizontal beam fastened to the endwalls. In the analysis we included the horizontal contribution of the balcony as a spring support based on the stiffness of the plywood sheathing on the balcony steps. There was evidence that the balcony, with its considerable plywood sheathing,
c07.indd 97
12/18/08 10:12:24 PM
98
The Restoration of St. Helena’s Church
was performing well in that there was no cracking of the plaster ceiling under the balcony. Of course, all of the lateral loads applied to the sidewalls needed to be resolved through the balcony sheathing, roof sheathing, and ceiling framing into the endwalls of the nave. I argued that through jacking, the exterior wall could be forced back into alignment. In order to do this, both the balcony and roof loads would have to be temporarily relieved and the sidewall temporarily braced. All mortar joints that had opened over time and have been filled, in the vicinity of the fold, would have to be raked out in order to reverse the alignment. The gap above the balcony sill would have to be filled and the end of the balcony beam flat cut, blocked, or tied in where the sloped bearing conditions exist. The balcony sill beam would have to be replaced where deteriorated, with a dry timber that would not shrink over time.
TOWER The tower was rebuilt in 1940 in accordance with architectural drawings by architect Albert Simmons of Charleston. The 1940 architectural tracings (drawings) for the tower were stored in the Fireproof Building in Charleston in flat files. The tower as built included wood siding on diagonal sheathing on wood studs attached to a steel framing system. FIGURE 7-7 The bell tower was reframed in 1940 with wood on a steel frame.
c07.indd 98
12/18/08 10:12:25 PM
Church Garden Wall
99
The steel frame provided great rigidity to the steeple up to the transition level where the framing changes to timber. The bell support system appeared to be much older than the 1940s work. The new tower structure was apparently designed to accommodate the geometry of the bell and its framing system. The lantern and spire sections were framed in timber in a configuration similar to St. Michael’s in Charleston. The west side of the tower rested on two cast-in-place concrete blocks supported by the original west wall. The east side of the tower rested on a 30-inch-deep steel beam that spanned the masonry opening between the narthex and the nave. Critical to the bell tower were loading conditions that included northsouth wind, which would tend to place unbalanced loads onto the supporting wall or the W30 beam. Wind in the east-west direction would impose the greatest total load on the 30-inch-deep steel beam. In the computer analysis of the tower, we applied a 120 mph wind in accordance with ASCE-7, except that a shape factor of 0.8 was used for the spire and lantern levels. The bell and bell frame were included as a 1,500-pound load. The analysis was performed in the north-south and east-west directions. The calculations indicated that the steel structure was rigid and that most of the movement in the spire is a result of the open lantern level. Diagonal sheathing was simulated in the timber-framed portion of the steeple to provide a reasonable amount of rigidity. A theoretical deflection of 4 ½ inches at the top of the spire was calculated with these assumptions. The 30-inch-deep steel beam, steel tower legs, and the steel cross-bracing appeared to be adequate in size. Critical to the performance of the steeple in a 120 mph wind load was its anchorage to the top of the outside wall and the anchorage of the 30-inch-deep steel beam to the inside wall on either side of the choir loft. The 22,000 pounds of resistance to hold the steeple legs down could be achieved by assuring that the tie-down points contained a minimum of 150 cubic feet of concrete, or 225 cubic feet of brick masonry. The bearing pressures at all support points were adequate as long as each location has 240 square inches of contact against the brick. The uplift capacity of the steeple could be enhanced by rebuilding the beam and tower bearing points with a compatible but harder brick rather than concrete and facilitating a tie that engages at least 225 cubic feet of masonry.
CHURCH GARDEN WALL The church property is surrounded by a brick wall that defines the perimeter of the block that contains the sanctuary and churchyard. This free-standing brick wall contains portions built at various times. Differences in grade causing
c07.indd 99
12/18/08 10:12:26 PM
100
The Restoration of St. Helena’s Church
lateral earth pressure and pressure from trees have pushed the wall out of alignment. The wall contains settlement and temperature cracks, as well as shear cracks at various locations. At the time of our inspection, mortar was missing or deteriorated in areas, and bricks were deteriorated, broken, or missing. Unsuitable repairs with Portland cement mortar and stucco had been made. We recommended that a tree survey that notes not only species, size, condition, and location, but also location in regard to present or potential damage to the church wall or monuments be undertaken. This would require the services of an architect, landscape architect, structural engineer, and materials conservator working together. The condition of the garden wall varied greatly along its length and required various types of repairs.
MASONRY The masonry of the existing walls of the church consisted of a lime-based mortar and oversized bricks. The bricks appeared to be of medium hardness and the mortar medium to soft. The interior plaster and exterior stucco served to provide a finish, while protecting the wall on the exterior from the weather. Historic walls with plaster on the inside surface tend to provide better service than unplastered walls. In an unplastered wall, mortar joints tend to deteriorate at a more rapid rate with a loss of bond within the lime mortar causing the sand component to spill from the joints. Obviously, even with deterioration of mortar joints in a plastered wall, the sand component would be contained. Deterioration in a masonry wall with a plaster finish will eventually be obvious, as the plaster will crack and separate from the face of the brick wall as the wall disintegrates. In contrast, at St. Helena’s we had a building in which the existing interior plaster was well bonded to the brick walls except at a few notable locations. The service life of lime-based mortar in historic walls is dependent on the structure remaining relatively dry. The roof of St. Helena’s had been well maintained, and the crawl space was dry. The soil beneath St. Helena’s consisted of well-drained light gray or brown sands and clayey sands. In August 1995, S&ME, a geotechnical firm from Mt. Pleasant, South Carolina, reported that the water table was at 15 feet below the ground surface. Historic lime-based masonry walls can be reinforced after construction by installing pencil rod or all thread rods reinforcing into horizontal masonry joints during deep repointing. In this manner, common thermal stress cracks can be “stitched” back together at locations such as above the numerous window openings in St. Helena’s. Such stitch reinforcing, although disruptive to walls covered with plaster or stucco, work well in repairing cracks in masonry walls that have been troublesome for many years.
c07.indd 100
12/18/08 10:12:27 PM
Masonry
101
In the past, we have also applied metal lath to historic masonry walls as a reinforcing procedure, which when plastered, acts to seal the mortar joints from extremes in moisture and temperature. The wall over the Chancel arch at St. Philip’s in Charleston was treated in this manner. Besides serving to structurally tie the wall together and bridge cracks, this system provides a “tell-tale” system to indicate future movement in the wall. The inside faces of the interior walls of one wing of the circa 1903 Kivett Hall at Campbell University, in Buie’s Creek, North Carolina, were covered with metal lath and plaster in 1976. During a recent inspection, no cracks were observed in these walls, which consisted of interior wythes of very soft brick and lime mortar. The large cracks in the endwalls of the nave of St. Helena’s Church resulted from an inadequate masonry tie between sections of walls built at various times.
FIGURE 7-8 Very little bonding connected walls built at various times.
The large cracks beneath the 30-inch-deep steel beam were the result of just such a discontinuity due to faulty construction. To properly “tooth” a wall together requires that the original and new bricks match in size, that the addition courses with the original, and that sufficient skill and effort is expended to ensure that as many of the original bricks are engaged by the new brickwork. In the large crack that was exposed between the walls constructed at different times, only one tie brick was observed. The joint between wall sections was quite wide, indicating that the tendency of the balconies to move outward
c07.indd 101
12/18/08 10:12:27 PM
102
The Restoration of St. Helena’s Church
could not be restrained across the joint. The wildly random coursing of the brick in the two sections of wall could be corrected by reworking a sufficient width of masonry to obtain coursing, or by stitching across the crack with joint reinforcing. The clay tile in the east and west gable walls of the attic obviously did not course with previous brick masonry when used to rebuild gable ends blown out by a storm.
FIGURE 7-9 The gable walls were rebuilt in 1940 with clay tile instead of brick masonry.
This material was used because it is light, economical, and a popular method of construction in the 1940s. We recommended that the clay tile be replaced with brick units to match the original in size.
PLASTER AND STUCCO Traditional plaster and stucco applied to brick masonry is an excellent “telltale” system for crack evaluation. Any discontinuity or crack that causes movement will telegraph through the plaster or stucco system. The history of a crack can be determined by observing its progression in historic photographs and evaluating the materials used as crack fillers in the past. The fine cracks in the sidewalls above the windows were, for the most part, thermal in nature, typical
c07.indd 102
12/18/08 10:12:28 PM
Subsurface Evaluation
103
of cracks in eighteenth and nineteenth century un-reinforced brick masonry walls with large window openings. Most of the sidewall cracks in St. Helena’s were thin hairline cracks. They were observed to be running in a vertical direction usually above or near window head locations. These cracks were located above most of the windows in the sidewalls of the nave.
TABBY Tabby is an early cast-in-place construction material consisting of sand, lime (from shells and wood ash), and water. The foundations of the 1842 addition to St. Helena’s consist of a 26-inch-deep unreinforced footing of tabby on which rested the brick masonry walls. The original foundation walls are of brick construction extending to a greater depth than the foundations of the addition. Because of its relatively low strength, tabby performs well when uniformly loaded. The support of a post or beam is problematic when concentrated loads are not distributed such as on a wood plate or brick masonry-bearing block. The computed design pressure for the combined dead load and live load of 6.8 psi was low when compared to the 350 psi compressive strength obtained by Sickels-Taves. In St. Helena’s we had a fairly uniform load. There were no cracks in the sidewalls related to settlement caused by failure in the tabby.
SUBSURFACE EVALUATION To determine the nature and consistency of underlying soils in the vicinity of the exterior wall, in 1994 we requested that the S&ME office in Charleston provide a proposal to the church for a geotechnical investigation and analysis consisting of borings, small test pits and laboratory analysis. S&ME’s proposal was accepted and field exploration occurred in August of 1995. The purpose of the soils investigation was to determine the amount of settlement that had occurred, its cause, and how much future settlement was anticipated. We also wanted to determine the probable response of the underlying soils during a seismic event. S&ME’s subsurface exploration Report No. 1131-95-034 dated August 18, 1995, presented the results of the exploration and analysis. We were in contact with Billy Camp, P.E. of S&ME, during this procedure and also consulted with George Fore prior to, and after, obtaining the results from S&ME. The purpose of the exploration work was to determine the nature and consistency of the soils directly below the balcony sidewalls of the church and the configuration of the wall at the bearing elevation. It was thought by others that this might explain the outward rotation of the walls. The question of whether
c07.indd 103
12/18/08 10:12:30 PM
104
The Restoration of St. Helena’s Church
the movement was due to settlement or rotation in loose or unconsolidated soils was important to answer because foundation underpinning solutions are very expensive. The results of the settlement analysis indicated that the supporting soils are sands that are relatively dense. Settlement occurred during construction as load was gradually applied. The report concluded that there is no reason to believe that the foundation soils have caused ongoing settlement. In the report, S&ME proposed that a 1,500 psf allowable bearing pressure be used for design. This compared well with the calculated wall loads. At this point, we discarded underpinning as a part of the work. Monitoring was recommended to study the problem further. The results of a monitoring program would indicate whether the movement shows seasonal fluctuations due to temperature or moisture changes. This would determine how active the hinge point was. The crack and wall movement was an indication of a problem. As long as the balcony remained attached, there was no danger of collapse due to vertical loads. The weakened (open) horizontal joint was a possible problem with regard to high wind forces acting outward on the exterior wall.
SEISMIC ANALYSIS Previous comments by other structural engineers had raised the level of concern in the congregation with regard to seismic safety. As a result of those discussions, we included in the evaluation report a rather extensive discussion of seismic issues affecting St. Helena’s. We insisted that several broad questions be asked before we would recommend or adopt a complicated or excessive seismic mitigation. First, what is the risk of injury, death, or property damage in Beaufort due to a seismic event? Second, how much would seismic provisions add to the cost of rehabilitating St. Helena’s? Third, what were the current requirements of the state and federal building codes with regard to seismic reinforcing and repairs to historic structures? From this, it was apparent that the risk of death or injury in a seismic event for a person in St. Helena’s Church is extremely small. Although the building code required that higher seismic factors be used when reviewing an assembly type building such as St. Helena’s, which seats 300 or more people in one room, in reality the building is fully occupied for only a very few hours each week. As part of the geotechnical analysis, we asked S&ME to review the
c07.indd 104
12/18/08 10:12:30 PM
Liquefaction
105
potential for the liquefaction of the soils underlying St. Helena’s in a seismic event because the greatest amount of damage is often caused by the subsidence of masonry buildings on soils as occurred in Kobe, Japan, and in nearby Charleston in 1886. To enhance the wind and seismic capacity of St. Helena’s, the exterior walls could be rehabilitated by repairing cracks. The balcony floor and roof framing had to be securely anchored to the exterior walls. Repairs had to include a positive anchorage to all of the exterior walls in accordance with the “Bolts-Plus” philosophy of seismic reinforcing. This method of seismic reinforcing relies on traditional methods to tie building elements together. The seismic (and wind) resistance of a building can be greatly enhanced by simply providing a positive connection between the floor and roof framing and the exterior walls. The earthquake anchor, developed in Charleston as a result of the 1886 earthquake, is an example of a “Bolts-Plus” type seismic repair. For “Bolts-Plus” to work, we insisted that deteriorated masonry and timber be repaired.
LIQUEFACTION Liquefaction, the loss of a soil’s shear strength due to the increase in water pore pressure resulting from seismic vibrations, is always a concern in the Charleston area. Liquefiable soils are commonly found in South Carolina, and much of the geological evidence suggests that liquefaction has occurred during past earthquakes. The potential for liquefaction depends on the nature of the soils, groundwater potential, and the magnitude of the earthquake. Using standard methods of analyzing liquefaction, based on the seismic risk of the Beaufort area, the probability of liquefaction or the liquefaction potential for a given exposure time can be predicted. The amount of ground settlement due to liquefaction can also be predicted. The S&ME report indicated that assuming an earthquake magnitude of about 5.9 and a base acceleration of 0 to 12g, the liquefaction potential of the underlying soils beneath St. Helena’s was within acceptable limits. Based on the above assumptions, factors of safety against liquefaction were calculated for the potentially liquefiable deposits. Standard Penetration data (N values) from the soil test borings indicated that the factors of safety were greater than 1.5 and, consequently, the risk of liquefaction would be acceptable by today’s standards. The report concluded that some densification of the loose sands above the water table, and therefore settlement, could occur during an earthquake even without liquefaction.
c07.indd 105
12/18/08 10:12:30 PM
106
The Restoration of St. Helena’s Church
The liquefaction potential can be reduced in one of six ways: base isolation, deep foundations, drainage wells, chemical grouting, jet grouting, or compaction grouting. These methods range in cost from the most expensive to the least expensive. The first two are structural modifications to the foundation of the building; the others affect the subsoils. At that time, recent experience from the West Coast indicated that seismic events varied to such a degree that predicting the response of a building that has been modified or that rests on remedied soils was almost impossible. Since the costs for mediation were high and the benefits unpredictable, a reasonable solution was to not do anything if the potential for liquefaction and the amount of settlement was determined to be tolerable. Damage from a major seismic event can be controlled by ensuring that wall and floor systems are tied together and masonry is contained and reinforced. In this manner, settlement due to liquefaction can be tolerated and structural stability does not depend on soils mediation or foundation modification. In fact, the summary of S&ME’s report concluded that the underlying soils were resistant to liquefaction, and that modification to the foundation was not necessary. Based on the soil conditions encountered at the site, there was no reason to believe that the foundation soils were settling. However, settlement would be expected if the foundation loads or soil stresses were increased. Consequently, from a geotechnical standpoint, ground modification or foundation underpinning was not necessary.
RECOMMENDATIONS Based on our analysis, and by applying engineering judgment relating to other historic structures such as St. Helena’s, we offered the following recommendations for the building committee and vestry to consider: • The sidewalls of the building should be jacked into a vertical alignment and the masonry reworked, reducing the eccentricity of the wall and increasing the net section of the masonry at the critical juncture with the balcony while reestablishing vertical continuity. At the same time, the balconies should be securely tied into the masonry sidewalls in a manner often referred to as “bolts-plus” reinforcing. This will require the installation of a new balcony header sill in accordance with sketches enclosed with our report. • Roof truss number IV should be repaired by replacing the deteriorated lower chord. This will require the shoring of the curved plaster ceiling
c07.indd 106
12/18/08 10:12:31 PM
Recommendations
107
and ceiling framing. Other repairs are required to individual truss joints and members. Additional bracing should be applied to the ceiling structure to tie the roof structure into the endwalls. Lateral bracing added to the top chord of the trusses will greatly increase their capacity to resist buckling. • The bell tower will require miscellaneous repairs to various items, such as the bell support frame. A proper paint restoration specification should be followed to renew the exterior millwork and siding, which is very important in protecting the structural system of steel and wood. To properly anchor the tower will require the reworking of the two concrete-bearing blocks at the corner of the front wall and at the bearing of the 30-inch-deep steel beam. Sufficient masonry should be reworked to ensure that an adequate amount of masonry is engaged with an anchor bolt tie to prevent the overturning of the tower by strong winds. • The greatest portion of the work will involve masonry restoration by rebuilding and reinforcing weakened or inadequate sections of wall. A masonry restoration and repair program consisting of compatible brick units and lime mortar should be implemented to repair the joints in the endwalls and the horizontal balcony level joints in the sidewalls. Minor temperature cracks should be stitch reinforced. In summary, the following items of work were required to structurally stabilize St. Helena’s Church. All of these tasks were completed, resulting in a structural shell and building envelope that should provide continued service for many years: • Protect interior plaster work. • Shore the roof structure. • Use cribbing temporarily to support balcony. • Make timber repairs to the roof trusses. • Laterally brace sidewalls. • Replace the balcony sill plate. • Jack balconies, sidewalls. • Repair masonry and stucco at sidewall cracks. • Rework brick at endwall cracks. • Repoint the brick masonry. • Paint exterior at steeple.
c07.indd 107
12/18/08 10:12:31 PM
108
The Restoration of St. Helena’s Church
FIGURE 7-10 Lateral bracing consisting of timber poles and framing was installed on both sidewalls. (See color insert.)
FIGURE 7-11 Great care was taken to protect the monuments in the church yard.
c07.indd 108
12/18/08 10:12:31 PM
Recommendations
109
FIGURE 7-12 JR Graton provided much of the labor required to build and set the temporary lateral bracing.
In fact, the project included several other work components, resulting in a comprehensive and coordinated project that was bid in the traditional manner. These other work items included rebuilding the floor of the narthex, anchoring the supports of the steeple to resist wind forces, and providing a lateral bracing system in the attic to ensure resistance to wind acting in the transverse direction across the sanctuary. The general contractor for the renovations to St. Helena’s Episcopal Church was Ruscon of Charleston, South Carolina. Their bid was based on a set of architectural and structural drawings compiled by architect J. Stephen Smith of Camden, South Carolina. When it was apparent that the building could be fixed by pulling the sidewalls inward to a plumb position, I recommended that the church contact Arnold M. Graton, Master Bridgewright (of covered bridges), who was engaged at the time rebuilding the Auchumpkee Creek Covered Bridge in Thomaston, Georgia, which had been destroyed in a flood. After a visit to Georgia to meet Arnold, the building committee stipulated that Ruscon include Arnold M. Graton & Associates as the subcontractor to perform this work. Temporary vertical supports of 6 8 spruce cribbing were installed inside the church, through the balconies, to support the roof. The sidewalls were laterally supported by braced timber frames, placed on the outside of the building, and the sidewalls were gently and carefully pulled
c07.indd 109
12/18/08 10:12:34 PM
110
The Restoration of St. Helena’s Church
FIGURE 7-13 Cribbing consisted of 6 7 (actual dimension) by 4-foot-long eastern white spruce.
FIGURE 7-14 The timber frames were used to stabilize the sidewalls during the straightening operation.
inward using a large number of Griphoists® (cable ties with come-alongs) placed across the sanctuary. Arnold Graton secured the Griphoists® to timber framing secured to the outside of the sidewalls.
c07.indd 110
12/18/08 10:12:35 PM
Recommendations
111
FIGURE 7-15 Griphoists® were used to pull the sidewalls together.
FIGURE 7-16 The Griphoists® were secured to timbers that straddled the window openings.
The renovation of St. Helena’s Episcopal Church won a 2001 South Carolina Honor Award by the Palmetto Trust for Historic Preservation.
c07.indd 111
12/18/08 10:12:37 PM
112
The Restoration of St. Helena’s Church
FIGURE 7-17 The completed project won an award from The Palmetto Trust for Historic Preservation.
FIGURE 7-18 The underside of the side balconies were replastered.
c07.indd 112
12/18/08 10:12:40 PM
Reference
113
FIGURE 7-19 All exterior surfaces were renewed, including the steeple. (See color insert.)
REFERENCE 1. George Fore’s November 1994 “Conditions Analysis and Conservation Studies” report
c07.indd 113
12/18/08 10:12:42 PM
CHAPTER
8
Market Hall Rehabilitation
ot only did Charleston’s 1841 Market Hall survive war, tornados, hurricanes, fire, and the 1886 earthquake, but also it suffered underutilization and neglect forced by Reconstruction and the Depression that hit South Carolina’s economy especially hard. During the bombardment of the city from Morris Island by federal forces, an artillery shell burst through the roof, grazing the bottom chord of one kingpost roof truss. Damage by historic events such as the Civil War and the 1886 earthquake, combined with the low country’s harsh climate of sun, rain, and humidity, were abundantly evident when Phillips & Oppermann, PA obtained the architectural design contract for its restoration in 1992. This chapter will relate the design team’s struggle to apply conservation principles by integrating high-tech solutions of analysis and materials testing with simple traditional approaches of timber framing and masonry restoration. Once the strategy for structural rehabilitation was developed, it had to be defended on several occasions prior to the start of construction and through a construction period that lasted more than three years. Major items of discussion were shoring and bracing, masonry rehabilitation, and timber framing. Although Charleston, being a port city, is hardly isolated, much of the expertise for the rehabilitation was obtained at a distance from the project. The Winston-Salem– based architect Joseph K. Oppermann assembled a team consisting of a structural engineer, materials conservator, and a mechanical engineer from such diverse locations as Raleigh, North Carolina; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; and East Norwalk, Connecticut.
N
Structural Investigation of Historic Buildings: A Case Study Guide to Preservation Technology for Buildings, Bridges, Towers, and Mills. David. C. Fischetti © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
c08.indd 115
115
12/18/08 10:13:27 PM
116
Market Hall Rehabilitation
FIGURE 8-1 The Civil War was especially hard on Charleston. An artillery shell penetrated the roof of Market Hall.
The structural engineer’s decision to pull the floor structure out and rehabilitate timber-bearing pockets was a much-debated issue. To enhance Market Hall’s resistance to wind and seismic forces, the design strategy called for the existing flooring to be temporarily removed and the floor joists lifted out to be rehabilitated or replaced. A diagonal subfloor consisting of 5/4 sheathing boards was specified to be installed between the original joists and flooring forming a structural diaphragm. Both shear and axial forces had to be transferred between the two elements of wall and floor. The number of floor joists requiring replacement or rehabilitation was a question of debate. I insisted that the contractor’s carpenters could best make that determination after the joists were pulled out and examined. The contractor wanted, in advance, to be provided with the exact number of timbers to order. Much of the masonry had to be rebuilt with loose bricks pulled out and relaid. The masonry restoration contractor questioned the scope of the work after their bid proposal was accepted. Construction management issues such as these greatly impacted the overall preservation plan. A diverse team of designers led an extensive construction team through a difficult rehabilitation tempered by constraints inherent in municipal capital projects. Through friendly persuasion, the design team ultimately prevailed in rehabilitating Market Hall as designed and detailed. The rehabilitation of the main floor system required that the original 4 14 floor joists be reinforced, supplemented, or replaced. The original span of 34 feet
c08.indd 116
12/18/08 10:13:27 PM
Market Hall Rehabilitation
117
was excessive by modern standards for any application including the intended Confederate Museum. The ends of the floor joists in the masonry pockets were severely deteriorated, especially beneath the wide window openings.
FIGURE 8-2 The ends of the joists were exposed for examination.
Most of the joists were sound immediately beyond the inside face of the masonry with few exceptions. One or two joists were severely deteriorated for their full length. The original survey of the floor framing was made through gaps in the flooring where the architect had arranged to remove the first one or two floorboards on each side of the building. Access to the floor framing from below was limited by the presence of four retail establishments on the first floor that continued to operate during the design phase. The ceiling in the lower level was tongue-and-groove 134 beaded-ceiling boards nailed directly to the joists. The flooring of the main room was oneinch-thick dense pine tongue-and-groove boards nailed to the floor joists. Attachment of the floor system consisted of the simple embedment of the joist ends into the wall approximately 8 to 10 inches. The joists rested on a 3-inchthick timber plate that was severely deteriorated, especially below the windowsills. Termite tracks were visible on the face of several joists. To maximize the use of existing fabric, I recommended that the floor system of north–south joists be reinforced with two lines of support running east–west.
c08.indd 117
12/18/08 10:13:29 PM
118
Market Hall Rehabilitation
The support would be at the third points of the joist span, greatly increasing the stiffness of the floor system. To maintain the floor system as a timber structure, the primary reinforcing members were specified to be two 8 ¾-inch-wide glued laminated timber beams. I recommended that these members be let into the floor joists rather than be set below the joists. This decision caused a great deal of concern to the architect and owner and had to be defended through several discussions and special meetings. The insertion of the floor beams provided an excellent opportunity to gain length in the soon-to-be three-piece floor joist system if each joist was first removed, end trimmed, and then cut into thirds.
FIGURE 8-3 The gaps in the floor joists to accommodate the 8 3/4-inch-wide glued laminated timber beams allowed for the deteriorated ends to be removed.
In this way, 8 ¾ inches would be gained in two places, offsetting the loss of deteriorated wood at the joist ends. The need for total structural intervention had to be defended through preliminary design and into design development, during special meetings with city project managers and department administrators. The structural design concept was subjected to an informal peer review during which alternate solutions were offered. Apparently, the city’s primary concern was that the proposed solution appeared to be too drastic, resulting in a possible loss of historic fabric and possibly excessively high construction costs. All manner of alternate concepts were suggested, including the application of load-bearing metal studs to support the floor and roof and steel channels to
c08.indd 118
12/18/08 10:13:30 PM
Market Hall Rehabilitation
119
act as ledgers epoxy bolted to the masonry to support the floor joists and tie the floor system to the perimeter walls. My intent to transform the floor system into a diaphragm had to be explained. Floor joist removal was integral to this effort also because the application of 5/4 (1 inch thick) diagonal flooring as a subfloor was key to that effort. For the finish floor to remain at the original level, the floor joists would have to be lowered to compensate for the inch-thick diagonal floor sheathing. This could only be accomplished by temporarily removing all flooring and joists, and reworking the masonry joist pockets and bearing plates. Obviously, this would also require the installation of temporary shoring and bracing during construction to ensure stability of the masonry walls. Various forms of cross-bracing or sheathing were suggested to be installed beneath the floor system by the architect, peer reviewers and city officials. All suggestions were aimed at not disturbing the floor joists in their original state. Unfortunately, decay and deterioration had greatly impacted a severely undersized floor system, which would be required to support the display cases and exhibits of a newly minted Confederate Museum. City managers insisted that the existing flooring would be difficult to remove without destroying it. To be fair, their concerns were fueled by the advice of peer review engineers and consulting contractors. All of the suggested alternates seemed to contain either steel or plywood as a primary ingredient. Many of the suggestions were verbally transmitted without benefit of a written report or calculations. Each was required to be debunked as we progressed over many months into the construction document phase. In my opinion, the steel-stud support system would not work because it would forever change the original structural system of the building. Often, structural engineers propose this solution without considering that the stability of the building depends on the weight of the floor system resting on the masonry walls. Take that away, and the original, thick masonry walls become unstable. Their answer, to tie the masonry to the studs, further debases the original system. Although the American Plywood Association credits the ancient Egyptians with the invention of plywood by alternating the direction of grain of wood veneers in the construction of mummy cases, I did not want to use a twentiethcentury construction material in the restoration of Market Hall. One concern of using plywood for such an application is that the layers of adhesive, although thin, might act as an improved vapor barrier, retarding the movement of moisture through a building. A practical reason for resisting the use of plywood is that traditional framing rarely is at an even spacing, accommodating 8- or 12-foot sheets of plywood without trimming. This leads to waste and additional labor.
c08.indd 119
12/18/08 10:13:32 PM
120
Market Hall Rehabilitation
Most structural engineers feel very comfortable designing steel structures. As a result, many reach for the Steel Manual when rehabilitating historic buildings. There are places where structural steel is most appropriate, and often it is the only workable solution. For Market Hall, a masonry box with a timber lid, a traditional approach utilizing technology similar to the original, was called for. FIGURE 8-4 The technology used is common to the timber period of original construction. (See color insert.)
Key to my concept was the utilization of restoration masons and timber framers in the restoration of Market Hall. The general contractor embarked on the project with the intention of utilizing his own forces to undertake the timber-frame portion of the work. Many of the timber frame tasks were unique and difficult to execute. Besides rehabilitating the kingpost trusses in a traditional way utilizing through bolted splices and shear blocks, a seismic resisting X-bracing system had to be integrated into the attic to transmit shear forces between the masonry walls and the timber structure. Timber plates were keyed into the masonry with timber shear blocks that had to be laid up in the masonry and dapped into the timber plates. This work was required both at the main floor level and at the ceiling level. Discussions between the design team, contractor, and the city managers finally resulted in subcontractor proposals being solicited from among a few qualified individuals with timber frame credentials. The project specifications attempted to pre-qualify the timber framer component by requiring membership in the Timber Framers Guild of North America or other prerequisite experience. From the start, the work of timber framers Michael Goldberg of Woodstock,
c08.indd 120
12/18/08 10:13:32 PM
Market Hall Rehabilitation
121
Georgia and Peter Bull of Cleveland, Georgia greatly impressed project superintendent Tom Magee of NBM Construction. Once the structural design concept was accepted by the County and the contractor was on board, work a Market Hall proceeded smoothly. FIGURE 8-5 The iron work was restored to its original configuration and color. (See color insert.)
FIGURE 8-6 This completed building again houses the Confederate Museum. (See color insert.)
Timber framers and masons worked together to rehabilitate a landmark building that had suffered greatly.
c08.indd 121
12/18/08 10:13:33 PM
122
Market Hall Rehabilitation
AWARDS The Restoration of the 1841 Market Hall received the following honors: • Restoration and Renovation 2004 Palladio Award for the Restoration of Market Hall, Charleston, South Carolina • 2003 South Carolina Historic Preservation Honor Award for the Restoration of Market Hall, Charleston, SC • 2003 South Carolina Historic Preservation Honor Award— The Palmetto Trust for Historic Preservation SC Department of Archives & History Governors Office for the Restoration of Market Hall, Charleston, South Carolina • 2003 National Preservation Honor Award National Trust for Historic Preservation for the Restoration of Market Hall, Charleston, South Carolina • 2002 Samuel Gaillard Stoney Conservation Craftsmanship Award by the Historic Charleston Foundation for work on the Restoration of 1841 for the Restoration of Market Hall, Charleston, South Carolina • 2002 Carolopolis Award presented by The Preservation Society of Charleston for the Restoration of Market Hall, Charleston, South Carolina
c08.indd 122
12/18/08 10:13:35 PM
CHAPTER
9
Differential Settlement at St. Philip’s Moravian Church at Old Salem
ifferential settlement caused by the degradation of underlying organic materials is a common occurrence in many building sites. Often, a building is placed on marginally adequate soils without the benefit of a deep foundation or the removal of pockets of organic material. A similar occurrence often happens when an addition to a church building is placed on top of a cemetery. The consolidation of these features can produce quite dramatic amounts of differential settlement. Correcting the problems associated with differential settlement is but one aspect of the Old Salem project, which included restoration of the existing church and replication of a previous log church known only through a single photograph, church history, and archeology.
D
HISTORY The Salem community was founded in 1766 by the Moravians, a Protestant sect from Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, with origins in the Czech states of Moravia and Bohemia. How the Moravians came to North Carolina is quite interesting. In November of 1751, leaders of the Moravian church met in London to consider the offer of one of the Lords Proprietors, John Carteret, the Earl of Granville, to sell them a large tract of land in North Carolina. Under the leadership of Structural Investigation of Historic Buildings: A Case Study Guide to Preservation Technology for Buildings, Bridges, Towers, and Mills. David. C. Fischetti © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
c09.indd 123
123
12/18/08 10:14:39 PM
124
Differential Settlement at St. Philip’s Moravian Church at Old Salem
FIGURE 9-1 Historical photograph provided by Old Salem, Inc.
FIGURE 9-2 The termite damaged floor joists were removed to provide access for the archeologist.
Count Zinzendorf, the Moravians accepted the offer and directed Bishop August Gottlieb Spangenberg to lead a small exploratory expedition into the interior of North Carolina to select a suitable tract of land. After much effort, the explorers staked out a tract containing 98,985 acres to be known as Wachovia.1
c09.indd 124
12/18/08 10:14:40 PM
Replication and Restoration
125
From almost the beginning, enslaved and free African Americans lived in Salem. The African American congregation of St. Philip’s Moravian Church in the community of Salem was formed in 1822. In 1823, the Moravians constructed for their black citizens a simple log church a few blocks south of Salem Square adjacent to the Stranger’s Graveyard. In 1861, the congregation moved into a newly constructed Greek Revival brick church, again built by the Moravians, which is now the oldest standing African American church building in North Carolina. The black church prospered so well after the Civil War that the Moravian Church agreed to enlarge the building in 1890. The 1890 addition to the 1861 St. Philip’s Moravian Church in Winston-Salem was constructed on a portion of the preexisting Stranger’s Graveyard. The addition contains two first-floor rooms, a central corridor, and a balcony above.2
REPLICATION AND RESTORATION Work at St. Philip’s included the reconstruction of a replica of the 1823 log church based on photographic and archeological evidence. Restoration of the brick church included replication of the original steeple and underpinning repairs to the 1890 addition. The other major structural issue was to provide adequate support inside the attic of the log church for the addition of a replicated belfry and the additional weight of a mechanical unit. FIGURE 9-3 The log church was replicated based on one photograph and archeological evidence.
c09.indd 125
12/18/08 10:14:42 PM
126
Differential Settlement at St. Philip’s Moravian Church at Old Salem
FIGURE 9-4 A pair of structural steel trusses was designed to support the replicated belfry.
Between the two projects, structural engineering tasks at St. Philip’s included the design of traditional timber frames and connections, structural steel, underpinning, masonry restoration and repair, and a number of construction details. Drawings for the log church were executed by John Milner Architects, Inc. of Chadds Ford, Pennsylvania, based on review, input, and sketches provided by us. FIGURE 9-5 The log church has a false chimney and cupola. (See color insert.)
c09.indd 126
12/18/08 10:14:43 PM
Description of The Church
127
For St. Philip’s, we provided comprehensive drawings depicting suggested underpinning, means and methods for the underpinning, and complete detailing of the steeple frame and supporting trusses.
DESCRIPTION OF THE CHURCH St. Philip’s is approximately 40 feet wide by 85 feet long with exterior brick masonry walls and first-floor framing above a crawl space.3 We estimated that the 2 10 floor joists, spaced at 24 inches on center in the 1861 building, were equivalent to No. 1 dense or better timber and the 1890 floor joists equivalent to No. 2 or No. 3 dense southern pine. The 1890 floor joists and floor sheathing were removed from the front portion of the building prior to construction so that archeologist could map the features without interference. The roof of the 1861 church is framed with “queen rod trusses” consisting of 5 8 timber top chords, double 7/8-inch square iron queen rods, 2 ¾-inch by 3 ½-inch braces (webs), and a bottom chord consisting of double 4 10 timbers spliced together with trunnels (wood pegs).
FIGURE 9-6 The bottom chord consists of two 4 10s.
c09.indd 127
12/18/08 10:14:46 PM
128
Differential Settlement at St. Philip’s Moravian Church at Old Salem
Technically, these members constitute an assembly better described as tied and braced principal rafters with sag rods.
FIGURE 9-7 The connection at the queen rod joint appears to have been reworked during the original construction.
The exterior walls and the corridor walls of the 1890 addition are constructed of brick masonry, with very shallow footings. Obviously, when setting the bearing elevation for the walls, the builders were well aware of the numerous burial sites in the area of the addition. Subsidence of the remains within disturbed pockets in the stiff clay caused major cracks to form in the exterior walls at the northwest corner of the 1890 building addition. Numerous settlement cracks in the masonry of the northwest corner of the 1890 addition were obvious by the 1980s. The cracks extended from the base to the top of the wall on both the front face and north side of the building. The cracks were through-wall cracks as much as 1 ½ to 2 inches in width. During the exploratory phase, distance from the underside of the floor joists to the bottom of the walls was measured to be from 17 ¾ inches to 26 inches. The bases of the walls were found to be rectangular in shape without projections or footings of any kind. The foundation walls, as found, were approximately 17 ½ inches thick at the exterior locations and 8 inches thick at the corridors. The oversized brick units of the 1890 addition measured 3 inches high, by 4 inches wide, by 8 inches in length.
c09.indd 128
12/18/08 10:14:48 PM
Recommendations for Repair
129
FIGURE 9-8 The northwest corner was temporarily braced prior to our involvement with this project.
FIGURE 9-9 The cracks extended to the top of the wall and were up to 2 inches in width.
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR REPAIR Our involvement in this “little church repair” spanned a period of more than 10 years. The original preliminary structural evaluation report was based on a January 1993 jobsite observation made for architect Charles A. Phillips of the
c09.indd 129
12/18/08 10:14:50 PM
130
Differential Settlement at St. Philip’s Moravian Church at Old Salem
firm Phillips & Oppermann, P.A. of Winston-Salem. In a condition assessment report of that visit, we stated the following: Although the walls of the 1890 addition can be successfully underpinned, it will require considerable engineering to accomplish the task. Consideration should be given to removing the 1890 addition altogether. The two reasons for recommending this alternative are that the 1890 addition should not have been built over a cemetery to begin with, and second, replacing the steeple with the 1890 addition intact would result in a church with a steeple located at the third point of its length in lieu of directly above the narthex3.
By 1995 it was made clear to me that St. Philips would have to be interpreted as an 1890s building and the addition could not be removed. In a letter to John Larson of Old Salem, Inc., we listed “the order of tasks required to repair the front section of the church . . .”4 First, the cracks in the masonry needed to be located, in the drawings, on the building elevations. The location of the graves under the addition needed to be mapped, noting the depth of these features and the extent of undisturbed soil. With the benefit of an archeological base map and a geotechnical report, the type, number, location, and depth of the mini piles (or other ground modification techniques) would be determined so that budget prices could be derived. By this time, John Milner had been retained to execute the design of both the log church and St. Philip’s Moravian Church restoration. In 1993, we had recommended that a subsurface investigation be undertaken “to determine the relative depth and configuration of the 1861 and 1890 wall footings, as well as the nature of the soils located directly beneath the footings in both areas.”3 Successful underpinning of a wall requires that it be uniformly supported continually along its length. It was obvious that support needed to be provided along the wall by bridging the less consolidated pockets of soil without disturbing those areas. The main purpose of the proposed soils investigation was to determine the capacity of the firm soils to support a continuous grade beam with, or without, the installation of soil modification or support elements, such as piles. If sufficient support could be obtained in the undisturbed locations, then a continuous concrete grade beam could be designed to span the archeological features. The underpinning approach that we devised was to install the mini piles first so that they could be used for temporary support of the building and act as “hard points” to jack against in lifting the badly cracked masonry walls. In order to be successful, the walls would have to be lifted and pulled together simultaneously. In this way, the maximum amount of existing masonry could be retained by merely closing the cracks.
c09.indd 130
12/18/08 10:14:53 PM
The Log Church
131
The project documents included structural details and notes that spelled out a suggested sequence of work, a suggested method for execution, and a layout of the mini piles.
SUBSURFACE EXPLORATION Froehling & Robertson, Inc. of Raleigh, North Carolina, was finally authorized to undertake a subsurface exploration in April of 2002 to evaluate subsurface conditions for underpinning of the west wall of the addition. At our request, it had provided a proposal for this work in 1993. F&R drilled two 40-foot-deep borings approximately 5.5 to 6 feet west of the exterior face of the west wall at locations cleared by the project archeologist. Borings were drilled with an allterrain CME-550 drill rig using hollow stem augers to advance the borings.5 The usual approach of including “test” pits, also known as observation pits, in the soils exploration was not necessary because the work of the archeologist exposed the bottom of the walls in the interior of the 1890 addition. The configuration of the base of the wall and the nature of the supporting soils could be observed without the need for observation pits. General engineering characteristics of the subsurface soils were determined from samples obtained at selected intervals in accordance with Standard Penetration Tests (SPT) procedures (ASTM D-1586). Beneath a thin veneer of topsoil and approximately 2 feet of firm, silty clay residual soil, there was 8 to 12 feet of very stiff micaceous, fine sandy silts. Extending for the remaining 40 feet of depth, firm to stiff slightly micaceous to very micaceous, fine sandy silts were encountered. After 24 hours, a piezometer installed in Boring B-1 detected no groundwater. F&R concluded that the conditions encountered at the two borings would be favorable for the installation of friction-type mini piles to a depth approximately 25 to 35 feet below existing grades. F&R anticipated that steel mini piles could develop a design skin friction of 300 to 400 pounds per