SYMMETRIES AND LAPLACIANS introduction to Harmonic Analysis, Group Representations and Applications
NORTH-HOLLAND MATHEMATICS STUDIES 174 (Continuation of the Notas de Matematica)
Editor: Leopoldo NACHBIN Centro Brasileiro de Pesquisas Fisicas Rio de Janeiro, Brazil and University of Rochester New York, U S A .
NORTH-HOLLAND - AMSTERDAM
LONDON
NEW YORK
TOKYO
SYMMETRIES AND LAPLACIANS Introduction to Harmonic Analysis, Group Representations and Applications
David GURARIE Department of Mathematics and StaYjstics Case Western University Cleveland, OH, U.S.A.
1992
NORTH-HOLLAND - AMSTERDAM
LONDON
NEW YORK
TOKYO
ELSEVIER SCIENCE PUBLISHERS B.V. Sara Burgerhartstraat 25 P.O. Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
ISBN: 0 444 88612 5
0 1992 ELSEVIER SCIENCE PUBLISHERS B.V. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher, Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., Copyright & Permissions Department, RO.Box 521, 1000 A M Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Special regulations for readers in the U.S.A. - This publication has been registered with the Copyright Clearance Center Inc. (CCC), Salem, Massachusetts. Information can be obtained from the CCC about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the U S A . All other copyright questions, including photocopying outside of the U.S.A., should be referred to the publisher, Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. This book is printed on acid-free paper. Printed in The Netherlands
In the memory of my parents, whom I owe so much to Valentina
Eli and Mark
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction .................................................................................................................. 1 Chapter 1. Basics of representation theory
51.1. Groups and group actions ............................................................................. $1.2. Regular and induced representations; Haar measure and convolution algebras .................................................................................... 51.3. Irreducibility and decomposition .................................................................. 51.4. Lie groups and algebras; the infinitesimal method ........................................
13 24 37 46
Chapter 2. Commutative Harmonic analysis
$2.1. Fourier transform: inversion and Plancherel formula .................................... 62 52.2* Fourier transform on function-spaces ........................................................... 71 52.3. Some applications of Fourier analysis ........................................................... 83 52.4. Laplacian and related differential equations .................................................. 92 52.5* The Radon transform ................................................................................. 120 Chapter 3 . Representations of compact and finite groups
53.1. The Peter-Weyl theory ............................................................................... 53.2. Induced representations and Frobenius reciprocity ..................................... 53.3* Semidirect products ...................................................................................
125 137 147
Chapter 4 . Lie groups SU(2) and Sq3) 54.1. Lie groups and SU(2) and Sq? and their Lie algebras ................................ 161 54.2. Irreducible representations of U(2)............................................................................. 164 &3* Matrix entries and characters of irreducible representations: Legendre and Jacobi polynomials .............................................................. 171 54.4. Representations of SO(3): angular momentum and spherical harmonics ..... 174 $4.5* Laplacian on the n-sphere .......................................................................... 184 Chapter 5 . Classical compact Lie groups and algebras
$5.1. Simple and semisimple Lie algebras; Weyl “unitary trick” .......................... 55.2. Cartan subalgebra, root system, Weyl group .............................................. $5.3. Highest weight representations ................................................................... 95.4* Tensors and Young tableaux ...................................................................... $5.5. Haar measure on compact semisimple Lie groups ....................................... $5.6. The Weyl character formulae ..................................................................... $5.7* Laplacians on symmetric spaces .................................................................
191 197 206 217 227 231 241
Chapter 6. The Heisenberg group and semidirect products
$6.1. Induced representations and the Mackey’s group extension theory .............. 257
...
Vlll
56.2. The Heisenberg group and the oscillator representation .............................. $6.3* The Kirillov orbit method .......................................................................... Chapter 7. Representations of SL,
274 290
.
305 57.1. Principal. complementary and discrete series .............................................. 57.2. Characters of irreducible representations .................................................... 313 57.3. The Plancherel formula on SL. (W) .............................................................. 317 67.4. Infinitesimal representations of SL. spherical functions and characters ....... 328 §7.5* Selberg trace formula ................................................................................. 334 $7.6* Laplacians on hyperbolic surfaces W/r....................................................... 348 57.7* SL. (C) and the Lorentz group .................................................................... 361 Chapter 8. Lie groups and hamiltonian mechanics 58.1. Minimal action principle; Euler-Lagrange equations; canonical formalism ... 369 58.2. Noether Theorem, conservation laws and Marsden-Weinstein reduction ..... 378 385 $8.3. Classical examples ...................................................................................... 58.4, Integrable systems related to classical Lie algebras..................................... 393 $8.5* The Kepler Problem and the Hydrogen atom ............................................. 408 Appendices: A: Spectral decomposition of selfadjoint operators .............................................. 423 B: Integral operators .......................................................................................... 427 C: A primer on Riemannian geometry: geodesics. connection. curvature ............. 430 Rderences ................................................................................................................. List of frequently used notations ................................................................................ Index .........................................................................................................................
439 447 449
Introduction Throughout this book word Group will be synonymous with transformations and symmetries. Groups are omnipresent in the mathematical and (possibly) physical universe. In Mathematics symmetries play several important functions. On the one hand they allow to reduce the “number of variables”, and often render problem soluble (like reducing the order, or separating variables in differential equations). On the other hand they allow to analyze and synthesize complex objects in terms of simple (elemental) blocks/constituents (eigenvalues of matrices and operators, expansion in Fourier modes, harmonic analysis in general). The prime example came from the very onset of the subject, the Galois theory of algebraic equations. The thrust of this early work was precisely to relate the symmetry (Galois) group of the equation to its solvability’ in radicals. Then Sophus Lie set up the task to develop the “Galois theory” for differential equations. He naturally came up with the concept of a continuous Lie group and its infinitesimal versions Lie algebra. Since its inception in the mid XIX-century the Lie theory rapidly grew and spread across the broad range of subjects, to occupy its present central position at the crossroads of Geometry, Analysis, Differential equations, Classical mechanics and Physics in general. Symmetries in physical systems2 are inextricably linked to conservation laws (via Noether’s Theorem), and the Galois chain repeats: “symmetries of hamiltonians”
+ “conserved integrals” + “solvability (via symmetry-reductions)”.
Our book sets more limited goals. The main objective is to introduce the reader to a wide range of concepts, ideas, results and techniques, that evolve around
. 1-
[symmetry-groups\, Irepresentations], and
We strived to stress the diversity
and versatility of the subject, but at the same time to unravel its common roots. More specifically, our main interest lies in geometrical objects and structures {X}, discrete or continuous, that possess sufficiently large symmetry-group G, like regular graphs (Platonic solids); lattices; symmetric Riemannian manifolds, and other. All such objects have a natural Laplacian A, a linear operator on functions over X, invariant under the group action. There are many problems associated with Laplacians on X. Typically one is interested in certain “continuous or discrete-time” evolutions, on
X, random walks, diffusion processes, wave-propagation. All these problems require to ‘Thence came the terminology of solvable groups (abelian ext,ensions of abelian groups), as the abelian ones were directly associated with solvability. ‘Symmetries acquire yet greater significance in the murky world of subatomic physics, where nothing could be observed, measured, sensed and compared to the everyday experiences of the macroworld. Here symmetries and conservation laws provide the only guiding light, and Lie groups enter in the very formulation of fundamental models of particles, fields and forces.
2
introduction
compute certain “functions of A”, L = f ( A ) , like powers { A ” } ; the semigroup, generated by A {e-“}; function {cos(tJ-6)}, etc. To explain and motivate the problems and the methods, based on symmetries, we shall start with a few simple prototypical examples. Fibonacci sequence is defined by a 2-term recurrence relation: Ixn+l = x, (or more general, xnS1 = a x ,
+b
+ .z,-~]
~ ~ - and ~ ) the , two initial values {zo;xl}.One is asked
to find all {z”}. To solve the problem, one first converts the 2-term numerical recurrence to a one-term recurrence for vectors: y, = Frobenius-type matrix L =
and we need to compute all iterates {L“}. The latter could be accomplished by diagonalizing matrix L , i.e. solving the eigenvalue problem: finding spectrum {A,$,}, and the matrix of eigenvectors U = {&;$,}.
The latter serves to diagonalize L,
L = U A U - I , where A=diag{A,;X,}. Once L is brought into the diagonal form, its iterates {Ln= UA”U-’} come right away, as well as more general “function of L”, f(L)= U f ( A ) U - ’ . So we immediately get an explicit solution
’.
Of course, no group-analysis was needed here, as the “eigenvalue problem” had an easy direct solution. However, similar “finite” problems could quickly become intractable, as we shall demonstrate in our next example.
Random w&
on graphs
I‘. The process consists of random jumps from any site
(vertex) of the graph to any one of its nearest neighbors with equal probabilities. Starting with the initial position at {xo}, or the initial probability distribution Po(,) (ZE
r),one is asked to find the probability distribution after the R time-steps, { P n ( x ) } .
Once again vector {P,(z)} is completely determined by the initial state Po and the transition-matrix L , which could be called the “Laplacian” of the graph, that sends any vectorffunction $(x) on
I‘ into L!b(x) = ?&b(Y),
sum over all m nearest vertices {y} of
Y
2.
Since the jumps are statistically independent
(the process has no memory of the past, when deciding to go from {x} to {y}), and
stationary in time (the “jump-rules” remains the same for all times n = 0; 1;...), we get a sequence of iterates, 3The classical Fibonacci numbers are given by
=c
I+&”
+
]-fin
, the generalized ones, z, = clX1” where coefficients, {cl;ez} depend on the initial data {zo;zl}. 2,
, ( ~ ) c2(-7_!
+ C,X,~;
3
Introduction
P, = Ln[P,],at time n. To compute powers
{L”}we
(2)
need once again to diagonalize
L, i.e. to solve the
eigenvalue problem. But this time the difficulty increases drastically with the size of
r,
if one tries a direct approach (imagine diagonalizing a 20 x 20 “dodecahedral” matrix!). There is not much to do in the general case, so we turn to a special, but important, class of regular graphs (like polygons, Platonic solids, a “Knight on a periodic
r are characterized by the abundance of symmetries. One can associate with any such r group G of vertex-transformations, that preserve all links (the incidence relations) between vertices. For regular r, group G takes any vertex x into any other4, so r becomes a homogeneow space o f G, r = H\G, where H denotes the stabilizer subgroup of some xo E r, H = {g:xog = xo}. For instance, the chessboard”, etc.). Regular graphs
regular m-gone is itself a finite abelian group Z , = {integers modulo m} (its symmetries are made of all finite rotations and reflections), whereas Platonic solids (cube, octahedron, dodecahedron, etc.) are homogeneous spaces H\G
of some well-known
symmetric or alternating groups (see 31.1 and 33.2). Given a homogeneous space X, group G acts on X by translations, g:x-+xg,and this action gives rise to the regular representation R = R X of G on the function-space
L = L(X ) over X , R g f ( 4= f ( 4 .
(3)
One easily verifies that map g+Rg, from G into operators on L, takes group multiplication into the product of operators, in other words defines a group-
L commutes with all operators {Rg},group G leaves L invariant, and we have to analyze the resulting “reduced
representation. Since Laplacian eigenspaces { E x } of
L
in
representations” of G on eigenspaces { E x } . Among all representations of the group one distinguishes the minimal ones, called irreducible, the ones that do not allow further reduction to smaller invariant subspaces (they play the role of “joint eigenvalues” for a g E G}).The typical problems in representation theory include: family of operators {Rg: (i) characterization all ineducible {n’s}for a given group G (analysis-problem); and
(ii) decomposition of an arbitrary (natural) representation R into the direct sum (or integral, to be explained below) of irreducibles (synthesis problem). The harmonic analysis on X suggests a possible approach to the spectral problem 41n fact, in many cases G takes any connected pair of vertices {qy} to any other such pair. Such graphs T’s could be called 2-point symmetric spaces, by analogy with their continuous counterparts.
4
Introduction
for operator L. Namely, we need
(I) to study the structure of the symmetry-group G; (11) to determine its elemental (irreducible) representations
{T};
(111) to interpret Laplacian L in terms of group-elements of G, to be able to assign operators { T ~ to} it for various irreducible { T } (IV) finally, to decompose the regular representation into the direct sum of irreducible components: RX = @ d .
i
The latter means that space L ( X ) is split into the direct sum of subspaces @ Ei, 3
invariant under all operators { R,:g E G}, irreducible relative to the G-action. Such decomposition, generalizes the notion of spectral/resolution (diagonalization) of a single operator. Steps (I-IV), when successfully accomplished, would lead to the desired spectral resolution of L. Namely, the reduced Laplacian L I E j r L becomes scalar5, N
So the “eigenwalue spectrum {X,(L)]” could be identified the “representation spectrum {d}of R”, the “eigenspaces” being “irreducible components” of R. Once L is diagonalized we immediately obtain all iterates {L”), and more general functions {f(L)}, needed to solve (3). { T = ~ X,(L);
for each irreducible
T}.
The details of the scheme could be found in 52.3 (Finite Fourier transform) for polygons, and in 53.3 for Laplacians on Platonic solids. After a brief excursion through the finite/discrete cases (graphs) we shall turn now to a completely different geometric setup: smooth Riemannian manifolds, Lie groups and their quotients, symmetric spaces X . All these objects will be introduced and studied at length in the due course (chapters 1,4,5,6,7).
Here for the sake of
introduction we consider 3 familiar examples: the Euclidian space R”, the n-sphere
S” c Rn+’, and the hyperbolic (Poincare-Lobachevski) plane‘ W2 = { z = z+iy:y 2 0). To motivate the continuous case we shall mention 3 typical problems in the integral geometry with some physical context. The setup for all 3 is basically the same. We are given a solid body D of constant (or variable) density p ( z ) . In the first case one considers all lines {y}, passing through
D,and computes integrals along
y: ?(y)
=
I,
pds. In the
’There is a general reason, why Laplacian L goes into the scalar operator nL under any irreducible A, known as Schur’s lemma. ‘the latter could be also interpreted, as a continuous limit of properly scaled i n space and time random walks on trees.
5
Introduction
second solid D (assumed to be convex, symmetric) is illuminated from all possible directions, and we measure the area of the shadows, cast by D. In the third case (somewhat simpler than the second) we take all cross-sectional areas of D by the family of planes, passing through its center. In all 3 cases one would like to recover either density p (case l), or the geometric shape of D (case 2 and 3) from such data. The first case is essentially the celebrated X-ray transform, used in tomography. The 2-nd and 3-rd give somewhat different versions of the Radon transform on the 2-sphere. Indeed, a (convex) body D can be represented as a graph of function f(z) on the 2-sphere, S2 = { I z I = 1). The cross-sectional areas of D are obtained by integrating :fz along all
great circles {y} in S2. So in all cases we are dealing with certain integral transforms of functions, either on the Euclidian space, or the sphere.
W have the natural Riemannian metric (§1.1), and possess G of distance-preserving transformations (isometries). The
All 3 spaces, R", S", large symmetry-group
Euclidian isometries consists of rigid motions: group En, generated by all translations and rotations in R"; the n-sphere S" has the orthogonal symmetry-group SO(n+l), made of all (n+l) x ( n + l ) - orthogonal matrices in Rn+' 3 S"; symmetries of
W coincide
with the ubiquitous unimodular group SL,(R) - all 2 x 2 real matrices of detg = 1, acting az+b by the fractional-linear transformations, g: z-+Cz+d. In fact, all 3 examples represent the of group G modulo the maximal compact
so called symmetric spaces, quotients K\G
subgroup K , that fixes a particular point in X , K = {g:z,g examples:
Ii' = S q n ) for Rn and S",
while the hyperbolic
' A
= z,}.
In the above
= SO(2).
The analog of the discrete-time random-walk on space X is played either by
spherical means:
(average value of function
f over the sphere of radius r , centered at
{z}), or by more
general integral kernel,
I
u(z)+K[u]= Ii'(z;y)u(y)dy. Transition-operator7 K takes any distribution p,(y) on X into pl(z) = li'[po], at a single time-step. As before we are interested in iterates
{I{"},
and once again have to
face the "diagonalization problem" for Ii'. In general, the problem is hardly tractable, so we turn to a special class of integral kernels, K ( z ; y ) ,that commute with the G-action, 7Strictly speaking, density K ( z ;y)dy represents transitional probabilities t o j u m p from point {y} to {z}, provided jK(z;y)dy = 1.
6
Introduction
(3) on X . Any G-invariant operator has kernel K , that depends only on the distance’ T = d(z;y), between z and y, 1-(z;y) = K [ T ) .Spherical means give one such example, the Radon and X-ray transforms also obey this condition, but the foremost of all Ginvariant operators is the natural Laplacian’ A (the Laplace-Beltrami operator) on X . Associated to A there are various evolution processes on X (continuous analogs of the “discrete-time random walks”), described by partial differential equations (pde). One of them is the standard heatdiffusion problem, ut
- AU= 0; ~ ( 0 =) f;
(4)
whose formal solution of (4) is given by the heat-semigroup of A, u = et”[fl.
Another important model is the wave equation: utt - Au = ...,whose solutions can also be represented by “functions of A”, {u = e *it-;
or cos t a ; sin tJ--Zij}.
Since A commutes with the G-action on X , all its functions { f ( A ) }do the same, including the heat and wave-propagators (another names for the “transition-matrices”, I( = etA; e i t f i ) . But any such I( has a radially symmetric kernel (I = K ( r ) . So a pdeproblem for I(, is often reduced to an ordinary differential equation (see chapters 2;4;5). Those in many cases, including R”, S”, W, could be solved explicitly in terms of the well-known special functions. Once again we are lead to analyze the G-action on X , and the resulting regular representation R,f(z) = f(zg),on suitable function-spaces over X.
So spectral decomposition of any radial operator K is reduced to the harmonic analysis of representation R. The latter involves among other a good understanding of the symmetry-group G itself, its ‘elemental (irreducible) representations” nature of the direct sum and/or integral decomposition,
R=
@ x j ; or 3
xSdp(s).
{T},
and the
(5)
To give some feeling of the issues involved, let us take the Euclidian space Rn, as an abelian group with translations only. Irreducible representations of R” are all 1‘This result is a direct consequence of the “double-transitive” action of G on rank-one symmetric spaces X,i.e. any pair {z;y} C X , is taken any other equidistant pair. ’In fact, any spherically symmetric kernel K on X (in either one of 3 examples) is given by a “function of the Laplacian”, K = f(A). This result, far from obvious, comes from the harmonic analysis of rank-one symmetric spaces (chapters 4-5). It has to do with the “multiplicity-free spectrum” of regular representation R, equivalently, with the fact that the commutator of R (all operators, that commute with it) forms a commutative algebra. “Functions of operators” {f(L)}will be introduced and discussed in chapter 2 and Appendix A via spectral resolution of operator L.
7
Introduction
dimensional (characters!), they consist of the family of exponentials {eit. €:[ E R”}. Decomposition (5), amounts to the Fourier-transform of f(z), expansion in the Fourierseries or integral. In chapter 2 we explore in detail various aspects of the commutative Fourier analysis and apply it to differential equations. The relevant analysis on the n-sphere, however, has a very different flavor. Here one has to start with “irreducible representations”
S q n t l ) , that would play the role of exponentials
{T}
of the orthogonal group
{ e i ” * < } on
R”. This, by itself a
challenging task, requires to develop a fair amount of the linear and multilinear (tensorial) algebra, as well as the relevant structure theory of Lie groups and algebras (chapters 4-5). Irreducibles
{T}
of S q n t l ) turned out to be finite dimensional, and the
decomposition of R has purely “discrete spectrum”lo,
R=
co @ rk.
k=O The corresponding irreducible subspaces { 36k} of L2(Sn), called spherical harmonics, have many remarkable features. Aside of being eigenspaces of the spherical
Laplacian, they proved to be closely connected to harmonic polynomials on Fin+’, and the classical Legendre and Jacobi functions. Our last example
W2 reveals even more striking difference. SL, is a
simple, not
compact group (in fact, the “smallest” of them). Unlike R” or S q n ) , its irreducible
unitary representations are infinite-dimensional, they make up certain continuous and discrete families {#:s E R} and {rrn:mE Z}. The decomposition problem for regular representations { R X } on homogeneous spaces, strongly depends on the “geometric nature” of quotient
X
continuous (direct integral), R = discrete subgroup of
+
= H\G. In some cases (Poincare half-plane W) it becomes purely
G) -
TSdp(s);in other cases (compact quotients r\G,
purely discrete (direct sum) R =
%0 r S j .It
r-
could also be a
combination of both, like the regular representation R on the entire group
G! The
relevant harmonic analysis becomes quite involved (see chapter 7). Its most spectacular application to the spectral theory of Laplacians appears in the context of quotients X = r\G, modulo discrete subgroup r c G. It turns out that “spectrum of such X” (either Laplacian A,, or representation Rx) is intimately connected with some fine “arithmetic properties” of via the celebrated Selberg-trace Theorem (a noncommutative version of the “Poisson summation” on R”). As an off-short we
r,
-Both results are general and hold for arbitrary compact (finite in size) groups (chapter 3). But specific examples, like S q n ) will carry a great deal more structure and information about {m} and
R.
8
Introduction
establish some interesting links between the “eigenvaluespectrum {A,}
of A,”, and the
“geometric length-spectrum of X” (length of all closed geodesics in X ) . We elaborate some aspects of spectral theory on compact quotients r \ G in 57.6-7.7. Our discussion of the “continuous cases” vs. “discrete cases”, although very different in technical terms, clearly demonstrates similarities in the basic procedures. Namely,
I) investigation of the group-structure of G, and its “elemental” irreducible representations { T } ;
11) study of G-invariant objects “Laplacians” on G, or on its quotients X = H\G; 111) decomposition of natural G-actions, regular representations R X , RG; its L on G and X ;
connection to Laplacians
IV) application of parts (1)-(111), particularly, the correspondence between “spectrum of L” and “spectrum of R” to various “junctions of L”,like iterates {L”}, semigroups { e-“; e - t f i } , and solutions of the associated differential equations. The development in the book largely will largely follow the general scheme (IIV), although not always step by step, as in the model examples. We may or may not start with a simple model problem. Often a significant effort has to be spent first to study the relevant groups, and their representation theory: problems of irreducibility and decomposition (cf. chapters 5-7). As we mentioned our main interest lies in the natural G-actions and representations, regular RG; RX,and their generalizations called
induced representations. The latter extend G-actions on scalar function { f(s)}, to vector-functions and sections of vector-bundles over X (so G-action combines translations in the X-space with “twisting” in fiber-spaces). The decomposition of the regular and induced representations makes up the content of the so called Plancherel Theorem. Although we follow steps (I-IV) throughout the book their relative “size” and “weight”, as well as the amount and depth of applications, varies from chapter to chapter. Thus chapter 2 is largely devoted to applications of the commutative Fourier transform, while chapters 5 or 7, deal mostly with the analysis of groups and represent at ions. An introductory chapter 1 brings in the principal players: basic examples of
9
Introduction
groups and geometric structures (51.1). Then we proceed to develop some fundamental concepts and results of the representation theory (§§1.2-3), and the Lie theory ($1.4). In chapters 2-7 we take on the main themes of the book with many facets of the general scheme (I-IV). Each chapter has its own LLfavorite” Laplacians and symmetry-groups: 0
standard Laplacian A on commutative groups Wn;Un and certain domains
D c Rn, in chapter 2 0
polyhedral Laplacians and the relevant finite groups in chapter 3
0
the spherical Laplacian A on S2 and S”, whose theory is based on Lie groups
SU(2);SO(3), in chapter 4 0Laplacians on more general compact Lie groups and symmetric spaces in chapter 5 0
the harmonic oscillator H = - A
+ I x I ’,and the Heisenberg group in chapter 6
0Laplacians on the Poincare plane
W, SL,,
and compact Riemann surfaces r \ H
in chapter 7. Chapter 8 stands somewhat aside from the mainstream, as it takes on the subject of “symmetries in nonlinear(!) hamiltonian systems”, and their role in integrability. But the very end of chapter 8 (58.5) brings us back to the main issues in grouprepresentations. We discuss the quantization problem of classical hamiltonians, particularly, the “quantized Kepler problem” - the hydrogen atom, one of the best studied models in quantum mechanics (see [LL]). The “Laplacian” pops in here in a quite interesting and unexpected form. A remarkable feature of the Kepler (hydrogen) in @, is that the “discrete hamiltonian, Schrodinger operator H = - A -1 Izl
(negative) part of H” is equivalent to the inverse Laplacian A - ’ on the 3-sphere. Along with the main themes (I-IV) a number of side issues and problems come to the discussion in different places. The reader will learn, for instance, why the geodesic flow is integrable on Sz (chapter 8), and ergodic on compact negative-curved Riemann surfaces X (chapter 7); what group-representations have to do with a topological problem of “counting linearly independent vector fields on spheres” (chapter 3); how Lie groups and representations explain some peculiar properties and rela.t,ionsof special functions (Legendre, Jacobi, Hermite, etc.). The book was designed as an introduction to harmonic analysis and group representations for graduate students in Mathematics and applications, or anybody
10
Introduction
(non-expert), interested in the subject, who would like to gain a broad perspective, but also learn some basic techniques and ideas. In the words of H. Weyl
“... it
is primarily
meant f o r the humble, who want to learn as new the things set forth therein, rather than f o r the proud and learned who are already familiar with the subject and merely look for
quick and ezact information...” The material of the book is based on the lectures and seminars, given by the author over the passed few years at UC Irvine, Caltech, and CWRU. Student comments and suggestions were helpful in preparing the manuscript. Our goal was to cover a wide range of topics, rather than to delve deeply into any particular one. The exposition is largely based on examples and applications, which either precede or follow the general theory. Some are important on their own, others serve to elucidate and motivate general concepts and statements. Of course, if the general approach seemed conceptually easy and directly leads to the main point, we do not hesitate to bring it forth (like the “Peter-Weyl theory” of chapter 3). But we never engage in “abstract” studies for their own sake. In order to keep the minimal prerequisites, and to shorten the background preparations, the book often appeals to intuition, example and analogy, rather than formal derivations. So the reader versed to some degree in the basic Riemannian geometry, functional analysis and operator theory, should be able to go through most of the topics without difficulty. The less prepared reader would be granted a paragraph (or two) of a footnote/appendix style explanations, to enable him to grasp quickly a new concept (or idea), and to follow the rest. Certain parts of the book (sections/paragraphs) are addressed to a better prepared reader, without detracting from the main themes.
As we wanted not to rely heavily on the standard (4-8 semester) staple of real analysis, algebra, topology, the book provides a number of ‘shortcuts’. So some basic concepts in algebra, geometry, topology are introduces “on fly”, as the need arises. We were somewhat more patient and systematic with the analysis of operators and differential equations: chapter 2 could serve as a brief introduction to PDE’s, mostly from the classical standpoint (cf. [CHI; [WW]). We also provided 3 appendices: on spectral decomposition of self-adjoint operators (A); on integral operators (B), and on basic Riemannian geometry (C). Finally, to cover a sizable material in a moderate-size volume required a departure from certain standards of mathematical exposition. We found it impossible
11
Introduction
(and undesirable) to try to maintain a uniform level of rigor and detail throughout the text. So some results are provided with fairly complete arguments, others are only outlined, relegated to problems, or just stated. The role of formal proofs is in general downplayed. The book contains sufficient material for a 1 or 2-semester course in the Harmonic analysis and Group representations. The instructor could make several choices, and follow different path in selecting topics. Aside of chapter 1, that provides a general core and background, all other parts are relatively independent. So the reader could start at practically any place in the book, going back and forth, as deemed necessary. The only exception are chapter 4 and 5, which should proceed in their natural order. In each chapter we marked with
* more
advanced topics, that could be
omitted in the first reading. In writing an introductory text on a fairly broad subject, one inevitably has to make certain choices, and put aside some important topics. Our selection and style reflected largely on the author’s personal experience and prejudices, rather than anything else. Among a few important topics, left outside the scope, let us mention the representation theory of infinite-dimensional Lie groups and algebras (Kac-Moody), which was actively pursued over the passed 20 years, and recently came to the focus in connection with the String theory (monographs [Kac] and [GSW] present the mathematical and the physical view on the subject). Another important topic is related to symmetries of differential equations, dynamical systems, integrable hamiltonians. Although we do touch upon integrability in chapter 8, our analysis is limited to finitedimensional systems. The exciting developments in the field of “infinite integrable hamiltonians” over the past 30 years were also left out (see [Per]; [Olv] for references). The book was composed on the IEXP-2 word processing system, with an additional help of the Microsoft Windows PBRUSH-graphics, responsible for the figures (the author takes entire responsibility for errors, misprints, omissions). After a somewhat bumpy initiation to the world of the modern information technology, the author had a highly rewarding experience working with both programs. Both became the most indispensable tools in the arduous enterprise of writing and organizing the manuscript.
He thought he saw a Garden-Door That opened with a key He looked again, and found it was A Double Rule of Three: ‘And all its mystery”, he said, “Is clear as day to m e !” He thought he saw an Argument That proved he was the Pope He look again, and found it was A Bar of Mottled Soap. “A fact so dread, ” he faintly said, “Eztinguishes all hope !” Lewis Carroll, “The Mad Gardener’s Song”
Chapter 1. Basics of representation theory. 51.1. Groups and group actions. We introduce basic examples of discrete and continuous transformation groups; classical matrix Lie groups; isornetries of symmetric spaces; rigid motions of the Euclidian, spherical and hyperbolic geometry, as well as symmetries of regular polyhedra.
1.1. Geometric transformations. Groups, discrete and continuous, typically arise as symmetries of “geometric” structures of different kinds, which includes both discrete objects (graphs, polyhedra), and the continuous, like manifolds, symmetric spaces. Important examples of discrete groups include:
i) permutations of a finite sets A = {l;...n}, G(A) = W,; ii) isomorphisms of graphs, lattices, regular polyhedra;
iii) matrix groups over finite fields. Some of them will be described at the end of the section (example 1.1). Throughout this book we shall be mostly interested in the continuous (Lie) groups. The latter typically arise as transformations (linear or nonlinear) of vector spaces,
or
manifolds
A, equipped
with
certain
geometric
structure.
Such
transformations q5:A+A preserve the structure (or transform it in a prescribed manner), in other words they represent symmetries of A. For instance, classical (matrix) Lie groups over vector spaces R”, c”, or quaternionic1 Q”, consists of linear transformations, that preserve certain bilinear/quadratic forms, like the general linear
group made of all non-singular n x n - matrices, Gf, = {A:detA# 0 } , its subgroup
Sl, = { A :detA = l}, called special linear (or unimodular) group, as well as their numerous subgroups (orthogonal, unitary, symplectic etc.). Lie groups also arise naturally as isometries of certain Riemannian (pseudoRiemannian) manifolds, or more general conformal transformations2. The foremost cases are symmetric spaces, Riemannian manifolds which possess large isometry groups. Here we shall briefly discuss 3 basic examples of symmetric spaces (flat, spherical and hyperbolic), and the related symmetry groups. a) Euclidian space
Rn, respectively Minkowski Mn,equipped with either positive-
+ + +
‘Quaternions Q = {( = a b i c j dk a, b, c,d € R} form a noncommutative field (division algebra), generated by 3 imaginary units:i2 = j 2 = k2 = -1; i j = - - j k k ; j k = -kj=i; t i = -ik = j . They can be also represented by complex 2-vectors: ( = z wk ( z , w E C), where k2 = -1, with the multiplication rule: kzu = ii~ t. Quat,ernions along with R and C are known to form the only 3 possible division algebras over reals (see J3.1 for further details).
+
§l,l.Groups and group actions.
14
definite product: z . y = Czjyj, or indefinite product3: (z I y) = zoyo-
n-1
zcjyj. The
isometries of the Euclidian space form a group E, of rigid motions of W", generated by
+ a}, and rotations (orthogonal matrices) {U:'UU = I } . So each the form 4(z) = Uz + b. The proof is outlined in problem 1. The tricky part is to show that any rigid motion q5 is affine, d(z) = A z + b, with some
all translations {a:z+z transformation
4 E En is of
matrix A. Then orthogonality of A follows fairly straightforward. Thus group becomes a subgroup of a larger affine group,
En
+
A f f , = {4(z) = AX b: A E G L ; b E W"}. The En-linear factors { A } are either general orthogonal matrices, A E q n ) , or special orthogonal, A E S q n ) = {U:detU = l}, if 4 preserves the orientation.
Mn the role of the orthogonal affine factors is taken by the
In Minkowski space
Lorentz (pseudoorthogonaZ) group Sql;n - l), which c nsists of matrices B, that preserve the indefinite product (z I y) = Jz y, where J = - matrix of Minkowski form,
41-11)
{ A : ( A zI A d = (z I Y)). So symmetries of the Minkowski space form the Poincare group P, of Special Relativity. The latter is generated by all translations and all Lorentz transformations, 4(z) = Az
+ b; b E Rn;A E S q 1 ; n ) .
Let us notice that in all three cases (affine, Euclidian, Poincare) elements
4 are
2We recall that a Riemannian manifold Ab carries a positive definite metric g = Cgijdtidzj, i.e. an inner product (( I tJg = Cgij
O, on tangent spaces of Ab {( E Tz}.Pseudo-riemannian refers t o the indefinite metric g, usually of the type (+; - ;- ;...). Any diffeomorphism (change of variables) z = #(y), on a Riemannian (pseudo-Riemannian) manifold Ab transforms the metric: g+T = g# = #'*(go #) #', the new entries being N
gkm(Y)
= C (9; j 4) 'I' '
azjwhere
aykaYm9
4' = (%) denotes the Jacobian (matrix) of #. aY
Map # defines an isometry of Ab, if the transformed metric g4 is equal to g. Such maps # obviously preserve the length of any path y = { y ( t ) : 0 5 1 5 T } ,
IY['
T
=
{ Cgij(~(t))i.ii.jdt,
hence the distance between points, d(+;y) = rnin{L[y]: y(0) = 2 ; y ( T ) = y}. Conversely, for any distance preserving diffeomorphism #:Ab-+Jb, the differential 42 (Jacobian matrix of 4), considered as the map of tangent spaces, #':T,+Ty (y = d(z)), preserves the metric (norm) on T,, (#:([) I#:(()) = ((I (), for any tangent vector (. Isometries of Ab clearly form a group. Conformal maps # do not preserve metric, but multiply it with a scalar (conformal) factor p(z), i.e. g4(z) = p(z)g. So they form a larger symmetry group of Ab. 31n Special Relativity R4 = {zo;
...;z3} represents a simplified version of space-time,
serves as time variable, while (zl; z2;z3)represent space coordinates.
where
I,,
51.1. Groups and group actions
15
identified with pairs (A; b), and the group multiplication takes the form
( A ;b) * (A';b') = (AA';Ab' t b).
(1.1)
It is easy to check that translations {b} form a normal subgroup
H
N
Rn of G,
while linear factors { A } , or { U } , form a subgroup I(
N GL,, or S q n ) ; S q 1 ; n ) . So group G is decomposed into a semidirect product4, G = H D K . The representation theory of
semidirect products will be analyzed in chapters 3 and 6. Two other examples of geometric symmetries arise on the sphere and the hyperbolic (Poincare-Lobachevski) space, the prototypes of the spherical and hyperbolic geometries. They also serve as the simplest prototypes of symmetric spaces of the compact and non-compact (hyperbolic) type. b) Sphere: Sn-' = {3::113:11~= l} in Rn with the natural (Euclidian) metric has the isometry group G = S q n ) - all orthogonal transformations (rotations) in R". In fact,
Sn-' can be identified
with the quotient (coset) space of group G = S q n ) , modulo the
stabilizer (isotropy subgroup)'
K = S q n - 1) of
fixed point zo in
a
Sn-' (the
North
Pole!), Sn N G / K . In other words (definition of stabilizer), I( = { U : U ( z 0 )= x0}. c) Hyperbolic space W, can be realized either as Poincare-Lobachevski complex half-plane { z = 3:
+ iy: y > 0 } , with metric
or as complex disk D = {IZI
< 1 ) with metric, ds2 =
the Mobius transformation,
One can easily check that
0
rn. dzdf
Both spaces are related by
takes W onto D, and transforms their Poincare
metrics, one into the other. The isometry group of 04 in both realizations is made of the fractional-linear transformations: az+c @z+w = bz+d'
U:Z-+X",
4A semidirect product G = H D U , of groups H and U , where U acts by automorphisms on H , (zE H ; u E U ) , consists of all pairs g = (z,u) witbthe multiplication rule (2,u)* (y, w) = (2 * y" ;uw). It is easily seen that H = {(z;e)} forms a normal subgroup of G, while K = {(e;u)} a
subgroup, so that H
nK = { e } , and the whole group G = H . K .
'Stabilizer (isotropy subgroup) of point c in a G-space X , consist of all elements {g E C}, that leave z fixed, K , = {g: zg = z}.
31.1. Groups and group actions.
16
5
1
In the half-plane case matrices {A = fi]:ad- bc = 1 belong to SL,(R) - the real unimodular group. In the disk realization they are given by complex matrices
detA=iaiZ-IPlZ=l A that preserve the indefinite hermitian form: J ( z ) = I z1 1' - / z 2 on C2 = {(q; 2,)). This group is called conformal and denoted SU(1;l), by analogy with the standard unitary group SU(2), that preserves the positive
in
other
words
matrices
I,,
hermitian product, l z l z = 1z11' +1zzl2. Once again the hyperbolic space coincides with the quotient of G = SL, (or SU(l;l)),modulo stabilizer I< of a fixed point z,, = i E W. The stabilizer I< is easily seen to coincide with an orthogonal group in R2,
I< = {A:
= i} =
SO(^), so w N SL,/SO(~).
Remark: The hyperbolic nature of the Poincare-Lobachevski geometry stems from its close connection to a hyperboloid r = { z 2 - (z2+y2) = 1) in R3. The former represents an orbit of the Lorentz group Sq2;1), acting by linear transformations of @ N h.03. So the Lorentz metric ds2 = ds2+dyZ - dz2, restricted on I?, remains invariant under Sq2;1). Furthermore, its restriction, ds2 I r becomes positive-definite (since all rtangent vectors [ = (z;y;z) are space-Me, 2 + y 2 - z 2 > O!). So r turns into a Riemannian manifold with a large symmetry group (symmetric space). In fact,
r N Sq2;1)/S0(2), where Sq2) acts as a stabilizer of the vertex (0;O;l)of I?. The connection between I' and D is established via a stereographic map @ (see fig.1). We parametrize
r and D by polar coordinates in the sy-plane, { ( r ; 8 ) : z= 2 1 +r2)for l?,and { ( p , 8 ) ) for D.
Then @:p+r = 2'2P So 1-P
the metric on dr' dsz _-_ -$
is taken into the Poincare metric in D,
r:
l+r2
ds2 = 4
dp2
r2dO2,
+ p2d@
(1 - p y
.
Fig. 1. Sfereographic m a p 9 takes a I': z2 - (z2 + yz) = 1, in hyperboloid R3 -M3, i n f o f h e unit disk D p2 = x 2 + y z < 1, in the xy-plane, and transforms the nafural ( S O ( 2 ; 1)-invariant metric on r into the Poincare metric on D.
51.1. Groups and group actions
17
The relation between I?, D and W suggests that their groups of isometries should be identical. Indeed, we shall see (chapters 5,7) that SL,@) 21 Swl;1) makes a two-fold cover of SO(2;1)(problem 5). Thus we have exhibited 3 classes of manifolds with rich symmetry groups: Euclidian/Minkowski spaces, spheres and the hyperbolic plane. In all 3 cases group G acts transitively on A (each point is moved to any other by an element of G). Hence space A is identified with the quotient G / K , where K denotes a stabilizer of a point xo E A, namely Rfl
21 E,/SO(n);
(I = S q n ) - stabilizer of {O};
Mn 21 P,/SO(l;n-l) Sn-'
N
- stabilizer of {0} in P,
SO(n)/So(n - 1) - stabilizer of xo = (1; 0; ... )
W IISL,(R)/So(2);
or D = SU(1;1)/SO(2); K = So(2)-stabilizer of {i} (or (0))
In fact in all three cases group G acts in a stronger double-transitive manner on A, meaning that any pair of points (2; y } can be transformed into any other equidistant pair {x';y'}, d(e; y ) = d ( d ; y'). This fact has important implications for the analysis on such manifolds. Let us remark that all the Riemannian examples above (except Minkowski) belong to a wide class of symmetric spaces. These manifolds can be generally described as quotients of Lie groups modulo maximal compact subgroups, A N G / K , and we
shall see many more examples in subsequent sections.
1.2. Finite groups. The easiest to describe are commutative finite group. The complete list includes cyclic groups: Z, 21 Z/nZ, which could also be written in the - the n-th primitive root of unity), and complex form: {eiEw:O 5 k 5 n - l}, (w = their direct sums: G = Zfll x ... x Z ,.
2) Symmetries of regular polyhedra and finite subgroups of SO(3). We shall start with regular polygons in the plane.
i)
Symmetries of the regular n-gon consist of rotations by angles EZ , - a finite subgroup of all planar rotations SO(2), or the larger dihedral group, D, = Z, Z, c O(2) - a semidirect product of rotations and a reflection
{gk:k = 0; l...}
about any symmetry axis. D, can be thought of as the symmetry group of the dihedral A,, a solid in R3, built of 2 pyramids based on a regular polygon R, in W2 and a pair of opposite vertices that project onto the center of R, (see figure ). Then Z, implements
18
$1.1. Groups and group actions.
axisymmetric rotations of the dihedral in the plane, while a generator of
Z, flips 2
opposite (spatial) vertices. In 3-D one also has 5 Platonic perfect solids, each one with a symmetry group of orthogonal transformations in
W3 that
preserve its vertices:
ii) tetrahedral symmetries: A, - alternating group (even permutations) of order 4. The generators of A, are cyclic permutations of 3 vertices in each tetrahedral face, that leave the opposite vertex fixed. iii) cubo-octahedral symmetries: the symmetric (permutation) group W,. Cube contains two opposite regular inscribed tetrahedra (fig.2), so its group contains an A, plus an element u that transposes both tetrahedra. Hence Gcube= A,
UaA, = W,.
Fig.:! shows cube with 2 opposit inscribed tetrahedra.
A, - alternating group of order 5 [Cox]. Indeed, a dodecahedron contains 5 inscribed tetrahedra {TI;...;T5}(the set of 20 vertices is evenly split into 5 quadruples). A rotation of order 3 about any pair of opposit verteces leaves a pair of tetrahedra (say T,;T,) fixed and cyclicly permutes the remaining triple (2'5 T,;T,). Obviously, even permutations, {(123);(234);(345);...} generate As! iv) Icoso-dodecahedral group:
Fig.3 demonstrates one of 5 regular tetrahedrons, inscribed inside the dodecahedron. Any pair of opposit vertices ( A ;A') selects a pair of tetrahedra, and any rotation of order 3 about the AA'-aixis, leaves the pair fixed, and cyclicly permutes the remaining triple.
We shall see now that (i-iv) completely describe all finite subgroups of the orthogonal group S q 3 ) . Classification Theorem 1: A n y finite subgroup G of S q 3 ) coincides with one of the
above polyhedral groups (i)-(iv).
19
51.1. Groups and group actions The proof involves several steps. 1) We observe that any rotation U E S q 3 ) has two fixed points on the unit sphere
S2 = {It t 11 = l}, indeed the eigenvalues of an orthogonal U in R2 are X = e
* ip; l!
2) Take set X of all G-fixed points on S2. Set X is G-invariant, hence splits it into the union of G-orbits:
X = w1
G, = { U : U z = z}, and call
u...Uwm.
For each point z E X we consider its stabilizer
I G, I = n2 - the
degree of
(2).
same orbit have equal degrees (stabilizers are conjugate!),
80
Obviously, all points on the nz
= n(w 1.) = n3., for I E w j .
3) Next we count the number of pairs { ( z ; U ) :z E X ; U E Gz} (the “total degree of C”) in two ways: #{fixed points of all U E G\{e}} = “sum of degrees of all {z}”.This yields,
c
2(IGI-1)=
c rn
(IG,l
-l)=
lwjl(nj-1).
(1.3)
+EX 1 4) Dividing both sides of (1.3) by I G I we derive the equation relating the order of G t o degrees of its fixed points:
I
I
The rest of analysis closely resembles a classification of Platonic solids. Namely, one can show that m in (1.4) could take on two values m = 2;3 only! Each case is analyzed separately. 5) In case
m,one easily shows n1 = n2 = n = I G I. So G has two 1-point orbits of
degree n, which implies G = Zn- cyclic!
6) In case1 Case
there are 3 possible subcases:
PI = n2 = 2; n3 = nl. Here G has two “n-point” orbits of deg = 2 and a “2-point”
orbit of deg = n, which implies G = Dn- the dihedral group!
-1
Case
yields 3 possibilities for
n3
3; I G I = 12; Gtetr ( 3 orbits of degree: 2;3;3) 4; I G I = 24; GCube(3 orbits of degree: 2;3;4) 5; I G I = 60; Gdodec(3 orbits of degree:2;3;5)
In a similar vein one can describe symmetries of regular polytopes in higher dimensions [Cox].
3. Other interesting classes arise as automorphisms of finite groups, and regular graphs. Among them we shall mention finite groups of Lie type: G = GLn(F), and
SLn(IF),made of n x n-matrices with entries in
a
finite field IF. There many similarities
51.1. Groups and group actions.
20
in the analysis and representation theory of classical and finite-type Lie groups, but our attention will be focused mostly on the continuous case.
1.3. Compact groups. These are topological groups with compact space G. The E [O;l]}ci Rn/Zn; the classical most important examples include t o w 8" = {(tl;.,.tn):tj compact Lie groups, like orthogonal - S q n ) ; unitary - SU(n); symplectic - Sp(n), et al. The general theory of the compact and finite groups will be developed in chapter 3. The classical compact Lie theory will be covered in detail in chapters 4-5. Other interesting examples arise as matrix groups over p-odic numbers (pprime): Q,, or integers Z,, i.e. the closure of rationals Q, or integers Z, in the padic norm: II a llP = p-". Here n denotes the largest power (positive or negative) of prime p in fraction a = p"a'.
The corresponding p - a d i c Lie groups: GLn(Qp); SLn(Qp), and their compact subgroups
GL,(Z,); SL,(Z,), consists of all Qp(Zp)-valued n x n matrices (respectively matrices of det
= 1). These groups find applications in the number theory and algebraic geometry,
but we shall not venture into the subject of the padic analysis (see [GGP]; [JL]).
1.4. Lie groups form the most important and interesting class, which plays the fundamental role in many areas of Mathematics and Physics: analysis, differential equations, geometry; classical, quantum, statistical mechanics. In general, Lie groups are defined as manifolds with smooth (differential) group structure: multiplication and inversion operations. A brief introduction to the Lie theory is provided in $1.4. The main bulk of the book will deal with the analysis and representations of Lie groups, emphasizing both general aspects of the Lie group theory as well as many specific examples and applications. Lie groups could be divided into two large and distinct classes: solvable and nilpotent (a subclass of solvable); simple and semisimple. The definitions of both classes will be given in 51.4, and the detailed analysis conducted in chapter 6 (nilpotent and solvable groups), and chapters 4,5,7 (simple and semisimple groups). Although both classes differ substantially in their structure, there are abundant connections, and parallels in the harmonic analysis and representation theory. The first class is exemplified by
+
b}- all affine transformations of W. i) 1-D affine group: A f f = {da,*:x-iax This group can be also realized by 2 x 2 matrices of the form { A = b E W;a E R*}. ii) the celebrated Heisenberg group 3 x 3 matrices
W, (and its higher-D
(" i);
cousins Hn), realized by
21
31.1. Groups and group actions
iii) The group B, of upper/lower triangular matrices in GL, (called often the
Bore1 subgroup),
{
B,= A =
r
A, b
1
Xj;a,b,cER,orC
Groups Aff, and B, are solvable, whereas
.
W, - nilpotent.
In $1.4 we shall see that any Lie group can be decomposed into a semidirect
product B D H , of the solvable normal subgroup B, and a semisimple subgroup H . Any semisimple group H in turn can be decomposed into the direct product of sample groups. The latter were completely classified in celebrated works of E. Cartan. They comprise 4 series of classical Lie groups, listed below, and a few exceptional groups. Many classical Lie groups arise as linear transformations of vector spaces over 02, C or quaternions Q, that preserve certain bilinear/quadratic forms, in other words as subgroups of GL, or SL,. These include,
i) Orthogonal groups: q n ) , S q n ) , preserve Euclidian inner product x .y , q n ) = {U:Ux . Uy = z . y } , and S q n ) = {U E q n ) :det U = 1). There are also indefinite orthogonal groups q p ; q ) and S q p ;q), that preserve indefinite products: P P+Q (z y ) = f: z j y j - C z j y j in P+l
I
so that
RPtQ,
or
CP+q,
( U z I Uy) = (z I y ) , for all z,y. The principal difference between the definite-type and indefinite-type groups in the real case is that the former are compact, while the latter are not, as exemplified by the S q n + l ) and the Lorentz S q l ; n ) , mentioned earlier. But in the complex case the difference disappears, so S q p ;q ) N Sqp+q), for p , q. ii) Unitary groups: U(n), U(k;m), preserve definite (or indefinite) hermitian inner product in C“, z . F , or k
( z I w) = ?zjwj
- c zjwj; in cktrn. ktm
ktl
A particular example is the conformal group SU(1;1). iii) SympIectic grou s: Sp(n) consist of all 2n x 2n matrices that preserves a skewsymmetric form J =
[-I IF (z
I z’) = a:.y’-z’.y
= J z .z‘; z = ( 2 , y ) .
$1.1. Groups and group actions.
22
In all cases the corresponding group consists of matrices, that satisfy
U*JU = J , where U* denotes the transpose (or hermitian adjoint) of U , and
J is either identity (for
the orthogonal and unitary groups), or the symmetric form Xkm with k pluses and m minuses on the main (for the indefinite orthogonal and unitary groups), or the skew symmetric form J in the symplectic case. The above list contains most of the classical examples, but it does not represent their classification scheme (see chapter 5 ) , our emphasis was mainly on construction. The reader will find (problems 5,6), that 3 series overlap, particularly in low dimensions. More examples of this nature will come in $1.4 and subsequent chapters. 1.5. Discrete groups. Those typically arise as discrete subgroups of continuous
(Lie) groups, like lattices Z' 2 Z" in W", or their noncommutative counterparts, lattices r c Gf,; SL,, and other Lie groups. Important examples of the noncommutative lattices are i) the unimodular group I' = SL,(Z), and some related subgroups of SL, ii) discrete Heisenberg group: matrices (1.5) with integer a , b,c E Z.
iii) discrete subgroups
r of the Euclidian motion group En.
The latter are called crystallographic gToups, as they describe all possible crystalline arrangements in Euclidian spaces. They were thoroughly investigated, and classified in dimensions 2 and 3. As E, itself such groups are decomposed into a
r =A
U , where A 21 Zn forms a lattice in R", while a finite group U c Gf, acts by automorphisms (linear transformations) of A. semidirect product,
In 2-Dthe complete list contains 17 groups, whose U-components could take only 10 possible values: {Zm;Dm:m = 1;2;3;4;6}. The complete list in 3-D includes 219 nonisomorphic and 230 nonconjugate crystallographic groups. It was worked out by Fedorov, Schoenfliess and Barlow at the turn of the last century. As a step towards classification one needs all finite orthogonal symmetries, derived in Theorem 1. For further details and relates issues we refer to [BH]; [HC]; [Sch].
$1.1. Groups and group actions
23
Problems and Exercises: 1. Show that any rigid motion on R" (Euclidian or Minkowski) is linear, d(z) = A z for some a E R", and matrix A. Follow steps:
i) The Jacobian q5'(z) is an orthogonal matrix, i.e.
+ a,
aid. ajq5 = 6ij
ii) Differentiate the orthogonality relation (i) in the k-th variable, ak(...), then dot,. Show the resulting 4-tensor tLJ = (8,,,+4 Bid) to be symmetric multiply with 84 in both row-indexes: tik = tki; tm3= tJm; and antisymmetric in column-indexes (changing i - j or k-m changes its sign). iii) Show that any such t must be at once symmetric and antisymmetric in the pair of indexes {ij}. Hence t = 0, for all quadruples ijkm, which implies 8'4 = 0, i.e. q5 is linear! 2. The isometry group of S"-' consist of rotations {V E Sqn)}. Hint: any isometry of s n - 1 extends to an isometry of R"\{O} N S"-'xR+. But the latter are linear by problem l!. 3. Show that fractional-linear transformations (1.2) of SL, on H, or SU(1;I) on D, are isometries. 4. Show that all finite subgroups of S q 3 ) are either polyhedral, or polygonal groups, described in Example 1.1.
5. Establish and find explicit form of the isomorphism SL,(R)+SU(l;I), using their fractional-linear actions on H and D, and the Caley transformation 4: z - + G , from M z+z
to D. Notice that both are subgroups of the larger complex unimodular group SL,(C), with a Caley element u E SL,(C). Find and can be obtained by conjugation, U+U-'UU, U!
6. Show that the symplectic group Sp(1) coincides with SL,. 7. Show that complex groups S O ( p ; q ) and SO(p+q) are isomorphic (Hint: the indefinite product ( z 1 w ) in Cp+* is equivalent to the definite product z . w by conjugation with a complex diagonal matrix).
$1.2. Regular and induced representation
24
51.2. Regular and induced representations; Haar measure and Convolution algebras. We introduce two basic concepts of regular and induced representations, discuss continuity and unitarity and develop some basic algebraic constructions: direct sum, direct integral, tensor product. In the process we introduce the (invariant) Haar measure on groups and homogeneous (coset) spaces H\G, define convolution (group) algebras L’(G), and find the links between representations of the group and those of its groupalgebra.
2.1. Regular representations: In the last section we have described some examples of transformation groups acting on various geometric structures (graphs, manifolds, symmetric spaces), including the action of group on itself by the right/left multiplication (translation), g: x-+xg; or x+g-’x. With any such action of group G on space X (denoted by x - + x g ) , we can associate a
linear
G-action on functions over
homomorphism of G into linear operators over
X, {f(x)} = e = e ( X ) , i.e. a
e,
In particular, the right/left translations, x-+xg; x+g-lx,
on G give
IR,f(x) = f ( g - ’ z ) (left), or f ( x g ) (right), on e(G)l Homomorphisms g+T,, vector space
Y,are
(2.2)
of group G into linear transformations/matrices on a
called representations, and formulae (2.1)-(2.2) provide important
examples of regular representations of G on X, or on itself. In the analysis of group actions and associated representations on various function-spaces, it is often necessary to “integrate” over G or X . So we need some measures on X and G . 2.2. The Haar measure. It turns out that all discrete and continuous (locally compact) groups G , as well as large classes of homogeneous spaces6 X = H\G have an invariant measure, dp(xg) = dp(x), for all x E X, g E G, called the Haar measure. The general proof will be outlined below. More important, however, will be to compute the Haar measure in a suitably chosen coordinate system on group G or space X. Here we shall list a few examples of Haar measures on groups and homogeneous spaces (many more will appear throughout the book). ‘homogeneous (quotient) space X = H\G, or G / H , consists of all right/left cosets {z = Hgo:gOE C } , or {z goH:go E C}. Group G acts on X by right/left translations, g:z+zg = ( H g o ) g , or 2-9(z).So X could be viewed as a G-space, with a transitive G-action, and subgroup H coincides with the stabilizer of a fixed point, H = {g:rog= zo}.
$1.2. Regular and induced representation
a) finite/discrete group G has dp(z) =
25
C C ~ ~sum ( Xof) &-functions over
all
Y
y E G.
b) for commutative groups Wn;Tn, dp coincides with the standard Lebesgue measure (volume element), dz = dxldz, ...dx,. We have shown in $1.1that Rn could be regarded as a homogeneous space of the Euclidian motion group G = En. The Lebesgue measure is clearly invariant under all translations and rotations on
W", hence it also
forms a G-invariant measure on homogeneous space W" = E n / S q n ) . c) on compact Lie groups S q n ) , SU(n), the Haar measure can be explicitly calculated in terms of suitably chosen coordinates, like Euler angles (chapters 3-4). The same could be done on non-compact (Lorentz, conformal, etc.) groups, like S q 1 ; n ) or
SU(1;n ) , by a combination of spherical and hyperbolic angles.
W is a homogeneous space of dz d y measure d p = -is G-invariant.
d) the hyperbolic (Poincare-Lobachevski) half plane
G = SL,(R). One can check (problem l), that
Y2
e) GLn(W) has a natural set of coordinates, matrix entries {zjk}'&l
of g. One can
show (problem 6) the invariant measure on GL,
dPk)=
&=
ndXjk. Jk
For more examples see problems 5-8.
Existence Theorem: i) On any compact (and more general locally compact) group
there ezists a Bore1 measure dp(x), positive on all open subsets, finite on all compact subsets and invariant under all right (or left) translations: EX) = p ( E ) , for all subsets E c G and elements x E G. ii) A right and left Haar measures: d,x; d,x are unique up to a constant factor. iii) On a compact group G the left and right Haar measures are equal, furthermore dp is invariant under the group inversion and conjugation,
dp(x-') = dp(x), dp(g-'sg) = dp(z). Let us briefly outline the proof.
Existence: To construct a right-invariant measure dp, we pick a small neighborhood U of the identity e E G to serve as a gauge. Given a (open, closed) subset E optimal (least) covers of E and G by translates of U , m n E C u U z j , G = U U yj*
j=1
j=l
C G, we choose
51.3. Regular and induced representation
26 The ratio
represents an approximate relative size of E in G in the ”U-gauge”.
m ( E ; U ) as U-.{e}, (by standard arguments such limit always exists!), one Taking limit n(C;U ) gets an honest Borel measure on G. The limiting measure, dp, thus constructed is easily seen to be right-invariant. Also p ( E ) > 0 for any open E, and p(G)
< 00 for a compact
G , since G is covered by finitely many translates of E. Uniqueness: If dji is another right-invariant measure, then for small U ,
m ( E , U ) ef-i ( E ) while n ( G ; U )e m(U)’
subsets E.
fi(U)’
whence p ( E ) = lim
U-lel .
$ = Const f i ( E ) , for
all
I
iii) T o show that the right and the left-invariant Haar measures on a compact G are equal, we take a left translate, d j i ( z ) = dp(az), of a right-invariant measure d p ( z ) . Of course, dji is also right-invariant. Hence dji = p ( o ) d p , by the uniqueness of dp. The map a+p(a) is a homomorphism of
G into the multiplicative group R+. But there are no such
nontrivial continuous homomorphisms on a compact group (continuous functions on compact sets are always bounded, whereas nontrivial homomorphisms p: G-R,
are
unbounded!). Hence, p = 1, and d p is also right-invariant. Two other invariance properties of d p easily follow now. Indeed, change of variable 2-z-l
takes a right-invariant measure into a left-invariant measure, the conjugate-
invariance immediately follows from the bi-invariance: d p ( a r b ) = d p ( z ) for all a, b. This completes the proof. R e m a r k In many cases (e.g. Lie groups) the right and left invariant measures are dlb) absolutely continuous one relative t o the other. The corresponding density -= A(g) is 4(9) a character (homomorphism into the numbers) of G with positive real values
A:G+R,; A(gh) = A(g)A(h), called the modular function. Groups with equal right and left Haar measures, A(g) = 1, are called unimodular. Large classes of groups are known t o be unimodular, for instance, all compact groups, semisimple and nilpotent Lie groups. Nonunimodular examples include: a f i n e groups and more general Borel groups of all upper/lower triangular matrices (problem 8).
The invariant (Haar) measure, topology/metric, and the differential structure on group G allow to int,roduce a variety of function-spaces. The most important among those are
C(G) - continuous (bounded) functions {f(z)}on G, with norm
II f II 00 = S U P I f(z) I ZEG
7
$1.2. Regular and induced representation and its subspaces functions; 0
e,, -
LP-spaces on
27
functions vanishing at {cm},and C, - compactly supported
G with respect
to the Haar measure dz,
in particular Hilbert space LZ(G)with the standard inner product
0 For Lie groups G (smooth manifold) one can consider a variety of differentiable function-spaces: Y ( G ) - Um-smoothfunctions”, C”(G) - infinitely smooth functions; their subspaces of functions vanishing at {m}, or compactly supported ep, with norm
er;
sum over all
llfllrn = C S U P Jaaf(41, XEG “partial derivatives” of order I a I 5 m (the meaning
: f l * f z ) ( z= )
J
fl(zy-’) f z ~ d )y = G
J
of “derivatives”) on
~ I ( Y )f z ( ~ - ’ z d5 )
(2.3)
G
integration with respect to the Haar measure d y on
G. On
finite/discrete groups
integration in (2.3) is replaced by the sum,
f*h =
c
f(zy-’)h(y).
YEG
The meaning of convolution, as an extension of the group multiplication to functions, becomes transparent here, as each group element {z} is identified with the delta-function 6,, so that
31.2. Regular and induced representation
28
6,* 6, = SZy;for all x,y E G. For continuous groups
G convolution-integral (2.3) is well defined on compactly
supported functions (ec;ep),then it extends to larger classes by the standard density arguments7. Spaces closed under convolution forms convolutzon/group algebras. One important example is space L'(G) of all integrable functions on G. Here,
Ilf*hli
(2.4)
A similar estimate holds for a convolution of L' and LP-functions,
1 f* h Il p 5 (1 f 1 IIh IIp ; for all pairs f E L', h E LP.
(2.5)
In the standard terminology L' is a Banach algebra, while other LP are modules over L'. Estimates (2.4)-(2.5) follows from the well known Minkowski inequality,
applied t o function F = f(zy-')h(y).
The inequality (2.6) has an obvious interpretation,
any function F ( z ; y ) (z E X ; y E Y) defines a map F:Y-.LP(dz), then (2.6) claims:
1 JF(y)dyll<
lIIF(y)Ildy, where
(1 11 means the LP(dz)-norm. Other examples of
convolution-algebras include spaces of continuous and differentiable functions:
em,
e, em,
as well as bounded (Borel) measures on G, A ( G ) 3 L'(G). Condition (2.5) can be
stated as boundedness of the convolution (bilinear) map, L'*LP-LP,
or L'*LP
c LP, 1 5 p 5 03.
It is also easy t o see that L2*Lz C Loo, and Ilf*hll, 5 llfl1211 hllz (Cauchy-Schwartz). Such results can be extended to many other triples: LP*Lq
c L', and other "scales of
function-spaces" by interpolation discussed in chapter 2 (J2.2).
2.4. Continuity and unitarity. The study of group representations combines two
aspects: algebraic, which reflects purely algebraic properties of groups and operators, and analytic (topological), which involves the geometric structure of manifolds A (differentiable, complex, etc.), as well as topological properties of the relevant vector (function) spaces and operators over A. In the topological context (locally compact/Lie groups G, Banach or Hilbert spaces V) one needs to impose some continuity assumptions on 'Spaces
ec and ep are dense in all Lp, 1 5 p < co!
T.One possibility would
$1.2. Regular and induced representation
29
be to require continuity of the map g+Tg in the operator (norm) topologfl on space %(V), of all bounded operators on T. This notion, however, turns out to be too restrictive, (see problem 2, and the author's paper ', JFA, 35, 1980).
A weaker notion of continuity asks vector functions {TgfiG+T}, or the matrix t E T*-dual space} to be continuous. It is called entries of T , {tcv(g)= (T,J I ~ ) E: T;Q strong continuity. Strong continuity holds in most natural examples, including regular representations (2.1), (2.2), and (2.8) below, in different function-spaces: e; em;LP(G), etc. (both on G and on homogeneous spaces X=H\G, G modulo a closed subgroup H ) . Let us remark that quotient-spaces X of topological groups often inherit basic structures of G, like metric, differential structure, and in some cases G-invariant (Haar) measure. An important class of group representations consist of unitary representations in Hilbert (inner product) spaces:
The natural example is furnished by the regular representation R on squareintegrable functions V = L 2 ( X ) ,provided space X has a G-invariant Haar measure, d ( x g ) = dx, for all g E G. The Haar measure was shown to exist on any locally compact group G, but quotient spaces X = H\G may or may not have it, as we shall demonstrate. The invariant measure always exists, if subgroup H is compact, e.g. on symmetric spaces. However, in any case a homogeneous space (manifold) X comes equipped with some measure (volume element) dx. Group elements ( g E G}, acting on X transform dx into another measure dxg, which will differ from dx by a density factor: In case of the smooth (Riemannian) manifolds and G-actions (e.g. a(x;g) symmetric space X ) , a represents the Jacobian determinant of the map 4: x - d ,
=%.
a ( x ; g )= d e t # ( x ) .
(2.7)
We can still construct a unitary representation of G on L * ( X ; d z )by combining the group (translational) action on X with multiplication by fi,
Function a ( x ; g )is easily seen to obey the so called cocycle condition, 'We remind the reader that the space of all bounded linear operators in a normed vector space 11(11< l}, or sup{(A( 7):all ( ; q } in the Hilbert space setup.
Y is equipped with an operator-norm: 11 All = sup{IIA(Il: all
'We have proved that any norm-continuous irreducible T must be finite dimensional, which automatically excludes large and important classes of m-D representations.
51.2. Regular and induced representation
30
4";9192)= +;g1)4z91;gz); all gI;gZ E G , which yields the representation property for operators T , (2.8),
(2.9)
T g l g 2= Tg1Tg2, for all gr;g2in G . Obviously operators {T,} preserve the L2-norm of
f, so we get once again a
unitarity representation of G on L 2 ( X ) !
2.5. Induced representations. Regular representations (2.2)-(2.1) on G and quotients H\G, as well as more general representation (2.8) are obtained by the process called induction. In general, induction allows to construct representations of group G , starting from representations of its subgroup H. An alternative definition is based on the notion of cocycle u(z;g)on the homogeneous space X = H\G, i.e. a function u: X
x G + {numbers} or {operators},
that satisfies the cocycle condition (2.9)
a(z;glg2)= a(z;gl)u(xgl;gz);for all gl;g2 E G , x E X . The induced representation, T = ind(a I H ; G ) , acts on the space of (Y-valued) functionslO on X,
e = C(x;Y)
= {f(z) : X + Y },
and is given by
We leave to the reader, as an easy exercise, to check that (2.10) does give a representation of G. Furthermore, if u is continuousfunitary and X has a Haar measure
d x , then T , also becomes a continuousfunitary representation'' of G on space L 2 ( X ; Y ) , of square-integrable Y-valued functions on X (problem 9). Let us remark that the cocycle condition (2.9) for elements of stabilizer H = G, = {g: xg = z}, yields a representation ~ ( h=)a ( z ; h )of H on
Y,u ( h l h 2 )= u(hl)u(hz).So one could start with a
representation u of H and construct a cocycle u(z;g)!This alternative way to define 2nd will be discussed in $3.2. Regular representations R on G and quotients X = H\G, are induced by the trivial cocycle u,
R = ind(1 I H;G). '"In the topological (Lie) setup one takes a suitable function-space on X, e.g. continuous, differentiable, L2-functions, etc. "In the absence of invariant measure on X we can modify operators T, (2.10) by a scalar (2.7) to make T unitary. Obviously, the product of two cocycles (I and makes factor another cocycle!
fi
$1.2. Regular and induced representation
31
We shall see the induction procedure to appear throughout this book in various places and contexts, in the representation theory of finite, compact, simple, nilpotent, solvable groups alike. The role of induction will be twofold: on the one hand it extends the notion of regular representations on G and X to vector functions and sections of
vector bundles12, on the other hand many irreducible representations of groups will be constructed via induction. Here we shall illustrate the induced action by two examples of homogeneous spaces H\G, without G-invariant measure (see problem 4), and construct the relevant regularlinduced unitary representations.
+
1) Affine group G = {g = (a;b):z-iaz b = zg} of $1.1 acts transitively on R z H\G, where H denotes the stabilizer of {0}, H = {(a;O)} R* (multiplicative group of reds). The “az+b” action on R has no G-invariant measure. Indeed, the translational invariance ({b}-part) requires dp to be Lebesgue, but multiplication with the {a}-factors dilate it, dp-‘ 1 a 1 d p . However, we get the cocycle a ( rr g) --@dz =lab
(2.11)
hence a unitary action of G on L2(R),
The representation theory of affine groups will be discussed in chapter 6 (56.1). 2) Group G = SL,(R) and its subgroup of upper-triangular matrices
H
=
{(R akl)}
yield the quotient-space X N R, with G acting by the fractional linear transformations, g: 5
ac+b
3 cz+d9
for
(2.12)
=
Indeed, cosets z E H\G can be parametrized by matrices
{rz = (i
coset representatives, via the Gauss factorization: (almost) any element g = factors into the product,
(: 3 = (d-l
$(b/ld
l):z E R}
-
(ii), ( d # 0 )
1) =
To find the cocycle we take the product yzg, and factor out the h-term, y z . g = ( az+b a cr+d ) = h . y ,
where
vector bundle TI consists of the base manifold X , stuffed with fibers (linear vector spaces) {YZ} associated to points of z E X . The natural example is the tangent bundle, made of all tangent spaces {Tz: z E X } of a smooth base-manifold.
A-
51.2. Regular and induced representation
32
The density factor a is computed from the transformation law (2.12) to be a(t;g) = 1 ct+d
I - 2.
(2.13)
So a unitary representation of SL, on space L2(R) takes the form,
More general representations of SL,(W) on Lz(W) are obtained by taking complex powers of the cocycle,
(2.14) These are so called principal series representations of SL,, that will be studied in detail in chapter 7.
2.6. Representations of group algebras. Any group representation T, gives rise to a representation of a suitable group-algebra L = {f}, of functions on G, by integrating T against f , (2.15) It is easy to check that map f+Tf satisfies
Tf*,, = TfTh, for any pair f , h E L . Conversely, any algebra-representation f -tTf, subject to a minor technical assumption (span{T,('V):f E L} is dense in 'V), can be shown to come from a group representation g-tT, via (2.15). As usually, in the topological context one has to give a meaning to integration (2.15) and to find a proper class of functions { f } on G. If T is continuous (which is always the case), and f - compactly supported, integral obviously exists and yields a bounded operator, )IT,II 5 Jlf(~)IIITllld..
Tf
(2.16)
Estimate (2.16) also indicates the class of functions, for which T , can be extended, as a bounded operator. The latter depends on the behavior of function w(z) = IIT,II on G. Clearly T f extends to the space (algebra) of functions, integrable
{f:/lf(z)lw(s)ds < m}. In particular, unitary (or more general bounded) representations, I(T,(I5 C, yield bounded operators {T,} for all f in the group algebra with weight w,
L = L'(G), indeed, I)T,(II Cllflll. If T is a left regular representation (2.2) on G, then operators (2.15) are nothing but left convolutions with f,
51.2. Regular and induced representation
33
R f [ h ]= f*h. The main advantage of passing from the group representation T , to its integrated form (2.15) has to do with nice (smoothing/regularizing) properties of operators { T I } . To wit the “unitary/bounded group operators” {T,} could yield a better class of “algebra operators” { Tf}:compact, Hilbert-Schmidt, or trace-class. The latter often depends on the regularity properties of
L = em(G);P‘(G), the “smoother11
{ f ’ s } one takes the “better” { T I }results. A simple illustration is furnished by convolutions with f E Cm(G) (or Coo). It is easy t o check (problem l l ) , that any such operator
R,: ZP-.Cm
(P), i.e. Cm*ZP C em,for all p, m.
In other words, convolutions with m-smooth
{f} transform ZP-singular functions { h } into
m-smooth functions. Smoothing properties of convolution operators with nice (smooth) functions are well known and frequently utilized techniques in harmonic analysis and differential equations, that go under the name of regularization methods. We shall use them extensively in subsequent sections, but here we just give a simple illustration of smoothing by convolutions in problem 10.
2.7. Algebraic constructions. We shall conclude this section with a few algebraic constructions of representations. Direct sum of {T’; Tz;...}lacting in spaces Yl;Y,...is defined in the obvious way by taking the direct sum of spaces Y,@ Y2@ ... , and setting,
(T’ @ T2@
...)g((1;(2;...)
= TL(1@Ti(, @ ...; (j E Yj.
(2.17)
There is a continuous version of (2.17) called the direct integral decomposition. Given a family of representations {TX:XE A}, in spaces {X’} (assumed to be regularly embedded in the embient space X), and a measure dp on A, we define direct integral X’dp(X), to consist of all L2-vector valued functions on A, that for each X E A, take on values in 36,: F = f(X) E X’. We then define direct-integral operators,
to map vector-functions f(X)
+ Tx[f(X)].
Tensor (Kronecker) product T’ &I T 2 is defined in the tensor-product space’
Y1@ Y,: (T’ @ T2),({&I 17) = Tb{ &I Tiq.
81.2. Regular and induced representation
34
An analytic version requires a proper topological product
Y,@ Y2.
Thus for
regular representations R3 ( j = 1,2) in spaces YJ = L 2 ( X j ) , the product space Y = Y 1 @ Y 2 L~ ' ( X , x X , ) , a n d G a c t s o n Y b y
Rgf(";Y) = f(& Y,). The contragredient (dual) representation Pg = Ti-,, in the dual space Y* to Y.Here T* denotes the dual (adjoint) operator to T. 0
The adjoint representation: Ad = AdT in the space L(Y)-all linear transformations on Y, or its subspaces, Ad,(A) = Ti'AT,, A E L(Y). Space L(Y) is naturally identified with the tensor product of Y 8 Y' (Y by its dual Y'), where tensor (@e+"rank-one operator (el ...)?. Then one can show that AdT= T@F - tensor product of T and its contragredient. A natural example of Ad is the action of GL, by conjugations on the space of all matrices, g:A+g-'Ag; g E GL,, A E Mat,,. More generally, the adjoint action appears in the context of Lie groups acting on their Lie algebras, and will be explained in 81.4. 0
-Tensor product of 2 vector spaces W = Y,@ Yz is spanned by linear combinations of {( 8 q:( E Yl;q E Y2}, subject to the natural bilinear rules: elemental products ( ( + q ) 8 ( = < @ ( + q @ { , and similarly for ( @ ( q + ( ) . The easiest way to think of W is in terms of function-spaces: Y,N e ( X ) , Y2 N e ( Y ) (for finite-D spaces Y,sets X and Y are finite!). Then W is also a function-space e ( X x Y ) , where elemental tensors {( 8 q ) correspond t o product-functions {<(z)q(y)). Such correspondence extends to some infinite function-spaces, e.g. L 2 ( X )8 P ( Y ) u Z2(X x Y ) .
35
51.2. Regular and induced representation
Problems and Exercises: 1. Show that the fractional-linear action (2.12) of group G = SL,(R) on the Poincare, and that d p is the Lobachevski half-plane H leaves measure dp = ~ - ~ d z d yinvariant only G-invariant measure of H. 2. Show that the regular representation of G = R" (1")is strongly continuous on various function spaces over R" (1"): (i) (ii)
e, = {all continuous functions vanishing at co} with
norm 11 f 11 = ma4 f(z)I;
e r = {m-times
continuously differentiable functions, vanishing a t co), with norm IIfIIm= C la1 <mmazl'of(z)I; (iii) C F = Q with a sequence of seminorms (11 f m=O; 1; ...)
er;
Ilm:
(iv) Lebesgue Lp-spaces, 1 5 p
< 00, with l l f l l p = (llf(z)rd~)'/~.
Hint: Verify continuity of the map a + R , f , for compactly supported functions f in e, or (uniform continuity!), then utilize the standard functional analysis: density of compactly supported f ' s in e,, and LP, and the uniform boundedness of the family of translations { R,: Q E R"}, R , = I!
er
1 1
The above argument applies t o other groups G and homogeneous spaces X, and their regular representations R on e ( X ) ;Zp(X), etc. as long as transformations g: z+zg, are continuous and measure preserving, i.e. X has a G-invariant Haar measure. (v) The regular representation R on G or X = H\G is not uniformly continuous, as
1 R , - 111= 2, for all g in the vicinity of {e}.
3. Check that any cocycle a ( z ; g ) defines a representation T = T f fvia formula (2.8). Show that the product, a@, and a power 19of cocycles, are also cocycles, hence T" of (2.14) is also a representation. 4. A cocycle (I is trivial, if a(z,g)= @(z8) for some function p(x).
4.)
(i) Show that cocycles (2.11) and (2.13) are nontrivial. (ii) A trivial cocycle yields a Haar measure on X. Thus in both examples (affine and SL,) the quotient H \ G has no Haar measure.
5. Show that the Haar measure on a semidirect product G = H D K, with compact group K (e.g. Euclidian motions En = R" D Sqn)), is equal t o dg = dhdk - the product of Haar measures (Hint: Haar measure is invariant under any compact group of automorphisms).
6. Show that the Haar measure on SL,(R) = {g = (5
!) detg = l},
Use the Haar measure on GL, = SL, x R', write any g E GL,
is given by
as
and compute the Jacobian a(a; b; c; d ) y; 2;A)
' ( 2 ;
=I
I
Xz'
.'7 Show that the Haar measure on SL,(R) parametrized by its entries (excluding zll!)) is equal t o
d
g
=
1
{g
= (zjk):j + t > 2
36
51.2. Regular and induced representation where M , , denotes the 1,l-minor of g. Formulae of problems 5-6 look elegant, but found little practical use in harmonic analysis on SL,. The latter exploits a different set of coordinate, based on certain factorizations of SL, (Cartan, Iwasawa), described in chapter 7.
8. a ) Find the left and right Haar measures on the atline group G = {az and compute the modular factor: A(a; b) = l/a.
+ b } over R, or C,
b) Do the same problem for the Bore1 group of all upper-triangular matrices
9. Show that formula (2.10) defines a representation T of G. The induced representation is continuous/unitary, provided u is continuous/unitary and X has a G-invariant measure. Another simple (functorial) property of ind, ind(ul @ u z )= ind(ul) @ ind(u2).
10. Consider convolutions on the unit circle G = 1, 2rr
~ , p=] f * h = J f ( t - e) q e ) de, on L2-space ( h E L*), and show
0
i) L'-functions f yield compact operators R , ii) L2-functions f yield Hilbert-Schmidt operators R , iii) Cm-smooth functions (rn 2 2) yield trace-class operators. Hint: use Fourier expansion of f = C a m e i m t ; and some basic facts of Fourier analysis on 1: (a) f E L'*{a,}-O, as k-m; ( b ) f E L 2 e { a , } E e2; and (c) f e e m 3 a, = O(k-m), as k-m. We remind the reader that compactness for diagonalizable (self-adjoint) operators means Hilberl-Schmidt means C I A, I < 00, and trace-class is that their eigenvalues A,+O, equivalent to C I A, I < 00 (see Appendix B). 11. Show that convolutions f * h with f E em on groups R", T", take any LP-space back into Cm (interchange integration J ...d y , and differentiation 8:). The same argument works on any Lie group and its homogeneous spaces, when integration and differentiation are G-invariant!
$1.3. Irreducibility and decomposition
37
51.3. Irreducibility and decoinp~tion. Section 1.3 studies irreducibility and decomposition of representations. We establish basic irreducibility tests: Schur’s Lemma and Burnside’s Theorem, discuss direct sum/integral decompositions, equivalence, intertwining spaces, and outline some basic problems of the representation theory.
3.1. Irreducibility. One of the main goals in the representation theory is to
analyze the structure of any representation T in terms of its simple constituents, called
irreducible representations. In this section we shall discuss some general features of irreducibility and decomposition.
A representations T of grouplalgebra in space Y is called irreducible, if operators { T g }have no joint nontrivial invariant s~bspaces’~:Y~ c Y; T , I Yo c Yo, for all g E G,+ Yo = {0} or Y. An
invariant subspace Y 0 c Y reduces
T , so one can talk about a
subrepresentation (restriction) T“ = T I Yo, and the factor-representations on the quotient-spaces Y/Yo.Irreducible representations play the role of elementary building blocks, in the decomposition of an arbitrary T . In this respect they resemble eigenvalues of linear operators, or characters (joint eigenvalues) of commuting families of operators. Two general results provide useful irreducibility tests: Schur ’s Lemma and Bumside (von Neumann) Theorem. Each has a purely “algebraic” (finite-dimensional) version, and a “topological” (unitary) version. Since the arguments are very similar in both cases, we shall discuss them in parallel. Given a representation T , we introduce its
commutator algebra:
Com(T)={A:AT, = T,A, for all g E G} - all operators that commute with T . Schur’s Lemma: (i) An irreducible finite-D representation T in complex space Y has scalar commutator algebra, Com(T)= {XI}. (ii) A unitary representation T is irreducible, iff Com(T) is scalar.
Proof: (i) If Com(T) has a nonscalar operator Q, then any (nontrivial) of Q, is obviously invariant under T , which means
eigensubspace E , = {(:Qt = A(} reducibility.
(ii) The unitary version requires some basic facts of the spectral theory of unitary and selfadjoint operators, described in Appendix A. Let us remark that algebra -In the topological context (Banach/Hilbert spaces subspaces {Yo}.
Y) one usually considers closed invariant
81.3. Irreducibility and decomposition
38
Com(T) is closed under conjugation Q+Q* (adjoint operator to Q ) . So a nontrivial algebra Com(T)# {XI} has a nonscalar selfadjoint operator Q. The role of the eigenspaces in part (i) will be played now by the spectral
subspaces15 {E(A)} of Q. Each subspace E ( A ) is known to be invariant under the commutator algebra of Q , since the corresponding spectral projections { P ( A ) } are approximated by “functions (polynomials) of Q . The argument is easily completed now. A nontrivial Q = Q* in Com(T) would yield a nontrivial T-invariant spectral subspace E(A). So irreducibility of T implies Com(T) = {XI}. Conversely, if T has an invariant subspace Yo, then the orthogonal projection P: T-+Y,,
gives a nonscalar
element of Com(T),QED. Let us remark that for general (nonunitary) T , Schur’s Lemma gives only a necessary condition of irreducibility. It is easy to find examples of reducible T with scalar commutator, for instance, all upper-triangular matrices in Cn (problem 3). An immediate corollary of Schur’s Lemma is Corollary: A n irreducible finite-D or unitary representation of a commutative
group/algebra is one-dimensional,
T, = x ( g ) - a character of G.
Remark: There is a version of Schur’s Lemma for representations in real spaces Y. Here irreducibility of T does not always imply Com(T) to be scalar. But the commutator algebra must contain nonsingular matrices only, hence it makes a division
algebra. There are only 3 such beasts: reals W (the corresponding T a r e called real-type); complex numbers 43 (complez-type T), and quaternions Q (puaternionic-type T). All 3 cases can be characterized in terms of complexification of T , i.e. the family of operators {TC(E+iq)= T[+i(Tq):(,qE V}. Then “real type” yields an irreducible representation TC= T @ C; “complex-type” - a pair of inequivalent (conjugate) representations: TCN T I @ T while quaternionic-type results in a pair of equivalent representations:
TCN T $ T . A simple illustration of this statement is given by 3 algebras, Iw;C;$, themselves, of a selfadjoint operator Q in Hilbert space 36, consists of { A E R: so that (AZ-Q) is not boundedly invertible). Spec(Q) is always a c l w d subset of R, and operators with 1-pointed spectrum, spec(&) = {A), are known t o be scalar, Q = XI. Furthermore, any closed subset A C R has an associated spectral subspace E ( A ) and the corresponding spectral projection, P ( A ) : 36-+E(A).Spaces { E ( A ) }are invariant under Q, and have spec(Q I E ( A ) )c A n Z . For operators with discrete spectrum { A k } , space E ( A ) = @ E(Aj),consists of all eigensubspaces with A j E A . An easy way to obtain { E ( A ) ) is to use the canonical model of a selfadjoint operator Q,namely, a multiplication: f(A)-,Af(A), on the space of square-integrable (scalar or vector) functions on C = spec(&), f E Z*(Z;dp). Then E ( A ) consists of all L2-functions vanishing outside A (see Appendix A). -Spectrum
$1.3. Irreducibility and decomposition when realized by matrices (problem ll),
R = { [ a ] ; a E W}; 43 =
{;[
] a , b E R}; and
Q=
39
{b
: ] u , b E C}.
Burnside (von Neumann) Theorem: (i) A finite-D representation T in space
(3.1)
Y is
irreducible if and only if t he algebra A = A(T), spanned by T, coincides with the full operator/matriz algebra L(Y) N Matd, where d = d ( T ) = d i m Y , called the degree of T. (ii) A unitary (infinite-D) representation T in Hilbert space 36 is irreducible, i f and only af the closure of A ( T ) in the weak operator topology16 coincides with the algebra of all bounded operators %&).
Sufficiency follows from the irreducibility of the full matrix/operator algebra Mat,/%(%). The proof of necessity: “irreducibility” ==+ ‘@ll-operator algebra”, exploits a
L‘bootstrap’’argument (see problems 7,8). In the m-D case one could not expect the purely algebraic (Burnside’s) version of the Theorem to hold, as there are many transitive operator-algebras, different from %(%), like all finite-rank operators 5,or compact operators R in 36. But the weak (operator) closure of both coincides with
%(36)! A Theorem of von Neumann extends the algebraic result to symmetric transitive subalgebras A c %(%), by combining LLbootstrap”with some standard functional analysis, to show that A must be weakly dense in ’3(36).
3.2. Decomposition. If a finite-D representation T on space 36 is reducible, one X0,so that T I Mo becomes irreducible.
can always find a minimal invariant subspace
Hence, any such representation can be brought into a ‘quasi-triangular form” with irreducible diagonal blocks. But for unitary T each invariant subspace 36, has also an Tinvariant orthogonal complement 36, = 36 8 Xo. Therefore, quasi-triangular reduction for unitary T amounts to LLquasi-digonalizationnor complete decomposition. Proposition 1: A finite-dimensional unitary representation can be decomposed into
the direct orthogonal s u m of irreducible components: T = 9 Ti, i.e. 36 = @ Mi3 3 direct s u m of invariant subspaces, and T3 = T I Xj. In other words a unitary finite-D representation is completely reducible. Thus irreducible representations provide the “building blocks” of which any T is made. In this sense Proposition 1 extends the well-known diagonalization of a unitary/self-adjoint
16Weakly dense algebra A means that any operator B E %(%) can be approximated by r) E %}, equivalently, by all traceoperators { A E A } , relative to a sequence of seminorms { ( A t I r)):t, class operators K , identified with functionals on %(%), via the natural pairing K : A-.tr(KA). In other words the distance between operators { A ; B } is measured by n-tuples of vectors {ti;qi: 1 5 j 5 m}, or trace-class operators { K } : { ( ( A- B ) t j I qi)} or {tr K ( A - B ) } .
51.3. irreducibility and decomposition
40
operator (Appendix A). There exists a continuous version of Proposition 1, called the direct integral decomposition of a unitary representation in m-D case. We briefly introduced it in the previous section and will discussed later in 56.1. Let us remark that the decomposition of Proposition 1 is not unique in general, due to possible multiplicities of irreducible components of T , the same way as multiple eigenvectors of a matrix are not unique. We shall describe a canonical (unique!) decomposition of T into the direct sum of multiples of irreducibles, ?r@m,where m rn(?r;T)denotes the multiplicity of
?r
in
T.
Theorem 2 (primary decomposition): A unitary finite-D representation T in space 36 is uniquely decomposed into the direct sum of multiples of irreducible
representations, i.e. % = @36, - direct sum of invariant subspaces, so that k T/%, N x k @ mk - a multiple of an irreducible ?rk, and
(3.2) with mk = m ( x k ; T )- multiplicity of 'a in T . Multiples of irreducibles Irk}are often called primary components of T , spaces { % k } are primary subspaces, and
(3.2) is referred to as a primary decomposition of T .
The main difference between Theorem 2 and Proposition 1 is that the primary subspaces Xj = %(d) are uniquely determined, whereas within each Nj there are many ways to break T
I Xj into the sum of irreducibles. So the primary subspaces represent
noncommutative analog of the eigenspaces of a linear operator. There are different ways to establish the primary decomposition. Some depend on specific structures of groups in question. For instance, for finite and compact groups G (3.2) could be derived via irreducible characters of G and the associated primary projections (see
chapters 3-5). Another method is based on central projections of the commutator algebra
Com(T). Here we shall exploits matrix entries of T: given a pair of vectors ( , q E 36, we def ( 9 ) = (Tg( I q ) defines a function on G. For each vector ( E 36
define the matrix entry t
€v
we introduce a cyclic subspace, Y (() = Span{Tg(: g E G}. Obviously, under T. Any vector q E 36 defines a linear map,
Y(() is invariant
9:, (-+(Tg(I q ) , that takes V(() into a
subspace '3 of functions on G (matrix-entries), invariant under right translations, f ( z g ) E GJ, for any f E '3. In fact, Qq intertwines the subrepresentation T regular representation R 1'3,
RgQq = QqTg,for all g E G.
I Y(()
and the
a
51.3. Irreducibility and decomposition
41
This shows, in particular, that any irreducible T can be embedded into the regular representation on a suitable function space. We say that vector (E 36 transforms according t o an irreducible
A,
if all matrix-entries { t
span T ( A ) of matrix-entries of
A,
(2): r)
€r)
a R-invariant subspace of L(G). An equivalent
statement: all irreducible constituents of T I Y(() are copies of claim that T I 36(()
E 36) belong to the linear
T , 80
T I Y(() u T 8 rn. We
u A has multiplicity 1. Indeed, by Schur’s Lemma one can show that
the only cyclic subrepresentations of
S = A 8 m are copies of
A.
Now we are able to
identify primary subspaces { % ( A ) } of Theorem 2: % ( A ) = {( E 36: transformed according T}.
Spaces % ( A ) are obviously T-invariant, their intersection % ( T ) ~ ) % ( A ’ ) = 0, if
# A‘,
and their sum, @ % ( A ) , spans 36. Thus we get a unique (canonical!) primary
to 7r
decomposition of T, QED.
Proposition 1 and Theorem 2 naturally lead to the following problems:
(I) Construct and classify all irreducible representations of the group/algebra G. (11) Decompose the given representation (regular, tensor-product, etc.) into the sum/integral of irreducibles. These are indeed two basic questions in representation theory, that will be addressed at length in chapters 3-7. We shall construct, classify and analyze irreducible representations for many different classes of groups: 0
finite and general compact groups (chapter 3);
0
classical compact Lie groups S q 3 ) ;Sl.42) (chapter 4), as well as their higher-D
analogs: SU(n);S q n ) ,... (chapter 5); 0
semidirect products, including the Heisenberg group:
W,
N
R D Cn, the
Euclidian motion groups: E I , = R” D S q n ) , and affine groups (chapter 6); 0
the celebrated SL, in its various incarnations: conformal SU(1; 1); Lorentz
Sql;2) and S q l ;3), and also the Poincare group: P,
N
R4D S q 1 ; 3 ) in chapter 7.
Once the list of irreducible components of G is found (usually denoted by
G,and
called the dual object of G ) , one can turn to the decomposition Problem (11) for specific classes of representations. The most interesting examples include regular and induced
representation R on G , or homogeneous spaces X = H\G. We shall see that in the compact case ( X or G), the decomposition is always “discrete”,
-l F CB
C 3 m ( T ) - direct sum of irreducibles.
For non-compact groups/spaces the decomposition is typically “continuous”
51.3.Irreducibility and decomposition
42 (direct integral),
or more generally a combination of the "discrete" and the "continuous" parts, as is the
case with SL,(W) (chapter 7). The resulting measure dp on G (whether discrete or continuous) is called the Plancherel measure of R. It will be one of principal objects of our study. The classification problem could easily become "unmanageable", if one insists on "all irreducible representations" of G, since any T can be deformed in infinitely many ways by conjugations with invertible operators,
Q : T ~ +T$ = Q - ~ T ~ Q . Such deformations, T-T', however, retain many essential features of T (e.g. spectrum), and could be regarded trivial. Thus we are lead to the notion of equivalence: a pair of representations, T and S in spaces 36 and W , are called equivalent, if they are conjugated (intertwined)by an invertible linear map Q: %+W,
The space of all intertwining operators is denoted by Int(T;S), its dimension (if finite) is called an intertwining (branching) number m(T;S).Operators that intertwine T with itself form the commutator algebra of T , I n t ( T ; T )= Com(T), and other spaces Int(S;T ) acquire the structure of {Com(T);Com(S)}- bimodule, i.e. Com(T) acts on Int(S;T )by the left multiplication while Com(S)by the right one. Problem (I) usually refers to classification of equivalence classes of irreducible representations, rather than individual {T's}. In some cases, however, equivalent representations T and S may be given in different realizations. Then one is interested in specific intertwining operators that implement the equivalence. Let us mention yet another useful application of Schur's Lemma. Proposition 3: For any pair of irreducible representations T and S, space Int(T;S ) is either 1-D,if T and S are equivalent, or (0). So the intertwining number m(T;S ) = 1 or 0. Indeed, for any
Q E Znt(T;S), its range %(Q)and kernel N(Q) are invariant subspaces
of S and 7'. So space Znt of an irreducible finite-D pair ( T; S ) consists of invertible operators Q. But QIQ;'ECom(S)
for any pair Q I Q z in Znl(T;S), so by Schur's
51.3. Irreducibility and decomposition
43
Lemma, QIQ;’ = XI, i.e. Q1 = XQ2. The unitary version requires a slight modification. We observe that two spaces Znt(T;S) and Znt(S;T)are naturally conjugate one to the other by taking the adjoint Q-Q*. X-’/*Q
By Schur’s Lemma Q*Q= XI, hence operator
is unitary and invertible, and the rest of the argument proceeds as above.
Our final result in this section gives irreducible unitary representations of the direct product group G = H x K in terms of its factors.
Theorem 4 Each irreducible representation
of G = H x K is decomposed into
?r
the tensor productl’l of two irreducible representations of H and K ,
?r
= u @ 7,
where u E 8, 7 E I?. Conversely, the product of two irreducibles u E and 7 E k , is an irreducible representation of G, T = u @ , ~G. E So the dual object of G = H x I( also factors into the product, A
1Proof:The second statement follows directly from the Burnside’s Theorem and the known facts of multilinear algebra about tensor-products of operator/matrix algebras (problem
1%
Mat,, 8 Matm N Mat,,;
(3.3)
or in terms of operator algebras
%(X)8 %(Y)
2: %(36
T o prove the first statement we take an irreducible first factor
A
8 r). A
(3.4)
E G in space 36, restrict it on the
I H, and write the primary decomposition of Theorem 2, r1HN
$Uk@mk; k
where ak E if, and mk- the multiplicity of uk in
A
IH.
so the representation space
36 N $36, - direct sum of primary subpaces of H. Since each 36, is invariant under the k
commutator Com(r I H), hence under K , it follows that 36 has only one primary component, 36 N Kk,and
A
I H N u 8 I,,,.
In other words, space 36 is a direct sum of { m }
copies of the “irreducible space” V of u,
36 N Y a3 ...$ Y N Y 8 cm.
x
Any operator A in 36 can be represented by a block-matrix A = (aij), aij E Mat(Yi;‘Tj). We are interested in operators A E Corn(* I H). By Proposition 3 all “matrix entries” {aij) of such A must be scalars: aij = yijZ; yijE C. When restricted on subgroup K,
matrices (yij(k)) clearly yield a representation of K. So space 36 is decomposed into the product
Y 8 C d , as well as operators {rg), g = (h;k) E G, rg = u,, 8 rk. Obviously, for A
17The reader should not confuse the tensor product u 8 y of Theorem 4 with the Kronecker product of 51.2. The latter is obtained, when the tensor product u@y of the product-group G x G is restricted on the diagonal subgroup ( ( 9 ;g)) N G C G x G .
51.3. Irreducibility and decomposition
44
t o be irreducible, y must also be irreducible, which completes the proof!
Problems and Exercises. GL, and u(n) on C" are irreducible.
1. Show that the natural actions of
2. Show that an eigenspace E A or a root subspace ET = {<: (T-Al)m( = 0) of a matrix T in C" are invariant under C o m ( T ) .
3. Show: the group B , of all upper/lower triangular matrices in R"; C" has trivial (scalar) commutator, though B, is clearly reducible (This exercise shows Schur's Lemma t o provide only a necessary condition for general non-unitary representations!).
X = {1,2, ...n} induces the regular representation R on the function-space: e ( X ) N C", R , f ( j ) = f( j ' ) .
4. A symmetric group W, (permutations of n objects) acting on
(i) Show that e ( X ) is the sum of two invariant subspaces: f(j ) = 0). constant function fo( j ) = 1, and 36, = 32f:
C
X0 = {Afo} - spanned by the
(ii) Show that subrepresentations ro = R 1 360-trivial, and r1 = R I M1-irreducible (Use Schur's Lemma for rl, represent any operator Q on e ( X ) by a kernel/matrix [ q j k ] ,
QfW =
qjkfk).
5*.(i) Show that the adjoint representation Ad,(A) = g-'Ag, of the group G = SL, on the space of all traceless matrices: Jb, = { A E Mat,,: t r A = 0) is irreducible (Hint: any Q E C o m ( A d ) is uniquely determined by its.values on the subspace '3 C A, of diagonal matrices, moreover Q:P+P, commutes with the natural action of W, on 9. Use problem 3!).
r''..]
(ii) Prove the same result for the special unitary group SU(n).
6. Show that a pair of matrices: A =
)t n
(diagonal), B =[1
1) (cyclic
permutation), generate the full matrix algebra in C", provided all {Aj} are different.
7. Let A be an operator-algebra in space Y, vector ( E Y. We denote by ) =I(() the annihilator of in A, ) = { A : A< = 0) - a left ideal A, ( A ) C I), and by Yo = Yo(<) - a cyclic subspace of (, Yo = {A<: A E A).
<
(i) Show that Yo is A-invariant, and the restriction of A on Yo is equivalent t o the regular representation of A on factor-space A / ) , R,(B) = A E ( m o d 8). (ii) If )(<) c )(9), then there exists a linear map Q: Yo(<)+Yo(q), that intertwines two representations of A on Yo(() and Yo(q). (Set: Q [ A < ]= A?, for all A E -4, and check that Q is well defined!).
8. Prove the Burnside's Theorem by the "bootstrap argument", as outlined below. It is convenient t o use the following terminology an operator-algebra A is transitive (irreducible!), if for any vectors ( # 0 and q there exists A E A, that takes A: <+q; algebra A is double-transitive, if for any pair (t1;t2) of linearly independent vectors and any pair (q1;q2) there exists A E A, so that At l = q l , A t Z = q2. Similarly, a k-transitive A takes any linearly independent k-tuple k-tuple (ql; ...qk), i.e. A t i = q3., j = 1; .A.
(F1;...(k) into any
81.3. Irreducibility and decomposition
45
Clearly, a n-transitive algebra in n-space coincides with the full matrix algebra! The idea of ”bootstrap” is to show that “ t r a n s i t i v i t y ” ~“2-lransilivity”* transitivity“.
...“k-
Step 1’: Show “transitivej2-transitive”. For any vector [ E Y denote by 3 = I ( [ ) the annihilalor of 5 in A (problem 6). Given an operator-algebra A and a left ideal 1, consider 1-cyclic subspaces Yo = Yo(q) = {Bv: BE 7 E Y. Each of them is A-invariant, A) c ). So for transitive (irreducible) A, each space Yo must be either 0 or the entire Y.
a},
Pick a linearly independent pair (tl;t2), and consider the ideal ) = )(tl) of t1,and the C )-cyclic subspace, Yo = Y0(t2). Use problem 6 to show: if Yo = {0}, i.e. extends to an intertwining operator Q E Com(A), impossible for then map Q: irreducible A (Schur’s Lemma)! Conclude, that Yo = Y,i.e. for any q E Y there exists A E A, Show that the latter implies double-transitivity of A.
50
that Atl = 0, A t 2 = q.
Step 2”. Demonstrate in a similar fashion that “k-transitive*(k+l)-transitive”, completes the argument of Burnside’s Theorem.
and
The same “bootstrap” applies to transitive algebras A in (oo-D) Hilbert spaces, to show that A is k-transitive for all k! Then fairly standard functional analysis implies that A is weakly closed in %(36) (von Neumann). 9.
Prove: (i) the commutator algebra of a primary representation T N ~ 8 m , Com(T) N Mat,,,, and any Q E Com(T) factors into the product I, 8 Q ,in the tensorproduct decomposition of space YT N Y, 8 Cm (rn = multiplicity of A in T!). (ii) If representation T N A’ 8 mj - is completely reducible (direct sum of primary components), then the algeura spanned by T,A ( T )N @ Matd , @ I m( .d j = d e g d ; m3. = multiplicity of A’ in T), while the commutator algebja
’
Com(T)
2:
e,3 I d j 8 Mat,
’
..
1
(iii) The intertwining number of a pair of representations m(T;S) is defined as d i m I n t ( T ; S ) .Show, if T N @ ~ @ m ( r ; Tand ) , S2: @ n 8 m ( n ; S ) then ,
10. Show that the tensor product of matdx/operator algebras is equivalent to the full matrix algebra on the tensor-product space: Mat, 8 Mat,,, u Mat,. ,,,; and %(X) 8 %(Y) N %(36 8 Y) (Use rank-one operators and vectors). 11. Check formulae (3.1) for C and Q in terms of real/complex matrices. Show that complexification of C yields the direct sum of two conjugate representations: z + ( z ; 5 ), z E C; while complexified Q yields two copies of Q itself.
$1.4. Lie groups and algebras; The infinitesimal method
46
$1.4. Lie groups and algebras; The infinitesimal method. Here we shall introduce two principal players in the Lie theory: Lie algebras and Lie groups. Although different in appearance both are intimately linked through the ezponential map, and its inverse log. Two maps allow to express the local group structure (multiplication) through the Lie bracket (Campbell-Hausdorff formula). We discuss the basic classes of Lie algebras: solvable; nilpotent; simple, semisimple, and state the decompition result (Levi-Malcev). The section is concluded with an infinitesimal method, that allows to reduce group representations to those of its Lie algebra, and thus provides a powerful tool in their analysis.
4.1. Lie groups and Lie algebras. We remind the reader that Lie groups are
smooth manifolds G with differential, (sometimes analytic, or algebraic) group structure. This means that the group operations: ( ~ , y ) + z y and z-u-’, are differentiable (analytic or algebraic). The most common examples of Lie groups are subgroups of matrices, G c Mat,,, like the general and special linear groups: GL,, and SL,; orthogonal, unitary, symplectic, and other groups described in 51.1. Let us remark, however, that not all Lie groups can be realized by finite-D matrices. One such example is a simply connected cower of Sf,, G = SL, (examples in 4.2 below). The class of Lie groups admits all natural operations, performed with groups in general, like taking closed subgroups, factor-groups, direct and semidirect products, etc. All those result in new Lie groups. N
Lie algebras can be viewed as “linearizations” of Lie groups, although formal definition does not allude to an underlying group structure. Formally, Lie algebra 0 is defined as a vector space equipped with the Lie bracket (product) [X;Y], a bilinear map 0 x 0 + 0, that satisfies: (i) skew symmetry: [X;Y] = - [Y;X] for all X,Y.
(ii)Jacobi identity: [X;[Y;Z]] + [Y;[Z;X]] + [Z;[X,Y]]= 0, for all triples X, Y,Z. We can rephrase (i-ii) is in terms of the so called adjoint action of Lie algebra on itself, adx(Y) = [X;Y]; adX:@+@. Then, (i) adX(Y) =
.-
ady(X), for all X, Y
(ii)adlX;yl = [ad,; ady] = adxady - adyadx,
(4.1)
51.4. Lie groups and algebras; The infinitesimal method
47
In particular, the Jacobi identity means that map, X+ad,, is a representation of the Lie algebra 6 by linear transformations over (5. It can also be written as ad,[Y;Z] = [adx(Y);Z] -t- [Y; adx(Z)], for all Y,Z, (4.2) which means that operators {adx} are derivations of the Lie algebra. The examples of Lie algebras are abundant. Any associative algebra (e.g. matriz/operator algebra Mat,) turns into the Lie algebra with respect to the commutator bracket: [x,y ] = xy - yx. Considered as a Lie algebra it is usually denoted A n ) . a
Any vector space A with the trivial bracket, [x;y]= 0, gives a commutative Lie
algebra.
*Important examples of Lie algebras are given by vector fields on a manifold {X=Cui(x)aj} (in local coordinates { x l ;...z,}), with the standard Lie bracket of vector fields, [X;Y] = X Y - Y X =
x ( x u j i 3 j b j - b j a j a i ) a i = C ( a x [ b i ] - d y [ a j ] ) a i ; (4.3) i
i
j
Here aX;ay denote directional (Lie) derivatives along fields X,Y. Those include the algebra 9(A)of all vector fields on A, or its subalgebras of fields, preserving certain structures on A: volume, symplectic (chapter 8), etc. Many examples arise as Lie subalgebras of Mat,, and will be examined below. There is a close relationship between Lie groups and algebras.
Theorem 1: (i) Any Lie group G has an associated Lie algebra (5, which consists of infinitesimal generators of all one-parameter subgroups of G. (ii) Conversely, given a Lie algebra with algebra (5.
(5
one can construct a ‘’local” Lie group18 G
(iii) A local Lie group can be extended to a global group in many different ways. Namely, there exists a unique simply-connected extension G, and any other Lie group G with Lie algebra (5 is isomorphic to a factor-group G/r, G modulo a discrete subgroup of the center
r c Z(G).
Theorem 1 summarizes the basic facts of the Lie theory. We shall not provide complete details of the proof, but rather demonstrate different statements in several 18By local Lie group we mean an open neighborhood of the identity {e} in a Lie group, i.e. a manifold, where the group operations: z.y, and z-*,are defined only locally.
$1.4. Lie groups and algebras; The infinitesimal method
48
important cases. The easiest case to consider are matriz groups and algebras, i.e. subgroups and subalgebras of Mat,. We shall start with infinitesimal generators. It is well known that any (continuous) one-parameter subgroup { U , } of Mat, is generated by a matrix A, in the sense that
U , = etA; where A = dt Such A is naturally to call a generator of subgroup of Mat,.
Lo.
(4.4)
{U,}.Let now G be a closed (Lie)
Proposition 2: (i) The set of infinitesimal generators { A } of G coincides with the
tangent space Te(G)at the identity.
(ii) The commutator of two generator A , B E Te(G) is also a generator, [A;B ] E Te(G),so tangent space forms a Lie subalgebra (5 c Mat,. Proof: (i) Obviously, generators {A} C T,, and the latter forms a subspace of Mat,. To show that {A} is a subspace in T, we pick two subgroups of G { U , = etA], {V, = efB}, generated by A , B E T, according to (4.4), then a subgroup generated by A
+ B, can be
approximated by an “amalgamation” of U , V,
= hence { e t ( A t B ) }
liyi(ezp(;A)ezp(;B))n,
(4.5)
(I G (problem 2). So A+B E T,, and clearly XA E T, for any scalar A.
Conversely, if matrix A is tangent to G, i.e. tangent t o a curve g ( t ) c G, A = g’(O), then we can easily construct a I-parameter subgroup tangent to A, by setting,
u, = g~&(t/4)n.
(4.6)
The generator of U , is A (problem 2), thus we show that generators {A} span the entire space T,! (ii) It suffices to exhibit [ A ; B ]as a tangent vector of some curve in G. Once again we take a pair of subgroups U t = e t A , V, = e t B , and consider the group commutator g ( t ) = cI;’V;’U,V,.
Expanding U and V in the Taylor series, multiplying and collecting
terms we get g(t) = I
+ t2[A;B ] + fl (t3).
Neglecting the cubic and higher order terms the commutator becomes the tangent vector a t { e = I},
[ A ; B ]= lim t-+O
g(,) - I ; QED. t2
We have shown that the Lie algebra of a matrix group G can be identified with the “set of infinitesimal generators’’ = “tangent space of G at { e } ” . A similar description
51.4. Lie groups and algebras; The infinitesimal method
49
could be given for all (non-matrix) Lie groups, namely 6 N T,(G). Lie algebra 6 can also be characterized, as the set (subalgebra) of left/right invariant vector fields on G. Group G acts on itself by left/right translations g: z+g-lz left/right invariant vector fields, {X =Caj(z)aj
- in
(or 2-zg),
gives rise to
local coordinates (zl;...z,) on G}.
Lefl-invariance of X means that the transformed field”:
XO(z)
= g‘[X]og-’
= X,
where g’ denotes the Jacobian map of the left translate g: z+gz. Left-invariant vector fields form a subalgebra
(s
in the algebra of all vector fields 9(G)with the Lie bracket
X can be identified with its value at { e } , a tangent for any point g E G. So 19 N T,2: {left/right invariant fields
(4.3). Any left-invariant vector field
vector
t E T,,X(g)
= g’[(],
on g}.
4.2. The exp and log maps. The correspondence between Lie groups and Lie
algebras is given by two maps: exponential and tog, exp: 6+G; log: G+@.
Map exp: 6 NT,+G, sends a tangent vector/line { t t } into a one-parameter subgroup { e x p t t } of G, tangent to
<
at {e}20. Map d(<)=exp(t)
is a local
4;
= I!), and its inverse is called log. So exp takes a neighborhood of {0} in 6 onto a neighborhood of identity { e } in G, while log does vice diffeomorphism (since its Jacobian
versa. The easiest way to introduce exp and log is for matrix groups and algebras. Here two maps are given by their Taylor-expansions,
Exponential map on the full matrix algebra Mat,, = gl,, takes it onto the full linear
group
GL, = { z E Mat,,:
det(z) # 0).
Clearly, exp on
is a local
Mat,
diffeomorphism (near X = 0), but globally it may not be 1-1. For instance, all complex matrices { X } with purely imaginary integer eigenvalues {Aj = 27rim}, are taken to the identity by exp. We shall list now a few basic and familiar properties of exp and log. W -e remind the reader that a diffeomorphism (coordinate change) y = 4(z) on a manifold transforms vector field X = C a .a. into a field Y = X4 = (#[XI)o d-’, with components J Z bi = C4:jaj, where 4’ denotes a Jacobian (matrix) of 6. 20Such notion of exp arises in differential geometry and is closely connected with geodesics and parallel transport (Appendix C). On Lie groups the parallel transport is furnished by the left/right group multiplication, z-g-lz, g E G. The latter gives rise a notion of parallel field (along a curve ~ ( t ) )the , geodesic path y (whose tangent field y‘(t) is parallel), and exp:t< E Ta-y (t) - a geodesic initiated at {a} in the direction (!
<
51.4. Lie groups and algebras; The infinitesimal method
50
Lemma 3 (i) If matrices A and B commute, AB = BA, then particular {e"A}t is a one-parameter subgroup of Mat,.
= eAeB, in
(ii) det(eA) = elrA. (iii) exp preserues complez conjugation, transposition and taking adjoint matriz: exp(2) = 3, exp(=A)= TexpA; exp(A*) = (expA)*.
The proof is fairly straightforward (problem 1). Using Lemma 3 we are able to characterize Lie algebras of many classical Lie groups (orthogonal, unitary, symplectic, etc.), listed in $1.1. For instance, the expmap takes a Lie algebra of n x n hermitian antisymmetric matrices, denoted u(n), or real antisymmetric matrices, denoted o(n), into the unitary and orthogonal groups: U(n) and q n ) . Special (traceless) Lie algebras { X :trX = 0) are taken into special { detg = 1) Lie groups, like 0
d ( n )= {A:trA = 0) (all traceless matrices) goes into SL,
0
so(.)
0
su(n) = {A* = - A; t r A = 0 ) (unitary traceless) goes into SU(n).
= {TA = - A; tr A = 0 ) (orthogonal traceless) goes into S q n )
In fact, in all cases the exp map is locally onto, since by Lemma 3 generators of groups SL,; U(n); q n ) , etc., must traceless, unitary, orthogonal. We have already shown that Lie algebras are obtained as tangent spaces at {e} of Lie groups G, or as infinitesimal generators of one-parameter subgroups of G. Going in the opposite direction one would like to construct Lie group G, starting from Lie algebra (5. As we stated earlier (Theorem 1) the correspondence C k G is not 1-1, as many Lie groups could have the same Lie algebra. Although all such groups are locally isomorphic, their global structure may be different. The local group-structure, however, is completely determined by the Lie algebra formula bracket, via the so called Campbell-Haudorff-Dynkin
Here the inner sum extends over all tuples of integers { p l , q l ;... p,,q,) with the property: pj+qi 1 1, and [AP1[Bql ...Bqm]] denotes the iterated commutator [A[A...[B...[B...]]]]. The Campbell-Hausdorff series can be shown to converge for all Lie algebra elements (matrices) of norm 11 Alk llBll< and thus defines a local group
a,
31.4. Lie groups and algebras; The infinitesimal method
51
structure in a neighborhood of {0} in Q. Formula (4.8) explains, why the exponential sends any Lie subalgebra 0 c Mat, into a Lie group. Indeed, e x p A e x p B = e x p ( A t B + i [ A ; B ] t ...), so e x p o
is closed under the matrix multiplication.
The local Lie group uniquely extends to a global simply connected Lie group G (not necessarily matrix group) with the Lie algebra (5. Any other Lie group G with algebra (5 is then isomorphic to G/I', where is a discrete subgroup of the center of G, identified with the fundamental group21 of G . So all locally isomorphic Lie groups {G} with the given Lie algebra are in 1-1 correspondence with discrete subgroups r c Z(G ).
r
N
N
We shall illustrate the relations between Lie algebras Q and groups G; G and with a few simple examples.
r
1) The easiest of the sort is the abelian Lie algebra 8 = W", which gives rise to several Lie groups: G=Rn;or G=T"=Wn/Z"orG=Bm$W"-m,for a n y m = 1 , 2 , ... corresponding to various discrete subgroups N Z", or Zm, of G.
r
2) Another example is the unitary group SU(2) (simply connected), which forms a 2-fold cover of S q 3 ) (chapter 3). All other (higher-D) orthogonal groups S q n ) also have 2-fold simply connected covers, called spinor groups Spin(n), S q n ) N Spin(n)/Z2. 3) Group G = SL,(W) is not simply connected, and its simply connected cover cannot be realized as a matrix group!
N
G
Indeed, group G is topologically equivalent to the product R2 x 1 ' (this follows from realization of the Poincare-Lobachevski half-plane H as quotient SL2/So(2), and could also be established by the Iwasawa decomposition, as explained in $7.1, chapter 7). So the
"We remind the reader that a fundamental group of manifold W consists of the hornotopy equivalence classes of closed path (loops) in W . Two loops 7 1 ; 7 2 in W are equivalent, if rl can be continuously deformed into yz inside W . Any pair {yl;y2)of closed path (loops) passing through a fixed point z,,E W can be formally multiplied by combining them into a single path ~ 1 ~ ("71'' 7 2 followed by "y2"), and any 7 can be inverted, by traversing it in the opposite direction. Such multiplication and inversion are easily verified to respect the (homotopy) equivalence on the space of loops passing through a fixed point. So equivalence classes of (7) acquire the group structure, the identity being made of all path contractible to {zo}. The resulting fundamental group of A, = al(W), is a discrete group, that carries some important topological information a b u t the manifold. It acts freely (by the so called deck Iran_sformations) on a simply connected cover W of W , so the latter is isomorphic to a quotient-space &IT. The fundamental group of a E e group G is c G , hence belongs to the center of G (problem a), identified-with a normal discrete subgroup and G rz G
/r.
r
r
51.4. Lie groups and algebras; The infinitesimal method
52
fundamental group
r of SL, is isomorphic to Z,and its simply connected cover G has
Z. If SL, were realized by matrices we would get a finite-D faithful (one-te one) representation of SL, in C”.The detailed analysis of finite-D representations of SL, in chapter 4 shows that any such T has { d e t T , = 1; for all g E C}, and the same holds for representations of G (in other words T m a p S L p S L , ! ) . Furthermore, any center Z N
representation T of G or
2:
is completely reducible ( u “direct sum of irreducibles a”).
Since center of any group is represented by scalars { X I } under an irreducible (Schur’s Lemma), and for
SL,
i~
EG
these scalars must be m-th roots of the identity { w :
wm = 1 ) (due to d e t r , = I), it follows that center Z(G) is mapped by T into a finite
group of matrices with diagonal entries { w } . But Z N Z is infinite, so some g to { I } , which means T can not be exact. In other words,
Z must go
Sf, can not be realized
as
matrix group!
Let us make a few comments concerning the explog correspondence: (5-G. It clearly, preserves all general (functorial) properties of groups and algebras. So a
closed (connected) subgroups of G u subalgebras of
(5,
normal subgroups H c G u ideals @ c (5 - subalgebras invariance under the adjoint action of (5: [@;@I c @, or adx(@) c 8, for all X E (5).
Z(G), commutant G, = [G;G] (a subgroup, generated by all group commutators {g-lh-lgh: g , h E G}),etc., have proper counterparts in the Lie algebra: central ideal 3 = 3((5), commutant a other “natural mbgroups”, like center Z =
(5,
= [(5;(5] = S p a n { [ X Y ] X : , Y E (5}, etc.
Also any decomposition of group in the direct, semidirect product, yields a similar decomposition of its Lie algebra. 4.3. The adjoint action. Lie group acts on its Lie algebra by the so called adjoint action Ad,. First let us observe that G acts on itself by the group conjugation g : h6+g - ‘hg. The lakter can be lifted to the Lie algebra via exponential map:
g
-1
(expA)g = exp ( g - ‘Ag), for A E 6.
(4.9)
We call the resulting action (4.9) of G on (5 the adjoint representation Ad,. Of course, for matrix groups G,the adjoint action is nothing but a conjugation with g, Adg(A) = g - ‘ Ag . In general, adjoint action represents G by automorphisms of its Lie algebra,
g1.4. Lie groups and algebras; The infinitesimal method
53
Ad,[A;B] = [Ad&A);Ad,(B)]. We shall see that the adjoint action of group G by automorphisms of its Lie algebra corresponds to the adjoint action (4.1) of 6 on itself by derivations, adA(B)= [A;B]. In fact derivations {adA} represent infinitesimal generators of oneparameter subgroups of automorphisms {AdexptA},as will be explained in Theorem 5 below. 4.4. Basic classification of Lie groups and algebras; Examples. On the algebraic level the realm of Lie algebras (it is easier to start with them, as one avoids many topological complication) contains two large and distinct classes:
I) solvable and nilpotent algebras (the latter make up a subclass of solvables); 11) simple and semisimple algebras. We shall briefly describe both of them. The definition of the former is given in terms of the upper derived series of repeated commutators,
8 3 8'= [0;0] 3 8" = [@';@'I Here each subsequent term X , Y E d k - l ) } of the preceding term
3 ... 3
dk) = [(5@-1); d k - 9
dU is derived dk-').
3 ...
(4.10)
via commutators, Span{[ X ;Y ] ;
Algebra 8 is solvable (of step n), if its derived series terminates at {0}, (similar notion applies to groups with group-commutators { g - ' h - ' g h } in place of Lie brackets [ X ; Y ] )A. commutator 8' of Lie algebra is the smallest ideal 8 c 8,with the commutative factor-algebra 8/@, and one can check that all are also ideals of 8. So solvable algebras/groups are obtained by subsequent abelian extensions of abelian algebras22. Nilpotent algebras form a subclass of solvable, they are defined in a similar manner with a (smaller) lower derived series,
dn+') = (0)
{dk)}
8 3 8,= [@;@I 3 8, = [O;O,] 3 ... 3
[8;(5J 3
...
(4.11)
So each subsequent term is the commutator of the entire algebra 8 with the preceding term. Once again the series is required to terminate at {0}, On+' = [@;On] = (0) (step-n nilpotent). In particular, 8, belongs to the center of 8, and the entire algebra is obtained by a sequence of central extensions. The natural examples of solvable and nilpotent algebras are made of upper22The terminology came from the Galois theory, where solvability of the Galois group of an algebraic equation implies that the equation can be solved in radicals. Radicals correspond to cyclic subgroups of quotients dk)/dk-').
$1.4. Lie groups and algebras; The infinitesimal method
54
1
triangular matrices, respectively matrices with (0) on the main diagonal (problem 5 ) . Other examples incude t e affine group Affl, matrices of the form{ and
[
realized by the upper-triangular
(a step-one solvable group), and the Heisenberg groups HI
W, (step-one nilpo ent g oups) (see $1.1and chapter 6).
Next we turn to semisimple and simple algebras. The former are characterized by the property that the commutator [0;(5] = (5 (in other they have no commutative quotients), the latter (simple) have no ideals at all (hence no nontrivial
quotient^)^^.
These properties have important implications for the structure and analysis of simple and semisimple groups and algebras (see chapters 4-6). At this point we shall mention only two basic results:
i) any semisimple algebra is a direct sum of simple ones, 0 21 @I Gj;in other 3 words the adjoint action (4.1) on (5 is completely reducible; ii) all simple Lie algebras can be completely classified; they consist of the classical
series: unimodular, orthogonal, symplectic, and a few exceptional ezamples. Here we shall list the basic classical simple Lie algebras, which correspond to
classical Lie groups of $1.l. Examples: 1) Lie algebra gqn) = Mat,, of the general linear group GL,; and its subalgebra sqn) = {A:t r A = 0 } , which corresponds to a special linear group SL,. Other classical groups (11.1) preserve certain quadratic/bilinear forms J on Wn;
Cn, so that 'gJg = J ; or g*Jg = J ; for group elements ( 9 ) .
(4.12)
The corresponding condition for the Lie algebra elements {X} becomes
'XJ + J X = O ; o r X * J + J X = O , which easily derived from (4.12) by differentiating g = exptX, at t = 0. Thus we get 2) so(n)
- algebra of all n x n real/complex antisymmetric traceless matrices
{'X = - X ; tr X = 0}, which corresponds to the orthogonal group S q n ) . In the real case "traceless" condition holds automatically for all skew-symmetric matrices.
3) u(n) and su(n) - algebras of all n x n complex (hermitian) antisymmetric matrices, { X * = - X}, and traceless antisymmetric matrices { t r X = 0}, correspond to to the unitary, or special unitary groups, U(n) and SU(n). In a similar fashion one can of ad,
23We can phrase both definitions in terms of the adjoint action: simplicity means irreduci6ility on 8 , while semisimple implies that operators {adx(@):X E 8 ) span entire space 8.
51.4. Lie groups and algebras; The infinitesimal method
55
describe Lie algebras so(p;q); su(p;q) of ( p ;q)-indefinite orthogonal and unitary groups S q p ;q) and S y p ;q), symplectic algebra sdn). For instance, matrices X E s o ( p ; q ) have block structure d E sa(q), and c = Tb E Matp
4.) (problem 6). So
{X=(i
:)}with
a€+);
and similar representations could be found for ur(p; q),
vector space 4 p ; q ) is isomorphic to 4 p ) x so(q) x Mat,
Q, which
yields the dimension of Lie group S q p ; q).
We shall see more examples in subsequent chapters 4-6. Two classes: solvable and semisimple, provide the building blocks for arbitrary Lie algebras S!. The following general result will be stated here without proof. Levi-Malcev decomposition Theorem: A n y finite-dimensional Lie algebra I? has the maximal solvable ideal '32, called radical, and a semisimple subalgebra 6,so that S! is decomposed into a semidirect product: S!='[email protected] h e radical 8 is a characteristic ideal of I? (invariant under all automorphisms of S!), and obviously unique, while a n y two semisimple factors 6;6' differ by a n automorphism of !2, 6'= a(@),a E AutI?. Let us recall that a semidirect product S! = ?R@ s6, is defined for a pair of Lie algebras {%;@}, where 6 acts by derivations on '32,
6 3 z+a = az E Der('32), where a ( [ a ; b ] = ) [ a ( a ) ; b+ ] [ a ; a ( b ) ) for ; all a,b E '32. By definition, I? consists of all pairs { ( a ; z ) }with the Lie bracket (problem 6), [(a;2);(4Y)1 = ( a -t
4)); 2 -t Y ) .
(4.13)
The natural examples of semidirect products include the Euclidian motion and the Poincare algebras: En = W" @so(.) and Sp, = M" @ 4 1 ;n - 1). In both cases the radical '32 = W" (or M") is commutative, and a (simple) factor 6 II 4.) or 41;n-1) (orthogonal/pseudo-orthogonal)acts on '32 by linear transformations. Another important example, discussed in chapter 6, is a semidirect product of the Heisenberg and symplectic Lie algebras: 8, @ 4.). Further details and references on the general Lie theory could be found in [Che]; [Jac]; [Kir]; [Ser]; [Hell. 4.5. The infinitesimal method. The correspondence between Lie groups and Lie
algebras extends to their representations. It is often convenient to replace Lie group representations by those of its Lie algebra, as the latter are much easier to analyze (study irreducibility; decomposition, etc.). We shall conclude this section with a general
56
81.4. Lie groups and algebras; The infinitesimal method
result that serves the basis of the infinitesimal method in representation theory. It will require a notion of the generator of a 1-parameter group of unitary (bounded) operators U t in an oo-D space 36. Proposition 4 (i) A one-parameter strongly continuous group {U,} of matrices, or bounded operators in space 36 has a generator A, defined on a dense subspace of “smooth vectors” {t}(i.e. vectors which yield smooth vector-functiow t(t)= U t t ) ,
Conversely, any selfadjoint (bounded and unbounded) operator A ( o r more general A, subject to some technical constraints) generates a 1-parameter group, denoted by Ut( = e t A t .
(ii) Generators of orthogonal/unitary groups {Ut} are skew-symmetIic, A* = - A . The algebraic (finite-D) version exploits the well known feature of any {U,}: differentiability t o any order (even real analyticity)! The same holds for a uniformly continuous group U , in Hilbert/Banach spaces. In both cases, U , = etA, with a bounded operator24 A (problem 4). The strongly continuous (unitary) case is more subtle, as not all vectors [ E 36 have differentiable “tails” { [ ( t ) = U t [ } , in general. However, any U has smooth vectors { < : [ ( t )E el} (or
em;Coo; real
analytic), which form dense subspaces in
36: 36 3 36, 3 ...36, 3 ...X6, 3 A. Indeed, smooth vectors can be obtained by mollifying (smoothing) operators of J1.2,
It is easy to check that operators {U,} send 36 into the m-smooth subspace 36,. The density of the embedding 36, supported functions {f E
c 36 is verified by observing that m-smooth compactly
er}approximate any L’-function
(in the weak sense!). If f,4, then images U ,
on R, as well as distribution 6
[I
are easily seen t o approach any [ E 36. d Thus we get a densely defined (closed) generator: A = &Y, on 36, c 36. For unitary { U } operator A is selfadjoint, A*=A,
90
n
its exponential eitA (as well as any other function
=f(A)”) can be defined via spectral resolution (Appendix A), eitA =
I
eiXtdE(X) = U,.
Smooth vectors form a domain 9 ( A ) = 36, of a closed, skewadjoint (in the unitary case) -This fact is a generalization of differentiability of continuous one-parameter groups of numbers, or characters (~(1): t E R) c R or C. Such x is shown to be differentiable, by smoothing i t 1 where c = J f ( s ) x ( s ) d s# 0, and the out via convolution with nice f E e:(R), i.e. ~ ( t=) i;(x*f)(t), RKS is obviously as smooth as f! Now it follows immediately, that ~ ( t=) eat, for a E R or C.
51.4. Lie groups and algebras; The infinitesimal method
57
unbounded operator A . Space 9 ( A ) is closed under a stronger (graph) norm,
11 ( ]I1 = 11 ( 11 + 11 A(
1
or norm ( I +I A
b( 1 where I A I = (A*A)’/’- the modulus of A.
In fact, any such A defines a scale of densely embedded (“Sobolev”) spaces 36 3 36,3
where 36, = ( I
+ I A I )-“36
intersection 36, =
n
36,-
... 3 36,3 ... = 36,;
=domain
of A’” = {rn-smooth vectors in 36}. The
consists of oo-smooth vectors, and is also dense in 36
m>O
(moreover, 36, contGns yet another dense subspace A of analytic vectors!). All subspaces are invariant under the group U , , and of course, U,136,
is strongly continuous in the rn-
norm.
Let us illustrate the general concepts of smooth vectors; closedness; domains; “strong” vs. “uniform” continuity of operator-groups with a few simple examples. 4.6. Examples: 1) Multiplication operator, A f ( z ) = zf(z), on L2-spaces: L2(W); ~ ~ ( bl); [ a ;or more general
L’(w; dp), generates a unitary group: U,f = e i t t f ( z ) , also
acting by multiplications. i) On finite intervals [a;b],or for measures dm of “finite support”, the group is uniformly (norm) continuous, and generator A is bounded, 11 A 11 5 C ,if supp I c [ - C;C ] . The two conditions (norm-continuity and boundedness) always come together. Furthermore, all vectors {f} in L2 are “00-smooth” (even real analytic), so
36 = 36, = A = L*.
ii) On infinite intervals (e.g. W), A is no more bounded, and U , is only strongly continuous: 1 U ,f - fIP0, as t+O, for any f E L2. Not all vectors are smooth, however, the space of “1-smooth vectors”: 361 = P(A) = {f: similarly “m-smooth vectors”:
I f 111 = I (I+ I 2 I 1f(z)llL2
36, = 9(Arn) = { f :llfllrn =Il(ltI z I
)“f(.)IIL2
< CQ}’ < 00}, etc.
Vector-function ei‘”f(z) could be differentiated at t = 0, only for 1-smooth vectors { f } , to get Af = zf!
2) The translation-group W: U,f(z) = f ( z - t ), acing on L2 (or other LP-spaces) is strongly continuous. Its generator A = d is an unbounded operator with a dense domain made of “1-smooth” vectors/functions, f E L2,so that f’ is also L2,
{
1 1
36, = f:1 f 1 1 = 1 f 1 L~ t f’
L2}
- the so called first-Sobolev space.
$1.4. Lie groups and algebras; The infinitesimal method
58
Similarly, LLm-smoothvectors” coincide with um-smooth (Sobolev) functions” (see
36, =
{f : l l f l l m
= IlfllL2
-+ ... +I1 f(m)IIL2} - m-th Sobolev space25.
The last example explains the terminology “smooth vectors”. It could be extended to more general one-parameter group actions, e.g. flows on
manifolds,
4,:
z+y(z;t) on A. Any such flow is generated by a vector field
as a solution of an ordinary differential system:
X = Cajaj,
+ = X(y); y(0) = z (so we could write:
dt = exptX). Associated to any flow dt is a 1-parameter group of linear transformation on function-spaces over A, e.g. L’(A),
U , f ( z ) = ~ ( I # J , ( z )or ) ; more general V,f(z) = a ( z ; t ) f od,(z), where
(I
satisfies the cocycle condition: a(+;t + s ) = a(+;t ) a ( d , ( z ) ; s ) The . generator of
X considered as a 1-st order differential operator C ajaj on (it plays the role of D = in example 2). Smoofh vectors consist of dz
group U,, is the vector-field functions over A
functions differentiable along the flow. In the second case, the generator is the 1-st order operator of the form: A = X + q , where q is a multiplication operator with function q(z) = crt(z;O)(at- derivative of
(I
at t = 0). If function q is sufficiently smooth, one can
check that Um-smoofh vectors” of A are the same as for X.
Once the notion of generator of one-parameter groups was made clear, we can proceed to more general Lie group representations.
Theorem 5: Any representation g+T, of Lie group G in space 36 gives rise to a representation X +Tx of its Lie algebra (li: (4.14)
In the 00-D c u e generators { T x } are unbounded operators defined a joint dense core of “smooth vectors” 36, = {.$(Tg(I q ) E C?(G);for all q E 36). Furthermore, for unitary T operators { T x } are skew-symmetric. Conversely, a representation of Lie algebra 0 by (closed, unbounded) generators { T x } can be ezponentiated (lifted) to a representation of its simply connected Lie group,
T,
= exp T x .
(4.15)
Proof: On the purely algebraic level (finite-D, uniformly continuous case) the result becomes a simple consequence of the exp and log maps (defined via Taylor expansions)
1 + I D I )“f
-One can show (52.2) that the m-th Sobolev norm is equivalent to (1 I D I = ( D * D ) 1 / 2 is the modulus of the differentiation operator D = L. dz
lL2;where
51.4. Lie groups and algebras; The infinitesimal method
59
and the Campbell-Hausdorff formula (4.2). On the functional-analytic (unitary) level some technical complications appear, as generators { TX} could be unbounded (densely defined) operators, each with its own domain !D(TX).However, all of them have a joint dense core of I-smooth uecfors 36,. As in the one-parameter case, 36, contains the range
{( = T f ( q ) :q E 36) of any mollifier T with f E e,!(G). In fact, there exists the whole
f
scale of
3 6 , 3
m-smooth
spaces: 36 3 36, 3 ...36,
3
...36,
3A
(analytic vectors), with
{ T f ( q ) :E f ey(G)}. All of them are dense and invariant under the group action
{Tg}(for analytic vectors this result is due t o L.G$rding). On each space 36, one can define the m-fold products and powers of generators {TX...T X :XjE a}, furthermore 00
1
,
on analytic vectors {( E A } the Taylor series:F$TF(E), converges. Thus we get the group action on analytic vectors { T gI d:g = e x p X } , which then extends rough the whole space 36. An alternative way t o obtain the group representation in the unitary case (skewsymmetric generators) is via spectral resolution:
T X = JXdE(X), E(X)-spectral measure, whence the corresponding unitary group: exp(t T
~= T~~~~~ ) = Je’”dE(X),
as in Proposition 4. This completes the proof.
Let us remark that many natural properties of representations, including irreducibility, decompositiona6, etc. can be transferred from Lie algebra 8 to Lie group
G. However, in the absence of simple connectivity of G local representation { T e X p x } given by (4.15) may not be extendible through the whole group. Indeed, only “half’ of irreducible representations of simply connected group SU(2) extend through the representations of Sq3)u SU(2)/{i I} (chapter 4), and a similar pattern holds for all other non-simply-connected groups. Clearly, the dual object of any factor-group G / H consists of all i~ E G, that annihilate H , i~ I H = 1.
26with some obvious qualification: for any invariant subspace of the Lie algebra generators So irreducibility of { T x } means any {Tx}-invariant subspace 36 is dense in 36.
ITx} we take its closure in the %norm.
60
51.4. Lie groups and algebras; The infinitesimal method
Problems and Exercises: 1. Prove Lemma 3 (Hint: some statements, like (ii), are easy to check first for diagonalizable mairices A = U-'DU (D - diagonal, U E GL,), and then to use density of diagonalizable {A) in Mat,!). 2. (i) Prove formula (4.5) for matrix subgroups, using the Taylor expansion of { e x p t A } . It is known as Trotter product formula (4.5), and has numerous extensions and applications to groups (and semigroups) of operators in spaces of finite and infinite dimensions. (ii) Show that formula (4.6) defines a 1-parameter group with generator A. 3. Show that subspaces d,; so(n) and
4.)of g/, = Mat,
form Lie algebras.
4. A (strongly continuous) one-parameter group of unitary Hilbert-space operators { U t } has a selfadjoint generator A = A*, i.e. U , = exp(iAt). Show U , is uniformly (norm)
continuous iff operator A is bounded. Steps: i) Use spectral decomposition of a selfadjoint (not necessarily bounded!) operator: A is unitarily equivalent to a multiplication, r : f + r f ( z ) , in LZ(R;dp) or in the direct sum
e,3 L2(R;dpj).
ii) Show: A is bounded iff s u p p t d p } or U s u p p { d p j } is compact in R. iii) Unitary group { U t : f-e""f(z)} compact.
in L2(dp) is norm-continuous iff s u p p { d p } is
5. Show that all upper triangular matrices over R or C form a solvable Lie algebra 23,. Find the derived series for B,, and the corresponding Lie group. Do the same for the the algebra U, of all upper triangular matrices with 0 on the main diagonal (show that U is nilpotent, find its lower derived series, and its Lie group).
6. Find block-structure (as explained in example 3) of Lie algebras: 4 n ) , su(n), s o ( p ; q ) , w ( p ; q ) , sp(n), and use it to compute dimensions of the corresponding Lie groups.
7. Show that (4.13) defines Lie bracket on the semidirect product % @ 8 of Lie algebras.
r
8. Show that a normal discrete subgroup of a Lie group G belongs in the center Z ( G ) (Hint: conjugate each y E r by elements g E G, y+g-'-yg, and observe that all {g} in a vicinity of {e} fix y).
Chapter 2. Commutative Harmonic Analysis. Schur's Lemma implies that irreducible representations of a commutative group G consists of I-D characters, i.e. homomorphisms { x:G+C* numbers)}, or {x:G-+T
(multiplicative complex
= {e"} - unitary characters}. We shall mostly deal with the
latter. The characters can be multiplied and inverted: (x1;xz)
+
x1x2;
x
x-l =
-+
1 Xb)' -
so they also form a commutative group, called the dual group
e. Dual group of a locally
compact G , is itself locally compact [Po,], hence carriea an invariant (Haar) measure. Three commutative groups lie a t the heart of the classical harmonic analysis: R";
Z" C R" and 1"N R"/Z". The characters of all three consist of exponentials X,(z)
= e i t . '.
In the case of R", parameter ( runs over R",
80
the group becomes isomorphic t o its dual.
For Z", identified with an integral lattice {m = (ml; ...mn)] in R", characters
x = xO(m)= e " . m ,
...
are labeled by the dual torus, 0 = (Ol; On), 0 5 O 5 2u, so
A
Z" u T". The characters of torus T" = {(el;...On) : 0 5 Oj 5 2 x 1 , or more general (0 5 Oj 5 Tj], are in turn labeled by the lattice points,
x = Xm(4
eim .O.
, m E Z",
so 1"N Z". Let remark that the mutual duality of groups 1" and
Z" exemplifies the
general Pontrjagin Duality principle for locally compact Abelian groups [Pon]: the second dual group (characters of G) is isomorphic t o G itself, via the map: u-G(x) = x(a), a E G (elements a E G define characters on G). So the classification problem (I) of
chapter 1 for commutative groups G amounts t o characterization of
6,
while the
decomposition problem (11) for the regular representation R will lead to study the Fourier transform 9 on L2-spaces and other spaces. This marks the starting point of the Fourier analysis. Chapter 2 gives the basic overview of the Commutative Fourier analysis, and some of its applications, the main emphasis being on differential equations.
$2.1. Inversion and Plancherel Formula.
62
$2.1.Fourier transform: Inversion and Plancherel Formula. In this section we shall introduce the Fourier transform/series expansion on R"; 2"; T", discuss their basic properties (with respect to translation, differentiation, dilation, rotations. Then we establish the key result of the Fourier analysis, Plancherel/Inversion formula, in 2 different ways. One exploits Gaussians and Schwartz functions, another Poisson summation.
1.1. Fourier transform 4 on group G = R";T" is defined by integrating functions {f} against characters {x = e i t e Z } ,
while on
Znintegration becomes summation,
Sometimes we shall indicate the
"I
to
transform by TZjt.
From the
definition one could easily check a few basic properties of 4. 1) Convolution-+product, 4:f*g---+?(t)G(t) 2) Translation-tmultiplication with character, 4:R, f = f ( z - a)-+eia't?(t)
3) Differentiationjmultiplication, 4:8,f +itj?(t); hence 4:aaf+(it)"Y Here
{aj} and (8%= ( a l...; a,,)}denote partial differentiations in I . The latter
relation is easily verified via integration by parts:
/(a"f)g = / f ( - a ) a g ;
with g = e T i Z . t .
We introduce an involution on functions { f ( s ) }on G,as a linear map,
-
f(-.),
*: f(.)-f*(.) = with the obvious properties: ( f * g ) * = g**f*; (f*)* = f . Clearly, 4) Involution-tcomplex conjugation, 9:
f*(z)+?(t).
5)A linear change of variable, A:z+Az
( A E GL,)
on Rn,
defines a
transformation of functions,
f + f A ( z )= f o A = ~ ( A I ) . Fourier transform takes such linear change into its inverse transpose, precisely 4 : f AdetA + ~ ~('AA-'). o
$2.1. Inversion and Plancherel Formula
63
Finally, relation (3) differentiation-+multiplication, can be reversed into
6) m ultiplication-tdifferentiation, 9:xjf(x)+$3,,f^([); As we mentioned earlier characters
+~~f-(ia,)~?
{x} describe all irreducible representations of
the commutative group G. On the other hand they can be interpreted as joint eigenfunctions of all translations { R,:a E G } , respectively, of their infinitesimal
generators {aj} (on 53"; U"), as well as convolution operators: R f [ g ]= ( f * g ) ( x ) . Formulae (1-3) can be rephrased now in the language of the representation theory by saying: map 9 diagonalizes regular representation R of G,
9R9-
N
"direct sum/integral of characters".
Precisely, any function f (in a suitable space) can be expanded into the direct sum/integral of characters
x = eix
*
€,
C
1
f(x) = bEeix* t; or f(z) = b( [) eiz ' '%(, (1.3) with "Fourier coefficients/transform" b(() = ?([), and the regular representation turns into multiplication on the space of "Fourier coefficients",
Later on (chapters 3-7) we shall establish various noncommutative versions of this result.
1.2. Plancherel and Inversion formula. The fundamental property of exponentials { e i < ' + } is their orthogonality and completeness. In case of compact G (e.g. U"), orthogonality can be understood literally',
as all
{x,}
are L2-functions on G. Completeness means that any f can be
approximated, hence uniquely expanded into the Fourier series. An elementary proof for
T"exploits the
Cezaro means (problem 3).
More general explanation has to do with compactness of convolution-operators, R f:u (z )d f*u (+) , in L2 (LP)-spaces on 1" (Appendix B). Compact self-adjoint (f = f*)
operators, are well known to have a complete orthogonal system of eigenvectors, and exponentials {xm = ei+ * m} are precisely the eigenvectors of R
f , f*eiz
*
= F(m)eic ' €.
'The same holds on an arbitrary compact group G (see [HR]; [Loo]),namely,
(X, I xa) = I&',&d+
= I G I 6km;
I G I = Ud(G);6km-
Kronecker 6.
62.1. Inversion and Plancherel Formula.
64
Similar arguments apply to all compact groups (chapter 3).
For non-compact groups W"; Z" orthogonaZity should be understood in a generalized (distributional) sense,
l(eit.z I ,ir)
.z)=
c
,i(t-r))
*
zdz
(1.5)
In other words, the role of Kronecker 6,k = S(m - k), being played by the Dirac 6-function. The integral (1.5) is strictly speaking divergent, but it makes sense as a distribution. Namely, for any nice (testing) function f(q) on R",
We shall see that in such form orthogonality is equivalent to the
Inversion/Plancherel formula for 9. Namely the transform,
4':h(q)-tL(x) = ( h I eWiV.') = Ih(q)eiV*'dq, takes
f^
(1.6)
back into Const x f. Therefore, (1.6) defines the inverse Fourier
transform of h. The precise result is usually stated for a suitable class of
functions on G. We shall treat separately compact (T";Z")-cases and noncompact Rn- case.
1.3. Compact case. A suitable class of functions on torus, called Fourier algebra, consists of absolutely convergent Fourier series, A = {f(x) = CakeiZ * k: Clearly, algebra Ace(U"),
c I ak I < m}.
is made of continuous functions on
U", and
contains sufficiently many smooth functions, A 3 em,for m > n. The latter is easy verified using differentiation formula 3). Indeed, Fourier coefficients of a partial derivative
aaf = C(ik)aakeiz'k , by (iii). So if f E em, then its
Fourier coefficients ak = o( I k I,),-
which
guarantees convergence of
c l%I. Uniqueness and Plancherel Theorem on T": (i) Any function f E A(Tn) is uniquely determined by its Fourier coefficients, {ak}*f(z)
(ii) For any function f =
=
Cakeiz' '.
CakeiZ " E L',
In other words 9:L2(T")+12(Z"), is a unitary map. Both results are fairly
52.1. Inversion and Plancherel Formula obvious corollaries of the completeness and orthogonality' (problem 3).
65 of {eiz * k: k E Z"}
1.4. Continuous case W". Here a suitable class consists of all functions { f},
integrable along with their 9-transforms,
{f E ~
T E L I } = L' nA.
1 :
As above, A denotes the Fourier algebra {y(z): f E L'}, of absolutely convergent Fourier integrals. As with T" algebra A is shown to consist of continuous functions, decaying at {oo}, a consequence of the Riemann-Lebesgue p ' - compactly supported mTheorem (problem 1 of 52.2). Furthermore, A 3 C smooth functions3, so
C'y c A c C',,
for m > n.
Inversion/Plaucherel Theorem on R": (I) A n y function f E A n L', can be uniquely
recovered from
1 b y the Inverse Fourier transform
(11) transformation 4,normalized b y factor L2(Rn) onto L"), i.e.
1becomes a unitary map from (27r)"/2 '
The Fourier transform of an Lz-function in (1.9) should be understood in the "square-mean" sense, i.e. by approximating f with nice (L'; compactly supported) functions. Let us make a few comments: 0
the general inversion formula (1.8) is equivalent to a special case z=O (and is
often stated in that form), G
multiplication of ?(() by e i z * < corresponds to a shift f(O)+f(z), under the inverse transform 9':
?+f.
'Indeed, for any complete orthogonal system (basis) { $ J ~in } Hilbert space 36, any f E 36, is uniquely decomposed into a series f = C akdlr,and 11 f 11 = C 1 ak I Gk (Parceval identity). Clearly, factor ( 2 ~ ) "in (1.9) represents L2-norms of Fourier harmonics {gk=
1) 1 '
3The inclusion
er c A
j(<= ) U( I < I -"'), Slf(f)ld<.
whe_nce
follows from the differentiation formula (3): 9[13"f] = (i<)"j for anyf E, :e which yields absolute convergence of the integral
52.1. inversion and Piancherel Formula.
66 0
Plancherel formula (1.9) follows from the Inversion (1.8) applied to a function:
g(4=
If(. + Y)f(y)dY
Indeed, from (i)-(ii) it follows that
5 via (1.8), 0
?(()
=
f*f**
(1.10)
=I ?(() f, while g(0) = Ilfll'.
So inverting
we get the Plancherel formula (1.9) for f .
The result holds for any locally compact Abelian group
4 transforms functions { f(z)} on G into defines a unitary map: L'(G)+L2(8).
{ j ( x ) } on
G ([Loo];[HR]). Here
e, takes AnL'(G)+AnL'(G), and
We shall present two arguments based on very different, but equally important ideas. One of them exploits the Gaussian and Schwartz functions, another a "discrete (lattice) approximation" of
W", and the so called Poisson summation formula.
The Gaussian method. Obviously, it suffices to prove (1.9) for a dense class of functions in AnL' or L '.
One possible choice are infinitely smooth {f},rapidly decaying a t {co}
with all their derivatives
I z I -"aaf(z)-+0,
as z - o q for all m and a,
equipped with a suitable system of seminorms, e.g.
IIf llaP = "$2 I ."f%) These are
90
1
called Schwarlr functions on R". The class of Schwartz functions and
distributions is discussed in detail in 52.2. Here we shall only remark that the Schwartz class is sufficiently rich. It contains, all C3-
compactly supported
{f}; the Gaussian
.
function: G = G,(z) = e-tz2 (z2 = z z = I z I 2), and all products: G x "polynomials".
T h e latter class, 9 = Szf = p ( z ) e - z 2 / 2 : polynomial p ( z ) } , will be used in our proof of inversion Theorem. Let us remark that space 9 is dense in C,(R"),
by the Weierstrass
"uniform approximation" principle, as well as in other spaces: Lz, ZP, A n L ' ,
Y, with
appropriate norms. The inversion for the Gaussian itself is verified directly (problem 5):
9:Gt-Gt = (2nt)"/2e-t2/4', i.e. Gaussian is Fourier-transformed into another (differently scaled) Gaussian, whence follows G(z) = T-'[C]. Then it remains to apply the differentiation and multiplication rules 3)-6), to get Fourier-inversion for any product-function, f = p , ( z ) G in 9. The proof is completed by the standard density argument: once Plancherel formula is established for a dense subspace 9 C Lz, it follows for all f E Lz.
1.5. Poisson Summation Formula: Let functions f and
1
be integrable and
52.1. Inversion and Plancherel Formula
67
continuow on Rn (e.g. f E A n L'). Then for any period T
> 0, (1.11)
Similar result holds for an arbitrary lattice: r = { m = Emitj}, spanned b y vectors { t , ;...tn} c R", and its dual lattice, r1 = (7= E kjaj}, where a;. t . = 2x6. .. Namely, 3 83 (1.12)
where J L = R"/r
21
T" denotes the fundamental domain of
r.
The proof is fairly easy and straightforward. We define a new f-periodic function:
Series obviously converges and gives a continuous function on torus R " / f
N
Tn. Function
F is expanded in the Fourier series,
with coefficients {a,) on the dual lattice f':
Next the torus inversion formula applies,
and the result follows.
Remark Formula (1.11) has many different meanings, interpretations, and S(x - rn) on Rn, "6applications. One of them is in terms of distribution: 6, = function of r".The LHS of (1.12) pairs b r to a nice test-fun%sxf(z), while the RHS defines the Fourier transform of 4 = S f . By definition, ($If^) = ($If), for any distribution 4 and a test-function f. So (1.11)-(1.12)reads,
c
in other words LL6-function of
r is Fourier-transformed into -volX1
"6-function of
rl".
$2.1. Inversion and Plancherel Formula.
68
In such s form Poisson summation turns into a special case of the general result for arbitrary Abelian locally compact groups: if
r
is a closed subgroup of G, and
r'
denotes
r in G, r'={ x : x I r = l}, fhen 6-funcfion of r (understood as (6rIf ) = Sffdy,dy-Haar measure on r), is Fourier fransformed into the 6function of Z", T:Cr-Constbrf. The key idea is that averaging over r, sends functions the annihilafor of integral
f(x) on G into functions on the factor-group G / r ,
f ( . ) + f ( z + r )= Jrf(z+V)dY = 6 r * f . The dual group l o G / r is identified with
r', and
the Fourier transform takes the A
A
projection map: f --df *f (from G to G / r ) ,into the restriction map: f -f
1 r'.
Poisson summation immediately yields the inversion/Plancherel formula on R". We let T-co in (1.11.), and remember that f(z)-+O at {m}. The LHS of (1.11) clearly goes to f(O), while the RHS converges to
&/?(O&, so f(0) =
(2x1
?(t)d<, QED.
Further applications of the Poisson summation will appear in $2.4 and chapter 7.
52.1. Inversion
69
and Plancherel Formula
Problems and Exercises: 1. Show that any continuous character on R (a homomorphism x:R-C') is of the form x ( a ) = eZa, for some z E C (prove it first for rational a E Q, then use continuity of x ! ) . Deduce the character formulae (1.0) for R"; Z"; 1". 2. i) If a sequence of functions {Fn]on R"; 1" approximate &function: (F, I h) -h(O), as n-co, for any continuous h, then the corresponding convolution kernels: F,*f(z)-f(z), as n+m, for all {f} in C and Lp, 1 5 p < cm (such sequences are called approximate unities).
ii) Any sequence of positive functions {Fn] with the properties: (a) J F , d z = 1; (b)
1
1x1
F,dz
-.)
0, as n+m, for any
6
0,
56
forms an approximate unity. 3. Completeness of characters
eim * =} on 1":any f E e, or Lz is approximated by
{x,=
trigonometric polynomials,
c
PN=
lml I N
bm
eim.I
Hint: I t suffices to check the result for continuous {f] with the standard 11 1 1 ~ . Note, that partial sums, may not converge t o f E e uniformly, in general. However, certain means of s, do, like Ces a Po, i) Show that both sums s, and cn are given byconvolutions, s,(f) = S , * f ; c , ( f ) = F,* with kernels, which in
sn(e) =
f,
1-Dcase take the form, sin'? ( l - Ln+ )e1 i k e = - , sin':
sin (n+,$)~
called the Fejer kernel.
sin^
; andF,(B)=
Ikl 5"
ii) Show that the Fejer kernel forms an approximate unity (problem 2), hence F,*f(z)+f(z), uniformly in e, as well as in any LP-norm, 1 5 p < 00. 4. Establish the decay rates of Fourier transform of m-smooth functions
1"and
emand
36,
on
R": estimates (1.11); (1.0); (1.0).
5. Fourier integrals on R are often evaluated by the techniques of complex analysis: calculus of residues, branch-cuts (if necessary), changing path of integration. Use complex analysis t o evaluate the following integrals:
-t2
i) Gaussians: G, = T(e-t22/z n- D).
sin? iii) T(-) = 2n sinh bz cos@ + ~ b
= G, (in 1-D); and (znt)-"/ze-t2/zt (in
on R 0 < a < b (calculus of residues).
0 ~ 5 '
b
Integrals (ii-iii) are evaluated by the residue calculus. They represent the Poisson kernels (j2.2) in the half-plane and a strip.
70
$2.1.Inversion and
Plancherel Formula.
The following 3 Fourier integrals appear in the harmonic analysis on group SL,(R) celebrated Selberg-trace formula ($7.6 of chapter 7):
00
vi)
xis
d 1 - 2Xcos 0 +
X2
dX = -
rsinhs(O+r) sin 0 sinhns
' -'<
- the
< O'
6 . Show that the Fourier transform o f the radial function f = f(lz I) in R" is also radial, find the convolution of two radial functions f(r), g(r) in polar coordinates. 7. Show that the Gaussian G,(z) and the Poisson kernel Pi form convolution-semigroups:
G,*G, = Gt+,, and P,*P, = Use the Yproducl,+convolutionn property of 4, and explicit form of
and
p).
52.2. Fourier transform on function-spaces
71
52.2.Fourier transform on function-spaces. In this section we shall briefly discuss the basic properties of Fourier transform on various function-spaces, including LPspaces, Sobolev spaces, distributions and analytic functions. The material will provide some background for a subsequent study of differential equations in 52.4 and other parts of the book.
2.1. L p - spaces and interpolation. Plancherel formula implies unitarity of the normalized Fourier transform '3':f+(27r)-"/23 on L2, On the other hand Riemann-Lebesgue Lemma means that 5:L'+Lm
boundedly,
Such estimates can be extended to other LP-spaces by the Riesz interpolation Theorem. Namely, S:L*-+Lq, where q = L,is the dual Holder index, furthermore P-1
1-
(Hamdorff-Young inequality).
The exact constant in the Hausdorff-Young was calculated by Beckner in ~ O ' S ,
2
and was shown to be attained on the Gaussian function f =e-" 12. Interpolation provides a powerful tool in estimating linear (bilinear, multi-linear) operators in { L p } and other scales of spaces. The simplest linear version states,
Riesz-Thorin Theorem: i f operator T maps boundedly Lpl(X)+Lql(Y), and L P 2 ( X)+LQ2(Y ) , IITf IIQ' I ClIlf then for any pair of indices:
IIP1'
1-l-s Bp1
andllTf
s +--' P2'
I Q2
1-14
I C2Il.fIIP2'
&
B -T i+ operator T is bounded from L p ( X ) to Lq(Y), and its
I T IILPLQ I c:-sc;. So function
4($f) = ZoglITllLpLqis
convez in the plane of reciprocal parameters
{++I. The Hausdorff-Young inequality arises via interpolation between pairs of Holder indices ( 1 ; ~ )and (2;2) for '3. Of course, interpolation does not yield the best constant
$2.2. Fourier transform on function-spaces
72
( 2 . 1 ) , as C , = C2= l : + C ( p ; q ) = 1 , for all p . The interpolation also applies to convolutions of Lp-spaces. This time we deal with triples of indices so that Lp*Lq c L', in other words, (f;g)--+f*g,maps
(f;$i),
boundedly Lp x Lq4.L'. The general principle for bilinear T remains the same, as for
and LP2x LQ2+L'2, with
linear operators. So if T maps boundedly LplxLql+L'l, bounds C,;C,, then for any interpolating triple:
1-L
8-1
1-
8
1 - A s-1 T-rrl+F;
8-1
q-q+%; T maps Lp x L b L ' , with the norm estimate p-pl+pz;
To apply ( 2 . 2 ) to convolutions of LP-spaces we observe that L'*Lp words operators { R : f E L'} are bounded in L p by
f
llfl/l).
c L p (in other
On the other hand
L2*L2c L". Interpolating between the resulting triples ( 1 ; h fand ) ($;;;O), we get the Young's inequality,
Young's inequality holds for all groups G = R"; T";Z". Moreover, for compact groups (like T") the range of (2.3) can be extended to { ( p , q , ~ ) : 2 $ 1 - l } , due to the
+
obvious inclusions: L"
c LQ,for all 1 I q < p I 00.
The proof of the Riesz interpolation Theorem is based on a version of the maximum principle for holomorphic functions in the strip, called 3-line Lemma (see problems 2,3,4). Let us remark, that so far we didn't use any special features of R"; 1" or Z", so all results about Lp-spaces, which involve interpolation (like Young and Hausdorff-Young
inequalities) extend to arbitrary locally compact Abelian groups [HR].
2.2. Smooth functions and Sobolev spaces. Riemann-Lebesgue Theorem (problem
1) implies that continuous functions on T" (or continuous, compactly supported
R") have
{f} on
bounded, decaying at {m} Fourier transform. Thence one could easily show
(problem 5) that m.-smooth functions f E Cm(Tn), or er(R"), have their Fourier transform/coefficients {T(k)}; {f^([)} decay at a polynomial rate:
Conversely, if Fourier transform
T([)
decays as
I [ I -p,
with p
> m+n,
then f(z)
is at least m-smooth. Both results are easily verified via the differentiation formula:
( 8 f j= (it)'?([),
and the obvious relation:
f^ = O( I ,$ I -"-')+?
E L'. Hence, by
52.2. Fourier transform on function-spaces Riemann-Lebesgue Theorem,
73
f = S-l(f^) E C,.
Thus Fourier transform relates the "degree of smoothness of f" to the "decay rate of f^ at (00)". More precise results, however, could be stated in terms of L2-norms, rather than uniform (L"). The main disadvantage of smooth functions from the standpoint of harmonic analysis, is that erndoes not allow a simple characterization in terms of Fourier transform/coefficients, which could done for Lz-functions. Thus we are naturally lead to the notion of Sobolev spaces.
Sobolev space X,, all their derivatives
{ti(@)
of order rn, consists of functions {u},which belong to L2 with E Lz: I (I I 5 rn}. It is equipped with the norm
The Plancherel Theorem and the differentiation rule of 52.1 give an explicit characterization of 36, in terms of Fourier transform/coefficients {ti(()} of u,
- sum of weighted L2-norms with polynomial weights w(()= (a. It is easy to check that the sum of monomials {ka} in (2.6) (respectively partials
{aa} in (2.5)), could be replaced by powers of (1+ I k I 2)m, respectively (l-A),,
where
A = V . V = Ca: is the Laplacian on Wn. So norm (2.6) is equivalent to IIuI?mz J ( 1 t
~E~2)m~~(()~z=~~(l-A)m~2~~~~.
In other words 4 takes Sobolev space 36, onto the weighted Lz-space, Lz(wmd() (or L2(wm)in the Tn-case), with polynomial weight turn(() = (1
+ I(I
2)m,
and
This allows to extend the notion of Sobolev n o m and derivatives (powers of
Laplacian) from integers to all real (fractional; negative) values of m. By definition,
I
(l-A)-% = T 1 ( 1 -t I [ I z)-s/24u = I(l+I ( 2)-s/2G([)e""'td[.
(2.7)
Fractional Laplacian (2.7) are given by convolution kernels, Bs*u, with the so called Bessel potential -s/2
B s = ~ ~ , ( I ~ I ) = ~ - "It1 ( 1 t) I, where K,(r)-modified Bessel function (3-rd kind) of order v = 2
Thus we get a scale of Sobolev spaces {X,:s 2 0 } ,
(problem 3).
62.2. Fourier transform on function-spaces
74
36, = (1-A)-"/2[L2] = B,*L2 = 9-'[L2(w,d()], where w, = (1+ I
t I ')'.
The above definition also extends for negative s by duality. Namely, we define space 36-, as the dual space (of distributions) to 36,, via the pairing,
( F I f) = J f ( z ) F W s =
J 3 ( 0 f i ( O d t , f E 36,;
F E 36-s.
(2.8)
We shall list a. few basic properties of Sobolev spaces. Theorem 1: i) Spaces (36,) form a continuous scale of embedded Hilbert spaces:
with 36-, = "dual to 36, via the natural pain'ng (2.8)".
ii) O n t o w 8" ( o r more general compact manifolds, domains) the embedding 36, c 36, is compact f o r all t < s. iii) Sobolev embedding: spaces (36,) are related to
{em}in the following way:
Xm c e, for m > n/2, more generally,
ern+'c 36, c em-n/2,for any m I s < m+1, Proof: (i-ii) Each 36, is mapped onto 36, by a fractional Laplacian (l-A)-m, which is Fourier-equivalent to a multiplication of ['-sequences
m = d-t 2 '
of coefficients by a
decaying sequence { a k = (1+ I k I 2)-m/2}, clearly a compact operator. (iii) Multiplying and dividing a sequence of Fourier coefficients of f E 36, by a polynomial weight (1+ I k
c
lakl
I 2)m/2,
and applying the Cauchy-Schwartz inequality, we get
=~~(1+~kI2)m/2a~J(1+I~I2)-n~2~~~{(1+I~I2)m'*~~}~~e2~(l+IkI*)-m
which shows that the Fourier series of u(z) =
C akeik
'
is absolutely convergent, whence
follows continuity.
Remark 1: The last statement of the Theorem extends to embedding of Sobolev spaces 36, into the LP-scale. The general result (Sobolev-Hardy-LittlewoodTheorem) claims: space
36,
c LP - continuously
embedded, i.e.
II f llLP I I ( 1 - 4 , h for all
;1,
(2.9)
$ = f - 3 (on R"), and $ 2 f - 3 (on 1").The argument exploits interpolation for
Bessel potentials B , E Lq, with q = y . Convolutions, u+B.*u, with such B, shifts any LP-space into Lr, where
$2.2. Fourier transform on function-spaces
Consequently, for negative s, a,,,,,
75
2 36-, 2 '3,,,-n,2. Therefore,
as claimed in (i).
Remark 2: Sobolev spaces provide a natural framework to analyze solutions of differential equations, as outlined in $2.3. This often requires Sobolev spaces of both integral and fractional order, as well as Sobolev spaces on manifolds and domains
RcW". Let us also notice that spaces 36, constitute "m-smooth vectors" of regular representation R on L2(Wn), or L2(T"), in the terminology of $1.4. 2.3. Distributions { F } are defined as continuous linear functionals on suitable spaces of test-junctions {u}, like em, em, etc. One usually writes them as formal integrals
/
( F I u ) = F(z)u(s)dz.
(2.10)
So for the class of bounded continuous functions, f E e ( X ) , all functionals are given by finite Borel measures p E A ( X ) , ( p I u ) = u(z)dp(z).Test-spaces en, em we equipped with a sequence of seminorms,
I
{Ilullm=
c
maz I a"u(z) I ;m = 1;2;...},
therefore the corresponding distribution spaces, called gm,goo,consist of functionals satisfying
m
I ( F I U ) I ICCIIuIIj.
(2.11)
j=O
Using (2.11) one can show Proposition: Any distribution F E bDm (m = 0; 1;..LO),is equal to a fznite sum of
derivatives of Borel measures, (2.12)
Integer m is called the (differential) order of F . Derivatives of measures in (2.12) are defined via pairing to smooth functions:
I f) =
/ aaf(.)dP(.).
The proof of (2.12) is fairly straightforward. Indeed, the m-jet map
f ( z ) 4 ) ( 4 :I a I I ml7 takes P ( R ) into the direct sum:
e, =
C(R") @ la1 5 m
- N-component vector functions on R";
N = (n+m m 1-
$2.2. Fourier transform on function-spaces
76
Distribution F defines a bounded linear functional (in the supnorm of
em c eN,which can be extended
through the entire space
vector-valued continuous functions, Idpa: I a
eN, is
e,)
on the image
e. But any linear functional on
given by an N-tuple of Bore1 measures
I I m}, QED.
Let remark that all natural linear operations on test-functions can be transferred to distributions by duality. For instance, differentiation is introduced via
( P F I u ) = ( F I (-a)%), by analogy with the standard "integration by parts" formula for test-functions. Clearly, daF E am, for any F E am, in fact aa:am+gm+I a I . Thus we get the following chain of test-function spaces along with their distribution-spaces
1-
00
...
ln7eEC ... C e m c ... c e c L ' c ~ = P o c ca,c
co
...c a = ua, (2.13) 0
Examples of distributions include (i) &functions and their derivatives: 6 z ( x ) = S(x-z), or (6(");u)= ( - 1) I a I u(a)(O), as well as their linear combinations, e.g. hA = cb(x-m) (A- lattice in Rn); (ii) &functions of hyper-surfaces and submanifolds: (bC I u) = J,udS, where dS is the natural surface area element on C, like the spherical distribution SS = (S = S,- sphere of radius r in Rn), that appears in the wave propagator solution of the wave equation); (iii) Certain singular integrals, like Halbert transform,
I
(HI u ) = P.V. +x
(principal-value integral) = lim
WX,
as well as its higher-D analogs, called Calderon-Zygmund integrals, can be interpreted as distributions ([Zy];[St];[SW]). (iv) Distributions often arise as limits of families of regular functions4, e.g. lim 1_ = H i~(x). ,4J z+ae
+
Another linear operation on functions, the change of variable, f +f o 4, can also 4Such approximating families {fc(z)}, called regularizations, exist for any F E 3.The easiest way to construct a regularization is to take a em- smooth approximate unity {hr+6}, e.g. h, = c-"h($), with h E ( h 2 0, and J h = l), and to convolve h,*F = f, (problem 1).
cr
$2.2. Fourier transform on function-spaces
77
be transferred to distributions (problem 2), def
( F 0 4 I 21) = ( F I
'&'4-7 jF ( l ) ( h ) 4-Y+. =
0
0
Distribution spaces on torus can be characterized by their Fourier coefficients, the same way as smooth functions. For any F E !Dm we define
bk = ( F I e-iz * k =
j
F(z)e-ik*z.
T"
Fourier coefficients of continuous functions, u(x) = x a k e i k ' 2 , are bounded and go to 0, as k-too, those of cm-functions decay at a polynomial rate, ak = o( I k I -"). Since, ( F I 21) = x a k b k (an extension of Plancherel's Theorem to pairs 'functiondistributions"), it is natural to expect {ak} to increase polynomially. Indeed, if F € 9,
I l b r l = l ( F l e i k * z ) l
(2.14)
for any F of order m. We shall illustrate (2.14) by the example of &function and its derivatives,
6=
C eik
*
I , so all bk= 1;
6(")=C(ik)a eik", so bk - (ik)a* The latter extends to all (integer and fractional) powers of the Laplacian:
(-A)sb=
C 1k12seik'z,or(1-4)'6=
~(1+Ik12)Seik*z.
Hence both belong to space gm,for m > 2s. Remark 3 On R" test-function and distribution spaces are defined similar to the compact (torus) case, but additional constraints are imposed at {co}. If no such constraints are
imposed (spaces
em and P)one gets
compactly supported C-spaces 2(';:
The R"-Sobolev spaces 36,
compactly supported distributions '3. Conversely,
Cr) give all distributions (with unlimited support).
satisfy all the properties (i-iii), except compactness of the
embedding 36, c 36,. To show for instance, the embedding: 36, c C,, for m
> n/2, we
replace Fourier sums by Fourier integrals,
If
3 E L',
then f =
the rate of decay of
fF'(3)E C,. 1 at
As in the torus case smoothness of f can be linked to
00,
f E cy *?(c) = O( I < I Conversely, sufficient decay rate O( I C I -"')
or
f E 36, *(I+ I < I m ) j E ~
2 .
off. o f f guarantees (m-g)-smmthness 2
52.2. Fourier transform on function-spaces
78
2.4. Schwartz functions and tempered distributions. The most convenient classes
of functions and distributions combine both features (smoothness and the decay rate ay {co}). These are so called Schwartz finctiom 9 and tempered distributions Y'. Space I consists of €?-functions, that decay faster than any polynomial, Y = {f:z*f (z)+O,as
(a)
z+co}, along with all their derivatives. It is equipped with a sequence of semi-norms,
I(f 1I.p
=
1 z*@f I Lm
; or equivalently
1 f llpq
1
= (1t I 5 I ')P(l-A)qf
/IL=-.
(2.15)
Let us that the choice of supnorm in (2.15) is not essential, it could be replaced with any other Lp-norm. Also the order of two operations (differentiation and multiplication) could be interchanged (problem 4). So space 9 can be characterized by semi-norms,
lp-A)p(l+ Space
Y
I I 2)Pf11L2 <
is sufficiently rich, it contains
(2.16)
{ep}; the
Gaussian { e - t z 2 } ;
{polynomials}x { e - t z 2 } , etc. The important features of the Schwartz spaces are due to the fact that T:Y+lf, represents an isomorphism of 3, i.e. semi-norms (2.15) or (2.16) of f and are equivalent. Schwartz (tempered) distributions Y' are linear functionals on Y. So distribution F E Y", if it satisfies,
7
I ( F I u)I 5 C
~ I 1lpq; I Ufor any Schwartz u.
This class includes all examples we encountered so far, like the lattice &function,
8,
6, = c 6 ( z - k ) ; its transform;
= z e i k z ; &functions of
hyper-surfaces, or
submanifolds in Rn; their derivatives, etc. We shall list a few other examples of Schwartz distributions and their transforms (see problem 7,8): i) Dirac-6 is transformed into constant 1, hence distribution 6 E KS, for s > n / C . ii) &function of subspace E
c Wn, 6E+(27r)n-k6E1;
where E' is the orthogonal
complement of E , k = dimE, iii) F = bS (&function of the r-sphere S) + P(() = cn(r I ( I )-"l2+lJ n/2-1('
I€ I)
- the Bessel function of order (;-I);
iv) fractional derivatives of Dirac 6: (-A)-",
(Riesz potential), and (1+ I ( I 2)-s/2
or (1-A)-s6
I ( I -2s
(Bessel) potentials (problem 9).
v) &function of the light cone C = { z = c
m
} in
W3 is Fourier-transformed
into 8&;0;C)
turn into
1 =r n H ( c C-
m),
52.2. Fourier transform on function-spaces
79
where H is the Heaviside function. So the Fourier transform of 6, is supported in the dual cone C ' = {(:(.z 2 0). isomorphically.
Y the Fourier transform maps Y'+Y'
As with
2.5. Analytic functions and the Paley-Wiener Theorem. After the Fourier analysis of LP-spaces and smooth functions
decaying functions LP, = { f :f (z)e"
{ern;Xm}, we turn
our attention to exponentially
I I E Lp}, and yet smaller spaces of compactly
supported functions. Clearly, in both cases the Fourier transform ?(() extends from the c Cn. In the former case the domain of
3
real space W" to a complex domain {( = (+iq}
is a tubular neighborhood of the real space R", O,= {(+if): 171
imaginary iq, furthermore,
1
I,r,z(d()
5 eprlllf
(2.17)
llL2'
The necessity of (2.17) is fairly straightforward. The proof of sufficiency is more involved. T o give the reader a flavor of the arguments we shall briefly outline the 1-D case. The proof exploits the so called LZ-Hardy spaces, made of analytic functions { F ( z ) } in the half-
>
plane H = {Sz 0}, square-integrable along lines {% = yo}, parallel t o the real axis, such that all L2-norms are uniformly bounded, m
]' I F(z+iy) I ' d z 5 C; for all y > 0.
-m
Any Hardy function F ( z ) is obtained by Fourier-transforming an Lz-function f ( i ) , supported on the positive half-line [O; m) (problem 6): 00
F ( z ) = f(t)e""' tdt,
z
E H.
(2.18)
0
A similar result holds for functions { F ( z ) } , holomorphic in the lower half-plane, the corresponding {f(i)} being supported on the negative half-line
(-00;
increasing functions { F ( z ) } (2.17) the support of {f(t)} gets shifted by
01. For exponentially p to the left/right, an
easy consequence of the Fourier-translation formula of J2.1:
eizpF(z) = 9 t - , J f ( i + ~ ) I , and the fact that {eazpF(z)}belongs to the Hardy Lz-class. Therefore, analytic function F ( z ) , exponentially bounded in both the upper and the lower half-planes, has its inverse 9-transform inside the interval [-p;p], QED.
62.2. Fourier transform on function-spaces
80
Problems and Exercises: 1. Riernann-Lebesgue Theorem: Fourier 1,ansfot-m ?(<) of any L'-function f on R" is continuous and goes lo 0, as [+m, i.e. f 6 e., Hint: Check the result directly for indicator functions {xe} of rectangular boxes: B=[al; b,] x ...x [a,;b J. Then use the standard density argument: any f E L' is approximated by linear combinations of xw 2. Three line Lemma: If function F ( z ) is holomorphic in a complex stn'p 0 < 9?ez has maximal values on both sides of the strip:
< 1, and
M , = auP(F(it)\ M1=sup I F(l+it) 1, t then F is bounded inside the strip'and /F(F(s+it) I
5 MA-";,
for all z=s+it.
1'. Truncate F ( r ) by a family of exponentials {Mb-'M;e('2-')~n}, 2
(i) product G,(z) = MA-zMfe(z -"/"F(z),
to ensure that
goes to 0, as z=s+it+m, and
(ii) maximal values of G, on both sides of the strip I1.
2 . Use the maximum principle for holomorphic functions to show IG,(z) Observe, G , ( z ) + F ( z ) , as n-m!
I 5 1, for all
z.
3. Prove the Riesz interpolation Theorem,
I s ( T f )(z)s(z) dz I IMA-":
IIf llp(s)II9 ll*'(s);
P'
=
gig
for a dense subset of stepfunctions functions {f;g}, i.e. linear combinations of the indicator functions {xi = ,yo ,} of subsets {Q C X).
1 . Represent: f =
Cajx3;
ck bkXk; with coefficients
3
g=
j
ie . a . = r .e 3; b, = pkei4,. 3
3
2 . It is convenient to use reciprocal Hijlder indices:
a =:;; p = I. 9' a 0- Po'
a,=+ 90
al, pl; a(.) = (1-z)ao+zal,
etc.
Introduce two families of functions (one-parameter deformations of f ; g) depending on complex z , - Cr+z)/aeiejxj; gz = c p j ,1-@(z)l/(1-@)ei4kxk, z -
3
where a,p in the denominators of powers of {r .}, { p , ) mean a ( s ) and p ( s ) for some real 0 < s < 1 (without loss of generality assume 11 = 1; 11 g 11 l-p = 1).
f]la
3 . Consider a holomorphic function F(z) = of the strip: 0 < 32er < 1. For
s T(f,)g,dz,
and estimate it on both sides
express F ( i t ) = $T(f)Gdz,in terms of new functions f = Crjao/aez(ej+...) x j ; G = C P k(l-@O)/(l-@)ei(~k+"')xk.
Apply the (ao;C)o)-estimate to the pair { j ; j } ,to show
Is
m
GdzII...
I~ollflll~aollGll'~@o=~o.
1-
Similarly, on the other side of the strip
IF(l+it)I
=I S T ( f , + i t ) S l + i t d ~ ( I M lIlf Ilo119111-p=M1.
Conclude the proof by the Three Line Lemma (problem 2).
52.2. Fourier transform on function -spaces 4. Outline the proof of the Interpolation Theorem (specifically the construction of holomorphic function F ( z ) ) , for a bilinear map T.
5. Compute LP-norm of the Gaussian and check the Beckner estimate of the YoungHausdorff constant (2.1). 6. Hardy classes on the half-plane [Hofl are defined by (2.18) with an L2-norm (or, more
generally, LP-norm, 1 < p < m). i) Hardy functions are known t o have the (limiting) boundary values in Lz (Lp):
1
F(z+ic)-F(z), as (-0, and F ( z )
1 5 C.
This holds for yet more general harmonic functions u(z) in {Sr> 0) (solutions of the u = 0, while F ( r ) solves only the Cauchy-Riemann Laplaces equation: Au = equation: 4 F = O!), as a consequence of the Poisson representation of u (§2.2),
I Py(z-r)u(T)dr, Y =r(22+y2)'
u(z+iy) = (Py*u)(z)=
with the Poisson kernel P&Z)
The latter forms an approximate unity {Py}, as y-0, i.e. P , 4 , and Py*u+u, for all u E LP (see problems 2,5,7 of 52.1 and problem 2 of $2.2). ii) Furthermore, analytic (Hardy) functions F ( z ) are represented through their boundary value by the Cauchy integral:
a convolution of the Cauchy kernel K , ( z ) = 2 4 2 parts are
WK = py(z) =
-+@(z) 2r(zZ+y2)
SK =Hy(z)=
2r(z2+y2)
+ iy)'
whose real and imaginary
- Poisson kernel;
+m;
where H denotes a distribution P.V.(i), called HilberZ transform (see 32.2, and [SW]). iii) The FouGer tran_sforms of both distributions, Hilbert H and Dirac 6, on R are easy t o compute: 6 = 1; H ( t ) = sgn t (52.2). iv) Use (i-iii) t o show that, any Hardy function F(z) in H is given by Fourier transforming an Lz-function f ( t ) on the half-line (2.18). The latter provides a crucial step in the proof of the Paley-Wiener Theorem.
7. Smooth regularization of distributions. Take a smooth compactly supported function h ( z ) , consider a family of dilations: h,(z) = r - " h ( z / f ) , and show that convolutions {h,*F} yield a family of regular functions, that converge t o F: ( f c 1 u)-(F I u), for any test-function u.
8. a ) Show that (6 o 4) = y
d ( z - y ) ,
E ToI 4 " V ) I
for the Dirac delta on R, sum over all zeros
ro= {y} of functiond. b) If$: R"+R, then (6 o 4) =
dS
4(z)= 0vgl' I
where d S is the Euclidian surface
element on the level set {z:d(z) = O}. 9. Bessel and Riesr potentials are formally _defined as Fourier transforms of tempered distributions: B , ( ( ) = (1 1 ( I z)-s/2, and R , ( ( ) = I ( I -'on R".
+
81
52.2. Fourier transform on function-spaces
82
i) Use polar coordinates and the Bessel-function representation of is = Jv(r ...) (on the r-sphere) to compute B,( I z I ) in terms of the modified Beasel function K,,. A Hankeltype integral relates Bessel functions J and K of the 1-st and 3-rd kind:
In our case v = n- 1; p = S- I. 2 2 ii) Check that Fourier transform takes homogeneous functions/distribuGons of degree s: f(tz) = t-'f(z), t > 0, into homogeneous functions of degree (s-n): f(t() = t""f((). Apply it to the Riesz potential to show, R,( I z I ) = C(s) I z I Compute constant
'-".
C(S).
10. Show that the Lm-norm in the definition of Schwartz functions Y can be replaced with any other Lp-norm. Show also that operations (1+ I z I 2, and (1 - A ) can be interchanged in the definition of 9. (Hint: apply a version of the Hardy-LittlewoodSobolev inequality (2.17) for LP-Sobolev spaces: 36: = (l-A)-'I2LP, to show that 36; is embedded in LQ, for = - & and
II f 11LQII (1-A)"'2f
IILP'
$2.3.Applications o f Fourier analysis
83
v.3.Some applications of Fourier anal+. Here we picked up a few selected topics and applications of the commutative Fourier analysis: Central limit Theorem of probability; the Heisenberg uncertainty principle; Finite Fourier transforms, Bochner’s Theorem and the Mellin transform. The latter has application to special functions and differential equations in R“, and also in the harmonic analysis on SL, (chapter 7).
3.1. The uncertainty principle. The Heisenberg uncertainty principle of the Quantum mechanics will be discussed in 56.2 of chapter 6. It has a simple Fourier-
for a n y function $ in
Iz I
and
I< I
Rn, such that $ and
4 are both square-integrable
with weights
respectively.
Rephrasing (3.1) in terms of the derivative (gradient) a$, we get
In this form it becomes an easy consequence of the standard integration by parts formula, /z$# =
/z(i I $ I
2)1
=
-$I 14 I ’,
(1-D); or/V$.z$ = -
I31
$ I ’(Vex) =
-51
I $ I 2, (n-D),
and the Cauchy-Schwartz inequality applied to the LHS,
I/z$.v+(/
lv$,~yz~
Izdi~)li2(l
Relation (3.2) implies that one can simultaneously localize functions $ and
4 at
I $ 11L2
(0) maintaining the Lz-norm = 1 (LHS), in other words, localizing supp($) in zspace will ‘‘stretch” its Fourier transform $, hence increase gradient, and vice versa. In quantum mechanics operators z: $+$, and &$+a$, represent the “position and momentum” of the quantum particle, while integrals
(1 I4
V d x ) and (IlW 1 2 4 ) estimate errors in their measurements. So the Heisenberg principle prevents
simultaneous precise determination of both operators to any degree of accuracy.
3.2. Finite Fourier transform. Here we shall briefly discuss the Fourier transform on finite commutative groups. The simplest of them is a cyclic group Z,. Its characters
52.3. Applications of Fourier analysis
84
coincide with the n-th roots of unity ( x Q $ j ) = w J } , where w = e z p ( F ) . So the dual group Z, N if,, and t,he Fourier transform on Z, becomes
c5
s:f(j)+?(e) =
f(j)w
3e.
(3.3) Characters { x Q= (wQJ)} form an orthogonal system of eigenvectors of the o53
n-1
translation operator R:f(j)+f( jtl),on space L*(Z,)
N
C"
, with norms
(x I x) = IIXIIZ = n. The inverse transform takes the form,
c
+i(j)= A
4-1:qe)
o
while the Plancherel formula,
a(e)w~l,
5 Q 5 n-1
llfllZ= ~lf(dlZ=AE I?(e,12=11?112, both being obvious consequences of the orthogonality of {xl}.
":I
We shall study now the czrculunt mat& A, that appears in many applications of finite groups (in linear algebra, probability, etc.),
[ :; :
... A = ... ... ... ... ...On-1 an a2
1 . -
each subsequent row of A is obtained by a cyclic permutation of the n-tuple (ul; ..a,,). Notice that matrix A is a convolution with function u(k) on Z,,
A f = a* f. So Fourier transform (3.3) applies to diagonalize A (find its eigenvalues and eigenvectors), compute inverse, determinant, etc. A specific model of such A is given by the
random walk on
Z,, where
az =a,
=f
(probabilities to j u m p from point (1) t o its neighbors (2) and {n) in a unit time), and the rest aJ = 0. More generally, we consider a stationary stochastic matriz':
C a , = 1 (aJ measures probability
aJ
2 0;
to j u m p from cite (1) t o { j ) ) .
Characters { A @ } form a complete set of eigenfunctions of A with eigenvalues,
c~,~J~,
A, = q e ) = - the l-th Fourier coefficient of function { ~ ( j ) l} ,= 0;1;...n-1. Diagonalizing A, via 4, 'Stationarity means that all rows of A are permutations of a single row, so the process is independent of the starting point: probability of "i+j"-jump depends only on the difference i - j E 2,: a . . = a(i-j). 13
92.3. Applications of Fourier analysis
85
allows to compute d e t A ; A-', all iterates A"', and yet more general "functions of A", B = f ( A ) . Indeed, any such B is itself a convolution with function b ( j ) , whose Fourier transform, b = f i?, so A
0
b(j)=T'[foi?] =
Sc e
foZ(e)wje.
As an application to random walk on Z,, we immediately find the probability distribution of the process after m steps (units of time), i.e. find entries of the m-th iterate Am. If p$:)+k denotes the probability of jump from j to j+k after m steps, then p$:)+k = s-'[xT].
Hence, pi:) =
ax
and P$:3)+k = 4
cosm (T); 2=e
e
c
cosm(@) cos(@).
e
Remark: More general finite groups G are known t o decompose into the direct product of cyclic groups, G cz
n Z,.
Hence, G =
nZ,
u G, and the Fourier transform reduces to
the Fourier transforms (1.3) on cyclic components of G. One interesting application of such finite Fourier transform is the random walk on the n-cube (problem 9).
3.3. Central Limit Theorem. Another interesting application of the Fourier Analysis is to r a n d o m walks on groups W , Z,or more generally, to sums of independent r a n d o m variables, S , = X,+X,+ ...+X,. Here we shall establish the Central Limit Theorem, that describes asymptotic distribution of S,, as n + w .
Any real random variable X defines a probability measure (distribution), d p X on R. Independence of two random variables X , Y means that their joint distribution d p x , y ( z , y ) on RZ is the product d p x ( z ) d p r ( y ) . So the sum of two independent random variables X + Y has distribution,
+x+,
= dPX*dClY (3.4) W. Another simple transformation of X ,
- convolution of two probability measures' on
scaling X + o X , results in the dilation of the measure dPx+dPx(3
(3.5)
We consider the sum of n independent identically distributed r a n d o m variables,
s,
x,,
= XI+ ...+
with equal probability distributions, d P x . = 4% 3
and ask about the asymptotic behavior of sums {S,} at large n. 'Convolution of L'-functions f*g on R" (or any group G) can be extended t o bounded measures {dm}, and other (compactly supported) distributions/generalized functions (see 92.2), via pairing to continuous test-functions
If).
$2.3.Applications of Fourier analysis
86
A typical example will be random walk on the lattice Z. Here variable X takes on values f 1 (jumps from
k t o k f 1) with equal probabilities
f, so dp = 36,+6-,).
Then the sum
of n variables, S,, measures the position of the walk after n time-steps, relative to the initial point.
It turns out that the limiting (large n ) behavior of sums {S,} carries some universal features, independent of a particular distribution dp. In what follows, we always talk about convergence of random variables {Y,} in the distributional (weak) s e m e , namely,
Yn+Y, if
I
fdpy
n-I
f d p y , for any continuous f(z)on W.
Theorem 1: L e t { X n } r be a sequence of independent identically distributed r a n d o m variables with mean: E = xdp(x), and the dispersion
I
0=
J
I(x-E)'dp = z'dp - E2 > 0.
Then n
(i) S, = EXi has n o limiting distribution, as n+w. j=1
.
(ii) $ , 4 , n
(iii) L E ( X I . - E ) + N ( E ; U ) = 0.
normal distribution with dispersion
J;;1
Rephrasing Theorem 1 we can say that the mean value of sum: E(S,) increases linearly with n, while its dispersion o(Sn-nE) u f i , grows as f i .
-
= nE,
The proof exploits the notion of the characteristic function of variable X ,
the Fourier transform of measure p. The characteristic function has the following properties:
A ) d(() is continuous and positive-definite 7, for all tuples
{t1;... tn} in R and {al; ... an] in C; also d(0) = 1; Id(€) I 51.
B) if measure dp has all moments to order k, i.e. 'The converse result is also true (see Bochner's Theorem below). is also true. Namely (problem 12): any positive-definite continuous function on group R; R", or more general commutative G , is the Fourier transform of a positive (probability) measure.
52.3.Applications of Fourier analysis then function
I
I z J I dp < co, j=O;
d(<) if k-smooth, and its derivatives:
87
1; .A,
#(O)
= iE; d"(0) = -o-E2.
C ) For any sequence of random variable { Y k } measures dp,
iff q5~n(<)+&(<),
n
uniformly on compact sets of R. The first two properties follow directly from the definition of 3 and positivity of measures dp. The last one relies on the fact that families of exponential {e'"(} with ( varying over compact sets D, approximate all continuous functions {f} on compacts in {z}. So the convergence of characteristic functions is equivalent to the weak convergence of measures. We consider characteristic functions
{dn} of S,.
By (3.4)
d"(0 = %*P*...*P) where
d(<) = b(() -
= d(O",
the characteristic function of a single variable distribution dp.
4 1, i.e. p = 6. This proves (i). Next we apply (3.4) and (3.5) to the =ergodic mean" AS,,, Property (A) shows that
d(<)" does not
converge to a continuous function, unless
ds,/,(€) = d(4". Taking the Taylor expansion of
d(() at
{0}, we get
{ 1 + iETi € + O(n-')}"+e'tE= '5(15,),as n+co. This implies by (C), dps /,,+bE,
(*r,
as claimed in (ii). Finally, Fourier transforming
of variable Y , = L ( S ,
distribution-measures dpy
- nE),
we get by (3.4)-(3.5),
J;; where 4 denotes thne shifted measure d p ( z + E ) , with the zero mean,
I
z d p ( z + E ) = 0.
Taking the Taylor expansion of 1 €2
(1 -lo,+O(n
-3
d(<) at 0 we get by (B)
11n+,-oE
2/2
(e-z2/2u)
=9
- the Gaussian.
Sequence of measures {dp, } converges, as above, to the normal distribution, QED. n
We shall illustrate the foregoing argument with an example of the random walk on the lattice aZ (problem 8). Then measure d p = f ( ~ 5 ~ + 6 - has ~ ) , characteristic function $6 = corn( = (1
jxdp = 0,
with mean: and dispersion: Hence, the limit:
-$[ "...},
0
= jx2dp = 2.
(1 - 2n a2t2
+ ...) +e -a2(2/2*
88
52.3.Applications of Fourier analysis 3.4. Positivedefinite functions and Bochner’s Theorem. In the previous part we
I
encountered Fourier transforms of positive (probability) measures q5(€) = e-jZ ’ (dp(z), which are positive-definite on R (or W”) in the sense of definition (6). It turns out that all positive-definite functions are obtained in this way. Bochner’s Theorem: Any continuous positive-definite function q5(()
on
W” is the
Fourier transform of a positive (probability) measure,
q5(() =
j
ei= * % p ( z ) .
Two direct arguments, outlined in problem 5, utilize spectral theory of selfadjoint operators, and regularization of distributions. There is yet another fairly general argument, based on the convezity and eztreme points. It applies to all locally compact groups (and even more positive functionals on Banach algebras). We observe that the set of all continuous positive-definite functions {q5} is a convex cone 36 in space e(W”), aq5 b$ is positive-definite, along with {q5;$}, for any
+
pair of coefficients a , b > 0. When normalized at {0}, subset 36, = {q5:q5(0) = 1 ) becomes a convex compact set in the Banach space
e.
c 36,
Any convex compact I< in a
+
Banach space has the set of eztreme points, e z ( K ) = {$:$ # adl ( l - a ) & } . By the general Krein-Milman Theorem, any point inside K can be represented by a “convex linear combinations” of extereme points. In other words, for any q5 E I<, there exists a probability measure d,u&$), supported on ez(K), so that q5 is a baricenter of dp,
(3.7) Applying this result to positive-definite functions one first shows that ex(%,) consists precisely of all characters {$,(()
= eiz‘t} (“extreme directions” in 36 must be
translation-invariant!). Hence, by the Krein-Milman, any q5(() = je-jr
*
(d,u(~),QED.
Remark The Bochner’s Theorem has a far reaching extension to noncommutative groups, known as Gelfand-Naimark-Segal Theorem. The latter characterizes positive-definite functions on G in terms of matrix-entries of unitary representations. The extreme points of % are then identified with irreducible representations, and formula (7) gives a decomposition of a unitary representation Td, associated to 4, into the direct sum/integral of irreducibles.
3.5. Mellin transform. Mellin transform of function f(t) on the half-line t E [O;m)
defined by integrating f against a family of multiplicative characters {X,(t) = t S ; sE C} with respect to the multiplicative-invariant measure d p = $ on R+;
is
$2.3.Applications of Fourier
89
analysis
t,7 E R+,
d p(t7) = d p ( t ) , for all
m
-m:j(t)+3(s) = p ( t ) t s - ' d t .
(3.8)
0
So A can be viewed as Fourier transform on the multiplicative group R+. Its inverse 31t-l is obtained by integrating T ( s ) over the imaginary line: {Res = b } i.e. { s = b iu},
+
F+f(t) = &Jmf(.)t-Sds.
(3.9)
b-im
A few important examples of the Mellin transform include 1) r-function:
r(s)=
T
e-tts-ldt
= ~ t L [ e - ~and ];
0
7
2) ~ - s r ( s= ) e-"ts-'dt
=~ [ e - ' ~ ]
0
the latter can be also viewed as the Laplace transform, L:f(t) = ts-'+F(X) = ~ ( S ) X - ~ ; W
3) r ( s ) r ( l - s) = /&t% 0
=
-+&I
4) Bessel function of the 3-rd kind (McDonald):
I%-$('
W
K,(r) =
+ l/t)"tu-ldt = At+v[e-i(t
+ l/l)z]
(3.10)
0
5) Riemann Zeta-function:
Formulae (1) and (2) are essentially the definition of r; function I{, of (4) is directly verified to satisfy the modzjied Bessel equation (problem 10); two remaining relations (3), (5), however, would require further explanation. The former (3) is based on the so called B-function,
for special values p = s, q = 1-s. The latter exploits formula (2) and the definition of Riemann zeta-function.
Let us remark that all examples (1)-(5) of Mellin transforms involve integrals of the form
$2.3. Applications of Fourier analysis
90
m
Z(s) =
F(t) tS-'dt, 0
with certain meromorphic/rational function F. Such integrals can be evaluated by the Residue Theorem, combined with the branch-cut along the half-line R+, Z(S)
=2 1-e2"'8 %
Res,j(F)z;-';
sum over all residues (poles) of F.
Fig.1: Branch cut and residues of e-z/2
F(z) = 2 sinh 212 in the Zeta-function transform. Here poles: zk = 2 r i k ; k = f 1; f 2; ...
Thus we compute the right hand side of (3) and (5), and find (3.12) ) s - l ( z b ) " z . - ](5) &[ A 2 sinh t / 2
- sin(?)
As the result we derive the functional equations for I' and Z-functions, which relate their values at {s} to those at {-s}, (3.13)
The Mellin transform, in general, and functional equations (3.13), in particular, play extremely important role in the analysis of both functions, numerous applications (see
r
and 2, and their
[Tit];[Ven];[Ter];[HST]). We shall see m in the next section,
and later in chapter 7 (representations and harmonic analysis of SL,). The standard notion of Zeta-function (11) can be extended to Zeta-functions of differential operators L (e.g. Laplacian on a manifold),
Z L ( s )= tr(L+) =
C Ale-';
{ Ak}-eigenvalues of L.
Analytic continuation (regularization) of Z L ( s ) , particularly, its zeros, poles and residues in C, contain some interesting spectral and geometric information about operator L (57.6). Among other things it allows to define a seemingly absurd (but highly useful) entity, the "determinant of L", det(L) = e-' one finds from (3.13), Z(0) = -f; Z'(0) = -$ln(27r).
I
('1. For the standard Riemann Z
52.3.Applications of Fourier analysis
91
Problems and Exercises: 1. Work out an example of the random walk on Z with uneven probabilities: p (jump to the right) and p = 1-p (jump to the left). What is the most likely position after n (large) steps? What is the probability t o find oneself in the range [ ( p - q ) n + a f i ; ( p - q)n P f i ] after n steps?
+
2. Apply the finite Fourier transform to the random walk on the n-cube
11
I, x
... x Z,
x
to
find P$:$~. 3. Verify that function K = K , ( z ) of (10) satisfies the modified Bessel's equation in variable I, a K " + $ K ' + ( l + Sz) K = 0. 4. Evaluate integrals (12) and establish functional equations (13) for
r and Z.
5. Prove Bochner's Theorem in two possible ways.
i) Using spectral theory of self-adjoint operators (Appendix A). Hint: show that the quadratic form, determined by 4,
(S,?
I 3)= J I d(t-~)3(O%dtdq > 0,
is positive for all functions f E 2'
nA, hence defines an inner product on A n L', II f Ib = (043I 3).
A
,
.
The regular representation, R,f = f(<-u), is unitary in Ailbert space Xd = 11 lidclosure of A n L ' . Furthermore, space %+ has cyclic vectors: any f, whose Fourier transform f(z)# 0, for all 2. Observe, that Bochner's Theorem is equivalent to the spectral decomposition (existence of spectral measure dp) for a family of commuting unitary operators {R,) on Xd, or for their infinitesimal generators (Appendix A). ii) Direct prpof of Bochner's Theorem on groups R"; Z", exploits a regularization of distribution d(z) by an approximate unity (problem 2): pJ2)
= €-"p(f),
p(z) 2 0; J p d z = 1.
Set Jc = pcq& and show that {$<} defines a family of positive linear functionals on continuous functions e(R") (or T"),
I(i,lf)l 5d(O)llfIlm; ( & l I ) Z O , Conclude that
forf20.
4 =€lim4 04,is a finite positive measure d p on R" of 11 p 11 = d(0).
52.4. Laplacian and related differential equations.
92
52.4. Laplacian and related differential equations. The Fourier transform provides an efficient tool in the study of differential/difference equations on R”; T”, due to its diagonalizing properties. Solving a differential equation is then reduced t o an algebraic problem, followed by the Fourier inversion. The utility and power of Fourier analysis will be shown by the basic examples of differential equations (heat, wave, Schriidinger), associated t o the Laplacian - the most symmetric of all differential operators on R”. In all case8 we shall construct explicit fundamental solutions (Green’s functions) and analyze their properties. After the freespace Green’s functions are constructed and analyzed in via the Fourier techniques in part (I), we turn t o the boundary-value problems in special regions (part (11)). Our analysis will emphasize groupsymmetries of the problem (discrete and continuous). One such techniques exploits the reductions (separation) of variables t o bring the problem t o exactly solvable ODE. Another one, known as the “method of images”, gives solution of the boundary-value problem expressed through the free-space Green’s function, subjected t o a finite/discrete group of transformations. Our third example, the ball problem, exploits yet another conformal symmetry of the Laplacian.
4.1. The role of Fourier transform in differential equations is that 9 diagonalizes all constant coefficient differential operators: L = a , < a(,Da, ( D = +a), on R”; I Tn.Namely,
TL[u]= a(<)G((),for all
{u},
or TLT-’ = a(<).
So 4 takes L into a multiplication with a polynomial function a(() = C a a t a , called symbol of L. This clearly follows from the eigenvalue property of exponentials {eic‘”} for any such L. In fact, {eiz.(} form joint eigenfunctions of all such operators8, with symbol a(() serving as “joint eigenvalue”. In many applications operator L is the Laplacian - A , or more general elliptic operato? L = - v ‘ p v q, with a positive
+
definite coefficient-matrix p = (pjk). A few basic examples of differential equations associated to operator L include:
I. Elliptic: -(L
+ X)u = f; (called Helmholtz, or “reduced wave” equation)
8 0 n torus 1” characters {erm*’} are honest L2-eigenfunctions, while on R” they represent the generalized eigenfunctions (bounded, but not L2). ’We keep a convention of writing elliptic operators with sign (-), to make L a positive operator: (Lf I f ) =
J C p i j ( a i f ) ( a j f ) d z 2 0, for all {f}.
93
$2.4. Laplacian and related differential equations
11. Parabolic (heat-difbion): a,u
+ L[u]= f; for u = u(s;t )
111. Elliptic equation in n+l variables: (a2 - L)u = f (called Poisson); IV. Hyperbolic (wave): utt + t [ u ]= f(s;t) V. Schrodinger: atu = iL[u]. Each equation must be supplemented by an appropriate boundary and initial
conditions. On regular boundaries (hyper-surfaces C c R”) one usually takes one of the 3 basic conditions: u I = ... (Dirichlet); d,u I r:= ... (Neurnann); or more general
+
I
( a ,LM,)u = .... (mized). The condition at (00) (“singular point”) typically require u to be bounded, or to have a prescribed asymptotics (incoming/outgoing “radiation
condition”). The initial conditions depend on the type of equation. One has u 1 t=O = uo (for elliptic/parabolic problems 11-111; V), and Ilt=O uo; (for hyperbolic IV).
{;
I
t=o - u1 We recall the general definition of the Green’s function, for a boundary value problem t
M[u] = F; in D . (4.14) B[u] = h; on aD’ where M could be any differentiafoperator in a space (or space-time) region D (e.g.
M = - V . pV+q; or
at2- V . pV+q),
and E a suitable boundary/initial conditions on
a D (e.g. B = a + pa,). The Green’s function (fundamental solution) of (4.14) is a n integral kernel K(z;y), or K(z,t;y,s) (possibly distributional) on D x D , that satisfies the differential equation M in z-variables with the 6-source at {y}, (also the formal adjoint equation in y-variables with the 6-source a t {z]), and the zero boundary conditions,
BJK] = 0
M,*[K] = ~ ( z - Y ) By[K] = O *
For instance, heat-problem (11) has operators M = , = 8,
+ L,,
M*,, ,=
(4.15)
- a, + L,,
and
the Green’s kernel K(z,y;l-s). Function K of either one of problems (4.15) allows t o solve a nonhomogeneous system (4.14) with an arbitrary RHS { F ; h ] ,
+
u(z) =
K(z;y)F(y)dy P(z;y)h(y)dS(y); dS-surface area element on aD. J D So the Green’s term K gives a contribution of the “continuously distributed sources”
F I D, while the so called Poisson term P(z;y) on D x a D , those of the “boundary sourcesn h
I
The Poisson kernel P(z;y) is not independent of K, in fact, K is
constructed explicitly in terms of K and the boundary operator B. For instance, the Dirichlet condition for
L = -V .pV + q, yields
P(z;y) = p(y)a, K(z;y) (normal derivative of K in y o n the boundary), Y
while the Neumann condition gives
52.4. Laplacian and related differential equations.
94
P(z;y) = p K ( z ;y), for z E D;y E aD. Similar constructions, based on Green’s identities could be given for arbitrary M and boundary operator B.
I. Formal solutions and frespace Green’s functions. We shall construct fundamental solutions (Green’s functions) for each of problems (I-V) in
Wn, by first writing its formal solution, then applying the
Fourier analysis. Formal solutions of problems (I-V) can be written in the form of certain ‘functions” of L”. Thus we get
u = (A
+
u = etL‘[uo] and similarly,
+ L)-’[f], for the elliptic problem (I);
1:
e(t-s)L[f(...;s)]ds, for the heat-problem (11),
u = eitL[uo];for the Schrodinger problem (V). Here uo represents the initial value of u,and f - its RHS, the “heat-sources”. Elliptic L‘n+l”- problem (111), is solved by
*
u=e 4 [ u 0 ] .
< 00 (unbounded range), one takes the negative “forward-stable” exponential {e-‘...}, while finite time-intervals, a 5 t 5 b,
So in the half-line case: 0 5 t
with 2-point boundary condition require a suitable combination of 4 exponentials. The wave problem (IV) is solved in either of 2 forms,
The choice depends on the type of the LLboundaryconditions” in t-variable, either “initial” at t=O, or “asymptotic” at t = f00. In all cases (I-V) fundamental solution { d ( L ) }is given by an integral kernel,
K ( z ;y), called the Green’s function of the problem. For constant-coefficient L these are convolution-integrals K = K(z-y), due to translational invariance of operator L. The Fourier transform yields explicit form of kernels K ( z ) , z = z-y. By definition of K we have to find a distribution
K ( z ) , z=z-y,
that satisfies the equation,
luuFunctions of L” for a self-adjoint operator, could be given precise meaning via diagonalization (spectral resolution) of L. Given a diagonal (multiplication) operator D:d(A)+Ad(A), on Lz(dp)-space of functions/sequencea {d(A)), function f ( D ) is also a multiplication operator, f ( D ) :d+f(A)d(A). But any self-adjoint L is unitary equivalent to a diagonal operator: L = U D U - ’ , then f(L)= U f ( D ) U - (Appendix A).
’
$2.4. Laplacian and related differential equations
L [ K ]= 6(z-y).
95
(4.16)
Applying ’3 to both sides of (4.16) we get
where aL(<) is the symbol of L. So we immediately get the transformed Green’s function 1 R(t) = -
(4.17)
ad€)’
in other words “symbol of K” is inverse to “symbol of L”. Then it remains to Fourier-invert l / a L ( ( ) to recover K. The Fourier-inversion, however, involves the techniques of complez analysis, distribution theory, and also
reduction of variables via group-symmetries, as we shall demonstrate below. 4.2. Laplacian is the most symmetric of all differential on
Wn as it
commute
all translations and rotations (Euclidian motions). In fact, A generates all such operators, in the sense that any operator M on a suitable functionthat commutes with En is a convolution with a radiallyspace (LZ;Lf’;ew), symmetric function M ( I z I ),
WuI=
pc I
5
- Y I MY)dY.
(4.18)
The Fourier-transform of (4.18) gives a multiplication-operator with another radially symmetric function
% = F( I t 1 ),
u ^ - q I t I )u^, where F ( p ) is related to M ( r ) through the reduced Fourier-Bessel (Hankel)
transform (52.1-2.3). Since, p2 is the symbol of - A , we can call M a “function of A”, M = F ( m ) .The proof of (4.18) is an easy application of the Fourier transform. It contains 2 statements. Theorem 1: i) A n y translation-invariant operator M on a suitable function-class
(e.9. Schwartz) is a convolution: MR,u = R a M u , for all a E Rn, and all u E Y,+ M [ u ]= f * u , f o r some distribution f .
ii) Rotationally-symmetric convolutions, M T , = T,M, g E Sqn), are given by radial functions, f = f( I z I ). Indeed, any such M is taken by 9 into an an operator
% = 9M9-’,that
commutes
with multiplications by characters { e i b * t},
--
f i e i b * = eib ’ €I@, for all b E R”. A-
Hence
A
fi commutes with all multiplications, M h = h M , h in the Fourier-algebra A. But
52.4. Laplacian and related differential equations.
96
algebra A contains sufficiently many functions, so any operator, commuting with A must
= F ( ( ) , so Mu = k*u. The 2-nd statement is obvious, as 5
itself be a multiplication,
takes radial functions into radial.
Our discussion will be limited to the Laplacian, L = -A, although many results and techniques extend to more general (2-nd and higher-order) operators. The corresponding Green's functions then become inverse '%transforms of certain symbols. i) resolvent kernel: RX(z)= (X+L)-
4(, ii) heat-semigroup (Gaussian): G,(z) = etL has 9[Gt] = G ( t ; t )= e-t I ( I 2.
has Fourier transform P(t;t )
iii) half-space Poisson kernel: Pl(z)= e-td, = e-,
(a semigroup, generated by
a)
I.
JL JL'
sin I
iv) cos- and sin-type 'waue propagators": U , = c o s t a ; V , =*-
U ( z ; t )= ( 2 ~ ) - ~ j c o Is [( 1t )e'c'zd(. sintI(1
.
V ( z ; t )= ( 2 ~ ) - " 1 ~ e ' ( ' ~ d ( . or the unitary group { e
generated by
fi.
v) Schrodinger propagator W, (a unitary group generated by L),
W, = (21)-n/ei(t I t I 2+t.z)dt. In some cases the Fourier-inversion is easy and straightforward like for the Gaussian and Schr6dinger propagators (problem 5 of 52.1)'
L
I
I
I
The latter is obtained by analytically continuing G,to imaginary time, t-it. 4.3. The resolvent kernel R(z;X)is expressed through the Bessel functions of the 1-st and 3-rd kind [Leb];[Erd];[WW]of order Y = - 1,
5
(4.20)
In the limiting case, eigenvalue X = 0, the Green's functions (-A)-' with the classical Newton's potentials:
coincides
$2.4. Laplacian and related differential equations
97
To derive (4.20) we notice, that all kernels (i-v) are radial functions of z , an easy consequence of the underlying rotational symmetry of A. Writing integral R(z;A) in polar coordinates
I z I = p;
I € 1 = r, we get (4.21) The inner integral gives the
80
called Poisson representation of the Bessel function J,, u =
5- 1,
Hence we get in (4.21)
The latter integral can be evaluated by complex integration in the r-plane of holomorphically extended Bessel function J,, whence comes K , ( z ) = J,(iz). We shall illustrate the foregoing argument in R3. The inner integral r r p cos
2sin rp (4.22) sinode = -. rP ' since J 1 , 2 ( z ) is an elementary function &. We substitute the RHS of (4.22) in the outer je.
0
Jnt
4.4. The half-space Poisson kernels. Next we turn to the Poisson kernel Iin the half-space W?+'. The 1-D Poisson kernel is computed directly
- e-tl t-
(problem 5 of 52.1),
The multidimensional case is, however, more subtle, and could be derived via the so called subordination principle, which allows to express the Poisson-semigroup, generated by
fi,in
terms of the heat-semigroup, generated by L, (4.23) The derivation of (4.23) is fairly straightforward, via 1-D Fourier transform (problem 1). In the case of Laplacian L = -A on Rn, we get the Poisson kernel P ( z ;t) in RT++' in terms of the Gaussian { G t } . By (4.24) and an explicit form of the Gaussian (4.19) we find,
98
$2.4. Laplacian and related differential equations.
P, = tn(1 +
Cn Cnt ' I I 2 / p ) ( n + 1)/2 - ( p + I I 2 ) ( n + 1)/2
(4.25)
(4.26) is then given by the convolution integral: u ( z ; t )= P l * f , with kernel (4.25). As an application of (4.19), (4.25) one can show
Theorem 2 Solution u ( z ; t ) of the elliptic Dirichlet problem (I.%), and the initialvalue heat-problem: ut = Au;u I t=O = f, converges to the boundary value f(z)as t+O.
The proof is outlined in problem 2. After the Dirichlet Poisson problem is solved we can proceed to the Neumann problem for the half-space Laplacian, (4.27) The formal solution of (4.27)
-f=3-t'%
21 = = &t[fl, is given by the conjugate Poisson erne1 related to P , via
co
&(...;t ) = / P (...;3) ds, and P = $. d
(4.28)
t "Let us remark that Green's functions (i-v) are related one t o the other through various transforms. For instance, the resolvent RA is obtained by Laplace-transforming the heat-semigroup G t , (A
+ L)-'
do
=
1e-"-Ltdt, 0
while (4.27) gives a similar representation for P,. Formula (4.27) exemplifies such relations. It represents a special case of the so called Sonin-Mehler integral representation of modified Bessel functions of the 3-rd kind (McDonald functions) OD
K J r ) = i J e t p [ - ( t + t ) i ] t-'-'dt. 0
Precisely, (4.28) correspond t o order u = elementary, K 1 / J r ) = &e-'.
i, the
only case, when Bessel-function becomes
99
52.4. Laplacian and related differential equations
00
as a consequence of an identity, L-le-tL = Se-sLds. Substituting (4.28) in (4.25) we t find
So the Neumann problem (4.27) is solved by the convolution kernel ti(";
t ) = &(...;t)*f.
4.5. Wavepropagatom. We shall use Poisson kernels P and Q, found in the previous part to find the wave-propagators, U ( z ; t )= c o s c t a , V =
9
= 0,
i.e. fundamental solutions of the propagation) with 2 different-type initial conditions:
( c = speed of
u I t=O = 0 ; for V . "tIt=o = 0' "1 I 1=0 = As in the Gaussian case this will be accomplished via analytic continuation of
I t=o = *. for u, or
*
the time parameter through the imaginary axis, t-it. The Fourier transforms of both propagators: n
U ( &t ) = cos ct
sin ct I < I I ( I , V((;t= ) 1c1 ' n
*-
as well as Poisson P , are easily inverted in 1-D. Thus,
turns into a Heavi.de jump-function, truncated at { fc t } . Similarly, the cos-propagator,
cos(ct I c I ) = ;(eict I c I + ,-ict I € I )
* u = ;{*(Z-ct) + *(z+ct)},
which is the sum of the right and left-traveling *-pulses, the classical d'Alambert solution. One has to compute two limiting distributions:
In dimension n = 2 both are given by certain densities,
$2.4. Laplacian and related differential equations.
100
{I
z-y I 5 c t } . So for each fixed t > 0 support of U(..;t); V( ...;t ) belongs to a disk of radius R = ct, centered at the source12 {y} (fig.2). In 3-D space we get supported in the light-cone
1
1
2ECt
I z I 2 + (c+ict)Z - I z I 2 t (r-ictlz} = lim (c2t2- I I 2 + E 2 ) 2 + qE2
2 t 244.29)
The RHS of (4.29) represents a limiting distribution of the family
{wd=*} I ’.
with a regular function f = fr(.z) = cZtZ- I z
From the basic distribution theory of
$2.2, we find,
where dS means the natural surface element on the level-set {f = 0). In other words, the limiting distribution bf is made of the “zero-level” &function of f , divided by a continuous density IVf(z) 1 . In our case (4.29) we get
Vt(Z) = k b ( c t 2 V,(z) = a,v = + ( 4*(ct)
12 1 2 )
=(6’47rct
12
I z I - C t ) t &a’(
I -Ct) I2 I -C t )
So the 3-D wave-propagator { V ; V }can be thought of either as distributions in supported on the forward light-cone C = ((2;t): I z I = c t } c R4, or as a t-parameter family of spherical &functions ( 6 * of radius R = c t } in R3. The SR* corresponding solution of the initial value problem: u I = f ; ut I = g, in 2-D and 3-D (2;t)-variables
are given by convolution kernels,
Remark: Similar expressions hold for higher-D wave-problems. Namely, the Green’s functions V ( z ;t); V ( z ;t ) are given by distributions supported either inside the light cone
C,{ 1 z I 5 ct} (even dimensions), or on the surface of the cone { I z I = ct}, as illustrated in fig.:! below (problem 4). The exacts solution of the n-D wave problem are given in terms of spherical means of function f,
1 M,f(z) = ,n-l wn-l
s
lyl =P
f(Z-Y)dS(Y),
-Green functions are often called point-sources, aa they describe solutions produced by sharp (&type) initial impulses.
$2.4. laplacian and related differential equations
101
where w , - ~ is the area of the unit sphere in R". Then the initial data u I, = 0; ut10 = f(z), yields [Hell u(2; t ) = 2 (n-2)! -0-2
1
[
~ { M 8 f ) ( x ) s ( t z -n-3 s2)~ds
(4.31)
In special cases n=2;3 one recovers solutions (4.30). Formula (4.31) demonstrates the
Huygens principles for solutions of the wave equation: any initial disturbance propagates inside the light-cone based on supp{f) with a finite speed c. Furthermore, in odd dimensions disturbance of any finite extent vanishes after a signal passes (sharp Huygens
principle), whereas in odd dimensions once a particular space-point is reached by the disturbance will remain forever, dying out exponentially fast with time. Indeed, derivatives of integral (4.31) in odd dimensions take the form
c
Pk(t)a:[M'f
1,
with some polynomial coefficients { P k ( t ) } .
Fig. 2. The forward and backward light-cones for the wave equation. The left figure (forward) shows a point-source solution (Greens function) at 3 differenl lime cross-sections. At each 1 the disturbance is localized either on the surface (sphere S R ( x ) of radius R = ct, centered at the source {t}), or inside the ball BR(z) = { yx I 5 ct}. The right figure shows the domain of dependence: any solution u(z;t) depends on the initial data inside the ball { I y-+ I 5 ct). There are different way to derive (4.31), all exploiting to some degree the underlying group symmetry of the problem. We shall mention 2 of them: [He121 (chapter 1) is baaed on the Radon transform on R" (and rotational symmetries), whole R. Howe [How] presents an elegant derivation baaed on the representation theory of the Heisenberg group (cf. $6.2).
We have summarized the main results of the section in the table at the end of the section. It. Symmetries and differential equations in regions of R".
After we obtained the free-space fundamental solutions in Wn, let us turn to boundary-value problems. The analysis below will emphasize group-symmetries (discrete
102
52.4. Laplacian and related differential equations.
and continuous), and whenever possible provide explicit formulae and constructions of Green's functions. Of course, our discussion will be limited to special classes of symmetric regions and differential equations.
(I = f(L) L; region Q), which
4.6. Symmetry reduction and the sou~cecondition. Green's function
clearly inherits all original symmetries of the problem13 (operator
allows to reduce the number of variables in the Green's function K . For instance, hermitian symmetry,
L = L*,implies symmetry of integral kernel, K ( z ,y) = It'*(y, z)
complex conjugate. Time-independence of L means that K = I'(t-s;
5,y)
-
are time-
convolutions kernels. Similarly, constant-coefficient, i.e. translational-invariance of L in R" yield translational-invariant (convolution) kernels K = K(z-y). Larger symmetry groups play the role for special operators L, like orthogonal rotations S q n ) for the Laplacian/Helmholtz operators: A , A + m 2 on Rn, and hyperbolic rotations 5 q l ; n ) for the d'Alambertian (wave operator) 0 = 6': - A , or the
Klein-Gordon (KG) operator: a: - A f m2.The corresponding Green's functions, It'(z) or K ( t ; z ) ,z = z-y, retain the symmetries of L, which allows to reduce Zt' to a single variable function I'(r), of the Euclidian or hyperbolic radius: T = I z I , or r = In both cases the radial function I' solves the reduced ODE,
d q .
which is singular at the end-points r = O;m, hence requires an appropriate boundary condition at both. The "source condition" refers to a proper choice of the boundary condition at a "singular (source) point". We shall demonstrate with 2 familiar examples. 4.7. Elliptic Caae. Laplacian/Helmholtz-type operator: L = -A
+ q.
The condition at (0)
represents the so called Upoinl-source",
,.
p - 1 ~ 1
()Ir=O==
1
(4.33)
2rnI2 - surface area of the unit sphere in R". To derive (4.33) we take any where Cn-l =---
r("/a
function u(y) on R", write L[u]= F(y), apply kernel K(z,y) to the equation, and integrate by parts (Green identity) over the complement R = R"\B,(r), of a small ball B , ( z ) centered at {z}. On one hand,
W -e shall not pursue any systematic study of symmetries in differential equations here, but refer to the recent book [Olv], which explores the subject in great depth (see also [Ovs];[Mil]). Our goals will be limited to exploiting some apparent and well know (geometric) symmetries, rather than investigate all of them.
82.4. Laplacian and related differential equations
103
but
First integral in the RHS vanishes, since L,[K] = 0 outside of the source. Remembering that
K = K ( Iz-y
I ), we get the second integral
f while the third
4
... = Cn-l F 1 K ’ ( e )(u(z)+ o ( E ) ) , Iz-yl
=€
... FT t ” K ( c )Au(z) +O,
as € 4 0 .
12-yI = c
Thus
+ {c” K(c)}Au(z),
u(z) = lim {C,-,r”-’K’(c))u(z) C+O
for any function u, which yields the source condition (4.33). Equation (4.32) for q = 0 takes the form
+V
K,,
K r = 0,
it has 2 solutions (regular and singular): { l;logr} in n
= 2, and
{1;r2-,} for n 2 3. So
K = c1 + c2rZ--n(or logr). The boundary condition for K at {m} eliminates the constant term, while the source condition
(4.33) yields c2, whence the familiar form of the Newton/Gauss potential, the Green’s function of the Laplacian,
A similar treatment applies to the case q # 0. But this time (4.32) becomes the equation of Bessel-type, y”+qyrfXy=O,
with X = q .
It is easily reduced to the standard (I-st or 3-nd kind) Bessel equation 2
Y ” + k Y ’ f ( l - E ) Y = O , oforder v=&, 2 r2
(4.34)
by the change, y(r)
= r-’Y,(Jir).
Thus solution of (4.32) with positive rn2 becomes a combination of the 1-st and 2-nd kind Bessel functions: K = r-”{clJ,(mr)
+ cZYv(mr)},of order
v=
9. The source-condition at (0) is
furnished by a non-vanishing coeficient c2. The condition at {co} should be chosen either as incoming, or outgoing “radiation” condition
The latter with a proper normalization at (0) uniquely determines K as the MacDonald function, M, = Const ( J , f iY,), so
52.4. Laplacian and related differential equations.
104
~
Similarly, for A-m’,
the reduced equation changes into the modified Bessel,
Krr + n-1 7 K r - m2K = 0, whose solutions are
I,
-
1-n r 2 emr, and K,
-
1-n
rTeWmr.
We obviously choose the exponentially decaying Kelvin function K,, which could be normalized
to satisfy the source condition a t (0). 4.8. Hyperbolic b. The wave and KGequations:
= utt - cZAu = 6;and (0f m2)u= 6, have all the symmetries of R” +
space-time, translations as well as hyperbolic rotations
So(1;n). The corresponding Green’s functions K = K(1,z) are reduced as above t o a single variable, the hyperbolic radius r =
d-.
They satisfy the Bessel-type equation
Kr,+:K,fm2K
= 0.
(4.35)
But unlike the elliptic case it is not easy to write down the proper %wee condition” a t r = 0. In the last section we used the Fourier analysis t o derive the wave-propagators, which yields for dimensions n = 1,2,3,
(4.36) In higher dimensions K becomes yet more’singular distribution, supported in the light cone
{ I z I 5 ct) or its surface { I z I = ct} (4.31), i.e. K = d ( r ) - a distribution in r = ct - I z 1, or hyperbolic r =
d m .T h e KGGreen’s functions satisfy the Bessel-type (4.35) equation
in hyperbolic r, and we can use solutions (4.35), as proper “source-conditions”. This yields
in spatial dimensions n = 1,2,3.
4.9. Discrete symmetriea and the method of images. The method of images
(reflected sources) applies to differential equations in regions of Rn, and other symmetric spaces (see 57.6 of chapter 7), obtained by “discrete symmetries” (reflections, translations, conformal mappings), like the half-space, quadrants, strips/ slabs, rectangles, spheres, etc. The Green’s function of the corresponding problem is obtained from the free-space Green’s function KO by subjecting KO to a (discrete) set of symmetry transformations, or by subtracting from
KO a suitable regular solution.
32.4. Laplacian and related differential equations
105
Namely, K Osatisfies the source (6 -function) condition, Lz[KO] = 6 ( x - y) in R, but it fails to vanish on the boundary, B[K,] # 0. So we want to find a family of regular functions {u(z;y)}, depending on the position of the source {y}, so that
Lz[u(...;y)] = 0 in 0; and Bz[u]I r = Ko(z;y).
(4.37)
4.10. Renectiona and half-upam problems. We consider the half-space R?+’ t
> 0},
and assume operator Z to be reflection-invariant: (z;t)+(z;
= { ( z , t ) : z E Rn;
-t),
for instance
L = 8: + A - the half-space Laplacian. The corresponding Green’s function depends on the type of boundary condition. For Dirichlet Problems the Green’s function KD
= K ( z ; t , s )= K,(r;t - s) - I f o ( z ; t + s),
represents the difference between the “sourcesolution” K , ( y ; s) (e.g. Newton’s potential) and the
“reflected source” K , ( y ;
- s)
(fig.3). The reflected source gives the requisite correction u in
(4.37). So the half-space Dirichlet Green’s function represents a convolution kernel in 2-variable, K ( z - y ; t , s) of the form
If = &{( I z 1 2
+ ( t - s)2)
n-1 -2
-( Iz
12
+ ( t +.)2) -F}.
This yields, in particular, the half-space Poisson kernel P ( z - y ; t ) , derived earlier in by the Fourier-transform methods
(4.38)
Let us observe, that solution of the Dirichlet problem: Au = F ; u I r: = f; in any region R with boundary C = 80, is represented by the Green’s identity, as
4.) = where
an denotes
/
nK(z;Y)F(Y)dY
+ / za,K(z;Y)f(Y)dS(Y),
the normal derivative of the Dirichlet Green’s function in y E C. So the
Green’s function K picks up the “continuously distributed sources” F over R, while its normal derivative P = 8°K - the Poisson kernel gives the contribution of the “boundary sourcesn.
Fig.%: Free-space Green’s functions at a source {y] and the reflected source {b} cancel each other on the boundary r, separating two half-spaces (Dirichlet problem). In the Neumann problem 2 “sources” add up, so the normal derivative vanishes on the boundary.
106
$2.4. Laplacian and related differential equations. For Neumann Problem the difference of two source8 is replaced with the sum
K N = Ko(z;t-s) +Ko(z;t+s), (so that normal derivative8 would cancel each other). As application we obtain the conjugate
Poisson kernel Q in the half-plane14,
found earlier by the Fourier transform methods. In a similar vein one constructs Green’s functions for other problems, e.g. the half-space Dirichlet/Neumann “heat problem” has K(z,y; t ) = G(2 - y;t)
- the difference/sum {y’
C(z - y’; t )
of two Gaussians with “sources” a t {y = (yl; ...y,))
and the reflected point:
= ( - yl; ...yn)}. Quadrants and other product-type regions are treated in a similar fashion.
Thus the quadrant {(z1;z2) > 0) Green’s function consists of 4 reflected sources: K(z,Y ...) = Ko(z - y) - K o ( z - y’)
- Ko(2 - Y”)
+ KO(Z + y);
where y’; y” represent reflections of {y) relative to the 1-st, respectively 2-nd coordinate axis. 4.11. Green’s functions in finite regions. Green’s functions of elliptic differential operators in
bounded regions S2 (compact manifolds) can always be expanded in terms of eigenfunctions {$k} of L, subject to a proper boundary condition. We leave t o the reader as as exercise t o write expansions for the inverse operator L-’, the heat semigroup e-tL; Poisson kernel exp(-t&); wave-propagators, etc. Let us remark that the Green’s function of any regular S-L problem on interval [O;T]can be represented in two different ways: via the eigenfunction expansion 15 K(z;y) = Cfdk(Z)iJ,(Y), (4.39) k or in terms of a fundamental pair of solutions: L[ul,,] = 0, one of which satisfies the zero
boundary condition on the left (ul I t=O = 0)’ and the other on the right (uz I T = 0). Given a fundamental pair {ul; uz}, the Green’s function is constructed as, (4.40)
For constant coefficient operators L =
- 8 + q,
two representations are related by another
version of the Mtthod of images. Namely, we take source y E [O;TJ,and “reflect it” infinitely 141ndeed, solution of the Neumann problem: Au = F; a,u identity, as
I = f; is represented
via Green’s
where K = K N is the Neumann Green’s function, so Q(z;y) = K ( z ;y), for z E 0 , y E E. 151f one of eigenvalues A, = 0, then kernel K (4.5) (sum over nonzeros A’s defines the so called modified Green’s ,function, i.e. inverse of L on the subspace spanned by nonzeros eigenfunctions {dk},so the product of operators L K = b(z - y) - v,bo(z)$o(y).
52.4. Laplacian and related differential equations
107
many times by the lattice Z = {mT}. So the free-space Green's function of Z on R.
is shifted and summed over the
corresponding Green's function
K on [O;T]has different representations depending on the type of boundary condition. Namely, the periodic bounda y condition (torus), gives ~ ( z , y= )
C~
+
~- y ( mT) z
= +C'ezp(i%$z - y)); (4.41) k with eigenvalues: {Ak = ( r k / T ) ,+ q: k E Z}, while for the Dirichlet/Neumann condition the m
source a t {y} is reflected to {-y},
and then the process is repeated periodically with period 2T.
So one has
The reader should recognize relations (4.41) and (4.42), as special cases of the Poisson summation for function f ( t ) = KO(I z - y I
+ t ) on the lattice Z = {mT}. Similar considerations
apply to the heat, wave, KG and other equations, and to equations on multi-dimensional tori. Two such examples are
4.12. Dirichlet Laplacians on triangles.
Rightisoseeles triangle makes up
i of the square. The (rx r)-square eigenmodes are made of
products of the even and odd Fourier modes { c k = cos(k +:)z}, and
y).
{ C k ( t ) s,(y);
So
consist
of
products
{srn= sin2mz) (in variables z
{ c k ( ~ ) c , ( ~ ) ) , { s k ( ~ ) s , o ) and
s k ( z ) c , ( y ) } . The former two (cc- and ss-types) correspond to different families
+i)2+
+
(m +$)'}, and {4(k2 m')}, so they never mix. The latter ( c s - and types) produce eigenmodes Gkrn of the form Ck(z)6rn(Y) 2 L,(')'k(Y), that vanish on
of eigenvalues {(k
sc-
{4krn}
diagonals z = f y, hence yield the triangle Dirichlet eigenfunctions. Equilateral triangle T makes lattice
r c C, spanned by
i of the diamond,
the fundamental region of the hexagonal
{ l ;a = e i S / , } (fig.4). Its Dirichlet eigenfunctions fall into 3 families,
according to the natural action of dihedral symmetry group D, = Z, D Z, on T. The latter has 3 irreducible representations: trivial
xo = 1, x1 = f 1 (trivial on rotations { 1;u;CJ:u= eizXl3}
and
equal -1 on any reflection), and a 2-D representation u, uu:((;q)+(u(;CJq) (for rotations {I;wp}),
and u,((;q) = ( q , ( ) , for reflection r about the z-axis (see 53.3). So family (I) consists
of eigenfunctions16, symmetric relative to the D,-action
, family
(11) are rotation-invariant, but
"Dirichlet eigenfunctions are uniquely determined by the values of their normal derivatives on , on all 3 sides of T. the boundary, so the description here refers to the values of a+
108
$2.4. Laplacian and related differential equations. mapped t o -(1, by reflections, finally (111) gives a pair of conjugate values { @ ; a }{-l;-l},{Sp} , on each of 3 sides of T (see fig.5~). Our goal is to link eigenvalues of A, to the well known eigenvalues of the f-periodic A on torus
c/r, A,
= I i k + a m I = k2 +m2- km.
Figure 4 demonstrates how each eigenfunction of family (I), (11) and (111) extends t o a fperiodic eigenfunction of A: for (I)-(11) is equal to the size of the triangle (the plane is cut into the union of copies of T, and 11, is taken into all images {T‘} of T with signs f , depending on the orientation of T‘. That same reflection procedure applied to a 111-type eigenfunction requires to triple the period. Since each periodic eigenfunction is a combination of Fourier modes {exp[i(kz+m%(E::y)]:k,m E Z}, we obtain the eigenvalue-spectrum of A,,
t o be made of 2
sequences:
1 Atm
= k2 + m2 - km (for 1-11) A’km = g(k2 + rn2 - km) (for 111)
I
Fig.6 below demonstrates a 11-type eigenfunction as a combination of rotated and reflected exponents, (1, = XI - x2
+ x3 - x4 + x 5 - xs. Fig.4 shows cubic roots {w,G = w z } of 1, along with their negatives { a = - w-; E = - w } . Numbers { 1;w;G } give 3 irreducible characters of subgroup Z, c Q,, while reflection (complex conjugation) defines a 2-D representation of D,. Fig.5 illustrates a periodic extension of eigenfunctions of types I, 11, and 111. A Dirichlet eigenfunction (1, in T is determined by its normal derivatives {fi =a,$, on the i-th side Si, i = 1,2,3}.
We schematically represent each I f i } by a curve along Si; the portion of the curve inside the triangle corresponds t o a positive derivative a,f, while the outside portion t o the negative derivative. For type-I all functions { f i } are equal and symmetric with respect t o the center of the side.
So given a type-I (1, in a “+”-triangle, we reflect it t o a neighboring “”triangle, changing the sign to+-$, and repeat the process. The resulting fperiodic function on C is clearly an eigenfunction of A. For type-I1 11, (b) boundary function f is odd on
109
$2.4. Laplacian and related differential equations
each side Si and repeats itself under rotational symmetries with { 1 ; q Z }. Once again reflections +-$, from T + t o T - across {S,;S,;S,} produces a r-periodic eigenfunction of A in C. The type-111 (c) is somewhat more complicated. Here we pick a pair of complex conjugate functions {+;$}. Then one ca? easily verify that the boundary functions {fi;f i} have absolute values I f l I = I f z I = I f JI = p (an even positive function), and differ one from the other by a_ factor w , f 2 = wfl; f, = 5 f l (and similarly for f .). If we choose fl.(left side) to have phase a= then f 2 (horizontal) have phase - 1 , while f, = E p. The reflection $+-4 about side S, takes triple { a ; - l ; Z } into { u = - E ; + l ; G = a } , and the process has to continued 3-times along the (horizontal) line t o get the original triple { a ; - ; E } . So type-I11 $ yields a 3r-periodic eigenfunction of the Laplacian in C.
&,
Fig.6 shows a type-I11 eigenfunction constructed a combination of 6 exponentials: 4 = x1 - XZ x3 - x4 x 5 - x6.
as
+
+
4.13. Conformal symmetry: Green's function and Poisson kernel in the ball. The group-symmetries used so far in our discussion involved space-translations (continuous and discrete); rotations (spherical and hyperbolic) and reflections. Our last example will exploit yet another transformation, the conformal symmetry of the Laplacian, to study harmonic functions in the balls B , = {
12
I 5 R } c W".
The Green's function
A'
and
Poisson kernel P of the unit disk D c R2 = 43 are well known from the complex analysis, and can be derived in many different ways. We just state the result, referring to problem 6 for details, (4.43)
where z = reit; w = pei6 are complex points in D ( p = 1 for P). Our goal is to extend
(4.43) to higher dimensions. Namely, the Poisson kernel in the n-ball is given by
(4.44)
52.4. Laplacian and related differential equations.
110
2~r 4 2 - volume of the where 12 1 = r; I y I = 1; e = angle between z and y, and w ~ =- r(n/2) unit sphere in Wn. The derivation of (4.44) will utilizes a particular conformal transformation in R", the inversion, u: z+z*
=A *
(4.45)
IZl2'
We recall that name conformal refers to diffeomorphisms {$} of R" (or any Riemannian manifold) that preserve angles between vectors, but not necessarily norms. T h e Jacobian of such m a p $, A = $', is a conformal matriz, product 'scalar x orthogonal", i.e. t A A = AZ (problem 8). Conformal m a p u of (4.45) takes interior of the unit ball in R" into the exterior, and vice versa,
I I = 1). T o construct the Green's function of A on B (Newton's potential) K O = C, I z - y I - " (for n > 2),
and acts identically on the unit sphere { we take the free-space Green's function and &ln
Iz-y I
in R2. It satisfies the differential equation: A,K = 6(z - y), but not the
boundary condition, Ko(z - y) function u&z) in
I an= h,(z) > 0, 80
n, that satisfies A,[u,]
we need t o correct KO by a regular harmonic
I
= 0; ).(,it
an= h , ( z ) ,
K ( r ; y )= Ko(z - Y) - )(., Such uy can be constructed by inversion of KO.We shall use the following identity valid for any function u, A(
I2
I 2-nu(+)) IZI
= I z I -"(Au)
(-1,
(4.46)
IZI
The proof of invariance-relation17 (4.46) is outlined in problem 8. Its immediate corollary is
Proposition: Function u is harmonic iffv(x) = Applying Proposition t o the Newton potential
12
I "-'u(z/ I z I ')
is harmonic.
KO = C I z - y I - " we get the requisite
harmonic correction: u
Cn
(2)=
l(z/Izl-
IzlY)l"-2'
Obviously, uy is harmonic and coincides with K o ( r - y) on the unit sphere. Thus the Green's function of the unit ball (4.47)
Finally, t o compute the Poisson kernel we take the normal derivative 8°K = ny.V,K,and observe that for y on the boundary ( I y I = l), ny = y. Hence,
It remains to note that both denominators in (4.48) are equal (see fig.7),
50
we get Poisson
17The R"-Laplacian is not invariant under the conformal map u, but comes 'very near" t o it. !), Indeed, (4.30) means that the unitary operator U , : f ( z ) + I z I -"f(z*); ( I z I -" = ,/intertwines operators A I z I and A, (A I z I ' ) U , = U,A.
32.4. Laplacian and related differential equations
111
kernel (4.44),
From the Poisson kernel on the unit ball we can easily derive P for any radius p,
(4.49) Fig.?
demonstrates equality of two denominators of (4.49), that measure the distances between pairs {z;y} and
I./
I2
I ; I 2 I Yl.
Formula (4.49) has many applications in the theory of harmonic functions. It follows from (4.49)that any harmonic u(x) is real analytic, since P ( q ...) is real-analytic in x for each y on the boundary. In fact, one could estimate the radius of convergence of the Taylor series ~ ~ ~ ( ~ ) ( ofz harmonic - - x ~ )function ~ u ( z ) at each interior point {xo}
C. Furthermore, (4.49) gives the minimal and maximal value of the Poisson kernel for each 0 < r < p, they correspond to in terms of the distance from {xo} to the boundary
case=
fl,
(4.50) As a consequence of (4.50)we get an important result in the theory of harmonic
functions.
Harnack inequality: The ratio between the maximal and minimal values of a harmonic positive function u(x) 2 0 an the ball of radius r is estimated by max {u(x):I z I = r } min {u(x):I z I = r ) -
(4.51)
4.13. Green’s functions and Poiason kernels in arbitrary domains D are constructed, as in
solid sphere case, from the free-space Green’s function (Newton/Bessel potential) KO,and an auxiliary (harmonic) function u(x; y)
(2,y
E D), that satisfies the homogeneous
equation: A,u = 0; and the boundary condition: u( ...;y) or a,u
I aD = -a,Ko(x-y)
I,
= -Ko(z-y) (Dirichlet);
(Neumann). Then, the Green’s function of D,
62.4. Ladacian and related differential equations.
112
K(z;y) = Ko(z-y)--(z;y); while the Poisson kernel, P ( z ;y) = -B,K(z; y)(Dirichlet); and P(z;y) = -a,K(z;y) (Neumann). Solution of any inhomogeneous problem: Au = F; u I
=I
= f ; is given by
,my ) ~ ( y ) d y+ r aDp(z;y ) f ( y ) d w .
Another construction of P(z;y) in terms of the solid-angle form is outlined in problem 12.
Additional comments and results. Our discussion of differential operators was limited to specific examples and methods. Here we give a cursory introduction to the general elliptic theory, based on symbolic calculus. For detailed exposition see [Hor];[Tal]. 1. Symbolic calculus. We write differential operators on R", as L = Cu,(z)D", where (I
= (el;...a,) means a multi-index, Do- the corresponding partial derivative ( D =
-
partial divided by i). We define a symbol u = u L ( z ;
'
(L[ei2*
13
and the Fourier transform links symbols to operators,
L [ f ] ( z )=
I
&
cr(z;<)ei(z-y)'CF(<)
(4.52)
d<.
Another way to write (4.52) is
L =T0ULOTJ-~, here uL acts on
f
<. Formula
by a multiplication in
(4.52) could be extended from
polynomial symbols of of pdo's (partial differential operators), to more general classes of functions {u(z;<)} with "nice" asymptotic behavior at large (. This gives rise to a wider class of operators; A = u(z;D), called pseudo-differential. A $do A (4.52) is given by an integral (possibly distributional) kernel,
qz; 2-y)
I
= 1,i(z-y)
(W"
*
C4 z ; € ) 4 .
(4.53)
Pseudedifferential operators ( g o ' s ) retain many basic properties of differential operators (see S2.2). For instance, one can introduce a notion of order: symbol u(z;<) is said to be
of order rn E R (positive, negative, fractional), if u(z;() = U( I differentiation in
<
lowers the order by 1: a?(z;<) = U( I < I "'-")}.
< I "),
and each
The reflects the
natural properties of the corresponding go's, A = u ( z ; D ) .Namely, Proposition: i) A $do's A of order 0 is bounded in L2 (and all Sobolev 36,) spaces. ii) Furthermore, a $do A of order m maps properly the Sobolev scale,
A: 36,+36,-,,
for all s.
(4.54)
$3.4. Laplacian and related differential equations
113
So positive-order $do’s deregularize smooth functions, while negative-order A smooth them out. The proof of (4.54) exploits the Fourier analysis of $02.1-2 (interpolation and Sobolev estimates). tDdo’s could be multiplied A . E (product rule), inverted (in some cases) and conjugated,
A-A’,
maintaining the proper order, m ( A E ) = m(A)
+ m(E),
m(A-’) = 1 (for m(A)
elliptic A). Both operations have natural characterization in terms of symbols. To write both rules we shall use the convention: a(), for partial
- for partial derivatives D”a in (, and a (0)
aa in 2. Then
-
(4.55) the expansions are taken in all multi-indices
(I
...
= ( a l ; (I”). Asymptotic sign
-
reflects
our emphasis on local (in 2-variable) properties of $do’s {A}, determined (via 41) by the
behavior of symbols at (-00. So “large a-terms” in (4.55) define “locally small (smoothing)” $do’s A, = a0( 2 ; D ) (each differentiation in ( lowers the order of a by
l!). Moreover, “smallness” of {A,} could be established not only in terms of their smoothing (order), but also operator norms of {A,} could be estimated, and shown to decay to 0 sufficiently fast. So the resulting expansions (4.55) can be interpreted as exact relations with “small remainders” in either sense. Let us remark, that both rules correspond to the standard convention of writing differential operators: derivatives {a,(z)}.
A=
Other
conventions
Caa[au(z) ...I),
{aa} (on the (multiplication
right) followed by multiplications with followed
by
differentiation,
i.e.
or Weyl-convention (where 8 and z are symmetrized, chapter 6)
give somewhat different rules. Thus $do’s {a(z;D)} form an algebra, that extends the algebra of all (variable-coefficient) differential operators. Product of $do’s is easily seen to maintain the order,
m( A * E ) = m( A) + m(E ) ; 0-order $do’s are bounded operators, and negative-order A’s (order - m ) have “nice integral kernels”, estimated by
1 K(2;y) I 5 Const 1 2-y I m-”.
(4.56)
Constant in (4.56) is bounded by certain seminorms, that involve symbol {a(z;()} and its derivatives in
(2;
(). The goal of symbolic calculus is to utilize symbols and estimates,
like (4.56), to (approximately) construct inverses {A -’},
powers {A’}, or more general
“functions of A” { f ( A ) } ; to find the kernels of {f(A)}, and to analyze their properties.
114
52.4. Laplacian and related differential equations. The crucial role here is played by the Fourier analysis. 2. Elliptic theory. Differential operators (pdo’s) or $do’s with nonvanishing (at {cm}!)
symbol a ( + ; ( ) are called ellipfic. For 2-nd order pdo’s, A = Caij(z)c3ij,this means that their symbol, quadratic form a ( + ; ( ) = C a i j ( ; t j is definite (positive or negative), a(+;()
> 0 or a(+;() < 0, for all < # 0.
Hence,
c1It I I a(+;€) 5 C, I €I *; for all (,
(4.57)
the standard notion of ellipticity. Estimate (4.57) plays the crucial role in the approximate inversion of elliptic operators. Indeed, inverse $do A - (if it exists) has the principal symbol given by the product-rule, uA-l
-1 (l.o.t), +... a(+; 0
and 1 is also an elliptic $do or order -m. As a consequence, one can construct an
4%; C)
approximate inverse B N A - ’ for any elliptic &lo A. Namely, one defines a $do B by (4.37) with symbol 1 , then shows via the product-rule (4.39) and norm estimates 4 r ;C)
(4.40), that
A - B = Z + R (remainder), where remainder R has negative order -c, hence operator R is smoothing in the Sobolev scale (4.38),
R: 36,+36,+,.
c R”, any such R becomes a compact operator, due to compactness of the Sobolev embedding: 36,(R) c X t ( Q ) , for any pair s > t (Theorem 1 of 52.2). In other words approximate inverse B = &(+;D) becomes the When restricted on a compact domain R
Fredholm inverse of A (inverse modulo compact operators). This result along with the
basic spectral theory of compact operators (Appendix A) has important consequences for the theory of elliptic equations. Before we state the general results, let us mention that the notions of symbol, &lo, Sobolev space, etc., could be extended from R“ to manifolds and domains18, i.e. boundary value problems (see [Hijr];[Tal]). Theorem: Let A be an elliptic operator on a compact manifold, o r domain (with proper boundary conditions). Then (i) spectrum of A consists of a discrete set of eigenualues
{Xk-+m};
each eigenspace Ek ( o r root subspace f o r non-self-adjoini A ) being finite-dimensional;
T -o construct &lo’s on manifolds { A } one exploits local formula (4.36), then patches together “local pieces”. Such process, however, defines a +do A only approximately to the leading order. So { u L ( z ; ( ) }on rnanifolds could be understood only as principle symbols, a consistent choice of other lower-order terms, requires additional structures. In some cases, groupstructure or geometry provide necessary tools to build a “complete symbolic calculus on manifolds” ((Be];[Un];[Ur];[Wi]).
52.4. Laplacian and related differential equations (ii)
for
any
X
4 spec(A),
operaior
(A - A)
is
inueriible
and
115 (A - A ) -':36,*36,+,;
(m = order(A)). Hence, differential equation: (A - X)u = f , with any f E
K,, has solution
In particular, f E Coo, yields oo-smooth soluiions. Also
u E 36,+,.
(iii) for all X E C operaior (A - A) is Fredholm-invertible. So equation (A - X)u = f, has solutions for all f , orthogonal l o the null-space {$}, of ihe adjoini operator: ( A * - X ) $ = 0 (Fredholm alternative); (iv) eigenfunctions: A 4 = Ak$, are oo-smooih. In case of (real) analytic A 'COO" could be replaced by (real) analyticity. Further analysis of operators {A}, via $do techniques, reveals much more. One can find for instance, asymptotic distribution of eigenvalues {Xk}, given by the celebrated Weyl (wolumecounting) principle:
5 A},
N ( X ; A )= #{Xk(A) 5 A} -+'d{(z;():a(~;<) (2*)
(4.58)
here the volume is taken in the the cotangeni bundle IT(&) = {(z;():< E T:}. The key idea in derivation of (4.58) is to compute the trace of a suitable function f ( A ) , e.g. or tr[(< - A)-'] (for sufficiently large s). On the one hand such traces represent
tr(e-"),
certain transforms (Laplace, Cauchy-Stieltjes) of the counting function N(A;A ) , e.g. tr(e-tA) =
00
C e-tAk = J e-A'dN(A). 0
On the other hand symbolic calculus yields kernels and symbols of +do's {B = f ( A ) } ,
-
u,(~)
f
ouA.
The connection between tr(B), and its symbol
uB
results from the basic
integral representation (4.37),
Hence, tr(e-tA)
-
tr(B) =
J Ib(z;()dzd(.
Ie-'"(2;0dzd(,
where the RHS gives the Laplace transform of the
volume-function V(A) = uoI{(z;():a
5 A}. Once Laplacetransformed " N ( A ) and V(A)" are
found asymptotically equivalent (at small t ) , one can go back t o the original =N and V", via Tauberian Theorems.
Remark In quantum mechanics, T*(&) gives the phase space of the classical-mechanical system (with coordinate z being the position-variable, and ( - the momentum variable); symbol a(z; () means the classical hamiltonian (e.g. energy-function), while differential/ pseudc-differential A = a(z; D)
-
the corresponding quantum hamiltonian. We shall
discuss the quantitaiion procedure in chapters 6 and 8 (see [How]).
116
52.4. Laplacian and related differential equations.
Problems and Exe.rcises: 1. Check the subordination principle by Fourier-transforming both sides of (4.47) in 1.
2. Regularity and convergence of solutions of the heat- and Laplaces equations. Show that for any f E Lp solutions of the heat and Laplaces problems: ut = Au, and utt = Au, with initial value f satisfy i) u(z;t)is ern for all t
I
> 0;
I
ii) 4 - 4 t ) LP(&) I IIf I L P iii) u(z;t)-f(z), as t-0, in LP-norm
Use the convolution representation of solutions, u = 4jt*f, with the Gaussian or Poisson kernel, 4 j t = t - W ( I z I /t),and show that both kernels form an approximate unity as defined in problem 2 of 92.1. In fact, one could show that u(z;t)+f(z), pointwise almost everywhere inside any cone: I z - zo I < c t , but this would require more powerful tools of Fourier analysis [SW]. 3. Use the Fourier transform to solve Dirichlet problem for the Laplaces equation in the strip: 0 < y < b, Au = 0; u I = = f(z); u I = b = 0.
4. Calculate wave propagators U ;V; W in higher dimensions, using the relation:
c
5. Obtain the fundamental solution of the beabproblem: Kt-AK=O - 2 )- Gaussian, * K ( z ; t ) = ( 4 ~ t ) - " / ~ e z p (41
I t = 0 = 6(z)
by symmetry reduction, using non-isotropic dilations in the
(2;
Itspace:
D,: (2, t)-(az; a%), a 2 0. (i) Show, if u ( t , t ) solves the homogeneous heat-equation, then u* = u ( a 2 t ; a z )does so. (ii) Write the fundamental solution K * = K ( a 2 t ; a z ) as a multiple of K ( t ; z ) , K * = c(a) K , compute coefficient .(a) from the "6 sourcen condition at t = 0, and prove K ( t ;z) = a" K ( a 2 t ; a z ) .Thus K is reduced to a single variable function K ( r ) ,
K = t-"/'K(rt-'/'). (iii) Verify that K ( r ) solves an ODE,
K'/ Change variable: r-$
2
+ (+ + 5)K' + ;K
= 0;
= z, and show that in the new variable K satisfies an ODE: 2r(K'+iK)'+ n(K'+:K) = 0;
(iv) Obtain the general solution of the latter,
K = e-'l2(Cl
+ C,
ez/2z-n/2dz),
show that the second (singular term) must vanish. Hence, K = e-'I2 = e-r2/4,
QED.
6. (i) Derive the Poisson kernel of the Laplacian in the unit disk D as Fourier series expansion 00 qr; 8 -t )= p I L. I - 0.
c
--m
(ii) Sum the resulting series to get
,w
52.4. Laplacian and related differential equations
117
in complex variables z = reie. (iii) Show that P- C( 0- t ) , coordinates).
as r+l,
and verify the equation A P = O (use polar
(iv) Expand the Green's function K(z;w ) ( z = reie; w = peiQ) into the Fourier series (4.59)
Km(r;p)eim(e-Q),
and demonstrate that coefficients {Km} are Green's functions of the S - L Problems:
+
+2~ = a(r - p), 2
KI' ~ K I
(4.60)
(v) Find a fundamental pair {ul(r);u2(r)} of each S-L problem (4.60) and compute functions { Km} using (4.40). (vi) Sum series (4.59) to get
(m
~ ( zw ); = k / n I *-l/tul ). Interpret this form of K in terms of reflected sources and P is equal t o the normal (radial) derivative of K on the boundary { I w I = 1).
7. Verify the Laplace equation A,P = 0, and the boundary condition, P ( z ;y) = 6(z - y), on aB - the unit sphere, for the Poiason kernel (4.44).
8. Prove the identity (4.46) for any function u on R". Steps: (i) Use a general coordinate-change formula for the Laplacian A: if map Q:Z-y = (...Qi(z)...), has Jacobian matrix A = Q', with determinant J = detA, then A,+V
. J ( = A A ) - 'V.
Written explicitly this yields,
A ( . 0 Q)=
{c ( c ajdi a k d i ) a p k u + c A Q aiu} ~ ik i
0
Q
I
(ii) Check that inversion u:z+z/ I z I ', gives a conformal map, so Jacobian = (alu; anu) satisfies tu' u' = p(z) I , with factor p = I z I - '. Hence,
ul
...
A[(*)]=
06)
II: 2).
IZI
(iii) Combine (4.61) with the product rule: A ( f g ) = A(f)g to f = I z I and g = u(z/ I z I 2), to get
A( I z I au
x
IzI -'(du-2(n-2)+.Vu
= I z I a-'{a(a
(4.61)
+ 2V f .V g + f Ag,
+ n - 2). - 2(a+n-2)+.
121
applied
V u + Au o u,
}
whence follows (4.46) for a = 2-n.
9. Mean-value property for harmonic functions: Show that any harmonic function u(z) on R" satisfies u(2) = 1 J u(z - ry)dSy - mean over the sphere of radius r; p-1 wn-l lyl = I
u(z) = 2J u(z - y ) d y - mean over the ball B ( r ) of radius r.
uolB(r) B(r)
Hint: Apply the Green's identity: JuAu - uAu = J (& - &)dS; aD an an D in region D c R" - normal derivative on OD), to the pair: { u ( z ) ; u = K o ( z - y)Newton's potential}, integrated over the ball D = {y: I z - y I _< r } .
(a an
10. Apply (4.51) to show that there are no non-constant positive harmonic functions on
118
$2.4. Laplacian and related differential equations. R". More elementary fact: there are no bounded harmonic functions on R", follows from the mean-value property (problem 9).
11. Use the mean-value property (problem 9) t o prove that a nontrivial harmonic function u(z) on R" is unbounded. Hint: w u m e I u(z) I 5 C ; pick a pair of points z,y; write u(z), u(y) by their mean values in large balls {B(r)}; estimate I u(z) - u(y) I 5 ...( r), and let r+m.
12. The Poisson kernel P(z;y), r E D , y E C = B D , in any (convex) region D, can be constructed in terms of the solid-angle kernel, T ( z , y ) = 1 - cos(I.
as
c,,-~as - ~ , - ~ ~ n - 1 '
where a is the angle between normal nu and vector (z-y),(see fig.8). Geometrically kernel T ( z ; y ) represents the density of the solid angle with vertex a t {z}, subtended by a surface area element a t {y}. It can be obtained by restricting the (n-1)-differential form (solid-angle form),
8 = 1 ( z l d z z A ...Adz, - zzdzl A d z 3 A ... A d z , r"
+ ...),
on the boundary surface C = a D . i) Show that T = 81,E (parametrize C by map @:R"-'+R"; vector surface-area element ndS = @91 A A @yn-ldn-l Y I
z = @(y)), and show that
...
where {By} are partial derivatives of @ in variables {y}, n-unit normal t o C. ii) Show u(z) = J'T(z;y)f(y)dS(y), boundary condition,
solves the Laplaces equation, Au = 0; but not the u I C = if
+ Q [ fI,
where operator Q is obtained by restricting kernel T ( z ; y ) on C. iii) Integral operator Q is compact on Lz(C) (see Appendix B), since Q has integrable So , operator ?jZ Q is Fredholm-invertible singularity, I Q(z;y) I 5 C 12-y I (modulo possible finitedimensional eigensubspace A = -?), and )the Poisson kernel,
'-".
I-
+
P = T($Z+ Q)- * = 2(T - 2TQ + 4TQ2- ...). Fig.8 Geometric view of the solid angle form, that gives a Poisson kernel
where 8 = 8(x;y) - solid angle, centered at {z}, as a function y E aD; S = S(y) - surface area element.
$2.4. Laplacian and related differential equations ~~~~
Table of basic differential equations and their Greens functions in
Equatwn
Fonnal solution
Laplace:
-Au = 6
Resolvent:
(A
Heat:
ut - A u = 0 L o =6
Schriidinger:
- A). = 6
Conj. Poisson:
RA = (A - A) - 1
Tt = e tA
ut-iAu=O UlkO
Poisson:
K=A-'6
=6
+
utt Au = 0 4t=0 =6 utt
+ Au = 0
Utlt=o
=6
p t
?t
- t o -e
=&
-
Wave (initial velocity): utt - c2Au = 0
u I = O;utlt=O= 6
I t
sin t f i
--
fi
Wave (initial disturbance): utt - czAu = 0 u 10 = 6; U t l t = O = 0
r, = cos t J E
1
6
119 ~~~
R".
~
62.5. Radon transform
120
$2.5. The Radon trandorm. The Radon transform appears in many guises and different geometric settings. The standard R2-transform takes a func_tion f in R2, and integrates it along all lines { l } , %:f-f(t). Similarly, the R"-functions can integrated along lines (X-ray transform), hyperplanes (Radon), or all intermediate p-planes (1 5 p 5 n-1). One can similarly define the Radon transform on n-spheres, integrating either over great circles (geodesics) or hyperspheres, or intermediate p-spheres. The basic problem is to invert W, i.e. recover function f from its integrals over a suitable family of lines, surfaces, etc. It turns out that the Radon transform is closely connected to the Fourier analysis in the Euclidian setup, and to harmonic analysis of relevant groups (orthogonal, Lorentz, etc.) in other cases. In this section we shall give a brief introduction to the Radon transforms on Euclidian spaces, and its connections to the Fourier transform, then mention how these results extend to other rank-one symmetric spaces.
5.1. General framework for the Radon transform is a dual pair of manifolds:
{t}c Z with a natural measure [(I = {z} c 96, with measure
where each paint z E 96 is assigned a subset [z] = d,((). Similarly, each point E Z corresponds to a subset
t
d&z). The generalized Radon transform 5 takes %-functions into Z-functions, and the dual transforms,
5:f (+3(t)
=
J "1 f (4d&);
%f(t)-.j(.) = /[,lf(Od,(t). In general, little can be said about the product and inversion of %-transforms,
5% - ? 3% ? jL-'-?
(5.1)
The situation becomes more manageable when both manifolds are homogeneous spaces of some (Lie) group G, and G-actions on 96 and Z are consistent: [tg]
= {zg:z E
[t]}, and [zg] = {(g:t
E [z]}, for all z;t.
We also assume that measures {d,([)} on leaves [z]c Z, and { d [ ( z ) } on leaves
[(I
c 96, are transformed accordingly, 9:d<(z)-.dp(z); and dz(t)-+(t)*
Group G obviously commutes with both transforms, as well as their products. Therefore, product-operators: %%kon L 2 ( 2 ) , and '%'& on L'(96) commute with the regular representations R of G on both L2-spaces. The analysis of the resulting
52.5. Radon transform
121
intertwining operators can often be reduced to special classes of functions (spherical {$}), where calculation of (5.1) can be performed explicitly. The foremost is the case of the so called rank-one symmetric space 96 (s& examples below and 55.7 of chapter 5). Here the algebra of intertwining operators is generated by a single element, the Laplacian A . So the product of two transforms and one only needs to compute the proper (1-variable!) function F(X). Formula (5.2) immediately yields the Radon inversion:
The following 3 examples will illustrate (5.2). 5.2. Euclidian space: The Radon transform on W" is defined by integrating function f ( x ) over all hyperplanes { t c W"}, that make up the dual space Z. The latter can be parametrized by all pairs { ( r ; w ) : r2 0;w-unit vector}, t = (r,w = {z:x.w = r } . Each point z E R" defines a subset [z] of all hyperplanes passing through it, which can be identified with the projective space Pn-l N S"-'/Z, = {lines in R" through 0 } , equipped with the natural (rotation-invariant) measure d x t = d t . So the entire space Z factors into the product: R+ x P"". Then the Radon transform, A
GjL:f(x)+f(r;u) =
I
fdS =
€r, W
while the dual transform & : $ ( r ; u ) + $ ( z )=
I
$dt =
[XI
1
f(x)dn-'x,
w*x=r
$(u.z;w)dS(w).
wESn-1
The Euclidean motion group En = W" b S q n ) acts naturally on both spaces,
z),
g = (a;u):x+xUta (x E Rn); (r,w+tr+a. w ; w u (€ E and transforms the corresponding function-spaces, f+Rgf. Operators ?k,%clearly intertwine the resulting regular representations, %(Rgf) = R g f . Space W" has rank 1 relative to En, in the sense that all En-invariant polynomials, respectively constantcoefficient differential operators, are functions of the Laplacian A (see Theorem 1 of 52.4 and $54.4-5 and 55.7). So (5.2) follows. Function F can be computed explicitly [Hell, and is found to be, A
n-1
9r(n/2)
F(X)= C A - 2 , with constant C = C, = (47r)
In other words the R"-Radon transforms satisfies
-.
r(:)
62.5.Radon
122
transform
To establish (5.3) we observe that set [z]of hyperplane {€} passing through obtained
from
a
single
(coordinate)
hyperplane
I,
is
to, rotated by all elements
u E K = SO(n+l). So [z]= {z+€l:u E K), and we can write (fig.9), ( T ) - ( z )=
1% +
€l)du =
I
f(z + YU)d(o(Y)dU=
K
I
(MI
I f)(z)d"-'y
5
= (5.4)
CO
= Cn-2 (Mrf)(z)r"-'dr.
K€o
0
Here du denotes the normalized Haar measure on K; d (y) =d"-'y
€
(Lebesgue)measure on S,(z)={y: I y - z l
-
the natural
to,and Mrf - the spherical mean of function f over the sphere
=r)inR",
Constant C, measures the volume of the unit k-sphere S'C Rk+'. Now it remains t o rewrite integral (5.4), as
Here we used the volume element in spherical-coordinate, dy = r"-'drdS,
and noticed
that factor F 2 d r d S , in the LHS of (5.5) turns into g y . So integral (5.5) becomes a convolution, f*$. But the convolution-kernel $ = 1 gives (up to a constant factor) a
I 2-Y I
fractional power of the Laplacian, Riesz potential: I , = ( - A ) - e , of order s = n-l 2 (see
§2.2), which completes the proof.
Fig.9 The double Radon transform: %%[f] at point z i s reduced in (5.4) to taking the Rn-spherical means {M I I f(z)} through all points {y) in the hyperplane to, and integrating them over
to.
By analogy with hyperplane transforms one can introduce the family of d-plane Radon transforms for all intermediate dimensions 1 5 d 5 n-1. Here we integrate
s2.5. Radon transform
function f on Rn over all d-planes
< c W".
123
The standard % corresponds to d = n-1,
while another extreme case d = 1 gives the famous X-ray transform". The space of all d-planes is parametrized by the points ( 7 ) of the Grassmanian Gr,(n-d), and all points E 7 . The Grassmanian Gr,(d) can be identified with the
<
double quotient space SO(d)\SO(n)/SO(n-d), of dimension, dimGr,(d) = d(n-d). The Radon space Ed can be thought of as a natural vector (n-d)-bundle over Gr,(n-d),
so its dimension = d(n-d)
+ (n-d) = (n-d)(d+l).
Once again we have a correspondence between points {xER"} and subsets
<
[x] c Zd (all d-planes through x) on the one hand, and all points (d-planes) E s d and subsets [ = {x E [} in Rn. So can define a pair of transforms %, 3, and hose turn out to be related by an analog of (5.5)
(5.6) 5.3. The spherical and hyperbolic spaces. The standard Radon transform on Sn is
given by integrating f over either totally geodesic (equatorial) hyperspheres 0N
Sn-l c S" (intersections of Sn with hyperplanes), or geodesics/great circles
(spherical X-ray transform), or intermediate totally geodesic d-spheres. This time space
Z is identified with the Grassmanian of 2-planes (X-ray transform), 3-planes, etc., in UP+'. The symmetry group here is still K = SO(n+l), and space Sn has rank one. As a consequence of Frobenius reciprocity (§5.7), the regular representation R on 5'" has multiplicity-free spectrum. Hence formula (5.2) holds with a function F(A) depending on
d. It turns out that for all even d , Fd is polynomial of degree ~131,
.+
P d ( X ) = [A
So we get
(d--I)(n-d)] ...[A +
$ (like in R").
+ 1(n-2)].,
Precisely
(5.7)
d 12- factors
-The energy (intensity) of an X-ray passing through a medium of variable density p ( z ) is attenuated at a rate proportional to the integral along its (straight-line) path I: E(incoming) In E(outgoing) - I pds. So X-ray measurements produce density integrals of p along all lines, passing through the body (of a patient), and one would like to recover the density variations (e.g. tumor).
I
52.5. Radon transform
124
Similar result holds for the rank-one hyperbolic spaces: H” = SO(1;n)/SO(n).The role of circles and planes is played here by the closed geodesics or totally geodesic dsubmanifolds. Once again relation (5.8) holds with the same constant C = C(d), but polynomial F d (5.7) ‘has all “$” signs in factor [A ...I changed to “-”,so the hyperbolic
+
Remark: Another version of the Radon transform is defined by integrating function u on R” over all spheres, passing through the origin. Any such sphere is parametrized by the radius r , and the direction-vector w, Sr,w= {z: I z -rwI = r } , %:u(z)-.G(r;w) =
J
u(z)dS(z),
(I-rwl = r
where d S is the natural surface area element on Sr,y. We refer t o [CQ] for further details. Let us only remark that geometrically the space of “spheres through the origin” is identical t o the space of “hyperplanes”, via the inversion map of $2.4, y-y’ difference is in the family of measures {dC(z)} on surfaces {(,,, Euclidean dPr(y) =
dy
{(I
-
= %. The IYI
Sr,,,}.The standard
on
hyperplanes
$y
(see fig.10). The Radon transform on spheres finds an interesting
is
repalced
by
the
spherical
measure
applications to the Darboux problem for the wave equation, utt = Au; with characteristic boundary conditions,
U(Z, 11:
I ) = f(z),on the light-cone { t = I z I } (see(CQ1).
For complete proofs and further details of Radon transforms we refer to a superb exposition of the subject in the Helgason’s books (Hell (see also [Ter]; [Wall; [Karl). Fig.10. The inversion y-y/ I y I takes a hyperplane tr= {y w = r } into the sphere S,,r,w (of radius 2/r), passing through the origin, and transforms the Euclidean measure dy on into the measure,
<
$0 = e
2
y = by. r2+y2
Chapter 3. Representations of compact and finite groups. In the first section of chapter 3 we develop the general representation theory of compact groups G , known as Peter- Weyl theory. We show among other results the orthogonality and completeness of irreducible matrix entries and characters of G, and complete reducibility for any representation T of G. Then (83.2) we shall study irreducibility and decomposition of regular and induced representations of compact and finite groups, based on Mackey's imprimitivity systems and Frobenius reciprocity. Several examples illustrates the general concepts and methods of $3.2: symmetric and alternating groups, symmetry-groups of regular polyhedra. We apply these results to "Laplacians on Platonic solids". In the last section 53.3 we carry out a detailed study of semidirect products. Our presentation here will be motivated and illustrated by specific examples of finite group: symmetric and alternating groups; unimodular group
SL, over finite fields, finite
Heisenberg groups H,. The latter are closely t o Clifford groups and algebras, and find an interesting application t o a topological problem of determining the number of linearly independent vector fields over spheres.
33.1. The Peter-Weyl Theory.
1.1. Matrix entries and characters. For any representation finite-dimensional space
Y N C", we choose a basis
{el;...;en} in
K
of group G in a
Y, and
define matrix
entries
I ek)}jk'
{"jk(")=("uej
(1.1)
More generally, we pick any pair of vectors <;qE Y,and set y7(")=(AuJ
I v).
(1.2)
The character of a representation K is obtained by taking the trace of ru,
Definition (1.3) strictly speaking applies only to finite-D representations However, we can define character
xT
distribution on G, (XT
for
a
suitable
class of
{T}.
of infinite-D (unitary) representations, as a
I f)=wJ);
test-functions
e={f(u)} on
G, provided operators
{Tr= If(u)T,du: f E e} belong to the trace-class. The latter holds for regular representations RG;RX on G, or its quotients X = H\G, for
$3.1. The Peter-Weyl Theory
126
L2; Lp. Indeed, operator {Rf:f E C!} are given by continuous integral kernels, e.g. K(z;y) = f(zg-'), on the compact space G or X. Any all reasonable function-spaces C!;
such K is well known t o be of traceclass (see Appendix B), with IrK =
I
K(z;z)dz.
In particular, character of the regular representation R on G ,
i.e. (problem 3),
XR = I I 6*,
(1.4)
We already know (1.4) for commutative groups R"; T", where it can be interpreted as orthogonality relations for exponentials/characters
{x<(2) = e i z
'
(}, and was shown t o be
equivalent t o the Inversion/Plancherel formula. In this section we shall establish a (noncommutative) compact version of these results.
Matrix entries (1.1)-(1.2) and characters are continuous functions on G, hence belong to L*-space with respect to the Haar measure' du. The characters are easily seen to be conjugate-invaiiant functions on G,
~ ( u z u - ' )= ~ ( z )for, all z , u E G, so they make up the center of the group algebra Z(G) (problem 1).
The following Theorem due to Peter-Weyl summarizes the main results of the representation theory of compact groups.
1.2. Peter-Weyl Theorem: (i) Any irreducible representation T of a compact group G is finite dimensional. (ii) Matriz entries and characters of irreducible representations following orthogonality relations
{T}
satisfy the
(iii) The orthogonality relations for characters
(iv) Completeness: matriz entries { T j k : 1 5 j , k 5 d(T);T E G} form a complete orthogonal system in L2(G); characters { x ~ : ET G } are complete and orthogonal
in the subspace of conjugate-invariant functions 'We have shown in $1.2 that the right/left invariant Haar measure exists on any compact (even locally compact) group. It defines the scale of Lp-spaces (1 5 p 5 m), and the convolution structure on G.
$3.1. The Peter-Weyl Theory
127
Z(G) = { f E C2:f ( u - ' z u ) = f ( ~ )Z;, E G } , center of the group algebra2 L2(G).
Proof involves two steps: first we show that any irreducible r can be embedded into the regular representation on LZ(G),then we apply the averaging procedure to certain rank-1 operators in L2(G),and utilize Schur's Lemma. Step 1: Embedding.W e pick a vector 'I in the representation space V = V ( r ) and define a map
I r)) = f ( Z ) l
W = W'I:€+z€ from V into L2(G). Map W is bounded:
I1f I1 = so
11 W 11 5 11 1) 11,
JI
I
(Xu€ 11)) 2du
I II 'II1 II € II 2>
and it intertwines representations "r I V" and ' R I range W C L2(G)".
From the unitary version of Schur's Lemma we easily deduce that W is an isometry, modulo scalar factor. Indeed, W*W commutes with r, hence W*W = cZ - scalar. Thus an irreducible r can be identified with a subrepresentation of R on a subspace
Y c L2(C).
Step 2 Averaging. If a compact group G acts on a vector space Y by linear transformations { T z } , all associated objects (vectors, operators, tensors) could be
averaged over G t o yield G-invariant objects (problem 7). In particular, average of a linear operator Q on Y is defined via Q d= ef
T,'QT,dz, G and is easily seen t o commute with all { T z } . Given an irreducible representation r on
Y C L2(C),we pick a pair of functions 'p, 4 in Y
and define a rank-one operator
W) = Q,@
= (f I
Q:L * ( G ) + S P ~ ~ { ~ ) .
Its average Q has the form
Q(f)=
1
R,QR;'(f)du =
1(K'fI
4 R U W = (f I
Notice that Q maps L2(G)onto the cyclic subspace of
V($) = Span{R,$:u
and
R , d R,4 du.
4,
E G},
a is 0 on the orthogonal complement of V(4) = Span{R,$;u G } . In the case of Y(4) = V($) = Y,hence a = XI is scalar on Y. E
irreducible r, both cyclic spaces coincide
Constant X can be computed from the bilinear form
'We
remind the reader that L2-functions on compact G form a convolution algebra, as
IIf * h 112 I I1f 112 11 h 112'
83.1. The Peter-Weyl Theory
128 whence
Here {r4+} denote matrix entries of the representation R. This shows that the average operator Q is indeed a A-multiple of the orthogonal projection that both Q and
P:L2+V. Let us observe
0 are given by integral kernels: Q(f)= JK(z;I)f(y)dy;
Q(f) =
J
where K ( ~ , Y =),to(zG(~),
where ~ ( zy), =
~ ( 2y)f(y)dy, ,
J $(zs)P(v)ds.
Obviously, kernel R(z;y) E L2(G x G), in fact R(z,y) is continuous on G x G. Therefore, integral operator Q: L2(C)-L2(G) is compact (even Bilbert-Schmidt). But a compact projection has always finite rank, hence dimY
< 00. This proves the first statement of the
Theorem. Step 3 Orthogonality. Given an irreducible representation r we once again pick a rankone operator Q = (... 10'1,and average it over G,
Q=
/
~;~Qr,,du. G Obviously, Q commutes with T, and irreducibility of T, implies by Schur's Lemma, that
Q = XI is scalar. But trQ = tr Q = Ad(*), whence we find trQ ('I I€) x -=Now we evaluate the bilinear form
4 x 1 4*)' (Qt' I9'), for a pair of vectors (';q'.
On the one hand
On the other hand
which proves orthogonality relation (1.5) for matrix entries of the same representation r. If entries r . and unmcome from two different (nonequivalent) representations, we take a rank-one operat,or Q from Y ( r )into
Y(u),and average it with respect to the pair
Q=
(rp),
J v;lQr,,du.
Such Q is easily seen to intertwine r and u, hence by Schur's Lemma Q = 0, whence follows the orthogonality of r j kand unm.The orthogonality of characters (1.6) is a direct consequence of (1.5)
Step 4 Campletensti of matrix entries and characters in Lz(C). Careful analysis of the argument in step 1, shows that any cyclic representation T (a representation with a cyclic vector
to),can be embedded in L*(G), also any cyclic subrepresentation T of R contains
129
83.1. The Peter- Weyl Theory a finite-dimensional (hence an irreducible) subrepresentation r. So if the span of all A
matrix entries { r j k : jk,; r E C ) were incomplete (had an orthogonal complement 'T c L2), then the restriction T = R I 'T would contain an irreducible r, a contradiction!
Completeness of characters results from completeness of matrix entries
{rjk)
via the
orthogonal projection (averaging), P:f'f(Z)
= /Gf(U-%u)d",
that maps Lz(C) onto the subspace of conjugate-invariant functions Z(G)= "center
L2(C)., QED.
Corollaries: (i) Matrix entries of irreducible representations { K j k : 1 5 j ; k 5 d(a);aE &} form a complete, orthogonal system in L2(G), a noncommutative analog of characters {~(u) = earn' "} on t o m . So any f E L2 can be decomposed into a generalized "Fourier series" in matriz entries,
f ).( = ' K , j k K j k ( " ) , with coefficients a K ,j k = (f I K j k ) d ( a ) . The series converges in the L2-norm, as in the torus-case, and one can also show convergence in all LP-norms ( 1 < p < m), via interpolation. (ii) Convolution formulae for matrix entries and characters, 1 O ; .i f k # i d ( r ) ajm,if k=i
Kjk*Kim=-{
and
I
xT; if K
X**Xa
{ 0;
if
K
I
=u
#u
Those follow by expanding each entry into the product, ajk("Y) =
Kji(z)K&(Y)? 2
using unitarity, K I.k (x-') = r I r k j (and z ) , orthogonality relations (1.5)-(1.6).
1.3. Decomposition. Formula (1.9) implies that characters { x A } form a system of mutually disjoint central projections in the convolution group algebra C(G). This property of characters will be applied now to construct the canonical decomposition of representations. In section 1.3 (proposition 3.2) we have shown that any unitary finite-D representation T is uniquely decomposed into the direct sum of primary components (multiples of irreducibles). For compact groups this result can be extended to all (m-D)
$3.1. The Peter-Weyl Theory
130 representations.
Decomposition Theorem 2 Any unitary representation T of a compact group G is uniquely decomposed into the direct sum of primary components, i.e. Jb = CBJb, - direct sum of invariant subspaces, and the restrictions T I Jb, N a 8 m - are knltiples of a E 8, with finite or infinite multiplicities m = u(a;T). The result is established by passing from the group representation to the convolution algebra e ( G ) ,or L'(G), Irreducible characters
f'Tf
{ x } yield
I
= Gf(U)Tudu.
a family of mutually disjoint (orthogonal) projections
{ P , = TX,:x E &} in 36. The fact that images, (36, = P,(36)} are primary subspaces follows from the characterization of primary subrepresentations:S N r @ m is primary, iff all motriz entries of S { s . (u) = ( S u e j l e k ) } are linear combinations of the matriz 3k entries of T.
Remarks: 1) Irreducible characters, as well as characters of more general finitemultiplicity representations, T N @ a @ m(a); m ( a ) < 00, provide a convenient way to label G, also to analyze irreducrbility and decomposition of T . Indeed, by general (functorial) properties of characters (problem 6),
+
1XT @ s = XT xs; XT gl s = XTXSli it follows that the correspondence T+xT is 1-1, and X T = Cm(a)xr.
(1.10)
As a consequence, one can show i) equivalence: T
-
S iff
xT = xs;
ii) d e g ( T ) = (xT I xT);hence T is irreducible iff 1lxT 112 = 1
(1.11)
iii) intertwining spaces: dim Znt(T;S) = (xT I xs). Formulae
(1.10) along with
orthogonality relations
for
{x,}
yield
a
decomposition of tensor (Kronecker) products of irreducible representations,
a @0 =
@-T
@C(n;a) .1
(1.12)
The multiplicities {C(a;uI T ) } called Clebsch-Gordan coefficients can computed from (1.12)-(1.10) (1.13)
2) The decomposition Theorem remains valid for Banach-space representations, in
83.1. The Peter-Weyl Theory
131
particular, the regular representation R in LP-spaces or e(G). In each case we get a complete system of mutually disjoint central projections { P % } .So any vector ( in V has a generalized Fourier series expansion, ( =
C (%; (* = P , ( ( ) .
However, convergence of
%
such series is usually more subtle issue, it holds in all spaces {LP(G): 1 < p < co}, but not in e(G).
1.4. Noncommutative Fourier transform. Given a function f on a compact group
G we define its operator-Fourier coefficients, ?(A)
= jcf(s)a,dz; so S:f-{3(n)}.
Map 9 takes convolution of functions into the product of Fourier coefficients,
( f * g ) - ( n ) = f ^ ( ~ ) g ^ ( ~ )So . any convolution algebra on G (C, L', etc.) is taken into the direct sum of matrix algebras: $ M a t Map %f share many properties of its 4x1' commutative counterpart, Inversion and Plancherel Theorem: for any function f e C(G'), or L'nL2(G), (1.14)
f o r any f E L2(G), (1.15) I
Here IIAllrrS denotes the Halbert-Schmidt norm of the matrix/operator A
I(A Ilks=t r ( AA*). Inversion
7,
easily follows from the orthogonality relations for matrix
entries and characters, while Plancherel (1.15) is obtained from (1.14), specified to functions g = f*f*. Sequence of degrees {d(a):?rE
c} defines the so called Plancherel
measure on G. Later (chapters 4-5)we shall compute them explicitly for the classical compact Lie groups. Finally,
we
shall specify the
decomposition Theorem
to
the
regular
representation R,f = f ( m ) , and describe the structure of the group algebra LZ(G). Theorem 3: i) regular representation R I L2(G)is decomposed into the direct sum of irreducibles,
RN each
~ - A B ~ ( A ) ,
nEG
appearing with multiplicity equal to its degree d(.rr). Furthermore, LZ(G)= $ L(A)- direct orthogonal sum of subspaces, A
63.1. The Peter-Weyl Theory
132
L(x) = Span{ait:l obtain by central projections, x,: L z - d ( x ) ,
5 j,k 5 d(x)},
1
x r ( f = Xr*f = f *Xr-
ii) Each subspace L(x) is closed under the convolution: L(x)*L(x) c L(x), so L ( r )
f o m a subalgebra of LZ(G),and L(x)*L(u) = 0 for x # u . iii) Each subalgebra L(x) z Matd(,) - the full mat& algebra of degree d ( x ) . Indeed, convolution formulae (1.8) identify basic matrix entries { x j k } in L ( T ) with the Kronecker (bjk}-basis in Matd. So the group algebra LZ(G)on group compact G is decomposed into the @-direct sum of matrix algebras,
1.5. Finite groups. We shall illustrate the foregoing by a few examples of finite
groups. All the above results apply here, but some can be further refined. Namely,
Theorem 4 (i:) There are finitely many irreducible representations number 1 GI = # { conjugacy classes of G}.
9 Matd(,),
v l -
(ii) The group algebra L(G) N representations satisfy:
{x}
hence degrees of
of G , their
irreducible
the order of G.
(1.16)
(iii) Degrees of irreducible representations { d ( x ) } divide the order of G . The first two statements readily follow by labeling irreducible representations by their characters
{xr), then
identifying
{x,}
with a basis of the center
Z(G).The last
statement is less obvious, it exploits some properties of algebraic integers (see problem 5 and ). Example 5: Symmetric group W, has conjugacy classes labeled by all ordered ptuples of integers: m, 2 mz 2 ... 2 mp; E m 3. = n. A representative of conjugacy class LY = (ml;...m k ) , can be chosen as a product of cyclic permutations: ol...ok; o1 = (12...m,), u, = ([m,+l] ...[ml+mz]),...
(i.e. cyclic reshuffling o1 of the first m,
numbers, then m, subsequent numbers, etc.). Two obvious examples of irreducible representations of VV, are the trivial representation x i = 1; and T: = sgng. Another one arises from the natural action of W,
63.1. The Peter-Wevl Theory
133
by permutations of C = {1,2, ..A},( R , f ) ( k ) = f(kg), for k 6C.The regular representation
R on L(E)N 43" has an invariant subspace 'V {f: C f ( k )= 0) N C"-', and one can show that a"-' = R I 'V is irreducible (problem 4, of §1.3), so R is decomposed into the sum, R T O e a"-'. The characters of all three are easy to compute,
-
x,o(s) = 1; xR(g) = #{lC E (1,2,***n), fixed by 9 ) XTn-l(g) = XR - x 0 = #{fixed k ' ~ } 1. Specifically, group W3 of order 6 has 3 conjugacy classes (by the number of
+ m,+ ... = 3) labeled by
partitions a:m, (a) =
{el;
(ab) - made of transpositions ((12); (13); (23)) (2-cycles); (abc) - 3-cycles {(123);(213)}.
So W, has 3 irreducible representations, whose degrees can be found from (1.16)
IG I
= 6 = 12+12+22 (the only way to decompose 6 into the sum of 3 squares!). Thus
we get a complete table of the representations and characters of W3.
I
I
The relative sizes of conjugacy classes {wj= C j / I G I } for VV, are
{i;;;;} (for
classes (a), (ab), (abc) respectively), and one can check directly the orthogonality of characters {xo;x1;x2}with weights {wj}.
Example 6: An ultemuting gToup G = A,, consists of all even permutations of 4 objects {1;2;3;4}. It has order 12 and 4 conjugacy classes:
ICl I = 1; (ab)(cd)- products of 2-cycles, I C, I = 3 (abc) - the class of a 3-cycle (123), I C3I = 4, - the class of (123)2= class of ( M ) , I C4I = 4. (a)={e),
Group A, is split into a semidirect product of an abelian normal group
H Z, xZ,={e; (12)(34); (13)(24); (14)(23)}, and a subgroup Z, generated by a 3-cycle, A, = H Q Z., In the next section we shall develop the representation theory of semidirect products, but here we shall use more elementary tools. We already know two of
A,-
representations: the trivial no, with character xo=l, and a 3-D representation a3 on
53.1. The Peter-Weyl Theory
134
Yoc 43,. Two other are easy to find from the decomposition (1.16): 12 = 1z+1z+1z+32. Thus ?yl = x l and ? y 2 = x z are both one dimensional. In fact both are nontrivial characters of the Abelian factor-group A,/Z, x Zz 1~ Z,. So the character table of A, takes the form: (acb) 1
1
1
1
As above one can easily check the orthogonality relations for
{xj} with weights:
(1.1.1.1) 12’4’3’3
’
Example 7 The symmetric group W, has order 24 and 5 conjugacy classes, (according to partitions a: m, + m, + ... = 4), labeled by ( a ) = {e}-trivial; (ab) - a 2cycle; (ab)(cd)- a pair of 2-cycles; (abc)- a 3-cycle; (abcd) - a 4-cycle. Hence there are 5 irreducible representations. We already know 3 of them: x+ = 1; x- = sgn; and a 3-D representation 7r3, realized in functions on a 4-element set (a homogeneous space of VV,!). Counting their degrees l Z +1’ 3’ = 11, we find that the remaining two representations have degrees: a’ bz = 13, so a = 2; b = 3 (the only solution!). We shall construct them explicitly in $3.3 (see also chapter 5, 55.5).
+
+
A similar analysis applies to W, of order 5! = 120. It has 7 conjugacy classes, labeled by {5}; {4;1}; {3;2}; {3;1;1}; {2;2;1}; {2;1;1;1} and { l ; l ; l ; l ; l }= { e } (by the number of partitions). We already know 3 of its representations: x+ = 1 (trivial); x- = sgn; and 7r4 (of degree 4). The remaining 4 could be shown (problem 8) to have degrees: d = 6;5;5;4. So the entire dual object of VV, consists of 3 pairs: { ~ * } ; { 7 r ~ * } ; { 7 r ~ * } , and {T‘}. In the next sections we shall explain the “breaking into pairs”, and the relation between representations of W, and its subgroup A,. Let us also mention that group A, has 5 conjugacy classes, hence 5 irreducible representations of degrees: d = 1;3; 3; 4; 5 (problem 9).
$3.1. The Peter-Weyl Theory
135
Problems and Exercises: 1. Show that center 1; of any group algebra L(G) consists of class-functions f(uzu-') = f(z) (Elements of 1; commute with the regular representation!). 2. Show that an irreducible character 2; into C.
xr
defines a homomorphism, f
m'
(x*f)(e), from
3. Find the character of the regular representation R on G , and show that XR = 6 ( U ) = 4r)xr. 4. Calculate the Clebsch-Gordan coefficients for K, @ r, and r, @ T , in Examples 5 and 6: groups G = S, and G = A,.
c
5. Theorem [Ser3]: For any fin_ife group order1 G I divides %he degree d(r) of any irreducible representation I 6 G. Follow steps: i) An algebraic integer in the center 2; of the group algebra, is an element u that solves an algebraic equation:
c' aju"-J= n
u"+
with integer coefficients {aj} E Z.
0,
ii) All integers in 1; form a ring, closed under multiplication with complex algebraic integers (numbers), i.e. any combination b j u j of Zintegers {uj} with algebraic integer coefficients {bj} in C, is itself a Zinteger.
c
iii) Take the natural basis in the space Z, which consists of class-functions
1. on C . the j-th conjugacy class e j = (0; elsewiere rnfjek; with integer mfj). Show that functions {ej} are Zintegers (eicej=
C
So any class-function whose values {u(g):g E G} are algebraic integers is itself an integer in Z, therefore any character x is an integer. iv) Any irreducible character
x defines an algebra homomorphism
(problem 2),
qi * Z + C,qi (u) = ' c u ( g ) f ( g ) ; d = degree of r, x that maps algebraickintegers into alghraic complex integers.
v) Apply qix to
x
to show:
qix(x) = + IG I I x) =
I G I - algebraic integer.
But any rational algebraic integer in C is an integer, QED.
6. Characters: (i) check the direct sum, tensor product and conjugation formulae for characters:
xT$s=xT+xs; xT@s=xTxs; XT = R T . (ii) Use these formulae and orthogonality relations for characters to establish (1.10)(1.13). 7 . Averaging: Show that any representation T of a compact group G in an inner product space 36 is equivalent to a unitary representation (Take the product (( q ) in 36 and average it over G, (( I q),, = (Tu( I T,q)du!).
I
8. Analyze 4 remaining irreducible representations of W, (example 7), and show their degrees to be 6; 5; 5; 4. This is the only solution of the equation a2+bz+cz+dz = 102, subject to constraint of problem 5: a,b,c,d divide 120, and another constraint: all four are greater than 1 (as any W, has only two 1-D representations, those of the quotient
136
$3.1. The Peter-Weyl Theory Wn/An!). 9. i) Show that alternating group A, has 5 conjugacy classes, represented by the following elements (cycles and products of cycles): (12345); (21345); (123); (12)(34); and {e}. Hint: take 'even" conjugacy classes in W,, and show that all of them but one, (12345), coincide with the "alternating conjugacy classes"; the W-class of (12345) though splits into two A-classes. Splitting or unsplitting of the W-conjugacy class of g E A, depends on whether the commutant (centralizer) of g in W, Z(g) = {h E W: h - ' g h = g}, 'has" or "has no" an odd permutation (check)! ii) Use Theorem 4 (problem 5) to derive the degrees of irreducible representations of As: d = 1;3;3;4;5.
53.2.Induced representations and
Frobenius reciprocity
137
53.2.Induced representations and Frobenius maprocity. Induction of group representations was introduced in seetion 1.2 (chapter 1). This procedures allows one to construct in a canonical way a representation (2’) of group G , starting from a representation of its subgroup H , and provides one of the basic constructions in the representation theory. Here we shall study induced representations of compact groups, and addreas both problems: irreducibility and decomposition. The former is given by Mackey’s test, the latter by the Frobenius Reciprocity Theorem. Several examples will illustrate the general results, but many more will come in subsequent sections and chapters.
2.1. Induction. The induction procedure arises in the context of group
G acting
on a homogeneous space X cz H\G, g:x-+xg,where H denotes the stabilizer of a fixed point x,,E X . We pick a system of coset representatives { 7 z } z E X in each class
{x = Hg}. Then any element g E G is uniquely decomposed into the product g = hy,, where x = H g is the class of g (mod H ) , and h E H depends on g , and on the choice of coset representatives. Given a pair x E X , g E G we take the product y2g and decompose it as
729 = h(x,9 ) 7,s. The resulting function h:X x G -+H satisfies the cocycle condition
h(x;gu) = h(x;g)h(xg;u),for all x E X and g , u E G.
(2.1)
The induced representation T = ind(S I H ; G ) of group G is constructed from a representation S of H , acting in space ‘V, and could be realized in many different ways.
Construction 1: We take a suitable space of ‘V-valued functions on X ,
e = e ( X ;Y),or L2;etc.,
and define operators
It is an easy exercise to check, using (2.1), that T is a group-representation, independent of a particular choice of coset representatives { r2}. Furthermore, equivalent representations S’; S2of H induce equivalent T’, T 2 of G. The natural examples of induction are furnished by regular representations on G and X , both induced by the trivial representation 1,
RG = ind( 1 I { e } ;G);RX = ind(1 I H ;G). Construction 2. We take a subspace e(G;S) c C(G;‘V) of all ‘V-valued functions on G that transform according to S under the left translates with H ,
83.2. Induced representations and Frobenius reciprocity.
138
representation
I T g f ( z )= f(zg); all z,g E GI. Here T is realized as a subrepresentation of the d(S)-multiple of the regular representation on G, T c R B I
4s)'
One can easily check that both definitions (2.2) and (2.3) of T are equivalent, by writing an intertwining operator W : e(G;S) * e(X;Y). Indeed, each function F ( g ) on G, that transforms according to S, is uniquely determined by its values at coset representatives {yz:z E X } . So we get
W:F(g)-+f(z) = F(y,). The second construction is clearly
independent of a particular choice of {7,}!
Construction 3. A subgroup H c G and a representation S I H in the standard way to an associated vector bundle W = U
Y, N Y.
Y,, over X
Y give
rise in
= H\G, with fibers
ZEX
Group G acts on the bundle W and the base-space X , and two actions commute with the natural projection T:W+X. Moreover on each fiber-space map g:Yz-+Yzs is linear. We call it u ( z , g ) .Function g(z,g) is easily seen to satisfy a cocycle condition
(2.1), with group multiplication turning into the product of operators. The G-action on the vector-bundle results in the induced action by linear transformations on vector-spaces of cross-sections T ( X ;W )= {f(z)E Y,}, equipped with usual (L', L", etc.) norms',
As above one can easily construct an intertwining map W :T ( X ;W)+e(X;Y);or
to C(G;S), and to show that all three definitions (2.2); (2.3); (2.4) are equivalent. 2.2. Commutator algebra and the irreducibility test for Ind. Let X = H\G and u be a representation of H in Y.We choose a particular set of coset representatives {y,}, and construct T = Int(o I H ; G ) in space e ( X ; Y ) .Let H, = y;'Hy, denote a stabilizer (for each fixed z) defines a representation of of Z E X . Notice that the cocycle u h ( z ;9 ) H , in Y.We call it u2,the "pull back o f u I H" by the adjoint (inner) automorphism 4,:
H-+H, = y,Hy,'; W -e assume that all fiber-spaces are furnished with certain norms (inner products), and X has a suitable (G-invariant) ,volume element.
53.2. Induced representations and Frobenius reciprocity
139
4 s ) = 4”; 9)=47A7Yz).
(2.5)
Our goal is to characterize the commutator algebra Com(T), in particular to find conditions for Com(T) to be scalar, i.e. T - irreducible. To this end we use a simple analytical result: any linear operator W on the function-space e ( X ; V ) is given by an operator-valued kernel (in the “finite cue’’ a matrix, with entries labeled by z , y E X ) ;
A(z, y): X x X-’3(V) - the algebra of linear operators on T ‘
Wf(.) = Ix4z;Y)f(Y)al; or
c
A(z;Y)f(Y)* ,EX If W commutes with the induced representation, W T , = TgW,it follows that
A(z; Ybh(y; g)[f(Y’)] = u h ( q g ) A ( z g ; y)[f(y)l; for any
(2.6)
f in e(X;‘V).Changing the variable y+yq in (2.6) we get:
= ah(z,g)A(zg;Yg); and the latter can be rewritten as A(z;Y)ah(y;g)
for
z,y E x; E
The G-action on the product-space X x X = {(z, y)} splits it into the union of Gorbits: 6 w j ; each w . = {(z,y), = (zg;yg): g EG}. One of the orbits is the diagonal 3 1 w,= {(qz)}. Obviously, the value of kernel A at each diagonal point (z,z) is determined by its value at a single point (zo;zo) E w,. Moreover, if H denotes the
in G, then the value A(z,;z,) = A, E le(V), commutes with the representation a of H, A, E Corn(a I H). Conversely, any A, E Com(u I H) can be extended to a matrix/operator-valued kernel A(z; z) on w,, satisfying (2.7). stabilizer of {z,}
Next we shall analyze orbits spanned by non-diagonal pairs { p = (z;y)}, and
H, = H, nH,. Let us observe that any cocycle o(z, g) defines a family of stabilizers {H,} in space ‘V. The RHS of (2.7) can be written in terms of the family of representations {u”}of stabilizers {Hz}, their stabilizers
of representations
(Q-’A(z;y)(u$) = A(z,y), for all g E H(z.y) = H,flHy. This implies in particular that each operator A, = A(z;y) on space ‘V intertwines
n
representations: d‘ I H, H, and a, space of two representations u’ and
I H,nH,.
Conversely, any A, in the intertwining can be extended to an
d‘, restricted on H,nH,,
operator-valued kernel A(z; y), satisfying (2.7) on the entire orbit w of (z; y). Combining both results of our analysis (diagonal and non-diagonal parts of
X X X ) , we get a complete characterization of the commutator algebra for induced
$3.2. Induced representations and Frobenius reciprocity.
140 representations.
Mackey’s Theorem 1: The commutator algebra of t h e induced representation T = ind(a I H;G) consists of all operator-valued kernels A(z,y), satisfying (2.7). Hence,
ComT IICorn(a I H).g Int(aYjI HzjnHyj;azjI HzjnHyj) 3=1
- sum over all orbits { w j }
in
(2.8)
X x X , where (xj;yj) is a point in w j .
Since any G-orbit in X X X has a point of the form (zo;y),where zo is a fixed (distinguished) point in X , we can state (2.8) as
sum over all orbits ( J c X x X . Here we picked a point y = y(w) in each orbit w , and denoted by H , its stabilizer, and by uw the pull-back u y (2.5) of u on H y ( w ) .As a corollary we obtain the folowing Irreducibility Test for induced representations.
Theorem 2: T = ind(u I H;G) is irreducible iff intertwining spaces: .Tnt(az I H ,
Remarks: 1) For
u
is irreducible, and all
nIfy;# I H , n HY)= 0,for any pair z # y.
(2.10)
the sake of presentation we stated the above results for finite/discrete
spaces X. Both of them extend with some technical modifications t o infinite/continuous spaces, the direct sum (2.9) in Mackey’s Theorem being replaced by the direct integral over the orbit-sp;ace R = (X x X ) / G , while the intertwining condition of Irreducibility Test required for almost any pair ( q y ) , or almost any orbit w E R.
2) In many cases, like semidirect products to be discussed in subsequent chapters, the “off-diagonal” part of A(z,y) vanishes for obvious reasons, so irreducibility of T reduces t o irreducibility of a!
A special case of (2.9) arises when H is a normal subgroup of G. Then space coincide with H . X = H \ G is the factor-group, and all conjugate stabilizers The action of G on H,h-tg-lhg, induces the “dual” action4 on “representations of H”, g:u-u[ = o(g-’hg).
-
Note that elernents h E H transform u into an equivalent representation: oh u.
So d depends only on the class of g in H\G, i.e. d= uz (z = H g E X ) . 4The same holds for any automorphism a E Aut(H), a:u-uE = u(ha)!
$3.2.Induced
representations and Frobenius reciprocity
141
Now part relation (2.10) of Theorem 2 takes the form
ICom(T)= Corn(a I H ) V C o n ( o " j I H ; a y j I H)I If o is irreducible and all {#:r # q,}belong to different equivalence-classes in p, then T is irreducible! This observation will be essential in the study of semidirect products in the next section and in chapter 6. But the importance of induction extends far beyond the class of semidirect products and group extensions. Here we shall briefly describe two such examples.
Example 1. Let G = SL(2;IF) be the group of 2 x 2 matrices of determinant 1 over finite (or infinite) field F, and H denote a subgroup of upper triangular matrices , called the Bore1 subgroup of G.
[t :4}
We shall pick a character (1-D representation) x ( h ) of H , and study
T =ind(G;xI H ) . To compute operators { T g }explicitly we choose coset representatives of the form
rZ= (i9,
and write the product:
This factorization shows that the homogeneous space X = H\G
can be identified
with the projective space: P,(F) N IFU{m}, group G acts on X by fractional-linear transformations g:z cz+d' and the representation T transforms functions f(x) by
T,xf(4= x @ . + d ) f ( S ) ; 9 = Using Mackey's test one can check that
3
(2.11)
T X is irreducible iff xz # 1 (Problem 3).
Formula (2.1 1) defines the so called principal series irreducible representations of SL,.
Example 2: Alternating group A,. We already know the degrees of irreducible representations of A, (problem 9 of 53.1): 1; 7r3*;7r4; and 7r5 (superscript indicates the degree of T ) . Two of the list are known to us: 1, and a 4-D representation in "functions
on a 5-point homogeneous space",
C, = {1,2,3,4,5}N A5/W4. In other words the regular representation R = ind(1 I A4;A5) of A, on C, is decomposed into the direct sum: R N 1@ a4. It turns out T' can also be realized, as an induced representation on X,. But this time the inducing character is nontrivial: x = x * , either one of (nontrivial) 1-D representations of A, (rather A,/[commutator]
N
Z3),described in example 6 of 53.1. SO
142
$3.2.Induced representations and Frobenius reciprocity.
7r
= k d ( x 1 A,;A,).
Mackey’s test applies to show that
7r
(2.12)
is irreducible, and 2 representations
T*,
induced by X * are equivalent (problem 6). To complete the analysis of A5 we need to construct a pair of 3-D irreducible representations {7r3*}. Let us remember that A, acts naturally by orthogonal matrices (dodecahedral symmetries) on I$ ($1.1). This action is easily seen to be irreducible (leaves no invariant lines or planes!), and to be of real type
($3.1), i.e. scalar commutator. Another 3-D representation of A, is obtain by conjugating with an outer automorphism 0 = (12) E W,, so 7r3-(g) = 7r3(uga).
7r3
2.3. Characters of induced representations. Since the equivalence class of
T = ind(G;aI H ) is uniquely determined by xT in terms of xg. Indeed, from (2.2),
u we should be able to express its character
Tgf (z) = u(h(z;d ) [(f4 1 , it follows that the only nonzeros contribution to t r ( T g )comes from fixed points {z} of transformation g , i.e. {z: T z g T i l E H } . Then summation over all { Y ~ } ,that conjugate g into H . We can rewrite it in the form,
where summation extends over all fixed points {z}of element g. In subsequent chapters we shall derive similar expressions for induced representations of Lie groups. After the natu.re of irreducible induced representations was analyzed we turn to the decomposition problem for induced T .
Frobenius Reciprocity Theorem: Given an induced representation T = ind(u I H ; G ) , and a representation S of G , the intertwining spaces I n t ( S ; T ) and Int(S I H ; aI H ) are naturally isomorphic. In particular multiplicity of an irreducible 7r E G in T is equal to the intertwining number m(u;alH)= “multiplicity of u in 7r I H”. Proof: We denote by Y(S); Y(u); Y(T)the representation spaces of S, u and T. Each linear map W :Y(S)+Y(T)
is given by an operator-valued function F ( z ) :Y(S)+Y(u),
defined via F(z)u = (Wu)(c),for all u E Y(S).
For operator W to intertwine S and T function F ( z ) must obey the relation:
33.2.Induced representations and Frobenius reciprocity F(z)Sgu= uoh(z,g)F(zg)u, for all z E
143
X,and g E G.
So F ( z ) is uniquely determined by its value at a single point, zo = {H} E H\G,
and
F ( z o ) = u-'(h)F(zo)Sh, for any h E H, so F(zo) intertwines representations S and u of
H. Conversely, each intertwining linear
map Fo = F(zo)E Znt(S;u), extends to an 'intertwining function" f Y z ) = u - l o h(zo;gz)FoS(gz),
which proves the requisite isomorphism of the Znt-spaces, QED.
As a corollary we recover the multiplicities of irreducible { T } in the canonical decomposition of the regular representation RG = ind(l1 {e};G), established in the previous section, RG = @ _T @ d ( T ) , TEG
so the multiplicity of each irreducible
T
is equal to its degree. We also obtain a
decomposition of the regular representation
RX = ind(1 I H;G) on
By Frobenius Reciprocity RX is made up of
{T
E
quotients X = H\G.
G}, whose restriction on H contains a
trivial subrepresentation 1 of H , and the multiplicities,
m(n;Rx)= #{H-invariant
vectors in V ( T ) } . A specific example in case is the regular representation of G = Sq3) on the 2-sphere, R,f(z) = f(z"), f E L2(S2),u E G, induced by a subgroup H = S q 2 ) . In the next chapter 4, we shall obtain a complete decomposition of Lz in the sum of irreducible 00
components @36, 0
(dim%, = 2m+l), each appearing with multiplicity 1, and each
subspace containing a unique H spherical
harmonics on
-
invariant vector (function), Ym(0), called zonal
Sz. The same holds for higher dimensional
spheres
S" N Sqn+l)/SO(n). Once again the regular representation R of group S q n + l ) on L2(S") has simple spectrum (direct sum of multiplicity-free irreducible components), as each irreducible subspace contains a unique Sqn)-invariant (see 55.7).
2.4. Laplacians on Platonic solids. We retell a horror story from a popular thriller
[Kirl]: A student of mathematics having once spent a long but disappointing night playing dice, decided to make the dice "fair". He relabeled its faces from the standard (integer) set {1;2;3;4;5;6},to another sextet, by averaging each face over its 4
neighbors. The new fractional dice played somewhat better, but not quite to his satisfaction, so the student kept on relabeling the faces again and again, maintaining the utmost accuracy he could. How close did he come to the fair mean 3.5 after 30 laborious steps
§3..2. Induced representations and
144
Frobenius reciprocity.
The reader has probably recognized lurking behind this not “very serious” problem, the cubical Laplacian,
L f ( a )= f E f ( @ ) , sum over 4 neighboring faces, acting on “faces of the cuben 4, better to say functionspace ‘Y = e(4). Clearly, Laplacian L commutes with the action (regular representation) of symmetry group G = Gcubeon Y. To diagonalize L we need to decompose ‘Y into the sum of irreducible components @ Ti,and compute eigenvalues { X i = L I Yj}. The number of components equal to the number of G-orbits: w c 4 x 9, and the latter has 3 terms: diagonal wo = {(aa)};neighboring pairs w1 = {(a@)};and opposite pairs, w2 = {(aa’)}(check that
G
acts
transitively on all 3). So there are 3 irreducible
components in ‘Y, and these are easily identified:
Yo = {constants} (deg = 1); ‘TI = {even functions of total sum 0: C f ( a )= 0 (deg = 2); ‘Y2 = {odd functions} (deg = 3).
(rE9
The value of ,C on ‘Yo is Xo = 1. To find A, we pick a particular
fl
= 1 on top and
bottom, and -f on walls of the cube, hence A, = -f. Finally, subspace Yz is represented by f z = 1 (top); - l(bottom); 0 (walls). Hence, A, = 0. Triple {l;-$;O} completely determines L and all its iterates. So we find Lm[f] (f = (1;2;3;4;5;6)) to be within E
= 2-m11
f-f
1 proximity of the mean f = (3.5; ...;3.5).
A similar argument applies to other regular dice, tetrahedron: X = 1;-1 (deg = 3); 3 octahedron: X = 1;-1; 0; dodecahedron: X = 1; -1 (deg = 5); l/& (deg = 3); - l / & (deg = 3). 5 We shall briefly sketch the last case. The dodecahedron has 12 faces and 4 orbits in 4 x 4: diagonal ( c ~ a )adjacent ; pairs
(ap); pairs
one-face-apart (a7);and opposite
pairs (aa’). To identify irreducible components of T ( 4 )N
CI2, we
break it into the even
and add parts, write
‘Yet,= ‘Yo{const}CB ‘Y, (all even f of sum
cf(a) = 0), a
while T o d d = ‘Y3+ CB ‘ Y 3 2
The former (‘V3+) consists of linear functions (vectors) ( E Ff‘ restricted on faces {a E 4 ) . We associate unit ort ea with each face a,and set
t+f&)
= ( . ea.
53.2.Induced representations and
Frobenius reciprocity
145
The latter (Y3-) is made of bi-vectors (tensors) t A 'I by a similar rule
t A 'I+f ( A ,(a) = t /l'I ea = det[t;'I;ea]* *
-8.
The eigenvalues of the even part: A,-, = 1; A, = For T, we pick f = 1 on top face, and f = -15 on 5 adjacent. For T3+ we pick vertical ort ( and compute the (components of 5 adjacent {ea} = l/&, which yields, ,A = l/&. A similar argument applies to A-, = - l/&. But we can also observe that total trace of L = 0, hence A-, = --A3+. Based on our results one can easily analyze more general symmetric random walks of regular polyhedra of (p;q)-type, i.e. probability p to stay at a given vertex/face and probability q to jump to an adjacent one, where p 3q = 1 (or p +4q = 1; p 5q = l), depending on polyhedron. The corresponding operators (stochastic matrices) are combinations: qL p1.
+
+
-+
146
53.2.Induced representations and Frobenius reciprocity. Problems and ExeTcises: 1. Show that the equivalence class of T = ind(S I H ; G ) is unequally determined by the class of S, i.e. given W , E Znt(S,;S,) construct W E Int(T1;Tz). 2. Calculate F(y,g) and show that W intertwines both representations (2.2) and (2.3). 3. Show that the representation T of SL(2;F) given by (2.7) is irreducible iff 'x Mackey's test). 4. Calculate the character of
# 1. (Use
T in problem 3.
5. Find the character of the regular representation and expand it in the sum of irreducible characters.
RX on the quotient-space X = H\G
'
6. Use Mackey's test to show that induced representation 12 of A, is irreducible. Show that representations r (2.12), induced by characters x f!c A,, are equivalent.
*
7. i) Compute irreducible characters of A, on all 5 conjugacy classes, represented by elements: a = (12345); a' = (13524); b = (12)(34); c = (123), and {e}. ii) decompose the regular representation R of A, on space e ( X , ) 2: C" of dodecahedra1 faces (X = A,&), into the sum of 4 irreducible representations: 1 @ 17' (even part of e); r3+@ r3- (odd part).
$3.3. Semidirect products
147
93.3. Semidirect products. In this section we shall examine the structure of irreducible representations of semidirect products: G = R D K . Although the answer becomes more complicated, compared to the directproduct case, there is a systematic procedure t o describe and construct them completely, in the language of Mackey's group extension theory and induced representations. Our presentation here will emphasize the finite/compact examples, but later (chapter 6) many of the results will be extended to continuous (Lie) groups.
3.1. Definition and examples. Let us remind the definition of a semidirect product. Given a pair of groups H and K , K acting by automorphisms of H, u : z +xu, (uE K ; z E H ) , a semidirect product H DK consists of all pairs g = ( 2 , ~ with ) the multiplication rule (z,u).(y,v)=(z.yU
-1
;uv).
It can be easily seen that H = { ( q e ) } forms a normal subgroup of G, while I( = {(e;u)} a subgroup, so that H nI( = {e}, and the whole group G = H . I(. Natural examples of semidirect products include:
i) Dihedral group: D, = Z,
D Z,;
K = Z, acting on Z, by inversion, u: z-+(-z).
ii) Alternating group: A, = (Z, x Z,)
D
Z,. Two subgroups Z, are generated by
double cyclic elements: (12)(34) and (13)(24), while Z, is generated by a triple cyclic permutation (123). iii) Symmetric group:
W, = A,,
D Z,.
Any transposition can be chosen to represent
I( = Z, in VV,,. iv) Affine transformations: (a,b):z+az
+ b, over a finite (or infinite) field IF. Here
translations, b:z+z+b, form a normal subgroup, isomorphic to the additive group IF, while multiplications, z-+az, make up a multiplicative subgroup F* of F. So Aff(F) ? D F*. The affine group can also be realized by the upper-triangular matrices
{P PI},
There are many examples of (infinite) Lie-group semidirect products. Here we mention just two of them (the details of both will appear in chapter 6). v) Euclidian motion group: En = W"
all translations, while subgroup
D
S q n ) . Here normal subgroup Iw" consists of
Sqn)acts on W" by rotations.
vi) Another well-known example is the Poincare group of Special relativity:
$3.3.Semidirect products
148
P4= M4D Sq1,3), here M4 denotes the Minkowski 4-space with indefinite metric (+---),
and S q l ,3) the Lorentz group of all linear transformations that preserve it. Let 8 denot8e the dual object of H, the set of all equivalence classes of irreducible representations of H. Group K (respectively G) acts on H by automorphisms and this action is transferred to 8,
g: x'xg( h) = x(hg Thus the dual object
x
).
a splits into the union of K-orbits
w = {K:K =
For each stabilizer in G.
-1
xg;g E K } E a\K
= R-orbit space.
in H we denote by K , its stabilizer in K , and G, = H D K, its
3.2. Semidirect products with commutative normal subgroups. We shall first study this special case of semidirect products, as it makes the result somewhat easier to formulate and to prove. Theorem 1: Irreducible representations T of a semidirect product, G = HDK, with
commutative normal subgroup H, are parametrized by pairs { ( w ; ~ ) }w, E R - a n orbit of K in H, and U E K, - a n irreducible representation of stabilizer K , of point x E w . Furthermore, T is equivalent to induced representation, T i n d ( x 8 a I H DK,;G). N
Proof: Take a representation T of G, and decompose its restriction, T I H, into a sum of primary components:
Let us observe that the set of characters
{x E fi}
in decomposition (3.1), splits into the
union of G-orbits { w } , under the natural action of G on H . Note also that any two x's in the Same orbit,
xl=xir have
equal multiplicities, the corresponding subspaces being
transformed one into the other by
Tg:Vx1)--'T(x2). Furthermore, direct sum of primary subspaces over w,
is invariant under the entire group G. We denote by S =Sx a subrepresentation,
T g I T(x), of stabilizer G X= H D K X on the X-th primary subspace. Then irreducibility of T I G implies that the primary decomposition of TI H is made of a single orbit w. Picking a point
xo in
w with stabilizer,
Go = H
D K O , one
can easily show that subspace
$3.3.Sem idirect products
149
‘+‘(,yo) is irreducible under representation
S I Go, and T = ind(G;S I Go). Indeed, G acts
on the homogeneous space w =Go\G,
and the associated family of subspaces
{‘+‘(x)}~
forms a G-invariant vector bundle over w. The resulting G-action on
“sections” of the bundle is obviously ind(G;SIG,). Hence, the Mackey test applies to
T is irreducible, iff G
show that
xo
a c t s irreducibly on Y(xo). The verification of the
Mackey’s criteria for
T = ind(G,X@ u I H b KO), is fairly straightforward. All pair-intersections: G ,
nGXo2 H - normal subgroup of G,
and the fiber-actions of H at two different points, y,
# xo are clearly disjoint,
sxo I a 2: xo 8 z # sx 1 a 2: Hence, SxO I G ,
,I. 8
nGo and Sx I G , nGo are also disjoint!
So the irreducibility problem is reduced from representation T of G to a subrepresentation
S = Sx of a stabilizer G X = H b K X on a single fiber Y(x). But the normal subgroup H c G , acts on Y(x) by scalars, {S, = x(h)Z), so irreducibility of Sx I G , is reduced to a representation u(u) = Sx(u) of stabilizer subgroup
K X C K. This completes the proof.
Remark Theorem is a special (finite) case of Mackey’s imprimitiuily system [Mac]. In general such systems are made of a group G, acting on manifold X, and a pair of representations: {T)of G , and {Lf]of the function-algebra e ( X ) in space 36, that obey the natural consistency condition,
Tg-’L,Tg = L f g , for all f , g , where
fg(z) = f(zg).
G. Mackey shows that any irreducible imprimitivity system must be realized in L2 vector-valued functions {$(z)} on the orbit w C X (or a closure of the orbit), by operators, Tg$= $(zg); and Lf$ = f(z)$(z).
We shall illustrate Theorem 1 with several examples:
Example 2: The dihedral group, “9, = Zn b Z,. Its dual, 2, = Z,, each character
x I.(a)
= txp(2ri%); j=o; 1; ...n-1.
Group Z, = (1;~)and automorphism c : x ~ - + x , - ~ ,and point orbits
{w
. = (x3.;xn -3.)}, 3
2,
9)
splits into
(or 2(depending on the odd\even parity of n), and a 1-point
wo = {0}, (or a pair of 1-point orbits: (0); {;}, for even n). So the dual object b, consists of 2-D representations, corresponding to 2-point { w . } , and a pair (or two
orbit:
(9)
3
corresponding to pairs) of 1-dimensional representations of the factor-group Z, = D,/Z, (0) (and/or (9)). The reader could check directly all the general results (Theorem 4 of $3.1) for the dihedral group: (i) the correspondence between irreducible representations
and
#
of
conjugacy
classes; (ii)
orthogonality
relations,
and
the
identity
63.3. Semidirect products
150
Ed(r)’ = order(&); (iii) divisibility of the order of D, b y irreducible degrees {d(r)}. Example 3: The tetrahedral (alternating) group A, = (Z, e Z,) D Z,. We studied this example in the previous section, and now revisit it in the light of Theorem 1. Here normal subgroup
H consists of elements { e ; a = (12)(34); b = (13)(24); c = (14)(23)},
while K = Z, = {e;(123);(132)} permutes {a,b,c} cyclically. Thus
k has
two orbits:
{xo} with 3 chosacters (irreducible representations) of Z, “sitting above it”; and a 3-point orbit w1 with a 3-dimensional representation 2. One can verify straightforward that r1 is equivalent to a representation of problem 4 (51.3 of chapter 1).
wo =
3.3. General yemidirect products. Now we turn to a general case of G = H D K , with an arbitrary (noncommutative) normal subgroup H, and establish the analog of Theorem 1. This discussion will bring in a few important concepts in representation theory: projective representations; cocycles and central extensions. The first step in the derivation is similar to the commutative case. Namely, the representation space breaks into the direct sum of fibers over a single G-orbit w
Here
c c?:
x E H denote equivalence classes of irreducible representations of H. Notice, that
any automorphisrn a E Aut(H) can be lifted t o space
c?,
a:T-TE = Tha;h E H. Thus we get a natural action of G, respectively factor-group K on H . As in the commutative case the restriction Sx = T I T(x) of stabilizer GX = H D K X , is irreducible on the fiber-space T(x). However, the ensuing analysis of S x becomes more involved, since now we have to deal with equivalence classes of H-representations, rather than characters
{ x E E?}.
Cocyclea and central extensions. Given a representation
x E g , and a group K of
automorphisms of H, that leave “class X” invariant, each element u of K defines an
x.
intertwining operator W , in the representation space Yo of Of course, such W , is not unique, but is determined only modulo scalars (Schur’s Lemma). However, once operators { W,} are chosen, they form a so called projective representation of K ,
W,W, = a(u,v)W,,; for all u,vE K , with scalar factor a(u,v). The associative (group) law immediately yields a cocycle condition5 on function
53.3. Semidirect products
151
a(u;v)a(uv;w ) = a(";vw)a(v;w ) , for all triples u, v, w.
(3.3)
4 u ;v), Cocycle a is called trivial (coboundary), if
a(u;v) =
m, for a function (cochain) p(u). P(,.)
A trivial cocycle implies that W could be transformed into an honest representation of K by multiplying each operator W , with P(u). Thus a projective representation is determined up to equivalence by the 2-nd cohomology class of
0,i.e.
element of the quotient group " 2 - ~ 0 ~ y c l/eU2-coboundaries". s~ All notions of representation theory: irreducibility, equivalence, etc., extend to projective representations. In fact, any projective representations of group K can be made an honest representation of a certain central extension of I<, by group T, C*, or more general Abelian group. For a given group K and a cocycle a satisfying (3.3) on K with values in
G,
=K
T = { z =e":O<8<2s},
we define an a-central eztension6 of K ,
g T,as the set of pairs { ( z ; u): z E T;u E K } with multiplication law, ( z ; u )* (21;v) = ( z z ~ a ( u ; v ) ; u v ) .
It is easy to see that any a-projective representation of K gives rise to a
G,. Conversely, any representation of G,, restricted on a subset ((1;~)) =I<, yields an a-projective representation of K . Thus there is 1-1 correspondence between dual objects: a-k (a-projective irreducible representations of K ) and A natural example of central extension, is given by the celebrated Heisenberg group, that will be discussed at the end of the section and in chapter 6.
representation of
ea.
5The terminology came from algebraic topology. The cocycle condition can be written in a more conventional form, via c o b o u n d a y operator B on spaces e p ( G ) of cochaines, i.e. functions a(zl; "'2,): G x x G +"numbers".
...
yzz Operator B takes a p c h a i n a into a p+l-chain, 8:a-(8a)(z0; ...z p )= c (-1)3a(zo; ... zjzjtl; P
"1;
.
... z p ) .
3=0
Here we write the group operation on numbers in the additive form. Linear operator 8 sends and has the property a'= 8.8 = 0. Hence, space of null-vectors vector space ep+Cptl, Zp = {a E eP:8(a)= 0}, called cocycles, contains the image of 8, W' = { p = 8(a):aE €Yt'}, called coboundaries (or trivial cocycles). The quotient ZP/%P forms the p t h cohomology group, X P ( C ) . Cocycles arise naturally in group extensions, and in off-diagonal matrix-entries of group representations (see ch.6). 6For finite K one can show that, modulo coboundary corrections, each cocycle a takes values in a finite subgroup Z, of T (n-th roots of unity). So we can always use a finite group 2, instead of T in the definition of the a-central extension. More general notion of the central extension arises, when circle T is replaced by an Abelian group A, and a represents an A-valued cocycle.
83.3. Semidirect products
152
We proceed to analyze semidirect products. With each point
x E E (a clam of irreducible
representations of H, acting in space To),we associate its stabilizer K,, a cocycle a = aX on K , and an a-projective representation W of K X ,that results from its action on To:
~ ( h "= ) W , x(h)W,'; h E H ; u E K X . On the other hand representation T of the product E DK also yields a ,-primary subspace T(x) of TI H, on which stabilizer G X acts irreducibly by S = Sx. Space Tx
I
factors into the tensor product To8 T,, and each T h Y(x) = ~ ( h81. ) Conjugating the latter with operators {S,:u E K,} we get
S,'(x(h) 8 Z)S, = ,(hU) 8 z = (W,18 Z)(X(h) 8 Z)(W, 8 I ) . Therefore, operators { Q , = S,(W,'
8 I):, E K , } commute with all {X(h) @ I: h E H}.
By Schur's Lemma (see Theorem 3.5 of §1.3), operators {Qu} must be of the form I 8 u,, which yields a representation u of K X in Tl. Since W was a-projective it follows that u must be &projectfive in order for the product S, = W , 8 uu, u E K,, to make an honest representation of K , . It is also obvious that irreducibility of S I G , is equivalent to irreducibility of u.
The results of our analysis can now be summarized in the following
Theorem 4: Let G = H DK be a semidirect product. We take a representation x E H, and denote b y w a K-orbit through point { x } , by K , and G, - stabilizers of x in groups K and G respectively. The action of group K , on "space of X" determines a 2-cocycle (rather 2-nd cohomology class) a E X 2 ( K x ) .We also pick a pair of representations: a-projective W in space to= t ( ~and ; )irreducible, , - projective u in t,.Then (i) irreducible representations T of G are parametrized by all pairs { ( w ; ~ ) } , of K-orbit w c H,and &-projective representations u of K,, at some x E w . (ii) the dual object of G can be viewed as a fibered space over the set of orbits f2 = {w c E?}, with fibers labeled by $-projective irreducible representations of K,, the $-dual object (&K,) , A
6 = uJ w ; ( & q
A
1.
WCH
Furthermore, T is induced by a representation S of G,, whose restrictions on subgroups H and K , are:
S I H c z x 8 1 , SIK,cz
W ~ U .
Remark Theorem 4 obviously includes all previous results for direct products
$3.3. Semidirect products
153
($1.3) as well as semidirect products with Abelian normal subgroups. In both cases representation W becomes trivial, which simplifies the final result.
The following examples illustrate Theorems 1 and 4, as well as the notion of central extension.
Example 5: The affine group, G = { g : I-+ az+b} is a semidirect product F D F*, with the action a:b+b” = ab. The dual group i of a field F is identified with F by means = Xl(ab), and the action of F* of a nontrivial character xl:F+C*, so that each a-Xa(b) def on libecomes a multiplication, a:Xb+X,b. Clearly, $ splits into the union of two orbits,
{O}uw, w = F*. The stabilizer of w is trivial, so there is only one irreducible representation, “sitting above” w, rW=ind(xbI F;G), where b E B*. Thus the dual object G consists of an irreducible representation rwof degree = #F*,and all l-D characters of the Abelian factor-group G/F N F*;G = { a WUF*. }
Example 6 Symmetric group W, is a semidirect product of W,DZ,; ?!,-factor could be represented by any odd permutation of order 2, e.g. Q = (12). We already know all irreducible representations of A, (example 6, $3.1), which is itself a semidirect product (problem 7). These are (i) { x o = 1 ; x I ; x 2 } A,/[commutator] N Z3;
l-D
characters
of
the
commutative
quotient
(ii) x3 - a 3-D irreducible representation. Automorphism Q acting on the dual object A, leaves (1) and { x 3 } invariant (one-point orbits), and permutes {x1;x2}(a two-point orbit). Theorem 4 applies now, and we get a pair of representations of W, over each one-point orbit (labeled by the dual object of Z,):
{ 1}+{ 1; sgn} - l-D characters of the quotient W,/A, { ~ ~ } + ( 7 r ~ ~- +a ;pair a ” of } 3-D representations,
N
Z,;
x3 I A,, extended by g+I,
or -I.
A 2-point orbit w = { x I ; x 2 }yields a 2-Dirreducible (induced) representation r2 of VV,, whose elements are represented by matrices, for h E A,; and a: = Of course, the count of degrees: 12+12+22+32+32= 24, agrees with the general results of $3.1. Group W4 makes up the cubo-octahedral symmetries ($l.l),so it has a number of other interesting “geometric” representations, discussed in problem 8.
53.3. Semidirect products
154
Example 7: Symmetric group W, = A, D Z,. Once again we know the dual object (here we call irreducibles of A, x's, rather than 7r's). of A,: (1); {~3+;x3-~};{x4};{xs} The dual space clearly breaks into 4 orbits: 3 of them one-pointed, and 1 a two-pointed orbit. Each one-point orbit yields a pair of W,-representations of the same degree (with Z,-generator CT being represented by & I ) , while a 2-orbit yields a degree-6 irreducible representation:
(11; {w};
1+
x4 x5
--$
{7r4+}; {*4-};
+
{7r5+}; {*5-};
{x3+;x3-}+
{T".
Thus we recover all 7 irreducibles of W,,and their degrees (problem 8, $3.1).
Example 8: The Hewenberg group G = W, consists of all 3 x 3 upper-triangular matrices
Group G is nilpotent of step 2, i.e. the commutator subgroup the center,
[G;G] is equal to
Group G can be viewed as a semidirect product, F'DF, where IF2 is identified with the normal subgroup
and subgroup
acts on F2by linear transformations a:(b;c)+(b;ctab).
The dual group g2is isomorphic to IF2, where character and the dual action of IF on
x&b) i2becomes,
= Xl(XCtPb),
53.3. Semidirect products a: (A;
F-orbits in each nonzeros A,
@)-(A;
iz are identified with
155
@+.A).
lines parallel to the @-axisthrough (X;O), for
wA= {(A;b):b€IF}
and points {(O;@): PEF} for A=O. Stabilizers of the first family are trivial, while for w = { (O;@)} they coincide with the center 2.The resulting irreducible representations, become
T ~ ind(xX10 = I IF~;G),for A
+ 0,
(3.4)
and all characters of the factor-group G/Z=F2. The reader could write down explicit formula for T X(problem 3 and chapter 6), T X g f ( x )= xO(Xc t x)f(x t a ) , (3.5) where x o ( a )is a nontrivial character of the additive group F, a finite-field analog of eza on R. So the dual object G consists of two families of representations: ITX}, F* of degree #F, and 1-D characters {x E i '}. On the other hand group G can be viewed as a central extension of an Abelian group
by a cocycle, a(h; h') = ab'.
Indeed, multiplying matrices
So irreducible representations (3.4) of
G can be viewed as a-projective
representations of the commutative group F2,with cocycle a (3.6)! More general (finite) Heisenberg group H, represents a central extension of F2"by 2 = F, i.e. elements {g} are given by triples {(a; b;c): a, b E F"; c E F}, with multiplication a ( g ; 9')
= (I .6'.
(3.7)
H, is also a semidirect product, F"+*iF",and has a family of irreducible representations
{T':x F*} (3.5) in spaces of functions on F", T l g f ( z= ) xo(~c+~b.+)f(z+a). Those along with characters
{ x ~ D }of the commutative factor-group
H,/Z
N F2"
$3.3. Semidirect products
156
comprise all irreducible representations of H,
(8ee
chapter 6 for more details). We shall
describe now an interesting topological applications of the finite Heisenberg group.
Example 9: Vector fields on spheres. The problem is to find the maximal number of tangent vector fields on spheres 9 - l C R", linearly independent at each point x E s"-1. Let D(n) denotes their number. If fields {El;...ZD} form such a system, then the standard Gram-Schmidt orthogonalization yields m orthonormal basis of fields
;<&)I,
{ & ( x ) ; ...
tj(z). z = 0; (I.(z) . ( k ( i ) = 6I.k ; for all j , k; at each x .
Taking linearization of fields
(3.8)
{ t j }we get D matrices { A l ;...AD}, so that t j ( z )N Ajx.
(3.9)
We shall apply the representation theory to solve a more simple linear problem
(3.9), although the final answer, number D(n), turned out to be the same for both (3.9) and (3.8). The orthogonality conditions (3.8) imply that matrices { A j } are antisymmetric and satisfy A; = -1; A j A k = -AkAj, for all j # k; (3.10) (problem 3). We want to find the maximal number D of such matrices in R". In the language of representation theory we deal with a group G = GD in D+1 generators {a,; ...a D ; b } , that obey the following relations, b2=l; a~k .a = a a b; (3.11) k j and ask for a minimal degree representation of G , that takes generator b into - I . We claim that G is a finite Heisenberg group 04, over the field7 IF = Z,. Precisely, a'. = b; 3
(i) G contains center
{
Z,; for even D 2 = Z ( G ) = Z, x Z,; for odd D; and the quotient GJZ N Zf is commutative. Center Z is spanned by { b } in the former (even) case, and by ( b } and a = al...aD in the latter case, so (problem 2),
BID,,; even D
'Its official name is the Clifford group, as it generates the Clifford algebra, that plays an important role in representation theory, geometry, topology and Physics. It serves the basis for so the called spinor-groups (2-fold simply connected covers of orthogonal groups), gives rise to spinor structures on manifolds and the Dirac operator.
53.3. Semidirect products
157
We shall state a few other simple properties of G, which the reader is asked to verify (problem 4):
...a . , or
(ii) any element of G is uniquely represented either as ai (il
1
< ... < ip);
2P
as bai l-aiP
(iii) square of any element g in G belongs to the center, moreover, P(P+l)
9 - b 2 , for elements of length p .
Form the previous example 8 (see problem 3) we already know all irreducible representations of the Heisenberg group. They are either 1-D characters of the commutative quotient G / Z (trivial on Z), or an irreducible T = T A ,which takes central generator b to -I (the only possible nontrivial character on Z2!). Representation T Acan D-1 be realized on functions on Z;l2 (even D), or 2 7 (odd D), (problem 3). Hence it has degree: D-1 n = 2’f2; or 2 2 . It might seem we have essentially completed the argument. But there is a small catch, not to be overlooked! Construction (3.4) gives complex irreducible representations of Wn, whereas our goal was a representation (3.10) of real type’. Of course, any complex T can be thought of a real representation of the double-degree, but our goal was to find the esact minimal D to represent (3.10).
So the argument would be completed after we determine the type of representation 2’ (real, complex or quaterni~nic~). The latter could be accomplished by a type-criterion due to Schur. Schur’s Criterion: An irreducible representation T of a finite/compact group G belongs to a real, complex or quaternionic type, depending on the sign of the integral, Schur(T) =
I
G
XT(g2)dg=
+; real-type
- ;quoternionic
(3.12)
The proof of Schur’s criterion is outlined in problem 6. We apply it in our setup. P(P+l) Remembering that all squares { g 2 E G } are &I, depending on parity of 7 (for elements of length p , (iii)), we find the Schur’s number (3.12) to be ‘ha1 type T means that the representation space Y has a real invariant subspace Yo, so T I Y becomes a cornplexification of T I Yo.
-
’We remind the reader that an irreducible unitary representation T in complex space Y belongs to the quaternionic type, if T T (complex conjugate, or contragredient of T ) , i.e. T has real but there is no real invariant subspace in Y. character xT =
xT,
$3.3.Semidirect products
158
...}
x(e)(l- 4-(f)t):( - 7 (3.13) the “double-alternating” sum of binomial coefficients, the tnth term corresponds to
elements of length rn in G. The latter can be written as R(l+i)D - S(l+i)D.Thence, one finds that the sign of Schur(T) depends on the remainder of D modulo 8, and is given by the following table 1
2
3
4
-
-
-
5
0
6
7
+
+
Dt2
22;
I
if D=8m+2, or 8m+4 D-1
22;
if D=8m+7
As an off-shot; of our analysis we see that the number D(n) depends only on the maximal factor 2P in n ! Our exposition closely followed the Kirillov’s book [Kirl].
53.3. Semidirect products
159
Problems and Exercises. 1. (i) Find all irreducible characters of the affine group and show their orthogonality.
(ii) Do the same for the finite Heisenberg groups H, and H,.
2. Show that the Clifford group G of example 9 in D generators {ui:l 5 i 5 D;u:= -1; u i u j = -ujui} is isomorphic to a finite Heisenberg group over Z,: HDIz (for even D)and H(D-l I z x Z , (for odd D). Hint: for even D = 2n, elements { u ~ u ~ ; u ~ u ~ ; . . . ; u , ~ ~ ~ u ~ ~ generake a maximal commutative subgroup, A N find another subgroup E N 2, to get a Z2-cocycle cy(u;b). For odd D = 2n+l, we still have subgroups A , E 2: Z;, but the center is now spanned by b=-Z and element c = ul...uD Show that c commutes with all { u j } . 3. i) Show that irreducible representations { T A }of H, can be realized in space of functions {f(z)} on F, by operators,
T A f ( z ) = xo(Ac+Ab.z)f(z+u), where g = (u,b;c); A E F*, anc! xo(u) - a nontrivial characte! from the additive group F to complex numbers, an analog of exponential function {e"} on R. It is well known (and could be easily verified) that any character x = XA on F is obtained from xo by a "A-factor" : X A ( 4 = xo(Aa); A E F. an analog of xA(u) = ei'a, on R. ii) establish a similar formula for the n-D Heisenberg group H, (the characters of F" have the form: x P ( u ) = xo(p.a);p E F"). 4. Verify the relations (3.10) for matrices { A . } (Use a characterization of antisymmetric 3 matrices, as { A : A z .z = 0, for all E E R"}).
5. Verify properties (i)-(iii) of group G,. 6. Sehur's "type-Criterion". i) We denote by S'(T), A '(2') symmetric and antisymmetric tensor-ezlensions of an operator/representation T in space Y. Show xT(g2) = tr s'(T,) - t r A '(T,), for any g.
ii) Observe that tensor-product space Y @ Y is identified with the matrix-space Mat(Y), whereas subspaces of symmetric and antisymmetric tensors turn into symmetric and antisymmetric matrices { A = ( u j k ) : u k j = & a j k } , and group G acts on Mat(Y) by conjugation, 9: A+=T,AT,. (3.14) iii) Representation (3.14) on Mat(Y) is also equivalent to a G-action, T i ' A T , , on space Mat(Y;Y*). Integrating the latter over G,
-
A+A = $, T i ' A T , , on yields G-invariants l:Y+Y*,intertwining representations T in Y and T in Y*. Note that Mat(V) N S'(Y) @ A ,(Y) - direct sun of symmetric and antisymmetric spaces, and show that Schur integral, IxT(g2)dg, gives the difference of two intertwining numbers: Im(?
T ) on symmetric space PI- Im(T; T
on antisymmetric A
'1
iv) Conclude that for complex-type T, Schur(T) = 0 (space Int(T;T) = O!). For realtype T , the only intertwining operator { A } lies in the symmetric subspace, S'(Y), so Schur(TJ = 1,while quaternionic T has Znt(T;T)1: Com(T) inside antisymmetric space A (Y),so Schur(T)= -l! In the former case, A = I , and representation operators IT,} belong to the orthogonal
53.3. Semidirect products
160 group
qn), in the latter case A =
'} and {Tg}belong to symplectic group
7. Find all irreducible representations of alternating group A, method of Theorem 1.
N
(2, x 2,)
D 2,
Sp(n).
by the
8. Find irreducible characters of W,, and make its character table. 9. Group W, acts naturally by symmetries of the cube (each h E A, rotates 2 antipodal tetrahedral into themselves, while u $ A, f l i p both). There 3 different function-space on
the cube: C (functions on faces); a) eF N ' b) eE N C" (functions on edges); c) e, N c8 (functions on vertices).
So we get 3 associated regular representations of G = W,: RF;R E ; R". i) Write each of them as the induced one, ind(l1 B;G)(find subgroups H); ii) Decompose each R into the sum of irreducible by two different methods, using characters (problem 8), or applying Frobenius reciprocity.
Chapter 4. Lie groups SU(2) and SO(3). Groups of unitary and orthogonal matrices: SY2) and S q 3 ) provide the simplest examples of the classical compact Lie groups, yet they exhibit many essential features of the general theory. Both appear in many different contexts in Mathematics and Physics, not surprising due to the fundamental role of 3-D Euclidian space and its translational and rotational symmetries. After a brief survey of groups SY2), S q 3 ) , their Lie algebras and Haar measures in H.1, we construct and analyze (54.2) their irreducible representations in different realizations: polynomials in 1 and 2 variables, infinitesimal construction. In the next seetion ($4.3) we compute matrix entries and characters of irreducible representations { P }of 4 2 ) , and establish their connections to the classical orthogonal polynomials: Legendre and Jacobi. Then (94.4) we turn to representations of SO(3) realized in spaces of spherical harmonics {Jb,}
on the 2-sphere. Here we shall see
the connection between spectral theory of the spherical Laplacian and the regular representation of SO(3). The last section 94.5 will extend the SqS)-theory to higherdimensional spheres and orthogonal groups.
54.1. Lie groups SU(2) and Sq3) and their Lie algebras.
1.1. Lie group SU(2) consists of all 2 x 2 complex unitary matrices of det = 1, { u = [ -p a- h p ]detu=Ia~+l~~=1
while S q 3 ) is made of 3 x 3 real orthogonal matrices u of det = 1. Both are three dimensional Lie groups, which means they have the structure of smooth (real analytic) %manifolds with differentiable group operations of the product and inverse. The two groups are closely related, SU(2) forms a two-fold cover of SO(3): S q 3 ) u SY2)/{center f I}.
(1.1)
One way to show (1.1) is to realize SU(2) as a multiplicative subgroup of quaternions,
<
Q = {z t iy t j z + h; 2,y , t ,u-real$, j , k - imaginary units} = { = (Y +t jp: a,,&complex}. In the (noncommutative) field of quaternions there exists the norm,
d
m
, with the property: l
Hence the set of unit quaternions (unit sphere)
U = {(:
/
isomorphic to SU(2). Conjugation, <-+u-~(u, with u E U leaves invariant a 3-D real subspace of pure imaginary quaternions {( = yi+ t j t uk}. So it defines a map from
U - SU(2) onto S q 3 ) (problems 1;2).
84.1. Lie groups and Lie algebras: SU(2) and
162
1.2. Local coordinates
Sq3).
(Ed= angles). There are many possible choices
of local
coordinates on SU(2) or SO(3), for instance, a pair ( a ; R e p ) or (a;Smp), on SU(2), or any three independent entries of u E Sq3). Another (better) choice of coordinates is given by so called Euler angles (4,B,$). They arise in a factorization formula: u = u4veu$; 0 5 B
Indeed,
'
writing
p = smZei(4-4)/2, we get '
matrix-entries
of
u E SU(2),
a = cos-e e i(4++)/2.
as
2
(1.2). For Sq3) the corresponding one-parameter subgroups
can be identified with rotations by angles 4,$ about the z-axis, and by angle 6 about the x-axis. The Haar measure (invariant volume element) on both groups is expressed in the Euler-angles as
I
du = -&1inBdBdq5d$
I
(1.3)
Formula (1.3) is a special case of a general invariant volume-element formula on compact Lie groups to be derived in the next chapter. But translational invariance of du can be verified directly. We observe that the quotient-space of G = Sq3), modulo oneparameter subgroup
H = {u4:0
5 4<2r},
G on S2.Given
,B
S2,with the natural action of E S2,we identify z with an element uz = ueull of
is isomorphic to the 2-sphere, H\G
point z=z(e;$)
N
SU(2), via the Euler decomposition. Then the product dS(z)=sinOdOd$, represents the natural (rotation-invariant) area element on S2N H\G. We take u E S y 2 ) factor it as u4uz, then multiply on the right by u E G. The product (u uz)u is factored once again
according to (1.2) into uu = u4,u
,; where
4
the new Euler coordinates are: z'= zu
(zE S2,rotated by u E C ) , and 4 shifted by an angle depending on
(2;
u),
4' = 4+4(z; u).
Since dS(z) is invariant under all rotations z-rz";u E Sq3),and d4 is invariant under all translations: +#~+q5,-,
it follows that du = dSd4 is the right-invariant Haar measure.
1.3. Lie algebras 4 2 ) and 4 3 ) . Lie algebra 4 2 ) consists of all 2 x 2 hermitian
antisymmetric traceless matrices:
while 4 3 ) is made of all 3 x 3 real antisymmetric matrices. Both have a basis of three elements:
$4.1. Lie groups and Lie algebras: SU(2) and
So(3).
163
The basic elements satisfy the commutation relations:
[H;V]= 2 w ; [v;W]= 2H; [W;H]= 2v.
(1.5)
So both Lie algebras are isomorphic, but Lie groups are not! In physics {H; V ;W } are commonly called PauJi (spin) matrices, and denoted by ao;a';a2.The corresponding one-parameter subgroups of Sy2) generated by { H;V ;W } are
[
e z p ( t H ) = ,it L
,-it
1
[
J
L
ezp(tV)=
cost
sint
-sint
cost
1
1
J
L
;ezp(tV)=
cost
isint
isint
cost
1; J
while for S q 3 ) they consist of rotations about 3 coordinate axes.
Problems and Exercises: 1. Quaternions Q can b e
i) 2 x 2 complex matrices ii) all pairs {u = ( a ; z ) : aE R;zE R3}, made of real scalars and 3-vectors, with multiplication given by the dot and cross-products: 21.
u = (ap - t .y;ay
+ p t + t x y}.
Check both statements.
2. Calculate explicitly the homomorphism Su(2)-.So(3). Hint: consider the adjoint action: u+Ad,(X)=u-'Xu of Su(2) on its Lie algebra 4 2 ) 2 : R 3 . Show that (X;Y) = -trXY, is a positive definite inner product on 4 2 ) , and {Adu:u E 342'3' preserve this product. Thus So(2) act by orthogonal transformations on 4 2 ) N R Compute matrix of Ad, in the basis { H; V; W } .
.
Another way to establish the correspondence S m Q N 4 2 ) is via the cross-product in R3 (problem 1): (u . N t x y.
$4.2. Irreducible representations of SY2).
164
54.2. Irreducible representations of SU(2). 2.1. Irreducible repreeentations of group SU(2) can be constructed starting from
its natural action on the complex 2-space C2= {(z'w)}. We shall call this representation a = a19' The action of S y 2 ) on C2 extends to a representation 7rm on the space of all homogeneous polynomials in (z,w) of degree m, !Pm = {f(z, w) = C a j zJw"-J}, as1
(*?f)(z, w) = f(G z-pw; p z
+ow)
O<j<m
(2.1)
It will be convenient to write polynomials f E Tm, in the form
Let us observe that space Tm can be identified with the rnth s y m m e t r i c tensor power of C2,
Tm N P ( C 2 ) c
-
c2El c2€3 ...El c2 = P ( C 2 )
by assigning monomials zjwm-j to symmetrized tensors 2.j = ~
-
y m el ( 8
1 ...8 e, 8 e, ~l ...8 e, ) = xc (el8 ... ~l e 0
~ ) ~ ;
(2.2)
s - (
sum over all permutations c r W,~. Here {el;%} form the natural basis of C2. All tensor-product spaces (C') m, consequently symmetric tensors Ym and polynomials Tm, inherit the natural inner product of C2: (t111) = 6.9; ( t 1 ~ 8t m 1..
I 71 Q ...Q vm) = 0 ( t j I v j ) . 3
So for symmetrized tensors (2.2) we find,
which in the TP,-space takes the form, 0;
Since the original
T
j#k
was unitary the resulting representation am (2.1) also
'We remind the reader that the groupaction on manifold g:z-+g(z) is transformed into the ) left action (representation) on functions {f(z)}, as R ~ ~ (=zf(g-'(z)).
34.2. Irreducible representations o f SU(2).
165
becomes unitary with respect to the product (2.3). Space 9, can be identified with polynomials in one-variable 2 = & by writing
It will be convenient to write polynomials F as
and relabel spaces ,T , so that 3 , will consists of (2m+l)-degree polynomials (dimy, = 2m -k l), with m taking on integer or half-integer values: m = 0;;; I; ... We define an inner product on space 3 , = { F = C a j z m + j } , according to (2.3) m+j)!(m-j)!
-m_<j_<m
and write representation
?rm
as
Theorem 1: Representations { T " } are unitary and irreducible. Any unitary irreducible representation of SU(2) is equivalent to {zm:m = 0;3;1;...}. Proof: We shall use the infinitesimal method of section 1.4 and study the associated representation of Lie algebra 4 2 ) = Span{H;V ;W } . The one-parameter subgroups of the Lie algebra generators (1.4)
after substitution in (2.5) yield ( z ~ ~ ~ = ~ e-i2mt ~ ) ( F(eZitx) z )
(.lrzptvF)(z) = (X sin +- C O S ) ' ~ F (z zcos sin i- cos1
(2.6)
(7r;ptwF)(z) = (z isin i- cos)2mF(S?;;;';;;) Differentiating the RHS of (2.6) in t at t = 0, we find infinitesimal generators of
{ H ;v;W I ,
166
84.2. Irreducible representations of SU(2).
$.
where d denotes the derivative Formula (2.7) could be directly verified to realize su(2)- commutation relations (1.5) by differential operators (problem 1). Next we shall represent generators {HIV;W}by matrices in the natural basis of monomials {zm+j}$ -m in .3 , The direct calculation with (2.7) yields
So operator 7rE is represented by the diagonal matrix, diag(2m;2m-2; .,.-2m), while 7rT and 7 rg are given by tridiagonal matrices with 0's on the main diagonal, {1;2; ...;2m) above the diagonal and {2m;2m-l; ...;I} below the diagonal. Notice, that matrices T;;" and 7rE are not skew symmetric in Czm+' 2: Tm with its natural hermitian product. But if we change it to the product (2.4), i.e. (ej I ek) = (2m-j)!j! bjk1 by conjugating {nV;rW}with diagonal matrix Q = diag (..[(2m-j)!j!]-'/'...}, bring both operators to a skew symmetric form (problem 6).
this will
Irreducibility. By Schur's Lemma we need to show that Com(7rm) is scalar. Matrix A = T; was shown to be diagonal with distinct eigenvalues. Commutator of any such A consists of diagonal matrices. But any diagonal matrix B = diag(b,;...;b,,+,) that commutes with {~;;7rE},also commutes with their linear combination. We take X = T;;" f i7rE - an upper/lower triangular matrix with a single sub/super-diagonal row of non-vanishing pairwise disjoint entries. It is easily to show that any diagonal B that commutes with such .Y must be scalar (problem 2). This proves the first statement. To show that { P : m= 0;f;l; ...} comprise the entire "irreducible list" of SU(2), we shall apply once again the infinitesimal method. Let us note that any representation of Lie algebra s\=su(2) can be lifted (exponentiated) to a global representation of SU(2), since SU(2) 2: S, is simply connected. Lie algebra si =su(2) is contained in the complex Lie algebra (5 =s(2), and forms a so called real (compact) form. This means that (5 = R e is\, as any matrix A E 0 can be decomposed into its symmetric (is\)and antisymmetric (R)parts. So any representation of s\ extends to a complex representation of (5,
54.2. Irreducible representations of SU(2).
I
167
I
In fact there exists a natural 1-1correspondence between representations of s 4 2 ) , respectively SU(2), and complez representatiod of 4, which respects irreducibility and decomposition. This correspondence, known as Weyl "unitary trick", will be examined closely in chapter 5 for more general simple and semisimple groups. Representations of 4 are easier to deal with. We introduce the so called Cartan basis in 4: h=-iH=[l-l)
X=#+W)=
[O 03 Y = - % V + W ) = k o}
and verify the commutation relations [ h ; X ]= 2X; [ h ; Y ]= -2Y; [ X ; Y ]= h.
(2.10)
-
Let r be an irreducible representation of sl, in a complex vector space 9T. We denote by h = r h ; X = rx; Y = r y its generators, respectively H = r H ; V = rv; W = rw - the generators of 4 2 ) . Operator K is diagonalizable with real eigenvalues, since H = ih is equivalent to a skew-symmetric operator (problem 3). Let X, > X, > ... denote the eigenvalues of K, and { E ( X j ) }the corresponding eigenspaces. We shall use the following A
A
-
Lemma 2 i) Ail eigenspaces of r,, are one dimensional, E(Xj) = span{vj}; vj- the
the j-th eigenvector. ii) the highest eigenualue A, = 2m is an integer, and the j - f h eigenvalue X j = 2(m-j); for 0 5 j 5 2m. So dim 'V = 2m 1. iii) operator X is raising eigenvalues: X ( v j )= ajvj-,; while Y ( v j )= bjvj+l
+
A
A
lowering them. iw) sequences of coeffzcienta { a j } , { b j } , obtained by applying eigenvectors satisfy the relations 3 = 2(" - j ) = U i + , b j - bj-l"jl.
p
2 and p
to the j-th (2.11)
'
To prove the Lemma we pick an eigenvector vi of an eigenvalue X j and apply the lowering operator rY to u j . It will move ui to another eigenvector of
7rh,
due to the
'd2(C) can be considered as either real or complex Lie algebra, so one can talk about its real or complex (holomorphic) representations. On the Lie-group level this corresponds to an additional holomorphic (algebraic) structure on G = SL,, which turns it into a complex (algebraic) manifold. In this context one can talk about the usual class of continuous representations T, or impose stronger assumptions, like holomorphic (algebraic) T, i.e. representations with holomorphic (algebraic) matrix entries: i(z) = (T%
54.2. Irreducible representations of Su(2).
168
commutation rehtion (2.10), iP(Vj)
So
P
= (Ph^+[h^;P])(uj) = (Aj-2)9(uj).
mapa E(A,j) into E(Aj-2),
and in a similar fashion, ?:E(Aj)+E(Aj+2).
shows that the eigenvalue spectrum of
h^
This
is invariant under the shift A+A f 2. To get
relation (2.11) we apply the commutator
[?;?I
to
up Next we pick the highest
A .
eigenvector
uo
and
form
a
sequence
{uj=YJ(uo)EE(&,-2j).
The
span
Yo = Sp{uo;...uj...} is invariant under all three generators {h; X ; Y}, as -
8(uj)
.
A
-
= j[&,-2(j-1)]uj.
Hence (irreducibility) To = Y. So spectrum of
h^
(2.12)
is {A,;
&,--2;...},
eigenspaces are 1-dimensional. In order for a sequence of coefficients
as claimed, and all aj
= j[Ao-2(j-1)] in
(2.12) to vanish after finitely many steps A, must be an integer. The symmetric form of sequence {A,;
(A,
- 2); ...; - A,}
results from an involution on
(5,
that interchanges X
and Y.
2.2. Matrix realization. We shall apply Lemma 2 to show that any irreducible representation x of 4 2 ) (respectively 4)is equivalent to xm of (2.1). The goal is to construct a basis in the representation space V ( x ) ,where the generators {H,V;W}, or { h ; X ; Y }could be brought to the form (2.8). We start with the highest eigenvector vo of operator g, according to Lemma 2, and iterate it by lowering operator 9, to get a sequence of eigenvectors v j = YJ(v,). Here all coefficients b j = 1, and { a j } can be calculated by (2.11), A
U1. = X , + . . . + X ~ - ~
.
=j(pm-j+l).
Thus, in the basis {vj = pj(vo)}, operators h ; X; Y are represented by matrices -
r
A
-
.,-
A
Renormalizing the basis: vj+ J M u j , we can bring x into the symmetric form: P = 2*, i.e. 0
1
In this form one easily recognizes the symmetrized form of generators p = ?d - 9 and @ = i(2 P) of 4 2 ) derived in (2.8) (problem 6). So representation x am of
+
-
34.2. Irreducible representations of SU(2).
169
(2.5), and we complete the proof of the Theorem. Remark 1) The construction of irreducible 42)-representations {r"} in (2.5) gave a t
once all finite-dimensional representations of &@).
Both series were linked via
complex/analytic continuation through their joint complex hull 4 ( C ) . Next we would like to determine all irreducible finite-D representations of 4(C), considered as real Lie algebra, respectively representations of the real Lie group G = SL,(C). Both (group and
algebra)
have an involution
g-7
(complex conjugation),
and
two series of
representations, arising from 4 2 ) : holomorphic { r r } and anliholomorphic { a
= r;}.
It turns out that all other representations are obtained by tensor/Kronecker products of two series. Namely, a;m=7r;c33g";
9EG;
and r;.m
= r;@ I + I c3 a:
for Lie algebra elements z (problem 7), a consequence of general properties
of
complexifications and representations of direct products (Theorem 4 of $1.3). Representations
T"""
of SL,(C) could be realized in polynomials of holomorphic and
antiholomorphic variables: F ( z , w ) = z a k j z k 6 j j ,by an extension of (2.5),
>;
-
( m y ?" F ) ( z ;w) = (cz+d)Zm(cG +d)Z"F(%
where matrix g =
E SL,(C). All representations
{P; 3";
2) The infinitesimal construction of irreducible representations eigendata of
(2.14) of SL, are non-
7rm
in terms of the
i,for a specially chosen (Cartan) basis ( h ; X ; Y ) of 4, gives the simplest
example of the highest weight construction of irreducible representations of simple and semisimple Lie algebras, to be studied in the next chapter.
84.2. Irreducible representations of SU(2).
170
Problems and Exercises: 1. Verify the commutation relation of 4 2 ) for differential operators { r H ;rv;
rw} in
(2.7). 2. Check: if a diagonal matrix A = diag(al; ...;a,) commutes with an upper/lower diagonal matrix B with nonzero8 entries bl;...;bn-l above/below the diagonal, then A is scalar.
4
3. Show that for any representation T of the operator T is diagonalizable (Hint: a representation T~ of a Lie group G is unitary iff infinitesimal generators { T X : X € 8 ) are skew symmetric. Any representation of a compact group is unitarizable!).
31
4. If a pair of matrices ( A ; X )satisfies the commutation relation [ A ; X ]= OX,for o # 0, then X is nilpotent, i.e. Xm = 0 for some m (Study the eigenspaces and root-subspaces
of X ) .
5. Apply problem 4 to show that SL, has no nontrivial unitary representations in finite dimension. 6. Conjugate matrices (2.8) with Q = diag [(2,,,- j)!j!]-'/'...}, to bring them to a skewsymmetric form obtained from (2.13).
(..
7.
i)
Given
a
complex
Lie
algebra
8, show
that
its
complexification
6 = 8 @ C = { X + i Y ; X , Y E 8 )is isomorphic to 0 @ 8 (direct sum of Lie algebras). ii) Complex conjugation g+
in
(s
induces a conjugation of representations:
T-rT, = T7 ; which takes holomorphic representations into antiholomorphic ii) Conclude (via Theorem 4 of §1.3), that any irreducible representation T of 8, as a real Lie algebra, is equivalent to a tensor/Kronecker product of holomorphic and antiholomorphic irreducible representations: T 1:r @F
.
54.3. Matrix entries: Legendre and lacobi polynomials.
171
$4.3. Matrix entries and characten of irreducible representations: Legendre and J a d pdynombk In this section we shall compute matrix entries and characters of irreducible representations { P }of 4 2 ) , constructed in the previous section and establish their connection to classical orthogonal polynomials: Legendre and Jacobi.
We shall find matrix entries: rrn = ( T r e kI en) in the natural basis of 9,
Notice that the inner product in 3 , can be expressed by means of the differential operations: (rn+k)!am-', associated to each monomial {P-'}, where a = -.d dz
In other words each polynomial f = ~ u k z m tisk assigned a differential operator
D f = f(a)=
c
(rn--L)!akamSk.
The inner product (4.7) in 9, is then given by rn
rn
-rn
-rn
(f I g ) = Df[g]L=o;where f = Curnzmtk, g = Cbpmtk Using this new form of the inner product and formula (3.1) we can write the knth matrix entry of am as
- b)m-k(-cz
rrn(u)= /,?am-rn-n)!( '(dz rn-k)!(m+k)!
[
+ a),+'
for any u = :]E SL,(C), or 9 4 2 ) . Changing variable, z - e = c(dz - b), and derivative az+d, = we can rewrite (3.2) as
$az,
Next we shall recast (3.3) in terms of Eder angles on SU(2), introduced in 54.1,
(3.4) = i(4-4)12. Remembering that all where the entries a = cosZe e i(4++)/2; are eigenvectors of diagonal elements { e z p t H } , that appear in the right and {ek = J ... left factors of (3.4), rz"zptH(ek)
we get
=
ikt
e&;
84.3. Matrix entries: Legendre and Jacobi polynomials.
172
the RHS to be evaluated at z = sin2B/2. Making another substitution: 2-2 = c o d (the new z bears no relation to the original variable of Tm),and the substitution 1-2 := l+z 2 = cos2e/2;
we bring
7rpn to the form
= 1-Z 2 = sin26/2 ; and
a, = -28,;
Tg(d,e,$) = e i ( t $ + n 4 ) kn(COS ~ m e), with a single variable function
We shall express functions P c in terms of the classical Jacobi polynomials [Erd], [Leb]. There are many different ways to introduce Jacobi polynomials, one of them is through the Rodriguez formula:
The Jacobi polynomials are orthogonal on [-1;1], relative to the weighted L2product:
(3.7) with weight w = (l.-z)O(l+z)P. In fact, orthogonalization of the natural basis {l;z;z2;...zm;...} vie product (3.7) provides an alternative definition of { P ( a ' p ) } . Furthermore, Jacobi polynomials are known to satisfy a second order differential equation: L[y] Amy = 0, y = P k j P ) ( z ) ,where
+
L = a(].- zz)a +
t (a+p)z~a,and ,A = m(m+a+p+i).
(3.8)
In other words, { Pk,P)}m represent eigenfunctions of the Jacobi differential operator L (3.8) with eigenvalues {Am}. This gives yet another characterization of Jacobi polynomials. Returning to functions {Pz}that appear in formulae (3.5)-(3.6) for matrix entries rpn we find them to be n-k
with coefficients
C = C(n;rn;k)= 2-
( n + k ) $ F
m+t)!(m-t)!'
Thus we get a representation of matrix entries of {P} in Euler angles as products of exponentials, trigonometric terms and Jacobi polynomials,
$4.3. Matrix entries: Legendre and Jacobi polynomials.
173
A special class of Jacobi polynomials called Legendre are given by
They correspond to special values
a!
= /3 = 0 in formula (3.6). So Legendre
polynomials are orthogonal on [-1; 11 relative to constant weight ~ ( z =) 1, 1
(f I 9 ) = and satisfy the differential equation:
jf(s)g(z)dz; -l
L[P,] t m ( m t l ) P , = 0, where L = a ( 1 - z2)a, in other words {Pm}are eigenfunctions of the Legendre differential operator L. Let us remark that many other classes of orthogonal polynomials on 1-1; 11 ( Tchebyahev; Gegenbauer; etc.) are also special cases of Jacobi, corresponding to certain values of a;@. Legendre polynomials give a special set of matrix entries,
rG($,O,$)= Const P,(cosO), called spherical functions on SU(2). More general entries of the form TO", are given by the so called associated Legendre functions:
- 2)-n/2{(1 - Z2)m}(m-n). P&(,) = -(I zmm! Namely, = ,/(m+n)!(n-m)! 1
Gn($,',+)
Family
~nm(cosO)eind.
{PL}, also forms an orthogonal system of eigenfunctions in L2[-1; 11 for
the so called u-th associated Legendre operator: 2
L, = a( 1 - z2)a- 1-22' with eigenvalues {Am= m(m+l): m 2 u}.
(3.9)
We shall examine them closely in the next section.
Problems and Exercises: relations for Jacobi polynomials and find the norming constants 2. Show that the Jacobi differential operator L is symmetric w.1. to the product (3.7):
(LfI d = (f I Lg). 3. Use orthogonality of Jacobi polynomials and the fact that the Haar measure on SU(2), du = sinf?d6d4d& in the Euler-angle coordinates, to show that matrix entries are orthogonal. Find their norms 11 rkm, 11
{rrn}
L (G)'
$4.4. Angular momentum and Spherical harmonics
174
$4.4. Representations of SO(3): Angukr momentum and spherical harmonics.
Irreducible representations of the orthogonal group Sq32 will be realized in spaces of spherical harmonics 36, C L (S'). Subspaces (36,) can be characterized in different ways: harmonic polynomials of degree rn on @, eigenspaces of spherical Laplacian A, on S2, irreducible subspaces of Sq3). We Nhall give several proofs of the main decomposition result. One of them exploits important concepts of Weyl algebra and dual pairs (due to R. Howe). It finds an interesting link between irreducible representations of Sq3) and thoee of SL,. Another (computational) argument provides a grouptheoretic base for some well-known recurrence relations of associated Legendre functions. In conclusion we apply the analysis of the regular representation on Sz to the spherical Radon transform.
In the preceding sections we constructed irreducible representations { am} of SU(2), labeled by the spin parameter m = 0;;;l;p; ... (integers and half-integers), which at the same time comprised all complex (holomorphic) irreducible representations of SL,. Only half of {a""},those of integer-valued m, factors through the representation of the orthogonal group S q 3 ) = SY2)/{ 1;-1). Indeed, operators representing the diagonal (Cartan) subgroup { m p t H } of SU(2),
become trivial at t = a (i.e. at u = -I), iff m is integer. Here we shall give another construction of representations {a"} of integral spin realized in spherical harmonics on S2.We denote by 9, the space of all homogeneous polynomials in 3 variables of degree m,
dirn9" = C "A2K = (m+2)(m+l) 2 ' and consider its subspace 36, of harmonic polynomials, i.e. solutions of the Laplace's equation,
Af = (@+ai+a;)f= 0. Group G = 5 q 3 ) acts on W3 by rotations and this action extends to polynomials,
T u f ( 4 = f ( z U ) ,u E 5q31, z E p, and x - d -the action of 5 q 3 ) on W3. There is a natural inner product on polynomials o;, 9 = 9,, which makes T unitary. It can be introduced via differentiation on UP, D= a,; Namely, to each polynomial p = t a , z q , a = (a1;a2;a3), we assign a
(al; a3).
175
i4.4.Angular momentum and Spherical harmonics constant-coefficient differential operator p(D) = x a , D a ; polynomial r' = I z 1 yields the Laplacian A. Then we set
for
instance
radial
for any pair of multi-indices a$. This product coincides with the product induced on symmetric tensor powers of p,Y"(@) E 9, by the natural p-product. Indeed, given a pair of m-tensors t = @ ...8 &,,, q = q1 8 ...8 q,; with the usual product (tI q ) = (tiI qi), and the operation of symmetrization,
n
Sym,:t-+Ym(t) =
$E€,(l)~ ...@tn(,)- s u m over all permutations
0,
the product of symmetrized tensors,
(f"(t)I Yrn(77))
=
f (tI Yrn(rl))*
--
Applying the latter formula to decomposable tensors of the form tCr=e l @... @el a q@...@q a,... whose symmetrizers
Yrn(ta) are identified with monomials zcI E,T,
we get
Theorem 4.1: (i) Space 3, is decomposed into th