SYNTHESIS GAS COMBUSTION Fundamentals and Applications
SYNTHESIS GAS COMBUSTION Fundamentals and Applications
Edited...
396 downloads
2565 Views
8MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
SYNTHESIS GAS COMBUSTION Fundamentals and Applications
SYNTHESIS GAS COMBUSTION Fundamentals and Applications
Edited by
Tim C. Lieuwen Vigor Yang Richard Yetter
Boca Raton London New York
CRC Press is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business
CRC Press Taylor & Francis Group 6000 Broken Sound Parkway NW, Suite 300 Boca Raton, FL 33487-2742 © 2010 by Taylor and Francis Group, LLC CRC Press is an imprint of Taylor & Francis Group, an Informa business No claim to original U.S. Government works Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 International Standard Book Number: 978-1-4200-8534-1 (Hardback) This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the author and publisher cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials or the consequences of their use. The authors and publishers have attempted to trace the copyright holders of all material reproduced in this publication and apologize to copyright holders if permission to publish in this form has not been obtained. If any copyright material has not been acknowledged please write and let us know so we may rectify in any future reprint. Except as permitted under U.S. Copyright Law, no part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced, transmitted, or utilized in any form by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without written permission from the publishers. For permission to photocopy or use material electronically from this work, please access www.copyright. com (http://www.copyright.com/) or contact the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. (CCC), 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400. CCC is a not-for-profit organization that provides licenses and registration for a variety of users. For organizations that have been granted a photocopy license by the CCC, a separate system of payment has been arranged. Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Synthesis gas combustion : fundamentals and applications / editors, Tim Lieuwen, Vigor Yang, Richard Yetter. p. cm. “A CRC title.” Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-1-4200-8534-1 (hardcover : alk. paper) 1. Synthesis gas--Combustion. 2. Gas as fuel. I. Lieuwen, Timothy C. II. Yang, Vigor. III. Yetter, Richard A., 1952- IV. Title. QD516.S926 2010 665.7’72--dc22 Visit the Taylor & Francis Web site at http://www.taylorandfrancis.com and the CRC Press Web site at http://www.crcpress.com
2009026277
Contents Preface......................................................................................................................vii The Editors.................................................................................................................ix Contributors...............................................................................................................xi Chapter 1. Gasification Technology to Produce Synthesis Gas..............................1 Geo A. Richards and Kent H. Casleton Chapter 2. Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms....................... 29 Marcos Chaos, Michael P. Burke, Yiguang Ju, and Frederick L. Dryer Chapter 3. Laminar Flame Properties of H2/CO Mixtures.................................. 71 Jayaprakash Natarajan and Jerry M. Seitzman Chapter 4. Fundamental Combustion Characteristics of Syngas............................ 99 Guillaume Ribert, Piyush Thakre, Zhe Wang, Richard A. Yetter, and Vigor Yang Chapter 5. Turbulent Combustion Properties of Premixed Syngas.................... 129 Robert K. Cheng Chapter 6. Pollutant Formation and Control....................................................... 169 Kevin J. Whitty, Hongzhi R. Zhang, and Eric G. Eddings Chapter 7. Syngas Utilization............................................................................. 193 Geo A. Richards, Kent H. Casleton, and Nathan T. Weiland Chapter 8. Catalytic Combustion of Syngas....................................................... 223 John Mantzaras Chapter 9. Operability Issues Associated with Steady Flowing Combustors.... 261 Tim Lieuwen, Vincent McDonell, Domenic Santavicca, and Thomas Sattelmayer v
vi
Contents
Chapter 10. Combustion of Syngas in Internal Combustion Engines.................. 289 Melanie K. Fox, Gregory K. Lilik, André L. Boehman, and Olivier Le Corre Chapter 11. Solid Oxide Fuel Cells Using Syngas............................................... 329 Robert J. Kee, Huayang Zhu, and Gregory S. Jackson Index....................................................................................................................... 375
Preface The confluence of concerns about climate change, environmental degradation, and energy supply raises many far-reaching challenges regarding energy sources and use. Power suppliers and consumers are looking for an affordable energy supply that will cause limited environmental impact. This situation has created unprecedented technological challenges and opportunities. The fact that coal is an abundant and indigenous U.S. resource makes it a likely contributor to the future energy mix. Furthermore, both India and China, two of the most rapidly developing economies in the world, are also heavy coal users. Coal currently supplies over 50% of the electric power in the United States. Coal usage, however, has been associated with degradation of air quality, water resources, and habitat. In addition, concerns over the role of carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions in global warming raise additional questions about carbon management with coal usage. Currently, 80% of the CO2 emissions due to electric power production come from coal. The continued use of coal and the need to reduce CO2 emissions will thus require lower cost and more effective approaches to coalbased power generation with reduced emissions. Such “clean coal” energy conversion devices will rely on combustion of gasified coal, referred to as synthesis gas, or syngas. Developing a basic understanding of synthesis gas and hydrogen combustion has relevance to many situations—the most near-term application, however, appears to be coal-based integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC) technology. Through coal-based IGCC technology, cleaner electric power production with reduced carbon dioxide emissions is possible. Opportunities for cleaner coal use, hydrogen combustion and production, and the potential for CO2 capture are all strong motivators for the development of IGCC technology. IGCC technology produces significantly lower emissions than other coal-based power systems. When IGCC emissions are compared with those of its nearest coalbased competitor—the super critical pulverized coal (SCPC) boiler power plant—we see that IGCC produces 82% less carbon monoxide, 24% less oxides of nitrogen, 71% less sulfur dioxide, 66% less mercury, 97% less fluorides, 90% less sulfuric acid mist, and 58% less particulate matter. For a 600 megawatt (MW) IGCC power plant, this would represent an overall reduction of 6426 tons annually of regulated pollutants, compared to SCPC. Furthermore, system-level–based models indicate that IGCC is the lowest-cost, coal-based approach to CO2 mitigation through CO2 capture and geologic storage. There is also growing interest in the combustion of bio-derived synthesis gas. Signatory countries to the Kyoto protocol must minimize CO2 emissions—this has motivated substantial interest in utilizing bio-derived fuels, such as tree residues, agricultural waste, paper and pulp residue, switchgrass, and other biomass, which emit near zero net CO2 emissions. vii
viii
Preface
There are other benefits to gasification technology that go beyond reduced emissions and more effective CO2 capture. These include opportunities for hydrogen and liquid fuel production, the use of biomass feedstocks, and compatibility with fuel cells and other advanced power generation technologies. For the above reasons, there is significant interest in better understanding the combustion characteristics of coal and bio-derived synthesis gases. This book presents the current understanding of syngas combustion by summarizing and compiling it into a single volume. The book is divided into two sections, focusing on combustion fundamentals and application/utilization-specific issues. The first section begins with a chapter on syngas production, detailing the technical issues and trade-offs that influence fuel composition. The remaining chapters in this section then treat syngas combustion fundamentals, such as chemical kinetics, laminar and turbulent flame properties, and emissions. The second section details application-specific issues associated with syngas usage in fuel cells, internal combustion engines, and steady-flowing combustion devices, such as gas turbines or boilers. It begins with an overview chapter, with the subsequent chapters focusing on different energy utilization devices. Publication of this book was made possible through the substantial contributions of a number of individuals. We thank the authors for sharing their time and talent in preparing their manuscripts and carefully revising them. The technical drawing and editorial services provided by Xiaodong Chen are gratefully acknowledged. Richard A. Dennis National Energy Technology Laboratory U.S. Department of Energy Timothy C. Lieuwen Georgia Institute of Technology Vigor Yang Georgia Institute of Technology Richard A. Yetter Pennsylvania State University
The Editors Tim Lieuwen, Ph.D., P.E., is an associate professor in aerospace engineering at Georgia Institute of Technology. Dr. Lieuwen performs research in areas relating to clean combustion technologies and alternative fuels. He is an associate editor of the Journal of Propulsion and Power, Combustion Science and Technology, and the Proceedings of the Combustion Institute. He is also on the editorial review board of the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics (AIAA) Publication Committee. Dr. Lieuwen has been the recipient of a variety of teaching awards, best paper awards, and the AIAA Lawrence Sperry Award.
Vigor Yang is William R. T. Oakes Professor and Chair of the School of Aerospace Engineering at Georgia Institute of Technology. He also serves as the editor-in-chief of the Journal of Propulsion and Power. He is the author and editor of several books on propulsion and combustion.
Richard Yetter is professor of mechanical engineering at Pennsylvania State University. He has conducted research in the fields of combustion and propulsion for more than 30 years. He is coauthor of the 4th Edition of Combustion and serves as editor-in-chief for Combustion Science and Technology.
ix
Contributors André L. Boehman Department of Energy and Mineral Engineering Pennsylvania State University University Park, Pennsylvania
Melanie K. Fox Department of Energy and Mineral Engineering Pennsylvania State University University Park, Pennsylvania
Michael P. Burke Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering Princeton University Princeton, New Jersey
Gregory S. Jackson Department of Mechanical Engineering University of Maryland College Park, Maryland
Kent H. Casleton National Energy Technology Laboratory U.S. Department of Energy Morgantown, West Virginia Marcos Chaos Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering Princeton University Princeton, New Jersey Robert K. Cheng Environmental Energy Technology Division Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Berkeley, California Frederick L. Dryer Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering Princeton University Princeton, New Jersey Eric G. Eddings Department of Chemical Engineering Institute for Clean and Secure Energy University of Utah Salt Lake City, Utah
Yiguang Ju Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering Princeton University Princeton, New Jersey Robert J. Kee Engineering Division Colorado School of Mines Golden, Colorado Olivier Le Corre Department of Energetics and Environmental Engineering École des Mines de Nantes Nantes, France Gregory K. Lilik Department of Energy and Mineral Engineering Pennsylvania State University University Park, Pennsylvania John Mantzaras Paul Scherrer Institute Combustion Research Villigen PSI, Switzerland xi
xii
Vincent McDonell UCI Combustion Laboratory University of California (UCI) Irvine, California Jayaprakash Natarajan Georgia Institute of Technology Atlanta, Georgia Guillaume Ribert CORIA–CNRS 6614–INSA de Rouen Campus du Madrillet St. Etienne du Rouvray, France Geo A. Richards National Energy Technology Laboratory U.S. Department of Energy Morgantown, West Virginia Domenic Santavicca Department of Mechanical and Nuclear Engineering Pennsylvania State University University Park, Pennsylvania
Contributors
Piyush Thakre Department of Mechanical and Nuclear Engineering Pennsylvania State University University Park, Pennsylvania Zhe Wang Department of Mechanical and Nuclear Engineering Pennsylvania State University University Park, Pennsylvania Nathan T. Weiland National Energy Technology Laboratory West Virginia University Morgantown, West Virginia Kevin J. Whitty Department of Chemical Engineering Institute for Clean and Secure Energy University of Utah Salt Lake City, Utah
Thomas Sattelmayer Lehrstuhl für Thermodynamik TU–München Garching, Germany
Hongzhi R. Zhang Department of Chemical Engineering Institute for Clean and Secure Energy University of Utah Salt Lake City, Utah
Jerry M. Seitzman School of Aerospace Engineering Georgia Institute of Technology Atlanta, Georgia
Huayang Zhu Engineering Division Colorado School of Mines Golden, Colorado
Technology 1 Gasification to Produce Synthesis Gas Geo A. Richards and Kent H. Casleton Contents 1.1 Overview............................................................................................................1 1.2 Feedstock Properties..........................................................................................3 1.2.1 Reactivity...............................................................................................4 1.2.2 Ash Composition and Properties...........................................................6 1.2.3 Feedstock Preparation...........................................................................7 1.3 Gasifiers.............................................................................................................8 1.3.1 Moving Bed Gasification.......................................................................9 1.3.2 Fluid Bed Gasification......................................................................... 10 1.3.2.1 Bubbling Bed........................................................................ 11 1.3.2.2 Circulating Fluid Bed........................................................... 12 1.3.2.3 Transport Reactor................................................................. 13 1.3.3 Entrained Flow, Slagging Gasifiers..................................................... 13 1.3.4 Comparison of Gasifier Types and Approaches.................................. 15 1.3.5 Syngas Thermal Management............................................................. 16 1.4 Syngas Purification.......................................................................................... 18 1.4.1 Cold Gas Cleanup................................................................................20 1.4.1.1 Acid Gas Scrubbing.............................................................. 22 1.4.1.2 Tars and Carbonyls............................................................... 23 1.4.2 Warm Gas Cleanup.............................................................................. 23 1.5 Conclusions......................................................................................................24 References.................................................................................................................25
1.1 Overview This chapter presents an overview of the processes that are used to create synthetic gas (syngas) for applications described in subsequent chapters. The production of syngas has a long history, dating back to the 1800s. Before the wide availability of electricity and natural gas, “town gas” was generated by coal gasification, and distributed for street lighting, residential cooking, and industrial heating. Some interesting historical milestones for gasification are shown in Table 1.1. While electricity and natural gas have supplanted syngas in these instances, growing demand for energy and chemicals has renewed interest in syngas technology. There are two major reasons: First, syngas can be generated from multiple solid fuel feedstocks, providing greater 1
2
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Table 1.1 Some Milestones in the Early History of Gasification 1804: Coal gas first patented for lighting. 1813: Westminster Bridge (London) illuminated with “town gas” lights on New Year’s Eve using wooden pipes for gas delivery. 1816: Baltimore, Maryland, becomes the first U.S. city to light streets with town gas. 1800s: Town gas lighting in factories replaces candles and lanterns, making the night shift possible and enabling the Industrial Age. Source: NETL (2008).
opportunity to use low-cost and renewable fuels. Second, syngas itself can be flexibly used for power generation, fuel production, or chemical manufacturing. In addition, the carbon associated with the feedstock can be converted to CO2 and separated for geologic sequestration. Historically, many approaches to gasification have been developed, and some have adopted specific terminology that is still used occasionally. Some of these are listed in Table 1.2. Throughout this chapter, the term syngas will be used to describe gasification products from any process. Syngas is ideally a mixture of hydrogen and carbon monoxide produced by gasifying a solid fuel feedstock (such as coal or biomass). Figure 1.1 shows a schematic representation of the general process of converting a solid fuel to synthesis gas. The process is usually carried out by using the heat from carbon oxidation to sustain the gasification reaction. The solid fuel is mixed with the oxidant (air or oxygen) to gasify the fuel. Water or steam is added to control the reaction temperature, and participates in some of the gasification reactions shown in Figure 1.1. In actual practice, the details of this conversion are complicated, and multiple products aside from CO and H2 may be included in the syngas, such as CH4 and tars. Tars are complex mixtures of hydrocarbon materials that can condense on downstream equipment if not removed Table 1.2 Historical Terminology for Various Types of Syngas Town Gas—Syngas that was generated from coal and distributed principally for lighting in the late 1800s. Depending on the gasification approach, higher hydrocarbons could be added to create a yellow flame for illumination (termed carbureted). Water Gas—Syngas produced by reacting hot coke with steam, producing nearly equal volumes of CO and hydrogen. Producer Gas—Syngas produced by reacting humid air with coke, resulting in syngas with significant nitrogen diluent. Blast Furnace Gas—The product gas from blast furnaces where coke is used to reduce iron oxide to iron. The resulting gas is mostly nitrogen-diluted CO, because air is used to oxidize the coke. Source: Shadle et al. (2002).
Gasification Technology to Produce Synthesis Gas
3
Major Gasification Reactions
Oxygen or Air
Gasification with Oxygen CO –111 MJ/kmol C + 1/2 O2
Combustion with Oxygen CO2 –283 MJ/kmol CO + 1/2 O2 Gasification with Carbon Dioxide 2CO + 172 MJ/kmol C + CO2 Gasification with Steam C + H2O CO + H2 + 131 MJ/kmol Gasification with Hydrogen C + 2H2 CH4 + –75 MJ/kmol Water–Gas Shift CO + H2O H2 + CO2 –41 MJ/kmol
Fuel (coal, biomass, petcoke, waste…)
Water (Steam)
Syngas
Ash/Slag
Figure 1.1 Gasification process and major reactions.
or further processed and utilized. Impurities in the solid feedstock (compounds of sulfur, nitrogen, chlorine, and others) will produce impurity species that need to be removed from the syngas. Solid ash residue, the noncombustible material that is primarily the inorganic component of the fuel feedstock, must likewise be separated. The syngas is usually cooled to allow impurity removal, providing sensible heat that can be used to raise steam for power generation, or chemical processes. To understand the various process steps involved in producing clean syngas, this chapter is divided into three sections: properties of the fuel feedstock, approach to gasification, and gas treatment and conditioning.
1.2 Feedstock Properties This chapter emphasizes solid fuel gasification. Coal is the predominant source of gasifier feedstock, supplying 55% of syngas worldwide in 2007 (Gasification World Database, 2007). Although not discussed in this chapter, petroleum and natural gas can also be used to create syngas, supplying 33% and 12%, respectively (Gasification World Database, 2007). In many aspects, liquid and gaseous feedstocks are simpler to gasify than solid fuels. Heavy petroleum liquids may have ash residues and impurities that require consideration, as with solid fuels, but in general are easier to feed into the gasifier. More discussion on gas and liquid fuel gasification can be found in Higman and van der Burgt (2003). The solid fuel feedstock properties are a major factor in deciding what type of gasifier is best suited to a given application. There is a significant body of literature on solid fuel properties; the discussion here will focus on just those properties that
4
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
are relevant to explain why some gasifier designs are a better (or worse) match to a given feedstock. Properties of some example feedstocks are discussed; other types of feedstock can be found in the literature data, or recorded using standard methods. The American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) has established test methods that can be used to measure properties of interest. Details can be found in the ASTM literature. The major properties of interest to evaluate a given fuel are included in the proximate analysis. The proximate analysis for coal is carried out following standard procedures as found in ASTM D3172. An example of the proximate analysis for several coals, biomass, and some petcoke is presented in Table 1.3. The properties of biomass are not necessarily measured in the same manner as coal. Jenkins et al. (1998) describe the different ASTM methods associated with biomass, and present data for many different types of fuels. Comparing the different coals in Table 1.3, it is important to note that the moisture and ash content of the coal are widely variable. For the coals listed, notice, for example, that up to 44% of the coal feedstock can be ash and water that do not contribute to the syngas product (see the lignite entry). Aside from simply diluting the usable feedstock, these constituents rob the syngas product in a second manner. They must be heated to the gasification temperature, yet do not contribute to usable product. For example, if coal with 10% ash is gasified at 1400°C, the ash must be heated to 1400°C by using heat generated during oxidation of carbon. Similar comments apply to the coal moisture, although water can participate in some desirable chemistry, such as hydrogen production. The quantity of heat supplied to the ash and moisture is not available to drive endothermic gasification reactions. This means that more carbon must be “burned” simply to sustain gasification temperatures, thereby lowering the overall process efficiency. The situation is exacerbated by gasifiers that operate at higher temperatures, and explains why moist high-ash coals, particularly when prepared with a water slurry for pumping, are not a good match for high-temperature entrained gasifiers, discussed later. When reporting the performance of gasifiers, it is common to describe the syngas properties per mass of feedstock. Because ash and moisture can represent a significant part of the feedstock, it is important to distinguish performance using coal “as received (ar),” “moisture free (mf),” or “moisture and ash free (maf).” Sometimes maf is designated “dry ash free (daf).” The actual values of moisture and ash content are measured according to ASTM D3302 and D3172 for coal, or E871, E830, and D1102 for biomass. Table 1.3 also includes the ultimate analysis and some ash fusion temperatures, discussed later. The ultimate analysis lists the feedstock composition in terms of chemical elements, and is especially useful to determine the balance of oxygen (and possibly steam) required to produce syngas.
1.2.1 Reactivity In addition to the properties listed in Table 1.3, the reactivity of a feedstock is an important consideration for gasification. The rate of carbon conversion, R = dC/dt, is a measure of reactivity. Depending on the temperature, the rate can be controlled by
33.3 23.4 5.2 17.6 7.7 n/r n/r n/r n/r n/r n/r 6.0 2.2
43.6 40.8 40.2 44.2 6.4 72.9 76 87.1 85.6 76.7 84.8 9.1 5.1
Volatile Matter % (dry) 45.3 54 50.7 45 83.1 24.2 18.7 12.4 12.0 14.4 12.5 89.8 93.6
Fixed Carbon % (dry) 11.1 5.2 9.1 10.8 10.5 2.9 5.3 0.5 2.44 9.0 2.7 1.1 1.35
Ash % (dry) 63.3 72.0 74.0 69.0 83.7 53.4 49.7 48.3 48.6 46.7 50.2 88.7 86.3
C 4.5 5.0 5.1 4.9 1.9 5.6 5.4 6.1 5.9 5.8 6.1 3.6 2.2
H 19.0 16.4 7.9 10.0 2.3 37.9 39.3 45.0 42.8 37.4 40.4 0.0 0.8
O 1.0 1.0 1.6 1.0 0.9 0.1 0.2 0.03 0.2 0.8 0.6 1.8 2.4
N
Ultimate Analysis % (dry)
1.2 0.4 2.3 4.3 0.7 0.1 0.1 0.03 0.04 0.2 0.02 4.7 6.9
S 24.7 28.9 30.7 29.0 29.9 18.4 17.5 17.2 19.0 18.1 19.0 33.8a 32.6a
Dry HHV (MJ/kg)
Notes: A = Babcock and Wilcox Co. (2005); B = Tillman (1994); C = Jenkins et al. (1998); D = Bryers (1995); n/r = not reported. a Not reported wet or dry analysis.
Lignite, North Dakota Sub-Bituminous, Montana Bituminous, Pittsburgh #8 Bituminous, Illinois #6 Anthracite Pine bark Oak bark Tan oak Bagasse Switchgrass Poplar Petcoke (delayed) Petcoke (fluid)
Moisture %
Proximate Analysis
Table 1.3 Properties of Representative Feedstocks Used for Gasification
1,110 1,160 1,216 1,055 n/r 1,194 1,477 1,377 n/r n/r n/r 1,540+ 1,380
Ash Initial Deformation Temperature, Reducing Conditions °C
A A A A A B B B C C C D D
Source
Gasification Technology to Produce Synthesis Gas 5
6
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
gaseous diffusion to the fuel particle, diffusion in the pores, or the chemical reaction rates themselves. It is difficult to precisely quantify the reactivity without specific measurements because it can be influenced by a host of factors, including catalytic effects from ash constituents, and the temperature history of the char. Reactivity data are often developed from thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) measurements. The fuel is heated at a rate that is much slower than in most practical gasifiers. Megaritas et al. (1998) compared measured reactivity from slowly versus rapidly heated coal. The heating rate has a large impact on the measured reactivity, with a higher heating rate producing a more reactive char. Thus, the reported reactivity data should be used only with an awareness of how the reactivity was measured. In spite of the complexity of quantifying reactivity, it is generally true that reactivity is greater for lower-rank coals and biomass than for higher-rank coals:
high reactivity
low reactivity
biomaass, lignites > bituminous > anthracite This particular ordering has practical implications. A relatively unreactive feedstock is difficult to use in a low-temperature gasifier because the carbon conversion is very slow, reducing the gasifier throughput. This is why low-temperature fluid bed systems are usually not considered for anthracite gasification, whereas biomass is very well suited. Petcoke, which is a by-product of petroleum refining, is not very reactive relative to fuels having a greater volatile content. Bryers (1995) discussed different types of petcokes, and presented a table of typical proximate and ultimate analyses, along with ash properties. The reactivity data from TGA show that the reactivity is at the low end of the bituminous range. Salvador et al. (2003) suggested that the reactivity of petcoke is enhanced by catalytic effects of vanadium, which is usually present in petcoke.
1.2.2 Ash Composition and Properties The composition of the ash influences how the ash can be handled during gas ification and subsequent gas processing. For example, in fluid or fixed-bed gasifiers, the feedstock is converted in a reacting bed that is designed to handle the feedstock as a dry solid. The bed temperature must be high enough to convert the carbon, but avoid melting the ash. In contrast, high-temperature “slagging” gasifiers are designed to operate at temperatures where the ash is molten, and can flow as a liquid slag. In this approach, the slag viscosity becomes an important factor, and the gasification temperature must be high enough to insure proper slag flow. The ash properties are most commonly reported with several temperatures that identify how a specified sample behaves following ASTM D1857. As the sample is heated, the sequence of temperatures are reported with the initial deformation, softening, “hemispherical” (that is, forming a hemisphere), and fluid states. For slagging, the temperature where the viscosity is less than 250 Poise is also useful. This is
Gasification Technology to Produce Synthesis Gas
7
accepted as the minimum viscosity to allow slag to flow (Babcock and Wilcox Co., 2005). It is possible to use limestone to “flux” the slag, lowering the temperature needed for adequate slag flow. This approach allows using feedstocks with high melting temperature ash, but at a reduced gasification temperature. Aside from the viscosity and melting temperature, the ash chemical composition is an important consideration. Biomass ash is typically high in alkali, notably potassium, which can attack the refractory used to line some high-temperature gasifiers. This can limit the quantity and type of biomass that can be used in refractory-lined gasifiers, and again emphasizes the need to consider carefully the properties of the fuel and ash when evaluating an application in a specific gasifier. Ash and refractory interactions are discussed in more detail by Bennett et al. (2007, 2008). Table 1.3 lists initial deformation temperatures for the feedstocks under reducing conditions (e.g., for gasification). It is important to emphasize that the characteristic ash temperatures may be considerably different between oxidizing and reducing conditions, sometimes by more than a 100°C. This is because of the different melting characteristics of oxides versus their parent (unreduced) compounds. As a result, ash behavior studied in combustion applications may not be relevant to gasification situations. The characteristic temperatures are strongly influenced by composition, and care must be taken to fully characterize the behavior of ash properties associated with specific fuels. It is not possible to generalize any trend in ash behavior between biomass, coal, or petcoke from Table 1.3, except to note that the ash initial deformation temperatures cover a wide range.
1.2.3 Feedstock Preparation The gasification behavior can be influenced by how the feed is prepared for gasification. Relatively unreactive feedstock could (in principle) be ground fine enough to operate in lower-temperature systems, but the finer particles may not be compatible with fluid bed systems, for example. Likewise, the gasification and feeding behavior may be influenced by drying the feedstock, so that feed preparation should be considered when evaluating how to use a given feedstock. As discussed later, some gasifiers will not operate with coal fines and require removing the fines from the feedstock. Feedstock preparation includes size reduction and drying as needed to meet the gasifier requirements. Drying the coal with low-grade waste heat avoids diluting the high-grade heat from exothermic reactions needed to sustain the endothermic gasification reactions. Drying is also helpful to ensure good feed handling. Takematsu and Maude (1991) review various studies showing the efficiency advantage of drying coal prior to integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC) applications. In one case, the net IGCC power plant efficiency was projected to rise by more than 1.5% when using dry coal feed versus adding water to create a coal slurry for easy coal feeding (discussed below). Takematsu and Maude (1991) also report the change in efficiency to create liquid fuel from coal when using coal dried to 2% moisture versus as received (16.5% moisture). Even though some coal energy was spent drying the coal, the conversion efficiency increased with drying. Adding water to create a coal slurry for feeding produced a significant loss in efficiency. The details of this analysis were presented by Vogt et al. (1984).
8
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Size reduction requirements can range from 50 mm to finely ground particles (~100 microns) for different gasifiers, described in Section 1.3. After proper sizing, the feedstock must be supplied at a controlled rate and conveyed into the gasifier. This can be very challenging for high-pressure gasifiers. Lockhopper arrangements can be used to batch-feed the coal into a high-pressure feed system, but this introduces an awkward cyclic valve arrangement into an otherwise steady-state process. These valve systems require significant maintenance as well as purge and conveyance gas (typically nitrogen) to operate. The conveyance gas is not insignificant because at high pressure, gas density and flow required for dilute-phase solids transport will compromise the syngas purity. Where pulverized coal is used, steady feed coal “pumps” have recently been developed (Aldred and Saunders, 2003, 2005) that are expected to simplify the process of feeding dry solids. Alternatively, the coal can be suspended in water slurry having as much as ~70% solids loading by mass. This allows easy pumping of the coal, but the injected water adds a significant energy penalty, discussed above. Because of growing interest in biomass as a feedstock, a few points are discussed relative just to biomass. At the present writing, there is no standard method to prepare and feed biomass for pressurized gasifiers. Biomass preparation techniques for atmospheric pressure boilers are still developing (Werthera et al., 2000; Zulfiqar et al., 2006), such that pressurized feeding for gasification presents added challenges. Wood biomass (e.g., trees) requires considerable grinding energy to reduce the wood to small particles (submillimeter), which are required in entrained gasifiers. Likewise, fibrous biomass (such as switchgrass) is very difficult to shred and grind into easily fed particles. For high-pressure entrained flow gasifiers, Bergman et al. (2005) evaluate the use of a low-temperature (200 to 300°C) heat treatment called torrefaction to simplify grinding the biomass. Without torrefaction, the electrical power required to mill woody biomass to 0.2 mm size is approximately 12 to 16% of the electrical energy produced by the biomass (assuming a 40% efficient biomass to electricity). With torrefaction, this grinding energy could drop to as low as 1.5%, but this is offset by the need to supply heat, albeit at low temperature. Further study is recommended on optimizing the methods to prepare and feed biomass and coal mixtures in high-pressure gasifiers. It is interesting to note that in some laboratory studies of mixed coal/biomass gasification (McClendon et al., 2004) the addition of fine sawdust actually improved the feeding reliability for coal injection. Thus, there may be a beneficial synergy when combining coal and particular forms of biomass, as expected from fundamental studies (Zulfiqar et al., 2006).
1.3 Gasifiers Detailed descriptions of gasifier types can be found in various references (Probstein and Hicks, 1990; Simbeck et al., 1993). Operating data and novel gasifiers studied prior to the 1980s are found in some early reports (Handbook of Gasifiers and Gas Treatment Systems, 1976; Hendrickson, 1975). Novel approaches to gasification such as catalytic, molten salt, plasma, or indirectly heated systems are described elsewhere (Handbook of Gasifiers and Gas Treatment Systems, 1976;
9
Gasification Technology to Produce Synthesis Gas
Hendrickson, 1975; Heinemann and Somorjai, 1994; Dighe and Lazzara, 2002; Paisley and Overend, 2002). In this chapter, only the major gasifier configurations in use today are described. The main gasifier types are moving bed, fluid bed, and entrained flow systems.
1.3.1 Moving Bed Gasification Figure 1.2 shows the general layout of the moving bed gasifier. The gasifier can be arranged in updraft (countercurrent) and downdraft (co-current) arrangements. In the downdraft arrangement, coal and oxidants enter together, so that the highest temperatures occur at the exit, producing a relatively high-temperature exhaust stream (~700°C) (Reed and Gauer, 2001). This is shown schematically by the temperature profile in Figure 1.2. The high temperatures help complete gasification reactions, so that relatively little tar exists in the products. This type of gasifier has been used extensively in small-scale applications, including vehicle applications during World War II (Reed and Gauer, 2001). Compared to the counterflow arrangement, the disadvantage Coal
Product gas Updraft Bed
Temp Oxygen or air
Oxygen or air
Ash Coal
Steam
Steam
Downdraft Bed Product gas Ash
Figure 1.2 Moving bed gasifiers.
Temp
10
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
of the co-flow arrangement is that the higher sensible energy of the product gas must be integrated in downstream processes to achieve comparable overall efficiency. For the updraft (counterflow) arrangement, coal enters the reactor at the top through a lockhopper arrangement. The coal typically enters via a rotating distributor in a bed that is supplied with oxygen and steam from the bottom. The counterflow arrangement allows high-temperature combustion reactions to consume the coal char at the bottom of the bed. Hot products flow upward to gasify the coal and volatiles in the upper region of the bed. Thus, as shown in Figure 1.2, the temperature profile has a bulge in the middle of the bed. Ash drops out of the bottom of the bed to an ash handling system. The advantage of this counterflow arrangement is that the gases exiting the bed are cooled by the incoming fuel, so that the gas exit temperature is typically between 425 and 650°C, but may be even lower (250 to 500°C), depending on the coal type (Rudolph, 1984). This makes efficient use of the thermal energy released by oxidizing some of the solid carbon. However, because of these low temperatures, coal tar and some oxygenated compounds are formed in the syngas. These compounds can represent a significant fraction of the input fuel energy (Higman and van der Burgt, 2003) and should be used in the process downstream for efficient operation. The moving bed design can be used with multiple coal types. However, care must be taken when using “swelling” coals, which can essentially plug the bed. Coal swelling can be characterized on scales defined, for example, in ASTM D720-91. Where high-swelling coals are used, the distributor can be arranged to stir the bed (see Rudolph, 1984). For moving bed operation, coal fines (less than 3mm diameter coal) should be avoided to prevent the bed from agglomerating. The necessity to avoid fines adds process complexity to the plant configuration. In existing designs, the coal fines can be separated from the fuel stream, and supplied to an auxiliary boiler to raise steam, or some of the fines can be bound into “briquettes” using coal tars as a binder (Higman and van der Burgt, 2003). The counterflow moving bed configuration is the type of gasifier widely used to produce synthesis gas for the Fischer-Tropsch process for creating liquid fuel from synthesis gas (Gasification World Database, 2007). A slagging version of the moving bed has been developed, and operates in the same manner as described above, except that steam injection is reduced. This allows the bed peak temperatures to rise high enough to melt the ash and produces an easily handled slag product (Higman and van der Burgt, 2003).
1.3.2 Fluid Bed Gasification Within the category of fluid bed gasifiers, there are subcategories distinguished by the bulk velocity of gas moving in the bed. Each of these processes is described below and shown schematically in Figure 1.3. The higher gas velocities of circulating and transport gasifiers produce greater heat transfer to the fuel particles. This increases the heating rate, and as discussed in Section 1.2, rapid heating produces a more reactive char (Megaritis et al., 1998), and is favored for carbon conversion to syngas. The different types of fluid bed gasifiers are described in the following subsections referring to Figure 1.3.
11
Gasification Technology to Produce Synthesis Gas Coal
Product gas
Bubbling
Steam
Ash
Oxygen or air Product gas
Coal
Entrained solids
Cyclone
Circulating
Steam
Ash
Oxygen or air Product gas
Transport Coal
Steam
Oxygen or air
Figure 1.3 Fluid bed gasifiers.
1.3.2.1 Bubbling Bed At relatively low velocity (less than 5 m/s), the bed is characterized by discrete bubbles of gas, much like a boiling fluid. The region above the bed (freeboard) is clearly distinct from the bed. The fluid motion of the bed approximates a continuously stirred reactor and provides a homogenous temperature environment for coal reaction. The bed itself is mostly ash, and the intent is that the carbon leaves the bed as syngas, although some ash with carbon and unburned fines are conveyed up into the freeboard region. A key to operating is avoiding temperature conditions where the ash will soften and form agglomerates. This means that the bed temperature must be maintained well below the ash fusion temperature, which may range from 950 to 1100°C for coal, and
12
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
can be even lower for some types of biomass ash. Thus, control of the bed conditions and knowledge of the ash properties are design considerations for these systems. The relatively low gasification temperature requires less oxygen than for entrained flow gasifiers. However, the stirred-reactor mixing ensures that some of the extracted ash will contain unburned carbon. Higman and van der Burgt (2003) state that the best atmospheric pressure fluid bed gasifiers achieve only 97% carbon conversion, but that pressurized biomass fluid bed gasifiers can achieve 99% efficiency. Because fluid bed gasifiers operate at low temperature, and the bed is made of ash, they can handle fuels with high reactivity and high levels of ash content—which describes many biomass fuels and low-rank coals. For less reactive coals, the lower carbon conversion is a disadvantage. In some cases, the ash can contain 20% of the original fuel carbon, and a subsequent boiler is added to burn out the remaining carbon (Higman and van der Burgt, 2003). To improve carbon conversion, and increase throughput, additional oxidant and steam can be added to the freeboard region, raising the temperature of the product stream to provide better conversion of the fines and unburned carbon carried into this region. The higher temperatures also reduce the tars remaining in the syngas. A recycle loop is used to further oxidize unburned carbon. Supp (1990) provides some data on a commercial process using this approach, and notes that ash leaving the bottom of the bed can still carry 4% of the carbon input and may be sent to an auxiliary boiler. There are numerous small-scale commercial vendors of bubbling fluid bed gasifiers. A report by Ciferno and Marano (2002) considered the range of possible gasifiers for biomass applications, and noted that there were multiple bubbling fluid bed gasifiers being used for biomass applications. From the report, bubbling fluid bed reactors have been developed or demonstrated over the following range of conditions: • 4.5 to 181 metric tons per day input of biomass • Both air and oxygen input • Pressures from 1 to 35 bar(s) 1.3.2.2 Circulating Fluid Bed Compared to the bubbling bed approach, the circulating fluid bed can provide greater carbon conversion and reduced tar formation. As shown in Figure 1.3, raising the fluidization gas velocity (typically 5 to 8 m/s) entrains smaller particles, which are converted above the bed or separated in a cyclone for return to the bed (that is, circulating bed). The larger coal particles remain in the bed where they are oxidized. The higher velocity increases the coal heating rate, which lowers tar production. The higher gas velocity can accommodate greater throughput than a bubbling bed system. Circulating fluid bed (CFB) systems are being used for multiple biomass applications. In many installations, CFB gasifiers are atmospheric pressure and use air as an oxidant. This approach is relatively simple, and where the fuel is used for process heat (combustion) applications, it is very effective. Commercial literature indicates
Gasification Technology to Produce Synthesis Gas
13
multiple applications of CFB gasifiers to provide fuel gas to ambient pressure combustors used in lime kilns, or boilers (Palonen et al., 2005). A pressurized version of a CFB gasifier has been used for a biomass-fueled IGCC demonstration in Värnamo, Sweden. The concept was technically successful, but was not profitable enough for continued operation in the year 2000 (see Reed and Gauer, 2001, or more recently, the Chrisgas project, http://www.chrisgas.com). CFB gasifiers have been evaluated as a source of biomass syngas for liquid fuel production by Boerrigter et al. (2003). These authors suggest (but do not quantitatively demonstrate) that biomass syngas plants will likely be plants with pressurized, oxygen-blown gasifiers. The relative merits of pressurized (versus atmospheric) gasifiers for biomass applications are discussed by Bridgewater (1995). 1.3.2.3 Transport Reactor At sufficiently high gas velocity (~15 m/s), all of the bed material can be deliberately transported up the reactor by the gas flow (Figure 1.3). The particulate matter is separated from the gas and then collects in a “standpipe” before being entrained again in the riser reactor for another cycle around the reactor. The circulating solid, including the ash, provides useful thermal ballast that recycles heat back into the incoming reaction stream. Compared to circulating fluid bed, the transport reactor has yet again greater throughput, and the heating rates for coal particles are higher than in other fluid beds. The rapid coal particle heating serves to rapidly evolve the coal volatile matter, reducing the tendency to crack the volatiles and form tars. For coal applications, a development reactor has been built at Wilsonville, Alabama (Leonard, 2007) and has demonstrated gasification of low-rank coal at up to 2500 kg/h (Nelson et al., 2003). Most experience to date has been on low-rank coals, but less reactive bituminous coal has also been gasified with a lower carbon conversion (Wallace et al., 2006).
1.3.3 Entrained Flow, Slagging Gasifiers Unlike moving bed or fluid bed gasifiers, entrained flow gasifiers are designed to operate at temperatures high enough to melt the coal ash, usually above 1250°C. This is achieved by using more oxygen to achieve higher temperatures in the gasifier. Compared to other approaches, this uses more of the fuel energy for gasification, and lowers the overall efficiency of converting the feedstock to syngas. The lower efficiency is offset by some significant advantages. The higher temperatures usually ensure that the product gas is free of tars, and the carbon conversion is very high. Virtually any type of solid fuel can be used in these gasifiers, as long as it is properly ground for the feed system, usually less than 100 microns in size. In some designs, the slag is easily disposed, or ground to saleable product (Amick and Dowd, 2001; Geertsema et al., 2002). These advantages explain why many new IGGC plants have been proposed to use entrained flow systems. Figure 1.4 shows simple schematics of different types of entrained flow gasifiers. In the single-stage system at the top, all the coal and oxidant enter at one end of the
14
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications Oxygen or air
Coal
Steam Product gas
Downflow
Single Stage
Upflow
Coal Steam Oxygen or air
Product gas Slag Oxygen or air
Coal 1st stage
Slag Steam Product gas
Downflow Two Stage
Upflow Coal 2nd stage
Coal 2nd stage
Coal 1st stage Steam Oxygen or air
Product gas Sl ag
Slag
Figure 1.4 Entrained flow gasifiers.
gasifier, and the heat released by combustion serves to gasify the coal. The flow can be arranged up or down, with the slag flowing out the bottom. Sufficient residence time is needed to completely oxidize the coal carbon to CO, typically requiring less than 10 s residence time. In the lower part of Figure 1.4, the two-stage gasifier uses the products of the first gasification zone to gasify coal injected in the second stage. Again, the process can be arranged with up- or downflow configuration. Endothermic gasification reactions in the second stage serve to lower the exit temperature compared to a single-stage design. The result is a lower oxygen demand per mass of coal, and a higher efficiency conversion to syngas fuel. If the second stage is operated with excess coal, some tars and hydrocarbons can be formed, but this can be avoided with proper design and operation.
Gasification Technology to Produce Synthesis Gas
15
1.3.4 Comparison of Gasifier Types and Approaches The discussion thus far has not specifically described the trade-offs between oxygenblown and air-blown gasification, or between high-pressure and ambient-pressure gasification. In principle, the gasifiers described above could operate with air or oxygen and at any pressure level. In practice, the choice to use oxygen, or high pressure, depends on the overall plant economics and energy needs. Pressurized operation increases the throughput for a given size reactor, and is especially favored when the syngas is to be used in a pressurized application such as a gas turbine, or highpressure chemical synthesis. Likewise, oxygen gasification avoids diluting the syngas with nitrogen from air, making it suitable for many chemical applications that require undiluted syngas. However, oxygen generation typically requires considerable energy—1.3 MJ/kg oxygen is a typical value of the electrical energy required by a cryogenic oxygen plant (from Simbeck et al., 1993) for oxygen supplied at pressure. This energy requirement may be 5 to 7% of the electrical power produced by an IGCC power plant (Higman and van der Burgt, 2003) or even greater (Jaeger, 2007). For some applications, the cost of the oxygen supply may not be justified and air-blown gasification can be used. For example, a recent IGCC plant in Japan uses a two-stage air-blown gasifier with a very small air separation unit to provide small amounts of nitrogen for conveying the feedstock and slightly enriching the gasifier oxygen level (“Mitsubishi,” 2007). Table 1.4 summarizes the features of the different gasifiers discussed above. The table listings are typical, but it should be recognized that different fuel types and operating conditions can change these listings. For example, high-moisture feedstocks may operate at temperatures below the range listed if they have adequate reactivity. The throughput and residence times are useful to compare each style of reactor, but the actual fuel throughput is a strong function of the specific feedstock and operating conditions. The chart shows the advantage of the higher-temperature gasifier: the throughput is much greater for a given reactor cross section, and essentially any fuel that is suitably ground can be used. As already explained, the dis advantage of the higher temperature is that the sensible energy in the product gas needs to be recovered for efficient fuel use, and this is discussed in Section 1.3.5. Table 1.4 lists some cold gas efficiencies. The cold gas efficiency is the ratio of fuel heat content to the syngas heat content at ambient conditions and is a measure of how efficiently fuel energy is converted to syngas energy. For the cases reported, the moving bed is most efficient but has the disadvantage that some of the syngas energy is produced in tars. The listed efficiencies (~85%) support the rule of thumb that approximately 15% of the feedstock heating value is used to convert the feedstock to syngas. The oxygen requirement in Table 1.4 applies to oxygen-blown gasification only and is expressed as the ratio of oxygen to moisture and ash-free coal. The advantage of low-temperature gasification is evident—the oxygen demand for the moving bed design is slightly more than half that of the entrained flow gasifier. Given the high
16
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Table 1.4 Comparison of Gasifier Types Moving Bed
Fluid Bed
Entrained Flow
References
Feedstock size
5–50 mm
<5 mm
<100 microns
Preferred feedstock type
Low rank, limited fines, swelling coals must be stirred 425–650 C
Low rank
Any feedstock
Simbeck et al., 1993; Higman and van der Burgt, 2003 Simbeck et al., 1993; Higman and van der Burgt, 2003
900–1,050 C
1,250–1,600 C
100–160
240–320
320–450
60–120 min 84% (dry ash) 88% (slagging) 0.43 (dry ash) 0.53 (slagging)
20–30 min 80.8
<10 s 81
0.71
0.81
Gasifier outlet temperature Throughput (metric tons/day/m2) Residence time Cold gas efficiency (high-rank coal) Oxygen requirement (kg/kg maf coal)
Simbeck et al., 1993; Higman and van der Burgt, 2003 Takematsu and Maude, 1991 Riemert, 1989 Takematsu and Maude, 1991 Takematsu and Maude, 1991
Note: The numbers are typical from the cited sources, but may differ with specific installations and feedstocks.
energy demand for making oxygen, that can be an advantage, but is somewhat offset by lower throughput, tar production, and feedstock limits for moving bed designs.
1.3.5 Syngas Thermal Management While higher gasification temperatures are advantageous to avoid tars and enhance carbon conversion, the product synthesis gas contains appreciable sensible thermal energy that should be used for efficient fuel conversion. Mahagaokar and Doering (1995) discuss the various approaches to recover this energy, typically about 15% of the fuel heating value for entrained flow gasifiers. Figure 1.5 shows three approaches that are used. These methods are typically considered for entrained flow gasifiers, where the higher gasification temperature justifies heat recovery. At the top, water quench can be used to cool the syngas in one step to approximately 250°C. This approach is very effective for cooling, and where water needs to be added to the process (for downstream water gas shift), quenching is not a significant drawback. The quench also serves to freeze molten slag and ash in the water, reducing the solid filtration load. However, the quench does degrade the sensible energy availability that could otherwise be used to raise steam for power cycles such as IGCC. To recover more energy, the gas quench approach (middle, Figure 1.5) recycles cooled syngas to lower the temperature enough so that convection coolers can be used to raise steam. Enough gas is recycled to cool the syngas below the temperature
17
Gasification Technology to Produce Synthesis Gas
Water Quench Coal and O2 Gasifier
Solid filtration
Water ~250°C Slag
Coal and O2
Partial Gas Quench Recycle blower Solid filtration
Gasifier
~250°C
H2O (liq) Steam
~900°C Radiant Syngas Cooler Coal and O2 Solid filtration
Gasifier
~250°C Radiant boiler
H2O (liq)
H2O (liq) Steam
Steam ~90°C
Figure 1.5 Approaches to thermal integration. Temperatures are approximate.
18
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
where ash adhesion could foul the heat exchangers, usually below 900°C, depending on the ash. Finally, at the bottom of Figure 1.5, a radiant boiler can be used to directly cool the gasifier products from the gasification temperature. This has the potential to raise steam from the syngas at very high temperature, and is currently practiced in one IGCC plant. The radiant cooler measures an impressive 30 m in length and weighs 815 metric tons (Tampa Electric Integrated Gasification Combined-Cycle Project, 2000). The size and complexity of this type of boiler are obviously a trade-off with the value of recovering high-grade thermal energy. The approach selected to manage the syngas thermal energy depends on specifics of the syngas application. For example, when the syngas is used to make chemicals, the benefit of adding syngas coolers may not offset the penalty of size, cost, and complexity. For example, the Fischer-Tropsch process to create liquid fuels from syngas is carried out at 200 to 250°C, so that direct quench to saturation at these conditions can provide water needed for the process, and cools the gas in a straightforward manner.
1.4 Syngas Purification Syngas must usually be cleaned to meet requirements for downstream applications or environmental emission standards. Table 1.5 summarizes the major species that must be considered for cleanup and indicates why some cleanup requirements are established for different applications or environmental reasons. The table does not include quantitative standards for every species, because the actual requirements can differ considerably and must be evaluated in the application of interest. Where the syngas is used in combustion applications, impurities are removed to meet requirements limiting atmospheric emissions such as SOX or NOX. In this instance, the required syngas purity can be estimated from combustion material balances, and making some assumptions about how the syngas species are oxidized in the combustor.* As indicated in the table, the sulfur removal requirement may also be linked indirectly to the NOX emissions where selective catalytic reduction (SCR) is used to scrub the flue gas. This is discussed in further detail in Chapter 2. For particulate removal, it is usually the case that current gas purification techniques control particulate to levels well below any environmental standard because the downstream processes simply cannot tolerate significant levels of fine ash accumulation over extended operation. Where the syngas is used for chemical or fuel production, syngas purity may be dictated by catalyst requirements, which can be very stringent. For example, Higman and van der Burgt (2003) report that catalysts used to produce liquid fuel by the Fischer-Tropsch (FT) process require syngas with a combined HCl + HBr + HF content of less than 10 parts per billion. This level of gas cleaning is achieved in current practice for FT production, so it is not a deterrent to syngas use, but requires different purification steps than might be needed in power production applications. *
For estimates, it is usually adequate to assume that the impurities like H2S and NH3 are converted directly to SO2 and NOX stack emissions.
19
Gasification Technology to Produce Synthesis Gas
Table 1.5 Syngas Cleanup Requirements Impurity
Turbines
Chemical Production
Particulate
Typical: <1 ppmw in fuel, wide range possible (Stringer, 1989; Wenglarz et al., 1986; Bossart et al., 1990; GE Power Systems, 1999).
Total Sulfur
Environmental, or may be set by SCR catalysts (~10 ppmv H2S fuel gas) (DeBiasi, 2005).
Total Nitrogen Compounds Trace Impurities Halides (HCl, HF)
Alkali (Na, K)
Environmental
Environmental Process requirements often exceed environmental; typical stack range (see notes) PM10 < 0.015 lb/106 BTU (Ratafia-Brown et al., 2002)
See notes for molten carbonate and solid oxide fuel cells below.
Turbines: Stack SO2 range 0.03–0.2 lb/106 BTU, see Ratafia-Brown et al., 2002. Stack NOX limit, typical range 2 ppm–25 ppm.
Set by material corrosion limits; typical range 0.4–0.6 ppm (Takematsu and Maude, 1991). Vendor specs, typical range 0.02–1 ppmw fuel (GE Power Systems, 1999).
Metals (Hg, Cd, Se, V, and others)
Environmental and vendor specs.
Carbonyls Fe(CO)5, Ni(CO)4
Produce in-situ; controlled to avoid turbine material deposits.
Carbon Dioxide
Catalyst and process specific
Fuel Cells
Environmental
Recent IGCC permits: Hg stack emission ~0.5 lb/1012BTU (WePower SCPC and IGCC Information, 2003).
No standards to date.
Fuel cells: For molten carbonate fuel cells (MCFCs), earlier studies and requirements are summarized by Thambimuthu (1993). For solid oxide fuel cells (SOFCs), recent studies have established the required purity for multiple trace species; see papers by Gemmen and Trembly (2006) and Trembly et al. (2007a, 2007b, 2007c). PM10: The particulate matter smaller than 10 microns in diameter.
The common methods of gas cleanup are described next. For virtually all operating syngas plants, gas purification is accomplished with the syngas cooled to ambient temperature, usually referred to as cold gas cleanup. The advantage of cold gas cleanup is that virtually all of the syngas impurities can be removed with available technology operating near (or below) ambient temperature. The disadvantage of cooling is an exergy loss. Both the sensible thermal energy and the latent heat of vaporization (for syngas H2O) are degraded by cooling, especially where significant quantities of syngas steam are condensed during cooling. This is the motivation to develop warm or humid gas cleanup, discussed in Section 1.4.2.
20
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
1.4.1 Cold Gas Cleanup Figure 1.6 shows the major process steps involved in syngas purification using conventional cold gas cleanup. The figure shows the major process steps in most cleanup systems and gives some approximate temperatures at each step. It is emphasized that there are many possible variants in process arrangement; this is a generalization. Following the schematic in Figure 1.6, the syngas temperature is reduced via process steps described in Section 1.3.5. If quench is used to cool the syngas, much of the slag and particulate will be caught in the water quench. The remaining fly ash can be separated using cyclones or filters, and at the temperatures shown (400°C), most of the alkali materials will condense on the ash (Thambimuthu, 1993). Depending on the gasifier, the separated ash may contain enough carbon that it is worthwhile to recycle it to the gasifier where carbon conversion is completed, and the remaining mineral matter then exits with the slag or ash removal. Following the particulate removal, a subsequent water wash is used to capture the finest particulates and the majority of water-soluble impurities. The bulk of the fuel ammonia, HCN, and HCl will be captured by the scrubbing water, but further purification may occur in downstream water knockout or in the acid gas scrubbers (Section 1.4.1.1). After the wet scrubbing, it may be necessary to “shift” the COS to H2S because some of the sulfur removal schemes are not selective to COS:
COS + H2O → CO2 + H2S
COS hydrolysis
COS can also react with hydrogen in the syngas stream, producing CO and H2S; see Supp (1990) for details about where this reaction is dominant. Where more hydrogen is sought in the syngas, the water gas shift can be conducted at this point:
CO + H2O → CO2 + H2
Water gas shift
This important reaction is a key element in future scenarios where CO2 is removed from the syngas for the purpose of carbon dioxide sequestration. By using water gas shift and CO2 scrubbing (Section 1.4.1.1), a carbon-containing feedstock can be converted to hydrogen fuel. The details of the water gas shift are more involved than shown schematically in Figure 1.6, and can include catalysts suited to both hightemperature (~400°C) and low-temperature operation (~250°C). The shift reaction can occur in multiple stages, with intermediate heat removal; more details can be found in Twigg (1996). In Figure 1.6, the water gas shift is shown ahead of the sulfur removal (sour shift), but it can also be arranged after the sulfur removal (sweet shift), although the latter requires reheating the gas. Continuing to follow the schematic, the temperature is further reduced so that significant water condensation occurs (knockout). The condensing water serves to capture even more water-soluble trace species like ammonia. As shown, the gas can now be sent to a carbon bed where mercury is removed. A description of these beds is given by Klett et al. (2002). The bed can operate for multiple months, capturing trace metals before the bed material needs to be exchanged. As an alternative to Figure 1.6, Klett et al. noted that the bed may be placed downstream
Recycled to consume residual carbon
Temperature reduction Possible via: - Heat exchanger - Gas quenching - Water quenching
Particulate flyash
Cyclone separation or filters
400°C
Scrubbing water
Shift steam
COS hydrolysis and/or water gas shift
200–230°C
To water treatment and recycle
Removes in water - Finest particulate - Nitrogen compounds (NH3, HCN) - Halogen (HC2, HF, not 100%) - Alkali
Wet scrubbing
Figure 1.6 Schematic of conventional cold gas cleanup system.
Slag
Gasifier
Gasifier exit temperature
Water knockouts
Mercury
20°C
CO2 H2S
Acid gas scrubber
Typical range (Specifics may vary)
Clean syngas
Gasification Technology to Produce Synthesis Gas 21
22
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
of the acid gas removal, but the upstream location keeps some impurities out of the acid gas wash, described next. 1.4.1.1 Acid Gas Scrubbing The final cleanup step shown in Figure 1.6 is the acid gas purification (CO2 and H2S). Because both H2S and CO2 will form an acid when contacting water, they are referred to as acid gases, and the techniques to remove them are called acid gas removal. Multiple choices exist for liquid solvents that can remove these species, with distinctions being the level of sulfur removal versus CO2, the operating temperature, and the method of solvent regeneration. Thambimuthu (1993) lists more than 15 commercial processes that could be used to treat coal syngas. With this wide number of options, the advantages for selecting a process depend on the details of the specific plant requirements. Design data and options for these process steps can be found in various papers and reference texts (see Shah and McFarland, 1988; Kohl and Nielson, 1997; and Kriebel et al., 1989). Among these different processes, there are three major classes of solvents: chemical, physical, and mixed, described below. The trade-offs among the various processes and general considerations for selecting a process are discussed by Korens et al. (2002). 1.4.1.1.1 Chemical Solvents These solvents form a reversible chemical bond with the target acid gas. They are regenerated by heating the solvent to a sufficient temperature to reverse the chemical reaction and release the absorbed gas (known as thermal swing regeneration). The most common chemical solvents for H2S (and also effective on CO2) are based on amine compounds dissolved in water. Acid gases are absorbed in a column contactor, and then the “rich” solvent is regenerated with heat that reverses the absorption process. After regeneration, the “lean” solvent is cooled and recycled to the absorber. The energy required to regenerate the solvent is a key parameter in evaluating the performance of the acid gas removal system; typical regeneration energies are reported in Kohl and Nielsen (1997). 1.4.1.1.2 Physical Solvents In contrast to chemical solvents, the physical solvents capture the acid gas by physical absorption. There is no chemical bond; the gas species j at partial pressure Pj is simply dissolved in the liquid to mole fraction xj following Henry’s law:
xj = Pj /Hj Henry’s law
In this expression, Hj is the Henry’s law coefficient for the species of interest. The solvents are devised to have greater solubility (large 1/Hj) for the captured acid gas, while ideally excluding desired syngas species (H2, CO). The published solubilities of H2S and CO2 are orders of magnitude greater than CO or H2, such that good separation of these gases is readily achieved, with very little syngas lost into the solvent (Kohl and Nielsen, 1997). A complication arises in the solvent regeneration if CO2 and H2S are desired in separate streams. Depending on the solvent, sequential absorption stages can be designed to capitalize on differences in solubility, as
Gasification Technology to Produce Synthesis Gas
23
well as absorption rates, to produce the desired separation. One species of particular interest is COS, which has a solubility between CO2 and H2S, making it difficult to exclude from the CO2 stream. As discussed above, this is why COS hydrolysis is used upstream of the acid gas solvent. Because the physical solvents operate using the gas partial pressure, regeneration is achieved with straightforward depressurization. No additional thermal regeneration energy is necessary, and this can be an advantage compared to chemical solvents. However, depending on the solvent loading, and required circulation rates, the advantages for physical versus chemical solvents are a function of specific installation requirements. One widely used physical solvent is chilled methanol. At temperatures operating between –70 and –30°C, methanol will absorb both H2S and CO2, as well as many other coal gas impurities to very low levels. This explains why chilled methanol is usually used to purify syngas for chemical processes. While the solvent is effective, there is an obvious complication and penalty associated with cooling the syngas to subzero temperature. Another common physical solvent is based on a mixture of dimethyl ethers of polyethylene glycol. This type of solvent can be used at approximately ambient temperatures, avoiding the need to chill the syngas. However, the solvent does not achieve the same level of purification as chilled methanol, and is therefore applicable where modest impurities can be tolerated in the syngas (e.g., combustion applications). 1.4.1.1.3 Mixed Chemical/Physical Solvents Physical and chemical solvents each have advantages and disadvantages in terms of required circulation rates, separation performance, regeneration energy, and process complexity. This has been the motivation for the development of solvents that combine features of both chemical and physical absorption, combining, for example, amines with methanol to raise the temperature of absorption compared to chilled methanol. 1.4.1.2 Tars and Carbonyls Figure 1.6 has shown some of the main process steps in conventional gas cleanup. There are different variations possible depending on the gasification approach. For example, because of their low gasifier exit temperature, moving bed gasifiers will produce appreciable tars. These tars must be recycled or used, and this is done with a solvent wash stream (not shown in Figure 1.6). Details can be found in Rudolph (1984) or Supp (1990). Table 1.5 also lists requirements to avoid carbonyls. Carbonyls are not coal impurities; they can form in the low-temperature section of the syngas processing and can be avoided by process design. Higman and van Burgt (2003) describe the process conditions that must be avoided to prevent carbonyl formation.
1.4.2 Warm Gas Cleanup To maximize the use of syngas thermal energy in power cycles, it is very desirable to conduct the gas purification at high temperatures, usually referred to as warm
24
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
gas cleanup or humid gas cleanup (because the syngas moisture is not condensed). Some studies suggest that the efficiency of an integrated gasification combined cycle power plant can be increased more than 3% when comparing cold gas to warm gas cleanup (Schlather and Turk, 2007). With the exception of particulate removal, warm gas cleanup is in the research and development stage. Korens et al. (2002) assessed the status of warm gas cleanup in 2002 and noted that particulate control methods for warm gas conditions have been successfully developed, and sulfur removal schemes also appeared promising. Since that time, laboratory tests have demonstrated techniques to remove other impurities (Siriwardane et al., 2007b; Poulston et al., 2007; Granite et al., 2006), but these are not yet being used commercially. A relatively recent consideration is how to remove CO2 under warm gas conditions. Laboratory studies have evaluated ionic liquid solvents (Heintz et al., 2005), CO2 membranes (Ilconich et al., 2007), and solid sorbents (Siriwardane et al., 2007a) for the purpose of carbon dioxide removal at warm gas conditions.
1.5 Conclusions This chapter has described the basic concepts for producing clean synthesis gas as a fuel for power production or a precursor for fuel or chemical production. Syngas produced by solid fuel gasification is expected to play an increasingly important role in the future to make greater use of multiple fuel sources and permit direct removal of CO2 from fuel streams. Many different types of solid fuels can be gasified, but key differences in fuel and ash properties must be considered when matching a gasifier to a fuel type and application. Lower-temperature gasification schemes are best suited to fuels with significant ash content because chemical energy must be spent to heat the ash to the gasifier temperature, penalizing the process efficiency. Likewise, the ash behavior must be matched to the process equipment; for example, fluid bed operating temperatures must be maintained below the ash fusion temperature. The reactivity of the fuel is also a consideration, with less reactive fuels requiring higher temperatures or longer residence time for complete conversion. The different types of gasifiers, with their various attributes, were discussed. Trade-offs among the different types of gasifiers involve the operating temperature, the required coal preparation (size reduction), and methods to utilize the thermal energy released during gasification. The choice to operate the gasifier with oxygen or air depends on the application, but oxygen is preferred, especially for chemical production, and pressurized gasification is favored when the syngas is needed for high-pressure applications. A survey of methods to clean the syngas of trace impurities shows that very clean syngas can be produced using a combination of physical separation (for particulates), water scrubbing, solvents, and carbon beds. While existing cleanup methods are effective, they require cooling the gas to ambient or even lower temperatures, degrading the available thermal energy released during gasification. This has been the motivation to develop gas cleaning techniques that can operate at elevated temperatures. In conclusion, gasification technology can convert a wide range of solid fuels into a common syngas product. The syngas can be used for many power and chemical
Gasification Technology to Produce Synthesis Gas
25
production applications discussed in this book. The syngas itself can be converted to pure hydrogen, with CO2 separated for geological sequestration. The combined attributes of fuel flexibility and separation of CO2 explain the growing appeal of gasification for power and chemical production.
References Aldred, D., and Saunders, T. (2003). Continuous injection of solid fuels into advanced combustion and gasification system pressures. Paper presented at 2003 Gasification Technologies Conference, San Francisco. Available at http://www.gasification.org. Aldred, D. L., and Saunders, T. (2005). Achieving continuous injection of solid fuels into advanced combustion system pressures. Final report, DE-FC26-02NT41439. U.S. Department of Energy Project. Amick, P., and Dowd, R. (2001). Environmental performance of IGCC repowering for conventional coal plants. Paper presented at the 2001 Gasification Technology Conference, San Francisco. Available at http://www.gasification.org/. Babcock and Wilcox Co. (2005). Steam 41:9–11. Bennett, J. (2008). Issues in hydrogen production using gasification. In: Materials for the hydrogen economy, ed. R. H. Jones and G. J. Thomas, chap. 1, pp. 1–36. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. Bennett, J. P., Kwong, K.-S., and Powell, C. A. (2007). Issues impacting refractory service life in biomass/waste gasification. In Corrosion 2007, Nashville, Tennessee, p. 10. Houston, TX: NACE International. Bergman, P. C. A., Boersma, A. R., Kiel, J. H. A., Prins, M. J., Ptasinski, K. J., and Janssen, F. J. J. G. (2005). Torrefaction for entrained-flow gasification of biomass. ECN-C-05-067, Energy Research Center of the Netherlands (ECN). Available at www.ecn.nl/biomass. Boerrigter, H., den Uil, H., and Calis, H.-P. (2003). Green diesel from biomass via Fisher-Tropsch synthesis: New insights in gas cleaning and process design. In Pyrolysis and gasification of biomass and waste, ed. A. V. Bridgewater, 371–84. Newbury, UK: CPL Press. Bossart, S. J., Cicero, D. C., Zeh, C. M., and Bedick, R. C. (1990). Gas stream cleanup. DOE/ METC-91/0273, U.S. Department of Energy, Morgantown Energy Technology Center. Bridgewater, A. V. (1995). The technical and economic feasibility of biomass gasification for power generation. Fuel 74:631. Bryers, R. W. (1995). Utilization of petroleum and petroleum coke/coal blends as a means of steam raising. Fuel Proc. Tech. 44:121. Chrisgas: Fuels from biomass. http://www.chrisgas.com. Ciferno, J., and Marano, J. (2002). Benchmarking biomass gasification technologies for fuels, chemicals and hydrogen production. NETL report. Available at www.netl.doe.gov. DeBiasi, V. (2005). SCR poses problems but can be used with IGCC to achieve ultra-low NOX. Gas Turbine World, July–August, p. 28. Dighe, S. V., and Lazzara, D. (2002). Westinghouse plasma gasification technology for application to coal gasification and co-fired coal/biomass gasification. Paper presented at the 19th International Pittsburgh Coal Conference, Pittsburgh, PA. Gasification World Database. (2007). Available at www.netl.doe.gov/technologies/coalpower/ gasification/database/database.html. Geertsema, A., Groppo, J., and Price, C. (2002). Demonstration of beneficiation technology for Texaco gasifier slag. Paper presented at the Gasification Technology Conference, San Francisco. Available at http://www.gasification.org/. Gemmen, R. S., and Trembly, J. (2006). On the mechanisms and behavior of coal syngas transport and reaction within the anode of a solid oxide fuel cell. J. Power Sources 161:1084.
26
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
GE Power Systems. (1999). Specifications for fuel gases for combustion in heavy duty gas turbines. Report GEI 41040G. Revised January 2002. Granite, E. J., Myers, C. R., King, W. P., Stanko, D. C., and Pennline, H. P. (2006). Sorbents for mercury capture from flue gas with application to gasification. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 45:4844. Handbook of gasifiers and gas treatment systems. (1976). Final report, Contract E(49-18)-1772, FE-1772-11, U.S. Energy Research and Development Administration. Heinemann, H., and Somorjai, G. A. (1994). Fundamental and exploratory studies of catalytic steam gasification of carbonaceous materials. Final report, U.S. DOE Contract DE-AC03-76SF00098, LBL-35374, UC109. Heintz, Y. J., Lemoine, R. O., Sehabiague, L., Morsi, B. I., Jones, K. L., and Pennline, H. W. (2005). Investigation of perflourinated compounds as physical solvents for selective CO2 capture at elevated pressures and temperatures. Paper presented at 22nd Annual International Pittsburgh Coal Conference, Pittsburgh, PA. Hendrickson, T. A. (1975). Synthetic fuels data handbook. Denver, CO: Cameron Engineers. Higman, C., and van der Burgt, M. (2003). Gasification. Boston, MA: Gulf Professional Publishing (Elsevier). Ilconich, J., Myers, C., Pennline, H., and Luebke, D. (2007). Experimental investigation of the permeability and selectivity of supported ionic liquid membranes for CO2/He separation at temperatures up to 125°C. J. Memb. Sci. 298:41. Jaeger H. (2007). CO2 cloud looms large over IGCC and gasification plant development. Gas Turbine World, November–December, p. 16. Jenkins, B. M., Baxter, L. L., Miles, T. R., Jr., and Miles, T. R. (1998). Combustion properties of biomass. Fuel Proc. Tech. 54:17. Klett, M. G., Maxwell, R. C., and Rutkowski, M. D. (2002). The cost of mercury removal in an IGCC plant. Available at www.netl.doe.gov. Kohl, A., and Nielsen, R. (1997). Gas purification. 5th ed. Houston, TX: Gulf Publishing. Korens, N., Simbeck, D. R., and Wilhelm, D. J. (2002). Process screening analysis of alternative gas treating and sulfur removal for gasification. Final report, U.S. Department of Energy, National Energy Technology Laboratory Task Order 739656-00100. Kriebel, M., Sclicting, H., and Tanz, H. (1989). Gas treating. In Ullman’s encyclopedia of industrial chemistry, sect. 5.4–5.8, pp. 395–429. 5th ed. Weinheim: Wiley-VCH. Leonard, R. (2007). Gasification testing at the power systems development facility. Paper presented at 2007 Gasification Technologies Conference, San Francisco, October 14–17. Available at www.gasification.org. Mahagaokar, V., and Doering, E. L. (1995). High level heat recovery in coal and coke gasification and combined cycles. ASME 95-67-259. McClendon, T. R., Lui, A. P., Pineault, R. L., Beer, S. K., and Richardson, S. W. (2004). High-pressure co-gasification of coal and biomass in a fluidized bed. Biomass and Bioenergy 26:377. Megaritis, A., Messenbock, A.-G., Collot, Y., Zhuo, Y., Dugwell, D. R., and Kandiyoti, R. (1998). Internal consistency of coal gasification reactivities determined in bench scale reactors: Effect of pyrolysis conditions on char reactivities under high-pressure CO2. Fuel 77:1411. Mitsubishi 250MW demo plant on target for mid-2007 testing. (2007). Gas Turbine World, January–February, pp. 42–45. Nelson, J. M., Leonard, R., Liu, G., Peng, W., Romans, D., Vimalchand, P., Smith, P. V., and Longanbach, J. (2003). Low-rank coal gasification studies at the PSDF. Paper presented at the 18th Low-Rank Fuels Symposium, Session 2B—Gasification, Billings, Montana, June 24–26, 2003. Available at http://psdf.southernco.com/pdf/2003/paper-145.pdf. NETL. (2008). http://www.netl.doe.gov/technologies/coalpower/gasification/basics/3.html.
Gasification Technology to Produce Synthesis Gas
27
Paisley, M. A., and Overend, R. P. (2002). Verification of the performance of Future Energy Resources: Silvagas biomass gasifier. Operating Experience in the Vermont Gasifier, Paper presented at 19th International Pittsburgh Coal Conference, Pittsburgh, PA. Palonen, J., Anttikoski, T., and Eriksson, T. (2005). The Foster Wheeler gasification technology for biofuels: Refuse-derived fuel (RDF) power generation. Paper presented at Power Gen Europe. Available at http://www.fwc.com/publications/tech_papers/. Poulston, S., Granite, E. J., Pennline, H. W., Myers, C. J., Stanko, D. P., Hamilton, H., Rowsell, L., Smith, A., Ilkenhans, T., and Chu, W. (2007). Metal sorbents for high temperature mercury capture from flue gas. Fuel 86:2201. Probstein, R. F., and Hicks, R. E. (1990). Synthetic fuels. Cambridge, MA: pH Press. Ratafia-Brown, J., Manfredo, L., Hoffman, J., and Ramezan, M. (2002). Major environmental aspects of gasification-based power generation technologies. National Energy Technology Laboratory. Available at http://www.netl.doe.gov/technologies/coalpower/ gasification/pubs/. Reed, T. B., and Gauer, S. (2001). A survey of biomass gasification 2001. 2nd ed. National Renewable Energy Technology Laboratory, written under DOE Contract DE‑AC3683CH10093, Subcontract ECG-6-16604-01(BEF). Riemert, R. (1989). Gas production from coal, wood, and other solid feedstocks. In Ullman’s encyclopedia of industrial chemistry, 357–379, 5th ed. Weinheim: Wiley-VCH. Rudolph, P. F. H. (1984). Lurgi coal gasification (moving bed gasifier). In Handbook of synfuel technology, ed. R. A. Myer, pp. 3-127–3-148. New York: McGraw-Hill Publishing. Salvador, S., Commandre, J.-M., and Stanmore, B. R. (2003). Reaction rates for the oxidation of highly sulphurized cokes: The influence of thermogravimetric conditions and some coke properties. Fuel 82:715. Schlather, J., and Turk, B. (2007). Comparison of warm-gas desulfurization process versus traditional scrubbers for a commercial IGCC power plant. Paper presented at the 2007 Gasifica tion Technology Conference, San Francisco. Available at http://www.gasification.org/. Shadle, L. J., Berry, D. A., and Syamlal, M. (2002). Coal conversion processes, gasification. In Kirk-Othmer encyclopedia, ed. S. Seitz. New York: John Wiley & Sons. Shah, V. A., and McFarland, J. (1988). Low cost ammonia and CO2 recovery. Hydrocarbon Proc. 67:43. Simbeck, D. R., Korens, N., Biasca, F. E., Vejtasa, S., and Dickenson, R. L. (1993). Coal gasification guidebook: Status applications, and technologies. EPRI-TR-102034, Research Project 2221-39. Siriwardane, R., Robinson, C., Shen, M., and Simonyi, T. (2007a). Novel regenerable sodiumbased sorbents for CO2 capture at warm gas temperatures. Energy and Fuels 21:2088. Siriwardane, R., Tian, H., Simonyi, T., and Webster, T. (2007b). Regenerable sorbent development for sulfur, chloride and ammonia removal from coal derived synthesis gas. Paper presented at 2007 International Conference on Coal Science and Technology, August 2007, Nottingham, England. Stringer, J. (1989). Material issues in pressurized fluidized bed combustors. Paper presented at Proceedings of the 1988 Fluidized Bed Combustion Technologies for Utility Appli cations, May 3–5, 1988, Palo Alto, CA. Supp, E. (1990). How to produce methanol from coal. Berlin: Spinger-Verlag. Takematsu, T., and Maude, C. (1991). Coal gasification for IGCC power generation. IEA CR 37. Tampa Electric Integrated Gasification Combined-Cycle Project. (2000). U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Fossil Energy, Clean Coal Technology Topical Report 19. Available at http://www.fossil.energy.gov/programs/powersystems/publications/ Clean_Coal_Topical_Reports/. Thambimuthu, K. V. (1993). Gas cleaning for advanced coal-based power generation. IEACR/53, IEA Coal Research, London.
28
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Tillman, D. A. (1994). Fuels from waste. In Kirk-Othmer encyclopedia of energy technology. 4th ed., Vol. 12. New York: John Wiley & Sons. Trembly, J., Gemmen, R. S., and Bayless, D. J. (2007a). The effect of IGFC warm gas cleanup system conditions on the gas-solid partitioning and form of trace species in coal syngas and their interactions with SOFC anodes. J. Power Sources 163:986. Trembly, J., Gemmen, R. S., and Bayless, D. J. (2007b). The effect of coal syngas containing HC1 on the performance of solid oxide fuel cells: Investigations into the effect of operational temperature and HC1 concentration. J. Power Sources 169:347. Trembly, J., Gemmen, R. S., and Bayless, D. J. (2007c). The effect of coal syngas containing AsH3 on the performance of SOFCs: Investigations into the effect of operational temperature, current density and AsH3 concentration. J. Power Sources 171:818. Twigg, M. V. (1996). Catalyst handbook. London: Manson Publishing. Vogt, E. V., Weller, P. J., and Vanderburgt, M. J. (1984). The Shell coal gasification process. In Handbook of synfuel technology, ed. R. A. Myer, pp. 3-27–3-44. New York: McGrawHill Publishing. Wallace, F., Guan, X., Leonard, R., Nelson, M., Vimalchand, P., Peng, W., Smith, P. V., and Breault, R. W. (2006). Operation of the Transport Gasifier™ at the PSDF. Paper presented at the 31st International Technical Conference on Coal Utilization and Fuel Systems, Clearwater, FL, May 21–25, 2006. Available at http://psdf.southernco.com/ pdf/2006/paper-155.pdf. Wenglarz, R., Lippert, T., and Alvin, M. A. (October 1986). Alternative combustion turbine designs and clean-up systems for pressurized fluidized bed combustion power plants. EPRI-CS-4860, Electric Power Research Institute. WePower SCPC and IGCC. (2003). Information from April 2003 draft environmental impact statement, Elm Road generating station, Table 7-11, p. 157. Vol. 1. Public Service Commission of Wisconsin and Department of Natural Resources. Werthera, J., Saengera, M., Hartgea, E.-U., Ogadab, T., and Siagib, Z. (2000). Combustion of agricultural residues. Prog. Energy Comb. Sci. 26:1. Zulfiqar, M., Moghtaderi, B., and Wall, T. F. (2006). Flow properties of biomass and coal blends. Fuel Proc. Tech. 87:281.
Chemical Kinetics 2 Syngas and Reaction Mechanisms Marcos Chaos, Michael P. Burke, Yiguang Ju, and Frederick L. Dryer Contents 2.1 Introduction..................................................................................................... 29 2.2 Explosion Characteristics of H2-Containing Systems..................................... 30 2.2.1 Effect of Impurities: NOX.................................................................... 35 2.3 Recent and Proposed Updates to the H2/CO Kinetic Model........................... 37 2.4 High-Pressure/Low-Temperature Syngas Ignition and Kinetic Implications..................................................................................................... 43 2.4.1 Shock Tube Pressure Histories............................................................46 2.4.2 Modeling Approaches.......................................................................... 49 2.4.3 Other Systems...................................................................................... 51 2.5 Premixed Flame Propagation in High-Pressure Media................................... 52 2.6 Conclusion....................................................................................................... 61 Acknowledgments..................................................................................................... 63 References................................................................................................................. 63
2.1 Introduction Chapters 1 and 7 detail syngas generation technologies and their use in established and developing applications for power production as well as chemical synthesis. Syngas is receiving renewed interest, as it can be flexibly generated from a variety of nonpetroleum, renewable feedstocks. In addition, syngas production, along with the implementation of carbon capture and storage (CCS) technologies (Chiesa et al., 2005), has the potential for substantially “greening” fossil fuel and biomass energy resource use, particularly when polygeneration of fuels, chemical products, and electrical power generation are integrated with CCS (Larson et al., 2009). Although gasification technologies are well established and syngas combustion is widely used in, for example, refineries for process heat (see Chapter 1), its application to power generation is not sufficiently developed. Conditions relevant to the applications described in Chapter 2 (e.g., gas turbine combustors, internal combustion engines, etc.) are typically characterized by lower temperatures and higher pressures (T < 1000 K, 10 < P < 30 atm). At such conditions, the chemistry and combustion dynamics of syngas as well as hydrogen are not fully understood. This is despite the great amount of detailed studies that have been carried out through the years on the CO/H2/O2 29
30
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
kinetic system (e.g., Davis et al., 2005; Dixon-Lewis and Williams, 1977; Gardiner and Olson, 1980; Kim et al., 1994; Li et al., 2007; Rasmussen et al., 2008; Sun et al., 2007; Sung and Law, 2008; Westbrook and Dryer, 1984; Yetter et al., 1991a, 1991b), as this system is the fundamental basis of all hydrocarbon combustion chemistry. As a result of interest in syngas combustion noted above, robust fluid dynamics as well as chemical kinetic modeling tools are sought that are thoroughly validated against experiments spanning a wide range of operating conditions. The ultimate goal of these modeling efforts is to achieve accurate predictive behavior, for example, of dynamic combustor features such as blowout, flashback, stability, and autoignition, including how fuel composition might affect these properties (Lieuwen et al., 2008). Driven by the above discussion, data have recently become available (Beerer and McDonell, 2007; Bradley et al., 2007; Burke et al., 2007, 2009a; Kalitan et al., 2006; Mittal et al., 2006; Natarajan et al., 2007; Petersen et al., 2007a; Sivaramakrishnan et al., 2007; Sun et al., 2007; Walton et al., 2007a) for conditions that are sufficiently removed from the range of previous kinetic model validations, as reviewed by Chaos and Dryer (2008). Since this early work and that of Sung and Law (2008), additional experimental data have been published (Beerer and McDonell, 2008; Herzler and Naumann, 2008; Le Cong and Dagaut; 2008; Mertens et al., 2009; Natarajan et al., 2009; Rasmussen et al., 2008) that lend support to further considering the title topic. A common feature of the studies listed above is the use of undiluted systems (i.e., fuel–air), high pressures, and relatively low temperatures in autoignition studies (e.g., Beerer and McDonell, 2008), as well as preheated mixtures in laminar flame speed measurements (e.g., Natarajan et al., 2009). Under these conditions, there have been several reports noting considerable discrepancies between experimental data and kinetic model predictions. These observations motivate further consideration, and it is the purpose of this chapter to discuss the need for careful analysis of data collected at high pressures and the implications that experimental anomalies, known to be present at these conditions, may have on interpreting these data. This discussion is further motivated by recent evaluations of key reactions in the hydrogen system, which will be reviewed below. This chapter begins with an introduction to the chemistry driving the explosive characteristics of hydrogen oxidation and how they can be altered by the presence of impurities. A review then follows of available chemical kinetic models for simulation of H2/CO chemistry along with important updates to elementary reactions that can considerably affect the performance of these models at high pressures. Finally, recent experimental ignition and burning velocity data collected at conditions relevant to practical applications noted above are presented and analyzed; emphasis is placed on what implications these data have on further development of new and existing chemical kinetic models. For further overview and background of H2/CO kinetics, the reader is referred to the works of Chaos and Dryer (2008) and Rasmussen et al. (2008).
2.2 Explosion Characteristics of H2-Containing Systems Syngas derived from gasification can consist of high levels of hydrogen, depending on the feedstock used. Syngas combustion is very similar in character to that of hydrogen, particularly since the principal reaction producing CO2 is CO + OH = CO2 + H. The
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
31
reactivity of any fuel-oxidizer mixture is driven by the generation and chain propagation of free active radicals. In the case of carbon monoxide oxidation, in the absence of any source of hydrogen atoms, reactions that can initiate the chain (mainly through propagation of O atoms) are slow at practical conditions, as are reactions of O atoms with CO. The addition of even small amounts of hydrogen or hydrogen-containing species (e.g., water) dramatically increases the rate of CO oxidation (Brokaw, 1967; Yetter et al., 1991a), as radicals are propagated through much faster hydrogen-related reactions. Hence, in design of syngas combustion systems it is important to have an understanding of the oxidation characteristics of hydrogen, as it will determine properties of interest, such as ignition and extinction limits, flame propagation, etc. This is best explained through the concept of explosion limits, that is, the pressure-temperature boundaries that demarcate regions of slow and explosively fast reaction of a given fuel-oxidizer mixture. Details for hydrogen oxidation explosion limits are given below, with emphasis on the conditions of interest in the present study. Figure 2.1 shows a typical depiction of the classical explosion limits for hydrogen– oxygen mixtures (Lewis and von Elbe, 1987). These limits arise because of competition between chain-branching and chain-terminating reactions either on surfaces or in the gas phase. Reactions of free radicals with other species yielding more than one free radical as a product would by themselves lead to an exponential growth of the radical pool (i.e., chain-branching reactions). On the other hand, chain-propagating reactions only produce one radical for every radical consumed, and reactions that remove radicals entirely can reduce the radical pool (i.e., chain-terminating reactions). The balance of overall chain propagation with termination processes such that the radical pool neither grows nor decays represents a critical branching factor for the chemical reacting system. The critical branching factor for a homogenous gas phase reacting system is a function of system properties, including its temperature, pressure, and reactant mixture fractions. The presence of diffusion and heterogeneous surfaces can also lead to radical production and destruction, modifying the critical branching factor, depending on the characteristic time scales of these processes relative to those in the gas phase. Finally, if a reaction is endothermic or exothermic, changes in local temperature as a result of reaction can also affect the critical branching factor. The loci of all critical branching factor conditions as a function of system parameters define regions of explosive chain branching and slow chemical reaction, which are termed explosion limits. For the following discussion it is assumed that the pressure of a reacting system maintained at a constant temperature of about 750 K is slowly increased from low (<0.001 atm) to high (>10 atm) pressure. The reaction properties associated with these constraints (Figure 2.1) cross the explosion limit curve for the hydrogen–oxygen system in three classical explosion limit regimes. The first limit, observed at very low system pressures, is determined by a balance between the removal of radicals on surfaces (wall effect), when diffusion time scales in the gas phase are short in comparison to characteristic reaction time scales and their production in the gas phase. At pressures below the limit, gas phase reaction branching is exceeded by termination (which is dominated by radical diffusion to and termination at surfaces), and the rate of branching is less than the critical branching factor. Above the limit, the rate of radical branching is sufficient to exceed the rate of termination, since there
32
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications 102 Thermal-chain explosion (Mild ignition)
rd
3
101
Lim
100
No explosion
k1 = k2 [M]
1+
10–1
1 st
10–3
600
k6
Branched-chain explosion (Strong ignition)
Lim it
10–2
1 k7
2 nd
Pressure (atm)
it
2k1 = k2 [M]
Lim
it
800
1000 1200 Temperature (K)
1400
Figure 2.1 Explosion limit characteristics for stoichiometric H2 /O2 mixtures. Classical limits (Lewis and von Elbe, 1987) are shown by the solid line. Calculations (using reaction rates from the model of Li et al., 2004) for the pressure-temperature boundaries determining the second explosion limit (dashed line) and the extended second explosion limit (dash-dot line) are also shown (see text). The filled circles denote the conditions, in temperature-pressure space, for the plots shown in Figure 2.2.
is a greater number of molecular collisions and diffusive time scales increase due to pressure. As the system pressure is further increased, the classical second explosion limit condition is reached, a limit that results entirely from gas phase kinetic processes (i.e., homogeneous gas phase kinetic branching and termination processes). In pure hydrogen oxidation, the most effective chain-branching reaction is H + O2 = O + OH (R1), while the competing reaction, H + O2(+M) = HO2(+M) (R2), leads to the production of a radical (HO2) that is much less reactive than OH or O. Table 2.1 shows a list of reactions considered in this chapter. The time scales for HO2 to regenerate active radical species at these parameter conditions are very large in comparison to the overall reaction time scale. With increasing pressure, the rate of ternary collisions in reaction (R2) increases relative to binary collisions in (R1). Performing a steady-state analysis of the radical pool at the second limit using these two reactions yields the concentration of M (i.e., a collision partner stabilizing reaction (R2)) for the classical second limit, given as [M] = 2k1/k2 (Lewis and von Elbe, 1987), where ki (i = 1, 2) represent the specific reaction rate constants of (R1) and (R2) in the
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
33
Table 2.1 List of Reactions Discussed in the Text Label
Reaction
Label
Reaction
(R1) (R2) (R3) (R4) (R5) (R6) (R7) (R8) (R9)
H + O2 = O + OH H + O2(+M) = HO2(+M) HO2 + HO2 = H2O2 + O2 H2O2(+M) = OH + OH (+M) HO2 + H2 = H2O2 + H HO2 + H = H2 + O2 HO2 + H = OH + OH NO + HO2 = NO2 + OH NO2 + H = NO + OH
(R10) (R11) (R12) (R13) (R14) (R15) (R16) (R17)
CO + OH = CO2 + H HCO + M = H + CO + M HCO + O2 = HO2 + CO CO + HO2 = CO2 + OH HO2 + OH = H2O + O2 H2 + OH = H2O + H O + H2 = H + OH H + OH + M = H2O + M
forward direction (reverse rates are neglected as they involve processes that are very slow at these conditions relative to the forward processes). At higher pressures well above the classical second limit, a third limit condition is reached, as a result of two principal issues: (1) the high concentration of M leads to a sufficient concentration of HO2 such that reaction HO2 + HO2 = H2O2 + O2 (R3) and subsequent reactions of H2O2, principally H2O2(+M) = OH + OH(+M) (R4), transition the terminating character of (R2) into an overall process (represented by the combination of (R2) and the additional subsequent reactions) that is essentially chain propagating; and (2) the reaction process becomes very exothermic, and along with increased thermal diffusion time scales with increasing pressure, this leads to local mixture self-heating (the process is no longer isothermal). Reactions (R2) and (R3) are very exothermic, being moderated by the endothermicity of reaction (R4) (Lee and Hochgreb, 1998). At high pressures, the character of the reaction also changes with initial reaction temperature. Calculations shown in Figure 2.2a exemplify this behavior. These computations were performed for a constant-volume, adiabatic, and stoichiometric H2/O2 system at an initial pressure of 20 atm and for temperatures of 1000 K and 1300 K; these conditions are also marked in Figure 2.1. The displayed results are normalized in each case by the initial temperature and by the time at which the maximum rate of temperature rise is observed. At 1000 K, a significant increase in the system temperature is seen during a chemical induction period due to heat release associated with the above reactions (R2, R3, R4), while at 1300 K, no similar heat release effect is observed. Also shown in Figure 2.2b is a plot of characteristic reaction times (determined by the ratio of the initial H2 concentration to the maximum H2 consumption rate) as a function of temperature for the same system. Figure 2.2b shows that as temperature increases there is a distinct transition in characteristic reaction times indicating the presence of an explosion limit. Increasing temperatures produces an increasing flux of HO2 radicals via HO2 + H2 = H2O2 + H (R5), generating H radicals. H radicals, in turn, react with the abundant HO2 through HO2 + H = H2 + O2 (R6) and HO2 + H = OH + OH (R7). Reaction (R6) is chain terminating, whereas (R7) is chain branching. Therefore, a system that is initially straight chain in overall reaction character (i.e., R2→R3→R4) can become chain branching as a result of
34
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Normalized Temperature
1.2 1000 K 1300 K
1.15 1.1 1.05 1 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
Normalized Time (a)
[H2]o/(d[H2]/dt)max (seconds)
1.00 Extended second limit
10–1 10–2 10–3
Ea = 46,500 cal/mol
10–4 10–5
Ea = 26,350 cal/mol 1000
1200 Temperature (K)
1400
(b) Figure 2.2 Constant-volume adiabatic calculations (using the model of Li et al., 2004) for a stoichiometric H2/O2 system at 20 atm. (a) Normalized temperature-time traces for two temperature conditions (solid line, 1000 K; dashed line, 1300 K) below and above the extended second limit (see Figure 2.1). (b) Characteristic reaction times as a function of temperature; overall activation energies (Ea) at temperatures above and below the extended second limit are listed and have been estimated by fitting the computed data to an equation of the form tc = A exp(Ea /RT), where tc is the characteristic time, R the universal gas constant, T the temperature, and A a preexponential factor.
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
35
temperature rise (R2→R5→R7, R4). The limit observed under these conditions is an extension of the classical second limit, modified by the importance of added termination and branching routes (R6 and R7) at high pressures and temperatures. A steady-state analysis of the radical pool considering these additional reactions leads to the determination of a critical third-body concentration (i.e., pressure) marking the explosion limit as
[M] =
k1 1 k2 1 + k7 k6
This limit is typically referred to as the extended second limit (Mueller et al., 1996, 1999a). The relevance of the extended second limit to overall system behavior depends upon a comparison of chemical kinetic time scales with convective, back-mixing, or diffusive time scales (Mueller et al., 1996, 1999a; Zheng and Law, 2004). Figure 2.2b shows that at temperatures below the extended second limit the overall reaction is characterized by a high activation energy. Thus, any self-heating that occurs during induction (see Figure 2.2a) is important to overall system behavior. Conditions located in the region between the third limit and the extended second limit can be described as leading to thermal-chain explosions (Figure 2.1), where heat release from slow chain-propagating reactions brings a reactive mixture to a chain-branched explosive condition, as explained above. This region, for example, is associated with mild ignition phenomena observed in shock tubes (Strehlow and Cohen, 1962; Meyer and Oppenheim, 1970; Oppenheim, 1985), as will be further detailed below. On the other hand, at pressures below and temperatures above the extended second limit, explosions are nonthermal and strictly due to chain branching, characterized by relatively low overall activation energies (see Figure 2.2b). For conditions relevant to practical syngas applications (e.g., lean premixed gas turbine engines), typical pressures are on the order of 10 to 30 atm and temperatures not in excess of 1000 K. These conditions place these systems in the thermalchain explosion regime. Therefore, chemical kinetics defining the extended second limit remain an important aspect in the design of such combustion systems. In fact, the recent experimental studies listed above have placed new emphasis on the importance of the chemistry of the hydroperoxyl radical (HO2) as well as hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) due to the conditions studied. These investigations are the subject of further analyses given in the next sections.
2.2.1 Effect of Impurities: NOX It is relevant to present in this section a brief discussion on the effects that impurities may have on the kinetic character of hydrogen and syngas oxidation, particularly as applied to the nature of the explosion limits discussed above. Although syngas is mostly composed of hydrogen and carbon monoxide, the presence of other trace
36
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
species can have a pronounced effect on combustion processes (Glarborg, 2007). These species alter kinetic behavior by catalyzing radical generation or recombination processes. Contaminants generated during feedstock gasification (to produce syngas) include nitrogen and sulfur oxides, among other species (see Chapter 1). For representative purposes, and to complement the discussions in Chapters 6 and 10, attention is given here to nitrogen oxides; details on the combustion chemistry of H2/CO in the presence of sulfur oxides can be found in the work of Mueller et al. (2000). The presence of small quantities of NOX can have significant influence on the underlying H 2/O2 kinetic behavior of syngas mixtures by drastically modifying the relative influence of HO2 chemistry at conditions near those of the extended second explosion limit (Ashmore and Tyler, 1962; Chaos and Dryer 2008; Mueller et al., 1998, 1999b). NOX provides an alternate consumption route for HO2 radicals via NO + HO2 = NO2 + OH (R8) and NO2 + H = NO + OH (R9). This route effectively competes with (R2) for H atoms. Reactions (R8) and (R9) therefore establish a catalytic cycle that releases OH so that fast fuel consumption can occur at temperatures well below the explosion limit of the unperturbed system. In the temperature range where this catalytic cycle is active, small amounts of NOX significantly increase the overall chemical reaction rate, principally through substantial reduction in the chemical induction time, leading to establishing critical branching. Figure 2.3 shows the effects of the addition of small amounts of NO on the constant pressure oxidation of H2/CO mixtures at pressures from 0.5 to 40 atm. This figure is similar to Figure 2.2 in that it plots the numerically predicted characteristic reaction times (using the model of Li et al. [2007] with NOX kinetic reactions adopted from Mueller et al. [1999b]). One can clearly observe that not only is the extended second explosion limit behavior modified as NO concentration increases, but the overall rate of reaction (defined by the fuel concentration reacted over the characteristic reaction time) is significantly altered. For low pressures and at temperatures below the explosion limit, HO2 radicals are the primary chain carriers, and the addition of even small quantities of NO can reduce the characteristic reaction times by orders of magnitude, as NO establishes chain braching as opposed to the thermal-chain processes described above. This result can have significant consequences on the auto ignition characteristics of hydrogen–oxygen and carbon monoxide–hydrogen–oxygen reactions if small amounts of combustion exhaust gases become back-mixed into entering reactants, an expected circumstance as a result of residual gas and exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) in the combustion of hydrogen and syngas in reciprocating engines (Chapter 10). As noted in Chapter 10, introduction of H2 in engine applications tends to increase NOX emissions due to an increase in reaction temperature. Even small levels of NOX in the EGR stream or in residual cylinder gases can affect ignition timing as well as engine performance (Chaos and Dryer, 2008). Note from Figure 2.3 that there is a nonlinear effect in terms of the amount of added NO, and further that the effect is also a function of both reaction temperature and pressure. Addition of an appropriate amount of NO causes the overall activation energy of the reaction to be nearly the same above and below the explosion limit condition. The difference in overall oxidation rate above and below the explosion limit
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
37
Figure 2.3 Characteristic reaction times of H2/CO mixtures (defined as in Figure 2.2) as a function of temperature at various pressures and initial NO concentrations. For illustration purposes, mixture compositions similar to those of Mittal et al. (2006) are chosen (H2/CO/ O2 /N2 /Ar, 6.25/6.25/6.25/18.125/63.125 mol%). Reaction times were determined assuming isobaric systems.
eventually is decreased (due to the increased rate of reactions involving HO2), and the explosion limit becomes described by essentially the same overall temperature dependence. It is this function that is most important in defining the engineering parameters over which mixing can be accomplished without flashback or preignition in syngas combustion applications.
2.3 Recent and Proposed Updates to the H2/CO Kinetic Model Kinetic models that can be applied to hydrogen and syngas systems continue to be refined (Davis et al., 2005; Konnov, 2008; Li et al., 2004, 2007; O’Connaire
38
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
et al., 2004; Rasmussen et al., 2008; Sun et al., 2007; Wang et al. 2007) as new rate evaluations, thermochemical parameters with reduced uncertainties, and experimental validation data become available. For example, Li et al. (2004, 2007) recently revised prior work by updating the detailed H2/O2 model of Mueller et al. (1999a). The updates by Li et al. included a revision in the rate correlations used for the branching reaction (R1), taken from Hessler (1998), and for the low pressure of the competing reaction (R2), adopted from Michael et al. (2002). A major constraint in selecting these two correlations was that their ratio in the temperature range between 800 K and 900 K replicated the ratio experimentally determined by Mueller et al. (1998). This ratio is a representation of the critical third-body concentration (i.e., pressure) that marks the classical second explosion limit ([M] = 2k1/k2), as described above. In fact, as models develop, one has to ensure that he or she can properly represent the classical explosion limits of the hydrogen system; such tests, however, are often not performed. Figure 2.4 shows comparisons of explosion limit data against predictions from the kinetic models listed above (Davis et al., 2005; Konnov, 2008; Li et al., 2004, 2007; Sun et al., 2007). Agreement is good overall, but some differences are appreciable. For example, at 0.1 atm the models predict a range of temperatures for transition into the explosive regime of about 745 to 765 K. These differences manifest when using the models to predict observables such as ignition delay at conditions near the extended second limit (such computations using various
Davis et al. (2005) Konnov (2008) Li et al. (2004, 2007) Sun et al. (2007)
Pressure (atm)
100
10–1
10–2
Baldwin et al. (1967) Baulch et al. (1988) Egerton and Warren (2005) Muller et al. (1999a) Von Elbe and Lewis (1942) 650
700
750 800 850 Temperature (K)
900
950
Figure 2.4 Comparison of H2/O2 second explosion limit experimental data (symbols) with the criterion [M] = 2k1/k2 computed using rate values obtained from the kinetic models listed (lines) for M = N2. Data are for stoichiometric mixtures, obtained in a flow reactor (Mueller et al., 1999a), static reactors (Baldwin et al., 1967; Egerton and Warren, 1951; von Elbe and Lewis, 1942), and a well-stirred reactor (Baulch et al., 1988). Experiments used 2:1 (mol) H2:O2 mixtures except the studies of Baldwin et al. (28% H2, 14% O2, 58% N2, mol) and Mueller et al. (1% H2, 0.5% O2, 98.5% N2, mol). The data have been modified to take into account the third-body efficiencies of H2 and O2 relative to N2; efficiencies were taken from von Elbe and Lewis (1942). The bold dash-dot line denotes the explosion boundary for a system containing water (10 mol%), calculated using the model of Li et al. (2004, 2007).
39
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
Baulch et al. (2005) Fernandes et al. (2008) Michael et al. (2002) Sellevag et al. (2008) Troe (2000)
k2,0(cm6/mol2/s)
1×1016 8×1015 6×1015 4×1015 2×1015 0.4
0.8
1.6 1.2 1000/T(K–1)
2
Figure 2.5 Temperature dependence of the low-pressure-limit reaction rate of H + O2(+M) = HO2(+M) (R2) for M = N2. The recent evaluation of Baulch et al. (2005) is also plotted with associated uncertainties.
models, including Li et al. [2004] and O’Connaire et al. [2004], can be found in the recent works of Konnov [2008] and Ströhle and Myhrvold [2007]). Experimental measurements and theoretical studies continue to appear in the literature for both (R1) and (R2) (Bates et al., 2001; Fernandes et al., 2008; Hahn et al., 2004; Hwang et al., 2005; Sellevåg et al., 2008; Troe, 2000; Troe and Ushakov, 2001) to further reduce uncertainties in predicted rates, particularly at temperatures below 1000 K. For example, Figure 2.5 compares recent correlations for the low pressure rate of reaction (R2) with N2 as the collisional partner. Although some uncertainties remain (e.g., see Hwang et al., 2005), all of them lie within 20% of each other and within the uncertainty estimates derived from the literature review of Baulch et al. (2005). Figure 2.6 shows calculations for the effective rate of (R2) using values obtained from the recent work of Fernandes et al. (2008) and Sellevåg et al. (2008). Overall, values differ by about 25% over the temperature and pressure range of interest to practical applications. Fernandes et al. (2008) claim these differences are due to a less complete database and a less detailed analysis considered by Sellevåg et al. (2008). Nevertheless, studies of (R2) remain important, especially in determining the collisional efficiencies of species such as water and carbon dioxide. Efficiencies are hard to determine experimentally, and associated uncertainties can be considerable; furthermore, the interaction of polar species such as water in (R2) is not completely understood (Michael et al., 2002). The presence of these species increases the recombination rate of (R2), effectively shifting the explosion limit behavior of H2/O2. The explosion limit data shown in Figure 2.4 were adjusted to make all values relative to N2. However, for comparison, model results are also plotted for a mixture consisting of 10% (mol) H2O. The presence of this highly effective collision partner has a very noticeable impact; pressure and temperature conditions for which a N2 system is explosive (e.g., 1 atm and 950 K) can become nonexplosive with the addition of water. This has direct implications in practical systems where back-mixing
40
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
1015 k2,
k2(cm3 mol/s)
1014 100 atm
1013
10 atm
1012
1 atm
1011
0.1 atm
1010 109 108
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
1000/T(K
–1)
2.5
3
3.5
Figure 2.6 Temperature and pressure dependence of (R2) from recent evaluations for M = N2. Solid lines represent the values of Fernandes et al. (2008); dashed lines are the recommendation of Sellevåg et al. (2008).
of reaction products in combustor recirculation zones (for example, to control NOX emissions) can change combustion behavior and stability. Furthermore, as discussed in Chapter 7, steam may also be used in gas turbines to achieve the desired power output by increasing mass flow. Other reactions of critical importance in the oxidation of H2/CO/O2 as well as moist CO mixtures have received further attention recently. Li et al. (2007) employed a weighted empirical fit of the entire body of experimentally measured rate constants for reactions CO + OH = CO2 + H (R10), HCO + M = H + CO + M (R11), and HCO + O2 = HO2 + CO (R12), all of which have a strong impact on the burning rate of hydrocarbon flames (Zhao et al., 2005). New high-pressure data (described above) have allowed analyses to be performed that have led to proposed updates in some of the reactions involving HO2, two of the most significant being the rate correlations for CO + HO2 = CO2 + OH (R13) and HO2 + OH = H2O + O2 (R14). Mittal et al. (2006, 2007) used data from high-pressure rapid compression machine (RCM) ignition of H2/CO/O2/N2/Ar mixtures and noted that the rate of (R13) could be up to a factor of 10 lower than some accepted values (e.g., Baulch et al., 1973). This is consistent with the recommendation of Mueller et al. (1999b), who argued, based on flow reactor data, that lower values for (R13) might be justified upon further evaluation. Theoretically, (R13) has received less attention than other reactions in the CO-hydrogen system (Allen et al., 1996; Sun et al., 2007; You et al., 2007). The detailed treatment of You et al. (2007) (which considered critical geometries, hindered internal rotations, as well as the complex potential energy surface of (R13)) supports a much lower rate for (R13) than those commonly used in kinetic models. Chaos and Dryer (2008) showed that implementing the rate of You et al. (2007) in the model of Li et al. (2007) considerably improved predictions against the data of Mittal et al. (2006) (Figure 2.7). Chaos and Dryer (2008) and Li
41
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
Ignition Delay (ms)
6 Experiment (Mittal et al. 2006) Base model (Li et al. 2007) Base model (Li et al. 2007) w/update from You et al. (2007)
4
2
0
0
0.2
0.4 Rco
0.6
0.8
Figure 2.7 Comparison between measured (Mittal et al., 2006) and predicted RCM ignition delay times for a (H2 + CO)/O2/N2/Ar—12.5/6.25/18.125/63.125 (molar) mixture. RCO is the fraction of CO in (H2 + CO). Compressed conditions are 50 bar and 1044 K. Lines show the difference in the quality of model predictions when the rate of You et al. (2007) for (R13) is used in the model of Li et al. (2007). Modeling performed in accordance with the methods described in Mittal et al. (2006).
et al. (2007) also showed through computational singular perturbation (CSP) analyses (Kazakov et al., 2006) how reaction (R13) contributed to the ignition process through its effect on the induction period. Chaos and Dryer (2008) further concluded that the updates put forth by Mittal et al. (2006) and You et al. (2007) for (R13) can be readily absorbed into current kinetic models without affecting the quality of their predictions against validation targets that are insensitive to induction chemistry.* Reaction (R14) is of particular significance in oxygen-rich systems; for example, (R14) can alter the nature of the extended second limit as the relative importance of O and OH radicals as chain carriers varies with the presence of excess oxygen. Reaction (R14) has been mostly studied at atmospheric conditions (Braun et al., 1982; Burrows et al., 1981; Cox et al., 1981; DeMore, 1979, 1982; Goodings and Hayhurst, 1988; Keyser, 1988; Kurylo et al., 1981; Lii et al., 1980; Peters and Mahnen, 1973; Rozenshtein et al., 1984; Sridharan et al., 1984) due to the significance of this reaction in the HOx cycle of atmospheric chemistry. More recently, high temperature measurements (Hippler et al., 1995; Kappel et al., 2002) have shown that (R14) exhibits an uncommon and highly non-Arrhenius behavior, indicative of the formation of an activated complex (see Figure 2.8). Sivaramakrishnan et al. (2007) identified (R14) as a sensitive reaction in studying oxidation of H2/CO/O2/Ar mixtures in a high-pressure shock tube (up to 450 atm). They parameterized reaction (R14) by fitting experimental data and capturing the unusually narrow and deep minimum in the rate at about 1000 to 1200 K. However, the fit gives larger weight to the data *
Li et al. now distribute their 2007 model with the substitution of the parameters of You et al. (2007) for those of Mueller et al. (1999a).
42
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications 1014
kR8(cm3/mol/s)
1014
1013
1013
0.4 0.5
1
1.5
0.6
2 2.5 1000/T(K–1)
0.8 3
1 3.5
4
Figure 2.8 Rate constants for HO2 + OH = H2O + O2 (R14); 3, Peeters and Mahnen (1973); 5, DeMore (1979); 9, Lii et al. (1980); G, Cox et al. (1981); -, Kurylo et al. (1981); ,, Braun et al. (1982); #, DeMore (1982); , Goodings and Hayhurst (1988); , Keyser (1988); /, Hippler and Troe (1992) (reevaluation of data from Hippler et al., 1990); A, Hippler et al. (1995); +, Kappel et al. (2002); =, Srinivasan et al. (2006); dashed line, rate expression of Sivaramakrishnan et al. (2007); solid line, fit by Chaos and Dryer (2008) considering the rate minimum measured by Hippler et al. (1995); dash-dot line, fit by Chaos and Dryer (2008) considering the rate minimum measured by Kappel et al. (2002). The figure insert provides details of data and rate fits at high temperatures.
of Hippler et al. (1995) rather than to the more recent, and arguably more reliable, measurements of Kappel et al. (2002) (Figure 2.8). The expression thus derived was able to improve predictions (using the model of Davis et al. (2005)) against the data of Sivaramakrishnan et al. (2007). Chaos and Dryer (2008) noted that the expression proposed by Sivaramakrishnan et al. (2007) could reach values over the collision limit at temperatures greater than about 1400 K. They performed least squares analyses by considering the data of Srinivisan et al. (2006) and Goodings and Hayhurst (1988), who showed very little temperature dependence of the rate for (R14) for temperatures greater than about 1300 K. Two fits were performed, taking into account the two different minima observed by Hippler et al. (1995) and Kappel et al. (2002). The resulting expressions are plotted in Figure 2.8. Li et al. (2007) performed CSP analyses of model results under the conditions of Sivaramakrishnan et al. (2007). Chaos and Dryer (2008) further extended these analyses to show that over the temperature range of interest (1200 to 1400 K) for the study of Sivaramakrishnan et al. (2007), the data only support the likelihood of a lower rate for reaction (R14). As pressure increases, reaction (R14) strongly competes with (R7) for HO2 radicals. Reaction (R7) is one of the major direct sources of OH at high pressures (especially near the extended second limit), thus determining the amount of OH available to react with CO through (R10). Therefore, reactions involving HO2 that compete for and generate OH radicals (such as reactions (R7) and
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
43
(R14)) become more important at high pressures in the H2/CO system since the availability of OH determines the rate of CO oxidation. Sivaramakrishnan et al. (2007) noted that their data could be reconciled by increasing the rate of (R13), which is consistent with the above argument, as (R13) both consumes CO and releases OH; however, increasing this rate degrades model predictions against flow reactor data (Kim et al., 1994), and as discussed above, recent studies support a much lower rate for (R13). The update proposed by Sivaramakrishnan et al. (2007) as well as by Chaos and Dryer (2008) essentially lowers the rate of (R14) over the temperature range of interest (see Figure 2.8), thus slowing a termination path for both HO2 and OH. At higher pressures (>250 atm), (R14) is not as sensitive (Chaos and Dryer, 2008) since the flux of HO2 to form H2O2 through (R3) is considerably larger than through reaction (R14) and, at high temperatures, H2O2 decomposes rapidly to yield OH (R4), removing the significance of reaction (R14). Clearly, additional studies of (R14) are required; the lack of experimental data at intermediate temperatures (400 to 900 K), however, makes finding an expression that accurately captures the observed temperature dependence challenging. Moreover, reactions (R6) and (R7) continue to have large uncertainties associated with their rates and temperature dependences, which, as shown above, can have a direct effect in the determination of the oxidation characteristics of systems near the extended second limit.
2.4 High-Pressure/Low-Temperature Syngas Ignition and Kinetic Implications Ignition of H2/CO mixtures has traditionally been studied at relatively low pressures and high temperatures (e.g., Dean et al., 1978). These conditions correspond to the chain-branched or strong ignition regime shown in Figure 2.1. The need to establish an experimental database at conditions found in practical applications has recently led to considerable interest in syngas ignition at high pressures and relatively low temperatures. Perhaps the most representative of such studies is that of Petersen et al. (2007a), who reported new ignition delay data for syngas–air mixtures in a shock tube and a flow reactor. These new data are summarized in Figure 2.9, along with other recently published data from the rapid compression study of Walton et al. (2007a) and from an earlier high-pressure flow reactor study described by Peschke and Spadaccini (1985). All of the ignition delay data have been normalized to conditions of 20 atm pressure. Petersen et al. (2007a) noted that at reaction temperatures lower than about 1050 K, experimental observations of ignition delay, although consistent among the different apparatuses considered, all begin to differ considerably from kinetic model predictions generated using homogeneous, zero-dimensional, isochoric assumptions (i.e., constant internal energy, U, and volume, V) typically employed by kineticists (Figure 2.9). The above discussion raises considerable concern as these results bring into question the predominant fundamental kinetic understanding of gas phase oxidation phenomena for the H2/CO system. Hydrogen and carbon monoxide oxidation are the fundamental basis for all hydrocarbon combustion chemistry, and severe
44
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications 107 P = 20 atm
Ignition Delay (µs)
106
2%/ms
Constant U, V
5%/ms
105
10%/ms
104 103 Petersen et al. (2007), shock tube Petersen et al. (2007), flow reactor Walton et al. (2007a), rapid compression Peschke and Spadaccini (1985), flow reactor Blumenthal et al. (1995), shock tube
102 101 100
0.7
0.9
1.1 1.3 1000/T(K–1)
1.5
Figure 2.9 Ignition delay times of syngas-air (Peschke and Spadaccini, 1985; Petersen et al., 2007a; Walton et al., 2007a) and hydrogen–air mixtures (Blumenthal et al., 1995). Conditions: 38.6% H2 + 51.1% CO + 10.3% CO2 + Air, ϕ = 0.5, 16.5 < P < 28.9 atm (Petersen et al., 2007a; shock tube), 11.9 < P < 23 atm (Peschke and Spadaccini, 1985); 50% H 2 + 50% CO + Air, 0.33 < ϕ < 0.6, 5.0 < P < 5.3 atm (Petersen et al., 2007a; flow reactor); (6.7 < H2 < 13.6%) + (4.5 < CO < 9.1%) + (16.2 < O2 < 18.6%) + (44.1 < N2 < 63.2%), 0.3 < ϕ < 0.7, 12 < P < 23.5 atm (Walton et al., 2007a); 15% H2 in air, 35 < P < 47 bar (Blumenthal et al., 1995). Filled and open circles correspond to strong and weak ignition events, respectively (Blumenthal et al., 1995). All experimental data have been normalized to 20 atm assuming proportionality to P–1. Lines show chemical kinetic computations using the model of Li et al. (2007) under constant U, V assumption as well as for different preignition linear pressure rise rates (see text). To improve clarity, modeled results are not shown for times greater than 10 s, although it is noted that constant U, V predictions can reach values of approximately 1000 s for the lowest temperatures (T ~ 630 K).
deficiencies in reaction rates or thermochemistry sufficient to be the cause of these disparities would be far reaching. Yet, the noted discrepancies between syngas ignition delay experimental results and gas phase kinetic predictions are repeatable and real, and thus, they impose limitations to design of combustion systems using syngas or hydrogen, or both. As noted in Section 2.2, carbon monoxide oxidation is strongly influenced by the presence of small amounts of hydrogen-containing species, including moisture, hydrocarbons, and most importantly, hydrogen itself (e.g., Yetter et al., 1991a). Subsequently, ignition phenomena for syngas-air mixtures will be similar in character to those for hydrogen–air mixtures. In fact, hydrogen shock tube ignition delay results exhibit similar disparities between predictions and observations and have been frequently discussed in the published literature since the early 1960s. This has been detailed by Chaos and Dryer (2008) and is shown in Figure 2.10, which shows experimental hydrogen shock tube ignition data (Blumenthal et al., 1995; Craig, 1966; Fujimoto, 1963; Martynenko et al., 2004; Slack, 1977; Snyder et al.,
45
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
105
106
Fujimoto (1963)
104
103 H2/O2/Ar 2/1/7 P~2 atm
102
Ignition Delay (µs)
101 0.9 10
6
10
4
102
1
1.1
1.2
10 10
1
101 0.8
0.9
1
1.1
1.2
Martynenko et al. (2004) Stoichiometric H2/Air
4
10
103 102
P = 2 atm
1
10
2.1 < P < 3.86 atm 10.1 < P < 14.9 atm 0.7
0.8
0.9
1
1.1
5
10
104 P = 3 atm
Blumenthal et al. (1995) Wang et al. (2003)
103
101 10–1 0.5
H2/Air Φ=1 P~2 atm
102
10
Stoichiometric H2/O2 Voevodsky and Soloukhin (1965) P = 1 atm
10–1 103
103
5
100 3
Snyder et al. (1965) Craig (1966) Slack (1977)
105
104
102 0.7
0.9
1.1
101 1.3 1000/T(K–1)
15% H2 + 85% Air P~4 atm 0.9
1
1.1
Figure 2.10 Hydrogen shock tube ignition delays (symbols) from a number of experimental studies compared against chemical kinetic predictions (lines) using the model of Li et al. (2007). Modeling performed using the reported gas temperature and a constant U, V thermodynamic assumption.
1965; Voevodsky and Soloukhin, 1965; Wang et al., 2003) compared against model predictions. Note the remarkable similarity between Figure 2.10 and results reported by Petersen et al. (2007a) for syngas (Figure 2.9). In considering the observations above, Dryer and Chaos (2008) and Chaos and Dryer (2008) emphasized that the high sensitivity of induction chemistry to any type of experimental perturbations or nonidealities is what principally led to similarities in observations among the various experimental venues. Furthermore, they argued that disparities in observations and kinetic predictions were a result of the ideal
46
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
modeling assumptions applied and their inability to represent experimental conditions appropriately. In the particular case of shock tube observations, the disparities occur at temperatures below the extended second explosion limit, where mild ignition occurs (Strehlow and Cohen, 1962) and characteristic kinetic times are strongly influenced by induction chemistry and heat release involving HO2 and H2O2 reactions (see Section 2.2). Since the publication of the study of Chaos and Dryer (2008), several papers have drawn attention to the fact that significant pressure variations can occur during ignition in shock tubes at long test times (several milliseconds or longer). These revelations have significant impact on the arguments made with regard to syngas combustion as well as model validation based upon shock tube data presently in the literature. Below, further attention is brought to these issues, along with their implications in interpreting and modeling ignition delay data.
2.4.1 Shock Tube Pressure Histories Shock-induced self-ignition of undiluted fuel–air mixtures at the conditions of interest noted above are characterized by relatively long ignition delay times on the order of a few milliseconds. Ignition under these conditions is strongly coupled to the thermodynamic state and fluid dynamics of the gas behind the reflected shock wave. Ideally, the gas behind a reflected shock should be stationary and have uniform thermodynamic properties over the entire test volume. In the case of syngas-air mixtures, ideal analyses further predict that no significant preignition heat release can occur without substantial depletion of reactants, voiding the philosophical definition of ignition. Practically, however, even for dilute mixture studies, unavoidable nonidealities exist in the shocked gases, due to the ubiquitous presence of boundary layers. Incident shock attenuation, boundary layer growth, and shock wave–boundary layer interactions lead to nonuniform pressures and temperatures behind the reflected shock that gradually increase with time (Davidson and Hanson, 2004; Kahandawala et al., 2006; Petersen and Hanson, 2001). Furthermore, residual gas velocities may exist behind the reflected shock wave that further lead to the establishment of pressure gradients along the shock tube axis (Frenklach et al., 1984; Michael and Sutherland, 1986). These nonidealities can be minimized by using large-diameter shock tubes, dilute fuel-oxidizer mixtures in monoatomic gases, and short test times (less than about 500 µs). The latter two options, however, are not applicable to shock tube experiments that study higher concentration fuel–air mixtures of direct relevance to energy conversion applications. For such highly reactive, exothermic mixtures, the above phenomena are further compounded by the fact that at high pressures and lower temperatures, ignition in reflected shock tube regions is inhomogeneous (Terao, 1977), initiating at localized hot spots in a deflagrative manner, progressing eventually to detonation (Blumenthal et al., 1996; Fieweger et al., 1997; Wang et al., 2003). An example of this behavior is shown in Figure 2.11, which contrasts ignition processes during mild and strong combustion. Prior to the main ignition event, the finite exothermicity of the initial, localized, heterogeneous reaction sites induces further increases in pressure, which
47
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
(a)
(b)
Figure 2.11 Shadowgraphs of the ignition process of 15% H2 + 85% air mixtures in a shock tube. (a) Mild ignition: 7.7 atm, 977 K, 100 µs separation between frames; (b) strong ignition: 3.4 atm, 1096 K, 40 µs separation between frames. Note that these conditions lie on either side of the extended second limit (see Figure 2.1). (Images have been adapted from Blumenthal et al., 1996. With permission.)
are quickly equalized throughout the gases behind the reflected shock due to the high speed of sound. These features are typical of the well-known mild ignition process. For nonreactive mixtures, Petersen and Hanson (2001) reported temperature increases (due to observed pressure gradients behind the reflected shock) of up to 40 K over 500 µs for representative pressure and temperature ranges of 24 to 530 atm and 1275 to 1900 K, respectively. For conditions relevant to practical fuels (i.e., 25 to 50 atm and 700 to 1000 K) and due to reactivity and the likelihood of much longer ignition times, more severe pressure and temperature effects are to be expected. It should be noted, however, that the magnitude of these changes also depends on the shock tube diameter (Petersen and Hanson, 2001), being less severe (but still considerable) as the tube diameter is increased. From the discussion above, it is clear that changes in the thermodynamic state of the gas behind the reflected shock wave are likely to be significant and, thus, can have pronounced effects on kinetic observations as well as the ignition process. Figure 2.12 shows the pressure-time history record during ignition of a sample syngas mixture studied by Reehal et al. (2007). A preignition pressure increase of nearly 50% over the reported nominal reflected shock pressure can be observed (Figure 2.12b). In such instances, kinetic modeling of the ignition delay process under the common assumption that the shock tube behaves as a constant-volume system with constant internal energy is no longer reasonable. Approximate homogenous modeling can be performed if individual experimental pressure histories are known for each test condition; however, this information rarely accompanies reported shock tube ignition delay measurements. With some frequency, an exemplar experimental
48
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
100
A
80
Syngas, P = 13.2 atm, T = 1022 K 18.01% H2 0.22% Ar 1.03% CO 16.13% O2 0.89% CH4 61.37% N2 2.36% CO2
60
Pressure (atm)
40 20 0 30
B
20
6 atm/ms
10
0 0
200
400 600 Time (µs)
800
1000
Figure 2.12 Pressure profile during syngas ignition obtained from Reehal et al. (2007). Panel (b) zooms into the profile shown in (a) to show preignition pressure rise.
pressure profile is presented, but generally the ordinate scaling chosen (large enough to capture pre- and postignition pressure values) is such that pressure history prior to ignition is not known with sufficient accuracy (Figure 2.12a). Even though the aforementioned nonidealities present in shock tubes at the conditions of interest have been known for some time and noted by shock tube experimentalists (e.g., Blumenthal et al., 1996; Fieweger et al., 1997; Petersen and Hanson, 2001), recent shock tube studies of fuel–air mixtures have failed to consider these phenomena in interpreting the reported data (e.g., Petersen et al., 2007a). Furthermore, because of the lack of pressure-time history information noted above and the established, common practice to assume constant U, V in modeling shock tube data, the experimental and general chemical kinetic modeling communities (including ourselves) have ignored the implications to model validation. The issues outlined above have recently begun to receive more attention, as shock tube experimentalists continue to understand and attempt to determine early ignition events at lower temperatures and for high-energy density mixtures (Li et al., 2008; Pang et al., 2009; Petersen et al., 2007b; Shen et al., 2009). In these studies ignition
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
49
delay data are further examined and pressure variations prior to ignition are identified and taken into account when interpreting and modeling the data. Their implications into how ignition delay chemical kinetic modeling should be approached are discussed below.
2.4.2 Modeling Approaches In several previous studies, it has been suggested that preignition pressure variations in reflected shock tube observations can be approximated by assuming they are polytropic processes (Fieweger et al., 1997; Petersen and Hanson, 2001). Recently, some investigators (e.g., Pang et al., 2009) have used pressure histories and associated temperatures deduced from isentropic relations to adjust ignition data affected by preignition pressure rise, while others (e.g., Petersen et al., 2007b) have opted to compute an effective or average pressure and temperature based on the observed pressure history and plot the data with respect to these adjusted values. The presence of dynamic pressure features prior to ignition, however, can have considerable effects on radical initiation processes, as discussed in Mittal et al. (2008). Therefore, it is important to include measured pressure histories in modeling approaches rather than using averaged or effective values. Li et al. (2008) proposed a specific modeling tool for shock tube applications, CHEMSHOCK, which allows for the treatment of time-varying pressures coupled with chemical kinetics. CHEMSHOCK solves the coupled energy and chemical species system of differential equations using a two-step process: at every time step the system is first solved assuming constant U, V conditions, and then pressure and temperature are adjusted isentropically to match the measured pressure profile while keeping the chemical composition fixed. Pang et al. (2009) showed promising results using CHEMSHOCK in modeling ignition delay data of H2/O2 mixtures. Alternatively, SENKIN (Lutz et al., 1987), part of the CHEMKIN II (Kee et al., 1989) suite of programs, is capable of embodying the same assumptions with similar generality. A time-dependent polytropic compression (or expansion) results in both volume and density changing with time. In contrast to the CONP (constant enthalpy and pressure) and CONV (constant internal energy and volume, commonly used for shock tube modeling), the VTIM (i.e., volume as a function of time) option in SENKIN can be employed to emulate a time-dependent polytropic state change. The user must only provide time functions for variations in the specific volume of the system. Knowing the functional variation of pressure from measured data and assuming isentropic compression/expansion, the functions to be provided are
1 P (t ) ν (t ) = ρ0 P0
−1
dν 1 ν (t ) dP =− dt γ P (t ) dt
γ
50
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Ignition Delay (µs)
where ν is the specific volume, P the measured pressure, γ the specific heat ratio, and P0 and ρ0 the initial pressure and density, respectively, behind the reflected shock wave. This approach has been successfully used in modeling rapid compression machine ignition processes (Mittal et al., 2008), while Petersen and Hanson (2001) used a similar methodology to account for observed pressure variations in nonreacting mixtures behind reflected shock waves. Using this approach, the syngas data of Reehal et al. (2007) were further considered. It was assumed that preignition pressure rise, on average, can be approximated by a linear positive gradient, as evidenced by Pang et al. (2009). It is noted, however, that for high reactant concentrations (i.e., fuel–air mixtures) and due to the mild ignition processes discussed above, observed pressure rises may deviate from this linearity (e.g., see Figure 2 in Petersen et al., 2007b). As shown in Figure 2.12b, an approximate rise of 6 atm/ms can be applied to the data. Figure 2.13 plots the dataset for the mixture shown in Figure 2.12, along with model predictions using a constant U, V assumption, as well as VTIM with the pressure rise shown in Figure 2.12b. For the shortest test time, the constant U, V model predictions agree reasonably with the data, but at longer test times, the gradual pressure (and temperature) increase results in considerable departure of predictions and measurements, as noted above. In this case, Figure 2.13 shows that the constant U, V approach quickly fails to provide a good estimate of ignition delay at lower temperatures. SENKIN modeling with VTIM assuming a linear pressure profile provides much improved predictions. The above results are encouraging and warrant consideration in interpreting the syngas data of Petersen et al. (2007a). It is noted that Petersen et al. (2007a) did
104
103
102 0.85
0.9
0.95
1
1000/T(K–1)
1.05
1.1
Figure 2.13 Syngas ignition delay data (symbols) and predictions using the model of Li et al. (2007). Data are those of Reehal et al. (2007) for the mixture shown in Figure 2.12 at an average pressure of 11.8 atm. The dashed line corresponds to modeling assuming constant U, V; the solid line is the result of calculations using the pressure gradient shown in Figure 2.12b and employing CHEMKIN-VTIM (see text). The gray symbol corresponds to the case shown in Figure 2.12.
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
51
not discuss the characteristics of the pressure signals associated with their shock tube data; however, in recent work (Mertens et al., 2008; Reehal et al., 2007) these researchers have shown that syngas shock tube ignition can exhibit considerable pressure variations. Furthermore, emission from the hydroxyl radical collected at the shock tube’s endwall (Reehal et al., 2007) indicates that these data show severe mild ignition characteristics that, as explained above, in conjunction with boundary layer effects lead to compression of the test mixture over the ignition delay period. In fact, Figure 2.9 also shows shock tube data from the H2-air ignition study of Blumenthal et al. (1995), who were able to identify and perform temporal measurements on the appearance of flame kernels and subsequent transition to detonation in the mild ignition regime. Cases that exhibited mild ignition processes are identified in Figure 2.9 as open circles; note that these closely agree with the shock tube data from Petersen et al. (2007a), which considerably deviate from constant U, V model predictions. Since pressure profiles for the data reported by Petersen et al. (2007a) are not available, Figure 2.9 shows results using assumed linear pressure gradients of 2, 5, and 10%/ms (i.e., 0.4, 1, and 2 atm/ms) prior to ignition. These values may be conservative, as the presence of mild ignition events will certainly change pressure signals considerably; for example, Figure 2.12b shows a pressure gradient of nearly 50%/ms. It can be seen that these simplified assumptions yield good agreement with the data over the entire temperature range. However, the accuracy of the measured pressure histories in the preignition region as well as the validity of the isentropic compression assumption produce additional uncertainties that must be considered in developing and validating models utilizing such data.
2.4.3 Other Systems One of the more intriguing points raised by data in Figure 2.9 is that data collected in flow reactor and rapid compression venues apparently follow the trend established by the shock tube data in the mild ignition regime. Given that nonidealities present in shock tubes (discussed above) do not apply to these experiments, the question remains as to what causes accelerated ignition in these systems. Chaos and Dryer (2008) suggested that both flow reactors and rapid compression measurements can suffer similarly from other experimental perturbations. The strong sensitivity of chemical induction processes in the thermal-chain explosive regime to any source of perturbation leads to reductions in the overall ignition delay period in the mild ignition region (see Figure 2.9), similar to those observed for shock tube studies. The presence of reaction fronts (Walton et al., 2007b) as well as particles (Elsworth et al., 1969; Haskell, 1970) may influence rapid compression studies. On the other hand, catalytic processes may affect flow reactor measurements (Chaos and Dryer, 2008). Similar to the effects of NOX on combustion systems discussed above, all these perturbations act to remove the rate-limiting nature of reactions below the explosion limit, and the exothermicity of the system is increased, as detailed in Section 2.2. This rapidly drives the reaction across the explosion limit, considerably shortening induction and, therefore, ignition delay time. The multiplicity of and the strong sensitivities of induction chemistry to experimental perturbations are very difficult to characterize accurately in research experiments
52
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
and are unlikely to be controlled in real engineering applications. The implications for developing lean premixing schemes for advanced syngas combustion applications are that designs should accommodate the likely presence of perturbations and their effects on ignition delay through, for example, empirical relations (Beerer and McDonell, 2008), if stimulated flashback into the mixing region is to be precluded.
2.5 Premixed Flame Propagation in High-Pressure Media One parameter of great importance in the design of gas turbine combustors using syngas or hydrogen is the laminar burning velocity, and in turn, the turbulent mass burning rate. Measurements of syngas burning velocities have been mostly studied at atmospheric conditions (e.g., Hassan et al., 1996; McLean et al., 1994). A number of recent advancements in flame speed measurement methodologies have resulted in a substantial extension in the range of initial parameters and mixture compositions that can be studied. Tse et al. (2000) devised a constant-pressure dual-chambered cylindrical bomb apparatus, extending the pressure range for the stretched spherical flame method by nearly an order of magnitude. The device enabled H2 and H2/CO flame speed measurements up to 40 atm (Tse et al., 2000; Sun et al., 2007). Bradley et al. (2007) conceived a method to extract planar burning velocities from wrinkled outwardly propagating flames and employed the technique to measure burning velocities of lean H2-air flames up to 10 atm. Natarajan et al. (2007) demonstrated that the Bunsen flame approach for flame speed measurement yields values that are consistent with other, more widely accepted methodologies. Flame speeds were determined using conical H2/CO/CO2/He flames at pressures to 15 atm and preheat temperatures to 700 K (Natarajan et al., 2007, 2009). In a study of transient effects arising from ignition in a homogeneous mixture, Chen et al. (2009a) found that unsteady and nonlinear effects are substantial for small, spherical flames of nonunity Lewis number. Burke et al. (2009b) and Chen et al. (2009b) showed that flame speeds observed close to the wall in cylindrical and spherical chambers are systematically lower due to confinement of the flow field. Correction techniques were developed that extend the flame radius range that can be used for accurate determinations of flame speed, allowing for burning velocity measurements of dilute mixtures with prolonged ignition transients. The techniques of Burke et al. (2009b) and Chen et al. (2009a, 2009b) permitted experimental study on the burning rates of H2/O2/CO/CO2/diluent flames of temperatures from 1500 to 1800 K in a cylindrical bomb up to 25 atm (Burke et al., 2007, 2009a). Similar to the recent ignition delay observations discussed in the previous section, the above flame speed studies extend results significantly beyond previous works with which modeling results presently in the literature were compared. Furthermore, it appears that current kinetic models result in predictions that fail to replicate these recent data (Figure 2.14). Figure 2.14 shows that there exists considerable scatter in available atmospheric pressure measurements (Figure 2.14a) (Burke et al., 2007; Hassan et al., 1997; McLean et al., 1994; Sun et al., 2007), especially at rich conditions. A similar trend is also observed for high-pressure H2/CO flame conditions (Figure 2.14b) (Burke et al., 2009a; Sun et al., 2007). Inconsistencies that may be present in data
53
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
Laminar Burning Velocity (cm/s)
200 160 120 80 40 0
Laminar Burning Velocity (cm/s)
Burke et al. (2007) Hassan et al. (1997) McLean et al. (1994) Sun et al. (1994) 1
0
2 3 Equivalence Ratio (a)
4
5
Burke et al. (2009a) Sun et al. (2007)
100
10 atm
80
20 atm
60
40 1
2 3 Equivalence Ratio (b)
4
Figure 2.14 Laminar burning velocities of syngas mixtures. (a) H2:CO (1:1) in air at 1 atm; (b) H2:CO (1:3) + O2:He (1:7) mixtures at high pressure. Symbols are experimental measurements. The solid line shows predictions from the model of Li et al. (2007); the dashed line are results assuming a Fe(CO)5 content of 200 ppm in the CO source (using the kinetic subset of Rumminger et al., 1999).
processing methodologies to obtain laminar burning velocities (e.g., Burke et al., 2007, 2009b; Chen et al., 2009b) cannot fully explain the observed disparities. Sun et al. (2007) noted these discrepancies and developed a syngas kinetic model that exhibited improved predictions against high-pressure H2/CO flames. Sun et al. also demonstrated acceptable model performance against other H2/CO targets (Dean et al., 1978; Fotache et al., 2000; Mueller et al., 1999b; Yetter et al., 1991b). However, as shown in Figure 2.15, model updates implemented by Sun et al. (2007) seriously
54
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Laminar Burning Rate (g/cm2/s)
0.4
0.3
10 atm 15 atm 20 atm
0.2
0.1 0.8
1.2 1.6 Equivalence Ratio
2
2.4
Figure 2.15 Measured and calculated unstretched laminar mass burning rates for H2 + (O2:He, 1:11.5) flames at 10, 15, and 20 atm. Symbols are experimental data (Tse et al., 2000); solid lines are predictions using the model of Sun et al. (2007); dashed lines are predictions using the model of Li et al. (2007).
degrade the quality of predictions against high-pressure pure hydrogen burning velocities. On the basis of the above discussion, Chaos and Dryer (2008) considered the possibility of experimental contamination effects due to unintentional addition of iron pentacarbonyl, Fe(CO)5. For laboratory combustion experiments, many researchers have employed high-pressure carbon-steel cylinders as the source of the fuel. CO can readily react at high pressure with metals present in steel to form carbonyls, especially Fe(CO)5. Depending on handling, steel CO cylinders obtained from commercial suppliers with initially little or no contaminants are prone to contamination by Fe(CO)5 over time (Tepe et al., 1999). An example of experimental contamination by Fe(CO)5 is the study of Williams and Shaddix (2007), who recently reported observing wall deposits formed when operating a swirl-stabilized combustor running on simulated syngas-air mixtures; these deposits were found to be mostly iron oxides originating from Fe(CO)5 in the CO source used. Metallic compounds have been shown to have strong flame inhibition effects (Lask and Wagner, 1960; Linteris et al., 2008; Reinelt and Linteris, 1996; Rumminger and Linteris, 2000, 2002; Rumminger et al., 1999; Vanpee and Shirodkar, 1978). When present in premixed flames, iron pentacarbonyl can reduce the burning velocity considerably (Lask and Wagner, 1960; Linteris et al., 2008; Reinelt and Linteris, 1996; Rumminger and Linteris, 2000). The presence of chromium, nickel, and iron carbonyls has also been shown to accelerate carbon monoxide and hydrogen oxidation in shock tubes (Izod et al., 1972; Linteris and Babushok, 2009; Matsuda, 1972a, 1972b). For the conditions of the study of Petersen et al. (2007a), however, the presence of Fe(CO)5 is not sufficient (Chaos and Dryer, 2008; Linteris and Babushok, 2009) to explain the results discussed in the section above. Finally, in gas turbines used in
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
55
commercial IGCC installations, the formation of large iron deposits on nozzle hardware has been noted. These deposits lead to restriction/alteration of the airflow into the combustor, overheating parts of the combustion chamber. These iron deposits have been reported to originate from Fe(CO)5 introduced into the chamber after CO in the syngas used reacted with steel pipes (García, 2006). Furthermore, iron pentacarbonyl is a well-established challenge in the development of gasification technologies (Rezaiyan and Chereminisoff, 2005). To further investigate the effects of Fe(CO)5 contamination on H2/CO burning velocities, Chaos and Dryer (2008) added the Fe(CO)5 kinetic rate correlations and transport properties developed by Rumminger et al. (1999) to the model of Li et al. (2007) and performed calculations for the flame conditions of Figure 2.14. In the computations, it was assumed that the CO source contained 200 ppm of Fe(CO)5 so that the overall maximum iron pentacarbonyl mixture concentrations for a wide range of equivalence ratios were always less than 75 ppm, approximately. Figure 2.14 compares the model-predicted burning velocities for pure fuel (solid lines) and for mixtures using CO contaminated by 200 ppm of Fe(CO)5 (dashed lines) with experimental data. The figure confirms that Fe(CO)5 has a very noticeable effect on rich flames, in qualitative agreement with the onset of the experimental disparities found in the literature. Experimental data, however, are needed to conclusively determine contamination by iron pentacarbonyl. As part of the present study, the CO cylinder used in the experiments of Burke et al. (2007) was analyzed by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy means. A Nicolet Magna IR 560 spectrometer was used for the tests. The instrument consisted of a 2.0 L gas cell with an optical path length of 10.0 m maintained at 100°C and 0.07 atm (~1 psia). Rather than trying to handle Fe(CO)5 (due to its high toxicity) to perform a calibration, pure CO was obtained from Airgas, stored in an aluminum cylinder to prevent formation of iron pentacarbonyl. The gas from this cylinder was used to establish a background signal. Absorption spectra from the CO gas stored in the steel cylinder used by Burke et al. (2007) were then recorded by averaging 32 scans at a resolution of 0.25 cm–1 over a 600 to 4000 cm–1 wave number range. The results of the tests are shown in Figure 2.16; the typical rovibrational CO band heads (R and P branches) do not appear in the spectra as pure, Fe(CO)5-free carbon monoxide was used as background. However, strong absorption bands are evident, centered around 2013 and 2033 cm–1. These are positioned at relatively higher frequencies than the CO rovibrational frequencies and can be ascribed to the presence of gas phase Fe(CO)5 (McDowell, 1971; Myrstad and Fredriksen, 1998; Rao et al., 1989), as it only has two CO stretching modes that are IR active (Rao et al., 1989). Based on the absorbance values measured and using the extinction coefficients reported by McDowell (1971) for the 2013 and 2033 cm–1 bands, consistent concentration values of 25.7 and 24.3 ppm, respectively, were calculated. This contamination level is approximately an order of magnitude lower than that used to generate the plots in Figure 2.14. Therefore, the data of Burke et al. (2007) can be considered free from iron pentacarbonyl effects. The discussion above motivated additional consideration of the important kinetic pathways affecting the propagation of flames at high pressure, particularly for diluted
56
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications 0.5
Absorbance
0.4 2014 cm–1
0.3 0.2 0.1 0 2100
2033 cm–1
2075
2000 2050 2025 Wave Number (cm–1)
1975
1950
Figure 2.16 Infrared spectra of the carbon monoxide gas used in the experiments of Burke et al. (2007). The main absorption bands of Fe(CO)5 are identified.
and low flame temperature conditions. Such conditions are of considerable significance, as combustion dilution is essential to controlling NOX emissions in syngas combustion applications. Burke et al. (2009a) performed experimental and modeling studies of H2/CO/CO2 flames of temperatures from 1500 to 1800 K at high pressures. Significant disagreement among the model predictions as well as with experimental data were noted to correlate strongly with high pressure and lower flame temperature conditions where the reactive portion of the flame was restricted to a smaller, higher-temperature window. The discrepancies were found to exist even for pure hydrogen flames. Preliminary experimental data from Burke et al. (2009a) and model predictions (Li et al., 2007; Davis et al., 2005; Sun et al., 2007; Konnov, 2008) for the mass burning rate of both lean and rich H2/O2/diluent mixtures are shown in Figure 2.17. The experimental data show a negative pressure dependence of the burning rate for pressures above ~15 atm for these low flame temperature conditions. Negative pressure dependence of the burning rate for syngas flames could have interesting consequences for thermoacoustic stability behavior in engines. While the predictions of Li et al. (2007) and Davis et al. (2005) reproduce experimental results well to about 10 atm, no model reproduces the new measurements for pressures above 10 atm across all equivalence ratios. Large disparities in predicted burning rates at higher pressures (up to a factor of 2) are observed among the models and against the experimental data. The disparity in predictions yielded from the various models is particularly noteworthy, as nearly the same target data were used in developing and validating each of the models. Analyses conducted using the model of Li et al. (2007) indicate that sensitivity of mass burning rate predictions to elementary rates increases considerably with pressure, as demonstrated in Figure 2.18. The reactions, to which the pressure dependence for rich conditions is most sensitive, are primarily reactions that involve H
57
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
Mass Burning Rate (g/cm2/s)
0.16 0.12 0.08 0.04 0
0
20
10
30
Pressure (atm) (a)
Mass Burning Rate (g/cm2/s)
1.2
0.8
0.4
0
0
10 20 Pressure (atm)
30
(b)
Figure 2.17 Laminar burning velocities of hydrogen mixtures at constant flame temperature (~1600 K) for various pressures: (a) H2/O2/He (1.7/1/11.5) mixture, ϕ = 0.85; and (b) H2/O2/Ar (5/1/9.5) mixture, ϕ = 2.5. Symbols are experimental measurements from Burke et al. (2009a) (open circles) and Tse et al. (2000) (open triangles), lines are model results: Li et al. (2004, 2007), bold solid line; Davis et al. (2005), bold dashed line; Sun et al. (2007), solid line; Konnov (2008), dashed line.
atoms, namely, (R1), (R2), (R6), and (R7) (Figure 2.18b). Rates of these four reactions define the extended second explosion limit, as discussed above. The reactions that appear to govern the pressure dependence for lean conditions are the reactions above in addition to reactions involving OH radicals, namely, (R14) and H2 + OH = H2O + H (R15) (Figure 2.18a). Other reactions include O + H2 = H + OH (R16) and H + OH + M = H2O + M (R17). Reaction (R16) is a branching reaction that becomes increasingly important at lean conditions, as more O radicals are produced due to
58
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
1 atm
HO2 + H = H2 + O2 (R6)
10 atm 20 atm
H + OH + M = H2O + M (R15) O + H2 = H + OH (R14) HO2 + OH = H2O + O2 (R12) HO2 + H = OH + OH (R7) H2 + OH = H2O + H (R13) H + O2 (+M) = HO2 (+M) (R2) H + O2 = O + OH (R1) –0.8
O + H2 = H + OH (R14)
–0.4 0 0.4 Sensitivity Coefficient (a)
0.8
1 atm 10 atm
HO2 + OH = H2O + O2 (R12)
20 atm
H + OH + M = H2O + M (R15) H2 + OH = H2O + H (R13) HO2 + H = H2+O2 (R6) H + O2(+M) = HO2 (+M) (R2) HO2 + H = OH + OH (R7) H + O2 = O + OH (R1)
–0.8
–0.4 0 0.4 Sensitivity Coefficient (b)
0.8
Figure 2.18 Sensitivity of mass burning rates to rate parameters as a function of pressure for (a) H2/O2/He mixtures (Figure 2.17a) and (b) H2/O2/Ar mixtures (Figure 2.17b).
59
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
the presence of excess oxygen. Even at lean conditions, however, reaction (R1) is the dominant branching reaction (Figure 2.18). Reaction (R17) is highly exothermic and has been previously shown to affect predictions of laminar burning rates (Li et al., 2004); in fact, Li et al. (2004) modified the rate of (R17) to improve model predictions at flame conditions. Uncertainties in collision parameters of species stabilizing the recombination of H and OH in (R17) remain and have been the subject of recent studies (Sellevåg et al., 2008; Srinivasan and Michael, 2006). At increasing pressures, the OH radical is present in higher concentrations and plays a larger role in the kinetic pathways for lean conditions. Reaction (R14) competes with (R6) and (R7) for HO2 radicals and inhibits the overall kinetics by converting two radicals to stable species. As discussed above, the reaction rate of (R14) has an uncommon and highly non-Arrhenius temperature dependence (see Figure 2.8). Temperature window sensitivity analyses (Zhao et al., 2005) of burning rate to (R14) for the lean H2/O2/He mixture of Figure 2.17a were conducted (Burke et al., 2009a). The results (shown in Figure 2.19) reveal that the temperature window of peak sensitivity to (R14) at pressures above 10 atm is almost exclusively in the deep well of the rate correlation (around 1000 K; see Figure 2.8). Therefore, accurate characterization of the rate of (R14) in this region is critical to predicting the burning rate of lean syngas mixtures at pressures of practical significance. Indeed, simulations performed using the model of Li et al. (2007) substituting the two rate expressions proposed by Chaos and Dryer (2008) for (R14) yield substantially different results at pressures above 10 atm. Substitution of the fit based on the data of Hippler et al. (1995), which exhibit a local minimum at ~1200 K, yields substantially higher values than those shown in Figure 2.17, whereas substitution of the fit based on Kappel et al. (2002)
Temperature Sensitivity Coefficient
0 1 atm
–0.005
10 atm
–0.01
–0.015
20 atm
–0.02 0.5
1
1.5 1000/T(K–1)
2
2.5
Figure 2.19 Pressure dependence of temperature window sensitivities of burning rates to HO2 + OH = H2O + O2 (R14) for the lean H2/O2/He mixture of Figure 2.17a. The laminar burning rate exhibits strong sensitivity to the reaction in the location of the local rate minimum of this reaction (see Figure 2.8).
60
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
data, which exhibit a local minimum at ~1000 K, has little effect on the predictions. Additionally, direct substitution of recent rate expressions for (R2) and (R17) proposed by Srinivasan and Michael (2006), Sellevåg et al. (2008), and Pang et al. (2009) into the mechanism of Li et al. (2007) does not substantially improve, and in some cases degrades, predictions. Direct substitution of the proposed rate expression from Michael et al. (2000) for (R6) yields improvements to the predictions, but does not completely reconcile differences between the models and experimental data. At present it appears that under fuel-rich conditions, the relative rates of HO2 + H = H2 + O2 (R6) and HO2 + H = OH + OH (R7) must be significantly revised to bring predictions into reasonable consistency with experimental results. As these reactions remain important even under fuel-lean conditions, further refinements of predictions involving HO2 + OH = H2O + O2 (R14) are dependent on them. Additional experimental and theoretical analyses on reactions (R6), (R7), and (R14) are needed to support resolution of models at conditions important to syngas combustion at high pressures. The effect of pressure on the flame structure based on flux of H radicals through the competing pathways, (R1) and (R2), and H radical mole fraction using the model of Li et al. (2007) is illustrated in Figure 2.20 (Burke et al., 2009a). Figure 2.20 also shows the temperature of the extended second limit for the given pressures (see also Figure 2.1). The results indicate that with increasing pressure, the temperature of extended second limit increases accordingly, moving significantly toward the postflame region for lean and rich mixtures. Therefore, the portion of the flame
0.002
0.004
0 10 atm
0.12
0.0008
0.08
0.0004
0.04
0 0.0006
0
20 atm
0.2
0.0004
0.1
0.0002 0
400
800 1200 Temperature (K)
(a)
0 1600
Mole Fraction
Mole Fraction
0
0.004
0.01
0.001
0.002
0.006
1 atm
0.02
0 0.006
10 atm
0.4 0.3
0.004
0.2
0.002 0 0.003
0.1 0 1.2
20 atm
0.002
0.8
0.001
0.4
0
0.002 0
400
1200 800 Temperature (K)
Flux (mole/cm3/s)
0.006
0.0012
0.03
0.003
1 atm
Flux (mole/cm3/s)
0.01 0.008
0 1600
(b)
Figure 2.20 Comparison of relevant aspects of the flame structure at various pressures for (a) H 2/O2/He mixtures and (b) H 2/O2/Ar mixtures at the conditions shown in Figure 2.17. Black lines represent H radical mole fraction, and gray lines show the flux of H radicals through H + O2 = O + OH (R1) (solid line) and H + O2(+M) = HO2(+M) (R2) (dashed line). The temperature of the extended second limit temperature is marked by the vertical lines.
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
61
that undergoes strong branching kinetics (i.e., at temperatures above the extended second limit) is reduced to a smaller temperature window at higher pressures. The peak H radical mole fraction is decreased substantially and also moves toward the postflame region with increasing pressure. Furthermore, the reaction zone region in which (R1) and (R2) compete is restricted to higher temperatures and a smaller overall temperature range as pressure is increased. Similar shifts toward smaller, higher-temperature windows occur in the flux profiles of other controlling reactions, including (R6) and (R7). Such a restriction of the strongly reactive portion of the flame to higher temperatures can be expressed as an increase in the overall activation energy or Zeldovich number of the mixture with pressure. Comparing Figure 2.20a and b, the responses of the flame structure to pressure are different for different equivalence ratios. The peak fluxes of the H radical through (R1) and (R2) occur closer to the unburned region in rich flames, where the concentration of oxygen is higher. Since the peak flux of the H radical occurs at lower temperatures, where (R2) is favored relative to (R1), the peak flux through (R2) relative to (R1) is higher than that at lean conditions. At both lean and rich conditions, the mole fraction of HO2 compared to H is substantially higher at higher pressures, as a much larger portion of the flame is below the extended second limit. Consequently, pathways involving HO2 play a much larger role in the overall kinetics. Reactions involving HO2 with H and OH (and possibly even O for very lean conditions) exhibit higher sensitivities to the burning rate at higher pressures. Additionally, since the reactive portion of the flame is restricted to higher temperatures at high pressures, the peak sensitivity to these reactions occurs at higher temperatures (e.g., Figure 2.19). Since (R6), (R7), and (R14) continue to have large uncertainties in their rates and temperature dependences, as discussed above, these reactions deserve further attention, particularly at higher temperatures (above 1000 K). In general, high-pressure syngas as well as hydrogen flames emphasize HO2 kinetics and radical-radical recombination reactions such as (R17). Additionally, most of the flame reactivity, i.e., branching) occurs in a relatively small portion of the flame as, for increasing pressures, the extended second limit shifts to higher temperatures. Since many new techniques have been developed in the past decade that extend the pressure and temperature ranges of flame studies and recent interest in syngas combustion is focused on conditions relevant to gas turbines, further investigations of high-pressure and temperature syngas flame kinetics are surely forthcoming. As many of the recent studies (Tse et al., 2000; Sun et al., 2007; Natarajan et al., 2009; Burke et al., 2009a) have motivated changes to the models or highlight model discrepancies with experimental data, substantial improvements in modeling flames at gas turbine conditions will likely occur over the next decade.
2.6 Conclusion Syngas mixtures are an increasingly important commodity in developing lowpolluting solutions to energy security and resources in a carbon-constrained world. Interest in syngas combustion has inspired an extension of the existing experimental validation resources to considerably higher pressures and lower temperatures that are sufficient for testing the comprehensive nature of existing detailed chemical kinetic
62
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
models. The present chapter has considered some of the unique properties of syngas combustion kinetics, summarized a number of recent theoretical and experimental advancements on the fundamental understanding of important elementary reactions, reviewed new experimental efforts to provide validation data for high-pressure, high-energy-density kinetic behavior, and discussed the kinetic issues that relate to improving predictions of these new data. The higher-pressure, lower-temperature conditions encountered in practical syngas applications point to the importance and the need of further theoretical as well as experimental studies of elementary reactions involving HO2 and H2O2. We note that recent reevaluations of the reaction rate for CO + HO2 = CO2 + OH (R13) are primarily important to ignition delay measurements at high pressures due to modifications of induction chemistry, and have little influence on postinduction observations. It appears that modifications in the reaction of HO2 + OH = H2O + O2 (R14) improve comparisons of predictions with highpressure oxidation, but recommended rate correlations for this reaction should be modified to avoid exceeding collisional rates at high temperatures. We show that recent investigations of high-pressure ignition and flame propagation of H2/CO mixtures should be cautiously evaluated prior to implementing any changes to improve the agreement of predictions from chemical kinetic models. H2/CO ignition measurements in shock tubes, rapid compression machines, and flow reactors can exhibit aberrations at low temperature and high pressures that cause observations to considerably differ from homogenous gas phase predictions. Although phenomena characterized as mild ignition in hydrogen–oxygen shock tube experiments are historically well known and can even be kinetically differentiated from strong ignition observations, the sources of chemical induction perturbations that lead to their manifestation are not understood in quantitative detail. Behavior of syngas mixtures under similar conditions is derived almost entirely as a result of perturbations of hydrogen–oxygen chemical induction kinetics, with only minor differences from the presence of carbon monoxide. Numerous processes can affect induction chemistry (i.e., compressible flow, physical mixing, impurities, and catalytic surface coupling), and it is likely that even in shock tubes, no one cause is universally responsible for the mild ignition observations. Moreover, that multiple sources of chemical induction perturbations can all lead to similar magnitudes of reduction in ignition delay in the mild ignition regime is the reason that observations in shock tubes can be correlated with experimental observations in other venues (flow reactors, rapid compression machine experiments). However, it is unlikely that in real systems, the multiple sources of perturbations can be controlled to an extent such that homogenous kinetic predictions provide limiting, realistic design criteria. While the exact nature and relative importance of each perturbing source in the various experimental venues remain to be determined, simple engineering approximations can be valuable for the safe design of lean premixing systems for gas turbines, based upon fundamental experimental data. Carbon monoxide stored in high-pressure carbon-steel cylinders is commonly used in laboratory research. These sources are prone to contamination by metal carbonyls, and it has been shown through computations that these contaminants, especially iron pentacarbonyl, can considerably affect fuel-rich H2/CO laminar burning velocities. The potential effect of this contaminant in applied conditions is relatively
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
63
unknown, but it is important that fuel-rich burning rate measurements used for validation of kinetic models should be carefully scrutinized for contaminant effects. Finally, we note that all of the hydrogen–oxygen kinetic models in the literature are deficient in yielding predictions of laminar burning rates at all equivalence ratios, pressures, and flame temperatures of likely importance to gas turbine applications. While the key reactions that most affect burning rates under these conditions are identified, a suitable solution, supported by fundamental kinetic results, remains to be achieved. Additional fundamental work on the reaction of HO2 with OH and H radicals, as well as characterizations of H2O2 and these radicals under reaction conditions, would be extremely beneficial in further constraining model validation at high pressures and temperatures.
Acknowledgments This work was supported by U.S Department of Energy grant DE-FG0286ER13503 (FLD) from the Chemical Sciences, Geosciences and Biosciences Division, Office of Basic Energy Sciences, Office of Science, and by grants DE-FG26-05NT42544 (FLD) and DE-FG26-06NT42716 (FLD, YJ) from the Pittsburgh National Energy Technology Laboratories. Support from Siemens Power Generation, Inc. (technical monitor, Dr. Scott Martin) (FLD) and by the Petroleum Research Fund from the American Chemistry Society under grant PRF 43460-AC5 (YJ) is also acknowledged. The authors thank Dr. Gregory Linteris for providing an electronic version of the iron pentacarbonyl kinetic model developed at NIST.
References Allen, T. L., Fink, W. H., and Volman, D. H. (1996). Theoretical studies of the mechanism of the gas phase reaction of the hydroperoxo radical with carbon monoxide to form hydroxyl radical and carbon dioxide. J. Phys. Chem. 100:5299. Ashmore, P. G., and Tyler, B. J. (1962). Reaction of hydrogen atoms with nitrogen dioxide. Trans. Farad. Soc. 58:1108. Baldwin, R. R., Jackson, D., Walker, R. W., and Webster, S. J. (1967). Interpretation of the slow reaction and second limit of hydrogen oxygen mixtures by computer methods. T. Faraday Soc. 63:1676. Bates, R. W., Golden, D. M., Hanson, R. K., and Bowman, C. T. (2001). Experimental study and modeling of the reaction H + O2 + M → HO2 (M = Ar, N2, H2O) at elevated pressures and temperatures between 1050 and 1250 K. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 3:2337. Baulch, D. L., Bowman, C. T., Cobos, C. J., Cox, R. A., Just, T., Kerr, J. A., Pilling, M. J., Stocker, D., Troe, J., Tsang, W., and Walker, R. W. (2005). Evaluated kinetic data for combustion modeling: Supplement II. J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 34:757. Baulch, D. L., Drysdale, D. D., Duxbury, J., and Grant, S. (1973). Evaluated kinetic data for high temperature reactions, 3. London: Butterworths. Baulch, D. L., Griffiths, J. F., Pappin, A. J., and Sykes, A. F. (1988). Stationary-state and oscillatory combustion of hydrogen in a well-stirred flow reactor. Combust. Flame 73:163. Beerer, D. J., and McDonell, V. G. (2007). Experimental study of ignition delay for application to hydrogen and syngas fired lean premixed gas turbine engines. Paper E01 presented at Proceedings of the 5th U.S. Combustion Meeting, San Diego.
64
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Beerer, D. J., and McDonell, V. G. (2008). Autoignition of hydrogen and air inside a continuous flow reactor with application to lean premixed combustion. J. Eng. Gas Turbines Power 130:051507. Blumenthal, R., Fieweger, K., Komp, K. H., and Adomeit, G. (1996). Gas dynamic features of self ignition of non diluted fuel/air mixtures at high pressure. Combust. Sci. Tech. 113/114:137. Blumenthal, R., Fieweger, K., Komp, K. H., Adomeit, G., and Gelfand B. E. (1995). Selfignition of H2-air mixtures at high pressure and low temperature. In Proceedings of the 20th International Symposium on Shock Waves, 935. Pasadena, CA, July 23–28. Bradley, D., Lawes, M., Liu, K., Verhelst, S., and Woolley, R. (2007). Laminar burning velocities of lean hydrogen–air mixtures at pressures up to 1.0 MPa. Combust. Flame 149:162. Braun M., Hofzumahaus, A., and Stuhl F. (1982). VUV flash-photolysis study of the reaction of HO with HO2 at 1 atm and 298 K. Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 86:597. Brokaw, R. S. (1967). Ignition kinetics of the carbon monoxide-oxygen reaction. Proc. Combust. Inst. 11:1063. Burke, M. P., Chaos, M., Dryer, F. L., and Ju, Y. (2009a). The dependence of mass burning rates of H2/CO/CO2 flames on pressure and flame temperature. To appear. Burke, M. P., Chen, Z., Ju, Y., and Dryer, F. L. (2009b). Effect of cylindrical confinement on the determination of laminar flame speeds using outwardly propagating flames. Combust. Flame 156:771. Burke, M. P., Qin, X., Ju, Y., and Dryer, F. L. (2007). Measurements of hydrogen syngas flame speeds at elevated pressures. Paper A16 presented at Proceedings of the 5th U.S. Combustion Meeting, San Diego. Burrows, J. P., Cox, R. A., and Derwent, R. G. (1981). modulated photolysis of the ozonewater vapour system: Kinetics of the reaction of OH with HO2. J. Photochem. 16:147. Chaos, M., and Dryer, F. L. (2008). Syngas combustion kinetics and applications. Combust. Sci. Tech. 180:1051. Chen, Z., Burke, M. P., and Ju, Y. (2009a). Effects of Lewis number and ignition energy on the determination of laminar flame speed using propagating spherical flames. Proc. Combust. Inst. 32:1253. Chen, Z., Burke, M. P., and Ju, Y. (2009b). Effects of compression and stretch on the determination of laminar flame speed using propagating spherical flames. Combust. Theor. Model. 13:343. Chiesa, P., Consonni, S., Kreutz, T., and Williams, R. H. (2005). Co-production of hydrogen, electricity and CO2 from coal with commercially ready technology. Part A. Performance and emissions. Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 30:747. Cox, R. A., Burrows, J. P., and Wallington, T. J. (1981). Rate coefficient for the reaction OH + HO2 = H2O + O2 at 1 atmosphere pressure and 308 K. Chem. Phys. Lett. 84:217. Craig, R. R. (1966). A shock tube study of the ignition delay of hydrogen-air mixtures near the second explosion limit. Report AFAPL-TR-66-74, Air Force Aeropropulsion Lab, Wright-Patterson. Davidson, D. F., and Hanson, R. K. (2004). Interpreting shock tube ignition data. Int. J. Chem. Kinet. 36:510. Davis, S. G., Joshi, A. V., Wang, H., and Egolfopoulos, F. (2005). An optimized kinetic model of H2/CO combustion. Proc. Combust. Inst. 30:1283. Dean, A. M., Steiner, D. C., and Wang, E. E. (1978). A shock tube study of the H2/O2/CO/Ar and H2/N2O/CO/Ar systems: Measurement of the rate constant for H + N2O = N2 +OH. Combust. Flame 32:73. DeMore, W. B. (1979). Reaction of HO2 with O3 and the effect of water vapor on HO2 kinetics. J. Phys. Chem. 83:1113.
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
65
DeMore, W. B. (1982). Rate constant and possible pressure dependence of the reaction hydroxyl + hydroperoxo. J. Phys. Chem. 86:121. Dixon-Lewis, G., and Williams, D. J. (1977). The oxidation of hydrogen and carbon monoxide. In C. H. Branford and C. F. H. Tipper (eds.), Comprehensive chemical kinetics, 1–248. Vol. 17. Amsterdam: Elsevier. Dryer, F. L., and Chaos, M. (2008). Ignition of syngas/air and hydrogen/air mixtures at low temperatures and high pressures: Experimental data interpretation and kinetic modeling implications. Combust. Flame 152:293. Egerton, A., and Warren, D. R. (1951). Kinetics of the hydrogen/oxygen reaction. I. The explosion region in boric acid-coated vessels. Proc. R. Soc. A Math. Phys. 204:465. Elsworth, J. E., Haskell, W. W., and Read, I. A. (1969). Non-uniform ignition processes in rapid-compression machines. Combust. Flame 13:437. Fernandes, R. X., Luther, K., Troe, J., and Ushakov, V. G. (2008). Experimental and modelling study of the recombination reaction H + O2 (+M) → HO2 (+M) between 300 and 900 K, 1.5 and 950 bar, and in the bath gases M = He, Ar, and N2. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 10:4313. Fieweger, K., Blumenthal, R., and Adomeit, G. (1997). Self-ignition of S.I. Engine model fuels: A shock tube investigation at high pressure. Combust. Flame 109:599. Fotache, C. G., Tan, Y., Sung, C.-J., and Law, C. K. (2000). Ignition of CO/H2/N2 versus heated air in counterflow: Experimental and modeling results. Combust. Flame 120:417. Frenklach, M., Li Kwok Cheong, C. K., and Oran, E. S. (1984). LDV measurements of gas flow behind reflected shocks. Prog. Astronaut. Aeronaut. 95:722. Fujimoto, S. (1963). Chemical reaction in a shock wave I: The ignition delay of a hydrogen– oxygen mixture in a shock tube. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 36:1233. García, F. (2006). Syngas combustion experience at the Puertollano IGCC plant. Panel discussion GT2006-91352 at ASME Turbo Expo 2006, Barcelona, Spain, May 8–11. Gardiner, Jr., W. C., and Olson, D. B. (1980). Chemical kinetics of high temperature combustion. Ann. Rev. Phys. Chem. 31:377. Glarborg, P. (2007). Hidden interactions—Trace species governing combustion and emissions. Proc. Combust. Inst. 31:77. Goodings, J. M., and Hayhurst, A. N. (1988). Heat release and radical recombination in premixed fuel-lean flames of H2 + O2 + N2—Rate constants for H + OH + M → H2O + M and HO2 + OH → H2O + O2. J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. 2:745. Hahn, J., Krasnoperov, L., Luther, K., and Troe, J. (2004). Pressure dependence of the reaction H + O2 (+Ar) → HO2 (+Ar) in the range 1–900 bar and 300–700 K. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 6:1997. Haskell, W. W. (1970). Fuel ignition in a rapid compression machine: Sensitivity to flame ignition by particles. SAE Paper 700059. Hassan, M. I., Aung, K. T., and Faeth, G. M. (1996). Markstein numbers and unstretched laminar burning velocities of wet carbon monoxide flames. AIAA Paper 96-0912. Herzler, J., and Naumann, C. (2008). Shock tube study of the ignition of lean CO/H2 fuel blends at intermediate temperatures and high pressure. Combust. Sci. Tech. 180:2015. Hessler, J. P. (1998). Calculation of reactive cross sections and microcanonical rates from kinetic and thermochemical data. J. Phys. Chem. A 102:4517. Hippler, H., Neubauer, H., and Troe, J. (1995). Shock wave studies of the reactions HO + H2O2 → H2O + HO2 and HO + HO2 → H2O + O2 between 930 and 1680 K. J. Chem. Phys. 103:3510. Hippler, H., and Troe, J. (1992). Rate constants of the reaction HO + H2O2 → HO2 + H2O at T ≥ 1000 K. Chem. Phys. Lett. 192:333. Hippler, H., Troe, J., and Willner, J. (1990). Shock wave study of the reaction HO2 + HO2 → H2O2 + O2: Confirmation of a rate constant minimum near 700 K. J. Chem. Phys. 93:1755.
66
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Hwang, S. M., Ryu, S.-O., De Witt, K. J., and Rabinowitz, M. J. (2005). High temperature rate coefficient measurements of H + O2 chain-branching and chain-terminating reaction. Chem. Phys. Lett. 408:107. Izod, T. P. J., Kistiakowsky, G. B., and Matsuda, S. (1972). Mechanism of oxidation of carbon monoxide in the presence of chromium carbonyl. J. Chem. Phys. 56:1083. Kahandawala, M. S. P., Corera, A. P., Williams, S., Carter, C. D., and Sidhu, S. S. (2006). Investigation of kinetics of Iso-octane ignition under scramjet conditions. Int. J. Chem. Kinet. 38:194. Kalitan, D. M., Petersen, E. L., Mertens, J. D., and Crofton, M. W. (2006). Ignition of lean CO/H2/air mixtures at elevated pressures. ASME Paper GT2006-90488. Kappel, Ch., Luther, K., and Troe, J. (2002). Shock wave study of the unimolecular dissociation of H2O2 in its falloff range and of its secondary reactions. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 4:4392. Kazakov, A., Chaos, M., Zhao, Z., and Dryer, F. L. (2006). Computational singular perturbation analysis of two-stage ignition of large hydrocarbons. J. Phys. Chem. A 110:7003. Kee, R. J., Rupley, F. M., and Miller, J. A. 1989. CHEMKIN II: A Fortran chemical kinetics package for the analysis of gas phase chemical kinetics. Technical Report SAND89-8009, Sandia National Laboratories. Keyser, L. F. (1988). Kinetics of the reaction OH + HO2 → H2O + O2 from 254 K to 382 K. J. Phys. Chem. 92:1193. Kim, T. J., Yetter, R. A., and Dryer, F. L. (1994). New results on moist CO oxidation: High pressure, high temperature experiments and comprehensive kinetic modeling. Proc. Combust. Inst. 25:759. Konnov, A. A. (2008). Remaining uncertainties in the kinetic system of hydrogen combustion. Combust. Flame 152:507. Kurylo, M. J., Klais, O., and Laufer, A. H. (1981). Mechanistic investigation of the HO + HO2 reaction. J. Phys. Chem. 85:3674. Larson, E. D., Fiorese, G., Liu, G., Williams, R. H., Kreutz, T. J., and Consonni, S. (2009). Co-production of synfuels and electricity from coal + biomass with zero net carbon emissions: An Illinois case study. Energy Procedia 1:4371. Lask, G., and Wagner, H. Gg. (1960). Influence of additives on the velocity of laminar flames. Proc. Combust. Inst. 8:432. Le Cong, T., and Dagaut, P. (2008). Experimental and detailed kinetic modeling of the oxidation of methane and methane/syngas mixtures and effect of carbon dioxide addition. Combust. Sci. Tech. 180:2046. Lee, D., and Hochgreb, S. (1998). Hydrogen autoignition at pressures above the second explosion limit (0.6–4.0 MPa). Int. J. Chem. Kinet. 30:385. Lewis, B. and von Elbe, G. (1987). Combustion, flames and explosion of gases. 3rd ed. Orlando, FL: Academic Press. Li, H., Owens, Z. C., Davidson, D. F., and Hanson, R. K. (2008). A simple reactive gas dynamic model for the computation of gas temperature and species concentrations behind reflected shock waves. Int. J. Chem. Kinet. 40:89. Li, J., Zhao, Z., Kazakov, A., Chaos, M., Dryer, F. L., and Scire, Jr., J. J. (2007). A comprehensive kinetic mechanism for CO, CH2O, and CH3OH combustion. Int. J. Chem. Kinet. 39:109. Li, J., Zhao, Z., Kazakov, A., and Dryer, F. L. (2004). An updated comprehensive kinetic model of hydrogen combustion. Int. J. Chem. Kinet. 36:566. Lieuwen, T., McDonell, V. G., Petersen, E. L., and Santavicca, D. (2008). Fuel flexibility influences on premixed combustor blowout, flashback, autoignition, and stability. J. Eng. Gas Turbines Power 130:011506. Lii, R.-R., Corse, R. A., Sauer, M. C., and Gordon, S. (1980). Temperature dependence of the gas-phase self-reaction of hydroperoxo radicals in the presence of ammonia. J. Phys. Chem. 84:813.
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
67
Linteris, G. T., and Babushok, V. I. (2009). Promotion or inhibition of hydrogen-air ignition by iron-containing compounds. Proc. Combust. Inst. 32:2535. Linteris, G. T., Rumminger, M. D., and Babushok, V. I. (2008). Catalytic inhibition of laminar flames by transition metal compounds. Prog. Energ. Combust. Sci. 34:288. Lutz, A. E., Kee, R. J., and Miller, J. A. (1987). SENKIN: A Fortran program for predicting. Homogeneous gas phase chemical kinetics with sensitivity analysis. Technical Report SAND87-8248, Sandia National Laboratories. Martynenko, V. V., Penyaz’kov, O. G., Ragotner, K. A., and Shabunya, S. I. (2004). Hightemperature ignition of hydrogen and air at high pressures downstream of the reflected shock wave. J. Eng. Phys. Thermophys. 77:785. Matsuda, S. (1972a). Gas phase homogeneous catalysis in shock waves. II. The oxidation of carbon monoxide by oxygen in the presence of iron pentacarbonyl. J. Chem. Phys. 57:807. Matsuda, S. (1972b). Gas phase homogeneous catalysis in shock waves. III. The oxidation of carbon monoxide by oxygen in the presence of nickel carbonyl. J. Phys. Chem. 76:2833. McDowell, R. S. (1971). Metal carbonyl vapors: Rapid quantitative analysis by infrared spectrophotometry. Am. Ind. Hyg. Assoc. J. 32:621. McLean, I. C., Smith, D. B., and Taylor, S. C. (1994). The use of carbon monoxide/hydrogen burning velocities to examine the rate of the CO + OH reaction. Proc. Combust. Inst. 25:749. Mertens, J. D., Kalitan, D. M., Barrett, A. B., and Petersen, E. L. (2009). Determination of the rate of H + O2 + M → HO2 + M (M = N2, Ar, H2O) from ignition of syngas at practical conditions. Proc. Combust. Inst. 32:295. Mertens, J. D., Mussmann, S. S., Kalitan, D. M., and Petersen, E. L. (2008). A chemical kinetics model for the fast ignition of syngas at lower temperatures and higher pressures. Paper 08S-3 presented at spring meeting of the Western States Section of the Combustion Institute, Los Angeles, March. Meyer, J. W., and Oppenheim, A. K. (1970). On the shock induced ignition of explosive gases. Proc. Combust. Symp. 13:1153. Michael, J. V., and Sutherland, J. W. (1986). The thermodynamic state of the hot gas behind reflected shock waves: Implications to chemical kinetics. Int. J. Chem. Kinet. 18:409. Michael, J. V., Su, M. C., Sutherland, J. W., Carroll, J. J., and Wagner, A. F. (2002). Rate constants for H + O2 + M → HO2 +M in seven bath gases. J. Phys. Chem. A 106:5297. Michael, J. V., Sutherland, J. W., Harding, L. B., and Wagner, A. F. (2000). Initiation in H2/O2: Rate constants for H2 + O2 → H + HO2 at high temperature. Proc. Combust. Inst. 28:1471. Mittal, G., Chaos, M., Sung, C.-J., and Dryer, F. L. (2008). Dimethyl ether autoignition in a rapid compression machine: Experiments and chemical kinetic modeling. Fuel. Process. Technol. 89:1244. Mittal, G., Sung, C.-J., Fairweather, M., Tomlin, A. S., Griffiths, J. F., and Hughes, K. J. (2007). Significance of the HO2+CO reaction during the combustion of CO+H2 mixtures at high pressures. Proc. Combust. Inst. 31:419. Mittal, G., Sung, C.-J., and Yetter, R. A. (2006). Autoignition of H2/CO at elevated pressures in a rapid compression machine. Int. J. Chem. Kinet. 38:516. Mueller, M. A., Kim, T. J., Yetter, R. A. and Dryer, F. L. (1999a). Flow reactor studies and kinetic modeling of the H2/O2 reaction. Int. J. Chem. Kinet. 31:113. Mueller, M. A., Yetter, R. A., and Dryer, F. L. (1996a). Explosion limit behavior of dilute hydrogen–oxygen mixtures from 0.3 to 3.0 atm and 850 to 950 K. Paper presented at fall meeting of the Eastern States Section of the Combustion Institute, Hilton Head Island, SC, December. Mueller, M. A., Yetter, R. A., and Dryer, F. L. (1999b). Flow reactor studies and kinetic modeling of the H2/O2/NOX and CO/H2O/O2/NOX reactions. Int. J. Chem. Kinet. 31:705. Mueller, M. A., Yetter, R. A., and Dryer, F. L. (1998). Measurement of the rate constant for H + O2 + M → HO2 + M (M = N2, Ar) using kinetic modeling of the high-pressure H2/O2/NOX reaction. Proc. Combust. Inst. 27:177.
68
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Mueller, M. A., Yetter, R. A., and Dryer, F. L. (2000). Kinetic modeling of the CO/H2O/O2/ NO/SO2 system: Implications for high-pressure fall-off in the SO2 + O (+M) = SO3 (+M) reaction. Int. J. Chem. Kinet. 32:317. Myrstad, T., and Fredriksen, G. R. (1998). Removal of Fe(CO)5 from CO gas as detected by FTIR spectroscopy. Chem. Eng. Technol. 21:297. Natarajan, J., Kochar, Y., Lieuwen, T., and Seitzman, J. (2009). Pressure and preheat dependence of laminar flame speeds of H2/CO/CO2/O2/He mixtures. Proc. Combust. Inst. 32:1261. Natarajan, J., Lieuwen, T., and Seitzman, J. (2007). Laminar flame speeds of H2/CO mixtures: Effect of CO2 dilution, preheat temperature, and pressure. Combust. Flame 151:104. O’Connaire, M., Curran, H. J., Simmie, J. M., Pitz, W. J., and Westbrook, C. K. (2004). A comprehensive modeling study of hydrogen oxidation. Int. J. Chem. Kinet. 36:603. Oppenheim, A. K. (1985). Dynamic features of combustion. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. A 315:471. Pang, G. A., Davidson, D. F., and Hanson, R. K. (2009). Experimental study and modeling of shock tube ignition delay times for hydrogen–oxygen–argon mixtures at low temperatures. Proc. Combust. Inst. 32:181. Peeters, J., and Mahnen, G. (1973). Reaction mechanisms and rate constants of elementary steps in methane-oxygen flames. Proc. Combust. Inst. 14:133. Peschke, W. T., and Spadaccini, L. J. (1985). Determination of autoignition and flame speed characteristics of coal gases having medium heating values. Report EPRI AP-4291, Electric Power Research Institute. Petersen, E. L., and Hanson, R. K. (2001). Nonideal effects behind reflected shock waves in a high-pressure shcok tube. Shock Waves 10:405. Petersen, E. L., Kalitan, D. M., Barrett, A. B., Reehal, S. C., Mertens, J. D., Beerer, D. J., Hack, R. L., and McDonell, V. G. (2007a). New syngas/air ignition data at lower temperature and elevated pressure and comparison to current kinetics models. Combust. Flame 149:244. Petersen, E. L., Lamnaouer, M., de Vries, J., Curran, H. J., Simmie, J., Fikri, M., Schulz, C., and Bourque, G. (2007b). Discrepancies between shock-tube and rapid compression machine ignition at low temperatures and high pressures. Paper P911 presented at Proceedings of the 26th International Symposium on Shock Waves, Göttingen, Germany, July. Rao, K. M., Spoto, G., Guglielminotti, E., and Zecchina, A. (1989). IR investigation of Fe(CO)5 adducts at the surface of silicalite, ZSM-5, zeolite Y, and γ-Al2O3. Inorg. Chem. 28:243. Rasmussen C. L., Hansen, J., Marshall, P., and Glarborg, P. (2008). Experimental measurements and kinetic modeling of CO/H2/O2/NO, conversion at high pressure. Int. J. Chem. Kinet. 40:454. Reehal, S. C., Kalitan, D. M., Hair, T., Barrett, A. B., and Petersen, E. L. (2007). Ignition delay time measurements of synthesis gas mixtures at engine pressures. Paper C24 presented at Proceedings of the 5th U.S. Combustion Meeting, San Diego. Reinelt, D., and Linteris, G. T. (1996). Experimental study of the inhibition of premixed and diffusion flames by iron pentacarbonyl. Proc. Combust. Inst. 26:1421. Rezaiyan, J., and Chereminisoff, N. P. (2005). Gasification technologies: A primer for engineers and scientists. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. Rozenshtein, V. B., Gershenzon, Yu. M., Il’in, S. D., and Kishkovjtch, O. P. (1984). Reactions of HO2 with NO, OH and HO2 studied by EPR/LMR spectroscopy. Chem. Phys. Lett. 112:473. Rumminger, M. D., and Linteris, G. T. (2000). Inhibition of premixed carbon monoxidehydrogen–oxygen–nitrogen flames by iron pentacarbonyl. Combust. Flame 120:451. Rumminger, M. D., and Linteris, G. T. (2002). The role of particles in the inhibition of counterflow diffusion flames by iron pentacarbonyl. Combust. Flame 128:145. Rumminger, M. D., Reinelt, D., Babushok, V., and Linteris, G. T. (1999). Numerical study of the inhibition of premixed and diffusion flames by iron pentacarbonyl. Combust. Flame 116:207.
Syngas Chemical Kinetics and Reaction Mechanisms
69
Sellevåg, S. R., Georgievskii, Y., and Miller, J. A. (2008). The temperature and pressure dependence of the reactions H + O2 (+M) → HO2 (+M) and H + OH (+M) → H2O (+M). J. Phys. Chem. A 112:5085. Shen, H.-P. S., Vanderover, J., and Oehlschlaeger, M. A. (2009). A shock tube study of the auto-ignition of toluene/air mixtures at high pressures. Proc. Combust. Inst. 32:165. Sivaramakrishnan, R., Comandini, A., Tranter, R. S., Brezinsky, K., Davis, S. G., and Wang, H. (2007). Combustion of CO/H2 mixtures at elevated pressures. Proc. Combust. Inst. 31:429. Slack, M. W. (1977). Rate coefficient for H + O2 + M = HO2 + M evaluated from shock tube measurements of induction times. Combust. Flame 28:241. Snyder, A. D., Robertson, J., Zanders, D. L., and Skinner, G. B. (1965). Shock tube studies of fuel–air ignition characteristics. Report AFAPL-TR-65-93, Air Force Aeropropulsion Lab, Wright-Patterson. Sridharan, U. C., Qiu, L. X., and Kaufman, F. (1984). Rate constant of the OH + HO2 reaction from 252 to 420 K. J. Phys. Chem. 88:1281. Srinivasan, N. K., and Michael, J. V. (2006). The thermal decomposition of water. Int. J. Chem. Kinet. 38:211. Srinivasan, N. K., Su, M.-C, Sutherland, J. W., Michael, J. V., and Ruscic, B. (2006). Reflected shock tube studies of high-temperature rate constants for OH + NO2 → HO2 + NO and OH + HO2 → H2O + O2. J. Phys. Chem. A 110:6602. Strehlow, R. A., and Cohen, A. (1962). Initiation of detonation. Phys. Fluids 5:97. Ströhle, J., and Myhrvold, T. (2007). An evaluation of detailed reaction mechanisms for hydrogen combustion under gas turbine conditions. Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 32:125. Sun, H. Y., Yang, S. I., Jomaas, G., and Law, C. K. (2007). High-pressure laminar flame speeds and kinetic modeling of carbon monoxide/hydrogen combustion. Proc. Combust. Inst. 31:439. Sung, C.-J., and Law, C. K. (2008). Fundamental combustion properties of H2/CO mixtures: Ignition and flame propagation at elevated pressures. Combust. Sci. Tech. 180:1097. Tepe, R. K., Vassallo, D., Jacksier, T., and Barnes, R. M. (1999). Iron pentacarbonyl determination in carbon monoxide. Spectrochim. Acta B 54:1861. Terao, K. (1977). Explosion limits of hydrogen–oxygen mixtures as a stochastic phenomenon. Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 16:29. Troe, J. (2000). Detailed modeling of the temperature and pressure dependence of the reaction H + O2 (+M) → HO2 (+M). Proc. Combust. Inst. 28:1463. Troe J. and Ushakov, V. G. (2001). Theoretical studies of the HO + O ↔ HO2 ↔ H + O2 reaction. II. Classical trajectory calculations on an ab initio potential for temperatures between 300 and 5000 K. J. Chem. Phys. 115:3621. Tse, S. D., Zhu, D. L., and Law, C. K. (2000). Morphology and burning fluxes of expanding spherical flames in H2/O2/inert mixtures up to 60 atmospheres. Proc. Combust. Inst. 28:1793. Vanpee, M., and Shirodkar, P. P. (1978). Study of flame inhibition by metal compounds. Proc. Combust. Inst. 17:787. Voevodsky, V. V., and Soloukhin, R. I. (1965). On the mechanism and explosion limits of hydrogen–oxygen chain self-ignition in shock waves. Proc. Combust. Inst. 10:279. von Elbe, G., and Lewis, B. (1942). Mechanism of the thermal reaction between hydrogen and oxygen. J. Chem. Phys. 10:366. Walton, S. M., He, X., Zigler, B. T., and Wooldridge, M. S. (2007a). An experimental investigation of the ignition properties of hydrogen and carbon monoxide mixtures for syngas turbine applications. Proc. Combust. Inst. 31:3147. Walton, S. M., He, X., Zigler, B. T., and Wooldridge, M. S. (2007b). An experimental investigation of iso-octane ignition phenomena. Combust. Flame. 150:246. Wang, B. L., Olivier, H., and Grönig, H. (2003). Ignition of shock-heated H2-air-steam mixtures. Combust. Flame 133:93.
70
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Wang, H., You, X., Joshi, A. V., Davis, S. G., Laskin, A., Egolfopoulos, F., and Law, C. K. (2007). USC Mech Version II: High-temperature combustion reaction model of H2/CO/ C1-C4 compounds, http://ignis.usc.edu/USC_mech_II.htm (accessed May 2007). Westbrook, C. K., and Dryer, F. L. (1984). Chemical kinetics modeling of hydrocarbon combustion. Prog. Energ. Combust. Sci. 10:1. Williams, T. C., and Shaddix, C. R. (2007). Contamination of carbon monoxide with metal carbonyls: Implications for combustion research. Combust. Sci. Tech. 175:1225. Yetter, R. A., Dryer, F. L., and Rabitz, H. (1991a). A comprehensive reaction mechanism for carbon monoxide/hydrogen/oxygen kinetics. Combust. Sci. Tech. 79:97. Yetter, R. A., Dryer, F. L., and Rabitz, H. (1991b). Flow reactor studies of carbon monoxide/ hydrogen/oxygen kinetics. Combust. Sci. Tech. 79:129. You, X., Wang, H., Goos, E., Sung, C. J., and Klippenstein, S. J. (2007). Reaction kinetics of CO + HO2 → products: Ab initio transition state theory study with master equation modeling. J. Phys. Chem. A 111:4031. Zhao, Z., Li, J., Kazakov, A., and Dryer, F. L. (2005). Temperature-dependent feature sensitivity analysis for combustion modeling. Int. J. Chem. Kinet. 37:282. Zheng, X. L., and Law, C. K. (2004). Ignition of premixed hydrogen/air by heated counterflow under reduced and elevated pressures. Combust. Flame 136:168.
Flame Properties 3 Laminar of H /CO Mixtures 2
Jayaprakash Natarajan and Jerry M. Seitzman Contents 3.1 Introduction..................................................................................................... 71 3.2 Premixed Flame Properties............................................................................. 72 3.2.1 Adiabatic Flame Temperature............................................................. 72 3.2.2 Flame Structure and Flame Thickness................................................ 74 3.2.3 Flame Propagation...............................................................................80 3.2.3.1 H2/CO Ratio.......................................................................... 81 3.2.3.2 Pressure................................................................................. 81 3.2.3.3 Preheat Temperature............................................................. 86 3.2.3.4 Diluents................................................................................. 88 3.2.3.5 Flame Stretch........................................................................90 3.2.4 Flame Extinction.................................................................................92 3.3 Nonpremixed Flame Properties....................................................................... 95 3.4 Conclusions......................................................................................................96 References.................................................................................................................96
3.1 Introduction Laminar flames represent an excellent starting point for understanding syngas flame properties. Moreover, knowledge of laminar flame properties is essential to understanding the behavior of turbulent flames. Finally, various computational tools used to design an efficient fuel-flexible combustor require an understanding of the fundamental combustion properties of these mixtures, such as flame temperature, laminar flame speed, strain sensitivity, and extinction strain rates. Thus, this chapter provides an overview of laminar flame properties of syngas fuel mixtures, primarily with air as the oxidizer. We begin with premixed laminar flames, where fuel and oxidizer are well mixed before reaching the flame. In particular, the first section emphasizes the structure and propagation characteristics (that is, flame speed) for syngas flames. Because the operating environment for syngas fuels can range from atmospheric burners for process heating to gas turbine engines, this section also describes the dependence of the premixed flame properties on mixture composition, pressure, and preheat temperature. The effects of strain on flame propagation are also discussed briefly, including the influence of H2 on the extinction
71
72
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
characteristics of CO and CH4 flames. Finally, we describe some important attributes of nonpremixed laminar syngas flames.
3.2 Premixed Flame Properties 3.2.1 Adiabatic Flame Temperature The first parameter of interest is the adiabatic flame temperature (Tad ). It is defined as the equilibrium temperature of the products when the reactants are burned at constant pressure without any heat transfer to or from the surroundings. In flames, reactants are converted to products essentially at constant pressure; thus, the maximum temperature of the flame is typically close to the adiabatic flame temperature in the absence of nonunity Lewis number, differential diffusion, and strain effects (Law and Sung, 2000). Flame temperature is an important parameter for a number of reasons; for example, NOX production is highly sensitive to temperature through the thermal (Zeldovich) mechanism, which tends to dominate NOX production beyond about 1800 K. Moreover, flame temperature also has a significant influence on flame propagation and extinction. Figure 3.1 compares the adiabatic flame temperatures for different pure fuel gases (CH4, H2, and CO) and a nominal syngas fuel mixture (35% H2, 35% CO, and 30% CO2). Of the three pure fuels, CO has the highest flame temperature for a given equivalence ratio, while CH4 has the lowest. For a lean mixture with equivalence ratio Φ = 0.6, the CO flame temperature is around 300 K higher than that of CH4 and the differences are even greater for rich mixtures. Methane-air mixtures have lower flame temperatures than CO and H2, because CH4 requires four times more oxidizer (on a molar basis) to achieve a stoichiometric mixture. For an undiluted oxidizer (e.g., pure O2), the CH4 flame temperatures are much closer to those of the other fuels.
Adiabatic Flame Temperature Tad (K)
2500
CH4 H2 CO Syngas
1.25 1.06
2300
1.04
2100
1.04
1900 1700 1500
0.5
0.75
1
1.25
1.5
1.75
2
Equivalence Ratio Ф
Figure 3.1 Adiabatic flame temperatures for CH4, H2, CO, and typical syngas (35% H2, 35% CO, and 30% CO2) fuels and air at atmospheric pressure and 300 K initial temperature.
73
Laminar Flame Properties of H2 /CO Mixtures
Though both CO and H2 require the same amount of oxidizer for a given equivalence ratio, the CO flame temperature is slightly higher than for H2 owing to the higher molar heating value of CO. At Φ = 0.6, the CO flame temperature is around 130 K greater than Tad for hydrogen. This difference is greatly reduced as the mixture nears stoichiometric conditions, since the higher temperatures there lead to reduced CO2 levels, and therefore less heat release associated with the additional fuel. The chosen syngas mixture’s flame temperature is lower than that for either pure H2 or CO due to the significant amount of diluent in the syngas fuel. For the 30% CO2 dilution considered here, the flame temperature is similar to that for the CH4 flame (within ~100 K) over the range of practical equivalence ratios. Thus, we see that undiluted syngas mixtures would have higher temperatures than conventional methane (or natural gas) fuel, while syngas compositions with typical levels of dilution will have flame temperatures closer to those encountered in natural gas combustion. For all the fuels shown in Figure 3.1, the peak Tad occurs at slightly fuel-rich conditions. This can be explained by considering the balance between the energy required to raise the product temperature (characterized by the specific heat of the combustion products) and the amount of heat release, which is reduced by the extent of product dissociation (Law, 2006). For these fuels, the trade-off leads to the peak Tad occurring at slightly less rich conditions (Φ ≅ 1.04 for CH4, 1.06 for H2, and 1.25 for CO flames) than the peak heat release point. For the diluted syngas fuel, the peak adiabatic flame temperature occurs at a lower equivalence ratio than for the pure CO or H2 flames. This is mainly due to the lower stoichiometric Tad, which reduces the extent of product dissociation. Apart from fuel and oxidizer composition, other factors that influence adiabatic flame temperature include pressure and (initial) reactant temperature (Tu). Figure 3.2 highlights the effect of pressure on adiabatic flame temperature for the nominal
Adiabatic Flame Temperature Tad (K)
2500 1.1 2300
1.02
p = 1 atm; Tu = 300 K p = 30 atm; Tu = 300 K p = 1 atm; Tu = 700 K
1.04
2100
1900
1700
1500 0.5
0.75
1 1.25 1.5 Equivalence Ratio Ф
1.75
2
Figure 3.2 Influence of pressure and preheat temperature on adiabatic flame temperatures for typical syngas (35% H2, 35% CO, and 30% CO2) fuel burning with air.
74
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
syngas fuel mixture. As the pressure increases from 1 to 30 atm (for a fixed Tu), there is no significant change in adiabatic flame temperature, except for a small increase (~50 K) near stoichiometric conditions. The temperature rise is associated with the high-pressure suppression of product dissociation, which is an issue only in the region of high Tad (e.g., near Φ ≅ 1). The suppression of product dissociation also tends to shift the peak flame temperature toward Φ = 1. The influence of reactant temperature on adiabatic flame temperature is also evident in Figure 3.2. The adiabatic flame temperature increases with reactant temperature, and the rise in Tad decreases as the reactant mixture approaches stoichiometric. For the case considered here, the increase in reactant temperature by 400 K (from room temperature to 700 K) causes Tad to increase by ~300 K at Φ ≅ 0.5 and 2.0, but only by ~200 K for Φ near 1. Higher levels of product dissociation at the high temperatures associated with near stoichiometric conditions lower the energy available to raise the product temperature; thus, there is a lower temperature increase there. More product dissociation with higher initial reactant temperatures also shifts the peak Tad to richer mixtures. As shown in Figure 3.2 for the nominal syngas fuel composition, the peak in Tad moves from Φ ≅ 1.04 for room temperature reactants to Φ ≅ 1.1 for the preheated reactants.
3.2.2 Flame Structure and Flame Thickness In order to understand laminar flame propagation in syngas mixtures, it is important to have a picture of the premixed syngas flame structure. The detailed structure of a one-dimensional, premixed laminar flame can be faithfully simulated using the steady-state mass, species, and energy conservation equations, state equations, and a comprehensive reaction mechanism for the fuel and oxidizer of interest. For the results presented here, we employ the freely propagating flame code, Chemkin PREMIX (Kee et al., 2006), which includes a detailed package to evaluate the transport (diffusive) properties for complex gas mixtures. There are a number of detailed chemical reaction mechanisms that include the fundamental H2/CO kinetics (see Chapter 2); for the numerical results presented here, a detailed C1 mechanism (Li et al., 2007) is used. The chemical structure of a syngas flame significantly changes with the amount of H2 in the fuel mixture, owing to the widely different kinetic and transport properties of H2 and CO. For example, we consider two lean syngas mixtures: one with very low H2 content (5% by mole) and the other with a medium level of H2 (50%). The simulations are performed for undiluted mixtures at room temperature and pressure. Figure 3.3 shows the profiles of temperature and heat release rate associated with key exothermic reactions along the flame coordinate for the low H2 case. The main heat release reaction here is CO + OH ↔ CO2 + H. In the absence of any hydrogen in the reactants (which can lead to OH production), CO oxidation is rather slow. The heat release rate profile of this CO + OH reaction is very broad; it starts at a temperature of around 800 K, peaks around 1300 K, and continues until the final flame temperature is reached. Notably, this reaction is also the main source for H atoms produced in the flame zone (McLean et al., 1994).
75
Laminar Flame Properties of H2 /CO Mixtures 2.5
1800
H + O2(+M) = HO2(+M) HO2 + O = O2 + OH
2.0
1500
H2 + OH = H2O + H
Temperature
CO + O(+M) = CO2(+M)
1.5
Total heat release rate/2
CO + OH = CO2 + H
1200
1.0
900
0.5
600
0.0
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
Temperature (K)
Heat Release Rate (10–9erg/cm3s)
HO2 + H = OH + OH
300
Flame Coordinate (cm)
Figure 3.3 Chemical structure of a lean (Φ = 0.6) H2/CO fuel mixture with 5% mole fraction of H2 at p = 1 atm and Tu = 300 K.
The H atoms produced in the flame zone diffuse upstream into the incoming reactant mixture. There, the H atoms react with O2 to form the hydroperoxyl radical, HO2, through the three-body radical termination reaction H + O2(+M) ↔ HO2(+M). As shown in Figure 3.3, this reaction is also one of the main heat release reactions in the leading edge of the flame. The HO2, which is relatively stable at low temperatures, reacts with H and O atoms to produce a pool of OH radicals as the reactants move into the flame zone. These OH radicals attack CO and convert it to CO2, thus completing the cycle. The other significant route for CO oxidation is through the reaction CO + O(+M) ↔ CO2(+M). The importance of this reaction is drastically reduced as the amount of H2 in the fuel mixture increases beyond 15 to 20%. The main H2 oxidation reaction (H2 + OH ↔ H2O + H) has little direct contribution to the overall heat release; yet it is still an important reaction as it competes for OH radicals with the main CO oxidation reaction in low H2 content syngas flames. Figure 3.4 presents the corresponding profiles of temperature and heat release rate for a lean syngas fuel mixture with a medium (50%) level of H2. Since the equivalence ratio is the same as that used for the low H2 simulation, the flame temperature is only slightly lower. The first notable difference between the low and medium H2 cases is that the overall heat release rate increases by a factor of 4, owing to the higher reactivity of H2 compared to CO. This higher reactivity, combined with the higher diffusivity of H2 compared to CO, results in an increase in flame propagation speed as H2 levels rise in a syngas fuel.
76
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications 9.0
Total heat release rate/2
1800
Temperature
1500 H + O2(+M) = HO2(+M)
6.0
HO2 + H = OH + OH H2 + OH = H2O + H
4.5
1200
CO + OH = CO2 + H H + OH (+M) = H2O(+M)
900
Temperature (K)
Heat Release Rate (10–9erg/cm3s)
7.5
3.0 600
1.5
0.0 0.05
0.075
0.1 0.125 0.15 Flame Coordinate (cm)
0.175
300 0.2
Figure 3.4 Chemical structure of a lean (Φ = 0.6) H2/CO fuel mixture with 50% mole fraction of H2 at p = 1 atm and Tu = 300 K.
Another important difference can be observed by comparing the temperature profiles with the overall heat release rate profiles (see Figures 3.3 and 3.4). For the medium H2 case, the overall heat release starts earlier, where the temperature is closer to the initial reactant temperature. In other words, the thickness of the nominal preheat zone decreases as H2 levels rise in syngas fuel mixtures. Looking at the contribution from individual exothermic reactions, this early rise in heat release is mainly due to the contribution of the H atom termination reaction H + O2(+M) ↔ HO2(+M). This reaction is also the dominant heat release reaction throughout most of the reaction zone, with a peak in its heat release rate when the temperature has risen to ~900 K (it is surpassed by the CO2 and H2O formation reactions (CO + OH and H + OH + M) only after most of the heat release has occurred). To better understand the balance between different reactions, consider the production and destruction of H atoms. There is a significant amount of H atom production in the later stage of the flame, through the main H2 and CO oxidation reactions H2 + OH and CO + OH, respectively. These two reactions dominate H atom production, as opposed to the low H2 case where CO + OH ↔ CO2 + H was the only significant source of H atoms. Similar to the low H2 case, the produced H atoms diffuse back to the incoming (cold) reactants. There they react with O2 to form HO2, causing a sharp rise in HO2 concentration in the early part of the flame. Recall that this reaction is highly exothermic and consumes H atoms. The HO2 reacts further, with H atoms, and produces two OH radicals (i.e., HO2 + H ↔ OH + OH), again consuming more H atoms in the early part of the flame. Then the produced pool of OH radicals attacks H2 and CO to form more H atoms in the later portion of the flame, and thus complete
77
Laminar Flame Properties of H2 /CO Mixtures Φ = 0.6 Φ = 0.8 Φ = 1.0 Φ = 2.0
Flame Thickness, δf (µm)
1000
750
500
250
0
20
40
% H2
60
80
100
Figure 3.5 Laminar flame thickness from simulations for a range of H2/CO fuel mixtures at p = 1 atm and Tu = 300 K.
the cycle. This medium H2 content syngas flame structure is very similar to that for pure H2 flames (Law, 2006), where the reactions occurs through the entire flame zone, which can be split into H atom consumption and H production layers, and there is no preheat zone as such. This is in contrast to conventional CH4-air flames, where the majority of the heat release reactions occur in the later regions of the flame, only after the temperature has risen significantly. Hence, it is clear that the relative thickness of the reaction zone to the diffusional (preheat) zone thickness increases as the amount of H2 increases in the fuel mixture. Also, the amount of H2 in the fuel mixture has significant influence on the overall flame thickness. We can define the overall flame thickness (δf ) based on the temperature gradient, that is, δf = ∆T/∇Tmax, the ratio of the temperature rise in the flame to the maximum temperature gradient (Law and Sung, 2000). Figure 3.5 shows that the flame becomes much thinner as the level of H2 in the syngas fuel increases. Generally, flame thickness can be considered a function of the diffusive and chemical rates of the mixture, that is,
δ f ∝ ρα RR ,
where ρ is the density of the mixture, α is the thermal diffusivity, and RR is the overall reaction rate (Glassman, 1996). The increase in the overall reaction rate with the amount of H2 is greater than the increase in diffusivity, resulting in an overall decrease in flame thickness. Similarly, an increase in equivalence ratio can also cause the flame thickness to decrease. Another parameter that has a key influence on flame thickness is pressure. Figure 3.6 shows the variation of flame thickness with pressure for three (lean,
78
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Φ = 0.6 Φ = 1.0 Φ = 2.0
1.5
1.2 0.9
100 0.6
pδf (atm mm)
Flame Thickness, δf (µm)
1000
0.3 10
0
10
20
30
0 40
Pressure (atm)
Figure 3.6 Pressure dependence of laminar flame thickness (solid lines) and pressureflame thickness product (dashed lines) from simulations for a 50:50 H2/CO fuel mixture at Tu = 300 K.
stoichiometric, and rich) 50% H2 syngas fuel mixtures. In all cases, the flame thickness decreases monotonically with pressure. The influence of pressure on flame thickness is drastic at lower pressures but reduced at elevated pressures, with leaner flames exhibiting a greater decline in pressure dependence. As noted above, the flame thickness can be modeled as
δ f ∝ ρα RR .
Since ρα is nearly insensitive to pressure and the reaction rate normally increases with pressure, the flame thickness generally decreases with pressure. Figure 3.6 also shows the variation of the pressure-flame thickness product (pδf ) with pressure. The intent is to compare the relative decrease in flame thickness with pressure at different equivalence ratios. As seen in the figure, pδf is roughly constant for stoichiometric mixtures, with a weak minimum near 5 atm. The rich (Φ = 2) mixture produces a similar result. Thus, we find that the drop in flame thickness is nearly proportional to pressure (i.e., δf ∝ 1/p) for the stoichiometric and rich flames. On the other hand, pδf increases with pressure for the lean mixture, indicating that the flame thickness is a weaker function of pressure for lean mixtures. Above 10 atm, the increase in pδf for the Φ = 0.6 case is nearly linear, i.e., pδf ∝ p, indicating δf ~ constant. Figure 3.7 highlights the influence of H2 level on the variation of flame thickness with pressure. As shown, the decrease in flame thickness is slightly more significant for high H2 mixtures, especially at lower pressure ranges. The influence of preheat temperature on flame thickness of syngas fuels is seen in Figure 3.8, which shows the variation of δf for 300 < Tu < 700 K for a 50:50 H2/CO
79
Laminar Flame Properties of H2 /CO Mixtures 1.8
H2 = 20% H2 = 50% H2 = 80%
1.5 1.2
100 0.9
pδf (atm mm)
Flame Thickness, δf (µm)
1000
0.6 10
0
10
20 Pressure (atm)
30
0.3 40
Figure 3.7 Pressure dependence of laminar flame thickness (solid lines) and pressureflame thickness product (dashed lines) from simulations for three H2/CO fuel mixtures at Φ = 0.6 and Tu = 300 K.
700
Φ = 0.6 Φ = 0.8
Flame Thickness, δf (µm)
Φ = 1.0 600
Φ = 2.0
500
400
300 300
400
500 600 Preheat Temperature Tu (K)
700
Figure 3.8 Laminar flame thickness as a function of preheat temperature from simulations for four 50:50 H2/CO fuel–air mixtures at p = 1 atm.
fuel mixture. In general, the flame thickness increases with preheat temperature, in a roughly linear manner. For the leanest (Φ = 0.6) mixture, the reactant temperature has a small effect below ~450 K. Though the increase in preheat temperature increases the overall reaction rate, which tends to decrease the flame thickness,
80
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
the increase in thermal and mass diffusivities with preheat temperature dominates, hence the increase in flame thickness.
3.2.3 Flame Propagation The fundamental parameter that characterizes flame propagation in a premixed reactant mixture is the laminar flame speed (SL). Since a stationary flame is achieved when the local flow velocity normal to the flame equals the flame speed, SL is relevant to determining blow-off and flashback velocities of a burner (Zhang et al., 2007), as well as other burner parameters, such as quenching diameter. Apart from the utility of flame speed information in the design of fuel-flexible syngas combustion systems, SL is also a useful parameter for validating and optimizing chemical kinetic models. Extensive research has been performed to characterize the laminar flame speed for syngas-type fuel mixtures at a variety of operating conditions, as it is strongly influenced by reactant mixture composition, pressure, and preheat temperature. Laminar burning velocities for near-stoichiometric and fuel-rich CO/H 2 mixtures have been measured with conical flames stabilized with Mach Hebra nozzle burners (Scholte and Vaags, 1959), Bunsen burners (Günther and Janisch, 1971), spherically expanding flames (Strauss and Edse, 1958), and flat flames (Yumlu, 1967). In early flame speed studies, the effect of flame stretch (see Section 3.2.3.5) on the measured flame speed was not considered. In later studies, the stretch-corrected measurements of laminar flame speed and its strain sensitivity for H2/CO fuel mixtures were obtained in counterflow flames (Vagelopoulos and Egolfopoulos, 1994) and spherically expanding flames (McLean et al., 1994; Brown et al., 1996; Hassan et al., 1996, 1997; Sun et al., 2006). Vagelopoulos and Egolfopoulos (1994) and McLean et al. (1994) reported laminar flame speeds for H2/CO mixtures for a range of H2/CO and equivalence ratios. These stretch-corrected measurements are primarily for atmospheric pressure, though there are exceptions. Hassan et al. (1996, 1997) measured the laminar flame speed and Markstein length in spherically expanding flames at 4 atm for H2/CO fuel mixtures with only 5% H2. They reported that the onset of severe instabilities restricts the flame speed measurements for high H2 content mixtures even at a few atmospheres. In order to overcome these flame instabilities, Sun et al. (2006) used O2/He as an oxidizer rather than standard air and reported flame speed information for H2/CO fuel mixtures up to 10 atm for fuels containing up to 50% H2, and up to 40 atm for mixtures with 5% H2. Also, all the above data (both at atmospheric and elevated pressure) for H2/CO fuel mixtures are restricted to room temperature reactants. Laminar flame speeds of H2/CO mixtures have been reported for a range of reactant preheat temperatures (up to 700 K) and fuel compositions at both atmospheric (Natarajan et al., 2007a, 2007b, 2008b) and elevated (up to 15 atm) (Natarajan et al., 2008a, 2009) pressure conditions. These more recent studies not only include the influence of diluents such as CO2 and N2, but also focus on the lean mixtures relevant to many low emissions combustors. This section summarizes the findings of these studies, including the general influence of (1) H2/CO ratio, (2) pressure, (3) preheat temperature, (4) dilution, and (5) flame stretch on the laminar flame speed of syngas fuel mixtures. Many of these
Laminar Flame Properties of H2 /CO Mixtures
81
effects can be qualitatively modeled with a simplified analysis of a flame based on a balance between heat release and diffusion (Glassman, 1996). From this model, the flame speed can be modeled as
SL ∝
α ⋅ RR ρ
(3.1)
where α is the thermal diffusivity, RR is the overall reaction rate, and ρ is the unburned gas density. 3.2.3.1 H2/CO Ratio We begin by examining the influence of H2 level in the syngas fuel on laminar flame speed. The results again are based on simulations with Chemkin PREMIX. As shown in Figure 3.9, the flame speed increases as more H2 is added to the fuel. This is not due to changes in flame temperature, as Tad changes only slightly with H2 level, as noted above. The SL behavior is explained by the simple flame speed model presented in Equation 3.1: (1) the overall reactivity of the fuel mixture increases with the amount of H2, as illustrated in the flame structure description (Section 3.2.2), and (2) the low molecular weight of hydrogen acts to increase the diffusivity of the reactant mixture. Interestingly, the increase in flame speed is slightly more pronounced for low H2 amounts; the flame speed increases more rapidly as the amount of H2 increases to 15%. This is mainly due to the sensitivity of the CO oxidation rate to the presence of small amounts of hydrogen-containing species. As pointed out in the flame structure discussion, the main CO oxidation reaction shifts from the slower CO + O(+M) reaction to the relatively faster CO + OH reaction as the amount of H2 increases. The higher reaction rates result in the rapid increase in flame speed. For higher levels of H2, for example, >20%, there is still an increase in flame speed, partly due to higher diffusivities, though the sensitivity to H2 is reduced. Above ~60 to 70% H2 for the lean mixtures (Figure 3.9a), the sensitivity of the flame speed to H2 content slightly increases again. 3.2.3.2 Pressure The influence of pressure on SL is presented in Figure 3.10, based on simulations for a 50:50 H2/CO fuel mixture at lean to rich conditions, with the results normalized by the laminar flame speed at 1 atm. The laminar flame speed decreases nearly logarithmically with pressure (as indicated by the curve fits in the figure). The increase in pressure raises the overall reaction rate (RR), as molecular collision rates rise with pressure. Hence, higher pressures would tend to produce faster laminar flame speeds (see Equation 3.1). On the other hand, the increased density of the reactant mixture necessitates more thermal energy transfer from the reaction zone to raise the reactant temperature in the preheat zone. Since thermal diffusivity (α) is also inversely proportional to pressure, the net effect of increasing pressure is a reduced flame speed. Flame temperature changes with pressure are relatively small at these conditions (as noted previously), so flame temperature effects do not greatly influence the SL
82
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
160
Φ = 0.6 Φ = 0.8
Flame Speed (cm/s)
120
80
40
0
0
300
20
40
% H2 (a)
60
80
100
60
80
100
Φ = 1.0 Φ = 2.0
Flame Speed (cm/s)
240 180 120 60 0
0
20
40
% H2 (b)
Figure 3.9 Laminar flame speeds from simulations for a range of H2/CO fuel mixtures for (a) lean and (b) stoichiometric and rich cases, at p = 1 atm and Tu = 300 K.
pressure dependence. Unlike the flame thickness variations (see Figure 3.6), the drop in flame speed with pressure is slightly more pronounced for lean mixtures than for stoichiometric conditions. Also shown in Figure 3.10 is the variation of normalized mass burning rate (or equivalently for a one-dimensional flame, the mass flux = ρuSL ) with pressure. The
83
Laminar Flame Properties of H2 /CO Mixtures
SL/SL,atm
0.75
9
0.5
6
0.25
0
(ρuSL)/(ρuSL)atm
15 Φ = 0.6 Φ = 1.0 Φ = 2.0 12
1
3
1
10 Pressure (atm)
0 100
Figure 3.10 Laminar flame speed (solid lines) and mass burning rate (dashed lines) as a function of pressure for a 50:50 H2/CO fuel mixture at Tu = 300 K (symbols = simulations, lines = curve fits).
mass burning rate specifies the reactant consumption rate, and therefore the flame’s heat release rate (Watts or BTU/s). As opposed to SL , the mass burning rate rises with pressure, as the increase in reactant density is greater than the decrease in flame speed. The increase in mass burning rate with pressure is less pronounced for the lean (Φ = 0.6) mixture, which also exhibits a drop in the pressure dependence above ~10 to 15 atm. Varying the H2 level in the fuel has only a weak effect on the pressure dependence of the flame speed and mass burning rate. This is illustrated in Figure 3.11, which shows results for the lean case (Φ = 0.6). The drop in normalized flame speed with pressure is slightly more pronounced for high H2 content fuel mixtures, while the increase in normalized burning rate with pressure is less pronounced (above ~10 atm). One way to capture the pressure dependence of flame propagation speeds is through simplified models, such as those that employ single-step (overall) chemical reaction rates (Egolfopoulos and Law, 1997) and assume the flame has a two-zone structure (a broad diffusion dominated zone followed by a thin reaction zone). While the flame structures shown in Section 3.2.2 reveal that reactions occur throughout the flame zone in fuels with significant levels of hydrogen, it is still useful to analyze syngas flames with these assumptions. In this case, we find
E R m ′′ ≈ ρSL ∝ p n 2 ρα exp − a 2Trz
(3.2)
where m ′′ is the burning mass flux, n is the overall reaction order, Ea /R is the activation energy of the overall reaction normalized by the gas constant, and Trz is the apparent reaction zone temperature (typically modeled as Tad for thin reaction zones).
84
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications 10 8
SL/SL,atm
0.75 6 0.5
4
0.25
0
(ρuSL)/(ρuSL)atm
H2 = 20% H2 = 50% H2 = 80%
1
2
1
10 Pressure (atm)
0 100
Figure 3.11 Laminar flame speed (solid lines) and mass burning rate (dashed lines) as a function of pressure for three H2/CO fuel mixtures at Φ = 0.6 and Tu = 300 K (symbols = simulations, lines = curve fits).
Neglecting small changes in ρα and Tad with pressure due to compositional variations, the reaction order can be calculated from Equation 3.2:
∂ ln m ′′ n = 2 ∂ ln p Tad
(3.3)
The apparent reaction order has been calculated for a 50:50 H2/CO fuel mixture for lean, stoichiometric, and rich conditions at various pressures (Figure 3.12). At atmospheric pressure, n is ~1.9 for the rich (Φ = 2) case, 1.75 for the stoichiometric mixture, and 1.5 for the lean (Φ = 0.6) case. So for low pressures, n drops with equivalence ratio. In addition, the reaction order decreases monotonically with pressure for all the cases shown. However, the pressure dependence is most pronounced for the rich mixture. So for high pressures (above 20 to 30 atm), the rich and lean mixtures have similar apparent reaction orders, while the stoichiometric mixture has a higher n. The pressure dependence of the flame propagation speeds also brings to light the relative importance of chain branching and terminating reactions in syngas flames. For example, one of the main chain branching reactions in the H2/O2 system is H + O2 ↔ OH + O, which is a two-body reaction. On the other hand, the chain terminating reaction H + O2 + M ↔ HO2 + M is third order. Hence, a pressure rise will tend to increase the relative rate of the H chain termination reaction compared to the chain branching step. This leads to a reduction of overall reaction rate, which hinders flame propagation. Since lean mixtures have a lower n at low pressures, a reduction in H atoms affects flame propagation more for lean mixtures—hence the drastic reduction in mass burning rates for lean conditions. Moreover, the fact that n ~ 2 at
85
Laminar Flame Properties of H2 /CO Mixtures 2
Φ = 0.6 Φ = 1.0
Reaction Order, n
1.75
Φ = 2.0
1.5 1.25 1 0.75 0.5
1
10 Pressure (atm)
100
Figure 3.12 Variation of overall reaction order with pressure for a 50:50 H2/CO fuel mixture at three equivalence ratios and Tu = 300 K (symbols = simulations, lines = logarithmic fits).
low pressures indicates the dominance of the two-body branching reaction (over the three-body terminating reaction) there. The amount of H2 in the fuel mixture also influences the overall reaction order. For example, Figure 3.13 shows results for three H2 levels at a fixed fuel–air ratio. While variations in H2 level do not change the monotonic decrease in n with pressure, the H2 level does change the value of n. For pressure above ~2–3 atm, high H2 1.75
H2 = 20% H2 = 50%
Reaction Order, n
1.5
H2 = 80%
1.25 1 0.75 0.5 0.25
1
10 Pressure (atm)
100
Figure 3.13 Variation of reaction order with pressure for three H2/CO fuel mixtures at Φ = 0.6 and Tu = 300 K (symbols = simulations, lines = logarithmic fits).
86
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
content syngas mixtures have a lower reaction order. This suggests that the H termination reaction is more prominent for high H2 mixtures, which should have higher H atom concentrations. In addition, it is useful to note that the calculated n is positive for all the cases considered, which indicates that the mass burning rate will increase with pressure for these syngas mixtures. However, n drops rapidly with pressure for the high H2 mixture, and negative n values have been observed for lean, pure H2 mixtures at ~20 atm (Law and Sung, 2000). Hence, it is possible that mass burning rates may drop with pressure for high H2 syngas fuels under some conditions. 3.2.3.3 Preheat Temperature Reactant preheating occurs in various combustion systems, for example, due to compression (in high-pressure combustion) or waste heat recovery. Therefore, it is important to examine the dependence of flame speed on reactant temperature. According to the model represented by Equation 3.1, reactant preheating influences the laminar flame speed mainly through changes in reaction rate and diffusive properties. At a constant pressure, the functional dependence of laminar flame speed on preheat temperature can be approximated from the simplified model of Equation 3.2, that is,
SL ∝
E R α exp − a ρ 2Trz
(3.4)
An increase in preheat temperature increases the reaction zone temperature (Trz ) and the diffusivity (α) of the mixture, and decreases the unburned density; all tend to increase SL . To explore the sensitivity to Tu, we begin by presenting a comparison of measured and simulated laminar flame speeds for atmospheric pressure, lean syngas fuels for various amounts of preheating (Figure 3.14) (Natarajan et al., 2007a, 2007b). For the low-temperature cases (300 to 500 K), the simulations produce a fairly close approximation of the measurements, which should help assure the reader that the simulation results presented thus far provide a reasonably accurate representation of syngas flame speeds. For the higher reactant temperatures (Tu > 500 K), the simulations provide a less accurate match to the data, but qualitatively the results are similar. Thus, the simulation results presented below for high reactant temperatures should be considered primarily as indicators of the general influence of preheat. Figure 3.15 shows a similar comparison of measured and simulated laminar flame speeds for different syngas compositions at elevated pressure (Natarajan et al., 2009). At both the low (300 K) and high (600 K) reactant temperatures, the flame speed increases as H2 is added to the fuel, as demonstrated previously (Section 3.2.3.1). The two preheat cases have different equivalence ratios, which were adjusted in order to achieve nearly the same adiabatic flame temperature for both preheat temperatures. This approach isolates the effect of preheat temperature. Thus, the increase in flame speed with Tu for fixed Tad presented in Figure 3.15 can be attributed to a combination of increase in diffusivity and the increase in the reaction rate in the leading part of the syngas flame (that is, the HO2 formation zone presented in Figure 3.4).
87
Laminar Flame Properties of H2 /CO Mixtures
Flame Speed (cm/s)
Tu = 700 K
C1 Mech (Li et al.)
500
Tu = 600 K
400 300
Tu = 500 K
200
Tu = 400 K
100
Tu = 300 K
0 0.55
0.65
0.75 0.85 Equivalence Ratio
0.95
1.05
Figure 3.14 Laminar flame speed for a 50:50 H2:CO syngas composition for various preheat temperatures at p = 1 atm (symbols = measurements, lines = simulations) (Natarajan et al., 2007a).
150
C1 Mech (Li et al.)
Flame Speed (cm/s)
120
Tu = 600 K; Φ = 0.6
90
60 Tu = 300 K; Φ = 0.8
30
0
0
20
40
% of H2
60
80
100
Figure 3.15 Laminar flame speeds for a range of H2/CO fuel mixtures (1:9 O2:He oxidizer) at elevated pressure (p = 15 atm) (symbols = measurements, lines = simulations) (Natarajan et al., 2009).
88
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications 8
Φ = 0.6
SL/SL,atm and (ρuSL)/(ρuSL)atm
Φ = 0.8 6
Φ = 1.0 Φ = 2.0
4
2
0 300
400
500 600 Preheat Temperature Tu (K)
700
Figure 3.16 Normalized flame speed (solid lines) and mass burning rate (dashed lines) as a function of preheat temperature and equivalence ratio from simulations for a 50:50 H2/CO fuel at p = 1 atm.
Figure 3.16 provides a more detailed examination of the influence of Tu for different fuel–air ratios, with results shown for both laminar flame speed and mass burning rate. The simulations reveal SL increases exponentially with Tu; as Tu rises from room temperature to 700 K, the flame speed increases by a factor of 4 to 8 for the range of equivalence ratios shown. Overall, flame speeds and mass burning rates of lean mixtures show the most sensitivity to preheating. It is interesting to note that the rate of increase in mass burning rate is less than that for flame speed. As the reactants are heated from room temperature to 700 K, the mass burning rate increases by only two to three times. This is due to the decrease in the density of the unburned reactants with preheat temperature. 3.2.3.4 Diluents As previously noted, syngas fuels exhibit a large variability in composition, not only in the combustible fuel content, but also in diluents such as CO2, N2, and H2O. Fuel dilution impacts flame propagation in at least three ways, through changes in (1) mixture-specific heat and adiabatic flame temperature, (2) chemical kinetic rates, and (3) radiative heat transfer. First, addition of diluents to the fuel reduces the flame temperature, and thus reduces the laminar flame speed (and narrows the flammability range) through reduction in the reaction rate. From Equation 3.4, the effect of flame temperature on overall reaction rate can be estimated through the activation energy (Ea) term. This global parameter can be determined from Equation 3.4, assuming that λ/cp is nearly constant; the result is
89
Laminar Flame Properties of H2 /CO Mixtures
d ln m ′′ E =− a d (1 Tad ) 2R
(3.5)
Overall Activation Energy, Ea (kcal/mole)
To properly determine the activation energy, it is thus important to vary only the flame temperature. One approach for estimating Ea is to change Tad by replacing a small amount (2 to 6%) of the N2 in air with argon. This leads to a small increase in the flame temperature and hence the mass burning rate. Based on this approach, the calculated overall activation energy for a 50:50 syngas mixture at two lean conditions over a range of preheat temperatures is shown in Figure 3.17. Both lean mixtures show an increase in Ea with preheat temperature, reaching a nearly constant value above Tu ~ 600 K. As higher Ea values imply a greater sensitivity to flame temperature (see Equation 3.4), one can expect that diluent effects on flame speed may be more pronounced for preheated conditions. The simulations also indicate that Ea for the leaner (Φ = 0.6) condition is significantly less than for the more stoichiometric (Φ = 0.8) case for this 50:50 H2/CO fuel. It should be noted that this trend is opposite of that observed for pure H2 under lean conditions using the same calculation approach (Law and Sung, 2000). Second, some diluents are not inert. For example, the chemical kinetic effects of CO2 dilution can be manifested through the main CO oxidation reaction CO + OH ↔ CO2 + H. Higher CO2 dilution levels lead to enhanced backward reaction rates, and hence reduced rates of CO oxidation and H atom production. This will reduce flame propagation speeds. Chemical kinetic studies have emphasized this
70
Φ = 0.6 Φ = 0.8
60
50
40
30 200
300
400 500 600 Preheat Temperature Tu (K)
700
Figure 3.17 Variation of overall activation energy with preheat temperature for 50:50 H2/CO fuel mixtures at lean equivalence ratios and p = 1 atm (symbols = simulations, lines = curve fits).
90
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
point by comparing the flame speeds of mixtures with CO2 dilution, and a fictitious, chemically inert species with the same specific heat as CO2. The results showed that CO2 diluted flame speeds were lower (Zhu et al., 1988). This kinetic effect is expected to have profound influence on flame speeds for lean H2/CO flames due to the importance of H atom concentration, especially for low H2 syngas fuels. As seen in the flame structure examples, H atoms control the main branching (H + O2 ↔ O + OH) and termination (H + O2 + M ↔ HO2 + M) reactions. Third, addition of diluents can influence flame propagation through radiative heat transfer. For example, CO2 and H2O are effective absorbers and emitters of infrared radiation, unlike N2 and O2. The presence of significant amounts of CO2 or H2O in the reactants can result in reabsorption of energy radiated from the hot products. This enhancement of thermal energy transfer across the flame can increase laminar flame speeds and extend flammability limits (Ruan et al., 2001; Chen et al., 2006; Ju et al., 1998). Conversely, the presence of an effective radiative emitter within the initial part of the reaction zone can also lead to increased heat losses and reduced flame speeds. 3.2.3.5 Flame Stretch So far we have considered the influence of various physical and chemical parameters on laminar flame speed of a freely propagating, planar (one-dimensional) flame. However, such flames are rarely found in practical devices, and actually difficult to create even in controlled environments. Thus, we must also consider propagation speeds of flames that are not one-dimensional. Laminar flame speed and thus overall heat release rate are strongly influenced by flame stretch, especially for reactant mixtures consisting of species with drastically different diffusivities. The stretch (κ), defined as the fractional rate of change of flame surface area, is mainly due to tangential strain (velocity nonuniformity in the approach flow) and flame curvature (Law and Sung, 2000). For example, flow strain is relevant in a stagnation flame, while a propagating nonplanar flame can have stretch effects due solely to the motion of the curved flame. In this section, we characterize stretch effects on unburned flame speeds due to strain for typical syngas mixtures. The results are based on simulations of strained flames obtained with the Chemkin OPPDIF code (Kee et al., 2006), for identical premixed mixtures exiting opposing nozzles. Based on a standard approach (Wu and Law, 1984), the minimum velocity before the preheat zone is defined as the reference strained unburned flame speed (Su ), and the maximum gradient of the axial velocity ahead of the minimum velocity location is defined as the imposed strain rate (K). As an example, Figure 3.18 shows the effect of strain rate on the unburned flame speed for a lean, 10:90 H2:CO fuel mixture. Typically for lean H2/CO mixtures with low to moderate strain, the unburned flame speed increases linearly with imposed strain rate. For this low H2 content fuel, this is accompanied by a drop in the maximum flame temperature, due to a decrease in residence time in the reaction zone, thus leading to incomplete combustion. The linear dependence of flame speed on strain is generally expressed by the equation Su = Su0 – L M κ, where Su0 is the unstrained flame speed and L M is the unburned Markstein length (Law and Sung, 2000). The Markstein length is essentially the sensitivity of the unburned flame speed to strain.
91
32
1950
28
1925 Su = 0.038 K + 24.8
24
1900
20
1875
Maximum Temperature (K)
Flame Speed Su (cm/s)
Laminar Flame Properties of H2 /CO Mixtures
Flame speed 16
Max. temperature 0
30
60 90 Strain Rate K (1/s)
120
1850 150
Figure 3.18 Strained laminar flame speed and maximum flame temperature for a lean (Φ = 0.6) 10:90 H2:CO composition at p = 1 atm and Tu = 300 K (symbols = simulations, lines = linear fits).
As an example, the unstrained flame speed, based on extrapolating the simulations to zero strain rate in Figure 3.18, is 24.7 cm/s, while L M is 0.038 cm. Like laminar flame speed, the Markstein length is also affected by various parameters, such as the amount of H2 in the fuel mixture, equivalence ratio, pressure, and preheat temperature. Usually L M tends to scale with laminar flame thickness. To demonstrate this, Figure 3.19 shows the results of strained flame simulations for a 50:50 H2:CO fuel mixture, again for Φ = 0.6, and at two pressures. The influence of H2 level in the syngas is illustrated by a comparison of the results for the 10:90 (Figure 3.18) and 50:50 (Figure 3.19) H2:CO fuel mixtures at p = 1 atm and Φ = 0.6. As expected from the SL results presented previously, Su0 increases for the higher H2 content fuel. In addition, LM decreases from 0.038 cm to 0.026 cm. This correlates well with the reduced flame thickness for the higher H2 fuel (see Figure 3.5). The influence of pressure is evident from comparison of the 1 and 5 atm results shown in Figure 3.19. The higher-pressure condition produces a lower unstrained flame speed and lower Markstein length. Again, the reduced LM value parallels the demonstrated decrease in syngas flame thickness with pressure (see Figure 3.6). Similarly, the qualitative dependence of Markstein length on other parameters such as equivalence ratio and preheat temperature for syngas fuels can be determined from their influence on laminar flame thickness (Natarajan et al., 2007b, 2008b). Interestingly, increasing the amount of H2 in the H2/CO fuel mixture (from 10:90 to 50:50) also inverts the dependence of the maximum flame temperature on the strain rate (see Figures 3.18 and 3.19). For the 50:50 fuel mixture, the maximum flame temperature now increases with the strain rate. Though the increase in strain rate still decreases the residence time in the reaction zone, the addition of H2 also
92
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Flame Speed Su (cm/s)
Su = 0.0258 K + 48.5
P = 1 atm P = 5 atm Max. temperature
55
2000
1975
Flame speed 1950
45 1925 35
25
Su = 0.0097 K + 28.9
0
250
500 Strain Rate K (1/s)
750
1900
Maximum Temperature (K)
65
1875 1000
Figure 3.19 Strained laminar flame speed and maximum flame temperature for a lean (Φ = 0.6) 50:50 H2:CO composition at two pressures and Tu = 300 K (symbols = simulations, lines = linear fits).
significantly decreases the flame’s Lewis number (Le, the ratio of thermal to mass diffusivity) (Law and Sung, 2000). Thus, there is a faster diffusion of reactants toward the reaction zone compared to its loss of thermal energy through conduction back to the fresh reactants for this positively strained flame; the net result is a local increase in the reaction zone temperature. This is further enhanced by preferential diffusion, owing to the higher diffusivity of H2. The result is a local increase in the equivalence ratio (toward Φ = 1) for this positively strained, lean mixture. As the strain rate is increased further, the drop in residence time eventually dominates, leading to a decrease in flame temperature.
3.2.4 Flame Extinction At sufficiently high imposed stretch rates (for example, due to higher deceleration rates experienced by a stagnating flow), the flame temperature and heat release rate begin to decrease drastically, and the flame eventually extinguishes. The corresponding strain rate is called the extinction strain rate (Kext ). Similar to laminar flame speed, extinction strain rate is a fundamental property of the reactant mixture, contributing to phenomena such as flame liftoff and combustor blowout. Extinction strain rates have also been used for partial validation of detailed chemical kinetic models (Dong et al., 2005). Various research efforts have focused on characterizing extinction strain rates for a variety of reactant mixtures that include CH4, H2, and CO (Vagelopoulos and Egolfopoulos, 1994; Law et al., 1986; Jackson et al., 2003; Choudhuri et al., 2008). Most of these experimental and numerical studies utilized the premixed opposing jet
93
Laminar Flame Properties of H2 /CO Mixtures
Extinction Strain Rate, Kext (1/s)
2000
1500
1000
500
0 0.4
0.7
1
1.3
1.6
Equivalence Ratio Φ
Figure 3.20 Extinction strain rates for premixed CH4-air flames at various equivalence ratios at p = 1 atm and Tu = 300 K (symbols = measurements, line = curve fit) (Law et al., 1986).
flow configuration to directly measure the extinction rates. As a basis for comparison, we begin by examining measured extinction strain rates (Figure 3.20) for CH4air flames (Law et al., 1986). Similar to SL and Tad, the extinction strain rate generally increases as the mixture equivalence ratio is adjusted toward stoichiometric. In other words, higher strain rates are required to extinguish fast-burning and high flame temperature reactant mixtures. Unlike SL and Tad, Kext peaks for slightly lean (rather than rich) mixtures. This behavior can be explained by considering both stretch and preferential diffusion effects. For rich CH4-air mixtures, Le is greater than 1, and hence the flame temperature drops with increasing stretch. But for lean CH4-air mixtures, Le is less than 1, and the flame temperature rises with stretch (at least before the onset of incomplete combustion), requiring more stretch to extinguish the flame. The presence of small amounts of H2 in relatively slow-burning reactant mixtures, such as CH4-air or CO-air, can strongly influence the extinction characteristics due to the intense burning nature of H2. Figure 3.21 shows measured extinction strain rates for various H2-doped, lean CH4-air flames at elevated preheat temperature (Tu = 578 K). As with the room temperature data (Figure 3.20), the extinction strain rate increases with equivalence ratio. Comparing the pure (0% H2 doping) case at Tu = 578 K (Figure 3.21) with room temperature results (Figure 3.20), the extinction strain rate increases significantly with preheat temperature for a given equivalence ratio. For example, Kext increases from ~750 to ~4000 s–1 due to the ~280 K increase in reactant temperature. The higher Kext values are associated with greater burning rates and flame temperatures for the preheated mixtures. For the same reasons, higher H2 levels are also seen to increase extinction strain rate (Figure 3.21). Figure 3.21 further illustrates that increasing the amount of H2 also extends the lean flammability limit of the reactant mixture. This can be observed by extending each
94
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Extinction Strain Rate, Kext (1/s)
8000
H2 = 0% H2 = 5% H2 = 10%
6000
4000
2000
0 0.4
0.5
0.6 0.7 Equivalence Ratio Φ
0.8
0.9
Figure 3.21 Extinction strain rates for atmospheric pressure, premixed CH4-air flames with various amounts of H2 addition (0, 5, and 10%) at elevated preheat temperature (Tu = 578 K) (symbols = measurements, lines = curve fits) (Jackson et al., 2003).
of the constant H2 curves to Kext = 0, which in theory should correspond to the flammability limit of the reactant mixture. For syngas mixtures, the amount of H2 has a similarly significant influence on extinction characteristics. Figure 3.22 shows the variation of measured extinction strain rates for two lean mixtures as a function of H2 content in the fuel. As before, Kext increases with H2 and Φ due to the increase in burning rate with both, and due
Extinction Strain Rate, Kext (1/s)
800
Φ = 0.39 Φ = 0.32
600
400
200
0
0
10
20 30 % H2 in H2/CO Mixture
40
50
Figure 3.22 Extinction strain rates as a function of H2 level in H2/CO-air flames for two lean mixtures at p = 1 atm and Tu = 300 K (symbols = measurements, lines = curve fits) (Vagelopoulos and Egolfopoulos, 1994).
95
Laminar Flame Properties of H2 /CO Mixtures
to the increase in flame temperature with Φ. The addition of diluents to syngas fuels will tend to lower the extinction strain rate. This point has been emphasized in studies on the effects of CO2 dilution of CH4 and H2 fuels (Ren et al., 2001).
3.3 Nonpremixed Flame Properties The flame properties presented above were for perfectly premixed reactants, that is, where mixing has occurred well before the reactants encroach upon the flame region. In some combustions systems, premixing of fuel and oxidizer is not desirable, for example, due to flame stability or safety concerns. Thus, it is also helpful to describe the characteristics of laminar syngas flames that are nonpremixed. An example of such a flame structure is shown in Figure 3.23, for a 50:50 H2:CO fuel composition. As above, the simulation results were obtained with the Chemkin OPPDIF code. For this example, the flame occurs between two opposing jets, which is the same geometry used above to characterize stretch effects on laminar flames. In this case, the two nozzles contain different reactants: the fuel exits from one nozzle and air from the other. The figure shows the chemical composition (major species) and temperature as a function of distance along the axial centerline between the two nozzles. Various characteristics of undiluted, nonpremixed syngas flames are visible here. First, the peak temperature, which is sometimes considered a marker of the flame location, occurs on the oxidizer side of the stagnation plane, since a stoichiometric mixture of fuel and air requires more air. Thus, the fuel species must diffuse across the stagnation plane to reach the oxidizer. The high-temperature region is also typically characterized by high heat release rates, as well as the peak levels of flame radicals, such as O, OH, and H. The peaks in the H2O and CO2 mole fractions also occur here; for syngas fuels diluted with high levels of H2O or CO2, however, the major product peaks can occur elsewhere, depending on the level of dilution and the strain 1
2500 Stagnation Plane
T
Mole Fra ction
CO
1500
0.5 1000
H2
H2 O
0.25
O2
Temperature (K)
2000
0.75
500
CO2 0
0 0
2.5 5 7.5 Distance from Fuel Nozzle (mm)
10
Figure 3.23 Simulated structure of a nonpremixed strained (opposing jet flow, 170 s –1 strain rate) laminar flame for a 50:50 H2:CO fuel at p = 1 atm and Tu = 300 K.
96
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
rate (or residence time within the flame). It is also interesting to note how the mole fractions of CO and H2 begin to diverge some distance from the fuel nozzle due to the much higher diffusivity of the lighter H2. This is one of the key features of nonpremixed syngas flames. While the flame structure presented is characteristic for nonpremixed syngas flames, it should be noted that strain rate plays a key role, as it did for premixed strained flames. At sufficiently high levels of strain, peak temperatures and radical and product mole fractions drop, eventually reaching a point where the flame is extinguished. Analogous to the extinction strain trends observed for premixed flames, higher levels of strain are required to extinguish the flame as one increases the fraction of H2 in the fuel, raises the initial temperature of either reactant, or reduces the diluent level in the fuel (analogous to reducing the equivalence ratio for lean premixed flames).
3.4 Conclusions Understanding the fundamental laminar flame properties of syngas fuel mixtures is a critical aspect for developing syngas-fueled combustion devices. One of the major variables in syngas combustion is the composition of the fuel. While variations in the H2/CO ratio have little effect on flame temperature, they have a major impact on flame thickness, flame speed, flammability limits, stretch sensitivity, and extinction strain rate. Due to the high reactivity and diffusivity of hydrogen, the flame structure of syngas flames is also unlike that of natural gas flames. Additional components of many syngas fuels are diluents such as H2O and CO2. Understanding the influence of these diluents requires attention to their impact on radiative energy transfer and, as they are also combustion products, to their tendency to reduce overall product formation rates. This chapter also describes the dependence of laminar syngas flame properties on various physical parameters (pressure, reactant temperature, and stretch), which can in some cases be modeled and interpreted using global flame parameters such as overall reaction order, overall activation energy, and mixture thermal diffusivity. The sensitivity to flame stretch can also be correlated to flame thickness in premixed flames. These simplified modeling approaches can be beneficial in the development of scaling laws for combustor design tools.
References Brown, M. J., McLean, I. C., Smith, D. B., and Taylor, S. C. (1996). Markstein lengths of CO/H2/air flames, using expanding spherical flames. Proc. Combust. Instit. 26:875. Chen, Z., Qin, X., Xu, B., Ju, Y., and Liu, F. (2006). Studies of radiation absorption on flame speed and flammability limit of CO2 diluted methane flames at elevated pressures. Proc. Combust. Instit. 31:2693. Choudhuri, A. R., Subramanya, M., and Gollahalli, S. R. (2008). Flame extinction limits of H2-CO fuel blends. J. Eng. Gas Turbines Power 130:031501. Dong, Y., Holley, A. T., Andac, M. G., Egolfopoulos, F. N., Davis, S. G., Middha, P., and Wang, H. (2005). Extinction of premixed H2/air flames: Chemical kinetics and molecular diffusion effects. Combust. Flame 142:374.
Laminar Flame Properties of H2 /CO Mixtures
97
Egolfopoulos, F. N., and Law, C. K. (1997). Chain mechanisms in the overall reaction order in laminar flame propagation. Combust. Flame 80:7. Glassman, I. (1996). Combustion. 3rd ed. New York: Academic Press. Günther, R., and Janisch, G. (1971). Messwerte der Flammegeschwindigkeit von gasen und gasmischen. Chemie-Ing-Technol. 43:975. Hassan, M. I., Aung, K. T., and Faeth, G. M. (1996). Markstein numbers and unstretched laminar burning velocities of wet carbon monoxide flames. Paper AIAA 96-0912 presented at the 34th Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit, Reno, NV. Hassan, M. I., Aung, K. T., and Faeth, G. M. (1997). Properties of laminar premixed CO/H2/air flames at various pressures. J. Propulsion Power 13:239. Jackson, G. S., Sai, R., Plaia, J. M., Boggs, C. M., and Kiger, K. T. (2003). Influence of H2 on the response of lean premixed CH4 flames to high strained flows. Combust. Flame 132:503. Ju, Y., Masuya, G., and Ronney, P. D. (1998). Effects of radiative emission and absorption on the propagation and extinction of premixed gas flames. Proc. Combust. Instit. 27:2619. Kee, R. J., Rupley, F. M., Miller, J. A., Coltrin, M. E., Grcar, J. F., Meeks, E., Moffat, H. K., Lutz, A. E., Dixon-Lewis, G., Smooke, M. D., Warnatz, J., Evans, G. H., Larson, R. S., Mitchell, R. E., Petzold, L. R., Reynolds, W. C., Caracotsios, M., Stewart, W. E., Glarborg, P., Wang, C., and Adigun, O. (2006). CHEMKIN collection. Release 4.1. San Diego: Reaction Design. Law, C. K. (2006). Combustion physics. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Law, C. K., and Sung, C. J. (2000). Structure, aerodynamics and geometry of premixed flamelets. Prog. Energy Comb. Sci. 26:459. Law, C. K., Zhu, D. L., and Yu, G. (1986). Propagation and extinction of stretched premixed flames. Proc. Combust. Instit. 21:1419. Li, J., Zhao, Z., Kazakov, A., Chaos, M., Dryer, F. L., and Scire Jr., J. J. (2007). A comprehensive kinetic mechanism for CO, CH2O, and CH3OH combustion. Int. J. Chem. Kin. 39:109. McLean, I. C., Smith, D. B., and Taylor, S. C. (1994). The use of carbon monoxide/hydrogen burning velocities to examine the rate of the CO + OH reaction. Proc. Combust. Instit. 25:749. Natarajan, J., Kochar, Y., Lieuwen, T., and Seitzman, J. (2008a). Laminar flame speed measurements of H2/CO/CO2 mixtures up to 15 atm and 600 K preheat temperature. ASME Paper 08-GT2008-51364 presented at Proceedings of the ASME/IGTI Turbo Expo 2008, Berlin. Natarajan, J., Kochar, Y., Lieuwen, T., and Seitzman, J. (2009). Pressure and preheat dependence of laminar flame speeds of H2/CO/CO2/O2/He mixtures. Proc. Combust. Instit., doi:10.1016/j.proci.2008.06.110. Natarajan, J., Lieuwen, T., and Seitzman, J. (2007a). Laminar flame speeds of H2/CO mixtures: Effect of CO2 dilution, preheat temperature and pressure. Combust. Flame 151:104. Natarajan, J., Lieuwen, T., and Seitzman, J. (2007b). Laminar flame speeds and strain sensitivities of mixtures of H2 with CO, CO2 and N2 at elevated temperatures. ASME Paper 07-GT2007-27967 presented at Proceedings of the ASME/IGTI Turbo Expo 2007, Montreal, Canada. Natarajan, J., Lieuwen, T., and Seitzman, J. (2008b). Laminar flame speeds and strain sensitivities of mixtures of H2/O2/N2 at elevated preheat temperatures. J. Eng. Gas Turbines Power 30:061502. Ren, J.-Y., Qin, W., Egolfopoulos, F. N., Mak, H., and Tsotsis, T. T. (2001). Methane reforming and its potential effect on the efficiency and pollutant emissions of lean methane-air combustion. Chem. Eng. Sci. 56:1541. Ruan, J., Kobayashi, H., Niioka, T., and Ju, Y. (2001). Combined effects of nongray radiation and pressure on premixed CH4/O2/CO2 flames. Combust. Flame 124:225. Scholte, T. G., and Vaags, P. B. (1959). Burning velocities of mixtures of hydrogen, carbon monoxide, and methane with air. Combust. Flame 3:511.
98
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Strauss, W. A., and Edse, R. (1958). Burning velocity measurements by the constant-pressure bomb method. Proc. Combust. Instit. 7:377. Sun, H. Y., Yang, S. I., Jomass, G., and Law, C. K. (2006). High pressure laminar flame speeds and kinetic modeling of carbon monoxide/hydrogen combustion. Proc. Combust. Instit. 31:439. Vagelopoulos, C. M., and Egolfopoulos, F. N. (1994). Laminar flame speeds and extinction strain rates of mixtures of carbon monoxide with hydrogen, methane, and air. Proc. Combust. Instit. 25:1317. Wu, C. K., and Law, C. K. (1984). On the determination of laminar flame speeds from stretched flames. Proc. Combust. Instit. 20:1941. Yumlu, V. S. (1967). Prediction of burning velocities of carbon monoxide-hydrogen-air flames. Combust. Flame 11:190. Zhang, Q., Noble, D. R., and Lieuwen, T. (2007). Characterization of fuel composition effects in H2/CO/CH4 mixtures upon lean blowout. J. Eng. Gas Turbines Power 129:688. Zhu, D. L., Egolfopoulos, F. N., and Law, C. K. (1988). Experimental and numerical determination of laminar flame speeds of methane/(Ar, N2, CO2)–air mixtures as function of stoichiometry, pressure, and flame temperature. Proc. Combust. Instit. 22:1537.
Combustion 4 Fundamental Characteristics of Syngas Guillaume Ribert, Piyush Thakre, Zhe Wang, Richard A. Yetter, and Vigor Yang Contents 4.1 Introduction.....................................................................................................99 4.2 Premixed Systems.......................................................................................... 101 4.2.1 Ignition and Extinction in Closed Homogeneous and Perfectly Stirred Reactors................................................................................. 101 4.2.2 Premixed Flames............................................................................... 104 4.2.2.1 CO/H2 Mixtures.................................................................. 104 4.2.2.2 CO2, H2O, and N2 Dilution................................................. 107 4.2.2.3 Pressure and Temperature Effects...................................... 112 4.3 Counterflow Diffusion Flames...................................................................... 114 4.3.1 H2/CO Mixtures................................................................................. 117 4.3.2 CO2, H2O, and N2 Dilution................................................................ 117 4.3.3 Pressure Effects................................................................................. 120 4.4 Strained Counterflow Premixed Flames....................................................... 124 4.5 Conclusions.................................................................................................... 124 Acknowledgments................................................................................................... 126 References............................................................................................................... 126
4.1 Introduction Synthetic gas (syngas) is primarily a mixture of hydrogen (H2) and carbon monoxide (CO). Varying proportions of carbon dioxide (CO2), steam (H2O), nitrogen (N2), and small quantities of hydrocarbons, mainly methane (CH4), may also be present (Shilling and Lee, 2003). In order to employ syngas as a practical fuel for power and propulsion applications, detailed understanding and characterization of the key syngas combustion properties, such as self-ignition delay, flame speed, extinction limit, and heat-release rate, over a wide range of permissible fuel compositions, equivalence ratios, and operating conditions, will be necessary. Scholte and Vaags (1959) were the first to experimentally study the premixed flame speeds of mixtures of H2/CO, CO/CH4, and H2/CH4 with air, using various compositions. A decade later, kinetics studies of H2/CO oxidation based on shocktube experiments were carried out (Brabbs et al., 1970; Gardiner et al., 1972; Dean et al., 1978). McLean et al. (1994) obtained H2/CO burning velocities using a spherical 99
100
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
bomb apparatus. All the above measurements were limited to low pressures. Kim et al. (1994) studied the oxidation of moist CO up to 9.6 atm using a flow reactor. More recently, several experimental investigations of H2/CO autoignition and flame speeds were carried out at much higher pressures (Mittal et al., 2006; Sivaramakrishnan et al., 2007; Walton et al., 2007; Sun et al., 2007). One of the questions concerning the syngas oxidation mechanism was the relative importance of the dry oxidation of CO (R1, R2) and the oxidation of CO in the presence of hydrogen. It is now well known that while the reaction of the dry CO/O2 mixture is slow even at high temperatures, the overall reactivity is greatly accelerated if trace amounts of H2 and moisture are present. The oxidation route between CO and hydroxyl radicals (R3) is the dominant pathway, and it accounts for a significant portion of the heat release (Sung and Law, 2008). At higher pressures, however, reaction (R4) provides another route for the conversion of CO to CO2 (Sung and Law, 2008).
CO + O2 → CO2 + O
(R1)
CO + O + M → CO2 + M
(R2)
CO + OH → CO2 + H
(R3)
CO + HO2 → CO2 + OH
(R4)
A detailed reaction mechanism for H2/CO/O2 was developed by Yetter et al. (1991a, 1991b). Subsequently, a few analytical studies focused on modeling wet CO premixed flames in the presence of H2 and H2O, with simplified reduced chemistry (Wang and Rogg, 1993; Rightley and Williams, 1995, 1997). The Yetter et al. (1991a, 1991b) mechanism has since been updated (Kim et al., 1994) and further extended by Li et al. (2007) to predict a wide range of flame characteristics. Other mechanisms, with small variations in reactions and associated rate constants parameters, have also been developed (e.g., Davis et al., 2005). While the flame propagation and stability characteristics of lean premixed systems have been fairly well investigated for conventional hydrocarbon-air systems, not much is known about the characteristics of alternative gaseous fuels. Recently, Lieuwen and coworkers characterized the impact of syngas composition on flashback, blowout, dynamic stability, and autoignition (Zhang et al., 2005; Lieuwen et al., 2006, 2008; Noble et al., 2006). Other key characteristics, such as premixed flame speeds, have also been studied (Natarajan et al., 2005). Giles et al. (2006) conducted a numerical investigation of counterflow syngas nonpremixed flames with dilution by N2, CO2, and H2O. They noted that H2O and CO2 proved more effective than N2 in reducing NOX in H2/CO (50:50) flames. Further improvements to the model are still required, such as incorporation of the inhibitor effect of CO in H2/CO autoignition (Mittal et al., 2006) and more accurate flame speed calculations (Natarajan et al., 2005), especially at high pressures. Hydrogen has a lower autoignition temperature than natural gas and reacts rapidly with oxygen, which leads to a high burning velocity (Qin et al., 2000). Thus, switching from hydrocarbon fuels to syngas requires a detailed understanding of
Fundamental Combustion Characteristics of Syngas
101
flammability range, flame propagation speeds, and safety issues. In this chapter, an overview of syngas combustion characteristics is presented through a numerical study. First, the ignition delays and extinction times for the closed homogeneous reactor (HR) and perfectly stirred reactor (PSR) configurations are presented over a broad range of equivalence ratios and pressures. Simulations of laminar premixed and counterflow diffusion flames are then conducted for various syngas compositions, equivalence ratios, and operating conditions. Finally, the impact of dilution on syngas combustion with varying quantities of CO2, H2O, and N2 is considered. The GRI-Mech 3.0 chemical kinetics mechanism has been used unless mentioned other wise. The species proportions in all mixtures considered herein are described in terms of molar ratios.
4.2 Premixed Systems 4.2.1 Ignition and Extinction in Closed Homogeneous and Perfectly Stirred Reactors The combustion characteristics and operability limits of syngas flames differ considerably from those of conventional hydrocarbons. An HR and a PSR represent two different scenarios in terms of mixing characteristics (Turns, 2000). The former is a closed system, in which the mixture composition and temperature are spatially uniform but vary with time. The latter, on the other hand, is an open system, and the mixture composition and temperature in the reactor are different from their counterparts at the inlet. Thus, in the case of a PSR, the fresh reactant mixture at the inlet encounters a growing pool of intermediate reaction species and products in the reactor, and instantly mixes with them. This phenomenon bears significance in determining the ignition properties. The ignition delay for a PSR is defined as the residence time required for the onset of significant heat release without any external ignition source. In contrast, the blow-off/extinction time is specified as the residence time in which an already ignited mixture can be extinguished within a PSR. The ignition delay for an HR is defined as the time delay prior to a steep rise in temperature due to ongoing exothermic chemical reactions. In order to avoid undesirable autoignition, characteristic chemical reaction times should be greater than mixing times. Syngas fuel with equal CO/H2 (50:50 molar concentrations) was chosen as a reference mixture and CHEMKIN (2004) was used for analyses. Table 4.1 lists the ignition time delays for stoichiometric mixtures of CO/H2 (50:50), H2, and CH4 in air at T = 700 K, p = 20 atm as calculated employing the GRI-Mech 3.0 mechanism. For both the perfectly stirred and homogeneous reactors, the shortest ignition delay is exhibited by the CO/H2 mixture. Also included are the PSR ignition delays calculated using the kinetics scheme of Li et al. (2007), which is a comprehensive mechanism for the combustion of CO, CH2O, and CH3OH. The mechanism was developed in a hierarchical manner by substantial validation of submechanisms with experimental measurements involving the combustion of fuels such as H2, CO, and CH2O. The predictions using the Li et al. (2007) mechanism differ slightly from those obtained from the GRI-Mech 3.0 mechanism. The estimated ignition delays for all three cases using both the mechanisms are much higher than
102
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Table 4.1 Ignition Delay Timesa at Stoichiometric Conditions (700 K, 20 atm; in air) Reactor Perfectly stirred reactor Homogeneous reactor a b c
CO/H2 (50:50)
H2
13.5 18c 50b
26 19c 104b
b
CH4 b
29b 187b
Unit: second. Based on GRI-Mech 3.0 mechanism. Based on Li et al. (2007) mechanism.
typical mixing times. The ignition delays for methane, H2, and the CO/H2 mixture decrease progressively, in that order. Consequently, the practical use of hydrogen and hydrogen-enriched fuels will require considerable care to ensure safe operations. Figure 4.1a shows the PSR and HR ignition time delays for CO/H2 mixtures as a function of temperature at 1 atm and different equivalence ratios ϕ. The comparison between the estimated and measured ignition delays is reasonable at high temperatures, but the model significantly overpredicts the delay at low temperatures. It should be noted, however, that most of the experiments were carried out at higher pressures. The disagreement at lower temperatures may be attributed in part to the pressure sensitivity of the CO/H2/O2 kinetic mechanism. There is significant scatter in the ignition delay data reported by different researchers, perhaps because the experiments were performed in several types of facilities, including shock-tube apparatus (Petersen et al., 2007), rapid compression facility (Walton et al., 2007), and flow reactors (Peschke and Spadaccini, 1985; Petersen et al., 2007). Moreover, the chosen ratio of H2/CO, the type and quantity of diluents, the equivalence ratio, and the operating pressure are not uniform throughout the various experimental studies. The same reasons may also cause the disagreement between the estimated and measured values at low temperature. The differences in the low-temperature ignition delay have been the subject of several recent studies and interpretations (Chaos and Dryer, 2008; Dryer and Chaos, 2008). The ignition delay decreases with the increase in temperature, albeit in a non uniform manner, as seen in Figure 4.1a. The apparent activation energy (slope of the curve) is different for the temperature ranges of 650–1000 K and 1000–2000 K. In the former range, the ignition delay for the HR is about ten times that for the PSR. In the latter range, it is only about twice that for the PSR. The lower value in the case of the PSR can be attributed to the perfect mixing of the incoming fresh reactant mixture with the developing pool of radicals in the reactor. Such mixing enhances the rate of chemical reactions. The steeper slope for the low-temperature range is the result of formation and consumption of relatively stable HO2 and H2O2 species, which precedes the formation of significant amounts of OH, O, and H. The HR ignition delay is highest for the fuel-lean case, followed by the stoichiometric and fuel-rich cases.
103
Fundamental Combustion Characteristics of Syngas
103
τ (s)
101 10–1 HR (φ = 1) HR (φ = 0.27) HR (φ = 3.5) PSR (φ = 1) Exp. (Petersen et al.) Exp. (Peschke et al.) Exp. (Walton et al.) Exp. (Markides et al.)
10–3 10–5 10–7
0.001
0.0005
0.0015
1/T (K–1)
0.002
0.0025
(a)
Extinction and Ignition Time (s)
103
PSR ext (φ = 1) PSR ext (φ = 3.5) PSR ext (φ = 0.27) PSR ext (φ = 1, Li et al.) PSR ignition (φ = 1)
101
10–1
10–3
10–5
10–7
0.001
0.002
1/T (K–1)
0.003
0.004
(b)
Figure 4.1 Ignition time delays for homogeneous and perfectly stirred reactors as a function of temperature for CO/H2 mixtures in air (1 atm).
Figure 4.1b shows that the extinction and ignition times for the PSR are comparable at high temperatures, but the former is much smaller (~106–7 times at 700 K) than the latter at low temperatures. This trend again shows the influence of blending an incoming fuel–air stream with an already ignited and radical species containing
104
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
mixture in the reactor. Intuition suggests that in order to extinguish an already ignited mixture, the residence time in the reactor must be decreased further. Thus, at low temperature, the critical residence time required to maintain combustion is much shorter than that for autoignition, and this implies that a small ignition source would enhance combustion tremendously. The extinction times overlap for fuel-rich and stoichiometric cases, but are much larger for the fuel-lean case at temperatures lower than ~1000 K. The extinction time predictions from the mechanisms of GRIMech 3.0 and Li et al. (2007) are quite close. The results show that even a small recirculation zone containing radical species can potentially serve as an ignition source. It has been suggested by Markides and Mastorakos (2005) that autoignition is not simply kinetically controlled, but rather, the location and onset of autoignition may be determined by mixing due to turbulent fluctuations. In addition, many other factors, such as compressible flow, physical mixing, operating conditions, and catalytic surface processes occurring in the mild ignition regimes, could be the sources of the departure of experimentally observed ignition delays from homogeneous gas-phase kinetic predictions. As enumerated in Table 4.1, the calculated ignition delays at high pressure (20 atm) are on the order of tens of seconds, closer to the measured values than the calculations at 1 atm.
4.2.2 Premixed Flames Laminar flame speed is one of the most important parameters characterizing premixed combustion. It dictates the flammability domain for a chosen fuel composition, equivalence ratio, and operating condition. Furthermore, it encompasses the information on the reaction mechanisms in the presence of diffusive transport. In the following, combustion characteristics—including flame speeds, flame structures, and flammability limits—are investigated for different syngas compositions. The effects of equivalence ratios and mixture dilution with CO2, N2, H2O, and CH4 are studied. In addition, the influences of temperature and pressure variations are considered. The calculations were performed using the one-dimensional PREMIX code from the CHEMKIN II package (Kee et al., 1986, 1992). 4.2.2.1 CO/H2 Mixtures Figure 4.2 shows the laminar flame speed (SL) as a function of equivalence ratio (ϕ) for five different CO/H2 (5:95, 25:75, 50:50, 75:25, and 95:5) compositions. The pressure is set to 1 bar and the initial temperature is 300 K. At a given equivalence ratio, the flame speed increases with the increase in the concentration of H2. The premixed flame speed is proportional to chemical reaction rates and molecular diffusivity, both of which are enhanced when the concentration of H2 is increased. The fuel-lean and fuel-rich flammability limits are approximately ϕ = 0.35 and ϕ = 5 for all mixture compositions. The flame speed increases with ϕ to reach a maximum value at a fuel-rich condition, and thereafter decreases. Table 4.2 lists the maximum values of SL and the corresponding equivalence ratios denoted by φ max SL . The flame speed increases with H2 content, but the associated φ max SL decreases.
105
Fundamental Combustion Characteristics of Syngas
Flame Speed (cm/s)
400
05% CO + 95% H2 25% CO + 75% H2 50% CO + 50% H2 75% CO + 25% H2 95% CO + 05% H2
300
200
100
1
0
2 3 Equivalence Ratio
4
5
Figure 4.2 Flame speeds as a function of equivalence ratio for various H2/CO mixtures, p = 1 atm and Tin = 300 K.
Table 4.2 Maximum Flame Speeds and Corresponding Equivalence Ratios for H2/CO Mixtures in Air H2:CO SL (cm/s) ϕmax SL
05:95
25:75
50:50
75:25
95:05
100:0
73 2.7
144 2.35
206 2.08
264 1.85
307 1.69
318 1.65
Figure 4.3 shows the flame structure of premixed combustion in terms of spatial variations of major and minor species and temperature for different equivalence ratios (ϕ = 0.6, 1.0, and 2.08) of a CO/H2 (50:50) mixture in air. The value of φ max SL = 2.08 corresponds to the maximum flame speed. At the fuel-lean condition, CO and H2 are entirely consumed to produce CO2 and H2O. In the fuel-rich case, however, a large quantity of unreacted CO remains after combustion. On the burned side, the CO concentration even increases slightly because of CO2 dissociation. Similarly, the nonnegligible mass fraction of H2 promotes the presence of intermediate species such as H. The increase in equivalence ratio up to 2.08 leads to a decrease in the characteristic flame thickness (δf). The trend is clear when H2O2 concentrations over different equivalence ratios are compared. The premixed flame thickness is related to the thermal diffusivity (aT) and the flame speed as δf ~ aT /SL . The observed trend is expected since the flame speed increases with the equivalence ratio up to φ max SL. The maximum flame temperature, however, is attained near the stoichiometric condition
106
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
CO
0.00 –0.2
Mass Fractions
H 2O
H2 0.0
0.2
O2
0.15
CO
Temperature
2.0
CO2
1.5
H 2O
0.10 0.05 0.00 –0.2
1.0
H2
0.5 0.0
0.2
2.0
CO
0.20 0.15
Temperature O2
CO2
0.10 0.05 0.00 –0.2
H2O H2
1.5 1.0 0.5
0.0 0.2 Position (cm)
0.4
4 2
8
0.1
0.2
0.4
0.3
φ = 1.0
6
H O OH HO2 × 10 H2O2 × 10
4 2 0 0.0
0.4
φ = 2.08
Mass Fractions
0.25
2.5
H O OH HO2 × 10 H2O2 × 10
6
0 0.0
0.4
φ = 1.0
0.20
0.30
0.5
Mass Fractions (10–3)
0.05
1.0
Mass Fractions (10–3)
0.10
0.25
1.5
Mass Fractions (10–3)
CO2
0.15
φ = 0.6 Temperature (1000 K)
O2
0.20
2.0
Temperature
Temperature (1000 K)
φ = 0.6
Temperature (1000 K)
Mass Fractions
0.25
8
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
φ = 2.08 H O OH HO2 × 10
6
H2O2 × 10
4 2 0 0.0
0.1
0.2 0.3 Position (cm)
0.4
Figure 4.3 Spatial distributions of major and minor species for a 50:50 H2/CO mixture at ϕ = 0.6, ϕ = 1.0, and ϕ = 2.08.
(ϕ = 1). Figure 4.4 shows the adiabatic flame temperatures and flame speeds for three different H2/CO compositions as a function of equivalence ratio. The maximum flame temperature always occurs at a fuel-rich condition close to ϕ = 1, but not near the equivalence ratio corresponding to the peak value of SL . The maximum adiabatic flame temperature occurs near the stoichiometric value, where all the available reactants are transformed entirely into products causing maximum heat release. For the combustion of conventional hydrocarbons fuels (methane, propane, etc.), however, the flame speed and adiabatic temperature profiles are correlated more closely when plotted as a function of equivalence ratio. The maximum flame speed for hydrocarbon fuels occurs around the stoichiometric condition, whereas for pure hydrogen it is around 1.7.
107
Fundamental Combustion Characteristics of Syngas
250
2200
200
2000 150 1800 100
1600
Flame Speed (cm/s)
2400 Adiabatic Temperature (K)
300
50:50 H2:CO 25:75 H2:CO 75:25 H2:CO
50
1400 1
2 3 Equivalence Ratio
4
5
0
Figure 4.4 Adiabatic flame temperature (lines) and flame speed (symbols and lines) as a function of equivalence ratio for 25:75, 50:50, and 75:25 H2/CO mixtures.
4.2.2.2 CO2, H2O, and N2 Dilution Since one or more of the species, CO2, H2O, N2, or CH4, are likely to be present in a practical syngas composition, the impact of these diluents on the flame structure and speed has to be carefully studied. The diluents can affect the combustion characteristics by influencing adiabatic flame temperature, specific heat of mixtures, chemical kinetics rates, and radiative heat transfer. Addition of a diluent to the fuel will reduce the flame temperature, and hence the laminar flame speed by reducing the reaction rate. Figure 4.5a,b,c shows the flame speeds of three CO/H2 compositions at different equivalence ratios as a function of percentage of dilution with CO2, H2O, or N2, where, for example, 20% of CO2 dilution implies a 40:40:20 H2/CO/CO2 mixture. The slopes of the curves show that the impact of diluents becomes most significant in the fuel-rich case (ϕ = 2.08). For a given dilution percentage and equivalence ratio, the flame speed is highest with N2, followed by H2O and then CO2. A similar trend is seen in Figure 4.6a, with respect to the maximum flame temperature attained. The diluents, H2O and CO2, may undergo decomposition and then be regenerated through the flame. Energy is spent in bond breaking and liberated in recombination, and as a consequence, the flame speeds and adiabatic temperatures are lower than their counterparts for dilution with N2. The addition of H2O and CO2, which also happen to be the final combustion products, may slightly enhance the backward reaction rates of a few exothermic elementary reactions. The increase in cp (triatomic H2O and CO2 vs. diatomic N2) and smaller diffusivities of H2O and CO2 (smaller than that of H2O), however, are likely to have a greater effect on the reduction of flame speed than their decomposition.
108
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications 250 φ = 0.6 φ=1 φ = 2.08
Flame Speed (cm/s)
200
CO2 dilution
150
H2O dilution N2 dilution
100
50
0
20
40 Dilution (%) (a)
60
80
300 φ = 0.6 φ=1 φ = 2.08
Flame Speed (cm/s)
250 200
CO2 dilution
150
N2 dilution
H2O dilution
100 50
0
20
40
60
80
Dilution (%) (b)
Figure 4.5 Flame speed response to variable CO2, H2O, and N2 dilution for (a) 50:50, (b) 75:25, and (c) 25:75 H2/CO mixtures at three equivalence ratios.
Figure 4.6a shows that the CO2 mass fraction in the burned gases of the 50:50 H2/CO fuel mixture remains nearly constant for the considered range of dilution with H2O or N2. The same is true for the H2O mass fraction in burned gases as seen in Figure 4.6b, when the diluent is either CO2 or N2. The CO mass fraction in burned gases, however, reveals some chemical activity at 30% and 40% dilutions with CO2
109
Fundamental Combustion Characteristics of Syngas 150 φ = 0.6 φ=1 Flame Speed (cm/s)
φ = 2.08 100
CO2 dilution H2O dilution N2 dilution
50
0
20
40 Dilution (%) (c)
60
80
Figure 4.5 (Continued.)
and N2, respectively. No such activity for CO is seen for dilution with H2O. In addition to 50:50 H2/CO at ϕ = 1, several other simulations (not shown here) were conducted for 25:75 and 75:25 cases at different equivalence ratios. In these cases, the flame response to the variable dilution exhibits a similar behavior. In order to separate the thermal and chemical effects of dilution, the flame speeds of various H2/CO fuel mixtures are replotted as a function of the adiabatic flame temperature in Figure 4.7a,b,c. Three different equivalent ratios are considered over the dilution range of 0 to 70%. The highest equivalent ratio corresponds to the maximum flame speed in each case, i.e., 2.08 for 50:50, 1.85 for 75:25, and 2.35 for 25:75 H2/CO fuel mixtures, respectively. The strongest impact on the flame speed results from the thermal effect of dilution; however, the chemical effect is also evident. The chemical activity of H2O and CO2 is observed to change with the equivalence ratio. For the lean mixture, both H2O and CO2 dilution equally decreases the flame speed for an equivalent flame temperature. The situation for the fuel-rich case becomes considerably different. The chemical effect of H2O dilution is more prevalent, causing a steeper decrease in the flame speed at flame temperatures below 1800 K. For the stoichiometric mixture, CO2 dilution has the largest impact, particularly for temperatures greater than 1600 K. Methane was added to the 50:50 H2/CO composition, in combination with varying dilutions of H2O/CO2/N2. Table 4.3 summarizes the flame characteristics of 50:50 H2/CO stoichiometric mixtures in air with different levels of dilution in fuel. The characteristics tabulated include flame speed, adiabatic flame temperature, and CO2 mass fraction in burned gases. Introduction of 5% CH4 alone to a nondiluted H2/CO mixture does not change the flame speed or adiabatic temperature,
110
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
1.00
N2 dil. H2O dil. CO2 dil.
0.80
2500
Diluents Temperature COb2
2400
0.60
2200 2100
0.40
Temperature (K)
Mass Fractions
2300
2000 0.20
0.00
1900
0
10
20
30
40
1800
Dilution (%) (a) 0.3
H2Ob
N2 dil.
COu COb
H2O dil.
Mass Fractions
CO2 dil.
0.2
0.1
0.0
0
10
20 30 Dilution (%)
40
50
(b)
Figure 4.6 Effect of dilution (N2, H2O, or CO2) on adiabatic flame temperature and maximum mass fractions of major species for a 50:50 H2/CO mixture at ϕ = 1.0. Subscripts u and b indicate unburned and burned.
111
Fundamental Combustion Characteristics of Syngas 50:50 H2/CO Fuel Mixture CO2 H2O N2 φ = 1.0
sin
100
gd
ilu
tio
n
150
φ = 2.08
In cr ea
Flame Speed (cm/s)
200
50
I 0
1500
rea nc
sin
on
uti
il gd
2000
Flame Temperature (K)
Flame Speed (cm/s)
40
30
φ = 0.6 CO2 H2O
N2
20
10
0 1200
a cre In
sin
1400 1600 Flame Temperature (K) (a)
on
uti
il gd
1800
Figure 4.7 Effect of dilution (N2, H2O, or CO2) on adiabatic flame temperature and flame speed for (a) 50:50, (b) 75:25, and (c) 25:75 H2/CO mixtures at three equivalence ratios.
but slightly decreases the CO2 mass fraction. As compared to the results with dilution of 2.5:1.25:1.25 H2O/CO2/N2, the CH4/H2/CO flame has higher flame speed and adiabatic temperature, but a lower concentration of CO2. On increasing the overall dilution from 10 to 45%, but keeping the amount of CH4 constant at 5%, the adiabatic temperature is not significantly reduced. The flame speed, however, is noticeably lower than that for the corresponding CH4/H2/CO flame. The corresponding CO2 mass fraction in the burned gases, on the other hand, increases with dilution. The
112
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications 75:25 H2/CO Fuel Mixture φ = 1.85 CO2 H2O N2
200
n
φ = 1.0
sin
gd
ilu
tio
150 cr ea
100
In
Flame Speed (cm/s)
250
50
a cre In
0 1000
sin
1500 2000 Flame Temperature (K)
60
φ = 0.6
CO2 H2O N2
50 Flame Speed (cm/s)
on
uti
il gd
40 30 20
ea cr In
10 0 1200
n
tio
1400
g
sin
lu di
1600 1800 Flame Temperature (K) (b)
2000
Figure 4.7 (Continued.)
flame speed remains nearly constant for the two cases of 45% dilution, with and without CH4. For any given level of dilution, the CO2 mass fraction in burned gases is smaller when CH4 is present. 4.2.2.3 Pressure and Temperature Effects Flame speed also varies with the inlet preheated temperature and pressure. Figure 4.8a shows the variation of flame speed with pressure, for a syngas mixture
113
Fundamental Combustion Characteristics of Syngas 25:75 H2/CO Fuel Mixture φ = 2.35 CO2 H2O N2
tio n
100
sin
gd
ilu
φ = 1.0
In cr ea
Flame Speed (cm/s)
150
50
Inc
0 1000
s rea
n
tio
ilu
d ing
1500 2000 Flame Temperature (K)
35
Flame Speed (cm/s)
φ = 0.6
CO2 H2O N2
30 25 20 15
g
10
I
r nc
sin ea
n
tio
lu di
5 0 1200
1400
1600 1800 Flame Temperature (K) (c)
2000
Figure 4.7 (Continued.)
of 40:40:20 H 2/CO/H 2O at different inlet temperatures and equivalence ratios. The flame speed reduces monotonically with the increase in pressure. A similar trend is seen for the flame thickness, as depicted by species concentrations in Figure 4.8b. Changes in pressure and temperature may alter the pathways and kinetic rates of the ongoing chemical reactions, leading to a change in the flame speed and the spatial distribution of mass fractions of species. In general, an increase in pressure raises the overall reaction rate, and consequently should tend
114
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Table 4.3 Flame Characteristics of H2/CO (50:50) Stoichiometric Mixtures in Air with Various Diluents Degree of Dilution
Diluent Composition CH4:H2O:CO2:N2
SL (cm/s)
Tad (K)
YCO2
0% 5%
0:0:0:0 5:0:0:0 0:2.5:1:25:1.25 5:2.5:1.25:1.25 0:5:2.5:2.5 5:7.5:3.75:3.75 0:10:5:5 5:20:10:10 0:22.5:11.25:11.25
120 121 114.3 101.7 108.1 89.2 94.4 53.7 53.85
2,362 2,371 2,334 2,322 2,311 2,271 2,250 2,090 2,020
0.2277 0.2101 0.2332 0.2184 0.2389 0.2272 0.2511 0.2519 0.2862
10% 20% 45%
to increase the flame speed. But the elevated density necessitates more thermal energy transfer from the reaction zone to raise the reactant temperature in the preheat zone. Since thermal diffusivity is inversely proportional to pressure, the net effect of increase in pressure leads to a reduction in flame speed. The same phenomena are observed for other compositions of species (H 2:CO:diluents), but are not shown here. Figure 4.8c shows the impact of pressure on adiabatic flame temperature for four different inlet conditions. In the fuel-lean cases, no influence of p is revealed. For stoichiometric flames, however, a difference of 4% (~100 K) in the adiabatic flame temperature for the two inlet temperatures indicates the importance of product dissociation at the higher flame temperature of the stoichiometric mixture at low pressure.
4.3 Counterflow Diffusion Flames Figure 4.9 shows the schematic of the counterflow configuration for studying nonpremixed flames. The physical model considered here is an axisymmetric laminar diffusion flame, stabilized somewhere near the stagnation plane of opposing syngas and air streams. This type of configuration is frequently used to investigate nonpremixed combustion, as it is approximately one-dimensional and because the residence times within the flame zone can be varied with ease. The flow is characterized by a strain rate, εs, which represents a characteristic velocity gradient for the flow. An increase in εs leads to a decrease in the flow residence time in the flame zone. A critical strain rate, εsext, represents the limit when the flame is quenched. This key parameter (εsext ) is tracked in simulations of nonpremixed syngas flames using the detailed modeling of counterflow flame (DMCF) code (Darabiha et al., 1988; Darabiha 1992). The code incorporates detailed chemical kinetic mechanisms and multispecies transport through the CHEMKIN package (Kee et al., 1986).
115
Fundamental Combustion Characteristics of Syngas
500 φ = 0.5, T = 300 K φ = 0.5, T = 600 K φ = 0.5, T = 700 K φ = 1.0, T = 300 K φ = 1.0, T = 600 K φ = 1.0, T = 700 K
Flame Speed (cm/s)
400
300
200
100
0
10
20
30 Pressure (bar)
40
50
1E–06
0.20
8E–07
HCO, 50 bar CO, 50 bar CO2, 50 bar HCO, 10 bar CO, 10 bar CO2, 10 bar
0.15
0.10
0.05
0.00 0.05
6E–07
4E–07
HCO Mass Fraction
CO and CO2 Mass Fractions
(a) 0.25
2E–07
0.06
Position (cm)
0.07
0 0.08
(b)
Figure 4.8 Effect of pressure on (a) flame speed at different inlet temperatures and equivalence ratios, (b) species profiles through the flame front, and (c) adiabatic temperature at inlet temperatures and equivalence ratios (40:40:20 H2/CO/H2O mixture).
116
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Normalized Adiabatic Temperature
1
0.99
0.98
0.97
Tad, φ = 1, T = 300 K Tad, φ = 1, T = 600 K
Tad, φ = 0.5, T = 300 K
0.96
0.95
Tad, φ = 0.5, T = 600 K
10
40
20 30 Pressure (bar) (c)
50
Figure 4.8 (Continued.)
Flame Stagnation plane
Syngas
Air y x
Z = Zst
Figure 4.9 Schematic view of a counterflow diffusion flame.
Fundamental Combustion Characteristics of Syngas
117
4.3.1 H2/CO Mixtures Figure 4.10 shows the variation of the maximum temperature with the strain rate. The pressure is set to 1 bar and the incoming flow temperatures of the opposing streams are 300 K. Five different H2/CO compositions (5:95, 25:75, 50:50, 75:25, and 95:5) were treated and simulations were performed until the extinction limit of the strain rate (εsext ) was reached. As the strain rate increases, the maximum temperature decreases monotonically and eventually reaches a point where the flame is quenched. The temperature at εsext is referred to as the quenching temperature. For very low strain rates, Tmax is in the range of 2200 to 2350 K. For all H2/CO compositions, the quenching temperatures are found to be between 1300 and 1350 K. The higher value of εsext with increasing H2 concentration implies a stronger resistance to flame quenching. The value progressively increases from 6000 s–1 for 5% H2 to about 27,500 s–1 for 95% H2. The heat-release rate per unit flame area ( q s ) is defined by
q s =
Ns h W ω dy k k k −∞ k =1
∫ ∑ +∞
(4.1)
where hk, Wk, and ω k represent the mass enthalpy, molecular weight, and reaction rate of species k, respectively. Figure 4.10b shows the heat-release rate as a function of the strain rate for five different H2/CO compositions. For a nonquenched flame, the heat-release rate decreases slightly with the increase in the percentage of H2.
4.3.2 CO2, H2O, and N2 Dilution Figure 4.11a shows the maximum temperature as a function of strain rate for different dilution concentrations of H2O. The value of Tmax decreases with the increase in dilution, but the corresponding εsext is slightly reduced. The dilution does not affect the heat-release rate per unit flame area (Figure 4.11b.) Figure 4.12 shows the variation of maximum temperature and heat-release rate with the strain rate, for 20% dilution with each of N2, H2O, and CO2. The curves with different diluting species overlap completely, implying that any diluent would result in the same level of maximum temperature and heat-release rate. The corresponding flame structures, however, are dissimilar. Figure 4.13a and b exhibits the flame structure in terms of major species at strain rates of 1000 s–1 and 10,000 s–1, respectively. All three 20% dilution cases are shown. The main products of H2/CO/diluent air combustion are H2O and CO2. For dilution with N2 or CO2, the mass fraction of H2O starts from zero on both sides of the counterflow burner and attains a peak value of ~0.22 in the flame zone. A similar trend is observed for CO2 concentration with diluent N2 or H2O, except it has a much lower peak (~0.025) in the flame zone. For dilution with H2O, the peak value of H2O mass fraction is ~0.24. The increase in the strain rate (Figure 4.13b) lowers the peak in the H2O concentration to ~0.2 for dilution with CO2 or N2. Figure 4.13a shows that on approaching the flame from the syngas (right) side, the CO2 mass fraction decreases to a local minimum followed by a feeble rise to a local
118
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications 2400 05% H2, 95% CO
Maximum Temperature (K)
2200
25% H2, 75% CO 50% H2, 50% CO
2000
75% H2, 25% CO 95% H2, 05% CO
1800 1600 1400 1200
0
10000 20000 Strain Rate (1/s) (a)
3.50
Heat-Release Rate (102 W. cm–2)
3.00 2.50 2.00 1.50
05% H2, 95% CO
1.00
25% H2, 75% CO 50% H2, 50% CO
0.50
75% H2, 25% CO 95% H2, 05% CO
0.00
0
10000 Strain Rate (1/s) (b)
20000
Figure 4.10 Effect of strain rate on (a) maximum temperature and (b) heat-release rate for five different H2/CO mixtures.
maximum, before it decreases to zero on the oxidizer side. Increasing the strain rate to 10,000 s–1 erases the local extrema (Figure 4.13b). Figure 4.14a and b exhibits the flame structure in terms of minor species at strain rates of 1000 s–1 and 10,000 s–1, respectively, for syngas diluted with 20% CO2. The two sets of peaks on either side of the diffusion flame indicate two distinct zones of chemical activity, which somehow lead
119
Fundamental Combustion Characteristics of Syngas 2400
Maximum Temperature (K)
2200 2000 1800 1600 1400
1200
50%
102
103 Strain Rate (1/s)
0%
104
105
Heat-Release Rate (102 W. cm–2)
(a) 5 4 3
0%
2
50%
1
101
102
103 Strain Rate (1/s) (b)
104
105
Figure 4.11 Effect of strain rate on (a) maximum temperature and (b) heat-release rate for different levels of H2O dilution.
to a unique peak in the temperature profile (the temperature profile is not shown). On the oxidizer side, O2 and H2 first react to form HO2 and H2O2, and subsequently form the transient species of OH, H, and O. On the syngas side, only hydrocarbon and oxygenated hydrocarbon species are present, namely, CH2O, HCO, and CH4. The entire diffusion flame structure thus exhibits two distinct chemical zones. The phenomenon makes it difficult to reduce the detailed kinetic scheme to simpler semi-global mechanisms. Figure 4.14b shows that the increase in the strain rate considerably reduces the
120 2400
3.0
2200
2.5
2000
2.0
1800
1.5
1600
1.0
1400
0.5
1200
0
5000
10000 Strain Rate (1/s)
15000
Heat-Release Rate (102 W. cm–2)
Maximum Temperature (K)
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
0.0 20000
Figure 4.12 Effect of strain rate on maximum temperature and heat-release rate for 20% dilution with N2 (–), H2O (), and CO2 (▲) dilution.
OH concentration and promotes the formation of HO2. Switching the diluent from H2O to CO2 or N2 changes the flame structure slightly (not shown here).
4.3.3 Pressure Effects Figure 4.15a shows the heat-release rate q s as a function of the strain rate for different H2/CO compositions at three different pressures (1, 15, and 30 bar). The inlet temperature is fixed at 300 K. Results are compared with those for a CH4-air counterflow diffusion flame at the same operating conditions. At a given pressure, the heat-release rate increases with the strain rate, with the slopes of all the curves being ~0.5. The heat-release rate for the CH4-air flame is equivalent to that for the 50:50 H2/CO flame. However, εsext is much shorter for the CH4-air flames. Thus, switching from methane to syngas in a device that encounters diffusion flames may lead to a more stable and resistant flame with a slightly higher flame temperature (less than 10% at a given pressure). Based on Figure 4.15a, the heat-release rate per unit flame area may be described by a simple expression,
( )
q s = αεs
1/ 2
(4.2)
where the coefficient α depends on pressure and syngas composition. Figure 4.15b shows that α varies linearly with pressure. The H2/CO composition is 50:50 and the stain rate is 20 s–1. Figure 4.15c shows the effect of three different strain rates, εs = 20, 900, and 15,000 s–1, on the heat-release rate in a pressure range of 1 to 40 bar. The inlet temperature is fixed at 300 K. The heat-release rate is plotted as a function of pεs, the
121
Fundamental Combustion Characteristics of Syngas 0.4
CO2 H2O
CO
H2O dil.
0.3 Mass Fractions
εs = 1000 s–1
CO2 dil. N2 dil. O2
0.2
0.1
0.0
–2
0.4
CO2 H2O
0 Position (cm) (a)
1
εs = 10000 s–1
2
CO
H2O dil.
0.3 Mass Fractions
–1
CO2 dil. N2 dil. O2
0.2
0.1
0
–1
–0.5
0 Position (cm)
0.5
1
(b)
Figure 4.13 Spatial distributions of major species (O2, CO, CO2, and H2O) for a 20% dilution with N2, H2O (■), and CO2 () at two strain rates: (a) 1000 s–1 and (b) 10,000 s–1.
product of pressure and strain rate. A functional relationship of q s ~ pεs is exhibited, except near point A (pεs ~ 15,000 bar/s), which represents the flame extinction limit close to 1 bar. The correlation is similar to the situation observed in a H2-air or H2-O2 counterflow diffusion flame (Ribert et al., 2007). In the case of 20% dilution with H2O, CO2, or N2 species, the same correlation remains valid.
122
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
12
H × 103 O × 103 OH × 103 HO2 × 106 H2O2 × 106 CH4 × 106 CH2O × 106 HCO × 106
εs = 1000 s–1
Mass Fractions
10 8 6 4 2 0
–2
–1
0
1
2
Position (cm) (a) 30
H ×103 O × 103 OH × 103 HO2 × 106 H2O2 × 106 CH4 × 106 CH2O × 106 HCO × 106
εs = 10000 s–1
Mass Fractions
25 20 15 10 5 0
–1
–0.5
0 Position (cm) (b)
0.5
1
Figure 4.14 Spatial distributions of minor species for 20% dilution with CO2 for two different strain rates.
123
Fundamental Combustion Characteristics of Syngas
Heat-Release Rate (102 W. cm–2)
30 bar 15 bar 101
1 bar 100
10–1 1 10
25% H2, 75% CO 50% H2, 50% CO 75% H2, 25% CO 100% H2 100% CH4 102
103
104
105
106
40
50
Strain Rate (1/s) (a)
εs = 20 s–1
α Parameter
400
300
200
100
0
0
10
20
30
Pressure (bar) (b)
Figure 4.15 (a) Variations of heat-release rate with strain rate at different pressures. (b) Effect of pressure on α parameter at a strain rate of 20 s–1. (c) Heat-release rate as a function of product of pressure and strain rate.
124
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Heat-Release Rate (102 W. cm–2)
102 εs = 20 s–1 εs = 900 s–1 εs = 15000 s–1 101
100
10–1 101
102
103
p . εs
104
105
106
(c)
Figure 4.15 (Continued.)
4.4 Strained Counterflow Premixed Flames A twin laminar counterflow premixed flame was also simulated, using the DMCF code. The same composition of premixed syngas was used on both sides. The pressure was set to 1 bar and the inlet temperature was 300 K. Figure 4.16a and b shows the variation of Tmax and q s with the strain rate for different compositions. As the H2 quantity in the mixture decreases, the strained premixed flames show less resistance to quenching. This may be due partly to the fact that the level of dilution increases as the quantity of H2 is reduced. The same trend is also observed for q s. As compared to syngas diffusion flames (Figure 4.10a), strained premixed flames exhibit lower values of εsext and hence are easier to quench. For the former case, q s increases with the strain rate (Figure 4.10b). In contrast, for the latter case, q s decreases with the increase in strain rate. These observations have also been made for classical fuels such as methane (Im et al., 1996), and syngas combustion follows the same trend.
4.5 Conclusions The characteristics of syngas combustion have been investigated. Laminar flames in premixed and counterflow diffusion configurations, as well as the ignition characteristics in homogeneous and perfectly stirred reactors (PSRs), were studied in detail by treating various syngas compositions at different operating conditions. The ignition time delay is found to be strongly dependent on the pressure and the inlet/preheated temperature. The lower value of ignition delay for the PSR than for the homogenous reactor can be attributed to the perfect mixing of incoming reactant mixture with a
125
Fundamental Combustion Characteristics of Syngas
2400
Maximum Temperature (K)
2200 2000 1800 1600 1400
1200
50% H2 + 50% CO 40% H2 + 40% CO + 20% H2O 30% H2 + 30% CO + 40% H2O 30% H2 + 30% CO + 20% H2O + 20% CO2 30% H2 + 30% CO + 20% H2O + 20% N2 102
103 Strain Rate (1/s) (a)
104
Heat-Release Rate (102 W . cm–2)
3
2
1 50% H2 + 50% CO 40% H2 + 40% CO + 20% H2O 30% H2 + 30% CO + 40% H2O 30% H2 + 30% CO + 20% H2O + 20% CO2 30% H2 + 30% CO + 20% H2O + 20% N2 102
103 Strain Rate (1/s)
104
(b)
Figure 4.16 Effect of strain rate on (a) maximum temperature and (b) heat-release rate for a premixed syngas flame in a counterflow configuration.
developing pool of radicals in the former case. At low temperature, the PSR extinction time is much lower than its ignition delay. Consequently, the critical residence time to maintain combustion is much shorter (~106–7 times at 700 K) than that for autoignition at low temperature, which indicates that even a tiny ignition source would enhance combustion tremendously. The estimated ignition delays at low temperatures, however, are not in good agreement with experimental data. Many factors,
126
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
such as physical mixing, different operating conditions, and catalytic surfaces, could be responsible for the departure of predictions from experimental results. The laminar flame speed for premixed syngas systems increases with H2 concentration. The flame speed exhibits a strong dependence on pressure, inlet/preheated temperature, and equivalence ratio. The maximum flame speed occurs at a fuel-rich condition, whereas the maximum flame temperature occurs near the stoichiometric value. The dilution of syngas with N2, CO2, or H2O lowers the flame speed. For a given dilution percentage and equivalence ratio, the flame speed and temperature are highest with N2, followed by H2O and then CO2. For counterflow diffusion flames, extinction limits of strain rate εsext are reported for various syngas compositions. The extinction limit increases with H2 concentration. The dilution of syngas does not affect the extinction limit, but it does alter the diffusion flame structure. Two zones of chemical activity are observed for the diffusion flame, one on the syngas side and the other on the air side. The heat-release rate per unit flame area correlates well with the product of the square root of pressure and strain rate. Compared to diffusion flames, premixed counterflow flames exhibit lower values of εsext and hence are easier to quench.
Acknowledgments This work was sponsored partly by the National Energy Technology Laboratory, U.S. Department of Energy, Grant DE-FG26-07NT43069, and partly by the Pennsylvania State University. The technical drawing service provided by Xiaodong Chen is gratefully acknowledged.
References Brabbs T. A., Belles F. E., and Brokaw R. S. (1970). Shock-tube measurements of specific reaction rates in branched-chain H2-CO-O2 systems. Proc. Combust. Inst. 13:129. Chaos M. and Dryer F. L. (2008). Syngas combustion kinetics and applications. Combust. Sci. Tech. 180:1053. CHEMKIN 4.0. (2004). San Diego: Reaction Design. Darabiha N. (1992). Transient behavior of laminar counterflow hydrogen air diffusion flames with complex chemistry. Combust. Sci. Tech. 86:163. Darabiha N., Giovangigli V., Candel S., and Smooke M. (1988). Extinction of strained premixed propane-air flames with complex chemistry. Combust. Sci. Tech. 60:267. Davis S. G., Joshi A. V., Wang F., and Egolfopoulos F. (2005). An optimized kinetic model of H2/CO combustion. Proc. Combust. Inst. 30:1283. Dean A. M., Steiner D. C., and Wang E. E. (1978). A shock tube study of the H2/O2/CO/Ar and H2/N2O/CO/Ar systems: Measurement of the rate constant for H+N2O = N2+OH*. Combust. Flame 32:73. Dryer F. L. and Chaos M. (2008). Ignition of syngas/air and hydrogen/air mixtures at low temperatures and high pressures: Experimental data interpretation and kinetic modeling implications. Combust. Flame 152:293. Gardiner W. C., Mallard W. G., McFarland M., Morinaga K., Owen J. H., Rawlins W. T., Takeyama T., and Walker B. F. (1972). Elementary reaction rates form post-inductionperiod profiles in shock-initiated combustion. Proc. Combust. Inst. 14:61.
Fundamental Combustion Characteristics of Syngas
127
Giles D. E., Som S., and Aggarwal S. K. (2006). NOX emission characteristics of counterflow syngas diffusion flames with airstream dilution. Fuel 85:1729. GRI-MECH. http://www.me.berkeley.edu/gri_mech/. Im H. G., Bechtold J. K., and Law C. K. (1996). Response of counterflow premixed flames to oscillating strain rates. Combust. Flame 105:358. Kee R., Dixon-Lewis G., Warnatz J., Coltrin M., and Miller J. (1986). A Fortran computer code package for the evaluation of gas phase multicomponent transport properties. Technical Report SAND86-8286 UC401, Sandia National Laboratories. Kee R. G., Grcar J. F., Smooke M. D., and Miller J. A. (1992). A Fortran program for modeling steady laminar one-dimensional premixed flames. Technical report, Sandia National Laboratories. Kim, T. J., Yetter R. A., and Dryer F. L. (1994). New results on moist CO oxidation: High pressure, high temperature experiments and comprehensive kinetic modeling. Proc. Combust. Inst. 25:759. Li J., Zhao Z. W., Kazakov A., Chaos M., Dryer F. L., and Scire J. J. (2007). A comprehensive kinetic mechanism for CO, CH2O, and CH3OH combustion. Int. J. Chem. Kinet. 39:109. Lieuwen T., McDonell V., Petersen E., and Santavicca D. (2006). Fuel flexibility influences on premixed combustor blowout, flashback, autoignition and stability. Paper GT2006-90770 presented at ASME Turbo Expo, Barcelona, Spain. Lieuwen T., McDonell V., Santavicca D., and Sattelmayer T. (2008). Burner development and operability issues associated with steady flowing syngas fired combustors. Combust. Sci. Tech. 180:1169. Markides C. N. and Mastorakos E. (2005). An experimental study of hydrogen autoignition in a turbulent co-flow of heated air. Proc. Combust. Inst. 30:881. McLean I. C., Smith D. B., and Taylor S. C. (1994). The use of carbon monoxide/hydrogen burning velocities to examine the rate of the CO+OH reaction. Proc. Combust. Inst. 25:749. Mittal G., Sung C.-J., and Yetter R. A. (2006). Autoignition of H2/CO at elevated pressures in a rapid compression machine. Int. J. Chem. Kinet. 38:516. Natarajan J., Nandula T., Lieuwen T., and Seitzman J. (2005). Laminar flame speeds of synthetic gas fuel mixtures. Paper GT2005-68917 presented at the ASME Turbo Expo, Reno, Nevada. Noble D. R., Zhang Q., Shareef A., Tootle J., Meyers A., and Lieuwen T. (2006). Syngas mixture composition effects upon flashback and blowout. Paper GT2006-90470 presented at the ASME Turbo Expo, Barcelona, Spain. Peschke W. T. and Spadaccini L. J. (1985). Determination of autoignition and flame speed characteristics of coal gases having medium heating values. Report EPRI AP-4291, Electric Power Research Institute. Petersen E. L., Kalitan D. M., Barrett A. B., Reehal S. C., Mertens J. D., Beerer D. J., Hack R. L., and McDonell V. G. (2007). New syngas/air ignition data at elevated pressure and comparison to current kinetics models. Combust. Flame 149:244. Qin X., Kobayashi H., and Niioka T. (2000). Laminar burning velocity of hydrogen-air premixed flames at elevated pressure. Exp. Thermal Fluid Sci. 21:58. Ribert G., Zong N., Yang V., Pons L., Darabiha N., and Candel S. (2008). Counterflow diffusion flames of general fluids: Oxygen/hydrogen mixtures. Combust. Flame 154(3):319–330. Rightley M. L. and Williams F. A. (1995). Analytical approximations for structures of wet CO flames with one-step reduced chemistry. Combust. Flame 101:287. Rightley M. L. and Williams F. A. (1997). Burning velocities of CO flames. Combust. Flame 110:285. Scholte T. G. and Vaags P. B. (1959). Burning velocities of mixtures of hydrogen, carbon monoxide and methane with air. Combust. Flame 3:511.
128
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
Shilling N. Z. and Lee D. T. (2003). IGCC—Clean power generation alternative for solid fuels: GE Power Systems. PowerGen Asia. Sivaramakrishnan R., Comandini A., Tranter R. S., Brezinsky K., Davis S. G., and Wang H. (2007). Combustion of CO/H2 mixture at elevated pressures. Proc. Combust. Inst. 31:429. Sun H., Yang S. I., Jomaas G., and Law C. K. (2007). High-pressure laminar flame speeds and kinetic modeling of carbon monoxide/hydrogen combustion. Proc. Combust. Inst. 31:439. Sung C.-J. and Law C. K. (2008). Fundamental combustion properties of H2/CO mixtures: Ignition and flame propagation at elevated pressures. Combust. Sci. Tech. 180:1095. Turns, S. (2000). An introduction to combustion. 2nd ed. New York: McGraw-Hill. Walton S. M., He X., Zigler B. T., and Wooldridge M. S. (2007). An experimental investigation of ignition properties of hydrogen and carbon monoxide mixtures for syngas turbine applications. Proc. Combust. Inst. 31:3147. Wang W. and Rogg B. (1993) Reduced kinetic mechanisms and their numerical treatment. I. Wet CO flames. Combust. Flame 94, 271. Yetter R. A., Dryer F. L., and Rabitz H. (1991a). A comprehensive reaction mechanism for carbon monoxide/hydrogen/oxygen kinetics. Combust. Sci. Tech. 79:97. Yetter R. A., Dryer F. L., and Rabitz H. (1991b). Flow reactor studies of carbon monoxide/ hydrogen/oxygen kinetics, Combust. Sci. Tech. 79:129. Zhang Q., Noble D. R., Meyers A., Xu K., and Lieuwen T. (2005). Characterization of fuel composition effects in H2/CO/CH4 mixtures upon lean blowout. Paper GT2005-68907 presented at the ASME Turbo Expo, Reno, Nevada.
Combustion 5 Turbulent Properties of Premixed Syngas Robert K. Cheng Contents 5.1 Introduction................................................................................................... 129 5.2 General Description of Turbulence Length and Time Scales....................... 131 5.3 Classification of Premixed Turbulent Flames and Turbulent-Flame Interactions.................................................................................................... 134 5.4 Heat-Release Rate and Turbulent Flame Speed............................................ 142 5.5 Effects of Syngas and Hydrogen on Turbulent Flame Speed........................ 154 5.6 Premixed Turbulent Combustion Properties at High Temperatures and Pressures................................................................................................. 157 5.7 Modeling Considerations for Syngas and Hydrogen Flames........................ 161 5.8 Conclusions.................................................................................................... 163 Acknowledgment.................................................................................................... 165 References............................................................................................................... 165
5.1 Introduction Lean premixed combustion is the technological foundation for the ultralow NOX industrial burners and for the dry-low-NOX (DLN) method employed in state-ofthe-art low-emissions gas turbines. Though effective, the lean premixed combustion method is hampered by undesirable side effects, such as flame instability and combustion oscillations. These problems can be exacerbated by the variations in the combustion properties of syngases. Therefore, understanding how the basic properties of premixed turbulent flames change with fuel compositions is essential to the development of fuel-flexible combustors that can burn a variety of syngases derived from coal gasification. Turbulence occurs naturally in all flow systems of practical interest and is one of the most significant unresolved problems of engineering physics. In combustion devices, turbulence is generated by the shearing fluid motions when the fuel and oxidizer streams mix with each other, or when the reactants flow through narrow internal passages. Once generated, turbulence can persist for an extended period before being dissipated by viscous forces. The coupling of turbulence with combustion involves complex thermal, fluid, and chemical processes that occur simultaneously 129
130
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
over a wide range of spatial and temporal scales. Many of these processes have not been well characterized or fully understood. Nevertheless, premixed turbulent flame models have been developed based on classic turbulence scaling laws and conceptual arguments on the reactive scalar structures and laminar flame behaviors. Turbulence has two roles in a premixed combustor. In the premixer, it promotes molecular mixing of the fuel and oxidizer streams into a homogeneous mixture for delivery to the burner. In the burner, turbulence produced in the wakes of the swirl vanes and the bluff bodies, together with residual turbulence in the flow of the reactants, controls most aspects of the flame. These aspects include the heat release rate, flame properties, flame evolution, and emissions. The most important role of turbulence is to increase the mean heat release rate. For premixed combustion, the rate of increase is often expressed in terms of a turbulent flame speed that is much higher than the laminar flame speed. Elucidating the underlying fluid-mechanical and chemical processes responsible for the increase in mean heat release by turbulence has been the central focus of fundamental research on premixed turbulent combustion. The studies involve measurements of velocity and scalar fields by laser diagnostics, development of turbulent flame models, numerical simulations of turbulence-flame interactions, and characterization of combustion dynamics. Due to the diversity of the subjects, there is a wealth of knowledge and information available in combustion textbooks and review articles (e.g., Libby and Williams, 1994; Peters, 2000; Bilger et al., 2005). The fundamental issue with syngas combustion is associated with the significant variation in their compositions that changes the laminar flame speed, heat release ratio, local fuel consumption rate, and flame front instability mechanisms. The responses of premixed turbulent flames to these changes are not well characterized or understood. Because of the presence of high hydrogen concentration in some syngases, the effects can be substantial and may cause a significant increase in the turbulent flame speed. This is a particular concern to manufacturers of industrial heaters and DLN gas turbines because of the increased propensity for the premixed turbulent flame to flash back. Despite decades of extensive research since Damkohler (1940) introduced the basic modeling concept for premixed turbulent flames, many issues regarding the turbulent flame speed and its relationship to the heat release rate are still unresolved. Several recent reviews called attention to this situation (Lipatnikov and Chomiak, 2002, 2005; Driscoll, 2008) and elaborated on the theoretical and computational approaches to address the problems. This chapter offers an alternate perspective to show that the generalization of Damkohler’s original premise has led to inconsistencies and discrepancies in the experimental data, and their sometimes contradictory implications. Consequently, the collective studies available in the scientific literature cannot give meaningful insights into the fuel effects unless the differences associated with the flame geometry and the experimental methods are scrutinized and carefully considered in the data interpretation. This chapter begins with an overview of the fundamental processes of premixed turbulent flames and the physical models for their analysis. This is followed by a review of the many approaches for defining and measuring the turbulent flame
Turbulent Combustion Properties of Premixed Syngas
131
speeds. The effects of burning syngases are addressed in the context of the characteristics of lean hydrogen premixed turbulent flames. The changes due to high temperatures and pressures are also reviewed. To close, general comments on the characteristic features of lean hydrogen turbulent flame structures and their implications on modeling of the heat release are given.
5.2 General Description of Turbulence Length and Time Scales Turbulence is a property of the flow and not of the fluid. It is sustained by receiving energy from the momentum of the bulk flow through shearing motions at the wall regions or around obstacles, such as swirl vanes or fuel spokes. Due to its random and chaotic nature, statistical methods are required to describe turbulence behavior (Hinze, 1959). The classic statistical turbulence model considers the flow as a chaotic array of eddies of widely different sizes being convected by the mean flow. The largest eddy sizes are on order of the flow passages or the characteristic dimensions of the combustion device. The smallest sizes are on the order of the characteristic length scale associated with molecular transport by viscosity. The wide range of eddy sizes are generated by vortex stretching in a cascading process through which the large eddies break down and transfer their energy to the smaller ones. Eventually, the energy contained in the smallest eddies is dissipated by viscous stresses. The basic property of turbulence can be described in terms of the spatial and temporal statistical distributions of the velocity vector using Reynolds decomposition of the turbulent fluid motion into a fluctuating velocity component, ui , about a mean velocity, Ui . The subscript i denotes the three orthogonal velocity components on the x, y, and z axes. Here, x is the principal axis in the direction of the mean flow. The distribution function for a given stochastic variable, that is, the time-varying velocity component at a point, is expressed by means of its probability density function (pdf), from which the statistical moments can be deduced. The first two moments of the velocity pdf are the mean and the variance. The Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) equations for Ui and ui contain a correlation turbulent stress tensor that represents turbulence production via a transfer of energy from the mean flow to the turbulent motions. The normal terms of the stress tensor are the root mean square (rms) fluctuating velocity components usually abbreviated as u′, v′, and w′ in combustion literature. The cross-terms are called shear stresses or Reynolds stresses, which are the cross-correlations between two of the three fluctuating velocity components, for example, ui uj . These cross-correlations are deduced from the joint pdfs of the two fluctuating velocity components. The presence of the stress tensor in RANS represents the first closure problem for turbulence modeling. Most commercial RANS codes for turbulent combustion use the κ-ε model to close the shear tensor, with κ being the turbulent kinetic energy and ε being its dissipation by eddy viscosity. The κ-ε model is based on the assumption that the turbulent transport processes are diffusive in nature so that the eddy viscosity relates to the shear forces through the mean velocity gradients. Inherent in this approach is that the turbulence is locally isotropic. Turbulence isotropy, which means
132
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
1.0
fx (r,t)
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
2
4
6
8 10 r (mm)
12
14
16
18
Figure 5.1 Two-point cross-correlation of isotropic turbulence produced by a perforated plate. The line is the exponential fit. Integration of the exponential fit gives an integral length scale l x of 2.5 mm, approximately the same as the hole size of the perforated plate.
that all three fluctuation components are equal to zero Reynolds stresses, rarely exists in complex combusting flows. Therefore, the modeling constants in RANS CFD calculations need to be well calibrated against combustion experiments. Dissipation is central to turbulence theory. It invokes the eddy cascade hypothesis to describe the rate at which energy is transferred from the large eddies to the small ones. For free shear flows without wall effects, dissipation is invariant within the inertial subrange of turbulence. The invariant dissipation process provides a theoretical basis for the development of scaling laws for turbulence scales that represent the size and strength of the turbulent eddies. Comparison of turbulence scales with the characteristic scales of premixed laminar flames is the foundation of premixed turbulent combustion theories and models. Experimentally, turbulence length scales are deduced from the cross-correlation coefficient, R( x , r , t ) = ui ( x , t )ui ( x + r , t ), of the velocity fluctuations ui at two points separated by a distance r. A typical shape of the normalized correlation function fi (r,t) = R(r,t)/u 2j (t ) is shown in Figure 5.1, where it approaches 1 at r → 0 and decays to 0 at large r. The decay range represents eddy sizes within the inertial subrange, which contains most of the turbulent kinetic energy. The length scale associated with these eddies is the integral length scale li and is defined by ∞
li (t ) =
∫ f (r , t)dr i
0
(5.1)
133
Turbulent Combustion Properties of Premixed Syngas
3
Dissipation
Energy cascade
Generation
Log E (k)
5
k lt
lk
Energy Spectrum
Figure 5.2 Typical turbulence energy spectrum.
The integral time scale, ti = li/ui′, with ui′ being the rms of the velocity fluctuation, is proportional to the mean turnover time of these eddies. Invoking the assumption of turbulence isotropy gives the Kolmogorov length scales lk at which the turbulent eddies are influenced by viscosity. The basic premise is that the rate of energy transfer from larger eddies at the integral length scale is equal to the dissipation rate of energy at the Kolmogorov scale. A Fourier transform of the isotropic two-point cross-correlation function yields the turbulent kinetic energy spectrum, E(k). It represents the density of kinetic energy per unit wave number, k, which is the inverse of the eddy size. Figure 5.2 shows a typical shape of the energy spectrum for isotropic turbulence on a log-log scale. The spectral distribution at the small wave numbers is in general not universal because it corresponds to the large eddies associated with flow instabilities at the inflow boundary. The maximum of E(k) is usually found at wave numbers corresponding to the integral length scale. The decrease in E(k) at larger wave number represents dissipation within the inertial subrange. The –5/3 slope of decay is a characteristic feature of the dissipation of homogeneous isotropic turbulence, and is derivable from analysis of the energy density distribution in wave number space. The drop-off at k > lk is due to viscous effects. The energy cascade spectrum, or the turbulence spectrum, relates the integral length scale and the Kolmogorov scale to turbulence intensities, and it has been the subject of extensive experimental and theoretical studies. Measuring the two point correlations presents some difficulties, especially at small r on the order of the Kolmogorov scale lk . The situation is much worse in combustion flows where the hostile environments prohibit the use of hot-wire anemometry, which has been the mainstay for verifying turbulence theories.
134
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
To circumvent these difficulties, the use of autocorrelation function at one point has become the prevalent method to measure the turbulence spectrum and the turbulence length scales. By invoking Taylor’s hypothesis, the turbulent eddies in a homogeneous turbulent flow with Ui >> ui can be perceived as being transported across the point of observation at a rate equal to the mean velocity along x. The fluctuation of the velocity at that point with time will be nearly identical to the instantaneous distribution of the velocity along x so that the autocorrelation function has the same distribution as the two-point cross-correlation function in the principal flow direction. The integral time scale ti, that is, the time integration of the autocorrelation function, can be used to deduce the integral length scale through simple space-time transformation, li = Ui ti. ∞
ti ( x ) =
∫ R(x, t, t + ∆t)dt
(5.2)
0
Analogously, the Fourier transform of the autocorrelation function yields the turbulent frequency spectrum. The integral of the turbulent frequency spectrum is the mean square of the velocity fluctuation. Taylor’s hypothesis, despite the limitation of its application to only the principal flow axis, is clearly a much simpler and convenient approach to measure turbulence length scales. In fact, the turbulence length scales reported in the combustion literature are mostly the longitudinal integral scale, lx, obtained from the autocorrection function.
5.3 Classification of Premixed Turbulent Flames and Turbulent-Flame Interactions The interaction between a discrete vortex and a planar laminar premixed flame is the simplest physical model of the premixed turbulent flame (Figure 5.3). Here, the laminar flame is considered to be a thin interface separating the reactants and products. This interface propagates into the reactants at a displacement flame speed, sD, which is close to the laminar flame speed, SL . When the size of the vortex is large compared to the thickness of this interface, the planar flame front becomes wrinkled as it burns through the vortex. The degree of flame wrinkling depends on the ratio between sD and the turbulence intensity of the single vortex, defined by the eddy size and its turnover velocity. If the flame front propagation rate is unchanged while it burns through the vortex, that is, fuel consumed by a unit area on the flame surface remains constant, wrinkling of the flame front increases the flame surface density per unit volume and thus the volumetric heat release rate. Wrinkling is therefore the primary process through which turbulence increases the mean heat release rate of a premixed flame. When the flame interacts with multiscale turbulence, its flame wrinkle structures become more complex in response to the range of turbulent eddy sizes. Typical wrinkled flame structures at low turbulence are shown in Figure 5.4 by a laser tomographic image of a premixed CH4/air flame at equivalence ratio ϕ = 0.7 (laminar flame speed SL = 0.196 m/s). This flame was generated in a low-swirl burner that
135
Turbulent Combustion Properties of Premixed Syngas
Products
SD
Vortex
Fl
am
ef
ro
nt
Reactants
Figure 5.3 Model of a planar laminar flame interacting with a discrete vortex. SD is the displacement flame speed of the front. (With permission.)
20 mm
Products Flame
Reactants
Co-flow air
Figure 5.4 Laser sheet tomographic image of a premixed turbulent flame in the wrinkled flamelet regime. The cold reactants appear bright due to Mie scattering from oil aerosol introduced in the flow. The oil aerosol burned and evaporated in the hot products to outline the topology of the wrinkled flame. (With permission.)
supplied a flow of reactants at a bulk flow velocity U0 = 5 m/s, turbulence intensity of u′ = 0.32 m/s, and integral length scale of lx = 3.5 mm (Cheng et al., 2002). In laser tomography, the reactants are seeded with an oil aerosol that burns and evaporates at the flame front. When illuminated by a thin laser sheet, the wrinkled flame is outlined by the sharp boundary between the reactants, which appeared bright due
136
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications C=1 Reaction zone
Preheat zone
Products
Reactants SL,0 C=0
dL Thermal thickness lf ~ 1 mm
Figure 5.5 Inner structure of a laminar flame.
to Mie scattering from the aerosol, and the products, which appeared dark due to absence of light scattering sites. The tomographic image of Figure 5.4 shows that the flame wrinkles have different sizes but are all on the order of 5lx . The topologies of the convex and concave wrinkles (relative to the reactants) are different. Whereas the convex wrinkles are rounded, the concave wrinkles are sharp and form into cusps. Formation of the flame cusps is a consequence of the flame fronts merging into each other as they propagate in the concave region. This occurs only when the eddy turnover time, estimated by lx /u′, is long compared to the flame residence time dL/sD, where sD is the local displacement flame speed and dL is the reaction zone thickness of the laminar flame defined by dLSL = ν, with ν being the fluid viscosity. The reaction zone thickness, dL , is one of two characteristic length scales of a laminar flame that is a convenient scaling parameter for premixed turbulent combustion. The other characteristic length scale is the preheat zone thickness, lf , and it is sometimes referred to as the thermal thickness. Figure 5.5 shows a schematic of the inner structure of a laminar flame to differentiate the two. The preheat zone is a chemically inert region where the temperature of the reactants increases due to heat transfer from the chemically active reaction zone in which fuel is consumed and radicals are depleted by chain-breaking reactions. For a CH4/air flame at atmospheric temperature and pressure, the preheat zone thickness, lf , is on the order of 1 mm. The corresponding reaction zone thickness is smaller by about an order of magnitude. Damkohler (1940) introduced the flame wrinkling concept as a theoretical foundation for premixed turbulent combustion. The formation of the flame cusps at low turbulence was one of the first characteristics to be identified. This phenomenon illustrates that the features of the flame wrinkles are dependent on the ratios of the turbulence scales and the flame scales. Subsequent elaboration on the flame wrinkling concept led to the classification of premixed turbulent flames into various regimes (Borghi, 1985; Peters, 1986; Abdel-Gayed et al., 1989; Poinsot et al., 1990). Many authors proposed regime diagrams that are expressed on phase spaces defined by the nondimensional parameters for the initial turbulence and flame conditions. Figure 5.6 shows a regime diagram by Peters (2000) that is expressed in terms of
137
Turbulent Combustion Properties of Premixed Syngas 103
Broken reaction zones
u´/SL
102
101
Re t
1
10–1 10–1
=
100
e: gim e Re than n o l Kaδ = 1 n Z smal ss ctio e Rea ce scal hickne n i Th ulen ame t n b erio Tur rmal fl Crit e s h m t illia l = lm ov-W m i l 1, K Ka = Wrinkled Flamelet Regime: Turbulence scale > chemistry scale Laminar Turbulence does not affect reaction zone flames 100
101
102
103
104
lx/dL
Figure 5.6 Regime diagram for premixed turbulent flames according to Peters (2000).
u′/SL and lx /dL . The nondimensional numbers associated with the two parameters are the turbulent Reynolds number,
Ret = (u′/SL)(lx/dL)
(5.3)
the Damköhler number representing the ratio of the turbulent time scale, tt , and the flame time scale, tf :
Da = (lx/dL) (u′/SL) –1 = tt /tf
(5.4)
and the Karlovitz number for the ratio of the reaction zone thickness to the Kolomogorov dissipation scale:
Ka = (u′/SL )3/2 (lx /dL) –1/2 = dL/lk
(5.5)
The boundaries between the regimes are defined by the lines Ret = 1 and Ka = 1. The Ret = 1 line separates the laminar flames from the turbulent flames. The Ka = 1 line in the turbulent flame region is known as the Klimov-Williams criterion, and it separates the wrinkled flamelet regime below from the thin reaction zone regime above. Ka = 1 means that the Kolmogorov scale of the incident turbulence is equal to the reaction zone thickness of the laminar flame. For flames with initial condition of Ka < 1, the smallest relevant turbulent eddies are larger than the reaction zone thickness. The role of turbulence is to wrinkle the flame front without affecting its inner chemical structure. The flame in Figure 5.4 is an example of a flame in the wrinkled flamelet regime. Flames with Ka > 1 are within the thin reaction zone regime where
138
Synthesis Gas Combustion: Fundamentals and Applications
10 mm Flame 1 u´/SL = 3.45 Parallel contours
c > 0.8 c = 0.7 c = 0.6 c = 0.5 c = 0.4 c = 0.3 c = 0.2 c < 0.2 Flame 6 u´/SL = 18.7 Complex topology and pockets
Figure 5.7 Two-dimensional Rayleigh scattering images of ϕ = 0.7 CH4/air flames with moderate, Ka = 1.3 (left), and intense, Ka = 17.1 (right), turbulence. (From Shepherd et al., 2002. With permission.)
the smallest turbulent eddies are smaller than the reaction zone thickness. These smallest eddies may influence the reactive-diffusive structure while the large eddies wrinkle the flame fronts. Peters also proposed an additional criterion of Kaδ = 1, with Kaδ defined by an inner-layer length scale lδ that replaces dL in Equation 5.5. lδ characterizes the fuel consumption layer within the flamelet. The physical meaning of Kaδ > 1 is that the smallest turbulent eddies can penetrate into the inner layer to disrupt the reactive-diffusive structures and locally quench the flamelet. Therefore, the region above the Kaδ = 1 line is called the broken reaction zone regime. In Figure 5.7, the wrinkled structures of flames at Ka ≈ 1 and Ka > 1 are shown by the two planar laser-induced Rayleigh scattering images from Shepherd et al. (2002). These lean CH4/air flames of ϕ = 0.7 were generated in a low-swirl burner