Synthetic Diamond Films
Synthetic Diamond Films Preparation, Electrochemistry, Characterization, and Applications
Edi...
87 downloads
1529 Views
125MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Synthetic Diamond Films
Synthetic Diamond Films Preparation, Electrochemistry, Characterization, and Applications
Edited by
Enric Brillas Carlos Alberto Mart´ınez-Huitle
The Wiley Series on Electrocatalysis and Electrochemistry Series Editor:
Andrzej Wieckowski
A John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Publication
Copyright © 2011 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. All rights reserved Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey Published simultaneously in Canada No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning, or otherwise, except as permitted under Section 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or authorization through payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, (978) 750-8400, fax (978) 750-4470, or on the web at www.copyright.com. Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, (201) 748-6011, fax (201) 748-6008, or online at http://www.wiley.com/go/permission. Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty: While the publisher and author have used their best efforts in preparing this book, they make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy or completeness of the contents of this book and specifically disclaim any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. No warranty may be created or extended by sales representatives or written sales materials. The advice and strategies contained herein may not be suitable for your situation. You should consult with a professional where appropriate. Neither the publisher nor author shall be liable for any loss of profit or any other commercial damages, including but not limited to special, incidental, consequential, or other damages. For general information on our other products and services or for technical support, please contact our Customer Care Department within the United States at (800) 762-2974, outside the United States at (317) 572-3993 or fax (317) 572-4002. Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic formats. For more information about Wiley products, visit our web site at www.wiley.com. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data: Synthetic diamond films : preparation, electrochemistry, characterization, and applications / edited by Enric Brillas, Carlos Alberto Mart´ınez-Huitle. p. cm.—(The Wiley series on electrocatalysis and electrochemistry) Includes index. ISBN 978-0-470-48758-7 (cloth) 1. Diamonds—Electric properties. 2. Diamond thin films. I. Brillas, Enric. II. Mart´ınez-Huitle, Carlos Alberto. TK7871.15.D53S96 2011 666 .88—dc22 2010053392 Printed in Singapore oBook ISBN: 978-1-118-06236-4 ePDF ISBN: 978-1-118-06234-0 ePub ISBN: 978-1-118-06235-7 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Contents
PREFACE
xix
PREFACE TO THE WILEY SERIES ON ELECTROCATALYSIS AND ELECTROCHEMISTRY
xxiii
CONTRIBUTORS
xxv
PART I
SYNTHESIS OF DIAMOND FILMS
1. Electrochemistry on Diamond: History and Current Status
1 3
John C. Angus
1.1
Enabling Technologies / 3 1.1.1 Chemical Vapor Deposition of Diamond / 3 1.1.2 Doping of Diamond / 4 1.1.3 Surface Characterization of Diamond / 5
1.2
First Studies of the Electrochemistry on Diamond / 5 1.2.1 From 1987 to 1996 / 5 1.2.2 From 1996 to Present / 6
1.3
Development of Electrochemical Applications of Diamond / 8 1.3.1 Surface Functionalization / 8 1.3.2 Destruction of Wastes / 9 1.3.3 Sensors and Electroanalysis / 9
1.4
Other Directions / 10 1.4.1 Biolectronic Applications / 10 1.4.2 Anomalous Surface Conductivity of Diamond / 11 v
vi
CONTENTS
1.5
Conclusions / 13 References / 13
2. Synthesis of Diamond Films
21
Vadali V. S. S. Srikanth and Xin Jiang
2.1
Introduction / 21
2.2
Diamond Film CVD Techniques / 23 2.2.1 History / 23 2.2.2 Thermal Decomposition Techniques / 25 2.2.2.1 Hot Filament Chemical Vapor Deposition (HFCVD) / 25 2.2.2.2 Oxy-Acetylene Torch Method / 25 2.2.3 Plasma-Aided Deposition Techniques / 26 2.2.3.1 Microwave Plasma-Enhanced CVD (MWCVD) / 26 2.2.3.2 DC Plasma CVD / 27 2.2.3.3 RF Plasma CVD / 28 2.2.3.4 Electron Cyclotron Resonance Microwave Plasma-Assisted CVD / 28
2.3
Diamond Nucleation and Growth / 28 2.3.1 Nucleation / 28 2.3.1.1 Definition and Types / 28 2.3.1.2 Methods / 30 2.3.2 Growth / 32 2.3.3 Role of Hydrogen and Oxygen / 39
2.4
Diamond Epitaxy / 40
2.5
Nanodiamond Thin Films / 45
2.6
Diamond Nanocomposite Films / 46
2.7
Conclusions / 48 References / 48
3. Types of Conducting Diamond Materials and Their Properties Marco A. Quiroz and Erick R. Bandala
3.1
Introduction / 57
3.2
Conducting Diamond Materials (CDMs) / 62
3.3
CDM Preparation Procedures / 63
3.4
CDM Doping Materials / 63 3.4.1 Characteristics of Boron-Doped CDMs / 63 3.4.2 Electrochemical Properties / 64
57
vii
CONTENTS
3.4.3 3.4.4 3.4.5 3.4.6
Photoelectrochemical Properties / 66 Optical Spectroscopy Properties / 67 Photo- and Cathodoluminescence Properties / 68 Electrical Conductivity and Superconductivity Properties / 69
3.5
Non-Boron-Doped CDMs / 69
3.6
Conclusions / 71 References / 71
PART II ELECTROCHEMISTRY OF DIAMOND FILMS
77
4. Electrochemistry of Diamond
79
Yuri Pleskov
4.1
Introduction / 79
4.2
Principal Electrochemical Properties of Diamond / 80
4.3
The Effect of Semiconductor Nature of Diamond on its Electrochemical Behavior / 83
4.4
The Effect of Crystal Structure on the Electrochemical Behavior of Diamond / 92 4.4.1 The Effect of Crystallographic Orientation of Crystal Faces / 92 4.4.2 The Effect of Surface Morphology / 95 4.4.3 The Effect of the Diamond Grain Size (or the Film Thickness, or the sp 2 -Carbon Impurity) / 98
4.5
Diamond-Based Nanostructures as Electrode Materials: Vacuum-Annealed Undoped Polycrystalline Diamond / 102
4.6
Conclusions / 106
4.7
Acknowledgments / 106 References / 106
5. Applications of Polycrystalline and Modified Functional Diamond Electrodes Yasuaki Einaga and Akira Fujishima
5.1
Introduction / 109
5.2
Preparation of BDD Electrodes / 110
5.3
Electrochemical Properties of BDD as Electrode Materials / 111
5.4
Applications in Electrochemical Analysis Using Polycrystalline BDD electrodes / 111 5.4.1 Detection of Free Chlorine / 111
109
viii
CONTENTS
5.4.2 5.4.3
Detection of Oxalic Acid / 113 Proteins (Including Cancer Markers) / 113
5.5
Modified Functional BDD Electrodes / 116 5.5.1 Production of High-Concentration Ozone-Water Using Free-Standing Perforated Diamond / 116 5.5.2 Modified Functional BDD Electrodes for Electrochemical Analysis / 119 5.5.2.1 Ion-Implanted BDD Electrodes / 119 5.5.2.2 Selective Detection of As(III) and As(V) by Stripping Voltammetry / 124 5.5.2.3 In vivo Dopamine Detection by BDD Microelectrodes / 125 5.5.2.4 BDD Nanograss Array (Whisker BDD) / 126
5.6
Conclusions / 130
5.7
Acknowledgments / 130 References / 131
6. Diamond Ultramicroelectrodes and Nanostructured Electrodes
133
Katherine B. Holt
6.1
Introduction / 133
6.2
Ultramicroelectrodes: Definition and Electrochemical Characteristics / 134
6.3
Boron-Doped Diamond UMEs / 136 6.3.1 Substrate Preparation and Growth of Diamond Films / 136 6.3.2 Insulation Methods and Control of Exposed Electrode Geometry / 140 6.3.3 Electrochemical Performance and Applications / 142
6.4
Boron-Doped Diamond UME Arrays / 143 6.4.1 Fabrication of BDD UME Arrays / 144 6.4.2 Electrochemical Performance and Applications / 146
6.5
Nanostructured BDD Electrodes / 147 6.5.1 Random Array BDD Nanodisk Electrodes / 147 6.5.2 Fabrication of Nanostructured BDD Arrays / 148 6.5.3 Electrochemical Performance and Applications of Nanostructured BDD Electrodes / 149
6.6
Conclusions and Future Directions / 150 References / 151
CONTENTS
ix
PART III ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS
153
7. Electroanalytical Applications of Diamond Films
155
Weena Siangproh, Amara Apilux, Pimkwan Chantarateepra, and Orawon Chailapakul
7.1
Introduction / 155
7.2
Pharmaceutical Compounds / 156
7.3
Biomolecules or Biological Compounds / 159
7.4
Pollutant Compounds / 162
7.5
Heavy Metals / 165
7.6
Food and Dietary Contaminants / 166
7.7
Miscellaneous / 168
7.8
Conclusions / 170
7.9
Acknowledgments / 178 References / 178
8. Cathodic Pretreatment of Boron-Doped Diamond Electrodes and Their Use in Electroanalysis Leonardo S. Andrade, Giancarlo R. Salazar-Banda, Romeu C. Rocha-Filho, and Orlando Fatibello-Filho
8.1
Introduction / 181
8.2
Cathodic Pretreatment of Conductive Diamond Films / 182
8.3
Electroanalytical Applications / 192 8.3.1 General Aspects / 192 8.3.2 Determination of Pesticides in Environmental Samples / 193 8.3.2.1 Carbaryl / 193 8.3.2.2 4-Nitrophenol / 193 8.3.2.3 Chlorophenols / 196 8.3.3 Determination of Substances in Food Samples / 198 8.3.3.1 Aspartame / 198 8.3.3.2 Sodium Cyclamate / 199 8.3.3.3 Aspartame and Sodium Cyclamate / 200 8.3.3.4 Total Phenols / 201 8.3.4 Determination of Substances in Pharmaceutical Samples / 201 8.3.4.1 Sulfamethoxazole and Trimethoprim / 201 8.3.4.2 Sulfamethoxazole and Sulfadiazine / 205
181
x
CONTENTS
8.3.4.3 8.3.4.4 8.3.4.5 8.3.4.6
Acetylsalicylic Acid / 205 Paracetamol and Caffeine / 206 Sildenafil Citrate (Viagra®) / 206 Lidocaine / 207
8.4
Gold Deposition and Stripping / 209
8.5
Conclusions / 209 References / 210
PART IV INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS 9. Use of Boron-Doped Diamond Electrode in Electrochemical Generation and Applications of Ferrate
213
215
Virender K. Sharma, Enric Brillas, Ignasi Sir´es, and Karel Bouzek
9.1
Introduction / 215
9.2
Electrochemical Generation of the Ferrate Ion with Iron Anodes / 217
9.3
Electrochemical Generation of the Ferrate Ion with Inert Anodes / 222
9.4
Electrochemical Generation of the Ferrate Ion with Boron-Doped Diamond Anode / 223 9.4.1 Acidic Medium / 223 9.4.2 Alkaline Medium / 225
9.5
Applications / 228 9.5.1 Common Inert Anodes / 228 9.5.2 Iron Anodes / 229 9.5.3 BDD Anode / 230
9.6
Conclusions / 233
9.7
Acknowlegments / 233 References / 233
10. Electrochemical Oxidation of Organic Compounds Induced by Electro-Generated Free Hydroxyl Radicals on BDD Electrodes Agnieszka Kapałka, Helmut Baltruschat, and Christos Comninellis
10.1
Introduction / 237
10.2
Influence of Anode Material on the Reactivity of Electrolytic Hydroxyl Radicals / 238
10.3
Electro-Generation and Detection of Quasi-Free Hydroxyl Radicals on BDD Electrode / 240
237
xi
CONTENTS
10.3.1 10.3.2 10.3.3 10.3.4
Hydroxyl Radicals Spin Trapping / 240 Trapping by Salicylic Acid / 240 Competitive Reactions / 242 Formation of Hydrogen Peroxide / 242
10.4
Concentration Profile of Hydroxyl Radicals on BDD Electrode / 244 10.4.1 HO • Concentration Profile during Oxygen Evolution / 244 10.4.2 HO • Concentration Profile during Electro-Oxidation of Organic Compound / 246
10.5
Kinetic Model of Organics Oxidation on BDD Anode / 248 10.5.1 Electrolysis under Current Limited Control (japplied < jlim ) / 249 10.5.2 Electrolysis under Mass Transport Control (japplied > jlim ) / 251
10.6
Electrochemically Induced Mineralization of Organic Compounds by Molecular Oxygen / 253
10.7
Conclusions / 256
10.8
Exercises / 256 10.8.1 Solutions / 257 References / 260
11. Modeling of Electrochemical Process for Water Treatment Using Diamond Films
261
Onofrio Scialdone and Alessandro Galia
11.1
Introduction / 261
11.2
Theoretical Models / 263 11.2.1 General Considerations / 263 11.2.2 Oxidation of Organic Pollutants in Water at BDD by Means of Direct Anodic Oxidation or Reaction with Electro-Generated Hydroxyl Radicals (“Direct Processes”) / 265 11.2.2.1 The Model of Comninellis and Coauthors / 268 11.2.2.2 The Theoretical Works of Polcaro and Coauthors / 272 11.2.2.3 The Approach Proposed by Rodrigo and Coauthors / 273 11.2.3 Oxidation of Organic Pollutants in Water by Means of Electro-Generated Oxidants (“Indirect Processes”) Such as Active Chlorine / 274
11.3
Conclusions / 278
11.4
Acknowledgments / 279 References / 279
xii
CONTENTS
12. Production of Strong Oxidizing Substances with BDD Anodes
281
Ana S´anchez-Carretero, Cristina S´aez, Pablo Ca˜nizares, and Manuel A. Rodrigo
12.1
Electrolyses with Conductive-Diamond Anodes / 281
12.2
Production and Storage of Oxidizing Substances: Experimental Setups / 283
12.3
Production of Hydroxyl Radicals with Conductive-Diamond Anodes / 284
12.4
Synthesis of Peroxoacids and Peroxosalts / 288 12.4.1 Peroxosulphuric Acids / 288 12.4.2 Peroxodiphosphate Salts / 292 12.4.3 Monoperoxophosphoric Acid / 296
12.5
Synthesis of Halogen Oxoanions / 300 12.5.1 Perchlorates / 300 12.5.2 Perbromates / 300
12.6
Synthesis of Ferrates / 301
12.7
Effect of the Type of Diamond on the Efficiency of the Production of Oxidants / 305
12.8
Conclusions / 307
12.9
Acknowledgments / 308 References / 308
13. Ozone Generation Using Boron-Doped Diamond Electrodes
311
Yunny Meas, Luis A. Godinez, and Erika Bustos
13.1
Introduction / 311
13.2
Ozone 13.2.1 13.2.2 13.2.3 13.2.4
13.3
Technologies for Producing Ozone / 317 13.3.1 Corona Discharge Technique / 317 13.3.2 Electrical Discharge Ozone Generators (EDOGs) / 319 13.3.3 Electrolytic Ozone Generators (ELOGs) / 319 13.3.3.1 Anodes for Electrochemically Producing Ozone / 320 13.3.3.2 Boron-Doped Diamond (BDD) / 323
13.4
Reaction Mechanism for the Production of Ozone with Boron-Doped Diamond / 325
/ 311 Physical and Chemical Properties of Ozone / 312 Production of Ozone / 313 Importance of Ozone Applications / 313 Efficiency and Production / 315
CONTENTS
13.5
xiii
Conclusions / 326 References / 327
14. Application of Synthetic Diamond Films to Electro-Oxidation Processes
333
Marco Panizza
14.1
Introduction / 333
14.2
Application in Wastewater Treatment / 335 14.2.1 Oxidation in the Potential Region before Oxygen Evolution / 335 14.2.2 Oxidation in the Potential Region of Oxygen Evolution / 339 14.2.3 Influence of the Nature of Organic Pollutants / 342 14.2.4 Influence of the Concentrations of Organic Compounds / 343 14.2.5 Influence of the Applied Current Density / 343 14.2.6 Influence of the Flow Rate / 345 14.2.7 Influence of the Temperature / 345 14.2.8 Comparison with Other Electrode Materials / 346
14.3
Application in Organic Electrosynthesis / 347
14.4
Conclusions / 348 References / 349
15. Fabrication and Application of Ti/BDD for Wastewater Treatment
353
Xueming Chen and Guohua Chen
15.1
Fabrication of Stable Ti/BBD Electrodes / 353 15.1.1 Introduction / 353 15.1.2 HFCVD Facility / 354 15.1.3 HFCVD Parameter Optimization / 354 15.1.4 Reactive Gas Component Improvement / 357 15.1.5 Methods to Enhance the Service Life of Ti/BDD / 363
15.2
Use of 15.2.1 15.2.2 15.2.3
15.3
Conclusions / 369
Ti/BDD Electrodes for Wastewater Treatment / 365 Oxidation of Acetic and Maleic Acids / 365 Oxidation of Phenol / 365 Oxidation of Dyes / 366
References / 369 16. Application of Diamond Films to Water Disinfection Jessica H. Bezerra Rocha and Carlos A. Mart´ınez-Huitle
16.1
Introduction / 373
373
xiv
CONTENTS
16.2
Disinfection Water / 374
16.3
Science and Technology for Water Purification / 375
16.4
Electrochemical Disinfection/Purification Systems / 376
16.5
Diamond Films for Drinking Water Disinfection / 384
16.6
Production of Inorganic Disinfection by-Products and Inorganic Species Elimination / 388 16.6.1 Chloride, Chlorite, and Chlorate Ions / 389 16.6.2 Perchlorate in Drinking Water / 392 16.6.3 Electrolysis of Nitrates / 394
16.7
Electrochemical Free-Chlorine Systems Using Diamond Films / 396
16.8
Conclusions / 400 References / 400
17. Fenton-Electrochemical Treatment of Wastewaters for the Oxidation of Organic Pollutants Using BDD
405
Enric Brillas
17.1
Introduction / 405
17.2
Fundamentals of Fenton’s Electrochemistry / 406
17.3
Electrogeneration of H2 O2 and Regeneration of Fe2+ / 409
17.4
Degradation of Organics in BDD/O2 Tank Reactors / 413 17.4.1 Herbicides / 414 17.4.2 Dyes / 417 17.4.3 Pharmaceuticals and Amino Acids Precursors / 420
17.5
Degradation of Organics in others Tank Reactors with a BBD Anode / 426
17.6
Degradation of Organics in Batch Recirculation BDD/O2 Flow Cells / 427
17.7
Conclusions / 433 References / 433
18. Electrochemical Energy Storage and Energy Conversion Systems with Diamond Films Juan M. Peralta-Hern´andez, Aracely Hern´andez-Ram´ırez, Jorge L. Guzm´an-Mar, Laura Hinojosa-Reyes, Giancarlo R. Salazar-Banda, and Carlos A. Mart´ınez-Huitle
18.1
Introduction / 437
18.2
Different Techniques Used to Modify BDD Films / 438 18.2.1 Microemulsion Synthesis / 438
437
xv
CONTENTS
18.2.2 18.2.3 18.2.4
Thermal Deposition / 443 Electrodeposition / 446 18.2.3.1 Electrodeposition of Metal Particles on BDD / 449 Sol-Gel Modification / 453
18.3
Application of Modified BDD Films as Electrocatalytic Surfaces for Fuel Cells / 459
18.4
Application of BDD Films in Batteries / 466
18.5
Application of BDD Electrodes as Electrochemical Capacitors / 474
18.6
Conclusions / 477 References / 478
19. Use of Diamond Films in Organic Electrosynthesis
483
Siegfried R. Waldvogel, Axel Kirste, and Stamo Mentizi
19.1
Introduction / 483
19.2
Specific Features of BDD Electrodes / 485
19.3
Stability of BDD Electrodes in Organic Media / 487
19.4
Electrolysis Cells for BDD Electrodes for Organic Transformations / 489
19.5
Anodic 19.5.1 19.5.2 19.5.3 19.5.4 19.5.5 19.5.6
19.6
Cathodic Synthesis on BDD Electrodes / 504 19.6.1 Reduction of Oximes / 504 19.6.2 Reductive Carboxylation / 505
19.7
Conclusions / 506
19.8
Acknowledgment / 506
Transformations on BBD Electrodes / 491 Alkoxylation Reactions / 491 Fluorination Reactions / 493 Cyanation Reactions / 494 Cleavage of C,C-Bonds / 495 Oxidation of Activated Carbon Atoms / 496 Anodic Phenol Coupling Reaction / 496 19.5.6.1 Anodic Homo-Coupling of Phenolic Substrates / 497 19.5.6.2 Nonsymmetrical Phenol Coupling and Phenol-Arene Cross-Coupling Reaction / 499
References / 507
xvi
CONTENTS
PART V BIOELECTROCHEMICAL APPLICATIONS
511
20. Diamond Sensors for Neurochemistry
513
Bhavik Anil Patel
20.1
Introduction / 513
20.2
Central and Peripheral Nervous System / 513
20.3
The Process of Neurotransmission / 514 20.3.1 Neurotransmitters / 516
20.4
Electroanalytical Methods to Study Neurotransmitter Release / 517 20.4.1 Sensors Utilized / 519
20.5
Limitations of Current Techniques for In Vitro and In Vivo Monitoring / 520 20.5.1 Long-Term Recordings / 521 20.5.2 Fouling from Large Biomolecules / 523 20.5.3 Fouling from Redox Reaction By-Products / 525
20.6
Applications of Diamond Sensors and Devices in Neurochemistry / 529 20.6.1 Recording Neuronal Activity / 529 20.6.2 Single Cell Measurements of Vesicular Release / 530 20.6.3 Neurotransmitter Release from Sympathetic Nerves Innervating Mesenteric Arteries / 531 20.6.4 Measuring Transmitter Release from the Gastrointestinal Tract / 533 20.6.4.1 Detection of Histamine Release from Enterochromaffin-Like Cells Located in the Stomach / 534 20.6.4.2 Monitoring Serotonin Release from Enterochromaffin Cells Located in the Mucosa / 535 20.6.4.3 Monitoring Nitric Oxide Release from Myenteric Plexus Neurons / 537 20.6.5 Studying the Neurotransmitter Clearance Process / 538 20.6.5.1 Measurements of Multiple Transmitters from Brain Synaptosomes / 539 20.6.5.2 Investigation of Serotonine Clearance by Transporters Present on Lymphocytes / 540 20.6.6 In vitro and In vivo Measurements from the Central Nervous System / 541 20.6.6.1 In vitro Measurements / 541 20.6.6.2 In vivo Measurements from Anesthetized Animals / 542
20.7
Conclusions and Outlook for the Future / 543
CONTENTS
20.8
xvii
Acknowledgments / 544 References / 544
21. DNA-Modified Diamond Films
551
Nianjun Yang and Christoph E. Nebel
21.1
Introduction / 551
21.2
Diamond Transducer Properties / 558 21.2.1 CVD Diamond Growth / 558 21.2.2 Surface Terminations / 562 21.2.3 Diamond Nanotexture and Wire Formation / 564
21.3
Surface Modification of Diamond / 571 21.3.1 Photochemical Surface Modification of Intrinsic Diamond / 571 21.3.2 Electrochemical Surface Functionalization of Boron-Doped Diamond / 582 21.3.3 Tip Functionalization of Diamond Nanotextures / 589
21.4
DNA Molecules on Diamond / 593 21.4.1 DNA Attachment / 593 21.4.2 Characterizations of DNA Layers / 595
21.5
Sensing 21.5.1 21.5.2 21.5.3
21.6
Summary and Outlook / 612
21.7
Acknowledgments / 614
of DNA Hybridization / 602 DNA Field Effect Transistor / 602 Cyclic Voltammetry and Impedance Spectroscopy / 606 DNA Sensing on Nanotextured Diamond Surfaces / 609
References / 614 INDEX
621
Preface
Diamond is an extremely hard crystalline form of carbon and it is considered an excellent material for many applications due to its unusual physical and chemical properties. For this reason, it has long attracted the attention of scientists and the public. Interest in diamond has been further increased by the discovery of the possibility to produce polycrystalline diamond films with mechanical and electronic properties comparable with natural diamond. Over the last few years, the number of publications has increased considerably regarding the synthesis and/or applications of this new material. Currently, synthetic diamond films have been the subject of applications and fundamental research in several fields of the science. Much effort was spent during the 1960s and 1970s to investigate diamond synthesis until it was successfully achieved by using the chemical vapor deposition (CVD) technique with excellent diamond growth rates, which led to good prospects for films being used for some industrial applications. Since their introduction into electrochemical research in 1987, doped-diamond electrodes have become more and more popular. This is based on their unique properties that distinguish them from conventional electrode materials and make many electrochemical processes more attractive or even possible. These electrodes, then, have been the subject of a large variety of applications and fundamental research in electrochemistry, opening up a novel branch known as the “electrochemistry of synthetic diamond films.” Almost every aspect of electrochemistry has been impacted by the diamond electrode, from instrumental analysis to industrial applications. Electrically conductive films of boron-doped diamond (BDD) have gained increasing popularity in many electrochemical applications, in large part due to the fact that very high quality films possess background currents that can be some orders of magnitude lower than those other types of electrode materials. Other important properties of these electrodes are related to their large potential window, low adsorption, corrosion stability in very aggressive media, high efficiency in oxidation processes, and very low doublelayer capacitance. Therefore, diamond films have become suitable materials for several purposes classified in different areas: synthesis of chemicals, modification of diamond surfaces, electroanalysis, water disinfection, destruction of pollutants in waters, and so xix
xx
PREFACE
on. The versatility of these materials has also been extended to develop sensors, microelectrodes, nanoelectrodes, and biosensors. Recently, synthetic diamond is starting to be commercialized for practical purposes—for example, diamond electrochemical detectors for liquid chromatography and large-scale diamond films for industrial wastewater treatment. The future for the synthetic diamond films is bright. These materials are starting to make important contributions for the measurements and understanding of an extensive range of chemical processes. Several other complementary techniques are emerging and can provide new knowledge for the chemistry of materials. Future interdisciplinary developments based on the close collaboration of chemists, electrochemists, engineers, biologists, and neuroscientists can be envisaged to ensure an effective application and productive use of synthetic diamonds to answer important chemical and medical questions and to resolve vital environmental problems. Several areas of interest have been opened up by these developments, including the measurement of release from single neurons, new sensors that are smaller and yet faster responding, sensor arrays for simultaneously detecting several analytes, novel biosensors for new neurochemical species of interest, and medical and clinical applications to neurochemistry and neuroscience. Synthetic Diamond Films: Preparation, Electrochemistry, Characterization, and Applications is a timely book that has gathered together the best international experts of the electrochemical community and who have imagined a large number of approaches to investigate the electrochemical properties of diamond films and their characteristics. All of these contributing experts now focus on aspects that promote efficiency, selectivity, and high performances for a broad variety of laboratory and industrial diamond applications with goals ranging from organic synthesis to environmental problems. The first part of the book (Chapters 1 to 3) deals with diamond history, emphasizing the discovery of synthetic diamond films and types of them. The second part (Chapters 4 to 6) concerns the beginning and new branches of the electrochemistry of diamond films. Chapters 7 and 8, which make up the third part of the book, summarize the studies of the diamond films on electroanalytical applications. The chapters focus on the use of these materials as sensors for detecting organic or inorganic species in order to propose the electroanalysis as an alternative quality control technique as well as for monitoring chemical species on air, soil, and water ecosystems. The fourth part (Chapters 9 to 19) is devoted to industrial applications of diamond films describing specific problems of particular interest for organic chemistry, energy conversion (fuel cells and batteries), and environmental aspects. Since diamond films are the most efficient materials for water treatment and water disinfection, Chapters 9 to 17 are devoted to these industrial applications in order to show the properties of these materials for environmental protection. The electrochemical oxidation with diamond films has been recognized as an electrochemical advanced oxidation process (EAOP), whereas the recent application of synthetic diamond films to other emerging EAOPs, such as electro-Fenton and photoelectro-Fenton, has also opened new prospects for wastewater remediation. The last part of the book (Chapters 20 to 21) focuses on innovative applications of diamond films, ranging from novel biosensors for chemical species of interest, as well as medical and clinical applications to neurochemistry and neuroscience by diamond microelectrodes and nanoelectrodes.
PREFACE
xxi
We strongly believe that this book will greatly promote research in this key field in the forthcoming years for the benefit of our society. Carlos A. Mart´ınez-Huitle Enric Brillas Editors
Preface to the Wiley Series on Electrocatalysis and Electrochemistry
This series covers recent advances in electrocatalysis and electrochemistry and depicts prospects for their contribution into the present and future of the industrial world. It aims to illustrate the transition of electrochemical sciences from its beginnings as a solid chapter of physical chemistry (covering mainly electron transfer reactions, concepts of electrode potentials and structure of electrical double layer) to the field in which electrochemical reactivity is shown as a unique chapter of heterogeneous catalysis, is supported by high-level theory, connects to other areas of science, and includes focus on electrode surface structure, reaction environment and interfacial spectroscopy. The scope of this series ranges from electrocatalysis (practice, theory, relevance to fuel cell science and technology) to electrochemical charge transfer reactions, biocatalysis and photoelectrochemistry. While individual volumes may appear quite diverse, the series promises updated and overall synergistic reports providing insights to help further our understanding of the properties of electrified solid/liquid systems. Readers of the series will also find strong reference to theoretical approaches for predicting electrocatalytic reactivity by such high-level theories as density functional theory. Beyond the theoretical perspective, further vehicles for growth are such significant topics such as energy storage, syntheses of catalytic materials via rational design, nanometer-scale technologies, prospects in electrosynthesis, new instrumentation and surface modifications. In this context, the reader will notice that new methods being developed for one field may be readily adapted for application in another. Electrochemistry and electrocatalysis have both benefited from numerous monographs and review articles due to their depth, complexity, and relevance to the practical world. The Wiley Series on Electrocatalysis and Electrochemistry is dedicated to present the current activity by focusing each volume on a specific topic that is timely and promising xxiii
xxiv
PREFACE TO THE WILEY SERIES ON ELECTROCATALYSIS AND ELECTROCHEMISTRY
in terms of its potential toward useful science and technology. The chapters in these volumes will also demonstrate the connection of electrochemistry to other disciplines beyond chemistry and chemical engineering, such as physics, quantum mechanics, surface science, and biology. The integral goal is to offer a broad-based analysis of the total development of the fields. The progress of the series will provide a global definition of what electrocatalysis and electrochemistry are now, and will contain projections about how these fields will further evolve in time. The purpose is twofold, to provide a modern reference for graduate instruction and for active researchers in the two disciplines, as well as to document that electrocatalysis and electrochemistry are dynamic fields that are expanding rapidly, and are likewise rapidly changing in their scientific profiles and potential. Creation of each volume required the editors involvement, vision, enthusiasm and time. The Series Editor thanks each Volume Editor who graciously accepted his invitation. Special thanks go to Ms. Anita Lekhwani, the Series Acquisitions Editor, who extended the invitation to edit this series to me and has been a wonderful help in its assembling process. Andrzej Wieckowski Series Editor
Contributors
Leonardo Santos Andrade, Departamento de Qu´ımica, Universidade Federal de Goi´as, Campus de Catal˜ao, Avenida Lamartine P. Avelar 1120, 75704-020 Catal˜ao, GO, Brazil John C. Angus, Department of Chemical Engineering, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH 44106-7217, USA Amara Apilux, Sensor Research Unit, Department of Chemistry, Faculty of Science, Chulalongkorn University, Patumwan, Bangkok 10330, Thailand Helmut Baltruschat, Institute for Physical and Theoretical Chemistry, Universit¨at Bonn, D 53117 Bonn, Germany ´ Erick Roberto Bandala Gonzalez, Universidad de las Am´ericas-Puebla, Departamento de Ingenier´ıa Civil y Ambiental Grupo de Investigaci´on en Energ´ıa y Ambiente, Sta. Catarina M´artir, Cholula-Puebla, M´exico J´essica Horacina Bezerra Rocha, Centro de Ciˆencias Exatas e da Terra, Departamento de Qu´ımica, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte, Campus Universit´ario-Lagoa Nova, CEP 59.072-970, Natal/RN, Brazil Karel Bouzek, Department of Inorganic Technology, Institute of Chemical Technology Prague, Prague, Czech Republic Enric Brillas, Laboratori d’Electroqu´ımica dels Materials i del Medi Ambient, Facultat de Qu´ımica, Departament de Qu´ımica F´ısica, Universitat de Barcelona, Mart´ı i Franqu`es 1-11 08028 Barcelona, Spain Erika Bustos, Centro de Investigaci´on y Desarrollo Tecnol´ogico en Electroqu´ımica, Parque Tecnol´ogico Quer´etaro, Sanfandila, C.P. 76703, Pedro Escobedo, Edo. de Quer´etaro, M´exico ˜ Pablo Canizares, Department of Chemical Engineering, Faculty of Chemical Sciences, Enrique Costa Building, Universidad de Castilla La Mancha, Campus Universitario s/n 13071 Ciudad Real, Spain xxv
xxvi
CONTRIBUTORS
Orawon Chailapakul, Department of Chemistry, Sensor Research Unit and Center for Petroleum, Petrochemicals, and Advanced Materials, Chulalongkorn University, Patumwan, Bangkok 10330, Thailand Pimkwan Chantarateepra, Program in Biotechnology, Faculty of Science, Chulalongkorn University, Patumwan, Bangkok 10330, Thailand Guohua Chen, Department of Chemical and Biomolecular Engineering, Hong Kong University Science & Technology, Clean Water Bay, Kowloon, Hong Kong, China Xueming Chen, Department of Environmental Engineering, Zhejiang University, 388 Yuhangtang Road, Hangzhou 310058, China Christos Comninellis, Ecole Polytechnique F´ed´erale, Lausanne, Group of Electrochemical Engineering, EPFL, 1015 Lausanne, Switzerland Yasuaki Einaga, Department of Chemistry, Keio University, 3-14-1 Hiyoshi, Yokohama 223-8522, Japan Orlando Fatibello-Filho, Departamento de Qu´ımica, Universidade Federal de S˜ao Carlos, C.P. 676, 13560-970 S˜ao Carlos-SP, Brazil Akira Fujishima,
President, Tokyo University of Science, Kagurazaka, Tokyo, Japan
Lu´ıs A. God´ınez, Centro de Investigaci´on y Desarrollo Tecnol´ogico en Electroqu´ımica, Parque Tecnol´ogico Quer´etaro, Sanfandila, C.P. 76703, Pedro Escobedo, Edo. de Quer´etaro, M´exico ´ Jos´e L. Guzman-Mar, Facultad de Ciencias Qu´ımicas, Centro de Laboratorios Especializados, Universidad de Nuevo Le´on, Pedro de Alba s/n, Cd. Universitaria, San Nicol´as de los Garza, NL, M´exico ´ırez, Facultad de Ciencias Qu´ımicas, Centro de Laborato´ Aracely Hernandez-Ram rios Especializados, Universidad de Nuevo Le´on, Pedro de Alba s/n, Cd. Universitaria, San Nicol´as de los Garza, NL, M´exico Lu´ıs Hinojosa-Reyes, Facultad de Ciencias Qu´ımicas, Centro de Laboratorios Especializados, Universidad de Nuevo Le´on, Pedro de Alba s/n, Cd. Universitaria, San Nicol´as de los Garza, NL, M´exico Katherine Holt, Department of Chemistry, University College London, Christopher Ingold Building, 20, Gordon St., London, WC1H 0AJ, UK Xin Jiang, Institute of Materials Engineering, University of Siegen, Paul-Bonatz-Str. 9-11, 57076 Siegen, Germany Agnieszka Kapalka, Ecole Polytechnique F´ed´erale, Lausanne, Group of Electrochemical Engineering, EPFL, 1015 Lausanne, Switzerland Axel Kirste, Kekul´e-Institut f¨ur Organische Chemie und Biochemie, Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms Universit¨at Bonn, Gerhard-Domagk-Str. 1, 53121 Bonn, Germany Carlos Alberto Mart´ınez-Huitle, Centro de Ciˆencias Exatas e da Terra, Departamento de Qu´ımica, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte, Campus Universit´ario-Lagoa Nova, CEP 59.072-970, Natal/RN, Brazil Yunny Meas, Centro de Investigaci´on y Desarrollo Tecnol´ogico en Electroqu´ımica, Parque Tecnol´ogico Quer´etaro, Sanfandila, C.P. 76703, Pedro Escobedo, Edo. de Quer´etaro, M´exico
CONTRIBUTORS
xxvii
Stamo Mentizi, Johannes Gutenberg-Universit¨at Mainz, Institut f¨ur Organische Chemie, Duesbergweg 10-14, 55128 Mainz, Germany Christoph E. Nebel, Fraunhofer-Institute for Applied Solid State Physics (IAF), Department Micro- and Nano-Sensors (GF5), Tullastrasse 72, 79108 Freiburg, Germany Marco Panizza, Department of Chemical and Process Engineering, Universit`a di Genova, P.le J.F. Kennedy 1, 16129 Genoa, Italy Bhavik A. Patel, Centre for Biomedical and Health Sciences Research, School of Pharmacy and Biomolecular Sciences, University of Brighton, Brighton, BN2 4GJ ´ Juan Manuel Peralta-Hernandez, Facultad de Ciencias Qu´ımicas, Centro de Laboratorios Especializados, Universidad de Nuevo Le´on, Pedro de Alba s/n, Cd. Universitaria, San Nicol´as de los Garza, NL, M´exico Yurnny V. Pleskov, Frumkin Institute of Physical Chemistry and Electrochemistry, Russian Academy of Sciences, Leninsky prospekt 31, 119991 Moscow, Russia Marco Antonio Quiroz-Alfaro, Universidad de las Am´ericas Puebla. Departamento de Ciencias Qu´ımico Biol´ogicas, Grupo de Investigaci´on en Energ´ıa y Ambiente, Sta. Catarina M´artir, Cholula-Puebla, M´exico Romeu Cardozo Rocha–Filho, Departamento de Qu´ımica, Universidade Federal de S˜ao Carlos, C.P. 676, 13560-970 S˜ao Carlos-SP, Brazil Manuel A. Rodrigo, Department of Chemical Engineering, Faculty of Chemical Sciences, Enrique Costa Building, Universidad de Castilla La Mancha, Campus Universitario s/n 13071 Ciudad Real, Spain ´ Cristina Saez, Department of Chemical Engineering, Faculty of Chemical Sciences, Enrique Costa Building, Universidad de Castilla La Mancha, Campus Universitario s/n 13071 Ciudad Real, Spain Giancarlo R. Salazar-Banda, Laborat´orio de Eletroqu´ımica e Nanotecnologia, Instituto de Tecnologia e Pesquisa, Universidade Tiradentes, Av. Murilo Dantas 300, Farolˆandia, 49032-490 Aracaju-SE, Brazil ´ Ana Sanchez-Carretero, Department of Chemical Engineering, Faculty of Chemical Sciences, Enrique Costa Building, Universidad de Castilla La Mancha, Campus Universitario s/n 13071 Ciudad Real, Spain Onofrio Scialdone, Dipartimento di Ingegneria Chimica, Gestionale, Meccanica e Informatica, Universit`a di Palermo, Viale delle Scienze, 90100, Palermo, Italy Virender K. Sharma, Florida Institute of Technology, 150 West University Boulevard Melbourne, Fl 32901, USA Weena Siangproh, Department of Chemistry, Faculty of Science, Srinakharinwirot University, Sukhumvit 23, Wattanna, Bangkok 10110, Thailand Ignasi Sir´es, Laboratori d’Electroqu´ımica dels Materials i del Medi Ambient, Facultat de Qu´ımica, Departament de Qu´ımica F´ısica, Universitat de Barcelona, Mart´ı i Franqu`es 1-11 08028 Barcelona, Spain Vadali V.S.S. Srikanth, School of Engineering Sciences and Technology, University of Hyderabad, Central University (P.O.), Hyderabad 500046, India
xxviii
CONTRIBUTORS
Siegfried R. Waldvogel, Institut f¨ur Organische Chemie, Johannes GutenbergUniversit¨at Mainz, Duesbergweg 10-14, 55128 Mainz, Germany Nianjun Yang, Fraunhofer-Institute for Applied Solid State Physics (IAF), Department Micro- and Nano-Sensors (GF5), Tullastrasse 72, 79108 Freiburg, Germany
Current density (mA cm–2)
0.20 (a) 0.15 0.10 (b) 0.05 (c) 0.00 0.2
0.0
0.4
0.6
0.8
Potential (V) vs. Ag/AgCl Figure 5.9 For caption see page 122.
counter electrode
BDD
stimulating electrode Reference electrode
anesthesia induction
Counter electrode
Stimulating electrode reference electrode
BDD
Brain Cortex Corpus Striatum Substantia Nigra Dopaminergic Neuron
Figure 5.14 For caption see page 127.
(c)
(b)
(d) 75 nA
4.0 3.0 2.0 1.0
0 nA
0.0
10 0 –10 0
20 40 60 Distance (μm)
80
Figure 6.3 For caption see page 145.
Current density(A m–2)
Anodic potential (V) vs. SCE
20
2.0
65
2.2
90
2.5
155
3.5
195
4.1
0.04 Thermodynamics
0.03
Pt
0.02 j (A cm–2)
Height (nm)
it/i(∞)
DDB
0.01 0
–0.01 –0.02
–2.0
–1.0
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
E (V) vs. NHE
–0.03 Figure 12.1 For caption see page 282.
Power supply V
A
catholyte
anolyte +
–
Electrochemical cell
Membrane Anode (BDD)
Cathode (AISI 304)
Out
Out
In
In
Figure 12.7 For caption see page 286.
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
μm 5
μm 5 4
4 3
3 2
2 1
1
Figure 16.16 For caption see page 398.
Figure 19.5 For caption see page 488.
Platelets Figure 20.6 For caption see page 523.
sensor
sensor
sensor
sensor
sensor BLOOD
Red blood cells
Activated platelets
Protein
Fibrin
Before stimulation
(a)
(b)
After stimulation at 10 Hz
Stimulator 210 µm
210 µm
Diamond Microelectrode (c) Imax = 10.4 pA
Stimulation Current (pA)
Diameter (µm) 30 µm
Figure 20.13 For caption see page 532.
Ileum–cross section
Submucosal plexus neurons EC Cells
Myenteric plexus neurons
Circular Muscle
Longitudinal Muscle
Enterochromaffin cells
Mucosal layer
SERT transporters present in enterocytes
Figure 20.14 For caption see page 533.
Myenteric plexus
(a)
Gastric Pit
(b) 8
Gastric glands Parietal cell
Current / nA
6
4
2 ECL-cell 0 0
100
200
300
500
400
Time (s)
Figure 20.15 For caption see page 534.
Figure 20.20 For caption see page 541. Au
Current (mA cm−2)
Pt Glassy Carbon
(H)SCD B:PCD (USU)
B:PCD (NRL)
B:(H)SCD –3
–2
–1
0
1
Potential (V) vs. SCE
Figure 21.1 For caption see page 552.
2
3
600
3
–1 –2
0
2
–3
CdS
–χ
–4.2
pH2 = 1 bar 1 mbar 1 μbar
0
2
–4.0
μe (eV)
1
μ
EVAC
–1
–4.6 6 8 10 12 14 pH-Value
4
–2 –3
CdSe
μ
–5 –6 GaP
SiC
–7
GaAs Si
–4 –5
H-terminated Diamond
Ge
–6
Diamond
–7
Semiconductors Figure 21.3 For caption see page 554.
1500 Diamond 1000
Gold Silicon
500 Glassy Carbon
0
0
5
1 0
–4.4
–4
Fluorescence intensity (a.u.)
Energy rel. to vacuum level (eV)
2
3
–3.8
Hydrogen Term Diamond EVBM
10
15
20
Hybridization cycles Figure 21.5 For caption see page 555.
25
30
(I)
(II)
Nanocrystalline Diamond
(a)
1 μm
1 μm
Silicon Polycrystalline Diamond
(b)
200 μm 200 μm Substrate Side
(c)
CL Intensity (a.u.)
4 x 106
FE(TO)
T = 16 K E = 13 kV I = 2 μA
3 x 106
2 x 106
1 x 106
0 5.0
1.00
0.5 nm
0.75
0.3 nm
0.50
0.0 nm
0.25 FE(LO) FE(TA) FE(TO + OΓ) 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 Photon Energy (eV)
5.5
0
0.25
0.50
Figure 21.6 For caption see page 556.
0.75
0 1.00 μm
(a) Electrochemical nitrophenyl grafting
Nanotextures from Boron-Doped Diamond
(c) Probe DNA immobilization
Nanotextures from Boron-Doped Diamond
(b) Animation & cross-linker attachment
Nanotextures from Boron-Doped Diamond
(d) DNA hybridization & detection
Nanotextures from Boron-Doped Diamond
Figure 21.7 For caption see page 559.
500
400
[nm]
300
200
100
0 0
100
200
300
400
500
[nm] 0.00
0.50
[nm] Figure 21.8 For caption see page 560.
(a)
Current density (mA cm–2)
0.5 (b) (c) 0
–0.5
(d)
–0.5
0
0.5
Potential (V) vs. Ag/AgCl Figure 21.12 For caption see page 564.
1
(c)
(b)
(a)
(d)
Figure 21.13 For caption see page 565.
5
Sensor Area (norm.)
[×1013] 6 (a)
C –2 (F–2)
4
3 (c) 2
1
0 –0.5
2.2 2 1.8 1.6 1.4 1.2 1 0
(d)
5 10 15 Etching time (s)
20
(b)
0
0.5
1 1.5 2 E (V) vs. Ag/AgCl
2.5
Figure 21.16 For caption see page 568.
3
3.5
40
Height / A
32
24
16 0
1000
2000 Distance (nm)
Figure 21.21 For caption see page 573.
Figure 21.24 For caption see page 576.
3000
(
(a)
(
(b)
Figure 21.27 For caption see page 578.
Figure 21.28 For caption see page 579.
100 nN 120 nN >120 nN
6 Height (nm)
5 4 3
26 Å
8Å
2 1 0
0
2000 1000 Distance (nm)
3000
Figure 21.38 For caption see page 588.
Figure 21.41 For caption see page 590.
Figure 21.46 For caption see page 596.
Figure 21.47 For caption see page 597.
(a)
(b)
Figure 21.48 For caption see page 597.
(a) PEEK-Sample Holder (part 1)
(b) PEEK-Sample Holder (part 2, backside)
Figure 21.58 For caption see page 604.
(c) Mounted Sample (part 1 and 2)
NA ds -D
ds -D
ds -D
NA
NA
Pt
Debye Length λD DRAIN
Source
Figure 21.59 For caption see page 604.
(a) Single-stranded (ss) DNA
(b) Double-stranded (ds) DNA
Redox-Molecules diffuse into the ss-DNA film.
ss
Redox-Molecules are repelled by Coulomb Force
ds
Diamond
Diamond
Generation of Redox-Current
No Redox-Current
ss
4
5.0 x 10
0.0 4
–5.0 x 10
–1.0 x 104 –0.4 –0.2
0.0
0.2
0.4
Potential (V vs. Ag/AgCl)
0.6
Current density (A/cm2)
2
Current density (A/cm )
Ferrocyanide (5mM) redox reaction 1.0 x 104
1.0 x 10
4
ds
5.0 x 104 0.0 –5.0 x 10
4
–1.0 x 104 –0.4
–0.2 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 Potential (V vs. Ag/AgCl)
Figure 21.62 For caption see page 607.
Part I
Synthesis of Diamond Films
1 Electrochemistry on Diamond: History and Current Status John C. Angus
1.1
ENABLING TECHNOLOGIES
The use of diamond in electrochemistry was not anticipated during the initial explosion of interest in low-pressure diamond growth during the 1980s. Most attention was focused on electronic, optical, and mechanical applications (e.g., for high temperature electronic devices, radiation detectors, high voltage switches, x-ray windows, audio speaker diaphragms, and protective and tool coatings). Little attention was paid to electrochemical applications. In this chapter, we describe the enabling technologies underlying diamond electrochemistry, the early work on diamond electrochemistry itself, and two major threads of current research. The present status of the field is covered in the other chapters of this volume. 1.1.1
Chemical Vapor Deposition of Diamond
Diamond electrochemistry has been made possible by development of methods for the chemical vapor deposition of diamond. The first reported growth of diamond at sub-atmospheric pressure, where diamond is metastable with respect to graphite, was by Eversole [1] at Union Carbide Corporation. He grew diamond on high-surface area powder from methane and carbon monoxide. This effort was ultimately abandoned after Synthetic Diamond Films: Preparation, Electrochemistry, Characterization, and Applications, First Edition. Edited by Enric Brillas and Carlos Alberto Mart´ınez-Huitle. © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Published 2011 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
3
4
ELECTROCHEMISTRY ON DIAMOND: HISTORY AND CURRENT STATUS
the announcement of the successful growth of diamond at high pressures by General Electric Corporation [2]. Eversole’s work was later extended by Angus et al. at Case Western Reserve University [3–7] and by Deryagin and a large group at the Physical Chemistry Institute in Moscow [8–13]. The Angus group showed the beneficial effect of added hydrogen on diamond yield, developed methods for removing unwanted graphitic carbon using atomic hydrogen, and grew boron-doped diamond by chemical vapor deposition [5]. In their first studies, the Soviet workers reported the growth of filamentary diamond whiskers using a vapor-liquid-solid (VLS) technique with molten iron and nickel [8,9]. Surprisingly, this process has received little attention in subsequent years. From the same group at the Physical Chemistry Institute, Varnin et al. [11] grew diamond thin films from the gas phase; Spitsyn, Bouilov, and Deryagin [13] reported both diamond films and isolated diamond crystals grown on copper substrates by chemical vapor transport from a graphite source. These very early studies were the first to show that diamond could be grown at conditions in which it is not the stable phase. At the time, diamond synthesis at low pressures was widely believed to be impossible and in violation of the second law of thermodynamics. Although the early studies showed the feasibility of diamond synthesis by chemical vapor deposition, the growth rates were low. This situation changed dramatically in the mid-1980s. A group at the National Institute for Research in Materials in Tsukuba, Japan, under the leadership of Nobuo Setaka achieved large increases in growth rates by activating the gas phase during growth with a hot filament [14,15], a microwave discharge [16], and an RF discharge [17,18]. Matsui, Matsumoto, and Setaka [19] also performed careful characterization of their product diamond. Since the mid-1980s, the interest in chemical vapor deposition of diamond has expanded enormously, and it is now used to grow extremely high-quality diamond in many shapes and sizes. 1.1.2
Doping of Diamond
For most electrochemical applications, it is necessary to use conducting diamond obtained by doping with the group III element, boron. The effect of boron on the electrical conductivity of diamond has been well studied and is covered in several classic review volumes [20–24]. Poferl, Gardner, and Angus [5] in 1973 were the first to grow boron-doped conducting diamond by chemical vapor deposition. This study was done to provide further confirmation of metastable diamond growth. Since then, numerous studies of diamond doping have been made. The boron-doping agent is usually added through small amounts of diborane, trimethyl boron, or organic borates in the source gases, but solid-state boron sources have also been successfully used. Reviews by Pan and Kania [25] and Werner and Locher [26] describe the state of the art in the mid-1990s; more recent discussions [27–29] are available. At low concentrations, boron promotes p-type semiconductivity in diamond with an acceptor level 0.37 eV above the valence band [30]. At boron concentrations higher than 1017 to 1018 cm−3 , an impurity band forms and the acceptor gap is reduced [31–34]. At boron concentrations from 1020 to 1021 cm−3 , diamond is a semimetal, with resistivities as low as 0.001 -cm. For electrosynthesis and electrodestruction applications, high conductivities are desirable; for photoelectrochemistry and semiconductor electrochemistry, low conductivity electrodes are used. The uniformity of boron concentration is an important variable in electrochemical applications. Spitsyn et al. in 1981 [13] and Janssen et al. in 1990 [35] showed that more boron was incorporated in (111) growth sectors than in (100) sectors.
1.2 FIRST STUDIES OF THE ELECTROCHEMISTRY ON DIAMOND
1.1.3
5
Surface Characterization of Diamond
Diamond, graphene and carbon nanotubes are unique among the common semiconductors in having no stable solid surface oxide. Furthermore, the chemistry of the diamond surface is closely related to well-known organic chemical processes. As a consequence, it is possible to tailor the properties of the diamond surface for sensor and other applications by changing the surface functionalization. The most significant early paper on diamond surfaces was the LEED study by Lander and Morrison at Bell Laboratories in 1966 [36]. They showed that hydrogen-termination of (111) diamond surfaces eliminated the reconstruction of the clean surface and gave an (essentially) bulk-terminated surface. They also found significant atom mobility on the diamond surface between 900◦ C and 1400◦ C. Lander and Morrison explicitly stated that this behavior could make epitaxial extension of diamond feasible. Another important early study of diamond surfaces and their interaction with gases was by Lurie and Wilson in 1977 [37].
1.2
FIRST STUDIES OF THE ELECTROCHEMISTRY ON DIAMOND
Even after the chemical vapor deposition of diamond became more or less routine, there was little availability of boron-doped conducting diamond. Therefore, some of the earliest electrochemical studies done on diamond were performed on samples in which conductivity was induced by damage from ion implantation. In 1983, Iwaki et al. [38] of the Institute of Physical and Chemical Research in Hirosawa, Japan, reported the use of diamond electrodes made conductive by ion implantation of nitrogen, argon, and zinc. However, the ion implantation converted the diamond surface into nondiamond carbon [38,39] so the measurements did not reflect the electrochemical characteristics of diamond itself. 1.2.1
From 1987 to 1996
The first measurements of the inherent electrochemical properties of diamond were by Yuri Pleskov and co-workers at the Frumkin Institute of Electrochemistry in Moscow. In 1987, they reported the photoelectrochemical properties of diamond electrodes [40]. They found a photoresponse of diamond at sub-bandgap wavelengths that they attributed to excitation of electrons from mid-gap defect states to the conduction band. They also observed sluggish evolution of hydrogen at cathodic potentials. Subsequently, in 1989 Natishan and Morrish at the Naval Research Laboratory in Washington, D.C., described the electrochemical properties of composite diamond/molybdenum electrodes in which the diamond acted as an inert insulating material [41]. During the early 1990s, Pleskov and co-workers continued and expanded their earlier work on diamond electrochemistry. They analyzed the impedance of conducting polycrystalline diamond thin films between two ohmic contacts and showed that intercrystalline boundaries are capacitive/resistive barriers in the bulk of diamond [42,43]. This same group continued its photoelectrochemical studies [44,45] and measured the minority carrier diffusion length and the acceptor concentrations in diamond [46]. A large group at the University of Tokyo led by Akira Fujishima made extensive progress on diamond electrochemistry during the early 1990s. Patel, Hashimoto, and
6
ELECTROCHEMISTRY ON DIAMOND: HISTORY AND CURRENT STATUS
Fujishima examined the photoresponse of diamond [47,48]. They showed that the diamond electrodes acted as a p-type semiconductor; from the flat band potential, they deduced that the bottom of the conduction band of diamond was near the vacuum level. Tenne and others of this same group exploited the large overpotentials for hydrogen evolution for the reduction of nitrate to ammonia on boron-doped diamond electrodes [49,50]. In 1993 Marchywka et al. [51] described an interesting process in which they used low-energy carbon ion implantation, followed by electrochemical etching of the damaged region, to separate thin diamond layers from bulk diamond crystals. Also in 1993, Ramesham and co-workers [52] deposited diamond films on both glassy carbon and graphite to make a composite electrode that they said “may have some use in electroanalysis”. Miller et al. in 1994 used ion implantation of 140 keV Co ions to form a patterned, nondiamond conductive region on a planar diamond electrode surface [53]. In the early and mid-1990s, Swain and his colleagues published a series of papers [54–58] that demonstrated many of the essential properties of diamond electrodes: their low capacitance, featureless background current, large signal to noise ratio, and chemical stability. They suggested that these properties made diamond electrodes suitable for electroanalysis and sensors. In 1995 a group of researchers at the Shanghai Institute of Metals also reported on the stability and reproducibility of diamond electrodes and noted their potential for sensor applications [59–61]. The large overpotential for hydrogen evolution on diamond was observed in the earliest work [49,50], but the large overpotential for oxygen evolution did not become apparent until high-quality diamond electrodes, without significant nondiamond carbon, were used. In 1995 and 1996, Martin et al. [62], Argoitia et al. [63], and Martin et al. [64] demonstrated that high-quality diamond electrodes did not evolve hydrogen until −1.25 V and oxygen until +2.3 V (versus the standard hydrogen electrode). Bouamrane et al. [65] reported a similar observation in 1996. The high overpotentials for both oxygen and hydrogen evolution on diamond give rise to an extremely wide potential window of water stability that is found on no other electrode material. Figure 1.1 shows the current-voltage characteristics for water electrolysis on high- and low-quality diamond, glassy carbon, and platinum [63]. The wide potential window and the lack of background current within the potential window for high-quality diamond are apparent. 1.2.2
From 1996 to Present
In the latter part of the 1990s, several intensive efforts were made to understand the nature of charge transfer at diamond electrodes and how it differed from conventional carbon electrodes. In 1996, Vinokur et al. [66] performed a careful analysis of electron transfer to both lightly and heavily doped diamond electrodes. Highly reversible electrode behavior was found for heavily boron-doped electrodes, especially at potentials more positive than −0.50 V versus the saturated calomel electrode. Lightly doped, semiconducting electrodes showed very slow kinetics at more negative potentials, which was attributed to a lack of available states in the bandgap of diamond. During this same time period, the Swain [67] group measured the boron distribution on diamond electrodes and Granger et al. [68] presented a detailed study of the electrode kinetics of diamond from two different sources. They examined the difference in electrode kinetics for processes involving outer sphere
1.2 FIRST STUDIES OF THE ELECTROCHEMISTRY ON DIAMOND
(a) Platinum
(b) High-Quality Diamond 30
15 0 −1
−15
1
2
3
i (mA / cm−2)
i (mA / cm−2)
30
−2
15 0 −2
−1
V vs. SHE(V)
1
2
3
i (mA / cm−2)
i (mA / cm−2)
0
V vs. SHE(V)
3
1
2
3
30
15
−30
2
(d) Glassy Carbon
30
−15
1
V vs. SHE(V)
(c) Low-Quality Diamond
−1
−15 −30
−30
−2
7
15 0 −2
−1
−15 −30 V vs. SHE(V)
Figure 1.1 Early comparison of voltammograms of water electrolysis on (a) platinum, (b) high-quality diamond, (c) low-quality diamond, and (d) glassy carbon. The electrolyte was 0.50 M H2 SO4 ; potentials are measured versus the standard hydrogen electrode. The wide potential window between hydrogen evolution at ∼ − 1.5 V and oxygen evolution at ∼ + 2.5 V and lack of background current for the high-quality diamond electrode are evident. Reprinted from [63].
electron transfer and for reactions that go through adsorbed intermediates; they also studied the effect of hydrogen-termination and surface oxidation on the electrode kinetics. In 1999 Martin and associates [69] showed that increasing amounts of sp2 , nondiamond carbon on the diamond surface reduced the potential window of water stability and made the electrodes behave more like glassy carbon or pyrolytic graphite. The results of these and other studies showed the intrinsic differences between diamond and conventional carbon electrodes. Many of these differences arise from the very different types of surface structure and functionalities that are found on diamond electrode surfaces. One of the most striking features is the relatively inert, hydrogen-terminated diamond surface. The high overpotentials for hydrogen and oxygen evolution (and other reactions) are attributed, at least in part, to the limited adsorption of intermediate species on diamond. High overpotentials are not observed for rapid outer-sphere reactions that do not rely on an adsorbed intermediate. However, it should be emphasized that the diamond surface is not completely inert. Anodic polarization and liberation of oxygen changes the surface properties of a previously hydrogen-terminated surface [40,64,69–71]. These changes have been attributed to the replacement of hydrogen with oxygen functionalities to the surface [72]. Rao et al. [72] also showed that changing the surface functionalization changed the absolute position of the band edges and hence the flat band potential. Furthermore, there is evidence that in some cases oxidized diamond surfaces have a greater potential window of water stability than do hydrogenated surfaces [73–76].
8
ELECTROCHEMISTRY ON DIAMOND: HISTORY AND CURRENT STATUS
Of great interest is the possibility that the chemically bound hydrogen participates in the hydrogen evolution reaction generating a free radical site, for example, CH + H+ + e− → C • + H2
(1.1)
Anderson and Kang [77] showed that the energetics of this reaction are favorable. Furthermore, Yagi et al. [78] demonstrated deuterium exchange between the solution and a hydrogenated diamond surface during hydrogen evolution. Argoitia et al. [63] and Martin et al. [69] reported a rather surprising result that oxygen was added to hydrogenterminated diamond surfaces during liberation of hydrogen. The preceding results show that the electrochemical processes on diamond are significantly more complex than if the diamond were a completely inert source or sink of electrons. The early work on the electrochemistry of diamond was summarized in reviews by Tenne and Levy-Clement [79], Swain, Anderson, and Angus [80], Angus et al. [81], Kobashi [82], and Pleskov [83].
1.3 DEVELOPMENT OF ELECTROCHEMICAL APPLICATIONS OF DIAMOND By 2000 boron-doped diamond electrodes were receiving much attention. In addition to the very low background currents, low capacitance, and extremely wide potential window for water stability, diamond electrodes were shown to be extremely stable in many corrosive environments. Furthermore, the electrodes resisted fouling, especially when hydrogen-terminated. These properties began to be exploited in a number of laboratories around the world for a variety of applications. 1.3.1
Surface Functionalization
A natural extension of the early surface studies has been the extensive efforts on adding specific functional groups to the diamond surface. One of the first reported studies was that of Freedman and Stinespring [84] who in 1990 fluorinated diamond surfaces with an atomic beam of fluorine atoms. Smetkowski and Yates [85] in 1996 added fluorine to diamond surfaces by x-ray irradiation of perfluoroalkyl iodide layers on the surface. Ohtani et al. [86] in 1998 treated diamond with chlorine under ultraviolet irradiation; subsequent heating in boiling pyridine added quaternary pyridinium salts to the diamond. In 1999 Kuo, McCreery, and Swain [87] electrochemically coupled phenyl groups to diamond surfaces using phenyl diazonium. Polarization-induced modifications of diamond surfaces were described by Goeting et al. [88] in 1999. Throughout the early 2000s, there were many studies of addition of hydrocarbon functional groups to diamond. In 2001 Mathieu [89] reported functionalizing diamondcovered silicon wafers to improve biocompatibility. Wang et al. [90] used Diels-Alder chemistry to functionalize diamond with hydrocarbons. The theory of Diels-Alder reactions on diamond surfaces was discussed by Fitzgerald and Doren [91] and Lu et al. [92]. The reactivity of the 2 × 1 reconstructed (100) surface of diamond to 1, 3 butadiene and cyclopentene was reported by Russell et al. [93]. Hovis et al. [94] and Strother et al. [95] photochemically functionalized polycrystalline diamond surfaces with several
1.3 DEVELOPMENT OF ELECTROCHEMICAL APPLICATIONS OF DIAMOND
9
organic molecules. Another approach was reported by Ida et al. [96,97], who treated hydrogenated diamond surfaces with organic peroxides to add carboxylic acids and other functionalities. In 2002 Bent [98] reviewed the status of chemical functionalization of group IV semiconductor surfaces, including diamond. 1.3.2
Destruction of Wastes
One early application of conducting diamond was the anodic destruction of organic wastes. This process takes advantage of the very high anodic overpotentials that can be achieved on diamond electrodes as well as their chemical and dimensional stability under extreme conditions. Carey, Christ, and Lowery [99] used this method to oxidize photo solutions, phenol, hydroquinone, sodium salts of EDTA, and formic, oxalic, and malonic acids. From 1999 to 2001, Comninellis and co-workers [100–110] published an extensive series of papers on the use of boron-doped diamond electrodes for destruction of wastes. They showed that highly oxidizing species, for example, the persulfate ion, could be generated on diamond electrodes at anodic potentials well above the reversible potential for oxygen evolution [104]. They also demonstrated that hydroxyl groups generated at high anodic potentials were efficient oxidizing agents that kept organic films from forming on the diamond anodes [102,103,107,110]. Other workers used diamond anodes to both detect and destroy organic materials in waste streams. Davila-Jimenez et al. [111] reported in 2000 that textile dyes could be anodically treated using diamond electrodes. In 2002, Terashima et al. [112] used diamond electrodes to detect chlorophenols in drain waters. Bellagamba et al. [113] employed diamond anodes to oxidize dissolved polyacrylates in water, and Van Hege, Verhaege, and Verstraete [114] at the State University of Ghent oxidized organic components and ammonia in the concentrated filtrate from reverse osmosis membranes on diamond anodes. Lawrence et al. [115] detected and oxidized sulfide ion on boron-doped diamond electrodes; Van Andel and Janssen [116] described a process for the regeneration of chrome solutions using diamond electrodes, and Canizares et al. [117,118] described the destruction of phenol wastes using diamond anodes. Another interesting application is the use of boron-doped diamond anodes for the highly oxidizing electro-Fenton reaction [119,120]. Electrochemical oxidation on diamond electrodes is an active and ongoing field; recent work is described in later chapters of this book. 1.3.3
Sensors and Electroanalysis
The potential of diamond electrodes for sensor and analytical applications was recognized early by a number of workers: Ramesham et al. [52], Swain and Ramesham [54], Awada, Strojek, and Swain [58], and Zhu et al. [59]. The first applications followed shortly after this recognition. In 1996, Argoitia et al. [63] reported that the cerium/cerous redox couple could be detected on diamond. Strojek et al. [121] found enhanced signal to noise ratios at diamond electrodes. Also in 1996, Davidson et al. at Vanderbilt University developed diamond-based hydrogen [122] and oxygen [123] gas sensors. Use of diamond electrodes for analysis of biological molecules was an early research direction. In 1998 a group at Heriot Watt University in Edinburgh described the use of heavily boron-doped diamond electrodes for the determination of glucose [124]. In 1999 Rao et al. [125] from the University of Tokyo reported the electrochemical oxidation of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH) and sensors based on enzyme-catalyzed
10
ELECTROCHEMISTRY ON DIAMOND: HISTORY AND CURRENT STATUS
reactions involving NADH as a cofactor. Methods for determining sulfadiazine [126] as well as histamine and serotonin [127] were developed by Sarada et al., and Popa, Tryk, and Fujishima [128] developed methods for purines. Fujishima, Rao, and Tryk [129] demonstrated that diamond electrodes could be used for the detection of trace amounts of lead, without the use of mercury. In 2001 two reports described the use of transparent diamond electrodes for making in situ spectroscopic observations. In one, the addition of hydroxyl groups to diamond was observed [130] and in the other the electro-oxidation of ferrocyanide and electroreduction of methyl viologen was monitored [131]. Also in 2001 Hayashi et al. [132] used a double layer of undoped- and boron-doped diamond between two platinum electrodes to detect phosphine, diborane, and arsine. Kawarada et al. [133] fabricated electrolytesolution-gate field effect transistors (FETs) as biocompatible ion sensors. Kohn et al. [134] discussed the prospects of diamond micro devices and reviewed the use of diamond in electromechanical, electrothermal, and electrochemical sensors [135]. Saterlay, Foord, and Compton [136] developed a diamond sensor to be used with ultrasound for the detection of 4-chlorophenol in aqueous solution. Fujishima and Rao [137] described diamond detectors for flow-injection analysis of chlorophenols and theophylline. Development of diamond-based sensors is continuing in many laboratories around the world. Carbon-based sensors, including diamond, have been the subjects of an extensive review by McCreery [138]; other recent reviews on diamond-based sensors are by Chailapakul, Siangproh, and Tryk [139] and Zhou and Zhi [140].
1.4
OTHER DIRECTIONS
Two current directions of research on diamond electrochemistry deserve mention: bioelectronic applications of diamond and the anomalous surface conductivity of diamond. Both areas are the subject of much current research and both appear to have significant long-range implications. 1.4.1
Biolectronic Applications
Diamond as a platform for bioelectronic and bioelectrochemical applications is becoming a major research tool. These applications exploit the biocompatibility of diamond, its chemical inertness, and the ability to tailor its surface chemistry to permit attachment of biologically active molecules (e.g., DNA) for bioelectronics and biosensing. Diamond has significant advantages over silicon and the other common semiconductors because it does not have a solid surface oxide interposed between it and the external environment. Biosensor work using diamond has been a continuing focus. These studies include not only early sensor studies mentioned in the previous section but also the electrochemical analysis of nucleic acids [141] and the determination of single and double-stranded DNA [142] at boron-doped diamond electrodes. Another direction was explored by Tachiki et al. [143] who measured the inter-relationship between the surface charging of diamond and the physisorption of DNA. In 2001 Adamschik et al. described a diamond lab on a chip for biochemical applications including DNA synthesis [144]. In 2002 Ushizawa et al. immobilized DNA on diamond powder through an ester linkage [145]. The covalent bonding of the DNA to the diamond was verified by diffuse reflectance infrared spectroscopy. In 2002 and 2003, Hamers and co-workers
1.4 OTHER DIRECTIONS
11
used a photochemical scheme to obtain DNA functionalization of nanocrystalline and polycrystalline diamond films through amine groups [146,147]. In 2003 Takahashi et al. [148] sequentially hydrogenated, chlorinated, aminated, and finally carboxylated a diamond substrate to provide a platform for chemically binding DNA. Also in 2003, Wenmackers et al. [149] used thymidine as a linker molecule to immobilize DNA on diamond; the bound DNA was confirmed by confocal fluorescence microscopy. Functionalization of diamond with DNA for sensor and other applications remains of major current research interest. A significant body of work has been achieved by Hamers and co-workers at the University of Wisconsin. These studies include measuring changes in surface electrical properties of DNA modified diamond films as a function of exposure to complementary and noncomplementary DNA molecules [150], the fabrication of a biologically sensitive field effect transistor on a nanocrystalline diamond film [151], and an electrically addressable functionalized film [152]. This same group also compared the thermal stability of DNA-modified diamond and silicon surfaces [153] and developed methods for functionalizing diamond surfaces to resist protein adsorption, while still permitting specific binding for biorecognition [154,155]. Nebel and co-workers [156] at the Diamond Research Center in Tsukuba, Japan, studied the geometric orientation of DNA covalently bonded to single crystal diamond and the photochemical attachment of oriented amine linkers to hydrogen-terminated single crystal diamond [157]. This same group used periodically arranged benzene linker molecules, also on single crystal diamond, to obtain dense DNA films [158]. Recent reviews on bioelectronics and bioelectrochemistry have been written by Linares, Doering, and Linares [159], Nebel et al. [160] and Vermeeren et al. [161]. 1.4.2
Anomalous Surface Conductivity of Diamond
Most of the interaction between diamond science and electrochemistry exploits the unusual properties of diamond for electrochemical applications. There is one important example of the reverse in which electrochemical principles have lead to a deeper understanding of the properties of diamond. In 1989 Landstrass and Ravi [162] reported a curious observation that hydrogenterminated diamond developed a pronounced p-type surface conductivity upon exposure to air. This observation was extremely unusual because surface conductivity had not been reported previously despite more than a century of study of the electronic properties of diamond. Subsequent research, initially by Gi et al. [163–165], started to unravel the cause of the conductivity. Gi showed that the conductivity increased with exposure to acidic gases such as NO2 , decreased in the presence of basic gases such as NH3 [163,164], and that the sheet concentration of holes was as high as 7 × 1013 cm−2 [164]. In order to explain the effect, Gi proposed that the holes arose from the oxidation of the terminal hydrogen atoms by the hydronium ion, H3 O+ [165]. Gi’s mechanism was one of several put forward to explain the surface conductivity, including the presence of acceptor sites arising from subsurface hydrogen. Maier et al. [166,167] framed the surface oxidation process in terms of an electrochemical redox reaction. They proposed that the hydrogen redox couple, 2H+ + 2e− = H2 , in an adsorbed water film acted as an external electrochemical acceptor to the electrons in the diamond. The electron chemical potential (Fermi energy) of the redox couple lay below the Fermi energy of hydrogen-terminated diamond, which permitted the couple to act as an external electron acceptor, for example, to oxidize the diamond. In this model, the
12
ELECTROCHEMISTRY ON DIAMOND: HISTORY AND CURRENT STATUS
role of the hydrogen-termination was to provide a surface dipole that raised the electronic band structure of diamond so that the electron transfer could take place. This proposal also received rather limited support, in part because the partial pressure of H2 in the atmosphere is so low that it was difficult to understand how it could support a reversible redox couple. Subsequently, Foord et al. [168] and Chakrapani et al. [169] gave evidence that the electrochemical mechanism was correct, but that the oxygen redox couple, 4H+ + 4e− + O2 = 2H2 O, was responsible for the effect. Calculations of Petrini and Larson [170] showed that the oxygen and ozone redox couples were both more favorable for electron transfer from diamond than the hydrogen couple. Chakrapani et al. [171] used macroscopic size samples of diamond and water to demonstrate that the changes in pH and dissolved oxygen concentration were consistent with electron transfer to the oxygen redox couple. It is of considerable interest that electron transfer to an external redox couple was proposed by Shapoval et al. earlier (in 1995) to explain conductivity changes in diamond exposed to molten salts [172]. The electrochemical transfer doping of diamond is still a subject of active research. Much more remains to be done to achieve a full understanding of the effect and to explore potential applications. It should be noted in this context that the surface conductivity has been used as the basis of interesting field effect transistors, most notably by Kawarada et al. [133] and Denisenko, Aleksov, and Kohn [173]. The understanding that an electrochemical mechanism played a role in mediating the electrical properties of diamond led to attempts to find the effect in other systems. Ristein [174] discussed the general nature of transfer doping as an alternative to conventional impurity doping. Strobel et al. [175] demonstrated transfer doping of diamond to an adsorbed surface layer of fullerene molecules, C60 . Chakrapani et al. reported electrochemical transfer doping of carbon nanotubes [176] and that the photoluminescence of GaN and ZnO could be mediated by electrochemical transfer doping by changing the
300
Number of publications
250 200 150 100 50 0 1990
1995
2000 Publication year
2005
2010
Figure 1.2 Number of publications on diamond electrochemistry versus year of publication. Three publications appeared prior to 1990: Iwaki et al. [38] in 1983 and Pleskov et al. [40] and Natishan and Morrish [41] in 1989. Source: ISI Web of Knowledge; the count was limited to papers identified by the keyword combinations (diamond electrochemistry), (diamond electrochemical) etc.
REFERENCES
13
acidity or basicity of the ambient humid air [177]. A very interesting development is the prediction that electrochemical charge transfer to the oxygen redox couple can be used to alter the conductivity of graphene [178]. Chen et al. [179] have recently published a comprehensive review of surface transfer doping.
1.5
CONCLUSIONS
The current status of diamond electrochemistry can be found in a recent review volume [180] and in the following chapters of this volume. Major areas of expanding interest include waste treatment using diamond anodes, electroanalysis on diamond electrodes, diamond-based electrochemical sensors, diamond electrodes for functional stimulation of muscle, diamond as a substrate for affixing DNA and other molecules of biological interest, and electronic devices based on diamond surface conductivity. The interest in these and other types of electrochemistry involving diamond is continuing to increase. The number of published papers concerned with diamond electrochemistry as a function of time is shown in Figure 1.2.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20.
W.G. Eversole, US patents 3,030,187 and 3,030,188, 1962. F.P. Bundy, H.T. Hall, H.M. Strong, R.H. Wentorf, Nature 1955, 176 , 51–55. J.C. Angus, H.A. Will, W.S. Stanko, J. Appl. Phys. 1968, 39 , 2915–2922. J.C. Angus, D.J. Poferl, N.C. Gardner, S. Chauhan, T.J. Dyble, P. Sung, Sint. Almazy 1971, 3 , 30–31 (in Russian). D.J. Poferl, N.C. Gardner, J.C. Angus, J. Appl. Phys. 1973, 44 , 1428–1434. S.P. Chauhan, J.C. Angus, N.C. Gardner, J. Vac. Sci. Tech. 1974, 11 , 423. S.P. Chauhan, J.C. Angus, N.C. Gardner, J. Appl. Phys. 1976, 47 , 4746–4754. B.V. Deryagin, D.V. Fedoseev, V.M. Lukyanovich, B.V. Spitsyn, V.A. Ryabov, A.V. Lavrentiev, J. Cryst. Growth 1968, 2 , 380–384. B.V. Deryagin, D.V. Fedoseev, Russ. Chem Rev . 1970, 39 , 783–788. D.V. Fedoseev, K.S. Uspenskaya, V.P. Varnin, S.P. Vnukov, Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR, Seriya Khimicheskaya 1978, 6 , 1252–1256. V.P. Varnin, B.V. Deryagin, D.V. Fedoseev, I.G. Teremetskaya, A.N. Khodan, Kristallografiya 1977, 22 , 893–896. D.V. Fedoseev, B.V. Deryagin, V.P. Varnin, G.K. Sokolina, Doklady Akad. Nauk SSSR 1979, 247 , 1201–1204. B.V. Spitsyn, L.L. Bouilov, B.V. Deryagin, J. Cryst. Growth 1981, 52 , 219–226. S. Matsumoto, Y. Sato, M. Kamo, N. Setaka, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 1982, 21 , part 2 , L183–L185. S. Matsumoto, Y. Sato, M. Tsutsumi, N. Setaka, J. Mater. Sci . 1982, 17 , 3106–3112. M. Kamo, Y. Sato, S. Matsumoto, N. Setaka, J. Cryst. Growth 1983, 62 , 642–644. S. Matsumoto, J. Mater. Sci. Lett . 1985, 4 , 600–602. S. Matsumoto, M. Hino, T. Kobayashi, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1987, 51 , 737–739. Y. Matsui, S. Matsumoto, N. Setaka, J. Mater. Sci. Lett . 1983, 2 , 532–534. R. Berman, Physical Properties of Diamond , Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1965.
14
ELECTROCHEMISTRY ON DIAMOND: HISTORY AND CURRENT STATUS
21. J. E. Field, ed., The Properties of Diamond , Academic Press, London, 1979. 22. G. Davies, Diamond , Adam Hilger Ltd., Bristol, 1984. 23. J. Wilks, E. Wilks, Properties and Applications of Diamond , Butterworth Heinemann, Oxford, 1991. 24. J.E. Field, ed., Properties of Natural and Synthetic Diamond , Academic Press, London, 1992. 25. L.S. Pan, D.R. Kania, eds, Diamond: Electronic Properties and Applications, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston, 1995. 26. M. Werner, R. Locher, Rep. Prog. Phys. 1998, 61 , 1665–1710. 27. C.E. Nebel, J. Ristein, eds., Thin Film Diamond I, Semiconductors and Semimetals, Volume 76 , Elsevier Academic Press, Amsterdam, 2003. 28. C.E. Nebel, J. Ristein, Eds., Thin Film Diamond II, Semiconductors and Semimetals, Volume 77 , Elsevier Academic Press, Amsterdam, 2004. 29. R. S. Sussman, ed., CVD Diamond for Electronic Devices and Sensors, John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, Chichester, 2009. 30. A.T. Collins, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 1993, 342 , 233–234. 31. D. Narducci, C.R. Guarnieri, J.J. Cuomo, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1991, 138 , 2446–2451. 32. Y.F. Tsai, K.P. Ananthanarayanan, P.J. Gielisse, S.S. Mitra, J. Appl. Phys. 1972, 43 , 3677–3682. 33. J. Mort, K. Okumura, M.A. Machonkin, Phil. Mag. B 1991, 63 , 1031–1036. 34. K. Nishimura, K. Das, J.T. Glass, J. Appl. Phys. 1991, 69 , 3142–3148. 35. G. Janssen, W.J.P. van Enckevort, W. Vollenberg, L.J. Giling, Diamond Relat. Mat . 1990, 1 , 789–800. 36. J. J. Lander, J. Morrison, Surf. Sci . 1966, 4 , 241–246. 37. P. G. Lurie, J. M. Wilson, Surf. Sci . 1977, 65 , 453–475. 38. M. Iwaki, S. Sato, K. Takahashi, H. Sakairi, Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. 1983, 209–210 , 1129–1133. 39. M. Iwaki, K. Takahashi, H. Watanabe, S. Sato, RIKEN Review 1996, 12 , 27–28. 40. Y. V. Pleskov, A. Y. Sakharova, M. D. Krotova, L. L. Bouilov, B. V. Spitsyn, J. Electroanal. Chem. 1987, 228 , 19–27. 41. P.M. Natishan, A. Morrish, Mat. Lett . 1989, 8 , 269–272. 42. A.Ya. Sakharova, A.E. Sevastyanov, Y.V. Pleskov, G.L. Teplitskaya, V.V. Surikov, A.A. Voloshin, Soviet Electrochemistry 1991, 27 , 239–244. 43. A. Sakharova, L. Nykos, Y.V. Pleskov, Electrochim. Acta 1992, 37 , 973–978. 44. Y.V. Pleskov, A.Y. Sakharova, E.V. Kasatkin, VA. Shepelin, J. Electroanal. Chem. 1993, 344 , 401–404. 45. A.Y. Sakharova, Y.V. Pleskov, F. Diquarto, S. Piazza, C. Sunseri, I.G. Teremetskaya, V.P. Varnin, Russ. J. Electrochem. 1995, 31 , 169–174. 46. Y.V. Pleskov, V.Y. Mishuk, M.A. Abaturov, V.V. Elkin, M.D. Krotova, V.P. Varnin, I.G. Teremetskaya, J. Electroanal. Chem. 1995, 396 , 227–232. 47. K. Patel, K. Hashimoto, A. Fujishima, J. Photochem. Photobiol. A: Chem. 1992, 65 , 419–429. 48. K. Patel, K. Hashimoto, A. Fujishima, Denki Kagaku 1992, 60 , 659. 49. R. Tenne, K. Patel, K. Hashimoto, A. Fujishima, J. Electroanal. Chem. 1993, 347 , 409–415. 50. C. Reuben, E. Galun, H. Cohen, R. Tenne, R. Kalish, Y. Muraki, K. Hashimoto, A. Fujishima, J.E. Butler, C. Levy-Clement, J. Electroanal. Chem. 1995, 396 , 233–239.
REFERENCES
15
51. M. Marchywka, P.E. Pehrsson, D.J. Vestyck, D. Moses, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1993, 63 , 3521–3523. 52. R. Ramesham, R.F. Askew, M.F. Rose, B.H. Loo, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1993, 140 , 3018–3020. 53. B. Miller, R. Kalish, L. C. Feldman, A. Katz, N. Moriya, K. Short, A. E. White, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1994, 141 , L41–L43. 54. G. M. Swain, R. Ramesham, Anal. Chem. 1993, 65 , 345–351. 55. G. M. Swain, Adv. Mater. 1994, 6 , 388–392. 56. G. M. Swain, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1994, 141 , 3382–3293. 57. S. Alehashem, F. Chambers, J. W. Strojek, G. M. Swain, R. Ramesham, Anal. Chem. 1995, 67 , 2812–2821. 58. M. Awada, J. W. Strojek, G. M. Swain, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1995, 142 , L42–L45. 59. J.Z. Zhu, S.Z. Yang, P.L. Zhu, X.K. Zhang, G.X. Zhang, C.F. Xu, H.Z. Fan, Fresenius J. of Anal. Chem. 1995, 352 , 389–392. 60. P.L. Zhu, J.Z. Zhu, S.H. Yang, X.K. Zhang, G.X. Zhang, Fresenius J. of Anal. Chem. 1995, 353 , 171–173. 61. J.L. Wu, J.Z. Zhu, L. Shan, N.Y. Cheng, Anal. Chim. Acta 1996, 333 , 125–130. 62. H. B. Martin, A. Argoitia, J. C. Angus, A. B. Anderson, U. Landau, in Applications of Diamond Films and Related Materials: Third International Conference ( A. Feldman et al., eds.), NIST Special Publication 885, U.S. Dept. of Commerce, 1995, pp. 91–94. 63. A. Argoitia, H. B, Martin, E. J. Rozak, U. Landau, J. C. Angus, in “Diamond for Electronic Applications” ( D.L. Dreifus et al., eds.), Mater. Res. Soc. Proc. 1996, 416 , 349–354. 64. H. B. Martin, A. Argoitia, U. Landau, A. B. Anderson, J. C. Angus, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1996, 143 , L133–L136. 65. P. Bouamrane, A. Tadjeddine, J.E. Butler, R. Tenne, C. Levy-Clement, J. Electroanal. Chem. 1996, 405 , 95–99. 66. N. Vinokur, B. Miller, Y. Avyigal, R. Kalish, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1996, 143 , L238–L240. 67. J. Wang, G. M. Swain, M. Mermoux, G. Lucazeau, J. Zak, J. W. Strojek, New Diamond Frontier Carbon Tech. 1999, 9 , 317–343. 68. M.C. Granger, M. Witek, J.S. Xu, J. Wang, M. Hupert, A. Hanks, M.D. Koppang, J.E. Butler, G. Lucazeau, M. Mermoux, J.W. Strojek, G.M. Swain, Anal. Chem. 2000, 72 , 3793–3804. 69. H.B. Martin, A. Argoitia, J.C. Angus, U. Landau, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1999, 146 , 2959–2964. 70. C.H. Goeting, J.S. Foord, F. Marken, R.G. Compton, Diamond Relat. Mat . 1999, 8 , 824–829. 71. C.H. Goeting, F. Marken, A. Gutierrez-Sosa, R.G. Compton, DiamondRelat. Mat . 2000, 9 , 390–396. 72. T.N. Rao, D.A. Tryk, K. Hashimoto, A. Fujishima, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1999, 146 , 680–684. 73. T. Yano, E. Popa, D.A. Tryk, K. Hashimoto, A. Fujishima, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1998, 145 , 1870–1876. 74. I. Yagi, H. Notsu, T. Kondo, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, J. Electroanal. Chem. 1999, 473 , 173–178. 75. T. Yano, E. Popa, D.A. Tryk, K. Hashimoto, A. Fujishima, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1999, 146 , 1081–1087. 76. D.A. Tryk, K. Tsunozaki, T.N. Rao, A. Fujishima, Diamond and Related Mat . 2001, 10 , 1804–1809. 77. A.B. Anderson, D.B. Kang, J. Phys. Chem. A 1998, 102 , 5993–5996.
16
ELECTROCHEMISTRY ON DIAMOND: HISTORY AND CURRENT STATUS
78. I. Yagi, K. Ogai, T. Kondo, A. Fujishima, K. Ueda, K. Uosaki, Chem. Lett . 2003, 32 , 1050–1051. 79. R. Tenne, C. Levy-Clement, Israel J. Chem. 1998, 38 , 57–73. 80. G. M. Swain, A. B. Anderson, J. C. Angus, MRS Bulletin 1998, 23, 56–60. 81. J. C. Angus, H. B. Martin, U. Landau, Y. E. Evstefeeva, B. Miller, N. Vinokur, New Diamond Frontier Carbon Tech. 1999, 9, 175–187. 82. K. Kobashi, ed., Collection of articles from New Diamond and Frontier Carbon Tech. 1999, 9 , Nos. 3 & 5. 83. Y. V. Pleskov, Russ. Chem. Rev . 1999, 68 , 381–392. 84. A. Freedman, C.D. Stinespring, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1990, 57 , 1194–1196. 85. V.S. Smentkowski, J.T. Yates, Science 1996, 271 , 193–195. 86. B. Ohtani, Y.H. Kim, T. Yano, K. Hashimoto, A. Fujishima, K. Uosaki, Chem. Lett . 1998, 9 , 953–954. 87. T.C. Kuo, R.L. McCreery, G.M. Swain, Electrochem. Solid State Lett . 1999, 2 , 288–290. 88. C.H. Goeting, F. Marken, A. Gutierrez-Sosa, R.G. Compton, J.S. Foord, Diamond Relat Mat . 2000, 9 , 390–396. 89. H.J. Mathieu, Surf. Interf. Anal . 2001, 32 , 3–9. 90. G.T. Wang, S.F. Bent, J.N. Russell, J.E. Butler, M.P. D’Evelyn, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2000, 122 , 744–745. 91. D.R. Fitzgerald, D.J. Doren, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2000, 122 , 12334–12339. 92. X. Lu, G. Fu, N.Q. Wang, Q.N. Zhang, M.C. Lin, Chem. Phys. Lett . 2001, 343 , 212–218. 93. J.N. Russell, J.E. Butler, G.T. Wang, S.F. Bent, J.S. Hovis, R.J. Hamers, M.P. D’Evelyn, Mat. Chem. and Phys. 2001, 72 , 147–151. 94. J.S. Hovis, R.J. Hamers, M.P. D’Evelyn, J.N. Russell, J.E. Butler, J. Am. Chem. Soc. Comm. 2000, 122 , 732–733. 95. T. Strother, T. Knickerbocker, J.N. Russell, J.E. Butler, L.M. Smith, R.J. Hamers, Langmuir 2002, 18 , 968–971. 96. S. Ida, T. Tsubota, O. Hirabayashi, M. Nagata, Y. Matsumoto, A. Fujishima, Diamond Relat. Mat . 2003, 12 , 601–605. 97. S. Ida, T. Tsubota, S. Tanii, M. Nagata, Y. Matsumoto, Langmuir 2003, 19 , 9693–9698. 98. S.F. Bent, Surface Sci . 2002, 500 , 879–903. 99. J.J. Carey, C.S. Christ, Jr., S.N. Lowery, “Method of Electrolysis Employing a Doped Diamond Anode to Oxidize Solutes in Waste Water,” US patent, 5,399,247, 1995. 100. G. Foti, D. Gandin, C. Comninellis, A. Perret, W. Haenni, Electrochem. Solid State Lett . 1999, 2 , 228–230. 101. M. Fryda, D. Herrmann, L. Shafer, C.P. Klages, A. Perret, W. Haenni, C. Comninellis, D. Gandini, New Diamond Frontier Carbon Tech. 1999, 9 , 229–240. 102. D. Gandini, P.A. Michaud, I. Duo, E. Mahe, W. Haenni, A. Perret, C. Comninellis, New Diamond Frontier Carbon Tech. 1999, 9 , 303–316. 103. D. Gandini, C. Comninellis, A. Perret, W. Haenni, Fifth Eur. Symp. Electrochem. Engng. 1999, 145 , 181–190. 104. P.A. Michaud, E. Mahe, W. Haenni, A. Perret, C. Comninellis, Electrochem. Solid State Lett . 2000, 3 , 77–79. 105. S. Ferro, A. DeBattisti, I. Duo, C. Comninellis, W. Haenni, A. Perret, J. Electrochem. Soc. 2000, 147 , 2614–2619. 106. D. Gandini, E. Mahe, P.A. Michaud, W. Haenni, A. Perret, C. Comninellis, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2000, 30 , 1345–1350.
REFERENCES
17
107. M. Panizza, P.A. Michaud, G. Cerisola, C. Comninellis, J. Electroanal. Chem. 2001, 507 , 206–214. 108. M. Panizza, P.A. Michaud, G. Cerisola, C. Comninellis, Electrochem. Comm. 2001, 3 , 336–339. 109. W. Haenni, J. Gobet, A. Perret, L. Pupunat, P. Rychen, C. Comninellis, B. Correa, Diamond Materials VII, Proceedings (Electrochemical Society Series) 2002, pp. 16–23. 110. J. Iniesta, P.A. Michaud, M. Panizza, G. Cerisola, A. Aldaz, C. Comninellis, Electrochim. Acta 2001, 46 , 3573–3578. 111. M.M. Davila-Jimenez, M.P. Elizalde-Gonzalez, A. Gutierrez-Gonzalez, A.A. Pelaez-Cid, J. Chromatography 2000, 889 , 253–259. 112. C. Terashima, T.N. Rao, B.V. Sarada, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, Anal. Chem. 2002, 74 , 895–902. 113. R. Bellagamba, P.A. Michaud, C. Comninellis, N. Vatistas, Electrochem. Comm. 2002, 4 , 171–176. 114. K. Van Hege, M. Verhaege, W. Verstraete, Electrochem. Comm. 2002, 4 , 296–300. 115. N.S. Lawrence, M. Thompson, C. Prado, L. Jiang, T.G.J. Jones, R.G. Compton, Electroanalysis 2002, 14 , 499–504. 116. Y. Van Andel, L.J.J. Janssen, Appl. Electrochem. 2002, 32 , 481–486. 117. P. Canizares, M. Diaz, J.A. Dominguez, J. Garcia-Gomez, M.A. Rodrigo, Ind. & Eng. Chem. Res. 2002, 41 , 4187–4194. 118. P. Canizares, F. Martinez, M. Diaz, J. Garcia-Gomez, M.A. Rodrigo, J. Electrochem. Soc. 2002, 149 , D118–D124. 119. K.J. McKenzie, D. Asogan, F. Marken, Electrochem. Comm. 2002, 4 , 820–824. 120. E. Brillas, B. Boye, I. Sires, J.A. Garrido, R.M. Rodriguez, C. Arias, P.L. Cabot, C. Comninellis, Electrochim. Acta 2004, 49 , 4487–4496. 121. J.W. Strojek, M.C. Granger, G.M. Swain, T. Dallas, M.W. Holtz, Anal. Chem. 1996, 68 , 2031–2037. 122. Y. Gorbuz, W.P. Kang, J.L. Davidson, D.L. Kinser, D.V. Kerns, Sensors and Actuators B-Chemical 1996, 33 , 100–104. 123. Y. Gorbuz, W.P. Kang, J.L. Davidson, D.V. Kerns, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1999, 146 , 387–391. 124. C.E. Troupe, I.C. Drummond, C. Graham, J. Grice, P. John, J.I.B. Wilson, M.G. Jubber, N.A. Morrison, Diamond Relat. Mat . 1998, 7 , 575–580. 125. T.N. Rao, I. Yagi, T. Miwa, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, Anal. Chem. 1999, 71 , 2506–2511. 126. B.V. Sarada, T.N. Rao, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, New Diamond Frontier Carbon Tech. 1999, 9 , 365–377. 127. B.V. Sarada, T.N. Rao, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, Anal. Chem. 2000, 72 , 1632–1638. 128. E. Popa, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, Diamond Materials VI, Proceedings (Electrochemical Society Series) 2000, 99 , 512–517. 129. A. Fujishima, T.N. Rao, D.A. Tryk, Electrochim. Acta 2000, 45 , 4683–4690. 130. H.B. Martin, P.W. Morrison, Electrochem. Solid State Lett . 2001, 4 , E17–E20. 131. J.K. Zak, J.E. Butler, G.M. Swain, Anal. Chem. 2001, 73 , 908–914. 132. K. Hayashi, Y. Yokota, T. Tachibana, K. Kobashi, T. Fukunaga, T. Takada, J. Electrochem. Soc. 2001, 148 , H17–H20. 133. H. Kawarada, Y. Araki, T. Sakai, T. Ogawa, H. Umezawa, Phys. Stat. Solid. A-Appl. Res. 2001, 185 , 79–83. 134. E. Kohn, M. Adamschik, P. Schmid, A. Denisenko, A. Aleksov, W. Ebert, J. Phys. D-Appl. Phys. 2001, 34 , R77–R85.
18
ELECTROCHEMISTRY ON DIAMOND: HISTORY AND CURRENT STATUS
135. E. Kohn, W. Ebert, M. Adamschik, P. Schmid, A. Denisenko, New Diamond Frontier Carbon Tech. 2001, 11 , 81–100. 136. A.J. Saterlay, J.S. Foord, R.G. Compton, Electroanalysis 2001, 13 , 1065–1070. 137. A. Fujishima, T.N. Rao, Diamond Related Mat . 2001, 10 , 1799–1803. 138. R.L. McCreery, Chem. Rev . 2008, 108 , 2646–2687. 139. O. Chailapakul, W. Siangproh, D.A. Tryk, Sens. Lett . 2006, 4 , 99–109. 140. Y.L. Zhou, J.F. Zhi, Talanta 2009, 79 , 1189–1196. 141. C. Prado, G.U. Flechsig, P. Grundler, J.S. Foord, F. Marken, R.G. Compton, Analyst 2002, 127 , 329–332. 142. T.A. Ivandini, B.V. Sarada, T.N. Rao, A. Fujishima, Analyst 2003, 128 , 924–929. 143. M. Tachiki, Y. Kaibara, Y. Sumikawa, M. Shigeno, T. Banno, K.S. Song, H. Umezawa, H. Kawarada, Phys. Status Solidi A-Appl. Res. 2003, 199 , 39–43. 144. M. Adamschik, M. Hinz, C. Maier, P. Schmid, H. Seliger, E.P. Hofer, E. Kohn, Diamond Relat. Mat . 2001, 10 , 722–730. 145. K. Ushizawa, Y. Sato, T. Mitsumori, T. Machinami, T. Ueda, T. Ando, Chem. Phys. Lett . 2002, 351 , 105–108. 146. W.S. Yang, O. Auciello, J.E. Butler, W. Cai, J.A. Carlisle, J. Gerbi, D.M. Gruen, T. Knickerbocker, T.L. Lasseter, J.N. Russell, L.M. Smith, R.J. Hamers, Nature Materials 2002, 1 , 253–257. 147. T. Knickerbocker, T. Strother, M.P. Schwartz, J.N. Russell, J.E. Butler, L.M. Smith, R.J. Hamers, Langmuir 2003, 19 , 1938–1942. 148. K. Takahashi, M. Tanga, O. Takai, H. Okamura, Diamond Relat. Mat . 2003, 12 , 572–576. 149. S. Wenmackers, K. Haenen, M. Nesladek, P. Wagner, L. Michiels, M. vandeVen, M. Ameloot, Phys Status Solidi A-Appl. Res. 2003, 199 , 4–48. 150. W. Yang, J.E. Butler, J.N. Russell, R.J. Hamers, Langmuir 2004, 20 , 6778–6784. 151. T.L. Lasseter, W. Cai, R.J. Hamers, Analyst 2004, 129 , 3–8. 152. W. Yang and R.J. Hamers, Appl. Phys. Lett . 2004, 85 , 3626–3628. 153. M. Lu, T. Knickerbocker, W. Cai, W. Yang. R.J. Hamers, L.M. Smith, Biopolymers 2004, 73 , 606–613. 154. T. Lasseter, B.H. Clare, B.M. Nichols, N.L. Abbott, R.J. Hamers, Langmuir 2005, 21 , 6344–6355. 155. T.L. Lasseter, B.H. Clare, N.L. Abbott, R.J. Hamers, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2004, 126 , 10220–10221. 156. B. Rezek, D. Shin, T. Nakamura, C.E. Nebel, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2006, 128 , 3884–3885. 157. C.E. Nebel, D. Shin, D. Takeuchi, T. Yamamoto, H. Watanabe, T. Nakamura, Diamond Relat. Mat . 2006, 15 , 4–8. 158. D.C. Shin, N. Tokuda, B. Rezek, C.E. Nebel, Electrochem. Comm. 2006, 8 , 844–850. 159. R. Linares, P. Doering, B. Linares, Stud. Health Technol. Inform. 2009, 149 , 284–296. 160. C.E. Nebel, D.C. Shin, B. Rezek, N. Tokuda, H. Uetsuka, H. Watanabe, J. R. Soc. Interf . 2007, 4 , 439–461. 161. V. Vermeeren, S. Wenmackers, P. Wagner, L. Michiels, Sensors 2009, 9 , 5600–5636. 162. M. I. Landstrass, K. V. Ravi, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1989, 55 , 975–977. 163. R.S. Gi, T. Ishikawa, S. Tanaka, T. Kimura, Y. Akiba, M. Iida, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 1997, 36 , 2057–2060. 164. R.S. Gi, K. Tashiro, S. Tanaka, T. Fujisawa, H. Kimura, T. Kurosu, M. Iida, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 1999, 38 , 3492–3496.
REFERENCES
19
165. R.S. Gi, T. Mizumasa, Y. Akiba, Y. Hirose, T. Kurosu, M. Iida, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 1995, 34 , 5550–5555. 166. F. Maier, M. Reidel, B. Mantel, J. Ristein, L. Ley, Phys. Rev. Lett . 2000, 85 , 3472–3475. 167. J. Ristein, M. Riedel, F. Maier, B.F. Mantel, M. Stammler, L. Ley, J. Phys.: Condensed Mat . 2001, 13 , 8979–8987. 168. J.S. Foord, C.H. Lau, M. Hiramatsu, R.B. Jackman, C.E. Nebel, P. Bergonzo, Diamond Relat. Mat . 2002, 11 , 856–860. 169. V. Chakrapani, S.C. Eaton, A.B. Anderson, M. Tabib-Azar, J.C. Angus, Electrochem. Solid State Lett . 2005, 8 , E4–E8. 170. D. Petrini, K. Larsson, J. Phys. Chem. C 2007, 111 , 13804–13812. 171. V. Chakrapani, J.C. Angus, A.B. Anderson, S.D. Wolter, B.R. Stoner, G. U. Sumanasekera, Science 2007, 318 , 1424–1430. 172. V.I. Shapoval, I.A. Novosyolova, V.V. Malyshev, H.B. Kushkhov, Electrochim. Acta 1995, 40 , 1031–1035. 173. A. Denisenko, A. Aleksov, E. Kohn, Diamond Relat. Mat . 2001, 10 , 667–672. 174. J. Ristein, Science 2006, 313 , 1057–1058. 175. P. Strobel, M. Riedel, J. Ristein, L. Ley, Nature 2004, 430 , 439–441. 176. V. Chakrapani, J.C. Angus, A.B. Anderson, G. Sumanasekera, Diamond Electronics Symposium, Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. 2007, 956 , paper J15-01. 177. V. Chakrapani, C. Pendyala, K. Kash, A.B. Anderson, M.K. Sunkara, J.C. Angus, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2008, 130 , 12944–12952. 178. S.J. Sque, R. Jones, P.R. Briddon, Phys. Stat. Sol. (a) 2007, 204 , 3078–3084. 179. W. Chen, D. Qi, X. Gao, A.T.S. Wee, Prog. Surf. Sci . 2009, 84 , 279–321. 180. A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, T.N. Rao, D.A. Tryk, eds, Diamond Electrochemistry, Elsevier/BKS Inc., Tokyo, 2005.
2 Synthesis of Diamond Films Vadali V. S. S. Srikanth and Xin Jiang
2.1
INTRODUCTION
Diamond is a well-known gemstone and considered as a precious possession. About fourth century BC, diamonds were first mined in India, and in the second century BC, Chinese realized diamond’s first industrial use originating from its ultimate hardness. Based on the optical and electrical properties, and the nature and percentage of impurities present, natural diamonds are classified into four types of monocrystalline (types Ia, Ib, IIa, and IIb) and two types of polycrystalline (carbonados and ballas) diamonds. However, type Ia diamonds constitute 98% of the total natural diamonds. The space group for the diamond lattice is O7h (F4,/d 32/m) with two carbon atoms per Bravais cell. Diamond structure can be visualized as two interpenetrating face-centered cubic (FCC) lattices (see Figure 2.1) displaced along the body diagonal by (1/4, 1/4, 1/4)a, where a is the dimension of the cubic unit cell. Each carbon atom of the lattice has a tetrahedral configuration consisting of sp 3 hybrid atomic orbitals. The {111} crystallographic planes are constituted by 6-atom hexagonal rings that are arranged in such a way that the adjacent atoms are alternatively displaced upward and downward from the plane. The stacking sequence along the <111> direction is ABC ABC ABC . . . . In the ˚ same crystallographic direction, the lattice constant and bond length are 3.56 and 1.54 A, respectively. Diamond has two isomers—namely, graphite and lonsdaleite. In graphite, each carbon atom has sp 2 atomic configuration and therefore has three inplane σ bonds; the remaining valence electron forms π bonds using a pz atomic orbital. Consequently, the trigonally bonded 6-carbon rings are situated in a flat plane, contrary to that in the diamond structure. The stacking sequence of the planes in graphite is ABABAB. . . . The lattice constant in ˚ and the in-plane, nearest neighbor the basal plane between repeating layers is 6.707 A, ˚ spacing is 1.42 A. On the other hand, the structure of lonsdaleite is derived from diamond Synthetic Diamond Films: Preparation, Electrochemistry, Characterization, and Applications, First Edition. Edited by Enric Brillas and Carlos Alberto Mart´ınez-Huitle. © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Published 2011 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
21
22
SYNTHESIS OF DIAMOND FILMS
Figure 2.1
FCC structure of the diamond crystal. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 23.)
A
B
C
A
B
B
A
A
Figure 2.2 Crystal structure of cubic (left) and hexagonal (right) diamond. The difference in stacking sequence of (111) layer pairs in the two structures has been illustrated. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 23.)
(see Figure 2.2) in that the positioning of atoms in each plane is the same as that in the cubic diamond. However, the stacking sequence of planes is AB AB AB. . . . In lonsdaleite the atoms thus bond closely; the lattice constants in the a and c directions are 2.52 and ˚ respectively. The distance between adjacent atoms is 1.52 A. ˚ 4.12 A, Apart from being a precious gemstone, the diamond has always attracted a special attention due its unique and unsurpassed properties [1–3]. Consequently, research interests have risen to obtain synthetic diamond. Synthetic diamond was obtained for the first time by employing the high-pressure high-temperature (HPHT) technique [4]. In this
2.2 DIAMOND FILM CVD TECHNIQUES
23
technique, graphite and transition-metal (Fe, Ni, Co, etc.,) catalyst powders are mixed and the mixture is subjected to high pressures (∼80–300 kbar) and high temperatures (∼1900–3000◦ C) such that the catalyst component melts. The reaction is then equilibrated for a certain time; the temperature is then gradually decreased to reduce the carbon solubility in the catalyst, resulting in the precipitation of excess carbon as diamond. The role of catalyst in the HPHT technique is not only to lower the activation energy required for the conversion of graphite into diamond but also to dissolve the carbon atoms in the graphite, thus enabling them to reconstitute as diamond. Due to the availability of only expensive natural diamonds and synthetic diamonds only in the form of abrasive grit (via the HPHT technique), it was understood that most properties of diamond could be realized for technological applications only when it is synthesized as a thin film often chemically bonded to an underlying nondiamond substrate material. For almost five decades, chemical vapor deposition (CVD) has been the most commonly used technique to synthesize diamond films. The CVD of diamond involves growth of a tetrahedrally bonded carbon atom network affected by addition of one carbon atom at a time from a suitable gas phase to an initial template; it is accomplished at much lower pressures when compared to the HPHT technique [5–8]. The CVD of diamond thin films has been an interesting topic of research ever since its accomplishment [9–11] and subsequent modifications [12–23]. A typical diamond film growth process via any CVD method includes three main stages that lead to the incorporation of suitable gas species into the growing diamond solid phase: (1) activation of the gas mixtures; (2) gas-phase reactions; and (3) diffusion of gas species onto the substrate surface. Further chemistry occurs on the reaction surface and finally diamond growth takes place. Diamond films’ microstructure can range from oriented columnar grains (including epitaxial grains) to a nanocrystalline structure, depending on the deposition conditions such as surface pretreatment, temperature, pressure, and gas composition. When gas species responsible for diamond growth reach the reaction surface, adhere to it, and settle quickly into possible equilibrium positions before any structural defects form on the growth front, a single crystalline diamond film can be obtained. On the contrary, when the same atoms do not quickly settle into stable equilibrium positions upon their arrival at the reaction surface, nanocrystalline diamond films can be obtained. At present, diamond thin films are serving in a variety of applications related to machining, field emission, electromechanical systems, electrochemical systems, biomedical, biosensing, and others [24–34]. By making a review of diamond film synthesis, the objective of this chapter is to cover the most important scientific and engineering aspects of diamond CVD. This chapter starts with a review of typical diamond thin film synthesis techniques. In the subsequent sections, various aspects pertaining to diamond film (1) nucleation and growth and (2) epitaxy will be discussed. This chapter concludes with a brief discussion of some future perspectives.
2.2 2.2.1
DIAMOND FILM CVD TECHNIQUES History
In the early stages of research concerning CVD of diamond films, the most exciting feature was the formation of the diamond film itself. Although diamond film could be formed, it had been of little technological or commercial importance due to drawbacks
24
SYNTHESIS OF DIAMOND FILMS
such as extremely low growth rate, lack of substrate selectivity, formation of graphite, and other nondiamond forms of carbon. However, with time these drawbacks have been considerably overcome. Early CVD experiments employed mainly thermal decomposition of carbon containing gases at a pressure less than 1 atm to grow a diamond homoepitaxially on natural diamond crystals maintained at 900◦ C. The growth rate of diamonds in such experiments was a meager 1 nm/h; also, graphite was co-deposited alongside diamond. Later it was shown that atomic hydrogen could preferentially etch graphite during the diamond deposition. Subsequent research works extended the possibilities of diamond CVD by showing that diamond could be grown on nondiamond surfaces as well. In the early 1950s, Eversole and Kenmore [9] developed the cyclic pyrolysis process and demonstrated, for the first time, diamond synthesis under low pressures. In the early 1960s, Angus, Will, and Stanko [10] extended Eversole’s work and synthesized a boron-doped diamond film on diamond grit. Eversole’s work was further extended by Derjaguin et al. [11]. Interestingly, in 1953, Schmellenmeier [35] (of Germany) reported synthesis of crystalline diamond containing hard carbon films from acetylene in an electrical discharge. In 1982, Matsumoto et al. [15] made a major breakthrough in diamond CVD technology. A hot filament was used, and hydrocarbon and hydrogen gas mixtures were passed over it to directly activate the gas phase. The diamond film was then deposited onto a nondiamond substrate located about 1 cm away from the filament. Due to the presence of atomic hydrogen during the deposition, graphite was etched away simultaneously; this rendered the previously used deposition and etching cycles unnecessary, which in turn led to higher diamond growth rates. Since then, various gas phase activation methods such as direct current (DC)-plasma, radio frequency (RF)-plasma, microwave plasma, electron cyclotron resonance (ECR)-microwave plasma, and so on, were developed. Mainly, the role of atomic hydrogen in diamond growth was recognized, and the diamond growth rates approached the rates acceptable by industrial standards. In a further development, Rudder, Posthill, and Markunas [36] suggested that the pyrolysis of fluorocarbons such as tetrafluoromethane (CF4 ) could produce epitaxial diamond growth; this suggestion was based on the understanding that OH, O, O2 , F, and F2 species are better graphite etchants than atomic hydrogen. In this method, CF4 and F2 gas mixture diluted in He was blown onto a diamond substrate maintained at 875◦ C. The deposited diamond film was devoid of any graphite. Although the fluorocarbon pyrolysis process took place nearly at thermodynamic equilibrium, a growth rate of only ∼0.6 μm h−1 was achieved. In another development, hydrogen-deficient carbon-containing noble gas plasma was used to deposit phase-pure nanocrystalline diamond films on Si substrates [37]. On the other hand, other non-CVD methods based on low- [38] and high- [39] energy carbon ion beams have also been developed. Methods based on electron bombardment of the substrate have also been developed that resulted in an increase of diamond growth rates almost up to 20 μm h−1 [40,41]. In large areas, as large as 19 cm2 , low pressure diamond film growth has also been reported [42]. Besides CVD, physical vapor deposition methods were also employed [43,44]. A method wherein diamond growth at low temperatures (as low as 75◦ C) was also reported [45]. At present, various developments in plasma-type CVD processes are not only allowing the growth of polycrystalline diamond films with fewer defects but also the growth of single crystalline CVD diamond films with required and highly consistent properties. A good report on the synthesis of diamond in laboratory explaining several of the above discussed progresses is available [46].
2.2 DIAMOND FILM CVD TECHNIQUES
2.2.2
25
Thermal Decomposition Techniques
2.2.2.1 Hot Filament Chemical Vapor Deposition (HFCVD) The hot-filament CVD method is the earliest [15,16] and the most popular method used for diamond film deposition under low pressures (∼20–40 Torr). In this method, a refractory metal (such as tungsten, tantalum, and rhenium) filament is heated to a temperature above 2000◦ C; a methane (CH4 ) and hydrogen (H2 ) gas mixture, typically about 1:99 in volume, is then passed over the hot filament. Hydrocarbon pyrolysis takes place and diamond is deposited on a substrate (at ∼700–900◦ C) kept at a distance of about 8–10 mm from the hot filament. In the HFCVD process, atomic hydrogen is produced, which etches away graphite much faster than diamond. Thus, the deposition rate of diamond is typically about 1 μm h−1 , which is suitable for industrial purposes. For a schematic diagram of typical HFCVD reactor, please refer to [47, p. 155]. In the HFCVD method, the refractory metal filaments are first carburized prior to the deposition of diamond films. The vapor pressure of metal carbides is less than the respective metal. Therefore, at the working filament temperatures, carburization reduces the metallic impurity incorporation in the diamond films. The HFCVD method possesses the ability to adjust to a wide variety of carbon gas sources such as methane, propane, ethane, and other hydrocarbons. Even oxygen-containing hydrocarbons—including acetone, ethanol, and methanol—can be used. The addition of oxygen-containing species widens the temperature range within which diamond deposition can take place. With the aim of improving the phase purity and growth rate of diamond, some modifications have been incorporated into the typical design of HFCVD. In one such modification, a DCplasma is used in combination with the typical HFCVD setup; a bias voltage is applied to the substrate and filament [41,42,48]. A moderate positive voltage is applied to the substrate and a negative voltage to the filament (or an accessory electrode), resulting in electron bombardment of the substrate, which induces desorption of the surface hydrogen which in turn increases the growth rate (up to about 10 μm h−1 ). This technique is called electron-assisted HFCVD. When the bias voltage is high enough to ignite a stable plasma discharge, the decomposition of H2 and hydrocarbon is greatly enhanced, leading to a remarkable increase in the diamond growth rate (up to about 20 μm h−1 ). When the polarity of the bias is reversed—that is, when the substrate is negatively biased—substrates’ surface undergoes ion bombardment, which results in the enhanced nucleation of diamond on nondiamond substrates. Another modification is to replace the single hot filament with multiple filaments or a filament net for uniform diamond film deposition over large areas. 2.2.2.2 Oxy-Acetylene Torch Method Hirose and Kondo [49] were the first to introduce the combustion flame-assisted diamond CVD. In this method, the smoldering tip of a welding torch is used to oxidize a mixture of acetylene (C2 H2 ) and oxygen (O2 ) gases (ratio 1:1). Diamond film gets deposited on the substrate where the tip of the bright interior region of the flame touches the substrate, which is maintained at a temperature of 800–1050◦ C. Under appropriate experimental conditions, the diamond growth rate in this method can go up to 50–100 μm h−1 . Using this method, homoepitaxial films could be deposited at high rates [50]. The aerosol-doping technique, in combination with the oxyacetylene torch method, was used to dope boron into diamond films [51]. When the torch is used in its transversing mode, large-area diamond coatings could be obtained [52]. The advantages of this method over the conventional CVD methods include simplicity and cost-effectiveness of the equipment, lack of power supply, high growth rate, and the
26
SYNTHESIS OF DIAMOND FILMS
ability to deposit diamond over large areas and on curved substrate surfaces. On the other hand, in this method the deposition is difficult to control and consequently the deposited diamond films are inhomogeneous in both microstructure and composition. Also, the torch produces thermal gradients over the substrates’ surface, thereby causing the substrate to warp or fracture during the process of coating large substrate areas. Murakawa, Takeuchi, and Hirose [52] and Cappelli and Paul [53] have achieved great progress in enhancing the diamond film quality and area by using the oxy-acetylene torch method. 2.2.3
Plasma-Aided Deposition Techniques
2.2.3.1 Microwave Plasma-Enhanced CVD (MWCVD) It was found that the atomic hydrogen concentration under CVD conditions could be increased by using a DC plasma ignited by an electrical discharge [14,54]. Thus, plasma became another pathway to dissociate molecular hydrogen into atomic hydrogen and to simultaneously activate hydrocarbon species, thereby leading to the diamond deposition. Besides DC plasma, two other kinds of plasma with different excitation frequencies are possible. The excitation frequency for microwave plasma CVD is typically 2.45 GHz, whereas for radio frequency (RF) plasma CVD it is 13.56 MHz. A schematic of ASTeX microwave plasma CVD reactor is shown in Figure 2.3. Also, Davis [47, p. 159] provides a typical microwave reactor setup.
Microwave Gas inlet
Water cooling Plasma Substrate
Heating
Pump Bias power supply 0 ± 300 VDC
Figure 2.3 Schematic of a microwave plasma-enhanced CVD reactor manufactured by ASTeX. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 23.)
2.2 DIAMOND FILM CVD TECHNIQUES
27
The microwave frequency used to ignite the plasma oscillates the electrons in the gas mixtures used to deposit diamond. Consequently, high ionization fractions are generated as electrons collide with gas atoms and molecules. Microwave plasma has hot electrons as well as cold ions and neutrals. A substrate typically about 2–3 cm in diameter is placed on a holder in a tube reactor (quartz or steel) compatible with a waveguide that can guide the microwaves generated by a magnetron. Microwaves enter into the reaction chamber from a proprietary antenna that converts a rectangular microwave signal into a circular one. The microwave proceeds through a quartz window into the reaction chamber filled with gas at a particular pressure. The microwave energy is transmitted to the gas mixtures, thereby igniting a luminous ball-shaped plasma, the size of which can be enlarged by increasing the microwave power. The edge of the luminous plasma will be located typically about 2 cm above the substrate’s surface. In this setup, the substrate can be independently heated. Under suitable conditions of gas pressure, microwave power, gas mixture ratio, gas flow rates of different gases, substrate temperature, and so on, diamond film grows on the substrate. 2.2.3.2 DC Plasma CVD Direct current plasma CVD is another deposition technique wherein DC plasma is used to activate the gas source (typically hydrocarbon and hydrogen) for diamond growth. Suzuki et al . [21] developed the DC-plasma-assisted CVD (DC PACVD). In this method, a glow discharge is generated in the reactor between the substrate and the other electrode when the bias voltage is sufficiently high. The activation of the gas phase is thus achieved via the collisions of high-energy electrons with the neutral gas species, resulting in the dissociation of the gas species and the generation of diamond-forming reactive gas species. In all the DC PACVD setups, substrate is mounted on the anode of the reactor. The DC PACVD possesses the ability to coat large areas, which are limited only by the size of the electrodes and the DC power supply. However, this method has a drawback of depositing diamond at very low rates (<0.1 μm h−1 ). With the increase of gas pressure (∼150 Torr), DC voltage (∼1 kV), and discharge current, growth rates of up to 250 μm h−1 can be approached but with a reduction in the deposition area. Davis [47, p. 166] provides the schematic of a typical DC plasma CVD reactor. Another advance in DC plasma CVD is the DC plasma jet method. Kurihara et al. [55] have designed a DC plasma jet facility termed DIA-JET, which employs a gas- injection nozzle consisting of a cathode rod surrounded by an anode tube [56]. In this method, the substrate is placed on a separate water-cooled holder and the plasma is ignited by generating a DC arc discharge between the electrodes (typically a water-cooled copper anode and a tungsten cathode). Due to the use of high pressures and powers, a DC arc discharge can be generated. Typically, methane will be mixed with H2 /Ar plasma jet at high pressures (∼188 Torr). Due to the high temperatures (∼5000 K) in the plasma, a large fraction of H2 molecules dissociate and a sufficient supply of active diamond-forming carbon gas species are generated. The gas species in the plasma jet are transported to the substrate surface within a few hundred microseconds, thereby reducing hydrogen combination reactions. Typical growth rates up to 80 μm h−1 can be achieved. Because various DC arc methods can synthesize high-quality diamond on nondiamond substrates at fast growth rates, they provide a marketable means for diamond film synthesis. Ohtake and Yoshikawa [57] have achieved a growth rate of 930 μm h−1 using the DC plasma jet CVD. For many years, by using DC plasma jet CVD, thick diamond films are being obtained on a routine basis. Boron- or
28
SYNTHESIS OF DIAMOND FILMS
phosphorous-doped diamond film can also be obtained using DC plasma jet CVD [58]. As previously mentioned, in another DC-plasma deposition variation, Fujimori et al. [48] synthesized diamond films at high rates using a hybrid HFCVD plus DC plasma method. 2.2.3.3 RF Plasma CVD In this technique, radio frequency is used to generate a plasma using two electrode configurations—namely, capacitive-coupled parallel plates and induction at atmospheric pressure. Davis [47, p. 164] provides schematics of the two. RF plasma-assisted CVD utilizes a frequency of 13.56 MHz. RF plasma can be used to deposit diamond on areas larger than are possible using microwave plasmas. However, RF capacitive plasma is limited in that the frequency of the plasma is optimal for sputtering, especially if the plasma contains argon. On the other hand, capacitive coupled RF plasma is not suitable for the growth of high-quality diamond due to the ion bombardment from the plasma, which results in severe defects in the growing diamond film. Polycrystalline diamond films have been synthesized by the induction method using MWCVD deposition conditions [59]. Homoepitaxial diamond films have also been deposited by RF induction plasma enhanced chemical vapor deposition (PECVD) [48]. 2.2.3.4 Electron Cyclotron Resonance Microwave Plasma-Assisted CVD In this method, electron cyclotron resonance (ECR) is used to generate the microwave plasma. The cyclotron resonance is obtained when the frequency of an alternating electric field is made to match the natural frequency of the electrons orbiting the magnetic field force lines. This occurs in a magnetic field of 875 gauss at the standard microwave frequency of 2.45 GHz. A typical ECR-MP-CVD setup is shown in Figure 2.4. As discussed in the previous sections, direct current, radio frequency, and microwave plasmas ionize and decompose hydrogen and hydrocarbon species into hydrogen atoms and hydrocarbon radicals, and thus promote the diamond growth. It can thus be expected that ECR-MP-CVD can be a method capable of synthesizing diamond films since ECRMP generates high-density plasma (>1 × 1011 /cm3 ) that is favorable for diamond growth. In fact, Hiraki et al. [60] used ECR-MP-CVD to synthesize diamond in 1990. The growth temperature could be reduced to 500◦ C. Later, Yara et al. [61] and Mantei et al. [62] succeeded in diamond deposition using the ECR-MP-CVD technique. They obtained uniform films at substrate temperatures as low as 300◦ C. However, due to the extremely low pressure of the ECR process (10−4 –10−2 Torr), diamond growth proceeds at a very low rate. Therefore, this method is mainly used for laboratory experiments.
2.3 2.3.1
DIAMOND NUCLEATION AND GROWTH Nucleation
2.3.1.1 Definition and Types Diamond nucleation is the first and foremost step in diamond growth via CVD routes. The nucleation process affects film thickness, grain sizes, homogeneity, morphology, defects, surface roughness, and adhesion pertaining to the deposited diamond films. Nuclei are the smallest diamond units that have to be formed for the subsequent diamond growth to start. Nucleation is broadly classified into two types: homogeneous (gas phase) and heterogeneous (on the substrate). There are only few experimental evidences regarding gas phase nucleation [63] of diamond resulting from hydrocarbon molecules such as adamantane, tetracyclododecane, and hexacyclopentadecane acting as the possible diamond embryos. However, it was later shown
2.3 DIAMOND NUCLEATION AND GROWTH
H2 + CH4
Magnetic coil A
2.45 GHz microwave
Plasma
Sample loadlock Magnetic coil B
29
Windows
Diamond film Sample holder
Turbo pump
Figure 2.4 Ref. 23.)
Experimental setup for ECR plasma CVD of diamond. (Reprinted with permission from
that the suggested hydrocarbons are very unstable at CVD temperatures [64]. Additionally, diamond particulates if at all formed in the gas phase were in very low concentrations (when compared to the surface nucleation densities) and would have almost no effect on nucleation [65]. This revelation also led to the idea that small molecular species (for example, CH3 and C2 H2 ), which are capable of surviving the CVD atmosphere and reaching (to be incorporated into the growing diamond nuclei) the seeded substrate, are the ones more suitable for diamond nucleation and growth. On the other hand, heterogeneous nucleation (i.e., surface nucleation) of CVD diamond follows heteroepitaxial growth mechanism from a diamond-seeded (pretreated) substrate surface. First, gas atoms impinge on the reaction surface from the gas phase and get adsorbed onto the surface. Subsequently, the adatoms may either desorb or diffuse over the reaction surface; they may also diffuse into the substrate or bond to other surface atoms. With the deposition time, the surface concentration of the adatoms increases, resulting in the formation of nanoclusters. A statistical fluctuation in the local adatom concentration results in the growth or decay of the clusters. When the clusters attain a size just greater than a critical size, they become stable. Critical size is defined as the size above which growth will be greater than decay of the clusters during the concentration fluctuation. The time taken to form a stable nucleus is called the incubation period . The stabilized
30
SYNTHESIS OF DIAMOND FILMS
clusters then act as suitable sites for further growth either from the continued migration of single adatoms or from direct impingement of atoms from the gas phase. 2.3.1.2 Methods Scratching substrate surface with an abrasive powder has been the most common and powerful method for achieving diamond nucleation densities enough for the formation of continuous diamond films with uniform grain sizes. Mitsuda et al. [66] demonstrated for the first time that scratching the substrate surface with diamond powder could enhance the diamond nucleation density. Besides diamond powder, other abrasive powders such as SiC [67], cubic-BN [68], Cu or stainless steel [69], ZrB2 [70], Al2 O3 [71], and others, have also been used to scratch the substrate surface to enhance the diamond nucleation. Among all the powders, diamond powder has been the most effective one. The scratching technique can be applied to most of the substrates used for diamond growth. For Si substrates, a nucleation density of 107 –108 cm−2 can be routinely obtained after thoroughly scratching it with diamond powder. In contrast, the nucleation density in the case of nonscratched Si substrates can reach only 104 cm−2 . The nucleation density is proportional to the scratching time; the morphology changes from large isolated crystals for short scratching times to smaller, high-density crystals for long scratching times [71,72]. The grit size of the diamond powder used for scratching also influences the nucleation density; 0.25 μm grit is the most effective one for manual scratching [73], and a 40–50 μm powder is best for scratching in an ultrasonic bath using a grit suspension [74]. During scratching with diamond, cubic-BN, or a-SiC powder, the residual powder or fragments are unavoidably left in the scratched grooves and act as seeds for diamond growth. Crystal structures of cubic-BN and a-SiC are close to that of diamond and thereby diamond grows easily on them. In fact, Iijim, Aikawa, and Baba [75] observed the presence of diamond fragments in the scratched grooves of Si, upon which the diamond growth occurred. Scratching with abrasive powder changes the surface morphology; it creates edges, steps, dislocations, and other surface defects. These defects are considered as chemically active sites, which prefer to adsorb diamondforming gas species due to enhanced bonding at high-energy intersecting surfaces with a high density of unsaturated bonds and low coordination numbers [71,76,77]. In this context, using electron microscopy, Denning and Stevenson [70] experimentally observed diamond nucleation on the ridges that have been lithographically etched on nonscratched Si. Singh et al. [71] also reported enhanced nucleation on Si etched by HF/HNO3 . Si+ implantation on nonscratched Si has also been found to enhance the nucleation density [78]. In this method, neither diamond seeds nor carbon-rich layers existed; only the surface morphology or surface structure was changed. However, other attempts to enhance nucleation by creating etch pits on nonscratched Si using acid, H+ [79], or other reactive gas treatments [69] proved unsuccessful. Similarly, attempts to generate large numbers of defect sites via implantation with surface saturation levels of C+ [80] or Ar+ [79] on the unscratched substrates did not result in nucleation enhancement. An array of holes of 0.1–0.3 μm in diameter created by a focused Ga+ ion beam on a Si substrate resulted only in the deposition of nondiamond carbon in the grooves [81]. The reason for the discrepancy among these experiments is unclear. In order to avoid any such problems of understanding, the substrate surface must be thoroughly characterized (with nucleation point of view) prior to any diamond deposition since nucleation is a surface phenomenon and the most critical one. Another method to enhance diamond nucleation is to coat the substrate surface with graphite [82,83], amorphous carbon [82,84], diamond-like carbon [85–87], C60 , and
2.3 DIAMOND NUCLEATION AND GROWTH
31
mechanical oil [84]. This method and the previously mentioned scratching method cannot, however, result in oriented nucleation or epitaxial growth on nondiamond substrates. Bias-enhanced nucleation (BEN) is the method that not only results in higher nucleation densities, but under suitable experimental conditions, results in oriented or epitaxial nucleation. Yugo et al. [88] used the BEN method for the first time and obtained a high nucleation density (109 –1010 cm−2 ) on a mirror-polished substrate (without scratching). In this method a negative bias voltage is generally applied on the substrate in a typical MWCVD setup. BEN can lead to nucleation densities as high as 1010 –1011 cm−2 on mirror-polished Si substrates [89]. Using this method, Jiang and associates [90,91] and Stoner and Glass [92] realized the first ever heteroepitaxial growth of diamond on silicon and silicon carbide substrates, respectively. Yugo, Kimura, and Kanai [93] and Gerber et al. [94] explained the nucleation mechanism by suggesting a shallow ion implantation model in which the sp3 -bonded carbon clusters, formed by low-energy ion implantation, act as the active nucleation sites. The negative bias causes the positively charged ions in the gas phase (plasma in the case of MWCVD) to accelerate toward and bombard the substrate surface, thereby removing any contamination and facilitating the sp3 -bonded carbon cluster formation on the surface. These events in turn enhance the diamond nucleation. On the other hand, Stoner et al. [95] indicated that the critical process for nucleation should be the formation of a surface carbide layer and change in plasma chemistry, such as increase in the concentration of atomic hydrogen caused by substrate biasing. Jiang and colleagues [96,97] found that the overall temporal evolution of the nucleation density corresponds well with a surface kinetic model involving immobile active nucleation sites, germs, and nuclei. They also suggested that, in addition to surface defects (point defects, steps and sp3 -bonded carbon clusters) serving as the nucleation sites, the enhanced surface diffusion and sticking probability of carbon on silicon due to ion bombardment should be the decisive factors. The enhancement of surface diffusion of carbon species has been clearly observed by investigating the distribution of the first nearest-neighbor distances [96]. Stubhan et al. [98] and Lin and associates [40,41] showed that BEN also works in the HFCVD system. In the HFCVD method, the thermally activated gas-phase species (atomic hydrogen and hydrocarbon radicals) are neutral, and as a result, a negative substrate bias as in MWCVD cannot induce enhanced nucleation. However, when plasma is generated by proper choice of bias, enhancement of diamond nucleation similar to that in MWCVD can be achieved. Using BEN in HFCVD, a nucleation density of 109 –1010 cm−2 on mirror-polished Si was obtained, which is similar to the result obtained in the MWCVD system. There are also methods of obtaining high diamond nucleation densities without any surface scratching or substrate biasing. One method is by employing very low gas pressures; the other method is by Si+ implantation [78] into mirror-polished Si substrate prior to the introduction of methane into the deposition chamber. High-density diamond nucleation (109 –1011 cm−2 ) has been obtained on mirror-polished Si substrates using either HFCVD or ECR microwave plasma CVD setup working at very low pressures (0.1–1 Torr) [99]. Similar results have also been obtained on Ti substrates. Using this method, diamond grain density greater than 1010 cm−2 can be obtained, which is two orders of magnitude higher than the highest density (107 –108 cm−2 ) that can be obtained on scratched substrates under conventional CVD process pressure (10–50 Torr) values. In order to obtain high diamond nucleation densities by CVD methods, the substrate surface must be treated in such a way that (1) surface adsorption sites can be created for the incoming hydrocarbon radicals and (2) the distributed region of the adsorption sites
32
SYNTHESIS OF DIAMOND FILMS
is large enough (larger than the critical size of the nucleus) for continuing the growth of diamond nuclei. Si+ ions implantation into the mirror-polished Si substrate meets these criteria exactly. It changes only the surface structure without affecting the composition of Si. After a treatment with Si+ energy of 25 keV (lower energy would be better) and an implantation dose of 2 × 1017 cm−2 , diamond can easily nucleate and grow on a Si wafer. Si+ implantation-enhanced nucleation is assumed to create nanoscale surface defects on the Si substrate. These defects serve as active sites for the adsorption of hydrocarbon radicals necessary for initial diamond nucleation. A similar effect can also be found in the case of diamond growth on porous silicon [100] because, its surface has a dense nanoscale microstructure. 2.3.2
Growth
In order to grow diamond thin films more efficiently and economically, minimize defects in the films, know the most effective gas precursors, and so on, it is critical to understand the diamond film growth mechanism. Tsuda, Nakajima, and Oikawa [101,102] gave the first account of atomic scale {111} diamond growth mechanism [101,102]; it was proposed that diamond growth involved C+ 3 cations or a positively charged surface. However, this mechanism could not be generalized since, under HFCVD conditions, C3+ cations are scarce and the substrate surface is uncharged. Later, Chu et al. [103] proposed that the methyl radicals are the dominant species for the growth of all {111}, {100}, and {110} diamond facets under HFCVD conditions. However, at high temperatures, CH4 and C2 H2 will decompose into various products and it is difficult to distinguish from which original source the products originate. To this end, Martin and Hill [104] and Harris and Martin [105] showed that methyl or methane is more effective than acetylene for diamond film growth. Harris [106] used a nine-carbon model compound [bicyclononane (BCN)] and proposed a growth mechanism involving only neutral CH3 and hydrogen atoms. Frenklach and colleagues [107–110] proposed that acetylene, which is present in greater quantities than CH3 under HFCVD conditions [111–113], is the primary growth specie for {111} diamond and other low-index surfaces. On the other hand, the primary growth specie for nanocrystalline diamond growth has been found to be C2 dimer [114,115] but not CH3 or C2 H2 . In the following (111) and (100) diamond growth mechanisms, and the roles of hydrogen and oxygen gases during diamond film growth will be discussed in detail. Figure 2.5 shows high-resolution electron energy loss (HREEL) spectra obtained in situ during the growth of homoepitaxial (111) diamond surfaces and highly oriented (111) diamond films on Si (0 0 1) for different growth temperatures [116]. The loss peaks at 365, 155, 110, 310, and 460 meV correspond to CH stretching, CH bending, C–C stretching, and the first and second overtones of CH bending vibrations, respectively. The vibration modes and characteristic frequencies of CHx molecular subgroups [117,118] clearly indicate that the surface is not CH3 terminated, but CH terminated. Thus, diamond growth on the (111) surface proceeds via two-by-two layers mode. It can be noted that the CH stretching vibration is perpendicular to the (111) diamond surface, while the CH bending vibration is parallel to the (111) diamond surface. The electron-energy-loss spectral selection rule [119] does not allow the vibration parallel to the (111) surface and therefore should be absent in the spectra. However, in Figure 2.5, CH bending vibration loss peak at 155 meV is present. In order to understand this contradictory presence, the H on the (111) diamond surface was replaced by its isotope D [116]. By doing so, two types of adsorption sites were found to exist; one on the (111) surface, and the other
Intensity (arb. unit)
2.3 DIAMOND NUCLEATION AND GROWTH
33
(a)
(b)
14
(c) –100
100
300 500 Energy loss (meV)
700 ◦
◦
◦
Figure 2.5 HREEL spectra of (1 1 1) diamond facets grown at (a) 800 C, (b) 900 C, and (c) 1000 C. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 116.)
on another facet. If it is speculated that the growing (111) diamond surface consists of (111) faces and (110) steps, it is not difficult to reconcile the contradiction. The bending vibration of CH on the (110) surface steps is perpendicular to the (111) surface and therefore the CH bending vibration is active. As Frenklach pointed out, growth on the (111) surface takes place in two stages [109,110]. In the first, kernel forms; in the second, it propagates. In the first stage, the appearance of island and the (110) steps are possible. The existence of the CH bending vibration can thus be understood. The second stage of the Frenklach model, which details the connection of C2 H2 in a two-layers by two-layers manner, is experimentally supported [116]. In addition, it has been shown experimentally that during the kernel formation, CH3 is the responsible diamond growth specie [120]. In summary, growth on the (111) diamond surface has been proposed to be completed in two stages. In the first stage, a surface carbon (active site) is activated by H abstraction, adsorption, and catenation of CH3 , which results in kernel formation. In the second stage, the (111) surface grows along the (011) direction aided by acetylene alone. As for the growth mechanism of (100) diamond surface, Harris’ predictions [106] (BCN model) agreed well with experiments. However, the steric repulsion for the H–H site on BCN is different from that on the (100) diamond surface. On the (100) diamond surface, which is terminated by CH2 radicals, a very strong steric repulsion should exist
34
SYNTHESIS OF DIAMOND FILMS
between the neighboring hydrogen atoms because the intermolecular H–H spacing is only ˚ Such a repulsion will ˚ about 0.77 A—nearly the same as that in the H2 molecule (0.74 A). greatly affect the growth of the {100} diamond surfaces. Similar reasons hold true for some low-index surfaces as well. Hamza, Kubiak, and Sulen [112] obtained a 1 × 1 lowenergy electron diffraction (LEED) pattern on the (100) diamond surface at temperatures between 500 and 750 K [121]. This was attributed to the saturation of the dangling bonds of a surface carbon atom by two hydrogen atoms, and thus surface reconstruction did not occur. This surface was a nominally di-hydrogenated surface. Above 1300 K, the surface structure showed a 2 × 1 reconstruction due to desorption of one H atom from a surface carbon atom. This surface was a nominally mono-hydrogenated surface with an elongated C–C dimer bond [122]. A 2 × 1 reconstruction of the (100) diamond surface grown at 1000◦ C was also observed by both scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and atomic force microscopy (AFM) [123,124]. Figure 2.6 shows HREEL spectra of the (1 0 0) diamond surface grown at a temperature of 800◦ C [125]. Intensity losses occur at 156, 180, and 372 meV, with three smaller losses at 110, 310, and 530 meV. Compared with the characteristic frequencies of the molecular subgroups CHx [115,116], the spectrum is consistent with that of the CH2 radical, which has its stretching, scissors, wagging, twisting, and rocking vibrations at 370, 179, 157, 150, and 108 meV, respectively. In the HREEL spectra, 372, 180, and 110 meV losses are assigned to CH2 stretching, scissors, and rocking vibrations, respectively; and 156 meV loss is assigned to the overlapping of wagging and twisting vibrations. The 310 meV is the overtone of the loss at 156 meV, and the loss at 530 meV is the combination of CH2 wagging and stretching vibrations. The film deposited at 800◦ C exhibits a good crystallinity. At 1000◦ C, the film shows a “cauliflower”-like morphology, and the Raman spectrum exhibits a broad peak at 1580 cm−1 , which is characteristic of graphite, whereas its HREELS is similar to the one at 800◦ C. However, a prominent peak appears at 140 meV. This peak corresponds to the bending vibration of the mono-hydrogenated dimer. Due to the appearance of the mono-hydrogenated surface, hydrogen atoms that are bonded to the (100) surface become further separated. As a result, it releases the strong steric repulsion between the H atoms. Nevertheless, the CH bond of mono-hydrogenated dimer possesses to some extent π bond character. As the hydrocarbon radicals attach to the CH bond, they also take in some π bond character. Their tendency to form graphite is the reason why we observe a broad peak at 1580 cm−1 in the Raman spectrum. Noteworthy is that if the (100) surface of the as-grown sample is exposed to atomic hydrogen (no hydrocarbon involved), the 140 meV loss peak also appears in the HREEL spectrum. This can be explained by the abstraction of one of the two hydrogen atoms bonded to a surface carbon by gas-phase atomic hydrogen. If the abstraction is strong enough, mono-hydrogenated dimers appear in some local regions where the surface is similar to the growth surface at 1000◦ C. If the amount of atomic hydrogen is small, or if the abstraction proceeds at a moderate temperature (∼800◦ C), or if hydrocarbon is involved in the gas source, the abstraction of H will not be strong. Thus, di-hydrogenated carbon atoms remain in the neighborhood of C with one abstracted H, and mono-hydrogenated dimers cannot be formed. The carbon atom then keeps only one H and one vacant site, which may bond to the hydrocarbon radical. As a result, diamond growth proceeds steadily. The quantity of carbon with one hydrogen is determined by the growth temperature, the amount of atomic hydrogen near the surface, and the concentration of activated hydrocarbon. At growth temperatures around 1000◦ C, the (100) diamond surface consists of mono-hydrogenated H–C–C–H dimers as well. For even higher temperatures, a large amount of hydrogen
2.3 DIAMOND NUCLEATION AND GROWTH
35
Intensity (arb. unit)
(a)
(b)
(c) 14
(d) –100
100
300 500 Energy loss (meV)
700 ◦
Figure 2.6 HREEL spectra of (a) (1 0 0) diamond facets grown at 800 C (b) (1 0 0) facets grown at ◦ 1000 C, (c) the sample of (a) dosed with atomic hydrogen, and (d) dosed with oxygen. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 116.)
desorbs from the surface and the surface carbons become CC dimers. The growth rate of the CH2 -terminated surface is determined by the amount of CH3 radicals in the gas phase. It has been shown that atomic hydrogen can easily abstract one hydrogen atom from CH3 ; therefore, CH2 radicals become the precursor of (100) diamond growth [126]. The control of the appearance of diamond grain facets becomes significant not only in practical usage but also in the testing of established diamond growth mechanisms. The morphology of CVD diamond films is correlated with the growth parameters. Systematic studies on the relationship between the appearances of the (111) and (100) facets and the growth parameters such as the ratio of CH4 /H2 , O2 content, and distance from the hot filament to the substrate have been reported [127,128]. It is well known that, for a kinetically controlled growth system, the crystal morphology is determined by the appearance of facets that have the slowest growth rate in their normal direction and by the corresponding relative growth rates [129]. Because the (110) surface is an S (stepped) face and encounters no repulsion between adjacent hydrogen atoms, it should have the highest growth rate and appear as diamond facets on the film surface. In fact, the growth rate of the (110) surface via the CVD method is the highest among the low-index surfaces, and either CH3 radical- or acetylene-speciesbased mechanisms can be postulated. Thus, in most cases, the surface of CVD diamond crystals appear with {100} faces and {111} faces. According to the established growth
36
SYNTHESIS OF DIAMOND FILMS
model, the growth rate of the (100) face depends on the concentration of CH2 or CH3, whereas the growth rate of the (1 1 1) facet relies on both CH3 and C2 H2 for kernel formation and subsequent growth. If the CH3 concentration near the substrate is much higher than the C2 H2 concentration, the {100} growth rate will be high, and hence the {100} faces will be absent. The crystal appears to have just {111} diamond faces. In contrast, if the C2 H2 concentration near the growth surface is dominant, the {111} diamond face grows faster [130], which consequently results in the appearance of {100} diamond facets. In most cases, the concentrations of CH3 and C2 H2 are comparable, so both {100} and {111} facets are present. Harris and Weiner [131] and Harris and colleagues [132] have measured the dependence of the CH3 and C2 H2 concentrations on the CH4 /H2 and O2 /H2 ratios, as well as on the spacing between the hot filament and substrate. Based on their experimental results, Sun, Zhang, and Lin [125] explained the regularity of the appearance of the diamond facets. In general, CVD diamond growth involves site activation by a surface hydrogen abstraction reaction, (Equation 2.1), followed by addition (Equation 2.2) of a hydrocarbon radical like CH3 [133,134]. Cd represents a surface radical. The competition between surface activation (Equation 2.1) and H-atom recombination with the surface radical site (Equation 2.3) determines the number of active nucleation sites available for a particular set of experimental parameters [133]: Cd H + H∗ ↔ Cd∗ + H2
(2.1)
Cd∗ + CH∗3 ↔ Cd − CH3
(2.2)
Cd∗
(2.3)
∗
+ H ↔ Cd − H
The stable nano-sized crystals formed during the nucleation stage typically exhibit spherical shapes. With time, nucleation density increases to a certain value on which it terminates or ceases to occur at a measurable rate. The isolated crystallites now grow and develop facets due to the relatively high rate of surface carbon diffusion from the surrounding surface sites. Once the crystals grow large enough to coalesce with each another, they form grain boundaries and then continue growing as a continuous film. The morphology of a growing diamond surface depends on the rates at which different diamond planes grow. Under typical growth conditions, the morphology assessment of a diamond film can be made by the growth parameter (Equation 2.4): α=
√ ν100 3 ν111
(2.4)
where ν100 and ν111 are the normal growth velocities of (100) and (111) diamond planes respectively [129,135]. The grains exhibiting fastest growth in the direction perpendicular to the substrate overshadow other slower-growing grains to form a continuous film with a columnar structure [136]. This mode of film growth is known as the evolutionary selection principle [137]. On the contrary to evolutionary selection principle, Jiang et al. [138] showed an oriented diamond growth dependent on facet reactivity and selectivity. Due to the presence of a very little amount of tetramethylsilane gas during a typical MWCVD of diamond, nanocrystalline β-SiC phase selectivity forms on different growing diamond
2.3 DIAMOND NUCLEATION AND GROWTH
37
faces—namely, (001) and (111)—appearing to the gas phase. At the considered experimental conditions, (001) diamond faces avoid any solid deposition resulting from siliconcontaining gas species. In addition, the defective nature of {111} diamond faces will decrease the nucleation barrier and provide high density of active nucleation sites for nano–β-SiC deposition. Figure 2.7 shows the scanning electron microscope (SEM) crosssectional image of the film. There is a single grain growth (marked by arrows) in [001] with its size increasing toward the surface, indicating that tetramethylsilane (TMS) addi¯ direction that tion allows only few suitable nuclei to grow. Typical edges along [110] are formed due to the intersection of {111} planes can also be clearly observed. To explain theoretically this novel growth mechanism, the energy levels of the frontier molecular orbitals (FMOs) and other nearby orbitals of the reactants, a CH3 , a diamond nanoparticle, and a SiH3 , determined at HF/6-31G** level of theory, see Figure 2.8. The growth mechanism was explained by analyzing the reaction occurrence by judging the energy difference between the FMOs of the reactants diamond and CH3 /SiH3 , using frontier orbital theory. The theoretical study revealed that {111} diamond facets are more reactive with SiH3 than the {100} diamond facets, readily forming SiC phases on the {111} facets and leaving the {100} facet clean and with only diamond growth. The selection of diamond (001) plane growth is therefore due to the distortion and/or termination of non-{001} planes growth. Here, the evolutionary selection theory [129,137] is no longer valid because the growth of all the non-{001} faces is interrupted due to nano–β-SiC deposition, even though their growth rates could be higher than that of (001) face. The formation of [001] texture in the present case is therefore due to an angular selection. The {001} facets growth without any tilt will be the fastest and occupy the top-most position, and as a result the tilted facets have no space to develop due to the geometric limitations. Diamond growth models are developed by considering the effects of C1 hydrocarbon radicals—namely, CH3 , CH2 , CH, and C atoms—on both monoradical and biradical reaction surface sites [139]. At typical CVD diamond deposition conditions, diamond growth takes place mainly via the addition of CH3 radicals to monoradical sites. Growth can also take place via the addition of CH3 radicals to the biradical sites; here, the
Figure 2.7 Backscattered field emission scanning electron microscope (FE-SEM) cross-sectional morphology of a film deposited with a continuous variation of TMS gas from a value of 0.0506 to 0% during the deposition. The brighter spot-like regions represent β –SiC phase. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 138.)
38
SYNTHESIS OF DIAMOND FILMS
0.4 0.3
FMO eigenvalues of reactants (a.u.)
0.2
LUMO {111}
LUMO
{111}
{111}
0.1
LUMO
{100}
0.0 –0.1 {111}
–0.2
{111} {111}
–0.3 –0.4
HOMO {100}
HOMO
HOMO
–0.5 –0.6 –0.7 CH3
Diamond
SiH3
Figure 2.8 The energy levels of FMOs (with isosurfaces as inset) and other nearby orbitals of the reactants of CH3 , diamond nanoparticle (C54 H56 ), and SiH3 . The two energy levels with equal value next to the HOMO for CH3 or SiH3 are degenerate. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 138.)
unused surface dangling bonds can be rapidly hydrogenated during the conversion of CH3 adducts into a CH2 surface groups [140]. At some deposition conditions, the biradical mechanism is dominant; in this case, the probability of species like C2 , C2 H, and so on, to be the biradical site adducts is enhanced. Such reactive species then have the opportunity to cross-link on the surface, creating a strongly bonded (maybe even nonetchable) defect. This surface defect could act as either a renucleation point for a new epitaxial layer, or, if it is misaligned with the existing lattice, a new crystallite growing in a different direction to that of the main bulk. This last possibility, often termed renucleation, leads to a decrease in the average crystal size. If renucleation occurs frequently, the crystallite size can drop from mm to μm, and eventually to nm, and the films are referred to single crystalline diamond, microcrystalline diamond , and (Ultra) nanocrystalline diamond , accordingly. In addition to CH3 , addition of the other less abundant but highly reactive C1 species, particularly atomic C, to either type of radical site at high H-atom concentration, can also be a route to growth, since the dangling bonds on the adduct would be readily hydrogenated converting the adduct into CH2 . However, at low H-atom concentration, the dangling bonds on the adduct can cross-link to lattice sites, again leading to renucleation and subsequent smaller crystal sizes. Models based on the surface migration of reactive species could predict even diamond growth rates and average crystallite sizes [141,142]. May et al. [143] have critically reviewed the diamond growth mechanism to simulate diamond growth on the (100) surface and presented a unified model for diamond growth based on Monte Carlo simulations [143]. Surface migration, nucleation processes, and
2.3 DIAMOND NUCLEATION AND GROWTH
39
the effects of gas impurities and gas surface reactions have been carefully incorporated into the model to generate diamond growth on the (100) surface. The growth rate is determined mainly by a balance between the flux of CH3 species to the surface and the desorption/etching rate. Using values for the various rates from the literature, a growth rate for standard diamond growth conditions of ∼1 μm h−1 has been estimated, which is consistent with experimental values. Migration of species along and across dimer rows is essential to obtain step-edge growth and smooth surfaces. Without migration, the surfaces become rough and spiky, and the growth rate drops typically by a factor of ∼2, although the exact amount depends on the choice of conditions, and can be several times this value if, for example, a much faster migration rate is used. The growth rate enhancement caused by migration is roughly proportional to the surface diffusion length. It follows that the growth rate enhancement is due to the increased probability of the migrating species meeting a step-edge due to sampling a larger number of surface sites than stationary species. By using a parameter to represent random surface defect formation, growth morphologies resembling “wedding cake” structures can be produced, which again, are consistent with atomic-scale morphologies seen experimentally, and may, in principle, be scaled up to rationalize the cauliflower or ballas diamond morphologies seen at higher C:H ratios. β-scission has been shown to be a minor process, removing only 1-in-800 of the adsorbing carbons from the lattice. Thus, its importance in maintaining a smooth growing surface and in removing longer-chained polymeric species from the surface may have been previously overestimated. 2.3.3
Role of Hydrogen and Oxygen
The most crucial aspect in a typical diamond CVD process is that the hydrocarbon gas must be diluted in hydrogen to as low as 1% and that the hydrogen must be dissociated into atomic hydrogen, which has several specific roles. During the deposition process, atomic hydrogen etches graphite about 20–30 times faster than diamond, resulting in rapid removal of graphite and other nondiamond phases from the substrate and thereby allowing only clusters with diamond structure to remain and grow [125]. The process stabilizes the diamond surface and maintains the sp3 hybridization configuration [144]. Atomic hydrogen not only converts hydrocarbons into the respective radicals that are the necessary species for diamond formation but it also abstracts hydrogen from the hydrocarbons attached on the surface [145], thereby creating active sites for adsorption of the diamond-forming species. However, excess atomic hydrogen causes unnecessarily strong abstraction. The formation of mono-hydrogenated dimers will increase and the graphite phase will readily appear, which results in the deterioration of diamond film quality. As already mentioned, diamond growth is a combined process of deposition and carbon etching that take place concurrently. The growth of diamond occurs if the deposition rate is larger than the etching rate. During CVD growth of diamond films, both atomic H and H+ ions in the plasma cause etching, and H+ ions etch even faster than atomic H [146,147]. It was found that a [001]-textured top layer can be prepared on polycrystalline or [111]-textured diamond films by the application of a negative substrate bias potential during diamond growth [147–149]. An etching effect of hydrogen ions on the growth of diamond films was observed and confirmed to play a dominant role for the [001]-textured growth. The H+ ion bombardment was performed by applying a negative substrate bias during a microwave plasma CVD process, using only hydrogen as the reactant gas. It was discovered that the etching efficiency of H+ ions on non-[001]- oriented grains is
40
SYNTHESIS OF DIAMOND FILMS
higher than that on grains with their (001) faces parallel to the substrate. Lateral growth of the (001) faces can occur during the bombardment process. As a result, the size of the (001) faces increases after H+ etching while grains oriented in other directions are etched off. This effect provides a way to improve the orientation degree of [001]-oriented diamond films and may be helpful for obtaining very thin [001]-oriented diamond films. As for the role of oxygen, its addition (in the form of CO, O2 , or alcohol) to the reaction gases not only has a beneficial effect on the growth rate and quality of the diamond films but it also allows low-temperature diamond growth [150]. Although hydrocarbon species are somewhat reduced by oxygen addition, oxygen has only a relatively small effect on the mole fractions of radical species such as H and CH3 [151]. Also, OH is formed at concentrations sufficient for the removal of nondiamond carbon at a rate comparable to that of diamond growth. At low temperatures (<800◦ C), the addition of oxygen not only enhances the growth rate but it also extends the region of diamond formation [152]. At temperatures lower than 500◦ C, oxygen was explained to have stronger preferential etching behavior than hydrogen. Another possible explanation about the role of atomic oxygen is its aid in the effective abstraction of surface hydrogen [153]. These occurrences are helpful for diamond growth. On the other hand, the addition of too much oxygen will cause strong hydrogen abstraction and even oxidation of the surface, which in turn will deteriorate the diamond film.
2.4
DIAMOND EPITAXY
Fabrication of diamond-based electronic devices requires diamond single crystals or epitaxial films. Even though epitaxial diamond films can be grown on natural or HPHT diamond [127,154–160], their industrial viability is quite low. This is because natural diamonds are rare and expensive, whereas HPHT-grown diamond crystals are small for practical purposes. To counter such problems, it is necessary to obtain heteroepitaxially grown diamonds. In this context, cubic boron nitride (cubic-BN) is the best candidate for diamond heteroepitaxy [161–166]. Cubic-BNs’ lattice parameter (1.3% mismatch) and surface energy are similar to that of diamond [167,168]. In spite of its large lattice mismatch (22%) with diamond, β-SiC is the second best candidate for diamond heteroepitaxy. Stoner and Gloass [92] obtained highly oriented diamond crystallites on β-SiC; diamond crystallites with diamond (100)//β-SiC (100), diamond [011}]//β-SiC [011] crystallographic relationships were obtained. Jiang and Klages [90] and their colleagues [91] obtained [001]-oriented diamond films grown epitaxially on Si (001) substrate. High-resolution transmission electron microscopy analysis showed that diamond (001) grew directly on silicon (001) [169,170] (see Figure 2.9). It was therefore understood that under certain experimental conditions when a negative electrical potential is applied to the substrate, there is no necessity for an intermediate β-SiC layer for epitaxial diamond nucleation on Si. Various researchers [171–174] and Stubhan et al. [98] could also obtain heteroepitaxial growth of diamond (0 0 1) on Si (0 0 1) employing the HFCVD method. It was also possible to improve the structural quality of diamond films by reducing the orientation deviation on Si (1 0 0) substrates from a best value of about 9◦ [175], as determined from the full width at half maximum (FWHM) of x-ray rocking curves, to a best value of about 2◦ [176]. The misorientation of diamond grown on β-SiC (001) has also been greatly reduced. An orientation deviation of smaller than 1◦ could be achieved in the case of diamond epitaxy on β-SiC (001) [177].
2.4 DIAMOND EPITAXY
41
Figure 2.9 HRTEM cross-sectional lattice image showing epitaxially grown diamond on Si; the image is taken along the [1 1 0] direction of the diamond-silicon interface. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 169.)
Diamond was heteroepitaxially grown on other types of substrate materials—namely, BeO [178], Ni [179], Pt [180], Co [181], Ir [182–184], and SrTiO3 [185]. However, practical applications of diamond epitaxy on these substrates are still unclear. As for practical applications, diamond epitaxy on Si is highly desirable not only because of the ease of Si wafer availability but also because of its extensive usage in the electronics industry. Diamond epitaxy on Si will facilitate the integration of diamond-thin film electronics with that of already established Si technology and consequently could give a big leap to the diamond-based electronic device fabrication. Diamond heteroepitaxy on Si, then, has immense technological and scientific importance. In the following, diamond heteroepitaxy on Si will be elucidated. Typically, diamond heteroepitaxy on silicon involves two stages: nucleation and growth. It is well known that diamond nucleation on mirror-polished silicon substrates is difficult. Under conventional nucleation procedures (without substrate pretreatment), a nucleation density of only 104 cm−2 can be obtained, which can lead to the growth of only isolated individual diamond crystals. To avoid the substrate scratching with diamond powder, which severely damages the arrangement and periodic structures of the surface atoms, BEN was employed in a MWCVD system to epitaxially grow diamond on a mirror-polished Si substrate. Figure 2.10 shows a schematic diagram of the process parameters. Prior to BEN, in situ hydrogen plasma etching was performed in order to remove the native surface oxide layer. By carefully controlling the nucleation process, diamond nucleation with more than 90% [001]-oriented nuclei was achieved [97]. Later, high-density nucleation and oriented diamond films were also achieved by applying a negative bias to the substrate in a HFCVD system [96,171]. The investigation of the nucleation process reveals a narrow parameter window for epitaxial nucleation. The crucial parameters are the substrate temperature, methane concentration, applied bias voltage to the substrate during nucleation, and the nucleation time. A critical bias
42
SYNTHESIS OF DIAMOND FILMS
nucleation cooling growth
Magnitude (arb. units)
etching
0.4–4.0 0.4–2.0
CH4 (%)
700–800
Ts (°C)
0
0 ≈ 850
800–900
0 Vb (V) –50––150 –150 0
20
60 40 Time (min)
80
1000
Figure 2.10 Schematic diagram of the MWCVD process for preparing heteroepitaxial diamond films on Si. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 97.)
Figure 2.11 Diamond nucleation density as a function of substrate bias voltage. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 186.)
voltage exists, although experimental results show different values for various reaction chambers. Typically, the critical bias voltage for a process pressure of 20–40 mbar is approximately −80 to −120 V (see Figure 2.11) [186]. The early stages of diamond nucleation on Si have been systematically studied by using atomic force microscopy (AFM) and reflection-high-energy-electron diffraction (RHEED) [187,96]. The RHEED patterns (see Figure 2.12) obtained for different nucleation times
2.4 DIAMOND EPITAXY
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
43
Figure 2.12 RHEED patterns obtained for different nucleation time (a) 7.5 min, (b) 10 min, (c) 12.5 min and (d) 15 min. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 23.)
contained diffraction spots corresponding to diamond after several minutes of deposition, which suggested that a certain period of time is necessary for the initiation of nucleation. It is demonstrated that the diamond nuclei formed at the start of the nucleation are oriented. As the nucleation time increases, the nucleation density increases dramatically to 5 × 1010 cm−2 (see Figure 2.13) [96] and the nuclei become randomly oriented. It is therefore important to control the nucleation process for epitaxial diamond growth [97]. Schreck and associates [188,189] studied this processing space for heteroepitaxial nucleation of diamond on Si (001) using the bias process by x-ray diffraction texture measurements. It was found that the bias time lies within a distinct time interval and that the width of the time window and the bias time for optimal crystal alignment decrease sharply as the absolute value of the bias voltage decreases. A possible mechanism of the loss of diamond epitaxy was suggested by Jiang et al. [190] and Schreck et al. [188] after investigating diamond growth under bias conditions. According to this mechanism, slightly misoriented crystallites grow homoepitaxially on {100} facets and the crystal misorientation can be traced back to either the formation of defects during the homoepitaxial growth of the crystallites induced by ion bombardment or the increased renucleation of strongly misoriented grains.
44
SYNTHESIS OF DIAMOND FILMS
Figure 2.13 Nucleation density (islands/cm2 ) versus deposition time. In the abscissa, an induction time of 6.5 min is subtracted. The curve is obtained by computer modeling. The open and full circles in the plots represent data calculated from crystal size distribution and obtained by direct particle counting, respectively.
Textured diamond growth follows Van der Drift’s growth mode [137] if the growth process proceeds to longer times (larger thickness), and permits only crystallites that are oriented in the fastest growth direction (approximately parallel to the general growth direction) to grow further. As previously mentioned, the fastest growth direction can be varied by changing the process parameters, the most important of which are the substrate temperature and methane concentration [137]. Application of a proper bias potential to the substrate is also another parameter that leads to a strong selection of the growth direction [190]. The selection effect is attributed to the direction-dependent etching of the diamond crystal by H+ ions [191]. Therefore, film texture can be achieved for thin films. Both of the aforementioned approaches have been used to prepare epitaxially oriented films [135,149]. Heteroepitaxial [001]-oriented diamond films with considerably increased lateral grain size and strongly improved orientational perfection could be prepared by a microwave plasma-assisted chemical vapor deposition using a [001]-textured growth process on Si (001) substrates followed by a [110]-step-flow growth process [176,192]. The diamond films were characterized by atomic force microscopy, scanning electron microscopy, and transmission electron microscopy. The results indicate that diamond crystals increase their lateral dimensions at the (001) film surface either by coalescence of grains combined with a termination of the propagation of grain boundaries or by changing the grain boundary plane orientations from preferentially vertical to preferentially parallel directions with respect to the (001) growth faces. In the second case, the grains with relatively large angle deviation from the ideal epitaxial orientation are overgrown by those with relatively small angle deviation. As a result, the degree of orientational perfection of the films improves considerably in comparison to that of films prepared by the established process of [001]-textured growth. The presence of boron in the gas phase was found to strongly enhance the step-flow lateral grain growth. It was possible to achieve deposition of a thin boron-doped diamond films characterized by a full width at half maximum value of the measured tilt angle distribution of only 2.1◦ .
2.5 NANODIAMOND THIN FILMS
45
Early studies revealed that the growth of diamond on Si occurred through a β-SiC interlayer [193,194]. This perhaps is expected, considering that the lattice misfit between diamond and β-SiC (22%) is much smaller than that between diamond and silicon (52%). However, a direct lattice observation of the interface between silicon and epitaxially grown diamond crystals has been successfully performed [169,170]. It clearly demonstrated that the diamond nuclei are grown in direct contact with the silicon substrate (see Figure 2.9). Because the ratio of the lattice constants of silicon and diamond is close to 1.5, a nearly perfect 3 to 2 correspondence (1.5% mismatch) of lattice spacing is seen at the interface (e.g., every three Si (111) fringes are matched well with four diamond (111) fringe; the mismatch is about 1.5%). Individual 60◦ interface misfit dislocations for every ˚ can third (111) atomic plane, with a spacing between two such dislocations of about 7 A, be clearly identified (see Figure 2.9). The presented results are reproducible for many of the epitaxially oriented diamond grains observed and they provide strong evidence that diamond crystal can be epitaxially grown directly on Si. From the experimental results, it can be concluded that if the growth temperature is not too high and the incubation time is sufficiently short, diamond can grow directly on the Si substrate, avoiding the formation of the β-SiC interlayer. A thin epitaxial SiC intermediate layer is unnecessary for diamond heteroepitaxy. Theoretical investigations of the interface structure between diamond and silicon have also provided support for the direct growth of diamond on silicon [195,196]. Although great progress has been made in the heteroepitaxy of diamond on silicon, efforts are still needed to obtain large-area, single crystalline diamond films. For the heteroepitaxy of diamond directly on silicon, the following approaches may be taken into consideration. This is the first and essential requirement: The substrate surface must be clean, without surface contamination and oxidation, and the dangling bonds of the Si surface atoms must be saturated by hydrogen. During the BEN process, surface damage due to ion bombardment and the formation of amorphous carbon must be avoided. The bias voltage, biasing time, and pressure strongly influence crystal orientations. The bombardment of energetic ions above a critical energy is necessary for the formation of nuclei. A negative influence by ion bombardment on the alignment of the diamond grains has also been demonstrated. An improved epitaxy requires a compromise of the positive and negative influences. On the other hand, at present the vacuum for CVD diamond nucleation and growth is low and the residual gas in the chamber would contaminate or even oxidize the Si surface and change the surface status. Thus, improvement of the base vacuum in the growth chamber and the purity of gas source would be helpful in achieving better epitaxy.
2.5
NANODIAMOND THIN FILMS
With their unusual structure, properties, and applications, nanocrystalline (NC) films have been attracting rapidly increasing research interests [197]. Nanocrystalline diamond-thin film intrinsically possesses high uniformity, extremely high grain boundary density, and pin-hole-free ultra-smooth surface morphology even for film thicknesses well below 1 μm. Such films serve in a variety of applications [198–204]. Nanocrystalline diamond films were first deposited on Si substrates from a hydrogen-deficient carbon-containing noble gas CVD plasma [37]; phase-pure diamond film with nanometer-sized grains was also grown at very low hydrogen concentrations via a chemical pathway involving the insertion of C2 dimer into carbon-carbon and carbon-hydrogen bonds of the growing
46
SYNTHESIS OF DIAMOND FILMS
film [205]. One may obtain NC diamond films by adding nitrogen [206] to a high methane-containing CVD plasma or a very little amount of tetramethylsilane [207] to a very low methane-containing CVD plasma. Another special route developed to synthesize NC diamond films was based on the effect of ion-bombardment-induced, high-frequency secondary diamond nucleation [208,209]. By means of the ion bombardment as induced by the negative bias applied on the substrate at a voltage above 80 V, grain size in the films can be decreased and consequently the film morphology can be changed. At a bias voltage exceeding −140 V, very smooth NC diamond films can be obtained. Owing to the shallow ion penetration into the subsurface region (ion subplantation) [210], the sp3 –bonded carbon clusters are formed and act as the nucleation precursors. The negative bias applied to the substrate causes the positively charged ions in the growth chamber to accelerate toward the substrate’s surface and bombard it, thereby removing the contamination and facilitating cluster formation at the surface. These events in turn advance the diamond nucleation. Since early 1990s, the substrate bias-induced ion bombardment route has been an established one for the heterogeneous CVD diamond nucleation and made the heteroepitaxial growth of diamond on silicon a great success. On the other hand, only recently, research has been underway regarding the usage of continuous or intermittent ion bombardment effects during diamond film growth. Detailed investigations indicated that the combination of CVD diamond growth from neutral species (H and CH3 ) with the simultaneous bombardment of the growth surface by energetic particles of variable energies can provide a wide range of diamond phase modifications and thereby improved film properties. It was demonstrated [147,190] that, via H+ ion bombardment during the diamond CVD, largely variable diamond film growth can be obtained; from microcrystalline (MC), through a fine crystalline and fully (001) textured film morphology, to a nanocrystalline diamond growth can be obtained, independent of the substrate type. Due to the small grain size and ion bombardment, the grown nanocrystals show much higher density of crystal defects and larger lattice distortions in comparison to microcrystals. Due to the high compressive film stress introduced by ion subplantation, thicker films could hardly be prepared. The boron incorporation can, however, lower the intrinsic compressive stress of the NC diamond films, which is due to an interesting cancellation effect between the boron doping-induced tensile stress and the ion subplantation-induced compressive stress.
2.6
DIAMOND NANOCOMPOSITE FILMS
As for the research concerning diamond-related composite films, most of the work has been aimed at preparing diamond composites [211–218] with (1) carbides of molybdenum, tungsten, and titanium; (2) nitrides of silicon, aluminium, and titanium; (3) nickel alloy; and (4) copper–titanium–gold alloy by employing techniques such as modified MWCVD, metal powder plasma spraying, modified HFCVD, sputtering, electroplating, and laser ablation. Works reporting a-C/nanodiamond composite films [219–221] also exist in the literature. There are also a number of reports that are available regarding the preparation of (graphitic/amorphous) carbon-SiC nanocomposites [222–231]. The previously mentioned composites are not phase mixture diamond nanocomposite films. On the other hand, there are phase mixture diamond nanocomposite systems such as diamond/TiC [232,233], diamond/WC [234], and diamond/β-SiC [235–237].
2.6 DIAMOND NANOCOMPOSITE FILMS
47
The idea behind synthesis of nanocrystalline phase mixture composite films is to obtain films that possess a whole range of combined properties of diamond and the other phase (TiC, WC, β-SiC etc.). An example of a diamond/β-SiC nanocomposite film system will be briefly discussed. This film system is designed in such a way that the resultant material contains a required volume of nanometer-sized grains of both the components, such that the availability of a large volume of grain boundaries can be controlled based on the application requirement. The MWCVD technique was used to carry out the nanocomposite film depositions with the aid of hydrogen-methane-tetramethylsilane (TMS) gas mixtures. The presence of TMS in the gas phase along with hydrogen and methane not only results in a decrease of diamond crystallite size but also helps in the incorporation β-SiC as a second phase in the resulting film. The growth process of the nanocomposite films was attributed to the competitive nature of diamond- and β-SiC-forming species to occupy the reaction sites on the substrate [238]. Based on the microstructural analyses, these nanocomposite films are classified as granular-type composite films that contain diamond and β-SiC components as nanocrystalline grains distributed contiguously and laterally throughout the thickness of the film in a desired volume fraction combinatorial form [207]. Field emission (FE) SEM surface morphology image of a diamond/β-SiC nanocomposite thin film is shown in Figure 2.14. The content of β-SiC in the films could be increased by increasing TMS concentration in the gas phase. This factor was used in depositing films with gradient nature in a single process step, resulting in stress-free diamond top layers [239]. Indentation modulus and hardness values of the nanocomposite films revealed their linear relationship with βSiC content in the films. Very low friction coefficient values were also measured for the nanocomposite films [240]. It was also shown that the nanocomposite films are tougher than typical CVD polycrystalline diamond films and can be used as interlayers to obtain low-stress adherent diamond top layers on metallic substrates and cutting tool inserts [241].
Figure 2.14 Ultra-high magnification FE-SEM surface morphology image of nanocrystalline diamond/β-SiC composite film deposited on a BEN step pretreated (100) Si substrate. Bright regions represent diamond; darker regions represent β-SiC.
48
2.7
SYNTHESIS OF DIAMOND FILMS
CONCLUSIONS
Diamonds possess unmatchable mechanical, thermal, optical, electronic, electrochemical, electromechanical, biosensing, biomedical properties—and many others. Chemical vapor deposition of diamond-thin films was a major breakthrough in synthetic diamond research and has made a variety of diamond-based applications possible. With the aim of increasing the growth rate and improving the quality of diamond films, CVD methods—namely, HFCVD, MWCVD, RF-PCVD, DC-PCVD, ECR-MWCVD, and combustion flame-CVD—have been continuously developed. Standard diamond growth models based on both experimental and theoretical research works have been developed. At present, with the help of these models, CVD diamond growth process can be controlled to obtain diamond films according to the application requirement. A variety of film types—microcrystalline (poly), highly oriented, epitaxial, nano, and nanocomposite diamond—can now be readily synthesized. As a consequence, CVD diamond has opened the door to various applications. Nitrogen-doped diamond films can now be used as electron-emitting cathodes in flat-panel displays. Free-standing diamond windows that are transparent to infrared (IR), x-rays, high-power lasers, and high-power microwaves can be operated under severe temperature, pressure-differential, and reactivity conditions. Water treatment for organic effluents and production of strong oxidants employing conductive diamond electrodes are now possible. Also, CVD diamond has shown great promise as a potential radiation-detection material. It has also been successfully used as a substrate for surface acoustic-wave devices. Additionally, NC diamond films have been used as substrates for the preservation of DNA. The most sorted out application of diamond-thin films that has been already industrialized is using them as protective and/or wear-resistance coatings on cutting tools.
REFERENCES 1. J.T. Field, ed., Properties of Natural and Synthetic Diamond , Academic Press, London, 1992. 2. J.C. Angus, Thin Solid Films 1992, 216 , 126. 3. M.N. Yoder, in Synthetic Diamond: Emerging CVD Science and Technology, 1st ed. (K.E. Spear, J.P. Dismukes eds.), John Wiley & Sons, 1994. 4. F.P. Bundy, H.T. Hall, H.M. Strong, R.H. Wentorf, Nature 1955, 176 , 51. 5. J.E. Field, The Properties of Diamonds, Academic Press, New York, 1979. 6. K. Nassau, J. Nassau, J. Cryst. Growth 1979, 46 , 157. 7. R.C. De Vries, Ann. Rev. Mater. Sci . 1987, 17 , 161. 8. P.K. Bachmann, R. Messier, Chem. Eng. News 1989, 67 , 24. 9. W.G. Eversole, N. Y. Kenmore, US Patents 3030187 and 3030188, 1962. 10. J.C. Angus, H.C. Will, W.S. Stanko, J. Appl. Phys. 1968, 39 , 2915. 11. B.V. Deryagin, D.V. Fedoseev, V.M. Lukyanovich, B.V. Spitsyn, A.V. Ryanov, A.V. Lavrentyev, J. Cryst. Growth 1968, 2 , 380. 12. D.J. Poferl, N.C. Gardner, J.C. Angus, J. Appl. Phys. 1973, 44 , 1418. 13. B.V. Derjaguin, D.V. Fedoseev, Sci. Am. 1975, 223 , 102. 14. B.V. Spitsyn, L.L. Builov, B.V. Derjaguin, J. Cryst. Growth 1981, 52 , 219. 15. S. Matsumoto, Y. Sato, M. Kamo, N. Setaka, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 1982, 21 , part 2 , 183. 16. S. Matsumoto, Y. Sato, M. Tsutsumi, N. Setaka, J. Mater. Sci . 1982, 17 , 3106.
REFERENCES
17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42.
43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51.
49
M. Kamo, U. Sato, S. Matsumoto, N. Setaka, J. Cryst. Growth 1983, 62 , 642. S. Matsumoto, Y. Matsui, J. Mater. Sci . 1983, 18 , 1785. S. Matsumoto, J. Mater. Sci. Lett . 1985, 4 , 600. Y. Saito, S. Matsuda, S. Nogita, J. Mater. Sci. Lett . 1986, 5 , 565. K. Suzuki, A. Sawabe, H. Yasuda, T. Inuzuka, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1987, 50 , 728. Y. Hirose, M. Mitsuizumi, New Diam. 1988, 4 , 34. S.-T. Lee, Z. Lin, X. Jiang, Mater. Sci. Eng. R 1999, 25 , 123. P.W. May, Endeavour 1995, 19 , 101. K. Okano, S. Koizumi, S.R.P. Silva, G.A.J. Amaratunga, Nature 1996, 381 , 140. M. Seal, Interdiscipl. Sci. Rev ., 1989, 14 , 64. M. Panizza, G. Cerisola, Electrochem. Acta 2005, 51 , 191. D. Gandini, E. Mah´e, P.A. Michaud, W. Haenni, A. Perret, C. Comninellis, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2000, 20 , 45. P.A. Michaud, E. Mah´e, W. Haenni, A. Perret, C. Comninellis, Electrochem. Solid-State Lett . 2000, 3 , 77. M. Bucciolini, Nucl. Instr. Meth. Phys. Res. A 2005, 552 , 189. B. Dishchler, C. Wild, Low-Pressure Synthetic Diamond Manufacturing and Applications, Springer, Heidelberg, 1998. B. Bi, W.-S. Huang, J. Asmussen, B. Golding, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2002, 11 , 677. W. Yang, O. Auciello, J.E. Butler, W. Cai, J.A. Carlisle, J. Gerbi, D.M. Gruen, T. Knickerbocker, T.L. Lasseter, J.N. Russel, Jr., L.M. Smith, R.J. Hamers, Nature Mater. 2002, 1 , 253. W. Ahmed, H. Sein, N. Ali, J. Gracio, R. Woodwards, Diamond Rel. Mat ., 2003, 12 , 1300. H. Schmellenmeier, Exp. Tech. Phys. 1953, 1 , 49. R.A. Rudder, J.B Posthill, R.J. Markunas, Electron. Lett . 1989, 25 , 1220. D.M. Gruen, S. Liu, A.R. Krauss, J. Luo, X. Pan, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1994, 64 , 1502. P.H. Gaskell, A. Saeed, P. Chieux, D.R. McKenzie, Phys. Rev. Lett . 1991, 67 , 1286. J.F. Prins, Mat. Sci. Rep. 1992, 7 , 271. Q. Chen, Z. Lin, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1996, 68 , 2450. Q. Chen, J. Yang, Z. Lin, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1995, 67 , 1853. H.S. Shin, N.G. Glumac, D.G. Goodwin, Fourth Int. Conf. On New Diamond Science & Technology (S. Sato, N. Fujimori, O. Fukunaga, M. Kamo, K. Kobashi, M. Yoshikawa, eds.) Myu, Tokyo, 1994, pp. 27–30. W.M. Lau, S.-T. Lee, F. Qin, Surface Modification Technologies V , 1992, p. 263. X.S. Sun, N. Wang, H.K. Woo, W.J. Zhang, G. Yu, I. Bello, C.S. Lee, S.T. Lee, Diam. Rel. Mat . 1999, 8 , 1414. P. Aublane, V.P. Novikov, L.V. Kuznetsova, M. Mermoux, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2001, 10 , 942. S. Ferro, J. Mater. Chem. 2002, 12 , 2843. R.F. Davis, ed., Diamond Films and Coatings, Noyes Publications, New Jersey, 1992. N. Fujimori, A. Ikegaya, T. Imai, K. Fukushima, N. Ota, in “Diamond and Diamond-like Films” (J. Dismukes et al,. eds.), Electrochem. Soc. Proc. 1989, PV 89-12 , 465. Y. Hirose, N. Kondo, Program and Book of Abstracts, Japan Applied Physics 1988 spring meeting, 1988, p. 434. G. Janssen, W.J.P. van Enckefort, J.J.D. Schaminee, W. Vollenberg, L.J. Giling, M. Seal, J. Cryst. Growth 1990, 104 , 752. K. Doverspike, J.E. Butler in Diamond 1992 (P.K. Bachmann, A.T. Collins, M. Seal, eds.), Elsevier Sequoia, Lausanne, 1993, p. 1078.
50 52. 53. 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62. 63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71.
72. 73. 74. 75. 76. 77. 78. 79. 80. 81. 82.
83.
SYNTHESIS OF DIAMOND FILMS
M. Murakawa, S. Takeuchi, Y. Hirose, Surf. Coat. Technol . 1990, 43/44 , 22. M.A. Cappelli, P.H. Paul, J. Appl. Phys. 1990, 675 , 2596. A.R. Badzian, R.C. De Vries, Mater. Res. Bull . 1988, 23 , 385. K. Kurihara, K. Sasaki, M. Kawarada, N. Koshino, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1988, 526 , 437. M. Kawarada, K. Kurihara, K. Sasaki, A. Teshima, K. Koshino in Diamond Optics II (A. Feldman, S. Holly, eds.) SPIE Proc., 1146, Bellingham, WA, 1990, p. 28. N. Ohtake, M. Yoshikawa, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1990, 137 , 717. N. Fujimori, New Diam. 1988, 2 , 10. D.E. Meyer, T.B. Kustka, R.O. Dillon, J.A. Woollam in Diamond Optics II (A. Feldman, S. Holly, eds.), SPIE Proc., 1146, Bellingham, WA, 1990, p. 21. A. Hiraki, H. Kawarada, J. Wei, J.I. Suzuki, Surf. Coat. Technol . 1990, 43/44 , 10. T. Yara, M. Yuasa, M. Shimizu, H. Makita, A. Hatta, J.I. Suzuki, T. Ito, A. Hiraki, Jpn J. Appl. Phys. 1994, 33 , 4405. D. Mantei, Z. Ring, M. Schweizer, S. Tlali, H. E. Jackson, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 1996, 35 , 2516. M. Frenklach, R. Kematick, D. Huang, W. Howard, K.E. Spear, J. Appl. Phys. 1989, 66 , 395. S.E. Stein, Nature 1990, 346 , 517. H. Liu, D.S. Dandy, Diam. Rel. Mat . 1995, 4 , 1173. K. Mitsuda, Y. Kojima, T. Yoshida, K. Akashi, J. Mater. Sci . 1987, 22 , 1557. A. Sawabe, T. Inuzuka, Thin Solid Films 1986, 137 , 89. N. Fujimori, T. Imai, A. Doi, Vacuum 1986, 36 , 99. C.P. Chang, D.L. Flamm, D.E. Ibbotson, J.A. Mucha, J. Appl. Phys. 1988, 63 , 1744. P.A. Denning, D.A. Stevenson, Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on New Diamond Science and Technology, Pittsburg, PA, MRS, 1991, pp. 403–408. B. Singh, O. Mesker, A.W. Levine, Y. Arie, Growth of Polycrystalline Diamond Particles and Films by Hot-Filament Chemical Vapor Deposition, Report CN-5300, David Sarnoff Research Center, SRI International, Princeton, NJ, 1988. B. Singh, Y. Arie, A.W. Levine, O.R. Mesker, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1988, 526 , 451. C.P. Beetz Jr, T.A. Perry, Hot and Cold Wall Filament-Assisted Growth of Diamond Films, General Motors Research Publication GMR-6093, November 24, 1987, pp. 1–21. S. Yugo, T. Kimura, H. Kanai in Science and Technology of New Diamond (S. Saito, O. Fukunaga, M. Yoshihara, eds.), KTK Scientific Pub., Tokyo, 1990, pp. 119–128. S. Iijima, Y. Aikawa, K. Baba, J. Mater. Res. 1991, 6 , 1491. S.P. Murarka, M.C. Peckerar, Electronic Materials Science and Technology, Academic Press, San Diego, CA, 1989. S. Yugo, A. Izumi, T. Kanai, T. Muto, T. Kimura, Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on New Diamond Science and Technology, Pittsburg, PA, MRS, 1991, pp. 385–390. J. Yang, X. Su, Q. Chen, Z. Lin, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1995, 66 , 3284. P.K. Bachmann, R. Weimer, W. Drawl, Y. Liou, R. Messier, Diamond Technology Initiative Symposium, Paper T20, SDIC/IST ONR, Crystal City, VA, July 12–14, 1988. M. Marchywka, P.E. Pehrsson, D.J. Vestyck, D. Moses, Appl. Phys Lett . 1993, 63 , 3521. A.R. Kirkpatrick, B.W. Ward, N.P. Sconomou, J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B 1989, 7 , 1947. J.C. Angus, Z. Li, M. Sunkara, R. Gat, A.B. Anderson, S.P. Mehandru, M.W. Geis in A.J. Purdes, J.C. Angus, R.F. Davis, B.M. Meyerson, K.E. Spear, M. Yoder (Eds.), Proceedings of the 2nd International Symposium on Diamond Materials, The Electrochemical Society, Pennington, New Jersey, 1991, p. 125. Z. Feng, K. Komvopoulos, I.G. Brown, D.C. Bogy, J. Appl. Phys. 1993, 744 , 2841.
REFERENCES
84. 85. 86. 87. 88. 89. 90. 91. 92. 93. 94. 95. 96. 97. 98. 99. 100. 101. 102. 103. 104. 105. 106. 107. 108. 109. 110. 111. 112. 113. 114. 115. 116. 117. 118. 119. 120. 121. 122. 123.
51
A.A. Morrish, P.E. Pehesson, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1991, 59 , 417. J. Singh, M. Vellaikal, J. Appl. Phys. 1993, 73 , 2831. K.V. Ravi, C.A. Koch, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1992, 57 , 348. K.V. Ravi, C.A. Koch, H.S. Hu, A. Joshi, J. Mater. Res. 1990, 5 , 2356. S. Yugo, T. Kanai, T. Kimura, T. Muto, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1991, 58 , 1036. B.R. Stoner, G.-H.M. Ma, S.D. Wolter, J.T. Glass, Phys. Rev. B 1992, 45 , 11067. X. Jiang, C.-P Klages, Diam. Rel. Mat . 1993, 2 , 1112. ` X. Jiang, C.-P. Klages, R. Zachai, M. Hartweg, H.-J. FuEsser, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1993, 62 , 3438. B.R. Stoner, J.T. Glass, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1992, 60 , 698. S. Yugo, T. Kimura, T. Kanai, Diam. Rel. Mat . 1993, 2 , 328. J. Gerber, S. Sattel, K. Jung, H. Ehrhard, J. Robertson, Diam. Rel. Mat . 1995, 4 , 559. B.R. Stoner, G.H. Ma, S.D. Wolter, W. Zhou, Y.-C. Wang, R.F. Davis, J.T. Glass, Diam. Rel. Mat . 1993, 2 , 142. X. Jiang, K. Schiffmann, C.-P. Klages, Phys. Rev. B 1994, 50 , 8402. X. Jiang, C.-P. Klages, Phys. Stat. Sol . 1996, 154 , 175. ` F. Stubhan, M. Ferguson, H.-J. FuEsser, R.J. Behm, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1995, 66 , 1900. S.T. Lee, Y.W. Lam, Z. Lin, Y. Chen, Q. Chen, Phys. Rev. B 1997, 5524 , 15937. Z. Liu, B.Q. Zong, Z. Lin, Thin Solid Films 1995, 254 , 3. M. Tsuda, M. Nakajima, S. Oikawa, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1986, 108 , 5780. M. Tsuda, M. Nakajima, S. Oikawa, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 1987, 26 , L527. C.J. Chu, M.P. D’Evelyn, R.H. Hauge, J.L. Margrave, J. Appl. Phys. 1991, 70 , 1659. L.R. Martin, M.W. Hill, J. Mater. Sci. Lett . 1990, 9 , 621. S.J. Harris, L.R. Martin, J. Mater. Res. 1990, 5 , 2313. S.J. Harris, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1990, 56 , 2298. M. Frenklach, K.E. Spear, J. Mater. Res. 1988, 3 , 133. D. Huang, M. Frenklach, M. Maroncelli, J. Phys. Chem. 1988, 92 , 6379. M. Frenklach, H. Wang, Phys. Rev. B 1991, 43 , 1520. D. Huang, M. Frenklach, J. Phys. Chem. 1991, 95 , 3692. F.G. Celii, J.E. Butler, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1989, 54 , 1031. M. Frenklach, J. Appl. Phys. 1989, 65 , 5142. D.G. Goodwin, G.G. Gavillet, J. Appl. Phys. 1990, 68 , 6393. D.M. Gruen, MRS Bull . 1998, 239 , 32. P.C. Redfern, D.A. Horner, L.A. Curtiss, D.M. Gruen, J. Phys. Chem. 1996, 100 , 11654. B. Sun, X.P. Zhang, Q.Z. Zhang, Z.D. Lin, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1993, 62 , 31. T. Shimanouchi, Table of Vibrational Frequencies, Natl. Bur. Stand. Ref. Data Ser., Natl. Bur. Stand. (U.S.) Circ. No. 39, U.S. GPO, Washington, DC, 1968, Consolidated Vols. I and II. T. Shimanouchi, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 1977, 6 , 993. H. Ibach, D.L. Mills, Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy and Surface Vibrations, Academic Press, New York, 1982. L.B. Zhao, K.A. Feng, Z.D. Lin, Diamond Rel. Mater. 1993, 3 , 155. A.V. Hamza, G.D. Kubiak, R.H. Stulen, Surf. Sci . 1990, 237 , 35. S.P. Mehandru, A.B. Anderson, Surf. Sci . 1991, 248 , 369. T. Tsuno, T. Imai, Y. Nishibayasi, K. Hamada, N. Fujimori, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 1991, 30 , 1063.
52 124. 125. 126. 127. 128. 129. 130. 131. 132. 133. 134. 135. 136. 137. 138. 139. 140. 141. 142. 143. 144. 145. 146. 147. 148. 149. 150. 151. 152. 153. 154. 155. 156. 157. 158. 159. 160. 161.
SYNTHESIS OF DIAMOND FILMS
L.F. Sutcu, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1992, 60 , 1685. B. Sun, X. Zhang, Z.D. Lin, Phys. Rev. B 1993, 47 , 9816. K.A. Feng, Z.D. Lin, J. Phys Chem. Solids 1994, 55 (6), 525. K. Kobashi, K. Nishimura, Y. Kawate, T. Horiuchi, Phys. Rev. B 1988, 38 , 4067. Y.J. Baik, K.Y. Eun, Applications of Diamond Films and Related Materials, Elsevier, New York, 1991, p. 521. C. Wild, N. Herres, P. Koidl, J. Appl. Phys. 1990, 68 , 973. Z.D. Lin, B. Sun, J. Vac. Soc. Jpn. 1994, 37 , 579. S.J. Harris, A.M. Weiner, J. Appl. Phys. 1990, 67 , 6520. S.J. Harris, D.N. Betton, A.M. Weiner, S.J. Schmieg, J. Appl. Phys. 1989, 66 , 5353. J.E. Butler, R L. Woodin, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. A 1993, 342 , 209. D.G. Goodwin, J.E. Butler, in Handbook of Industrial Diamonds and Diamond Films (M.A. Prelas, G. Popovici, L.G. Bigelow, eds.), Marcel Dekker Inc., 1998. C. Wild, P. Koidl, W. M¨uller-Sebert, H. Walcher, R. Kohl, N. Herres, R. Locher, R. Samlenski, R. Brenn, Diam. Rel. Mat . 1993, 3 , 158. R.A. Bauer, N.M. Sbrockey, W.E. Brower Jr., J. Mater. Res. 1993, 8 , 2858. A. van der Drift, Philips Res. Reports 1967, 22 , 267. X. Jiang, V.V.S.S. Srikanth, Y.L. Zhao, R.Q. Zhang, Appl. Phys. Lett . 2008, 92 , 243107. P.W. May, Y.A. Mankelevich, J. Phys. Chem. C 2008, 112 , 12432. S. Skokov, B. Weiner, M. Frenklach, J. Phys. Chem. 1994, 98 , 7073. P.W. May, M.N.R. Ashfold, Y.A. Mankelevich, J. Appl. Phys. 2007, 101 , 053115. Y.A. Mankelevich, P.W. May, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2008, 17 , 1021. P.W. May, N.L. Allan, M.N.R. Ashfold, J.C. Richley, Y.A. Mankelevich, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 2009, 21 , 364203. B.J. Waclawski, D.T. Pierce, N. Swanson, R.J. Celotta, J. Vac. Sci. Technol . 1982, 21 , 368. T.R. Anthony, Vacuum 1990, 41 , 1356. K. Ishibashi, S. Furukawa, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 1985, 24 , 912. X. Jiang, W.J. Zhang, M. Paul, C.-P. Klages, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1996, 68 , 1927. W.J. Zhang, X. Jiang, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1996, 68 , 2195. W.J. Zhang, X. Jiang, Y. B. Xia, J. Appl. Phys. 1997, 82 , 1896. Y. Muranaka, H. Yamashita, H. Miyadera, J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A. 1991, 9 , 76. S.J. Harris, A. M. Weiner, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1989, 55 , 2179. Y. Liou, A. Inspektor, R. Weimer, D. Knight, R. Messier, J. Mater. Res. 1990, 5 , 2305. B. Sun, X. Zhang, Q. Zhang, Z. Lin, J. Appl. Phys. 1993, 73 , 4614. S.-T. Lee, Y.W. Lam, Z.D. Lin, Y. Chen, Z.Q. Gao, Phys. Rev. B. 1996, 54 , 14185. A. Badzian, T. Badzian, X.H. Wang, Carbon 1990, 28 , 804. M. Kamo, H. Yurimoto, Y. Sato, Appl. Surf. Sci . 1988, 33/34 , 553. B.V. Derjaguin, B.V. Spitsyn, A.E. Gorodetsky, A.P. Zakharov, L.I. Bouilov, A.E. Aleksenko, J. Crystal. Growth 1975, 31 , 44. H. Nakazawa, Y. Kanayama, M. Kamo, K. Osumi, Thin Solid Films 1987, 151 , 199. N. Fujimori, T. Imai, H. Nakahata, H. Shiomi, Y. Nishibayashi, Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. 1990, 162 , 109. M. Yoshikawa, H. Ishida, A. Ishitani, T. Murakami, S. Koizumi, T. Inuzuka, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1990, 57 , 428. S. Koizumi, T. Murakami, K. Suzuki, T. Inuzuka, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1990, 57 , 563.
REFERENCES
53
162. S. Koizumi, T. Inuzuka, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 1993, 32 , 3920. 163. A. Argoitia, J.S. Ma, J.C. Angus, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1993, 63 , 1336. 164. A. Argoitia, J.C. Angus, J.S. Ma, L. Wang, P. Pirouz, W. Lambrecht, J. Mater. Res. 1994, 9 , 1849. 165. R.O. Jones, O. Gunnarsson, Rev. Mod. Phys. 1989, 61, 689. 166. T. Tomizuka, S. Shikata, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 1993, 32 , 3938. 167. R.C. De Vries, Cubic Boron Nitride: Handbook of Properties, G.E. Representative. No. 72 CRD, 1972, p. 178. 168. T. Suzuki, A. Argoitia, Phys. Stat. Sol . 1996, 154 , 239. 169. X. Jiang, C.L. Jia, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1995, 67 , 1197. 170. C.L. Jia, K. Urban, X. Jiang, Phys. Rev. B 1995, 52 , 5164. 171. J. Yang, Z.D. Lin, L.X. Wang, S. Jin, Z. Zhang, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1994, 65 , 3203. 172. K. Feng, J. Yang, Z.D. Lin, Phys. Rev. B. 1995, 51 , 2264. 173. J. Yang, Z.D. Lin, L.X. Wang, S. Jin, Z. Zhang, J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 1995, 28 , 1153. 174. Q.J. Chen, L.X. Wang, Z. Zhang, J. Yang, Z.D. Lin, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1996, 68 , 176. ` ` 175. X. Jiang, C.-P. Klages, M. RoEsler, R. Zachai, M. Hartweg, H.-J. FuEsser, Appl. Phys. A 1993, 57 , 483. 176. X. Jiang, K. Schiffmann, C.-P. Klages, D. Wittorf, C.L. Jia, K. Urban, W. Jaeger, J. Appl. Phys. 1998, 83 , 2511. 177. H. Kawarada, C. Wild, N. Herres, R. Locher, P. Koidl, J. Appl. Phys. 1997, 81 , 3490. 178. A. Argoitia, J.C. Angus, L. Wang, X.I. Ning, P. Pirouz, J. Appl. Phys. 1993, 73 , 4305. 179. W. Zhu, P.C. Yang, J.T. Glass, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1993, 63 , 1640. 180. T. Tachibana, Y. Yokota, K. Miyata, K. Kobashi, Y. Shintani, Diam. Rel. Mat . 1996, 5 , 197. 181. W. Liu, D.A. Tucker, P. Yang, J.T. Glass, J. Appl. Phys. 1995, 78 , 1291. 182. K. Ohtsuka, K. Suzuki, A. Sawabe, T. Inuzuka, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. Part 2 . 1996, 35 , L1072. 183. K. Ohtsuka, H. Fukuda, K. Suzuki, A. Sawabe, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. Part 2 . 1997, 36 , L1214. 184. T. Saito, S. Tsuruga, N. Ohya, K. Kusakabe, S. Morooka, H. Maeda, A. Sawabe, K. Suzuki, Diam. Rel. Mat . 1998, 7 , 1381. 185. M. Schreck, H. Roll, B. Stritzker, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1999, 74 , 650. ` 186. X. Jiang, C.-P. Klages, R. Zachai, M. Hartweg, H.-J. FuEsser, Diam. Rel. Mat . 1993, 2 , 407. 187. X. Jiang, K. Schiffimann, A. Westphal, C.-P. Klages, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1993, 63 , 1203. 188. M. Schreck, K.H. Thuerer, R. Klarmann, B. Stritzker, J. Appl. Phys. 1997, 81 , 3096. 189. M. Schreck, K.H. Thuerer, B. Stritzker, J. Appl. Phys. 1997, 81 , 3092. 190. X. Jiang, W.J. Zhang, C.-P. Klages, Phys. Rev. B 1998, 58 , 7064. 191. W. J. Zhang, X. Jiang, C.-P. Klages, J. Cryst. Growth 1997, 171 , 485. 192. X. Jiang, C.L. Jia, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1996, 69 , 3902. 193. S.D. Wolter, B.R. Stoner, J.T. Glass, P.J. Ellis, D.S. Buhaenko, C.E. Jenkins, P. Southworth, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1993, 6211 , 1215. 194. W. Zhu, X.H. Wang, B.R. Stoner, G.H.M. Ma, H.S. Kong, M.W.H. Braun, J.T. Glass, Phys. Rev. B 1993, 47 , 6529. 195. R.Q. Zhang, W.L. Wang, J. Esteva, E. Bertran, Thin Solid Films 1998, 317 , 6. 196. X. Jiang, R.Q. Zhang, G. Yu, S.T. Lee, Phys. Rev. B 1998, 58 , 15351. 197. C.C. Koch, I.A. Ovid’ko, S. Seal, S. Veprek, Structural Nanocrystalline Materials: Fundamentals and Applications, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 2007. 198. D.M. Gruen, Ann. Rev. Mater. Sci . 1999, 29 , 211.
54
SYNTHESIS OF DIAMOND FILMS
199. A.R. Krauss, O. Auciello, M.Q. Ding, D.M. Gruen, Y. Huang, V.V. Zhirnov, E.I. Givargizov, A. Breskin, R. Chechen, E. Shefer, V. Konov, S. Pimenov, A. Karabutov, A. Rakhimov, N. Suetin, J. Appl. Phys. 2001, 89 , 2958. 200. O.A. Williams, M. Nesladek, Phys. Stat. Sol. A 2006, 203 , 3375. 201. Y.P. Ma, F.H. Sun, H.G. Xue, Z.M. Zhang, M. Chen, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2007, 16 , 481. 202. O. Auciello, S. Pacheco, A.V. Sumant, C. Gudeman, S. Sampath, A. Datta, R.W. Carpick, V.P. Adiga, P. Zurcher, Z. Ma, H.C. Yuan, J.A. Carlisle, B. Kabius, J. Hiller, S. Srinivasan, IEEE Microw. Mag. 2007, 8 , 61. 203. C.E. Nebel, B. Rezek, D.C. Shin, H. Uetsuka, N. Yang, J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. 2007, 40 , 6443. 204. T.-H. Kim, W.M. Choi, D.-H. Kim, M.A. Meitl, E. Menard, H.Q. Jiang, J.A. Carlisle, J.A. Rogers, Adv. Mater. 2008, 20 , 2171. 205. D.M. Gruen, S. Liu, A.R. Krauss, J. Luo, X. Pan, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1994, 64 , 1502. 206. D.M. Gruen, MRS Bull . 1998, 23 , 32. 207. V.V.S.S. Srikanth, T. Staedler, X. Jiang, Appl. Phys. A 2008, 91, 149. 208. X. Jiang, C.Z. Gu, L. Sch¨afer, C.-P. Klages, Proceedings of ADC/FCT’99 (M. Yoshikawa, Y. Koga, Y. Tzeng, C.-P. Klages, K. Miyoshi, eds.), September 3, 1999, Tsukuba, Japan, p. 28. 209. C.Z. Gu, X. Jiang, J. Appl. Phys. 2000, 88 , 1788. 210. Y. Lifshitz, S.R. Kasi, J.W. Rabalais, W. Eckstein, Phys. Rev. B 1990, 41 , 10468. 211. M. Kawadara, K. Kurihara, K. Sasaki, J. Appl. Phys. 1992, 71 , 1442. 212. C. Tsai, J.C. Nelson, W.W. Gerberich, J. Heberlein, E. Pfender, Diam. Rel. Mat . 1993, 2 , 617. 213. W.D. Fan, X. Chen, K. Jagannadham, J. Narayan, J. Mater. Res. 1994, 9 , 2850. 214. M. Nagano, T. Urasaki, K. Wakiyama, M. Komori, Diam. Rel. Mat . 1997, 6 , 501. 215. M.L. Terranova, S. Piccirillo, V. Sessa, M. Rossi, G. Cappuccio, Chem. Vap. Deposition 1999, 5 , 101. 216. M.S. Raghuveer, S.N. Yoganand, K. Jagannadham, J. Bailey, R.L. Lemaster, Wear 2002, 253 , 1194. 217. K. Jagannadham, H. Wang, J. Appl. Phys. 2002, 91 , 1224. 218. F.A. Khalid, O. Beffort, U.E. Klotz, B.A. Keller, P. Gasser, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2004, 13 , 393. 219. X.T. Zhou, Q. Li, F.Y. Meng, I. Bello, C.S. Lee, S.T. Lee, Y. Lifshitz, Appl. Phys. Lett . 2002, 80 , 3307. 220. X.T. Zhou, X.M. Meng, F.Y. Meng, Q. Li, I. Bello, W. J. Zhang, C.S. Lee, S.T. Lee, Y. Lifshitz, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2003, 12 , 1640. 221. W.J. Hsieh, P.S. Shih, J.H. Lin, C.C. Lin, U.S. Chen, S.C. Huang, Y.S. Chang, H.C. Shih, Thin Solid Films 2004, 469 , 120. 222. S. Yajima, T. Hirai, J. Mater. Sci . 1969, 4 , 416. ˇ Suˇznjevi´c, I. Deˇzarov, A. Mihajlovi´c, D. Cerovi´c, Carbon 1970, 8 , 283. 223. S. Marinkovi´c, C. 224. J.L. Kaae, T.D. Gulden, J. Amer. Ceram. Soc. 1971, 54 , 605. 225. J.J. Nickl, C.V. Braunm¨uhl, J. Less-Common Metals 1971, 25 , 303. 226. Y.C. Wang, M. Sasaki, T. Hirai, J. Mater. Sci . 1991, 26 , 5495. 227. W.C. Liu, S.J. Sun, M.J. Li, Y.L. Wei, J. Mater. Sci. Letters 1993, 12 , 886. 228. M.R. Richards, A.C. Richards, M. Taya, F.S. Ohuchi, J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A 1995, 13 , 1196. 229. Y. Kim, J.T. Choi, J.K. Choi, K.H. Auh, Mater. Lett . 1996, 26 , 249. 230. I.M. Kostjuhin, S.V. Sotirchos, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2001, 40 , 2586. 231. J.I. Kim, W.J. Kim, D.J. Choi, J.Y. Park, W.-S. Ryu, Carbon 2005, 43 , 1749.
REFERENCES
232. 233. 234. 235. 236. 237. 238. 239. 240.
55
L. Xiang, Ph.D. Thesis, Technical University Braunschweig 2002. F.Z. Ding, Y.L. Shi, Surf. Coat. Technol . 2007, 9-11 , 5050. H.A. Samra, R.J. Hong, X. Jiang, Chem. Vap. Deposition 2007, 13 , 17. X. Jiang, C.-P. Klages, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1992, 61 , 1629. X. Jiang, C.-P. Klages, Diam. Rel. Mat . 1993, 2 , 523. Y.L. Shi, M.H. Tan, X. Jiang, J. Mater. Res. 2002, 17 , 1241. V.V.S.S. Srikanth, M.H. Tan, X. Jiang, Appl. Phys. Lett . 2006, 88 , 073109. V.V.S.S. Srikanth, T. Staedler, X. Jiang, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2009, 18 , 1326. T. Staedler, V.V.S.S. Srikanth, X. Jiang, Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. 2006, 890 , 0890Y01-04.1. 241. V.V.S.S. Srikanth, Deposition and Characterization of Nanocrystalline Diamond/ β-SiC Composite Film System, Shaker Verlag GmbH, Aachen, Germany, 2008.
3 Types of Conducting Diamond Materials and Their Properties Marco A. Quiroz and Erick R. Bandala
3.1
INTRODUCTION
Historically, carbon has played, an important role in electrochemistry development. However, its use until the last 20 years has been restricted mostly to graphite, one of its natural allotropic forms. As traditionally taught in material science courses, natural carbon possesses two allotropic, structurally different forms: graphite and diamond. Since the now classical works by Curl and Smalley in 1991 [1], fullerenes have been also recognized as a third allotropic form of carbon. Graphite exhibits a structure of layers of carbon atoms arranged in hexagonal rings. ˚ In diamond structure, each carbon The distance between successive layers is 3.35 A. 3 atom is sp -hybridized, giving a tetrahedral geometrical arrangement. In both cases, carbon atoms are linked by covalent bonds. Fullerenes constitute a wide family (from C20 to C720), with closed structures and variable stability; angle strain in the sp2 carbon atoms is a consequence of bond bending to adopt a curve structure. Their stability results from a mix of topological and chemical properties, beyond the subject of this chapter. The diverse electronic structure in carbon atoms at the different structural arrangements determine, in most cases, whether or not the different carbon allotropic forms show electrical conductivity, considered as an unavoidable requirement for their use in
Synthetic Diamond Films: Preparation, Electrochemistry, Characterization, and Applications, First Edition. Edited by Enric Brillas and Carlos Alberto Mart´ınez-Huitle. © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Published 2011 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
57
58
TYPES OF CONDUCTING DIAMOND MATERIALS AND THEIR PROPERTIES
electrochemical applications. In this way, it is noteworthy that electrical conductivity requires nonbonding electrons (valence band electrons) to be able to move through the solid (into the conduction band). Separation between both valence and conduction band (the bandgap) determines the electrical conduction properties of the different carbon allotropes. The graphite structure, as mentioned earlier, consists of layers of carbon atoms arranged in hexagonal rings that are stacked in a sequence ABAB . . . (see Figure 3.1a) ˚ The atoms are all sp 2 -hybridized in the with a separation between them of 3.35 A. hexagonal arrangement on every layer, which allows every carbon atom to get three ˚ length covalent bonds oriented 120◦ on the hexagonal plane. The remaining 1.42 A unhybridized 2p orbital is perpendicular to the hexagonal plane and it is used in π bonding. The three σ orbitals contribute six electrons to the valence band. The 2p atomic orbital contributes 2 electrons to the partially filled conduction band (see Figure 3.1b). Superimposition of parallel layers generates an interlayer region with an electronic density that allows an electrical conductivity of 3 × 104 S·cm−1 , very different from the value determined for electrical conductivity in the perpendicular direction to the planes (5 S·cm−1 ). This laminar structure is “glued” by p − p and van der Waals interaction providing graphite with a high anisotropy degree.
(a)
(b)
Energy, E
3σ*sp2 2p atomic orbitals
π2p
Conduction band partially filled
sp2 hybrid orbitals 2s atomic orbital
Figure 3.1
2p atomic orbitals
3σsp2
Valence band completely filled
(a) Structural representation and (b) Electronic diagram of hexagonal graphite.
3.1 INTRODUCTION
Figure 3.2
59
Different structure and size of fullerenes (C60 , C540 , and simple wall nanotube).
Fullerenes are carbon-based structures that vary in size and stability: buckminsterfullerene (C60 ) has 60 carbon atoms and measures around 1 nm of diameter; higher-order fullerenes can have numbers from 540 to 720 carbon atoms (C540 –C720 ) in quasi-spherical geometries [1,2], as shown in Figure 3.2. Every single structure is, by itself, spherically shaped, highly symmetric, and electronegative [3]. It has been observed that fullerene electronic properties may be affected by structure variations and/or doping with atoms other than carbon. Thus, for instance, the C60 fullerene is not an electric conductor but if potassium (K) is added as an impurity a conducting material is obtained. Nevertheless, at high potassium concentrations an isolating compound is generated. In other compounds, including alkaline metals (X3 C60 fullerenes with X = Na, K, Rb, Cs), the origin of the electrical behavior is not completely clear [4]. However, it is noteworthy that fullerenes are capable of forming nanotubes [5,6], just another allotropic form of carbon, which are considered as the best electrical conductors at the nano-sized scale. Fullerene and carbon nanotubes chemistry and electrochemical properties are widely discussed in scientific literature and its application perspectives are currently analyzed in research facilities around the world. The tetrahedral atomic arrangement of diamond is generated by sp 3 -hybridization of the carbon atomic orbitals. This sp 3 -hybridization leads to forming four covalent bonds symmetrically oriented to the neighbor carbon atoms (see Figure 3.3a) and forming a ˚ The superimposicompact tridimensional structure where internuclear distance is 1.54 A. tion of the sp 3 -hybrid orbitals in diamond carbon atoms is so effective that it has several different consequences, such as a large energy gap (5.5 eV) between the valence and conduction bands (see Figure 3.3b). This extreme electron distribution defines two of the main characteristics of diamond: (1) a very strong bonding action, which is extended over the whole crystalline structure, with the consequent diamond being extremely hard and virtually absent of reactivity; (2) the bandgap creates an energetic barrier that makes the electron transference from the valence to conduction band practically impossible, thus generating a material with a high thermal stability and good dielectric behavior (≈1016 cm−1 ). To make use of these properties it is necessary to develop methods of synthesis capable to make synthetic diamond an accessible material, both in quantity and in cost. However, Because many chemically prepared diamonds are now available, it is important to distinguish between diamond and diamond-like materials such as synthetic diamond (SD), diamond-like carbon (DLC), and imitation diamonds (ID), to mention some. Diamond-like carbon is a carbon-based material obtained usually by vapor-phase chemical deposition. To obtain DLC, a mixture of hydrogen and gaseous hydrocarbons is used.
60
TYPES OF CONDUCTING DIAMOND MATERIALS AND THEIR PROPERTIES
(a)
(b)
Energy, E
* 3 4σsp
2p atomic orbitals sp3 hybrid orbitals 2s atomic orbital
Figure 3.3
Conduction band empty
Energy gap 5.5 eV 4σsp3
Valence band filled
(a) Structural representation and (b) Electronic diagram of diamond.
Synthetic diamond may be obtained by different chemical-physics methods of synthesis; however, the high pressure high temperature (HPHT) and the chemical vapor deposition (CVD) are the two most commonly published techniques. In the case of CVD, monocrystalline or polycrystalline layers of diamond with grain size ranging from nanometers to some micrometers (see Figure 3.4a) are commonly generated. In addition, the diamond layers’ hardnesses vary depending on the specific preparation method, and the chemical and structural heterogeneity is determined by the arrangement of regions with diamond and nondiamond character (Figure 3.4b). Technological and commercial interests of SD obtained through CVD techniques are diverse and depend on their specific application. In some applications, such as mechanical grinding, the thickness of the films as well as their chemical and structural heterogeneity are important characteristics. For other uses, electrical conductivity will be the most important property. An interesting example on actual SD research trends is the Micromachined Diamond Device Initiative (MIDDI) project in the UK, where high advanced micro- and nanoscaled manufacturing technologies for preparation of synthetic single
3.1 INTRODUCTION
61
(a)
(b)
Figure 3.4 (a) Microcrystalline CVD diamond film on Si growth onto a lower methane atmosphere. (b) Nanocrystalline CVD diamond film on Si growth onto a rich methane atmosphere.
crystal sp3 -carbon diamond is being currently developed for different applications [7]. This concept is recent and it is associated to modern CVD methods. The actual quality of thin films obtained depends on the degree of sp2 -carbon impurity (i.e., graphite carbon), which is proposed to be controlled by regulating the methane-hydrogen ratio: The higher the methane content, the greater the amount of graphite carbon produced. Synthetic diamond, as the natural one, is not a conducting material. Nevertheless, not all kinds of natural diamond are electrical insulators. It is well known that blue diamond, containing boron as impurity, is able to behave as extrinsic p-type semiconductor. This fact is transcendental not only because of the aesthetics point of view but mainly because of the relevance to obtain conducting SD. Semiconducting properties of doped synthetic diamond (DSD) are basically similar to those observed in other wide bandgap semiconductors such as silicon (1.12 eV) or germanium (0.67 eV). The type and conducting level depends on the dopant agent and
62
TYPES OF CONDUCTING DIAMOND MATERIALS AND THEIR PROPERTIES
Conduction band (CB)
Band gap 5.5 eV
P (0.6 eV below CB) donors
N (1.6 eV below CB)
B (0.37 eV above VB)
acceptor
Valence band (VB) Figure 3.5 Energy diagrams of selected states in the bandgap of diamond. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 12.)
its concentration. When DSD is doped with an acceptor material (i.e., with electron deficiency or hole excess), such as boron, a p-type semiconductor is produced [8] (socalled boron-doped diamond, BDD), whereas when doped with donating materials (i.e., electron excess), such as phosphorous or nitrogen, a n-type semiconductor will be produced [9–11] (see Figure 3.5). Conducting capacity in the DSD changes with dopant concentration up to reach a quasi-metallic behavior for boron concentration in the order of 1019 –1021 atoms cm−3 [10,11].
3.2
CONDUCTING DIAMOND MATERIALS (CDMs)
As a consequence of the large energy gap between the filled and empty bands (over 5 eV), there is no a real chance for the highest-energy electrons to move under the influence of an applied electrical potential. Consequently, undoped diamond is not considered a good electrical conductor, so no practical use as electrochemically active materials has been reported for it [12,13]. In summary, pure diamond, just as other large bandgap materials, can be used as conducting material only when doped appropriately. The inclusion of light dopants during diamond crystal growth expands the possibility of creating new and versatile wide bandgap semiconductors [13]. The transformation from insulator to semiconductor by doping is achieved by the creation of discrete acceptor states just above the valence band (i.e., 0.35 eV for boron in diamond) which form a pseudo-conduction band [14]. Several different factors may have influence on the properties of these new conducting diamond materials generated after doping: (1) the potential dependent density of electronic states closely related to the doping type, distribution, and level; (2) the surface
3.4 CDM DOPING MATERIALS
63
chemistry, microstructure, and morphology of the CDMs; and (3) the defect density and nondiamond carbon impurity content. In the case of application of CDMs to electrochemical processes, the effect of these factors on the electrode properties will depend on the reaction mechanism for the particular redox system [15]. Moreover, all the properties listed earlier can be controlled using the appropriate laboratory conditions for deposition.
3.3
CDM PREPARATION PROCEDURES
So far, two main procedures for creating CDM have been reported [12]: chemical vapor deposition (CVD) of thin CDM films (CVD–CDMs) and high-pressure hightemperature (HPTP) CDM particle production. For electrode applications, vacuum annealing of undoped diamond and surface transfer doping of undoped diamond have been also described for preparing conducting diamond electrodes [12]. The detailed description of these major CMD preparation methodologies are provided in Chapter 2. For this reason, in this chapter we will only briefly refer to them in order to correlate them with their influence on the properties of the CDMs. All the aforementioned properties are subject of manipulation providing the appropriate selection of deposition conditions. These conditions may vary depending on the source and affect the resulting CDM on its quality and response [15]. For example, in the case of CVD–CDM, pretreatment of substrate before diamond coating and surface activation with nanoscale diamond particles are important treatment steps [16–18]. Other important conditions are source gas composition, cool-down procedures as well as postgrowth chemical treatment. All these variables can lead to differences in the properties and performance of CDMs [15].
3.4 3.4.1
CDM DOPING MATERIALS Characteristics of Boron-Doped CDMs
Boron is the doping element most used in carbon doping [19]. This element is the only atom able to enter into carbon atom lattice. Substituting carbon atoms at the trigonal sites, boron alters the electronic properties of the material without significantly changing the lattice parameters [20,21]. Application of boron for doping graphite [22–25], C–C composites [16,20,26], and related carbon derivatives [27–33] have been a common practice in the last 30 years to improve the resistance of these materials to oxidizing conditions. In the last decade, boron has also been widely used in carbon nanotubes preparation [34–39]. As occurs with doping of other carbon lattices, boron is also the most common doping element for diamond [12,19,40–44]. By the replacement of carbon atoms by boron, formation of an impurity level with activation energy at 0.37 eV above the valence band in the diamond occurs [46]. Figure 3.5 shows the energy diagram of selected states in the diamond bandgap as one dimensional representation. Because trivalent boron atoms are electron deficient, they will accept electrons from the diamond valence band generating electron-deficient carbon atoms (so-called holes) and they are able to carry a positive charge. Generation of p-type semiconductors is aimed at producing as many holes as possible. In the diamond atomic structure, every hole is associated with a negatively charged boron ion, which maintains the electric neutral
64
TYPES OF CONDUCTING DIAMOND MATERIALS AND THEIR PROPERTIES
charge in the semiconductor. Under these conditions, each hole moving through the lattice behaves as a positive charge equilibrated with one electron. As long as the boron concentration reaches high enough values to generate a material with a resistivity between 5 and 100 m cm−1 (usually considered ≥1019 atoms cm−3 ), the hole concentration will exceed the electron thermal excitation and it becomes the major charge carrier. As previously mentioned, p-type conductivity has been reported occurring naturally in diamond only under rare conditions where boron is the main impurity at concentrations under 1 mg/kg. Boron loadings at upper concentrations can only be achieved synthetically in diamond using mainly HPHT or CVD technologies. As reported by Ristein et al. [47], surface conductivity in B-doped diamond (BDD) seems to be related to the following experimental conditions: (1) surface conductivity is enhanced by positive charge carriers moving at 30 to 70 cm2 V−1 s−1 at room temperature, indicating holes transportation within the crystalline solid [48]; (2) the concentration of charge carriers, as well as the mobility, is weakly temperature dependent with values among 1012 and 1013 cm−2 at room temperature [49]; and (3) surface conductivity may vary in orders of magnitude depending on the environment to which the surface is exposed [50]. 3.4.2
Electrochemical Properties
Conducting diamond materials possess very interesting properties as anodes useful in several electrochemical processes. Currently, one of the most attractive of applications for BDD anodes is water treatment—probably the most intensively investigated use. For water treatment, BDD properties such as their large potential window, low species adsorption, corrosion stability, high efficiency, and low double-layer capacitance and background current, among many others, have made the use of CDMs especially interesting for destruction of organic pollutants and waterborne pathogens in water. These exceptional BDD properties are clearly evident when comparing their potentiodynamic profile with that exhibited by a typical platinum electrode, such as illustrated in Figure 3.6a. The potentiodynamic profiles for the BDD electrode obtained after purged with nitrogen gas are featureless, and the background current is very low (less than 1 μA) in both cases. In acidic media the oxygen evolution peak appears about +2.0 V vs. SCE (Figure 3.6a). On the other hand, the curve B exhibits a broad oxidation peak at about +0.9 V vs. SCE. Thus, it can be assumed that this peak is due to water decomposition. These results are in agreement with Yano et al. [11]. Finally, a comparison between Pt and BDD electrodes is shown in Figure 3.6a and b, where BDD electrodes exhibit a most important characteristic: a potential window about 4 V. In alkaline media a similar broad potential window is observed, as shown in Figure 3.6b. As an important difference from conventional anodes—that is, Pt, PbO2 , SnO2 (doped and undoped), IrO2 , and RuO2 —the oxidation mechanism on CDMs does not proceed through preliminary introduction of oxygen into the oxide lattice generating a change in the oxidation state. Rather, the oxidation mechanism proceeds by generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and weak oxidants such peroxodisulfate, peroxodicarbonate, and peroxodiphosphate [51–54]. The wide range of applications of CDMs in organic compound oxidation includes degradation of ammonia, phenols, cyanides, dyes and colorants, pharmaceuticals, and an extended list of other pollutants [55–59] (see Chapters 10, 14, and 17) as well as its use in electrochemical disinfection processes for different microorganisms [60–62].
3.4 CDM DOPING MATERIALS
65
(a)
(b)
Figure 3.6 Potentiodynamic profiles (a) for the BDD and Pt electrodes in acidic media (0.5 M H2 SO4 ) and (b) for the BDD electrode in alkaline media (0.25 M NaOH + 0.5 M Na2 SO4 ).
This last case is important because microbiological contamination of fresh water with pathogens constitutes a major sanitary concern. Thus, for this instance, Furuta et al. [60] have shown that use of BDD as CDM anodes for water disinfection generates a high inactivation rate of pathogenic bacteria and viruses, such as is observed in Figure 3.7. More examples and results are commented on in Chapter 16. In addition to water treatment, CDM electrodes have also been used in a wide variety of other interesting industrial processes. Examples are chemical synthesis (see Chapter 19) and electro-analysis (see Chapters 7 and 8), where they have been used as sensors and biosensors [54,63], as well as in the in situ production of common chloride-based disinfection agents [62], fuel cells (see Chapter 18), and metal finishing processes such as electrodeposition of noble metals [64]. The most recent trends for the use of boron-doped CDM are its use as ultramicroelectrodes (UME) and biosensors (see Chapters 5 and 6). A UME is defined as an electrode with an effective diameter smaller than the scale of the diffusion layer, typically a critical diameter <25 μm. As a consequence, a rapid radial diffusion is performed dominating at the electrode surface, and faradic currents can be detected with improved signal:noise
66
TYPES OF CONDUCTING DIAMOND MATERIALS AND THEIR PROPERTIES
Virus activity (%) 100.0 80.0 60.0 40.0 20.0 0.0 0
10 Time (min)
15
20
Figure 3.7 Inactivation of Adenovirus (H 40/1; 105 virus/mL) in tap water by chemical chlorine dosing (dashed line) and electrochemical disinfection (solid line). (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 60.)
ratio [65]. BDD-UME have been reported to be suitable for use in scanning electrochemical microscopy (SECM) probes as confirmed by Holt, Hu, and Foord [65], who fabricated and used these BDD-UMEs to obtain approach curves and image electrochemical activity of E. coli cells, as shown in Figure 3.8 and 3.8b. Boron-doped diamond electrodes have been recently investigated as potential substrates for biosensor devices [66]. In particular, H-terminated epitaxial diamond has been used as a convenient substrate to grow neuronal cultures for application in the fabrication of electrodes for recording electrical signals of excitable cells [66]. Recently, Carlisle [63] proposed that the use of electro-active enzymes chemically immobilized on conducting nanocrystalline diamond-conducting materials could be the basis of diamond-based electrochemical biosensors and bio-interfaces. The main advantages identified for CDMs for the generation of biosensors (1) no preparation is required to have electrodes ready to use, (2) the electrode surface is relatively free of oxygen providing pH-independent behavior of voltammetric background, and (3) there is an absence of problems related to surface functional groups and high stability level during exposure to biological environments [67]. Diamond microelectrodes have shown improvement performance for in vivo measurements with respect to other conventional microelectrodes made with Pt, Au, or C, among others [68–71].
3.4.3
Photoelectrochemical Properties
Boron doped-conducting diamond electrodes possess also some attractive photoelectrochemical properties [72–74]. Due to the large energy gap in undoped diamond, low energetic ultraviolet (UV) and visible radiation are not able to promote electrons from the valence to the conducting band. For example, in high-quality diamond electrodes with low nondiamond carbon content, only radiation with energy over the bandgap is able to promote electrons in the conducting band [74,75]. However, by the inclusion of boron as a dopant, measurable photocurrents have been determined probably associated with surface states produced by impurity within the bandgap. Boonma et al. [74] tested the photoelectrochemical behavior of boron-doped diamond electrodes with excimer lasers under different wavelengths of 193, 248 and 351 nm (6.4, 5.0, and 3.53 eV, respectively). They found that photocurrent observed using the highest energy (193 nm; 6.4 eV) was higher than that observed with the other two lasers and that photoelectrochemical properties of the CDM were sensitive to surface conditions [73].
3.4 CDM DOPING MATERIALS
67
(a)
(b) 12 pA 9 pA
350 μm
6 pA 3 pA 0 pA
2000 μm
Figure 3.8 (a) Sharp electrode tip of radius ≈3 μm achieved by bias-enhanced growth of nanocrystalline diamond. (b) SECM image of immobilized E. coli cells obtained by detecting ferrocyanide produced from their respiration. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 65.)
3.4.4
Optical Spectroscopy Properties
Boron doping in diamond allows several very interesting spectral properties in the infrared band—for example, the absorption spectra in the range from 160 to 830 meV at room temperature due, at 160 meV, to one-phonon-absorption [76] and to transitions to boronbound hole excited states at 304, 347, and 363 meV [77]. Under low temperature conditions, the absorption spectra have been solved over 25 different absorption lines [78,79]. Under these conditions, the ground state splits by an energy of about 2.1 meV into degenerated 8 lower and 7 higher levels. The electronic transitions between these
68
TYPES OF CONDUCTING DIAMOND MATERIALS AND THEIR PROPERTIES
energy levels can couple to the defect-induced first-order (DIFO), one phonon density of states spectrum leading to a repetition on absorption bands at higher energies [80]. On this spectrum type, lines at 462 and 508 meV are dominant and are usually shifted by the O Raman phonon. At about 370 meV, photoionization continuum as phononrepeat and extend to the visible region producing a bluish color of IIb-type diamond until reaching 10 μm (<0.1 eV) where free carrier absorption have been observed [78]. Perfect crystalline diamond is not able to absorb into infrared spectra but the presence of impurities or defects are able to produce slightly absorption in the visible region [81]. As described earlier, diamond doping with boron produce the diminishing on its transparency [82]; nevertheless, boron-doped CDMs are currently used in UV-Vis and infrared spectroscopy [83,84]. Boron-doped CDMs are also widely used as optically transparent electrodes (OTE) in spectroelectrochemical determinations in an extensive wavelength range [83–85,137]. The type of CDMs used for the different OTE applications depends on the use requirements. Thin-doped diamond films on a nondiamond substrate such as Si are currently used for IR, whereas quartz substrate is used in UV-Vis spectroelectrochemical measurements [83,12]. More recently [137], other ways for OTE production have been described—such as mechanically polished free-standing diamond electrodes that are prepared by growing thick films of CDM on a metallic substrate. The film is then separated from the substrate by cooling rapidly from the growth temperature, using the differences in thermal expansion coefficients of the CDM and the supporting material. The resulting film is mechanically polished to smooth the surface and to eliminate roughness and avoid light scattering. Generally, CDM-OTEs possess a short-wavelength cutoff about 225 nm, related with the bandgap of the material [85], and its optical window goes well out into the infrared, except for the boron acceptor band and the intrinsic multiphonon absorptions described early. 3.4.5
Photo- and Cathodoluminescence Properties
Doped diamond good-quality photo and cathodoluminescence spectra at 5.355 eV shows a sharp no-phonon (NP) recombination line of the boron-bound exciton (BE) [86]. Some authors have found a linear relationship between conductivity and boron content [87,88] in boron-doped polycrystalline films. They are derived from a phenomenological relationship that allowed the boron-doping level in the range between 1017 cm−3 to 1019 cm−3 from cathodoluminescence spectra. In the same way, doping level has an important effect on the spectral position and line width of the boron-bound exciton; for boron loads over 1019 cm−3 the boron-bound exciton shifts to lower energies. By increasing boron concentration, sudden shifts of the BE (up to 5.05 eV) have been reported [86]. BE luminescence have also been reported in boron-implanted HPHT-CDM. For these materials, high temperatures (about 1000–1200◦ C) are required to heal lattice damage and activate boron on optically active substitutional lattice sites even at, comparatively, low implantation doses (about 2 × 1013 cm−2 ). In addition to this bandgap BE, other boron emission bands have been identified in cathodoluminscence measurements for HPHT and CVD–CDMs. For example, a band centered in the UV region at 4.6 eV (mainly from high boron-loaded areas) has been reported for CVD–CDMs [89] at high temperature and disappears when samples are at room temperature. Other bands in the visible region, centered at about 2.3 eV and related to the donor-acceptor pair between boron and nitrogen or between unidentified donors with the same energy, have been detected [86]. The band at 2.3 eV is
3.5 NON-BORON-DOPED CDMs
69
characteristic of high-boron-loaded regions and it is dependent on boron concentration; nevertheless, nitrogen concentration does not affect it [86]. Another band at 1.8 eV has been reported by Klein et al. [90], which may compete with that at 2.3 eV and associate with transitions from other deep donors to boron acceptors. 3.4.6
Electrical Conductivity and Superconductivity Properties
A recent report on type-II superconductivity in boron-doped CDMs [91] found a revolutionary discovery that may change the actual basic science and technology concept on the field [43,92]. So far, the report of superconducting diamond material synthesized at about 8–9 GPa and 2500–2800 K with Tc = 4 K have brought back the controversy on the mechanisms in covalent materials. Several theoretical proposals on the superconductivity mechanisms of CDMs have been suggested [93,94]. These deal with the theory that superconductivity is an impurity band phenomenon driven by strong electron correlation effects and that the disordered superconductivity state is located in the vicinity of the Mott transition band, Further work is required to evidence any of these theories. As mentioned earlier, when acting as a dopant, boron atoms replace carbon atoms in the diamond lattice by bonding to the neighbor carbon atoms with a sp 3 hybridization. Because boron has one fewer electron than carbon, an electron deficiency (a hole) is generated in the otherwise filled valence band. It has been determined that the generated hole is associated in the ground state to the boron with a binding energy about 0.37 eV. By increasing of doping with boron, an Anderson-Mott transition from insulator to conductor is proposed via the overlapping of impurity wave functions after reaching a critical boron concentration, nc . Some authors have proposed superconductivity in CDMs as a result of the impurity band phenomenon dominated by strong physical correlation within the impurity band subsystem [86]. However, other recent theoretical studies have used band structure calculations and suggested that the superconductivity in CDMs results in strong coupling between phonons and holes at the point [93–95]. Further research is necessary to generate accurate knowledge to understand the mechanisms of superconductivity in CDMs and for future development of new diamond superconducting devices.
3.5
NON-BORON-DOPED CDMs
Diamond dopage using a wide variety of elements has been an interesting scientific issue in the last few years [96]. Doping agents tested include an extensive number of metals and semiconductors [97]. Besides boron, other elements such as phosphorous [98–100], nitrogen [99,101–103], silicon [104–106], and palladium [107] have been used as dopants. In most cases, the objective of doping diamond is to achieve a p-type or n-type semiconductor [96]. In the case of p-type dopants, despite boron being the most widely reported dopant, other doping diamond elements such as potassium, sodium, and aluminum have been recently tested. In the case of potassium and sodium, they show low acceptor levels; aluminium shows a deeper acceptor level [108]. Research on viable n-type dopants has become increasingly more complex with time [109]. Theoretically, in analog to silicon doping, elements from groups V and VI are expected to become donor impurities. Several different elements such as lithium, sodium [110–111], arsenic, antimony [112–113], as well as previously mentioned nitrogen [114],
70
TYPES OF CONDUCTING DIAMOND MATERIALS AND THEIR PROPERTIES
phosphorous, and sulfur [115–117] have been tested as doping agents. Among them, nitrogen (activation energy 1.6–1.7 eV below the CB), phosphorous (activation energy 0.6 eV below the CB), and sulfur are the most useful [46,100,118] as well as co-doped diamond (e.g., nitrogen-boron or boron-sulfur) [99,100,103,118]. Phosphorous or nitrogen doping, known as pentavalent impurities or donor elements, increase the number of negative charge carriers (i.e., electrons) in diamond [119]. The purpose of n-type doping is to produce abundant negative charge carriers in diamond. By adding a pentavalent atom to the crystallite lattice in diamond, the covalent tetrahedral structure in carbon atoms is maintained, allowing one nonbonded electron. In this way, the generation of free electrons will exceed holes and become the main charge carriers in n-type semiconductors. The use of sulfur as a doping agent has usually been restricted to the presence of boron, generating an n-type semiconductor at low boron concentrations [100,118]. Nevertheless, other works [138] have reported that diamond layers obtained by CVD in the presence of H2 S exhibit p-type conduction with activation energy and carrier concentration very similar to those reported for boron-doped diamond. In the case of nitrogen, its use as a dopant depends on growing conditions as well as on crystallographic orientation of the diamond films [120]. It can be incorporated in many different bonding configurations, the most common being as a single substitution nitrogen and as complex as lattice defects. It has been reported that electrochemical parameters obtained by nitrogen doping are only slightly lower to conventional borondoped diamond with a wide potential window and low background current [121]. The inclusion of nitrogen increases the thermoluminescence activity in diamond dosimeters [122]. More studies are needed to determine what optimal nitrogen impurity concentration should be performed to identify the best operation conditions. Recent work dealing with the generation of nitrogen-doped nanocrystalline diamond suggests that high conductivity could not be the result of conventional doping with nitrogen atoms but the increase of sp 2 bonding at grain boundaries and the introduction of π and π * states within the bandgap [123]. These increases may generate that conduction occurs along grain boundaries [98,121], however the exact transport mechanism remains unknown [124]. Phosphorous atoms, which are larger than carbon atoms, are able to form defects in diamond sp 3 structure by substitution [125], forming P-containing carbon tetragons. These structures are stable in CPx sp 2 cage-like structures [126,127]. P-doped diamond has been widely used as light emitting diodes [128] and UV detectors [129], among other uses [130]. An interesting donor level has been reported for phosphorous [111,116,131,132]; however, electron mobility values determined for P-containing diamond are low (23 cm2 V−1 s−1 ) [96,133]. The conductivity dependence on temperature for P-doped CDMs and its low mobility lead some authors to suggest that the observed conduction may be related more to crystal imperfections than to n-type conductivity. Sodium, antimony, arsenic, and oxygen have been tested as n-type donors. In none of these cases, however has n-type doping been definitively demonstrated with experimental evidence [96,134]. Controversy remains on the donor activity for n-type doping. In contrast to p-type doping, which has been demonstrated in diamond using many different techniques [135], n-type doping preparation is considered by some authors to be associated with several
REFERENCES
71
different problems [135]. They believe that these difficulties have limited its application to few special cases [136], mainly because several attempts to generate n-type semiconducting diamonds have resulted in low-quality CDMs. 3.6
CONCLUSIONS
Nowadays, the synthetic diamond is an advanced material with a wide spectrum of applications in fundamental research as well as in technological development. The conductive limitations of diamond in the past are no longer a problem today. It is clear that insertion of foreign atoms into the crystalline structure of diamond can decrease the large energy gap to an acceptable level to allow the electrical conduction but keep their thermal and chemical stability properties. This is a relevant aspect because some of the most important applications of synthetic diamond could be dependent on these latter properties. Boron, nitrogen, and phosphorus are the most common foreign atoms to add to electronic acceptors or charge donors in doping processes. Although the electronic states of nitrogen and phosphorus in diamond are well known, BDD has become the more popular material of synthetic diamond since its introduction in 1987. This fact is due in part to BBD’s strong impact in the field of application and fundamental research of the electrochemistry. Good quality, oxygen, or hydrogen-terminated diamond thin-film electrodes exhibit suitable properties for electrochemical studies such as (1) a low and stable background current over a wide potential range and (2) a good resistance to fouling due to weak adsorption of polar molecules on the nonpolar surface. Knowledge branches such as organic electrosynthesis, electroanalysis, and water treatment have found in these conducting diamond films a new perspective of development. In addition, the versatility of this material has also been exploited in developing sensors and biosensors, also being useful for several bioelectrochemical applications. Finally, doped synthetic diamonds will make scientific development in possible applications such as microsensors and instrumentation, thermal devices, biomedical devices, electronic and microelectronic systems, optic and photonics, microfluids, and nanomaterials, as well as in the fuel cell technology. However, the most relevant application in the future will be associated with the elaboration of nanoparticles of synthetic diamond able to be used in environmental problems that remain unresolved and in medical diagnostic activities. REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
R.F. Curl, R. Smalley, Sci. Am. 1991, 265 , 54–63. F. Diederich, R. Ettl, Y. Rubin, Science 1991, 252 , 548–551. O. Vasilievna, U. Ortiz, Ciencia UANL 2002, 5 , 475–479. O. Gunnarsson, Rev. Modern Phys. 1997, 69 , 575–606. P. Byszewsri, Z. Klusek, Optoelect. Rev . 2001, 9 , 203–2010. S. Iijima, Springer Proc. Phys. 2001, 87 , 24–34. Micromachined Diamond Device Initiative (MIDDI). Element Six Ltd. and Institute of Photonics, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow, UK, 2008. 8. V.S. Vavilov, Usp. Fiz. Nauk 1994, 164 , 287–293. 9. R. Kalish, Carbon 1999, 37 , 781–785.
72
TYPES OF CONDUCTING DIAMOND MATERIALS AND THEIR PROPERTIES
10. M. Nesladek, Semicond. Sci. Technol. 2005, 20 , R19–R27. 11. T. Yano, E. Popa, D.A. Tryk, K. Hashimoto, A. Fujishima, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1999, 146 , 1081–1087. 12. A. Kraft, Int. J. Electrochem. Sci . 2007, 2 , 355–370. 13. M. Pagels, C. Hall, N.S. Lawrence, A. Meredith, T. Jones, H.P. Godfried, J. Pickless, J. Wilman, C. Banks, R. Compton, L. Jiang, Anal. Chem. 2005, 77 , 3705–3708. 14. C. Saguy, Defect Diff. Forum 2004, 31 , 226–228. 15. A.E. Fisher, Y. Show, G.M. Swain, Anal. Chem. 2004, 76 , 2553–2558. 16. S. Ragan, G.T. Emmerson, Carbon 1992, 30 , 339–345. 17. M. Fryda, T. Matthee, S. Mulcahy, A. Hampel, L. Schafer, I. Troster, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2003, 12 , 1950–1955. 18. X. Jiang, M. Fryda, C.L. Jia, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2000, 9 , 1640–1648. 19. A. Marchand in Chemistry and Physics of Carbon ( P.L. Walker, ed.), Marcel Dekker, New York, 1971. 20. X. Wu, L.R. Radovic, J. Phys. Chem. A 2004, 108 , 9180–1987. 21. V. Serin, R. Brydson, A. Scott, Y. Kihn, O. Abidate, B. Maquin, A. Derre, Carbon 2000, 38 , 547–555. 22. D.J. Allardice, P.L. Walker, Carbon 1970, 8 , 375–385. 23. T. Hagio, M. Nakamizo, K. Kobayashi, Carbon 1989, 27 , 259–263. 24. N.M. Rodriguez, R.T.K. Baker, J. Catal . 1993, 140 , 287–293. 25. T. Sogabe, T. Matsuda, K. Kuroda, Y. Hiroata, T. Hino, T. Yamashina, Carbon 1995, 33 , 1783–1795. 26. W. Kowbel, Y. Huang, H. Tsou, Carbon 1993, 31 , 355–363. 27. D.H. Zhong, H. Sano, Y. Uchiyama, K. Kobayashi, Carbon 2000, 38 , 1199–1118. 28. L.E. Jones, P.A. Thrower, Carbon 1991, 29 , 251–258. 29. L.R. Radovic, M. Karra, K. Skokova, P.A. Thrower, Carbon 1998, 36 , 1841–1864. 30. W. Cermignani, T E. Paulson, C. Onneby, C.G. Pantano, Carbon 1995, 33 , 367–374. 31. T. Durkic, A. Peric, M. Lusevic, O. Neskovic, M. Vejkovic, Z. Lausevic, Carbon 1997, 35 , 1567–1575. 32. M. Chesneau, F. Beguin, J. Conard, R. Erre, J. Thebault, Carbon 1992, 30 , 714–716. 33. S. Jacques, A. Guette, X. Burrat, F. Langlais, C. Guimon, C. Labrugere, Carbon 1996, 34 , 1135–1143. 34. B.Q. Wei, R. Spolenak, P. Kohler, M. Ruhle, E. Arzt, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1999, 74 , 3149–3156. 35. P.C.P. Watts, W.K. Hsu, G.Z. Chen, J. Mater. Chem. 2001, 11 , 2482–2490. 36. W.Q. Han, Y. Bando, K. Kurashima, T. Sato, Chem. Phys. Lett . 1999, 299 , 368–375. 37. W.K. Hsu, S. Firth, P. Redlich, M. Terrones, H. Terrones, Y.Q. Zhu, N. Grobert, A. Schilder, R.J. Clark, D. Walton, J. Mater. Chem. 2000, 10 , 1425–1432. 38. A.S. Kotosonov, D.V. Shilo, Mol. Mater. 2000, 13 , 113–121. 39. P.L. Gai, O. Stephan, K. McGuire, A.M. Rao, M.S. Dresselhaus, G. Dresselhaus, C.J. Colliex, J. Mater. Chem. 2004, 14 , 669–675. 40. N. Vinokur, B. Miller, Y. Avygal, R. Kalish, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1996, 143 , L238–L243. 41. C.H. Goeting, F. Jones, J.S. Foord, J.C. Eklund, F. Marken, R.G. Compton, P.R. Chalker, C.J. Johnston, J. Electroanal. Chem. 1998, 442 , 207–213. 42. R.G. Compton, J.S. Foord, F. Marken, Electroanalysis 2003, 15 , 1349–1356. 43. E. Bustarret, P. Achatz, B. Sac´ep´e, C. Chapelier, C. Marcenat, L. Ortega, T. Klein, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 2008, 366 , 267–275.
REFERENCES
73
44. B. Sac´ep´e, C. Chapelier, C. Marcenat, J. Kacmarcik, T. Klein, M. Bernard, E. Bustarret, Phys. Rev. Lett . 2008, 96 , 097006.1. 45. J. R. Chelikowsky, S.G. Louie, Phys. Rev. B 1984, 29 , 3470–3477. 46. M. Nesdalek, Semicond. Sci. Technol. 2005, 20 , R19–R28. 47. J. Ristein, M. Riedel, M. Stammler, B.F. Mantel, L. Ley, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2002, 11 , 359–370. 48. H.J. Looi, R.B. Jackman, J.S. Foord, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1998, 72 , 353–370. 49. K. Hayashi, S. Yamanaka, H. Okushi, K. Kajimura, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1996, 68 , 376–378. 50. M. Szameitat, X. Jiang, W. Beyer, Appl. Phys. Lett . 2000, 77 , 1554–1560. 51. P.A. Michaud, E. Mahe, W. Haenni, A. Perret, C. Comninellis, Electrochem. Solid-State Lett . 2000, 3 , 77–85. 52. M.S. Saha, T. Furuta, Y. Nishiki, Electrochem. Solid-State Lett . 2003, 6 , D5–D11. 53. P. Ca˜nizares, F. Larrondo, J. Lobato, M.A. Rodrigo, C. S´aez, J. Electrochem Soc. 2005, 152 , D191–D198. 54. C.A. Martinez-Huitle, E. Brillas, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed . 2008, 47 , 1998–2005. 55. M. Panizza, G. Cerisola, Electrochem. Acta 2005, 51 , 191–198. 56. M.A. Quiroz-Alfaro, S. Ferro, C.A. Martinez-Huitle, Y. Meas-Vong, J. Braz. Chem. Soc. 2006, 17 , 227–236. 57. I. Sir´es, P.L. Cabot, F. Centellas, J.A. Garrido, R.M. Rodr´ıguez, C. Arias, E. Brillas, Electrochem. Acta 2006, 52 , 75–82. 58. M. Villanueva, A. Hernandez, J.M. Peralta-Hern´andez, E.R. Bandala, M.A. Quiroz, ECS Transactions 2008, 15 , 411–417. 59. M. Villanueva, A. Hernandez, J.M. Peralta, E.R. Bandala, M.A. Quiroz, J. Hazard. Mater. 2008, 167 , 1226–1230. 60. T. Furuta, H. Tanaka, Y. Nishiki, L. Pupunat, W. H¨anni, P. Rychen, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2004, 13 , 2016–2023. 61. I. Tr¨oster, L. Sch¨afer, M. Fryda, T. Matthe´e, Water Sci. Technol . 2004, 49 , 207–215. 62. W. Haenni, J. Gobet, A. Perret, L. Pupunat, P. Rycehn, C. Comninellis, B. Correa, New Diam. Front. Carbon Technol . 2002, 12 , 83–98. 63. J.A. Carlisle, Nat. Mat . 2004, 3 , 668–675. 64. J. Wurm, New Diam. Front. Carbon Technol . 2002, 12 , 107–115. 65. K. B. Holt, J. Hu, J.S. Foord, Anal. Chem. 2007, 79 , 2556–2563. 66. P. Ariano, A. Lo Giudice, A. Mercantoni, E. Vittone., E. Carbone, D. Lovisole, Biosens. Bioelect . 2009, 24 , 204–2072. 67. S.H. Park, U. Krull, Anal. Chem. Acta 2006, 564 , 133–141. 68. C.A. Martinez-Huitle, Small 2007, 3 , 1474–1476. 69. Y. Zhou, J. Zhi, Talanta 2009, 75 , 1189–1193. 70. Y. Pleskov, M.D. Krotova, V.V. Elkin, V.G. Ralchenko, A.V. Saveliev, S.M. Pimenov, P.Y. Lim, Electrochem. Acta 2007, 52 , 5470–5478. 71. T. Watanabe, Y. Einaga, Biosens. Bioelect . 2009, 24 , 2684–2693. 72. A.Y. Sakharova, Y.V. Pleskov, F. Di Quarto, S. Piazza, C. Sunseri, I.G. Teremetskaya, V.P. Varnin, Russ. J. Electrochem. 1995, 32 , 168–175. 73. T.N. Rao, D.A. Tryk, K. Hashimoto, A. Fujishima, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1999, 146 , 680–688. 74. L. Boonma, T. Yano, K. Tryk, K. Hashimoto, A. Fujishima, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1997, 144 , L142–L150. 75. Y. Pleskov, V.M. Mazin, Y.E. Evstefeeva, V.P. Varnin, G. Teremetskaya, V.A. Laptev, Electrochem. Solid State Lett . 2000, 3 , 141–153.
74
TYPES OF CONDUCTING DIAMOND MATERIALS AND THEIR PROPERTIES
76. G. Davies, in The Chemistry and Physics of Carbon ( P.L. Walker, P.A. Thrower, eds.), Marcel Dekker, New York, 1977. 77. A.T. Collins, A.W. Willams, J. Phys. C: Solid State Phys. 1971, 4 , 1789–1795. 78. H. Kim, A.K. Ramdas, S. Rodriguez, T.R. Anthony, Solid State Commun. 1997, 102 , 861–873. 79. H. Kim, R. Vogelgesang, A.K. Ramdas, S. Rodriguez, M. Grimsditch, T.R. Anthony, Phys. Rev. B 1997, 57 , 15315–15323. 80. E. Gheeraert, J. Deneuville, J. Mambou, Diam. Rel. Mat . 1998, 7 , 1509–1514. 81. A.N. Obraztsov, I.Y. Pavlovski, T. Izumi, H. Okushi, H. Watanabe, Appl. Phys. A: Mater. Sci. Process. 1997, 65 , 505–511. 82. R.L. McCreery, Chem. Rev . 2008, 108 , 2646–2653. 83. H.B. Martin, P.W. Morrison, Electrochem. Solid-State Lett . 2001, 4 , E17–E23. 84. J. Stotter, J. Zack, Z. Behler, Y. Show, G.M. Swain, Anal. Chem. 2002, 74 , 5924–5932. 85. J.K. Zak, J.E. Butler, G.M. Swain, Anal. Chem. 2001, 73 , 908–915. 86. K. Thonke, Semicond. Sci. Technol. 2003, 18 , S20–S31. 87. H. Kawarada, Y. Yokota, Y. Mori, K. Nishimura, A. Hiraki, J. Appl. Phys. 1990, 67 , 983–989. 88. H. Kawarada, H. Matsuyama, Y. Yokota, T. Sogi, A. Yamaguchi, A. Hiraki, Phys. Rev. Lett . 1993, 47 , 3633–3645. 89. S.C. Lawson, H. Kanda, T. Tsutsumi, H. Kawarada, J. Appl. Lett . 1995, 77 , 1729–1734. 90. P.B. Klein, M.D. Crossfield, J.A. Freitas, A.T. Collins, Phys. Rev. B 1995, 51 , 9634–9645. 91. E.A. Ekimov, V.A. Sidorov, E.D. Bauer, N.N. Mel’nick, N.J. Curro, J.D. Thompson, S.M. Stishov, Nature 2004, 428 , 542–549. 92. Y. Takano, M. Nagao, I. Sakaguchi, M. Tachiki, T. Hatano, K. Kobayashi, H. Umezawa, H. Kawarada, Appl. Phys. Lett . 2004, 85 , 2851–2863. 93. L. Boeri, J. Kortus, O.K. Andersen, Phys. Rev. Lett . 2004, 93 , 237–242. 94. K.W. Lee, W.E. Pickett, Phys. Rev. Lett . 2004, 93 , 1–13. 95. X. Blas´e, C. Adessi, D. Connetable, Phys. Rev. Lett . 2004, 93 , 237004. 96. A.S. Barnard, S.P. Russo, I.K. Snook, J. Phys. Chem. 2005, 109 , 11991–11998. 97. J.P. Goss, R. Jones, M.I. Heggie, C.P. Ewels, P.R. Briddon, S. Oberg, Phys. Rev. B 2002, 65 , 115207. 98. M. Nesdalek, D. Tromson, P. Bergonzo, P. Hubik, J.J. Mares, J. Kristofik, D. Kindl, O.D. Williams, D. Gruen, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2006, 15 , 607–616. 99. S.C. Eaton, Y.E. Evstefeeva, J.C. Angus, A.B. Anderson, Y. Pleskov, Russ. J. Electrochem. 2003, 39 , 154–159. 100. S. Vaddiraju, S. Eaton-Magana, J.A. Chaney, M.K. Sunkara, Electrochem. Solid-State Lett . 2004, 7 , G331–G343. 101. S. Ferro, A. De Battisti, I. Duo, C. Comninellis, W. Haenni, A. Perret, J. Electrochem. Soc. 2000, 147 , 2614–2621. 102. Q. Chen, D.M. Gruen, A.R. Krauss, T.D. Corrigan, M. Witek, G.M. Swain, J. Electrochem. Soc. 2001, 148 , E44–E53. 103. W. Haenni, P. Rychen, M. Fryda, C. Comninellis, in Semiconductors and Semimetals Series (C, Nebel, ed.), Academic Press, New York, 2004. 104. G. Sittas, H. Kanda, I. Kiflawa, P. Spear, Diam. Rel. Mat . 1996, 5 , 866–875. 105. W.J. Wu, M.H. Hon, Surf. Coat. Technol . 1999, 111 , 134–142. 106. I. Kiflawi, G. Sittas, H. Kanda, D. Fisher, Diam. Rel. Mat . 1997, 6 , 146–154. 107. A.V. Simakin, E.N. Loubnin, G.A. Shafeev, P. Doppelt, Appl. Surf. Sci . 2002, 186 , 227–232.
REFERENCES
75
108. G. Popovici, T. Sung, M.A. Prelas, J. Chem. Vap. Deposition 1994, 3 , 115–123. 109. L. Ley, J. Ristein, F. Meier, M. Riedel, P. Strobel, Physica B: Cond. Mater. 2006, 376-377 , 262–267. 110. S.A. Kajihara, A. Antonelli, J. Bernholc, R. Car, Phys. Rev. Lett . 1991, 66 , 2010–2023. 111. S.A. Kajihara, A. Antonelli, J. Bernholc, Physica B: Cond. Mater 1993, 185 , 144–156. 112. V.S. Vavilov, Phys-Usp. 1994, 37 , 269–275. 113. V.S. Vavilov, Phys-Usp. 1997, 40 , 387–393. 114. J.P. Goss, P.R. Briddon, R. Jones, S. Sque, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2004, 13 , 684–695. 115. D. Saada, J. Adler, R. Kalish, Appl. Phys. Lett . 2000, 77 , 878–894. 116. L.G. Wang, A. Zunger, Phys. Rev. B 2002, 66 , 161202. 117. T. Miyazaki, H. Okushi, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2002, 11 , 323–332. 118. S.C. Eaton, A.B. Anderson, J.C. Angus, Y.E. Evstefeeva, Y.V. Pleskov, Electrochem. SolidState Lett . 2002, 5 , G65–G78. 119. K. Haenen, M. Nesdalek, L. De Schepper, R. Kravets, M. Vanecek, S. Koizumi, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2004, 13 , 2041–2054. 120. F.K. De Theije, J.J. Schermer, J.P. van Enckevort, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2000, 9 , 1439–1445. 121. Y. Pleskov, M.D. Krotova, A.V. Saveliev, V.G. Ralchenko, Diam. Relat. Mat . 2007, 16 , 2114–2123. 122. C. Descamps, D. Tromson, M.J. Guerrero, C. Mer, E. Rzepka, M. Nesdalek, P. Bergonzo, Diam. Relat. Mat . 2006, 15 , 833–845. 123. E. Kohn, A. Denisenko, M. Kubovic, T. Zimmermann, A.O. Williams, D.M. Gruen, Semicond. Sci. Technol . 2006, 21 , L32–L43. 124. Y. Pleskov, S.M. Pismenov, P. Lim, V.G. Ralchenko, Russ. J. Electrochem. 2008, 44 , 861–865. 125. H. Sternschulte, K. Thonke, R. Sauer, S. Koisomi, Phys. Rev. B 1999, 59 , 12924–12935. 126. G.K. Gueorguiev, A. Furlan, H. Hogberg, S. Stafstrom, L. Hultman, Chem. Phys. Lett . 2006, 426 , 374–86. 127. E. Cruz, D.A. Cullen, L. Gu, J.M. Romo, E. Mu˜noz, F. Lopez, B. Sumpter, V. Meunier, J. Charlier, D.J. Smith, H. Terrones, M. Terrones, ACS Nano 2008, 2 , 441–453. 128. S. Koizumi, K. Watanabe, M. Hasegawa, H. Kanda, Science 2001, 292 , 1899–1901. 129. A. BenMoussa, U. Schule, K. Haenen, M. Nesdalek, S. Koizumi, J.F. Hochedez, Phys.Stat. Sol. A 2004, 201 , 2536–2546. 130. A. Lazea, V. Mortet, J. D’Haen, P. Geithner, J. Ristein, M. D’Olieslaeger, K. Haenen, Chem. Phys. Lett . 2008, 454 , 310–318. 131. E. Gheeraert, S. Koizumi, T. Teraji, H. Kanda, M. Nesdalek, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2000, 9 , 948–957. 132. E. Gheeraert, N. Cassanova, S. Koizumi, T. Teraji, H. Kanda, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2001, 10 , 444–453. 133. S. Koizumi, M. Kamo, Y. Sato, H. Okazi, T. Inuzuka, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1997, 71 , 1065–1074. 134. J.F. Prins, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2000, 9 , 1275–1284. 135. S. Koizumi, T. Teraji, H. Kanda, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2000, 9 , 935–943. 136. I. Sakaguchi, M. Gamo, Y. Kikuchi, E. Yasu, H. Haneda, T. Suzuki, T. Ando, Phys. Rev. B 1999, 60 , R2139. 137. S. Haymond, J.K. Zak, Y. Show, J.E. Butler, G.T. Babcock, G.M. Swain, Anal. Chem. Acta 2003, 500 , 137–143. 138. R. Kalish, A. Reznik, C. Uzan, C. Cytermann, Appl. Phys. Lett . 2000, 76 , 757–765.
Part II
Electrochemistry of Diamond Films
4 Electrochemistry of Diamond Yuri Pleskov
4.1
INTRODUCTION
Diamond undoubtedly is a significant electrode material. However, unlike other carbonaceous materials that have long found their practical applications (e.g., graphite, glassy carbon, pyrolytic graphite, carbon fibers, etc.), the electrochemical study of diamond was started relatively recently, in 1987, when the first paper on the (photo)electrochemistry of CVD-diamond electrode was published [1]. These studies were triggered by the fact that during the preceding three decades, highly effective methods of polycrystalline diamond film growth at conducting substrates at subatmospheric, rather than ultra-high, pressure were developed. By doping with acceptor-type impurity (boron), well-conducting films were prepared, which were semiconducting (p-type) or, at a higher doping level, even quasi-metallic in their nature. Thus, ultra-high corrosion resistance and sufficient conductivity were combined in the same material. With these first studies on diamond electrodes, a new field of the semiconductor electrochemistry [2] was established—namely, the electrochemistry of diamond [3]. The electrochemistry of diamond has several specific features. First, diamond is crystalline; thus, it is not unexpected that it demonstrates semiconductor behavior. Second, the charge carrier (hole) mobility in polycrystalline CVD-films is rather low (∼10 cm2 V−1 s1 ) [4]; therefore, to demonstrate substantial conductivity, diamond must be rather heavily doped, so that the semiconductor becomes degenerate and its semiconductor properties appear somewhat blurred. Third, the semiconductor and structural properties of diamond are interrelated rather quaintly. Synthetic Diamond Films: Preparation, Electrochemistry, Characterization, and Applications, First Edition. Edited by Enric Brillas and Carlos Alberto Mart´ınez-Huitle. © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Published 2011 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
79
80
ELECTROCHEMISTRY OF DIAMOND
In this chapter, we present an overview of the principal electrochemical properties of CVD-diamond, with emphasis on the semiconductor and structural effects.
4.2
PRINCIPAL ELECTROCHEMICAL PROPERTIES OF DIAMOND
We first discuss current–voltage curves taken in supporting electrolyte solutions. In Figure 4.1, we show a typical background current curve taken potentiodynamically at a polycrystalline diamond thin-film electrode in the supporting electrolyte (0.5 M H2 SO4 ) solution [5]. The potential window of diamond electrodes is incomparably wider than that of any other material: It may be as wide as three volts (sometimes even more). The advantage of diamond electrodes in the width of the potential window, as well as in the lowest background current in the mid-window, is most clearly seen when compared with other carbonaceous materials (glassy carbon, graphite, etc.) or platinum, which have long had applications as electrodes. The wide potential window arises from the high overvoltage for solvent (water) decomposition. Indeed, the hydrogen electrode reaction (HER) or oxygen electrode reaction (OER) are inner-sphere reactions; their kinetics are very sensitive to the adsorption of their intermediates (e.g., H • ) at the electrode surface. Diamond is a poor adsorbent; hence, its catalytic effect is rather weak for these reactions. In contrast, outer-sphere reactions that are not limited by the adsorption of intermediates proceed very fast, often in a reversible mode [6]. Thus, within the potential window the solvent is stable, and the diamond electrode is suitable for the studying of reactions that involve neither the solvent nor the electrode substance; the reactions can be studied bearing in mind their electro-analytical, electrosynthetic, other applications. Because the growth process occurs in a hydrogen atmosphere, as-grown CVD-diamond surfaces are hydrogen-terminated; when oxidized (e.g., anodically or under the action of O-plasma), they are oxygen-terminated. The surface termination affects the electrochemical kinetics drastically [7,8] (see Chapter 5 of this book).
1 0.8 0.6 j (μA cm–2)
0.4 0.2 0 –0.2 –0.4 –0.6 –0.8 –1 –1
0
1
2
3
E (V) vs. Ag/AgCI Figure 4.1 Voltammetric curve of boron-doped diamond electrode, recorded in supporting electrolyte (0.5 M H2 SO4 ) at a potential scan rate of 50 mV/s. (Reprinted from Ref. 5.)
4.2 PRINCIPAL ELECTROCHEMICAL PROPERTIES OF DIAMOND
81
Diamond is extremely corrosion-resistant. For example, its long-term potential cycling in 1 M HNO3 + 0.1 M HF solution between the potentials of cathodic hydrogen evolution and anodic oxygen evolution has no effect on the diamond surface morphology. In contrast, glassy carbon and pyrolytic graphite electrodes are strongly damaged under the same conditions [9]. Similarly, diamond demonstrates strong corrosion resistance in 1 M HNO3 + 2 M NaCl solution at a potential of anodic chlorine evolution [10]. In Figures 4.2a and 4.2b, we give anodic and cathodic potentiodynamic curves in solutions containing a single (either oxidized or reduced) form of the [Fe(CN)6 ]3−/4− redox couple, taken at different polarization rates [11]. Contrary to expectations, these curves appeared mutually symmetrical, as with metal electrodes. Meanwhile, an ideal semiconductor electrode should demonstrate current rectification [2]: Usually, its polarization curves distinctly show the forward and blocking directions of the electrode current. Such polarization curves have indeed been experimentally observed time and again for lightly or moderately doped diamond electrodes (which will be discussed later). Yet, for rather heavily doped diamond, the anodic and cathodic curves are mirror images of each other. (In all probability, this is due to the fact that the heavily doped diamond is a degenerate semiconductor (as discussed earlier), or even demonstrates a metal-like behavior.) This characteristic shape of the curves, with the anodic and cathodic current maxima, is evidence that the interfacial charge transfer stage proper is rather fast (quasi-reversible), so that the reaction is limited by diffusion difficulties caused by slow mass transfer of the reacting species from the solution bulk to the electrode surface. This is often the case with outer-sphere reactions. The dependence of the anodic and cathodic current maximum potentials Ep in Figures 4.2a and b on the logarithm of the polarization rate dE /dt = v is given in Figure 4.2c. From the slope of the lines, using the theory of the kinetics of quasi-reversible reactions (as applied to the potentiodynamic curve method) [12,13], the transfer coefficients for the anodic (α) and cathodic (β) reactions can be calculated by the following formula: Ep = const − (RT/2αnF) ln v
(4.1)
where n is the number of electrons participating in the reaction (n = 1 for the [Fe (CN)6 ]3−/4− redox couple). Another approach to measuring the transfer coefficients is based on measuring the electrode’s electrochemical impedance spectra in redox-couple-containing solutions, such as in the “model” redox solution K3 [Fe(CN)6 ] + K4 [Fe(CN)6 ], in which the electrode acquires the equilibrium potential of the redox couple. Figure 4.3 shows a complex-plane plot of impedance spectra for a diamond electrode, measured in such a solution [14]. The low-frequency cutoff of the semicircle gives the Faradaic (or charge-transfer) resistance RF . To calculate the transfer coefficient of cathodic reaction α (or anodic, β), the following expression can be used: j0 = nFk0
1−α α cox cred
(4.2)
where k 0 is the rate constant. The exchange current j0 is interrelated with the Faradaic resistance measured in a redox-couple-containing solution at its equilibrium potential as RF = RT/(nFj0 )
(4.3)
82
ELECTROCHEMISTRY OF DIAMOND
1.2
i (mA/cm2)
(a)
0.8
5 4 3
0.4 2 1 0 0.4
0.6
0.8 E, V (Ag/AgCI)
1.0
1.2
E, V (Ag/AgCI) 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
(b) 1 2
i (mA/cm2)
–0.2 3 –0.4 4 –0.6 5 –0.8 –1.0 1.0
I
0.9 (c) 0.8 E P, V
0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 2
0.2 –2.4
–2.0
–1.6 log ν (V/s)
–1.2
–0.8
Figure 4.2 (a) Anodic and (b) cathodic potentiodynamic curves for diamond electrode in 0.5 M H2 SO4 + 0.01 M K4 Fe(CN)6 (resp., K3 Fe(CN)6 ) solution. Potential scan rate (mV/s): (1) 5; (2) 10; (3) 20; (4) 50; and (5) 100. (c) Determination of transfer coefficients: (1) the anodic reaction, ( 2) the cathodic reaction. (Reprinted from Ref. 11.)
Substituting equation (4.3) into (4.2), we reveal the dependence of RF on the variable concentration of one of the forms in the redox couple (e.g., the oxidant, cox ) while the concentration of the other form (the educing agent, cred ) is kept constant, and vice versa. The transfer coefficients of the cathodic and anodic reactions α and β are found by the slope of the corresponding linear dependence of RF on cox (at cred = const) or cred (at cox = const).
4.3 THE EFFECT OF SEMICONDUCTOR NATURE OF DIAMOND
83
–Im Z (kOhm cm2)
420 0.1
12
8000 0
0.1
0.2 0.3 Re Z (kOhm cm2)
Figure 4.3 Complex-plane plot of impedance spectrum, measured at a diamond electrode in solution 1M KCl + 5 × 10−2 M K3 [Fe(CN)6 ] + 5 × 10−2 M K4 [Fe(CN)6 ]). AC frequency (in Hz) is shown at the corresponding points. (Reprinted from Ref. 14.)
4.3 THE EFFECT OF SEMICONDUCTOR NATURE OF DIAMOND ON ITS ELECTROCHEMICAL BEHAVIOR For semiconductor electrodes (diamond, in particular), the transfer coefficients α and β are less than ∼0.5 (the value characteristic of metals); hence, their sum α + β is less than 1. The reason of this is still an open question. (We come back to this point later.) We now turn to the dependence of the electrochemical reaction rate on the diamond electrode doping level. In Figure 4.4, we correlate the charge transfer (Faradaic) resistance RF and the diamond resistivity ρ for two redox systems: [Fe(CN)6 ]3−/4− and benzoquinone/hydroquinone [14,15]. (The RF values are measured experimentally, either from the slope of polarization curves taken in solution containing equal concentrations of [Fe(CN)6 ]3− and [Fe(CN)6 ]4− at the equilibrium potential, or as a “low-frequency cutoff” at the real resistance axis for a complex-plane plot of electrode impedance spectra measured in the above solution, as shown in Figure 4.3.) Recall that the resistance RF is related to the exchange current of the electrode reaction j0 by Equation (4.3). From the relative position of the plots in Figure 4.4, one may conclude that the reaction rate in the [Fe(CN)6 ]3−/4− system is three orders of magnitude higher (RF is three orders of magnitude lower at a fixed ρ) than that in the benzoquinone/hydroquinone system. Most importantly, the exchange current (j0 ∼ 1/RF ) appears to be nearly proportional to the diamond conductivity (1/ρ) over a wide range of ρ values for both reactions. Indeed, the slope of the lines in Figure 4.4 approaches 1. The resistivity is known to be approximately inversely proportional to the charge carrier concentration in semiconductors (provided their mobility may be thought of as ρ-independent). Thus, the heavier the diamond electrode is doped, the faster are electrochemical reactions thereon. (The possible reason for this dependence will be discussed at the end of this section.) Anyhow, various practical applications (e.g., water purification, electroanalysis, etc.) require rather heavily doped electrodes whose resistivity comes to mOhm cm (which corresponds to a boron concentration of approximately 1021 cm−3 ). Now, let’s compare electrochemical kinetics for n- and p-type diamond electrodes. Since 1987, and over the entire time of studies of CVD-diamond electrochemistry, only ptype samples were dealt with because boron remained the only dopant with low ionization
84
ELECTROCHEMISTRY OF DIAMOND
7 2 1 logRF (Ohm cm2)
6
5
4
3
2
4
5
6 log ρ (Ohm
7
8
cm2)
Figure 4.4 Dependence of the Faradaic resistance RF at the equilibrium potential in solutions (a) [Fe(CN)6 ]3−/4− and (b) benzoquinone/hydroquinone on the diamond film resistivity ρ. (Reprinted from Ref. 14.)
energy that imparted diamond reasonable conductivity at room temperature. Only recently [16–18] n-type diamond thin-film electrodes well conducting at room temperature were prepared by co-doping diamond with boron and sulfur. (It appeared rather difficult to find an appropriate donor for diamond; the well-known donors, nitrogen and phosphorus, lie too “deeply” in the bandgap of diamond—1.6 and 0.6 eV below the conduction band—and therefore practically are not ionized at room temperature and hence do not contribute to the diamond conductivity.1 ) Obtaining sulfur-doped n-type diamond for the first time is quite a detective story. From 1999 to 2001, sulfur was reported to give n-type conductivity in synthetic diamond [19,20]. The supposed n-type samples were sent from Japan, where they were first prepared, to Israel for closer examination. However, the measurements indicated that the samples were contaminated with boron and therefore were p-type [21]. Post factum we can say that in works referenced in [19] and [20], the reactor was evidently used earlier for the deposition of boron-doped diamond; hence, it contained residual boron even after careful cleaning. In the samples prepared, the boron overcompensated the introduced sulfur. Later, n-type diamond films [16,17] were CVD-grown by deliberate co-doping of diamond with sulfur and boron, using H2 S and trimethylboron as sources of the S and B dopants, respectively. When the films were grown without adding trimethylboron to the feed gas (no traces of boron were present in the reactor), particle-induced x-ray emission (PIXE) analysis showed no boron in the grown films. Sulfur was not detected using secondary ion mass spectroscopy (SIMS) either, despite the presence of H2 S in 1
Nonetheless, irrespective of the relative position of the energy levels in the bandgap of diamond, nitrogen (a donor) can compensate boron (the adopted acceptor in diamond). Because nitrogen is always present (e.g., in methane used as raw material in the CVD-process), preparation of lightly doped diamond is quite a problem, since the required low acceptor concentration is inevitably obtained as a poorly controlled small difference of two large quantities (the boron and nitrogen concentrations).
4.3 THE EFFECT OF SEMICONDUCTOR NATURE OF DIAMOND
TABLE 4.1 Ref. 23.) Ratio in feed gas (C/H)feed
85
Growth conditions (co-doping with B and S) and the film properties. (Adapted from Ratio in feed gas (S/C)feed (ppm)
Ratio in feed gas (B/S)feed
Crystal orientation of diamond substrate
Seebeck coefficient α ∗ (mV/ ◦C)
Resistivity (Ohm cm)
S concentration (PIXE)/ Detection limit (ppm)
Below detection limit Below detection limit Below detection limit
39000 350000 59000
0/53 6/24 35/215
9.8 1.6 7.5 2050 63 9450
627/550 30/39 270/37 240/29 39/45 84/21
Prior to the boron introducing to reactor 0.40% 0.20% 0.10%
375 500 2000
0 0 0
{110} {111} {111}
After the boron introducing to reactor 0.50% 0.10% 0.10% 0.20% 0.10% 0.05%
1000 5000 2500 1250 100 29000
4 0.5 0.4 0.2 0 0.4
{111} {110} {111} {100} {110} {111}
0.32 103 −25 −78 −0.11 −150
the feed gas. The films appeared to be too resistive (see Table 4.1) for electrochemical or thermoelectric measurements. However, when the film growth was performed with both H2 S and trimethylboron to the feed gas, the grown films were either n- or p-type depending on the relative amount of boron (both residual and added) and sulfur (Table 4.1). The X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS), PIXE, and SIMS analyses showed that sulfur was incorporated into these films at any substrate crystal orientation. The samples were analyzed for the sulfur concentration profile by XPS and SIMS. Both methods showed that the sulfur concentration was high at the surface and decreased several orders of magnitude, to a relatively constant value, in the bulk diamond (Figure 4.5). For example, the SIMS analysis of the samples with {111} and {110} orientations showed the sulfur concentration of 2.5 1019 and 7.0 1016 cm−3 at the surface and in the bulk, respectively. The boron concentration there was 1.0 1018 and 3.0 1017 cm−3 , respectively.2 The sign of the thermoelectric effect (a sign of the Seebeck coefficient) gives a determination of the sign of the charge carriers in the solid. The thermoelectric power measurements were done using a two-point probe. The sign of the thermal electro motive force (EMF) was determined by measuring the voltage between the probes when the heater was turned on. For the n-type silicon samples, the cool probe was charged negatively, relative to the warm probe; for p-type samples, the cool probe was positive, relative to the warm probe. Determination was made of the sign of the thermal EMF, with two series of samples grown on {111} and {110} substrates from a gas mixture in which the sulfur-to-carbon (S/C) atomic ratio was held constant and the boron-to-sulfur (B/S) ratio increased. In these experiments, the residual concentration of boron in the 2 Here, we draw special attention to the enrichment of just the film-subsurface region with B and S. As the film growth goes on, the gas/diamond film interface (the depth = 0 in Figure 4.5) moves to the left, and the dopants’ concentrations in what currently was the subsurface region would take on their steady-state values. One may speculate that the heat effect of the doping process is so high that the system acts as if it “jumps through” its equilibrium state (one may remember the famous Belousov–Zhabotinsky reaction); as time goes, it comes back to the steady state.
86
ELECTROCHEMISTRY OF DIAMOND
Atomic concentration (cm–3)
1020
1019
Sulfur
Boron 1018
1017
1016 0
20
40
60 Depth (nm)
80
100
120
Figure 4.5 SIMS depth profile of sulfur and boron in a film grown on a (111) diamond substrate. Feed conditions were an S/C atomic ratio of 2000 ppm, a B/S ratio of 2000 ppm, and a 0.12% methane concentration. The film thickness was approximately 2.25 μm. (Reprinted from Ref. 16.)
reactor prior to each run was minimal. Figure 4.6 shows a plot of the Seebeck coefficient versus the B/S atomic ratio in the feed gas for a series of diamond films grown on the {111} face at a constant methane concentration (0.12%) and constant S/C atomic ratio (0.001). For these conditions, the change-over from n-type to p-type occurs at a B/S atomic ratio of approximately 0.23. Similar results were observed with a series of samples deposited on {110}-oriented substrates; however, here the change-over from n-type to p-type is observed at a B/S atomic ratio of approximately 0.12. Relatively lightly doped electrodes clearly demonstrated their semiconductor nature. A cyclic voltammogram taken at a moderately-boron-doped p-type diamond electrode (Figure 4.7 [22]) clearly shows that the cathodic reaction is suppressed, whereas the anodic reaction is fast and diffusion-controlled. And vice versa, at the sulfur-doped ntype diamond the forward direction of the current is the cathodic one, whereas the anodic current is small and has kinetic nature (Figure 4.8). Thus, as expected [2], the semiconductor diamond electrodes demonstrated electrical current rectification, even if poorly pronounced, so that the n- and p-type electrodes are as if they are mirror images of each other in their electrochemical properties. Equally, the n- and p-type diamond electrodes differ in their capacitive behavior. To estimate the acceptor or donor concentration in the semiconductor diamond, measurements of differential capacitance were used. The capacitance values are used in plotting the Mott-Schottky graphs showing the relationships between the inverse reciprocal capacitance (C −2 ) and the electrode potential E . Physically, the Mott-Schottky plot reflects the potential dependence of the space charge layer (more precisely, the depleted layer) thickness Lsc in the semiconductor: Lsc =
2εε0 |E | eNA
1/2 (4.4)
4.3 THE EFFECT OF SEMICONDUCTOR NATURE OF DIAMOND
87
α*(MV/°C) 1 0.5
p-type
0 0.00 0.05 –0.5 n-type
0.10
0.15
0.20
0.25
0.30
0.35
0.40
–1 –1.5 –2 –2.5 B/S ratio in gas phase
Figure 4.6 Plot of the Seebeck coefficient versus the B/S atomic ratio in the feed gas for a series of diamond films grown on the {111} face at a constant methane concentration (0.12%), increasing trimethylboron flow, and constant S/C atomic ratio (0.001). The vertical dashed line shows the approximate B/S atomic ratio at which the passing from n-type to p-type occurs. (Reprinted from Ref. 17.)
I (μA)
40
20
0 0.5
–0.5
1.0 E (V)
–20
Figure 4.7 Cyclic voltammogram at polycrystalline p-type diamond electrode, taken in 1 M KCl + 0.008 M K3 Fe(CN)6 + 0.008 M K4 Fe(CN)6 . Potential scan rate is 20 mV/s. (Reprinted from Ref. 22.)
where ε and ε0 are the diamond and vacuum permittivities, respectively; e is the electron charge. The intercept at the potential axis is the electrode flat-band potential Efb ; the slope of the line allows determination of the noncompensated (NA ) acceptor or donor (ND ) concentration in the semiconductor by using the following formula: N =±
2 [d(C −2 )/dE ]−1 εε0 e
(4.5)
where the “+” or “–” sign relates to the donors and acceptors. [In what follows, when speaking of the acceptor or donor concentration, we shall mean the noncompensated
88
ELECTROCHEMISTRY OF DIAMOND
ja (mA cm–2) 0,15
0,00 –1,4
–0,7
0,0
0,7
1,4
2,8 2,1 E (V)
–0,15
–0,30
jc (mA cm–2)
1013 C2(μF2 CM4)
Figure 4.8 Potentiodynamic curves at single-crystal n-type diamond electrode, taken in 0.5 M H2 SO4 + 0.01 M K3 Fe(CN)6 (cathodic) and 0.5M H2 SO4 + 0.01 M K4 Fe(CN)6 (anodic). Potential scan rate is 200 mV/s. Film growth conditions: CH4 concentration 0.1%, S/C ratio in gas phase 60 ppm. (Reprinted from Ref. 17.)
1.0
5.0
0.0 –0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
E (V) Figure 4.9 Mott-Schottky plot for a sample grown at single crystal (111)-substrate. Film growth conditions: CH4 concentration 0.25%, S/C and B/C ratios in gas phase 0.0025 and 0.4, respectively. The negative slope of the line points to the presence of acceptors; the acceptor concentration calculated by the slope is 2.7 × 1018 cm−3 . (Reprinted from Ref. 17.)
acceptor concentration (NA − ND ), or, correspondingly, the noncompensated donor concentration.] When sulfur is not present, or present in relatively small amounts, the Mott-Schottky plots have a negative slope characteristic of p-type semiconductor electrodes. A representative example for a sample grown at a B/S atomic ratio of 0.40 is shown in Figure 4.9. Despite some scatter of experimental points, we can conclude from the intercept that the flat-band potential is 1.0 V.
4.3 THE EFFECT OF SEMICONDUCTOR NATURE OF DIAMOND
89
1011C–2(μF–2cm4)
2,0
1,5
1,0
0,5
0,0 0.0
0.5 E (V)
1.0
Figure 4.10 Mott-Schottky plot for a sample grown at single crystal (111)-substrate. Growth conditions: CH4 concentration 0.12%, S/C and B/C ratios in gas phase 0.0024 and 0.1, respectively. The positive slope of the line points to the presence of donors; the donor concentration calculated by the slope is 1.4 × 1020 cm−3 . (Reprinted from Ref. 17.)
At still lower B/S ratios, the as-grown samples were n-type. The Mott-Schottky plots show a positive slope, which indicates the prevalence of donors. A representative MottSchottky plot for one of the samples grown from a feed gas with a B/S atomic ratio of 0.1 is shown in Figure 4.10. Its flat-band potential is close to 0.1 V. Qualitatively, the difference in the flat-band potentials corresponds to the difference in the conduction type [2]. It is important that all samples whose thermal EMF sign showed n-type conductance showed Mott-Schottky plots characteristic of an n-type semiconductor. And vice versa, all films with p-type conductance, as evidenced by the thermal EMF measurements, have Mott-Schottky plots characteristic of a p-type semiconductor. By and large, qualitatively, the electrochemical behavior of sulfur-containing diamond electrodes is typical of n-type semiconductors. In particular, this is true for some potentiodynamic curves showing the current rectification. In accord with the type of conductance, the cathodic current flows in forward direction, whereas the anodic current is blocking. It should be noted that the pronounced rectifying properties of semiconductor/electrolyte interfaces have been rarely observed with semiconductors, diamond in particular [23]. The very idea of co-doping diamond with boron and sulfur is based on the suggestion that a small boron atom can facilitate incorporation of a large sulfur atom into diamond [24,25]. Indeed, the quantum-chemical calculations of dopant energies in diamond allowed one to conclude that the BS pair in a substitutional site is energetically more stable than isolated substitutional B and S atoms in diamond [26]. In addition, boron can affect the concentration of sulfur adsorbed on diamond surfaces. An increase in this concentration during the diamond film growth should, in turn, facilitate sulfur incorporation into the diamond. Gas-phase equilibria calculations performed for the feed gas compositions used for the film deposition, showed [26,27] that the hydrogen-boron-sulfur compound (HBS) and BS2 concentrations are greater than the CH3 concentration; and the B/S concentration, although less than the CH3 concentration, is still greater than the concentration of monatomic sulfur vapor.
90
ELECTROCHEMISTRY OF DIAMOND
Calculations of the adsorption energy for these species at the diamond surface were performed. The results show that boron- and sulfur-containing species adsorb on diamond more strongly than those containing only sulfur. For example, the (H3 C)3 C–S and (H3 C)3 C–BS bond energies were estimated to be 280 and 480 kJ/mole, respectively. Therefore, the calculated sulfur concentration on the growing diamond surface increased in the presence of boron by up to two orders of magnitude. Thus, the very process of diamond co-doping with boron and sulfur can be thought of as a two-stage (adsorption of a dopant’s compound and the further diamond overgrowing thereover) process. The detailed microscopic nature of the donors in boron/sulfur-containing diamond still is not understood. Because both the thermoelectric power and impedance (Mott-Schottky plots) measurements sample the near-surface region of the semiconductor, the donor centers are spread over the diamond bulk rather than restricted to its surface. In addition, these centers can form narrow bands in the diamond bandgap [18]. These mid-gap bands are likely the source of the n-type conductivity. The knowledge of the flat-band potential allows one to draw an energy diagram of the diamond/solution interface (Figure 4.11 [27]). The diagram shows the relationship between the electrode potential scale and the physical scale of electron energies. The connection between these scales has been revealed by Gurevich and Pleskov [28] (see also [29]) as: eE = 4.44 + ε
(4.6)
where the electrode potential E is in volts (versus the standard hydrogen electrode, SHE), the electrochemical potential/electron energy ε is in electron volts, and e = −1 is the charge of an electron. The electrochemical potential ε refers to the electron at rest in a vacuum near the electrode surface (but outside the field of purely surface forces). Equation (4.6) permits one to relate the electrode potentials E used by electrochemists to the electron energies measured by other means. For example, shown in Figure 4.11 are the electrochemical potentials (“Fermi levels in solution”) of several common electrochemical redox couples in aqueous solution. Also shown in Figure 4.11 are the estimated positions of the band edges of diamond in contact with an aqueous solution determined by measuring the flat-band potential. The flat-band potential Efb gives the position of the Fermi level EF on the electrode potential scale. Hence, by knowing the potential EF one can obtain the energy εF of the Fermi level from Equation (4.6). For moderately doped p-type diamond (NA ∼ 1019 cm−3 ), the difference between the Fermi level and the valence band maximum εF − εVBM can be estimated as ∼0.1 eV. Thus, knowing the bandgap of diamond εG = εCBM − εVBM = 5.5 eV, one can fix the energy of the conduction band minimum εCBM . In Figure 4.11, the band edges of diamond in aqueous solution were placed using EF = Efb ≈ 1.0 eV(SHE)—see earlier Figure 4.9; this is a typical value for slightly oxidized diamond electrodes. From Equation (4.6), the energy of the Fermi level is given by εF = eEF − 4.44εV = −1.0 − 4.44 = −5.44 eV. The energy of the valence band maximum is approximately 0.1 eV lower than εF ; hence, εVBM ≈ −5.54 eV. Because the bandgap of diamond is 5.5 eV, this puts the conduction band minimum at εCBM ≈ −0.04 eV. Because, according to the Franck–Condon principle, one may conclude that the electron transitions occur between levels with equal energy, and better overlapping of the electrochemical potential levels in solution and energy levels in the valence band of diamond (hence, facilitation of electrode reactions) must take place for redox couples
4.3 THE EFFECT OF SEMICONDUCTOR NATURE OF DIAMOND
91
with more positive equilibrium potentials. Conversely, because the connection has been made between electrode potentials in aqueous solution and the electron energies in diamond, one can use well-defined electrochemical couples to probe the band structure of diamond [6]. Indeed, it was shown (for relatively lightly doped diamond electrodes) that the electrode irreversibility increased as the equilibrium potential of the couple became more negative (moved higher in the bandgap of diamond) for the following series: Fe(o-phenanthroline) Cl3 (1.08 V); ferrocene(1,1 )dimethanol (0.42 V); Ru(NH3 )6 Cl3 (–0.01 V); methyl viologen (–0.45 V). This effect was attributed [6] to a decreased number of available charge carriers in the diamond for couples with electron energies higher in the gap (more negative electrode potentials). In this connection, we now come back to the dependence of the reaction rate on the charge carrier concentration in the semiconductor diamond bulk (Figure 4.4). At an “ideal” semiconductor electrode, the potential drop in the Helmholtz layer at interfaces is small compared to the potential drop in the space-charge layer in the solid [2]. Therefore, energy band edges εCBM and εVBM (Figure 4.11) must act as if “pinned” at the interface, irrespectively of the doping level, hence, on the bulk-free carrier concentration (which is approximately inversely proportional to the diamond resistivity). Therefore, the surfacefree carrier concentration in a semiconductor electrode also does not depend on the doping. Equally, the electrochemical reaction rate on the semiconductor electrode, which is proportional to the surface concentration of the charge carriers participating in the reaction, must be doping-independent [2]. This is not the case with diamond electrodes (see Figure 4.4). From the experimental RF vs. ρ dependence we thus draw the conclusion that the potential drop in the Helmholtz layer at diamond electrodes is not small. More particularly, the potential distribution at the diamond/electrolyte solution interface in
Hydrogen Terminated Diamond
E ε [V][eV]
Solution –6
–4.44
Diamond in Aqueous Solution
εCEM = 1.3 eV 0
εCEM = –0.04eV ε = –1.39eV
Li+ + e– = Li
5.5 eV
–2 –2
MV2+ + e– = MV+ 2H+ + 2e– = H2 O
5.5 eV -4
O2 + 4H+ + 4e– = 2H2O -6
ε = –1.39eV ε = –4.44eV ε = –4.83 eV (pH=14) ε = –5.66 eV (pH=0)
εCEM = –4.2 eV εCEM= -5.54 eV
Figure 4.11 Energy diagram of the diamond/solution interface. The electrode potential (E) scale is referred to the standard hydrogen electrode, and the electrochemical potential ε is referred to as the electron at rest in a vacuum. The electrochemical potentials ε for the couple O2 + 4H+ + 4e− = 2H2 O at pH = 0 and pH = 14 are shown along with the band edges for diamond in contact with an aqueous solution. Also shown are the positions of the two couples: Li+ /Li (E ◦ = −3.045 V (SHE); ε = −1.39 eV) and methyl viologen (E ◦ = −0.45 V (SHE); ε = −3.99 eV). (Reprinted from Ref. 27.)
92
ELECTROCHEMISTRY OF DIAMOND
redox solutions depends on the diamond doping level—even more so for more heavily doped samples. And this is the reason why the semiconductor diamond behavior is far from “ideal.” (For example, no current rectification is observed on more heavily doped diamond electrodes; see Figure 4.2). Thus, we see that moderately doped diamond demonstrates almost ideal semiconductor behavior in inert background electrolytes, in particular, linear Mott-Schottky plots, which indicates band edge “pinning” at the semiconductor surface. In redox electrolytes, however, a metal-like behavior is observed, with the band edges “unpinned” at the surface. This phenomenon, although not yet fully understood, has been observed with numerous semiconductor electrodes (e.g., silicon, gallium arsenide, and others) [30]. It must be associated with chemical interactions between the semiconductor and the redox system, which results in a large and variable Helmholtz potential drop.
4.4 THE EFFECT OF CRYSTAL STRUCTURE ON THE ELECTROCHEMICAL BEHAVIOR OF DIAMOND 4.4.1
The Effect of Crystallographic Orientation of Crystal Faces
It is of interest to compare the electrochemical reaction kinetics at differently oriented faces of single crystal diamond electrodes. For this purpose, single-crystal films deposited onto appropriately oriented faces of undoped (that is, dielectric) single crystal diamond substrates should be used, rather than the polycrystalline films deposited onto nondiamond (metal or silicon) substrates. Here, the growing film replicates the substrate crystal structure (epitaxial growth), yielding a single-crystal film. Electrodes with (111), (110), and (100) faces were prepared in this manner [31,32]. All three crystals were grown simultaneously (at the same trimethyl borate concentration in the gas phase). The acceptor concentration was determined using differential capacitance measurements. Given the Mott-Schottky plots for the films in Figure 4.12, the acceptor concentration values calculated from slopes of the lines are given here (in cm−3 ): (100) (2–3) × 1019
(110) 1.3 × 1020
(111) (5–7) × 1020
Polycrystalline 5 × 1020
The polycrystalline thin-film electrode approaches the (111)-oriented epitaxial one in its electrode behavior; probably the crystallites constituting the polycrystalline film are mainly edged by (111) faces. In Figure 4.13a, b, we give cyclic voltammograms taken in [Ru(NH3 )6 ]2+/3+ and [Fe(CN)6 ]3−/4− redox solutions at differently oriented single-crystal thin-film electrodes. At the electrodes with (111) and (110) faces (as well as polycrystalline film studied for comparison) the curves have the shape characteristic of irreversible, yet reasonably fast electrode reactions. Particularly, the reaction is more reversible at a (111) than (110) face as follows from the difference of the anodic and cathodic current peak potentials Ep —that is, 450 and 555 mV, respectively. (Recall that this difference is a measure of the reaction reversibility [12].) By contrast, at a (100)-oriented electrode the curve has no current peaks at all; the process must be under kinetic, rather than diffusion, control. These results obtained at the (111) and (100) faces agree well with those of Kondo et al. [33] in that the reactions at the former face proceed more quickly than at the latter one.
4.4 THE EFFECT OF CRYSTAL STRUCTURE ON THE ELECTROCHEMICAL
93
C –2 x 10–12(F –2 cm4)
2.0 (100)
1.0
(111)
(110)
0.0 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
E (V) Figure 4.12 Mott-Schottky plots for diamond films orientated as (110), (100), and (111), in 2.5 M H2 SO4 solution. (Reprinted from Ref. 31.)
The difference in the electrochemical activity of different crystal faces manifests itself also in the transfer coefficients of the anodic and cathodic reactions α and β. At the (111) face, these quantities are 0.40 and 0.44, respectively; for the (110) face, the quantities are 0.2 and 0.23, respectively. The electrode behavior of the (111) face approaches metallic behavior; that of the (110) face is characteristic of a semiconductor. Thus, the electrode reactions in the [Fe(CN)6 ]3−/4− and [Ru(NH3 )6 ]2+/3+ redox couples experience retardation in the following sequence: (polycrystalline) ≈ (111) >(110) >(100). This is associated with the decrease, in the same sequence, of the doping level in diamond bounded by these crystal faces. Earlier we showed that the rate of electrochemical reactions at polycrystalline diamond electrodes is approximately proportional to the acceptor concentration in a boron-doped diamond (Figure 4.3). The difference in the boron concentration in single-crystal films is explained by well-known different intensities of boron incorporation from gas phase into different diamond crystal faces during the film growth. (In particular, the (111) face “absorbs” boron most intensely; the (100) one is less intense.) If, however, the (111)- and (100)-oriented films are compared at equal acceptor concentration, practically no difference in their electrochemical activity is observed; compare the corresponding cyclic voltammograms in Figures 4.13a and 4.13c. (To this purpose, another (111)-oriented film was deposited separately, the trimethyl borate concentration in the feed gas being chosen much lower than in the first growth process, in order to obtain as lightly doped film as the previously grown (100)-oriented film. The acceptor concentration in this film is 6 × 1018 cm−3 , which is not far from that in the (100) film.) Similar differences in the electrochemical reaction rates were observed [34,35] between different faces of a diamond single crystal grown by the more traditional method—namely, at high temperature and high pressure from a carbon solution in molten metal. The differential capacitance measurements revealed differences in the doping level of the so-called growth sectors (pyramids) inside the crystal (the sectors begin with seed-crystal and end as the faces of different hkl ).
94
ELECTROCHEMISTRY OF DIAMOND
(a) 0.008
(111)
j (Acm–2)
0.004
(110) (100)
0.000
–0.004
–0.008 –0.5
–1.0
0.5
–0.0
1.0
1.5
E (V) (b) 0.004
(111)
0.002 j (Acm–2)
(110) (100)
0.000
–0.002
–0.004
–0.8
–0.6
–0.4
0.2 E (V)
0.0
0.2
0.4
(c) j (mA cm–2)
0.16
0.08
–1
0
1
2 E (V)
–0.08
Figure 4.13 Cyclic voltammograms taken in (a) 0.01 M K3 Fe(CN)6 + 0.01 M K4 Fe(CN)6 + 2.5 M H2 SO4 and (b) 0.1 M NaCl + 0.005 M Ru(NH3 )6 Cl2 + 0.005 M Ru(NH3 )6 Cl3 solutions at singlecrystal (epitaxial) thin-film diamond electrodes with different crystallographic orientation of the faces (shown in the figure). All films were deposited under identical conditions (the same trimethyl borate concentration in gas phase). (c) Cyclic voltammogram taken at lightly doped (111)-electrode in 2.5 M H2 SO4 + 0.01 M K3 Fe(CN)6 + 0.01 M K4 Fe(CN)6 solution. Potential scan rate is 10 mV s−1 . (Reprinted from Ref. 31.)
4.4 THE EFFECT OF CRYSTAL STRUCTURE ON THE ELECTROCHEMICAL
111
95
111
111 100
100
111 Figure 4.14 Schematic presentation of the studied diamond single crystal grown at high temperature and high pressure.
For illustration, Figure 4.14 gives a scheme of a diamond single crystal bounded by (111) and (100) faces. By studying its differential capacitance and kinetics face by face (by insulating the rest of the surface), the electrode behavior of individual faces was revealed, as described earlier; however, here the data were collected from a unique single crystal, rather than from three different single-crystal (epitaxial) films. The observed differences in the electrochemical properties (the impedance and kinetic parameters) of differently oriented crystal faces can be explained mainly by the difference in the acceptor (boron) concentration in the growth sectors terminated by these faces, which in turn is caused by the different ability of the faces to incorporate boron during the synthesis. Evidently, finer effects, if any (e.g., the dependence of electrochemical properties of individual faces on their atomic density, etc.), can be elucidated by comparing faces with different hkl at a constant boron concentration in diamond; for this purpose, a set of electrodes should be appropriately prepared and examined. To summarize this section, at first glance, the “structural” aspect of the diamond electrode behavior actually reduces to a purely “semiconductor” one—that is, the dependence of the electrochemical activity on the doping level of diamond. 4.4.2
The Effect of Surface Morphology
Varying the micro- or nano-sized roughness is another method of structurally diversifying surfaces. We analyzed the effect of the “chaotic” microroughness on the electrochemical kinetics for the previously discussed case of comparable rates of interfacial charge transfer and mass transfer in solution. In Lim et al. [5] and in Pleskov et al. [36], the diamond surface roughness was controlled by varying the roughness of titanium substrates, onto which the diamond film was deposited. In particular, prior to the deposition, the substrates were annealed in air in order to change the crystal structure of the titanium. On removing the scale from titanium by sand blasting, the annealed plates were subjected to etching in hot 6 M HCl for different times. Then the surface topography, average roughness Ra and roughness factor Sef (the true-to-geometrical surface ratio) were measured using a White Light Interferometric Microscope. Shown in Figure 4.15a is an SEM photomicrograph of a roughened titanium substrate prepared in this manner.
96
ELECTROCHEMISTRY OF DIAMOND
(a)
(b)
Figure 4.15 SEM images of (a) roughened Ti substrate surface and (b) diamond film deposited onto the roughened substrate. Note the difference in scale bars: 5 μm and 1 μm, respectively. (Reprinted from Ref. 36.)
4.4 THE EFFECT OF CRYSTAL STRUCTURE ON THE ELECTROCHEMICAL
97
Upon depositing diamond films on the rough substrates (Figure 4.15b), the average roughness Ra and the roughness factor Sef changed but insignificantly. The measured electrochemical characteristics of the rough diamond electrodes are summarized in Table 4.2. We begin their analysis with the differential capacitance measured in background electrolyte. This procedure reveals the general trend in the electrode capacitance changes with varying substrate pretreatment. As follows from Table 4.2, in the sequence of the etched substrates the capacitance by and large follows the value of surface roughness. The same is true for the background current in supporting electrolyte. Concerning the kinetic data, we can conclude, first, that the transfer coefficients α and β are less than 0.5 and their sum α + β is less than 1 (which is characteristic of semiconductors [2], see earlier text). Second, the kinetic characteristics of diamond electrodes are affected by the microroughness of the diamond surface. With increasing roughness, the irreversible character of the electrochemical reaction is less pronounced, as we see from the quantity Ep . The electrochemical activity increases monotonically with increasing roughness, which follows from an increase in α + β. However formal this criterion may be, it still points to the apparent increase in the electrochemical activity, which may be explained by a decrease in the true current density in the series and, hence, gradually approaching the reversible mode of charge transfer. It is noteworthy that the difference in the true surface area did not affect the potentiodynamic curves of the oxidation and reduction reactions in the [Fe(CN)6 ]3−/4− redox system, because the measured quasi-steady-state current is controlled by diffusion, rather than kinetics. Indeed, under the quasi-steady-state conditions of the experiment, the diffusion front has already propagated far away from the electrode surface (to a distance well exceeding the microroughness size). Thus, it is the geometrical, rather than the true, electrode surface area that is the crucial issue in the evaluating of the reaction rates, unlike the kinetic parameter Ep (the anodic and cathodic current peak separation), as well as the background current, that are determined by the true current density; hence, it depends on the true surface area. Therefore, the roughening of the diamond surface gives no gain in the measured current; however, the roughening improves the charge transfer and facilitates the passing of the reaction from kinetic to diffusion control. This may be beneficial for electroanalytical applications, for example.
TABLE 4.2 The electrochemical parameters for roughened polycrystalline diamond electrodes. (Adapted from Ref. 5.) Roughness Seff
2.29 2.44 2.64
Background current in 2.5 M H2 SO4 measured at the potential scan rate of 50 mV s−1 (μA cm−2 )
Potential window width (V)
4.46 5.40 8.45
2.8 2.9 2.95
Transfer coefficients for [Fe(CN)6 ]3−/4− system α β α+β
0.34 0.37 0.38
0.37 0.39 0.39
0.71 0.76 0.77
Differential capacitance C in 2.5 M H2 SO4 per 1cm2 of geometrical surface (μF cm−2 )
Ep (V)
6.9 7.5 8.3
0.36 0.30 0.29
98
ELECTROCHEMISTRY OF DIAMOND
4.4.3 The Effect of the Diamond Grain Size (or the Film Thickness, or the sp2 -Carbon Impurity) We now discuss the effects introduced to the diamond electrode behavior by some peculiarities in the electrode structure. In particular, the electrochemical properties of polycrystalline films depend somewhat on the diamond grain size [37]. As any crystalline solid, diamond is not free from crystal defects that often take the form of nondiamond (sp 2 -) carbon. In particular, intercrystalline boundaries (containing disordered carbon) can be thought of as defects. The effect of the nondiamond carbon on the electrochemical behavior of diamond has been discussed in the literature; different methods of introducing sp 2 -carbon into diamond have been used (e.g., diamond graphitization under the action of high-energy ions [38–40]). Nondiamond carbon was deliberately imposed on a diamond film surface by mechanically rubbing it with a sample of highly oriented pyrolytic graphite. Next, the kinetics of electrochemical reactions in the quinone/hydroquinone and [Fe(CN)6 ]3−/4− redox solutions were studied [41,42]. In both cases the nondiamond carbon made the reactions more reversible, which suggested that the sp 2 -carbon forms active sites at diamond surfaces. Varying the film thickness is another method of the controlling the sp 2 -carbon impurity in polycrystalline CVD-diamond films. Here, the dependence of diamond crystallite size on the film thickness is used. In Figure 4.16, the cross-section of such a film is schematically presented. The crystallites start growing at the substrate surface that is preliminarily sowed with seed-nanocrystallites. Columnar crystallites are oriented at right angle to the substrate surface. Because their size increases gradually as the film grows (“stronger” crystallites suppress the growth of “weaker” ones), the intercrystalline boundary network is denser in the fine-grained layer attached to the substrate than near the film’s growth side. The growth side is faceted; the size of its constituent diamond crystallites l is assumed to be approximately proportional to the film full thickness d , which is demonstrated in Figure 4.17, where SEM photomicrographs of the surfaces of diamond films with different thickness are given [37]. The outcroppings of the intercrystalline boundaries at the surface may be thought of as “active sites.” It is clear that one may control the intercrystalline boundary network density, and hence the disordered carbon content near and at the electrode surfaces, by merely specifying the film growth time. Qualitatively, the amount of the disordered carbon content near and at the electrode surface can be estimated by Raman spectroscopy. Shown in Figure 4.18 are the Raman spectra for two films of different thickness. We see that in the spectrum of the thinner film, the “diamond” peak (at 1332 cm−1 ) is lower, whereas the sp 2 -carbon maximum is more pronounced than those of the thicker film. For the two films, the thickness differs by a factor of 8, while the ratio of the “diamond” maximum is only twice as high as the “nondiamond” maximum. Figure 4.18 clearly shows that the amount of nondiamond carbon in films increases with the thickness of the film. The crystal size at the films’ surfaces was estimated semiquantitatively by counting the number of crystals per unit length (see Table 4.3, second column). Cyclic voltammograms measured in an indifferent electrolyte solution at diamond film electrodes of different thickness are given in Figure 4.19. They are typical for borondoped diamond electrodes of rather high quality: The potential window is wide; even the thinnest (0.5 μm-thick) film evidently has no through-holes; and the background current in mid-window is as low as ∼10 μA cm−2 . We see that with decreasing the film
4.4 THE EFFECT OF CRYSTAL STRUCTURE ON THE ELECTROCHEMICAL
99
l
d
Substrate
Figure 4.16
Schematic presentation of cross-section of polycrystalline diamond film.
TABLE 4.3 Dependence of electrochemical properties of diamond film electrodes on their thickness. (Adapted from Ref. 37.) Thickness d (μm) 0.5 1.4 1.83 4.0
Crystallite average size (μm)
Transfer coefficients α
0.57 ± 0.07 0.75 ± 0.10 1.1 ± 0.03 2.02 ± 0.7
(0.8) 0.15 0.13 0.12
β
Background current JBG (μA cm−2 )
Differential capacitance C (μF cm−2 )
0.36 0.17 0.17 0.1
10 5 5 1
4.94 4.95 3.17 2.27
thickness, the potential of the onset of anodic chlorine evolution (the anodic boundary of the potential window) becomes ever less positive; both the background current and the differential capacitance in the mid-window region increase (Table 4.3). In other words, the overvoltage for the Cl2 (and O2 ) evolution is less for thinner films (and finer grains at their surfaces). It was mentioned earlier that the kinetics of gas evolution reactions is sensitive to the adsorption of their intermediates at the electrode surface. Evidently, the sp 2 -carbon forms additional adsorption sites on the surface, while crystalline diamond per se is a poor adsorbent. The effect of diamond film thickness on the electrochemical kinetics was further explored by measuring the transfer coefficients in the [Fe(CN)6 ]3−/4− model redox system; of the two previously described methods, the second one (impedance spectra taken at the equilibrium potential in K3 [Fe(CN)6 ] + K4 [Fe(CN)6 ] solutions) was applied. Equally, in the [Fe(CN)6 ]3−/4− redox system, with the decreasing of the film thickness d , the values of the transfer coefficients α and β increased from ∼0.15 (which is characteristic of semiconductor electrodes [28] and “poor conductors” in general) up to ∼0.35—that is, approaching the values characteristic of metal-like electrodes (Table 4.3). Another method of exploring the effect of grain size on the electrochemical properties is to compare, on a free-standing diamond film (that is, after the etching-off its substrate), the film’s growth side and its “nucleation” side. The former consists of rather perfect
100
ELECTROCHEMISTRY OF DIAMOND
(a)
(b)
Figure 4.17 SEM photomicrography of surfaces of diamond films with different thickness: (a) 2.6 μm, (b) 3.6 μm. (Reprinted from Ref. 37.)
4.4 THE EFFECT OF CRYSTAL STRUCTURE ON THE ELECTROCHEMICAL
101
160 140 Intensity (arb. units)
d = 0.5 μm 120 100 80 60 d = 4 μm 40 20 1000
1200
1400
1800
1600
Raman shift (cm−1) Figure 4.18 Raman spectra for two films of different thickness. (Reprinted from Ref. 37.)
2.5 μm j (A / cm–2) 3.7 μm d = 0.5 μm 0.5
–1.0
0.0
1.0
2.0 E (V)
Figure 4.19 Cyclic voltammograms measured in indifferent electrolyte solution (1 M KCl) at diamond film electrodes of different thickness (determination of the potential window). Potential scan rate is 50 mV/s. (Reprinted from Ref. 37.)
large crystallites; the latter has defective submicrocrystallites (compare Figure 4.16) and approaches, in its behavior, on the surfaces of very thin diamond films. Such a comparison showed that for thicker films, the difference in electrochemical behavior is quite striking: The electrochemical activity of the coarse-grained growth surface is rather poor, whereas the “nucleation” surface is noticeably more active. In particular, it demonstrates higher
102
ELECTROCHEMISTRY OF DIAMOND
differential capacitance and higher acceptor concentration (the crystal lattice defects may play the role of acceptors) [43,44]. Thus, leaving the question of the corrosion stability open (in all probability, sp 2 -carbon “impurity” impairs the corrosion resistance), we may conclude, even if qualitatively, that the nondiamond carbon “impurity” in crystalline diamond electrodes favors their electroactivity. Very close results were obtained by Bennett et al. [45] who introduced the sp 2 -bonded nondiamond carbon impurity through adjustment of the C/H source gas ratio used during the deposition of polycrystalline diamond films. To conclude this section, we suggest that the “crystallographic” (at first glance) effect of grain size on the CVD-diamond films’ electrochemical properties arises mainly from variations in the amount of sp 2 -carbon therein.
4.5 DIAMOND-BASED NANOSTRUCTURES AS ELECTRODE MATERIALS: VACUUM-ANNEALED UNDOPED POLYCRYSTALLINE DIAMOND By no means is doping the only way of imparting electrical conductance to dielectric diamond. For example, time and again it was attempted to convert dielectric single crystal diamond to conducting electrodes by implanting it with ions. This resulted in the formation of a conducting layer on the diamond surface; however, it appeared to be due to diamond graphitization under the action of the high-energy ions [38–40]. Strictly speaking, such an electrode with the graphite layer on top of diamond cannot be called “diamond electrode.” One more way to convert insulating diamond to a room-temperature-conducting material is the high-temperature annealing of undoped (dielectric) diamond films in a vacuum. The changes in the structure of these films, after annealing at temperatures up to 1900 K, were studied by optical and spectroscopic methods (see, e.g., Khomich et al. [46]). By using high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM) [47], the formation of amorphous carbon and even crystalline graphite layers up to ∼20 nm thick along the intercrystalline boundaries was detected (see Figure 4.20, [48]); islets of graphitelike material in defective areas inside the crystallites also emerged. The amount of the newly formed nondiamond phase depends on the annealing temperature and time, as well as the “quality” of the initial films: The more defective the film, the easier to partially graphitize it. The nondiamond phase is formed from disordered carbon constituting the intercrystalline boundaries, as well as the adjacent periphery of diamond crystallites proper. Noteworthy is that the annealing at temperatures exceeding 1700 K forms dislocations in the diamond crystallites near the intercrystalline boundaries. (These dislocations cause specific photoelectrochemical effects at the electrodes made of vacuum-annealed undoped polycrystalline diamond [48,49].) The formation of defects is due to mechanical stresses caused by the diamond-to-graphite transformation. The stresses emerge because of the large difference in the densities of diamond (3.51 g cm−3 ) and nondiamond carbon (∼2 g cm−3 ); hence, the nondiamond carbon requires nearly twice as much volume as the initial diamond. Because diamond is incompressible, high inner pressure arises. (After the annealing at ∼1970 K, the stress is so strong that the polycrystalline diamond disintegrates into separate crystallites [50]). This result is specific to the annealing of polycrystalline diamond. By contrast, when single crystal diamond is subjected to annealing, the defect concentration therein decreases, as is usual with single crystal semiconductors.
4.5 VACUUM-ANNEALED UNDOPED POLYCRYSTALLINE DIAMOND
103
Figure 4.20 High-resolution transmission electron photomicrograph showing intergranular boundary in an undoped polycrystalline diamond film annealed in vacuum at 1670 K. (Reprinted from Ref. 48.)
It is noteworthy that the nondiamond carbon of the anneal-transformed intercrystalline boundaries cannot be thought of as being identically equal to ordinary graphite or amorphous carbon because this material exists at high pressure in the diamond matrix. The pressure may alter its properties, in particular, the electrochemical properties. The amorphous carbon or graphite-like phase emerging at the intercrystalline boundaries form a continuous conducting network permeating the entire diamond film from its nucleation side to the growth side (compare Figure 4.16); the undoped dielectric diamond crystallites appear within the nondiamond matrix. Hence, the initial dielectric film is apparently converted to a (two-phase) conducting material. The outcroppings of the intercrystalline boundaries at the diamond film surfaces may play the role of active spots where the charge transfer across the electrode/electrolyte solution takes place. The electrochemical properties of this novel material were studied [51–53] using a 400 μm-thick diamond film grown on silicon substrate. The substrate was etched off in a nitric acid–hydrofluoric acid mixture, leaving a free-standing film. The specimens were annealed in a vacuum (10−5 Torr) furnace at temperatures from 1725 to 1925 K for one hour. The electrochemical studies were carried out at both sides of each sample—that is, the faceted growth surface (grain size 20–60 μm) and the smooth nucleation surface formed by submicron crystallites. After annealing at temperatures above 1825 K, the initially dielectric films became conducting, which allowed them to be used as electrodes. With a further increase in temperature to 1915 K, the effective resistivity of this two-phase material decreased from the initial value of 1011 –1012 Ohm cm to less than 0.1 Ohm cm; the differential capacitance increased from ∼10−3 up to ∼50 μF per 1 cm2 of geometrical surface. As to the potential window, this material is only slightly inferior to the boron-doped diamond. With an increase in the annealing temperature, all kinetic properties also change. For
104
ELECTROCHEMISTRY OF DIAMOND
(a)
β
0.4
0.2
0 1840
1860
1880
1900
1920
Tann (K) 0.5 (b)
i (mA / cm–2)
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0 1820
1840
1860
1880
1900
1920
Tann (K) Figure 4.21 Kinetic characteristics of vacuum-annealed polycrystalline films as functions of the annealing temperature: (a) transfer coefficient for [Fe(CN)6 ]4− anodic oxidation reaction; (b) cathodic peak height for [Fe(CN6 ]3− cathodic reduction reaction (◦ growth side, • nucleation side). (Reprinted from Ref. 52.)
example, the transfer coefficients in the [Fe(CN)6 ]3−/4− redox couple increased from ∼0.2 to 0.4–0.5 (see Figure 4.21a); the current per se also grows (Figure 4.21b). By and large, both sides of the film (the growth side and the nucleation side) behave similarly to each other. Their possible kinetic difference (caused by the difference in the density of the intercrystalline boundary network) must be leveled off because the reactions in the model redox couple [Fe(CN)6 ]3−/4− are fast and therefore are mainly diffusion-controlled. With increasing annealing temperature, the anodic and cathodic peak current potentials approach each other in the cyclic voltammograms (Figure 4.22a), eventually reaching the “theoretical” value of 59 mV for a one-electron reaction (Figure 4.22b) [12,13]; this points out that the electrode reaction becomes more reversible with an increase in the annealing temperature. The observed annealing-induced changes in the electrode characteristics are associated with the formation of a nondiamond phase along the intercrystalline boundaries. With
4.5 VACUUM-ANNEALED UNDOPED POLYCRYSTALLINE DIAMOND
(a)
105
I (μA) 100
50
0 0.3
0.5
0.7 E (V)
50
100 (b) 1.0
ΔEp (V)
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 1820
1840
1860
1880
1900
1920
Tann (K) Figure 4.22 (a) Cyclic voltammogram taken in 0.01 M K4 Fe(CN)6 + 0.01 M K3 Fe(CN)6 + 2.5 M H2 SO4 solution at growth side of a film annealed at 1910 K. Potential scan rate is 5 mV/s; (b) dependence of difference of the anodic and cathodic current peak potentials Ep on the annealing temperature (◦ growth side, • nucleation side). Dotted line shows the theoretical Ep value for a reversible reaction. (Reprinted from Ref. 52.)
increasing annealing temperature, the amount of this newly formed phase increases, which is the principal reason for the increase in the differential capacitance because the total area of the “active spots” at the insulating film surface increases. The conductivity of the nondiamond phase also grows. Indeed, the growth of the capacitance has always kept ahead of the growth of the ohmic resistance, as the impedance data showed [54]. These two factors in aggregate underlie the transition of the material from the category of “poor conductor” to that of a “metal-like” conductor. One can see that by and large the behavior of the vacuum-annealed undoped polycrystalline diamond resembles that of boron-doped diamond deliberately enriched with the sp 2 -carbon, described in the preceding section.
106
4.6
ELECTROCHEMISTRY OF DIAMOND
CONCLUSIONS
To conclude, we emphasize the common feature of the variety of diamond-based materials, in particular, microcrystalline diamond (either boron-doped or vacuum-annealed), nitrogenated ultrananocrystalline diamond [55,56], as well as sp 3 -diamond-like carbon doped with metals or nitrogen [57–59]. With increase of conductivity (whatever is its reason), the material properties (electrochemical, in particular) change from those of a “poor conductor” (semiconductor) to metal-like properties.
4.7
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The author is grateful to the colleagues who invaluably contributed to the studies overviewed in this chapter: Marina Krotova, Yulia Evstefeeva, Valentin Varnin, Irina Teremetskaya, John Angus, Sally Eaton, Viktor Ralchenko, and Roman Khmelnitskiy. I express my thanks to John Angus for valuable discussions and his stylistic improvement of the text. Financial support from Russian Foundation for Basic Research (project no. 10-03-00011) is acknowledged.
REFERENCES 1. Yu.V. Pleskov, A.Ya. Sakharova, M.D. Krotova, L.L. Bouilov, B.V. Spitsyn, J. Electroanal. Chem., 1987, 228 , 19. 2. Yu.V. Pleskov, Yu.Ya. Gurevich, Semiconductor Photoelectrochemistry, Consultants Bureau, New York, 1986. 3. Yu.V. Pleskov, Elektrokhimiya almaza (Electrochemistry of Diamond), Editorial URSS, Moscow, 2003. 4. D.M. Malta, J.A. von Windheim, H.A. Wynands, B.A. Fox, J. Appl. Phys. 1995, 77 , 1536. 5. P.Y. Lim, F.Y. Lin, H.C. Shih, V.G. Ralchenko, V.P. Varnin, Yu.V. Pleskov, S.F. Hsu, S.S. Chou, P.L. Hsu, Thin Solid Films 2008, 516 , 6125. 6. N. Vinokur, B. Miller, Y. Avyigal, R. Kalish, Electrochem. Solid State Lett . 1998, 1 , 265. 7. I. Yagi, H. Notsu, T. Kondo, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, J. Electroanal. Chem. 1999, 473 , 173. 8. H. Notsu, T. Fukazawa, T. Tatsumo, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, Electrochem. Solid State Lett . 2001, 4 , H1. 9. G.M. Swain, Adv. Mater. 1994, 6 , 388. 10. Q. Chen, M. Granger, T.E. Lister, G.M. Swain, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1997, 144 , 3806. 11. Yu.V. Pleskov, Yu.E. Evstefeeva, M.D. Krotova, P.Y. Lim, S.S. Chu, I.I. Vlasov, V.V. Kononenko, V.P. Varnin, I.G. Teremetskaya, H.C. Shih, Elektrokhimiya 2005, 41 , 387. 12. Z. Galus, Fundamentals of Electrochemical Analysis, Ellis Horwood, Chichester, 1976. 13. P. Delahay, New Instrumental Methods in Electrochemistry, Interscience Publishers, New York, 1954. 14. A.D. Modestov, Yu.E. Evstefeeva, Yu.V. Pleskov, V.M. Mazin, V.P. Varnin, I.G. Teremetskaya, J. Electroanal. Chem. 1997, 431 , 211. 15. A.D. Modestov, Yu.V. Pleskov, V.P. Varnin, I.G. Teremetskaya, Elektrokhimiya 1997, 33 , 60. 16. S.C. Eaton, A.B. Anderson, J.C. Angus, Yu.V. Pleskov, Yu.E. Evstefeeva, Electrochem. Solid State Lett . 2002, 5 , G65.
REFERENCES
107
17. S.C. Eaton, J.C. Angus, A.B. Anderson, Yu.E. Evstefeeva, Yu.V. Pleskov, Elektrokhimiya 2003, 39 , 170. 18. S.C. Eaton, A.B. Anderson, J.C. Angus, Y.E. Evstefeeva, Y.V. Pleskov, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2003, 12 , 1627. 19. I. Sakaguchi, M. Nishitani-Gamo, Y. Kukuchi, E. Yasu, H. Haneda, T. Suzuki, T. Ando, Phys. Rev. B 1999, 60 , 2139. 20. M. Nishitani-Gamo, C. Xiao, Y. Zhang, E. Yasu, Y. Kukuchi, I. Sakaguchi, T. Ando, Thin Solid Films 2001, 382 , 113. 21. R. Kalish, A. Resnick, C. Uzan-Saguy, C. Cytermann, App. Phys. Lett . 2000, 76 , 757. 22. Yu.V. Pleskov, Elektrokhimiya 2003, 39 , 1411. 23. Yu.V. Pleskov, in Advances in Electrochemical Science and Engineering ( R.C. Alkire, D.M. Kolb, eds.), vol. 8, Wiley—VCH, Weinheim, 2003, p. 209. 24. S.C. Eaton, A.B. Anderson, J.C. Angus, Y.E. Evstefeeva, Yu.V. Pleskov, Proceedings of the 6th Applied Diamond Conference/Second Frontier Carbon Technology Joint Conference, NASA/CP-2001-210948, 2001, p. 164. 25. S.C. Eaton, A.B. Anderson, J.C. Angus, Y.E. Evstefeeva, Y.V. Pleskov, in Diamond Materials VII ( G.M. Swain, T. Ando, J.C. Angus, W.D. Brown, J.L. Davidson, A. Gicquel, W.P. Kang, B.V. Spitsyn, eds.), PV 2001-25, The Electrochemical Society, Pennington, New Jersey, 2001. 26. T. Albu, A.B. Anderson, J.C. Angus, Diamond Materials VII ( G.M. Swain, T. Ando, J.C. Angus, W.D. Brown, J.L. Davidson, A. Gicquel, W.P. Kang, B.V. Spitsyn, eds.), PV 2001-25, The Electrochemical Society, Pennington, New Jersey, 2001. 27. J.C. Angus, S.C. Eaton, Yu.V. Pleskov, in Thin-Film Diamond II ( C.E. Nebel, J. Ristein, eds.), Academic Press, Amsterdam, 2004, p. 97. 28. Yu.Ya. Gurevich, Yu.V. Pleskov, Elektrokhimiya 1982, 18 , 1477. 29. A.J. Bard, R. Memming, B. Miller, Pure Appl. Chem. 1991, 63 , 569. 30. Yu.V. Pleskov, Yu.Ya. Gurevich, in Modern Aspects of Electrochemistry ( B.E. Conway, R.E. White, J. O’M. Bockris, eds.), vol. 16, Plenum Press, New York, 1985, p. 189. 31. Yu.V. Pleskov, Yu.E. Evstefeeva, V.P. Varnin, I.G. Teremetskaya, Elektrokhimiya, 2005, 41 , 1023. 32. Yu.V. Pleskov, Yu.E. Evstefeeva, M.D. Krotova, V.P. Varnin, I.G. Teremetskaya, J. Electroanal. Chem. 2006, 595 , 168. 33. T. Kondo, Y. Einaga, B.V. Sarada, T.N. Rao, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, J. Electrochem. Soc. 2002, 149 , E179. 34. Yu.V. Pleskov, Yu.E. Evstefeeva, M.D. Krotova, V.Ya. Mishuk, V.A. Laptev, Yu.N. Palyanov, Yu.M. Borzdov, J. Electrochem. Soc. 2002, 149 , E260. 35. Yu.V. Pleskov, Yu.E. Evstefeeva, M.D. Krotova, V.Ya. Mishuk, V.A. Laptev, Yu.N. Palyanov, Yu.M. Borzdov, Elektrokhimiya 2002, 38 , 698. 36. Yu.V. Pleskov, Yu.E. Evstefeeva, M.D. Krotova, P.Y. Lim, H.C. Shih, V.P. Varnin, I.G. Teremetskaya, I.I. Vlasov, V.G. Ralchenko, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2005, 35 , 857. 37. Yu.V. Pleskov, M.D. Krotova, V.P. Varnin, I.G. Teremetskaya, Elektrokhimiya 2010, 46 , 340. 38. M. Iwaki, S. Sato, K. Takahashi, H. Sakairi, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. Phys. Res. 1982, 209–210 , 1129. 39. B. Miller, R. Kalish, L.C. Feldman, A. Katz, N. Moriya, K. Short, A.E. White, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1994, 141 , L41. 40. C. Reuben, E. Galun, H. Cohen, R. Tenne, R. Kalish, Y. Muraki, K. Hashimoto, A. Fujishima, J.F. Butler, C. Levy-Clement, J. Electroanal. Chem. 1995, 396 , 233. 41. I. Duo, A. Fujishima, C. Comninellis, Electrochim. Commun. 2003, 5 695. 42. E. Mah´e, D. Devilliers, C. Comninellis, Electrochim. Acta 2005, 50 , 2263.
108
ELECTROCHEMISTRY OF DIAMOND
43. V.G. Ralchenko, Yu.V. Pleskov, V.I. Polyakov, A.V. Khomich, Yu.E. Evstefeeva, M.D. Krotova, E.N. Loubnin, I.I. Vlasov, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2003, 12 , 531. 44. Yu.V. Pleskov, Yu.E. Evstefeeva, M.D. Krotova, V.G. Ralchenko, I.I. Vlasov, E.N. Loubnin, A.V. Khomich, J. Appl. Electrochim. 2003, 33 , 909. 45. J.A. Bennett, J. Wang, Y. Show, G.M. Swain, J. Electrochim. Soc., 2004, 151 , E306. 46. A.V. Khomich, V.G. Ralchenko, A.V. Vlasov, R.A. Khmelnitskiy, I.I. Vlasov, V.I. Konov, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2001, 10 , 546. 47. L. Nistor, V. Ralchenko, I. Vlasov, A. Khomich, R. Khmelnitskii, P. Potapov, J. Van Landuyt, Phys. Stat. Sol. A 2001, 186 , 207. 48. Yu.V. Pleskov, M.D. Krotova, V. Ralchenko, A. Khomich, R. Khmelnitskii, Elektrokhimiya, 2005, 41 , 343. 49. Yu.V. Pleskov, M.D. Krotova, V.V. Elkin, V.G. Ralchenko, A.V. Khomich, R.A. Khmelnitskiy, Electrochim. Acta 2005, 50 , 1149. 50. V. Ralchenko, L. Nistor, E. Pleuler, A. Khomich, I. Vlasov, R. Khmelnitskii, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2003, 12 , 1964. 51. Yu.V. Pleskov, M.D. Krotova, V. Ralchenko, A. Khomich, R. Khmelnitskii, Elektrokhimiya 2003, 39 , 886. 52. Yu.V. Pleskov, M.D. Krotova, V.G. Ralchenko, A.V. Khomich, R.A. Khmelnitskiy, Electrochim. Acta 2003, 49 , 41. 53. Yu.V. Pleskov, M.D. Krotova, V.G. Ralchenko, A.V. Khomich, R.A. Khmelnitskiy, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2003, 12 , 1957. 54. V.V. Elkin, M.D. Krotova, Yu.V. Pleskov, Elektrokhimiya 2003, 39 , 1053. 55. Yu.V. Pleskov, M.D. Krotova, V.V. Elkin, V.G. Ralchenko, A.V. Saveliev, S.M. Pimenov, P.-Y. Lim, Electrochim. Acta 2007, 52 , 5470. 56. Yu.V. Pleskov, M.D. Krotova, V.G. Ralchenko, A.V. Saveliev, Elektrokhimiya 2007, 43 , 868. 57. Yu.V. Pleskov, Yu.E. Evstefeeva, A.M. Baranov, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2002, 11 , 1518. 58. Yu.E. Evstefeeva, Yu.V. Pleskov, A.M. Kutsay, I. Bello, Elektrokhimiya 2005, 41 , 866. 59. Yu.V. Pleskov, M.D. Krotova, M.L. Shupegin, A.D. Bozhko, V.G. Ralchenko, Elektrokhimiya 2006, 42 , 1002.
5 Applications of Polycrystalline and Modified Functional Diamond Electrodes Yasuaki Einaga and Akira Fujishima
5.1
INTRODUCTION
Conductive boron-doped diamond (BDD) is an alternative to traditional carbon electrodes that provides superior chemical and dimensional stability, low background currents, and a very wide potential window of water stability. Recently, electrochemical applications using BDD electrodes are attracting much attention in many fields, not only in electrochemistry but also in fields such as functional materials science, analytical chemistry, environmental science, biomedical or biological science, and so on [1–3]. In fact, waste water treatment systems and ozone or fluorine generation systems that use BDD electrodes have already become commercially available, and the number of publications involving BDD electrochemistry research is drastically increasing year by year (see Figure 5.1). In this chapter, several examples of electro-analytical applications using polycrystalline BDD electrodes will be shown. Furthermore, some examples using modified functional BDD electrodes such as self-standing perforated BDD with regular patterns of holes, ion-implanted BDD, BDD microelectrodes, and BDD nanograss arrays (whisker BDD),
Synthetic Diamond Films: Preparation, Electrochemistry, Characterization, and Applications, First Edition. Edited by Enric Brillas and Carlos Alberto Mart´ınez-Huitle. © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Published 2011 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
109
110
APPLICATIONS OF POLYCRYSTALLINE AND MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL DIAMOND ELECTRODES
180
160
140
Publications
120
100
80
60
40
0
1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
20
Year Figure 5.1 Yearly research publications on diamond electrochemistry.
which have achieved ozone generation with high efficiency, and the highly sensitive detection of arsenic, dopamine, and glucose, will be introduced.
5.2
PREPARATION OF BDD ELECTRODES
The BDD electrodes were deposited on Si (100) wafers in a microwave plasma-assisted chemical vapor deposition system (ASTeX Corp.) [4]. The vapor of liquid mixtures of acetone and trimethoxyborane (B(OCH3 )3 ) as the source gases were introduced into the reactor by bubbling with hydrogen gas. The liquid mixtures were prepared with appropriate mixing ratios based on Raoult’s law so that the boron/carbon (B/C) ratios in the reactor were controlled. The typical grain size of the resulting BDD thin films was up to ∼5 μm, with a thickness of ∼20 μm for a deposition time of 7 h using 5 kW of plasma power.
5.4 APPLICATIONS IN ELECTROCHEMICAL ANALYSIS USING POLYCRYSTALLINE BDD ELECTRODES
111
5.3 ELECTROCHEMICAL PROPERTIES OF BDD AS ELECTRODE MATERIALS Boron-douped diamond electrodes have an extremely wide potential window of water stability, low background currents (see Figure 5.2), chemical and mechanical stability, resistance to fouling, lack of a surface oxide film, and controllable surface termination. These characteristics have led to the application of BDD electrodes in electrochemical sensing, in electroanalysis, in electrochemical synthesis, and for the anodic destruction of organic wastes. BDD also can be used as a transparent, conducting medium for analytical chemistry and photoelectrochemical applications.
5.4 APPLICATIONS IN ELECTROCHEMICAL ANALYSIS USING POLYCRYSTALLINE BDD ELECTRODES 5.4.1
Detection of Free Chlorine
Chlorine is a strong oxidizing agent and is the conventional chemical used for the continuous disinfection of drinking water, water in swimming pools, and wastewater [6]. The ability of chlorine to disinfect depends on its concentration. If the concentration is too small, the disinfectant effect is insufficient; however, too much chlorine is wasteful and creates other dangerous side products such as trihalomethanes. The World Health Organization drinking water standard states that 2–3 mg L−1 chlorine gives satisfactory disinfection and residual concentration, where the maximum amount of chlorine allowed is 5 mg L−1 . Therefore, the exact determination and continuous on-line monitoring of residual water disinfectant is a strict requirement. The general detection methods for free chlorine include the colorimetric method, the amperometric titration method, and iodometry. However, these methods are unsuitable
Figure 5.2 Electrochemical properties of various electrodes.
112
APPLICATIONS OF POLYCRYSTALLINE AND MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL DIAMOND ELECTRODES
for continuous online monitoring because they each have a number of disadvantages, such as the requirement for many types of reagents that may produce greater toxicity, high detection limits, difficulty of operation, and so on. Electroanalytical methods require fewer reagents, promote easy handling, and can provide high sensitivity as well as long-term response stability. The reduction of HClO and ClO− has mainly been reported for the electrochemical determination of free chlorine. However, there are several problems that should be considered when using this method, such as interference, due to a similar reduction potential to that of dissolved oxygen, metal deposition from the sample solution at the electrode, and the effect of trace metal ions. On the other hand, there have been few investigations on quantitative determination based on the anodic reaction of free chlorine, which should be superior, because it is not subject to the preceding problems. In the present study, we focused on the quantitative determination and the possibility of continuous online monitoring of free chlorine oxidation using BDD electrodes [5]. Cyclic voltammograms (CVs) for various concentrations of NaClO in a 0.1 M NaClO4 obtained at a scan rate of 100 mV s−1 using an as-deposited (ad) BDD electrode are shown in Figure 5.3. A well-defined irreversible oxidation peak was observed at a potential of ca. 1.4 V (vs. Ag/AgCl). This is the typical advantage of wide potential window, because the observation of oxidation current at such high potential is impossible in the case of other conventional electrodes due to the narrow potential window. The inset in Figure 5.3 shows a plot of the oxidation peak current versus the free chlorine concentration. A linear calibration curve (R 2 = 0.999) obtained in the concentration range of 20–100 mg Cl L−1 , indicating that determination of free chlorine can be performed at ad-BDD electrodes. A slope of 0.744 μA cm−2 mg−1 L shows the sensitivity. This sensitivity was three to four times higher in comparison with those at conventional electrodes, suggesting the superiority of using ad-BDD for chlorine oxidation. A background current of 3 μA cm−2 was obtained, which is very small in comparison with that at a Pt electrode under the same conditions (115 μA cm−2 ). It is known that BDD electrodes have extremely small background currents due to the inert surface. The small background current can give rise to a very low detection limit due to
Current density (µA cm–2)
90 80 70
y = 0.744x – 2.767 R 2 = 0.9981
60 40
50
20 30
0
20
40
60
80
100
CIO– Concentration(mg Cl l–1)
10
–10
0
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
Potential (V) vs. Ag/AgCl Figure 5.3 Cyclic voltammograms of a 0.1 M NaClO4 solution in the presence of various concentrations of free chlorine (2–100 mg Cl L−1 ) at as-deposited diamond electrodes. Linear calibration plots are shown in the inset. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 5.)
5.4 APPLICATIONS IN ELECTROCHEMICAL ANALYSIS USING POLYCRYSTALLINE BDD ELECTRODES
113
the decrease in the noise. Furthermore, excellent stability was also shown for repetitive voltammograms. 5.4.2
Detection of Oxalic Acid
Oxalic acid, which exists naturally in many plants (spinach, ginger, chocolate, etc.), combines with Ca, Fe, Na, Mg, or K to form poorly soluble oxalate salts. High levels in the diet lead to irritation of the digestive system, and particularly of the stomach and kidneys. It is also known to contribute to the formation of kidney stones. The urinary level of oxalic acid has long been recognized as an important indicator for the diagnosis of renal stone formation. Cyclic voltammetry and flow injection analysis with amperometric detection were used to study the electrochemical reaction [7]. In this case also, the oxidation current was observed at a high potential (about 1.35 V vs. Ag/AgCl), which cannot be observed with conventional electrodes. A good linear response was observed for the concentration range from 50 nM to 10 μM, with an estimated detection limit of about 0.5 nM (S/N = 3). 5.4.3
Proteins (Including Cancer Markers)
The detection of proteins, including cancer markers, has been attracting increasing attention. The direct, unmediated electron transfer between proteins and electrodes has been studied for many different combinations of proteins and electrode surfaces in recent years. These studies have received much attention because of the requirement in understanding the fundamental reactions of biomolecules, from the viewpoint of developing a direct detection method of the protein at the electrode, or in order to develop new materials by combinations between the protein and the electrode surface. In general, direct electrochemical oxidation of proteins is based on the electro-oxidation of metal ions or electro-active amino acids in the protein structure [8]. The proteins studied in this manner range from small, water-soluble redox proteins, to large, sometimes multi-redox enzyme-centered proteins. However, it can be said that the cytochromes, the blue-copper proteins, and the iron-sulfur proteins are as familiar to electrochemical analysts as they are to biochemists. In contrast, the electrochemical detection of the larger nonmetalated proteins (e.g., albumin) is reported much less frequently. The limited number of reports is not only due to the complexity of the protein structure but also to the strong adsorption of the proteins on the electrode surface, which can lead to signal depression and result in lack of predictability and reproducibility. On the other hand, other superior properties of BDD hydrogen-terminated diamond films are that they are well faceted, hydrophobic, and have a low surface energy. Therefore, it is expected that even proteins can be directly detected electrochemically using BDD because of the surface inertness. Figure 5.4a (upper curve) shows the CV of 300 mg dl−1 BSA in 0.1 M PBS pH 10 at the BDD electrode. Interestingly, the CV included three peaks. It is known that BSA contains 20 types of amino acids, including cystein, tryptophan, and tyrosine, as well as 17 disulfide bonds that are known to be electro-active at BDD electrodes. In order to confirm the active sites of BSA at the BDD electrode, comparison was made between the CVs of BSA and several amino acids (Figure 5.4a [lower curves]). The oxidation peaks can be observed separately at different potentials at pH 10. Thus, it is suggested
114
APPLICATIONS OF POLYCRYSTALLINE AND MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL DIAMOND ELECTRODES
(a) BSA
Current density
2 mA/cm2
tyrosine
tryptophan cysteine 20 mA/cm2
0.2
0.0
0.4
0.6 0.8 Potential (V) vs Ag/AgCl
1.0
1.2
(b) 40
50
3000
30 20
2100
10
40 Current (nA)
0 0
500
30
1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 Concentration/mg dl
1500 1200
900
20
150
600
300
75 mg/dl 10
0 0
10
20
30
40
50
Time (min) Figure 5.4 (a) Cyclic voltammograms of 300 mg dl−1 BSA (up) and 1 mM amino acids (bottom) in 0.1 M phosphate buffer solution at diamond electrodes. (b) Signal responses of BSA in various concentrations by using flow injection analysis with a diamond electrode as the detector in the concentration range 75–3000 mg dl−1 . The applied potential was 0.8 V versus Ag/AgCl. The mobile phase was a 0.1 M phosphate buffer solution at pH 7.4. The flow rate was 1 mL/min. Inset shows linear dynamic concentration of BSA. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 9.)
that the oxidation peaks of BSA correspond to the oxidation peaks of cystein, tyrosine, and tryptophan. Further, flow injection analysis (FIA) was used to minimize the adsorbing effects of the protein and to obtain calibration curves (see Figure 5.4b). The peak current shows good linearity in the concentration range of 5–3000 mg dl−1 of BSA, with an experimental detection limit of 5 mg dl−1 , as shown in the linear dynamic calibration
115
5.4 APPLICATIONS IN ELECTROCHEMICAL ANALYSIS USING POLYCRYSTALLINE BDD ELECTRODES
in the inset of Figure 5.4b. The stability of the current response is also shown for 5 injections of each concentration in the concentration range of 5–3000 mg dl−1 . Reproducibility was also confirmed. As an example of cancer-maker detection, the possibility of using H-terminated BDD for the direct electrochemical detection of other proteins was also investigated for immunosuppressive acidic protein (IAP). The amperometric FIA responses of IAP showed the possibility of the direct electrochemical detection. A linear detection range of 200–800 μg ml−1 was observed. Since the normal human serum IAP level is ∼355 μg ml−1 , the detectable range should be suitable for cancer screening [9]. Then, as one of the applications of protein detection, the detection of conformational changes in large, nonmetallo proteins such as bovine serum albumin, using FIA coupled with hydrogen-terminated BDD electrodes, was performed [10]. Briefly, the oxidation current was used as a signal reporter in the monitoring of urea-induced BSA denaturation. In the denatured state at high urea concentrations, the electrochemical signal increased, and the amperometric responses for the oxidation potential at 1300 mV were consistent with the results of conventional methods of denaturation monitoring using fluorescence spectroscopy. The oxidation involved at least five redox-active species (cysteine, tryptophan, tyrosine, methionine, and disulfide bonds). Furthermore, the method also showed high sensitivity for the quantitative analysis of proteins. A linear dynamic range for concentrations 50–400 μg ml−1 (r 2 = 0.977), with a lower detection limit (LOD) of 190 ng ml−1 , was achieved for BSA. Furthermore, in order to realize the selectivity of the protein detection, surface modification can be useful. As one example, a poly-o-ABA-modified BDD was developed for a protein immunosensor (see Figure 5.5) [11]. The amperometric sensing of mouse IgG (MIgG) was selected as the model at the poly-o-ABA-modified BDD to compare to the poly-o-ABA-modified glassy carbon (GC) at the same condition. An anti-mouse IgG from goat (GaMIgG) was covalently immobilized at a poly-o-ABA-modified BDD electrode, which used a sandwich-type alkaline phosphatase (ALP) catalyzing amperometric
AAP ALP ALP
ALP ALP
AA
AARe
O
NH
C
O
C
NH O
NH
C
O
NH
C
AAP
C
NH O
AAOx
NH
C
2e–
BDD
BDD
ALP
ALP conjugated
GaMIgG
GaMIgG
MIgG
Figure 5.5 Schematic of the amperometric enzyme immunosensor based on the poly-o-ABA modified BDD electrode. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 11.)
116
APPLICATIONS OF POLYCRYSTALLINE AND MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL DIAMOND ELECTRODES
immunoassay with 2-phospho-L-ascorbic acid (AAP) as a substrate. The ALP enzyme conjugated at the immunosensor can generate the electro-active ascorbic acid (AA), which can be determined by amperometric detection. The signal was found to be proportional to the quantity of MIgG. The limit of detection (LOD) of 0.30 ng mL−1 (3SD) and 3.50 ng mL−1 (3SD) for MIgG at BDD and GC electrodes was obtained. It also was found that the dynamic range of three orders of magnitude (1–1000 ng mL−1 ) was obtained at BDD, while at GC, the dynamic range was narrower (10–500 ng mL−1 ). The method was applied to a real mouse serum sample that contained MIgG.
5.5
MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL BDD ELECTRODES
In order to improve the electrochemical properties, several modified types of BDD electrodes were also fabricated. 5.5.1 Production of High-Concentration Ozone-Water Using Free-Standing Perforated Diamond Ozone dissolved in water is one of the most powerful chemicals used for disinfection and sterilization. The effectiveness is based on the generation of reactive oxygen species by reactions between ozone and water molecules as well as the strong oxidative ability of ozone. Furthermore, ozone-water is very environmentally friendly because the residual ozone spontaneously decomposes to oxygen, rendering postwashing unnecessary. Due to these advantages, ozone-water has been employed for hand washing in hospitals and welfare institutions, vegetable washing in food factories and kitchens, and so on. Water electrolysis with a solid polymer electrolyte (SPE) cell, or a zero-gap (ZG) electrolytic cell, is a unique technique suitable for ozone-water production. The cell is divided into two compartments by a proton exchange membrane, to which a porous anode and a porous cathode are firmly attached. The system is user-friendly, in that an electrolyte is unnecessary for electrochemical ozone production (EOP). The anode and cathode compartments are filled with pure water; water electrolysis at the anode evolves oxygen and ozone; protons electrogenerated at the porous anode move thorough the membrane toward the porous cathode; and the hydrogen evolution reaction occurs at the cathode surface. When pure water, or tap water, is continuously supplied to the electrolytic cell, electrolyte-free ozone-water can be continuously produced. EOP systems available in Japan have employed a porous lead dioxide (PbO2 ) plate or a platinum (Pt) mesh as an anode. Although they are effective in producing ozone gas or ozone-water, they have the drawbacks of being low in durability, costly, and environmentally harmful. Conductive diamond has attracted much attention as a promising electrode material for EOP because of the large overpotential for the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) as well as the superior chemical and dimensional stability. Here, direct electrochemical ozone-water production (EOWP) was performed with a ZG cell made of an acrylic frame, which included a porous anode, a porous cathode, and a proton exchange membrane, as shown in Figure 5.6a [12]. As the anode, free-standing BDD electrodes with various patterns of perforated holes were used (summarized in the table above Figure 5.7), a photograph of a representative free-standing perforated BDD electrode, D10HN410, on which 410 holes 1 mm in diameter were perforated, is shown in Figure 5.6b). The perfectly circular holes with sheer edges were formed by means
5.5 MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL BDD ELECTRODES
Hydrogen water
(a)
117
Ozone water
Porous cathode
Porous anode
Membrane
Water
Water
(b)
Figure 5.6 (a) Schematic of a ZG electrolytic cell. (b) Photograph of the representative free-standing perforated BDD electrode (D10HN410). (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 12.)
of laser beam machining. A Pt mesh was used as the cathode, and they were firmly pressed onto the membrane (Nafion film). A Pt mesh was also adopted as the anode for comparison purposes. At the porous anode, the oxygen evolution and ozone generation reactions occurred, as follows: Hydrogen ions generated at the anode are reduced at the cathode to produce hydrogenated water. Pure water of about 12◦ C with electrical conductivity of less than 1 (μS cm−1 ) was continuously supplied into the anodic compartment at a flow rate of 2.0 L min−1 (120 L h−1 ). Cathodic water was pure water cycled at a flow
118
APPLICATIONS OF POLYCRYSTALLINE AND MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL DIAMOND ELECTRODES
ID2 D10HN166 D10HN288 D10HN312 D10HN410 D10HN144 D10HN196
Thickness (mm)
Total edge length (cm)b
0.77 0.92 0.3,0.54,0.90 0.54,0.94 0.82 0.90
65.78 103.48 111.01 141.80 80.86 105.56
Diameter Hole number (mm) 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.5 1.5
166 288 312 410 144 196
Ucell (V)
30
20
10
D10HN196 : D10HN288 :
0 50
D10HN312 : D10HN410 : Pt mesh :
ε03(%)
40 30 20 10 0 10
c02(mg L–1)
8 6 4 2 0
0
2
4
6
8
10
/app (A) Figure 5.7 Plots of (a) ozone concentration, (b) current efficiency, and (c) cell voltage with respect to applied current. Ozone-water was produced by electrolysis of pure water with free-standing perforated BDD electrodes and a Pt mesh electrode. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 13.)
rate of 0.1 L min−1 . Electrogenerated hydrogen was spontaneously released as gas. Water electrolysis was performed under galvanostatic conditions. A ZG cell newly constructed was pre-electrolyzed at 10 A for 2–5 h to normalize the cell conditions. Then, ozone concentration and cell voltage were recorded at a steady state attained after the application of a constant current to the cell. Ozone-water produced at the anodic compartment drained into a reservoir and was then introduced into an ozone meter by a pump. This prevented gas interfusion, thereby providing more reliable data compared with that reported previously [13]. Ozone-water concentration was measured with a dissolved ozone meter based on the UV absorption method.
5.5 MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL BDD ELECTRODES
119
Figure 5.7 shows (a) ozone concentration, (b) current efficiency, and (c) cell voltage for EOWP as a function of applied current. The perforated free-standing BDD electrodes with holes 1 mm in diameter exhibited superior performance for EOWP compared to the Pt mesh electrode. Figure 5.7a demonstrates that, accompanied with an increase in the applied current at the BDD electrodes, ozone-water is gradually concentrated to a maximum of about 9 mg L−1 at 10 A. Although applying higher current was not performed due to limitations of the power source, we believe that more concentrated ozone-water could be available. In contrast, at the Pt mesh electrode, the ozone concentration was much lower, less than 0.5 mg L−1 maximum. The low catalytic activity is attributed to the lower overpotential toward OER and the absence of anions in pure water, which could otherwise adsorb on the Pt surface and inhibit the OER process [13]. The current efficiency reached a maximum at 3–4 A, as shown in Figure 5.7b. This tendency is rather different from that reported in the previous research, in which the current efficiency monotonically dropped depending on applied current [13]. The difference is partly attributed to the employment of a flow system in which electrolyzed ozone-water was directly introduced into the ozone meter. The direct injection was accompanied by small bubbles of ozone and oxygen gases, which caused UV light scattering, resulting in an overestimation of the ozone-water concentration. In the present system, however, ozone-water was drained into a reservoir and then introduced into the ozone meter by a pump, which inhibited gas interfusion. Because excess gaseous ozone was dispersed at the reservoir, the current efficiency was probably underestimated. However, in view of the estimation of the current efficiency for ozone-water production, we believe that the present results are more realistic. In summary, EOWP with free-standing perforated BDD electrodes was proven to be dependent on the number of holes, hole diameter, and electrode thickness. In particular, increasing the number of holes per unit area is the most effective method for improving the current efficiency. The electrode configuration optimal for EOWP was D10HN410, which was 0.54 mm in thickness and offered a current efficiency of 47% under moderate conditions, the highest thus far. The advantage of using free-standing diamond plates is obvious. The entire electrode surface retains an ideal diamond crystalline structure, and thus durability is considerably superior under high current conditions. The application of a diamond electrode formed on a mesh or a porous substrate is another option and has some merits, including low cost and high mechanical strength. However, diamond deposition onto complex substrates is a quite difficult task. Thinner areas of the diamond film tend to contain pinholes, which lead to the erosion of the substrate after long-term usage under high current conditions. Accordingly, we believe that the present system is the most appropriate for EOWP in terms of high current efficiency as well as high durability. 5.5.2 5.5.2.1
Modified Functional BDD Electrodes for Electrochemical Analysis Ion-Implanted BDD Electrodes
Detection of Arsenic Using Ir-implanted BDD Electrodes Many arsenic compounds are known to be toxic. Their direct exposure to especially humans and animals and the side effects to the ecosystem remain international problems. Arsenic exists in many different chemical forms in nature; particularly, in groundwater it is found almost exclusively as arsenite (AsO2 − , As3+ ) and arsenate (HAsO4 2− , As5+ ). Arsenite can
120
APPLICATIONS OF POLYCRYSTALLINE AND MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL DIAMOND ELECTRODES
be converted to arsenate under oxidizing conditions. However, the conversion in either direction is difficult. The reduced species can be found in both oxidized environments and vice versa. Typical targets of arsenic toxicity are the respiratory system, the circulatory system, and the reproductive system. The toxicity of arsenic is greatly dependent on the arsenite level, since arsenite is ∼50 times more toxic than arsenate due to its reactions with enzymes in human metabolism. The higher mobility of arsenite in groundwater also accentuates the potential danger compared to arsenate. In addition, arsenite and arsenate are more toxic than organic arsenic. According to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the World Health Organziation arsenic guidelines, the maximum contaminant level of arsenic in community water systems is 10 μg/L−1 . However, arsenic compounds cannot be detected directly by BDD, because BDD does not have sufficient electrochemical catalytic activity due to the surface inertness. On the other hand, metal electrodes such as iridium have electrochemical catalytic properties, even though the sensitivities are not good due to the large background currents [14]. Modification of BDD electrodes with redox-active particle/compounds offers significant advantages in the design and development of electrochemical sensors. The redox-active sites facilitate electron transfer between the substrate electrode and analytes, with a significant reduction in activation overpotential. A wide variety of particles or compounds have been used as electron transfer mediators via modification of BDD surfaces. Preparation of modified diamond by using chemical precipitation and the electrochemical deposition method have been reported. Although electrochemical deposition is a convenient method to prepare metal deposits on substrates, it is not suitable for metal deposition at BDD, because the nonuniform doping of boron in diamond crystals causes the surface conductivity to be inhomogeneous. Furthermore, the stability of the deposited metal is not good. Since its inception, ion implantation has been considered as the most feasible method to change the electrical properties of a diamond substrate. The method modifies the nearsurface structure of the target due to the heavy ion bombardment. Here, BDD electrodes modified with implanted iridium ions were investigated for arsenic (III) detection by using cyclic voltammetry (CV) and flow injection analysis (FIA) [15]. BDD electrodes were implanted with 800 keV Ir+ by using iridium metal powder as the targets. Cyclic voltammetry and flow injection analysis with amperometric detection were used to study the electrochemical reaction (see Figure 5.8). The electrodes exhibited high catalytic activity toward As (III) oxidation, with the detection limit (S/N = 3), sensitivity, and linearity being 20 nM (1.5 ppb), 93 nA μM−1 cm−2 , and 0.999, respectively. The precision for 10 replicate determinations of 50 μM As (III) was 4.56% relative standard deviation. The advantageous properties of the electrodes were its inherent stability with a very low background current. The electrode was applicable for the analysis of spiked arsenic in tap water containing a significant amount of various elements in ionic form. The results indicate that metal implantation could be a promising method for controlling the electrochemical properties of diamond electrodes. Selective Detection of Glucose Using Cu-implanted BDD Electrodes Recently, highly sensitive and simple glucose detection has been considered to be very desirable for the diagnosis and management of diabetes mellitus. However, glucose is normally undetectable using bare BDD electrodes, similar to the previous example of arsenic detection. Glucose oxidation is a complex process that requires a catalytic reaction using an enzyme or active metal surfaces. Although Au, Pt, Ni, and Cu metal electrodes are known for
5.5 MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL BDD ELECTRODES
121
(a)
Current density (mA cm2)
0.6 0.4 0.2 0 –0.2 Phosphate Buffer 1 mM As
–0.4 –0.6 –0.8
–0.6
–0.4
–0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
Potential / V (vs. Ag/AgCl) (b) 1000
1200
800
600
100µM
y = 13.615x + 0.502 R 2 = 0.999
900
50µM
600
300 0
20 40 60 80 Concentration (µM)
100
400
0
10µM
200
Current (nA)
1500
0.1µM
0
2
4
0.5µM
6
1µM
8 Time (min)
5µM
10
12
14
16
Figure 5.8 (a) Cyclic voltammograms of 0.1 M phosphate buffer solution in the absence and presence of 1 mM As(III) at an Ir-implanted BDD electrode. (b) Amperometric response of flow injection analysis using Ir-implanted BDD as a detector. Applied potential was 0.6 V versus Ag/AgCl. Mobile phase was 0.1 M phosphate buffer solution. Flow rate was 1 mL min−1 . Inset shows the variation of current vs. As(III) concentration. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 15.)
showing electrocatalysis for glucose oxidation, the BDD electrode does not have catalytic properties. Here, we have studied the electrochemical detection of glucose using Cu-modified BDD electrodes (Cu-BDD). We report the simple technique of selective glucose detection using the Cu-BDD. The selectivity was derived from the differences in the diffusion processes for interfering species such as ascorbic acid (AA) and uric acid (UA) (linear diffusion to the BDD surface) and for glucose (spherical diffusion to implanted copper particles). Each dispersed copper particle of the Cu-BDD acts as an ultramicroelectrode (UME), because glucose reacts only at the copper surface but not at the BDD surface. On the other hand, interfering substances react at both electrode surfaces. Eventually, the difference of diffusion leads to a dependence or independence
122
APPLICATIONS OF POLYCRYSTALLINE AND MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL DIAMOND ELECTRODES
of the Faradic current on time, and the steady-state component of the current reflects only glucose concentration. That is, the time dependence of the observed current should be followed by Equations (5.1) and (5.2), respectively. √ Interfering species (linear diffusion) : I = nFACD (1/ π Dt) √ Glucose (spherical diffusion) : I = nFACD (1/ π Dt + 4/π r)
(5.1) (5.2)
Current density (mA cm–2)
Figure 5.9 (curve a) shows a CV recorded for the oxidation of glucose at Cu-BDD. Figure 5.9 (curves b and c) show CVs in the absence of glucose at Cu-BDD and in the presence of glucose at a bare BDD electrode respectively. Because no peak was observed in curves (b) and (c), we conclude that glucose was oxidized at the copper surface but not the BDD surface. Furthermore, the copper particles of Cu-BDD act as UMEs for glucose oxidation in the case of low-density modification with Cu, as evidenced by the fact that the curve of the negative scan was superimposed on the positive scan for the Cu-BDD electrodes, whereas this did not occur for pure metallic Cu electrodes. Electrochemical quantitative analyses of glucose at Cu-BDD electrodes were carried out by chronoamperometry. A linear calibration curve for the intercepts of Cottrell plots (current vs. inverse square root of time) depending on the glucose concentration was obtained (shown later), indicating that Cu-BDD electrodes can be used as a glucose sensor. On the other hand, CV plots for both AA and UA showed oxidation peaks at ca. +0.2 V vs. Ag/AgCl, and Cottrell plots of the chronoamperometric response at +0.6 V versus Ag/AgCl exhibited linear curves passing through the origin. These results indicate that the intercepts of the Cottrell plots reflect the glucose concentration at Cu-BDD, even in the presence of interfering substances. As indicated above, at Cu-BDD, glucose differs from interfering substances in the dimensions of diffusion. Figure 5.10 shows a schematic illustration of these differences. Glucose could only be oxidized at modified copper with spherical diffusion, whereas UA and AA could be oxidized at a BDD surface following a linear diffusion process. The
0.20 (a) 0.15 0.10 (b) 0.05 (c) 0.00 0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
Potential (V) vs. Ag/AgCl Figure 5.9 Cyclic voltammograms of 3 mM glucose in 0.2 M NaOH at the (c) diamond electrode, (a) Cu-implanted diamond electrode, and (b) Cu-implanted diamond electrode in the absence of glucose. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 16a.) See color insert.
5.5 MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL BDD ELECTRODES
123
(a)
(b)
Figure 5.10 Illustration of the diffusion profiles at Cu-implanted diamond electrodes for (a) ascorbic acid and uric acid and (b) glucose. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 16a.)
Cottrell plots of 6 mM glucose solutions and a mixed solution containing 6 mM glucose and interfering species (0.5 mM AA and 0.5 mM UA) showed similar values for both intercepts. Electrochemical quantitative analyses of glucose at Cu-BDD electrodes were carried out by chronoamperometry at 0.6 V vs. Ag/AgCl. Figure 5.11 shows chronoamperograms of 0.2 M NaOH aqueous solutions containing 1–5 mM (n = 5) glucose, respectively.
(a)
(b)
Figure 5.11 Chronoamperograms of 1–5 mM (a–e) glucose in 0.2 M NaOH at Cu-implanted diamond electrodes, respectively. The insets show (A) related Cottrell plots and (B) dependence of current on glucose concentration, extracted from the intercepts of the Cottrell plots. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 16a.)
124
APPLICATIONS OF POLYCRYSTALLINE AND MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL DIAMOND ELECTRODES
Cottrell plots in inset A of Figure 5.11 shows that the intercepts were not zero and the slopes were small, indicating that the amperometric response to glucose was at a steady state. A linear calibration curve for the concentration dependence of the intercept value was obtained (Figure 5.11, inset B), indicating that Cu-BDD electrodes can be used as a glucose sensor by this method. Furthermore, Figure 5.12 shows the Cottrell plots of 6 mM glucose solution (Figure 12a) and a mixed solution containing 6 mM glucose and interfering species (0.5 mM AA and 0.5 mM UA) (Figure 5.12b). According to the previous discussions, similar values for both intercepts reflect the concentration of glucose (6 mM) only. These results suggest that the simple methodology using Cu-BDD could be promising for selective glucose sensors [16]. 5.5.2.2 Selective Detection of As(III) and As(V) by Stripping Voltammetry The electrochemical detection of mixed solutions of As3+ and As5+ has been investigated by stripping voltammetry at gold-modified diamond electrodes [17]. The method was implemented based on the oxidative stripping of As0 deposited at the electrode surface. Whereas As3+ can be deposited by simple electrochemical reduction of As3+ to As0 at −0.4 V (vs. Ag/AgCl), a much more negative potential is required to overcome the activation energy of As5+ reduction. However, in such a negative potential region, hydrogen evolution also occurs. Consequently, one more step should be added to release the hydrogen gas adsorbed at the electrode surface during the reduction step. During the deposition of As5+ , the As3+ species was also simultaneously deposited. Therefore, to differentiate As3+ and As5+ quantitatively in a mixed solution, both stripping voltammetry methods should be performed and compared mathematically. A comparison of stripping voltammograms for both methods for As3+ solution in the absence of As5+ demonstrated similar peak shapes and current intensities, confirming that errors in the calculation of As5+ concentration in the mixed solution with As3+ can be avoided. Good linear responses were observed for each standard solution of As3+ and As5+ . A linear calibration curve could also be achieved for a series of concentrations of 100–1000 ppb As5+ in mixed solutions with 100 ppb As3+ (r 2 = 0.99) and for a series of concentrations of
Figure 5.12 Chronoamperograms of (a) 6 mM glucose and (b) a mixture of 0.5 mM ascorbic acid, 0.5 mM uric acid, and 6 mM glucose in 0.5 M NaOH with Cu-implanted diamond electrodes. The inset shows their related Cottrell plots. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 16a.)
5.5 MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL BDD ELECTRODES
125
5–30 ppb As3+ in mixed solutions with 100 ppb As5+ . Detection limits of 5 and 100 ppb can be achieved for As3+ and As5+ in mixed solution, respectively. Good reproducibility was shown for stripping voltammetry of As3+ and As5+ with RSD values (n = 8) of 7.5 and 8.4%, respectively. Good stability of gold-modified diamond electrodes before and after arsenic detection was also evaluated by SEM images. Application of the method for real sample analysis was performed for arsenic detection in Yokohama (Japan) tap water. 5.5.2.3 In vivo Dopamine Detection by BDD Microelectrodes The borondoped diamond (BDD) microelectrode has received much attention as an electrochemical sensor, especially as an in vivo sensor [18–20]. By using this promising electrode, in vivo electrochemical detection of dopamine (DA) was investigated. Dopamine is one of the neurotransmitters, and thought to act as a trigger of many vital activities. Therefore, in vivo DA monitoring is important. However, in the case of the carbon fiber, which is a conventional in vivo sensor, it is a long-standing problem to separate the response from that of some interfering substances, particularly ascorbic acid (AA). To overcome this issue, we used the BDD microelectrode. Anodically oxidized BDD (ao-BDD) has the property to recognize DA and AA separately by investigating their specificity of oxidation potential [21]. So, we applied this useful property for in vivo analysis with microelectrodes. Finally, a good separation between DA and AA could be obtained not only in vitro but also in vivo. Moreover, some advantages over the conventional carbon fiber electrode were demonstrated. Therefore, we concluded that BDD microelectrodes are highly promising for future in vivo analysis [22]. BDD thin films were grown on chemically etched tungsten wires (50 μm dia.) by using a microwave plasma-assisted chemical vapor deposition system at a hydrogen pressure of 60 Torr and microwave power of 2.5 kW for 3 h. Boron was doped with a concentration of 104 ppm (B/C). A single compartment cell was employed for in vitro electrochemical experiments. Ao-BDD was formed by the electrochemical oxidation of as-deposited, hydrogen terminated, BDD (ad-BDD) at an applied potential of +2.5V (vs. Ag/AgCl) in 0.1 M HCl for 20 min. In vivo measurements were conducted in a mouse brain. Electric stimulations for the medial forebrain bundle (MFB) were applied to release DA. Square wave pulse voltammetry (SWPV) was used for electrochemical characterization. All experiments were conducted by using an Ag/AgCl electrode as reference and a Pt wire as counter electrode. Polycrystalline BDD on tungsten wire with the tip diameter of about 5 μm was obtained. This was the smallest among published reports of BDD microelectrodes, and its small size was expected to be workable for in vivo studies without any invasive damage for cells or tissues (see Figure 5.13 shows a schematic drawing of the diamond microelectrode used for in vivo analysis). At first, the basic electrochemical properties of BDD microelectrodes were studied in vitro. It was already reported that, at an ao-BDD electrode, the oxidation potential of AA was shifted to a higher potential than that of DA, whereas at ad-BDD, AA was oxidized at almost the same potential as that of DA (i.e., about +0.6V vs. Ag/AgCl). This is because AA is charged negatively in the aqueous solution, so that electrostatic repulsion is exhibited between the AA and the surface of the ao-BDD macroelectrode, which is terminated with oxygen. Therefore, for the oxidation of AA, much excess potential is needed to approach to the electrode. This behavior was also observed at the
126
APPLICATIONS OF POLYCRYSTALLINE AND MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL DIAMOND ELECTRODES
about 1cm BDD
resin about 5cm
pre-pulled glass capillary silver epoxy
coated metalwire Figure 5.13 Ref. 22.)
Schematic drawing of a diamond microelectrode. (Reprinted with permission from
ao-BDD microelectrode. Two steps of steady-state current responses appeared for the measurement for the mixture of DA and AA. Moreover, high sensitivity was obtained, with an experimental detection limit of 50 nM in the presence of AA. This value was adequate for the application for in vivo monitoring of DA. Based on these observations, an ao-BDD microelectrode was utilized for the in vivo measurements (see Figure 5.14). The BDD electrode was inserted into the striatum in the mouse brain, and MFB stimulations were applied to induce DA release. Figure 5.15 shows signal responses following the stimulations. Clear signals were recorded for each stimulation and indicated that in vivo monitoring of DA was successfully achieved at the ao-BDD microelectrode. Moreover, a correlation diagram for in vivo analysis showed very similar features to that for in vitro DA. These results confirmed that these signals certainly came from DA oxidation. 5.5.2.4 BDD Nanograss Array (Whisker BDD) In order to expand the electrochemical application field of BDD electrodes, a BDD nanograss array was created [23]. A simple method was applied to prepare the BDD nanograss array on a heavily doped BDD film by reactive ion etching. The boron dopant atoms in the diamond act as the mask during plasma etching, thus avoiding the complicated pre-preparation processes involved in using an intentional mask or removal of the template by using additional processes. The diameter of the prepared nanograss gradually increased from 5 to 20 nm with increasing etching time from 30 s to 10 min, while the morphology of the nanograss was disturbed by use of an etching time of 60 min. Figure 5.16 shows SEM images of the microstructure of a BDD nanograss array. It can be seen that the nanograss array on
127
5.5 MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL BDD ELECTRODES
counter electrode
stimulating electrode
BDD
Reference electrode
anesthesia induction
Counter electrode
Stimulating electrode reference electrode
BDD
Brain Cortex Corpus Striatum Substantia Nigra Dopaminergic Neuron
Figure 5.14 Photograph and schematic drawing of in vivo mouse brain experimental setup. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 22.) See color insert.
Current (nA)
5.4 5.2
0.20 0.18 0.16 0.14 0.12
36
0.8
5.0
0.9 1.0 Time (s)
1.1
4.8
Current (nA)
(a)
Current (nA)
5.6
(b)
34 32
4.6 4.4 200
400
600 Time (s)
800
1000
30 200
400
600 Time (s)
800
1000
Figure 5.15 Differential pulse voltammetry (DPV) monitoring of current response following MFB stimulation (50 Hz, 100 pulses for 2 s) measured at an applied potential of 0.9 V (vs. Ag/AgCl) with (a) a diamond microelectrode and (b) a carbon fiber electrode. The inset shows the dependence of the signal current on the applied potential. DPV settings: frequency, 50 Hz; potential step, 100 mV; pulse amplitude, 150 mV; starting potential, 0.65 V versus Ag/AgCl. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 22.)
the BDD surface has the following dimensions: ∼20 nm diameter and ∼200 nm length, and the distance between each nanograss structure is about 50 nm. The electron transfer on the electrode surface was investigated by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). Figure 5.17 shows the results of EIS for 10 mM [Fe(CN)6 ]3-/4- in 0.1 M KCl on the electrode surface. The lower semicircle diameter obtained on the BDD nanograss array electrode (b), compared to that on the oxidized BDD film electrode (a), indicated that the presence of the nanograss array on the electrode
128
APPLICATIONS OF POLYCRYSTALLINE AND MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL DIAMOND ELECTRODES
Figure 5.16 SEM images of a BDD nanograss array at (A) low resolution and (B) high resolution. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 23.)
500 (b) oxidized BDD film BDD nanograss array
–Z ’’(ohm)
400
300
200 (a) 100
0 200
400
600 Z ’’(ohm)
800
Figure 5.17 Nyquist plots of 10 mM [Fe(CN)6 ]3−/4− in 0.1 M KCl from 105 Hz to 0.1 Hz at an ac amplitude of 10 mV under open circuit potential conditions, obtained on (a) the oxidized BDD film and (b) the BDD nanograss array. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 23.)
surface improved the reactive site, reduced the interfacial resistance, and made the electron transfer easier. The effect of the nanograss array structure on the enhancement of electrocatalytic activity of electrodes was demonstrated by detecting dopamine (DA) and uric acid (UA). It is essential to develop simple and rapid methods for their determination in routine analyses. Here, the electrochemical detection of DA and UA was studied on the BDD nanograss array electrode and the oxidized BDD film electrode. In the CVs of 5 × 104 M DA (Figure 5.18a), the oxidation peak potential shifted from 0.585 V on the oxidized BDD film electrode to 0.395 V on the BDD nanograss array electrode, and the oxidation peak current increased from 16.35 to 22.44 mA. That is, on the BDD nanograss array electrode, the oxidation peak potential shifted negatively by ∼0.19 V
5.5 MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL BDD ELECTRODES
129
(a) 5x10–4M DA
Current (µA)
20
15
10
5 oxidized BDD film BDD nanograss array
0
–0.2
0.0
0.2 0.4 Potential (V) vs. Ag/AgCl
0.6
0.8
(b) 16 5x10–4M UA
Current(µA)
12
8
4
oxidised BDD film BDD nanograss array
0
0.0
0.3
0.6
0.9
1.2
Potential (V) vs. Ag/AgCl (c) Current (µA)
6.0
Current (µA)
4.5
6
xxx xxx xxx
4
120µM (b) 100µM
2 0 0
3.0
80µM
(a)
40 80 120 Concentration/µM 60µM 40µM
(c) 1.5
20µM 10µM
0.0
(a) oxidised BDD film (b) BDD nanograss array
blank 0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
Time (s)
Figure 5.18 CVs for (A) 5 × 10−4 MDA, and (B) 5 × 10−4 MUA obtained on the oxidized BDD film (solid line) and the BDD nanograss array (dashed line) electrodes in 0.07 M phosphate buffer solution (PBS) (pH 7.0). The scan rate was 50 mV s−1 . (C) Amperometric response of the oxidized BDD film electrode (a) and the BDD nanograss array electrode (b) through the successive addition of DA in 0.07 M PBS (pH 7.0) under continuously stirred conditions. The applied potential was kept at 0.58 V (vs. Ag/AgCl) for (a) and 0.38 V (vs. Ag/AgCl) for (b), respectively. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 23.)
130
APPLICATIONS OF POLYCRYSTALLINE AND MODIFIED FUNCTIONAL DIAMOND ELECTRODES
and the oxidation peak current increased by 37.25%, compared to those on the oxidized BDD film electrode. In the case of the oxidation of UA (Figure 5.18b), the oxidation peak current was 11.17 mA at 0.832 V on the oxidized BDD film electrode whereas on the BDD nanograss array electrode, the oxidation peak current of UA at 0.76 V increased by 33.36%. In comparison with the oxidized BDD film electrode, on the BDD nanograss array electrode, the negative shift of peak potential and the increase in peak current on the oxidation of DA and UA were ascribed to the following: The structure of nanograss array could increase the surface area, provide better electric linkage between electrode active sites, promote the electrocatalytic ability, and accelerate the electron transfer. The amperometric response of DA was also investigated through the successive addition of DA into 0.07 M PBS (pH 7.0) under continuously stirring conditions on the BDD nanograss array electrode and the oxidized BDD film electrode, as shown in Figure 5.18c. It was observed that the current response increased with increasing concentration of DA for the two electrodes. The current response of the BDD nanograss array electrode was higher than that of the oxidized BDD film electrode for the same concentration of DA. The inset of Figure 5.18c shows the dependence of the steady-state current on the concentration of DA for the two electrodes. Linearity was observed in the range of 5–120 mM for the two electrodes (r = 0.999). Sensitivity corresponding to the linear range for DA was 465.57 mAM−1 cm−2 on the oxidized BDD film electrode and 642.14 mAM−1 cm−2 on the nanograss array BDD electrode. The detection limits were calculated to be about 1.5 and 0.8 mM, respectively, according to the 3 sb /m criteria. These results also demonstrated the better electrocatalytic activity of the BDD nanograss array toward the detection of DA, with higher sensitivity and a lower detection limit.
5.6
CONCLUSIONS
We have reported not only the preceding examples but also several additional examples of sensitive detection by BDD electrodes, such as uric acid [24], NADH [25], acids [26], toxic gases [27], and others. In fact, some of the examples are now in progress for the development of practical electrochemical sensor applications. Furthermore, in order to add other functions and improve the electrochemical properties, BDD electrodes with surfaces chemically modified by functional organic molecules are also actively being developed [28,29]. Thus, it appears likely that, in the near future, electrochemical sensors using BDD can be applied for environmental analysis and medical analysis.
5.7
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors would like to express thanks to Prof. Donald A. Tryk for carefully reading the manuscript. We also express thanks to all of co-workers, especially Dr. C. Terashima (Central Japan Railway Company), Dr. T. A. Ivandini, Dr. M. Murata, Dr. M. Chiku, Dr. T. Watanabe, Ms. A. Suzuki (Keio University), Prof. K. Yoshimi, and Prof. S. Kitazawa (Juntendo University).
REFERENCES
131
REFERENCES 1. A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, T N. Rao, D.A. Tryk, eds., Diamond Electrochemistry, BKC Inc. and Elsevier, 2005. 2. A. Kraft, Int. J. Electrochem. Sci . 2007, 2 , 355. 3. J.H. Luong, K.B. Male, J.D. Glennon, Analyst 2009, 134 , 1965. 4. T. Yano, D.A. Tryk, K. Hashimoto, A. Fujishima, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1998, 145 , 1870. 5. M. Murata, T.A. Ivandini, M. Shibata, S. Nomura, A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, J. Electroanal. Chem. 2008, 612 , 29. 6. F. Kodera, M. Umeda, Y. Yamada, Anal. Chim. Acta. 2005, 537 , 293. 7. T.A. Ivandini, T.N. Rao, A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, Anal. Chem. 2006, 78 , 3467. 8. F.A. Armstrong, Encyclop. Electrochem. 2002, 9 , 11. 9. M. Chiku, T.A. Ivandini, A. Kamiya, A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, J. Electroanal. Chem. 2008, 612 , 201. 10. M. Chiku, J. Nakamura, A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, Anal. Chem. 2008, 80 , 5783. 11. A. Preechaworapun, T.A. Ivandini, A. Suzuki, A. Fujishima, O. Chailapakul, Y. Einaga, Anal. Chem. 2008, 80 , 2077. 12. K. Arihara, C. Terashima, A. Fujishima, J. Electrochem. Soc. 2007, 154 , E71. 13. K. Arihara, C. Terashima, A. Fujishima, Electrochem. Solid-State Lett . 2006, 9 , D17. 14. A. Salimi, M.E. Hyde, C.E. Banks, R.G. Compton, Analyst 2004, 29 , 9. 15. T.A. Ivandini, R. Sato, Y. Makide, A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, Anal. Chem. 2006, 78 , 6291. 16. (a) T. Watanabe, T.A. Ivandini, Y. Makide, A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, Anal. Chem. 2006, 78 , 7857. (b) T. Watanabe, Y. Einaga, Biosensors and Bioelectronics 2009, 24 , 2684. 17. D. Yamada, T.A. Ivandini, M. Komatsu, A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, J. Electroanal. Chem. 2008, 615 , 145. 18. B.V. Sarada, T.N. Rao, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1999, 146 , 1469. 19. A.M. Bond, Analyst 1994, 119 , R1. 20. P.S. Cahill, Q.D. Walker, J.M. Finnegan, G.E. Mickelson, E.R. Travis, R.M. Wightman, Anal. Chem. 1996, 68 , 3180. 21. E. Popa, H. Notsu, T. Miwa, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, Electrochem. Solid State Chem. 1999, 2 , 49. 22. A. Suzuki, T.A. Ivandini, K. Yoshimi, A. Fujishima, G. Oyama, T. Nakazato, N. Hattori, S. Kitazawa, Y. Einaga, Anal. Chem. 2007, 79 , 8608. 23. M. Wei, C. Terashima, M. Lv, A. Fujishima, Z.-Z. Gu, Chem. Commun. 2009, 3624. 24. E. Popa, Y. Kubota, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, Anal. Chem. 2000, 72 , 1724. 25. T.N. Rao, I. Yagi, T. Miwa, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, Anal. Chem. 1999, 71 , 2506. 26. N. Mitani, Y. Einaga, J. Electroanal. Chem. 2009, 626 , 156. 27. T.A. Ivandini, D. Yamada, T. Watanabe, H. Matsuura, N. Nakano, A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, J. Electroanal. Chem. 2010, 645 , 58. 28. T. Kondo, H. Hoshi, K. Honda, Y. Einaga, A. Fujishima, T. Kawai, J. Phys. Chem. C . 2008, 112 , 11887. 29. T. Kondo, S. Aoshima, K. Hirata, K. Honda, Y. Einaga, A. Fujishima, T. Kawai, Langmuir 2008, 24 , 7545.
6 Diamond Ultramicroelectrodes and Nanostructured Electrodes Katherine B. Holt
6.1
INTRODUCTION
Miniaturization of boron-doped diamond (BDD) electrodes is desirable for incorporation into devices and for their effective use in vivo. However, the ability to carry out electrochemical analysis within a confined volume is not the only advantage to using small electrodes. At ultramicroelectrode (UME) dimensions, diffusion of reactant to the electrode surface is very fast, resulting in steady-state (time-independent) limiting currents. This is advantageous for applications requiring continuous monitoring of an analyte concentration by amperometry or for use in imaging applications requiring fast response times and spatial resolution, such as scanning electrochemical microscopy (SECM). UMEs can also be used in highly resistive media—for example with low levels of added electrolyte, or in nonpolar solvents, as they draw small Faradaic currents that result in very minor iR drops in solution. Due to the small electrode area, very low- charging (capacitive) currents result, meaning that higher scan rates can be employed than for conventionalsized electrodes (as charging current increases proportionally with scan rate). This allows short-lived reaction intermediates to be detected and the kinetics and mechanisms of fast time scale electrochemical events to be investigated using fast scan cyclic voltammetry (CV).
Synthetic Diamond Films: Preparation, Electrochemistry, Characterization, and Applications, First Edition. Edited by Enric Brillas and Carlos Alberto Mart´ınez-Huitle. © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Published 2011 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
133
134
DIAMOND ULTRAMICROELECTRODES AND NANOSTRUCTURED ELECTRODES
When coupled with the highly desirable electrochemical characteristics of BDD—a wide potential window, low background currents, robustness, and the ability to resist fouling in biological/organic media—it is clear that the development of diamond UMEs should result in very impressive and versatile sensors. Indeed, very small < 100 μm dimensioned BDD electrodes have successfully been incorporated into capillary electrophoresis systems for the end-column electrochemical detection of dopamine, catechol, ascorbic acid, naphthol, norepinephrine, and epinephrine [1–2]. The analytical performance of BDD microelectrodes was impressive when compared to carbon fiber microelectrodes, achieving lower detection limits and stable, reproducible responses with no evidence of electrode deactivation. BDD microelectrodes have also been used particularly successfully in vivo for the detection of dopamine in mouse brain [3] and for in vitro neurochemistry and neurodynamic studies [4–7]. In many in vivo applications, the exact geometry of the electrode is not important, as long as the performance of the electrode is stable and reproducible. Likewise, although a small size and sharp tip is desirable for use within tissues to minimize damage, the exact exposed electrode area is less important and steady-state electrochemical behavior is not essential. In contrast, in order to be suitable for use in quantitative electrochemical investigations, for example, fast-scan CV for the measurement of heterogeneous and homogeneous rate constants, or in SECM investigations, development of diamond UMEs with a well-defined geometry, is desirable. Importantly, in order to obtain steady-state measurements, we require that the electrode dimensions are of similar magnitude to the diffusion layer thickness. In practice this means that electrodes with at least one dimension of less than 25 μm are required. In this chapter, the electrochemical characteristics of UMEs are briefly summarized (see section 6.2), along with the progress made in fabrication and application of single BDD UMEs of different geometry and sizes < 25 μm (see section 6.3). Most progress has been made with the fabrication and characterization of UME arrays of BDD, where multiple electrodes are embedded in an insulating matrix. The availability of microfabrication techniques, such as photolithography, allows arrays of different geometries to be fabricated with high precision, as discussed in section 6.4. These arrays are highly sensitive, with excellent signal-to-noise characteristics that allow very low detection limits. Some remaining challenges will also be discussed, including issues of inhomogeneity of dopant distribution and crystallite size, and morphology and how this affects the electrochemical response. Finally, the fabrication and application of nanostructured BDD array electrodes will be discussed. This is a very new field where nanoscale structure is introduced onto the surface of BDD electrodes resulting in “nanograss,” “nanowire,” or “nanorod forest” morphologies, with posited applications including selective sensing of dopamine and DNA hybridization.
6.2 ULTRAMICROELECTRODES: DEFINITION AND ELECTROCHEMICAL CHARACTERISTICS An ultramicroelectrode is defined as an electrode with at least one dimension smaller than the diffusion layer developed during a typical electrochemical experiment—in practice this requires one “critical” dimension of 25 μm or less [8]. When a potential is applied to an UME, such that species O in solution is reduced to R, a constant steady-state current is achieved very quickly. This is because diffusion of reactant O to the electrode
6.2 ULTRAMICROELECTRODES: DEFINITION AND ELECTROCHEMICAL CHARACTERISTICS
135
(a)
Macroelectrode linear diffusion (b) Disk UME
(c)
0.5
R i (nA)
insulation
Microelectrode radial diffusion
0.3
0.1
–0.1 0
RG = R / r
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
E (V) vs. Ag / Agcl (i)
(ii)
(d) Insulating surround Electrically connected UMEs
Figure 6.1 (a) Schematic of diffusion processes at macroelectrode (linear diffusion predominates) and microelectrode (radial/hemispherical diffusion predominates). (b) Schematic of disk UME with critical dimension, r, and an approximate RG of 3. (c) Typical CV of BDD disk UME of radius 1.5 μm in 1 mM FcOH in 0.2 M KCl, scan rate 20 mV s−1 . (d) Schematic of diffusion profiles formed around UMEs in an array: (i) UMEs widely spaced so that diffusion profiles do not overlap and diffusion remains hemispherical and (ii) for closely spaced UMEs the diffusion profiles overlap and diffusion becomes linear.
is radial rather than linear, as shown in Figure 6.1a, and a thick (relative to the size of the electrode) diffusion field is rapidly established. Mass transport to the electrode is therefore very fast and reactant reaches the surface at a constant flux, and time-independent steady state currents are achieved. Ultramicroelectrodes may be fabricated with a range of geometries—for example disk, hemispherical, spherical, cylinder, cone, and microband—as long as one dimension is < 25 μm. The most common UMEs are of disk geometry (e.g., formed by sealing a metal wire in glass) which gives a steady-state current, i , described by Equation (6.1): i =4 nFDCr
(6.1)
where n is the stoichiometric number of electrons involved in the electrode reaction, F is Faraday’s constant (96485 C mol−1 ), D is the diffusion coefficient of the solution species, C is the bulk concentration of species, and r is the radius of the electrode. Therefore for a 25 μm diameter disk electrode, a typical aqueous redox couple of concentration 1 mM should result in a steady-state current of ∼3–4 nA. The thickness of the insulation surrounding the electrode can also influence the currents achieved; for a thin insulating layer, more diffusion of species around the edges of the electrode is possible,
136
DIAMOND ULTRAMICROELECTRODES AND NANOSTRUCTURED ELECTRODES
leading to larger currents. The ratio of the radius of the whole electrode assembly, including insulation (R) to the radius of the electroactive electrode (r), is termed the RG (illustrated in Figure 6.1b) and the steady state current is found to be dependent on this value for RG of 10 and below. This becomes important for very sharp electrodes with thin insulation, such as those fabricated for scanning probe applications such as SECM, where close approach to a surface are required and a small RG is advantageous [9]. The effect of RG on limiting current may be calculated by changing the suffix “4” in Equation (6.1) (which is valid for RG ≥ 10) to the value most appropriate for the RG in question, which may be found in the literature [10]. Similar equations allow one to calculate the steady-state current for other electrode geometries [8,9]. The cyclic voltammetric (CV) response of an UME is shown in Figure 6.1c, where, in comparison to the conventional “duck-shaped” CV of a macroelectrode, a sigmoidal response is obtained with limiting currents observed rather than peaks. The backward scan follows the forward scan exactly, as products formed at the electrode rapidly diffuse away from the interface and are therefore not detected on the reverse scan. As the CV is mass transport limited, its shape and limiting currents will be independent of scan rate over most routinely used values (< 0.5 V s−1 ). Some UMEs approaching the upper size limit may exhibit quasi-steady-state behavior, where a limiting current is observed at slow scan rates but a peaked CV response is obtained as scan rates are increased. This is particularly the case for electrode geometries where some of the dimensions (other than the critical dimension) are greater than 25 μm, such as cylinder or microband electrodes. Ultramicroelectrode arrays consist of many individual but electrically connected electrodes of UME dimensions distributed within an insulating matrix. Each electrode has the electrochemical behavior of an UME if individually addressed, but the response of the array depends on the spacing between them, as shown in Figure 6.1d. If the electrodes are spaced far enough apart, then their diffusion profiles will not overlap and the CV response will be similar to the sigmoidal steady-state response shown in Figure 6.1c. However, if the electrodes are too close together, the diffusion profiles will overlap and merge, resulting in linear diffusion and a peaked CV response consistent with a planar macroelectrode of the same geometric area. An advantage of a well-spaced UME array is that the steady-state response of a single UME is obtained but with a much larger limiting current, which is proportional to the number of individual electrodes making up the array. An array therefore has the advantages of a single UME but with a much enhanced current response and thus greater sensitivity. 6.3
BORON-DOPED DIAMOND UMEs
The most common strategy for the preparation of single BDD UMEs is to coat a suitable substrate, of the correct geometry and dimensions, with a BDD film using conventional CVD techniques. The entire assembly is then sheathed with an insulating coating, except for a very small electroactive area at the very tip, which is exposed to form the UME. The conditions and methods employed for each of these steps has an influence on the final size and geometry of the resulting UMEs; they are discussed in detail in the sections. 6.3.1
Substrate Preparation and Growth of Diamond Films
The most common substrates for the deposition of single BDD UMEs are sharpened tungsten [3,11–15] or platinum [1,16] wires. Sharpening of 50–250 μm tungsten wires
6.3 BORON-DOPED DIAMOND UMEs
137
is carried out electrochemically in a 2 M NaOH solution with an applied DC voltage. The sharpness of the W tips obtained using this method is found to be independent of initial wire diameter, instead depending on the depth of immersion into the NaOH solution and the threshold voltage at which the power supply is switched off [14]. As the highest etching rate is obtained at the solution/air interface, the lower, immersed part of the wire tends to fracture away when the force of gravity exceeds the yield strength of the etched neck of wire. When there is a greater depth of wire in the solution, the part of wire below the necking point at the solution/air interface is heavier and so it will fracture sooner, leading to larger cross-section tips. The threshold voltage is important because if it is too high, the power supply will be cut off before the lower part necks off; however, if it is too low, etching will continue after necking off, leading to a much blunter tip. It was found that for a 250 μm W wire at 2 mm immersion depth, 2–3 V initial potential and 0.75 V threshold voltages, the sharpest tips of 100 nm diameters can be obtained. In some situations, less sharp tips may be required (e.g., for increased robustness) in which case the threshold voltage and immersion depth may be varied appropriately. Platinum wires (of 10, 25, or 76 μm) can also be sharpened electrochemically using an etching solution of CaCl2 in water and acetone and an applied AC voltage [1]. Both Pt and W wires make excellent substrates for diamond growth due to the ease of their etching and their ability to withstand the high temperatures for CVD deposition. An advantage of using platinum is that it has highly characteristic voltammetric features, which would be discernible if cracks were to form in the diamond film, and hence can be used as an indicator of loss of film integrity. If pinholes form in films deposited on tungsten, leakage of solution through to the underlying tungsten can lead to the formation of an oxide layer and loss of electrical connectivity between the BDD films and the tungsten substrate [14]. Once sharpened, the metal wires must be seeded by sonicating in a suspension of diamond powder, which embeds diamond nanoparticles into the wire and also roughens the surface to provide nucleation sites for growth. Without this nucleation step, very little diamond growth will occur on the smooth etched tips even after 12 h or more of growth. Diamond growth can be carried out under the same conditions as for regular BDD electrodes, by either HF or MW CVD, with the wires typically aligned vertically with the sharpened tips upward, taking some care that the wires are secured mounted to prevent their disturbance during pumping down. As the BDD film coats the sharpened wires, it is inevitable that the diameter of the tip will increase as a function of diamond film thickness and hence growth time. Figure 6.2a shows a typical SEM image of a BDD-coated W wire after 10 h of HFCVD growth, where microcrystalline diamond is found to coat the entire wire. The thickness of the coating is about 5–10 μm, as determined from a cross-section image of a broken tip, as shown in Figure 6.2b. The size of the individual crystallites is dependent on the methane concentrations used in the feed gas mixture during growth. Low methane concentrations (0.3–0.4% CH4 in H2 ) result in larger grains, with grain size increasing toward the sharpened tip. For HFCVD growth, it is not uncommon for single crystals to form at the very tip, as diamond grains tend to coalesce in regions that are higher in temperature. As microcrystalline films are very rough and so more difficult to insulate effectively (see Section 6.3.2), the effect of growth conditions on crystal size and the smoothness of coating has been explored [13,14]. Increasing the methane concentration to 3% increases nucleation and growth rates and results in the deposition of nanocrystalline BDD films, which are much smoother, as shown in Figure 6.2c. However, films grown with such high
138
DIAMOND ULTRAMICROELECTRODES AND NANOSTRUCTURED ELECTRODES
(a)
(b)
Figure 6.2 (a) SEM image of microcrystalline BDD coating a sharpened W wire. (b) SEM image of cross-section through BDD-coated W wire. (c) SEM image of smooth nanocrystalline BDD coating on W wire. (d) SEM image of BDD-coated W wire insulated with electrophoretic paint, with 3 μm diameter disk of BDD exposed at the tip using focused ion beam (FIB) in the ‘‘head-on’’ configuration. (e) SEM image from side of BDD disk UME formed from BDD tip coated in electrophoretic paint and then exposed by FIB operating in ‘‘side-on’’ geometry. [Figures a, b and c: (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 13. Figures d and e: Reprinted with permission from Ref. 15.)]
6.3 BORON-DOPED DIAMOND UMEs
139
(c)
(d)
Figure 6.2
(Continued)
methane content may contain poorer quality diamond and the electrochemical response may be compromised as a result. An alternative method to producing smooth films, even at lower methane concentrations (0.72%), is to apply a negative bias between the hot filament and the W wire substrates throughout the growth procedure. Negative bias-enhanced nucleation (BEN) increases nucleation density and produces continuous smooth film coatings with small grain size (∼1 μm) in less than half the growth time
140
DIAMOND ULTRAMICROELECTRODES AND NANOSTRUCTURED ELECTRODES
(e)
2 μm
Figure 6.2 (Continued)
required for nonbiased growth. As low methane concentrations are used, the films are of higher quality (containing less nondiamond carbon) than the nanocrystalline films grown under methane rich conditions. The growth conditions and resulting film morphology are important, as microcrystalline films typically give superior electrochemical response, but generally provide a poorer coverage and greater incidence of pinholes, as well as being more difficult to insulate. Nanocrystalline films are smoother, are easier to insulate, produce sharper tips, and are more continuous (pinhole free), but being of lesser quality diamond can have a shortened potential window and increased background current. The best compromise, then, appears to be small grain size films grown with BEN under low methane concentration conditions [14]. An alternative approach to producing BDD microelectrodes is employed by Halpern et al. [6] and Xie et al. [7], where a 25 μm diameter tungsten wire is sealed in a quartz glass capillary and the entire assembly is then placed in the HFCVD reactor. Growth of diamond occurs both on the exposed W disk and on the surrounding quartz insulation, resulting in an unusual disk-ring structure due to the different diamond growth rates on the two materials. The electrodes produced in this way thus tend to have larger dimensions than the initial substrate (typically 35 μm) and the geometry and morphology is quite complicated. However, this method could potentially be modified to produce BDD UMEs of better defined geometry. The authors have successfully used these electrodes for a range of neurodynamic investigations. 6.3.2
Insulation Methods and Control of Exposed Electrode Geometry
As-grown BDD-coated wires are typically attached to a copper wire (current collector) using a silver conducting epoxy to provide a suitable electrical contact. The whole
6.3 BORON-DOPED DIAMOND UMEs
141
assembly must then be insulated; various methods have been reported, including sealing in glass, epoxy, polyimide or other polymers, nail polish, polypropylene tubing, and electrophoretic paint. Most of these methods result in the complete coverage of the electrode surface, requiring that the insulation be later removed from a controlled area at the tip of the electrode by physical or chemical means. Although heat-sealing in glass is the most common approach to fabricating disk UMEs from platinum and gold wires or carbon fibers, diamond UMEs are more difficult to seal in glass due to the typical roughness of the polycrystalline film and the difference in thermal expansion coefficients of the two materials. However, Cooper et al. [11] reported the successful fabrication of diamond UMEs of exposed BDD diameter < 7 μm by completely sealing BDD-coated W tips in a glass capillary (by heating in a ceramic furnace) and then partially exposing the diamond tip by careful polishing or by chemically etching the glass in hydrogen fluoride (HF). The authors noted that although glass insulation was advantageous for use in corrosive or organic environments and is very chemically and physically robust, it is difficult to routinely obtain well-sealed electrodes with a small and defined exposed geometry using this method. The most common and simple insulation methods are to coat the electrode with a suitable epoxy, a nail varnish, or a polymer coating (polyimide films have been reported as being particularly successful for this application [1]) and allow it to dry or cure. The tip of the electrode can then be exposed by touching gently to filter or tissue paper soaked in a suitable solvent (e.g., acetone for nail varnish, sodium hydroxide for polyimide). UMEs may be fabricated surprisingly reproducibly using this method—the size of the resulting exposed electrode depends mainly on the geometry of the as-grown BDD-coated wire tip [13]. As well as its ease, another advantage to this technique is that if too much insulating material is accidentally removed, the whole electrode can be recoated very quickly and the procedure repeated. A disadvantage is that success relies on the skill of the person carrying out the selective exposure, but with practice the technique is very reliable. Another problem is the relative stability of the different coatings toward electrochemical cycling, especially at extreme anodic or cathodic polarizations. The chemical composition of the different epoxy and nail varnish brands may vary considerably, so it is advisable to carefully assess the stability of the chosen insulation under the desired experimental conditions. Another common method for the insulation of sharp etched Pt or C fiber UMEs is the use of electrophoretic paint, which forms a thin insulating coating suitable for fabricating very sharp electrodes (i.e., electrodes with a very small RG). Different types of paints are commercially available and they work on the principle that when a negative (cathodic paint) or positive (anodic paint) potential is applied to the sharpened wire, a local pH change around the electrode, caused by water hydrolysis, results in precipitation of the paint in the form of a thin, uniform polymer film. After curing in an oven, the film becomes electrically insulating and inert. If a sharp needle-shaped electrode is used—for example, an electrochemically etched Pt wire—the paint coating shrinks and retracts from the sharpened point during curing, resulting in a small exposed electrode area at the very tip. This particular property of electrophoretic paint works only rarely with BDD UMEs because the paint tends to retract also from the sharp edges of diamond crystallites down the entire length of the electrode, leading to pinholes and incomplete insulation. Repeating the paint deposition/curing cycle many times results in the formation of a thicker, continuous insulating coating; however, a method is then required to selectively remove the paint from the tip of the electrode to expose the underlying BDD.
142
DIAMOND ULTRAMICROELECTRODES AND NANOSTRUCTURED ELECTRODES
As these paints are mostly impervious to common chemical treatments, the removal of the paint by exposure to a suitable solvent, as discussed previously, is not possible. The paint can be removed by gentle polishing but this can lead to damage to the fragile, fine tips, so a more sophisticated method is to etch away the paint using a focused ion beam (FIB) [15]. The apexes of insulated BDD electrodes can be exposed by FIB milling in different geometries, ranging from “head on” where the ion beam is directly incident in a perpendicular geometry onto the diamond surface, to “side on” where the ion beam is parallel to the exposed electrode surface. Figure 6.2d shows a SEM image of the top of an insulated BDD tip, where a 3 μm diameter circle can be seen in the center of the image, corresponding to the area milled by the FIB in a “head on” configuration. The depth of the milled area is around 0.3 μm, which is thicker than the electrophoretic paint coating, to ensure that all of the paint is removed from that area and that the underlying diamond is exposed. It was found, however, that less than one-third of UMEs fabricated using “head on” FIB milling give satisfactory electrochemical performance. This is believed to be due to damage to the exposed diamond surface from the high-energy impact of the ion beam in the “head on” geometry. In contrast, when the FIB was employed in a “side on” geometry, almost all of the resulting UMEs gave a good electrochemical response consistent with small dimensions, small RG, and defined geometry. To fabricate UMEs using this route requires that the tip radius of the BDD-coated W is roughly similar in size to that required for the UME, as shown in Figure 6.2e for a side on SEM image of a BDD UME of diameter 2 μm. The result is a flat, disk-shaped electrode that is quite suitable for applications such as SECM where the tip needs to approach closely to a substrate. 6.3.3
Electrochemical Performance and Applications
Figure 6.1c shows the CV response for a typical UME in 1 mM ferrocenemethanol (FcOH), fabricated using the “side on” FIB method just described, which exhibits the predicted sigmoidal response for a UME. The limiting current of ∼0.5 nA is consistent with an exposed electrode radius of 1.5 μm (assuming a disk geometry and an RG of 1.1) and electrodes of these dimensions or even smaller are routinely achievable using this method. The backward trace follows the forward scan almost exactly, indicative of very low capacitive charging currents. Some small difference in the forward and backward currents is inevitable and acceptable; the degree of hysteresis observed depends to some extent on the porosity and thickness of the insulating medium, with some materials prone to greater charging than others. If large charging currents are observed, this usually indicates a poor seal between the BDD electrode and the insulating surround, and the electrode should be re-insulated or discarded. The CV response of BDD UMEs of ≤ 25 μm in diameter is largely independent of the scan rates used in conventional experiments (≤ 0.5 V s−1 ) due to the steady-state diffusion of reactant to the electrode surface. Electrodes that are recessed or “lagooned” in their insulating coating may give the expected steady state CV response at slow scan rates, but their behavior at higher scan rates may deviate. Thus, it is important that newly fabricated BDD UMEs should be tested over a range of scan rates to ensure that the geometry of the electrode is as expected. For small electrodes, it is often difficult to assess their size and geometry and the integrity of insulation under a microscope, so using simple electrochemical investigations to diagnose potential issues and obtain accurate electrode dimensions is essential.
6.4 BORON-DOPED DIAMOND UME ARRAYS
143
Boron-doped diamond electrodes have much lower background currents than similar carbon fiber and platinum UMEs and so, as expected, perform particularly well for the detection of low concentrations of analytes. BDD UMEs are particularly valuable in applications where other electrode materials become fouled or require activation in order to be effective. The performance of BDD UMEs in biological media is exemplary, having been used within animal tissue to investigate the role of adenosine in the modulation of breathing [6], serotonin as a neuromodulator [7], norepinephrine release in mesenteric artery [16], and dopamine in mouse brain [3]. Under similar experimental conditions, carbon fiber microelectrodes can become irreversibly deactivated and require polishing and pretreatment steps. The sharper BDD UMEs can also be used in SECM experiments and have been used to image the respiratory activity of immobilized living E. coli cells [13], showing the stability of the electrode during the time taken to obtain an image, its ability to withstand fouling in a biological environment, and its sensitivity to very low concentrations of analyte. The advantage to using BDD UMEs in electroanalytical and biological applications is without question, but their use in quantitative or mechanistic studies is less clear. When BDD UMEs from the same batch, fabricated using identical methods, are tested with a range of common outer-sphere redox couples—FcOH, hexaammineruthenium (Ru(NH3 )6 3+/2+ ), hexachloroiridate (IrCl6 2−/3− ), and ferrocyanide (Fe(CN)6 3−/4− ) —the electrodes often vary in their relative responses to the different couples [15]. For example, an electrode may exhibit perfect steady-state behavior, indicating fast electrode kinetics, when a CV is carried out in FcOH (as in Figure 6.1c) but perform poorly in IrCl6 2−/3− . Another electrode may give ill-defined and nonsteady-state CV responses in both of these redox solutions but perform very well in Ru(NH3 )6 3+/2+ . This variation in redox response is little understood at present; however, it has long been known that some couples usually considered to be outer sphere, in particular Fe(CN)6 3−/4− , are very sensitive to the surface termination of BDD and probably require the presence of specific surface functionalities for optimum electron transfer. Additionally, electrochemical and scanning probe investigations of larger BDD electrodes have revealed that their activity is inhomogeneous, with some areas being highly conductive and hence electrochemically active while other regions show much lower activity [17–19]. The heterogeneity in conductivity has been attributed to differences in boron accumulation of the different diamond crystal faces during growth. However, as similar heterogeneity has been noted for nanocrystalline BDD films, it is clear that several factors must play a role, including dopant distribution and surface chemistry. Regions of high and low electrochemical activity are found to cover areas of several tens of microns on the surface of planar macroelectrodes, with the same area showing a different electrochemical response to different redox couples [19]. As the exposed electroactive area of an UME is of similar (or smaller) dimensions to these regions of heterogeneity, it is not surprising that the electrochemical response of the UMEs varies considerably even within the same batch. 6.4
BORON-DOPED DIAMOND UME ARRAYS
The production of BDD microelectrode arrays is desirable in order to exploit the excellent sensitivities obtainable in electroanalytical applications. The variety of microfabrication facilities now routinely available has meant that several approaches to the production of
144
DIAMOND ULTRAMICROELECTRODES AND NANOSTRUCTURED ELECTRODES
these arrays has been reported [20–23] as well as their use in analytical applications, such as for the amperometric detection of dopamine [24], sulphate and peroxysulfate [23], and 4-nitrophenol and manganese (II) [25]. 6.4.1
Fabrication of BDD UME Arrays
Several of the reported fabrication procedures make use of photolithographic macrofabrication methods in order to produce either masks or moulds of the required geometry for the array. Tsunozaki et al. [21] patterned a Si (100) surface with photoresist, which acted as a mask while the surrounding Si was chemically etched. The resulting microstructured Si surface was then coated with BDD using conventional CVD methods. The entire surface of the deposited BDD layer was then spin-coated with an insulating polyimide layer. The BDD microelectrode array was revealed by mechanically polishing the assembly until the diamond tips were exposed. The distance between each UME was controlled by the photoresist mask and was about 250 μm; the size of each electrode was controlled by the etching conditions used to form the structured Si substrate and was about 25–30 μm in diameter. Soh et al. [22,24] have produced UME arrays of several different geometries, again using photolithography techniques to produce a mould for diamond deposition. A conducting Si substrate was coated with a 0.5 μm thick insulating SiO2 layer by thermal treatment and further coated with a 0.5 μm layer of sputtered Mo. The surface was then patterned using a standard photoresist mask and the unmasked areas of Mo and SiO2 were wet-etched away. The resulting mould was seeded with diamond nanoparticles by sonicating in a suspension, and excess diamond powder on the surface was removed by lifting off the photoresist layer. BDD was then deposited under standard CVD conditions, with the diamond preferentially nucleating and growing in the seeded recessed Si regions. Finally, the Mo layer was removed to leave the ultramicroelectrode array, with the electrodes being reported as very slightly recessed from the insulating SiO2 surround. Arrays of 10 μm × 75 μm or 2 μm × 80 μm microbands were produced, as well as square electrodes of 10 μm × 10 μm with spacings of 20 μm or 100 μm. Provent et al. [23] took a similar fabrication approach, producing an array of 106 slightly recessed 5 μm diameter BDD disk UMEs separated by 150 μm by covering a BDD film with a 0.5 μm layer of insulating silicon nitrite and exposing the microdisks by dry etching of the silicon nitrite. A very successful approach to producing an all-diamond electrochemical device has been to coat a patterned BDD array with an insulating diamond layer [20]. A 500 μm thick BDD film was polished to a mirror finish on one side, masked to define an array pattern, and then ablated in the unmasked regions using a UV laser. The result was an arrangement of BDD columnar structures of 10–25 μm in diameter, with a height of up to 50 μm and separated by about 250 μm. A layer of undoped, insulating diamond was then grown over this array to completely coat the surface. Finally, the nonconducting diamond layer was polished back to expose the tips of the BDD columns, creating a flat surface with an array of BDD UMEs embedded coplanar with the insulating diamond surround, as shown in the SEM image in Figure 6.3a. An advantage of this arrangement is that the electrode can be repeatedly cleaned and polished without structural damage to the device.
6.4 BORON-DOPED DIAMOND UME ARRAYS
145
(a)
(c)
(b)
75 nA
Height (nm)
0 nA
10 0 –10 0
20 40 60 Distance (μm)
80
(d) 4.0 3.0 2.0 1.0 0.0
it/i(∞) Figure 6.3 (a) SEM image of all-diamond BDD UME array showing ‘‘side-on’’ cross-section of conducting BDD disk embedded in insulating diamond matrix (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 20). (b) Topographic AFM image of 80 × 80 μm area of all-diamond BDD UME array showing the conductive BDD disks are coplanar with the surrounding insulating diamond. (c) Conductive AFM image taken simultaneously with image in (b) showing heterogeneity in conductivity of the BDD disk. (d) ECM image of reduction of Ru(NH3 )6 3+ at one of the BDD disks showing inhomogeneity in electrochemical activity. Figures (b), (c), and (d): (Adapted from Ref. 17.) See color insert.
146
DIAMOND ULTRAMICROELECTRODES AND NANOSTRUCTURED ELECTRODES
6.4.2
Electrochemical Performance and Applications
The ideal behavior of an array of UMEs is discussed in Section 6.2; namely, if the diffusion profiles of the individual electrodes do not overlap, the steady-state, sigmoidal CV response of an UME should be obtained, but with a limiting current proportional to the number of individual electrodes in the array. If the packing density of electrodes in the array is too high, then the individual diffusion profiles will overlap and the CV behavior of the array will approach that of a planar macroelectrode. Optimum electrode spacing was investigated by Soh and coworkers [22] for 10 μm × 75 μm microband UMEs separated by 20 μm or 100 μm, where the smaller spacing was found to result in macroelectrode behavior at most scan rates and the larger spacing indicated the expected microelectrode behavior. Simms et al. [26] investigated in some detail the electrochemical response of an all-diamond microarray device described earlier, where although calculation suggested that the diffusion profiles of the individual electrodes did not overlap, true steady-state UME behavior was not observed experimentally. For the simple one electron oxidation of Fe(CN)6 4− some scan rate dependence in the resulting CVs was observed, as well as a gentle peak on both the forward and backward scans. This may be because the individual disks were about 40 μm in diameter, which is toward the upper limit of UME dimensions and a relatively larger degree of linear diffusion to the electrode surface would be expected. An advantage of UME arrays is an increased sensitivity (better signal/noise ratio), meaning that lower detection limits are achievable than at a standard planar BDD macroelectrode, as demonstrated by Lawrence et al. [25] for direct detection of 4-nitrophenol (seven-fold increase in sensitivity observed) and the electrochemical determination of Mn(II) concentration (ten-fold lower limit of detection). All-diamond microdisk arrays were also modified with gold, silver, and copper by electrodeposition for the selective detection of arsenic, hydrogen peroxide, and nitrate respectively, with significant (six to seven times) increase in sensitivity per unit area [26]. These BDD microelectrode arrays were found to be excellent and stable substrates for modification by these different metals. Moreover, the deposits could be simply removed after use, either electrochemically or by polishing, allowing the same BDD sensor to be used for multiple analytical tasks without degradation. Such arrays have also been modified by electrodeposition of palladium for the detection of hydrazine, again achieving much higher sensitivity and lower detection limits than previously available [27]. Boron-doped diamond ultramicroelectrode arrays also have advantages for use in specific environments—for example in media of low ionic strength. Lawrence and colleagues [25] showed that a BDD UME array exhibited a defined, approximately steady-state reduction wave for Ru(NH3 )6 3+ in water in the absence of any supporting electrolyte. In contrast, a planar BDD macroelectrode did not produce a well-defined redox response under the same conditions. Provent et al. [23] showed that their BDD UME array performed well for the industrially relevant detection of sulphate and peroxodisulfate. The small size of the array, which was formed along with a crook-shaped BDD counterelectrode on a single 7 mm × 2.8 mm silicon chip, suggests its use as a maintenance free and cost-effective sensor in real industrial applications [23]. Although BDD UME arrays are very valuable for diffusion-limited amperometric detection applications, caution must be exercised in the analysis of voltammetric wave shapes. Colley et al. [17] investigated the spatial heterogeneity in electroactivity of an all-diamond BDD microarray (such as that shown in Figure 6.3a) using conducting-AFM
6.5 NANOSTRUCTURED BDD ELECTRODES
147
(C-AFM) and SECM. Each conducting microdisk within the array is made up of polycrystalline BDD with different grain orientations exposed. Boron uptake is known to vary with grain orientation and so it is not surprising that conductivity of individual grains within the same microdisk was found to vary. Figures 6.3b and 6.3c show simultaneously recorded C-AFM topographic and conductivity images for a single microdisk BDD electrode embedded in an insulating diamond matrix. The mirror finish of the alldiamond microarray is demonstrated clearly in this image, where a surface roughness of only about 10 nm was observed; the BDD disk, however, could readily be distinguished from the nonconducting diamond surround and individual grains easily discriminated. The conductivity image shows clear heterogeneity both from grain to grain and within a single grain. The most conductive grains exhibited metallic conductivity when their current-voltage characteristics were investigated; in contrast, the less conductive regions indicated p-type semiconductivity. The influence of this heterogeneity on electroactivity was investigated using SECM, by imaging the production of Ru(NH3 )6 2+ by the microelectrode disks (electrogenerated by reduction of Ru(NH3 )6 3+ ). Most disks showed a similar (high) level of activity, but it was clear that some electrodes were much less electrochemically active. High-resolution imaging of the electroactivity of one of the less active disks showed clear variations in electroactivity over the electrode, as shown in Figure 6.3d. Only part of the electrode exhibited the currents expected at a metallic electrode, with the variation in electron transfer kinetics most likely linked to the differences in conductivity of the individual grains. For this reason, care should be take in kinetic analysis of voltammetric measurements using these arrays, as the variation in electroactivity will be even more significant at lower electrode overvoltages. 6.5
NANOSTRUCTURED BDD ELECTRODES
Random arrays of BDD nanodisk electrodes may be prepared by selective insulation of a planar BDD macroelectrode, using a similar approach to UME array fabrication [28]. However, the mass transport and hence voltammetric characteristics of nanoarrays vary significantly from UME arrays, as will be discussed in Section 6.5.1. An alternative reported approach is to nanostructure existing BDD films by formation of vertically aligned BDD nanowires on the surface. Production of diamond nanowires was realized some time ago with suggested applications in advanced composites, thermal management, field emission, and microelectronics. However, only very recently have nanostructured BDD films been fabricated to allow their use in electrochemical and biosensing applications [29–31]. In contrast to UME arrays, where conducting BDD electrodes are embedded within an insulating matrix, the entire surface of the nanostructured electrode is exposed and electrochemically active. The electrochemical characteristics, and in particular the mass transport behavior, are thus quite complicated, with greater similarity to a porous macroelectrode than to a microelectrode array. Perhaps as a consequence of this, or also due to nanoscale or even atomic scale morphological and chemical modifications to the diamond surface, the electrochemical response toward some analytes is very different to that at a planar macroscopic BDD electrode. 6.5.1
Random Array BDD Nanodisk Electrodes
A random array of BDD nanodisk electrodes has been prepared by a three-step process [28]. First, a conventional BDD electrode was modified by electrodeposition of
148
DIAMOND ULTRAMICROELECTRODES AND NANOSTRUCTURED ELECTRODES
molybdenum dioxide nanoparticles. The entirety of this modified electrode was then coated in an insulating polymer film layer by the electropolymerisation of 4-nitrophenyldiazonium salt. Finally, the molybdenum oxide nanoparticles were dissolved from the surface using dilute HCl. This step also results in the removal of the polymer film directly above the nanoparticles and hence the exposure of nanodisks of BDD of 20 ± 10 nm in diameter. This method is reported as producing 650 ± 25 million BDD nanodisks per cm2 . Due to the high density of nanodisks, the diffusion profiles of each individual electrode overlap, with the result that diffusion to the surface is linear. The CV response is thus that of a macroelectrode with the maximum current achievable being that of the geometric area of the electrode (i.e., the area of the BDD electrode before modification)—despite most of the surface being covered with an insulating layer. In contrast, the background capacitive current of the nanoarray electrode is significantly reduced compared to the bare BDD, as most of the surface is insulated. This provides significant benefits in the electroanalytical detection of small concentrations of analytes. 6.5.2
Fabrication of Nanostructured BDD Arrays
Two different approaches to the fabrication of BDD nanoarrays have been used to date: the “top-down” formation of nanowires using reactive ion etching (RIE) of a conventional BDD film [29,30] and the “bottom-up” growth of nanostructures on a silicon nanowire template [31]. In the first method, smooth highly doped BDD films are exposed to oxygen plasma, and unmasked areas of the diamond film are etched away to form gaseous CO2 and CO, leaving an array of BDD nanostructures under the masked regions. Yang et al. [29] used a layer of 8–10 nm diamond nanoparticles as the etching mask, which they formed by sonicating the diamond film in a suspension of diamond nanoparticles. The seeded nanoparticle layer is dense, and after RIE treatment vertically aligned nanowires arise where the nanoparticles were deposited. The length of the BDD nanowires depends on the nature of the mask and the time of the plasma treatment—the etching rate of the ´˚ s−1 , meaning that a 10 nm particle will act as a diamond nanoparticles is about 10 A mask for 10 s before being etched away. Therefore, the optimum geometric dimensions of the nanostructures formed after 10 s etching time is 10 nm length nanowires with about 10 nm separation between them and diameters of 1–5 nm (determined by tapping mode AFM measurements). If the time of plasma treatment is increased past the lifetime of the masking layer, then the newly formed nanowires also begin to be etched away, eventually resulting in a smooth film. If silicon nanoparticles are used as a mask, the length of the nanowires can be increased to several microns, as the etching rate of silicon ´˚ s−1 . in the oxygen plasma is only 1 A Wei et al. [30] have taken a different approach for the formation of a BDD “nanograss array” using oxygen plasma RIE. No etching mask was used in this case; it was assumed that in the oxygen plasma environment boron oxide species form on the film surface at boron-rich sites and were themselves able to act as a mask. The boron oxides are less volatile than the CO and CO2 species formed from diamond etching, and so in the early stages of treatment remain on the surface while the surrounding area is etched. Eventually, they too are removed, but tend to redeposit near the tops of the nanostructures and continue to serve as a mask. Final dimensions of the nanograss array (determined
149
6.5 NANOSTRUCTURED BDD ELECTRODES
by SEM) after about 10 min etching time were 20 nm diameter, 200 nm length, and a separation of 50 nm between structures. Luo and Zhi [31] used a more conventional CVD growth approach to the formation of BDD “nanorod forest electrodes,” Electroless metal deposition of silicon onto a p-type (100) silicon wafer was carried out to form a silicon nanowire (SiNW) array, which was used as the substrate for the HFCVD growth of a BDD film. SEM investigation showed complete and continuous coverage of the polycrystalline diamond film over the whole length of the SiNW. This resulted in the formation of vertically aligned BDD nanorods of several microns in length and about 100–500 μm in diameter, with similar spacing between structures, as shown in Figures 6.4a and b. 6.5.3 Electrochemical Performance and Applications of Nanostructured BDD Electrodes The interfacial electronic properties of the nanorod arrays produced by Yang et al. [29] using RIE were assessed using capacitance (C)–voltage (V) measurements and analysis using the Mott-Schottky equation. The active sensor area was estimated to be about 1.3–2.0 times that of the smooth electrode before plasma treatment, which was consistent with the estimated geometric area calculated from AFM images. Additionally, the builtin potential of the BDD surface was found to increase significantly from the 1.7 V of the hydrogen-terminated smooth BDD film, to 3.2 V for the oxygen-terminated plasma treated surface where many surface defects were generated. These BDD nanorod arrays were utilized as DNA biosensors in order to detect DNA hybridization, reaching a detection level of single-base mismatch [32]. The formation of the DNA biosensor relied on a unique property of these nanostructured films. Because of the surface morphology of the nanoarrays, current density is greatest at the very tip of the nanorods allowing selective electrochemical modification of the tips of the nanorods, while the remaining electrode area is unchanged. The first step in the formation of the sensor is the electrochemical attachment of aminophenyl linker molecules to the tip of the nanorods, first by electrochemical reduction and grafting of the corresponding nitrophenyl diazonium salt to form a layer of immobilized nitrophenyl groups, followed by their electrochemical reduction to the aminophenyl moieties. Single-stranded DNA molecules can then be cross-linked to
(a)
10
(b)
(c)
Current (µA)
8 500 nm
Nanoforest BDD 6 4 2 planar BDD
10 µm
1 µm
0 0.0
0.2
0.4 0.6 Potential (V)
0.8
Figure 6.4 (a) and (b) SEM images of ‘‘nanoforest’’ BDD array. (c) Linear sweep voltammogram for the oxidation of glucose at a planar BDD electrode and a nanoforest BDD electrode. (Adapted from Ref. 33.)
150
DIAMOND ULTRAMICROELECTRODES AND NANOSTRUCTURED ELECTRODES
the aminophenyl groups. As only the very tips of the nanostructures are modified in this way, the remaining electrode area is available for electrochemical detection of solution redox probes. When the DNA is in its single-stranded form, negatively charged redox probes such as Fe(CN)6 3−/4− can readily diffuse through the strands to the underlying unmodified electrode where it can be detected voltammetrically. However, when the DNA is hybridized with its target DNA strand, the larger size and increased negative charge of the double-stranded DNA blocks the passage of the Fe(CN)6 3−/4− probe to the electrode surface. The resulting decrease in current can be used as an indicator of DNA hybridization. The nanostructure of this electrode is essential to its operation; if a planar BDD electrode is used, the initial deposition of the aminophenyl linker groups occurs indiscriminately over the whole electrode surface, blocking the electrode and preventing any redox response to Fe(CN)6 3−/4− . It is the ability to modify only the tips of the nanorods while leaving the remaining electrode area unblocked and available for electrochemical sensing that makes these electrodes so promising for biosensing applications. The “nanograss array” electrodes developed by Wei et al. [30] were used for the detection of dopamine and uric acid. In comparison to an oxidized planar BDD film, oxidation of both species took place at a less positive applied potential and higher peak currents were obtained. This is indicative of increased electrocatalytic activity and faster rates of electron transfer, perhaps due to the formation of more active sites, as well as increased electrode area. These observations would suggest that nanostructuring of electrodes may also result in activation of the electrode toward some analytes, by providing additional sites for adsorption and catalysis. Similarly, Luo, Wu, and Zhi [33] used their “nanorod forest” electrodes for the oxidation of adenine and direct amperometric (non-enzymatic) detection of glucose, as shown in Figure 6.4c [33], where in comparison to the equivalent planar BDD much greater sensitivity and selectivity toward the analytes was observed. The authors attribute this advantage to the high surface area and porosity of the nanoarray electrode, as the Faradaic currents for the kinetically sluggish oxidation of glucose will depend on the nanoscopic area of the electrode rather than its geometric area.
6.6
CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE DIRECTIONS
Several different strategies for the fabrication of single BDD UMEs and arrays of microand nanostructured BDD electrodes are available, allowing these electrodes to be used in a wide range of applications. The advantage of BDD for many of these uses is unquestionable—its biocompatibility and sensitivity to low concentrations of analytes lends its use to in vivo applications in particular. Several areas can be identified as particularly promising for future application of BDD UMEs—for example, in the use of surface modified electrodes (e.g., with metals or enzymes) for sensing of specific analytes. In order to optimize the use of BDD UMEs, further work is required in understanding the fundamental behavior of these electrodes, especially the factors that contribute to observed variation in electrochemical activity. Although research into nanostructured diamond electrodes is at a very early stage, the unusual sensitivity of these films to analytes such as glucose that are not readily detected at planar electrodes is very interesting and suggests future applications in biosensing. As micro- and nanofabrication technologies advance and become more available, it is likely that even more sophisticated BDD electrodes on a ultramicro- and nanoscale will be achievable.
REFERENCES
151
REFERENCES 1. J. Cvacka, V. Quaiserova, J.W. Park, Y. Show, A. Muck, G.M. Swain, Anal. Chem. 2003, 75 , 2678–2687. 2. D. Shin, B.V. Sarada, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, Anal. Chem. 2003, 75 , 530–534. 3. A. Suzuki, T.A. Ivandini, K. Yoshimi, A. Fujishima, G. Oyama, T. Nakazato, N. Hattori, S. Kitazawa, Y. Einaga, Anal. Chem. 2007, 79 , 8608–8615. 4. J. Park, V. Quaiserova-Mocko, B.A. Patel, M. Novotny, A.H. Liu, X. C. Bian, J.J. Galligan, G.M. Swain, Analysis 2008, 133 , 17–24. 5. B.A. Patel, X.C. Bian, V. Quaiserova-Mocko, J.J. Galligan, G.M. Swain, Analysis 2007, 132 , 41–47. 6. J.M. Halpern, S. Xie, G.P. Sutton, B.T. Higashikubo, C.A. Chestek, H. Lu, H.J. Chiel, H.B. Martin, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2006, 15 , 183–187. 7. S. Xie, G. Shafer, C.G. Wilson, H.B. Martin, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2006, 15 , 225–228. 8. A.J. Bard, L.R. Faulkner, Electrochemical Methods Fundamentals and Applications, 2nd ed., John Wiley and Sons, 2001, pp. 168–176. 9. A.J. Bard, M.V. Mirkin, eds., Scanning Electrochemical Microscopy, Marcel Dekker, New York, 2001. 10. D. Shoup, A. Szabo, J. Electroanal. Chem, 1984, 160 , 27–31. 11. J.B. Cooper, S. Pang, S. Albin, J. Zheng, R.M. Johnson, Anal. Chem. 1998, 70 , 464–467. 12. B.V. Sarada, T.N. Rao, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1999, 146 , 1469–1471. 13. K.B. Holt, J.P. Hu, J.S. Foord, Anal. Chem. 2007, 79 , 2556–2561. 14. J.P. Hu, J.S. Foord, K.B. Holt, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2007, 9 , 5469–5475. 15. J.P. Hu, K.B. Holt, J.S. Foord, Anal. Chem. 2009, 81 , 5663–5670. 16. J.W. Park, Y. Show, V. Quaiserova, J.J. Galligan, G.D. Fink, G.M. Swain, J. Electroanal. Chem. 2005, 583 , 56–68. 17. A.L. Colley, C.G. Williams, U. D’Haenens Johansson, M.E. Newton, P.R. Unwin, N.R. Wilson, J.V. Macpherson, Anal. Chem. 2006, 78 , 2539–2548. 18. (a) K.B. Holt, A.J. Bard, Y. Show, G.M. Swain, J. Phys. Chem. B 2004, 108 , 15117–15127. (b) N.R. Wilson, S.L. Clewes, M.E. Newton, P.R. Unwin, J.V. Macpherson, J. Phys. Chem. B 2006, 110 , 5639–5646. (c) K. Honda, T. Noda, M. Yoshimura, K. Nakagawa, A. Fujishima, J. Phys. Chem. B 2004, 108 , 16117–16127. (d) S. Szunerits, M. Mermoux, A. Crisci, B. Marcus, P. Bouvier, D. Delabouglise, J.-P. Petit, S. Janel, R. Boukherroub, L. Tay, J. Phys. Chem. B 2006, 110 , 23888–23897. 19. S. Wang, G.M. Swain, J. Phys. Chem. C 2007, 111 , 3986–3995. 20. M. Pagels, C.E. Hall, N.S. Lawrence, A. Meredith, T.G.J. Jones, H.P. Godfried, C.S.J. Pickles, J. Wilman, C.E. Banks, R.G. Compton, L. Jiang, Anal. Chem. 2005, 77 , 3705–3708. 21. K. Tsunozaki, Y. Einaga, T.N. Rao, A. Fujishima, Chem. Lett . 2002, 502–503. 22. (a) K.L. Soh, W.P. Kang, J.L. Davidson, S. Basu, Y.M. Wong, D.E. Cliffel, A.B. Bonds, G.M. Swain, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2004, 13 , 2009–2015. (b) K.L. Soh, W.P. Kang, J.L. Davidson, Y.M. Wong, D.E. Cliffel, G.M. Swain, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2008, 17 , 240–246. 23. C. Provent, W. Haenni, E. Santoli, P. Rychen, Electrochim. Acta 2004, 49 , 3737–3744. 24. K.L. Soh, W.P. Kang, J.L. Davidson, Y.M. Wong, D.E. Cliffel, G.M. Swain, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2008, 17 , 900–905. 25. N.S. Lawrence, M. Pagels, A. Meredith, T.G.J. Jones, C.E. Hall, C.S.J. Pickles, H.P. Godfried, C.E. Banks, R.G. Compton, L. Jiang, Talanta 2006, 69 , 829–834. 26. A.O. Simms, C.E. Banks, S. Ward-Jones, T.J. Davies, N.S. Lawrence, T.G.J. Jones, L. Jiang, R.G. Compton, Analyst 2005, 130 , 1303–1311.
152
DIAMOND ULTRAMICROELECTRODES AND NANOSTRUCTURED ELECTRODES
27. C. Batchelor-McAuley, C.E. Banks, A.O. Simm, T.G.J. Jones, R.G. Compton, Analyst 2006, 131 , 106–110. 28. L. Xiao, I. Streeter, G.G. Wildgoose, R.G. Compton, Sens. Actuators B 2008, 133 , 118–127. 29. N. Yang, H. Uetsuka, E. Osawa, C.E. Nebel, Nano Lett . 2008, 8, 3572–3576. 30. M. Wei, C. Terashima, M. Lv, A. Fujishima, Z.-Z. Gu, Chem. Comm. 2009, 3624–3626. 31. D. Luo, J. Zhi, Electrochem. Commun. 2009, 11 , 1093–1096. 32. (a) N. Yang, H. Uetsuka, C.E. Nebel, Adv. Funct. Mater. 2009, 19 , 887–893. (b) C.E. Nebel, N. Yang, H. Uetsuka, E. Osawa, N. Tokuda, O. Williams, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2009, 18 , 910–917. 33. D. Luo, L. Wu, J. Zhi, ACS Nano 2009, 3 , 2121–2128.
Part III
Electroanalytical Applications
7 Electroanalytical Applications of Diamond Films Weena Siangproh, Amara Apilux, Pimkwan Chantarateepra, and Orawon Chailapakul
7.1
INTRODUCTION
The success of an electrochemical-sensing process relies mainly on the careful choice of electrodes. An ideal electrode should exhibit several features: It should be mechanically stable, chemically inert, and have a wide range of potential and an easily reproducible surface. Electrode materials and designs can be classified into two main categories: solid electrodes and liquid electrodes. Metal electrodes offer very fast electron transfer, but the available working potential window is often quite narrow due to the onset of background reactions, such as metal oxidation and oxygen and hydrogen gas evolution. Alternatively, various types of graphite and carbon materials (e.g., glassy carbon), offer significantly wider working potential ranges. Although a number of different types of carbon materials have been applied to electrochemical methods, there are specific characteristics that electrochemists would like to see improved, such as the undesired adsorption of electroactive species from solution, the undesirably large capacitive background current and oxidation current at higher potentials, and the lack of mechanical ruggedness. Therefore, there remains a need for new, selective, sensitive, and mechanically stable materials.
Synthetic Diamond Films: Preparation, Electrochemistry, Characterization, and Applications, First Edition. Edited by Enric Brillas and Carlos Alberto Mart´ınez-Huitle. © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Published 2011 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
155
156
ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS OF DIAMOND FILMS
Since the early twentieth century, synthetic conductive diamond thin films, a new carbon material, have been increasingly used and reported [1–6]. In addition, there has been a growing interest in the use of boron-doped diamond (BDD) electrodes in various applications. The BDD electrode is one of the best insulators; boron is utilized as a thin metal film in diamond, at levels between 1016 and 1021 cm−3 , with activation energies down to less than one-tenth of an electron volt. Conductivity can be fine-tuned for a variety of purposes. Therefore, boron-doped diamond is one of the most promising new materials for electroanalytical measurements. The BDD electrode possesses electrochemically attractive properties compared to other electrodes, including low and stable voltammetric background currents [7]. The currents for double-layer charging are quite small due to the low number of carriers and the nearly complete lack of porosity. These attributes make the BDD electrode well suited for current-based electrochemical measurements. Other attractive features include wide working potential window in aqueous electrolyte solution, low adsorption of polar molecules from aqueous solution, long-term response stability, and good activity without any pretreatment. Because of the unique properties of BDD electrodes, they have been widely used in various applications. Therefore, the use of diamond as an electrode material in electrochemistry has been summarized up through early 2006 [8]. In this chapter, we provide a detailed, up-to-date, and compact review covering nearly all aspects of electroanalytical application using boron-diamond electrodes from late 2006 until now.
7.2
PHARMACEUTICAL COMPOUNDS
Pharmaceutical compounds are the usual form of prescribed medicines. In addition to the benefits of these medicines, they may have side effects that can be very serious, so quality control of the active ingredient is required. In pharmacokinetic studies, the levels of pharmaceuticals in biological fluids can provide information about treatment to biomedical scientists. However, the successful exploitation of such an approach is dependent on the availability of analytical techniques that can provide fast quantitative measurements of the concentrations of various therapeutic substances. Electroanalytical chemistry has an important place in contemporary chemical analysis because of its large potential for possible applications. In comparison to other instrumental methods, electroanalytical chemistry offers a great variety of advantages, including high sensitivity, simplicity, quickness, low cost, and relatively easy detector miniaturization. Electrochemical methods using boron-doped diamond electrodes have been successfully applied to analyze pharmaceutical compounds, and some examples follow. In 2006, Karuwan et al. [9] reported the construction and application of boron-doped diamond thin film electrodes as sensors for pharmaceutical analysis. A flow injection system with pulsed amperometric detection (PAD) for anti-fouling of the BDD electrode was developed for the determination of three beta-agonists: salbutamol, terbutaline, and clenbuterol. A linear response was obtained in the concentration ranges of 0.5–100 μM, 1.0–100 μM and 0.5–50 μM for salbutamol, terbutaline, and clenbuterol, respectively. The developed PAD-BDD system was applied to determine salbutamol and terbutaline in commercial pharmaceutical products. In 2007, Oliveira et al. [10] reported an electroanalytical method to detect lidocaine using boron-doped diamond electrodes by cyclic voltammetry (CV) and square-wave
7.2 PHARMACEUTICAL COMPOUNDS
157
voltammetry (SWV). Lidocaine is an active ingredient in many commercial local anesthetic products. Because of its widespread use, the development of a new analytical method is required. From the results, an irreversible oxidation peak of lidocaine in 0.1 M Britton-Robinson buffer was observed at 1.68 V versus Ag/AgCl. The detection and quantification limits obtained from pure water were 10.0 μg L−1 and 34.4 μg L−1 , respectively. Furthermore, the electrochemical responses of lidocaine in pharmaceutical preparations were also determined. The results obtained were in agreement with those determined by standard methods. The presence of propyleneglycol as interference in the gels samples had no effect on the voltammetric responses. Lidocaine recoveries ranged from 97.6 to 99.2%. Next, Topal, Uslu, and Ozkan [11] reported the method for electroanalytical investigation of atorvastatin calcium at boron-doped diamond electrodes using voltammetry. The electrooxidation of atorvastatin was irreversible and exhibited a diffusion-controlled behavior. A linear response was obtained in the range of 9.65 × 10−7 M to 3.86 × 10−5 M in 0.1M H2 SO4 with detection limits of 2.27 × 10−7 M and 1.31 × 10−7 M with differential pulse voltammetry (DPV) and square-wave voltammetry (SWV), respectively. The methodology was successfully validated and applied to a high-throughput process for detection of atorvastatin in tablets, human serum, and human urine with good recovery and repeatability. Interestingly, BBD electrodes also displayed excellent behavior for the determination of fluvastatin in pharmaceutical formulations and human serum without any requirements for separation or complex sample preparation [12]. The electrooxidation of fluvastatin sodium at a boron-doped diamond electrode was investigated using cyclic, differential pulse, and square-wave voltammetry. The oxidation of fluvastatin was irreversible and exhibited a diffusion-controlled manner. The results indicated that a linear dynamic range was observed from 1 × 10−6 M to 6 × 10−4 M in a Britton-Robinson buffer solution (pH 10.0), with a detection limit of 1.37 × 10−7 M by DPV and 1.44 × 10−7 M by SWV. The RSD values obtained were 0.66% and 0.15% for the peak currents with DPV and SWV, respectively. In 2008, many researchers reported on the use of boron-doped diamond electrodes for electroanlytical purpose. Uslu, Topal, and Ozkan [13] proposed the electrooxidation for the determination of pefloxacin in pharmaceuticals, and serum at boron-doped diamond and glassy carbon electrodes using cyclic, linear sweep, differential pulse, and squarewave voltammetry. Using cyclic voltammetry, the oxidation peak was irreversible and exhibited a diffusion-controlled behavior. Linearity was obtained in the concentration range of 2 × 10−6 M to 2 × 10−4 M in 0.5 M H2 SO4 at about 1.20 V versus Ag/AgCl for DPV and SWV. The potential applicability of these methods was measured by successful determination of this drug in pharmaceutical dosage forms and human serum samples with good recovery results, reproducibility, precision, and accuracy. There was no interference from the excipients and other substances in the determination of these real samples. Additionally, two sulfonamides—sulfadiazine and sulfamethoxazole—were independently quantified in pharmaceutical products by SWV using a boron-doped diamond electrode by Souza et al. [14]. A well-resolved irreversible oxidation peak was observed at around 1.1 V of sulfadiazine in ethanol + 0.5 M H2 SO4 (50/50 v/v) and of sulfamethoxazole in ethanol + pH 6.0 phosphate buffer (50/50 v/v) solutions. Linearity was observed in concentration ranges from 8.01 × 10−6 M to 1.19 × 10−4 M (r = 0.9995) for sulfadiazine and 6.10 × 10−6 M to 6.01 × 10−5 M (r = 0.9995) for sulfamethoxazole
158
ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS OF DIAMOND FILMS
with detection limits of 2.19 × 10−6 M and 1.15 × 10−6 M, respectively. For both sulfonamides’ detection, the accuracy of the proposed methodology had no statistical error when compared to those of standard HPLC methods. The recoveries obtained were 95–104%. These findings indicated that the proposed electroanalytical method is attractive and suitable for the determination of sulfa drugs in pharmaceuticals and other products. In addition, Andrade et al. [15] proposed the simultaneous determination of sulfamethoxazole and trimethoprim in pharmaceutical products. The hydrogen-terminated (HT) and oxygen-terminated (OT) BDD electrodes were used in order to investigate the electrooxidation of these compounds. The HT-BDD electrode demonstrated two well-defined oxidation peaks, and the oxidation current peak increased 20-fold when compared to those of the OT-BDD electrode. The calculated limit of detection (LOD) values for sulfamethoxazole and trimethoprim using the HT-BDD electrode were 3.65 μg L−1 and 3.92 μg L−1 , respectively. Wei et al. [16] reported on the investigation of electrochemical oxidation of procaine hydrochloride (PC center dot HCL, 2-diethylaminoethyl 4-aminobenzoate hydrochloride) at an as-deposited boron-doped diamond electrode, anodically oxidized BDD (ao-BDD) electrode, and glassy carbon (GC) electrode by cyclic voltammetry (CV). The cyclic voltammograms showed the oxidation of PC center dot HCL with a high signal-tobackground ratio, low tendency for adsorption, good reproducibility, and long-term stability at the BDD electrode. Good linearity was observed for a concentration range from 5 μM to 200 μM and a detection limit of 0.5 μM was achieved. Radovan, Cofan, and Cinghita [17] used BDD electrodes to simultaneously determine l-ascorbic acid (AA) and acetaminophen (AC) by several techniques, including cyclic voltammetry (CV), chronoamperometry (CA), and differential pulse voltammetry (DPV). Using differential pulse voltammetry, the relationship between the concentration and peak current was linear for both analytes in the 0.01–0.1 mM concentration range with very high correlation coefficients. The relative standard deviation of 2–3% and high sensitivities were obtained from the DPV data in single and dicomponent systems. In the same year, similar studies were conducted using CV and CA for the simultaneous determination of ascorbic acid and acetaminophen [18]. Both techniques provided good linearity for each of the investigated compounds in single and dicomponent solutions within concentrations of 0.01–0.1 mM with very good correlation parameters. High sensitivity values and 2–3% RSDs were obtained. In conclusion of this work, the BDD electrode was identified as an excellent promising material for the simultaneous determination of AA and AC in real sample solutions from pharmaceutical products. The electrochemical oxidation of promethazine hydrochloride at highly boron-doped diamond electrodes using square-wave adsorptive voltammetry was investigated by Ribeiro et al. [19]. This analyte provided two oxidation peaks. The second peak was generated from the formation of the adsorbed product. The parameters were optimized and the highest current intensities were obtained by applying a potential at 0.78 V for 30 s. The best conditions were obtained at pH 4.0 using Britton-Robinson buffer, a frequency of 50 s−1 , a step of 2 mV, and an amplitude of 50 mV. The linear dynamic response was obtained for the concentration range of 5.96 × 10−7 M to 4.76 × 10−6 M, with detection limits of 2.66 × 10−8 M (8.51 μg L−1 ) for peak 1 and of 4.61 × 10−8 M (14.77 μg L−1 ) for peak 2. Altogether these results indicated that the method was stable, sensitive, and reproducible. Then, in 2009, the determination of acetylsalicylic acid (ASA) in pharmaceutical formulations using boron-doped diamond electrodes was reported by Sartori et al. [20].
7.3 BIOMOLECULES OR BIOLOGICAL COMPOUNDS
159
This method was applied to determine ASA in 0.01 M H2 SO4 by SWV without the need of a previous time-consuming alkaline hydrolysis step. An irreversible oxidation peak at 1.97 V versus Ag/AgCl (in 3.0 M KCl) was observed. The concentration curve was linear from 2.50 × 10−6 M to 1.05 × 10−4 M with a detection limit of 2.0 × 10−6 M. The relative standard deviation values were smaller than 1.4% for a 45 μM ASA solution (n = 10). This method was successfully applied for the determination of ASA in several pharmaceutical formulations. The reports on these studies confirmed that BDD electrodes can be used to determine many active ingredients in various pharmaceutical compounds. The proposed methods showed excellent performances and great potential for application in control processes.
7.3
BIOMOLECULES OR BIOLOGICAL COMPOUNDS
The use of boron-doped diamond electrodes to detect biomolecules has also been a frequently published topic because of their important role in biological system. Due to the overwhelming amount of literature available, biomolecules is another growing trend in this field. Beginning in 2006, the unmodified boron-doped diamond electrode was the first to be used successfully for the simultaneous measurement of tryptophan (Trp) and tyrosine (Tyr) by differential pulse voltammetry [21]. The oxidation peaks of Trp and Tyr using a Na2 PO4 /NaOH buffer solution pH 11.2 were completely separated at a BDD electrode. The detection limits of Trp and Tyr were 1 × 10−5 M and 1 × 10−6 M, respectively. This method was also used for the determination of real amino acid samples. In 2007, Zhaom Li, and Li [22] reported on the use of the BDD electrode without further modification for selective detection of dopamine (DA) in the presence of ascorbic acid (AA) by differential pulse voltammetry. The oxidative peaks of DA and AA were separated by 0.44 V at the BDD electrode, whereas these two peaks cannot be separated at the glassy carbon electrode. The results showed high sensitivity and a detection limit of 1.1 × 10−6 M in a 200-fold excess of AA in acidic media. This method was also applied to determine DA in real samples. In a related report, BDD microelectrodes were used for the in vivo analysis of dopamine in mouse brain by differential pulse voltammetry [23]. The BDD microelectrodes with very small tips (5 μm diameter and 250 μm long) were fabricated by depositing BDD on chemically etched micrometer-sized tungsten wires using microwave plasma-assisted chemical vapor deposition. These microelectrodes were inserted into the corpus striatum of the mouse brain. The results showed a clear signal for DA following electrical stimulation of dopaminergic neurons, suggesting that the BDD microelectrode is a promising electrode for future in vivo electroanalysis. Consequently, in the same year, the electrochemical behavior of native and thermally denatured fish DNA was explored using a boron-doped diamond thin film electrode with cyclic voltammetry by Apilux, Tabata, and Chailapakul [24]. The BDD electrode is advantageous for measuring currents less than 1 μA for DNA solutions due to its low background current. The results of the thermally denatured fish DNA showed two clear oxidation peaks due to the oxidation of guanine and adenine at about 1.1 V versus Ag/AgCl and 1.3 V versus Ag/AgCl, respectively. In contrast, native fish DNA showed a poor oxidation peak at 1.1 V versus. Ag/AgCl (see Figure 7.1). In addition, the electrochemical behavior of thermally denatured fish DNA was studied in the presence of cytosine, cytidine, cytidine-5-monophosphate, tetrakis (1-methylpyridinium-4yl) porphyrin (H2 (TMPyP)4+ ), and RuII(TMPyP)4+ .
160
ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS OF DIAMOND FILMS
Current (μA)
1.8 1.3
Current(μA)
2.3
0.8
5 4 3 2 1 0 –1 –2 –0.7
–0.2
0.3
0.8
1.3
1.8
Potential (V) vs. Ag/AgCl
0.3 –0.2 –0.7 –0.7
–0.2
0.3
0.8
1.3
1.8
Potential (V) vs. Ag/AgCl Figure 7.1 Cyclic voltammograms of 1 mM in base pair of the thermally denatured fish DNA in 0.2 M acetate buffer pH 4.6 at BDD electrode at scan rate 0.01 Vs−1 . Inset: 1 mM in bp the native fish DNA in 0.2 M acetate buffer pH 4.6 at BDD electrode at scan rate 0.01 Vs−1 . The background cyclic voltammograms are also shown (dashed line). (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 24.)
Next, Fortin et al. [25] reported on the use of BDD electrodes to study the electrochemical oxidation of 2 -deoxyguanosine. Interestingly, the BDD electrode showed excellent mechanical properties for the investigation of 2 -deoxyguanosine that is not easily electrochemically detectable on other electrodes. The oxidation peaks of 2 -deoxyguanosine and 2 -deoxyadenosine were detected at potentials of 1.1 and 1.4 V versus Ag/AgCl, respectively. Moreover, small nucleoside concentrations could be detected because of the low background-to-signal ratio. Furthermore, the attractive behavior and advantages of a boron-doped diamond electrode for HPLC amperometric detection were noticed. Ivandini et al. [26] reported the simultaneous detection of purine and pyrimidine bases in mild acidic media by BDD electrodes. As-deposited (AD) and anodically oxidized (AO) BDD electrodes were used to study the electrochemistry property of the analytes by cyclic voltammetry. Under the optimized conditions for HPLC, the linear range of the calibration curves was from 0.1 μM to 10 μM, with limits of detection from 26.3 μM to 162.1 nM. The sensitivity was an order of magnitude higher than when using the conventional electrodes, and this method was successfully applied for the determination of 5-methylcytosine in real DNA samples with high reproducibility. In 2008, the conductive boron-doped diamond electrodes were also successfully demonstrated for the direct electrochemical detection of proteins, including bovine serum albumin (BSA) and immunosuppressive acidic protein (IAP, a cancer marker) [27]. Cyclic voltammetric results suggested that cysteine, tyrosine. and tryptophan contribute to the direct electrochemical oxidation at BDD electrodes. A linear dynamic response in the range of 10 to 100 μg mL−1 (r = 0.9) with a low detection limit of 10 μg mL−1 was achieved for BSA. For IAP detection, the linearity was observed from 200 to 800 μg mL−1 with a detection limit of 100 μg mL−1 . The excellent reproducibility was demonstrated with an RSD value of 5%. In addition, in 2009, a BDD thin film electrode with amperometric detection was used to detect biphenyl amino derivatives (2-aminobiphenyl, 3-aminobiphenyl, and
7.3 BIOMOLECULES OR BIOLOGICAL COMPOUNDS
161
4-aminobiphenyl) in model drinking and river water samples [28]. The separation of studied analytes was performed at a ChiraDex column (Merck, Germany) with chemically bonded P-cyclodextrin in a mobile phase aqueous buffer/acetonitrile/methanol (40/30/30, v/v/v). The separation time of six minutes was achieved. Nanomolar limits of quantitation were obtained. To enhance sensitivity and selectivity for the detection of various species, the modification of BDD electrode surface has been extensively investigated. Biosensers are the example of surface modification by attachment of organic functional groups and biomolecules. In addition, biosensors based on the use of BDD electrodes with enzymatic immobilized for enhancing the sensitivity of electrochemical analytical applications in conjunction with the specificity of biological recognition have been gaining interest recently. A mediator-free glucose biosensor, termed a third-generation biosensor, was fabricated by immobilizing glucose oxidase (GOD) directly onto a BDD electrode [29]. Glucose was determined in the absence of a mediator. The effects of the response of the biosensor in response to pH, applied potential, and cross-linking time were investigated in order to optimize the performance of the sensor. The biosensor responded to glucose within an analysis time of 5 s and provided acceptable results for lifetime, reproducibility, and measurement repeatability. The calibration curve was linear in the glucose concentration range of 6.67 × 10−5 to 2 × 10−3 M with a detection limit of 2.31 × 10−5 M. The alternative method of a protein immunosensor has been developed at boron-doped diamond (BDD) electrode material [30]. To construct the base of the immunosensor, oaminobenzoic acid (o-ABA) was electropolymerized at an electrode by cyclic voltammetry. After polymerization, the poly-o-ABA-modified BDD was characterized by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). The XPS result found that carboxyl groups were formed at the electrode surface. The carboxyl groups were then used to covalently attach protein probes. The amperometric sensing of mouse IgG (MIgG) was selected as the model at the poly-o-ABA-modified BDD to compare to the poly-o-ABA-modified glassy carbon (GC) at the same condition. An antimouse IgG from goat (GaMIgG) was covalently immobilized at a poly-o-ABA-modified BDD electrode that used a sandwich-type alkaline phosphatase (ALP) catalyzing amperometric immunoassay with 2-phospho-L-ascorbic acid (AAP) as substrate. The ALP enzyme conjugated at the immunosensor can generate AAP to the electroactive species of ascorbic acid, which can be determined by amperometric detection. The signal was found to be proportional with the quantity of MIgG. It also was found that the dynamic range of 3 orders of magnitude (1–1000 ng mL−1 ) was obtained as displayed in Figure 7.2. The examples of surface oxidation and the deposition of metal or metal oxide particles, including the selective detection of dopamine (DA) in the presence of ascorbic acid (AA) on the bare and gold nanoparticle/polyelectrolyte-coated polystyrene colloid modified BDD electrode, were studied [31]. The cyclic voltammetric results indicated a high electrocatalytic activity and strong enhancement of the DA oxidation. The detection limit of DA was 8.0 × 10−7 M and the linear range was 5 × 10−6 M to 100 × 10−6 M in the presence of 1 × 10−3 M AA. Additionally, Shang et al. [32] reported a method for the selective detection of dopamine in the presence of 3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine (L-DOPA), ascorbic acid, uric acid, and other dopamine metabolites using electropolymerized (poly-tyramine and polypyrrole-1-propionic acid) on a BDD electrode. A layer-by-layer film of tyramine and pyrrole-1-propionic acid (PPA) was fabricated subsequent to electropolymerization on a
162
ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS OF DIAMOND FILMS
2
R = 0.999 Y = 0.12851 + 0.021x
j / μA cm–2
20
10
g j (μA cm–2)
0 0
400 500 [MIgG] / ppb c b a 0.1
a
2.5
100
200 Time (s)
300
Figure 7.2 Amperograms of products (AA) after adding substrates (AAP) of ALP in Tris buffer solution (pH 8.5) at a poly-o-ABA-modified BDD immunosensor by various target MIgG concentrations (0, 1, 5, 100, 200, 500, and 1000 ng mL−1 (a–g). The potential applied was 0.4 V. The inset in the top is a calibration plot showing the correspondence between the changes in anodic peak current after subtracting the control current (0 ng mL−1 ; absence of MIgG) and the concentration of MIgG, and that below is a zoom (a) 0, (b) 1, (c) 5 ng mL−1 . (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 30.)
BDD electrode with an overall thickness of about 33 nm. The modified BDD electrode exhibited a rapid response to dopamine within 6 s and a detection limit of 50 nM with excellent reproducibility. Moreover, Hason et al. [33] described copper-enhanced label-free anodic stripping method for detection of guanine and adenine bases in acid-hydrolyzed DNA at anodically oxidized boron-doped diamond electrodes (AO-BDDE). In the presence of copper, the guanine oxidation signal was increased by about two orders of magnitude. Additionally, the proposed technique was demonstrated to be suitable for the determination of the purine (particularly guanine) content in DNA samples and was applied to magnetic bead-based DNA assays.
7.4
POLLUTANT COMPOUNDS
The application of BDD electrodes was extended to the investigation of the electrochemical behavior of different kinds of environmental pollutants. Starting with Chang and colleagues [34], they studied the electrochemical behavior of formaldehyde (FA) at BDD electrodes by cyclic voltammetry, electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS), and linear scanning voltammetry (LSV). The cyclic voltammetric results indicated that the oxidation reaction of FA is influenced by the hydroxyl concentration in the solution. A linear response was achieved over the range of 10–100 mM. The differential capacitance from the EIS results indicated that the FA molecules were adsorbed at the BDD electrode surface at low potentials. The results of kinetic studies indicated that the adsorption of
7.4 POLLUTANT COMPOUNDS
163
FA molecules at the BDD electrode is the rate-determining step at low potentials. Next, Pedrosa, Machado, and Avaca [35] proposed the use of anodic square-wave voltammetry to investigate behaviors of 4-chlorophenol (4-CP) in aqueous solution at a BDD electrode. The results revealed the oxidation of 4-CP in a Britton-Robinson buffer solution pH 6.0 and a detection limit as low as 9.2 μg L−1 . Subsequently, Ivandini et al. [36] published the use of bare BDD electrodes to study the electrochemical oxidation of oxalic acid (OA) by cyclic voltammetry and flow injection analysis with amperometric detection. Hydrogen-terminated BDD electrodes exhibited well-defined oxidative peaks of oxalic acid over a wide pH range. A good linear response was observed for a concentration range from 50 nM to 10 μM with a detection limit of 0.5 nM. In 2007, the direct and simultaneous determination of phenol (Ph), hydroquinone (HQ), and 4-nitrophenol (4-NP) at unmodified BBD electrodes by voltammetry were investigated by the same group [37,38]. The oxidative peak currents of these three phenolic compounds were completely resolved at the BDD electrodes in acidic media. Each phenolic compound displayed a good linear relationship between the oxidation peak current and concentration over a rather wide range even though one or two of the other phenolic pollutants were appeared. This method is also promising for the determination of phenolic contaminants in real wastewater samples. The electrochemistry of the benzene oxidation process in aqueous solution at BDD electrodes was investigated [39]. The irreversible oxidation peak of benzene in 0.5 M H2 SO4 was found at 2.0 V versus Ag/AgCl at the BDD electrode by cyclic voltammetry. Hydroquinone, resorcinol, p-benzoquinone, catechol, and phenol were the main products generated during the oxidation process. The benzene oxidation was completed using a rotating BDD electrode and the potential was fixed at 2.5 V for 5 h. All products were measured at concentrations below 10−5 M. In addition, the electrochemical behavior of aniline was investigated at BDD electrodes by linear-sweep cathodic stripping voltammetry [40]. The results showed that a dimeric species (p-aminodiphenylamine and benzidine) formed by anodic oxidation of aniline in acidic media during the accumulation period is involved in the electrochemically reversible redox processes, with a detection limit of 1 μM. In the following work, Radovan and Manea [41] reported that the BDD electrode is a feasible alternative for the analytical determination of sodium diethyldithiocarbamate (DEDTC) in protic media, using cyclic voltammetry or chronoamperometry. Linear plots of current against concentration correlated with an anodic stepwise oxidation mechanism in delimited potential ranges with high correlation coefficients. The voltammetric behaviors of 3-nitrofluoranthene and 3-aminofluoranthene in mixed methanol-water solutions were examined at BDD thin-film electrodes by differential pulse voltammetry [42]. The optimal conditions were reported and limits of detection were 3 × 10−8 M of 3-nitrofluoranthene and 2 × 10−7 M of 3-aminofluoranthene. In addition, the boron-doped diamond electrode was the first developed for detecting the chemical oxygen demand (COD) by amperometric methods [43]. A linear range for the COD test was observed from 20 mg L−1 to 9000 mg L−1 COD and the detection limit was 7.5 mg L−1 COD. This BDD electrode was successfully employed to measure the COD of both synthetic and real wastewater samples from chemical manufacturing and pharmaceutical factories. This method is environmental friendly because no toxic substances are used. To increase the performance of analytical method, the BDD electrodes have also been used as detectors in a flow injection analysis (FIA) system for
164
ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS OF DIAMOND FILMS
the determination of COD [44]. The effect of several important experimental parameters, such as applied potentials, pH, flow rates, and supporting electrolyte concentrations, on the analytical performance was investigated. Under optimized conditions, the proposed method was applied to COD analysis in synthetic samples. Linear dynamic ranges from 2 mg L−1 to 175 mg L−1 COD and a detection limit of 1 mg L−1 were obtained. In 2008, Cinghita, Radovan, and Dascalu [45] investigated the electrochemical behavior of thioacetamide (TAA), a harmful presumptive pollutant in tap and wastewaters. The investigation was performed at a BDD electrode both in unbuffered and buffered 0.1 M Na2 SO4 solutions as the supporting electrolytes. The results showed a well-defined oxidation peak for TAA and good linearity of the amperometric signal versus concentration. Comparison experiments were carried out using glassy carbon electrodes, highlighting the excellent properties of the unmodified BDD electrode and its potential as an amperometric sensor for environmental applications. Next, Martinez-Huitle et al. [46] discussed the electrochemical oxidation of oxalic acid (OA) in the presence of NaCl and NaBr in alkaline media using BDD. Based on the results obtained, bromide was selected as a more suitable mediator of OA oxidation at BDD electrodes in comparison to chlorides. To perform the fully automatic system, a gas diffusion sequential injection system with amperometric detection using a BDD electrode was developed for the determination of sulfite [47]. The sample was mixed with an acidic solution to generate gaseous sulfur dioxide prior to its passage through the donor channel of the gas diffusion unit (GDU). The sulfur dioxide diffused through a PTFE hydrophobic membrane into a carrier solution of 0.1 M phosphate buffer (pH 8) + 0.1% (w/v) sodium dodecyl sulfate in the acceptor channel of the GDU and was converted into sulfite. The sulfite was carried to the electrochemical flow cell and detected directly by amperometry using a BDD electrode at 0.95 V versus Ag/AgCl. Sodium dodecyl sulfate was added to the carrier solution to prevent electrode fouling. This method was applicable in the concentration range of 0.2 to 20 mg L−1 SO3 2− with a detection limit of 0.05 mg L−1 SO3 2− . This method was successfully applied to the determination of sulfite in wines and the analytical results agreed well with those obtained by iodimetric titration. The relative standard deviations for the analysis of sulfite in wines were in the range of 1.0–4.1%. As mentioned previously, to overcome the limitation of unmodified BDD electrodes, surface modifying process is also utilized to prepare BDD electrodes for electroanalysis of variety pollutant compounds. For example, Roustom et al. [48] developed a new method for the synthesis of bimetallic nanoparticles (Au–Pt) on BDD substrates, and these modified electrodes were used to study oxygen reduction. Kondo et al. [49] reported on the use of photochemical modification of alyltriethylammonium bromide (ATAB) onto BDD thin film surfaces for the electrochemical detection of oxalate. The anodic current for oxalate at ATAB-modified BDD with both cyclic voltammetry and flow-injection analysis using amperometry was up to two times larger in comparison to an unmodified BDD electrode. These results may be due to the electrostatic interaction between the oxalate anion and the electrode surface. In addition, the stability of the electrochemical detection of oxalate was improved at the ATAB-BDD electrode compared to those of the unmodified electrode. In 2009, Hutton et al. [50] reported on the fabrication and use of platinum nanoparticle (NP)-modified polycrystalline boron-doped diamond (pBDD) disk electrodes as amperometric sensors for the determination of dissolved oxygen concentrations in aqueous solutions. The electrodes offer high precision over a pH range of 4.0–10.0.
7.5 HEAVY METALS
7.5
165
HEAVY METALS
Trace metals play an important role in many systems and biological processes. A range of metals is essential for the efficient growth and functioning of aquatic organisms. A potential application of boron-doped diamond electrodes for heavy metal determination in various samples was reported. In 2006, McGaw and Swain [51] reported the performance of the BDD electrode for the anodic stripping voltammetric determination of heavy metal ions (Zn2+, Cd2+ , Pb2+ , Cu2+ , Ag+ ) in comparison with Hg-coated glassy carbon. The linear dynamic range obtained from using the BDD electrode was three to four orders of magnitude (r > 0.995) similar to Hg-GC electrode. However, the BDD electrode provides a detection limit three to five times lower than that the Hg-GC electrode because the BDD electrode has a lower background and a higher signal/noise ratio. The detection limits were 50 ppb Zn2+ , 1.0 ppb Cd2+ , 5.0 ppb Pb2+ , 10 ppb Cu2+ , and 1.0 ppb Ag+ . The results demonstrated that BDD is a viable alternative electrode for metal analysis by anodic stripping voltammetry. In the similar concept, the BDD electrodes were also used to investigate the possibility of detecting trace levels of lead by linear-sweep anodic stripping voltammetry [52]. A low limit of detection (2 nM) was obtained in comparison to those by the other electrodes. At low pH values, the Cu2+ concentrations usually present in drinking water do not affect the measurement. Therefore, these methods are attractive and suitable for the determination of trace levels of lead in drinking and tap water. Furthermore, the determination of Zn2+ , Cd2+ , Pb2+ , and Cu2+ by differential pulse anodic stripping voltammetry at BDD electrodes at very low concentrations was reported [53]. Quantification was possible for the simultaneous determination of Zn2+ , Cd2+ , and Pb2+ despite the fact that the Zn2+ and Cd2+ peaks overlapped. Comparison experiments were performed using a glassy carbon electrode, and the BDD electrode provided a lower baseline current, wider potential range, higher sensitivity, and greater longevity than glassy carbon. In 2008, Seehra, Ranganathan, and Manivannan reported the determination of mercury in solutions by BDD electrodes using differential pulse anodic stripping voltammetry [54]. Gold was added to the solution for enhanced sensitivity. Impurity peaks from Cu2+ and Ag+ were identified by choosing the optimal deposition potential. The modified surfaces have been not only used extensively for the analysis of organic and biochemical compounds but some have also been used for inorganic species. Metal and metallic nanoparticles modified boron-doped diamond electrodes and their application to electrochemical analysis have been widely reported. For example, iridium-modified BDD electrodes were used for the electrochemical detection of As3+ by cyclic voltammetry and flow injection analysis with amperometric detection [55]. This method was also applied to the analysis of spiked arsenic in tap water containing a significant amount of various ion elements. Toghill et al. [56] demonstrated a bismuth nanoparticle modified boron-doped diamond (Bi-BDD) electrode for the simultaneous determination of Pb2+ and Cd2+ by square-wave anodic stripping voltammetry (SWASV). In situ plating was achieved using 0.1 mM Bi(NO3 )3 in 0.1 M HClO4 at pH 1.2. The detection limits obtained from this report were 1.9 μg L−1 and 2.3 μg L−1 for Pb2+ and Cd2+ , respectively. Mixtures of As3+ and As5+ at gold-modified diamond electrodes by stripping voltammetry were also electrochemically detected [57]. Good linear responses were observed for standards of As3+ and As5+ . Linear calibration curves were obtained in the concentration range of
166
ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS OF DIAMOND FILMS
100–1000 ppb As5+ in a mixture with 100 ppb As3+ (r 2 = 0.99) and in the concentration ranged of 5–30 ppb As3+ in a mixture with 100 ppb As5+ . Detection limits of 5 ppb and 100 ppb were achieved for As3+ and As5+ in a mixture with reproducibility of 7.5% and 8.4%, respectively. This method was used to measure arsenic contaminants in Yokohama tap water.
7.6
FOOD AND DIETARY CONTAMINANTS
Due to the frequent appearance of contaminant compounds from food sample/dietary/supplement matrices, the development of a highly sensitive detection method is needed. Therefore, the use of BDD electrodes as sensors for the electrochemical analysis of food contaminants has been widely published. In 2006, Juliao et al. [58] reported on the electrochemical behavior of nitrofurazone (NFZ) in a predominantly aqueous medium, in the absence and presence of glutathione (reduced form) (GSH), L-cysteine (Cys), and oxygen (O2 ) using BDD electrodes by voltammetry. A linear response was observed for NFZ in the concentration range of 9.9 × 10−7 M to 1.1 × 10−5 M at pH 8.0 with a sensitivity of 2.2 × 106 M cm−2 and a detection limit of 3.4 × 10−7 M. Codognoto et al. [59] demonstrated the examination of electrochemical property of pesticide carbaryl at a BDD electrode with square-wave voltammetry without any previous steps. A linear response was obtained for carbaryl detection from 2.5 × 10−6 M to 30.0 × 10−6 M in 0.1 M Na2 SO4 at pH 6.0 with a detection limit of 8.2 ± 0.2 μg L−1 . Flavonoids, which exhibit high antioxidant activities, were also analyzed in tea samples using BDD amperometric detection coupled to a flow injection system [60]. The experiments were performed at a fixed potential of 0.42 V versus Ag/AgCl with a flow rate of 2.5 mL min−1 . A Britton-Robinson buffer solution at pH 5.0 was used as the carrier stream. A good linear response was observed for a rutin concentration range of 0.1 × 10−4 M to 2.5 × 10−4 M with a detection limit of 7.7 × 10−6 M. In addition, this method was used to determine rutin in three different green teas (Camellia sinensis) with a relative standard deviation of 2.1% (n = 20). In 2008, Medeiros et al. [61] reported the use of square-wave voltammetry in conjunction with a cathodically pretreated BDD electrode for the determination of sodium cyclamate. A linear response was observed for sodium cyclamate in 0.5 M H2 SO4 solution over a concentration range of 5.0 × 10−5 M to 4.1 × 10−4 M and with a detection limit of 4.8 × 10−6 M. The RSD was smaller than 1.2%. In addition, this method was used to determine sodium cyclamate in several dietary products. The use of BDD thin film electrodes to study the electrochemical properties of chloramphenicol using cyclic voltammetry and flow injection analysis was demonstrated [62]. A linear curve for chloramphenicol over the range of 0.1 mM to 10 mM was obtained by cyclic voltammetry. Chloramphenicol was then analyzed by flow injection analysis at −0.7 V versus Ag/AgCl. A linear range of 0.1 μM to 50 μM and a limit of detection of 0.03 μM (S/N = 3) were obtained (see Figure 7.3). This method was successfully applied to the determination of chloramphenicol in sterile eye drops and milk samples using the standard addition method. The average recoveries of chloramphenicol were 98.0% and 93.9 to 103% in eye drops and spiked milk, respectively. N-nitrosamines (N-nitrosopyrrolidine, N-nitrosopiperidine and N-nitrosodiethylamine) in aqueous solutions were also examined at BDD electrodes using cyclic voltammetry
7.6 FOOD AND DIETARY CONTAMINANTS
167
–7.0 Peak current (μA)
(b)
–5.0 Current (μA)
–1.5
(a)
–6.0
(c)
–4.0
y = –0.0216x – 0.0437 R 2 = 0.9948
–1.0 –0.5 0.0 0
(d)
–3.0
(e) –2.0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Chloramphenicol concentration (μM)
(f) (g) (h) (i) (j) (k) (l) (m) (n)
–1.0 0.0 0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
Time (s) Figure 7.3 Flow-injection analysis with amperometric detection results for various concentrations of chloramphenicol in 0.1 M phosphate buffer (pH 6) in 1% ethanol (a) 1000, (b) 500, (c) 250, (d) 100, (e) 50, (f) 25, (g) 10, (h) 5, (i) 2.5, (j) 1, (k) 0.5, (l) 0.25, (m) 0.1, and (n) 0.05 μM. The calibration graph is also shown in the inset. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 62.)
[63]. An irreversible oxidation peak was observed at approximately 1.8 V versus Ag/AgCl for all N-nitrosamines. The maximal electrochemical response was obtained using the following square-wave voltammetry parameters: f = 250 Hz, Esw = 50 mV, and Es = 2 mV with a Britton-Robinson buffer solution as the electrolyte (pH 2.0). The detection and quantification limits determined for total N-nitrosamines were 6.0 × 10−8 M and 2.0 × 10−7 M, respectively. Furthermore, the determination of aspartame in dietary products samples without pretreatment was achieved using a BDD electrode [64]. A single irreversible oxidation peak at a potential of 1.6 V versus Ag/AgCl was obtained. A linear response over the range of 9.9 × 10−6 M to 5.2 × 10−5 M with a detection limit of 2.3 × 10−7 M was observed in Figure 7.4. The relative standard deviation (n = 5) was less than 0.2% for a 1.0 × 10−4 M aspartame solution. The proposed method yielded similar results to those obtained from the HPLC method at a 95% confidence level. In 2008, the simultaneous determination of aspartame and cyclamate in dietary products at a BDD electrode was developed [65]. Square-wave voltammetry gave separated oxidation peak potentials in binary mixtures of approximately 400 mV (see Figure 7.5). The detection limits for aspartame and cyclamate were 3.5 × 10−7 M and 4.5 × 10−6 M, respectively, while the relative standard deviations were 1.3% for aspartame and 1.1% for cyclamate. This electrochemical method is simple and highly selective, and can be applied to the determination of aspartame in dietary products. An electrochemical biosensor using a BDD electrode was developed and used for detecting o-nitrophenol released from o-nitrophenyl-β-d-galactopyranose, a reaction catalyzed by β-galactosidase, a marker of E . coli contamination in food [66]. Cyclic voltammogram of o-nitrophenol in a 50 mM phosphate buffer at pH 7.0 showed a well-defined oxidation peak at 0.93 V versus Ag/AgCl. This BDD sensor can be used directly without any surface modification. The enzyme was effectively induced by isopropyl-β-d-thiogalacto-pyranoside. The results showed a biphasic calibration plot
168
ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS OF DIAMOND FILMS
12
20
xxxx
8
10
6
9 8
4 2 0
I (μA)
11
10 I (μA)
25
1 2 3 4 5 6 [Aspartame]/10–5 mol L–1
15
7 6 5 4 3
10
2
1
5
0 1.3
1.4
1.5
1.6
1.7
1.8
1.9
E (V) vs. Ag/AgCl Figure 7.4 Square-wave voltammetric response of the BDD electrode for different aspartame concentrations: (1) 0; (2) 9.9 × 10−6 ; (3) 1.5 × 10−5 ; (4) 2.0 × 10−5 ; (5) 2.4 × 10−5 ; (6) 2.9 × 10−5 ; (7) 3.4 × 10−5 ; (8) 3.8 × 10−5 ; (9) 4.3 × 10−5 ; (10) 4.8 × 10−5 ; (11) 5.2 × 10−5 mol L−1 . Insert: Analytical curve for the oxidation process of aspartame. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 64.)
with a linear range between 4 × 104 cells mL−1 and 2 × 105 cells mL−1 , and 2 × 105 and 6 × 106 cells mL−1 for the first and second regions, respectively. The detection limit was 4 × 104 cells mL−1 with a total analysis time of less than 1.5 h. This method is a suitable alternative for the highly sensitive detection of multiple pathogens simultaneously and can be adapted for field tests to rapidly detect traces of E . coli and other food-borne pathogens. Last, Andrade et al. [67] demonstrated the use of a multidimensional high-performance liquid chromatography method coupled with amperometric detection using a BDD electrode for the simultaneous determination of sulfamethoxazole and trimethoprim in bovine milk. Results showed good linearity in the concentration from 50 to 800 μg L−1 and from 25 to 400 μg L−1 for sulfamethoxazole and trimethoprim, respectively. The intraand interassay coefficients of variation were less than 10% for both drugs. It was also found that LOD values were 25.0 μg L−1 for sulfamethoxazole and 15.0 μg L−1 for trimethoprim. 7.7
MISCELLANEOUS
Several outstanding properties of BDD electrodes make them very attractive for use in many potential applications, including for pH measurements. The electrooxidation of ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) at a thin-film BDD polycrystalline diamond electrode was studied by cyclic voltammetry and amperometry [68]. Under optimal conditions, the linear responses were obtained for concentration ranges from 1.0 × 10−5 M to
7.7 MISCELLANEOUS
169
(a) 80
12 10
60
Ip (μA)
70
8 6
I (μA)
4
50
2 0
40
0
1
2 3 4 –5 –1 [Aspartame]/ 10 mol L
5
30 20
j
10
a
0 1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
2.0
2.2
E (V) vs. Ag/AgCl (b) 60 30
50 Ip (μA)
40
l 20
k
I (μA)
10
30
0 0
20
1 2 3 –4 –1 [Cyclamate]/ 10 mol L
4
10 0 1.4
1.6
1.8
2.0
E (V) vs. Ag/AgCl Figure 7.5 (a) SW voltammograms for various concentrations of aspartame at a fixed concentration of cyclamate (3.0 × 10−4 mol L−1 in 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 ). Aspartame concentrations (a–j): 5.0 × 10−6 to 5.0 × 10−5 mol L−1 . (b) SW voltammograms for various concentrations of cyclamate at a fixed concentration of aspartame (1.0 × 10−4 mol L−1 in 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 ). Cyclamate concentrations (k–l): 5.0 × 10−5 to 5.0 × 10−4 mol L−1 . Insets are the corresponding analytical curves for the peak current corresponding to the oxidation process of aspartame or cyclamate. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 65.)
5 × 10−4 M and with a detection limit of 1 × 10−6 M, showing that the BDD electrodes can be used in the quantitative determination of EDTA with a low background current and detection limit. Mitani and Einaga [69] developed the simplest method using BDD electrodes for the analyses of acid concentrations in acidic solutions. Linear sweep voltammetry using BDD electrodes was used to measure the proton concentration. These methods were also applied in vivo for measurements unable of being conducted by conventional glass electrodes.
170
ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS OF DIAMOND FILMS
For surface modification, a method for covalent immobilization onto an amineterminated BDD surface was described in 2007 for the determination of phenolic compounds by Zhou and colleagues [70]. The hydrogen-terminated BDD surface was first functionalized by photochemically linking vinyl groups of allylamine to produce a covalently linked amine-terminated active BDD surface. Then the tyrosinase was immobilized onto the active BDD surface using the carbodiimide coupling reaction. The amperometric response was measured as a function of concentration of phenolic compounds in 0.1 M phosphate buffer solution at pH 6.5. The resulted indicated that the BDD enzyme electrode exhibits a good performance in terms of linear dynamic range, sensitivity, and long-term stability to phenolic derivatives as well as the efficient covalent bonding of the enzyme to the substrate and the electrochemical stability of BDD electrode. The tyrosinase-aminophenyl-modified BDD electrode was developed for the detection of phenolic compounds using amperometry. Moreover, Tyrosinase was covalently immobilized on an aminophenyl-modified BDD (AP–BDD) surface via carbodiimide coupling [71]. The effect of the oxygen level, phenolic compound diffusion, and pH of the solution were studied. The Tyr–AP–BDD electrode showed a linear response from 1 to 200 μM, 1 to 200 μM, and 1 to 250 μM and sensitivities of 232.5, 636.7, and 385.8 mA M−1 cm−2 for phenol, p-cresol, and 4-chlorophenol, respectively. Next, the electrochemistry and electrocatalytic activity of cytochrome C (Cyt C) covalently immobilized on a boron-doped nanocrystalline diamond electrode were studied [72]. The linear response to H2 O2 detection was observed over a concentration range of 1 μM to 450 μM, and the detection limit was 0.7 μM. This method showed excellent electrocatalytic performance in terms of fast response, low detection limit, and high stability toward the reduction of H2 O2 . Afterward, Geng et al. [73] described the SiO2 /Cyt C/SiO2 sandwich on the pretreated BDD electrode. Cyt C was immobilized between the SiO2 gel membranes via electrostatic interactions and by carefully controlling the pH of the solution. The SiO2 interlayer was suggested to play a significant role in the sandwich structure of the SiO2 /Cyt C/SiO2 /BDD electrode. The immobilized Cyt C maintained high stability and good electrochemical performance. This electrode was applied to monitor nitrite, and the oxidation current was proportional to the concentration of nitrite in the range of 1.0 × 10−6 M to 1.0 × 10−3 M with a detection limit of 0.5 μM. Finally, the summarization of analytical applications from the use of BDD electrodes for the determination of wide range of analytes is shown in Table 7.1.
7.8
CONCLUSIONS
Since their introduction into the electroanalytical field in the early twentieth century, boron-doped diamond electrodes have become more and more popular. Their unique properties distinguish them from conventional electrode materials, and allow for many electrochemical processes to become more attractive, simple, or even possible. The BDD electrode can be modified with various species such as metals and functional molecules, including biomolecules such as enzymes and nucleic acids. These contribute to their continued progress in new electroanalytical applications. In the future, we expect to see the broad introduction of diamond electrodes in numerous applications.
171
Cyclic and square-wave voltammetry Differential pulse and square-wave voltammetry Cyclic, differential pulse and square-wave voltammetry Cyclic, linear sweep, differential pulse, square-wave voltammetry square-wave voltammetry
Lidocaine
differential pulse voltammetry
Cyclic voltammetry Cyclic and differential pulse voltammetry and chronoamperometry
Sulfonamides (sulfamethoxazole and trimethoprim)
Procaine hydrochloride L-ascorbic acid, Acetaminophen
Sulfonamides (sulfadiazine and sulfamethoxazole)
Pefloxacin
Fluvastatin
Atorvastatin calcium
Flow injection system with pulsed amperometric detection
Three beta-agonists (salbutamol, terbutaline, and clenbuterol)
Technique
Electroanalytical applications of diamond films.
1. Pharmaceutical compound
Analyte
TABLE 7.1
5–200 μM 0.01–0.1 mM
3.65 μg L−1 (sulfamethoxazole) and 3.92 μg L−1 (trimethoprim) 0.5 μM —
2.19 × 10−6 M (sulfadiazine), 1.15 × 10−6 M (sulfamethoxa-zole)
8.01 × 10−6 − 1.19 × 10−4 M (sulfadiazine), 6.10 × 10−6 − 6.01 × 10−5 M (sulfamethoxazole) —
2 × 10−6 − 2 × 10−4 M
2008 2008
2009
2008
2008
2007
2007
2007
10 μg L−1 2.27 × 10−7 1.31 × 10−7 1.37 × 10−7 1.44 × 10−7 4.65 × 10−7 5.78 × 10−7
2006
Year
—
M (DPV) M (SWV) M (DPV), M (SWV) M (DPV) M (SWV)
Limit of detection
9.65 × 10−7 − 3.86 × 10−5 M 1 × 10−6 − 6 × 10−4 M
0.5–100 μM (salbutamol), 1.0–100 μM (terbutaline), 0.5–50 μM (clenbuterol) —
Linear range
AO-BDDE
Comments
(continued overleaf )
16 17
15
14
13
12
11
10
9
Ref.
172 Cyclic and square-wave voltammetry Square-wave voltammetry
Promethazine hydrochloride
Acetylsalicylic acid (ASA)
Biphenyl amino derivatives (2-aminobiphenyl, 3-aminobiphenyl, and 4-aminobiphenyl)
Dopamine in mouse brain Native and thermally denatured fish DNA 2’-deoxyguanosine Purine and pyrimidine bases Proteins
Tryptophan (Trp) and tyrosine (Tyr) Dopamine
Cyclic voltammetry HPLC amperometric detection Cyclic voltammetry and flow injection analysis Amperometric
Differential pulse voltammetry Differential pulse voltammetry Differential pulse voltammetry Cyclic voltammetry
2. Biomolecules or Biological Compounds
Cyclic voltammetry and chronoamperometry
Technique
L-ascorbic acid, Acetaminophen
Analyte
TABLE 7.1 (Continued)
10 μg mL−1 (BSA), 100 μg mL−1 (IAP) 2 × 10−7 M (2-AB), 3.2 × 10−7 M (3-AB), 5.1 × 10−7 M (4-AB)
10–100 μg mL−1 (BSA), 200–800 μg mL−1 (IAP) 4 × 10−7 −100 × 10−7 M (2-AB), 2 × 10−7 −100 × 10−7 M (3-AB and 4-AB)
—
— 26.3–162.1 nM
—
0.5 nM − 100 μM
— 0.1–10 μM
50 nM
5 × 10−6 M − 1 × 10−4 M
0.8 and 0.86 μM (L-ascorbic acid), 0.97 and 1.42 μM (Acetaminophen) 2.66 × 10−8 M (peak 1), 4.61 × 10−8 M (peak 2) 2.0 × 10−6 M
Limit of detection
1 × 10−5 M (Trp), 1 × 10−6 M (Tyr) 1.1 × 10−6 M
—
2.50 × 10−6 − 1.05 × 10−4 M
5.96 × 10−7 − 4.76 × 10−6 M
0.01–0.1 mM
Linear range
2009
2008
2009 2007
2007
2007
2007
2006
2009
2008
2008
Year
28
27
25 26
24
23
22
21
20
19
18
Ref.
Comments
173
Cyclic voltammetry
Cyclic voltammetry
Dopamine
Dopamine
Phenol (Ph), hydroquinone (HQ) and 4-nitrophenol (4-NP)
4-chlorophenol Oxalic acid
Formaldehyde
3. Pollutant Compounds Cyclic voltammetry and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy square-wave voltammetry Cyclic voltammetry and flow injection analysis Differential pulse voltammetry
Amperometry
Protein
Guanine and adenine bases
Amperometry
Glucose
8 × 10−7 M
5 × 10−6 − 100 × 10−6 M
2006 2006
9.2 μg L−1 0.5 nM 1.82 × 10−6 M (Ph), 1.67 × 10−6 M (HQ), 1.44 × 10−6 M (4-NP) for DPV
0.7–4.0 × 10−5 M 50 nM−10 μM 5 × 10−5 − 1.4 × 10−3 M (Ph), 5 × 10−5 − 7 × 10−3 M (HQ), 5 × 10−5 − 3 × 10−3 M (4-NP) for DPV
2007
2006
2008
—
25 fmol
2009
2008
2008
2006
10–100 mM
—
50 nM
0.3 ng mL−1
1–1000 ng mL−1
—
2.31 × 10−5 M
6.67 × 10−5 − 2 × 10−3 M
37
35 36
34
33
32
31
30
29
(continued overleaf )
GOD/BDD electrode poly-o-ABAmodified BDD AuNPs/polyelec trolyte/BDD electrode Tyramine/PPA/BDD electrode AO-BDDE
174
Oxalic acid Sulfite Oxygen reduction
Thioacetamide
Chemical oxygen demand (COD) COD
Sodium diethyldithiocarbamate 3-nitrofluoranthene and 3-aminofluoranthene
Benzene Aniline
Analyte
TABLE 7.1 (Continued)
Cyclic voltammetry Amperometry
Cyclic voltammetry and flow injection analysis Chronoamperometry
Amperometry
Differential pulse voltammetry
Cyclic voltammetry Linear-sweep cathodic stripping voltammetry Cyclic voltammetry and chronoamperometry
Cyclic voltammetry
Technique
1 mg L−1
2–175 mg L−1 0.02–0.06 mM (in supporting electrolyte 0.1 M Na2 SO4 ) 0.005–0.06 mM (in supporting electrolyte BR2 pH 2.16) — 0.2–20 mg L−1 —
— 0.05 mg L−1 —
0.84 μM
—
3 × 10−8 M (3nitrofluoran-thene), 2 × 10−7 M (3-aminofluo ranthene) 7.5 mg L−1
2 × 10−8 − 1 × 10−6 M (3-nitrofluo ranthene), 2 × 10−7 −1 × 10−5 M (3-aminofluorathnene) 20–9000 mg L−1
2007
0.3 μM
—
2008 2008 2008
2008
2009
2007
2007
2007 2007
8.2 × 10−6 M (Ph), 1.2 × 10−5 M (HQ), 1.1 × 10−5 M (4-NP) for CV — 1 μM
5 × 10−5 − 2 × 10−3 M (Ph), 5 × 10−5 − 1 × 10−2 M (HQ and 4-NP) for CV — 1–5 μM
Year
Limit of detection
Linear range
46 47 48
45
44
43
42
41
39 40
38
Ref.
Py/AuNPs/BDD electrode
Highest Sensitive
Comments
175
Mixtures of As3+ and As5+
Cadmium(II), lead(II)
Arsenite
Hg
Differential pulse anodic stripping voltammetry Cyclic voltammetry and flow injection analysis Square-wave anodic stripping voltammetry Stripping voltametry
Linear-sweep anodic stripping and anodic stripping voltammetry Differential pulse anodic stripping voltammetry
Pb
Zn, Cd, Pb, and Cu
Anodic stripping voltammetry
Cyclic voltammetry and flow injection analysis with amperometry Amperometry and cyclic voltammetric
Zn, Cd, Pb, Cu and Ag
4. Heavy metal
Dissolved oxygen concentration
Oxalate
100–1000 ppb (As5+ ), 5–30 ppb (As3+ )
1.9 μg L−1 (Pb2+ ), 2.3 μg L−1 (Cd2+ ) 100 ppb (As5+ ), 5 ppb (As3+ )
20 nM
0.1–100 μM —
1.6 ppb (Zn), 0.36 ppb (Cd), 1.15 ppb (Pb), 0.9 ppb (Cu) 10 ppt
2 nM
50 ppb (Zn), 1 ppb (Cd), 5 ppb (Pb), 10 ppb (Cu), 1 ppb (Ag)
—
32 nM
5–20 ppb (Zn), 1.2–25 ppb (Cd), 3.8–45 ppb (Pb), 3–20 ppb (Cu) —
50–1000 ppb (Zn), 1–1000 ppb (Cd), 5–1000 ppb (Pb), 10–1000 ppb (Cu), 1–1000 ppb (Ag) 2–100 nM
—
0.8–100 mM
2008
2008
2008
2008
2007
2006
2006
2009
2008
57
56
55
54
53
52
51
50
49
(continued overleaf )
BiNPs/BDD electrode Au/BDD electrode
Ir/BDD electrode
Allyltriethylammonium Bromide PtNPs/BDD electrode
176 Flow injection analysis with amperometric detection Square-wave voltammetry Cyclic voltammetry and flow injection analysis with amperometric detection Cyclic and square-wave voltammetry Square-wave voltammetry Square-wave voltammetry
Cyclic voltammetry
HPLC-Amperometric detection
Flavonoid
Aspartame Aspartame, cyclamate
E. Coli
Sulfonamides (sulfamethoxazole and trimethoprim)
N-nitrosamines
Sodium cyclamate Chloramphenicol
Cyclic voltammetry Square-wave voltammetry
Technique
Nitrofurazone Carbaryl
5. Food and dietary contaminants
Analyte
TABLE 7.1 (Continued)
2.3 × 10−7 M 3.5 × 10−7 M (aspartame), 4.5 × 10−6 M (cyclamate) 4 × 104 cells mL−1
9.9 × 10−6 − 5.2 × 10−5 M 5.0 × 10−6 − 5.0 × 10−5 M (aspartame), 5.0 × 10−5 − 5.0 × 10−4 M (cyclamate) 4 × 104 − 2 × 105 cells mL−1 (first regions), 2 × 105 − 6 × 106 cells/mL (second regions) 50–800 μg L−1 (sulfamethoxazole) and 25–400 μg L−1 (trimethoprim)
25 μg L−1 (sulfamethoxazole) and 15 μg L−1 (trimethoprim)
6.0 × 10−8 M
2 × 10−6 − 1.36 × 10−5 M
67
66
2008
2009
64 65
63
61 62
60
58 59
Ref.
2007 2008
2008
2008 2008
2006
7.7 × 10−6 M 4.8 × 10−6 M 0.03 μM
2006 2006
Year
3.4 × 10−7 M 8.2 ± 0.2 μg L−1
Limit of detection
5.0 × 10−5 − 4.1 × 10−4 M 0.1 mM to 10 Mm for CV 0.1 μM to 50 μM for FI-amperometry
9.9 × 10−7 − 1.1 × 10−5 M 2.5 × 10−6 − 30.0 × 10−6 M 0.1–2.5 × 10−4 M
Linear range
Comments
177
Cyclic voltammetry and amperometry Linear sweep voltammetry Cyclic voltammetry
Amperometry
Cyclic voltammetry Cyclic and differential pulse voltammetry
Ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) pH in acidic solutions Phenolic compound
Phenolic compound
H2 O2
Nitrite
6. Miscellaneous
0.7 μM 0.5 μM
1.0 × 10−6 − 1.0 × 10−3 M
— 1.0 μM (phenol), 0.5 μM (p-cresol), 0.8 μM (4-cholorophenol) 0.2 μM (phenol), 0.1 μM (p-cresol and 4-cholorophenol)
— 1–175 μM (phenol), 1–200 μM (p-cresol and 4-cholorophenol) 1–200 μM (phenol and p-cresol) 1–250 μM, (4-chlorophenol) 1–450 μM
1 × 10−6 M
1.0 × 10−5 − 5 × 10−4 M
2008
2008
2006
2009 2006
2008
73
72
71
69 70
68
Cyt c/BDD electrode SiO2 /Cyt c/SiO2 / BDD electrode
Tyrosinase/BDD electrode
Tyrosinase/BDD electrode
178
7.9
ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS OF DIAMOND FILMS
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors would like to thank the Thailand Research Fund and Faculty of Science, Chulalongkorn University.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27.
A. Fujishima, T.N. Rao, D.A. Tryk, Electrochim. Acta 2000, 45 , 4683–4690. T.N. Rao, A. Fujishima, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2000, 9 , 384–389. A. Fujishima, T.N. Rao, Diam. Rel.Mat . 2001, 10 , 1799–1803. R.G. Compton, J.S. Foord, F. Marken, Electroanalysis 2003, 15 , 1349–1363. A. Fujishima, in Diamond Electrochemistry (Y. Einaga, T.N. Rao, D.A. Tryk, eds.), Elsevier, Tokyo, 2005. O. Chailapakul, W. Siangproh, D.A. Tryk, Sens. Lett . 2006, 4 , 99–119. O. Chailapakul, E. Popa, H. Tai, B.V. Sarada, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, Electrochem. Commun. 2000, 2 , 422–426. W. Siangproh, in Recent Advances in Analytical Electrochemistry (D. A. Tryk, O. Chailapakul, eds.), Transworld Research Network, India, 2007, pp. 167–197. C. Karuwan, T. Mantim, P. Chaisuwan, P. Wilairat, K. Grudpan, P. Jittangprasert, Y. Einaga, O. Chailapakul, L. Suntornsuk, O. Anurukvorakun, D. Nacapricha, Sensors 2006, 6 , 1837–1850. R.T.S. Oliveira, G.R. Salazar-Banda, V.S. Ferreira, S.C. Oliveira, L.A. Avaca, Electroanalysis 2007, 19 , 1189–1194. B.D. Topal, B. Uslu, S.A. Ozkan, Comb. Chem. High Throughput Screening 2007, 10 , 571–582. B.D. Topal, S. Tuncel, B. Uslu, S.A. Ozkan, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2007, 16 , 1695–1704. B. Uslu, B.D. Topal, S.A. Ozkan, Talanta 2008, 74 , 1191–1200. C.D. Souza, O.C. Braga, I.C. Vieira, A. Spinelli, Sens. Actuators B 2008, 135 , 66–73. L.S. Andrade, R.C. Rocha-Filho, Q.B. Cass, O. Fatibello-Filho, Electroanalysis 2009, 12 , 1275–1280. M. Wei, Y.L. Zhou, J.F. Zhi, D.G. Fu, Y. Einaga, A. Fujishima, X.M. Wang, Z.Z. Gu, Electroanalysis 2008, 20 , 137–143. C. Radovan, C. Cofan, D. Cinghita, Electroanalysis 2008, 20 , 1346–1353. C. Cofan, C. Radovan, Sensors 2008, 8 , 3952–3969. F.W.P. Ribeiro, A.S. Cardoso, R.R. Portela, J.E.S. Lima, S.A.S. Machado, P. de Lima, D. De Souza, A.N. Correia, Electroanalysis 2008, 20 , 2031–2039. E.R. Sartori, R.A. Medeiros, R.C. Rocha, O. Fatibello, J. Braz. Chem. Soc. 2009, 20 , 360–366. G.H. Zhao, Y. Qi, Y. Tian, Electroanalysis 2006, 18 , 830–834. G.H. Zhao, M.F. Li, M.L. Li, Cent. Eur. J. Chem. 2007, 5 , 1114–1123. A. Suzuki, T.A. Ivandini, K. Yoshimi, A. Fujishima, G. Oyama, T. Nakazato, N. Hattori, S. Kitazawa, Y. Einaga, Anal. Chem. 2007, 79 , 8608–8615. A. Apilux, M. Tabata, O. Chailapakul, Bioelectrochemistry 2007, 70 , 435–439. E. Fortin, E. Vieil, P. Mailley, S. Szunerits, T. Livache, Anal. Chem. 2007, 79 , 3741–3746. T.A. Ivandini, K. Honda, T.N. Rao, A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, Talanta 2007, 71 , 648–655. M. Chiku, T.A. Ivandini, A. Kamiya, A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, J. Electroanal. Chem. 2008, 612 , 201–207.
REFERENCES
179
28. K. Peckova, K. Jandova, L. Maixnerova, G.M. Swain, J. Barek, Electroanalysis 2009, 21 , 316–324. 29. W. Jing, Q. Yang, Anal. Bioanal. Chem. 2006, 385 , 1330–1335. 30. A. Preechaworapun, A. Suzuki, A. Fujishima, O. Chailapakul, Y. Einaga, Anal. Chem. 2008, 80 , 2077–2083. 31. M. Wei, L.G. Sun, Z.Y. Xie, J.F. Zhi, A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, D.G. Fu, X.M. Wang, Z.Z. Gu, Adv. Func. Mater. 2008, 18 , 1608–1608. 32. F.J. Shang, Y.L. Liu, S. Hrapovic, J.D. Glennon, J.H.T. Luong, Analyst 2009, 134 , 519–527. 33. S. Hason, H. Pivonkova, V. Vetterl, M. Fojta, Anal. Chem. 2008, 80 , 2391–2399. 34. C.C. Chang, L.C. Chen, S.J. Liu, H.J. Tien, H.C. Chang, J. Chin. Chem. Soc. 2006, 53 , 839–844. 35. V.A. Pedrosa, S.A.S. Machado, L.A. Avaca, Anal. Lett . 2006, 39 , 1955–1965. 36. T.A. Ivandini, T.N. Rao, A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, Anal. Chem. 2006, 78 , 3467–3471. 37. G.H. Zhao, Y.T. Tang, M.C. Liu, Y.Z. Lei, X.E. Xiao, Chin. J. Chem. 2007, 25 , 1445–1450. 38. Y.Z. Lei, G.H. Zhao, M.C. Liu, X. Xiao, Y.T. Tang, D.M. Li, Electroanalysis 2007, 19 , 1933–1938. 39. R.T.S. Oliveira, G.R. Salazar-Banda, M.C. Santos, M.L. Calegaro, D.W. Miwa, S.A.S. Machado, L.A. Avaca, Chemosphere 2007, 66 , 2152–2158. 40. T. Spataru, N. Spataru, A. Fujishima, Talanta 2007, 73 , 404–406. 41. C. Radovan, F. Manea, Electroanalysis 2007, 19 , 91–95. 42. K. Cizek, J. Barek, J. Fischer, K. Peckova, J. Zima, Electroanalysis 2007, 19 , 1295–1299. 43. H.B. Yu, H. Wang, X. Quan, S. Chen, Y.B. Zhang, Electrochem. Commun. 2007, 9 , 2280–2285. 44. H.B. Yu, C.J. Ma, X. Quan, S. Chen, H.M. Zhao, Environ. Sci. Technol. 2009, 43 , 1935–1939. 45. D. Cinghita, C. Radovan, D. Dascalu, Sensors 2008, 8 , 4560–4581. 46. C.A. Martinez-Huitle, S. Ferro, S. Reyna, M. Cerro-Lopez, A. De Battisti, M.A. Quiroz, J. Braz. Chem. Soc. 2008, 19 , 150–156. 47. C. Chinvongamorn, K. Pinwattana, N. Praphairaksit, T. Imato, O. Chailapakul, Sensors 2008, 8 , 1846–1857. 48. B.E. Roustom, G. Sine, G. Foti, C. Comninellis, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2007, 37 , 1227–1236. 49. T. Kondo, Y. Niwano, A. Tamura, T.A. Ivandini, Y. Einaga, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, T. Kawai, Electroanalysis 2008, 20 , 1556–1564. 50. L. Hutton, M.E. Newton, P.R. Unwin, J.V. Macpherson, Anal. Chem. 2009, 81 , 1023–1032. 51. E.A. McGaw, G.M. Swain, Anal. chim. Acta 2006, 575 , 180–189. 52. D. Dragoe, N. Spataru, R. Kawasaki, A. Manivannan, T. Spataru, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, Electrochem. Acta 2006, 51 , 2437–2441. 53. O. El Tall, N. Jaffrezic-Renault, M. Sigaud, O. Vittori, Electroanalysis 2007, 19 , 1152–1159. 54. M.S. Seehra, S. Ranganathan, A. Manivannan, Anal. Lett . 2008, 41 , 2162–2170. 55. T.A. Ivandini, R. Sato, Y. Makide, A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, Anal. Chem. 2006, 78 , 6291–6298. 56. K.E. Toghill, G.G. Wildgoose, A. Moshar, C. Mulcahy, R.G. Compton, Electroanalysis 2008, 20 , 1731–1737. 57. D. Yamada, T.A. Ivandini, M. Komatsu, A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, J. Electroanal. Chem. 2008, 615 , 145–153. 58. M.S.D. Juliao, E.I. Ferreira, N.G. Ferreira, S.H.P. Serrano, Environ. Sci. Technol. 2006, 41 , 5080–5086.
180
ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS OF DIAMOND FILMS
59. L. Codognoto, S.T. Tanimoto, V.A. Pedrosa, H.B. Suffredini, S.A.S. Machado, L.A. Avaca, Electroanalysis 2006, 18 , 253–258. 60. V.A. Pedrosa, A.R. Malagutti, L.H. Mazo, L.A. Avaca, Anal. Lett . 2006, 39 , 2737–2748. 61. R.A. Medeiros, A.E. de Carvalho, R.C. Rocha, O. Fatibello, Quim. Nova 2008, 31 , 1405–1409. 62. S. Chuanuwatanakul, O. Chailapakul, S. Motomizu, Anal. Sci . 2008, 24 , 493–498. 63. R.T.S. de Oliveira, G.R. Salazar-Banda, S.A.S. Machado, L.A. Avaca, Electroanalysis 2008, 20 , 396–401. 64. R.A. Medeiros, A.E. de Carvalho, R.C. Rocha, O. Fatibello, Anal. Lett . 2007, 40 , 3195–3207. 65. R.A. Medeiros, A.E. de Carvalho, R.C. Rocha-Filho, O. Fatibello-Filho, Talanta 2008, 76 , 685–689. 66. E. Majid, K.B. Male, J.H.T. Luong, J. Agric. Food. Chem. 2008, 56 , 7691–7695. 67. L.S. Andrade, M.C. de Moraes, R.C. Rocha-Filho, O. Fatibello-Filho, Q.B. Cass, Anal. chim. Acta. 2009, 654 , 127–132. 68. A.E. Denisova, Y.V. Pleskov, Russ. J. Electrochem. 2008, 44 , 1083–1085. 69. N. Mitani, Y. Einaga, J. Electroanal. Chem. 2009, 626 , 156–160. 70. Y.L. Zhou, R.H. Tian, J.F. Zhi, Biosens. Bioelect . 2007, 22 , 822–828. 71. Y.L. Zhou, J.F. Zhi, Electrochem. Commun. 2006, 8 , 1811–1816. 72. Y.N. Zhou, J.F. Zhi, Y.S. Zou, W.J. Zhang, S.T. Lee, Anal. Chem. 2008, 80 , 4141–4146. 73. R. Geng, G.H. Zhao, M.C. Liu, M.F. Li, Biomaterials 2008, 29 , 2794–2801.
8 Cathodic Pretreatment of Boron-Doped Diamond Electrodes and Their Use in Electroanalysis Leonardo S. Andrade, Giancarlo R. Salazar-Banda, Romeu C. Rocha-Filho, and Orlando Fatibello-Filho
8.1
INTRODUCTION
Diamond electrodes have been a subject of investigation and application ever since 1987, when Pleskov et al. [1] reported pioneering electrochemical measurements carried out on undoped diamond films. Most of the early work on diamond electrodes, both fundamental and applied, was summarized in the book edited by Fujishima et al. [2], in book chapters by Angus, Pleskov, and Eaton [3] and by Swain [4,5], and in short reviews on boron-doped diamond (BDD) sensors by Chailapakul, Siangproh, and Tryk [6], Chen [7], and Park et al. [8]. More recently, Peckov´a, Musilov´a, and Barek [9] reviewed the voltammetric determination of organic substances using BDD electrodes, whereas Luong, Male, and Glennon [10] reviewed their functionalization and analytical applications. The electrochemical behavior of BDD electrodes depends on their physical, chemical, and electronic properties, which can be significantly affected by the surface termination (hydrogen, oxygen, and others). Microcrystalline BDD films currently prepared by
Synthetic Diamond Films: Preparation, Electrochemistry, Characterization, and Applications, First Edition. Edited by Enric Brillas and Carlos Alberto Mart´ınez-Huitle. © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Published 2011 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
181
182
CATHODIC TREATMENT OF BDD ELECTRODES AND THEIR USE IN ELECTROANALYSIS
chemical vapor deposition (CVD) methods are hydrogen terminated (HT-BDD). Many redox couples present relatively high electron transfer rates on HT-BDD. In this sense, in 1997, in one of the first efforts to use BDD thin-film electrodes in electroanalysis, Jolley et al. [11] reported reversible to quasi-reversible electron transfer kinetics for the hexacyanoferrate(II)/hexacyanoferrate(III) [Fe(CN)6 4−/3− ] redox couple on a CVD-prepared BDD electrode that did not undergo any surface pretreatment before use. Afterward, Granger and Swain [12] reported on the influence of oxygen and hydrogen surface terminations of BDD electrodes (as deposited and obtained by plasma treatments) on the electron transfer involving Fe(CN)6 4−/3− and other redox couples. Since the electron transfer was much faster on HT-BDD electrodes, the researchers concluded that the Fe(CN)6 4−/3− redox reaction proceeds through a specific surface interaction available on the hydrogen-terminated surface and that such surface interactions appear to be blocked on the oxygen-terminated surface. However, they observed only a quasireversible response (Ep = 70 mV) for the hydrogen-terminated surface. The surface termination on BDD surfaces is usually generated by electrochemical methods (hydrogen evolution to produce hydrogen terminations; oxygen evolution for oxygen terminations) or RF-plasma treatment (H and O terminations) among others [13–28]. Hydrogen-terminated surfaces are hydrophobic with a negative electron affinity and are highly conductive [29–32], whereas oxygen-terminated ones are hydrophilic, with a positive electron affinity, and present a low conductivity [18,33,34]. As a consequence, the charge transfer rate for some redox couples, including Fe(CN)6 4−/3− , can significantly change with the surface termination on the BDD electrode. Thus, many authors have investigated the charge transfer mechanism and kinetics of several redox couples on BDD electrodes, using, for this purpose, physical and electrochemical methods [12,18, 35–45]. Here, we will concentrate on the cathodic pretreatment of BDD electrodes, which produces HT-BDD electrodes. First, investigations on the effect of the cathodic pretreatment of BDD electrodes on their electrochemical properties will be presented. Second, the use of HT-BDD electrodes on the determination of specific analytes in different matrixes will be reviewed. Third, the effect of the electrochemical pretreatments on the deposition of metals on BDD electrodes will be briefly reviewed.
8.2 CATHODIC PRETREATMENT OF CONDUCTIVE DIAMOND FILMS Despite the fact that enhanced electron transfer kinetics for some redox couples and high conductivity for HT-BDD surfaces (as-prepared or obtained by plasma treatments) were reported since the latter 1990s [12], in 2004, Suffredini et al. [18] called attention to the enhanced electrochemical response of BDD electrodes brought on by a cathodic surface pretreatment, for a variety of reactions. This research was inspired by previous observations in the analytical detection of pentachlorophenol (PCP) and 4-chlorophenol (4-CP) using square-wave voltammetry (SWV) at cathodically [−3.0 V versus Ag/AgCl (3.0 mol L−1 KCl) for 30 s] pretreated BDD electrodes [43,45], when excellent analytical performances were obtained. Thus, Suffredini et al. [18] compared the effect of anodic and cathodic electrochemical pretreatments [applying ±3.0 V versus Ag/AgCl (3.0 mol L−1 KCl), for 30 min, in 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 ] on the electrochemical response
8.2 CATHODIC PRETREATMENT OF CONDUCTIVE DIAMOND FILMS
183
(a) 20
I (μA)
15
10
5
0 0.5
0.6
0.7 0.8 E (V) vs Ag/AgCl
0.9
1.0
8 (b)
I (μA)
6
4
2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6 0.8 E (V) vs Ag/AgCl
1.0
1.2
Figure 8.1 Cyclic voltammetry (ν = 0.05 V s−1 ) on BDD (A = 0.62 cm2 ) for 5.0 × 10−5 mol L−1 pentachlorophenol (a) and 4-chlorophenol (b) in a 0.1 mol L−1 Britton-Robson buffer (pH 5.5), after anodic (dotted lines) and cathodic pretreatments (full lines). (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 18.)
for the oxidation of these analytes. As seen in Figure 8.1, in both cases the electroanalytical response was significantly enhanced at the cathodically pretreated BDD electrode. Suffredini et al. [18] also reported on the effect of the electrochemical pretreatments of BDD surfaces on the cyclic voltammetry and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) responses for solutions containing K4 [Fe(CN)6 ] in aqueous 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 . The results of the cyclic voltammetry experiments show that the hexacyanoferrate(II)/hexacyanoferrate(III) redox couple behaves in a quasi-reversible manner after the anodic pretreatment, whereas the cathodic pretreatment leads to a reversible behavior with a Ep value of 60 mV. In addition, the EIS data for this redox couple showed that the value of a resistance associated to a high-frequency element presented values of over 300 cm2 and about 4 cm2 after anodic and cathodic pretreatments, respectively (see Figure 8.2). From these studies the authors concluded that the electrochemical response of BDD electrodes is strongly affected by the type of electrochemical pretreatment applied to their
184
CATHODIC TREATMENT OF BDD ELECTRODES AND THEIR USE IN ELECTROANALYSIS
(a) 400
−Z ′′ (Ω cm2)
320
240
160 0.15 Hz 80 5.0 Hz 0 0
80
160
240 Z ′ (Ω
400
(b)
12
−Z ′′ (Ω cm2)
320
cm2)
8
4 320 Hz
0 0
4
8 Z ′ (Ω
12
cm2)
Figure 8.2 Complex-plane plots for the BDD electrode in a 1.0 mmol L−1 K4 [Fe(CN)6 ] + 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 aqueous solution after anodic (a) or cathodic (b) pretreatment. Frequency intervals: 50 kHz to 30 mHz (a) and 50 kHz to 10 Hz (b). Measurements carried out at 0.60 V versus HESS—hydrogen electrode in the same solution. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 18.)
surface before measurements. This effect is very noticeable for some analytes, although it was also present for electron transfer reactions of well-known reversible couples, for which a cathodic pretreatment of the BDD electrode surface prior to measurements leads to an enhanced electrochemical activity. After, Mah´e, Devilliers, and Comminellis [19] also reported data that evidenced a significantly improved electrochemical reactivity of the Fe(CN)6 4−/3− redox couple on
8.2 CATHODIC PRETREATMENT OF CONDUCTIVE DIAMOND FILMS
185
cathodically pretreated BDD electrodes. According to these authors, the cathodic polarization gives rise to a very high rate constant with great reproducibility, which is consistent with the existence of a hydrogen participation into the hole-generation process at BDD surfaces. They also concluded that simple electrochemical treatments could be used to achieve reversible chemical surface modification of BDD electrodes, associated to a drastic change in the rate of electron transfer. In 2006, Salazar-Banda et al. [20] reported on studies to elucidate the effect of different pretreatments (anodic, cathodic, and thermal) on 800 ppm BDD electrodes on the electrochemical response of the hexacyanoferrate(II)/hexacyanoferrate(III) redox couple. As-prepared BDD electrodes were subjected to either an anodic (3.0 V versus HESS, for 30 min) or a cathodic (−3.0 V versus HESS, for 3 or 30 min) pretreatment in a 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 aqueous solution; the thermal pretreatment was carried out at 400◦ C during 30 min in an oven with an oxygen atmosphere. The kinetics of the Fe(CN)6 4−/3− redox couple was greatly affected by the different pretreatments, as can be seen in Figure 8.3. Clearly, the cathodic pretreatment significantly facilitated the redox reaction, leading to a reversible behavior with a Ep of 60 mV and an Ipox /Ipred ratio of 1.0. An analysis of baseline for the cathodically pretreated electrode, also shown in Figure 8.3, concludes that HT-BDD presents a clean surface with no faradaic processes except for a small anodic signal at the positive end of the scan; this signal has been attributed to the presence of small amounts of sp2 carbon as surface impurity [19,46]. On the other hand, the anodic and thermal pretreatments yielded electrode surfaces that do not favor the kinetics of this redox reaction, resulting in irreversible behaviors, with Ep values of 1010 mV and 440 mV associated to Ipox /Ipred ratios equal to 1.5 and 1.3, respectively. This clearly confirms that the cathodic pretreatment of the BDD electrode (resulting in a hydrogen-terminated surface) leads to an enhanced electrochemical response, as previously reported [18].
Figure 8.3 Cyclic voltammograms (ν = 0.05 V s−1 ) for BDD electrodes (A = 0.63 cm2 ) in the presence of a 1.0 mmol L−1 K4 [Fe(CN)6 ] + 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 aqueous solution after cathodic, anodic, and thermal pretreatments. Also included is the background response for the cathodically pretreated electrode. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 20.)
186
CATHODIC TREATMENT OF BDD ELECTRODES AND THEIR USE IN ELECTROANALYSIS
Salazar-Banda et al. [20] also investigated the effect of time of cathodic pretreatment on the electrochemical response of the pretreated BDD electrode. They showed that the voltammetric behavior of the Fe(CN)6 4−/3− redox reaction is highly dependent on the duration of the cathodic pretreatment. As seen in Figure 8.4, the reversibility of this redox reaction increases significantly even after pretreatment times as short as 3 s. The value of Ep decreases from 420 mV for the as-received electrode to 110 mV, 72 mV, and 60 mV after pretreatment times of 3 s, 3 min, and 30 min, respectively. Thus, a pretreatment time of 30 min (corresponding to a passed charge of about −60 C cm−2 ) led to a totally reversible electrochemical response of the Fe(CN)6 4−/3− redox couple. It is worth highlighting that short pretreatments time and, consequently, low charges passed already had a significant effect on the BDD electrochemical response. Suffredini et al. [18] attributed the large differences in the electrochemical response of BDD electrodes after cathodic and anodic pretreatments to either an internal transformation of the BDD film or, most probably, to the presence of a discontinuous passive layer. However, Raman studies performed on 800 ppm BDD electrodes before and after a cathodic pretreatment showed that neither important bulk structural differences nor significant changes in the sp2 /sp3 carbon content are introduced into the BDD film by the pretreatment [20]. Thus, this indicates that the enhanced electrochemical response brought on by the cathodic pretreatment is due only to superficial changes, most probably in the surface terminations of the BDD film that becomes mainly hydrogen terminated. In this sense, it is important to mention that several studies have reported that the surface of nondoped diamond is either conducting when it is hydrogen terminated or insulating when oxygen terminated [31,47–51]. Furthermore, the hydrogen-terminated surface becomes insulating when heated under vacuum at temperatures higher than 700◦ C [52], a process that leads to the elimination of hydrogen from the diamond surface.
tcp = 3min 60
tcp = 30min
I (μA)
30 tcp = 0 0
–30 tcp = 3 s –60 0.2
0.4
0.6 E (V) vs. HESS
0.8
1.0
Figure 8.4 Effect of cathodic pretreatment time on the electrochemistry of BDD electrodes (A = 0.63 cm2 ): cyclic voltammograms (ν = 0.15 V s−1 ) for an 800 ppm BDD electrode in a 1.0 mmol L−1 K4 [Fe(CN)6 ] + 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 aqueous solution after cathodic pretreatments at −3.0 V versus HESS, for different lengths of time (tcp ), as indicated on the curves. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 20.)
8.2 CATHODIC PRETREATMENT OF CONDUCTIVE DIAMOND FILMS
187
However, the conductivity is reinstated when the diamond is hydrogenated again by a plasma treatment. According to Hayashi et al. [29], the conductivity of nondoped hydrogen-terminated diamond is in the range of 10−6 to 10−4 S, due to p-type carriers with a lateral concentration in the range of 1012 to 1013 cm−2 and with a mobility between 10 and 100 cm2 V−1 s−1 . The mobility measured for BDD is not too different, there being a general agreement that the carriers are holes residing in a layer near to the surface [50,51]. Thus, on nondoped diamond, a hydrogen-terminated surface is necessary for the existence of this superficial conductivity that allows the onset of bulk conductivity. On the other hand, if the diamond surface is insulating (oxygen terminated), no bulk conductivity arises. Taking this into account, in electrodes with low boron doping levels it could be assumed that there is a mixed conductivity at the BDD electrode surface, due to areas with high boron contents and to hydrogen-terminated areas. These areas must be connected to boron-rich regions in the diamond bulk, leading to conductive pathways [35]. Probably one of the most interesting results reported by Salazar-Banda et al. [20] is the one that cathodically pretreated BDD electrode surfaces present a dynamic electrochemical behavior; that is, the HT-BDD electrochemical response changes with time of exposition to air. Hence, after a cathodic pretreatment (−3.0 V versus HESS, for 30 min), the HT-BDD electrodes present a progressive decrease of the electron transfer rate for the Fe(CN)6 4−/3− redox couple that results in a loss of the reversibility as a function of time exposed to atmospheric conditions. This dynamic behavior was associated to a loss of superficial hydrogen due to oxidation of the surface by oxygen from the air. This assumption was confirmed by XPS analysis, since a cathodically pretreated electrode exposed to air for 30 days clearly presented an increased superficial content of oxygen. For a cathodically pretreated 800 ppm BDD electrode, Ep changes from 60 mV to 85 mV, after the first 48 h of exposition to the atmosphere, and to 293 mV after 100 days (see Figure 8.5) [20]. These changes must be related to loss of superficial hydrogen due to the oxidation of the surface by atmospheric oxygen or by other species (HCO3 − , OH− ) contained in the thin layer of water naturally formed on the surface of solids exposed to air [31,50]. In fact, when these results were correlated with oxygen content from XPS data, it was possible to observe that after one month of exposition to air, an increase of 85 mV in the value of Ep is related to a difference of 5.8% in the value of the O/C ratio on the electrode surface [20]. In this sense, Kulesza, Patyk, and Rozploch [53] reported on the spontaneous oxidation of hydrogenated nondoped diamond surfaces. When hydrogenated nondoped diamond surfaces are in contact with air, a degradation of the hydrogen layer occurs by oxidation, followed by long-term deterioration of the surface electrical conductivity. The increase rate of the surface resistance was calculated to be approximately (10 ± 6) k month−1 . If one assumes that the surface resistance of BDD electrodes exposed to air increases similarly to the one for hydrogenated nondoped diamond surfaces, this may explain the variations in the electrochemical behavior of the hexacyanoferrate(II)/hexacyanoferrate(III) redox couple (see Figure 8.5). Additionally, Salazar-Banda et al. [20] reported that the dynamic behavior of the electrochemical response of cathodically pretreated BDD electrodes also presents an inverse dependence with the doping level. Figure 8.6 shows how the value of Ep changed with time of exposition to air for the different cathodically pretreated (−3.0 V versus HESS, for 30 min) BDD electrodes. From this figure one can see, for instance,
188
CATHODIC TREATMENT OF BDD ELECTRODES AND THEIR USE IN ELECTROANALYSIS
Figure 8.5 Effect of exposure to air on the electrochemical response of a cathodically pretreated 800 ppm BDD electrode (A = 0.63 cm2 ): cyclic voltammograms (ν = 0.05 V s−1 ) for the Fe(CN)6 4−/3− redox couple as a function of the time after pretreatment (tap ) that the BDD electrode was exposed to atmospheric conditions, recorded in a 1.0 mmol L−1 K4 [Fe(CN)6 ] + 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 aqueous solution. Cathodic pretreatment: −3.0 V versus HESS, for 30 min, in 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 . (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 20.)
Figure 8.6 Effect of exposure to air on the Ep values for the Fe(CN)6 4−/3− redox couple for cathodically pretreated (−3.0 V versus HESS, for 30 min) BDD electrodes having different doping levels, as indicated in the inset. Data from cyclic voltammograms (ν = 0.05 V s−1 ) recorded in a 1.0 mmol L−1 K4 [Fe(CN)6 ] + 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 aqueous solution. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 20.)
8.2 CATHODIC PRETREATMENT OF CONDUCTIVE DIAMOND FILMS
189
that after 140 h of exposition to the atmosphere the Ep values for the 300 ppm, 800 ppm, 2000 ppm, and 8000 ppm BDD electrodes increased by 35, 32, 8, and 5 mV, respectively. This dynamic behavior of the electrochemical response inversely dependent on the electrode doping level clearly suggests that the boron content has a stabilizing effect on the H-terminated surface. According to the authors, these results can be further understood if one assumes that there is a mixed conductivity at the surface of the BDD electrodes with low boron doping levels, due to the existence of heterogeneity in the boron content on the surface; the boron-poor areas lose hydrogen quicker than the boron-rich areas, due to a stabilizing effect of boron. These areas must be connected to boron-rich regions in the diamond bulk, leading to conductive pathways [35]. However, this mixed conductivity is less important in electrodes with high boron doping levels, where most of the surface is covered with boron-rich areas (hydrogen stabilized). The findings of the study by Salazar-Banda et al. [20] clearly show that hydrogenterminated sites play an important role in the electrochemical response of BDD electrodes. Findings also indicate that when reproducible results are required, the BDD electrode has to be cathodically pretreated just before the electrochemical experiments are carried out, especially when the electrode was not used for a long period of time. Girard et al. [21] studied the influence of anodic and cathodic pretreatments on the behavior of highly doped (1020 cm−3 ) BDD electrodes. The electrochemical pretreatments were performed during 10 s with two significantly different current densities: ±10−4 A cm−2 (±10−3 C cm−2 ) for mild pretreatments and ±10−1 A cm−2 (±1 C cm−2 ) for severe ones. The authors observed that when the mild cathodic pretreatment (−10−4 A cm−2 ) was carried out, the reversibility of the Ce3+/4+ and Fe(CN)6 4−/3− redox couples diminished (see Figure 8.7). It is worth noticing that the mild cathodic pretreatment is indeed very mild, associated to a potential difference between working and reference electrodes that is nearly stable and about −1.0 V versus MSE [mercury sulfate electrode, equal to about −1.4 V versus Ag/AgCl (3.0 mol L−1 KCl)]. This electrode potential is actually not in the potential range of the hydrogen evolution reaction (see, for instance, Figure 5 in Mah´e, Devilliers, and Comninellis [19] or Figure 2 in Hupert et al. [54]); consequently, this mild pretreatment cannot be considered as a truly cathodic pretreatment in the sense used in previous studies (water electroreduction to produce hydrogen terminations) [18–20]. On the other hand, after the severe cathodic pretreatment {corresponding to a nearly stable electrode potential in the range of −3 V versus MSE [∼−3.4 V vs. Ag/AgCl (3.0 mol L−1 KCl)]}, the Ep value (700 mV with a small peak current increase) in the voltammograms registered with the ceric species (see Figure 8.8) is a bit smaller than that obtained for the as-deposited BDD electrode (750 mV), while Ep for Fe(CN)6 4−/3− redox system reaches the quasi-reversible value of 100 mV with a notable increase of the peak current [21]. In a subsequent study, Simon et al. [22] confirmed the enhancement in the conductivity of moderately doped (1019 cm−3 ) BDD surfaces after cathodic pretreatments of as-deposited samples. They also showed that previously annealed samples (1100◦ C in ultrahigh vacuum, for 12 h, in order to outgas the hydrogen introduced into the diamond layer during the deposition process) do not exhibit an enhancement of conductivity after the electrochemical pretreatments. This shows that the presence of hydrogen in the BDD electrodes seems to be crucial to increase the superficial conductivity after the electrochemical pretreatments.
190
CATHODIC TREATMENT OF BDD ELECTRODES AND THEIR USE IN ELECTROANALYSIS
400 (a) Ce3+/4+ in H2SO4 medium
j (µA cm–2)
200
0
NT –200
A1 C1
–400 –0.3
300
0.0
0.3
0.6 E (V/ESM)
0.9
1.2
1.5
(b) Fe(CN)64–/3– in KOH medium
j (µA cm–2)
200 100 0 –100
NT A1
–200
C1 –1.5
–1.0
–0.5 E (V/ESM)
0.0
0.5
Figure 8.7 Cyclic voltammograms (ν = 0.02 V s−1 ) for (a) 5.0 mmol L−1 Ce3+/4+ in 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 and (b) 5.0 mmol L−1 Fe(CN)6 4−/3− in 0.5 mol L−1 KOH, at BDD electrodes after mild electrochemical pretreatments (±10−3 C cm−2 ): anodically (dashed lines) or cathodically (dotted lines) pretreated and as-deposited (full lines) electrodes. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 21.)
A recent tentative to elucidate the electron transfer behavior on HT-BDD electrodes in an electrolytic solution was carried out by Wang et al. [55] using scanning probe microscopy and ab initio methods. The HT-BDD electronic structures were investigated in detail. Shallow acceptors were found in the HT-BDD bandgap and were attributed to the interaction between physisorbed active adsorbates and C–H bondings on the diamond surface. The authors also concluded that these shallow acceptors favor electron transfer. Studies of diamond electrodes in nonaqueous electrolytes are more limited. PastorMoreno and Riley [56] studied the reduction of 1,4-benzoquinone in acetonitrile at BDD electrodes with different surface pretreatments. They showed that the mechanism of reduction is dependent on the electrode pretreatment. Whereas the electrochemistry at an oxygenated BDD surface (prepared by immersion in a hot chromic acid solution) resembles that of a glassy-carbon electrode, the electrochemistry at an HT-BDD
8.2 CATHODIC PRETREATMENT OF CONDUCTIVE DIAMOND FILMS
400
191
(a) Ce3+/Ce4+ in H2SO4 medium
300
j (µA cm–2)
200 100 0 –100 NT –200
A2
–300
C2
–400 –0.5 600
0.0
0.5 E (V/ESM)
1.0
1.5
(b) Fe(CN)64–/3– in KOH medium
j (µA cm–2)
400 200 0 –200 NT
–400
A2 C2
–600 –1.0
–0.5 0.0 E (V/ESM)
0.5
Figure 8.8 Cyclic voltammograms (ν = 0.02 V s−1 ): (a) for 5.0 mmol L−1 Ce3+/4+ in 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 and (b) for 5.0 mmol L−1 Fe(CN)6 4−/3− in 0.5 mol L−1 KOH, at BDD electrodes after severe electrochemical pretreatments (±1 C cm−2 ): anodically (dashed lines) or cathodically (dotted lines) pretreated and as-deposited (full lines) electrodes. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 21.)
surface (as-prepared or obtained by applying a potential in the hydrogen evolution region, for 6 h, in 1 mol L−1 KCl) indicates the presence of a hydrogen source. In the latter case, the authors concluded that hydrogen in the diamond subsurface may participate in electrochemical processes. In view of the small number of reports available in the literature about the effect of cathodic treatments on the electrochemical and electroanalytical behavior and surface properties of BDD films, it is clear that this issue will demand further investigations in the future. For example, studies must be carried out to (1) elucidate the changes (in the bulk and in the surface) in the physical and/or physicochemical properties of diamond materials caused by cathodic pretreatments; (2) evaluate the physical and/or chemical stability of BDD films after repeated and severe cathodic pretreatments, focusing on the use of in situ
192
CATHODIC TREATMENT OF BDD ELECTRODES AND THEIR USE IN ELECTROANALYSIS
techniques; and (3) quantify and understand the relationship between different properties of diamond materials before and after cathodic pretreatments [properties such as sp2 type carbon content, grain boundary size (micro and nanodiamond), level of doping, conductivity, and surface termination, among others]. The results from these studies would certainly contribute to advance the fundamental knowledge and the technological applications of BDD in electrochemistry and electroanalysis. 8.3 8.3.1
ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS General Aspects
One of the great challenges of analytical chemistry has been the fulfillment of the demand for analytical methods for the quantification of biological, environmental, and pharmaceutical analytes in several kinds of matrixes. The concentration of degradation products and/or impurities present in analytes varies widely and the analysis procedures usually require physical and/or chemical separation(s) prior to any meaningful determination. The assay of chemical species of interest may correspond to a very complex process, due to limiting factors that can be represented by the need to determine ever-smaller amounts (often below the LOD value offered by the techniques available), the interferences arising from the complex character of many matrixes, and the need to distinguish and quantify various chemical species associated with the same product (selectivity). As was pointed out previously in this chapter and by others (see, for instance, refs. 1–5), thin BDD films have an important number of electrochemical properties that distinguish them from other carbons bonded by sp2 , commonly used as electrodes in electroanalytical determinations. Because of these properties, BDD electrodes have been widely studied in recent years, both in terms of fundamental electrochemical properties [1–3,18,20,35,57,58] and electroanalytical [1,4–6,59,60] and environmental (wastewater treatment) applications [61–67]. The wide potential window (up to 3.5 V) presented by BDD electrodes in aqueous solutions—as well as their very low and stable voltammetric background current, long-term response stability, and low sensitivity to dissolved oxygen—are important characteristics that allow the detection of many electroactive species, which otherwise would be masked by the water decomposition reactions. However, it is clear that the analytical performance of BDD electrodes greatly depends on their surface termination (i.e., whether they are hydrogen or oxygen terminated [68–74]). Accordingly, surface modifications of BDD have a strong effect on its electroanalytical behavior when detecting several kinds of analytes. The presence of different functional groups on the BDD surface plays an important role when using diamond electrodes in electroanalysis. Initially, in most studies found in the literature, diamond electrodes were subjected mainly to an anodic treatment of the surface in order to make it hydrophilic (standard procedure) [74–76]. However, as pointed out in Section 8.2, more recently Suffredini et al. [18] and Salazar-Banda et al. [20] highlighted that cathodic pretreatments of BDD electrodes lead to a nearly-ideal reversible behavior for the Fe(CN)6 4−/3− redox system, along with improving the electrochemical responses for other analytes in aqueous media. So, this pretreatment has been used in many studies, especially those involving measurements for the detection of pesticides, drugs, and food additives using classical voltammetric techniques [e.g., square-wave voltammetry (SWV) and differential pulse voltammetry (DPV)]. It has been shown that for many analytes the combination
8.3 ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS
193
of a cathodically pretreated (hydrogen-terminated) BDD electrode with these techniques becomes a very powerful analytical tool. Hence, a summary of electroanalytical applications of cathodically pretreated BDD electrodes in the determination of several kinds of analytes in different matrixes is presented hereinafter. 8.3.2
Determination of Pesticides in Environmental Samples
Although chemical substances such as herbicides, germicides, and insecticides (pesticides) are necessary to improve agricultural productivity, they can cause prejudicial effects on the environment since they flow into natural or public water systems. Commonly, most of them are carcinogenic; consequently, their presence in the environment can also be harmful to human health. Since most electroanalytical studies to determine pesticides are done using a mercury electrode, the search for new materials becomes increasingly important. The electroanalytical determination of some pesticides using cathodically pretreated BDD electrodes is summarized here. 8.3.2.1 Carbaryl Carbaryl, like any other insecticide, must be toxic to insects to be effective; like all pesticides, it is also toxic to certain nontarget organisms, including humans. Carbaryl acts both by entering the stomach of the pest with food and by being absorbed through body contact. The occupational exposure of humans to this insecticide has been observed to cause cholinesterase inhibition and reduction of the activity of this enzyme in the blood, which may cause neurological effects [77]. Therefore, simple, sensitive, and reliable methods for the analysis of carbaryl in air, food, grains, and natural water are quite welcome. Codognoto et al. [78] reported the development of an analytical method to determine carbaryl, in aqueous solutions as well as in natural waters, using a BDD electrode and SWV. Prior to the determinations, the electrode was first anodically pretreated [+ 3.0 V versus Ag/AgCl (3.0 mol L−1 KCl) for 30 min] to clean its surface, followed by a cathodic pretreatment [−3.0 V versus Ag/AgCl (3.0 mol L−1 KCl) for 30 min]. The developed method of analysis does not involve any previous extraction, cleanup, preconcentration, or derivatization steps. The obtained analytical curve range was 2.5–30.0 μmol L−1 (see Figure 8.9), with a limit of detection (LOD) of 8.2 ± 0.2 μg L−1 in pure water (analytical sensitivity of 3.07 mA mmol−1 L) and a limit of quantification (LOQ) of 27.5 μg L−1 ; the attained reproducibility and repeatability (n = 10) were 3.9% and 3.2%, respectively. This analytical sensitivity was slightly decreased (to 2.80–2.90 mA mmol−1 L) when the experiments were carried out using water samples collected from two different points in a polluted urban creek. The obtained LOD value is quite adequate, considering that according to the local legislation the maximum amount of carbaryl allowed in natural water is 10 μg L−1 . The authors also evaluated the effect of other pesticides (fenthion and 4-nitrophenol) on the carbaryl determination and found an insignificant influence, as shown in Figure 8.10. In other words, the voltammetric procedure reported by the authors leads to clearly separated electrochemical responses for the three analytes, which can thus be determined simultaneously. 8.3.2.2 4-Nitrophenol 4-Nitrophenol (4-NP), a hazardous substance that can have a high environmental impact due to its toxicity and persistence, is a metabolite of several
194
CATHODIC TREATMENT OF BDD ELECTRODES AND THEIR USE IN ELECTROANALYSIS
Figure 8.9 Calibration curve from SWV responses of a cathodically pretreated BDD electrode (A = 0.62 cm2 ) for different carbaryl concentrations in the range 2.5–30.0 μmol L−1 in 0.1 mol L−1 Na2 SO4 (pH 6.0). SWV conditions: Es = 2 mV, a = 50 mV, f = 300 Hz. Inset: linear dependence of the peak current on the carbaryl concentration. (Reprinted from Ref. 78.)
Figure 8.10 SWV profile on the BDD electrode (A = 0.62 cm2 ) for 10 μmol L−1 4-nitrophenol (1), 10 μmol L−1 fenthion (2), and 25 μmol L−1 carbaryl (3) in a 0.1 mol L−1 Na2 SO4 (pH 6.0) solution. SWV conditions: Es = 2 mV, a = 50 mV, f = 300 Hz. (Reprinted from Ref. 78.)
organophosphorus pesticides. Thus, some electroanalytical methods have been developed to determine its residues in different types of samples. Pedrosa, Codognoto, and Avaca [79] reported the electroanalytical determination of 4-NP in aqueous solutions on a BDD electrode using SWV. Prior to the experiments the electrode was cathodically pretreated at − 3.0 V versus Ag/AgCl (3.0 mol L−1 KCl) for 30 s. The compound presented only one irreversible peak for both its oxidation at 1.0 V versus Ag/AgCl (3.0 mol L−1 KCl) and its reduction at −0.8 V versus
8.3 ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS
195
Ag/AgCl (3.0 mol L−1 KCl), as seen in Figure 8.11. The corresponding LOD values are 8.4 μg L−1 and 12.1 μg L−1 , respectively. Garbellini, Salazar-Banda, and Avaca [80] also investigated the determination of 4-NP on a cathodically pretreated BDD electrode using SWV, but associated with ultrasound radiation. Since this radiation can clean the electrode surface, its fouling commonly caused by strong adsorption of the electroactive species could be minimized and, consequently, the LOD values were improved. Prior to the experiments, the BDD electrode was pretreated in a 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 solution by applying + 3.0 V versus Ag/AgCl (3.0 mol L−1 KCl) for 5 s, followed by −3.0 V Ag/AgCl (3.0 mol L−1 KCl) for 30 s. As can be apprehended when Figure 8.12 is compared with Figure 8.11, clearly the application of ultrasound radiation increased the sensibility of the detection method compared to the silent conditions (about 3 times higher). This was explained by the authors as due 20
(a)
9
20
Ip/µA
15
8
10 5
15 I (µA)
0
7 0
3 4 1 2 5 –5 –1 [4–Nitrofenol]/10 mol L
6
10 5 4 3 2 1
5
0 0.8
0.9
1.0
1.1
1.2
E (V) vs Ag/AgCI 15
–15
9
(b)
–12
–Ip/µA
12 9
8
6
I (µA)
3
–9
7
0 0
1 2 3 [4–Nitrofenol]/10–5mol L–1
6 5
–6 4 3
–3
2 1
0 –0.4
–0.5
–0.6
–0.7
–0.8
–0.9
–1.0
–1.1
E (V) vs Ag/AgCI
Figure 8.11 SWV response of the BDD electrode (A = 0.62 cm2 ) for different 4-NP concentrations in a 0.1 mol L−1 Britton-Robson buffer (pH 6.0). (a) oxidation and (b) reduction-based determinations. SWV conditions: a = 60 mV, Es = 2 mV, f = 100 Hz. Insets: linear dependence of the peak current with 4-NP concentration. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 79.)
196
CATHODIC TREATMENT OF BDD ELECTRODES AND THEIR USE IN ELECTROANALYSIS
50 40 Ip/µA
30
12
30
11
20
10
A
I (µA)
10
9
0
20
(a)
13
B
40
8 0
10
20 30 40 50 –6 –1 [4–NP]/10 mol L
60 7 6
10
5 4 1
0 0.6
0.8
3 2
1.0
1.2
E (V) vs Ag/AgCI –120
13
−140
B
−120 −100 Ip/µA
–100 –80
11
−80 −60
10
A
−40
9
I (µA)
−20 0
–60
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
[4–NP]/10–6 mol L–1
–40
8 7 6 5 4
–20
3 2 1
0 –0.2
(b)
12
–0.4
–0.6
–0.8
–1.0
E (V) vs Ag/AgCI
Figure 8.12 SWV responses obtained on a BDD electrode (A = 0.25 cm2 ) using different 4-NP concentrations in a 0.1 mol L−1 Britton-Robson buffer (pH = 6.0) in the presence of ultrasound radiation. (a) oxidation and (b) reduction-based determinations. SWV conditions: f = 100 Hz, a = 50 mV, Es = 2 mV. Ultrasound conditions: d: 5 mm and A: 20%. Insets: The respective analytical curves for the oxidation and reduction processes under silent (A) and ultrasound conditions (B). (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 80.)
to the increase in mass transport and the cleaning of the electrode surface brought on by the ultrasound radiation. Furthermore, the sensitivity of the method based on the 4-NP reduction process was increased much more significantly than that based on the oxidation process. The obtained LOD values were 3.87 μg L−1 for the oxidation process and 2.57 μg L−1 for the reduction process; the corresponding LOQ values were 12.9 μg L−1 and 8.58 μg L−1 , respectively. 8.3.2.3 Chlorophenols Pentachlorophenol (PCP) is a very toxic compound and among the chlorophenols it was extensively used for decades as a fungicide in wood preservation. Its analysis has received special attention in order to measure the amounts of this substance that can be transferred to food by direct contact with wood treated with
8.3 ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS
197
PCP. Besides, it can be used as model compound for the development of new analytical techniques [43]. The toxicity and persistence of PCP in contaminated places is well known, so that it is considered as a toxicologically relevant pollutant [82]. Codognoto, Machado, and Avaca [43] reported on the optimization of the experimental parameters for the determination of PCP in pure and contaminated water on a BDD electrode also using SWV. Prior to the experiments, the electrode was cathodically pretreated by applying −3.0 V versus Ag/AgCl (3.0 mol L−1 KCl) for 30 s. The obtained calibration curves for the determination of PCP showed an excellent linear response, for solutions both in pure and contaminated water, but with different slopes (see Figure 8.13). Possible explanations for this behavior, which leads to different LOD values, were put forth by the authors: hindrance of a 4-CP adsorption step by contaminant organic molecules, decrease of the concentration of 4-CP or other chlorophenols by interaction with humic and fulvic substances, or presence of other unknown species that undergo oxidation in the same potential region. The optimized method yielded LOD values for PCP of 5.5 mg L−1 and 15.5 mg L−1 in pure and contaminated water, respectively. According to the authors, the LOD value obtained in pure water was low enough to comply with the limits imposed by environmental and/or health authorities for human consumption, whereas that obtained in polluted matrixes was just above that limit. Two years later, Suffredini et al. [18] clearly demonstrated that the electrochemical response of a BDD electrode in the determination of 4-chlorophenol or PCP was strongly affected by the type of pretreatment applied to its surface before measurements (see Section 8.2). Pedrosa, Machado, and Avaca [45] reported on the simultaneous determination of 4chlorophenol (4-CP), 2,4-dichlorophenol (2,4-CP), and 2,4,6-trichlorophenol (2,4,6-CP) in different water samples on a cathodically pretreated BDD electrode through a deconvolution procedure. This procedure was used in order to obtain a separation of the peaks
Figure 8.13 Analytical curves for PCP in solutions prepared with pure water () and with samples collected at point 1 (•), point 2 (), and point 3 () of a contaminated urban creek. SWV conditions: a = 60 mV, Es = 2 mV, f = 100 Hz. BDD electrode area = 0.62 cm2 . (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 43.)
198
CATHODIC TREATMENT OF BDD ELECTRODES AND THEIR USE IN ELECTROANALYSIS
TABLE 8.1 Analytical parameters for 4-CP determination in pure and contaminated water (from two different points of a polluted creek) samples, using SWV with a cathodically pretreated BDD electrode or an HPLC method. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 45.) Method BDD HPLC
Sample
R
LOQ (μg L−1 )
Recovery (%)
Milli Q Point 1 Point 2 Milli Q Point 1 Point 2
0.998 0.995 0.996 0.999 0.998 0.998
9.2 37.2 42.2 1.2 36.1 38.4
94.0 ± 3.1 92.2 ± 4.2 91.1 ± 3.5 96.0 ± 1.1 94.2 ± 5.2 95.1 ± 4.8
for each compound and to construct standard curves for each chlorophenol in the mixture. Analytical curves were obtained with the cathodically pretreated BDD electrode by the standard addition method for the mixture of chlorophenols in the different water samples (pure or collected in two different points of a polluted urban creek) and compared with those obtained using an HPLC method. Recovery experiments were also carried out. From the obtained analytical results, summarized in Table 8.1, the authors concluded that excellent recoveries were attainable even in highly polluted water samples, thus indicating that the reported procedure could be used for determinations in environmental matrices. A slight dependence of the LOQ values on the amount of pollution in the water samples was attributed to the same factors put forth by Codognoto, Machado, and Avaca [43] to explain the variation of the slope of the analytical curves for PCP in pure and contaminated water.
8.3.3
Determination of Substances in Food Samples
8.3.3.1 Aspartame Aspartame (N-L-α-aspartyl-L-phenylalanine methyl ester) has the potential to reduce the amount of sugars and calories in food products, and thus may be combined with sugars (such as sucrose, dextrose, and fructose) and/or sweeteners (such as acesulfame-K, sodium cyclamate, and saccharin). However, aspartame is not always suitable for baking because it often breaks down when heated and it loses much of its sweetness. Considering that most methods developed for aspartame determination require a lengthy pretreatment of the sample prior to analyses, Medeiros et al. [68] proposed an electroanalytical method using a BDD electrode and SWV to determine the aspartame concentration directly in the sample without pretreatment or chemical separation. Prior to the experiments, the BDD electrode was cathodically pretreated by applying −1.0 A cm−2 for 60 s in a 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 solution. As shown in Figure 8.14, the oxidation of aspartame on BDD presents a single peak at 1.6 V versus Ag/AgCl (3.0 mol L−1 KCl), with the characteristics of an irreversible reaction. The obtained analytical curve is linear in the aspartame concentration range 9.9–52 μmol L−1 , with an LOD of 0.23 μmol L−1 ; in repeatability studies (n = 5) of a 0.10 mmol L−1 aspartame solution, the obtained relative standard deviation (RSD) was 0.2%. Several dietary products containing aspartame were analyzed using the proposed SWV method and employing the standard addition method. The inset in Figure 8.14b is the obtained analytical curve
8.3 ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS
12 R = 0.9998 10 8 6 4 2 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 [Aspartame]/10–5 mol L–1
11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2
I (µA)
25
I (µA)
20
199
15
10
1
5
(a) 0 1.3
1.4
1.5
1.6
1.7
1.8
1.9
E (V) vs. Ag/AgCl 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 –3 –2 –1 0 1 2 3 4 [Aspartame]/10–5 mol L–1
5
I (µA)
25
20
4 3 2
15 I (µA)
1 10
5 (b)
0 1.3
1.4
1.5
1.6
1.7
1.8
E (V) vs. Ag/AgCl
Figure 8.14 (a) SWV response of a cathodically pretreated BDD electrode (A = 0.72 cm2 ) for the oxidation of aspartame in increasing concentrations [9.9–52 μmol L−1 , in 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 (curve 1)]; Inset: corresponding analytical curve. (b) Square-wave voltammograms obtained for the determination of aspartame in a sweetener (Zero cal®). SWV conditions: a = 40 mV, Es = 2 mV, f = 10 Hz. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 68.)
for the determination of aspartame in a sample of a dietary product, the sweetener Zero cal®. 8.3.3.2 Sodium Cyclamate Sodium cyclamate is a white, crystalline, and odorless powder. Although 30 times sweeter than sucrose, it is noncaloric (zero calories) and more stable than other artificial sweeteners, such as aspartame and saccharin, which allows its use at high and low temperatures [82]. Sodium cyclamate is commonly used together with saccharin because cyclamate can mask the bitter flavor left by saccharin, but its
200
CATHODIC TREATMENT OF BDD ELECTRODES AND THEIR USE IN ELECTROANALYSIS
use has been banned in the US because it was found that it could be metabolized as cyclohexylamine, which can cause several health problems. So, taking into account the interest in the development of analytical methods for the determination of these sweeteners in dietary products, Medeiros et al. [69] proposed the use of SWV with a BDD electrode for the analytical determination of sodium cyclamate. The BDD electrode was cathodically pretreated the same way as it was done for the determination of aspartame [68] (discussed earlier). Figure 8.15 clearly shows the enhancement of the BDD electrochemical activity brought on by this cathodic pretreatment, compared to its untreated (as-received) response. The samples were analyzed as received in a 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 solution in the concentration range 5.0 × 10−5 −4.1 × 10−4 mol L−1 , with an LOD of 4.8 × 10−6 mol L−1 . In the repeatability and reproducibility studies (n = 5) of a 3.0 mmol L−1 cyclamate solution, RSD values of 1.2% and 2.4% were obtained, respectively; furthermore, the proposed method was applied with success in the determination of sodium cyclamate in several dietary products. 8.3.3.3 Aspartame and Sodium Cyclamate Medeiros et al. [70] also reported on the simultaneous determination of aspartame and sodium cyclamate in dietary products using SWV and a cathodically pretreated BDD electrode. The SWV oxidation peak potentials of aspartame and cyclamate present in binary mixtures are about 400 mV apart, as shown in Figure 8.16. For aspartame, LOD was 0.47 μmol L−1 in the presence of 0.30 mmol L−1 cyclamate; for sodium cyclamate, LOD was 4.2 μmol L−1 in the presence of 0.10 mmol L−1 aspartame. When simultaneously changing the concentration of both sweeteners in a 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 solution, the corresponding LOD values were 0.35 and 4.5 μmol L−1 , respectively. In repeatability tests (n = 5), the obtained RSD values were 1.3%, for a 0.10 mmol L−1 aspartame solution, and 1.1% for a 3.0 mmol L−1 cyclamate solution. The proposed voltammetric method
200 a b
I (µA)
150
100
50
0 1.6
1.7
1.8
1.9
2.0
2.1
E (V) vs. Ag/AgCl (KCl 3.0 mol L–1)
Figure 8.15 SWV responses for 3.0 mmol L−1 sodium cyclamate in 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 using an as-received (a) or a cathodically pretreated (b) BDD electrode. SWV conditions: a = 20 mV, Es = 2 mV, f = 10 Hz. BDD electrode area = 0.72 cm2 . (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 69.)
8.3 ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS
201
(b) (a)
(c)
Figure 8.16 (a) SW voltammograms obtained for the oxidation of aspartame and cyclamate in 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 . The concentrations of both aspartame (5.0–50 μmol L−1 ) and cyclamate (0.050–0.50 mmol L−1 ) were changed simultaneously. (b) Analytical curves for aspartame. (c) Analytical curves for cyclamate. SWV conditions: a = 40 mV, Es = 2 mV, f = 10 Hz. BDD electrode area = 0.72 cm2 . (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 70.)
was successfully applied in the simultaneous determination of aspartame and sodium cyclamate in several dietary products, with results in very good agreement with those results obtained using an HPLC method. 8.3.3.4 Total Phenols Total phenol concentration is an essential indicator of the state of quality of pharmaceutical products and food, since its concentration could be related to nutritional, processing, and health aspects. Thus, Dejmkova et al. [83] report on a method to determine total phenols in foods such as teas, juices, and wines. The electrode was electrochemically pretreated in 1 mol L−1 HNO3 by a procedure similar to the one proposed by Suffredini et al. [18]: +3.0 V versus Ag/AgCl (3 mol L−1 KCl) for 20 min, followed by −3.0 V versus Ag/AgCl (3 mol L−1 KCl) also for 20 min. When the applied potential on the cathodically pretreated BDD is positive enough to oxidize the phenols present in the sample, the charge consumed during the oxidation could be related to the total phenol content in the sample. The proposed method is robust, allowing a rapid evaluation of total phenols directly in real samples after a simple dilution with the supporting electrolyte. The electrode does not present the drawback of fouling (an electrochemical cleaning procedure was successfully optimized) and the results were validated using the standard Folin-Ciocalteau assay. 8.3.4
Determination of Substances in Pharmaceutical Samples
8.3.4.1 Sulfamethoxazole and Trimethoprim Sulfonamides, indicated primarily to treat urinary infections, are used in combination with trimethoprim (TMP) for the treatment of ear infections, bronchitis, sinusitis, and pneumocystis pneumonia. The corresponding pharmaceutical products usually consist of a sulfonamide mixed with another
202
CATHODIC TREATMENT OF BDD ELECTRODES AND THEIR USE IN ELECTROANALYSIS
μ
drug that increases its power, such as the sulfamethoxazole (SMX) and TMP mixture, an often used pharmaceutical product. In the specific case of analysis of drugs, quality control can be considered as one of the most important aspects because it contributes to ensure the efficacy, safety, and fundamentally the quality standards of medicines. Thus, the search for techniques that are sensitive, accurate, and easily accessible for the determination of compounds present in several commercial drugs has received much attention. In this context, Andrade et al. [73] reported on the simultaneous electrochemical detection by differential pulse voltammetry (DPV) of SMX and TMP using cathodically (HT-) or anodically (OT-) pretreated BDD electrodes. The cathodic or anodic pretreatment was carried out by applying −0.5 A cm−2 or 0.5 A cm−2 , respectively, during 60 s, in a 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 solution. Cyclic voltammetric studies (see Figure 8.17) show that on an HT-BDD electrode both the SMX and TMP voltammograms exhibit well-defined irreversible oxidation peaks at 1080 mV and 1100 mV versus Ag/AgCl (3.0 mol L−1 KCl), respectively. Conversely, within the investigated potential range (0.5 V to 1.3 V versus Ag/AgCl), no reduction peaks are observed on the reverse scan. However, since the anodic peak potentials for SMX and TMP are separated by only 20 mV, their simultaneous analyses would not be possible under these conditions. Thus, by changing the solution pH, a greatly increased difference in the oxidation peak potential values (180 mV) was found at pH 7 (see Figure 8.18a), associated to two well-defined oxidation waves [Ep = 920 and 1100 mV versus Ag/AgCl (3.0 mol L−1 KCl)] that correspond to the oxidation of SMX and TMP, respectively. When an OT-BDD electrode was used, the magnitude of these oxidation waves decreased, but this decrease was more significant for the SMX oxidation. As can be seen in Figure 8.18b, independently of whether an HT-BDD or an OT-BDD electrode is used, the SMX oxidation current peak decreases as the pH increases. Besides, the magnitude of the current peak obtained for the SMX and TMP oxidation was always higher when the HT-BDD electrode was used.
Figure 8.17 Cyclic voltammograms (ν = 50 mV s−1 ) for (a) blank solution (0.2 mol L−1 Britton-Robison buffer, pH 2.0) and solutions containing (b) 1.0 mg L−1 SMX or (c) 1.0 mg L−1 TMP in this buffer, on a cathodically pretreated BDD electrode. BDD electrode area = 0.63 cm2 . (Reprinted from Ref. 73.)
8.3 ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS
203
(a)
(b)
Figure 8.18 (a) Differential pulse voltammetric responses (oxidation) obtained at an anodically (solid line) or cathodically (dashed line) pretreated BDD electrode (A = 0.63 cm2 ) using a mixture of 1.0 mg L−1 SMX and 1.0 mg L−1 TMP in a 0.2 mol L−1 Britton-Robson buffer (pH 7.0). (b) Effect of pH on the SMX oxidation peak current at an anodically (solid line) or cathodically (dashed line) pretreated BDD electrode. DPV conditions: scan rate, 50 mV s−1 ; pulse amplitude, 60 mV; pulse width, 10 ms. (Reprinted from Ref. 73.)
In an effort to explain the different electrochemical behaviors obtained when using an HT- or an OT-BDD electrode, Andrade et al. [73] analyzed the acid-base chemistry of SMX and TMP. The former is a weak acid (pKa = 5.6), whereas the latter is a weak base (pKa = 7.3). Thus, if pH > pKa , the conjugate base predominates in the solution bulk, the analyte then being negatively charged. Consequently, an electrostatic repulsion between sulfa anions and the OT-BDD electrode could be expected for the measurements carried out at pH > 5.6. In fact, for pH > 5.6, the current peaks obtained for the SMX oxidation on the OT-BDD electrode (see Figure 8.18b) were always lower than those obtained on the HT-BDD electrode. However, when the measurements were
204
CATHODIC TREATMENT OF BDD ELECTRODES AND THEIR USE IN ELECTROANALYSIS
done at pH < 5.6, the SMX oxidation current peaks were not higher on the OT-BDD electrode when compared with those obtained on the HT-BDD electrode, as it could be expected. Furthermore, in the pH range investigated (2 to 7) the oxidation current peaks always decreased linearly with pH, independently of whether an HT-BDD or an OT-BDD electrode was used. Conversely, for pH < 7.3, the magnitude of the TMP oxidation current peak could be expected to be higher on the OT-BDD electrode than on the HT-BDD electrode, but actually it was about 40% lower. Taking this into account, the authors concluded that the electroanalytical performance of the electrodes is not significantly influenced by electrostatic interaction between the analytes and the BDD surface; hence, the obtained results should be explained mainly taking into account the different surface conductivity presented by the HT-BDD or OT-BDD electrodes. However, Ivandini et al., [84] have pointed out that while HT-BDD acts as an excellent electrode for the detection of negatively charged DNA, OT-BDD works exceptionally well for the detection of the positively charged oxidized form of glutathione [85], due to the operation of strong electrostatic interactions. Clearly, questions involving the influence of surface chemistry of the BDD films on the electrochemical processes occurring on these electrodes are still controversial, needing to be further investigated. A series of DPV voltammograms obtained for the simultaneous determination of SMX and TMP at different concentrations (1.0−10 mg L−1 and 0.2−2.0 mg L−1 for SMX and TMP, respectively) in a 0.2 mol L−1 Britton-Robinson buffer (pH 7) by DPV at an HT-BDD electrode are shown in Figure 8.19. Notice in the figure insets that the respective analytical curves presented a good linearity in the investigated concentration range (r 2 = 0.9993 for both SMX and TMP). The calculated values for LOD and LOQ were 3.65 μg L−1 (14.4 nmol L−1 ) and 12.2 μg L−1 (48.2 nmol L−1 ) for SMX; these values were 3.92 μg L−1 (13.5 nmol L−1 ) and 13.1 μg L−1 (45.1 nmol L−1 ) for TMP.
Figure 8.19 Differential pulse voltammetric responses (simultaneous oxidation) obtained on an HTBDD electrode (A = 0.63 cm2 ) at different concentrations of SMX/TMP in a 0.2 mol L−1 Britton-Robson buffer solution (pH 7.0). SMX/TMP concentrations: (1) 1.0/0.2; (2) 2.0/0.4; (3) 3.0/0.6; (4) 4.0/0.8; (5) 5.0/1.0; (6) 6.0/1.2; (7) 7.0/1.4; (8) 8.0/1.6; (9) 9.0/1.8, and (10) 10/2.0 mg L−1 . Inset: respective analytical curves for SMX and TMP. DPV conditions: scan rate, 50 mV s−1 ; pulse amplitude, 60 mV; pulse width, 10 ms. (Reprinted from Ref. 73.)
8.3 ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS
205
Besides, repeatability tests carried out by successive measurements (n = 10) in the same solution (10 mg L−1 SMX and 2.0 mg L−1 TMP) showed RSD values of 0.3% and 0.1%, respectively. Despite the fact that LOD and LOQ are not considered so relevant in drugs determination, because of their high concentration in commercial formulations, the obtained values clearly indicate that quite low concentrations of SMX and TMP can be detected using the HT-BDD electrode. So, the proposed method was applied successfully to determine SMX and TMP by the standard addition method in three different commercial formulations. 8.3.4.2 Sulfamethoxazole and Sulfadiazine Souza et al. [86] also reported on the electrochemical determination of sulfonamides (sulfadiazine and sulfamethoxazole, independently) in pharmaceutical formulations employing a cathodically pretreated BDD electrode and SWV. The BDD electrode was pretreated in 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 similarly to what was done by Salazar-Banda et al. [20]. The as-received electrode was first anodically pretreated (+3.0 V versus SCE for 30 min) to clean its surface, followed by a cathodic pretreatment [−3.0 V versus SCE for 30 min). Then, before each measurement, this cathodic pretreatment was carried out for 30 s (only for the very first pretreatment each day, the applied potential was −2.0 V versus SCE). Good linear analytical curves were achieved for both sulfonamides and the obtained LOD values were 2.19 and 1.15 μmol L−1 for sulfadiazine and SMX, respectively. In the repeatability studies (n = 7) of 90 μmol L−1 sulfadiazine and 0.25 mmol L−1 SMX solutions, RSD values of 0.56% and 0.58% were obtained, respectively. In the corresponding reproducibility study (n = 5), RSD values of 0.78% and 0.71% were obtained for sulfadiazine and SMX, respectively. The recovery values for both sulfonamides were in the range 95–104% and the methodology was successfully compared with the standard HPLC method, with relative errors of −4.31% and −0.79% for sulfadiazine and sulfamethoxazole, respectively. 8.3.4.3 Acetylsalicylic Acid Acetylsalicylic acid (ASA), also known by the trade name aspirin, is one of the oldest medicines that still play an important role in modern therapeutics, being widely employed in pharmaceutical formulations for the relief of headaches, fever, muscular pain, and inflammations caused by arthritis or injury. Commonly, ASA is determined by titration after its conversion to salicylic acid and acetic acid by alkaline hydrolysis. Aiming at obtaining a simpler procedure, Sartori et al. [87] investigated the determination of ASA in pharmaceutical formulations using SWV and a cathodically pretreated BDD electrode. In this proposed electroanalytical method, ASA can be directly determined in a 0.01 mol L−1 H2 SO4 solution (see Figure 8.20). The obtained analytical curve was linear in the ASA concentration range 2.50 × 10−6 −1.05 × 10− mol L−1 , with a LOD of 2.0 μmol L−1 ; in the repeatability study (n = 10) of 45 μmol L−1 ASA solutions, a RSD value of 1.4% was obtained. The proposed method was applied with success in the determination of ASA in several pharmaceutical formulations (commercial adult and children tablets) and the obtained results were in close agreement, at a 95% confidence level, with those obtained using an official method of the British Pharmacopoeia. The reported results demonstrate that the combination of SWV with an HT-BDD electrode is a feasible alternative for the analytical determination of ASA in commercial adult and children tablets without previous hydrolysis of the analyte.
206
CATHODIC TREATMENT OF BDD ELECTRODES AND THEIR USE IN ELECTROANALYSIS
50
50 I /µA
40
40
30 20 10
I /µA
0 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 –6 –1 [AAS]/10 mol L
30 20
17 10 1 0 1.7
1.8
1.9 2.0 E (V) vs Ag/AgCl
2.1
2.2
Figure 8.20 SWV response (direct current) of an HT-BDD electrode (A = 0.33 cm2 ) for different ASA concentrations in 0.01 mol L−1 H2 SO4 : (1) 0; (2) 2.50 × 10−6 ; (3) 5.00 × 10−6 ; (4) 7.50 × 10−6 ; (5) 1.50 × 10−5 ; (6) 2.25 × 10−5 ; (7) 3.00 × 10−5 ; (8) 3.75 × 10−5 ; (9) 4.50 × 10−5 ; (10) 5.25 × 10−5 ; (11) 6.00 × 10−5 ; (12) 6.75 × 10−5 ; (13) 7.50 × 10−5 ; (14) 8.25 × 10−5 ; (15) 9.00 × 10−5 ; (16) 9.75 × 10−5 ; (17) 1.05 × 10−4 mol L−1 . Inset: analytical curve for the ASA oxidation process. SWV conditions: a = 40 mV, Es = 3 mV, f = 50 Hz. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 87.)
8.3.4.4 Paracetamol and Caffeine Paracetamol (N-acetyl-p-aminophenol, acetaminophen), a substance derived from p-aminophenol, is considered an excellent analgesic in cases of mild to moderate pain, besides not causing relevant gastrointestinal effects. It is noncarcinogenic and an effective substitute for aspirin for patients with sensitivity to it. Caffeine is used therapeutically in combination with ergotamine in the treatment of migraines or with nonsteroidal anti-inflamatories in analgesic formulations. Lourenc¸a˜ o et al. [88] investigated the use of a cathodically pretreated BDD electrode to develop simple, selective, and sensitive methods for the determination of paracetamol and caffeine, simultaneously and individually. This was achieved using (1) SWV, for paracetamol; and (2) DPV, for caffeine individually and for both drugs simultaneously. The HT-BDD electrode was obtained by applying −1.0 A cm−2 for 180 s in a 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 solution. In the binary mixtures, a separation of about 550 mV between the peak oxidation potentials of paracetamol and caffeine was obtained. Figure 8.21 shows the DPV voltammograms obtained for the simultaneous determination of the drugs. The corresponding calibration curves showed an excellent linear response, in the range 0.50–83 μmol L−1 for both compounds. The LOD values for the simultaneous determination of paracetamol and caffeine were 0.49 and 0.035 μmol L−1 , respectively. In the repeatability study (n = 5) of a 50 μmol L−1 paracetamol and caffeine solution, RSD values of 0.3% and 1.8% were obtained, respectively. The proposed method was successfully applied in the simultaneous determination of paracetamol and caffeine in several pharmaceutical formulations (tablets), with results similar to those obtained using a reference HPLC method. 8.3.4.5 Sildenafil Citrate (Viagra®) Sildenafil citrate (1-[[3-(6,7-dihydro-1methyl-7-oxo-3-propyl-1-H-pyrazolo[4,3-d]pirydin-5-yl)-4-ethoxyphenyl]sulfonyl]-4methylpiperazine citrate), commonly known as Viagra®, is a drug widely used as oral
8.3 ELECTROANALYTICAL APPLICATIONS
207
200
I (μA)
150
100 15 50 1 0 0.4
0.6
0.8 1.0 1.2 E (V) vs. Ag/AgCl
1.4
1.6
Figure 8.21 Differential pulse voltammetric curves obtained for the oxidation of paracetamol and caffeine at equal concentrations in a 0.2 mol L−1 acetate buffer solution (pH 4.5): (1) 0.50, (2) 2.0, (3) 4.0, (4) 5.9, (5) 7.9, (6) 9.8, (7) 19, (8) 28, (9) 37, (10) 45, (11) 54, (12) 61, (13) 69, (14) 76, and (15) 83 μmol L−1 . DPV conditions: scan rate, 70 mV s−1 ; modulation amplitude, 100 mV; modulation time, 7 ms. BDD electrode area = 0.72 cm2 . (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 88.)
therapy for erectile dysfunction. Due to the high consumption of sildenafil, selective, sensitive, and easily used methods of analysis of its pharmaceutical formulations are welcome, to assess not only their quality but also their authenticity. Accordingly, Batista et al. [89] proposed the use of DPV in conjunction with a cathodically (−1.0 A cm−2 for 240 s in 0.5 mol L−1 H2 SO4 ) pretreated BDD electrode for the analytical determination of commercial pharmaceutical samples of Viagra®. According to the authors, the HT-BDD electrode presented a better peak definition and a higher current magnitude, indicating that the cathodic pretreatment of the electrode led to a larger electrochemical activity for sildenafil oxidation. The cyclic voltammetric response of sidenafil presents two electrochemically irreversible anodic peaks, at ∼1.5 and ∼2.0 V versus Ag/AgCl (3.0 mol L−1 KCl). In order to avoid interference from the oxygen evolution reaction, only the first peak was considered for the development of the electroanalytical method. After optimization of the DPV parameters, which included the maximum peak current and the minimum half-peak width values, the authors validated the method taking into account selectivity (possible interferents), linearity, and recovery studies. All these validation criteria were satisfied and the obtained LOD value was 0.64 μmol L−1 . In the repeatability (n = 10) and reproducibility (n = 5) studies of 4.0 μmol L−1 sildenafil solutions, RSD values of 1.1% and 1.9% were obtained, respectively. Table 8.2 summarizes the results obtained for determinations of sildenafil citrate in Viagra® commercial tablets of different dosages employing the proposed DPV method compared with those obtained using a reference HPLC method. 8.3.4.6 Lidocaine Lidocaine (2-(diethylamino)-N -(2,6-dimethylphenyl)acetamide) is a local anesthetic commonly used to relieve pain related to surgical, dental, and gynecological procedures. The therapeutic and toxic effects of lidocaine are directly related to its concentration and metabolites. The toxicity of lidocaine affects primarily the cardiovascular and central nervous systems, and overdoses can result in ventricular
208
CATHODIC TREATMENT OF BDD ELECTRODES AND THEIR USE IN ELECTROANALYSIS
TABLE 8.2 Sildenafil citrate content in Viagra ® pharmaceutical formulations determined by a proposed differential pulse voltammetric (DPV) method using an HT-BDD electrode and by a comparative HPLC method. (Reprinted from Ref. 89.) Determined value (mg) DPV a
HPLC a
Relative errorb (%)
25.7 ± 0.9 51.5 ± 0.5 105.0 ± 0.9
26.1 ± 0.5 52.4 ± 0.8 102.0 ± 0.6
–1.5 –1.7 2.9
Label value (mg) 25 50 100
a Average of 3 measurements. b 100 × [(DPV value—HPLC value)/HPLC value].
arrhythmia. Taking into account the lack of a simple and direct electroanalytical method for lidocaine determination, Oliveira et al. [90] investigated the use of SWV with a BDD electrode for this purpose. According to the authors, a cathodic pretreatment was necessary for conditioning the BDD surface prior to the electroanalytical determinations. Thus, before each analysis the BDD electrode was pretreated in a 0.1 mol L−1 HClO4 solution by applying + 3.2 V versus Ag/AgCl for 30 s (to clean the electrode surface), followed by −2.8 V versus Ag/AgCl, for 30 s. Figure 8.22 shows the SWV responses obtained for different concentrations of lidocaine as well as the corresponding analytical curve. The obtained LOD and LOQ values were 10.0 and 34.4 mg L−1 , respectively. The proposed method was successfully applied in the determination of lidocaine in three different commercial gel formulations, in which lidocaine is mixed with propyleneglycol; the presence of propyleneglycol had no influence on the voltammetric responses, as it can be verified in Table 8.3.
60 Ip (µA)
50
70 60
I (µA)
40 30
50 40 30 20 10 0
20
background curve
(b) 6 8 10 12 2 4 Concentration (10–5 M)
0
10 0
(a) 0.0
0.4
0.8 1.2 E (V) Ag/AgCl
1.6
2.0
Figure 8.22 (a) SWV response obtained for the oxidation of lidocaine at different concentrations in a 0.1 mol L−1 Britton-Robson buffer (pH 2.0); (b) Linear dependence of the oxidation peak current with the lidocaine concentration. SWV conditions: a = 50 mV, Es = 2 mV, f = 150 Hz. BDD electrode area = 0.25 cm2 . (Reprinted from Ref. 90.)
8.5 CONCLUSIONS
209
TABLE 8.3 Lidocaine recovery percentage from samples of commercial pharmaceutical preparations (gels) analyzed using square-wave voltammetry and a cathodically pretreated BDD. (Reprinted from Ref. 90.)
Cream A Cream B Cream C
Label value (mg g−1 )
Found value (mg g−1 )
Recoverya (%)
RSDb (%)
50.0 50.0 50.0
49.8 49.2 48.8
99.6 98.4 97.6
2.1 2.3 2.6
a 100 × (found value/label value); b Relative standard deviation of measurements done in triplicate.
8.4
GOLD DEPOSITION AND STRIPPING
Finally, it should be noted that BDD films have also been used as electrodes to investigate the deposition of different metals, when the electrochemical pretreatment of their surfaces was also found to play a role. Specifically, Holt et al. [91] reported on the deposition of gold on BDD by the reduction of tetrachloroaurate(III). Considering that the adhesion and the electrochemical reactivity of gold particles on diamond likely depended on the physical and chemical nature of the electrode surface, Holt and colleagues investigated the deposition and stripping characteristics of gold metal on a cathodically or anodically pretreated BDD electrode. The cathodic or anodic pretreatment was carried out in dilute aqua regia by applying − 1.2 V (versus SCE) for 10 s or + 2.0 V (versus SCE) for 30 s, respectively. Significant increases in both the gold deposition current and the stripping efficiency were found when the cathodically pretreated BDD electrode was used. The authors reported that the cathodic pretreatment had a dramatic effect on the reduction process of the tetrachloroaurate(III) ion: decrease of the reduction overpotential by about 0.1 V and enhancement of the reduction current by nearly a factor of 2. Additionally and even more significant, the size of the stripping peak increased, enhancing the stripping efficiency. XPS quantitative analyses revealed that the amount of gold deposited on the cathodically pretreated BDD electrode was about 10 times higher than that on an untreated BDD electrode.
8.5
CONCLUSIONS
The cathodic pretreatment of BDD electrodes, which increases the fraction of hydrogen termination on their surfaces, has been shown to enhance the electrochemical activity of the electrodes toward many redox couples and analytes. Consequently, the use of hydrogen-terminated BDD in the electroanalytical determination of several analytes has been found to be quite convenient, since boosted sensitivities and selectivity could be attained. Such effects have been reported in the determination of different pesticides in environmental samples, sweeteners, and total phenols in food samples, and drugs in pharmaceutical samples. Nevertheless, a better characterization of the superficial state of BDD brought on by different types of cathodic pretreatments is still necessary and might contribute to even more significant advancements in the application of this electrode in electroanalysis.
210
CATHODIC TREATMENT OF BDD ELECTRODES AND THEIR USE IN ELECTROANALYSIS
REFERENCES 1. Y.V. Pleskov, A.Y. Sakharova, M.D. Krotova, L.L. Bouilov, B.V. Spitsyn, J. Electroanal. Chem. 1987, 228 , 19–27. 2. A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, T.N. Rao, D.A. Tryk, Diamond Electrochemistry, Elsevier, Tokyo, 2005. 3. J.C. Angus, Y.V. Pleskov, S.C. Eaton, in Semiconductors and Semimetals: Thin Film Diamond II (C.E. Nebel, J. Ristein, eds.), Elsevier, San Diego, 2004, 77 , pp. 97–120. 4. G.M. Swain, in Semiconductors and Semimetals: Thin Film Diamond II (C.E. Nebel, J. Ristein, eds.), Elsevier, San Diego, 2004, 77 , pp. 121–148. 5. G.M. Swain, in Electroanalytical Chemistry (A.J. Bard, I. Rubinstein, eds.), Marcel Dekker, New York, 2004, 22 , pp. 182–278. 6. O. Chailapakul, W. Siangproh, D.A. Tryk, Sens. Lett . 2006, 4 , 99–119. 7. G. Chen, Talanta 2007, 74 , 326–332. 8. J. Park, V. Quaiserov´a-Mocko, B.A. Patel, M. Novotny, A. Liu, X. Bian, J.J. Galliganb, G.M. Swain, Analyst 2008, 133 , 17–24. 9. K. Peckov´a, J. Musilov´a, J. Barek, Crit. Rev. Anal. Chem. 2009, 39 , 148–172. 10. J.H.T. Luong, K.B. Male, J.D. Glennon, Analyst 2009, 134 , 1965–1979. 11. S. Jolley, M. Koppang, T. Jackson, G.M. Swain, Anal. Chem. 1997, 69 , 4099–4107. 12. M.C. Granger, G.M. Swain, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1999, 146 , 4551–4558. 13. E. Popa, H. Notsu, T. Miwa, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, Electrochem. Solid-State Lett . 1999, 2 , 49–51. 14. H. Notsu, I. Yagi, T. Tatsuma, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, J. Electroanal. Chem. 2000, 492 , 31–37. 15. D.A. Tryk, H. Tachibana, H. Inoue, A. Fujishima, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2007, 16 , 881–887. 16. M. Panizza, I. Duo, P.A. Michaud, G. Cerisola, C. Comninellis, Electrochem. Solid-State Lett . 1999, 3 , 429–430. 17. I. Duo, C. L´evy-Cl´ement, A. Fujishima, C. Comninellis, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2004, 34 , 935–943. 18. H.B. Suffredini, V.A. Pedrosa, L. Codognoto, S.A.S. Machado, R.C. Rocha-Filho, L.A. Avaca, Electrochim. Acta 2004, 49 , 4021–4026. 19. E. Mah´e, D. Devilliers, C. Comminellis, Electrochim. Acta 2005, 50 , 2263–2277. 20. G.R. Salazar-Banda, L.S. Andrade, P.A.P. Nascente, P.S. Pizani, R.C. Rocha-Filho, L.A. Avaca, Electrochim. Acta 2006, 51 , 4612–4619. 21. H. Girard, N. Simon, D. Ballutaud, M. Herlem, A. Etcheberry, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2007, 16 , 316–325. 22. N. Simon, H. Girard, M. Manesse, D. Ballutaud, A. Etcheberry, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2008, 17 , 1371–1375. 23. A. Denisenko, C. Pietzka, A. Romanyuk, H. El-Hajj, E. Kohn, J. Appl. Phys. 2008, 103 , 1–8. 24. M. Wang, N. Simon, C. Decorse-Pascanut, M. Bouttemy, A. Etcheberry, M. Li, R. Boukherroub, S. Szunerits, Electrochim. Acta 2009, 54 , 5818–5824. 25. C.H. Goeting, F. Marken, A. Guti´errez-Sosa, R.G. Compton, J.S. Foord, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2000, 9 , 390–396. 26. F. Marken, R.G. Compton, C.H. Goeting, J.S. Foord, S.D. Bull, S.G. Davies, J. Solid State Electrochem. 2001, 5 , 88–93. 27. I. Yagi, H. Notsu, T. Kondo, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, J. Electroanal. Chem. 1999, 473 , 173–178.
REFERENCES
211
28. S. Ferro, A. De Battisti , Electrochim. Acta 2002, 47 , 1641–1649. 29. K. Hayashi, S. Yamanaka, H. Watanabe, T. Sekiguchi, H. Okushi, K. Kajimura, J. Appl. Phys. 1997, 81 , 744–753. 30. J.B. Cui, J. Ristein, L. Ley, Appl. Phys. Lett . 1998, 81 , 429–432. 31. F. Maier, M. Riedel, B. Mantel, J. Ristein, L. Ley, Phys. Rev. Lett . 2000, 85 , 3472–3475. 32. D. Takeuchi, H. Kato, G.S. Ri, T. Yamada, P.R. Vinod, D. Hwang, C.E. Nebel, H. Okushi, S. Yamasaki, Appl. Phys. Lett . 2005, 86 , 1–3. 33. P.K. Bachmann, W. Eberhardt, B. Kessler, H. Lade, K. Radermacher, D.U. Wiecher, H. Wilson, Diam. Rel. Mat . 1996, 5 , 1378–1383. 34. M. Tachiki, T. Fukuda, K. Sugata, H. Seo, H. Umezawa, H. Kawarada, Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 2000, 39 , 4631–4632. 35. K.B. Holt, A.J. Bard, Y. Show, G.M. Swain. J. Phys. Chem. B 2004, 108 , 15117–15127. 36. D.A. Tryk, K. Tsunozaki, T.N. Rao, A. Fujishima, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2001, 10 , 1804–1809. 37. M.N. Latto, D.J. Riley, P.W. May, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2000, 9 , 1181–1183. 38. M.N. Latto, G. Pastor-Moreno, D.J. Riley, Electroanalysis 2004, 16 , 434–441. 39. I. Duo, A. Fujishima, C. Comninellis, Electrochem. Comm. 2003, 5 , 695–700. 40. D. Becker, K. J¨uttner, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2003, 33 , 959–967. 41. D. Becker, K. J¨uttner, New Diam. Front. Carbon Technol . 2003, 13 , 67–78. 42. D. Becker, K. J¨uttner, Electrochim. Acta 2003, 49 , 29–39. 43. L. Codognoto, S.A.S. Machado, L.A. Avaca, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2002, 11 , 1670–1675. 44. V.A. Pedrosa, L. Codognoto, L.A. Avaca, Quim. Nova 2003, 26 , 844–849. 45. V.A. Pedrosa, S.A.S. Machado, L.A. Avaca, Anal. Lett . 2006, 39 , 1955–1965. 46. S. Ferro, M. Dal Colle, A. De Battisti, Carbon 2005, 43 , 1191–1203. 47. M. Szameitat, X. Jiang, W. Beyer, Appl. Phys. Lett . 2000, 77 , 1554–1556. 48. J. Ristein, F. Maier, M. Riedel, J.B. Cui, L. Ley, Phys. Stat. Sol. (A) 2000, 181 , 65–76. 49. M.C. Rossi, F. Spaziani, S. Salvatori, G. Conte. Phys. Stat. Sol. A 2003, 199 , 71–76. 50. J. Ristein, M. Riedel, L. Ley, J. Electrochem. Soc. 2004, 151 , E315–E321. 51. J. Ristein, W. Zhang, L. Ley, Phys. Rev. E 2008, 78 , 041602–1–041602-8. 52. J.B. Cui, J. Ristein, L. Ley, Phys. Rev. B 1999, 59 , 5847–5856. 53. S. Kulesza, J. Patyk, F. Rozploch, Chem. Phys. Lett . 2004, 391 , 56–59. 54. M. Hupert, A. Muck, J. Wang, J. Stotter, Z. Cvackova, S. Haymond, Y. Show, G.M. Swain, Diam. Rel. Mat . 2003, 12 , 1940–1949. 55. J. Wang, F. Liu, H. Chen, D. Chen, Mater. Chem. Phys. 2009, 115 , 590–598. 56. G. Pastor-Moreno, D.J. Riley, Electrochem. Comm. 2002, 4 , 218–221. 57. Y.V. Pleskov, Russ. J. Electrochem. 2002, 38 , 1275–1291. 58. S. Wang, G.M. Swain, J. Phys. Chem. C 2007, 108 , 3986–3995. 59. Y.V. Pleskov, J. Anal. Chem., 2000, 55 , 1045–1050. 60. V.A. Pedrosa, H.B. Suffredini, L. Codognoto, S.T. Tanimoto, S.A.S. Machado, L.A. Avaca, Anal. Letters 2005, 38 , 1115–1125. 61. M. Panizza, G. Cerisola, Electrochim. Acta 2005, 51 , 191–199. 62. M.A.Q. Alfaro, S. Ferro, C.A. Martinez-Huitle, Y.M. Vong, J. Braz. Chem. Soc. 2006, 17 , 227–236. 63. C.A. Martinez-Huitle, S. Ferro, Chem. Soc. Rev . 2006, 35 , 1324–1340. 64. L.S. Andrade, L.A.M. Ruotolo, R.C. Rocha-Filho, N. Bocchi, S.R. Biaggio, J. Iniesta, V. Garc´ıa-Garc´ıa, V. Montiel, Chemosphere 2007, 66 , 2035–2043.
212
CATHODIC TREATMENT OF BDD ELECTRODES AND THEIR USE IN ELECTROANALYSIS
65. C.A. Mart´ınez-Huitle, M.A. Quiroz, C. Comninellis, S. Ferro, A. De Battisti, Electrochim. Acta 2004, 50 , 949–956. 66. L.S. Andrade, R.C. Rocha-Filho, N. Bocchi, S.R. Biaggio, J. Iniesta, V. Garc´ıa-Garc´ıa, V. Montiel, J. Hazard. Mater. 2008, 153 , 252–260. 67. A. Kapalka, G. F´oti, C. Comninellis, Electrochim. Acta 2009, 54 , 2018–2023. 68. R.A. Medeiros, A.E. Carvalho, R.C. Rocha-Filho, O. Fatibello-Filho, Anal. Lett . 2007, 40 , 3195–3207. 69. R.A. Medeiros, A.E. Carvalho, R.C. Rocha-Filho, O. Fatibello-Filho, Quim. Nova 2008, 31 , 1405–1409. 70. R.A. Medeiros, A.E. Carvalho, R.C. Rocha-Filho, O. Fatibello-Filho, Talanta 2008, 76 , 685–689. 71. T.A. Ivandini, T.N. Rao, A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, Anal. Chem. 2006, 78 , 3467–3471. 72. T.A. Ivandini, K. Honda, T.N. Rao, A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, Talanta 2007, 71 , 648–655. 73. L.S. Andrade, R.C. Rocha-Filho, Q.B. Cass, O. Fatibello-Filho, Electroanalysis 2009, 21 , 1475–1480. 74. D.A. Tryk, T. Kondo, A. Fujishima, in Diamond Electrochemistry (A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, T.N. Rao, D.A. Tryk, eds.), Tokyo, Elsevier, 2005, pp. 174–217. 75. V. Fisher, D. Gandini, S. Laufer, E. Blank, C. Comninellis, Electrochim. Acta 1998, 44 , 521–524. 76. A. Perret, W. Haenni, N. Skinner, X.M. Tang, D. Gandini, C. Comninellis, B. Correa, G. Foti, Diam. Rel. Mat . 1999, 8 , 820–823. 77. J.M.P. Carrazon, A.D. Recio, L.M.P. Diez, Talanta 1992, 39 , 631–635. 78. L. Codognoto, S.T. Tanimoto, V.A. Pedrosa, H.B. Suffredini, S.A.S. Machado, L.A. Avaca, Electroanalysis 2006, 18 , 253–258. 79. V.A. Pedrosa, L. Codognoto, L. A. Avaca, J. Braz. Chem. Soc. 2003, 14 , 530–535. 80. G.S. Garbellini, G.R. Salazar-Banda, L.A. Avaca, J. Braz. Chem. Soc. 2007, 18 , 1095–1099. 81. D.G. Crosby, Pure Appl. Chem. 1981, 53 , 1051–1080. 82. M.V.S Pinheiro, M.N. Oliveira, A.L.B. Penna, A.Y. Tamine, Int. J. Dairy Technol . 2005, 4 , 193–199. 83. H. Dejmkova, M. Scampicchio, J. Zima, J. Barek, S. Mannino, Electroanalysis 2009, 21 , 1014–1018. 84. T.A. Ivandini, B.V. Sarada, T.N. Rao, A. Fujishima, Analyst 2003, 128 , 924–929. 85. C. Terashima, T.N. Rao, B.V. Sarada, A. Fujishima, Anal. Chem. 2002, 74 , 895–902. 86. C.D. Souza, O.C. Braga, I.C. Vieira, A. Spinelli, Sens. Actuators B 2008, 135 , 66–73. 87. E.R. Sartori, R.A. Medeiros, R.C. Rocha-Filho, O. Fatibello-Filho, J. Braz. Chem. Soc. 2009, 20 , 360–366. 88. B.C. Lourenc¸a˜ o, R.A. Medeiros, R.C. Rocha-Filho, L.H. Mazo, O. Fatibello-Filho, Talanta 2009, 78 , 748–752. 89. E.F. Batista, E.R. Sartori, R.A. Medeiros, R.C. Rocha-Filho, O. Fatibello-Filho, Anal. Letters 2010, 43 , 1046–1054. 90. R.T.S. Oliveira, G.R. Salazar-Banda, V.S. Ferreira, S.C. Oliveira, L.A. Avaca, Electroanalysis 2007, 19 , 1189–1194. 91. K.B. Holt, G. Sabin, R.G. Compton, J.S. Foord, F. Marken, Electroanalysis 2002, 14 , 797–803.
Part IV
Industrial Applications
9 Use of Boron-Doped Diamond Electrode in Electrochemical Generation and Applications of Ferrate Virender K. Sharma, Enric Brillas, Ignasi Sir´es, and Karel Bouzek
9.1
INTRODUCTION
Iron commonly exists in the zero, +2, and +3 oxidation states; however, in certain environments, higher oxidation states of iron such as +4, +5, and +6 can also be obtained [1–4]. Fe(IV) and Fe(V) species have been proposed as reactive intermediates in selective oxygenation of hydrocarbons by iron-induced activation of hydrogen peroxide in organic solvents [5,6]; the ferryl (FeIV = O) and perferryl (FeV = O) species may play an important role in the oxygen activation and transfer reactions mediated by heme and nonheme iron proteins [7–11]. In recent years, iron in the +6 oxidation state, commonly called ferrate (FeVI O4 2− ), has been of great interest because of its role as an oxidant and hydroxylating agent in industrial and water treatment processes, such as the development of a “super iron” battery, the green chemistry synthesis, and the nonchlorine oxidation/disinfection of aqueous effluents for pollutant remediation [12–14]; Fe(VI) provides an environmentally benign, high-energy density battery cathode [15–17], whereas selective oxidations by Fe(VI) can be utilized for synthesizing organic compounds without the release of toxic by-products [18].
Synthetic Diamond Films: Preparation, Electrochemistry, Characterization, and Applications, First Edition. Edited by Enric Brillas and Carlos Alberto Mart´ınez-Huitle. © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Published 2011 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
215
216
USE OF BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ELECTRODE
The aqueous ferrate solutions have a distinctive violet color similar to that of solutions of the permanganate ion. The alkaline solutions of the ferrate ion show a maximum at 510 nm (ε = 1150 ± 25 M−1 cm−1 ) and a shoulder between 275 and 320 nm [19]. The ferrate ion is a powerful oxidizing agent in aqueous media. Under acidic conditions, the reduction potential of the ferrate ion is relatively high compared to that of other oxidants used as disinfectants in water treatment processes, as shown in Table 9.1 [19,20]; however, the reduction potential strongly decreases under more alkaline conditions (Table 9.1). The spontaneous decomposition of ferrate in water leads to the formation of molecular oxygen according to Reaction (9.1) [21]: 2FeO4 2− + 5H2 O → 2Fe(OH)3 + 3/2 O2 + 4OH−
(9.1)
The decomposition rate of ferrate is strongly dependent on the initial ferrate concentration, temperature, pH, and even on the surface properties of the hydrous iron oxide formed upon decomposition. The ferrate ion is an emerging water treatment oxidant, disinfectant, and coagulant, which can address the concerns on disinfection by-products (DBPs) associated with currently used chemicals, such as free chlorine, chloramines, and ozone [22]. Like ozone, Fe(VI) does not react with the bromide ion, and so, the carcinogenic bromate ion is not produced during the treatment of bromide-containing water [22]. Several studies on the reaction of ferrate with a series of pollutants including sulfide, thiourea, cyanides, amines, phenols, and anilines have shown that the destruction of pollutants by ferrate is achieved in seconds to minutes; moreover, it leads to the formation of relatively nontoxic by-products [13]. The reaction rates are pH-dependent; thus, the half-lives determined for the pollutant removal are also pH-dependent [23,24]. Ferrate can also degrade effectively emerging contaminants such as estrogens, bisphenol-A, and sulfonamide antimicrobials present in water [25–30]. Furthermore, the nontoxic byproduct generated from ferrate reaction (i.e., ferric oxide/hydroxide) acts as a powerful TABLE 9.1 Redox potentials for the oxidants/disinfectants used in water treatment [19,20]. Reaction
E ◦ (V/SHE)
OH + H+ + e− ⇔ H2 O OH + e− ⇔ OH− FeO4 2− + 8H+ + 3e− ⇔ Fe3+ + 4H2 O FeO4 2− + 4H2 O + 3e− ⇔ Fe(OH)3 + 5OH− O3 + 2H+ + 2e− ⇔ O2 + H2 O O3 + H2 O + 2e− ⇔ O2 + 2OH− H2 O2 + 2H+ + 2e− ⇔ 2H2 O H2 O2 + 2e− ⇔ 2OH− MnO4 − + 4H+ + 3e− ⇔ MnO2 + 2H2 O MnO4 − + 8H+ + 5e− ⇔ Mn2+ + 4H2 O MnO4 − + 2H2 O + 3e− ⇔ MnO2 + 4OH− HClO + H+ + 2e− ⇔ Cl− + H2 O ClO− + H2 O + 2e− ⇔ Cl− + 2OH− ClO4 − + 8H+ + 8e− ⇔ Cl− + 4H2 O Cl2 + 2e− ⇔ 2Cl− O2 + 4H+ + 4e− ⇔ 2H2 O O2 + 2H2 O + 4e− ⇔ 4OH− ClO2 + e− ⇔ ClO2 −
2.80 1.89 2.20 0.70 2.08 1.24 1.78 0.88 1.68 1.51 0.59 1.48 0.84 1.39 1.36 1.23 0.40 0.95
Oxidant Hydroxyl Radical
• •
Ferrate (VI) Ozone Hydrogen peroxide Permanganate
Hypochlorite Perchlorate Chlorine Dissolved Oxygen Chlorine Dioxide
9.2 ELECTROCHEMICAL GENERATION OF THE FERRATE ION WITH IRON ANODES
217
coagulant that is suitable for the removal of metals, nutrients, radionuclides, and humic acids [31–33]. Because of the wide range of applications of ferrate, the most economic production ways for individual applications have been sought. Basically, there exist three major approaches for the synthesis of ferrate: (1) dry thermal synthesis, (2) wet chemical synthesis, and (3) electrochemical synthesis. In the thermal synthesis, ferric oxides are heated together with an alkali metal oxide or peroxide to obtain solid ferrate. Different dry syntheses have recently been reviewed [34]. In the wet chemical synthesis, the ferric ion is converted into the ferrate ion by oxidation with hypochlorite in a highly alkaline environment [35]. Ozone and oxone™ (a mixture of K2 SO4 , KHSO4 , and KHSO5 ) can be used instead of hypochlorite to synthesize ferrate [36,37]. The electrochemical synthetic procedure generally occurs in a concentrated solution of alkali metal hydroxides. Traditionally, two kinds of electrochemical setups have been employed, based on the use of (1) inert anodes (e.g., Pt) able to oxidize soluble Fe3+ ions and (2) iron-based anodes (e.g., grey cast iron, white cast iron, steel, mild steel, etc.) that act as the iron source. More recently, boron-doped diamond (BDD) electrode has been applied to the synthesis of ferrate. The present contribution summarizes different electrochemical synthetic approaches for the generation of the ferrate ion. Several descriptions have been recently reviewed [38]. Hence, this chapter briefly reviews the electrochemical synthetic procedures that are available but mainly focuses on the use of the BDD anode for the electrogeneration of the ferrate ion, as well as on the recent applications of this methodology.
9.2 ELECTROCHEMICAL GENERATION OF THE FERRATE ION WITH IRON ANODES Several studies have been addressed to overcome some of the difficulties associated with the electrochemical synthesis of ferrate [16,17,38–41]. Problems include the formation of a residual passive film on the electrode surface and the extent to which the competitive oxygen evolution reaction (OER) is given at the potential at which ferrate is formed. The current efficiency for the ferrate(VI) generation is very sensitive to the type of electrode pretreatment applied, as well as to the reaction conditions. Therefore, main attention has been paid to the chemical composition, geometry, and mode of activation of the anode, as well as to the electrolyte composition in order to optimize the synthesis of ferrate [38,41]. The influence of other experimental parameters including the temperature, applied current, and electrolysis time has been assessed as well. Various studies have focused on establishing the suitable conditions for electrosynthesizing ferrate when using an iron anode. It has been demonstrated that the presence of high silicon content in grey cast iron allows enhancing the ferrate production, reaching current yields in the range of 20–40% [42]. As can be seen in Figure 9.1, alloys produced by centrifugation led to better results compared to molded alloys, and a content of 2.80% Si produced a current yield of 33%. The degree of porosity of the iron anode also has great influence on the process [43]. For example, Figure 9.2 illustrates the comparative production of ferrate using pellet electrodes. After 1 h of electrolysis, the current yield was much higher using the foil electrode when working at the lowest current density, whereas the pressed iron powder gave the highest yield working over 5.5 mA cm−2 current density [43]. In the latter case, the porous structure of the anode favors the dissolution process, thus accelerating the transformation of the dissolved iron
218
USE OF BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ELECTRODE
40
Current yield (%)
30
20
10
0 2.0
2.4
2.2
2.6
3.2
3.0
2.8
Si content (wt %) Figure 9.1 Dependence of the current yield with the silicon content in grey cast iron for twohour ferrate production using a U-cell with a glass diaphragm. Volume of anodic solution: 50 cm3 ; electrode area: 30 cm2 ; current density: 17–25 mA cm−2 . () Centrifugation, () molded. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 42.)
100 100 80 Current yield (%)
Current yield (%)
80
60
Pellet
60 40 20
Foil 40
0 0
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 j (mA cm–2)
20 Pellet Foil 0
0
100
200 j (mA
300
400
500
cm–2)
Figure 9.2 Current yield as a function of current density after 1 h of electrolysis for (•) iron foil and () pellet electrodes. The hollow circles (◦) correspond to the current yields computed by taking the zero time at the instant at which the electrode potential reached 0.6 V for the pellet electrode. The inset shows the plot for the low current density region. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 43.)
9.2 ELECTROCHEMICAL GENERATION OF THE FERRATE ION WITH IRON ANODES
219
into ferrate. It is then evident that the maximum current yield varies depending on the physical appearance of the anode used in the electrolysis. Recently, rapid electrochemical preparation of Na2 FeO4 was studied in detail by using an iron wire gauze anode [44]. The ferrate yield (η) was determined upon variation of the NaOH concentration, anodic current density, and electrolysis time. The increased ratio of effective anode surface area to anolyte volume using a thinner anodic chamber enhanced the production rate of ferrate in the anolyte. The dependence of the ferrate concentration, apparent ferrate yield (ηapp ), NaOH concentration, and Fe(III) concentration versus the electrolysis time is presented in Figure 9.3. The curve for the ηapp shows a vertical step because it represents the 1h-average apparent yield. The highest ηapp occurred during the first hour, which corresponded to 0.148 M ferrate. The maximum ferrate concentration (=0.48 M) was obtained at 6 h. But one of the major causes of relatively low ferrate production was the formation of a passive layer of iron oxide on the iron anode surface. Hence, the study was made using anisomeric square pulse with fluctuating frequency to favor the continuous activation of the anode, aiming at obtaining a high ferrate yield [45]. The results in Figure 9.4, which were obtained in a cylindrical electrolytic bath with bipolar membranes, show that the ferrate concentration increased over time in all cases, whereas the corresponding current efficiency always exhibited a progressive decay. This suggests that it was though possible to destroy the passive iron oxide film, but the formation of the passive layer still occurred. Therefore, a low current efficiency and a gradual decrease of the ferrate generation rate were observed [45]. The optimum fluctuating frequency was 2 Hz, as depicted in the inset of Figure 9.4b. Table 9.2 summarizes the current efficiency values reported for the ferrate production under various conditions, using different iron-containing anodes [46–55]. It seems clear that the nature of the anode and the carbon content have a large influence on the current efficiency. Based on the cyclic voltammograms for the formation of ferrate from metallic iron, the following mechanism involving Reactions (9.2) through (9.7) has been proposed 1.0 16
0.8
SFe-[FeO42–]
0.6
[OH–] happ
15
14 0.4
[OH–] (M)
Content(mM) or happ
[FeO42–]
13 0.2 12
0.0 0
1
2
3
4 5 Time (h)
6
7
8
Figure 9.3 Time course of some species and ηapp during a continuous electrolysis using 14-layer iron gauzes for 8 h at 35.0 ± 0.8◦ C. Initial anolyte: 16 M NaOH; volume: 75 cm3 ; estimated total anode surface area: 690 cm2 . The ηapp is the average apparent yield for 1-h intervals. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 44.)
USE OF BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ELECTRODE
60
30
(a)
25
55
50
20 h (%)
Oxidant(mM FeO42– )
60
(b)
15
2Hz
h (%)
220
50 45
40
0.2Hz
20Hz
0Hz 40 Frequency/Hz
30
10 2Hz 20Hz 0.2Hz 0Hz
5
2Hz 20Hz 0.2Hz 0Hz
20
0 0
1
2
4 3 Time (h)
5
0
6
1
2
3 4 Time (h)
5
6
7
Figure 9.4 (a) Concentration of electrogenerated FeO4 2− and (b) current efficiency with time at 5 mA cm−2 by varying the applied frequency between 0 and 20 Hz for a CS–CMC bipolar membrane electrolysis cell. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 45.)
[39–41,48,56–60]. Reactions (9.2) and (9.3) represent both the active dissolution of the anode material and the surface layer restructuration, respectively. The reaction of the passive layer of FeOOH with OH− ions results in the breakage of the iron oxide surface and allows the continuous dissolution of the anode material to form FeO2 − by Reaction (9.4). This can be given simultaneously to the oxidation to the FeO3 2− ion from Reaction (9.5a), followed by disproportionation to the ferrate ion from Reaction (9.6). However, the formed FeO2 − ions dissolved in the anolyte may be further anodically oxidized to yield FeO3 2− via Reaction (9.5b). The concerned reaction of oxygen evolution occurs in the vicinity of ferrate formation zone from Reaction (9.7). Fe + 2OH− → Fe(OH)2 + 2e−
(9.2)
−
Fe(OH)2 + OH → FeOOH + H2 O + e
−
FeOOH + OH− → FeO2 − + H2 O
(9.3) (9.4)
FeOOH + 3OH− → FeO3 2− + 2H2 O + e−
(9.5a)
FeO2 − + 2OH− → FeO3 2− + H2 O + e−
(9.5b)
3FeO3 2− + H2 O → 2FeO2 − + FeO4 2− + 2OH−
(9.6)
−
2OH → H2 O + 1/2O2 + 2e
−
(9.7)
This mechanism is generally in good agreement with the oxidation steps undergone by metallic iron to yield Fe(III), but some controversy exists concerning the formation of the ferrate ion from Fe(III). The electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) study of the system suggests an alternative four-step mechanism; after the oxidation of the zero-valent iron to FeOOH (Reactions 9.2 and 9.3), the reaction can proceed according to Reactions (9.8) and (9.9) [61]: FeOOH + 3OH− → (FeO3 − )ads + 2H2 O + 2e− −
−
−
3(FeO3 )ads + 2OH → FeO2 + 2FeO4
2−
+ H2 O
(9.8) (9.9)
9.2 ELECTROCHEMICAL GENERATION OF THE FERRATE ION WITH IRON ANODES
221
TABLE 9.2 Effect of the operation conditions on the current efficiency for the ferrate production with iron-based anodes. Current efficiency (%)
Operation conditions
Reference
12
Anode: Silver steel with 0.08% C j = 1 mA cm−2 [NaOH] = 9.0 M T = 25◦ C Electrolysis time = 15 min
[46,47]
21
Anode: Grey cast iron j = 2 mA cm−2 [NaOH] = 14 M T = 20◦ C Electrolysis time = 60 min Anode: Mild steel j = 4 mA cm−2 [NaOH] = 14 M T = 20◦ C Electrolysis time = 180 min Anode: Porous magnetite j = 3.3 mA cm−2 [NaOH] = 16 M T = 30◦ C Electrolysis time = 300 minutes Anode: White cast iron j = 5 mA cm−2 [NaOH] = 14 M T = 20◦ C Electrolysis time = 60 min Anode: Pure iron j = 4.4 mA cm−2 [NaOH] = 14 M T = 50◦ C Electrolysis time = 60 min Anode: Grey cast iron j = 4.54 mA cm−2 [NaOH] = 14 M T = 20◦ C Electrolysis time = 60 minutes Anode: Silver steel with 0.9% C j = 1 mA cm−2 [NaOH] = 10 M T = 25◦ C Electrolysis time = 5 min
[48]
42
52.3
64
64
68.5
>70
[49]
[54]
[50]
[51]
[55]
[46,47]
More recently, spectroscopic approaches have also been used to gain information on the processes taking place at the electrode surface, which eventually will help to produce ferrate in a more efficient manner [62]. One of the main drawbacks of the electrochemical synthesis is the instability of ferrate in aqueous medium. Therefore, the molten hydroxides approach, which excludes altogether water from the environment, has been applied to perform the direct anodic oxidation process with an iron anode or with soluble iron species using a platinum anode [63–65]. Under molten hydroxides conditions, the ferrate produced is expected to be in dry stable solid form in the cooled-down reaction mixture. Furthermore, the previously
222
USE OF BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ELECTRODE
proposed mechanism involves a chemical reaction; hence, the increased temperature in the molten state can accelerate the overall generation of ferrate. The electrochemical synthesis of ferrate using this approach was therefore performed at 170, 180, and 200◦ C; the anode passivation was less pronounced during the ferrate(VI) generation in comparison with the experiments in an aqueous environment [63–65], which is important for the continuous production of ferrate. However, the problem related to the competing OER found in aqueous solution was noticed in the molten environment as well. Furthermore, electrolysis operation temperature became the key factor in the process. An excessive temperature increase was detrimental regarding the ferrate yield because of the limited thermal stability of ferrate [66,67]. Conversely, only a few studies have discussed the use of an inert electrode for synthesizing ferrate, although it is advantageous because a bulk Fe3+ solution can be used, which allows avoiding the impact of the anode dissolution kinetics on the overall process. Moreover, only three electrons are needed to generate the ferrate ion, instead of the six electrons required when using zero-valent (i.e., metallic) iron, which reduces the electrical consumption to half the value. The reported synthesis of ferrate using an inert electrode is reviewed hereafter.
9.3 ELECTROCHEMICAL GENERATION OF THE FERRATE ION WITH INERT ANODES In a previous study, cyclic voltammetric (CV) curves were collected using a rotating ringdisk electrode (RRDE), as well as platinum electrodes under stationary conditions [38]. Solutions of 0.03 M Fe(II), Fe(III), and Fe(VI) in a 14 M NaOH electrolyte solution were investigated. CV curves were also recorded in the 14 M NaOH solution using a platinum electrode with the surface covered by cathodically deposited iron. During the potential scan to more positive values, a current plateau in the potential region from +0.060 to +0.675 V versus Hg/HgO was observed in all the studied solutions. This plateau was ascribed to the oxidation of FeO2 − to FeO4 2− . Importantly, the current density of the plateau strongly depended on the electrolyte temperature, whereas it was independent of the rotation speed. This suggests that the mechanism of ferrate formation involves at least one chemical step. Recently, CV curves for the Fe(VI)/Fe(III) system were investigated using a SnO2 -Sb2 O3 /Ti anode in strong basic solution [68,69]. Figure 9.5 shows steady-state CVs obtained with solutions of FeO2 − in 14 M NaOH. They suggest the formation of an intermediate during the oxidation of FeO2 − to FeO4 2− . The slope of the linear relationship in the inset of Figure 9.5 is about 0.028; accordingly, two electrons are transferred in the oxidation step, which is associated with the formation of Fe(V) from Reaction (9.10) and its disproportionation to give the ferrate ion via Reaction (9.11): FeO2 − + 4OH− → FeO4 3− + 2H2 O + 2e− 3FeO4
3−
+ 2H2 O → 2FeO4
2−
−
+ FeO2 + 4OH
(9.10) −
(9.11)
This system was also examined using a powder microelectrode as the anode, which yielded similar conclusions [69]. Not only FeO2 − , but also Fe2 O3 and Fe(OH)3 were used as iron sources, yielding no ferrate ion instead.
9.4 ELECTROCHEMICAL GENERATION OF THE FERRATE ION WITH BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ANODE
223
(a) 0.15 scan rate: 1 m V s–1
j (mA cm–2)
0.10
0.05
0.00
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
j (V) vs Hg/HgO
j (mA cm–2)
0.08
j(V)vs Hg/HgO
(b) 0.12 0.65
0.60
0.55 –2
–1
0
1
2
log (il(i1–i))
0.04
scan rate: 0.2 m V s–1 0.00
0.1
0.2
0.3 0.4 0.5 j (V) vs Hg/HgO
0.6
0.7
Figure 9.5 Steady-state cyclic voltammogram at (a) 1 mV s−1 and (b) 0.2 mV s−1 at a SnO2 –Sb2 O3 electrode in 14 M NaOH containing 0.02 M FeO2 − . The arrows indicate the scan direction. The inset gives the linear relationship of ϕ vs. log(i/(il − i)). (Reprinted from Ref. 68.)
9.4 ELECTROCHEMICAL GENERATION OF THE FERRATE ION WITH BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ANODE 9.4.1
Acidic Medium
Original work on the use of the BDD anode for the electrochemical generation of ferrate was carried out in 0.1 M HClO4 [70]. A 0.006 M FeSO4 solution was used to collect the CVs given in Figure 9.6a at different scan rates. The voltammograms exhibited three peaks: two anodic (AI and AII) and one cathodic (CI). The redox couple Fe3+ /Fe2+ is responsible for peaks AI (∼+1.1 V versus Ag/AgCl) and CI (∼+0.4 V versus Ag/AgCl). The peak potential corresponding to AII varied from +2.3 to +2.75 V versus Ag/AgCl
224
USE OF BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ELECTRODE
(a) 4m
CI
0 AI
–4m j (A cm–2)
(a)
(b)
–8m (c) –12m (d) –16m
(e)
–20m
(f) (g)
–24m 3.0
AII 2.5
2.0 1.5 1.0 E (V) vs Ag/AgCl
0.5
0.0
(b) CI 0.0 (a) (b)
AI
j (A cm–2)
–1.0m (c) –2.0m
–3.0m AII (d)
–4.0m 2.5
2.0
1.5 1.0 E (V) vs Ag wire
0.5
0.0
Figure 9.6 Cyclic voltammograms at a boron-doped diamond (BDD) electrode. Plot (A): (a) 0.1 M HClO4 alone, or in the presence of 6 mM FeSO4 at scan rates of (b) 10, (c) 50, (d) 100, (e) 250, (f) 500, and (g) 1000 mV s−1 . The electrochemical cell was a single compartment cell with the surface of the BDD electrode exposed at the bottom of the cell through an O-ring supported opening with a Pt mesh counter electrode, and a Ag/AgCl reference electrode (in saturated KCl). Plot (B): (a) acetonitrile with 0.1 M LiClO4 alone, (b) as in (a) but with addition of 6 mM FeSO4 , (c) as in (b) but with addition of 1.13 M of water, and (d) as in (b) but with addition of 2.83 M of water. Scan rate: 100 mV s−1 . A Pt mesh counter electrode and Ag wire pseudo-reference electrode were used. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 70.)
depending on the scan rate, and it was assigned to the generation of the ferrate ion from the oxidation of Fe3+ in accordance with Reaction (9.12): Fe3+ + 4H2 O → FeO4 2− + 8H+ + 3e−
(9.12)
9.4 ELECTROCHEMICAL GENERATION OF THE FERRATE ION WITH BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ANODE
225
This is supported by the known thermodynamic potential in acidic medium (see Table 9.1) [71]. Interestingly, no cathodic peak was seen for the reduction of Fe(VI) to Fe(III) and the amount of oxygen in the system did not affect the peak. Furthermore, the AII peak was much larger than what expected from Reaction (9.12). This was accounted for by the fact that the generated ferrate ion rapidly decomposed in acidic medium to Fe3+ and oxygen by Reaction (9.13): 2FeO4 2− + 5H2 O → 2Fe3+ + 13/2O2 + 10H+
(9.13)
A similar set of CV experiments was performed by using acetonitrile instead of water as the solvent in order to provide evidence for Reaction (9.12). The CVs of Figure 9.6b show a decrease in the overpotential required by the Fe3+ /Fe2+ redox couple, along with a new anodic peak, AII, at a less positive potential compared to that required for the ferrate formation. This demonstrates the important role of the water content in the system, as deduced from Reaction (9.12). The authors concluded that the initial apparent number of electrons transferred resulted in 3, which further confirmed the occurrence of Reaction (9.12). 9.4.2
Alkaline Medium
The work on the electrochemical generation of ferrate ion using the BDD electrode in alkaline medium has been performed only recently [72,73]. The time course of generated ferrate was monitored in experiments using both, stainless steel and BDD electrodes, as depicted in Figure 9.7. The concentration of ferrate was determined by using the chromite method [35]. When the stainless steel electrode was initially used for 2 h, the concentration of the generated ferrate increased progressively and then the production slowed down to reach a constant value. This can be related to the existence of Reaction (9.14): Fe + 8OH− → FeO4 2− + 4H2 O + 6e−
(9.14)
Oxidant (mM FeO42–)
0.25 0.2 0.15 Anode: SS 0.1
Anode: BDD
0.05 0 0
50
100 150 Time (min)
200
250
Figure 9.7 Variation of the ferrate concentration with time during the electrolysis of hydroxide solutions with () stainless steel and () BDD electrodes. Experimental conditions: 14 M NaOH, at current density of 13 mA cm−2 and 30◦ C. (Reprinted with the permission from Ref. 72.)
226
USE OF BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ELECTRODE
The replacement of the stainless steel anode by a BDD one in the solution treated for 2 h resulted in an increase in the concentration of the ferrate ion; this was possibly due to the oxidation of the iron species accumulated in the solution during the preliminary electro-oxidation process. This finding is interesting because it suggests that BDD can increase the efficiency of the ferrate electrogeneration process. In such studies, the cell voltage did not change, which indicates that the usual phenomenon of passivation and deterioration of the electrode did not occur. The efficiency was found to be dependent on the electrical charge consumed [72]. Experiments were also carried out using the BDD anode, with iron powder and Fe(III) hydroxide as the iron source, at different current densities. Figure 9.8 illustrates that iron powder turned out to be the preferred primary iron material. This suggests that the process to generate ferrate using BDD is determined by the availability of the iron species. Figure 9.8 also shows that an increase in the current density led to a larger production of ferrate. This phenomenon is similar to that observed for the synthesis of other oxidants using BDD (i.e., H2 O2 , S2 O8 2− , etc.) [74–77]. Hydroxyl radicals formed when using BDD electrodes may also be coresponsible for the formation of ferrate in the BDD system [72]. The effect of other parameters, such as the concentration of hydroxide anions and the operation temperature, on the efficiency of ferrate production was assessed as well [73]. The effect of the content of hydroxide anions is shown in Figures 9.9a and 9.9b. The production of ferrate at ≤5 M NaOH was not significant, whereas continuous ferrate yield was obtained as the concentration of hydroxide salt increased up to 14 M NaOH (Figure 9.9a). This may be related to the stability of ferrate after its generation in strong alkaline solution. Figure 9.9b demonstrates that the use of KOH instead of NaOH as the electrolyte markedly increased the amount of ferrate produced. The different stability of the generated ferrate salts, K2 FeO4 and Na2 FeO4 , in the system under alkaline conditions may explain these results. 1.6
Oxidant(mM FeO42−)
1.4 1.2 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0
500
1000
1500
2000
Current density (A m-2) Figure 9.8 Variation of the ferrate concentration with the current density in the electrolysis with BDD electrodes of hydroxide solutions () saturated with 9.4 mM Fe(OH)3 and () with iron-powder bed. Experimental conditions: 10 M KOH and temperature of 30◦ C. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 72.)
9.4 ELECTROCHEMICAL GENERATION OF THE FERRATE ION WITH BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ANODE
Oxidant (mM) FeO42−)
0.1
227
(a)
0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0 0
Oxidant (mM FeO42−)
0.08
1
2 Q (Ah L–1)
3
4
1
2 Q (Ah L–1)
3
4
(b)
0.06
0.04
0.02
0 0
Figure 9.9 Variation of the ferrate concentration with the electric charged passed during the electrolysis of Fe(OH)3 solutions with BDD electrodes at 13 mA cm−2 at 30◦ C. Plot (a): () 5, () 10, and () 14 M NaOH. Plot (b): () 10 M NaOH and () 10 M KOH. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 73.)
Figures 9.10a and 9.10b show the effect of the electric charge consumed in the electrolysis of iron hydroxide at several temperatures. The former figure presents the initial dependence of the ferrate concentration on the electric charge passed at all temperatures. This fact is very clear at electric charge ≤5 Ah L−1 . Figure 9.10b depicts the change of the ferrate generation yield with the temperature, reaching a maximum at 25◦ C. Two different processes—the solubility of Fe(III) and the stability of ferrate—may be occurring simultaneously to cause such dependence of the ferrate yield on the temperature. At low temperatures, the solubility of Fe(III) is low and a small amount of Fe(III) species is then available to be oxidized, causing a small production of ferrate; conversely, the stability of ferrate decreases with increasing temperature to give low yields of ferrate at too high temperatures (Figure 9.10b). In summary, the current density, electric charged passed (which is related to the electrolysis time), concentration of electrolyte, and temperature have a great influence on the efficiency of the electrosynthesis of ferrate with the BDD anode.
228
USE OF BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ELECTRODE
Oxidant (mM) FeO42−)
0.24
(a)
0.2 0.16 0.12 0.08 0.04 0 0
Oxidant (mM) FeO42−)
0.15
5
10
15 Q (Ah L–1)
20
25
30
(b)
0.1
0.05
0 10
20
30
40
50
60
Temperature (°C) Figure 9.10 Variation of the ferrate concentration (a) with the electric charge passed and (b) with the temperature, during the electrolysis of Fe(OH)3 solutions with BDD electrodes in 10 M KOH at 100 mA cm−2 . Plot (a), temperature: () 17, () 23, () 30, (*) 40, and () 57◦ C. Plot (b), ferrate concentrations obtained at an electric charge passed of 1.5 Ah L−1 . (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 73.)
9.5
APPLICATIONS
In contrast to the wide use of chemically produced ferrate, a very limited amount of work has been conducted on the applications of electrochemically generated ferrate. Examples reported in the field of fuel cells as well as in the remediation of water pollutants are described briefly in subsections below on the basis of the different types of electrodes used as the anode. 9.5.1
Common Inert Anodes
In recent years, direct methanol fuel cells (DMFCs) have shown applications in electronic equipments [78]. In alkaline solution, the anodic reaction of the DMFCs is described as follows: CH3 OH + 6OH− → CO2 + 5H2 O + 6e−
(9.15)
9.5 APPLICATIONS
229
Pt or Pt-based alloy anodes are commonly used for methanol oxidation, but these anodes become easily poisoned by the CO-like intermediates. Recent work demonstrated that addition of ferrate ion and Fe(III) in 1 M methanol and 12 M NaOH promoted both the catalytic activity and poison tolerance of Pt [78]. The assessment of the long-term stability of the methanol electro-oxidation in the presence of ferrate and Fe(III) ions under alkaline conditions was carried out through current-time curves at a steady potential. As can be seen in Figure 9.11, there is a fast current decay during the early stages; then, after ∼500 seconds the decay becomes slower in the four electrolytes, and the current progressively tends to zero during the rest of the electro-oxidation of methanol. The initial trends of the curves suggest poisoning of the electrocatalyst. The lowest current was obtained in the absence of ferrate or Fe(III) ions. Interestingly, the oxidation current in the electrolyte containing the decomposed ferrate ion was the largest compared to solutions with a stoichiometric amount of Fe(NO3 )3 and K2 FeO4 . These results were also in agreement with the CVs of the systems, indicating that the reduction product of ferrate ion greatly promoted the electrocatalytic activity of Pt for the oxidation of methanol in alkaline media. 9.5.2
Iron Anodes
The online preparation and use of ferrate in the wastewater treatment at a pilot scale has been only tested recently [79]. Steel was used as the anode in the pilot plant setup for the electrochemical production of ferrate. The steel had an iron content >99% and carbon content in the range of 0.10–0.12%. The thickness of each steel plate was 2 mm and a bipolar configuration of the electrodes was used. The optimum current density was 3.6 mA cm−2 . In the laboratory scale, the possible risk arising from the hydrogen
Normalized current (mA cm–2)
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2 d a
0.0 0
b
c 5000
10000 Time (s)
15000
20000
Figure 9.11 Current–time curves for methanol electro-oxidation in 1 M CH3 OH + 12 M NaOH: (a) at −0.041 V versus Hg/HgO, (b) with a Fe(NO3 )3 loading of 203 mg L−1 , (c) with a K2 FeO4 loading of 164 mg L−1 , and (d) with the decomposed K2 FeO4 at −0.080 V versus Hg/HgO. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 78.)
230
USE OF BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ELECTRODE
production in the electrochemical process was not observed [80]. However, such risks need to be examined for the electrochemical generation of ferrate at the large scale. In the treatment process, different parameters of water quality such as suspended solids (SS), chemical oxygen demand (COD), biological oxygen demand (BOD), and phosphate content were tested. The concentrations in tests were 242–730 mg L−1 for the SS, 523–1125 mg L−1 for the COD, 235–441 mg L−1 for the BOD, and 11.3–18.5 mg L−1 for the phosphate as total P. The results are presented in Figure 9.12. At a maximum ferrate dose of 0.04 mg L−1 , the average removal percentage achieved was 70% for the SS (Figure 9.12a), 40% for the phosphate (Figure 9.12b), 40% for the COD (Figure 9.12c), and 30% for the BOD (Figuer 9.12d). Interestingly, Table 9.3 shows that the performance of a low ferrate dose (0.03 mg Fe L−1 ) could be similar or even better than that obtained with a high amount of ferric sulfate (37 mg Fe L−1 ). The superior performance of ferrate is not surprising, taking into account that it is a much more powerful oxidant compared to the ferric ion. Another significant advantage of ferrate is related to the residual iron concentration in the final effluent. Table 9.3 shows that the use of ferrate leads to only 0.25 mg Fe L−1 in the effluent, whereas the iron concentration in the case of ferric sulfate was much higher (17.2 mg Fe L−1 ). Therefore, the use of a very low dose of ferrate(VI) would generate a much smaller volume and mass of the sludge than that from high doses of ferric salts. This would then be beneficial concerning the reduction of the cost of sludge handling. However, before implementation of the ferrate technology to a full-scale treatment of water and wastewater, the full assessment of the operation cost should be performed. 9.5.3
BDD Anode
Recently, the ferrate ion has been suggested to enhance the electrochemical oxidation of Acid Yellow 36 azo dye (AY36) using the BDD electrode in a system containing Fe(II) ions under acidic conditions [81]. The decolorization of the dye solution using different
100 (a)
80
P removal (%)
SS removal (%)
100
60 40 20 0
60 40 20 0
0
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
0
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
100
100 BOD removal (%)
COD removal (%)
(b)
80
(c)
80 60 40 20 0 0
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
(d)
80 60 40 20 0 0
Ferrate dose(mg Fe(VI) L–1)
Figure 9.12 Average removal with ferrate(VI) in the treatment of crude wastewater. (a) Suspended solids, (b) phosphate ion, (c) COD, and (d) BOD. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 79.)
231
9.5 APPLICATIONS
TABLE 9.3 Comparative performance of crude sewage treatment with ferric sulfate and ferrate(VI)a [79]. Average percentage removal (%)
Residual iron and pH
Chemical and dose
SS
P
COD
BOD
Fe (mg L−1 )
pH
Ferrate(VI) (0.03 mg Fe L−1 ) Ferric sulfate (37 mg Fe L−1 )
79 ± 5
56 ± 1
50 ± 3
30 ± 5
0.25 ± 0.08
9.8 ± 0.1
78 ± 4
59 ± 2
54 ± 5
43 ± 6
17.2
–
a Crude sewage properties: [SS] = 730 mg L−1 , [P] = 18.5 mg L−1 , [COD] = 1125 mg L−1 , [BOD] = 388 mg L−1 , [Fe] = 1.0 mg L−1 , pH = 8.0.
1.0
AY36 (C1/Co)
0.8 (a) 0.6 (b) (c)
0.4
(d) 0.2 (e) 0.0 0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
Time (min) Figure 9.13 Effect of the FeSO4 concentration over the decolorisation of 40 mg L−1 of Acid Yellow 36 under an anodic potential of 2.5 V. (a) Electrochemical oxidation process (EOP), and with FeSO4 content of (b) 12, (c) 8, (d) 6, and (e) 1 mM FeSO4 . (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 81.)
amounts of Fe(II) ions is presented in Figure 9.13. The electrochemical oxidation process (EOP) achieved only ∼41% of the AY36 degradation in 180 min. Comparatively, adding Fe(II) ions improved the degradation markedly under the same conditions. The added amount of the Fe(II) ions had a great influence on the degradation of the dye. It is noteworthy that an increase in the concentrations of Fe(II) ions decreased the degradation efficiency. The results obtained in Figure 9.13 were explained by performing CV measurements over the BDD electrode under the same conditions, as illustrated in Figure 9.14. The absence of Fe(II) ions does not yield any redox signal (curve a); similarly, the addition of 12 mM Fe(II) ions does not yield any redox signal (curve b), whereas a signal appeared from Fe(II) contents lower or equal to 8 mM. Three distinctive peaks could be observed: two anodic (AI and AII) and one cathodic (CI) (curve c). The Fe3+ /Fe2+ redox couple was associated with the AI and CI signals, while AII corresponded to the generation of the ferrate ion at ∼+2.3 V from Reaction (9.12). This findings are similar to those reported by Lee et al. (see Section 9.4.1) [70]. The CI peak increased with Fe(II) concentration decreasing from 6 to 1 mM (curves d and e).
232
USE OF BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ELECTRODE
Cl 0.000 (a) (b) (c) (d)
0.002
j (A cm–2)
0.004
AI
0.006 0.008
(e) AII
0.010 0.012 0.014 0.016 3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5 1.0 E (V) vs Ag/AgCl
0.5
0.0
Figure 9.14 Cyclic voltammograms at BDD in 0.1 M HClO4 for ferrate ion generation in the following conditions: (a) without FeSO4 , and with FeSO4 loading of: (b) 12, (c) 8, (d) 6, and (e) 1 mM. Scan rate: 100 mV s−1 . (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 81.)
H2O BDD Oxidation products
a) Oxidation products
H++e– Fe2+ b) BDD(•OH) f)
Pollutants
[Fe(VI)] d)
Fe2+
Pollutants
e) BDD c)
Fe3+
Fe3+
Fe3+
Figure 9.15 Proposed mechanism for the electrochemical oxidation of organic compounds with the simultaneous ferrate ion formation in the system. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 81.)
Results of Figures 9.13 and 9.14 clearly demonstrate the role of Fe(II) ions in the enhancement of the electrochemical oxidation of AY36 using a BDD electrode. The mechanism given in Figure 9.15 suggests that the ferrate ion is the species responsible for such an enhancement. In the proposed mechanism, step (a) produces hydroxyl radical, which oxidizes the AY36 (step (b)). The generation of the ferrate ion occurs in step (c), so that AY36 can also be oxidized by this species (step (d)), which shows the enhancement effect of the Fe(II) ions. The Fe(II) ions are regenerated by the reduction of the Fe(III) ions in step (e). A certain amount of Fe(II) is oxidized by hydroxyl radicals (step (f)). It seems that steps (b) and (d) give rise to a synergistic effect for degrading AY36 at low concentrations of the Fe(II) ions by avoiding minimizing steps (e) and (f).
REFERENCES
9.6
233
CONCLUSIONS
Significant advances in terms of the optimization of parameters such as the anode material and operating conditions have been made regarding the electrochemical synthesis of ferrate. However, the mechanism of the Fe(III) oxidation to yield ferrate still needs to be fully understood. The use of classical electrochemical techniques may not be sufficient to explore the mechanism because the reaction of Fe(III) to Fe(VI) is overlapped by oxygen evolution. Hence, spectroscopic approaches are currently being used to gain insight on the processes occurring at the electrode surface. Two relatively new synthesis approaches—the employment of molten hydroxides as the electrolysis environment and the utilization of inert anodes—are currently being pursued to minimize the influence of the anode material and the oxygen evolution in synthesizing ferrate. Studies reporting the use of BDD anode to synthesize ferrate are forthcoming. The efficiency of the synthesis is greatly influenced by the availability of oxidizable iron species in the reaction solution. The potential role of ferrate in the electrochemical oxidation of methanol and dyes using inert anodes have been suggested, but mechanistic understanding of the system is still missing. The in situ electrochemical ferrate production method is promising for treating pollutants in water and wastewater treatment facilities. 9.7
ACKNOWLEGMENTS
V.K. Sharma would like to acknowledge the support of United States National Science Foundation (CHE 0706834). V.K. Sharma and K. Bouzek also acknowledge the partial support of NATO collaborative linkage grant (CBP.EAP.CLG.983119). K. Bouzek acknowledges the support of the Ministry of Education, Youth and Sports of the Czech Republic (project No. ME 890).
REFERENCES 1. J.D. Rush, B.H.J. Bielski, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1986, 108 , 523–525. 2. C. Jeannot, B. Malaman, R. Gerardin, B. Oulladiaf, J. Solid State Chem. 2002, 165 , 266–277. 3. J.F. Berry, E. Bill, E. Bothe, S.D. George, B. Mienert, F. Neese, K. Wieghardt, Science 2006, 312 , 1937–1941. 4. F.T. De Oliveira, A. Chanda, D. Banerjee, X. Shan, S. Mondal, L. Que, Jr., E.L. Bominaar, E. M¨unck, T.J. Collins, Science 2007, 315 , 835–838. 5. H.C. Tung, C. Kang, D.T. Sawyer, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1992, 114 , 3445–3455. 6. J.T. Groves, J. Inorg. Biochem. 2006, 100 , 434–447. 7. J. Kaizer, E.J. Klinker, N.Y. Oh, J.-U. Rohde, W.J. Song, A. Stubna, J. Kim, E. M¨unck, W. Nam, L. Que, Jr., J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2004, 126 , 472–473. 8. E.Y. Tshuva, S.J. Lippard, Chem. Rev . 2004, 104 , 987–1011. 9. S.V. Kryatov, E.V. Rybak-Akimova, S. Schindler, Chem. Rev . 2005, 105 , 2175–2226. 10. N.Y. Oh, Y. Suh, M.J. Park, M.S. Seo, J. Kim, W. Nam, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed . 2005, 44 , 4235–4239. 11. X. Shan, L. Que, Jr., J. Inorg. Biochem. 2006, 100 , 421–433. 12. J.D. Carr, P.B. Kelter, A. Tabatabai, D. Splichal, J. Erickson, C.W. McLaughlin, in Proceedings of the Fifth Conference on Water Chlorination: Chemistry, Environmental Impact and Health
234
13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19.
20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30.
31. 32.
33. 34.
35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41.
USE OF BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ELECTRODE
Effects (R.L. Jolley, R.J. Bull, W.P. Davis, S. Katz, M.H. Roberts, V.A. Jacobs, eds.), Lewis Publishers, Chelsea, MI, 1985, Vol. 5, pp. 1285–1298. V.K. Sharma, Adv. Environ. Res. 2002, 6 , 143–156. V.K. Sharma, F. Kazama, J. Hu, A.K. Ray, J. Water Health 2005, 3 , 45–58. S. Licht, B. Wang, S. Ghosh, Science 1999, 285 , 1039–1042. S. Licht, X. Yu, in Ferrates: Synthesis, Properties, and Applications in Water and Wastewater Treatment (V.K. Sharma, ed.), Vol. 985, ACS Symposium Series, 2008, pp. 2–51. S. Licht, X. Yu, in Ferrates: Synthesis, Properties, and Applications in Water and Wastewater Treatment (V.K. Sharma, ed.), Vol. 985, ACS Symposium Series, 2008, pp. 197–256. L. Delaude, P. Laszlo, J. Org. Chem. 1996, 61 , 6360–6370. V.K. Sharma, in Advances in Control of Disinfection By-Products in Drinking Water Systems (A. Nikolau, L. Rizzo, H. Selcuk, eds.), Nova Science Publishers, New York, 2007, pp. 370–380. E. Brillas, I. Sir´es, M.A. Oturan, Chem. Rev . (doi. 9.1021/cr900136g). H. Goff, R.K. Murmann, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1971, 93 , 6058–6065. V.K. Sharma, S.K. Mishra, N. Nesnas, Environ. Sci. Technol. 2006, 40 , 7222–7227. V.K. Sharma, Water Sci. Technol . 2004, 49 , 69–74. R.A. Yngard, V.K. Sharma, J. Filip, R. Zboˇril, Environ. Sci. Technol. 2008, 42 , 3005–309. J.Q. Jiang, J. Hazard. Mater. 2007, 146 , 617–623. V.K. Sharma, Chemosphere 2008, 73 , 1379–1386. V.K. Sharma, X.Z. Li, N. Graham, R.-A. Doong, J. Water Supply: Res. Technol.- AQUA 2008, 57 , 419–426. G.A.K. Anquandah, V.K. Sharma, J. Environ. Sci. Health, Part A: Toxic/Hazard. Subst. Environ. Eng. 2009, 44 , 62–66. V.K. Sharma, G.A.K. Anquandah, N. Nesnas, Environ. Chem. Lett . 2009, 7 , 115–119. V.K. Sharma, G.A.K. Anquandah, R.A. Yngard, H. Kim, J. Fekete, K. Bouzek, A.K. Ray, D. Golovko, J. Environ. Sci. Health, Part A: Toxic/Hazard. Subst. Environ. Eng. 2009, 44 , 423–442. M.E. Potts, D.R. Churchwell, Water Environ. Res. 1994, 66 , 107–109. U.M. Joshi, R. Balasubramanian, V.K. Sharma, in Ferrates: Synthesis, Properties, and Applications in Water and Wastewater Treatment (V.K. Sharma, ed.), Vol. 985, ACS Symposium Series, 2008, pp. 466–476. Y. Lee, S.G. Zimmermann, A.T. Kieu, U. Von Gunten, Environ. Sci. Technol. 2009, 43 , 3831–3838. Y.D. Perfiliev, V.K. Sharma, in Ferrates: Synthesis, Properties, and Applications in Water and Wastewater Treatment (V.K. Sharma, ed.), Vol. 985, ACS Symposium Series, 2008, pp. 112–123. G.W. Thompson, L.T. Ockerman, J.M. Schreyer, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1951, 73 , 1379–1381. M.D. Johnson, US patent No. 5746994, 1998. Y.D. Perfiliev, E.M. Benko, D.A. Pankratov, V.K. Sharma, S.K. Dedushenko, Inorg. Chim. Acta 2007, 360 , 2789–2791. Z. M´acov´a, K. Bouzek, J. H´ıveˇs, V.K. Sharma, R.J. Terryn, J.C. Baum, Electrochim. Acta 2009, 54 , 2673–2683. K. Bouzek, M.J. Schmidt, A.A. Wragg, Collect. Czech. Chem. Commun. 2000, 65 , 133–140. F. Lapicque, G. Valentine, Electrochem. Commun. 2002, 4 , 764–766. X. Yu, S. Licht, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2008, 38 , 731–742.
REFERENCES
42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62.
63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69.
70. 71. 72. 73. 74. 75. 76.
235
V. Lescuras-Darrou, F. Lapicque, G. Valentin, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2002, 32 , 57–63. M. De Koninck, D. B´elanger, Electrochim. Acta 2003, 48 , 1435–1442. W. He, J. Wang, C. Yang, J. Zhang, Electrochim. Acta 2006, 51 , 1967–1973. Y. Ren, Z. Chen, Y. Geng, R. Chen, X. Zheng, Chem. Eng. Process. 2008, 47 , 708–715. A. Denver, D. Plecher, J. Appl. Electrochem. 1996, 26 , 815–821. A. Denver, D. Plecher, J. Appl. Electrochem. 1996, 26 , 823–827. K. Bouzek, I. Rouˇsar, J. Appl. Electrochem. 1996, 26 , 919–923. K. Bouzek, I. Rouˇsar, J. Appl. Electrochem. 1993, 23 , 1317–1322. K. Bouzek, I. Rouˇsar, M.A. Taylor. J. Appl. Electrochem. 1996, 26 , 925–931. K. Bouzek, I. Rouˇsar. J. Appl. Electrochem. 1997, 27 , 679–684. K. Bouzek, M.J. Schmidt, A.A. Wragg, Electrochem. Commun. 1999, 1 , 370–374. K. Bouzek, M.J. Schmidt, A.A. Wragg, J. Chem. Technol. Biotechnol . 1999, 74 , 1188–1194. Z. Ding, C. Yang, Q. Wu, Electrochim. Acta 2004, 49 , 3155–3159. J. Xu, J. Wang, W. Yang, C. Chen, J. Zhang, Dianhuaxue 2004, 10 , 87–93. M. Alsheyab, J.-Q. Jiang, C. Stanford, J. Environ. Manage. 2009, 90 , 1350–1356. F. Beck, R. Kaus, M. Oberst, Electrochim. Acta 1985, 30 , 173–183. J.-Y. Zou, D.-T. Chin, Electrochim. Acta 1988, 33 , 477–485. K. Bouzek, I. Rouˇsar, H. Bergmann, K. Hertwig, J. Electroanal. Chem. 1997, 425 , 125–137. K. Bouzek, M. Nejezchleba, Collect. Czech. Chem. Commun. 1999, 64 , 2044–2060. H.B. Shao, J.M. Wang, W.C. He, J.Q. Zhang, C.N. Cao, Electrochem. Commun. 2005, 7 , 1429–1433. Z. M´acov´a, K. Bouzek, V.K. Sharma, in Ferrates: Synthesis, Properties, and Applications in Water and Wastewater Treatment (V.K. Sharma, ed.), Vol. 985, ACS Symposium Series, 2008, pp. 52–67. J. H´ıveˇs, M. Benov´a, K. Bouzek, V.K. Sharma, Electrochem. Commun. 2006, 8 , 1737–1740. J. H´ıveˇs, Z. M´acov´a, M. Benov´a, K. Bouzek, J. Electrochem. Soc. 2008, 155 , E113–E119. J. H´ıveˇs, M. Benov´a, K. Bouzek, J. Sitek, V.K. Sharma, Electrochem. Acta 2008, 54 , 203–208. J. Madar´asz, R. Zboˇril, Z. Homonnay, V.K. Sharma, G. Pokol, J. Solid State Chem. 2006, 179 , 1426–1433. L. Machala, R. Zboˇril, V.K. Sharma, J. Filip, O. Schneeweiss, Z. Homonnay, J. Phys. Chem. B 2007, 111 , 4280–4286. C.Z. Zhang, Z. Liu, F. Wu, L.-J. Lin, F. Qi, Electrochem. Commun. 2004, 6 , 1104–1109. C.Z. Zhang, H.B. Deng, T. Zhao, F. Wu, W. Liu, S. Cai, K. Yang, V.K. Sharma, in Ferrates: Synthesis, Properties, and Applications in Water and Wastewater Treatment (V.K. Sharma, ed.), Vol. 985, ACS Symposium Series, 2008, pp. 81–93. J. Lee, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, S.-M. Park, Chem. Commun. 2002, 5 , 486–487. R.H. Wood, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1958, 80 , 2038–2041. P. Ca˜nizares, M. Arc´ıs, C. S´aez, M.A. Rodrigo, Electrochem. Commun. 2007, 9 , 2286–2290. C. S´aez, M.A. Rodrigo, P. Ca˜nizares, AIChE J . 2008, 54 , 1600–1607. K. Serrano, P.A. Michaud, C. Comninellis, A. Savall, Electrochim. Acta 2002, 48 , 431–436. M.S. Saha, T. Furuta, Y. Nishiki, Electrochem. Commun. 2004, 6 , 201–204. P. Ca˜nizares, F. Larrondo, J. Lobato, M.A. Rodrigo, C. S´aez, J. Electrochem. Soc. 2005, 152 , D191–D196.
236
USE OF BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ELECTRODE
77. P. Ca˜nizares, C. S´aez, A. S´anchez-Carretero, M.A. Rodrigo, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2009, 39 , 2143–2149. 78. Z. Xu, J. Hu, Z. Yan, S. Yang, J. Zhou, W. Lu, Electrochim. Acta 2009, 54 , 3548–3552. 79. J.-Q. Jiang, C. Stanford, M. Alsheyab, Sep. Purif. Technol. 2009, 68 , 227–231. 80. M. Alsheyab, J.-Q. Jiang, C. Stanford, J. Chem. Health Safety 2008, 15 , 16–20. 81. M. Villanueva-Rodr´ıguez, A. Hern´andez-Ram´ırez, J.M. Peralta-Hern´andez, E.R. Bandala, M.A. Quiroz-Alfaro, J. Hazard. Mater. 2009, 167 , 1226–1230.
10 Electrochemical Oxidation of Organic Compounds Induced by Electro-Generated Free Hydroxyl Radicals on BDD Electrodes Agnieszka Kapałka, Helmut Baltruschat, and Christos Comninellis
10.1
INTRODUCTION
In the last decade, the advanced oxidation processes (AOPs) have been demonstrated as an effective means of wastewater treatment [1]. The main principle of AOPs is based on oxidation of organic pollutants using hydroxyl radicals that are highly reactive and destroy organics with a very high rate and low selectivity. AOPs are classified depending on the reaction phase or HO • generation method, generally classified as chemical (Fenton processes), electrochemical, sonochemical (ultrasound processes), and photochemical methods (UV/H2 O2 , UV/O3 photolysis, photo-Fenton, TiO2 photocatalysis) [1]. The electrochemical method for the oxidation of target organic pollutants is a technology for treatment of dilute wastewater (COD < 5 gl−1 ). In this method, organic pollutants are oxidized by intermediacy of hydroxyl radicals electro-generated from water on high Synthetic Diamond Films: Preparation, Electrochemistry, Characterization, and Applications, First Edition. Edited by Enric Brillas and Carlos Alberto Mart´ınez-Huitle. © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Published 2011 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
237
238
ELECTROCHEMICAL OXIDATION OF ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
oxidation power anodes. An ideal anode for electrochemical oxidation of organic compounds is a boron-doped diamond electrode (BDD). The aim of this work is to elucidate the principles of electrochemical oxidation of organic compounds induced by electro-generated free hydroxyl radicals on BDD electrode. The following points will be treated: — Influence of anode material on the reactivity of electrolytic hydroxyl radicals — Electro-generation and detection of quasi-free hydroxyl radicals on BDD anode — Concentration profile of quasi-free hydroxyl radicals during the oxygen evolution reaction and electro-oxidation of organic compounds on BDD — Kinetic model of organics mineralization on BDD — Electrochemically induced mineralization of organics by molecular oxygen on BDD 10.2 INFLUENCE OF ANODE MATERIAL ON THE REACTIVITY OF ELECTROLYTIC HYDROXYL RADICALS In the electrochemical mineralization (EM) reactions oxygen is transferred from water to the organic pollutant using electrical energy. According to the generally accepted mechanism of the EM in acid media [2], water is first discharged at the anode active sites M, producing hydroxyl species (either adsorbed species, if the potential is low or, if the potential is high enough, even free radicals), as seen in Equation 10.1: M + H2 O → M(HO • ) + H+ + e−
(10.1)
These electrogenerated hydroxyl species are involved in the mineralization of organic pollutants R (see Equation 10.2): R + M(HO • ) → M + mineralization products + H+ + e−
(10.2)
This reaction (Equation (10.2) is in competition with the side reaction of the anodic discharge of hydroxyl species to dioxygen (see Equation 10.3): 1 M(HO • ) → M + O2 + H+ + e− 2
(10.3)
The activity of these electrolytic hydroxyl species is strongly linked to their interaction with the electrode surface M [3]. As a general rule, the weaker the interaction, the lower the electrochemical activity is toward oxygen evolution (high O2 overvoltage anodes) and the higher the chemical reactivity is toward organics oxidation. Based on this approach, we can classify the different anode materials according to their oxidation power in acid media as it is shown in Table 10.1 [4]. This table shows that the attainable oxidation potential of the anode is directly related to the overpotential for oxygen evolution and to the adsorption enthalpy of hydroxyl species on the anode surface (i.e., for a given anode material, the higher the O2 overvoltage, the higher its oxidation power is). A low oxidation power anode is characterized by a strong electrode-hydroxyl species interaction resulting in a high electrochemical activity for the oxygen evolution reaction
10.2 INFLUENCE OF ANODE MATERIAL
TABLE 10.1
239
Oxidation power of the anode material in acid media. (Adapted from Ref. 4.)
Electrode RuO2 − TiO2 (DSA-Cl2 ) IrO2 − Ta2 O5 (DSA-O2 ) Ti/PtOx Ti/PbO2 Ti/SnO2 -Sb2 O5 p–Si/BDD
Oxidation potential of organics (V)∗
Overpotential of O2 evolution (V)∗∗
1.4–1.7 1.5–1.8 1.7–1.9 1.8–2.0 1.9–2.2 2.2–2.6
0.18 0.25 0.3 0.5 0.7 1.3
Oxidation power of the anode
∗ Depending on the applied current densities ∗∗ Considering an overpotential for O evolution of 0.1 mA cm−2 2
(low overvoltage anode) and to a low chemical reactivity for organics oxidation (low current efficiency for organics oxidation). A typical low oxidation power anode is the IrO2 -based electrode. Concerning this anode, it has been demonstrated using differential electrochemical mass spectrometry (DEMS) [5] that the interaction between IrO2 and hydroxyl species is so strong that a higher oxidation state oxide is formed as an intermediate. This higher oxide can act as mediator for both organics oxidation and oxygen evolution. On low oxidation power anodes, oxidation of organics occurs with a low current efficiency but with a high selectivity. Typically, in electrosynthesis, a high selectivity is achieved under potentiostatic conditions. However, on low oxidation power anodes, a high selectivity can be achieved also under galvanostatic conditions [6]. This can be explained by the fact that on these anodes, under galvanostatic conditions, the potential is “buffered” by the oxygen evolution reaction, which is the competing side reaction. Under these so-called pseudo-potentiostatic conditions, the working potential is fixed by the nature (oxidation power) of electrode material, which is related to the oxygen evolution overpotential (i.e., the higher the oxygen evolution overpotential, the higher the oxidation power of the anode (Table 10.1)). The principle of the anode potential “buffering” induced by the oxygen evolution reaction is shown in Figure 10.1 This figure shows that during 11 IrO2
10 9 j (mA cm–2)
8 7 6 5
Dj
4 3 2 1 0 0.0
DE 0.5
1.0 1.5 E (V) vs SHE
2.0
Figure 10.1 Principle of buffering the anode potential induced by the oxygen evolution reaction using steady-state current potential curve recorded on Ti/IrO2 in 1 M HClO4 + 100 mM i-propanol. (Adapted from Ref. 6.)
240
ELECTROCHEMICAL OXIDATION OF ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
oxidation of isopropanol on IrO2 , a large increase in current results in a small change of anode potential due to potential buffering by the side reaction of oxygen evolution. In fact, a change of one decade in current induces a shift of only 40 mV of potential. On the contrary to low oxidation power anode, the high oxidation power anode is characterized by a week electrode-hydroxyl species interaction resulting in a low electrochemical activity for the oxygen evolution reaction (high overvoltage anode) and to a high chemical reactivity for organics oxidation (high current efficiency for organics oxidation). Boron-doped diamond based anode is a typical high oxidation power anode. Here, the electrode-hydroxyl interaction is so weak that hydroxide radicals are formed. The evidence for the formation of hydroxyl radicals on BDD was found by means of spin trapping, hydroxylation of salicylic acid, and formation of hydrogen peroxide [7], as discussed next.
10.3 ELECTRO-GENERATION AND DETECTION OF QUASI-FREE HYDROXYL RADICALS ON BDD ELECTRODE 10.3.1
Hydroxyl Radicals Spin Trapping
The principle of the spin trapping method is to produce a stable adduct by allowing a specific scavenger to react with a less stable radical. As shown in Equation 10.4, the spin trap 5.5-dimethyl-1-pyrroline-N-oxide (DMPO) reacts with hydroxyl radicals to produce a stable adduct, detectable by electron spin resonance (ESR). H3C H3C
N+
+
HO•
O−
DMPO spin trap
H 3C H 3C
N
OH
O•
DMPO hydroxyl radical spin adduct
(10.4)
The main advantage of using DMPO is that it exhibits different ESR spectra with hydroxyl radical and singlet oxygen. The rate constant between DMPO and hydroxyl radicals is equal to 4.3 × 109 mol−1 s−1 [8]. Figure 10.2 shows ESR spectrum obtained after 2 hours of electrolysis of 10 mM DMPO in 1 M HClO4 at 0.1 mA cm−2 on BDD. This spectrum reveals the existence of the DMPO hydroxyl radical spin adduct (see Equation 10.4). The ESR hyperfine couplings of the DMPO adduct produced by electrolysis (obtained by simulation) are aN = aH = 14.95 G. These hyperfine coupling constants are typical of the spin adduct DMPO-OH [9,10], indicating that hydroxyl radicals are indeed produced during electrolysis on BDD electrode.
10.3.2
Trapping by Salicylic Acid
Salicylic acid (SA) is usually used for trapping free hydroxyl radicals in biological system. In fact, SA reacts with hydroxyl radicals to form dihydroxylated aromatic compounds [7]. The main products of the hydroxylation of salicylic acid with hydroxyl radicals are
10.3 ELECTRO-GENERATION AND DETECTION OF QUASI-FREE HYDROXYL RADICALS
241
Figure 10.2 Electron spin resonance of DMPO adduct obtained after electrolysis of 8.8 mM DMPO solution in 1 M HClO4 for 2 h on BDD electrode at 0.1 mA cm−2 . (Adapted from Ref. 7.)
2,3- and 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acids (DHBA) (see Equation 10.5). COOH
COOH HO•
OH
COOH
OH
OH +
OH
HO
2,3-Dihydroxybenzoic acid
2,5-Dihydroxybenzoic acid
(10.5)
Figure 10.3 shows the concentration profile of salicylic acid and its conversion during electrolysis on BDD anode. As expected, the hydroxylation of salicylic acid results in formation of dihydroxylated intermediates. High 2,5- and 2,3-DHBA formation yields cannot be achieved because of its further oxidation to catechol and aliphatic acids. On BDD, the current density has almost no influence on the salicylic conversion as well as
100
6
4
60
X (%)
Conc. (mol m–3)
80
40 2 20 0
0 0
0.4
0.8
1.2
1.6
2
Q (Ah L–1) Figure 10.3 Oxidation of salicylic acid in 1 M HClO4 on BDD anode at 20 A m−2 ; (•) salicylic acid, () 2,5-DHBA, () 2,3-DHBA, () conversion of salicylic acid. (Reprinted from Ref. 7.)
242
ELECTROCHEMICAL OXIDATION OF ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
the DHBA selectivity indicating that the chemical reaction of salicylic acid hydroxylation takes place. 10.3.3
Competitive Reactions
When a mixture of organic compounds is present in solution, one can consider that there is a competition for hydroxyl radicals between the organics. Figure 10.4 shows the results of electrolysis performed on BDD anode in an equimolar solution of formic acid and oxalic acid. It can be seen that the concentration of formic acid decreases much faster than the concentration of oxalic acid. In fact, only when the concentration of formic acid is very low, oxalic acid starts to be oxidized with a significant rate. These results indicate that formic acid competes with oxalic acid for hydroxyl radicals. Indeed, the rate constant between hydroxyl radicals and formic acid (k = 108 M−1 s−1 ) is higher by two orders of magnitude than the rate constant between hydroxyl radicals and oxalic acid (k = 106 M−1 s−1 ) [11]. Such a difference in k between these acids explains why the oxidation of formic acid occurs first on BDD. 10.3.4
Formation of Hydrogen Peroxide
If the interaction between the electrode surface and hydroxyl radicals is weak, hydrogen peroxide is expected to be formed by combination of two hydroxyl radicals, as seen in Equation 10.6: HO • + HO • → H2 O2
(10.6)
Figure 10.5 shows generation of hydrogen peroxide during electrolysis of 1 M HClO4 on BDD anode at the current densities from 23 to 160 mA cm−2 . Depending on the applied current density, the concentration of hydrogen peroxide, after 1 h, reaches a plateau ranging from 0.3 to 1 mM. The obtained steady state H2 O2 concentration (plateau) is
Figure 10.4 Evolution of concentration of formic and oxalic acids during electrolysis of a mixture of 0.5 M formic acid and 0.5 M oxalic acid in 1 M HClO4 on BDD at 238 A m−2 . (Reprinted from Ref. 7.)
10.3 ELECTRO-GENERATION AND DETECTION OF QUASI-FREE HYDROXYL RADICALS
243
1.0
[H2O2] (mol m–3)
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0 0
5
10
15
Time (h) Figure 10.5 Production of H2 O2 at different current densities; (♦) 23 mA cm−2 , () 47 mA cm−2 , () 95 mA cm−2 , (x) 160 mA cm−2 during electrolysis of 1 M HClO4 on BDD electrode. (Reprinted from Ref. 7.)
due to the further anodic oxidation of hydrogen peroxide to oxygen. The initial current efficiency of H2 O2 formation reaches a value up to 0.5% [12]. Therefore, these results show that upon anodic polarization, a significant amount of hydroxyl radicals is formed at BDD electrode. Considering that free hydroxyl radicals are formed in acid aqueous solution according to Reaction (10.7), it is enlightening to calculate the thermodynamic standard potential of its formation using Equation 10.8 [13]. • − + H+ H2 O(l) HO(aq) (aq) + e
E◦ = −
Gr◦ zF
(10.7) (10.8)
where E ◦ (V) is the standard thermodynamic potential of reaction, Gr ◦ (kJ mol−1 ) is the standard Gibbs free energy of the reaction, and z is the number of transferred electrons (z = 1). Taking the standard Gibbs free energy of liquid water formation as −237.178 kJ mol−1 and that of hydroxyl radicals in the aqueous state as −7.74 kJ mol−1 [13], one obtains the thermodynamic standard potential for HO • formation equal to 2.38 V.1 On BDD electrodes, the onset potential of oxygen evolution reaction is about 2.3 V (see Figure 10.6). The fact that O2 is evolved close to the thermodynamic potential of HO • formation (and at potentials positive of it) may indicate that electro-generated hydroxyl radicals on BDD surface are quasi-free. This assumption is justifiable, taking into account the inert nature of diamond surface, which contains closely packed sp3 carbon atoms, and a lack of adsorption sites [14]. As shown in Figure 10.6, the oxygen evolution reaction on BDD occurs with a high overpotential with respect to 1 A somewhat higher value of 2.73 V has also been suggested in literature. [P. Wardman, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data, 1989, 18, 1637-1755] For a concentration of 10 μM, which is the steady state concentration obtained only of at high current densities (see below), the equilibrium concentration would be 2.4 V, similar to the value given above.
244
ELECTROCHEMICAL OXIDATION OF ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
BDD IrO2
8
j (mA cm–2)
7 6 5 4
•OH/H
Ir(V)/Ir(IV)
3 2
2O
O2/H2O
1 0 0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
E (V) vs. SHE
Figure 10.6 Oxygen evolution reaction on IrO2 and BDD electrode in acid media. ◦ thermodynamic potential for O2 formation (EOER = 1.23 V versus SHE), but is very ◦ • = 2.38 V versus SHE). close to the thermodynamic potential of HO formation (EHO Therefore, it might be concluded that formation of this active intermediate (H2 O/HO • ) determines the overpotential for OER on BDD. Similarly, on IrO2 , OER proceeds close to the thermodynamic potential of Ir(V)/Ir(IV) redox couple (Figure 10.6), as it was demonstrated by DEMS measurements [5].
10.4 CONCENTRATION PROFILE OF HYDROXYL RADICALS ON BDD ELECTRODE It is interesting to determine the concentration profile of hydroxyl radicals during oxygen evolution and organics electro-oxidation on BDD electrode. To do that, one should consider that anodically polarized BDD electrode generates quasi-free hydroxyl radicals, which mediate the oxidation processes in the vicinity of the electrode surface. 10.4.1
HO • Concentration Profile during Oxygen Evolution
In the absence of organic compounds, electro-generated free hydroxyl radicals can react with each other to form hydrogen peroxide, as given by Equation 10.6. Hydrogen peroxide can be further oxidized to oxygen either by its direct discharge on the electrode surface (Equation 10.9) or via assistance of hydroxyl radicals (Equation 10.10): H2 O2 → O2 + 2H+ + 2e− H2 O2 + 2HO → O2 + 2H2 O •
(10.9) (10.10)
Assuming that the first step (Equation 10.6) is the rate determining step and that four hydroxyl radicals (four electrons) are needed for oxygen evolution, by applying onedimensional Fick law referred to the molecular diffusion in a stagnant layer, the mass balance for hydroxyl radicals in an element of width x can be expressed as [15]: dcHO • dcHO • 2 • • • − 4kHO cHO • x = −DHO (10.11) −DHO dx x dx x +x
10.4 CONCENTRATION PROFILE OF HYDROXYL RADICALS ON BDD ELECTRODE
245
where DHO • (m2 s−1 ) is the diffusion coefficient of HO • , kHO • (m3 mol−1 s−1 ) is the rate constant of Reaction 10.6, and cHO • (mol m−3 ) is the concentration of HO • . If x goes to 0, we can write: DHO •
d2 cHO • 2 = 4kHO • cHO • dx 2
(10.12)
The boundary conditions are obtained by assuming that far from the electrode (x = ∞) concentration of hydroxyl radicals is 0, whereas at the electrode (x = 0) there is a surface s concentration of hydroxyl radicals (cHO • ): cHO • = 0 at x = ∞
(10.13)
s cHO • = cHO at x = 0 •
(10.14)
Considering these boundary conditions, the solution of differential Equation 10.12 gives the concentration profile of hydroxyl radicals, as a function of the distance x from the electrode surface, during oxygen evolution. cHO • =
2kHO •
3DHO • 2 • x + 2k3DHO • cs • HO
(10.15)
HO
The gradient of the concentration can be expressed as: dcHO • = dx
kHO
•
−3DHO • 3 • x + 2k3DHO • cs • HO
(10.16)
HO
Using Equation 10.16, it is possible to calculate the flux of hydroxyl radicals at the electrode surface, as given by Equation 10.17: [JHO ]x =0 = −DHO •
•
dcHO • dx
x =0
s 3 = 1.63 (cHO • ) kHO • DHO •
(10.17)
The flux of hydroxyl radicals at the electrode surface can also be expressed in terms of the current density j : [JHO • ]x =0 =
j F
(10.18)
Thus, comparing Equation 10.17 with Equation 10.18, the surface concentration of hydroxyl radicals during oxygen evolution (OER) can be obtained (see Equation 10.19): s cHO •
OER
=
3
j2 2.67F 2 kHO • DHO •
(10.19)
246
ELECTROCHEMICAL OXIDATION OF ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
Figure 10.7 Simulated concentration profile of hydroxyl radicals during oxygen evolution according to Equations 10.15 and 10.19; j = 300 A m−2 ; DHO = 2.2 × 10−9 m2 s−1 ; kHO = 5.5 × 109 M−1 s−1 [10]. (Reprinted from Ref. 15.)
Figure 10.7 shows the concentration profile of hydroxyl radicals during oxygen evolution as a function of the distance from the electrode surface. It can be seen that for current density of j = 300 A m−2 , the reaction layer thickness is about one micrometer, whereas the maximum (surface) concentration of hydroxyl radicals reaches the value of several tenths of μM.
10.4.2 HO • Concentration Profile during Electro-Oxidation of Organic Compound By analogy to Equations 10.11 through 10.19, it is possible to determine the concentration profile of hydroxyl radicals during oxidation of organic compounds under these hypotheses: •
Oxidation of organic compounds R proceeds only via assistance of hydroxyl radicals in the vicinity of the electrode surface. R + zHO • → oxidation products
•
(10.20)
Concentration of organic compound is high enough to be considered as a constant in the reaction layer. • Oxygen evolution, via H2 O2 oxidation, is negligible. The two latter hypotheses apply to the charge-transfer controlled region.
10.4 CONCENTRATION PROFILE OF HYDROXYL RADICALS ON BDD ELECTRODE
247
Under these hypotheses, the mass balance for hydroxyl radicals leads to Equations 10.21 and 10.22: dcHO • dcHO • • • • − zkR cHO cR x = −DHO (10.21) −DHO dx x dx x +x DHO •
d2 cHO • = zkR cHO • cR dx 2
(10.22)
where z is the number of electrons involved in oxidation of organic compound R, kR (m3 mol−1 s−1 ) is the rate constant of Reaction 10.20, and cR (mol m−3 ) is the concentration of organic compound. Thus, solving Equation 10.22 with the boundary conditions given in Equations 10.13 and 10.14, one can obtain the concentration profile of hydroxyl radicals during oxidation of organic compounds (Equation 10.23):
cHO • =
s cHO •
zkR cR exp − x DHO •
(10.23)
The gradient of the concentration can be expressed as: dcHO • s = −cHO • dx
zkR cR zkR cR exp − x DHO • DHO •
(10.24)
Using Equation 10.24, the flux of hydroxyl radicals at the electrode surface is given by Equation 10.25:
s zkR cR DHO • [JHO • ]x =0 = cHO •
(10.25)
Comparing Equation 10.25 with Equation 10.18, the surface concentration of hydroxyl radicals during oxidation of organic compounds R is obtained (Equation 10.26): s cHO • = R
j √ F zkR cR DHO •
(10.26)
In the presence of organic compound, concentration of hydroxyl radicals decreases exponentially (Equation 10.23) with the distance from the electrode surface. The thickness of the reaction layer (reaction cage) depends on the root of the concentration of organic compound, the rate constant of organics oxidation (via hydroxyl radicals), and the applied current density. As a typical example, Figure 10.8 shows the simulated HO • concentration profile during oxidation of formic acid (0.25–1 M) at 300A m−2 . It can be seen that the higher is the formic acid concentration, the lower is the surface concentration of HO • , and the smaller is the thickness of the reaction layer. For investigated concentrations of formic acid, the thickness of the reaction layer (reaction cage) drops down to barely tenths of nanometers, which is significantly lower as compared with that in the absence of organics (Figure 10.7). Figure 10.9 shows the comparison of HO • concentration profile for 1 M formic acid, methanol, and ethanol. Depending on the rate constant, the thickness of the reaction layer varies between few nanometers and tenths of nanometers.
248
ELECTROCHEMICAL OXIDATION OF ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
Figure 10.8 Simulated concentration profile of hydroxyl radicals during oxidation of (1) 1 M, (2) 0.75 M, (3) 0.5 M, and (4) 0.25 M formic acid, according to Equations 10.23 and 10.26; j = 300 A m−2 ; DHO = 2.2 × 10−9 m2 s−1 ; kHCOOH = 1.3 × 108 M−1 s−1 [10]; z = 2. (Reprinted from Ref. 15.)
Figure 10.9 Simulated concentration profile of hydroxyl radicals during oxidation of 1 M (1) formic acid, (2) methanol, and (3) ethanol according to Equations 10.23 and 10.26; j = 300 A m−2 ; DHO = 2.2 × 10−9 m2 s−1 ; kHCOOH = 1.3 × 108 M−1 s−1 ; kCH3OH = 9.7 × 108 M−1 s−1 ; kC2H5OH = 1.9 × 109 M−1 s−1 [10]; z = 2, 6, and 12 for formic acid, methanol, and ethanol, respectively. (Reprinted from Ref. 15.)
10.5
KINETIC MODEL OF ORGANICS OXIDATION ON BDD ANODE
Under electrolysis regime, electrogenerated hydroxyl radicals (Equation 10.1) are the intermediates for both the main reaction of organics oxidation (Equation 10.2) and the side reaction of oxygen evolution (Equation 10.3). Considering this simplified reaction scheme (Equations 10.1, 10.2, and 10.3), a kinetic model is proposed based on following
249
10.5 KINETIC MODEL OF ORGANICS OXIDATION ON BDD ANODE
suppositions: (1) adsorption of the organic compounds at the electrode surface is negligible; (2) all organics have the same diffusion coefficient D; and (3) the global rate of the electrochemical mineralization of organics is a fast reaction and it is controlled by mass transport of organics to the anode surface. The consequence of this last assumption is that the rate of the mineralization reaction is independent of the chemical nature of the organic compound present in the electrolyte. Under these conditions, the limiting current density for the electrochemical mineralization of an organic compound (or a mixture of organics) under given hydrodynamic conditions can be written as Equation 10.27 [3]: jlim (t) = 4Fkm COD(t)
(10.27)
where jlim is the limiting current density for organics mineralization (A m−2 ), F is the Faraday constant (C mol−1 ), km is the mass transport coefficient (m s−1 ) and COD is the chemical oxygen demand (mol O2 m−3 ). At the beginning of electrolysis, at time t = 0, the initial limiting current density (jlim ) is given by: 0 jlim = 4Fkm COD0
(10.28)
where COD0 is the initial chemical oxygen demand. Working under galvanostatic conditions, two different operating regimes are defined: at japplied < jlim the electrolysis is controlled by the applied current, whereas at japplied > jlim it is controlled by the mass transport control. 10.5.1
Electrolysis under Current Limited Control ( japplied < jlim )
In this operating regime, the current efficiency is 100% and the rate of COD removal is constant and can be written as: r =α
0 jlim 4F
(10.29)
where α is the dimensionless current density defined as: α=
japplied with 0 < α < 1 0 jlim
(10.30)
Using Relation 10.28, the rate of COD removal (Equation 10.30) can be given by: r = αkm COD0
(10.31)
It is necessary to consider the mass-balances over the electrochemical cell and the reservoir to describe the temporal evolution of COD in the batch recirculation reactor system given in Figure 10.10. Considering that the volume of the electrochemical reactor VE (m3 ) is much smaller than the reservoir volume VR (m3 ), we can obtain from the mass-balance on COD for the electrochemical cell the following relation: QCODout = QCODin − αkm ACOD0
(10.32)
250
ELECTROCHEMICAL OXIDATION OF ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
CO2 O2 W1
W2 F2
F1
R3
R4
P3
P4 _
+
R1
E
R2
R5
R6 P1
P2
Figure 10.10 Scheme of the two-compartment electrochemical flow cell; R = reservoirs; P = pumps; E = electrochemical cell with membrane; W = heat exchangers, F = gas flow controllers. (Reprinted from Ref. 4.)
where Q is the flow-rate (m3 s−1 ) through the electrochemical cell, CODin and CODout are the chemical oxygen demands (mol O2 m−3 ) at the inlet and at the outlet of the electrochemical cell, respectively, and A is the anode area (m2 ). For the well-mixed reservoir (Figure 10.10), the mass balance on COD can be expressed as: Q(CODout − CODin ) = VR
dCODin dt
(10.33)
Combining Equations 10.32 and 10.33 and replacing CODin by the temporal evolution of chemical oxygen demand COD, we obtain: COD0 Akm dCODin = −α dt VR
(10.34)
Integrating this equation subject to the initial condition COD = COD0 at t = 0 gives the evolution of COD(t) with time in this operating regime (japplied < jlim ): Akm COD(t) = COD 1 − α t VR 0
(10.35)
This behavior persists until a critical time (tcr ), at which the applied current density is equal to the limiting current density, which corresponds to: CODcr = αCOD0
(10.36)
10.5 KINETIC MODEL OF ORGANICS OXIDATION ON BDD ANODE
251
Substituting Equation 10.36 in Equation 10.35 it is possible to calculate the critical time (Equation 10.37): tcr =
10.5.2
1 − α VR α Akm
(10.37)
Electrolysis under Mass Transport Control ( japplied > jlim )
In this operating regime, the current efficiency is 100% and the rate of COD removal is constant and can be written as: When the applied current exceeds the limiting one (japplied > jlim ), secondary reactions (such as oxygen evolution) start to proceed, resulting in a decrease of the instantaneous current efficiency (see Equation 10.38): ICE =
COD(t) jlim = japplied αCOD0
(10.38)
This regime is realized either at: 0 1. japplied < jlim when the electrolysis is continued over the critical time (COD < 0 αCOD at t > tcr ), or 0 2. japplied > jlim when applied current exceeds its initial limiting value (COD < αCOD0 at any finite time)
In these cases, the COD mass balances on the anodic compartment of the electrochemical cell E and the reservoir R2 (Figure 10.10) can be expressed as: dCOD Akm COD =− dt VR
(10.39)
Integration of this equation from t = tcr to t, and COD = αCOD0 to COD(t) leads to: Akm 1−α at t > tcr t+ 1. COD(t) = αCOD0 exp − VR α Akm 0 2. COD(t) = COD exp − t VR
(10.40) (10.41)
From Equations 10.38, 10.40 and 10.41 the instantaneous current efficiency, ICE, is now given by: Akm 1−α at t > tcr 1. ICE = exp − t+ VR α Akm 1 2. ICE = exp − t α VR
(10.42) (10.43)
A graphical representation of the proposed kinetic model is given in Figure 10.11. In order to verify it, an anodic oxidation of various organic compounds has been performed on BDD. Figure 10.12 shows both the experimental and predicted values (continuous
252
ELECTROCHEMICAL OXIDATION OF ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
(a)
COD0
A
COD(t ) = COD0(1–
B αAkm t) VR
COD(t) = αCOD0exp ( – CODcr =
i appl
Akm 1–α ) VR t + α
4Fk m
0 (b) ICE(%)
t
100
ICE = exp ( –
o (1–α) Qcr = i cr km
Ak m 1–α ) t+ VR α
0 t
Figure 10.11 Evolution of (a) COD and (b) ICE in function of time (or specific charge); (A) represents the charge transport control; (B) represents the mass transport control. (Reprinted from Ref. 4.)
1.0
2500 ICE/–
0.8
COD (ppm)
2000
0.6 0.4 0.2
1500
0.0 0
5
10
15
Specific charge (Ah L–1)
1000
500
0 0
5
10
15
Specific charge (Ah L–1)
Figure 10.12 Evolution of COD and ICE (inset) in function of specific charge for different organic compounds: (x) acetic acid, () isopropanol, (o) phenol, () 4-chlorophenol, (♦) 2-naphtol; i = 238 A m−2 ; T = 25◦ C; Electrolyte: 1 M H2 SO4 ; the solid line represents model prediction. (Reprinted from Ref. 4.)
line) of both ICE and COD evolution with the specific electrical charge passed during the anodic oxidation of different classes of organic compounds (acetic acid, isopropanol, phenol, 4-chlorophenol, 2-naphtol). This figure demonstrates that the electrochemical treatment is independent on the chemical nature of the organic compound. Furthermore, there is an excellent agreement between the experimental data and predicted values from proposed model. Figure 10.13 shows the influence of current density on both ICE
10.6 ELECTROCHEMICALLY INDUCED MINERALIZATION OF ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
253
1.0
2000 ICE /–
0.8
COD (ppm)
1500
0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0
1000
0
5
10
15
Specific charge (Ah L–1) 500
0 0
5
10
15
–1)
Specific charge (Ah L
Figure 10.13 Influence of the applied current density, (x) 119 A m−2 , (o) 238 A m−2 , (♦) 476 A m−2 on the evolution of COD and ICE (inset) during electrolysis of 5 mM 2-naphtol in 1 M H2 SO4 on BDD; T = 25◦ C; the solid line represents model prediction. (Reprinted from Ref. 4.)
and COD evolution with the specific electrical charge passed during the galvanostatic oxidation of a 5 mM 2-naphtol in 1 M H2 SO4 at different current densities (119–476 A m−2 ). As previously, an excellent agreement between the experimental and predicted values is observed.
10.6 ELECTROCHEMICALLY INDUCED MINERALIZATION OF ORGANIC COMPOUNDS BY MOLECULAR OXYGEN Electrochemical mineralization of organic compounds on BDD anode not only involves hydroxyl radicals but also molecular oxygen present in air/oxygen-saturated aqueous organic solutions [16]. The direct evidence for this process was found using differential electrochemical mass spectrometry (DEMS). Figure 10.14 shows a DEMS measurement, in which the cyclic voltammogram (CV) and the mass spectrometric cyclic voltammograms (MSCV) for C16 O2 , 18 O2 , 16 O18 O, C18 O2 , and C16 O18 O were simultaneously recorded during oxidation of acetic acid solution (1) deaerated and (2) saturated with isotopically labeled 18 O2 . Figures 10.14e and 10.14f show that isotopically labeled C18 O2 and C16 O18 O are evolved in parallel to 18 O2 diminution (Figure 10.14c) indicating that oxygen dissolved in the solution is involved in mineralization of acetic acid. The rate of C18 O16 O is higher than that of C18 O2 due to the higher probability of C18 O16 O formation, because one atom of oxygen (16 O) comes from water. It is interesting to note that ionic current of C18 O2 reaches a limitation at higher potentials (Figure 10.14e). The limiting current may indicate that oxidation of acetic acid by 18 O2 (similarly, 16 O18 O formation in Figure 10.14d) is limited by diffusion of 18 O2 to the electrode surface. Under investigated conditions, 7% of additional, non-Faradaic CO2 was evolved. This non-Faradaic enhancement of the acetic acid electro-oxidation proceeds most likely through the sequence of reactions that are initiated by HO • formed on the electrode
254
ELECTROCHEMICAL OXIDATION OF ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
CV
I f (mA)
4
1–2
2
(a) 0 MSCV, m/z = 44 (C16O2)
I i (nA)
6
1–2
3 (b) 0 1.0
2
16
I i (nA)
MSCV, m/z = 36 (18O2)
I j (pA) 0.8
12 1 (c) 8
0.6 75
MSCV, m/z = 34 (16O18O)
I i (pA)
2 50
25 27
(d)
1
MSCV, m/z = 48 (C18O2)
I i (pA)
2 18
9 (e)
1
0
I i (nA)
0.4
MSCV, m/z = 46 (C16O18O) 2
0.2 1
(f) 0.0 1.8
2.0
2.2 2.4 E (V) vs RHE
2.6
2.8
Figure 10.14 Simultaneously recorded cyclic voltammogram (CV) (a) and mass spectrometric CV (MSCV) for (b) C16 O2 (m/z = 44), (c) 18 O2 (m/z = 36), (d) C16 O18 O (m/z = 34), (e) C18 O2 (m/z = 48), and (f) C16 O18 O (m/z = 46) of (1) deaerated and (2) 18 O2 -saturated solution of 50 mM acetic acid; scan rate 10 mV s−1 , flow rate 5 μls−1 , electrolyte 1 M HClO4 , T = 25◦ C. (Adapted from Ref. 16.)
10.6 ELECTROCHEMICALLY INDUCED MINERALIZATION OF ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
255
surface. Such a reaction scheme was proposed in radiolysis of hydrocarbons (RH). It has been reported that during the ionizing irradiation of aqueous solution of organic compounds (upon x-ray or γ -ray), molecular oxygen enhances the oxidation processes [17–19]. This occurs via addition of molecular oxygen to an organic free radical (R • ) resulting in formation of an organic peroxy radical (RO2 • ), which can participate in subsequent reactions. The organic free radical (R • ) is formed via dehydrogenation of hydrocarbons (RH) initiated by HO • formed during radiolysis of water. Therefore, by analogy between radiation-induced oxidation of organic compounds and our system, in which HO • are generated electrochemically, a general model of electrochemically induced oxidation of organic compounds via molecular oxygen on BDD electrode can be proposed, as shown in Figure 10.15. Such a non-Faradaic enhancement of electrolysis opens the possibilities for designing a less energy consuming electrochemical mineralization process in which current is applied mainly to initiate formation of HO • , whereas complete degradation of pollutant proceeds via reaction with molecular oxygen in aerated solutions (Figure 10.15, reactions 1–4). To do so, it is necessary to ensure an efficient transport of molecular O2 to the interface and thus the organic radicals (via porous electrodes). The key factors of the efficient mineralization process are the stability of organic radicals (reaction 5 in Figure 10.15, corresponding to formation of 18 O16 O in Figure 10.14d) and its reactivity toward molecular oxygen dissolved in solution (reaction 3 in Figure 10.15). It can be further concluded that such electrochemically induced activation process may occur also on other electrode materials on which organic radicals are formed during a direct discharge of organic compounds at the electrode surface.
RO•2 (4) (5)
(3) O2 (aq)
O2 R•
RO
1/2O2 (2)
RH (6)
H2O
(1)
H+
HO• e–
H+
e–
BDD electrode surface Figure 10.15 Simplified diagram for electrochemically induced oxidation of organic compounds via molecular oxygen dissolved in aerated solution on boron-doped diamond electrode; (1) water discharge to hydroxyl radical HO • ; (2) dehydrogenation of organic compound RH via HO • and formation of free organic radical R • ; (3) addition of molecular oxygen to R • resulting in formation of an organic peroxy radical RO2 • ; (4) decomposition of RO2 • leading to regeneration of HO • and formation of RO; (5) decomposition of RO2 • to R • ; (6) oxygen evolution, a side reaction. (Adapted from Ref. 16.)
256
10.7
ELECTROCHEMICAL OXIDATION OF ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
CONCLUSIONS
On boron-doped diamond electrodes, organic compounds are oxidized by intermediacy of quasi-free hydroxyl radicals electro-generated from water at high anodic potentials. These hydroxyl radicals initiate chain reactions in which molecular oxygen dissolved in aerated aqueous solution contributes to mineralization of organic compounds at ambient temperature. In general, oxidation of organic compounds on BDD proceeds with very high current efficiency, which makes BDD an ideal anode material for electrochemical mineralization of organic wastes. 10.8
EXERCISES
1. Calculate the concentration of hydroxide radicals (DHO • = 2.2 × 10−9 m2 s−1 ) at the surface of BDD electrode (x = 0), at a distance of 0.1 μm and at 0.5 cm from the electrode surface during oxygen evolution in 1 M HClO4 at 200 A m−2 , T = 25◦ C. Consider that the rate determining step of the process is the following reaction: HO • + HO • → H2 O2
kHO • = 5.5 × 106 m3 mol−1 s−1
2. Calculate the concentration of hydroxide radicals (DHO • = 2.2 × 10−9 m2 s−1 ) at the surface of the BDD electrode (x = 0) during oxygen evolution under galvanostatic conditions in 1 M HClO4 at 25◦ C at current densities of: a) 300 A m−2 b) 100 A m−2 c) 10 A m−2 Consider that the rate determining step of the process is this reaction: HO • + HO • → H2 O2
kHO • = 5.5 × 106 m3 mol−1 s−1
3. The anodic oxidation of 1 M HCOOH solution in 2 M HClO4 has been carried out at 25◦ C under galvanostatic conditions (300 A m−2 ) using BDD electrodes. Calculate the concentration of hydroxide radicals (DHO • = 2.2 × 10−9 m2 s−1 ) at the surface of the BDD electrode (x = 0) after: a) Conversion of 30% of HCOOH to CO2 b) Conversion of 60% of HCOOH to CO2 c) Conversion of 90% of HCOOH to CO2 Consider that the process is controlled by the reactions: HO • + HO • → H2 O2
kHO • = 5.5 × 106 m3 mol−1 s−1
HCOOH + 2HO • → CO2 + 2H2 O
kHCOOH = 1.3 × 105 m3 mol−1 s−1
4. Calculate the initial concentration of hydroxide radicals (DHO • = 2.2 × 10−9 m2 s−1 ) at the surface of the BDD electrode (x = 0) during the anodic oxidation of the following organic compounds under galvanostatic conditions (100 A m−2 ) in 2 M HClO4 at T = 25◦ C:
10.8 EXERCISES
257
a) 1 M HCOOH (kHCOOH = 1.3 × 105 m3 mol−1 s−1 ) b) 1 M CH3 OH (kCH3OH = 9.7 × 105 m3 mol−1 s−1 ) c) 1 M C2 H5 OH (kC2H5OH = 1.9 × 106 m3 mol−1 s−1 ) 5. The mass transfer coefficient of an electrolytic cell, under given hydrodynamic conditions, has been estimated to be 1.2 × 10−5 m s−1 using the ferri-ferrocyanide (FFC) redox couple. Calculate: a) The mass transfer coefficient of formic acid, oxidized at the same conditions b) The limiting current density for the oxidation of 0.1 M formic acid aqueous solution given that DFFC = 1.1 × 10−9 m2 s−1 and DHCOOH = 1.7 × 10−9 m2 s−1 . 10.8.1
Solutions
• 1. .a) HO concentration at the surface of the electrode (x = 0): j2 3 s cHO • = 2 OER 2.67F kHO • DHO • 2002 3 = = 5.1 × 10−2 mol m−3 2.67 · 964852 · 5.5 · 106 · 2.2 · 10−9
b) HO • concentration at a distance of 0.1 μm from the electrode (x = 0.1 μm = 10−7 m): cHO • =
3DHO • 2 • 2kHO • x + 2k3DHO s •c • HO
HO
3 · 2.2 · 10−9 −2 −3 = 2 = 1.4 × 10 mol m 3·2.2·10−9 2 · 5.5 · 106 10−7 + 2·5.5·10 6 ·5.1·10−2 c) HO • concentration at a distance of 0.5 cm from the electrode (x = 0.5 cm = 5 × 10−3 m): cHO • =
3 · 2.2 · 10−9 −11 mol m−3 2 = 2.4 × 10 −9 3·2.2·10 2 · 5.5 · 106 5 · 10−3 + 2·5.5·10 6 ·5.1·10−2
• 2. a . ) HO concentration at the surface of the electrode (x = 0) for galvanostatic conditions at 300 A m−2 : j2 3 s cHO • = 2 OER 2.67F kHO • DHO • 3002 3 = = 6.7 × 10−2 mol m−3 2.67 · 964852 · 5.5 · 106 · 2.2 · 10−9
258
ELECTROCHEMICAL OXIDATION OF ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
b) HO • concentration at the surface of the electrode (x = 0) for galvanostatic conditions at 100 A m−2 : s cHO •
OER
=
3
2.67 ·
964852
1002 = 3.2 × 10−2 mol m−3 · 5.5 · 106 · 2.2 · 10−9
c) HO • concentration at the surface of the electrode (x = 0) for galvanostatic conditions at 10 A m−2 : s cHO •
OER
=
3
2.67 ·
964852
102 = 6.9 × 10−3 mol m−3 · 5.5 · 106 · 2.2 · 10−9
3. .a) During oxidation of an organic compound: s cHO • = R
j √ F zkR cR DHO •
with
cR = cR0 (1 − X )
where X is the conversion rate; cR0 = 1M = 103 mol m−3 HCOOH + 2OH • → CO2 + 2H2 O z = 2 b) HO • concentration at the surface of the electrode (x = 0) after conversion of 30% of HCOOH to CO2 : s cHO • = R
j 300 =
√ 5 F zkR cR DHO • 96485 2 · 1.3 · 10 · 103 (1 − 0.3) · 2.2 · 10−9
= 4.9 × 10−3 mol m−3 c) HO • concentration at the surface of the electrode (x = 0) after conversion of 60% of HCOOH to CO2 : s cHO • = R
300 = 6.5 × 10−3 mol m−3
5 96485 2 · 1.3 · 10 · 103 (1 − 0.6) · 2.2 · 10−9
d) HO • concentration at the surface of the electrode (x = 0) after conversion of 90% of HCOOH to CO2 : s cHO • = R
300 = 1.3 × 10−2 mol m−3
5 96485 2 · 1.3 · 10 · 103 (1 − 0.9) · 2.2 · 10−9
10.8 EXERCISES
259
4. .a) HO • concentration at the surface of the electrode (x = 0) during anodic oxidation of 1 M (103 mol m−3 ) HCOOH (kR = 1.3 × 105 m3 mol−1 s−1 ) at 100 A m−2 : HCOOH + 2OH • → CO2 + 2H2 O j s cHO • = √ R F zkR cR DHO • =
z =2
100 √ 96485 2 · 1.3 · 105 · 103 · 2.2 · 10−9
= 1.4 × 10−3 mol m−3 b) HO • concentration at the surface of the electrode (x = 0) during anodic oxidation of 1 M (103 mol m−3 ) CH3 OH (kR = 9.7 × 105 m3 mol−1 s−1 ) at 100 A m−2 : z =6 CH3 OH + 6OH • → CO2 + 5H2 O 100 s = 2.9 × 10−4 mol m−3 cHO • = √ R 96485 6 · 9.7 · 105 · 103 · 2.2 · 10−9 c) HO • concentration at the surface of the electrode (x = 0) during anodic oxidation of 1 M (103 mol m−3 ) C2 H5 OH (kR = 1.9 × 106 m3 mol−1 s−1 ) at 100 A m−2 : C2 H5 OH + 12OH • → 2CO2 + 9H2 O z = 12 100 s = 1.5 × 10−4 mol m−3 cHO • = √ R 96485 12 · 1.9 · 106 · 103 · 2.2 · 10−9 5. .a) Estimation of the mass transfer coefficient of HCOOH: kd =
D at invariant δ : δ
kd,HCOOH = kd,FFC
DHCOOH DFFC = kd,HCOOH kd,FFC
DHCOOH 1.7 · 10−9 = 1.2 · 10−5 = 1.9 × 10−5 m s−1 DFFC 1.1 · 10−9
b) The limiting current density for the oxidation of 0.1 M (102 mol m−3 ) HCOOH: jlim = z · F · kd,HCOOH · cHCOOH where z = 2 (HCOOH + 2OH • → CO2 + 2H2 O) jlim = z · F · kd · c = 2 · 96485 · 1.9 · 10−5 · 102 = 367 A m−2 = 0.37 kA m−2
260
ELECTROCHEMICAL OXIDATION OF ORGANIC COMPOUNDS
REFERENCES 1. S. Parsons, ed., Advanced Oxidation Processes for Water and Wastewater Treatment , IWA Publishing, London, 2004. 2. C. Comninellis, Electrochim. Acta 1994, 39 , 1857–1862. 3. G. F´oti, C. Comninellis, in Modern Aspects of Electrochemistry (R.E. White, B.E. Conway, C.G. Vayenas, M.E. Gamboa-Adelco, eds.), Modern Aspects of Electrochemistry, No. 37, Kluwer Academic / Plenum Publishers, New York, 2004, pp. 87–130. 4. A. Kapałka, G. F´oti, C. Comninellis, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2008, 38 , 7–16. 5. S. Fierro, T. Nagel, H. Baltruschat, C. Comninellis, Electrochem. Commun. 2007, 9 , 1969–1974, Electrochem. Solid State Lett ., 2008, 11 , E20–E23. 6. S. Fierro, E. Passas-Lagos, E. Chatzisymeon, D. Mantzavinos, C. Comninellis, Electrochem. Commun. 2009, 11 , 1358–1361. 7. B. Marselli, J. Garcia-Gomez, P.A. Michaud, M.A. Rodrigo, C. Comninellis, J. Electrochem. Soc. 2003, 150 , D79–D83. 8. G. Liu, J. Zhao, H. Hidaka, J. Photochem. Photobiol. A: Chem. 2000, 133 , 83–88. 9. G.R. Buettner, Free Rad. Biol. Med . 1987, 3 , 259–303. 10. M. Hermes-Lima, N.C. Santos, J. Yan, M. Andrews, H.M. Schulman, P. Ponka, Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1999, 1426 , 475–482. 11. NDRL Radiation Chemistry Data Center, http://allen.rad.nd.edu. 12. P.A. Michaud, Comportement anodique du diamant synth´etique dope au bore, PhD thesis, EPFL, No 2595, 2000. 13. J.P. Hoare, in Standard Potentials in Aqueous Solution (A.J. Bard, R. Parsons, J. Jordan, eds.), Marcel Dekker Inc., New York, 1985. 14. A. Fujishima, Y. Einaga, T.N. Rao, D.A. Tryk, eds., Diamond Electrochemistry, BKC Inc., Tokyo & Elsevier B.V., Amsterdam, 2005. 15. A. Kapałka, G. F´oti, C. Comninellis, Electrochim. Acta. 2009, 54 , 2018–2023. 16. A. Kapałka, B. Lanova, H. Baltruschat, G. F´oti, C. Comninellis, Electrochem. Commun. 2008, 10 , 1215–1218. 17. R. Scholes, J. Weiss, Radiat. Res. 1959, 1 , 177–189. 18. G.R.A. Johnson, J. Weiss, Chem. & Ind . 1955, 358–359. 19. W.M. Garrison, H.R. Haymond, W. Bennett, S. Cole, Radiat. Res. 1959, 10 , 273–282.
11 Modeling of Electrochemical Process for Water Treatment Using Diamond Films Onofrio Scialdone and Alessandro Galia
11.1
INTRODUCTION
In electrochemistry, as in other chemical methods, situations in which a single reactive path is obtained are seldom encountered. In most experimental cases the target reactive path is accompanied by side reactions leading to unwanted side products and/or to a higher energetic consume. Therefore, the optimization of the process becomes obviously a relevant issue. Quite often the high number of operative parameters that may be adjusted makes an empirical investigation exceedingly onerous in order to individuate the conditions that allow the optimization of an electrochemical process. In this perspective, theoretical models can offer useful strategies for both the individuation of the parameters that affect the selectivity of the process, and the design of new materials/apparatuses that can favor the selective occurrence of the desired route [1]. Furthermore, the experimental validation of mathematical models can furnish precious indications for scale-up stages and confirm the assumptions on which the model is based, thus allowing a proper description of the process. In the field of the electrochemical abatement of organic pollutants in wastewater, unwanted reactions should be severely minimized in order to avoid the formation of secondary pollutants and/or an increase of energetic costs. Hence, the Synthetic Diamond Films: Preparation, Electrochemistry, Characterization, and Applications, First Edition. Edited by Enric Brillas and Carlos Alberto Mart´ınez-Huitle. © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Published 2011 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
261
262
MODELING OF ELECTROCHEMICAL PROCESS FOR WATER TREATMENT USING DIAMOND FILMS
modeling of these processes has attracted the attention of numerous researchers in the last several years [2–10]. Both oxidation and reduction routes were used for the treatment of organic compounds in water [11,12]. Oxidation processes allow the conversion of organic pollutants in carbon dioxide (electrochemical “incineration” or “combustion”) (see Equation 11.1), to nontoxic compounds or to biocompatible organics that can be treated in a conventional biological process. Combined processes are more difficult to optimize. Therefore, the development of an oxidation process that allows treating the wastewater without the necessity of a posttreatment stage is more often pursued by researchers. Reduction processes are usually used for the conversion of some organic pollutants to nontoxic compounds. For example, halogenated aliphatic compounds can be electrochemically reduced to corresponding dehalogenated aliphatic hydrocarbons (see Equation 11.2 for the conversion of chloroalkanes to corresponding alkanes) [12], whereas nitrate ions can be converted in nitrogenous gas [13]. Cm Hn + 2mH2 O → mCO2 + (n + 4m)H+ + (n + 4m)e−
(11.1)
Cm H2m+2−p Clp + 2pe− + p H+ → Cm H2m+2 + p Cl−
(11.2)
Focusing on the oxidation route, it is relevant to observe that many organic pollutants can be anodically oxidized at a lower potential with respect to that involved for oxygen evolution, but in these conditions a decrease of the anode activity is often observed as a consequence of poisons formation [2]. These poisoning species can usually be oxidized only at high anodic potentials in the region of oxygen evolution. Therefore, the anodic abatement of organic pollutants is generally carried out at high potentials with simultaneous oxygen evolution. At these potentials the oxidation of organics can take place both by a direct anodic oxidation or by means of hydroxyl radicals generated by water oxidation. Depending on the nature of the electrode material, hydroxyl radicals can be present as free radicals in a reaction layer adjacent to the electrodic surface, with a thickness drastically lower than that of the diffusion layer due to the fast chemical evolution of these very reactive species, or adsorbed to the anodic surface. Both a weak physical and a chemical adsorption are furthermore possible depending on the electrodic material. A simplified mechanism for the electrochemical selective oxidation or combustion of organics with simultaneous oxygen evolution was proposed in 1994 by Comninellis [2]. According to this mechanism, selective oxidation to stable compounds occurs with oxide anodes (MOx ) forming a so-called higher oxide MOx +1 (chemisorbed hydroxyl radicals) and combustion occurs with phisisorbed hydroxyl radicals. On the basis of this assumption, Comninellis proposed two theoretical expressions for the instantaneous current efficiency (ICE) for the organics oxidation achieved by means of physical adsorbed hydroxyl radicals at “nonactive anodes” (electrodes which do not participate in the oxidation) or chemical adsorbed oxygen at “active anodes” (electrodes that participate in the oxidation) [2]. First, the author focused on processes that occurred in the absence of mass transfer limitations. Later, Comninellis and, co-authors (Simond, Schaller, and Comnindellis [3] and Simond and Comninellis [4]) developed a theoretical model for active electrodes that included the effect of the substrate concentration ([RH ]b ) polarization. More recently, an extension of the above mentioned theoretical models was proposed, which takes in account the occurrence of both direct anodic oxidation and oxidation mediated by physical or chemical adsorbed hydroxyl radicals [5]. Mass transfer control,
11.2 THEORETICAL MODELS
263
oxidation control, and mixed kinetic regimes were considered. Theoretical predictions were in good agreement with the experimental results obtained for oxalic and formic acids oxidation at Ti/IrO2 –Ta2 O5 anode [5,6]. In general, in the literature it has been observed more times that the weaker the interaction between hydroxyl radical with the electrodic surface, the lower is the electrochemical activity toward oxygen evolution (high oxygen overvoltage anodes) and the higher is the chemical reactivity toward organics oxidation [14]. In this frame, the high activity of Boron-doped diamond (BDD) toward the electrochemical incineration of a wide class of organics can be rationalized on the bases of the weak interactions between the diamond surface and hydroxyl radicals. These interactions are described to be so weak that the HO • can be considered as quasi-free, thus leading to high overpotential for oxygen evolution and to high reactivity toward organics oxidation [14]. The oxidation of organic pollutants can also take place in the homogeneous phase by electro-generated agents such as active chlorine, ozone, S2 O8 2− and CeIV [11]. Active chlorine or peroxidisulfuric acid, for example, can be generated by the oxidation of chlorides or sulfate ions, respectively, at the anodic surface. Particular interest has been focused on chlorine mediation, due to the ubiquitous character of Cl− species in wastewaters and its effective action. The homogeneous oxidation performed by means of active chlorine could coexist with the direct oxidation of the organics at the electrode surface, the oxidation mediated by electro-generated hydroxyl or oxychloro radicals or with both these paths. As a consequence, in this case it is not easy to evaluate a priori the effect of operative parameters on the performances of the process. In this context it highlights again the potential paramount importance of theoretical models to select the key operative parameters and design suitable materials/apparatus. So, many authors have focused their attention on the modeling of electrochemical oxidation of organic pollutants in water. Particular attention has been devoted to processes performed at BDD, due to the extreme efficacy of this electrode toward the oxidation of numerous pollutants. The modeling of both direct and indirect oxidation processes was attempted by various authors. A brief review of these studies is reported here.
11.2 11.2.1
THEORETICAL MODELS General Considerations
The electrochemical oxidation of water at BDD has been extensively investigated by various authors [11,15]. As prepared boron-doped diamond shows hydrogenated terminations that are oxidized before the oxygen evolution to oxygen-containing functionalities [16,17]. It has been suggested that hydroxyl groups are the result of strong electrochemical oxidation. Oxygen evolution at BDD starts at about 2.3 V versus SCE by oxidation of water and formation of hydroxyl radicals (see Equation 11.3) [15]. The experimental evidence for the formation of hydroxyl radicals on BDD electrodes was reported by Marselli et al. [18] by spin trapping, using electron spin resonance. Recently, Enache and co-authors have shown by DP voltammetry an oxidation peak at 2.1 V versus Ag/AgCl associated with the water discharge process and the electrochemical generation of hydroxyl radicals [19]. Many authors have supposed, on the bases of the poor adsorption ability of the BDD surface, that hydroxyl radicals generated by water oxidation at BDD are quasi-free or very weakly adsorbed on the electrode surface [14]. The
264
MODELING OF ELECTROCHEMICAL PROCESS FOR WATER TREATMENT USING DIAMOND FILMS
oxygen evolution can involve different mechanisms. In particular, two probable mechanisms involve the oxidation of the hydroxyl radical (Equations 11.4 and 11.6) or the coupling of two HO • (Equations 11.5 and 11.6) [20–22]. Note that coupling of HO • can proceed toward the formation of hydrogen peroxide (Equation 11.7), which, at its turn can be oxidized to oxygen (Equation 11.8) [21,22]. Reactions 11.4 and 11.5 can also coexist, but it is not easy, up to present knowledge, to assert what route should predominate. In this context one can consider that recombination of hydroxyl radicals is likely to be more favored on surfaces that present, in contrast from what is expected for BDD, a high active surface sites concentration [22]. On the other hand, the occurring of the recombination reaction at BDD is supported by the fact that Michaud et al. observed low H2 O2 concentrations during HClO4 electrolyses at BDD [21]. H2 O → HO • + H+ + e− HO
+
→O +H +e
•
•
−
2HO → O + H2 O •
2O
•
→ O2
•
(11.3) (11.4) (11.5) (11.6)
2HO → H2 O2
(11.7)
H2 O2 → O2 + 2H+ + 2e−
(11.8)
•
In the presence of organics, hydroxyl radicals are involved in their oxidation as proposed by Feng and Johnson [23], that of course takes place in competition with the oxygen evolution. BDD( • OH)n + RH → BDD + CO2 + H2 O
(11.9)
Furthermore, organics can be directly oxidized at the anodic surface or they can be oxidized by means of other electro-generated reagents such as O3 , H2 O2 , H2 S2 O8 , and so on [11]. Direct anodic oxidation and oxidation by means of hydroxyl radicals, whose main stages occur at the electrode surface, were often classified in literature as “direct processes”, whereas oxidation by means of other electro-generated oxidants, that usually take place in homogeneous phase, are called “indirect processes” [11]. Please consider that, in the case of free hydroxyl radicals, this classification is not so stringent. On the other hand, for the sake of simplicity, all the oxidation routes involving reactions with hydroxyl radicals were often grouped among the “direct processes” [11]. Concerning the “direct processes”, it is useful to observe that anodic oxidation could be potentially performed at BDD for some organics, such as phenol derivatives, at lower potentials with respect to that necessary for oxygen evolution, but the formation of a passive layer at these potentials usually prevents this possibility [7,8,24,25]. Hence, abatement of organics is usually performed in the range of potential of oxygen evolution. In these conditions, no formation of the passivation layer occurs, oxidation of organics can coexist with oxygen evolution [8–10], and both anodic oxidation and oxidation by means of hydroxyl radicals can potentially concur to the abatement of the organics.
11.2 THEORETICAL MODELS
265
Please note that in the following “direct” and “indirect” processes will be studied separately because a very different effect of operative parameters on the performances of the wastewater treatment can occur with these different groups of reactions. Amperostatic electrolyses will be considered, since the galvanostatic mode is general preferred from an applicative point of view.
11.2.2 Oxidation of Organic Pollutants in Water at BDD by Means of Direct Anodic Oxidation or Reaction with Electro-Generated Hydroxyl Radicals (‘‘Direct Processes’’) When the abatement of organic pollutants takes place by means of direct anodic oxidation or reaction with electro-generated hydroxyl radicals (“direct processes”), the oxidation processes arise on the anode surface or in a thin reaction layer adjacent to the electrode surface with a thickness dramatically lower with respect to that of the diffusion layer. Thus, hydroxyl radicals generated at BDD are expected to exist as weakly physical adsorbed species on the anodic surface or as free molecules that can diffuse through a very thin portion of the diffusion layer due to their very high reactivity. It follows that the oxidation process can be considered in these conditions as a surface or a pseudo-surface process [26] that can take place under oxidation reaction control, mass transfer control or mixed kinetic regimes depending on the rate of mass transfer of the pollutant toward the anodic surface in comparison with the oxidation rate. Please note that the process could also be under the kinetical control of adsorption or desorption stages. On the other hand, these stages are usually neglected for the poor adsorption ability of the BDD surface. When the rate of the mass transfer of the pollutant is dramatically lower than that of its anodic oxidation, the concentration of the pollutant at the anodic surface/reaction layer C0 is close to zero and the oxidation process is under mass transfer control. This case arises, for an oxidation process that proceeds up to the total oxidation of the organic pollutant, when the limiting current density ilim = nFkm [RH]b iapp ICEOC (where n is the number of electrons exchanged for the anodic oxidation of RH to carbon dioxide; F is the Faraday constant (96487 C mol−1 ); [RH]b and km are the bulk concentration and the mass transfer coefficient of the organic RH, respectively; iapp is the applied current density; and ICEOC is the instantaneous current efficiency for the oxidation of RH under oxidation reaction control under adopted operative conditions). Conversely, when ilim iapp ICEOC , mass transfer is significantly faster with respect to oxidation rate, C0 is very close to the concentration in the bulk Cb and the process is under reaction oxidation control. When more pollutants are present in the bulk during the electrolysis, one can focus on the chemical oxygen demand (COD) of the solution. In particular, the limiting current density, for a process that proceeds up to the total oxidation of organics, is given by ilim = 4Fkm COD and a mass transfer control will arise if ilim iapp ICEOC (where ICEOC is the average current efficiency for a process under oxidation reaction control and COD is the chemical oxygen demand computed on a molar base). The effect of operative parameters on the performances of the process was recently investigated [5,6,30,31], by considering, for the sake of simplicity, the complete oxidation of an organic pollutant that proceeds in competition with the oxygen evolution with no formation of intermediates with significant concentrations in the bulk. In this case, the instantaneous current efficiency for a process under galvanostatic mode can be rapidly estimated for both mass transfer and oxidation reaction control regimes.
266 •
MODELING OF ELECTROCHEMICAL PROCESS FOR WATER TREATMENT USING DIAMOND FILMS
Under mass transfer control, the current efficiency ICEMT is given by the ratio between the limiting current ilim and the applied current density iapp independently by the oxidation mechanism [5,7,8,30,31]. For [RH]b C ∗ ICEOC , ICE = ICE MT ≈ [RH]b /C ∗ = nFkm [RH]b /iapp (11.10) where C ∗ = iapp /nFkm . It follows that, under mass transfer control, the ICE should depend on the fluidodynamics of the system (trough its effect on km ), on the applied current density and on [RH]b (with a linear dependence on this parameter). It is important to observe that, under these conditions, the performances of the process are readily predictable. Thus, the mass transfer coefficient is readily given by the ratio km = D/δ where the diffusion coefficient D can be often found in literature or can be estimated by electroanalytical experiments or using the Wilke-Chang expression, whereas the thickness of the diffusion layer δ is easily estimated by typical limiting current essays using, as an example, the couple hexacyanoferrate (II)/hexacyanoferrate (III). Hence, it is also possible to predict the organics concentration as a function of the charge or of the time. Indeed, the instantaneous current efficiency is given, by definition, by: ICE = −nFV d[RH]b /dQ
(11.11)
and eliminating the term ICE by Equations 11.10 and 11.11, one easily obtains the relationships reported in Equations 11.12 and 11.13 (where V is the volume, A is the anodic surface, and t and Q are the time and the charge passed, respectively). [RH]b,Q = [RH]b,Q = 0 exp[−Q/(nFVC ∗ )] [RH]b,t = [RH]b,t = 0 exp[−(Akm /V )t] •
(11.12) (11.13)
For a process under the kinetic control of the oxidation reaction, the instantaneous current efficiency ICEOC is determined by the competition between the oxidation of the organic and the evolution of the oxygen [5,30,31,40]: For [RH]b C∗ ICEOC
iRH iRH = iapp iRH + iO2 1 1 = = iO2 [RH]∗ 1+ 1+ iRH [RH]b
ICEOC =
(11.14)
where iRH and iO2 are the current densities involved in the oxidation of the organic and in the oxygen evolution process, respectively. The term [RH]∗ is the value of [RH]b , which gives a current density for the RH oxidation iRH equal to the current density involved for the oxygen evolution reaction iO2 (e.g. the value of [RH]b that gives ICE = 50%) [5]. Please consider that the physical meaning of [RH]* depends on the oxidation route. Thus, if the oxidation of the organic takes place by direct anodic oxidation [RH]* is given by [RH]∗dir = 2r(E )/nk (E ), where k (E ) is the heterogeneous rate constant for the oxidation of RH and r(E ) is the rate of
11.2 THEORETICAL MODELS
267
the solvent oxidation. Otherwise, if the oxidation takes place by means of hydroxyl radicals, [RH]∗HO is given (as an example, considering for the sake of simplicity physically adsorbed hydroxyl radicals) by: [RH]∗OH = 2kor /nkO2
(11.15)
where kO2 (s−1 ) and kor (M−1 s−1 ) are the rate constants of Reactions 11.16 and 11.17, respectively, and n is the number of adsorbed hydroxyl radicals necessary to convert the substrate to carbon dioxide [5,7,30]. BDD( • OH) → BDD + 0.5 O2 + H+ + e−
(11.16)
BDD( • OH) + RH → BDD + H2 O + R •
(11.17)
It is interestingly to observe that [RH]∗dir assumes a constant value with the potential (and applied current density), given by the following relationship, if the transfer coefficients α of the two competitive oxidation routes assume similar values: [RH]∗dir = (2/n)(k /k
◦
RH )exp[(1
− α)F (E
◦
RH
−E
◦
W )/(RT)]
(11.18)
where k is given by the product of the standard rate constant for the oxidation of the solvent and the solvent concentration and E ◦ W and E ◦ RH are the standard potentials for the oxidation of the water and RH, respectively [5,7,30]. Hence, in the case of a direct anodic oxidation process, expression reported in Equation 11.14 can be readily used to predict the effect of some operative parameters such as current density and organic concentration on the performances of the process. A more complex scenario is expected for an indirect process mediated by hydroxyl radicals. In this case, in fact, [RH]∗ is expected to depend on the working potential (e.g., on the applied current density) so that a less easy prediction of the effect of operative parameters on ICE is achievable [5,30]. Anyway, this aspect is of less practical relevance if the kinetic constant of mediated reaction is so high that in any case [RH]∗ is close to zero and ICE under oxidation control is close to 1. In general, it is interesting to observe that according to Equations 11.10 and 11.14, the instantaneous current efficiency of the process is expected to depend on the concentration of the organic pollutant in the bulk [RH]b for both mass transfer and oxidation reaction control. On the other hand, in the case of a mass transfer control, ICE should depend linearly on [RH]b , whereas in the case of an oxidation reaction control, a linear relationship is expected between 1/ICE and 1/[RH]b . Furthermore, if the kinetic constant of the reaction between the organic pollutant and hydroxyl radical is very high, as usually expected for diamond anodes, for a process under oxidation reaction control, the dependence of the ICE by [RH]b can be practically observed only for very low values of both [RH]b and the applied current density (e.g., by working with electrodes characterized by a very large surface area). Please note also that, under oxidation reaction control, the process is expected to be dramatically affected by the nature of both the organic pollutant and of the electrode material through their effect on [RH]* but not by the flow dynamic regime. However, in the case of a mass transfer control, the ICE depends strongly on the flow dynamic regime (trough its effect on km ), slightly on the nature of the organic pollutant (trough the value of the diffusion coefficient) but not significantly on the nature of the anode. It follows
268
MODELING OF ELECTROCHEMICAL PROCESS FOR WATER TREATMENT USING DIAMOND FILMS
that the utilization of boron-doped diamond anodes is expected to affect positively the abatement of organic pollutants in water if the process is under oxidation reaction control but not if a mass transfer control arises. On the other hand, please consider that a mass transfer control is expected when [RH]b C∗ ICEOC . Therefore, if the same pollutant is treated at diamond anode with a high value of ICEOC (e.g., a low value of [RH]*) or at an electrode characterized by a very low value of ICEOC , for the same operative conditions BDD can experience a mass transfer control and the other electrode an oxidation reaction control with a slower rate with respect to that of the mass transfer at BDD. This case, as an example, was observed for the oxidation of oxalic acid in basic conditions at BDD and Ti/IrO2 -Ta2 O5 [6,42]. Thus, the oxidation reaction was so slow at the iridium-based anode that a mass transfer control never took place at this electrode under adopted operative conditions [42]. Let us now discuss the general case of a process whose rate determining step changes during the electrolysis from oxidation reaction control in the first stages to mass transfer control in the last part with a mixed regime between them. In this case, a general expression for the instantaneous current efficiency has to be adopted. In particular, under the previously mentioned conditions, it is easy to show that the following expression applies [5,30,31,40]: ICE =
1 2[RH]∗ 1+ [RH] + ([RH] 2 + 4[RH]∗ [RH]b )0.5
(11.19)
where [RH] = [RH]b − [RH]*−C * and C ∗ = i /nFkm . Theoretical predictions based on Equations 11.10, 11.14, and 11.19 were used, up to now, to predict the effect of operative parameters on the abatement of two quite simple molecules such as oxalic and formic acid. A very good agreement between experimental data and theoretical predictions was observed changing severely the current density, the flow rate, and the initial concentration of the acid (e.g., see Figures 11.1 and 11.2 for the oxidation of oxalic acid). This result appeared rather interesting also considering that the kinetic constant of the reaction between hydroxyl radicals and the organic presents very different values for these two acids. Please note that numerous pollutants can often be present in the water system from the beginning of the electrolysis or as a result of the formation of some intermediates with appreciable concentrations in the bulk. In this case, the modeling of the process has to take in account the contemporaneous presence of various organic pollutants in the solution. This general problem was studied by various groups, including those of Comninellis, Polcaro, Rodrigo, and Scialdone with different approaches. Some of these studies are briefly summarized in the following. 11.2.2.1 The Model of Comninellis and Coauthors Comninellis and coauthors observed that the oxidation of many organics, such as phenol, proceeds at BDD toward the complete incineration with very high current efficiency if no mass transfer limitations arise [7,8,24,25]. On the bases of these results, the authors developed a very simple kinetic model for a batch recirculation system with galvanostatic alimentation based on the assumption that when the oxidation of organics is performed at BDD at high anodic potentials, close to oxygen evolution, the electrochemical incineration of the organic
11.2 THEORETICAL MODELS
269
(a) 0.12
[OA]b(M)
0.10 0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0.00 0
2000
4000 Q(C)
6000
8000
0
2000
4000 Q(C)
6000
8000
0
2000
4000 Q(C)
6000
8000
(b) 0.12 0.10
[OA]b(M)
0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0.00
(c) 0.12 0.10
[OA]b(M)
0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0.00
Figure 11.1 Profile of oxalic acid concentration [OA]b versus charge passed for electrolysis performed at BDD with (a) 17, (b) 39, and (c) 56 mA/cm2 , at different flow rates. Flow rate: 1.7 (), 3.4, (-) 4.9 l/min (•). Amperostatic electrolyses. Theoretical curves (—) obtained by Equation 11.19 with [RH]* = 0.013 M. System solvent supporting electrolyte (SSE): Water, Na2 SO4 , H2 SO4 . Initial oxalic acid concentration: 100 mM. T = 25◦ C. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 30.)
270
MODELING OF ELECTROCHEMICAL PROCESS FOR WATER TREATMENT USING DIAMOND FILMS
(a) 0.20 0.04 0.15 [OA]b(M)
0.02 0.00
0.10
0
5000
10000
15000
0.05
0.00 0
5000 10000 Charge passed (C)
15000
0
0.05
0.15
(b) 1.2 1
ICE
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0
0.1 [OA]b(M)
(c) 5
1/(ICE)
4
3
2
1
0 0
40 ([OA]b)–1(M–1)
80
Figure 11.2 Oxalic acid concentration [OA]b versus (a) charge passed, (b) ICE versus [OA]b , and (c), 1/ICE versus 1/[OA]b . Initial substrate concentration: 0.01 (-), 0.05 (•), 0.1 () and 0.2 M (◦). Flow rate: 4.9 l/min. Current density: 17 mA/cm2 . Amperostatic electrolyses at BDD anode. System solvent supporting electrolyte (SSE): Water, Na2 SO4 , H2 SO4 . T = 25◦ C. Theoretical curves (—) in Figure 2a obtained by Equation 11.19 with [RH]* = 0.013 M. Theoretical curves in Figures 2b and 2c (–) obtained by Equations 11.14 and 11.10 with [RH]* = 0.013 M. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 30.)
11.2 THEORETICAL MODELS
271
compound is a fast reaction and it is controlled by mass transport toward the anode. Particularly, authors assumed that: •
The reservoir volume (V ) is much greater than that of the electrochemical reactor. The electrochemical reactor and the reservoir are perfectly mixed. • The oxidation in the bulk by electro-generated oxidants is not considered. • If iapp < ilim (e.g., if the electrolysis is under current limit contro)l, the current efficiency for the abatement of the organic is 100%. As a consequence, COD decreases linearly with time, as shown by the relationship reported in the following equation (where COD◦ is the initial COD, A is the anodic surface, V is the solution volume, and t is the time). •
iapp A α km A ◦ t = COD 1 − t COD = COD − nFV V ◦
(11.20)
◦ where α = iapp /ilim . • If iapp > ilim (e.g., if the electrolysis is under mass transfer control), secondary reactions (such as oxygen evolution) commence, resulting in a decrease of COD. The current efficiency can be simply estimated as
ICE = ICEMT ≈ ilim /iapp
(11.21)
and, as a consequence, the COD removal follows an exponential trend described by the following equation (where CODcr and tcr are the initial values of COD and time when the process is under mass transfer control from the beginning of the electrolysis or the values of COD and time achieved when iapp = ilim ): 1 − α Akm Akm ◦ (t − tcr ) = α COD exp − t+ COD = CODcr exp − V V α (11.22) It is important to underline the fact that this very simple model does not present any adjustable parameter. Thus, the mass transfer coefficient is readily given by the ratio km = D/δ, where the diffusion coefficient D can be often found in literature or can be estimated by electroanalytical experiments or using the Wilke-Chang expression, whereas the thickness of the diffusion layer δ is easily estimated by typical limiting current essays using, as an example, the couple hexacyanoferrate (II)/hexacyanoferrate (III). Of course, this model is expected to fit with accuracy experimental data when the current efficiency in the absence of mass transfer limitations is close to 1. Furthermore, the model does not describe mixed kinetic regimes or the evolution of the concentrations of different species present in the system. On the other hand, this simple model presents a very good agreement with experimental data for several organic compounds and various operative conditions for the evolution of COD with the time or the charge passed [7,8,14,15,24,25]. (see, as an example, Figures 11.3 and 11.4 for the case of the oxidation of 2-naphtol at acidic pH.) Therefore, it represents a very interesting tool for the prediction of the effect of operative parameters, such as current density, flow rate, and organic concentration, on the “direct” abatement of COD at a BDD anode in a batch recirculation system.
272
MODELING OF ELECTROCHEMICAL PROCESS FOR WATER TREATMENT USING DIAMOND FILMS
Figure 11.3 Influence of the initial 2-naphthol concentration () 9 mM; ( × ) 5 mM; (•) 2 mM on the trends of COD and ICE (inset) during electrolysis, using a BDD anode. Supporting electrolyte: 1 M H2 SO4 ; T = 30◦ C; j = 30 mA cm−2 . The solid lines represent the model prediction. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 8.)
60
1.2 1 0.8 ICE
COD (mol O2m–3)
50 40
0.6 0.4 0.2
30
0 0
2
4
6
8
10
14
16
Q (Ah dm–3)
20 10 0 0
2
4
6
8 10 Q (Ah dm–3)
12
Figure 11.4 Influence of applied current density (•) j = 15 mA cm−2 ; (×) j = 30 mA cm−2 ; () j = 60 mA cm−2 on the trends of COD and ICE (inset) during electrolysis in 1 M H2 SO4 + 5 mM 2naphthol, using a BDD anode. T = 30◦ C. The solid lines represent the model prediction. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 8.)
11.2.2.2 The Theoretical Works of Polcaro and Coauthors Polcaro and coauthors reported a more complex model with the aim of evaluating the trends of the concentrations of the starting pollutant and intermediate products in the stagnant layer and in the bulk [26]. Thus, it has been shown that the incineration of some organics at BDD proceeds trough the formation of intermediates. As an example, the oxidation of
11.2 THEORETICAL MODELS
273
phenol can be represented by the following schematic reaction path: Phenol → Cyclic intermediates → Aliphatic acids → CO2 Furthermore, this model applies also to the case of an oxidation process that gives rise to a current efficiency lower than 100% in the absence of mass transfer limitations. The model was based on the following assumptions: •
Oxidation of pollutants and intermediate compounds takes place by homogeneous chemical reactions with hydroxyl radicals (with first-order kinetic reaction with respect to both organics and hydroxyl radicals concentrations) in the diffusion layer in competition with the chemical deactivation of hydroxyl radicals, which is described by a first-order kinetic reaction not depending on the working potential. • A diffusion-reaction model is used to model the diffusion layer, whereas the bulk of the solution is represented by a stirred-tank reactor. The model required a numerical solution of pertaining equations (mass balance equations in the bulk and in the stagnant layer for the starting pollutant and intermediates and in the diffusion layer for hydroxyl radicals). As a result, authors were able to predict the trend with time of the concentration of different compounds present in the bulk of the solution during the electrolyses, as well as the evolution of the space profile of the species. As an example, the authors compared the theoretical predictions of the model with experimental data for the oxidation of Phenol at BDD. The model was able to predict with a good accuracy the trend with time of the concentrations of phenol and main intermediates (aromatic and aliphatic acids) by changing significantly the current density and the flow dynamic regime, and using one adjustable parameter (the average kinetic constant between hydroxyl radicals and aromatic compounds) [26]. A good agreement between theoretical predictions and experimental data was reported by the authors also in the cases of cyanuric acid and atrazine by using, as an adjustable parameter, the kinetic constant between hydroxyl radicals and the adopted pollutant [26]. As mentioned, the model involved also the calculation of the concentration profiles in the diffusion layer of hydroxyl radicals, pollutants, and intermediates with the time. Quite interestingly, according to this model, hydroxyl radicals diffuse in the stagnant layer for few tens of nanometers. As an example, a thickness of the reaction layer of about 50 nm was computed for a current density of 25 mA/cm2. 11.2.2.3 The Approach Proposed by Rodrigo and Coauthors In order to reduce the mathematic complexity of theoretical models aimed to determine the concentrations of compounds involved in the oxidation process, Rodrigo and coauthors considered some simplifying assumptions. Their model divides the electrochemical reactor into three zones: two are close to the electrodes (electrochemical zones) and a third zone corresponds to the bulk of the solution (chemical zone) that is considered as consecutive stirred-tank reactors [27–29]. Hence, in each zone, the concentration is assumed to depend on the time passed but not on the position. The concentration of each compound in the chemical zone is taken as the value measured experimentally. Mass transport processes between the electrochemical and chemical zones are quantified by assuming that the local exchange rate is proportional to the difference of concentration between the two zones. The authors observe that a number of processes can occur at the electrode
274
MODELING OF ELECTROCHEMICAL PROCESS FOR WATER TREATMENT USING DIAMOND FILMS
surface, and therefore the total current applied is shared among all these processes. The rate of each process is given by ri = (iapp A/F)αielectrode
(11.23)
where αielectrode , which gives the ratio of current density for a particular electrochemical process with respect to the applied current density, is a measure of the relative oxidizability of a compound and αielectrode = 1. In a first version of the model, αielectrode was a function of the oxidizability factors of the compounds present in the system that were computed as adjustable parameters [27]. Later, the authors assumed that the fraction of iapp used in each process depends on the cell potential (Vwork ) and the oxidation (or reduction) potential (Vi ) of each process by the relationship reported below, so that no adjustable parameters were used in the model [28]. αielectrode = (Vwork − Vi )/
(Vwork − Vi )
(11.24)
The model accounted also for the presence of homogeneous oxidation reactions between electro-generated oxidants and organics assuming second-order rate expressions depending on the concentrations of both the oxidant and the organic compound. In the case of phenol and carboxylic acids, no presence in the bulk of oxidants was evaluated with a I2 /I− test [28]. It was therefore concluded that no mediated oxidation processes occurred in the bulk zone. Hence, mediated process, involving oxidation by means of hydroxyl radicals, might occur only in the electrochemical zone and were considered as direct reactions. The model showed a good agreement with a very large set of experimental data obtained for the incineration of various organic compounds, including phenol and different carboxylic acids at BDD in a water solution of Na2 SO4 [28]. In the case of phenol, for example, the model considered the direct oxidation of phenol at the anode to carbon dioxide, through the formation of maleic and oxalic acids as intermediates, and the hydrogen evolution at the cathode (see Figure 11.5). As shown in Figure 11.6, theoretical predictions were in a good agreement with experimental data obtained under a very large range of operative conditions.
11.2.3 Oxidation of Organic Pollutants in Water by Means of Electro-Generated Oxidants (‘‘Indirect Processes’’) Such as Active Chlorine As previously mentioned, electrochemical oxidation of organics can occur also by the action of electro-generated oxidants such as active chlorine, ozone, peroxidisulfuric acid, CeIV , and more. Hence, various researchers included in their model the homogeneous oxidation of organics by means of electro-generated oxidants [10,28,29,40,44]. It is interesting to observe that in indirect processes the oxidation of the organics take place mainly by a homogeneous reaction and a very different effect of operative parameters on the performances of the process can arise with respect to direct ones. Thus, the current efficiency of the process is expected to be determined mainly by the current efficiency due to the electro-chemical formation of oxidants and by the competition between the homogeneous chemical oxidation of organic pollutants and competitive reaction paths
11.2 THEORETICAL MODELS
Anodic reaction zone (a)
anode
1
Phenol*
e–
Cathodic reaction zone (c)
cathode
Phenol
2 3
Maleic*
e–
Chemical reaction zone (b)
275
Maleic
9
Oxalic
Oxalic*
5
H2 e–
4 H2O
6
CO2
CO2* 7 H2O
e–
8 O2
(1) r1 = k·A·([Phenol]b–[Phenol]a) (2)
anode r2 = I a2 F
(3) r3 = k·A·([Maleic]b–[Maleic]a)
(4) r4 = k·A·([Oxalic]b–[Oxalic]a)
(7) r7 = k·A·([CO2]b–[CO2]a)
(5)
anode r5 = I a5 F
I anode (8) r8 = a8 F
(6)
anode r6 = I a 6 F
I cathode (9) r9 = a9 F
Figure 11.5 Sketch representing the processes considered in the modeling of the electro-oxidation of phenol-polluted wastewater using BDD anodes. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 28.)
involving the electro-generated oxidants. In the following, this aspect will be studied in the frame of the oxidation of organics by means of active chlorine. This process was considered as a model case for numerous reasons. First, the effect of chloride ions on the performances of the process has been the object of numerous researches [11] due to the ubiquitous character of Cl− species in waste waters and to the fact that chloride ions can cause an increase in the removal efficiency of organic pollutants for the involvement of active chlorine in the oxidation process. Furthermore, it has been shown that the addition of chloride ions can give rise in some cases to the formation of halogenated intermediates more toxic than the starting compounds [32]. Second, in the presence of Cl− , a quite intriguing change of the effect of some operative parameters on the performances of the process can occur with respect to “direct processes.” When chloride ions are added to a water solution, their oxidation can lead to the formation of chlorine, hypochlorous acid, and/or hypochlorite, depending on the pH (Equations 11.25–11.27) that can oxidize the organics near to the anode or/and in the bulk of the solution (Equation 11.28) in alkaline medium [33–36]. 2Cl− → Cl2 + 2e− Cl2 + H2 O → HOCl + H+ + Cl−
(11.25) (11.26)
35
Concentration (mmol C dm–3)
MODELING OF ELECTROCHEMICAL PROCESS FOR WATER TREATMENT USING DIAMOND FILMS
50
Concentration (mmol C dm–3)
Concentration (mmol C dm–3)
276
(a)
60 50 40 30 20 10 0 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
60
(b)
50 40 30 20 10 0 0
5
Concentration (mmol C dm–3)
Charge (A h dm–3) (c)
80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 0
10
20
30
40
Charge (A h dm )
25
(d)
70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
–3
10 15 20 Charge (A h dm–3)
0
10
20 30 40 50 Charge (A h dm–3)
60
70
Figure 11.6 Results obtained [simulation (lines) versus experimental data (points)] for four experimental runs for the abatent of phenol: () phenol, () maleic acid, () oxalic acid, (-) carbon dioxide. (a) j = 30 mA cm−2, T = 25◦ C, pH = 2. (b) j = 30 mA cm−2 , T = 25◦ C, pH = 12. (c) j = 30 mA cm−2 , T = 25◦ C, pH = 9. (d) j = 60 mA cm−2 , T = 25◦ C, pH = 12. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. 28.)
HOCl ↔ H+ + OCl− Organics + OCl− → intermediates → CO2 + Cl− + H2 O
(11.27) (11.28)
These reactions take place in competition with oxygen evolution, chlorate chemical and electrochemical formation, and cathodic reduction of oxidants in the presence of undivided cells. Amperostatic electrolyses of chlorides gives rise at DSA anodes mainly to hypochlorite and chlorate, whereas at BDD, a more complex mixture—including hypochlorite, chlorine dioxide, and reactive oxygen species—was found [32,37]. The authors supposed that these species could be formed by reaction paths involving the reaction between hydroxyl radicals and active chlorine. It has been proposed [33,38] that adsorbed chloro- and oxychloro-radicals could be also involved in the oxidation mechanism. Furthermore, the possibility that some role could be played by the anodic shift of the oxygen evolution, caused by Cl− ions in the solution, has also been taken in consideration for platinum electrodes [38,39]. It follows that the oxidation of organics performed by means of active chlorine could coexist with the direct oxidation at the electrode surface, the reaction with hydroxyl or oxychloro radicals, or with both these paths. As a consequence, it is not easy for these complex systems to rationalize the effect of operative parameters, on the performances of the process. Furthermore, the coexistence of these oxidative routes makes this process completely different from the chemical oxidation with hypochlorite. This has been confirmed by many experimental works that usually report higher abatement of organic pollutants for the electrochemical oxidation with chlorides with respect to the chemical one with hypochlorite [33–38].
11.2 THEORETICAL MODELS
277
A very simplified theoretical approach was recently presented with the aim to examine how the more important operative parameters are expected to affect the performances of the process both in the absence and in the presence of chlorides [40]. In particular, it was assumed, for the sake of simplicity, that the reaction between the organics and active chlorine takes place mainly in the bulk of the solution. In the absence of chlorides or in the presence of a very high ratio between the concentration of organics and NaCl, main processes should be “direct” ones, such as a direct anodic oxidation or a mediated oxidation by hydroxyl or oxychloro radicals. Hence, the current efficiency for the abatement of the organics should be favored, as previously explained in detail, by (1) high values of the organic concentration; (2) the use of an electrodic material such as BDD, which provides an high oxygen over potential (e.g., a low value of k (E ) and [RH]*); (3) higher flow rates and lower current densities (when the process is not under oxidation reaction control). Let us focus our attention on the opposite case of a sufficiently high ratio between the concentrations of chlorides and organics so that the contribution of the direct processes can be neglected. In this case, the current efficiency should depend mainly on the formation in the bulk of active chlorine ICE AC and on the competition between homogeneous oxidation of organics and chlorate formation [40]. Interestingly, ICEAC has been shown to increase for both BDD and DSA anodes in the presence of higher chloride concentrations and high current density, whereas a more complicated effect of the flow rate is reported. Higher and lower current efficiencies are reported by increasing the flow rate at BDD and DSA, respectively [37,40]. Hence, an opposite effect of current density is expected if the oxidation of organics takes place by a direct anodic process or by an oxidation mediated by active chlorine. Furthermore, BDD presents quite low current efficiency for the active chlorine formation with respect to low oxygen overpotential electrodes such as iridium and ruthenium oxides. Thus, the addition of chlorides in the case of BDD can result, depending on the adopted operative conditions, in a lower abatement of organics. Please note that when the direct process is under mass transfer control, the addition of chlorides is expected to result, if sufficiently high values of current density are imposed, in higher current efficiency for the mediated process. This is because in this case the process is no longer affected negatively by the kinetic limitations imposed by the mass transfer of the pollutant toward the anodic surface. Another important consequence is that BDD, which presents generally drastic higher abatement of organics with respect to DSA, can present, in the presence of suitable amounts of NaCl, a lower abatement with respect to these anodes. Real systems are complicated by the fact that direct and indirect processes could coexist under the same operative conditions. In this case, flow rate, current density, and anodic material should have an opposite effect on homogeneous and heterogeneous oxidation processes so that their overall effect on the performances of the process depends on the relative rates of heterogeneous and homogeneous oxidation reactions. Interestingly, the previously mentioned considerations on the effect of various operative parameters were confirmed by various studies [40,43,47], including one on the electrochemical incineration of oxalic acid at BDD and iridium-based anodes performed in the absence and in the presence of various amounts of NaCl [40]. Thus, a very different influence of the nature of the anodic material, the flow rate, and the current density on the performances of the process was observed in the absence and in the presence of chlorides so that optimization of the two processes required very different operative conditions. In the absence of chlorides, high current efficiency (CE) were obtained at BDD
278
MODELING OF ELECTROCHEMICAL PROCESS FOR WATER TREATMENT USING DIAMOND FILMS
when most of the process was under oxidation reaction kinetic control (i.e., when low current densities and high flow rates were imposed). On the other hand, in the presence of high concentrations of NaCl, higher CE was usually obtained at DSA with respect to BDD and at higher values of current densities. A simple theoretical model for the oxidation of organics in the presence of Cl− was proposed by Szpyrkowicz and Radaelli [44]. These authors described the kinetics of decolorization of simulated textile wastewaters in the presence of Cl− by means of a second-order rate constant: d(abs)/dt = −k (abs)[Cl2 ]
(11.29)
where (abs) is the measured absorbency and [Cl2 ] is the concentration of dissolved chlorine. The model was used by the authors, assuming that the Faradaic efficiency for the chlorine evolution is constant trough the electrolysis, with good results in the frame of the scale up of the oxidation of a textile wastewater at Ti/Pt-Ir anode from a batch to a continuous flow unit [44]. Recently, Anglada, Urtiaga, and Ortiz [45] studied in detail the electro-oxidation of landfill leachate at BDD on a pilot scale. Organic matter and ammonia oxidation were highly influenced by the applied current density value. Interestingly, the abatement of the organic matter was successfully modeled by using the approach proposed by Comninellis and coauthors (see Section 11.2.2) when a current density of 300 and 450 A m−2 was applied [45]. At higher current densities, the oxidation rate was higher than that predicted by the model, thus suggesting the occurrence of a mediated oxidation process by means of active chlorine. The authors also used the model proposed by Szpyrkowicz and Radelli [44] to predict the evolution of ammonium based on the hypothesis that the degradation takes place by a second-order reaction between ammonium and active chlorine. The kinetic model was able to predict the evolution of the concentration of the pollutant as a function of the current density in the range 300–600 A m−2 . At higher current densities a worse correlation between predicted and experimental results occurred. In these conditions a rapid decrease in chloride concentration occurred, thus suggesting that one of the model’s assumptions, the constancy of the Faradaic efficiency for the chlorine evolution during the electrolysis, was not complied [45]. It is relevant to observe that, as stated by Anglada et al. [45,46], many of the theoretical models proposed for the description of the electrochemical oxidation of organics in water still have to be validated for real wastewaters with complex and unknown detailed composition. In this case, in fact, the simultaneous occurrence of many competitive reactions at the anodic surface and in the homogeneous phase can create very complex scenarios that are very difficult to model in a simple and accurate way.
11.3
CONCLUSIONS
In the last years, several studies have proven that conducting diamond thin films can be used as very effective electrodes for the complete oxidation of organic pollutants in water and for water disinfection. The kinetic modeling of the electrochemical abatement of organics in water at diamond anodes has been attempted by many authors with the main objective of predicting the trend of the concentrations of pollutants and intermediates, of chemical oxygen demand, and of current efficiency by changing severely the operative
REFERENCES
279
conditions. The electrochemical oxidation of organic pollutants in water at diamond electrodes can take place by means of hydroxyl radicals generated by water oxidation and by direct anodic oxidation (“direct processes”) or in homogeneous phase by means of electro-generated reagents such as O3 , H2 O2 , H2 S2 O8 , active chlorine, and so on (“indirect processes”). “Direct processes” can be considered as surface or pseudo-surface processes and are strongly affected by the mass transfer rate of the organic pollutants toward the anodic surface. The modeling of these processes has been performed by various research groups, and a very good agreement between experimental data and theoretical predictions was generally reported. In “indirect processes”, the oxidation of the organics involves a homogeneous reaction with electro-generated oxidants, and a quite different effect of operative parameters on the performances of the process can take place with respect to the case of “direct processes”. Thus, in the case of “indirect processes”, the abatement of the organics is expected to depend mainly on the current efficiency due to the electrochemical formation of oxidants and on the competition between homogeneous chemical oxidation of organic pollutants and competitive reaction paths involving the electro-generated oxidants. The oxidation of organics in the presence of active chlorine was, in particular, briefly discussed as a model case.
11.4
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Universit`a di Palermo and Ministero dell’Istruzione, dell’Universit`a e della Ricerca (MIUR) are acknowledged for their financial support.
REFERENCES 1. C. Amatore, “Micro and Macropenomena,” in Organic Electrochemistry (H. Lund, M. Baizer, eds.), Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York, 1991, p. 220. 2. C. Comninellis, Electrochim. Acta 1994, 39 , 1857–1862. 3. O. Simond, V. Schaller, Ch. Comninellis, Electrochim. Acta 1997, 42 , 2009–2012. 4. O. Simond, Ch. Comninellis, Electrochim. Acta 1997, 42 , 2013–2018. 5. O. Scialdone, Electrochim. Acta 2009, 54 , 6140–6147. 6. O. Scialdone, S. Randazzo, A. Galia, G. Filardo, Electrochim. Acta 2009, 54 , 1210–1217. 7. M.A. Rodrigo, P.A. Michaud, I. Duo, M. Pamizza, G. Cerisola, Ch. Comninellis, J. Electrochem. Soc. 2001, 148 , D60–64. 8. M. Panizza, P.A. Michaud, G. Cerisola, Ch. Comninellis, J. Electroanal. Chem. 2001, 507 , 206–214. 9. A.M. Polcaro, S. Palmas, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 1997, 36 , 1791–1798. 10. A.M. Polcaro, M. Mascia, S. Palmas, A. Vacca, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2002, 41 , 2874–2881. 11. C.A. Martinez-Huitle, S. Ferro. Chem. Soc. Rev . 2006, 35 , 1324–1340. 12. O. Scialdone, A. Galia, G. Filardo, Electrochim. Acta 2008, 53 , 7220–7225. 13. B.P. Dash, S. Chaudhari, Water Res. 2005, 39 , 4065–4072. 14. A. Kapalka, G. Foti, Ch. Comninellis, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2008, 38 , 7–16. 15. M. Panizza, G. Cerisola, Electrochim. Acta 2005, 51 , 191–199. 16. R. DeClements, G.M. Swain, T. Dallas, M.W. Holtz, R.D. Herric, J.L. Stickney, Langmuir 1996, 12 , 6578–6586.
280
MODELING OF ELECTROCHEMICAL PROCESS FOR WATER TREATMENT USING DIAMOND FILMS
17. I. Yagi, H. Notsu, T. Kondo, D.A. Tryk, A. Fujishima, J. Electroanal. Chem. 1999, 473 , 173–178. 18. B. Marselli, J. Garcia-Gomez, P.A. Michaud, M.A. Rodrigo, C. Comninellis, J. Electrochem. Soc. 2003, 150 , D79–D83. 19. T.A. Enache, A.M. Chiorces-Paquim, O. Fatibello-Filho, A.M. Oliveira-Brett, Electrochem. Comm. 2009, 11 , 1342–1345. 20. K. Kinoshita, in Electrochemical Oxygen Technology, The Electrochemical Society, New York,Wiley, 1992, chap. 2. 21. P.A. Michaud, M. Panizza, L. Quattara, T. Diaco, G. Foti, Ch. Comninellis, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2003, 33 , 151–154. 22. M.H.P. Santana, L.A.D. Faria, J.F.C. Boodts, Electrochim. Acta 2005, 50 , 2017–2027. 23. J. Feng, D.C. Johnson, J. Electrochem. Soc. 1990, 137 , 507–510. 24. J. Iniesta, P.A. Michaud, M. Panizza, G. Cerisola, A. Aldaz, Ch. Comninellis, Electrochim. Acta 2001, 46 , 3573–3578. 25. F. Montilla, P.A. Michaud, E. Morallon, J.L. Vazquez, Ch. Comninellis, Electrochim. Acta 2002, 47 , 3509–3513. 26. A.M. Polcaro, A. Vacca, S. Palmas, M. Mascia, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2003, 33 , 885–893. 27. P. Canizares, M. Diaz, J.A. Dominguez, J. Garcia-Gomez, M.A. Rodrigo, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2002, 41 , 4187–4194. 28. P. Canizares, J. Garcia-Gomez, J. Lobato, M.A. Rodrigo, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2004, 43 , 1915–1922. 29. P. Canizares, J. Garcia-Gomez, J. Lobato, M.A. Rodrigo, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2004, 43 , 1923–1931. 30. O. Scialdone, A. Galia, C. Guarisco, S. Randazzo, G. Filardo, Electrochim. Acta 2008, 53 , 2095–2108. 31. O. Scialdone, A. Galia, S. Randazzo, in preparation. 32. M. Bergmann, J. Rollin, Catalysis Today 2007, 124 , 198–203. 33. L. Szpyrkowicz, J. Naumaczky, F. Zilio-Grandi, Toxicolog. and Environ. Chem. 1994, 44 , 189–202. 34. C. Comninellis, A. Nerini, J. Appl. Electrochem. 1995, 25 , 23–28. 35. L.C. Chiang, J.E. Chang, T.C. Wen, Water Res. 1995, 29 , 671–678. 36. C.H. Yang, C.C. Lee, T.C. Wen, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2000, 30 , 1043–1051. 37. A.M. Polcaro, A. Vacca, M. Mascia, F. Ferrara, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2008, 38 , 979–984; A.M. Polcaro, A. Vacca, M. Mascia, S. Palmas, J.R. Ruiz, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2009, 39 , 2083–2092. 38. F. Bonfatti, S. Ferro, F. Lavezzo, M. Malacarne, G. Lodi, A. De Battisti, J. Electrochem. Soc. 2000, 147 , 592–596. 39. C.A. Martinez-Huitle, S. Ferro, A. De Battisti, Electrochem. Solid State Lett . 2005, 11 , D35–D39. 40. O. Scialdone, S. Randazzo, A. Galia, G. Silvestri, Water Res. 2009, 43 , 2260–2272. 41. K. Serrano, P.A. Michaud, C. Comninellis, A. Savall, Electrochim. Acta 2002, 48 , 431–436. 42. O. Scialdone, S. Randazzo, A. Galia, G. Filardo, Electrochim. Acta 2009, 54 , 1210–1217. 43. M. Wu, G. Zhao, M. Li, L. Liu, D. Li, J. Hazardous Mat . 2009, 163 , 26–31. 44. L. Szpyrkowicz, M. Radaelli, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2006, 36 , 1151–1156. 45. A. Anglada, A. Urtiaga, I. Ortiz, Environ. Sci. Technol. 2009, 43 , 2035–2040. 46. A. Anglada, A. Urtiaga, I. Ortiz, J. Chem. Technol. Biotechnol . 2009, 84 , 1747–1755. 47. M. Zhou, H. S¨arkk¨a, M. Sillanp¨aa¨ , Separ. Purif. Techn. 2011, 78 , 290–297.
12 Production of Strong Oxidizing Substances with BDD Anodes Ana S´anchez-Carretero, Cristina S´aez, Pablo Canizares, and ˜ Manuel A. Rodrigo
12.1
ELECTROLYSES WITH CONDUCTIVE-DIAMOND ANODES
From the late nineties of the twentieth century to present, applications of conductive diamond surfaces in electrochemistry have grown significantly. One of these applications is their use as anodes in electrochemical wastewater treatment processes, where these anodes have led to very powerful oxidation processes, with high efficiencies in the removal of organic pollution. During the characterization of these processes, there have been reports about the significant action of mediated electro-oxidation in the achievement of good results, and the role of many particular oxidants has been described. In particular, the role of hydroxyl radical has been established to be very relevant. Its occurrence during diamond electrolyses of aqueous wastes was demonstrated by Marselli et al. [1], and later works have confirmed this occurrence with very different observations. This allowed classifying conductivediamond electrochemical oxidation (CDEO) of wastewaters as an advanced oxidation process (AOP). In this context, one of the more illustrative observations [2,3] about the role of hydroxyl radicals in wastewater treatment compares results of the electrolyses of phenol working at anodic potentials below and over the necessary amounts for water oxidation (around 2.5–2.7 V versus NHE). In this way, Figure 12.1 shows a comparison of the electrochemical windows of Pt and BDD electrodes and also summarizes the anodic Synthetic Diamond Films: Preparation, Electrochemistry, Characterization, and Applications, First Edition. Edited by Enric Brillas and Carlos Alberto Mart´ınez-Huitle. © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Published 2011 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
281
282
PRODUCTION OF STRONG OXIDIZING SUBSTANCES WITH BDD ANODES
Current density(A m–2)
Anodic potential (V) vs. SCE
20
2.0
65
2.2
90
2.5
155
3.5
195
4.1
0.04 Thermodynamics
0.03
Pt
j (A cm–2)
0.02
DDB
0.01 0
–0.01 –0.02
–2.0
–1.0
0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
E (V) vs. NHE
–0.03 Figure 12.1 Experimental methodology to demonstrate the role of hydroxyl radicals in CDEO process. (Adapted from Ref. 3.) See color insert.
potential measurement during the conductive-diamond phenol oxidation using different current densities. Figure 12.2 shows how the electrolyses of phenol solutions at potentials below water electrolyses (and hence without formation of hydroxyl radicals) lead to the formation of significant amount of intermediates (aromatic and aliphatic). Electrolyses at potentials higher than this value lead to the formation of negligible intermediates and to high efficient processes, suggesting that hydroxyl radicals improve the oxidation conditions and lead to very strong oxidation conditions. However, the better performance of conductive-diamond electrolyses over other advanced oxidation processes (those based on the production and use of hydroxyl radicals), and also over other electrolytic processes, indicates that in addition to direct oxidation and to hydroxyl radicals-mediated oxidation, there should be many other oxidants with a significant role in the destruction of organics during electrochemical wastewater oxidation with diamond anodes. In this context, the roles of chlorine [4–7], sulphates [8–10], phosphates [11,12], and many other types of salts on the electrochemical destruction of organics have been extensively studied in the literature. According to this fact, Figure 12.3 summarizes the main mechanism proposed to explain the good results of CDEO in the oxidation of organic pollutants during wastewater treatment. From this figure, it seems clear that the electrolyses of water solutions of different salts can lead to the formation of oxidants, and if proper conditions are found, oxidants produced can be separated and stored for later use (see Figure 12.4). This presence of oxidant species has encouraged many research groups to study the synthesis of particulate oxidants and to isolate them as valuable products. This work is intended to review some of these processes as examples of the significant applications of CDEO in the production of high-value oxidants. To do this, the
350
1200
300
1000
250
COD/g m–3
TOC(g m–3)
12.2 PRODUCTION AND STORAGE OF OXIDIZING SUBSTANCES: EXPERIMENTAL SETUPS
200 150 100
800 600 400 200
50
0
0 0
500
1000
1500
0
2000
Time(min)
500
1000 1500 Time(min)
2000
350 Carboxylic acids/g Cm–3
70 Aromatics(g Cm–3)
283
60 50 40 30 20 10
300 250 200 150 100 50 0
0 0
10
20 30 Q (kAh m–3)
40
50
0
20 40 Q (kAh m–3)
60
Figure 12.2 Results of the electrolyses of phenol solutions at different anodic potentials (C0 : 6.4 mM phenol; pH 7; T:25◦ C). (+) 2.0 V versus NHE, (◦) 2.2 V versus NHE, () 2.5 V versus NHE, () 3.5 versus NHE, () 4.1 V versus NHE. (Adapted from Ref. 2.)
production of hydroxyl radicals and more stable oxidants (peroxosalts and peroxoacids, ferrates, and halogen oxoanions) are going to be described. 12.2 PRODUCTION AND STORAGE OF OXIDIZING SUBSTANCES: EXPERIMENTAL SETUPS Prior to the description of processes that produce oxidants, it is necessary to take into account that contrary to the electro-oxidation of wastewaters, the synthesis of oxidants should be carried out in a double-compartment electrochemical flow cell in which anodic and cathodic compartments are separated by means of an ionic exchange membrane. This avoids the cathodic reduction of oxidants, and hence increases significantly the efficiency of the process. Usually, the ionic membrane is a cathionic one, because many oxidants are anionic species, and this allows storing the produced oxidants in the anodic compartment. Figure 12.5 illustrates with an example (obtained during the electrolytic production of perphosphates with boron-doped diamond anodes) the improvement obtained in the production of oxidants with the use of double compartment cells. At this point, it is important to be reminded that the use of double compartment cells in the destruction of the organic pollutants contained in wastewaters is not necessary because most reactions are irreversible. The separation of the anionic and cationic compartments only leads to an increase in the cell potential, and consequently in the operation cost, without any clear improvement in the treatment results.
284
PRODUCTION OF STRONG OXIDIZING SUBSTANCES WITH BDD ANODES
HYDROXYL RADICALS MEDIATED ELECTROLYSES
Anode DIRECT ELECTROLYSES
Direct
Si
Si e–
Si+1
With oxidants produced from saltsas mediators
Si+1
Mred-Mox
Si
Mred
2SO42– → S2O82–
H2O e–
Si+1
Mox
2PO43– → P2O84– Cl– → ClO–
OH· With ozone as mediator
O2
Si
2H+ + O2 Oxygen evolution
O3
Mred
H2O
Si
e–
Mox
Si+1
H2O2
Si+1 With hydrogen Si peroxide as mediator
Si+1
Mediated electrolyses with oxidants produced from salts contained in the wastewater Figure 12.3 Main mechanisms for the electrolyses with conductive-diamond anodes of wastewaters polluted with organics.
Another important point to be considered in the production of oxidants is their stability. Light, temperature, and pH use have a very significant influence on this stability, which is usually favored at low temperature, dark, and extreme pHs. An example of the huge influence of these parameters in the stability of oxidants is shown in Figure 12.6, in which the decomposition rate of peroxophosphates is shown as a function of the pH and temperature. For this reason, a typical setup to produce oxidants with diamond anodes should include a cryostat device to control temperature, a pH control device, and dark glass in tubes and storage tanks. With such requirements, an example of a complete setup to produce oxidants with conductive-diamond anodes electrolyses is shown in Figure 12.7. 12.3 PRODUCTION OF HYDROXYL RADICALS WITH CONDUCTIVE-DIAMOND ANODES Production of hydroxyl radicals during conductive-diamond electrolysis of aqueous wastes was first demonstrated by Marselli and co-workers [1] using selective reactions of hydroxyl radicals. This was a very significant work because it was the first
12.3 PRODUCTION OF HYDROXYL RADICALS WITH CONDUCTIVE-DIAMOND ANODES
285
Anode
Mred H2O
Mred-Mox
e–
Mox 2SO42– → S2O82–
OH·
2PO43– → P2O84–
O2
Cl– → ClO–
2H+ + O2 Oxygen evolution
O3 H2O
Mred e–
H2O2
Mox
Figure 12.4 anodes.
Mechanisms for the production of oxidants with electrolyses with conductive-diamond
Oxidants(mmol) P2O84–
300
Double-compartment electrochemical flow cell
250 200 150 100
Single-compartment electrochemical flow cell
50 0 0
50
100
150
200
250
300
Time(min)
Figure 12.5 Effect of cell compartments on the efficiency of the production of oxidants by electrolysis with conductive diamond anodes. (C0 : 1 M K3 PO4 ; pH 12.5; T: 25◦ C; j: 1250 A m−2 ).
286
PRODUCTION OF STRONG OXIDIZING SUBSTANCES WITH BDD ANODES
pH Decomposition rate(mol (1 min)–1)
1.00E–05 0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
1.00E–06
1.00E–07 Figure 12.6 Effect of temperature and pH on the decomposition rate of peroxophosphates. (C0 : 1 M HK3 PO4 ; j: 64 A m−2 ). (+) 35◦ C, () 22◦ C, () 10◦ C. (Reprinted from Ref. 36.)
Power supply V
A
catholyte
anolyte +
–
Electrochemical cell
Membrane Anode (BDD)
Out
In
Cathode (AISI 304)
Out
In
Figure 12.7 Typical setup to produce oxidants with CDEO technology. See color insert.
12.3 PRODUCTION OF HYDROXYL RADICALS WITH CONDUCTIVE-DIAMOND ANODES
287
demonstration that conductive-diamond electrochemical oxidation belongs to the group of the advanced oxidation technologies. Figure 12.8 summarizes graphically the two main findings of the work: the selective formation of DMPO and the selective hydroxylation of salicylic acid. The selective oxidation of 5,5-dimethyl-1-pyrroline-N-oxide (DMPO) involves trapping the hydroxyl radicals by an addition reaction (spin trapping) to produce a more stable radical spin adduct. The anodic oxidation of salicylic acid at the BDD anode leads to the formation of two particular dihydroxylated products, 2,3- and 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acids, just the same products formed by Fenton reaction. After that, many other works have supported this achievement with different observations that indicate the significance of hydroxyl radicals in the electrolyses with conductive diamond. The main drawback of hydroxyl radical is their small stability, which makes its storage impossible and even makes their detection very difficult (average lifetime lower than 200 μs [13]). However, the occurrence of hydroxyl radicals explains the production of many more stable oxidants, particularly two relevant oxidants: ozone and hydrogen peroxide. Thus, although many other technologies can provide for ozone or hydrogen peroxide in a more efficient way, there are many works in literature in which the production of both oxidants is obtained with conductive-diamond electrolyses. As it has been describe previously, hydroxyl radicals are produced during conductivediamond electrolyses of aqueous solutions. These radicals decompose following a complex system of reactions in which ozone [14] and hydrogen peroxide [14] can be intermediates or final products. In literature, it is reported that in absence of organic compounds, hydroxyl radicals can react with each other to form hydrogen peroxide from Reaction (12.1) [15]. In fact, Michaud et al. [16] observed the generation of hydrogen peroxide during the electrolysis with BDD anodes of HClO4 solutions. In addition, it is reported that electro-generated hydrogen peroxide can be further oxidized to oxygen either by its direct discharge on the
Figure 12.8 Demonstration of the occurrence of hydroxyl radicals during CDEO.
288
PRODUCTION OF STRONG OXIDIZING SUBSTANCES WITH BDD ANODES
electrode surface by Reaction (12.2) or by hydroxyl radical-mediated Reaction (12.3). •
OH · + • OH· → H2 O2 +
H2 O2 → O2 + 2H + 2e
(12.1) −
H2 O2 + • OH· → O2 + 2H2 O
12.4
(12.2) (12.3)
SYNTHESIS OF PEROXOACIDS AND PEROXOSALTS
Peroxoacids and peroxosalts are in a group of oxidants characterized by the presence of a group –O–O– in the molecules. Typically, these species come by the substitution of a group –OH by a –O–OH in oxoacids or oxosalts of the groups IV, V, and VI of the periodic table. Typical examples include peroxocarbonates, peroxonitrates, peroxosulphates, and peroxophosphates, although the last two are more important because of their actual and potential applications. The efficiency in the production of these products is high enough to study commercial applications; consequently, many applications have been proposed for these species. The main use of peroxosulphuric acids is as an initiator in polymerization processes (olefins, vinyl chloride, styrene-butadiene, vinyl acetate, acrylic ester). Its use as a reagent in the etching of printed circuit boards and in the removal of photo resists are also important. Other applications concern dyes oxidation, whitening fibers, promotion for radical polymerization, total organic compound measurements, and so on. Peroxophosphates have a wide variety of applications in areas such as oxidizing agents in organic synthesis [17,18] cosmetics [19,20], agriculture [21], wastewater treatment [22], and also as bleaching agents in the detergent industry [23,24]. Due to its similar properties, peroxodiphosphate can also be used in other processes as a substitute of peroxodisulphate. In these later uses, peroxodiphosphate has an important advantage: It is a more environmental-friendly reagent because its reduction product (phosphate) can be easily and economically removed from aqueous wastes that the reduction product of persulphates (sulphates). Electrolyses with conductive-diamond anodes have shown to be effective in the production of these species. In the following subsections, some details about the electrolytic production with diamond anodes of peroxodisulphuric acid, monoperoxophosphoric acid, and peroxodiphosphate are going to be described. 12.4.1
Peroxosulphuric Acids
Peroxosulphuric acids can be produced by electrolytic oxidation of sulphuric acid solutions. Two different species are included in this group: peroxomonosulphuric and peroxodisulphuric acid (Figure 12.9). They both have a very high reduction potential (1.81 and 2.08 V, respectively). Peroxodisulphuric acid is more stable than peroxomonosulphuric acid, but it can also suffer thermal decomposition giving to the generation peroxomonosulphuric acid and also hydrogen peroxide. The process is more significant at temperatures higher than 50◦ C, but it can be observed at any range of temperatures, and hence mixtures of both acids are typically encountered in commercial products in which the dimmer is the primary species.
12.4 SYNTHESIS OF PEROXOACIDS AND PEROXOSALTS
O HO
S O OH
O Monoperoxosulphuric acid
O
289
O
HO S O O S OH O O Peroxodisulphuric acid
Figure 12.9 Peroxosulphuric acids.
Traditionally, the synthesis of peroxosulphuric acids have been carried out by electrolyses of sulphuric acid by Reaction (12.4) with noble metal-coated anodes such as platinized, titanium, tantalum, or niobium [25]. 2H2 SO4 → H2 S2 O8 + 2e−
(12.4)
Efficiency of the process was found to depend strongly on the electrode material selected, and particularly on the high overvoltage value for oxygen evolution reaction provided by the anode material. In this context, the use of conductive-diamond electrodes was first proposed by Gandini et al. [26] and by Michaud et al. [27] in 2000, being one of the first electrochemical applications proposed for the anodes of conductive diamond. Figure 12.10 shows the results of the electrolyses with diamond electrodes of sulphuric acid solutions. As it can be observed, the production of significant concentrations of peroxosulphuric acids is obtained, and the efficiency is high enough to be used commercially. During the batch electrosynthesis, the oxidant concentration increases with the specific charge until a constant value is achieved, and current efficiency decreases continuously. This behavior could be explained in terms of mass transfer limitations (in the batch system studied, the concentration of reactant decreases continuously) or, most likely, some sort of chemical or electrochemical destruction of the oxidants formed, which promotes the concentration of a formed product. Electrolytic production of peroxosulphuric acids was found to depend significantly on the concentration of raw sulphuric acid, temperature, and current density. The effect of these parameters is shown in Figures 12.11 and 12.12, respectively. The production of peroxosulphuric acids and the efficiency of the processes increase with the concentration of raw H2 SO4 , with low temperatures and with high current densities. The influence of concentration is difficult to explain although it is as expected: The higher the concentration of raw materials, the higher the concentration of product. Preliminarily, it could be explained by mass transfer controlling mechanisms. However, concentration of sulphuric acid does not become small in any case, and hence some sort of electrochemical decomposition of peroxosulphuric acid should be considered to explain the effect of concentration. This also has to be related to the stabilization of the concentration of peroxosulphuric acids during batch electrolysis, and the plateau range of current charge could indicate the zone in which the production rate is equal to the decomposition rate. The influence of temperature is easier to explain. It is related with the thermal stability of peroxosulphuric acids, which are known to decompose with temperature to yield
290
PRODUCTION OF STRONG OXIDIZING SUBSTANCES WITH BDD ANODES
Oxidants(mmol H2S2O8)
40
30
20
10
0 0
20
40
60
80
100
Q (Ah dm–3)
Current efficiency(%)
40
30
20
10
0 0
20
40 60 Q (Ah dm–3)
80
100
Figure 12.10 Variation of the oxidants () and of current efficicency () with the specific electrical charge passed in the electrosynthesis of peroxosulphuric acids (C0 : 2 M H2 SO4 ; T: 10◦ C; j: 1250 A m−2 ).
sulphuric acid and hydrogen peroxide according to the mechanisms proposed in Reactions (12.5) to (12.7) [28]. S2 O8 2− + H2 O → 2 SO4 2− + 2H+ + 1/2O2
(12.5)
2− + S2 O8 2− + H2 O → SO2− 5 + SO4 + 2H
(12.6)
SO5 2− + H2 O → H2 O2 + SO4 2−
(12.7)
The influence of current density is the more interesting fact in the production of peroxosulphuric acids: There are two different behaviors as a function of the current density. Current densities higher than 1100 A m−2 lead to a more efficient process. Initially, this observation could be related to the massive formation of hydroxyl radicals in the reaction media, which complements the direct electrochemical formation of peroxosulphuric acid
12.4 SYNTHESIS OF PEROXOACIDS AND PEROXOSALTS
291
Oxidants(mmol H2S2O8 dm–3)
30 25 20 15 10 5 0 0
0.5 1 1.5 Concentration raw H2SO4(M)
2
Figure 12.11 Effect of the concentration of raw sulphuric acid on the production of peroxosulphuric acids for a specific current charge of 40 Ah dm−3 . ( j: 1250 A m−2 , T: 10◦ C).
Oxidants(mmol H2S2O8 dm–3)
30 25 20 15 10 5 0 0
10
20 30 Temperature(°C)
40
50
Oxidants(mmol H2S2O8 dm–3)
30 25 20 15 10 5 0 0
500
1000 1500 Current density(A m–2)
2000
Figure 12.12 Effect of the operation conditions on the production of peroxosulphuric acids for a current charge of 40 A h dm−3 . (C0 : 1 M H2 SO4 , pH 2).
292
PRODUCTION OF STRONG OXIDIZING SUBSTANCES WITH BDD ANODES
from Reactions (12.8) to (12.10). As it is going to state with other oxidants, current densities around 1100 A m−2 correspond to anodic potentials for water electrolysis in the experimental setup used. HSO4 − + • OH → SO4 − • + H2 O SO4
2−
+ OH → SO4 •
−•
+ H3 O
(12.8)
+
(12.9)
SO4 − • + SO4 − • → S2 O8 2− 12.4.2
(12.10)
Peroxodiphosphate Salts
Peroxophosphates chemistry is similar than that of persulphates, although peroxophosphates are less known because their synthesis methods were not very efficient, and they usually led to unpure species, but contaminated with some of the additives dosed to increase the efficiency of the production process. Similar to peroxosulphuric acid chemistry, two different species can be found: peroxomonophosphate and peroxodiphosphate salts (see Figure 12.13). Peroxomonophosphate is stable at acid pH, whereas peroxodiphosphate stability is higher at basic pH. Both are powerful oxidants, being their oxidation potentials are similar to those of persulphates (2.07 V peroxodiphosphate versus 2.08 V persulphates). Typically, potassium peroxodiphosphate, K4 P2 O8 , is obtained by electrolysis on platinum electrodes at alkaline conditions of potassium phosphate solutions containing some reagents [29], mainly fluoride or thiocianate. These reagents are primarily added to promote the blockage of oxygen evolution sites [30] of the anode in the synthesis process. Consequently, the direct oxidation of phosphate to peroxodiphosphate is favored over the water oxidation process and higher current efficiencies are obtained. However, some of the uses of peroxodiphosphates can be affected by the impurities. Likewise, some of the reagents can be highly corrosive to platinum and others can be toxic. Thus, in order to obtain impurities-free peroxodiphosphate, extensive purification is required [31]. This greatly increases the manufacturing costs. The synthesis of K4 P2 O8 can also be carried out with platinum without using any additives, but in these cases low current efficiencies are obtained [32]. Figure 12.14 shows the production of peroxodiphosphate by electrolysis with conductive-diamond of K3 PO4 in alkaline conditions (pH 12.5; T: 25◦ C; j: 1250 A m−2 ) [33]. As it can be observed, the process results are surprising. Huge conversions are obtained with very good efficiencies. In addition, peroxodiphosphate can be precipitated and separated from the reaction media simply by the addition of methanol to the electrolyzed solution. It can also be observed that the rate of generation of peroxodiphosphate decreases progressively during a batch process. This behavior (just the same that was observed in the electrochemical production of peroxosulphuric acids OH O P O OH OH Monoperoxophosphoric acid
OK
OK
O P O O P O OK
OK
Potassium peroxodiphosphate
Figure 12.13 Peroxophosphoric acids and salts.
12.4 SYNTHESIS OF PEROXOACIDS AND PEROXOSALTS
293
100
Conversion(%)
80 60 40 20 0 0
30
60
90
120
150
180
210
Q (Ah dm–3)
Current efficiencies(%)
100
80
60
40
20
0 0
30
60
90
120
150
180
210
Q (Ah dm–3) Figure 12.14 Variation of the conversion and of the current efficiency with the specific electrical charge passed in the electrosynthesis of peroxodiphosphate (C0 : 1 M K3 PO4 ; pH 12.5; T: 25◦ C; j: 1250 A m−2 ). (Reprinted from Ref. 33.)
with diamond anodes) is justified in terms of a progressive decrease in the efficiency of the process. This continuous decrease can be due to mass transfer limitations or some sort of electrochemical destruction of the oxidants formed. In this case, the high conversions obtained and the high stability of peroxodiphosphate suggests that mass transfer limits the process. Figure 12.15 shows the influence of the raw material used to produce peroxodiphosphate, particularly the concentration of potassium phosphate and the pH. As expected, process efficiencies increase with the concentration of raw phosphate in the solution to be electrolyzed and hence for the same current charge passed the production of peroxodiphosphate increases with the initial concentration of phosphates. However, on a few occasions it was observed that electrolyses of solutions with very high concentrations of K3 PO4 seemed to damage to the diamond surface and small corrosion circles appeared on the surface of the diamond after the treatment. This problem never appeared
294
PRODUCTION OF STRONG OXIDIZING SUBSTANCES WITH BDD ANODES
90 80
Conversion(%)
70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 0
1 Concentration of raw potassium phosphate/M
2
90 80 Conversion(%)
70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 8
9
10
11 pH
12
13
14
Figure 12.15 Effect of the characteristic of the raw materials on the electrosynthesis of peroxodiphosphate at an electrical charge passed of 130 Ah dm−3 (T: 25◦ C; j: 1250 A m−2 ). (Reprinted from Ref. 33.)
when working with initial concentration of 1 M K3 PO4 ; hence, this concentration should be recommended to warrant good results, and to protect the anodic surface. Likewise, pH influences greatly in the process performance and only good yields are obtained in strongly alkaline solutions. Optimum operation pH was 12.5—the same that literature indicates is the maximum stability of peroxodiphosphate. Figure 12.16 shows the effect of the main operation parameters (temperature and current density) on the efficiency of the process. Temperatures higher than 25◦ C lead to low conversions, and thus, to low current efficiencies. The thermal decomposition of peroxodiphosphate to give pyrophosphate and oxygen from Reaction (12.11) might justify the observed decrease, although the complex chemistry of the system needs more chemical studies to clarify this point. P2 O8 4− → P2 O7 4− + 1/2O2
(12.11)
12.4 SYNTHESIS OF PEROXOACIDS AND PEROXOSALTS
295
80 70
Conversion(%)
60 50 40 30 20 10 0 10
15
20
25 30 Temperature(°C)
35
40
45
100
Conversion(%)
80 60
40 20
0 0
50
100
150
200
250
j(mA cm–2) Figure 12.16 Effect of the operation conditions on the electrosynthesis of peroxodiphosphate with diamond anodes at an electrical charge passed of 80 Ah dm−3 (C0 : 1 M K3 PO4 ; pH 12.5). (Reprinted from Refs. 33,41.)
The influence of the current density is the same as that observed for peroxosulphuric acids. It can be seen that the conversion increases continuously with the specific charge passed, and that for a given current charge passed not a continuous change is obtained as a function of the current density, but only two limit behaviors can be discerned. For current densities below 1000 A m−2 maximum conversions do not exceed 30%, whereas for higher current densities, conversions over 70% are obtained. The abrupt change in the efficiency may be related to the mechanisms of peroxodiphosphate formation on BDD surfaces (see Figure 12.17). Thus, it is proposed [30] that peroxodiphosphate can be formed by direct electrooxidation from Reaction (12.12) on the surface of electrodes such as platinum. 2PO4 3− → P2 O8 4− + 2e−
(12.12)
296
PRODUCTION OF STRONG OXIDIZING SUBSTANCES WITH BDD ANODES
e–
PO4–3
anode
(PO4–2)• (PO4–2)• e–
H2O OH
Direct oxidation P2O8
–4
PO4–3 (PO4–2)•
(PO4–2)•
P2O8–4
OH mediated oxidation
Figure 12.17 Mechanism for the production of peroxodiphosphate with diamond anodes.
However, the higher efficiencies obtained with BDD anodes can be due to the presence of hydroxyl radicals. It is reported [1] that large quantities of these radicals are formed during electrolyses of aqueous solutions. These radicals can combine with phosphate ions and form PO4 2− • radicals [30]. These later radicals can oxidize other compounds in a region close to the anode surface (e.g., water peroxide to oxygen), or they can combine between them to form peroxodiphosphate or with hydroxyl radicals to form peroxomonophosphate. This can justify the higher efficiencies obtained in the electrosynthesis of these compounds when using BDD as anode materials, as these anodes combine both direct and hydroxyl-mediated oxidation processes. Conversely, this complex mechanism might justify the abrupt change in the efficiencies by the promotion of one or the two mechanisms in the electrochemical oxidation. Nevertheless, further research should be done in order to clarify this point. 12.4.3
Monoperoxophosphoric Acid
The synthesis of peroxomonophosphoric acid (H3 PO5 ) is usually based on highly exothermic chemical reactions, which, as a major drawback, led to the rapid decomposition of the peroxo-compounds generated and consequently to a low efficiency in the production of monoperoxophosphoric acids. Several improvements, such as the addition of inert diluents, have been proposed [34], but the low reproducibility of the results limits their use. For this reason, the hydrolysis of peroxodiphosphate salts in very acidic conditions appeared as one of the best synthesis method of peroxomonophosphoric acid [35]. However, the requirement of powerful reagents (peroxodiphosphate and perchloric acid or hydrogen peroxide), and its large manufacturing costs have limited its commercial application. In this context, the direct electrochemical production of monoperoxophosphoric acid using conductive-diamond electrodes can become in an important way of manufacturing this product. Figure 12.18 shows the results of batch electrolyses with conductive diamond of phosphoric acid [36]. As shown, monoperoxophosphoric acid is formed. As in the synthesis of other compounds, oxidant concentration increases to achieve a plateau. This plateau value results from the compensation of the rate of formation of
12.4 SYNTHESIS OF PEROXOACIDS AND PEROXOSALTS
297
4.5
Oxidants(mmol PO53–)
4 3.5 3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 0
20
0
20
40 Q (Ah dm–3)
60
80
4.5 4
Efficiency(%)
3.5 3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 40 Q (Ah dm–3)
60
80
Figure 12.18 Variation of the monoperoxophosphoric acid concentration and current efficiencies with electrical charge passed in the electrolysis of phosphoric acid (C0 : 1 M H3 PO4 ; pH 1.2; T: 13◦ C; j: 64 A m−2 ). (Reprinted from Ref. 36.)
oxidant and its decomposition rate. The results obtained exceed those obtained with other methods. However, the efficiency and the amount of oxidant generated are significantly smaller than the production of peroxodiphosphates salts using electrolyses of alkaline potassium phosphate. In spite of that, the efficiencies are high enough to suggest that this method could be a promising alternative to acidification of peroxodiphosphate solutions. Figure 12.19 shows the influence of the raw phosphoric acid (concentration and pH of the solution) on the production of monoperoxophosphoric acid for a particular electrical current charge passed. With respect to the H3 PO4 concentration, the amount of oxidant obtained is largely influenced by the concentration of the solute. The quantity of peroxomonophosphate increases significantly with the amount of H2 PO4 − ions available to be oxidized until achieving a given value (around 1 M H3 PO4 ). and then a decrease in the amount of peroxomonophosphate produced is observed. The optimum concentration for the peroxomonophosphate synthesis with BDD anodes in the operating conditions used in this work is 1 M H3 PO4 .
298
PRODUCTION OF STRONG OXIDIZING SUBSTANCES WITH BDD ANODES
Oxidants(mmol PO53–)
1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
5
6
Initial concentration(mol dm–3)
Oxidants(mmol PO53–)
5 4 3 2 1 0 0
1
2
3
4
pH Figure 12.19 Amount of oxidant generated in the electrosynthesis of peroxomonophosphate as a function of the initial concentration of H3 PO4 at an electrical charge passed of 1.5 Ah dm−3 (pH 5; T: 13◦ C; j: 20 A m−2 ). (Reprinted from Ref. 36.)
This unexpected behavior has to be explained in terms of the hydroxyl radical’s role in the formation of monoperoxophosphoric acid. Thus, hydroxyl radicals can contribute to the generation of H2 PO4• . This radical can be produced by direct electrolyses from Reaction (12.13) on the electrode surface or by the action of hydroxyl radicals from Reaction (12.14) in the nearest of the electrode. Moreover, the presence of hydroxyl radicals is also needed to promote the generation of peroxomonophosphoric acid by Reaction (12.15). As a result, an increment of the initial concentration of phosphate is not enough to ensure the generation of higher amount of oxidant generated, but the coexistence of both radical reagents is required. H2 PO4 − → (H2 PO4 ) • + e−
(12.13)
H2 PO4 − + • OH· → (H2 PO4 ) • + OH−
(12.14) −1 −1
(H2 PO4 ) + OH → H3 PO5 k = 4 · 10 L mol s •
•
9
(12.15)
12.4 SYNTHESIS OF PEROXOACIDS AND PEROXOSALTS
299
Conversely, the pH seems not to have a strong influence on the results, and within the range of 1 to 5 almost no changes are observed. This is important because due to the acid-base equilibrium given by Reactions (12.16) to (12.18), the hydrogenphosphoric anion can also be precursor of the formation of monoperoxophosphoric acid by Reaction (12.19). H3 PO4 ↔ H2 PO4 − + H+
pKa = 2.14
(12.16)
H2 PO4 − ↔ HPO4 2− + H+
pKa = 6.86
(12.17)
HPO4 2− ↔ PO4 3− + H+
pKa = 12.4
(12.18)
HPO4 2− → (HPO4 − ) • + e−
(12.19)
Figure 12.20 shows the influence of the operation conditions (temperature and current density) on the process at particular current charge passed. As it can be observed, the
Oxidants(mmol PO53–)
4
3
2
1
0 0
5
10
15 20 Temperature(°C)
25
30
35
Oxidants(mmol PO53–)
5
4 3
2 1 0 0
300
600
900
1200
1500
Current density(Am−2)
Figure 12.20 Amount of oxidant generated in the electrosynthesis of peroxomonophosphate as a function of the temperature at an electrical charge passed of 10 Ah dm−3 (1 M H3 PO4 ; pH 5; j: 64 A m−2 ). (Reprinted from Refs. 36,41.)
300
PRODUCTION OF STRONG OXIDIZING SUBSTANCES WITH BDD ANODES
conversion of phosphoric acid to monoperoxophosphoric acid shows a marked dependence with this operating parameter. The higher the temperature, the lower the oxidant concentrations obtained at the steady state. The influence of the current density is just as reported for the oxidants previously described in this chapter. Two significantly different types of behavior can be discerned. At low current densities, a smaller efficiency suggests that the direct mechanism is the main responsible for peroxoacid generation. At higher intensities, the mechanism may involve also the hydroxyl radicals as it was explained previously.
12.5 12.5.1
SYNTHESIS OF HALOGEN OXOANIONS Perchlorates
The good properties in the production of oxidants have encouraged the interest of comparing its performance with the performance of dimensionally stable anodes (DSA) in the production of hypochlorite. However, the properties of conductive diamond are completely different from that of DSA. Thus, Figure 12.21 shows the variation of the concentration of the main oxidant species generated during the electrolysis of 0.1 M NaCl solutions with DSA and BDD anodes. As it can be observed, hypochlorite, chlorite, and chlorate are the species produced in higher concentrations for low current charges in the case of conductive-diamond anodes [37–39]. Likewise, from a given electrical charge passed, significant amounts of perchlorate begin to be detected in the reaction system and the conversion to this product is quantitative for large current charges. These results are opposite to those obtained with other electrodes such as DSA in which chloride ions are almost only transformed into hypochlorite ions. It is well documented [40] that DSA electrodes can be successfully used for the electrochemical generation of hypochlorite, although they are not able to attain significant concentrations of perchlorate salts. 12.5.2
Perbromates
Perbromates are oxoanions of bromine that cannot be presently found commercially due to the nonexistence of a good synthesis method. Figure 12.22 shows results about the production of perbromate during the oxidation of bromate solutions at strong alkaline media. It can be easily verified that conductive diamond allows the further oxidation of bromate ions, giving to the formation of Br(VII) species [41]. This observation is a very important insight because, to the authors’ knowledge, the electrochemical generation of perbromate has not been previously reported by electrochemical methods in aqueous media. However, at the present moment, the low concentration attained and the low current efficiency serve as warnings about the use of this electrochemical technique as a promising synthesis method. So, further studies must be done to establish the optimum operating conditions that allow improving the current efficiency and the generation of large amount of perbromate.
12.6 SYNTHESIS OF FERRATES
301
90 DSA 80
% Conversion
70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 0
50
100
150
Q (Ah dm–3) 40
BDD
35
% Conversion
30 25 20 15 10 5 0 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Q (Ah dm–3) Figure 12.21 Production of perchlorates with dimensionally stable anodes (DSA) and conductive− diamond anodes (DDB) (C0 : 0.1 M NaCl, pH 10, T: 35◦ C, j: 300 Am−2 ). () ClO− , (•) ClO− 3 , () ClO2 , . () ClO− 4
12.6
SYNTHESIS OF FERRATES
Typical oxidation states for iron species are +2 and +3; however, unusual oxidation states are observed to be stable in particular conditions, such as +6 in the form of ferrate (VI), FeO4 2− . Ferrate ions are very powerful oxidizing agents with standard halfcell reduction potentials ranging from 2.20 V at acidic pHs to 0.72 V versus NHE at alkaline condition [42,43]. Moreover, during the oxidation process, ferrate (VI) ions will be reduced to Fe (III) ions or ferric hydroxide, making them suitable to be used in a wide
302
PRODUCTION OF STRONG OXIDIZING SUBSTANCES WITH BDD ANODES
12
Oxidants(mmol BrO4–)
10 8 6 4 2 0 0
100
200
300
400
Q (Ah dm–3) Figure 12.22 Production of perbromates with conductive diamond anodes. (C0 : 0.1 M NaBrO3 , pH 10, T: 17◦ C, j: 1000 Am−2 ).
range of applications: “green” organic synthesis [44,45], wastewater treatment (oxidation and coagulation) [46,47], and water treatment (persistent disinfection, coagulation, and oxidation of nondesirable compounds) [42,48–50]. Due to their highly oxidized iron basis, multiple electron transfer, and high intrinsic energy, ferrate (VI) can be used as “super-iron” catode [45]. The ferrate synthesis can be divided into the following three categories: (1) thermal chemical synthesis, by heating/melting various iron oxide containing minerals under conditions of strong alkaline and oxygen flow [51]; (2) wet chemical synthesis, by oxidizing Fe(III) salt at strong alkaline condition and using hypochlorite or chlorine as the oxidant [52] or electrochemical techniques; and (3) anodic oxidation using iron or alloy as anode and NaOH or KOH as electrolyte [53]. However, these generation techniques have shown important drawbacks. Thus, it is reported that thermal techniques require the use of very high temperatures that unfortunately also favor the decomposition rate of the ferrate generated. Likewise, wet or dry oxidation technologies also lead to important drawbacks such as low efficiencies and in some cases the use of hazardous compounds as reagents. In this context, electrochemical synthesis of ferrate using iron electrodes in alkaline solutions has shown better yields, but it has also shown significant problems such as the formation of passivation layers on the electrode surfaces. Figure 12.23 shows the variation of the concentration of ferrate and the current efficiencies during the electrolysis with conductive-diamond anodes of an alkaline solution (14 M NaOH saturated with iron (III) hydroxide). As can be seen, there is a rapid increase in the ferrates concentration during the first stages of the electrolyses. Then, the oxidation rate decreases markedly to a constant value, and the ferrate concentration starts to increase in a slower way. Consequently, the current efficiency of the electrosynthesis decreases during the electrolyses being very low even at the initial stages of the electrolyses. In this context, the maximum concentration of soluble iron species (around 0.2 mM) clearly suggests that the small amounts of available iron can limit markedly the efficiency of the electrosynthesis [54,55].
12.6 SYNTHESIS OF FERRATES
303
Oxidants / mmol FeO42–dm–3
0.07 0.06 0.05 0.04 0.03 0.02 0.01 0 0
1
2
3
4
Q (Ah dm–3)
Current efficiency/%
1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0
1
2
3
4
Q (Ah dm–3) Figure 12.23 Batch production of ferrates with diamond electrodes (C0 :14 M NaOH, j: 1300 A m−2 , T: 30◦ C). (Reprinted from Ref. 54.)
Figure 12.24 shows the effect of the raw matter on the efficiency of the process. Notice that the process depends strongly on the concentration of hydroxyl ions, and it is only efficient for a very high content of this anion. According to literature, the stability of ferrate is greatly influenced by the pH of the system [45,56,57], and ferrate salts seem to be more stable in strongly alkaline conditions. In this context, hydroxide anion concentration was also found to be a key parameter in the electrosynthesis of ferrates with iron electrodes [45]. To increase the availability of oxidizable-iron species, and therefore improve the efficiency of the electrosynthesis with BDD, an iron-powder bed placed near to the anode surface (separated of the anode surface by means of a very thin plastic mesh) was used as raw material. During the electrolysis of aqueous solutions, the oxygen evolution that takes place on the anodic surface, consumes large amounts of hydroxyl anions. This fact leads to changes in the pH in a region very close to the anode surface that can favor the chemical dissolution of the iron particles [58]. This would increase the amount of iron ionic species in the reaction system (coming from the dissolution of iron particles) and, consequently, the efficiencies of the electrosynthesis of ferrate. Part b of Figure 12.24 shows the variation of the ferrate concentration with the electrical charge passed during
304
PRODUCTION OF STRONG OXIDIZING SUBSTANCES WITH BDD ANODES
Oxidants/mmol FeO42–dm–3
0.1
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0 0
5 10 NaOH(mol dm–3)
15
Oxidants/mmol FeO42–dm–3
1.2 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0
50
100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 550 Q (Ah dm–3)
Figure 12.24 Effect of the raw materials on the production of ferrates with diamond anodes (C0 : 10 M KOH, j: 1000 A m−2 , T: 10◦ C). (Reprinted from Ref. 55.)
the electrolysis of hydroxide solution (10 M KOH) using iron-powder as raw iron. As the figure shows, high ferrates concentrations are obtained (onefold higher than those obtained with Fe(OH)3 ). This also means that efficiencies increase by onefold and the process could become interesting from the commercial viewpoint. Figure 12.25 shows the effect of the operation conditions in electrolysis with the ironpowder bed as raw material for two particular current charge passed. The concentration of obtained ferrates is strongly dependent on the temperature of the electrosynthesis, and the generation process seems to be favored at temperatures around 25◦ C. The observed maximum may be explained in terms of two opposite processes: the solubility of iron (III) (raw material) and the stability of ferrates. Thus, low temperature can lead to lower concentration of iron species available to be oxidized and thus to a more significant masstransfer control. This explains the lower efficiency obtained at this operation condition.
12.7 EFFECT OF THE TYPE OF DIAMOND ON THE EFFICIENCY OF THE PRODUCTION OF OXIDANTS
305
Oxidants / mmol FeO42–dm–3
1.6 1.4 1.2 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0
1500 500 1000 Current density(A m–2)
2000
Oxidants / mmol FeO42–dm–3
1.6 1.4 1.2 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0
10
20 30 40 Temperature(°C)
50
60
Figure 12.25 Effect of the operation conditions on the results of the production of ferrates (C0 : 10 M KOH). (Reprinted from Ref. 54.)
Conversely, higher temperatures can disfavor the stability of the oxidant electrogenerated and lead to higher decomposition rate. The effect of current density is as expected according to the results shown for other oxidants produced with conductive diamond. The higher the current density, the better the results obtained. This behavior can be explained in terms [27] of the hydroxyl radical contribution, and indicates that the role of hydroxyl radicals is not only important in the production of peroxo compounds but also on the production of other oxidants. 12.7 EFFECT OF THE TYPE OF DIAMOND ON THE EFFICIENCY OF THE PRODUCTION OF OXIDANTS The rapid development of the diamond technology has focused attention on the search for applications and not on the fundamental aspects of diamond technology. Electrocatalysis of conductive-diamond anodes is still unclear, and the effects of the characteristics of diamond on the process efficiencies have to be further studied in the near future. An example of this is shown in Figure 12.26 for the production of peroxophosphates salts during the discontinuous electrolyses of alkaline solutions containing 1 M K3 PO4 .
306
PRODUCTION OF STRONG OXIDIZING SUBSTANCES WITH BDD ANODES
2.2 Oxidants/mmoles P2O84–
2 1.8 1.6 1.4 1.2 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0
0.5
1
2
1.5
Q (Ah dm–3) Figure 12.26 Electrolyses of potassium phosphate solution at pH12.5 and current density of 1250 Am−2 . (♦) 1049-4, () 1038-4, () 1050-4, (×) 983-5, ( ) 802-3, (◦) 60–61, (+) 908-5, () 858-5, (-) 792-1, ♦ 805-1, (•) 805-3, () 825-6.
Table 12.1 summarizes the main characteristics of the lots of conductive-diamond electrodes used in this work [59,60]. In every case, the pH was controlled at 12.5 ± 0.1, and the current density was fixed at 1250 A m−2 . As it can be observed, the use of conductive diamond with different characteristics leads to a variety of responses in which difference is even more than onefold. However, almost no differences are observed if the experiments are repeated with the same electrodes or with other electrodes of the same lot. This observation confirms that the characteristics of electrodes influence strongly on the electrosynthesis results; hence, they should be taken into account in the study of the applications of conductive-diamond electrolyses. Figure 12.27 shows the results of simple statistical analyses of these results in which the effect of different parameters of the diamond surfaces on the efficiency of production of peroxophosphates is compared. As seen, boron content and thickness of the diamond anode seem to have a significant effect on the production of peroxodiphosphates, ˜ TABLE 12.1 Characteristics of the conductive-diamond electrodes lots used by Canizares et al. [54].
Reference of the BDD 1049-4 1050-4 60-61-G1 1038-4 825-6 908-5 983-5 792-1 805-1/3 858-5 802-3
Conductive-diamond layer Boron Ratio Thickness BDD layer (μm) contents (ppm) sp3 /sp2 100 200 500 1300 1300 2500 1300 100 1300 2500 8000
65 75 93 66 45 68 77 89 105 43 80
1.09 1.14 2.4 1.33 2.33 1.15 2.27 1.03 2.25 1.13 1.05
p-Si substrate Si-Resistivity Roughness, (m cm) Si-Surfinra (μm) 100 100 100 100 100 100 10 10 10 10 10
0.3-0.5 0.3-0.5 0.3-0.5 0.3-0.5 <0.1 <0.1 0.3-0.5 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1 <0.1
12.8 CONCLUSIONS
307
0.6 0.4
99.5 % significance
0.2
95.0 % significance
0
Effect =
–0.2
95.0 % significance
–0.4
99.5 % significance
Positive y+ – n+
y− n−
Negative
–0.6 –0.8
sp
re si
st iv i ty r ou 3/ sp gh 2 ne sp (fr ss 3/ om th sp ic lo 2 kn w (fr es to om s m sp m ed 3/ ed i sp u iu m 2 m ) bo (fr to ro o m hi n gh lo bo (fro w ) m ro t o n lo hi w (fr gh om to ) m m e ed di bo um iu ro m ) n to (fr om hi gh lo ) w to hi gh )
Effect/mmol peroxophosphate (Ah)–1
0.8
Parameter
Figure 12.27 Statistical analyses of the influence of the main properties of diamond anodes on the production of peroxodiphosphates.
appearing around the line of 99.5% of significance. This means that these are the most significant parameters from a statistical viewpoint. According to these observations, an increase in the boron content or a decrease in the thickness of the diamond layer improves the efficiencies of the electrolyses. A graphical analysis of the influence of the boron content does not result in any significant conclusion, except for a very large value of the efficiency in the case of the highly boron-doped diamond (8000 ppm). However, the graphical analysis of the influence of the thickness shows some important observations. Points corresponding to the thinner layer are significantly over the points corresponding to the thicker layer and the same points are randomly distributed as a function of the characteristic of the p-Si substrate. In addition, there is no significant influence of the diamond to graphite ratio (except for points corresponding to thicker layer are below in this graph) and the boron content does not influence except for the 8000 ppm boron-doped diamond. At the light of the actual knowledge, it is difficult to explain the results obtained. However, they would be related to the nature of the mechanisms involved in the oxidation processes.
12.8
CONCLUSIONS
From this work, the following conclusions can be drawn: — Strong oxidants can be produced by electrolysis with conductive-diamond anodes. The process is particularly efficient in the production of peroxoacids and peroxosalts.
308
PRODUCTION OF STRONG OXIDIZING SUBSTANCES WITH BDD ANODES
— Current density has important influences on the results obtained. Values higher than 1000 A m−2 promotes the formation of hydroxyl radicals and increases the efficiency of the processes. — The oxidation of chlorine and bromine species leads to the formation of the perhalogen acid. This is particularly significant in the case of bromine because it allows a new route to produce this species efficiently. — Production of ferrates is highly efficient and is limited only by mass transport. Use of iron-beds allows significant increases in the efficiency of the process because of the higher availability of oxidizable-iron species in the reaction system. — Properties of diamond surfaces strongly influence the process efficiency. Thin layer seems to increase the yield of the processes.
12.9
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Financial support from Consejer´ıa de Educaci´on y Ciencia of the Junta de Comunidades de Castilla-La Mancha through the project PCI-08-0068-9073 is gratefully acknowledged.
REFERENCES 1. B. Marselli, J. Garc´ıa-G´omez, P.A. Michaud, M.A. Rodrigo, C. Comninellis, J. Electrochem. Soc. 2003, 150 , 79–83. 2. P. Ca˜nizares, R. Paz, C. S´aez, M.A. Rodrigo, J. Electrochem. Soc. 2007, 154 , 37–44. 3. P. Ca˜nizares, C. S´aez, J. Lobato, M.A. Rodrigo, Afinidad 2006, 63 , 19–25. 4. M. Panizza, G. Cerisola, Electrochim. Acta 2003, 48 , 1515–1519. 5. J. Hastie, D. Bejan, M. Teutli-Leon, N.J. Bunce, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2006, 45 , 4898–4904. 6. A. Cabeza, A.M. Urtiaga, I. Ortiz, Ind. Eng. Chem. 2007, 46 , 1439–1446. 7. M. Mascia, A. Vacca, A.M. Polcaro, S. Palmas, J. Rodriguez Ruiz, A. Da Pozzo, J. Hazard. Mater. 2010, 174 , 314–322. 8. E. Brillas, I. Sir´es, C. Arias, P.L. Cabot, F. Centellas, R.M. Rodr´ıguez, J.A. Garrido, Chemosphere 2005, 58 , 399–406. 9. M. Panizza, G. Cerisola, Electrochim. Acta 2005, 51 , 191–199. 10. E. Guinea, E. Brillas, F. Centellas, P. Ca˜nizares, M.A. Rodrigo, C. S´aez, Water Res. 2009, 43 , 2131–2138. 11. P. Ca˜nizares, B. Louhichi, A. Gadri, B. Nasr, R. Paz, M.A. Rodrigo, C. S´aez, J. Hazard. Mat . 2007, 146 , 552–557. 12. P. Ca˜nizares, M. Hernandez, M.A. Rodrigo, C. Saez, C.E. Barrera, G. Roa, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2009, 48 , 1298–1301. 13. E. Kilinc, Talanta 2005, 65 , 876–881. 14. A. Kraft, M. Stadelmann, M. W¨unsche, M. Clanschke, Electrochem. Commun. 2006, 8 , 883–886. 15. A. Kapałka, G. F´oti, C. Comninellis, Electrochim. Acta 2009, 54 , 2018–2023. 16. P.A. Michaud, M. Panizza, L. Ouattara, T. Diaco, G. F´oti, C. Comninellis, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2003, 33 , 151–154. 17. J.A. Rosso, F.J. Rodr´ıguez, M.C. Gonz´alez, D.O. Martire, J. Photochem. Photobiol. A. Chem. 1998, 116 , 21–25.
REFERENCES
309
18. J.A. Rosso, P. Caregnato, V.C. Mora, M.C. Gonz´alez, D.O. Martire, Helvetica Chim. Acta 2003, 86 , 2509–2524. 19. B. Cohen, P.R. Mucenieks, FMC Corp. 1971 US Patent 3 555 147. 20. B. Puetzer, A.V. Finn, L. Mackles, Tintex Corp. 1967 US Patent 3 337 466. 21. Hunan Agricultural College, T’uJang (Nanking) 1978 (1), 9–11. 22. A.S. Groisman, A.G. Belyaeva, O.B. Khachaturayn, I.Y. Sugurova, 1991 US Patent 1 699 953 A1. 23. A. Gaffar, D.B. Calvin, 1983 DE Patent 3 246 946 A1. 24. A. Gaffar, C.J. Edwards, 1983 DE Patent 3 627 759 A1. 25. G.B. Balazs, P.R. Lewis 1999 U.S. Patent 5919350. 26. D. Gandini, E. Mah´e, P.A. Michaud, W. Haenni, A. Perret, C. Comninellis, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2000, 30 , 1345–1350. 27. P.A. Michaud, E. Mah´e, W. Haenni, A. Perret, C. Comninellis, Electrochem. Solid-State Lett . 2000, 3 , 77–79. 28. K. Serrano, P.A. Michaud, C. Comninellis, A. Savall, Electrochim. Acta 2002, 48 , 431–436. 29. C.J. Battaglia, J.O. Edwards, Inorg. Chem. 1965, 4 , 552–558. 30. A. El Ghazali, S. Beldaci, J.J. Rameua, F. Dalard, J. Appl. Electrochem. 1998, 28 , 725–735. 31. J.S.C. Chiang, 1986 US Patent 4 626 326. 32. O.G. Tyurikava, N.B. Miller, 1984 US Patent 1 089 174 A. 33. P. Ca˜nizares, F. Larrondo, J. Lobato, M.A. Rodrigo, C. S´aez, J. Electrochem. Soc. 2005, 152 , D191–D196. 34. G. Toennies, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1937, 59 , 555–557. 35. T. Zhu, H. Chang, J.F. Kadla, Can. J. Chem. 2003, 81 , 156–160. 36. E. Weiss, C. S´aez, K. Groenen-Serrano, P. Ca˜nizares, A. Savall, M.A. Rodrigo, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2007, 38 , 93–100. 37. H. Bergmann, J. Rollin, Catalysis Today 2007, 124 , 198–203. 38. H. Bergmann, J. Rollin, L. Lourtchouk, Electrochim. Acta 2008, 54 , 2102–2107. 39. P. Ca˜nizares, C. S´aez, A. S´anchez-Carretero, M.A. Rodrigo, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2009, DOI: 10.1007/s10800-009-9792-7. 40. C.R. Costa, C. Botta, E. Espindola, P. Olivi, J. Hazard. Mater. 2008, 153 , 616–627. 41. C. S´aez, P. Ca˜nizares, A. S´anchez-Carretero, M.A. Rodrigo, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2010, DOI 10.1007/s10800-010-0108-8. 42. V.K. Sharma, Adv. Environ. Res. 2002, 6 , 143–156. 43. C. Li, X.Z. Li, N. Graham, Chemosphere 2005, 61 , 537–543. 44. L. Delaude, P. Laszlo, J. Org. Chem. 1996, 61 , 6360–6370. 45. W. He, J. Wang, C. Yang, J. Zhang, Electrochim. Acta 2006, 51 , 1967–1973. 46. D.S.J. Luca, M. Cantelli, D.M.S. Luca, Water Sci. Technol . 1992, 26 , 2077–2080. 47. J.Q. Jiang, B. Lloyd, Water Res. 2002, 36 , 1397–1408. 48. M. Gilbert, T.D. Waite, C. Hare, J. Am. Water Works Assoc. 1976, 56 , 466–474. 49. A. Basu, K.R. Williams, J. Biol. Chem. 1987, 262 , 9601–9607. 50. S. Licht, B. Wang, S. Ghosh, Science 1999, 285 , 1039–1042. 51. Y.M. Kiselev, N.S. Kopelev, N.A. Zavyalova, Y.D. Perfiliev, P.E. Kazin, Russ. J. Inorg. Chem. 1989, 34 , 1250–1253. 52. G.W. Thompson, L.T. Ockerman, J.M. Schreyer, Chem. Anal . 1951, 73 , 1379–1381. 53. K. Bouzek, I. Rousar, J. Appl. Electrochem. 1996, 26 , 919–924. 54. C. S´aez, P. Ca˜nizares, M.A. Rodrigo, AIChE Journal 2008, 54 , 1600–1607.
310 55. 56. 57. 58. 59.
PRODUCTION OF STRONG OXIDIZING SUBSTANCES WITH BDD ANODES
P. Ca˜nizares, M. Arc´ıs, C. S´aez, M.A. Rodrigo, Electrochem. Commun. 2007, 9 , 2286–2290. M. De Koninck, T. Brousse, D. Belanger, Electrochim. Acta 2003, 48 , 1425–1433. V. Lescuras-Darrou, F. Lapicque, G. Valentin, J. Appl. Electrochem. 2002, 32 , 57–63. J.J. Pignatello, D. Liu, P. Huston, Environ. Sci. Technol. 1999, 33 , 1832–1839. P. Ca˜nizares, C. S´aez, A. S´anchez-Carretero, M.A. Rodrigo, Electrochem. Commun. 2008, 10 , 602–606. 60. E. Guinea, F. Centellas, E. Brillas, P. Ca˜nizares, C. S´aez, M.A. Rodrigo, Appl. Catal. B. Environ. 2009, 89 , 645–650.
13 Ozone Generation Using Boron-Doped Diamond Electrodes Yunny Meas, Luis A. Godinez, and Erika Bustos
13.1
INTRODUCTION
Ozone is an attractive gas for wastewater treatment due to its high oxidizing power; it can oxidize a large number of organic and inorganic compounds. This chapter reviews the various ozone technologies and focuses on the production of ozone using boron-doped diamond (BDD) electrodes by electrochemical methods. BDD is a good candidate for use in electrochemical production of O3 due to its high overpotential for O2 production, high chemical stability to corrosion, and low adsorption properties. Although the efficiency of BDD ozone production could be improved by modifying the BDD composition and by increasing the rate of adsorption of oxygenated species in the reaction mechanism, BDD is a good candidate material for electrodes in ozone generators.
13.2
OZONE
The discovery of ozone was officially announced by Sch¨onbein [1], at the Academy of Munich, in 1840. The name ozone was derived from the Greek word ozein, meaning ‘to smell’ [2]. In 1845, ozone was obtained by submitting pure dry oxygen to an electric spark [3], and later it was described as existing in four electronic resonance structures (see Figure 13.1) [4,5]. Synthetic Diamond Films: Preparation, Electrochemistry, Characterization, and Applications, First Edition. Edited by Enric Brillas and Carlos Alberto Mart´ınez-Huitle. © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Published 2011 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
311
312
OZONE GENERATION USING BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ELECTRODES
O O
O O
O
O O
O
O O
O
O
Figure 13.1 Structure of the ozone molecule as four canonical forms.
13.2.1
Physical and Chemical Properties of Ozone
Ozone (O3 ) has a molecular weight of 48 g/mol, a gas density of 2.144 g L−1 at 0◦ C, and a boiling point of −112◦ C at atmospheric pressure. Ozone follows Henry’s Law, which states that at equilibrium, the concentration of a gas in water is directly proportional to its partial pressure in the vapor phase above the liquid (i.e., its gas phase concentration). The proportionality constant (Henry’s constant) varies with temperature. Ozone solubility decreases with decreasing temperature, in order of the Henry’s Law (Equation 13.1) considering the adequated conversi´on for other conditions (Equation 13.2), where Cliquid is the dissolved concentration in liquid, Cgas is the gas concentration, β is the Bunsen coefficient (solubility) with temperature dependent, Pgas is the gas pressure, T1 in K and P1 in Pa [6]. Cliquid = Cgas βtemperature Pgas
(13.1)
[O3 ](T1,P1) = [O3 ](T0,P0) (273.15/T1 )(P1 /101325)
(13.2)
Ozone is a reactive substance. The level of measurable dissolved ozone at any instant in time is affected by the specific aqueous conditions present, including pH, alkalinity, and ozone demand from any oxidizable substances present [7]. Ozone is much more soluble in acetic acid, acetic anhydride, dichloroacetic acid, chloroform, and carbon tetrachloride than it is in water. Ozone is an unstable molecule that quickly reacts to form oxygen. The half-life of ozone in environmental air is short, depending on the temperature and humidity. The half-life in water ranges between seconds, hours, or days, depending on the temperature, pressure, velocity, pH, and oxidizable substance concentrations (see Table 13.1) [6,7].
TABLE 13.1 Typical ozone half-life in water at normal conditions: 21◦ C and 1 atm. Phase of ozone
Gas Dissolved at pH 6.0 Dissolved at pH 7.0 Dissolved at pH 8.0
Half-life time ≈3 months ≈18 days ≈8 days ≈3 days ≈1.5 h ≈1.5 s ≈20 min ≈30 min ≈20 min ≈15 min ≈12 min ≈8 min 5 min
Temperature (◦ C) −50 −35 −25 20 120 250 21 15 20 25 30 35 21
Stability
Stable Unstable Stable Stable Unstable
13.2 OZONE
313
Molecular ozone (O3 ) is more stable in high purity water when the pH is less than 6. As pH increases above 7.0, hydroxyl free radicals are formed as ozone decomposes: O3 + H2 O → O2 + • OH + HO− [2,7]. The rate of ozone decomposition to form • OH increases with increasing pH, with the process becoming essentially instantaneous at pH 10.0. The hydroxyl free radical, with available hydrogen (H+ ) ions, is a stronger oxidizing agent than molecular ozone (oxidation potential of 2.76 V versus 2.076 V for O3 ). However, hydroxyl free radicals are so unstable and reactive that they are consumed within microseconds by most oxidizable constituents (e.g., bicarbonate or carbonate ions and organic compounds dissolved in the water) [8]. The principal physic-chemical characteristics of ozone are summarized in Table 13.2. 13.2.2
Production of Ozone
Usually, ozone (O3 ) is generated by the exposure of air or another gas containing normal oxygen (O2 ) to a high-energy source, which, in commercial production, is a high electrical voltage discharge or ultraviolet radiation. Typical oxygen sources are air, bottled “dry” oxygen, liquid oxygen (LOX), and oxygen concentrators [7–9]. Ozone must be manufactured on site for immediate use because it is unstable and quickly decomposes to form oxygen [10]. When generated from air, ozone has a bluish color in the generator cell, but ozone/air mixtures are invisible even at the high concentrations that exit ozone generators. The distinctive, pungent odor of ozone is readily detected at concentrations above 0.02 ppm in air. Although the gas is only partially soluble in water, concentrations up to 10 ppm can be achieved in water, under normal conditions [7,11]. To produce ozone it is necessary to deliver 10–20 kW h per kg of O3 at 1–5 g m−3 concentration. For this reason, the ionization is 2 or 3 times more expensive than chlorination [10]. O3 is known to be generated simultaneously with O2 during anodic discharge if particular electrode materials are used in a variety of aqueous media [12]. 13.2.3
Importance of Ozone Applications
O3 is a clean and strong oxidant, and its application in so-called green chemical processes (e.g. pollutant combustion, removal of contaminants, etc.) has received special attention
TABLE 13.2 Physico–chemical properties of ozone [6–9,11]. Properties Color
Molecular Weight Density (0◦ C and 101.3 KPa) Boiling Point (101.3 KPa) Fusion Point of Solid O3 Redox Potential Bunsen coefficient (solubility) in water at 0◦ C
Values Gas: blue colored Dissolved in water: purple blue in concentration >20 ppm 48 g mol−1 2.154 g L−1 –111.9◦ C –192.5◦ C 2.07 V (Hydroxyl radical • OH 2.80 V) 20 mg L−1
314
OZONE GENERATION USING BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ELECTRODES
in recent years [13–23]. It is used to minimize the environmental impact of industrial activity, because it is a very powerful oxidant and does not produce toxic products on decomposition [14,16,20,24–30], in contrast with other highly oxidizing compounds. Ozone, therefore, is chosen for industrial processes as the best available technology with minimum cost and without pollution [2,11,31]. The ozone used in both potable water and wastewater treatment may be classified as both an oxidant and a germicidal compound. It therefore has the same properties exhibited by aqueous chlorine, and there is tendency to view the two substances as competitors. Therefore, the distinct properties of ozone are (1) as a bactericide, (2) as a vermicide, and (3) as a powerful chemical oxidant [11,17,23,32,33]. The solubility of ozone in water is a limiting factor that greatly affects the process of ozonation. Although ozone is more soluble than oxygen, chlorine is 12 times more soluble than ozone. In pure aqueous solutions, ozone is thought to decompose as follows [11]: O3 + H2 O → HO3 + + OH− +
−
(13.3)
HO3 + OH → 2HO2
(13.4)
O3 + HO2 → • OH + 2O2
(13.5)
OH + HO2 → H2 O + O2
(13.6)
•
The free radicals (HO2 + and • OH) that form when ozone decomposes in aqueous solutions have great oxidizing power; they may react with impurities present (e.g., metal salts, organic matter, hydrogen, and hydroxide ions present in solution). Ozone, while it exists, does not loose its oxidizing capacity in an aqueous solution. When ozone reacts with hydrogen peroxide, the process is called peroxone, and a hydroxyl radical is formed [10,11,34,35]. Ozone is a powerful oxidizing agent. Its oxidation potential is −2.07 V versus the hydrogen electrode at 25◦ C and at unity H-ion activity. Only fluorine has a more electronegative oxidation potential [11]. The oxidation-reduction potentials provided in Table 13.3 show that ozone is the most powerful of the commonly used drinking water TABLE 13.3 [7,36].
Standard potentials of different oxidants
Reaction OH + H+ + e− → H2 O O3 + 2H+ + 2e− → O2 + H2 O • OH + e− → HO− H2 O2 + 2H+ + 2e− → 2H2 O + − MnO− 4 + 4H + 3e → MnO2 + 2H2 O + HOCl + H + 2e− ↔ Cl− + H2 O HOBr + H+ + 2e− ↔ Br− + H2 O O2 + 4H+ + 4e− ↔ 2H2 O HOI + H+ + e− ↔ I− + H2 O CIO2(aq) + e− ↔ CIO− 2 OCl− + H2 O + 2e− → Cl− + 2OH− OBr− + H2 O + 2e− → Br− + 2OH− OI− + H2 O + 2e− → I− + 2OH− •
Oxidation-reduction potential (V) 2.760 2.076 2.020 1.776 1.679 1.482 1.331 1.229 0.987 0.954 0.810 0.761 0.485
13.2 OZONE
315
oxidants [7]. Ozonation is one of the most widely used advanced oxidation technologies with strongly increased process efficiencies [10,34,35]. Frequently identified by-products from the ozonation of organic substances contained in drinking or wastewaters are aldehydes, carboxylic acids, and other aliphatic aromatic or mixed oxidized compounds. Such substances are often quite easily biodegradable, and it is not surprising to observe the decrease of toxic effects [36,37]. Certain halogenated and other heat-resistant or so-called refractory organics (e.g., benzene, tetrachloroethylene, or other volatile organic compounds (VOCs) in drinking water) can be oxidized only by hydroxyl free radicals ( • OH) that are produced when ozonation is coupled with ultraviolet (UV) radiation and/or hydrogen peroxide (H2 O2 ) treatment [7,10]. These coupled ozonation processes produce hydroxyl free radicals ( • OH) rapidly over a wide pH range and destroy most refractory VOC organic compounds [10]. This coupled ozone technology, in which • OH is deliberately produced from ozone decomposition, is called an advanced oxidation process (AOP) [7,10,38]. AOPs are identified as chemical processes that accelerate the decomposition of ozone to yield sufficient quantities of the potent hydroxyl free radical to cause specific improvements in the water treatment process. These processes produce peroxone, which is the result of the reaction between hydrogen peroxide and ozone [39–42], ultraviolet radiation (UV) with ozone, elevated pH with ozone, and UV with hydrogen peroxide. The AOPs enable water producers to achieve definitive water quality goals at lower costs and greater reliability than conventional oxidation methods [11]. As a highly reactive gas, ozone quickly corrodes most metals (e.g., iron, copper, and mild steel) and damages most plastics if used without consideration for ozone compatibility. Natural rubber exposed to ozone will harden quickly and crack. Gaskets, sealing compounds, and piping should be chosen with attention to ozone compatibility [7]. Generally, the main areas in which ozone is used are: •
Disinfection: pathogenic pollution (excluding parasitic organisms), bacterial disinfection, viral and cyst inactivation, and befouling control [7,37] • Oxidation of inorganic compounds: Fe2+ , Mn2+ , As3+ , organically bound heavy metals and cyanides [7,37] • Oxidation of organic compounds: alkenes, chlorinated compounds, chloroaromatics, aldehydes, alcohols, carbonic acids, aliphatics, some pesticides, polyaromatic hydrocarbons, some detergents, phenols, and trihalomethane (THM), including taste, odor, color removal, algae control, and particle removal (particles of 0.5–2 mg L−1 ), micro flocculation (of soluble organics), pretreatment of organics for biological oxidation and precursor control [7,37] • Treatment of wastewater. Pulp and paper mill (reduction of color, COD, absorbable organic halogens), municipal (disinfection, odor control, sludge reduction, and biodegradability), pesticides (elimination of recalcitrant compounds) [2,43–48] 13.2.4
Efficiency and Production
Ozone has been used to treat groundwater and surface water in preparation for the drinking supply or for use in swimming pools in Europe since 1906. By 1982, there were well over 2000 municipal water treatment plants and many more public swimming pools using ozone throughout the world. It is estimated that more than 3000 water
316
OZONE GENERATION USING BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ELECTRODES
treatment plants use ozone today; more than 200 of these are in the US. The EPA’s water treatment regulations for primary disinfection and control of chlorination by-products encourage municipalities to use ozone for both purposes. Actually, a larger proportion of US municipal water treatment plants are expected to be using ozone for both disinfection by-product controls [7]. In the past, the attitudes in the United States and Mexico were that ozone was simply an alternative disinfectant to chlorine. Although ozone is the most effective and most rapidly acting primary disinfectant available, its residual disinfection property can be more stable in distribution systems. The most critical consideration for water quality is persistent contamination. Using ozone as a primary oxidizing agent (or as the primary disinfectant) does not require the addition of chemicals to the water, whereas chlorine, potassium permanganate, chlorine dioxide, and so on, do [7]. Recently, Americans have begun to realize that even though some European plants use ozone as the primary disinfectant after filtration in municipal water treatment, it is generally recommended that ozone be accompanied by small amounts of chlorine, chlorine dioxide, or monochloramine to produce a disinfectant residue throughout the water distribution system. Much of the disinfectant demands of the water are satisfied by ozonation steps. For this reason, only small amounts of chlorine-containing compounds are necessary to produce the required stable residue [7]. Ozone is increasingly recognized as being more of a chemical oxidant, in the early stages of water treatment (prefiltration), than simply a disinfectant. Ozone performs oxidation better than other available oxidants with the formation of fewer problematic by-products [7]. Most large-scale applications of ozone treatment in municipal water treatment plants can be transferred to small systems markets. This is because many of the same contaminants are present in both types of aqueous environments. All of the treatment techniques used in professional water treatment (i.e., filtration, ion exchange, activated carbon adsorption, or reverse osmosis) can be coupled beneficially with ozone to solve specific water treatment problems. In fact, incorporation of ozone can solve some of the problems resulting from the use of these other devices (e.g., befouling control of ion exchange resins and membranes, and disinfection following activated carbon adsorption) [7]. Within the last 15 years, the cost-effectiveness of ozone production systems has improved. Several technological advances have contributed to cost reduction [37]: •
Higher ozone yield per unit electrode area, due to medium frequency technologies Increased ozone concentration with modern ozone generators, from 6% to 14 wt % in oxygen • Increase in the unitary ozone production capacity by a factor of two or three • 40% reduction in specific energy consumption (since 1990) • Improved operational reliability •
Considering the investment and operation costs, ozonation still is not a cheap technology. Although safe operation is no longer a problem, ozonation systems require considerable safety precautions, increasing the investment costs. Especially in smaller applications, the investment and capital costs cannot be neglected, because they can considerably lengthen the time required for investment return [37].
317
13.3 TECHNOLOGIES FOR PRODUCING OZONE
An ozonation system, from a customer’s perspective, must meet the following technical and economical requirements [37]: •
Achieve the treatment goal (e.g., reduce contamination below the legal limits). Use minimum oxygen. • Keep the energy costs low. • Safe to operate. •
13.3
TECHNOLOGIES FOR PRODUCING OZONE
Ozone is an unstable oxidizing gas with a maximum half-life in very clean water (double distilled) on the order of only a few hours, which is reduced when pollutants are present [7]. The methods of ozone generation and their differences are summarized in Table 13.4 [37]. The first two methods of ozone production, electrical discharge and electrolysis, are the only methods of practical importance, both in the laboratory and in full industrial-scale applications. Ozone production from ambient air or pure oxygen, in an electrical discharge chamber, is the most widespread technology for ozone generation. Considering that ozone is a threeatom molecule modification of molecular oxygen, its production directly from oxygen seems reasonable. In recent years, electrochemical ozone production by electrolysis of water has gained some attention in certain applications [37]. Ozone is made by rupturing the stable oxygen molecule, forming two oxygen fragments that can combine with oxygen molecules to form ozone: O2 ↔ 2[O]
(13.7)
2[O] + 2O2 ↔ 2O3
(13.8)
Nature generates ozone continuously by means of sunlight acting on oxygen in the atmosphere, or intermittently by lightning passing though the air. Humans simulate this natural process of generating ozone by passing high-voltage electrical discharges, high or low electrical frequencies, or high-energy radiation through air or oxygen. Ozone is also generated unintentionally by humans as a by-product during electrical power generation, electrostatic precipitators, welding equipment, electrostatic copying machines, UV lights, and a variety of other electrical devices. Generation of ozone is energy intensive, with some 90% of the power supplied to the generator being utilized to produce light, sound, and primarily heat, rather than the desired ozone. Thus, minimizing electrical power requirements in future technological advances for ozone production is a prime target of ozone generator manufacturers. 13.3.1
Corona Discharge Technique
For the generation of ozone by the corona discharge technique, the type, thinness, and surface area of the dielectric medium used, width of the discharge gap between electrodes, degree of flawlessness of the dielectric medium (no pin-holes), pressure, temperature, and
318
OZONE GENERATION USING BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ELECTRODES
TABLE 13.4 Overview of the types of ozone generation, working principles, and fields of application [7–8,37]. Method of ozone generation
Working principle
Ozone source
Electrical
Electrical discharge (ED)
Electrochemical
Electrolysis (EL)
Photochemical (λ = 185 nm)
Irradiation (abstraction of electrons) X-rays, radioactive γ -rays
Radiation chemistry
Thermal
Light arc ionization
Field of application
Air or O2
Standard method, from laboratory to large-scale. Uses a 10–20 kV potential with larger performance ranges, >100 g O3 /h Predominately for pure water Water without organic applications, laboratory to compounds or small industrial scale, with an suspended particles, ozone performance of with a conductivity of ∼15 mg O3 /h with an energy <20 μS cm−1 of ∼12 Wh g−1 O2 (air), water (drinking Generation of [O3 ] < 1 g m−3 , water quality or highly with high energy use, around purified) 3 kW h g−1 Water (highly purified) Very seldom, solely experimental. Use of radioactive isotopes, such as 137 Cs, 60 Co, and 90 Sr. Ozone yields of ∼82 kW h g−1 Water Very seldom, solely experimental. Ozone yield ∼5 kW h g−1
rate of flow of feed gas through the ozone generator, composition (air versus oxygen), and moisture content of the feed gas are among the most important factors [2,49]. Because ozone is only slightly soluble in aqueous media, contact between ozone and water requires the bubbling of ozone mixed with air or oxygen. Mass transfer of ozone from the gaseous bubbles occurs across the gas/liquid interface into the water [23]. Factors that affect the mass transfer of ozone into liquids, and that themselves are affected by the design and operation of the contactor systems include miscibility with water, ozone demand of the substances to be ozonized, concentration of ozone in the gas, whether the carrier gas is air or oxygen, method and duration of contact, bubble size, pressure, and temperature. In designing an ozone contacting system, it is important to minimize the amount of ozone required for the specific purpose for which the ozone is to be used. There are only four different types of gas/liquid contacting systems: spray towers (liquid sprayed into gas), packed beds, bubble plate or sieve towers (an intermediate situation between the last), and units for dispersing gas bubbles into liquid [49,50]. The main drawback associated with this technology is that the limited current efficiency leads to low O3 concentrations in the gaseous phase (O2 + O3 ), thus restricting O3 application [46,51]. Such a process is represented as follows: O • + O2 + M → O3 + M ∗
(13.9)
where M can be the reactor wall, a nitrogen molecule, or a molecule of carbon dioxide. M acts by removing the energy excess acquired during ozone molecule formation, resulting in an excited inert body, M* [2].
13.3 TECHNOLOGIES FOR PRODUCING OZONE
13.3.2
319
Electrical Discharge Ozone Generators (EDOGs)
Electrical discharge, sometimes also called silent discharge ozone generators, ionizes molecular oxygen by applying high-power alternating current to the gas. Air or pure oxygen can be used as a feed gas, at either ambient or elevated pressures (Pabs = 100–600 katm). Ozone is formed by recombination of ionized oxygen atoms and ionized molecular oxygen. In this process, only 4–12% of the energy supplied is used for the formation of ozone, and the rest is transformed into heat. An efficient cooling system must be installed, because ozone decays quickly at elevated temperatures, with T = 50◦ C regarded as the critical value. In full-scale systems, the gas is cooled to T = 5–10◦ C. Newly developed techniques, such as double-sided cooling of the electrodes, help increase energy efficiency [37]. Various types of discharge chambers are available with plate or tubular geometries. The classical and most frequently used type is the tubular, often also called van der Made-type or Welsbach-type. The central rod electrode technology is a more recent development, especially designed for applications with pure oxygen as the feed gas [37]. 13.3.3
Electrolytic Ozone Generators (ELOGs)
In an electrolytic ozone generator (ELOG), ozone is produced from the electrolysis of high purity water. In the electrolytic cell, water is broken down into molecular hydrogen (H2 ), oxygen (O2 ), and ozone (O3 ) by the action of electrons supplied by the catalytic properties of the electrode material. Water, O2 , and O3 leave the cell on the anode side, whereas H2 is produced at the cathode side of the specialized electrolytic cell [2,23,37,46,52–54]. The cell anode and cathode spaces are separated by a solid electrolyte membrane. The anode is made of a porous, water-penetrable, and current-conductive carrier material coated with an active layer. However, the active catalytic layer and the electrolyte membrane are present, ozone is produced when a direct current of 3 to 6 V at currents of up to 50 A (corresponding to a current intensity of 0.2 to 3.0 A cm−2 ) are applied [37]. Because all materials of the cell must be electrochemically stable and must provide high conductivities, the cell is constructed with refined metals or metal oxides at their highest oxidation levels. The feed water must be of high purity, because it must pass through the porous anode and cathode materials without clogging or causing chemical damage. Therefore, ions and other impurities, present in normal drinking water, must be removed by ion-exchange, ultra or nanofiltration, reverse osmosis, or distillation [37]. Electrolytic ozone generators are supplied by several producers. The ozone production capacity of one cell is 1–4 g O3 h−1 , but several cells can be combined in one generator. Cell temperature strongly influences ozone production, and efficient cooling is necessary [37]. Relevant reduction half-reactions and their corresponding standard potentials are [12,29]: Anode reaction: ◦
3H2 O ↔ O3 + 6H+ + 6e−
E = 1.51V vs. NHE
2H2 O ↔ O2 + 4H+ + 4e−
E = 1.23V vs. NHE
◦
(13.10) (13.11)
320
OZONE GENERATION USING BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ELECTRODES
Cathode reaction: 2H+ + 2e− → H2
(13.12)
It is apparent from these E ◦ values that anodic generation of O2 is thermodynamically favored over generation of O3 . Strategies for increasing the current efficiency for O3 generation generally include one or more of the following: 1. The electrode material should present good conductance and resistance to anodic corrosion and a high anodic overpotential for the oxygen evolution reaction, such as. PbO2 and glassy carbon (GC) [12,15,16,29,46,52–56,37,52]. 2. The morphological characteristics (roughness, porosity) of the electrode material significantly affect the current efficiency and require further investigation of the electrode preparation in order to optimize ELOG, thus reducing energy demands [2,16,23]. 3. Anions and cations from the electrolyte should not engage in competitive reactions with the oxygen and hydrogen evolution reactions or electrochemical ozone production. This can be possible using acidic electrolytes (e.g. H2 SO4 , HClO4 ) [15,57], which must be select in order of protect the electrode material [2,53,54]. 4. Electrochemical ozone production efficiencies can also be increased if special electrolytes are used, such as solid polymer electrolytes (SPEs) [14,26,29,40] or aqueous electrolytes, wh conducting salts containing fluoride-containing anions [12,15,23,52]. Addition of an adsorbate (e.g., F− , BF4 − , or PF6 − ) can help block the O2 evolution mechanism [12,15,16,46,52,55,56]. 5. Apply a large anodic current density to achieve a large positive electrode potential [2,53,54]. 6. Lower the temperature [2,16,53,54]. 7. Use a solid polymer electrolyte-based cell [13,16,40,58]. 8. Allow for diverse configurations [52]. Relative to the corona process, the ELOG process produces higher O3 concentrations, making the ELOG process more appropriate for situations in which a high O3 concentration is essential. However, the ELOG process is associated with higher costs of electrical energy consumption [16,26,52,59]. In addition to UV ozone generation, electrochemical production of ozone is a better alternative to corona discharge techniques [60]. Electrochemical ozone production has the advantage that it is a low DC voltage technology, and that ozone can be produced directly in water with a support electrolyte, thereby eliminating or minimizing technical problems associated with dissolving ozone in water. The widespread use of electrochemical ozone production requires an increase in current efficiency, simplified production systems, stable electrode materials, and/or easy handling of the electrolytes [61]. 13.3.3.1 Anodes for Electrochemically Producing Ozone The drastic operation conditions required for ELOG (very low interfacial pH and high anodic potentials) impose stringent specifications on the electrode materials [59]. In addition, the ELOG
13.3 TECHNOLOGIES FOR PRODUCING OZONE
321
technology’s water electrolysis produces oxygen as the main competitive reaction to ozone production. Thermodynamically, oxygen evolution is strongly favored over ozone production [61]. Therefore, high current efficiencies for electrochemical ozone production are possible only if high oxygen overvoltage anode materials are used. Examples of such materials that have been investigated for ozone production are Pt [2,19,46,48,52,62,63]; Ti/Pt [5]; Ti/IrO2 [13]; PbO2 [2,12–15,20,23,26–29,40,46–48,57,64–69]; PbO2 /Ebonex (Ebonex is a commercial material based on titanium suboxides) [2,46];-Fe-F-PbO2 [70]; Ti4 O7 /PbO2 [71]; Ti5 O9 /PbO2 [71]; Ti/RuO2 [52,72]; SnO2 [52,72–74]; Sb(SnO2 ) [74]; Ni(SnO2 ) [74]; PbO2 /Ti [12,20]; Fe-PbO2 /Ti [12]; Ti/[IrO2 -Nb2 O5 ] [46,75–77]; TaO2 [77]; Ti(Pt-TaO2 /Ti) [77,78]; Ti/(IrO2 + Ta2 O5 ) [46]; or glassy carbon [2,20,46,52]. Electrochemical ozone production efficiencies can also be increased if special electrolytes are used—namely SPEs or aqueous electrolytes with fluoride-containing conducting salts [16,75]. Using PbO2 at the high anodic potentials involved, the same oxygen species may be involved in the formation of O3 in addition to O2 , as illustrated in the pathway described below [2,16,20,23,48,79–85]: Electrochemical Steps: Kinetic Control: H2 O → H+ + ( • OH)ads + e−
(13.13)
( • OH)ads → (O • )ads + H+ + e−
(13.14)
Chemical Steps: Efficiency Control: (O • )ads → [1 − θ ](O • )ads + θ (O • )∗ads
(13.15)
(0 < θ <1)
[1 − θ ](2O )ads → [1 − θ ](O2 )ads •
[1 − θ ](O2 )ads → [1 − β][1 − θ ](O2 )ads + β[1 − θ ](O2 )∗ads
(13.16) (0 < β<1) (13.17)
Oxygen Evolution: 2( • OH)ads → O2 + 2H+ + 2e−
(13.18)
2(O • )ads → (O2 )ads → O2
(13.19)
[1 − β][1 − θ ](O2 )ads → O2 ↑
(13.20)
Ozone Formation: (O • )ads + (O2 )ads → (O3 )ads → O3
(13.21)
θ (O • ) ∗ads +β[1 − θ ](O2 )∗ads → [θ + β[1 − θ ]](O3 )ads
(13.22)
[θ + β[1 − θ ]](O3 )ads → O3 ↑
(13.23)
where θ and β indicate the partial surface coverages describing what characterizes the competition between oxygen evolution reaction and electrochemical ozone production processes. respectively; whereas “*” represents the surface coverage by oxygenated species leading that yield to O3 —formation.
322
OZONE GENERATION USING BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ELECTRODES
Current efficiencies for O3 generation are significantly larger at Fe (III)-doped PbO2 film electrodes as compared to the current efficiencies of pure β-PbO2 , due to the apparent electrocatalytic effect of the Fe (III) sites in Fe-PbO2 anodes. The oxygen from the hydroxyl species on Pb (IV) sites is transferred to the O2 molecule adsorbed at an adjacent Fe (IIII) sites to produce O3 , as [12]: H2 O → ( • OH)ads + H+ + e−
(13.24)
(O2 )ads + ( • OH)ads → O3 + H+ + e−
(13.25)
or [20]: H2 O → • OH + H+ + e−
(13.26)
( • OH) → (O)ads + H+ + e−
(13.27)
2(OH)ads → (O2 )ads → (O2 )
(13.28)
(O)ads + (O2 )ads → O3
(13.29)
In the specific case of Ti/[IrO2 − Nb2 O5 ] or Ti/(IrO2 + Ta2 O5 ), Santana, De Faria, and Boodts [77] and Da Silva et al. [46] propose that the ozone is formed in the high overpotential region (j ≥ 0.4 A cm−2 ). In this case, O3 formation strongly depends on an effective encounter between O2 and O • , which, in turn, depends on the partial surface concentration of the oxygen intermediates, as: Kinetic Control Steps: ≡ S + H2 O →≡ S −∗ OH + H+ + e−
(13.30)
≡ S −∗ OH →≡ S − OH
(13.31) +
≡ S − OH →≡ S − O + H + e
−
2 ≡ S − OH → 2 ≡ S + O2 + 2H+ + 2e−
(13.32) (13.33)
Efficiency Control Steps: ≡ S − O → [1 − θ ] ≡ S − O + θ ≡ S∗ − O
(13.34)
[1 − θ ]2 ≡ S − O → [1 − θ ]2 ≡ S − O2
(13.35)
[1 − θ ]2 ≡ S − O2 → [1 − β][1 − θ ]2 ≡ S − O2 + β[1 − θ ]2 ≡ S∗ − O2 (13.36) Oxygen Evolution: [1 − β][1 − θ ]2 ≡ S − O2 → O2 ↑
(13.37)
Ozone Formation: ≡ S − O + O2 →≡ S + O3
(13.38)
θ ≡ S ∗ −O + β[1 − θ ]2 ≡ S ∗ −O2 → [θ + β(1 − θ )]3 ≡ S − O3
(13.39)
[θ + β(1 − θ )]3 ≡ S − O3 → O3 ↑
(13.40)
13.3 TECHNOLOGIES FOR PRODUCING OZONE
323
where S is an active surface site, θ and β indicate the partial surface coverages describing the competition between oxygen evolution and electrochemical ozone production, and the asterisk represents the surface coverage by oxygenated species that ultimately form O3 . One of the major technical limitations for the electrochemical generation of ozone is the anode material. For example, •
PbO2 anodes are currently used because the material is cheap and it is relatively stable under the high positive potentials required [20], with relatively high current efficiencies [86]. It must be protected from chemical reduction by applying an external current [87]. • Glassy carbon is used in a very limited range of materials suitable for ozone evolution [20]. It is easily corroded in acid solution [87]. • Pt is too costly for practical applications and produces high current efficiencies only at very low temperatures [52,88]. It is consumed due to a high rate of wear [87]. • Dimensional stable anode (DSA) materials have not proven to be stable for ozone evolution and have shown very poor current efficiencies [52,72]. On the basis of these comparisons, BDD is expected to be useful for ozone generation in which a high product purity would be required [87]. In the last several years, new doped diamond electrodes have been developed and thoroughly investigated. Several studies have attempted to use diamond as an electrochemical electrode for wastewater treatment and electroanalysis. It was discovered that diamond possesses a wider electrochemical window and a lower background current than other electrodes [46,87–94]. Aside from these interesting properties, diamond is distinguished by its exceptionally high overvoltage for oxygen evolution in aqueous electrolytes, which makes it an even more highly efficient • OH radical producer. 13.3.3.2 Boron-Doped Diamond (BDD) Diamond is a wide bandgap p-type semiconductor [95,96] with a unique and extraordinary combination of electronic properties (high breakdown voltage [97,98], electron/hole mobility [99], and carrier saturation velocity [100]); mechanical properties (high hardness and strength); chemical inertness; stability; and high thermal conductivity [101–104]. In contrast to natural diamonds, synthetic diamonds contain inclusions of a metalcarbon solid solution that originate from the growth environment. The number of inclusions can be considerably reduced by decreasing the crystal growth rate, but this yields several technical problems [95]. During synthesis, the structure of diamond crystals can be doped with boron in the C–H–B system. The results demonstrate that the addition of boron to the binary system C–H (naphthalene) notably reduces the pressure and temperature required for diamond synthesis. One possible reason for this observation is that boron-doping forms structurally imperfect graphite as an intermediate step to diamond synthesis [96]. Microwave plasma chemical vapor deposition (MPCVD) [105–107,113] and hot filament chemical vapor deposition (HFCVD) [96,108,109,112] are two of the most extensively used techniques for depositing diamond films [102]. High-pressure high-temperature (HPHT) technologies are used as well [93,104,110–113]. Boron-doped diamond presents a very high overpotential for both oxygen and hydrogen evolution in acidic conditions. This electrode leads to a wide potential
324
OZONE GENERATION USING BORON-DOPED DIAMOND ELECTRODES
window (approximately 3.5 V) that can be used for other electrochemical reactions in the presence of aqueous electrolytes [93]. Diamond electrodes, indeed, have the largest potential window measured thus far in aqueous electrolytes. This differentiates them from common electrode materials, such as gold, platinum, or mixed metal oxide DSA-type electrodes [114]. For example, the oxygen evolution potential on BDD is 2.4 V in 0.2 M H2 S O4 [114,115]. This is much higher than 1.5 V for Pt, which demonstrates that BDD is more beneficial for the direct and indirect oxidation of organic compounds than Pt, and the reaction efficiency on BDD is higher than for Pt [115]. The width of the window decreases with the quality of the film and the incorporation of nondiamond sp2 carbon impurities, and its response resembles that obtained from glassy carbon and highly oriented pyrolytic graphite [93,96,116–126]. The large oxygen overpotential of BDD in water is due to the fact that BDD is a nonactive electrode material (it not oxidizable, similar to SnO2 or PbO2 ). Form