Teacher–Parent Collaboration describes specific challenges that arise in schools and early childhood settings which commonly require collaboration between teachers and parents. Separate chapters outline how teachers can respond to the needs of parents whose sons or daughters have disabilities or chronic illness, are gifted learners, are displaying disruptive or aggressive behaviour (including bullying) at school, or whose families are enduring adversity or child neglect or abuse. This book describes how teachers can collaborate with parents to resolve these challenges to improve the children’s functioning and achievement throughout their education years.
ISBN 978-0-86431-623-3
Teacher–Parent Collaboration Early childhood to adolescence
LOUISE PORTER
About the author Dr Louise Porter PhD, MA (Hons), MGiftedEd, DipEd is a child psychologist and trained teacher with almost 30 years’ experience working with children, their parents and educators. She has published widely and is currently an adjunct senior lecturer in Education at Flinders University, South Australia.
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
Teacher–Parent Collaboration: Early childhood to adolescence describes the skills teachers will need for productive collaboration with their students’ parents. It employs a solution-focused approach which honours the diversity of families, respects the expertise of both parents and teachers and promotes authentic communication between them.
9 780864 316233
LOUISE PORTER
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd i
15/1/08 11:47:33 AM
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd ii
15/1/08 11:47:34 AM
4EACHERn0ARENTå #OLLABORATION Early childhood to adolescence
LOUISE PORTER ACER Press
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd iii
15/1/08 11:47:34 AM
First published 2008 by ACER Press, an imprint of Australian Council for Educational Research Ltd 19 Prospect Hill Road, Camberwell Victoria, 3124, Australia www.acerpress.com.au
[email protected] Text © Louise Porter 2008 Design and typography © ACER Press 2008 This book is copyright. All rights reserved. Except under the conditions described in the Copyright Act 1968 of Australia and subsequent amendments, and any exceptions permitted under the current statutory licence scheme administered by Copyright Agency Limited (www.copyright.com.au), no part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, transmitted, broadcast or communicated in any form or by any means, optical, digital, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the written permission of the publisher. Edited by Renée Otmar, Otmar Miller Consultancy, Melbourne Cover design by Andrew Ritchie Text design by Kerry Cooke, eggplant communications Typeset by Kerry Cooke, eggplant communications Printed in Australia by Hyde Park Press National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-Publication data: Porter, Louise. Teacher-parent collaboration : early childhood to adolescence. Bibliography. Includes index. ISBN 9780864316233 (pbk). 1. Education - Parent participation. 2. Parent-teacher relationships. 3. Home and school. I. Title. 371.192
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd iv
15/1/08 11:47:34 AM
Contents
Part I
Dedication
ix
Foundations of collaboration
1
1
Rationale for collaborating with parents Parent–teacher relationship styles Dimensions of parental involvement A rationale for collaboration Measures for supporting parents’ interest in their children’s education Conclusion
3 3 10 15 15 21
2
Honouring diversity Family composition and size Working parents Child care Divorce Single parenthood Young mothers Lesbian mothers Stepfamilies Intermittent parental absence Grandparent guardians Families from minority cultures Engaging diverse families Conclusion Additional resources
23 23 24 25 27 29 31 31 32 33 33 34 35 39 40
3
Communication skills Interaction styles Authentic listening Assertiveness Collaborative problem solving
41 42 44 48 52
v
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd v
15/1/08 11:47:34 AM
vi
Contents
4
Conclusion Additional resources
54 54
Solution-focused problem solving Guiding principles Steps for solution building View problems differently Solution-focused consultation Referrals Conclusion Additional resources
55 55 57 66 69 71 71 72
Part II Problem solving with parents 5
6
7
8
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd vi
Collaborating with parents of children with disabilities or chronic illnesses Parents’ reactions to their child’s disability Services sought by parents Children living with chronic illness Communicating with parents of able children Conclusion Additional resources
73 75 75 79 87 91 92 92
Collaborating with parents of gifted learners Sources of conflict between teachers and parents of gifted learners Provisions sought by parents of gifted learners Support for parents Conclusion Additional resources
94 99 104 112 114 114
Collaborating with parents to solve disruptive behaviour Attention deficits Educational assessment Educational interventions Behavioural guidance Support for parents Conclusion Additional resources
116 117 119 120 121 126 127 128
Collaborating with parents to solve school-based aggression and bullying Developmental trends in aggression
129 129
15/1/08 11:47:34 AM
Contents
vii
Types of aggression Responding to the concerns of parents of victims Collaborating with parents of perpetrators Conclusion Additional resources
131 140 145 150 151
9
Supporting families who are experiencing adversity Effects of family adversity Chaotic households Stressed neighbourhoods Poverty Parents with disabilities Parents with mental illness Parental drug use Parental conflict Spousal abuse Family bereavement Promoting resilience in disadvantaged students Support for parents Conclusion Additional resources
152 153 153 153 154 157 158 159 160 161 162 164 166 169 169
10
Collaborating with parents whose children are abused Types of abuse A profile of perpetrators Effects of abuse Support for students Support for parents Responding to allegations of abuse by staff Conclusion Additional resources
171 172 173 176 182 184 187 188 188
Bibliography Index
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd vii
189 255
15/1/08 11:47:34 AM
Figures and Tables
Figures I.1 4.1 7.1 8.1
Components of collaboration in schools Phases of solution-focused problem solving A recursive cycle of escalating disruptiveness and coercion Types of aggression
2 56 122 132
Tables 1.1 1.2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 3.1
Continuum of parent–teacher relationship styles Effects of parents’ self-efficacy on their style of involvement in schools Number of births to cohorts of Australian women Percentage of marriages with both partners still alive Percentage of marriages with both partners still alive and together Percentage of Australian sole-parent families with dependent children Communication styles determined by perceptions of self and parents
4 20 24 27 27 30 41
viii
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd viii
15/1/08 11:47:34 AM
Dedication
To my daughter’s Steiner teachers, in gratitude and admiration
ix
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd ix
15/1/08 11:47:34 AM
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd x
15/1/08 11:47:34 AM
Part I Foundations of collaboration Your students will feel safe when they see the adults from the two parts of their lives, school and home, come together to focus on their interests. When, in your interactions, you honour your students’ parents, the students themselves will feel honoured (Keyser 2006). And when children see their parents relating comfortably with their teachers, they perceive this as ‘permission’ to develop comfort and trust in you also (Keyser 2006). Through their interactions with each other, parents and teachers gain access to information, acknowledgment, support and a sounding board for their educational concerns about students, while authentic interactions between them enhance the self-confidence of both (Keyser 2006). Of course, when referring to ‘parents’ throughout this book, I include any caregivers who are significant to young people in schools, regardless of whether these adults are the students’ biological parents or not. In many families, grandparents or other extended family members have crucial roles as elders, or as prime or supplementary care providers for children. Similarly, although in this book I address you as the teacher, the principles of collaboration apply to any paediatric professional whose role is to teach children or promote their development. As a teacher or other professional, your primary responsibilities are to the children in your care. However, any individuals who are in ongoing contact unavoidably have an influence on each other (Fisch & Schlanger 1999). Therefore, what happens with your students during their day at school goes home with them and reverberates within their family environment. And some of what happens at home comes in with them when they start their day at school. Like the ripples that spread outwards when a pebble is dropped into a pond, events in one location can affect individuals elsewhere. This interplay between children and their
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 1
15/1/08 11:47:34 AM
2
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
families means that your role is more multifaceted than simply relating with students. You need also to be attuned to their family experience. Collaboration with your students’ parents is a process built upon a personal commitment, which comes from having a clear rationale and a high level of collective and personal self-efficacy. This commitment, which honours the diverse structures and backgrounds of families, employs authentic communication skills, provides curricula and solutions to problems that are in tune with parents’ and students’ aspirations, and occurs within a parent-driven relationship. These elements are depicted in Figure I.1. Parent-driven context
Personal commitment
Honouring diversity
Authentic communication
Solutions
Figure I.1: Components of collaboration in schools Source: adapted from Friend & Cook (2007, p. 23)
The four chapters in Part I of this book describe these components of collaboration in schools, while the chapters in Part II apply them to specific, school-based challenges that commonly require collaboration with parents.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 2
15/1/08 11:47:34 AM
1
Rationale for collaborating with parents
Entering interactions only to give – whether knowledge, support, direction, or something else – with no acknowledgement of what others can contribute, inhibits not only what we might receive but also the full potential of what we seek to give. Barrera & Corso (2002, p. 106)
A student’s adjustment to school relies, at least in part, on the practical and emotional resources made available to him or her over the years from home, school and the wider community (Christenson 2004; Deslandes et al. 1999). An over-riding rationale for collaborating with your students’ parents, then, is to coordinate these sources of support. Parents and teachers commonly believe in the value of education, want the best for children and want them to be happy at school. Yet, teacher– parent relations are often strained (Hughes & MacNaughton 2002). I contend that this is because their relationships are based on a flawed model that entrenches a power imbalance between parents and teachers. The problem is one of politics.
Parent–teacher relationship styles As teachers, our reasons for engaging with parents in schools differ according to the model that we use to guide our interactions. As summarised in Table 1.1 (page 4), there is a continuum of parent–teacher relationship styles, ranging from those that are driven by professionals through to those directed by parents. These speak to the overt power differences between teachers and parents. However, in schools, parent–teacher relationships are also characterised by concealed power. Educators have supremacy by virtue of their expertise, being part of the system and being the ones who frame understandings of students’ disabilities or behavioural difficulties
3
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 3
15/1/08 11:47:34 AM
Source of their child’s problems Joint victims
Comply with practitioner advice Show deference towards professionals
Practitioners locate deficits within the child or family
Practitioners dictate goals and interventions
To advise parents of their child’s needs and program
One-way flow of information Parent training
Secondary schools
View of parents
Parents’ role
Assessment
Source of goals or priorities
Purpose of interaction with parents
Communication style
Common venues
Professional-driven
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 4
Primary schools Preschools Child care centres
Some early intervention services
Some private practitioners e.g. tutors, therapists
Communication aims to build a relationship and support parents’ interest in their child’s education Responsive to parents Collaborative consultation
To listen to parents so that practitioners can provide a service that meets their goals
Parents and students articulate their own goals or aspirations
Solution focused: identify solutions that are already in place
Parents steer their child’s education Parents choose their style of participation
Family leaders Teachers’ employers
Family-driven
Sources: Dunst 2002; Osher & Osher 2002
To empower parents to meet their child’s and family’s needs
Joint goal setting and shared decision making to meet family needs
Practitioners assess children’s needs and the family’s strengths
Parents and teachers share responsibility for planning and enacting programs
Equal participants with complementary skills and expertise
Family-centred
Communication is task Communication aims to build a focused relationship and empower parent Parent education participation
To engage parents in helping practitioners to teach their child
Parents consent to a program designed by practitioners
Practitioners assess children’s needs
Carry out assigned tasks to support their children’s learning at school and home
Agents of practitioners
Family-allied
Table 1.1: Continuum of parent–teacher relationship styles
4 Teacher–Parent Collaboration
15/1/08 11:47:34 AM
Rationale for collaborating with parents
5
(Fylling & Sandvin 1999). Furthermore, teachers are university educated and typically come from the middle classes and the dominant culture, while parents may be none of these things. Even without these differences in background, parents have needs that make them vulnerable (Waters 1996). When their child is young and a new school entrant, has recently changed schools, or has additional educational or emotional needs, parents are especially reliant on the quality of care and education that you provide their child. Yet, they have imperfect information on which to base their selection of school and, even when confident that they have selected the ‘right’ one, are painfully aware that they cannot anticipate problems that might arise after they have enrolled their child (Larner & Phillips 1994). Changes of teacher, the unfolding needs of a growing child and other unforeseen events can neither be anticipated nor guarded against. This vulnerability makes parents reliant on teachers.
Professional-driven interactions The first style of parent–teacher relationships is characterised by teacher dominance. When professionals ‘drive’ their relationships with parents, it is assumed that they are exclusively qualified to apply a specialised body of knowledge that is considered the only information relevant to the issue at hand (Osher & Osher 2002; Thompson et al. 1997). They are the ones to assess children’s needs, interpret these to parents and formulate a suitable program, with parents expected either to defer to practitioners’ diagnoses and comply with their recommendations, or clear the scene to allow the professionals to get on with their job. Parents must either accept professionals’ advice or go elsewhere (Osher & Osher 2002). From this elevated position, professionals often regard parents as the source of children’s problems, particularly when their family is disadvantaged socially or has a structure other than the idealised nuclear family (Fylling & Sandvin 1999). Sometimes this view is softened into a conceptualisation of parents as joint victims with their child, as being somewhat fragile and in need of ‘empowerment’. For their part, children are considered too young, badly behaved, incompetent or troubled to participate in devising solutions to their problems (Osher & Osher 2002). Thus, within this model, professional diagnosis focuses on deficits, within children and/or their families. When students are making inadequate progress at school, for example, teachers often blame this on a lack of family support, rather than reflecting on the nature of teaching. Although this model is usually ascribed to the medical profession, from the middle of the 20th century some schools not only evolved an unwritten ethos of ‘No parents past this point’, but on school gates some
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 5
15/1/08 11:47:34 AM
6
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
actually posted signs to that effect. This view has been termed ‘turfism’. One review found it to be common in schools today, particularly at secondary level (Dunst 2002). Turfism dictates that parents should assist their children with their school work and behaviour, but must not interfere by questioning teachers about their curriculum or teaching strategies (Daniels & Shumow 2003). Within this style of relationship, the rationale for engaging with parents is largely to give them enough information to explain the professional’s recommendations and how he or she is planning to achieve these. Hence, communication largely entails a one-way flow of information from the practitioner to parents. The first disadvantage of professional dominance is that it can work only when short-lived, but will not sustain an ongoing relationship (Galil et al. 2006). During a medical crisis or when a child’s learning difficulties are being diagnosed, for example, it is clearly vital that parents receive enough information to be able to make prudent decisions. But even in these instances, the professional’s expert stance makes it less likely that information about children’s needs will be provided sensitively or with follow-up so that parents can ask their questions (Whitehead & Gosling 2003). Instead, a hierarchical frame of reference and deficit orientation lead to attempts at ‘parent education’, which implies a one-way flow of information from the skilled (the professionals) to the unskilled and inadequate (that is, parents) (Winton, Sloop & Rodriguez 1999). The effectiveness of this style of parent training is doubtful, however. Some research has found that the quality of parenting improves barely at all, with only weak benefits for children’s development or behaviour (Fagan & Iglesias 1999; Wagner, Spiker & Linn 2002). In short, this is not a model for the 21st century. It cannot equip teachers with the information from parents that they need to teach their students well, nor secure for them the support of parents. Its deficit orientation criticises parents and leaves teachers feeling increasingly pessimistic over time about their inability to counteract family ‘inadequacies’ (Daniels & Shumow 2003). It sets up teachers to fail by expecting them to be the ones to generate solutions to problems that are beyond their sphere of influence. And this professional-driven stance contravenes both the spirit and provisions of departmental policies on parent collaboration.
Family-allied relationships Epitomised in the platitude that, ‘Parents are their child’s first (or best) teachers’, a common stance within schools, preschools and child-care centres is that parents should actively help teachers to educate their children (Dunst 2002). This view recognises that families and parents cannot work in isolation: parents need schools and teachers need parents
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 6
15/1/08 11:47:34 AM
Rationale for collaborating with parents
7
(Christenson 2004). Therefore, educators accept the responsibility to communicate with parents about their child’s education, while parents are expected to support the school. Nevertheless, this parental engagement is often only in token activities that do not challenge teachers’ domain, with teachers directing parents and the two working in parallel rather than jointly (Elliott 2003). However, even these relatively modest expectations for parents are both excessive and unworkable. They are excessive because it is not parents’ job to act as their children’s teachers, to ‘police’ homework completion, or to discipline their children at home for problems that occur at school. Parents function best as parents: they ‘should not try to feel like teachers, or act like social workers or behave like psychologists’ (Blodgett 1971, p. 92). And the expectations are unworkable, because parents’ instructional support is seldom beneficial. For children with disabilities, for example, placing parents in the role of their child’s instructor does not improve outcomes for children, and can even be detrimental to them and to their family (Foster, Berger & McLean 1981; Ramey & Ramey 1992; White, Taylor & Moss 1992). Formal instruction highlights for parents their child’s difficulties, can focus them on the next developmental skill and thus deny them the opportunity to appreciate their child’s present skills and qualities, can limit the exchange of affection between parent and child as the parent becomes task focused rather than nurturing, and can require parents to neglect their other commitments to themselves and other family members (Harris & McHale 1989). Instead, across the ability range, formal teaching by parents is less vital than merely reading to their young children. This is beneficial both because it fosters children’s literacy skills and allows them thereafter to access information independently (Halle, Kurtze-Costes & Mahoney 1997). The second reason that a family–allied model fails us in schools is similar to the shortcomings of professional-driven relationships. This is that, in dictating how parents should raise their children, it pits teachers against those parents who do not conform to expectations. An adversarial and confrontational relationship is established, which leads to more negative or fewer interactions between teachers and nonconformist parents (RimmKaufman & Pianta 1999). The end result is that the parents and students who most need teacher support in order to be educationally successful are the ones who are least likely to receive it (Hill & Taylor 2004; RimmKaufman, Pianta & Cox 2000; Schulting, Malone & Dodge 2005).
A family-centred philosophy Family-centred relationships are based on a philosophy of openness to parents. They uphold that schools and families share the common task of educating young people (Adams & Christenson 2000). Therefore, power
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 7
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
8
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
between parents and teachers is equalised (Daka-Mulwanda, Thornburg & Klein 1995), with the two collaborating to determine goals for children’s education, jointly planning strategies and sharing responsibility for delivering educational programs (Friend & Cook 2007; Hostetler 1991). Nevertheless, while power is shared between parents and teachers, the two can fulfil different roles, as negotiated between them. This philosophy recognises that teachers and parents have complementary expertise. Thus, family-centred practice entails both equal status and parity, which refers to valuing and blending each partner’s ideas and knowledge (Christenson 2004; Friend & Cook 2007). While recognising teachers’ expertise, a collaborative stance also appreciates that parents have the most important and enduring relationship with their children, possess detailed knowledge about them across time and in a variety of settings, have a strong commitment to their children and families, and know best how to meet their family’s and individual children’s needs. By harnessing this intimate knowledge, you gain information that helps you to teach these students, while feeling assured of parents’ support for your efforts. In a departure from the deficit orientation characterised by the two interaction styles described previously, family-centred relationships focus on the strengths of both students and their families (although the presumption that practitioners are the rightful diagnosticians of these assets violates the principles of true collaboration). Having diagnosed, teachers and parents will jointly design an intervention to meet the needs of children and their parents. On the understanding that, when families are functioning successfully children can function successfully, some support focuses directly on the parents, not just the child (Dunst, Trivette & Deal 1994; McWilliam, Maxwell & Sloper 1999). Communication aims to empower both parents and teachers to meet students’ needs (Turnbull et al. 2006) by exchanging information and building a relationship that enables them to function as equal and joint participants in decision making. There are two disadvantages of this model. First is that there is little evidence of its effectiveness. One study within early intervention found no developmental gains for children with disabilities, no reductions in parental stress, nor any improvements in parent–child interaction patterns in those programs that were family centred, compared with those that were child centred (Mahoney & Bella 1998). Second, despite being a legislative requirement within special education in the United States (Deslandes et al. 1999) and being stated education policy in many other places, family-centred practice is rare in early intervention services and even less common in preschools and schools (Dunst 2002; McWilliam et al. 1999). Even when enacted, it is tinged with the sense that schools
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 8
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
Rationale for collaborating with parents
9
are ‘giving’ parents equality, rather than that equality is their entitlement (Roffey 2002). Many writers explain the dearth of family centredness in schools as being due to teachers’ lack of training for collaborating with parents (e.g. Bruder 2000; Soodak et al. 2002). However, when practice so often falls short of its stated goals, the fault cannot lie with such vast numbers of practitioners. Instead, the model is failing them. Family-centred practice is impractical in schools because teachers lack the resources (especially time) that they would need to establish frequent enough contacts with parents (Rimm-Kaufman & Pianta 1999). This is particularly so for high schools, where teachers instruct a large number of classes and thus would have to form relationships with unmanageable numbers of parents. For their part, parents must develop trust in many teachers (Adams & Christenson 2000). This inevitably results in a lessened focus on parent–teacher interactions at this age level (Cattley 2004). Thus, whereas the family-allied model imposes inappropriate expectations on parents, a family-centred model imposes inappropriate expectations on teachers, particularly when it comes to supporting students and families with multiple problems. While it is fair to expect teachers to be skilled communicators – as that is the essence of teaching – it is unreasonable to expect them to possess the counselling skills and experience needed to act as social workers, psychologists or counsellors. The more challenging the students, the more skilled teachers have to be at their job – but their job is teaching. In a diverse society, this is enough to expect. Children need dental care, but that does not mean that their teachers should perform dentistry along with their other duties. We must let teachers do what they do best: teach – and, when students and their families have issues that are beyond teachers’ sphere of responsibility, to refer them to relevant outside services.
A parent-driven model In its stance that teachers and parents are full and equal partners, familycentred practice gives too much power to professionals – without, however, giving them the resources or knowledge base to exercise that power. The one remaining option, then, is for teachers to adopt a parentdriven model to guide their relationships with their students’ parents. This stance honours parents’ role as family leaders. It recognises that, more than being mere consumers or even equal participants in a partnership with you, parents are actually your employers. Their function is not to help you teach their children, but the reverse: they employ you to assist them in raising skilled, knowledgeable and well adjusted children. They
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 9
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
10
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
hire you for your expertise as an educator, much as they might employ doctors, naturopaths or other practitioners to consult about their children’s health, and tutors and various therapists to advise on children’s developmental or atypical educational needs. Parents pay your salary by way of private school fees or taxes for public education. Therefore, your task is to further their aims for their children. In a parent-driven model, you are accountable to parents: they are not accountable to you. Using the analogy of taking a road trip, in a parent-driven approach, parents work out the route, with the practitioner holding the map as a guide so that the parents can reach their destination satisfied by the journey and its outcome (Tannen 1996, in Osher & Osher 2002). In other words, parents are the ones to steer their children’s education. This style of interaction assumes that parents know more about themselves and their family than outsiders ever will (Selekman 1997). It also assumes that young people have the capacity to contribute to solving their own problems. Both students and their parents are the experts in their own needs. This stance extends beyond the family-centred notion of empowering parents, arguing that in reality you cannot give people skills that they are incapable of performing (Murphy 2006). Instead, all that students and their parents need is enfranchisement to use the skills they already have. The parent-driven model shares the aims of the family-centred approach – namely, to build constructive relationships with parents and support their interest in their children’s education. This transforms communication from ‘telling’ parents to listening to them (Dunst, Trivette & Deal 1988, 1994; Sokoly & Dokecki 1995). Parent ‘education’ becomes collaborative consultation through which professionals respond to parents’ expressed requests for information, rather than assuming what parents need to learn and imposing training on them (Winton et al. 1999).
Dimensions of parental involvement Parental engagement with their children’s schooling can span three dimensions: values, beliefs and aspirations; indirect support and involvement at home; and direct engagement at school (Fan 2001; Grolnick et al. 1997; Hong & Ho 2005; Kohl et al. 2000; Raffaele & Knoff 1999; Scott-Jones 1995; Singh et al. 1995). Parents’ values, beliefs and aspirations about education explain why they become involved, while the remaining two dimensions describe the form their involvement takes (Fan 2001). These three dimensions may be quite distinct from each other, have differing effects on children’s educational outcomes (Fan 2001; Keith et al. 1998) and will be more or less appropriate and effective, depending on the children’s ages (Singh et al. 1995).
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 10
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
Rationale for collaborating with parents
11
Values, beliefs and aspirations Parents’ negative values, particularly their attitudes to schooling itself, will to some extent limit their educational involvement. Some parents distrust schooling altogether as a result of their own schooling history (Miller 2003; Roffey 2002). Many have residual feelings of anger, fear or distrust of teachers as a result of their childhood school experiences (Rafaelle & Knoff 1999), while some from minority cultures or socially disadvantaged groups regard middle-class education as a form of imperial colonisation. Many parents resent the dictates of teachers and intrusions by schools into their family life, such as with the imposition of homework. Such negative parental attitudes indirectly reduce children’s educational attainments by minimising their academic engagement and also by lowering teachers’ expectations, particularly when teachers perceive a difference in education-related values between themselves and their students’ parents (Hauser-Cram, Sirin & Stipek 2003). On the other hand, parents’ positive values do not necessarily lead to active engagement in their children’s education (Jodl et al. 2001): their engagement will also depend to some extent on parents’ beliefs about their own versus teachers’ roles. Parents from lower socioeconomic circumstances tend to give schools more autonomy over their children’s education than do middle-class parents (Wood & Baker 1999). Across all groups, however, some believe that schools should meet their children’s educational needs; others assess that schools are not adequately resourced to do this and therefore that they must provide supplemental teaching at home; while still others value home time as an opportunity for relaxation and leisure, not for doing more schoolwork (Coots 1998). Thus, when children have learning difficulties, some parents respond by increasing the amount of academic work that they oversee at home, while others reduce it to nil to give their children time to relax (Coots 1998). Those with the economic resources to hire tutors sometimes prefer this to teaching their children themselves (Coots 1998). In terms of aspirations, most parents want their children to do well in school, have friends and contribute to their communities in adulthood (Hanson et al. 1998). They hold optimistic expectations for their children’s futures (Halle et al. 1997; Wood & Baker 1999). Nevertheless, when asked how much schooling they would like their child to complete, their expectations in large part reflect their children’s actual abilities and become more realistic as these unfold over time (Clare, Garnier & Gallimore 1998; De Civita et al. 2004; Singh et al. 1995). Parents who themselves are well educated expect their children to be also (Davis-Kean 2005; Singh et al. 1995). It is not surprising, therefore, that research consistently finds that parents with high aspirations for their children’s learning tend to have
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 11
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
12
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
children who are academically successful, hold positive attitudes towards school and are well adjusted emotionally and socially (Demaray & Malecki 2002; Demaray et al. 2005; Deslandes et al. 1997; Englund et al. 2004; Fan 2001; Fan & Chen 2001; Feinstein & Symons 1999; Flouri 2006; Flouri, Buchanan & Bream 2002; Gonzalez-DeHass, Willems & Holbein 2005; Hill et al. 2004; Izzo et al. 1999; McBride, Schoppe-Sullivan & Ho 2005; McWayne et al. 2004b; Marcon 1999; Miedel & Reynolds 1999; Paulson 1994; Ratelle et al. 2004; Shumow, Vandell & Posner 1999). But most of these benefits are due to the children’s innate abilities and reflect the advantages of being middle-class (Fan 2001). Children who are economically advantaged receive enough home stimulation to achieve well academically, with or without parental engagement at school (Dearing et al. 2006a; McWayne et al. 2004b). Parents’ high aspirations do, however, have some small additional benefits, over and above the advantages children enjoy from being capable and receiving adequate stimulation and resources. One study found that higher levels of parental aspirations lowered the likelihood of academic failure during primary school by 48 per cent compared with equally poor but low-aspiring parents (De Civita et al. 2004). When parents hold higher aspirations, the children themselves develop high self-appraisals and consequently achieve better initially and make more academic progress than those with similar aptitude but whose parents have lower expectations (Fan 2001; Halle et al. 1997). Particularly in the primary school years, parents’ aspirations influence young people’s commitment to schooling by conveying to them the sense that their parents value both them and their education (Bouchey & Harter 2005; De Civita et al. 2004; GonzalezDeHass et al. 2005; Hong & Ho 2005; Jodl et al. 2001; Marchant, Paulson & Rothlisberg 2001; Noack 2004; Scott-Jones 1995). In turn, young people internalise their parents’ values about effort and learning.
Indirect involvement at home Parents can encourage their children’s educational attainment through providing indirect support at home. This can involve keeping informed of what is happening for their children at school, monitoring their academic progress, reading to them and providing intellectually stimulating activities for them at home and within the community. These forms of emotional support actually have more influence on children’s academic outcomes than parents’ direct participation at school (Ho & Willms 1996). The benefits are particularly tangible during early childhood, when parents’ high-quality instruction and guidance teach children to regulate their emotions and, thereby, help their children to develop the task attack and social skills that are necessary for academic success (Englund et al. 2004; Hill & Craft 2003).
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 12
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
Rationale for collaborating with parents
13
A more interventionist form of home-based support is providing active help with children’s schoolwork. As well as their values affecting whether they take on this role (as already discussed), there are three additional constraints on parents’ abilities to do this. First, their children’s characteristics can influence this choice. For example, when children have behavioural difficulties, their parents are less willing to incite outbursts by attempting formal tutoring or supervising their homework (Coots 1998). Second, some parents may want to assist their children’s learning at home but they themselves received little education and therefore need additional information from teachers to guide them (Hill et al. 2004; Kohl et al. 2000). A third group of parents are immigrants. Those with little proficiency in English are often reluctant to be present at school and may lack knowledge about the local education system and curriculum (having been educated in their homeland). This can limit their practical support for their children’s learning at home, although these constraints will not limit their educational aspirations or emotional support for their children (Wood & Baker 1999).
Direct engagement at school A second, more visible, form of parent engagement in their children’s education is direct involvement at school. This can occur through attending parent–teacher meetings, being an audience at their children’s school performances, assisting in the classroom, collaborating with teachers to make educational decisions for their child, volunteering on fundraising activities or staffing the canteen and contributing to the development of school policies. However, many parents experience a range of practical impediments to becoming directly involved or present at school. The most significant of these is the competing demands posed by their employment status, having a young baby and moving home (Castro et al. 2004; LambParker et al. 2001). Next, family stress, impoverishment and single parenting (Grolnick et al. 1997; McWayne et al. 2004b), inflexible working hours and purely practical issues such as problems with transport, babysitting and shift work, all limit the flexibility and resources available to support parents’ involvement, particularly of parents with low incomes. Nevertheless, these impediments may limit only their presence, not their educational aspirations for their children or emotional investment and personal interest in their education (Grolnick et al. 1997; Ho & Willms 1996). Parents’ direct engagement in their children’s education seems particularly beneficial during the early childhood years. As well as the indirect instruction that they provide at home, engagement in their child’s care or educational setting can provide parents with information and guidance about child development and parenting dilemmas. This information contributes to more responsive parenting which, in turn,
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 13
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
14
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
enhances children’s educational outcomes. However, by the late primary and high school years, parents’ direct engagement at school has no discernible effect on their children academically (Singh et al. 1995).
Conclusion: Dimensions of parental involvement The conclusion from an abundant body of research is clear: whether parents engage with their child’s schooling is actually less relevant than how they do so. Their overall parenting style, rather than parents’ school engagement as such, most influences children’s educational outcomes (Hill et al. 2004). Controlling parental involvement actually diminishes young people’s academic achievements (Deslandes et al. 1997; Grolnick & Ryan 1989; Hong & Ho 2005; Singh et al. 1995; Steinberg et al. 1992; Taylor, Hinton & Wilson 1995). Intrusive control in the form of authoritarian surveillance by parents of their children’s homework and their delivery of rewards for high grades generates in children less initiative and persistence (Baumrind 1967, 1971; Grolnick, Frodi & Bridges 1984), declining intrinsic motivation (Deci et al. 1993; Leung & Kwan 1998), less engagement in learning (de Kruif et al. 2000; Kim & Mahoney 2004) and greater negativity towards schoolwork (Dornbusch et al. 1987; Ginsberg & Bronstein 1993; Gonzalez-DeHass et al. 2005; Gottfried, Fleming & Gottfried 1994; Grolnick & Ryan 1989; Maccoby & Martin 1983; Parker et al. 1999; Paulson, Marchant & Rothlisberg 1998; Ratelle et al. 2004; Steinberg, Elmen & Mounts 1989; Steinberg et al. 1992, 1994). In turn, these negative learning styles lead to declining academic and social performances (Aunola & Nurmi 2004; Chen, Dong & Zhou 1997; Mattanah 2001). These findings are paralleled in the early childhood years, where one study found that egalitarian discipline and parents’ responsiveness to their children’s interests during play improved the children’s school readiness, whereas demanding or didactic parental instruction produced in children poorer task orientation and greater negativity towards school work (Parker et al. 1999). Similar conclusions apply to children’s extracurricular activities: young people benefit when their parents facilitate and support their recreational endeavours (Jodl et al. 2001), but when parents pressure or control children’s sporting engagement, the children become less motivated, more anxious, enjoy the activities less, develop less proficiency and are more likely to cease participating (Anderson et al. 2003). In contrast are parents who take an interest in their children’s schooling, without attempting to direct or control it. The benefits of this style of engagement have been demonstrated in studies showing that, while the literacy skills of children whose mothers have little education are typically behind their peers’, when these mothers become responsively
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 14
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
Rationale for collaborating with parents
15
involved in their children’s schooling, the gaps in both the children’s skills and their self-appraisals dissipate (Dearing et al. 2006a). Thus, parents’ interest and emotional support – both in education and beyond – helps young people, whereas parental control is detrimental emotionally and to students’ performances. This is explained by selfdetermination theory (Deci & Ryan 2000, Ryan & Deci 2000), which holds that being self-governed (that is, autonomous) is an innate human need. Therefore, young people will be well adjusted emotionally when their parents allow them to steer their own course in life based on their personal values (Soenens et al. 2007). In reverse, they will resist and rebel against imposed controls as these violate their need for personal autonomy (Porter 2007a, 2007b, 2008).
A rationale for collaboration Guided by both a parent-driven model and the research reported so far on the effects of parents’ involvement in their children’s schooling, three conclusions can be drawn about the reasons to collaborate with parents. The first is that parents employ you to educate their children and, therefore, you are accountable to them for your performance of this task. It is your job to collaborate with your employers. Not only is that common courtesy, but it reflects the true lines of accountability. Second, parents’ interest in – but not control of – their children’s schooling enhances students’ progress, especially at young ages and particularly for disadvantaged students (Dearing et al. 2006a). Even those parents with previous negative experiences or attitudes to education can come to endorse their child’s school when they have increased contact with their child’s teachers (Kohl et al. 2000). Therefore, you will need to invite and support their engagement. Third, when problems arise at school, parents are your best source of information about their child and how they have solved similar problems in the past. This third rationale for collaborating with parents in schools, then, is not that your relationships with them will inform, impel, encourage or even empower them to help you to teach their children – but simply that you need their advice and support to allow you to teach well.
Measures for supporting parents’ interest in their children’s education Comparing children who were similarly disadvantaged, one study found that those whose parents demonstrated interest in their schooling achieved 24 percentage points better on academic ability tests than similarly
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 15
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
16
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
disadvantaged young people whose parents were disengaged (Feinstein & Symons 1999). The clear conclusion from this finding is that, beyond the early childhood years, when early stimulation and responsive parenting teach the specific skills of self-regulation, benefits of parental engagement in schooling accrue when parents take an interest in their children’s academic progress. To support parental interest, schools require sustained administrative commitment to establishing proactive relationships with parents (Raffaele & Knoff 1999).
Collective efficacy In the increasingly interdependent profession that is modern teaching, all individuals within a school need a sense that as a whole it has the capacity to operate collectively to achieve its mission (Caprara et al. 2003). This capacity is referred to as ‘collective efficacy’, which is individuals’ belief in their capacity individually and as a group to influence their work circumstances and students’ learning and behaviour (Friedman 2003). A sense of collective efficacy contributes to a school’s prestige and is a potent source of teachers’ job satisfaction (Caprara et al. 2003). It requires strong leadership from the principal and a well-qualified teaching team who individually and collectively fulfil their role obligations (Caprara et al. 2003).
An inviting school climate The most crucial practical measure influencing parents’ involvement in their child’s schooling is their perception of the school’s receptivity to them (Christenson 2004; Overstreet et al. 2005; Raffaele & Knoff 1999). Teachers’ attitudes and collaborative practices have a considerable influence on parents’ level of school engagement (Kohl et al. 2000), with one study finding that school practices accounted for just over 22 per cent of the differences in parental participation rates between schools (Ho & Willms 1996). When teachers invite parents to the school, they are more likely to come (Simon 2001). Typically, however, parents’ contact with teachers declines progressively from children’s first year of school (Adams & Christenson 2000; Izzo et al. 1999; Rimm-Kaufman & Pianta 1999). This is partly because older children are more reliable informants about events at school and therefore parents do not need to approach their children’s teachers directly for feedback about their daily activities, as is the case during the years prior to school. In addition, parents are attempting to give their older sons and daughters increasing independence. However, it also reflects diminishing invitations by the school. In one study, for example, 60 per cent of parents reported that their child’s school had not requested from them
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 16
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
Rationale for collaborating with parents
17
information about their child, 65 per cent reported that they had not been given information about their child’s progress at school and 70 per cent had not been invited to volunteer at school (Spera 2005). At the first contact, schools can communicate in writing their intention to collaborate with parents. A statement of intent, such as illustrated in Box 1.1, could be posted at the school office or included in the package of documents given to parents at enrolment. Such statements, of course, would be meaningless and even damaging unless followed up by specific and practical efforts to engage parents.
Box 1.1: Sample statement of philosophy about parent engagement Dear parent Our school is honoured that you have entrusted us with your child’s education. While our teachers have considerable knowledge and skills about children and teaching, we are also eager to learn from your expertise and knowledge about your particular child, family and culture. We invite your voice, your perspective and your participation as an advocate for your child and family as well as for our community of students and families. Our school is fortunate to include a diverse group of families, students and staff whose range of life experiences enriches the entire school community and each one of us individually. We believe that every family deserves support in its efforts to raise healthy and skilled children, and we work to build and encourage this support among families, school staff and the larger community. Source: Keyser (2006, pp. 85–86)
Maintain high expectations for students While parents’ aspirations have a modest effect on their children’s educational outcomes (as already reported), the quality of schooling their children receive is actually more influential. School quality accounts for between 20 and 25 per cent of differences between schools in student outcomes, with family and neighbourhood factors explaining only 15 per cent and students’ qualities just 10 per cent of their educational attainment (Boyle et al. 2007; Mortimore et al. 1988; Osterman 2000; Rutter 1983; Rutter & Maughan 2002; Sylva 1994). The quality of each classroom may be even more influential than the quality of the school overall (Sylva 1994), if only because classrooms vary so much more than
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 17
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
18
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
do schools. Therefore, your students’ parents depend on you far more than you depend on them to equip their children to learn. A core influence on student attainment is teacher expectation. As is the case for parents, these in large part reflect the students’ actual abilities (Hauser-Cram et al. 2003). However, when teachers expect less of their students, they subsequently employ less effective teaching strategies that actually lower student achievement (Rubie-Davies 2007). In fact, teacher expectations are so potent that they can be only partially offset by parents’ higher ambitions for their children (Benner & Mistry 2007).
Promote teachers’ self-efficacy Like parents, teachers need to be able to translate their high expectations into behaviours that support student learning, for which they require a sense of personal and professional self-efficacy (that is, a sense that they can control student outcomes). Teachers with low professional efficacy are more likely to become overwhelmed by their work, stressed by disruptions (Martin, Linfoot & Stephenson 1999) and more concerned with promoting order than with meeting students’ needs. They experience less job satisfaction and perceive colleagues, students and parents more negatively (Caprara et al. 2003). In contrast, those with high self-efficacy not only become less stressed but, when faced with challenges, take action to resolve problems rather than avoiding them or venting emotion inappropriately (Friedman 2003). Confident of their ability to generate solutions, rather than feeling helpless, teachers with high self-efficacy exhibit high levels of planning and organisation, are open to new ideas and willing to experiment with new approaches, implement varied programs, modify tasks to attract students’ engagement, create a supportive climate to maintain student involvement and foster mastery and students’ personal progress, rather than encouraging students to outperform each other (Caprara et al. 2006; Tollefson 2000; Wolters & Daugherty 2007). They are also more willing to collaborate with parents (Caprara et al. 2003). This is because, although few teachers receive any specific training for collaborating with parents, those who are confident of their expertise as teachers tend to be more open to collaboration, in all likelihood because they feel less threatened about having others scrutinise their work (Abbott-Shim, Lambert & McCarty 2000; Castro et al. 2004; Ghazvini & Readdick 1994).
Communicate regularly Mutual trust between parents and educators cannot develop in a vacuum, and is even more difficult to establish during crises, when emotions are
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 18
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
Rationale for collaborating with parents
19
likely to be running high. Instead, you must engender parents’ trust through frequent, ongoing, everyday responsive communication with them (Adams & Christenson 2000). There are many occasions when you can exchange information with parents, including orientation visits before their child starts at the school or in a new classroom; during everyday informal contacts; in brochures about the school’s policies and procedures; at meetings to review students’ progress; in newsletters; on bulletin boards; by asking parents about their priorities for their child’s education; and writing a letter to parents and students at the beginning of the school year to introduce yourself, your philosophy about education, the curriculum at that grade level and your aims for the year. As the year progresses, personal contact with parents over positive events at school is a powerful communication both for them and for students (Miller 2003; Miller, Ferguson & Moore 2002). Regular communication with parents about classroom learning activities, their child’s progress and ideas for supporting their child academically contribute to students’ intrinsic motivation (Gonzalez-DeHass et al. 2005) and can cement cooperation between parents and teachers by helping familiarise them with each other (Raffaele & Knoff 1999). With very young children in early childhood centres, parents want daily feedback so that they can vicariously experience their child’s day, discuss with their child his or her activities and, perhaps, follow these up at home for continuity (Elliott 2003). By school age, parents seldom need such a high frequency of communication, although those whose children have learning difficulties require more than school reports at the end of term, instead needing weekly updates (Bennett, Lee & Lueke 1998).
Foster parents’ self-efficacy Parents’ self-efficacy – their belief in their own capacity to influence their child’s schooling – is crucial for them to be willing to become involved (Coots 1998; Deslandes et al. 1999; Pelletier & Brent 2002; Seefeldt et al. 1999). Parents with high self-efficacy will be able to harness the family’s internal resources and secure any necessary support from outside the family in order to promote their children’s achievements (Thompson et al. 1997). They provide support in ways that contribute to their children’s academic self-efficacy and, in turn, their educational success (Seefeldt et al. 1999). As well as improving children’s outcomes, parents’ sense of self-control increases their satisfaction with their relationships with their children’s teachers (Turnbull et al. 2006). In contrast, parents with low self-efficacy will doubt their ability to solve their children’s problems or to influence their educational outcomes, even if they were to become involved (Grolnick et al. 1997). This can be
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 19
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
20
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
particularly the case for parents of high school students with disabilities (Deslandes et al. 1999), parents who have little education themselves (Seefeldt et al. 1999) and parents who present with depression, which signals that they feel unable to influence their circumstances (Reyno & McGrath 2006). Parents’ self-efficacy combines with their values about education and beliefs about teachers’ and parents’ respective roles to produce four styles of interaction in schools, as given in Table 1.2. Table 1.2: Effects of parents’ self-efficacy on their style of involvement in schools Low self-efficacy
High self-efficacy
Negative view of education in general or of current school provisions
Resistant Withdrawn Isolated
Public complaints Destructive criticism
Positive view of education
Emotionally supportive of children High educational aspirations
High involvement, e.g.: • attending meetings • audience at school • assistance with schoolwork • guiding students’ educational or career plans • child advocacy
Source: adapted from Raffaele & Knoff (1999, p. 455)
Although you are not responsible for parents’ personal self-efficacy, you can create an environment for it to flourish in parents’ interactions with you (Keyser 2006). Two key measures are to convey your respect for their role as leaders in their family and to give them relevant information that will enable them to have control over decisions about their child’s education.
Provide information In order for parents to translate their high educational aspirations into behaviours that support their children’s learning both indirectly at home and directly at school (as relevant), they need high-quality information (Coots 1998; Halle et al. 1997; Hill & Taylor 2004). In order to give parents the confidence to become involved, the information you provide must be responsive to their needs, rather than imparting information that you want to convey (Elliott 2003); be accurate and comprehensive so that parents can make informed decisions (Osher & Osher 2002); and be accessible to parents. On this last aspect, some may be comfortable receiving knowledge from books and articles, which you can amass in a parent resource library, while others may prefer verbal communication (Jacobson & Engelbrecht 2000).
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 20
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
Rationale for collaborating with parents
21
One group with particular information needs are parents of young children. First-time parents often request information to help them understand their child (Elliott 2003) and guide them to parent responsively. Topics of particular interest may include building children’s self-esteem, helping them to have good relationships, using effective discipline and developing appropriate expectations of children at different ages (Jacobson & Engelbrecht 2000). By the middle school years, parents may need information about curricula and how they can guide their children’s learning at home; by the time young people are nearing the end of schooling, their parents often benefit from information about school subject choices, employment options and university admission criteria. One group that may need specific information about how to support children’s learning are those parents with little education themselves (Pelletier & Brent 2002). Even when these parents have high educational aspirations for their sons and daughters, the young people’s actual academic achievements may not improve, perhaps because their parents are not able to assist them with academic learning (Hill et al. 2004). Therefore, disadvantaged parents may need practical information about how they can support their children’s attainments.
Outreach In contrast to the critical and distancing attitudes towards parents characterised by the professional-driven or family-allied models, within a family-driven model, schools reach out to parents to support them. Some practical measures include establishing a lending library to help disadvantaged parents who lack the resources to purchase books, which can cause a decline in their children’s literacy skills, on which all other learning relies (Halle et al. 1997). Schools can also be a hub of family and community services, these being determined in response to surveyed parent needs. This will not necessarily entail attracting more resources but may include the provision of a parents’ lounge or drop-in centre to promote informal contacts between parents; structured parent support groups; or bringing in community health specialists to deliver some services at the school so that their efforts and the school’s can be coordinated (Raffaele & Knoff 1999). Such activities can accustom parents to attending their child’s school, on which further contact can be built.
Conclusion The scarcity of family-centred practices, even in those children’s services that aspire to them, attests to the lack of utility of this approach. Under this and the other two models that give professionals ultimate power,
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 21
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
22
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
the paradox is that, if as a teacher you attempt to use that power, you will lose influence over both your parent group and your students. When parents do not comply with the solutions imposed on them, the resulting despondency and failure will disempower all of you. Instead, when problems arise, the respect inherent in a parent-driven stance allows you to recruit parents’ advice and harness their expertise at solving problems for their own family and its members. This will increase the likelihood of finding workable solutions that parents are willing to enact. Given that increases in parental involvement produce improvements in children’s academic skills, particularly in those most at risk of academic failure (Dearing et al. 2006a), a parent-driven approach has the best chance of achieving what you and your parent group both want: engaged and successful students.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 22
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
2
Honouring diversity
All people want to be treated with respect, want to be valued and accepted, loved, and cherished, and made to feel they are making important contributions to society and that their wishes and desires are heard and respected. Berg & Steiner (2003, p. 9)
Families differ on many dimensions, encapsulated by the acronym addressing: age and generational differences, development, disability, religion or spirituality, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, sexual orientation, indigenous heritage, national origin and gender (Clay 2007). Sometimes, our relationships in schools are tainted by societal stereotypes and prejudice against parents who differ from us on these dimensions. There is a belief that some contemporary family structures compromise parents’ ability to raise well-adjusted children. However, this chapter reports that it is parenting processes that affect children’s adjustment, not the type of families in which children are reared (Papero 2005).
Family composition and size One myth is that families today lack the supports of their extended family network because the generations no longer live together as they once did. However, the truth is that, certainly in Western cultures, extended family members have never lived together, due to the short life expectancy, which meant that grandparents had died before their own children had finished childbearing. Despite the mythology that was popularised in British literature, households there have been stable in size over the past 400 years (Bottomley 1983). Between 1574 and 1821, only 11 per cent of British households included extended kin of any kind (Waters & Crook 1993). Thus, other than in aristocratic classes, most Western households have always been basically nuclear in composition. Today, increased 23
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 23
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
24
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
longevity means that members of older generations are still alive and, while they may not be geographically close to their families, communication technologies and fast transportation enable extended family members to be emotionally supportive (Waters & Crook 1993). There is a distinction, then, between extended households and extended kinship, which is now more available than ever, particularly during family crises. A second aspect of family size is the number of children. Australian women are having slightly fewer children now than in the past, but only marginally so. As can be seen in Table 2.1, women born in the 1860s had larger families, but once birth control became practised in the early 1900s, the birth rate dropped from its previously high level. There was a slight rise in births to women born in the 1930s, when women were marrying younger. The relatively recent decrease in births is due mainly to the trend towards a longer gap between marriage and the birth of the first child (Waters & Crook 1993). Table 2.1: Number of births to cohorts of Australian women Women born
Number of children
1861–1866
5.1
1903–1908
2.6
1928–1938
3.2
1940s
2.9
1960s
2.2
1999
1.7 Sources: Australian Bureau of Statistics 2006; McDonald 1993; Waters and Crook 1993
Working parents In 1996, in two-parent families with the youngest child aged under five, 49 per cent of mothers were in paid employment (predominantly part-time); with children aged 10–14 years, 71 per cent of mothers worked outside of home (Australian Bureau of Statistics 2006). This represents increased workforce participation for women. A second trend is that the combined working hours of parents has increased, as individual employees are working longer hours. Nevertheless, having two working parents has a strong precedent in history when, prior to child labour laws and the introduction of universal education at the beginning of the 20th century, working class women (and their children) always worked. Even once women were relegated to home duties, most were never wealthy enough to have the choice between domestic and non-domestic labour: they always had to do both (Bottomley 1983), while women of all classes in Australia participated at high rates in the work
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 24
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
Honouring diversity
25
force during war years and times of economic depression. Indeed, the concept that mothers should remain at home full-time dates from the 1950s and thus is both a recent idea and a departure from the pattern of previous eras. Having two working parents – or an employed sole parent – improves adolescents’ health and wellbeing (Weston 1993). Mothers’ participation in the work force during their children’s early years is beneficial for children’s development, especially in families on a low income. This is because paid employment can assist the family to meet the costs of children’s developmental needs (Harvey 1999). Employed women sacrifice time on household, leisure and social activities to devote proportionally more time to their children. Working mothers spend between 66 and 84 per cent of the time spent by mothers who are home full-time with their children, and this difference produces no ill effects in the children’s skills (Huston & Aronson 2005). Similarly, during young people’s secondary schooling, working mothers devote barely any less time to them than do mothers who are home full-time, with no discernible effects on their adolescents’ school achievements (Feinstein & Symons 1999). Thus, the amount of time that mothers spend with their children is unrelated to their development (Huston & Aronson 2005). Rather, it is mothers’ investment in parenting and thus how they allocate the time available to them that predicts the quality of care that they provide their children (Huston & Aronson 2005). The effects on children of having both parents in paid employment depend on the parents’ working circumstances. Once impoverished parents gain employment they are better adjusted (as evidenced by less depression) and therefore use less coercive parenting (Dearing, McCartney & Taylor 2006b; Raver 2003), while their children (girls in particular) are less aggressive, more independent and achieve better at school (Fuller et al. 2002). Parents’ and children’s adjustment improves when mothers’ employment pays well enough to raise them out of poverty (Dearing et al. 2006b; Fuller et al. 2002); when returning to work does not involve stressful or prolonged commuting (Dunifon, Kalil & Bajracharya 2005); lead to inadequate monitoring of the children (Macmillan, McMorris & Kruttschnitt 2004); impose full-time work during children’s first year (Hill et al. 2005); or result in low-quality or unstable child-care arrangements (Papero 2005; Youngblade 2003).
Child care Since 1990, around half of Australia’s children aged under 12 years attend child care, which is double the rate of previous decades (ABS 2006). Concern about children’s enrolment in centre-based child care is most often framed in terms of its threat to their ‘attachment’ to parents. However, this theory itself has very weak evidential support. Bowlby’s original concept that human
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 25
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
26
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
babies needed intensive care exclusively from a single caregiver is false. Unlike other species, human infants develop affection for many people, such as extended family members, even when they spend little time in their company (Verschueren & Marcoen 1999; Waters & Cummings 2000). Moreover, children’s attachment to their parents does not, as the theory predicts, determine their subsequent emotional wellbeing. Instead, children’s attachment to parents and their emotional wellbeing at the time both depend on the quality of parenting they receive. When parents’ sensitivity improves, so too does the children’s wellbeing (Bakermans-Kranenburg, van IJzendoorn & Kroonenberg 2004; Diener, Nievar & Wright 2003; Hamilton 2000; Koren-Karie et al. 2002; Lewis, Feiring & Rosenthal 2000; Moss et al. 2005; National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (NICHD) Early Child Care Research Network 2001b, 2006; Posada et al. 1999; Raval et al. 2001; Seifer et al. 2004; Waters, Hamilton & Weinfield 2000a; Waters et al. 2000b; Weinfield, Sroufe & Egeland 2000). In other words, it is parenting quality that governs children’s wellbeing, not the quality of children’s ‘attachment’ to their parents. Evidence about the effects of child care support the proposition that it can benefit rather than harm children’s development, particularly for children from deprived home circumstances (Geoffroy et al. 2007). Those attending high-quality centres show improved overall cognitive, language and literacy skills as toddlers and preschool-aged children, contributing in turn to their adaptive functioning in the early years of school (Burchinal & Cryer 2003; Burchinal et al. 1996, 2000; Clarke-Stewart et al. 2002; Fantuzzo et al. 2005; Gilliam & Zigler 2000; Gormley et al. 2005; NICHD Early Child Care Research Network 2000, 2003b; NICHD Early Child Care Research Network & Duncan 2003; Peisner-Feinberg & Burchinal 1997; Peisner-Feinberg et al. 2001; Phillips, McCartney & Scarr 1987; Rubenstein, Howes & Boyle 1981; Sundell 2000; Sylva et al. 2006; Zaslow et al. 1998). They are more sociable, have higher self-esteem, are more assertive, less likely to initiate conflict with peers, and are less aggressive than children with little or no centre-based care experience (Andersson 1989, 1992; Field 1991; Field et al. 1988; Howes 1990; NICHD Early Child Care Research Network 2001a; O’Brien et al. 1999; Phillips et al. 1987; Schwarz, Krolick & Strickland 1973; Vandell, Henderson & Wilson 1988). When followed up with responsive educational programs, these gains are maintained through the school years (Andersson 1989, 1992; Reynolds, Ou & Topitzes 2004), with the benefits particularly pronounced for children experiencing environmental risks (Hubbs-Tait et al. 2002; Love et al. 2003; Peisner-Feinberg et al. 2001). These results show that we do not have to despair about children who attend child care in their early years, even when they do so for a considerable proportion of their day. Our only concern needs to be that
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 26
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
Honouring diversity
27
not all child care is of high quality, and that those parents with the least flexibility in their working lives tend to be least able to be highly selective about the quality of the centre in which they enrol their child. Their choice tends to be dictated by cost, location and opening hours, rather than by the quality of care and education made available to their children (Early & Burchinal 2001; Peyton et al. 2001).
Divorce The doomsday scenario is that high rates of divorce will result in the demise of the family altogether. However, divorce dissolves marriages: it does not dissolve families. The present divorce rate does not indicate a decline in the importance of marriage, but a continued commitment to monogamy, albeit in a serial form. Despite the divorce rate, marriages last longer today than ever before. This somewhat surprising state of affairs comes about because spouses now live longer, as shown in Table 2.2. On its own, this table tells us little, but when we add the rate of divorce at the beginning of the 20th century (1 per cent) and informal separations (thought to be around 10 per cent) to the death rates of the times, the percentage of Australian marriages that endure for 30 years is higher now than 100 years ago, as shown in Table 2.3. Thus, the two-parent family remains the dominant family type. While 40 per cent of all marriages end in divorce, the reverse statistic is that up to 60 per cent of people will stay married to the same person until one partner dies (ABS 2006). Table 2.2: Percentage of marriages with both partners still alive 1891
1991
After 30 years
46%
88%
After 45 years
15%
56% Source: McDonald 1993
Table 2.3: Percentage of marriages with both partners still alive and together
After 30 years
1891
1991
2000
41%
53%
60%
Source: ABS 2006; McDonald 1993
The duration of marriages that end in divorce is also increasing marginally, with couples in 2003 separating after 8.7 years of marriage, compared with 7.6 years a decade earlier (ABS 2006). The longer gap between marriage and child bearing means that divorce is increasingly likely to occur before
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 27
15/1/08 11:47:35 AM
28
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
children are born. Nevertheless, just over half of Australian divorces are to couples with dependent children (Amato 2000; Harrison 1993). The number of children whose parents divorce goes up by about one per cent per year of the children’s age, with the result that by 18 years of age, 18 per cent of all children will experience their parents’ divorce (Harrison 1993; McDonald 1993). We could rue these figures, but their converse is that over three quarters of children live most of their childhood with both biological parents. Separation and divorce threaten individuals’ sense of belonging, which is an innate human need (Sheldon et al. 2001). Therefore, we can expect some short- and longer-term effects on both parents and their children in the years of estrangement that can precede separation, during the divorce process itself and for some time subsequently. Although persistent family conflict is harmful to children and separation can provide relief from that tension, parental separation still produces at the time small increases in the emotional and behavioural problems of young children in particular (Cheng et al. 2006). In the years prior to a divorce and in its immediate aftermath, there can be an exacerbation of social, emotional, behavioural and academic problems in young people, particularly when they have preexisting vulnerabilities (Amato 2000). A separation or divorce can set in train a series of additional losses, such as moving house, school or neighbourhood, changes in parents’ employment status and children’s care and schooling arrangements, financial hardship and subsequent re-partnering of one or both parents. These changes add to the adjustments that children need to make to the separation itself. On the other hand, divorce allows couples and their children to leave violent or unsupportive relationships. Young people growing up in these households experience more stress and disillusionment with relationships than those who grow up in single-parent families with a parent who is less stressed (Amato 2000; Burns & Goodnow 1985). In the long term, divorce of their parents prior to age 16 lowers young people’s educational attainment (although this could reflect a reduction in family income, which means that the family has insufficient resources to support the children’s continued education), earlier onset of emotional difficulties and earlier sexual debut, tobacco and alcohol use (D’Onofrio et al. 2006). Nevertheless, the differences in adjustment between children of divorced and intact families are small (Amato 2000). Whether in the longer-term (within two to three years), children return to their predivorce levels of adjustment depends on: •
how the children view their parents’ divorce: approximately one third believe it is their fault, while others are relieved to see an end to their parents’ misery and their own victimhood, particularly in violent families
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 28
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
Honouring diversity
• • • • • • • •
29
the children's ability to use active coping in contrast with avoidance or distraction their sense of control over events the level of social support they receive whether economic hardships (particularly experienced by women) endure and later restrict the children’s opportunities the quality or responsiveness of parenting the children receive whether the parents’ conflict is resolved by their separation parents’ subsequent emotional adjustment whether the children can maintain high-quality contact with the non-residential parent (Amato 2000; Dunn 2004; Dunn et al. 2004; Spence et al. 2002).
It seems that when children experience persistent emotional difficulties following their parents’ divorce, they would have developed these problems anyway for reasons unrelated to their parents’ disharmony (D’Onofrio et al. 2007), or their antisocial behaviour is due not to their parents’ separation itself, but to the acrimony, parenting problems and socioeconomic difficulties that preceded and contributed to the divorce (Amato 2000; D’Onofrio et al. 2007).
Single parenthood From 1986 to 1996 in Australia, the proportion of one-parent families with dependent children rose from 15 to 19 per cent (ABS 2006). The vast majority of these families (87 per cent) were headed by women. Three quarters of single-parent households result from dissolution of marriage between the two parents, with the remaining quarter typically being due to the ending of a de facto relationship. Just 12 per cent of lone mothers are aged under 24 years (ABS 2006). Mother-headed households have been a significant feature of many societies and classes over time, including in those societies in which the nuclear family has been idealised (Bottomley 1983). In the United States, 28 to 34 per cent of White children born between 1920 and 1960 lived with one or no biological parent; the figure for the same period for African–Americans was 55 to 60 per cent (Hanson & Carta 1995). In Australia, mother-headed households have been commonplace for almost all of White settlement (see Table 2.4, page 30) as fathers went to the gold fields, fought in a series of wars and sought work away from home during times of economic recession. It was only in the 1950s that two-parent, single-income families became the norm. Outside of that era, the mothers who remained at home managed to rear their children successfully; they can still do so today. Even so, single parenthood can be stressful for the adults (Williford, Calkins & Keane 2007), can potentially reduce parental supervision and
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 29
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
30
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
Table 2.4: Percentage of Australian sole-parent families with dependent children 1991
16.6%
1974
9.2%
1891
16.7% Source: McDonald 1993
support for the children and may not allow for one parent to act as a check on the other’s overly lax or controlling discipline (Sandefur & Wells 1999). Nevertheless, some research reports that any deleterious effects are due not to being raised by a single parent as such, but by three factors often accompanying single parenthood. The first and most fundamental of these is poverty. Women earn less than men overall and, during marriage, are employed for fewer hours and thus achieve promotions less than men do; therefore upon separation, mother-headed households are more likely to be in the lowest income bracket, to rent rather than own their accommodation, to live with another family to share expenses and to have limited access to private transport (McDonald 1993). Single mothers find it harder to work and raise young children alone, with 36 per cent of lone mothers with children aged under five working in paid employment, compared to 49 per cent of partnered mothers. Sole-parent families are particularly likely to be destitute if their family finances were strained before the separation. The second effect is that sole-parent families are often the result of parental conflict. However, when the separation ends the conflict, the children are less stressed than when their family is intact but there is ongoing disharmony between their parents (Burns & Goodnow 1985; Dearing et al. 2006b). The third characteristic that can reduce children’s adjustment as a result of being raised in a sole-parent family is when the residential parent experiences a series of disharmonious romantic partnerships. Children raised by stably single parents are as well adjusted as those in two-parent, contented families (Spence et al. 2002). However, children can be stressed by a series of structural changes in the family that occur when their parent endures a sequence of unsuccessful relationships (Haveman & Wolfe 1995; Sandefur & Wells 1999). Single parenthood need not produce poor outcomes in children, however, with some studies finding no deleterious effects on young children’s academic skills (Downer & Pianta 2006) and others finding only marginal reductions in the duration of their schooling (Sandefur & Wells 1999). Single parenthood does not diminish parents’ interest in their children’s schooling and indirect support at home, although it can limit their presence at school (Kohl et al. 2000). In terms of young people’s emotional adjustment, many in sole-parent families report that they enjoy a particularly close relationship
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 30
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
Honouring diversity
31
with their parent (Golombok et al. 2003; MacCallum & Golombok 2004; Weston 1993). The reduced conflict in these families and possibly increased social support from extended family and friends account for the fact that children are better adjusted in sole-parent families than in conflicted twoparent families (Dearing et al. 2006b). Children with antisocial fathers are better adjusted when their father is not present in the family (Jaffee et al. 2003), while the absence of a parent who took no interest in their children’s education makes no difference to young people’s eventual secondary school attainment (Feinstein & Symons 1999).
Young mothers It has been assumed that the immaturity of teenaged parents means that they are less able to nurture their children (Bornstein et al. 2006; Gowen & Nebrig 2002). However, although young mothers may offer less cognitive stimulation for their infants, in reasonably supportive families they are as nurturing as older mothers (Bornstein et al. 2006; McGroder 2000). At any age, mothers will be less responsive in their parenting when enduring poverty, family disruption, unemployment or partner abuse, and when they have a history of abuse or neglect in their own childhood (Ellis et al. 2003; Fergusson & Woodward 2000; Jenkins, Shapka & Sorenson 2006; Moffitt & the E-Risk Study Team 2002; Turley 2003). These adverse circumstances increase their children’s propensity for childhood illness and injury, behavioural problems including adolescent delinquency, teen parenthood and poor academic achievement (Moffitt & the E-Risk Study Team 2002; Turley 2003). The children start school at lower levels of functioning and remain behind their age peers throughout the school years (Turley 2003). The net result can be that children of these parents leave school earlier (three-quarters of a year sooner) than those in more advantaged families (Boyle et al. 2007). These outcomes are due to family adversity, however, not to the age of the mother. This is verified by two facts; first, that babies born to these mothers later in life are as disadvantaged as those born to them in their teens (Turley 2003). Second, even when they have their own children at the typical childbearing age, the sisters of teen mothers have equally disadvantaged children (Turley 2003).
Lesbian mothers In one study, one in five lesbian women had or lived with children (Millbank 2002, in Semann 2004). Whereas it was once assumed that this would affect the children’s gender identity, it is now clear that children raised by lesbian mothers have similar romantic relationships and sexual orientation to all
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 31
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
32
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
other young people (Golombok et al. 2003; MacCallum & Golombok 2004; Wainright, Russell & Patterson 2004). Having lesbian parents seems to produce in children greater awareness of discrimination and more accepting attitudes about nonconformity to gender roles (Wainright et al. 2004). Findings on other measures fail to distinguish between children raised by lesbian versus heterosexual mothers (Wainright et al. 2004). Both groups of children have similar self-esteem, personal adjustment, academic achievement and neighbourhood integration. One fear has been that the children would be subjected to more peer harassment because of heterosexist discrimination against their gay or lesbian parent. However, young people have not reported this, although on their children’s behalf their mothers report a slightly increased incidence (Golombok et al. 2003). This leaves one remaining potential concern for children growing up with two female parents – that is, the absence of a father figure. This fear is also unfounded: regardless of whether their mother is homosexual or heterosexual, boys in fatherless families display slightly more feminine but no less masculine behaviour (MacCallum & Golombok 2004). They experience a similar quality of parenting, with lesbian and co-mothers more likely to use egalitarian discipline and more equally sharing child care and household duties than occurs in heterosexual families (Bos, van Balen & van den Boom 2004; Golombok et al. 2003; MacCallum & Golombok 2004; Wainright et al. 2004). When their mothers have a partner, children of lesbian parents can experience warmer care from their social mother than from their biological father (Golombok et al. 2003). The only disadvantage of being raised by lesbian parents is that, regardless of their sexual orientation, sole parents can be more stressed and more likely to be impoverished (Golombok et al. 2003; MacCallum & Golombok 2004). In that case, it is the poverty, not the parents’ sexual orientation that affects their children.
Stepfamilies Stepfamilies are as common today as in the 16th and 17th centuries (Whelan & Kelly 1986), although today they typically succeed parental divorce rather than the death of a parent, making the children’s adjustment somewhat different. When working with a newly formed stepfamily, it would be a mistake to assume that it is like any biological family, dealing with the usual challenges of the life stage suggested by the ages of the children. The fact that the marriage is new determines the demands on the family. Stepfamilies need different operating principles than nuclear families, because they are performing many roles at once, with responsibilities spread across their present and former families, and are negotiating complex relationships
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 32
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
Honouring diversity
33
among all family members. The elevated divorce rate in second and subsequent marriages attests to the difficulty of achieving all this. At the time that their parent forms a new couple relationship, you might see at school a resurgence of the behavioural difficulties that children displayed at the time of their parents’ original separation. Their grief can be renewed not only because the re-partnering signals the finality of their parents’ separation, but because it can lead to fewer contacts with their non-residential biological parent. In addition, their parent’s closeness with a new partner can be seen by children as a rejection of themselves, especially when it does in fact lead to less one-on-one time with their parent. These behavioural and emotional reactions can persist because at home, where the same phenomenon is being experienced, the children’s reactions raise unfamiliar parenting issues. In terms of educational outcomes for children, there is some evidence that being part of a stepfamily has the same effects as being in a singleparent family – namely, a marginal reduction (measured in months) in the duration of children’s schooling (Sandefur & Wells 1999). This is probably a result of the stress from the original separation and from changes in family structures, rather than to any qualities inherent in stepfamilies as such.
Intermittent parental absence Children can display grief and unsettled behaviour when one of their parents departs to work away from home for extended periods. Some parents attempt to distract them by asking them to look after their mother while their father is away (as though women are so incompetent that they need a child to look after them). However, this responsibility is inappropriate. Children need their remaining parent to be the family leader and will cope when he or she does so. Nevertheless, the reason for the absence makes a difference. For example, boys whose fathers are imprisoned display more antisocial behaviours throughout their life than those whose fathers die, leave as a result of parental conflict or for hospitalisation, or were imprisoned before their birth (Murray & Farrington 2005). The effects on children are not due either to parents’ criminality or to the separation itself, but also to the stigma, loss of family income, potentially reduced quality of care, inadequate explanation being given to the children and copying their parents’ criminal behaviour (Murray & Farrington 2005).
Grandparent guardians A recent phenomenon is the increasing prevalence of grandparents raising their grandchildren. Grandparents typically take on the care of their
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 33
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
34
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
grandchildren suddenly, after a family trauma such as parental death, the breakdown of the parenting couple’s relationship, or as a result of mental illness, alcohol or drug addiction or parental incarceration. Obviously, grandparents are older than parents, with 39 per cent aged 35–54 years and the majority (61 per cent) being aged over 55. The grandchildren are typically older as well, with just 15 per cent being aged under five (ABS 2006). Most grandparents have just one or two children in their care, although some (around 11 per cent as of 2003) have three or more children for whom they are responsible. They usually have fewer financial resources and less physical stamina to devote to this task, with half doing so without a spouse. Moreover, some of the reasons for their care of their grandchildren result in developmental delays or disabilities in the children – such as parental alcohol addiction causing fetal alcohol syndrome (McCallion, Janicki & Kolomer 2004). Thus, these children can be traumatised by the events in their family as well as having additional educational and behavioural difficulties. Consequently, teachers report them to have elevated rates of academic, emotional and behavioural difficulties (Edwards 2006). While this is also true of foster children, grandparents typically have less preparation for the role of substitute carer and they can feel partly culpable for raising a son or daughter who neglected or abandoned his or her own child. The grandparents’ role is complex, with day-to-day care of their grandchildren ensnaring them in a situation in which they must act as a parent when the grandchildren may expect them to act ‘grandparentally’ (Kornhaber 2002). Those who are elderly worry about what will happen to their grandchildren if they die or become incapacitated. The grandparents’ own health and degree of choice in the matter will have a great deal of influence on whether they see their caretaking as a source of a new zest for life or an encumbrance to be resented. Whatever their personal reactions, they will need the support of a range of social services – financial, respite care, schooling, health care and support groups – not least because they may lose touch with their informal network. This can come about because few people of their age will be having similar life experiences to themselves and because their grandchildren’s difficulties can make attending social functions difficult (McCallion et al. 2004).
Families from minority cultures The term ‘culture’ encompasses demographic characteristics such as race, gender, country of origin, language and socioeconomic status, as well as less explicit features such as individuals’ beliefs, values and attitudes (Sheridan 2000). It also refers to the norms and customs of institutions such
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 34
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
Honouring diversity
35
as schools. The challenges that families face because they observe different norms and customs from the dominant culture are compounded by the social discrimination they experience, which results in minority cultural groups disproportionately experiencing economic disadvantage. While race marks people for discrimination, marginalisation and socioeconomic inequalities are about politics as much as they are about race (Dennis & Giangreco 1996). This is evidenced by the fact that, while English language proficiency limits the social mobility of the first and perhaps second generation of immigrants, achieving proficiency in English does not necessarily guarantee social mobility (Reis & McCoach 2000). This tells us that discrimination is also an issue. Parents from all cultural groups hold high educational aspirations for their children. They may be educationally involved in different ways and to different degrees, with their levels of aspirations and parent–teacher communication varying (Hong & Ho 2005) but, on the whole, across cultures parents’ emotional support for their children’s education is similar and seems to be equally beneficial in terms of their children’s school grades (Ho & Willms 1996; Jodl et al. 2001; Keith et al. 1998). Lack of communication with parents with little English will deny you vital information about their child, while limiting how much information they can receive from you. Even those who can use everyday language might have difficulty comprehending more technical educational terms (Rosin 1996; Salend & Taylor 1993). Even without language barriers, some immigrant parents can distrust authority figures or may have experienced the intrusion of social services and therefore will be reluctant to disclose personal information to you (Dennis & Giangreco 1996).
Engaging diverse families Depending on their socioeconomic or cultural background, some parents may be unfamiliar with the concept of advocacy or direct parental involvement at school, and may believe that they have to acquiesce to your opinion out of deference to your status as an authority figure (Haboush 2007; Zhang & Bennett 2003).
Inclusive curricula Inclusive day-to-day practices within your classroom will communicate more effectively than any other means that you honour diversity. Particularly in the face of the traditional silencing of minorities, when you are a member of the majority culture, you will need to listen to students, their families and members of other cultures to find out how to make learning culturally and socially meaningful and relevant for
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 35
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
36
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
these students (Ford & Trotman 2001). Among other measures, this will entail prohibiting gender, racial or heterosexist discrimination within your classroom and school and respecting students’ use of dialects and their home languages (Ford 2003; Ford & Harris 2000; Ford et al. 2000; Harmon 2002). Meanwhile, an anti-bias curriculum must not perpetuate stereotypes through a ‘tourist curriculum’ that focuses on other cultures’ exotic customs (Derman-Sparks & the A.B.C Task Force 1989), but must recognise how the various cultural groups that make up a society have contributed to how it has been shaped as a collective (Ford 2003; Ford & Harris 2000; Ford et al. 2000).
Cultural competence Adopting a ‘colour-blind’ stance that other people’s culture is irrelevant would disrespect its deep significance to them, ignore differences and entrench oppression by failing to question it (Chan 2006). On the other hand, stereotyping people on the basis of their culture would disrespect their individuality (Ramirez et al. 1998). Instead, we need to develop cultural awareness. As an analogy for this, Barrera and Corso (2002) describe a building with two rooms. Cultural imperialism declares that the one room I occupy is the only one that exists or matters; dualism recognises that there are two separate rooms but their two occupants cannot communicate unless one or both moves; the concept of a ‘third space’ upholds that it is the wall that keeps us from occupying a shared space. The wall obstructs our view of the other; therefore, if we can remove the obstruction, we can acknowledge, respect and integrate our diverse perspectives. Cultural literacy begins with developing awareness of our own cultural biases (Lynch 2004; Ramirez et al. 1998). Professional development, multicultural experiences, reading about other cultures and forming personal and professional contacts with individuals who bridge cultures can help you as a member of the dominant culture to become aware of its implicit assumptions, biases and values, being sensitive to the fact that these are not universally shared (Lynch 2004; Lynch & Hanson 1996). While cultural differences are inevitable, it is not difference but our interpretation of it that creates conflict across cultures (Chan 2006). Thus, while cultural awareness asks us to question, ‘What do I believe?’, the next step of clarifying values expands this reflection to query, ‘What meaning am I attaching to the other person’s actions?’ (Barrera & Corso 2002). As will be mentioned in chapter 3, respect does not mean that we have to accept others’ values (cultural or otherwise), but merely recognise that they believe that their perceptions are the proper and logical way to understand and respond to their circumstances.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 36
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
Honouring diversity
37
A next measure to enhance cross-cultural collaboration is developing awareness of other cultural perspectives, including a political awareness of the oppression by the dominant culture of minorities (Ingraham 2000; Ramirez et al. 1998). While it will never be possible to walk in another person’s shoes and understand how others experience the social oppression that often accompanies their cultural membership, cross-cultural empathy can be informed by an awareness of the distinction between voluntary and involuntary minority groups. Some families migrate voluntarily to a country in search of more opportunities (although, even then I doubt that they could have anticipated the hardships and discrimination they would endure in the process). Despite having chosen to emigrate and thus surmount the challenges, when they confront educational dilemmas about their child, their immigrant status can disenfranchise these parents, as they are more likely to be living in poverty, may have low proficiency in English and may have less support from social services (Lai & Ishiyama 2004; Salend & Taylor 1993). The fact that recent immigrants were educated elsewhere and thus do not know the local education system can lead to their reluctance to engage with educators or join parent groups, which results in their being particularly isolated (Marion 1980). In contrast, involuntary minorities were brought to a country against their will (e.g. African–Americans) or were invaded (as with Native Americans, Australian Aborigines and the New Zealand Maori peoples) (Borland & Wright 2000). The history of oppression and ongoing negative contact between involuntary minorities and the dominant culture generate repeated disadvantage that can give rise to oppositional coping mechanisms, including a resistance to ‘acting White’ via school success (Borland & Wright 2000). For these groups, school learning is perceived not as adding to their lives but as detracting from their own cultural values, traditions and attitudes (Townsend-Cross 2004), while effort during the school years is less likely to be rewarded in their working life because discrimination limits their social mobility. This points to the need to promote pluralism (in contrast with assimilationism) so that children from minority cultures feel that they can preserve their own cultural heritage at the same time as acquiring the knowledge and skills that are necessary for success in the majority culture (Maker & Schiever 1989).
Use of translators For parents with limited proficiency in English, it can be essential to locate a translator for formal conversations, or to invite a community volunteer to accompany them on a regular basis at drop-off or collection times so that you can pass on to parents day-to-day information about their child’s experiences and, in so doing, build a trusting relationship with them.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 37
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
38
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
When using an interpreter in formal meetings, provide the translator ahead of time with copies of any documents that will be discussed at the meeting. It is wise to avoid using the parents’ son or daughter as a translator as that burdens a child with inappropriate responsibility, while the use of translators who are children or family friends can lead to parental discomfort at the translator’s exposure to private information (Lynch 2004; Lynch & Hanson 1996; Salend & Taylor 1993).
Formal meetings In advance of formal meetings with parents from an unfamiliar minority culture, endeavour to learn from a ‘cultural interpreter’ about protocols and social interaction norms within the family’s community (Dennis & Giangreco 1996). In terms of who should attend the meeting, even if the parents do not require an interpreter, they may still wish to invite a cultural advocate to the meeting. This person may be a member of their own community or extended family, or a member of the school staff who shares their cultural background. The parents have to be the ones to make the choice of inviting an interpreter or cultural advocate, because in some cultures the presence of an outsider would be experienced as supportive, whereas in others it would cause parents to lose face. If they choose to see you without a cultural advocate or none is available, you can check with them if, despite your cultural differences, they are nevertheless willing to discuss with you the issues about their son or daughter. A second consideration about who should attend the meeting is that if it grows too large in numbers, parents can feel intimidated. This is true for any parent; in certain minority cultures it can make family shame public. In that case, it would be wise to limit the numbers of professionals who attend (Dennis & Giangreco 1996). On the other hand, when collaborating with parents from a patriarchal culture, they may feel more comfortable if there is a male teacher or other male professional at the meeting (Haboush 2007). Given some cultures’ perspective that their children’s difficulties are a threat to family honour, your assurances of confidentiality and discretion are vital (Dennis & Giangreco 1996). For the same reason, and because it would violate a parent-driven perspective, it will be crucial to avoid any implication that parents are to blame for their child’s difficulties. Some cultures do not value efficiency to the extent that Western culture does and therefore parents do not mean any disrespect if they do not attend meetings at the appointed time. Some will seek a prolonged time frame in which to develop a personal relationship with you and to discuss and tell stories about their child (Dennis & Giangreco 1996; Haboush 2007; Zhang & Bennett 2003), while you will need to allocate extra time
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 38
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
Honouring diversity
39
when using an interpreter. Some cultures value hospitality very highly, in which case they will be especially honoured to have you offer them some refreshment at meetings. As we cannot possibly know the nuances of every culture and there is considerable variation in beliefs and practices within any group, the most useful stance when working with parents from other cultures is one taken by the solution-focused approach (see chapter 4) – that is, a posture of ‘not-knowing’ (Berg & Steiner 2003). This is also consistent with a parent-driven model which recommends that you ask parents about their aspirations for their child, their expectations of your respective roles, preferences for how formally or informally to interact with you, and their values and preferred practices concerning their children’s behaviour and learning (Lynch 2004; Phoenix 2002). An inquisitive stance is ideal for working cross-culturally because, in having parents generate their own definitions of problems, determine their own goals and design interventions based on their own past successes, necessarily these will be in tune with their cultural and personal perspectives.
Father involvement In one study, father participation in preschool and the first year of school comprised only 10 per cent of all family involvement (Rimm-Kaufman & Zhang 2005). The preponderance of female teachers, particularly in early education, may serve as a barrier to fathers’ engagement at school. Also crucial is whether fathers are present in the home, while the level of conflict between the two parents determines to a significant extent fathers’ engagement with their children (Coley & Hernandez 2006). Offering sessions exclusively for fathers may not be as effective as specifically reaching out to include fathers alongside their partners (Turbiville & Marquis 2001). On the other hand, in the absence of court orders prohibiting fathers’ contact, school personnel need to give nonresidential fathers the chance to engage at school independently of their former partners (Frieman & Berkeley 2002).
Conclusion Children grow up accepting the family type in which they are reared. Indeed, ‘this is how cultures are transmitted’ (Bottomley 1983, p. 12). The conclusion from examining these diverse families is that it is not the type of family that influences children’s outcomes, but the quality of the parenting the children receive. This is independent of family type (Cleveland et al. 2000; Papero 2005). This awareness can allow us to recognise and respect parents’ personal emotional resources as the main
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 39
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
40
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
ingredients of parenting and the main influence on children’s adjustment and educational outcomes.
Additional resources Some of the following books will be useful either for your own background reading or for parents.
Divorce Burrett, J. (1999). But I want to stay with you: Talking with children about separation and divorce. Sydney: Simon and Schuster. Teyber, E. (1992). Helping children cope with divorce. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Wells, R. (1997). Helping children cope with divorce. London: Sheldon. Weyburne, D. (1999). What to tell the kids about your divorce. Oakland, CA: Harbinger.
Stepfamilies Boyd, H. (1998). The step-parent’s survival guide. London: Ward Lock. Hart-Byers, S. (1998). Secrets of successful step-families. Port Melbourne, VIC: Lothian. Rodwell, J. (2002). Repartnered families. Auckland: Penguin.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 40
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
3
Communication skills
When a teacher talks to parents about their children, he [or she] inevitably intrudes on family dreams... What the teacher says about the child touches on deep feelings and hidden fantasies. A concerned teacher is aware of the impact of his [or her] words. He [or she] consciously avoids comments that may casually kill dreams. Ginott (1972, pp. 277–78)
Communication skills are not solutions to problems, but they are the tools for solving problems. Communication with your students’ parents is a matter of both substance and style. Interpersonal courtesies such as keeping appointments, being on time, being organised and prepared and following up on commitments all reinforce the quality of your communication (Dinnebeil, Hale & Rule 1996). Authentic communication is built on a belief in your own worth and that of parents, yielding four stances as depicted in Table 3.1. High-quality communication with your students’ parents gives you access to their intimate knowledge of their children, which helps you understand and therefore Table 3.1: Communication styles determined by perceptions of self and parents
You’re okay
You’re not okay
I’m okay
I’m not okay
COLLABORATIVE High self-efficacy High collective efficacy Solution focus
APPROVAL SEEKING Low self-efficacy Intimidated or placating
PROFESSIONAL-DRIVEN High self-efficacy Distrustful, turfism
ISOLATION Low self-efficacy Low quantity and quality of communication with parents
41
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 41
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
42
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
respond to your students’ needs. It also promotes a climate of trust between parents and teachers, and assures you of each other’s support.
Interaction styles Teachers’ use of ‘top-down’, or didactic, teaching can unwittingly extend into professional-driven interactions with parents. In contrast, parentdriven communication with parents requires that you respond to them with respect, warmth, positiveness and sensitivity. With these qualities in evidence, parents will be able to trust in your dependability and discretion (Blue-Banning et al. 2004) – that is, believe that you can be relied upon (Adams & Christenson 2000).
Respect Respect means honouring both parents and your students as individual human beings who are imbued with dignity (Kasahara & Turnbull 2005). Prizing individuals is more than being polite, but reflects a connection to their humanity (Townsend-Cross 2004). As an extension of this, parents want you not only to see their children as active in their learning, but also to demonstrate care for them and to promote respectful acceptance of them by others (Kasahara & Turnbull 2005). Nevertheless, when parents – perhaps out of stress – seem to be acting against their children’s interest, respect does not mean admiring or agreeing with their values or behaviour. In such cases, while you cannot endorse the behaviour, you can admire parents’ tenacity in surviving crises and enduring challenging circumstances (Rosenthal & Sawyers 1996). People do the best they can in the conditions that confront them.
Warmth Parents want an emotionally rich and supportive relationship with their child’s teachers, rather than a formal or distant one (Bennett et al. 1998; Fox et al. 2002; Galil et al. 2006; Kasahara & Turnbull 2005; Nelson, Summers & Turnbull 2004; Summers et al. 1990). However, for a range of reasons, warmth and friendliness are not the same as being friends with your students’ parents. This is because, first, you are paid to teach their children. Once a student leaves your class, you are no longer paid to relate to the parent, whereupon that relationship will usually end. Second, unlike most friendships, your relationship with parents has a particular purpose. Third, friendships have no boundaries (Stonehouse & Gonzalez-Mena 2004), whereas you will need to maintain limits on your professional responsibilities in order to avoid conflicts of interest and exploitation of both of you. A
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 42
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
Communication skills
43
lack of appropriate boundaries can be apparent when parents become overly reliant on you, with their escalating requests for support becoming unmanageable. Fourth, friendships with your students’ parents can cause them to be reluctant to question your recommendations, in case doing so jeopardises your relationship (Nelson et al. 2004) while, for your part, it may be difficult to be assertive with them over professional matters when trying to safeguard your friendship. Fifth, breakdown in the relationship can jeopardise your continuing professional obligations to their child. Finally, you also lay yourself open to accusations of favouritism (Nelson et al. 2004).
Positiveness Positiveness involves thinking the best about students’ and families’ capacities, your own skills and the possibilities for children’s progress. At the same time, this must be balanced with honesty. While honesty without tact is plain cruelty, when their child is experiencing difficulties at school, it is no kindness to parents to withhold this feedback in order to shield them or to protect yourself from confronting them with unpleasant information. Therefore, you will need to outline your concerns, illustrated with a concrete description of a behavioural incident or examples of the student’s work, as the case may be. In the next phase, you will need to listen to their impressions and respond to their questions and suggestions.
Sensitivity When collaborating with families, it is important to be sensitive, first, to their circumstances, as these will affect what energies they have available to support their children’s education. Second, you need to listen to parents’ aspirations for their son or daughter. On the other hand, although sensitivity and empathy towards parents are clearly beneficial qualities, you must avoid feeling sympathy for those enduring stressful circumstances. Pity does not give families confidence in their own ability to overcome adversity, and when they instead become reliant on outside support you may become overwhelmed with ‘compassion fatigue’ that will result in burn out.
Responsiveness Like sensitivity, responsiveness involves listening to parents, having an enquiring mind and being willing to suspend judgement in order to provide, arrange for or recommend services that they request. Responsiveness can also mean not imposing services that parents do not want. Responsiveness requires that you be accessible to parents, as working only to a rigid timetable relegates them to being mere ‘cases’ (Nelson et al.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 43
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
44
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
2004). This signals your commitment to your students and their parents – that is, a willingness to ‘do whatever it takes’. Responsiveness also requires some role flexibility (Swick 2003), or an ability to ‘make things happen’ (Blue-Banning et al. 2004). At the same time, however, teachers have to guard against being too available, as that can unwittingly undermine parents, creating dependence on outsiders and reducing their confidence in their ability to solve their own problems, while contributing to unmanageable demands on you. Responsiveness also does not imply that you must indulge parental requests that violate your professional judgement about best practice because, while in a parent-driven model, you must respect parents’ expertise, you both must equally respect yours. Responsiveness also requires that you be willing to learn and keep up to date with information as it emerges (Blue-Banning et al. 2004). While having confidence in your knowledge of available information, you do not have to feign expertise about the unknown, but instead can admit to uncertainties (Hughes & MacNaughton 2002).
Authentic listening Listening is at the heart of authentic communication. Its first component is to give others your attention. This conveys that you value both the person and their message (Swick 2003). Giving attention means stopping whatever else you are doing, as portrayed in the motto: Don’t just do something: stand there. (Rosenberg 2003, p. 91)
Your other nonverbal behaviours also communicate interest, by maintaining appropriate eye contact and using a courteous tone of voice. Once attending, you can invite speakers to tell you more, in response to which you might say very little – maybe just ‘mm-hmm’, ‘oh’ or ‘I see’ – or you could repeat back the last few words that they have said, to encourage them to carry on. When listening, it pays to ask very few questions – especially ones that call for a yes/no answer – because questions will direct, rather than follow, what they are telling you. A series of questions can make speakers feel that they are being subjected to an inquisition, rather than being listened to. The next component of listening is reflecting others’ feelings. This can be especially confronting when others are expressing strong emotions, particularly anger at us. But emotions, like rivers, cannot be stopped – only channelled (Ginott, Ginott & Goddard 2003). Reflection is a core skill for channelling feelings in a more constructive direction. It paraphrases
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 44
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
Communication skills
45
or summarises what others are saying, reflecting the content, emotion or meaning behind their message (Bolton 1987). Often, we believe that we are listening when instead our responses discourage others from talking to us. Box 3.1 (page 46) lists 12 common conversational habits that Gordon (1970) called ‘roadblocks to communication’, to which Bolton (1987) later added a 13th: accusing other people (blaming them) or feeling guilty ourselves for using the communication roadblocks. Of the three categories that Gordon identified, giving advice is probably the most common because we all want to help others to feel better. But it foreshortens your conversation by not waiting to hear what was their real problem, tells others that you think they are not capable of finding their own solutions and makes it less likely that they will do as you suggest because it was not their idea.
Responding to parental complaints A prime occasion when you will need to use listening skills is when parents have approached you with a complaint. As consumers of an important (and in terms of private school fees or tax contributions for public education, an expensive) service, parents would be irresponsible if they did not closely question what you offer their children (Greenman & Stonehouse 2007). This means that, regardless of their manner, you need to meet their questions and demands with courtesy. Even ‘difficult’ parents are not being demanding just to make you jump through hoops: they need and have a right to ask questions. Although strong emotions can be intimidating, it will help not to take parents’ behaviour personally. Remember that it is being triggered by their situation (not by you) and that, from their perspective, they believe that they have a valid reason for their feelings. All mammals become feral when their young are under threat, while some will be hostile because of their own unsatisfactory or abusive schooling history (Miller 2003; Roffey 2002). Any expression of blame or hopelessness is a sign that they care deeply about their child. Given that you also want the best for their child, a statement of this, your shared interest, is a good starting point (Keyser 2006). Also, keep in mind that it takes courage for parents to confront you with a complaint and perhaps they have had to stir themselves up to summon the nerve. On that basis, you will need to listen, acknowledge their frustration or anger, and reflect what they are saying. Nevertheless, if parents become belligerent, uncooperative, abusive or otherwise disrespectful, offensive or overpowering you will need them to moderate how they are talking to you. It might help to direct such parents to what they want to accomplish (Jones & Jones 2004). For example:
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 45
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
46
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
Box 3.1 Roadblocks to communication Judging It is important to accept that others feel something, even when we do not understand why they feel as they do. • Criticising or blaming. Criticising others is a clear message that we do not accept their feelings. • Praising others tries to talk them out of their feelings, as when we say to a parent, ‘I know you’ll figure out what to do for the best. You’re such a resourceful person’. • Name-calling is much the same and has similar effects to criticising and blaming others. • Diagnosing or interpreting what others are feeling is an attempt to tell them what their ‘real’ problem is, discounting their view of it. Sending solutions Sometimes, we believe that we are listening, when instead we are attempting to tell others what they should do about their problem. • Directing them to stop what they are feeling or doing tells them that their perspective is not important. • Threatening is an attempt to impose a solution on others. • Preaching explains why they should feel or behave differently. It is patronising because it treats others as if they did not already know what you are telling them. • Interrogating asks a series of questions to try to get to the root of the problem. Probing suggests that you are about to find a solution for speakers, instead of trusting them to find their own. • Advising is an attempt to impose a positive solution which, although intended well, hurries people to take action before they have had time to explore their thoughts and feelings adequately. Avoiding the other person’s feelings A third group of communication roadblocks tries to take the heat out of others’ feelings, perhaps because these embarrass or distress us. • Distracting people from their worries without giving them time to resolve these can cause them to believe that we do not really want to hear what is on their mind. • Logical argument sends the message: ‘Don’t feel: Think’. • Reassuring tries to change how others feel, conveying that they are not allowed to feel as they do. This ignores the depth of their emotions and communicates that you do not understand them.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 46
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
Communication skills
47
‘I accept that you are angry that Simon was sent out of class. Perhaps we can focus on what you would like to see happen next time so that his behaviour doesn’t hurt others but he still feels that he has been listened to?’ It is crucial that you do not get hooked into placating or pleasing parents when their complaints are unjustified, as that demeans you and the colleague who handled the incident (Swick 2003). On the other hand, blaming parents, yourself or colleagues is not helpful either. A method called ‘negative assertion’ can be useful, as long as it is genuinely meant. In this approach, after listening to parents’ first complaint, you would ask them to tell you more about it, until you have explored all you can about that particular issue. If they remain disgruntled, you then ask what else they want to tell you… and then what else, until finally they have exhausted their head of steam and are now willing to move to the next step of working with you to find a solution. Sometimes, inevitably, your time will be limited. When anxious about an impending commitment, your response is likely to be less than ideal. In that case, it will help to advise the parents of your time constraints at the outset and suggest that all you can do now is schedule another meeting. A second occasion during which pressure will not help is when parents confront you with a grievance without prior warning. In that event, it can be useful to impose a time limit deliberately to give yourself time to evaluate their complaint. A delay will also give them time to calm down. No one can listen to even the most reasonable explanation while he or she is angry. Therefore, take the information, offer to think about it or to gather more facts from those involved, and then get back to the parents for a follow-up conversation. If this does not satisfy their immediate concerns, you can invite the parents to speak with the principal. Even if, like you, the principal cannot resolve the issue immediately, nevertheless being granted access to someone in higher authority can satisfy the parents that you are taking the matter seriously. In most instances, listening to the feeling behind parents’ manner will effectively avoid a confrontation. However, to cover those rare instances in which that does not work, your school will need a policy for protecting staff from physical threats. This will encompass procedures for withdrawing to a safe location and requesting backup from a colleague or even the police or other security personnel. In the long term, it will be helpful to let parents know about a procedure for expressing complaints. This will ask that, in the first instance, they approach the teacher involved, rather than speaking first with the principal. To go to superiors before giving those involved a chance to explain or respond is disrespectful and will make them defensive (Penney & Wilgosh 2000).
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 47
15/1/08 11:47:36 AM
48
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
Assertiveness The second communication skill of assertiveness is necessary when others’ behaviour frustrates your own needs or those of your students. Generally, you will be aware that this is happening because it will provoke what is often called a ‘negative’ emotion. Although we would prefer to feel only ‘positive’ emotions, despite their pejorative label these ‘negative’ feelings are actually very helpful as they signal that our needs are being violated (Hart & Hodson 2004). The cornerstone of assertiveness is accepting responsibility for our own feelings and needs. This means that we must avoid victim language that blames others for how we feel and obscures the recognition that we make our own choices. For example, we often claim that we ‘cannot help’ our behaviour, perhaps because of uncontrollable impulses. Or we believe that we ‘have’ to or ‘must’ do something (as if someone is threatening execution at dawn if we do not comply) because our role demands it: ‘I have to stay back late to get this done’. At its most basic, avoiding this kind of victim language means that we cannot say to students or their parents, ‘That makes me angry’. Instead, we must accept that our feelings are created by our own thoughts – by how we interpret (that is, think about) events. When attempting to be assertive, we often also use words that appear to describe feelings, when in fact they are interpretations of others’ actions. Examples include when we say that we are feeling manipulated, pressured, overworked, oppressed or taken for granted (Rosenberg 2003). Alternatives that express our actual feelings rather than others’ actions (or lack of them) include: annoyed, bitter, disappointed, disgruntled, tired, frustrated, irritated, overwhelmed and resentful. Being assertive is likely to be more successful than simply hoping that someone else will guess what you require. It is also a better option than waiting until a problem has festered into simmering resentments or caused you to vent your anger inappropriately. Assertiveness helps others to know and understand you as an honest human being, and to act thoughtfully once they realise what you need. It demonstrates that you respect yourself and communicates that you believe others are mature enough to handle what you tell them. Although confronting others may seem like a negative reflection on their behaviour, it does in fact convey not a criticism but respect for their ability to withstand your dissatisfaction.
Manage anger It is both natural and human to be angry on occasion at students’ (and parents’) behaviour. However, being such a strong emotion, anger takes careful management and should not be indulged: it is not okay to become
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 48
15/1/08 11:47:37 AM
Communication skills
49
abusive just because we are outraged. To regulate anger, it can help, first, to recognise that it is not the first emotion that you feel but is a response to a prior feeling. Usually anger is a reaction to being hurt or fearful that you will not receive what you need (which is known as frustration). Communicating these original feelings will be more effective than telling others that you are angry at them. Even more importantly, anger indicates that we are analysing or judging – others or ourselves; instead, we must reflect on which of our needs is not being met (Rosenberg 2003). Thinking angry and resentful thoughts makes it less rather than more likely that our need will be satisfied. Our task, then, is to harness the energy behind the anger and channel it into expressing what we require. Anger simply signals that our present methods are not working and need to be changed. As with any problem solving, the steps are to ask yourself: • • •
What do I want to achieve here? Is what I am doing helping me to achieve that? If not, what else could I do?
The next steps are to act in these new ways and, subsequently, check that they are working.
Construct I-messages When others’ actions are interfering with getting your needs met, you will have to tell them so, by relating what you need, not describing their behaviour. Telling others about themselves is called a ‘you’ message and is generally aggressive, not assertive. Instead, assertiveness involves that word ‘I’: ‘I have another meeting shortly and need to prepare for that. I would be glad to make a time to talk to you about this as soon as I can’. Assertive messages need to avoid any hint of accusation, because otherwise recipients will feel guilty and react negatively. The basic I-message has three components: • • •
a statement about how we feel about the behaviour we are seeing a description of the needs, values or wishes that are generating these feelings a request to the other person to do something to meet our needs.
Taking each aspect in turn, when disclosing how you feel, it is important to be accurate about the strength of your emotions, neither over-stating them nor diluting them with qualifiers such as ‘really’ ‘pretty’ or ‘a bit’. During part two of the assertive message, it can be difficult to detect and name the need that is giving rise to your feelings, especially when you have been trained never to ask for what you require. This takes practice. Part three
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 49
15/1/08 11:47:37 AM
50
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
of the assertive message asks others to do something to meet your needs. When doing so, it is important not to tell them what they should do, as that would invite submission, rebellion or sabotage (Rosenberg 2003). You can determine if you are making a demand rather than a request by observing how you respond if the person does not do as you ask: if you blame, attempt to lay on guilt or in other ways punish the person for not complying, that is a demand. In contrast, a request is signified by a display of empathy for the other person’s objections to your request (Rosenberg 2003). Your goal cannot be to ensure compliance, but to build better understanding. Having described these three basic components, there are five specific types of assertive messages that can be useful (Jakubowski & Lange 1978). For each, there will be two phases to their delivery: first, saying what you require and, second, listening to the recipient’s reaction.
‘I-want’ statements This first type of assertive message asks someone to meet our needs. However, sometimes when we express what we want, it can be misinterpreted as a demand instead of a request. To prevent this, you can qualify your statement in some way. One option is to ask how willing or able the other person is to do as you ask. For example: ‘I need Sam to be at school on time so he doesn’t disrupt us when he comes in after the lesson has started. Do you think that’s manageable for you?’ A second way to qualify a request is to state how strongly you would like it: ‘I absolutely must prepare for my next meeting. So, while I want to talk with you about this, I urgently need to leave now. Can we make another time to meet?’ A third approach is to state what your request means and doesn’t mean: ‘I really hope we can find a way for you to get Sam here on time most days. But I certainly don’t want you to be under such pressure that you decide to keep him home for the day rather than bringing him in late’.
‘I-feel’ messages As its title implies, this second type of assertive message tells others about your feelings. Most people who have read anything about assertiveness are familiar with the ‘I feel’ statement in the form of: When you (do such and such), I feel (whatever) because (my rights are being violated in this way). However, in my experience, this kind of statement is not very successful. It tends to provoke defensiveness, as listeners can feel blamed and criticised, with the result that they become defensive. Furthermore, we
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 50
15/1/08 11:47:37 AM
Communication skills
51
often mistakenly express thoughts rather than feelings. You can tell if you are doing this by noticing whether ‘I feel’ is followed by words such as that, as if, or like, with pronouns (I, you, she, they or it) or by a person’s name (Rosenberg 2003). Examples of the distinction are given in Box 3.2.
Box 3.2 Distinctions between thoughts and feelings Thought I feel that you should help tidy up. I feel like a failure. I feel that I have to do everything around here. I feel that she is being bossy.
Feeling I am frustrated at this mess. I am disappointed in myself. I resent being overworked. I am angry at being denied the chance to make my own decisions.
Therefore, to avoid resistance and to ensure that you talk about feelings rather than thoughts, instead name the need that leads to your feelings. This follows the format: I feel… because I need... This message is more likely to receive a compassionate hearing from others. As an example, instead of, ‘When you bring Sam late to school, I feel frustrated because it disrupts the class when he comes in’, your statement of need would become, ‘I feel disappointed when Sam is late, because I need a few quiet minutes to settle everyone down so they can concentrate’.
Empathic assertion Like the When you… I feel… because formula, an empathic assertive message also has three parts, but it begins by expressing understanding of others. This is powerful as it conveys that they have reasons for the behaviour but that, coincidentally, their attempts to fulfil a need happens to frustrate satisfaction of yours. This empathy reduces their defensiveness at a perceived accusation and, by listening to them first, builds goodwill and therefore makes it more likely that they will listen to you in return. Having expressed understanding, the second part of an empathic assertive message is to tell the person about your need and, third, ask for a joint resolution. For example: I understand that there is a lot for you to do in the mornings and I appreciate the times when Sam is here early. (Empathy.) I would like, though, to see if we can come up with a plan for him to be here on time routinely, without putting you under pressure. (Statement of your need.) Do you have any ideas that might help? (Resolution attempt.)
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 51
15/1/08 11:47:37 AM
52
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
Mixed feeling statements In this fourth type of assertive message, you name more than one feeling and explain why you feel each. For example: I appreciate that Sam has been on time these past three days. I was disappointed this morning, though, that he disrupted the group by arriving late.
Confrontive assertion This is useful when others have broken a prior agreement about their behaviour. The confrontive assertive message has three parts: • • •
Describe in a non-judgemental way what the two of you previously agreed. Describe what the other person did. Negotiate what you can do about that.
For example: We agreed that you would ask Marta to bring Sam a couple of times a week to take the pressure off you. I see that this isn’t happening any more and he is arriving late quite often. Do you have any suggestions for solving this?
Listen to others’ reactions After you have stated what you need, others sometimes respond negatively, perhaps by becoming aggressive or defensive, or by withdrawing. These emotions signal that they now have the problem. Therefore, give them some time to digest your statement and their feelings, and then reflect back the emotion behind the reaction. For example: ‘I sense that you think I don’t understand how difficult the mornings are for you’. Finally, repeat your assertive message, stating again your feelings and the unmet need that gives rise to them. It can take from three to 10 assertive messages before other people are willing to change their behaviour; therefore you will need to persist. And of course, if you notice even a hint that they are willing to do as you ask, reflect this back.
Collaborative problem solving The third communication skill, collaborative problem solving, is used when two people are being negatively affected by each other’s actions. Conflict between individuals is both inevitable and productive, in that it signals that their needs are not being met and therefore can trigger a search for a solution. In the process, resolution can build greater understanding of each other. Therefore, rather than looking for someone to blame for a
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 52
15/1/08 11:47:37 AM
Communication skills
53
violation of our needs, our goal will be to craft a solution that allows both people to receive what they require without impinging on others.
Guiding principle Look for a solution, not a culprit.
The collaborative problem-solving process entails the following six steps. 1. Agree to talk it over. 2. Listen to what others need and tell them assertively, but without aggression, what you require. Keep in mind that you both are attempting to get your needs met: the conflict is merely about the strategies you each have chosen. 3. Together, come up with ideas of what you could do that would satisfy both of you. At this stage, do not evaluate how practical these suggestions are, just brainstorm all possibilities, even silly ones. If it helps, write them down. 4. Next, decide which of the options you will take. Do not choose a compromise that satisfies no one, but instead persist until you find a solution that meets both your needs. 5. Decide when and how to carry out your chosen solution. 6. Once a solution is in place, check whether it is working. With simple, everyday problems, the steps do not have to be as regimented, although solving even minor issues will always entail the basic component of listening to each other.
Box 3.3 Summary of communication skills Whose need is unfulfilled
Communication skill
The parent is in need
➔
Listening
Your rights or those of your students are being violated
➔
1 Assertiveness 2 Listening to others’ reaction
Both yours and a parent’s needs are not being fulfilled
➔
Collaborative problem solving
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 53
15/1/08 11:47:37 AM
54
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
Conclusion The professional-driven and family-allied models locate power with teachers. This lack of respect for parents inevitably leads to failures in parent–teacher communications. In other words, failed communication is not the reason that solutions to school-based problems are not found; failed communication is only a symptom of inequity between teachers and parents (Hughes & MacNaughton 2002). Within the alternative, parent-driven model, authentic communication respects the goodness and fragility of others (Swick 2003). This deep connection to their humanity provides the foundation for a truly collaborative relationship.
Additional resources Bolton, R. (1987). People skills. Sydney: Simon and Schuster. Hart, S. & Hodson, V.K. (2004). The compassionate classroom: Relationship based teaching and learning. Encinitas, CA: Puddle Dancer Press. Rosenberg, M.B. (2003). Nonviolent communication: A language of life. (2nd ed.) Encinitas, CA: Puddle Dancer Press.
Website Center for Nonviolent Communication: http://www.cnvc.org
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 54
15/1/08 11:47:37 AM
4
Solution-focused problem solving
The person is not the problem; The problem is the problem. Winslade & Monk (1999, p. 2)
When collaborating with parents to resolve their children’s school-based difficulties, your starting point will be to respect the fact that they will have been co-opted somewhat involuntarily into discussing these with you. While wanting the best for their child and thus being willing to be involved, parents would prefer not to have the problem in the first place. Therefore, they will not relish the prospect of yet another encounter with school personnel about their child’s difficulties. The fact that previous efforts to solve recurrent problems have been unsuccessful means that parents’ selfassurance may be compromised and they may feel sceptical and lack hope about the chances of success of any new intervention. Furthermore, their child’s failure at school may mirror their own unsuccessful school career, in which case they are likely to approach you with suspicion and distrust. Nevertheless, you have a common interest in wanting the problem to be resolved. You both want relief from it.
Guiding principles Solution-focused theory holds that, when people have problems that undermine their functioning, they are more familiar with those problems than outsiders can ever be (Selekman 1997). They are the experts on how the problem affects their lives and, often unbeknownst to themselves, are the experts on how they can affect it. This belief that young people and their parents have the wisdom to solve their own problems not only respects them, but also relieves you of the responsibility of being the expert with all the answers. Instead, you may quiet your own assumptions and
55
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 55
15/1/08 11:47:37 AM
56
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
‘expert’ frame of reference, enquire about what they want for their life and affirm their skills for attaining this (De Jong & Berg 2002). Their answers to your questions (rather than your own assumptions) will provoke your next question. This means that, although this chapter and Figure 4.1
1 Define the problem Discover participants’ definition of the problem
2 Map the problem’s influence Describe the length, breadth and depth (severity) of the problem
3 Articulate goals Discover what is important in life to those experiencing the problem
4 Explore exceptions Identify occasions when the problem was absent or less severe; discover how participants caused that
5 Expand on solutions Recommend that those involved repeat or enlarge on previously successful solutions
6 Notice and highlight progress Elicit exceptions; amplify changes; reinforce solutions; start again
7 Plan to maintain progress Plan how to overcome setbacks Plan for unanticipated challenges
Figure 4.1: Phases of solution-focused problem solving
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 56
15/1/08 11:47:37 AM
Solution-focused problem solving
57
might imply that a solution-focused approach is linear, it actually flows from recursive conversation (Carey & Russell 2003). Solution-focused theory states that recurrent problems are not a sign of individual pathology, but merely signal that people are stuck (not sick) (Murphy 2006). The theory takes little interest in how people got stuck in the first place. Instead, it focuses on how solutions can be developed (Nichols & Schwartz 1995). As such, it has a future orientation, rather than an interest in the past (De Jong & Berg 2002; Molnar & de Shazer 1987; Murphy 1994). As its name implies, solution-focused problem solving also avoids a deficit perspective: your task is not to assess problems, but to listen for parents’ and students’ accounts of what is working (Murphy 2006). To focus in this way on people’s competencies instead of their presumed pathologies is a choice, rather than an issue of fact (Durrant & Kowalski 1995, in Murphy & Duncan 1997). It is based on the assumptions that young people want to please their parents and make their parents proud of them; they want to be active and involved and learn new skills; to be accepted and belong in their social group; for their opinions and choices to be honoured; and to be surprised by and to surprise others (Berg & Steiner 2003, p. 18). Adolescents, in particular, want to be respected for who they are now, rather than who they have been (Davis & Osborn 2000). From this description, it is clear that the solution-focused approach fits neatly within a parent-driven model because its interventions are driven by those experiencing the problem, rather than by an outside adviser (Duncan, Miller & Sparks 2003).
Steps for solution building The recursive and coercive interactions that can occur between students and teachers, particularly over chronic disruptive behaviour (as illustrated in Figure 7.1 on page 122), can also take place between parents and teachers, with each accusing the other of incompetence. Teachers tend to blame student problems on home or child factors, while overlooking the teaching context that might be provoking some of the difficulties (BibouNakou, Kiosseoglou & Stogiannidou 2000; Miller 2003). Students and parents tend to blame teacher unfairness and student vulnerability (although parents do also recognise certain disadvantaging features of their home life) (Miller et al. 2002). Rather than allocating blame, four principles can inform your interactions with parents to resolve school-based difficulties. First, you must recognise that this is a school-based problem and therefore the school must be the one to solve it. Even if parents did instigate disciplinary
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 57
15/1/08 11:47:37 AM
58
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
measures at home, these would have little impact on their child’s behaviour at school (Miller 2003). Second, your purpose in informing parents of concerns about their child at school is not to have them punish their child at home. You would not punish a child at school for something that happened at home. On the contrary, your purpose is to harness their expertise to suggest how you might solve it. The third principle is that all parents from all backgrounds want to be proud of their children, to give them educational and other opportunities that they themselves might not have had, and to have a good relationship with their children (Berg & Steiner 2003). They want to have hope for their children. Therefore, when collaborating with parents it is important to fortify and restore their pride in their children. Finally, it is self-evident that you will be working with parents at times when there is a problem to be solved, rather than when all is going well. At such times, it could be easy to fall into a trap of judging them or assuming that their personal or parenting deficiencies are the cause of their children’s difficulties. However, pressure on students at school can cause stress for even a well-functioning family and can add intolerable pressure to one that is already strained. This implies that the final key ingredient of collaborating with parents is to bear in mind the quote that heads this chapter: that students or their parents are not the problem: The problem is the problem (Winslade & Monk 1999, p. 2).
Preparation Problem-solving meetings must be conducted in a private space, without distractions (Hughes & MacNaughton 2002; MacNaughton 2004). You will need to allocate enough time to enable parents to feel comfortable and to discuss your concerns and listen to their reactions. This groundwork aside, the most fundamental aspect of preparation for a conference with parents is to know their child well.
Negotiate whom to involve In many families, grandparents or other extended family members have a crucial role as elders or as major or supplementary care providers for children. In light of this, discover ahead of time who should be included in any meeting aimed at resolving students’ difficulties. As those most affected by the outcome of any meeting between you and their parents, students have a right to be involved in discussions concerning them. More than this, however, they are the experts on their own problems and can advise adults how to respond. If their attendance at
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 58
15/1/08 11:47:37 AM
Solution-focused problem solving
59
meetings would mean that they were heavily out-numbered by adults, they can invite a best friend along for moral support or as adviser to the adults. If a friend cannot attend or students decline to invite anyone, you can allocate an empty seat on which you place the friend’s name. Participants at the meeting can address the empty chair, asking hypothetically of the friend in his or her absence questions such as, ‘I wonder what Shara would advise us about this?’
Engage parents’ expertise Given that they see their children in a wide variety of contexts and over a longer time period than teachers, that children behave differently at home versus school and that parents have intimate knowledge of their children’s emotional wellbeing, they can be more accurate than teachers in describing their child’s characteristic behaviours (Lindsay & Dockrell 2000). This expertise can inform solutions. Additionally, when attempting to solve their son’s or daughter’s school-based difficulties, parents can fulfil the following many supportive functions (Freeman, Epston & Lobovits 1997): • • •
•
Parents can give examples and enlarge on stories that enrich the descriptions of their child’s problem and of exceptions to it. They can brainstorm ideas and solutions. They can become co-conspirators or part of the student’s ‘team’, helping him or her to outwit, tame, combat, conquer, oppose or overcome the problem. They form an audience that can highlight and celebrate their child’s mastery over the problem.
This embracing of parents’ expertise can be a significant reversal of the pattern of uncooperative and unproductive relationships between families and school that can become entrenched when students have chronic difficulties (Lindquist, Molnar & Brauchmann 1987; Lusterman 1985).
Phase 1 Define the problem Following the sequence of steps illustrated in Figure 4.1, your first task in solution-focused work is to describe what happens when the problem occurs and to identify who does what in response to it. When eliciting these details, your purpose is not to establish a consensus about the facts: it is enough to understand how participants perceive the problem, because they act as though their perceptions are reality. Perceptions are all there ever is (Fisch, Weakland & Segal 1982). Therefore, you do not have to agree with their view or endorse it as the only possible perspective, but merely recognise that it is the one from which they are operating.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 59
15/1/08 11:47:37 AM
60
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
Students’ and parents’ description of the sequence of events surrounding the problem will yield their history or ‘story’ of the problem. However, when problems have endured for some time, a person’s whole identity can come to be defined by his or her difficulties. The image that others have of the person – and often the image he or she holds of himor herself – becomes saturated with incidents of problematic behaviour. The person is seen in terms of being ‘mad, bad or sad’, while his or her many other skills and qualities are overlooked (Perry 1999). In order to avoid the spiralling gloom and despondency that inevitably arises from an exclusive focus on problems, early in your conversation you will need to ask students or their parents to tell you something about them that would surprise you, that you might not know. This focus on aspects other than the problem is not merely to build rapport or ease into talking about difficult issues, but to gather information about their skills and personal attributes that can become part of the solution that you will jointly generate. Skills to look out for include actions that indicate courage, strength, dedication, effort, wise judgement, loyalty, cooperation and caring for others, to name but a few (De Jong & Berg 2002; Sklare 2005).
Phase 2 Map the problem’s influence So that you can appreciate the gravity of the problem, once you have understood its manifestations, you can ask how long it has been in the student’s life, whether it has been getting worse or better, and how those involved anticipate that it might unfold in the future. This maps the problem’s length. You also need to understand to what depth or intensity the problem is felt: does it weigh heavily on the student? Does its severity vary? When is it hardest to handle? (Winslade & Monk 1999). Third, its breadth refers to how widely the problem has affected the student’s life (Winslade & Monk 1999). Does it affect school life only, or has it spread into his or her family, peer and other relationships? Has it interfered with school work, career plans, social life, extracurricular activities? Does it affect how the student thinks about him- or herself (Freeman et al. 1997; Morgan 2000)? These questions are aimed at acknowledging the distress that the problem has caused to those experiencing it. You might summarise this effect as taking the fun out of life, interfering with the student’s relationships, or causing him or her to do poorly in class.
Phase 3 Articulate goals In order to provide a clear direction for change, goals must be concrete, realistic and measurable so that improvement can be recognised. Even more importantly, goals must be meaningful to those having to make changes so that they are motivated to do so. You can elicit the goals of those involved by asking them what they would like to get out of your
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 60
15/1/08 11:47:37 AM
Solution-focused problem solving
61
conversation or how they would know things were improving. The ‘miracle question’ is fundamental here (de Shazer 1988); this asks those involved to imagine that last night, while they were sleeping, a miracle happened and their problem was fixed. You follow this up by asking what will have changed in their lives, who will be doing what differently. This question can be made less formal by asking, ‘If tomorrow turned out to be a good day for you, what would be happening?’ (Ajmal 2001). Or, you can ask them to pretend that there are two movies of their life, one with the problem as it is now and another without the problem: What does the second movie look like? (Murphy 2006). Their answers will tell you what is important to them in life, what they value and how they would like to live. This is their goal. The aim is for those involved to express positive goals that state what they want to happen in their lives, rather than negative goals stating what they want stopped (De Jong & Berg 2002; Sklare 2005). Thus, when they declare that they want a given behaviour to cease or for other people to change, these negative goals will have to be translated into something positive that they can do (e.g. ‘If you weren’t losing your temper, what would you be doing instead?’, ‘If your teacher were being nicer to you, what would you be doing differently to make that happen?’). When they identify impossible goals, such as for their divorced parents to reunite, you can respond to such wishes by asking, ‘That means a lot to you because…?’ (Sklare 2005, p. 30), which allows you then to focus on finding ways to meet the underlying need. The same rationale lies behind instances in which the student’s goal is to leave school or take up a delinquent lifestyle, when you can ask how that will help him or her, so that you can detect the need (goal) that the antisocial behaviour is intended to satisfy. If, even with the miracle question, those involved still say that they do not know what they want, you can ask hypothetical questions: ‘If you did know… If you had to take a guess, what might it be?’ or distal questions such as, ‘What would your Mum (or best friend) tell me was the most important thing to you?’ Once their goals are framed in achievable terms, scaling questions can ask students or their parents to rate their present problem on a scale of 1 to 10 (with 1 being the worst it’s ever been and 10 being the day after the miracle), so they can assess how close they already are to achieving their goal. The following questions can be useful (Kral & Kowalski 1989; Rhodes 1993; Wagner & Gillies 2001). • • • • •
At what number is your life at the moment? How happy are you with that number? (This will tell you how motivated they are to change their behaviour.) What number would you prefer to be at? What will life be like at x + 1? What will you be doing differently? Have you ever been at x + 1 before? If so, what was happening then?
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 61
15/1/08 11:47:37 AM
62
• • •
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
What do you think are the chances that you will reach (the goal number)? How will you know that you are making progress? What will be the first sign? When this problem is entirely solved, what will be happening that is different from what is occurring now?
Some parents can be so oppressed by what seems to be the intractability of their child’s school difficulties that they find it difficult to identify any optimistic goals. The exploration of exceptions can assist with this.
Phase 4 Explore exceptions The assumption guiding this next phase is that, although an enduring problem can appear to be ‘always’ happening, this is an illusion: change is inevitable. There will be times when the problem is not occurring, is happening less often, or is less intense. These occasions are called exceptions. Their existence proves that a solution is already in place. All individuals, no matter how stuck, are doing something to prevent a problem from occurring at least some of the time; and all environments, no matter how bleak, are supporting them to achieve that. Your task in this phase, then, is to help students or their parents identify these occasions and describe what they did to make these happen. In other words, rather than looking for what is wrong and how to fix it, a solution orientation searches for what is right and how to use it (Berg & Miller 1992, in Davis & Osborn 2000). Once those involved can recount instances when the problem was absent or less severe than usual, you can ask specific questions to help them identify what they did to generate these exceptions (Carey & Russell 2003): • • • •
Are you aware of how you got that to happen? Did you take any steps leading up to it? What did you do to pull that off? What were you thinking at the time that helped you do that?
A second set of questions implies something about the person’s identity (Carey & Russell 2003): • • • •
What does this tell us about your ability to control the problem? What does it tell us about what is important to you in life, that you were willing to do that? What did the problem have you thinking about yourself before?… What do you think about yourself now?’ Can you tell me about other times you have acted to give yourself a better life?
When parents are so paralysed by their child’s or their own problems that they cannot notice exceptions or their role in enabling these, resiliency
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 62
15/1/08 11:47:37 AM
Solution-focused problem solving
63
questions can help. You can begin by asking them in their child’s presence how they know that he or she can do better (Berg & Steiner 2003). When young people hear that their parents believe they have some fine qualities, they will experience the care and support that they seldom otherwise hear and cannot ask for outright. Another resiliency question asks family members about previous occasions when they have overcome adversity or solved this or other issues for their family. You could ask, ‘What skills and strategies have you been using that have prevented this problem from getting worse than it is now?’ (Selekman 1997). If even the miracle question and these resiliency questions do not assist them in identifying goals and their capacity to achieve these, you can externalise the problem, as outlined below. This method allows the problem to be the villain, rather than the child.
Phase 5 Expand on solutions Once those involved can describe their goals and the skills they have used on occasion to achieve at least part of what they want, you need to ‘build a bridge’ between their past and future successes (De Jong & Berg 2002). During your exploration of exceptions, you will have listened for solutions, of which there are four types: those that have failed, those that have worked, those that have been considered but not implemented, and those that others have advised (Murphy & Duncan 1997). Discovering what has failed tells you what not to try again, while finding out what has worked, even partially, gives you the clue to what may work again and what strengths those involved have already brought to bear on the problem – and therefore could use again. Once the discussion has generated a potential solution, you might support their ideas with some suggested tasks aimed at increasing the frequency of their solution attempts and transferring these to other situations (Murphy 2006). These tasks constitute the ‘bridge’ between their former and future successes. •
•
When those involved can identify their previously successful strategies, ask what it would take for them to use these again. If they doubt their abilities to do so, merely have them observe what is different about those times when they do manage to create an exception (de Shazer 1988). When those involved believe that the exceptions were just flukes, to heighten their awareness that these are not in fact mere accidents but happen as a result of something they do (Carey 1999), you could, for example, ask younger students about their heroes and then enquire: ‘What do you think (their hero’s name) would do if faced with this problem? Would that be something you’d be willing to try?’ (Murphy 2006). Alternatively, you could set up a game where on any given day the student could pretend that the miracle/solution/goal had happened. Durrant (1995) gives the example of inviting a student to act as
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 63
15/1/08 11:47:38 AM
64
•
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
though he did not feel like throwing things at his peers, was having fun and was enjoying his work. Meanwhile, his teacher was to guess whether he was pretending or was ‘for real’. This helped the teacher to notice those occasions when the student’s behaviour had improved, instead of naturally focusing on the times when the problem was manifested. When those involved are convinced that the problem always happens and accordingly feel hopeless or helpless, you can suggest observational tasks such as, ‘Next time we meet, I want you to describe to me one thing in your life that you want to continue to have happen’ (De Jong & Berg 2002, p. 130). Or you can ask them to reflect on what they are doing to prevent the problem from becoming even more serious (Molnar & de Shazer 1987).
When students or their parents are having difficulty believing they can control exceptions, you can use what is known as ‘reversal questions’, which ask students or their best friend to act as the adults’ advisers about how their parents should respond to their behaviour at home, or how their teachers should handle it at school. Alternatively, consultancy questions can explicitly capitalise on parents’ knowledge: ‘Given that you know your child better than anyone else, what suggestions do you have for us to help him/her at school? (Murphy 2006)… You’ve spoken to your child’s previous teachers about this in the past. What have we all missed so far that could help?… If I have another student with similar issues in my class in future, what could you tell me about how I might help him or her?… If there was one useful question about your child’s behaviour that I could ask, what would that question be?’ (Selekman 1997). When two parents disagree on a solution, it is clear that they are both committed to solving the child’s difficulties and both want what is best for him or her. Therefore, you cannot take sides with one or the other. Instead, you can suggest that each morning they flip a coin, with heads signalling that the mother is in charge for the day and tails denoting that the father is. The one who is in charge enacts his or her solution for the day, while the other notices what works about the other’s approach (De Jong & Berg 2002). This undermines the either/or thinking, which upholds that one parent is right and the other is wrong, allows them to save face with their partner and almost inevitably results in their collaborating to build a new solution (De Jong & Berg 2002).
Phase 6 Notice and highlight progress In the next review meeting, begin with the question, ‘What’s better/different since last time we spoke?’ This conveys confidence that those involved have the skills to have taken some steps towards improving their life (De Jong & Berg 2002). Do not ask if they performed the task they generated at the last meeting, because if they have not, they will be embarrassed or
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 64
15/1/08 11:47:38 AM
Solution-focused problem solving
65
despondent. Besides, the task is irrelevant if they came up with a different strategy altogether or improvements are happening anyway. Those involved could report that there has been some improvement, no change, a deterioration in the child’s behaviour, or different members could have mixed opinions. In a process represented by the acronym EARS, you need to elicit exceptions, amplify these, reinforce (celebrate) their successes and start again by asking about other exceptions (De Jong & Berg 2002). When eliciting exceptions, it is crucial to notice even those changes that do not appear to be related to the problem or its solution. Each improvement needs to be appreciated for its own sake, not just as a step towards further advances. Next, highlight (or amplify) these changes, investigating the ripple effect that they have wrought on others (Sklare 2005). To reinforce these effects, highlight the skills that students or their parents have used to bring them about, not out of any attempt to flatter them but in an effort to help them recognise their own skills. One technique that is termed ‘positive blame’ can use the same kinds of questions employed to explore exceptions, such as, ‘How did you get that to happen?… Where did you get such a useful idea?… What did you tell yourself that helped you do that?… Is that something different for you?’ (Kral & Kowalski 1989). Further reinforcement can be achieved by asking, ‘What does that tell you about yourself?’ (as described earlier). Finally, you can help those involved to recognise additional changes through questions such as, ‘What else is better?… What else have you done to be friendly to the other children?’ or by mentioning what you have noticed. When there appears to all those involved to have been no change, or even a deterioration in the problem, you will need to listen to their despondency. Having acknowledged their discouragement, you can then compare bad days with worse days and ask what creates the difference (McLeod 1989); ask resiliency questions such as how come they have not given up, what keeps them hanging in there and trying, or how come the problem is no worse than it is. If you have not already done so, it could help to externalise or reframe the problem in order to generate a new view of it that will suggest how it can change (see the sections below). When parents’ progress reports are mixed, with one reporting improvement while another is still pessimistic, begin by highlighting the improvements. This can help sceptics to rise above their pessimism. At the same time, however, acknowledge their caution, agreeing that it is only sensible, given how long they have been battling the problem.
Phase 7 Develop a plan to maintain progress Relapses are so common as to be predictable. One specific way to reduce the chances that students’ old habits take hold again is to engage as wide
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 65
15/1/08 11:47:38 AM
66
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
an audience as possible in celebrating and supporting their successes. This is especially important within schools, where teachers’ or peers’ scepticism can make it difficult for students to overcome their negative reputation. One way to do this is to formulate lists, charts, diaries, letters, certificates of achievement, art or poetry to document their progress. With their consent, you could circulate these to selected readers such as their parents, the principal, or other teachers, as appropriate. The most important audience, however, will be the students themselves. Whereas conversations are ephemeral, documents endure and can be used to reaffirm students’ successes at times when they are discouraged (Fox 2003). A crucial means for maintaining progress is to develop with the student and parents ahead of time a plan for coping with obstacles and any new or unfamiliar experiences that might flow from an improvement in their problem (Murphy 2006). This helps them to be realistic about the work ahead of them and prevents their being caught off guard by unforeseen challenges (Sklare 2005). For example, you might have to ask whether their new behaviour will disrupt their friendship groupings and, if so, how they could deal with that. In order to avoid despondency at relapses, you can describe these as ways that the problem tests them to see if they can ‘get back on track’; alternatively, you could frame setbacks as providing new information about the tricks and tactics the problem uses to take over their lives (Morgan 1999). Next, you can remind those involved of the strategies that they originally used to overcome the problem and encourage them to resume using those (Kowalski 1990). An alternative perspective is that even a failure contains a partial success. When the alcoholic who is trying to be abstinent takes six drinks, she used a strategy not to have a seventh; when a student has been verbally abusive towards a peer or teacher, you can ask what he did to stop himself lashing out physically as well. When students are deeply discouraged, you could try coping questions such as, ‘What have you done since this happened to calm yourself down?… How did you find the courage to come and speak with me about this?… On a scale of one to 10, how badly did you feel at the time? How does that compare with how you feel now?… What did you do to bring about that improvement?’ This highlights that, even in the face of failure, they are still using some skills to recover from setbacks.
View problems differently So far, I have described solution-focused methods that aim to do things differently. Sometimes, this has to be enabled by first viewing them
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 66
15/1/08 11:47:38 AM
Solution-focused problem solving
67
differently. This involves either thinking about problems in new ways so that they become solvable, or externalising problems. This is a process of naming them as though they were a separate entity, so that those experiencing them no longer have to be oppressed by their own supposed deficiencies. They can distance themselves to some extent from the problem.
Reframe your understanding of the problem The technique of reframing is based on the notion that your response to students’ behaviour will depend on what you think causes it. The fact that your responses are not working suggests that perhaps your explanation of the behaviour is not helping. Like taking a different route when a roadblock prevents access to your destination, reframing suggests thinking about problems in a new way so that you can take a different route to solving them. It follows the advice of Einstein (in de Shazer 1993, p. 84), who observed, ‘You cannot solve the problem with the same kind of thinking that has created the problem’. In a reference to how an old painting can look quite different in a revitalised picture frame, changing how you interpret or view a problem is termed developing a reframe. Reframing is performed in the following steps. Step 1. Describe what is occurring. Describe the problem. You can reflect on what a video camera would capture if it were focused on incidents. Step 2. Describe present corrective attempts. Describe who gets involved in trying to correct the behaviour and what their responses entail. Identify the usual effects of these measures. Step 3. Identify your present explanation for the behaviour. Explanations that do not work usually comprise one of two themes. The first is that students are ‘doing it deliberately’ (perhaps even ‘to get at you’). This interpretation is usually employed when young people are aggressive or lack remorse for their antisocial behaviour (Morgenson 1989). Teachers typically find such attitudes intolerable and feel victimised, angry and frustrated by the behaviour (Amatea & Sherrard 1989). In response, they use a range of escalating punishments which, although different on the face of it, all have the same intent of forcing students to cease their behaviour. The second belief – namely, that students cannot help themselves – is most common with passive behaviours such as mood disturbances, phobic reactions or learning disabilities (Amatea & Sherrard 1989), and when students seem remorseful about their behaviour (Morgenson 1989). Although apparently more sympathetic than thinking of students
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 67
15/1/08 11:47:38 AM
68
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
as malevolent (‘bad’), viewing them as incompetent (‘mad’) helps little. When students believe that they are helpless, they do not attempt to take charge of the problem; when you believe they are helpless, you will be too permissive, alternated with frustration and exasperated demands that they ‘pull their socks up’. Neither response will be effective, as students alternate between feeling so comfortable that they are not motivated to change and feeling victimised and misunderstood, against which they rebel. Step 4. Generate a new explanation. A new view of the problem will be based on the recognition that human beings are rational – that is, they act in ways that they expect will meet their needs. Therefore, it can be assumed that the behaviour is having some positive effect in their lives. The task at this stage, then, is to identify that positive effect in order to describe the purpose of the behaviour in a new way that, in turn, will imply a new response to it. For example, when students experience anxiety about coming to school, a deficit view might regard them as emotionally fragile or immature, when a reframe of the same behaviours could be that they are trying to look after stressed parents by staying home with them. As long as this fits the perceptions of those experiencing the problem, this view transforms children from being seen as immature to seeing them as exercising too much responsibility. When you are generating this new explanation, keep in mind that you cannot read minds and therefore cannot diagnose the intention behind others’ behaviour: you are simply looking for its effect. When the reframe that you generate does not correspond with everyone’s experience of the problem, it simply signals the need to generate another hypothesis about the possible effect of the behaviour. Step 5. Change how you respond. The new view of the problem will enable you to let go of an ineffective solution and try something else (Fisch et al. 1982). Now that you have identified (in step 4) the effect of the behaviour, the aim of your modified responses to it will be to allow students to meet their need, but in a less disruptive fashion.
Externalise the problem Individuals’ entire image of themselves can become saturated with examples of their problem behaviour. Thus defined as defective, they have no confidence that they can do anything to overcome the problem. One way to turn around this helplessness is to avoid locating blame within individuals, by giving the problem a name and speaking about it as if it were its own entity that was external to them. Narrative therapy calls this externalising. It can be particularly useful when the problem seems to have a life of its own, or when those involved report feeling helpless
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 68
15/1/08 11:47:38 AM
Solution-focused problem solving
69
to control it. Together with the young person and parents, generate a name for the problem, using their language or having them select from a list of potential labels that you propose, such as calling outbursts of anger ‘Temper’, ‘Trouble’ or ‘the Rage’; sadness might be labelled as ‘the Misery’; for those with concentration difficulties, it could be that ‘Squirmies’ make it difficult for them to listen, for example (Huntley 1999). Sometimes these problems have allies that team up with them and cause further oppression, such as self-doubt or self-criticism (Morgan 2000) which, for younger children, you might label ‘Name-calling’. Your questions then become, ‘How do you feel when Rage pushes you around and gets you into trouble?… Do you think that’s fair?… Would you like to tame Temper so that it stops bossing you around?’ and so on. Next, enquire what tactics the problem uses: ‘How does it speak to you: does it shout at you or only whisper nasty things in your ear about how hopeless you are? What sorts of things does it tell you?’ You could then ask students how they feel about the influence of the problem and the strategies it uses to maintain its hold over them. You might also ask what they could possibly have done to deserve being spoken to in that way, and querying whether it is fair that the problem uses these tactics to take the fun out of life. Such questions will get them in touch with their motivation to reduce the impact of the problem on their lives. Once students express a desire to conquer or tame their problem, you might suggest some specific skills and strategies they can use. These could include employing constructive self-talk to weaken the influence of the problem when it is trying to divert them from their goal, or teaching emotional regulation or conflict management skills so that they do not inflame peer conflicts, for example.
Solution-focused consultation Consultation in schools is a voluntary and active process whereby one professional with specialist knowledge (often a special educator, educational psychologist, social worker or the like) assists another with generalist knowledge (i.e. a teacher) to plan a program or intervention for individual students (Friend & Cook 2007). In teachers’ interactions with consultants, the parent-driven style becomes teacher-driven. That is to say, the classroom teacher employs the consultant for his or her specialist knowledge and, therefore, is the one who drives their interaction. The consultant is accountable to the teacher and responsible for suggesting appropriate and feasible solutions (Friend & Cook 2007), which requires familiarity with the teacher’s setting and its constraints. For their part,
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 69
15/1/08 11:47:38 AM
70
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
teachers will also be responsible for generating potential solutions, while having the ultimate authority to determine which are practicable in their classrooms. They are also expected to be open to being innovative and incorporating adjustments to their practices, which is more likely when they are extremely knowledgeable about curriculum and pedagogy, are student-centred in their teaching, and able to reflect on whether their teaching is achieving their goals for students’ engagement and outcomes (Brownell et al. 2006). The typical expectation of consultants in schools is that they adopt a clinical style of assessment to diagnose a cause for children’s school-based difficulties, in order to generate a prescription detailing what teachers and parents can do about it (Wagner & Gillies 2001). However, this can degenerate into the administration of increasingly detailed assessments to discover more and more obscure names for conditions that ultimately prove to be untreatable. Meanwhile, teachers are frustrated by the delay in gaining the support and advice they need. Furthermore, this approach represents a top-down rather than collaborative style, which violates the basic tenets of a parent-driven approach. It fails to respect the wisdom and expertise of teachers. Instead, a solution-oriented assessment involving observation of students will not yield a ‘laundry list’ of what is going wrong, but will examine exceptions to the problem and what brings those about (McGlone 2001). Subsequent consultative problem solving with teachers will begin in the same way as any solution-building approach: it will start with listening to their concerns and asking in what ways they hope the consultation will be useful. Goals are clarified by asking what they want to see changed (perhaps employing the miracle question), and enquiring who will be doing what differently when the miracle has eventuated. Next follows an examination of what is working. This gives the consultant an opportunity to reflect to the student, parents and teacher what his or her observations indicate that they are each doing to enable those exceptions. This focuses the discussion on what they have done previously that has worked. Useful questions include, ‘When faced with this kind of behaviour before, what did you do that worked?… What effects did you notice?… How do you explain those?… How could you do that again?’ (Wagner & Gillies 2001). The consultant would then ask all those involved to rate the difficulty (on a scale of 1 to 10). The discussion can close on the following questions (Wagner & Gillies 2001, p. 156): • • • •
How close are we to making a plan? What else do we need to consider? What would it take to put these ideas into action? If you were to do this as an experiment, what would you do?
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 70
15/1/08 11:47:38 AM
Solution-focused problem solving
71
In the period between consultations, teachers can experiment with new ways of responding to the student’s problem and notice exceptions, observing what they and the student are doing differently when these occur. As with parents, guided by the acronym EARS, subsequent consultations will elicit the exceptions, amplify changes, reinforce these and start on the next problem, if necessary (Wagner & Gillies 2001, p. 157).
Referrals No one knows everything about everything, even within his or her field of expertise. Furthermore, a teacher’s role is typically not one of counselling students or their parents. Therefore, on occasion it will be necessary to refer parents to specialist counsellors. In order to do so, you will need to find out about available services, including details of waiting time, costs and contact phone numbers. The more specific your information, the easier it will be for parents to follow up your concerns promptly.
Conclusion The parent-driven and solution-focused approaches share the view that the most potent source of information for problem solving is students and parents themselves. They know more about their lives than outsiders ever will. Thus, in contrast to approaches in which the practitioner is the hero and those with problems are regarded as fragile and ineffective, the solution-focused approach chooses to see young people, their parents and teachers as the heroes in their own story, the creators of their own solutions (Murphy & Duncan 1997). Nevertheless, as Murphy and Duncan (1997, p. 49) observe, this positive focus: does not mean that the practitioner ignores suffering or assumes a pollyannish, ‘hear no evil, see no evil’ attitude, but rather that he or she listens to the whole story: the confusion and the clarity, the suffering and the endurance, the pain and the coping, the desperation and the desire.
Distilled down to its simplest notions, solution-focused approaches advise that when present solutions are not working, you either view something differently or do something differently (Murphy & Duncan 1997). Viewing differently encompasses noticing non-problems (exceptions) as well as the problems, externalising or reframing problems; while doing something differently obeys the maxims (de Shazer et al. 1986, p. 212): If something works, do more of it. (Look for exceptions.) If something isn’t working, stop it. (Do less of the same.) If something isn’t working, do something else. (Do something different.)
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 71
15/1/08 11:47:38 AM
72
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
Additional resources Solution-focused approach Berg, I.K. & Steiner, S. (2003). Children’s solution work. New York: Norton. De Jong, P. & Berg, I.K. (2002). Interviewing for solutions. (2nd ed.) Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks/Cole Thomson. Durrant, M. (1995). Creative strategies for school problems. Epping, NSW: Eastwood Family Therapy Centre/New York: Norton. Murphy, J.J. (2006). Solution-focused counseling in middle and high schools. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Merrill Prentice Hall. Selekman, M.D. (1997). Solution-focused therapy with children: Harnessing family strengths for systemic change. New York: Guilford. Sklare, G.B. (2005). Brief counseling that works: A solution-focused approach for school counselors and administrators. (2nd ed.) Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press.
Narrative therapy Freeman, J., Epston, D. & Lobovits, D. (1997). Playful approaches to serious problems: Narrative therapy with children and their families. New York: Norton. Morgan, A. (Ed.) (1999). Once upon a time… Narrative therapy with children and their families. Adelaide, SA: Dulwich Centre Publications. Morgan, A. (2000) What is narrative therapy?: An easy-to-read introduction. Adelaide, SA: Dulwich Centre Publications. Winslade, J. & Monk, G. (1999). Narrative counseling in schools: Powerful and brief. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press.
Websites Brief Family Therapy Center, United States: http://www.brief-therapy.org Brief Therapy Institute of Sydney, Australia: http://www.brieftherapy sydney.com.au SYCOL, Solution-oriented training, United Kingdom: http://www.sycol. co.uk United Kingdom Association for Solution Focused Practice: http://www. ukasfp.co.uk
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 72
15/1/08 11:47:38 AM
Part II Problem solving with parents Parents look for two sets of qualities in their children’s teachers or other professional advisers (Summers et al. 2005). The first is that they want you to be competent in working with their children. They want their children to be happy at school and, to that end, value teachers acting professionally but also in ways that protect, nurture and encourage their children (Roffey 2002). When parents see you being superb at what they are employing you to do – namely, teaching their children – they will support you. Beyond this, when children have additional needs or challenges such as those examined in Part II of this text, being competent calls on you not only to be an excellent teacher, but also skilled at problem solving. Although this may sound daunting, it does not mean that you have to find the solutions yourself; merely that you know where to look for these. The second set of skills parents look for in their children’s teachers is to be respectful and supportive of themselves (Summers et al. 2005). To help you satisfy these two requirements, this section provides some background information about the challenge under discussion and then describes the needs of parents and how you can meet these, much of which involves providing for their child’s requirements. In those instances where it is not your role to meet certain needs yourself, it can be useful to recommend other agencies that can. Ultimately, your success in solving students’ problems will reduce the need for ongoing problem solving with their parents.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 73
15/1/08 11:47:38 AM
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 74
15/1/08 11:47:38 AM
5
Collaborating with parents of children with disabilities or chronic illnesses
It is not just, as some assume, that one should fit the intervention to the child, but rather that one should fit the intervention to the goal. Jordan (2004, p. 4)
The inclusion of children with disabilities in regular education is not constrained by teachers’ willingness or attitude to disability, but by the availability of resources for meeting students’ additional needs. A majority of teachers believe that inclusive settings can benefit students both with and without disabilities, but they also believe that there is limited capacity to adjust teaching procedures, particularly in high schools (Scruggs & Mastropieri 1996). The more severe a child’s disability, the less support both parents and teachers believe there is to ensure inclusion and the less confident they are of its benefits both for students with disabilities and their peers (Hanson et al. 2001; Scruggs & Mastropieri 1996). Not surprisingly, therefore, throughout their schooling students with significant disabilities come to be placed in increasingly segregated settings as their academic capacities and consequent requirements for curricular adjustments become more discrepant from those of their typically developing peers (Hanson et al. 2001; Hughes & May 1988). Against this background, collaborating with parents whose children have additional needs will require you to be sensitive to their reactions to disability and to the services they require.
Parents’ reactions to their child’s disability A few decades ago, research on parents whose children had disabilities commonly reported higher parental stress levels and increased marital strain. More recent research, however, is reporting that these parents experience the same variety of life events and adjustment issues as all others. This improvement over time in parents’ adjustment has been attributed to
75
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 75
15/1/08 11:47:38 AM
76
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
increased social tolerance of diversity and improved services for children with additional needs (Seltzer et al. 2001). Thus, parents’ reactions that were once thought to be about their child’s disability itself were in large part frustration, hurt and anger at a lack of appropriate services.
Stress It is likely that stress is cyclical and transitory for these parents, just as it is for any others. The nature of the disability may be less relevant than whether it is accompanied by behavioural difficulties and low levels of adaptive skills – that is, whether the child has high caretaking needs (Baker et al. 2002; Fox et al. 2002; Hodapp, Fidler & Smith 1998a; Roach, Orsmond & Barratt 1999; Scorgie, Wilgosh & McDonald 1998; Stores et al. 1998; Suarez & Baker 1997; Turnbull & Ruef 1996; Williford et al. 2007). Especially when their child’s behaviour is unpredictable, it limits many other aspects of family functioning, such as their recreational or social outings. Sometimes a disability such as Down syndrome can create less public embarrassment than one that is less obvious, such as autism. And, although we might assume that parents are more stressed when their children have severe disabilities, having these disabilities more readily diagnosed can save them much uncertainty and worry (Siklos & Kerns 2007). Research shows that, despite the higher caretaking needs of many children with disabilities, fathers’ involvement increases little to compensate (Roach et al. 1999), leaving mothers disproportionately taking on the extra demands (Bright & Wright 1986). This exacerbates mothers’ physical and emotional health difficulties, restricts their working opportunities, and negatively affects their marital satisfaction (Roach et al. 1999). As with all families, stress can come from outside sources, not just from the children. Families whose children have disabilities are as various as all others, with some enduring poverty and other life challenges. The combination of their circumstances and a child’s disability can magnify the effects of each, however. For example, children’s additional needs can require extra costs, which can put strain on impoverished families. At the same time, the working life of parents whose children have additional needs can be repeatedly disrupted by the need to attend medical and other appointments. Consequently, mothers tend to work fewer hours or not at all (Barnett & Boyce 1995; Seltzer et al. 2001). Although the choice to surrender their career ambitions is voluntary and in midlife mothers are satisfied with their choice to do so (Seltzer et al. 2001), this is still a loss to them personally and leaves the family with restricted finances at the same time as having additional expenses, only a portion of which will be offset by welfare benefits. Mothers whose infants have high care needs also find it difficult to secure high-quality child care that can provide for their children’s additional
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 76
15/1/08 11:47:38 AM
Collaborating with parents of children with disabilities or chronic illnesses
77
needs and, when they do, there can be extra travel to their selected service and frequent changes of care arrangements (Booth & Kelly 1999; Knoche et al. 2006; Warfield & Hauser-Cram 1996). The lack of suitable child care affects mothers’ prospects of returning to work, with 56 per cent working outside of home, compared with 76 per cent of mothers of typically developing children (Roach et al. 1999).
Parenting skills Particularly when their children have significant behavioural difficulties, parents’ physical energies can be drained by relentless demands and the need for constant vigilance, or ‘being on call 24 hours a day’ (Fox et al. 2002; McKenzie 1994; Turnbull & Ruef 1996; Webster-Stratton & Spitzer 1996). As is true for all families, over and above major stressors, daily hassles combined with depleted resources will lead to strain (Smith, Oliver & Innocenti 2001). In reverse, irritable parenting associated with high parental stress levels contributes to children’s escalating behavioural problems over time, both for children with and without disabilities (Baker et al. 2003; Belsky, Hsieh & Crnic 1998; Dallaire & Weinraub 2005; Donovan, Leavitt & Walsh 2000; Hastings & Rubin 1999; Kilgore, Snyder & Lentz 2000; Meyers 1999; Nix et al. 1999; O’Leary, Slep & Reid 1999; Shaw et al. 2003; Smith et al. 2004, Snyder et al. 2005; Stoolmiller 2001).
Emotional wellbeing Decreased confidence in their parenting skills and a heightened sense of restrictions on their functioning contribute to reduced emotional satisfaction for parents whose children have disabilities, but typically within the normal range for the population in general (Roach et al. 1999). Although some parents of children with disabilities show elevated rates of depression (McCarthy et al. 2006; Roach et al. 1999), others do not (Scott et al. 1997). In the long term, their emotional wellbeing is indistinguishable from parents in the general community (Seltzer et al. 2001).
Marital satisfaction One study reported a doubling of marital separation in families whose child has a disability (Fujiura 1998). Others report similar levels of marital satisfaction between these and all other families (McCarthy et al. 2006; Stoneman & Gavidia-Payne 2006).
Grief Parents may discover their child’s disability before or at birth, gradually in later years when their child’s development does not proceed as expected,
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 77
15/1/08 11:47:38 AM
78
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
or suddenly when their child acquires a disability from an acute illness or trauma. An unanticipated disability may be met with feelings of loss, although parents who have their child’s disability confirmed after a long period of concern can sometimes be relieved to finally achieve some understanding of their child’s atypical development or behaviours (Fox et al. 2002; Whitehead & Gosling 2003). In my experience, having a clear diagnosis helps parents to understand their child’s needs and to predict some of the decisions they will need to make in the future. This might explain why parents whose children have Down syndrome report lower stress levels than those with less predictable disabilities (Scott et al. 1997). Parents with a diagnosis can access information and may even have a dedicated agency that they can consult for support. However, in over half of instances, no clear cause for a child’s disability will be found, while other children will have multiple disabilities that result in their ‘falling through the cracks’ as each agency defines them as ineligible for a service because of their dual or multiple diagnoses.
Satisfaction Parents of children with disabilities typically experience the same satisfaction and joy at their child’s achievements as felt by all other parents (Baker et al. 2002; Glidden, Valliere & Herbert 1988; Grant et al. 1998; Mullins 1987; Sandler & Mistretta 1998; Stainton & Besser 1998; Turnbull, Guess & Turnbull 1988; Turnbull et al. 2006). Many also identify some additional gains, including: •
• •
personal gains such as awareness of their personal strengths, increased tolerance of diversity, increased knowledge and intellectual stimulation from learning skills to parent their child, the impetus to gain formal education in disability, adjustment of their personal priorities and increased spirituality parenting gains including greater understanding of, and responsiveness towards, their child social benefits spanning new opportunities to meet other parents or disability workers, strengthening of their family relationships, appreciation of the resources in their marriage, renewed closeness as a family and appreciating supportive networks within the community (Meyer 1993; Pakenham, Sofronoff & Samios 2004; Sandler & Mistretta 1998).
Almost all parents would do anything to protect their children from harm. These parents’ inability to do so creates a searing pain that prevents their ‘acceptance’ of (if this is defined as ‘not minding’) their child’s restrictions. However, in time, they do adjust in the dual senses of finding happiness and satisfaction and being able to balance their child’s additional needs with meeting their own personal needs, satisfying the requirements
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 78
15/1/08 11:47:38 AM
Collaborating with parents of children with disabilities or chronic illnesses
79
of other family members and maintaining social relationships beyond the family.
Services sought by parents For most parents, the first awareness that their child is not developing typically often ushers in a long cycle of receiving troubling information about their child (Fox et al. 2002). Even the assessment process itself can be gruelling, with one study of parents whose children had autism finding that half were dissatisfied with the assessment process. Attaining a diagnosis required them to confer with, on average, over four separate professionals, with five per cent of parents consulting more than 10 (Siklos & Kerns 2007). Parents’ frustration at their struggle to achieve a diagnosis and secure services can spill over into their initial interactions with each new practitioner they meet. Like all parents of younger children, those whose child has a disability are excited at the prospect of starting school, but it is also a stressful time (Bentley-Williams & Butterfield 1996). Parents and children have to leave familiar programs and staff and accept that, at school, there is generally less opportunity for their involvement (Bentley-Williams & Butterfield 1996; Fowler, Schwartz & Atwater 1991; Hadden & Fowler 1997). They can also experience renewed grief that early intervention has not ameliorated their child’s difficulties. Like all parents, they have to adjust to the notion that no school is going to provide all that their child requires. However, there is likely to be an even greater than usual disparity between their child’s additional needs and the schooling options that are available. By high school age, the caretaking demands of young people with significant disabilities decrease compared with when they were younger, but nevertheless are considerably higher than is expected for adolescents without disabilities (Haveman et al. 1997). Parents’ awareness of limited supports in adolescence and adulthood, combined with their son’s or daughter’s diminished academic progress and lack of independence cause them to be less optimistic about their children’s future than is the case for young people without disabilities (Whitney-Thomas & Hanley-Maxwell 1996). On the other hand, by the time their children reach adolescence, parents are experienced at parenting and navigating the service system (Hughes & May 1988). Their successes will have given them confidence. Their goals may be less ambitious and by now they are more likely to be ‘taking one day at a time’ (Hughes & May 1988). Alternatively, exhaustion may have set in. They may have passively resigned themselves to the limited services that are available to their child (Hughes & May 1988). These competing effects have been termed the ‘wear and tear’ effects.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 79
15/1/08 11:47:38 AM
80
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
Choice of type and level of engagement Chapter 1 described how a formal teaching role can detract from parents’ duties and obligations to themselves, their partner and other children. In formalising instruction to children with disabilities, parents and children may miss out on the informal and uniquely personal qualities of parenting, and may raise parents’ stress levels (Harris & McHale 1989; Seligman & Darling 1997) with little developmental gain for the children themselves (Ramey & Ramey 1992; White et al. 1992). Also, as mentioned earlier, children’s behavioural difficulties and parents’ preference that their children have relaxation time, can cause parents not to want to deliver formal instruction at home. Others – such as single parents – may not have the resources, especially time, to do so (Schilling et al. 1986). Thus, while some parents choose to conduct training at home, those who do not wish to do so can be reassured that it is usually unnecessary; how parents interact with their child is more important than what they teach him or her. Children and their parents benefit more from guidance to recognise and respond to their children’s atypical modes of communication than from delivering formal instruction (Guralnick 1991; Kim & Mahoney 2005).
Information sharing Parents want their children’s teachers to be receptive to information they want to share about their child’s history and present needs, without becoming defensive (Ryndak et al. 1996). They need you to be interested in learning about interventions that have been tried to date and the effects of these (Kasahara & Turnbull 2005). Whereas teachers and therapists can change year by year, parents have ongoing experience with their child and therefore bring with them considerable expertise in their child’s needs and how best to meet these. They also have extensive knowledge about disability services that could support their child’s schooling. Their information can be particularly useful when their child’s condition is less common and thus unfamiliar to you. Parents also need their child’s teachers and other professionals to be a source of information for them on a range of issues, as listed in Box 5.1. The relevance of these topics changes as children age, with parents of young children usually being in most need of information about their child’s atypical needs and available resources. Parents having ongoing needs for feedback about their child’s progress at school (Hadden & Fowler 1997; Westling 1996). This can be a delicate issue. While you must preserve their hope by reporting that their child is progressing, you cannot imply that his or her skills are approaching
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 80
15/1/08 11:47:38 AM
Collaborating with parents of children with disabilities or chronic illnesses
81
Box 5.1 Information sought by parents whose children have disabilities Parents tend to want information about: • their child’s disability and additional needs • their emotional reactions and that of other family members • typical and atypical child development • how to recognise and respond to any atypical cues that their child uses to communicate with them • their child’s learning characteristics and future potential or prognosis • how to support their child at home • how to play with their child at home • how to foster their child’s social inclusion at school and in the wider community • strategies for fostering their child’s functioning in everyday settings • the range of available services such as respite care, relevant extracurricular activities, financial assistance, schooling options • behavioural guidance strategies, including responding to their child and onlookers in public • parent support groups Sources: Bailey et al. 1999; Mahoney et al. 1999; Westling & Plaute 1999
normality if they are not. In such cases, you might find it useful to say something such as, ‘James is communicating more clearly now, and uses a number of new words. This is a big advance on last year, when he was saying very little. His skills then were near a two-year level. Now they are closer to three years’ (say, when James is aged six).
Participation in planning Many parents want to be able to choose their children’s programs (Freeman, Alkin & Kasari 1999; Westling 1996; Westling & Plaute 1999). But when it comes to planning interventions, the core difference between parents and teachers is that parents are considering their child’s needs over his or her entire life span, whereas school-based professionals tend to focus solely on the child’s current or forthcoming school year (Bennett et al. 1998). Although Australia and other countries have adopted some of the procedures required under United States legislation, individualised education planning (IEP) meetings that are intended to include parents on
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 81
15/1/08 11:47:39 AM
82
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
an equal basis still tend to be dominated by the professionals. One study observed that during these meetings teachers talked for up to 60 per cent of the time and parents and students only 18 per cent (Martin et al. 2006). Aside from this imbalance, some parents experience the planning process as daunting rather than empowering, as they find themselves facing a bevy of professionals and a barrage of advice, along with the expectation that they will make a prudent decision based on incomplete understanding of the information being conveyed. Also, the formality of the meeting and the need to cover so much at once can unintentionally leave parents feeling overwhelmed. To avoid this, prepare parents in advance for meetings and listen to them so that their agenda drives the meeting, rather than topics for discussion being determined by the professionals. One strategy to avoid overwhelming parents with new information is to record the meeting by video or audio tape. This way, they can review the meeting later, or an absent parent can see or hear the conversation. Alternatively, send minutes of the meeting to parents so they can review the discussion and perhaps meet with you later to follow up any unresolved issues. As children leave the early childhood years, their presence at planning meetings can be beneficial and is a simple matter of inclusion and courtesy. When they attend planning meetings, the conversation tends to be less deficit-oriented and more respectful (Martin, Marshall & Sale 2004), which honours both them and their parents. Nevertheless, even more so than their parents, students may need you to prepare them for meetings and encourage them to speak on their own behalf (Martin et al. 2004, 2006).
Assessment Parents whose children’s disabilities were diagnosed in early childhood will be familiar with many terms relating to their child’s condition, but when the disability is just being recognised, you will need to be sensitive to parents’ understandings of the terms professionals use. Once, when I reported to a mother that her child had an intellectual disability, she expressed relief that her daughter was not retarded! Thus, it pays to avoid jargon and to define those terms that you cannot avoid (Turnbull et al. 2006). Most parents want assessments to be comprehensive, without sole reliance on testing. It can be difficult for children to display their optimal skills in a formal setting (McKenzie 1993; Ryndak et al. 1996). When children receive a wider-ranging assessment in which their parents have been active participants, they are more likely to understand and endorse both the assessment process and the recommendations that arise from it. Even so, while their estimations of their children’s abilities and needs
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 82
15/1/08 11:47:39 AM
Collaborating with parents of children with disabilities or chronic illnesses
83
generally tally with teachers’, parents might nonetheless resist a particular diagnosis, as they regard their child as a whole person who is more complex than a single label may suggest (Harry 1992).
Choice of educational placement Parents want their children’s curriculum to be tailored to their needs and to be challenging, with relevant specialist services provided (Hodapp, Freeman & Kasari 1998b; Ryndak et al. 1996). Many share teachers’ hesitations about whether this can be delivered in a regular placement. Some prefer inclusive settings for reasons of convenience, the availability of positive role models in general settings, socialisation benefits and, in the case of children with less severe disabilities, for the extra educational challenge (Bennett, DeLuca & Burns 1997; Freeman et al. 1999; Guralnick, Connor & Hammond 1995; Hodapp et al. 1998b; Ryndak et al. 1996). Yet, parents also share educators’ cautions about the constraints on teachers’ ability to meet students’ additional needs. These constraints may include large class sizes, unavailability of specialist services and teachers’ limited training and experience with disability (Bennett et al. 1998; Hanson et al. 2001; Scruggs & Mastropieri 1996). For these reasons, some parents judge that their children’s educational needs are best met in segregated settings in which, they believe, their children can be adequately resourced and receive individualised programs in a physically and emotionally safe environment (Bentley-Williams & Butterfield 1996; Hanline & Halvorsen 1989; Hodapp et al. 1998b; McWilliam et al. 1995; Palmer, BorthwickDuffy & Widaman 1998a; Palmer et al. 1998b; Ryndak et al. 1996; Westling 1996).
Social support for children Parents whose children are in inclusive settings realise that co-location alone is insufficient for friendships to develop. While many children with significant disabilities are accepted by their able peers, over one quarter are rejected and a greater number still are neglected or ignored (Odom et al. 1999, 2006). Their isolation comes about because, even compared with younger children of an equivalent developmental level, those with intellectual disabilities lack the cognitive and metacognitive skills necessary to read social cues and to instigate and maintain peer relationships. As a result, they interact less frequently, initiate fewer and less successful interactions with peers, respond less to approaches from peers and take the lead less often in play (Brown et al. 1999; Guralnick & Groom 1987; Hanline 1993; Hanson et al. 1998; Odom et al. 1999; Reynolds & Holdgrafer 1998).
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 83
15/1/08 11:47:39 AM
84
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
Social isolation is not universal across disability categories, however. For example, children with physical disabilities appear to be well understood, accepted and included in the play of young non-disabled children (Okagaki et al. 1998). Students whose intellectual skills are close to those of their peers and who possess social problem solving and emotion regulation skills are typically well accepted by their classmates (Odom et al. 2006). Given that all parents want their child to be happy at school, the parents of socially isolated children will want you to take active steps to facilitate their child’s social inclusion (Palmer et al. 1998a; Ryndak et al. 1996). This can involve intervening with the dynamics of a group, or coaching children with disabilities in problem solving and self-regulation skills, for example. It can also be necessary to teach them specific play skills (e.g. kicking a ball) needed for activities that their peers enjoy at recess times.
Direct therapy services To that end, access to direct therapy (e.g. physiotherapy or occupational therapy) can be beneficial. The skills that are targeted for such therapy need to be embedded in the children’s daily life and be relevant to the quality of life of both the child and family (Kasahara & Turnbull 2005). Therefore, therapists need your guidance about which skills will most help particular students to function academically and socially at school, with parents providing similar advice about the skills their children need in the home and community settings.
Social support for parents During the school years, a fundamental need for parents of children with disabilities can be social support (Lin 2000). Their child’s disruptive behaviours and other challenges can restrict parents’ access to social and recreational activities in the community (Fox et al. 2002). They tend to have a smaller circle of friends, although the quality of their social relationships seems unimpaired and parents report satisfaction from the relationships that they do have (Seltzer et al. 2001). However, in schools, parents whose children have additional needs tend to be isolated from other parents unless educators specifically foster interactions between them (Hanson et al. 1998; Winton 1993). Most parents will be polite, but as children with disabilities may not be invited to social events such as birthday parties, neither will their parents have these occasions to make contact with the wider parent group (Bennett et al. 1998). Some parents can be reluctant to ask about a child’s condition or are afraid of saying the wrong thing, and therefore avoid parents whose
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 84
15/1/08 11:47:39 AM
Collaborating with parents of children with disabilities or chronic illnesses
85
child has a disability. Those whose children are recipients of aggression from a child with a disability may be protective and actively reject both the child and parent.
Advocacy Many parents will feel that they are ‘just’ a parent, while others will realise that if they do not speak up for their child, no one will (Fox et al. 2002). Many of these parents will be their child’s advocates. In other circumstances, your position ‘on the inside’ can make you a useful ally: to deflect criticism from your colleagues that can arise when parents are active in advocating for their child (Bennett et al. 1997), in advocating on their behalf for particular services within or beyond your school (Hanson et al. 2001), or being an ally for parents during planning meetings that otherwise they might find overwhelming. Parents find that having an advocate within the system amplifies their own voices and adds an objective view to their personal perspective on their child’s needs (Kasahara & Turnbull 2005).
Transition planning Times of transition from one class or school to another can affirm to parents their child’s difference (Hanline 1993) and therefore can arouse renewed anxiety, sadness or stress (Seligman & Darling 1997; Wolery 1989). The concern may not necessarily be about their child’s disability as such, but about the ability of a new service to cater adequately for the child’s needs. Children’s eligibility for services can be in doubt until the last minute, while transitions might not occur at the same ages as for able children, making it difficult for parents to fully prepare for changes in advance. Moreover, not only does their child change placement, but so do the parents, who have to abandon one set of advisers whom they know in favour of another that is unfamiliar (Bentley-Williams & Butterfield 1996; Fowler et al. 1991; Hadden & Fowler 1997). In order for parents to plan for their son’s or daughter’s next placement, they will need information well in advance about the transition process and their child’s future options (Fowler et al. 1991; Hanline 1993). You will need to listen to their concerns and aspirations for the next placement. You will also need to be clear with them, however, if a service that they want is not available, because it does not benefit them if you promise something that subsequently is not provided. Lacking appropriate services is one thing, but feeling let down will disillusion, alienate and even enrage parents. Part of your joint planning, then, might be to develop a plan for bridging gaps in services.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 85
15/1/08 11:47:39 AM
86
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
Respite care Respite care is one of the most requested services by families, especially when their children have behavioural difficulties (Hayes 1998; Rimmerman, Kramer & Levy 1989). The use of respite care increases mothers’ feelings of wellbeing and, as a result, has positive effects on the functioning of the family as a whole (Botuck & Winsberg 1991). Hence, some parents will need information about respite care options.
Integration of services The disability service system has been described as ‘discontinuous, inconsistent, redundant, fragmented and disintegrated’ (Kasahara & Turnbull 2005, p. 259). The inefficiency of having to navigate an uncoordinated series of services can be a considerable drain on parents’ energy (McKenzie 1996; Turnbull & Ruef 1996), while a lack of awareness of laws, policies and their rights denies them and their children access to services for which they may be eligible (Kasahara & Turnbull 2005). Integration of services is most necessary during transitions between sequential services such as preschool to school, and for the coordination of simultaneous services. When all involved with a given student have access to the information they need to do their jobs, their work is likely to be more effective, relationships between parents and professionals are improved and parents are more satisfied with services (Dunst & Bruder 2002). Parents’ workloads are reduced, as otherwise they have to be the couriers of information between the professionals (Dunst & Bruder 2002). For this collaboration to occur, both interpersonal and structural resources are needed. At the interpersonal level, trust, sound communication and commitment to collaboration are required. At the structural level, all parties need to be clear about their own and others’ goals, roles and responsibilities; key personnel with the power to make decisions need to be engaged in the process; someone needs to adopt the central role as organiser and coordinator; and there needs to be an efficient method for continuous communication between all those involved (Park & Turnbull 2003). Within a parent-driven model, the obvious candidate to act as coordinator is the parent. However, faced with a lack of insider knowledge about how to access services, a complex service system and the need for prolonged advocacy in the case of children with multiple needs, some parents find a case manager to be an asset (Dinnebeil, Hale & Rule 1999; Kasahara & Turnbull 2005; Westling 1996; Westling & Plaute 1999). Whenever professionals are collaborating, parents need to be able to trust in your discretion (Blue-Banning et al. 2004). Therefore, when meeting with other colleagues or members of a multidisciplinary team,
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 86
15/1/08 11:47:39 AM
Collaborating with parents of children with disabilities or chronic illnesses
87
it is important that parents are present or they at least receive a copy of any written material. Parents’ presence helps ensure that they know who knows what about them and their child, that the information shared focuses on strengths rather than deficits and that the discussion does not degenerate into gossip about the student or family.
Referral to other services Parents of children with disabilities may require a range of services, some of which will be within your role to deliver while others will require referral to outside agencies – such as therapists, after-school care or extracurricular activities. In order to make appropriate referrals, you will need to know about a range of practitioners, including their location, eligibility criteria, waiting time, costs and contact details. Your group of parents can supplement your own knowledge by nominating services that they have found useful, which you can then collate into a resource list. For extracurricular activities, it can be particularly beneficial to locate a program attended by a student’s classmate, as the children’s contact in two locations can help them to socialise in both (Beckman et al. 1998).
Children living with chronic illness With improved medical technology, many children with formerly lifethreatening illnesses now survive, while those with chronic illnesses can now participate in regular educational settings. This has resulted in around two per cent of the childhood population enduring repeated and chronic bouts of illness (Ashton & Bailey 2004). This includes conditions such as severe allergies, asthma, epilepsy, arthritis, diabetes, meningitis, kidney, liver or heart disease, AIDS and cancer (Shiu 2001, 2004) and, increasingly, health complaints associated with obesity, which will disproportionately affect economically disadvantaged students. Chronic illness has a well-documented effect on young people’s school performance (Boyle et al. 2007), increasing the risk of grade retention or dropping out of school (Cunningham & Wodrich 2006). In contrast, returning to school after a relapse or prolonged illness symbolises normality and hope for the future (Worchel-Prevatt et al. 1998). Achieving this transition can entail: • • •
collaborating with the convalescing student and his or her parents to organise a schedule for the student’s return gaining the information you need to manage the illness and to understand the student’s emotional reactions to it establishing ongoing liaison with the parents and medical personnel
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 87
15/1/08 11:47:39 AM
88
•
• •
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
assessing the school environment ahead of time to assess architectural or other constraints to mobility so these can be attended to before the student returns to school arranging for a tutor or other means to assist the student to catch up academically preparing peers for changes in their classmate (Worchel-Prevatt et al. 1998).
Management of illness Your own self-efficacy and duty of care to chronically ill children require that you understand the nature of individual students’ illness and its implications for their education (Ashton & Bailey 2004). Incomplete information can result in unrealistic expectations for students, inadequate educational adjustments, or over- or under-protectiveness by educators (Ashton & Bailey 2004; Cunningham & Wodrich 2006). Therefore, your first task will be to learn from parents and, with their consent, medical personnel about individual students’ condition and its ramifications for their learning. You will also need to gain an understanding of the expected course of the illness over time. In terms of health care, you will need to know whether ill students require monitoring, how to deal with any medical emergencies, what restrictions the illness may place on their activities, what medication or dietary regimes they need to observe and which educational tasks will need to be adjusted to accommodate their condition. Any medication and dietary regimes will need to be integrated unobtrusively into their daily routines, ensuring that these are followed strictly without making a spectacle of them in front of their peers. So that the adults know which procedures to follow, it will be important to prepare all staff and classmates for the possibility of a health crisis in ill students, to have at least one staff member with specialised first aid training, and to have on file the contact details for emergency medical personnel.
Environmental adjustments Health impairments often weaken the body’s immunological system, making children susceptible to other illnesses. Therefore, control of contagious diseases can be crucial. This may mean simply advising parents of chronically ill children that an infection is going around, so that they can decide if it is necessary to withdraw their children from school for the time being. Other environmental adjustments can include adapting equipment so that children whose illnesses produce physical limitations can nevertheless access activities (Shiu 2004).
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 88
15/1/08 11:47:39 AM
Collaborating with parents of children with disabilities or chronic illnesses
89
Curricular adjustments With the exception of AIDS, most chronic childhood illnesses do not have a direct permanent effect on the brain’s capacity to learn, although fatigue and many conditions such as low blood sugar levels (e.g. associated with Type 1 diabetes mellitus) can temporarily affect students’ cognitive functioning for the duration of the episode (Cunningham & Wodrich 2006). Some medical treatments such as radiotherapy or chemotherapy can themselves cause disabilities and subtle attention, sequencing, memory and sensory integration difficulties, particularly in younger children (Shiu 2001). In addition, children who are unwell produce higher levels of the stress-related hormone, cortisol (Watamura et al. 2003). This can lead to stress reactions when they are exhausted or feel that the demands of their day exceed their capacity to cope. Many convalescing children are anxious about their ability to catch up and keep up with their work, and will need a planned program for doing so (Bessell 2001; Worchel-Prevatt et al. 1998). Although you might be able to send home some learning activities during their absence, the illness can impair their ability to complete these. Upon their return, while extra tutoring may be needed, they can still lack the energy during convalescence to add this into their day. Upon their return, routine procedures will need to be adjusted – for example, you may need to allow a classmate to accompany a student to the school office during a health crisis, or to recognise that some students will need to leave the classroom without seeking permission, so that they can attend to urgent physical care needs (Kliebenstein & Broome 2000). Prohibitions on students’ activities in an effort to keep them safe from further injury or infection not only limit their ability to learn, but also affect their self-esteem (Ashton & Bailey 2004). Therefore, encourage students to be as independent as possible and do not restrict them unless a particular activity poses a clear danger. It is important that, as far as possible, school provides a venue for them to be ‘normal’ and, therefore, does not emphasise their additional needs (Bessell 2001).
Emotional support Children’s misunderstandings of their condition and its treatment, their early encounters with pain and perhaps even the prospect of death can lead to anxieties and fears that surpass those of healthy children (McCarthy 1987). Unwell children may be fearful about the future and be stressed not only from their illness and its treatment but as a result of the observable strain it causes for their family members. Many children will adapt to the demands of their illness and its management, whereas
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 89
15/1/08 11:47:39 AM
90
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
those with emotional difficulties may resist the imposition of regimens for its management, placing them at risk for treatment non-compliance that compromises both their health status and school inclusion (Cunningham & Wodrich 2006). Some, therefore, can benefit from opportunities to talk about their experiences. So that you do not confuse them or undermine their parents, you will need to prepare for these inevitable discussions by discovering from parents what their children have been told about their condition and what they would like you to say, particularly with respect to terminal illnesses (McCarthy 1987).
Social inclusion Children’s repeated absences are likely to interrupt and disrupt their peer relationships (Shiu 2001). Half of all children living with chronic illness experience social dislocation, may feel very different from their peers and suffer anxiety about their inclusion on their return to school after prolonged absences (Bessell 2001; Shiu 2004). They may fear their classmates teasing them about changes in their appearance (WorchelPrevatt et al. 1998). To prevent social anxieties, you might be able to coordinate a roster of home visits by some of their classmates during their absences so that they do not feel like outsiders when they return. On their return, peers might need information about the reason for their absence, changed appearance or atypical needs (McCarthy 1987; Tyler & Colson 1994). On the other hand, the students themselves might not want this information disclosed, so that they can be treated as people rather than as patients (Shiu 2001). Not only are chronically ill children’s relationships with peers interrupted, but so too are their contacts with their teachers. As well as sending work home, teachers can ensure ongoing contact by making personal phone calls or emailing students during their absences. Children’s relationships with adults can also be distorted by their experience of relating with medical personnel, which can cause them to direct their social interactions to adults rather than peers. Moreover, the requirements of their management can increase children’s dependency on adults. To offset this tendency, you might have to assist their peer engagement. It will also be important not to make undue allowances for their behaviours, lest their peers interpret this as unfair favouritism and reject them (Norris & Closs 1999).
Support for parents At the time of initial diagnosis, particularly of a potentially life-threatening illness, parents will be in shock, and this may be accompanied by fear and
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 90
15/1/08 11:47:39 AM
Collaborating with parents of children with disabilities or chronic illnesses
91
a sense of powerlessness. During their child’s chronic illness and treatment, mothers in particular are likely to have their working lives disrupted (Ashton 2004; Vickers, Parris & Bailey 2004). Your understanding of the competing and often overwhelming demands on them may be a considerable help (Vickers et al. 2004). The family’s physical, social, emotional and financial resources may be stretched during their child’s prolonged illness (Dockett 2004) – particularly if other members of the family are also ill (as with AIDS), or when the child’s condition is uncertain or life-threatening (Bruder 1995). Parents have to advocate for their child’s needs. Even if their concerns seem excessive or parents seem to be too protective, trust them. ‘Helicopter parents’ hover over their children because they have a genuine reason to be concerned. Parents are the ones who have to live with the risk, and therefore they are the ones who have to determine how to minimise it (Sanagavarapu 2004).
Communication Communication across the school will be necessary to support classroom teachers and those on duty at recess to be fully informed about courses of action to be taken in the event of a health incident. This communication also reduces the burden on parents to inform each and every staff member who may come into contact with their child, and reduces their anxiety about the care available for their child (Kliebenstein & Broome 2000; Norris & Closs 1999). To reduce the burden on parents, it may be useful to appoint a single influential person within the school who can transmit information from parents to the wider staff team.
Support for staff Particularly when students are left with permanent disabilities or are dying, you will have to look after yourself so that you can channel your grief into making their lives at school as normal and productive as possible.
Communicating with parents of able children Parents of able students have a right to reassurance that a student with high support needs will not require a disproportionate amount of teacher time, resulting in reduced education of their own child. Naturally, you must secure the permission of the parent whose child has additional needs before imparting any information to the other parents. Even then, you will need to decide on a case-by-case basis how much information you should give, as disclosure could create unnecessary anxiety or be construed as a
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 91
15/1/08 11:47:39 AM
92
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
tacit invitation for protests (Chandler 1994). Conversely, if you do not discuss the issue with your parent group, some might feel that you are not receptive to their legitimate concerns.
Conclusion Although there are considerable differences between children living with chronic illness and those with disabilities, they have four things in common: first is parental uncertainty about their children’s futures (Norris & Closs 1999). Second, while many are enrolled in regular schools, a substantial proportion of both populations are marginalised or excluded (Norris & Closs 1999). Third, parents perceive barriers to the inclusion of children with disabilities or chronic illnesses as human made, rather than being inherent in the conditions themselves (Kliebenstein & Broome 2000). Fourth, both sets of parents have to navigate a sometimes complex service system, perhaps at times when their own resources are depleted by worries, extra costs and interrupted employment (Norris & Closs 1999). For both populations of students, parent-driven, collaborative relationships between their parents and teachers are essential to promote the students’ inclusion. These relationships will be based on the recognition that parents are knowledgeable about their children and are a source of valuable information about their needs (Norris & Closs 1999).
Additional resources Batshaw, M.L., Pellegrino, L. & Roizen N.J. (Eds.) (2007). Children with disabilities. (6th ed.) Sydney: Elsevier; Baltimore, MD: Paul H. Brookes.
Early childhood Allen K.E. & Cowdery, G.E. (2005). The exceptional child: Inclusion in early childhood education. (5th ed). Albany, NY: Delmar. Cook, R.E., Klein, M.D., Tessier, A. & Daley, S.E. (2004). Adapting early childhood curricula for children in inclusive settings. (6th ed.) Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Merrill Prentice Hall. Kranowitz, C.S. (1998). The out-of-sync child: Recognizing and coping with sensory integration dysfunction. New York: Perigee. Porter, L. (Ed.) (2002). Educating young children with additional needs. Sydney: Allen and Unwin. Also published as Educating young children with special needs. London: Paul Chapman/Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 92
15/1/08 11:47:39 AM
Collaborating with parents of children with disabilities or chronic illnesses
93
Sandall, S.R. & Schwartz, I.S. (2002). Building blocks for teaching preschoolers with special needs. Baltimore, MD: Paul H. Brookes.
School-aged populations Ashman, A. & Elkins, J. (Eds.) (2005). Educating children with diverse abilities. (2nd ed.) Sydney: Pearson Education. Foreman, P. (Ed.) (2005). Inclusion in action. Melbourne: Nelson Australia. Hallahan, D.P. & Kauffman, J.M. (2006). Exceptional learners: Introduction to special education. (10th ed.) Boston, MA: Pearson Allyn & Bacon. Vaughn, S., Bos, C.S. & Schumm, J.S. (2007). Teaching exceptional, diverse, and at-risk students in the general education classroom. (4th ed.) Boston, MA: Pearson Allyn & Bacon. Westwood, P. (2003). Commonsense methods for children with special educational needs: Strategies for the regular classroom. (4th ed.) London: RoutledgeFalmer. Westwood, P.S. (2004). Learning and learning difficulties: A handbook for teachers. Melbourne: ACER Press.
Autism spectrum Cumine, V., Leach, J. & Stevenson, G. (1998). Asperger syndrome: A practical guide for teachers. London: David Fulton. Gillberg, C. (2002). A guide to Asperger syndrome. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Collaboration with parents Turnbull, A., Turnbull, R., Erwin, E.J. & Soodak, L.C. (2006). Families, professionals, and exceptionality: Positive outcomes through partnerships and trust. (5th ed.) Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Merrill Prentice Hall.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 93
15/1/08 11:47:39 AM
6
Collaborating with parents of gifted learners
Many influences on happiness and success are like love – it is possible to say how it feels and what happens because of it, but there is no sure recipe to apply to others. We do, however, have very clear information about what the gifted and talented need by way of support towards self-fulfillment – an education to suit their potential, opportunities to flourish, and people who believe in them. Freeman (2006, p. 400)
By definition, there are as many students who are gifted learners as there are with learning disabilities. By conservative definitions, each group constitutes the extreme 3–5 per cent of the population. Yet, five differences distinguish gifted from special education. First, although both aim to meet the additional needs of atypical learners, in special education students are provided with individualised programs when they need them, whereas in gifted education they often have to earn access to special provisions through exemplary behaviour (Borland 1989). Paradoxically, this behaviour may indicate that they are functioning adaptively within present arrangements and therefore do not need these to be adjusted. Instead, the students more likely to need a differentiated curriculum are those with disruptive behaviour or other signs of academic disengagement, frustration and boredom (Borland 1989). The second difference is that, whereas special education has a rich history of at least attempting family-allied or family-centred services, gifted education largely ignores and discounts parental input (Alsop 1997; Hertzog & Bennett 2004; Huff et al. 2005). In one study, even when parents had procured a psychological assessment, only one quarter of classroom teachers or principals responded positively to its diagnosis of giftedness (Alsop 1997). When parents report that their child is gifted, a common response from school personnel is, ‘There, there, dear. Everyone
94
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 94
15/1/08 11:47:39 AM
Collaborating with parents of gifted learners
95
thinks her child is gifted’. The same remark would never be offered if the parent had reported that her child had cerebral palsy. Third, despite ample evidence of the need for early intervention to offset educational disadvantage, provisions for gifted children are seldom available prior to the middle primary school years – if then (Gillman & Hansen 1987). A sensible reluctance to label young children as gifted translates into ignoring the fact that they learn more quickly than others and disregards their additional needs. Fourth, whereas parents of children with disabilities have been encouraged – if not pressured – to teach their children at home, when parents have responded to their gifted child’s advanced interests, they are accused of ‘pushing’ their child and trying to ‘hot-house’ him or her for their own aggrandisement. In fact, most parents attempt to respond to the skills and interests of the children themselves, encouraging them to develop their own special gifts and abilities, in contrast with pumping children full of information or hot-housing, which promotes adults’ ambitions (Smutny, Veenker & Veenker 1989). Fifth, while almost all teacher-training courses include some modules on disability, few include any on giftedness. This fails to prepare teachers to recognise and provide for gifted students. Given a resulting lack of awareness in schools about the indicators of gifted development, Box 6.1 lists these.
Box 6.1 Common indicators of giftedness Many children are gifted in a range of skill domains and, even within their area of talent, may manifest all the indicators listed here. Ultimately, given that the term ‘gifted’ signifies a significant advance compared with normal development, for children from the dominant culture, comparative or normed assessments will be needed if confirmation is required.
Cognitive (thinking) skills Children who are intellectually gifted display many of the following features: • early achievement of developmental milestones (at least one-third sooner) • quick learning • keen observation of the environment • active in eliciting stimulation from the environment • quick and accurate recall
➡
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 95
15/1/08 11:47:39 AM
96
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
• • •
recall of skills and information introduced some time ago deeper knowledge than other children understanding of abstract concepts (e.g. death or time).
Academic giftedness Children who are both intellectually and academically gifted might: • read, write or use numbers in advanced ways • write words other than their own name prior to school entry • show advanced preferences for books and films (unless too sensitive to older themes).
Learning styles Many gifted children not only achieve more than average, they also approach tasks with a sophisticated style. Their application to tasks may decline in the face of fatigue, discouragement (immediate or long-term) or a lack of challenge. Nevertheless, when highly achieving, they display: • alertness • responsivity to novel stimuli • speed and efficiency of information processing • willingness to reflect when necessary in order to maintain accuracy • preference for challenge and complexity • openness to new ideas and experiences • motivation and curiosity in a search for understandings • wide-ranging interests • an intense focus on, or the ability to immerse themselves in, an area of interest, in order to achieve a depth of understanding • longer than usual concentration span on challenging topics of interest (but may ‘flit’ from one activity to another if activities are not challenging enough) • early use of metacognitive skills to manage their own thinking processes • internal locus of control • independence at challenging, non-routine tasks • willingness to take risks • perseverance in the face of obstacles • tolerance of ambiguity. Creative thinking style Children who are intellectually and creatively gifted might display the following learning styles, applying these across skill domains or in a single domain in which they excel:
➡
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 96
15/1/08 11:47:39 AM
Collaborating with parents of gifted learners
• • • • •
•
97
imagination creative problem solving use of intuition (that is, allowing some of their thinking to occur at a preconscious level) fluency, which reflects an ability to employ a range or quantity of ideas flexibility, which refers both to the quality of ideas brought to bear on the problem and to skill at adapting their learning style to the task demands and goals being nonconforming and rejecting limits.
Auditory–sequential learning style Children who learn by listening and ordering ideas often: • learn sequentially: one idea at a time • are analytical – that is, able to break down problems into their parts • attend well to details • learn well from verbal instructions • are able to carry out instructions to do several things in succession • think logically • have good planning skills • are organised • are less impulsive than age peers • have a clear understanding of cause and effect • use rehearsal to remember • once in school, achieve reasonably consistent grades across all subject areas. Visual-spatial (or holistic) learning style Children who learn by forming visual images of concepts may be later than others to excel, but nevertheless: • learn concepts all at once • synthesise ideas – that is, put them together • see the big picture and, correspondingly, may miss details • learn intuitively • have what can only be termed ‘quirky’ organisational systems • learn instantly and so do not benefit from rehearsal or repetition • once in school, obtain uneven grades across subject areas.
Speech and language skills Intellectually gifted children with advanced verbal skills often show: • early comprehension of language
➡
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 97
15/1/08 11:47:39 AM
98
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
• • • • • •
advanced speech in terms of vocabulary, grammar and clear articulation use of metaphor and analogy ability to make up songs or stories spontaneously ability to modify language for less mature children use of language for a real exchange of ideas and information at an early age a sophisticated sense of humour.
Motor abilities Many intellectually gifted children have fine motor skills that lag behind their intellectual level, as seen in untidy handwriting, for example. On the other hand, those who are gifted in the motor domain can show a range of the following characteristics: • early motor development, particularly in skills that are under cognitive control, such as balance • ability to locate themselves within the environment • early awareness of left and right • facility at putting together new or difficult puzzles • ability to take apart and reassemble objects with unusual skill • ability to make interesting shapes or patterns with objects • advanced drawing or handwriting • high levels of physical energy.
Artistic expression Early signs of artistic talent include: • superior visual memory • engaging with an imaginary playmate in elaborate conversations and games • assigning elaborate characters to dolls or teddies • creating and performing in plays • enjoyment of drama, role playing • advanced skill at drawing, painting or other artistic modalities.
Musical skills Musical giftedness may be among the earliest to emerge – by one year of age – although very young children’s motor ability can block their musical performance. Musically gifted children: • are enthralled by musical sounds • have a deep appreciation and understanding of music (with or without musical performance) • are sensitive to musical structure – tonality, key, harmony and rhythm
➡
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 98
15/1/08 11:47:40 AM
Collaborating with parents of gifted learners
• •
99
appreciate the expressive properties of music – timbre, loudness, articulation and phrasing have a strong musical memory that permits them to recall music and play it back later either by singing or through an instrument.
Social skills Intellectually and verbally advanced children typically are also advanced in their social skills, showing some of the following characteristics: • highly developed empathy for others • less egocentricity: they can deduce the cause of others’ emotions • advanced play interests • early ability to play games with rules • early ability to form close friendships • seeking out older children or adults for companionship • withdrawing to solitary play if intellectual peers are not available • often being sought out by peers for their play ideas and sense of fairness • leadership skills • early development of moral reasoning and judgment • early interest in social issues involving injustices.
Emotional and behavioural characteristics Some intellectually gifted children are emotionally gifted as well. These children might display: • emotional sensitivity, intensity and responsiveness • for some, early spiritual awareness • early development of fears • early development of self-concept and awareness of being different • high self-esteem in their strong domains • perfectionism, in the sense of having high standards (self-referenced) • over-sensitivity to criticism • frustration, which can lead to emotional or behavioural outbursts • acceptance of responsibility usually given only to older children • nonconformity. Source: Porter (2005, pp. 8–12).
Sources of conflict between teachers and parents of gifted learners The responsibility that parents of gifted students feel to support their learning can, in extreme cases, put unnecessary strain on them to devote every waking hour to their children’s needs. This can lead to the syndrome
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 99
15/1/08 11:47:40 AM
100
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
of ‘helicopter’ parents, who hover over their children’s every action, trying to ensure that their ‘potential’ is not wasted (Colangelo & Brower 1987; Fisher 1981; Hackney 1981). These parents can then impose this pressure on teachers, demanding that they perform some special magic to ensure that their children are learning constantly. This is a pressure that teachers cannot answer to anyone’s satisfaction. It is, however, only one reason for conflict between parents and teachers of gifted learners. Two others are teachers’ resistant attitudes to giftedness and disputes between teachers and parents over the identification of students as being gifted.
Teachers’ attitudes to giftedness Conflict between parents and teachers can arise when they do not agree on the necessity for gifted provisions (Moon 2003). Teachers may be resistant to providing for gifted students in schools because of a range of unconducive attitudes, the first of which is prejudice. Many researchers have found that teachers tend not to have positive views of gifted students or of educational provisions for them, with attitudes ranging from indifference to outright antagonism (Cramond & Martin 1987; Forster 2002; Lee 2000; McBride 1992; Sankar-DeLeeuw 2002; Sharma 2001). This is perhaps due to cultural anti-intellectualism, as found in the United States (Gallagher 1991), the United Kingdom (Eyre 1997), Australia (Bailey 1998; Wilson 1996) and New Zealand (Fraser 2004). In these countries, authorities are keen to allocate extra money for elite sports programs, for example, but are less willing to fund elite intellectual training (Gross 2004). This ‘cultural cringe’ is then sustained by a lack of teacher training in gifted education (Forster 2002) and, in the absence of provisions for gifted students, a lack of familiarity with these (Carrington & Bailey 2000). Some teachers are sceptical about the concepts of intelligence and standardised testing, believing that both are arbitrary and meaningless. However, while it is true that we created a definition of ‘high ability’, this does not mean that we invented high ability itself. Giftedness is a psychological reality in that there are individual differences in ability (Gallagher 1996; Pyryt 1996). Others believe that everyone is gifted at something. Gardner’s (1983) multiple ‘intelligences’ popularised the notion that everyone has a special talent (despite Gardner himself refuting this). However, this is arithmetically absurd: it is not possible for everyone to be ‘above average’ on any human capacity: height, driving skill or intellectual ability. While it is true that students do have individual strengths, these abilities seldom fall so far above the average that the students need special programming in those domains (Braggett 1992; Gagné 1997; Gross 2004; Runco 1997).
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 100
15/1/08 11:47:40 AM
Collaborating with parents of gifted learners
101
Moreover, some of Gardner’s domains (such as spiritual or naturalistic intelligence) are not even the core business of schools. Other educators accept the notion of giftedness, but claim that gifted learners are already advantaged and are able to progress academically without specific help. However, although it is true that they can learn more easily than most, they are still children and still need to be taught how to learn (Braggett 1994). They cannot excel without assistance (Webb, Meckstroth & Tolan 1991). A philosophical extension of this argument is that everyone should have equal opportunities and that, as gifted learners already have academic and often social advantages, they should not get any further help. However, true egalitarianism upholds that all children have an equal right to develop; this should not be confused with a right to equal development (Gross 2004; Stanley & Baines 2002). Although students have an equal right to access appropriate educational experiences, justice does not demand that these experiences be the same for all students (Benbow 1992; Strike 1988). Yet another argument is that, while gifted learners have needs, these have to take a lower priority compared with students who have disabilities. Therefore, the argument proceeds, we cannot devote resources to gifted provisions until the higher-priority needs of students with disabilities have been fully resourced. In favour of gifted education is a national resources rationale, which upholds that society should invest in gifted education because talented children will grow up to become our political and business leaders. This is nonsense: there is no evidence that our political or financial leaders come from the ranks of the gifted. Moreover, like the pressure to realise children’s ‘potential’, in focusing on how gifted learners will ‘turn out’ as adults, this rationale ignores that they have needs now and have a right to have these met, regardless of how they ultimately function in adulthood. This, then, is the same perspective as the one adopted in special education: it treasures children for being themselves, rather than for what they can do now or might do in the future (Corrigan 1994). This rationale for gifted education is that gifted learners have as much right to have their needs met as other students – but are no more deserving than anyone else (Peterson 1993). Thus, advocacy for gifted education becomes advocacy for individualised education for all students, not for better treatment for the gifted. When gifted students are provided for on the basis of need – that is, are offered a modified curriculum because their present program is not meeting their requirements – this is not elitism or favouritism: it is what schools are supposed to do for students with atypical needs (Borland 1989).
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 101
15/1/08 11:47:40 AM
102
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
Disputed identification A second source of conflict between parents and teachers of gifted learners is dispute over identification of them as gifted. Parents have detailed knowledge of their child’s milestones, motivation and personality, which allows them to be skilled reporters of his or her abilities. As a result, various studies have found that parents identify their children’s giftedness with an accuracy rate of between 61 per cent (Louis & Lewis 1992) and 76 per cent (Ciha et al. 1974; Jacobs 1971). Generally, when parents inaccurately describe their child as gifted, the children are typically advanced, although not quite within the gifted range. But, in a study by Silverman and colleagues (1986), all the children who were nominated by their parents but who did not score as such on an IQ test had histories of recurrent early ear infections, which contributed to lowered verbal scores and thus could classify the children as gifted–learning disabled. In that case, the parents’ nominations were taken to be 100 per cent accurate. Contrary to the myth that parents’ impressions of their children’s skills are exaggerated, it is more usual for them to underestimate their children’s abilities (Chitwood 1986), especially when well educated themselves (Roedell, Jackson & Robinson 1980). Those with inflated concepts of giftedness as prodigious performance tend to recognise their child’s advancement but understate its extent (Smutny, Walker & Meckstroth 1997). In comparison, early studies indicated that teachers were generally poor at recognising giftedness, especially in children from minority cultural groups (Hadaway & Marek-Schroer 1992). Accuracy rates of between 4.4 and 48 per cent have been reported (Ciha et al. 1974; Gear 1976), with early childhood teachers accurately identifying fewer than 10 per cent of gifted children (Jacobs 1971). A more recent study found an improved rate of 57 per cent (Hodge & Kemp 2006). In that study, teachers most readily recognised students who were verbally gifted and early readers. Teachers’ lack of training in gifted education and stereotypical views that all gifted children are academically productive contribute to their lower effectiveness in identifying gifted learners. Sometimes, a discrepancy between a teacher’s assessment and the parents’ is not due to error by one or the other but to the differing behaviours that children display in each setting. •
•
Some gifted children disguise their giftedness from their teachers, perhaps to be tactful or to avoid the spotlight. The result is that, while they display their talents at home, their teachers do not see their advanced performances at school (Hodge 2004). The activities on offer at school are age-appropriate and therefore do not allow gifted children to display their advanced skills.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 102
15/1/08 11:47:40 AM
Collaborating with parents of gifted learners
•
•
•
•
• •
103
The children’s average fine motor skills impede their ability or motivation to produce sophisticated products in writing or drawings. The mechanical aspects of putting ideas on paper can discourage or impede the flow of creative expression. Observing average performances on these tasks, teachers may incorrectly conclude that the children’s thinking or creative skills are average also. Students may be creatively or emotionally gifted, which parents might observe but these skills may not emerge on IQ tests or in school performances, and therefore can be overlooked at school. Students can be intellectually but not academically gifted. Some intellectually gifted learners manipulate information in sophisticated ways but are not especially advanced in the core academic subjects of reading, writing and mathematics. Students may be visually or spatially gifted (see Box 6.1). This can have a range of effects: they may be less motivated to apply themselves to nonvisual tasks; they can get lost in the visual scenes that they generate in their minds and therefore do not pay close attention to verbal instruction; or they can resist sequential tasks or rote rehearsal on the grounds that they have already mastered the information holistically. Students can possess both gifted thinking capacities and learning disabilities, with parents more likely to notice the former and teachers the latter. Students may come from minority cultures and manifest their talents in domains that are less recognisable to teachers from the dominant culture.
Box 6.2 Manifestations of giftedness in students from minority cultures Although intelligent thinking processes are the same across cultures, the content to which they are applied can differ (Sternberg 2007), with giftedness in minority cultures manifesting as: • communication skills that are rich in imagery (making allowances for any lack of proficiency in English if it is not the students’ first language) • ability in visual or performing arts • social skills such as responsiveness to the feelings of others or skilfulness in group activities, including leadership or facilitation of others’ achievements • emotional expressiveness. Sources: Bevan-Brown 1999, 2004; Fernández et al. 1998; Frasier 1993; Gibson 1998; Shaklee 1993; Shaklee & Viechnicki 1995; Torrance 1998.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 103
15/1/08 11:47:40 AM
104
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
These examples tell us that both the parents’ judgements and an IQ score diagnosing giftedness can be accurate, while at the same time the child does not perform at advanced levels at school. In other words, despite their contradictory assessments, both the parents and teachers are accurate in their impressions of the children’s abilities. It is just that each has an incomplete picture.
Provisions sought by parents of gifted learners The commonalities between parents of students with disabilities and gifts are many. First, both want a developmentally appropriate education for their children. Despite the myths, most parents seek a balanced education for their gifted child: they do not wish to promote intellectual skills alone (Creel & Karnes 1988). Second, both sets of parents want their children to fit in socially at school. For gifted students, this will require an approximate match between their abilities and interests and those of their classmates, which means that some will have to be placed among older peers. Third, both sets of parents feel a responsibility to nurture their children’s abilities and, to that end, recognise the need to advocate for their children in schools. Fourth, both are confused and apprehensive about how their child’s future will unfold in the absence of appropriate provisions. Finally, both sets of parents can be isolated and therefore require support within the school community.
Curricular adjustments Many schools adopt the slogan that they strive for excellence. However, given that no school proclaims to strive for mediocrity, this statement is meaningless unless supported by specific programs that cater for gifted and other atypical learners. In the absence of challenge, gifted learners will be bored, which manifests in their being inattentive but still offering accurate answers to teachers’ questions, asking abstract questions to raise the level of the discussion, disrupting the class with humour, or reading or sleeping during class (Kanevsky & Keighley 2003). In the long term, these students’ moral indignation at being neglected can cause them to withdraw from learning altogether and become increasingly unproductive. Curricular adjustments must be systematically structured to match students’ learning needs, allowing for differences in both the pace (quantity) and depth (quality) of their learning (Borland 1989; Piirto 1999). These adjustments span relevant modifications to the learning environment, teaching and learning processes, curricular content and the products whereby students demonstrate their mastery. Environmental adjustments include allowing students prolonged periods to be absorbed
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 104
15/1/08 11:47:40 AM
Collaborating with parents of gifted learners
105
and to complete projects about which they are passionate or, at other times, moving quickly through material that they can master rapidly. It entails placement and grouping decisions – placing gifted learners with others of similar ability for at least some of their day, and subsequently making instruction more complex. Homogeneous grouping improves students’ achievement, attitude to learning, social skills and self-esteem (Allan 1991; Gamoran 1992; Hallinan 1990; Kolloff & Moore 1989; Kulik & Kulik 1982, 1992; Lando & Schneider 1997; Rogers 2001; Rogers & Span 1993; Rist 1970; Shore & Delcourt 1996; Slavin 1987, 1990; Van Tassel-Baska 1992). Adjustments to teaching and learning processes include generating opportunities for gifted learners to engage in sophisticated thinking. As is true for all learners, five qualities of teaching are vital for motivation: control (self-determination), choice (opportunities to act on preferences), challenge, complexity and a caring teacher (Kanevsky & Keighley 2003). Although ‘process’ is conceptually different from ‘content’, in practice we cannot teach students how to learn without teaching content that is worth learning. Therefore, curricular content also needs some modification. Some students can gain access most readily to advanced curricular content by early entry to school or grade skipping, although even then further adjustments within classes are likely to be necessary. This is usually referred to as ‘acceleration’, although in reality it is merely an attempt at a developmentally appropriate placement (Feldhusen 1989; Feldhusen, Van Winkle & Ehle 1996; Rogers & Kimpston 1992; Southern, Jones & Stanley 1993). The academic aims of acceleration are to avoid boredom, along with any resultant behavioural and motivational difficulties; to promote students’ development of study skills; to honour their enthusiasm for learning; and to meet their needs for social inclusion. Research consistently reports that acceleration meets all of these aims (Benbow 1991; Eales & de Paoli 1991; Heinbokel 1997; Janos 1987; Kulik & Kulik 1984; Paulus 1984; Proctor, Black & Feldhusen 1986; Proctor, Feldhusen & Black 1988; Rimm & Lovance 1992a, 1992b; Robinson & Robinson 1992; Rogers & Kimpston 1992; Sayler & Brookshire 1993; Schiever & Maker 1997; Shore & Delcourt 1996; Southern & Jones 1992; Southern, Jones & Fiscus 1989; Southern et al. 1993; Swiatek & Benbow 1991; Townsend 2004; Vialle et al. 2001). One study found that, compared with their classmates, early entrants’ relative academic standing increased as they progressed through school (Proctor et al. 1986). It appears that students’ early exit from school that results from early entry or grade skipping is not a problem for them: they continue to do well into the university years and beyond, particularly with early
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 105
15/1/08 11:47:40 AM
106
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
career counselling (Olszewski-Kubilius 2002; Swiatek & Benbow 1991). Grade skipping (sometimes by three or more years) can be particularly necessary and beneficial for extremely gifted students with IQs above 160 (Gross 2006). Nevertheless, educators are right to be cautious about early school entry for individual students with moderate giftedness (IQs of 130–145). While the majority of these students may benefit from the experience, perhaps as many as 15–20 per cent of early entrants experience some adjustment difficulties (Gagné & Gagnier 2004; McCluskey, Baker & Massey 1996). However, it is uncertain whether these difficulties are due to acceleration as such, or to negative attitudes by teachers that result in accelerated students receiving little support in their new placements (Heinbokel 1997; Southern & Jones 1992), or to the fact that acceleration is used so rarely that accelerants feel abnormal (Southern et al. 1993). The final aspect of curriculum differentiation for gifted students is the medium in which they will express their learning. Gifted learners may need some latitude to take their product beyond the level normally achievable by their age peers or, for those with accompanying learning disabilities, to express their learning in other than written form. Aside from the obvious benefits for gifted students’ learning, appropriate curricular adjustments improve their social and emotional wellbeing. Being recognised as gifted enhances their self-esteem, as it confirms what they already know about themselves (Bain & Bell 2004; Manaster et al. 1994). When this recognition is followed by access to gifted provisions, students’ academic self-esteem may decline to more realistic but still positive levels, while their social and physical self-appraisals can improve (Chan 1988; Coleman & Fults 1982; Craven & Marsh 1997; Hershey & Oliver 1988; Hoge & Renzulli 1993; Marsh & Craven 1998; Marsh et al. 1995; Moon, Swift & Shallenberger 2002; Olszewski, Kulieke & Willis 1987; Ring & Shaughnessy 1993; Schneider et al. 1989; Wright & Leroux 1997). Healthy levels of academic self-esteem are particularly likely when students compare their performances with their own past achievements, rather than judging themselves in comparison with others (Craven & Marsh 1997; Gross 1997).
Self-referenced perfectionism Gifted learners are often accused of being perfectionists, although that is not necessarily a liability. With respect to self-expectations (as opposed to expectations of others), perfectionism comes in two forms. The first is a healthy form of self-referenced perfectionism, whereby individuals strive for excellence because they know that they are capable of achieving it (LoCicero & Ashby 2000; Parker 1996; Parker & Adkins 1995; Siegle
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 106
15/1/08 11:47:40 AM
Collaborating with parents of gifted learners
107
& Schuler 2000; Wood & Care 2002). These students are intrinsically motivated and therefore generally have a strong work ethic and are organised and thorough in their study habits (Neumeister 2004a). They develop this personal style by copying their parents’ industrious work habits and having an early history of success, the pattern of which they are then motivated to sustain (Neumeister 2004b). In contrast are those whose attempts to excel are an effort to prove their self-worth. These socially prescribed perfectionists fear failure and, consequently, avoid challenge if failure is a possibility, are highly anxious, depressive, have low self-esteem, and treat themselves harshly when they perceive that they have performed below expectations (Feldhusen, Dai & Clinkenbeard 2000; Neumeister 2004a, 2004b; Neumeister & Finch 2006). Their extrinsic motivation causes them to procrastinate so that if they do less well than expected, they can blame a lack of time or effort, rather than any lack of ability. This pattern arises from authoritarian parents who demand rather than encourage high standards (Rice, Ashby & Preusser 1996), and who induce guilt in their children or withdraw love when they perform below expectations; it also comes from competing for school awards (Neumeister 2004b). These messages encourage extrinsic motivation and imply to students that their self-worth is contingent on being perfect. Therefore, schools need to avoid delivering external rewards such as praise, merit certificates and high-achiever awards that foster comparisons with others, and, instead, should give students informative feedback that helps them to recognise their own achievements and progress. (See Porter 2007a, 2007b, 2008.)
Provisions for gifted–disabled learners It is thought that around 5–10 per cent of gifted students – that is, somewhere between one in 200 and one in 400 children – could also have a learning disability (Dix & Schafer 1996). The reverse statistic is that approximately 2–5 per cent of children with disabilities may also be gifted (Johnson, Karnes & Carr 1997; Whitmore 1981; Yewchuk & Lupart 2000). These children’s giftedness is often obscured by their disability and therefore is seldom identified (Karnes 1979). The manifestations of combined learning disabilities and giftedness are listed in Box 6.3 (page 108). Dyslexia is the most commonly studied learning disability to co-occur with giftedness. In many cases, students’ learning difficulties are subtle, and manifest as disorganised work habits that cause adults to regard them as unmotivated or lazy. A second group of students with dual exceptionalities are recognised as having learning difficulties, but these mask their gifts and therefore their high abilities are overlooked. A third group are those whose gifts and learning difficulties both go unnoticed.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 107
15/1/08 11:47:40 AM
108
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
Their wide spread of abilities can leave these students frustrated and confused, their parents exasperated and their teachers feeling helpless (Fall & Nolan 1993). This often worsens as they grow older; as the discrepancy widens between their expected and actual academic performances (Weinfeld et al. 2002). Their self-esteem is vulnerable because they are aware that they do not understand, but do not know why they find some tasks impenetrable when others come easily to them.
Box 6.3 Characteristics of gifted students with specific learning disabilities Gifted–learning disabled children have some intellectual skills within the gifted range but also some academic skills below age level.
Academic performance • • • •
strengths or expertise in at least one specific academic subject very able at mathematics, but poor in language/arts, or vice versa difficulties with spelling or handwriting speaking vocabulary exceeds written expression
Intellectual style • • • • • • • •
understand and discover patterns and connections between concepts unusual and active imagination highly creative excel at tasks requiring abstract thinking, analysis and problem solving deep commitment to, and highly productive in, activities outside of school wide range of interests difficulty with simple tasks, but competent at more sophisticated activities sophisticated sense of humour
Intellectual skills: auditory–sequential giftedness • exceptional comprehension • superior memory and general knowledge • extensive vocabulary • good communication skills • grasps metaphors, satire and analogies
➡
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 108
15/1/08 11:47:40 AM
Collaborating with parents of gifted learners
109
Intellectual skills: visual–spatial giftedness • keen visual memory • capable of solving puzzles and mazes • exceptional ability in geometry and science • difficulty with computation but capable of higher-level mathematical reasoning • can articulate the goal of tasks but cannot complete the sequence of steps needed for completion • ability to grasp broad concepts at once, rather than ‘step by step’ • inattentive to verbal instruction • poor spelling • difficulty with phonics • difficulty with rote memorisation
Emotional signs • • • • • • • • • • •
fragile self-esteem feel academically inept generalise minor academic failures to feelings of overall inadequacy unrealistically high or low self-expectations confused about their abilities report feeling different from others strong anxiety or fear of failure in academic tasks do not achieve well under pressure – e.g. on timed tasks sensitive to criticism of their work, even constructive criticism experience intense frustration poor social skills with children and adults
Behaviours • • • • • • •
disruptive in class often off-task disorganised, especially when unmotivated impulsive and act out without thinking about the consequences offer creative excuses to avoid difficult tasks often aggressive may be withdrawn Source: Porter (2005, pp. 183–84).
Emotional support for gifted students The notion of the ‘mad genius’ still permeates community understanding of giftedness, despite evidence that ongoing mental illness and gifted
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 109
15/1/08 11:47:40 AM
110
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
productivity are incompatible (Yewchuk 1995a, 1995b). There simply is not ‘a fine line between insanity and genius’, as the myth claims. Instead, the weight of research evidence indicates that giftedness does not cause emotional maladjustment (Clark 2002; Dwairy 2004; Feldhusen & Nimlos-Hippen 1992; Freeman 1991; Gallucci 1988; Gallucci, Middleton & Kline 1999a, 1999b; Garland & Zigler 1999; Grossberg & Cornell 1988; Gust 1997; Gust-Brey & Cross 1999; Janos & Robinson 1985; Kunkel et al. 1995; Lehman & Erdwins 1981; Moon, Kelly & Feldhusen 1997; Nail & Evans 1997; Neihart 1999, 2002; Olszewski-Kubilius, Kulieke & Krasny 1988; Parker 1996; Robinson & Noble 1991; Rost & Czeschlik 1994). In general, gifted children and adults are better adjusted than the average, because they usually have the support of well-resourced parents who themselves are high achievers (Stedtnitz 1995). As well as these external resources, they also have the internal thinking skills to solve any problems they face (Freeman 1997; Preuss & Dubow 2004; Webb 1993; Whitmore 1980). Thus, in the words of Clark (2002, p. 175), ‘the very ability that creates the problem can supply the solution’. Nevertheless, like other young people, gifted students are not insulated from adverse life events such as the death of a relative, or parental divorce. Similarly, they can become less well adjusted when enduring unsuitable educational provisions. Their emotional state can cause parents to have them assessed and, when giftedness is found, the myth connecting giftedness to maladjustment is invoked to blame that for their emotional difficulties (Freeman 2006). The problem with making this assumption is that the real cause of these young people’s difficulties is never recognised, with the result that they do not receive the educational provisions or emotional support they require.
Social inclusion Socially, many gifted learners are aware that, although they themselves value their special skills, many others – including their parents, teachers and peers – do not (Colangelo 2003; Coleman & Cross 1988; Cross, Coleman & Terhaar-Yonkers 1991; Cross, Coleman & Stewart 1992; Kerr, Colangelo & Gaeth 1988; Swiatek 1995; Tidwell 1980; van Boxtel & Mönks 1992). Nevertheless, even less popular gifted students have higher self-esteem than those with average abilities (Norman et al. 2000). Gifted students cannot help but notice that they are ‘out of step’ with age peers, in which case it is crucial that the important adults in their lives validate this perception. Conforming and being ‘normal’ – that is, the same as everyone else – is not an option for them. Parents might be tempted to protect them from this reality by rationalising that they are different from others ‘in a better way’, but this will not help them to build bridges with their peers (Hackney 1981; Roeper 1995). Instead, you can
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 110
15/1/08 11:47:40 AM
Collaborating with parents of gifted learners
111
help them to understand that no one has more than one or two friends at a time, and that their selectivity with friendships and ability to be selfsufficient can be assets. Verbally bright, emotionally aware, mature adolescents can find that they are a magnet for unsolicited romantic advances. Being popular with potential sexual partners might seem to be the type of problem that every adolescent wants to have, but unwanted attention can be embarrassing, in which case young people in this position will need some guidance about how tactfully to decline unwelcome advances.
Cultural inclusion Students from minority cultures are under-identified as being gifted (Borland & Wright 2000; Braggett 1998; Butler-Por 1993; Davis & Rimm 2004; Ford et al. 2000; Frasier 1989, 1997; Gallagher & Gallagher 1994; Maker 1996; Milner & Ford 2007; Renzulli 1973; Richert 1987, 1997; Scott et al. 1996; Tannenbaum 1983). This is clearly inequitable, as giftedness occurs at equal rates in all cultures (Borland & Wright 1994, 2000; Casey & Quisenberry 1976). The reduced recognition of students from minority backgrounds comes about in part because of the social disadvantage many of them experience and because the dominant culture’s definition of giftedness overlooks its manifestations in different cultures (Neumeister et al. 2007) – see Box 6.2. This, plus the presumption that disadvantaged students from minority cultures cannot excel, generates neglect of their needs (Huff et al. 2005). Gifted students from minority cultures are likely to be sensitised to the injustices they experience and to perceive a conflict between their racial identity and high achievement in the dominant culture’s terms (Ford 2002; Neihart 2005; Worrell 2007). Their motivation to excel, and therefore their productivity at school, can be reduced by their need to be loyal to their culture.
Behavioural guidance Children who achieve at high levels are typically curious, with a hunger to learn and a strong need to control (Freeman 2000). Although these traits foster high achievement, they can simultaneously create conflict with authoritarian disciplinarians at home or school. Combined with advanced verbal skills, many gifted young people can negotiate tirelessly, to the intense frustration of any adult who is trying to ensure compliance. Authoritarian discipline is detrimental to all young people across the ability range (for reviews see Porter 2007a, 2007b, 2008) but, with their processing capacities, gifted individuals are particularly insulted at attempts to make them think and do as others tell them.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 111
15/1/08 11:47:40 AM
112
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
Because their cognitive skills allow them to anticipate outcomes, gifted learners tend to be more careful and less impulsive than other children (Roeper 1995). Nevertheless, a proportion do show some behavioural difficulties at school: • • • • •
as a way of coping with boredom (Freeman 1995; Plucker & McIntire 1996) to prove to peers that they are not so smart after all (Clark 2002) because of heightened activity levels (Shaywitz et al. 2001) as part of an under-achievement syndrome (Clark 2002; Delisle 1992; Freeman 1995) when their emotional development has not caught up with their intellectual precocity.
Their uneven development across skill domains can make it difficult for adults to know what to expect of gifted learners. The children can reason and perform at advanced levels one minute, then revert to age level the next. Their mature behaviour can cause adults to expect too much of them and then to become frustrated at age-appropriate behaviour in the mistaken belief that the children ‘should know better’ (Colangelo 2003; Colangelo & Assouline 2000). By the end of primary school, some gifted learners can reason at levels in advance of most adults and will notice when they are brighter than their teachers. This will develop into disrespect, however, only if you take it as an affront, rather than feeling invigorated by the intellectual stimulation that these students can offer.
Career guidance Gifted students may begin to consider their career options earlier than others – often during their late primary school years. Because of their high accomplishments, they often set themselves career goals that require detailed planning and lengthy academic preparation (Moon et al. 1997). Rather than abiding by the maxim that ‘You are what you do’, these students have the luxury of abilities that enable them, when they are willing to rise to the challenge, to ‘Do what you are’. To achieve this, they will need guidance to select careers that reflect their abilities, interests and values, rather than status or salary.
Support for parents Although there is a common misconception that all parents want their child to be gifted, it is indeed a mixed blessing, one which raises in parents many uncertainties about how best to respond to their children’s particular needs and about whether they personally are equipped to do so
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 112
15/1/08 11:47:40 AM
Collaborating with parents of gifted learners
113
(Colangelo & Dettman 1983). Their responses to their child’s giftedness will depend, in part, on their values and understandings about giftedness, their experiences of how giftedness was handled in their family of origin, what they have believed about their own abilities throughout their life, and their own schooling history (Solow 2001). Given that giftedness is largely genetic (Gottfredson 2003; Patrick 2000; Plomin & Price 2003; Segal 2000; Thompson & Plomin 2000), the identification of their children’s talents can confront parents with their own giftedness and generate sadness for the child they once were whose needs were not recognised or met. Especially when parents have had a traumatic passage through school, they can be determined to protect their son or daughter from the same unsatisfactory experience. This is understandable, but can come across to teachers as excessive concern or being ‘pushy’. Although most parents recognise the need to advocate for their gifted child, they find it difficult to cope with the perception that they are unreasonably demanding (Silverman 1997). Yet, they know equally that they will achieve special educational provisions only when they instigate these, and realise that they will have to spend a great deal of energy just trying to make sure that their children are actually learning something at school (Fraser 2004). In the face of their disillusionment at a lack of accommodation for their child’s additional needs, parents might react by continually pressuring teachers, by over-scheduling their child with enriching extracurricular activities, or withdrawing from contact with their child’s teachers and complaining instead (Colangelo 2003; Colangelo & Assouline 2000). None of these reactions is ideal. Parents of gifted children from minority cultures report experiencing both interpersonal and institutional racism when advocating for their children in schools (Huff et al. 2005). Those with high levels of education themselves can feel confident about advocating for their children, while those with less education or reduced English proficiency may withdraw. Given that the most important condition for high achievement is the support the children receive, and that their families are the most valuable source of this support, you will need to recruit the support of parents from minority cultures by ensuring that your gifted provisions are culturally inclusive, non-elitist and non-threatening (Davis & Rimm 2004). At the same time as having to advocate for their children, parents of gifted students can be socially isolated. Whereas family, friends and professionals understand the fears of parents whose child has a disability, few appreciate the concerns of parents of gifted learners (Alsop 1997; McBride 1992). The largely unreliable and often unhelpful advice they receive leaves this group of parents particularly isolated (Alsop 1997).
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 113
15/1/08 11:47:40 AM
114
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
For this reason, it can be useful to recommend that they contact their local Gifted and Talented Children’s Association so that they can meet with other parents of gifted children. This can normalise what they are experiencing, provide information about solutions to common issues, reduce their isolation and give them some emotional support (Moon et al. 1997; Webb 1993).
Conclusion Parents and teachers of gifted students have much in common. Both want the children to be contented in school and to feel positively about learning and about themselves as learners. Both can be uncertain about how best to provide for gifted students. Both feel alone in their efforts, with teachers in particular hampered by a lack of training in gifted education and by bureaucratic constraints on best practice (Chyriwsky & Kennard 1997; Hall 1994). As with special education, there is no recipe for gifted education and, in the absence of training in giftedness, teachers cannot be expected to enact what they do not know. On the other hand, professionalism does not demand that they know everything, just that they be willing to find out. Parents can be an invaluable resource as a first step to discovering about giftedness and its various manifestations in individual students.
Additional resources Baum, S., Owen, S.V. & Dixon, J. (2002). To be gifted and learning disabled: From identification to practical intervention strategies. Melbourne: Hawker Brownlow Education. Colangelo, N. & Davis, G.A. (Eds.) (2003). Handbook of gifted education. (3rd ed.) Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon. Davis, G.A. & Rimm, S.B. (2004). Education of the gifted and talented. (5th ed.) Boston, MA: Pearson Allyn and Bacon. Freeman, J. (1996). Highly able girls and boys. London: Department for Education and Employment. Kerr, B.A. & Cohn, S.J. (2001). Smart boys: Talent, manhood, and the search for meaning. Scottsdale, AZ: Great Potential Press. Porter, L. (2005). Gifted young children: A guide for teachers and parents. (2nd ed.) Sydney: Allen and Unwin/Buckingham, UK: Open University Press. Rogers, K.B. (2002). Re-forming gifted education: Matching the program to the child. Scottsdale, AZ: Great Potential Press. Silverman, L.K. (Ed.) (1993). Counseling the gifted and talented. Denver, CO: Love Publishing.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 114
15/1/08 11:47:40 AM
Collaborating with parents of gifted learners
115
Silverman, L.K. (2002). Upside-down brilliance: The visual-spatial learner. Denver, CO: DeLeon. Smutny, J.F. (1998). Gifted girls. Bloomington, IN: Phi Delta Kappa Educational Foundation. Smutny, J.F. (2001). Stand up for your gifted child: How to make the most of kids’ strengths at school and at home. Minneapolis, MN Free Spirit.
Websites Gifted Development Center: http://gifteddevelopment.com
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 115
15/1/08 11:47:41 AM
7
Collaborating with parents to solve disruptive behaviour
Often, anger, irritation, and frustration seem to motivate externalizing behaviors (e.g. reactive aggression); [while] other people’s negative responses to [these] behaviors… may also elicit frustration and anger from the child. Eisenberg et al. (2005, p. 193)
According to an extensive survey in the United States, teachers reported that only half of school entrants were able to navigate a successful entry to school, with over 30 per cent experiencing some problems and 16 per cent having serious difficulties making the transition (Rimm-Kaufman et al. 2000). With so many students failing at such a tender age, this raises the question of whether our expectations of children in schools are appropriate. Many junior-primary teachers report that the system requires of young children skills that are unattainable at that age (Wesley & Buysse 2003). This not only causes stress for students but also their teachers, while the children’s early lack of success at school begins a trajectory of academic failure that is difficult to reverse in subsequent years (VotrubaDrzal 2006). School readiness is not just an attribute required of children but also comprises the familial, educational and social resources that support their success at school (Piotrkowski, Botsko & Matthews 2000). In terms of children’s qualities, they need two core sets of skills. First, their intellectual maturity, in general, and metacognitive skills (including self-regulated attention) account for 25 per cent of their adjustment and success in the early years of school (La Paro & Pianta 2000; McWayne, Fantuzzo & McDermott 2004a; Piotrkowski et al. 2000). Second, accounting for around 10 per cent of their success at making the transition to school, is children’s ability to regulate their own emotions and social behaviour (Downer & Pianta 2006; Fantuzzo et al. 2007; Graziano et al. 2007; La Paro & Pianta 2000; McClelland & Morrison 2003; McClelland, Morrison & Holmes 2000; Miles & Stipek 2006; NICHD Early Child Care Research 116
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 116
15/1/08 11:47:41 AM
Collaborating with parents to solve disruptive behaviour
117
Network 2003a). Emotional self-control may be particularly crucial for navigating school entry, because the new learning environment and challenging academic tasks can arouse anxiety and frustration. Children who have acquired self-regulation are successful academically and socially when they first enter school, as a result of which they develop an image of themselves as competent (Luster, Lekskul & Oh 2004). Meanwhile, their teachers view them more positively, which contributes to an improved teacher–child relationship that, in turn, supports children’s subsequent educational engagement and success (Graziano et al. 2007; Ladd, Birch & Buhs 1999). Nevertheless, even when individual students seem not to be developmentally ready for school, their skilfulness improves in response to high-quality instruction and social support from their teachers (Downer & Pianta 2006; Hamre & Pianta 2005).
Attention deficits In a survey of teachers in 21 countries, spanning 30,000 students, the most common student behavioural problems reported were inattentiveness and aggression, with emotional difficulties also frequent concerns for both teachers and parents (Rescorla et al. 2007). Although aggression seems the most serious of these problems, inattentiveness and hyperactivity have a greater influence on whether students will complete high school (Vitaro et al. 2005). Two forms of inattentiveness generate problems for teachers: students who are disruptive but still achieve well, and students with attention difficulties and low overall ability that lead to both behavioural disruptiveness and low academic achievement (Johnson, McGue & Iacono 2005). The first group of students has been labelled as ‘bright but bored’, tends to be more able than their peers and uses disruption as entertainment. The second group may or may not qualify for a formal diagnosis of attention-deficit disorder (ADD) or attention-deficit disorder with hyperactivity (ADHD), but these students’ risk for school failure requires primarily a proactive educational intervention, supplemented by behavioural responses. Children’s attention difficulties can be identified from as early as their first weeks of life (Auerbach et al. 2005) and are apparent in their earliest years of schooling. Thereafter, they may remain relatively stable into adolescence, with three out of four students still displaying continuing problems in high school (Hart et al. 1995; McGee et al. 1991). Those with ADD display academic (particularly literacy) difficulties, while those with ADHD continue to experience both academic and behavioural problems (Fischer et al. 1990; McGee et al. 1991, 2002; Spira & Fischel 2005). Inattentiveness typically does improve during the first year or two of school, after which it remains stable, while hyperactivity and impulsive behaviours continue a slow decline (Hart et al. 1995). Even
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 117
15/1/08 11:47:41 AM
118
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
with improving attention skills, however, a small subgroup of children with early attention difficulties display escalating disruptive behaviour (Zhou et al. 2007), perhaps in frustration at their inability to keep pace with their peers and with teacher expectations. Notwithstanding the complexities of making accurate diagnoses in individual cases, extensive research is concluding that in true cases of ADD, the cause appears to be impairment in the brain’s executive functions (Glanzman & Blum 2007). These processes control or regulate our thinking and problem solving. Deficits in these areas produce inattention, lack of self-awareness, and poor planning, judgement, organisational skills, reflection and coordination abilities. Individuals with the conditions are less able to divide their attention between aspects of the task (Karatekin 2004) and take less time to plan ahead before initiating a response (Papadopoulos et al. 2005). This may be because they cannot retain a long sequence of steps in their working memory and thus have to get started prematurely. Students with ADD and ADHD know what to do, but cannot do what they know – that is, they do not lack knowledge, but have difficulties performing or enacting what they know (Purvis & Tannock 1997). Their resulting inability to sustain a planned approach to tasks is manifested in impulsive behaviour. These deficits in executive function lead to academic problems across many domains. The first is in verbal skills (Clark, Prior & Kinsella 2002). In expression, children with ADD and ADHD have problems organising and monitoring their conversation, making it difficult for listeners to follow their train of thought. In comprehension, they have problems organising a sequence of ideas and checking their information recall (Purvis & Tannock 1997). In short, they are misunderstood by listeners and misunderstand speakers (Clark et al. 2002). In order to overcome the disorganisation of their thinking, these children talk aloud to themselves more than usual (Berk & Landau 1993; Berk & Potts 1991; Diaz & Berk 1995; Kopecky et al. 2005). They may be constantly reminded to be quiet. When their hyperactivity is in verbal rather than in motor skills, the children are insatiable: once they get an idea in their mind, they talk about it incessantly (Green & Chee 2001). Attention difficulties (but not hyperactivity) also lead to reading impairments because the children miss out on early instruction (Clark et al. 2002; Glanzman & Blum 2007; Lonigan et al. 1999; McGee et al. 2002; Rabiner, Coie & The Conduct Problems Prevention Research Group 2000; Spira & Fischel 2005). Subsequently, their reading failure leads to progressive declines in attention skills and academic achievement (McGee et al. 2002; Spira & Fischel 2005). Socially, children with the attention deficits have difficulty regulating their emotions and actions (Clark et al. 2002). They also lack
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 118
15/1/08 11:47:41 AM
Collaborating with parents to solve disruptive behaviour
119
self-awareness, having inflated evaluations of their social performance, and therefore do not moderate their actions in response to others’ negative feedback (Hoza et al. 2000). These social problems exceed those of children with behavioural difficulties alone (Clark et al. 2002), and produce socially intrusive and disruptive behaviours that generate significant social problems for them (Hoza et al. 2000). Their inappropriate social behaviour leads to acrimony at home, difficulties in establishing friendships at school and, even more importantly, in sustaining friendships – except perhaps with peers who are experiencing similar difficulties (Barkley 1988). This has an emotional cost. Students whose attention deficits give rise to social difficulties suffer associated emotional problems, including low self-efficacy, depression and anxiety (Hinshaw 2006; Hoza et al. 2000; Shelton et al. 1998; Young et al. 2005). While these emotional difficulties may be caused by children’s problems with emotional self-regulation (Lengua 2003), emotional maladjustment is almost certainly also a result of their social difficulties. In terms of motor activity, unlike normally boisterous activity, ADHD activity levels are excessive, task irrelevant, developmentally inappropriate and pervasive across settings (Anastopoulos & Barkley 1992). In short, children with ADHD fail to regulate their motor activity to suit the context. Their impulsive behaviours disrupt their own learning and that of classmates, and also result in a high rate of accidental injuries. For unknown reasons, these children experience a higher than usual rate of health problems such as incoordination, sleep disturbances, middle ear and upper respiratory infections, asthma and allergies (Anastopoulos & Barkley 1992), any or all of which can affect their school attendance. Finally, ADHD, in particular, often occurs in association with aggression and oppositional behaviour (Glanzman & Blum 2007). These behavioural problems tend to increase over the early school years (Snyder et al. 2004) but, nevertheless, are considered a byproduct rather than a defining feature of the attention deficits. Children with attention difficulties but without hyperactivity tend not to develop aggression (Loeber & Hay 1997).
Educational assessment Given that ADD and ADHD are intellectual impairments, students’ attention, intellectual and language skills must be assessed. The results they obtain on formal testing should be compared to observations by the practitioner (e.g. psychologist or speech pathologist), teachers and parents in order to determine whether there is a significant discrepancy between their measured intellectual abilities and their ability to apply their intelligence in their daily lives (Shelton et al. 1998). Other
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 119
15/1/08 11:47:41 AM
120
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
potential developmental problems must also be excluded, for which a medical assessment can be necessary as well (American Psychiatric Association 1994).
Educational interventions Surprisingly little research has been conducted on how best to remediate the constellation of learning difficulties experienced in association with attention deficits (Raggi & Chronis 2006). Compared with all other interventions, stimulants still appear to produce greater improvements in attention skills for children aged over five years and those with moderate to severe difficulties. However, medication achieves no permanent academic, social or emotional improvements, has lesser effects on the hyperactive-impulsive and aggressive elements of the conditions and can produce unpleasant sideeffects (Anastopoulos & Barkley 1992; Barkley 1988; Fox & Rieder 1993; Glanzman & Blum 2007; Goldstein 1995; Hinshaw 2006; Kopecky et al. 2005; Levy 1993; Moline & Frankenberger 2001; Purdie, Hattie & Carroll 2002; Whalen et al. 2006). It is clear that medication is over-prescribed, but it has also been found that only 12 per cent of accurately diagnosed students were prescribed medication and consequently many received no relief from their problems (Glanzman & Blum 2007). Parents and teachers become more positive when the children’s behaviours improve, perhaps in response to medication (Whalen, Henker & Dotemoto 1981; Wodrich 1994). This suggests that, in severe cases, drug treatment should be considered, primarily to give the students themselves relief from their social difficulties, including loneliness, but also to protect them from coercive discipline. Nevertheless, even with appropriately prescribed medication, simulants only enable more efficient brain functioning: these students will still need you to adjust their learning environment, curricular content and teaching processes to accommodate their learning deficits. •
•
Children with attention deficits are likely to be more productive in settings that are well organised, with clear procedures and predictable schedules. In classrooms, it can also be useful to seat them in the least distracting location in the room (Lewis & Doorlag 2003), or to give them two desks so that they can regularly change location, thus relieving surrounding peers of their disruptive influence. In terms of curricular content, students with attention deficits will need intensive instruction in problem solving (Purdie et al. 2002) and self-restraint skills, such as using an ‘inside’ voice, settling to activities, taking turns and raising a hand before answering a question (Merrell & Wolfe 1998; Rogers 2003), as well as remediation of their associated learning difficulties (e.g. language or reading impairments). To counteract this focus on their difficulties,
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 120
15/1/08 11:47:41 AM
Collaborating with parents to solve disruptive behaviour
•
121
they also need ample opportunities to demonstrate their strengths (Lewis & Doorlag 2003). Teaching and learning processes will need to be modified so that students’ attention problems do not impede their ability to profit from instruction. They need to be actively engaged in learning, in contrast to passive listening, receive simplified instructions in short bursts, be allocated extra time to complete tasks, and be given assistance to structure activities and manage transitions. Fidget items can help them concentrate while sitting still. When their attention difficulties are accompanied by hyperactivity and impulsive behaviour, they will need social support and intervention for any aggression (see chapter 8).
Aside from the ‘bright but bored’ students described earlier and the occasional clowning in class, these educational interventions are based on the assumption that students who are chronically disruptive want to achieve in school but cannot. A solution-focused approach chooses to think the best of students; not assuming that they are ‘bad’ but rather that they have neurological impairments or other limitations causing their learning difficulties. Nevertheless, this approach is not fatalistic; it recognises that for every student with dyslexia who cannot read, there are plenty more who can (Wagner & Watkins 2005). Therefore, to counteract the problem-saturated description of students as ‘learning disabled’, a solution-focused intervention would highlight the attributes they use to help themselves to learn other skills (the exceptions), and support them to transfer these learning skills to the tasks that they are finding difficult (Wagner & Watkins 2005). For example, if they can apply themselves to practising football, their same application abilities can help them learn to read. Another option is to externalise the learning difficulty (see chapter 4). Addressing their problem as an external entity rather than as some inbuilt flaw gives them permission to overcome it. It could be that ‘Squirmies’, ‘Rushing’ or ‘Guessing’ make them unsuccessful, for example (Huntley 1999). And, as mentioned in chapter 4, sometimes these problems have allies that team up with them and cause further oppression, such as ‘Selfdoubt’ or ‘Self-criticism’ (Morgan 2000).
Behavioural guidance The behavioural disruptions that accompany students’ attention deficits, particularly when accompanied by hyperactivity and impulsivity, contribute to teacher stress (Kokkinos 2007). Students are also disadvantaged by being labelled as ‘disruptive’. They often experience teacher rejection, receiving four times more negative than positive feedback and receiving fewer positive responses to their contributions during instruction (Stormont 2002; Strein, Simonson & Vail 1999; Tucker et al. 2002).
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 121
15/1/08 11:47:41 AM
122
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
This population of students also form the core of those most likely to be subjected to verbal abuse by teachers (Brendgen, Wanner & Vitaro 2006; Delfabbro et al. 2006). Repeated reprimands of these students signals to onlookers that their chastised peer is less worthy of their friendship, thus exacerbating their social isolation. According to the solution-focused approach, problematic behaviour persists when everyday developmental challenges or crises are accidentally mishandled. Subsequently, when the problem worsens, people try harder to solve it, but the harder they try, the worse it gets (Murphy 2006). Adults’ methods – which were aimed at solving the problem – unintentionally maintain or intensify it (Amatea 1988; Amatea & Sherrard 1991; Fisch et al. 1982). This leads to a recursive cycle of problems and attempted solutions (as illustrated in Figure 7.1) whereby the student disrupts, you attempt to correct the behaviour, the student resists your correction, you respond to that reaction... and so on. Thus, you each are caught up in doing ‘the same damn thing over and over’ (de Shazer et al. 1986, p. 210). This is no one’s fault: it just happens. The problem is not the dancers, but the dance in which they are engaging. Teacher
Exclusion/suspension
Imposition of time out
Loss of rewards
Instructs for compliance
Anger, coercion
Anger, defiance Disengagement
Active resistance
Belligerence
Student
Aggression
Figure 7.1: A recursive cycle of escalating disruptiveness and coercion Source: Porter (2007a, 2007b, p. 157)
When students and teachers are caught up over a long time in these repetitive cycles of action and reaction, they both feel victimised by the
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 122
15/1/08 11:47:41 AM
Collaborating with parents to solve disruptive behaviour
123
other’s behaviour. Students complain of being ‘picked on’ and that it is ‘unfair’. Teachers do likewise (although perhaps using more mature terms). Both parties to this interaction believe that their actions are justified in light of the behaviour of the other person, but this self-righteousness does not help to resolve the difficulty (Cooper & Upton 1991) and may even block them from enacting a new solution on the grounds that they are not the one with the problem. Instead, finding a solution involves changing how individuals are presently responding to the behaviour. Given that the cycle surrounding the behaviour is circular, the search for an initial cause is both fruitless and unnecessary, because there is no beginning or end in a circle. As the starting point does not matter, the place to intervene in this repetitive cycle is with yourself, as explained by an analogy suggested by Fisch and colleagues (1982) who observe that, if you wanted to put an end to a tennis rally, the simplest way would be for you to dispense with your racquet, rather than trying to convince your opponent to concede defeat and surrender. In school-based behavioural difficulties, it is virtually impossible for teachers to convince students to be the one to ‘discard their racquet’: the adults have to initiate the change. A solution-focused approach recognises that, if present solutions were going to work, they would have by now. Given that they have not, in the words of Fisch and colleagues (1982, p. 88) you will need to ‘change a losing game’ or, quite simply, obey the self-evident truth that if something isn’t working, you should stop doing it and try something else instead. Therefore, it is time to abandon rewards and punishments. Despite the fact that these students’ lack of self-control might suggest the need for adults to take charge of them through the delivery of rewards and punishments, even intensive behaviourist interventions with children with ADD produce minimal improvements in their functioning in the classroom and no measurable improvement at home or on any test of academic skill (Barkley et al. 2000). Coercive responses to disruptions can even exacerbate students’ behavioural problems, as illustrated in Figure 7.1 (Johnson et al. 2005). In contrast, adults’ use of a guidance approach improves students’ social skilfulness and reduces their antisocial and defiant behaviour (Hinshaw 2006). This method involves the use of time away, in which students who have become overwhelmed and consequently disruptive can withdraw to a pleasant location where they can enjoy activities that soothe them, returning to class once they have recovered their emotional balance. They could even choose to take along a friend to whom to vent their feelings. For behaviourists, this might sound like a reward for poor behaviour, but the rationale is to teach students to regain control of their emotions, for which only two methods are known to the human race: get
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 123
15/1/08 11:47:41 AM
124
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
some emotional support from a friend, or do something soothing. The method is about teaching self-control, not about punishing students for lacking self-regulation skills (see Porter 2007a, 2007b, 2008).
Adjust your attributions Attributions are explanations for the outcomes of events. When attempting to explain students’ behavioural disruptions, your attributions will focus either on your students or yourself and, accordingly, will influence how you respond. When you blame students’ behaviour on causes beyond their control (such as a disability or family adversity), you are likely to be sympathetic, warm and supportive, expecting less of them in light of their circumstances. However, while positively motivated, this entrenches the students’ own attributions about their personal incapacities and can cause you to expend less effort to ensure that they are successful at school, with the result that they may not engage and will make little progress. This would only confirm your low expectations (Tollefson 2000). On the other hand, when you regard the source of their problems as being internal to students – for example, assuming that they are being deliberately disruptive – you may tend to become angry and, in turn, less willing to help, you may deliver more negative feedback and administer more punitive discipline (Martin et al. 1999; Scott-Little & Holloway 1992; Stormont 2002; Tollefson 2000; Weiner 2000). The result is a downward spiral of adult coercion and child resistance (as illustrated in Figure 7.1). Your deteriorating relationship is likely to cause a decline in influence over your students’ learning or behaviour. Nevertheless, while excusing or blaming your students is not ideal, neither is blaming yourself, because self-criticism paralyses rather than energises. The conclusion, therefore, is that you need to focus on strategies rather than on finding a culprit. According to this way of thinking, the persistence of problems merely indicates the need to change strategy, rather than signalling a personal failure of your students, their parents, or yourself.
Build improved relationships with disruptive students Some parents believe that their children’s behaviours are incited or exacerbated by difficult work demands or unfair disciplinary or teaching practices at school (Roffey 2002). They want to see you focusing sincerely on their child’s positive attributes. As for the students themselves, in a context of coercive attempts to make them change their behaviour, they are not likely to be motivated to change how they are acting. They will not volunteer that they have a problem, as that would be an admission
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 124
15/1/08 11:47:41 AM
Collaborating with parents to solve disruptive behaviour
125
that they are damaged; instead, they will blame their teachers. Arguments about who is at fault are irrelevant, however, because interactions between teachers and students are cyclical. When teachers modify their side of the interaction, students will have to change in response. Therefore, building a more positive relationship with students with disruptive behaviour will not only reduce their disruptiveness, but will also help build rapport with those parents who feel that the school is victimising (‘picking on’) their child. In order to build more constructive relationships with troublesome students, in everyday interactions you can use a method known as ‘storming the back door’. This involves acknowledging something positive or neutral about students or their behaviour, without focusing at all on the problem (Molnar & Lindquist 1989). Because all interactions are linked, changing any one interaction – even when it has nothing to do with the problem – alters your relationship with the students and in turn changes the problem. A behaviourist approach to managing student behaviour advises adults to record how often problems occur, impose controlling discipline, then count again if there has been an improvement in the rate of problems. The solution-focused approach recommends the opposite focus. It recognises that when teachers are frustrated with students’ continuing behavioural difficulties, it is easy for them to overlook the times when the problem could have occurred but did not, or was less severe than usual. You might recall from chapter 4 that these occasions are called ‘exceptions’. In order to gain a more positive perspective that honours rather than discounts students’ successes, the solution-focused approach advises you to record these instances (McGlone 2001).
Garner support for yourself When they have internal and external resources for surmounting obstacles, individuals can face challenges without experiencing stress. Guided by a parent-driven model, your first source of support is parents themselves. You can exchange information with them about what works and does not work for each of you. If their child has received a formal diagnosis of an attention-deficit disorder, you can, with their permission, also gain information by speaking directly to his or her medical and developmental specialists. A second source of support is your principal and other colleagues. You will be protected from reacting with stress when you can contribute to decisions and feel sufficiently experienced and confident about responding to disruptive behaviours – that is, when you have high collective and personal efficacy (Nelson et al. 2001). You can receive formal collegial support in the form of case conferences aimed at planning a solution to
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 125
15/1/08 11:47:41 AM
126
Teacher–Parent Collaboration
chronic disruptiveness. Whereas most case conferences merely confirm a student’s negative reputation and entrench teachers’ feelings of hopelessness through their almost exclusive focus on problems, solution-focused case conferences instead follow the format outlined in chapter 4. That is, they describe the problem, formulate goals, discuss present interventions and identify which of these has worked by highlighting exceptions and noting what is happening when the student is not behaving disruptively, and then plan to do more of what is working. Each teacher involved with the student can rate his or her behaviour on a scale of 1 to 10 before, during and after a planned intervention. The different ratings by various teachers and by the same teacher in different contexts help identify what contributes to the higher ratings, can clarify what goal is realistic (‘What rating would you settle for?’) and, later, can document progress (Harker 2001).
Support for parents In my experience, you are likely to encounter more than the usual difficulties if your intention is to use a professional-driven or family-allied approach to recruiting the support of parents whose children’s disruptive behaviour is associated with attention deficits. This is because there is a high genetic component to these conditions (Auerbach et al. 2005; Glanzman & Blum 2007; Groot et al. 2004; Hinshaw 2006; Stein et al. 2002), which means that many parents themselves are likely to have similar difficulties. In cases in which this is true, these parents may have experienced considerable failure and resulting low self-esteem during their own schooling, and as a consequence they may be reluctant to engage with you to resolve their children’s current difficulties. Even without such a history themselves, some may believe that their child’s difficulties reflect their own failings and, consequently, are reluctant to expose themselves to outside scrutiny and potential criticism (Grolnick et al. 1997). More so with this population than with others, you cannot expect parents to follow up at home any school-based interventions. Children’s behavioural difficulties make home-based interventions very demanding on any parent (Coots 1998), but those whose children have attention deficits and highly disruptive behaviours experience particularly elevated stress levels (Sheridan, Dwyer & Sanders 1997; Williford et al. 2007). Compounding this, parents who share their children’s condition may have difficulties structuring everyday family life, with household chaos unconducive to preparing their children for a school day. Against this background, any attempt to impose an alien routine may add intolerably to their stress, especially when you consider other adversities that they may be navigating, such as economic hardship or the presence of siblings with similar problems.
01 Teach_parent_TXT_FINAL.indd 126
15/1/08 11:47:41 AM
Collaborating with parents to solve disruptive behaviour
127
In turn, added stress can endanger their children because parents who have attention deficits can have shorter fuses when parenting (Whalen et al. 2006). This causes them to use coercive discipline. You must be sure, therefore, not to add to the family’s stress levels, as just described, and also to state clearly when informing parents of incidents that the problems are occurring at school and therefore can only be solved there. You need to reiterate that you do not want the parents to punish their child at home for events that occur at school. On rare occasions when you cannot be certain that their child will be safe should you disclose an incident, it can be wise to limit how much you tell parents. A second constraint on how much to tell parents is the need for a balance of information. If all that