The Evolution of Adaptive Systems
This page intentionally left blank
The Evolution of Adaptive Systems James P. Bro...
178 downloads
1808 Views
5MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
The Evolution of Adaptive Systems
This page intentionally left blank
The Evolution of Adaptive Systems James P. Brock
This book is printed on acid-free paper. Copyright 2000 by ACADEMIC PRESS All Rights Reserved.
No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
Academic Press A Harcourt Science and Technology Company 525 B Street, Suite 1900, San Diego, California 92101-4495 http://www.academicpress.com Academic Press Harcourt Place, 32 Jamestown Road, London NW1 7BY http://www.hbuk.co.uk/ap/ Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 00-102539 International Standard Book Number 0-12-134740-0 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 00 01 02 03 04 05 MM 9 8 7 6 5 4
3
2
1
Dedicated to Diane and Melanie
This page intentionally left blank
CONTENTS
FOREWORD ix PREFACE xi
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Adaptation and the Adaptive System 1 Spatial Structure of the Adaptive Niche 27 Dynamics of the Adaptive Niche 43 The Selection Interface 53 Adaptive Equilibrium 67 The Cladogenetic Selection Interface 85 Adaptive Potential, Biophysical Paradigms, and the Selectional Attractor 121 Evolutionary Mode 145 Structural Paradigms of Development 161 Adaptive Capacity and Potential in the Mechanisms of Development 175 Developmental Genetics, Adaptive Capacity, and Potential 199 vii
viii
CONTENTS
12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21
Mutation and Realization of Adaptive Potential 231 Chromosome Structure and Adaptive Topography 275 Evolutionary Impediments and the Adaptive Substrate for Evolutionary Change 299 Darwinian versus Thompsonian Factors in Evolution 325 The Morphogenetic Topology of Evolutionary Change 351 Architecture of the Phyletic Lineage 401 Evolutionary Rate and Episodic Evolution 441 Stasis and the Adaptive Substrate 491 Extinction—Lineage to Clade 511 From Lineage to Taxon 531 EPILOGUE: AN OVERVIEW OF THE GENERAL THEORY 591 GLOSSARY 599 BIBLIOGRAPHY 619 INDEX 631
FOREWORD
The study of evolutionary biology is at an exciting time as many new ideas and new techniques are integrated into our understanding of the process. Too often the trend has been to take an extreme reductionist approach and pull everything apart into the smallest possible unit. The study of adaptations does not lend itself to that approach because natural adaptive systems evolve as a unit in response to an extremely wide range of external functions. Adaptation is also the fundamental process underlying the behavior of natural biotic systems. I therefore welcome this book that brings together a broad spectrum of data about the adaptive process in a well-integrated way. It also does a lot to define and clarify terms that have been used in so many different ways, but you will have to learn several new terms as you read this book. This is a timely volume written by a natural historian who has a broad view of biology and who draws examples from a large range of organisms from many different habitats and niches where interesting adaptations have evolved, yet the book probes deeply into the mechanisms of evolution such as developmental genetics, morphogenesis, chromosome structure and cladogenesis. The recent advance in these fields and especially in developmental genetics enables a much deeper analysis of adaptive systems and of the way in which natural selection works. Here we have an in-depth analysis of the adaptive side of evolution that will be of considerable use to all evolutionary biologists. Professor Sir Ghillean Prance FRS Director, Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew
ix
This page intentionally left blank
PREFACE
The data of evolutionary biology have changed in a very radical way since the 1960s, the most significant input to this revolution perhaps having been the great advances made in developmental genetics. The dialetic of the ‘‘synthetic school’’ which preceded this explosion of information is now inadequate to serve as an analytical tool to assimilate these new data, and there thus exists a real need for provision of a firm basis for a fresh overview of contemporary knowledge in the context of the wider adaptive system. Another recent development is a noticeable shift away from the trend toward extreme specialization in evolutionary biology, and in this, we are perhaps to be reminded of the comments of George Gaylord Simpson: ‘‘Evolution is an incredibly complex but at the same time integrated and unitary process. Violence is done whenever we pick out one factor, process, or element of the pattern and attempt to consider this apart from the whole.’’ Indeed, evolution either is panmictic in biology or else is a loose set of unconnected populations with little or no gene migration between. This broader view should be the starting point from which any fresh analysis should proceed. The main objective of this book is to illustrate how natural adaptive systems evolve as a unity, with the particular objective of identifying and merging several ‘‘special theories’’ of evolution within the framework of a single general theory. The outlook thus follows an interdisciplinary ideal, looking at the ways in which diverse subject areas within biology interlink in their relationship to evolutionary theory with particular respect to large scale, longer term manifestations of the evolutionary process. The approach has been especially concerned with the dynamic behavior of biotic adaptive systems, with special reference
xi
xii
PREFACE
to the question of innate capacities and potentials residing in such systems—an understanding of which latter may be incorporated into conceptual structures relating the static aspect to the dynamic. The methodology has been to look firstly at the fundamental structure of the adaptive system itself, following this with a deeper analysis of niche and environment with respect to the manner in which organism and environment interact in the state of adaptive equilibrium. This leads naturally to the question of the means by which innate evolutionary potential in adaptive systems is actually realized—a process which must be located in a firm understanding of development and of the mechanisms of genetic control over developmental events. The way in which major patterns of structural differentiation arise and are sculptured by selection during the course of long-term evolution thus forms the central core of the ensuing argument. Finally, I have looked briefly at the criteria of phylogeny reconstruction in the light of constraints emerging from findings concerning the evolutionary process. The analytical approach throughout this study has concerned a search for minimum models within each area of investigation, rather than to follow each line of enquiry into specialized areas remote from the primary aims and objectives of the book. Each topic is thus given a broadly biosystematological treatment, and it will be fruitless to look for anything beyond that. In this, I have followed the maxim that ‘‘everything should be simplified as much as possible—but no more than desirable’’ (thus remaining wary of any assumption that the simplest explanation is necessarily the correct one!). So far as the raw data of evolutionary biology are concerned, I have not attempted to give a comprehensive coverage of observational data other than via the medium of brief cross-references to other sources. Attention must be drawn to the fact that it has been found necessary to introduce a certain amount of new terminology in this study. Too large a proportion of the existing dialectic is confused, with the same term at times being used to denote wholly different phenomena, or several terms encompassing merely a single mechanism. There has thus frequently been a difficult choice to make between creation of new or revision of existing terminology. Wherever I have chosen the latter option, I have striven to indicate precisely where and why a revised usage of a term is used, and introduction of entirely new nomenclature has generally been the chosen option only with new or radically re-formed concepts. Owing to the fact that first attempts at redefinition of a term frequently resulted in the discovery that other terms used axiomatically in new definitions were themselves heterogeneous, redefinition of terms has been designed to meet the criterion of interdisciplinary homogeneity, rather than to necessarily agree with any supposedly accepted or contemporary usage. So far as the reader is concerned, this means careful attention must be paid to the precise meaning of the nomenclature, for a clear understanding of the train of argument followed in this book. Resolving the semantic question is, of course, only a secondary goal to the refinement and revision of earlier theoretical structures. In this endeavor, introduction of new concepts should, it is hoped, seek to avoid extreme polarization in the reassessment of earlier ideas, thus (wherever appropriate) following the viewpoint of G. L. Stebbins that ‘‘new facts require modification and
xiii
PREFACE
amplification of accepted principles, rather than their rejection.’’ Nevertheless, the adaptive systems approach does in fact also lead to radically new conceptual structures, the relationships of which to some earlier models that are quite widely held to constitute mere observational data in disguise, must of course be rendered fully explicit. As a general rule, I have striven to distinguish between hypothesis and theory throughout, seeking an holistic view, rather than a standpoint biased toward any particular school of thought. Many apparent divergencies of opinion in evolutionary biology really reflect an intrinsic pluralism in the manner in which biotic adaptive systems exist and evolve in Nature. This pluralism lies not only in the deep dichotomy between unicells and higher organisms (which latter form the subject matter of the present work), but also between different lineages of multicellular organisms. Despite this problem, there must of course be many fundamental axioms which do apply more or less universally to the evolution of multicellular organisms, and discovering what these axioms are obviously constitutes a major objective in any work of this kind. Of even greater priority in the question of pluralism is the problem of ‘‘generality’’ itself. There are, indeed, several ‘‘special’’ theories of evolution. Quite apart from the question as to how these structures integrate in the context of a general theory, it is not at all clear what these components actually are. Even the widely held assumption that any general theory must constitute a further expansion of ‘‘neo-Darwinism’’ must be challenged most assidiously (and, indeed, the solution proposed in the present work plainly does not in fact fall into that category). Last, it is necessary to add the customary coda that all works of this size are inevitably shortcuts to what should have been a more extensive treatment, and all carry the same apology, namely, that omissions are at least in part due to the impossibility of encompassing everything in the time available.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Various institutions have provided facilities connected in one way or another with the groundwork which went into this study, most notably (and in chronological order), the Universities of Glasgow, Oxford, Liverpool, and London (Imperial College). Most significantly, the Director and Trustees of the Horniman Museum played a lead role in provision of facilities for completion of the book. This help, along with that provided by the Horniman Library, Leaford Patrick (Deputy Keeper of Natural History at the Horniman Museum), and the libraries of The Linnean Society and Imperial College, is gratefully acknowledged. My wife Diane and daughter Melanie endured a great many privations during the writing period, and a special thank you goes to them. James P. Brock
This page intentionally left blank
1
ADAPTATION AND THE ADAPTIVE SYSTEM
While it may be possible to conceive of a simple biotic system existing as a single organic entity, all life-forms really exist within the confines of a larger adaptive system in which competition occurs within and between gene pool boundaries, and where diverse means of cycling energy exist as a function of the strategy of interactivity within the system. The origins of evolutionary change lie in the fundamental structure of this adaptive system.
ADAPTATION AS A PROCESS Fundamental to any discussion of biological principles is the differential between process, mechanism, and emergent properties arising from the nature of the temporospatial matrix in which biotic adaptive systems operate. A process is defined here in the context of an adaptive goal: the reason some biotic function is being carried out (namely, any activity directly involved in promoting survivorship). A functional mechanism then concerns the means by which a given process is actually realized (competition, natural selection, etc.). Additionally, an emergent evolutionary corollary constitutes some point of interest arising from a process or mechanism, but which is clearly neither: for example, a gene pool is holistically adapted to a varied external environment as a corollary of a mechanism operating at the level of individual selectional activity. A further term that has been used in a similar context is effect, which is seen here as constituting a corollary that is not a point of any evolutionary interest. Williams (1966) uses the ‘‘apple’s contribution to Newtonian inspiration’’ as an example of an effect—also, the red color of blood containing
1
2
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
hemoglobin. An appreciation of the difference between the above gene pool example and those just given should suffice to explain the differential between corollary and effect, and the fundamental significance of the former compared to the irrelevance of the latter. In the past, theoretical structures in evolutionary biology have often been built around corollaries and effects, with the result that our understanding of process and mechanism has frequently been obscured (as with the Haeckelian doctrine of recapitulation, to name but one example). While many significant evolutionary corollaries arise in the context of adaptational mechanisms (as with the architecture of the gene pool mentioned above), a great many ‘‘effects’’ (sensu Williams) are clearly of no biosystematological interest whatsoever. However, the existence of many mechanismic and processive corollaries in the evolution of adaptive systems does suggest that we need to concern ourselves with both primary and emergent aspects of the behavior of adaptive systems. It is a basic goal of this book to attempt to unravel the correct hierarchic relationship between process, mechanism, corollary, and effect, and in particular to dismember many of the heterogenies which still exist in evolutionary biology as a result of lack of clarity in this domain. In this study, the central process is clearly that of adaptation itself,* and this is affected by a complex hierarchy of mechanisms manifesting a range of functions. Secondary to the relationship between mechanism and process lies the question of the evolutionary corollary, in that many significant biological phenomena are essentially levels of complexity arising from some mechanism or process operating at a lower level.
ADAPTATION AND ADAPTIVE CAPACITY Any attempt at an analysis of the behavior of adaptive systems clearly must begin with a definition of the term adaptation itself. In attempting to solve this problem, a useful approach would be to look firstly at the different ways in which ‘‘adaptation’’ has been characterized in the past. Using the term adaptation in the context in which it has previously been more loosely applied, it is quite possible to assemble the following statement: The horns of rhinos are an adaptation of the hair on the top of the head. This is an adaptation for defense; however, the character ‘‘number of horns’’ is nonadaptive. Any attempt to find a consistent definition of the term adaptation that will easily resolve the above anomaly will reveal something of the confusion that has been wrought! How can we discuss (for example) the possibility of a nonadaptive input to evolution, when the term adaptation has not itself been adequately defined?
Adaptation Defined According to Rose and Lauder (1996), adaptation refers both to a process and to its product—the process of modifying one thing to another, and the condition * Adaptation clearly forms the true essence of the Darwinian thesis, in that selection has no meaning in any other context.
1. ADAPTATION AND THE ADAPTIVE SYSTEM
3
of being adapted. Adaptation looks to the past and to a trait’s selective history, while fitness points to future reproductive success. The process of adaptation (natural selection) is a cause of states of adaptation. It is also, however, quite widely agreed at the present time that there are disadvantages in using adaptation to mean both process of change and fitness enhancing state. Thus, while it appears that there is general agreement that adaptation is concerned with survivorship, there is concern that the term is often used synonymously with others linked to the same propensity. Disentangling adaptation proper from this heterogeny therefore becomes a necessary prerequisite to any rigorous investigation of evolutionary theory. Various solutions have been proposed to the problem of adaptation. The following treatment begins with a brief survey of some variants of current and past usage, continuing with a solution linked to the analysis of adaptive systems (and accepting the link with survivorship as axiomatic): Adaptation as function
Adaptation as functional change
Adaptation as change of form
Adaptation as evolution Adaptation as specialization
Adaptation as differential in fitness
Adaptation as absolute fitness
The statement, ‘‘The wing is an adaptation for flight,’’ can be equated with, ‘‘The function of a wing is flight’’ (in that, depending on context, flight may or may not manifest an actual input to survivorship). ‘‘The walking limb was adapted for flight.’’ Adaptation is not exactly synonymous with functional change, since there is clearly also a static aspect to the adaptational process (the ‘‘nonadapted’’ walking limb must also serve an adaptive role!). Here, adaptive shift is the preferred description. ‘‘The planispiral cephalopod shell has been adapted to form a variety of different configurations.’’ Adaptation is not exactly synonymous with change of form, since (for example) vestigiating structures are changing form but not ‘‘adapting.’’ ‘‘The process through which adaptedness is acquired is called adaptation’’ (Cockburn, 1991). This is clearly an abbreviation for adaptive evolution. ‘‘The reduced form of many parasites is due to adaptation to mode of life.’’ Adaptation is not synonymous with ‘‘specialization,’’ since ‘‘generalized’’ structures clearly also express adaptation in terms of manifestation of propensity for survivorship. ‘‘Adaptation refers to a state of form that is more efficient than some other, related state’’ (‘‘a fitness enhancing trait which was produced by selection for its current fitness benefits,’’ following Fisher, 1930). This statement refers not to adaptation, but to an adaptational differential. The latter is in fact concerned with selection, which, again, is not exactly synonymous with adaptation. ‘‘Adaptation’’ must also have an absolute meaning if a comparative one exists. ‘‘Functional mechanisms manifest adaptation in their propensity for survivorship.’’ This again is only partly true, since survivorship is not manifested by function other than in certain closely specified contexts. It is possible to have ‘‘perfect function’’ yet no adaptation, in the absence of interaction with an appropriate external environment. Nevertheless, adaptation is clearly linked to absolute fitness via function.
Adaptive Capacity Following on from the above argument, adaptation must now be defined as: performance of function in the context of interaction between an organism
4
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
and its external environment such that survivorship is maintained between generations. From this definition, it follows that organisms possess, only adaptive capacity and not adaptation, as such. The concept of adaptive capacity can readily be linked to certain past interpretations: West-Eberhard in Keller and Lloyd (1992) summarized that ‘‘adaptation’’ had been applied to propensity to survive and reproduce in a particular environment, following Mayr (1988), who proposed using adaptedness in this context. Dobzhansky (1970) also used ‘‘adaptedness’’ as ability to survive in a given environment. As will be argued at a later point, the term adaptive capacity also encompasses both ‘‘backward and forward looking’’ aspects of adaptation.* Adaptation is thus to be correctly understood as residing in that capacity through which survivorship is perpetuated, as manifested in that subset of the total functional activity actually contributing to survivorship in the organism– environment interaction. In general, then, the static view of adaptation (‘‘facility for’’ adaptation) can be said to constitute adaptive capacity, as a description of an innate propensity for survivorship which may or may not be realized. This accordingly encompasses both static and dynamic aspects of adaptation.
Mechanisms of Adaptive Capacity in the Function Ensemble and the Adaptation Interface Adaptive capacity is contained in a set of organic functions. What mechanisms are involved in this, and how do they interact with each other and with the external environment? Structure, Behavior, and Metabolism Continuing to analyze adaptation as our target process in the analysis of evolution, it is first of all evident that several linked mechanisms interact to bring about realization of an adaptive goal. All organic systems express two fundamental functional mechanisms in structure and metabolism, and a third mechanism, behavior, is expressed to a greater or lesser extent in different lifeforms (or at different stages in the same organism). Structure is the organization of organic material for a range of functions (feeding, locomotion, reproduction, etc.) and is thus seen as having ‘‘inward and outward reaching’’ components, with respect to both external and internal environments. Metabolism incorporates the processes through which energy is cycled between external and internal environments and the manner in which it is used for work and growth in the latter. The role of behavior clearly lies in coordinating structure and function in the function ensemble (behavior– metabolism–structure) with the adaptive strategy of activity in the external environment. Function is therefore expressed in the integrated role of structure, behavior, and metabolism in providing capacity for survivorship. Function thus lies in all mechanisms contributing (either directly or indirectly) to the probability of survivorship of an organism. The capacity for expression of function accord* As noted by Begon et al. (1990), the prefix ab- in abaptation emphasizes that heritable characteristics of an organism are consequences of the past, not anticipation of the future or present, whereas ad- implies the latter.
1. ADAPTATION AND THE ADAPTIVE SYSTEM
5
ingly lies in the function ensemble, in the interaction between the mechanisms of structure, behavior, and metabolism: The function ensemble in relation to flight incorporates structure (wings and muscles), metabolism (enriched energy supply to flight muscles and biochemical modifications for efficient release of energy), and behavior, the manner in which flight is performed in the context of interaction with the external environment. The function ensemble constitutes an open system facilitating energy exchange between internal and external environments, and adaptation is realized by interaction between the function ensemble and the external environment in the context of maintaining survivorship. In this situation, functional activity may or may not lead to adaptation (for example, not all flight activity necessarily contributes to survivorship). Organic capacity for adaptation (adaptive capacity) clearly lies with the function ensemble, in its ongoing interaction with the external environment. The function ensemble thus becomes the adaptive ensemble, in its interaction with the external environment, at which point we also encounter the adaptation interface between organism and external environment.
FIGURE 1 The adaptive ensemble.
The dichotomy function interface/adaptation interface will also need to be explored further in relation to endogenous/extrinsic domains of natural selection at a later point (see Chapter 7).
6
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
The Logistic Domain Clearly, the function ensemble cannot be considered to constitute a complete representation of the adaptive relationship between organism and environment in the absence of a logistic component. Populations and gene pools must also contain an appropriate survival strategy in terms of intrinsic rate of increase and generational structure if population crash and extinction are to be avoided. And it is pertinent to point out that a gene pool that is ‘‘perfectly adapted’’ in terms of behavior, structure, and metabolism may have no adaptive capacity whatsoever if its intrinsic rate of increase is too high in relation to size of some limiting resource (or too low with respect to competition/predation): The logistic component of adaptive capacity is easily illustrated by examples such as numbers of pollen grains produced by windpollinated plants, as well as by the Darwinian maxim that most organisms produce many more offspring than can hope to survive. The relationship between the structural and logistic components of adaptation forms an important theme in any discussion of the evolutionary behavior of adaptive systems.
Orientation of the Adaptive Ensemble The adaptive ensemble can clearly have a greater or lesser input from any chosen component mechanism (for example, the logistic component of adaptive capacity may tend to predominate in interactions between organism and environment in certain environments). The particular mechanism tending to dominate the adaptive response will clearly depend on the precise nature of the links between gene pool and external environment in relation to the leading effect component of the allelomorphic component of the gene pool. This situation reflects orientation of the adaptive ensemble, with which concept we are concerned whether the system tends to be structure, behavior, or logistics led, according to which of these components forms the principal component of adaptive capacity.
Locus of the Adaptation Interface To explore the adaptation interface concept in more detail it is first of all necessary to investigate further the special meaning of the term adaptation in its biological context. It should be evident from the above discussion that structure does not always manifest function and also that all function does not constitute adaptation. The adaptation interface is that usually four-dimensional locus within the adaptive system defined jointly by some aspect of the adaptive ensemble (structure, behavior, or metabolism) and the external environment, at which adaptational activity is directly expressed. Therefore, while a broader environment interface forms the locus of all interactions between organism and environment, our point of interest lies in the adaptation interface, at which such interactions also affect survivorship directly.
7
1. ADAPTATION AND THE ADAPTIVE SYSTEM
Function Cycles and the Adaptation Interface Activity within any one mechanism of the adaptive ensemble is generally organized in function cycles that describe the mechanismic link between internal and external environment in terms of direct or indirect capacity for manifestation of adaptation. Function cycles are of two main types, according to relationships with generation time, primary cycles occurring within the domain of generation time (t) and epicycles lying in that of time ⱖt. Primary cycles also fall into two categories according to whether they are always completed or sometimes not, being either obligate (complete, as with many metabolic cycles) or facultative (need not be completed, as with much quasi-cyclic behavioral activity). Epicycles also fall into these same categories (development and reproduction are obligate epicycles, and dynamic equilibrium in the genome–environment interaction is a facultative epicycle). Some function cycles can also be regarded as being endogenous (e.g., development), whereas others are exogenous (as with behavior). Adaptation is directly expressed only in the latter. As we have seen, a function cycle may involve energy release without necessarily expressing truly adaptational activity, or else it may link function to adaptation. The adaptation interface therefore only exists at those loci in time and space at which activity in the adaptive system expresses some effect on survivorship, as a direct function of interaction between organism and external environment. Adaptation can thus be seen to be expressed at the end point of a function chain that can be any subset of a complete facultative function cycle: Flight mechanisms interact with the aerial environment and with other functional activity in a manner that is promotional to survival (location of food resources, evasion of predators, finding a mate, etc.). The relevant function chain involves metabolic and biomechanical activity directed to that end in the behavior–environment link. This situation can be broadly summarized as follows: Activity within function chain
Adaptation interface
May or may not contribute to survivorship; in that endogenous function alone need not constitute adaptational activity. Includes loci of energy usage:
Actual contribution to survivorship is affected by the direct interaction between organism and external environment. Includes loci of energy exchange with external environment: The act of feeding/taking shelter/ mating manifests energy exchange, mortality, reproduction, etc.
Muscles provide locomotion in search of food, locating shelter or mate, avoidance, etc.
A function chain involving locomotion could thus be described in terms of any one mechanism within the function ensemble, whereas adaptation is realized only in terms of interaction within the entire adaptive ensemble and between the latter and the external environment. The function ensemble is thus essentially ‘‘metabolism led’’—and the adaptive ensemble, ‘‘behavior led’’, in the context of the adaptation interface.
8
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
FIGURE 2 Function and adaptive ensembles in the adaptation interface (S ⫽ structure, B ⫽ behavior, M ⫽ metabolism).
ENDOGENOUS AND EXOGENOUS DOMAINS IN ADAPTIVE CAPACITY As stated above, adaptation is not an intrinsic property of any part of the adaptive ensemble, but rather it is a process manifested in the dynamic relationship between certain intrinsic propensities of the organism and its external environment. These properties are • The endogenous component of adaptive capacity of the organism (namely, that element which resides within the function ensemble itself ) • A complementary extrinsic component of adaptive capacity lying in the external environment (the capacity of some subset of the external environment to be adapted to) Adaptive capacity can thus be defined as being that capacity for survivorship residing in mechanisms of the function ensemble as these in turn link to complementary parameters existing in the external environment. We can thus view the adaptive system as a structure concerned with interactivity between gene pools and between living and nonliving environments, in terms of complementary endogenous and exogenous components of adaptive capacity.
9
1. ADAPTATION AND THE ADAPTIVE SYSTEM
Since the mechanisms of adaptation interdigitate with the external environment, endogenous ‘‘adaptive capacity’’ is functionless in the absence of complementary capacity in the external environment. This endogenous component must therefore be seen as an extrinsic component of adaptive capacity, as a functional subset of a larger adaptive system: Endogenous adaptive capacity
Extrinsic adaptive capacity
Structure Metabolism Behavior Logistic activity
The limiting resource (K ) Competitors Predators Shelter sites Various abiotic factors
The extrinsic component of adaptive capacity is thus confirmed as being the capacity of some subset of the external environment ‘‘to be adapted to’’ with respect to a given gene pool or population (limiting resource plus other gene pools of the same adaptive system). It is also highly significant that the extrinsic complement of adaptive capacity has a large probabilistic input relating to spatial distribution and periodicity of resources, while the endogenous component is intrinsically deterministic in nature (although capable of responding to the probabilistic dimension within constraints imposed by the structure of the genotype, namely, through changing genotype frequencies and genetic mutation). Most significantly of all, adaptive capacity must be defined as being limited to the domain of structure as determined by the existing gene pool (although it may obviously come to be expanded in the context of mutational change). In summary, adaptation therefore correctly describes integrated activity between the function ensemble and the external environment. The ‘‘raw’’ function ensemble thus invariably expresses adaptive capacity—but not necessarily adaptation itself, unless integrated activity also involves positive interaction with the external environment.
Dynamic Aspects of Adaptive Capacity Adaptation clearly has both static and dynamic aspects. For example, color pattern may be said to express adaptedness with respect to camouflage, thermoregulation, etc., and it thus seems self-evident that for many traits, adaptive capacity is linked to genetic allelomorphism in order that there may be interdigitation with a changing external environment. The concept of adaptive capacity thus further serves to explain the dynamic nature of adaptation when extended to the population level. Following this approach, it is evident that the true epicenter of adaptive capacity lies with the gene pool, and that realization of adaptive capacity most usually describes a state of dynamic equilibrium between organism and environment, rather than either stasis or true evolutionary change. Adaptive capacity is thus not held solely by a single structural state, but also by the recombinative capacity of the allelomorphic component of the
10
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
genome with respect to a minimum range of genotypes possessing the capacity to manifest a changing response in gene frequency in view of periodic variation in the external environment. Adaptive capacity is thus seen to be a dynamic structure, in the ongoing interaction between environmental fluctuation and genetic variation, and is held by the gene pool rather than by the individual genotype. The concept of adaptive capacity can therefore be only incompletely understood from the activity of a single individual participating in the organism–environment interaction. Dynamics of the Logistic Component of Adaptive Capacity Structure and behavior alone cannot describe the totality of adaptational mechanisms, as shown by the important contribution made by the logistic domain. In the context of population structure, dynamic balance between N (population size) and K (the limiting resource) expresses an important dimension in the logistic component of adaptive capacity, this being expressed in an adjustability residing in such factors as variability of fecundity and generational time, in terms of matching intrinsic rate of increase with mortality factors in the external environment. Additionally, the concept of variation within the gene pool is meaningless in the absence of an active participation on the part of the logistic behavior of populations. The capacity for dynamic interaction between population growth rate, generational structure, and intrinsic limits in environmental resources also identifies endogenous and extrinsic components within the logistic component of adaptive capacity, for population and resource, respectively: Endogenous logistic capacity
Extrinsic logistic capacity
Population size, N Intrinsic rate of population increase, r Growth rate Generational structure
Dimensions of the limiting resource, K Size of predator population Size of competitor population
The logistic component of adaptive capacity can thus be seen as a dynamic relationship existing between population size and dimensions of the limiting resource in a minimum model (in reality, usually expanding to include predator/ competitor interactions in addition). Behavior clearly also has a role to play in both logistic and structural mechanisms since the logistic activity of populations is partly a function of behavioral activity. In order to predict patterns of adaptational change, it is thus instructive to view all functional mechanisms as being capacities of the adaptive system and to also consider complementary capacities existing in the external environment. Structure possesses the capacity for function and behavior for niche realization (see Chapter 2). These, along with the logistic component of developmental capacity, identify and define the totality of the adaptive capacity of a gene pool in a dynamic context—and there is a significant dynamic aspect to all of these propensities.
1. ADAPTATION AND THE ADAPTIVE SYSTEM
11
THE LOCUS OF THE ADAPTIVE STATE The concept of fitness is generally understood as relating to some differential in survivorship capacity, comparing one genotype or gene pool to another. Given that such relative states exist, then this must surely link to some absolute state residing in adaptive capacity of a genotype, gene pool, or species. What is ‘‘the adaptive state,’’ and where is it located in the adaptive system?
The Adaptive State Defined Adaptation cannot be explicitly analyzed in the absence of some means of quantification. As a preliminary step in this direction, it will be useful to consider the adaptive state (A) of an individual, population, genotype, gene pool, species, or lineage as being some function of its probability of survival in the context of the adaptive system. This is no more than a first approximation, the significance of which is not evident at first sight. A value of A ⫽ 1.0 must relate to a complex reality, in that some values of A 씮 1.0 might well conceal adaptational strategies with lower long-term survivorship capacity (depending on the relative influence of structural as against logistic components), and indeed this casual observation indicates that A is also a function of time frame! In further investigation of the adaptive state, it is necessary to say that fitness in A must not be misconstrued as constituting a question of maximizing reproduction in a single generation, bearing in mind the necessity of r (intrinsic rate of population increase) being adjusted to avoid ‘‘population crash.’’ Consequently, A as an absolute value for W (fitness) concerns proximity to an optimum, rather than maximum reproductive capacity. The adaptive state must additionally be rationalized as containing contributions A1, A2, . . ., Aj from different elements within the adaptive ensemble (structure–behavior–logistic component–metabolism), and the logistic element in degree of fit between a given genotype and its environment must allow for adjustment in fecundity geared to balancing against ‘‘unavoidable’’ mortality factors. Indeed, it will be shown that the degree to which the logistic component contributes is important to longer term adaptive strategies, as well as to shortterm flexibility. The approximation A ⫽ probability of survival must therefore relate to incidence of stochastic mortality factors in the environment and to the differential contributions made by structure, metabolism, behavior, and logistic capacity in the adaptive strategy as a whole, and some suboptimum structural states may thus be tailored toward a high adaptive state in a gene pool predominantly through logistic capacity (see fundamental versus real adaptive states, Chapter 5). A must indeed be the integral of contributions from all loci; however, the dichotomy between structural and logistic components is the major question concerning ‘‘locus of the adaptive state,’’ in that the logistic component of the adaptive response effectively constitutes ‘‘the buffering zone’’ with respect to possible suboptimal states held in the structural component of adaptive capacity, as a corollary of dynamism in the external environment.
12
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
The Gene Pool as ‘‘Epicenter of the Adaptive State’’ We have already indicated that the gene pool is the most appropriate reference point from which to measure the adaptive state, owing to the dynamic nature of the organism–environment interaction. The adaptive state of a gene pool is determined by the balance between positive and negative survivorship factors—in limiting and other (positive) resource factors, and in a range of mortality factors. Some survivorship factors will be deterministic, some stochastic in nature. Survivorship of the species cannot, however, be determined by the fate of a single individual, other than in terms of its adaptive capacity to perpetuate the genotype, and success may therefore generally require some minimum subset of the gene pool for realization and perpetuation of adaptive capacity. Survivorship of the gene pool as a whole must therefore depend significantly on the logistic component, and the adaptive state should therefore ideally be measured relative to the gene pool, as an ‘‘epicenter of adaptational activity.’’ Since adaptive capacity has been shown to be dynamic, so too must A lie in the gene pool. What matters, in the longer term, is not the probability of survival of an individual in a population, but that of the gene pool itself. Individuals compete to pass their genes to the next generation. For a gene pool to survive in the longer term, a certain proportion of the total gene pool of a species must be maintained in the population due to the variable incidence of niche parameters within a temporospatial matrix and the consequent need for maintenance of variation. At this point, it must be made clear that there must be no confusion between the concepts of gene pool as epicenter of the adaptive state and group selection. The gene pool is perpetuated by repeated genic selection (and not direct biotic adaptation; see Williams, 1966), so far as the per generation input is concerned, and higher level complexity arises in the greater context of the gene pool specifically as a mechanismic corollary of individual selection.* With further reference to the question of ‘‘the unit of adaptation,’’ Wright (1940) held the view that a factor N reflects the effective size of a breeding population, the effectiveness of selection tending to vary inversely with the value of this quantity. The population N is then seen as being greater than, and the deme smaller than, the effective level. Wright analyzed this situation via a factor m (representing genetic migration). However, Simpson (1953) criticized the deme concept/migration hypothesis of Wright, doubting whether m is generally low enough. Nevertheless, any reinterpretation of Wright’s hypothesis in terms of the precise level of N cannot escape the view that the adaptive state is held by the gene pool (albeit for quite different reasons than those proposed by Wright). The significance of the ‘‘minimum subset’’ concept as seen here lies not so much in the effectiveness of selection, as in the survivorship capacity of a lineage as a function of the adaptive state contained by an array of individual genotypes within a population. The minimum subset in question is that capable of perpetuating the gene pool itself, and this constitutes the unit with which to investigate adaptational dynamics in natural populations. * Another view of ‘‘genome selection’’ (Lewontin, 1983) holds that individual genes are not the units of selection, so much as larger units. However, this also must not be interpreted as ‘‘group selection’’ (see Chapter 13).
1. ADAPTATION AND THE ADAPTIVE SYSTEM
13
In this sense then, the gene pool is fully confirmed as constituting ‘‘the locus of the adaptive state’’: The peppered moth Biston betularia demonstrates adaptive capacity as a function of maintenance of the carbonaria gene in the gene pool in regions where this morph holds some selective advantage apparently linked to presence of atmospheric pollution. The gastropod mollusc Cepaea has a more complex polymorphism, involving color and banding traits, that has similarly been shown to be correlated with several environmental variables (see Cockburn, 1991, for a review). Small populations of these species tending to monomorphism may lack sufficient adaptive capacity to cope, either with changing external factors or with migration to a fresh habitat. There is no special reason to assume that the highly visible polymorphisms shown by the above animals are not mirrored in similar structural, metabolic, and behavioral polymorphisms in the vast majority of other species. The Gene Pool and Kin Selection The mechanism of kin selection apparently conflicts with the concept of a minimum subset gene pool in that matings based on kinship may appear to constitute a force favoring genetic uniformity. However, kin selection clearly cannot proceed as a simple linear function of degree of relatedness in the longer term, without incurring a tendency toward inbreeding depression. This merely extends the view that the locus of adaptational activity must be some minimum subset gene pool, to include the maxim that negative components of ‘‘shortsighted’’ selectional activity are balanced by forces positive to longer term maintenance of the adaptive state.* The apparent conflict between kin selection and the gene pool concept will be examined in more depth in the context of the isotropic selection interface (Chapter 4). Gene Pool, Gene Reservoir, and Population Owing to difficulties with the Wright deme concept (see above), it is now advisable to adopt a different nomenclature for components of the total gene pool of a species. The gene pool has been defined as a subset of a larger structure, which latter must ultimately be the species itself. The gene reservoir can now usefully be defined as constituting the genetic complement held by all gene pools of a species within the time frame of a single generation, in which context we could also chose to redefine gene pool as being that minimum subset of the gene reservoir necessary to perpetuate adaptive capacity with respect to a changing external environment, also allowing for the effectiveness of selection. The adaptive state is then more usefully described as being held by the gene pool as a subset of the gene reservoir and superset of the population, and a population is then any natural subset of a gene pool (irrespective of adaptive state) that * The ultra-Darwinist view holds that no supraindividual selectional activity occurs other than through a corollary of individual selection, not that it does not occur at all!
14
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
is spatially (although not necessarily genetically or geographically) isolated from other populations of the same gene pool: Odum (1971) reviewed the contemporary concept of population as comprising a group of organisms of the same species with unique characteristics in density, mortality, age distribution, biotic potential, dispersion, growth form, and fitness; an individual does not have a birth rate, death rate, or age ratio. The gene reservoir will be formed by the sum total of gene pools having the potential for gene flow (although also including geographically discrete ‘‘races’’). The species is thus the gene reservoir in its four-dimensional (lineage) perspective, and it is clearly this larger structure which contains the adaptive potential for further evolution (see Chapter 7).
REALIZATION OF ADAPTIVE CAPACITY AND THE ADAPTIVE RESPONSE Given that adaptive capacity may vary from one generation to the next in terms of gene frequencies, it follows that a quasi-cyclic path is described by movement from capacity to realized response, in terms of the manner in which the allelomorphic component of the genome reacts to different selection regimes in the organism–environment interaction. The process of adaptation occurs through interaction between the population and limiting resource (endogenous adaptive capacity and an extrinsic complement residing in the external environment), and this activity constitutes realization of adaptive capacity. Behavior is thus more explicitly defined as being a significant component of that strategy of integrated activity in the function ensemble through which movement is translated into realization of adaptive capacity, essentially ‘‘the realization function’’ of adaptation. The adaptive response can now be defined as being the altered complement of adaptive capacity following interactivity between the gene pool and environment within the time frame of a single generation, as expressed in a quasicyclic structure connecting adaptive capacity at time t with adaptive response at time t ⫹ 1 with respect to the behavior of a larger dynamic system. The adaptive response thus becomes the next state of adaptive capacity interacting with a subsequent selectional regime (Fig. 3). The adaptive response can therefore be manifested in such phenomena as stasis, dynamic equilibrium, and evolution: In the Cepaea example cited above, different shell color and banding morphs are known to hold the highest selective advantage in different kinds of terrain, and a gene pool subjected to a changing external environment will clearly express a changing sequence of adaptive capacity 씮 response structures from one generation to the next.
The Passive versus Active Adaptive Response There are two different modes of competition between individuals: (1) nonselective or ‘‘passive’’ competition corresponding to the sole influence of the
1. ADAPTATION AND THE ADAPTIVE SYSTEM
15
FIGURE 3 The adaptive response: a–f ⫽ allelomorphic states held by the gene pool, of which a, d, and f are those selected in the generation in question.
(K ⫺ N/K ) factor in the Verhulst equation (see below) and manifesting no functional genetic difference between ‘‘winners’’ and ‘‘losers’’ such as could determine a survivorship differential; and (2) selective or ‘‘active’’ competition, relating to genetic deterministic factors linked to an adaptive differential between individuals: Failure of a pollen grain to reach its target is not ‘‘selection,’’ but adaptational failure—assuming that there is no heritable differential between winners and losers—and competition is thus ‘‘passive’’ in this context. On the other hand, survivorship of the melanic peppered moth relative to the wild type is ‘‘active,’’ since a heritable differential is involved in relation to differential mortality. Realized adaptive capacity thus manifests not only a range of active adaptational mechanisms (the apparently ‘‘true’’ adaptive response), but also passive logistic interactions between populations belonging to the same adaptive system.
16
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
The adaptive response can now be defined more explicitly as any change in adaptive capacity due to differential mortality, whether passive or active, heritable or nonheritable, selectional or nonselectional in origin. This excludes only purely stochastic survivorship factors, which cannot be said to be part of adaptation at any level. Realization of adaptive capacity thus incorporates much activity in the adaptive response, in terms of the purely passive logistic behavior of populations. It is axiomatic that changes in population size (N ) due to mortality with no complement in heritable adaptational differential constitute a passive response within adaptive systems and thus relate to maintenance of, rather than change in, the adaptive state of a gene pool. It is clearly only with active responses that we identify that component expressed by selected logistic changes or through changes in structure and behavior—and it is also with the active adaptive response that we may encounter true evolutionary change. The respective influences of passive and active competition are further analyzed with respect to evolutionary rate in Chapter 18.
‘‘Stasis’’ and the Passive Response The inclusion of ‘‘stasis’’ in the adaptive process seems intrinsically unlikely. However, the latter seemingly prima facie conclusion is based on a misunderstanding of the nature both of adaptation and of stasis, since the primary objective of adaptation is simply maintenance of the adaptive state, dynamic change being a corollary arising from encounter with a changing external environment. Similarly, the concept of species stasis cannot be taken to exclude dynamic activity in the passive logistic component of adaptive capacity (see Chapter 19). Maintenance of stasis is a thus a passive dynamic process so far as the logistic component of adaptive capacity is concerned. The notion that dynamism may be restricted to passive logistic activity in the adaptive system may, however, be an illusion. Many variables expressing apparent ‘‘genetic unity’’ manifest phenotype plasticity as a result of varying environmental influences interacting with the genotype, and genetic variation is probably always maintained in a large number of gene alleles (probably including those affecting fecundity and thus, also, controllant to an active logistic adjustability of populations). This scenario may then generally incorporate much dynamism in the structural component of adaptation in relation to changing gene frequencies associated with polymorphism. Whether ‘‘stasis’’ in the sense of genetic stability is in any way a realistic concept is a question that will be explored further in Chapters 5 and 19.
Dynamic Equilibrium versus Evolution in the Adaptive Response The architecture of the adaptive response is clearly linked to certain reference time frames, since a trait exhibiting apparent stasis may in fact represent one stage in a larger trend when seen in the perspective of longer term evolution: thus, over n generations, the broad picture emerging of the adaptive response will be as follows:
17
1. ADAPTATION AND THE ADAPTIVE SYSTEM
Maintenance role: stasis Dynamic role: adaptive equilibrium Evolution
Including passive logistic change Active logistic or structural change, generally involving quasi-cyclic changes in gene frequencies Active structural change, often acting in noncyclic mode, sometimes manifesting very long-term directionality
The adaptive response is thus expressed in the phenotypic variance of a gene pool or population, following realization of adaptive capacity (excluding the effects of stochastic processes), and it represents any arbitrarily chosen reference frame within the quasi-cyclic realization of adaptive capacity. Adaptive equilibrium between organism and environment (rather than true evolutionary activity) may thus form a very significant part of this (see Chapter 5).
THE ADAPTIVE SYSTEM CONCEPT We have already identified several of the principal components of a biotic adaptive system in the preceding discussion. How are the various mechanisms of the adaptive ensemble linked in an interactive manner in the context of the greater adaptive system, and what are the principal coordinates of the behavior of such systems?
The Adaptive System Defined The adaptive system incorporates all parameters of the niche of any chosen reference point gene pool, inclusive of both direct and indirect links to other trophic levels (primary and secondary consumers, competitors, etc.) and to the abiotic component of the external environment, excluding only stochastic interactions. It also encompasses the adaptive capacity and potential of all constituent gene pools, which latter thus form an integral part of the adaptive system: Following Frank (1996), an adaptive system satisfies the three conditions of natural selection. The inclusive entities vary, there is a heritability factor, and there is differential success. Information decay will occur in the system if mutation is too frequent, and the genetic system has to be capable of creating complex form from a limited set of instructions. The adaptive system thus explicitly describes interactivity between organism and environment on a multitiered basis, thereby incorporating endogenous and extrinsic components of the interaction between organism and environment within a single structure.
Toward an Equation Set of the Adaptive System In any biosystematological approach to the study of evolution we must consider the behavior of equations describing logistic and structural inputs to the adaptive system. Of these equations, the logistic component can readily be understood from the Verhulst equation.
18
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
The equation set of an adaptive system has to describe the various aspects of adaptive capacity, and it must therefore contain adjustable, interactive variables capable of maintaining a specific range of values in response to feedback mechanisms operating between interacting populations and between organic and abiotic resources. This ‘‘adjustability factor’’ therefore clearly brings the equations of population genetics into the equation set, and the essential nuclei of this larger equation set must lie in a relationship between the genetic equations in question and the familiar Verhulst and Lotka–Volterra equations. The Rate of Increase, r, in Adaptive Capacity The nature of the structural component of adaptive capacity is perhaps most overtly evident in allelomorphic variation within that domain. However, the role of the logistic component must form a significant component of any equation modeling the behavior of adaptive systems. The logistic component of adaptation is clearly part of r as expressed in the Verhulst equation, and r is, furthermore, most definitely capable of structural adjustment through deterministic activity within the genome itself. The ‘‘backbone of the adaptive system’’ must therefore lie in its logistic structure, in that genes do not have the capacity to provide dynamic change other than in the context of interaction between populations and the external environment. In this interaction then, logistic activity must play a lead role in the dynamic relationship between components of the system. The Verhulst equation illustrates logistic activity in a simple dynamic system with two variables, N and K, with N being dependent on K in a density dependent manner in the context of a negative feedback loop: dN/dt ⫽ rN(K ⫺ N)/K Passive logistic activity in the adaptive system is thus explicit in (K ⫺ N)/K in the above equation. This passive response can clearly be demonstrated when there is no genetic variation in a population, or when variation is not a factor involved in competition. The Verhulst equation thus serves to define a major part of the functioning adaptive system in terms of purely passive logistic activity, and it also takes a first step toward description of the active adaptive response in terms of the genetic component, since r must possess an essential adjustability in the face of variation in K. The model for an adaptive system must clearly contain a larger set of interacting equations, of which the Verhulst equation forms the central core in expressing logistic dynamics of (N ) population with limiting resource (K ). An organic dynamic system can, however, only become a true adaptive system through initial adjustment at the lowest variable pair (the abiotic resource with K, the carrying capacity of the external environment), which means that the abiotic resource must also be cyclically replenishable as a component of the dynamic system. The logistic aspect of adaptation is thus ideally expressed in a minimum model by the Verhulst equation, extended to include a differential which is in turn a function of the interaction between organic populations and an abiotic cycle. K and the Extrinsic Component of Adaptive Capacity As we have just seen, the logistic behavior of adaptive systems is expressed, not only in r, but also in K. The organic element in K must be some function
1. ADAPTATION AND THE ADAPTIVE SYSTEM
19
of available energy resources, jointly determined by extrinsic adaptive capacity in the environment and by endogenous adaptive capacity of the consumer gene pool. K is thus not merely some intrinsic property of the external environment, but is partly determined by the gene pool in its interaction with the limiting resource. It must also be pointed out at this stage that K is not confined to the energy resource of a gene pool, but additionally contains parameters relating to other density dependent interactions, including, for example, abiotic resources such as shelter and hiding places. The K factor is thus a heterogeny, some part of which may be prone to stochastic influences, and variation in K may thus serve to introduce a measure of instability into a dynamic system of this kind. Nucleus of the Structural Component of Adaptive Capacity The Lotka–Volterra equations describing interaction between competing populations suggest how a biotic adaptive system must differ from a simple dynamic one, when one considers the organic basis for differentiation between two genotypes in terms of relative adaptive states. This equation set thus clearly also encompasses the input from the structural component of adaptation into the equation set of the adaptive system (albeit in rudimentary fashion), in that the 움 factors in the Lotka–Volterra equations are clearly based on genotypic differentials rather than being determined by mere passive logistic behavior: dN1/dt ⫽ rn1 ⫻ N1 ⫻ (K ⫺ N1 ⫺ 움21 ⫻ N2)/K dN2/dt ⫽ rn2 ⫻ N2 ⫻ (K ⫺ N2 ⫺ 움12 ⫻ N1)/K Most significantly, the Lotka–Volterra equations describe not only passive logistic activity, but also the interaction between the logistic component of adaptation and adjustability in the structural sector, therefore becoming transformed in the role of wider equations of adaptivity. The Lotka–Volterra equations do not describe adaptation directly, but this is nevertheless implicit in their relationship to the structural component of adaptive capacity. Certain implicit factors also identify adaptivity in the Verhulst and Lotka– Volterra equations by virtue of inferred capacity to counteract instability, manifested in adaptive capacity for • Adjustability of r in the face of variation in K • Adjustability of the 움 factors as indices of competitiveness (see also Chapter 4) Some portion of the active adjustability component is thus seen as being implicit in r, with reference to the genetic determination of fecundity and/or longevity. Hence r is also closely linked to adaptive strategy (see below), just as other components of the adaptive system (including the spectrum of genetic variation in the gene pool with respect to behavior, structure, and metabolism) are likewise ‘implicit’ in the 움 factors. The above equations describe fundamental inputs to adaptive capacity and also identify the extrinsic domain in the latter. However, the true adaptive response must be explicit in some as yet unexplored relationship between the Lotka–Volterra equations and those of population genetics. What that
20
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
relationship is, and why it is of great significance for an understanding of adaptation and evolution, will be explored at a later stage. The Adaptive State in the Verhulst Equation It may appear at first sight that the Verhulst model incorporates logistic interactions which encounter no active capacity for any heritable adaptive response, hence describing purely passive survivorship factors. However, this is due to the artificiality of the logistic equation itself. In reality, delayed responses generally occur in the logistic equation, as incorporated, for example, in the Hutchinson model (1948) and in other, more realistic equations. This property was studied further by Wangersky and Cunningham (1956, 1957), who identified two kinds of time lags: time needed to start increasing when conditions are favorable (t ⫺ t1) and time required to react to unfavorable conditions (t ⫺ t2). Hutchinson equation: dN/dt ⫽ rNt(K ⫺ Nt⫺T )/K
(t ⫺ T expressing time shift)
Wangersky and Cunningham equation: dN(t)/dt ⫽ rN(t⫺t1)(K ⫺ N(t⫺t2))/K In the above equations, density overshoots and oscillates with decreasing amplitude in time, and this is thought to be a common behavior of real populations in Nature. May (1974) has shown also that when the artificialities of the Verhulst and Lotka–Volterra differential equations are replaced by equivalent difference equations describing a more realistic system in which generational structure is taken into account, characteristic oscillations appear in the graph of population growth, and these may approach chaos for certain configurations of the variables in question. Similarly, in the Hassell equation (see Hassell, 1976, and elsewhere), time delay is implicit in the context of discrete generations modeled by a difference equation which also describes the effects of extremes of contest to scramble competition on the basis of a parameter, b: Xt⫹1 ⫽ er Xt(1 ⫹ aXt) ⫺
b
X ⫽ N in successive generations
A sample output for a time delay equation should be compared with the usual logistic curve, as shown in Fig. 4. Following the more realistic models of population growth that have been proposed (and particularly in view of the likely prospect of stochastic variation occurring with respect to K itself !), it is clear that fecundity must be adjusted in order to avoid population crash. The adaptive state can thus be described in this context as ‘‘probability of survival in ongoing dynamic equilibrium of N.’’ If we consider the K씮N interaction to be an oscillatory or chaotic one, then the probability of survival (given an element of stochasticity in K ) becomes a function of the tendency for the periodicity of N to reach zero. It is thus evident that chaotic (rather than stochastic) interactions constitute that force demanding a variable adaptive response within the domain of adaptive capacity. The above, of course, only relates to the logistic component of activity in the adaptive system. However, a parallel element must nevertheless be significant in
1. ADAPTATION AND THE ADAPTIVE SYSTEM
21
FIGURE 4 Logistic curve following the Verhulst differential equation (left) compared to (right) an oscillatory trend based on a difference equation describing the discrete generations situation (Hassell equation).
determining A as a function of other components of adaptive capacity also (see Chapter 5). If the Verhulst equation can be linked to probability of survival in the logistic component of adaptation, then the same must consequently be true for the structural component as reflected in the Lotka–Volterra equations for competing genotypes, and very many facets of adaptive capacity may be linked to chaotic behavior of the external environment in a similar manner. Likewise, there may be rare events in which logistic bottlenecks may also tend to create the necessary substrate for novel evolutionary change (see Chapters 14 and 18).
Major and Minor Selectional Attractors in the Adaptive System Perhaps the most important property of dynamic systems from the viewpoint of evolving organic adaptive systems lies in a tendency to gravitate toward some particular type of behavior through possession of some intrinsic propensity for adjustment. The behavior toward which such systems gravitate is the attractor of the system. An attractor is, for example, easily identified in the behavior of the Verhulst equation, in that similar equilibrium states arise from various configurations of initial conditions. Of considerably greater interest is the concept of a selectional attractor defined by an optimized state toward which biotic adaptive systems gravitate as a function of variation in the input variables to dynamic interactions between individuals and gene pools, a propensity which must be clearly implicit in the 움 factors of the Lotka–Volterra equation set. Following on from the concept of a selectional attractor, it is of interest at this point to consider whether or not there may perhaps be two fundamental entities of that kind operating in natural adaptive systems: a major selectional attractor in the structural adaptive response and a minor selectional attractor in the logistic domain. This hierarchy would appear perhaps to be indicated from evidence already discussed concerning the relative influence of structural versus logistic components of the adaptive ensemble, and this speculative question can be taken up in greater detail as we progress with the present analysis.
22
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
In this context, orientation of the adaptive ensemble (see p. 6) must also be linked to the major–minor attractors theory, in connection with the question as to whether the leading adaptational function lies in the logistic versus structural component of adaptation. Here, we shall also be examining the question of the optimum balance between these two inputs.
The Reciprocity Principle in Adaptive Systems Adaptation can be analyzed through the organism–niche interaction in the analysis of a larger adaptive system, and a subject gene pool can be chosen as a convenient reference point for analysis of the state of adaptation (for example, a single consumer species interacting with a producer resource, so that other consumers are either competitors or predators in relation to that reference frame). The object resource is then the next lowest trophic level relative to the subject gene pool, forming the latter’s limiting resource. These terms constitute useful reference points when we come to define adaptive system, niche, and environment, and to analyze certain aspects of evolutionary activity, and we have in fact already adopted a similar approach in designation of N and K in the Verhulst equation. Designation of ‘‘subject’’ (N ) and ‘‘object’’ (K ) gene pools allows analysis of the adaptive state of any chosen genotype, population, or gene pool with respect to the relative contributions of structural and logistic activity and in terms of the entire adaptive system. Implicit in this relationship, however, is the observation that ‘‘adjustability’’ should not be seen as a propensity possessed solely by our chosen N point of interest, but as a feature capable of reciprocal adjustment at other points in the adaptive system also. From this, we arrive at the reciprocity principle, which states that there is generally a reciprocal adaptive response between gene pools of an adaptive system which interact at a mutual adaptation interface. Accordingly, it is easy to see that the adaptation interface itself is in fact a reciprocal structure that can be analyzed from any chosen reference point. Looking at the reciprocity principle more closely, we can observe, for example, that the Lotka–Volterra equations for predator–prey interaction can be stabilized by modulation of the intrinsic rate of increase of prey or, alternatively, by adjusting the behavior of a predator. And it is predictable that both adjustments may tend to evolve alternately in temporal sequence during the course of longer term evolutionary activity. It must therefore be one fundamental axiom of adaptive systems that change in any adaptational parameter of a predator species has the reciprocal effect of changing the adaptive state of its prey, so favoring some reciprocal change that might otherwise not have been selectively positive. This same principle, of course, applies in the relationship between consumer and limiting resource, etc. Specialization and Reciprocity It has already been suggested above that the structural component of adaptation also possesses the adaptive capacity for reciprocally generated activity, so that a reciprocal adaptive response may thus occur in either the logistic or structural component of adaptation. The reciprocal structural adaptive re-
1. ADAPTATION AND THE ADAPTIVE SYSTEM
23
sponse may also be either positive or negative with respect to the subject–object interaction. The reciprocal logistic response between two gene pools thus also constitutes that force acting to favor reciprocal adaptation in the structural domain, leading thus to specialization, which latter propensity can clearly only be expressed in the organic component of the adaptive ensemble and not in the logistic. The term specialization is thus seen to be concerned with limitation to degrees of freedom in function. Any tendency for specialization in a gene pool thus creates selectional drive favoring reciprocal specialization in its organic limiting resource—and also in any higher trophic level for which the gene pool in question is itself a limiting resource: Modulation of floral structure correlated with haustellum elongation in a nectar feeding moth species is an example of a positive reciprocal adaptive response in the structural domain, whereas acquisition of toxic tissues in a plant species would constitute a negative adaptive response in the limiting resource with respect to consumer activity. The adaptive response is thus fundamentally complex in nature. The reciprocal adaptive response is most overtly manifested in a variety of symbiotic and mutualistic species interactions, reflected in all domains of the adaptive ensemble—not only in logistics, but also in behavior, structure, and metabolism. However, from the adaptive system concept, all biotic adaptation is fundamentally coadaptive, despite the fact that this may often be confined to the logistic dimension; taking any subject and object pair in an adaptive system with an adaptive state of x, there will always be a contribution to that state from both subject and object population, even if only in the logistic dimension. Specialization and reciprocity are, however, only ‘‘inextricably linked’’ when there is adaptive potential (see Chapter 7) for reciprocal specialization to achieve this end. In summary, although adaptational activity can be analyzed with respect to any set of chosen reference points, the viewpoint from the adaptive system concept indicates a fundamental reciprocity in the adaptive response. Gene pool–environment interactions clearly express such reciprocity, and the adaptive state can be measured from any reference point within the system, depending on the particular focus of interest. ‘‘Subject’’ and ‘‘object’’ express reciprocity over the hierarchy of trophic levels, in that the ‘‘subject of interest’’ may also be the object with reference to some higher trophic level in the same adaptive system, and this interchangeability reflects the reciprocal nature of interacting adaptational mechanisms. The Reciprocity Principle in the Logistic Domain It is instructive to consider in slightly more detail how the reciprocity principle affects the logistic component of adaptation. The adaptive response in N is driven by the effect of (K ⫺ N)/K on rN. A reciprocal response in K could thus constitute an increase in dK/dt, relative to pressure from the N population. A simple reciprocal adaptive response can therefore be expressed in the Verhulst equation in avoidance of dangerously chaotic population interactions:
24
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
The oak (Quercus) has a spring regenerative growth which seems to be an adaptive response that is specifically linked to the very high levels of attack from several extremely abundant geometrid moth species which hatch from eggs in early spring. Increased production of regenerative foliage while at the same time protecting reproductive tissues is an example of a complex response in the limiting resource, involving both negative and positive adaptive responses. This reciprocal aspect of adaptational activity can be explained as follows. The logistic attractor (the state dN/dt ⫹ dK/dt ⫽ 0) is the state toward which adaptive systems must constantly tend, since if subject and object do not become reciprocally adapted, the system may become unstable and collapse. The reciprocity solution, as in, ‘‘Regeneration in K increased with protection of reproductive tissues,’’ is more stable than the scenario, ‘‘Consumer kills K,’’ and this situation may also entail a reciprocal adaptive response in the subject gene pool (for example, to consume regenerative and not reproductive parts): Dobzhansky (1970) discussed the evolution of pesticide resistance in Australian rabbit populations in relation to the pathogenic myxoma virus. The rabbits evolved resistance to the myxomatosis virus, and the virus also evolved the capacity not to kill the host. The reciprocity of much adaptational activity with respect to interactions between gene pools not only again confirms adaptive capacity as being a property of the whole adaptive system but also serves to underline the significance of the logistic behavior of such systems. It is axiomatic that, whatever the ‘‘polarity’’ of reciprocity appears to be from any chosen reference point, it has to be positive with respect to the adaptive state of the whole system. It is also true for evolutionary analysis in general that the adaptive response will tend toward a fundamental reciprocity for all constituent gene pools of an adaptive system. The response in question may be structural or logistic, active or passive—and it can be either phenoplastic or genetic in nature. For any given trophic level then, there may thus be some adaptive response (heritable or otherwise) that is linked to survivorship factors arising in the next inferior trophic level to equivalent or superior levels. Linking the concept of trophic levels to that of adaptive capacity and the adaptive state, it will be useful to propose an appropriate adjustment to the usual terminology: an enhancer (in contradistinction to a depressor or consumer) tends to raise the adaptive state of an interacting gene pool (as with ant species that cultivate certain insects or plants or in human agriculture, etc.). In this context, the principle of reciprocity is clearly confined (a) to the biotic component of adaptive systems and (b) to that situation where two gene pools act directly as depressors or enhancers in relation to each other. These differentials are also implicit in the 움 factors of the Lotka–Volterra equations, for any system which reaches stable mutual equilibrium. From the above, the logistic behavior of populations can be analyzed from the total complement of the following: primary logistic mortality factors arising from intraspecific competition linked to inferior trophic levels; secondary factors, from interspecific factors (competition at equivalent trophic level); and tertiary factors, from predation, at a superior trophic level(s).
1. ADAPTATION AND THE ADAPTIVE SYSTEM
25
The complete adaptive system is the sum of all gene pools interacting with the subject population and its object resource, thus including all equivalent and superior trophic level gene pools, however interlinked within the system. In conclusion, the ‘‘orientation’’ of any equation expressing activity within a larger adaptive system depends on our chosen reference point within a fundamentally reciprocal structure. The Domain of Coevolution Van Valen (1973) views the evolutionary fate of a species as depending on what is happening simultaneously to all other species in the same ecological setting, proposing that coevolution may comprise most of evolution (van Valen, 1984): ‘‘Coevolution occurs when the direct or indirect interaction of two or more evolving units produces an evolutionary response in each.’’ At a later stage (Chapter 20), we shall examine these hypotheses more closely. At the present stage, it will be sufficient to point out that, as already stated above, reciprocal adaptation can only relate to the biotic component in adaptive systems, and that much evolutionary change is clearly linked to the abiotic domain.*
MAIN POINTS FROM CHAPTER 1 1. Many important aspects of evolution arise as emergent corollaries of primary mechanisms and processes, rather than being direct outputs of either. 2. Adaptation (as propensity for survivorship) is the fundamental process underlying the behavior of natural biotic systems. 3. Organisms can be deemed to hold adaptive capacity by virtue of stable states of structure, behavior, and metabolism, as also in their allelomorphic genetic makeup. 4. Adaptive capacity has both extrinsic and endogenous components. The former lie in the external environment and the latter are held by that suite of endogenous mechanisms forming the function ensemble (behavior, structure, and metabolism), including also the logistic capacity of the genotype. 5. Realization of adaptive capacity occurs at the adaptation interface between organism and external environment. In this mechanism, we also observe the fundamentally dynamic nature of adaptive capacity. 6. A quasi-cyclic relationship exists between adaptive capacity and adaptive response. Orientation of the function ensemble forms an important input to this relationship, especially in the extent to which the adaptive response tends to be led by the logistic component. 7. The gene pool constitutes the epicenter of adaptive capacity, as a higher emergent property of selectional interactivity linked to differential survivorship between individuals. The gene pool is in turn a subset of a larger structure, the gene reservoir. * It should also be noted that coevolution can be confused with parallel adaptation, as apparently demonstrated with respect to the top-level predator Dimetrodon in the Carboniferous– Permian in Oklahoma and Texas (Olson, 1983).
26
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
8. The adaptive system holds all direct and indirect connections of the adaptive interface, including the ‘‘subject’’ (point of interest) gene pool itself together with all other gene pools linked to the same interface. 9. The Lotka–Volterra equations contain implicit links with those of population genetics, in modeling the logistic behavior of adaptive systems with respect to adaptive properties held by genetic differentials. 10. Adaptive systems gravitate toward logistic and structural attractors, following dual pathways of dynamic equilibrium and evolution with respect to the structural element. 11. Reciprocal adaptivity is commonly manifested in the biotic domain of an adaptive system.
2
SPATIAL STRUCTURE OF THE ADAPTIVE NICHE
Griesemer (1992) has written a useful historical account of the complex history of the niche concept, of which the following introduction is a brief summary. Grinell (1924 and elsewhere) and Elton (1927, etc.) both saw the niche as being a property of the environment into which species could fit. They proposed the environmental niche concept, within which broad construct Grinell’s version is sometimes called the habitat niche and Elton’s, the functional niche: Niche specificity is exemplified by such examples as the adaptive radiation of cichlid fishes in the Great Lakes of Africa, each species having a distinctive pattern of habitat usage relating to such parameters as depth and feeding resources. Even species with similar niches have been shown from analysis of stomach contents to differ slightly in preferences of algal food (Reinthal and Meyer, 1997). The same situation has been shown to exist in very many other organisms, including the classical example of the geospizine finches studied by Darwin on the Galapagos Islands (see below). The existence of ‘‘ecological equivalents’’ in different phyletic lineages appears perhaps to support the environmental niche perspective; however, this view has lead in turn to the paradox of the ‘‘vacant niche.’’ The concept of a macroniche (on which the ecological equivalents concept is in turn based) clearly relates to adaptive specialization in terms of larger ‘‘environmental’’ niche parameters which tend to express stability in the temporal dimension (higher group limiting resource, aquatic habitat, etc.), a circumstance that is
27
28
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
often reflected in structural convergence between unrelated lineages. The latter observation can be readily misinterpreted as evidence of the existence of ‘‘vacant spaces’’ in adaptive systems. Gause (1934) later brought Elton’s niche concept and the Volterra equations together in the context of the competitive exclusion principle, so bringing the niche concept more into focus with contemporary evolutionary doctrine. Hutchinson (1957, 1965), in turn, further redefined the niche as an attribute of the population or species expressed in relation to its environment, so defining the population niche concept, which held that gene pools do not adapt to a niche, but create actual niche shifts. Hutchinson’s model incorporated all environmental factors acting on organisms, as well as rejecting the earlier concept of the vacant niche. Hutchinson also recognized the existence of a fundamental versus real niche, the former being the niche in the absence of competitors and predators. This model clearly constituted the definition of the niche of a species, rather than of a ‘‘macroniche’’ into which many species could fit, but was nevertheless a static view which did not incorporate variability nor changes in space and time. Hutchinson additionally restated the competitive exclusion principle by saying that realized niches do not intersect, whereas Hardin’s more realistic axiom of inequality (1960) argued that some resource dimension will explain coexistence, so that niches may in fact intersect, provided there is also some element of independent adaptive capacity with respect to competing species: Lack’s study of the Galapagos finches (1947) led him at first to propose nonadaptive differentiation between species, but he later found differences in resource utilization that were clearly correlated with bill size. MacArthur’s work on warblers (see MacArthur and Levins, 1967) also showed avoidance of competition on the slenderest of niche separations. More recent niche theory also concerns some reframing of the competitive exclusion principle. In the model of MacArthur and Levins (1967), emphasis is shifted from the permissive range of environmental conditions to actual resource utilization, thus indicating a more dynamic than static approach as compared with that of Hutchinson. In the following treatment, I have moved away from the strictly ‘‘ecological’’ definition of niche, toward a view more closely bound in with the structure of the adaptive system as a whole. In that sense, we are now effectively dealing with the concept of the adaptive niche.
NICHE AND ADAPTIVE SYSTEM Adaptation is not to the niche, but within the adaptive system as a whole, and this is a reciprocal activity in which there can clearly be no ‘‘vacant niche’’ (see Chapter 1). In this view, the true nature of the adaptive system in relation to the niche now becomes apparent.
2. SPATIAL STRUCTURE OF THE ADAPTIVE NICHE
29
The Adaptive Niche Defined To look more deeply into the adaptive niche concept, it is instructive to continue to examine points of interest in an adaptive system through the medium of a chosen subject gene pool. Following this approach, we can identify two domains within the adaptive system which might be said to jointly form the niche of the subject gene pool: 1. The major adaptive niche, linked directly or indirectly to the limiting resource 2. The minor niche, lying in that reciprocal interface for which the subject is itself the ‘‘object resource’’ for other gene pools, the latter domain furthermore containing any competitor gene pools sharing the same resource
FIGURE 5 Minor and major adaptive niche: subject ⫽ point of interest gene pool; object ⫽ limiting resource of subject gene pool.
The simplified scheme of Fig. 5 merely represents the trophic system, and not the whole of the direct interface between subject gene pool and adaptive system. In addition, the abiotic plane encompasses such parameters as temperature, pH, hiding places, and substrate, some of which latter are linked to the biotic plane and some not.
30
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
In the above system, the total adaptive niche is simply the locus of first level contact between gene pool and adaptive system. This is defined by direct interaction between organism and external environment and is manifested in the adaptation interface, inclusive of the reciprocal aspect in activity of other gene pools of equivalent and superior trophic levels. We can now see also that the adaptation interface of a gene pool is formed by the adaptive niche plus the gene pool itself (alternatively, the adaptive niche is the adaptive interface minus the subject gene pool, and is essentially the same thing as the extrinsic component of adaptive capacity; see Chapter 1).
FIGURE 6 The adaptive niche in the context of the wider adaptive system.
The Major and Minor Adaptive Niche Colwell and Fuentes (1975) attempted to include predation, parasitism, mutualistic interactions, and competition in their niche concept, although this view has not received wide acceptance. In the scheme presented above, competitors and predators do not form part of the object niche of a gene pool; nevertheless, they hold secondary status as part of the adaptive system ‘‘orbit’’ of a chosen subject gene pool. In this system, shelter from predation (as a component of K ) clearly forms part of the major adaptive niche, whereas predators or competitors to which there is some element of adjustment in adaptive capacity belong to the minor niche domain (as indeed would be assumed from the Lotka–Volterra equations, as well as following the reciprocity principle; see Chapter 1). The major adaptive niche thus forms the system nucleus and is an
2. SPATIAL STRUCTURE OF THE ADAPTIVE NICHE
31
active adaptational goal, while the minor niche belongs to the ‘‘system orbit’’ and is essentially ‘‘passive’’ in adaptational terms (notwithstanding the input from adaptational reciprocity which may be invoked). The major niche can thus be seen as ‘‘attracting,’’ while the minor niche ‘‘repels.’’ The adaptive response is ultimately to both major and minor adaptive niches; however, the passive (logistic) response may often predominate with respect to the latter: Clear evidence of the influence of the minor niche in provoking a structural adaptive response is seen in situations in which it is absent, as, for example, in the fresh colonization of remote islands. Evolutionary trends observed in such situations include such adaptive shifts as that toward dropped seeds from plants with ancestors utilizing a windborne strategy, a tendency toward loss of flight in winged animals, and a reduced dispersal propensity in general (see Grant, 1998). Having decided which parameters do and do not belong to the adaptive niche, it is now necessary to consider scalar aspects of the model. A large weakness in the Hutchinson system clearly lies in its reliance on quantitative dimensions, whereas many important niche parameters are clearly defined by such qualitative traits as taxonomic category of limiting resource, and so on. In this sense, the Hutchinson model appears biased toward the abiotic, and the Elton–Grinell models toward the biotic (qualitative) plane, and a general model thus clearly needs to incorporate all of these parameters. The solution to this problem lies in considering the real spatial distribution of both quantitative and qualitative parameters. Niche parameters can, of course, have no fixed Cartesian coordinates in space or time, and we must therefore begin by plotting the intersect of all niche-directed behavior cycle activity in real space, extrapolating from this to a generalization based on all included qualitative and quantitative information. The adaptive niche is then the intersect of all parameter defined volumes, and its dynamic structure is expressed in the fourth (temporal) dimension. Finally, it is necessary also to abstract volume intersects from real space, so that the latter becomes, in effect, ‘‘parameter space’’; it is a ‘‘generalized real space,’’ rather than any localized subset of the same: The adaptive niche of a typical holometabolous insect obviously manifests a temporal sequence, comparing niche parameters of larva with those of adult. Some of these parameters will be quantitative (for example, relative humidity), whereas others will be qualitative in nature (range of food plants, part of plant eaten, etc.).
Fundamental versus Real Adaptive Niche The fundamental adaptive niche as hereby defined (and not sensu Hutchinson; see above) comprises all niche space for which adaptive capacity resides in the gene pool, whereas the real niche constitutes that component of the fundamental niche that is actually realized by a gene pool or population in the course of a single generation. With many dynamic niche parameters it is probable that there will be a large and variable differential between fundamental and real
32
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
adaptive niche, owing to the influence of stochastic factors in the adaptive system, and it is also likely that greater levels of dynamism will appertain to minor than to major niche parameters. The true adaptive niche is thus viewed here as a partially dynamic structure, tending toward the fundamental state as a function of dynamic equilibrium between organism and environment. This (along with the incorporation of both scalar and taxonomic dimensions) unites the Grinell–Elton, Hutchinson, and MacArthur–Levins models, also removing the typological element inherent to some interpretations.
Niche Interface and Environment Realized adaptation (as distinct from the broader domain of adaptive capacity) occurs at the adaptation interface, which contains the loci in time and space of all deterministic organism–environment interactions manifesting an effect on survivorship (see Chapter 1). This concept allows the temporospatial loci of niche and of selectional activity to be defined explicitly, an appreciation of the nature of each functional interface being essential to an understanding of the evolutionary behavior of adaptive systems. Here, we can also locate the niche interface, which contains any adaptation interface space external to the subject gene pool—including not only the limiting resource of the same, but all first contact spatial parameters in the adaptive system of a subject gene pool with the capacity to be manifested in deterministic survivorship factors in the external environment. Following clarification of the domain of the adaptive niche, the environment of a gene pool can now be explicitly defined as containing all interactive resources external to the gene pool itself, including stochastic survivorship and mortality factors (Fig. 7): The niche interface for a phytophagous insect species comprises the subject gene pool itself, its major niche (food plant) and minor niche (regular competitors, predators, and parasites). Its environment additionally includes sporadic predation, stochastic climatic effects, unpredictable geophysical events, and so on.
SPATIAL ARCHITECTURE OF THE ADAPTIVE NICHE At the epicenter of the niche interface lie those loci at which actual changes to K and N occur. However, the adaptive niche is obviously regarded as also containing more remote parameters such as general environmental cues which allow location of the limiting resource (including abiotic factors in temperature, humidity, pH, etc.). These broader horizons clearly lie in a probability gradient in terms of determination of capacity for survivorship, the adaptive state being affected directly or indirectly according to position of niche parameter in some hierarchic structure. A large question relating to the architecture of niche space thus lies with the varying functional role of different components of the niche interface in the way in which these reflect the link between structure, behavior, and function in the context of realization of adaptive capacity. In this respect, the central question now lies in the nature of the hierarchical structure of the niche as a dynamic entity. In this, we see the adaptational process itself manifested in a sequence of events, rather than in a single activity.
2. SPATIAL STRUCTURE OF THE ADAPTIVE NICHE
33
FIGURE 7 The niche interface as a subset of the adaptation interface.
Behavior and the Hierarchic Structure of Niche Space Behavior has already been cited as having a leading role to play in realization of adaptive capacity (see Chapter 1), effectively constituting the realization function for niche. In the latter role, behavior should then also reflect the hierarchical organization of niche space. Firstly, it is essential to see that behavior not only directly affects positive survivorship, but it also has a crucial role to play in counteracting mortality in the adaptive system. An adequate analysis of niche space must therefore be concerned with the function of behavioral activity in relation to all survivorship factors, and not merely around the immediate boundaries of the limiting resource. We therefore need to categorize behavioral activity in terms of both direct and indirect functions in relation to the K and r factors in the equation set of the adaptive system (see Chapter 1). Certain of the generalizations that can be made regarding the role of behavior in niche realization are clearly of wider relevance to higher animals, especially because of the lack of a ‘‘central office’’ directing activity in the plant kingdom (Stebbins, 1988). The Behavior–Niche Link and the Adaptive Orientation Strategy Hierarchy Behavioral activity is quasi-cyclic when viewed in relation to realization of adaptive capacity, and this is most clearly explicit in the central structure of behavior in its role as realization function for adaptive capacity. This structure, which may be referred to as the adaptive orientation strategy hierarchy, lies
34
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
in the trajectory of activity leading through kinetic 씮 taxic 씮 processive behavioral activity, where processive refers to the process of adaptation, equivalent to, for example, a sought limiting resource or predator to avoid. The processive element thus constitutes behavior involved in direct realization of adaptive capacity (therefore usually affecting ⌬K, r). In this system, kinesis constitutes a response to a stimulus invoking some change in behavior, but no change in orientation, whereas taxis involves some change in directionality, to or from a source of stimulus, and these activities must clearly relate to some other domain of niche space.* Where the major adaptive niche is concerned, we are clearly looking at positive polarity with respect to behavioral activity in general, as distinct from ‘‘behavioral polarity’’ in the usual sense of merely describing orientation relative to the source of stimulus. Here, we are clearly interested solely in polarity relative to probability of realization of adaptive capacity. Evidently, the existing repertoire of behavioral responses must form a key component of adaptive capacity. The ongoing balance between positive and negative behavioral activity will thus constitute an essential part of adaptive capacity with respect to environmental dynamism within the time frame of a generation, and the behavioral component of adaptive capacity must be linked to optimality strategies in that context. That the above repertoire of behavioral responses will tend to be quasicyclic implies that, from each category of activity, we can pass to any other (for example, returning to taxic or kinetic from any processive point), and the turning points between each activity in this cycle must link to stimuli (Fig. 8). What now requires clarification is the relationship between the behavior quasicycle and realization of adaptive capacity in terms of the hierarchy of spatial domains in the niche. In that context, any positive taxis will clearly be toward the major adaptive niche (the limiting resource), and away from the minor (competitors and predators).† In this scheme, kinesis follows the same polarity rule as taxis, some being ‘‘hopeful of locating a positive taxic stimulus,’’ some of avoiding negative interactivity. Clearly the functional hierarchy within the spatial dimension of the adaptive niche must then be identified on the basis of niche realization following a complete positive behavioral trajectory ending in direct adaptational activity (kinesis 씮 taxis 씮 process): The link between behavior and architecture of the adaptive niche can be demonstrated with reference to a parasitic wasp, which will probably display some form of positive kinetic locomotory activity initiated by broad abiotic parameters in the niche of the host’s food plant. This will in turn maximize the probability of detection of more specific clue signals such as odors from the food plant of its host, the latter in turn stimulating taxic behavior (directed locomotion on host’s food plant, probably following a gradient in some external stimulus), finally ending with processive behavior in oviposition into the host. * Transverse orientation also constitutes active orientational behavior, and is here regarded as being taxic in nature. † This identifies an abiotic component in the minor adaptive niche also.
2. SPATIAL STRUCTURE OF THE ADAPTIVE NICHE
35
FIGURE 8 Movement between processive, taxic, and kinetic behavior.
Although the above relationships are perhaps self-evident in the animal kingdom, they are rather less so in plants. However, wind and animals may form the subparametric niche of plants, in links with pollination and seed dispersal—and this at least constitutes ‘‘parataxic behavior’’ (in the same way, some component of phenoplasticity in plant growth may be construed as being ‘‘parakinetic behavior’’). The adaptive niche has already been defined as being circumscribed by the loci of positive deterministic interactions in terms of capacity for survivorship, and these are now seen as constituting those loci in time and space at which behavioral activity manifests some change in probability of survival of the gene pool. These are not merely those loci of adaptational activity at sites of encounter with limiting resources in K, but also include ‘‘indirect’’ behavioral activity leading to the latter, plus ‘‘r-directed’’ behavioral activity lying deeper in the same function chain, so that any behavioral target in the adaptive niche that is not N or K must in fact form part of a function cycle leading to one or other of these categories. All function cycles thus have a processive ‘‘end target’’ or turning point at the effect on K or N defining the niche interface. Processive behavior can thus be linked to either N (oviposition) or to K (for example; feeding), these ‘‘targets’’ being reached through activity in the logistic and structural components of adaptation, respectively.
FIGURE 9 Sequence of functions brought into action through a temporospatial cascade of behavioral activity in the role of niche realization.
36
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
The Niche Space Hierarchy Using the term ‘‘parametric’’ in the sense of a functional boundary to that component within which direct realization of adaptive capacity is contained, the above-mentioned link between the hierarchies expressed by behavioral activity and adaptive niche may be encapsulated through adoption of the following nomenclature: • Parametric niche space, in which K and other direct resources are located, is defined by positive processive behavioral activity directed toward realization of adaptive capacity. • The subparametric component of the adaptive niche is similarly realized through positive taxic behavior, a secondary-level boundary in the tripartite hierarchy with a relatively high probability function for location of parametric niche space. • Hypoparametric niche space is determined via positive kinetic behavior, thus defining the outermost boundary of the adaptive niche in the lowest probability zone for realization of adaptive capacity. Behavior determines niche realization following a hierarchic pattern of activity, and we have now encountered a complementary hierarchy of functional levels in niche space, identified as parametric (the actual sites of adaptational activity) to infraparametric (which latter would collectively include those loci of sub- and hypoparametric niche space converging on parametric niche space loci via a behavioral function chain directed toward change in K or N ). The pathway between different levels in the adaptive niche hierarchy can also be linked to the question of energy flow in the adaptive system.
FIGURE 10 Links between levels in niche space hierarchy and direction of energy flow.
The functional hierarchy in adaptive niche space has now been categorized in concrete terms, utilizing the stimulus ‘‘turning points’’ in behavioral activity to explicitly define each functional domain of niche space: the processive–taxic boundary defining parametric from subparametric, and the taxic–kinetic boundary delimiting hypo- from subparametric niche space. Given that processive, taxic, and kinetic behaviors are also expressed in relation to competitors
2. SPATIAL STRUCTURE OF THE ADAPTIVE NICHE
37
and predators, it follows that the above spatial hierarchy applies to both the major and minor domains of the adaptive niche. Limiting Factors in the Niche Space Hierarchy Within the niche space hierarchy, it is further instructive to investigate the distribution of limiting factors, since there is clearly an overt relationship between category of niche space and locus of the K limit. Following the behavioral quasi-cycle, and from the starting point of a random encounter scenario, there will be a probability gradient for encounter with limiting factors with respect to kinetic, taxic, and processive niche parameters, and this in turn will be linked to a correspondence between category of niche space and trophic level in the adaptive system. Parametric niche space is both finite and reducible, whereas at the other end of the spectrum, hypoparametric niche space may tend toward the status of being infinite and nonreducible. Bearing this in mind, the probability of a limiting factor being encountered in a given niche space domain will be approximately inversely proportional to the dimensions of that domain in real space. A large proportion of behavioral activity in kinetic or taxic niche space will thus come into the category of ‘‘function expressed, but no adaptation interface actually encountered,’’ and much of this exploratory activity will relate to large spatial dimensions within the abiotic environment. However, it is important to see that some component of sub- or hypoparametric niche space may also hold a limiting factor, since the same resource can be limiting at high population densities and not at low. In this respect, status in the niche space hierarchy must be linked to optimum population density, to which both logistic and behavioral components of adaptive capacity will tend to be adjusted (accordingly, any attempted typological view of the adaptive niche must consider this dynamic aspect most carefully!).
FIGURE 11 Probability pyramid for size of spatial dimension and probability of encounter with K limit within the niche space hierarchy (links to trophic levels also indicated).
38
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
The main points of the above discussion can be summarized in tabular form: Category of niche space
Category of behavioral activity
Role in equations of population dynamics
Principal direction of energy flow
Probability of holding the K limit
Parametric Subparametric Hypoparametric
Processive Taxic Kinetic
⌬K or ⌬N Usually indirect Usually indirect
In Out Out
High Low Rarely
Thus, hypoparametric niche space seldom holds the K limit, subparametric sometimes does so, and parametric niche space is generally the focus for the activity of limiting factors in the adaptive niche. Parametric Niche Space Processive behavior lies at those spatial parameters in the adaptive system at which there is capacity for energy exchange or for mortality avoidance (capacity for increment in N or for avoidance of decrement to N ), and this defines parametric niche space explicitly. Parametric niche space will thus be described by at least one parameter related to energy exchange, reproduction, or mortality avoidance sites in the normal limiting resource, where such activities carry a direct function in modulating K or N. This level in the niche space hierarchy is thus ultimately definable as a spatial locus containing some limiting resource that is described by survivorship-directed processive behavior linked to direct manifestation of adaptation, taking into account both major and minor niche: Returning to the example of the parasitic wasp, the host species (or host range) of a particular parasite species clearly forms part of its parametric niche space. Parametric niche space is obviously important for the principle of reciprocal specialization, since it is generally trophic behavior which manifests the greatest degree of mutual evolutionary change between closely interacting gene pools of an adaptive system (see below). It is also the locus of the equation set of the adaptive system (see Chapter 1) for most ambient selectional activity. The situation in which other categories of niche space may enter these equations is best understood in terms of nonregular upward fluctuations in population density (or in the context of adaptive shifts; see Chapters 17–19). Subparametric Niche Space Subparametric niche space is realized through the function of positive taxic (search) behavior, in that it tends to lie ‘‘below’’ the actual sites of change in K or N in the context of ambient population densities. This category is nevertheless directed toward the location of parametric niche space, thus holding some probability function for survivorship activity. Abiotic niche space may also come into this domain: The limiting resource of a parasitic wasp’s host species may often form the subparametric niche space of the parasite itself, given that visual or olfactory stimuli from that source may be involved in host detection.
2. SPATIAL STRUCTURE OF THE ADAPTIVE NICHE
39
The hyperparasitic wasp Pseudorhyssa searches for the oviposition borings of its host, Rhysella, the primary parasite of a wood-boring sawfly larva. Species of the ichneumonid genus Ophion tend to have several host species, but these tend to be linked to a particular microhabitat such as larvae of arboreal host species (Brock, 1981a). Hypoparametric Niche Space Hypoparametric niche space is that component of niche space corresponding to positive kinetic behavior in the niche realization function, as defined by the nondirectionalized activity of kinetic behavior. This mechanism is linked to the domain of a function cycle leading to modulation of K or N via an increase in the probability of encounter with taxic stimulus points. Taxic behavior is clearly deterministic in nature by virtue of being confined to a certain subset of the environment, and thus we may feel confident in attaching this category of ‘‘adaptation space’’ to the niche itself: Continuing with the example of the hyperparasitic wasp Pseudorhyssa and host (see above), certain biotic factors linked to the distribution space of the host’s own limiting resource (trees of the genera Betula and Alnus) might offer a suitable pabulum for some form of taxic response, so constituting the hypoparametric niche space of the parasite. Taxic behavior is thus performed within certain definable boundaries intrinsic to the adaptive system. The primary goals of behavioral activity in niche realization are thus those of locating hypoparametric within subparametric niche space, and parametric within subparametric.
Niche Hyperspace Owing to the fact that all niche space is to a greater or lesser extent ‘‘repetitive’’ by virtue of recurrent behavioral patterns over the time span of a generation, the temporal summation of realization for a given set of niche parameters at any hierarchic level creates a four-dimensional construct, niche hyperspace. Niche hyperspace can clearly be manifested in parametric, subparametric, and hypoparametric domains in both major and minor adaptive niches: The significance of niche hyperspace for adaptation can be demonstrated from a ‘‘time and motion’’ comparison between two species competing to locate the same limiting resource, as with two parasitic wasp species seeking the same host. That species with the greatest efficiency in host location (e.g., through ability to find the host more rapidly and more often than a competitor) clearly manifests the highest adaptive state within the niche intersect zone. This is fundamental to an understanding of the fact that no two species may occupy exactly the same niche—especially in that it is not the qualitative or quantitative nature of niche parameters that matter here, but some aspect of activity that may either lie exclusively in behavioral strategy itself or else be connected with structure through biomechanical efficiency.
40
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
Thus, if one species can search n times the total volume of major adaptive niche space than another within the same time frame, then it has the greater probability of locating the shared limiting resource. Parametric niche space is of particular significance with respect to niche hyperspace differentials, since active competition is concentrated here, and sub- or hypoparametric niche space tends by way of contrast to be much less finite or reducible. The value of the niche hyperspace concept lies in differentiation of adaptive strategies of different gene pools exploiting the same adaptive niche, namely, in that it is hypothetically possible for two gene pools to overlap with respect to niche, while having different adaptational states with respect to niche hyperspace. In that circumstance, one gene pool may simply be more efficient at exploiting the same niche space than another, and this will be crucial in deciding the outcome of competition. In this, we observe that competition occurs in the specific context of niche hyperspace.* It also follows that niche hyperspace is reflected both in r and in the 움 factors of the Lotka–Volterra equations.
The Adaptive Niche and the Reciprocity Principle In the previous chapter, we saw that the reciprocity principle applied to the biotic adaptive niche alone, for gene pools expressing mutual depressor or enhancer properties. We can now add that the particular biotic element favoring reciprocal adaptivity also tends to lie with parametric niche space. This means that coadaptive evolution in general will tend to be expressed in some sequences of structural change and not in others (for example, there is no ‘‘reciprocity’’ between the functional activity of a wing and the abiotic aerial environment!): The reciprocal relationship between angiosperm reproduction and insect feeding habits has been understood since the late nineteenth century, and this clearly played a decisive role in the origin of the flower (Takhtajan, 1954). The same is obviously true in the relationship between plant fruiting bodies and dispersal mediated by birds and mammals.
MAIN POINTS FROM CHAPTER 2 1. The adaptive niche is defined according to the ‘‘locus of first contact’’ between gene reservoir and external environment, and is thus linked to the extrinsic component of adaptive capacity. 2. The adaptive niche contains major and minor components, the former being linked to the limiting resource, the latter lying in gene pools of equivalent and superior trophic level. 3. There are fundamental versus real domains in the adaptive niche, respectively constituting the total possible versus per-generation realized complements of extrinsic adaptive capacity. * However, see Chapter 17 for a discussion of niche space in view of a major adaptive shift.
2. SPATIAL STRUCTURE OF THE ADAPTIVE NICHE
41
4. The niche interface concept links to a revised definition of environment, which latter additionally encompasses stochastic interactions impinging on adaptive systems. 5. An orientation strategy hierarchy reflects the central role of behavior in realization of adaptive capacity, identifying a complementary hierarchy of functional domains in the adaptive niche which in turn carry significant links to the dynamic behavior and evolution of adaptive systems. The niche space hierarchy in question is parametric–subparametric–hypoparametric, as respectively defined by positive processive, taxic, and kinetic behavior. 6. Limiting factors tend to reside in parametric niche space, which latter thus forms the principal focus of the equation set of the adaptive system. Parametric niche space is also linked to influx of energy. 7. Niche hyperspace exists as a function of repeated behavioral patterns in niche realization. This aspect of niche space forms an important contribution to fitness differentials existing between genotypes and gene pools.
This page intentionally left blank
3
DYNAMICS OF THE ADAPTIVE NICHE
It is axiomatic that the value and polarity of selection are frequently a variable, owing to the periodic behavior of many adaptive niche parameters. Consequently, an understanding of niche periodicity is essential in order to investigate the capacity of a gene pool for dynamic activity. The niche forming the extrinsic adaptive capacity of a given gene pool is clearly not a fixed entity, but has a probabilistic structure within a temporospatial matrix. To understand the effect of such variation on the nature of the adaptive response, it is useful to begin by examining the manner in which the niche is distributed in terms of the adaptive response, before proceeding to look into temporal fluctuations and spatial dynamism in the distribution of niche parameters.
TEMPORAL AND SPATIAL REFERENCE FRAMES OF THE ADAPTIVE NICHE Certain temporal and spatial reference frames are crucial to the analysis of niche structure, particularly because the dichotomy between dynamic equilibrium in adaptive capacity and true evolutionary behavior is reflected in such factors (see Chapter 5).
Temporal Reference Frames of the Adaptive Response It is instructive to define some preliminary reference frames which effectively ‘‘set the clock’’ on the basis of major parameters of the adaptive response, as
43
44
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
a typological starting point from which to explore niche dynamism. In the following system, certain ‘‘temporal landmarks’’ are identified as being strategic to the discussion in hand: 1. t ⱕ life span of an individual: Obviously, much dynamic activity at this primary level can only be met by metabolic or behavioral adjustment, since genetic adjustment based on allelomorphism can only be manifested within the intergenerational time frame. This reference frame is therefore pivotal in distinguishing the direct genetic response from the apparently nongenetic, and it also holds quite different implications for logistic and structural components of adaptation. It is here that behavioral activity and phenoplasticity allow an adaptive response to be made to variables operating within the narrow time frame of t itself. 2. T ⫽ time taken for fixation of a given allele of W ⫽ 1.0 and its dispersal through subpopulations of a sympatric gene pool: This reference frame will serve as a useful guideline for assessment of the nature of the adaptive response to a dynamic external environment. Much genetic adjustment will in fact be transitory, expressing dynamic equilibrium within a relatively short time frame, rather than manifesting directionalized evolutionary change. Any allelic change that expresses reversibility to the point of transient elimination within time frame T is clearly also of dynamic equilibrium. 3. Tc ⫽ ‘‘ambient speciation time,’’ that is, time for accumulated genetic changes in geographically mobile gene pools of a gene reservoir to reach that point at which sympatry–rejoin with the parent lineage (or divergence in allopatry) tends to lead to cladogenesis, causal either to extinction of one emergent gene pool or to speciation: This reference frame is clearly crucial to several genuinely evolutionary patterns of change, as distinct from those constituting mere dynamic equilibrium in the adaptive response. It should be clear from the outset that the same selectional regime operating within the domain of periodicity expressed within t, T and Tc will give rise to quite different evolutionary potentials in each case. A niche parameter fluctuating within the domain of time t will obviously be met by quite different manifestations in the adaptive response, than if this periodicity were only evident in the context of a much larger time frame, such as T or Tc. The ambient state of niche periodicity for a large percentage of genetic variation is probably ⬎t but ⬍T, so that by convention (and due to practicality!), adaptive niche structure is generally best analyzed in its ‘‘static’’ perspective (corresponding to periods ⬍t 씮 ⬍T ). We must, however, also consider dynamic aspects of niche change for periods T 씮 Tc in order to gain deeper insights into evolutionary activity, and this clearly leads us from observational to extrapolatory criteria of analysis. These larger time frames thus form valuable reference points through which to examine major anagenetic change, as distinct from the shorter term behavior of allelomorphic states in a gene pool which expresses dynamic behavior within the context of a preexisting adaptive capacity. Spatial Reference Frames of the Adaptive Response Niche space must also contain significant reference frames for evolving adaptive systems, the two primary divisions following the ‘‘micro- versus macrospatial’’ coordinate systems:
3. DYNAMICS OF THE ADAPTIVE NICHE
45
s ⫽ real space within the niche of a gene pool ( gene pool niche space) S ⫽ geographic space containing similar, noncontiguous gene pools of a species ( gene reservoir niche space) The coordinates of gene reservoir space are clearly the macrospatial coordinates of the adaptive niche and environment linked to geographic distribution and dispersal, and these coordinates must be crucial in the allopatry–sympatry scenario affecting speciation mechanisms (see Chapter 6).
Population, Gene Pool, Species, and Lineage Niche Using the temporospatial framework proposed above, we can now look at the niche interface in several dimensions. Taking niche space in general, we can consider some useful summations over various temporospatial scenarios: N⬍s ⫽ population niche, the smallest contingent of functional niche space tNs ⫽ gene pool niche, the adaptive niche relative to any single gene pool, over one generation tNS ⫽ gene reservoir niche, the niche occupied by the entire gene reservoir over one generation TcNS ⫽ species niche, the niche occupied by the gene reservoir for the life span of a species ⬎TcNS ⫽ lineage niche, moving into the domain of anagenesis and longer term evolutionary phenomena t
The above categories must also have some bearing on the dichotomy between fundamental and real adaptive niche (that is to say, fundamental niche relates to species niche, real niche to population niche, and so on). We can also extract parametric or sub- or hypoparametric niche space from the above expressions in order to examine short- and long-term evolutionary effects of different adaptational regimes, an approach which in fact will be shown to have far-reaching consequences for evolutionary theory. In the latter context, the lineage niche is clearly the fundamental concept required in discussions of long-term evolutionary mechanisms. This approach will be developed further, as anagenesis and other modes of evolutionary change come to be examined in detail in later chapters.
TEMPORAL PERIODICITY OF THE NICHE INTERFACE Although it is possible to arrive at a categorization of niche space following the above system, it is obvious that much dynamism must be contained within ‘‘static’’ domains (e.g., leading species niche parameters may well be stable in the longer term, but many other parameters within the boundary of a species unit will manifest temporospatial polymorphism). It is evident that some niche parameters are variable in time and others are not, and it is also evident that degree of dynamism is linked to level in the niche space hierarchy. The manner in which niche regimes vary in time and space must also have a large impact on the evolutionary behavior of adaptive systems. In particular, speciation
46
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
mechanisms and the impact of interspecific evolution on anagenetic change must depend heavily on temporospatial configuration with respect to the larger coordinates (see Chapters 6 and 17), and the boundary between evolutionary scenarios characteristic of dynamic equilibrium in adaptive capacity as against evolution also lies here.
Modes of Periodicity in the Niche Interface Niche periodicity can best be defined in terms of the reference frames designated earlier. It must also be stated at the outset that the periodicity of niche parameters can take either of two forms, with very different effects on the adaptive response: 1. Oscillatory periodicity, or bidirectional variability of some niche parameter within the range ⬎0 씮 1.0, where the adaptive response may be reflected in frequency changes in the allelomorphic structure of the gene pool 2. Boolean periodicity, where a niche parameter is simply present or absent over a temporal sequence (or at a given spatial location), and the genetic response can only be based on more erratic fluctuations, perhaps in allelomorphic variation linked to recurrent mutation Static and regularly periodic niche interface structures of period ⬎t are clearly those most likely to enter the organismic level in terms of evolutionary changes in behavior and structure, truly stochastic survivorship factors therefore being identifiable as irregularly periodic (or nonperiodic) influences for which there can be no ongoing adaptive response within the domain of existing adaptive capacity: Consider (for example) dimorphism in the peppered moth Biston betularia (see Kettlewell, 1973)*; a scattered distribution of positive adaptive niche space appropriate to the carbonaria morph exists, namely, polluted environments. Temporal change is clearly also manifested in this, in that subsequent widespread recovery of the wild-type morph has been reported in the aftermath of pollution control. Environmental change has not occurred over so long a time frame that adaptive capacity for reversal has been lost. Dynamic and Static Niche Interface From the above analysis of periodicity in the niche interface, and using the proposed time frames as our standard for the analysis of the structural component of evolution, we may now derive categories of ‘‘temporal dependence’’ for niche periodicity: • Dynamic niche parameters will be defined here as having periodicity of ⬍t 씮 ⬍Tc, and in this situation the adaptive response adjustment can be deemed to fall into the category of dynamic equilibrium for the * More recent studies have seriously questioned some of the original Kettlewell data. The treatment here consequently omits reference to certain aspects of interpretation.
3. DYNAMICS OF THE ADAPTIVE NICHE
47
allelomorphic component of the gene pool (assuming that the latter is affected by adaptive capacity alone). • Static niche parameters express periodicity at ⱖ Tc, where evolutionary patterns involving iterative gene fixation will tend to be manifested, this being associated with the kind of long-term directional change linked to speciation and anagenesis. Clearly then, different niche periodicities will have fundamentally different evolutionary potentials, of which the dichotomy between dynamic adaptive equilibrium and evolution is the most fundamental. Although the great majority of niche parameters are probably dynamic in the very long term, it is nevertheless possible to distinguish essentially static from dynamic in this scenario in the domain of such key modes of change as speciation and anagenesis. Periodicity and the Niche Space Hierarchy How do the above periodicity factors relate to the niche space hierarchy defined in Chapter 2? Shorter periodicities, say, of ⬍t 씮 앑T, are probably of frequent occurrence with respect to much parametric niche space, especially with oscillatory periodicity, whereas longer periodicities (often ⱖTc) more probably typify hypoparametric niche space, owing to the greater long-term stability of broader spatial parameters (which will be much less narrowly defined than the loci of the parametric niche): The aquatic habitat (in general) may have much greater stability as an environment than the presence of any single biotic limiting resource, for a specialized consumer species living in that environment. For Tc and above, we in fact find many macroniche parameters of hypoparametric status. Clearly, major body plan design can only be linked to such nonchanging components of the adaptation interface. At the outset then, category of niche space seems likely to be linked to periodicity, and this in turn affects the mode of adaptive response. Microniche versus Macroniche It is highly significant that a four-dimensional perspective based on stability versus periodicity of a given set of niche parameters reveals the existence of two broad categories of static versus dynamic type, which can then be used to identify the parameters of micro- versus macroniche: the macroniche is made up of niche parameters static in the temporal dimension, whereas the microniche contains parameters with a purely transient existence (Fig. 12). In this scheme, there is an approximate relationship between macroniche and environmental niche, also between macroniche and the adaptive zone concept of Simpson (see Chapter 17). The categories ‘‘static’’ and ‘‘macro-’’ seem more often to be linked to sub- and hypoparametric niche space, given the very frequent dynamic behavior of differentials at the parametric level expressed in species differences and the link between the higher systematic categories and other levels in the niche space hierarchy.
48
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
FIGURE 12 Relationship between niche periodicity and micro- or macroniche status.
SPATIAL STRUCTURE OF THE NICHE INTERFACE Adaptive capacity contains a range of different phenotypes manifested in the gene pool, some of which obviously have a niche interface varying with space, rather than time. It is therefore now necessary to explore this spatial dimension. Here we are no longer concerned with the spatial dimensions of population versus gene pool, but with the degree to which niche space in general is disjunctly distributed in real space. The Isotopic and Anisotopic Niche Interface Adaptive capacity interdigitates with the spatial structure of the niche interface via the allelomorphic structure of the genotype as follows: • The isotopic niche interface is one that is uniformly distributed on the spatial plane, so that a given gene locus may be expressed in a single phenotype, the fitness of which is constant over gene reservoir niche space. • The anisotopic niche interface is one that is differentially distributed on the spatial plane, so that a gene locus may be expressed in two or more allelomorphic phenotypes that have separate fitness values linked to different loci within gene reservoir niche space. It is evident in examples such as the shell banding and color traits in the terrestrial gastropod mollusc Cepaea studied by Cain and Sheppard (1954) that different morphs of a species may dominate different spatial regions, owing to differentials in the nature of the selective agency determining gene frequencies (visual selection in some areas, temperature effects in others). A similar interpretation has been made with regard to variation in wing marking traits in the nymphaline butterfly Maniola jurtina studied by Ford and others (see Brakefield, 1990, for a review), although in the latter example it is less clear exactly how selective pressures vary from one locality to another. These factors clearly reflect the spatial structure of the adaptive niche itself. Similarly, chromosomal races in Drosophila pseudoobscura indicate clinal changes associated with changing environment on a much wider spatial plane (see Dobzhansky, 1970). There are clines in the frequencies of
49
3. DYNAMICS OF THE ADAPTIVE NICHE
different chromosome types across the distribution area of this species, and where the environment changes rapidly (over altitude, for example), change may be rapid. Dobzhansky also pointed out that this does not necessarily mean that the same factors apply to a wider geographic pattern. Returning to the concept of adaptive capacity introduced in Chapter 1, we can now confirm that many genotypes within the repertoire of adaptive capacity will actually prove nonadaptive in the context of the ambient anisotropic selection interface.
NICHE PROFILE AS THE COMBINED TEMPOROSPATIAL PERSPECTIVE The significance of temporospatial patterns of niche variation must clearly depend ultimately on the longer term aspect of both temporal periodicity and spatial fluctuation manifested in an evolving adaptive system. This composite structure can conveniently be termed niche profile (see below).
Niche Profile and Long-term Dynamics of the Niche Interface Dynamism in the spatial aspect of the adaptive niche was described above in terms of the isotopic–anisotopic dichotomy, and we must now additionally consider how this scheme links to the temporal aspect of static versus dynamic niche parameters for the species niche. Niche profile describes the expression of both temporal and spatial aspects of the niche interface of a species. We may thereby identify two highly significant niche profile categories: isotropic (constant with respect to both time and space) and anisotropic (variable in both time and space), as follows:
Static Dynamic
Isotopic
Anisotopic
isotropic (isotopic)
(anisotopic) anisotropic
For example, a gene pool niche could be temporally static, yet spatially disjunct (as with very many polymorphisms). ‘‘Isotropic’’ is thus an abbreviation for ‘‘static–isotopic,’’ and ‘‘anisotopic,’’ for ‘‘static–anisotopic’’ in the context of niche profile. To maintain the adaptive state, the realized adaptive response must clearly also be variable when interacting with anisotropic niche profile, different subsets of adaptive capacity attaining realization at different temporospatial loci, wherever a given niche change presents capacity for complementary adaptational adjustment. Niche profile must therefore act to determine the evolutionary behavior of the adaptive system—given, of course, the additional prerequisite of complementary genetic variation. Isotropic Niche Profile and Adaptive Potential A temporospatially uniform niche profile state obviously links to evolutionary stasis itself. However, by no means is all apparent stasis derived from a
50
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
temporospatially static niche profile (see Chapter 19). And paradoxically, the latter may also link to anagenetic change (since progressive evolution could not occur over lineage time in the absence of a constant niche interface). The above are very broad generalizations, and clearly, much more needs to be done before these relationships can be adequately understood. In particular, it must be that adaptive capacity alone cannot provide the basis for evolutionary advancement with respect to features of the external environment carrying long-term stability, and we must consequently now presume the existence of a greater domain residing in adaptive potential (see Chapter 7). Anisotropic Niche Profile and Adaptive Equilibrium A temporospatially dynamic niche profile must have a significant bearing on ‘‘nonlinear’’ patterns of change in the adaptive response, including dynamic equilibrium between the allelomorphic component of the genome and a variable external environment (see Chapter 5). Anisotopic Niche Profile, Polymorphism, and Cladogenesis The effect of a (static) anisotopic niche profile can best be analyzed with respect to balanced polymorphism and also to broader cladogenetic selectional regimes, this scenario clearly favoring diversification of the gene reservoir. Of special interest here is the relationship with speciation (see Chapter 6). Niche Profile and the Adaptive Response in General From the preceding analysis, we may now link the configurations of niche profile listed above with certain broad categories of adaptive response, ranging from stasis, through dynamic equilibrium, to clado- and anagenesis: Isotropic Anisotopic Isotopic Anisotropic
Stasis or anagenesis Gene changes on the spatial plane: balanced polymorphism and cladogenesis Genetic differentiation on the temporal plane: simple dynamic equilibrium in the genetic component of adaptive capacity Genetic differentiation on both spatial and temporal planes: ‘‘complex adaptive equilibrium’’
Given the above range of configurations in niche profile, it is of course axiomatic that periodicity in niche parameters may or may not lead to complementary change in the adaptive response. There is no reason to suppose that the existence of, for example, an anisotopic niche profile will necessarily lead to speciation, although it is essential to see that the latter is clearly facilitated by the system in question. The above categories of niche profile therefore are descriptions of evolutionary potential alone, and the link between ‘‘potential’’ and ‘‘realization’’ must be explored with reference to the structure of selection as it relates to adaptive capacity, as well as to other as yet unexplored propensities of the adaptive system. One useful overview in this will be to consider the supreme importance of the static versus dynamic niche, given that the temporal dimension is of special significance in determining whether an ‘‘expected’’ adaptive response has time to appear and be perpetuated. For example, the reciprocity principle (Chapter 1) is unlikely to be manifested in the structural component of the adaptive response in absence of long-term stability of selectional interactions between gene pools of an adaptive system.
3. DYNAMICS OF THE ADAPTIVE NICHE
51
The link between the adaptive niche space hierarchy (Chapter 2) and niche profile must be looked at with respect to species and lineage niche. Hypoand subparametric niche space are obviously closely linked to longer term evolutionary trends, since many parametric niche resources may be contained as subsets of much larger sub- or hypoparametric domains, so that the latter will often tend to be linked to an isotropic niche profile. Furthermore, both parametric niche space and niche hyperspace in general are of great significance for the development of cladogenetic potential, owing to their link with active competition, and these categories must link to a fundamentally anisotopic niche profile. In general then, static niche parameters will tend to be linked to macroevolutionary patterns of change, and an isotopic spatial domain is of special significance in the same context.
MAIN POINTS FROM CHAPTER 3 1. It is useful to define a set of temporal and spatial reference frames for analysis of the dynamic behavior of adaptive systems: t (⫽ life span of an individual) to ⬎Tc (⫽ that of a lineage). These points of reference identify fundamental static/dynamic categories in the niche interface. 2. In the spatial perspective, the adaptive response falls into s (gene pool) and S (gene reservoir) primary categories. Spatial dynamism is in turn defined in terms of the degree of disjunctness of niche parameters in real space (isotopic/ anisotopic niche interface). 3. Niche profile is defined jointly by configurations of temporal plus spatial reference frames of niche dynamism. The longer term aspect of niche profile can be used to distinguish between adaptive equilibrium and true evolutionary change, and isotropic versus anisotropic categories of niche profiles underline this dichotomy. 4. Dynamism is expressed differentially at different levels in the niche space hierarchy. Significantly, there are micro- versus macroniche (‘‘dynamic’’ versus isotropic) domains, reflecting the relationship between niche profile and adaptive response. The microniche is more often linked to parametric, and the macroniche, to sub- and hypoparametric niche space.
This page intentionally left blank
4
THE SELECTION INTERFACE
THE NATURE OF SELECTION The Darwinian thesis holds that evolutionary change is directed by selection in terms of improved adaptive function, rather than by action of any endogenous ‘‘orthogenetic’’ force. Selection is that mechanism through which differential survivorship is conferred on genotypes as a result of mortality in which a heritable differential between survivors and nonsurvivors is also manifested. Are the supposed properties that have been widely attributed to selection intrinsic to the agencies of selective mortality, or are they a manifestation of some larger domain of interaction within the adaptive system?
Properties of Selection At the outset, it must be clear that selection cannot simply be equated with mortality alone. How, then, does it relate to the adaptive state concept, to equations of the adaptive system, and to measures of fitness for competing genotypes and gene pools? The adaptive state A was defined earlier as being some measure of the probability of survival of a genotype or gene pool in terms of the nature of its survival strategy of a function of adaptive capacity, and accordingly A must have some predictable relationship with the selection coefficient s. Clearly, two genotypes may have A ⫽ 1.0 in isolation from one another, while at the same time, A for both is depressed in the sympatric situation. This scenario clearly indicates the existence of relative adaptive states expressing a differential in
53
54
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
A, where there is at least partial competition for some limiting resource. That locus in time and space in the adaptive system within which genotypes or gene pools with different adaptive states exist in competition owing to presence of a mutual niche intersect constitutes the selection interface, and the relative adaptive state of such genotypes or gene pools is described by the selection coefficient s (effectively the reciprocal of the coefficient of fitness, W ). Selection can thus be viewed as a property residing in relative adaptive states for genotypes or gene pools, each of which may well carry a survivorship probability of 1.0 in absence of the other. It is thus equivalent to differential survivorship of genotypes, the outcome of which is an increase in the adaptive state of one genotype and a depression for another for the duration of the selection interface. From this standpoint, a monomorphic population clearly has the hypothetical potential to survive with no selection acting on it, solely through the process of adaptation. Selection thus operates only in the niche intersect zone between two or more competing genotypes or gene pools, and outside the intersect zone lies the adaptation interface alone: Biston betularia presents no selection interface unless B. betularia f. carbonaria is also present at the same temporospatial locus. A B. betularia population carrying a frequency of 1.0 for the wild-type allelomorph is thus perpetuated through adaptation (or eliminated through adaptational failure), and selection only comes into play when there is a relative adaptive differential between two allelomorphs present in a sympatric state (in reality, there will of course always be other selectional differentials between individuals and populations, and this scenario is thus a purely hypothetical one).
ARCHITECTURE OF THE SELECTION INTERFACE Selection appears at first sight to be a vector quantity, the directionality of which may be supposed to be reflected in topology of the adaptive response, and the apparent quantitative properties of selection similarly derive from relative adaptive states when a given gene pool or genotype carries a higher adaptive state relative to a competitor. However, these characteristics cannot truly be regarded as being intrinsic qualities of selection itself, in the context of any agency existing independently of the organism–environment interaction, since polarity (and also directionality) may vary with respect to different configurations of niche profile. These differentials clearly derive, not exclusively from the selective agency, but from both extrinsic and endogenous properties of adaptive capacity. The natural conclusion would therefore be that the supposed properties of selection lie, not in the selective agent, but in a larger selection interface. Of great importance for evolutionary theory is the fact that the selection interface can be shown to exist in a higher domain than that of individual selection—not only at gene pool and gene reservoir levels, but also in the transspecific dimension. This observation will be confirmed and emphasized at many junctures in the ensuing analysis.
55
4. THE SELECTION INTERFACE
The Selection Interface and Adaptive Capacity The selection interface clearly lies in the existence of adaptive capacity for an adaptive response to a changing adaptation interface, being determined not only by the nature of niche profile, but also by the capacity of the organism to manifest some complementary heritable differential within the domain of adaptive capacity (see Chapter 3). The external selection interface thus occurs whenever demanded by the periodicity and spatial distribution of niche, being defined explicitly by the intersect existing between niche profile and adaptive capacity in terms of heritable differentials in the adaptive state.
FIGURE 13 The selection interface as an intersect between niche profile and adaptive capacity.
The selection interface is therefore made up of the loci of adaptational change, wherever adaptive capacity has the facility through heritable variation to respond to dynamic niche structure or to improve on preexisting adaptive strategies. It is now possible to identify supposed attributes of selection, as characteristics of the selection interface as a whole, for example: Mortality derived properties Adaptive capacity derived properties
Density dependence Directionality
Directionality in the Selection Interface There are two configurations in niche profile that can be shown to be of fundamental significance for the evolutionary behavior of adaptive systems: isotropic and anisotopic (see previous chapter), both of which have particular potential to influence evolutionary directionality when iterated over a lineage time frame then translated into a selection interface. This will clearly not be the case with respect to the anisotropic/isotopic case, which can only relate to adaptive equilibrium, because of links with temporal dynamism. The anisotopic selection interface will be discussed in greater detail in Chapter 5, but it can be illustrated in a preliminary manner as shown in Fig. 14. In contrast, the isotropic selection interface might conversely be supposed to constitute a ‘‘normalizing’’ structure, either in a single stable state, or else around the mean of a variance (Fig. 15). However, owing to the almost universal multiple functionality of organic structures, the ‘‘single stable state’’ situation
56
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
FIGURE 14 A normally distributed variance gravitates toward two discrete components of the total original frequency distribution, manifesting spatial ‘‘disruption’’ of the gene pool in the presence of an anisotopic selection interface (X ⫽ measurement of a quantitative character, Y ⫽ frequency in population).
is probably more accurately described as the resultant of a minimum of two antagonistic selection vectors, in the context of a complex isotropic selection interface: Simpson (1953) discussed an example with shell thickness (as in molluscs), which he reasoned was controlled by the balance between selective forces acting separately in favor of thickness (for protection against predators) and thinness (favoring freedom of locomotion), the result being a ‘‘compromise’’ solution between two extremes, each of which carries some negative corollary.
FIGURE 15 One expression of the ‘‘normalizing’’ (isotropic) selection interface, in which an initially wide variance tends to narrow around an optimum state (axes as in fig. 14).
57
4. THE SELECTION INTERFACE
The above factors can be viewed as important elements in determination of the architecture of the selection interface, serving to identify the various ‘‘properties of selection’’ as factors residing in particular configurations, as these relate to long-term tendencies of the adaptive system. Canalizing, directional, centrifugal selection, etc., are thus more usefully seen as properties of the selection interface in its iterative perspective (see below). Selection Profile and Configurations of the Selection Interface What do different configurations of the selection interface mean in the context of long-term niche profile? Just as niche profile describes the temporal and spatial dynamic status of the adaptive niche, selection profile similarly describes both the periodicity of the selection interface and its status in the link with the spatial perspective in the genetic component of adaptive capacity over speciation time. In other words, when we speak of ‘‘configurations of the selection interface,’’ we are simply linking the activity of differential mortality to the pattern of temporospatial variation in the adaptive niche itself: The Cepaea and Maniola exemplars given for the anisotropic niche profile scenario (see p. 48) naturally serve also to identify the behavior of a selection interface, since it is only through the existence of adaptive capacity for polymorphism that modulation of the gene pool with respect to dynamism in the external environment is rendered possible in the sense of ‘active’ adjustment. Selection profile thus describes both temporal periodicity and spatial perspectives of the selection interface over speciation time, thus determining directionality of the adaptive response (adopting the same scheme as that devised for niche profile; see Chapter 3): Selection profile
Properties of the selection interface
Isotropic Anisotopic Isotopic Anisotropic
‘‘Normalizing selection’’: determining permitted range of variation ‘‘Diversifying selection’’: perpetuation of two or more states ‘‘Cyclic selection’’: recurrent allelomorphic variation ‘‘Diversifying plus cyclic selection’’: transient polymorphism
It is furthermore axiomatic that, in certain configurations of selection profile, changes in the adaptive response may tend to ‘‘shadow’’ selection profile, with a phase difference between selection interface and adaptive response. This is due to the incremental manner in which most gene frequency changes occur, as a function of the mode of operation of the genetic system itself and of the behavior of the equations of the adaptive system. Of special interest is the fact that in an isotropic selection profile (see above), the selection interface will disfavor any deviation from the existing adaptive state, excepting when there is advance toward the major (structural ) attractor (see Chapters 1 and 7). The adaptive response may thus acquire an iterative form of directional orientation with respect to this configuration of selection profile.
The Phenon as Locus of the Selection Interface It should by now be clear that the whole organism cannot be presumed to manifest an holistic selection interface, and that only specific phenotype struc-
58
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
ture units expressing active allelomorphism can be presumed to exhibit selectional activity at any point in time. This does not mean, of course, that structural units controlled by ‘‘fixed’’ genes and thus lacking a selection interface are ‘‘nonadaptive,’’ but merely implies that they present only an adaptation interface. The selection interface is alone controllant to changes in gene frequency, and thus also to the dynamics of the adaptive response as manifested both in dynamic equilibrium and in evolutionary change. The selection interface may thus lie in a different unit of structure in different individuals of a population, and it may continually change position, so that the gene pool tends to become the focus of selectional activity over n generations (n being some function of the dynamic structure of the external environment). These conclusions clearly reiterate out revised definition of selection versus adaptation, as well as ratifying the status of the gene pool as the epicenter of the adaptive state (see Chapter 1). The phenon is any structural locus in the phenotype manifesting genetic allelomorphism (or possessing adaptive potential to do so), and having an active selection interface within the time frame of a given generation—whether via one major gene or n additive minor genes. A phenon may be manifested in substructural variation, and when structural, it may concern one or more subordinate parts of some larger structure unit (see Chapter 7). The selection interface refers, not merely to the interface of one phenon at individual level at time t, but to the sum of all phenons presenting an active interface in the gene pool at time t. A ‘‘super-selection interface’’ therefore also lies in the gene pool as an holistic structure defined over n generations and over geographic space, expressed in both temporal and spatial dimensions. And as we shall see at a later point, there is also an interspecific selection interface operating above phenon level (see Chapter 7). Different phenons may contribute interactively to fitness in either of two ways: multiplicative or additive. In the former situation, two genotypes may affect different temporal phases of development, whereas in the latter, the same component may receive separate increments to fitness from two or more discrete genes. It is of special interest that, where additive genes affect the same phenon, a potential exists for linear, iterative modulation in the adaptive response. Exogenous and Endogenous Components of the Selection Interface Clearly, selection may affect the adaptive state whenever a discontinuity occurs in the adaptive ensemble. This can happen at various developmental loci, thus defining the extrinsic and endogenous selection interface—the extrinsic lying in the behavior–niche function cycle in the interaction between organism and external environment, and the endogenous lying in the development epicycle (or in metabolism). The extrinsic selection interface is perhaps explicit in the definition of selection itself. The endogenous selection interface is more difficult to understand. For example, a more parsimonious developmental event may be selected over a less parsimonious one; however, the adaptation interface for this change probably lies elsewhere in time and space (probably in the postdevelopmental zone), and it may be widely disseminated as an energetic economy which holds the capacity to facilitate efficiency increase in several other mechanisms. The
59
4. THE SELECTION INTERFACE
extrinsic selection interface can therefore often be traced to a specific phenon recognizable as an allelomorphic effect in the visible phenotype (as with melanism), but the endogenous may be effectively undetectable in this respect. Three themes will be developed from the above argument at a later stage: 1. The extrinsic component of the selection interface must have some vital relationship with evolutionary rate (Chapter 18). 2. The endogenous selection interface is of particular significance with respect to evolutionary forces acting to favor cladogenetic activity (Chapter 6). 3. The endogenous selection interface is also of significance in understanding the directional component of the isotropic selection vector (see below) as this affects the evolution of developmental systems (and this may also invoke an important evolutionary corollary with regard to evolutionary rate).
Properties of the Isotropic Selection Interface Having examined the broad anatomy of the selection interface via selection profile, it would now seem pertinent to go on to consider the most evolutionarily significant state in this scenario more closely, namely, that of the complex isotropic state (which may well be the basis for most selectional regimes of a long-term ‘‘static’’ kind). Given the existence of multiple functionality, the isotropic selection vector can most easily be understood in terms of a simplified model which describes a pair of antagonistic selectional forces acting on a single phenotype trait (and it is in this sense that we must apply the term complex to the selection interface). If the selection interface between adaptive capacity and mortality can be described by a vector, then the phenon is its ‘‘point of action.’’ Given capacity for bidirectional change in the phenon, the selection vector is (in a general model, and for any complex isotropic selection interface) the resultant of two component vectors acting with respect to different possible expressions of a given trait. This can be most easily illustrated in an artificial example, adopting ‘‘X-ness’’ and ‘‘Y-ness’’ in the analogy of a simple orthogonal model. In the idealized scheme, shown in Fig. 16, the resultant vector R of vectors X and Y is given by R ⫽ (X2 ⫹ Y2 ) and the directional component, by tan ; ⫽ Y/X. ‘‘X-ness’’ and ‘‘Y-ness’’ are clearly an abstraction only in the above model. However, this artificial model is nevertheless helpful (a) in order to take qualitative differentials into account and (b) in order to allow clear comparisons to be made between isotropic and anisotopic selection interface structures. For example, the differential between antagonistic selectional forces is often qualitative in the anisotopic selection interface (see Chapter 6), but may be quantitative or colinear in the isotropic case. Most significantly, any tendency for movement in the above system (change in X or in Y ) is opposed to a greater or lesser degree by an antagonistic force
60
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
FIGURE 16 Simplified model of the complex isotropic selection interface. Axes X and Y represent directionally antagonistic vectors expressing potential for directional change in the adaptive response (quantitative aspect reflected in X, Y).
favoring change in the opposite direction, the fully balanced state for which will be some expression of ‘‘XY’’*: An interesting and widely investigated case study exists in the shell form of Gryphaea oysters, in which the selective advantage of increased shell coiling was apparently balanced by progressive restrictions on valve opening caused by further extrapolation of this trend. It is believed that increased coiling probably had the advantage of raising the body above the surface of sediment in more unstable substrates, while at the same time leading to difficulty in terms of restriction of the feeding mechanism. Evidently, a point is reached at which continued extrapolation of the coiling trend leads to vulnerability (in fact, later forms suffered extinction in many lineages, owing to changes in the external environment; see Chapter 20). The above principle applies well beyond the domain of the biophysical dimension for a single isotropic vector, extending also to encompass the question of mutual dynamic balance and optimality with respect to different parameters of adaptive capacity: An example is seen in the Williams demographic theory of optimum reproduction states (see Williams, 1966). Reproductive effort results in loss of immediate adaptive capacity, but on balance, the net advantage must be greater probability of survival of the lineage. Conse* The isotropic vector does not have to be bipartite. However, this is the most useful ‘‘general’’ model.
4. THE SELECTION INTERFACE
61
quently, increase in reproductive activity cannot expand beyond that point at which net survivorship capacity begins to be reduced. Another nonstructural example lies in infraspecific aggression, which will tend to be optimized in ritualistic behavior. Similarly, increase in inclusive fitness cannot exceed a point of negative feedback with respect to inbreeding depression! (See Chapter 1.) The intensity of selection acting on the isotropic selection interface must clearly also relate to permissible frequency distribution in variance of a given phenotype parameter, as a function of contribution to overall fitness. Where this value is high, variance will be low, and vice versa (so that positive variance of low contribution to fitness will tend to be manifested in continuous variation on an intraspecific basis, and that expressing a very high selective advantage will conversely be reflected in tight constrainment of form). The isotropic system may thus tend often to invoke monomorphism—although if the trait in question has a low contribution to fitness, it may alternatively manifest continuous variation about a mean approximating to the XY vector state. We have now extended our view beyond the fitness of one trait relative to another at the same locus, to consideration of W of that locus relative to the entire genotype. It is clearly only when the former tends to constitute a very large proportion of overall fitness that we get a single ‘‘stasigenetic’’ state; otherwise, we witness an expansion of continuous variation. The basis for the complex isotropic selection vector thus lies with the existence of an isotropic selection interface with two antagonistic selectional attractors, as a reflection of the axiom of multiple functionality (see Chapters 1 and 7). The ideal adaptive response to the isotropic selection vector must often lie somewhere between two attractors, with bias toward that with the greatest fitness enhancing state—the adaptive response thus being expressed in a single phenotype state. The isotropic selection vector is also an essential tool for an understanding of the manner in which linear directionality is expressed in the adaptive response, as with anagenesis. Principal Components of the Isotropic Selection Interface in the Adaptive Ensemble A general model for the architecture of the complex isotropic selection vector can clearly incorporate dimensions in each functional mechanism within the adaptive ensemble, and the selection interface is thus a fundamentally bipartite structure in terms of principal components in the following: • Logistic dimension: the selection interface as it concerns intrinsic rate of increase in the population • Structural dimension: structural advance toward an adaptive paradigm state as an optimum with respect to n component vectors • Behavioral dimension: for example, as this concerns social interactions within the gene pool in the kinship domain Each dimension within the isotropic selection interface may thus express a fundamentally bipartite structure with antagonistic components acting in two
62
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
FIGURE 17 Complex isotropic selection interface in three domains of the adaptive ensemble.
principal directions. In Fig. 17, the negative corollary of either ‘‘too high’’ or ‘‘too low’’ r in the logistic component of adaptive capacity is a tendency to ‘‘crash’’ N. Consequently the ideal value for r lies between two extremes. Similarly, in the behavioral dimension, we encounter a negative corollary for iterated kin adaptation with inbreeding depression, balanced with that of ‘‘overoutbreeding’’ in loss of inclusive fitness. Again, the resultant constitutes a compromise solution. The above system reflects the balance X : Y for certain principal components of the structural attractor, which seem intrinsically likely to express a complex isotropic selection profile. In order that net change may occur in this system, sexual selection, for example, might act to bypass inbreeding depression—if certain visual stimuli also favor fitness, irrespective of kinship.* As stated at an earlier point (p. 57), the significance of the isotropic selection interface lies in its relationship with adaptive potential, which propensity must lie in innate properties of the genome to build an adaptive response to some stable parameter of the external environment (see Chapter 7).
SELECTION IN EQUATIONS OF THE ADAPTIVE SYSTEM In Chapter 1, the rudiments of the structural component of adaptation in the Lotka–Volterra equations for competing populations were identified. How is this equation set related to conventional measures of selection? Clearly, there are two different answers to this question, in consideration of the fundamental dichotomy between density dependent and density independent mortality as these affect selection profile. Only the former category will be affected by population size; however, the importance of density dependent selectional * According to Maynard Smith (1998), many courtship routines do in fact tend to test sensory and locomotor skills, which would in turn probably serve as good indicators of general fitness. The fact that the Y chromosome of males is reduced in size also confirms that factors such as success in mating are not allowed to outweigh general fitness (see Rice, 1999, who investigated the effects on fitness of artificially enlarged Y chromosomes in Drosophila).
4. THE SELECTION INTERFACE
63
factors for much evolutionary activity renders it necessary that this relationship be explored further: According to Maynard Smith (1998), density dependent selectional factors may predominate in the perpetuation of genetic variability (this broad statement is not of course intended to exclude such density independent factors as temperature sensitivity differentials in the genotype in the face of a variable microclimate, and so on).
Fitness in the Equations of the Adaptive System The fitness of a genotype, W, is conventionally defined as being given by its reproductive capacity, relative to that of a competitor: For instance, genotype a produces 100 offspring in a given environment, and genotype b, only 90: w for the latter is then 0.9 (taking the most successful genotype as w ⫽ 1.0). The above measure of fitness now requires closer examination, especially in the way it relates to the Lotka–Volterra equations. It seems intuitively obvious that W must be an element embedded in the Lotka–Volterra equations, in terms of density dependent interactions. Correct location of W and s in the equation set of the adaptive system would thus permit integration of the Lotka– Volterra equations with those of population genetics, the latter combining into a larger equation set. Some selectional differentials, of course, clearly result in W values based on factors that are not linked in any way to population density. However, for the density dependent component, there must be an intersect between genetic equations and those of population dynamics—in which latter context, W must be a variable rather than a constant. To investigate the relationship between the Lotka–Volterra equations and those of population genetics more closely, it is useful firstly to simplify the former. Here, K will be taken to be fully coincident for N1, N2 populations.* In this analysis, interaction can be considered to occur in three stages, during which: 1. The 움 factors in the Lotka–Volterra equations describe the effect of competition affecting changing proportions of N1 and N2 populations in the extrinsic selection interface. 2. The factor rn also manifests components expressed in both the extrinsic and endogenous selection interface (namely, via inputs to rn from fecundity and developmental viability, respectively).† 3. Assuming that fecundity is regarded as being the same for N1 as N2, the Hardy–Weinberg equation (following the effect of competition) * This also anticipates the addition of a qualitatively different ‘‘unshared K’’ factor that will be explored when we later come to examine the anisotopic selection interface. † Fisher’s assertion that the absolute fitness of a genotype lies in r is clearly incorrect. However, this statement is true for a monomorphic or ‘‘static–polymorphic’’ gene pool in a state of stable equilibrium with its natural environment!
64
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
determines genotype frequencies of progeny, and viability then affects the distribution of genotype frequencies in the next generation.
FIGURE 18 Links between equations of population and genetical dynamics. (A–)1–4 ⫽ frequencies of A– at four stages, in a system in which simple dominance is manifested. Note that in the above scenario, selection can be density dependent or independent at extrinsic (premating stage), but only density independent at the endogenous (postmating) selection interface.
The above scheme essentially inserts the Hardy–Weinberg equation into the Lotka–Volterra one, indicating that W (and therefore also s) is a function of r and 움, and also of initial conditions of N and K. W is thus not a simple constant, but a complex variable (which may, however, behave as a constant under certain stable conditions). With different initial conditions, W as an attractor may tend to converge on some particular value as both populations reach equilibrium level. More usefully, W is described directly by the above equation for all values of t, when we adopt the standard of identical initial conditions for N1 and N2 and when we exclude any nonheritable differentials. In this equation set, fitness (W ) is thus more correctly described by;
65
4. THE SELECTION INTERFACE
W⫽
兰tt⫹1 (dN1/dt) 兰tt⫹1 (dN2/dt)
It is highly significant that this link with the Lotka–Volterra equations identifies W as a variable, since differential survivorship based on a competitive element must be partly a function of logistic activity arising from the effect of the limiting resource K on population size N. W will consequently increase as population size ascends toward equilibrium, attaining the status of an apparent constant at the latter point only. Where W is a dynamic variable, the coefficient of selection s must also be dynamic, and neither can logically be determined as a constant when a density dependent element is present. While this may make little or no difference to parameters of mere recurrent or polymorphic variation within the domain of changing gene frequencies, it can nevertheless have considerable impact on the question of longer term evolutionary rates in angenesis (see Chapter 18). From the above analysis then, the equations of population genetics become part of the equation set of the adaptive system, extending the largely logistic role of the Verhulst equation to link with equations expressing dynamics of the structural component of the adaptive response.
MAIN POINTS FROM CHAPTER 4 1. Selection can only be defined in the context of a heritable differential survivorship between different genotypes. 2. The apparent properties of selection have to be understood in the context of the whole selection interface in the adaptive system, rather than being viewed as being intrinsic propensities of the selective agency itself. 3. Intensity, directionality, and degree of density dependence are the most important properties of the selection interface. 4. The selection interface lies in the link between adaptive capacity and niche profile, and different configurations of selection profile (combining temporal and spatial elements) can be linked to classical ‘‘selection modes.’’ Isotropic and anisotropic selection interface structures are of special interest, particularly in view of the essential dichotomy existing between adaptive equilibrium and evolution. 5. ‘‘Points of action’’ in the selection interface are located in particular phenon units, rather than in the whole organism. 6. The selection interface has both extrinsic and endogenous components, the latter being of fundamental importance to an understanding of the developmental perspective in evolution. 7. The complex isotropic selection vector reflects balance between antagonistic selectional forces linked to multiple functionality, and this configuration of the selection profile is of fundamental importance for an understanding of directionality in anagenesis. 8. The complex isotropic selection vector has dimensions in all components of the function ensemble (behavior, structure, metabolism, logistics). Consequently, there are no ‘‘selfish’’ domains that can bypass a state of negative feedback in the context of iterated evolutionary change.
66
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
9. Because fitness is frequently a function of population density, the vital density dependent component of the selection interface can be modeled in terms of a link between the Lotka–Volterra equations and those of population genetics. W and s are, in this context, variables rather than constants. 10. The linked equations of population genetics and of the Lotka–Volterra model must form a key component of the equation set of the adaptive system.
5
ADAPTIVE EQUILIBRIUM
A stark dichotomy exists between the population and developmental perspectives in genetics, as perhaps crystallized by Gilbert (1997), in criticism of an earlier pronouncement of Dobzhansky’s: ‘‘A major assumption of the population genetics approach to evolution was that the search for homologous genes is quite futile except in very close relatives. . . . Molecular biology and developmental genetics have shown this assumption to be invalid.’’ The Mendelian perspective, having been largely based on the behavior of substructural genes manifesting ongoing allelomorphism in populations, is clearly fundamentally different from that of the developmental approach, and a realistic understanding of evolutionary events (as distinct from recurrent variation) clearly depends on a firm understanding of the latter. It is from this standpoint that Stebbins (1988) rejected the view that ‘‘evolution consists of alterations in gene frequencies within and between populations.’’ It must be underlined at this point, that many supposedly ‘‘evolutionary’’ perspectives in population genetics have in reality tended to concern dynamic equilibrium and not actual evolutionary change. There are fundamental differences in the way adaptive systems express adaptive equilibrium as against true evolutionary behavior, and this has clearly been reflected in quite different points of interest in population, as against developmental genetics. It is indeed at this point that we encounter a ‘‘split’’ between special theories of evolution, centered on that particular aspect of adaptive systems theory relating to the dichotomy between adaptive capacity and adaptive potential. In resolving this
67
68
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
dilemma, we need to pay closer attention to the sharp dichotomy existing between the ambient scenario of fluctuating frequencies of substructural allelic states and that concerning the complex evolutionary pathway to multiple gene fixation in the morphogenetic domain. Similarly, we must also pay more attention to the role of selectively positive (and less to the role of neutral) mutation in the adaptive equilibrium model itself. Above all else, we must not give in to the temptation to describe realization of preexisting adaptive capacity as ‘‘evolution,’’ but rather we should pursue a deeper understanding of other mechanisms which manifest greater relevance to the analysis of the longer term evolutionary behavior of adaptive systems. Finally, we must of course, at the same time, take positive steps toward retrieving what is useful from population genetics, and not (as some workers have done) discard the notion that true evolutionary change must pass through transient states that are broadly analogous to frequency fluctuations observed in adaptive equilibrium. Indeed, the allelomorphic structure of the gene pool is the same for all but a few unchangeable domains controlled exclusively by maternal inheritance. In the present chapter, we shall continue to examine the phenomenon of adaptive capacity in the context of a facultative epicycle expressed in adaptive equilibrium, expanding the argument that this mode of activity probably constitutes the major component of the ambient adaptive response in the gene pool. In this context, the Mendelian model serves perfectly well in the analysis of most selectional activity actually observed in natural populations.
ADAPTIVE EQUILIBRIUM AND ALLOMORPHISM IN THE ADAPTIVE RESPONSE It is clear that the adaptive response contains two different modes of dynamic behavior, the most dramatic of these being evolution itself, the other being manifested only in fluctuating gene frequencies within a preexisting repertoire of recombinable allelomorphic genes comprising the genetic component of the adaptive capacity of a gene pool, as this interdigitates with a dynamic selection interface. The latter is the state of adaptive equilibrium referred to above, and this is the fundamental behavior expressed by adaptive systems under the guise of apparent ‘‘ambient stasis’’ (see Chapters 1 and 19): That the viability of some mutants is dependent on environmental factors has been known since the work of Timofeef-Ressovsky (1934), who demonstrated that the Drosophila eversae mutant is inferior to the wild type at 15–16⬚C and 28–30⬚C, but superior at 24–25⬚C.
Allomorphism Organism and environment can be said to exist in a state of mutual adaptive equilibrium when dynamism in the adaptive niche is met by complementary dynamism in the adaptive response through realization of adaptive capacity. This is clearly not a function of mere stochastic changes in population structure, the active as against ‘‘passive’’ logistic element in this implicating the presence of selectional activity.
69
5. ADAPTIVE EQUILIBRIUM
In analyzing adaptive equilibrium, it will be convenient to begin by looking at that dynamic selection interface in which selection fluctuates purely on a temporal plane. This approach allows us to analyze adaptive equilibrium in an elementary manner, before going on to look at more complex anisotropic systems which concern dynamism additionally involving the spatial dimension. The simplest scenario through which to understand the influence of selection profile on adaptive equilibrium is when some genotype in a gene pool has a variable contribution to fitness, as a function of time: Time Polarity of selection
t1 ⫹
t2 ⫺
t3 ⫹
tj ⫺
In the above scenario, a gene allelomorph is positively or negatively selected according to temporal periodicity in the selection interface. This situation clearly corresponds to a simple form of dynamic adaptive equilibrium in the adaptive response: Dempster (1955), also Haldane and Jayakar (1963a,b), found stable polymorphism possible with regular cyclic variation in which an allele is positively selected in alternate generations. Perhaps more generally, there will be a more complex anisotropic relationship between adaptive capacity and selection profile, where genetic variation is expressed in relation to both spatial and temporal dimensions*: Biston betularia f. carbonaria (the melanistic form of the peppered moth) is positively selected in some habitats and within certain time frames, but negatively selected at other places and times (see Kettlewell, 1973), and thus links to an anisotropic selection interface. The same phenomenon has been documented for Cepaea snails. Huxley and Mayr both thought that variation in Cepaea could only be random. However, cryptic coloration is now known to be selected—although ‘‘least conspicuous color’’ varies between habitats—and selection on the basis of temperature regulation is also differentially expressed on a spatial plane. Both positive and negative frequency dependent selection may be involved in this ( Jones et al., 1977). Developing the theme of the influence of selection profile on patterns of phenotypic variation a little further (see table in Chapter 4), we can predict the adaptive response for each configuration of the selection interface. In this approach, we can identify allomorphism as that selectionally determined component of adaptive equilibrium which encompasses all leading effect genetic and phenoplastic variation (Fig. 19). In general, adaptive equilibrium describes the ambient adaptive response in allomorphism to any manifestation of a temporally and/or spatially dynamic selection profile. In this context, variation expressed purely as a function of the temporal element may be referred to as chronomorphism, so that the generic term allomorphism thus encompasses * Models of a dynamic environment (such as those proposed by Dempster, 1955, and Levene, 1953) have sometimes led to conflicting views on the effect of ‘‘coarse grained environments’’ on supposed evolutionary change (see Maynard Smith, 1998). It is essential to see that the spatial ‘‘patches’’ in such environments must not be seen as fixed points, but are themselves dynamic.
70
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
FIGURE 19 Allomorphism and configuration of the selection profile.
both temporal and spatial (‘‘stable’’) polymorphism. Adaptive equilibrium is thus explicitly described by the iterative trend in allomorphism over n generations: Dobzhansky (1970) stated that genetic diversity is maintained primarily not by new mutants, but by the advantage of heterozygosis. It is thus ‘‘kept up by natural selection, and also by environmental fluctuations in space and time that alter the signs and magnitudes of selective advantages and disadvantages.’’ Dobzhansky also held that there are two major kinds of genetic variability in natural populations: that maintained by mutation and controlled by ‘‘normalising selection,’’ and that maintained by ‘‘balancing selection,’’ the latter being stable polymorphism which cannot be explained by recurrent mutation alone. In contrast to the situation seen with allomorphism, many deleterious mutations tend to be maintained in populations because of the low level of selection acting against them, combined with recurrent mutation (as a consequence of which, allomorphism is clearly not synonymous with allelomorphism!). Dobzhansky’s view therefore encompasses adaptive capacity in ambient adaptive equilibrium for many, but not all, fluctuating or recurrent allelomorphs. Only a certain proportion of observed genetic variation is actively poly- or chronomorphic, as is clearly demonstrated by the proven existence of very many near neutral allelomorphs in natural populations. The generic term allomorphism therefore specifically excludes variation perpetuated by purely stochastic processes in the behavior of adaptive systems.
Temporal Domains in Adaptive Equilibrium In consideration of the overwhelming importance of time frame in determination of patterns of evolutionary change, adaptive equilibrium may now be usefully analyzed as a particular function of temporal wavelength and amplitude in the selection profile. It will be seen that different modes of expression are largely controlled by conditions in these variables.
5. ADAPTIVE EQUILIBRIUM
71
The relationship between mode of periodicity in the selection interface and adaptive response identifies three fundamental domains of adaptive equilibrium, and it should be noted that any ‘‘general reference time frame’’ constitutes an artifact that is exclusively relevant to specific structure units and gene pools. 1. Primary Adaptive Equilibrium In primary adaptive equilibrium (period ⬍ t ⫽ periodicity of environmental parameters within the life span of the individual), we encounter variation corresponding to environmentally controlled variation of the phenotype in the adaptive response, as generally met by metabolic and behavioral adjustment within adaptive capacity. Within time ⬍t, adaptive systems must have the adaptive capacity to tolerate certain levels of misalignment in the external environment, by adjustment not only in the logistic response, but also in phenotype form. This adjustment is clearly beyond the domain of allelomorphism so far as this particular time frame is concerned, but it can nevertheless be realized in terms of a dynamic epigenetic response to externally generated, nongenetic determinant signals (phenotype plasticity). This situation will be examined in greater detail when we go on to investigate extrinsic determination factors affecting development (Chapter 11): The monocotyledon Plantago lanceolata is well known for its ability to display gross phenotypic variation according to habitat, producing short, broad leaves in heavily grazed or trampled ground, and elongate, narrow leaves in ‘‘rough’’ conditions. While some component of this is ‘‘microgenetic,’’ much of it is phenoplasticity. ‘‘Phenoplasticity’’ is thus the mechanism for adjustment within a narrow temporal frame, although primary adaptive equilibrium is also expressed in the plastic relationship between behavior and the external environment: This is reflected in learning, when new neurons are created in response to experience; Gilbert (1997) refers to learning as ‘‘an environmentally adaptive component of the nervous system.’’ 2. Secondary Adaptive Equilibrium In secondary adaptive equilibrium, the existing genotypic repertoire of the gene pool is capable of a dynamic response to changing selection regimes in the external environment. Periodicity in the range ⬎t 씮 T thus constitutes the fundamental substrate for genetic allomorphism in the adaptive response as manifested in frequency fluctuations of allelomorphic genes, and this clearly constitutes the main focus for the genetic component of ‘‘adaptive capacity in dynamic equilibrium’’: The polymorphic variation in Cepaea, Biston, and Maniola quite clearly belongs to this category, and similar examples have been very widely documented in population genetics. Dobzhansky (1970) observed that the fitness of some Drosophila mutants can be greater or lesser than the wild type, according to varying external environments. Dobzhansky and Pavlovsky (1958) also found that chromosomal inver-
72
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
sion variants in Drosophila apparently allow temporary ‘‘pseudolinkage’’ between genes adapted to transient environmental factors. Genotype specific habitat selection must also greatly broaden the conditions for allomorphism when pleiotropism is involved, or when the relevant alleles are closely associated on the chromosome (Hedrick, 1989): Experimental evidence from de Souza et al. (1970) has demonstrated habitat preferences in Drosophila larvae that are linked to polymorphism. Secondary adaptive equilibrium is therefore expressed in fluctuating gene frequencies within the domain of the existing gene pool, and this may encompass behavioral as well as structural traits. 3. Tertiary Adaptive Equilibrium In tertiary adaptive equilibrium, adaptive capacity for recurrence of transiently ‘‘lost’’ genotypes with positive selection regimes of longer periodicity in the range ⬎T 씮 ⬍Tc (periodicity greater than fixation time, less than speciation time) is maintained via recurrent mutation. This criterion, in fact, forms the functional boundary of adaptive capacity: Data on genetic variation in beak size in two species of Darwin’s finches in the Galapagos Islands (Geospiza magnirostris and G. fortis) show directional change in the adaptive response in terms of unusual changes in the wet–dry season cycle affecting seed production in the birds’ food resource, with return to normal phenotype distributions on reversal of climatic conditions at a later stage. This may be presumed to involve parameters of adaptive capacity implicating recurrent, rather than novel mutation. Adaptive capacity for tertiary adaptive equilibrium thus clearly resides in recurrent mutation, and it is interesting to consider the view of Lande (1975) that quantitative variation in general is maintained through recurrent mutation, rather than selection. This is a somewhat extreme claim, considering the capacity of a periodic selection profile to maintain allomorphism. However, Lande’s hypothesis does serve to indicate the level to which recurrence may contribute to the domain of minor additive (that is, nonallomorphic) variation. The existence of mutator genes which apparently operate in a site specific manner (Cairns, 1988) strongly supports the view that adaptive capacity is partly linked to recurrent mutation. In summary, Primary adaptive equilibrium ⫽ phenoplasticity and behavioral/ metabolic adjustment Secondary adaptive equilibrium ⫽ ambient genetic allomorphism Tertiary adaptive equilibrium ⫽ recurrent genetic allomorphism Adaptive equilibrium can thus be defined in general as comprising ongoing and recurrent genetic allomorphism plus ‘‘phenoplasticity.’’ It excludes the
5. ADAPTIVE EQUILIBRIUM
73
passive logistic response, along with any stochastic element impinging on the system. Its relationship to the adaptive response in general is shown in Fig. 20.
FIGURE 20 Adaptive equilibrium in relation to the total adaptive response.
At a later stage, we shall also consider that a larger domain beyond that of tertiary adaptive equilibrium accounts for much disjunct periodicity in the adaptation interface, much of which has frequently been interpreted in terms of ‘‘linear evolution,’’ and which links to realization of adaptive potential (as distinct from adaptive capacity).
Variation Where does the familiar term variation fit in with our concept of a hierarchy of levels of adaptive equilibrium? Variation lies in the range of phenotypes complementary to the allelomorphic complement of a given gene pool, as expressed by the state of adaptive equilibrium existing between gene pool and environment within any chosen temporospatial reference frame, but it also includes allelomorphic states perpetuated through action of a heterogeny of stochastic factors. ‘‘Variation’’ thus refers to true allomorphism plus the influence of randomization factors (as well as to rare and frequently transient changes of the evolutionary kind). More traditionally, ‘‘variation’’ has been used in the sense of referring to any randomly chosen group of phenotypes, rather than being defined exclusively in the context of unbiased population sampling. It is thus a heterogeneous descriptive term, with little value in evolutionary analysis. It is important to realize at this stage that not all apparent variation is selectional, since it can arise through stochastic factors alone. It is also significant that the special theory sometimes termed ‘‘neo-Darwinism’’ and synthesized by Haldane, Fisher, and Wright in the early part of the twentieth century
74
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
was largely based on observations concerning either nonadaptive or allelomorphic variation perpetuated in a state of adaptive equilibrium. This component of the general theory will become a major topic of discussion in Chapter 13.
STRUCTURAL AND LOGISTIC STRATEGIES OF ADAPTIVE CAPACITY The concept of the ambient selection interface as a fundamentally tripartite and anisotropic structure interacting with the allelomorphic gene pool in the context of adaptive capacity is essential to an understanding of the nature of the adaptive response. Having identified adaptive equilibrium in both logistic and structural components of the adaptive response, it is now necessary to consider how the architecture of the anisotropic selection interface provides a suitable substrate for maintenance of the adaptive state, bearing in mind the probability that much variance–selection interactivity is likely to center around a selection interface of this kind. It has been useful up until now to consider modulations of logistic and structure capacities as being separate logistic and structural components of the adaptive response. However, these mechanisms clearly play linked roles in adaptation, forming an integrated strategy for maintenance of the adaptive state in the face of a changing external environment. It is now necessary to look more closely at the role played by the logistic component of adaptive capacity in adaptive equilibrium.
Logistic Adaptation and Adaptive Equilibrium How does the strategy of adaptive capacity compensate for the highly dynamic behavior of anisotropic niche profile in view of the influence of stochastic factors in the adaptive system? With reference to these questions, it is instructive to analyze the adaptive state in terms of the logistic component of the adaptive response. Given that a gene pool may possess some structural deficiency in one or more components of the adaptive state (for example, a low developmental viability) or else face predation and interspecific competition against which there is no defense, it appears axiomatic that one simple means of balancing such a deficiency would simply be to increase fecundity. The balancing effect of increasing the intrinsic rate of increase thus explains the usually large discrepancy between fecundity and ‘‘expected rate of increase.’’ Logistic adjustment in r therefore must perform a fundamental function in balancing against deficiency in the adaptive state, in terms of counteracting negative viability and also counteracting stochastic mortality factors: Dobzhansky (1970) expressed the view that ‘‘differential fecundity is in principle, as powerful a selective agent as differential survival mortality.’’* * In retrospect, it would now be better to use the term ‘‘substrate’’ rather than ‘‘selective agent’’ in this context.
5. ADAPTIVE EQUILIBRIUM
75
The balancing function of logistic adjustment can be better understood by analyzing the adaptive state A by designating the fundamental adaptive state as Af ⫽ survivorship capacity of a gene pool in the absence of any logistic adjustment with respect to ambient mortality factors. Af is then a subset of A (the probability of survival), exclusive of the balancing effect of increased fecundity to offset stochastic mortality factors, the logistic contribution being encompassed by the real adaptive state Ar. Thus, if Af ⫽ survivorship in the absence of logistic adjustment, then fecundity will ideally modulate to 1/Af, which latter is linked to the logistic attractor for r in adaptive systems (since if r is too large, populations will tend to ‘‘crash’’ through ‘‘overshoot,’’ and if too small, N may also converge on zero). The structural and logistic components of the real adaptive state are therefore additive in their interactive effect. The differential between real and fundamental adaptive states illustrates how A always carries some element of reciprocity, Af being inadequate for survivorship in any other than an artificial environment, not only in terms of abiotic inputs to the adaptive system, but also in relation to the minor adaptive niche. Owing to the discrepancy between fundamental and real adaptive states, some varying fraction of fecundity must relate to compensation for a heterogeny of deficiency factors, logistic adjustment balancing against potentially negative effects arising from stochasticity manifested in the dynamics of the external environment, as well as in endogenous nonviability factors. ‘‘r-selected gene pools’’ are thus those that tend toward the domain of logistic adaptation, their adaptive state being strongly influenced by the logistic component of the adaptive response. In contrast, ‘‘K-selected’’ gene pools tend toward competition on the basis of heritable differentials in the structural domain, thus manifesting an adaptive state that is less reliant on logistic balance (see also Chapter 6). Clearly, the size of the differential between fundamental and real adaptive states must have a crucial bearing on the evolution of adaptive systems: The relationship between fecundity and adaptive capacity is exemplified by such examples as wind-pollinated plants, as also by certain root feeding moths (Hepialidae) which scatter immense numbers of eggs at random—and of course in the very high fecundity values manifested in a great many marine organisms (especially invertebrate species). All of these examples clearly link to the very high levels of stochastic mortality found in certain types of environments.
Structural and Logistic Components of Adaptive Capacity in the Fecundity Offset Strategy What is the actual relationship between the real adaptive state and fecundity? To answer this question, we must continue to accept that a great many sexually reproducing organisms live in unstable environments. In a perfect adaptive system, (fecundity) would be equal to 2 in order to replace the parent generation. However, assuming that sexual reproduction constitutes an adaptive response to environmental imperfection that can never be completely bypassed, we shall call this optimum replacement figure , for a more realistic system. Therefore, as the fundamental adaptive state Af 씮 1.0, so 씮 , and when Af ⬍ 1.0, fecundity must increase.
76
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
A useful index expressing the degree to which mortality is in fact having to be logistically (or ‘‘structurologistically’’) compensated may then be /. In reality, / is probably generally less than 1.0 (perhaps often very low). Given that fecundity may normally be increased in order to compensate for deficiency in structural adaptation in the face of environmental instability ( ⬎ ), it is now necessary to examine this ‘‘offset’’ figure in more detail. It can in fact be shown that the fecundity offset value is really a bipartite structure that is not in fact exclusively linked to the logistic component of adaptation, notwithstanding the fact that ‘‘structural overshoot’’ is perhaps less apparent than logistic. The greater the expression of stochastic–dynamic behavior in the selection profile, the more the structural component of the adaptive response will tend to constitute an ‘‘approximate fit’’ only, and the more this will tend to be reflected in fluctuating gene frequencies in the domain of adaptive capacity. This fact therefore identifies the existence of a composite offset complement in fecundity where, specifically in the adaptive equilibrium model, we have also to compensate for loss of superfluous ‘‘bad fit’’ genotypes in each generation. Some increase in r is thus needed in order to compensate for loss of genotypes that are sometimes positively selected and sometimes not—this being quite different from the situation where, for example, some element of the fecundity offset simply balances against developmental nonviability that is not subject to any fluctuation with respect to selection. Thus, it may often be a useful strategy to generate a larger population, not only in terms of mortality factors against which no defense exists other than ‘‘safety in numbers,’’ but also in terms of generation of a range of ‘‘potentially useful’’ genotypes. This element should clearly be interpreted as a property of the gene pool which constitutes an emergent corollary of genic selection within the boundary of the larger gene pool (following Williams, 1966). One component of the composite fecundity offset strategy in which fecundity is increased in order to offset stochastic mortality factors is therefore concerned with a dynamic selection interface acting in terms of the structural component of the adaptive ensemble, while another counteracts the effects of mortality factors against which there is no defense other than the logistic. There must also be a varying degree of interplay between structural and logistic components of the adaptive response with respect to the anisotropic selection interface, and this will depend on the nature of stochastic activity present in the adaptive system in question. Adaptive equilibrium is thus expressed by the changing pattern of adaptation described by the adaptive response to selection profile over a given time course, not only in terms of logistic, but also of structural variation within the domain of adaptive capacity. Selective and Nonselective Offsets of Fecundity Following the above analysis, the value of can be regarded as holding numerical offsets against a heterogeny of mortality factors, including that concerned with maximizing the adaptive strategy of the range of genotypes available within the adaptive capacity interacting with an anisotropic selection profile, and another balancing ‘‘nonadaptable mortality factors against which
5. ADAPTIVE EQUILIBRIUM
77
no such structural response exists.’’ As already stated, there must also be some degree of interaction between these two offsets. That fraction of the logistic component of adaptive capacity that is structured to balance against ‘‘nonadaptable’’ (i.e., stochastic) mortality factors is the nonselective offset of fecundity. Similarly, that numerical offset balancing stochastic mortality factors affecting the expression of the structural component of adaptive capacity with respect to genetic allelomorphism in adaptive equilibrium constitutes the selective offset. The logistic component of adaptive capacity is thus expressed in selective and nonselective offsets of fecundity, these being linked, respectively, to fluctuating deterministic and stochastic environmental influences in the adaptive system which jointly reflect the differential between fundamental and real adaptive states. The nonselective offset even acts to counteract intrinsic factors arising from the genome itself (for example, with respect to the mutational load incurred through accumulated deleterious mutations). In particular, the selective offset of fecundity is that adjustment to fecundity such that variation in the external environment can be met through the mechanism of recombination in the allelomorphic component of the genome (see Chapter 13). This relates to parameters for which some adaptive strategy exists, but where the adaptive response is imperfectly adjusted with respect to the irregular periodicity of survivorship factors in the niche interface. The fecundity offset strategy can thus be more explicitly understood as being a structurologistic adaptive response, and its significance lies in its relationship with the gene pool selection interface. The genetic element in the
FIGURE 21 Selective and nonselective offsets of fecundity.
78
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
above scenario can also be illustrated with reference to the genotypic output as shown in Fig. 22.
FIGURE 22 Selective and nonselective offsets of fecundity in the architecture of the gene pool.
In the simplified model of Fig. 22, the selective offset lies in a range of three genotypes of a single gene locus, only one or two of which actually have a probability of encountering positive selectional interaction within a given time frame; the nonselective offset is an additional factor that takes into account the ambient level of stochastic mortality in the adaptive system. The simplest structure for three genotypes at a locus (with no dominance) can only equal 4, and thus the nonselective offset is simply twice the size of the gene pool, with 50% random mortality. In this system, selection acting in a single generation does not favor all genotypes simultaneously (for example, the heterozygote may be positive in one generation, and negative in another). A more realistic system must involve n haplotype frequencies, to which we must also add a variable influence of stochastic mortality factors, leading to a need for dynamism in the recombination strategy itself (hence with a variable crossing-over strategy also coming under genetic control; see Chapter 13). The above scenario can accordingly be expressed in terms of the equation set for an adaptive system, in terms of a larger number of haplotype frequencies—assuming that recombination frequencies are here only an approximation to ‘‘good fit’’ with environmental fluctuations for all but a few leading effect loci.* * The genetically effective population size (generally denoted Ne, following Wright, 1940) is not equivalent to the N of the Lotka–Volterra equation set, but is that subset of the same which actually contributes in a genetic sense to the succeeding population. In gene pools with a large nonselective offset, ‘‘effective N’’ will clearly be much smaller than in a more deterministically sculptured gene pool.
5. ADAPTIVE EQUILIBRIUM
79
The Intersect between Selective and Nonselective Offsets of Fecundity The situation of a failed adaptive strategy within the selective offset clearly identifies an intersect between deterministic and stochastic factors, in that stochastic events also play a part in determining the outcome of interactions for the selective offset. The intersect selective offset/nonselective offset takes the form shown in Fig. 23. Why is stochastic mortality not just the nonselective offset itself? The difference is that ‘‘failed strategy’’ mortality factors are due to potentially adaptable factors that are subject to periodic behavior, whereas the true nonselective offset also incorporates factors against which no adaptive strategy exists. The intersect is thus the expected nonfit rate within the selective offset, and the nonselective offset sensu stricto is any additional stochastic mortality excluded from this.
FIGURE 23 Average expected stochastic loss within the selective offset effectively forms part of the nonselective offset.
The relative status of the selective and nonselective offsets is fundamental to the outcome of longer term evolutionary events, since the nonselective offset contains factors which affect the dynamics of the coefficient of selection, and thus also of evolutionary rate (see Chapter 18).
The Fecundity Offset Strategy and an ‘‘Index of Adaptation’’ It has been shown above that the probability of survival of a gene pool must take into account developmental and metabolic viability linked to the structural response (and thus to ‘‘true’’ adaptation), and that it also includes balance against ‘‘nonadaptables,’’ linked to the logistic response. The concept that the adaptive state A is ‘‘some function of the adaptive strategy of a gene pool’’ clearly needs expanding in order to explicitly reflect the fundamentally different roles played by the logistic and structural elements of adaptation. The real adaptive state (Ar ⫽ probability of survival of a gene pool) must now be supplemented by some index linked to goodness of fit in the fecundity offset strategy, thus reflecting the differential between fundamental and real
80
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
adaptive states. How, then, can Ar be modified to encompass differentials in adaptive strategy in this domain? We may begin by considering that the size of the fecundity offset is very approximately inversely proportional to ‘‘goodness of fit’’ between a gene pool and its environment, justifying this by observing that if r is moving toward that level at which a high level of unpredictability is invoked, then this may be an adaptive response to a level of stochastic factors in the adaptive system whereby extinction is threatened. Logistic adaptation has been selected over structural, and the fundamental adaptive state has been diminished. In the above approach, we are of course really only comparing adaptive strategies within Ar ⫽ 1.0 states, in terms of the degree to which logistic adaptation is required in order to counteract deficiencies in the fundamental adaptive state. However, the probability of survival of a given gene pool may be equal to 1.0, yet that gene pool may not be fully adapted to its environment in the structural sense, in that a ‘‘poor fit’’ adaptation interface is compensated for by logistic adjustment through existence of a large fecundity offset. The adaptive state might then be more fully understood through consideration of the relative roles of deterministic and probabilistic factors in the structure of the fecundity offsets, based on the premise that, in general, the higher adaptive state is that which maximizes the deterministic against the probabilistic component of adaptation. In this context, a useful adaptive index might therefore be more accurately reflected in terms of the differential between fundamental and real adaptive states. The degree to which ‘‘blind logistic adaptation’’ is used to counteract unpredictable mortality factors may thus more accurately reflect the adaptive state of the gene pool through an appropriately chosen adaptive index Ai, which seeks to compare two dimensions of adaptation, one defined by the structural component, the other, by the logistic. However, this assumption clearly requires closer examination. Major and Minor Attractors and the Adaptive Index To what extent does / (see p. 76) as an index of structural versus logistic adaptive capacity really reflect the probability of longer term survival of a gene pool, and what is the evolutionary significance of this index? Is the adaptive state particularly dependent on the structural or on the logistic component of adaptation in the longer term of evolution—and what evidence is there for any preferred predominance of one or other of these two factors? Should it arise that the structural component of adaptive capacity is indeed ‘‘the leading factor,’’ could it then be that an ‘‘all structural’’ strategy constitutes the ideal one for maximization of the adaptive state? Or should the adaptive system in reality oscillate between two attractors as an expression of ‘‘the appropriate balance between structural and logistic elements in the fecundity offset strategy’’ (this situation thus forming the causal factor behind the latter)? To answer the above questions, it is obviously necessary to consider the separate roles of the selective and nonselective offsets of fecundity in the Ai equation, and here it will also be crucial to consider the index / in terms of the time span held by adaptive capacity itself, as a possible further step toward a more realistic index of the adaptive state of a gene pool. Given that ( ⫺ )
5. ADAPTIVE EQUILIBRIUM
81
is the total offset value, we should therefore be comparing the long-term adaptive capacity residing in Os /( ⫺ ) and Ons /( ⫺ ), respectively.* In view of the fact that a purely logistic strategy may intuitively seem to constitute a weaker option than the structural, it would perhaps be surprising that structural adaptation may not necessarily form the attractor for A in the adaptive system. The arguments for and against supremacy of the structural offset factor are as follows: For A high logistic component will lead to low evolutionary rate, in that environmental change is being met by logistic and not structural modification, thus implicating a likely long-term disadvantage. Very low evolutionary rate does in fact seem often to link with a hostile environment, suggesting that ‘‘retained structural primitiveness’’ is probably a poor adaptive strategy in the very long term (a view that is seemingly confirmed by the observation that many ‘‘extant primitives’’ are rare and/or of restricted distribution; see Chapter 18). Similarly, relict gene pools probably do not become extinct through mere logistic deficiency, but through structural misalignment arising as a corollary of overreliance on compensatory logistic adaptation (Chapter 20). Adaptive capacity for a gene pool or lineage to control and manipulate the environment is primarily a function of the structural component. An all logistic strategy might also allow buildup of negative viability in the gene pool. A logistic offset adjustment serves to balance against loss of (structural) fitness, only so long as a balanced relationship between N and K is maintained. Against Just as it is possible to postulate negative feedback in the logistic strategy, so too the structural adaptive response can be seen to have certain detrimental corollaries. One major problem with iterative structural modification lies with ‘‘overspecialization’’ resulting from reciprocity in the adaptive response (see Chapters 1 and 20). Retention of a more generalized structural state through low evolutionary rate may thus actually conserve structural flexibility, so that logistic plasticity seems a necessary component of long-term survivorship. Many lineages have, in fact, clearly manifested long-term survival on the basis of a high logistic component in adaptation, without either becoming ‘‘overspecialized’’ in the structural domain or being ‘‘rare.’’ The hypothesis of ‘‘the structural component manipulating the logistic’’ assumes that the eventual outcome of such a strategy is not environmental catastrophe! The Solution Despite a prediction that the selective offset might seem to be the most likely candidate as a ‘‘leading effect’’ in the fecundity offset strategy, it would appear that an all structural adaptive response may not be sufficiently resilient in view of sudden changes in the external environment. And indeed, it seems very likely that no natural adaptive system would be stable enough to allow * Where Os ⫽ selective offset, and Ons ⫽ nonselective offset.
82
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
complete loss of logistic adjustability, especially with respect to the emergence of novel stochastic mortality factors. We must therefore now consider the likelihood that capacity to be able to adopt a selective and/or nonselective offset strategy ‘‘as and when needed’’ must constitute the true optimum in terms of longer term survivorship prospects. However, it is nevertheless clear that this capacity would be easier for a predominantly structural regime to attain than for an exclusively logistic one, in that the selective offset might readily convert to a purely logistic one if the environment becomes more unpredictable, whereas this flexibility clearly does not appertain to the nonselective offset. The correct solution to the above question therefore seems to be ‘‘a middle road’’: enough structural adaptation to allow selection to respond genetically with respect to fluctuating environmental factors, along with the capacity to provide purely logistic adaptability that can compensate for other factors in the dynamics of the environment, while at the same time preserving structural flexibility. Long-term survivorship thus depends on maximization of a structural response strategy, while concurrently keeping the purely logistic option open. The ratio of structural to logistic components of adaptive capacity may thus lie in a state of dynamic equilibrium between two attractors (structural and logistic), either of which can predominate at any given time. However, of these, the structural is probably the ‘‘major’’ attractor, and the logistic, the ‘‘minor’’ (see also Chapter 1). The gene pool thus tends toward the logistic attractor as a function of the level of stochastic mortality factors, but also gravitates toward the structural attractor whenever adaptive capacity allows. Given that adjustment of the nonselective offset is probably an easily realized modulation from a base in the selective offset, the true adaptive index might therefore lie primarily in adaptive capacity for expansion or contraction of the variance of Os /( ⫺ ), measured within a time frame not greater than that of the rate of environmental change—in which case, 2[ Os /( ⫺ )] over lineage time might be the best index of the adaptive state. The values of Ai ⫽ 2[Os/( ⫺ )] can now be seen to reflect an adjustable input which links to both logistic and structural components of the adaptive response, and a high adaptive index so defined thus explicitly describes affinity with the structurologistic attractor. The adaptive state is now more appropriately expressed as an index that has some link to capacity for longer term survivorship, although Ai is not simply a fixed high or low value. The adaptive index is also linked to diversification of the adaptive niche via the selective offset of fecundity, as well as to the degree to which adaptive systems tend toward a state of chaos. The main significance of the index Ai will be shown at a later point to be linked to its effect on evolutionary rates, in the substrate of evolutionary change (see Chapter 18). The Adaptive Index and the Adaptive Response How do Ai values as defined by the above equation fit with the nature of the adaptive response? Where the selective offset is low, this may clearly often be associated with an unstable niche interface linked to high levels of stochastic mortality, a situation that will be correlated with high levels of ‘‘drifting’’ microgenetic variation. Differentials in the fecundity offset strategy thus have
5. ADAPTIVE EQUILIBRIUM
83
a bearing on the way in which niche architecture links to selectional activity in the adaptive system and, through this, also on how adaptive strategy determines evolutionary rate. Almost paradoxically, it can also be shown that higher values of the adaptive index may in fact offer less opportunity for initiation of anagenetic evolution, in that population space may frequently come to be dominated by adaptive equilibrium within the allomorphic genotype (see Chapters 14 and 19). In the adaptive index, we see a reflection of the changing balance between major and minor attractors, and thus also of long-term propensity for survivorship (see Chapter 20). Of course, ‘‘long-term’’ does not imply ‘infinite’ (and there can therefore be no ‘‘ultimate index of the adaptive state’’ of a lineage!). Adaptive Equilibrium and the Gene Pool Concept The concept of selective and nonselective fecundity offsets further confirms the role of the gene pool as the ‘‘epicenter of adaptation,’’ in that the optimum adaptive state clearly lies with the survivorship capacity of a range of potentially viable genotypes by virtue of a necessity to maintain flexibility in adaptive capacity against a dynamic niche profile. Here, it is only necessary to see that, for a dynamic selection curve, fitness is higher for a gene pool retaining capacity for recombination, than for any homozygous population. If homozygotes AA and BB are, respectively, the fittest genotypes in alternating generations, then retention of both alleles is clearly essential to longer term survival: This situation can be further investigated from a simple hypothetical example. Let gene A have a greater capacity for reproduction irrespective of its value to fitness in general (for example, by virtue of a sexual selection trait that masks some other deficiency in fitness). An anomaly must exist here, since the course of selectional activity must actually depend on the leading allelomorph gene (for which sexual selection may well provide no visual ‘‘marker’’). However, in the context of the selective offset of fecundity, we can see that some ‘‘reproduction winners’’ will also ‘‘hit the leading allelomorph target’’ through recombination, while others that do will carry only the false marker. Clearly, those genotypes which combine both ‘‘false’’ and ‘‘genuine’’ traits are those best suited to survive. This means that selection continues to act in favor of fitness in general, and evolutionary change will therefore not be channeled into any ‘‘selfish’’ domain, other than in the very short term. The gene pool thus constitutes the epicenter of adaptive capacity, and not the gene—despite the fact that this situation arises as a corollary of apparently ‘‘selfish’’ activity in the face of a dynamic environment! The gene pool thus remains an outcome of organic (rather than biotic) adaptation (see Williams, 1966), in that it evolves primarily as a corollary of individual selection, and not through group selection. The foregoing scenario is permitted by the allelomorphic structure of the gene pool in the context of the fecundity offset strategy, which allows coexistence of various recombinatory subsets of the fundamental genotype that would
84
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
not be manifested in a gene pool with ‘‘perfect fit’’ in relation to the external environment (see Chapter 13). Inclusive fitness similarly resides in the gene pool, and not in the gene. The complex isotropic selection interface model (Chapter 4) may indeed manifest forces both favoring and opposing ‘‘selfishness,’’ but evolution can only proceed when the balance is against this criterion. The model in question is thus, in fact, a superset of the inclusive fitness model. Finally, the fecundity offset strategy can be seen to clearly confirm the validity of the adaptive capacity concept introduced in Chapter 1 (see also Chapter 3).
MAIN POINTS FROM CHAPTER 5 1. Allomorphism is defined as the genetic component of adaptive capacity, as this relates to the state of dynamic balance between gene pool and external environment. 2. Most selection controlled change in gene pools is directed toward ‘‘adaptive capacity in dynamic equilibrium’’ as monitored via the allomorphic component of the gene pool, rather than being concerned with true evolutionary change. This mechanism is manifested in both genetic and phenoplastic variation. However, the concept of allomorphism excludes stochastic, nonselectional components of variation. 3. Primary to tertiary domains exist for adaptive equilibrium, according to different configurations of the selection profile. Most genetic allomorphism lies in the secondary domain, but the functional boundary of adaptive capacity lies with tertiary adaptive equilibrium. 4. A fecundity offset strategy is manifested in both structural and logistic inputs to the state of adaptive equilibrium, owing to the gravitation of gene pools toward logistic and structural attractors. This is reflected in the existence of selective and nonselective offsets of fecundity. 5. The fundamental adaptive state excludes any input from the logistic component, which latter is included in the real adaptive state. 6. It is useful to define an index of adaptivity which reflects the dynamics of the fecundity offset strategy as this relates to longer term survivorship. However, as selection can only be ‘‘blind to the future,’’ there can be no ‘‘ultimate coefficient of adaptation.’’
6
THE CLADOGENETIC SELECTION INTERFACE
It has been useful to simplify discussion of the behavior of adaptive systems by ignoring interactions between competing gene pools. However, the potential for lineages to undergo spatial diversification and cladogenesis is self-evident. What happens when adaptive divergence in the gene reservoir on the spatial plane of niche creates large scale hybrid depression, or when gene pools diverge in allopatric populations such that capacity for reproduction is lowered in the event of subsequent sympatry? Either divergence must reach a limit, or else the gene reservoir must ‘‘split’’ in some way. These manifestations of change clearly derive from activity originating within an anisotopic selection interface that constitutes a demand for cladogenesis. This is no longer movement within adaptive equilibrium, but actual evolutionary change involving differentiation of the genome such that there is disjunct divergence in the genotype or phenotype, either via the action of epigenetic homeostatic mechanisms or through the erection of reproductive barriers, as an adaptive response to forces in the anisotopic selection interface. Certain aspects of cladogenesis have been widely investigated in the light of discoveries in the fields of classical Mendelian and population genetics. However, owing in part to certain limitations inherent to the latter disciplines, the true domain of cladogenesis has not been evident, nor has the full meaning of cladogenesis as a process been adequately understood. The behavior of cladogenetic systems clearly has a general application in evolutionary theory, since many selectional regimes resulting in modulation to gene frequencies or in gene loss are derived from cladogenetic activity of one kind or another. The full extent of this can best be appreciated following the tenets of adaptive systems theory.
85
86
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
ORIGINS OF THE CLADOGENETIC FORCE Cladogenetic forces arise from spatial dynamism in the selection interface, as a function of the adaptive response to particular configurations of the anisotopic selection profile (see Chapter 4). The nature of this dynamism is diverse, the result being that more than a single route to cladogenesis is possible. There are, in fact, two principal models of the cladogenetic process, in which the spatial differential lies in s (sympatric) and S (allopatric) domains, respectively (see Chapter 3).
The Cladogenetic Selection Interface Whereas the complex isotropic selection interface implies a single ‘‘compromise solution’’ to antagonistic selectional forces, cladogenesis demands two solutions to a scenario in which separate structural attractors relate to spatially discrete niche space for independent sectors in the gene reservoir, the key mechanism for which is eradication of capacity for generation of the hybrid state. When an anisotopic selection interface invoking hybrid depression is involved, we may also encounter a selectional force acting against a maladaptive hybrid state which carries no complementary niche space in the external environment, along with a greater or lesser component of developmental nonviability. The X and Y axes of the selection vector diagram (Chapter 4) will clearly now constitute independent allelomorphic traits in the fundamental anisotopic selection interface. Here, there can be no resultant vector since X and Y can only be acting at two or more discrete phenon points linked to noncontiguous niche space. This structure may, however, also present an obligate selection vector ([XY]), owing to the allelomorphic structure of the genotype, whenever sympatry occurs. Again, we use a simple orthogonal model as an analogy.
FIGURE 24 The obligate selection vector ([XY]) representing the hybrid state in a cladogenetic selection interface.
The hybrid selection vector thus has a directionality that is determined entirely by the endogenous genetic environment, which can ideally be taken as being halfway between the two parent homozygote states. In quantitative
87
6. THE CLADOGENETIC SELECTION INTERFACE
terms, the contribution to fitness of the hybrid state is determined as a function of the external selective environment and endogenous factors in viability, plus any element of frequency overshoot involved. Its quantitative value is then the resultant of opposing positive and negative components.
FIGURE 25 Resultant of the obligate (hybrid) selection vector as a function of opposing elements.
In more general terms then, the cladogenetic selection interface is essentially an anisotopic one in which there is • Either a centrifugal selectional force arising from hybrid depression, where the hybrid state is less fit than either homozygote • Or a spatial dimension in gene reservoir niche space; that is to say, the gene reservoir manifests allopatry in which some element of genomic divergence is occurring in noncontiguous gene pools It is also of great significance that in either situation, separate gene pools (or subgene pools) may also manifest some qualitative property linked to unshared niche space. In the first scenario, cladogenetic forces clearly arise from the fitness difference between homogeneous and split gene pools. In terms of the gene pool selection interface, the difference is W(X ⴙ Y ⴙ 2[XY]) W(X ⴙ Y ) If the value of the above expression is ⬎1.0, then we have a centripetal selectional force favoring homogeneity of the gene pool. If it is ⬍1.0, then there is a cladogenetic selection interface expressing a centrifugal element which favors splitting of the gene pool. In the latter instance, the cladogenetic element clearly arises ultimately in the balance between centrifugal and centripetal cladogenetic forces, the former being that component of the anisotopic selection interface tending to favor differentiation of the genome in terms of hybrid depression
88
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
(and also of the niche intersect), the centripetal cladogenetic force being that component favoring unity through hybrid vigor. In this scenario, both genomes are selectively positive, but the hybrid state decides whether or not both parent states will tend to be perpetuated without modification. With the generation of larger scale cladogenetic forces, we also tend to observe an emerging dichotomy between quantitative and qualitative phenotypic differentials. This situation is caused, in particular, by the differential between genetic incompatibilities appearing in the sympatric versus allopatric domains. We have now seen that there are in fact two ways in which ‘‘centrifugal forces’’ can be said to exist in adaptive systems. There are antagonistic centrifugal selectional forces residing in the complex isotropic selection interface and acting jointly on a single phenotype state (see Chapter 5), and there are also combined centripetal/centrifugal forces acting on the gene pool through allomorphism, heterozygote advantage, hybrid depression, etc., in the anisotopic selection interface—the latter tending to favor the presence of more than a single phenotype state in the gene pool, thus giving rise to a cladogenetic selection interface. In the first scenario, the solution will gravitate toward a single optimization point for traits with a high contribution to overall fitness (or a continuous distribution around that point, where contribution to W is low), while in the second scenario, gene pool splitting will clearly be favored. The centrifugal force residing in the second model above clearly has a centrum in the hybrid state, frequently incurring the unstable condition of hybrid depression (which latter acts against the balancing effect of hybrid vigor). Here, there are n genes affecting n traits, conforming to an anisotopic selection interface with principal components in the spatial domain, which could be resolved either through splitting of the genome or else via internal homeostatic adjustment. In the allopatric model (gene pools of a gene reservoir diverging in noncontiguous regions of niche space), we also witness the evolution of cladogenetic forces in the complete absence of any capacity for the expression of hybrid depression. Here, the ‘‘obligate XY vector’’ is absent, and the principal components of the X and Y vectors (as they affect speciation) become prezygotic isolating mechanisms diverging in allopatric gene pools. At this stage, we can see that the allopatric model could include two resolutions: one in which full speciation occurs entirely within the allopatric state, and another in which incomplete reproductive isolation leads to pressure for speciation in the neosympatric state (namely, as the allopatric state converges on the sympatric). It also follows that speciation is an unlikely outcome in the state of plesiosympatry (where we would probably witness homeostatic solutions to antagonistic selection pressures rather than genome splitting). Centripetal and Centrifugal Selectional Forces and Cladogenetic Drive The tripartite structure of the sympatric cladogenetic selection interface is due to a combination of unshared niche space and simultaneous existence of a niche intersect factor—that component of the cladogenetic selection interface affected by niche overlap between competing genotypes or gene pools, and forming the exogenous component of the centrifugal cladogenetic force (see
6. THE CLADOGENETIC SELECTION INTERFACE
89
above). In approaching the problem of the dichotomy between a shared and unshared limiting resource, we also come to confront the problem of the contribution to fitness, both of ‘‘competition space’’ and niche space unique to specific genotypes or gene pools interacting within the same adaptive system. Under what circumstances does adaptational divergence within the gene pool actually generate cladogenetic selectional forces? Looking at the single allelic locus situation, there has to be some force opposing elimination and favoring perpetuation of the weaker genotype of a positive allelic pair. When a new allelomorph is positively selected, the parent allele may or may not tend toward elimination through fixation of the new allele, depending on whether or not the two allelomorphs contain some degree of independence in terms of unshared niche space. If the niche intersect is ⬍1.0, the old allele may be readily perpetuated, but if it tends to 1.0, it will tend to be eliminated in the absence of any element of hybrid vigor providing a centripetal force. Thus although if there is hybrid depression there will be a centrifugal force, the proportion of unshared niche space present is clearly highly significant in deciding whether or not mutual survival is possible. Clearly, centrifugal and centripetal forces arise specifically in the niche intersect zone, while areas of unshared K also impart some element of directionality to the behavior of cladogenetic systems. In general then, the centripetal component in the cladogenetic selection interface (unshared niche space plus hybrid vigor) favors perpetuation of the hybrid state and unity of the gene pool, and the centrifugal component (niche intersect plus hybrid depression, also divergence in allopatry with respect to prezygotic isolating mechanisms) favors elimination of the hybrid state or speciation (Fig. 26). The above is clearly only one possible scenario for the infraspecific case (since many alleles only differ in quantitative aspect), but it is clearly more highly probable for gene pools evolving in the allopatric state and rejoining in neosympatry: Dobzhansky (1970) similarly recognized two types of ‘‘balancing selection’’: heterotic balance (⫽ centripetal polymorphism) and diversifying selection (⫽ one component of the centrifugal element), ‘‘Diversifying selection favours different genotypes in different environments.’’ We shall now conclude that the balance between centripetal and centrifugal selectional forces of the above kind constitutes cladogenetic drive, in the degree to which the net centrifugal element favors occlusion of the hybrid state. To what extent can cladogenetic drive also be said to occur in the purely allopatric situation? Here, we must consider the evolution of prezygotic isolation factors as a further component of cladogenetic drive, since this factor also derives from selectional forces tending to partition the lineage gene reservoir and is thus centrifugal in nature. Hence cladogenetic drive has to be defined in terms of forces arising in either the sympatric or allopatric domain. The Extrinsic Component of Cladogenetic Drive in the Niche Interface As we have seen, a tripartite selection interface clearly lies at the root of the sympatric centrifugal force, specifically in the zone of the niche intersect,
90
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
FIGURE 26 Centrifugal and centripetal elements in the anisotopic selection interface (unshared niche space in hybrid state not shown).
from which premise we can identify two extrinsic properties, both of which form a highly significant input to cladogenetic drive: 1. The niche intersect factor itself: the actual extent of niche overlap for two competing genotypes or gene pools, which equals the intersect of set K1 with K2.* A small intersect may mean little probability of generation of the hybrid state. Similarly, the amount of adaptive niche space peculiar to each parent gene pool determines the degree of influence of any niche overlap on the strength of the centrifugal force, in terms of the probability of being able to bypass the intersect zone by virtue of shifting niche parameters for one or both competitor gene pools. 2. Niche ‘‘intensity’’: the relative ‘‘degree of penetration’’ of the niche for each genotype with respect to the intersect region as a function of the extent to which niche hyperspace is expressed (see Chapter 2). There are, in fact, two main factors to consider here: (a) the efficiency of nutrition location (behavioral component; for example, ratio of time spent in parametric as against subparametric niche * Using K as an approximation to niche (since this identifies the essential limiting resource component).
91
6. THE CLADOGENETIC SELECTION INTERFACE
space) and (b) the energy utilization factor (‘‘metabolic component’’; for example, velocity of ingestion process, efficiency of energy conversion or assimilation). The above factors will have an important directionalizing input to cladogenesis, in that the stronger competitor will tend to oust the weaker from the zone of niche overlap in any speciation event. As already stated, the extrinsic element also has a large part to play in the allopatric evolution of differentials between gene pools, and this will be particularly true in the dichotomy between heterokaryosis and simple heterozygosis (see below), whenever hybrid depression in the neosympatric state is involved. Endogenous Cladogenetic Drive and Hybrid Depression Although it has been possible to show the origins of cladogenetic forces as being partially a function of niche interactions, it is also apparent that various endogenous factors must also be active within the framework of the gene pools concerned. Of these, negative developmental viability resulting from hybridization between noncompatible or only partially compatible genomes is clearly a major influence. While developmental deficiency can in general be offset by logistic balance, this is clearly not possible when the negative element is located in the hybrid state, and this incapacity for logistic balance of hybrid depression must in fact constitute the basis for a large contingent of cladogenetic drive. The endogenous component of the centrifugal force is thus that element arising from the degree of genotypic differential between competing genotypes or gene pools and resulting in depression of viability for that component of the genotype expressing heterozygosity or heterokaryosis. The genotypic or gene pool classes may be presumed to have specific areas of adaptive niche. Looking at this in the context of a simple single allele divergence, the further apart the AA and aa classes are in developmental terms, the more likely the Aa genotype will contain a large negative developmental component in the adaptive state: 씯AA WAA
Aa ⬎
WAa
aa씮 ⬍
Waa
Negative developmental viability thus identifies a major endogenous element in the cladogenetic selection interface in the form of a centrifugal force tending to favor suppression of the hybrid state, and clearly the presence of genetic capacity to evolve dominance is part of the adaptive response to this scenario. The above model must of course be extended to the multigenic case, with respect to gene pools arriving at a neosympatric state. Here, suppression of the hybrid state itself is a question of more profound evolutionary changes than mere acquisition of epigenetic homeostasis in dominance. Heterozygosis and Heterokaryosis in Cladogenetic Drive The hybrid state may clearly be positive or negative in terms of the coefficient of selection, and two different expressions of hybridity exist with respect to the organization of the genome, namely, in heterozygosis and heterokaryosis.
92
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
The former constitutes the differential between homologous chromosomes as expressed by allelomorphism alone, whereas the latter is that differential manifested in more complex misalignment between partially nonhomologous chromosomes (the latter situation more probably originating from allopatric changes occurring in the genome): Dobzhansky (1970) investigated chromosomal sterility with regard to translocation hybrids, reporting deficiencies and deleterious duplications in some meiotic products. He also observed that hybrid Drosophila pseudoobscura ⫻ D. persimilis males are generally sterile. Here, meiotic chromosome pairing is variable and only a single division occurs. Only when the X chromosome is paired with parent autosomes do testes develop normally, and the more the autosomes include the other species, the smaller the testes. Thus, all chromosomes carry genes concerned with fertility, and depression of the latter may often form a large component of the endogenous element in the development of cladogenetic drive. The influence of negative heterokaryosis in cladogenetic drive is again underlined by evidence from isozyme studies showing a likelihood that regulatory genes from one species may be incompatible with structural genes from another (Nei, 1987). Heterozygosity and heterokaryosis also form the collective categories: Hybrid vigor Hybrid depression
Positive heterozygosis/heterokaryosis Negative heterozygosis/heterokaryosis
Negative heterozygosis and heterokaryosis can be distinguished as shown in Fig. 27. Negative heterozygosis concerns the presence of two allelic states of a single gene locus that are homeostatically compatible but selectionally deleterious in combination, whereas negative heterokaryosis concerns nonsense combinations of nonhomologous chromosomes where genetic divergence has evolved in allopatry, and where the chromosomes have been restructured to such an extent that they may be unable to take part in normal meiosis. The latter situation frequently leads to fertility loss, owing to 50% or so of the
FIGURE 27 In negative heterozygosis (left), the heterozygote is less fit than either homozygote. In negative heterokaryosis (right), chromosomes are meiotically unmatched.
6. THE CLADOGENETIC SELECTION INTERFACE
93
heterokaryotic gametes being entirely deficient in certain genes. Negative heterozygosis and heterokaryosis both form an important part of the postmating isolating mechanism of the speciation process, and frequency overshoot (see below) is also part of hybrid depression, a general scheme for which latter is shown in Fig. 28.
FIGURE 28 Components of hybrid depression.
As indicated above, there may also be positive heterozygosis/heterokaryosis, as, for example, with the centripetal element or with sex determination. The Centripetal Force and Hybrid Vigor As we have seen, the hybrid state for two competing genotypes or gene pools often carries a negative selective state, or else a fitness value lying between that of the two homozygous classes. However, it may alternatively relate to unshared niche space or to metabolic superiority relative to either homozygote or gene pool. This is the centripetal selectional force, tending to maintain rather than suppress the hybrid state and favoring balanced polymorphism in the adaptive response. The centripetal force may also tend to suppress genome splitting, indicating that cladogenesis derives from the degree to which balance between centrifugal and centripetal selectional forces determine the degree of cladogenetic drive: Levene (1953, also Li, 1955) showed that in a gene pool adapted to two different environments, a sufficient condition for stable polymorphism is that the harmonic mean of the viabilities of the heterozygotes be greater than that of the homozygotes. Dobzhansky (1970) stated that many dominant lethal genes have been found to be ‘‘heterotic,’’ showing that hybrid superiority has the capacity to perpetuate even deleterious alleles (as, for example, with malarial resistance in human hemophilia mutants). Dobzhansky also suggested possible ‘‘physiological and ecological sources’’ as the causes of heterozygote advantage, citing experiments on Drosophila pseudo-
94
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
obscura which indicated various differential survivorship factors at play, including rate of development, fecundity, and longevity. Hybrid vigor is thought to be frequently due to overdominance (where the heterozygote is fitter than either homozygote), including ‘‘associative overdominance’’ (where different inbred lines become homozygous for different deleterious alleles). In this situation, a centripetal force can be seen to operate within the domain of endogenous gene homeostatic properties alone. The centripetal force is often simply a function of positive heterozygosis, although inversion heterozygotes probably constitute positive heterokaryosis, in which more complex factors must be involved.
The Cladogenetic Selection Interface in the Equation Set of the Adaptive System An understanding of cladogenetic drive and of the cladogenetic selection interface in general can most readily be modeled in the equations of the adaptive system, in the context of the sympatric gene pool. The Cladogenetic Selection Interface and Partitioning of K The simplest situation with which to understand the nature of the spatial differential in the adaptive response is to examine the situation where the selection profile is anisotopic: Spatial loci Genotype
s1
s2
AA
⫹
⫺
aa
⫺
⫹
This situation clearly constitutes a stable polymorphism in the adaptive response, leading to a higher adaptive state for the gene pool by virtue of ‘‘diversifying selection.’’ Where is this genetic scenario actually located in the modified Lotka–Volterra equation set? (See chapter 5) Clearly a noncompetitional element must now be introduced. The Lotka–Volterra equations have already been shown to identify the selection coefficient in terms of differentials in r and in heritable elements in the 움 factors. However, not all selectional differentials between genotypes are linked to competition, since some new genotypes may expand the contours of the existing niche, thereby bestowing a positive change which involves no element of competition with the parent genotype. W is therefore not exclusive to the intersect K1:K2, nor to the selection interface so defined, since there may be additional factors in fitness linked to unshared niche space. Indeed, in ‘‘pure’’ polymorphism, two genotypes can only be maintained at constant relative frequencies if both also manifest an unshared K complement, which may be located in the homozygote classes or even in the heterozygote state, as in centripetal polymorphism (see above). Consequently, W is only determined by the modified Lotka–Volterra equations when no such factor is involved and the genotypes in question are in total competition with respect to niche space. W is thus a composite term, which must also be made to encompass the
95
6. THE CLADOGENETIC SELECTION INTERFACE
‘‘unshared K’’ factor. To incorporate ‘‘unshared niche space,’’ K must accordingly be split, so that there has to be a K value shared by competing genotypes (K1⫹2) plus a K value unique to each niche (K1 and K2). The equation set of the adaptive system may now be set out in algorithmic fashion for the polymorphism-with-dominance situation, assuming that the polymorphism in question does not constitute the whole niche: a. Some part of N1 is controlled by dN1/dt ⫽ rn1 ⫻ N1t⫺1 ⫻ (K1 ⫺ N1t⫺1)/K1, and some by rn1 ⫻ N1t⫺1 ⫻ (K1⫹2 ⫺ N1t⫺1 ⫺ 움21 ⫻ N2t⫺1)/K1⫹2 b. Similarly, part of N2 is determined by dN2/dt ⫽ rn2 ⫻ N2t⫺1 ⫻ (K1 ⫺ N2t⫺1)/K1, and some by rn2 ⫻ N2t⫺1 ⫻ (K1⫹2 ⫺ N2t⫺1 ⫺ 움12 ⫻ N1t⫺1)/K1⫹2 The above expands the structural component in the equation set of the adaptive system by incorporating additional terms discriminating between shared and unshared K in the Lotka–Volterra equations, thus extending the domain of the selection interface beyond that of direct competition. The revised equation set now identifies a noncompetitive differential between interacting genotypes or gene pools, determining W, not only as a dynamic variable, but also as one that is only partially expressed in the 움 factors. W can therefore be directly determined solely when there is no noncompetitional element in the system in question. The modified Lotka–Volterra equation set serves to define a more complete adaptation interface of which the selection interface is a subset, in that the unshared K element allows coexistence of two only partially competitive states manifesting an ongoing selectional differential. ‘‘Unshared K’’ lies in the adaptation interface, while only shared K lies in the selection interface. The model given above is of course a simplification, in that the majority of variance–selection interactions obviously involve, not allelic, but haplotype frequencies. However, the actual conclusions drawn above will be valid well beyond the domain of the minimum model. From the above observations then, the behavior of the cladogenetic selection interface must be a function of (a) the 움 factors of the hybrid state and (b) the size of unshared K, relative to shared K for all genotypic states. Cladogenetic Drive in the Equation Set of the Adaptive System To identify the locus of the centripetal and centrifugal forces in terms of density dependent selection in the Lotka–Volterra equations, it is only necessary to look at the simple situation where niche space corresponding to the anisotopic selection interface can be examined in relation to a single allelic pair. Continuing to use K as an approximation to adaptive niche in the equation set of the adaptive system (K ⫽ limiting resource ⫽ that part of the total niche actually entering into the logistic equation), hybrid vigor or depression then arises in the fitness relationships of W values of homozygous and heterozygous phenotypes, as a joint function of niche intersect and the adaptive state of the heterozygote genotype (WAa). In the anisotopic selection interface: K1
K1ⴙ2
K2
AA
Aa
aa
96
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
if WAa ⬎ WAA, Waa (and K1⫹2 is large), then cladogenetic drive results from a centripetal force; if WAa ⬍ WAA, Waa, then the system experiences a centrifugal force. We must now extend this approach to encompass that situation where compound heterozygosis and heterokaryosis exist, and a large cladogenetic force is generated. Following on from the equation set introduced above (where K1⫹2 ⫽ shared K, and Kn ⫽ unshared K ), 움13,23 are additional factors describing the selectional differential between hybrid and parental genotypes or phenotypes. The anisotopic selection interface is described by an equation set in which the adaptive state of monomorphic populations is higher than that of the hybrid population. Thus, in a population where N1 and N2 have high levels of shared K, the genotype corresponding to N3 has the capacity to lower the adaptive state of the combined gene pool. This situation thus models the cladogenetic selection interface when the rn3 and 움13,23 factors reflect hybrid depression.
FIGURE 29 Definition of the selection differential 움13, 23.
The above modified equation set thus clearly identifies the locus of the centripetal and centrifugal forces in the adaptive system, in expressing the distribution of the K dimension as the ‘‘functional niche’’ in cladogenetic activity, and also in identifying the locus of the centrifugal force in the adaptive state of the hybrid genotype or gene pool. Differential adaptational viabilities of genotypes or gene pools may thus be understood as being implicit in the 움 factors in the Lotka–Volterra equations, so that both extrinsic and endogenous elements are expressed therein, given the presence of an additional complement relating to the hybrid state. In this situation, hybrid depression constitutes the leading factor for the quantitative input to cladogenetic activity in the anisotopic selection interface, while the directional component is expressed in the vector model (see Fig. 25).
6. THE CLADOGENETIC SELECTION INTERFACE
97
CLADOGENETIC CAPACITY AND POTENTIAL Cladogenetic drive (see above) does not ‘‘cause’’ cladogenesis, but only ‘‘favors’’ it, since actual divergence at any level can only occur if there is adaptive capacity or potential for this to happen. Cladogenetic capacity and potential constitute special subsets of adaptive capacity and potential in general, and as such, they similarly manifest both extrinsic and endogenous components.
The Nature of Cladogenetic Capacity and Potential Cladogenesis is clearly influenced by a complex of antagonistic centripetal and centrifugal forces promoting cladogenetic drive and by the architecture of the selection profile, and this mechanism can therefore be viewed as an adaptive response in which capacity and potential must exist in order to resolve antagonistic selectional forces arising in the gene reservoir. Cladogenetic capacity is linked to that component of adaptive capacity which relates to resolution of selectional conflict in the cladogenetic selection interface. It is a genotype or gene pool interactive function of the sum selection profile ⫹ adaptive capacity in which not only niche structure, but also the developmental viability component of the adaptive state (and thus, the endogenous component of adaptive capacity) play a significant role. Cladogenetic capacity is manifested in capacity for homeostatic adjustment within the boundaries of the existing genome. The allelomorphic structure of the genotype must contain significant inputs to cladogenetic capacity, since some component of adaptive capacity may balance against hybrid depression via recombination or rearrangement of genetic material on the chromosomes, or through homeostatic adjustment. Cladogenetic potential is likewise linked to an innate adaptive potential for resolution of cladogenetic drive.* It is frequently concerned with the more complex problem of multiple allelic differentials and complex karyotypic dichotomies that have evolved in the allopatric scenario and which cannot be resolved other than by speciation. Cladogenetic capacity and potential are thus defined in terms of adaptive capacity or potential for cladogenetic drive to be resolved, either through gene homeostasis or else via speciation. We have now effectively separated ‘‘factors demanding’’ (cladogenetic drive) from ‘‘factors facilitating’’ cladogenesis, the latter lying with endogenous and extrinsic components of adaptive capacity or potential. In this scenario, the ‘‘centripetal and centrifugal forces’’ already mentioned are seen to be selectional attractors toward which actual propensity for movement may or may not be present. The Extrinsic Component of Cladogenetic Capacity and Potential and ‘‘Free, Adjacent Niche Space’’ Where speciation involves some degree of niche shift in one or both competitor gene pools, a potential to move into free, adjacent niche space must also * A full definition of the boundary between ‘‘capacity’’ and ‘‘potential’’ will require deeper analysis of the means by which novel major changes are effected in the adaptive ensemble (see Chapter 7).
98
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
form an important component of the extrinsic factors facilitating resolution of cladogenetic drive, and this must play a particularly significant role in realization of cladogenetic potential. The hybrid depression element in the centrifugal force cannot, for example, always be satisfactorily resolved in the absence of free niche space. This is a further, extrinsic component of cladogenetic capacity or potential which must also contribute to directionality in the adaptive response. The Endogenous Component in Cladogenetic Capacity and Potential and Developmental Nonviability The developmental component in the cladogenetic selection interface residing in negative heterokaryosis cannot be resolved in lack of genetic capacity or potential for genomic change in that domain. In this, we identify capacity and potential for developmental homeostasis or for reproductive isolation as constituting the principal endogenous components for resolution of the centrifugal force in the cladogenetic selection interface. The presence of potential for the development of species isolating mechanisms is of prime significance to the question of endogenous elements in cladogenesis (see below).
REALIZATION OF CLADOGENETIC CAPACITY AND POTENTIAL It is now clear that realized cladogenesis is derived from resolution of cladogenetic drive via cladogenetic capacity and potential. This can be summarized as shown in Fig. 30.
FIGURE 30 The complex of factors leading to cladogenesis: cladogenetic drive to cladogenetic capacity and potential.
It is furthermore necessary to ask, what factors decide how cladogenetic capacity or potential is realized? Although it is obvious that speciation constitutes one possible outcome of the above, it has also emerged that resolution of cladogenetic drive can also occur within the boundary of the gene reservoir. Furthermore, not all apparently species level outcomes actually involve separation of two lineages, since two apparently emergent species may simply gravitate toward racial merging, or else one may simply oust the other from the adaptive
6. THE CLADOGENETIC SELECTION INTERFACE
99
system. Realization of cladogenetic capacity and potential can occur at several levels, from infraspecific to divergence of major evolutionary lineages.
Axial and Tangential Components of the Adaptive Response to Cladogenetic Drive A general model can seek to identify all aspects of realization of cladogenetic capacity and potential. However, this model must also relate to different domains of cladogenetic activity in a different manner. Given that several different outcomes of cladogenetic behavior are possible (see above), it must be that the behavior of a particular cladogenetic selection interface depends particularly on the balance existing between centrifugal and centripetal forces. If cladogenetic drive is slight, and the interface is a plesiosympatric one, then a purely infraspecific resolution may be possible on the basis of genetic homeostasis alone. However, if cladogenetic drive is greater and allopatry is implicated, then cladogenetic potential must determine whether or not two lineages can coexist. This question of balance is universal but can be most clearly illustrated in that situation in which emergent species are involved. Firstly, we must consider the possibility of racial merging. Genomic anastomosis occurs when two emergent gene pools merge into a common gene pool via compound mutual allelic substitution and when homeostatic readjustment in the epigenetic environment involving ‘‘exchange of best alleles of each emergent genome’’ and reorganization of dominance hierarchies occurs. This mechanism could clearly be biased toward one parent gene pool in the context of any racial merging event. The next higher level is clearly that of the complete divergence of two emergent species, a process that can be called binary resolution (speciation), with respect to cladogenetic drive (with a 1:1 survival of emergent species). If, however, a very large difference in cladogenetic potential exists between two emergent gene pools, then one may simply replace the other in the context of species or cladogenetic substitution (the 1:0 element in resolution of cladogenetic potential). Cladogenetic substitution thus occurs when one discrete gene reservoir entirely replaces another in its adaptive niche as a result of selectional differentials with a leading effect in a cladogenetic selection interface. The above scenarios are clearly based on discrepancies in the balance between cladogenetic forces affecting gene pools in different ways, and it is this question of balance that we must now pursue further. In this context, we are now additionally concerned with the question of whether the parent classes are of approximately equivalent adaptive states. Clearly, this may often be approximately true in the context of ambient microevolution, but it is of special interest in the context of the longer term behavior of cladogenetic forces that there may be a larger dichotomy between ‘‘best’’ and ‘‘second best’’ pathways out of cladogenetic conflict. Cladogenesis may thus tend at times to manifest two quite unequal potential resolutions, the axial and tangential, depending on the quantity/quality of free niche space available to each (these being greater for the axial, and lesser for the tangential). This dichotomy arises from inherent differentials in cladogenetic capacity and potential. Therefore, although these resultants may actually be approximately equal for ambient speciation events, we must in a general model also consider the existence of a greater domain in
100
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
which considerable potential for divergence may lie in the gap between axial and tangential resultants. The preceding concept can be explained more clearly with reference to the binary resolution model (see above), in consideration of the interactive qualities of two genotypes or incipient gene pools occupying partially intersecting niches. In this model, endogenously generated axial and tangential cladogenetic potentials for realization of cladogenesis are now further facilitated by the dimensions of free, adjacent niche space. Here, resolution of the cladogenetic force will clearly depend, not only on the degree of negative selectional force encountered in the hybrid class and in the size of the ‘‘unshared K’’ component for both homozygote and parent genome classes, but also on the degree to which adaptational change can permit exodus from the niche intersect state via accessible niche space in the external environment. In this, we witness a capacity to reduce or eliminate the intersect itself.
FIGURE 31 A niche intersect which is large in relation to the K1 gene pool, but small in terms of the K2, at the same time indicating that capacity for resolution of the centrifugal force lies partly in existence of free, adjacent niche space (which is again limited for K1 and large for K2).
Successful cladogenetic realization may accordingly depend on the existence of niche space particular to each genotype or gene pool in the niche interaction, and clearly this may lie within the extrinsic component either of adaptive capacity (existing unshared niche space) or of adaptive potential (free, adjacent niche space). The entire niche interaction underlying cladogenetic activity in speciation is thus seen as a function of niche intersect, independent niche space, and free, adjacent niche space [and this appears to have a preferred
6. THE CLADOGENETIC SELECTION INTERFACE
101
axial (K2) and tangential (K1) resolution in the example shown in Figure 31 above]. Cladogenetic Drive and the Concept of Benign and Hostile Adaptive Niches As we have just seen, spatial relationships of the niche interface may at times give rise to divergent axial and tangential potentials in terms of adaptational strategy. This could simply mean a quantitative differential, but it could also constitute a qualitative one in terms of, for example, a switch from one prey or food plant to another. More significantly for certain processes of macroevolutionary change, binary resolution of cladogenetic drive could sometimes mean a fundamental differential in adaptive strategy relating to a dichotomy existing between the benign and hostile adaptive niche. The ‘‘hostile’’ adaptive niche is that in which penetration of competition and selection is low because of a high incidence of stochastic mortality factors. In contrast, the ‘‘benign’’ niche holds a larger contingent of deterministic, selectional interactivity. These we may now choose to link to tangential and axial resolutions of cladogenetic potential. In the axial (⫽ benign) niche, stochastic mortality is low and selectional interactions in population dynamics are high, tending to maximize niche realization through competition where the niche is expanding as a fraction of the total environment—the stronger genome thus tends to take over intersect niche space, forcing the weaker into a more restricted and hostile zone. In the benign niche, the fundamental adaptive state is thus converging on the real, and the structural component of the adaptive response predominates. The tangential (⫽ hostile) niche contains higher levels of stochastic mortality, and thus little selectional interactivity, tending to maximize niche realization within a zone of lower competition complementary to a smaller and/or contracting niche—the ‘‘weaker’’ genome thus tends to retract into relatively less functional niche space. Here, the fundamental adaptive state is diverging more widely from the real, and the logistic component of adaptation predominates, this adaptational scenario being one in which there is ‘‘stochastic override’’ of natural selection as well as of mortality in general. In the hostile niche, competition may be further diminished through an ‘‘impenetrability factor’’ equivalent to a state of sequestration from the action of selection. Given that positive gene mutation constitutes ‘‘the substrate’’ and selection, the ‘‘reagent’’ of evolutionary change, a niche in which there is shelter from predation, competition, weather conditions, etc., is one in which both substrate and reagent may be present, but interaction occurs with a low level of probability only. The benign niche is more open to selectional activity through efficient exploitation of a ‘‘popular’’ limiting resource (shared by many competitors) and is additionally removed from random mortality factors. Such regimes are thus not to be construed as being ‘‘benign’’ in the sense that high levels of mortality are excluded, but only with regard to facilitation of a deterministic organism–environment interaction with respect to the structural component of adaptation—and it should thus be realized that the terms benign and hostile refer solely to penetrability of selection.
102
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
Since the ‘‘benign’’ state is the deterministic choice, and the ‘‘hostile’’ one is that in which logistic adaptation is pitted against stochastic factors, this must also reflect greater movement toward the major (structural) attractor in the competitively superior emergent species. This dichotomy may often constitute an improved definition of the terms axial and tangential, so that the ‘‘size of free, adjacent niche space’’ may frequently constitute a qualitative rather than quantitative attribute, at least with regard to longer term evolutionary events. The differential between axial and tangential resultants in the largest domain of cladogenesis can be summarized in the context of a cascade described by the following parameters: Axial (as benign niche)
Tangential (as hostile niche)
Expanding into ‘‘larger’’ niche volume High Af, reflecting deterministic, structural adaptive response Higher Ai in variance of Os /( ⫺ ) Tending toward structural attractor
Contracting into ‘‘smaller’’ niche volume Low Af, reflecting stochastic, logistic adaptive response Lower adaptive index Tending toward logistic attractor
In this model then, the axial resultant tends to maximize niche realization through competitive superiority, and the tangential, through avoidance of competition and predation via a logistic strategy. It does not, of course, follow that qualitative differentials of the above kind exist in every cladogenetic selection interface, and a qualitative differential may actually only be ‘‘different food plant,’’ etc.; consequently ‘‘axial’’ is not automatically equivalent to ‘‘benign.’’ In fact, the degree to which more deeply seated niche factors penetrate resolution of cladogenetic potential underlies the differential between ambient speciation and larger scale cladogenetic events. The axial and tangential resultants of cladogenetic potential may at times, however, manifest identifiable links with the nature of the adaptive response at higher levels, and then broadly contiguous elements of the environment may become compartmentalized via specialization in the context of cladogenesis. In this scenario, we can observe a cladogenetic cascade in that train of mechanisms in the organism–environment interaction tending to give rise to axial and tangential (and potentially, benign versus hostile) resultants in the realization of cladogenetic potential (Fig. 32). The above scenario is of great importance for an understanding of the macroevolutionary activity of adaptive systems, with implications extending well beyond the domain of cladogenesis itself. It is interesting also to consider that the existence of axial and tangential components of the resolved cladogenetic force may constitute support for the view that structural and logistic attractors may have respective ‘‘major–minor’’ status in the evolution of adaptive systems. In this context, the adaptive index Ai (Chapter 5) probably does not contribute directly to the long-term survivorship of a lineage so much as acting to determine the life span of a species, in that the axial choice in binary resolution may, on average, have a greater chance of establishing a stable lineage niche. r- and K-Selection and the Benign–Hostile Adaptive Niche The concept of axial and tangential resultants of the centrifugal selectional force clearly links to the concept of r and K strategies and also to the question
6. THE CLADOGENETIC SELECTION INTERFACE
103
FIGURE 32 The cladogenetic cascade in its relationship with the benign and hostile adaptive niche.
of evolutionary rate. However, the actual role of the r versus K dichotomy has been the subject of much confusion in the past. The dichotomy ‘‘r- versus Kselection’’ is in fact often used simply to denote high versus low reproductive rates, rather than the differential between constant versus variable environments: Brookfield’s model (1986) uses the Lotka–Volterra equations plus two parameters ( q ⫽ size of regularly repeated nonselective crash in population size and x ⫽ time in generations between crashes). However, there is no change in relative abundance on the basis of this model. In contrast, experiments with Drosophila (Mueller and Ayala, 1981a,b) show that K-selected populations do in fact manifest higher growth rates than r-selected ones under K conditions, and, similarly, r-selected populations do likewise under r-selection. However, not all predictions of the experimental regime were fulfilled.
104
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
In the present interpretation, a ‘‘K-selected’’ population implies the presence of a selectable heritable differential between genotypes, even in a variable environment, whereas an r-selected regime does not. Thus, ‘‘r-selected’’ gene pools do not actually need to have higher growth rates than ‘‘K-selected’’ ones, since the fecundity offset strategy (Chapter 5) may be high in the latter (namely, in terms of a large selective offset component). Perhaps the most significant factor here is that the K limit (and thus also the selection interface) will have a much lower probability of lying in sub- or hypoparametric niche space in the hostile than in the benign adaptive niche (see Chapter 2); clearly this must have profound implications for evolutionary rate of lineage (see Chapter 18).
THE DOMAINS OF CLADOGENESIS It is evident that the resolution of cladogenetic forces is not confined to speciation, since cladogenetic activity may be expressed, not only in the speciational domain, but also in infraspecific genomic change and in postspeciational divergence. Cladogenetic forces may in the first instance be resolved through homeostatic mechanisms maintaining allomorphism. Second, binary resolution need not be resolved by complete elimination of the niche intersect zone, since the hybrid depression component of the cladogenetic force will cease once two gene pools have erected reproductive barriers (hence two species often show niche overlap). In the latter instance, we must identify gene pool isolation as the leading factor in determination of the functional boundaries between two emergent gene pools of a cladogenetic selection interface. It is also essential to see that resolution of cladogenetic potential does not end with speciation, since much niche modulation will in fact be postspeciational, and structural diversification may also follow the speciational event. Another possibility is, of course, that newly emergent species may differ in little else other than niche divergence, and whether or not this situation will be perpetuated will clearly depend on the degree of residual cladogenetic drive and cladogenetic potential: Dobzhansky (1970) described ‘‘sibling species’’ as good biospecies lacking morphological differentiation. The siblings Drosophila pseudoobscura and D. persimilis have ethological differences combined with sterility of males and other viability breakdown factors; each has its own chromosomal polymorphisms.
Minor and Major Cladogenesis—The Phenotypic and Genotypic Domains A simple anisotopic selection interface describes allomorphism perpetuated for one or more gene loci, its form being at least bi- and potentially tripartite in nature with respect to the spatial dimension of the adaptive niche of a gene pool. As we have seen, it is partly with the latter that cladogenetic
6. THE CLADOGENETIC SELECTION INTERFACE
105
drive lies. The same situation exists in a multiallelic situation, where two incipient gene pools manifest negative hybridism in the neosympatric state. In the first example, realization of cladogenetic capacity and potential may constitute nothing more than homeostatic adjustment within the contours of the gene pool itself, but in the latter case, cladogenetic pressure may lead to speciation. The fundamental similarity between these ‘‘minor’’ and ‘‘major’’ expressions of disjunct phenotypic divergence must not be overlooked, however, since both clearly constitute resolution of conflicting cladogenetic forces in the gene reservoir. In this scenario, selectional conflict involving simple heterozygosis will tend to be realized through evolution of dominance, and more complex heterokaryosis via speciation or cladogenetic substitution (see Chapter 14). It is now clear that cladogenetic activity may occur in three broad domains: 1. That resolved in an intraspecific mode by evolution of acquired dominance (some proportion of which may be derived from cladogenetic capacity alone). As stated by Givnish and Sytsma (1997), ‘‘Ecological and adaptive divergence can occur without speciation.’’ Here, we view this event occurring as a response to cladogenetic drive. 2. That involving speciation, always involving realization of cladogenetic potential. 3. That involving postspeciational divergence. Speciation to Postspeciational Divergence As we have just seen, minor (⫽ phenotypic) cladogenesis is that mode which incorporates only subspeciational microevolutionary change in the domain of genetic homeostasis. Major (⫽ genotypic) cladogenesis encompasses speciation plus that component of postspeciational divergence which expresses continued activity of the same cladogenetic selection interface which gave rise to the preceding speciation event in the first place. Thus, Minor (phenotypic) cladogenesis is the homeostatic occlusion of the hybrid state. Major (genotypic) cladogenesis is speciation, with actual elimination of the hybrid state, plus residual cladogenetic pressure continuing into the postspeciational domain. We can compare and contrast major and minor cladogenesis as shown in Fig. 33. In this context, minor cladogenesis can range from establishment of dominance with respect to a single allelic state, to reorganization of a substantial proportion of the parent genomes (for example, in the context of genomic anastomosis). Allomorphism (see Chapter 5) in which there is evolved dominance clearly derives from a cladogenetic selection interface with respect to the allelic classes, and such a scenario may commonly express adaptive equilibrium. Realization of cladogenetic potential occurs here as an expression of epigenetic homeostasis, so as to occlude the hybrid (heterozygote) state, in manifestation of acquired dominance (as distinct from the usually deleterious scenario of spontaneous
106
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
FIGURE 33 Major cladogenesis (top) removes the entire hybrid zone, whereas minor cladogenesis (bottom) merely removes negative heterozygous states from part of the repertoire of adaptive equilibrium and restores order into ‘‘nonsense heterokaryotypes.’’
dominance). The ‘‘dominance solution’’ is thus diagnosed as constituting a true resolution of cladogenetic selectional conflict, and it obviously applies only to the intraspecific case, where a genetic load in the recessive homozygote class can be homeostatically accommodated. As a broad approximation then, cladogenetic capacity may be largely realized in allomorphism via dominance, and cladogenetic potential links to speciation and an element in postspeciational divergence derived from the original cladogenetic selection interface (Fig. 34). This view will, however, also have to be expanded with closer examination of racial merging and species substitution (see Chapter 13). Adaptive Equilibrium and Minor Cladogenesis Competition is the struggle between genotypes or gene pools to occupy the maximum state of adaptation in a shared niche. A gene pool is always tending to increase its state of adaptation through allomorphism, by spreading
6. THE CLADOGENETIC SELECTION INTERFACE
107
FIGURE 34 Manifestation of cladogenesis in minor and major modes.
its dependence on limiting niche parameters over a progressively more diverse range of resources. The primary adaptive response in the genetic component of adaptive capacity may thus generally be structured so as to counteract intraspecific competition in the adaptive system through allomorphism, so lowering total mortality through ‘‘spread of K,’’ thus maximizing the adaptive index via the selective offset of fecundity. Allomorphism will occur in a gene pool containing allelomorphic genotypes which have access to areas of unshared niche resources, when different allelomorphs coincide with mutually independent temporal and/or spatial components of the adaptive niche, and where individual genotype fitnesses are together additive to overall gene pool fitness. Even when the heterozygote simply equals half of homozygote fitness, this may still generate a centrifugal force as a result of ‘‘frequency overshoot,’’ since recombination cannot adjust hybrid genotype frequencies to the selection profile. Centripetal polymorphism constituting allelomorphism perpetuated by the existence of a higher hybrid adaptive state than for either homozygote is, in contrast, intrinsically ‘‘anticladogenetic’’ in nature, but nevertheless may sometimes evolve as a solution to cladogenetic forces through modification of fitness in the hybrid state. The overall view of polymorphism (sensu lato) is that it frequently constitutes an adaptive response complementary to resolution of cladogenetic conflict arising in the anisotopic selection profile. And even where dominance is not involved, polymorphism still has the capacity to raise the adaptive state of the gene pool through ‘‘spread of K.’’ Chronomorphic regimes also serve to maximize the adaptive state, although not directly within the context of cladogenetic capacity or potential.
Major Cladogenesis—Speciation to Postspeciational Divergence The dichotomy between intraspecific and transspecific resolutions of cladogenetic capacity or potential clearly points to a fundamental division within cladogenesis itself, and it has already been shown that this dichotomy must arise from the quite different opportunities for genetic differentiation existing
108
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
in the sympatric versus allopatric situation. The speciational domain clearly requires further elucidation. The Influence of Neosympatry in Major Cladogenetic Potential Negative developmental viability clearly has a greater probability of arising when gene pools have evolved in geographic isolation for a long period prior to sympatry rejoin, so that factors such as dispersal, migration, and dynamism in the abiotic environment may often be the overriding factor in the development of major cladogenetic drive. With plesiosympatry, the gene pools in question have always formed part of the same gene reservoir, but with neosympatry, gene pools of a formerly sympatric gene reservoir have become allopatric then rejoined in sympatry at a later stage. The latter scenario clearly has a profound effect on the genotypic component of adaptive capacity or potential, since neosympatric systems will tend not to have evolved those homeostatic adjustments tending to support hybrid genotypes in sympatry. Since the incidence of novel mutation within allopatric populations clearly forms a highly significant input to selectional conflict in the event of neosympatry, the accumulation of nonhybrid compatible differentials in the genotype in the neosympatric state clearly constitutes a fundamental problem for cladogenetic potential, having a profound effect on endogenous cladogenetic forces. Consequently, a large interactive component exists between extrinsic and endogenous elements. Above all else, the dichotomy between plesiosympatry and neosympatry is reflected in a parallel differential between simple heterozygosity and complex heterokaryosis in the hybrid state. As we have already seen, this must have a large bearing on the question of whether a major or minor resolution is possible for cladogenetic drive. The capacity for the neosympatric scenario to influence speciation is now beyond question. Whether or not we also accept the possibility that total species isolation can evolve in allopatric gene pools (see below), it is nevertheless widely argued that much ambient speciation occurs in the neosympatric situation, at least in part because of the endogenous viability component of fitness acting to favor genome splitting in a developmentally negative hybrid genotype state. In this instance, some component of the hybrid problem will additionally be due to nonallelic genes that are incapable of expressing mutual allelism in the hybrid state, namely, where chromosomal rearrangement is implicated (as with inversions and translocations). Cladogenetic forces arising in the anisotopic selection interface will therefore be resolved either through homeostatic adjustment or through speciation, according to cladogenetic capacity and potential in the adaptive system in question, and the presence or absence of a neosympatric scenario must play a significant role in determining which strategy is actually invoked. In general, however, polymorphism will tend to arise in the sympatric situation (often to some extent via cladogenetic capacity), and speciation will occur in the neosympatric state, via cladogenetic potential (Fig. 35).
109
6. THE CLADOGENETIC SELECTION INTERFACE
FIGURE 35 Links between plesiosympatry and neosympatry and minor versus major cladogenesis.
A general summary of the differential between different levels of cladogenesis can now be made: Postspeciational divergence
Minor (phenocladogenesis)
Major (genocladogenesis)
Intraspecific gene pool origin, evolving in plesiosympatry One to several allelic differences Domain of negative heterozygosis Hybrid viability predominates in resolution Partly via domain of cladogenetic capacity
Interspecific gene pool origin, Interspecific competition evolving in neosympatry Multiple allelic differences (No hybrid state) Domain of negative heterokaryosis — Free, adjacent niche space predominates Domain of cladogenetic potential
Further progress into adjacent niche space Involves both cladogenetic and anagenetic potential
110
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
The above will, however, require some modification in light of the strictly allopatric model of the speciation process (see below).
MODELS OF THE SPECIATION PROCESS Speciation identifies irreversibility as a further propensity in realized major cladogenetic potential (bearing in mind the manner in which the dominance system of minor cladogenesis may presumably break down in the event of a reversal in the selection interface). How speciation actually occurs is a question that cannot be easily answered in terms of a single universal model, and the solution is consequently pluralist in nature. We have already considered the possibility of speciation occurring in allopatric divergence in prezygotic isolation mechanisms, either intrinsically or as a result of subsequent sympatry rejoin, and these are clearly quite different processes. In particular, speciation in the neosympatric state is clearly an actively evolved process, whereas speciation through evolution of a barrier in prezygotic isolation in the allopatric state is a corollary of activity occurring in such mechanisms as the specific mate recognition system, as argued by Paterson (1985). Unfortunately, the prospect of a unifying principle emerging from this overview has been much marred by the polarized stance taken by some supporters of both sides of the argument, as has often been the case in the past with many other aspects of evolutionary theory. In this context, it should also be noted that Dobzhansky and Mayr did in fact recognize the significance of divergence in prezygotic isolating mechanisms in their speciation theories. Criteria for evaluating the relative significance of these two seemingly ‘‘rival’’ hypotheses may also contain hidden difficulties; for example, good evidence exists for the predominance of sexual selection in the speciation process (see Chapter 15), but this does not necessarily help discriminate between the two main models that have been proposed!
The Reinforcement and Specific Mate Recognition Models Following Dobzhansky’s (1937a) theory that species formation is due to development of reproductive isolating mechanisms evolved in response to hybrid depression, Mayr (1942) proposed the biological species concept, which held that ‘‘species are groups of (actually or potentially) interbreeding natural populations that are reproductively isolated from other such groups’’ (also Mayr, 1963: ‘‘Species are not defined by the fertility of individuals but by the reproductive isolation of populations’’). Mayr (1982) later revised the biological species model to incorporate the adaptive niche concept, a move that was attacked by Hengeveld (1988) on the grounds that the latter is typological and undefinable. However, this criticism can surely now be met from the standpoint that the adaptive equilibrium of a species is complementary to a suite of niche parameters that are nonidentical with those of any other species, and which reside in adaptive capacity linked to the architecture of the gene pool (see Chapter 5).
6. THE CLADOGENETIC SELECTION INTERFACE
111
Dobzhansky also discussed the question of whether speciation occurs through isolation derived from a by-product of the accumulation of genetic differences between races or through active selection for reproductive barriers in the neosympatric state, citing good evidence for the latter theory, particularly in the context of reinforcement of preexisting partial barriers developed in allopatric populations. Where the cladogenetic force is linked to incipient, neosympatric gene pools, resolution has reached maximum expression when gene flow between gene pools approaches zero, and the speciation process has been manifested. The boundary of the gene pool must be determined by isolating factors arising in all dimensions within the selection interface. In particular, hybrid states will tend to be negatively adaptive as a function of the genetic distance between parental genotypes and kin, and sexual selection must both similarly act negatively against remote genotypes, the result being that these and other factors will tend to erect active behavioral barriers against gene flow between dissimilar incipient gene pools. Such mechanisms are obviously of paramount importance in understanding the speciation process. In the Dobzhansky–Mayr model then, prezygotic gene pool isolating mechanisms are presumed to evolve actively in order to eliminate a passively evolved negative hybrid class. Such nonviability does not necessarily lie in the structural domain, since many ‘‘biospecies’’ are known to be capable of producing hybrids (and the adaptive state of the hybrid class is, in any case, by no means limited to morphogenetic nonviability). Species isolating mechanisms (whether behavioral, structural, or metabolic) are viewed here as forming part of the adaptive response to viability deficiencies in the hybrid state as it relates to the natural environment. That alternative routes to the speciation mode are also possible is certain, and it is now necessary to consider other perspectives on speciation. Paterson (1985) rejected the Dobzhansky–Mayr synthesis, defining species as the most inclusive population of individual biparental organisms which share a common fertilization strategy, the specific mate recognition system, which latter evolves in allopatry independently of any need for any input from the postzygotic mechanisms visualized by Dobzhansky and Mayr as forming an integral part of the biological species concept. Paterson also criticized the Dobzhansky–Mayr view of the mechanisms underlying the biological species concept on the grounds that isolation was reputedly regarded by these authors as constituting ‘‘the primary function of traits defining a species.’’ However, as King (1993) points out, isolating mechanisms are regarded as being a product of geographic isolation and not a causal mechanism for production of species. Paterson thus assumed that in the biological species concept, postzygotic reproductive isolating mechanisms are selected for, which is not the case; as stated by King (1993), they are selected against. King also stressed the obvious importance of chromosomal change in promoting speciation as evidence in favor of the usual interpretation of speciation mechanisms implicit in the Dobzhansky– Mayr model. However, evidence for and against the specific mate recognition hypothesis often tends to be open to more than a single interpretation, and some of the data could be used alternatively to support either view! (See Lambert and Spencer, 1995, for a range of opinions in this area).
112
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
Profound genetic differences exist between certain Australian Rattus species (Baverstock et al., 1986) including chromosomal traits, but laboratory hybrids manifest increased vigor. Would some species hybridize in the wild if they became sympatric, and would the ‘‘more vigorous’’ laboratory hybrids survive in a natural environment? Different answers to such questions could either support or oppose the Paterson model. The dichotomy between the Dobzhansky–Mayr and Paterson hypotheses has clearly become linked to the differential between the relative importance in the speciation process of prezygotic as against postzygotic isolation mechanisms. Maynard Smith (1998) discusses this problem, comparing what he terms the reinforcement hypothesis (genetic divergence in allopatry reducing viability and/or fertility of hybrids, following Dobzhansky–Mayr) with the recognition in allopatry model (prezygotic isolation evolving rapidly in allopatry, independently of hybrid depression factors arising in subsequent neosympatry, following Paterson). In this context, Maynard Smith reviewed evidence from the work of Coyne and Orr (1989), who carried out tests on 118 species pairs of Drosophila, measuring genetic distance on the basis of number of amino acid substitutions plus degree of hybrid inviability or infertility and prezygotic isolation. The findings of Coyne and Orr were as follows: • Mating discrimination, sterility, and inviability all increase gradually with time, as a function of genetic distance. • For allopatric species pairs, pre- and postzygotic isolation evolve at similar rates. • For sympatric species, prezygotic isolation evolves more rapidly. Maynard Smith concluded that, on the whole, the data in question tend to support the neosympatry–reinforcement hypothesis, more than they do the specific mate recognition system model. In particular, the recognition in allopatry hypothesis would predict a greater degree of prezygotic isolation mechanisms evolving in allopatric species, whereas this factor is actually more evident in sympatric species pairs. Proponents of the Paterson model tend in contrast to stress the many uncertainties surrounding the observed behavior of hybrid zones between supposedly speciational gene reservoirs, although apparently failing to give due consideration to the prospect of total niche intersect between gene pools. It is instructive at this juncture to compare the specific mate recognition system option with the fundamental cladogenetic selection interface and to ask whether the former could actually be a direct derivative of the latter, rather than a completely independent option. It could be argued that the specific mate recognition mode of speciation might be derived from a niche dichotomy which was originally a subset of some larger, preexisting anisotopic selection interface in a eurytopic gene reservoir with a wide distribution. Evidence for this lies in the fact that mate recognition itself is partly based on niche differentials linking to mate search and/or chance encounter activity (as is perhaps evident in cases where laboratory matings succeed and natural ones do not occur). Minor cladogenesis could thus feed into major, as the spatial component gravitates
6. THE CLADOGENETIC SELECTION INTERFACE
113
toward allopatry for certain gene pools. Where dominance would constitute a solution in the sympatric situation, allelic substitution would tend to evolve in allopatric populations, and this could affect either future propensity for generation of hybrid depression or divergence in the specific mate recognition system: Koopman (1950) destroyed marked hybrids between D. pseudoobscura and D. persimilis in each generation and was successful in increasing reproductive isolation over n generations. Kessler (1966) repeated this experiment, but chose from observed mating frequencies on the basis of mating choice, obtaining both high and low isolation lineages. Most significantly, Dobzhansky (1970) interprets these experiments as working on preexisting mechanisms. Wallace (1954) and Knight et al. (1956) initiated ethological isolation between two strains of Drosophila melanogaster that had previously exhibited no mating discrimination, uncovering a weak yet statistically significant preference for homogamic matings over about 30 generations. The interpretation offered here is that the facility for reproductive isolation observed in the above experiments must have been part of adaptive capacity in the first place, so that the raw material of species isolation probably lies latent within the boundaries of adaptive capacity. The question of variability in prezygotic species isolating mechanisms thus becomes crucial to an understanding of the relationship between what seem to be two quite different models of the speciation process. It is perhaps significant that Paterson did in fact regard courtship related characteristics as being rigidly defined throughout the range of a species—a view that must remain controversial in view of the work cited above. Taking a much wider view then, speciation could be regarded as being that mechanism by means of which reproductive isolation between gene pools is either actively or passively established in the binary resolution of a major cladogenetic selection interface, and we must begin by assuming that a propensity both for hybrid depression and for effective divergence in prezygotic isolation mechanisms might be present to some degree in the adaptive capacity of a gene pool entering a cladogenetic selection interface. Given the existence of some plasticity with respect to prezygotic isolation factors, followed by occurrence of neosympatry associated with a certain degree of negative hybridization, the system would naturally tend to evolve away from the latter and toward the nonhybridizing element in the gene pool. In this way, the dynamics of the anisotopic selection interface may often tend to be influenced jointly by endogenous and extrinsic forces, according to the existing variance in both pre- and postzygotic mechanisms. In this view, there may then be a complete spectrum of speciational substrates between the ‘‘pure’’ Paterson model on the one hand, and the Dobzhansky–Mayr model on the other. The specific mate recognition system itself may thus be partly a function of cladogenetic capacity, in that some degree of prezygotic isolation may evolve in contiguous gene pools:
114
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
Certain ‘‘races’’ of insect species are attached to certain food plants, but they are not specifically distinct from other populations with a slightly different habit. Outcomes of the Paterson model also do not necessarily predict speciation. Where (as has been claimed) the specific mate recognition model produces new species with no fundamental niche divergence with respect to limiting factors, the likely outcome will be cladogenetic substitution in neosympatry, following the tenets of the competitive exclusion principle. Alternatively, if two species are only separated by the specific mate recognition system, and if substitution does not occur, there may well be a devolution of species isolation between them, manifested in racial merging. A further possibility may of course be that niche divergence could sometimes constitute a purely postallopatric isolation phenomenon, and then the specific mate recognition system would be operating quite independently of any link to the reinforcement model. However, where taxonomically ‘‘good’’ species do meet and hybridize in nature, there appears to be no firm evidence that the specific mate recognition system has been evolving any faster than negative viability (a conclusion apparently confirmed by the Coyne and Orr data). Consequently, if the specific mate recognition system does occur independently of the existence of a neosympatric selection interface, then this may be a relatively infrequent event, excepting perhaps where cladogenetic (species) substitution is invoked. A General Model of Speciation Summarizing the above in a general model of speciation, under the S (geographic space) condition, there may be genome splitting, under two possible regimes: 1. Neosympatric state: Genome splitting occurs via reinforcement, as an adaptive response to cladogenetic drive in hybrid depression. 2. Allopatric state: Genome splitting occurs via ‘‘autospeciation’’ (⫽ allopatric speciation sensu stricto, for example, via the specific mate recognition or equivalent mechanism). Thus, summarizing all possible outcomes, we have the model shown in Fig. 36. It should also be understood at this point that allopatric speciation (sensu novo) encompasses not only the specific mate recognition model, but also any other components of prezygotic isolation which possess the potential to achieve total species isolation. With respect to the actual question of species definition, we should take the view of Butlin (1987), ‘‘Species should be defined by the absence of gene flow, whatever the characters responsible for its prevention.’’ In addition, we must not confuse validity of any theoretical species concept (concerning the manner in which species are formed) with taxonomic questions relating to how they are defined in actual practice! Nor should any ‘‘general’’ model of speciation overlook the deep dichotomy between animal and plant systems, with particular regard to the propensity for raising barriers to reproduction through courtship behavior in animals, as well as to the much greater capacity for viable hybridization and speciation via polyploidy found in plants (Stebbins, 1988).
6. THE CLADOGENETIC SELECTION INTERFACE
115
FIGURE 36 Manifestations of cladogenesis in different configurations of gene reservoir niche space.
Sympatric Speciation Mayr (1942) dismisses sympatric speciation other than for polyploids, although Maynard Smith (1966a) seriously considered the possibility of genetic potential for this to occur. A large part of the problem surrounding sympatric speciation of course lies in the extent to which ‘‘allopatric’’ also means geographic isolation. Examples such as the Lake Victoria cichlid fishes (and others) show that this question is not easily answered: Evidence for sympatric speciation can be difficult to distinguish from the ‘‘microallopatric’’ model, even in the presence of molecular data, as, for example, concluded by Reinthal and Meyer (1997) with respect to their data on Cichlidae. The behavioral plasticity of many cichlid species allows considerable niche overlap to exist in Nature (Greenwood, 1981). However, it is unclear to what extent this constitutes a postspeciational development. Kondrashov and Mina (1986) define sympatric speciation in terms of probability of mating dependent on genotype only, with the intention of removing the semantic argument from the question as to what ‘‘sympatric’’ actually means. As Futuyma (1998) points out, allopatry must be defined according to severe reduction in movement of individuals or of their gametes and not by geographic distance. The parapatric model (see King, 1993, for a discussion) considers environmental as against purely geographic divergence. The Maynard Smith model of sympatric speciation (1966a) has ‘‘disruptive selection’’ determined by some loci while reproductive isolation is affected by others, a system which requires ‘‘linkage disequilibrium’’ between selected and isolating loci to operate (see Chapter 13). This would in fact only be possible
116
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
if the cladogenetic selection interface also formed the leading effect phenon cluster—and there may be good reasons to suppose that this is an unlikely scenario, in that a leading effect in the anisotropic (as against anisotopic) selection interface is likely to be the most frequent configuration. White (1968) reassessed the view that sympatric speciation demands the spread of mutations which would be deleterious (namely, those involved with preventing mating, or rendering this fruitless) with particular respect to chromosomal as against ‘‘point’’ mutations. Mechanisms of sympatric speciation have thus been linked to chromosome breakage and reorganization: White and others (see White, 1968) studied 160 segregates of Moraba viatica and M. scurra superspecies of grasshoppers in which semispecies with different karyotypes occupy adjacent territories. Races of the M. viatica group contain chromosomal fusions, inversions, plus a translocation. Significant reduction in male fecundity has been found in hybrids collected in nature, presumably having evolved subsequently to the original chromosomal mutations. The allopatric model has been rejected for the M. viatica group, and White proposed stasipatric divergence occurring through ‘‘meiotic drive’’ on the basis of some hypothetical segregational advantage in the egg, so that speciation (or at least raciation) might thus be driven by ‘‘endogenous chromosomal activity).’’ An endogenously driven model of sympatric speciation of the above kind has found little favor, however, appearing unlikely unless there are other advantages in chromosomal rearrangements. White (1968) believes that over 90% of all species differ in chromosome traits and that the latter are causal to speciation. Carson (1982) disagrees with this conclusion, arguing that chromosomal reorganization should be seen as part of the speciation process. It is nevertheless possible that the cladogenetic phenon cluster could become the leading effect in the face of chromosomal change, especially since it seems likely that the latter may usually be linked to leading effect allomorphism of the exclusively spatial kind in the first place. That is to say, chromosomal change is positively selected through extrinsic demands of an anisotopic selection interface, with no temporal element being involved, and thus with no need to invoke any ‘‘endogenous first cause’’ (see also Chapter 3). Although no great problem exists with acceptance of the view that chromosomal change forms a significant component of postzygotic isolation, it does, however, seem unlikely that this can form part of any viable model for sympatric speciation in the absence of other factors discussed by Maynard Smith (see above).
The Postspeciational Selection Interface The initial stages of speciation may frequently be behavioral–metabolic, with little or no anagenetic separation (as with ‘‘sibling species’’), whereas other manifestations of cladogenesis may affect major structural divergence involving longer term changes expressed in the postspeciational domain. A selection
6. THE CLADOGENETIC SELECTION INTERFACE
117
interface thus clearly also exists between discrete species. There must therefore be two different types of cladogenetic selection interfaces, one tripartite (with a hybrid state), the other bipartite. The latter relates to that component of cladogenetic activity which continues beyond the species isolation event itself (and even beyond subsequent speciational bifurcations) and which thus constitutes true postspeciational cladogenesis. In addition, two species may diverge on the basis of characteristics that formed no part of the original cladogenetic interface, and we should therefore confine the term postspeciational divergence to the converse situation. Finally, there may also be a cladogenetic selection interface between nonsister species (even between remote lineages), when a limiting resource comes to be shared by unrelated organisms. This situation cannot be deemed to form any part of postspeciational divergence (sensu lato) and must be construed as part of species selection (see below). Following the concept of the postspeciational selection interface, we also identify a higher level of divergence, in that not all speciational change is substructural or ‘‘ambient’’ in nature. Ambient versus Renschian Cladogenesis The macroevolutionary aspect of cladogenesis clearly belongs partly in the postspeciational and transspeciational domain, as a corollary of the rare coincidence of qualitative niche shift and iterated neomorphic change in structure. We must therefore now distinguish between ambient and Renschian modes of cladogenesis, the former constituting a purely microevolutionary expression of cladogenetic activity in the context of a predominantly substructural mode of species divergence, the latter being linked to postspeciational divergence plus anagenetic change (see also Chapter 8). Above all else, the diversity of cladogenetic activity underlines the limits of adaptive capacity in general, so that adaptive potential clearly now requires a more detailed analysis. We conclude by asking the question, what is the function of cladogenesis in general in the evolution of adaptive systems? The answer lies at least partially with resolution of antagonistic forces in the anisotopic selection interface. Allomorphism thus lies at the root of all cladogenesis, although only major (genotypic) cladogenesis has a very large effect on the topology of macroevolutionary change. Species Selection We must also consider the interspecific selection interface in the light of problems that have been raised concerning confusion with ‘‘group selection.’’ Eldredge (1989) has discussed the conceptual difficulty in regarding species selection as a direct, ‘‘higher level analogue of natural selection,’’ namely, in that species cannot be regarded as being interactors in the sense that individual organisms are. However, Eldredge nevertheless insists that group level effects do in fact occur: ‘‘It is to be stressed at this juncture that species as wholes do not participate in interspecific competition.’’ Following the criticism of group selection by Williams (1966), it is quite clear that such factors can only emerge as a corollary of individual level selectional activity. Eldredge supports his claim by proposing that ‘‘spatiotemporal localization qualifies as a heritable and species level emergent character, thus posing a possibly valid example of
118
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
true species selection.’’ For example, if a new species becomes fully sympatric with an old one (as is in fact the case with many real examples), then interspecific competition may well result in extinction (or pressure for change) of one or both species involved. However, this does not occur as a result of group selection in terms of any trait that was originally selected as having been advantageous to a group entity, but as an emergent corollary of some negative competitional propensity that is manifested at the genic (individual) level. Clearly, the familiar competitive exclusion principle applies to interspecific competition, and indeed, the niche of one species may simply be a subset of that of another (as distinct from the less probable scenario of expressing exact niche coincidence!). This situation clearly does not constitute a case for group selection in the sense that the latter has been widely understood in the past. Thus, we must accordingly accept species selection in terms of Eldredge’s emergent properties interpretation, in accordance with the effect hypothesis first advanced by Vrba (1984). Species selection is thus only to be understood in the context of an interspecific selection interface which acts essentially as an emergent property of genic selection (see also Chapter 8). In contrast to some recent interpretations, the influence of species selection is not limited to cladogenetic substitution, but also extends into the domain of the postspeciational selection interface. Contrary to the view of Williams (1992), species selection does in fact also hold special status within the domain of ‘‘clade selection,’’ since it is here that reproductive boundaries begin to act to remove the significant influence of hybrid depression or hybrid vigor from the architecture of the cladogenetic selection interface.
MAIN POINTS FROM CHAPTER 6 1. Cladogenesis derives from spatial dynamism in the selection interface, and can thus be analyzed via the anisotopic selection vector. 2. The cladogenetic selection interface describes selectional forces manifesting cladogenetic drive, as an expression of the balance between antagonistic centripetal and centrifugal elements of an anisotopic selection interface that is linked either to the niche intersect between competing genotypes of a neosympatric gene pool or to divergence in allopatry. 3. Cladogenetic drive contains both extrinsic and endogenous factors. The former lie in the niche intersect, the latter, in hybrid depression. 4. Cladogenetic capacity and cladogenetic potential can be identified in the innate capability of a gene reservoir for an appropriate adaptive response to a cladogenetic selection interface. Each has endogenous and extrinsic components—homeostatic adjustment is the leading endogenous factor, and free niche space, the predominant extrinsic element. Facility for reproductive isolation clearly constitutes the essential component of cladogenetic potential. 5. The sympatric cladogenetic selection interface can be modeled through introduction of factors representing shared and unshared K in the equation set of the adaptive system. Shared niche space lies in the selection interface, and unshared, in the adaptation interface alone.
6. THE CLADOGENETIC SELECTION INTERFACE
119
6. Realization of cladogenetic capacity and potential can occur at more than a single level. In the intraspecific domain, evolved dominance constitutes a ‘‘phenotypic resolution’’ of cladogenetic drive in the same way as speciation through reproductive isolation constitutes a genotypic solution. There are thus two principal domains for resolution of antagonistic cladogenetic forces: minor ( phenotypic) and major ( genotypic) cladogenesis, the latter constituting speciation itself. 7. There are two main models of the speciation process, the neosympatric (‘‘reinforcement’’) and allopatric (‘‘recognition’’) models. The former is better supported by the existing empirical data. A general model encompasses both. 8. Binary resolution of cladogenetic potential in speciation may at times manifest a major ‘‘axial–tangential’’ dichotomy between benign and hostile niche structures, and this can be of considerable significance with respect to major lineage bifurcations. 9. Renschian cladogenesis, as manifested in the divergence of higher group lineages, is linked to a postspeciational selection interface (which may be punctuated by further ambient speciational events). Many Renschian cladogenetic events are linked to a divergence between benign and hostile niche regimes. 10. Species selection does not constitute any form of ‘‘group selection,’’ but arises as an emergent corollary of genic selection. In this context, species selection has a highly significant role to play in evolution.
This page intentionally left blank
7
ADAPTIVE POTENTIAL, BIOPHYSICAL PARADIGMS, AND THE SELECTIONAL ATTRACTOR
ADAPTIVE POTENTIAL It has already emerged that the concept of adaptive capacity is clearly an inadequate explanation of the adaptive response as manifested beyond the domain of adaptive equilibrium and that the greater domain of evolution demands the existence of a higher sphere residing in adaptive potential.
Evolution and Adaptive Potential Manifestation of adaptive equilibrium in the structural adaptive response via perpetuated allomorphism does not constitute true evolutionary change in the adaptive system, implicating nothing more than a link to niche diversification and changing selection polarity in the realization of adaptive capacity, in terms of preexisting and/or recurrent allomorphism. In contrast, evolution is concerned with the much larger question surrounding realization of adaptive potential, in which propensity for patterns of change extending beyond the domain of adaptive capacity must be manifested. We may at this point be tempted to restrict evolution sensu stricto to mechanisms which give rise to breakdown of gene flow between gene pools, and this again would reiterate the functional boundary of adaptive capacity as being that existing between evolutionary and nonevolutionary modes of change in the adaptive response. However, it is essential to point out that some component even of intraspecific (minor) cladogenesis must surely belong to novel, as against recurrent mutation, so that ‘‘evolutionary’’ does not in fact
121
122
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
translate simply as ‘‘transspecific’’ as against ‘‘intraspecific.’’ As we shall see also in the next chapter, not all iterative mutational change in the genome is necessarily ‘‘one way.’’ The essential definition of evolution therefore links to the dichotomy between adaptive capacity and potential, although the latter can clearly include microgenetic additions to the repertoire of adaptive capacity itself, as well to cladogenesis and anagenesis. A deeper analysis of adaptive potential is clearly fundamental to any understanding of the general theory of evolution, as well as of the links between several ‘‘special’’ theories that have been proposed in the past. Of special interest, here, is the contribution of Thompson (1917), who was the main architect of one significant special theory that has attracted closer attention only in recent years. The adaptive systems approach allows us to look at these problems within the unified concept of adaptive potential. Limits of Adaptive Capacity Speciational change clearly cannot be wholly derived from adaptive capacity, nor can much postspeciational change belong in that domain. While realization of cladogenetic potential may occur in the substructural domain (for example, via behavioral change), much speciation clearly also involves structural differentiation, and it is in the latter scenario that we encounter the problem of adaptive potential in its widest horizons: Thoday and Boam (1959) selected for low and high sternopleural bristle number in Drosophila melanogaster, with 50% gene exchange between two populations at each generation. The difference in bristle number between the two lineages gradually increased, owing in fact to only two genes on chromosome II. This differential must have been concealed within adaptive capacity in the first place, such propensities presumably reaching realization through recombinational changes or recurrent mutation (or a combination of both). Although the concept of adaptive capacity can thus demonstrate a certain degree of propensity for iterative change to the phenotype, this gives no indication of how major anagenetic changes can occur. Large scale evolutionary events must involve fundamental changes to the structure of the preexisting genome, frequently linked to iterative changes in phenotypic structure which facilitate radical modifications to body plan of a kind that cannot possibly lie within the domain of adaptive capacity. Such changes clearly indicate movement toward some distant goal, apparently thereby manifesting an apparent element of directionalization in evolution: Although artificial selection can expand variance within a range, a plateau is reached beyond which no further progress can be made, so that change via recombination/recurrent mutation clearly only operates within a certain limited domain. The usual explanation for this is that ‘‘the store of variation is exhausted’’ (that is to say, adaptive capacity has been fully explored ). Mather (1953; and others) stated that several ‘‘selection plateaus’’ of this kind may occur in nature, owing to a
7. ADAPTIVE POTENTIAL, BIOPHYSICAL PARADIGMS, AND THE SELECTIONAL ATTRACTOR
123
gradual recombination of tightly linked genes through crossing-over and through novel mutation. These observations serve to illustrate the importance of neomorph mutation in adaptive potential. Thus, although some part of ambient speciational divergence may be accounted for via mutation within genes linked to the adaptive capacity in dynamic equilibrium, major anagenetic change cannot be explained through recombination and chromosomal rearrangement alone. Adaptive potential must therefore concern additional genetic mechanisms plus a propensity for iterative morphogenetic directionality, whenever large scale genetic and structural transformations occur during longer term evolution. In summary, many potentially attainable structural states lie well beyond the limits of adaptive capacity and beyond the bounds of probability of realization through simple allelic recombination and ‘‘ambient–recurrent mutation’’ of existing genes. Since adaptive capacity is the innate ability of the organism to adapt (endogenous component) or of the external environment to be adapted to (extrinsic component), there must similarly be a larger structure expressing the relationship between existing adaptive capacity and possible states containing potential for major topological change in the structural component of adaptation—and clearly it must be this latter domain which constitutes true adaptive potential. Where periodicity of selection profile is much greater than average ambient speciation time, niche parameters linked to the isotropic selection profile may permit iterative change toward a more distant structural state, thus linking to realization of adaptive potential. Where an isotropic selection interface exists, there is therefore a probability that iterated change in the genome could lead to improved levels of adaptation in terms of phenotype changes which lie far beyond the domain of existing adaptive capacity. Adaptive Potential and Prospective Adaptation or Evolutionary Competence It is perhaps axiomatic that adaptive potential must lie partly in a domain defined by preexisting form, and this element has been investigated in terms of prospective adaptation (following Simpson) and evolutionary competence (following Stebbins). Simpson developed the concept introduced by Parr (1926) regarding the ‘‘prospective versus real’’ functions of organisms. In this context, adaptive potential can be viewed as being initially a function of adaptive shift in the behavioral domain (a vital concept that will be taken up at a later stage in the context of the relationship between adaptive shift and architecture of lineage in Chapter 17). In fact, this link between behavioral change and emergence of the structural domain in realization of adaptive potential further confirms behavior as being ‘‘the realization function’’ for adaptation in general (see Chapter 1): Simpson discussed the significance of prospective adaptation on the basis of such examples as the observation that vertebrate lungs developed in the aquatic environment, but were evidently an adaptational prerequisite for later evolution in the terrestrial domain, as initially
124
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
mediated by behavioral change. In the same way, it is thought that the evolution of desiccation-resistant spores in aquatic algae may have constituted a vital preadaptation which allowed subsequent invasion of the terrestrial environment by plants (Thomas and Spicer, 1986). One component of the epigenetic dimension to adaptive potential therefore lies with hidden propensities of existing phenotype structure itself, and here we may identify behavioral change as a redirective force in the adaptive ensemble, with eventual corollaries for all levels of function. Prospective adaptation affords a first indication of the nature of a directionalization component implicit in adaptive potential, while obviously at the same time offering little more than a superficial view of a much larger structure. This particular mechanism should therefore perhaps be viewed as arising from ‘‘structure potential that is merely waiting for a behavior shift to happen’’ (see also Chapter 17)—although it must be clear that prospective adaptation has a proximal limit, in the same way that adaptive capacity does.
Components of Adaptive Potential As with adaptive capacity, it is presumed that separate endogenous and extrinsic components exist also in the domain of adaptive potential. The reality of this demands an understanding of a more complex array of mechanisms than those described by the concepts of the adaptive niche linked to Mendelian population genetics, including several important conceptual structures that were investigated by Thompson (1917). A fresh interpretation of the Thompsonian approach is explored below, and this aspect of adaptive potential will be further integrated into the general theory at a later stage (see Chapter 15). The Endogenous Component of Adaptive Potential in Morphogenetic Potential Within the endogenous domain of adaptive capacity, the logistic component centers largely on fecundity and behavior, while the structural component is closely linked to the variance of structure as defined by the phenotype spectrum complementary to existing and recurrent allomorphism. Adaptive potential for complex morphogenetic change clearly cannot lie with mere ‘‘prospective adaptation’’ alone, nor in the preexisting complement of allelomorphic genes, but instead must concern a multidimensional relationship between genes, development, the preexisting phenotype, and adjacent morphosystems, linked to complementary adaptive potential existing in the external environment. Genes involved in this scenario will furthermore tend to be those which do not express major allelomorphism in the gene pool within the context of the ambient time frame. The attainable morphosystems of endogenous adaptive potential must be presumed to lie both close to the existing phenotype (the prospective adaptation component) and also in proximity to the architecture of existing developmental coordinates. In this context, we must consider the existence of a morphogenetic potential constituting that set of morphosystems generated by the entire range of possible configurations of the equation(s) controlling parameters of the growth curve for a given unit of phenotype
7. ADAPTIVE POTENTIAL, BIOPHYSICAL PARADIGMS, AND THE SELECTIONAL ATTRACTOR
125
structure. Clearly, adaptive potential must be linked to this morphogenetic landscape in some way. The concept of morphogenetic potential can be usefully explored with reference to one particularly well-known and illuminating example, namely, that of the logarithmic spiral curve as found in the protective shells of many molluscs and other animals: A spiral is described by polar coordinates: O ⫽ the pole, and a straight line starting at the pole and revolving around it is the radius vector. A point P moving along the radius vector under a given velocity then describes the ‘‘equable’’ spiral. A radius OP comprising successive whorls increases in arithmetic progression and will equal a constant quantity a multiplied by the number of whorls (given in effect by the angle of revolution, ), so that r ⫽ a. To connect this equation with the situation found in mollusc shells, it is necessary to consider a spiral in which the whorls gradually increase in width, owing to the fact that a constant acceleration supplements the velocity of movement of the point P. In this situation, the equation changes from r ⫽ a to r ⫽ a. The equable (arithmetic) spiral now becomes the logarithmic or equiangular spiral. Thompson (1917) showed that generation of a logarithmic spiral could be explained in terms of a simple growth curve in terms of growth at a point P resolved into a force F acting along the line OP (see above) and a force T acting perpendicular to OP, with constant magnitude of each force. The resultant of forces F and T (PQ) makes a constant angle with the radius vector, the latter being a fundamental property of the logarithmic spiral. He also showed that the most fundamental intrinsic property of such a curve lies in the property of continual similarity (hence the observed association with organic growth). Above all else, this property of increase by terminal growth without change of form is exclusive to the equiangular or logarithmic curve. It is thus a unique class within that set of forms regarded as gnomonic.* There are several good reasons for choosing the log spiral as an exemplar for the adjacent morphosystems concept: first, its status as the simplest gnomonic growth curve. Second, the morphogenetic potential of this curve has been computed (see below). Again, the realized frequency distribution of this particular morphogenetic landscape is also known for living and fossil organisms. Finally, the nonliving nature of the spiral shell might perhaps also hold the highest probability of providing evidence for or against a ‘‘nonadaptationist’’ interpretation of morphogenetic change (see Chapter 15). Before going on to look at this system in greater depth, it will be pertinent to add that a consideration of ‘‘geometric versatility’’ in development (Vermeij, 1974) does not automatically transmit into morphogenetic potential, since capacity for actual expression will depend on such factors as developmental modularity (see Chapter 12): * Following Aristotle, a figure added to a geometric shape such that magnitudinal change occurs without change of shape (see Thompson, 1917).
126
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
Thomson (1988) following Holder (1983) notes that manifestation of tetrapod limb types has been consistent, both in what is and in what is not produced: ‘‘The simplest and most obvious element of constraint in this system is that where there is a strong axis of organisation, the medial digit will be the hardest to lose.’’ Thus, not all ‘‘geometrically possible’’ configurations are necessarily developmentally feasible. Wolpert (1971) has also pointed out that a geometrical understanding of form gives no indication of the developmental and biochemical mechanisms behind evolutionary change. Fortunately, however, the log spiral example seems, from actual observation, to lie close to a realistic morphogenetic landscape in terms of developmental potential also. Raup computed a range of molluscan shell morphotypes on the basis of different configurations of an equation describing the above logarithmic spiral, specifically in terms of the ratios of two radii originating in the center of the spiral (see Raup and Stanley, 1971, 1978, for a comprehensive treatment). He showed that within the considerable range of form generated by this equation, realized structure was concentrated around an adaptive optimum in which the ratio 1/W (W ⫽ square of ratio of radii) was equal to 2, and D (distance of aperture from apex) was equal to 0.35, thus with a pronounced bias away from biophysically weak designs in which successive shell whorls are not in contact (namely, where intrinsic strength and hydrodynamic stability are both low). Thus, while the entire range of spirals does seem developmentally attainable, only an adaptationally viable subset is actually realized in real organisms. Structure potential, as the endogenous component of adaptive potential, must therefore relate particularly to innate properties of the genome to encompass novel parameters in the structural adaptive response, such as those giving rise to the generating curve in the above example, thereby connecting to morphogenetic states which lie, not only beyond the limits of existing and recurrent allelomorphic systems, but also within the adaptationally positive range: At a more complex level, Simpson (1953) theorized that the ancestral mustelids did not have lutrine prospective functions in a static sense but in a dynamic one, having apparently been capable of being developed in the course of time. The same applies to the potential in early angiosperms for the independent acquisition of water conducting vessels in monocotyledons and dicotyledons (Takhtajan, 1954). Endogenous adaptive potential (structure potential ) may thus be postulated to reside in the adaptationally positive complement of morphogenetic potential lying beyond the boundaries of extant and recurrent gene-developmental systems, yet nevertheless having some relationship to existing structure through probability of realization via iterated genetic mutation. Thus, morphogenetic potential only becomes adaptive potential when we examine that subset of the former that is also adaptationally positive: The same concept is implicit in the ‘‘morphogenetic construction rules’’ of Oster et al. (1988), who deduced those parameters via which the vertebrate limb may and may not alter, in relation to a reaction– diffusion model for determination of form. Shubin and Alberch’s gen-
7. ADAPTIVE POTENTIAL, BIOPHYSICAL PARADIGMS, AND THE SELECTIONAL ATTRACTOR
127
eral theory of limb formation (1986) utilized the Oster et al. model to show that a great range of tetrapod limbs can be produced from generative rules of the limb field. Goodwin (1984) discussed the findings of Maden (1982), who studied supernumerary limbs in the amphibian Ambystoma in which digit number varies from one to six, concluding that the limb field of a single species is capable of generating a variety of basic skeletal patterns which is greater than that observed in the full range of tetrapod limbs: ‘‘Each organism carries within it the potential of creating a great variety of forms, for each morphogenetic field is described by equations with many solutions which define a set of morphological possibilities.’’ Some of these outcomes are thus developmentally constrained, while others are ‘‘attainable, but adaptationally valueless.’’ As already argued above, our view of morphogenetic potential and its relationship to adaptive potential must be tempered with acceptance of the fact that theoretical range and actual range may be two different things, and that adaptive potential is further restricted to the positive component of the attainable morphogenetic landscape. Most significantly for the question of realization of adaptive potential, the range of form generated by the log spiral curve (see above) constitutes a real, rather than hypothetical morphogenetic potential, and the relationship between this and real adaptive potential is also understood. Degrees of Freedom in Endogenous Adaptive Potential The extent to which an attainable morphogenetic potential may also generate a range of adaptationally positive phenotype states leads naturally to the concept of degrees of freedom in adaptive potential. Clearly, some arrays of generated morphotypes may contain a larger contingent of positive states than others, depending on the nature of structure and function in the involved trait: The concept of degrees of freedom in adaptive potential is linked to the question of ‘‘adaptational versatility’’ following Vermeij (1974), who cited an example in the branching patterns of angiosperms which apparently led to a much greater range of possible forms than in gymnosperms. Another exemplar of increased ‘‘adaptive versatility’’ lies with actinopterygian bony fishes, in the freeing of the maxilla from the cheeks in the upper jaw, then in subsequent freeing from the ethmopalatine connection in holosteans—which in turn allowed unprecedented adaptive radiation of feeding types in the acanthopterygians. The Extrinsic Component of Adaptive Potential in Niche Potential Structural evolutionary change must also carry some adaptive advantage, and thus the extrinsic component of adaptive capacity was framed in terms of parameters of the niche interface (see Chapter 2). This niche capacity is largely a dynamic structure for periodic niche parameters. Consequently, the greater domain of adaptive potential must, in contrast, relate to nonperiodic niche parameters manifesting an isotropic selection profile (see Chapter 4). The ex-
128
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
trinsic component of adaptive potential must consequently relate in part to free, adjacent niche space lying near the boundary defined by the constraints of existing adaptive capacity. This need not, however, involve qualitative niche shift. Niche potential can be merely a larger, inaccessible biomass within the domain of the existing adaptive niche—or else, most significantly, an improvement in the way the existing niche is exploited via ‘‘niche intensification’’ (see Chapter 6). The extrinsic component of adaptive potential may thus relate to free, accessible niche space, or else capacity to expand in the domain of niche hyperspace. Unlike niche capacity, however, the emphasis must clearly lie with the isotropic niche profile. Adaptive potential is now visualized as being the sum of structure (endogenous component) and niche (extrinsic) potentials, in the same way as adaptive capacity is derived from endogenous and extrinsic components—capacity and potential being distinguished by the boundaries of attainable morphosystems within the existing genetic complement for the endogenous component, and frequently also by existing, as against free, adjacent niche space for the extrinsic component. These elements are of course further linked to the isotropic (as against dynamic) selection profile. The quasi-infinite nature of resources such as ‘‘aerial environment’’ also indicates the importance of sub- and hypoparametric niche space in this (see Chapter 2). Evolution can therefore proceed through functional or qualitative change in niche or by niche intensification, and this must constitute a fundamental dichotomy (see Renschian cladogenesis, adaptive shift and function shift). Adaptive potential seems likely also to engender a major directionalization function (see below), owing to the intersect between degrees of freedom in structure potential and niche potential.
ADAPTIVE POTENTIAL, BIOPHYSICAL PARADIGM, AND STRUCTURAL ATTRACTOR The adaptive response cannot ‘‘direct itself.’’ What factors, then, do direct long-term iterative evolutionary change? Directionality must lie primarily in the isotropic selection vector (see Chapter 4), but what is the source of this directionalization influence? The answer can be shown to lie in a dialogue between two major elements: the biophysical paradigm for a given adaptational function, and the endogenous component of adaptive potential. These factors formed part of a heterogeny of mechanisms studied by Thompson (1917), who did not, however, clearly distinguish between different components nor seek to integrate his own theoretical work with the Darwinian synthesis. The most significant elements in the Thompsonian special theory are those which plead for an ‘‘internal force’’ directing evolution. What is the true significance of this phenomenon?
The Biophysical Paradigm Concept The structure–function paradigm approach of Rudwick (1964) can be linked to analysis of directionality in terms of the iterative selection interface, linked to the directional component of exogenous adaptive potential. Although Rudwick
7. ADAPTIVE POTENTIAL, BIOPHYSICAL PARADIGMS, AND THE SELECTIONAL ATTRACTOR
129
considered his adaptational paradigm as a basis on which interpretation of structural states of unknown function could be made, we can more usefully invert Rudwick’s concept by asking which structural state would, in view of the fundamental physical laws, serve a prestated functional demand? This particular approach identifies the biophysical paradigm concept. As we have seen already, the endogenous component of adaptive potential can only be understood in terms of selectively positive changes to structure. Positively selected changes clearly must enhance the adaptive state within the context of the external selection interface, and structure must therefore be capable of incremental progression in some absolute, biophysical sense. In any understanding of the organization of the biophysical paradigm, the first principle must therefore be that the topology of major structural change must also agree in its adaptational role with what Thompson termed ‘‘a special subset of the physical laws.’’ The biophysical paradigm is now definable as being that structure which maximizes functional efficiency relating to a specific demand determined by the external adaptation interface, as constrained by some subset of the fundamental physical laws relating to intrinsic limitations peculiar to organic structure. In this concept, we also witness a fundamental axiom concerning organic adaptive systems, namely, that their behavior is bound by the tenets of Newtonian physical laws. As indeed argued by Pennycuik (1992), ‘‘At the intermediate scales of biology, Newtonian physics still works as well as it ever did’’: The essential parameters of a structure for the function of flight must include factors such as an aerofoil surface capable of providing lift that is suitably powered by an appropriately designed skeletomusculature system, linked in turn to essential propensities of metabolic rate and ventilation of the respiratory system. The biophysical paradigm concept links to adaptive potential in the sense that it is the major determinant factor of directionality in the isotropic selection vector for iterative variation–selection interactions. A given structure needs to fulfill some adaptational function in the adaptive system. There is thus a large input from the fundamental physical laws, in the way these relate to biological systems, and the architecture of organic superstructure must take into account various factors which effectively act as ‘‘universal constants’’ in adaptive systems. It must also be made clear, at this juncture, that biophysical limits should not be confused with ‘‘geometric limits’’ (Simpson, 1953): Lull and Gray (1949) showed that D’Arcy Thompson’s morphological transformations often cannot be extrapolated beyond a certain intrinsic limit. The concept of limits may thus be confused. ‘‘Geometric limits’’ are of no concern for the analysis of evolution, whereas those of biophysical systems most certainly are. Simpson correctly reasoned that there are also mechanical limits (for example, upward limit to size change): ‘‘Often when a trend stops, it has reached an inherent or mechanical limit.’’ It is essential to realize also that a close relationship exists between the biophysical paradigm concept and that of extrinsic adaptive potential, in the same way
130
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
as extrinsic adaptive capacity was linked to the adaptive niche at an earlier stage (see Chapter 2). Degrees of Freedom in the Biophysical Paradigm Degrees of freedom exist not only in endogenous adaptive potential, but also in the biophysical paradigm, a fact that is most strongly overt in the extreme convergencies which occur between remotely related lineages with respect to certain organ systems, namely, where the number of degrees of freedom is apparently very small: Convergence between compound eyes of the superposition type in different higher groups is so extreme that it is said to be virtually impossible to tell one phylum from another from isolated histology sections (Nilsson and Osorio, 1998). This demonstrates how tight functional constraints can be, and how precise the evolutionary response to them can be. Alexander (1983) discusses similar narrowly defined structural paradigms in the design of aerofoils and hydrofoils. Some of the most fundamental components of adaptive systems may in fact possess no degrees of freedom whatsoever. Rensch (1959), for example, listed 20 essential requirements of living systems: the necessity of being carbon based and requiring the properties of colloidal proteins, having to evolve within a certain temperature range, etc. Conversely, some biophysical paradigms may be much more loosely defined, including, for example, those that are fractal in nature (following Mandelbrot, 1977), as with many absorptive surfaces in respiratory and digestive systems (see Pennycuik, 1992).*
The Structural Selectional Attractor The attractors of adaptive systems have really only been clearly understood in terms of the logistic domain (e.g., as with that situation where several initial states converge on a single stable one in the context of the Verbulst equation). Structural attractors clearly emerge in a similar manner in the context of selectional interactions linked to logistic mechanisms and structural variation residing in evolving adaptive systems. Accordingly, biophysical paradigms for structure can be likened to both stable and dynamic logistic attractors, the former being more analogous in topology to the Verhulst than to the May equation, while in the same way, adaptive equilibrium can be used to illustrate structural systems which resemble dynamic logistic attractors of the foregoing kind. The overall view is that the stable biophysical paradigm state is a structural selectional attractor emerging from iterated selectional activity in the adaptive system. The biophysical paradigm, in its role as the fundamental structural attractor, clearly determines which changes are adaptationally positive and which are not, whereas the endogenous component of adaptive potential determines which changes are likely to actually occur. Thus it should be clear even at this * Although the contribution of fractal geometry is probably low in terms of most higher group traits, its significance may nevertheless be profound in certain other respects (see p. 133).
7. ADAPTIVE POTENTIAL, BIOPHYSICAL PARADIGMS, AND THE SELECTIONAL ATTRACTOR
131
stage that ‘‘degrees of freedom in adaptive potential’’ is a meaningless concept in the absence of complementary freedom in the biophysical paradigm. Directionality in this interaction thus lies in the intersect between degrees of freedom in the biophysical paradigm and in the structural component of adaptive potential, the outcome being a selectional attractor which invokes a directionalizing element in the context of the isotropic selection vector. This now identifies the (real) structural attractor of the adaptive system (see Chapter 1) as a multidimensional entity lying in the intersect of the structural component of adaptive potential with the biophysical paradigm.
FIGURE 37 Relationship between degrees of freedom in endogenous adaptive potential and biophysical paradigm and the structural selectional attractor.
In Fig. 37, ‘‘degrees of freedom in biophysical paradigm’’ is equivalent to ‘‘number of ways a function could be carried out,’’ and those in endogenous adaptive potential concern ‘‘the range of selectionally positive morphosystems actually within reach.’’ That part of the biophysical paradigm excluded from the structural attractor thus consists of ‘‘unattainable states,’’ while the excluded domain of adaptive potential amounts to ‘‘potential to actually expand the existing extrinsic niche interface.’’* It is thus now possible to expand Thompson’s ‘‘special subset of the physical laws’’ (see p. 129) by adding ‘‘as defined by constraints imposed by the limits of adaptive potential.’’ The structural attractor thus defines the directional input and the selection interface, the magnitudinal input to an isotropic selection vector directionalizing the iterative adaptive response (see Chapter 4). The biophysical paradigm clearly determines a fundamental orientation in the architecture of the selection interface during longer term, iterative change * Endogenous adaptive potential and degrees of freedom in the biophysical paradigm are (quite artificially!) assumed to be of similar magnitude in Fig. 37.
132
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
in evolution, and in this, adaptive potential also has a directionalizing influence on the structural attractor. With respect to the actual directionality of iterative selection interactions, it is easy to see that ‘‘multiple initial solutions’’ at the locus of a novel adaptive shift (see Chapter 17) will generally tend to become one or a few as the structural adaptive response proceeds. We may now draw together our earlier definitions of the extrinsic and endogenous factors and define the totality of adaptive potential as constituting a relationship between the preexisting adaptive state and a higher one reflected in the biophysical paradigm for a given function, as constrained by the probability of the existing genome being able to progress toward this ideal by virtue of neomorphic mutational change. To what extent does the concept of the structural selection attractor reflect the influence of so-called orthoselection? In the context of this perplexing question, Williams (1966) has stated that ‘‘selection has no eyes for the future.’’ However, the structural attractor apparently constitutes just such a mechanism. In this, it should nevertheless be noted that Williams’s view that the goal of an individual’s reproduction is to maximize representation of its own germ plasm relative to that of others in the same population is in no way contradicted by the concept of directionality via the structural attractor of the adaptive system, and movement toward a distant adaptive state is simply a complex evolutionary corollary of genic selection arising from intrinsic properties in the greater adaptive system. The Dimensional Spectrum of the Structural Attractor The structural attractor clearly manifests a dimensional spectrum. That is to say, it expresses a range of dimensional configurations according to absolute size, within a range defined by the endogenous adaptive potential of the genome in question. This happens in certain superstructures, owing to the presence of such influences as the relationship between area and volume as size changes, and to the interaction between gravity and biophysical mechanisms: Certain surface area to volume ratio constraints affect design, for example, those connected with heat gain or loss and those connected with surface structures such as cilia (see Reiss, 1989). Biomechanical aspects of the dimensional spectrum are of particular interest in the context of the Simpsonian adaptive zone concept (Chapter 17) and also serve as a useful exemplar of the interactive roles of extrinsic and endogenous factors in the determination of selectionally favored pathways of morphogenetic transformation (see Chapter 15). Although the dynamic behavior of biophysical paradigms can perhaps most easily be construed in terms of biomechanical factors, their true domain is universal. The link with metabolism can, for example, be amply illustrated in the relationship between absolute size and metabolic rate: According to Kleiber’s law, many biological variables tend to increase or decrease by body mass raised to the power 1/4 or 3/4, in which the relationship with metabolic rate is of fundamental significance. Here, Kleiber’s law is known to hold for 27 orders of magnitude, from the
7. ADAPTIVE POTENTIAL, BIOPHYSICAL PARADIGMS, AND THE SELECTIONAL ATTRACTOR
133
subcellular level to the dimensions of a blue whale. Increase in surface area compared to volume as a function of linear measure clearly predicts an inherent incapacity to cope with geometric increase in terms of surface area for dissipation of heat, so that a considerable downward adjustment of metabolic rate is imperative for survival. Change in metabolic rate with size increase is, however, optimized in the Kleiber relationship. According to West et al. (1997), the key to understanding this phenomenon probably lies in the fractal geometry of branching networks forming the transport systems of living organisms, which is now shown to constitute the optimal design for efficiency of nutrient transport and maximization of metabolic rate in the face of size increase.
Constraint and Directionalization in Adaptive Potential and the Biophysical Paradigm We must now explore the link between ‘‘constraint’’ and directionalization in the evolution of adaptive systems. At the outset, it must be made clear that more than one view of the effect of constraint has been offered in the past. For example, Maynard Smith et al. (1985) have discussed the role of developmental constraints, with heavier emphasis on the question of possible links with stasis than will be found in the ensuing treatment. That analysis does not distinguish between limits of the biophysical paradigm and those arising in endogenous adaptive potential, nor do these authors separate anagenesis from ‘‘evolutionary trends’’ in general. For these reasons, no detailed comparison between the two very different approaches is offered below. The directionalization function comprises a heterogeny of constraintive mechanisms and their corollaries, each of which tends in one way or another to orientate the iterative adaptive response in anagenesis. Many intrinsic limitations act on the biophysical paradigm, all of them having some effect on the probability that a given functional change will also be reflected in structure, and some of these limitations serve also to define a constrained subset of the maximized physical paradigm state in terms of organismic limits. The structural attractor thus tends to be a somewhat limited subset of the fundamental physical paradigm, owing to the many constraints peculiar to natural adaptive systems, and these factors may also serve to determine the probability that a given adaptive potential will in fact reach realization. Thomson (1988) holds that ‘‘developmental constraints can explain evolutionary trends.’’ However, this should certainly not be taken to infer that anagenetic evolutionary sequences arise simply through ‘‘constrainment’’ alone. What does occur is that degrees of freedom in adaptive potential may tend to directionalize the adaptive response along one of several possible pathways: Thomson (1988) agrees that it will be a general property of any constrained system that, to the extent to which it is alterable, it will be more readily changed in some directions than in others. The degree to which major coordinates both of endogenous adaptive potential and of the extrinsic biophysical paradigm may often be highly directionalized is most clearly demonstrated by the frequency, not only of evolutionary
134
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
convergence, but (in particular) of parallel evolution, the continuation of an anagenetic sequence beyond one or more cladogenetic nodes owing to manifestation of the directionalization function. Simpson (1953) correctly rejects simplistic genetic reasons for parallel evolution, since convergence between remote lineages is common. Parallelism offers proof of the maxim that many major coordinates in the structural attractor have one to a few degrees of freedom, most probably arising from the influence of constrainment within the biophysical paradigm. The above factors clearly form a basis for directionality in evolutionary change, and this relationship between adaptive potential and biophysical systems also forms a rationale for an explanation of the early concept of so-called orthogenesis or ‘‘programmed evolution.’’ The complex of constraints acting to directionalize the adaptive response may be listed as follows. a. Constraints Due to Accumulated Adaptive Shifts A majority of superstructural traits in higher organisms have undergone one to several qualitative adaptive shifts, in which a structure originally designed for one purpose has come to take on a new one. This naturally imposes design limitations on the newly acquired function, depending on the degree of difference between old and new biophysical paradigms: The trajectory of the recurrent pharyngeal nerve in higher vertebrates as compared to its original trajectory in the fishlike ancestors of terrestrial vertebrates (and particularly in its diversional pathway in long-necked mammals such as the giraffe) is a well-known exemplar of suboptimal design (see Ridley, 1993, for a discussion). b. Constraints Due to Multiple Functionality The multiple functionality principle states that most modular components of phenotype form tend to manifest more than a single adaptation interface. Very many biophysical systems fulfill more than a single function as a result of incomplete adaptive shifts (see above); therefore, each functional component of a compound superstructure may sacrifice efficiency to a greater or lesser extent, in that an advance for one function may constitute a negative step in terms of another function concurrently residing in the same structure. Consequently, the ideal state of adaptation for a given sequence of structural change may be less efficient in biophysical terms, than if the structure in question had no other function: A leg may both walk and grasp prey. The biophysical paradigm for a structure capable of fulfilling both functions will tend to be more tightly constrained (in terms of either walking or grasping) than one performing either function independently of the other. Similarly, Niklas (1988) concluded that the geometry of plant design very frequently tends to manifest a considerable level of suboptimality owing to division of labor. The influence of multiple functionality has already been implicated in the architecture of the fundamentally complex structure of the isotropic selection interface (Chapter 4).
7. ADAPTIVE POTENTIAL, BIOPHYSICAL PARADIGMS, AND THE SELECTIONAL ATTRACTOR
135
c. Constraints Due to the Nature of Biological Kinematic Systems There tend to be only a few kinematic links and few planes of action in many biophysical systems, leading to a narrow channeling of adaptive solutions to a functional problem. This is often linked to the ‘‘prospective adaptation’’ situation, where a structure is evolved from a preexisting structure of quite different function (see a and b above): Flight in vertebrates is accomplished by modification of a walking limb. The earliest flying appendages would have been of suboptimum design (as evident from the rarity of any transitional forms in the living fauna). This element of constraint is a natural corollary of the interactive nature of degrees of freedom residing in both the biophysical paradigm and endogenous adaptive potential. d. Fabricational Constraint Owing to the limitations of continuous development (as distinct from a ‘‘parts-assembly’’ mode of construction), certain physical structures may have a very low probability of realization in biophysical structure systems, for example, where an assembly strategy is needed to maximize mechanical efficiency (this may, however, be partially negated in the very long term, in the context of duplication–cooption; see Chapter 12): The vertebrate eye is constructed back to front in terms of the positioning of light receptor cells in relation to nerve supply. It could have been designed more efficiently given a more direct mode of assembly. Here again, phyletic history forms a significant input to the situation at hand. Many other less obvious constraints appertain to development, and these will be examined in detail at a later point (see developmental chapters). e. Constraints Arising from the Nature of Anagenetic Change As with the question of continuous development, biophysical paradigms can only be reached through the intermediary of a progressive sequence of suboptimum forms, often through a process of simplification from an initially more complex state or, alternatively, through complexification (sometimes the latter, followed by the former). This means that for most complex superstructures, there will only be incremental progress toward paradigm form, and there will thus be a large temporal element defining the degree to which adaptive potential has actually been realized with respect to any given niche interface. More significantly, it also means that there has to be a fully functional state at each point along the anagenetic sequence (as with the continuous development scenario already mentioned above). f. ‘‘Constraints Imposed by Selection’’ Maynard Smith et al. (1985) distinguished developmental from selectional constraints (although Arthur, 1997, modifies this to make certain apparent ‘‘selectional’’ constraints ‘‘developmental’’).
136
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
A low intensity of natural selection in the selection interface may mean that some attainable minor functional refinements are never actually realized in certain lineages, owing to their very low contribution to fitness. This situation may also occur for larger manifestations of potential anagenetic change also, if the leading effect lies elsewhere in the phenotype, and the latter scenario can in fact be shown to be of quite profound significance in this context (see Chapters 18 and 19). There is also a definite link to pleiotropism in the context of selectional constraints, in that evolutionary rate may be affected by negative side effects of otherwise positive gene mutations.* The biophysical paradigm is thus not ‘‘the ideal physical paradigm,’’ but some subset of this as constrained by various interrelated organic factors, inextricably constrained by endogenous adaptive potential for any other than the smallest paradigm distance. The most significant deductions to be made here are that (1) a great many adaptations are likely to be closely channeled, rather than divergent, when we consider separate lineages adapted to similar niche parameters, and (2) the same anagenetic sequence evolving in parallel in different lineages may do so at quite different evolutionary rates. This means in turn that parallel evolution will often tend to predominate in phylogeny and that divergent, monophyletic solutions will be uncommon for many response mechanisms: The propensity for parallelism in evolution is exemplified by examples where the fossil record is more than unusually complete, as with Sheldon’s work (1987) on trilobites, where changes in the mean number of pygidial ribs clearly occurred independently in several lineages. The same phenomenon is almost universally implicit in cladistic analyses, both of paleontological and of neontological data (see Chapter 21); even the formerly widely held assumption that the coelom is monophyletic has been challenged (see Nielsen, 1995). The above conclusions are of fundamental significance in the interpretation of morphological data in a phylogenetic perspective (see Chapter 21), as well as for an understanding of how structure is organized, controlled, and modified in development during periods of major evolutionary change in natural adaptive systems. Adaptive potential thus determines that constrainment of the fundamental structural attractor as determined by endogenous limits, and is in turn directionalized by the extrinsic biophysical paradigm. The biophysical paradigm– endogenous adaptive potential interaction can also be shown to be the true basis for an understanding of ‘‘structuralism’’ in evolution, in the same way as it explains the early concept of ‘‘orthogenesis’’ (see Chapter 15). It should also be stressed at this juncture that ‘‘constrainment’’ must be understood in terms of a directionalization function (particularly in the sense of ‘‘directing parallelism’’), and neither as a factor preventing evolution from occurring nor as a causality for ‘‘nonadaptive evolution.’’ * This category of ‘‘selectional constraint’’ is linked to the genetic component of adaptive potential, and it will be discussed separately in the context of development.
7. ADAPTIVE POTENTIAL, BIOPHYSICAL PARADIGMS, AND THE SELECTIONAL ATTRACTOR
137
Paradigm Distance and Directionality Clearly, some biophysical paradigm states will lie close to existing structure, while others will be topologically and developmentally more distant from the ‘‘preadaptive state.’’ Paradigm distance, the morphotopological distance between preadaptive state and biophysical paradigm form, is an expression of the degree of impediment to realization of adaptive potential resulting from the gap existing between endogenous and extrinsic elements. Paradigm distance tends to 0 and directionality in the selection vector is unidimensional when structure complementary to some freshly discovered niche parameter lies within the reach of existing adaptive capacity, and its value is deemed as being ⬎0 when one or more structure units are required to change in such a way that appropriate modifications lie beyond the reach of existing or recurrent allelomorphic systems, thus requiring iterative, directionalized mutational change in realization of adaptive potential. A large paradigm distance is therefore equivalent to ‘‘remote adaptive potential’’ in the sense of there being only a rudimentary intersect between the morphogenetic landscape and the biophysical paradigm: Flight appendages in insects, birds, and mammals must have presented a very great paradigm distance from any rudiments which preceded them in fully terrestrial forms. Not only was adaptive capacity equal to 0 for this transition, but adaptive potential must have been very low. Even such remote biophysical paradigms as the examples given above must, however, have carried some probability of realization in adaptive potential, which clearly contains a dimension far beyond that expressed in ‘‘prospective adaptation.’’ Nevertheless, ‘‘paradigm distance’’ must certainly constitute one of the most significant true constraints on actual evolutionary change. Likewise, choice between n adaptive solutions to a functional problem must tend to involve preferential shifts toward states of low, rather than high paradigm distance, and this clearly constitutes an important input to the directionalization function also.
Dynamics of the Biophysical Paradigm The biophysical paradigm (and thus also the structural attractor) cannot be considered to be a static structure, toward which adaptational change progresses in linear fashion. Directionality must tend to be driven into progressively narrower channels as adaptive potential is realized and ‘‘multiple possible solutions become just one or a few’’: With early flight adaptations, gliding appendages formed by simple transformations of climbing or grasping limbs clearly presented a high adaptive potential for further modification; the earliest changes must also have determined what subsequent ones would be the most favored. In such scenarios we may also witness divergence, as lineages with a common ancestor directed by Renschian cladogenesis (see previous chapter) explore separate realizations of adaptive potential. Not all anagenetic change is mani-
138
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
fested in parallelism and convergence, and in this, the question of degrees of freedom in the structural attractor clearly becomes of special significance. Dynamic Factors in Adaptational Reciprocity The reciprocal nature of the adaptive response must influence the form of the biophysical paradigm, in particular for parametric niche-adapted traits. The nature of the limiting resource of a gene pool clearly determines functional needs, and adaptational change may in turn create a demand for some reciprocal adaptive response in the resource gene pool. Examples of positive reciprocal responses (as in the moth haustellum length and flower depth in insect pollinated plants already mentioned) show the high degree to which reciprocal factors may at times define and alter preexisting adaptive paradigm states. Dynamic Factors in the Dimensional Spectrum It is a further fundamental attribute of the biophysical paradigm that it is often profoundly affected by factors correlated by absolute size (see above). The nature of the biophysical paradigm is determined by dimensional parameters in the adaptive system itself and is thus a fundamentally dynamic structure, owing not only to the reciprocity principle, but also to allometric laws (and especially to gravity influenced parameters, as a principal component in the latter, see Thompson, 1917; Huxley, 1932). One fundamental law of allometry holds that volume tends to increase as the square of increase in surface area, and the corollary of this is that mass increases in a similar way. The outcome is that many biophysical paradigms must also change according to increase in absolute size, and also that there may be finite limitations imposed on the latter. Consequently, the true principal components of the biophysical paradigm contain the equation for allometric modulation with respect to any particular structure in relation to specific function and absolute size, as determined by parameters of the adaptive niche: Thompson (1917) noted that a fish, in doubling its length, multiplies its weight eight times, and it all but doubles its weight in growing from 4 to 5 inches long. Other well-known examples include the changing length:breadth ratio of supporting vertebrate limbs and the limits on insect body size according to the diffusion properties of oxygen in the tracheal system. Similar relationships exist with scaling and flight; for example, body mass carries many design implications for wing structure (see Pennycuik, 1992). Thompson also pointed out that a common effect of scale is that some forces act in proportion to surface area, while others (above all, gravity) do so in proportion to body mass. According to the same argument, and following Herbert Spencer, Thompson also showed that structural paradigms for biological function invoke Galileo’s principle of similitude: ‘‘If we build two bridges geometrically similar, the larger is the weaker of the two.’’ In addition to the direct implications of size change, there are numerous complex corollaries of even quite simple dynamic paradigms: The scaling of body mass and metabolic rate (see pp. 132–133) also carries an indirect impact on such factors as biodiversity: large species
7. ADAPTIVE POTENTIAL, BIOPHYSICAL PARADIGMS, AND THE SELECTIONAL ATTRACTOR
139
with higher energy efficiency can eat lower quality food, and this in turn affects niche structure. Longevity, age at maturity, and population density are also affected by this relationship (West et al., 1997). The above observations clearly confirm the concept and significance of a dynamic structural paradigm, notwithstanding the fact that certain exceptions exist: Some structures do not follow the principle of similitude: the vertebrate eye, for example, does not vary in proportion with surface area or mass of a body. Dynamic Factors Linked to Incremental Change The incremental change hypothesis expresses the view that positively selected mutations in evolution correspond to small morphogenetic changes only. Owing to the existence of large paradigm distance and to constraints imposed by preexisting structural architecture on adaptive potential, it must be assumed that complex macroevolutionary anagenetic sequences are generally built stage by stage, in an incremental manner, this being linked to the above observation that the biophysical paradigm itself expresses dynamism during the trajectory of evolutionary change. This not only contributes to the directionalization element (see above), but also carries a corollary for the changing architecture of the structural attractor. This maxim will be investigated in greater depth in later chapters.
THE STRUCTURE AND FUNCTION INTEGRAL AS LOCI OF ADAPTIVE POTENTIAL To fully understand the changing architecture of the adaptive response with respect to realization of adaptive potential, it is necessary to look further into the way in which complex structure is organized. It is evident that organismic structure cannot advance as a unity toward some complex new biophysical state (‘‘preadaptive state to distant paradigm state in a single step’’), but must change incrementally and in iterative fashion, one component at a time. The ‘‘components’’ in question are units of structure capable of responding more or less autonomously to a selection interface, in response to demands in the external environment. These units are phenons (Chapter 4), the phenotypic unit corresponding to a unit of genetic change, and certain phenons must also contain the potential to be integrated incrementally in longer term evolution, thus forming larger units of structure. The theory of biophysical paradigms thus clearly necessitates recognition of higher structure units and integrals which operate above the level of the phenon, and this is a natural corollary of the fact that adaptive potential and the structural attractor are both dynamic entities.
The Structure Unit and Integral While the phenon is ‘‘a gene–phenotype unit having an active selection interface,’’ a structure unit constitutes a larger unit of discrete superstructure, the
140
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
lowest holistic unit above tissue level, irrespective of the existence of an active selection interface. Following the maxim outlined above, phenons of a common selection interface may be progressively integrated as structure units, and a structure unit is thus effectively an assemblage of genetically ‘‘fixed’’ phenons linked to an isotropic adaptation interface. Although many structure units have a fully autonomous function, others clearly operate in concert with other units belonging to a greater whole. A structure integral is a set of structure units expressing physical integration as part of a single holistic system linked to a common adaptive paradigm, illustrating the way in which smaller structure units are organized into larger superstructures: The insect wing is a good example of a complex integrated structure containing many structure units. Such structures cannot possibly have evolved ‘‘in a single step,’’ and must have involved iterative superimposition of a large number of structure units, each of which lies above the domain of a single phenon.
The Function Integral A function integral is a set of structure units expressing some degree of functional homogeneity, regardless of level of actual structural integration, and for which no other functional links exist. This concept reflects the fact that there is an adaptational (and thus potentially selectional ) modularity acting on different structures, which can act quite independently of the boundaries of purely developmental modularity (see Chapters 9–16). The structure units of a single structure integral may thus belong to one or more function integrals, either alternatively or else simultaneously in time, thus expressing the multiplicity of function criterion discussed earlier in this chapter. Those structure units belonging to a function integral are thus correlated according to the tenets of a common adaptation interface: Tinbergen (1959) pointed out that 25 characters of kittiwake gulls can be grouped into just a few adapted systems (cliff nesting behavior, pelagic feeding, etc.). As we have seen, the insect wing plus muscles and central nervous system can similarly be taken to form a single function integral; however, not all aspects of the wing belong to a single function integral. Wing color pattern, for example, belongs to a separate function integral which also incorporates components of behavior (for example, wing color pattern and behavior linked to choice of concealment position in cryptically patterned species). Similarly, the nervous system’s function is not restricted to control of flight. Thompson (1917) likewise drew reference to the fact that, although we consider muscle and bone as being independent entities, ‘‘They come into being together, and they act and react together. . . . There can be no change in the one that is not correlated with changes in the other’’. Whereas Thompson was concerned with the problem of ‘‘single character evolution,’’ Simpson (1953) observed that it is common for
7. ADAPTIVE POTENTIAL, BIOPHYSICAL PARADIGMS, AND THE SELECTIONAL ATTRACTOR
141
‘‘blocks of characters’’ to be involved in the rise of higher categories, and that this need not always be a simultaneous mechanism. Hypsodonty in horses is linked to size increase, even although each trait evolved independently of the other. All of the above examples clearly point to the existence of highly organized function integrals in the superstructure of higher organisms. It is important at this stage to realize that the boundaries of structure and function integrals are drawn, not by developmental modularity, but by the present and past architecture of the selection interface. At a later stage, we shall see how structure can be modified during evolution in order that developmental modularity can be tailored to selectional modularity (see Chapters 9–12). Multiple Functionality and the Structure Integral As we have already seen, a given structure unit may also belong to more than a single function integral. Curio (1973) has argued that when the same character is employed in more than one context it should only be regarded as an adaptation in that context in which it makes the greatest contribution to fitness. However, no reason has been offered to suppose that such balance is not itself subject to further dynamic change. In general, it may be assumed that many structure integrals belong to more than a single function integral, and that the adaptational balance between n functions expressed in them may also be subject to change. Additionally, new functions may be added to supplement or even to supplant the preexisting repertoire of adaptive capacity.
The Structure Integral and the Transspecific Selection Interface The allomorphic component of adaptive capacity is differentially distributed over n phenon units which relate in turn to differentials in niche dynamism, and the selection interface contains n phenons of n structure or function integrals at any one point in time. How then do individual structure units relate to fitness? Each phenon (and structure unit) must carry an individual contribution to the adaptive state. Most significantly, an active selection interface will be manifested in some structure units and not in others, and then only in the phenon itself. Essential superstructures will exhibit little or no variation, in contrast to the phenotype traits of an anisotropic selection profile relating to the allomorphic component of the genome. The selection interface appears thus to be limited to loci expressing several relative adaptive states at the phenon level, while the adaptation interface is manifested by the whole organism–environment interaction. This is, however, an intraspecific rule only, applying where the heritable adaptive differential is most noticeable in the presence of allelomorphism. In addition, a common selection interface also exists between competing species (see previous chapter), and this may clearly be based on holistic units of superstructure, since the heritable differential between species exists partly with respect to fixed genetic states. Thus, many structure integrals which seem invariable within a species may nevertheless manifest a transspecific selection interface of some kind.
142
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
The Leading Effect Phenon It is of considerable significance for the evolutionary behavior of the adaptive system that certain phenons may act to ‘‘carry’’ the rest of the genome in the context of the selection interface. There are thus leading effect and sequiform phenons within any chosen time frame. A leading effect phenon holds the highest contribution to fitness within the selection interface, thereby tending to ‘‘direct the adaptive response.’’ A sequiform phenon is one which holds a lower contribution to the adaptive state than the leading effect, consequently tending to be ‘‘directed’’ by the latter. This observation can be shown to be of great significance for the longer term evolutionary behavior of adaptive systems in terms of the probability of a given increment being made in the integration of phenon to structure unit, and structure unit to structure integral (see Chapters 14 and 18): Wright (1982a) rejected the notion of ranking genes in order of importance, because of changing selectional balance in adaptive topography. However, this ignores the existence of a leading effect in terms of major genes which manifest allomorphic variation carrying a large contribution to the active selection interface (see Chapter 13). Many genes of allomorphic status do in fact exhibit high modularity in Nature, certain loci of high contribution to fitness in this sense acting to ‘‘direct’’ gene frequency change in general. The concept of leading effect and sequiform phenons can perhaps most easily be demonstrated in the context of vestigiation. The contribution to fitness may not equal 0 for a functionally redundant state equivalent to a single structure unit, since there may be some residual morphogenetic role of that structure. In the latter case, the adaptation interface is broken for a single structure unit, but not for the entire organismic state. Some ‘‘weak’’ structure units are thus perpetuated by the overall adaptive state of the entire phenotype.
MAIN POINTS FROM CHAPTER 7 1. Realization of adaptive potential (as against capacity) defines the essential differential between adaptive equilibrium and evolution itself. 2. ‘‘Prospective adaptation’’ is linked to realization of adaptive potential through behavioral change alone. However, this component of adaptive potential has a proximal limit in the absence of structural change. 3. As with adaptive capacity, adaptive potential manifests both extrinsic and endogenous domains. The extrinsic domain lies in free, adjacent niche space, and in optimization of the existing adaptation interface in terms of gravitation toward a biophysical paradigm complementary to some exogenous function. The latter must, in turn, link to an endogenous domain in the selectionally positive component of morphogenetic potential residing in the developmental system. 4. The trajectory of anagenetic evolution is qualitatively different from that of adaptive equilibrium and microevolution, in terms of gravitation toward
7. ADAPTIVE POTENTIAL, BIOPHYSICAL PARADIGMS, AND THE SELECTIONAL ATTRACTOR
143
a more or less ‘‘distant’’ structural selectional attractor contained in the intersect between degrees of freedom in the biophysical paradigm for adaptive function and endogenous adaptive potential. 5. The structural attractor is not a ‘‘fixed’’ entity, but manifests dynamism in the dimensional spectrum, as a particular function of lability in absolute size. 6. A complex of directionalization factors can be identified in the structural attractor, as a mechanismic corollary of the activity of various endogenous developmental (and other biotic) ‘‘constraints.’’ 7. Although actual change within the time frame of a generation can occur only in the phenon of the active selection interface, adaptive capacity and potential must be regarded as being distributed among n iteratively assembled structure units and structure integrals. Structure integrals are in turn coordinated in terms of a superior domain in the context of a function integral reflecting adaptational (and potentially also selectional) modularity. 8. Multiple functionality explains both the degree of complexity and the apparent suboptimality manifested by many structure integrals of higher organisms.
This page intentionally left blank
8
EVOLUTIONARY MODE
EVOLUTIONARY MODE AND THE ITERATIVE ADAPTIVE RESPONSE The term evolutionary mode describes the topology of iterative phenotypic change in the adaptive response to the long-term selection profile. What range of modes of evolutionary change are manifested through realization of adaptive potential, and how are these related to the behavior of adaptive systems? Speciation (Chapter 6) is clearly one mode, but not all evolutionary activity can be analyzed in the context of a cladogenetic selection interface. A deeper understanding of the nature and diversity of evolutionary modes in general is clearly an essential component of any global theory. In the context of the analysis of adaptive systems, these questions clearly relate to all aspects of the topology of realized adaptive potential.
Allelogenesis and Evolutionary Mode in Amphigenesis, Cladogenesis, and Anagenesis Positive neomorph (namely, nonrecurrent) mutation, which we shall now term allelogenesis, must clearly form the true root of all evolutionary change. Thus, although we have defined evolutionary mode in terms of topology of realized iterative change in the phenotype, not all evolution actually leads to ‘‘modal’’ behavior in that sense. Although the genic mutational mechanism is in all probability fundamentally homogeneous for all evolutionary modes, much allelogenesis will express no form of iterative topology, mutational activity thus often simply constituting ‘‘evolution in the absence of any evolutionary mode being expressed,’’ as, for example, in addition to the existing complement of allomorphs.
145
146
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
Evolutionary mode can be understood only in terms of the topology of iterative phenotypic change resulting from repeated allelogenesis according to the dynamics of the selectional attractor, in the context of the long-term selection profile. There also has to be a time scale over which evolutionary topology is observed, and this could very usefully be not less than that of ambient speciation time for the lineage in question, thus linking back to our earlier definition of Tc in Chapter 3 (for which, of course, there can be no ‘‘general’’ value, only an average that is specific to the lineage over a given time course). Earlier authors defined several distinct evolutionary modes. Notably, Huxley (1958) recognized cladogenesis, anagenesis, and stasigenesis, and Rensch (1959) held a similar viewpoint. Cladogenesis has already been explicitly defined in terms of disjunct diversification linked to a bipartite selectional attractor in an anisotopic selection interface (see Chapter 6). In contrast, anagenesis manifests a linear topology with respect to an isotropic selection profile and a unipartite selectional attractor, generally for greater than ambient speciation time, so that anagenetic increments may often tend to be transspecific modulations toward a distant paradigm state. Not all evolution can, however, be usefully categorized in terms of clado- and anagenesis. Where there is a cyclic topology in the form of evolutionary reversal with respect to periodicity in the selection interface and adaptive response that is expressed over a much longer time frame, we may then encounter an additional evolutionary mode which can be termed amphigenesis. In this mode, incremental evolutionary steps tend to be species traits lying just beyond the domain of adaptive capacity. Rising slightly above the domain of tertiary adaptive equilibrium (see Chapter 5),
FIGURE 38 The topology of evolutionary mode (some component of allelogenesis does not, of course, enter any topological channel, and much may be presumed simply to join the repertoire of allomorphism in adaptive equilibrium).
8. EVOLUTIONARY MODE
147
amphigenesis can be seen as being truly evolution through its links with realization of adaptive potential and despite both bidirectionality in terms of topology and apparent similarity to adaptive equilibrium. Possible links between this evolutionary mode and the speciation process will also need further examination (see below). Given the variable expression of both linearity and directionality in evolutionary mode, it is once more underlined that the defining characteristic of evolution lies with the boundary between adaptive capacity and potential. Any change in adaptation is therefore equivalent to evolution, provided only that transgression of adaptive capacity is indeed manifested. Thus, when an apparently new phenotype arises through recombination of preexisting alleles alone, this does not constitute evolution, unless we are looking at the time delay between a neomorph mutation and its attainment of an adaptive peak (a new allelomorph may take some considerable time to reach its adaptive zenith in terms of recombination with other allelomorphs). However, the ‘‘peak-climbing’’ process is seen as transgressing adaptive capacity into adaptive potential, only when we are not observing a recurrent state in the ongoing adaptive equilibrium existing between variation and a fluctuating external environment: It is not entirely clear, for example, whether or not observed examples of ‘‘acquired dominance’’ such as that of Biston betularia f. carbonaria are due to truly neomorphic or recurrent allomorphic variation.
Simpsonian Phyletic Evolution Simpson (1953) recognized phyletic evolution as an evolutionary mode, a term regarded by Wright (1949, 1982b) as being linked to anagenesis sensu Rensch. Simpson included ‘‘short range adaptation to occasional or nonrecurrent environmental changes’’ and ‘‘evolutionary trends’’ of a heterogeneous kind in his concept of phyletic evolution, and despite its obvious heterogeneity, he viewed phyletic evolution as the alternative mode to speciation on the grounds that anagenesis occurs within the framework of a nonbranching lineage. This view has found little support from other workers, however, and the concept of phyletic evolution can be shown to have only restricted application to reality (see Chapter 17). Linear anagenetic change must not be equated with phyletic evolution, since the latter may contain not only novel anagenetic factors, but also amphigenetic patterns and diverse postspeciational allomorphic elements. Continued linear evolution beyond the boundaries of a speciation event may obviously derive from a wide heterogeny of genetic and selectional systems, some of which did and some of which did not form part of the cladogenetic selection interface that gave rise to the original speciation. Similarly, anagenesis cannot be supposed to occur solely within the confines of a lineage that has not undergone speciation at some point! ‘‘Phyletic evolution’’ as noncladogenetic change in a lineage is clearly a heterogeny.
148
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
The Microevolution/Macroevolution Dichotomy It is important to realize that neither evolutionary mode nor status within the microevolution/macroevolution dichotomy is concerned with differentials in mechanism or process, only in pattern (see also Carroll, 1997). The distinction between micro- and macroevolution was first made by Goldschmidt (1940). Macroevolution (sensu Goldschmidt) was supposed to occur through chromosomal rather than genetic mutation, irrespective of the action of selection. This view was not generally accepted by other workers, particularly once the origins and function of chromosome mutations had become better known, and the terms microevolution and macroevolution have also subsequently come to be applied somewhat loosely by many authors. Attempts have also been made to define macroevolution on the basis of changes occurring between rather than within a species, often on the assumption that macroevolutionary mechanisms are slow accumulations of changes occurring at the ‘‘micro’’ level (see Brooks and McLennan, 1991, for an overview). The developmental perspective on genetics obviously does not support such a view, and other difficulties with this simplification will be discussed at a later point (see Chapters 17 and 18). At this point, it is possible to usefully redefine microevolution and macroevolution on the basis of reversibility versus nonreversibility with respect to endogenous adaptive potential. To fully understand the differential between micro- and macroevolution, it is necessary in the first instance to consider the scenario presented by the isotropic niche profile. In this situation, very longterm stability in key parameters of the adaptive niche may permit complex structural change to evolve, given the existence of an attainable distant biophysical paradigm plus the presence of complementary endogenous adaptive potential. This situation may lead to a macroevolutionary event, in that circumstance where degree of movement toward the structural attractor is great enough to invoke irreversibility due to loss of endogenous adaptive potential, as a corollary of increase in developmental complexity. Micro- versus macroevolutionary patterns are therefore determined by the nature of activity within the adaptive system with special reference to the long-term selection profile, macroevolution thus generally also tending to encompass some component of gene pool splitting in addition to anagenesis, as a corollary of the time factor itself. With the foregoing revised definition of macroevolution, irreversibility in anagenesis can be interpreted as invocation of the ‘‘developmental ratchet,’’ whereas for cladogenesis, it is simply equivalent to speciation. It is also important to see that the microevolution/macroevolution dichotomy as defined above has no direct relationship to evolutionary mode, since these constitute potentially independent criteria (see below). A further problem lies in the fundamental similarity between different modes of linear structural change, certain of which have a subtle interrelationship (and one of which does not in fact constitute evolution at all). Here, it is useful to consider a time scale which may tend often to center around ambient speciation time of a lineage as a convenient yardstick for comparing tertiary dynamic equilibrium and amphigenesis. We may now attempt to list different manifestations of linear evolutionary topology (inclusive of the micro/macro dichotomy) thus:
149
8. EVOLUTIONARY MODE
Tertiary adaptive equilibrium
Evolution: amphigenesis
Micro- or macroanagenesis
Reversible through adaptive capacity. Mutations have arisen and entered adaptive capacity as allomorphs perpetuated in dynamic equilibrium, thus being fully reversible in the face of a changing selection profile.
Only reversible through adaptive potential. Mutations involved are generally both neomorphic and (other than transiently) nonallelomorphic. This clearly constitutes ‘‘microevolutionary anagenesis in reverse mode.’’
Linked to proximate biophysical paradigm and dynamic selection profile, tending to be expressed in quantitative change. Commonly only manifested in substructural traits.
Linked to a more distant biophysical paradigm and greater periodicity in the selection profile. May be expressed in qualitative change. Generally manifested in structural traits. Often transspecific in expression.
Microanagenesis is fully competent with respect to reversibility, but this does not occur, owing to the presence of an isotropic selection profile within the minimum time span of speciation. Macroanagenesis is not reversal-competent, owing to the degree of developmental complexity extending beyond threshold for same. Remote biophysical paradigm. Very long periodicity in the selection profile eventually invokes a ‘‘developmental ratchet’’ mechanism in macroanagenesis.
Generally expressed in infraspecific mode.
Generally manifested at higher taxonomic levels.
Most ‘‘nonlinear’’ allelogenesis may be usefully categorized as constituting microevolution, although as we have seen above, anagenesis can also come under the latter category. In much the same way as genomic anastomosis is a microevolutionary resolution of the same cladogenetic regime which gives rise to speciation, some component of anagenesis is microevolutionary, since with limited paradigm distance, reversibility is (at least in theory) possible, even when no actual reversal in selection profile demands it. In this, we can also see that the only dichotomy between microanagenesis and amphigenesis lies in actual reversal of the selection profile and adaptive response, with respect to amphigenetic mode. Microevolution (as amphigenesis) differs from tertiary adaptive equilibrium only in that loss of adaptive capacity for reversal has been invoked in the context of speciational divergence, and in the correlated occurrence of longer periodicity of the selection profile. Tertiary adaptive equilibrium itself (as reversible change in continuous variation within adaptive capacity) is clearly equivalent to classic ‘‘directional selection,’’ but unlike anagenesis and amphigenesis, here there is only change in variance within the existing repertoire of continuous variation. At the other end of the spectrum, in macroevolution, the genetic system has simply changed beyond any potential for reversal. The above relationships can perhaps best be illustrated from a hypothetical (and unrealistic!) example: Tertiary adaptive equilibrium: Flying appendage is facultatively evolved within existing spectrum of adaptive capacity, hence is both genotypically and phenotypically reversible in the time span of a few generations.
150
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
Amphigenesis: Flying appendage completely reverts to walking function with respect to reversal in selection profile over ambient speciation time. Microanagenesis: Flying appendage is capable of reverting, but no selectional demand actually exists for this to happen. Macroanagenesis: Flying appendage becomes completely nonfunctional on reversal of an adaptive shift, owing to irreversibility in adaptive potential. In reality, of course, progression from rudimentary gliding to an advanced flight mechanism rather obviously constitutes a macroanagenetic trajectory, since this change could only occur via iterative incremental change toward a superstructural state defined by a rigidly constrained biophysical paradigm, and since the selection profile in this scenario can only be isotropic. Where a subsequent reversal in the external selective environment does occur, this will mean either extinction or vestigiation. Not all real examples, however, manifest a clear categorization in terms of micro/macro status: In the above context, the classic work on ‘‘orthogenesis’’ in Gryphaea oysters may refer, not to microevolution (as claimed by Carter, 1951, on the grounds that ‘‘microevolution consists in gradual change of the mean form of a population’’), but to true macroevolutionary change. It is apparent that many Gryphaea lineages were unable to revert structurally in the face of a reversal in external environmental conditions (see also Chapter 20). The Link between Minor/Major Cladogenesis and the Microevolution/ Macroevolution Dichotomy Returning to our earlier categorization of cladogenesis as minor versus major (Chapter 6), it is further necessary to point out that there need be no precise correspondence between micro- and minor or macro- and major categories of cladogenesis. Macrocladogenesis clearly contains all components of both minor and major cladogenesis that have transcended a certain threshold of reversibility, and microcladogenesis similarly contains those that have not. However, it is nevertheless clear that there will often tend to be some rough approximation between micro and minor and between macro and major. Both evolutionary mode and the micro/macro dichotomy are thus functions of the interaction between selection profile and adaptive potential, in which the value of Tc forms a highly significant controllant influence.
ANALYZING EVOLUTIONARY MODE We have now outlined the primary topological definitions of the terms cladogenesis, amphigenesis, and anagenesis, placing these evolutionary modes in perspective with the architecture of the selection interface, also clarifying the microevolution/macroevolution dichotomy as a function of reversibility in the
8. EVOLUTIONARY MODE
151
context of adaptive capacity or potential. There now follows an account of each mode in turn.
The Role of Allelogenesis Although allelogenesis includes noniterative, transient allelomorphic states leading both to gene fixation and to expansion of allomorphism, we must now add that it should be taken to exclude the addition of neutral microgenetic alleles, the frequencies of which come to be determined purely as a function of nonselectional (stochastic) forces, a situation that has been aptly termed ‘‘genetic drift’’ in the past. As already indicated above, allelogenesis is concerned with the addition of new allomorphic genes, not only to the repertoire of adaptive equilibrium, but also to all modes of true evolutionary change.
Amphigenesis Amphigenesis is a fundamental evolutionary mode that has previously been overlooked. As stated above, its differentiation from ‘‘reversible directional selection’’ lies with the distinction between adaptive capacity and potential, and with a differential in temporal periodicity of the selection profile that is very often linked to a duration greater than or equal to the ambient speciation time for a given lineage. Amphigenesis is thus essentially a superset of adaptive equilibrium, as we transpose from adaptive capacity to adaptive potential and microevolution. Similarly, amphigenesis is distinguished from microanagenesis only through links with actual reversal in response to a dynamic selection profile: Ovipositor length in parasitic wasps cannot constitute ‘‘linearly progressive evolutionary change,’’ since increase–decrease trends are universally distributed in the taxonomy of these insects, being often expressed even in species-to-species differentials. This parameter can obviously change in either direction, according to such extrinsic selectional demands as (for example) degree of concealment of the parasite’s host. This pattern of change seems unlikely to be explained as movement within adaptive capacity, and thus probably constitutes amphigenesis. Similarly, the distribution of the anal cremaster in the pupa of ditrysian Lepidoptera is in all probability a trait that has ‘‘come and gone’’ in many different lineages, according to a highly labile adaptational requirement that is met by a simple structural adjustment (Brock, in prep.). Sheldon (1987), in his detailed study of well preserved lineages of trilobites, observed definite examples of evolutionary reversal, which he remarked had probably gone unnoticed owing to a reliance on the validity of Dollo’s law. This probably also constitutes amphigenesis, given the time frame over which these trends were in operation, plus the usual taxonomic value of the characters involved. Chromosome number is a further example of an amphigenetic character (see Chapter 13).
152
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
Most observed ‘‘microevolutionary’’ change in organisms is in fact either genetic drift or adaptive equilibrium expressed in allomorphism, leading neither to speciation nor to anagenetic change, only rarely constituting true microevolution, when the presence of neomorph mutation is explicitly proved. Likewise, amphigenesis (rather than linear anagenesis) is probably a very common input to speciation patterns in many evolutionary lineages (see Chapter 21). Considering the likely correlation between amphigenesis and generation of species diversity, this evolutionary mode may be linked more to spatial (than to purely temporal) dynamism. This is why amphigenetic change can tend to be approximately coincident with speciation time, while at the same time being expressed by different parameters of superstructure than those affected by an intrinsically more isotropic anagenetic selection interface. Amphigenesis and the Disjunct Selection Interface Amphigenesis may often be expressed in that situation in which a structural state is entirely lost in the phenotype because of a disjunct discontinuity in the selection interface, then reappears, either through recurrent mutation or else via a neomorphic change in which the recurrent phenotype state is determined by analogous rather than homologous genetic material. Our definition of amphigenesis therefore does not require that a recurrent phenotypic state equates with an atavistic genotypic one, since the same outcome may result from a different genotypic background: This can easily be understood from an analogy in mimicry, where the similar color patterning of model and mimic are obviously generated from different gene systems. In the same way, there is no reason why some evolutionary reversals within a single lineage should invariably occur by true atavistic mutation.
Anagenesis Wright (1982b) used the term orthogenesis for anagenesis. Rensch (1959) discussed many early accounts of ‘‘directed evolution’’ in the context of his own concept of anagenesis, which latter was, however, tied to a misleading and poorly defined notion of ‘‘progressive evolution.’’ Confusion between anagenesis and the Simpsonian heterogeny of ‘‘phyletic evolution’’ has already been discussed above. Similarly, the term trend has also given rise to much confusion. Some workers use the latter term only for parallel anagenesis, while Simpson (1953) stated that his own usage was ‘‘neutral . . . without implication to causes.’’ Gould (1990) has claimed that ‘‘trends’’ have always been discussed as ‘‘lineage anagenesis.’’ However, evolutionary biologists from Darwin to Huxley have in fact long presumed that anagenetic change must pass through multiple speciation events. Gould also argues that ‘‘anagenesis is almost always the product of accumulated cladogenesis filtered through a higher level process of species sorting’’ (see Chapter 20). Clearly, we must now dismiss the term ‘‘trend’’ as a heterogeny that is descriptive and nothing more. Similarly, such concepts as ‘‘phyletic evolution’’ and ‘‘species sorting’’ do not form any rationale for an interpretation of anagenesis.
8. EVOLUTIONARY MODE
153
We have already redefined anagenesis in terms of an iterative adaptive response in some component of phenotype form to the isotropic selection profile, involving realization of adaptive potential and manifesting linear structural progression toward a static structural attractor. As we have already seen above, this mode of evolution also includes both micro- and macroevolutionary elements, according to whether or not irreversibility is possible. In contrast to the situation with amphigenesis, the principal coordinates of the structural attractor for an anagenetic sequence are constant at least over ambient speciation time of a lineage, and often far beyond (i.e., excluding allometric influences in the dimensional spectrum and the effect of adaptational reciprocity). Although anagenesis may at times initially constitute a response to a changing external environment, it may tend to proceed in the context of a niche profile that is static, at least for certain major coordinates of the biophysical paradigm. This link between anagenesis and static niche profile may seem intuitively unlikely. However, this will be shown to be a correct interpretation for a significant element of anagenetic evolution (although this hypothesis will nevertheless have to come under closer scrutiny at a later juncture in Chapters 17 and 19). Redundancy of the isotropic selection profile for anagenesis during the later stages of a complex anagenetic sequence results in developmental–homeostatic barriers to structural reversal, giving rise to vestigiation (or even extinction), and this phenomenon again underlines the reality of the dichotomy existing between micro- and macroanagenesis. Anagenesis and the Adaptive Niche The total niche will contain components linked to modes of adaptive response as diverse as primary allomorphism and anagenesis, there being no sense in which anagenetically structured components of the phenotype constitute ‘‘nonadaptive’’ aspects of the organism–niche interface by virtue of the absence of an active selection interface during periods of anagenetic stasis (as has sometimes been imagined). The correct interpretation here is that the selection interface is largely concentrated on adaptive equilibrium for most ambient activity in the adaptive system, whereas essential niche-linked structural parameters exist in a state of evolutionary stasis maintained by a fixed contribution to the adaptive state for long periods of time, namely, through the medium of the adaptation interface alone. The anagenetic component of the total niche is simply the spatial summation of a cluster of isotropic niche parameters (the macroniche), the most stable of which are identifiable particularly (although not exclusively) in sub- and hypoparametric niche space (see Chapter 2).
Major Cladogenesis and Anagenesis Is all anagenesis ultimately derived from a major cladogenetic selection interface? Speciation occurs as a partial realization of cladogenetic potential. How does iterated cladogenetic activity affect subsequent evolution following the actual genome split itself? And what happens when a cladogenetic event is also coincident with a major anagenetic shift?
154
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
Cladogenesis is composed of several levels of selectional activity, from minor (phenotypic) through speciation (genotypic), continuing into the domain of the transspecific selection interface. The reason for rapid structural divergence of species may often lie, not in the act of speciation itself, so much as in postspeciational divergence. There will clearly have been a release from the centripetal component of cladogenetic potential once reproductive isolation has been implicated, and this may in fact facilitate such activity. Postspeciational cladogenesis (see Chapter 6) is identified as an evolutionary mechanism involving mutual repulsion between isolated gene pools following a speciation event, in which the two gene pools involved continue to compete for shared niche space until the centrifugal cladogenetic force is fully resolved. This results from a tendency for progressive elimination of the gene pool niche intersect following the evolution of gene pool isolating mechanisms—a mechanism that is also partly signified by ‘‘character displacement’’ for gene pools with only a partial distributional overlap (see below). The speciation process itself need contain only that complement of potential for behavioral or structural modulation lying within the domain of gene pool isolating mechanisms, up until gene pool isolation is effectively equal to 1.0, although the degree of divergence between emergent gene reservoirs will obviously depend on events that have occurred in independently evolving, allopatric gene pools. In this context, ‘‘microspeciation’’ is, in fact, the true speciation mechanism per se, and much postspeciational divergence will probably tend to reside in postspeciational cladogenesis. This is the result of postspeciational centrifugal selection forces affecting the continued morphodifferentiation of species through extension of the influence of cladogenetic forces beyond the narrower confines of primary species isolating mechanisms. Postspeciational divergence is also the mechanism responsible for (rather than being strictly synonymous with) ‘‘character displacement’’: Lack (1947) found that seed eating geospizine finches in the Galapagos occurring on the same island were more divergent in beak length than when they occurred alone, and that species with very similar beaks rarely occurred together. Brown and Wilson (1956) stated, ‘‘When two species overlap geographically, differences between them are accentuated—the effect in question being weakened or lost outside this zone.’’ Dobzhansky (1970) stated that habitat, temporal, and ethological mechanisms in particular were involved in ‘‘character displacement’’ of this kind. Character displacement between species is clearly one aspect of postspeciational cladogenesis, and this also belongs in the postspeciational component of the phyletic evolution heterogeny of Simpson. The intensity of the postspeciational cladogenetic force must clearly be proportional to the degree of distributional sympatry in gene reservoir space; hence, character displacement is simply the expected steep end of the postspeciational cladogenetic gradient manifested in evolutionary change to gene pools of a gene reservoir that are only locally contiguous in distribution, so far as species emerging from a common cladoge-
155
8. EVOLUTIONARY MODE
netic bifurcation point are concerned. This does not, of course, exclude competition from more distantly related species having an effect on evolutionary rate and direction in the postspeciational domain (see Chapter 18). Given that some ‘‘cladists’’ have chosen to reject the concept of postspeciational divergence, it is essential to see that the phenomenon of character displacement quite clearly proves the reality of this mechanism, in the context of restricted overlap between ranges of species. Where complete neosympatry exists (as must surely be a frequent scenario), postspeciational divergence must logically be at least as great as that expressed when there is only a partial intersect. Renschian Cladogenesis and the Domain of Anagenesis The above analysis contains several points which clearly require deeper investigation. Under certain conditions, a speciational event may lead to the origin of a new lineage manifesting a new anagenetic sequence. This mechanism is clearly not ‘‘ambient speciation,’’ which latter must contain much amphigenetic activity. The cladogenetic event that gave rise to the class Aves, for example, is clearly of a qualitatively different nature to that separating closely related species of phylloscopine warblers! ‘‘Macrocladogenesis’’ (where two new higher groups diverge at a speciation node) occurs whenever a cladogenetic event explores divergent paths, one of which is linked to a novel anagenetic sequence, complementing a new lineage niche. Renschian cladogenesis (see Chapter 6) is thus expressed by an iterated adaptive response to a coincident cladoanagenetic selection interface. In Renschian cladogenesis, a new anagenetic lineage is initiated; in ambient speciation, new gene pools are defined within the context of the preexisting lineage: Ambient speciation
Renschian cladogenesis
Iterative dimension is not constantly directional in terms of the selectional attractor. Niche profile is not isotropic for any leading effect.
Iterative dimension is directional in terms of niche profile and the structural attractor. Niche profile is isotropic for some leading effect phenon or structure unit or integral.
Renschian cladogenesis is therefore ‘‘cladoanagenesis,’’ its origin involving functional change and qualitative niche shift. It is also transspeciational in ultimate directionality, in that an emergent lineage may subsequently be punctuated by further, ambient speciation events. The corollary of this is that any anagenetic sequence that is linked to the Renschian bifurcation will in no way be impeded by subsequent cladogenesis. Cladogenesis and anagenesis may alternatively be manifested as potentially independent mechanisms, since there is no reason why anagenesis cannot be initiated by factors which did not form part of the preceding cladogenetic selection interface. Thus, postspeciational cladogenesis only includes that component of anagenetic activity that is ‘‘residual’’ in terms of a partially resolved, preexisting Renschian cladogenetic event. However, we must at a later stage go on to consider how much anagenetic change can occur before speciation is actually invoked by that process (see Chapter 17).
156
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
ANAGENESIS AND EVOLUTIONARY PROGRESS Rensch (1959) proposed usage of the term anagenesis for ‘‘development towards higher phylogenetical levels’’ and cladogenesis for lineage splitting. Huxley (1942) developed similar ideas to Rensch, defining progress as an unrestricted type of improvement permitting further improvement. Rensch’s view of anagenesis included the notion that ‘‘a general improvement is met with in all major animal phyla and in numerous animal classes so far as we may judge by their phylogeny,’’ a viewpoint that has since been widely contested (see, for example, Williams, 1966). This insistence of an equation between anagenesis and general evolutionary progress was probably in large part responsible for a decline in interest in this evolutionary mode in many quarters.
Dimensions of Evolutionary Progress Huxley (1942) and Rensch (1947) listed those characteristics which they regarded as constituting progressive evolution. Their views were, however, later dismissed by Simpson (1949), although Dobzhansky (1970) chose to disagree with this refutation: Rensch’s features of anagenesis were given as increased complexity, rationalization of structure or function (including simplification or centralization), increased plasticity of structure and function, ‘‘improvement permitting further improvement,’’ and increased independence of environment and command over environmental factors. Rensch further concluded that the most essential phenomena of anagenesis were increased complexity and rationalization of form and function of organs and structures. Not all measures of evolutionary progress have been linked to anagenesis. Thoday (1953, 1958) proposed time as the measure of progress. However, some of the least evolved living things then become ‘‘the most advanced,’’ despite the observation that many long-term ‘‘survivors’’ are in fact of very restricted distribution and probably approaching extinction! Similarly, diversity of species in a lineage is no measure of progress, as many ‘‘explosive radiations’’ have been short lived in geological terms. The question of evolutionary progress has also been raised in relation to the profile of additive genetic variance in populations, as with Fisher’s fundamental theorem of natural selection, which held that the rate of increase in fitness of any organism at any time is equal to its additive genetic variance at that time. Fisher’s theorem is, however, a misunderstanding of fitness. For example, a gene pool may enjoy high survivorship in a stable, channeled environment or in a highly chaotic one, by virtue of having little in the way of additive genetic variance in the former, or a mainly logistic adaptive strategy in the latter (see also Maynard Smith, 1998, for a discussion). The question as to whether long-term evolutionary change can manifest any characteristics which may be described as ‘‘progressive evolution’’ must now be critically reexamined, and here it is necessary in the first instance to
8. EVOLUTIONARY MODE
157
distinguish progress in the adaptive state from anagenetic progress toward the structural attractor. Progress must clearly be investigated with reference to two quite different dimensions. The state of adaptation for a given subject gene pool seeks to maintain stasis (probability of survival 씮 1.0) in relation to changing selection profiles in the adaptive system. Over time, the fundamental adaptive state of a lineage may tend to increase by virtue of such diverse criteria as expansion of the total number of gene pools and expansion of the allomorphic domain in response to the periodic behavior of the selection interface. However, the real adaptive state of a gene pool perpetually tends to 1.0, in the absence of extinction. The fundamental adaptive state (see Chapter 5) thus follows a path of dynamic equilibrium, since variation in the external environment is continually acting to depress adaptivity and thus, also, to deflect the lineage gene pool toward a logistic strategy. Even if we consider that the index Ai gives an indication of the degree of gravitation toward the structural attractor, this no doubt also follows a pathway of dynamic equilibrium at the level of lineage, at least in the longer term. Evolution thus constitutes organic change in the adaptive response in terms of maintenance (rather than ‘‘raising’’) of the real adaptive state. However, evolutionary topology simultaneously describes the integral of structural adaptational change over lineage time. This integral is ‘‘summed,’’ not within the state of adaptation (which, as we have just seen, perpetually tends to 1.0), but only in the dimension of structure as this relates to the biophysical paradigm state. The later situation can thus only be understood within the context of anagenesis, and in relation to the structural selectional attractor (see previous chapter). Adaptational progress thus appears to relate to fluctuation between fundamental and real adaptive states, and not to the structural element of evolution as manifested in anagenetic change, but the latter can nevertheless objectively be termed ‘‘progressive’’ in relation to the biophysical paradigm state. Only on the anagenetic plane do we find (in this modified context) true progressive evolution, since the state of adaptation cannot proceed beyond 1.0. This situation can be visualized by viewing evolutionary progress on two planes (Fig. 39). To what extent can ‘‘structural progress’’ in the above scenario be linked in turn to improvement in the actual adaptive state? Knoll (1984) states that no mass extinction of vascular plants occurred at the K–T boundary. However, taxon replacement was clearly associated with improvement of vascular architecture and mechanisms of fertilization, and angiosperms thus ousted other groups. The above example seems to show that the anagenetic state does ultimately affect the probability of longer term survival. However, many other lineages (for example, Echinodemata and Coelenterata) have survived in the very long term with similar logistic adaptive strategies to those of lower plants! Consequently, although it is possible to find examples where structural progress has apparently led to a sustained increase in the adaptive state, these two planes appear not to be inextricably linked in the very long term.
158
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
FIGURE 39 The adaptive index (Ai) is seen following a pathway of adaptive equilibrium, whereas anagenesis (Ya) progresses toward an adaptive optimum (X axis ⫽ lineage time; Y axis ⫽ adaptive state).
We must now go on to reconsider the view expressed by Williams (1966), ‘‘Selection will maintain adaptation by occasionally substituting one adaptive character for another, but this will not result in any of the kinds of cumulative progress that have been envisioned.’’ This statement is entirely true in terms of the adaptive state of a lineage, but it does not apply to the phyletic trajectory toward a functionally refined state in the structural attractor as manifested in anagenesis. A further problem is, of course, that we also have to distinguish between functional and adaptational progress: A flint axe is functionally primitive compared to a powered chain saw, but it could prove adaptationally superior if the high technology method encounters nonsustainability over a longer time frame. Because selection (and adaptation in general) is ‘‘blind to the future,’’ many functional advances will constitute adaptational blunders in the longer term. Gryphaea coiling is an example of this (see also Chapter 20). Behavioral Evolution and Evolutionary Progress From the above analysis, progress in evolution appears to be a predominantly structural phenomenon. However, the ultimate goal is stabilization of the strategy of maximizing deterministic survival factors over purely stochastic influences in the adaptive system, and the mechanism for this may in fact tend ultimately to shift toward the behavioral domain, as the axial drive of longterm evolution reaches fruition. This function may be seen as an extension of behavioral control beyond the time t dimension (life span of an individual), as rendered possible by flow of information from generation to generation, initially through the medium of parental care and learning and ultimately
8. EVOLUTIONARY MODE
159
through cultural evolution. This clearly constitutes the true axis of evolutionary progress, in the very long term: The selection interface for perpetuation of genes concerned with social interactivity follows a modified paradigm defined by Hamilton (1964a,b), according to an increase in probability of survival arising from an effect of the behavioral interaction in question, this being linked to degree of genetical relatedness between ‘‘helper’’ and ‘‘recipient’’ individuals. This is inclusive fitness, as defined by number of offspring produced by a ‘‘helper’’ genotype AA minus offspring produced by the carrier owing to help received, plus additional offspring produced by relatives as a result of help from AA, weighted by degree of relatedness between AA and recipients. In the tripartite model of the selection interface (Chapter 4), the leading factor may fall progressively more to kinship adaptation via the medium of inclusive fitness. However, this does not change the concept of the gene pool as forming the ‘‘epicenter of adaptation.’’ This confusion arises only from the (perfectly valid) approach of adopting a ‘‘genocentric’’ view of the manner in which inclusive fitness operates (see Dawkins, 1976). However, choice of a convenient reference frame should not be misconstrued as a negation of the way in which higher levels of complexity evolve in the gene pool, as an emergent evolutionary corollary of fundamental genic selection. Behavior is thus ultimately dominant over structure as the leading realization function in orientation of the adaptive ensemble (see Chapter 1), in the quest for maximization of the adaptive state, and the selectional attractor similarly comes to encompass that domain. Advanced behavioral systems clearly possess the capacity or potential for direct manipulation of the environment—and ultimately also of the structural component of adaptation itself. In this context, genetic engineering becomes part of human adaptive capacity and potential. Capacity for information processing could thus be a better measure of progress (although only if this is additionally linked to cognizance of shortterm gain as against long-term loss!). Complexity and Evolutionary Progress The behavioral paradigm clearly requires a certain level of preexisting structural complexity before an optimum fitness strategy can be further invoked. Evolution thus must initially follow a path of increasing biophysical efficiency, and this in turn may or may not contain a corollary for an increase in behavioral plasticity also. In the release of complex behavior patterns, we may ultimately also observe a mechanism tending to release the adaptive state from its pathway of dynamic equilibrium. The criterion of complexity extends far beyond that of structural advancement and behavioral flexibility, to additionally encompass aspects of the holistic activity of entire biotas: Odum (1971) stated that increasingly complex and diverse systems have achieved control over the atmosphere. In this view, there is in fact some form of general progress in the evolution of adaptive systems
160
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
that is manifested by whole biotas, rather than by discrete phyletic lineages. This must be viewed in the context of the potential of global adaptive systems to proceed toward the evolution of higher levels of complexity within which consciousness emerges. In this manner, it can also be seen that adaptive systems themselves manifest progress in terms of the level of complexity emerging during very long-term evolution.
MAIN POINTS FROM CHAPTER 8 1. Allelogenesis, as positive neomorph mutation (exclusive of mutations perpetuated in a state of genetic drift by stochastic factors alone), is the raw material of all evolutionary change. 2. Evolutionary mode is manifested in topology of the phenotypic adaptive response following iterative allelogenesis over lineage time. Three fundamental modes exist: cladogenesis, anagenesis, and amphigenesis. 3. The microevolution/macroevolution dichotomy should ideally be based on the presence or absence of reversibility within adaptive potential. Only speciation and anagenesis (in part) constitute true macroevolution. 4. Amphigenesis constitutes evolutionary reversal within the domain of adaptive potential. It is thus equivalent to ‘‘anagenesis which not only retains adaptive potential for reversal, but where the latter actually occurs.’’ This evolutionary mode may frequently form a large element in species differentiation. 5. Anagenesis arises from an iterative train of evolutionary changes gravitating toward major coordinates of a distant structural attractor, in the context of an isotropic niche profile. It may be linked to postspeciational divergence or else function entirely independently of any cladogenetic selection interface. 6. Evolutionary progress can be defined in relation to the trajectory of an anagenetic sequence, but not necessarily in the adaptive state of a lineage. However, progress is also an emergent property in the evolutionary behavior of entire adaptive systems.
9
STRUCTURAL PARADIGMS OF DEVELOPMENT
Having investigated those factors which determine the architecture of the structural attractor and the modes of evolution associated with different configurations of selection profile, it is now necessary to consider how these factors relate to development. There is clearly a need at this juncture to understand the biophysical paradigm concept, not only in relation to the final phenotype state at the adaptation interface, but also in consideration of aspects of function which operate during development. In this approach, we should also hope to be able to identify the developmental coordinates of adaptive potential, as a prelude to a deeper investigation of the manner in which genetic systems control and modify structure paradigms. Adaptive potential cannot be envisaged as being realized by virtue of one step gene mutation or from mere recombination of preexisting alleles, but must involve factors appertaining to iterative neomorphic mutational activity of genes affecting the major coordinates of development. The genetic dimension in adaptive potential thus clearly lies with the developmental, rather than Mendelian model, in that the latter can have only limited relevance beyond realization of adaptive capacity. As stated by Maynard Smith (1972), the failure of neo-Darwinism lay mainly in the lack of a developmental component to the genetics program. It is in the latter that we must now seek a deeper understanding of the true significance of the Thompsonian ‘‘internal’’ input to the general theory of evolution.
161
162
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
DEVELOPMENTAL DYNAMICS OF THE BIOPHYSICAL PARADIGM We have so far considered evolution of the phenotype, yet the final adaptive state of structure cannot be divorced from the mechanisms of development. Thus, there must be other biophysical paradigms operating at precursor levels. The structural selectional attractor cannot therefore constitute a single entity relating to the final phenotype state, but must tend to vary in some manner with respect to different phases of development. The biophysical paradigm is thus a dynamic entity, not only during anagenesis, but also throughout development. The ensuing discussion will be particularly concerned with the morphogenetic dimension in development, since major evolutionary changes are defined and measured in that context, in terms of progress toward paradigm form in biophysical design. In this context, the largest functional ‘‘anagenetic targets’’ must be four-dimensional loci described by the coordinates of growth and morphogenesis.
Adaptational and Fabricational Paradigms of Development That the biophysical paradigm is dynamic within the trajectory of development for any chosen structure integral is clear from the fact that different developmental activities evidently perform different functions at different developmental stages: The thoracic tracheae of the insect wing manifest independent functions at different developmental stages, having a respiratory role in the embryo combined with a morphogenetic one connected to the trajectory of developing wing veins, ultimately providing mechanical support of the wing membrane in the adult phase. What principal biophysical paradigms does a structure pass through during the course of a complex developmental trajectory of the kind just described? To answer this question, we may begin by comparing and contrasting two different goals of development, one linked to the structural coordinates of direct adaptational mechanisms of the free-living phenotype, the other concerning the mechanisms through which phenotype form is actually assembled. These functions thus appear to be respectively linked to adaptational versus fabricational paradigms, a dichotomy which will be shown to identify a sharp divergence in the morphogenetic patterns around which development is organized. Thus, not all function is adaptation in the sense of direct interaction with the external environment, in that those fabricational mechanisms lying deeper in the trajectory of development clearly have an indirect adaptational role to play, thus relating to a quite different biophysical paradigm. The adaptational paradigm is the biophysical paradigm state that we have already examined in some detail (Chapter 7), and which relates to direct manifestation of adaptation in the organism–environment interaction, whereas the fabricational paradigm is that which is concerned with ‘‘how to construct something in an energy efficient manner.’’
9. STRUCTURAL PARADIGMS OF DEVELOPMENT
163
The overall biophysical paradigm thus changes during development, owing in particular to the existence of a fabricational function at certain stages. There are therefore phases when the coordinates around which development is organized are predominantly external (linked to the adaptation interface) or internal (linked to fabricational function), and these differentials have profound implications. Clearly, a fundamental distinction also exists between structural paradigms lying in earlier parts of the developmental function cycle and those existing at later stages, since the former are more likely to be linked to the fabricational than to the adaptational paradigm. Structural paradigms for early development thus may manifest a completely different relationship to the function integral components of final phenotype form. In general then, the developmental trajectory tends to begin within the framework of a predominantly fabricational paradigm, then gravitate progressively toward an adaptational one as we approach the phenotype state. Locus of the Selection Interface in Development While the adaptation interface lies at the end of a function cycle in behavior, the selection interface can lie at any point in a behavioral or developmental function cycle. Selection acts not only on ‘‘final traits,’’ but also on the fabricational viability of precursor morphogenetic states of earlier development. The endogenous selection interface is that which demands the fabricational paradigm. At a later stage, we shall also see that a further, indirect adaptation interface also exists in development, in the restricted sense of the embryogenetic paradigm (see below).
PRINCIPAL STRUCTURAL PARADIGMS OF DEVELOPMENT We may consider that early development is dominated by cytogenesis as the zygote divides and cells multiply, at first seemingly with little evidence of determination, then with the fixing of a few major coordinates such as the anterior–posterior and dorsoventral body axes, as cytogenesis gives way to a histogenetic phase. As cleavage ends and gastrulation commences, we begin to see the emergence of those morphogenetic coordinates that are characteristic of higher group lineage, then of progressively narrower systematic divisions. Many observed evolutionary changes are reflected within these mid-level developmental coordinates, so that a first approach must be to examine the nature of the morphogenetic paradigms around which development evolves in the immediate wake of early cytohistogenesis.
Ontogeny, Phenogeny, and Embryogeny Given that qualitatively different biophysical paradigms clearly do exist for fabricational versus adaptational states (see above), it follows that the developmental process itself must be subdivisible into several interacting yet quasiautonomous systems.
164
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
The highest coordinates of morphogenesis must in fact be organized around biophysical paradigms defining developmental processes corresponding to three principal paradigms based on quasi-autonomous functions linked to adaptational and fabricational structural paradigms, and also to the external versus internal adaptation interface. The three principal processes of development are here named as follows*: 1. Phenogeny is that developmental paradigm which is linked to an active adaptation interface with the external environment. 2. Ontogeny is that paradigm which is concerned with purely endogenous fabricational function. 3. Embryogeny is the endogenous adaptational paradigm, linked to parent metabolism rather than to the external environment. The above scheme can be visualized as shown in Fig. 40, using part of the development trajectory for the insect wing as an exemplar.
FIGURE 40 Embryogeny, ontogeny, and phenogeny in relation to a single developmental trajectory (the thoracic tracheal system of an insect).
No developmental paradigm can of course be presumed to be a single static entity, but rather the phenogenetic, fabricational, and embryogenetic paradigms must constitute dynamic structures. In the same way, the three structural paradigms must also interdigitate with one another during the course of development. Each fabricational sequence thus forms part of a continuum which gradually merges with a phenogenetic sequence, the latter ending at the adaptation interface in the final phenotype state. Separate function chains in the developmental trajectory may thus express qualitatively different manifestations of evolutionary activity, and certain developmental trajectories may manifest considerable mutual autonomy. For example, the embryogenetic paradigm may include certain elements that are completely independent of the phenotype state. * In the nomenclature used here, I have striven to avoid proliferation of new terminology, while at the same time being aware that certain terms have been used either in different contexts or even synonymously in the past.
9. STRUCTURAL PARADIGMS OF DEVELOPMENT
165
The above observations can be shown to have profound implications for the concepts of adaptive capacity and potential, and it is also evident that the structural attractor has separate domains in pheno- and ontoanagenesis. Origins of the Phenogenetic Sequence The nature and origins of phenogeny as a dynamic structure can be understood through consideration of a simple developmental sequence expressing only growth by repeated binary cell division. Change in absolute size may come to link to a sequence of temporal changes in the adaptive niche as the organism–environment relationship complexifies, and this in turn may favor change in the structural adaptive response. Even in the absence of any real qualitative change in niche, the adaptive paradigm will thus tend to manifest an endogenous differential expressed in the dimensional spectrum (see Chapter 7) as a result of a varying gravitational influence as growth proceeds. The adaptive response to selection pressure linked to dynamic niche parameters may thus tend to be expressed in differential growth, thereby describing a simple phenogenetic sequence, rather than a single final state. Altered adaptational paradigms linked to changing niche structure may thus come to be expressed in the adaptive response as a phenogenetic sequence. In this scheme, some cell lineages may express simple linear growth while others manifest an ‘‘allometric’’ (log–linear) pattern, and the values of constants and variables in the equations of growth may diverge between different cell lineages, the outcome being the evolution of a progressively more complex phenogeny. Of particular interest from the viewpoint of adaptive potential is the likelihood that one focus for flexibility in developmental coordinates clearly lies with those axes of growth linked to allometric differentials in the phenogenetic sequence, a circumstance which seems likely to be a fundamental attribute of most higher organisms (see Chapter 16). The phenotype of higher organisms is frequently described by a sequence of connected states, rather than by a single postembryonic form: The larval body vestiture of butterflies and moths has a phenotypic adaptive function through several instars which often differs considerably from one instar to the next. Such state-to-state changes are not of exclusively fabricational function, but reflect differences in the external adaptation interface at different stages of postembryonic development, which are probably at least partly linked to size differentials.
Phenogeny thus describes the trajectory of development of the phenotype in terms of structure linked to adaptational activity in a changing external environment and is frequently described by a phenogenetic sequence. Caenophenogeny The more niche change during development tends to lie with qualitative differentials, the more the phenogenetic sequence will tend to express discontinuity over the course of a developmental trajectory, as the adaptive response meets a demand for structural specialization. Very many phenogenetic sequences thus consist of nonlinear patterns of change. In this, we must distinguish between simple and complex ‘‘caenophenogenetic’’ developmental trajectories. The biophysical paradigm for a given developmental phase can thus be either ‘‘axial’’ or ‘‘tangential’’ to the primary phenogenetic sequence:
166
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
• Axial refers to quantitative change, for example, linked to an environmental cline correlated with simple growth relationships in the relevant adaptive response. • Tangential refers to qualitative change, where the adaptive niche is qualitatively different from one phenogenetic phase to next; differentials do not then form a simple linear progression with respect to the coordinates of morphogenesis.
FIGURE 41 Caenophenogeny: P1, P2, P3 ⫽ three phenogenetic states carrying adaptational specializations in terms of qualitative temporal differentiation in the adaptive niche (N1–N3).
In this way, the phenogenetic sequence either shows an axial progression between closely related adaptational paradigms, or else it manifests qualitative changes when the adaptation interface links to highly tangential adaptative states. Caenophenogeny can therefore be defined as that manifestation of phenogeny in which a qualitatively different adaptation interface affects independent components of morphogenesis via the adaptive response, and this will usually reflect a sequence of qualitatively different niche regimes. Haeckelian ‘‘caenogenesis’’ is thus a special case of phenogeny: The above trend can be seen in its most extreme manifestation in the metamorphosis of holometabolous insects, which incurs two phases of embryogeny (namely, where there is a second quiescent phase linked to larval metabolism). This clearly constitutes complex caenophenogeny. Dynamism in the spatial and temporal planes is, of course, a fundamental characteristic of the adaptation interface. The ‘‘horizontal perspective’’ is derived from distribution of ‘‘spread K’’ over gene reservoir niche space via the allomorphic structure of the gene pool, while the ‘‘vertical perspective’’ of phenogeny lies with niche parameters which change over a time course (the distribution of K over time t). The Origins of Ontogeny and Embryogeny The emergence of a multicellular organism resembling the cytogenetic stage has been supposed to have occurred from a ciliated unicell which formed
9. STRUCTURAL PARADIGMS OF DEVELOPMENT
167
an aggregate not unlike the early embryos of the first metazoan phyla (see Gilbert, 1997). Wolpert (1990a) states that the evolution of development required little that was not in the original eukaryotic cell, and that the origin of embryonic structures probably lies with Haeckel’s gastrea theory. A colonial protozoan gave rise to a two-layered structure, the inner layer entering through invagination (many higher animals manifest an early gastrea stage resembling this hypothetical ancestor). From the gastrea body plan, retention of nonciliated cells created adaptive potential for evolution of a multiplicity of specialized cell types, so that an early stage in which migration of cells to a protected interior occurred was a crucial development in the advance toward a more advanced form of multicellular organization. Greater stability of the blastula suggests that this is that stage at which the fundamental body structure is established (Anderson, 1973). The early gastrealike organism possessed a multicellularity which in turn must have constituted the substrate on which not only phenogeny but also ontogeny and embryogeny must subsequently have been superimposed as an adaptational corollary of increasing complexity. Following origins of the gastrea, the embryo must then have appeared in the form of a quiescent stage, which in turn would have favored the evolution of fabricational and other endogenously functioning specializations. Two mechanismic corollaries follow on from quiescence: (1) ontogenetic traits are permitted to evolve in response to selection for fabricational parsimony, while (2) truly embryogenetic traits such as mechanisms for communication with the external environment (for example, oxygen exchange) would be demanded in the context of a progressively prolonged quiescent stage. The appearance of specialized embryogenetic and ontogenetic traits may then have facilitated the capacity to evolve an even longer period of quiescence, which in turn required supplementation of stored food resources, while at the same time increasing the opportunity for further complex differentiation of tissues. Embryogeny and ontogeny must therefore have evolved in concert from the earliest stage in the evolution of complex multicellular organisms. The Intersect Ontogeny–Phenogeny Ontogeny sensu stricto was defined above as being that sequence of precursor states in the developmental function cycle which precedes a fully active adaptation interface with the external environment, also describing a fabricational sequence in morphogenesis. From the preceding analysis, the phenotype itself must be defined by a phenogenetic sequence of structural change or single final state having a direct interface with the adaptive niche. Exclusively ontogenetic states are therefore neither phenotypic, nor are they part of phenogeny. However, during much of development, a given structure unit clearly may simultaneously express both fabricational and adaptational function. It is thus evident that the three developmental paradigms (phenogeny, embryogeny, and ontogeny) do not display total autonomy. The greatest levels of ‘‘vertical’’ modularity may perhaps be found in the early divisions between endo-, ecto-, and mesoderm (for example, many endoderm derived structures have a truly embryogenetic role
168
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
to play, whereas mesodermal features tend more toward the phenogenetic paradigm); likewise, ontogeny may often tend to constitute the dominant force in early development: Predominantly fabricational paradigms can be seen in operation, for example, with gastrulation in the Drosophila embryo. Anterior and posterior rudiments of the developing gut do not join up until stage 14 (following Hartenstein’s nomenclature, 1993), although these rudiments are evident by stage 5 (stages 1–4 ⫽ cleavage). This can only relate to the ontogenetic paradigm. The possibility that some pivotal point exists at which the predominant morphogenetic paradigm changes from ontogenetic to phenogenetic may perhaps be approached from the observation that diverse vertebrate classes share a common phylotypic stage which appears after organogenesis has begun. This phenomenon is linked to the ‘‘developmental hourglass’’ metaphor of Raff (1996), which describes that situation whereby propensity for mutational change of developmental parameters is high ‘‘above’’ and low ‘‘below’’ the phylotypic stage—a circumstance which, according to Duboule (1994), might have some correlation with the domain of the Hox genes (see Chapter 11). From the viewpoint of the present analysis, Raff’s model seems likely to relate in some way to the transition between fabricational and adaptational paradigms during development. However, despite the broad pattern of ‘‘phenogeny succeeds ontogeny,’’ it is clearly not possible to define any absolute spatial or temporal dividing line between these two developmental paradigms, since many structures have a joint fabricational and adaptational role to play at the same time horizon, and since some parts of the embryo may be forming organs while others are still in the process of gastrulation (as indeed is the case, e.g., with the chick embryo). Fabricational Parsimony in Ontogeny Wolpert (1990a) considered that the selection forces acting on development were to some extent unclear, yet apparently suggestive of economy of energy usage; if the same thing can be done in two ways and one is more energy efficient, perhaps selection will act on this. In the present view, the basis for endogenously acting selection pressure in development is presumed to lie with fabricational parsimony, with respect to the ontogenetic rather than phenogenetic paradigm. Much ontogenetic activity presumably expresses a dual function: fabricational (how to make something) and fabricational parsimony (the most economical way of fabricating a structure in terms of energetic economy), given the relative absence of constraints normally imposed by the adaptational paradigm. ‘‘Pure’’ ontogeny thus describes that component which completely excludes coordinates linked to the active adaptation interface and which is thus concerned with fabricational parsimony, often with a broadly modularinteractive function for several different morphogenetic trajectories. The further we recede from final phenotype form in the developmental sequence, the more the paradigm for ontogeny may tend to converge on a state defined by fabricational parsimony, this evidently frequently overriding the modularity expressed by discrete structure and function units of the final phenotype.
9. STRUCTURAL PARADIGMS OF DEVELOPMENT
169
Only where the adaptation interface is completely redundant (i.e., in the sense of former adaptational coordinates becoming encapsulated into the quiescent phase of development) can selection favor developmentally parsimonious change in the fabricational sequence of ontogeny. A ‘‘lost terminal state’’ may then either tend to ‘‘recapitulate’’ an earlier phenotype, or else more probably, it may represent some modification of the latter which has come to serve as a fabricational precursor to the final phenotype state, while at the same time introducing some metabolic saving by virtue of being a simplification of the original phenotype state from which it was derived. The ontogenetic sequence must not therefore be presumed to automatically manifest the phenomenon of recapitulation, although it may sometimes converge on that state under certain circumstances (see Chapter 16). Earlier ontogeny is thus characterized as being that component for which biophysical paradigms tend toward fabricational parsimony, rather than being concerned with the exogenous adaptation interface. It is further seen as an energy rationalization function superimposed on development, the function for which probably lies in economic distribution of energy throughout development—and thus also through metabolism in general. The domain of fabricational parsimony clearly has an intersect with all ontogeny, although earlier development clearly offers the greatest opportunity for its manifestation. The structure–function interface for ‘‘pure’’ ontogeny is truly internal, and any selectional activity will also link to an endogenous paradigm. It is a major part of the definition of pure ontogeny that fabricational parsimony will, furthermore, tend to include structures derived from cell lineages that are not functionally linked in the final phenotype and that also may not have originally been developmentally linked. This phenomenon will be investigated more fully in the context of fundamental developmental mechanisms (see next chapter). Fabricational parsimony acts continually to modify precursor states, potentially leading to an expansion of free morphospace for continued evolution, while also invoking some degree of rigidity against further change. That paradox will clearly need considerably more attention in the analysis of adaptive potential. Embryogeny and the Endogenous Adaptation Interface We have already observed the existence of separate exogenous and endogenous adaptational paradigms. This criterion explicitly defines embryogeny sensu stricto, at the same time distinguishing the extrinsic from the endogenous adaptation interface. The latter lies with the embryo in its links with parent metabolism and direct exchange with the external environment, while the former lies in the external environment itself. As predicted by the intersect between phenogeny and ontogeny, all three developmental paradigms are not discrete but interlocking, in that a given structure may jointly manifest ontogenetic and embryogenetic functions, etc. (Fig. 42): The interaction between ontogeny and embryogeny is exemplified by the development of the wing in some holometabolous insects. The course of the adult wing veins, following the paths of thoracic tracheae
170
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
FIGURE 42 The intersect between the three developmental paradigms (X ⫽ ontophenogeny, Y ⫽ ontoembryogeny).
of more primitive insect groups, has come to be partly determined independently of the developing tracheae, which latter continue to function in respiration, during that phase in which specialized changes to adult wing veins are beginning to appear from separate rudiments. In those orders where tracheation is reduced, the tracheae may not actually penetrate the wing sac until after the wing veins have formed (see Comstock, 1918, also Snodgrass, 1935). Thus embryogeny and ontogeny are more closely coupled in hemimetabolous than in advanced insect lineages (nevertheless expressing some degree of interaction in both). The embryo itself is thus essentially that phase of development during which energy exchange is linked to parent metabolism, and is therefore to be regarded as constituting the functional basis for an endogenous environment interface.
General Architecture of Development The principal structure paradigms of development have now been identified as phenogeny, embryogeny, and ontogeny. The broad relationship between these three processes during the course of a generalized developmental trajectory can be most conveniently illustrated following the tenets of the following simplified model.* In the purely schematic system used in Fig. 43, the following conventions have been adopted: * Reiss (1989) gives three common growth curves for animal development: the Bertalanffy equation, dW/dt ⫽ AWm ⫺ BW; the Gompertz equation, dW/dt ⫽ AW(loge W ); and the logistic equation, dW/dt ⫽ AW ⫺ BW 2. The simple log–linear model used here is merely a convenient reference frame for discussion of partitioning within the developmental landscape, rather than being intended as a realistic model of growth or morphogenesis.
9. STRUCTURAL PARADIGMS OF DEVELOPMENT
171
X axis ⫽ time course of development Y axis ⫽ accumulative growth in embryogeny ⫹ ontogeny ⫹ phenogeny (highly schematized as following a simple linear trend) Ye ⫽ accumulative morphogenesis partitioned to embryogeny Ye⫹o ⫽ morphogenesis partitioned to embryogeny plus ontogeny Following the above conventions, the proportion of growth apportioned to the three developmental paradigms for morphogenesis is indicated by partitions within the total growth curve. The schematic model serves to address, in a very general way, the usual level of complexity found in the developmental systems of higher animals.
FIGURE 43 Generalized model of animal development, showing the three principal paradigms of structure (X ⫽ developmental time, Y ⫽ all growth, Ye ⫽ growth in embryogeny, Ye⫹o ⫽ growth in embryogeny ⫹ ontogeny).
Ignoring the artificiality of the above model, the significant features are as follows: • Early development is dominated by ontogeny and embryogeny. • Embryogeny tends to end more or less abruptly at, or immediately after, the eclosion line, that point in time at which the embryo becomes a free-living organism. • Ontogeny may tend to continue into the free-living juvenile stage for some time, but it terminates before the final sexually mature phenotype state is reached.
172
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
• A large component of pre-eclosional development has a combined (embryogeny ⫹ ontogeny ⫹ phenogeny) paradigm, with ontogeny and phenogeny dominating the mid range. • Phenogeny is the dominant force in postembryonic development. • Following the end of phenogeny, the ‘‘static’’ adult stage is reached: An exemplar exhibiting all of the above features can be found with the development of a hemimetabolous insect in which pre-eclosional ontogenetic development of wing is followed by continued fabricational development during the posteclosional stage, and where there is also an embryogenetic function of wing tracheae at the pre-eclosion stage. Posteclosional phenogeny is also evident in the larval stage of many holometabolous insects. The above system cannot of course serve as a ‘‘universal’’ model for all developmental systems. There is a particularly stark contrast between animal and plant development, which latter is said by Stebbins (1988) to possess only about one-fiftieth of the degree of complexity of that found in higher animals, as well as exhibiting a very different temporal pattern for cell and tissue differentiation in the embryonic meristem. The Principle of Morphogenetic Accommodation A framework for the analysis of adaptive potential must link to the coordinates of biophysical paradigms existing in the temporospatial matrix of development. From the above observations, two principles emerge regarding the distribution of the coordinates of complex morphogenesis, the second of which constitutes a corollary of the first. The modularity principle states that there must be n epicenters of morphogenetic activity that are at least partially but probably never totally developmentally autonomous. Even the developmental loci of adaptive versus fabricational biophysical paradigms may lack complete autonomy, but must to some extent constitute a continuum passing from fabricational to adaptational paradigm, rather than simply ‘‘lying end-to-end’’ in the developmental trajectory: Thompson (1917), referring to the developmental process in general, stated that ‘‘the form of the entire structure under investigation should be found to vary in a more or less uniform manner, after the fashion of an approximately homogenous and isotropic body.’’ However, the divisions between phenogeny, ontogeny, and embryogeny must nevertheless have some influence on the modularity hierarchy expressed in the developmental program (see also Chapters 10 and 11). The accommodation principle states that the principal coordinates of developmental topology for a given phenotype structure integral lie in a more or less extended time frame within development, thus spanning different biophysical paradigms, separately linked to the external adaptation interface and to fabricational parsimony. Briefly, there can be no ‘‘final adaptive state,’’ in lack of morphogenetic continuity with some precursor fabricational state existing at an earlier developmental horizon. The same view is expressed in the continuity principle of Horder (1983).
9. STRUCTURAL PARADIGMS OF DEVELOPMENT
173
The principle of morphogenetic accommodation can also be shown to have a larger dimension with respect to parameters of mutational change (see Chapter 12), and adaptive potential must in turn be linked to both modularity and accommodation, with special reference to degrees of freedom residing in adaptive potential itself. In the latter, we see evidence of that category of socalled evolutionary constraints which in reality manifest a directionalization function over anagenetic change (see ensuing chapters).
MAIN POINTS FROM CHAPTER 9 1. Adaptive potential can only be fully understood in the context of development. The coordinates of adaptive potential must accordingly be viewed as being four-dimensional in nature. 2. The structural biophysical paradigm changes during the course of development, owing to the existence of separate extrinsic and endogenous adaptive paradigms plus an additional fabricational paradigm. 3. Three principal structural paradigms of development can now be recognized: ontogeny (endogenous fabricational paradigm), phenogeny (extrinsic adaptive paradigm), and embryogeny (endogenous adaptive paradigm). 4. Owing to the existence of the endogenous fabricational paradigm in ontogeny sensu stricto, not all biophysical paradigms manifest a direct adaptation interface during development. However, all are linked to either an extrinsic or an endogenous selection interface. 5. The fabricational paradigm of true ontogenetic development is probably chiefly concerned with fabricational parsimony. 6. A generalized ‘‘root model’’ of animal development can be designed to reflect the three structural paradigms of development. This much simplified model provides a convenient basis for analysis of the role of development in evolution. 7. Owing to the functional diversity of developmental paradigms, separate domains of pheno- and ontoanagenesis must also be presumed to exist. 8. Development may express both modularity and morphogenetic accommodation in terms of the geometric coordinates of a given superstructure, and degrees of freedom in adaptive potential are much influenced by these factors. Modularity is concerned with the degree of autonomy expressed by a given phenotypic structure unit during different phases of development, whereas morphogenetic accommodation reflects the manner in which phenogenetic, embryogenetic, and ontogenetic paradigms interlock within the developmental trajectory of a given phenotype structure integral.
This page intentionally left blank
10
ADAPTIVE CAPACITY AND POTENTIAL IN THE MECHANISMS OF DEVELOPMENT
We now have a broad understanding of adaptive capacity and potential and of the principal structural paradigms of development, and it is already evident that the apparent mystery surrounding the structural component of adaptive potential is due to complications with the dichotomy existing between Mendelian and developmental schools of genetics. Attention therefore needs now to be diverted to analysis of the fundamental mechanisms of development itself. As we saw in the previous chapter, there has to be a topological continuum between the fabricational and adaptational paradigms of development. This is not necessarily a geometric continuum in superstructure, since it may also concern substructural factors such as the manner in which cells are aggregated into tissues. It is this latter translational aspect of development which forms the main subject matter of the present chapter. The developmental model must now be followed from gene transcription, through a hierarchy of translation levels. Here, we must endeavor to understand the nature of the controllant factors affecting morphogenesis and the primary mechanisms underlying changing developmental architecture. How do these mechanisms allow structure to be channeled into a multiplicity of trajectories relating to different biophysical paradigms in a manner manifesting a greater or lesser degree of modularity? Adaptive potential cannot be understood, nor the outcome of its realization predicted in the absence of an answer to this question. Any general model must also seek to incorporate the common factors of quite diverse systems operating in different lineages.
175
176
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
COORDINATES OF ADAPTIVE CAPACITY AND POTENTIAL IN DEVELOPMENT The framework of adaptive capacity and potential must derive from roots in the modular-interactive array of mechanisms of developmental translation as they ascend from determination to morphogenesis. This analysis must therefore begin with a broad overview of those coordinates around which superstructure is progressively built, on the assumption that potential for change must somehow reside within these same parameters.
Translation Levels of Development Translation, beginning with primary translation in protein synthesis, refers to any stage in the course of genetic activity beyond gene transcription itself. At the primary translation level, a protein is ordered from the genetic code held in a DNA sequence, while subsequent events beyond this stage concern epigenetic interactivity* manifesting determination, differentiation, and morphogenesis as the outcomes of repeated sequences of translational events. Lower translation levels are thus expressed in determination and differentiation, these being the first links in a cycle of epigenetic interactivity, while higher translation levels can be identified in growth and morphogenesis. The geometric coordinates of morphogenesis condense thus from precursor states residing in a nested sequence of complex interacting translational mechanisms. Some part of the developmental structural paradigm is therefore translative, so that at each point, geometric and translative coordinates may coexist. Determination, differentiation, and growth clearly form that set of developmental mechanisms which constitutes the essential ‘‘building blocks’’ of morphogenesis, and all translation levels involved can be supposed to contain some component of adaptive potential, in the sense that the developmental program may (at least in theory) be subjected to mutational change in a positive direction at any stage. The coordinates of development are both translative and accommodative (see previous chapter). In ‘‘pure’’ ontogeny, there may frequently be amalgamation of ultimately functionally independent cell lineages, and in this scenario, adaptive potential must be ‘‘flexible’’ with respect to some coordinates and ‘‘rigid’’ for others, as a function (in part) of translation level, and also modularity in relation to accommodation. Lower Translation Levels—Determination and Differentiation The primary translational activity of genes above protein synthesis itself lies in determination, which is structured around a program of repressor and activator functions in gene regulation. Repressors may act to limit cell commitment by blocking unwanted genetic activity, while activators are selective ‘‘on’’ switches acting on other, more ‘‘downstream’’ genes with specific functions for each required cell type.† In a general model, the time delay between determi* The term ‘‘epigenetic’’ was originally used to describe supposedly nongenetic influences on development (see Hall, 1992, for an overview). Here, it is applied to the properties of higher translation levels of diverse determination factors—in the sense of determinative signals passing between cells and tissues, ‘‘above’’ the level of primary genetic translation. † Determination has also been distinguished from specification (Slack, 1983). This nomenclature essentially separates ‘‘capacity for differentiation in the correct environment’’ from ‘‘capacity for autonomous differentiation.’’
10. ADAPTIVE CAPACITY AND POTENTIAL IN THE MECHANISMS OF DEVELOPMENT
177
nation and the earliest detectable evidence of cell commitment can vary over a wide range: The totipotence of egg cells is often lost during the first few cell divisions. Drosophila labeling experiments carried out by Chan and Gehring (1971) demonstrated that the blastoderm cells (not nuclei) are already determined in terms of anteroposterior developmental destinies and that events of detailed pattern formation have occurred by the third larval instar, indicating a stepwise sequence of determination apparently involving a binary switch mechanism operating at an epigenetic level. Cell determination can be brought about in many ways: extrinsic signals such as gravity (identifying ‘‘top from bottom’’), external ionic molecules, unequal cell divisions, uneven molecular gradients, contact with other specialized cells, and so on. In general, cell-endogenous determination factors can be deemed to be of proximal type, extrinsic ones, remote acting. Some of these signals function as simple Boolean switch mechanisms, whereas others (especially those of remote acting type) initiate graded responses affording positional information. Given that some component of remote acting regulation may arise through nongenetic signals, determination itself is thus not to be seen exclusively as a direct genetic function (see next chapter). To adopt a uniform system of nomenclature for ‘‘proximal as against remote acting’’ determination factors, the following convention is proposed here, and will be used throughout: • ‘‘cis- and trans-acting’’ (in lowercase) will be used to refer to the intracellular aspect of gene regulation (i.e., in the customary usage of these terms). • ‘‘CIS- and TRANS-acting’’ (in uppercase) will be used to denote proximal and remote acting functionality, in the intercellular domain. For example, any determination factor acting through cell-to-cell contact is CIS-acting, and a TRANS-acting factor is one that travels from cell to cell without the need for actual physical contact. The overall view of determination and commitment in relation to activity of genetic controllant factors can be illustrated as in Fig. 44. Differentiation The state of commitment is a function of the sum of the activator or repressor activity of determination (any state ⬍ totipotence)—it is effectively a state of differentiation. Differentiation itself describes the outcome of progressive determination and can thus be regarded as being ‘‘accumulative’’ in the sense of being iterated with respect to higher translation level activity. Competence is the developmental capacity of a cell (or of any higher morphogenetic locus) to respond to an inductive signal (Waddington, 1957) and thus to undergo subsequent differentiation, growth, or morphogenesis (Fig. 45). Determination is thus the first step toward morphogenesis, and differentiation constitutes the final state of iterated determination at the cell-tissue level. Determination is manifested at the level of the cell and initiated through a
178
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
FIGURE 44 Parameters of control over determination and commitment.
combination of cell-autonomous (cis-/trans-) plus external (CIS-/TRANSacting) molecular and physical stimuli. Even at this stage, it is possible to hypothesize that the coordinates of adaptive capacity and potential must in some sense be fundamentally linked to those of determination and differentiation. While the lower translation levels obviously relate more to earlier development, they nevertheless also form those precursor stages through which any apparent ‘terminal addition’ at phenotype level must pass. Consequently, the degrees of freedom residing in endogenous adaptive potential must depend in part on the architecture of determination and differentiation. Higher Translation Levels—Growth to Morphogenesis The geometric coordinates of phenotype form arise from loci of determination–differentiation as translation transcends the cellular level to differential tissue growth in morphogenesis, and the largest structural coordinates of development thus emerge from higher level translational activity. Morphogenesis can therefore only be understood from analysis of a sequence of precursor translational events occurring between gene transcription and the organization
10. ADAPTIVE CAPACITY AND POTENTIAL IN THE MECHANISMS OF DEVELOPMENT
179
FIGURE 45 Iterated determination leading to differentiation.
of structure. The complete sequence of such events is therefore transcription 씮 primary translation 씮 determination 씮 differentiation 씮 growth and morphogenesis. This is not a single train of events, but rather, it is a set of nested sequences, elements of which progressively ascend a trajectory of mechanisms involving complex interactivity. Not only is there an ascending hierarchy of translation levels, but also the sequence determination 씮 differentiation can be followed at different temporospatial levels in the same organism. Intermediate translation levels include the establishment of loci and coordinates of determination, while the highest translation levels clearly lie in the differential mitotic activities surrounding ordered growth patterns following on from the creation of coordinates systems. Growth itself can be cellular or mitotic. As mitotic activity, it may be organized around simple coordinates derived from programmed binary cell division (thus excluding allometric or other complex models). In morphogenesis, we observe a more complex programming of growth, such that varied responses to transformational coordinates systems give rise to complex form. To this observation, we should also add that the ‘‘morphogenetic substrate’’ itself consists of two quite distinct modes of supracellular organization: Thomson (1988) points out that there are two basic patterns at the tissue level that are of fundamental importance in morphogenesis, epithelium and mesenchyme. The former is a single cell layer on a
180
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
basement membrane, the latter, multidimensional. Epithelia can be folded and distorted in various ways, whereas mesenchyme forms organ rudiments through migration, condensation, cell division, change of cell shape, also via effects arising in the extracellular matrix, and through differential cell death. It is at the level of morphogenesis alone that we find those major coordinates systems corresponding to the geometry of adaptational paradigms, although this may of course link to complex emergent properties arising from such simpler control systems ordering lower translational events. The nature of gene control over the above mechanisms is now quite extensively understood for some (but by no means for all) components. Major Loci of Translation—Compartments to Morphogenetic Fields The larger coordinates systems of development define closely circumscribed temporospatial zones of developmental space-time in a sequential hierarchy, within which determination, differentiation, growth, and morphogenesis take place, the spatial loci of translation. TRANS-acting factors tend to describe the largest of these loci (frequently acting in analog mode), and these include the morphogenetic compartments that have been particularly well studied in Drosophila. Following the establishment of the largest TRANS-determined boundaries, a nested sequence of narrower (often digitally coded ) coordinates is then defined. From these events, we obtain a hierarchy of loci of growth and morphogenesis. There may be compound morphogenetic fields (such as the vertebrate limb field), which constitute complex loci of translation in which latent loci of determination, differentiation, growth, and morphogenesis are nested within some larger locus of determination. What form do the ‘‘major coordinates’’ alluded to above actually take? A locus of translation may be particular to a specific determination, differentiation, growth, or morphogenetic event, or else it may harbor an array of different functions (as in a complex morphogenetic field). The coordinate parameters for development are thus found within a hierarchy of loci of translation comprising: Loci of determination Loci of differentiation Loci of growth Morphogenetic fields Loci of morphogenesis A locus of determination is that zone in developmental space-time at which a totipotent cell or cell clone is determined in terms of its subsequent developmental fate. As we have seen above, loci of determination are of particular significance in defining major coordinates in positional information, and a locus of differentiation evolves as iterated determination comes to that point at which the fully functional state of a specialized cell type is reached. A locus of growth is the locus described by regular, binary mitotic activity in developmental space-time, for any cell or cell clone (excluding allometric or other complex models). A locus of morphogenesis is a growth locus in which mitosis undergoes complex organized patterns of growth (or cell movement
10. ADAPTIVE CAPACITY AND POTENTIAL IN THE MECHANISMS OF DEVELOPMENT
181
of preexisting cellular units). Any such locus may be descended from a single cell or else constitute a polyclonal assemblage. A morphogenetic field is a compound morphogenetic locus in which integrated determinative–differentiative activity is coordinated. It involves a group of cells whose position and fate are determined with respect to the same boundaries (following Weiss, 1939), despite showing little or no differentiation at an early stage. All translational loci should be viewed as dynamic structures, having a fourth dimension in developmental space-time. Morphogenetic compartments
FIGURE 46 Hierarchy of loci of determination and morphogenesis.
are also larger fieldlike loci determined through the action of morphogens and other top-level regulatory genes. Included are the parasegments and other known compartments of Drosophila:
182
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
‘‘Compartmental boundaries are lines separating regions of tissue whose cells have progeny which do not cross the boundary’’ (Kauffman, 1993; see also Garcio-Bellido et al., 1973). A compartmental boundary separates domains of cells which have taken alternative developmental commitments. Fields and morphogenetic compartments constitute major loci for determination of patterns of growth, differentiation, and morphogenesis, the translative domains of which change as development proceeds, and often form the initial step in the move to compartmentalize structural units as quasi-autonomous entities. Most significantly, the hierarchy of nested major 씮 minor coordinates from morphogenetic fields downward describes the essential paradigm of how developmental gene activity is organized, and the sequence of TRANS- 씮 CISacting determination in this has considerable implications for adaptive potential (see below, also Chapters 11 and 12).
Adaptive Potential in TRANS-acting Determination Factors As we have already seen, the effect of iterative determination is the generation of complex coordinates systems around which translation and morphogenesis are constructed. What kind of coordinates systems lie within this asecending sequence of translation levels? Clearly, these must in some way progress from translative to geometric structures in an accommodative manner. Adaptive potential may appear to be restricted to coordinates of the highest translation level, but it must be that translational resources for this propensity really lie throughout a hierarchic sequence of determinative events. We may thus follow ontogeny through to phenogeny with respect to a given structure, but not necessarily via geometric coordinates, in that other, lower translational mechanisms may also be involved. It seems intrinsically likely that truly phenogenetic paradigms must lie in the domain of the coordinates of morphogenesis itself, and that morphogenetic accommodation with respect to such parameters probably lies particularly in the intersect of phenogeny with ontogeny. In the same way, the most labile structural paradigms of all should perhaps be found in the loci of lower translation levels, in the domain of ontogeny. In what way are adaptive capacity and potential linked to particular proximate and remote acting factors of determination? This situation cannot be understood without first examining the foregoing loci of translative activity more closely. Some component of determination must be cell-autonomous; however, the greater component of morphogenesis is determined via signals passing from cell to cell and from tissue to tissue. Thus, while determination and differentiation may perhaps be partially understood in terms of cell-endogenous linear mitotic programs, the true basis for complex morphogenesis clearly must lie with higher coordinates systems of the kind based on CIS-/TRANS-acting mechanisms. Early development is partly typified by distribution of TRANS-acting morphogenetic factors which travel widely in a syncytium or in a cytohistogenetic
10. ADAPTIVE CAPACITY AND POTENTIAL IN THE MECHANISMS OF DEVELOPMENT
183
medium, defining morphogenetic coordinates which in turn underlie the lower translation levels of determination 씮 differentiation. Morphogen gradients define positional information (see below), and these form an important class of molecular determinants arising remote to the locus of determinative activity. Some gradient models of this kind indicate quite simple coordinates systems, while others are considerably more complex in nature: Wolpert (1969, 1971) proposed that cells have access to an underlying coordinates system, and thus know their position in relation to a developmental field. The cell first assesses its positional information, interprets this according to its cell type, then forms a specific part of the overall pattern. Genes thus interpret signals which specify a cell’s position within a field, and the specifying signals act like coordinates of position, carrying no other information. Evidence for this theory came originally from the antennapedia mutant in Drosophila, which causes distal antennal cells to become distal leg cells, while Bicoid was the first morphogen producing gene to be discovered in Drosophila (see next chapter). Sander (1960) first discovered evidence for the presence of anterior and posterior morphogens in bug eggs, on the basis of data gained from ligation experiments. Polar, Cartesian, and spherical coordinates systems have been proposed for such determination factors. In the above view, complex differential growth can be understood in the context of systems of coordinates and positional information laid down by primary determinants of the morphogen kind. However, this is not the only model that has been proposed: Maynard Smith and Szathmary (1995) discussed the interactions taking place between cells in a morphogenetic field in two possible models: (a) positional information, a gradient within which scalar quantities (or qualities) specify position in the field, and (b) ‘‘prepattern and competence,’’ where a standing wave of values of some scalar quantity is directly responsible for organization of differentiation for repeated patterns. TRANS-acting systems of the above kind apparently create the major coordinates of development, and the programmed order built around them could, whatever its mechanistic strategy, form a significant component of adaptive potential (see also Chapter 15). However, Horder (1983) criticizes the validity of the view that TRANS-acting genes (of the homoeotic kind, for example) control pattern, stating that the available data suggest that the latter is built up gradually by multiple sequential interactions between differentiated structures, so that the CIS-acting mechanism of induction may often be a central mechanism, at least with regard to the domain of phenogeny (see below). This viewpoint will be given careful consideration in the present analysis. Complex Coordinates Systems and the Turing Model More complex coordinates systems of the ‘‘prepattern’’ kind may be a function of simpler models, as argued by Kauffman (1993). The Turing model has two chemicals with activator–repressor relationships:
184
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
Substance X autocatalyzes formation of itself and catalyzes formation of Y; Y inhibits formation of X and of Y itself. X is the activator, Y, the inhibitor. Both X and Y can diffuse in the tissue—but Y does so more rapidly than X. The whole system can reach a steady state (⫽ no pattern formation). However, if equilibrium is disturbed (namely, through flow of energy and matter invoking a dissipative system), then patterns may then be generated (see Kauffman, 1993). Such reaction–diffusion models have been applied to many systems, and some aspects of how shape may be controlled in relation to coordinates of morphogenesis may well be based on the Turing model. Of particular interest is the fact that dissipative systems are said to be capable of generating patterns of morphogenetic order on the basis of reaction–diffusion activity alone: Meinhardt and Klingler (1987) utilized models based on reaction– diffusion mechanisms to predict the generation of pigmentation and relief patterns on mollusc shells belonging to a number of different genera and species. In their model, an autocatalytic reaction is antagonized by an inhibitory substance, and more complex patterns occur with more than one inhibitory substance, or with superimposition of two patterning processes. Computer simulations based on this model reproduce fine details of natural patterns. Shell patterns in the gastropod Bankivia fasciata can also be predicted from the Turing model, although explanations based on neural activities could also fit this data! (see Meinhardt, 1982; Murray 1989, etc.). Murray (1981) devised a model for generation of lepidopteran wing patterns on the basis of a biochemically plausible mechanism based on a diffusion morphogen that activates a gene in a threshold manner, to generate a stable heterogeneous pattern. However, diffusion fields suggested in this model are very much larger than any known examples. Likewise, Maynard Smith and Szathmary (1995) state that the Turing model’s main weakness lies in lack of direct evidence for the molecular mechanisms involved. Molecular systems for determination of morphogenetic coordinates are of the highest significance for an understanding of adaptive potential, since they link coordinates of determination with the higher translational activity of the gene on the one hand, and with the functional coordinates of potential for adaptational change on the other. In this, we witness a further, translative dimension in morphogenetic accommodation.
Adaptive Potential in CIS-acting Determination Factors Later development in higher organisms is often heavily dominated by CISacting morphogenetic factors, passing from one cell to the next or between adjacent tissues, including both chemical and physical agencies. In such systems, we may at times observe further evidence of apparent ‘‘self-organizational’’
10. ADAPTIVE CAPACITY AND POTENTIAL IN THE MECHANISMS OF DEVELOPMENT
185
factors. According to Horder (1983), induction probably plays a very much larger role in more ‘‘downstream’’ morphogenetic activity, than do TRANSacting determination factors. Induction Many morphogenetic events have been traced to determinative factors derived from cell–cell or tissue–tissue contact, a process known as induction.* Induction arises from tissue-to-tissue molecular stimuli acting at higher translation levels, as differentiation proceeds to growth and morphogenesis. Inductors are thus often molecular determinants acting as ‘‘proximal morphogens,’’ the molecular CIS factor of tertiary translation generating morphogenesis within higher coordinates defined by earlier (often TRANS-acting) mechanisms: The manner in which lens formation in the vertebrate eye is brought about through inductive action of the optic cup on the overlying ectoderm has been known since the work of Spemann (1901). The same phenomenon is also known with the balancer organ in salamanders (for example, Triturus), and here experiments have been carried out with trans-species implants which show that the inductive stimulus is still present in forms (Ambystoma) which have lost the organ itself (see Sang, 1984; also see Gilbert, 1997, for a broad review of revisionary work since Spemann). Paracrine or growth and differentiation factors have been identified as those proteins responsible for short distance induction in the formation of numerous organs. The same molecules are widely involved throughout the animal kingdom and appear to form just four families ( fibroblast growth factor, hedgehog, wingless, and TGF-웁; see Gilbert, 1997). Also involved are the cell adhesion molecules responsible for the specific aggregation properties of mobile cells. Newtonian Morphogenetic Factors Brenner (1981) postulated that hierarchic systems of gene control over development may involve shared substrates, also that the way in which genetic space maps onto organismic space may involve further unknowns. Among these latter is the question of mechanical interactions between cells and tissues. Mechanical induction is due to determination factors arising from physical forces between adjacent differentiating tissues, as distinct from the direct action of products of gene transcription–translation. This factor is indicative of the diversity of influences affecting morphogenesis which could have some input to adaptive potential. Newtonian morphogenetic factors are those determination factors arising from interaction of physical forces resulting from growth and morphogenetic movement, and constituting the physical ‘‘CIS factor’’ of tertiary translation in morphogenesis. It is evident that much kinetic activity is expressed during early development, as at the gastrulation stage, for example, and wherever cell motility and adhesion properties play a prominent role in morphogenesis. Similar mechanical elements in determination must also exist during later development, particu* Holtzer (1968) distinguished two modes of induction, instructive and permissive.
186
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
larly in the way in which quasi-autonomous units of developing superstructure interact. From this observation comes the question as to whether certain tissue movements are due to intrinsic determination factors or to mechanical forces imposed from elsewhere. While thermodynamic models linked to differential adhesive properties of cells may explain cytohistogenetic kineses (see Gilbert, 1997, for a review), it seems likely that direct mechanical stresses must also be involved in some areas of morphogenetic activity. Mechanical forces potentially affecting development at the highest translation level must arise naturally from growth functions and morphogenetic movement in individual developmental trajectories. Such forces have both quantity (growth rate and period) and directionality (according to the nature of the coordinates of loci of commitment, differentiation, and differential mitosis), and they may therefore be regarded as constituting ‘‘Newtonian developmental vectors’’ in terms of their influence on the course of development. There will thus be certain sites in the temporospatial matrix of development at which morphogenetic vectors interact as physical forces: Thompson (1917) referred to the way in which developing vertebrate tooth buds coalescence, creating mechanical pressures which play a large part in determining the final arrangement and conformation. ‘‘Mechanical induction’’ has been investigated by Oster et al. (1980) using a computer model which simulates the viscoelastic properties of the cell wall contained in microfilaments, and this model can be used to simulate the behavior of epithelial cells with respect to forces transmitted from cell to cell. The biophysical properties of such tissues could apparently alone account for gastrulation movements and for the ventral furrow of the Drosophila embryo, even in the lack of positional coordinates. Another form of mechanical induction is seen in the development of the wing in Drosophila and other insects, where expansion is brought about by the internal pressure of the body fluid, and mechanical stresses have likewise been identified in the coordination of chondrogenesis with osteogenesis in vertebrates. As stated by Sang (1984), ‘‘It is salutary to remember that cells have intrinsic properties affecting their shape and motility, not readily predictable from their active genes.’’ It is only necessary to extrapolate slightly from the Oster model to permit incorporation of more widely active mechanical vectors arising from growth and morphogenesis (especially in terms of quasi-autonomous but physically interacting morphogenetic trajectories), and thus to see that force vector fields might sometimes play a significant role in epigenetic interactions at certain stages of development. A significant consequence of the Newtonian morphogenetic factor is that morphogenetic forces may interact with one another during the unfolding of a complex developmental trajectory, and clearly, complex determination systems must cope with interactivity of this kind (see next chapter). Morphogenetic vectors express quantity in terms of growth functions and also directionality, which latter may be, in turn, modified and redefined. Where
10. ADAPTIVE CAPACITY AND POTENTIAL IN THE MECHANISMS OF DEVELOPMENT
187
such vectors act as major determinant forces in complex superstructural systems, this domain may hold a large influence over the behavior of some developmental events. In this model, we may envisage the endogenously generated determination vectors of a given morphogenetic trajectory interacting with ‘‘passive lability’’ characteristics of a second trajectory, the two manifesting some degree of intrinsic modularity combined with a certain level of interactivity in that domain in which Newtonian morphogenetic factors come into play. In this situation, the outcome is the product of two antagonistic forces. From this, it can be seen that the same degree of morphogenetic force can be attained by different balances between endogenous and exogenous factors affecting a given cell lineage, and that the resultant value may be expressed in isomorphic zones described by a graph connecting equivalent values for different combinations of Newtonian determination factors arising endogenously versus extrinsically to a given morphogenetic parameter. A large morphogenetic force may therefore be due to endogenous factors in the developmental trajectory of a structure, or else it may be due to the impinging influence of some other cell lineage, as a function of passive lability in the first trajectory. In terms of adaptive potential, it seems most probable that the influence of Newtonian determination factors in general will tend to dominate the fabricational rather than the adaptational paradigm for evolutionary change, being thus sequestered from the latter as a function of ‘‘vertical’’ modular inhibition (see below). Most probably then, mechanical determination factors will tend to be particularly active during earlier ontogeny, when fabricational parsimony tends to predominate the structure paradigm. This is an important conclusion in terms of the degree to which ‘‘self-organization and spontaneous order’’ can be said to influence patterns of evolutionary change with regard to the final phenotype, as against the early ontogenetic stage of development (see Chapter 15). While it has been concluded that CIS-active determination factors in general lie close to the loci of adaptive potential, it seems likely that mechanical induction may tend usually to be excluded from this.
ADAPTIVE CAPACITY AND POTENTIAL IN THE CONTEXT OF DEVELOPMENTAL MODULARITY Why are the temporospatial loci of lability with respect to adaptive potential tightly constrained in certain domains within the developmental program? We cannot begin to see what the parameters of adaptive capacity and potential actually are, until development has been understood in terms of the relationship between the loci of translation and known ‘‘architectural’’ models of development.
Architectural Models of Development and Morphogenetic Lability As we have seen, morphogenesis is essentially a dialogue between growth functions and complex organizational mechanisms. It can be affected by either cell or tissue movements, differential cell growth, or differential mitosis, and
188
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
will frequently occur through a combination of several of these factors. Morphogenesis is thus growth organized around a complex hierarchy of developmental coordinates, and as we have seen above, an element of modularity in terms of the degree of mutual autonomy manifested by different morphogenetic trajectories also enters this equation. It has already emerged that some part of this modularity must be linked to the dichotomy between adaptational and fabricational paradigms, and this latter element must also be encapsulated within the principle of morphogenetic accommodation. Not all aspects of developmental modularity can be presumed to link to lability in adaptive potential. Thus, while Gerhart and Kirschner (1997) have argued that morphogenetic compartments are important for potential evolutionary change as a function of their developmental independence, it has to be assumed that modularity in general is closely linked to the more complex strategies of translation—and it is also apparent from comparative morphology alone that the phenotype is not altered ‘‘per compartment,’’ so much as through the medium of more integrated, holistic units of the structure unit and integral kind described earlier (Chapter 7). Clearly, this situation can be understood from the fact that developmental and selectional modularity cannot be one and the same thing from the viewpoint of adaptive potential. In fact, the integration of many developmental modules must occur predominantly through the activity of CIS-acting factors, so that any subsequent gravitation toward complex neomorphic transformation must accordingly be more closely linked to factors of this kind than to those elements actually conferring compartment identity at an early developmental stage. The strategy through which morphogenesis is organized around the loci of determination, differentiation, and growth has thus been presumed to follow a path described by the balance between modularity and interactivity, as this particularly relates to emergent holistic units of the phenotype. However, this pattern also has to be capable of large scale reorganization, if complex domains within adaptive potential are to be realized—and it is clear that many of the restrictions imposed on realization of adaptive potential must be due to the way in which modularity is organized around fabricational paradigms of ontogeny. Mosaic and Regulative Development, Modularity, and Adaptive Potential Given that developmental modularity may be very different from that residing in latent adaptive potential, it is clearly important to arrive at some understanding of the architecture of translational modularity in a ‘‘typical’’ developmental system. In what way are patterns of differential growth in morphogenesis generally organized around developmental coordinates systems? Although it is possible to identify the various translational mechanisms underlying growth and morphogenesis and to understand their broad relationships to positional information and other coordinates laid down by determination, it is much more difficult to see how these processes are organized and integrated in the context of a supposedly ‘‘generalized’’ developmental trajectory leading to the final phenotype form.
10. ADAPTIVE CAPACITY AND POTENTIAL IN THE MECHANISMS OF DEVELOPMENT
189
In the past, morphogenesis was thought to be organized in two fundamentally different ways, according to the degree to which autonomous and conditional specification are involved. In model 1 (the mosaic or lineage model), cell specification is predominantly autonomous to cell lineage and morphogenesis evolves as a linear program tending to manifest high levels of modularity. In model 2 (the regulative or assembly model), cells retain a wide ranging developmental potential and a greater degree of cell-to-cell interactivity is involved in determination, so that a nonlinear assembly of parts is facilitated on the basis of controlled interactivity between only quasi-autonomous modular trajectories. In mosaic development, particular cells give rise to particular structures, while the regulative strategy is in contrast more flexible, in that cell fates can be altered without derailing development. Some component of morphogenesis has thus been viewed as the result of programmed cell division or cell death from a smaller number of precursor cells, and some as being due to movement and reorganization of larger, preexisting bodies of cells for which endogenous determination factors are less significant. This apparent dichotomy has also been presumed to apply to the ways in which development is organized in different phyletic lineages: The above differential could be presumed to be present, for example, in the dichotomy between epithelial and mesenchymal cells, since the two main ways of communication (diffusible substances versus cell contact) and the different mechanisms of morphogenesis (cell division, cell death, movement–segregation–aggregation, shape change, etc.) are to some extent differentially expressed in these two cell types. All cell divisions have been followed from egg to adult in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans, the body of which comprises only around 1000 cells. The embryo is still spheroid when about half the final number of mitoses has already taken place, and attainment of the elongated adult form occurs predominantly through cell differentiation, further mitosis tending to be mainly growth rather than morphogenesis. In C. elegans, morphogenesis was at first thought to be predominantly an autonomous linear, algorithmic program of cell division coupled with cell death, with relatively little input from interactive effects between cells, as perhaps suggested by the fact that the entire cell lineage can be written down as a branching tree. In contrast to the nematode scenario, insect bodies are to a much greater extent, ‘‘assembled from pieces,’’ especially during later development: Drosophila nuclei at first divide in a syncytium, and cell membranes do not appear until after the thirteenth nuclear division. The first plane of cleavage is random, but nuclei do not mix randomly as they divide, since there are roughly male and female ‘‘territories.’’ Unlike C. elegans, later developmental events are clearly not decided strictly on the basis of cell lineage. Drosophila in fact shows a sequential hierarchy of parasegments and morphogenetic compartments around which differ-
190
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
entiation and morphogenesis is organized, the ground plan of which is laid down at gastrula stage—furthermore, the compartments are evidently polyclonal in origin. Marked cells at the blastoderm stage of Drosophila show wing plus leg anterior or posterior compartments, while the same experiment carried out at the gastrula stage shows descendant cells confined to either wing or leg. At a later stage, the wing divides into two compartments. Kauffman (1983 and elsewhere) found that the process of compartment subdivision continues until end–middle and even–odd sectors have been defined. However, many structures display a more ‘‘fabricational’’ process of assembly: the muscles take cues from nervous tissue, and (as in the majority of higher organisms that have been studied) cell–cell and tissue–tissue induction mechanisms play a much higher profile in morphogenesis than they appear to do in nematode worms. Mesoderm compartments, for example, have been studied in relation to muscle formation. Each muscle is initiated by a specific founder cell, but this is joined by elements from a pool of mesodermal cells which then acquire the identity of the founder. Nerves are thought to play a role in induction here also. Lawrence (1992), reviewing the situation with Drosophila, concluded that there is clearly evidence that no ‘‘linear program’’ is involved. Caenorhabditis, in contrast, seemed clearly to follow the mosaic model. However, more recent work has shown that this is an oversimplification. Cell interactions do in fact play a role in development in C. elegans, and gut development (for example) is dependent on induction (see Wolpert et al., 1998, for a review). Considerable doubt must therefore be placed on the apparently sharp dichotomy existing between mosaic and regulative patterns of development. Determination certainly tends to occur earlier in mosaic embryos than in regulative ones, but there are no totally mosaic embryos—and the presence of an apparently invariate cell lineage does not mean that fate cannot subsequently be changed. Just as several competing models of genetic control over development exist, probably all having some validity within certain proscribed domains, theories of morphogenesis may also best be seen in a diversity of mechanisms operating at different levels. Clearly, the regulative model may be an advanced development of higher organisms, as has already been suggested with respect to ontogeny (see Chapter 9), and it may in that context have a relationship with developmental paradigms derived from the endogenous selection interface, namely, in fabricational parsimony. In vertebrates, regulative–inductive mechanisms also play an even larger role than they do in the insect developmental system. There is thus clearly a varying degree to which cell lineage versus cell or clone position are of significance in different higher groups and at different times during development in a single species, and in our general model we must therefore take both systems into account. If any ‘‘general rule’’ does exist, it may perhaps be that lower metazoans with a simple body plan and smaller total number of cells and of cell types tend more toward the apparently linear–algorithmic (mosaic) strategy, whereas more complex organisms show progressively more advanced expressions of
191
10. ADAPTIVE CAPACITY AND POTENTIAL IN THE MECHANISMS OF DEVELOPMENT
the parts-assembly/regulative interactivity model. Complexity thus seems to have generated a much greater demand on the rationalization of development: According to Thomson (1988), in regulative systems, complexity grows out of itself, and this is possibly the only way that a truly complex organism can be created. Two models of organization have thus been proposed: the mosaic or lineage model, which is essentially based on a linear algorithm for differential mitotic activity in morphogenesis, and the regulative or assembly model, based on fabrication of superstructure following a nonlinear assembly of separately formed rudiments in which induction may play a leading role. However, these modes of development are apparently not as different as was at first thought. The apparent divergencies between lower and higher organisms which have actually been confirmed may seem to suggest certain restrictions in the way adaptive potential is linked to the hierarchy of coordinates around which development is structured, and this is clearly also related in turn to the dichotomy between fabricational and adaptational biophysical paradigms, namely, in ontogeny as against phenogeny. In view of the above, it is possible to propose a broad relationship between developmental modularity and degrees of freedom in adaptive potential. This does not of course identify ‘‘lower’’ organisms as having low adaptive potential, but merely reflects the differential distribution of propensity for evolutionary change in different morphogenetic domains within any given lineage—from which it is possible perhaps to predict, for example, that more complex metamorphoses form a more probable modification of simpler ‘‘mosaiclike’’ developmental systems than they do of complex regulative ones. We can summarize some of the foregoing aspects of development in relation to lability within adaptive potential as follows: Determination
Predominant paradigm Modularity Lability to change
Remote (TRANS) Fabricational Proximal (CIS) Adaptational
Low High
High Low
The above clearly fits the broad observation that the most dramatic changes in structure are often those seen in earlier development. Against this, we must, however, balance the fact that remotely related higher group lineages may share common ontogenetic states, even where the phenogenetic phase has diverged very widely indeed, implying that considerable stability may be enforced on certain stages of early development (see comments on the phylotypic stage, Chapter 9). Above all else, the regulative model of development demonstrates a very large influence on the evolutionary ‘‘rigidity’’ of many TRANSdetermined ontogenetic coordinates, while at the same time suggesting that this apparent lack of lability in adaptive potential can more readily be bypassed in a strictly mosaic developmental system.
Loci of Adaptive Capacity and Potential and Architecture of the Morphogenetic Trajectory Although smaller modules defined by loci of translation can be defined within certain temporospatial boundaries, these generally also collectively form trajec-
192
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
tories of development common to unit structures in the final phenotype, in that the loci of determination, differentiation, growth, and morphogenesis must be connected in translational and temporal sequence over the course of development. The train of such events for a given structure unit constitutes a morphogenetic trajectory, describing the complete fabricational sequence for development of a single structural unit from embryo to phenotype. A morphogenetic trajectory is described by the train of developmental events from the first locus of determination through all descendant loci of differentiation, growth, and morphogenesis for all cell lineages leading to formation of a given structure unit or integral, as a four-dimensional structure traversing the whole of development. Each morphogenetic trajectory is bounded, either by a cell lineage or (quite frequently) by the convergence of two or more cell lineages to form a functionally integrated whole. Either way, it can be determined as having certain root parameters (namely, the parent cell or cells of the lineage). Following the establishment of the root parameters of a morphogenetic trajectory, it will also tend to have a geometry built around a set of morphogenetic coordinates. The characteristics of a given trajectory can therefore be described in terms of the loci and coordinates of translation. Each morphogenetic trajectory must also pass through fabricational and adaptational paradigms, and here again we encounter the axiom that the developmental pathway concerned must be accommodative. Owing to the fact that different developmental phases of a single structure unit or integral have different temporospatial loci during development, and particularly because of the influence of the assembly model in morphogenesis, it follows that some structural units will be derived from convergent trajectories and some from divergent: The pharyngeal muscles of the nematode C. elegans are derived from elements originating from two discrete cell lineages, both of which also contribute to other structures quite independently. The Drosophila wing disc shows examples of divergent trajectories for scutum, scutellum, wing, and parts of the adult thorax, and thus for discrete subunits of a structure integral. ‘‘Pure’’ ontogeny clearly links to the assembly model of morphogenesis, involving much manifestation of convergence–divergence in morphogenetic trajectories. Convergence tends to be expressed most noticeably in ontogeny: In the Drosophila embryo, the endoderm invaginates dorsally and at the anterior end during gastrulation, two separate gut primordia eventually joining in the middle, thus following the convergence strategy. Since it is logically impossible that this could in any way represent a ‘‘recapitulation’’ of any conceivable ancestral form, it must be concluded that this ‘‘parts assembly’’ of the gut is a derived condition reflecting a fabricational paradigm. In contrast, later development rarely involves such dramatic events. The differential distribution of convergence and divergence during the course of a morphogenetic trajectory clearly reflects both temporal and spatial modu-
10. ADAPTIVE CAPACITY AND POTENTIAL IN THE MECHANISMS OF DEVELOPMENT
193
larity in the changing topology of lability in adaptive potential during development (see below). Modularity in the Morphogenetic Trajectory Determination clearly lies at the root of the framework within which adaptive capacity and potential must reside. However, as we have seen, adaptive capacity and potential have a higher probability of residing in some zones of a morphogenetic trajectory than in others, a fact which can be linked to the question of developmental modularity. Raff (1996) defines modularity in terms of units with a discrete genetic organization. These units may be parts of larger entities, they have specific locations and varying degrees of connectivity to other modules, and they undergo temporospatial transformations: Huxley (1932) diagnosed the presence of a constant partition of growth intensity between different regions of the developing organism, implying constant difference in rates of growth between certain modules. Raff (1994) argued that plasticity is much restricted by global inductive activity (lack of modularity) at the neurula stage. Most morphogenetic trajectories express a greater or lesser degree of modularity (as reflected, for example, in the spatial convergence or divergence of cell lineages), and the latter propensity must in turn derive from developmental activity in the sequential progression from TRANS- to CIS-acting determination with respect to larger loci of translation, plus a correlated influence from the dichotomy between adaptational and fabricational paradigms. This hierarchically nested structure in the morphogenetic trajectory has been appropriately termed a ‘‘level-interactive modular array’’ (Dyke, 1988). As we have already seen, spatial modularity tends to be particularly low during ontogeny, in the sense that many different phenotype structures may be derived from a common primordium, rather than from separate precursors: Gilbert (1997) cites the neural crest derived structures of vertebrates (precursors of jaw, middle ear, etc.) as an example of spatial modularity. It can be seen that in some morphogenetic trajectories, different levels of autonomy may be displayed at different time horizons in the same trajectory, so that there is a temporal as well as a spatial dimension in modularity: Changes to mollusc embryos may produce new larval types, yet result in normal adults. This temporal expression of modularity is also manifested in a quite different manner in existence of the pharyngula stage shared by many vertebrate groups (Raff et al., 1991) and by the gastrula in many higher groups, namely, in view of the great changes occurring in later development in different lineages. The principle of morphogenetic accommodation underlies the existence of an intersect zone between ontogeny and phenogeny, and the lability element in adaptive potential must clearly lie here, where both temporal and spatial modularity are increasing most rapidly.
194
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
Developmental Modularity and Adaptive Capacity Allomorphism has already been discussed as an essential component of ‘‘adaptive capacity in dynamic equilibrium’’ (Chapter 4), and this mechanism clearly contains a vital element of developmental modularity. In fact, allelomorphism in general clearly links to epigenetic events in which a bifurcation in some developmental trajectory occurs at a given stage. However, a large proportion of sustainable allomorphic variation tends to lie in the substructural rather than in the morphogenetic domain. Developmental Modularity and Adaptive Potential As we have already seen, two qualitatively different pathways of morphogenetic change may occur in realization of adaptive potential, in that phenogenetic coordinates will follow an adaptational paradigm, and ontogenetic coordinates, a fabricational one. The coordinates systems of development as defined through determination have a simple relationship to adaptive capacity via allomorphism, but a much more complex one with respect to adaptive potential, in terms of a latent propensity for movement toward a more or less distant biophysical paradigm via an iterative sequence of morphogenetic changes. Owing to the influence of temporospatial modularity, this transition must frequently be accommodative with respect to onto- and phenogenetic structural paradigms, at least in the intersect zone. Most significantly, earlier mutational change is likely to have downstream knock-on effects in development (see Arthur, 1997), and the extent to which such changes can be positively selected will clearly depend particularly on the degree of modularity expressed in the temporal dimension. Adaptive potential will thus tend to be differentially distributed in developmental space-time, as a corollary of the temporospatial distribution of developmental modularity. What exactly is the nature of the ‘‘constraints’’ imposed on adaptive potential due to developmental modularity, and how are these factors ultimately bypassed? Genetic factors which determine truly ontogenetic loci such as the morphogenetic compartments of Drosophila must clearly comprise ‘‘essential’’ coordinates with a very long phylogenetic history, and which may thus possess greater resistance to evolutionary change than do many ‘‘minor’’ downstream parameters. Many of the important evolutionary changes in Drosophila do in fact occur further downstream than the known genetic cascade of development (Powell, 1997), and this is an expected corollary of both temporal and spatial modularity built around large scale coordinates laid down in earlier development. Some developmental modules thus clearly manifest lability, and others, resistance to mutational change—and this must in turn link to degrees of freedom in adaptive potential. While both early and late coordinates of determination may form potential targets of mutational change affecting morphogenesis, rigidity must tend to reside more in certain ‘‘major’’ ontogenetic parameters. The reason for this is that TRANS-determined coordinates seem usually to define mosaic morphogenetic objects that are only later assembled as components of a holistic phenotype structure unit (parasegments, wing compartments, etc.). The subsequent assembly of a compound phenotype structure integral
10. ADAPTIVE CAPACITY AND POTENTIAL IN THE MECHANISMS OF DEVELOPMENT
195
thus seems most likely to be coordinated within CIS-determined translational loci. This situation is presumably due to the fact that TRANS-determined coordinates are linked to a fabricational rather than adaptive paradigm. And as we have already seen, certain major ontogenetic parameters are often effectively ‘‘frozen’’ with respect to mutational effects which actually penetrate the phenotype state. The question of lability to large Newtonian determination factor effects suggests another likely source of negative spatial modularity in development, this probably also manifesting a greater effect in ontogeny than phenogeny. In general, an emergence of increasing developmental lability at or around the ontophenogenetic intersect zone (i.e., in the transition between low and higher levels of modularity) thus seems most likely to coincide with the intersect zone between TRANS- and CIS-acting determination factors, and it is reasonable to suggest that realization of adaptive potential is most likely to be concentrated at or beyond this domain. To what extent do the foregoing postulates agree with actual observations on the developmental systems of real organisms? Early ontogeny does indeed appear to be very tightly constrained in general. However, there are nevertheless certain notable exceptions to this rule: Dramatic change does sometimes occur during early development in species with complex metamorphosis. For example, recent work on Heliocidaris urchins confirms the view that early development can be radically altered. In H. erythrogramma (see Raff, 1996), even gastrulation undergoes profound changes. The latter could perhaps be permissible if very low selectional differentials appertain to the reshuffling of certain early ontogenetic features, which could in fact be the case if self-organization has a higher profile in ontogeny sensu stricto than it does in phenogeny (see Chapter 15). There is clearly a fundamental modular interactivity expressed in the spatial dimension at certain levels in development, identifying rigidity where adaptive potential with respect to the exogenous environment must be effectively occluded. This is especially true at those horizons at which development is organized largely around the fabricational paradigm; however, this does not always exclude radical reorganization of certain ontogenetic coordinates. Despite exceptions of the kind described by Raff, certain modes of determination (as well as certain zones within a developmental trajectory) clearly do contain a negative corollary for realization of adaptive potential. The question of modular inhibition intrinsic to certain aspects of development can be seen to be linked to that phenomenon known as ‘‘the developmental ratchet,’’ and this seems often to be a peculiarly ontogenetic effect arising from high levels of interactivity between major prepatterns for separate modules emerging only in later development. Consequently, the dichotomy between adaptive and fabricational paradigms is at least partially linked to differential lability in terms of degrees of freedom in adaptive potential. However, as we have just seen, this does not mean that change is not permitted in ontogeny, only that this is generally confined to ontogenetic level by virtue of temporal modularity (see
196
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
earlier remarks on the phylotypic stage in vertebrates and on Raff’s ‘‘hourglass’’ model, pp. 168–191): Wolpert (1990b) also noted that enormous variations occur in early development which might provide raw material for innovation. However, the question of modularity and the differential between fabricational and adaptational paradigms may often preclude this so far as parameters actually penetrating phenogeny are concerned. In general then, lability to mutational change will tend to be distributed in the developmental trajectory according to capacity for morphogenetic accommodation between a small number of quasi-autonomous modules of determinative activity. So far as the problem of morphogenetic accommodation traversing the coordinates of both the adaptational and fabricational paradigms of a given developmental trajectory is concerned, it is perhaps apparent that the most probable focus of accommodation may be unlikely to penetrate below the intersect zone for phenogeny and ontogeny that is linked to the transitional zone between TRANS- and CIS-acting determination factors. Here we must consider the large measure of stability that is clearly imposed at and around the phylotypic stage as constituting one likely source of confirmatory evidence. Having examined the question of developmental constraints, it is now necessary to go on to briefly examine certain other aspects of modularity that are actually conducive to morphogenetic change. The autonomy of certain morphogenetic trajectories, as evidence of temporal modularity freeing adaptive potential, is nowhere more noticeable than in the division between the germ line and somatic line. And this has obvious connotations for heterochrony, while at the same time drawing attention to the relative absence of such a high degree of dissociation for many other modules of development: In Drosophila, the somatic and germ lineages diverge while the embryo is still in the syncytial stage, at the ninth cycle of cell division. In many other lineages, this element of modularity has been seized upon as a basis for paedomorphosis (see Chapter 16). In contrast to the strong dissociation between germ line and somatic line, those coordinates of determination holding the highest level TRANS-acting determination factors with effects over many units of phenotype structure seem conversely to manifest the greatest level of evolutionary conservatism known in the genetic systems of eukaryote organisms (for example, those under the control of the Hox genes, see next two chapters). In summary, the most ‘‘adjacent’’ morphosystems of a given phenotype state are determined by the degree of modularity expressed by its morphogenetic trajectory. Adaptive potential is thus most fluid in such modes as heterochronous change, where the accommodation requirement is at its lowest level. In this context, both adaptive capacity and adaptive potential may in fact display a linked modularity at certain stages of development, and this must also have important consequences for evolution (see Chapter 16). More remote neomorphic systems may also have the potential to arise through a propensity for some degree of modular interactivity between trajectories linked to different morphogenetic objects via modifications to a variety
10. ADAPTIVE CAPACITY AND POTENTIAL IN THE MECHANISMS OF DEVELOPMENT
197
of translational mechanisms, assuming only that the problem of morphogenetic accommodation can be solved. As will be seen at a later point, this is often made possible by gene duplication (see Chapter 12). Much evidence has been accumulated to support our earlier proposition that realization of adaptive potential with respect to adult phenotype traits seems most likely to occur in the transition zone between proximal- and remoteacting determination factors, no earlier in the morphogenetic trajectory than that point at which the largest intersect between ontogeny and phenogeny exists, and certainly later than the phylotypic stage. Directionalization and ‘‘Constraint’’ in Developmental Modularity We have seen that, owing to a fundamental capacity for reciprocity in determinative activity, both within and between morphogenetic trajectories, the coordinates of adaptive potential must be at least partly accommodative for both the adaptational and fabricational biophysical paradigms. Raff (1996) has also discussed the question of ‘‘vertical’’ (temporal) developmental constraints, which concepts clearly must be connected with morphogenetic accommodation. Raff also noted that exceptions to apparent ‘‘constrainment rules’’ are widespread in that domain, an observation which might in turn be linked to lability in the fabricational paradigm. Raff additionally emphasized the point that ‘‘horizontal’’ (spatial) constraints may be more prevalent, as a function of degree of modular interactivity at any point in time. However, the various ‘‘constraints’’ discussed in this chapter do not constitute impediments to evolution so much as factors affecting directionalization of anagenetic change (see also Chapter 15). The question of constraints in general has already been reexamined in the light of factors tending to directionalize the adaptive response (Chapter 7), and it is perhaps pertinent at this juncture to point out that the sum total of all so-called constraints that have so far been examined cannot be presumed to affect such fundamental evolutionary mechanisms as probability of speciation in any way. Many traits involved in species isolation are in fact substructural in nature, or else comprise a repertoire of simple allelic substitutional differentials or amphigenetic states: For example, the parasitic wasp family Ichneumonidae has an immense species diversity, yet a typical species-rich genus in this family exhibits very little in the way of morphogenetic differential between species. It follows that the narrow channeling of degrees of freedom in adaptive potential and in the biophysical paradigm which occur because of factors arising from developmental modularity only serve to directionalize anagenesis, and in no way do they constitute any form of constraint on the actual occurrence of evolutionary change, whether cladogenetic or anagenetic. In fact, a large part of this ‘‘constraint’’ must be interpreted as promoting directionalization, rather than imposing any real impediment to evolution.
MAIN POINTS FROM CHAPTER 10 1. The coordinates of adaptive capacity and potential do not lie in geometric dimensions of the final phenotype, but in those of development. These
198
THE EVOLUTION OF ADAPTIVE SYSTEMS
parameters must also be understood in terms of different levels of genetic translation. 2. The translation mechanism can be viewed in terms of a nested hierarchy of proximal-plus remote-acting determination factors, from primary translation of the genetic code through epigenetic interactivity to morphogenesis. 3. Remote-acting determination factors tend to manifest plasticity in the sole context of the true ontogenetic paradigm, so that the exogenous component of adaptive potential tends to lie more in the domain of CIS-acting factors. Mechanical induction factors seem likely to express the same mode of constrainment as do TRANS-acting determination factors, owing to their usual links with the fabricational paradigm. 4. The architecture of a generalized morphogenetic trajectory illustrates the differential distribution of modularity during development. The mosaic strategy demonstrates greater modular autonomy, the regulative, greater modular interactivity—plus a more wide-ranging lability in adaptive potential. 5. Modularity can be understood in terms of developmental units which manifest a discrete genetic organization. These un