Frontiers in Mathematics
Advisory Editorial Board Leonid Bunimovich (Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta) Benoît Perthame (Université Pierre et Marie Curie, Paris) Laurent Saloff-Coste (Cornell University, Ithaca) Igor Shparlinski (Macquarie University, New South Wales) Wolfgang Sprössig (TU Bergakademie Freiberg) Cédric Villani (Ecole Normale Supérieure, Lyon)
K. David Elworthy Yves Le Jan Xue-Mei Li
The
Geometry of
Filtering
K. David Elworthy Institute of Mathematics University of Warwick Gibbet Hill Road CV4 7AL Coventry United Kingdom
[email protected]
Yves Le Jan Laboratoire de Mathématiques Université Paris-Sud XI CNRS Orsay Cedex Bâtiment 425 France
[email protected]
Xue-Mei Li Institute of Mathematics University of Warwick Gibbet Hill Road CV4 7AL Coventry United Kingdom
Mathematics Subject Classification: 58J65, 60H 07 ISBN 978-3-0346-0175-7 DOI 10.1007/978-3-0346-0176-4
e-ISBN 978-3-0346-0176-4
© Springer Basel AG 2010 This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, re-use of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilms or in other ways, and storage in data banks. For any kind of use permission of the copyright owner must be obtained. Cover design: deblik, Berlin Printed on acid-free paper Springer Basel AG is part of Springer Science+Business Media www.birkhauser-science.com
Contents Introduction 1
2
3
4
Diffusion Operators 1.1 Representations of Diffusion Operators . . 1.2 The Associated First-Order Operator . . . 1.3 Diffusion Operators Along a Distribution 1.4 Lifts of Diffusion Operators . . . . . . . . 1.5 Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
vii
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
1 1 4 5 7 10
Decomposition of Diffusion Operators 2.1 The Horizontal Lift Map . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2 Lifts of Cohesive Operators and The Decomposition Theorem 2.3 The Lift Map for SDEs and Decomposition of Noise . . . . . 2.3.1 Decomposition of Stratonovich SDE’s . . . . . . . . . 2.3.2 Decomposition of the noise and Itˆo SDE’s . . . . . . . 2.4 Diffusion Operators with Projectible Symbols . . . . . . . . . 2.5 Horizontal lifts of paths and completeness of semi-connections 2.6 Topological Implications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.7 Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
11 11 17 23 24 25 26 28 30 31
Equivariant Diffusions on Principal Bundles 3.1 Invariant Semi-connections on Principal Bundles . . . . 3.2 Decompositions of Equivariant Operators . . . . . . . . 3.3 Derivative Flows and Adjoint Connections . . . . . . . . 3.4 Associated Vector Bundles and Generalised Weitzenb¨ock 3.5 Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Formulae . . . . . .
33 34 36 41 46 58
Projectible Diffusion Processes and Markovian Filtering 4.1 Integration of predictable processes . . . . . . . . . 4.2 Horizontality and filtrations . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3 Intertwined diffusion processes . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4 A family of Markovian kernels . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
61 62 66 66 70
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
vi
Contents 4.5 4.6 4.7 4.8 4.9 4.10 4.11 4.12
5
The filtering equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Approximations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Krylov-Veretennikov Expansion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conditional Laws . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . An SPDE example . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Equivariant case: skew-product decomposition . . . . . . . . . . . Conditional expectations of induced processes on vector bundles Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Filtering with non-Markovian Observations 5.1 Signals with Projectible Symbol . . . . 5.2 Innovations and innovations processes 5.3 Classical Filtering . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4 Example: Another SPDE . . . . . . . 5.5 Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . . . .
71 73 74 75 79 81 83 85
. . . . .
87 88 91 94 95 99
6
The Commutation Property 101 6.1 Commutativity of Diffusion Semigroups . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 103 6.2 Consequences for the Horizontal Flow . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 105
7
Example: Riemannian Submersions and Symmetric 7.1 Riemannian Submersions . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2 Riemannian Symmetric Spaces . . . . . . . . 7.3 Notes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
8
Example: Stochastic Flows 121 8.1 Semi-connections on the Bundle of Diffeomorphisms . . . . . . . . 121 8.2 Semi-connections Induced by Stochastic Flows . . . . . . . . . . . 125 8.3 Semi-connections on Natural Bundles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 131
9
Appendices 9.1 Girsanov-Maruyama-Cameron-Martin Theorem . . . . . 9.2 Stochastic differential equations for degenerate diffusions 9.3 Semi-martingales and Γ-martingales along a Subbundle 9.4 Second fundamental forms and shape operators . . . . . 9.5 Intertwined stochastic flows . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Spaces 115 . . . . . . . . . . . . 115 . . . . . . . . . . . . 116 . . . . . . . . . . . . 119
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
135 135 139 145 147 148
Bibliography
159
Index
167
Introduction Filtering is the science of finding the law of a process given a partial observation of it. The main objects we study here are diffusion processes. These are naturally associated with second-order linear differential operators which are semi-elliptic and so introduce a possibly degenerate Riemannian structure on the state space. In fact, much of what we discuss is simply about two such operators intertwined by a smooth map, the “projection from the state space to the observations space”, and does not involve any stochastic analysis. From the point of view of stochastic processes, our purpose is to present and to study the underlying geometric structure which allows us to perform the filtering in a Markovian framework with the resulting conditional law being that of a Markov process which is time inhomogeneous in general. This geometry is determined by the symbol of the operator on the state space which projects to a symbol on the observation space. The projectible symbol induces a (possibly non-linear and partially defined) connection which lifts the observation process to the state space and gives a decomposition of the operator on the state space and of the noise. As is standard we can recover the classical filtering theory in which the observations are not usually Markovian by application of the GirsanovMaruyama-Cameron-Martin Theorem. This structure we have is examined in relation to a number of geometrical topics. In one direction this leads to a generalisation of Hermann’s theorem on the fibre bundle structure of certain Riemannian submersions. In another it gives a novel description of generalised Weitzenb¨ock curvature. It also applies to infinite dimensional state spaces such as arise naturally for stochastic flows of diffeomorphisms defined by stochastic differential equations, and for certain stochastic partial differential equations. A feature of our approach is that in general we use canonical processes as solutions of martingale problems to describe our processes, rather than stochastic differential equations and semi-martingale calculus, unless we are explicitly dealing with the latter. This leads to some new constructions, for example of integrals along the paths of our diffusions in Section 4.1, which are valid more generally than in the very regular cases we discuss here.
viii
Introduction
Those whose interest is mainly in filtering rather than in the geometry should look at Chapter 1, most of Chapter 2, especially Section 2.3, but omitting Section 2.6. Then move to Chapter 4 where Section 4.11 can be ignored. They could then finish with Chapter 5, though some of the Appendices may be of interest. A central role is played by certain generalised connections determined by the principal symbols of the operators involved. To describe this in more detail let M be a smooth manifold. Consider a smooth second-order semi-elliptic differential operator L such that L1 ≡ 0. In a local chart, such an operator takes the form L=
n X ∂ 1 X ij ∂ ∂ a + bi i 2 i,j=1 ∂xi ∂xj ∂x
(1)
where the aij ’s and bi ’s are smooth functions and the matrix (aij ) is positive semi-definite. Such differential operators are called diffusion operators. An elliptic diffusion operator induces a Riemannian metric on M . In the degenerate case we shall have to assume that the “symbol” of L (essentially the matrix [aij ] in the representation (1)) has constant rank and so determines a subbundle E of the tangent bundle T M together with a Riemannian metric on E. In Elworthy-LeJan-Li [35] and [36] it was shown that a diffusion operator in H¨ ormander form, satisfying this condition, induces a linear connection on E which is adapted to the Riemannian metric induced on E, but not necessarily torsion free. It was also shown that all metric connections on E can be constructed by some choice of H¨ormander form for a given L in this way. The use of such connections has turned out to be instrumental in the decomposition of noise and calculation of covariant derivatives of the derivative flows. A related construction of connections can arise with principal fibre bundles P . An equivariant differential operator on P induces naturally a diffusion operator on the base manifold. Conversely, given an equivariant or “principal” connection on P , one can lift horizontally a diffusion operator on the base manifold of the form of sum of squares of vector fields by simply lifting up the vector fields. It still needs to be shown that the lift is independent of choices of its H¨ormander form. Consider now a diffusion operator not given in H¨ormander form. Since it has no zero-order term we can associate with it an operator δ which sends differential one-forms to functions. In Proposition 1.2.1, members of a class of such operators are described, each of which determines a diffusion operator. Horizontal lifts of diffusion operators can then be defined in terms of the δ operator. This construction extends to situations where there is no equivariance and we have only partially defined and non-linear connections. We show that given a smooth p : N → M : a diffusion operator B on N which lies over a diffusion operator A on M satisfying a “cohesiveness” property gives rise to a semi-connection, a partially defined, non-linear, connection which can be characterised by the property that, with respect to it, B can be written as the direct sum of the horizontal lift of its
Introduction
ix
induced operator and a vertical diffusion operator. Of particular importance are examples where p : N → M is a principal bundle. In that case the vertical component of B induces differential operators on spaces of sections of associated vector bundles: we observe that these are zero-order operators, and can have geometric significance. This geometric significance, and the relationship between these partially defined connections and the metric connections determined by the H¨ormander form as in [35] and [36], is seen when taking B to be the generator of the diffusion given on the frame bundle GLM of M by the action of the derivative flow of a stochastic differential equation on M . The semi- connection determined by B is then equivariant and is the adjoint of the metric connection induced by the SDE in a sense extending that of Driver [25] and described in [36]. The zero-order operators induced by the vertical component of B acting on differential forms turn out to be generalised Weitzenb¨ ock curvature operators, in the sense of [36], reducing to the classical ones when M is Riemannian for particular choices of stochastic differential equations for Brownian motion on M . Our filtering then reproduces the conditioning results for derivatives of stochastic flows in [38] and [36]. Our approach is also applied to the case where M is compact and N is its diffeomorphism group, Diff(M ) , with P evaluation at a chosen point of M . The operator B is taken to be the generator of the diffusion process on Diff(M ) arising from a stochastic flow. However our constructions can be made in terms of the reproducing Hilbert space of vector fields on M defined by the flow. From this we see that stochastic flows are essentially determined by a class of semiconnections on the bundle p : Diff(M ) → M and smooth stochastic flows whose one-point motions have a cohesive generator determine semi- connections on all natural bundles over M . Apart from these geometrical aspects of stochastic flows we also obtain a skew-product decomposition which, for example, can be used to find conditional expectations of functionals of such flows given knowledge of the one-point motion from our chosen point in M . The plan of the book is as follows: In Chapter 1 we describe various representations of diffusion operators and when they are available. We also define the notion of such an operator being along a distribution. In Chapter 2 we introduce the notion of semi-connection which is fundamental for what follows, and we show how these are induced by certain intertwined pairs of diffusion operators and how they relate to a canonical decomposition of such operators. We also have a first look at the topological consequences on p : N → M of having B on N over some A on M which possesses hypo-ellipticity type properties. This is a minor extension of part of Hermann’s theorem, [51], for Riemannian submersions. In Chapter 3 we specialise to the case of principal bundles, introduce the example of derivative flow, and show how the generalised Wietzenbock curvatures arise. It is not really until Chapter 4 that stochastic analysis plays a major role. Here we describe methods of conditioning functionals of the B-process given information about its projection onto M . We also use our decomposition of B and resulting decomposition of the B-process to describe the conditional B-process.
x
Introduction
In the equivariant case of principal bundles the decomposition of the process can be considered as a skew-product decomposition. In Chapter 5 we show how our constructions can apply to classical filtering problems, where the projection of the B-process is non-Markovian by an appropriate change of probability measure. We can follow the classical approach, illustrated for example in the lecture notes of Pardoux [85], and obtain, in Theorem 5.9, a version of Kushner’s formula for non-linear filtering in somewhat greater generality than is standard. This requires some discussion of analogues of innovations processes in our setting. We return to more geometrical analysis in Chapter 6, giving further extensions of Hermann’s theorem and analysing the consequences of the horizontal lift of A commuting with B, thereby extending the discussion in [9]. In particular we see that such commutativity, plus hypo-ellipticity conditions on A, gives a bundle structure and a diffusion operator on the fibre which is preserved by the trivialisations of the bundle structure. This leads to an extension of the “skew-product” decomposition given in [33] for Brownian motions on the total space of Riemannian submersions with totally geodesic fibres. In fact the well-known theory for Riemann submersions, and the special case arising from Riemannian symmetric spaces is presented in Chapter 7. Chapter 8 is where we describe the theory for the diffeomorphism bundle p : Diff(M ) → M with a stochastic flow of diffeomorphism on M . Initially this is done independently of stochastic analysis and in terms of reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces of vector fields on M . The correspondence between such Hilbert spaces and stochastic flows is then used to get results for flows and in particular skew-product decompositions of them. In the Appendices we present the Girsanov Theorem in a way which does not rely on having to use conditions such as Novikov’s criteria for it to remain valid. This has been known for a long time, but does not appear to be as well known as it deserves. We also look at conditions for degenerate, but smooth, diffusion operators to have smooth H¨ ormander forms, and so to have stochastic differential equation representations for their associated processes. We also discuss semi-martingales and Γ-martingales along a subbundle of the tangent bundle with a connection. One section of the Appendix is a very brief exposition of the differential geometry of submanifolds, defining second fundamental forms and shape operators. This is used in the final section which analyses the situation of intertwined stochastic flows or essentially equivalently of diffusion operators which are not only intertwined but also have H¨ormander forms composed of intertwined vector fields. It is shown that the H¨ormander forms determine a decomposition of the operator B, which is not generally the same as the canonical decomposition described in Chapter 2. Here it is not necessary to make the constant rank condition on the symbol of A which plays an important role in Chapter 2. At the end of this section we show that having intertwined Brownian flows which both induce Levi-Civita connections can only occur given severe restrictions on the geometry of the submersion p : N → M . For Brownian motions on the total spaces of Riemannian submersions much of our basic discussion, as in the first two and a half chapters, of skew-product
Introduction
xi
decompositions is very close to that in [33] which was taken further by Liao in [69]. A major difference from Liao’s work is that for degenerate diffusions we use the semi-connection determined by our operators rather than an arbitrary one, so obtaining canonical decompositions. The same holds for the very recent work of Lazaro-Cami & Ortega, [62] where they are motivated by the reduction and reconstruction of Hamiltonian systems and consider similar decompositions for semi-martingales. An extension of [33] in a different direction, to shed light on the Fadeev-Popov procedure for gauge theories in theoretical physics, was given by Arnaudon &Paycha in [1]. Much of the equivariant theory presented here was announced with some sketched proofs in [34]. Acknowledgements The collaborative work for this book was carried out at a variety of institutions, especially Orsay and Warwick, with final touches at the Newton Institute. We gratefully acknowledge the importance of our contacts during its preparation with many people, notably including J.-M.Bony, D.O.Crisan, R.Dalang, M.Fuhrman, E.P. Hsu, and J.Teichmann. This research also benefited from an EPSRC grant (EP/E058124/1). K.D. Elworthy, Y. Le Jan and Xue-Mei Li
Chapter 1
Diffusion Operators Pn Pn i ∂ ∂ ∂ n Let i,j=1 aij ∂x i ∂xj + i=1 b ∂xi be a differential operator on R , with smooth coefficients. We can and will assume that (ai,j ) is symmetric. Its symbol is given by the matrix-valued function (ai,j ) considered as a bilinear form on Rn or equivalently as a map from (Rn )? to Rn . The operator is said to be semi-elliptic if the symbol is positive semi-definite, and elliptic if it is positive definite. More generally if L is a second-order differential operator on a manifold M , denote by σ L : T ∗ M → T M its symbol determined by 1 1 1 df σ L (dg) = L (f g) − (Lf )g − f (Lg), 2 2 2 for C 2 functions f, g. We will often write σ L (`1 , `2 ) for `1 σ L (`2 ) and consider σ L as a bilinear form on T ∗ M . Note that it is symmetric. The operator is said to be semi-elliptic if σ L (`1 , `2 ) > 0 for all `1 , `2 ∈ Tu M ∗ , all u ∈ M , and elliptic if the inequality holds strictly. Ellipticity is equivalent to σ L being onto. Definition 1.0.1. A semi-elliptic smooth second-order differential operator L is said to be a diffusion operator if L1 = 0. The standard example of a diffusion operator is the Laplace-Beltrami operator or Laplacian , 4, of a Riemannian manifold M. It is given as in Rn by 4 = div ∇ = −d∗ d where div is the negative of the adjoint of the gradient operator ∇. Its symbol σ 4 : T ? M → T M is just the isomorphism induced by the Riemannian metric. Conversely the symbol of any elliptic diffusion operator determines a Riemannian metric with respect to which the operator differs from the Laplacian by a firstorder term.
1.1
Representations of Diffusion Operators
Apart from local representations as given above there are several global ways to represent a diffusion operator L. One is to take a connection ∇ on T M . Recall that
K.D. Elworthy et al., The Geometry of Filtering, Frontiers in Mathematics, DOI 10.1007/978-3-0346-0176-4_1, © Springer Basel AG 2010
1
2
Chapter 1. Diffusion Operators
a connection on T M gives, or is given by, a covariant derivative operator ∇ acting on vector fields. For each C r vector field U on M it gives a C r−1 section ∇− U of L(T M ; T M ). In other words, for each x ∈ M we have a linear map v 7→ ∇v U of Tx M to itself. This covariant derivative of U in the direction v satisfies the usual rules. In particular it is a derivation with respect to multiplication by differentiable functions f : M → R, so that ∇v (f U ) = df (v)U (x) + f (x)∇v U . For example on Rn a connection is given by Christoffel symbols Γkij : Rn → R, i, j, k = 1, . . . , n. These define a covariant differentiation of vector fields by n n k X X k ∂U (x) + Γkij (x)U j (x) v i (1.1) (∇v U ) = ∂x i i=1 j=1 where, for example, U j denotes the j-th component of the vector field U and we are considering v as a tangent vector at x ∈ Rn . We can also consider the Christoffel symbols as the components of a map Γ : Rn → L (Rn ; L(Rn ; Rn )) and equation (1.1) becomes: (1.2) ∇v U = DU (x)(v) + Γ(x)(v)(U (x)). Given any smooth vector bundle τ : E → M over M a connection on E gives a similar covariant derivative acting on sections U of E. This time v 7→ ∇v U is in L(Tx M ; Ex ), where Ex is the fibre over x for x ∈ M . In our local representation the Christoffel symbol now has Γ(x) ∈ L (Rn ; L(Ex ; Ex )) where Ex := p−1 (x) is the fibre of E over x. A connection on T M determines one on the cotangent bundle T ∗ M , and on all tensor bundles over M . Such connections always exist; more details can be found in [19], [55]. In terms of a connection on T M we can write Lf (x) = traceTx M ∇− (σ L (df )) + df (V 0 (x))
(1.3)
for some smooth vector field V 0 on M . The trace is that of the mapping v 7→ ∇v (σ L (df )) from Tx M to itself. To see this it is only necessary to check that the right-hand side has the correct symbol since the symbol determines the diffusion operator up to a first-order term. For the Laplacian on Rn , when Rn is given its usual “trivial ” connection this reduces to the representation: 4f (x) = trace D2 f (x)
(1.4)
where D2 f (x) ∈ L(Rn , Rn ; R) is the second Frechet derivative of f at x. If a smooth ‘square root’ to 2σ L can be found we have a H¨ormander representation. The ‘square root’ is a smooth map X : M × Rm → T M with each X(x) ≡ X(x, −) : Rm → Tx M linear, such that 2σxL = X(x)X(x)∗ : Tx∗ M → Tx M
1.1. Representations of Diffusion Operators
3
where X(x)∗ : Tx∗ M → Rm is the adjoint map of X(x). Thus there is a smooth vector field A with m 1X L= L j L j + LA , (1.5) 2 j=1 X X where X j (x) = X(x)(ej ) for {ej } an orthonormal basis of Rm , and LV denotes Lie differentiation with respect to a vector field V , so LV f (x) = dfx (V (x)). On Rn , X ∂ LV f (x) = V i (x) f (x). ∂x i i For the Laplacian on Rn the simplest H¨ormander form representation is n
4=
1 X√ ∂ √ ∂ 2 j 2 j 2 j=1 ∂x ∂x
and the generator, 12 4, of Brownian motion has n
1 1X ∂ ∂ 4= . 2 2 j=1 ∂xj ∂xj If σ L has constant rank, such X may be found. A proof of this is given in the Appendix, Theorem 9.2.1. Otherwise it is only known that locally Lipschitz square roots exist (see the discussions in the Appendix, Section 9.2). In that case LX j LX j is only defined almost surely everywhere and the vector field A can only be assumed measurable and locally bounded. Nevertheless uniqueness of the martingale problem still holds (see below). Also there is still the hybrid representation, given a connection ∇ on T M , m
Lf (x) =
1X ∇ j (df )(X j (x)) + df (V 0 (x)) 2 j=1 X (x)
(1.6)
for V 0 locally Lipschitz. The choice of a H¨ ormander representation for a diffusion operator, if it exists, determines a locally defined stochastic flow of diffeomorphisms {ξt : 0 6 t < ζ} whose one-point motion solves the martingale problem for the diffusion operator. In particular on bounded measurable compactly supported f : M → R the associated (sub-) Markovian semigroup is given by Pt f = E(f ◦ ξt ). See also Appendix II. Despite the discussion above we can always write L in the form N 1 X ij a LX i LX j + LX 0 , L= 2 ij=1
(1.7)
where N is a finite number, aij and X k are respectively smooth functions and smooth vector fields with aij = aji .
4
1.2
Chapter 1. Diffusion Operators
The Associated First-Order Operator
Denote by C r Λp ≡ C r Λp T ∗ M , r > 0, the space of C r smooth differential p-forms on a manifold N . To each diffusion operator L we shall associate an operator δ L : C r+1 Λ1 → C r (M ; R), see Elworthy-LeJan-Li [35], [36] c.f. Eberle [27]. The horizontal lift of L will then be defined in terms of a lift of δ L . The existence of δ L comes from the lack of a 0-order term in L: Proposition 1.2.1. For each diffusion operator L there is a unique smooth linear differential operator δ L : C r+1 Λ1 → C r Λ0 such that (1) δ L (f φ) = df σ L (φ) + f · δ L (φ), (2) δ L (df ) = Lf. In particular in the Rn case with L = δL φ =
m X
aij
i,j=1
Pn
i,j=1
∂ ∂ aij ∂x i ∂xj +
P
∂ bi ∂x i it is given by
X ∂ φj (x) + bi φi (x) ∂xi
where φ has the representation φx =
X
φj (x) dxi .
(1.8)
Equivalently δ L is determined by either one of the following: δ L (f dg) = σ L (df, dg) + f Lg, 1 1 1 δ L (f dg) = L(f g) − gLf + f Lg. 2 2 2
(1.9) (1.10)
Proof. The statements are rather obvious in the Rn case. In general take a connection ∇ on T M , then, as in (1.3), L can be written as Lf = trace ∇σ L (df ) + LV 0 f for some smooth vector field V 0 . Set δ L φ = trace ∇(σ L φ) + φ(V 0 ). Then δ L (df ) = Lf and δ L (f φ) = trace ∇(f (σ L φ)) + f φ(V 0 ) = f δ L φ + df (σ L φ). Pk Note that a general C r 1-form φ can be written as φ = j=1 fi dgi for some C r function fi and smooth gi , for example, by taking (g 1 , . . . , g m ) : M → Rm to be an immersion. This shows that (1) and (2) determine δ L uniquely. Moreover since L is a smooth operator so is δ L . Remark 1.2.2. If the diffusion operator L has a representation L=
m X j=1
aij LX i LX j + LX 0
1.3. Diffusion Operators Along a Distribution
5
for some smooth vector fields X i and smooth functions aij , i, j = 0, 1, . . . , m with aij = aji , then m X aij LX i ιX j + ιX 0 , δL = j=1
where ιA denotes the interior product of the vector field A with a differential form. [In particular if φ is a one-form, then ιA (φ) : M → R is given by ιA (φ)(x) = φx (A(x)).] One can check directly that δ L (df ) = Lf and that (1) holds.
1.3
Diffusion Operators Along a Distribution
Let N be a smooth manifold. By a distribution S in N we mean a family {Su : u ∈ N } where Su is a linear subspace of Tu N ; for example S could be a subbundle of T N . In Rn each Su can be viewed as a linear subspace of Rn . Given such a distribution S let S 0 = ∪u Su0 for Su0 the annihilator of Su in Tu∗ N . Definition 1.3.1. Let S be a distribution in T N . Denote by C r S 0 the set of C r 1-forms which vanish on S. A diffusion operator L on N is said to be along S if δ L φ = 0 for all φ ∈ C 1 S 0 . Example 1.3.2. For N = Rn − {0} let Su be the hyperplane orthogonal to u. The ∂2 spherical Laplacian, ( ∂θ 2 if n = 2), is along this distribution. Example 1.3.3. Let N = R3 with the C ∞ Heisenberg group structure induced by the central extension of the symplectic vector space R2 . This is defined by 1 (x, y, z) · (x0 , y 0 , z 0 ) = x + x0 , y + y 0 , z + z 0 + (xy 0 − yx0 ) . 2 This is isomorphic to the matrix group of 3 × 3 upper diagonal matrices: 1 x z (x, y, z) 7→ 0 1 y . (1.11) 0 0 1 Let X, Y, Z be the left-invariant vector fields which give the standard basis for R3 at the origin. As operators: 1 ∂ ∂ − y , ∂x 2 ∂z ∂ Z(x, y, z) = . ∂z
X(x, y, z) =
Y (x, y, z) =
∂ 1 ∂ + x ∂y 2 ∂z
Let L be the operator LH given by 1 (LX LX + LY LY ) 2 2 1 ∂2 ∂2 ∂2 1 2 ∂2 2 ∂ = −y . + 2 + (x + y ) 2 + x 2 ∂x2 ∂y 4 ∂z ∂y∂z ∂x∂z
LH =
(1.12) (1.13)
6
Chapter 1. Diffusion Operators
This operator is clearly along the distribution S given by left translates of the (x, y)-plane. This distribution is not integrable: it is not tangent to any foliation / Su . of R3 . Indeed the Lie bracket of X and Y is Z so [X, Y ](u) ∈ In general suppose L is along S and take φ ∈ C r S 0 . By Proposition 1.2.1 and the symmetry of σ L , 0 = (df )(σ L (φ)) = φ(σ L (df ) giving φx ∈ Image[σxL ]0 . This proves Remark 1.3.4 (i): Remark 1.3.4. (i) if δ L φ = 0 for all φ ∈ C 1 S 0 , then σ L φ = 0 for all such φ and Image[σxL ] ⊂ ∩φ∈C 1 S 0 [ker φx ] for all x ∈ N . (ii) If S is a subbundle of T N , (essentially a smooth family of subspaces of constant dimension), and L is along S, then without ambiguity we can define δ L φ for φ a C 0 section of S ∗ by δ L φ := δ L φ˜ for any 1-form φ˜ extending φ. Recall that S ∗ is canonically isomorphic to the quotient T ∗ N/S 0 . An important case is where Su is the image of σuL assuming that the symbol σ L has constant rank. Definition 1.3.5. If Sx = ∩φ∈C 1 S 0 [ker φx ] for all x we say S is a regular distribution. Clearly subbundles are regular. As another example take the circle, M = S 1 , and suppose that Su = 0 except for finitely many points. Then C 1 S 0 consists of those C 1 forms which vanish at those points. This distribution is regular but is not a subbundle. However this would not hold in general if it were non-zero precisely on a countably infinite set of points. The notion is introduced in order to be able to consider the vertical distribution {V Tu N := ker Tu p : u ∈ N } of a smooth map p : N → M : Lemma 1.3.6. Let p : N → M be a smooth map, then {ker Tu p : u ∈ N } is a regular distribution. Proof. This is immediate since ker[T p] is annihilated by all differential 1-forms of the form θ ◦ T p for θ a C 1 1-form on M . Proposition 1.3.7. (1) Let S be a regular distribution of N and L an operator written in H¨ ormander form: m
L=
1X L j L j + LY 0 2 j=1 Y Y
(1.14)
where the vector fields Y 0 and Y j , j = 1, . . . , m are C 0 and C 1 respectively. Then L is along S if and only if Y i are sections of S. (2) If B is along a smooth subbundle S of T N , then for any connection ∇S on S we can write B as Bf = traceSx ∇S− σ B (df ) + LX 0 f.
1.4. Lifts of Diffusion Operators
7
Also we can find smooth sections X 0 , . . . , X m of S and smooth functions aij such that 1 X ij a LX i LX j + LX 0 . B= 2 i,j [Recall that ∇S is a covariant derivative operator defined only on those vector fields which take values in S, though one can differentiate in any direction.] Proof. For part (1), if Y i are sections of S, take φ ∈ C 1 S 0 , then m
δL φ =
1X L j φ(Y j ) + φ(Y 0 ) = 0 2 j=1 Y
and so L is along S. Conversely L is along S. Define a C 1 bundle map Y : Rm → T N by Pm suppose j m Y (x)(e) = j=1 Y (x)ej for {ej }m j=1 an orthonormal base of R . Then 2σxL = Y (x)Y (x)∗ and Image[Y (x)] = Image[σxL ] ⊂ S, by Remark 1.3.4. Now δL φ =
1X LY j (φ(Y j )) + φ(Y 0 ) = φ(Y 0 ), 2
which can only vanish for all φ ∈ C 1 S 0 if Y 0 is a section of S. Thus Y 1 , . . . , Y m , and Y 0 are all sections of S. For part (2), we use (1.3) and take ∇ there to be the direct sum of ∇S with an arbitrary connection on a complementary bundle, observing σ B has image in S by Remark 1.3.4(i).
1.4
Lifts of Diffusion Operators
Let p : N → M be a smooth map and E a subbundle of T M . Recall that V Tu N := ker Tu p denotes the vertical distribution. If p(u) is a regular value of p, that is if Ty p : Ty N → Tp(u) M is surjective for all y ∈ p−1 (p(u)), then the fibre Ep (u) := p−1 (p(u)) is a submanifold with V Tu N as its tangent space at u. Let S be a subbundle of T N transversal to the fibre of p, i.e. V Tu N ∩ S = {0} all u ∈ N and such that Ty p maps Sy isomorphically onto Ep(y) , for each y. Example 1.4.1. Set N = R2 − {0}, M = R(> 0) with Ex = R for all x ∈ M . Take p(x) = |x|. Then for all u ∈ N the orthogonal complement to Ru is the vertical tangent spaced V Tu N and we may take Su = Ru. Here we are, as usual, identifying Tu {R2 − {0}} with R2 .
8
Chapter 1. Diffusion Operators
The example above was a special case of the situation when we have a Riemannian metric on N , and so an inner product, h−, −iu , on each tangent space Tu N and when E = T M . If, as in the example, p is a submersion , i.e. its derivative Tu p : Tu N → Tp(u) M is onto for each u, we can take each Su to be the orthogonal complement in Tu of V Tu N . If p were not a submersion, no transversal subbundle S would exist. Such submersions are described in detail in Chapter 7 with examples. Here is another one: Example 1.4.2. Let N = SO(3) − {Id}, be the special orthogonal group of R3 with identity element removed. Let M = RP2 , real 2-dimensional projective space, considered as the space of lines through the origin in R3 or equivalently as the 2sphere with antipodal points identified. Define p : N → RP2 by taking p(u) to be the axis of rotation of u, i.e. the line determined by the eigenvector with eigenvalue 1. The fibre through any u ∈ N is a copy of the rotation group SO(2), that is, of S 1 , with the identity removed. In fact it is part of a one-parameter subgroup {etα : t ∈ R}, say, of SO(3) through u. Here α is an element of the Lie algebra so(3). We can take Su to be the left translate of the orthogonal complement of α in so(3), identified with TId SO(3), to u. It is identified under T p with the plane in R3 orthogonal to p(u), which is naturally identified with Tp(u) RP2 . For another class of examples see Example 2.1.6 below. Lemma 1.4.3. Every smooth 1-form on N can be written as a linear combination of sections of the form ψ + λp∗ (φ) for λ : N → R smooth, φ a 1-form on M , and ψ annihilates S. In particular any 1-form annihilating V T N is of the form λp∗ (φ). If E = T M , then ψ is uniquely determined. Proof. Take Riemannian metrics on M and N such that the isomorphism between S and p∗ (E) given by T p is isometric. Fix y0 ∈ N . Take a neighbourhood V of p(y0 ) in M over which E is trivializable. Let v 1 , v 2 , . . . , v p be a trivialising family of sections over V . Set U = p−1 (V ). If φj = (v j )∗ , the dual 1-form to v j , j = 1 to p, over V , then {p∗ (φj )# , j = 1 to p} gives a trivialization of S over U . [Indeed p∗ (φj )y (−) = φjp(y) (Ty p−) = h(Ty p)∗ (v j ), −i.] Since any vector field over V can therefore be written as one orthogonal to S plus a linear combination of the p∗ (φj )# , by duality the result holds for forms with support in U . The global result follows using a partition of unity. For the uniqueness note that if E = T M , then T N = V T N + S. By a lift of a diffusion operator A on M over p we mean a diffusion operator B on N such that B(f ◦ p) = (Af ) ◦ p (1.15) for all C 2 functions f on M . Proposition 1.4.4. Let A be T M . There is a unique lift transversal bundle S. Write
a diffusion operator on M along the subbundle E of of A to a smooth diffusion generator AS along the S ¯ δ = δ A . Then AS is determined by
1.4. Lifts of Diffusion Operators
9
¯ (i) δ(ψ) = 0 if ψ annihilates S. (ii) δ¯ (p∗ φ) = (δ A φ) ◦ p,
for φ ∈ Ω1 (M ).
Moreover (iii) for y ∈ N let hy : Ep(y) → Ty N be the right inverse of Ty p with image Sy . Then S
(a) σyA = hy σ A h∗y . (b) If A is given by A=
N 1 X ij a LX i LX j + LX 0 2 i,j=1
(1.16)
where X 1 , . . . , X N and X 0 are sections of E, then AS =
N 1 X ij (a ◦ p) LX¯ i LX¯ j + LX¯ 0 2 i,j=1
(1.17)
¯ j (y) = hy (X j (p(y)). for X Proof. Lemma 1.4.3 ensures that (i) and (ii) determine δ¯ uniquely as a smooth operator on smooth 1-forms if it exists. On the other hand we can represent A S as in (1.16) and define AS by (1.17). It is straightforward to check that then δ A satisfies (i) and (ii). 2
d Example 1.4.5. . In Example 1.4.1 above we can take A = dx 2 on M = R > 0, 2 then the lift to N = R − {0} along the given distribution in polar co-ordinates ∂2 2 we could use is ∂r 2 . On the other hand if we changed p to be given by p(u) = u 1 ∂2 the same distribution S but the lift would be changed to 2r ∂r2 .
Definition 1.4.6. When an operator B is along the vertical distribution ker[T p] we say B is vertical, and when there is a horizontal distribution such as {Hu : u ∈ N } as given by Proposition 2.1.2 below and B is along that horizontal distribution we say B is horizontal . Proposition 1.4.7. Let B be a smooth diffusion operator on N and p : N → M any smooth map, then the following conditions are equivalent: (1) The operator B is vertical. Pm ij (2) The operator B has an expression of the form of j=1 a LY i LY j + LY 0 ij j where a are smooth functions and Y are smooth sections of the vertical tangent bundle of T N . (3) B(f ◦ p) = 0 for all C 2 f : M → R.
10
Chapter 1. Diffusion Operators
Proof. (a). From (1) to (3) is trivial. From (3) to (1) note that every φ which vanishes on vertical vectors is a linear combination of elements of the form f p∗ (dg) for some smooth g : M → R by Lemma 1.4.3. To show that B is vertical we only need to show that δ B (f p∗ (dg)) = 0. But B(g ◦ p) = 0 implies δ B (p∗ (dg)) = 0 and also p∗ (dg)σ B (p∗ (dg)) = 12 B(g ◦ p)2 − (g ◦ p)B(g ◦ p) = 0. By semi-ellipticity of B, σ B (p∗ (dg)) = 0. Thus assertion (1) follows since δ B (f p∗ (dg)) = df σ B (p∗ (dg)) + f · δ B (p∗ (dg)) from Proposition 1.2.1(1), and so (1) and (3) are equivalent. Equivalence of (1) and (2) follows from Proposition 1.3.7. Remark 1.4.8. (1) If B is vertical, then by Proposition 1.2.1, for all C 2 functions f1 on N and f2 on M , B (f1 (f2 ◦ p)) = (f2 ◦ p)Bf1 ; (2) If B and B 0 are both over a diffusion operator A of constant nonzero rank such that A is along the image of σ A , then B − B 0 is not in general vertical, although (B − B 0 )(f ◦ p) = 0 for all C 2 function f : M → R, since it may not be semi-elliptic. For example take p : R2 → R to be the projection ∂2 ∂2 ∂2 ∂2 ∂2 ∂2 0 p(x, y) = x with A = ∂x 2 , B = ∂x2 + ∂y 2 . Let B = ∂x2 + ∂y 2 + ∂x∂y . Then 2
∂ is not vertical. In particular this shows B 0 is also over A but B − B 0 = − ∂x∂y that Proposition 1.4.7 would not hold without the assumption that B is a diffusion operator.
1.5
Notes
On symbols What we have called the symbol of our diffusion operator is often called the principal symbol. In the semi-elliptic case it is related to the energy density used in Dirichlet form theory mainly for symmetric diffusions, and is also given in terms of the carr´e du champ or squared gradient operator Γ as used, for example, in Bakry-Emery theory, [3], by σ L (df, dg) = Γ(f, g).
Chapter 2
Decomposition of Diffusion Operators Consider again a smooth map p : N → M between smooth manifolds M and N and a lift B of a diffusion operator A on M . Definition 2.0.1. In this situation we say that B is over A, or that A and B are intertwined by p. In general a diffusion operator B on N is said to be projectible (over p), or p-projectible, if it is over some diffusion operator A. Recall that the pull-back p∗ φ of a 1-form φ is defined by p∗ (φ)u = φp(u) (T p(−)) = (T p)∗ φp(u) . In local co-ordinates p∗ (φ)i =
X ∂pk k
∂xi
φk ◦ p.
For our map p : N → M , a diffusion operator B is over A if and only if δ B (p∗ φ)) = (δ A φ)(p),
(2.1)
for all φ ∈ C 1 ∧1 T ∗ M .
2.1
The Horizontal Lift Map
Lemma 2.1.1. Suppose that B is over A. Let σ B and σ A be respectively the symbols for B and A. Then A (Tu p)σuB (Tu p)∗ = σp(u) ,
∀u ∈ N,
(2.2)
K.D. Elworthy et al., The Geometry of Filtering, Frontiers in Mathematics, DOI 10.1007/978-3-0346-0176-4_2, © Springer Basel AG 2010
11
i.e. the following diagram is commutative:
12
Chapter 2. Decomposition of Diffusion Operators σuB
Tu∗ N 6 ∗ (Tu p)
- Tu N Tu p
∗ Tp(u) M
? - Tp(u) M .
A σp(u)
Proof. Let f and g be two smooth functions on M . Then for u ∈ N , x = p(u), 1 1 1 A(f g)(x) − (f Ag)(x) − (gAf )(x) 2 2 2 1 1 1 = B ((f g) ◦ p) (u) − f ◦ pB(g ◦ p)(u) − g ◦ pB(f ◦ p)(u) 2 2 2 B = d (g ◦ p)u σu (d (f ◦ p)u )
(dfx ) σxA (dgx ) =
= (dg ◦ Tu p) σuB (df ◦ Tu p) , which gives the desired equality.
For x in M , set Ex := Image[σxA ] ⊂ Tx M . If σ A has constant rank, i.e. dim[Ex ] is independent of x, then E := ∪x Ex is a smooth subbundle of T M . Proposition 2.1.2. Assume σ A has constant rank and B is over A. Then there is a unique, smooth, horizontal lift map hu : Ep(u) → Tu N , u ∈ N , characterised by A hu ◦ σp(u) = σuB (Tu p)∗ .
(2.3)
hu (v) = σuB ((Tu p)∗ α)
(2.4)
In particular where α ∈
∗ Tp(u) M
Tu∗ N
satisfies
A σp(u) (α)
σ
= v.
B
Tu N hu
(Tu p)∗
∗ M Tp(u)
Tu p σA
Tp(u) M
Proof. Clearly (2.4) implies (2.3) by Lemma 2.1.1 and so it suffices to prove hu is well defined by (2.4). For this we only need to show σ B ((Tu p)∗ (α)) = 0 for every A α in ker[σp(u) ]. Now σ A α = 0 implies that (T p)∗ (α)σ B ((T p)∗ α) = 0,
2.1. The Horizontal Lift Map
13
by Lemma 2.1.1. Considering σ B as a semi-definite bilinear form this implies σuB (Tu p)∗ α vanishes as required. Recall from Lemma 1.3.6 that the vertical distribution ker[T p] is regular. Let Hu = Image[hu ], the horizontal subspace at u, and H = tu Hu . Set Fu = (Tu p)−1 [Ep(u) ] so we have a splitting Fu = Hu + V Tu N
(2.5)
where V Tu N = ker[Tu P ] the ‘vertical’ tangent space at u to N .
Tu p
hu
Fu ⊂ Tu N
Eu ⊂ Tp(u) M In the elliptic case p is a submersion, the vertical tangent spaces have constant rank, and F := tu Fu is a smooth subbundle of T N . In this case we have a splitting of T N , a connection in the terminology of Kolar-Michor-Slovak [57]. In general we will define a semi-connection on E to be a subbundle Hu of T N such that Tu p maps each fibre Hu isomorphically to Ep(u) . In the equivariant case considered in Chapter 3 such objects are called E-connections by Gromov. For the case when p : N → M is the tangent bundle projection, or the orthonormal frame bundle, note that the “partial connections” as defined by Ge in [45] are rather different from the semi-connections we would have: they give parallel translations along E-horizontal paths which send vectors in E to vectors in E, and preserve the Riemannian metric of E, whereas the parallel transports of our semi-connections do not in general preserve the fibres of E, nor any Riemannian metric, and they act on all tangent vectors. Lemma 2.1.3. Assume σ A has constant rank and B is over A. For all u ∈ N the image of σuB is in Fu . Proof. Suppose α ∈ Tu∗ N with σB (α) 6∈ Fu . Then there exists k in the annihilator of Ep(u) such that k Tu p σ B (α) 6= 0. However A (k) k Tu p σ B (α) = α σ B ((Tu p)∗ (k)) = α hu σp(u) A ∗ by Proposition 2.1.2; while σp(u) (k) = 0 because for all β ∈ Tp(u) M, A A β σp(u) (k) = k σp(u) (β) = 0
giving a contradiction.
14
Chapter 2. Decomposition of Diffusion Operators
Proposition 2.1.4. Let A be a diffusion operator on M with σ A of constant rank. For i ∈ {1, 2}, let pi : N i → M be smooth maps and Bi be diffusion operators on N i over A. Let F : N 1 → N 2 be a smooth map with p2 ◦ F = p1 . Assume F intertwines B 1 and B 2 . Let h1 , h2 be the horizontal lift maps determined by A, B 1 and A, B 2 . Then u ∈ N 1; (2.6) h2F (u) = Tu F (h1u ), i.e. the diagram Tu F
Tu N 1 @ I @
- T 2 F (u) N
h1u @ @
h2F (u) @ Ep1 (u)
commutes for all u ∈ N . Proof. Since F intertwines B 1 and B 2 , Lemma 2.1.1 gives 2
1
σFB (u) = Tu F ◦ σuB ◦ (Tu F )∗ . Now take α ∈ Tp∗1 (u) M with σpA1 (u) (α) = v, some given v ∈ Ep1 (u) . From (2.4) 2
h2F (u) (v) = σFB (u) ((T p2 )∗ α) 1
= Tu F ◦ σuB ◦ (Tu F )∗ (T p2 )∗ α 1
= Tu F ◦ σuB (Tu p1 )∗ α = Tu h1u (v) as required.
Definition 2.1.5. A diffusion operator B on N will be said to have projectible symbol for p : N → M if there exists a map η : T ∗ M → T M such that for all u ∈ N the diagram Tu∗ N 6 ∗ (Tu p) ∗ Tp(u) M
commutes, i.e. if
(Tu p)σuB (Tu p)∗
σuB
- Tu N Tu p
ηp(u)
? - Tp(u) M .
depends only on p(u).
2.1. The Horizontal Lift Map
15
In this case we also get a uniquely defined horizontal lift map as in Proposition 2.1.4 defined by equation (2.6) using η instead of the symbol of A. This situation arises naturally in the standard non-linear filtering literature as described later, see Chapter 5. Example 2.1.6.
1. Consider N = R2 , M = R, with p(x, y) = x. Take B = a(x)
∂2 ∂2 ∂2 + c(x, y) + 2b(x, y) ∂x2 ∂x∂y ∂y 2
2
∂ 2 so A = a(x) ∂x 2 . For semi-ellipticity of B we require a(x)c(x, y) > b (x, y) and 2 a(x) > 0 for all (x, y) ∈ R . For the constant rank condition on A and nontriviality we will assume a(x) > 0 for all real x. Define γ(x, y) = b(x,y) a(x) . Then the horizontal lift map, or more precisely its principal part, hu : R → R2 at u = (x, y), is given by
h(x,y) (r) = (r, γ(x, y)r).
(2.7)
To check this satisfies the defining criterion equation (2.3) observe that with our definition, for r ∈ R, A A A hu ◦ σp(u) r = (σp(u) r, γ(u)σp(u) r)
(2.8)
= (a(x)r, b(x, y)r);
(2.9)
while σuB (Tu p)∗ r =
a(x) b(x, y)
b(x, y) c(x, y)
= (a(x)r, b(x, y)r).
r 0
(2.10) (2.11)
2. More generally take N = Rn × R, M = Rn , with p the projection. Now take n X
n
X ∂2 ∂2 ∂2 a (x) f+ bk (x, y) k f + c(x, y) 2 f (Bf )(x, y) = ∂xi ∂xj ∂x ∂y ∂y i,j=1 i,j
k=1
where a = (ai,j ) is a symmetric n×n-matrix-valued function, b = (b1 , . . . , bn ) takes values in Rn and c is real-valued. Then B lies over A for A=
n X i,j=1
ai,j (x)
∂2 . ∂xi ∂xj
For A to be semi-elliptic with symbol of constant rank we require a(x) to be positive semi-definite for all x ∈ M and to have constant rank. It is
16
Chapter 2. Decomposition of Diffusion Operators easy to see that, assuming this, B will be semi-elliptic if and only if for all ξ ∈ Rn we have hb(x, y)ξ, ξi2 6 c(x, y)ha(x)ξ, ξi (2.12) or equivalently, as matrices, b(x, y)t b(x, y) 6 c(x, y)a(x)
(2.13)
for all (x, y) ∈ N . For this to hold we see that b(x, y) must always lie in the image of a(x), otherwise there will be some ξ orthogonal to the image of a(x) for which hb(x, y)ξ, ξi2 > 0 contradicting condition (2.12). Moreover since a(x) is symmetric its kernel is orthogonal to its image, and so if v is in its image, ha(x)−1 b, vi is well defined. In fact it is simply the inner product hb, vix of v and b in the metric on E determined by A. In this notation the horizontal lift map h(x,y) : Ex → N × (Rn × R) is given by h(x,y) (v) = ((x, y), (v, hb, vix )).
(2.14)
3. More generally if A(x) is given by a positive definite matrix (m + p) × (m + p) matrix A of rank m, B(x, y) is an (m + p) × q matrix with B(x, y) in the image of A(x), and C(x, y) a q × q matrix. We have a horizontal lifting map u ∈ Image(A(x)) → (u, B T (x, y)A−1 (x)u). Example 2.1.7 (Coupling of diffusion operators). Consider diffusion operators A1 and A2 on manifolds M 1 and M 2 . Take N = M1 × M2 with p1 and p2 the corresponding projections. A diffusion operator B on N is a coupling of A1 with A2 if B and Aj are intertwined by pj for j = 1, 2. If so it is easy to see that there is a bilinear ΓB : T ∗ M 1 × T ∗ M 2 → R such that B(f ⊗ g)(x, y) = A1 (f )(x)g(y) + f (x)A2 (g)(y) + ΓB ((df )x , (dg)y )
(2.15)
where f ⊗ g : M 1 × M 2 → R denotes the map (x, y) 7→ f (x)g(y) and f, g are C 2 . Note that the symbol σ B : T ∗ M1 × T ∗ M2 → T M1 × T M2 is given by 1 2 1,2 2,1 B σ(x,y) (`1 , `2 ) = σxA (`1 ) + σ(x,y) (`2 ), σxA (`2 ) + σ(x,y) (`1 ) , `1 ∈ Tx∗ M1 , `2 ∈ Ty∗ M2
(2.16)
1,2 2,1 : Ty∗ M2 → Tx M1 and σ(x,y) : Tx∗ M1 → Ty M2 are defined by where σ(x,y) 1,2 (`2 ) = `1 σ(x,y)
1 B 2,1 Γ (`1 , `2 ) = `2 σ(x,y) (`1 ). 2 1
Now take A = A1 and p = p1 and assume σ A has constant rank.
2.2. Lifts of Cohesive Operators and The Decomposition Theorem
17
Lemma 2.1.8. For (x, y) ∈ M1 × M2 : 1,2 2,1 1. σ(x,y) = (σ(x,y) )∗ : Ty∗ M2 → Tx M1 , 1,2 2. σ(x,y) has image in Ex .
Proof. The first assertion is immediate from the definitions. For the second we use the semi-ellipticity of B with the argument in the proof of the existence of a horizontal lift, Proposition 2.1.2, to see that if ` ∈ ker σxA , then, for all y ∈ M2 2,1 we have σ B (T(x,y) p)∗ (`) = 0. This means that ` ∈ ker σ(x,y) . By the first part 1,2 ∗ ˜ = 0 for all `˜ ∈ T M2 . Thus ` ∈ ker σ A implies that ` this implies that `σ (`) (x,y)
y
x
1,2 annihilates the image of σ(x,y) . On the other hand since A is symmetric ` ∈ ker σxA if and only if ` annihilates Ex .
By the lemma we can use the Riemannian metric on E induced by the symbol 1,2 # 1,2 ) : Ex → Ty M2 of σ(x,y) . We claim that the of A to define the adjoint (σx,y) horizontal lift of the semi-connection induced by our coupling is given by 1,2 # ) (v) ∈ Tx M1 × Ty M2 v ∈ Ex . (2.17) h(x,y) (v) = v, (σx,y) To check this, first note that from Proposition 2.1.2 we know 2,1 ((σxA )−1 (v)) . h(x,y) (v) = v, σ(x,y) Next take `1 ∈ Tx∗ M1 and `2 ∈ Ty∗ M2 . Write σx for σ A considered as a map from Tx∗ M1 → Ex . Then our claim follows from: 1,2 1,2 `2 [(σ(x,y) )# σx (`1 )] = `1 σx∗ (`2 ◦ (σ(x,y) )# ) 1,2 = h`1 |Ex , `2 ◦ (σ(x,y) )# iEx∗ 2,1 = `2 σ(x,y) (`1 ).
2.2
Lifts of Cohesive Operators and The Decomposition Theorem
A diffusion generator L on a manifold is said to be cohesive if (i) σxL , x ∈ X, has constant non-zero rank and (ii) L is along the image of σ L . Remark 2.2.1. From Theorem 2.1.1 in Elworthy-LeJan-Li [36] we see that if the rank of σxL is bigger than 1 for all x, then L is cohesive if and only if it has a representation m 1X L jL j L= 2 j=1 X X
18
Chapter 2. Decomposition of Diffusion Operators
where Ex = span{X 1 (x), . . . X m (x)} has constant rank. Let H be the horizontal distribution of the semi-connection determined by a cohesive diffusion generator A. We can now define the horizontal lift of A to be the diffusion generator AH on N given by Proposition 1.4.4. The equivalence of (i) and (ii) in the following proposition shows that AH can be characterised independently of any semi-connection. Proposition 2.2.2. Let B be a smooth diffusion operator on N over A with A cohesive. The following are equivalent: (i) B = AH . (ii) B is cohesive and Tu p is injective on the image of σuB for all u ∈ N . (iii) B can be written as m
B=
1X L ˜ j L ˜ j + LX˜ 0 2 j=1 X X
˜ 0, . . . , X ˜ m are smooth vector fields on N lying over smooth vector where X 0 ˜ j (u)) = X j (p(u)) for u ∈ N for all j. fields X , . . . , X m on M , i.e. Tu p(X Pm Proof. If (i) holds, take smooth X 1 , . . . , X m with A = 12 j=1 LX j LX j + LX 0 , ˜ j (u) = hu X j (p(u)) to see (iii) holds. Clearly (iii) by Proposition 1.3.7, and set X implies (ii) and (ii) implies (i), so the three statements are equivalent. Definition 2.2.3. If condition (ii) of the proposition holds we say that B has no vertical part. Recall that if S is a distribution in T N , then S 0 denotes the set of annihilators of S in T ∗ N . Lemma 2.2.4. For ` ∈ Hu0 and k ∈ (Vu T N )0 , some u ∈ N we have: A. `σ B (k) = 0, H
B. σ B (k) = σ A (k), H
C. σ A (`) = 0. In particular Hu is the orthogonal complement of V Tu N ∩Image(σuB ) in Image(σuB ) with its inner product induced by σuB . Proof. Set x = p(u). For part A and part B it suffices to take k = φ ◦ Tu p some φ ∈ Tx∗ M . Then by (2.3), σuB (φ ◦ Tu p) = hu ◦ σxA (φ) giving part A, and also part B by Proposition 1.4.4 (iii)(a) since φ = h∗u (φ ◦ Tu p). Part C comes directly from Proposition 1.4.4 (iii)(a).
2.2. Lifts of Cohesive Operators and The Decomposition Theorem
19
Theorem 2.2.5. For B over A with A cohesive there is a unique decomposition B = B1 + BV where B 1 and B V are smooth diffusion generators with BV vertical and B 1 over A having no vertical part. In this decomposition B 1 = AH , the horizontal lift of A to H. Proof. Set B V = B − AH . To see that BV is semi-elliptic take u ∈ N and observe that any element of Tu∗ N can be written as ` + k where ` ∈ Hu0 and k ∈ (V Tu N )0 by Lemma 2.2.4 and (` + k)σ B (` + k) = `σ B (`) > 0. Since B V (f ◦ p) = 0 any f ∈ C 2 (M ; R), Proposition 1.4.7 implies B V is vertical. Uniqueness holds since the semi-connections determined by B and B0 are the same by Remark 1.3.4(i) applied to B V and so by Proposition 2.2.2 we must have B 1 = AH . Remark 2.2.6. For p a Riemannian submersion and B the Laplacian, BerardBergery and Bourguignon [9] define B V directly by B V f (u) = ∆Nx (f |Nx )(u) for x = p(u) and Nx = p−1 (x) with ∆Nx the Laplace-Beltrami operator of Nx . Definition 2.2.7. For a smooth p : N → M vector fields A˜ and A on N and M respectively are said to be p-related if ˜ = A(p(u)) for all u ∈ N. Tu p A(u) Remark 2.2.8. When A and B are given in H¨ormander forms using p-related vector fields, another decomposition of B is described in the Appendix, Section 9.5 Remark 9.5. Example 2.2.9. Returning to Example 2.1.6 for p : R2 → R the projection and B = a(x)
∂2 ∂2 ∂2 + c(x, y) 2 + 2b(x, y) 2 ∂x ∂x∂y ∂y
the decomposition is given by B = a(x)
∂ ∂ + h(x, y) ∂x ∂y
2 + d(x, y)
∂2 ∂y 2 2
b(x,y) where as in Example 2.1.6 h(x, y) = b(x,y) a(x) while d(x, y) = c(x, y) − a(x) . This follows from the fact that from Example 2.1.6 we know that the horizontal subspace at (x, y) is just (r, h(x, y)r) : r ∈ R . This means that the first term in our decomposition is horizontal (while clearly a lift of A); the second term is clearly vertical.
20
Chapter 2. Decomposition of Diffusion Operators
Example 2.2.10. Take N = S 1 × S 1 and M = S 1 with p the projection on the first factor. Let 1 ∂2 ∂2 ∂2 B= . + 2 ) + tan α 2 2 ∂x ∂y ∂x∂y Here 0 < α < BV =
π 4
so that B is elliptic. Then A =
1 ∂2 (1 − (tan α)2 ) 2 , 2 ∂y
AH =
1 ∂2 2 ∂x2 ,
∂2 1 ∂2 ∂2 ( 2 + (tan α)2 2 ) + tan α . 2 ∂x ∂y ∂x∂y
This is easily checked since, with this definition AH has H¨ormander form AH =
∂ 1 ∂ ( + tan α )2 2 ∂x ∂y
and so is a diffusion operator which has no vertical part. Also B V is clearly vertical and elliptic. Note that this is another example of a Riemannian submersion: several more of a similar type can be found in [9]. In this case the horizontal distribution is integrable and if α is irrational the foliation it determines has dense leaves. Example 2.2.11. Take N = H, the first Heisenberg group with Heisenberg group action as in Example 1.3.3, 1 (x, y, z) · (x0 , y 0 , z 0 ) = x + x0 , y + y 0 , z + z 0 + (xy 0 − yx0 ) . 2 As before let X, Y, Z be the left-invariant vector fields which give the standard basis for R3 at the origin so that as operators: ∂ 1 ∂ ∂ 1 ∂ − y , Y (x, y, z) = + x , ∂x 2 ∂z ∂y 2 ∂z ∂ Z(x, y, z) = . ∂z Take B to be half the sum of the squares of X, Y , and Z. This is half the left invariant Laplacian: 1 ∂2 ∂2 ∂2 1 2 ∂2 ∂2 2 −y ) . + 2 + (1 + (x + y )) 2 + (x B= 2 ∂x2 ∂y 4 ∂z ∂y∂z ∂x∂z X(x, y, z) =
Take M = R2 and p : R3 → R2 to be the projection on the first 2 coordinates. Then the horizontal lift map, induced by (A, B), from R2 to H is 1 h(x,y,z) : (u, v) 7→ (u, v, (xv − yu)) 2 and 1 ∂2 ∂2 ( 2 + 2 ), 2 ∂x ∂y 1 1 ∂2 = Z2 = . 2 2 ∂z 2
A= BV
AH =
1 2 (X + Y 2 ), 2
2.2. Lifts of Cohesive Operators and The Decomposition Theorem
21
The decomposition of the operator is just the completion of squares. This leads back to the canonical left-invariant horizontal vector fields: ∂2 1 2 ∂2 ∂2 2 (x + + (1 + + y )) ∂x2 ∂y 2 4 ∂z 2 2 2 ∂ ∂ −y ) + (x ∂z∂y ∂z∂x ∂ y ∂ 2 x ∂ 2 ∂ ∂2 − ) +( + ) + 2. =( ∂x 2 ∂z ∂y 2 ∂z ∂z
2B =
This philosophy we maintain throughout the book. Note that the horizontal lift σ ˜ , of a smooth curve σ : [0, T ] → M with σ(0) = 0, is given by Z 1 t 1 1 2 2 2 1 σ ˜ (t) = σ (t), σ (t), (2.18) σ (t)dσ (t) − σ (t)dσ (t) . 2 0 Thus the “vertical” component of the horizontal lift is the area integral of the curve. Equation (2.18) remains valid for the horizontal lift of Brownian motion on R2 , or more generally for any continuous semi-martingale, provided it is interpreted as a Stratonovich equation ( or equivalently an Itˆo equation in the Brownian motion case). This example is also that of a Riemannian submersion. In this case the horizontal distributions are not integrable. Indeed the Lie brackets satisfy [X, Y ] = Z and H¨ ormander’s condition for hypoellipticity: a diffusion operator L satisfies H¨ormander’s condition if for some (and hence all) H¨ormander form representation such as in equation (1.14) the vector fields Y 1 , . . . , Y m together with their iterated Lie brackets span the tangent space at each point of the manifold. For an enjoyable discussion of the Heisenberg group and the relevance of this example to “Dido’s problem” see [79]. See also [5],[11], and [49]. Example 2.2.12. For nontrivial connections on the Heisenberg group discussed ∂2 ∂2 above, consider A = 12 ( ∂x 2 + ∂y 2 ) as before, and for real-valued functions r1 , r2 , γ with γ > r12 + r22 , Br1 ,r2 =
∂2 ∂2 1 ∂2 1 ∂2 ∂2 ( 2 + 2 ) + r1 + r2 + γ 2 . 2 ∂x ∂y ∂x∂z ∂y∂z 2 ∂ z
The horizontal lift map is: h(x,y,z) (u, v) = (u, v, r1 u + r2 v), X1 := hu (
∂ ∂ ∂ )=( + r1 ), ∂x ∂x ∂z
and Br1 ,r2 =
X2 := hu (
∂ ∂ ∂ )=( + r2 ) ∂y ∂y ∂z
1 2 1 ∂2 (X1 + X22 ) + (γ − r12 − r22 ) 2 . 2 2 ∂ z
22
Chapter 2. Decomposition of Diffusion Operators
Example 2.2.13. Consider N = R3 × R3 with coordinates u = (v1 , v2 , v3 ; w1 , w2 , w3 )(u). Take M = R3 and p(u) = (v1 , v2 , w3 ). On N , for a fixed α ∈ R, consider the operator 3 X 1 ∂2 ∂ ∂ 1 2 2 ∂2 ∂ 2 B= + α (vi+1 + vi+2 ) 2 + α(vi − vi+1 ) , 2 ∂vi2 2 ∂wi ∂vi+1 ∂vi ∂wi+2 1 where the suffixes are to be taken modulo 3. It projects by p on the operator A=
1 ∂2 ∂ ∂ ∂2 1 ∂2 ∂ ( 2 + 2 ) + α2 (v12 + v22 ) 2 + α(v1 − v2 ) . 2 ∂v1 ∂v2 2 ∂w3 ∂v2 ∂v1 ∂w3
Note that B =
1 2
P3 1
Xi =
Xi2 and A = 12 (Y12 + Y22 ) with ∂ ∂ ∂ + α(vi+2 − vi+1 ) ∂vi ∂wi+1 ∂wi+2
and ∂ ∂ − αv2 , ∂v1 ∂w3 ∂ ∂ + αv1 . Y2 = ∂v2 ∂w3
Y1 =
(2.19) (2.20)
The horizontal lift is determined by the identities: AH = 12 (X12 + X22 ), B V = 12 X32 and YiH = Xi , i = 1, 2. Note that N is a group with multiplication given by u·u0 = u00 , with vi (u00 ) = vi (u) + vi (u0 ) and wi+2 (u00 ) = wi+2 (u) + α(vi (u)vi+1 (u0 ) − vi+1 (u)vi (u0 )), and p is a homomorphism of N onto the Heisenberg group. The diffusion generators B and A are invariant under left multiplication. Recall that F ≡ tu Fu = ∪u (Tu p)−1 [Ep(u) ], we can now strengthen Lemma 2.1.3 which states that Image[σuB ] ⊂ Fu . Corollary 2.2.14. If B is over A with A cohesive, then B is along F . Proof. Since Hu ∈ Fu and V Tu N ⊂ Fu both B 1 and B V are along F .
2.3. The Lift Map for SDEs and Decomposition of Noise
2.3
23
The Lift Map for SDEs and Decomposition of Noise
Let us consider the horizontal lift connection in more detail when B and A are given by stochastic differential equations. For this write A and B in H¨ormander ˜ X(x) ˜ ∗ for form corresponding to factorisations σxA = X(x)X(x)∗ and σxB = X(x) X(x) : Rm → Tx M,
x ∈ M,
˜ ˜ → Tu N, X(u) : Rm
u ∈ N.
Then X(x) maps onto Ex for each x ∈ M . Define Yx : Ex → Rm to be its right i−1 h . inverse: Yx = Y (x) = X(x) ker X(x)⊥ ˜ such that Lemma 2.3.1. For each u ∈ N there is a unique linear `u : Rm → Rm ker `u = ker X(p(u)) and the diagram
˜ ∗ X(u)
Tu∗ N
-
6 (Tu p)∗
Tx∗ M
˜ Rm 6
˜ X(u) -Tu N
Tu p
`u
-
? -Tx M
Rm
X(x)∗
X(x)
˜ ◦ `u . commutes, for x = p(u), i.e. σxA = Tu p ◦ σxB (Tu p)∗ and X(x) = Tu p ◦ X(u) ˜ In particular the horizontal lift map is given by hu = X(u)`u Y (p(u)). Proof. The larger square commutes by Lemma 2.1.1. For the rest we need to construct `u . It suffices to define `u on [ker X(x)]⊥ . Note that [ker X(x)]⊥ = Image X(x)∗ in Rm . We only have to show that α ∈ ker X(x)∗ implies ˜ ∗ (Tu p)∗ α = 0. X(u) In fact for such α the proof in Proposition 2.1.2 is valid and therefore (Tu p)∗ α ∈ ˜ ˜ ∗ we see ker σ B = is injective on the image of X(u) ker σuB . However since X(u) u . ˜ ker X(u) . Thus `u is defined with ker `u = ker X(x) and such that the left-hand square of the diagram commutes. Since the perimeter commutes it is easy to see from the construction of `u that the right-hand side also commutes. The uniqueness of `u with kernel equal to that of X(x) is therefore clear since, on [ker X(x)]⊥ , we ˜ ∗ (Tu p)∗ for any α ∈ T ∗ M with X(x)∗ α = e. require `u (e) to be X(u) x From now on assume that X(x) has rank independent of x ∈ M . This ensures that `u is smooth in u ∈ N . Also assume that A(x) ∈ Ex for all x ∈ M , i.e. that A is cohesive. This is needed when we wish to consider the horizontal lift AH of A.
24
Chapter 2. Decomposition of Diffusion Operators
The horizontal lift of X(x), which can be used to construct a H¨ormander form representation of AH , as in Theorem 2.2.5 and Theorem 3.2.1 below is given by: X H (u) : Rm → Tu P, ˜ X H (u) = hu X(u) = X(u)` u since Yx X(x) is the projection onto ker X(x)⊥ . Now for x ∈ M let K(x) be the orthogonal projection of Rm onto the kernel of X(x)and K ⊥ (x) the projection onto [ker X(x)]⊥ , so K ⊥ (x) = Y (x)X(x).
(2.21)
˜ and X are p-related, i.e. Consider the special case that m ˜ = m and also that X ˜ Tu p(X(u)e) = X(p(u))e,
u ∈ N, e ∈ Rm .
Then `u = Y (p(u))X(p(u)) = K ⊥ (p(u)) giving ˜ hu = X(u)Y (p(u)) :
(Tu N )∗
Tu N
X˜ (u ∗ )
(Tu p)∗
˜ (u) X Rm
∗
X
(2.22)
)) (p(u
Tu p
X (p
(u)) Tp(u) M
(Tp(u) M )∗ `u = K ⊥ (p(u))
2.3.1
Decomposition of Stratonovich SDE’s
Suppose we have an SDE on N : ˜ t ) ◦ dBt + A(u ˜ t ) dt dut = X(u
(2.23)
˜ is as above and p-related to X on M while the vector field A˜ is p-related where X to a vector field A on M . Thus if xt = p(ut ) we have dxt = X(xt ) ◦ dBt + A(xt ) dt.
(2.24)
2.3. The Lift Map for SDEs and Decomposition of Noise
25
Then we can decompose our SDE for ut by: ˜ t )K ⊥ (p(ut )) ◦ dBt + A(u ˜ t ) dt + X(u ˜ t )K(p(ut )) ◦ dBt dut = X(u ˜ t )K(p(ut )) ◦ dBt + A(u ˜ t ) − AH (ut ) dt = X H (ut ) ◦ dBt + AH (ut ) dt + X(u ˜ t )K(p(ut )) ◦ dBt + A(u ˜ t ) − AH (ut ) dt. = hut ◦ dxt + X(u We shall come back to such decompositions in Sections 4.8, 5.4, and 8.2.
2.3.2
Decomposition of the noise and Itˆ o SDE’s
The decomposition of our SDE on N described above is closely related to the decomposition of the noise of an SDE into essential and redundant components. This was first described in [38] with a more general discussion in [36]. The latter allowed for infinite dimensional noise and incomplete SDE. Here we will review the situation for our SDE (2.24) assuming it is complete, and X has constant rank with A(x) ∈ Ex for all x ∈ M . The projections K and K ⊥ determine metric connections on the subbundles ker X and ker⊥ X of the trivial bundle Rm . Writing Rm − = ker X ⊕ ker⊥ X we have the direct sum connection on Rm . Let //˜t ∈ O(m) for t > 0, be the corresponding parallel translation along the sample paths of the solution to our SDE (2.24) starting at a given point x0 of M . Then //˜t [ker X(x0 )] = ker X(xt )] and //˜t [ker⊥ X(x0 )] = ker⊥ X(xt ). Define processes {Bte }t > 0 and {βt }t > 0 by Z t −1 //˜s K(xs ) dBs Bte = (2.25) 0 Z t −1 //˜s K ⊥ (xs ) dBs . βt = (2.26) 0
Then: 1. {Bte }t > 0 and {βt }t > 0 are independent Brownian motions, on ker⊥ X(x0 ) and ker X(x0 ) respectively; 2. The filtration of {Bte }t > 0 is the same as that of {xt }t > 0 ; 3. dBt = //˜t dBte + //˜t dβt . ˜. , the The process β. is the redundant noise and B e , sometimes denoted by B relevant or essential noise. Suppose now that M = Rn and N = Rk , and that we have an Itˆo SDE ˜ t ) dBt + A(u ˜ t ) dt dut = X(u on Rk whose solutions are such that if xt := p(ut ) for t > 0, then dxt = X(xt ) dBt + A(xt ) dt
(2.27)
26
Chapter 2. Decomposition of Diffusion Operators
˜ Then from above we have: where X is p-related to X. ˜ t )//˜t dB e + A(u ˜ t ) dt + X(u ˜ t )//˜t dβt dut = X(u t = X H (ut ) dBt + AH (ut ) dt ˜ t )//˜t dβt . ˜ t ) − AH (ut ) dt + X(u + A(u However note that the solutions to dzt = X H (zt ) dBt + AH (zt ) dt will not in general be horizontal lifts of solutions to equation (2.27) and unless p is linear will not in general be lifts.
2.4
Diffusion Operators with Projectible Symbols
Given p : N → M as before, suppose now that we have a diffusion operator B on M with a projectible symbol, c.f. Definition 2.1.5. This means that σ B lies over some positive semi-definite linear map η : T ∗ M → T M . Assume that η has constant rank. We will show that in this case we also have a decomposition of B. To do this first choose some cohesive diffusion operator A on M with σ A = η. In general there is no canonical way to do this, though if η were non-degenerate we could choose A to be a multiple of the Laplace-Beltrami operator of the induced metric on M . From above we also have an induced semi-connection with horizontal subbundle H, say, of T N . Definition 2.4.1. We will say that B descends cohesively (over p) if it has a projectible symbol inducing a constant rank η : T ∗ M → T M , and there exists a horizontal vector field, bH , such that B − LbH is projectible over p. The following is a useful observation. Its proof is immediate. Proposition 2.4.2. If B descends cohesively, then for each choice of A satisfying A σp(u) = Tu pσuB (Tu p)∗ there is a horizontal vector field bH such that B − LbH lies over A. Lemma 2.4.3. Assume that η has constant rank. If f is a function on M let f˜ = f ◦ p. For any choice of A with symbol η the map ]) f 7→ B(f˜) − A(f is a derivation from C ∞ M to C ∞ N where any f ∈ C ∞ M acts on C ∞ N by multiplication by f˜.
2.4. Diffusion Operators with Projectible Symbols
27
Proof. The map is clearly linear and for smooth f, g : M → R we have ^ g) η(df, dg) = σ B (df˜, d˜ so by definition of symbols: ^ ])˜ ] f˜ B(f˜g˜) − A(f g) = B(f˜)˜ g + B(˜ g )f˜ − A(f g − A(g) as required.
Let D denote the space of derivations from C ∞ M to C ∞ N using the above action. Note that for p∗ T M → N the pull-back of T M over p, the space C ∞ Γp∗ T M of smooth sections of p∗ T M can be considered as the space of smooth functions V : N → T M with V (u) ∈ Tp(u) M for all u ∈ N . We can then define Θ : C ∞ Γp∗ T M → D by Θ(V )(f )(u) = dfp(u) (V (u)). Lemma 2.4.4. Assume that η has constant rank. The map Θ : C ∞ Γp∗ T M → D is a linear bijection. Proof. Let d ∈ D. Fix u ∈ N . The map from C ∞ M to R given by f 7→ df (u) is a derivation at p(u); here the action of any f ∈ C ∞ M on R is multiplication by f (p(u)), and so corresponds to a tangent vector, V (u) say, in Tp(u) M . Then df (u) = dfp(u) (V (u)). By assumption df (u) is smooth in u, and so by suitable choices of f we see that V is smooth. Thus Θ(V ) = d and Θ has an inverse. From these lemmas we see there exists b ∈ C ∞ Γp∗ T M with the property that f (u) = dfp(u) b(u) (2.28) B f˜ − Af for all u ∈ N and f ∈ C ∞ M . Assume that b has its image in the subbundle E of T M determined by η. Using the horizontal lift map h determined by B, define a vector field bH on N : bH (u) = hu b(u) . Proposition 2.4.5. Assume that η has constant rank and that b has its image in the subbundle E determined by η. The vector field bH is such that B − bH is over A, and so B descends cohesively. Proof. For f ∈ C ∞ M , f + df (b(−)) − df ◦ T p(bH (−)) = Af f (B − bH )(f˜) = Af using the fact that T p bH (−) = b(−). We can now extend the decomposition theorem:
28
Chapter 2. Decomposition of Diffusion Operators
Theorem 2.4.6. Let B be a diffusion operator on N which descends cohesively over p : N → M . Then B has a unique decomposition: B = BH + BV into the sum of diffusion operators such that (i) BV is vertical, (ii) B H is cohesive and Tu p is injective on the image of σuB
H
for all u ∈ N .
With respect to the induced semi-connection B H is horizontal. Proof. Using the notation of the previous proposition we know that B − bH is over a cohesive diffusion operator A. By Theorem 2.2.5 we have a canonical decomposition B − bH = B1 + B V , leading to B = (bH + B 1 ) + B V . If we set B H = bH + B 1 we have a decomposition as required. On the other hand if we have two such decompositions of B we get two decompositions of B − bH . Both components of the latter must agree by the uniqueness in Theorem 2.2.5, and so we obtain uniqueness in our situation. Extending Definition 2.2.3 we could say that a diffusion operator B H satisfying condition (ii) in the theorem has no vertical part. Note that if we drop the hypothesis that bH is horizontal, or equivalently that b in Proposition 2.4.5 has its image in E, we still get a decomposition by taking an arbitrary lift of b to be bH but we will no longer have uniqueness.
2.5
Horizontal lifts of paths and completeness of semi-connections
A semi-connection on p : N → M over a subbundle E of T M gives a procedure for horizontally lifting paths on M to paths on N as for ordinary connections but now we require the original path to have derivatives in E; such paths may be called E-horizontal. Definition 2.5.1. A Lipschitz path σ ˜ in N is said to be a horizontal lift of a path σ in M if • p◦σ ˜ = σ, • the derivative of σ ˜ almost surely takes values in the horizontal subbundle H of T N .
2.5. Horizontal lifts of paths and completeness of semi-connections
N
•
σ ˜ (t)
•
σ ˜ (t)
29
σ ˜ (t) •
σ(t)
M
Note that a Lipschitz path σ : [a, b] → M with σ(t) ˙ ∈ Eσ(t) for almost all a 6 t 6 b has at most one horizontal lift from any starting point ua in p−1 (σ(a)). To see this first note that any such lift must satisfy σ ˜˙ (t) = hσ˜ (t) σ(t). ˙
(2.29)
This equation can be extended to give an ordinary differential equation on all of N . For example take a smooth embedding j : M → Rm into some Euclidean space. Set β(t) = j(σ(t)). Let X(x) : Rm → Ex be the adjoint of the restriction of the derivative Tx j of j to Ex , using some Riemannian metric on E. Then σ satisfies the differential equation ˙ x(t) ˙ = X(x(t))(β(t))
(2.30)
and it is easy to see that the horizontal lifts of σ are precisely the solutions of ˙ u(t) ˙ = hu(t) X(p(u(t)))(β(t)) starting from points above σ(a) and lasting until time b. In the generality in which we are working there may not be any such solutions, for example because of “holes” in N . We define the semi-connection to be complete if every Lipschitz path σ with derivatives in E almost surely has a horizontal lift starting from any point above the starting point of σ. Note that completeness is assured if the fibres of N are compact, or if an X, with values in E, and β, can be found so that σ is a solution to equation (2.30) and there is a complete metric on N for which the horizontal lift of X is bounded on the inverse image of σ under p. In particular the latter will hold if p is a principal bundle and we have an equivariant semi-connection as in the next chapter. It will also hold if there is a complete metric on N for which the horizontal lift map hu ∈ L(Ep(u) ; Tu N ) is uniformly bounded for u in the image of σ.
30
2.6
Chapter 2. Decomposition of Diffusion Operators
Topological Implications
Although our set-up of intertwining diffusions with a cohesive A seems quite general it implies strong topological restrictions if the manifolds are compact and more general. Here we partially extend the approach Hermann used for Riemannian submersions in [51] with a more detailed discussion in Chapter 6 below. For this let D0 (x) be the set of points z ∈ M which can be reached by Lipschitz curves σ : [0, t] → M with σ(0) = x and σ(t) = z with derivative in E almost surely. Its closure D0 (x) relates to the propagation set for the maximum principle for A, and to the support of the A- diffusion as in Stroock-Varadhan [95], see Taira [99]. Theorem 2.6.1. For B and A as before with A cohesive, take x0 ∈ M and z ∈ D0 (x0 ). Assume the induced semi-connection is complete. Then if p−1 (x0 ) is a submanifold of N so is p−1 (z) and they are diffeomorphic. Also if z is a regular value of p so is x. Proof. Let σ : [0, T ] → M be a Lipschitz E-horizontal path from x to z. There is a smooth factorisation σxA = X(x)X(x)∗ for X(x) ∈ L(Rm ; Tx M ), x ∈ M . Take ˜ : Rm → T N of X. the horizontal lift X By the completeness hypothesis the time dependent ODE on N , −1 dys ˜ s )X σ(s)|[ker X(x )]⊥ = X(y (σ(s)) ˙ 0 ds will have solutions from each point above σ(0) defined up to time T and so a flow giving the required diffeomorphism of fibres. Moreover, by the usual lower semi-continuity property of the “explosion time”, this holonomy flow gives a diffeomorphism of a neighbourhood of p−1 (x) in N with a neighbourhood of the fibre above z. The diffeomorphism commutes with p. Thus if one of x and z is a regular value so is the other. Corollary 2.6.2. Assume the conditions of the theorem and that E satisfies the standard H¨ ormander condition that the Lie algebra of vector fields generated by sections of E spans each tangent space Ty M after evaluation at y. Then p is a submersion all of whose fibres are diffeomorphic. Proof. The H¨ormander condition implies that D0 (x) = M for all x ∈ M by Chow’s theorem (e.g. see Sussmann [98] or [49]. In [49] Gromov shows that under this condition any two points of M can be joined by a smooth E-horizontal curve. Corollary 2.6.3. Assume the conditions of the theorem and that D0 (x) is dense in M for all x ∈ M and p : N → M is proper. Then p is a locally trivial bundle over M. Proof. Take x ∈ M . The set Reg(p) of regular values of p is open by our properness assumption. It is also non-empty, even dense in M , by Sard’s theorem, and so since D0 (x) is dense, there exists a regular value z which is in D0 (x). It follows from the
2.7. Notes
31
theorem that x ∈ Reg(p), and so p is a submersion. However it is a well-known consequence of the inverse function theorem that a proper submersion is a locally trivial bundle. Note that we only need Reg(p) to be open, rather than p proper, to ensure that p is a submersion. The density of D0 (x) can hold because of global behaviour, for example if M is a torus and E is tangent to the foliation given by an irrational flow.
2.7
Notes
Intertwined stochastic differential equations Consider p-related stochastic differential equations as in Section 2.3.1: ˜ t ) ◦ dBt + A(u ˜ t ) dt, dut = X(u dxt = X(xt ) ◦ dBt + A(xt ) dt. Then not only are their generators B and A interwined but also the operators B ∧ and A∧ , which they induce on differential forms, and their semigroups P˜.∧ and P.∧ : and P˜ ∧ ◦ p∗ = p∗ ◦ P ∧ . B ∧ ◦ p∗ = p∗ ◦ A∧ Recall that the pull-back f ∗ φ of a differential form φ by a differentiable map f : N → M is given by f ∗ φ(v 1 , . . . , v k ) = φf (u) (Tu f (v 1 ), . . . , Tu f (v k )) for v 1 , . . . , v k in Tu N when φ is a k-form on M . The operators are given by the same formulae as for functions: m
A∧ =
1X L j L j + LA , 2 j=1 X X
(2.31)
where now the Lie derivatives are acting on forms. Thus, for example, LA φ =
d (ηtA )∗ φ |t=0 dt
(2.32)
where η.A denotes the flow of the vector field A. The semi-groups are given by: Pt∧ φ = E(ξt )∗ φ
(2.33)
when the integrals exist, with modifications if the flow is only locally defined. There is a detailed discussion in [36]. That the operators are intertwined is clear from equation (2.32) and the fact that the flows of the vector fields involved are intertwined by p. Similarly the intertwining of the semi-groups comes from the fact that the flows of the SDE’s are intertwined.
32
Chapter 2. Decomposition of Diffusion Operators
In fact there is the stronger result, following in the same way, that the “codifferentials” δˆ and δˆ determined by the two SDE’s are intertwined. These take k-forms to (k − 1)-forms and are defined by: δˆ = −
m X
ιX j LX j
(2.34)
j=1
where ι denotes interior product. It is shown in [36], page 37, that A∧ = −
1 ˆ δd + dδˆ + LA 2
where d is the usual exterior derivative. There is further discussion about this and its relationships with the more classical results in [71], [105], [106], and [48] in the Notes to Chapter 7, and the Appendix, Section 9.5.2.
Chapter 3
Equivariant Diffusions on Principal Bundles Let M be a smooth finite dimensional manifold and P (M, G) a principal fibre bundle over M with structure group G a Lie group. Denote by π : P → M the projection and Ra right translation by a. Consider on P a diffusion generator B, which is equivariant, i.e. for all f ∈ C 2 (P ; R), Bf ◦ Ra = B(f ◦ Ra ),
a ∈ G. a
Set f a (u) = f (ua). Then the above equality can be written as Bf a = (Bf ) . The operator B induces an operator A on the base manifold M . Set Af (x) = B (f ◦ π) (u),
u ∈ π −1 (x), f ∈ C 2 (M ),
(3.1)
which is well defined since a
B (f ◦ π) (u · a) = B ((f ◦ π) ) (u) = B ((f ◦ π)) (u). Example 3.0.1. One of the simplest examples is obtained from the map p : SO(n+ 1) → S n defined by choosing some point x0 on S n , considering the natural action of SO(n + 1) on the sphere by rotation, and setting p(u) = u.x0 for u ∈ SO(n + 1). This has the natural structure of a principal bundle with group SO(n) when we identify SO(n) with the subgroup of SO(n + 1) which fixes x0 . If we take the bi-invariant Riemannian metric on SO(n + 1) determined by the Hilbert-Schmidt inner product hA, BiH S := trace(B ∗ A) on the Lie algebra so(n + 1), identified with the space of skew-symmetric (n + 1) × (n + 1)-matrices, the projection√ p is a Riemannian submersion, see Chapter 7 below, but onto the sphere of radius 2. It therefore sends the Laplacian of SO(3), which is bi-invariant under the full group √ SO(3), onto the Laplacian of S n ( 2).
K.D. Elworthy et al., The Geometry of Filtering, Frontiers in Mathematics, DOI 10.1007/978-3-0346-0176-4_3, © Springer Basel AG 2010
33
34
Chapter 3. Equivariant Diffusions on Principal Bundles
n+1 be the elementary (n + 1) × (n + 1)- matrix with entries which Let E[p,q] are all zero except for that in the p-th row and q-th column which is 1. Set √1 (E n+1 − E n+1 ). Then {An+1 }1 6 p
√ If we want A to be the usual Laplacian for S n , rather than for S n ( 2), we can modify the metric of SO(3) to be 12 times that given by the Hilbert-Schmidt norm. Denoting the resulting Laplacian by B we then have X 1 2A∗[p,q] 2A∗[p,q] . B= 2 1 6 p
3.1
Invariant Semi-connections on Principal Bundles
Definition 3.1.1. Let E be a subbundle of T M and π : P → M a principal Gbundle. An invariant semi-connection over E, or principal semi-connection in the terminology of Michor, on π : P → M is a smooth subbundle H E T P of T P such that (i) Tu π maps the fibres H E Tu P bijectively onto Eπ(u) for all u ∈ P . (ii) H E T P is G-invariant. Notes. 1. Such a semi-connection determines and is determined by, a smooth horizontal lift: hu : Eπ(u) → Tu P such that (i) Tu π ◦ hu (v) = v, for all v ∈ Ex ⊂ Tx M ; (ii) hu·a = Tu Ra ◦ hu . 2. The action of G on P induces a homomorphism of the Lie algebra g of G with the algebra of left invariant vector fields on P : if A ∈ g, d ∗ u exp(tA), u ∈ P, A (u) = dt t=0 and A∗ is called the fundamental vector field corresponding to A. Note that for a ∈ G: (3.2) A∗ (ua) = ad(a)A∗ (u)
3.1. Invariant Semi-connections on Principal Bundles
35
for ad(a) : g → g the adjoint action of a. Using the splitting (2.5) of Fu our semi-connection determines, (and is determined by), a ‘semi-connection one-form’ $ ∈ L(H + V T P ; g) which vanishes on H has $(A∗ (u)) = A, and $ua T Ra (V ) = ad(a−1 )$u (V )
V ∈ Hu + V Tu P.
(3.3)
3. Let F be an associated vector bundle to P with fibre V . An E-semi-connection on P gives a covariant derivative ∇w Z ∈ Fx for w ∈ Ex , x ∈ M where Z is a section of F . This is defined, as usual for connections, by ˜ u (w)) , ∇w Z = u d(Z)(h u ∈ π −1 (x). Here Z˜ : P → V is ˜ Z(u) = u−1 Z (π(u)) considering u as an isomorphism u : V → Fπ(u) . This agrees with the ‘semiconnections on E’ defined in Elworthy-LeJan-Li, [36], when P is taken to be the linear frame bundle of T M and F = T M . Such semi-connections could be called ‘linear semi-connections’ since they arise from a principal semiconnection via a linear representation, but since we will only deal with such connections when the vector bundle structure is being used we shall usually take as read the qualification ‘linear’. Theorem 3.1.2. Assume σ A has constant rank. Then σ B gives rise to an invariant semi-connection on the principal bundle P whose horizontal map is given by (2.4). Proof. It has been shown that hu is well defined by (2.4). Next we show hu defines a semi-connection. As noted earlier, h defines a semi-connection if (i) Tu π◦hu (v) = v, v ∈ Ex ⊂ Tx M and (ii) hu·a = Tu Ra ◦ hu . The first is immediate by Lemma ∗ 2.1.1 and for the second observe π ◦ Ra = π. So T π ◦ T Ra = T π and (T π) = ∗ ∗ (T Ra ) · (T π) while the following diagram
Tu∗ P
σuB
- Tu P
6 (Tu Ra )∗
∗ Tu·a P
Tu Ra
B σu·a
? Tua P
36
Chapter 3. Equivariant Diffusions on Principal Bundles
commutes by equivariance of B. Therefore ∗
Tu Ra ◦ hu = Tu Ra · σuB (Tu π) ◦ σxA
−1
∗
∗
= Tu Ra · σuB ◦ (Tu Ra ) ◦ (Tu·a π) ◦ σxA −1 ∗ B = σu·a ◦ (Tu·a π) ◦ σxA = hu·a .
−1
Curvature forms and holonomy groups etc for semi-connections are defined analogously to those associated two connections, we note the following: Proposition 3.1.3. In the situation of Proposition 2.1.4, suppose A is elliptic, p1 , p2 are principal bundles with groups G1 and G2 respectively, and F is a homomorphism of principal bundles with corresponding homomorphism f : G1 → G2 . Let Γ1 and Γ2 be the semi-connections on N 1 , N 2 determined by B 1 and B 2 . Then: (i) Γ2 is the unique semi-connection on p2 : N 2 → M such that T F maps the horizontal subspaces of T N 1 into those of T N 2 . (ii) If ω j , Ωj are the semi-connection and curvature form of Γj , for j = 1, 2, then F ∗ (ω 2 ) = f∗ ◦ ω 1 and F ∗ (Ω2 ) = f∗ ◦ Ω1 for f∗ : g 1 → g 2 the homomorphism of Lie algebras induced by f . (iii) Moreover f : G1 → G2 maps the Γ1 holonomy group at u ∈ N 1 onto the Γ2 holonomy group at F (u) for each u ∈ N 1 and similarly for the restricted holonomy groups. Proof. Proposition 2.1.4 assures us that T F maps horizontal to horizontal. Uniqueness together with (ii), (iii) come as in Kobayashi-Nomizu [56] (Proposition 6.1 on p79).
3.2
Decompositions of Equivariant Operators
Take a basis A1 , . . . , An of g with corresponding fields {A∗i }. P k fundamental vector k Write the semi-connection 1-form as $ = $ Ak so that $ are real-valued, partially defined, 1-forms on P . In our equivariant situation we can give a more detailed description of the decomposition in Theorem 2.2.5. Theorem 3.2.1. Let B be an equivariant operator on P and A be the induced operator on the base manifold. Assume that A is cohesive and let B = AH + B V be theX decomposition ofX Theorem 2.2.5. Then B V has a unique expression of the ij form α LA∗i LA∗j + β k LA∗k , where αij and β k are smooth functions on P ,
3.2. Decompositions of Equivariant Operators
37
given by αk` = $k σ B ($` ) , and β ` = δ B ($` ) for $ the semi-connection 1-form on P . Define α : P → g ⊗ g and β : P → g by X X α(u) = αij (u)Ai ⊗ Aj , β(u) = β k (u)Ak . (3.4) These are independent of the choices of basis of g and are equivariant: α(ug) = (ad(g) ⊗ ad(g)) α(u) and β(ug) = ad(g)β(u). Proof. Since every vertical vector field is a linear combination of the fundamental vertical vector fields, Proposition 1.4.7, shows that X X αi,j LA∗i LA∗j + β k LA∗k BV = H
for certain functions αij , β k . For f, g : P → R setting σ := σ B−A , 1 X i,j 1 X i,j α LA∗i LA∗j (f g) − gα LA∗i LA∗j (f ) 2 2 1 X i,j f α LA∗i LA∗j (g) − 2 X = αi,j LA∗i (f )LA∗j (g) X = αi,j df (Ai ∗ )dg(Aj ∗ ).
df (σ(dg)) =
Since $(A∗k ) = Ak , we see that $k (A∗` ) = δk` and $k (σ($` )) =
X
αi,j δik δj` = αk` .
H
Since AH is horizontal σ A has its image in the horizontal tangent bundle and so is annihilated by $k . Thus (3.5) αk` = $k σ B ($` ) . Note that by the characterisation, Proposition 1.2.1, X X V δB = αi,j LAi ∗ ιAj ∗ + β k ιA k ∗ . V
H
Since $` (A∗ ` ) is identically 1, it follows that δ B ($) = β ` . Again δ A ($` ) = 0 and so (3.6) β ` = δ B ($` ) as required.
38
Chapter 3. Equivariant Diffusions on Principal Bundles
For the last part α and β can be considered as obtained from the extension of the symbol σ B and δ B to g-valued two- and one-forms respectively: α = $(−)σ B $(−) and β = δ B ($(−)). To make this precise consider σuB as a bilinear form and so as a linear map σuB : Tu∗ P ⊗ Tu∗ P → R. The extension is the trivial one given by σuB ⊗ 1 ⊗ 1 : Tu∗ P ⊗ Tu∗ P ⊗ g ⊗ g → R ⊗ g ⊗ g ' g ⊗ g using the identification of Tu∗ P ⊗ g with L(Tu P ; g). Similarly the extension of δ B is δuB ⊗ 1 : Tu∗ P ⊗ g → R ⊗ g ' g. Thus α(u)(ω ⊗ ω) = σ B ⊗ 1 ⊗ 1 (P23 ω ⊗ ω) where P23 : T ∗ P ⊗ g ⊗ T ∗ P ⊗ g → T ∗ P ⊗ T ∗ P ⊗ g ⊗ g is the standard permutation and βu (ω) = (δuB ⊗ 1)(ω). The equivariance of $, (Rg )∗ $ = ad(g −1 )($),
g ∈ G,
is equivalent to the invariance of $ when considered as a section of T ∗ M ⊗g under T Rg ⊗ ad(g) : T ∗ M ⊗ g → T ∗ M ⊗ g,
g ∈ G. P Remark 3.2.2. (a) For any equivariant operator of the form B = i,j αij LA∗i LA∗j P k + β LA∗k with (αij (u)) positive semi-definite for each u ∈ P we can define maps α and β by (3.4). Note that α(u) is essentially the symbol of B restricted to the fibre Pπ(u) through u: σuB |Pπ(u) : Tu∗ Pπ(u) → Tu Pπ(u) with $u identifying Tu Pπ(u) with g. Similarly β determines δ B on a basis of sections of (V T P )∗ . (b) Let {ut : 0 6 t D6 ζ} be a B-diffusion on PE. By (3.5), 2αkl (ut ) is the derivative R· k R· $us ◦ dus , 0 $ul s ◦ dus of the integrals of ω k and ω l along of the bracket 0 {ut : 0 6 t < ζ}. See Chapter 4 below for a detailed discussion. Thus α(ut ) is the derivative of the tensor quadratic variation: Z 1 d t $ut ◦ dut ⊗ $ut ◦ dut . α(ut ) = 2 dt 0 Rt Moreover by (3.6) and Lemma 4.1.2 below 0 β(us )ds is the bounded variaRt tion part of 0 $us ◦ dus .
3.2. Decompositions of Equivariant Operators
39
(c) If we fix u0 ∈ P and take an inner product on g we can diagonalise α(u0 ) to write X µn An ⊗ An α(u0 ) = n
where {An : n = 1, . . . dim(g)} is an orthonormal basis. The µn are the eigenvalues of α(u0 )# : g → g obtained using the isomorphism: g ⊗ g → L(g; g) a ⊗ b 7→ (a ⊗ b)# , where (a ⊗ b)# (v) = hb, via. P Note that for g ∈ G, α(u0 · g) = n µn ad(g)An ⊗ ad(g)An . When the dim(g) inner product is ad(G)-invariant, then {ad(g)An }n=1 is still orthonormal # and the {µn }n are the eigenvalues of α(u0 · g) . They are therefore independent of the choice of u0 in a given fibre, (but depend on the inner product chosen). Example 3.2.3. Using the notation of Example 2.2.11, let P be the special orthonormal frame bundle of the two-dimensional horizontal distribution of the Heisenberg group H, whose fibre at (x, y, z) ∈ H are orthogonal frames with values in E = span{X, Y }. Note that E, and so P , is trivialised by the left action of H and using this we shall consider P as the product H × SO(2) with projection (x, y, z, A) 7→ (x, y, z). The actual frames are compositions of the rotation A on (u, v) and the map (u, v) 7→ (u, v, 12 (xu − yv)). Identifying SO(2) with the circle S 1 the bundle P becomes a principal bundle with group S 1 acting on the right to be written as: π : H × S 1 → H. Then the Lie algebra g = s1 , which we shall identify with the imaginary axis iR. The tangent space to S 1 at a general point eiθ of S 1 will then be represented by {ieiθ a : a ∈ R} ⊂ C. An invariant semi-connection on P may be defined by its semi-connection 1form $, which here will be a section of the dual bundle to the bundle E × T S 1 → H × S 1 , but with values in iR. In our situation this corresponds to a horizontal vector field V0 = v1 X + v2 Y . (As a vector potential determines the connection in the gauge-theoretic interpretation of electromagnetism.) The vector field defines such an $ given on E × T S 1 by $(x,y,z,eiθ ) (w, a) = e−iθ a + ihw, V0 (x, y, z)iE . The horizontal subspace HT P for this connection is given at (x, y, z, eiθ ) by: H(x,y,z,eiθ ) T P = {(w, a) : e−iθ a + ihw, V0 (x, y, z)iE = 0}. Consider a path σ on H3 with σ˙ ∈ E. Denote its horizontal lift starting at (σ(0), 1) by σ ˜ (t) = (σ(t), eiθ(t) ), some θ(t). Then ˙ + ihV0 (σ(t)), σ(t)i. 0 = $(σ ˜˙ t ) = iθ(t) ˙
40
Chapter 3. Equivariant Diffusions on Principal Bundles
giving σ ˜ (t) = (σ(t), e−i
Rt 0
hV (σs ),σ(s)ids ˙
).
Note that an E-semi-connection on the principal bundle E allows one to covariantly diffferentiate sections of E in E-directions; see Note 3 at the beginning of Section 3.1. The covariant derivative of such a section U is given by ˆ w U = ∇L ∇ w U + ihV0 (x, y, z), wiE U (x, y, z),
w ∈ E(x,y,z)
(3.7)
where ∇L refers to the left invariant connection on our Lie group H and we are treating E as a complex line bundle via its trivialisation. In fact this shows that our semi-connection on E is the restriction of an Esemi-connection on the full tangent bundle T H of H since ∇L is defined on all C 1 vector fields on H and E ⊂ H so the right-hand side of the formula (3.7) is defined as an element of T H for all C 1 vector fields on H and w ∈ E. As for standard connections, semi-connections are determined by suitable covariant differentiation operators. Next consider A = 12 (X 2 + Y 2 ) and for real-valued functions r1 , r2 , γ on H with γ > r12 + r22 set B=
∂2 ∂2 ∂2 ∂r1 ∂r2 ∂ o ∂2 1n 2 (X +Y 2 )+r1 +r2 +γ 2 +(xr2 −r1 y) +( + ) . 2 ∂x∂θ ∂y∂θ ∂ θ ∂z∂θ ∂x ∂y ∂θ
∂ Now we are treating θ 7→ eiθ as giving charts for S 1 and ∂θ refers to the use of ∂ these local co-ordinates. Thus ∂θ corresponds to the tangent vector whose value at eiθ is ieiθ in our representation in C. We shall find the vector field V0 corresponding to the semi-connection induced by B. If we complete the squares for B, recalling ∂ ∂ ∂ ∂ − 12 y ∂z and ∂y + 12 x ∂z respectively, we obtain: that X and Y are given by ∂x 1 ˜ 2 ˜ 2 1 1 ∂r2 ∂r1 ∂ ∂2 B= X +Y + (γ − r12 − r22 ) 2 − (x −y ) (3.8) 2 2 ∂ θ 2 ∂z ∂z ∂θ
˜ = X + r1 ∂ and Y˜ = Y + r2 ∂ . As vector fields on H × S 1 this gives where X ∂θ ∂θ ˜ = (X, ir1 e−iθ ) and Y˜ = (Y, ir2 eiθ ). X ˜ 2 + Y˜ 2 ) is cohesive and Tu π is injective on the image of its symbol, Now 12 (X which is {(a, b, i(ar1 + br2 )eiθ ) : a, b, ∈ R} ⊂ E(x,y,z) × Teiθ S 1 at u = (x, y, z, eiθ ), ˜ 2 + Y˜ 2 ) is the lift of A. The second and so, by Proposition 2.2.2, we see 21 (X term in equation (3.8) is clearly vertical hence (3.8) is the decomposition for the semi-connection determined by (A, B), using Theorem 2.4.6. That is: 2 1 ∂r2 ∂r1 ∂ 1 ˜2 ˜2 1 H V 2 2 ∂ A = (X + Y ) and B = (γ − r1 − r2 ) 2 − (x −y ) . 2 2 ∂ θ 2 ∂z ∂z ∂θ ˜ := hu (X), Y˜ := (hu Y ) and the horizontal lift map is: We see that X 1 1 h(x,y,z,eiθ ) (a, b, (xb − ya)) = (a, b, (xb − ya), i(r1 a + r2 b)eiθ ). 2 2
3.3. Derivative Flows and Adjoint Connections
41
This horizontal lifting map is determined by the vector field V0 := −r1 X − r2 Y . In particular a couple of choices of r1 and r2 give some interesting semi-connections. Letting r1 = −y, r2 = x, we have ∂2 ∂2 1n 2 ∂2 ∂2 o (X + Y 2 ) − y +x + γ 2 + (x2 + y 2 ) B1 := 2 ∂x∂θ ∂y∂θ ∂ θ ∂z∂θ which determines the semi- connection 1 1 (a, b, (xb − ya)) 7→ (a, b, (xb − ya), i(−ya + xb)eiθ )). 2 2 Taking r1 = x, r2 = y, we have ∂2 ∂2 ∂ o 1n 2 ∂2 (X + Y 2 ) + x +y +γ 2 +2 B2 = 2 ∂x∂θ ∂y∂θ ∂ θ ∂θ with semi-connection (a, b, 12 (xb − ya)) 7→ (a, b, 12 (xb − ya), i(xa + yb)eiθ ). We return to this example in Example 3.4.3 below.
3.3
Derivative Flows and Adjoint Connections
Let A on M be given in H¨ ormander form m
A=
1X L j L j + LA 2 j=1 X X
(3.9)
for some smooth vector fields X 1 , . . . X m , A. As before let Ex be the linear span of {X 1 (x), . . . , X m (x)} and assume dim Ex is constant, denoted by p, giving a subbundle E ⊂ T M . The vector fields {X 1 (x), . . . , X m (x)} determine a vector bundle map X : Rm → T M with σ A = X(x)X(x)∗ . We can, and will, consider X as a map X : Rm → E. Let Yx be the right inverse [X(x)|ker X(x)⊥ ]−1 of X(x) and h, ix the inner product, induced on Ex by ˘ on E Yx . Then X projects the flat connection on Rm to a metric connection ∇ defined by ˘ v U = X(x)d[y 7→ Yy U (y)](v), ∇
U ∈ C 1 ΓE, v ∈ Ty M.
(3.10)
(In [36] we have studied the properties of this construction together with the SDE ˘ is referred as the LW connection for the SDE; see also induced by X, and there ∇ Section 9.5.2 in the Appendix.) Moreover any connection ∇ on a subbundle E of T M has an adjoint semi-connection ∇0 on T M over E defined by ∇0U V = ∇V U + [U, V ],
U ∈ ΓE, V ∈ ΓT M.
42
Chapter 3. Equivariant Diffusions on Principal Bundles
Remark 3.3.1. Note the converse of this is not true. In the discussion of Example 3.2.3 we noted shortly after equation (3.7) that our construction determined a semi-connection over E on the the whole tangent bundle. This could not be the adjoint of any connection on E because brackets of E-valued vector fields are not E-valued in general. In fact it is noted in [36] that parallel translation using the adjoint of a connection on a subbundle E of a tangent bundle can only preserve E if E is integrable. Let π : GLM → M be the frame bundle of M , so u ∈ π −1 (x) is a linear isomorphism u : Rn → Tx M . It is a principal bundle with group GL(n). If g ∈ GL(n) and π(u) = x, then u · g : Rn → Tx M is just the composition of u with g. Any smooth vector field A on M determines smooth vector fields AT M and GL on T M and GLM respectively as follows: Let ηt : t ∈ (−, ) be a (partial) A flow for A and T ηt its derivative. Then v 7→ T ηt (v) is a partial flow on T M and u 7→ T ηt ◦ u one on GLM , Let AT M and AGL be the vector fields generating these flows. In fact AT M is τ ◦ T A : T M → T T M where τ : T T M → T T M is the canonical twisting map: τ (x, v, w, v 0 ) = (x, v, v 0 , w) in local coordinates. Using this, the choice of our H¨ ormander form representation induces a diffusion operator B on GLM by setting B=
1X L(X j )GL L(X j )GL + LAGL . 2
This is invariant under the action of GL(n)and π intertwines B and A. For cohesive A, a principal semi-connection is therefore induced on GLM . In turn this induces a semi-connection on T M with covariant derivative ∇, say, as described in Note 3 of Section 3.1. We will also use ∇ to denote these semi-conections. For w ∈ Ex , set Z w (y) = X(y)Yx (w). Theorem 3.3.2. Assume the diffusion operator A given by (3.9) is cohesive and let B be the operator on GLM determined by A. Let E be the image of σ A , a vector bundle. ˘ given by (3.10). (a) The semi-connection ∇ induced by B is the adjoint of ∇ Consequently ∇w V = LZ w V for any vector field V and w ∈ Ex , (b) For u ∈ GLM , identifying gl(n) with L(Rn ; Rn ), 1 X −1 ˘ u(−) X p ⊗ u−1 (−)∇ ˘ u(−) X p , u (−)∇ 2 1 −1 ˘ # 1 X −1 ˘ p ˘ u(−) A. u ∇∇ β(u) = − Ric u(−) + u−1 ∇ ˘ u(−) X p X − u 2 2
α(u) =
3.3. Derivative Flows and Adjoint Connections
43
˘ considered as an operator ˘ # : T M → E is the Ricci curvature of ∇ Here Ric from T M to E, defined by ˘ # (v) = Ric
m X
˘ v, X j (x) X j (x) R
j=1
˘ the curvature operator of ∇. ˘ for R Proof. The first part can be deduced from the stochastic flow results in Chapter 8 but we give a direct proof here. Let πte be the flow of X(·)(e). It induces a linear ˜ map X(u) : Rm → Tu GLM on the general linear bundle GLM : ˜ X(·)e = [X(·)(e)]GL , d ˜ X(u)(e) = (T Ste ◦ u)|t=0 , dt
u ∈ GLM.
˜ m = Rm and so `u = Y (p(u))X(p(u)). If We can apply Lemma 2.3.1 with R x = p(u) and e ⊥ ker[X(x)], then the horizontal lift map hu defined by Theorem 3.1.2 is d ˜ (T πte ◦ u) . (3.11) hu (X(x)(e)) = X(u) (`u (e)) = dt t=0 Note this will not hold in general if e ∈ ker[X(x)]. ˙ ∈ Eσ(t) each t. Then Let σ : [0, T ] → M be a C 1 curve with σ(t) ˙ Z σ(t) (x) := X(x)Yσ(t) σ(t). ˙ σ ˙ Let Ss,t be the flow, from time s to time t, of the time dependent vector field Z σ(t) . σ Now Ss,t (σ(s)) = σ(t) for 0 6 s 6 t 6 T . Also, for any torsion free connection and any v ∈ Tσ(s) M , D σ ˙ σ ˙ T Ss,t (v) = ∇Z σ(t) (v) |t=s = ∇v Z σ(s) . T Ss,t dt t=s
Thus
D σ(t) ˙ σ Z T S σ (v) = ∇T S0,t . dt 0,t If $ is the connection form of this torsion free connection, then −1 D D σ σ T S0,t T S σ (u0 (e))] $ ◦ u0 = [e 7→ T S0,t ◦ u0 dt dt 0,t −1 σ σ(t) ˙ σ u (e) Z ◦ u0 ∇T S0,t ] = [e 7→ T S0,t 0 σ ◦u (σ(t)) ˙ = $ hT S0,t 0
44
Chapter 3. Equivariant Diffusions on Principal Bundles
d σ σ ◦u (σ(t)) ◦ u0 and hT S0,t T S0,t by (3.11), showing that the vertical parts of dt 0 ˙ equal. On the other hand, using this auxiliary connection, the horizontal parts of d σ σ ◦u (σ(t)) ◦ u ˙ are both equal to the horizontal lift of σ(t). ˙ T S and hT S0,t 0 0,t 0 dt Thus d σ σ ◦u (σ(t)) T S0,t ◦ u0 = hT S0,t ˙ 0 dt σ ◦ u0 : 0 6 t 6 T } is the horizontal lift of {σ(t) : 0 6 t 6 T } and so {T S0,t with respect to the semi-connection induced by B. However by Lemma 1.3.4 in σ σ (v) of S0,t is the parallel translation of v along σ by Elworthy-LeJan-Li [36], T S0,t ˆ the adjoint semi-connection ∇ of the LeJan-Watanabe connection on E associated σ to X and {T S0,t ◦ u0 : 0 6 t 6 T } is the horizontal lift of {σ(t) : 0 6 t 6 T } with ˆ This proves the first claim. And ∇w V = LZ w V by Lemma 1.3.4 of respect to ∇. Elworthy-LeJan-Li [36]. For the last part let $ : H ⊕ V T GLM → g = L(Rn ; Rn ) be the semiconnection 1-form. For u0 ∈ GLM , set ut = T ξt ◦ u0 where {ξt } is a local flow for the stochastic differential equation dxt = X(xt ) ◦ dBt + A(xt )dt
(3.12)
on M where {Bt } is a Brownian motion on Rm . (This defines the derivative flow on GLM .) As for ordinary connections $(◦dut ) = u−1 t
ˆ D (ut −) ∈ L(Rn ; Rn ). dt
Here, on the right-hand side ut is differentiated as a process of linear maps ut ∈ L(Rn ; Txt M ) over (xt ). [It suffices to check the equality for C 1 curves (ut ) with ˜t · gt for x ˜t a xt = π(ut ) having x˙ t ∈ Ext , t > 0. For this we can write ut = x ˆ −1 d D ˜t dt (˜ xt ut −).] horizontal lift of {xt } and gt ∈ G. Then observe that dt (ut −) = x However as in [36], u−1 t
ˆ D −1 ˘ ˘ (ut −) = u−1 t ∇ut − X ◦ dBt + ut ∇ut − Adt. dt
From this the formula for α(u) follows by Remark 3.2.2(b). For β(u) we need Rt to identify the bounded variation part of 0 $(◦dut ). For this write −1 −1 ˆ ˆ −1 ∇ ˘ ˘ T ξ ◦u X ◦ dBt u−1 t ∇ut − X ◦ dBt = u0 Tx0 ξt //t ◦ //t t 0
where //ˆt is the parallel translation along {ξs (x0 ) : 0 6 s 6 t} using our semi˘ by Theorem 3.3.2. As in [36] connection, which is the adjoint of ∇ −1 −1 −1 ˘ T ξ ◦u X ◦ dBt = //ˆt ∇ ˘ T ξ u XdBt − 1 //ˆt Ric# (T ξt ◦ u0 −)dt //ˆt ∇ t 0 t 0 2
3.3. Derivative Flows and Adjoint Connections
45
while −1 ˆ u−1 0 T ξt //t
=
u−1 0
Z − 0
t −1 ˘ u−1 ˆ −X 0 T ξs ∇// s
Z ◦ dBs − 0
t −1 ˘ u−1 ˆ − Ads 0 T ξs ∇//
giving the formula claimed for β.
s
Example: Gradient Brownian SDE An isometric immersion j : M → Rm of a Riemannian manifold M determines a stochastic differential equation on M : dxt = X(xt ) ◦ dBt where X(x) : Rm → Tx M is the orthogonal projection and B. is a Brownian motion on Rm . More precisely X(x)(e) = ∇[y 7→ hj(y), i](x). It is well known that the solutions of the SDE are Brownian motions on M , see [30], [92], [31], and the equation is often called a “gradient Brownian SDE” . Moreover the LW connection given by equation (3.10) is the Levi-Civita connection, (by the classical construction of the latter), see [36]. Since the adjoint of the LeviCivita connection is itself, Theorem 3.3.2, shows that our connection induced on GLM by the derivative flow of a gradient Brownian system is also the Levi-Civita connection. Almost by definition, h∇v X p , wiRm = ha(v, w), ep iRm
(3.13)
where a : T M × T M → Rm is the second fundamental form of the immersion with v ∈ Tx M, x ∈ M, e ∈ Rm (3.14) ∇v X(e) = A(v, nx e) for nx : Rm → Tx M ⊥ the projection and A : T M ⊕ T M ⊥ → T M the shape operator given by hA(v, e), wiRm = ha(v, w), ep iRm . Here T M ⊥ refers to the normal bundle of M and Tx M ⊥ to the normal space at x to M , though we are considering its elements as being in the ambient space Rm . Thus the vertical operator in the decomposition of the generator of the derivative flow on GLM for gradient flows is given by Theorem 3.3.2 with m−n 1 X −1 u A(u−, lj ) ⊗ u−1 A(u−, lj ), α(u) = 2 j=1
β(u) = −
m−n 1 X 1 A(A(u−, lj ), lj ) − u−1 Ric# (u−) 2 j=1 2
46
Chapter 3. Equivariant Diffusions on Principal Bundles
at a frame u over a point x. Here l1 , . . . , lm−n denotes an orthonormal base for Tx M ⊥ . For the standard embedding of S n in Rn+1 we have a(u, v) = hu, vix for u, v ∈ Tx S n . Also the Ricci curvature is given by Ric# (v) = (n − 1)v for all v ∈ T M . Thus for the standard gradient SDE on S n , at any frame u we have 1 Id ⊗ Id 2 1 β(u) = − n Id. 2
α(u) =
3.4
(3.15) (3.16)
Associated Vector Bundles and Generalised Weitzenb¨ ock Formulae
As before let π : P → M be a smooth principal G-bundle and ρ : G → L(V ; V ) a C ∞ representation of G on some separable Banach space V . There is then the (possibly weakly) associated vector bundle π ρ : F → M where F = P × V / ∼ for the equivalence relation given by (u, e) ∼ (ug, ρ(g −1 )e) for u ∈ P , e ∈ V , g ∈ G. If [(u, e)] ∈ F denotes the equivalence class of (u, e) we can identify any u ∈ P with a linear isomorphism ¯ : V → Fπ(u) u by ¯ (e) = [(u, e)]. u
(3.17)
Consider the set of smooth maps from P to V which are equivariant by ρ: Mρ (P ; V ) = {smooth Z : P → V, Z(ug) = ρ(g)−1 Z(u), u ∈ P, g ∈ G}. There is the standard bijective correspondence Fρ between Mρ (P, V ) and Γ(F ), the space of smooth sections of F defined by ¯ [Z(u)], Fρ (Z)(x) = u
u ∈ π −1 (x), Z ∈ Mρ (P ; V ).
Via this map, an equivariant diffusion generator B on P induces a differential operator B ρ ≡ Fρ (B) on Γ(F ), of order at most 2, by Fρ (B)(Fρ (Z)) = Fρ [B(Z)],
Z ∈ Mρ (P ; V ).
(3.18)
Here B has been extended trivially to act on V -valued functions. Note that the definition makes sense since, B(Z)(ug) = B (Z ◦ Rg ) (u) = B ρ(g)−1 Z (u) = ρ(g)−1 B(Z)(u).
3.4. Associated Vector Bundles and Generalised Weitzenb¨ock Formulae
47
For such a representation ρ let ρ∗ : g → L(V ; V ) be the induced representation of the Lie algebra g (the derivative of ρ at the identity). Theorem 3.4.1. When B is a vertical equivariant diffusion generator the induced operator on sections of any associated vector bundle is a zero-order operator. With the notation of Theorem 3.2.1, the zero-order operator in Γ(F ) induced by B is represented by λρ : P → L(V ; V ) for λρ (u) = ρ∗ (β(u)) + Comp (ρ∗ ⊗ ρ∗ )(α(u)) ,
u∈P
(3.19)
for Comp : L(V ; V ) ⊗ L(V ; V ) → L(V ; V ) the composition map A ⊗ B 7→ AB. Proof. The operator B ρ is a zero-order operator if F ρ (B)(S)(x0 ) = F ρ (B)(S 0 ) whenever two sections S and S 0 of F agree at x0 . This holds if B(f Z) = f B(Z) for any invariant function f : P → R and V -valued function Z on P . But this holds by Remark 1.4.8. For the representation (3.19), suppose Z : P → V is equivariant: Z(u ◦ g) = ρ(g)−1 Z(u),
g ∈ G.
Then d Z(u · eAj t ))|t=0 dt d ρ(e−Aj t )Z(u)|t=0 = dt = −ρ∗ (Aj )Z(u).
LA∗j (Z)(u) =
Iterating we have B(Z)(u) = proving (3.19).
X
αij (u)ρ∗ (Aj )ρ∗ (Ai )Z(u) +
X
βk ρ∗ (Ak )Z(u)
From this theorem we easily have the following estimate, which combined with the discussion in Section 3.5 below, when applied to the associated bundle ∧F to the orthonormal bundle, shows that the Weitzenb¨ock curvature is positive if the curvature is. Corollary 3.4.2. If ρ is an orthogonal representation, i.e. (ρ∗ (α))∗ = −ρ∗ (α) for all α ∈ g, then λρ (v, v) 6 0 for all v ∈ V .
48
Chapter 3. Equivariant Diffusions on Principal Bundles
Proof. Write α = v ∈ F,
P
k
µk Ak ⊗ Ak where {Ak } is as in Remark 3.2.2(c). Then for
X hComp ◦(ρ∗ ⊗ ρ∗ )(α(u))(v), vi = h µk [ρ∗ Ak ]2 (v), vi X =− µk hρ∗ (Ak )(v), ρ∗ (Ak )(v)i 6 0, since µk > 0. The result follows from (3.19) since ρ∗ (β(u)) is skew symmetric. The situation of Corollary 3.4.2 arises when considering the derivative flow for an SDE on a Riemannian manifold whose flow consists of isometries ; for example canonical SDE’s on symmetric spaces as in Section 7.2 below and [36]. Example 3.4.3. We use the notation in Example 3.2.3. Let P be the special orthonormal frame bundle for E over the Heisenberg group H, with group S 1 . We 1 use the left action of the Heisenberg group to trivialise it to H × S . Denote by cos t − sin t 1 2 2 1 it ρ : S → L(R ; R ) the representation of S given by ρ(e ) = . sin t cos t ∗ Let s = s1 X + s2 Y be a section of Γ(E), identified as s1 + is2 . Let ρ (s) be the induced equivariant map from P → R2 : ρ∗ (s)(p, eiθ ) = e−iθ s(p),
p ∈ H.
Define (B ρ s)(p) = eiθ B(ρ∗ (s))(p, eiθ ). As in Example 3.2.3 take B=
∂2 ∂2 ∂2 ∂r1 ∂r2 ∂ o ∂2 1n 2 (X +Y 2 )+r1 +r2 +γ 2 +(xr2 −r1 y) +( + ) , 2 ∂x∂θ ∂y∂θ ∂ θ ∂z∂θ ∂x ∂y ∂θ
and recall that then H
A
1 ˜2 ˜2 1 = (X + Y ) and B V = 2 2
2 1 ∂r2 ∂r1 ∂ 2 2 ∂ (γ − r1 − r2 ) 2 − (x −y ) , ∂ θ 2 ∂z ∂z ∂θ
with semi-connection determined, as in Example 3.2.3, by the E-valued vector field V0 given by V0 (x, y, z) = −r1 X − r2 Y. From this B ρ = (B V )ρ + (AH )ρ with ∂r1 ∗ 1 1 ∂r2 −y )ρ (s)(p, eiθ ) B V (ρ∗ (s))(p, eiθ ) = − (γ − r12 − r22 )ρ∗ (s)(p, eiθ ) + i (x 2 4 ∂z ∂z and so ∂r1 1 1 ∂r2 −y )s(p). (B V )ρ (s)(p) = − (γ − r12 − r22 )s(p) + i (x 2 4 ∂z ∂z
(3.20)
3.4. Associated Vector Bundles and Generalised Weitzenb¨ock Formulae
49
We leave as an exercise the computation which verifies that 1 ˆ −∇ ˆ − (s) trace ∇ 2 1 L 2 4L s + i traceh∇L = − V0 , −iE + 2i∇V0 s − |V0 | s , 2
(AH )ρ (s) =
(3.21) (3.22)
recalling from Example 3.2.3 that the covariant derivative of our connection is given by ˆ w U = ∇L ∇ w U + ihV0 (x, y, z), wiE U (x, y, z),
w ∈ E(x,y,z)
L in terms of the left-invariant covariant derivative. Also 4L denotes trace ∇L − ∇− . Let us relate this to Theorem 3.4.1. Let 0 1 1 ρ∗ : t ∈ s → t −1 0
be the induced representation on the Lie algebra of S 1 . Consider B V , the vertical part of B. Now in the notation of Theorem 3.2.1 α1,1 (u) = 12 (γ − r12 − r22 ), and ∂r1 2 β(u) = 14 (x ∂r ∂z − y ∂z ) and hence ∂r1 1 1 ∂r2 0 0 1 0 1 (γ − r12 − r22 ) −y ) + (x −1 −1 0 −1 0 2 4 ∂z ∂z ∂r1 1 ∂r2 1 −y ) = − (γ − r12 − r22 ) + i (x 2 4 ∂z ∂z
λρ (u) =
1 0
which is indeed the multiplication operator appearing in formula (3.20) for (BV )ρ . We use the following conventions, as in [36]. Let V be an N -dimensional real inner product space. For 1 6 i 6 n, a1 ∧ · · · ∧ an =
ιv (u1 ∧ · · · ∧ uq ) =
1 X sgn (π)aπ(1) ⊗ · · · ⊗ aπ(n) , n! π
q X (−1)j+1 hv, uj iu1 ∧ · · · ∧ ubj ∧ · · · ∧ uq
(3.23)
j=1
h⊗ai , ⊗bi i = n!Πi hai , bi i, and h∧ai , ∧bi i = det(hai , bj i). Let ∧V stand for the exterior algebra of V and a∗j the “creation operator”on ∧V given by a∗j v = ej ∧v for (e1 , . . . , eN ) an orthonormal basis for ∧V . Let aj be its adjoint, the “annihilation operator” given by aj = ıej . Note the commutation law: ai a∗j + a∗j ai = δij .
(3.24)
50
Chapter 3. Equivariant Diffusions on Principal Bundles
If A : V → V is a linear map on V , there are the operators ∧A and (dΛ)(A) on ∧V , which restricted to ∧p V are: p
(dΛ )(A) (u1 ∧ · · · ∧ up ) =
p X
u1 ∧ · · · ∧ uj−1 ∧ Auj ∧ uj+1 ∧ · · · ∧ up ,
1
and also (∧p A)(u1 ∧ · · · ∧ up ) = Au1 ∧ · · · ∧ Aup . A useful formula for A ∈ L(V ; V ) is X dΛ(A) = Aij a∗i aj .
(3.25)
i,j
Note that since α(u) is symmetric, (ρ∗ ⊗ ρ∗ )α(u) : V ⊗ V → V ⊗ V has X αij (u)ρ∗ (Ai ) ⊗ ρ∗ (Aj )(v 1 ∧ v 2 ) (3.26) (ρ∗ ⊗ ρ∗ )α(u)(v 1 ∧ v 2 ) = i,j
=
X
αij (u) ρ∗ (Ai )v 1 ∧ ρ∗ (Aj )v 2 .
(3.27)
ij
and so (ρ∗ ⊗ ρ∗ )α(u) restricts to a map of ∧2 V to itself. Quantitative estimates can be obtained by some representation theory. For example suppose G = O(n) with ρ the standard representation on Rn . Consider the representation ∧k ρ on ∧k Rn . Corollary 3.4.4. Take the Hilbert-Schmidt inner product on so(n) and let 0 6 µ1 (x) 6 · · · 6 µ(x) 12 n(n−1) be the eigenvalues of α on the fibre p−1 (x), x ∈ M , as described in Remark 3.2.2(c). Then for all V ∈ ∧k Rn , D k E 1 1 − k(n − k)µ 12 n(n−1) (x) 6 λ∧ (u)V, V 6 − k(n − k)µ1 (x). 2 2 Proof. Following Humphreys [52], §6.2, consider the bilinear form β on so(n) given by β(A, B) = trace (d∧k )(A)(d∧k )(B) =
(n − 2)! trace(AB) (k − 1)!(n − k − 1)!
by a short calculation using elementary matrices. By Remark 3.2.2(c) since our inner product on so(n) is ad(O(n))-invariant we can write 1 2 n(n−1)
α(u) =
X
µl (x)Al (u) ⊗ Al (u)
l=1
with x = p(u) and {Al (u)}l an orthonormal base for so(n) at each u ∈ P .
3.4. Associated Vector Bundles and Generalised Weitzenb¨ock Formulae
51
For each u ∈ P , set A0l (u) =
(k − 1)!(n − k − 1)! Al (u) (n − 2)!
to ensure β(A0l (u), Aj (u)) = δlj for each u. Then D E X D E k ∧k Comp ◦(ρ∧ = µl (x) (d∧k )Al (u) ◦ (d∧k )Al (u)V, V ∗ ⊗ ρ∗ )(α(u))V, V E X h (k − 1)!(n − k − 1)! i−1 D = (d∧k )Al (u) ◦ (d∧k )A0l (u)V, V (n − 2)! l
6−
(n − 2)! c k V, V , (k − 1)!(n − k − 1)! ∧
where c∧k = (d∧k )Al (u) ◦ (d∧k )A0l (u), the Casimir element of our representation d∧k of so(n). Since the representation is irreducible, (for example see [12] Theorem 15.1 page 278), this element is a scalar, and we have, see Humphreys [52], c∧k =
n(n − 1) . . . (n − k + 1) dim so(n) 1 . = n(n − 1)/ k n dim ∧ R 2 k!
k
Thus λ∧ (u) 6 − 12 k(n − k)µ1 . The lower bound follows in the same way.
When B has an equivariant H¨ ormander form representation the zero-order operator F ρ (V ) can be given in a simple way by (3.28) below. This was noted for the classical Weitzenb¨ ock curvature terms using derivative flows in Elworthy [32]. Proposition 3.4.5. SupposePB lies over aPcohesive operator A and has a smooth H¨ ormander form: B = 21 βk LY 0 with the vector fields Y j , j = LY j LY j + j 1, . . . , m, being G-invariant. Let (ηt ) be the flow of Y j . For a representation ρ of G with associated vector bundle π ρ : F → M the zero-order operator F ρ (B V ) corresponding to the vertical component of B is given by F ρ (B V )(x0 ) =
m 1 X D2 j D 0 −1 η (u ) ◦ (¯ u ) + η (u ) ◦ (¯ u0 )−1 0 0 0 2 j=1 dt2 t dt t t=0 t=0
(3.28)
for any u0 ∈ π −1 (x0 ). Proof. Set ujt = ηtj (u0 ) ∈ P and σ(t) = π(ujt ) so u ¯jt ∈ L(V ; Fσ(t) ). From Remark 3.2.2(b), m 1X $(Y j (u0 )) ⊗ $(Y j (u0 )) α(u0 ) = 2 j=1
52
Chapter 3. Equivariant Diffusions on Principal Bundles
and so (ρ∗ ⊗ ρ∗ )α(u0 ) =
m D j D j 1X ¯t ¯ (¯ u0 )−1 u ⊗ (¯ u0 )−1 u 2 j=1 dt t=0 dt t t=0
as in the proof of Theorem 3.3.2. Also from equation (3.6) β(u0 ) =
m 1X 1 LY j $(Y j (−) (u0 ) + $(Y 0 (−) (u0 ). 2 j=1 2
Let (//t ) denote parallel translation in F along σ. Then d ρ∗ LY j $(Y j (−) (u0 ) = ρ∗ $ Y j (ujt ) dt t=0 d j −1 D j (¯ ut ) u ¯ = dt dt t t=0 D d (//t−1 ujt )−1 //t−1 ujt = dt dt t=0 D D D2 j j j = −¯ u−1 ut ◦u ¯−1 ut +u ¯−1 u 0 0 0 dt t=0 dt t=0 dt2 t t=0 leading to the required result via Theorem 3.4.1.
To examine particular examples we will need to have detailed information about the zero-order operators determined by a vertical diffusion generator. For this suppose B is vertical and given by X X B= αij LA∗i LA∗j + βk LA∗k for α : P → g ⊗ g and β : P → g as in Theorem 3.2.1 and (3.4). Motivated by the Weitzenb¨ ock formula for the Hodge-Kodaira Laplacian on differential forms, see Corollary 3.4.9 below, [93], [22], we shall examine in more detail the case of the exterior power ∧ρ : G → L(∧V ; ∧V ) of a fixed representation ρ showing that λ∧ρ has expressions in terms of annihilation and creation operators which are structurally the same as these of the Weitzenb¨ock curvature (which are shown to be a special case in Corollary 3.4.9). For notational convenience we give V an inner product in what follows. Lemma 3.4.6. If B is a vertical operator on P and (ei , i = 1, 2, . . . , N ) is an orthonormal basis of V , the zero-order operator on the associated bundle ∧F → M is represented by λ∧ρ : P → L(∧p V ; ∧p V ) with N X
λ∧ρ (u) =
h((ρ∗ ⊗ ρ∗ )α(u)) (ej ⊗ el ), ei ⊗ ek i a∗i aj a∗k al
i,j,k,l=1
+
N X
h(ρ∗ β(u))ej , ei ia∗i aj ,
i,j=1
u ∈ P.
3.4. Associated Vector Bundles and Generalised Weitzenb¨ock Formulae
53
Proof. Recall that if A ∈ L(V ; V ), then dΛ(A) =
N X
hAej , ei ia∗i aj ,
(3.29)
i,j=1
e.g. see Cycon-Froese-Kirsch-Simon [22]. Consequently dΛ(ρ∗ β(u)) =
N X
hρ∗ β(u)ej , ei ia∗i aj .
(3.30)
i,j=1
On the other hand by Theorem 3.2.1 and (3.4), we can represent α as: X an,m (u)An ⊗ Am α(u) = n,m
where {Ai }N i=1 is a basis of g. So Comp ◦(∧ρ∗ ⊗ ∧ρ∗ )(α(u)) X an,m (u) dΛ(ρ∗ Am ) ⊗ dΛ(ρ∗ An ) = Comp ◦ m,n
=
X
an,m (u)dΛ(ρ∗ Am ) ◦ dΛ(ρ∗ An )
m,n
=
X
an,m (u)
m,n
=
N X
hρ∗ Am ej , ei ihρ∗ An el , ek ia∗i aj a∗k al
i,j,k,l=1
N X 1X an,m (u) h(ρ∗ Am ⊗ ρ∗ An ) (ej ⊗ el ), ei ⊗ ek i a∗i aj a∗k al 2 m,n i,j,k,l=1
=
1 2
N X
h(ρ∗ ⊗ ρ∗ )α(u)(ej ⊗ el ), ei ⊗ ek i a∗i aj a∗k al ,
i,j,k,l=1
since our convention for the inner product on tensor products gives hu1 ⊗ v1 , u2 ⊗ v2 i = 2hu1 , u2 ihv1 , v2 i. The desired conclusion follows. 2
2
Theorem 3.4.7. Let R(u) : ∧ V → ∧ V be the restriction of 2(ρ∗ ⊗ ρ∗ )α(u) : V ⊗ V → V ⊗ V , then X λ∧ρ (u) = − hR(u)(ej ∧ el ), ei ∧ ek i a∗i a∗k aj al i
+
N X
h(ρ∗ ⊗ ρ∗ )α(u)(ej ⊗ el ), ei ⊗ ej i a∗i al +
i,j,l=1
X i,j
hρ∗ β(u)ej , ei i (ai )∗ aj .
54
Chapter 3. Equivariant Diffusions on Principal Bundles
This can be rewritten as: X hR(u)(ej ∧ el ), ei ∧ ek i a∗i a∗k aj al + d ∧ (Z ρ (u)) + d ∧ (ρ∗ β(u)). λ∧ρ (u) = − i
(3.31) where Z ρ (u) ∈ L(V ; V ) is defined by N X
hZ (v1 ), v2 i = (ρ∗ ⊗ ρ∗ )(α(u))(ej ⊗ v1 ), v2 ⊗ ej V ⊗V . ρ
j=1
Proof. This follows from Lemma 3.4.6 using the anti-commutation formula (3.24) since N X
h(ρ∗ ⊗ ρ∗ )α(u)(ej ⊗ el ), ei ⊗ ek i a∗i aj a∗k al
i,j,k,l=1
=−
N X
h(ρ∗ ⊗ ρ∗ )α(u)(ej ⊗ el ), ei ⊗ ek i a∗i a∗k aj al
i,j,k,l=1
+
N X
h(ρ∗ ⊗ ρ∗ )α(u)(ej ⊗ el ), ei ⊗ ej i a∗i al
i,j,l=1
=−
N X
hR(u)(ej ∧ el ), ei ∧ ek i a∗i a∗k aj al
j
+
N X
h(ρ∗ ⊗ ρ∗ )α(u)(ej ⊗ el ), ei ⊗ ej i a∗i al .
i,j,l=1
Remark 3.4.8. (a) Note that the second term in (3.31) in general depends on the symmetric part of (ρ∗ ⊗ ρ∗ )(α(u)) as well as on R. (b) If we write α(u) =
X
µk (u)Ak (u) ⊗ Ak (u)
as in Remark 3.2.2(c), Then Z ρ (u) in (3.31) has X Z ρ (u) = µk (u)ρ∗ (Ak (u))ρ∗ (Ak (u)). k
Corollary 3.4.9. For the derivative process in GLM of a cohesive generator A given in H¨ ormander form without a drift, the zero-order operator induced by the vertical diffusion on the exterior bundles ∧T M is minus one half times the generalised ˘ ∗ : ∧∗ T M → ∧∗ E, given by: Weitzenb¨ock curvature, R X ˘ q V = d ∧q (Ric# )(V ) − 2 Rikjl a∗l a∗j ak ai V (3.32) R 16i
3.4. Associated Vector Bundles and Generalised Weitzenb¨ock Formulae
55
for all VL∈ ∧q T M . Here Rikjl = hR(ei , ek )el , ej i , 1 6 i, k 6 n, 1 6 j, l 6 p for R : TM T M → L(E, E) the curvature transform of the associated connection on E, and if V ∈ ∧q Tx M the set {e1 , . . . , ep } is an orthonormal base for Ex which together with ep+1 , . . . , en forms an orthonormal base for some inner product on Tx M extending that of Ex . Proof. By Theorem 3.3.2, α(u) =
1 X −1 u ∇u(−) X p ⊗ u−1 ∇u(−) X p , 2
u ∈ GLM.
By Corollary C.5 in [36] the restriction 12 R(u) of α(u) to anti-symmetric tensors corresponds to one half of the curvature operator 12 R : ∧2 T M → ∧2 E composed with the inclusion of ∧2 E into ∧2 T M . By the relation between the curvature transform and the curvature operator: hR(v 1 ∧ v 2 ), w1 ∧ w2 i = hR(v 1 , v 2 )w2 , w1 i, the first term in λρ (u) of Theorem 3.4.7 corresponds to: X X hR(ei ∧ ek ), ej ∧ el i a∗j a∗l ai ak = − − 16i
Riklj a∗j a∗l ai ak
16i
=
X
Rikjl a∗l a∗j ak ai
16i
by the skew-symmetry of Riklj in i, k and in j.l and the anti-commutation of annihilation operators. By (ii) of Remark 3.4.8, the second term corresponds to m X 1 d ∧q ∇∇− X j X j . 2 j=1 The required result follows since β(u) = −
m 1 1 X −1 u ∇∇u(−) X j X j − u−1 Ric# u(−) . 2 j=1 2
Corollary 3.4.9 reflects the results in [36], Theorem 2.4.2, concerning Weitzenb¨ock formulae for H¨ ormander form operators on differential forms. In particular it ˘ is the Levi-Civita gives another approach to the result that when E = T M and ∇ connection, as holds for gradient stochastic differential equations, the generator induced on differential forms by the derivative process is a constant times the HodgeKodaira Laplacian for the induced Riemannian structure on M up to a first-order ˘ q given by equation term, see [36]. This comes from identifying the adjoint of R ˘ (3.32) when ∇ is the Levi-Civita connection, with the standard Weitzenb¨ock term
56
Chapter 3. Equivariant Diffusions on Principal Bundles
ock formula for the Hodge-Kodaira LaplaRq , say, which appears in the Weitzenb¨ cian on q-forms: (3.33) 4q φ ≡ −(dd∗ + d∗ d)φ = ∇∗ ∇φ − Rq φ. and is the zero-order operator given by X Rq φ ≡ R• φ = Rijkl (ai )∗ aj (ak )∗ al φ see [22], or [93] where the opposite sign is used. Here the annihilation and creation operators acting on a form φ are denoted by ai and (ai )∗ so that (ai φ)(v) = φ(a∗i v) = φ(ei ∧ v) and ((ai )∗ φ)(v) = φ(ai v) = φ(ιei v) = (e∗i ∧ φ)(v). One of the standard ways of writing Rq is with the decomposition ˜ (4) φ Rq φ = φ ◦ d ∧q (Ric# ) + R for φ a q-form, where ˜ (4) = − R
X
Rijkl (ai )∗ (ak )∗ aj al .
This follows from the definition of Rq using the anti-commutation relation (3.24) and the formula (3.25). For example see [22] page 260. In [36] we showed that the second term in the right-hand side of equation ˜ (4) . There was an error in the sign of this term in the (3.32) corresponds to R statement of Theorem 2.4.2 of [36] and in the discussion of its relationship with ˜ (4) , and for completeness we repeat the argument. R Working with the Levi-Civita connection and using the anti-commutatitvity of the creation operators we have ˜ (4) ≡ − R =−
n X
Rijkl (ai )∗ (ak )∗ aj al
i,j,k,l=1 n n X X
[Rijkl − Rkjil ](ai )∗ (ak )∗ aj al
1 6 i
=−
XX [Rijkl − Rkjil − Rilkj + Rklij ](ai )∗ (ak )∗ aj al . i
However by Bianchi’s identity: Rijkl + Riljk + Riklj = 0 we have Rijkl − Rkjil = Rikjl , and interchanging j and l: −Rilkj + Rklij = −Riklj = Rikjl .
3.4. Associated Vector Bundles and Generalised Weitzenb¨ock Formulae
57
Thus ˜ (4) = −2 R
XX
Rikjl (ai )∗ (ak )∗ aj al .
i
˘ q V in equation Taking adjoints we obtain the second term in the expression for R (3.32), as claimed. Note that if B is the operator on GLM determined by the H¨ormander form (3.9) of A, then for a representation ρ : GL(M ) → L(V ; V ) with associated π ρ : GL(n) → L(V ; V ) the induced operator F ρ (B) on sections of π ρ is also given P 1 by the ‘H¨ormander form’ 2 j LX j LX j + LA , where for any C 1 vector field Y on M and any C 1 section U of π ρ the Lie derivative LY U ∈ ΓF is given by ¯ (LY U )(x) = u
−1 d Y Tηt ◦ u U ηtY (x) dt t=0
for x ∈ M , u a frame at x, and (ηtY ) the flow of Y , using the notation of (3.17). ¯ U (π(u)), so U = F ρ (Z), Indeed by (3.17), for Z(u) = u F ρ (B)(U ) = F ρ
while L(X j )GL (Z)(u) =
h 1 X 2
d Xj dt Z(T ηt
i L(X j )GL L(X j )GL + LAGL (Z)
j
◦ u)
so that
t=0
i h j d ¯ Z(T ηtX ◦ u) F ρ L(X j )GL (Z) (x) = u = LX j (U )(x). dt t=0 This representation of F ρ (B) was noted in the case of the operator induced on differential forms by a stochastic flow in [36], and for the case of the Hodge-Kodaira Laplacian in Elworthy [32], see also Kusuoka [60]. Remark 3.4.10 (Elementary matrices, ∧2 Rn and so(n)). We always give so(n) its Hilbert-Schmidt inner product hA, Bi = trace B ∗ A. Using the standard basis n with E[p,q] (v) = vq ep . e1 , . . . , en of Rn let E[p,q] denote the elementary matrix E[p,q] 1 As in Example 3.0.1 set A[p,q] = √2 [E[p,q] − E[q,p] ] so that {A[p,q] : 1 6 p < q 6 n} forms an orthonormal basis for so(n). We have the isomorphism, but not isometry, of ∧2 Rn with so(n) given by mapping ep ∧ eq to 12 (E[p,q] − E[q,p] ) in accordance n n n with our √ usual interpretation of elements of R ⊗ R as linear operators on R . Then 2ep ∧ eq corresponds to A[p,q] . Example 3.4.11. Let P be the orthonormal frame bundle for a Riemannian metric on M . Let C : P → L(Rn ; Rn ) satisfy C(ug) = g −1 C(u)g for g ∈ O(n) with C(u) a symmetric map for all u ∈ P . Define α : P → so(n) ⊗ so(n) by X α(u) = tracehC(u)A[p,q] −, A[p0 ,q0 ] −iRn A[p,q] ⊗ A[p0 ,q0 ] , 1 6 p
58
Chapter 3. Equivariant Diffusions on Principal Bundles
where the {A[p,q] } are as in Remark 3.4.10 above. Then α corresponds to an equivariant operator B V , say, on P , namely, at u ∈ P , X tracehC(u)A[p,q] −, A[p0 ,q0 ] −iRn LA∗[p,q] LA∗[p0 ,q0 ] , BV = 1 6 p
and
1 1 Comp ◦α(u) = − (trace C(u))id + (2 − n)C(u). 4 4
Let Ric# : T M → T M be the Ricci curvature (for the Levi-Civita connection, −1 −) for u ∈ P . If the Ricci curvature is nonsay)and take C(u) = u Ric# π(u) (u V negative the operator B is a vertical diiffusion operator whose induced zero-order 1 term on vector fields is 14 (2 − n) Ric# π(u) − 4 k, where k is the scalar curvature. Proof. Since α(ug) = (ad(g) ⊗ ad(g)) α(u) for g ∈ O(n) the operator B V is equivariant. To compute Comp ◦α(u) first observe that tracehC(u)A[p,q] −, A[p0 ,q0 ] −iRn =
1 hC(u)A[p,q] + A[p,q] C(u), A[p0 ,q0 ] iso(n) 2
and so, because the {A[p,q] } form an orthonormal base, α=
1 X CA[p,q] ⊗ A[p,q] + A[p,q] C ⊗ A[p,q] . 2
Then we use the elementary fact about elementary matrices: E[p,q] CE[p0 ,q0 ] = Cqp0 E[p,q0 ]
3.5
Notes
G-invariant diffusion operators Suppose a diffusion operator on N is invariant under the action of a Lie group G. Even if the action is not principal in the sense that the quotient mapping N → N/G is not a principal bundle it may be possible to classify the orbits and give partial skew-product decompositions. This is discussed in L´azaro-Cami & Ortega’s article,[62], with special reference to stochastic Hamiltonian systems, and their analysis could easily be combined with the use of the connections described here. Canonical vertical diffusions on GLM We have seen in Corollary 3.4.9 that there is a zero-order operator on the associated bundle ∧F → M represented by the Weitzenb¨ock curvature of a given connection. On the other hand, given a curvature operator R of a metric connection, or more
3.5. Notes
59
generally an operator which has the same symmetry properties as a curvature tensor, is there a canonical vertical diffusion operator on GLM which induces zero-order operators on differential forms which have the form of the Weitzenb¨ock curvatures of R? A vertical operator with such a zero-order term always exists since we can take R in a diagonal form: R(u) =
N X
An (u) ∧ An (u),
(3.34)
n=1
for some An : GLM → gl(n) which are ad(G)-invariant, e.g. by taking an isometric embedding (e.g. see [36]). In this case let (ej ) be a basis of Eπ(u) and define N 1X An (u) ⊗ An (u), α(u) = 2 n=1
(3.35)
p N 1X 1X β(u) = − (An (u))2 − R(−, ej )ej , 2 n=1 2 j=1
see Remark 3.4.8(b). Then α is positive and we can define an operator with its coefficients these α and β. For a discussion of the representation of R in the form of (3.34) see Kobayashi-Nomizu [56] (Notes 17 and 18). In particular there is a discussion there of the number N required and of a rigidity theorem originating from Chern. See also Berger-Bryant-Griffiths [10]. When M is Riemannian with positive semi-definite curvature operator R : ∧2 T M → ∧2 T M there is a canonical construction. For this take the orthonormal frame bundle π : OM → M , with G = O(n). We will use the isomorphism of ∧2 Rn with so(n) described in Remark 3.4.10. Define α : OM → so(n) ⊗ so(n) by α(u) =
1 4
X
D E R(∧2 (u)(ep ∧eq )), ∧2 (u)(ep0 ∧eq0 ))
π(u)
16p6q6n,16p0 6q 0 6n
A[p,q] ⊗A[p0 ,q0 ] .
Our representation ρ is just the identity map and, by (3.27) and Bianchi’s identity, the restriction of α(u) : Rn ⊗ Rn → Rn ⊗ Rn to ∧2 Rn is just 12 R . In the notation of (3.31) we see 1 hZ ρ (v 1 ), v 2 i = − Ric(v 1 , v 2 ). 2 If we take β = 0, we obtain from (3.31) that X ρ λ∧ (u) = − Rjlik a∗i a∗k aj al − 2 (d∧)Ric# . i
To get the full Weitzenb¨ ock term, extend α over GLM by equivariance and define β(u), for u ∈ GLM , by β(u) = 32 u−1 Ric# (u−) as in (3.35).
Chapter 4
Projectible Diffusion Processes and Markovian Filtering S Let M + be the Alexandrov one-point compactification, M ∆, of a smooth manifold M . Consider the space CM + of processes (yt ) on M + with explosion time ζ, such that t → yt is continuous with yt = ∆ when t > ζ. We shall use Cy0 M + to denote those processes starting at a given point y0 of N . Let L be a diffusion operator on M and let {Py0 , y0 ∈ M + } be the family of L-diffusion measures in the sense of [53], i.e. the solution to the martingale problem on CM + so the canon+ ical process (yt , 0 6 t < ζ) with the system of diffusion measures {PL y0 , y0 ∈ N } + is a strong Markov process on M . Denote by E mathematical expectation with respect to the measure Py0 . We may add to these notations the relevant subscripts or superscripts indicating the diffusion operator or the Markov process concerned, L L,y0 or even Ey0 . e.g. {PL y0 }, ζ , E For y0 ∈ M and f ∈ Cc∞ M , the space of smooth functions on M with compact support, let Mtdf := Mtdf,L := f (yt∧ζ ) − f (y0 ) −
Z
t∧ζ
Lf (ys )ds.
(4.1)
0
Then (Mtdf : 0 6 t < ∞) is a martingale on the probability space (C(M ), PL y0 ) with respect to the {Fty0 }, where Fty0 = σ{ys ; 0 6 s 6 t}. Moreover it has bracket df
t∧ζ
Z
σ L ((df )ys , (df )ys )ds.
hM it = 2 0
This definition extends to the case of C 2 functions f but then Mtdf is only defined for 0 6 t < ζ L and is a local martingale.
K.D. Elworthy et al., The Geometry of Filtering, Frontiers in Mathematics, DOI 10.1007/978-3-0346-0176-4_4, © Springer Basel AG 2010
61
62
4.1
Chapter 4. Projectible Diffusion Processes and Markovian Filtering
Integration of predictable processes
Proposition 4.1.1. Let τ be a stopping time with τ < ζ and let {αt : 0 6 t < τ } be an F∗y0 predictable process in T ∗ M such that αt ∈ Ty∗t M for each t ∈ [0, τ ), and for each compact subset C of M we have Z τ χC (ys )αs (σ L αs ) ds < ∞ 0
almost surely. Then there is a unique local martingale {Mtα : 0 6 t < τ } such that for all f ∈ Cc∞ M , Z t
α df σ L (αs , (df )ys ) ds, t < ζ. (4.2) M ,M t = 2 0
Proof. We can write αt =
m X
gtj · dfj (yt ),
(4.3)
j=1
where the functions g j are predictable real-valued processes, for example by taking m and gtj = αt (X j (yt )), for X(x) = (f P1m, . . . , ifm ) : M → R to be an embedding m to Tx M . Using a partition of unity, at the i=1 X (x)ei the projection from R cost of having an infinite, but locally finite sum, we can assume that the fj in the representation are all in Cc∞ M . Define XZ t gsj dMsdfj . (4.4) Mtα := 0
j
Clearly (4.2) holds. For uniqueness suppose K is a local martingale orthogonal to M df for all f ∈ Cc∞ M . Then K vanishes since the martingale problem for L is well posed by an argument attributed to Dellach´erie (see Rogers-Williams [92], the end of the proof of Theorem 2.5.1). In fact it it were not zero we could take a suitable stopping time τ to ensure (1 + Kτ ∧t )PL x0 solves the martingale problem up to time t since Z s Kτ ∧t Msdf ≡ Kτ ∧t f (xs ) − f (x0 ) − Lf (xs )ds , 06s6t 0
is a uniformly integrable martingale.
We will often write Mtα =
Z
t
αs d{ys }
(4.5)
0
bringing out the fact that it is the martingale part of the Stratonovitch integral Rt α ◦ dy s s of (αt ) along the diffusion process (yt ) when that integral is defined, 0 e.g. when (αt ) is a continuous semi-martingale. Indeed
4.1. Integration of predictable processes
63
Lemma 4.1.2. Let α be a C 2 1-form, then Z t Z t α αys ◦ dys − δ L α (ys )ds, Mt = 0
0 6 t < ζ.
(4.6)
0
Proof. This is clear for an exact 1-form. Suppose λ : M → R is C 2 and α is exact, then for t < ζ, Z · Z t Z t 1 λα α α α Mt = λ(ys )dMs = λ(ys ) ◦ dMs − dλ(ys )dys , M· 2 0 0 0 t Z t Z t 1 = λ(ys ) αys ◦ dys − λ(ys ) δ L α (ys )ds − hM·dλ , M·α it 2 0 0 Z t Z t = λ(ys ) αys ◦ dys − δ L (λα)(ys )ds 0
0
since M dλ is the martingale part of λ(ys ) and hM
dλ
α
Z
, M it = 2
t
σ L (dλs , αs )ds.
0
This proves the result for general α by taking a suitable representation.
Let Sx be the image of σxL in Tx M and let S := ∪x Sx . By a predictable S -valued process (αt ) over (yt : 0 6 t < ζ) we mean a process (αt : 0 6 t) such that ∗
(i) αt ∈ Sy∗t for all 0 6 t < ζ, (ii) (αt ◦ σyLt , 0 6 t < ζ) is a predictable process in T M , canonically identified with T ∗∗ M . Note that condition (ii) is equivalent to (ii)0 there exists a predictable (α ¯ t ) in T ∗ M over (yt ) such that α ¯ t |Syt = αt for all 0 6 t < ζ. That (ii0 ) implies (ii) is immediate. To see (ii) implies (ii0 ) first note that αt ◦ σyLt ∈ Syt for each t since αt ◦ σyLt = σyLt (α ˜ t ) for any extension α ˜ t of αt to Ty∗t M . We can then choose a measurable selection α ¯ t in Ty∗t M with σyLt (¯ αt ) = αt ◦ σyLt . This 0 process α ¯ t will satisfy the requirements of (ii ) since α ¯ t σyLt = σyLt α ¯ t = αt σyLt . Definition 4.1.3. If (αt ) satisfies (i) and (ii) we will say it is in L2L if Z 0
t
αs σyLs (αs )ds < ∞
(4.7)
64
Chapter 4. Projectible Diffusion Processes and Markovian Filtering
for all t > 0, and will say it is in L2L,loc if for any compact subset C of M t∧ζ
Z
χC (ys )αs (σ L αs ) ds < ∞
E 0
for all t > 0. Remark 4.1.4. Suppose the processes associated to diffusion operators L and L+Lb are both non-explosive, where b is a locally bounded measurable vector field on M . Assume that there exists a T ∗ M -valued measurable process b# . defined on the canonical probability space Cy0 M such that PL -almost surely: 1. 2σ L (b# s ) = b(ys ), Rt # L # 2. 0 bs σ (bs )ds < ∞. Then, by the GMCM-theorem, as in the Appendix, Section 9.1, we have on C([0, T ]; M ), PL+Lb = Zt PL Rt # L # where Zt = exp{Mtb − 0 b# s σ (bs )ds}. In an obvious notation, for suitable α, as canonical processes we have, almost surely, Z t Z t Z t L L+Lb αs d{ys } = αs d{ys } − αs (b(us ))ds. 0
0
0
Lemma 4.1.5. Suppose σ L has its image in a subset S of T M . Then (Mtα ) depends only on the restriction of αs in L(Tys M ; R) to Sys , 0 6 s < ζ. In particular (4.2) defines uniquely a local martingale for each predictable S ∗ -valued process (αt ) over (yt )for which the right-hand side of (4.2) is always finite almost surely. Proof. For T ∗ M -valued F∗y0 predictable processes (αt1 , 0 6 t < ζ) and (αt2 , 0 6 t < ζ) over (yt , 0 6 t < ζ) which agree on S we see hM
α1
−M
α2
Z
df
t∧ζ
σ(αs1 − αs2 , (df )ys ) ds = 0
, M it = 2 0 1
2
for all f ∈ Cc∞ M . Therefore M α = M α . On the other hand this also shows that if αs ∈ Sy∗s for all s, we can use condition (ii0 ) above to choose a predictable process {¯ αs : 0 6 s < ζ} with values in T ∗ M over (yt ) and set M·α = M·α¯ without ambiguity. Example 4.1.6 (Canonical Brownian motion associated to a cohesive diffusion). For simplicity assume that our L-diffusion from a given point y0 is non-explosive. If L is cohesive with subbundle E of TM, take a metric connection Γ for E, using the metric determined by 2σ L . Let αs (σ) := (//sσ )−1 : Eσ(s) → Ey0
4.1. Integration of predictable processes
65
be the inverse of parallel translation, //sσ , along σ from Eσ(0) to Eσ(s) , for Py0 almost all paths σ in M . Each component of this with respect to an orthonormal basis for Ey0 clearly lies in L2L . With the obvious extension of our notation to the vector-space-valued case define an Ey0 -valued process Bt : t > 0 by Bt = Mtα =
t
Z
(//s )−1 d{ys }.
0
It is easy to check from its quadratic variation that it is a Brownian motion on the inner product space Ey0 . Moreover (as described in [36]) it has the same filtration as the canonical process on Cy0 M up to sets of measure zero. It is the martingale Rt part of the stochastic anti-development 0 (//s )−1 dys of our L-diffusion from y0 . The use of a different metric connection would change it bya random rotation, so this process is defined on the canonical probability space Cy0 M, F y0 , Py0 and up to such rotations depends only on it. We have, for α as usual: t
Z
Z αs d{ys } =
0
t
(αs ◦ //s ) dBs .
(4.8)
0
Using the definitions in Appendix 9.3 we see that if our diffusion process y. is a Γ-martingale, then Z t Z t αs d{ys } = Γ αs dys . (4.9) 0
0
Note that there is always some metric connection Γ on E for which a cohesive diffusion process is a Γ-martingale, by section 2.1 of [36]. Example 4.1.7. In Example 2.2.13, the martingales Mtdvi associated with the process ut are independent Wiener processes which we will denote by Wti , and we have: vi (ut ) = vi (u0 ) + Wti Z wi (ut ) = wi (u0 ) + α
(4.10) t
vi+1 (us )dWsi+2 − vi+2 (u)dWsi+1 .
0
In particular, it follows that: Z
t
v2 (us )dWs3 − v3 (us )dWs2 , and by Itˆo’s formula, 0 Z t w1 (ut ) = w1 (u0 ) + α −v2 (ut )Wt3 − v3 (u0 )ν2 (ut ) + 2 v2 (us )dWs3 , 0 Z t 3 3 w2 (ut ) = w2 (u0 ) + α v1 (u0 )Wt + v3 (u0 )ν1 (ut ) − 2 v1 (us )dWs .
w3 (ut ) = w3 (u0 ) + α
0
66
Chapter 4. Projectible Diffusion Processes and Markovian Filtering
4.2
Horizontality and filtrations
We can characterise horizontality of a diffusion operator or process in terms of filtrations using the following lemma: Lemma 4.2.1. Suppose p : N → M is a smooth map, B a smooth diffusion operator over a smooth diffusion operator A, and also (i) σ A and σ B have constant rank and (ii) the filtration generated by u· and p(u· ) agree up to sets of PB u0 -measure zero for some u0 ∈ N . A for all u ∈ N . Then rank σuB = rank σp(u)
Proof. Set p = rank σxA and p˜ = rank σuB . By assumption p and p˜ do not depend on x ∈ M and u ∈ N . Take connections on Image σ B and Image σ A which are metric for the metrics induced by the symbols. Extend these connections to T N and T M . The martingale part of the stochastic anti-development of (u· ) will be a Brownian motion stopped at ζ B of dimension p˜ and that of (p(u· )) will be one of dimension p. By (ii) these have the same filtration up to sets of measure zero. But this implies p = p˜ by the martingale representation theorem, as required. Proposition 4.2.2. The following are equivalent for B over A when A is cohesive: (a) B = AH , (b) B is cohesive and the filtration generated by its associated diffusion (u· ) agrees with that of p(u· ) up to sets of PB u0 -measure zero for given u0 in N . Proof. If (b) holds, Lemma 4.2.1 shows that Image[σuB ] = Hu for each u ∈ N , since by (2.3) we always have Hu ⊂ Image[σuB ]. Thus (b) implies criterion (ii) of Proposition 2.2.2. Also (b) follows from (iii) of Proposition 2.2.2 by considering ˜ m. ˜ 0, . . . , X the stochastic differential equation driven by horizontal lifts X
4.3
Intertwined diffusion processes
Let p : N → M be a smooth surjective map. Suppose that B is over A. However A we do not assume σ A of constant rank. Let {PB u0 } and {Px0 } be, respectively, the solutions to the martingale problem for B and A on the canonical spaces CM + and CN + . Denote by (ut ) and (xt ) the corresponding canonical processes with explosion time ζ N and ζ M respectively. Note that ζ N 6 ζ M ◦ p almost surely with respect to PB u0 . We shall assume that the paths of the diffusion on N do not explode before their projections on M do, more precisely ζ M ◦ p = ζ N almost surely with respect to PB u0 for each u0 , equivalently, • Assumption S. Cup0 M + := {σ : [0, ∞) → M + : lim p(ut ) = ∆ when ζ N (u. ) < ∞} t↑ζ N
4.3. Intertwined diffusion processes
67
has full PB u0 measure for each u0 ∈ N . This assumption holds for all the examples considered earlier. There are two ways it may fail, given the standing assumption that p is surjective. These are exemplified by p : U → R, the projection p(x, y) = x of certain open sets U of R2 onto R. If B is the usual Laplacian on U , with N = U , then Assumption S fails if (i) U = {(x, y) ∈ R2 : x2 + y 2 > 1} and if (ii) U = {(x, y) ∈ R2 : y < 1}. Denote by the following the filtrations induced by the processes indicated: Ftu0 = σ(us , 0 6 s 6 t), Ftx0 = σ(xs , 0 6 s 6 t), p(u0 )
Ft
= σ(p(us ), 0 6 s 6 t),
F u0 = σ(ys , 0 6 s < ∞), F x0 = σ(xs , 0 6 s < ∞), F p(u0 ) = σ(p(us ), 0 6 s < ∞).
A B Proposition 4.3.1. Under Assumption S, p∗ (PB u0 ) = Pp(u0 ) and Pt (f ◦ p) = A ∞ Pt (f ◦ p) for all f ∈ Cc (M ).
Proof. If p(u0 ) = x0 , f ∈ Cc∞ (M ), we only need to show that Mtdf,A is a martingale with respect to p∗ (PB u0 ). Using Assumption S, Mtdf,A (p(u))
Z
t
= f (p(ut )) − f (p(u0 )) −
Af ◦ p(us ))ds 0
Z = f (p(ut )) − f (p(u0 )) −
t
(B(f ◦ p)) (us )ds 0
d(f ◦p),B
= Mt
x0 is a martingale with respect to (Ftu0 ) and PB u0 . Take s 6 t and let G be a Fs measurable function. Then o o n n B B Ep∗ (Pu0 ) Mtdf,A G = EPu0 Mtdf,A (p(u· ))G(p(u· )) o o n n B B d(f ◦p),B G ◦ p = EPu0 Msd(f ◦p),B G ◦ p) = EPu0 Mt B = Ep∗ (Pu0 ) Msdf,A G
and the required result follows from the uniqueness of the martingale problem for A. We will need the following elementary lemma: Lemma 4.3.2. Let (Ω, F, Ft , P} be a filtered probability space and G∗ a subfiltration of F∗ with the property that for all s > 0, E{A|Gs } = E{E{A|Fs }|G}, where G = ∨s Gs . Then
∀A ∈ F,
(4.11)
68
Chapter 4. Projectible Diffusion Processes and Markovian Filtering
(i) (E{Mt |G}, t > 0) is a G∗ -martingale whenever (Mt : t > 0) is an F∗ martingale; (ii) For all G-measurable and integrable H, E H|Fs } = E{H|Gs }; (iii) E E{A|Fs }|G = E E{A|G}|Fs ,
∀A ∈ F.
Proof. For (i) set Nt = E{Mt |G}, 0 6 t < ∞. By (4.11), (Nt ) is Gt measurable. For s 6 t suppose that f is Gs -measurable and bounded. Then E(Nt f ) = E(Mt f ) = E(Ms f ) = E(Ns f ). For (ii), let H and F be bounded measurable functions with G-measurable and Fs -measurable representations. Then E H|F = E H|E F |G = E H|E F |Gs = E H|E F |G using (4.11). Thus E H|Fs } = E{H|Gs } as required. Part (iii) follows from (ii) on taking H = E E{A|G} and using equation (4.3.2). p(u0 )
Part (ii) of the following proposition says that the filtration F∗ mersed in the filtration F∗u0 in the terminology of Tsirelson [102]. Proposition 4.3.3. tion. Then
is im-
(i) For fixed t > 0 let f be a bounded Ftu0 -measurable funcn o n o p(u ) E f |F p(u0 ) = E f |Ft 0 .
p(u )
(ii) All F∗ 0 martingales are F∗u0 martingales. In fact if f = G ◦ p for G an integrable functional on C(M + ) with respect to PA , we have p(u0 )
Eu0 {f |Ft
} = Eu0 {f |Ftu0 }.
Proof. (i) Write f = F (us : 0 6 s 6 t) for F a bounded measurable function on CN + . Let G be bounded measurable functions of {p(us ) : 0 6 s 6 t} and g 1 , . . . , g k bounded Borel functions on M , with h1 , . . . , hk positive real numbers. By the Markov property of u· and of p(u· ), E F (us : 0 6 s 6 t) G g 1 ◦ p(ut+h1 ) · · · · · g k ◦ p(ut+h1 +···+hk ) = E F (us : 0 6 s 6 t)G PhA1 g 1 PhA2 (g 2 . . . PhAk g k ) (p(ut )) . Therefore, n o n o p(u) E F (us : 0 6 s 6 t)|F p(u) = E F (us : 0 6 s 6 t)|Ft as required. Part (ii) is immediate from (i) by Lemma 4.3.2.
4.3. Intertwined diffusion processes
69
As in §2.1 set Ex = Image σxA with hu : Ep(u) → Tu N the horizontal lift defined by (2.3), although now we have no constant rank assumption and so no smoothness of h. Also let EuB = Image σuB . For an F∗x0 -predictable E ∗ -valued process φt := φt (σ· ), 0 6 t < ζ M along (σt : 0 6 t < ζ M ) let (p∗ (φt ) : 0 6 t < ζ N ) be the pull-back restricted to be an (E B )∗ -valued process along (ut : 0 6 t < ζ N ) defined by p∗ (φt )(u· ) = φt (p(u)) ◦ Tut p : E B ut → R. Since φt has a predictable extension φ¯t so does p∗ (φt ) and so the latter is predictable. Moreover p∗ (φt )σ B (p∗ φt ) = φt σ A (φt ) by Lemma 2.1.1 showing φ· is in L2A if and only if p∗ (φ· ) is in L2B . For such φ we have the following intertwining: Proposition 4.3.4. Let φ be a predictable L2A -valued process. B,p∗ (φ)
A,φ (1) For PB ◦ p = Mt u0 almost surely all sample paths, Mt
for t < ζ N .
(2) If α ∈ L2B with αt ◦hut = 0 almost surely for all t < ζ N , then hMtα , Mtdf ◦T p i = 0 and EB,u0 {Mtα |F p(u0 ) } = 0 for all C 1 functions f on M . Proof. For φ = df , (1) follows from p∗ (df )u = d(f ◦ p)u as in the proof of Proposition 4.3.1. For general φ, taking a predictable extension if necessary, write Pm i j j φt (x) = 1 gt (x· )(df )xt for smooth functions f : M → R and real-valued j M predictable {gt : 0 6 t < ζ }. Therefore m Z t X B,p∗ (df j ) B,p∗ (φ) gsj (p(u· )) dMt = Mt MtA,φ ◦ p = j=1
0
for all t < ζ N , giving (1). For (2) let F : N → R be a smooth measurable function with respect to F p(u0 ) . Then F = f (p(u· )) for some measurable function f : M → R. Z 1 B,u0 1 B,u0 t B df ◦T p B,u0 α α (Mt f (p(u· ))) = E hMt , Mt i= E σ (αs , df ◦ T p(us ))ds. E 2 2 0 If αt hut = 0 almost surely for all t, we apply (2.3) to see A σ B (αs , df ◦ T p(us )) = αs σuBs T ∗ p(df ) = αs hus σp(u df = 0 s) and thus EB,u0 (Mtα f (p(u· ))) = 0 giving (2). L2B
B,u0
define βs ≡ E {αs ◦ hus |p(u· ) = x· }, 0 6 s < ζ to be the For α ∈ unique, up to equivalence, element of L2A such that (4.12) EB,u0 αs ◦ hus σ A (φs (p(u· ))) = EA,p(u0 ) βs σ A (φs ) for any φ ∈ L2A . To see that such an element exists and is unique, recall that A αs ◦ hus σp(u = αs σuBs (tus p)∗ s)
70
Chapter 4. Projectible Diffusion Processes and Markovian Filtering
which is an F∗u0 -predictable process with values in Ep(us ) ⊂ Tp(us ) M at each time s, and by Proposition 4.3.3, (4.12) is equivalent to n o A B,u0 B ∗ p(u0 ) βs (p(u· ))σp(u = E σ (T p) |F α (4.13) s u u s ) s s in the sense of Elworthy-LeJan-Li [36]. The predictable projection theorem and the results of [36] show that there is a unique, up to indistinguishability, F p(u· ) predictable T M version {γt : 0 6 t < ζ} say, over {p(ut ) : 0 6 t < ζ}, of the righthand side of (4.13). By applying the uniqueness part of this projection theorem p(u ) to {φs (γs ) : 0 6 s < ζ} when φ· is F∗ · -predictable, T ∗ M -valued over p(u· ) and φt vanishes on Ep(ut ) for all 0 6 t < ρ with probability 1, we see γt ∈ Ep(uu ) for A ∗ ]−1 γs in Ep(u . all 0 6 t < ζ almost surely. Now set βs (p(u· )) = [σp(u s) s) Proposition 4.3.5. For any α· in L2B we have B,u0
E
{Mtα
Z | p(u· ) = x· } =
T
EB,u0 {αs ◦ hus | p(u· ) = x· } d{xs }.
0
¯t (p(u)) for {N ¯t } a Ftx0 Proof. Set Nt = E{Mtα | F p(u0 ) } and write Nt (u) = N p(u· ) measurable function. By Proposition 4.3.3, (Nt ) is an F∗ -martingale and we ¯t ) is an F x martingale. Take g ∈ C ∞ M , then by Proposition 4.3.4, see (N ∗ c n o ¯ , M A,dg it ◦ p(u) = EB,u0 hM α , M d(g◦p) it |Ftp(u0 ) (u) hN n o p(u ) = EB,u0 σuBt (αt , (Tut p)∗ (dg)) |Ft 0 n o p(u ) A (dg)|Ft 0 = EB,u0 αt ◦ hut σp(u t) by equation (2.3). By Proposition 4.1.1 and the definition above of the conditional ¯t (p(u· )) = M A,β for β ◦ p(u· ) = EB,u0 αt ◦ hu |F p(u0 ) and so expectation, N t ¯t (x· ) = N
Z
t
E {αs ◦ hus |p(u· ) = x· } d{xs } 0
as required.
4.4
A family of Markovian kernels
For a probability measure µ0 on N + let the measures µt on N + be the distributions + of ut , t > 0, under PB µ0 and set νt = p∗ (µt ) on M . Let ηµ0 be the law of u· 7→ (p(u· ), u0 ) on CM + × N + under PB µ0 so Z y PA A ∈ B(M + ), Γ ∈ B(N + ) ηµ0 (A, Γ) = y (A) ρµ0 (Γ) ν0 (dy), y∈M +
4.5. The filtering equation
71
where ρyµ0 arises from a disintegration of µ0 , Z µ0 (Γ) = ρyµ0 (Γ) ν0 (dy),
Γ ∈ B(N + ).
y∈M +
For a measurable f : N + → R, integrable with respect to µt set πtµ0 ,σ f (v) = EB µ0 {f (ut )|p(u. ) = σ, u0 = v}.
(4.14)
It is defined for ηµ0 almost all (σ, v) in C(M + ) × N + and depends on the family of µ0 - measure zero sets rather than on µ0 itself. In particular for PA ν0 -almost all σ(0) + σ it is defined for ρµ0 -almost all v ∈ N . We could use the convention that πtµ0 ,σ f (v) = 0 if p(v) 6= σ(0). This enables us to choose a version of EB,v f (ut )|p(u. ) = σ which is jointly measurable in σ and v. With this convention, if we define θt σ(s) = σ(t+s) µt ,θt σ f (y) is defined for µt -almost we see that for PA v0 -almost all σ the map y 7→ πt + all y in N . Further for u0 ∈ N and f : N + → R bounded measurable define πt f (u0 ) : Cp(u0 ) M + → R, PA p(u0 ) -almost surely, by n o δ ,σ πt f (u0 )(σ) = E f (ut )|p(u· ) = σ = πt u0 f (u0 ).
(4.15)
This can be extended, as in [36], to the case of predictable processes in vector bundles over N . In particular if α. is a predictable σ B [T ∗ N ]∗ -valued process along u. , set h∗ (α. )t = αt ◦ hut . If σ A has constant rank this is a predictable process with values in the pull-back, p∗ (E), of E by p. In general it can be considered as an F∗N -predictable E ∗ -valued process because M. (αt ◦ hut ) ◦ σ A = αt ◦ σ B ◦ (Tut p)∗ ∈ Tx∗∗ t In any case we can define πt (h∗ (α. ). )(u0 ) : Cp(u0 ) M + → R as EB,u0 {h∗ (α. )t |p(u· ) = x· }.
4.5
The filtering equation
Theorem 4.5.1. (1) If f is Cc2 N , or more generally if f is C 2 with Bf and σ B (df, df ) bounded, then Z t Z t πt f (u0 ) = f (u0 ) + πs (Bf )(u0 )ds + πs (df ◦ hu· )(u0 )d{xs }. (4.16) 0
0 p(u0 )
In particular {πt f (u0 ) : t > 0} is a continuous F∗
semi-martingale.
72
Chapter 4. Projectible Diffusion Processes and Markovian Filtering
+ (2) For bounded measurable f : M + → R and PA v0 almost all σ in C(M ), for each s, t > 0, µ0 ,σ f (v) = πtµ0 ,σ πsθt σ, µt f (v) (4.17) πt+s σ(0)
for ρµ0
almost all v in N + .
(3) Moreover there exists a family of probability measures Qµν 0 ,σ on C(N + ) defining for ηu0 -almost surely all (σ, v) such that if F : CN + → R is of the form F (u· ) = f1 (ut1 ) . . . fn (utn ) some 0 6 t1 < t2 < · · · tn and bounded measurable fj : N + → R, j = 1, 2, . . . , n, then Z µtn ,θtn−1 σ µ 1 ,θt1 σ F (u)Qµv 0 ,σ (du) = πtµ10 ,σ f1 πt2t−t . . . π f f (v) 2 n −t t 1 n n−1 u∈CN +
= EB µ0 {F (u· )|p(u· ) = σ, u0 = v}, ηµ0 -almost surely in (σ, v). Proof. (1) By definition of M df we have Z f (ut ) = f (u0 ) +
t
Bf (us )ds + Mtdf
0
so Z πt f (u0 ) = f (u0 ) +
t
n o πs Bf (u0 )ds + E Mtdf,B | p(u· ) = x
(4.18)
0
and part (1) follows from Proposition 4.3.5. (2) We observed above that the right-hand side of (4.17) is well defined for PA almost all σ. The equation then follows from the Markov property. µ0 (3) The existence of regular conditional probabilities in our situation implies the existence of the probabilities Qµv 0 ,σ as required, together with a standard use of the Markov property. Remark 4.5.2. A description of the Qµv 0 ,σ is given in Section 4.8, in the case where A is cohesive. Recall that we have the decomposition Fu = Hu + V Tu N for each u ∈ N , and F = tFu . If ` ∈ Fu∗ there is a corresponding decomposition ` = `H + `V ∈ Fu∗ , where `H vanishes on V Tu N and `V on Hu . For ` ∈ Tu∗ N write `V = (`|Fu )V and `H = (`|Fu )H .
4.6. Approximations
73
Corollary 4.5.3. Suppose A is cohesive. If f is Cc3 N , then there is the Stratonovitch equation Z t Z t πs (B V f )(u0 )ds + πs (dfu0 ◦ huo ) ◦ dxs . (4.19) πt f (u0 )(x· ) = f (u0 ) + 0
0
Proof. We use (4.18). By Proposition 4.3.5, H
E{Mtdf | p(u· ) = x· } = E{Mtdf | p(u· ) = x· }. Note that Mtdf
H
Z =
t
(df H )us ◦ dus −
0
Z
t
δ B (df H )(us )ds
0
by Lemma 4.1.2. Furthermore V
H
H
H
δ B (df H ) = δ B (df H ) + δ A (df H ) = δ A (df H ) = δ A (df ) = AH (f ) since df H vanishes on vertical vectors and df = df H + df V while df V vanishes on H horizontal vectors, so δ A (df V ) = 0. This gives Z t Z t πt f (u0 )(x· ) = f (u0 ) + πs (B V f )(u0 )(x· )ds + E (df )H ◦ du ) = x p(u s · · us 0
0
Finally (4.19) follows since dfuH = p∗ (df ◦ hu ) = df ◦ hu ◦ Tu p and Tu p ◦ dut = ◦dxt .
4.6
Approximations
Assume now that the law of ut under PA u0 is given by Z PtA (u0 , A) = PtA (u0 , v)dv, A ∈ B(M ) A
for pA t (u0 , v) a smooth density with respect to some fixed, smooth, strictly positive measure on M to which ‘dv’ refers. This is the case if A is hypoelliptic. Consider the conditional probability qtu0 ,b (V ) = PB u0 {ut ∈ V |p(ut ) = b},
V ∈ B(N )
defined for pA t (u0 , −) almost surely all b in M . There is the disintegration of pB t (u0 , −), Z B pt (u0 , V ) = qtu0 ,b (V )pA t (p(u0 ), db), b∈M
and the formula −1 µµt 0 ,b (V ) = lim[pA t (p(u0 ), b)] ↓0
Z V
A pB t− (u0 , dv)p (p(v), b).
74
Chapter 4. Projectible Diffusion Processes and Markovian Filtering
Take a nested sequence {Π` }∞ l=1 of partitions of [0, t], Πl = {0 = tl0 < tl1 < · · · < tlkl = t}, say, with union dense in [0, t]. For any continuous bounded f : N + → R there is the following approximation scheme to complete πt f (u0 ): Proposition 4.6.1. Z
u ,σ(tl )
v ,σ(tl )
vk
−1 ,σ(t)
qtl0 1 (dv1 )qtl1−tl 2 (dv2 ) . . . qtl l−tl −1 (dvkl )f (vkl ) k k 1 2 1 B l l = lim Eu0 f (ut ) | p(utj ) = σ(tj ), 1 6 j 6 kl }.
πt f (u0 )(σ) = lim
l→∞ l→∞
Proof. The two versions of the right-hand sides are equal before taking limits. For l = 1, 2, . . . , set S l f (σ) = Eu0 f (ut ) | p(utlj ) = σ(tlj ), 1 6 j 6 kl }. + l It is defined for PA x0 -almost all σ in C(M ), where x0 = p(u0 ). Let Q be the σ-algebra on C(M + ) generated by σ 7→ (σ(tl1 ), . . . , σ(tlj )). Directly from the definitions we see πtl f = E{πt (f )(u0 ) | Ql }, ∗ A and so {S l f }∞ l=1 is a Q -martingale. it is bounded and so converges Px0 -almost l surely. Since ∨l Q is the Borel σ-algebra the limit is πt f (u0 ) as required.
4.7
Krylov-Veretennikov Expansion
Pm Suppose A = j=1 LX j LX j + LA for smooth vector fields {X j }m j=1 and A. We will now take {xt : 0 6 t < ζ} to be the solution to the stochastic differential equation (4.20) dxt = X(xt ) ◦ dBt + A(xt )dt, with x0 given, for a Brownian motion B· on Rm , rather than the canonical process. Here X(x) : Rm → Tx M is the map given by X(x)(a1 , . . . , am ) =
m X
aj X j (x),
x ∈ M.
j=1
Let {Pt : t > 0} be the sub-Markovian semi-group generated by B. Let f ∈ Cc∞ N . Assume Pt f ∈ C ∞ N . As in the proof of Theorem 4.5.1, from Z s d(Pt−r f )ur d{ur }, 0 6 s 6 t Pt−s f (us ) = Pt f (u0 ) + 0
4.8. Conditional Laws
75
we obtain Z
s
E {d(Pt−r f )ur ◦ hur | p(u· ) = x· } d{xr }
πs Pt−s (f )(u0 )(x· ) = Pt f (u0 ) + 0
Z
s
E {d(Pt−r f )ur ◦ hur | p(u· ) = x· } X(xr )dBr
= Pt f (u0 ) + 0
so that πs Pt−s f (u0 ), 0 6 s 6 t, is a continuous F∗x0 semi-martingale. Therefore Z t πt f (u0 ) − Pt f (u0 ) = ds (πs Pt−s f (us )) 0 Z t = E {d(Pt−r f ) ◦ hur | p(u· ) = x· } X(xr )dBr 0 Z t = Sr d(Pt−r f ) ◦ h− ◦ X k (p(−)) (u0 )dBrk 0
giving a ‘Clark-Ocone’ formula for πt f (u0 ). Iterating this procedure formally, Z t Sr d(Pt−r f ) ◦ h− ◦ X(p(−)) (u0 )dBr πt f (u0 ) = Pt f (u0 ) + 0 Z tZ r h i + πs dPr−s d(Pt−r f ) ◦ h− ◦ X k (p(−)) h− ◦ X j (p(−) dBsj dBrk 0
0
= ..., we obtain the Wiener chaos expansion of πt f (u0 )(x· ).
4.8
Conditional Laws
It will be convenient to extend the notation of section 4.3. For 0 6 l < r < ∞ let C(l, r; N + ) and C(l, r; M + ) be respectively the space of continuous paths u : [l, r] → N + and x : [l, r] → M + which remain at ∆ from the time of explosion; and Cu0 (l, r; N + ) and Cx0 (l, r; M + ) the paths from u0 ∈ N + and x0 ∈ M + respectively, (l,r),B (l,r),A Let {Pu0 } and {Px0 } be the associated diffusion measures. The conditional law of {us : l 6 s 6 r} given {p(us ) : l 6 s 6 r} will (l,r);A almost surely from be given by probability kernels σ 7→ Ql,r σ,u0 defined P Cp(u0 ) (l, r; M + ) to Cup0 (l, r; N + ) for each u0 ∈ N , where Cup0 (l, r; N + ) is the subspace of Cu0 (l, r; N + ) whose paths satisfy Assumption S. The defining property is that, for integrable f : Cu0 (l, r; N + ) → R, Z f (y)dQl,r (4.21) E {f (u· ) | p(us ) = σs , l 6 s 6 r} = σ,u0 (y). y∈Cu0 (l,r;N + )
To obtain the conditional law take the decomposition B = AH + BV of Proposition 2.2.5. Represent the diffusion corresponding to A by a stochastic differential
76
Chapter 4. Projectible Diffusion Processes and Markovian Filtering
equation dx0t = X(x0t ) ◦ dBt + X 0 (x0t )dt.
(4.22)
Take a connection ∇V on V T N and let (∇V )
dzt = V (zt )dWt + V 0 (zt )dt
(4.23)
be an Itˆo equation whose solutions are B V -diffusions. Here (Wt ) is the canonical Brownian motion on Rm for some m, independent of (B· ), the map V : M × Rm → T M takes values in ker[T p], and V and V 0 are locally Lipschitz. For ˜ : such a representation of BV diffusions see the Appendix, Section 9.2.4. Let X m 0 0 ˜ N × R → H and X : N → H be the horizontal lifts of X and X respectively using Theorem 2.1.2. The solution to the equation of mixed type (∇V )
(l,r),B
has law Pu0
˜ t ) ◦ dBt + X ˜ 0 (yt )dt + V (yt )dWt + V 0 (yt )dt, dyt = X(y u0 ∈ N, l 6 t 6 r. yl = u0 , ˜ . Noting that X(u) = hu X(p(u)) for u ∈ M , (∇V )
dyt = hyt ◦ dx0t + V (yt )dWt + V 0 (yt )dt, yl = u0 , l 6 t 6 r,
(4.24)
where x0t = p(yt ) so that (x0t ) is a solution to (4.22) starting from p(u0 ) at time l. Without changing the law of y· we can replace x0 by the canonical process x· . Then Theorem 4.8.1. Consider the solution (yt ) as a process defined on the probability space Cp(u0 ) (l, r; M + ) × C0 Rm with product measure, y : [l, r] × Cp(u0 ) (l, r; M + ) × C0 Rm → N + , m → Cu0 (l, r; N + ). For bounded and define Ql,r σ,u0 to be the law of y(σ, −) : C0 R + measurable f : Cu0 (l, r; N ) → R,
Z E {f (u· ) | p(us ) = σs , l 6 s 6 r} = y∈Cu0 (l,r;N + )
f (y)dQl,r σ,u0 (y).
4.8. Conditional Laws
77
Proof. Take a measurable function α : Cp(u0 ) (l, r; M + ) → R. Then ! Z B
EPu0
α(p(u)) y∈Cu0 (l,r;N + )
PA p(u
=E
f (y) dQl,r p(u),u0 (y)
!
Z 0)
α(x) y∈Cu0 (l,r;N + )
f (y) dQl,r x,u0 (y)
Z A f (y(x, ω)) dP(ω)) = EPp(u0 ) α(x) C0 Rm Z = α(x)f (y(x, ω)) dPA dP(ω)) p(u0 ) Cp(u0 ) (l,r;M + )×C0 Rm
= Ef (u)α(p(u)), as required.
Note that Theorem 4.8.1 is equivalent to the statement that ω 7→ (l,r),B
ω ∈ Cu0 (l, r; N + ), is a regular conditional probability of Pu0
Ql,r p(ω),u0 ,
given p.
(ξtl (·, ·), l
Remark 4.8.2. Let 6 t < ∞) be a measurable flow for (4.22) and (ηtl (σ, ·, ), 0 6 t < ∞) one for (4.24) with x0 replaced by σ ∈ Cp(u0 ) (l, r; M + ). For ω ∈ Ω, the underlying probability space for the Brownian motion B, define + to itself, by Ql,r ω , from the space of bounded measurable functions on N l l Ql,r ω (f )(u0 ) = Ef ηr (ξr (p(u0 ), ω), u0 ) . A direct calculation shows that r,s l,s Ql,r ω Qω = Qω
for 0 6 l 6 r 6 s < ∞. Thus their adjoints on a suitable dual space would form an evolution. More generally, letting Borel(X) stand for the Borel σ-algebra of a topological space X: Proposition 4.8.3. Let ϕ be a measurable map from Cx0 (l, r; M + ) to some measure space, and let : Cx0 (l, r; M + ) × Borel(Cx0 (l, r; M + )) → [0, 1] P(l,r),ϕ x0 (l,r)
be a regular conditional probability for Px0 given ϕ. For u0 with p(u0 ) = x0 set Z (l,r),ϕ (ω, A) = Ql,r (p(ω), dσ) Ql,r,ϕ◦p u0 σ,u0 (A)Px0 Cx0 (l,r;M + )
is a regular for ω ∈ Cu0 (l, r; N + ) and A ∈ Borel (Cu0 (l, r; N + )). Then Ql,r,ϕ◦p u0 (l,r),B given ϕ ◦ p. conditional probability of Pu0
78
Chapter 4. Projectible Diffusion Processes and Markovian Filtering
Proof. By definition n o l,r (l,r),A,x0 Q (ω, A) = E (A)|ϕ p(ω) Ql,r,ϕ◦p u0 p(−),u0 n o = E(l,r),A,x0 E(l,r),B,u0 {χA |p = −}|ϕ p(ω) = E(l,r),B,u0 {χA |ϕ ◦ p}(ω).
Corollary 4.8.4. For ϕ as in Theorem 4.8.3 suppose that the canonical process (0,T ),ϕ (σ, −) is a semi-martingale for almost all σ, in its own on M + with law Px0 (0,T ),A filtration Ftx0 , 0 6 t 6 T , for Px0 almost all σ. Then the solution y(σ, −) to the equation (∇V )
dyt = hyt ◦ dσt + V (yt )dWt + V 0 (yt )dt, yl = u0 , 0 6 t 6 T (0,T ),ϕ
where σt , 0 6 t 6 T is run with law Px0 from u0 conditioned by ϕ ◦ p.
(4.25)
(σ, −), is a version of the B-diffusion
Proof. That the law of the solution is as required follows from the discussion at the beginning of this section together with Proposition 4.8.3 and Fubini’s theorem. Conditions under which conditioned processes are semi-martingales are discussed by Baudoin [4]. In particular bridge processes derived from elliptic diffusions are, so we obtain the following version of Carverhill’s result [16]: Corollary 4.8.5. Suppose A is elliptic and let bt : 0 6 t 6 T be a version of the A-bridge going from x0 to z in time T , some z ∈ M . Then the solutions to (∇V )
dyt = hyt ◦ dbt + V (yt )dWt + V 0 (yt )dt, y0 = u0 , 0 6 t 6 T
(4.26)
give a version of the B diffusion from u0 conditioned on p(uT ) = z. Example 4.8.6. In Example 2.2.13 and its continuation Example 4.1.7, for all t > 0 the conditional distribution of (us , s ≤ t) given u0 and the path (p(us ), s ≤ t) is determined by the conditional distribution of ((v3 , w1 , w2 )(us ), s ≤ t) given σ(Ws1 , Ws2 , s ≤ t) (Cf formula (4.10) for the definition of the processes W i ). It is the law of Z t v2 (us )dWs , (v3 (u0 ) + Wt , w1 (u0 ) − v2 (u0 )Wt − v3 (u0 )ν2 (ut ) + 2 0
Z w2 (u0 ) + v1 (u0 )Wt + v3 (u0 )ν1 (ut ) − 2
t
v1 (us )dWs ) ,
0
4.9. An SPDE example
79
where Wt is a Wiener process independent of W 1 and W 2 . In particular, the conditional distribution of ut given u0 and the path (p(us ), s ≤ t) is a Gaussian distribution with mean vector v3 (u0 ), w1 (u0 ) − v3 (u0 )ν2 (ut ), w2 (u0 ) + v3 (u0 )ν1 (ut ) . Set g(s) = (1, 2v2 (us ) − v2 (u0 ), v1 (u0 ) − 2v1 (us )), then the covariance is given by Z
t
g(s)g T (s) ds .
0
4.9
An SPDE example
Consider now the SPDE dut (θ) = ∆ut (θ) + ut (θ)dWt + φ(θ)dBt
(4.27)
on the circle S 1 where W and B are independent one-dimensional Brownian motions. Suppose φ : S 1 → R is C ∞ . Let N be the Sobolev space H s (S 1 ; R), for sufficiently large s. Then for a smooth initial condition the solution to equation (4.27) will R t > 0. Take M = R and define p : N → M by R have ut ∈ N for p(u) = S 1 u(θ)dθ. Set m = S 1 φ(θ)dθ. The process xt := p(ut ) satisfies dxt = d{xt } = xt dWt + mdBt 2
∂ and is a diffusion process with generator A = 12 (x2 + m2 ) ∂x 2. xt t If m vanishes, Wt = log( x0 ) + 2 and conditionally to xs , 0 ≤ s ≤ t, ut is a Gaussian Markov process whose law is easily determined. 1 When m does not vanish, equation (4.16) applies. R As an example, for z ∈ S , to find the conditional expectation of ut (z) given { S 1 us (θ) dθ : 0 6 θ 6 t} take f : N → R to be the evaluation δz at z so f (u) = u(z) = δz (u). Then B(δz )(u) = ∆u(z) and therefore B(δz ) = δz ◦ ∆ : N → R. Also (dδz )u = δz for all u since δz is linear. Moreover, using Lemma 2.3.1, we see hu (1) = p(u)u+mφ p(u)2 +m2 ∈ N and so dδz ◦ hu :
R → R is multiplication by
p(u)u(z)+mφ(z) , p(u)2 +m2
(dδz ◦ hu )(λ) = λ
i.e.
pδz (u) + mφ(z) λ ∈ R. p2 + m2
Thus in equation (4.16) πs (dδz ◦ h)(λ) =
pπs (δz ) + mφ(z) (λ) p2 + m2
and
πs (Bδ z ) = πs (δz ◦ ∆)
80
Chapter 4. Projectible Diffusion Processes and Markovian Filtering
and equation (4.16) yields: Z t Z πs (δz ◦ ∆)(u0 )ds + πt (δz )(u0 ) = u0 (z) +
t
pπs (δz ) + mφ(z) (xs dWs + mdBs ). p2 + m2 0 0 (4.28) The SDE for the conditional process can be derived using the decomposition of the noise as in Section 2.3.2. For this write
dut = hut (1)dxt + dut − hut (1)dxt =
xt ut + mφ dxt + ∆ut dt + dMt x2t + m2
where x2t ut + mxt φ xt ut m + m2 φ dWt + φdBt − dBt 2 2 xt + m x2t + m2 m2 ut − mxt φ −xt ut m + x2t φ = dWt + dBt . 2 2 xt + m x2t + m2
dMt = ut dWt −
Note that as expected the bracket hM, xit vanishes. In fact Mt can be obtained by parallel translation of a Brownian motion βt , independent of xt , as explained in Section 2.3.2. The conditional expectation of ut given σ(xs , 0 ≤ s ≤ t) is easily obtained by taking its expectation against any stochastic integral with respect to x (which happens to be a Brownian martingale). We see that the two last terms do not contribute so that, if zt denotes E ut |σ(xs , 0 ≤ s ≤ t) , we have: dzt =
xt zt + mφ dxt + ∆zt dt. x2t + m2
(4.29)
since πs (δz )(u0 ) = zs , in this case the use of the conditioned process is much simpler than the use of the filtering equation (4.16). The latter yields equation (4.28) which would traditionally be interpreted as an equation for a process with values in the space of measures on our Sobolev space H s . The former gives the rather straightforward linear SPDE (4.29). However note that the Fourier coefficients of ut verify linear SDE’s: db ut (k) =
b b bt (k) + mφ(k) bt (k) − mxt φ(k) xt u m2 u 2 dx − k u b (k)dt + dWt t t 2 2 xt + m2 xt + m2 b bt (k)m + x2t φ(k) −xt u + dBt . 2 2 xt + m
As before we see that the two last terms do not contribute under our conditioning, and for zt as above, db zt (k) =
b xt zbt (k) + mφ(k) dxt − k 2 zbt (k)dt. 2 2 xt + m
4.10. Equivariant case: skew-product decomposition
81
which is a linear equation from which zbt , and so zt , can be computed in the standard way. This formula can be recovered easily from equation (4.16) as, if we take f (u) = u b(k), we have Bf = −k 2 f and df ◦ hu =
b p(u)f (u)+mφ(k) , p(u)2 +m2
so that πs (Bf ) =
b pπs (f )+mφ(k) . p2 +m2
−k 2 πs (f ) and πs (df ◦ h) = More complicated equations can be given for the conditional expectations of functions of u bt (k). They involve the vertical part of the generator B.
4.10
Equivariant case: skew-product decomposition
In the equivariant case, when N is the total space P of a principal bundle π : P → M as in Chapter 3, a version of Theorem 4.8.1 is given in [34] which reflects the additional structure. In particular the following is proved there: Proposition 4.10.1. Let B be an equivariant diffusion operator on P which induces a cohesive diffusion operator A on M . Let {yt : 0 6 t < ζ} be a B-diffusion on P . Then ˜t · gtx˜· , yt = x where (i) {˜ xt : 0 6 t < ζ} is the horizontal lift of p(y· ), starting at y0 , using the semi-connection induced by B, (ii) {gtσ : 0 6 t < ζ(σ)} is a diffusion independent of {p(yt ) : 0 6 t < ζ} on G starting at the identity with time dependent generator Lσt given by Lσt f (g) =
X
αij (σ(t) · g)LA∗i LA∗j f (g) +
X
β k (σ(t)g)LA∗k f (g),
i,j
0 6 t < ζ(σ), for any σ ∈ CM + , where A∗1 , . . . , A∗k are the left invariant vector fields on G corresponding to a basis of g and the αij and β k are the coefficients for B V as in Theorem 3.2.1. Note that for each t the operator Lσt is conjugate to the restriction of B V to the fibre through σ(t) by the map G 7→ g
7→
p−1 (p(σ(t))), σ(t)g.
It is a right-invariant operator. Remark 4.10.2. Note that by the equivariance of Lσ· there will be no explosion of the process (gtσ ) before that of σ· . Consequently Assumption S of §4.3 holds automatically.
82
Chapter 4. Projectible Diffusion Processes and Markovian Filtering
Below we give the equivariant version of Proposition 4.8.1. We shall use the notation of §4.8. However we replace the one-point compactification P + of P by P¯ = P ∪ ∆ with the smallest topology agreeing with that of P and such that π : P¯ → M + is continuous. Also let G+ be the one-point compactification G ∪ ∆ of G with group multiplication and action of G extended so that u · ∆ = ∆, ∆ · g = g · ∆ = ∆,
¯ ∀u ∈ P¯ , g ∈ G.
For 0 6 l < r < ∞ if y ∈ C(l, r; P¯ ), we write ly = l and ry = r. Let C(∗, ∗; P¯ ) be the union of such spaces C(l, r; P¯ ). It has the standard additive structure under concatenation: if y and y 0 are two paths with ry = ly0 and y(ry ) = y 0 (ly0 ) let y + y 0 be the corresponding element in C(ly , ry0 ; P¯ ). The basic σ-algebra of C(∗, ∗, P¯ ) is defined to be the pull-back by π of the usual Borel σ-algebra on C(∗, ∗; M + ). : Given an equivariant diffusion operator B on P consider the laws {P(l,r),B a a ∈ P } as a kernel from P to C(l, r; P¯ ). The right action Rg by g in G+ extends to give a right action, also written Rg , of G+ on C(∗, ∗, P¯ ). Equivariance of B is equivalent to = (Rg )∗ P(l,r),B P(l,r),B ag a (l,r),B
for all 0 6 l 6 r and a ∈ P . Therefore π∗ (Pa ) depends only on π(a), l, r and gives the law of the induced diffusion A on M . We say that such a diffusion B is basic if for all a ∈ P and 0 6 l < r < ∞ the basic σ-algebra on C(l, r; P¯ ) contains (l,r),B all Borel sets up to Pa negligible sets, i.e. for all a ∈ P and Borel subsets B of (l,r),B π −1 (A)∆B = 0. C(l, r; P¯ ) there exists a Borel subset A of C(l, r, M + ) s.t. Pa For paths in G it is more convenient to consider the space C˜id (l, r; G+ ) of cadlag paths σ : [l, r] → G+ with σ(l) = id such that σ is continuous until it leaves G and stays at ∆ from then on. It has a multiplication C˜id (s, t; G+ ) × C˜id (t, u; G+ ) −→ C˜id (s, u; G+ ) (g, g 0 ) 7→ g × g 0 where (g × g 0 )(r) = g(r) for r ∈ [s, t] and (g × g 0 )(r) = g(t)g 0 (r) for r ∈ [t, u]. Given probability measures Q, Q0 on C˜id (s, t; G+ ) and C˜id (t, u; G+ ) respectively this determines a convolution Q ∗ Q0 of Q with Q0 which is a probability measure on C˜id (s, u; G+ ). (l,r),B
Theorem 4.10.3. Given the laws {Pa : a ∈ P, 0 6 l < r < ∞} of an equivariant : a ∈ P } from diffusion B over a cohesive A there exist probability kernels {PH,l,r a l,r a.s. from C(l, r; P¯ ) to P to C(l, r; P¯ ), 0 6 l < r < ∞ and y 7→ Ql,r y , defined P C˜id (l, r; G+ ) such that : a ∈ P } is equivariant, basic and determining a cohesive generator. (i) {PH,l,r a (ii) y 7→ Ql,r y satisfies ly ,r
0
l
0 ,ry 0
Qy+yy0 = Qlyy ,ry ∗ Qyy0
for Ply ,ry ⊗ Ply0 ,ry0 almost all y, y 0 with ry = ly0 .
4.11. Conditional expectations of induced processes on vector bundles (iii) For U a Borel subset of C(l, r; P¯ ), Z Z Pl,r (U ) = a C(l,r;P¯ )
+) ˜ C(l,r;G
83
H,l,r χU (y· · g· )Ql,r (dy). y (dg)Pa
H,l,r ¯ The kernels PH,l,r are uniquely determined as are the {Ql,r a y : y ∈ C(l, r; P )}, Pa a.s. in y for all a in P . Furthermore Ql,r y depends on y only through its projection π(y) and its initial point yl .
The proof of this theorem is as that of Theorem 2.5 in [34] (although there the processes are assumed to have no explosion). Stochastic differential equations can be given for (˜ xt ) and (gtσ ) as in §4.8, from which the decomposition can be proved via Itˆo’s formula; see Theorem 8.2.5 below for details of a special case. Proposition 4.10.1 extends results for Riemannian submersions by ElworthyKendall [33] and related results by Liao[69]. A rich supply of examples of skewproduct decomposition of Brownian motions, with a general discussion, is given in Pauwels-Rogers[87]. For a special class of derivative flows, considered as a GLM -valued process as in §3.3, there is a different decomposition by Liao [70], see also Ruffino [94].
4.11
Conditional expectations of induced processes on vector bundles
In the notation of §3.4 let ρ : G → L(V, V ) be a C ∞ representation with Πρ : F → M the associated bundle. A B-diffusion {yt : 0 6 t < ζ} on P determines a family of {Ψt : 0 6 t < ζ} of random linear maps Wt from Fx0 → Fxt , where xt = π(yt ). By definition, Ψt [(y0 , e)] = [(yt , e)]. Assuming A is cohesive we have the parallel translation //t : Fx0 → Fxt along {xt : 0 6 t < ζ} determined by our semi-connection. This is given by //t [(y0 , e)] = [(˜ xt , e)] where x ˜· is the horizontal lift of x, starting at y0 . When taken together with Corollary 3.4.9 the following extends results for derivative flows in Elworthy-Yor[38], Li[68], Elworthy-Rosenberg [37], and Elworthy-LeJan-Li[36]. See the Notes below, Section 4.12. Theorem 4.11.1. Let ρ : G → L(V ; V ) be a representation of G on a Banach space V and Πρ : F → M the associated vector bundle. Let {yt : 0 6 t < ζ} be a B-diffusion for an equivariant diffusion operator B over a cohesive diffusion operator A. Set xt = p(yt ) and let Ψt : Fx0 → Fxt , 0 6 t < ζ be the induced
84
Chapter 4. Projectible Diffusion Processes and Markovian Filtering
transformations on F . Then the local conditional expectation {Ψt : 0 6 t < ζ}, for Ψt = E{Ψt |σ{xs : 0 6 s < ζ} exists and is the solution of the covariant equation along {xt : 0 6 t < ζ}: D Ψt = Λρ ◦ Ψt ∂t with Ψ0 the identity map, Λρ : F → F given by λρ in Theorem 3.4.1 and where refers to the semi-connection determined by B.
D ∂t
Proof. From above and Proposition 4.10.1 we have xt ◦ gtx˜ , e)] = [(˜ xt , ρ(gtx˜ )−1 e] Ψt [(y0 , e)] = [(˜ and so //t−1 Ψt [(y0 , e)] = [(y0 , ρ(gtx˜ )−1 e)]. Now from the right invariance of Gtσ , for fixed path σ and time t, we can apply Baxendale’s integrability theorem, [7], for the right action G × L(V ; V ) → L(V ; V ) (g, T ) → 7 ρ(gtσ )−1 ◦ T to see E|ρ(gtσ )−1 |L(V ;V ) < ∞ for each σ, t and we have E(σ)t ∈ L(V ; V ) given by E(σ)t e = Eρ(gtσ )−1 e. By considering //t−1 Ψt we see that the local conditional expectation Ψt exists in L(Fx0 ; Fxt ) and Ψt [(y0 , e)] = [(˜ xt , E(x· )t e)]. The computation in Theorem 3.4.1 shows that d −1 d // Ψt [(y0 , e)] = [(y0 , E(x· )t e)] = [(y0 , λρ (˜ xt )E(x· )t e)] dt t dt giving D Ψt [(y0 , e)] = [(˜ xt , λρ (˜ xt )E(x· )t e)] = Λρ (x· )Ψt [(y0 , e)] dt as required.
Remark 4.11.2. Theorem 4.11.1 could also be used to identify the generator of the operator induced on sections of F ∗ , re-proving Theorem 3.4.1, since if φ ∈ γF ∗ , then Eφ ◦ Ψt χt<ζ = Eφ ◦ Ψt χt<ζ if the expectations exist, by Corollary 3.3.5 of [36]. The extra information in Theorem 4.11.1 is the existence of the conditional expectation. Baxendales’ integrability theorem used for this applies in sufficient generality to give corresponding results for infinite dimensional G, for e