The Hodge Conjecture

Ai OL_}i UL?iU|hi M)  #i*}?i 41 Vwdwhphqw1 `i hiU@** |@| @ Tti_L UL4T*i t|hU|hi L? @  " 4@?uL*_ f Lu _4i?tL? 2 t @ F4L_*i t|hU|hi L? |i |@?}i?| M?_*i Af  5U @ 4L_*i t|hU|hi ?_Uit @? @U|L? Lu |i }hLT FW L? Af c | b 5 FW @U|?} M) 4*|T*U@|L? M) b ) |h@?tTLh| Lu ? t|hU|hitc |i }hLT FW @U|t @*tL L? i@U i |ihLh TLih a Af c @t i** @t L? |i UL4T*i ? _@* l? G' OL4Ea Af c F 6Lh R n ^ ' ?c @ ERc ^uLh4 t @ tiU|L? Lu l? L? U b 5 FW 7 3^  @U|t M) 4*|T*U@|L? M) b3R b 6hL4 ?L L?c i @tt4i f UL4T*i @?@*)|U  ERc ^uLh4 t |i? @ uLh4 Uc ? *LU@* L*L4LhTU ULLh_?@|itc U@? Mi h||i? @t [ @ ccR c ^ _5    _5R _7 5    _7 5^ c 2

2

2

2

2

@?_ |i _iUL4TLt|L? l? ' lRc^ ?_Uit @ _iUL4TLt|L? _ ' _ n _ Lu |i i |ihLh _gihi?|@*c | _ EhitT _  Lu _i}hii Ec f EhitT Efc  Wu f t UL4T@U| @?_ @_4|t @ k@*ih 4i|hUc uLh ?t|@?Ui u f t @ ThLiU|i ?L? t?}*@h @*}iMh@U @hi|)c |t @U|L? Lu F L? uLh4t ?_Uit @? @U|L? L? ULL4L*L}) Lhi ThiUti*)c M ? Efc F t |i tT@Ui Lu U*Lti_ ?uLh4t 4L_*L i @U| uLh4tc @?_ u i _i€?i M Rc^ |L Mi |i tT@Ui Lu U*Lti_ ERc ^uLh4t 4L_*L |i _ _ Lu ER  c ^  uLh4tc |i ?@|h@* 4@T 







W



E



 M Rc^ $ M ? Efc F

n^ '?

R

t @? tL4LhTt4 Wu i ULLti @ k@*ih t|hU|hi L? fc L?i U@? }i |i uL**L?} ? |ihThi|@|L? |L |i _iUL4TLt|L? E Lu M ? Efc FG |i @U|L? Lu F L? uLh4t UL44|it | |i w@T*@Ui LTih@|Lhc i?Ui ?_Uit @? @U|L? Lu F L? |i tT@Ui ? Lu @h4L?U W

W

?uLh4t `i @i ? $M ? Efc F @?_ M Rc^ _i?|€it | |i tT@Ui Lu @h4L?U ERc ^ uLh4t ;

`i? f 4Lit ? @ L*L4LhTU u@4*)c |i OL_}i €*|h@|L? 8 R G'  M @c?3@ Lu @DR M ? Efc F t Mi||ih Mi@i_ |@? |i OL_}i _iUL4TLt|L? wLU@**) L? |i T@h@4i|ih tT@Ui A c M ? Ef| c F t ?_iTi?_i?| Lu | 5 A @?_ |i OL_}i €*|h@|L? U@? Mi ii_ @t @ @h@M*i €*|h@|L? 8 E| L? @ € i_ iU|Lh tT@Ui W| @hit L*L4LhTU@**) | |c @?_ LMi)t Bh|t |h@?tiht@*|)G @| €ht| Lh_ih @hL?_ |f 5 A c 8 R E| hi4@?t ? 8 R3 E|f  5L u@hc i @i UL4T|i_ ULL4L*L}) t?}  " uLh4t `i UL*_ @t i** @i ti_ uLh4t | }i?ih@*3i_ u?U|L?t ULiUi?|tc |@| tc Uhhi?|t Ai hit*|?} }hLTt M ? Efc F @?_ M Rc^ @hi |i t@4i Wu ~ t @ U*Lti_ @?@*)|U tMtT@Ui Lu fc Lu UL4T*i UL_4i?tL? Rc ~ t @? ?|i}h@* U)U*i @?_c M) L?U@h‚i _@*|)c _i€?it @ U*@tt U*E~ ? M 2R Efc ] Ai ?|i}h@|L? Uhhi?| L? ~ t @ U*Lti_ ERc RuLh4 | }i?ih@*3i_ u?U|L? ULiUi?|tc hiThiti?|?} |i 4@}i Lu U*E~ ? M 2R Efc F Ai U*@tt U*E~ ? M 2R Efc ] t i?Ui Lu |)Ti ERc Rc ? |i ti?ti |@| |t 4@}i ? M 2R Efc F t +@|L?@* ERc RU*@ttit @hi U@**i_ OL_}i U*@ttit Ai) uLh4 |i }hLT M 2R Efc T _ M RcR Ef ' M 2R Efc T _ 8 R  M 2R Efc F W? dSoc OL_}i TLti_ |i Krgjh frqmhfwxuh ? @ ThLiU|i ?L? t?}*@h @*}iMh@U @hi|) Lih Fc @?) OL_}i U*@tt t @ h@|L?@* *?i@h UL4M?@|L? Lu U*@ttit U*E~ Lu @*}iMh@U U)U*it 51 Uhpdunv1 E ) L
S 5 M 2 Efc ] Lu |)Ti Ec  @t 4@}i f ? |i ^L|i?| M fc2 ' M 2 Efc  Lu M 2 Efc Fc @?_ |i *L?} i @U| Lu ULL4L*L}) _i€?i_ M) |i i TL?i?|@* i @U| ti^i?Ui i TE2Z



f $ ] $  $ W $ f tLt |@| S t |i €ht| ih? U*@tt Lu @ *?i M?_*i E Ai hi*@|L? Mi|ii? @*}iMh@U U)U*it @?_ @*}iMh@U iU|Lh M?_*it t @*tL |i M@tt Lu |)@ @?_ Oh3iMhU |iLhi4 d2o |@| |i OL_}i UL?iU|hi U@??L| L*_ ?|i}h@**) W? |i |)@Oh3iMhU tTiU|h@* ti^i?Ui uhL4 ULL4L*L}) |L |LTL*L}U@* g|iLh)G .2R^ ' M R Efc g ^ E |  ', g Rn^ Efc |i hit*|?} €*|h@|L? Lu g ? Ef t M) |i 8 R g ? Ef ' kihEg ? Ef $ g ? EER  t!i*i|L?c ? @?) |h@?}*@|L? ,^@*i?|*)c @ U*@tt S t ? 8 R u uLh tL4i |LTL*L}U@* tMtT@Ui t Lu UL_4i?tL? Rc S t |i 4@}i Lu @ U*@tt S | tTTLh| ? t  Wu ~ t @? @*}iMh@U U)U*i Lu UL_4i?tL? Rc @ hitL*|L? Lu ~ _i€?it @ g|iLh) U*@tt | tTTLh| ? ~G S~ 5 g f Efc f  ~ W|t 4@}i ? 8 R g f Ef @}hiit | |i U*@tt Lu ~ ? M 2R Efc ] Ai *@|ih i?Ui t ? |i !ih?i* Lu |i tUUitti _gihi?|@*t _o Lu |i tTiU|h@* ti^i?Ui L U)U*i ? M 2R Efc ]c !**i_ M) @** _o @?_ Lu |)Ti ERc Rc t !?L? ?L| |L Mi @? ?|i}h@* *?i@h UL4M?@|L? Lu U*@tt U*E~ ?i @t ?L _i@ Lu U U*@ttit tL*_ Mi igiU|ic |@| tc Lu |i uLh4 U*E~c h@|ih |@? @ _gihi?Ui Lu tU ? @ 5|i? 4@?uL*_ fc @?) |LTL*L}U@* UL4T*i iU|Lh M?_*i U@? Mi }i? @? L*L 4LhTU t|hU|hi @?_c @| *i@t| uLh f Lu |i L4L|LT) |)Ti Lu @ €?|i ` UL4T*i c | uL**Lt |@| @?) U*@tt ? M 2R Efc ] ? |i !ih?i* Lu @** _o t @ ]*?i@h UL4M?@|L? Lu U*@ttit Lu @?@*)|U U)U*it E Ai @tt4T|L? ? |i OL_}i UL?iU|hi |@| f Mi @*}iMh@U U@??L| Mi i@!i?i_ |L f Mi?} 4ihi*) k@*ih 5ii ~U!ih
61 Wkh lqwhuphgldwh mdfreldq1 Ai ULL4L*L}) U*@tt Lu @? @*}iMh@U U)U*i ~ Lu UL_4i?tL? R @t @ ?@|h@* *u| |L @ }hLT aR Efc i |i?tL? Lu |i }hLT Lu U*@ttit Lu |)Ti ERc R ? M 2R Efc ] M) |i ?|ih4i_@|i @ULM@? aR Eff G' M 2R3 Efc ] q M 2R3 Efc F*8 R  At i Thittit |@| |i U*@tt U@? Mi }i? @? ?|i}h@* _itUhT|L? E? t?}*@h ULL4L*L})c @t i** @t @? @?@*)|U L?ic @t @ U*Lti_ ERc R Uhhi?|c }?} @ )TihULL4L*L}) U*@tt ? K2R Lu |i tMUL4T*i 8 R lWL* G' Ef $    $ f $ lRL* $     Lu |i L*L4LhTU _i +@4 UL4T*i c | @? ?_iht|@?_?} @| |i ULU)U*i *ii* Lu ) |i |L @}hii ? M 2R Efc F W?_ii_c aR Ef t |i )TihULL4L*L}) K2R Lu |i L4L|LT) !ih?i* Lu |i _gihi?Ui 4@T ]  8 R lWL* $ lW  W? }i?ih@*c t?} |@| @** @*}iMh@U U)U*it L? f €| ? @ _i?4ih@M*i ?4Mih Lu @*}iMh@U u@4*itc L?i UiU!t |@| |i tM}hLT R Ef Lu aR Ef }i?ih@|i_ M) @*}iMh@U U)U*it t |i i |i?tL? Lu @ _i?4ih@M*i }hLT M) |t UL??iU|i_ UL4TL?i?| fR Efc @?_ |@| uLh tL4i tMOL_}i t|hU|hi M@*} Lu |)Ti iER  c Rc ERc R  j Lu M 2R3 Efc fR Ef t M@*} q M X *8 R  R5MOL_}i t|hU|hi 4i@?tG tM}hLT Lu |i ?|i}h@* *@||Uic | UL4T*i €U@|L? t4 Lu |t ?|ihtiU|L?t | |i M @cK  Ai OL_}i UL?iU|hi E@TT*i_ |L |i ThL_U| Lu f @?_ @ t|@M*i @Mi*@? @hi|) Thi_U|t |@| M t |i M}}it| tMOL_}i t|hU|hi Lu M R3 Ef Lu |)Ti iER  c RERc R  j L UL?iU|hi t @@*@M*i |L Thi_U| @| tM}hLT Lu aR Ef |i }hLT R Ef t @tit @hi !?L? ihi R Ef*R Ef t Lu ?€?|i h@?! 5ii uLh ?t|@?Ui |i hiUi?| T@Tih dbo @?_ |i hiuihi?Uit | UL?|@?t At @t 4@_i }i?ih@**) ?@TT*U@M*i |i 4i|L_t ?|hL_Ui_ M) Bh|t Etiic uLh ?t|@?Uic ~U!ih do |L ThLi |i OL_}i UL?iU|hi M) ?_U|L? L? |i _4i?tL? Lu fc t?} @ wiutUi|3 Ti?U* Lu )TihT*@?i tiU|L?t Lu f W?_ii_c |i 4i|L_ hi^hit ?L| t| |i OL_}i UL?iU|hi uLh |i )TihT*@?i tiU|L?t Mc M| |@| @** Lu aR EM UL4it uhL4 @*}iMh@U U)U*it @*}

@*}

2



f

71 Ghwhfwlqj Krgjh fodvvhv1 wi| Efr rM7 Mi @? @*}iMh@U u@4*) Lu ThLiU|i ?L? t?}*@h @*}iMh@U @hi|itG |i €Miht Lu @ ThLiU|i @?_ t4LL| 4@T s G f $ 7 `i @tt4i | t _i€?i_ Lih |i 7 Lu T ? F L @*}Lh|4 t !?L? |L _iU_i i|ih @ }i? ?|i}h@* @*}iMh@U U*Lthi T ULL4L*L}) U*@tt Lu @ |)TU@* €Mih ff t tL4iihi L? 7 Lu |)Ti ERc R Ai OL_}i e

UL?iU|hi 4T*it |@| |i *LUt ihi |t @TTi?t t @ _i?4ih@M*i ?L? Lu @*}iMh@U 7 E?!?L? tM@hi|it Lu 7 E!?L?G tii deoc @?_ t _i€?i_ Lih T ,i? u ? }i?ih@* | t _U*| |L _i|iU| OL_}i U*@ttitc |ihi @hi U@tit Lu ?|i}h@* U)U*it U @hi U*i@h*) ERc Rc @?_ uLh U |i OL_}i UL?iU|hi t T@h|U*@h*) |@?|@*3?} , @4T*i  6Lh f Lu UL4T*i _4i?tL? c |i _@}L?@* { Lu f  f t @? @*}iMh@U U)U*i Lu UL_4i?tL?  Ai OL_}i _iUL4TLt|L? Mi?} UL4T@|M*i | k ??i|c |i k ??i| UL4TL?i?|t U*E{@cK 5 M @ Ef M K Ef  M  Ef  f E@ n K ' 2 Lu U*E{ @hi OL_}i U*@ttit 2

, @4T*i 2 Wu # 5 M Efc ] t |i ULL4L*L}) U*@tt Lu @? )TihT*@?i tiU|L? Lu fc |i |ih@|i_ UT ThL_U| # R G M  3R Efc F $ M  R Efc F t @? tL4LhTt4 E@h_ wiu tUi|3 |iLhi4c ThLi_ M) OL_}i 5ii dfo WVS wi| \ 5 M  3R Efc F M  3R Efc F  M  3 R Ef f Mi |i U*@tt tU |@| |i ?ihti tL4LhTt4 E# R 3 t S :$ Th E\^ThW S Ai U*@tt \ t OL_}i 2

n

2

2



-

2

81 Prwlyhv1 *}iMh@U @hi|it @_4| @ T@?LT*) Lu ULL4L*L}) |iLhitc hi*@|i_ Lih F M) UL4T@h tL? tL4LhTt4t +it*|?} t|hU|hit L? M W Efc ] tL*_ Mi ii_ @t @?@*L}Lt |L |i OL_}i t|hU|hi , @4T*itG u f t _i€?i_ Lih @ tM€i*_ g Lu Fc | @*}iMh@U U*Lthi 7 ? Fc B@*Eg*g 7 g @U|t L? M W Efc ] ] @?_ M W Efc F ' M W Efc ] F @t @ ?@|h@* gt|hU|hi M#+ Ef Lih gc UL4T@|M*i | |i OL_}i €*|h@|L? ALti ULL4L*L}) |iLhit }i hti |L UL?iU|hit T@h@**i* |L |i OL_}i UL?iU|hic _i|ih4??} |i *?i@h tT@? Lu U*@ttit Lu @*}iMh@U U)U*it , @4T*iG |i A@|i UL?iU|hi dHo ALti UL?iU|hit @hi LTi? ii? uLh M 2  BhL|i?_iU!
D

91 Vxevwlwxwhv dqg zhdnhqhg irupv W? _itT@hc igLh|t @i Mii? 4@_i |L €?_ tMt|||it uLh |i OL_}i UL?iU|hi ? @Mi*@? @hi|itc OL_}i U*@ttit @| *i@t| t@hi 4@?) ThLTih|it Lu ULL4L*L}) U*@ttit Lu @*}iMh@U U)U*itG |i) @hi R@MtL*|i*) OL_}i Ed oc ii? R4L|@|i_ Edo At tUit uLh tL4i @TT*U@|L?t  uLh ?t|@?Ui |i ThLLu Lu @*}iMh@U hi*@|L?t @4L?} TihL_t @?_ ^@t TihL_t Lu @Mi*@? @hi|it Thi_U|i_ M) |i OL_}i UL?iU|hi Ed oc M| _Lit ?L| @**L uLh hi_U|L? 4L_*L R Ai uL**L?} ULhL**@h) Lu |i OL_}i UL?iU|hi L*_ Mi T@h|U*@h*) ?|ihit|?} wi|  Mi @? @Mi*@? @hi|) Lih |i @*}iMh@U U*Lthi I Lu @ €?|i €i*_ I^  wu|  ? |L _gihi?| @)t |L U@h@U|iht|U fc |L UL4T*i @Mi*@? 7 U! OL_}i U*@ttit \ @?_ \2 L?  @?_ 2 c Lu @hi|it  @?_ 2 _i€?i_ Lih T UL4T*i4i?|@h) _4i?tL? W?|ihThi|?} \ @?_ \2 @t @_U ULL4L*L}) U*@ttitc L?i U@? _i€?i |i ?|ihtiU|L? ?4Mih V Lu |i hi_U|L? Lu \ @?_ \2 Lih I Wt V @ h@|L?@* ?4Mihq Wu \ @?_ \2 ihi U*E~  @?_ U*E~2 c ~ @?_ ~2 UL*_ Mi ULti? |L Mi _i€?i_ 7 @?_ V L*_ Mi |i ?|ihtiU|L? ?4Mih Lu |i hi_U|L?t Lu ~ @?_ ~2  Lih T

S

+iuihi?Uit do v ?_h‚ic Lh ?i |‚iLhi ?UL?_|L??i**i _it 4L|utc M* @| WO,5 H EbbS T Deb d2o  6 |)@ @?_ 6 Oh3iMhUc ?@*)|U U)U*it L? UL4T*i 4@?uL*_tc ALTL*L})  EbS2 T 2DeD d o  #i*}?i Eh‚i_}‚i T@h a w h)*?t!c )U*it _i OL_}i @MtL* i| T‚ihL_it _it ?|‚i}h@*it _it @h‚i|‚it @M‚i*i??itc ‚i4Lhit 56 2 EbHf T 2   deo  #i*}?ic , @||@? @?_  k@T*@?c ? |i *LUt Lu OL_}i U*@ttitc a5 H 2 EbbD T eH DfD dDo  BhL|i?_iU!c OL_}i
.