The Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 A Legal Primer to an Emerging International Regime
By
Moira L. McConnell Dominic...
281 downloads
1490 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
The Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 A Legal Primer to an Emerging International Regime
By
Moira L. McConnell Dominick Devlin Cleopatra Doumbia-Henry
LEIDEN • BOSTON 2011
This book is printed on acid-free paper. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data McConnell, Moira L. (Moira Lynne), 1956The Maritime Labour Convention, 2006 : a legal primer to an emerging international regime / by Moira L. McConnell, Dominick Devlin and Cleopatra Doumbia-Henry. p. cm. Includes index. ISBN 978-90-04-18375-9 (hardback : alk. paper) 1. Maritime Labour Convention (2006) 2. Merchant mariners–Legal status, laws, etc. 3. Labor laws and legislation, International. I. Devlin, Dominick. II. Doumbia-Henry, Cleopatra. III. Title. K1196.A42006M38 2011 343.09'6–dc22 2011006123
ISBN 978 90 04 18375 9 Copyright 2011 by Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, The Netherlands. Koninklijke Brill NV incorporates the imprints Brill, Global Oriental, Hotei Publishing, IDC Publishers, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers and VSP. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, translated, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission from the publisher. Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use is granted by Koninklijke Brill NV provided that the appropriate fees are paid directly to The Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Suite 910, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. Fees are subject to change.
CONTENTS
Preface and Acknowledgements. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . vii Abbreviations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xi List of Figures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xiii
part i Chapter One. Overview and Introduction to the Maritime Labour Convention, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chapter Two. The Story of the Maritime Labour Convention, . . . . . . . Chapter Three. The Maritime Labour Convention, as an Instrument of the International Labour Organization. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chapter Four. Overview of the ILO’s Supervisory System: More than Years of Supervision . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3 37 63 93
part ii Chapter Five. Mapping the Terrain: Structure and Substance in the Maritime Labour Convention, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chapter Six. Principles and Rights—The Articles (and the Preamble). . . . . Chapter Seven. Title : Minimum Requirements for Seafarers to Work on a Ship . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chapter Eight. Title : Conditions of Employment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chapter Nine. Title : Accommodation, Recreational Facilities, Food and Catering . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chapter Ten. Title : Health Protection, Medical Care, Welfare and Social Security Protection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chapter Eleven. Title : Compliance and Enforcement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chapter Twelve. Conclusion and Reflections . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
115 165 243 275 337 389 473 563
appendices Appendix . Negotiation History Leading to the Maritime Labour Convention, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 575 Appendix . Annotated Maritime Labour Convention, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 577 Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 679
PREFACE AND ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This book was completed in the fifth year following the adoption of the Maritime Labour Convention, (MLC, )—the ‘seafarers’ bill of rights’— by the th (Maritime) Session of the International Labour Conference of the International Labour Organization (ILO), one of the oldest of the United Nations’ organizations and the first to become a UN specialized agency. It is also the year in which we expect that the very demanding legal requirement for entry into force of this convention, the / formula, will be achieved. Then the foundational work—the dreaming, designing, and construction, implementing process—will enter a new phase. This important new international law of the sea ‘framework’ convention that seeks to bring social justice and fair competition to the maritime world will be truly tested by the experiences of seafarers on the ships that ply the world’s oceans. Will it float? Will it in fact achieve the aspirations of the international seafarers’ and shipowners’ organizations that first conceived of it and the more than government delegations that supported its development and adoption? Will it be able to achieve real change and transcend the ‘paper tiger’ that international legal instruments so often appear to be, with their dependence on good faith effective national implementation. Certainly the tools—the combination of the best of the ILO’s traditional approaches based on tripartism, independent labour inspection, complaints systems, and the ILO supervisory system with the international maritime regulatory regime based on ship inspections and certification and port State control (essentially, spot checks) and the no more favourable treatment (fair competition) economic system approach—should serve to make the dreams a reality for seafarers and shipowners. But the key, as is often the case, lies not only with the good faith implementation of legal obligations by ratifying countries, but with the more difficult problem in a globalized sector of ensuring sufficient technical knowledge and capacity to implement on a widespread, ideally universal, basis. The three authors hope that this book, with its bifurcated (two part) structure and its mix of practical and scholarly and archival information, will prove to be a useful resource that will inform and assist a diverse audience. It is aimed at the cadre of maritime and law of the sea practitioners that will have the opportunity and cause to work with the MLC, , implementing it nationally or assisting shipowners or seafarers in its implementation, or those with an interest in the further development of the law of the sea and ocean governance regimes.
viii
preface and acknowledgements
Published in both print and as an E-book, this volume includes, as an appendix, the text of the page annotated MLC, . Three important additional sources of information about the MLC, that are frequently referred to in the body of the book, as well as the travaux préparatoires, are all available on the website of the ILO. For the convenience of of readers three key sources are also available (along with hypertext link to the relevant website of the ILO which contains many of the referenced materials), for download at http://brill.nl/MLC_. The first key resource is the “Article Report” that ratifying countries will be required to submit to the ILO regarding implementation of the MLC, , once it enters into force. This Report is the basis of the review of state-level compliance by the ILO’s supervisory system, which is discussed in detail in Chapter . The other two key resources also referred to throughout the book are the Guidelines for Flag State Inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, and the Guidelines for Port State Control Officers Carrying out Inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, . While from a legal perspective they cannot be considered as interpreting the text, they provide an authoritative tripartite view on the practical application of the Convention’s requirements. It is hoped that these additional resources will provide useful references for appreciating the more technical and operational elements of the MLC, . This book arose out of our work together over nearly a decade, in differing roles, to help develop the text of the Convention and then to help advance its rapid ratification and effective implementation. This is also an international book with its three authors living and working in three countries—Halifax, Canada; Rome, Italy; and Geneva, Switzerland—with much of our work reflecting modern working conditions and a shared workspace based on electronic communication and virtual presence. Each author has been responsible for the drafting of differing parts of the book, and in the case of one chapter on the ILO supervisory system, has also had the benefit of a contribution by another ILO expert, Tomi Kohiyama, International Labour Standards Department, ILO, Geneva. Thus the commentary and analysis in this book reflects our shared thoughts and ideas, developed through extensive discussions and experiences over nearly a decade of engagement to support the tripartite negotiations that led to this major new international legal instrument. However an important caveat must also be noted: the views in this book reflect the personal views of its authors, or co-authors as the case may be, and are not the views of the ILO or the International Labour Office. Each author has brought differing expertise to the project. Cleopatra Doumbia-Henry brought her maritime and international labour law scholarship and expertise combined with extensive legal and practical experience in the ILO with the supervision of international legal standards and her direct
preface and acknowledgements
ix
engagement with facilitating international and national level tripartism and social dialogue. Dominick Devlin, an international organizations lawyer with a career of legal advisory work in the legal department of a number of UN specialized agencies, including his role as a Legal Adviser for the ILO and, subsequently, as a Special Advisor to the ILO in connection with the MLC, , as well as his current position as Chair of the World Intellectual Property Organization Appeal Board, brought extensive expertise in international institutions law, legal drafting, and ‘problem solving’ through legal text. Moira L. McConnell, a Professor of Law and member of the Marine & Environmental Law Institute based in the Schulich School of Law at Dalhousie University, with her expertise in law of the sea, maritime law, international environmental law, and international regulatory systems as well as significant experience with national level law reform, brought both academic analysis and international law expertise. Trite though it may seem to say—the whole is, indeed, greater than the sum of the parts. As the content of this book reveals, an immense intellectual debt is owed to the shipowner and the seafarer representatives who dreamed and decided to act and to build on achievements of the past. They saw a way forward, even foreseeing many details of this Convention, and then worked steadily to bring it to fruition. Equally important is the guidance and ideas of far-sighted government representatives. Each of the authors, of course, have their personal debts, and gratitude and thanks must be expressed to acknowledge the unstinting support and sacrifices by their spouses and families and friends, all of whom one way or another have travelled with us on the voyage of the MLC, . Our collective thanks to Peter Katadotis, Carla Devlin, and Zandiougou, Zani and Bassi Doumbia for their patience and years of unflinching support. Some other acknowledgements and our sincere thanks to a few others are also in order. Our thanks to Susan Rolston of Seawinds Consulting Services, Halifax, Canada, for her professionalism in editing and her interest in this lengthy project through to completion. Dominick Devlin would like to express his indebtedness to Francis Maupain, ILO Legal Adviser from to , for his advice and support. Cleopatra Doumbia-Henry would like to express her special thanks to Mary Giacobino for more than ten years of unswerving support and to the ILO for giving her the opportunity to lead this monumental exercise. Moira McConnell would also like to express her gratitude to Dalhousie University and the Faculty of Law for the sabbatical leave that has provided her with time and support to allow completion of this book. Our collective thanks also to our publishers at Martinus Nijhoff/Brill for their patience with the length of time it has taken to finally produce the text. The only justification that can be given is that the
x
preface and acknowledgements
Convention is growing up alongside the book and the book has indeed benefited from the growth. Moira L. McConnell Halifax, Canada
Dominick Devlin Rome, Italy
Cleopatra Doumbia-Henry Geneva, Switzerland February
ABBREVIATIONS CBA CFA DMLC ECOSOC EEZ EU FOC GB GT HLTWG ICJ ICMA ILC ILO ILS IMO ISF ISM Code ITF JMC LILS LOSC MARPOL MLC MLC, MOU NGO OHS OSH PSC PSCO PTMC PTMLC RO SEA SMD SOLAS SPS Code
collective bargaining agreement Committee on Freedom of Association Declaration of Maritime Labour Compliance Economic and Social Council of the United Nations exclusive economic zone European Union flag of convenience Governing Body (ILO) gross tonnage High-level Tripartite Working Group on Maritime Labour Standards (ILO) International Court of Justice International Christian Maritime Association International Labour Conference International Labour Organization international labour standards International Maritime Organization International Shipping Federation International Safety Management Code International Transport Workers’ Federation Joint Maritime Commission Committee on Legal Issues and International Labour Standards (ILO) United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, International Convention on the Prevention of Pollution from Ships, as amended Maritime Labour Certificate Maritime Labour Convention, memorandum of understanding non-governmental organization occupational health and safety occupational safety and health port State control port State control officer Preparatory Technical Maritime Conference Preparatory Tripartite MLC, Committee recognized organization seafarers’ employment agreement safe manning document International Convention for the Safety of Life at Sea, as amended Code of Safety for Special Purpose Ships,
xii STCW
abbreviations
International Convention on Standards of Training Certification and Watchkeeping for Seafarers, as amended STM Committee Committee on Sectoral and Technical Meetings and Related Issues (ILO) STWGMLS Tripartite Subgroup of the High-level Tripartite Working Group on Maritime Labour Standards (ILO) UNCTAD United Nations Conference on Trade and Development WHO World Health Organization WTO World Trade Organization
LIST OF FIGURES Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure Figure
The eight ‘preferred solutions’ of the shipowners and seafarers Titles and appendices of MLC, Example of vertical integration Chairperson’s summary Legal Adviser’s opinion on the status of Part B of the Code Guidance for an approach to the implementation of the MLC, Inclusion of the area of recruitment and placement in Appendices A-I and A-III Figure Promotion of employment resolutions adopted by the th ILC Figure Overview of Title regulations (and sub-regulations) Figure Consensual Statement of Principles and Rights adopted by the Meeting of Experts on Working and Living Conditions of Seafarers on board Ships in International Registers, May
PART I
chapter one OVERVIEW AND INTRODUCTION TO THE MARITIME LABOUR CONVENTION, 2006
Overview: An Approach to International Maritime and Labour Law This book was completed in , following the ninetieth year since the adoption of the first maritime labour instrument in 1 by the then newlyestablished International Labour Organization (ILO).2 The year was also the year declared by the International Maritime Organization (IMO)3 as the ‘year of the seafarer’.4 The publication of this book in , shortly after the fifth anniversary of the adoption of the Maritime Labour Convention, (MLC, ),5 a major new maritime labour instrument, by the th International Labour Conference (ILC) of the ILO is significant. At the time the MLC, was adopted, it was expected that it would take approximately five years to achieve the ratifications necessary to bring this comprehensive maritime convention into force.6 Although at the time of completion of this book, the MLC, is not yet in force,7 it is expected that the stringent formula for entry into
1
On July , at its Genoa session, the ILO adopted the National Seamen’s Code Recommendation, (R), available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/recdisp.htm. 2 The ILO, a specialized agency of the United Nations, maintains its headquarters (the International Labour Office) in Geneva, Switzerland. See: http://www.ilo.org. 3 The IMO is a specialized agency of the United Nations. See: http://www.imo.org. 4 See: IMO, “IMO Council makes the ‘Year of the seafarer’,” available at http://www.imo .org/newsroom/mainframe.asp?topic_id=&doc_id=. 5 See: ILO, “Maritime Labour Convention, ,” available at http://www.ilo.org/global/ standards/maritime-labour-convention/WCMS_/lang-en/index.htm. The MLC, , adopted on February , is available in eight languages. Appendix in this book contains an annotated version of the Convention. 6 See: ILO, Action Plan to achieve rapid and widespread ratification and effective implementation of the Maritime Labour Convention, (Action Plan –) adopted in September , available at http://www.ilo.org/global/standards/maritime-labour-convention/ WCMS_/lang-en/index.htm. 7 As of February the Convention has been ratified by twelve countries that are the flag States for over per cent (by gross tonnage (GT)) of the world’s fleet (in order of ratification: Liberia, the Marshall Islands, Bahamas, Panama, Norway, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Spain, Croatia, Bulgaria, Canada, St Vincent and the Grenadines, Switzerland).
chapter one
force will be met in , with entry into force months8 later in . The MLC, has a bold agenda aimed at creating change at both the level of the workplace and international practice. It was strategically designed to place minimum international labour and social standards for seafarers—the essential human element—on the same footing as the increasingly effective international regulatory regime to ensure ship safety, security and protection of the marine environment from ship-source pollution. When the MLC, enters in force it is clear that it will have a major impact on the maritime sector.9 The international maritime regulatory system has a well-established and generally effective approach that has been developed over the last century to address the jurisdictional challenges posed by the primarily international character of this sector. It has many elements but chief amongst them are the widespread ratification by States with a maritime interest,10 combined with effective implementation and a system for compliance and enforcement that directly targets compliance by non-State actors (shipowners/ships) in addition to traditional international law concerns with State-level compliance. However, from a legal and institutional perspective, labour and social rights in the maritime sector uncomfortably straddle both shipping and labour expertise and practice. In fact, the issue of maritime labour or seafarers’ rights often risks falling between these two areas, in both international and domestic legal systems. In part this is because the international maritime regulatory regime is based on the international law of the sea and flag State and port State responsibility whilst labour and employment law, even if implementing standards in international conventions, is by contrast, more concerned with domestic law and is founded on territorial jurisdiction and national practice. This poses a 8
The entry into force formula under Article VIII of the MLC, is: . This Convention shall come into force months after the date on which there have been registered ratifications by at least Members with a total share in the world gross tonnage of ships of at least per cent.
9 In fact it has already had a discernable impact on the industry and organizations concerned with developing capacity to inspect and certify ships for compliance with the Convention or inspect for compliance under port State control when ships enter their ports. Several ships have already been inspected and certification has been prepared ahead of the relevant flag State ratification. See, for example: Shiptalk, “V Good,” February , available at http://www.shiptalk .com/?p=. See also with respect to recruitment and placement services: Shiptalk, “MLC Moves,” August , available at http://www.shiptalk.com/?p=, and OSM, “OSM: The first ever to be certified per the ILO Maritime Labour Convention!” (dated ..), available at http://www.osm.no/view_casearticle.asp?id=&news=news. 10 Traditionally there are three kinds of interests or faces to a State’s possible interest under the law of the sea: flag State, port State, and coastal State (see below at pp. –). As will be discussed throughout this book, the MLC, introduces a fourth law of the sea ‘face’ for States, that of labour-supplying responsibilities.
overview and introduction
challenge for the implementation of international conventions that are at the intersection of maritime and labour law. It may also be an explanation for the relative dearth of legal research and scholarship on this topic which cuts across matters that are, themselves, also specialized legal fields.11 It also poses a challenge for national implementation, in part because there is a paucity of people with expertise in both areas and because of the traditionally fragmented approach to the management of issues in most countries and internationally. Given the significant impact that this Convention will have when it enters into
11 There is a significant body of specialized research on seafarers, largely by maritime economists, specialist maritime or transport institutes, or by practitioners working with organizations representing seafarers. See, for example, the numerous empirical and other studies published by the Seafarers International Research Centre (SIRC), Cardiff University (http://www.sirc.cf.ac .uk/). See also: Nathan Lillie, “The ILO Maritime Labour Convention, : A new paradigm for global labour rights implementation,” in Cross-Border Social Dialogue and Agreements: An Emerging Global Industrial Relations Framework?, Konstantinos Papdakas, ed. (Geneva: ILO, International Institute for Labour Studies, ), –; Nathan Lillie, A Global Union for Global Workers: Collective Bargaining and Regulatory Politics in Maritime Shipping (New York: Routledge, ); Lisa Tortell, Rudi Delarue, and Jeffrey Kenner, “The EU and the ILO Maritime Labour Convention: ‘In our common interest and in the interest of the world’,” Chapter , in The European Union and the Social Dimension of Globalization: How the EU Influences the World, Jan Orbie and Lisa Tortell, eds. (New York: Routledge, ), . However other than ‘plain language’ industry handbooks prepared by shipowners’ and seafarers’ organizations, there is relatively little legal scholarship. In addition to various publications by the authors of this book, there have been a few interesting legal articles and studies on the MLC, by authors either involved with negotiation of the Convention, such as a member of the United States’ delegation, John Isaac Blanck, Jr., “Reflections on the negotiation of the Maritime Labor [sic] Convention at the International Labor [sic] Organization,” (–) Tulane Maritime Law Journal –, or larger studies undertaken by doctoral or other researchers such as Alexandre Charbonneau, Marche International Du Travail Maritime Un Cadre Juridique En Formation, Doctoral dissertation, , Faculté de Droit et des Sciences Politiques, Université de Nantes; Paul Bauer, “The Maritime Labour Convention: An adequate guarantee of seafarer rights or an impediment to true reforms?” (–) Chicago Journal of International Law –, or ILO experts, for example, Patrick Bolle, “The ILO’s new Convention on maritime labour: An innovative instrument,” () International Labour Review –, or legal scholars/practitioners that are involved in advocating for seafarers rights, such as Peter Payoyo, “The contribution of the ILO Maritime Labour Convention to global governance,” in The Future of Ocean Regime-Building: Essays in Tribute to Douglas M. Johnston, Aldo Chircop, Ted L. McDorman, and Susan J. Rolston, eds. (Leiden/Boston: Martinus Nijhoff/Brill, ), –. In that respect, Seafarers’ Rights, Dierdre Fitzpatrick and Michael Anderson, eds. (Oxford: Oxford University Press, ) is an important edited collection of studies of the both sources of rights combined with examples of protection under the national law of several countries. There is also a useful collection that reproduces and/or summarizes the texts of ILO maritime conventions with some analysis of provisions, in some cases relative to the MLC, , and some national legal references drawn from the ILO Committee of Experts reports by Iliana Christodoulou-Varotsi and Dmitry A. Pensov, Maritime Work Law Fundamentals: Responsible Shipowners, Reliable Seafarers (Berlin: Springer, ).
chapter one
force, it is important that greater knowledge and legal expertise and understanding of the Convention and the topic of maritime labour be developed. Viewed from a wider international law and maritime law perspective the MLC, also constitutes a further elaboration of the international maritime regulatory regime under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (LOSC)12 as it pertains to conditions on ships voyaging on the high seas and an approach to responding effectively to a globalized13 sector and better ensuring implementation and enforcement at the shipboard/seafarer level. In fact, the MLC, can be understood as filling a significant gap in the LOSC—long considered the ‘constitution for the oceans’. Despite its constitutive character, which was “[p]rompted by the desire to settle, in a spirit of mutual understanding and cooperation, all issues relating to the law of the sea” and aimed at “. . . establishing through this Convention, with due regard for the sovereignty of all States, a legal order for the seas and oceans”,14 the drafters of the LOSC failed to do more than peripherally address the use of the ocean,
12
United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, December , UN Doc. A/Conf. /, I.L.M. (entered into force on November ), available at http://www.un.org/ depts/los/convention_agreements/texts/unclos/closindx.htm. 13 See infra note and text at p. . The word ‘globalization’ and its offshoots, much like the term ‘sustainable development’ have various definitions and both positive and negative connotations depending on the disciplinary perspective or institution affiliation, for example, political, economic, or cultural. The following description, adopted in the preamble to the ILO Declaration on Social Justice for a Fair Globalization adopted by the th ILC on June , captures the main characteristics and concerns from a labour/employment perspective (emphasis added): Considering that the present context of globalization, characterized by the diffusion of new technologies, the flow of ideas, the exchange of goods and services, the increase in capital and financial flows, the internationalization of business and business processes and dialogue as well as the movement of persons, especially working women and men, is reshaping the world of work in profound ways: – on the one hand, the process of economic cooperation and integration has helped a number of countries to benefit from high rates of economic growth and employment creation, to absorb many of the rural poor into the modern urban economy, to advance their developmental goals, and to foster innovation in product development and the circulation of ideas; – on the other hand, global economic integration has caused many countries and sectors to face major challenges of income inequality, continuing high levels of unemployment and poverty, vulnerability of economies to external shocks, and the growth of both unprotected work and the informal economy, which impact on the employment relationship and the protections it can offer; . . . Convinced that in a world of growing interdependence and complexity and the internationalization of production: . . . 14
LOSC, supra note , Preamble.
overview and introduction
particularly the high seas, as a workplace or a site for human rights.15 As discussed later in this chapter these matters are simply left to the ‘default’ jurisdiction of the relevant flag State with a ‘genuine link’ to the ship and its general obligation to “effectively exercise its jurisdiction and control in administrative, technical, and social matters over ships flying its flag”.16 In terms of increased integration of UN organizations and international law-making activities, the high level of cross-fertilization between the IMO17 and the ILO is also clearly evidenced in the process to develop this Convention and in the text itself. With its interwoven labour and social rights and economic goals the MLC, is an international legal instrument that will also have a significant impact on approaches to securing decent work/minimum labour conditions for ‘globalized’ workers.18 The move to certification of working and living conditions— essentially a rights-based regime that uses the economic realities in the sector as leverage—is an especially important step by the ILO that may be of much wider significance. While not all aspects of the MLC, will be transferable, some elements, such as the structural approach to convention design, promotion of solutions to the problem of countries where there are no representative organizations of workers or employees, ways to provide a ‘floor’ of social protection, including, as yet, development of the insurance sector to address globalized workers. For example, the MLC, contains a number of specific structural 15 There are, however, some human rights provisions relating to slavery and piracy, although arguably wider human security rights are also encompassed in connection with, for example, the provisions governing the protection of the marine environment or living resources. 16 LOSC, supra note , Arts – ff. and see infra at pp. –. 17 Supra note . 18 See supra note and Lillie , supra note , p. (citations removed):
The forces that increasingly shape industrial relations are international, transnational, supra-national, or all three. International trade and investment put workers in distant locations in competition with one another. Transnational firms benchmark labour costs and work practices across borders, while unions and nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) compare conditions in factories around the world, pressuring firms to observe labour rights under threat of consumer boycott. Supranational organizations, in which nation States “pool” their sovereignty (most notably the European Union) form a new arena of industrial relations outside and in a sense above national industrial relations systems. Global labour rights standards are increasingly used as a frame of reference for judging the practices of employers and the claims of labour rights advocates. In so far as corporations retain unilateral control of how these rights are applied, this trend represents a privatization of rights formally guaranteed in the public sphere. The case of the ILO Maritime Labour Convention, (MLC) shows, however, that where there are sufficiently transnational and coherent global political actors representing labour and capital (particularly labour), global tripartitism in the International Labour Organization (ILO) context holds the promise of reintroducing effective state enforcement of labour standards.
chapter one
and substantive innovations related to important ILO values such as tripartism19 and encouraging social dialogue20 at the national levels as a mechanism for resolving specific national implementation issues. This approach, combined with a multi-level, multi-actor system based approach to ensuring effective implementation through more strategic compliance and enforcement activities, provides an opportunity for reflection on the broader questions of international law-making, and the relationship between States, private actors, and questions of governance.21 The Structure and Approach of This Book This two-part book with chapters authored22 (or co-authored23) by international law practitioners and scholars with combined expertise in the public international law of the sea, maritime law, and international labour law and, more specifically, direct involvement with the development of the MLC, over nearly a decade, is primarily concerned with providing a detailed legal analysis of the Convention text. It is specifically directed to labour, human rights, and maritime law and policy scholars and practitioners. However, it is also specifically intended to be of interest to a wide and diverse range of scholars and practitioners interested in international law in general, and law of the sea in particular, as well as those interested in international institutions and international relations and regulatory system/treaty design. It presents a number of arguments, from various perspectives, regarding the potential role and importance of the MLC, . The four main perspectives can be loosely categorized as: 19 States are represented in the ILO by national delegations. Under the ILO Constitution, the ‘State’ is conceived of as a tripartite entity comprising workers, employers, and government. Although only governments can ratify conventions (and be held accountable in international law), all three vote on the adoption of international legal instruments at the ILO using a weighted voting formula. See infra note . 20 The term ‘social dialogue’ also has a particular meaning for the ILO. See infra note . 21 See discussion infra at note . 22 Moira L. McConnell, Professor of Law and Faculty Associate of the Marine & Environmental Law Institute at Schulich School of Law, Dalhousie University, Canada, was also a Special Adviser to the ILO during the development and follow-up of the Convention; Dominick Devlin, the former Legal Adviser to the International Labour Office in Geneva is currently a Special Adviser to the ILO and Chair of WIPO Board of Appeal; Cleopatra Doumbia-Henry, Director of the International Labour Standards Department of the ILO, Geneva, has been responsible for the International Labour Office activities to develop the MLC, since the late s and is also responsible for the ILO supervisory system. The views expressed in this book are personal views of the authors and are not to be attributed to or understood as reflecting the views of the ILO. 23 Chapter on the ILO’s supervisory system was co-authored by Cleopatra Doumbia-Henry and Tomi Kohiyama, Assistant to the Director, International Labour Standards Department, ILO, Geneva.
overview and introduction – – – –
labour/employment law maritime regulation law of the sea international law and governance
This ambitious intra- and interdisciplinary reach reflects the view that, despite sharing the public law field and relationships through UN organizations, these law of the sea/maritime and labour areas draw upon differing experts and expertise and traditional legal, political, and institutional values at both the national and international levels. This book has been designed to provide a comprehensive legal resource on this important international convention and area of practice and research. It comprises chapters (including this present introductory chapter and the conclusion) organized into two Parts, with two appendices. The two appendices provide a brief review of the negotiation process for the MLC, (Appendix ) as well as the full text of the MLC, (Appendix ) with annotations providing additional information regarding the ILO conventions and recommendations that are consolidated in the MLC, . Part I, comprising four chapters, including the present chapter, provides an orientation to the MLC, in the context of the ILO and international labour standard-setting practices and supervision. It also serves as an introduction to the international maritime regulatory framework within which the MLC, also fits. The second half of the book, Part II, constitutes the main part of this book with seven substantive chapters and a conclusion. It is chiefly concerned with a detailed examination of the text of the MLC, , essentially, from a legal perspective. It provides a detailed discussion and analysis of the Convention text drawing on the ILO’s Provisional Records (travaux préparatoires) of meetings leading up to its adoption and other sources available to the authors. Part II provides a documented analysis of all key provisions and approaches adopted in this comprehensive and complex convention. The seven substantive chapters begin by exploring the drafting history for structural elements and the development of the text over the five years of negotiation (Chapter ). This is followed by detailed discussion in Chapter of the Articles of the Convention, and, in Chapters –, of the five Titles and Appendices to the MLC, . The exegesis of the Convention’s provisions in Part II is subject to a caveat. Like any other legal instrument, understandings at the time a convention is negotiated,24 and the records of these understandings, to the extent that they 24 Both recollections and the people involved change over time and ‘meaning’ evolves; inevitably there is a risk that the contextual understanding that can be brought to bear on any analysis of a legal text is lost. This is common to all legal instruments and can have the advantage of
chapter one
illuminate the text of the instrument, play an important role in the analysis of a text’s ‘meaning’ and, more importantly, what it means for national implementation and application to particular situations. In addition, general principles of international law relating to the interpretation of treaties, such as those found in the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties,25 are also important. Final recourse to the International Court of Justice (ICJ) for an authoritative interpretation also applies to the MLC, .26 This means that any commentary, including views based on the intentions captured in the travaux préparatoires, is, at best, explanatory and, ultimately, speculative. allowing a text to grow and evolve, freed from its history. But it can also mean that negotiated understandings that inform the application of a text are betrayed or misunderstood and defeat the objectives of an instrument. Not surprisingly, preambles to record the objectives of a convention have grown in length and detail in an effort to capture this context. 25 Done at Vienna on May , U.N.T.S. , entered into force on January , available at http://untreaty.un.org/ilc/texts/instruments/english/conventions/__ .pdf. Section , Interpretation of Treaties, of the Convention provides that: Article , General rule of interpretation . A treaty shall be interpreted in good faith in accordance with the ordinary meaning to be given to the terms of the treaty in their context and in the light of its object and purpose. . The context for the purpose of the interpretation of a treaty shall comprise, in addition to the text, including its preamble and annexes: a) any agreement relating to the treaty which was made between all the parties in connection with the conclusion of the treaty; b) any instrument which was made by one or more parties in connection with the conclusion of the treaty and accepted by the other parties as an instrument related to the treaty. . There shall be taken into account, together with the context: a) any subsequent agreement between the parties regarding the interpretation of the treaty or the application of its provisions; b) any subsequent practice in the application of the treaty which establishes the agreement of the parties regarding its interpretation; c) any relevant rules of international law applicable in the relations between the parties. . A special meaning shall be given to a term if it is established that the parties so intended. Article , Supplementary means of interpretation Recourse may be had to supplementary means of interpretation, including the preparatory work of the treaty and the circumstances of its conclusion, in order to confirm the meaning resulting from the application of Article , or to determine the meaning when the interpretation according to Article : a) leaves the meaning ambiguous or obscure; or b) leads to a result which is manifestly absurd or unreasonable. 26
Constitution of the International Labour Organisation, Art. , para. , available at http:// www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/constq.htm.
overview and introduction
Additional sources of legal information about the MLC, include the ILO’s Article Report on the MLC, 27 which provides supplementary information on the expectations of the ILO’s international supervisory system (see Chapter ) regarding ratifying States’ obligations to implement the Convention. Governments will be required to complete a report on how they have implemented the MLC, , once it enters into force. This report is the basis of the review of State-level compliance by the ILO’s supervisory system and is an important aspect of the multi-pronged compliance and enforcement system of the MLC, and other ILO conventions. The Report itself is of interest for both its innovative format and its approach to the use of the shipboard documentation. The Guidelines for Flag State Inspection System under the Maritime Labour Convention, 28 (hereinafter Guidelines for Flag State Inspection) and the Guidelines for Port State Control Officers Carrying Out Inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, 29 (hereinafter Guidelines for Port State Control Officers) address the more practical implementation questions such as ‘how to check’ for compliance, at the shipboard level, with national laws or measures implementing the MLC, . These guidelines were adopted in by an ILO tripartite meeting of experts. They are intended to achieve a level of harmonization in the implementation of a convention that also emphasizes national flexibility in implementation.30 While from a legal perspective they cannot be 27
Reports of the Committee on Legal Issues and International Labour Standards: Second Report: International labour standards and human rights, ILO Governing Body, Geneva, March , GB.// (Rev), Appendix IV, pp. –, available at http://www.ilo.org/global/standards/ maritime-labour-convention/WCMS_/lang--en/index.htm. 28 International Labour Office, Guidelines for Flag State Inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, (Geneva: ILO, ), available at http://www.ilo.org/wcmsp/groups/public/ed_norm/-normes/documents/publication/wcms_.pdf. This document is also available at http://brill.nl/MLC_. 29 International Labour Office, Guidelines for Port State Control Officers Carrying Out Inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, (Geneva: ILO, ), available at http://www .ilo.org/wcmsp/groups/public/-ed_norm/-normes/documents/publication/wcms_.pdf. This document is also available at http://brill.nl/MLC_. 30 As explained in the Preface to the Guidelines for Flag State Inspection, supra note , page V (citations removed): . . . A key feature of the MLC, , is that it builds on the strengths of the ILO approach to making sure that, in each country, international labour standards are effectively implemented at the “ground level” and enforced. At the same time the MLC, , meets the challenges of this globalized industry by taking over many elements that are found in other major maritime Conventions and have contributed to the success of those Conventions in ensuring safer and secure shipping and preventing marine pollution. The most important of these elements is found in the emphasis in the MLC, , on effective flag State inspection and certification of ships. Flag State inspectors, including those from Recognized Organizations, are at the front line of the combat to ensure decent conditions of work for seafarers. An effective and coordinated system of regular inspections, monitoring and other control measures of ships adopted by the competent
chapter one
considered as interpreting the Convention text, they provide an authoritative tripartite view on the practical application of its requirements and a reference for international lawyers assessing the implications of the more technical and operational elements of the MLC, . This is particularly important in the context of social and economic rights—matters often thought of as intangible or as potentially subjective and difficult to inspect. The Guidelines provide a useful if non-binding ‘interpretive’ resource that will be discussed from time to time throughout this book. Introduction: The ILO and the Legal and Maritime Law Context of the MLC, The remainder of this chapter provides an introduction to the ILO and highlights some of the key points about the MLC, and its background. These
authorities in flag States is the primary tool for ensuring that ships meet the requirements of the Guidelines for flag State inspections under the MLC, as implemented in national laws, regulations, collective bargaining agreements and practice. The International Labour Conference saw the importance of ensuring that the MLC, , was backed up by an effective system for inspections by flag States complemented by a widespread harmonized port State control. It adopted two key resolutions intended to support the promotion, ratification and effective implementation of the Convention and the achievement of decent working and living conditions for seafarers. These two resolutions are . . . Resolution XIII on developing guidelines for flag State inspection requested the ILO Director-General to convene a tripartite expert meeting to develop “. . . suitable guidance for flag State inspection.” The resolution explained that the success of the Convention will depend, among others, upon the uniform and harmonized implementation of flag State responsibilities in accordance with its relevant provisions, and that given the global nature of the shipping industry, it is important for flag State inspectors to receive proper guidelines for the performance of their duties. Developing international guidelines and the related national flag State inspections and guidelines for their inspectors is an important aspect of implementation of the MLC, , and an essential aspect of ensuring widespread harmonized implementation of the MLC, . . . . Each country may have its own practices relating to flag State inspection. The flag State’s competent authorities of the various countries may wish to adapt these guidelines to fit their current practices. These international guidelines are designed to be of practical assistance to governments in drafting their own national guidelines. It is hoped that they will, at the same time, achieve their primary aim—namely, effective flag State inspection and, where appropriate, certification of ships for compliance with the requirements of the MLC, , as implemented nationally. If this is achieved, seafarers will benefit from decent conditions of work, not only in law but also in practice.
overview and introduction
ideas31 are explored in more detail, from differing perspectives, in Chapters , , and . The remainder of this chapter also provides a brief overview of the international maritime regulatory regime, including the legal framework in the LOSC and some basic information about the ILO. The purpose of this part of the chapter is to provide introductory information on concepts and terminology in the fields covered by this book. It is directed to readers that may not have experience with the ILO or alternatively may be unfamiliar with maritime regulatory regime and law of sea or any of these fields. The International Labour Organization The ILO32 was formed in after the end of World War I as part of the peace settlement under the Treaty of Versailles.33 Its formation was part of the beginning34 of what has been described as “[o]ne of the most creative innovations of the international diplomatic community in the th century . . . [the] international regime”.35 The Preamble to the ILO Constitution sets out the aspirations of the creators of the earliest of the international organizations.36 It highlights 31
See also M.L. McConnell, “ ‘Making labour history’ and the Maritime Labour Convention, : Implications for international law making (and responses to the dynamics of globalization),” in The Future of Ocean Regime-Building: Essays in Tribute to Douglas M. Johnston, Aldo Chircop, Ted L. McDorman, and Susan J. Rolston, eds. (Leiden/Boston: Martinus Nijhoff/Brill, ), –. 32 The initial name used the spelling ‘Organisation’, as reflected in the title of its constitution, Constitution of the International Labour Organisation. 33 See Chapter . See also: ILO, “Origins and history,” available at http://www.ilo.org/global/ About_the_ILO/Origins_and_history/lang-en/index.htm. Aside from being one of the earliest of the international organizations, predating the United Nations, the ILO differs in several important respects from other UN organizations, the most predominant of which is its tripartite nature (see supra note and infra note ). 34 Aldo Chircop, Ted L. McDorman, and Susan J. Rolston, eds., “Introduction: Setting the Stage,” in The Future of Ocean Regime-Building: Essays in Tribute to Douglas Johnston (Leiden/Boston: Martinus Nijhoff/Brill, ), p. . 35 Douglas M. Johnston, The Historical Foundations of World Order: The Tower and the Arena (Leiden: Martinus Nijhoff, ), p. , also cited in Chircop et al., ibid. 36 In the ILO became the first UN specialized agency after the UN was established. The ILO describes it itself as . . . devoted to advancing opportunities for women and men to obtain decent and productive work in conditions of freedom, equity, security and human dignity. Its main aims are to promote rights at work, encourage decent employment opportunities, enhance social protection and strengthen dialogue in handling work-related issues. In promoting social justice and internationally recognized human and labour rights, the organization continues to pursue its founding mission that labour peace is essential to prosperity. The Member States of the ILO (as of February ) accomplish their work through three main bodies (the International Labour Conference, Governing Body, and the Office), all of which comprise government, employer and worker representatives. The International Labour Conference (ILC) meets in June annually to establish international labour standards and the broad
chapter one
the connection between labour conditions, human rights, social justice, and international peace and, also importantly, a nascent awareness of the primary challenges confronting the current international economic system, preventing ‘the race to the bottom’ in the face of increasingly globalized industries: Whereas universal and lasting peace can be established only if it is based upon social justice; And whereas conditions of labour exist involving such injustice hardship and privation to large numbers of people as to produce unrest so great that the peace and harmony of the world are imperilled; and an improvement of those conditions is urgently required . . . Whereas also the failure of any nation to adopt humane conditions of labour is an obstacle in the way of other nations which desire to improve the conditions in their own countries; The High Contracting Parties, moved by sentiments of justice and humanity as well as by the desire to secure the permanent peace of the world, and with a view to attaining the objectives set forth in this Preamble, agree to the following Constitution of the International Labour Organisation . . .
Uniquely, the ILO operates on the basis of a core value called tripartism, which is embedded in its Constitution and the institutional structure it establishes. Tripartism is perhaps most simply described37 as follows: The ILO aims to ensure that it serves the needs of working women and men by bringing together governments, employers and workers to set labour standards, develop policies and devise programmes. Its tripartite structure makes the ILO
social and labour policies of the ILO. At periodic intervals the ILO holds an extra ILC session devoted to addressing issues in the maritime sector. Two government delegates, an employer delegate and a worker delegate represent each Member State at the ILC. Technical advisors assist the delegations, which are usually headed by Cabinet Ministers who take the floor on behalf of their governments. Employer and worker delegates can freely express themselves and vote according to instructions received from their organizations. They sometimes vote against each other or even against their government representatives. Elected by the ILC, the Governing Body is the executive council of the ILO. It takes decisions on ILO policy and establishes the programme and the budget, which it then submits to the Conference for adoption. It also elects the Director-General. Composed of government members, employer members and worker members, States of chief industrial importance permanently hold ten of the government seats. Government representatives are elected at the Conference every three years, taking into account geographical distribution. The employers and workers elect their own representatives respectively. The International Labour Office is the permanent secretariat of the ILO and is the focal point for ILO’s overall activities, which it prepares under the scrutiny of the Governing Body and under the leadership of the Director-General For further details on the structure and operation of the ILO. For more information, see: “Who we are,” available at http://www.ilo.org/global/about-the-ilo/who-we-are/lang-en/index.htm. 37 See: ILO, “Tripartism,” available at http://www.ilo.org/global/About_the_ILO/Structure/ tripartism/lang-en/index.htm.
overview and introduction
unique among world organizations because employers’ and workers’ organizations have an equal voice with governments in all its deliberations. . . . Underlying the ILO’s work is the importance of cooperation between governments, employers’ organizations and workers’ organizations in fostering social and economic progress. Dialogue among and between the governments and the two “social partners” promotes consensus building and democratic involvement of those with vital stakes in the world of work. The ILO is the only “tripartite” United Nations agency in that it brings together representatives of governments, employers and workers to jointly shape labour standards, policies and programmes. The ILO encourages tripartism within member States by promoting social dialogue to help design and implement national policies. Achieving fair terms of employment, decent working conditions, and development for the benefit of all cannot be achieved without the active involvement of workers, employers and governments, including a broad-based effort by all of them.
This process of negotiation and consultation is described as ‘social dialogue’, a process that can occur nationally or internationally. The term social dialogue also has a specific meaning in the ILO.38 These values inform ILO activities including the development and adoption of the conventions such as the MLC, or other international labour instruments.39
38 The ILO defines social dialogue to include all types of negotiation, consultation and exchange of information between, or among, representatives of governments, employers and workers on issues of common interest. See: ILO, “Social Dialogue,” available at http://www.ilo.org/global/ about-the-ilo/decent-work-agenda/social-dialogue/lang-en/index.htm. How social dialogue actually operates varies from country to country and from region to region. Effective social dialogue depends on:
– Respect for the fundamental rights of freedom of association and collective bargaining; – Strong, independent workers’ and employers’ organizations with the technical capacity and knowledge required to participate in social dialogue; – Political will and commitment to engage in social dialogue on the part of all parties; – Appropriate institutional support The main goal of social dialogue itself is to promote consensus building and democratic involvement among the main stakeholders in the world of work. Successful social dialogue structures and processes have the potential to resolve important economic and social issues, encourage good governance, advance social and industrial peace and stability and boost economic progress. Social dialogue can mean negotiation, consultation or simply an exchange of information and views between representatives of employers, workers and governments. 39 Chircop et al., supra note . Since , the ILO has adopted conventions, five protocols, and recommendations (often described as international labour standards (ILS) (see Chapters and )). Until recently, ILO conventions tended to be either issue and/or sector specific, were usually fairly brief, and followed a standard format of specific requirements on the particular topic, with no preamble and all the mandatory (“shall”) provisions set out in articles. Normally, relatively few ratifications are required to bring the conventions into force. Recommendations are often adopted along with conventions and contain additional technical provisions framed as ‘should’. Once a convention is adopted by a two-thirds majority of the annual ILC there is an immediate obligation under the ILO’s Constitution on each Member to place it
chapter one Background to the MLC,
These ILO concerns and values were applied from the very beginning to labour conditions for seafarers, the workers in the earliest of the global industries. Establishing minimum labour standards that are universally applied irrespective of the nationality of the seafarer, the ship, or the shipowner has been a preoccupation of the ILO since its earliest sessions. On July , at its Genoa session, the newly-formed ILO adopted the National Seamen’s Code Recommendation, 40 which envisaged, inter alia, In order that, as a result of the clear and systematic codification of the national law in each country, the seamen of the world, whether engaged on ships of their own or foreign countries, may have a better comprehension of their rights and obligations, and in order that the task of establishing an International Seamen’s Code may be advanced and facilitated, the International Labour Conference recommends that each Member of the International Labour Organisation undertake the embodiment in a seamen’s code of all its laws and regulations relating to seamen in their activities as such.
Eighty-six years later, following the adoption of maritime labour conventions and related recommendations,41 on February , with more than , participants, the th Session of the ILC42 adopted the MLC, 43 a major new labour convention, by a record vote of in favour and none against.44 At the time of its adoption, Juan Somavia, Director-General of the before the national ‘competent authority’ for ratification within or months (Article ) and, if not ratified, to report on national coverage on the matter and efforts to move to ratification. There is a supervisory system under the ILO’s Constitution with mandatory reporting on implementation measures, reviews and also provision for complaints by employer or workers’ organizations or other ILO Members (see Chapter ). There is also the possibility of a reference to the International Court of Justice after a commission of inquiry (Article ) or for disputes regarding interpretation (Article ). Flexibility with respect to national implementation and concerns with respect to the stage of economic development is usually accommodated through declarations but without reservations. 40 Supra note . 41 These were, in addition, other conventions on a host of issues related to social and labour rights and conditions, some of which are generally applicable to all workers and others which are sector specific. 42 See: Ninth Sitting, “Final record vote on the adoption of the Maritime Labour Convention, ,” ILC, th (Maritime) Session, Geneva, February , ILO Doc. No. PR, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/pr-.pdf. The th Session of the ILC was held in Geneva, – February . This was also the th Maritime Session of the ILO since . The complete conference documents are available at http://www.ilo.org/ilc/ ILCSessions/thSession/lang-en/index.htm. See also Appendix for a guide to all the Convention negotiation sessions. 43 Supra note . 44 Supra note . The vote in favour reflects the fact that delegations from countries that are Members of the ILO attended the three week ILC and that tripartite support was obtained
overview and introduction
ILO, was moved to describe the MLC, , and the process by which it was developed, as “historic” and a model for a way forward to achieving “fair globalization”.45 He later wrote, “This Convention, often referred to as a charter for decent work or a ‘bill of rights’ for the world’s maritime workers, was clearly understood by all concerned—governments, seafarers and shipowners—as a landmark development for the world’s most globalized sector”.46 The Director of the International Labour Standards Department of the International Labour Office,47 also commented: We are leading the way in developing an innovative, integrated approach to ensuring that the industry moves forward together, in ensuring decent work for all seafarers wherever they come from, and wherever the vessel they are working on comes from. The ILO constituents have recognized that poor working conditions and quality shipping cannot go together. We have put a socio-economic floor to global competition in the maritime sector. This competition will continue, but it will be based on fair and well-conceived common rules for fair competition and on cooperation to ensure that they are followed.48
from Members. The ILO has a weighted voting system. The government representatives of two ILO Members, Venezuela and Lebanon (four votes), abstained for reasons placed on the record that were unrelated to the substance of the Convention. Venezuela abstained for reasons relating to its views on the reference in the Preamble of the MLC, to LOSC but placed on record its support for the substance of the Convention. See: Ninth sitting, supra note , pp. –. Lebanon also abstained and placed on record its support for the Convention but felt it could not vote in favour because of its lack of financial capacity to implement conventions. See: Ibid., p. . 45 Dr. Juan Somavia, Director-General of the International Labour Office, speech of February following the vote to adopt the Convention by the th ILC. See: Ibid., p. . The term ‘fair globalization’ stems from the work and the report of the World Commission on the Social Dimension of Globalization, A Fair Globalization: Creating Opportunities for All (ILO: Geneva, ), p. xi, which argues the problems, including social conflict and polarization of views, are . . . not due to globalization as such but to deficiencies in it governance. Global markets have grown rapidly without the parallel development of economic and social institutions necessary for their smooth and equitable functioning. At the same time, there is concern, about the unfairness of key gobal rules on trade and finance and their asymmetric effects on rich and poor countries . . . There is a serious democratic deficit at the heart of the system. . . . workers and the poor have little or no voice in this governance process. 46
ILO, “Preface,” Compendium of Maritime Labour Instruments: Maritime Labour Convention, , Seafarers’ Identity Documents (Revised) Convention, ; Working in Fishing Convention and Recommendation, (Geneva: ILO, ). 47 Cleopatra Doumbia-Henry, one of the co-authors of this book, was present throughout the international negotiation process, which, like the decade-long negotiations to adopt the LOSC involving influential personalities and many innovative procedures and drafting of ‘solutions’. 48 Interview (on file with the authors). See also: Cleopatra Doumbia-Henry, “The Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention: A marriage of the traditional and the new”, in ILO, Les normes internationals du travail: un patrimoine pour l’avenir. Melanges en l’honneur de Nicolas Valticos (Geneva: Bureau International du Travail, ), p. .
chapter one
The adoption and the coming into force of the MLC, on a universal or at least a widespread basis, and a sibling ILO convention adopted a year later, the Work in Fishing, Convention ,49 will represent the fruition of the s’ vision of an ‘international seamens’ code’. Chapters ,50 ,51 and 52 will explore the connection between the MLC, and the ILO textual and procedural antecedents as well innovations and the wider international maritime regulatory practices. The MLC, clearly had its genesis in internal ILO developments,53 however, looking back over the decade to , it is also clear that the MLC, can also be fairly described as responding to the many recommendations put forward in the report by the International Commission on Shipping, Inquiry into Ship Safety, Slavery and Competition.54 These recommendations included the mainstreaming and strengthening of the international maritime and labour regimes to improve living and working conditions for seafarers, which the report described, in some cases, as ‘inhumane’ and tantamount to slavery. As pointed out by many, including, notably, Efthimios Mitropoulos, IMO Secretary-General,55 the MLC, was specifically designed to become the ‘the fourth pillar’ of the international maritime regulatory regime, complementing and completing the approach established in three core IMO conventions dealing with ship-source marine pollution, ship safety and security, and seafarer competency (i.e., MARPOL, SOLAS, and STCW).56 But the relationship with the IMO conventions goes beyond this complementarity. In fact,
49 It was thought that the diversity of the fishing sector warranted a specific convention. There was a decision that the MLC, should not apply to fishing vessels (although a State can, of course, as a matter of national law, apply the MLC, requirements to fishing vessels under its flag if it so chooses). A convention that adopts similar ideas mutatis mutandis for the fishing sector was adopted by the ILO in June at the th ILC. See: Work in Fishing Convention, (No. ), Geneva, June , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm, and the associated recommendation, Work in Fishing Recommendation (R), Geneva, June , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/recdisp.htm. 50 See the reflection by Cleopatra Doumbia-Henry in Chapter on the ideas and aspirations behind the decision in the ILO to improve maritime labour standards. 51 See the analysis by Dominick Devlin (Chapter ) of the linkages between the MLC, and traditional ILO legal concepts and approaches as well as the interesting, if difficult, international law questions regarding the legal nature of ILO conventions. 52 See the detailed discussion of the structure and substance in Chapter . 53 See Chapter , pp. –. 54 International Commission on Shipping, Inquiry into Ship Safety, Slavery and Competition (Australia: ICONS, ). 55 Fourth Sitting, ILC, th (Maritime) Session, Geneva, February , ILO Doc. No. PR, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/pr-.pdf, p. . 56 The IMO has Member States and three Associate Members. Its mission is ‘safe, secure and efficient shipping on clean oceans’. The IMO describes its mandate as follows:
overview and introduction
as discussed throughout the chapters in Part II of this book, the MLC, reflects a conscious decision to mainstream labour standards and compliance and enforcement practices within the existing maritime regulatory regime.57 It IMO’s main task has been to develop and maintain a comprehensive regulatory framework for shipping and its remit today includes safety, environmental concerns, legal matters, technical co-operation, maritime security and the efficiency of shipping. . . . IMO’s specialized committees and sub-committees are the focus for the technical work to update existing legislation or develop and adopt new regulations, with meetings attended by maritime experts from Member Governments, together with those from interested intergovernmental and non-governmental organizations. The result is a comprehensive body of international conventions, supported by hundreds of recommendations governing every facet of shipping. See: IMO, “Introduction to IMO,” available at http://www.imo.org/About/Pages/Default.aspx. The IMO has adopted numerous conventions, however, three are usually considered key or ‘cornerstones’: International Convention for the Safety of Life at Sea, , London, November , U.N.T.S. , as amended (SOLAS); International Convention on Standards of Training, Certification and Watchkeeping, , London, July , U.N.T.S. , as amended (STCW); and International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships, London, November , U.N.T.S. , as amended by Protocol of relating to the International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships of , London, February , U.N.T.S. (MARPOL). One of the earlier ILO conventions, the Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, (No. ), Geneva, October , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm, which contained the concept of port State interventions, also required ratification of several IMO ship safety conventions as a minimum condition for ratification of the Convention. Article of this convention may be one of the earliest attempts to integrate the regimes and coordinate activities among UN organizations: . This Convention is open to the ratification of Members which – (a) are parties to the International Convention for the Safety of Life at Sea, , or the International Convention for the Safety of Life at Sea, , or any Convention subsequently revising these Conventions; and (b) are parties to the International Convention on Load Lines, , or any Convention subsequently revising that Convention; and (c) are parties to, or have implemented the provisions of, the Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea of , or the Convention on the International Regulations for Preventing Collisions at Sea, , or any Convention subsequently revising these international instruments. 57 Interestingly in their study considering the impact of both IMO and ILO conventions, K.X. Li and Jim Mi Ng, “International maritime conventions: Seafarers, safety and human rights,” () Journal of Maritime Law & Commerce – at , comment:
There is a new initiative in the ILO to consolidate its documents into two or three maritime labour codes, this structural gambit could “breathe new life” into the ILO’s labour standards. In this regard, the ILO could learn from the IMO. As a specialized UN organisation in maritime matters, the IMO has developed its maritime expertise and formed a close relationship with the shipping industry. There is certainly room for closer cooperation between the maritime organisations in the adoption and implementation of maritime conventions. See also, Two draft papers on enforcement and simplified amendment; Considerations for provisions on inspection and control in a consolidated maritime labour Convention (Draft I); Simplified
chapter one
will also be seen that the relationship has not been unidirectional since IMO conventions and amendments and other instruments were developed after the adoption of the MLC, . For example, the amendments to the STCW Code58 adopted in June by the IMO consciously attempted to follow the wording in, or at least avoid directly conflicting with, the MLC, , as much as possible, despite the differing institutional values, practices, and mandates of the IMO and ILO. The Law of the Sea and the International Maritime Regulatory Framework59 As explained earlier, this book is directed to a maritime, international, and labour law practitioners and scholars. In so doing it is bridging at least two areas of specialization and expertise, each with their own systems, assumptions, and terminology. The preceding sections of this introduction have provided an overview of ILO terminology, concepts and actors, and the background to the MLC, . Chapters , , and provide significant information on the ILO and its legal approach to issues, standard setting, and the ILO supervisory system. Chapter also provides a very useful description of some concerns about operating practices in the maritime sector. The following sections of this chapter will provide an overview of the law of the sea and the international maritime regulatory regime within which the MLC, , as a labour convention, is also situated and, indeed, is shaped by. Part II of this book, particularly Chapter , also contains additional information in relation to specific maritime practices in connection with compliance and enforcement. The Law of the Sea Framework Traditionally there are three kinds of interests or faces to a State’s interests under the law of the sea: flag State (the State in which as ship is registered has international regulatory responsibility); port State (a State’s action in relation to foreign ships entering its ports or to an economic interest as an exporter or importer of goods or provider of services, e.g., marine tourism); and a coastal State (States concerned about impacts on their coasts and coastal resources of shipping and other activities). The MLC, introduces a fourth ‘face’ for
amendment procedure for the proposed new maritime labour Convention (Draft II), Tripartite Subgroup of the High-Level Tripartite Working Group on Maritime Labour Standards (First Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. STWGMLS /. available at http://www.ilo.org/public/ english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/stwgmls/stwgmls-.pdf. See discussion in Chapter at pp. –. 58 See the discussion in Chapter at note and Chapter at note . 59 Elements of this section are based on McConnell, supra note , pp. –.
overview and introduction
States in connection with the development of the law of the sea, namely a State with labour-supplying responsibilities. It is important to realize that a State could have none, some, or all four interests to varying degrees. This creates a potential internal difficulty for governments seeking to reconcile differing, and sometimes conflicting, interests. When the LOSC was adopted in it was the culmination of a decadelong negotiation to achieve a comprehensive and over-arching legal regime for the oceans. In addition to issues with respect to the jurisdictional and resource-related rights of coastal States, it also dealt with the issue of (flag State) responsibility for ships in waters outside territorial waters (i.e., high seas) and related inspection rights and obligations vis-à-vis foreign ships in ports. In some respects the LOSC can be seen as an attempt to capture and codify the extant elements and principles in the ILO and IMO regimes. Interestingly, despite the more developed international maritime labour regime that existed at the time,60 marine environmental protection from ship-source pollution received significant attention in the LOSC (Part XII), whilst the issue of working and living conditions on ships is sparsely addressed. Arguably, the treatment of labour instruments was reduced in , in comparison to the provisions in the relevant predecessor convention, the Convention on the High Seas.61 60 By the ILO had developed an extensive body of conventions and recommendations as explained in Chapters and . Conventions directed to conditions both of ships and on board ships pre-date LOSC, and, even earlier attempts to codify the law of the sea in the Geneva Conventions, by many years. This is particularly the case with conventions addressing working and living conditions on ships. For example, among the earliest of the ILO conventions are the Minimum Age (Sea) Convention, (C), Genoa, July , the Placing of Seamen Convention, (C), Genoa, July (both available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp .htm), and the National Seamen’s Code Recommendation, (R), supra note . The IMO also developed conventions on marine protection in the early s, with ship safety instruments adopted (albeit prior to the creation of IMO and its predecessor the International Maritime Consultative Organization) as early as . 61 Paragraph (b) refers to labour conditions and only requires States to “take account” of international instruments, rather than international labour instruments as required under the Convention on the High Seas. Perhaps this reflects the fact that by then the IMO had also begun to look at manning and seafarer training and in some quarters was viewed as the (only) ‘competent organization’ in the reference under the LOSC. See also Convention on the High Seas, Geneva, April , U.N.T.S. , available at http://untreaty.un.org/ilc/texts/instruments/ english/conventions/___high_seas.pdf, at Article (emphasis added): . Every State shall take such measures for ships under its flag as are necessary to ensure safety at sea with regard, inter alia, to: (a) The use of signals, the maintenance of communications and the prevention of collisions; (b) The manning of ships and labour conditions for crews taking into account the applicable international labour instruments; (c) The construction, equipment and seaworthiness of ships. . In taking such measures each State is required to conform to generally accepted international standards and to take any steps which may be necessary to ensure their observance.
chapter one
The key provisions of the LOSC concerning flag State rights and responsibilities are (emphasis added): Article —Nationality of ships . Every State shall fix the conditions for the grant of its nationality to ships, for the registration of ships in its territory, and for the right to fly its flag. Ships have the nationality of the State whose flag they are entitled to fly. There must exist a genuine link between the State and the ship. . Every State shall issue to ships to which it has granted the right to fly its flag documents to that effect. Article —Status of ships . Ships shall sail under the flag of one State only and, save in exceptional cases expressly provided for in international treaties or in this Convention, shall be subject to its exclusive jurisdiction on the high seas . . .. Article —Duties of the flag State . Every State shall effectively exercise its jurisdiction and control in administrative, technical and social matters over ships flying its flag. . In particular every State shall: (a) maintain a register of ships containing the names and particulars of ships flying its flag, except those which are excluded from generally accepted international regulations on account of their small size; and (b) assume jurisdiction under its internal law over each ship flying its flag and its master, officers and crew in respect of administrative, technical and social matters concerning the ship. . Every State shall take such measures for ships flying its flag as are necessary to ensure safety at sea with regard, inter alia, to: (a) the construction, equipment and seaworthiness of ships; (b) the manning of ships, labour conditions and the training of crews, taking into account the applicable international instruments; . . . . In taking the measures called for in paragraphs and each State is required to conform to generally accepted international regulations, procedures and practices and to take any steps which may be necessary to secure their observance. . A State which has clear grounds to believe that proper jurisdiction and control with respect to a ship have not been exercised may report the facts to the flag State. Upon receiving such a report, the flag State shall investigate the matter and, if appropriate, take any action necessary to remedy the situation.
Although directed to responsibility on the high seas, these provisions, de facto, frame the overall regime for the regulation in this sector since shipping would be operationally impossible if ships on international voyages faced significantly62 differing regulatory regimes in the exclusive economic zone or territo62
LOSC, supra note , while not specifically addressing the question of flag State jurisdiction in these areas implicitly reflects this approach. See, for example,
overview and introduction
rial sea of other States. There are additional provisions in LOSC addressing responsibilities and rights with respect to ship-source marine pollution and other matters, but not with respect to working and other conditions on ships. As noted earlier63 this book argues that the MLC, can also be understood as addressing a significant gap in the LOSC, namely the failure of LOSC to do more than peripherally address the ocean, particularly the high seas, as a workplace or a site for human rights.64 These matters are simply left to the relevant flag State of the ship, which, as the above extract, indicates, is obliged
Article —Laws and regulations of the coastal State relating to innocent passage . The coastal State may adopt laws and regulations, in conformity with the provisions of this Convention and other rules of international law, relating to innocent passage through the territorial sea, in respect of all or any of the following: . . . (a) the safety of navigation and the regulation of maritime traffic; (b) the protection of navigational aids and facilities and other facilities or installations; (c) the protection of cables and pipelines; (d) the conservation of the living resources of the sea; (e) the prevention of infringement of the fisheries laws and regulations of the coastal State; (f) the preservation of the environment of the coastal State and the prevention, reduction and control of pollution thereof; (g) marine scientific research and hydrographic surveys; (h) the prevention of infringement of the customs, fiscal, immigration or sanitary laws and regulations of the coastal State. . Such laws and regulations shall not apply to the design, construction, manning or equipment of foreign ships unless they are giving effect to generally accepted international rules or standards. . . . Article —Pollution from vessels . States, acting through the competent international organization or general diplomatic conference, shall establish international rules and standards to prevent, reduce and control pollution of the marine environment from vessels and promote the adoption, in the same manner, wherever appropriate, of routeing systems designed to minimize the threat of accidents which might cause pollution of the marine environment, including the coastline, and pollution damage to the related interests of coastal States. Such rules and standards shall, in the same manner, be re-examined from time to time as necessary. . . . . Coastal States, for the purpose of enforcement as provided for in section , may in respect of their exclusive economic zones adopt laws and regulations for the prevention, reduction and control of pollution from vessels conforming to and giving effect to generally accepted international rules and standards established through the competent international organization or general diplomatic conference. 63 64
See discussion supra note . Ibid.
chapter one
to effectively exercise its jurisdiction and control in administrative, technical, and social matters over ships flying its flag. This means that this is a matter for domestic law (internal law) of the flag State, which is obliged to effectively exercise its jurisdiction and control over ships often voyaging well outside its territorial jurisdiction. Paragraph does, however, require conformity with “generally accepted” international regulations. Paragraph allows for what could be seen as some limited form of port State intervention but, unlike the provisions found elsewhere in LOSC regarding marine pollution, it does not go beyond reporting to the flag State on these matters. In principle, however, it can be seen that the State parties65 to LOSC have an obligation to address labour and social conditions on ships at least to the extent indicated above. The problem with this approach is evidenced in the much criticized failure to tackle the thorny international law problem of the ‘genuine link’,66 as set out in 65
As of November . See: UN Division for Ocean Affairs and the Law of the Sea, “Status,” available at http://www.un.org/depts/los. 66 See: M.L. McConnell, “Business as usual: An evaluation of the United Nations Convention on Conditions for Registration of Ships,” () Journal of Maritime Law and Commerce ; M.L. McConnell, “Darkening confusion mounted upon darkening confusion: The search for the elusive genuine link,” () Journal of Maritime Law and Commerce . See also, for example, the resurrected call for a definition of the ‘genuine link’ or even, in the fishing sector, a new convention to ‘define’ the genuine link in Resolutions / (at para. ) and / adopted by the UN General Assembly at its fifty-eighth session. These resolutions invited the IMO and other relevant agencies to study, examine, and clarify the role of the genuine link in relation to the duty of flag States to exercise effective control over ships flying their flag, including fishing vessels. Resolutions / (para. ) and / (para. ) also requested the SecretaryGeneral to report to the General Assembly at its sixty-first session on the study undertaken by the IMO in cooperation with other competent international organizations on the role of the genuine link and the potential consequences of non-compliance with duties and obligations of flag States described in relevant international instruments. The IMO reported on June and the lengthy report, comprising reports from the various organizations concerned, was reported to the General Assembly (Item (a) of the provisional agenda in connection with Oceans and the law of the sea, General Assembly, st Session, UN Doc. A/, July ). Despite some resurgence of interest in the meaning of the genuine link in cases before the International Tribunal on the Law of the Sea, that report commented, inter alia, . Participants in the Meeting took the view that the exclusivity attached by the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea to the right of States to fix conditions for the grant of nationality, as reaffirmed by the authoritative interpretations of the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea in the M/V Saiga (No. ) and subsequent cases, as well the other agreements referred to in section above, indicated that the questions relating to the precise criteria or conditions adopted by a State with respect to the grant of its nationality to a ship were a matter beyond the purview of the organizations participating in the Meeting. However, participants in the Meeting also considered that issues relating to securing the objective and purpose of the “genuine link” requirement, that is, assuring the ability of the flag State to effectively exercise its jurisdiction over ships flying its flag, were matters of central concern to all of the organizations and formed a substantial part of their programmes of regulatory initiatives and technical cooperation activities in the shipping and fishing sectors.
overview and introduction
Article , and flag State jurisdiction over the globalized economic activities of shipping and fishing. However, it is difficult, from a legal perspective, to envisage a viable alternative to flag State jurisdiction. The MLC, while not an amendment to the LOSC itself, is an important step in developing this obligation into a more effective regime.67 The MLC, develops, in detail and at the level of what will be a widely ratified comprehensive multilateral convention, explicit responsibilities for both flag States, in connection with the inspection and certification of labour conditions on ships, and port States that choose to inspect foreign ships. It also introduces a new player in the flag State, coastal/port State jurisdictional net—States with labour-supply responsibilities that arise independently of those of the flag State. The Maritime Context and the International Maritime Regulatory Regime The terms ‘maritime sector’ and ‘shipping’ are often loosely used to capture a range of activities spanning shore-based activities (dock or port workers), arranging the carriage of goods by sea, and shipboard operations and other port-related activities (e.g., pilots and tugs). For purpose of this book, the notion of maritime sector refers to commercially-operated ships and workers on those ships, whether operating internationally or only in the coastal waters of the country in which the ship is registered. Shipping is inseparable from world trade and economic development: access to inexpensive and reliable transportation impacts directly on the competitiveness of exports and imports, which in turn affects a wide range of domestic economic activities.68 Like other economic sectors, the cost of operating ships involves both that of the plant itself and the labour. Characterized as one of the first globalized or multinational sectors, despite the fact that there is
But see comments from a representative of the International Transportation Workers’ Federation (ITF) that suggests that there may be a shift in its strategy for dealing with flags of convenience. See: “ITF softens FOC stance,” Fairplay Daily News, July . 67 See generally papers in, for example, Oran Young, ed., The Effectiveness of International Environmental Regimes: Causal Connections and Behavioural Mechanisms (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, ). 68 Clearly the cost of transporting goods is an important aspect of the market competitiveness of many goods, aside from revenue related to ships’ operations. See discussion in, inter alia, United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), Emerging challenges and recent developments affecting transport and trade facilitation, Note by the UNCTAD Secretariat, Trade and Development Board, Multi-year Expert Meeting on Transport and Trade Facilitation, Third Session, Geneva, – December , UNCTAD Doc. No. TD/B/C./MEM./, dated September , available at http://www.unctad.org/Templates/WebFlyer.asp?intItemID= &lang=.
chapter one
domestic shipping in most countries, trade in goods is largely between countries and involves ships registered in/flying the flags of many different countries. Historically, in many countries, the shipping sector—sometime called the merchant marine—was heavily protected from international competition and ownership as an aspect of national public policy. Similarly, many countries had restrictions with respect to which ships/flags could trade to their ports, the terms of such trade, who could own ships or work on board those ships, or operate along their coastline. While many countries maintain this practice, there is no longer an emphasis on ownership and operation by nationals of the flag State with the emergence in the s of what are sometimes called flag of convenience (FOC) or, more usually now, ‘open registries’.69 These registries allow shipowners to register ships and operate (i.e., fly a flag) under the jurisdiction of countries in which the owner and the workers on board the ship are not necessarily resident or nationals of the State. Ships operating under such a system can transfer easily between flags and can be owned by a company in one State, managed by a company based in another country, with seafarers drawn from multiple jurisdictions. This is still the case today and, in fact, many countries that formerly had restrictions with respect to registration have now established ‘international registers’ and adopted other incentives to attract ships to their flags. Much of the movement between registers initially related to increased regulatory activity with respect to safety, labour, and environmental standards. However, with the rise of port State control, decisions as to where to flag are now more commonly related to corporate regulation and taxation, and in the case of fishing vessels, conservation measures. It is important to briefly consider the key elements of the maritime regulatory regime that has been elaborated under the IMO. From a legal perspective, the IMO conventions all generally follow a similar formula in addressing ship-related concerns.70 This approach is of interest as it expressly responds to the transnational character of a sector primarily regulated by IMO,71 and is focused on effectiveness whilst remaining firmly founded on traditional international law principles of State sovereignty. IMO conventions typically72 69
See McConnell, supra note . See: IMO, “List of IMO Conventions,” available at http://www.imo.org/About/Conventions/ ListOfConventions/Pages/Default.aspx, for a comprehensive list of all IMO treaties. 71 The IMO is generally, but not solely, concerned with ships GT and above that are engaged in voyages outside the flag State. 72 More recent conventions reflect landward ‘creep’ and address coastal state and even traditionally land-based activities such as environmental and safety standards in the operation of ship recycling facilities. 70
overview and introduction
‘speak’ to flag State administrations, requiring that the ships flying the flag of that State, which are covered by a convention, operate according to the international regulations set out in the relevant convention (usually in an annex). Ships are required to be inspected and certified by the flag State, or an organization acting on its behalf in carrying out the technical inspection/survey, such as a ship classification society (now often termed ‘recognized organizations’ or ROs). The development of international reliance on, and regulation of, these organizations is discussed in more detail in Chapter .73 It should be noted that this work includes traditional ship ‘survey’ work as well as carrying out company/shipowner safety management system audits in connection with the certification of these systems as required under the IMO International Safety Management (ISM) Code.74 As explained by the International Association of Classification Societies (IACS),75 Classification societies are organizations that establish and apply technical standards in relation to the design, construction and survey of marine related facilities including ships and offshore structures. The vast majority of ships are built and surveyed to the standards laid down by classification societies. These standards are issued by the classification society as published rules. A vessel that has been designed and built to the appropriate rules of a society may apply for a certificate of classification from that society. The society issues this certificate upon completion of the relevant classification surveys. . . . [T]he practice of assigning different classifications has been superseded, with some exceptions. Today a ship either meets the relevant class society’s rules or it does not. As a consequence it is either ‘in’ or ‘out’ of ‘class’. However, each of the classification societies has developed a series of notations that may be granted to a vessel to indicate that it is in compliance with some additional
73
See Chapter , notes and , and discussion at pp. –. See: IACS, Procedural Requirements for ISM Code Certification, No. (Rev. July ; Rev. Jan ; Corr. Mar ), available at http://www.iacs.org.uk/document/public/publications/ resolution_changes/pdf/pr__rev._corr._pdf.pdf. These were updated as of March to reflect IMO Resolution A.(), Revised Guidelines on the Implementation of the ISM Code by Administrators, and IMO Resolution A.(), International Safety Management (ISM) Code, as amended. In fact the term ‘recognized organization’ is circular in that a RO is defined in IMO documents as: 74
.. Recognized Organization: An organization which meets the relevant conditions set forth by resolution A.(), and has been delegated by the flag State Administration to provide the necessary statutory services and certification to ships entitled to fly its flag. See: Harmonization of Port State Control Activities—Draft procedures for port State control, , IMO, Sub-Committee on Flag State Implementation, th session, Agenda item , IMO Doc. No. FSI /WP., July . 75 IACS is a NGO that was granted consultative status with IMO in .
chapter one criteria that may be either specific to that vessel type or that are in excess of the standard classification requirements. . . . International Conventions have been agreed, setting out uniform standards to facilitate acceptance of a ship registered in one country in the waters and ports of another and in the general furtherance of safety at sea and protection of the environment. These standards are commonly referred to as ‘statutory’ requirements. ... Where the classification survey result is taken as evidence of compliance with the corresponding statutory requirement, e.g. load line or safety construction (hull, machinery, boilers, electrical equipment, etc.), this survey is de facto given the status of a statutory survey on behalf of the flag Administration, if the society is acting as its recognised organisation in this respect. . . . The RO is responsible and accountable to the flag Administration for the work that it carries out on its behalf. The principles of the inspection and survey work are the same as in respect of classification surveys, that is the verification by the RO that a ship is in compliance with applicable requirements at the time of the survey. The scope of these inspections and surveys regarding safety and pollution prevention are laid down by the flag Administration in compliance with the relevant international conventions to which it is a signatory.76
There are now approximately classification societies in the world.77 As noted by the IMO, All ships must be surveyed in ordered to be issued certificates which establish their seaworthiness, type of ship, and so on, and this is the responsibility of the flag State of the vessel. However, the flag State (“Administration”) may “entrust the inspections and surveys either to surveyors nominated for the the purpose or to organizations recognized by it” (SOLAS Chapter , regulation ). In practice these “recognized organizations” are often the classification societies.78
The certificates that are carried on the ship are then subject to inspection in other (port) States under a voluntary regime. There are numerous certificates that ships are now required to carry,79 so much so that efforts have been devoted by the IMO to harmonizing the timing of the various surveys (inspections) that are required under SOLAS and MARPOL.80
76
IACS, “Classification Societies—What, Why and How?”available at http://www.iacs.org.uk/ document/public/explained/Class_WhatWhy&How.PDF, pp. , , , and . 77 Eleven of these organizations form IACS and collectively they class about per cent of all commercial tonnage involved in international trade worldwide. Ibid., p. . 78 IMO, “FAQs: What about classification societies?” available at http://www.imo.org/About/ Pages/FAQs.aspx. 79 See partial list at IMO, “Surveys, Verifications and Certification,” available at http://www .imo.org/OurWork/Safety/Implementation/Pages/SurveysAndCertification.aspx. 80 See IMO, “The Harmonized System of Survey and Certification,” available at http://www .imo.org/SharePoint/contents.asp?topic_id=&doc_id=.
overview and introduction
Port States essentially carry out inspections of the documentation required by the IMO and, sometimes, one ILO convention and, if there are grounds to suggest a problem, a further inspection is carried out and, if necessary, the ship detained. The system known as port State control (PSC)81 is based on memoranda of understanding (MOUs) between maritime administrations. As discussed in Chapter , PSC has had an increasing impact on the international regulatory regime and has been so effective that an international network of regional PSC MOUs has emerged.82 This network helps to ensure that ships going on international voyages meet international standards and substandard ships and operators are eliminated.83 The development of PSC, to complement and verify/spot check flag State inspection and enforcement activities, is an outcome of both the practical difficulty of effectively exercising jurisdiction over ships as they voyage internationally and
81 The concept of inspection and detention of ships in foreign ports for failing to meet international standards (now known as port State control) emerged as early as in Article of SOLAS, supra note , and subsequent versions of the convention following the sinking of The Titanic. See: http://www.imo.org/includes/blastDataOnly.asp/data_idD/SafetyofLifeat SeaConvention.pdf. It is also set out in Article of MARPOL, supra note . However that convention did not come into force until after it was amended by a protocol in (MARPOL /), which entered into force in . (See: MARPOL, supra note .) The concept of inspections of foreign ships in ports in connection with enforcing international standards is also found in Part XII of LOSC, supra note . The modern day regional port State control regime emerged in in connection with ILO Convention No. (adopted in and into force in , supra note ), as explained on the Web site of the Paris Memorandum of Understanding on Port State control (MOU on PSC), available at http://www.parismou.org:
The Paris MOU is an administrative agreement between the maritime authorities of twenty-seven European countries and Canada. In the ‘Hague Memorandum’ between a number of maritime authorities in Western Europe was developed. It dealt mainly with enforcement of shipboard living and working conditions, as required by ILO Convention no. . However, just as the Memorandum was about to come into effect, in March , a massive oil spill occurred off the coast of Brittany (France), as a result of the grounding of the supertanker ‘Amoco Cadiz’. This incident caused a strong political and public outcry in Europe for far more stringent regulations with regard to the safety of shipping. This pressure resulted in a more comprehensive memorandum which covered: – safety of life at sea – prevention of pollution by ships, and – living and working conditions on board ships. Subsequently, a new, effective instrument known as the Paris Memorandum of Understanding on Port State Control was adopted in January and was, initially, signed by fourteen European countries. It entered into operation on July . 82 There are now PSC MOUs in most regions of the world. See: IMO, “Port State Control,” available at http://www.imo.org/OurWork/Safety/Implementation/Pages/PortStateControl.aspx. 83 Unfortunately, some countries move such ships into the coastal/domestic trade sector.
chapter one
the rise of the open registry flags.84 Disenchantment85 with the ‘flag State’ as an effective actor in ensuring that ships meet international standards led to strengthening of the regional regimes based on cooperation among maritime authorities through PSC MOUs rather than through international conventions. These more informal and practical or institutional arrangements developed largely in response to concerns about ship safety and marine pollution as a result major incidents.86 Reports from PSC officers are filed with flag States regarding any problems. Under current regional port State control arrangements, this information is also put into an electronic database accessible to others. This system can be seen as an important form of international cooperation in that the port State, while acting in its own interest in seeking safe and secure ships and cleaner seas to avoid 84 An interesting view of this practice, which as noted above, is found in maritime conventions as early as , from the perspective of an international/industrial relations scholar, is found in Lillie, supra note , p. :
The MLC paradigm applies different aspects of state authority in a fragmented manner, knit together by practices of maritime industrial regulation. Beside the traditional member State implementation model, in which member States commit to respecting ILO standards in their own sovereign space, the MLC will have member States enforcing labour standards directly on each other’s ships through the established maritime mechanism of port State Control (PSC). This involves a shift in the boundaries of state sovereignty in some respects, because ships, in a legal sense, have been regarded as floating pieces of their flag States’ territories. However, practically, PSC will also operate as an incentive encouraging shipowners and flag States to adequately regulate their own shipping. In this sense, the flag State role still remains primary. 85
See, for example, Mathew Gianni, Real and Present Danger Flag State Failure and Maritime Safety and Security (Oslo/London: WWF/ITF, ) and numerous commissions and reports in response to environmental incidents or labour conditions. The ITF has mounted a longterm campaign against FOCs. These concerns have resulted in alliances between environmental, conservation (fisheries), and labour organizations. Most recently, IMO initiatives have focused on flag State audits: . . . The twenty-fourth Assembly in November–December adopted resolutions A.() Framework and Procedures for the Voluntary IMO Member State Audit Scheme and A.() Code for the implementation of mandatory IMO instruments which provides the audit standard. The adoption of the framework and procedures for the scheme heralded a new era for IMO, in which the Organization has at its disposal a tool to achieve harmonized and consistent global implementation of IMO standards, which is key to realizing the IMO objectives of safe, secure and efficient shipping on clean oceans.
See: IMO, “Voluntary IMO Member State Audit Scheme,” available at http://www.imo.org/safety/ mainframe.asp?topic_id=. FAO is developing a similar audit approach for fishing vessels. See: FAO, “Report of the Expert Consultation on Flag State Performance, Rome, – June, ,” FAO Fisheries and Aquaculture Report No. (Rome: FAO, ), available at ftp://ftp.fao.org/ docrep/fao//ie/ie.pdf. Such approaches seek to also address capacity building issues that may lie behind flag State failures to regulate their fleets. 86 Supra note .
overview and introduction
harm to its waters and coastline, is also supporting and extending the regulatory control exercised by the flag State. In ensuring continual or ongoing compliance with international standards, the PSC system can also be seen as a way of assisting weaker flag State administrations that must, irrespective of their lack of capacity, ensure that its ships are operated in accordance with international standards. Obviously the system also operates indirectly as a check on a State’s implementation of its international obligations87 and provides an incentive for shipowners to operate under flag States that have a record of reliable flag State inspection and certification. A further aspect of the IMO conventions that is relevant to MLC, is the inclusion of a ‘no more favourable treatment clause’ whereby State parties agree that ships of non-party States will not be treated more favourably with respect to the matters under the relevant convention. This helps to establish a ‘level playing field’ in that shipowners that register in States that have not ratified a convention will still be subject to inspection for the same matters in foreign ports but will not have the benefit of a convention certificate. (The entry into force formula of the IMO conventions combines a number of States with a percentage of the world fleet (by GT) in order to ensure that flag States with a significant interest in and responsibility in a particular sector are party to relevant conventions.) In terms of structural elements relevant to the MLC, , the IMO conventions generally follow a standard design. They comprise fairly brief articles spelling out general State obligations regarding implementation, and often, inspection, certification and port State control, scope and coverage, entry into force, and amendments, as well as a requirement to comply with the convention and, importantly, any annexes. The more detailed mandatory technical provisions, the regulations, are attached in one or more annexes. Further instruments such as codes (sometimes with both mandatory and non-mandatory provisions) and voluntary guidelines are often developed to complement the convention and provide details on specific elements of the regulations in the annexes. The individual parts of the conventions often have different amendment provisions, with the tacit acceptance procedure used to allow for more rapid updating of the technical provisions in the annexes. As will be discussed in Part II, particularly Chapters and , the IMO convention design approach, which has both substantive and format implications, was an important influence on the design of the MLC, . The final actors in the maritime labour regime, emerging from what is described as the ‘fourth face’ of this regime, are the organizations that recruit and manage seafarers/crew for ships. They operate under various titles and 87 UN Doc. A/, supra note , Appendix , “Examination and clarification of the role of the ‘genuine link’ in relation to the duty of the States to exercise effective control over ships flying their flags, including fishing vessels, submitted by the International Labour Office,” para. .
chapter one
configurations such as ‘manning agents’; in some cases, ship management companies will carry out this function. These organizations/corporations are the entities with whom many seafarers have direct contact in order to work internationally, rather than the shipowner. This presents an additional layer of legal regulatory responsibility in that these services may operate in a State other than the flag State. As will be discussed in Chapter , the MLC, consolidates provisions in an existing ILO convention that are intended to address potential problems that seafarers encounter in this situation by regulating the activities of these entities. Conclusion: Observations on the Wider Relevance of the MLC, The adoption of the MLC, , on what is essentially a unanimous basis with very few amendments88 is remarkable, even revolutionary, from many perspectives. From an international labour law perspective the MLC, , comprising nearly pages of legal text when it was adopted, – consolidated and updated existing conventions, many of which had not been widely ratified, covering almost the full gamut of socio-economic issues in the maritime labour sector, including the very difficult issues of social security and other social protections for one of the most globalized work forces such as guarantees and insurance for shipowners’ liability for seafarer sickness and injury and repatriation; – adopted an entirely new format for an ILO convention; – brought in a new approach to the ratification and amendment of ILO conventions; – established a comprehensive compliance and enforcement system based on flag State inspection, port State control, and complaint procedures; and – significantly, for the first time, included certification of labour standards on board ships and the potential application of these standards to ships of non-ratifying States.
From a wider international law perspective, the Convention is of interest because it is one of the growing cadre of conventions that are responding to the search for ‘effectiveness of international law’ and reaches beyond the ‘face’ 88 There were amendments in total of which were adopted either as proposed or subamended. See: Seventh Sitting, International Labour Conference, th (Maritime) Session, Geneva, February , ILO Doc. No. PR, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/ standards/relm/ilc/ilc/pr-.pdfpage=, p. . Of these several related to areas such as the formula for coming into force and amendment of the MLC, and its Code that had been specifically left to be determined at the Conference. See: Report of the Discussion, Tripartite Intersessional Meeting on the Follow-up of the Preparatory Technical Maritime Conference, Geneva, – April , ILO Doc. No. PTMC//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/ dialogue/sector/techmeet/ptmc/ptmc-.pdf, paras –.
overview and introduction
the State sovereignty to directly affect the behaviour of private actors.89 Even more unusually, the MLC, contains provisions that seek to apply its requirements to non-ratifying States. In that sense it can be described as a convention that is ‘universal’ in its reach. This comprehensive Convention, and the process which led to its adoption, offers a rich case study relevant to broader twenty-first century concerns of international law and governance.90 These concerns include recent efforts to 89
This is explored in several case studies in Papdakas, supra note . A related and interesting analysis in the environmental context is provided by Natasha A. Affolder, “The private life of environmental treaties,” () American Journal of International Law . Her research explores the corporate performance and even ‘colonization’ of treaties arguing that increasingly there is a direct interaction between corporations and treaty performance, an issue that in her view has “long been a blind spot in international legal analysis” (p. ). See also Lillie , supra note , pp. –, who argues that (citations removed): The MLC negotiations show how, as capital globalizes, so do the state forms needed to support it. Much of the pressure for global reregulation of maritime shipping is arising from intensified class conflict, and the need for a global industrial relations system to resolve it. Investigation of the politics behind the MLC supports the contention that globalizing States are not “retreating” . . ., but neither are they continuing as insular entities, “sovereign” in the traditional sense of the word. Rather, States are “transforming”, as new forms of governance emerge, based perhaps on templates from the interstate system, but where this is the case, these forms of governance function in new ways. Regulatory demands on institutions like the ILO increase, as actors call on them to take on regulatory roles that nation States individually no longer can fulfil. In some respects, the MLC could be regarded as a reassertion of long-abandoned state regulatory authority over maritime labour standards. Despite the growth of private transnational industrial relations systems, ILO agreements continue to be embedded in the formal structures of an international system based on relations between sovereign States. The formal institution of national sovereignty and the intergovernmental global political framework are crucial to the MLC’s governance system. Clearly, the State retains importance as a central source of authority, in that it continues to mediate and apply international agreements. However, in a sense, the State’s role in the MLC is more as an intermediary than a coherent interest. There was a low level of state autonomy in formulating the MLC, and the implementation of the MLC’s “club” formation strategy involves a high degree of interlinked sovereignties. The degree to which States can in practice elect not to implement or enforce the MLC will be very limited (assuming of course that enough flag States ratify it for it to come into effect, and that enough port States ratify it to ensure that there is a strong incentive to comply). Although the formal institution of sovereignty is important in the MLC, it was formulated essentially by unions and shipowners and is aimed primarily at influencing the behaviour of private shipowners. While the MLC seeks to influence flag State behaviour, the primary pressure on flag States to ratify and comply will come not from ILO suasion or pressure from other governments but via the flagging preferences of shipowners. The ILO’s tripartite decision-making process encourages the formulation of transnational classbased interests. In the maritime shipping industry, transnational class-based actors have sufficiently well developed organizations and interests to take advantage of this, and build a functional global social partnership.
90
See discussion at pp. – and infra note . For a discussion of the potential arrangements, including delegation to international organizations, see: Mathias Koenig-Archibugi, “Mapping
chapter one
develop integrated approaches on matters that cut across international agency mandates; the emergence of international organizations of various ilk as a regulatory or administrative91 bureaucracy operating in what has been described as the “global administrative space”;92 the development of the compliance tools and supervisory systems under these organizations to ensure that international law is ‘effective’; and the implication of these and other concerns for the design of treaties. Aside from being of obvious sectoral interest and impact, the MLC, should also be understood as a first93 but important step—an experiment if you will—by the ILO in specifically addressing concerns raised by a number of commentators regarding imbalances in the global trade and economic law regime and its failure to truly address the relationship between the costs of labour and trade.94 From ILO and international labour and economic law perspectives, the MLC, is of interest in terms of the innovative approaches to the process and procedures, as discussed in Chapter , that were adopted
global governance,” in Governing globalization: power, authority and global governance, David Held and Anthony McGrew, eds. (Cambridge: Polity Press, ), p. . 91 See, for example, the case studies, including a case study of the ILO action on forced labour, in S. Cassese, B. Carotti, L. Casin, M. Macchia, E. MacDonald, and M. Savino, eds., Global Administrative Law: Cases, Materials, Issues, nd edition (New York: Institute for Research on Public Administration and the Institute for International Law and Justice, New York University School of Law, ), available at http://www.iilj.org/GAL/GALCasebook.asp. 92 Ibid. 93 The Work in Fishing Convention, and associated recommendation (R), supra note , adopts similar ideas mutatis mutandis for the fishing sector. 94 See supra note . Governance scholars Errol Mendes and Ozay Mehmet, Global Governance, Economy and Law: Waiting for Justice (New York, London: Routledge, ), have provided an extensive critique of the failure to integrate the issues of labour with trade in the ‘strong’ World Trade Organization (WTO) process and the failure of the trade policy review mechanism of the WTO or the supervisory system of the ILO to require that States provide a full picture of the relationship between labour costs and trade competitiveness, see esp. chapter at p. ff. and Chapter at pp. –. A recent joint study by the ILO and WTO, Marion Jensen and Eddy Lee, Trade and Employment: Challenges for Policy Research (Geneva: ILO and WTO, ), examined the interaction of trade and employment policy. See also Cleopatra Doumbia-Henry and Eric Gravel, “Free trade agreements and labour rights: Recent developments,” () International Labour Review –. In addition, the ILO has initiated research with respect to the economic dynamics of international labour standards. See: Project on Economic Dynamics of International Labour Standards, Governing Body, th Session, Geneva, November , ILO Doc. No. GB./LILS/, available at http://www.ilo.org/global/What_we_do/Officialmeetings/gb/ GBSessions/GB/lang-en/commId-LILS/WCMS_/index.htm. Possibly the MLC, may provide a response to critiques such as Philip Alston, “ ‘Core labour standards’ and the transformation of the international labour rights regime,” () European Journal of International Law which has raised concerns (see p. ) about the “eschewing of legalism” and, in his view, the related “weakening” of the labour standards regime, especially with the adoption of the Declaration and a principles based approach, relative to the stronger or ‘hard’ trade law system.
overview and introduction
during its development, as well as its relationship to existing ILO conventions and legal approaches, as discussed in Chapters and . The drafting and negotiation processes are also of interest because of the different actors and their roles, in particular the impacts of tripartism and the high level of involvement of shipowner and seafarer organizations. The MLC, is also of wider interest with respect to the increasing interest in the ILO in working with the economic dynamics of labour issues in promoting ‘decent work’ and ‘fair globalization’.95 The MLC, is explicitly based on the twin goals of helping to secure decent work for workers (seafarers) and helping to achieve fair competition. The latter goal is sometimes described as creating a ‘level playing field’96 among employers (shipowners) by addressing the unfair competition resulting from shipowners and flag States condoning or failing to regulate poor or substandard (below international norms) working conditions. The maritime sector, oft described, as explained earlier, as one of the first ‘internationalized’ or ‘globalized’97 sectors, presents particular challenges to the
95
The term ‘decent work’ encapsulates the contemporary agenda of the ILO: The Decent Work concept was formulated by the ILO’s constituents—governments and employers’ and workers’ organizations—as a means to identify the Organization’s major priorities and to modernize its approach for the twenty-first century. It is based on the understanding that work is a source of personal dignity, family stability, peace in the community, democracies that deliver for people, and economic growth that expands opportunities for productive jobs and enterprise development. In a relatively short time this concept has led to an international consensus among governments, employers, unions and civil society organizations that productive employment and Decent Work are key elements to achieving a fair globalization and the reduction of poverty.
See: ILO, “Facts on decent work,” available at http://www.ilo.org/global/About_the_ILO/Media_ and_public_information/Factsheets/lang-en/docName-WCMS_/index.htm. 96 This concept is, of course, one that can be debated, especially in the context of developing economies. 97 B. Wu and H. Sampson, “Reconsidering the cargo sector’s seafarer labor market: A st century profile of global seafarers,” in Ocean Yearbook, Volume , A. Chircop and M. McConnell, eds. (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, ), –. See also: Lillie , supra note , p. , who provides the following rather dramatic description of the situation in the maritime sector: The global maritime shipping business has often been portrayed as the archetype of unbridled free market capitalism, burst free from constraints of government and union regulation, . . . Effectively freed from national hiring restrictions, most shipowners no longer crew their vessels with the highly unionized seafarers of the traditional maritime countries . . . instead preferring to hire from the lower wage maritime labour exporting countries, such as . . . As a result, a global and transnational labour market for seafarers developed, with fierce global competition sending wages, union power and respect for workers’ rights in a downward spiral.
chapter one
international legal system.98 It is perhaps one of the most concrete examples of the ‘cutting edge’ or future of many of the underlying issues relating to globalization, with workers drawn from many countries working in workplaces that move between jurisdictions and involving employer/ownership arrangements that are similarly fluid. This is the future face of many sectors emanating from the impact of electronic communications and the equally fluid ‘e-highway’ on the location of workplaces and workers and diverse issues including, inter alia, extra-territoriality, the tension between the ‘North’ and the ‘South’, and the challenges to principles of State sovereignty as manifest in the concept of flag State control. As explained above and explored further in Chapter , since the late s, the ILO has increasingly focused it efforts on achieving change by working with governments and relevant national organizations to secure decent working conditions, including social protection, largely by adopting a rights-based approach. This has also involved attention to ensuring effective implementation—that is, moving beyond de jure to de facto implementation of legal obligations. Related to this has been a concern that while there are many conventions in force, key interested States have not ratified them for reasons such as technical aspects that are out dated or otherwise impede implementation even in cases where there is agreement with the principles of a convention. Not surprisingly, the interaction of the economic system, the international trade regime, and labour standards, particularly in the context of sustainable economic development, is a central concern. The ILO has not taken a position against globalization per se but rather has long argued for ‘fair globalization’, that is the need to ensure that exploitation of workers does not become a competitive advantage.99 All of these factors provide the backdrop against which the MLC, was developed.
98
From one perspective it may be a relative easy or vulnerable target for experimenting with change. The high degree of internationalization and the extensive international regulatory regime already in place under the IMO and the ILO means that, depending on the extent of economic reliance on the sector, some governments are more easily able to withstand domestic lobbying to resist international regulation and standards. 99 World Commission on the Social Dimension of Globalization, supra note .
chapter two THE STORY OF THE MARITIME LABOUR CONVENTION, 2006 author’s note1 This chapter is a narrative2 recounting of the sequence of events and concerns, as recalled by its author drawing on the reports of meetings that she attended and her continuing engagement with the development of the MLC, from its beginning. I have used the word ‘story’ to capture the sense of a particular purpose, perhaps even a mission, that accompanied and captured all who were involved in this effort. Certainly the period between and indelibly imprinted and shaped the lives of all who were engaged in the process to produce this major new international ‘bill of rights’—the seafarers’ representatives, the shipowners’ representatives, key government representatives, and staff and advisors of the International Labour Office. It had all the elements of a heroic journey with numerous challenges and successes, from which many lessons might be learned. While it is not possible to name all outstanding personalities it is equally unwise wise to venture to name a few key people. This is not because they did not exist, but because of a fear of overlooking one of the many who contributed, at differing stages, to the final text of the MLC, . Nevertheless the text of the Convention stands now as a legacy marking, albeit without individual attribution, the significant combined efforts of so many over so many years.
1
The views expressed in this chapter are the personal views of its author, Dr. Cleopatra DoumbiaHenry and are not to be understood as the views of the International Labour Office or the International Labour Organization. The author of this chapter, one of the co-authors of this book, is the Director of the International Standards Department, International Labour Office, ILO, Geneva. As an ILO official she was directly involved with, and variously responsible for legal advice (in the late s as Senior Legal Officer, Legal Office of the Secretariat) and guidance to the social partners in their examination of the issues and options and, ultimately, in her role first as the Director of the Sectoral Activities department and then the International Labour Standards Department, the carriage of the MLC, from its initiation until its adoption in . She is now responsible for the ILO’s role in ensuring follow-up, in cooperation with other ILO departments, to ensure that the Convention enters into force. As the Director responsible for the operation of the ILO supervisory system (see Chapter ), she is also responsible for the operation of the supervisory bodies of the ILO that will review national implementation of the Convention, once it enters into force. 2 This term is used to indicate the more reflective, experiential, even personal, approach to this chapter.
chapter two Seafarers Have Always Been a Concern for the ILO
From its first days, the Members of the ILO realized that in the world of work, seafarers and shipowners were different. Not land-based but working on the seas, they not only moved huge amounts of world trade even years ago, they were the most fluid and wide-ranging workforce on the planet. When the first ILC convened in June of , the year the Organization was created, and began discussing the regulation of working hours, the need for a special approach to living and working conditions in the maritime sector became apparent. A year later, in , the second ILC, held in Genoa, Italy, was devoted to seafarers. It adopted3 the National Seamen’s Code Recommendation, with its single substantive provision stating: In order that, as a result of the clear and systematic codification of the national law in each country, the seamen of the world, whether engaged on ships of their own or foreign countries, may have a better comprehension of their rights and obligations, and in order that the task of establishing an International Seamen’s Code may be advanced and facilitated, the International Labour Conference recommends that each Member of the International Labour Organisation undertake the embodiment in a seamen’s code of all its laws and regulations relating to seamen in their activities as such.4
Since , it has been the practice of the ILC to convene a special Maritime Session to deal exclusively with seafarers’ living and working conditions. The bipartite Joint Maritime Commission (JMC),5 established in , has advised the ILO’s Governing Body on maritime questions, especially on the selection of
3 See also Chapter and infra. It is also notable that in an era when social security schemes were not well developed for any sector that this Session also adopted a recommendation, Unemployment Insurance (Seamen) Recommendation, (R), “with a view to securing the application to seamen of Part III of the Recommendation concerning unemployment adopted at Washington on November . It recommended that each Member of the ILO establish for seamen an effective system of insurance against unemployment arising out of shipwreck or any other cause, either by means of Government insurance or by means of Government subventions to industrial organisations whose rules provide for the payment of benefits to their unemployed members.” See also: Unemployment Indemnity (Shipwreck) Convention, (No. ), Genoa, July , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm. However, as discussed in Chapter in connection with Regulation ., in the issue of social security coverage for all seafarers remained a difficult matter. 4 National Seamen’s Code Recommendation, (R), Genoa, July , available at http:// www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/recdisp.htm. 5 The JMC is a standing bipartite body established by the ILO Governing Body. It provides advice to the Governing Body on maritime questions including standard setting for the shipping industry. It is composed of titular members, representing shipowners and representing seafarers, and four deputy members for each of the two groups. They are all nominated by the ILC. The meetings of the JMC are chaired by the Chairperson of the Governing Body.
the story of the maritime labour convention,
items to be submitted to the Maritime Sessions of the ILC. As early as , at its th Session, the JMC adopted a resolution dealing, inter alia, with the ratification of maritime conventions and outlined a programme of work for the International Labour Office (the Office).6 That programme of work also included the possibility of preparing an international maritime charter. It is the special nature of the living and working conditions of maritime workers which led the ILC to adopt a large number of conventions and recommendations applying specifically to seafarers.7 The nine Maritime Sessions of the ILC prior to the adoption of the MLC, adopted over maritime legal instruments (conventions and recommendations).8 These instruments cover a wide range of issues, including recruitment and placement services, minimum age, hours of work or rest, safety, health and welfare, labour inspection, and social security. Together they have been referred to as the ‘International Seafarers’ Code’. This body of international standards represents a considerable achievement for the protection of the workers concerned and for the industry as a whole. The Origin of the MLC, The origin of the MLC, , which was adopted in at the th Maritime Session of the ILC, can be traced back to two important developments or phenomena in the late s: the review being undertaken of ILO standards by the Governing Body of the ILO9 and the major changes that were then taking place in the maritime industry. Turning to the first, the legal impetus came from the process launched by the ILO Governing Body in to establish a Working Party on Policy regarding the Revision of Standards (the Working Party) as a follow-up to discussions on ILO standard-setting policy held in the framework of the ILC in .10 The
6 See International Labour Office, Minutes of the Ninety-First Session of the Governing Body, London, – December , Fifth Sitting, Agenda Item Four, Record of the Twelfth Session of the Joint Maritime Commission and of the Meeting of its Subcommittee (London, June and May ), pp. –, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/libdoc/ilo/P//.pdf. 7 Some of these conventions and recommendations also apply under certain conditions to fishers, dockworkers, and personnel working on inland boats. 8 These include conventions, one protocol to a convention, and recommendations. See also the discussion in Chapter on predecessor conventions. 9 As noted in Chapters and , the Governing Body is the executive arm of the ILO. It is composed of government, employer, and worker representatives. 10 See, Defending Values, Promoting Change, Social Justice in a Global Economy: An ILO Agenda, Report of the Director-General, International Labour Conference, st Session, Geneva, .
chapter two
Working Party was to examine the need for revision of all ILO conventions and recommendations adopted by the Organization prior to with the objective of rejuvenating and strengthening the standard-setting system. Proposals were not to have the effect of reducing the protection afforded to workers by ratified conventions.11 The Working Party initiated its review of the relevant12 maritime labour instruments in November and completed it in March . Its work was facilitated by recommendations made to it, at its request, by the constituent Members of the JMC which had itself formed the Joint Working Group of Shipowners and Seafarers for this purpose. The Joint Working Group of Shipowners’ and Seafarers’ representative organizations met in Geneva in July and again in May . The JMC was also requested its view on five social security maritime instruments that it had not yet reviewed.13 The JMC formulated recommendations, most of which were approved by the ILO’s Governing Body.14 The result of this consultation with the industry was a decision taken by the Governing Body on the recommendation of the Working Party to promote six conventions as being up to date, to revise seven conventions considered to be outdated,15 and to propose for denunciation. 11 The ILO Working Party regarding the Revision of Standards was established under the auspices of the Legal Issues and International Labour Standards Committee (LILS) of the ILO Governing Body. One element of its terms of reference provided that proposals for revision of conventions and recommendations adopted before “were not to have the effect of reducing the protection already afforded to workers by ratified Conventions”. See: ILO Doc. No. GB.// (March–April ), para. . 12 It is important to recall that the Working Party did not examine conventions and recommendations adopted after , which the Governing Body considered were up to date. 13 They were the Unemployment Indemnity (Shipwreck) Convention, (No. ), Genoa, July ; Shipowners’ Liability (Sick and Injured Seamen) Convention, (No. ), Geneva, October ; Sickness Insurance (Sea) Convention, (No. ), Geneva, October ; Social Security (Seafarers) Convention, (No. ), Seattle, June ; and Seafarers’ Pensions Convention, (No. ), Seattle, June , all available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/ english/convdisp.htm. 14 While most of the recommendations made by the Joint Working Group were approved by the Governing Body, different decisions were approved in respect of four conventions, viz., the Placing of Seamen Convention, (No. ), Genoa, July ; Officers’ Competency Certificates Convention, (No. ), Geneva, October ; Minimum Age (Sea) Convention (Revised), (No. ), Geneva, October ; and Accommodation of Crews Convention (Revised), (No. ), Geneva, June , all available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/ convdisp.htm. Although the Joint Working Group had recommended the shelving of Convention No. , the Governing Body decided to maintain the status quo. In the case of Convention No. , the Joint Working Group proposed its revision, while the Governing Body decided to maintain the status quo. In the case of Conventions Nos. and , the Joint Working Group had proposed to maintain the status quo, but the Governing Body decided to invite Member States to ratify the more up-to-date conventions and to re-examine the status of the two conventions in due course. 15 The seven conventions were the Medical Examination of Young Persons (Sea) Convention, (No. ), Geneva, November ; Seamen’s Articles of Agreement Convention,
the story of the maritime labour convention,
Concerning the recommendations, were considered either up to date or that the status quo be maintained, four were considered to have been replaced, and five were considered obsolete and proposed for withdrawal. Prior to the meeting of the JMC, informal meetings were held between members of the Working Group of shipowners and seafarers and the secretariat of the Office on the possible options available and potential solutions, taking advantage of the Governing Body review exercise. When the JMC met in January , it had before it three reports: the first concerned the review of the relevant ILO maritime instruments; the second dealt with updating the ILO’s minimum basic wage for able seamen; and the third was a report on the impact on seafarers’ living and working conditions of changes in the structure of the shipping industry.16 The second development is reflected in the third report referred to above. This report, The Impact on Seafarers’ Living and Working Conditions of Changes in the Structure of the Shipping Industry17 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the third report’), highlighted structural developments in the industry, including changes in ownership, the financing and management of shipping fleets, new forms of registers, dramatic shifts in the origin of labour supply, the growth of multinational and multicultural crews, and developments in turnaround time of ships coupled with reduced crewing levels. Each of these developments has an impact on the living and working conditions of seafarers. Although shipping has always been considered a global industry by virtue of its very special nature, globalization18 of the world economy has not left the industry unaffected. Outside the structural changes that transformed the shipping industry, in the last quarter of the twentieth century, as mentioned in Chapter of this book,19 the emergence of a global labour market for seafarers has effectively transformed the shipping industry into the world’s first genuinely global industry.
(No. ), Geneva, June ; Food and Catering (Ships’ Crews) Convention, (No. ), Seattle, June ; Certification of Ships’ Cooks Convention, (No. ), Seattle, June ; Medical Examination (Seafarers) Convention, (No. ), Seattle, June ; Certification of Able Seamen Convention, (No. ), Seattle, June ; and Prevention of Accidents (Seafarers) Convention, (No. ), Geneva, October , all available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm. 16 For these reports, see http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/jmc/ index.htm. 17 The Impact on Seafarers’ Living and Working Conditions of Changes in the Structure of the Shipping Industry, Joint Maritime Commission, th Session, Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. JMC///, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/jmc/ jmc-r.pdf. 18 See introductory comments in Chapter , note for a discussion of the term ‘globalization’. 19 See introductory comments in Chapter , footnote .
chapter two
The third report considered that there was the need for a global response, an international regulatory response of an appropriate kind—global standards applicable to the entire industry. It called for standards that would ensure decent shipping fleets, and decent safety and social standards for all seafarers as called for by the Director-General of the ILO in his report Decent Work.20 The third report showed evidence that there had been a dramatic weakening of national regulatory regimes, with an accelerated shift from traditional maritime registers to other registers. The link between the flag State and the seafarer had become even more tenuous with the variety of forms of ownership, management, and control of ships. It was especially concerned about the growing avoidance of social regulations, which had become the weakest link in the chain in the face of increased international competition and the requirement for mandatory compliance with technical standards. The third report called for breaking the vicious circle of low freight rates, extremely poor conditions and standards, weak national regulatory mechanisms, and the reluctance to enforce internationally applicable labour standards. It did not make sweeping generalizations concerning living and working conditions of seafarers as it recognized that seafarers working on ships under some flag States or some types of ships did enjoy high standards. The third report expressed concern about the poor conditions21 that arose from some of these developments and recommended adopting minimum standards that would neither reflect the lowest common denominator nor be unrealistically high. These international standards should respond to the primary role of the ILO today, that is, to promote opportunities for men and women to obtain decent and productive work in conditions of freedom, equity, security, and human dignity. And this was precisely the action that the ILO’s Director-General called for in his report.22 This overall goal was endorsed by the ILC to be pursued within the context of the global economy. ‘Decent work’ is considered relevant for all countries, including the developed, developing, and transition economies, and equally applicable to all sectors of the global economy—not least the maritime industry.
20
Decent Work, Report of the Director-General, ILC, th Session, Geneva, , available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/rep-i.htm. See also: Chapter , p. , and ILO Web site, ‘Decent Work’, available at http://www.ilo.org/global/Themes/Decentwork/ lang-en/index.htm. 21 This report is consistent with the concerns expressed in by the International Commission on Shipping, Inquiry into Ship Safety, Slavery and Competition (Australia: ICONS, ), as noted in Chapter , note . 22 Supra note , p. .
the story of the maritime labour convention,
The Director-General’s report highlighted the importance of enhancing the ILO’s work on standards and considered a number of actions to raise the profile of its work. Many of these possible actions shaped the approach to the negotiation and adoption of the MLC, . These included: – preparing the ground for new standards more thoroughly; – exploring new methods of standard setting; – engaging in deeper analysis of existing standards, their synergy, lacunae, and impact on various groups; – accelerating the revision of outdated instruments to build on progress already made and promoting priority standards as problem-solving tools; – enhancing the impact of supervision of standards; and – reasserting the role of ILO standards in the broader world context.23
The third report and the results of the Working Party necessarily gave rise to a number of questions concerning the impact of maritime labour standards. What profile do these standards have? What has been their impact on the working and living conditions of seafarers, employment in the industry, and on the industry itself? What are the reasons for the low rates of ratification of maritime labour conventions compared to International Maritime Organization (IMO) conventions? Among the third report’s conclusions were those related to the fragmented nature of these numerous existing maritime labour instruments and the very low and uneven rate of ratifications of these conventions. The fragmentation can be explained by the fact that these instruments were all adopted in response to a specific problem or specific needs—over a period of almost years. They covered most of the essential issues relevant to seafarers’ working and living conditions. However, having them widely ratified and implemented, as well as keeping them up to date, had proved to be a major challenge.24 In addition, the problem of ‘treaty congestion’ made it difficult for Member States to engage in separate ratification processes for so many instruments. Essentially they did not represent a manageable set of standards to govern a truly global industry. 23
Supra note , p. . The Director-General’s Report also called for reasserting the usefulness of international labour standards; reinvigorating efforts to experiment with new approaches; encouraging closer consultation with constituents; analysing proposed standards in terms of their potential impact on economic and social policy and their complementarity with other international instruments; and reinvigorating promotional efforts to see that standards are ratified and applied. Reference was also made to the difficulties encountered with ratification, especially as parliaments around the world often have a long list of items awaiting their attention. 24 Ratification of the maritime conventions and one protocol ranged from Member States to none. By , the Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, (No. ), Geneva, October , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm, the best known ILO maritime convention, had been ratified by (as December ) Member States representing more than per cent of the world shipping gross tonnage.
chapter two
The low rate of ratifications of maritime conventions is widespread. The third report refers to the demands of competition as one reason. Another reason may be that social and labour issues are given lower priority than environmental and safety concerns. The fact that shipping issues are dealt with by national ministries dealing with maritime matters or by maritime authorities, and labour matters by ministries of labour, means problems of coordination and competence play a role in sustaining the interest for the ratification of maritime labour conventions. The role of national social partners in promoting ratification of ILO conventions was also seen as important. The shift to international registers and the fact that increasing numbers of seafarers are being employed on ships flying the flag of countries of which they are not a nationals has weakened the role of the social partners at the national level in these countries. Ratifications alone, however, do not give the full picture, and there is no doubt that although the pertinent conventions may not have been ratified, they have still influenced national law and practice—and in some cases are actually applied even if they are not ratified. For example, as the report showed, port State control has also permitted extending compliance with the requirements under the ILO’s Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, (No. ) to third countries, particularly those that had not ratified the pertinent conventions. Nevertheless the generally low rate of ratifications and the difficulty in putting labour issues on the maritime and legislative agendas at the national level raised concerns as to whether the maritime labour standards met the needs of the industry. The report25 prepared by the Office for the JMC meeting on the review of relevant ILO maritime instruments made several proposals responding to these concerns. It proposed an integrated approach to future standard setting in the maritime field, with three options for consideration. The first was to limit new standard-setting action to the revision of the seven outdated instruments as the Working Party had proposed. The second was a proposal for the consolidation of all existing and up-to-date maritime conventions into a single new framework convention. The third proposal consisted of consolidating the instruments into four or five framework conventions under major subject areas. The Office report also examined the possible added value, as well as the disadvantages of the approach of consolidating the instruments into one or more framework instruments. This was combined with the following suggestions for possible ‘value added’ elements beyond the simple fact of consolidation: 25
Review of Relevant ILO Maritime Labour Instruments, JMC, th Session, Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. JMC///, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/ techmeet/jmc/jmc-r.pdf.
the story of the maritime labour convention,
– the existing instruments would be thematically and coherently regrouped into one or more instruments; – articulation of the basic principles applicable to the maritime industry to achieve progress towards sectoral universality of obligations or progress towards it; – simplified content of the provisions of the convention; – no less favourable treatment provisions in the annexes; – inclusion of the substantial equivalence concept in the absence of acceptance of specific provisions, in respect of the provisions relating to Convention No. ; – facilitated mechanisms for the updating of annexes (amendment procedures different from that applicable to the convention); – enforcement procedures, including port State control; – the possibility of a new type of general survey, conducted at regular intervals, enabling a closer monitoring of progress made towards meeting the objectives of the convention; – inclusion of a new dynamic role for the maritime social partners through the JMC or an expanded JMC; and – provisions for technical assistance to complement efforts of governments, shipowners, and seafarers and to create incentives for compliance.
Several possible disadvantages were seen to this new approach. A framework convention extracting the main elements and principles in existing conventions could move certain detailed provisions, which currently are in the body of conventions, to the annexes, or possibly even to recommendations. However there was no guarantee that the new approach would meet with greater success than the existing instruments. Convention No. , in keeping with the globalized nature of the maritime sector, placed responsibility on all countries for ships flying their flag or coming within their territorial jurisdiction. It had become a generally recognized international standard, and every attempt should be made to preserve it. There was a fear that, if the new approach were not successful, it might weaken the existing body of standards. However, the possibility of regular monitoring of a single instrument through the new type of general survey might mitigate or even eliminate this risk. This new tool might well offer a guarantee for the success of the Convention. On the other hand, the consolidation of maritime labour instruments was also seen as a way to engage in a comprehensive rationalization of the ILO’s maritime activities. The standards were judged on their ability to promote the objectives of the ILO, with special attention being given to the changes in the shipping industry due to globalization. The adoption of the proposed consolidated instrument would be consistent with the will to incorporate individual standards into more comprehensive ones. It would imply an improved focus in the ILO’s maritime activities, including promotion of standards as well as technical cooperation, and would result in better coordination with similar activities of other institutions, particularly those of the IMO in the related areas of safety at sea and protection of the environment.
chapter two
The Office report26 took a comprehensive view of the entire body of maritime labour standards and proposed an approach that was consistent with the consensus arrived at by the ILO Governing Body in November concerning an integrated approach to standard setting. Two of the proposals presented (the second and third options) were intended to ensure that the maritime social partners would give due consideration to an effective response to a truly global industry, provide a level playing field that would address substandard shipping, and provide assurances to seafarers that they would enjoy decent working conditions on all ships irrespective of the flag they fly. It is this report that first articulated the idea of one flagship instrument that would represent ‘the bill of rights’ for the industry and seek to ‘ensure progress towards sectoral universality of obligations’. The idea was also to ensure that the new instrument would be capable of responding to the rapid changes, needs, and technological developments being experienced by a truly global industry— shipping. The th Session of the JMC: Turning of the Tide—A historic Moment The JMC discussed these three reports at its th Session in January .27 The Shipowners’ Members on the JMC indicated that this was the first time in its history that the JMC had considered a cycle of ILO maritime activities without having before it resolutions adopted at a previous Maritime Session of the ILC. They felt that this allowed the JMC to step back from specific issues and consider wider, more fundamental concerns about the system of regulation of labour standards in the maritime sector.28 They considered this issue to be of most long-term significance to the industry and submitted a proposal containing an outline of a possible future framework convention.29 The Seafarers’ Members on the JMC took the view that these reports provided an opportunity to change the face of international labour rights. In their opinion, truly global standards, enforced through port State control, were needed and new regulatory mechanisms were essential to protect basic social, welfare, and employment rights of those seafarers employed under globalized
26
Ibid. Final Report, JMC, th Session, Geneva, – January , ILO Doc. No. JMC/// , available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/jmc/jmcfr.htm. 28 Ibid., para. . 29 Ibid., para. and Appendix . 27
the story of the maritime labour convention,
conditions.30 They concurred with the shipowners that the boldest way forward, a single instrument, was the best approach.31 The major concern expressed at this stage was the need to ensure that the proposed framework convention approach would not discourage countries from ratifying Convention No. or those that had recently ratified it from ratifying the possible new instrument. They noted in particular that Convention No. was included as a relevant instrument in seven regional memoranda of understanding on port State control. While they were concerned that Convention No. should not be undermined, they were equally of the opinion that the proposed consolidated instrument would replace Convention No. as the primary port State control instrument concerning labour conditions for seafarers.32 In response to concerns raised by the Shipowners and Seafarers Members at the JMC concerning the impact of a new framework convention on Convention No. , the Office explained that the move towards a single consolidated instrument was based on the premise that the ‘capital’ of present and any future ratifications would remain. This would create an incentive for the ratification of the new framework convention. An ILO Member State would remain bound by the conventions it had ratified until it had assumed all the equivalent obligations under the new framework convention.33 The ratification of the new framework convention would provide for the automatic denunciation at the time of entry into force for the Member concerned of the existing convention. If the required conditions were not met, the ILO convention would remain in force for that Member. Care would need to be taken to ensure that at least the main provisions of the existing conventions would be identical in substance to those in the new convention. The Office also explained that, as far as Convention No. in particular was concerned, two possibilities presented themselves. The first case could be that of a Member State that had ratified Convention No. and had national legislation giving effect to its obligations under that convention. As the new framework convention would incorporate the obligations contained in Convention No. , the State should not have to change its legislation to be able to ratify the new framework convention. The State might decide not to ratify the framework convention if it contained other obligations concerning standards not included in Convention No. for which it did not have compliant laws
30 31 32 33
Ibid., para. . Ibid., para. . Ibid., para. . See the discussion in Chapter in connection with Article X.
chapter two
and regulations. The second case could be that of a Member State that had not ratified Convention No. but had ratified the new framework convention. Under Article ()(d) of the ILO Constitution, that Member was required to “take such action as may be necessary to make effective the provisions of [the new] Convention”. It was important that all States understood that ratification of Convention No. would in fact make it easier to ratify the new consolidated instrument. Promotion of the ratification of Convention No. was therefore to be encouraged. The Geneva Accord: Shipowners and Seafarers Spark the Renaissance of ILO Maritime Standards Both the Shipowner and Seafarer Members of the JMC agreed that the emergence of the global labour market for seafarers had effectively transformed the shipping industry into a global industry requiring an appropriate legal regime with a body of global standards. Their concerns regarding existing ILO maritime labour standards were that they: – – – – – –
had not kept pace with developments in the shipping industry; were often set out in complex, uncoordinated and overlapping provisions; were subject to time-consuming and costly amendment procedures, were inadequately applied at the international level; were unevenly enforced, unfairly burdening providers of decent work; and lacked certain aspects in comparison with those of non-tripartite bodies.
In expressing these concerns, they desired to bring the system of protection contained in existing instruments closer to the workers concerned and to improve the applicability of the system so that shipowners and governments interested in providing decent working conditions do not bear an unequal burden in ensuring such protection. They did not call into question the legal status or substance of the existing instruments but rather called for greater consistency and clarity, more rapid adaptability and general applicability. The Shipowner and Seafarer Members of the JMC agreed that the existing ILO maritime instruments should be consolidated and brought up to date by means of a new single framework convention on maritime labour standards. They therefore selected the second option offered in the Office report. They called the agreement, designed to improve safety, social and working conditions in the maritime industry, the ‘Geneva Accord’.34 The agreement was adopted in
34
Supra note , para. .
the story of the maritime labour convention,
the form of the Resolution concerning the review of relevant ILO maritime instruments.35 The Accord reaffirms the need for an international regulatory response establishing global standards applicable to the entire industry. It recognized the unique needs of the shipping industry, as regards international labour standards, and its historical status in the ILO. They considered that the development of an instrument that consolidated the text of the existing body of ILO instruments should be a priority for the maritime sector in order to improve the relevance of these standards for all the stakeholders. Further, the consolidated instrument should comprise a number of parts concerned with key principles of such labour standards as may be determined, together with annexes incorporating detailed requirements for each of the parts. The instrument should also provide for revision of the annexes through an accelerated amendment procedure. With a view to taking their conclusions forward, the Shipowner and Seafarer Members recommended to the Governing Body that it establish a high-level tripartite working group on maritime labour standards to assist with the work of developing the proposed new instrument and that membership should comprise ten representatives of each group. They also recommended that the Governing Body establish a tripartite subgroup to prepare and consider the working papers in advance of meetings of the high-level tripartite working group. In addition they recommended that the Governing Body convene (a) a preparatory meeting in for first discussion of the proposed new instrument; and (b) a Maritime Session of the Conference in to adopt the instrument with the following agenda: ) consolidation of ILO maritime instruments; and ) general discussion on developments in the industry. The Accord also recommended that a Resolutions Committee be established in accordance with Article of the Standing Orders of the ILC. In adopting the Geneva Accord, the Shipowner and Seafarer Members were clearly taking a stance that supported international regulation rather than national or regional regulation of maritime labour standards. They wanted such regulation to be up to date, relevant, widely accepted, and properly enforced irrespective of the flag of the ship, the nationality of the seafarer, or the port a ship visited. The Seafarer Members considered that the current system provided a financial incentive for substandard operations including conditions of work. They called for a new approach, universal regulation of working and living conditions of seafarers accompanied by an enforcement mechanism. Like any other employer, the Shipowner Members did not view the imposition of yet more regulation with more relish. However they wanted sensible
35
Supra note , Appendix .
chapter two
and impartially applied labour standards so that a level playing field could be created where standards of service, instead of poor conditions based on low cost, would dictate customer preference. For them, the uneven application of labour standards had lead to imbalances in international shipping. Their common point was that both social partners agreed that the international shipping industry needed global enforceable standards and that social dialogue at the international level should lead to improved global governance in the industry. The Director-General’s report to the th Session of the ILC in June specifically referred to the Geneva Accord as ‘historic’ noting the contribution the Accord would make to the future development of labour standards in the international shipping industry as the third global pillar—the social pillar— to complement the other two pillars, maritime environmental and safety standards.36 The Director-General singled out the maritime industry and the maritime social partners in particular for responding to his call for a global coalition for decent work. He stated in this respect, And one that I must say I like very much: in concluding a historic agreement at the Joint Maritime Commission earlier this year, shipowners and seafarers declared that they were proud to be, . . . “torchbearers for the ILO campaign to promote decent work the world over”.37
Thus the resolution of the th Session of the JMC, the Geneva Accord, met key ILO goals. Its call for the development of a new ‘framework’ convention, which would consolidate as far as possible and update the wide range of existing maritime labour standards into a single, simpler instrument, fits in both with the trends in the Organization’s standard-setting action over the last decade or so and with its current strategic objectives concerning decent work. Additionally, the shipowners and seafarers offered eight solutions (Figure ) that laid the foundation for the subsequent substantive discussions. Together these guiding principles38 governed the entire preparatory process leading to the elaboration, negotiation, and adoption of what was to become the MLC, .
36
See, Reducing the Decent Work Deficit: A Global Challenge, Report of the Director-General, ILC, th Session, ILO Doc. No. Report (A), , available at http://www.ilo.org/public/ english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/pdf/rep-i-a.pdf, pp. –. Interestingly, the MLC, also came to be known as the ‘fourth pillar’ complementing the three major IMO conventions, see text at Chapter , note . 37 Ibid., p. and the Third Sitting, ILC, th Session, Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. PR, p. . 38 These solutions comprise a mix of recommendations combining substantive objectives (i.e., , , and ), and structure and format (i.e., and ).
the story of the maritime labour convention,
Figure . The eight ‘preferred solutions’ of the shipowners and seafarers39 . The provisions of the corpus of international maritime labour standards that are sufficiently up to date should be consolidated as a matter of priority and in so far as this proves possible to achieve. . Their substance should be incorporated in a single, coherent instrument, seen as part of the general body of standards adopted by the ILO, and fitting in with other international maritime instruments. . The consolidated instrument should consist of a number of Parts setting out the key principles of international maritime labour standards. . The Parts should be complemented by annexes setting out detailed requirements for each of the Parts. . A simplified amendment procedure should be provided for updating the annexes and ensuring prompt entry into effect. . The instrument should also contain the substance of recommendations and other non-mandatory texts. . The instrument should be drafted in such a way as to secure the widest possible acceptability among governments, shipowners and seafarers committed to the principles of Decent Work. . The instrument should contain provisions giving responsibility to all States to ensure that decent conditions of work apply on all ships that are placed under their jurisdiction or that come within their jurisdiction.
Launching the High-level Tripartite Negotiation Process Less than two months after the JMC meeting, at its th Session (March ), the Governing Body of the ILO approved the proposals made to it by the JMC and established the High-level Tripartite Working Group on Maritime Labour Standards (HLTWG)40 to consider the development of a single, 39
Briefing Note, HLTWG (First Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS / , available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmlsr- .pdf, para. .. See also the discussion in Chapter at notes through . 40 Report of the th Session of the Joint Maritime Commission, Geneva, – January , Governing Body, th Session, Geneva, March , ILO Doc. No. GB /(Corr.), see especially para. : Taking account of . . . the relevant recommendations made by the Joint Maritime Commission, the Governing Body may wish to: (a) establish a high-level tripartite working group in accordance with paragraph above, with a composition of Government representatives, Shipowners’ representatives and Seafarers’ representatives and of Government, Employers’ and Workers’ observers with the right to speak and participate in the meetings of the working group taking due account of the criteria set out in paragraph (c) above and stressing that representatives and observers should be knowledgeable and active
chapter two
coherent international standard incorporating, as far as possible, the substance of all the various international maritime labour standards that were sufficiently up to date. The first meeting of the HLTWG was held in December .41 Importantly it operated on the basis of ‘tripartite consensus’, an approach that valued the views of the three Groups and allowed for a wide range of views in discussions without requiring weighted voting. It addressed several key issues: the task of consolidation, the innovations that could be included, for example, a new amendment procedure to address updating of the convention and the low level of ratifications, and the enhanced role given to ratifying States to ensure that decent conditions of work are present not only on ships registered in their territory, but also on ships calling at their ports. As will be discussed in more detail in Chapter , from a legal drafting perspective, the meeting had before it a possible general structure of the framework instrument.42 It was proposed that it would comprise of two components: a binding and a non-binding component. There would be a number of parts incorporating the basic principles of existing conventions whose general applicability is required to ensure that parties providing decent conditions of work are not placed at a disadvantage. Part I was envisaged to contain a statement of fundamental principles and rights at work, that is, those contained in maritime conventions and in other relevant international labour conventions. It would also set out the responsibilities of the parties with respect to the inspection of ships. The remaining parts would be devoted to a particular ‘family’ of principles and rights. Each part was intended to have an annex setting out detailed requirements for implementation of the principles and rights in the part concerned. This would relate to the more detailed provisions of the conventions concerned. These were the provisions that would be the subject of the simpli-
in the enforcement of the standards to be adopted and be able to commit the necessary time to lend to the continuity of the process; (b) approve the recommendation that the decisions of the high-level tripartite working group should be taken by consensus; (c) approve the setting up of a tripartite subgroup in accordance with the modalities set out in paragraph above; (d) invite the Director-General to take note of the requests contained in paragraphs and above when establishing the programme of work of the Office for the rest of this biennium as well as for the – and – Biennia. 41 Final Report, HLTWG (First Meeting), Geneva, – December , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS /, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/tw gmls/twgmls-fr.pdf. See also Chapters and . Appendix of this book provides a brief history of the negotiation sessions. 42 Working Paper, HLTWG (First Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS / , available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmlsr- .pdf. See also Chapter .
the story of the maritime labour convention,
fied amendment procedure. In the Office suggestions, it was initially envisaged that at the time of ratification, ILO Member States could decide not to be immediately bound by particular parts or annexes of the new instrument. It was also envisaged that there would be an additional component reflecting the international labour recommendations and other material that would not have mandatory force. Among the issues that the first HLTWG meeting had to discuss were those related to the content of the consolidation, the distribution of the provisions within this content, and the mechanisms for updating the instrument. Concerning the content of the consolidation, several issues were addressed: which provisions out of the existing maritime labour conventions and protocol should be included; whether it should include only the higher standard where there was an older lower standard and a more up-to-date higher standard on the same subject; what type of flexibility, including substantial equivalence, should be included if the higher standard was retained; and which options would facilitate ratification. Several other issues were raised as well. Concerning distribution, the questions were how to distribute the provisions of the instrument among its various components and what criteria should be used for the distribution. How would the provisions that constituted principles for inclusion in the parts be determined and which ones constituted details for inclusion in the annexes to which the simplified amendment procedure could be applied? Throughout the development of the instrument, governments were asked to indicate the kind of legislative provisions that would be included in their regulations or collective agreements rather than in acts of parliament. Concerning the simplified amendment procedure, the objective was to devise a mechanism for updating the annexes that would combine the greatest possible flexibility with general applicability to governments and national parliaments. In this case, the Office explored the options of both an ‘opting-in’43 and an ‘opting-out’44 procedure. 43 The ‘opting-in’ procedure would allow for amendments that were adopted by the ILC to be submitted to Members for acceptance. This was the case with the Employment Injury Benefits Convention, [Schedule I amended in ] (No. ). In , the ILC, identifying the need for a simplified procedure for updating a list of occupational diseases, adopted the List of Occupational Diseases Recommendation, (No. ). According to paragraph , the list annexed to this Recommendation should be regularly reviewed and updated through tripartite meetings of experts convened by the Governing Body. Any new list is to be submitted to the Governing Body for its approval, and upon approval will replace the preceding list and is to be communicated to Members of the ILO. The list of occupational diseases was revised and replaced by a new list in March when the Governing Body, at its th Session, adopted a new list of occupational diseases. As this list is now adopted through a recommendation, the question of ‘opting-in’ or ‘opting-out’ is moot. 44 Under the ‘opting-out’ procedure, amendments are binding on Member States that do not
chapter two
Finally, the meeting was invited to address the issue of the general enforceability of the new instrument, building on the provisions of Article of Convention No. . This Article had already given a ratifying Member State the right to take action if it “receives a complaint or obtains evidence” that a foreignregistered ship visiting its ports does not conform to the Convention’s standards. The action is limited under Convention No. to addressing a report to the government of the country of registration, with a copy to the DirectorGeneral of the ILO. If the conditions on board are “clearly hazardous to safety or health”, the Member State “may” take measures to rectify them, which may result in the detention of the ship, provided that the measures are not unreasonable. The question was whether these measures should be further strengthened. In particular, is reporting to the foreign government, with a copy to the Director-General, a sufficient measure in the case of shortcomings that are not hazardous? Further, should the new instrument give Member States the right to take rectification measures in cases other than those involving hazards to safety or health, and if so in what kind of cases?45 The Response of Governments to the Eight Preferred Solutions At the first HLTWG meeting, governments pledged their support for the eight points proposed by the social partners (see above Figure ) and indicated that they were committed to participating in the Working Group throughout its work. They agreed that the proposed new instrument should be consistent with the ILO’s Decent Work Agenda and with action undertaken by the ILO and in other organizations, particularly the IMO; the instrument should be simple, clear and easy to apply; and all Member States, maritime constituents, and other stakeholders would be kept informed of the progress of the preparatory work. The governments committed their support would not only extend to time and resources for the duration of the preparatory work, but also to the adoption, ratification, and uniform and strict implementation of the future instrument, in the interest of setting up a true level playing field. They also recognized that some Members would encounter difficulties at the implementation stage of the instrument.46
object to them within a certain period, unless the number of objections received exceeds a certain proportion of the parties to the convention concerned. 45 Supra note , p. . 46 Supra note , para. .
the story of the maritime labour convention,
The Shipowners’ Group, in responding to the positive acceptance by the governments of the principles they had jointly put forward with the Seafarers’ Group, noted that it was unprecedented in the history of ILO meetings. The Seafarers’ Group, in welcoming the support for the proposals, insisted on inclusion of the notions of the ‘seafarers’ bill of rights’, speedy amendment procedures, and enforceability. They did not want to see acquired rights reduced in any way, but would not oppose updating and modernization. The first meeting of the HLTWG had thus agreed on the structure, content and fundamental approach of the new convention and stressed certain key points such as the importance of having an effective enforcement mechanism as well as the underlying principle of inflexibility with respect to rights, and flexibility with respect to methods of implementation.47 A Tripartite Subgroup is Set Up The first HLTWG meeting set up a Tripartite Subgroup (STWGMLS) that was enlarged to ensure geographical distribution and representation of all major special interests in the shipping industry. The Tripartite Subgroup was composed of members: eight government, eight shipowner, and eight seafarer members, as well as the Chairperson and Vice-Chairperson of the HLTWG and the Chairperson and Vice-Chairperson of the Subgroup and the secretaries of the Government, Seafarers’ and Shipowners’ Groups.48 Other governments could attend as observers. The mandate of the Subgroup was to consider papers prepared for its meetings and to guide the Office in the preparation of papers and draft texts for consideration by the HLTWG and to report to that Working Group. The Subgroup was provided with guidance in making these recommendations. First, the Subgroup was to give ‘proper consideration’ to the eight preferred solutions that had been agreed to on a tripartite basis (see above Figure ). In addition, it was
47
Ibid. The meeting report includes a Chairperson’s summary (p. ) that encapsulates the matters on which there was agreement at this meeting. See Chapter , pp. –, which describes in greater detail the outcomes of this meeting, and Figure therein, which sets out the summarized points in full. 48 The members of the Subgroup were: Chairperson of the HLTWG: Mr. Schindler (France); Vice-Chairperson of the HLTWG: Mr. Nishikawa (Japan); Chairperson of the Subgroup: Ms. Solling-Olsen (Denmark); Vice-Chairperson of the Subgroup: Mr. Sommer (United States); Government members: Algeria, Brazil, China, Greece, Nigeria, Panama, Philippines, Russian Federation, Secretary: Norway; Shipowner members: Mr. Akatsuka, Mr. Cox, Mr. Koltsidopoulos, Mr. Lindemann, Mr. Lusted, Ms. Midelfart, Mr. Payne, Mr. Salinas, Secretary: Mr. Dearsley; and Seafarer members: Mr. Chande, Mr. Crumlin, Mr. Filho, Mr. Iijima, Mr. Lamug, Mr. Orrell, Mr. Tselentis, Mr. Verhoef, Secretary: Mr. Whitlow.
chapter two
to consider the essential aspects of the Decent Work Agenda, namely, human rights at work, employment and incomes, social protection and social security, and social dialogue. Further, the Subgroup was to perform the following tasks: . Preparation of preliminary draft provisions relating to: (i) enforcement mechanisms; and (ii) simplified procedures for rapid amendment of the annexes to the instrument. . For the purposes of consolidation, the identification of “families” for the Parts and the selection of instruments on which work should begin; . Development of the main elements of the instrument, including: (i) identifying where existing provisions overlap or conflict and making appropriate recommendations; and (ii) recommending the allocation of provisions as between mandatory and non-binding components; . Arrangements for gathering information and ideas for these and other questions.49
The work of the Subgroup clearly enabled more rapid progress to be made by the HLTWG. As discussed in Chapter , in connection with the details of the development of the structure of the Convention, the Subgroup held two meetings, each following HLTWG meetings, in June and February . Three further meetings of the HLTWG took place in October , July , and January . This work culminated in the submission of a recommended draft for a consolidated maritime labour convention to the Preparatory Technical Maritime Conference (PTMC) in . This was followed by the Intersessional Meeting in April , before the final session of the ILC in February (see also Appendix to this book). Firmness on Rights and Flexibility on Implementation During the negotiating process for the Convention, the Seafarers’ Group wanted a ‘bill of rights’ that would secure decent living and working conditions and did not want a consolidation of instruments that would deprive them of those rights. By the fourth and final HLTWG meeting,50 the Seafarers’ Group sought an instrument that would contain meaningful minimum standards that would be implemented effectively in practice and establish a level playing field in shipping. If the new convention was to further the ILO’s Decent Work Agenda, it also needed to improve their current situation and could not merely legitimate 49
Supra note , p. . See: Final Report, HLTWG, Fourth Meeting, Nantes, – January , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/ twgmls/twgmls-r-.pdf. 50
the story of the maritime labour convention,
the status quo. In return, the Seafarers’ Group were prepared to make substantial concessions and allow a considerable amount of detail to be transferred to a non-mandatory status. However, they considered several issues to be fundamental, and on these they were not prepared to negotiate. The trade-off for their flexibility was the establishment of a uniform standard that would in practice be enforced and would make a real difference to the conditions of certain disadvantaged seafarers. The Seafarers’ Group did not want to be deprived of the rights they currently enjoyed. They considered that all governments should be prepared to make some changes to their laws. The lowest common denominator and the adoption of meaningless provisions were not acceptable to them. The Shipowners’ Group were primarily concerned about ensuring widespread ratification and achieving sufficient clarity in the text. The Government Group, for its part, supported the principle of a level playing field of universally-applicable provisions with a strong system of enforcement. They recognized that this would entail some modification of national legislation. Procedural Innovations to Deal with Unresolved Issues A PTMC was convened from – September to consider a Recommended Draft for a consolidated maritime labour convention (hereinafter ‘the Recommended Draft’). This draft text for a convention was to be submitted to the ILC for adoption in early . In order to deal with both the diversity of topics and the length of the convention, the Governing Body adopted a special two-stage procedure, intended to facilitate a thorough discussion and provide a mechanism for resolution of areas of difficulty, for the PTMC. This mechanism focused on ensuring that sufficient time was devoted to areas that either needed more discussion or had proven to be controversial in the HLTWG. These areas were indicated in the Recommended Draft by either [__] underlined square brackets or by { . . . } broken underlined soft brackets. During the second stage of the procedure, the PTMC would consider any proposals for amendment to text that was considered ‘mature’ by the HLTWG. This text was referred to as ‘unbracketed’ text. Despite their best efforts, the three Technical Committees assigned the task of reviewing the various sections of the Recommended Draft were unable to move to the second stage.51 As a result, the proposals submitted for amendments to the unbracketed text were not considered during the PTMC. 51
Record of Proceedings, Nos. (Rev.), (Rev.) and (Rev.), PTMC, Geneva, – September . Committee No. was tasked with addressing the preamble, articles, explanatory note and Title (including appendices); Committee No. , with Titles –; and Committee No. , with Title .
chapter two
The PTMC, using this procedure, despite some difficulty on a few points, was able to review nearly all of the more than pages of text of the Recommended Draft,52 and agreed upon most of the text of a Draft Maritime Labour Convention.53 This was considered an important achievement and signaled the very high level of consensus that had been developed with respect to the principles, structure, and content of the proposed instrument. Despite its best efforts, however, several parts of the text remained unresolved at the end of the meeting. The PTMC decided that all such text should be removed (‘blanked out’— essentially tabula rasa) from the Draft Convention to be proposed by it and that these provisions would be reconsidered through a procedure in which all constituents would be given an opportunity to take an active part. Recognizing that these blanked-out provisions, most of which were the most controversial issues and the still unconsidered proposals for amendments, would provide significant difficulty if left to the ILC, the PTMC also adopted resolutions regarding the preparatory work to be carried out between the PTMC and the ILC.54 In the resolution concerning the unresolved issues,55 the PTMC requested the Governing Body to instruct the Office: (a) to convene a meeting, at no direct cost to the Office, which will be open to the governments of all Member States and to representatives designated by the international organizations of shipowners and seafarers, for the purpose of providing the Office with advice concerning generally acceptable wording for the previously bracketed provisions on which agreement has not been reached; (b) to provide the participants, in advance of the meeting, with information on the substance of the provisions concerned accompanied by the necessary explanations concerning the intentions and background for each such provision; (c) to communicate, for comment, all new wording on which tripartite consensus is reached, accompanied by the necessary explanations, to the governments of all Member States as well as to the international organizations of shipowners and seafarers; and (d) to include, in the report that it is to prepare for the Maritime Session of the General Conference in accordance with Article , paragraph (b), of the Standing Orders of the Conference, an account of all new wording referred to, together with a summary of the constituents’ views communicated to it.56
52
Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention, Recommended Draft, PTMC, Geneva, – September , ILO Doc. No. PTMC//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/ standards/relm/maritime/pdf/cmlc-draft.pdf. 53 Record of Proceedings, No. , PTMC, Geneva, – September , p. /. The Convention text that was adopted is found in Record of Proceedings, No. (Rev.). 54 Ibid., pp. /–/. 55 Ibid., p. /. 56 Ibid., p. /. The requests of the PTMC were approved by the Governing Body of the ILO at its st Session in November .
the story of the maritime labour convention,
Two papers prepared by the Office provided the background information and explanations requested under paragraph (b) of the resolution.57 They also sought to provide a basis for the discussions at the Intersessional Meeting in April on unresolved issues and the proposals for amendments, taking account of the background, including, in particular, previous discussions. The Office suggested possible text in the case of provisions that were not believed to be controversial and were left blank as a result of lack of time for discussion. Otherwise, they simply suggested approaches that might be considered with a view to achieving consensus on a text. The April Tripartite Intersessional Meeting was attended by Government representatives from countries, Shipowners’ representatives, and Seafarers’ representatives, as well as experts from international organizations, including the Secretariat of the Paris Memorandum of Understanding on Port State Control. The Intersessional Meeting, which operated in plenary throughout, considered the two documents prepared by the Office in response to the PTMC resolutions and, in accordance with the resolutions referred to above, identified those which had obtained tripartite consensus.58 It was also able to provide advice on generally acceptable wording for all the provisions on which the PTMC had been unable to reach agreement, apart from a few provisions (such as those relating to the requirements for entry into force), which it considered could best be left for the ILC. The Process: The Importance of an Intensive and Extensive Consultation Process Clearly the negotiating process for the MLC, involved intensive and extensive consultations at both the formal and informal level. The formal negotiations process spanned five years: – Four week-long HLTWG meetings between December and January 59 – Two week-long meetings of the Tripartite Subgroup between June and February 57
Unresolved Issues for the Draft Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention, , and Compendium of Proposed Amendments to the Draft Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention, , Tripartite Intersessional Meeting on the Follow-up of the PTMC, Geneva, , ILO Doc. Nos. PTMC// and PTMC//, respectively. For further discussion of these issues, see Chapter and the substantive chapters in Part II. 58 Report of the Discussion, Tripartite Intersessional Meeting on the Follow-up of the PTMC, Geneva, – April , ILO Doc. No. PTMC//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/ english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/ptmc/ptmc-.pdf. The final report of the Intersessional Meeting was circulated to all ILO Members. 59 These meetings generated considerable interest from Members, with the fourth meeting in
chapter two – Three officers meeting to consider feed back between various meetings – An ad hoc tripartite expert meeting of social security experts – Various meetings between shipowners and seafarers to discuss specific issues including, importantly, the text of Title – The PTMC in September , which generated considerable interest from Members – Written consultations – The Tripartite Intersessional Meeting on the Follow-up to the PTMC, – April – A Drafting group meeting before and after the Intersessional Meeting – The final Conference, the th (Maritime) Session of the ILC, – February , which adopted the Convention
In addition, the formal consultation process was complemented by specific opportunities for governments and the shipowner and seafarer representatives to make written submissions on the various drafts, which were considered by the Office, under the guidance of the officers of the HLTWG. There were several officers’ meetings to resolve particular issues in the text and to develop special procedures within the ILO framework to facilitate the consideration of texts. For instance, consultations were continued and led by the Office on Article III and Article IV, paragraph , between the end of the fourth HLTWG meeting in Nantes in February and the PTMC in September . Following these consultations, a proposal was made to the officers of the HLTWG for inclusion of an appropriate formulation in brackets in the text being submitted to the PTMC. During the PTMC, this provision helped the Chairperson of the Steering Committee and the President of the Conference to resolve the issues relating to the formulation of Article III concerning fundamental principles and rights at work. Another example relates to the compromise on the status of Part B of the Code of the MLC, . A high-level ‘Friends of the President’ group was set up during the fourth HLTWG meeting in Nantes, which resulted in a solution.60 The present wording of paragraph of Article VI of the MLC, was retained on the basis of the following understandings:
January involving participants, including government delegations. See: first meeting: Final Report, supra note ; second meeting: Final Report, HTLWG, Geneva, – October , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/ dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-r.pdf; third meeting: Final Report, HTLWG, Geneva, June– July , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/ english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-r-.pdf; and fourth meeting: Final Report, supra note . 60 See Chapter , Figure , which sets out the Legal Adviser’s opinion. See also Chapter , pp. .
the story of the maritime labour convention, Question: Answer: Question: Answer: Question: Answer: Question: Answer:
Is Part B mandatory? No. Can Part B be ignored by ratifying Members? No. Is the implementation of Part B verified by port state inspectors? No. Does the ratifying Member have to follow the guidance in Part B? No, but if it does not follow the guidance it may—vis-à-vis the competent bodies of the International Labour Organization—need to justify the way in which it has implemented the corresponding mandatory provisions of the consolidated Convention.61
These understandings are reflected in the Convention as well as in paragraph of the Explanatory Note of the MLC, . The use of innovative processes to help resolve difficult issues helped achieve consensus on all of the Convention’s provisions. These processes included the setting up of steering committees, as was done during the PTMC and the th ILC Session, and establishing the ‘Friends of the President’, as was done during the fourth HLTWG, the PTMC, and during the th ILC Session. These mechanisms helped broker agreement on the status of Part B, the inclusion of the reference to the Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work in the Preamble to the Convention, and the fundamental principles and rights in Article III of the MLC, and the solution in Article II regarding the scope of the Convention. The Recommended Draft Convention reflects the conclusions that were reached throughout this consultation process, taking into account the mandate of consolidation of existing conventions and the overall objectives to be achieved in developing a new maritime labour instrument. The HLTWG was chaired throughout the entire period by Mr. Jean-Marc Schindler, Government member of France, and the Chairpersons and Spokespersons of the Shipowners’ Group, Mr. Dierk Lindemann, and the Seafarers’ Group, Mr. Brian Orrell. They served for the entire period up to and including the PTMC, the Tripartite Intersessional Meeting, and the final th ILC Session in . They formed a team who knew each other well and could count on the trust built over the years and their expertise to find win-win solutions when difficult issues were to be resolved. In addition, the contributions of the large cast of personalities involved in the negotiations must also be acknowledged. Individuals with enigmatic personalities made fiery speeches and passionate pleas and, on so many occasions with a great sense of commitment and vision and, importantly, humour, contributed to the success of these negotiations.
61
Supra note , para. .
chapter two Conclusion
The story of the MLC, is about process as much as it is about content. It reflects a bond built between people over a period of five years. It required remaining true to the principles established in in all respects: substantive content, structure, and approach. It was about a long-discussed and carefully balanced application of the maxim of flexibility with respect to implementation and inflexibility with respect to rights, thus helping to find solutions to what would otherwise have been insoluble problems. Throughout the five years of its story being written, shipowners and seafarers worked with governments to reconcile their differences. The result is one that demonstrates and bears witness to tripartism62 at its best. Throughout this period, the tripartite actors forged a consensus around some of the most controversial issues: a broad definition of seafarers; a broad scope of application to all ships with a limited number of exceptions; a no more favorable treatment clause to put in place a level playing field; giving teeth to an ILO convention directly by providing, for the first time, for certification of compliance with labour standards with its legal basis in an ILO convention; and a facilitated amendment procedure to keep the instrument up to date. The MLC, reflects a unique legal regulatory framework for labour standards on the global scale for the most globalized of economic sectors—a truly global response to a global problem. It is a ‘bill of rights for seafarers’ and provides a level playing field for shipowners, as well as assisting States to comply with their international obligations. The MLC, has become a one-stop shop for seafarers, shipowners, and governments, combining firmness on rights and flexibility in implementation. It is truly an international regulatory response of an appropriate kind and a beacon for the future. In the words of the ILO Declaration on Social Justice for a Fair Globalization, its objective is to make globalization fair and thus work for the people most concerned: the world’s . million seafarers.
62
This term is used to describe the values and approach adopted by the ILO (see Chapter , note ). The term ‘social dialogue’ also has a particular meaning (see Chapter , note ).
chapter three THE MARITIME LABOUR CONVENTION, 2006 AS AN INSTRUMENT OF THE INTERNATIONAL LABOUR ORGANIZATION1
Introduction The Maritime Labour Convention, is an instrument of the ILO. Significantly, it is an international labour convention and it will be examined here from that point of view.2 This chapter has as its principal purpose an examination of the links between the MLC, and traditional ILO concepts and approaches to conventions. As a basis for this discussion, it may be useful first to see the Convention in its historical context. As a first step, the ILO’s standard-setting history is summarized. This review is necessarily selective as its focus is on developments which appear particularly relevant to the underlying approaches in the MLC, that were agreed to in the five years following . This analysis thus focuses on approaches relating to international labour standards, rather than on the substantive content of the previous conventions and recommendations that were consolidated in the MLC, , since, to the extent that these instruments were considered sufficiently up to date, their substance is to be found in the MLC, itself.3
1
The author, Dominick Devlin is a former Legal Adviser to the International Labour Organization. He is currently Chair of the World Intellectual Property Organization Appeal Board and has been a Special Advisor to the ILO in connection with the MLC, since . The views in this chapter are his own and do not necessarily reflect those of the International Labour Organization. The author is indebted to his predecessor, Francis Maupain, ILO Legal Adviser from to , for his advice in the preparation of this chapter. 2 In Jenks commented, “International labour conventions are in some ways of a more complex character than any other instruments known to international law, . . .”. W.C. Jenks, “Are international labour conventions agreements between governments,” () XV The Canadian Bar Review – at . 3 See Chapters – for a review of substantive provisions of the MLC, . See Appendix for the sources of many of the individual provisions.
chapter three The International Labour Organization
As the introductory overview in Chapter explained, the ILO was founded in , after the First World War, by the Treaty of Versailles as a part of the League of Nations.4 It was created in the realization that “universal . . . peace can be established only if it is based upon social justice”.5 It has always been a tripartite organization in which decision making is carried out by the representatives of governments, workers, and employers having equal status.6 The Organization managed to survive the demise of the League of Nations at the end of the Second World War. In , its supreme organ, the ILC, renewed the aims and purposes of the Organization in the eloquent and still very relevant Declaration of Philadelphia.7 The Declaration reaffirms the fundamental principles on which the Organization is based and, in particular, that: (a) (b) (c) (d)
labour is not a commodity; freedom of expression and of association are essential to sustained progress; poverty anywhere constitutes a danger to prosperity everywhere; the war against want requires to be carried on with unrelenting vigour within each nation, and by continuous and concerted international effort in which the representatives of workers and employers, enjoying equal status with those of governments, join with them in free discussion and democratic decision with a view to the promotion of the common welfare.8
The Organization summarizes its main aims as follows: to promote rights at work, to encourage decent employment opportunities, to enhance social protection, and to strengthen dialogue in handling work-related issues.9 The ILC meets once a year except when, as discussed in more detail in Chapter , it also holds a session to adopt maritime labour conventions and recommendations. The day-to-day work is performed by the International Labour Office (the Office), under the guidance of the ILO Governing Body, which normally meets three times a year.
4
In , the ILO was the first of the intergovernmental organizations to be brought into relationship, as a specialized agency, with the United Nations in accordance with Articles and of the UN Charter. 5 First preambular paragraph of Part XIII of the Treaty of Versailles, L.N.T.S. ( June ). 6 For more information see Chapter text at note . 7 The Declaration concerning the aims and purposes of the International Labour Organisation, adopted by the th Session of the ILC, now constitutes an annex to the Constitution of the International Labour Organisation, available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/iloconst.htm. 8 Ibid., section I. 9 See Chapter at note .
the mlc, as an instrument of the ilo
The Historical Context of the MLC, There is no doubt that the MLC, is an international labour convention: it was adopted as such, by the authority competent to adopt international labour conventions—the ILC—and its adoption basically followed the procedures established for that purpose.10 Chapter recounted the origins of the MLC, and its conception in the years and . It will be recalled that it was heralded by the “Geneva Accord” reached in the framework of the ILO’s Joint Maritime Commission (JMC) in , and was adopted in with the basic features that had been agreed upon five years before. These features were, in particular, the consolidation of the previous maritime labour conventions that were sufficiently up to date; a novel structure setting out basic principles, complemented by detailed requirements; the inclusion of recommendations and other non-mandatory texts in the Convention itself; a simplified amendment procedure enabling the Convention to keep pace with a rapidly developing industry; an orientation towards the widest possible acceptability by governments, shipowners, and seafarers; and a strong enforcement component. However, in appearance,11 the MLC, contains important differences from the previous international labour conventions adopted between and . The term ‘standards’ is understood by the ILO to refer to both international labour conventions and international labour recommendations. The constitutional basis for the ILO’s standard-setting action was established by Article of Part XIII of the Treaty of Versailles, from which the present Article of the ILO Constitution has developed.12 This provision gives the ILC the function of adopting (by a two-thirds majority) proposed conventions and recommendations, placed on its agenda by the ILO Governing Body.13 Decisions are taken
10 As is the case with other maritime labour conventions, the question of the future convention was governed by the ILC’s single discussion procedure following a preparatory technical conference (see Articles and of the Standing Orders of the Conference). The Preparatory Technical Maritime Conference (PTMC) was held from to September , and was followed by the Intersessional Meeting on the consolidated Maritime Labour Convention ( to April ) to resolve major outstanding differences between ILO constituents. See Chapter for the story of the MLC, . 11 See Chapter for a more detailed consideration of the format and organizational structure of the MLC, . 12 In order to give an idea of the continuity in the ILO’s action relating to international labour standards, this chapter makes reference to the original text of the ILO Constitution in Part XIII of the Treaty of Versailles where relevant. References below to the ‘Treaty of Versailles’ relate to that original text; references to the ‘ILO Constitution’ relate to the present text, which was applicable at the time of the preparation and adoption of the MLC, . 13 Treaty of Versailles, supra note , Art. ; ILO Constitution, supra note , Article , para. .
chapter three
by the Conference and the Governing Body in their tripartite compositions, representing governments, employers, and workers.14 The difference between conventions and recommendations is often explained by stating that the former are mandatory and the latter are not, but this is a simplification, as pointed out below. Under the ILO Constitution,15 the purpose of a recommendation is “to meet circumstances where the subject, or aspect of it, dealt with is not considered suitable or appropriate at that time for a Convention”. In practice, recommendations are often adopted at the same time as conventions, which they supplement, and sometimes as stand-alone instruments. The ILC immediately (at its first session in ) began to adopt international labour conventions and recommendations.16 International labour conventions and recommendations cover a whole range of subjects in the world of work and other social issues. The maritime sector is only one of the many areas covered, but its importance was recognized from the beginning. In the discussions at the Versailles Peace Conference, the Commission on International Labour Legislation had adopted a resolution stating that “the very special questions concerning the minimum conditions to be accorded to seamen might be dealt with at a special meeting of the International Labour Conference devoted exclusively to the affairs of seamen”. The Second Session of the Conference in was convened as a special Seamen’s Conference. It adopted three conventions, the Minimum Age (Sea) Convention, ; the Unemployment Indemnity (Shipwreck) Convention, ; and the Placing of Seamen Convention, , and 14 The Conference is composed of one tripartite delegation from each Member of the ILO, each delegation having two government representatives, one employer representative, and one worker representative; whereas these tripartite delegations meet as such in the plenary, much of the Conference’s work is prepared in committees or other subsidiary bodies in which the delegates or their advisers break up into their three respective groups, that is, governments, employers and workers (for work in committees, governments normally have one vote instead of the two that they have in the plenary). The Governing Body consists of members elected by the delegates in their respective groups at the Conference (apart from a certain number of government members who are designated by Member States of ‘chief industrial importance’). See Treaty of Versailles, supra note , Art. , first paragraph, and ILO Constitution, supra note , Art. , para. , for the tripartite composition of the delegations at the Conference, and Treaty of Versailles, Art. , and ILO Constitution, Art. , paras and , for the original and present tripartite composition (respectively) of the Governing Body. Each delegate at the Conference is entitled to vote individually (Treaty of Versailles, Art. , first paragraph; ILO Constitution, Art. , para. ). 15 Supra note , Art. , para. ; there was no equivalent in the Treaty of Versailles. 16 The first convention, the Hours of Work (Industry) Convention, (No. ), Washington, November , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm, included the area of transport by sea and inland waterways. However, it stated that the provisions would be determined by a special conference dealing with employment at sea and on inland waterways.
the mlc, as an instrument of the ilo
two maritime labour recommendations, including the National Seamen’s Codes Recommendation, .17 It also adopted a resolution concerning the JMC,18 which had been established in March to assist the technical maritime service of the Office on questions of maritime labour. In this resolution, the Conference stated that “All questions on maritime affairs put forward for consideration by conferences should be previously considered by the Joint Maritime Commission of the International Labour Office”. As discussed in Chapter , from onwards, maritime sessions of the ILC have been convened at approximately ten-year intervals, with the tenth occurring in . In view of the emphasis given in the MLC, to enforcement and evidencing compliance (discussed below and in Chapter ), it is interesting to note that although this is a contemporary focus of action at the shipboard level, it has been a long-standing concern of the Organization. Indeed, in Article of the very first convention that it adopted, the Hours of Work (Industry) Convention, , there is a requirement on employers to post notices and to keep records on hours of work “in order to facilitate the enforcement of the provisions of this Convention”, as well as an obligation on ratifying Members to make violations a criminal offence. This concern for enforcement at the national level of the provisions of ratified conventions was matched by a parallel concern which, at a very early date, led to the development of the ILO’s supervisory functions at the international level.19 The basis or origin of these functions is seen in Article of the Treaty of Versailles, under which Members agree to make an annual report to the Office on the measures they have taken to give effect to the provisions of conventions to which they are a party20 and the Director (now the DirectorGeneral) is to lay a summary of these reports before the next meeting of the Conference.21 The implementation of these provisions was developed at the Conference’s eighth session,22 which adopted the Resolution concerning the methods by which the Conference can make use of the reports submitted under Article of the Treaty of Versailles. In accordance with the resolution,23 a 17
See Chapter , p. . For more information see Chapter . 19 For a detailed discussion of the ILO’s supervisory system, see Chapter . 20 This provision is now in Article of the ILO Constitution. 21 This provision, as later developed, is found in Article of the ILO Constitution. 22 It may also be noted that, at its ninth session immediately following the eighth session, the Conference adopted two important maritime labour conventions: Seamen’s Articles of Agreement Convention, (No. ), Geneva, June , and Repatriation of Seamen Convention, (No. ), Geneva, June , both available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/ convdisp.htm. 23 International Labour Conference, Eighth Session (), Vol. I, Appendix VII, p. . See: Improvements in the standards-related activities of the ILO: Initial implementation of the interim 18
chapter three
standing tripartite ‘Conference Committee’ was established to consider the reports submitted under Article of the Constitution; and a ‘Committee of Experts’, consisting of eminent experts acting in their individual capacity, was established by the Governing Body to draw up a report submitted to the Governing Body for transmission to the Conference. These two committees, which have developed respectively into the Committee on the Application of Standards and the Committee of Experts on the Application of Conventions and Recommendations, are often referred to as the ILO’s regular supervisory mechanism.24 There are, in addition, ad hoc procedures for taking action alleging violations of ratified conventions.25 This mechanism for the supervision of compliance by ILO Members with the international labour conventions that they have ratified can fairly be said to be the most effective that exists today with respect to human rights conventions that are universal in scope (as opposed, in particular, to multilateral conventions that are regional in scope). In , a question arose as to how international labour conventions could be amended, given that this possibility was not provided for in the ILO Constitution or in the conventions that had been adopted up to that time. The Conference clearly had the power to adopt a revised version of a previous convention, but the situation with respect to ILO Member States that had ratified the previous text was less clear. Could the ratification of the new revising convention have the effect of varying or even removing obligations that they had previously assumed under the revised convention? Or must they first denounce the previous convention? However, from onwards the standard final clause of international labour conventions provided for a waiting period before they could be denounced, which might be as long as five years ( version of the clause) or ten years (from onwards).26 Moreover, if circumstances had changed
plan of action to enhance the impact of the standards system, Governing Body, Committee on Legal Issues and International Labour Standards, st Session, Geneva, March , ILO Doc. No. GB./LILS/(Rev.). 24 The change in the names of these committees to some extent reflects the expansion of their terms of reference in and takes account of the requirement on Members to promptly bring adopted conventions and recommendations to the attention of their competent authorities for the enactment of legislation or other action (Treaty of Versailles, supra note , Art. , para. ; ILO Constitution, supra note , Art. , paras (b) and (b)), as well as to report, when requested by the Governing Body on the position of their law and practice with respect to conventions that they have not ratified and to recommendations (ILO Constitution (amendment of ), Art. , paras (e) and (d)). See Chapter for a detailed explanation of the ILO’s supervisory system. 25 A procedure for making ‘representations’ (Treaty of Versailles, supra note , Art. ; ILO Constitution, supra note , Art. ); and complaints, which can lead to the establishment of a Commission of Enquiry (Treaty of Versailles, Art. ; ILO Constitution, Art. ). 26 The problem was unlikely to arise in the case of pre- conventions as they could be
the mlc, as an instrument of the ilo
since the adoption of the previous text, and the Conference considered that its provisions were no longer conducive to achieving social progress, could the ILC decide that the old text should no longer be open to ratification when the new revised convention entered into force? These questions called for a discussion of the nature of international labour conventions. It has always been agreed that international labour conventions have a number of specificities27—relating in particular to the way that they are drawn up and adopted, their constitutional basis and their tripartite origin— which distinguish them from ‘normal’ multilateral treaties drawn up at diplomatic conferences. According to one view at the time, international labour conventions were legislative instruments, adopted by the ILC, and requiring ratification only as a ‘conditional act’ to acquire the force of national law.28 If international labour conventions were seen as legislative instruments, rather than contracts between States, it could be concluded that the ILC, which had proposed the convention to ILO Members in the first place, could at least give them the option—through ratification of the new convention—of replacing their obligations under the previous revised convention by their obligations under the new one. However, the view that prevailed in the ILC (at its twelfth session) reflected a balanced opinion that had been given by the ILO Legal Adviser, Mr. J. Morellet: While it seems legitimate to consider the international conventions as conventions of a particular legal nature having a quasi-legislative element, there can, it seems, be no doubt that they are conventions in that—through the ratifications that they receive—they become real contracts between States.29
Seen as contracts between the ILO Members that had ratified them, the conventions could not be unilaterally modified by the Organization or by individual ratifying Members. As a consequence, a provision has been included in the final clauses of all international labour conventions adopted since , with one exception, providing that if the convention concerned is revised and unless the revising convention provides otherwise, ratification of the new convention
denounced at any time once five or (more frequently) ten years had elapsed from their initial entry into force. 27 See Jenks, supra note . 28 Referred to in Nicolas Valticos, Droit international du travail, nd edition (Paris: Dalloz, ), p. . 29 Quoted (in the original French) by Francis Maupain in “Une révolution tranquille dans le droit des traités: l’abrogation des Conventions internationales du travail obsolètes”, Chronique des institutions spécialisées, Annuaire français de droit international, XLII (Paris: CNRS Editions, ). This article related to the then future amendment of the ILO Constitution in so as to permit the abrogation of international labour conventions by the ILC following the same procedure as that required for their adoption.
chapter three
will be treated as ipso jure denunciation of the old convention when the ratification takes effect, and any new ratification of the old convention will no longer be possible after the new convention has come into force. The exception just referred to is the MLC, ; however, as will be explained below,30 the exception essentially relates to form since the Convention’s provision on its ‘amendment’ rather than its ‘revision’ still follows the basic concepts agreed to in . The second Maritime Session of the ILC, in , adopted several conventions and recommendations, including the Officers’ Competency Certificates Convention, (No. ); the Shipowners’ Liability (Sick and Injured Seamen) Convention, (No. ); the Hours of Work and Manning (Sea) Convention, (No. ); and the Seamen’s Welfare in Ports Recommendation, (R). The Hours of Work and Manning (Sea) Convention, is of interest in that it is the first convention to depart from what was until then a specificity of international labour conventions, namely the requirement for the deposit of only two ratifications for entry into force of a convention.31 Ten years later it became more usual for maritime labour conventions to contain a higher entry into force requirement covering both numbers of ratifications and shipping tonnage. But some maritime conventions still provided for an entry into force requirement of two ratifications, as has remained the general practice for international labour conventions on non-maritime subjects. At the following Maritime Session of the ILC in , the conventions adopted included several relating to seafarers’ accommodation and food and catering as well as the Certification of Able Seamen Convention, (No. ). The next Maritime Session in adopted the Seafarers’ Identity Documents Convention, (No. ). It is of interest from a conceptual point of view since it contains a new element, which is also present in the MLC, , although Convention No. was not one of the instruments consolidated by the MLC, . This new element could be described as interaction creating interdependent rights and obligations between the ratifying States themselves. Up to then, although in law it had been agreed that international labour conventions, when ratified, became “real contracts between States”,32 they appear in practice to have been implemented more as compacts between the ratifying Member State and the Organization. Under these compacts, the ILO provides a means—through the adoption of conventions and its supervisory mechanism—for each Member to demonstrate its commitment to social 30
See infra, pp. –. See also Chapter in this volume, at pp. –. Article , paragraph , required five ratifications by Members with a mercantile marine tonnage of not less than one million tons. 32 See the Legal Adviser’s opinion as quoted supra note . 31
the mlc, as an instrument of the ilo
justice by ratifying and properly implementing the conventions. If a Member fails to act in accordance with this compact, this will not have any effect on the rights and obligations of other ratifying Members in their implementation of the convention concerned. These Members have a general interest in ensuring proper implementation by all ratifying Members, as well as the right under Article of the ILO Constitution to lodge a complaint to the Organization alleging that another ratifying Member is not observing its obligations under the convention (although complaints under Article are rarely initiated by ratifying Members). Under Convention No. , on the other hand, the obligations of each ratifying Member depend, in one important respect, on the acts of other ratifying Members, and the failure by one ratifying Member to comply with the Convention can directly affect other ratifying Members. Specifically, each Member ratifying this convention has the obligation or the right to issue seafarers’ identity documents (SIDs) to seafarers who are its nationals or have some other link with it as specified by the Convention;33 the ratifying Member also has the corresponding obligation—in certain circumstances and subject to certain exceptions—to facilitate the entry on its territory for specified purposes of seafarers holding a SID issued by other ratifying Members. The existence of the latter obligation thus depends upon whether the issuing Member has ratified the Convention and whether the SID was issued in accordance with the requirements of the Convention. The failure to meet that obligation raises questions of accountability not only as far as the Organization and its supervisory mechanism are concerned, but also with respect to other ratifying Members in their capacity of contractual partners.34 In the First United Nations Conference on the Law of the Sea adopted, inter alia, the Convention on the High Seas affirming the duty of the flag State to effectively exercise its jurisdiction and control in administrative, technical and
33 That is, serving on ship registered in the Member State or a seafarer registered at an employment office in the Member’s territory (Art. , para. ). 34 It is true that, in several conventions, interaction with other ratifying Members is provided for by a requirement to cooperate with each other in the implementation of the convention (e.g., inter alia, the Social Policy (Basic Aims and Standards) Convention, , (No. ), Geneva, June , Art. ; Migrant Workers (Supplementary Provisions) Convention, (No. ), Geneva, June , Art. and others; Seafarers’ Welfare Convention, (No. ), Geneva, October , Art. ; Health Protection and Medical Care (Seafarers) Convention, (No. ), Geneva, October , Art. ; Social Security (Seafarers) Convention (Revised), (No. ), Geneva, October , Art. ; and Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention, , (No. ), Geneva, June , Art. ; all available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/conv disp.htm). However, these obligations do not appear to create rights or obligations of a kind that one Member would seek to enforce against another.
chapter three
social matters over ships flying its flag (Article , paragraph ).35 Referring to that provision, the ILO’s Social Conditions and Safety (Seafarers) Recommendation, (R) urged ILO Members to accept the full obligations implied by registration and to exercise effective jurisdiction and control for the purpose of the safety and welfare of seafarers in their sea-going merchant ships through the adoption of regulations and a proper ship-inspection service. In addition, the Seafarers’ Engagement (Foreign Vessels) Recommendation, (R) recommended that each ILO Member should do everything in its power to discourage seafarers within its territory from joining or agreeing to join vessels registered in a foreign country unless the conditions under which such seafarers were to be engaged were generally equivalent to those applicable under collective agreements and accepted social standards. These two recommendations were later to be taken up in the Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, (No. ), referred to below. The four Maritime Sessions preceding that for the MLC, , were held in , , , and . While very important conventions were adopted at these sessions (particularly those of and ) as far as substantive content is concerned, it was the session that adopted the convention that can be described as the stepping-stone to the MLC, , namely Convention No. . There are at least six aspects of this convention that are particularly relevant to approaches adopted for the MLC, . First, Convention No. brings within the ILO’s supervisory procedures the duty of flag States to effectively exercise their jurisdiction and control over ships flying their flag.36 Second, the Convention adopts a holistic approach in that this jurisdiction is to be exercised in three broad areas, safety, social security, and working and living conditions, covered by the conventions or provisions listed in its Appendix.37 Third, the means of exercising this jurisdiction and control is not necessarily through laws and regulations, but may, in the case of working and living conditions, be through collective agreements or court decisions. Fourth, to the extent that a ratifying Member has not ratified the conventions listed in the Appendix, its obligation is limited to satisfying itself that its law and regulations are substantially equivalent. Fifth, the flag State must verify, by inspection or other 35
Convention on the High Seas, April , U.N.T.S. , available at http://untreaty .un.org/ilc/texts/instruments/english/conventions/___high_seas.pdf. This duty is now found in Article , paragraph , of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, December , U.N.T.S. (LOSC): available at http://www.un.org/depts/los/convention_agreements/texts/unclos/closindx.htm. See also the discussion of both Chapter at pp. – and Chapter at pp. –. 36 LOSC, ibid., Art. , para. . 37 This list is expanded in the Protocol of to the Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, (P), Geneva, October , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/ english/convdisp.htm.
the mlc, as an instrument of the ilo
appropriate means, compliance with the requirements of the listed conventions. In this connection, it will be noted that years earlier the ILC had adopted the Labour Inspection Convention, (No. )38 and was to adopt years later the Labour Inspection (Seafarers) Convention, (No. ). A sixth aspect of Convention No. is of particular relevance to the MLC, . This is related to the role of the ratifying Members with respect to conditions of work that are primarily covered by the jurisdiction of another State in contexts in which there was a jurisdictional link with the ratifying Member. There are two contexts: nationality, in the case of a requirement to discourage national seafarers from working on foreign substandard ships (Article ); and the temporary presence within the ratifying Member’s territorial jurisdiction, in the case of the inspection of foreign ships for conformity with the standards referred to in the Convention (Article ). Convention No. seems to be the first international labour convention envisaging action with a global effect, rather than essentially applying at the national level. It provides for a ratifying Member to take unilateral action to eliminate obstacles to social progress which fall within the concurrent but primary jurisdiction of foreign countries. This last-mentioned step taken by Convention No. , relating to an industry that has always been globalized, is obviously less easy to achieve in the case of non-maritime labour conventions, or is no doubt impossible in many cases due to lack of jurisdiction on the part of ratifying countries. But with increasing globalization in non-maritime areas, other conventions could follow the same direction. For example, paragraph (d) of the Worst Forms of Child Labour Recommendation, (R) provides that measures aimed at the prohibition and elimination of the worst forms of child labour might include the prosecution in the ratifying country of a Member’s nationals who commit offences under its national provisions even when these offences are committed in another country. Convention No. was, however, cautiously drafted as far as this unilateral action is concerned. The Convention provides for the inspection of foreign ships as a right rather than an obligation (using the auxiliary ‘may’, as opposed to ‘shall’) and limits the “measures necessary to rectify conditions on board”, which may be taken with respect to the foreign ship, to conditions “which are clearly hazardous to safety or health”.39
38
The system of labour inspection under this convention applied to all industrial workplaces in respect of which legal provisions relating to conditions of work and the protection of workers while engaged in their work were enforceable by labour inspectors; transport undertakings could be exempted from the application of the Convention (Art. ). 39 Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, (No. ), Geneva, October , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm, Art. .
chapter three
Convention No. , by implication, recognizes the right40 of ratifying countries to inspect foreign ships for the purpose of verifying that the ships conform to the standards referred to in the Convention even where a country whose flag is flown by those ships has not ratified the Convention and is, therefore, under no obligation to ensure that its ships meet those standards. The freedom of each ILO Member to decide which international labour conventions it will ratify is an important principle that was knowingly accepted by the drafters of the ILO Constitution in .41 This potential lack of balance between the obligations of ILO Members has been the subject of criticism and discussion, especially since the dismantlement of the former Soviet Union and the discussions on globalization, particularly in relation to the World Trade Organization. In the early s, there was a burning debate in the ILO on what was called the ‘social clause’ which would link trade advantages to the observance of key labour standards. In , it was decided not to pursue the idea of such a link. In March , the World Summit for Social Development in Copenhagen identified as ‘core labour standards’ the principles set forth in the ILO’s seven ‘fundamental conventions’ that were later listed in the second preambular paragraph of the MLC, (with the addition of the eighth fundamental convention (No. ) adopted in ). In , the report of the Director-General that is submitted for discussion in plenary by the annual session of the ILC was entitled The ILO, Standard Setting and Globalization.42 It discussed, in detail, many concerns relating to ILO standard setting, which corresponded to those that later prompted the Geneva Accord, and also suggested solutions. One of the questions addressed in the report was whether to accumulate standards over several instruments or to consolidate them. Taking as an example the tendency to amass detailed regulations in the area of occupational health and safety, the report suggested an approach that might avoid “being caught up in a constant struggle to try and identify new hazards as they emerge and yet being often unable to do more than have provisions of a very general nature”.43 It continued—somewhat prophetically as far as the future MLC, is concerned—by noting that “Another more traditional approach would be to incorporate these more detailed regulations in an annex 40 See the discussion of port State control in Chapter at note and Chapter in connection with Regulation . of the MLC, . 41 See Francis Maupain, “La protection internationale des travailleurs et la libéralisation du commerce mondial: un lien ou un frein?”, (Janvier–Février ) Revue Générale de Droit International Public –. 42 The ILO, Standard Setting and Globalization, Report of the Director-General, ILC, th Session, Geneva, , available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/dgrep.htm. 43 Ibid., at Section II(A), “A More Targeted Choice of Subjects,” subsection (c).
the mlc, as an instrument of the ilo
to the instrument which could be revised and updated in accordance with a different and more simplified procedure than that applying to the Convention itself ”.44 In , the ILC adopted the ILO Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work,45 recalled in the fourth preambular paragraph of the MLC, . As a declaration, this text does not have binding force. However, it necessarily carries great weight in that it formally notes the understanding of the supreme organ of the ILO that the principles and rights expressed and developed in the eight fundamental conventions are already set out in the Constitution and in the Declaration of Philadelphia referred to earlier, which is annexed to the ILO Constitution. The Declaration then goes on to declare that, as a consequence (emphasis added), . . . all Members, even if they have not ratified the Conventions in question, have an obligation arising from the very fact of membership in the Organization, to respect, to promote and to realize, in good faith and in accordance with the Constitution, the principles concerning the fundamental rights which are the subject of those Conventions . . ..46
This conclusion that ILO Members are bound, by virtue of their membership in the Organization, by principles concerning certain fundamental rights (but not by the text of the related conventions if they had not ratified them) had in fact already been made in with respect to the right to freedom of association, when the ILO set up a Committee on Freedom of Association for the purpose of examining complaints about violations of that right, whether or not the country concerned had ratified the relevant conventions. However, the Declaration was adopted on the clear understanding that its objective was to be “of a strictly promotional nature”47 and it has accordingly been treated as a promotional instrument.48 44
Ibid. Adopted by the ILC, th Session, Geneva, June (Annex revised June ), available at http://www.ilo.org/declaration/thedeclaration/textdeclaration/lang-en/index.htm. 46 These fundamental rights are (a) freedom of association and the effective recognition of the right to collective bargaining; (b) the elimination of all forms of forced or compulsory labour; (c) the effective abolition of child labour; and (d) the elimination of discrimination in respect of employment and occupation. 47 See supra, note , Section I, “Overall Purpose,” para. in the “Follow-up to the Declaration” that is annexed to it. 48 Discussions on the social dimension of globalization continued. In , the ILO set up a World Commission on the Social Dimension of Globalization, which submitted its report in , entitled A Fair Globalization: Creating Opportunities for All. In , the ILC adopted the comprehensive ILO Declaration on Social Justice for a Fair Globalization. This related to the implementation of the Organization’s four strategic objectives for decent work, described as “inseparable, interrelated and mutually supportive”, comprising (i) promoting employment by creating a sustainable institutional and economic environment; (ii) developing and enhancing 45
chapter three
The action that was most relevant to the future MLC, , and which was continuing up to and beyond the Geneva Accord, related to keeping the corpus of international labour standards up to date. In June , an amendment to the ILO Constitution was adopted that empowers the ILC to terminate the legal effects for the Organization of international labour conventions which it judges obsolete or without purpose in respect of the objectives of the Organization.49 In accordance with Article of the Constitution, this amendment was submitted to ILO Members for ratification or acceptance and is not yet in force. The other action was the establishment by the Governing Body in of a Working Party on Policy regarding the Revision of Standards, which became known as the ‘Cartier Working Party’. The Working Party reviewed the current international labour conventions and recommendations from the point of view of such factors as the level of and prospects for ratification, any denunciations of conventions, the situation as regards the supervisory procedures as well as the need for substantive revision,50 and made recommendations with respect to the instruments concerned.51 The Special Features of the MLC, With the notable exception of the Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, (No. ), it would be difficult to see any of the developments outlined above as leading up to the MLC, . As explained elsewhere in this book,52 the MLC, has benefited from a cross-fertilization of approaches and format and concepts, many of them inspired by conventions adopted under the auspices of the International Maritime Organization (IMO). The drafters of the MLC, used some of the outcomes of previous developments to build the new convention, in particular the conclusions of the Cartier Working Party. However, the MLC, was mainly driven by need—the need to respond to the demanding specifications53 in the Geneva Accord. One of those needs was the achievement of widespread ratification, on the scale of the major measures of social protection—social security and labour protection; (iii) promoting social dialogue and tripartism; and (iv) respecting, promoting and realizing the fundamental principles and rights at work. 49 See footnote above. 50 See: Conventions in Need of Revision (Second Stage), Governing Body, Committee on Legal Issues and International Labour Standards, st Session, Geneva, November , ILO Doc. No. GB./LILS/WP/PRS/. 51 Except for one convention and its associated recommendation, on which it was unable to reach agreement. 52 See Chapters , and in particular. 53 See Chapter , Figure , p. , on the eight preferred solutions of shipowners and seafarers.
the mlc, as an instrument of the ilo
IMO conventions. In this connection, as will be seen below, a certain reliance was placed on the various ‘flexibility devices’ in previous international labour conventions; but these were not always appropriate54 and were also insufficient. Given that many previous maritime labour conventions, even those relating to a single subject, had not been widely ratified, how could one expect such an objective to be achieved in the case of the MLC, , especially having regard to its comprehensive subject matter? Innovative solutions were clearly required. Not all the special features of the MLC, consist of innovative solutions. Perhaps the most important feature relates to the achievement of an objective common to all previous maritime labour conventions, namely the right of seafarers to decent working and living conditions. The innovation lies in the whole focus of the Convention on those rights. Seafarers’ Rights and Tripartism The MLC, is often designated as a ‘seafarers’ bill of rights’.55 The Preamble to the Convention and its Articles III and IV set the requirements of the Convention within a human rights framework, and the various obligations throughout the text are expressed in the form of seafarers’ rights. Similarly, the MLC, contains a strong tripartite element. The ILO is not only a tripartite organization, as explained earlier, but the tripartite action in national decisionmaking is the subject of requirements in most, if not all, international labour conventions.56 The requirement for the consultation of seafarers’ and shipowners’ organizations before decisions are taken or in the decision-making process is to be found in the MLC, wherever provided for in the conventions that it consolidates and also in other contexts.57 In addition, the Convention contains an innovative provision, Article VII,58 to cover the case of ratifying countries in which shipowners’ or seafarers’ organizations do not yet exist.
54 As will be seen below, the ‘pick-and-choose’ approach as between various parts of a convention was not considered appropriate. 55 See also the discussion in Chapter , pp. –. 56 It is the subject of the whole convention in the case of one very important instrument, the Tripartite Consultation (International Labour Standards) Convention, (No. ), Geneva, June , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm. See also Chapter , note , regarding social dialogue. 57 In Article II, paragraph , for example. 58 See the discussion in Chapter .
chapter three Consolidated Convention Covering Both Substantive Requirements and Enforcement
The MLC, is not in fact the first international labour convention to carry both substantive requirements relating to the working and living conditions of a category of workers and the requirements for inspection and enforcement of compliance. Though far less developed than the MLC, , the first such self-contained convention was the Plantations Convention, (No. ). Compliance and Enforcement As explained earlier, since its first convention, the ILO has always emphasized not only establishing the requirements to be complied with, but also taking specific measures “in order to facilitate the enforcement of the provisions of this Convention”.59 However, with the MLC, , compliance and enforcement— in line with the Geneva Accord—has become a central component of the whole Convention in its Title . The details of the provisions in Title are explored in Chapter , however it is useful for the purpose of the analysis in the present chapter to note several novel elements in this Title, at least as compared with previous ILO conventions. First, there are its special provisions on the use of ‘recognized organizations’ (ROs) for inspection and certification, based on IMO provisions. Second, it extends the requirement for flag State inspections under the Labour Inspection (Seafarers) Convention, (No. ) to all ships covered by the MLC, , whatever their tonnage,60 and establishes a system of certification covering specified ships (inspired by similar systems under IMO conventions), including a document of maritime labour compliance (Declaration of Maritime Labour Compliance, DMLC Part II), giving shipowners responsibility for ensuring ongoing compliance on their ships with the Convention’s requirements. Third, it considerably amplifies the port State control provisions in Convention No. . Fourth, special provisions in Title highlight the importance that the Convention places on other regional port State control arrangements, and the extension of the powers of detention under port State control (as well as those of flag State inspectors61 under Convention No. ) to cover serious or repeated breaches of requirements (including seafarers’
59
Hours of Work (Industry) Convention, (No. ), Washington, November , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm, Art. . 60 Labour Inspection (Seafarers) Convention, (No. ), Geneva, October , does not apply to ships less than gross tonnage (Art. , para. ); available at http://www.ilo.org/ ilolex/english/convdisp.htm. 61 Standard A.., para. (c).
the mlc, as an instrument of the ilo
rights),62 in addition to threats to safety or health. Title also transforms the reference to complaints in Conventions Nos and into detailed provisions strengthening the role of complaints in the enforcement process. Finally, Title places each Member’s implementation of the enforcement and compliance provisions squarely in the context of the ILO’s supervisory system—not just with respect to labour inspections on board63 but also with respect to the enforcement of the Convention’s provisions relating to recruitment and placement services operating in the Member’s territory.64 Specifically, Members are required to establish effective inspection and monitoring systems in these areas, and to include information on those systems, including the methods used for assessing their effectiveness, in their reports to the ILO supervisory system under Article of the Constitution. The impact of the relevant provisions of the future MLC, was described as follows in the report prepared by the Office with respect to the draft Convention submitted to the th ILC in : The consolidated maritime labour Convention will have a strong enforcement component. The International Labour Organization’s greatest strength in the context of the implementation of international labour Conventions is undoubtedly its supervisory system, carrying the necessary institutional guarantees and authority and an important tripartite component. With the Convention, there will be a continuity of “compliance awareness” at every stage, from the national systems of protection up to the international system. It will start with the individual seafarers, who, under the Convention, will have to be properly informed of their rights and of the remedies available in case of alleged non-compliance with the requirements of the Convention and whose right to make complaints, both on board ship and ashore, will be recognized in the Convention. It will continue with the shipowners, who will be required to develop and carry out plans for ensuring that the applicable national laws, regulations or other measures to implement the Convention are actually being complied with. The masters of the ships concerned will then be responsible for carrying out the shipowners’ stated plans, and for keeping proper records to evidence implementation of the requirements of the Convention. As part of its updated responsibilities for the inspection of ships, the flag State will review the shipowners’ plans and verify and certify that they are actually in place and being implemented. They will also have to carry out periodic quality assessments of the effectiveness of their national systems of compliance, and their reports to the ILO under Article of the Constitution will need to provide information on their inspection and certification systems, including on their methods of quality assessment. This general inspection system in the flag State (which is founded on ILO Convention No. ) will be complemented by procedures to be followed in countries that are also or even primarily the source of the world’s supply of seafarers; these countries will similarly be reporting under 62 63 64
Standard A.., para. . Regulation .., para. , and Regulation .., para. . Regulation ., para. .
chapter three Article of the ILO Constitution. The system will, moreover, be reinforced by voluntary measures for inspections in foreign ports (port state control). An international information base will be developed, benefiting from the reports exchanged between port States or transmitted by them to the ILO as well as the documentation relating to complaints made by seafarers and other interested parties, under the Convention’s procedures.65
Certification The certification of ships for compliance with the requirements of the MLC, is one of the most important innovations as far as traditional ILO conventions are concerned. As will be explained in Chapter , it is both an obligation and a benefit for the ships that are required to carry certification, the benefit being in the prima facie evidence of compliance that certification provides in the context of port State control. The concept of certification by a government of ships flying its flag is certainly in line with the approach of international labour standards, in that it reflects at the national level the action of the ILO’s international supervisory bodies in identifying the progress or shortcomings of Members with respect to their implementation of the conventions that they have ratified. In one respect however, the provisions on certification constitute a departure from the traditional international labour convention since they give rise to rights and obligations as between the ratifying Members themselves, rather than only between each ratifying Member and the Organization. As has been noted above in the case of Convention No. , the same kind of interaction between ratifying Members also arises from the two conventions on seafarers’ identity documents, No. of , and the revising convention, No. of ; they provide for seafarers’ identity documents issued by each Member which other ratifying Members are required to recognize. Employers’ Rights Although international labour conventions promote social progress in general and relate to ‘rights at work’ (to use the terminology of the Declaration) and not just to workers’ rights, the MLC, , is one of the rare conventions (like those on freedom of association) that establish important rights for employers which can be enforced against ratifying Members. In particular, under the MLC, , shipowners have the right to request a maritime labour
65 Adoption of an Instrument to Consolidate Maritime Labour Standards, ILC, th (Maritime) Session, Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. Report I(A), available at http://www.ilo.org/public/ english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/rep-i-a.pdf, para. .
the mlc, as an instrument of the ilo
certificate (for ships not subject to certification),66 the right to decide, subject to the Administration’s approval, how they are going to ensure ongoing compliance on their ships (through the DMLC Part II),67 and, subject to prescribed exceptions, the right for their ships to be absolved from a more detailed inspection if the certificate and declaration are in order.68 Universality of Application and the Level Playing Field Many of the distinguishing features of the MLC, come from the need for equality among seafarers around the world and also among shipowners, in a context where the previous maritime labour conventions have been unevenly ratified and those that have been ratified have been unevenly applied. As indicated earlier, the traditional international labour conventions appear in practice to be compacts between each Member ratifying them and the ILO, rather than real contracts between ILO Member States. Moreover, they were compacts that could take effect under international law for an ILO Member even when only one other ILO Member was prepared to assume the same obligations, although this situation began to change in the case of maritime labour conventions in .69 In addition, international cooperation in the implementation of conventions had traditionally been a matter to be engaged in by each ratifying Member essentially for the benefit of its own nationals or residents. Other ILO Members had an interest in effective implementation and enforcement by the ratifying Member, especially if they had ratified the same convention. However, the action that they may have taken in this respect would have been in their capacity as Members of the Organization and in accordance with the Organization’s procedures rather than in implementation of the convention concerned. In the case of the MLC, as a whole, the cooperation in “effective implementation and enforcement” that is required of each ratifying Member by Article I, paragraph 70 is not restricted to the effective implementation and enforcement in the cooperating countries only, but also covers action to promote implementation and enforcement in other countries. Port State control under Regulation .. comes immediately to mind as an example of cooperation to ensure implementation on ships flying the flag of other ratifying Members and even of States that have not ratified the Convention or accepted the ILO Constitution. There are other examples: in particular, shipowners may 66
Regulation .., para. . Regulation .., para. (b). 68 Regulations .., para. , and .., para. , and Standard A.., para. . The issue of a ‘walk about’ under port State control provisions is discussed in Chapter . 69 Supra the paragraph marked by note above. 70 See Chapter . 67
chapter three
find themselves penalized for recruiting seafarers from agencies in a nonratifying country that do not meet the standards of the MLC, 71 even where the seafarers recruited are fully qualified to perform their duties on the ship. Thus, although the decision of an ILO Member on whether or not to ratify an international labour convention is a voluntary one, if its ships call in the port of a ratifying Member to take on a few passengers or cargo (for example) and then depart, the ships could be held in that port for the purposes of inspection for compliance with the MLC, and perhaps detained there for several days in the case of a serious breach of the Convention. Such a situation was also possible under Convention No. . But, as noted above, the MLC, provision72 also covers a serious or repeated breach of the Convention’s requirements unrelated to safety or health aspects. In addition, detention has now become mandatory in the case of such serious breaches or repeated non-compliance. The provisions on port State control appear as a response not only to the need for universality in the application of labour rights, but also to a more commercial need. The MLC, expressly establishes the principle, in Article V, paragraph ,73 that the ships of non-ratifying countries shall not receive more favourable treatment than those of ratifying countries: in other words, the Convention responds to the need to establish a level playing field for shipowners. Though worded differently, this response was anticipated in the Preamble to the ILO Constitution. It notes that “the failure of any nation to adopt humane conditions of labour is an obstacle in the way of other nations which desire to improve the conditions in their own countries”.74 However, in the MLC, , this constitutional consideration has been developed into an obligation on the ‘other nations’ to do what they can to remove that obstacle. Firmness and Flexibility As indicated above, one of the great challenges facing the drafters of the MLC, was how to introduce sufficient flexibility to achieve the unprecedented objective of widespread ratification without compromising the objectives of comprehensive consolidation, universality of protection and enforcement, and a level playing field. The basic solution to this challenge was formulated in the objective of firmness and flexibility, which was formulated at the first tripartite meeting on the future convention in as follows:
71 72 73 74
Under Regulation ., para. , and Standard A., para. . Standard A.., para. . See Chapter . Third preambular paragraph, which has remained unchanged since the Treaty of Versailles.
the mlc, as an instrument of the ilo
the instrument should be: – inflexible with respect to rights; – flexible with respect to implementation.75
What are known as ‘flexibility devices’ have been included in many international labour conventions on the basis of a provision in the ILO Constitution (Article , paragraph 76). This provision requires that international labour standards pay due regard to “those countries in which climatic conditions, the imperfect development of industrial organization, or other special circumstances make the industrial conditions substantially different”. A list of examples of the kinds of devices is given in the ILO’s Handbook of Procedures Relating to International Labour Conventions and Recommendations.77 Many, but not all, of these devices can be recognized in the MLC, , normally in a way which clearly shows the blend of firmness in the flexibility. In general, the flexibility in the MLC, covers all countries, without regard to any special local conditions, but relates to details, that is, to the way in which the basic rights and principles are to be delivered, but not to those rights and principles themselves. One traditional flexibility device was extensively discussed but was rejected as an overall solution: with this device, ratifying Members are given a choice between different parts of a convention.78 Or they are allowed, at the time of ratification, to accept a minimum number of parts. This is the case, for example, with the Plantations Convention (Article ): if a Member decides to exclude certain parts, it must attach a declaration to that effect to its instrument of ratification and report (in the framework of Article of the ILO Constitution) on progress towards the application of the excluded parts, which may be the subject of further declarations by the Member so as to include those parts within the scope of the original ratification. This flexibility device is however used—in a modified form—in one of the few provisions in the MLC, that is clearly designed for Members with ‘imperfect development of industrial organization, or other special circumstances’, namely the provision on social security protection. For example, the Social Security (Seafarers) Convention (Revised), (No. ) and Regulation 75
Final Report, HLTWG, First Session, Geneva, – December , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS /, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/ twgmls/twgmls-fr.pdf, at Chairperson’s Summary, Appendix. See also Chapter , Figure . 76 Treaty of Versailles, supra note , Art. , third paragraph. 77 ILO, Handbook of Procedures Relating to International Labour Conventions and Recommendations (Geneva: International Labour Office, ), available at http://training.itcilo.org/ils/ materials/public/english/-Handbook-ENGLISH.pdf, p. . 78 For example, under the Social Security (Seafarers) Convention (Revised), (No. ), supra note , Members may accept either the ‘minimum standards’ or the ‘superior standards’ laid down in the Convention.
chapter three
. and the related Standard in the MLC, require the acceptance of least three of the nine branches of social security protection. But, subject to this and other minimum requirements set out in the Convention, a ratifying Member is, in simplified terms, only required to do what its national circumstances— reinforced by any available international cooperation—allow it to do. This great flexibility for countries that are at an early stage in the area of social security is blended with greater firmness whereby each Member is placed under an obligation, right from the time of ratification, “to take steps, according to its national circumstances . . . to achieve progressively comprehensive social security protection for seafarers”79 (in all nine branches). The MLC, thus goes further than previous conventions in that the obligation is not simply to report to the ILO on progress, but also to make progress when national circumstances permit. Such an obligation probably only makes sense in the ILO context because of its supervisory procedures.80 For example, a Member might be required to provide justification to the supervisory bodies where its progress was slower than that in other countries which appeared to have similar national circumstances. Another flexibility device, which seems mainly to be in favour of countries with ‘imperfect development of industrial organization, or other special circumstances’, is found in paragraph of Article II.81 The blend of firmness can be seen in the temporary character of the dispensation in the sense that it relates to cases where the application of provisions would not be reasonable or practicable ‘at the present time’ and, like all other flexibility devices, it relates only to the provisions in the Code, as opposed to those of the articles and regulations. In addition, this flexibility is restricted to ships that do not go on international voyages. What could be described as the main, systemic flexibility in the MLC, lies in the relationship between the Parts of the Code to the MLC, , with the mandatory link in Article VI, paragraph , requiring “due consideration” to be given to the non-mandatory guidance in one part, Part B, in implementing the mandatory responsibilities in Part A.82 This kind of flexibility is seen in other international labour conventions. A good example is the Discrimination (Employment and Occupation) Convention, (No. ), which requires each ratifying Member to “declare and pursue a national policy designed to promote . . . equality of opportunity and treatment in respect of employment and occupation, with a view to eliminating any discrimination in 79 80 81 82
Regulation ., para. . See Chapter for more information. See Chapter . See Chapter in connection with Article II. This is extensively discussed in Chapters and .
the mlc, as an instrument of the ilo
respect thereof ” (Article ). Guidance as to the possible content of the national policies and ways of ensuring their implementation is, however, left to the Discrimination (Employment and Occupation) Recommendation, (R). In a sense ILO Members must give what could be described as ‘due consideration’ to international labour recommendations (regardless of whether they ratify a related convention) since they are required to “bring the recommendation or draft convention before the authority or authorities within whose competence the matter lies, for the enactment of legislation or other action”.83 The implementation of a Member’s responsibilities under its mandatory obligations, referred to in Article VI, paragraph , of the MLC, must also be achieved through legislation or other action.84 But there are good reasons why the MLC, departed from the Constitution-based practice of placing the non-mandatory guidance in a separate recommendation. First, as pointed out in paragraph of the Explanatory Note to the Regulations and Code of the Maritime Labour Convention, ,85 the general wording of many provisions in Part A of the Code gives little idea as to how they are to be implemented in practice unless they are read jointly with the related guidance in Part B. In addition, by being placed inside the Convention itself, the obligation to give due consideration to the non-mandatory guidance places it under the supervisory procedures relating to ratified conventions and makes it clear that the provision concerned—in the form recommended in Part B or in a different form decided by the ratifying Member—will be part of the national arrangements implementing the mandatory requirements of the Convention.86 This stronger approach with respect to guidelines is particularly justified when one considers that many of the provisions in Part B of the Code relate to the substance of (mandatory) international labour conventions. The other systemic flexibility device—substantial equivalence under paragraph of Article VI—is, of course, inspired by Convention No. .87 The elements of firmness in the MLC, , however, are the definition of the concept in paragraph of that Article, and the fact that a Member making use of the flexibility device may need to justify that it “is not in a position to implement the rights and principles in the manner set out in Part A of the Code”. 83
Emphasis added. Treaty of Versailles, supra note , Art. , fifth paragraph; ILO Constitution, supra note , Art. , para. (b). 84 MLC, , Article IV, paragraph , which reads: “. . . through national laws or regulations, through applicable collective bargaining agreements or through other measures or in practice”. See also the discussion in Chapter . 85 See Chapter , pp. –. 86 See paragraph of the Explanatory Note. 87 Art. (a). This device is also used, but only with respect to one provision, in the Seafarers’ Identity Documents Convention (Revised), (No. ), Geneva, June , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm, Art. , para. .
chapter three
Finally, mention could be made of the flexibility given with respect to the formulation of the national provisions implementing the MLC, , as opposed to their content. This relates to the fact that implementation does not necessarily have to be achieved through national laws and regulations (except where such means is expressly specified in the Convention). This is also the case with other international labour conventions. What is new, however, is the general statement to this effect in Article IV, paragraph , of the MLC, , which encourages, in particular, implementation through collective bargaining agreements. Amendment of the Convention The two Articles (XIV and XV)88 relating to the amendment of the MLC, may appear, at first glance, to be complete departures from the traditional provisions for revising international labour conventions. The formal result of the different amendment procedures provided for in Articles XIV and XV is a single amended version of the MLC, rather than two parallel conventions.89 In substance, however, there is little departure and the departures that are made are again dictated by specific needs. It will be recalled, in the first place, that the normal way of revising a convention was for the Organization to adopt a new, revising convention—with a new number—and, where appropriate, to block the old convention from further ratification and to release the Members that had ratified it from their obligations if they ratified the new convention.90 In the case of a large, comprehensive convention like the MLC, , this could in time result in a confusing host of differently numbered revising conventions. But this is perhaps not the main problem. As argued above, traditional international labour conventions appear in practice as compacts between each ratifying Member and the Organization, without any interaction creating interdependent rights and obligations between the ratifying States. For those conventions, the previous revision procedure may well be the most appropriate. However, as already noted, since the adoption of Convention No. , some maritime labour conventions do provide for such interaction between the parties. This is particularly relevant with respect to the maritime labour certificate. If the MLC, had been adopted as Convention No. , and were later revised by, let us say, a Convention No. containing substantial changes, the Members ratifying Convention No. and denouncing ipso iure Convention No. could no longer claim to have their 88
See the discussion in Chapter , pp. –. However, a ratifying Member that does not accept an amendment will remain bound by the previous version of the convention. 90 See supra the paragraph marked by note above. 89
the mlc, as an instrument of the ilo
maritime labour certificates recognized by the Members that had remained bound by Convention No. , and vice versa. Even though the certification provisions had remained the same in both conventions, the latter would in law be two separate instruments. Although this artificial rift in the nexus between ratifying Members could no doubt be patched up by appropriate drafting, it certainly appears as an unnecessary inconvenience.91 In the case of Article XIV, relating to the amendment of the MLC, as a whole, the new wording arrives at almost the same outcome as the normal result of revision under the traditional procedures: basically the same procedure is followed for the adoption of the revising text and for its communication to all ILO Members for ratification. Further, the effect of entry into force of the new text is the same: the previous text will be replaced by the new text only in the case of Members that ratify the new text or the amendment concerned. Unless the revising text provides otherwise, the old convention or version of the convention will no longer be open to ratification by Members which had not ratified it before the new text (a) enters into force or (b) receives the level of ratifications required for entry into force twelve months later. Alternative (a) relates to the traditional revision procedure; alternative (b) relates to the Article XIV procedure (see paragraph ). This is one of the differences between the two procedures. The other is that the level of requirements for entry into force and the period after which the revised text will enter into force is set by the MLC, itself (Article XIV, paragraphs , , and ), rather than by the revising convention. In contrast, Article XV, providing for a simplified amendment92 procedure that can be followed only with respect to the provisions in the Code, is essentially new to ILO conventions.93 It closely follows a similar provision in, inter alia, the IMO’s SOLAS Convention (Article VIII(b)). At the same time, the procedure based on what is known as the ‘tacit acceptance’ procedure in the IMO 91 As an alternative to the revision procedure, protocols have occasionally been used in the ILO as a method of amending conventions. Where the protocol (like that for Convention No. ) simply adds to previous obligations, no problem arises. However, in some cases (e.g., Protocol to the Night Work (Women) Convention (Revised), (P)), a protocol purported to allow a Member that had ratified the convention concerned, and even a non-ratifying Member, to be considered a party to the convention as substantively modified by the protocol regardless of whether or not the other parties had agreed to those modifications. There were good reasons for the modification; the procedure adopted thus appears to be conceptually sound, but only if international labour conventions are seen as compacts between each Member and the Organization, rather than as ‘real contracts between States’. 92 The indispensable need for an updating procedure of this kind requires no justification in the light of the concerns discussed in Chapter . 93 There are one or two precedents of the ILC being given the power to adopt amendments to a part, schedule, or annexes of a convention, which do not bind the current ratifying Members until they ratify or accept the amendment (e.g., Employment Injury Benefits Convention,
chapter three
conventions has been adapted to take account of the specificities of international labour conventions, referred to earlier, in particular the tripartite structure of the ILO and the pre-eminent role given by Article of the Constitution to the Organization as a whole, through the ILC, with respect to the adoption and revision of conventions. Thus, while the governments taking part in the adoption of amendments to the Code are restricted to those of the Members that have ratified the MLC, , their representatives act together with the representatives of shipowners and seafarers in the Special Tripartite Committee established by Article XIII of the MLC, . In addition, the ILC (consisting of all ILO Members) still retains control; its approval by a two-thirds majority is required before the amendments can be submitted for consideration to the ratifying Members. Once the Conference’s approval has been given, control returns to the ratifying Members, which have the right to express disagreement (under the tacit acceptance procedure) and to prevent entry into force of the amendment if the prescribed level of disagreement94 is reached. It will be noted that the two-thirds majority for the Conference’s approval of amendments of the Code is the same as that required for the adoption of conventions and recommendations under Article , paragraph , of the Constitution. Only the ILC has been given the power to adopt conventions. As is made clear in the Explanatory Note to the Regulations and Code,95 in the MLC, , the Code contains the details for the implementation of the regulations, and any amendments to it must remain within the general scope of the articles and regulations that have been adopted by the ILC (in the framework of Article of the Constitution).96 There could, however, be borderline cases in this regard. The approval by the Conference, by a twothirds majority, of amendments adopted under Article XV therefore not only provides a confirmation that the amendments are in line with the objectives of the Convention, but also gives a strong measure of legal certainty concerning the constitutionality of the use being made of Article XV in the particular case. Structure of the Convention The novel structure of the MLC, , as compared with that of the preceding international labour conventions, was determined by the need to present the Convention, in a clear way, with its unique and sometimes complex sub(No. ) and Night Work (Women) Convention (Revised), (No. )), or unless they notify their non-acceptance within a prescribed period (e.g., Seafarers’ Identity Documents Convention (Revised), (No. )). 94 See Art. XV, para. . 95 Paras and . 96 See also the discussion in Chapter .
the mlc, as an instrument of the ilo
stantive features. The organization and structural features of the Convention are the subject of detailed consideration in Chapter , however it is useful to briefly consider the question of structure relative to existing ILO practice. Two structural features distinguish the MLC, from the international labour conventions that preceded it. First, the articles of the Convention are restricted to the customary provisions relating to definition and scope, basic principles and rights underlying the Convention, general principles or rules introducing flexibility of a general nature, and the final clauses. The provisions setting out the specific requirements relating to the working and living conditions of seafarers, and the corresponding enforcement and compliance requirements are separated from the articles in the five Titles of the Convention. This separation seems helpful since it is mainly those provisions which need to be looked at by the national legislators and other officials when implementing the Convention through the adoption of national provisions and the establishment of the necessary infrastructures for enforcement and compliance. Second, each of the five Titles consists of groups of provisions setting out first a regulation, then the related standards followed by the related guidelines. These three types of provisions, covering the same subject matter, need to be read together for a proper comprehension of the Convention. At the same time, they need to be kept separate; in particular, for the purposes of the amendment procedure under Article XV, the content of the regulations needs to be distinguished from that of the related Code provisions consisting of the standards and guidelines. Similarly, as discussed above, the mandatory standards must be distinguished from the non-mandatory guidelines which must be given due consideration. Conclusion The Maritime Labour Convention, is essentially a consolidation of previous ILO standards and is in line with the standard-setting action of the ILO since , especially having regard to the developments since then with respect to maritime labour standards. It owes much to those standards—to Convention No. in particular—and to the special status that the Organization has accorded from the outset to the maritime sector, as seen in the periodic holding of a special maritime session of the ILC, in spite of the extra expense.97
97 One of the advantages of the MLC, is that the th Session of the ILC, during which the Convention was adopted, may be the last of the maritime sessions due to the Convention’s more flexible amendment procedures.
chapter three
At the same time, some of the traditional standard-setting approaches were inhibiting progress in meeting the needs of the maritime sector, namely the splitting up of the various areas of decent work for seafarers among different and often overlapping instruments, and a revision procedure that was incapable of keeping pace with the rapidly developing globalized industry. In addition, the maritime labour standards were caught up in a vicious circle, in which efforts to make progress in their ratification and effective enforcement by governments and shipowners committed to decent work were inhibited by the absence of the necessary level playing field to encourage ratification and enforcement. In addition to bringing the scattered standards together in a single coherent instrument and adopting suitable amendment mechanisms, the MLC, takes as a basis many of the approaches and concepts of the previous standards, such as the importance given to enforcement, as well as the various flexibility devices. The innovations that it contains have often resulted as a response to the same kinds of questions that the Organization has been asking itself since the s, and takes account of the answers given in the Organization. In particular, the primary importance of principles and rights, as compared with the details of implementation, reflects a feature of the Declaration. However, as discussed in Chapter , more was needed to resolve the serious problems that prompted the Geneva Accord of . In this respect, the MLC, could be seen as a genetic evolution of the traditional international labour convention in that its various components form a consistent whole directed towards the resolution of those problems in an inventive way. As indicated above in relation to the special features of the MLC, , this evolution was driven by pressing needs; but inventiveness was also required in order to find a synthesis for the achievement of contradictory objectives, such as those of firmness and flexibility. How could universal acceptability of an instrument that consolidates numerous and sometimes poorly ratified conventions be achieved at the same time as a level playing field of meaningful obligations? Part of the answer was to transform some sticking points of detail in existing obligations into non-mandatory guidance. But this contradicted the concern to maintain the level of protection under the existing standards. The resulting synthesis is to be found in Article VI, paragraph , of the Convention, by which nonmandatory guidance forms an integral part of mandatory obligations.98 But how were the drafters able to devise the complete and effective solutions that were unanimously agreed in ? At the outset, it seemed impossible, for example, to avoid including in the future convention a ‘pick and choose’ approach with respect to various parts or to cover the subject of social 98
The thinking behind this apparent paradox is to be found in the sentence marked by note above.
the mlc, as an instrument of the ilo
security protection, particularly since the main predecessor convention relating to social security had only been ratified by three countries.99 Having witnessed the five years of discussion in the preparation of the MLC, , the author of this chapter (like his co-authors) can only pay tribute to the power of tripartism—and to the effective leadership exercised in all three groups: governments, shipowners and seafarers—in enabling the best solutions to be worked out and agreed upon. The seafarers’ representatives, who had as their objective essentially the protection of seafarers’ rights, and the shipowners’ representatives, with their main objective for a level playing field, disclosed at the outset their core concerns, as did certain governments. Once each of the parties was satisfied that its core concerns would be met, the shipowners and seafarers often adopted a common position promoting their joint objective to ensure the adoption of a widely ratifiable convention. The governments for their part pursued the same objective, exercising responsible pressure towards that end in helping constituents surmount important obstacles that not infrequently arose. Finally, there was the necessary confidence among the ILO constituents in the effectiveness of the new convention—indeed a feeling of ownership100 on the part of those who had been working together over the previous five years. Without this general agreement that there was an essential need for the Convention, it could not have been adopted because of the procedural rules in the Standing Orders of the ILC. These rules include a complex system for the consideration of proposals, amendments and subamendments, which—while constituting an important safeguard—would almost certainly have frustrated the adoption of a -page convention in the time allotted if the constituents had not agreed beforehand to rely on less formal procedures. It is not surprising that the preparation and adoption of the MLC, has been described as tripartism at its best.101
99
The Social Security (Seafarers) Convention (Revised), (No. ). See Chapter . 101 See Chapter , at note . 100
chapter four OVERVIEW OF THE ILO’S SUPERVISORY SYSTEM: MORE THAN 90 YEARS OF SUPERVISION1
Introduction Since its creation in , the ILO has adopted international labour conventions, five protocols to existing conventions, and recommendations (collectively described as international labour standards or ‘ILS’2), a total of almost international labour instruments.3 The ILS are backed up by a supervisory system that is unique at the international level. This supervisory system helps to ensure that ILO Member States properly implement the conventions they ratify. The ILO regularly examines the application of standards in Members and points out areas where they could be better applied. If there are any problems in the application of standards, the ILO seeks to assist countries through social dialogue and technical assistance. The ILO has developed various means of monitoring the application of conventions and recommendations in national law and practice following their adoption by the ILC and, in the case of conventions, their ratification by States. The Constitution of the International Labour Organisation,4 which created the Organization, not only gave it a mandate to adopt conventions and recommendations but also to monitor the application of ratified conventions. The rationale for this is contained in the Preamble to the Constitution which states that “. . . the failure of any nation to adopt humane conditions of labour is an obstacle in the way of other nations which desire to improve the conditions
1
Dr. Cleopatra Doumbia-Henry, Director, International Labour Standards Department (see also Chapter , note ) and Ms. Tomi Kohiyama, Assistant to the Director, International Labour Standards Department, International Labour Office, ILO, Geneva. The views expressed in this chapter are the personal views of the two co-authors, and are not to be understood as the views of the International Labour Office or the International Labour Organization. 2 See the discussion in Chapter regarding the legal character of ILO conventions and recommendations. 3 In addition, the ILO has published numerous guidelines and/or codes to assist with national implementation of ILS on specific matters or areas, for example, HIV/AIDS and work, Using the ILO Code of Practice and Training Manual: Guidelines for Labour Judges and Magistrates (ILO: Geneva, ). 4 See Chapter . Available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/iloconst.htm.
chapter four
in their own countries”. Several provisions in the Constitution are thus devoted to what has come to be called ‘the supervisory system’. Articles ,5 ,6 and 7 5 Ibid. See also discussion at p. . Article —Conventions and Recommendations, paragraph , “Obligations of Members in respect of Conventions”, which reads:
. In the case of a Convention: (a) the Convention will be communicated to all Members for ratification; (b) each of the Members undertakes that it will, within the period of one year at most from the closing of the session of the Conference, or if it is impossible owing to exceptional circumstances to do so within the period of one year, then at the earliest practicable moment and in no case later than months from the closing of the session of the Conference, bring the Convention before the authority or authorities within whose competence the matter lies, for the enactment of legislation or other action; (c) Members shall inform the Director-General of the International Labour Office of the measures taken in accordance with this article to bring the Convention before the said competent authority or authorities, with particulars of the authority or authorities regarded as competent, and of the action taken by them; . . . and paragraph , “Obligations of Members in respect of Recommendations”, which reads: . In the case of a Recommendation: (a) the Recommendation will be communicated to all Members for their consideration with a view to effect being given to it by national legislation or otherwise; (b) each of the Members undertakes that it will, within a period of one year at most from the closing of the session of the Conference or if it is impossible owing to exceptional circumstances to do so within the period of one year, then at the earliest practicable moment and in no case later than months after the closing of the Conference, bring the Recommendation before the authority or authorities within whose competence the matter lies for the enactment of legislation or other action; (c) the Members shall inform the Director-General of the International Labour Office of the measures taken in accordance with this article to bring the Recommendation before the said competent authority or authorities with particulars of the authority or authorities regarded as competent, and of the action taken by them; . . . and paragraph , “Effect of Conventions and Recommendations on more favourable existing provisions”, which reads: . In no case shall the adoption of any Convention or Recommendation by the Conference, or the ratification of any Convention by any Member, be deemed to affect any law, award, custom or agreement which ensures more favourable conditions to the workers concerned than those provided for in the Convention or Recommendation. 6
Ibid., Article , which reads: Each of the Members agrees to make an annual report to the International Labour Office on the measures which it has taken to give effect to the provisions of Conventions to which it is a party. These reports shall be made in such form and shall contain such particulars as the Governing Body may request.
7
Ibid., Article , which reads: . The Director-General shall lay before the next meeting of the Conference a summary of the information and reports communicated to him by Members in pursuance of articles and .
more than years of supervision
of the ILO Constitution provide for what can be considered the regular supervisory procedures. They contain an obligation on all ILO Member States to send reports at regular intervals to the ILO with respect to all conventions they have ratified or not ratified and to communicate these reports to the representative organizations of employers and workers. They also include an obligation to submit conventions and recommendations adopted by the ILC to national authorities for “the enactment of legislation or other action”. Several provisions deal with what has come to be called the special supervisory procedures. Articles and of the Constitution deal with the representation procedure. These two articles give employers’ and workers’ organizations the right to submit representations alleging non-observance by a Member State government of a convention that it has ratified. Articles – and – deal with the complaints procedure under which a Member may file a complaint against another Member or a delegate to the ILC alleging failure by that Member State to secure effective observance of a convention that it has ratified. Since , the supervisory system with its various procedures has evolved substantially, mainly through the decisions taken by the ILC and the Governing Body. In addition, the various supervisory bodies involved in the system have taken a number of decisions relating to their methods of work and procedures. Historical Overview When the ILO was first created, it had been thought that supervision of the application of ratified conventions would be carried out by the ILC itself through the summary of annual reports that the Director-General would lay before it. After the first six years, the Conference recognized that its composition and method of work did not enable it to undertake a thorough examination of the reports submitted to it.8 This recognition gave rise to the need for a specific machinery to undertake such an examination. At the time, the distinction between the procedure for the examination of reports submitted by Member States and the procedures concerning complaints and representations was emphasized. The annual reports were presented as constituting a means of providing and sharing information among Member States; the procedure for their examination therefore differed essentially from the representation and complaint procedures. In , the Conference decided, . Each Member shall communicate to the representative organizations recognized for the purpose of Article copies of the information and reports communicated to the DirectorGeneral in pursuance of Articles and . 8
See Note prepared by the Office, ILC, th Session (), Vol. I, Appendix V, p. .
chapter four
through a resolution, to set up two committees to enable it to undertake this task: – the Committee on the Application of Standards (Conference Committee) – the Committee of Experts on the Application of Conventions and Recommendations (Committee of Experts)9
Under the terms of the above Conference resolution, the mandate of the Committee of Experts was to make “the best and fullest use of the information contained in the reports rendered by the State Members”. The submission of the first two representations in and raised several practical questions about the modalities of the procedure embodied in the Constitution. It was felt that to safeguard both the rights of industrial associations and the freedom of action of the Governing Body, some rules were needed. In , the Governing Body therefore adopted procedural rules (called Standing Orders in the ILO) concerning the application of the representation procedure.10 In the course of the discussion leading up to the adoption of these rules, members of the Governing Body emphasized the need to distinguish clearly between the representation procedure and the complaints procedure. The next important development in the supervisory system occurred through the amendments to the Constitution. Several significant changes were introduced in Articles and , particularly: (i) the obligation to report on measures taken to submit newly adopted instruments to the competent national authorities; (ii) the obligation to submit information and reports on unratified conventions and recommendations when so requested by the Governing Body; and (iii) the obligation to communicate reports and information under Articles and to representative employers’ and workers’ organizations.
The terms of reference of the Conference Committee and the Committee of Experts were revised to reflect the first two obligations. Other changes were also made to the complaints procedure under Article .
9
See, Resolution concerning the methods by which the Conference can make use of the reports submitted under Article of the Treaty of Versailles, ILC, th Session (), Vol. I, Appendix VII, p. . 10 The Standing Orders concerning the representation procedure were amended in , , and, most recently, in . See: Standing Orders concerning the procedure for the examination of representations under Articles and of the Constitution of the International Labour Organization, Governing Body, th Session ( April ), modified at its nd Session ( February ), th Session ( March ), and st Session ( November ), available at http:// www.ilo.org / global / standards/information-resources-and-publications/publications / WCM_/lang-en/index.htm.
more than years of supervision
The third major development in the supervisory system took place in . Following the adoption of the Freedom of Association and Protection of the Right to Organise Convention, (No. ), and the Right to Organise and Collective Bargaining Convention, (No. ), the ILO, in agreement with the Economic and Social Council of the United Nations (ECOSOC),11 established a procedure for the examination of allegations concerning the infringement of trade union rights, including a new supervisory body, the Fact-Finding and Conciliation Commission on Freedom of Association. It was also agreed that all allegations regarding infringements of trade union rights received by the United Nations against ILO Member States would be forwarded by ECOSOC to the Governing Body. The purpose of the new procedure was to provide facilities for impartial and authoritative investigation of questions of fact raised by allegations of infringements of trade union rights. In view of the fact that the principle of freedom of association was enshrined in the ILO Constitution and the Declaration of Philadelphia,12 as well as its importance for the tripartite structure of the ILO, allegations concerning infringements of trade union rights could be made against all ILO Member States, whether or not they had ratified the relevant conventions. However, no allegations could be referred to the FactFinding and Conciliation Commission on Freedom of Association without the consent of the government concerned.13 Further, the new arrangements would not in any way replace the existing constitutional provisions of the ILO concerning representations and complaints. In , the Governing Body went on to establish the Committee on Freedom of Association (CFA). Initially, the examination of complaints by the CFA was intended to determine whether the allegations warranted further examination by the Governing Body and, where it was so determined, to attempt to secure the consent of the government concerned to the referral of such allegations to the Fact-Finding and Conciliation Commission on Freedom of Association. The examination of allegations by the CFA, unlike the Fact-Finding and Conciliation Commission, did not require the consent of the government concerned. The CFA rapidly became the main body responsible for examining allegations of violations of freedom of association. It assumed this role largely because of the difficulty in obtaining the consent of governments to the referral 11
See Annex of the Digest of decisions and principles of the Freedom of Association Committee of the Governing Body of the ILO (Geneva: International Labour Office, Fifth (revised) edition, ). 12 The Declaration of Philadelphia adopted by the International Labour Conference in is an Annex to the ILO Constitution. See Chapter , note . 13 A compromise was thus reached between proponents of the universality of ILO action in respect of all its Members in relation to freedom of association and those who considered that the ILO could only intervene on the basis of the ratification of the relevant conventions.
chapter four
of matters to the Fact-Finding and Conciliation Commission; the formal nature of the investigation carried out by the latter; and substantial developments in the procedure of the CFA, which led to a broadening of the examination of complaints by the CFA.14 Following the establishment of the special procedure on freedom of association, subsequent developments in the supervisory system have related to the operation of existing supervisory arrangements. In the mid-s, the first decisions were taken to allow the Committee of Experts and the Conference Committee to deal with their increasing workload. First, a division of labour was progressively established between the Conference Committee and the Committee of Experts. At the beginning, both Committees examined successively all the issues arising out of annual reports. However, in , the Conference Committee adopted the ‘principle of selectivity’15 so that it would concentrate only on cases in which the Committee of Experts had drawn attention to definite discrepancies between the terms of ratified conventions and national laws and practices. Second, in , the Governing Body decided to lengthen the reporting cycle from one to two years. Starting in the s, supervision of the application of ratified conventions, which had hitherto been carried out mainly through the regular supervisory procedure, began to see the more frequent use of complaint and representation procedures. In , a complaint was lodged by one Member State against another, leading to the establishment of the first Commission of Inquiry. As of , employers’ and workers’ organizations began to have recourse more frequently to the representation procedure. A total of complaints and representations have been lodged to date.16 In addition to further adjustments to reporting arrangements, the main development in the s was the increased participation of employers’ and workers’ organizations in the supervisory procedures. In and , the Conference adopted two resolutions reinforcing tripartism17 in all ILO activities, including supervision of the application of ILSs.18 These resolutions 14
See: ILO, “Committee on Freedom of Association,” available at http://www.ilo.org/global/ standards / applying-and-promoting-international-labour-standards / committee-on-freedomof-association/lang-en/index.htm. 15 Record of Proceedings, ILC, th Session, , p. , paras and . 16 As of November , with commissions of inquiry. See: ILO, “Complaints,” available at http://www.ilo.org /global /standards /applying-and-promoting-international-labour-standards / complaints/lang-en/index.htm; http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/repframeE.htm. 17 See Chapters and , pp. –. 18 Resolution concerning the strengthening of tripartism in the overall activities of the International Labour Organisation, ILC, th Session, June ; Resolution concerning the strengthening of tripartism in ILO supervisory procedures of international standards and technical co-operation programmes, ILC, rd Session, June .
more than years of supervision
prompted various measures to encourage greater participation by employers’ and workers’ organizations in the supervisory procedures. Moreover, the Tripartite Consultation (International Labour Standards), Convention (No. ) was adopted in with a view to reinforcing the involvement of employers’ and workers’ organizations at the national level in all ILO standards-related activities, including the drawing up of reports by Member States under Article . When, in , the Governing Body decided to further lengthen the reporting cycle for conventions (except for the most important conventions) from two to four years, it approved a number of safeguards to ensure that the introduction of a longer reporting cycle did not weaken the effectiveness of the supervisory system. These measures included consideration by the Committee of Experts of comments sent directly to the Office by employers’ and workers’ organizations even in years when no report was due. Modifications to the reporting cycle were again made in and .19 Following the Report of the Director-General to the st Session of the Conference (),20 the Governing Body regularly discusses the working of the supervisory system within the overall framework of improvements to ILO standards-related activities with a view to strengthening the efficiency and impact of the supervisory mechanisms.21 An overview of the related discussions and decisions was presented to the Governing Body at its nd Session (March ).22
19 See: Improvements in the standards-related activities of the ILO: From Strategy to implementation, Fourth item on the Agenda, Governing Body, Committee on Legal Issues and International Labour Standards, th Session, Geneva, March , ILO Doc. No. GB./LILS/; paragraphs and present a summary of the various adjustments to reporting arrangements, including the reporting cycle, decided on by the Governing Body. 20 Defending Values, Promoting Change: Social Justice in a Global Economy: An ILO Agenda, Report of the Director-General (Part I), ILC, st Session, . 21 See for example the most recent considerations: Report of the Committee on Legal Issues and International Labour Standards, Second Report: International Labour Standards and Human Rights, Improvements in the Standards-related Activities of the ILO, Fourth item on the agenda, Governing Body, th Session, Geneva, November , ILO Doc. No. GB.//, available at http://www.ilo.org /gb/GBSessions /GB/lang-en/commId-GB/WCMS_/index.htm. See also: Improvements in the Standards-related Activities of the ILO, Fourth item on the agenda, Governing Body, Committee on Legal Issues and International Labour Standards, th Session, Geneva, November , ILO Doc. No. GB /LILS/, available at http://www.ilo.org/gb/ GBSessions/GB/lang-en/commId-LILS/WCMS_/index.htm. 22 See: Improvements in the Standards-related Activities of the ILO: A Progress Report, Seventh item on the agenda, Governing Body, Committee on Legal Issues and International Labour Standards, nd Session, Genva, March , ILO Doc. No. GB./LILS/, paras –.
chapter four The Supervisory System Institutional Machinery
As the foregoing historical overview explained, several specific bodies have been established to assist the ILC with respect to its supervisory functions. Committee of Experts The Committee of Experts is an independent body of legal experts. Its members are appointed by the Governing Body on the proposal of the DirectorGeneral for renewable periods of three years. There are currently experts. Appointments are made in a personal capacity among impartial persons with technical legal competence and independent standing. They are drawn from all parts of the world in order that the Committee may enjoy first-hand experience of different legal, economic, and social systems. The Committee’s fundamental principles are those of independence, impartiality, and objectivity in noting the extent to which the position in each State appears to conform to the terms of the conventions and the obligations accepted under the ILO Constitution. In this spirit, the Committee is called on to examine: (i) the annual reports under Article of the Constitution on the measures taken by Members to give effect to the provisions of conventions to which they are parties, and the information furnished by Members concerning the results of inspection; (ii) the information and reports concerning conventions and recommendations communicated by Members in accordance with Article of the Constitution; and (iii) information and reports on the measures taken by Members in accordance with Article of the Constitution.
On the basis of this information, the Committee of Experts issues a report annually containing its observations on compliance by Member States of the ILO concerning conventions ratified by them, based on the reports due for countries that year.23 It also issues a report on law and practice of Member States concerning a group of conventions selected by the ILO Governing Body. Other 23 For see: Report III (A): Report of the Committee of Experts on the Application of Conventions and Recommendations, ILC, th Session, , available at http://www.ilo.org/ ilc / ILCSessions / thSession / ReportssubmittedtotheConference / lang-en / docName-WCMS_ /index.htm. The ILO Web site notes that:
The Report of the Committee of Experts on the Application of Conventions and Recommendations provides an impartial and technical evaluation of the state of application of ILO Conventions and Recommendations in member States. This year, the Committee has examined more than reports from governments on the application of ratified Conventions. See also the General Report of the Committee of Experts on the Application of Conventions and Recommendations issued between – (available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/ ceacrrepsq.htm).
more than years of supervision
comments, called ‘direct requests’, are not published in its annual report but are sent separately to governments seeking further information on specific matters. The Conference Committee on Application of Standards The Conference Committee, a permanent committee of the ILC, is tripartite and universal in composition. It is the keystone of the supervisory system of the ILO, exercising a form of parliamentary control. These elements provide it with an unparalleled authority to exert pressure on countries that persistently fail to comply with their obligations under ratified conventions. The Conference Committee has the overall responsibility for considering the extent to which international labour standards are being implemented and reporting thereon to the Conference. This mandate follows from Article of the ILO Constitution, and is articulated in Article of the Standing Orders of the ILC, which enjoins this Committee to “consider the measures taken by Members to give effect to the provisions of Conventions to which they are parties, and the information furnished by Members concerning the results of inspections.” It has a dynamic mandate with considerable discretion to adapt its action to the changing needs of the international environment. The Conference Committee draws on multiple sources, including practical, doctrinal, economic, legal, and a broad policy viewpoint, in its reflection on measures States have taken or are taking. It is also important to note that this Committee is responsible for a process that involves several other important actors. At the international level, the Committee of Experts and the Office are this Committee’s main partners. The Conference Committee presents a report every year to the plenary of the ILC outlining the conclusions it has drawn with respect to specific cases of non-compliance by Member States concerning conventions they have ratified and, in certain cases, draws the special attention of the Conference to serious cases of continuous failure in a special paragraph in its report. The Committee on Freedom of Association As noted earlier, the CFA is an organ of the ILO’s Governing Body reflecting the ILO tripartite character.24 It is composed of nine regular and nine deputy members representing in equal proportion the Government, Employer and Worker Groups of the Governing Body. Each Member participates in a personal capacity. Representatives or nationals of the State against which a complaint has
24 For more information and links to reports see: http://www.ilo.org/global / standards / applyingand-promoting-international-labour-standards/committee-on-freedom-of-association/ lang-en/index.htm.
chapter four
been made, or persons occupying an official position in the national organization of employers or workers which has made the complaint, cannot participate in the Committee’s deliberations or even be present during the hearing of the complaint in question. The CFA meets three times a year (March, May, and November), and its recommendations are submitted to the Governing Body for adoption. Features of the Supervisory Procedures The historical overview explained that the supervisory system consists of several different procedures, each with a well-defined purpose. The regular supervisory procedure, based on the reports submitted regularly by Member States, ensures the continuous assessment of the application by Member States (difficulties and progress) of ratified international labour conventions. It combines the objective examination of the reports by the Committee of Experts with tripartite dialogue in the Conference Committee. Despite the lengthening of the reporting cycle, this continuity has been preserved, particularly by making the necessary arrangements for the active participation of employers’ and workers’ organizations through the submission of comments. The special supervisory procedures, which are based on the various types of complaints, focus on specific problems as they arise and are mainly initiated by employers’ and workers’ organizations. The main purpose is to resolve particular cases, generally involving complex issues of fact and law that call for close examination by a specially convened body. These special supervisory procedures each have specific mandates and attributes. The representation and complaint procedures address allegations of non-observance of ratified conventions. The representation procedure permits a relatively speedy resolution of the case by a tripartite body, while the procedure for the examination of a complaint by a commission of inquiry under Article of the Constitution is more formal and may, eventually, result in serious measures under Article of the Constitution. The scope of the special procedure on freedom of association is broader, as it can be invoked whether or not the country concerned has ratified the relevant conventions and the allegations are examined in the light of the principles of freedom of association. Relevant General Features of the Supervisory System The supervisory system as a whole has several features that are conducive to the establishment of links between its different components. First, the various supervisory procedures all pursue a common purpose: the effective observance of international labour standards, and in particular ratified conventions.
more than years of supervision
The links between the supervisory procedures therefore operate in respect of obligations freely assumed by Member States through the ratification of conventions. This consideration also includes the special procedure concerning freedom of association since, as will be seen below, this procedure interacts with other procedures only in cases where Member States have ratified the relevant conventions. As to be expected in a tripartite organization, in addition to governments, the system involves the participation of employers’ and workers’ organizations, and their role has continued to grow as the system has developed. Convention No. formalized the important role that these organizations should fulfil at the national level, where they contribute to the adoption of measures and assist in reviewing their implementation. Employers’ and workers’ organizations can contribute to the work of the Committee of Experts by sending comments on the application of ratified conventions, or they can initiate action by an ILO supervisory body through the submission of a representation under Article , a complaint under Article (through a delegate to the Conference), or a complaint to the CFA. Their representatives participate directly in the work of a number of the supervisory bodies and the Governing Body. Under the ILO Constitution, the Governing Body has a number of specific functions in relation to the operation of the supervisory procedures. These include the approval of report forms on ratified conventions, such as the innovative form approved in for the MLC, ,25 and the consideration of representations and complaints. Moreover, the Governing Body has responsibilities relating to the overall efficient functioning and work of the supervisory bodies. Accordingly it: (i) decides upon the mandates of certain supervisory bodies (although not in the case of commissions of inquiry and the Conference Committee); (ii) appoints the members of most of these bodies (on the proposal of the DirectorGeneral in the case of bodies composed of independent experts); and (iii) receives all the reports of the supervisory bodies, either to note or approve them (with the exception of the report of the Conference Committee).
The Governing Body has always exercised these responsibilities in full knowledge of the distinction between its own role and those of the specific bodies concerned. It has accordingly left them to determine their methods of work and procedures and has approved their reports after discussion by its members. As
25 The Article report form for the MLC, can be found in Appendix IV of ILO Doc. No. GB.// (Rev), March , available at http://www.ilo.org/global/standards/maritimelabour-convention/WCMS_/lang--en/index.htm.
chapter four
will be seen below, the Governing Body is also called upon to take decisions relating to the linkages between the various supervisory procedures. In accordance with its functions under Article of the Constitution, the Office also has an important role to play in acting as the secretariat of the supervisory bodies. In this capacity, it prepares the necessary materials for their meetings, including, where appropriate, draft texts for their consideration and adoption, taking into account the work carried out by other supervisory bodies. The Office therefore contributes, within its mandate, to the coherence of examination between the supervisory bodies. Further, the Office has specific responsibilities at the various stages prior to the examination of cases by the supervisory bodies in terms of obtaining full and appropriate information from the parties. It also follows up comments made by the supervisory bodies, particularly through its technical cooperation and assistance activities. While a range of supervisory procedures are available, the methods employed in each procedure are similar. These include: – submission of written information, which may be supplemented by oral information – on-the-spot missions, particularly in the form of direct contacts missions – arrangements to follow up on matters examined by a supervisory body in the context of a particular complaint or a representation – various publicity measures
Moreover, some supervisory mechanisms are similar in composition and procedure, which tends to create particular links between the bodies concerned. Thus, the CFA and the tripartite committees set up to examine representations are all tripartite bodies of the Governing Body examining submissions made by employers’ and workers’ organizations. The impartiality of their respective examinations is guaranteed by similar rules, which exclude from the examination of the case any representative or national of the State against which the submission is made, as well as any person occupying an official position in the organization which has made the submission.26 The introductory note to the Standing Orders concerning the procedure for the examination of representations refers to certain principles developed by the CFA in relation to the issues of receivability and prescription of complaints, which may be applied by analogy to the representations procedure.27 The two investigatory bodies of
26
Article , paragraph , of the Standing Orders, supra note , and paragraph of Annex I of the Digest of the CFA, supra note . 27 Possible Improvements in the Standards-related Activities of the ILO: Proposals regarding submission to the competent authorities and the representation procedure, Governing Body, Committee on Legal Issues and International Labour Standards, st Session, Geneva, November , ILO Doc. No. GB./LILS/, “Introductory Note to the Standing Orders concerning the procedure
more than years of supervision
the system—the Fact-Finding and Conciliation Commission and commissions of inquiry—also present a number of similarities regarding their membership (e.g., the independence and qualifications of their members) and procedures (e.g., both commissions have recourse to similar means to obtain full and objective information). They also have in common the mandate to investigate the facts relating to the alleged non-compliance. The Relationship between the Supervisory System Procedures On each occasion that the Conference and the Governing Body decided to supplement the institutional framework of the supervisory system, emphasis was placed on the distinctive nature of each procedure. This meant that the examination of issues under one procedure would not prevent the initiation of another procedure on the same issues. However, there is an inherent need for coordination and coherence between the various supervisory bodies in order to achieve the common purpose of the effective promotion and observance of international labour standards. This need has thus led to the establishment of more formalized linkages between the procedures. These links between the supervisory procedures operate at three levels: (a) the referral of matters to the appropriate supervisory body; (b) suspension or closure of a supervisory procedure upon the initiation of another procedure; and (c) the examination by other supervisory bodies, and particularly the Committee of Experts, of the effect given to the recommendations of supervisory bodies in specific cases. Referral In the context of a representation under Article Under Article , paragraph , of the Constitution, the Governing Body may initiate the complaint procedure of its own motion. One of the objectives of this provision, which was already included in the Constitution, was to enable the Governing Body to initiate a complaint procedure in light of a representation submitted by an industrial association under Article . This specific manner of initiating a complaint procedure was further specified in the first version of the Standing Orders concerning the procedure for the examination of representations adopted in . Article of the current Standing Orders was inserted to enable the Governing Body, when it receives a representation, to adopt at any time the complaint procedure provided for in Article . When the Standing Orders were revised in , it was decided to retain this provision “both to draw attention to this possibility and to make for the examination of representations under Articles and of the Constitution of the ILO,” Annex III, paras and , pp. and .
chapter four
it clear that the fact that the representation procedure under Article was under way did not prevent the initiation of the complaints procedure under Article ”.28 To date, the Governing Body has availed itself of this possibility on only two occasions.29 Under Article , paragraphs – of the Standing Orders concerning the procedure for the examination of representations, if the Governing Body deems a representation receivable, it can decide on one of the following three courses of action: (i) reference to a tripartite committee, which is the most common course of action; tripartite committees have thus been established to date; (ii) referral to the CFA30 of any aspects of a representation relating to a convention dealing with trade union rights, in which case the CFA will examine the case applying its own methods of work and procedures, and its conclusions and recommendations will be published in a report that is separate from the report on complaints examined under the special procedure; there have been such referrals to date; or (iii) postponement of the appointment of a tripartite committee if the representation relates to matters and allegations similar to those that have been the subject of a previous representation until the Committee of Experts has examined the followup to the recommendations adopted by the Governing Body in relation to the previous representation; the Governing Body has not yet formally resorted to this possibility.
In the context of a complaint relating to the application of ratified conventions on freedom of association In principle no complaint may be referred to the Fact-Finding and Conciliation Commission on Freedom of Association without the consent of the government concerned. Nevertheless, the government’s consent is not required in respect of any complaint relating to a ratified convention, in which case the Governing Body may designate the Fact-Finding and Conciliation Commission as a commission of inquiry under Article of the Constitution. The possibility thus open to the Governing Body is reflected in the six reports of the Fact-Finding and Conciliation Commission. Although the Governing Body has 28 See paper presented to the Governing Body, st Session (February–March ), ILO Doc. No. GB.//, para. . 29 In one of these cases, the representation had already been examined by a tripartite committee. When examining the report of the tripartite committee, the Governing Body decided to set up a commission of inquiry which, in the course of its examination, emphasized that its task did not consist of reviewing the conclusions of the tripartite committee that had examined the representation; rather, it was to carry out its own investigation. 30 The possibility of referral to the CFA, in accordance with Articles and of the Constitution, supra note , was introduced when the Standing Orders were revised in in light of the Resolution concerning the promotion, protection, and strengthening of freedom of association, trade union, and other human rights, adopted by the ILC at its rd session.
more than years of supervision
never availed itself of this possibility, it made use of similarities between the two commissions in one instance.31 In eight instances, where complaints lodged under Article concerned issues relating to the non-observance of ratified conventions on freedom of association already pending before the CFA, the Governing Body sought the latter’s recommendation as to whether the Article complaint should be referred to a commission of inquiry. In four of these cases, referral to a commission of inquiry was not considered appropriate in light of the information obtained through on-the-spot missions. These cases remained under the CFA’s examination. In two cases, the CFA recommended the referral of the complaint to a commission of inquiry, emphasizing that it was for the Governing Body to take a decision on the recommendation and the modalities of its implementation. In the two remaining cases, the CFA merely underlined that it was for the Governing Body to decide on the referral of the complaint to a commission of inquiry. It should also be noted that in one case the Governing Body decided of its own motion to refer allegations pending before the CFA to a commission of inquiry. Suspension or Closure It is the established practice that the examination of a case by the Committee of Experts, and subsequently by the Conference Committee, should be suspended in the event of a representation (Article ) or complaint (Article ) in relation to the same case being referred either to a tripartite committee or to a commission of inquiry. The Committee of Experts reverts to its examination once the Governing Body has taken a decision on the representation or complaint. As will be noted below, the Committee of Experts’ subsequent examination of the case may include follow-up of the recommendations of the body which examined the representation or complaint. Nevertheless, in cases where a complaint is lodged with the CFA, examination by the Committee of Experts of some of the issues raised therein is not suspended.32 31
At the time, allegations of infringements of trade union rights against a country which had not ratified the conventions on freedom of association had led to the establishment of a FactFinding and Conciliation Commission with the government’s consent. When the Conference subsequently requested the Governing Body to refer to a commission of inquiry the question of the observance by that country of other conventions it had ratified, the Governing Body nominated the same persons that it had appointed as members of the Fact-Finding and Conciliation Commission one month earlier to sit on the commission of inquiry. A double investigation was carried out by the Commission, which eventually submitted two reports to the Governing Body. 32 There may be several explanations for this established practice: (i) although the two bodies examine legislative as well as practical issues, their respective examinations have a different emphasis (case-specific and with greater emphasis on practical issues for the CFA, while the
chapter four
Similarly, referral by the Governing Body of a representation under Article to the CFA does not affect the examination of the matter by the Committee of Experts.33 In the process leading to the adoption of the Standing Orders concerning the representation procedure in , the Office suggested that a decision of the Governing Body to initiate a complaint procedure under Article () should imply ‘closure’ of a representation procedure on the same matter. However, no rule was introduced in the Standing Orders to that effect. The Governing Body has consequently retained its discretion as to the course of action to be decided upon in such cases. On one occasion, when discussing the report of the respective tripartite committee, the Governing Body decided to refer the matters raised in a representation to a commission of inquiry; in view of this referral, the Governing Body decided that it was no longer necessary to adopt the recommendations of the tripartite committee set up to examine the original representation. On another occasion, the Governing Body decided that the representation procedure should resume its course once the procedure for the examination of the complaint had become without object.34 Effect Given by Countries to the Recommendations Made by the Supervisory Bodies It is a well-established practice in the supervisory system that the Committee of Experts follows up the effect given by governments to the recommendations made by tripartite committees (Article ) and commissions of inquiry (Article ). The governments concerned are therefore requested to indicate in their reports under Article the measures taken on the basis of these recommendations. The related information is then examined by the regular supervisory machinery. As such, it becomes part of the ongoing dialogue between the Committee of Experts’ examination tends to focus on legislative issues or on more general questions relating to the application of conventions in practice); (ii) the importance of freedom of association and the related need to draw attention to serious problems relating to the application of the relevant conventions; and (iii) the special procedure was not meant to replace existing procedures but to supplement them. 33 The question of the effect of the complaint and representation procedures, including the special procedure on freedom of association, on the regular supervisory machinery was discussed by the Governing Body at its rd (November ) and th (November ) sessions. See the papers presented to the Governing Body, ILO Doc. Nos. GB./LILS/ and GB./LILS/. The amendments to the Standing Orders proposed in this respect did not achieve consensus. 34 In this particular instance, a complaint under Article and a representation under Article had been lodged by a Member State and a workers’ organization against the same Member State. The complaint and representation raised the same issues of non-observance of ratified conventions. The Governing Body decided that the issues should be referred to a commission of inquiry. A settlement was eventually reached between the two Member States and the complaint was withdrawn.
more than years of supervision
government, the Committee of Experts and the Conference Committee, if it so decides. In the case of the recommendations made by tripartite committees (Article ), this practice was officially acknowledged when the Standing Orders concerning representations were last revised in . There is a direct reference to the practice in Article , paragraph , of the Standing Orders concerning representations relating to matters similar to those which have been the subject of a previous representation.35 The practice itself is described in the introductory note to the Standing Orders on the representation procedure.36 In relation to recommendations made by commissions of inquiry (Article of the Constitution), the practice of follow-up by the Committee of Experts has been followed since the first commission of inquiry was set up. It was left to the Committee of Experts to determine when it was no longer necessary for the government to provide information on the matters (or certain of them) examined by the commission of inquiry.37 The procedure of the CFA provides for the examination of the action taken by governments on its recommendations.38 The relevant procedural rules were set forth for the first time in the th report of the CFA.39 At the time, they constituted a response to a paragraph in the resolution concerning trade union rights and their relation to civil liberties, adopted at the th session (June ) of the ILC. In accordance with this resolution, the Governing Body asked the CFA to examine what further measures might be taken to strengthen its procedure and, in particular, to consider arrangements for periodically reviewing the action taken by governments on its recommendations. Under these rules, where Member States have ratified one or more conventions on freedom of association, examination of the legislative aspects of the recommendations adopted by the Governing Body is often referred to the Committee of Experts. The attention of the Committee of Experts is specifically drawn in the concluding paragraph of the CFA’s reports to discrepancies between national laws and practices and the terms of the convention. However, it is made clear in the procedure that such referral does not prevent the CFA
35
Supra note . Supra note , para. . 37 In the case of a complaint concerning the application of Conventions Nos. and , the Commission of Inquiry recommended that the implementation of its recommendations should be followed up by the CFA, which had been examining the matters raised in the complaint over a long period. At the same time, the Commission of Inquiry observed that, within the framework of its regular supervision, the Committee of Experts would continue to examine the legislative aspects involved in respect of Conventions Nos and . 38 See paras – of Annex I of the Digest of the CFA, supra note . 39 See th Report in Official Bulletin, Vol. LV, , Supplement, paras and –. 36
chapter four
from examining the effect given to its recommendations, particularly in view of the nature and urgency of the issues involved. Since its th report (November ), the introduction has highlighted the cases to which the attention of the Committee of Experts has been drawn. The Interpretation of International Labour Conventions As the foregoing40 discussion has indicated, while the supervisory bodies examine the application of ratified conventions in law and in practice, under the terms of Article , paragraph , of the Constitution, the authority to interpret ILO conventions is vested with the International Court of Justice (ICJ). However, paragraph of Article envisages the possibility that the Governing Body may submit rules to the ILC for approval regarding the appointment of a tribunal “for the expeditious determination of any dispute or question relating to the interpretation of a Convention which may be referred thereto by the Governing Body or in accordance with the terms of the Convention”. To date this possibility has not been acted on. An explanation on the issue of interpretation was provided to the Governing Body at its th session (May ). At that time, the Office prepared a study41 with a view to providing the necessary background for a possible detailed examination by the Governing Body of the implementation of Article , paragraph . More specifically, the study reviewed the existing arrangements, including their limitations, under which questions of interpretation have been dealt with in the absence of any recourse to the machinery provided for in the Constitution. It examined whether and to what extent the appointment of the tribunal provided for in Article () could offer a useful additional mechanism and sketched out possible modalities for its institution and functioning. While the Governing Body welcomed the study, it did not come to any decision on the matter. Consultations are again underway to review the question of whether the implementation of this provision is now timely, particularly in light of the growth in specialized tribunals in other fora.
40 See also Chapter , p. , where its was pointed out that general principles of international law relating to the interpretation of treaties, such as those found in the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties apply. The International Labour Office does, however, on request, provide advice and information and opinions on the possible meaning and application of provisions, subject to the caveat regarding the ICJ. 41 See the paper presented to the Governing Body, th Session, May, ILO Doc. No. GB./SC//.
more than years of supervision
Conclusion This examination, albeit brief, demonstrates both the sophistication and complexity of the ILO supervisory system. Its functioning has evolved substantially over the years since it was first established under the Constitution. Its development has been informed by pragmatism shaped by the decisions of the Governing Body and the Conference in giving effect to their responsibility to ensure the smooth and effective functioning of the system. This chapter has highlighted the important role of the Governing Body with regard to all the supervisory procedures, except for the regular supervisory procedure, which is ultimately the responsibility of the Conference. This implies that the Governing Body is able to maintain oversight of the procedures and is in a position to ensure that the necessary linkages and differentiation are maintained. However, the Governing Body has exercised restraint, particularly by leaving it to the supervisory bodies themselves (with the exception of the tripartite committees set up to examine representations under Article ) to determine their methods of work and procedures. It has also developed in the light of decisions taken by the supervisory bodies themselves concerning their methods of work and procedures with a view to adapting the system to changing needs, particularly in relation to the increased workload with conventions and related instruments. It is also important to realize that the ILO supervisory system is a ‘living tree’ and is continuing to develop in response to the heightened awareness of the interaction and potential impacts of ILS with the economic system and globalization.42 Thus the implementation of ILS at a national level can have significant implications and these concerns extend well beyond the more traditional, somewhat abstract, obligation to adopt implementing legislation on ratification. This chapter has not discussed the MLC, and has instead focused on describing the institutional framework and ILO ‘norms’ against which the Convention and its system of compliance and enforcement (including ship certification), discussed elsewhere in the book,43 was adopted. The entry into force of the of the MLC, will provide some challenges for the ILO supervisory system, particularly during the transitional phase when there will be parallel convention reporting obligations operating,44 with increased and differing forms of data being submitted to the Office for consideration, as well as differing kinds of information in the Article forms. However, these developments can only serve to strengthen this well-established system and help ensure its continued 42 43 44
See the discussion in Chapters and . See Chapter on Title . See Chapter on the articles.
chapter four
relevance. The ILO supervisory system has been a model for other international and regional monitoring mechanisms. It has helped countries achieve social progress, and its impact has been far-reaching both in the number of changes countries have made to their legislation and practice but also in defending and upholding rights and promoting the rule of law and governance in States.
PART II
chapter five MAPPING THE TERRAIN: STRUCTURE AND SUBSTANCE IN THE MARITIME LABOUR CONVENTION, 2006
Introduction Part I of this book was primarily concerned with setting the stage for the detailed description and analysis, in Part II, of the content of the MLC, . Part I briefly described the international regime—the legal and institutional framework and background story, particularly in connection with the ILO—against which the text of the MLC, was developed and, finally, adopted. This wider context or ‘back story’ is important from a legal perspective as it provides a deeper understanding of the socio-economic problems that the Convention was expected address—and why a new legal instrument was seen as a solution. It also helps to explain the reasoning behind many of the textual ‘solutions’ that the MLC, contains. The information regarding the development of legal approaches in the ILO since , discussed in Chapter , and the account of the tripartite process in Chapter , are especially relevant to understanding why the MLC, has been described,1 inter alia, as “a marriage of the traditional and the new,”2
1
Of course any description reflects a particular view of history, a continuing validation of the relevance of law, as well as various institutional and other promotional aspirations for an instrument. See Ed Morgan, The Aesthetics of International Law (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, ), pp. –, with respect to a tendency in public international law, in LOSC-related doctrinal pronouncements, in particular, to lay claim to represent the progressive development of the law and much more besides. He argues that: By so situating the text historically between an instant of closure and a wide open process, the reader becomes aware of the momentum generated by international legal discourse, and it is from the dust this non-static phenomenon that the sovereign states emerge as ‘parties’ to the law of the of the sea system. . . . Modern doctrinal pronouncements seem to be positioning themselves as the energy or momentum coming between stasis and motion—that is, as both the potential and fulfilment of the law’s promise. 2 Cleopatra Doumbia-Henry, “The Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention: A marriage of the traditional and the new,” in Le norms internationales du travail: un patrimoine pout lávenir, Melangers en l’honneur de Nicolos Valticos (ILO: Geneva, ), p. .
chapter five
“innovative,”3 and a “veritable accomplishment in international regulatory policy.”4 As explained in Chapter , Part II of this book provides a detailed examination and analysis5 of the text of the MLC, from a legal perspective. Aside from the present chapter and the concluding Chapter , the six chapters that comprise Part II follow the general organization of the provisions of the MLC, . Before moving to examine the substantive content of the MLC, provisions, this chapter considers the structural and other design-related approaches in the MLC, . The term structural elements6 or ‘innovative features’, as they were often described during the process leading to the adoption of the Convention, is used in this chapter to capture a diverse or mixed bag of details of varying import that can be overlooked or often assumed away in legal analysis including, inter alia, – – – – – – – –
organization of the Convention relationship between various parts of the Convention nomenclature and numbering of the Convention format and numbering of the provisions insertion of purpose clauses use and status of the ‘Explanatory Note’ combination of flexibility and consultation use of existing documentation and reporting
These regulatory design-related elements are central to the subsequent legal analysis. They constitute the legal skeleton or underlying framework which shaped the substantive cloth—the text—that was ultimately developed. Put more simply, form and substance are inseparable, and it is impossible to fully appreciate and penetrate the way in which the MLC, is intended to operate
3
Patrick Bolle, Perspectives: “The ILO’s new Convention on maritime labour: An innovative instrument,” () International Labour Review . 4 Peter Payoyo, “The contribution of the ILO Maritime Labour Convention to Global Governance,” in The Future of Ocean Regime-Building: Essays in Tribute to Douglas M. Johnston, Aldo Chircop, Ted L. McDorman, and Susan J. Rolston, eds. (Leiden/Boston: Martinus Nijhoff/Brill, ), – at . 5 As noted in Chapter , this analysis is subject to a caveat. Like any other legal instrument, understandings at the time the Convention was negotiated and the records of these understandings illuminate the text of the instrument and play an important role in the analysis of a text’s ‘meaning’ and, more importantly, what it means for national implementation and application to particular situations. In addition, general principles of international law relating to the interpretation of treaties, such as those found in the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties are also important, with recourse to the International Court of Justice for an authoritative interpretation. Any commentary, including analyses based on the intentions captured in official records, is, at best, explanatory. 6 The term ‘strategic approach’ is used to refer to the multiple socio-economic and human rights objectives of the MLC, and the aspects of structure that help to achieve these objectives.
mapping the terrain
as a legal instrument without first understanding something about its ‘bones’.7 In essence this chapter can be understood as a legal mapping exercise, establishing both the broad parameters of the Convention as well as identifying particular markers in the landscape—the legal terrain—to be traversed in the subsequent chapters. An examination of these structural elements reveals their implications for the design of the future mandatory Article reports8 by countries regarding national implementation of their obligations under the MLC, . These elements also provide an excellent example of international integration and inter-institutional learning and exchange.9 The structural approaches successfully adopted by one UN specialized organization, the International Maritime Organization, were adapted and further developed to meet another institution’s (the ILO) concerns and the specific objectives of the convention in question. A point of particular interest in this chapter is the extent to which concern for these structural elements and the adaption of ‘best practices’ was explicit in the
7 In this respect the MLC, is very much like LOSC and the ‘package deal’ approach which explains the final textual results and the balances struck between the sometimes conflicting interests of the traditional maritime States and the emerging coastal States. As noted by David Anderson, in “Law-making processes in the UN system: Some impressions,” Modern Law of the Sea, Selected Essays (Leiden/Boston: Martinus Nijhoff, ), – at : “At the Law of the Sea Conference . . . [t]here were no clearly defined stages, nor a pre-ordained pattern for the work. There was no basic text at the outset only a list of subjects and issues. . . . On procedure, the way forward was often unclear, so that improvisation was required”. 8 The Article report form for the MLC, can be found in Appendix IV, Reports of the Committee on Legal Issues and International Labour Standards: Second Report: International labour standards and human rights, Governing Body, Geneva, March , ILO Doc. No. GB.// (Rev), pp. –, available at http://www.ilo.org/global/standards/maritimelabour-convention/WCMS_/lang--en/index.htm. See also Chapter for a discussion of the ILO’s supervisory system. 9 See: Moira. L. McConnell, “ ‘Making labour history’ and the Maritime Labour Convention, : Implications for international law-making (and responses to the dynamics of globalization),” in The Future of Ocean Regime-Building: Essays in Tribute to Douglas M. Johnston, Aldo Chircop, Ted L. McDorman, and Susan J. Rolston, eds. (Leiden/Boston: Martinus Nijhoff, ), – at :
The representatives of these shipowner and seafarer organizations also attend and closely follow the IMO meetings and processes, and had an interest in ensuring that labour standards were given the same profile as environmental and safety and security issues. As much as possible, efforts were made to ensure that the two regimes were consistent in approach and avoided uncertainty resulting from conflicting or differing requirements, especially in overlapping areas. In terms of integrating forces in the international system it was really the pressure from these civil society representatives that, far more than governments, perhaps because of the differing composition of delegations to the IMO and the ILO and the related national departmental assignments, that helped to ensure the cross-fertilization of ideas and cooperation to create complementary regimes.
chapter five
preparatory process and official documentation. For example, the report of the Office to the PTMC commented (emphasis added): . In order to achieve the aims established at the start of the exercise, the recommended draft Convention on maritime labour standards has had to embody a number of innovative solutions, which have from time to time prompted questions from Government representatives familiar with the ILO’s traditional Conventions. Many of these novel features for the ILO in fact rely on recognized and accepted approaches in other Conventions in the maritime sector—namely, those of the International Maritime Organization (IMO). This is the case with the general structure of the Convention, its simplified amendment procedure and the system of certification of ships for compliance with the requirements of the Convention. The IMO solutions have not however been imported en bloc in view of the very different constitutional requirements, procedures and philosophy of the ILO (particularly, those inherent in tripartism). In order to understand the reason why a particular innovation has been considered necessary, it is often useful to see the feature in the context of the problem that it is designed to resolve.10
The Structural Problem Chapters and in Part I of this book explored the particular industry problems that the MLC, was expected to address, as well as the overarching ILO objectives related to the role of minimum social and labour conditions in the context of globalization. The strategic response that was adopted to achieve these objectives has been described as a “blend of firmness on rights and flexibility with respects to approaches to implementation of the more technical requirements and because of the advantages it gives to ships of countries that ratify it”.11 Preparing such a comprehensive framework convention presented some difficult but interesting legal and drafting challenges. The chief initial drafting problem lay with developing an organizational structure that could consolidate and update the obligations in the existing conventions, as well as updating and incorporating provisions found in the related recommendations12
10
Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention: Commentary to the Recommended Draft, PTMC, Geneva, – September , ILO Doc. No. PTMC//, available at http://www.ilo .org/public/english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/ptmc/pdf/cmlc-comment.pdf. See also the discussion in Chapter . 11 ILO, “Maritime Labour Convention, , FAQs”, at question , available at http://www.ilo .org/global/standards/maritime-labour-convention/faq/lang–en/index.htm. 12 It is important to appreciate the fact that many of these conventions are associated with recommendations ( in all) that have a specific legal status under the ILO Constitution (see Article ()) but are not per se binding under international law although there is a level of obligation as discussed in Chapter . This will also be discussed in more detail in Chapter in connection
mapping the terrain
that had been adopted since —initially instruments13—on many different topics. Although many of the existing ILO maritime labour conventions were not widely ratified, or had already been revised, they generally represented intensive international tripartite negotiations and final agreement on a minimum standard. From a legal perspective, it was a significant drafting exercise to develop a structure that truly captured the legal principles or rights and standards in existing conventions so as to be viewed as ‘revising’14 them without simply reproducing the substantive text of all the instruments in their entirety. Certainly this was important for conventions that had attracted few ratifications because of the particular wording of the obligation. But eliminating text or adjusting binding obligations to any great degree would also be problematic, particularly for conventions that had achieved a larger number of ratifications. Indeed the ILO Constitution may provide some protection regarding the reduction of existing rights at the national level.15 At the same time, as noted in Chapter , many of these conventions were either not widely ratified or had not come into force.16 Arguably this was because of their level of regulatory detail or the fact that the requirements were outdated and no longer considered up to date by the ILO.17 In addition, many of the conventions adopted with the articles. In essence they contain the even more detailed aspects of the conventions to which they are related which could not be agreed to as binding obligations. The content of many of these recommendations was also to be consolidated in the new convention. 13 The Convention revises conventions (including one protocol) (see Article X) and related recommendations. Initially it had been expected that three other conventions (plus one revising convention adopted in ) might be revised. See Chapter . 14 There is a further specific complexity, as discussed in Chapter on the articles in connection with conventions adopted before , in that that they could not be revised. 15 Constitution of the International Labour Organisation, available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/ english/constq.htm, Art. , para. : In no case shall the adoption of any Convention or Recommendation by the Conference, or the ratification of any Convention by any Member, be deemed to affect any law, award, custom or agreement which ensures more favourable conditions to the workers concerned than those provided for in the Convention or Recommendation. Although this would not necessarily prevent the ILC from adopting a convention that changes a standard that had proved problematic for countries to implement. See also: Chapter , note . 16 For example, the Social Security (Seafarers) Convention, (No. ). 17 As noted in Adoption of an Instrument to Consolidate Maritime Labour Standards, ILC, th (Maritime) Session, Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. Report I(A), available at http://www.ilo.org/ public/english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/rep-i-a.pdf, p. : . Following the conclusions of the Governing Body Working Party on Policy regarding the Revision of Standards, which examined pre- standards, maritime labour Conventions, one Protocol and Recommendations were considered sufficiently up to date and relevant to the industry.10 This body of standards represents a considerable achievement for the protection of the workers concerned and for the industry as a whole. Each of these Conventions retains its intrinsic validity. Some of them have very novel
chapter five
since had been revised, but the parties were not necessarily the same to the revised conventions. Further, some of the conventions had “complex, uncoordinated and overlapping provisions”18 and, more problematically from a structural design perspective, there had been an earlier effort at consolidation19 of the Merchant Shipping Convention (Minimum Standards) Convention, (No. ) and its Protocol () was also to be revised. These two conventions simply appended and incorporated, by reference, the existing text of a list of conventions20 and focused instead on commitments to implement and features, in particular, the Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, (No. ), which, in keeping with the globalized nature of the maritime sector, places responsibility on all countries for ships flying their flag or coming within their territorial jurisdiction. Another is the Seafarers’ Wages, Hours of Work and the Manning of Ships Recommendation, (No. ) (and its predecessor), which contains a procedure for international collective bargaining on the basic minimum wage for able seafarers. [Fn ] ILO: Reports of the Committee on Legal Issues and International Labour Standards: Second report: International labour standards and human rights, Governing Body, rd and th Sessions, Geneva, Nov. and Mar. , GB.// and GB.//; ILO: Report of the Working Party on Policy regarding the Revision of Standards, Governing Body, rd and th Sessions, Geneva, Nov. and Mar. , GB./LILS/(Rev.) and GB./LILS/(Rev.). In fact, many of these conventions are not even listed on an ILO Web site dealing with ratifications. However countries are still legally bound by them. 18 Ibid., para. , p. . 19 See: Merchant Shipping Convention (Minimum Standards) Convention, (No. ), Geneva, October , and Protocol of to the Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, (P), Geneva, October , both available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/ english/convdisp.htm. Another more practical approach to consolidation was also tried with the publication, in and again in (th edition) of an edited and organized collection of the conventions. See para. . and note in Final Report, HLTWG (First Meeting), Geneva, – December , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS /, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/ english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-fr.pdf: The ILO publication Maritime labour Conventions and Recommendations contains the text of Conventions, one Protocol and Recommendations.2 Intended to contribute to the clear and systematic codification of laws on the rights and obligations of seafarers, these instruments have proved to be extremely valuable to the shipping industry. . . . [Fn ] Nine Conventions and six Recommendations are not included because, in the case of the Conventions, they have not received the number of ratifications for entry into force or are no longer open to ratification as a result of the entry into force of a revising Convention. The Recommendations which are not included are not considered to be of current interest. 20
Convention No. , ibid., Art. provides that: Each Member which ratifies this Convention undertakes— (a) to have laws or regulations laying down, for ships registered in its territory—. . . . and to satisfy itself that the provisions of such laws and regulations are substantially equivalent to the Conventions or Articles of Conventions referred to in the
mapping the terrain
enforce.21 In addition the MLC, was expected to develop new obligations related to, inter alia, enforcement of its standards at the shipboard level and to address in more concrete ways other contemporary concerns such as security for shipowners’ liability for seafarers’ repatriation, health care, and abandonment. Appendix to this Convention, in so far as the Member is not otherwise bound to give effect to the Conventions in question; . . .. (e) to verify by inspection or other appropriate means that ships registered in its territory comply with applicable international labour Conventions in force which it has ratified, with the laws and regulations required by subparagraph (a) of this Article and, as may be appropriate under national law, with applicable collective agreements; APPENDIX Minimum Age Convention, (No. ), or Minimum Age (Sea) Convention (Revised), (No. ), or Minimum Age (Sea) Convention, (No. ); Shipowners’ Liability (Sick and Injured Seamen) Convention, (No. ), or Sickness Insurance (Sea) Convention, (No. ), or Medical Care and Sickness Benefits Convention, (No. ); Medical Examination (Seafarers) Convention, (No. ); Prevention of Accidents (Seafarers) Convention, (No. )(Articles and ); Accommodation of Crews Convention (Revised), (No. ); Food and Catering (Ships’ Crews) Convention, (No. ) (Article ); Officers’ Competency Certificates Convention, (No. ) (Articles and ); (Note: In cases where the established licensing system or certification structure of a State would be prejudiced by problems arising from strict adherence to the relevant standards of the Officers’ Competency Certificates Convention, , the principle of substantial equivalence shall be applied so that there will be no conflict with that State’s established arrangements for certification.) Seamen’s Articles of Agreement Convention, (No. ); Repatriation of Seamen Convention, (No. ); Freedom of Association and Protection of the Right to Organise Convention, (No. ); Right to Organise and Collective Bargaining Convention, (No. ). P, ibid., with ratifications as of October , provides in Article that: . Each Member which ratifies this Protocol shall extend the list of Conventions appearing in the Appendix to the principal Convention to include the Conventions in Part A of the Supplementary Appendix and such Conventions listed in Part B of that Appendix as it accepts, if any, in accordance with Article below. . Extension to the Convention listed in Part A of the Supplementary Appendix that is not yet in force shall take effect only when that Convention comes into force. Supplementary Appendix
21
Part A: Accommodation of Crews (Supplementary Provisions) Convention, (No. ) and Seafarers’ Hours of Work and the Manning of Ships Convention, (No. ) Part B: Seafarers’ Identity Documents Convention, (No. ); Workers’ Representatives Convention, (No. ); Health Protection and Medical Care (Seafarers) Convention, (No. ); Repatriation of Seafarers Convention (Revised), (No. ). Although Convention No. is also sometimes described as the first international binding
chapter five
The remainder of this chapter discusses the structural solutions developed to address these problems and begins with an overview of the organization of the Convention and its format. It is notable that, although the Convention was often heatedly negotiated between and , the final text has been described as having “remained true to the principles established in in all respects: substantive content, structure and approach”.22 Organization of the MLC, Overview of the Format The final organizational or structural result23 of the negotiations is authoritatively explained in a unique text, the Explanatory Note to the Regulations and Code of the Maritime Labour Convention (Explanatory Note). Although physically located in the Convention, immediately following the Articles, the Explanatory Note “does not form part of the Maritime Labour Convention, [and] is intended as a general guide to the Convention”.24 It explains that: . The Convention comprises three different but related parts: the Articles, the Regulations and the Code. . The Articles and Regulations set out the core rights and principles and the basic obligations of Members ratifying the Convention. The Articles and Regulations can only be changed by the Conference in the framework of Article of the Constitution of the International Labour Organisation (see Article XIV of the Convention). . The Code contains the details for the implementation of the Regulations. It comprises Part A (mandatory Standards) and Part B (non-mandatory Guidelines). The Code can be amended through the simplified procedure set out in Article XV
articulation of a port State control regime, this is not, in fact, accurate. See Chapter , note , for the history of the port State control regime. 22 Report I(A), supra note , para. . 23 This result will also be discussed in Chapter in connection with the examination of Articles II and VI. 24 See: Appendix of this book, p. , Explanatory Note, para. . See also: Report I(A), supra note , Note (Explanatory note): . The Regulations and the Code begin with the “Explanatory note”, . . . The Explanatory note distils the agreements reached by the HLTWG and adopted by the PTMC concerning the approach and structure of the new Convention and the interrelationship between the Articles, Regulations and the Code and between Part A and Part B of the Code. The Explanatory note is included with the Convention, but indicates, in paragraph , that it should not, from a legal perspective, be considered a part of the Convention. It will have a status similar to that of the Preamble—to assist interpretation. It should also be useful for clarifying a number of matters (such as the treatment to be given to Part B of the Code) for national parliaments considering ratification of the Convention.
mapping the terrain
of the Convention. Since the Code relates to detailed implementation, amendments to it must remain within the general scope of the Articles and Regulations. . The Regulations and the Code are organized into general areas under five Titles: – Title : Minimum requirements for seafarers to work on a ship – Title : Conditions of employment – Title : Accommodation, recreational facilities, food and catering – Title : Health protection, medical care, welfare and social security protection – Title : Compliance and enforcement . Each Title contains groups of provisions relating to a particular right or principle (or enforcement measure in Title ), with connected numbering. The first group in Title , for example, consists of Regulation ., Standard A. and Guideline B. relating to minimum age. . The Convention has three underlying purposes: – to lay down, in its Articles and Regulations, a firm set of rights and principles; – to allow, through the Code, a considerable degree of flexibility in the way Members implement those rights and principles; and – to ensure, through Title , that the rights and principles are properly complied with and enforced.
This concise description, despite its explicit ‘non-status’, was very carefully negotiated text that outlines the structural and conceptual framework under which the existing conventions and related recommendations were consolidated. The organizational structure of the MLC, can be described as a ‘cascade’ of increasing specificity and flexibility and levels of obligation. The articles set out the overarching obligations and rights and principles of the Convention. They are followed by the regulatory provisions (regulations and standards), which contain detailed rights and obligations (under each Title). Finally, the more technical matters are set out in the most flexible part, from a legal perspective, the non-mandatory guidelines in Part B of the Code. Although described as three parts, in terms of the status of the legal obligations, the Convention really only has two parts: the binding provisions (articles, regulations and standards and the related appendix to Part A of the Code) and the non-mandatory ‘due consideration’ provisions (the guidelines and appendix Part B of the Code). This grouping and terminology, particularly the guidelines, differs from earlier ILO instruments. As noted by Payoyo, this combination of legal obligations of varying legal status and degrees of acceptance meant that “. . . in its form the MLC combines both ‘hard law’ and ‘soft law’ formulations and approaches in a single instrument”.25 25
Payoyo, supra note , p. .
chapter five
This hierarchal distinction in ‘status’ between the various levels of the binding provisions (articles and regulations vs the standards in Part A of the Code) relates primarily to differing amendment procedures and to the application of some of the flexibility provisions26 of the Convention. These aspects will be examined in more detail in Chapter on the articles. What is more interesting from an international law perspective is the extent to which the concept of an implicit hierarchy among binding provisions evolved, with more generic statements of principle or rights essentially ‘authorizing’ or defining the scope of more detailed technical provisions. This reflects a common law regulatory approach, with statutes authorizing or delegating authority to adopt or alter regulations on specific matters without an act of parliament. However, in principle in international law, there is no such hierarchy or distinction between binding obligations, irrespective of the approach to amendment. As discussed in Chapter ,27 this hierarchy was created in the Convention with some areas of flexibility expressly provided for matters relating to the detailed Code, which comprises both biding and non-binding provisions. As a result, it appears that that the provisions in the standards, or amendments to those provisions, cannot exceed the rights or obligations stated in the regulation concerned.28 Of course, the wording in regulations that refer to the ‘requirements set out in the Code’29 indicates that the reader needs to look at the Code to establish the content of the obligation in the regulation. Does this wording or the structure of the Convention necessarily mean that that a standard cannot be adopted or interpreted as exceeding the obligation set out in a regulation? Certainly this will be a question to be explored in the future when amendments to the MLC, are considered.30 As discussed in Chapter and explored further in the next section, in connection with the history of the development of its structure, it is notable that the MLC, was initially expected to follow an approach similar to the IMO’s International Convention on Standards of Training Certification and Watchkeeping (STCW) and other conventions. It has different but related parts, moving from the more general to the more specific: articles, regulations, and a twopart code (Part A—mandatory standards, Part B—non-mandatory guidelines). 26
For example, substantial equivalence under Article VI relates only to Part A of the Code, Titles –, and the possibility, under Article II, paragraph , of differing national implementation regimes for ships under GT that do not voyage internationally relates only to the Code. 27 See Chapter , pp. –. 28 But in principle, other than the understandings that evolved in the history of the development of the structure of the Convention, it is not entirely clear why this should be the case. 29 For example, Regulation ., para. . 30 See Ninth Session, Joint IMO/ILO Ad Hoc Expert Working Group on Liability and Compensation Regarding Claims for Death, Personal Injury and Abandonment of Seafarers, Geneva, February , IMO Doc. No. IMO/ILO/WGLCCS /, para. .
mapping the terrain
These move through the spectrum from binding broad statements of principles and rights to highly detailed flexible regulatory requirements and, finally, to guidance, the STCW follows what could be called a lateral or horizontal or a ‘book’ approach with the reader moving through consecutive blocks of text organized by a regulatory approach to legal status. Similarly, as described in its Explanatory Note, the MLC, is organized into articles (Articles I–XVI) with the remaining provisions organized under five Titles (Titles –) comprising the substance of the existing conventions and recommendations and new obligations. Each of these Titles comprises regulations, standards, and guidelines related to various topics, with appendices31 for Title related to the ship inspection obligations and the model documents referenced in the provisions contained in Title (Figure ). However, unlike the IMO conventions, the MLC, has what has been described as a ‘vertically integrated’ format. The regulations and Part A (Standards) and Part B (Guidelines) of the Code have a numbering system that visually and legally links the related regulations, standards and guidelines on a topical basis. Figure offers an example concerning the food and catering provisions in Regulation ., Standard A., and Guideline B.. The early draft MLC, texts that were prepared for consideration by the tripartite meetings to develop the text initially adopted a format based on the ‘horizontal’ structure of STCW and other IMO conventions and framework conventions in other sectors. The vertical approach evolved during the negotiations. In part this was because of a high level of transparency regarding access to the ‘text’, with informal copies of text being circulated electronically among key participant groups preparing for negotiations. This assisted in a tangible claim to ownership of ‘the text’ by ILO constituents. From a negotiating perspective, this level of investment in terms of encouraging support while providing some challenges regarding acceptance of later adjustments to the text, can be seen as ideal. The vertical format reflects a more pragmatic approach to the legal text and seems, on the face of it, to be an improvement over the IMO and other similar models with their extensive annexes. Certainly it is a textual approach that may be easier to read electronically. It also serves the very important substantive function of ensuring that the non-mandatory guidance in Part B of the Code is clearly and visually connected to the mandatory text that it is meant to inform. In the MLC, this particular aspect also has a significant legal meaning for implementation and for the ILO supervisory system. The development of the final form of the Convention is discussed in more detail in the following sections. 31
It is conceivable that future amendments to provisions in other Titles to the Convention might establish additional appendices also linked numerically to the relevant regulations.
chapter five
Figure . Titles and appendices of MLC, Title . Minimum requirements for seafarers to work on a ship Regulation .—Minimum age Regulation .—Medical certificate Regulation .—Training and qualifications Regulation .—Recruitment and placement Title . Conditions of employment Regulation .—Seafarers’ employment agreements Regulation .—Wages Regulation .—Hours of work and hours of rest Regulation .—Entitlement to leave Regulation .—Repatriation Regulation .—Seafarers’ compensation for the ship’s loss or foundering Regulation .—Manning levels Regulation .—Career and skill development and employment opportunities for seafarers Title . Accommodation, recreational facilities, food and catering Regulation .—Accommodation and recreational facilities Regulation .—Food and Catering Title . Health protection, medical care and social security protection Regulation .—Medical care on board ship and ashore Regulation .—Shipowners’ liability Regulation .—Health and safety protection and accident prevention Regulation .—Access to shore-based welfare facilities Regulation .—Social security Title Compliance and Enforcement Introductory paragraphs Regulation .—Flag state responsibilities Regulation .—Port state responsibilities Regulation .—Labour supplying responsibilities Appendix A-I—The working and living conditions of seafarers that must be inspected and approved by the flag State before certifying a ship in accordance with Standard A.., paragraph Appendix A-II—Maritime Labour Certificate; Declaration of Maritime Labour Compliance—Part I; Declaration of Maritime Labour Compliance—Part II; Interim Maritime Labour Certificate Appendix A-III—General areas that are subject to a detailed inspection by an authorized officer in a port of a Member carrying out a port State inspection pursuant to Standard A.. Appendix B-I—Appendix B-I—Example of a national Declaration (Parts I and II)
mapping the terrain
Figure . Example of vertical integration Regulation .—Food and catering Purpose: To ensure that seafarers have access to good quality food and drinking water provided under regulated hygienic conditions . Each Member shall ensure that ships that fly its flag carry on board and serve food and drinking water of appropriate quality, nutritional value and quantity that adequately covers the requirements of the ship and takes into account the differing cultural and religious backgrounds. . Seafarers on board a ship shall be provided with food free of charge during the period of engagement. . Seafarers employed as ships’ cooks with responsibility for food preparation must be trained and qualified for their position on board ship. Standard A.—Food and catering . Each Member shall adopt laws and regulations or other measures to provide minimum standards for the quantity and quality of food and drinking water and for the catering standards that apply to meals provided to seafarers on ships that fly its flag, and shall undertake educational activities to promote awareness and implementation of the standards referred to in this paragraph. . Each Member shall ensure that ships that fly its flag meet the following minimum standards: a) food and drinking water supplies, having regard to the number of seafarers on board, their religious requirements and cultural practices as they pertain to food, and the duration and nature of the voyage, shall be suitable in respect of quantity, nutritional value, quality and variety; b) the organization and equipment of the catering department shall be such as to permit the provision to the seafarers of adequate, varied and nutritious meals prepared and served in hygienic conditions; and c) catering staff shall be properly trained or instructed for their positions. . Shipowners shall ensure that seafarers who are engaged as ships’ cooks are trained, qualified and found competent for the position in accordance with requirements set out in the laws and regulations of the Member concerned. . The requirements under paragraph of this Standard shall include a completion of a training course approved or recognized by the competent authority, which covers practical cookery, food and personal hygiene, food storage, stock control, and environmental protection and catering health and safety. . On ships operating with a prescribed manning of less than ten which, by virtue of the size of the crew or the trading pattern, may not be required by the competent authority to carry a fully qualified cook, anyone processing food in the galley shall be trained or instructed in areas including food and personal hygiene as well as handling and storage of food on board ship. . In circumstances of exceptional necessity, the competent authority may issue a dispensation permitting a non-fully qualified cook to serve in a specified ship for a specified limited period, until the next convenient port of call or for a period not exceeding one month, provided that the person to whom the dispensation is issued is trained or instructed in areas including food and personal hygiene as well as handling and storage of food on board ship.
chapter five
. In accordance with the ongoing compliance procedures under Title , the competent authority shall require that frequent documented inspections be carried out on board ships, by or under the authority of the master, with respect to: a) supplies of food and drinking water; b) all spaces and equipment used for the storage and handling of food and drinking water; and c) galley and other equipment for the preparation and service of meals. . No seafarer under the age of shall be employed or engaged or work as a ship’s cook. Guideline B .—Food and catering Guideline B..—Inspection, education, research and publication . The competent authority should, in cooperation with other relevant agencies and organizations, collect up-to-date information on nutrition and on methods of purchasing, storing, preserving, cooking and serving food, with special reference to the requirements of catering on board a ship. This information should be made available, free of charge or at reasonable cost, to manufacturers of and traders in ships’ food supplies and equipment, masters, stewards and cooks, and to shipowners’ and seafarers’ organizations concerned. Appropriate forms of publicity, such as manuals, brochures, posters, charts or advertisements in trade journals, should be used for this purpose. . The competent authority should issue recommendations to avoid wastage of food, facilitate the maintenance of a proper standard of hygiene, and ensure the maximum practicable convenience in working arrangements. . The competent authority should work with relevant agencies and organizations to develop educational materials and on-board information concerning methods of ensuring proper food supply and catering services. . The competent authority should work in close cooperation with the shipowners’ and seafarers’ organizations concerned and with national or local authorities dealing with questions of food and health, and may where necessary utilize the services of such authorities. Guideline B ..—Ships’ cooks . Seafarers should only be qualified as ships’ cooks if they have: a) served at sea for a minimum period to be prescribed by the competent authority, which could be varied to take into account existing relevant qualifications or experience; b) passed an examination prescribed by the competent authority or passed an equivalent examination at an approved training course for cooks. . The prescribed examination may be conducted and certificates granted either directly by the competent authority or, subject to its control, by an approved school for the training of cooks. . The competent authority should provide for the recognition, where appropriate, of certificates of qualification as ships’ cooks issued by other Members, which have ratified this Convention or the Certification of Ships’ Cooks Convention, (No. ), or other approved body.
mapping the terrain
The Development of the Structure This section provides an account of the history of the development of the final format of the MLC, text. While to some extent this is inseparable from the story recounted in Chapter and the decisions on substantive content, the focus of this chapter, and this section in particular, is to describe the development of its form and the way in which particular legal concerns and drafting problems related to organization and structure, including matters such as numbering and terminology, were considered and addressed over time. The content of the Convention will grow or develop beyond the text adopted in . Essentially, the current organization and format was settled when the integrated or vertical format and the text of the Explanatory Note was developed and agreed to by the HLTWG in and subsequently adopted by the PTMC, also in . This following account does not attempt to document every step in the development of the text in the formative period –. Rather, it identifies key decision points in the commentaries in the working papers and other documents prepared throughout this period. Other important decisions relating to substance during the entire period – are considered in Chapter on the development of the Convention and in the following chapters dealing with the substantive aspects of the Convention’s provisions. The Initial Approach— As explained in Chapters and , the foundation for the MLC, was essentially an industry agreement, the Geneva Accord, which set out an agreement between the international representatives of shipowners and seafarers on the need for a framework convention with a new approach that focused on effectiveness and ensuring widespread ratification.32 The March 33 report
32
As noted in the Office Report prepared for the th ILC in , supra note , p. , Part II. In terms of format, it is of interest to note that the JMC considered a report, Review of relevant ILO maritime instruments (JMC, th Session, Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. JMC/// , available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/jmc/jmc-r.pdf), which set out three possible options with respect to the revision of the maritime labour instruments: limiting revision to seven outdated instruments; consolidating and updating the up-todate conventions in a new framework convention; and consolidating several conventions into four or five framework conventions covering major subject areas. The JMC adopted the second option; in fact, the framework convention, the MLC, , also revises several ‘outdated’ conventions. 33 Report of the th Session of the Joint Maritime Commission (Geneva, – January ), Governing Body, th Session, Geneva, March , ILO Doc. No. GB./(Corr.).
chapter five
to the th Session of the ILO’s Governing Body on that historic January meeting of the JMC records that: Review of relevant ILO maritime instruments . The Commission, under this item discussed the significance and impact of maritime labour standards. It agreed that many of the existing ILO maritime labour instruments were outdated, deficient and not reflective of modern practices; those which were up to date and pertinent were not sufficiently ratified. It concluded that the best way forward in line with the integrated approach approved by the Governing Body at its th Session (November ) was the adoption of a single “framework” instrument which would consolidate the existing body of ILO maritime Conventions and Recommendations.
This Session also called on the Governing Body to establish the HLTWG to develop the text of this new framework convention, which was to be adopted in at the tenth Maritime Session of the ILC.34 The Office, building upon the analysis of maritime and other labour standards carried out in the late s, prepared two key policy papers35 for the first meeting of the HLTWG in December . The Briefing Document recited the background to the meeting and the problems that a new framework instrument should help address. It also contained eight ‘preferred solutions’ identified by the shipowners and seafarers at the JMC (see Chapter , Figure , at p. ).36 These solutions comprised a mix of substantive objectives and recommendations as to structure and format. The second document, a Working Paper prepared for the meeting taking these solutions as a starting point, noted, “it would be desirable for thought to be given, at the earliest possible stage, to the form 34
Ibid., para. . The HLTWG, and a Subgroup that was also approved, was to meet three times, in , , and . As noted in Chapter , it had a fourth meeting in , along with several Subgroup meetings, working group meetings, meetings of the Officers of the HLTWG, the PTMC (), and an Intersessional Meeting (). Although one document suggests it would have been the twelfth Maritime Session, it appears that it was the tenth. See: Briefing Note, HLTWG (First Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS /, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-fr.pdf, paras . and . (NB: the document itself is not titled; however, this is the title given to it in the Final Report of the meeting, supra note , and in the second document, a working paper, provided to the meeting, which is also untitled (Working Paper, HLTWG (First Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS /). 35 Briefing Note and Working Paper, ibid. The International Shipowners’ Federation (ISF) also submitted a paper explaining the apparent anomaly of an employer seeking more regulation and the concerns that led it to support the Geneva Accord. See: ISF, ISF Submission to the ILO High Level Tripartite Working Group on Maritime Labour Standards, – December , p. (on file with the co-authors). See discussion at Final Report, supra note , paras and . 36 See Chapter . Briefing Note, supra note , para. ..
mapping the terrain
that such an instrument might take”.37 Interestingly, and reflecting perhaps the degree of open-mindedness of both the Office and constituents, the Working Paper begins with a proposal that might be seen as so obvious it is not even open 37 See also the discussion in Chapter . Working Paper, supra note , para. . This paper also posed several questions regarding key issues that could also affect structure, including:
. From the conclusions of the Working Party referred to in paragraph above and from proposals of the Joint Maritime Commission, it would appear that out of the maritime labour Conventions, one Protocol and of the Recommendations are sufficiently up to date and relevant to the industry. The volume of provisions to be included in the new instrument will be reduced, once provisions on the same subject are discarded or merged. Some cases, however, will have two or more overlapping provisions, one of which establishes a higher standard. The two Conventions referred to in paragraph above are an example of this. In such cases, should the instrument include only the higher standard? Perhaps ideally it should. But several countries may have ratified the Convention containing the lower standard. Indeed the lower standard may be contained in an old Convention with perhaps parties, and the higher standard may form part of one which has only just entered into force with the minimum number of ratifications. It may be assumed that if the higher standard alone is included, this could considerably delay the entry into force of the new instrument or at least impair its general applicability. Is this a reasonable assumption? If it is, what kind of flexibility might be provided for in order to enable ratification by countries which at present have a lower standard of protection? Might the following options be considered? – an option not to accept one or more of the annexes (see paragraph above) at the time of ratification? One possibility, as far as the annexes are concerned, would be to require ratifying Members to have laws and regulations that are “substantially equivalent”. This latter concept, used in Convention No. . . . has been interpreted to mean that national laws and regulations could be different in detail, but that the States should undertake to ensure that the general goals are achieved; or: – an option not to accept, at the time of ratification, one or more Parts of the instrument and the corresponding annex(es)? or: – an option, restricted to Members that are parties to a Convention with a lower standard, enabling them to replace the relevant provision of the instrument with the corresponding provision providing for a lower standard? This might, however, increase the complexity of the instrument. If options of this kind were provided for, they could be made subject to conditions designed to pave the way for full acceptance of the instrument. Governments exercising one or other of the options (in consultation with their social partners) might be required to: – give effect to the higher standard in so far as conditions permitted; – move as quickly as possible to renunciation of the option concerned; and – report regularly on progress made with regard to these two aspects. Would the existence of options significantly facilitate ratification of the instrument by countries whose legislation only provides for the lower standard? Would any advantage in this respect be outweighed by a possible disincentive regarding ratification of the new instrument by Members which are already at the higher standard?
chapter five
to question—the proposition that a new instrument, whatever its final structure or format, would take the legal form of an international labour convention, with all that this implies.38 Equally interesting, in light of the many innovations that were developed, only the concept of a rapid amendment procedure was explicitly foreseen at this early stage,39 although a significant innovation, from an ILO perspective, the Article XIII, Special Tripartite Committee, was foreshadowed.40 The Working Paper contains a preliminary ‘sketch’ for a possible structure for the Convention. In retrospect, this proposal appears highly complex and chiefly concerned with the legal problems posed by the consolidation of so many existing conventions and recommendations and responding to the structural suggestions in the ‘preferred solutions’. Despite this complexity, elements of what would be the final structure can be detected. For example, it was initially proposed that a five-part instrument could be developed, possibly with options regarding ratification of some annexes. This approach, although not stated as such, would be similar to that found in the IMO’s International Convention on the Prevention of Pollution from Ships, , as amended (MARPOL)41 with its mix of obligatory and optional annexes. Simply described, the five-part concept was envisaged as beginning with an overarching ‘principles and rights’ part. The balance of the convention (four parts) would be organized in topical ‘families’ of conventions/provisions comprising a mix of mandatory and non-mandatory provisions and annexes. The concept was explained in the Working Paper as follows: . Part I of the instrument might be a statement of fundamental principles and rights at work, those contained in maritime Conventions and perhaps those in other relevant international labour Conventions. This Part would also set out the responsibilities of the parties with respect to the inspection of ships, including those registered elsewhere. . . . Each of the remaining Parts would be devoted to a particular “family” of principles and rights; for example, one such Part might deal with social security matters. . Each Part, from Part II onwards, would have an annex, setting out detailed requirements for implementation of the principles and rights in the Part concerned (see point of the “preferred solutions”). It would essentially contain the more detailed provisions of the Conventions concerned. These details could be amended through simplified procedures of the kind mentioned above (see paragraph onwards). These procedures might be set out in the “final clauses” of the instrument.
38
Working Paper, ibid., para. . The proposition is advanced in connection with the Constitution of the ILO and the procedures under Article for adoption by an International Labour Conference. This already establishes a direct connection to the ILO’s supervisory system. 39 Ibid., para. . 40 Ibid., para. . 41 Supra note .
mapping the terrain
. The final clauses would also contain the usual provisions, perhaps with some adjustments, in order to avoid any duplication in the implementation of the new instrument with respect to existing Conventions ratified by the Member concerned, and, in order to preserve the “capital” of ratifications that has already been built up, by ensuring that obligations under existing Conventions remain fully in force until they are replaced for the Member concerned by equivalent or higher standards under the new instrument. . The Parts and annexes of the instrument would be binding on Members ratifying it. At the time of ratification, it might be possible for a Member not to agree to be immediately bound by particular Parts or annexes. There would be an additional component, reflecting the provisions of existing international labour Recommendations and other material, such as codes of practice (see point of the “preferred solutions”). This component would not have mandatory force. . Thus the substance of existing Conventions and Recommendations might be rationalized and consolidated in a single instrument covering five areas: Binding Part I: Fundamental principles and rights Parts II to ??: Substantive principles of families of Conventions “Final clauses” Annexes: Parts II to ??: Details plus simplified amendment procedure Non-binding Other provisions: Recommendations, codes of practice and guidelines.42
Even though the terminology and other elements changed, some aspects of the initial approach are retained in the final text, particularly the idea of a first part or section with ‘principles and rights’. However, as pointed out in a paper43 prepared for a subsequent meeting, it proved to be difficult to identify principles or rights per se in the many conventions that were being consolidated. The final content of that section (later to become simply the ‘articles’) may have been influenced by the structural approach in IMO conventions with their essentially standardized format that starts with articles setting out basic definitions and general State-level obligations relating to implementation and enforcement and other technical generic legal matters, such as amendments and requirements for entry into force, that exist for every convention. As discussed in Chapter , the influential first meeting of the HLTWG essentially set the course for the text that was finally adopted. The Final Report of that meeting, perhaps unusually for such an international meeting, contained a useful appendix, described simply as ‘Chairperson’s Summary’, setting out, in point form, the various matters on which there appeared to be consensus. Given the influence of this first meeting and the extent to which the IMO conventions are explicitly recorded as being relevant to considerations of form, as well 42
Working Paper, supra note . The Structure of the New Instrument: Allocation between Principles and Details, HLTWG (First Meeting), ILO Doc. Geneva, , No. STWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/ public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/stwgmls/stwgmls-.pdf, para. .
43
chapter five
as views on what would be become lynchpin substantive approaches (e.g., ‘substantial equivalence,’ ‘no more favourable treatment,’ port State control, and the concepts of ‘inflexibility on rights’ and ‘flexibility on approach’ and the ‘level playing field’), Figure below sets out this part of the Chairperson’s Summary in full.44 This informal record of agreed concepts and approaches at the beginning of a process that would continue for more than five years of international meetings is remarkable for both its prescience and its clarity. It provides evidence for the assertion in the report of the Office to the th ILC in that the “proposed consolidated maritime labour Convention has remained true to the principles established in in all respects: substantive content, structure and approach”.45
44
Final Report, supra note , Appendix. See also the discussion in Chapter text at note . The meeting (and Chairperson’s Summary) also established a detailed work plan and agenda for the meeting of the Subgroup in , a meeting that would focus mainly on structure. Substantive matters for initial consideration . The development of a draft programme of work . . . . Recommendations on the content of a draft framework instrument In making these recommendations, the subgroup will: (a) give proper consideration to the following solutions that have been agreed on a tripartite basis: . . . [the preferred solutions] (b) give proper consideration in a maritime context to the essential aspects of Decent Work, the components of which are: . Human rights at work. . Employment and incomes. . Social protection and social security. . Social dialogue. (c) give proper consideration to the contents of this summary; (d) perform the following tasks: . Preparation of preliminary draft provisions relating to: (i) enforcement mechanisms; and (ii) simplified procedures for rapid amendment of the annexes to the instrument. . For the purposes of consolidation, the identification of “families” for the Parts and the selection of instruments on which work should begin; . Development of the main elements of the instrument, including: (i) identifying where existing provisions overlap or conflict and making appropriate recommendations; and (ii) recommending the allocation of provisions as between mandatory and non-binding components; . Arrangements for gathering information and ideas for these and other questions. 45 Report I(A), supra note , Part II, Commentary, para. . It is notable that the same Chairperson, Mr. Jean Marc Schindler, remained throughout the process.
mapping the terrain
Figure . Chairperson’s summary (emphasis added) Preliminary thoughts on the various issues The wide-ranging discussion indicated the following points to be taken into account in elaborating the proposed new instrument: – there was overall support for the proposed general structure of the new instrument: – the structure is reflected in paragraph of the Office working paper and an example of one possible model is illustrated in the annex to the ISF submission; – the importance of a definition chapter was emphasized; – the new instrument should be clearly based on the existing body of ILO standards: – the capital consisting of existing rights, updated where necessary, should be faithfully preserved without prejudice to the need for innovation; – the provisions of existing ILO instruments should be taken as a starting point; – consistency with other ILO standards as well as those of other organizations, in particular the IMO, was considered essential; – IMO Conventions should be closely reviewed as a source of inspiration; – modifications of IMO solutions may be suggested where appropriate; – the instrument should set out standards that are clear, simple, easy to ratify and easy to implement: – the respective roles and responsibilities of flag States, port States and labour-supplying States should be clearly defined; – due account should be taken of the special features of the maritime sector, in particular the different existing registers, the multinational character of crews and the difficulties of implementation that small countries and small ports may face; – duplication should be avoided; – linking respect for the instrument with registration should be studied; – many observations were made stressing the importance of effective enforcement mechanisms: – both flag States and port States should be responsible for enforcement; – the principle of “no more favourable treatment” was supported; – consideration should be given to the appropriateness of the following enforcement mechanisms, inter alia: – extension of port state control as provided for in Convention No. and strengthening of related remedial measures; – the IMO “panel of competent persons” (there were however drawbacks that would need to be studied); – obligation on Members to submit their enforcement procedures for review at the time of ratification; – integration into IMO instruments such as the ISM Code or creation of similar mechanisms could be explored; – creation of a database for violation of social rights;
chapter five
– the availability of assistance from the International Labour Office, when needed, was considered essential; – there was full agreement on the need for simplified amendment procedures: – several speakers favoured a tacit acceptance procedure; – there should be a specific maritime tripartite body charged with continuously reviewing the operation of the instrument to ensure rapid updating; – the instrument should be: – inflexible with respect to rights; – flexible with respect to implementation; – the principal consideration should be the achievement and maintenance of a level playing field; – a balance sheet should be drawn up of the advantages and disadvantages of the following flexibility devices: – options concerning the provisions to be accepted – particularly the detailed annexes; – a period of transition for Members which are not immediately in a position to accept the highest standards; – “substantial equivalence”
First Concepts and Drafts—– The first meeting of the HLTWG Subgroup (STWGMLS) took place in June ,46 six months after the first HLTWG; the second HLTWG meeting was held in mid-October 47 and second Subgroup meeting in February .48 Between the two Subgroup meetings essential ground-breaking conceptual and ‘sorting’ work was undertaken to develop “a single, coherent international maritime labour standard incorporating, as far as possible, the substance of all the various international maritime labour standards that are sufficiently up to date”.49 As well as questions of form to be addressed, as noted in the Chairperson’s Summary (above at Figure ), studies50 were undertaken on specific substantive issues such as the rapid amendment procedure and ratifications needed to be taken into account in the organizational structure. In short, the Office, 46
Report, Tripartite Subgroup of the HLTWG (First Meeting), Geneva, – June , ILO Doc. No. STWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/ techmeet/stwgmls/stwgmls-r.pdf. 47 Final Report, HLTWG (Second Meeting), Geneva, – October , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/ twgmls/twgmls-r.pdf. 48 Final Report, Tripartite Subgroup of the HLTWG (Second Meeting), Geneva, – February , ILO Doc. No. STWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/ sector/techmeet/stwgmls/stwgmls-.pdf. 49 Report, supra note , para. . The final text revised almost all of the instruments adopted since . 50 A list of all () studies and working papers on the issues up to October is set out in the Appendix, List of documents concerning HLTWG, supra note , pp. –.
mapping the terrain
HLTWG, and the Subgroup faced an enormous and complex legal drafting challenge to be addressed within a relatively short time frame.51 The Working Paper prepared for the Subgroup meeting, The structure of the new instrument: Allocation between principles and details, offers the first organizational effort.52 It reflects the careful, almost tentative, wording and strategic approach adopted. It strove to find a line between developing a more “radical approach”53 to the text while at the same time not reducing existing protections or appearing to threaten the well-established foundation provided by the existing ILO standards. The Working Paper, although abbreviated, is an important document in terms of the conceptual approach ultimately adopted. It explained, first, that it “elaborates on two of the solutions: that ‘the consolidated instrument’ should consist of a number of Parts setting out the key principles of international maritime labour standards” and, second, that those parts “should be complemented by Annexes setting out detailed requirements for each of the Parts”.54 While this seems a fairly straightforward exercise, as the Paper points out, a review of the ILO conventions established that they mainly comprised detailed standards on specific technical issues of application (e.g., measurements for sleeping rooms on ships) rather than statements of principle or rights. Specifically, it pointed out, it might be difficult to get agreement on the criteria for demarcation between detail and principle and, second, as noted above, a preliminary review showed that few provisions actually appear as principles.55 The Working Paper explicitly proposed adopting what is described as a ‘pragmatic approach’, which was illustrated with an appendix containing an extract from the hypothetical ‘Promoting of Leisure at Sea Convention’.56 Although the organizational description is extremely complex, it laid the foundation for what would ultimately become a cascade approach, with provisions ranging from general or generic to the specific and increasing flexibility as provisions become more detailed. The Working Paper explained the approach as follows: . A pragmatic approach on the following lines appears preferable: the drafters of the new instrument would first examine the substance of the “family” of Conventions 51 Compare, for example, the more than a decade of negotiations in the Third United Nations Conference on the Law of the Sea to consolidate the international law of the sea in LOSC. The time frame is especially short when deadlines for translation and circulation of papers in advance to allow delegates to prepare are considered. 52 Structure of the New Instrument, supra note . 53 ISF Submission, supra note , p. . 54 Structure of the New Instrument, supra note , para. . 55 Ibid., para. . 56 Ibid., para. and Appendix A.
chapter five
to be included in a particular Part, rather than the wording used, and agreed on the key principles that flow from the Conventions concerned. They would then draft the respective Part of the new instrument on the basis of the principles that have been identified and applying the following criteria, which are derived from the rationale for the simplified amendment procedure, referred to in paragraph above: (a) the provisions of the Parts would be drafted in terms that are sufficiently general and comprehensive as to be likely to obviate the need for any amendment or additions over the coming decades; (b) at the same time, the text of the Parts would be sufficiently specific with respect to the intentions of the International Labour Conference and the objectives to be achieved, so as to provide clear parameters for each implementing provision to be included in the Annex and for any future amendments of those provisions. . The Annexes would contain more or less the same text as that contained in the existing Conventions to which they relate, with the deletion of any material that coincides with the provisions of the Part concerned in the first place. . . . . . . . The Preamble is an important element for making clear the general intention behind the provisions. . . . 57
The Subgroup considered this proposal and illustrative example and reached agreement on a proposal for structure which, although differing in terminology and presentation, is very close to the form the Convention now takes. In addition, there was explicit consideration of the approach adopted in the IMO’s MARPOL (emphasis added): . The Subgroup agreed that the consolidated Convention should consist of the following four levels: – Articles of the Convention; – regulations covering the basic rights and principles in each “family” of subjects; – rules setting out the details for the implementation of the regulations; – non-mandatory Recommendations. The Subgroup requested the Office to prepare a preliminary draft of such a Convention, leaving out definitions and scope of application, which were to be the subject of a separate paper, and only providing a sketch of the possible recommendations, which would include the details of rules that could appropriately be in this non-mandatory section. . The Seafarer spokesperson recommended that the Office produce the structure, the rights, rules and regulations and the flow of them. He suggested this draft prepared by the Office be submitted to the High-level Tripartite Working Group in October. As well, he requested that all of the rights and rules attached to them be mandatory as a whole package without options. The Seafarers had an open mind as to whether or not the simplified amendment procedure should be applicable to rights. 57
Ibid., paras , , and .
mapping the terrain
. The Government spokesperson suggested a comparison between this proposed structure of the new Convention and the MARPOL Convention. In that Convention some sections were compulsory and others optional. He noted that something similar could be adopted with a view to facilitating the rapid ratification of the new Convention. The Government group discussed the Korean proposal to use a Convention structure similar to that used in the IMO MARPOL Convention. Following that structure, the Articles and regulations would be incorporated in the Convention and the rules and recommendations would be in annexes, some of which would be compulsory for all parties to the Convention, others would be optional. The proposal received a large measure of support. It was considered that such a structure could be helpful to facilitate the rapid ratification of the Convention.58
As a result of the advice provided by the Subgroup meeting, a first ‘cut’ at allocation, the “preliminary draft for a consolidated maritime labour convention”,59 was produced for the second HLTWG meeting in October . The following edited extract from the table of contents is included for illustrative purposes. It does not contain any provisions drawn from recommendations (only existing binding provisions). However, it shows that the draft text already had established an approach, which begins with articles and is followed by five parts, with a list of regulations for each part (family of provisions) followed by specific ‘rules’ for each part. The Articles Definitions and scope of application Fundamental principles and rights Regulations and Rules; Recommendations Entry into force and denunciation Depositary functions Amendment Authoritative languages Part I. Prerequisites for going to sea and related provisions Regulation .. Minimum age Regulation .. Medical certification Regulation .. Certification of competency and qualification Regulation .. Safety, health, welfare and training Regulation .. Public and private recruitment and placement services Regulation .. Seafarers’ identity document
58
Report, supra note , paras –. First Preliminary Draft of Provisions for the New Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention, HLTWG (Second Meeting), Geneva, – October , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS// , available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls- .pdf.
59
chapter five Rules for Part I Rule .. Minimum age A. General B. Work at night C. Hazardous work D. Enforcement Rule .. Medical certification A. General B. Medical certification of young persons C. Delegation D. Transitional provision Rule .. Certification of competency and qualification ... Part II. Conditions of employment and manning Regulation .. Contracts of employment and articles of agreement Regulation .. Termination of contracts Regulation .. Wages Regulation .. Annual leave Regulation .. Record of employment Regulation .. Continuity of employment Regulation .. Repatriation Regulation .. Manning of vessels Rules for Part II ... Part III. Working and living conditions Regulation .. Accommodation Regulation .. Food and catering Regulation .. Health and safety and accident prevention Regulation .. Medical care on board ship and ashore Regulation .. Welfare on board and ashore Rules for Part III ... Part IV. Social security Regulation .. General principles Regulation .. Medical care Regulation .. Sickness benefit Regulation .. Unemployment benefit Regulation .. Old-age benefit
mapping the terrain
Regulation .. Employment injury benefit Regulation .. Family benefit Regulation .. Maternity benefit Regulation .. Invalidity benefit Regulation .. Survivors’ benefit Regulation .. Shipowners’ liability Part V. Enforcement Regulation .. Flag state responsibilities General Inspection and control Certification Record-keeping Quality control Internal resolution of grievances Marine casualties Regulation .. Port state responsibilities General Inspection and control Facilities available to seafarers Regulation .. Responsibilities of States of domicile or contract General Enforcement through contracts of employment
As the foregoing extract indicates, although there was some rearrangement among the groupings and structural adjustments over the next year, many of the organizational elements and allocation of provisions was already in place just over ten months after the first meeting. The Government, Shipowners’, and Seafarers’ Groups generally agreed on the structural approach based on four levels. However, there were still significant differences in their views about the approach in the preliminary draft and its content. The Government Group was generally in agreement with the consolidation: His Group agreed with a four-layered approach with Articles, Regulations, Rules and Recommendations. Terms could vary but the first three would be binding and the last one non-binding. The Rules and the Recommendations would be the equivalent of Codes A and B in the IMO’s STCW Convention. Some in his group favoured the MARPOL approach of “pick and choose” upon ratification. However, flexibility should not erode impact. Articles should be amended through an explicit amendment procedure. Tacit amendment could be envisaged for levels and , and possibly also level , provided that there was no back-door introduction of principles which were outside the scope of the Articles.60
The Shipowners’ Group was also generally supportive of the preliminary draft text but had concerns about some specific points and the short time frame and process for developing the text. Surprisingly, the Seafarers’s Group, while 60
Final Report, supra note , para. .
chapter five
agreeing with some aspects, expressed serious misgivings about what appeared to be an unwieldy document. Their spokesperson noted the complexity of the proposed instrument and voiced what would become an oft repeated concern: the convention needed to be clear, easy to understand, and not simply a consolidation of existing instruments.61 Commenting on the Seafarers’ Group ‘radical’ ‘package’ submission62 on structure and other issues submitted to encourage ratification, improve seafarers’ on-board conditions, and eradicate substandard shipping, the Seafarer spokesperson noted: [The Convention] should constitute a real and unambiguous Seafarers’ Bill of Rights, making decent work a reality on all ships. He advised that the Seafarers were proposing a radical approach, which was a package, and which would remove a lot of the prescriptive details. Regarding the structure of the future instrument, the first layer would be the Articles. The second layer, the Regulations, should consist of the principles and rights of seafarers. The rest of the instrument should comprise a mandatory Part A and a recommendatory Part B. He agreed that large portions of existing Conventions might need to be left out in order to have a coherent, modern and clear text.63
It is a point of no small interest that it was the Seafarers’ Group that called for an instrument that omitted a significant amount of prescriptive detail and portions of existing conventions. This call for an approach based on a “seafarers’ bill of rights”64 became a recurrent theme as they pushed for a modern and 61
Ibid., para. . ITF Submission to the High-level Tripartite Working Group on Maritime Labour Standards, HLTWG (Second Meeting), Geneva, , available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/ dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-.pdf. While this chapter is in a sense ‘unbundling’ the package and isolating the structural elements, it is important to realize that the inherently substantive implications of allocation decisions and amendment procedures were consciously considered and balanced or traded in this package. 63 Final Report, supra note , para. . 64 ITF Submission, supra note , para. : 62
. It has been notable that the idea of a framework Convention that consolidates all the existing ILO maritime Conventions has attracted wide support. However, there have been a number of caveats, the most important of which relates to demands for flexibility, for less prescriptive details to be included and for the impediments which currently prevent widespread ratification of the existing instruments to be removed. These considerations and the proposed new structure will ensure that the new instrument will be very different from the current maritime Conventions, both in style and in content. It was against this background that the Seafarers’ group adopted the “Seafarers’ Bill of Rights” approach, which would establish a number of unambiguous rights and principles, which would be strictly implemented, and link the negotiating process to the ILO decent work programme. The Seafarers’ group has stressed the importance of the inclusion of enhanced enforcement mechanisms which ensure implementation, the inclusion of a novel amendment process, which would draw on previous experience, and the potential problems widespread ratification can cause in updating existing international instruments, which are all prerequisites for establishing a new regime.
mapping the terrain
effective convention. It is clear from these preliminary comments and the Seafarers’ submission that they were concerned that the final text might be a large and probably unratifiable instrument with no real change or progress in achieving their objectives: putting labour and social conditions on the same level, from an enforcement perspective, as environmental protection and ship safety.65 The Seafarers’ Group also proposed a four-level structure that was clearly and explicitly influenced by the structural ‘hierarchy’66 of provisions and regulatory approach in IMO conventions. It also introduced the phrasing referencing the concept of linking the levels by indicating that the details were to be found in the Code. . The Seafarers’ group is broadly in agreement with the new proposed structure which we have noted is similar to that found in the revised STCW Convention. That being the case, the Articles should establish the format and set out the legal basis of the new instrument and also address a number of general administrative issues. The regulations should consist of the principles and rights which are found in the existing ILO maritime instruments, including, where appropriate, other ILO instruments, as is the case in ILO Convention No. . The rights and principles should merely set out the rights and principles and leave Part A and Part B of the Code to develop them. A possible example, using the right to repatriation, might be: Seafarers shall, in accordance with the relevant sections of the Code, be entitled to repatriation at no expense to themselves. The mandatory Part A of the Code should build on the rights or principles and establish the functional requirements which must be met and, wherever possible, leave the prescriptive and more detailed provisions to the recommendatory Part B of the Code. However, it is clear that some of the measures can be more readily addressed using this approach than others, where there will be a need for 65
Ibid., para. : . We have previously stressed the need for widespread ratification of the new instrument and that the end result should provide an international minimum standard, comparable to the technical and environmental standards established by the IMO, which addresses the social dimension. In doing so it will address the decent work deficit which was identified as an urgent issue by the May Meeting of Experts on Working and Living Conditions of Seafarers on board Ships in International Registers which recognized that conditions of employment, social protection, social security and social dialogue, including collective bargaining, are matters that require particular attention. That means that the new instrument should make a difference to those employed on ships and provide a tool which will complement the efforts being made to eliminate substandard shipping and establish a benchmark for entry into and participation in international shipping.
66 The preliminary draft also referred extensively to ‘the Rules’, but the regulations and rules were often indistinguishable in terms of detail. In addition, the regulations were sometimes unclear as to their relationship with the rules and the party to whom they were directed, for example, “. The Rules shall cover the design of the document, as well as procedures for its issue and for the verification of the data contained in it, with the object, in particular, . . .”.
chapter five
more detailed specifications in Part A if the rights and principles are to be made meaningful and readily enforceable. . This approach has implications for the amendment process . . . [and] suggests the following: – Articles—revision by a Maritime Labour Conference and requiring express ratification (as is the case now for new and revised ILO instruments). If the new instrument is to be amenable to change, the provisions in the Articles should be kept to a minimum as experience within the IMO has shown that if they are too detailed they can limit the further elaboration of the instrument in the future. – Regulations or rights and principles—revision by a Maritime Labour Conference with the possibility of using the tacit amendment procedure. – Parts A and B of the Code—amendment by a new tripartite maritime committee and endorsement by a plenary session of a general International Labour Conference and entry into force through tacit acceptance. . The new structure and style is likely to be less prescriptive and will be more flexible as to how the established rights and principles are actually delivered, the key being that the rights and principles are actually delivered and make a difference to those on board ships. . . . . The “Seafarers’ Bill of Rights” approach has implications for the future organization of the work of the HLWG and clearly requires the distillation of the rights and principles from the existing ILO maritime instruments and the formulation of the functional requirements to give effect to them, rather than cutting and pasting the existing text. The interlinkage between the rights and principles and the more detailed functional requirements which give effect to them need to be developed within the same body. . . . 67 (emphasis added)
The HLTWG meeting also considered a proposal by a government whereby the inspection system could be part of the IMO-related International Safety Management (ISM) Code, which the Seafarers’ Group vehemently opposed.68 67 68
ITF Submission, supra note , paras – and . Final Report, supra note , para. : . Regarding the enforcement issues, the Seafarer spokesperson indicated that his group strongly supported the concept of linking flag State inspection with the issuance of a certificate, based on a labour inspection, but could not support the inclusion of working conditions within the ISM Code which he felt was primarily self-regulation. The Seafarers wanted certified compliance rather than certification of the procedures. The fact that many member States did not sufficiently act after having received complaints indicated the necessity to define an appropriate complaints system. The so-called MARPOL-type approach would, according to the Seafarers, undermine the whole process, whilst the exclusion of certain groups of seafarers working on certain ships was clearly unacceptable and would be incompatible with the Declaration of Philadelphia and would be akin to institutionalizing a system of maritime apartheid. On the other hand, an examination of the scope of application on a case-by-case basis for each family of detailed requirements could be an alternative way forward. The Seafarers, whilst agreeable to the substantial equivalence concept, suggested that guidance on the interpretation of this concept should be provided in the new text. In conclusion, the Seafarer spokesperson underlined the
mapping the terrain
Ultimately, on the question of structure, the HLTWG is recorded only as having “decided to use the terminology suggested by the secretariat with some modifications: the terms used will include Articles (level ), Regulations (level ), Code, Part A (level ) and Code, Part B (level )”.69 In addition, to expedite the work on the text the Shipowners’ and Seafarers’ Groups produced the Joint paper by the Shipowners’ and Seafarers’ groups on the principles to be embodied in the consolidated Convention.70 This Paper is especially of interest in connection with the later development of the ‘purpose clause’. importance of looking for the identification of objective criteria which would permit verification, since the inspection of social conditions, as opposed to safety defects, was said to be more difficult to perform correctly, however, the Seafarers believed that the difficulties were over-stated. The interest of having a Bill of Rights would be that breaches of social regulations should lead to detention of a ship, just as is the case for safety considerations. The Seafarer spokesperson also indicated that his group was ready to work together with the Shipowners during part of the group meetings, if need be, to define clearly principles and rights. Otherwise, it was clear that the plenary was the only place to take decisions. 69 70
Ibid., para. . Final Report, supra note , Annex , pp. –. The Paper sets out the following principles: Articles of the Convention Level : Fundamental principles and rights All seafarers shall have the rights flowing from the following core Conventions: Freedom of Association (C. ) Right to Organise and Collective Bargaining (C. ) Discrimination (C. and C.) Child Labour (C. and C. ) Forced Labour (C. and C.) [NB: The above list of general instruments applying to seafarers is not exhaustive.] Level : Specific principles and seafarers’ rights Member States have the responsibility to ensure that seafarers shall have safe and decent working and living conditions which fully take into account the following specific principles and rights, which shall be applied by reference to the detailed regulations and rules: Part I: Prerequisites for going to sea and related provisions Minimum age—No under age person shall be engaged in a ship. Medical examination—All seafarers shall be certified medically fit for service at sea. Certificates of competency—No person shall be engaged on board a vessel to perform any duty unless he/she is certified to be competent or qualified to perform such duties. Training—All seafarers shall have the opportunity to benefit from appropriate national provisions and facilities for vocational training. Recruitment and placement—All seafarers shall have access to an efficient, adequate and regulated system for finding employment without charge.
chapter five
Given the concerns expressed by the Seafarers’ Group it is to be expected that the draft prepared for the second Subgroup meeting in February would be markedly different from the text prepared for the HLTWG meeting in October
Identity documents1—All seafarers shall have a seafarers’ identity document. [1 To be covered by a stand-alone Convention.] Part II: Conditions of employment Articles of agreement—All seafarers shall sign articles of agreement, which shall incorporate an agreed written and enforceable contract setting out the terms and conditions of employment incorporating any applicable collective bargaining agreement. [Equality All seafarers shall have the right to equal remuneration for work of equal value without discrimination.] Wages—All seafarers shall on a regular basis be paid their agreed wage and any other agreed remuneration such as overtime. Hours of work—As for other workers, the normal hours of work for all seafarers, shall be regulated. Annual leave—All seafarers shall have paid annual leave in addition to public holidays. Continuity of employment2—All seafarers shall benefit from the national policy that encourages continuous or regular employment at sea. Repatriation—All seafarers shall be repatriated at no cost to themselves. Crewing—All ships shall be sufficiently, safely and efficiently crewed. [2 Shipowners wish to shift this to Part IV (Social security).] Part III: Working and living conditions Accommodation—All seafarers shall be entitled to decent accommodation and such other facilities as may be necessary. Food and catering—All seafarers shall have, free of charge, a supply of sufficient food of good quality, and catering arrangements designed to secure their health and wellbeing. Health and safety and accident prevention—All seafarers shall live, work and train in a safe and hygienic environment and be represented on any on-board safety committee. Medical care—All seafarers shall be provided with occupational health protection and prompt medical and emergency dental care at no cost to the seafarer whilst engaged on a ship. Welfare on board and ashore—All seafarers shall be provided with adequate welfare facilities and services both on board and in port and shall have the right to shore leave. Part IV: Social security Social security—All seafarers and where applicable their dependants shall be provided with social security including social insurance no less favourable than that provided for [seafarers and] shoreworkers [in the flag State]. [Part V: Rules on enforcement Complaints procedure—All seafarers or their representative shall have easy access to an independent complaints procedure in the flag State.
mapping the terrain
. The text71 contained some elements such as changing the terminology of ‘rules’ to ‘sections’. Roman numerals were used for specific matters located within a section and linked to alpha-numeric headings that in turn were linked the part of the Code, e.g., Section A.—Minimum age, I. General. It also still contained the concept that the regulations ‘direct’ what would be the Code provisions: . The minimum age shall be specified in the Code by reference to the following requirements: (a) the specified age shall correspond to the age at which a person can be deemed to be physically and mentally fit for work on a vessel and to be no longer in need of full-time schooling; (b) the age at the time of the initial entry into force of this Convention shall be years. (CA) . The Code shall specify a higher age for particular types of work when required by the nature of that work, especially for— . . .. . The Code may specify ages lower than those referred to . . . 72
The Office Commentary73 attempted to defend the lengthy text and this approach in Titles – and the legal concerns that were seen as needing to be addressed: Comment (on Regulation .; Section A.) As explained in Comment above, under Level of amendment, this preliminary draft adopts the approach, favoured by the Shipowners’ and Seafarers’ representatives, of having the basic principles of the Convention expressed in concise statements. Where necessary, however, these statements are accompanied by provisions containing directions as to the nature and scope of future amendments of the Code by tacit acceptance. Provisions of this kind are often contained in Acts of Parliament as a means of controlling the scope of subsidiary legislation. Although these provisions in the Regulations may often duplicate the detailed provisions of the Code, these or equivalent provisions are essential in order to provide the necessary legal authority for the amendment of the Code by the proposed simplified procedure. In the present case, the directions in paragraphs to of Regulation . are in fact exceptionally long because of its importance. The Convention would, in effect, be giving Governments authority to change the minimum ages Port state control—All seafarers or their representative shall have easy access to an independent complaints procedure in the port State. Access to justice—All seafarers or their representative shall have the right to easy access to the legal system in the flag State, labour-supplying State and the port State.] 71 Preliminary Draft for a Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention, Tripartite Subgroup of the HLTWG (Second Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. STWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/stwgmls/stwgmls-r.pdf. 72 Ibid, p. . 73 Ibid., Annex.
chapter five fixed in it without going back to their Parliaments on a matter involving both the fundamental rights of the child and the possible postponement of a young person’s right to take on a particular job. The directions proposed here would, in particular, state the rationales for setting the ages concerned (see paragraphs (a) and ), thus limiting any modifications considered necessary in the future to fairly precise circumstances. Thus, the essence of any such modifications would already have been approved by national Parliaments prior to ratification of the new Convention.
In light of the subsequent development of the text it is difficult to see exactly what the concern was, however, the net effect was a lengthy draft, which was viewed with serious concern by the Subgroup.74 The Office, presumably foreseeing this reaction, produced the Informal paper supplementing the preliminary draft for a Convention on maritime labour standards75 for the meeting. It proposed an approach that would streamline and move many of the provisions now in Part A to Part B. Importantly this paper also raised what would later become a very important practical question relating in part to the legal status (allocation) of the provisions: What was to be inspected and by whom? The Paper commented (emphasis added): . It was recognized in the commentary on the preliminary draft that further work would be needed to meet the objective of the widespread ratification of the new Convention in the shortest possible time. Indeed, if the new Convention took the precise form of the preliminary draft, it might be difficult for national parliaments to find time even to study the instrument, let alone approve its provisions. There were however indications of an appropriate way forward in the High-level Group last October: namely, the transfer of some of the details in Part A of the Code to Part B. In its general comment at the start of the commentary on the preliminary draft, the Office has therefore suggested that provisions in Part A that are not essential from the point of view of the Decent Work Agenda or to maintain a level playing field could be transferred to Part B, provided that Part A 74
Final Report, supra note , see for example, para. : . In a joint submission to the meeting (STWGMLS/), the Shipowners’ and Seafarers’ groups, while commending the Office for preparing such a comprehensive and detailed preliminary draft for a Convention, expressed serious concerns on a number of aspects concerning the work expected of the Subgroup and the means of refining and finalizing the texts of the Convention during the coming months. Due to the late circulation of the draft texts, many Government representatives were unlikely to have had sufficient time to carry out adequate consultations with their colleagues in other departments. The two groups also regretted that the preliminary draft had not made suggestions on a redistribution of provisions between the mandatory Part A of the Code and the non-mandatory Part B. They noted that the Office had not had time to propose the necessary simplification of existing provisions. They put forward proposals for streamlining discussions and ensuring that the outcome was fully in line with the objective of achieving a simple, up-to-date, clear and, most importantly, enforceable new Convention. . . .
75
Ibid., Annex .
mapping the terrain
is sufficiently comprehensive: it must cover all aspects of implementation that are necessary to enable proper verification by the flag State and the port State and under the international supervisory procedures. This coverage should be expressed in mandatory terms, even if they might sometimes be of a general character. The Office has requested the Subgroup’s advice on, inter alia, how an approach of this kind might be applied with respect to concrete provisions of the preliminary draft. . The purpose of the present addendum is to assist the Subgroup’s discussions on this point by presenting an illustration [using repatriation] . . .. . In the illustration the Office has sought to achieve the following objectives: – make the provisions [on repatriation] easier to ratify by removing the detailed prescriptions from the mandatory provisions; – avoid any consequent weakening of existing standards by ensuring that the general provisions have the same scope as the detailed provisions that they would replace; and – ensure that the general provisions in Part A, read in conjunction with the detailed (nonbinding) provisions in Part B, are sufficiently clear as to enable national inspectors and the international supervisory bodies to assess whether or not Members are respecting their obligations under the Convention.76
The suggestions in this informal paper were supported by the meeting. The Shipowners’ and Seafarers’ Groups, concerned that a focus in Title solely on social security would create barriers to ratification or mean that the ‘pick and choose’ ratification option would be required to obtain ratification, also jointly proposed a reorganization of several areas from Title to Title combined with a renaming of Title .77 This is an excellent example of a strategic approach to use the structure to achieve substantive objectives. Their Joint Paper provided that: The Shipowners’ and Seafarers’ Groups note that the Office draft of Title is based largely on the provisions of ILO Convention No. . This Convention contains obligations which are not currently accepted by any significant maritime nation. Therefore, if the current draft is maintained, the new Convention is likely to attract few ratifications. In order to avoid such a situation arising, the social partners propose that an alternative approach is adopted to Title . Joint proposal . Title should be renamed as “Health Protection, Welfare, Medical Care and Social Security Protection”. . The relevant provisions dealing with health protection, welfare and medical care should be transferred from Title to Title . Title would then only cover all matters concerning crew accommodation and catering arrangements. 76
Ibid., p. . Ibid., Annex : Title . Social security. Joint submission by the Shipowners’ and Seafarers’ groups, p. . See also Chapter text at note . 77
chapter five . However, Title would deal with shipowners’ liability for sick and injured seafarers, payment of sick pay, social security protection, the provision of medical care and attention on board and ashore and other related issues. . The detailed provisions dealing with specific state social security services, e.g. old-age benefits, etc., should be removed from Title . . The relevant provisions currently in Title which deal with “General principles” concerning state social security protection (which are taken from Convention No. ) are, however, to be retained in Title . . Consideration could then be given to whether there were any significant provisions affecting health, welfare, medical care and social security protection which have been omitted from the text and which ought to be provided for in some way. . At the end of this process, Title would include provisions dealing with, among other things: (i) shipowners’ liability for sick and injured seafarers; (ii) medical care on board and ashore; (iii) accident prevention; (iv) welfare on board and ashore; (v) general principles concerning social security protection. . Central to addressing these aspects will be to agree on a suitable balance between the various sections of the Convention. . The social partners appreciate that this proposal might create difficulties with regard to the status of Convention No. once the new Convention is adopted. Nevertheless, the proposal would allow for the identification of one specific “family” of provisions within one title, and the advantages of this approach are considered to outweigh the disadvantages.
This approach was adopted in the final text of the Convention. Further, it is probably in large part a result of this timely ‘structural’ intervention that the social security obligations (albeit modified) in connection with the Social Security (Seafarers) Convention (Revised,) (No. ) were retained at all in text. The Subgroup meeting concluded with a call for a “rewriting” of the Convention and a plea: . The spokespersons and many other speakers were concerned regarding the timing of future work. They felt that internal ILO procedures were impeding the facilitation of work on the new instrument. In particular, that the Office had six weeks to do the work of rewriting the Convention, taking into consideration everything discussed this week for the next high level meeting, while it would take weeks to complete the paperwork including translation and printing. They were concerned by the large disparity in time and made a plea to those responsible for the office documents and translation services to devote the necessary resources that would render the work in a more realistic timeframe and would enable more time to be devoted to rewriting the Convention.78 78
Final Report, supra note .
mapping the terrain
A ‘Seafarers Bill of Rights’: Reduction and Reformation—– In the -week period for document preparation between the February Subgroup meeting and the third HLTWG meeting in June , the Convention was substantially reformed and the text reassigned and reduced.79 In addition, some strategic changes to terminology and other elements were added to capture ideas such as the ‘seafarers’ bill of rights’ that had arisen at the prior meetings. Perhaps, most interesting, was what may have seemed a radical shift to physically repackage the Convention format as three ‘books’ with new terminology: the articles and regulations;80 Code, Part A;81 and Code, Part B.82 This presentation format—three books—while ultimately not retained, proved to be a useful approach to give concrete expression to the idea of the differing nature of the levels of obligation. It facilitated consideration of the specific areas83 and captured the essence of the idea of a Code with technical, mainly shipboard, provisions, especially in Title .84 The Office Commentary explained:
79 The Office devoted additional resources and established a five-person external drafting team combining legal expertise and experts provided by the shipowners’ and seafarers’ organizations to reorganize the text in a very short time frame. 80 Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention (First Draft) Articles and Regulations, HLTWG (Third Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/ public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-r-.pdf. 81 Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention (First Draft) Code, Part A, HLTWG (Third Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/ english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-r-.pdf. 82 Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention (First Draft) Code, Part B, HLTWG (Third Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/ english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-r-.pdf. 83 Although the seafarers still expressed concern that that text was still not simple or clear, the official record of the meeting (Final Report, HLTWG (Third Meeting), Geneva, June– July , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/ dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-r-.pdf) indicates that the debate was focused on substance rather than format and structure. During this meeting a Government Group concern about the precise status of Part B provisions surfaced as did issues relating to the question of a tonnage limitation and definition of seafarer and the nature of the national obligations to consult/social dialogue when exercising flexibility. The use of square brackets [ ] was also introduced in this draft to indicate alternative wording or otherwise unresolved text. In fact the use of format and bracketing during negotiation including adding ‘squiggly’ brackets { } to focus debate and, even later in the process (at the PTMC in ), the ‘blank-out’ of entire areas of controversial text is itself an interesting aspect of the negotiation process to develop the text. See also the discussion in Chapter . 84 Initially it was imagined that the inspectors would use the ‘Code’ while legislators would be more concerned with the articles and regulations (personal reflection of the author).
chapter five General At the meeting in February the Subgroup identified a number of concerns and provided guidance on the further development of the draft text. An important point of concern identified by the Subgroup was the complexity and length of the preliminary draft, which embodied the actual text of all provisions of existing maritime labour instruments that appeared to be still relevant today. The length and, in some cases, the overlapping provisions as well as the more traditional legal formal style made it difficult to read. This created a barrier to adoption and implementation by governments and to the social partners in identifying rights and standards. It was felt that the preliminary draft did not clearly provide a statement of the core employment rights of seafarers. Adoption of a “plain language” drafting approach was recommended as well as inclusion of simple-purpose statements for the Regulations. Another point of concern related to the need indicated in the High-level Group at its last meeting to transfer some of the more highly detailed technical provisions from the mandatory to the non-mandatory part of the Convention. These details, taken from existing Conventions, were considered as partly responsible for inhibiting ratifications. The Subgroup emphasized the importance of the Office adopting a radical approach in this respect, without however compromising the general substance of existing mandatory standards. There were suggestions that some parts of the Convention would be more useful to the constituents if they were presented as separate publications on specific technical matters. It was also suggested that the Convention would be more readable if it were presented in separate parts reflecting the different levels of obligation under the Convention. The present “first draft”, does not itself always reproduce the wording of existing relevant maritime labour standards, but seeks to distil the essence of the obligations and rights contained in them in order to develop a text that will be possible for all Members to ratify and implement. In accordance with the guidance provided to the Office, this first draft is presented in the following three documents, which together would make up the Convention: . Articles and Regulations (in document TWGMLS//)—These would set out the core rights, principles and obligations in the Convention. They could only be changed by the General Conference in the framework of Article of the ILO Constitution. The Regulations are divided into five general areas: – Title : Minimum requirements for seafarers to work on a ship. – Title : Conditions of employment and crewing. – Title : Accommodation, welfare facilities, food and catering. – Title : Health protection, welfare, medical care and social security protection. – Title : Compliance and enforcement. . The Code—This is a two-part document, Parts A and B, which could be amended either by the General Conference, in the framework of Article of the ILO Constitution, or by a simplified amendment procedure described in Article XV of the Convention. The simplified procedure responds to the concern for more rapid and less costly updating of the detailed require-
mapping the terrain
ments for implementing the rights, principles and obligations under the Articles and Regulations. The Code is presented in two documents comprising: – Code, Part A, Standards (in document TWGMLS//)—This part would contain mandatory minimum standards for the implementation of the Regulations. It follows the same five-part division of topic areas as the Regulations and is numbered in the same way as the Regulations to ensure ease of reference. – Code, Part B, Guidelines (in document TWGMLS//)—This part would contain detailed guidelines, as well as recommendations and model documents. Although these would not be binding, Members would be required to take them into account and consider them when implementing the Standards. This part of the Code also follows the same five-part division of topic areas. Accordingly, in order to review, as a whole, the first set of provisions proposed for Title , for example, the reviewer would need to look at: – Regulation ., in document TWGMLS//; – Standard A., in document TWGMLS//; and – Guideline B., in document TWGMLS//. The Articles dealing with the core rights, Members’ obligations, matters relating to the scope of the Convention and procedures for entry into force and amendment, including a proposed Special Tripartite Committee, at the start of the draft Convention, can be regarded as at an advanced state given the comprehensive discussions of the High-level Group and the Subgroup. The substantive content of the Regulations is also well developed, on the basis of a document submitted to the High-level Group at its second meeting and of discussions in the Subgroup. . . . Square brackets [ ] have been placed in the text around points requiring further discussion before a proposal is made by the Office.85
In addition to the significant expansion of the text in the Preamble, there was a new Article IV with significant reformulation of the ‘rights’, including, importantly, the introduction of a new title of Article IV, Seafarers’ employment rights. In the prior draft (February ), Article III, Fundamental principles and rights, had provided: . Each Member shall ensure, within the limits of its jurisdiction and in accordance with the standards required by the provisions of this Convention – (a) that all ships are covered by the safety standards, including standards of competency, hours of work and manning, that are necessary to ensure the safety of life on board ship;
85
Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention (First Draft) Commentary, HLTWG (Third Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/ english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-r-.pdf, pp. –.
chapter five
(b) that all seafarers enjoy— (i) fair terms of employment; (ii) decent shipboard conditions of employment and shipboard living arrangements; and (iii) appropriate social security and welfare measures for themselves and their families, in full respect for the fundamental principles and rights referred to in paragraph above. . The rights referred to in paragraph (b) above shall be secured through laws and regulations in so far as they are not covered by collective agreements or laid down by competent courts in a manner equally binding on the shipowners and seafarers concerned. (CA(a))
The June reformulation provided, as a new Article IV, Seafarers’ employment rights, that: . Every seafarer has the right to a safe and secure workplace that complies with safety standards, including standards of competency, training, hours of rest and work and crewing levels that are necessary to ensure the safety of life on board ship. . Every seafarer has a right to fair terms of employment. . Every seafarer has a right to decent shipboard conditions of employment and shipboard living arrangements. . Every seafarer has a right to health, medical and appropriate social security and welfare measures for themselves and their families. . Each Member shall ensure, within the limits of its jurisdiction, that the minimum seafarers’ rights set out in this Article are fully implemented, in accordance with the provisions of this Convention, in national laws and regulations or applicable collective bargaining agreements or practice.
This reformulation, by isolating the provisions and using a rhetorical device (Anaphora) combined with an explicit heading,86 provided an emphatic and clear list of ‘every seafarers’ rights, including the obligation on States to ensure implementation of these rights. This change, which was essentially a change in format, directly responded to the call by the Seafarers’ Group for a new convention that was a clear and unambiguous ‘seafarers’ bill of rights’. Irrespective of its heading, this article, combined with Article V, is the most general statement of principles and rights and States’ obligations that are elaborated under Titles –. These articles are also considered as the beginning of the cascade of obligations. Another important development, which was later transformed into the use of an explanation located in the instrument but not forming part of the legal text, was directed at States and intended to provide information and guidance on the role of particular provisions. At the beginning of both Parts A and B of 86
The name of this article was subsequently modified, consistent with the content of paragraph of Article IV, to read ‘Seafarers’ employment and social rights’.
mapping the terrain
the Code, a one-page explanation of the content of each Part and the provisions, now called ‘Standards’ (in Part A) and ‘Guidelines’ (in Part B), was inserted. This change in terminology87 probably caused some challenges for the ILO’s drafting practices. As discussed in Chapter , normally, the term ‘standards’ or standardsetting is used to describe the ILO’s ‘law-making’ activities, which includes the adoption of conventions and recommendations in accordance with its Constitution, as international labour standards.88 The use of the term ‘standard’ in the MLC, is intended to indicate a more applied technical provision rather than a wider statement of principles or rights, and has no other constitutional or legal meaning. Likewise the term ‘guideline’ was simply meant, as the extract from the Commentary indicates, to convey the non-mandatory nature of Part B of the Code. The latter term generated questions that were discussed in a formal opinion from the ILO’s Legal Adviser on the status of Part B. Although substantive in nature, the opinion also relates to structure. Given the extent of debate and the relationship to the future content of the Article reports to the ILO supervisory system,89 Figure sets out the opinion in full. Figure . Legal Adviser’s opinion on the status of Part B of the Code90 Coexistence of mandatory and non-mandatory provisions in a Convention Questions were addressed to the Legal Adviser by the government representatives of the Netherlands and Denmark, as well as of Cyprus and Norway, as to the various consequences flowing from the co-existence in the draft consolidated Convention of binding and non-binding provisions for ratifying Members. The High-level Tripartite Working Group on Maritime Labour Standards is, in accordance with its mandate, working on a consolidated Convention as a new type of instrument compared with those adopted up to now. The consolidation of maritime instruments in force is aimed at placing all substantive elements in 87 This usage essentially moved these provisions of the new instrument outside the more usual dichotomy of convention and recommendation, which has particular consequences under Article the ILO Constitution. Given the four-level hierarchical approach in the new instrument this was, perhaps, necessary. Certainly the question of terminology, whether it be descriptors such as ‘section’ or ‘rule’, had clearly been a matter of internal debate. The use of the terms ‘standards’ and ‘guidelines’, which seemingly were easily accepted by the meeting participants, may have reflected the fact that they were familiar terminology in connection with the IMO’s STCW Convention. 88 See: ILO, Office of the Legal Adviser, The Manual for Drafting ILO Instruments, nd edition (Geneva: International Labour Office, ) (online interactive version), available at http://www .ilo.org/public/english/bureau/leg/man.pdf, section .. 89 See discussion of these reports in Chapters and . 90 Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention (Preliminary Second Draft), Commentary, HLTWG (Fourth Meeting), Nantes, , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS /, available at http:// www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-r-.pdf, Annex.
chapter five
a single instrument in an approach radically different to that employed up to now, where Conventions contain detailed technical provisions, often accompanied by recommendations. From this perspective, conclusions cannot be drawn from the traditional formal arrangement based on the distinction between a Convention— where the provisions are binding—and a Recommendation—where they are not. The future instrument is a Convention open to ratification by States Members providing explicitly for the coexistence of binding and non-binding provisions (draft Article VI, paragraph ). The provisions of Part A of the code would be binding, those of Part B not. Some international labour Conventions set out, alongside binding provisions, others that are of a different nature.1 The novelty introduced in the future instrument essentially resides in the great number of non-binding provisions in the instrument. It should equally be noted that other organizations such as the IMO have adopted conventions containing the two types of provisions without any apparent legal problems in their application. Members ratifying the Convention would have to conform to the obligations set out in the Articles, the regulations and part A of the code. Their only obligation under part B of the code would be to examine in good faith to what extent they would give effect to such provisions in order to implement the Articles, regulations and Part A of the code. Members would be free to adopt measures different from those in Part B of the code so long as the obligations set out elsewhere in the instrument were respected. Any State Member which decided to implement the measures and procedures set out in Part B of the code would be presumed to have properly implemented the corresponding provisions of the binding parts of the instrument. A Member which chose to employ other measures and procedures would, if necessary particularly where the Member’s application of the Convention was questioned in the supervisory machinery, have to provide justification that the measures taken by it did indeed enable it to properly implement the binding provisions concerned. July Loic Picard Legal Adviser 1 See, for example, the Occupational Health Services Convention, , Article , paragraph : “. . . Occupational health services should be multidisciplinary”.
Ultimately, this opinion resulted in an agreement91 regarding the practical implications for inspection of Part B provisions, which views them as similar to, but distinct from, the traditional ILO recommendations. Both terms (standards and guidelines) would, however, have been familiar to the maritime constituents attending the meetings concerning the STCW Convention. In fact, 91
See the discussion in Chapter on the articles regarding the definition of ‘requirements of this Convention’ and regarding Article VI.
mapping the terrain
the explanation at the beginning of Part A of the Code explicitly references this influence in explaining the content (emphasis added): Mandatory Standards for implementing the Regulations of the maritime labour Convention, . This part of the Code contains mandatory provisions that set out in greater detail the standards required to be maintained by Members in order to give full and complete effect to the Convention. (modified STCW Annex , Part A, ) . Where there is no specific standard provided in the Code the applicable Regulation and any applicable Article in the Convention constitute the standard. . When implementing the standards Members are encouraged to take into account the guidelines in Code B for further detailed guidance on effective implementation of their responsibility to protect seafarers’ employment rights.92 Guidelines to assist in implementing the Regulations and Standards of the maritime labour Convention . This part of the Code contains Guidelines to be considered by Members as providing guidance or models or examples of best practice when implementing their obligations under the Convention to protect seafarers’ employment rights.93
Notably, this draft text also introduced what was to be the new form of the name of the Convention, describing it as ‘the maritime labour convention ’ although the official Working Paper that contained the text still referred to the ‘consolidated maritime labour convention’. In response to the seafarers’ call for a clear and simple statement of the rights, which any seafarer could read, the new draft text introduced a ‘plain language’ purpose clause under each regulation.94 For example, Regulation .—Minimum age Purpose: To ensure that no under-age persons work on a ship . No person below the minimum age shall be engaged, employed or work on a hip. . The minimum age at the time of the initial entry into force of this Convention is years. (modified CA) . A higher minimum age shall be required in the circumstances set out in the Code.
92
Consolidated First Draft Code (Part A), supra note . Consolidated First Draft Code (Part B), supra note . 94 This reflects the view that the Convention’s coverage should be clearly stated and easily accessible by the workers it was intended to benefit. 93
chapter five Regulation .—Medical certificate Purpose: To ensure that all seafarers are medically fit . Seafarers shall not work on a ship unless they are certified to be medically fit to perform their duties. (modified C.A/). . Exceptions can only be permitted as prescribed in the Code.
As mentioned above, these clauses were clearly influenced by the Joint Submission of the Seafarers’ and Shipowners’ Groups extrapolating the core or minimum rights or principles for each matter.95 As the foregoing extract also evidences, the phrase in the regulations referencing ‘the Code’ shifted to more closely reflect the approach advocated in the seafarers’ submission96 of October . The Office’s Commentary explained: Comments on the Regulations and the Code Comment (General remarks on Titles to ) . Structure. As explained in Comment (point ) above, this draft adopts the approach, favoured by the Shipowner and Seafarer representatives, of having the basic employment rights and principles of the Convention expressed in concise statements including a simple statement of the purpose of each Regulation. In addition the terminology has been changed to more clearly delineate the nature of the Part A and Part B requirements. Part A provisions, which are mandatory, are called Standards. Part B provisions which are not binding are called Guidelines. A numbering system has been adopted which facilitates easier cross-referencing between the Regulations and the Code provisions. There is a Regulation that corresponds to every Code provision. However, where no additional text was proposed in order to elaborate on the obligation, there may be no Code A or Code B provision. . Relationship between Part A and Part B. Some provisions proposed in the first draft may still be too detailed or specific; in other cases, on the other hand, this first draft may be considered as insufficiently specific. As indicated above, the Office’s intention has been to move as much detail or specificity away from the Regulations to Code A and away from Code A to Code B, subject to the following two overriding considerations: (a) as far as the Regulations are concerned, it is important to ensure (as explained in comment above) that Government representatives agree that there is sufficient direction provided in the Regulations to support the simplified amendment procedures for the Code’s provisions; (b) in order to avoid any dilution of existing international labour standards where detailed requirements are moved from Part A to Part B of the Code, it appears equally important to ensure that Part A of the 95 Final Report, supra note , Annex : Joint paper by the Shipowners’ and Seafarers’ groups on the principles to be embodied in the consolidated Convention, pp. –. 96 ITF Submission, supra note .
mapping the terrain
Code, in principle, retains a general obligation adequately reflecting those requirements.
The June HLTWG meeting concluded with the view that “a meeting of the Officers of the High-level Group in September would give further indications to the Office in order to prepare the draft to be discussed in the High-level Group’s next meeting in Nantes in January ”.97 Further written comments98 on the draft text from participants were invited and considered by the Officers’ meeting. In addition, during this period, the text was prepared for the Officers’ meeting in both the ‘book’ or horizontal form and the ‘vertically integrated’ format it later assumed.99 On the latter point, the Commentary for the fourth HLTWG in explained: . In order to facilitate discussion in this respect, the preliminary second draft has been produced in a “vertical form” with the provisions concerning each principle or right grouped together. This should help participants to discuss the balance between: (a) the Regulations, laying down the basic principles and rights and intended to set the parameters to be approved by national Parliaments in the ratification process; (b) Part A of the Code, setting out the detailed obligations for the implementation of those principles and rights; and (c) Part B of the Code providing non-mandatory guidance on the scope of those obligations and on their implementation in practice. . The views of the High-level Group would be welcome on whether the final version of the Convention should be in this vertical form or should return to the “horizontal” arrangement, setting out all the Regulations first, followed by all the Standards in Part A followed by the Guidelines in Part B of the Code. 97 98
Final Report, supra note , para. . As reported at the fourth meeting of the HLTWG, supra note , at footnote : At the High-level Group’s last meeting it was agreed that constituents could submit comments to the Office on the first draft which would be taken into account in preparing the next draft. A preliminary draft and the comments would then be reviewed by the Officers in September and the text revised in light of that meeting for the High-level Group in January . Comments were received from: the Shipowners’ and Seafarers’ representatives and the representatives of Algeria, Bahamas, Cuba, Denmark, France, Germany, Honduras, Japan, Republic of Korea, Liberia, Mexico, Netherlands, Norway, United Kingdom and the United States of America and the International Maritime Organization (IMO), and also from the International Christian Maritime Association and the International Maritime Health Association.
99 This is based on internal informal documents on file with the author. The informal advisory status of the Officers’ meetings means there are no formal official records of these meetings or working documents. It is the authors’ recollection that the ‘integrated vertical’ format was prepared by Dr. Dierk Lindemann, Spokesperson for the Shipowners’ Group, for their internal deliberations. It was proposed as a much easier way to read the Convention. This approach moved in a very practical way beyond the earlier approach in the Office proposals and the existing ILO and IMO conventions.
chapter five
The fourth HLTWG meeting in Nantes had not been planned for or budgeted, however, there were many still key points of substance on which agreement had not been reached. The fourth meeting proceeded on the basis of working groups to make progress on the areas of difficulty.100 Many points were discussed,101 particularly with respect to the inspection and certification system and social security; on matters related to format and structure, there was agreement with the vertical format. In addition, as a result of the concerns about the Part B provisions, a decision was made to include a proposed ‘Explanatory Note’ in the text.102 Finally, the meeting proposed a procedural approach to the next meeting: . On behalf of the Officers, the Chairperson introduced the draft resolution concerning the text of the draft consolidated maritime labour Convention to be submitted to the PTMC (– September ). The resolution recommended, in its operative paragraphs, that: the Office be requested to submit to the PTMC a draft instrument based on the results of the important preparatory work undertaken in the framework of the High-level Group; the draft instrument be considered as containing mature provisions on which consensus has been reached on a significant 100
Preliminary Second Draft Commentary, supra note : . The comments have shown that substantial revision of certain sections of the Convention, and even their replacement by different provisions, is needed. This is why the present text is called a “preliminary second draft”. It seeks to identify certain areas of difficulty by placing wording inside square brackets and by reproducing some sections in italics to indicate that they may be the subject of proposals by constituents for substantial revision. The Officers propose that at its fourth meeting the High-level Group, rather than attempting to review the entire draft, should take up the suggestion made at its third meeting to make use of working parties. These would focus on specific areas of difficulty and in areas where little discussion has occurred in previous meetings because of time limitations. They would propose specific texts for approval. In addition to considering those texts, the Plenary would focus primarily on issues that would benefit from full discussion among constituents. . The Officers suggest that, at its fourth meeting, the High-level Group establish working parties for the following four areas: . Social Protection (Title , Regulation . and relationship to Regulations . and . medical coverage and liability) . The certification/inspection system (in Title ) . Accommodation (Title ) . Other areas of difficulty (Titles , and parts of Titles and not addressed under the preceding headings).
101
Final Report, HLTWG (Fourth Meeting), Nantes, – January , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS /, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/tw gmls/twgmls-r-.pdf. 102 Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention (Preliminary Second Draft), HLTWG (Fourth Meeting), Nantes, , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS /, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/ english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-r-.pdf.
mapping the terrain
number of provisions; the PTMC deal, in the first place, with the provisions included in the draft instrument which are placed in square brackets; the PTMC, in the second stage, deal with proposals concerning the draft instrument which have sufficient support; it take the necessary measures for the adjustment of the Standing Orders of the PTMC.103
At the PTMC, held nine months later in September , all matters of form and most matters of substance were resolved, including the very controversial text on social security. However, as became apparent at the PTMC, there were crucial issues necessitating a special Intersessional Meeting in Spring . By the PTMC it had also become clear that, for budgetary reasons, the ILC plan with as the meeting to adopt the Convention would need to be deferred until early . The structure and format of the Convention were agreed to and were adopted in . The vertical approach, despite requests for comments, was not specifically decided on but implicitly endorsed. As the Office’s Commentary to the PTMC notes: . As already indicated, one of the innovative solutions required to achieve the objectives of this instrument relates to the structure of the Convention. In accordance with the guidance provided to the Office, the recommended draft Convention has different parts which together would make up the Convention. The proposed Convention would comprise three different but related parts, the Articles, the Regulations and the Code. – The Articles and Regulations set out the core rights and principles and the basic obligations of Members ratifying the Convention. The Articles and Regulations can only be changed by the General Conference in the framework of Article of the Constitution of the International Labour Organization (see Article XIV of the Convention). – The Code contains the details for the implementation of the Regulations. It comprises Part A (mandatory Standards) and Part B (non-mandatory Guidelines) . . .. Since the Code relates to detailed implementation, amendments to it must remain within the general scope of the Articles and Regulations. . The Regulations and the Code are organized into general areas under five Titles: – Title : Minimum requirements for seafarers to work on a ship – Title : Conditions of employment – Title : Accommodation, recreational facilities, food and catering – Title : Health protection, medical care, welfare and social security protection – Title : Compliance and enforcement . These Titles are presented in what may be called a “vertical” format, to facilitate easier discussion and review. Each Title contains groups of provisions relating to a particular principle or right (or enforcement measure in Title ), with connected numbering. The first group in Title , for example, consists of Regulation ., 103
Final Report, supra note .
chapter five followed by Standard A. (taken from Part A of the Code) and then by Guideline B. (taken from Part B of the Code). Thus the reviewer can immediately see the overall scope of the particular Regulation and obligation. Constituents may wish to consider whether this vertical approach or the more traditional “horizontal” approach (that is, all Regulations placed together, followed by all provisions of Part A and then all provisions of Part B of the Code grouped together) should be used for the draft of the Convention to be presented to the International Labour Conference.104
Concluding Comments The latter part of this chapter has provided a detailed and, in many respects archival, account of the development of the structure and format of the final text of the MLC, . This account has on occasion necessarily ventured into matters of substance, largely because structural approaches can often provide a mechanism for solving substantive difficulties. It is the thesis of this book, and this chapter specifically, that the format and structure, that is, regulatory design, can and should be a matter of specific academic interest and analysis. Certainly this is the case with the MLC, . This analysis highlights the extent to which the structure, which was new for the ILO, the oldest of the UN organizations, was explicitly influenced by the structural approach to treaty drafting that had been successfully adopted in another specialized UN organization, the IMO. The approach was not adopted en bloc but was modified, and it is suggested, vastly improved, particularly in terms of readability, largely because of NGO (the Shipowners’ and Seafarers’ Groups) interventions. This chapter also provides a sense of how to ‘read’ the Convention by providing information on interstitial matters that may not be obvious on the face of the text but can affect legal interpretation and implementation. The following five chapters focus on the content of the text itself. This chapter has raised other points of interest in relation to structural matters. The MLC, is the first ILO convention that does not have an ILO convention number (it would have been C105). This is a break with ILO practice. The theory behind this decision is that the Convention would not be revised per se by a subsequent convention but instead would only be amended. Thus the base convention and its title would remain the same. Some of the points raised here will be explored in the following chapters including the strengthening of national level social dialogue by expressly requiring consultation when national administrations choose to exercise the flexibility provided 104
Commentary to the Recommended Draft, supra note , paras –. See the ILO list of conventions, available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp .htm. 105
mapping the terrain
under Convention. In addition the compliance and enforcement system in MLC, seeks to explicitly provide an ILO ‘value added’ approach to the adoption of the IMO ship certification system, beyond the seafarers’ complaint system. This is achieved by requiring that certain decisions and information also be provided to the ILO Director-General and/or the ILO supervisory system through the Article reports on national implementation of the MLC, as well as reports on some specific points. Thus compliance and enforcement at both the shipboard level and at the State level is to be achieved. These are points of substance but they can also be seen as structural patterns in the Convention.
chapter six PRINCIPLES AND RIGHTS— THE ARTICLES (AND THE PREAMBLE)
Introduction Chapter explained that Part I of this book has focused on an examination of the legal background and the policy context for the adoption of the MLC, , and that Part II is devoted to a detailed consideration of the Convention’s text in light of the travaux préparatoires (provisional records (PR)) and other preparatory reports. Chapter outlined the basic structure of the Convention and the discussions affecting its development, including the influence of the ‘hierarchical’ regulatory approach in the conventions adopted by the IMO (for example, STCW, with its articles, regulations, standards, and guidelines). At the same time, the MLC, , especially, with its topical vertically integrated format arguably constitutes a further, more functional, development in treaty design. Chapter moves to concentrate on an analysis of substance with a detailed examination of the international legal obligations in the articles of the Convention. Aspects of the discussion in this chapter have already been touched on, to the extent that the substantive content of the articles, for example the legal relationship between Parts A and B of the Code, also affected structural and organizational decisions. While generally following the presentation and grouping of the articles in the Convention this chapter is also concerned with the ‘solutions’ adopted to address particularly complex questions. As noted above, the development of the hierarchical ‘cascade’ approach to structure and substance in the Convention was discussed in Chapter .1 The following extract from the Explanatory Note2 to the Convention, explains the conceptual approach to the content of the differing parts of the Convention and, in particular, the role of the articles and the regulations, which as the excerpt below and the amendment procedures suggest, both ‘lay down’ rights and principles.
1
See Chapter , p. . See: Explanatory note to the Regulations and Code of the Maritime Labour Convention at page in Appendix . 2
chapter six
. The Convention comprises three different but related parts: the Articles, the Regulations and the Code. . The Articles and Regulations set out the core rights and principles and the basic obligations of Members ratifying the Convention. The Articles and Regulations can only be changed by the Conference in the framework of Article of the Constitution of the International Labour Organisation (see Article XIV of the Convention). . . . . The Convention has three underlying purposes: – to lay down, in its Articles and Regulations, a firm set of rights and principles; – to allow, through the Code, a considerable degree of flexibility in the way Members implement those rights and principles; and – to ensure, through Title , that the rights and principles are properly complied with and enforced. . . .
As explained at the PTMC in , the international meeting where the basic conceptual approach and legal relationship built into the structure of the Convention was adopted, The Special Adviser of the Committee explained that . . . the structure of the Convention could be seen as hierarchical. “Authority” was embedded in the Articles at a higher level. Specific rights were then raised in the Regulations, which also carried over to the Standards. This could seem repetitious as sometimes the Standard section elaborated on text already authorized. Articles and Regulations were the core of the Convention and could only be changed through normal ILO procedures. Standards, however, would be easier to amend and update in using the proposed simplified procedure.3
From a legal perspective, other than standard treaty provisions, such as depository functions (Articles XI and XII) and authoritative languages (Articles XVI), the majority of the sixteen articles of the MLC, provide the overarching and authorizing international obligations that States accept when ratifying the Convention. The wording, often in the form of broad statements of obligations or principles and rights, is also generic with confirming statements regarding implementation and enforcement. All other obligations laid out in the equally binding legal text, that is, regulations and standards, combined with the nonmandatory guidelines, can be seen as an elaboration of these core obligations. If the approach adopted by the IMO and the similar approach assumed in the MLC, amendment procedures is followed by ILO Members, the articles (and the regulations) should have been drafted in way that will survive the passage of time and future amendments to the more detailed provisions in the
3
Report of Committee No. , PTMC, Geneva, – September , ILO Doc. No. PTMC/ /–, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/ptmc/pdf/ptmc--.pdf, para. .
principles and rights
Code. It seems likely that this will be the case with the articles. However, in cases where the regulations also contain details or limitations that affect future amendments to the standards, Part A of the Code, this may not prove to be the case.4 From the point of view of achieving national implementation of the Convention, the articles establish the core obligations,5 including the methods for implementation.6 At the same time, the articles contain significant substantive provisions that are innovative. In particular, they provide the legal articulation of the approach7 of ‘firmness on rights: flexibility on method’. They also lay the foundation for many of the Convention’s provisions regarding cooperation in implementation and enforcement, promoting national social dialogue, particularly in the context of a globalized industrial sector and the ‘level playing field’. The articles also contain an important innovation on the wider international law of the sea with the development of another facet to State responsibility and roles—the labour supplying role—with responsibilities complementing those of the flag, coastal, and port States in other maritime conventions. Finally, these are also the provisions that squarely place human rights, and with them a rights-based intervention, in the development of the law of the sea, matters that had only a very limited presence in LOSC.8 Although not of the same legal status as articles, this chapter begins with a discussion of the preamble to the MLC, before moving to the detailed discussion of the articles.
4 See Chapter , note . For example, a future drafting problem regarding the scope of standards versus regulations could arise in connection with accommodating the decision on ‘principles’ by the Joint IMO/ILO Ad Hoc Expert Working Group on Liability and Compensation regarding Claims for Death, Personal Injury and Abandonment of Seafarers at its ninth session (– March ). The meeting recommended that the MLC, should be amended to include mandatory provisions to address the abandonment of seafarers, a matter only indirectly addressed in Regulation . on repatriation and Regulation . on compensation for ship’s loss or foundering, and the form of security for shipowners’ liability under Regulation .. See: Maritime Matters, Fifth item on the Agenda, Governing Body, Committee on Sectoral and Technical Meetings and Related Issues (STM) Committee, th Session, November , ILO Doc. No. GB//STM//. 5 See the Article report, General. The Article report form for the MLC, can be found in Appendix IV, Reports of the Committee on Legal Issues and International Labour Standards: Second Report: International labour standards and human rights, Governing Body, Geneva, March , ILO Doc. No. GB.// (Rev), pp. –, available at http://www.ilo.org/global/standards/ maritime-labour-convention/WCMS_/lang--en/index.htm. See also Chapter for a discussion of the ILO’s supervisory system. 6 Art. IV, para. . 7 See Chapters and . 8 As discussed in Chapter , pp. –. For example, in connection with the high seas provision regarding trafficking in humans (Article ) and less directly in connection with the obligation to transfer technology (Part XIV).
chapter six Best Intentions— The Preamble
Unusually9 for an ILO convention, but consistent with developments in other spheres of treaty making, such as multilateral environmental agreements, the MLC, has a relatively lengthy preamble.10 It refers, in two clauses, to the LOSC and key IMO conventions, as well as to what are regarded by the ILO as ‘fundamental’ human rights conventions.11 This extended preamble contextualizes the MLC, provisions and serves to firmly situate the Convention in the wider international law of the sea and international maritime legal regime. In addition to providing information as to the drafters’ intentions,12 preambles
9 See: ILO, Office of the Legal Adviser, The Manual for Drafting ILO Instruments, nd edition (Geneva: International Labour Office, ) (online interactive version), available at http:// www.ilo.org/public/english/bureau/leg/man.pdf, section ., p. ff. [hereinafter ILO Drafting Manual]. See also infra note referring to the Opinion of the Legal Adviser. 10 Compare for example the succinct ILO focused preamble in the Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, (No. ), Geneva, October , available at http://www .ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm. 11 The clauses read:
Desiring to create a single, coherent instrument embodying as far as possible all up-to-date standards of existing international maritime labour Conventions and Recommendations, as well as the fundamental principles to be found in other international labour Conventions, in particular: – the Forced Labour Convention, (No. ); – the Freedom of Association and Protection of the Right to Organise Convention, (No. ); – the Right to Organise and Collective Bargaining Convention, (No. ); – the Equal Remuneration Convention, (No. ); – the Abolition of Forced Labour Convention, (No. ); – the Discrimination (Employment and Occupation) Convention, (No. ); – the Minimum Age Convention, (No. ); – the Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention, (No. ); and Mindful of the core mandate of the Organization, which is to promote decent conditions of work, and Recalling the ILO Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work, , and Mindful also that seafarers are covered by the provisions of other ILO instruments and have other rights which are established as fundamental rights and freedoms applicable to all persons, . . . 12
Vienna Convention on the Law of the Treaties, Vienna May , entered into force on January , U.N.T.S. , available at http://untreaty.un.org/ilc/texts/instruments/ english/conventions/__.pdf. The Vienna Convention does not specifically address the role of preambles, noting only, in Article on the general rule of interpretation of treaties, that:
principles and rights
can also play a functional role in treaty negotiations as a mechanism for resolving conflict over specific text or references that are problematic. The text of the MLC, Preamble has this function, but it was also surprisingly controversial. During both the PTMC and the th ILC at least one Member State13 was concerned about the legal implications of references in the Preamble to a convention to which it was not a State party. The specific concern related to the following references14 to the LOSC: Recalling that the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, , sets out a general legal framework within which all activities in the oceans and seas must be carried out and is of strategic importance as the basis for national, regional and global action and cooperation in the marine sector, and that its integrity needs to be maintained, and Recalling that Article of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, , establishes the duties and obligations of a flag State with regard to, inter alia, labour conditions, crewing15 and social matters on ships that fly its flag, . . .
. A treaty shall be interpreted in good faith in accordance with the ordinary meaning to be given to the terms of the treaty in their context and in the light of its object and purpose. . The context for the purpose of the interpretation of a treaty shall comprise, in addition to the text, including its preamble and annexes: . . . Under domestic public law, preambles have a contextual role and may have a role in statutory construction. 13 Venezuela has not ratified the LOSC and has had long-standing concerns about any agreements that might prejudice its position. The following exchange is recorded in Report of the Committee of the Whole, ILC, th (Maritime) Session, Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. PR(Part I), available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/pr--i.pdf: . The representative of the Secretary-General, in response to the concern expressed by the Government member of the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela, stated that the proposed Convention did not address the issue of maritime boundaries. She recalled the legal opinion provided by the Legal Adviser at the PTMC that a Preamble did not, and could not, create legal obligations. Nor could a member State be indirectly bound. The Convention could not have that effect. The wording used in the Preamble clearly demonstrated that the only intention was to recall the spirit of the instruments mentioned. . . . . The Government member of the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela agreed to withdraw the amendment with the understanding that his position as well as the explanations of the representative of the Secretary-General would be clearly recorded in the Committee’s report. 14
This text was reviewed by the United Nations Legal Office. See: Adoption of an Instrument to Consolidate Maritime Labour Standards, ILC, th (Maritime) Session, Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. Report I(A), available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/rep-ia.pdf, Note (Preamble), para. . 15 Article of LOSC does not refer to ‘crewing’ per se. Article , Duties of the flag State, provides, inter alia,
chapter six
A legal opinion on this question was provided by the ILO’s Legal Adviser, as noted in the Office’s Report for the th ILC:16 . Preambles do not create legal obligations. The Preamble to the proposed consolidated maritime labour Convention provides information as to the overall context and intention of the Convention in relation to other relevant international law and principles. In particular, it indicates a clear intention that the new Convention should, inter alia, embody the fundamental principles to be found in the ILO’s “fundamental Conventions” (second paragraph) and recalls the ILO Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work, . . . . . as stated by the ILO Legal Adviser during the PTMC (in connection with a discussion regarding the ILO Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work, but with equal relevance to the ILO’s fundamental Conventions, UNCLOS and the other instruments mentioned in the Preamble): Finally, on the consequences of including a reference to the Declaration in the Preamble to the future Convention, the Legal Adviser recalled that the inclusion of a preambular clause referring to the Declaration, similar to that which exists in the Preambles to the Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention, (No. ), and the Maternity Protection Convention, (No. ), would not result in any legal obligation for Members. The Preambles to international labour Conventions do not create any legal obligations.
Despite this information the government in question abstained from voting because of the reference in the Preamble but placed on record its agreement with the MLC, .17 . Every State shall effectively exercise its jurisdiction and control in administrative, technical and social matters over ships flying its flag. . In particular every State shall: . . . b) assume jurisdiction under its internal law over each ship flying its flag and its master, officers and crew in respect of administrative, technical and social matters concerning the ship. . Every State shall take such measures for ships flying its flag as are necessary to ensure safety at sea with regard, inter alia, to: . . . b) the manning of ships, labour conditions and the training of crews, taking into account the applicable international instruments; . . .. United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, December , UN Doc. A/Conf. /, I.L.M. (entered into force on November ), available at http://www.un.org/ depts/los/convention_agreements/texts/unclos/closindx.htm. 16 Report I(A), supra note , paragraph and see infra notes and and pp. –. 17 See: Ninth Sitting, ILC, th (Maritime) Session, Geneva, February , ILO Doc. No. PR, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/pr-.pdf, pp. and . Original Spanish: Ms. POITEVIEN (Government, Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela) The Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela has taken part in this process with considerable interest and determination, to encourage the adoption of a Convention that would benefit seafarers, both men and women. Nonetheless, the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela decided to abstain from the vote on the consolidated maritime labour Convention, because
principles and rights
As the forgoing extract indicates, a further difficulty was encountered for some governments also with respect to a proposed reference in Article III to the ILO Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work, . The resolution of this very difficult issue in at the PTMC involved the transfer of this reference to the Preamble, despite the Legal Adviser’s ‘on record’ opinion that a reference in one legal instrument to another legal instrument does not necessarily result in an obligations with respect to the referenced instrument.18 This debate, even with respect to the wording of a preamble, of the reference in its Preamble to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, , which is not applicable to our country as the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela is not party to it and voted against it at the time of its adoption. This position has been systematically upheld by the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela in various forums, where reference has been made to the Convention on the Law of the Sea. We feel that it cannot be used as a model for all maritime activities that fall within the law of the sea. The Convention on the Law of the Sea is an integral part of this but it is not the sole source of rights and obligations. These reservations notwithstanding, the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela would like to confirm its belief, before the entire international community, that the consolidated maritime labour Convention aims to strengthen the labour rights of maritime workers and so my country, its people and my Government, will promote its application. Lastly, I would like to say that in my country, the domestic legislation on this matter is in fact more protective than the provisions of the Convention, which we regard as minimum standards and which we will apply and continue to strengthen within our country. 18
Supra note and see also Report of Committee No. , PTMC, Geneva, – September , ILO Doc. No. PTMC//–, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/standards/ relm/maritime/pdf/ptmc---.pdf: . The Employer member of the Governing Body of the ILO expressed the deep concern of the Employers’ group of the Governing Body over having any reference to the ILO Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work, , in any article of the proposed Convention. The inclusion of any such reference would add confusion to the Declaration’s objectives, which are different from those of Conventions. It would also make the Declaration itself subject to the scrutiny of the ILO supervisory bodies. Reference to the Declaration could be acceptable in the Preamble. The second alternative was also not acceptable, since it would deter ratification by governments that had not ratified one or more of the core Conventions. . The Seafarer Vice-Chairperson drew attention to Comment of PTMC//, which made reference to a similar provision found in Article (a) of the Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, (No. ). However, governments that had ratified this Convention were concerned about the same provision in the current context. . The Government member of the United States said his Government would accept Article (a) as currently found in Convention No. . The current text departed from this provision and was radically different from his Government’s understanding of Article (a). Before ratification of Convention No. , the Government member of the United States had requested a legal opinion from the ILO, which was appended to the articles of ratification. . . . . The Chairperson of the Steering Committee and President of the Conference reported that after consultations and legal advice the following proposal on Article III had received sufficient support to be brought back before the Committee for decision. The proposed wording read as follows: . . .
chapter six
demonstrates the level of sensitivity and continued relevance and importance that governments accord to international law and obligations. The Articles The sixteen (XVI) articles of the MLC, are organized in a typical,19 essentially chronological pattern, addressing who, what, how, and when.20 They begin, in Article I, with general obligations, which are followed by definitions and scope of application of the Convention (Article II), which in turn is followed by several articles setting out the core obligations, including implementation and enforcement related obligations (Articles III–VII). The remaining nine articles (VIII–XVI) are directed more to administration and operation of the Convention itself with provisions on entry into force, effect of entry into force on existing conventions, authoritative languages, depository functions, and convention amendment procedures. They also include provisions on the establishment of the Special Tripartite Committee to oversee the ‘working of the Convention’ and with a specific function in the amendment procedures. The analysis below generally follows the order in which the articles appear. However, the discussion is focused on the substantive obligations for ratifying States rather than on administrative or operational provisions. It highlights key aspects and matters of difficulty or special interest in the articles. Article I—General Obligations Article I comprises two paragraphs that, on their face, appear to be statements of the obvious and, possibly, even redundant in that they set out an obligation to give effect to the Convention’s obligations and, essentially, a duty21 to coop. The reference to the ILO Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work, , would be moved to the Preamble of the proposed Convention. 19 ‘Typical’ refers to basic coverage of both ILO and non-ILO conventions adopted in the maritime sector. As explained in Chapter , this convention’s organization and structure differs significantly from the usual ILO conventions. See: ILO Drafting Manual, supra note , p. ff. 20 The full text of the MLC, , annotated with reference to the conventions that it consolidates or draws upon for its wording, is found at Appendix . 21 See, for example, Declaration on Principles of International law Concerning Friendly Relations and Cooperation among States in accordance with the Charter of the United Nations, Resolution (XXV), General Assembly, rd Plenary Meeting, October . Article I, paragraph , has been described as the ‘the forgotten paragraph’ (emphasis added):
In analysing the precise impact of Article I, it should be remembered that the Articles and the Regulations of the Convention set out the core rights and principles and the basic obligations of Members ratifying the Convention. Many of the detailed obligations that are derived from those general provisions are set out in the Code—in the form of mandatory
principles and rights
erate. They are also standard text found in many IMO conventions. However, both paragraphs are nuanced and have points of interest for the remainder of the Convention. First, this is the first use of the terms ‘[e]ach Member’ and ‘Members’ in the Convention. Neither is defined, but the word ‘Member’ has a specific meaning in the ILO and also a particular meaning in the MLC, . From a wider international law perspective they can be understood as generally parallel to references in non-ILO conventions to ‘States party’ or ‘parties’. In the ILO, ‘Member’ is used to refer to a Member of the Organization. The MLC, Drafting Committee22 adopted the following approach: . The phrase “Each Member which ratifies this Convention” is first used in Article I. In accordance with ILO practice, subsequent references to a ratifying Member, wherever possible, simply use the term “each Member” or otherwise refer to “Member” in the singular. When reference is made to Members of the Organization in general, the wording will make this clear and normally the plural “Members” will be used.
Thus the obligations in Article envisage two partially overlapping audiences. The first paragraph applies to “Each ratifying Member” while the obligation in paragraph , “to cooperate”, applies to all Members of the ILO.23 Including a “Standards” in Part A of the Code, which are to be read in the light of the non-mandatory “Guidelines” in Part B. In other words, paragraph does not define particular rights and obligations, but rather provides the legal basis for more specific provisions. C. Doumbia-Henry, “The Maritime Labour Convention, : The forgotten paragraph of Article I,” Speech to the Seamen Welfare National Committee, Rome, April (copy on file with the co-authors). While not an official document, this speech is helpful in that it refers to some specific examples of cooperation related to provisions in the MLC, and explores the possible application in connection with various joint and regional arrangements, particularly in the connection with port State control. 22 Report I(A), supra note , Appendix A, Report on the work of the PTMC Drafting Group. 23 Ibid., Note (Article I), explains: . Having referred to the general obligation of “each Member”, paragraph states the general obligation on all Members which have ratified the Convention to cooperate with each other for the purpose of ensuring its effective implementation and enforcement. There are references to the need, at least, to consider international cooperation throughout the Convention with respect to recruitment and placement, health protection and medical care, occupational safety and accident prevention, seafarers’ welfare facilities, seafarers in foreign ports and social security protection; for example, in addition to Regulation ., whose purpose is: “To enable each Member to implement its responsibilities under this Convention regarding international cooperation in the implementation and enforcement of the Convention standards on foreign ships.” Most of these references are to be found in the non-mandatory Guidelines as, although the general obligation is mandatory, it is recognized that the decision when and how to cooperate with other Members is best left to the discretion of each Member. Two examples of the inclusion of a reference to cooperation in a Regulation or a Standard are found in the provisions relating to social security protection (Regulation ., paragraph ) and the investigation of marine casualties (Regulation .., paragraph ).
chapter six
general obligation that also applies to non-ratifying States might seem unusual in an international treaty. However, it can be understood as relating to the obligations of ILO Members under its Constitution.24 The phrase ‘complete effect’ in paragraph and its relationship to Article IV, paragraphs and (substantial equivalence and the relationship between the MLC, Code, Parts A and B), was also a matter of note in the Office’s Report for the th ILC:25 . Inflexibility with respect to rights and flexibility with respect to implementation, . . . is apparent from the start of the proposed consolidated maritime labour Convention: paragraph of Article I, on general obligations, requires Members to give “complete effect” to the provisions of the Convention in order to secure the right of all seafarers to decent employment. However, complete effect is to be given “in the manner set out in Article VI”, and Article VI is the provision which embodies the two main areas for flexibility in implementation of the Convention.
Similarly the reference to ‘cooperate’ in connection with the MLC, and the nature of this obligation26 has special importance for the globalized maritime The Committee of the Whole Report, supra note , Part I, para. , reiterates this point: . The representative of the Secretary-General referred to the Office report in Report I (A), in particular Note on Article I, and read out the relevant extracts. Subject to any formal legal opinion of the Legal Adviser, it seemed clear from the Office report that, in accordance with ILO practice, references in the text to “Member” or to “each Member” should be taken to mean a ratifying Member. If it was intended in any instance to refer to Members of the Organization in general, the wording would make that clear and normally the plural “Members” would be used. She went on to confirm the Worker Vice-Chairperson’s understanding that, for non-ratifying Members, ILO Conventions had the status of Recommendations. 24
See discussion in Chapter . Report I(A), supra note , Note (Article I). See also: Final Report, HLTWG (Third Meeting), Geneva, June– July , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo .org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-r-.pdf: 25
. A representative of the Office explained that, in his view, there was a very special concordance between the two provisions mentioned in that both placed their emphasis on the effect of the Convention’s provisions. Paragraph of Article VI made it clear that an implementing measure would be “substantially equivalent”, for the purpose of paragraph , if it was conducive to the full achievement of the general object of the Convention and had effects that were equivalent to those resulting from strict compliance with the provision concerned. In other words, Article VI coincided with Article I by requiring complete effect to be given to the Convention albeit through equivalent means. 26
Report I(A), supra note , Note (Article I), para. . See also: supra note and Reports of the Selection Committee, Second Report, International Labour Conference, th (Maritime) Session, Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. PR– (Rev.), available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/ standards/relm/ilc/ilc/pr--.pdf. Several of the resolutions adopted with MLC, at the th ILC are related to cooperation: Resolution I (concerning the promotion of the MLC, ) refers to technical cooperation; and Resolution X (concerning addressing the human
principles and rights
sector. It also buttresses the legal foundation for other provisions, such as the ‘may’ responsibility of States to undertake inspections of foreign ships in their ports (port State control) as well the port or coastal State obligations to, inter alia, allow seafarers to have access to seafarer welfare centres and onshore medical services, and to assist in facilitating repatriation, as well as the responsibility of States with respect to labour-supplying regulatory and enforcement matters. Article II—Definitions and Scope of Application Article II contains some of the most important provisions in the Convention as they establish the parameters for its application. The provisions in this eight paragraph article are complex and contain many carefully negotiated and subtle points. These are ‘lynchpin’ provisions for governments to consider for national implementation of the Convention. Article II also contains the major development in connection with the prior international labour conventions regarding the coverage in this sector. It is also the starting point for the approach to ‘flexibility’ as well the Convention’s entrenchment of national tripartism in connection with the flexibility in national implementation. Five major substantive and policy developments, embedded in the wording of the Article II provisions, are likely to affect regulatory and private law practices in the maritime labour sector significantly and in some cases may provide major challenges for national implementation: . The Convention explicitly widens coverage to apply to all workers (seafarers) on ships covered by the Convention. . The Convention does not have a general tonnage limitation (although there is one ( GT and above) on international voyages or voyages between or from nonflag State ports) with respect to mandatory ship certification and some specific flexibility for ships less than GT. . The Convention applies to ships that are engaged on international voyages and on domestic voyages, with very limited exclusions. . The shipowner, broadly defined, is the locus or focal point for regulatory activity and responsibility for all workers/seafarers on its ships, irrespective of other contractual and management arrangements between the seafarer and her or his employer. . The Convention introduces mandatory certification of working and living conditions on some ships (ships GT on international voyages or voyages between or from non-flag State ports or on request from a shipowner).
element through international cooperation between UN specialized agencies) refers to the joint ILO/IMO working group. The latter resolution was communicated to the IMO early in . However, establishing an additional permanent joint working group was not seen as necessary by the IMO, largely because there are already several issue-specific joint ILO/IMO working groups.
chapter six
The impact of this widening of coverage, in principle to all ‘ships’ and onboard workers (defined as seafarers) has significant implications for some parts of the industry, particularly cruise ships, and for flag State inspection systems. Before considering specific textual issues in connection with these eight paragraphs, it is useful to first understand the overall approach in the Article. Article II is expressly drafted, as its title indicates, to address both definitions and scope. It sets out general definitions (paragraph ) of terms occurring in different parts of the Convention, as well as the general scope of application of the Convention (paragraphs and ) together with some ‘flexibility’ related options (paragraphs , , , and ). In practical terms, both the worker (seafarer) and the workplace (ship) are defined as is the scope of application of these definitions, that is, determining which workers are protected by the Convention or, conversely, which workplaces are regulated, requires consideration of both the definition and the scope provisions for both seafarers and ships.27 This approach reflects a conscious policy, relating to securing a progressive forward-looking comprehensive ‘seafarers’ bill of rights’,28 while at the same time allowing some potential for national flexibility in application. As noted in the Office Report for the th ILC, . It is important, in this context, to note the difference between a definition and a scope-related provision. Although the concepts are related in that both are used to address the question of who or what activities—in this case ships, shipowners and seafarers—are governed by the Convention’s provisions, they are distinct ideas and can reflect differing considerations. In the proposed consolidated maritime labour Convention, the basic approach adopted is to provide inclusive or broad definitions. This is combined with some potential for flexibility provided to adopt narrower definitions for particular provisions (under the Titles), or to address particular situations through consultation.29
Although this suggests that the idea was to provide some possibility for tailoring the application of the Convention, in fact there are a very few instances of this narrowing in coverage in the Titles. Perhaps this could be the subject of future amendments, however, under the rapid amendment procedures (Article XV) this could only occur in connection with the Code, not the regulations or the 27
The interaction of the definitions and the scope of application of the Convention is probably one of the more difficult issues that was resolved at the th ILC. To fully understand the solutions adopted by the ILC reference also needs to be made to the ‘package’ of decisions reached at an Intersessional Meeting in regarding mandatory application of the certification system to ships GT or over engaged in international voyages or operating from a port or between ports in another country. It is important to be aware that the flag State inspection obligations in Regulation .. and the related Code apply to all ships covered by the MLC, even if they do not have to be certified. See discussion in Chapter on Title . 28 See Chapter . 29 Report I(A), supra note , Note (Article II), para. .
principles and rights
articles. Thus the basic coverage in the regulations would remain, unless the articles or the regulations were amended through the more extended ‘usual’ procedure set out in the Convention (Article XIV). Definitions—Article II, Paragraph (a)–(j) The approach to allowing for tailoring or narrowing of the application in relation to both definition and scope in subsequent provisions in the Convention is carried through in the particular wording of several paragraphs in Article II, using a formulation that first appears in the chapeau to the ten definitions (a)– (j) in paragraph .30 The formulation is along the lines of ‘unless provided otherwise in particular provisions, the term: . . . ’. This approach, initially inserted as one alternative approach to allow for tailoring the coverage, was adopted, along with the alternative approach using the scope provisions in the Convention text. The Convention does not use the possibility of further differing definitions to narrow the coverage, thereby excluding some workers or employers or ships from the otherwise broad definitions in Article II.31 30
See discussion in Chapter . See also: Unresolved Issues for the Draft Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention, , Tripartite Intersessional Meeting on the Follow-up of the PTMC, Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. PTMC//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/ dialogue/sector/techmeet/ptmc/ptmc-.pdf, Note (Article II), para. : . Article II sets out general definitions (paragraph (a) to (j)) of terms occurring in different parts of the Convention, as well as (paragraphs to ) the general scope of application of the Convention. It is the combination of these definitions and the scope-related provisions found in the Articles that sets the overall framework of who or what activities are generally intended to be affected by the Convention. In particular, the Draft Convention currently addresses the question of application using provisions relating to the definitions of seafarers and to ships. It would apply to all seafarers, as defined in paragraph (f), “except as expressly provided otherwise” (paragraph ) in specific provisions found elsewhere in the Convention. Under paragraph of Article II, the Convention would apply to all ships, subject to a number of qualifications or exceptions contained in different parts of Article II. The first narrowing of the broad application to “all ships” results from the definition of “ships” in Article II, paragraph (i), which does not include ships that navigate “exclusively in inland waters or waters within, or closely adjacent to, sheltered waters or areas where port regulations apply”.2 Then the chapeau of paragraph excludes (by implication) ships that are not “ordinarily engaged in commercial activities”. Two other exceptions are currently specified under subparagraphs (b) and (c) . . .
31 Report I(A), supra note , appears to have provided an argument against this text in favour of the formulation in the ‘scope’ provisions. Both options were retained in the final text, with no discussion at the Conference. The Report at Note (Article II), paragraph , provides that (emphasis added);
. . . . The words “unless provided otherwise” in paragraph would allow a term to be defined differently for the purpose of specific provisions of the Convention. For example, certain kinds of seafarers or ships could, in principle, be excluded from the application of certain provisions of the Regulations and the Code by stating in a specific definition that they are not to be considered as “seafarers” or “ships” for the purposes of those provisions.
chapter six
Each of the ten definitions of the Convention was the subject of comment in the negotiation process. However, not all are of significant substantive import.32 Some were related mainly to alignment with usage in the IMO conventions and industry practice, such as the definition of ‘gross tonnage’ or simply clarifying the meaning of a term, for example, the maritime labour certificate or the declaration of maritime labour compliance (DMLC), which are referred to in the articles but are not addressed until Title . There are, however, a number of definitions and related scope provisions that are especially important for the Convention. In some cases they draw on and modify definitions in existing ILO33 or IMO conventions in an effort to align the MLC, with other major instruments in the maritime regime. At the same time this pedigree must be viewed with caution since the resulting text was not based on the same understandings or assumptions found in other fora. As discussed in Chapter , in the development of the MLC, text, numerous studies and exhaustive analysis had been undertaken by the International Labour Office regarding the terminology in existing ILO conventions.34 If anything, these studies illustrated the problem of
However, the more logical and preferable policy approach and the one also provided for and followed in the proposed Convention is to use the scope-related provisions (Article II, paragraph (for seafarers) and paragraph (for ships)) for this purpose. Both of those paragraphs consequently begin with the phrase “except as expressly provided otherwise”. The result is that, rather than determining that certain seafarers are not to be considered as seafarers or that certain ships are not to be considered as ships for specific matters, the provisions relating to those matters would allow certain categories of seafarers or of ships to be excluded from the application of the provisions concerned. 32 For example, the definition of competent authority in paragraph (a) was the subject of discussion at the th ILC in and required a view from the Drafting Committee as to whether the word authority should be in the plural. It is clear that the term is meant to refer to the relevant national authority concerned with the specific issue. In some cases it might be labour ministry or a maritime administration or even a social security department. See: Committee of the Whole Report, supra note , para. . See also: Committee of the Whole Report, supra note , “Report of the Drafting Committee of the Tenth Maritime Conference, Article II, paragraph (a),” p. :
In response to a request by the Committee of the Whole relating to paragraph (a) of Article II of the English text, the Drafting Committee decided that it was not necessary to replace the word “authority” with “authorities” since the term “other authority” already in the text had a generic meaning which could be applied in either the singular or plural sense. 33 The annotated MLC, in Appendix of this book, shows the linkages to earlier ILO conventions. 34 See, for example, Duplicative or Contradictory Texts in the Existing Maritime Instruments, SubGroup of the HLTWG, First meeting, Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. STWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/stwgmls/stwgmls-.pdf. Significant variations were found especially with respect to the terms seafarer or seamen and vessel (at paras –).
principles and rights
conflicting or overlapping texts and terminology. Nonetheless, given the concerns about poor ratification levels for some conventions, it is clear that in some cases the intention was to adjust rather than repeat the wording of obligations. Thus the definitions should initially be approached as essentially new terms with meanings particular to the MLC, .35 At the same time, for questions of national implementation and application of specific obligations drawn from earlier conventions, it is likely that the basic rights or legal framework for the obligation will already be in place, although there may be questions of scope that will need to be considered. One of the definitions with no precedent in earlier texts that is often overlooked, perhaps because it is puzzling as to its role, is the definition of ‘requirements of this Convention’ in paragraph (e): e) requirements of this Convention refers to the requirements in these Articles and in the Regulations and Part A of the Code of this Convention:
This phrase can be viewed as a ‘term of art’ in this convention as it has a very specific meaning. This phrase, and its definition, were included in the text following the fourth meeting of the HLTWG in and reflect the arrangements36 reached as to the nature of Part B of the Code and, importantly, the fact that Part B provisions (guidelines) are not the subject of port State control inspections under Title .37 This will be discussed in more detail in 35 However, in many cases, existing national legislation implementing earlier ILO conventions may well be consistent with the MLC, provisions and coverage. 36 Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention: Commentary to the Recommended Draft, PTMC, Geneva, – September , ILO Doc. No. PTMC//, available at http://www.ilo .org/public/english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/ptmc/pdf/cmlc-comment.pdf:
. In the recommended draft, the above understandings [agreement] are reflected partly in the Explanatory note to the Convention (see comment below) and partly in the body of the Convention (see Regulation .., paragraph ). They could also be specifically drawn to the attention of the International Labour Conference with a view to their approval as part of the travaux préparatoires. 37 The phrase, other than the reference in Article V, paragraph , is primarily found in Title and is usually associated with the additional bracketed phrases added by the PTMC in and the Intersessional Meeting in , ‘(including seafarers’ rights)’. Since the majority of the MLC, provisions can be understood as ‘seafarers’ rights’, a reference to ‘requirements of this convention (including seafarers’ rights)’ might be viewed as a tautology. However, in some circumstances, it may indirectly address the difficult question of inspection and enforcement, at the ship-board level, of the fundamental rights referred to in Article III. See: ILO, Guidelines for Port State Control Officers Carrying out Inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, (Geneva: ILO, ), available at http://www.ilo.org/global/What_we_do/InternationalLabourStandards/ MaritimeLabourConvention/lang-en/index.htm, para. . However, it should be noted that Article II, paragraph (e), and Article V, paragraphs and , do not contain the phrase in brackets while the provisions in Title on compliance and enforcement do. See also Chapter in connection with minimum age.
chapter six
connection with Article VI, however, as noted in the Office Report for the th ILC: . Subparagraph (e) of paragraph contains a definition relating to the “requirements of this Convention” to make it clear that this term only refers to the mandatory provisions of the Convention; namely, those in the Articles, Regulations and Part A of the Code, which, however, also include Article VI requiring Members to give “due consideration” to implementing their responsibilities in the manner provided for in Part B of the Code.38
Article II, paragraph , essentially a standard provision that confirms the meaning of the term ‘convention’ by stating that “[u]nless expressly provided otherwise”, also refers to the regulations and the Code. Presumably the formulation ‘requirements of this Convention’ excluding Part B of the Code can be understood as expressly providing otherwise. One of the most controversial developments in the Convention relates to the definition of a ‘seafarer’ in paragraph (f): (f) seafarer means any person who is employed or engaged or works in any capacity on board a ship to which this Convention applies;
As suggested above, and is clear in the wording of the provision, in order to understand specifically which workers (as ‘seafarers’) are covered, the scope provisions39 for seafarer and ships must also be considered. There are, however, some key points to note also with respect to the definition itself. First, in English40 the term is gender neutral and clearly moves away from ‘seamen’. Secondly, the term is now understood to cover a wide range of working arrangements, including self-employment or other contractual arrangements.41 The records of the meetings to develop the Convention text are replete with concerns about ‘who is a (really) a seafarer?’.42 The focus of concern was on personnel working as entertainers or other passenger service roles such 38
Report I(A), supra note , Note (Article II). Art. II, para. (i); paras , , , and . See Final Report, Tripartite Subgroup of the HLTWG (Second meeting), Geneva, – February , ILO Doc. No. STWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org / public / english / dialogue / sector / techmeet / stwgmls / stwgmls-.pdf, Annex , Report of the Drafting group on Definitions, where this definition was introduced and specific categories of seafarers (i.e., masters, ratings, etc.) removed. 40 This is a more difficult issue in the equally authoritative French text which uses the term gens de mer or marin for seafarer. 41 See also Regulation . and Standard A. on seafarers’ employment agreements. 42 The Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention, supra note , at Comment , para. , footnotes and , states: 39
. Convention No. does not address the matter. See also a paper prepared by the Office for the second meeting of the High-level Tripartite Working Group on Maritime Labour Standards, Definitions and scope of application provisions in existing ILO maritime instruments and related texts, document TWGMLS// (Geneva, ).
principles and rights
as hair dressers or other ‘hotel staff ’. Essentially the issue is the impact on the cruise ship sector, where many of the workers, often a , or more on a single ship, had not previously been considered ‘seafarers’, and had various kinds of contractual arrangements, often with employers other than shipowners and sometimes for very short periods of time. As indicated in the Office Report for the th ILC,43 the MLC, reflects the consensus of the constituents . Some Conventions define seafarers to include any person working or employed on board in any capacity. Others simply leave the matter of definition to national law (i.e., a “seafarer” may be “any person defined as such” under national law or collective agreements— Article (d) of Convention No. ). This was a view adopted early in the negotiations. See: Final Report, Tripartite Subgroup of the HLTWG (First Meeting), Geneva, – June , ILO Doc. No. STWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/stwgmls/stwgmls-r.pdf: . The representative of the Government of France stated that, irrespective of the definition of “seafarer”, there should be no gaps in coverage of conditions of employment. He added that inspectors should be capable of covering all forms of working conditions on board and must be competent on the laws or regulations which are relevant for persons aboard ships. . The representative of the Government of the United Kingdom recalled that to assist with the definition of “seafarer” when implementing ILO Convention No. , the United Kingdom uses, as a rule of thumb, the concept of “normal place of work”. To ensure no gaps, a person whose normal place of work is at sea is covered by maritime regulation, and a person whose normal place of work is on land, is covered by shore-side legislation. She added that there were still borderline cases. . . . . The representative of the Government of Canada stated that their definition and interpretation of a seafarer is in line with the ILO Convention and what the Seafarer spokesperson said, a ship was a ship and the approach was driven by the command and control structure. However, there is a need to expand or have categories of seafarers to better define the reality of today’s shipping and labour practices in the world. We certainly need to explore the possibility of having categories of seafarers for the passengers industry and exploration and exploitation of oil and gas in the offshore zone. This ongoing problem with the definition of seafarer will have to be sorted out sooner than later. 43
Report I(A), supra note , Note (Article II): . The definition of a “seafarer” in subparagraph (f) of paragraph was the subject of extended discussion throughout the development of the proposed Convention text. Although the current definition or variations on it are found in many international labour Conventions, such as Conventions Nos. , , and and, more recently, Convention No. , there is now a greater awareness of the broad range of people who are employed at sea and who carry out jobs not traditionally understood to be part of the seafaring workforce or thought to be covered by the maritime labour Conventions. The content of many maritime labour Conventions primarily speaks to the employment of personnel involved in some way in the operation of the ship—the crew. In most cases, the crew are engaged directly or indirectly by the shipowner (broadly defined). There are a number of people working on board ships, particularly passenger ships, that may not fall within this category (such as aestheticians, sports instructors and entertainers). The employment situation and protection available to these maritime industry workers is less clear. The difficulty with leaving solely to national law the matter of determining which workers are to be considered
chapter six
that, in principle, all ocean workers should be covered and considered as seafarers.44 However, it was also agreed45 that there were some borderline cases, as discussed below46 in connection with Article II, paragraphs and , “in the event of doubt”. The definition of ‘seafarers’ employment agreement’ (SEA) in Article II, paragraph (g), is drafted inclusively to allow for a range of contractual situations and terminology in different legal systems. It is a new but relatively uncontroversial term in the MLC, . It should, however, be noted that this definition accommodates the traditional practice of ‘articles of agreement’. As mentioned above, the MLC, also includes countries with laboursupplying responsibilities in several provisions. One of these responsibilities relates to the obligation in Article V, paragraph , Regulation ., and Regulation . regarding regulation of seafarer recruitment and placement services (if any) operating in the country’s territory.47 These services are defined in Article II, paragraph (h), and draw upon the definition in the Recruitment and as seafarers for the purposes of the Convention is that it may perpetuate unevenness within the global maritime labour force with respect to the application of international standards. However, some national flexibility is provided for in paragraph . Moreover . . . the issue of who is a “seafarer” (definition) should best be kept distinct from the issue of which categories of seafarers should or should not be covered by certain provisions of the Convention (scope). 44 This was a view adopted early in the negotiations. See: Final Report, supra note . Despite efforts of the th ILC on this point to help resolve questions, see infra pp. –, this still remains a matter that is debated for some sectors of the maritime industry. The Background Paper, ILO.Doc. No. PTMLC/ available at http://www.ilo.org / global / standards / maritimelabour-convention / WCMS_, prepared for a meeting in September of the Preparatory Tripartite MLC, Committee notes that: III . . . B. Application of the MLC, to cruise ships . In general, the application of the MLC, to ships of gt and above engaged in international voyages does not appear to pose significant difficulties, possibly because these ships were also clearly covered by previous ILO Conventions. One exception where difficulties appear to have arisen is in connection with the cruise ship sector, primarily because the MLC, clearly covers many workers on board these ships who may not previously have been protected as “seafarers”. To date, where issues have been articulated, the International Labour Office has been able to assist with information and explanations regarding the requirements of the MLC, . . It is understood, however, that some cruise ship owners may still have significant concerns regarding the impact on their operations of certain MLC, provisions, particularly those in Titles and . In general, these concerns have taken the form of requests for advice concerning possible national determinations, under Article II, paragraph of the Convention, that certain categories of workers do not come within the definition of seafarers. In some of the countries concerned, there are no shipowners’ or seafarers’ organizations to consult with regard to such determinations. . . . 45 Committee of the Whole Report, supra note , para. . 46 See infra note , Resolution concerning information on occupational groups. 47 The details of the obligation are discussed in Chapter in connection with Regulation ..
principles and rights
Placement of Seafarers Convention, (No. ), Article , paragraph (b). Although there was little debate over the definition, the related regulation provoked extensive discussion.48 The definition of a ship in paragraph (i), a modified version of the term found in the IMO’s STCW Convention for ‘seagoing ship’,49 provides that: (i) ship means a ship other than one which navigates exclusively in inland waters or waters within, or closely adjacent to, sheltered waters or areas where port regulations apply;
Essentially this can be understood as a definition of a ‘seagoing ship’, the term previously preferred in ILO conventions, that allowed for national determination of what ships or vessels were ‘seagoing’ and de facto, which seafarers/workers were covered. This definition of a ship proved to be controversial once it became clear, after the ‘package’ adopted at the Intersessional Meeting in (see discussion below in connection with scope), that the MLC, would not have a tonnage limitation nor would ships on domestic voyages be excluded. Thus a much larger group of ships, including those generally not covered by international maritime regulatory systems, were bought under the Convention.50 In fact the definition had not been seen as controversial and was not 48 There are two potentially difficult issues that are raised with this definition, which adds the word ‘seafarer’ before ‘recruitment’. The first issue concerns recruitment and placement services that might only on occasion recruit a person who is a seafarer to work for an employer who might ultimately be a shipowner (e.g., in the entertainment sector). Second, there is the even more complicated issue of an agent or subsidiary corporation of the shipowner that directly recruits seafarers. The Convention does not address direct recruitment, however the phrase ‘on behalf of the shipowner’ may prove problematic. It is clear that the objective of the provisions in the Convention is to address the problem of unregulated private services. The determining factor may be the concept of ‘is engaged’, for example, contracted to carry out this service. See Chapter . 49 The International Convention on Standards of Training, Certification and Watchkeeping, , London, July , U.N.T.S. , as amended (STCW), defined the term ‘seagoing ships’ (Article II(g)): “Seagoing ship means a ship other than those which navigate exclusively in inland waters or waters within, or closely adjacent to sheltered waters or areas where port regulations apply”. The terms ‘seagoing ships’ or ‘seagoing vessels’ or ‘ships used in maritime navigation’ are commonly used in ILO conventions (e.g., C), often with tonnage limitations on application. The term, which was not defined and allowed for national determinations (often related to the nature of the voyage or tonnage), was initially included (in ) in the MLC, proposed definition of a ship, but was subsequently deleted as redundant. 50 Although the definition is based on STCW, the MLC, did not also import the STCW concept of ‘near-coastal voyages’, which allows for differing training and certification requirements for seafarers on ships (including foreign flag ships) regularly engaged in ‘near-coastal voyages’. See: Amended Annex to STCW, ibid., Chapter , Regulation I/., “Near-coastal voyages means voyages in the vicinity of a Party as defined by that Party”. This matter was also under some debate at IMO as it has been used (or arguably misused) by some governments to provide variation to the strict application of STCW sometimes out as far nautical miles. The definition was not amended by the June review conference held in Manila: Adoption of
chapter six
subject to comment in the Office Report for the th ILC other than in relation to the scope provisions.51 At the th ILC, however, a serious problem arose relating to this definition. The discussion centred on what could be considered as ‘closely adjacent to sheltered waters’52 and, in the case of a State comprised of islands (e.g., an archipelago), what are ‘inland waters’.53 The first issue was initially raised by the Final Act and Any Instruments, Resolutions and Recommendations Resulting from the Work of the Conference, Attachment to the Final Act of the Conference Resolution , The Manila Amendments to the annex to the STCW, , Text adopted by the Conference, Conference of Parties to the STCW Convention, , July , IMO Doc. No. STCW/CONF./, available at http://www.md.go.th/seaman/pdf/STCW-CONF.-.pdf [hereinafter Manila Amendments]. However principles were adopted (Section A/) to guide determinations including: “. It is not intended that ships engaged on near-coastal voyages shall should extend their voyages worldwide, under the excuse that they are navigating constantly within the limits of designated nearcoastal voyages of neighbouring Parties.” 51 See discussion below at note on Article II, paragraph . 52 As noted by the representative of Canada at the th ILC, supra note : . The Government member of Canada responded by expressing the hope that a solution satisfactory to all parties would be found, for example, one based on language such as “near-coastal voyages” which existed in other international instruments, and was well understood in the context of the IMO. Article II offered no flexibility with regard to a domestic fleet engaged in near-coastal voyages, and those vessels would not meet the requirements of the Convention. Hence, a provision was needed to make it possible for Governments to apply certain exemptions at the national level. Clearly, it would be very difficult to add the necessary flexibility to each and every provision. The best way would therefore be an overall flexibility provision, which he felt would be supported by many countries. He also recalled that, although Canada was not particularly significant in terms of tonnage, it was a major port State. He therefore called on the Committee to engage in dialogue with a view to agreeing upon an instrument that was attractive to all the various parties. 53
Ibid.,
. The Chairperson announced that, at the request of the Steering Committee, a Working Party had been established on Article II, paragraph (i), with the following task: to identify and clarify certain questions that had been raised with respect to the determination of ships that could be considered as navigating exclusively in inland waters or in waters within, or closely adjacent to, sheltered waters or areas where port regulations applied. . . . . The Working Party reported to the Steering Committee on its deliberations. An alternative approach was adopted to resolve the issue at hand. . The President of the Conference recalled that, when it became clear that the Working Party on Article II, paragraph (i), had not been in a position to elucidate the problem before it the problem had been referred to him by the Steering Committee for solution with the assistance of the “Friends of the President”. After discussion with some of the Members most interested in the amendments involving that question, it became clear that some of the detailed provisions of the Code of the proposed Convention could cause real administrative problems for certain countries in the case of smaller ships. He had, therefore, considered that some further flexibility in the Convention would be desirable in order not to prejudice the objective of wide-scale ratification of the Convention. He had discussed the problem with Members strongly opposed to the amendments concerned.
principles and rights
Canada, the United States, and Australia, all large coastal States with significant coastal trading activity, usually within their nautical mile exclusive economic zones.54 The difficulty with the term ‘internal waters’ related to a They had shown a very understanding attitude, but had naturally been concerned that any flexibility agreed would be strictly limited to the perceived problem and would not in any way affect the concept of a level playing field. He had therefore drafted a proposal for text which sought to meet those two concerns. The text would relate only to cases where particular problems were caused to a Government with respect to specific details in the Code. The Government, in consultation with its social partners, would be allowed to deal with those details by providing appropriate protection to seafarers in the manner set out under its national laws or regulations or other measures. The national provisions would of course have to comply with the Articles and Regulations of the Convention. His proposal would consist of an additional paragraph after Article II, paragraph , and a change to the present paragraph . . . . . Following these explanations, the Worker Vice-Chairperson expressed his group’s support for the proposal. The Workers’ group understood, however, that the proposal represented a global solution for all problems raised by different countries, including the Philippines. The Workers’ group only agreed on the basis that there would be no further discussions on this aspect of the Convention’s scope of application. 54 Given the likely importance of this issue for future implementation activity and the work of the ILO’s supervisory with the Article reports, a lengthy extract from the preparatory records is set out. Committee of the Whole Report, supra note :
. The Government member of Canada reaffirmed his country’s commitment to work towards a good Convention which was widely acceptable and could be ratified by many countries. However, the draft instrument in its current reading still raised concerns for his country with regard to its application to the domestic fleet. Although the provisions concerning “no more favourable treatment” and “substantial equivalence” allowed for a certain degree of flexibility, the Convention was generally drawn up in rigid, “black-or white” terms and its application to the domestic fleet would give rise to great difficulties The speaker observed that Note of the Office Office report had included the statement that “the Convention should not place unacceptable administrative and financial burdens on shipowners and governments by requiring all of its provisions to be applied with respect to ships of any size and any kind”. Article II did not offer sufficient flexibility in terms of applying relaxed requirements to the domestic fleet where necessary, ... . The Government member of Australia expressed concern that the Convention did not seem to take sufficiently into account national circumstances. . . . . The Government member of the United States supported the views expressed by the Government member of Canada. Although her country would like to ratify the Convention, some further flexibility was needed, either through an overall flexibility clause, or by relaxing the wording of individual provisions. The intention was not to weaken the Convention, but to provide the necessary flexibility so that the instrument could be widely ratified and provide coverage to as many seafarers as possible. . The Worker Vice-Chairperson . . . reiterated the position of the Workers’ group that, if confronted by any systematic attempt to exclude entire categories of seafarers, classes of ships or sectors of the industry, it would be preferable to retain the protection afforded by existing maritime Conventions. Certain governments were unlikely ever to ratify the Convention, while many others considered that the Convention was sufficiently flexible to meet their needs. . . .
chapter six
particular constitutional problem for the Philippines and the complex situation under LOSC whereby the Philippines has taken the view that the waters between the islands, irrespective of distances, are ‘internal waters’, a status that the Philippines suggested could be equated to ‘inland waters’.55 If this is correct, it would also have provided precedent for several other geographically similar States to exclude a number of ships (and seafarers on those ships) from the Convention. The underlying concern in all cases, irrespective of the geographic particulars, relates to the economics of coverage of additional workers and ships, particularly those engaged in domestic trade routes. These ships, even those with larger tonnages, are often not regulated or certified in the same way as ships
. The Worker Vice-Chairperson recalled that the definition of “near-coastal voyages” was “voyages in the vicinity of a Party as defined by that Party”. If the flexibility sought by Canada were to be given to all ratifying countries, the actual coverage of the Convention would be very different from that intended. . . . . The Government member of Australia supported the concerns expressed by the Government member of Canada. Previously, his delegation had raised some doubt as to whether the “substantial equivalence” clause was in itself sufficient to ensure that national circumstances were duly taken into account. . . . . The representative of the Secretary-General responded that the proposed Convention was unprecedented in terms of the detailed explanatory information available as to the evolution of each provision over the four years of preparatory work. Hence, the real intention of the drafters should be clear. Also, unlike the Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, (No. ), the proposed maritime labour Convention contained a clear definition of “substantial equivalence” in Article VI. The Committee of Experts would be relieved to have so many elements on which to evaluate compliance. She concluded by recalling that a Special Tripartite Committee was provided for by the Convention and would provide useful inputs to the Committee of Experts with regard to the practical application of the Convention. 55
Article of the Constitution of the Republic of the Philippines () provides: The national territory comprises the Philippine archipelago, with all the islands and waters embraced therein, and all other territories over which the Philippines has sovereignty or jurisdiction, consisting of its terrestrial, fluvial and aerial domains, including its territorial sea, the seabed, the subsoil, the insular shelves, and other submarine areas. The waters around, between, and connecting the islands of the archipelago, regardless of their breadth and dimensions, form part of the internal waters of the Philippines.
Both propositions seem difficult under LOSC, supra note , with its compromise status solution of ‘archipelagic waters’, especially as the Philippines is a State party. Irrespective of the merits of this view under LOSC, it appears the Philippines was able to ratify STCW with similar wording. However the underlying issue regarding application to the inter-island domestic fleet may have been less difficult, possibly because of the near-coastal voyage concept. The situation is especially complex as the Philippines is the country of nationality/residence for a very large number of the world’s seafarers, and therefore, presumably a beneficiary of the MLC, . However, it is also a flag State with a large domestic, rather than international, fleet.
principles and rights
engaged on international voyages and are not subject to port State control. The solution56 to both concerns was a scope provision (Article II, paragraph , as discussed below in connection with scope and in cases of doubt and flexibility) which addressed the underlying problem of providing some flexibility regarding application of the Convention to domestic fleets, without determining that those ships are not ‘ships’ under the Convention. However, the issue of coverage of smaller ships and domestic voyages is likely to remain a challenge as national authorities grapple with the problem of application to specific sectors57 of the industry. The economic questions that arise will undoubtedly result in a close examination of how to work within the boundaries of the definition of ships. While there was no opinion of the ILO Legal Adviser on the matter, it seems obvious that the usual international obligations58 regarding good faith would apply. In addition, although the definition of a ship is based on the STCW definition, the MLC, and the STCW have differing concerns and contain differing concepts. For example, the STCW also contains the concept of near-coastal voyages while the MLC, , in Article II, paragraph , addresses the application of certain details in the Code to ships of less than GT that do not go on international voyages. The latter clearly indicates that the Convention is understood as apply to ship of all sizes in the domestic fleet. While there is some flexibility and scope for national determinations based on the definition of a ship, it would be a highly unusual geographic configuration that would result in the exclusion of the entire domestic fleet, if only as a matter of good faith. Figure sets out a possible methodology or approach that national authorities might use to consider these specific application questions.
56
This was brought about through intervention by ‘Friends of the President’ (see Chapter ). For example, the application of structural requirements to commercially operated yachts and other smaller ships. 58 The Vienna Convention on the Law Treaties (supra note ) points out in Article (pacta sunt servanda) that, “Every treaty in force is binding upon the parties to it and must be performed by them in good faith”. As set out in note , Article , paragraph , provides the general rule of interpretation that “A treaty shall be interpreted in good faith in accordance with the ordinary meaning to be given to the terms of the treaty in their context and in the light of its object and purpose”. Any interpretation would also need to take into account the nature of the convention as a consolidating convention in relation to the obligations under Article of the ILO’s Constitution. See also the opinion of the ILO’s Legal Adviser in connection with the term ‘satisfy itself ’ in Article III, as set out at page infra, and see note , para. . 57
chapter six
Figure . Guidance59 for an approach to the implementation of the MLC, (a) . . . its purpose is to suggest an approach that the Government of a country may wish to follow in determining the extent to which its laws and regulations and other measures would need to be adjusted or complemented to meet the requirements of the Maritime Labour Convention, (“the Convention”). It is a first step towards ratification of the Convention, which is designed to facilitate the second step, namely the preparation (or finalization) by the Government, in a tripartite framework of a matrix showing: – the extent to which a country’s law or practice already meets the Convention’s requirements, especially with respect to domestic shipping, and – in the case of gaps or inconsistencies: – the extent to which national law or practice can be adjusted, and – the provisions of the Convention for which such adjustment would be difficult. Overview of the approach (b) With this approach, the Government would: – first, exclude from its consideration ships that are not covered by the Convention; – second, take account of the exclusions or exemptions that may be made in accordance with the Convention: – either in the case of a provision or provisions causing difficulty anywhere in the Code contained in the Convention, – or with respect to particular provisions or to a particular category of provisions; – third, take account of the flexibility that is provided under the Convention, – for implementing the requirements of the Convention in general (i.e., flexibility in the form of substantial equivalence and flexibility related to the status of Part B of the Code, and – for choosing the legal means of implementing the requirements (i.e., through legislation or other measures, and – for implementing particular provisions; – ensure that social dialogue can be put into operation, especially in all cases where it is a precondition to deciding upon an exclusion or exemption or exercising flexibility under the Convention; and – finally, – identify the gaps in the coverage of the Convention’s requirements under the country’s laws and regulations and other measures, with respect to certain ships or certain seafarers that are covered by the Convention, and – consider how those gaps might be filled, taking account of the flexibility provided under the Convention.
59
Extract and edited proposals for an approach prepared in . On file with the co-author.
principles and rights
The term ‘shipowner’ in Article II, paragraph (j) is aligned with the IMO conventions and is almost identical to the definition of ‘company’60 found in the ISM Code to SOLAS and the STCW. It also based on, inter alia, the definition in the ILO’s Convention No. .61 This comprehensive and complex definition has been designed to capture all known variations on corporate organizational, management, and operational practices in the sector. Importantly it specifically reflects the principle that ‘shipowners’ (as defined) are the responsible employers under the Convention with respect to all seafarers on board a ship.62 At the th ILC, the last clause of paragraph (j), “. . . regardless of whether any other organization or persons fulfil certain of the duties or responsibilities on behalf of the shipowner”, was added and the word ‘agent’ proposed as a deletion. The reasons and concerns were explained as follows: . The Government member of the United Kingdom explained that the amendment comprised two elements. The deletion of the word “agent” was proposed solely for the sake of consistency, since a very similar definition of “shipowners” was provided in the International Safety Management (ISM) Code, . The additional text had been drafted to clarify the provision and remove any uncertainty regarding the definition of regarding the definition of a shipowner. . . . . The Government member of Japan indicated that he would oppose the amendment, which would modify wording which was basically that contained in several international Conventions, including the SOLAS and STCW Conventions, the International Ship and Port Facility Security (ISPS) Code and ILO Conventions No. and the Seafarers’ Hours of Work and the Manning of Ships Convention, (No. ). By introducing new language, there was a danger that serious
60 International Convention for the Safety of Life at Sea, , London, November , U.N.T.S. , as amended (SOLAS), Chapter IX of the Annex, Regulation , para. ; IMO Resolution A.(), International Safety Management (ISM) Code, , available at http://www.imo .org/SharePoint/mainframe.asp?topic_id=, para. ..; and STCW, supra note , Amended Annex, Chapter , Regulation I/, paragraph .. 61 Article , paragraph (c). See also: Final Report, supra note , Annex , Report of the Drafting Group on Definitions, which had considered adding another definition of employer:
. Re: adding a new definition of “employer” It was concluded that the current definition of shipowner, which is consistent with ILO and IMO Conventions, should be retained. It was decided that the term “employer” should be defined in the specific parts of the Code where it is used and should not be defined in the Articles. 62
Report I(A), supra note , Note (Article II): . . . . The definition reflects the principle that shipowners are the responsible employers under the Convention with respect to all seafarers on board their ships, without prejudice to the right of the shipowner to recover the costs involved from others who may also have responsibility for the employment of a particular seafarer. This is expressly stated in Standard A. (paragraph ) on repatriation.
chapter six administrative difficulties could be caused if the meaning of the term “shipowner” differed from that used in other related instruments Moreover if, as indicated by the sponsors of the amendment, there was no intent to introduce a substantive change, the amendment was not needed. Rather than increasing clarity, its effect would be to amplify uncertainties. The problem arose in situations in which a particular shipowner (“A”) decided to delegate certain operating or managerial responsibilities to another party (“B”), who would then pass certain responsibilities to a third party (“C”) making it extremely difficult for the seafarer or the public authorities to identify the party truly responsible for fulfilling the obligations under the Convention, for example in relation to the payment of wages. The risk was that the proposed new wording would create a situation in which responsibilities could be endlessly passed from one party to another and in which it would be very difficult to identify the actual shipowner. The inclusion of such a clause would help unscrupulous shipowners to avoid their responsibilities.
In the end the word ‘agent’ was not deleted, but the proposed clause was adopted. Importantly, despite some debate over wording, the forgoing indicates there was a clear tripartite consensus on the idea that shipowners should be the central point for responsibility, irrespective of individual contractual arrangements.63 The practical issue raised by vesting responsibility for all seafarers in the shipowner is the situation of seafarers employed (also) by another employer. A possible approach with respect to contractual arrangements in relation to the requirement under Regulation . (requiring a SEA between the shipowner (or representative) and the seafarer) is discussed in Chapter . Scope of Application—Article II, Paragraphs and To determine who or what the MLC, applies to, both the definition and, perhaps even more importantly, the scope of application provisions must be considered. This section examines the provisions that are truly scope (Article II, paragraph (seafarers) and (ships)). The balance of scope of application provisions (Article II, paragraphs , , , and ) dealing with borderline cases “in the event of doubt” as to application and with a possible exercise of national flexibility for some ships will be considered in the following section. Scope proved to be one of the most difficult issues to resolve during the development of the MLC, . This is not surprising and would be the case in the negotiation of most treaties. Questions of scope, irrespective whether they are rolled into the definitions or dealt with separately, requires that the discussion
63
Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention (Preliminary Second Draft), Commentary, HLTWG, (Fourth Meeting), Nantes, , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-r-.pdf [hereinafter Office Report], Comment (on Article II).
principles and rights
move from general considerations of principles and rights to that of application, that is, which sectors will be affected/regulated and, in the case of the MLC, , which seafarers are to be protected (or not). In either case, important economic consequences and policy considerations turn on these determinations. In the MLC, this issue coalesced around the question of whether there should be a general tonnage limitation for the application of the entire Convention. Such a limitation, for example, GT, would generally follow the approach adopted in other international maritime conventions,64 with their focus on larger ships that go on international voyages. Thus domestic fleets have been left largely in the realm of national legislation rather than subject to international standards and, critically, not affected by the increasingly effective ship certification and shipboard level port State control enforcement regime. As the above discussion on the definition of a ship indicated, the question of coverage of ships that do not travel internationally, and smaller tonnage ships, (i.e., primarily the domestic fleet), was not resolved at the PTMC in , despite the efforts of working parties. Agreement on the majority of the provisions on the scope of application was achieved, only very late in the process, on the basis of a tripartite consensus on a negotiated package of solutions at the Intersessional Meeting in . The Office Report for the th ILC outlined this package as follows (with italicized text showing the agreed to principles and solutions adopted to implement them).65 – . . . This overall package consists of the following carefully balanced set of principles developed through a working group process, as the best way to address the difficult questions regarding the scope of application mentioned [above], including application of the Convention to ships operating within its flag State’s waters only: There would be no general or overall exclusion of ships below a certain gross tonnage or of ships not engaged in international voyages; however, the Convention could include some specific scope-related provisions under the various Titles to address particular concerns about application. It was therefore agreed that the words “Except as expressly provided otherwise,” should be added at the beginning of Article II, paragraph , of the Convention (as previously indicated). – Ships below a certain gross tonnage, which might be gross tonnage or less, could be excluded from the application of certain provisions of Title on accommodation. A provision corresponding to paragraph of Standard A. was accordingly agreed. It allows Members, after tripartite consultation, to exempt ships below a
64 For example, SOLAS, supra note , and the International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships, London, November , U.N.T.S. , as amended by Protocol of relating to the International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships of , London, February , U.N.T.S. (MARPOL /). 65 Report I(A), supra note , Note (Article II), para. . References to other parts of this Report have been removed. See also: Unresolved Issues, supra note , Note (Article II), para. .
– –
– – –
chapter six certain gross tonnage from the requirements of specified provisions on accommodation, taking account of the size of the ship and the number of persons on board and subject to the general rule on exemptions set out in paragraph of the Standard. Article II would not contain any provision allowing the exclusion of ships not engaged in international voyages. The certification requirements in Title would apply to ships of gross tonnage or over that either are engaged in international voyages or are operating in foreign ports. This limitation of the scope of application is contained in the first part of a new paragraph of Regulation .. The concept of an international voyage should be based on the definition in the SOLAS Convention. A definition which follows this approach is found in the second part of the new paragraph of Regulation ... The certification system under Title must be available, on request, to shipowners that request a certificate, even if the ship is not required to have a certificate. This is provided for in the new paragraph of Regulation ... Control measures in port States for ships that do not have a certificate would follow existing port state control practice already used with respect to IMO conventions for ships below “convention size”.
As explained above in connection with the definition of a ship, even with this package, these issues were still controversial at the th ILC. In fact, to the extent that these solutions did not meet particular concerns, the focus shifted to reducing the scope of application through use of the definitions. However, the above solutions and several other elements, for example, provisions in Title to address construction and equipment of existing (older) ships, were, except for the issue of ships in the domestic fleet, for the most part adopted as proposed. The package of principles, involving considerations cutting across several Titles, including, importantly, the enforcement provisions on the certification66 of working and living conditions on ships, is illustrative of both the complexity of the issues and the need to appreciate the careful linkages between provisions in the Convention. As discussed above in connection with Article II, paragraph , reference was made to the use of the formula ‘unless or except as expressly provided otherwise’ to allow for the possibility of narrowing coverage in specific parts of the Convention. It was noted that there are no examples of this use in connection with the definitions. The same formula is used for the two scope provisions on ships and seafarers. There are also no provisions narrowing application of any provisions for seafarers. The result is that, as paragraph states, “. . . this Convention applies to all seafarers” (on ships covered by the Convention). However, there is some flexibility available ‘in the event of doubt’ (see the discussion in the following section regarding paragraph ). 66
See Chapter .
principles and rights
In the case of ships, there is some narrowing of the application with exclusions in the scope provision in paragraph , as well as ‘expressly provided otherwise’ situations in Article II and in Title in relation to the application of some provisions to older ships and smaller ships.67 In accordance with paragraph , the Convention applies to all ships (as defined in paragraph (i), based on geographic parameters), whether publically or privately owned, “ordinarily engaged in commercial activities”.68 Paragraph also contains only a very few exclusions for ships engaged in fishing or similar pursuits69 and ships of 67 Report I(A), supra note , Note (Article II), para. . However, arguably the specific, narrowed application of some provisions may not be cases of non-application of the Convention. 68 Committee of the Whole Report, supra note . With respect to the term ‘ordinarily’, a proposal was made to remove it but not accepted:
. The Worker Vice-Chairperson observed that the issue raised by amendment D. had already been discussed at previous meetings. Discussion had revolved around ships that had been taken away from their commercial activities for one voyage to carry government cargo. Leaving the term “ordinarily” in this provision would mean that those ships were covered by the Convention, since their non-commercial activities were only occasional. It had been argued that the UNCLOS Article provisions on sovereignty were relevant to this issue; however, those provisions only related to the protection and preservation of the marine environment and so were not applicable in this case. Being on board a ship requisitioned for one non-commercial voyage was not sufficient reason to remove those seafarers from the protection of this Convention. The term ‘ordinarily’ was also used in earlier ILO Conventions, for example, C (in ) up to about C. C, supra note , adopted in , used the following formula (Art. , para. ): . Except as otherwise provided in this Article, this Convention applies to every sea-going ship, whether publicly or privately owned, which is engaged in the transport of cargo or passengers for the purpose of trade or is employed for any other commercial purpose. . National laws or regulations shall determine when ships are to be regarded as sea-going ships for the purpose of this Convention. Interestingly, the formulation differed in two conventions adopted in . A version of the C formulation was adopted in Convention No. on social security, as part of the definition of seafarers (ship and vessel were used interchangeably): Article (c) the term seafarers means persons employed in any capacity on board a seagoing ship which is engaged in the transport of cargo or passengers for the purpose of trade, is utilised for any other commercial purpose or is a seagoing tug, with the exception of persons employed on . . . On the other hand, Convention No. , on repatriation, contained the following definition, which is closer to the MLC, and earlier formulations (Art. , para. ): This Convention applies to every seagoing ship whether publicly or privately owned which is registered in the territory of any Member for which the Convention is in force and which is ordinarily engaged in commercial maritime navigation and to the owners and seafarers of such ships. 69
In the early stages of the development of the Convention there was debate about the exclusion of fishing vessels. However, the ILO Governing Body took what proved to be a wise decision
chapter six
traditional build such as dhows or junks. In addition an exclusion for warships or naval auxiliaries was adopted by the th ILC after debate on the question of when a ship would be considered an auxiliary.70 The other exclusions in paragraph were the subject of extensive discussion, especially during the PTMC in and the Intersessional Meeting in , mainly in connection with the tonnage limitation71 and also whether to include to develop a new comprehensive convention specifically addressing working and living conditions for fishers. This sector is much more disparate in both ownership and employment relationships and economic considerations, as well as in its representation in tripartite discussions, than the ‘maritime’ sector. Initially, this new convention tried to follow the approach taken in the MLC, but this was not adopted by the ILC in a very close vote in June . See: Nineteenth sitting, ILC, rd Session, June , ILO Doc. No. PR , p. , curiously the recommendation was adopted. Subsequently a reformatted convention and recommendation were adopted in , the Work in Fishing Convention, (No. ), Geneva, June , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm, and the Work in Fishing Recommendation, (No. ), Geneva, June , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/recdisp.htm. The parameters of ‘fishing’ in the MLC, are not defined, but the predecessor effort at consolidation in , C, supra note , made specific exclusions in Article , paragraph (). “This Convention does not apply to . . . (b) ships engaged in fishing or in whaling or in similar pursuits”. The Working Fishing Convention, , which is in force, defines commercial fishing in Article I, paragraph (a) as “all fishing operations, including fishing operations on rivers, lakes or canals, with the exception of subsistence fishing and recreational fishing”. 70 This exclusion was an important concern for a few governments that required express exclusion rather than relying on the implicit exclusion related to commercial operations and the fact that port State control would not extend to foreign warships. Committee of the Whole Report, supra note : . The Worker Vice-Chairperson pointed out that the wording in Article III(a) of the STCW Convention was the same . . . He reminded the Committee of an earlier discussion on the term “ordinarily engaged” that had already addressed the exclusion of warships. His group could understand the reasons for a short, explicit exclusion of warships and naval auxiliaries, but did not support the full language found in the STCW Convention. It was not clear why privately owned ships which just happened to transport state-owned cargo should be exempt from the inspection of the seafarers’ working and living conditions on board. These inspections would not concern the cargo but would focus only on labour issues, such as food and water supplies on board and crew accommodation. . . . . The Government member of Norway expressed the view that warships and naval auxiliaries were already exempt, in virtue of the wording of Article II, paragraph . Since these vessels could not be understood to be “ordinarily engaged in commercial activities”, they fell outside the scope of the Convention. An explicit exemption was therefore unnecessary. . The Government member of the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela indicated that an explicit exemption was necessary, since some naval vessels were in fact engaged in commercial activities. . The Government member of the United States reiterated her delegation’s desire for an explicit exclusion of warships and naval auxiliaries. Such exemption would be in line with other international instruments. She supported the suggestion to ask the Drafting Committee to devise appropriate wording. 71
For example, extract from Committee No. Report, supra note , shows the nature of the debate:
principles and rights
a proposed exclusion for offshore exploration or exploitation rigs or mobile offshore drilling units (MODUs). These structures present special difficulties as to their ‘maritime’ status as they are not always regarded as ships or necessarily regulated by the flag States72 when not navigating. They were partially excluded from the major existing ILO maritime convention, C, “. . . when not engaged in navigation”73 and other conventions on the basis of consultation.74 At the PTMC there was extensive discussion of the issue, and a working group was struck to resolve the issue. The resolution they reached was to not . The Shipowner Vice-Chairperson proposed keeping the text of Article , paragraph , subparagraph (a) and to limit the scope of the Convention to ships of more than gross tons. . The Seafarer Vice-Chairperson said that the rights of seafarers should not be related to the size of the ship they work on; issues such as hours of work and minimum working conditions were not tonnage related. He therefore proposed that subparagraph (a) be removed. . The Government member of the United Kingdom agreed. It was of fundamental importance to protect seafarers with this Convention. He suggested introducing size limits of ships in Titles and , as the absence of such limits in some cases would create a serious burden to the governments for regular inspection. . The Government member of the Netherlands stated that seafarers had rights on small vessels as well but agreed with the Government member of the United Kingdom regarding the burden to the Governments for regular inspection of small vessels. Report of the Discussion, Tripartite Intersessional Meeting on the Follow-up of the PTMC, Geneva, – April , ILO Doc. No. PTMC//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/ english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/ptmc/ptmc-.pdf: . The Seafarer spokesperson agreed that the Convention should be ratifiable, but disagreed with the Shipowner spokesperson on the definition of ships to be covered by it. He recalled the importance of compliance and enforcement in this Convention. The Convention ought to cover all seafarers, whether on large or small vessels and whether in domestic or worldwide trade. He could not accept that seafarers on vessels of less than gross tons or trading in national waters did not require protection. In fact, seafarers on these vessels might need more protection rather than less. Thus, the Convention should apply to all ships, irrespective of size or trade. Arguments to the contrary would have to be very convincing. Institutionalized “maritime apartheid” was unacceptable. Referring to exceptions in the application of the Convention, i.e. ships engaged in fishing or in similar pursuits and traditional vessels, he saw these as clear cases . . . 72 See also: Final Report, supra note , Annex , Report of the Working Party on Tonnage Issues in the draft proposed Convention. For example, under MARPOL /, supra note , Article , Definitions, “() Administration means the Government of the State under whose authority the ship is operating. . . . With respect to fixed or floating platforms engaged in exploration and exploitation of the seabed and subsoil thereof adjacent to the coast over which the coastal State exercises sovereign rights for the purposes of exploration and exploitation of their natural resources, the Administration is the Government of the coastal State concerned”. 73 C, supra note , Art. , para. . 74 Recruitment and Placement of Seafarers Convention, (No. ), Geneva, October , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm, Art. , para. .
chapter six
include an exclusion in paragraph , rather the Convention would be silent on the matter and each flag State could decide for itself whether an MODU would be covered or not. The result is that the Convention does not exclude MODUs and, presumably, they would be covered if or when the flag State regards them as a ship under the Convention’s definition. This is essentially the status quo. The status of MODUs is a potentially important and divisive issue, as is the related issue regarding the dredging industry. This issue did not recur at the th ILC75 in . Thus, the discussion at the PTMC regarding a proposed exclusion, “(d) for oil rigs and drilling platforms [when not engaged in navigation]. (modified C.A/(c))”, is reproduced below76 (emphasis added): . The Shipowner Vice-Chairperson stated that the text in square brackets in Article II, paragraph , subparagraph (d) should be deleted, since the Convention should not apply to oil rigs and drilling platforms. The Government member of Norway agreed, stating that the suggested text would mean that during repositioning, a different legal regime would need to be applied to the same rig. . The Seafarer Vice-Chairperson noted that different types of mobile maritime drilling units existed, some with large seafarer crews and others with much smaller seafarer crews. In both cases, seafarers that were not covered by shore regulations needed to be identified and covered by the Convention. . The Government member of the United Kingdom stated that fixed rigs were treated as land-based structures and, as such, were not under the jurisdiction of the maritime authority. When rigs were not drilling but were being moved they were treated as vessels. The suggested text should be kept, allowing the provisions to be applied to rigs in movement and excluding fixed rigs. . The Seafarer Vice-Chairperson reiterated that seafarers were still present on board mobile maritime offshore units even when fixed, and suggested examining the formulation concerning seafarers serving on maritime mobile offshore units found in Article I, paragraph of the Recruitment and Placement of Seafarers Convention, (No. ) . The Government member of the Netherlands drew the attention of the Committee to the dredging sector, which, according to the present definitions for “seafarer” and “ship”, would fall in the ambit of the Convention. Dredgers were seagoing vessels registered as ships and had certificates of seaworthiness. While suction dredgers were not self-propelled, mostly worked in a stationary position in ports and could not navigate, hopper dredgers were self-propelled. Due to their special structure, they would not satisfy the requirements of the Convention relating to accommodation or other provisions. Suction dredgers should be exempted from the Convention, and appropriate flexibility regarding accommodation requirements should be applied for hopper dredgers. 75
Although there was a discussion in connection with Regulation . regarding medical care, which suggests that it was assumed that MODUs would be covered. See: Committee of the Whole Report, supra note , paras –. 76 Committee No. Report, supra note .
principles and rights
. The Seafarer Vice-Chairperson felt that these concerns were sufficiently covered in paragraph , subparagraph (i), and paragraph . . The Government member of Mexico suggested deleting the text in square brackets in paragraph , subparagraph (d). The main purpose of drilling platforms was the exploration and production of petroleum, not navigation. If these platforms were treated as ships, any person employed on-board, including drilling and other petroleum specialists, would need to be considered to be a seafarer in accordance with Article II paragraph (i). However, provisions such as wages, port state inspection, working conditions and working schedules were not applicable to them. The Government of Mexico would not be able to ratify the Convention if the suggested wording was allowed to remain. The Government members of Denmark and Norway supported the deletion of the text in square brackets. . The Government member of the Republic of Korea pointed out that the suggested wording originated from Article I paragraph (c) of the Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, (No. ). Since this wording created a volatile legal situation, the subparagraph (d) should read “permanently fixed oil rigs and drilling platforms”. Personnel on-board platforms other than seafarers could be excluded according to paragraph , after consultation. . The Seafarer Vice-Chairperson deemed the proposal by the Government member of the Republic of Korea to be helpful, since fixed drilling platforms needed to be distinguished from self-powered mobile platforms. Since his group wanted all seafarers on moveable platforms to be protected, even while these units were anchored to the seabed and drilling, it would only agree with the deletion of the bracketed text, if they were adequately protected as other workers on platforms. A situation where seafarers on moveable platforms would be treated as seafarers under IMO instruments (e.g. the International Convention on Standards of Training, Certification and Watchkeeping for Seafarers, (STCW) and the International Safety Management Code, ), but would not fall under this Convention and would not be adequately covered otherwise, needed to be avoided. . The Government member of the United Kingdom stressed that moving mobile offshore drilling units were considered ships under IMO regulations, as well as in ILO Conventions Nos. and . . The Government member of Norway did not support the proposal by the Government member of the Republic of Korea. The act of navigation should not automatically lead to a different legal regime for one and the same activity. Therefore, the concept of temporary application of the Convention needed to be abolished. The Government member of Mexico supported this position. . The Government member of Qatar suggested that the whole of subparagraph (d) should be deleted, since working conditions on oil rigs and platforms were generally better than on ships. The Seafarer Vice-Chairperson expressed interest for this proposal. . The Committee set up a tripartite Working Party on this issue comprising Government members from Mexico, Norway and the United Kingdom; Shipowner members from Denmark, France, Mexico and Norway; and Seafarer members from the Netherlands, Norway and Sweden. . The Government member of Norway reported that in its first discussion the Working Party had identified six possible options: . . .
chapter six
. He concluded that the Working Party had done as much as had been possible within its remit . . .. . The Seafarer Vice-Chairperson suggested that the Working Party should reexamine the issue with the participation of the IMO, as it had great experience in the application of maritime instruments in the area of mobile maritime offshore units. Although it was clear that different countries had different regimes, the important thing was to ensure that all seafarers were adequately protected and to recognize that some people employed on offshore rigs were in fact seafarers. . The Government member of Mexico supported this suggestion. The emphasis needed to be on formulating a text that would ensure all seafarers on rigs were covered by the Convention, while excluding all those who were not seafarers. . It was agreed that the Working Party should reconvene, with some written suggestions from the Office. At the suggestion of the Government member of the United Kingdom, it was agreed that one or two additional Government members could participate, in view of the divergent views of the three existing Government members. . The Government member of Norway said that the Working Party had at first not reached a common position. The Seafarers’ group had proposed a new draft, which had not been accepted by the Shipowners and was considered problematic by the Government members. Finally, the Working Party suggested deleting paragraph , subparagraph (d) in its entirety, thereby leaving the Convention silent on this issue. This would mean States could apply the provisions fully, partially or not at all to these vessels, at their discretion.
A further application difficulty in connection with paragraph relates to the decision not to include an exclusion for commercially-operated yachts, particularly when this is combined with no tonnage limitation. An exclusion of ships powered in part or entirely by sail had often been included in previous ILO conventions.77 For some countries there are problems in applying the Convention, particularly in relation to seafarer accommodation requirements for smaller yachts that are either fully or seasonally commercially operated and travel internationally, for example, sailing between small island States. There is some flexibility78 with respect to the accommodation requirements for ships less than GT. However, commercially operated yachts between GT and GT or over (the ‘super yachts’) indicate that they may have some difficulty complying 77
For example, C, supra note , Art. , para. , provides: This Convention does not apply to – (a) ships primarily propelled by sail, whether or not they are fitted with auxiliary engines; . . . (c) small vessels and vessels such as oil rigs and drilling platforms when not engaged in navigation, the decision as to which vessels are covered by this subparagraph to be taken by the competent authority in each country in consultation with the most representative organisations of shipowners and seafarers.
78
See Standard A., para. . See also Chapter .
principles and rights
with the construction and equipment related requirements for seafarers’ accommodation.79 Many of these difficulties can probably be addressed through national social dialogue and the application of flexibility using substantial equivalence (under Article VI).80 Alternatively, these questions of application to specific sectors of the maritime industry may be in the category of issues that will be considered by the Special Tripartite Committee (MLC, , Article XIII), once it is established. Application Issues (Doubt and Flexibility)—Article II, Paragraphs , , , and In addition to the definitions and the two scope provisions set out above, Article II contains provisions (paragraphs , , and ) that provide some national flexibility to deal with particularly difficult application problems and address borderline cases where a determination on application can be made either in or after consultation with the seafarers’ or shipowners’ organizations concerned. Aside from specific issues of wording, there are two more subtle textual points in these provisions. The first point to note is that the Convention adopts various terms to describe the exercise of discretion or flexibility by either the ratifying State or its competent authority. In most cases81 these decisions are described as ‘determines’ or determinations. In all cases this term signals an obligation to engage in consultation with the relevant social partners. The second related point is the distinction between the terms ‘in consultation’ and ‘after consultation’. The phrase ‘after consultation’ is used in paragraphs and and the phrase ‘in consultation’ in paragraph .82 These two phrases were the subject to an opinion83 by the ILO’s Legal Adviser at the third meeting of the HLTWG in : . . . . the two terms were not absolutely identical but that there was a difference between them in respect of the continuity of the process of consultation. In the event of the term “in consultation with the shipowners’ and seafarers’ organizations”, it would be a continuous process of consultation. In the event of the term “after consultation with the shipowners’ and seafarers’ organizations”, the process of consultation would be completed once the decision had been taken, and that decision would be taken once and for all. . . .
79
Standard A.. This appears to be the case even for ships that are still to be built. See Final Report, Preparatory Tripartite MLC, Committee, Geneva, – September , ILO Doc. No. PTMLC/, available at http://www.ilo.org/wcmsp/groups/public/ed_norm/-normes/documents/meetingdocument/wcms_.pdf, paras – and . 81 In Title , the term ‘permit’ or ‘variance’ is also used. 82 See also the exchange on this matter at the th ILC, Committee of the Whole Report, supra note , paras and. 83 Final Report, supra note , paras –. 80
chapter six
. A Government representative asked whether she understood the meaning of continuous process correctly. Before issuing legislation, her Government sent the draft text to the social partners for comments, but only some of them were taken into account. She inquired whether, for the purpose of a continuous process, it was necessary to contact them again. . The Legal Adviser answered that the understanding of the Government representative was correct. He explained that the continuous process did not mean that the Government had to revert to the issue, once the decision had been taken. However, the question whether to continue to exclude that category of vessels might be raised again and be re-examined depending on the developments in general and in the decision. In this way the process became a continuous process. . . . . The Legal Adviser clarified that consultations did not represent negotiations. It was not necessary to have an agreement, but rather consultations with the social partners in good faith and with good will. The results of those consultations, i.e. the opinions expressed by the social partners, were to be considered fairly and justly, which did not mean that an agreement had to be reached. “In consultation”, therefore, did not require an agreement, but rather implied that the consultation process might continue depending on the circumstances.
A further complication, particularly for countries with open registries, is ascertaining who to consult if the country does not have a representative organization for seafarers or for shipowners, or if the national organization which does exist only represents seafarers and shipowners in its domestic fleet, not its international fleet. One of the underlying ILO approaches and themes in the Convention is strengthening and supporting national social dialogue to encourage establishment of national representative organizations in the long term. Recognizing this problem, the MLC, provides an innovative, global industry solution in the form of mandatory84 consultation, under Article VII, with the Special Tripartite Committee to be established under Article XIII. Turning to the specific flexibility provisions under Article II, as noted above, the MLC, applies to all seafarers (on ships covered by the Convention). Despite this firm principle, there will be borderline cases where some persons might on a very strict reading be regarded as seafarers under the Convention, but their situation is not one that the Convention is intended to address, for example, an entertainer on board for a few nights or, more obviously, inspectors coming on board to inspect a ship. Paragraph allows for a determination by the flag State competent authority “after consultation” “in the event of doubt as to whether any categories of persons are to be regarded as seafarers”. It is important to note that the provision does not allow for the exclusion of any category of workers that are seafarers. Rather it only allows for a determination that some categories of workers are not considered seafarers under the Convention and thus are not covered by the Convention. Paragraph does not allow 84
See discussion, infra, of Article VII. Article VII provides “may . . . only be decided . . .”.
principles and rights
selective application of provisions in the Convention. In order to provide guidance for national authorities, the th ILC adopted an important resolution that contains ‘information’, that is, advice that was agreed to on a tripartite basis.85 Most importantly, it sets out the following criteria for making these determinations: (i) (ii) (iii) (iv) (v)
the duration of the stay on board of the persons concerned; the frequency of periods of work spent on board; the location of the person’s principal place of work; the purpose of the person’s work on board; the protection that would normally be available to the persons concerned with regard to their labour and social conditions to ensure they are comparable to that provided for under the Convention.86
This resolution is not binding on countries or on the ILO supervisory system, as an interpretation of Article II, paragraph . However, it seems likely that it would be persuasive in the event that a country’s determination came under question. The important objectives of this resolution are: . . . the International Labour Organization should seek to ensure uniform implementation of the Convention and invites member States to maintain the intent of Article II, paragraph (f), through the application of Annex . . . . The Convention recognizes in Article II, paragraph , that there may be doubts whether a particular category or categories of persons who may perform work on board a ship covered by the Convention should be regarded as seafarers for the purpose of the Convention. This Annex has therefore been adopted by the General Conference of the International Labour Organization to assist administrations in resolving any difficulties that might arise . . . 85
Selection Committee Reports, supra note , Resolution concerning information on occupational groups, p. –/. It outlines situations whereby an administration may have doubts about categorizing a person working on board as a seafarer under Article , paragraph (f) (emphasis added) because: (i) the nature of their work is not part of the routine business of the ship (for example, scientists, researchers, divers, specialist offshore technicians, etc.); (ii) although trained and qualified in maritime skills, the persons concerned perform key specialist functions that are not part of the routine business of the ship (for example, harbour pilots, inspectors or superintendents); (iii) the work they perform is occasional and short term, with their principal place of employment being onshore (for example, guest entertainers, repair technicians, surveyors or portworkers). A person or category of persons should not automatically be excluded from the definition of seafarers solely on account of falling within one or more of the categories listed above. These lists are simply illustrative of situations where doubts may arise. Special factors in the situation may lead the administration to determine when a person is or is not a seafarer. 86
Ibid.
chapter six
Article II, paragraph , provides similar flexibility, again “[i]n the event of doubt” with respect to ships. However, in the case of ships, the determination could be with respect to a single ship or a “particular category of ships”. In principle, following on from the logic of the application and exclusions provisions in paragraph , the determination is not whether the ship is to be regarded as a ship, but rather whether the Convention applies to the ship (i.e., already considered a ship under Article II, paragraph (i)). However the wording in paragraph is not entirely clear and might also be considered as applicable to cases of doubt regarding the application of the definition in Article I paragraph (i).87 The formulation in paragraph is based on earlier ILO conventions, however those conventions did not contain a definition of a ship but, instead, as discussed above, used the phrase ‘seagoing ships’, with cases of doubt as to whether any ships are to be regarded as a ‘seagoing ships’ to be determined by the competent authority.88 As discussed above in connection with the definition of a ship, several countries at the th ILC had difficulty with the application of the Convention to smaller ships that do not go on international voyages. What is now paragraph was proposed by the ‘Friends of the President’ to resolve this problem.89 The 87 The difficulty is that the definition of ship under Article II(i) can be read as also calling, a vessel that does not fall under the definition of a ship, a ship, that is, “a ship other than one which . . .”. This is because, as discussed above, the wording was based on the STCW definition, which distinguishes between ‘seagoing ships’ and other ships (not covered by the Convention). This may lead to the question of whether Article II, paragraph , “in event of doubt”, applies to both the paragraph determinations and to the definition under Article II, paragraph (i). One argument against this approach, aside from the conceptual distinction between definition and scope, is that paragraph only mentions ‘a ship’ or ‘particular category of ships’ which suggest more to do with ships that would otherwise be covered. If it does apply to the definition then it would import also a consultation obligation regarding the geographic determination. 88 See for example the Seafarers’ Hours of Work and Manning of Ships Convention, (No. ), Geneva, October , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm, Art. , paras and . 89 In fact, a similar provision existed as early as the HLTWG in June :
. A Member may, after consultation with the shipowners’ and relevant seafarers’ organizations, exclude from the scope of its application ships that do not undertake international voyages, provided that the rights of seafarers’ rights in Articles III and IV are protected by national laws and regulations. At the PTMC in the following was considered and not included in the text proposed to the th ILC: . [A Member may, [in] [after] consultation with [representatives of] the shipowners’ and seafarers’ organizations concerned [in its territory], exclude from the scope of application of this Convention ships that do not undertake international voyages, provided that the fundamental rights of seafarers referred to in Article III [and seafarers’ employment and social rights referred to in Article IV, paragraphs to ] are protected by national laws and regulations. (HLTWG, W. proposal)].
principles and rights
result is carefully worded and might, at a first glance, appear to allow the total exclusion of the domestic fleet under GT: . Where the competent authority determines that it would not be reasonable or practicable at the present time to apply certain details of the Code referred to in Article VI, paragraph , to a ship or particular categories of ships flying the flag of the Member, the relevant provisions of the Code shall not apply to the extent that the subject matter is dealt with differently by national laws or regulations or collective bargaining agreements or other measures. Such a determination may only be made in consultation with the shipowners’ and seafarers’ organizations concerned and may only be made with respect to ships of less than gross tonnage not engaged in international voyages.
However, this is not a blanket exclusion of smaller ships (less than GT) in the domestic fleet (not engaged in international voyages) as the requirements set out in the Regulations would still apply. Rather, the flexibility is only with respect to cases where a competent authority determines “it would not be reasonable or practicable at the present time” to apply “. . . certain details of the Code . . . . to a ship or particular categories of ships” and then only “. . . to the extent that the subject matter is dealt with differently by national laws or regulation or bargaining agreement or other measures”. The details of implementation (in the Code) may differ, but must still be addressed. As explained at the th ILC (emphasis added): . The Worker Vice-Chairperson requested clarification on three issues. First, he enquired whether the wording “a ship or particular categories of ships flying the flag of the Member” meant that the new paragraph would only apply to national ships and not to foreign-flagged ships. Second, he asked for confirmation as to whether the phrase “the relevant provisions of the Code shall not apply to the extent that the subject-matter is dealt with differently by national laws or regulations or collective bargaining agreements or other measures” implied that having the subject matter unregulated was not an option. . . . . The representative of the Secretary-General responded to the first question by explaining that the new paragraph indeed only referred to national ships and not to foreign ships in the waters of a Member concerned. With respect to the second question, she confirmed that the wording implied that the subject matter had to be dealt with by national laws or regulations or collective bargaining agreements or other measures. The idea was precisely to avoid gaps in seafarers’ protection and to ensure protection for those who would be excluded from the coverage of the Code . . ..90
Paragraph of Article II provides a further layer to the Convention’s compliance and enforcement system. Paragraph is a transparency-oriented provision with respect to national implementation. It requires that “any determinations” (i.e., exercises of flexibility) under paragraphs , or “. . . shall 90
Committee of the Whole Report, supra note .
chapter six
be communicated to the Director-General of the International Labour Office, who shall notify the Members of the Organization”. This means that ILO must develop a database and communication process for this (and other) information that would, presumably, be linked to the ILO’s supervisory system for consideration during reviews of the Article reports. Article III—Fundamental Rights and Principles As discussed above,91 the ILO Legal Adviser issued an opinion on the legal consequences of references to fundamental rights and principles, which was provided initially in connection with Article III. The PTMC considered two options for wording.92 A third form, the current text of Article III, Fundamental rights and principles, was adopted after obtaining a Legal Opinion on its implications: Each Member shall satisfy itself that the provisions of its law and regulations respect, in the context of this Convention, the fundamental rights to:
91
See pp. – and notes and . Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention, Recommended Draft, PTMC, Geneva, – September , ILO Doc. No. PTMC//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/ standards/relm/maritime/pdf/cmlc-draft.pdf. The first option for Art. III, Fundamental rights, read as follows (underlining in the original deleted): 92
[Each Member reaffirms its commitment to respect, in the context of this Convention, the fundamental rights to: (a) freedom of association and the effective recognition of the right to collective bargaining; (b) the elimination of all forms of forced or compulsory labour; (c) the effective abolition of child labour; and (d) the elimination of discrimination in respect of employment and occupation as referred to in the ILO Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work, .] *** (Alternative) . [Each Member understands and recognizes that the seafarers’ employment and social rights set forth in Article IV below can be meaningfully achieved only in a context where the fundamental principles and rights at work are respected, promoted and realized for all seafarers, namely: (a) freedom of association and the effective recognition of the right to collective bargaining; (b) the elimination of all forms of forced or compulsory labour; (c) the effective abolition of child labour; and (d) the elimination of discrimination in respect of employment and occupation. . Therefore, each Member shall satisfy itself that the provisions of its laws and regulations are substantially equivalent to the provisions contained in the Conventions covering the fundamental principles and rights set out in this Article, in so far as the Member is not otherwise bound to give effect to the Conventions in question.]
principles and rights
(a) freedom of association and the effective recognition of the right to collective bargaining; (b) the elimination of all forms of forced or compulsory labour; (c) the effective abolition of child labour; and (d) the elimination of discrimination in respect of employment and occupation.
As discussed earlier, some States were concerned about the legal implication of a reference to the ILO Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work, or, even indirectly, referencing (as in ‘the alternative’) the fundamental conventions. The ILO Legal Adviser’s opinion set out below93 on the what is now the final text addresses the nature of the obligation on a country to ‘satisfy itself ’ and any future reporting obligations to the ILO supervisory system as to these principles and rights (emphasis added): . The reference to the ILO Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work, , would be moved to the Preamble of the proposed Convention. . The Chairperson of the Committee sought Members’ views on the new text now before it. He also requested the Legal Adviser to provide his opinion in writing so that it could be included in the Committee’s report. . This opinion is set out below: The Legal Adviser has been requested by the Chairperson of the Committee to put in writing his replies to the issues raised concerning Article III of the future Convention. . With regard to the legal status and the consequences of including the “wording” of the ILO Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work in the provisions of Article III, as proposed by the President of the Conference, the Legal Adviser observed that the “wording” of the Declaration was not included in the proposal; rather there was reference to the fundamental rights together with an obligation for Members who ratify the future Convention to satisfy themselves that the provisions of their national legislation respect those fundamental rights in the context of the future Convention. The status of the Declaration and its “wording” reflect, through reference to the fundamental principles and rights, the promotional character of that instrument, which varies significantly from an international labour Convention. . The reference to the fundamental rights in the text of Article III of the future Convention would not create any reporting obligations on the content of the Declaration to the ILO supervisory bodies. The two instruments are different and the ILO supervisory bodies have no competence to examine the implementation of the Declaration, which has its own follow-up mechanism. . Article III will be, as with all obligatory provisions of the Convention, subject to examination by the bodies responsible for the supervision 93
Committee No. Report, supra note . See also Report I(A), supra note .
chapter six of the implementation of ILO standards. The important issue is to identify the obligation that will be the focus of this supervision. Each Member who ratifies the future Convention will be obliged, in accordance with Article III, to satisfy itself that its legislation respects, in the context of this Convention, the four categories of fundamental rights. As with all obligations arising out of international labour Conventions, this should be carried out in good faith. Subject to what the ILO Governing Body may decide concerning the details to be requested in the report form in the framework of Article of the ILO Constitution, examination by the supervisory bodies will concern this specific obligation. This provision does not impose any additional obligation on States that have ratified one or more of the fundamental Conventions, because those Conventions already cover, without exception, the workers who are the subject of the future Convention. . With regard to the issue of whether the reference to the four categories of fundamental rights in Article III would create a reporting obligation under the ILO Declaration outside the scope of its follow-up mechanism, the reply is that it would not, as explained above. . Finally, on the consequences of including a reference to the Declaration in the Preamble to the future Convention, . . .
The reporting obligation was ultimately adopted by the ILO Governing Body in 94 for the Article reports on the MLC, obligations. As pointed out by Payoyo,95 although the MLC, reintroduced a fair competition or economic argument for international labour standards, it is also squarely based on human rights arguments for the universal application of fundamental rights and on the complementarity of human rights and labour standards. The text in Article III follows the approach in Convention No. with respect to the concept of ‘satisfy itself ’. However, Payoyo suggests that the MLC, does not go as far as the earlier convention, at least on paper, if not in practice, regarding the potential for enforcement of some of the fundamental conventions, most notably ILO Convention No. on Freedom of Association and Protection of the Right to Organize Convention, and Convention No. on the Right to Organize and Collective Bargaining Convention, . He comments (footnotes not included): The situation [in the MLC, ] contrasts with the regime established in ILO Convention , which recognized the legal position that labour standards em94
Supra note . Peter B. Payoyo, “The contribution of the Maritime Labour Convention,” in The Future of Ocean Regime-Building: Essays in Tribute to Douglas M. Johnston, Aldo Chircop, Ted L. McDorman, and Susan J. Rolston, eds. (Leiden/Boston: Martinus Nijhoff/Brill, ), – at . He notes that this complementarity and ‘mutual enrichment’ of human rights norms and labour standards in the developmental process was identified in by C.W. Jenks in Human Rights and International Labour Standards (London: Stevens & Sons. Ltd, ).
95
principles and rights
bodied in the Freedom of Association Convention, (No. ) and the Right to Organize and Collective Bargaining, (No. ) are appropriate subjects for international regulation through port State control. While these “fundamental” Conventions have been excluded, in practice, in the inspection procedures of the regional port State control authorities, it could be observed that the enforcement possibilities for these fundamental Conventions (Nos and ) are more expansive under ILO Convention than under the MLC. Under the MLC, Conventions and have been removed from the oversight and control of port states. On the other hand, the specific content of “seafarers’ employment and social rights” is given particularity in the MLC and is transposed as the regulations, standards and guidelines in the MLC. . . . These labour standards are in turn justified on the basis of the existence of, and commitment to, seafarers’ rights defined as the employment and social rights listed in Article V.96
While this view regarding the net effect of the ‘satisfy itself ’ obligation under Article III might be correct, it may also overstate the nature of possible port State obligations under Convention No. .97 Further, it does not consider the interaction between this provision and the evaluation, during port State control, of the seriousness of a breach98 and what can be considered a breach of the requirement of the Convention (including seafarers’ rights). It is clear that the issue of port State control with respect to human rights practices in flag States, including freedom of association and the right to collective bargaining, is sensitive, as evidenced by the difficulties associated with the development of the text of Article III. Contrary to Payoyo’s analysis, although concern at the preparatory meetings was primarily with respect to reporting obligations, there was also a question of whether these rights would be inspected and/or certified or subject to port State control at the shipboard level. This issue was raised, as noted above, in connection with the definition of the term ‘requirements of this Convention (including seafarers’ rights)’, which are subject to flag State inspection and port State control. Since there is no term ‘seafarers’ rights’ as such in the Convention, it is not entirely clear what 96
Payoyo, ibid., p. . Under Convention No. , supra note , Article , paragraph , the legal obligation (a ‘may’ obligation) in situations where it “receives a complaint or obtains evidence” is limited to preparing a report to the flag State with a copy to the Director-General of the International Labour Office. Rectification may also be required in cases where conditions are “clearly hazardous to safety or health”. In addition, the flag State obligation under Convention No. with respect to implementation of a list of conventions (including Nos. and ) is to “satisfy itself ” that the provisions in its laws or regulations are “substantially equivalent” to these conventions in so far as the State is not otherwise bound to give effect to the conventions in question (Art. , para. (a)). This is complemented by obligations regarding enforcement at the shipboard level (Art. , para. (b), (c), and (d)). 98 Guidelines for Port State Control Officers, supra note , pp. and ff and infra. See also Chapter on Title , pp. –. 97
chapter six
the term refers to. It could refer to Article III and, in particular, Article IV as they are seen as cornerstones of the ‘seafarers’ bill of rights’. Arguably a violation of the rights in Article III could be seen as a breach of requirements of the Convention and, if not directly subject to inspection, goes to question of the seriousness of a breach. This is supported by guidance in the text of the MLC, as well as the recommendations in the ILO Guidelines for Port State Control Officers Carrying Out Inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, , which were adopted in by a Tripartite Committee of Experts.99 Guideline B..—Inspections in port, of the MLC, regarding national policy for detention of foreign ships provides (emphasis added): . When developing a policy relating to the circumstances warranting a detention of the ship under paragraph of Standard A.., the competent authority should consider that, with respect to the breaches referred to in paragraph (b) of Standard A.., the seriousness could be due to the nature of the deficiency concerned. This would be particularly relevant in the case of the violation of fundamental rights and principles or seafarers’ employment and social rights under Articles III and IV. For example, the employment of a person who is under age should be considered as a serious breach even if there is only one such person on board. In other cases, the number of different defects found during a particular inspection should be taken into account: for example, several instances of defects relating to accommodation or food and catering which do not threaten safety or health might be needed before they should be considered as constituting a serious breach.
Article IV—Seafarers’ Employment and Social Rights The structure and organizational importance of Article IV was discussed in Chapter and referred to above in the discussion of Article III. Article IV is essentially the beginning of the cascade of the rights and obligations set out in the regulations and the Code. Although the rights in Article IV, paragraphs – do not neatly correspond to the Titles of the Convention, taken together, they encompass all the provisions within those Titles. As noted above in the quote by Payoyo, the rights set out in Article IV are given content in the rest of the Convention. These rights, as he correctly notes, are not primarily established as individual rights “granted to or endowed on seafarers qua individuals which would give them a basis to legally take action against their governments for violation of these rights”.100 However, in a globalized work force, this kind of right seems irrelevant and, in fact, the real remedy of the individual is much more pragmatic. It lies in the ability to make complaints at either the shipboard level, with the possibility of the immediate remedy such as having the ship detained, or at the level of international ‘supervi99 100
Ibid., para. . Payoyo, supra note , p. .
principles and rights
sory’ scrutiny and having the laws of the country in question reviewed. In many cases, the relevant government concerned is not the government (country of residence or nationality) of the individual concerned, but simply the State of registry, the (flag) State, of the workplace in question, that is, the ship. Thus the traditional State versus its citizens dichotomy does not easily apply. Although less obviously important, a key aspect of Article IV, particularly with respect to the form of national implementation, is the paragraph that follows the enumeration of the four rights. Paragraph provides that: . Each Member shall ensure, within the limits of its jurisdiction, that the seafarers’ employment and social rights set out in the preceding paragraphs of this Article are fully implemented in accordance with the requirements of this Convention. Unless specified otherwise in the Convention, such implementation may be achieved through national laws or regulations, through applicable collective bargaining agreements or through other measures or in practice.
As pointed out in the Office Report for the th ILC: . . . . Paragraph makes it clear that the “seafarers’ employment and social rights”, set out in paragraphs –, are to be fully implemented, not in the abstract but, rather, “in accordance with the requirements of this Convention”—i.e. in accordance with the relevant provisions of the Articles, Regulations and Part A of the Code.101
Although apparently not a national ‘flexibility mechanism’, this is nonetheless an important provision for flexibility regarding the form of implementation. Paragraph clearly allows, except where specified otherwise in the Convention, a country to implement the requirements of the Convention through laws or regulations, collective bargaining agreements, or other measures or in practice, or a combination of these. Thus the regulations and standards in the MLC, require a review to determine whether a law or regulation is actually required or whether implementation can occur in some other way. In a few cases, the Convention requires implementation through laws or regulations. For example, Standard A., paragraph , requires that seafarers’ employment agreements, and how they are to be concluded, must be established by laws or regulations, while laws and regulations are required to specify the matters that are to be covered in these agreements. However, the Standard does not require that the content of the measures dealing with those matters be established by law or regulation, except in the case of minimum notice periods (Standard A., paragraphs and ). The legal implementation of many of the Convention requirements relating to working and living conditions could, in principle, be solely implemented 101
Report I(A), supra note , Note (Article IV), para. .
chapter six
by an approved standard SEA, supplemented by any applicable collective bargaining agreements, except where the Convention indicates that a particular requirement has to be established in laws and/or regulations. This would not be the case where the Convention says, “Each Member shall adopt laws or regulations or other measures to ensure” (emphasis added). The only cases in which the means of implementation must take the form of legislation alone are where the Convention refers to the adoption of laws or/and regulations without giving the option of ‘other measures’.102 Sometimes, the use of laws and regulations is required, as under Regulation ., which refers to “laws and regulations and other measures” (emphasis added). The idea that a State can implement its treaty obligations through a private or corporate actor’s contractual arrangement to which the State would not be a party is of particular interest. It is common in ILO conventions, but is unusual from a wider international law perspective, where the concern is with action by the State itself.103 The wide range of topics and differing situations covered in the Convention, which undoubtedly cross several national departments, raises the question of whether the Convention’s requirements, which must be implemented in laws or regulations, can be done in different sets of legislation applying to different seafarers and, perhaps, involving different aspects of the law with requirements for the various sub-sectors that the Convention does not specifically address. Under a country’s legislative regime, if seafarers’ conditions are governed by more than one piece of legislation, the Member State must ensure that the minimum standards established by the Convention are respected in total when all the legislation concerned is considered. In addition, there is no requirement that all seafarers have exactly the same conditions of employment (provided that the minimum standards are met), although the legislation must not be discriminatory.104 It is clear from paragraph that the possibility of a country taking advantage of exclusions, exemptions, or other flexibility is considerably diminished if there are no representative “shipowners’ and seafarers’ organizations concerned” to be consulted or to conclude collective bargaining agreements relating to permitted variations from the requirements of the Convention.105 102
For example, Standard A.. In a different but relevant context see the analysis by Natasha A. Affolder, “The private life of environmental treaties,” () American Journal of International Law , considering both the use and performance of treaties by private (non-State) actors. 104 For example, it would not be discriminatory in the sense of Article III if the different treatment is due to the seafarer being engaged in domestic or overseas shipping. 105 In addition to the generally applicable possibilities for flexibility, there are specific provisions that can be adapted to the special circumstances of the country concerned. For example, 103
principles and rights
Moreover, even in cases where consultations or collective agreements are not required to exercise flexibility in implementation, difficult questions arise that could be resolved with more certainty of validity, if the solution adopted resulted from tripartite consensus. For example, is a national measure substantially equivalent to a requirement in Part A of the Code or is a departure from the guidance in Part B of the Code properly implementing the related requirement in Part A? This approach encourages the development of representative worker and employer organizations and national social dialogue and ultimately achieving social justice by using tripartism to deal with the challenges posed by globalization. Article V—Implementation and Enforcement Responsibilities The Office Report for the th ILC summarizes the impact of Article V as follows: . Article V provides the legal foundation for the provisions on compliance and enforcement in Title of the Convention. These obligations are implicit in the Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, (No. ), and the Labour Inspection (Seafarers) Convention, (No. ), both of which are consolidated by this Convention. . Paragraphs and are directed to encouraging each Member to effectively exercise its jurisdiction through the adoption of a systematic approach to compliance and enforcement of the legal standards.106
An important but less obvious point to note is that this article establishes three kinds of State responsibility: flag State, port State, and a third role, laboursupplying responsibilities. As noted in Chapter , the latter can be seen as a new actor in the international law of the sea regime. These provisions directly correlate with the more detailed provisions in Title , Compliance and Enforcement, namely, Regulation .—Flag State responsibilities; Regulation .—Port State responsibilities, and Regulation .—Labour-supplying responsibilities. Article V strengthens the rights in the Convention without adding any obligations that do not already exist in the regulations and the Code, Part A. The wording of most Article V provisions, which draw heavily on the approach in IMO conventions, was relatively uncontroversial, however there are some important points to note.
collective agreements may provide for a different but no less favourable basis for the normal working hours’ standard (Standard A., para. ). Or, for example, Standard A., paragraph enables variations in the required standards for seafarer accommodation that are justified by religious and social practices. 106 Report I(A), supra note , Note (Article V).
chapter six
First, paragraph is the foundation for the new and innovative approach to ship-level enforcement of labour standards, including the requirement for certification of conditions for seafarers working and living on a ship. This shifts the focuses in an international legal instrument to corporate/private actor compliance and enforcement, away from State compliance. Paragraphs and are key to ongoing compliance. Paragraph , which builds on Article of Convention No. and the IMO conventions, is a ‘may’ obligation with respect to a port State’s inspection of foreign ships entering its ports. The word ‘may’ reflects the principle that the decision by a State to exercise control over a foreign ship in its ports is voluntary. It is a responsibility of a ratifying State that is not necessarily an obligation. Regulation .., paragraph , provides: Every foreign ship calling, in the normal course of its business or for operational reasons, in the port of a Member may be the subject of inspection in accordance with paragraph of Article V for the purpose of reviewing compliance with the requirements of this Convention (including seafarers’ rights) relating to the working and living conditions of seafarers on the ship.
It is generally understood that port State inspection is a matter of right rather than obligation or permission. However, there is no correlative international obligation to carry out such inspections, other than State agreement through the various regional port State control MOUs. The exact nature of the ‘may’ obligation is difficult to ascertain; perhaps it could best be described as a discretionary obligation buttressed by the obligation on all Members under Article I, paragraph , to cooperate in effective implementation and enforcement. Paragraph , in line with the broader international maritime regulatory regime, refers to “requirements of this Convention”, that is, as explained earlier, the regulations and standards. Thus, while the Convention provides significant national flexibility, the initial concern at the port State level is considering compliance with the Convention, even though ships are certified with respect to compliance with national standards implementing the Convention. De facto this means that documents on the ship would essentially operate as a defense, providing an explanation to port States, in the event that conditions on the ship do not appear to meet the Convention requirements (regulations and standards, but not Part B of the Code). Superficially this differs from the IMO conventions, which are directed to uniformity. However, this difference in approach is probably more relevant to the Article reports and ILO supervisory system review than at the shipboard level.107
107
This issue is discussed in more detail in Chapter .
principles and rights
Paragraph addresses the basic requirement that States impose some form of sanction for breach of their national laws implementing the Convention. The main difficulty encountered with what might seem a basic proposition was to avoid wording that required punishment for activities outside the territorial jurisdiction of a State.108 Paragraph indirectly imposes the Convention requirements on ships of non-ratifying States. It is intended to provide an incentive to ratify by removing any advantage at the shipboard level to not ratifying. This provision is key to achieving the Convention’s objective regarding the ‘level playing field’ among shipowners. Article V, paragraph is what is described as a ‘no more favourable treatment clause’. It exists in the IMO conventions,109 however it is new to ILO conventions. Conceivably paragraph could apply in various situations, however, in practice it is only referred to in the context of port State control. This is illustrated in Resolution IV concerning the development of guidelines for port State control, which as noted earlier, was adopted by the ILC at the same time as the MLC, .110 The Resolution notes that paragraphs and of Article V, and Regulation .., Standard A.., and Guideline B.. “. . . provide for port State responsibilities and control under the term of ‘no more favourable treatment’.” This should not, however, mean that ships flying the flags of non-ratifying countries are treated more harshly, rather it means that they are treated the same as a ship of a ratifying State.111 108
Earlier drafts of the Convention included standard form text from MARPOL /, supra note , “. . . and that are equally severe irrespective of where the violations occur”. However, this proved to be difficult for some countries, hence the modified wording. 109 MARPOL /, ibid., Art. , para. ; SOLAS, supra note , Regulation . It is also found in LOSC, supra note . 110 Selection Committee Reports, supra note , Resolution concerning the development of guidelines for port State control, pp. –/––/. 111 Guidelines for Port State Control Officers, supra note , at paragraph proposes, for ships that are not certified, that: . Inspection in a foreign port applies even if the ship is flying the flag of a country that has not ratified the MLC, , because the MLC, , obliges the States that ratify it to give no more favourable treatment to ships of States that have not ratified (Article V, paragraph ). This means that these ships may be the subject of a more detailed inspection as provided under the MLC, .5 Footnote : The MLC, , does not expressly address the requirements for these ships; however, the Convention was intended to operate as consistently as possible with existing practices in the maritime sector and key international conventions of the International Maritime Organization. Based on the example found in IMO resolution A.(), section ., on port State control, the following would apply as the appropriate approach: “All Member Parties should as a matter of principle apply the procedures set out in these guidelines to ships of non-ratifying States and ships of ratifying States that, for reasons related to size, are not carrying documents required by the MLC, , in order to ensure that equivalent inspections are conducted and that equivalent level of seafarers’ working
chapter six
As noted above, Article V, paragraph , provides that a foreign ship (whatever its flag) may, “in accordance with international law”, be inspected by a Member when the ship is in its ports to determine whether it is in compliance with the requirements of the Convention. To the extent that a country that has ratified the MLC, takes on the responsibility under Regulation .. to inspect foreign ships visiting its ports, it is also required by paragraph of Article V to apply the relevant provisions, in particular those set out in Standard A.., to ships flying the flag of States that have not ratified the Convention. Thus such ships could or must (in the cases mentioned in the last sentence of paragraph of that Standard) be the subject of a detailed inspection to ascertain the working and living conditions on board the ship, since they would not be carrying the documents mentioned in Standard A.., paragraph (a).112 Article V obligations under paragraph with respect to control and regulation of seafarer recruitment and placement services in their territory are also important and link to the specific obligations under Regulations . and .. It is important to note that this provision does not require that these services be established. The obligation to regulate arises only “if these are established”. The wording, ‘if ’, was significant for some ILO Members who do not have such services in their territory and wanted it to be clear that there is no obligation on this point.113 Article VI—Regulations and Parts A and B of the Code Article VI deals with two significant matters. The first is the legal relationship between the differing parts of the Convention, in particular the nature of the obligations on the ratifying State with respect to the Code, Part B. The second is the ‘flexibility’ provisions in paragraphs and , that is, the ‘substantial equivalence’ of national implementation measures.
and living conditions (including seafarers’ rights) apply on board these ships. The seafarers’ working and living conditions on such ships should be compatible with the aims of the provisions of the MLC, ; otherwise, the ship should be subject to such requirements as are necessary to obtain a comparable level with the MLC, .” A similar approach is also reflected in the Paris Memorandum of Understanding on Port State Control. 112
Under Standard A.., para. , if the ship is found not to conform to the requirements of the Convention and the conditions on board are clearly hazardous to the safety, health, or security of seafarers, or the non-conformities constitute a serious or repeated breach of the requirements of the Convention (including seafarers’ rights), the port State control officer must take steps to ensure that the ship does not proceed to sea until the non-conformities have been rectified, or until the officer has accepted a plan of action to rectify such non-conformities and is satisfied that the plan will be implemented in an expeditious manner. See Chapter discussion. 113 See the discussion in Chapter at note , in connection with Regulation ..
principles and rights
As noted in Chapter , the provisions relating to the legal relationship between parts of the Convention, which relate to its structure, were the result of an explicit agreement reached at the fourth meeting of the HLTWG in January . In addition, an Opinion from the ILO’s Legal Adviser was provided to assist governments with understanding their obligations with respect to implementation of the provisions in Part B of the Code.114 It will be recalled that Part B of the Code is complex and that its provisions do not correspond to existing ILO recommendations because it also contains provisions from existing ILO conventions,115 whose level of detail may have precluded ratification by some States. The issue was raised by governments at the third HLTWG meeting in June . The extract reproduced below from the record116 of that meeting sets out the basis for the final agreement reached in , and is now the current text. It demonstrates the extent of government unease with both the change in the structure of the Convention and related implications for the nature of the obligations in the Convention (emphasis added). . A Government representative reiterated her concern about the legal status of Part B of the Code and asked for the advice of the Legal Adviser. Firstly, she asked how the provisions of Part B of the Code with their hybrid status fitted in the articulation between ILO Conventions and ILO Recommendations. Secondly, with regard to the wish of many Members that Part B of the Code have the status of a Recommendation, she inquired whether provisions with the status of a Recommendation could be an integral part of a Convention and what would be the legal consequences. Finally, she pointed out that more than half of the provisions of the Code were in Part B and had a hybrid status. . . . . In reply . . . the Legal Adviser provided clarification on the new Convention’s status and its Parts A and B. The new consolidated Convention would—in a formal sense—be a regular ILO Convention. Provisions in Part A would be mandatory, while provisions in Part B were not mandatory (cf. Article VI). Such inclusion of non-mandatory provisions in a Convention did not interfere with the ILO Constitution and precedents for the inclusion of non-mandatory parts in ILO Conventions existed. One example was Article of the Occupational Health Services Convention, (No. ). Instead of “shall”, which indicated cogent provisions, “should” had been used in this case to indicate that member 114
See Figure , Chapter , Legal Adviser’s Opinion on the Status of Part B of the Code, p. . See, for example, the Guidelines on repatriation (Guideline B .) and on seafarers’ accommodation and recreational facilities (Guideline B.) in Appendix of this book. The seafarers’ spokesperson noted:
115
. The Seafarer spokesperson drew attention to the overall structure of the instrument. Part B was a guideline and non-mandatory but he expected States to give “full consideration” to its contents since many of its provisions would have been moved down from Part A. Part B should not become irrelevant; if this was to be the case, he would demand a substantial amount of the text to be moved back to Part A. 116
Final Report, supra note .
.
.
.
.
chapter six States were not obliged to follow these provisions. The new Convention’s only real innovation was that in the new Convention the amount of nonbinding provisions was much higher than in any earlier Convention. Furthermore, the inclusion of non-binding text in International Conventions would not be new to most national legislators, since such provisions were prominently featured in instruments, such as SOLAS, and had not raised constitutional concerns. Elaborating on the above, the Legal Adviser added that Parts A and B had been created in the interest of greater flexibility. Members were obliged to comply with Part A, but were given discretion in regards to Part B. The provisions contained in Part B would shed light on the mandatory provisions in Part A and be seen as the ideal way to compliance with Part A. States were free to adopt whatever measure they deemed right, as long as the mandatory provisions of Part A were fulfilled. Members, which fully implemented Part B, would automatically be held to comply with Part A. The implementation of Part B would imply that Part A had been sufficiently dealt with. Member States that did not adopt provisions in Part B were free to do so, but might have to prove to the Organization that they were in compliance with Part A, if doubts arose. . . . In regard to a Government representative’s question on the legal implications of “full consideration” (as suggested by Article VI, paragraph ), the Legal Adviser noted that according to Article XIX ()(c) of the Constitution, Recommendations were to be given “consideration” by member States. The Legal Adviser deemed these two wordings interchangeable and stated that no relevant legal difference existed. Members needed to look upon non-mandatory provisions in good faith. Summing up the legal advice given, two Government representatives described the provisions contained in Part B as guidance and declared that their national legislators would thoroughly scrutinize them before taking any decisions on the best way to implement the Convention. Reference was made to SOLAS, which had similar provisions that assisted member States in their implementation efforts. A Government representative reminded the meeting that the content of Part B was the pool from which amendments would possibly be added to Part A in the future (emphasis added).
Despite this advice the issue remained of concern for governments. The fourth meeting of the HLTWG reached the following agreement on the status of Part B of the Code, which now uses the term ‘due’ rather than ‘full’ consideration wording recommended117 at the June meeting: . The High-level Group considered the status of Part B of the Code. A consensus was reached on the status as follows: The present wording of the relevant provision—paragraph of Article VI of the preliminary second draft—can be retained on the following understandings: 117
Final Report, supra note : . A Government representative addressed the legal status of the Code, Part B, and felt that the paragraph should not read “full consideration” but rather “due consideration”. This would permit flexibility and enable more countries to ratify it. He stressed that this would allow for a simple amendment procedure to apply to Part B.
principles and rights Question: Answer: Question: Answer: Question: Answer: Question: Answer:
Is Part B mandatory? No. Can Part B be ignored by ratifying Members? No. Is the implementation of Part B verified by port state inspectors? No. Does the ratifying Member have to follow the guidance in Part B? No, but if it does not follow the guidance it may—vis-à-vis the competent bodies of the International Labour Organization— need to justify the way in which it has implemented the corresponding mandatory provisions of the consolidated Convention.
These understandings would need to be clearly reflected in the Convention itself or in related documentation.118
As this agreement indicates, part of the solution to concerns about the status of Part B of the Code related to the performance of the Convention’s obligation by non-State actors (shipowner/shipboard level) and the scope of inspections of ships in foreign ports. This issue was resolved, as discussed earlier, with the adoption of the formula phrase and the definition in Article II, paragraph (e), “requirements of this Convention”. The concern about State responsibility for implementation and the related obligations to report to the ILO supervisory system is now addressed in the Article report that was adopted in .119 The other approach adopted was to include an illustration in the Explanatory Note to the Regulations and Code of the Maritime Labour Convention of how Part B could be used by governments: . Paragraph provides for an interaction within the Code of the Convention, under which Members are to give “due consideration” to implementing their responsibilities under Part A of the Code “in the manner provided for in Part B of the Code”. This provision paved the way for the shift of many of the detailed requirements in existing Conventions from the Standards in Part A to the Guidelines in Part B of the Code. In order to assist Members, an “Explanatory note” following the Articles of the Convention has been included in the text of the Convention. . . . This note (in paragraphs and ) [which] reflects the opinion given by the ILO Legal Adviser on the subject to the High-level Group at its third meeting, indicates the general context of Part B and gives an example of Part B’s interaction with Part A. An explanation, rather than a legal text, does indeed seem to be the best approach.120
118 119 120
Ibid. Supra note . Commentary to the Recommended Draft, supra note , Comment (on Article VI), p. .
chapter six
The second important element of Article VI is the ‘flexibility’ provision in paragraphs and . This is the concept of implementation of obligations through national provisions which are ‘substantially equivalent’. The concept is drawn121 from ILO Convention No. 122 and borrows from the ideas in a 121
The early draft of these provisions considered at the February meeting clearly points to concepts that were considered and either eliminated or reformulated and now appear elsewhere, for example, Article II, paragraphs and . The draft text (Preliminary Draft for a Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention, Tripartite Subgroup of the HLTWG (Second Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. STWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/ sector/techmeet/stwgmls/stwgmls-r.pdf) considered in February by the Subgroup at its second meeting contained the following provisions, most of which were eliminated from this article, although some of the initial wording in paragraph remains. It is interesting to note that this text expressly allowed for the adoption of lower standards and also provided for notification to the ILO. Interestingly, it sought to apply the concept of substantial equivalence to ships flying flags of non-ratifying countries. . However, a Member which is not in a position to implement the principles and rights in the manner set out in Part A of the Code may – (a) implement Part A of the Code through provisions in its laws and regulations which can be demonstrated to be substantially equivalent to the provisions of Part A; or (b) implement an initial lower standard, to the extent expressly permitted in the Code, and make adequate provision for the progressive achievement, in the shortest possible time, of the full standards set out in Part A of the Code. . Subject to any directions or guidance that may be given in the Code with respect to particular provisions, a law, regulation or other implementing measure shall, for the purpose of paragraph (a) above, be considered to be substantially equivalent to a provision of this Convention if – (a) it is conducive to the full achievement of the general object or purpose of the provision concerned, and (b) in all material respects, it complies with the specific requirements of the provision or has effects that are equivalent to those resulting from such compliance. . A Member may avail itself of the flexibility provided for in paragraph (b) only if the lower standard to be initially applied is specified in a declaration in or accompanying its instrument of ratification of this Convention. Such declaration shall have been made by the Member after consultation with the organizations of shipowners and seafarers concerned, where such exist. In no case may a Member apply a standard lower than any standard of an international labour Convention that was applicable to the Member at the time of ratification of this Convention. . Any Member availing itself of the flexibility provided for in paragraph (a) shall, in its reports upon the application of this Convention submitted under Article of the Constitution of the International Labour Organization, indicate the measures that have been taken or are proposed to be taken to achieve the full standards set out in Part A of the Code. . With respect to ships entitled to fly the flag of a State which is not a party to this Convention, each Member shall apply standards that are substantially equivalent to those under the Regulations and Part A of the Code, to the extent necessary to ensure that no more favourable treatment is given to such ships. 122
Convention No. , supra note , Art. , “Any Member which ratifies this Convention undertakes (a) to have laws or regulations laying down, for ships registered in its territory . . . and to satisfy itself that the provisions of such laws and regulations are substantially equivalent to the
principles and rights
provision entitled, ‘Equivalents’, commonly found in IMO conventions, usually for technical or specific application provisions.123 However, the concept set out in paragraphs and of Article VI is different from both and should be regarded as sui generis. The Office Report for the th ILC explains: . It will be noted that the definition in paragraph of Article VI will apply “for the sole purpose of paragraph ” (i.e. only as far as the provisions of Part A of the Code are concerned) and only “in the context of this Convention”; it is therefore not intended to affect the meaning that might be given to the term “substantially equivalent” in other ILO Conventions (Conventions Nos. and ) that may remain or come into force for some Members.
Paragraphs and of Article VII were the subject of extensive debate, including debate about the meaning of the words,124 and resulted in a request for advice Conventions or Articles of Conventions referred to in the Appendix to this Convention, in so far as the Member is not otherwise bound to give effect to the Conventions in question” (emphasis added). 123 See, for example, MARPOL /, supra note , Annex , Regulation , or SOLAS, supra note , Annex, Chapter I, Part A, Regulation . In the IMO, where an administration has accepted something (usually an apparatus, materials, or fitting) as equivalent, this information is communicated to the IMO, which in turn circulates this information to the other Contracting Parties. In some cases there is also provision for objections by other Contracting States. Thus the equivalence is in relation to the application of specific materials or equipment required, with the standard for equivalent being “at least as effective” as that required by the relevant regulation or the annex to the Convention. Under MARPOL the authority to accept ‘equivalents’ does not extend to operational methods. See also: STCW, supra note , Art. IX() regarding the adoption of “other educational and training arrangements . . . provided that the . . . has a preventative effect as regards pollution at least equivalent to the requirements of the Convention”. By contrast the provision in Convention No. , supra note , relates to determinations regarding national legislative implementation and requires that the Member “satisfy itself ” with no particular standard for that determination. The concept of ‘substantial compliance’ is also found in the port State control regime. For example, Section , Inspection procedures, rectification and detention, of the Paris Memorandum of Understanding on Port State Control, January , as amended, available at http://www.parismou.org/upload/pdf/amendedMoUcleanaccepted November.pdf, which provides (emphasis added): . In fulfilling their commitments the Authorities will carry out inspections, which will consist of a visit on board a ship in order to check the certificates and documents as referred to in section of Annex . Furthermore the Authorities will satisfy themselves that the crew and the overall condition of the ship, including the engine room and accommodation and including hygienic conditions, meets generally accepted international rules and standards. In the absence of valid certificates or documents or if there are clear grounds for believing that the condition of a ship or of its equipment, or its crew does not substantially meet the requirements of a relevant instrument, a more detailed inspection will be carried out, . . . 124 Committee No. Report, supra note , for example: . In response to questions concerning the hierarchy of the terms “similar”, “comparable” and “substantially equivalent”, the Legal Adviser responded that the term “substantial equivalence” contained a further element going beyond “comparable”, while “similar” introduced a semantic nuance suggesting more than just “substantial equivalence” and implying a slightly lower level of assessment for Members.
chapter six
from the ILO Legal Adviser at the PTMC in September .125 Although that opinion was directed to assisting the PTMC to evaluate the difference between two proposals for wording for the text in paragraph , neither of which were accepted, the ILO Legal Adviser noted, inter alia, that (emphasis added): . Paragraph of Article VI of the recommended draft before the Conference is intended to clarify the flexibility clause in paragraph , which reads as follows: . A Member which is not in a position to implement the principles and rights in the manner set out in Part A of the Code may, unless expressly provided otherwise in this Convention, implement Part A of the Code through provisions in its laws and regulations or other measures which are substantially equivalent to the provisions of Part A. . It is clear that the context in which “substantially equivalent” appears in the above paragraph is significantly different from that of Article (a) of Convention No. . The intention of the new instrument is to ensure the adoption of legislative or other provisions which will be substantially equivalent to those of Part A of the Code, where the Member is not in a position to implement the principles and rights set out in the Regulations “in the manner set out in Part A”. . . . . Under the terms of paragraph , a Member ratifying the Convention and deciding to invoke the provisions of this paragraph must in good faith adopt measures that meet the criteria of substantial equivalence.
As noted in the Office Report for the th ILC, the definition of ‘substantially equivalent’ ultimately adopted in paragraph means that: . . . a national provision implementing the rights and principles of the Convention in a manner different from that set out in Part A of the Code will be considered as “substantially equivalent” if the Member concerned “satisfies itself ” that the relevant legislation or other implementing measure “is conducive to the full achievement of the general object and purpose of the provision or provisions of Part A of the Code concerned” and “gives effect to the provision or provisions of Part A of the Code concerned”.126
In connection with the expression ‘satisfies itself ’, as noted earlier the following extract from the ILO Legal Adviser’s advice127 at the PTMC on another matter (Article III) with this phrase also appears relevant:
. The Government member of the United States affirmed that the term “equivalent” was at the top of the hierarchy of these terms, with “substantially equivalent”, “comparable” and “similar” coming below it. Since “substantial equivalence” was tautologically defined with reference to “equivalence”, this paragraph only defined the term “substantially” and was, therefore, superfluous. 125 126 127
Ibid., para. . Report I(A), supra note , Note (Article VI), para. . Committee No. Report, supra note .
principles and rights
. . . . . The Member’s obligation is principally to “satisfy itself ”, which nevertheless does not imply total autonomy, since it is incumbent on the authorities responsible for monitoring implementation at the national and international levels to determine not only whether the necessary procedure of “satisfying themselves” has been carried out, but also whether it has been carried out in good faith in such a way as to ensure that the objective of implementing the principles and rights set out in the Regulations is adequately achieved in some way other than that indicated in Part A of the Code.
It is likely that some questions of interpretation may arise in the future in connection with the appropriate application of the two-part definition of ‘substantial equivalence’ in paragraph , which is confined to “the context of this Convention”: . For the sole purpose of paragraph of this Article, any law, regulation, collective agreement or other implementing measure shall be considered to be substantially equivalent, in the context of this Convention, if the Member satisfies itself that: (a) it is conducive to the full achievement of the general object and purpose of the provision or provisions of Part A of the Code concerned; and (b) it gives effect to the provision or provisions of Part A of the Code concerned.
Assuming the ‘good faith’ standard under ‘satisfies itself ’, these two clauses require some consideration as to the meaning of ‘full achievement’ and the ‘general object and purpose’ of the provisions in Part A as well as what it means to ‘give effect’ to them but not to apply them. Clearly the intention of such a provision is to achieve the objectives or goals (principles and rights) while providing flexibility as to the precise approach or method that a country adopts to meet those objectives. The issue is not higher or more stringent national provisions, since in those cases the Convention requirements are clearly being met, rather it is the difference in approach. In the abstract this seems simple, but it may be more difficult to apply in practice. For example, in connection with Standard A. on seafarer accommodation, one could raise questions as to the general objective and purpose of the provisions on the size of sleeping rooms or ratio of washbasins to seafarers, or the requirement that men and women have separate sleeping rooms. The purpose clause for Regulation . might be of some assistance here where it states the purpose as “ensuring that seafarers have decent accommodation”. This does not provide much guidance, however. More specific questions on the purpose of these Code Part A provisions in connection with ensuring ‘decent accommodation’ and ultimately what could be considered as substantially equivalent in the event that a government concludes that it is not in a position to implement the Standard with respect to a specific category of ships or ship is not addressed. Arguably sleeping room matters relate to
chapter six
personal ‘space’ and privacy, and perhaps personal security, all of which essentially relates to mental and physical health and physical well-being. How else can these be achieved in a way that gives effect to these provisions? Would extra hours of shore leave achieve this objective? Or, if the equivalent measure needs to be of the same character or form as the requirement, in the case of spatial requirements, could this be achieved by giving seafarers access to other spaces on the ship, for example, use of offices or recreational space not required by the Convention? There is no clear answer. It is possible that these kinds of questions will arise in the context of the ILO supervisory system, or as matters considered by the Special Tripartite Committee under Article XIII of the MLC, , perhaps as an issue that requires clarification through amendment or guidance. Other aspects of this concept are likely to trigger national level difficulties in application. First, under paragraph , the concept of substantial equivalence relates only to the standards in Part A of the Code. Thus, as with Article II, paragraph , the requirements in the regulations still apply. Second, substantial equivalence can be used ‘unless expressly provided otherwise in this Convention’. Its application is only excluded with respect to the standards in Title on compliance and enforcement. Since, aside from Regulation .. (on-board complaint procedures), Title provisions are directed to government inspection and enforcement responsibilities for the requirements under the Convention, this makes sense. It is also important to note that, under paragraph , the Member (State) would need to conclude that it is not in a position to implement its laws and regulations or measures. This appears to focus implementation at the point of national law making in the initial process to implement the Convention, rather than by a later administrative decision by a relevant competent authority of the Member. The wording ‘not in a position’ is a phrase that entered the text in its preliminary drafts. It was not the subject of comment or legal opinion, however, it could be understood as implying a less stringent standard than ‘not able’. Although the State would be responsible for this initial evaluation it could, therefore, be asked to explain to the ILO supervisory bodies why it had this difficulty. Since many provisions in the MLC, can be implemented through a range of measures, careful analysis, before resorting to substantial equivalence, is required to evaluate whether, if legislation seems problematic, a standard could be implemented using other measures. Similarly, under paragraph , the substantially equivalent provisions could be in the form of “law, regulation, collective agreements or other implementing measures”. Finally, it is important to note the connection of this State responsibility provision with the shipboard level performance of these obligations. The Declaration of Maritime Labour Compliance, Part I, which is part of the
principles and rights
certification documentation that must be carried by some ships, requires128 that the flag State administration state any “substantial equivalencies” in relation to listed areas of the Convention and indicate whether any “equivalency has been granted”.129 This information is intended to avoid difficulties for ships entering foreign ports during port State control. Unlike the IMO provisions or the flexibility under Article II of the MLC, , there is no requirement130 that a notice regarding substantial equivalencies be sent to the Director-General of the ILO other than through information contained in the Article report. Article VII—Consultation with Shipowners’ and Seafarers’ Organizations As noted earlier, Article VII can be seen as an example of an innovative approach to the situation of globalized/transnational workforces and employers. It forms part of the underlying structural pattern in the Convention of
128
See the model Declaration of Maritime Labour Compliance, Part I, MLC, , Appendix A-II, and Guideline B.., . The statement of national requirements in Part I of the declaration of maritime labour compliance should include or be accompanied by references to the legislative provisions relating to seafarers’ working and living conditions in each of the matters listed in Appendix A-I. Where national legislation precisely follows the requirements stated in this Convention, a reference may be all that is necessary. Where a provision of the Convention is implemented through substantial equivalence as provided under Article VI, paragraph , this provision should be identified and a concise explanation should be provided. Where an exemption is granted by the competent authority as provided . . .
129
The latter wording could create some confusion as it may give an impression of a ship specific determination by an administrative agency rather than the question of whether the flag State has implemented the Convention using substantial equivalence with respect to matters and that substantial compliance is relevant to the ship in question. Essentially the purpose is to address situations, particularly for port State control, where a ship may appear not to be in full conformity with the Convention, but in fact is in compliance with the flag State’s implementation of the Convention. There would then be the possibility of scrutiny of the State implementation through the ILO’s supervisory system. 130 This idea had been initially considered in an internal draft but was not included in the draft reviewed by the third meeting of the HLTWG in June (Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention (First Draft) Articles and Regulations, HLTWG, (Third Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/ twgmls/twgmls-r-.pdf). This may have been because this practice of circulating information among Members was not a usual aspect of the ILO process. In that respect it is interesting to note that a version of this approach was adopted in the text following the fourth HLTWG meeting in January , in connection with Regulation .., Authorization of recognized organizations. See: Standard A.., para. . In addition “determinations” under Article II are to be communicated to the Director-General “who shall notify the Members of the Organization” (not just the States party to the Convention).
chapter six
strengthening national social dialogue by requiring consultation in most instances where national flexibility is exercised.131 Article VII was introduced relatively late in the process of developing the text. It was introduced as square bracketed text in the draft convention considered by the fourth and last meeting of the HLTWG in January . The Office Report on that draft notes: This is a proposal for a new provision made by the Seafarers’ representatives at the third meeting of the High-level Group as a way to respond to the situation where there may be no representative organization of shipowners or seafarers in a jurisdiction to consult with (as required by a number of provisions). The wording has been slightly modified by the Office to achieve legal precision. The proposal was initially presented in conjunction with the discussion of the Article II exemptions for the coasting trade . . .; however the provision appeared to engage the broader obligation to carry out tripartite consultation, that is found throughout the Convention and has consequently been taken into account as a separate Article.132
Article VII was adopted with no debate at both the PTMC in and the th ILC.133 Under Article VII, when the Convention requires consultation to exercise flexibility (in various forms, e.g., derogation, exemption, or other flexible application) and representative organizations do not exist in the country, flexibility “may . . . only be decided” through consultation with the Special Tripartite Committee to be established under Article XIII. The difficulty with this provision lies with the initial period before the Convention enters into force. Although Article XIII does not expressly state that the Committee can only be established once the requirements under Article VIII for entry into force are met, the voting and membership procedures suggest that this would be the case. This means that as countries move to implement and ratify the Convention in
131
Consultation is not specifically required with respect to substantial equivalence or a decision to implement provisions in a way that differs from the Guidelines in Part B of the Code. 132 Office Report, supra note , Comment (on Article VII). 133 Committee of the Whole Report, supra note , para. ; Committee No. Report, supra note : . The Shipowner Vice-Chairperson had no objections to Article VII and proposed removing the brackets so that the Article could be adopted. . The Seafarer Vice-Chairperson noted that, as was highlighted in the Office report to the draft Convention, Article VII had been originally proposed by the Seafarers’ group and therefore he fully supported the Shipowners’ proposal to remove the brackets. Article VII would enable a pragmatic approach in areas of the Convention that needed flexibility. In cases where some flag States might not have organizations of seafarers or shipowners, consultation and dialogue could still be conducted with the Maritime Committees in order to guarantee the rights of seafarers.
principles and rights
order to allow it to enter into force, there may be difficulty in exercising flexibility. This poses a particular problem for countries where the national practice does not allow ratification until national legislative provisions to implement it are in place. This seems to apply even when the Convention, under Article VIII, provides a -month ‘grace’ period following ratification.134 In addition, in some cases, for example, in connection with ship certification, legislation may be needed to authorize what may be an extensive process to inspect and certify ships that go on international voyages within this -month period.135 Whether an organization is viewed as representative of the seafarers or the shipowners concerned is also a problem for countries with substantial international fleets and international seafarers, even if there is a national organization that represents workers or employers. The best but longer term solution would be to encourage national organizations to develop an international section dealing with the interests of all seafarers on the country’s flag ships.136 However, this initial phase before the Convention enters into force is problematic. The decision of the ILO Governing Body at its th Session in November to establish a preparatory committee modeled on the Special Tripartite Committee might have been of some assistance in providing tripartite advice to such countries.137 Articles VIII–XVI The remaining Articles, VIII–XVI, are a mix of, essentially, standard form treaty provisions, for example, authoritative languages and depository functions, and provisions dealing with the operation of the Convention itself rather than State obligations under the Convention, for example, amendment procedures, entry into force, and effect of entry into force.138 For provisions such as Articles IX and XIII (depositary functions of the Director-General of the International Labour 134
In addition the Article report would not be required until a later date (i.e., months). This problem was foreseen by the th ILC and a resolution adopted to assist the States that help to bring the Convention into force. Selection Committee Reports, supra note , Resolution concerning the practical implementation of the issue of certificates on entry into force, pp. –/– –/. See also Chapter . 136 A government could also consult the local seafarers’ or workers’ and employers’ representative bodies, if any, on the question as to which organizations should be considered as the ‘organizations concerned’ with respect to these kinds of global issues. 137 The decision of the ILO Governing Body at its th Session in November to establish a preparatory committee modelled on the Special Tripartite Committee could have been of some assistance in providing tripartite advice to such countries. However the meeting of the Committee in September was of the view that no interim procedures could be established. See: Final Report, supra note . 138 As explained in the ILO Drafting Manual, supra note (citations omitted): 135
chapter six
Office) and Article XVI (Authoritative Languages), the standard ILO provisions were adopted with no discussion. There are, however, several points of legal interest in some of these operational provisions, such as entry into force, the effect of entry into force, and amendment procedures. Article VIII—Entry into Force For the most part, the entry into force provisions are not controversial and reflect standard ILO drafting practice.139 However, the precise formula for entry .. Final provisions ... International law and practice . The final provisions are an integral part of the operative provisions of any international convention or treaty and have binding force in law. Nevertheless, the final provisions have a different purpose from the other provisions. They are usually technical in nature and are intended as guidance for the implementation of the instrument, relating specifically to its entry into force, its expiry and ratification formalities. For this reason, they are sometimes referred to as “formal clauses” or “standard clauses”. . Final provisions in multilateral treaties vary in nature. Most contain articles on: the settlement of disputes; amendment and revision of the instrument; the status of any annexes; signature; ratification; accession; entry into force; duration; denunciation; reservations; designation of the depositary and the associated functions; registration; and authoritative language versions. Depending on the nature and substance of the instrument, there may also be other provisions referring to a transitional period; suspension of the instrument’s provisions; or its relationship with previous instruments. 139
It is notable that even the more standard aspects varied from the standard clauses with the addition of the first paragraph that appears to simply state the practice for ratification. It may also introduce a question about the implications of the phrase ‘formal ratifications’. See: ILO Drafting Manual, supra note , comments (citations omitted): . The Constitution of the ILO contains no provisions regarding the conditions of ratification of Conventions, their entry into force, revision or denunciation, or notification of ratifications to Members. These matters are determined by the provisions contained in the Final Articles of Conventions. The ILO has generally used standard provisions reproduced without any major modifications in the Final Articles of each new Convention. These standard provisions have been adopted as such by the ILC. ... . The standard final provisions adopted by the Conference have comprised two types of significant developments. The first concerns entry into force, which was significantly modified in some of the maritime labour Conventions adopted since . . . . .... Entry into force of the Convention (Standard provision B) . Article . . . in the final provisions governing entry into force now has the following form: Article . . . . This Convention shall be binding only upon those Members of the International Labour Organization whose ratifications have been registered with the Director-General of the International Labour Office.
principles and rights
into force was a matter that was not settled until agreement was reached by a working group140 at the th ILC on provisions that also dealt with the formula for amendment procedures in Articles XIV and XV. The entry into force formula is also linked to the amendment of the Convention obligation, . It shall come into force [twelve] months after the date on which the ratifications of [two] Members have been registered with the Director-General. . Thereafter, this Convention shall come into force for any Member [twelve] months after the date on which its ratification has been registered. 140
Committee of the Whole Report, supra note , concerning Article VIII: . At the suggestion of the Steering Committee, a Working Party was established to examine the provisions on entry into force and certain aspects of the amendment procedures. The Working Party was given the following tasks: . To make proposals to fill the gaps left in Article VIII, paragraph , Article XIV, paragraph , and Article XV, paragraph , of the proposed Convention, with any consequential adjustments to the text. . To make a proposal to fill the gaps left in Article XV, paragraph , of the proposed Convention, with any consequential adjustments to the text. . To clarify the issues concerning a possible inconsistency between Article XIV, paragraph , and Article XV, paragraph , with respect to the event (e.g. adoption, deemed acceptance, entry into force) after which an amendment will be binding on newly ratifying Members when it enters into force, and to set out options for resolving any such inconsistency, if necessary. After the completion of each task, the Working Party would report to the Steering Committee on the progress of its work. . The Chairperson invited the Committee to discuss in general terms the issues to be covered by the Working Party so as to give it guidance in its work. . The Employer Vice-Chairperson indicated that a variety of views had been expressed within the Employers’ group on the issues to be covered by the Working Party and that the Employer members of the Working Party would represent this range of views. The Employers’ group had not fixed specific figures for the number of member States and the tonnage of world shipping required for the entry into force of the Convention. In view of the broad support for the Convention, such figures were only of relative importance, although a decision would have to be taken on the subject. . The Worker Vice-Chairperson expressed the hope that, with regard to the complex issues involved in Article XV, paragraph , and the possible inconsistency between Article XIV, paragraph , and Article XV, paragraph , the Working Party would be able to propose solutions that were readily understandable. On the subject of the entry into force provisions, he recalled the position expressed previously by the Workers’ group that member States and one-third of world shipping tonnage might be appropriate figures. A balance would be required between a realistic approach that would allow the Convention to enter into force within a reasonable period, such as five years, while not setting thresholds that were too low. Current ratification rates of the maritime Conventions varied widely. Another issue was whether reference should be made to the actual world tonnage of shipping or ILO member State tonnage. There were countries, such as the Marshall Islands, which were not ILO member States, but had a considerable shipping tonnage. It would
chapter six
an innovation for ILO conventions. As explained in Chapter , ordinarily ILO conventions are revised though the adoption of a new instrument by an International Labour Conference, which would include States not party to the Convention concerned, rather than being amended. Leaving aside the issue of amendment, the main concern regarding entry into force was the formula that would trigger entry into force of the Convention. The final formula adopted is more stringent141 than previous ILO conventions and is specifically aimed at ensuring key actors, particularly flag and port States, in the sector are party.142
therefore be preferable to refer to ILO member State tonnage. One solution might be to provide a formula that combined the two criteria of tonnage and member States. . The Government member of China, speaking on behalf of the Government group, stated that on Article VIII, paragraph , there was general support for requiring ratification by Members for entry into force. There was also general agreement that gross tonnage should refer to world tonnage and not to ILO member State tonnage. Finally, a majority supported per cent of gross tonnage for entry into force, while some Governments favoured higher figures of up to per cent of gross tonnage. Regarding Article XV, paragraphs and , there had been general agreement on the figure of five Governments to allow for the proposal of amendments to the Code, although other views had also been expressed for larger and smaller numbers [. . .] The Government group shared the view that references to both tonnage and member States should be kept. 141
As discussed in Chapter , Convention No. , supra note , also had a fairly large tonnage figure and, for an ILO convention, a high number of ratifications. Article , paragraph , requires registered ratifications by at least ten Members with a total share of the world shipping gross tonnage of per cent. Typically, ILO conventions need very few ratifications to enter into force. See: ILO Drafting Manual, supra note , para. . 142 To some extent the gross tonnage figures are at a best an estimate. They are drawn from IHS Fairplay, World Fleet Statistics, available at http://www.ihsfairplay.com/Maritime_data/ World_Fleet_Statistics/World_Fleet_Statistics.html?product=Report,WorldFleetStatistics&i=. This annual publication shows “the composition of the current self-propelled, sea-going merchant fleet of GT or above, as at December”. These figures may rely on national definitions of ‘seagoing’ and the tonnage does not have the same coverage as the Convention. However, it can be viewed purely as an agreed upon formula that is accepted in the sector. Interestingly, the recently adopted Work in Fishing Convention, , supra note , requires ratification by coastal States (Art. ). However, coastal States would not necessarily have flag State responsibility for distant water fleets. Recommendation No. , supra note , adopted with the Convention, provides in paragraph : . A Member, in its capacity as a coastal State, when granting licences for fishing in its exclusive economic zone, may require that fishing vessels comply with the requirements of the Convention. If such licences are issued by coastal States, these States should take into account certificates or other valid documents stating that the vessel concerned has been inspected by the competent authority or on its behalf and has been found to be in compliance with the provisions of the Convention.
principles and rights
. This Convention shall come into force months after the date on which there have been registered ratifications by at least Members with a total share in the world gross tonnage of ships of at least per cent.
The rationale and policy considerations behind the final requirements were explained by the Working Party when making the proposal as follows (emphasis added): . With regard to Article VIII, paragraph , the Working Party had deemed it appropriate to keep the figures for the entry into force of the Convention high enough to give legitimacy to the instrument, yet low enough to allow the Convention to enter into force within the next five years. After lengthy discussion, the members of the Working Party had unanimously suggested a figure of registered ratifications and per cent of the world or global tonnage for the gaps left in Article VIII, paragraph . The Working Party had also unanimously agreed on the same results for Article XIV, paragraph , on the entry into force of amendments to the Articles and Regulations of the Convention, given that these provisions related to the core principles of the Convention. It should be noted that for both of these provisions, some participants of the Working Party had felt that the numbers were too high, while others had felt that they were too low, and others had felt that ILO tonnage, not world tonnage, should be used. After long debates, in the spirit of finding a way forward and getting the job done, compromises had been made by the participants.143
Clearly the participants at the th ILC envisaged a fairly lengthy lead time to bring the Convention into force, that is, within five years. This view, if anything, proved to have been somewhat optimistic.144 143
Committee of the Whole Report, supra note . See also: Report I(A), supra note , which noted that: . In addition to the consideration related to the “no more favourable treatment” clause, account needs to be taken of the position adopted by constituents concerning the effects of the Convention’s entry into force that result from Article X of the Convention. . . . the Convention reflects the view that existing maritime labour Conventions should, in most cases, be globally replaced by the new consolidating maritime labour Convention. This means, for example, that a country which is not in a position to ratify the comprehensive maritime labour Convention, but would like to ratify important existing Conventions such as Convention No. , would not be able to ratify these after the new Convention has come into force. This position concerning Article X would therefore be justified only if a relatively high level of ratifications is required before the new Convention can come into force. Taking the suggestion (consistent with what has just been said) that the number of ratifying Members should be set at , paragraph of Article VIII might be worded as follows: . This Convention shall come into force months after the date on which there have been registered ratifications by at least Members comprising at least half the number of States with a share of at least [one] per cent of the gross tonnage of the world’s merchant ships. 144
The International Labour Office subsequently (September ) adopted the comprehensive
chapter six
A further point to note in these provisions relates to what may, outside the Charter of the United Nations (Article ), be a unique ILO practice. This relates to what may simply appear to be the description of an administrative record-keeping action, the ‘registration’ of the ratifications. However, as noted in the International Labour Office guidance on this point (emphasis added), . Paragraph . . . of [this standard form] Article . . . nevertheless goes somewhat beyond the final sentence of Article of the Constitution, in stipulating that for a Convention to be binding on Members, ratification must be registered by the Director-General. Such a condition is unusual in international treaties, and would appear to be a special feature of ILO Conventions. If a ratification communicated to the Director-General is for any reason not registered, the Member would not be bound by the Convention that had been ratified. The effect of ratification thus depends on a positive act—namely, registration—by the depositary. By contrast with the usual role of the depositary under international law,113 the Director General of the ILO can refuse to register a ratification for reasons that go beyond questions of form. For example, a ratification which involved lack of conformity on a matter of substance, or which would effectively constitute a reservation, can be refused by the ILO Director-General himself.114 Paragraph . . . of Article . . . above thus imposes a procedural condition, in addition to that of Article of the Constitution and general international law according to which normally the mere fact of ratification gives rise to obligations. In practice, this additional condition has been useful as a means of ensuring that ratifications accompanied by declarations having the effect of reservations (which are not admissible) are revised and amended by the States concerned.145
The MLC, , unlike the predecessor Convention No. , does not expressly set any conditions on ratification (or registration). However, a question might arise as to whether the requirement under paragraph of Standard A. on social security, that “Each Member shall at the time of ratification specify the branches for which protection is provided in accordance with paragraph of this Standard. . . . The Director-General shall maintain a register of this information and shall make it available to . . . ”, is a condition of registration. Alternatively, since this requirement is in the Code rather than an article or five-year Action Plan to achieve widespread rapid ratification followed by efforts to ensure effective implementation of the Maritime Labour Convention, (Action Plan –), available at http://www.ilo.org/global/standards/maritime-labour-convention/WCMS_/langen/index.htm. 145 ILO Drafting Manual, supra note , citing at note , P. Reuter, Introduction to the law of treaties, Pinter Publishers, , para. ; and at footnote , “One particularly clear example of this is the simultaneous ratification by Malta of C and C. Although C did not have the effect of closing C to ratification, the ratification of the former did entail ipso jure denunciation of the latter. Consequently, ratification of C ceased to have any purpose, which the Director-General cited as a reason for non-registration”.
principles and rights
even a regulation, it may simply be that this is another substantive requirement and that failure to file this information is a matter that could be a subject of comment under the ILO supervisory system. A further point in connection with the entry into force date relates to when the requirements, especially those related to ship construction and accommodation, will be applicable. Often maritime conventions have a particular period or date for application of requirements once it enters into force, irrespective of the date that a particular State ratifies. As noted above, the MLC, follows ILO practice and allows for a -month period before entry into force for the first States required to trigger entry into force. Thereafter each State that ratifies also has months from the date of ratification before the provisions apply.146 As the Office Report for the th ILC in points out: . It is also important to note that paragraph of Article VIII proposes a -month period before ratification becomes effective for a Member ratifying after the Convention has come into force. This is the normal period in the ILO and it is particularly important in the context of Title and the transitional provision it contains for older existing ships and may also be relevant to the issue of adjustments within the domestic systems and to ship construction.147
Although this creates what might be seen as a potential disincentive to ratification for registries that may be attractive to older ships, port State control in 146
This has been described as an objective and a subjective phase for entry into force. See: ILO Drafting Manual, supra note : . Paragraphs . . .. of Article . . . set the date of entry into force of the Convention, which is essential for the Convention to give rise to obligations on member States. The paragraphs draw a distinction between two phases of entry into force. The first is the initial or “objective” entry into force with regard to the ILO, which is the starting point for the purpose of reckoning time limits for denunciation (see denunciation) and brings into effect the obligations and rights under Articles , and of the Constitution. It also marks the entry into force of the Convention for member States which ratified it months or more before this date (paragraph . . .). The second phase of entry into force is the individual or “subjective” entry into force for each Member that ratifies the Convention after its initial entry into force (paragraph . . .). These time limits are not set by the Constitution of the ILO or by any provision of public international law.
147
Report I(A), supra note , Note (Article VII). The existing ship provision in Title , Regulation ., paragraph , provides (emphasis added): . The requirements in the Code implementing this Regulation which relate to ship construction and equipment apply only to ships constructed on or after the date when this Convention comes into force for the Member concerned. For ships constructed before that date, the requirements relating to ship construction and equipment that are set out in the Accommodation of Crews Convention (Revised), (No. ), and the Accommodation of Crews (Supplementary Provisions) Convention, (No. ), shall continue to apply to the extent that they were applicable, prior to that date, under the law or practice of the Member concerned. A ship shall be deemed to have been constructed on the date when its keel is laid or when it is at a similar stage of construction.
chapter six
the context of the no more favourable treatment provisions in Article V, paragraph , are also an incentive to ratify. One question may arise in relation to the extent of implementation required when ratifying. The depositary authority would not extend to verifying whether or not a ratifying country is fully in a position to implement the Convention at the time of ratification,148 because implementation is not required until entry into force of the Convention for the country concerned, that is, twelve months (or more in the case of ratifications leading up to entry into force of the MLC, ). The first report for a country under Article of the ILO Constitution is not requested until twelve months after entry into force for the country concerned, that is, at least months after ratification for a country ratifying after the MLC, has entered into force. However the impact of port State control and the requirements for a Declaration of Maritime Labour Compliance, Part I, means that in fact most matters must be addressed at ratification or within months, once the Convention is in force. Article IX—Denunciation Article IX is a standard ILO provision. It provides that the countries that have ratified the Convention cannot denounce it until ten years after the Convention’s entry into force, with the denunciation becoming effective months later.149 There are two points of special interest to note in Article IX. First, the tenyear period is based on the Convention’s date of initial entry into force rather than the date of entry into force for the country concerned. Second, as described below, since Article X the MLC, revises existing conventions, subject to a few exceptions,150 any of those conventions that have been ratified by a 148
Although as a matter of national law and practice some countries require this before ratification. 149 See: “Denunciation,” ILO Drafting Manual, supra note , section .... As noted by the Legal Department of the ILO: . Denunciation is the act whereby a Member may terminate its obligations under a Convention it has ratified, as well as its constitutional obligations with respect to that Convention. [. . .] There are broadly two types of denunciation: those that follow automatically from the ratification of a Convention revising an earlier Convention . . .; and “pure” denunciations effected by an act of denunciation communicated to the Director-General of the International Labour Office. 150
Regulation ., paragraph , is a transitional provision regarding the Certification of Able Seamen Convention, (No. ). These training responsibilities were ‘transferred’ to the IMO to be dealt within in connection with the review of the STCW. However, until the IMO adopts mandatory provisions that enter into force or five years after entry in force of the MLC, , whichever date is earliest, existing obligations under Convention No. remain applicable. The IMO adopted such provisions in June (Manila Amendments, supra note ). See
principles and rights
country will be ipso jure (automatically without a further act by the country) denounced by the act of ratifying the MLC, . However, the existing obligations would remain in force until the MLC, enters into force. Article X—Effect of Entry into Force Initially it was expected that the MLC, would consolidate all existing upto-date maritime labour conventions. However, the final text lists conventions, some of which are not considered as ‘up-to-date’ by the ILO or are not even in force, and does not include four conventions. Two of these, the Seafarers’ Identity Documents Convention, (No. ) and its revising convention, Seafarers’ Identity Documents Convention (Revised), (No. ), were included in early drafts of the MLC, . However the rapid growth in border security concerns meant that a convention entering into force more rapidly than the MLC, was needed.151 Although Convention No. could have been included as of , there were concerns about potential difficulties with respect to implementation if the topic was included in the MLC, . A decision was made at the PTMC in not to include the topic and these two conventions. Two other conventions were not included for different reasons. The Minimum Age (Trimmers and Stockers) Convention, (No. ) is considered an out-of-date convention.152 The change in ship technology means that its provision are not consolidated in the MLC, other than in the general minimum age requirements. The Seafarers’ Pension Convention, (No. ) had been included in the Article X list of the text considered by the th ILC. However, in the Seafarers’ Group was of the view that its obligations were not in fact revised in the text of the MLC, and proposed instead an amendment that would add a new regulation on pensions. This was not accepted by the employers at the th ILC and the decision was taken to leave Convention No. out of the list of revised conventions.153 Chapter regarding the STCW review. In addition, conventions adopted prior to did not have provisions allowing for ipso jure termination of obligations through revision. 151 These documents confirm a seafarer’s professional identity as a seafarer. They are used to facilitate access for shore leave and use of welfare services in foreign ports and to transit foreign countries to join or leave ships. Convention No. includes several modern enhanced security features. 152 Arguably, its concerns are covered by Regulation . and minimum age and hazardous work restrictions. 153 See also the discussion in Chapter . Committee of the Whole Report, supra note : . The Chairperson opened a general discussion on the issues raised in amendment D., which was sponsored by the Workers’ group and sought to add square brackets around the words “Seafarers’ Pensions Convention, (No. )”. . The Worker Vice-Chairperson explained that this amendment related to a technical issue. In so far as the proposed Convention did not contain any provisions on seafarers’ pensions,
chapter six
Although the MLC, revises the conventions and seeks to establish a single set of international standards, States are party to different conventions. Thus “[u]ntil the consolidating Convention is ratified by all of the States that have ratified the existing maritime labour Conventions, it will necessarily have to coexist to varying degrees (depending on their ratification levels) with the obligations under the present international maritime labour Conventions”.154 As noted above under Article IX, once the MLC, enters into force, a country that has ratified will ipso jure denounce, subject to few exceptions, any of the conventions that it has previously ratified. The exceptions are conventions that although listed in Article X, were adopted before . The Office Report for the th ILC proposed that a “pragmatic commonsense approach will need to be take with respect to Conventions ratified before ”.155 The Office proposal was developed to help ensure a coherent approach
. . . . . .
it could not be deemed to revise the Seafarers’ Pensions Convention, (No. ), which had been ratified by member States. Instead of deleting the reference, his group preferred, however, to include provisions on pensions in the proposed Convention and would submit an amendment to that effect. He therefore suggested that consideration of the inclusion or deletion of the reference be postponed. The Employer Vice-Chairperson had no objection to deferring a decision with respect to the reference to Convention No. . He gave clear warning, however, that any reopening of the discussion on Regulation . regarding social security would have grave consequences. The Worker Vice-Chairperson suggested that the issue could be dealt with in a new Regulation. The Employer Vice-Chairperson replied that the question of pensions was part and parcel of the social security debate which his group was unwilling to reopen. The Worker Vice-Chairperson rejoined that a formal revision of the Seafarers’ Pensions Convention, (No. ) would not be acceptable, unless the issue of pensions was specifically addressed in the maritime labour Convention. The Chairperson concluded that consideration of this issue would be postponed. As a result of later discussions on Title , it was agreed that amendment D., subamended to delete the reference to Convention No. , was adopted. Article X, with the exception of the reference to the Seafarers’ Pensions Convention, (No. ) was adopted.
154
Report I(A), supra note , Note (Article X). Ibid., footnote . The Legal Department of ILO explained the situation as follows in the ILO Drafting Manual, supra note , footnote :
155
This means that the mechanism for closure to ratification and automatic denunciation is absent from C to C. Despite the adoption of a revising Convention, these Conventions remain open to ratification and explicit denunciation is required for them to cease to be enforceable with regard to a State ratifying the revised Convention. For example, Serbia and Montenegro ratified C and C on maternity protection on the same date ( November ). However, once the Constitution of the International Labour Organisation Instrument of Amendment, , will have come into force, it will be possible for the Conference to abrogate any Convention that has lost its purpose or that no longer makes a useful contribution to attaining the objectives of the Organization.
principles and rights
to achieving the intention behind Article X of bringing all existing commitments listed in Article X in line with the MLC, when it comes into force. This approach involved a proposal to ratifying countries that have also ratified pre- conventions that, unless they communicate otherwise to the International Labour Office, the Director-General, as depository, would regard ratification of the MLC, as having the effect of denunciation of these earlier conventions. That denunciation would then be registered on the date that the MLC, comes into force for the country concerned. Clearly a parallel system will also be required under the ILO supervisory system for a period of time as the conventions will remain in force for countries that have ratified them but not ratified the MLC, . This means that only parties to the MLC, will be able to file the single Article report for the MLC, , as required by the ILO reporting cycles;156 non-ratifying countries will continue to file reports on each ratified convention. However, the conventions listed in Article X will be closed to further ratifications as of the (initial) entry into force of the MLC, . The MLC, is often described as consolidating nearly instruments (initially now conventions and related recommendations). The situation of recommendations now contained in the MLC, provisions differs, and they are not listed in Article X. Recommendations are not binding obligations under international law. As pointed out in the Office Report for the th ILC: . . . . If considered necessary or desirable, the existing Recommendations, as well as the listed Conventions that have not yet entered into force can, in due course, be withdrawn by decision of the International Labour Conference taken in accordance with Article bis of its Standing Orders. The process of withdrawing outdated Recommendations . . . is in fact under way. In any event, should the provisions of any Recommendation conflict with any part of the new Convention, these would be regarded as superseded.157
One issue that may arise for governments, since the MLC, in consolidating also modifies and updates existing conventions, relates to the impact of the Convention on existing national standards adopted under an earlier convention, if they appear to be ‘higher’. This issue would arise in connection with Article , paragraph , of the ILO Constitution, which is referenced in the Preamble to the MLC, . Under this provision, the ratification of any convention by a Member must be deemed not to affect any law, award, custom, or agreement that ensures more favourable conditions to the workers concerned than those provided for in the convention. If a national law appears to establish more favourable conditions for seafarers, then these would apply. However, in 156 157
See Chapter . Report I(A), supra note , Note (Article X).
chapter six
almost all cases, the more favourable provisions would be in line with the MLC, since it only sets out minimum requirements. In addition, it incorporates the substance of most of the revised/denounced conventions, while providing some flexibility as to the details of application. However, the question of what is a more favourable condition may not be obvious. For example, in the context of accommodation and recreational facilities, the requirements in Standard A. of the MLC, should be considered as a whole, if the benefit to seafarers of the requirements under the Standard A. package is at least equivalent to the benefits given by the convention(s) previously ratified by the country concerned. The fact that certain aspects under the previous law appear in isolation to be more favourable to seafarers could then, probably, be ignored. There could, however, be cases where it may not be easy to weigh the benefits concerned, especially where the MLC, has adopted an approach different to that of existing conventions. However, these cases would be unusual. Articles XI and XII—Depositary Functions These two articles are, essentially, standard form administrative provisions confirming the obligations of the Director-General of the ILO to notify ILO Member States about the status of the Convention and to transmit information about ratifications to the Secretary-General of the United Nations. Article XIII—Special Tripartite Committee The Article XIII Special Tripartite Committee was referred to in connection with Article VII. This Committee will be established by the ILO’s Governing Body once the Convention receives sufficient ratifications to enter into force. Its main function is, as stated in Article XIII, paragraph , “keeping the working of this Convention under continuous review”. It also has, as previously explained, a specific function in connection with international global social dialogue. Importantly, as set out in Article XV, it has a central role in connection with the accelerated amendment procedure for the Code of the MLC, . The Special Tripartite Committee comprises two representatives of governments that have ratified the MLC, and shipowner and seafarer representatives chosen by the Governing Body on the advice of the JMC. Non-ratifying Members may also participate in meetings. An interesting institutional aspect of this new committee, once established, will be considering its role relative to the oversight work already undertaken by the Committee of Experts under the ILO supervisory system.158 The possible nature of that relationship was explained as follows (emphasis added):
158
See Chapter .
principles and rights
. The representative of the Secretary-General responded that the proposed Convention was unprecedented in terms of the detailed explanatory information available as to the evolution of each provision over the four years of preparatory work. Hence, the real intention of the drafters should be clear. Also, unlike the Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, (No. ), the proposed maritime labour Convention contained a clear definition of “substantial equivalence” in Article VI. The Committee of Experts would be relieved to have so many elements on which to evaluate compliance. She concluded by recalling that a Special Tripartite Committee was provided for by the Convention and would provide useful inputs to the Committee of Experts with regard to the practical application of the Convention.159
Aside from its role, as discussed above in connection with Article VII, in filling a gap in tripartite social dialogue for a globalized sector, another interesting feature of this Committee is that it may, in some respects, echo the more usual treaty approach whereby ratifying countries consider amendments to conventions to which they are a party, as opposed to the more usual ILO practice160 whereby all countries are involved, even if they have not ratified the convention in question. This seems like a logical step given the need for a more rapid amendment procedure for the Code (Part A, Standards), which contains the detailed operational provisions in the Convention. Since voting rights are involved, a point of some debate during the adoption of this article was the formula for voting rights and the (––) balance struck in Article XIII, paragraph , between the votes of governments’, shipowners’, and seafarers’ votes.161 Nevertheless the Committee will also remain linked to ILO practices as all Members may participate in meetings, with voting rights linked to ratification. Non-ratifying countries will also have the right to propose amendments and will take part in the process for the approval of such amendments in the ILC on the same basis as the Members that have ratified the Convention.
159 160 161
Committee of the Whole Report, supra note . See Chapter . Report I(A), supra note , Note (Article XIII): Paragraph provides for the Governments on the committee to have twice the voting power of the Shipowner and Seafarer representatives on the committee. This –– configuration will mean that, in the (probably unlikely) event of a formal vote being needed in the committee, the Governments will have per cent of the votes, and the Shipowners and the Seafarers will each have per cent. In addition, in the case of the adoption of amendments to the Code, paragraph (c) of Article XV protects any one of the three tripartite groups from being outvoted: a vote will not be carried if it does not have the support of at least half the voting power of each of the three groups.
chapter six
Articles XIV and XV—Amendments The Office Report for the th ILC suggests that, at least from an ILO perspective, the amendment provisions in this Convention, particularly in Article XV dealing with amendments to the Code, are one of its most innovative aspects.162 It will be recalled, from the discussion in Chapters and that the usual ILO process for changing provisions in a convention is to adopt a new convention revising the existing convention. Hence, in part, the reason for the proliferation of conventions and patchwork of coverage in terms of ratifications. The amendment provisions in Articles XIV and XV were subject to extensive debate mainly with respect to getting the voting balances agreed. The main legal point to note is that Article XIV, Amendment of this Convention, provides for amendments to the entire Convention (any level of provision) by the General Conference of the ILO in the framework of Article of the ILO Constitution. Under the process in Article XIV, in accordance with ILO practice, all ILO Member States, not just those that are party to the MLC, , are involved in the process of adopting amendments. Further, the process requires express ratification of the amended Convention. This is in contrast with Article XV, Amendments to the Code, which addresses only amendments to the Code through an accelerated amendment process that was developed to meet the need for more rapid updating of the technical parts of the Convention, without the need for a revision version of the Convention. The latter process draws on IMO convention procedures using what is sometime called ‘tacit acceptance’, which does not require express ratification. The Office Report for the th ILC, explains the conceptual differences and also provides information regarding expectations for future use of these two articles, again much as the distinction in the amendment procedures in IMO conventions: Note . . . . Article XIV sets out the procedures, in the framework of Article of the Constitution, for amendment of the Convention as a whole, involving an express ratification procedure. The procedure envisaged will be an innovation for the ILO, but the legal effects of this amendment procedure will be the same as that of the procedures used in the ILO for the revision or modification of instruments, with one important exception: there will be no separate revising Convention or Protocol; there will be a single amended Convention. . . . . . . . Although the procedure under Article XIV can be used for the amendment of any provision of the Convention, it is likely (because of the costs and potential delays involved) to be used only if there were an unavoidable need to amend major provisions of the Convention (in the Articles and Regulations). It is therefore reasonable for Members considering ratification of 162
Ibid., Note (Article XV).
principles and rights
the Convention to assume that such essential amendments will eventually enter into force. If, however, a Member wishes to have complete certainty in this respect it should take steps to ratify the Convention at an early date. . . . Indeed, under the Article XIV procedure, amendments could take several years to enter into force (or reach the stage of deemed acceptance), thus helping to perpetuate the coexistence of substantially different versions of the same Convention.163
The formula under Article XIV to trigger entry into force of the amended Convention is set out paragraph and is the same as the formula for the MLC, set out in Article VIII, including the -month ‘grace’ period between ‘date of acceptance’ (meeting the formula) or registration of the ratification if after ‘date of acceptance’. Article XIV also provides, in paragraph , for the situation of a country that is party to the MLC, but does not ratify the amendments to the Convention and, in paragraph , for countries to ratify the MLC, text after an amendment has been adopted but is not in force. This is consistent with ILO practice in that the existing conventions are not closed to ratification by a revising convention until the latter enters into force. As noted above Article XV, Amendments to the Code, provides for a process sometimes described as ‘accelerated amendment’. It is based on the tacit acceptance procedure adopted for one form of amendments of IMO conventions and is also the process available for the amendment of some provisions in the LOSC.164 The IMO approach was seen as important and useful, but was adopted with some modifications to meet concerns for the ILO processes.165 The tacit 163 164
Report I(A), supra note , Note (Article XIV). See: LOSC, supra note , Art. , Amendment by simplified procedure, . A State Party may, by written communication addressed to the Secretary-General of the United Nations, propose an amendment to this Convention, other than an amendment relating to activities in the Area, to be adopted by the simplified procedure set forth in this article without convening a conference. The Secretary-General shall circulate the communication to all States Parties. . If, within a period of months from the date of the circulation of the communication, a State Party objects to the proposed amendment or to the proposal for its adoption by the simplified procedure, the amendment shall be considered rejected. The Secretary-General shall immediately notify all States Parties accordingly. . If, months from the date of the circulation of the communication, no State Party has objected to the proposed amendment or to the proposal for its adoption by the simplified procedure, the proposed amendment shall be considered adopted. The Secretary-General shall notify all States Parties that the proposed amendment has been adopted.
165
Report I(A), supra note , Note (Article XV): . This simplified or accelerated amendment procedure developed for the consolidated maritime labour Convention is similar to that provided for in Conventions adopted in the framework of the IMO, such as SOLAS. The procedure has, however, been adapted to the special features of the International Labour Organization, in particular its tripartite
chapter six
acceptance procedure basically shifts from express ratification of an amendment to requiring express refusal or objection in order to prevent adoption or non-application of an amendment. Silence by a State that has ratified a convention is taken as tacit acceptance. This approach reflects the view that often countries do not disagree with the provisions in an international agreement, but may not be able to rapidly implement the necessary national legal steps to formally agree and be bound by an amendment. This puts some onus on governments to actively respond if there is a serious difficulty with a proposed amendment. As mentioned, Article XV deals only with amendments to the Code, in particular the standards in Part A, since these are the binding provisions. It not clear whether an amendment could be made to the Part B (Guidelines) provisions alone in any other way since the guidelines are not binding as such. Although the Convention does not distinguish between Parts A and B, presumably the Article XV procedures also apply to Part B of the Code. In practice an amendment only to Part B seems unlikely, since the guidelines in Part B are intended to provide guidance for the implementation of the binding obligations in Part A and the regulations: changes to Part B would, presumably, also involve amendments to Part A of the Code. Article XV is lengthy with paragraphs setting out details of voting procedures and the consequences of the adoption of amendments at the shipboard level under port State control. The process is complex and was so new to the ILO that the Office Report for the th ILC used a flow chart to explain it.166 For purposes of this chapter it is not necessary to examine all the details, however, several features are notable, particularly in connection with the role of the Article XIII Special Tripartite Committee and the countries that have ratified the MLC, . Paragraph establishes who can make proposals for amendments. A proposal for an amendment is submitted to the Director-General of the ILO by the group of shipowners’ or seafarers’ representatives on the Article XIII Special Tripartite Committee or by the government of any Member of the Organization. Proposals made by governments must be supported by a group or by a least five governments that have ratified the Convention or by the group of shipowners’ or seafarers’ representatives. The Director-General is then required to communicate the proposal to all ILO Members. structure and the pre-eminent role, given by the Constitution to the Organization as a whole, through the International Labour Conference, with respect to the adoption and revision of Conventions; in particular, the revision of a Convention is a matter for the Organization as a whole rather than only for the Members that have ratified it. 166
Report I(A), supra note , Appendix E.
principles and rights
After no less than three and no more than nine months, the proposal and a summary of observations or suggestions received is transmitted to the Article XIII Special Tripartite Committee for consideration with a view to adoption (subject to the approval of the ILC). Under paragraph , an amendment can be adopted by the Committee if at least half the ratifying Members are represented at the meeting and a two-thirds majority votes in favour of adoption of an amendment and the majority voting mix comprises half of the government (ratifying countries) and half of the shipowner voting power and half the seafarer voting power of Committee members registered at the meeting. The procedures under Article XIII mean that all countries that are Members of the ILO can participate in the discussions, but only the members of the Special Tripartite Committee can vote (i.e., the ratifying Members in the case of governments). If the vote is in favour, the next step is notification and transmission of all amendments to be considered and approved by a vote167 at the next ILC. However, the role of the ILC in question is limited under the MLC, . It cannot reformulate the amendment, and if approval is not obtained, the amendment is referred back to the Special Tripartite Committee. The procedures for approved amendments—the submission of approved amendments for consideration—is very similar to the IMO procedures. The amendments are notified only to Members that have ratified the Convention, which are given a period to react (normally two years); other ILO Members receive a copy for their information.168 The amendment is deemed to have been accepted unless a formal expression of disagreement by per cent of the Members ratifying the Convention, representing not less than per cent of the gross tonnage of the Members that have ratified the MLC, , is received by the end of the two years or another period (but at least one year) set by the Conference. It is notable that this formula differs from the Article VIII and Article XIV entry into force requirements. Clearly the focus in this provision is the Special Tripartite Committee and the views of the ratifying countries as to whether an amendment will be adopted. It is evident that this simplified or accelerated procedure nevertheless reflects several ILO safeguards based on ILO practice that do not exist under the IMO conventions. 167
See Article XV, para. . Article XV does not specifically refer to the question of applicability of an amendment to Members that ratify the Convention after the amendment has been approved by the Conference but before the amendment enters into force. However, paragraph provides that, after an amendment enters in force, the Convention may only be ratified in its amended form. This can be understood as implying that the Convention can be ratified in its original form before the amendment enters into force. It would be up to the ratifying country to clarify, perhaps in a declaration (i.e., as per Art. XIV, para. ), whether its ratification relates to the Convention without the amendments.
168
chapter six
Article XVI—Authoritative Languages Since it was established in , ILO conventions have had a provision to the effect that the English and French versions of the text are equally authoritative.169 Conclusion This chapter is lengthy. However, as explained above, the articles set out the overarching principles and rights in the ‘cascade’ of obligations under the MLC, . Importantly, the articles address the central concern—who the Convention applies to as well as establishing the legal basis for flexibility in the implementation of the Convention at a national level. Aside from setting out the core seafarer rights, the articles also contain the key ‘no more favourable treatment’ provision that helps to establish the ‘level playing field’ for shipowners. Although the more administrative articles relating to the operation of the Convention may not seem important to the Convention’s broader policy objectives, they are significant in terms of changes to the ILO procedures and to the future operation and development of the Convention. The next five chapters provide a detailed consideration of the five Titles containing the regulations and the Code, Parts A and B, which articulate the specific content, primarily at the shipboard level, of the seafarers’ right to decent work.
169
ILO Drafting Manual, supra note , section ..., Authoritative language versions, paras and .
chapter seven TITLE 1: MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS FOR SEAFARERS TO WORK ON A SHIP
General Introductory Note1 Chapters to examine each of the regulations and associated Code provisions in Titles to of the MLC, highlighting points of particular interest or difficulty. The annotated version of the Convention (see Appendix ) provides additional information regarding the ILO conventions and recommendations that are consolidated in the MLC, . Additional interpretive resources2 for the MLC, include the Article Report,3 which provides supplementary information on the expectations of the ILO’s international supervisory system4 regarding ratifying States’ obligations to implement the Convention. The Guidelines for Flag State Inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, 5 and the Guidelines for Port State Control Officers Carrying Out Inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, 6 address the more practical implementation and matters, such as ‘how to check’ for compliance, at the shipboard level, with national legislation or other measures implementing the MLC, .
1 This introductory note is included in Chapters to as an aide-memoire to summarize key information about the structure and approach adopted in the MLC, . Chapters and explore these issues in detail. 2 See Chapter at p. . 3 The Article report form for the MLC, can be found in Appendix IV of ILO Doc. No. GB.// (Rev) (ILO, Governing Body, Reports of the Committee on Legal Issues and International Labour Standards: Second report: International labour standards and human rights, Geneva, March ), pp. –, available at http://www.ilo.org/global/standards/maritimelabour-convention/WCMS_/lang--en/index.htm. 4 See Chapter . 5 See also Chapter , pp. –, on the role of these guidelines in implementing the MLC, . International Labour Office, Guidelines for Flag State Inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, (Geneva: ILO, ), available at http://www.ilo.org/wcmsp/groups/public/ed_norm/-normes/documents/publication/wcms_.pdf. 6 International Labour Office, Guidelines for Port State Control Officers Carrying Out Inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, (Geneva: ILO, ), available at http://www .ilo.org/wcmsp/groups/public/-ed_norm/-normes/documents/publication/wcms_.pdf. These guidelines are called for in the MLC, (Guideline B.., para. ), and both guidelines are the result of resolutions adopted by the th ILC in when it adopted the Convention
chapter seven
This chapter examines the regulations and the provisions in Part A (Standards) and Part B (Guidelines) of the Code of the MLC, in Title . As discussed in Chapter of this book these provisions are organized in a topical and vertically integrated manner with each Title comprising a number of regulations and the associated Parts A and B of the Code setting out more detailed requirements to implement the relevant regulations.7 Each regulation has a purpose clause indicating its objective in ‘plain language’.8 In turn, these regulations and the Code provisions set out more detailed specific implementation of the social and employment rights (and related obligations) generally set out in Article IV and the implementation and enforcement obligations under Article V.9 The provisions in the Titles are, as a matter of international law, directed to States, primarily as flag States, with an international obligation to regulate conditions on board ships that fly their flag. As applicable, regulations are also directed to coastal or port State or States that have a labour-supplying interest and require that the State take implementing action at the national level. It will be recalled that under Article IV, paragraph , unless specified otherwise States, can use various approaches to implement these obligations, including adopting legislation or through collective bargaining agreements or other measures.10 The provisions in Titles to and, in part, Title are ‘regulatory’ in that they set specific minimum requirements for working and living condition for seafarers, primarily on board ships.11 In this way the Convention operates at two
(See: Reports of the Selection Committee, Second Report, ILC, th (Maritime Session), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. PR– (Rev.), pp. –/–/ and –/–/). Initially it was thought that the port State control guidance would be adopted as a priority, with adoption of flag State guidance following. However, it became clear that the flag State guidance needed to be developed first as it provided the basis for port State control. 7 Regulations, like articles, are not subject to amendment using the more rapid tacit acceptance procedure in Article XV, nor are they subject to substantial equivalence under Article VI. Thus any analysis of the obligations, particularly in connection with exercising flexibility, must carefully consider the obligation in the regulations relative to the mandatory obligations in Parts A and B of the Code that must be given ‘due consideration’. Chapters and discuss the structure of the Convention in detail, as well its effect on future approaches to amendments (Chapter ). 8 Although the approach to interpretation of the application of the concept of substantial equivalence is not yet settled, presumably this would be one source to consider when evaluating whether a measure is “conducive”, as required under Article VI, paragraph (a), of the “general object and purpose” of the provision or provisions. See Chapter , footnote . 9 As discussed in Chapter , the articles mainly comprise general statements of principles and rights and obligations directed specifically to ratifying States. 10 See Chapter , pp. –. 11 It must also be recalled that Article II of the Convention regarding the definitions of seafarer and ship represents a fundamental change in the scope of the Convention, which in turn affects national implementation. A much wider group of workers, indeed all persons working at sea with very few exclusions for categories of ships, are now covered as ‘seafarers’ under the MLC,
title : minimum requirements
levels: the State obligation to implement Convention obligations and regulate shipowners and other actors, and through the enforcement and compliance system in Title where they pierce international law’s ‘corporate veil’ of the State to affect the actors that essentially ‘perform’ the majority of the Convention’s obligations. Failure at the shipboard level can, of course, also be evidence of a failure on the part of a State to implement or effectively implement its international obligations to regulate the issue in question. Thus the two levels are intertwined and mutually re-enforcing. It must also be emphasized that there is significant interaction among the provisions of these Titles, particularly in connection with Regulation . on seafarers’ employment agreements, which, especially from a ship inspection perspective, contain aspects that cuts across most Titles. The two Appendices in Title list areas that are drawn from all Titles. These areas are subject to certification for some ships and inspections under port State control. Under Title , flag States will need to address these areas in developing the document12 regarding their national requirements while shipowners must address them in the document13 that they are to prepare. Both documents must14 be carried on board ships GT and over engaged in international voyages or voyaging from or between ports in another country (other than the flag State). Linkages to these provisions will be noted when they arise in each of the regulations. Overview of Title : Regulations . to . and the Code, Parts A and B Title comprises regulations and the related Code Part A, Standards, and Part B, Guidelines, on four topics: – – – –
Regulation .—Minimum age Regulation .—Medical certificate Regulation .—Training and qualifications Regulation .—Recruitment and placement
provisions. Further, when a country has made a determination under Article II, paragraph , in connection with ships below GT that do not go on international voyages, the national law or other measures would still need to comply with the regulations. 12 Appendix A-II—Declaration of Maritime Labour Compliance, Part I, see p. of this book. 13 Appendix A-II—Declaration of Maritime Labour Compliance, Part II, see p. of this book. 14 Regulation .., para. . Shipowners may also request their ships be certified even if not within these categories. See: Regulation .., para. . It should be noted that the system established under Title requires that all ships must be inspected by the flag State.
chapter seven
Title may seem anomalous as both its name, ‘Minimum Requirements for Seafarers to Work on a Ship’, and content does not appear to address seafarer’s social and employment rights. The first three regulations establish minimum requirements that seafarers must meet to work on board a ship while the fourth, Regulation ., addresses minimum requirements for the operation of seafarer recruitment and placement services, essentially the regulation of an onshore business.15 However, the content of these regulations can be understood as relating to rights in the sense of broader protection of workers from exploitation. For example, the purpose clauses articulate concerns that are essentially interventions to protect workers from situations that may be harmful to themselves and/or others. This includes the protection of young people, protection of seafarers’ health, and the safety of other seafarers and passengers through training and medical examination requirements as well as avoiding exploitation of seafarers through the regulation of seafarer recruitment and placement services. Initially, this group of regulations also included provisions consolidating a convention16 on seafarers’ identity documents. However, with the developments of enhanced security after , a decision was taken to adopt a revising convention in , the Seafarers’ Identity Documents (Revised) Convention, (No. ) to address modern enhanced border security concerns. Ultimately, as discussed in Chapter in connection with Article X, a decision was taken by the HLTWG not to include this topic under the MLC, .17 In connection with the ship inspection and certification system established under Title (see Chapter ) it should be noted that all the regulations under Title are matters that must be inspected on all ships to which the Convention applies. In addition, they are also all on the list of areas that must be certified by flag States, largely for purposes of port State control, for ships subject to mandatory certification,18 that is, ships GT and above that engage in international voyages or voyages from or between ports in another country. Further, many of the regulations in Title are also addressed by the IMO STCW Convention at least for seafarers carrying out duties that are covered by the requirements of the STCW. Thus, there is the potential for possible 15
The name of the Title is a modified version of a heading ‘Prerequisites for going to sea and related provisions’ developed in one of the earliest drafts of the Convention. It seems to be based on a prior ILO publication compiling existing maritime labour conventions and recommendations. 16 Seafarers’ Identity Documents Convention, (No. ), Geneva, May , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm. 17 Report of Committee No. , PTMC, Geneva, – September , ILO Doc. No. PTMC/ /–, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/ptmc/pdf/ptmc--.pdf, paras –. 18 See: Regulation .., paras and .
title : minimum requirements
inconsistency or conflict between provisions adopted in two different fora. However the text of the MLC, was drafted to take account of the wording of the STCW Convention provisions. Subsequently the ‘Manila’ amendments to the STCW, adopted in June ,19 were drafted to avoid conflict between these international instruments. Regulation .—Minimum Age As indicated by its purpose statement, Regulation . and the related Standard A. and Guideline B. are “to ensure that no under-age persons work on a ship”. The Regulation has three paragraphs dealing with a simple prohibition: no person below the minimum age shall be employed or engaged to work on a ship. The minimum age is initially set at years, with the possibility that a higher minimum age may be provided in the Code. The reference to ‘person’ rather than seafarer reflects the idea that a person under the minimum age is, de facto, not a seafarer under the MLC, . The interesting features of the Regulation, which consolidates existing conventions from and , are, first, the level of detail found in a regulation and second, its interaction with fundamental rights. In principle, the regulations, while topic specific, should contain only core or general statements of principle or rights since they can only be amended in the same way as the articles. Given this approach it may appear surprising to find a specific age set out in an international regulation since it is foreseeable that this may alter as social ideas change. Paragraph is, however, carefully worded to set the minimum age “at the time of entry into force” of the Convention. In order to accommodate future changes, a higher age can be designated in the ‘Code’ (standards), whose provisions can be more easily updated. There was significant debate during the development of the Convention on this issue as some governments had proposed a lower minimum age, such as (the minimum age under the Convention20) to allow for training 19
See: IMO, Conference of Parties to the STCW Convention, Adoption of the Final Act and Any Instruments, Resolutions and Recommendations Resulting from the Work of the Conference, Attachment to the Final Act of the Conference Resolution , The Manila Amendments to the annex to the International Convention on Standards of Training, Certification and Watchkeeping for Seafarers (STCW), , Text adopted by the Conference, STCW/CONF./, July , available at http://www.md.go.th/seaman/pdf/STCW-CONF.-.pdf [hereinafter the Manila Amendments]. 20 Minimum Age (Sea) Convention (Revised), (No. ), Geneva, May , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm, Art. . This moved the age up from , with some exceptions for training purposes, under the Minimum Age (Sea) Convention, (No. ), Genoa, July , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm. Both
chapter seven
programs, family businesses, or child entertainers. Others, in particular the seafarers’ representative, took the view that the age should be . This age would be in line with the ILO’s fundamental conventions on minimum age, the Minimum Age Convention, (No. ), which sets as the minimum or work “likely to jeopardize the health, safety or morals . . . ”,21 and the Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention, (No. ), which also sets as the minimum for work that by its “nature or the circumstances in which it is carried out, is likely to harm the health, safety or morals of children”.22 This is consistent with a view that seafaring would necessarily be considered hazardous work. The solution was to retain the minimum age of with a prohibition in Standard A. of the Code on night work and employment that is likely to jeopardize the health or safety for seafarers under the age of . The reason for setting a minimum age in a regulation was that it was thought that this might be a matter of importance to governments when considering ratification as most countries23 are also party to the two general minimum age conventions. The Commentary for the PTMC in with respect to the interaction between these two conventions, particularly the Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention , is of interest. . . . .. If employment as a seafarer necessarily involves hazardous work, it might well come within the category of worst forms of child labour. Whether or not it does is a debatable question, but it is not one that has only arisen since Convention No. . Already in , the minimum age of for hazardous work had been established by the Minimum Age Convention (No. ) in its Article . Nevertheless, the Seafarers’ Hours of Work and the Manning of Ships Convention, (No. ), sets the age of as the minimum for work in its Part III on the manning of ships. For these reasons, Regulation . of the proposed Convention sets the initial minimum age at , which could be changed later in Part A of the Code to provide for a higher age.24
Under Standard A., paragraph , the prohibition regarding employment, engagement, or work on board ship of any person under the age of is repeated. Paragraphs and address the issue of night work (with specific conventions allowed work under the minimum age on vessels where only family members are employed. 21 Minimum Age Convention, (No. ), Geneva, June , available at http://www .ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm, Art. , para. . 22 Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention, (No. ), Geneva, June , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm, Art. (d). 23 Relatively few ILO Members are not party to the ILO’s eight fundamental conventions. 24 Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention: Commentary to the Recommended Draft, PTMC, Geneva, – September , ILO Doc. No. PTMC//, available at http://www.ilo .org / public / english / standards / relm / ilc / ilc / ptmc / pdf / cmlc-comment.pdf, Comment (on Title , Regulation .).
title : minimum requirements
parameters for what is considered ‘night’) with a possible exception for night work where a seafarer is in a training program. Under this provision ‘national law and practice’ is required to define ‘night’ in each country. Similarly the employment, engagement, or work of seafarers under is to be prohibited where it is likely to jeopardize health or safety. Perhaps reflecting the ‘modernization’ approach in the MLC, , the reference to morals is no longer included. The question of what kind of work on board a ship falls into this restricted category is a matter that is to be determined by laws or regulations or by the competent authority after consultation. Although not specifically referenced in the standard, some guidance on this point can be found in other provisions in the Convention. For example, Title , Guideline B.., Safety and health education of young seafarers, links this issue to medical examinations (from a health protection/prevention perspective) and also provides a list of some on-board work that should be restricted.25 Minimum age and protection of young seafarers, that is, seafarers between ages and , is also relevant in other Titles. For example, Standard ., paragraph , requires ships’ cooks to be or older. In other places, the Convention either requires, in standards, or recommends, in the guidelines, that special measures be taken to protect young seafarers by, for example, specific limits on hours of work or rest, repatriation rights, occupational safety and health, and, as in the next regulation to be discussed, medical certificates. In addition, from a verification and inspection perspective, a seafarer’s date of birth is a matter that must be included in the mandatory seafarers’ employment agreement (SEA) under Standard A., paragraph (a). The overall importance of protection for younger seafarers is also emphasized in Guideline B.. As discussed in Chapter , Article VI, paragraph , requires that States give due consideration to Part B of the Code when implementing their obligations. This guideline was introduced at the th ILC when the Convention was adopted. Although located under the minimum age requirement, it is clear from its wording that the intention is that the guidance, “[w]hen regulating working and living conditions, Members should give special attention to the needs of young persons under of ”, would apply across all requirements. As explained in the Office Report regarding its introduction: . The Government member of Norway introduced amendment D., which was sponsored by the Government members of Norway and Sweden and sought to insert the following text in Guideline B.: “When regulating working and living conditions, Members should give special attention to the needs of young persons under the age of , in particular with regard to their inexperience as 25
See discussion in Chapter , in connection with Regulation . at p. .
chapter seven seafarers”. The amendment sought to improve the instrument by paying more explicit attention to the needs of young seafarers.26
It is also important to note a further important interaction in the context of ship inspections and the possible refusal to allow a ship to sail under flag State inspection or a detention under port State control. Minimum age, as noted above, is also linked to the fundamental rights in connection with the abolition of child labour. As explained in Chapter of the Guidelines for Flag State Inspection,27 non-compliance with the minimum age requirement is considered as a “serious breach” and could amount to the violation of a fundamental right (Article III (c)) and the national provisions implementing these rights. This is in-line with the Convention’s guidance that even a single case of employment of a person who is under age should be considered as a serious breach of the MLC, 28 that would prevent a ship from sailing.29 Regulation .—Medical Certificate Regulation . and the Code provisions were relatively, perhaps even surprisingly, uncontroversial, even though they consolidated two much older conventions adopted in and .30 As its name suggests, Regulation . sets out a requirement that seafarers undergo a medical examination and hold a certificate. However, there are some points of subtlety in the wording adopted in the MLC, . As the purpose clause states, the objective of this requirement is “[t]o ensure that all seafarers are medically fit to perform their duties”.
26
Report of the Committee of the Whole, ILC, th (Maritime) Session, Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. PR(Part I), available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/pr-i.pdf. The text was subamended before adoption: . The Government member of Greece proposed a subamendment to delete the words “in particular with regard to their inexperience as seafarers”. He indicated that young age and inexperience were not necessarily synonymous.
27
Guidelines for Flag State Inspections, supra note , para. . See also: Guidelines for Port State Control Officers, supra note , para. . See also Chapter on Title . 28 Guideline B.., para. . This relates in part to an elaboration of the intention behind the phrase ‘requirements of this Convention (including seafarers’ rights)’. Although Article II, paragraph (e) and Article V, paragraphs and , do not contain the phrase in brackets, the provisions in Title on compliance and enforcement does. 29 Appendix B-I of the MLC, provides an example in connection with the Declaration of Maritime Labour Compliance, Parts I and II, of how a government and shipowner might indicate compliance with this requirement at the shipboard level. 30 Medical Examination of Young Persons (Sea) Convention, (No. ), Geneva, November , and Medical Examination (Seafarers) Convention, (No. ), Seattle, June , both available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm.
title : minimum requirements
The phrasing ‘to perform their duties’ or ‘to perform the duties they are to carry out at sea’ and the related reference ‘genuinely reflect their health in light of the duties they are to perform’ is repeated in Regulation ., paragraph , and Standard A., paragraphs and . The idea behind this wording is that the assessment of medical fitness is not fitness per se in relation to an absolute standard, but rather that it is contextual.31 The assessment is to relate to the specific duties the individual seafarer is expected to undertake on board ship. To some extent, of course, this is artificial given the two-year validity period of the certificates. It is based on the idea that examination and certification should instead provide a range of information, including indicating particular activities that a seafarer may not be able to carry out safely. This contextual approach is important given the much larger group of seafarers now covered by the MLC, and the increased awareness of the need to ensure that access to employment is not based on discrimination with respect to disability or medical conditions. This is a matter that has subsequently proved controversial in the context of the IMO’s review of the STCW Convention during which a standard table for ‘minimum fitness’ was proposed as mandatory text. However, at the June conference that adopted amendments to the STCW Convention, this table was moved to Code B as non-mandatory text.32 The amended text, when 31 See, for example, a discussion regarding the shift from ‘disease-eliminating to working ability’ in Heikki Saarni, “Medical examination of seafarers, who is fit for work at sea?” th International Symposium on Maritime Health, , Spain, available at http://www.mersante.com/ medicalexamination.pdf (accessed February ). The author advocates a move from temporary medical examination to continuous long-term medical follow-up because of the nature and stresses of the work and the difficulty in rapid access to land-based medical care on some voyages. 32 Draft Resolution , supra note (emphasis added),
Section A-I/ Medical standards Parties, when establishing standards of medical fitness for seafarers as required by regulation I/, shall adhere to the minimum in-service eyesight standards set out in table A-I/ and take into account the criteria for physical and medical fitness set out in paragraph . They should also take into account the guidance given in section B-I/ of this Code and table B-I/ regarding assessment of minimum physical abilities. These standards may, to the extent determined by the party without prejudice to the safety of the seafarers or the ship, differentiate between those persons seeking to start a career at sea and those seafarers already serving at sea and between different functions on board, bearing in mind the different duties of seafarers. They shall also take into account for any impairment or disease that will limit the ability of the seafarer to effectively perform his/her duties during the validity period of the medical certificate. The standards of physical and medical fitness established by the party shall ensure that seafarers satisfy the following criteria: . have the physical capability, taking into account paragraph below, to fulfil
chapter seven
in force, now requires a certificate and, while not mirroring the MLC, , is clearly consistent with it. Paragraph of Regulation . provides for the possibility of permitting exceptions only “as prescribed in the Code”. The Code only provides for two
all the requirements of the basic training as required by section A-VI/, paragraph ; . demonstrate adequate hearing and speech to communicate effectively and detect any audible alarms; . have no medical condition, disorder or impairment that will prevent the effective and safe conduct of their routine and or emergency duties on board during the validity period of the medical certificate; . are not suffering from any medical condition likely to be aggravated by service at sea or to render the seafarer unfit for such service or to endanger the health and safety of other persons on board; and . are not taking any medication that has side effects that will impair judgment, balance, or any other requirements for effective and safe performance of routine or and emergency duties on board. Medical fitness examinations of seafarers shall be conducted by appropriately qualified and experienced medical practitioners recognized by the Party. Each Party shall establish provisions for recognizing medical practitioners. A register of recognized medical practitioners shall be maintained by the Party and made available to other Parties, companies and seafarers on request. Each Party shall provide guidance for the conduct of medical fitness examinations and issuing of medical certificates, taking into account provisions set out in section B-I/ of this Code. Each Party shall determine the amount of discretion given to recognized medical practitioners on the application of the medical standards, bearing in mind the different duties of seafarers, except that there shall not be discretion with respect to the minimum eyesight standards for distance vision aided, near/immediate vision and colour vision in table A-I/ for seafarers in the deck department required to undertake look-out duties. A Party may allow discretion on the application of these standards with regard to seafarers in the engine department, on the condition that seafarers’ combined vision fulfils the requirements set in table A-I/. Each Party shall establish processes and procedures to enable seafarers who, after examination, do not meet the medical fitness standards or have had a limitation imposed on their ability to work, in particular with respect to time, field of work or trading area, to have their case reviewed in line with that Party’s provisions for appeal. The medical certificate provided for in regulation I/, paragraph shall include the following information as a minimum: . Authorizing authority and the requirements under which the document is issued . Seafarer information .. Name: (Last, first, middle) .. Date of birth: (day/month/year) .. Gender: (Male/Female) .. Nationality . Declaration of the recognized medical practitioner .. Confirmation that identification documents were checked at the point of examination: Y/N
title : minimum requirements
exceptions, in two distinct situations.33 The first is providing a competent authority with discretion to permit a seafarer to sail without a valid certificate in “urgent” cases (Standard A., paragraph ). The second is expiry of a certificate while a seafarer is on a voyage (Standard A., paragraph ). Both are subject to a three month maximum. At the th ILC in , a provision in Regulation . that essentially confirmed that some persons (e.g., port workers) that go on board ships but would not be considered seafarers and thus would not be covered by this regulation, was deleted.34 The only other debate on this issue related to the .. .. .. ..
Hearing meets the standards in STCW A-I/? Y/N Unaided hearing satisfactory? Y/N Visual acuity meets standards in STCW A-I/? Y/N Colour vision* meets standards in STCW A-I/? Y/N ... Date of last colour vision test. .. Fit for look-out duties? Y/N .. No limitations or restrictions on fitness? Y/N If “N”, specify limitations or restrictions. .. Is the seafarer free from any medical condition likely to be aggravated by service at sea or to render the seafarer unfit for such service or to endanger the health of other persons on board? Y/N .. Date of examination: (day/month/year) .. Expiry date of certificate: (day/month/year) . Details of the issuing authority .. Official stamp (including name) of the issuing authority .. Signature of the authorized person . Seafarer’s signature—confirming that the seafarer has been informed of the content of the certificate and of the right to a review in accordance with paragraph of section A-I/ Medical certificates shall be in the official language of the issuing country. If the language used is not English, the text shall include a translation into that language. 33 Although the amendments proposed to STCW regulations only envisaged one exception, two exceptions, consistent with the MLC, , Standard A., paragraphs and , were in fact adopted. See: supra note :
Reg I/ If the period of validity of a medical certificate expires in the course of a voyage, then the medical certificate shall continue in force until the next port of call where a medical practitioner recognized by the Party is available, provided that the period shall not exceed three months. In urgent cases the Administration may permit a seafarer to work without a valid medical certificate until the next port of call where a medical practitioner recognized by the Party is available, provided that: . the period of such permission does not exceed three months; and . the seafarer concerned is in possession of an expired medical certificate of recent date. 34
The inclusion of the provision that had been adopted by the PTMC in , stating that “[t]he provisions under this Regulation do not apply to persons not ordinarily employed at sea,
chapter seven
situation where a seafarer might be able to work without a valid certificate and a question concerning whether or not certificates must be in English for seafarers engaged on international voyages. At the PTMC in , however, there had been more debate not only about the concept but about the specific wording of the provisions. An important concern was to ensure that the wording avoided conflict with the STCW provisions. This even extended to the Intersessional Meeting in .35 This problem has now been addressed with the review of the STCW which limits the validity of certificates under STCW to the same validity periods as the MLC, . Until the comprehensive review of the STCW, although a medical examination was required, there was no stated requirement in the STCW for a certificate. However, many governments already follow the ILO requirements for a certificate under the Convention and use a version of the sample form for a certificate appended to the ILO/WHO Guidelines for Conducting Presea and Periodic Medical Fitness Examinations for Seafarers.36 The question of whether colour vision is a matter that needs to be retested was a point of some discussion. It was decided that a colour vision certificate would be also required, as this would be important for some duties on board a ship.37
such as pilots, travelling dockers and portworkers”, might have created significant uncertainty as it might have inadvertently give rise to an a contrario reading, for example, by specifically mentioning these groups in one regulation it might have implied that they could be covered by other regulations, unless mentioned are not covered. 35 Report of the Discussion, Tripartite Intersessional Meeting on the Follow-up of the PTMC, Geneva, – April , ILO Doc. No. PTMC//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/ english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/ptmc/ptmc-.pdf. The meeting agreed with the seafarers’ proposal to add “to perform their duties at sea”. This was supported as the shipowners and governments: . The Shipowner spokesperson stated that, while a seafarer might be on shore during leave or while visiting the offices of a shipowner’s organization, these areas were not of concern to the Convention. Rather, the Convention dealt with a seafarer’s fitness while at sea and the medical certificate indicated this. 36
ILO, Sectoral Activities Programme, Guidelines for Conducting Pre-sea and Periodic Medical Fitness Examinations for Seafarers, Part , ILO/WHO/D./, available at http://www.ilo.org/ public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/ilowho/meden.htmHeading. These guidelines are being revised concurrently with the STCW review. They are another example of cross-agency cooperation in areas of shared competency, in this case the ILO and World Health Organization (WHO). 37 The Commentary to the PTMC , supra note , states: Comment (on Regulation .) . In paragraph . . .. It has been suggested that since colour vision is permanent there may be no need to require examinations every six years. However, it appears colour vision defects can be acquired through ageing and eye disease some retesting would seem appropriate. Convention No. provides for six years.
title : minimum requirements
The MLC, was also specifically drafted to avoid the problem of a potential conflict with STCW on many small points of wording by providing, under Standard A., paragraph , that a certificate issued in accordance with the requirements of STCW shall be accepted and that a medical certificate meeting the substance of the requirements for seafarers not covered by STCW shall be similarly accepted. While express cross-referencing of instruments adopted by other organizations is not generally accepted in the IMO, the approach adopted in the MLC, appears to be to ‘mainstream’ and simplifies implementation at a national level by expressly recognizing these linkages and overlaps. This more pragmatic approach reveals relatively less concern for questions of institutional ‘jurisdiction’ and may stem from the tripartite nature of the ILO. In addition, the validity period is stated as a maximum38 and expressly accommodates a potentially shorter period under the current provisions of STCW. The MLC, does not contain a model certificate. However, Standard A., paragraph , does require that each certificate must state “in particular” that: (a) the hearing and sight of the seafarer concerned, and the colour vision in the case of a seafarer to be employed in capacities where fitness for the work to be performed is liable to be affected by defective colour vision, are all satisfactory; and (b) the seafarer concerned is not suffering from any medical condition likely to be aggravated by service at sea or to render the seafarer unfit for such service or to endanger the health of other persons on board.
At the PTMC in there was also a change in terminology to reflect evolving understanding regarding accommodation of persons with differing abilities and changing ideas about illness. The term ‘disease’, which is used in the Convention No. adopted in , was replaced, as above in paragraph (b), with ‘medical condition’, a term thought to capture a broader range of conditions, such as obesity, that are now understood to be matters falling within health and safety concerns.39 The other area of debate at the PTMC related to the precise wording in paragraphs and . As noted above, these two paragraphs provide exceptions to the requirement for a valid medical certificate. They reflect an important change from the existing ILO Convention No. 40 which is less restrictive, allowing a seafarer with a certificate that expires in the course of a voyage to continue until 38
Standard A., para. . Commentary to the PTMC , supra note , Comment (on Regulation .), para. . This is the term used in the ILO/WHO Guidelines, supra note , providing international guidance (taking into account of ILO, IMO, and WHO standards) to medical practitioners administering the examinations. 40 Convention No. , supra note , Art. , para. . 39
chapter seven
the end of the voyage, potentially a very long period, and certainly longer then the next port where she or he could get an examination. Much of the debate related to the question of when and whether a seafarer could be expected to get a valid certificate within the three-month maximum provided for this flexibility.41 Thus the careful phrasing in both cases is “. . . the next port of call where the seafarer can obtain a medical certificate from a qualified medical practitioner”. As explained in the provisional records: . The Shipowner Vice-Chairperson suggested deleting the portion of the paragraph in square brackets “until the next port of call where he or she can obtain a medical certificate from a qualified medical practitioner”, as it might be difficult to find a qualified doctor in the next port of call. . The Seafarer Vice-Chairperson recalled that the deletion of this text would leave the provision so open-ended that it could not provide sufficient guarantees that medical certification would be sought. How an urgent medical case would be defined, and by whom, was not clear in this provision. Safeguards were needed to ensure that everyone on board was fit, and it was important that the exception not dilute the rule. Generally, the seafarer should be required to obtain a medical certificate in the next port of call. There was a grey area between the Shipowner group’s concerns and the protection of seafarers. . The Chairperson observed the text said “. . . the next port of call where he or she can obtain . . .”, meaning a port where a medical certificate from a qualified medical practitioner could be obtained.42
There was no conclusion reached in connection with paragraph (b) (urgent cases) where a seafarer can be allowed to sail if he or she is in possession of an expired certificate of “recent date”. This matter came up at the th ILC. 41
Committee No. Report, supra note : . The Seafarer Vice-Chairperson said further clarification was still needed, particularly with reference to the limit of three months. Did this mean the “next” available port because it was probable that there could be access to other ports before three months? He expressed concern about diluting the original text. If a vessel did not have the minimum manning, and was in port, it was necessary to recruit a seafarer and ensure that he or she obtained medical certification at the next available opportunity. . The Government member of Denmark remarked that the proposed text to paragraph was not speaking of new seafarers but of those who previously had a clean medical certificate. Three months provided flexibility and would normally be enough time for the seafarer to get back to his or her own country for the required medical certification from a known doctor. . The Chairperson proposed that the new wording for paragraph as formulated by the Government member of Denmark be referred to the Drafting Committee and re-worded as Appropriate. . . . . The Chairperson said that the provision was clear, and that a medical certificate should be obtained at the next port of call. The time-limit was only in case this could not be done. With this explanation, the text was adopted.
42
Ibid.
title : minimum requirements
Although an amendment specifying the meaning of ‘recent’ was not adopted, the following view was recorded as to what it might mean: . The Government member of Chile withdrew his amendment, but stressed the need to specify days as the valid time frame for “recent date”.43
It is notable that paragraph requires permission from a competent authority while the triggering element in paragraph is “during” a voyage. One practical question that arises, largely because of the transnational nature of the industry, is whether the examination of seafarers in their home country will be recognized by the flag State or whether they have to undergo an examination in the flag State. This is particularly a question for non-STCW seafarers. It is not entirely clear in the Convention text, but as a practical matter, a flag State can either require an examination by a practitioner that it recognizes or simply accept another State’s determination of ‘duly qualified medical practitioner’ for the purpose of the certificate. Another issue that might also arise relates to whether a ship’s doctor could issue a certificate. It seems likely that this would not be acceptable under the requirement for “full professional independence” in Standard A., paragraph . One area that will be increasingly important in the future relates to concerns about discrimination against persons with differing abilities or with various medical conditions. The MLC, does not address this issue, except indirectly, as discussed above, in connection with fitness for the specific duties. However Standard A., paragraph , requires that seafarers have an opportunity for further examination by an independent medical referee in the case of a limitation imposed on the nature of the duties that the seafarer can undertake. Regulation .—Training and Qualifications This regulation has an important history and a unique place in the MLC, as one of two regulations that has no Code (standards or guidelines) and the only one that does not envisage any in the future.44 It would be unwise to assert that a Code will never be adopted in an amendment, however, it is clear from the negotiating history that the intention in the Convention is 43
Committee of the Whole Report, supra note . See also Regulation .., Marine casualties, which has headings for Standard A.. and Guideline B.. but has no specific provisions for either. To a large extent, this issue has also been addressed by the IMO. See, for example, International Standards and Recommended Practices for a Safety Investigation into a Marine Casualty or Marine Incident (Casualty) Investigation Code, adopted by the IMO Maritime Safety Committee (MSC), th session, – May . The PTMC in decided that Regulation . should not be followed by any indication that its provisions could be the subject of standards or guidelines. 44
chapter seven
to reduce the ILO’s role in establishing technical requirements for the training of seafarers, at least for those involved in traditional positions related to a ship’s navigation and operation. To the extent that seafarers have specific training related to the navigation of the ship, as opposed to, for example, training as a lifeguard, for ships that have swimming pools, or a medical practitioner, it was determined that this was a matter that should be formally ‘transferred’ to the IMO as the appropriate body to deal with the issue in a comprehensive way.45 This potentially unique transfer is, again, another example of the overall approach throughout the development of the MLC, to mainstream these labour standards and to work cooperatively with the IMO to develop complementary rather than competing or conflicting international standards. The issue was explicitly considered and settled as follows at the PTMC: Regulation .—Training and qualifications . The Chairperson read from a letter from the International Maritime Organization dated June , addressed to the Director-General, as follows: The IMO Sub-Committee on Standards of Training and Watchkeeping (STW), at its th session (– January ), agreed that competence for ratings could be included within the STCW Convention and deferred the consideration of preliminary proposals for the development of competence for ratings until the outcome of the Preparatory Technical Maritime Conference of the ILO was available. In considering the advice of the STW Sub- Committee, the Maritime Safety Committee at its th session (– May ) recognized that currently there are no international standards for the competence of ratings other than those for able-bodied seamen. The Committee agreed that IMO is the appropriate body to deal with standards related 45 It was originally imagined that ships’ cooks’ training would also transfer. This concept was discussed as early in the process as the first Subgroup meeting in June (Final Report, Tripartite Subgroup of the HLTWG (First Meeting), Geneva, – June , ILO Doc. No. STWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/ stwgmls/stwgmls-r.pdf):
. The secretary of the Seafarers’ group said that consideration should be given to the integration of the ILO training and certification instruments into the STCW Convention. What was important was that there would be no vacuum on training issues. Perhaps there was a need to include certain principles concerning training and certification in the new Convention in view of the role the ILO is afforded in the Articles of the IMO STCW Convention. However, specific provisions, such as the training requirements for able seafarers and ships’ cooks might better be incorporated in the STCW Convention. . The observer from the International Maritime Organization said that he saw no reason why such issues as training of able seamen and ships’ cooks could not be brought into the STCW Convention. He noted, however, that the existing ILO requirements were not very detailed, and that if such matters were included in the STCW Convention, it would be necessary to develop detailed provisions on the competencies required.
title : minimum requirements
to competences for ratings, except for the ship’s cook, and instructed the Secretariat to convey this decision to the ILO for consideration by the PTMC . . . . There was some discussion about the advisability of agreeing to transfer the entire responsibility for training and qualifications of seafarers to the IMO, or whether the services of the joint IMO/ILO Training Committee should also be involved, as proposed by the Shipowners. Clear instructions needed to be given to the IMO and a smooth transition phase ensured. . Consensus emerged that, as a consequence of the contents of the letter from the IMO reproduced above, all references to training and qualifications under Regulation . (with the exception of those concerning ships’ cooks) could be dealt with by the IMO, through its Sub-Committee on Standards of Training and Watchkeeping, taking the provisions of the STCW Convention and the ISM Code into consideration. The involvement of the existing IMO/ILO Training Committee was appropriate, in order only to ensure a smooth transition from one organization to the other, so that no seafarer could be deprived of access to arrangements governing training and qualifications. It was also remarked that Convention No. (), concerning the certification of able seamen, could not be disposed of without proper consideration.46
As the foregoing extract indicates, the IMO did not agree to take on the task of developing standards for the training of ships’ cooks. That aspect remains with the ILO and is consolidated in the MLC, as Regulation .. However, it is a matter that is still in need of development since the MLC, does not provide detailed training standards nor does it require certification of ships’ cooks. Regulation . explicitly recognizes other applicable training requirements, such as those under the STCW Convention, as amended, and provides for transitional arrangements for countries that have ratified the Certification of Able Seamen Convention, (No. ). At the time the MLC, was adopted the review process for the STCW had not yet begun, and the extent to which training would be required for the able seafarer category, or the future name of that category, was uncertain. Regulation ., paragraph , provides that, even though the Convention is revised by the MLC, under Article X (and therefore automatically denounced), it will remain binding for countries that have ratified it until mandatory provisions have been adopted by the IMO and entered into force, or five years have passed since the MLC, has come into force.47 The Manila Amendments to the STCW have developed 46 47
Committee No. Report, supra note . Report I(A) for the th ILC, explains at Note (Regulation .), para. : Paragraph paves the way for the transfer to the IMO by providing that training and certification in accordance with the instruments adopted by the IMO shall be considered as meeting the generally worded requirements of the Regulation. In the comments just
chapter seven
training for categories of ‘able seafarer deck’ and ‘able seafarer engineer’ which should be mandatory by .48 It should be noted that once the MLC, enters into force, the ILO would no longer have a convention that is open to ratification dealing with the training to attain the status of able seafarer. However, the term remains relevant for the ILO in connection with international minimum wage negotiations though the ILO Joint Maritime Commission. It is also retained in the MLC, under Guideline B. dealing with wages. Perhaps the most complicated aspect of this regulation is considering what is expected with respect to training of the wider group of non-STCW seafarers. Does Regulation . require that the relevant national maritime labour (competent) authorities supervise training for all positions or qualifications on board a ship, for example, on cruise ships, seafarers that have duties as hair stylists, sport instructors, or retail clerks? The answer seems to be no.49 To the extent that there are national requirements that apply for training or licensing of such personnel, then shipowners must make sure that these requirements are met by seafarers on the ship. However, there is one basic requirement. All seafarers must have successfully completed training for personal safety on board a ship (a basic STCW requirement as well). As explained at the th ILC, “The current provision reflects the advice of the IMO on the appropriate wording to referred to, the IMO has indicated that, at its th Session (May ), the Maritime Safety Committee (MSC) approved the establishment by the Standards of Training and Watchkeeping (STW) Sub-Committee of an intersessional correspondence group under the coordination of the United Kingdom to facilitate the development of standards of competence of ratings. The STW Sub-Committee also proposed that the LO should consider the legal status of those countries that have ratified the Certification of Able Seamen Convention, (No. ). Accordingly, if the IMO provisions are not sufficiently advanced at the time of the adoption of the present Convention, it might be prudent to add an appropriate transitional provision to this Regulation to take account of Members which have ratified Convention No. . Otherwise, the consolidated Convention would, by providing for the ipso facto denunciation of the revised Conventions, have the effect of diminishing existing protection during the interval preceding the adoption of appropriate arrangements under IMO instruments. Accordingly, the following paragraph might be considered for inclusion at the end of the Regulation . . .. See: Adoption of an Instrument to Consolidate Maritime Labour Standards, ILC, th (Maritime) Session, Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. Report I(A), available at http://www.ilo.org/public/ english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/rep-i-a.pdf. 48 Manila Amendments, supra note , Regulation I/: . Able seafarer deck means a rating qualified in accordance with the provisions of regulation II/ of the Convention; . Able seafarer engine means a rating qualified in accordance with the provisions of regulation III/ of the Convention; . . . 49
See Report I(A), supra note , Note , para. .
title : minimum requirements
ensure that it is consistent with the STCW. However, in its comments the IMO has noted that, unlike the proposed Convention, the STCW does not allow for substantial equivalence, a matter which may be important from the perspective of the ILO oversight process”.50 In fact the question of substantial equivalence is also not relevant under the MLC, since under Article VI, paragraph , substantial equivalence is not available for matter requirements set out in regulations. Regulation .—Recruitment and Placement Regulation . and the related Code, Part A, Standards, and Part B, Guidelines are among the more complex in the Convention. This is partly because they envisage various scenarios and forms of State responsibility. Although Regulation . and the Code primarily consolidate a relatively modern convention, the Recruitment and Placement of Seafarers Convention, (No. ), which was directed to States that have labour-supplying responsibilities, it also includes an important development in that it now includes flag State responsibilities. In addition, it contains provisions related to the regulation of three forms of seafarer recruitment and placement services: public, private, and union operated services. This regulation is also complicated because, even though it is focused on the issues under Convention No. , aspects of its wording draw on concepts from a much earlier convention, the Placing of Seamen Convention, (No. ). The Convention created an obligation to organize and maintain an efficient and adequate system of public employment offices for finding employment for seamen without charge. It was adopted at a time when most maritime States had merchant marines, publicly-owned shipping services. These offices or registries were to be operated by governments either alone or in partnership with unions. The convention adopted in did not revise the Convention, instead it was directed to the prevention and/or regulation of a new entity— private recruitment and placement services for seafarers—an outgrowth of the internationalization of the sector. By the time the MLC, was adopted, relatively few countries or unions operated these publically-operated employment registries as a way for seafarers to obtain employment. Further, although Convention No. is in force, it has only had ten ratifications.51
50
Ibid., Note , para. . At the time of the PTMC (), only nine countries had ratified (Croatia ratified in ): Bulgaria; Finland; France; Ireland; Morocco; Nigeria; Norway; the Philippines; and the Russian Federation. 51
chapter seven
Seafarers consider the Convention to be very important because of their concern about the exploitation of seafarers employed through the largely unregulated ‘middle person’ services. These concerns were expressed at the th ILC in response to an amendment that would have narrowed the application of these provisions because of difficulties regarding the potential impact of the regulation on more general recruitment services that only occasionally deal with seafarers (e.g., seafarers that are entertainers and have other positions on cruise ships).52 The main concern is that not only do some of these services engage in abusive practices such as ‘blacklisting’ or charging seafarers large fees for access to employment, they also created another barrier or entity between the seafarer and his or her employer, the shipowner, thereby creating the problem of ascertaining liability and responsibility. Convention No. , while an important step forward, is primarily directed to countries where these services are located, that is, countries with labour- supplying responsibility, and not necessarily the flag States and shipowners that employ the seafarers. The MLC, provisions represent a significant development in addressing these problems. A key strategic point that is not explicitly set out in Regulation . is the enforcement of flag State and labour-supply responsibilities under Regulation . at the shipboard level. The use of licensed, certified, or regulated private recruitment and placement services by shipowners is also included in the list set out in Appendices A-I and A-III of the MLC, as a matter to be inspected, and also certified by the flag State, for ships that require certification, and matters subject to port State control. The seafarers view was that such private services, if they exist, should be certified.53 Indeed they sought to 52
Committee of the Whole Report, supra note ,
. The Worker Vice-Chairperson drew the Committee’s attention to the stated purpose of Regulation ., which was “to ensure that seafarers have access to an efficient and well regulated seafarer recruitment and placement system”. The issues dealt with in this regulation were of major concern to seafarers. While passenger ships certainly employed seafarers who provided service to passengers, defining who among them also had duties related to the safe operation and navigation of the ship was virtually impossible. The amendment sought to limit the scope of application of the regulation of private recruitment and placement agencies. That was incompatible with the Recruitment and Placement of Seafarers Convention, (No. ). The amendment would permit the continued exploitation of seafarers who had to pay large sums of money to find a job and would encourage the criminal activity of agencies that lured people into paying for jobs that did not even exist. The amendment, if adopted, would exclude precisely those areas that most needed to be regulated. The Office text aimed to help solve such problems. 53
Although mandatory certification of services was not completely achieved in the MLC, , it is a logical ‘market response’ to the provision that some services will move to certification.
title : minimum requirements
discourage shipowners from using services in countries that do not ratify the MLC, . This inclusion of a flag State responsibility was seen as posing difficulties for flag States as they often had no way of verifying the situation in other countries where seafarers were recruited. This is especially true if the country where the seafarer is recruited has not ratified the MLC, . Several flag State requested a detailed explanation by the Secretary-General at the Intersessional Meeting in . Figure , reproduced as an appendix to the Report provided for the th ILC, clarifies flag State responsibilities in the area of recruitment and placement.54 See, for example, the certification offered by Det Norske Veritas (DNV), Revised “Standard for Certification of Crew Manning Offices, Private Recruitment and Placement Services— .,” (October ), available at http://www.dnv.com/industry/maritime/servicessolutions/ statutoryservices/mlc/CMO_Certification.asp. 54 Report I(A), supra note , Appendix F. For an even simpler practical explanation of this from a flag State inspector perspective, see the Guidelines for Flag State Inspection, supra note , which provides in Chapter , pp. –: How to check the basic requirements – Check the national web sites of the competent authority regarding the licensing or regulation of seafarer recruitment and placement services (manning agencies). – Check documentation or other information to allow the inspector to ascertain the following: . Direct engagement Seafarers were recruited and engaged by the shipowner. If this is the case, this fact should be noted and no further action is necessary. . Recruited through a public service Seafarers were engaged through a public seafarer recruitment and placement service in either the flag State or in Guidelines for flag State inspections under the MLC, another State to which the MLC, , applies. If this is the case, this should be noted and no further action is necessary. . Recruited through a private service (or a service operated by a seafarers’ organization) in a country that has ratified the MLC, A. If the seafarers were engaged through a private seafarer recruitment and placement service in the flag State, check for documentary evidence confirming that the service concerned is operating in accordance with the national laws or regulations or other measures implementing the MLC, , requirements. Where the supervision of such services is entrusted to another national authority in the flag State, a statement by that authority that the service has been found to be operating in accordance with the relevant law is sufficient for this purpose. B. If the seafarers were engaged through a private seafarer recruitment and placement service in another State that has ratified the MLC, , no action need be taken unless the inspector has received a clear indication that basic rights have been violated (such as charging seafarers for use of services). . Recruited through a service that is based in a country that has not ratified the MLC,
chapter seven
Figure . Inclusion of the area of recruitment and placement in Appendices A-I and A-III . A question has been raised by the Government representative of Japan concerning the inclusion, in the lists of areas to be inspected, of a reference to the use of recruitment and placement services. Is it appropriate to include this area for flag state inspection, bearing in mind in particular that, in the relevant Regulation (.), the obligations expressly placed on flag States are limited to regulating their shipowners in connection with recruitment services based in non-ratifying countries (Regulation ., paragraph )? And, if the area is included, what should be the scope of the responsibility of a Member with respect to ships that fly its flag? . It should be noted that the Regulations in the draft Convention are normally expressed as rights that are generally applicable to all seafarers. With respect to minimum age for example, the flag State inspectors must ensure that the requirements of the Convention under Regulation . are observed in the case of all seafarers on ships that fly their country’s flag. . However, the basic obligations concerning recruitment and placement services have been worded to take account of their special nature. While the obligation under paragraph of Regulation . is general in nature, the obligations under paragraphs and are linked to the place where the recruitment and placement services concerned are based. In this connection, there are three possible situations to be considered: A. Shipowners using private recruitment and placement services based in the Member’s own territory B. Shipowners using recruitment and placement services on the territory of Members ratifying the Convention C. Shipowners using recruitment and placement services based in countries that have not ratified the Convention . The situation under A above is covered by paragraph of Regulation .: “Seafarer recruitment and placement services operating in a Member’s territory shall conform to the standards set out in the Code”. This is an obligation on each Member as such, irrespective of the capacity in which it is acting. If therefore recruitment and placement services were included on the list of areas to be inspected, the obligation would be relevant in the context of the
If the seafarers were engaged through a seafarer recruitment and placement service based in a country that has not ratified the MLC, , check documentation showing that the shipowner has, as far as practicable, verified through a proper system that the service is operated consistently with the MLC, . This system may, for example, take account of information collected by the flag State, as well as any audits or certifications concerning the quality of services operating in countries that have not ratified the MLC, . Other evidence which shipowners could provide might be checklists against the MLC, requirements or an RO [recognized organization] audit of a recruitment and placement service based in a country that has not ratified the MLC, .
title : minimum requirements
flag state inspections of the Member, which could of course rely on the supervision of the recruitment and placement services that have already been carried out by the Member. . The situation under C above is covered by paragraph of Regulation .: “In respect of seafarers who work on ships that fly their flag, Members shall require that shipowners who use seafarer recruitment and placement services that are based in countries or territories in which this Convention does not apply, ensure that those services conform to the requirements set out in the Code.” This inspection would essentially relate to ensuring that the shipowners of the flag state have a proper system for verifying the conformity of the manning agencies concerned with the Convention’s requirements. . The situation under B is covered implicitly by the fact that the obligation under paragraph is limited to countries that have not ratified the Convention. The flag State would therefore not be expected to carry out any inspection in this situation unless of course they had received clear indications that the basic rights in paragraph of the Regulation were not being observed with respect to seafarers on the ship that was being inspected.
The wording of Regulation . and the Code require a close reading to determine the nature of the obligations regarding the services to be regulated. Both the purpose clause and Regulation ., paragraph , which refer to all seafarers having access to efficient and well-organized seafarer recruitment and placement services, hearken back to the Convention, and may, on first reading, appear to imply an obligation to establish these services. However, it is clear from the Provisional Records, and on a close reading of the text, that there is no obligation on a State to do so. There is, however, an obligation to regulate or operate services in accordance with Standard A. and Guideline B. where such services exist. This is clear under Article V, paragraph , which provides that “Each Member shall effectively exercise jurisdiction and control over seafarer recruitment and place services, if these services are established in its territory” (emphasis added).55 This conditional approach is also found in the wording in Standard A., paragraphs and , which provide (emphasis added),
55 See Chapter , p. , for the preliminary draft of paragraph (then paragraph ) of Article V considered by the HLTWG at its meeting in June . See: Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention (First Draft) Articles and Regulations, HLTWG (Third Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/ sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-r-.pdf. As a result of concerns voiced by governments of countries where private services do not exist as to whether this created an obligation to develop these services, and by the Seafarers’ Group which did not want to encourage the proliferation of these services, a conditional ‘where’, and finally ‘if ’, was introduced and the latter phrase removed to avoid confusion with the flag State obligations under Regulation .. The Commentary to the PTMC , supra note , describes the obligation, which was accepted at both the PTMC and the th ILC, as follows:
chapter seven
“. Each Member that operates a public seafarer . . . . Where a Member has private . . . ” Paragraph also makes the same point in negative terms: . Nothing in this Standard or Regulation . shall be deemed to: (a) prevent a Member from maintaining a free public seafarer recruitment and placement service for seafarers in the framework of a policy to meet the needs of seafarers and shipowners, whether the service forms part of or is coordinated with a public employment service for all workers and employers; or (b) impose on a Member the obligation to establish a system for the operation of private seafarer recruitment or placement services in its territory.
It is also equally clear that Regulation . does not require that shipowners use such services. As pointed out in the Report provided to the th ILC: . Paragraph of the Regulation obliges flag States to require shipowners using recruitment and placement services that are based in countries where the Convention does not apply to ensure that those services conform to the requirements in the Code. It should be noted that this Regulation and Standard would not, however, require that a shipowner use a recruitment and placement service, but rather that, if a service is used, it must be licensed, or certified or regulated in accordance with the Convention.56
As mentioned above, Standard A. addresses three forms of seafarer recruitment and placement services. It includes certain operating practices for public services. This created some difficulties for governments in that it was considered problematic to have one department of government regulate or licence another department. This led to a bifurcation in the Convention text. Regulation ., paragraph , states simply that, “Seafarer recruitment and placement services operating in a Member’s territory shall conform to the standards set out in the Code”. The first three paragraphs of the Code, Standard A., establish three different regulatory streams. Paragraph deals with public seafarer recruitment and placement services in countries “that operate” these services. There is a basic mandatory requirement that the Member “ensure that the service is operated in an orderly manner that protects and promotes seafarers’ employment rights as provided in this Convention”. Aside from general provisions in paragraphs Comment (on Article V) . Paragraph , relates essentially to the complementary responsibilities of Members from which the world’s seafaring workforce are drawn. It requires Members to exercise “effective jurisdiction and control” over seafarer recruitment and placement services, if these are established in its territory. This lays the foundation for the licensing and, if agreed, a certification system for private recruitment and placement services that is proposed in Title of the Convention. 56
Report I(A), supra note , Note (Regulation .), para. .
title : minimum requirements
and relating to supervision and a complaint mechanism, the details of what is considered as an ‘orderly manner’ is elaborated in Guideline B., paragraph , as “should consider”. As a guideline these provisions must be given due consideration, if applicable. Paragraph of Standard A. provides the main obligation with respect to private services “where” these operate in the Member’s territory. It requires that the State establish “a standardized system of licensing or certification or other form of regulation”. The details of this system, which can only be changed after consultation with shipowners’ and seafarers’ organizations, are set out in Standard A., paragraph . The third form of service was a matter that arose only at the th ILC in and provoked significant discussion.57 It relates to the continuing practice in some countries for example, the United States of America, of using ‘hiring halls’ operated by the relevant Seafarer’s Union. . The Worker Vice-Chairperson pointed out that Standard A., paragraph (a) [now (a)], was only applicable to private recruitment services. Hiring halls were neither private companies, nor manning agencies. Hiring halls were governed by national labour law and were most akin to public agencies, which were exempt 57 With respect to the introduction of an amendment to include what is now paragraph of Standard A.. See: Committee of the Whole Report, supra note :
. The Government member of Canada supported the amendment. As part of its preparations to implement the proposed Convention, his Government had examined issues related to national recruitment and placement systems. Canada did not supply a large number of seafarers to other countries, but a small number of organizations did provide placement services in an attempt to alleviate seafarer shortages. Cooperation between shipowners and seafarers’ trade unions in providing this service was a normal practice in North America. . The Government member of the United States supported the amendment, stating that it went to the heart of the United States maritime employment system that sought to guarantee seafarers’ social rights. The first amendment to the United States Constitution guaranteed freedom of association. The maritime industry in the United States was largely unionized and hiring halls were a product of collective bargaining. They were run by trade unions and regulated by national legislation. Employers paid for the operation of the halls and the complaints procedure was subject to the national Labour Relations Act. These hiring halls had been in existence for decades and had proved to be effective and efficient. . The Government member of Argentina supported the amendment. In her country, there were no private placement agencies for seafarers. Her country was a signatory to Convention No. and, in meeting its obligations to that Convention, had established a placement centre through a collective agreement between workers and employers. Regulations designed for private agencies could not easily be applied to services provided by trade unions and shipowners, who, as unions and employers, had other responsibilities in addition to placement. . The Government member of Australia supported the amendment of the Workers’ group as subamended by the Employers’ group, since it provided the flexibility for workers and employers to work together without regulation by the Government.
chapter seven from this provision. Hiring halls were however, operated through the collective bargaining process guaranteed by Article III. The amendment was limited to legally recognized trade unions and shipowners located in the Member whose flag a ship flies. The relevant recruitment and placement services did not supply seafarers to all flags of the world. This constituted a major difference from private agencies working for profit. The issue of opening a door to exemptions, raised by the Government member of the United Kingdom, needed some thought, especially in the light of “yellow unions”. [58] However, the amendment only covered legally recognized maritime trade unions. The speaker reminded the Committee that unless this issue were [was] resolved, it could lead to ratification difficulties for the two countries in question.59
Many countries were concerned whether the wider definition of seafarer under the MLC, meant that they had to regulate all employment services, not just those specializing in seafarer recruitment. This question really relates to the definition of seafarer recruitment and placement services. It will be recalled that Article II, paragraph , defines this term as follows: (h) seafarer recruitment and placement service means any person, company, institution, agency or other organization, in the public or private sector, which is engaged in recruiting seafarers on behalf of shipowners or placing seafarers with shipowners.
The issue of definition arose at the PTMC in : . The Shipowner Vice-Chairperson stated that the issue was whether certain workers on ships, such as performing artists, scientists and doctors, were to be included in the scope of application of Regulation .. The issue especially concerned passenger vessels and those on which scientific activities were conducted or entertainment provided. . The Seafarer Vice-Chairperson pointed out that if such persons were recruited directly, there was no problem as they were unlikely to be forced to accept a per cent agency fee, as many seafarers had to. The aim was to protect persons 58
Ibid.,
. The Worker Vice-Chairperson drew the Committee’s attention to the stated purpose of Regulation ., which was “to ensure that seafarers have access to an efficient and well regulated seafarer recruitment and placement system”. The issues dealt with in this regulation were of major concern to seafarers. While passenger ships certainly employed seafarers who provided service to passengers, defining who among them also had duties related to the safe operation and navigation of the ship was virtually impossible. The amendment sought to limit the scope of application of the regulation of private recruitment and placement agencies. That was incompatible with the Recruitment and Placement of Seafarers Convention, (No. ). The amendment would permit the continued exploitation of seafarers who had to pay large sums of money to find a job and would encourage the criminal activity of agencies that lured people into paying for jobs that did not even exist. The amendment, if adopted, would exclude precisely those areas that most needed to be regulated. The Office text aimed to help solve such problems. 59
Ibid.
title : minimum requirements
who were not otherwise protected in a mostly unregulated industry operating in a global environment. If such workers were being exploited at sea for long periods and were not protected, then the recommended draft should apply to them. The problem was defining an exception without diluting the regulation. . After some debate about the necessity of distinguishing between specific seafarers’ jobs and other jobs, or whether any individual working on a ship was a seafarer, the Chairperson reminded the Committee that the definition of seafarer was set out in Article (“any person who is employed or engaged or works in any capacity on board a ship to which this Convention applies”).60
This issue emerged again at the th ILC.61 In part, this controversy reflects the problem that the regulation of private employment agencies in many countries would not necessarily be a matter addressed by the maritime authority. . The Government member of Germany introduced amendment D., submitted by the Government members of Australia and Germany, to insert the words “whose main purpose is to carry out seafarer recruitment and placement” after the words “operating in its territory” in Standard A., paragraph . The amendment addressed two concerns. First, Standard A., paragraph , should not be imposed on placement agencies whose main purpose was not the recruitment of seafarers, but of workers for all industrial sectors. Second, due to the wide definition of “seafarer”, if a recruitment and placement agency placed a hairdresser or a dancer on board a ship, the agency would be required to comply with Standard A.. This was problematic. Flexibility was required. In response to Workers’ concerns regarding a narrowing of the scope of coverage that would exclude many seafarers, this amendment related to recruitment and placement agencies, not to seafarers. His delegation was flexible on the wording but called for support as regarded the purpose of the amendment.
The solution is the current wording in Standard A., paragraph (emphasis added): . Where a Member has private seafarer recruitment and placement services operating in its territory whose primary purpose is the recruitment and placement of seafarers or which recruits and places a significant number of seafarers, they shall be operated only in conformity with a standardized system of licensing or certification or other form of regulation. This system shall be established, modified or changed only after consultation with the shipowners’ and seafarers’ organizations concerned. In the event of doubt as to whether this Convention applies to a private recruitment and placement service, the question shall be determined by the competent authority in each Member after consultation with the shipowners’ and seafarers’ organizations concerned. Undue proliferation of private seafarer recruitment and placement services shall not be encouraged.
A further question that was not specifically addressed, but may arise, is whether direct recruitment by a shipowner or its subsidiary company is considered a 60 61
Committee No. Report, supra note . Committee of the Whole Report, supra note .
chapter seven
private seafarer recruitment and placement service. A related question is whether a clear line can be drawn between a local ‘liaison person’, who may be an employee (or more likely a related or subsidiary corporation) of the shipowner, and a person who is ‘acting on behalf of the shipowner’ to recruit seafarers (who would then be a private service that should be regulated under the MLC, ). The extracts of comments on Regulation . reproduced above, particularly the Seafarers’ Group’s comments at the PTMC concerning the applicability or not of substantial agency fee,62 support the view that the Convention does not prevent shipowners from directly recruiting seafarers. The provisions of Regulation . are directed at discouraging shipowners from using private recruitment and placement services (where they exist in a country) that are not regulated. Of course the more practical question of whether a shipowner is legally allowed to recruit directly in a particular country, where there may also be regulated services, would be a matter for national law regarding activities that can occur, or enterprises that can operate, in its territory. There may, however, be several scenarios that could affect this view. For example, a shipowner may be recruiting seafarers with whom it has come into direct contact, perhaps because they have previously served on one of its ships or because they applied directly for a job or were recommended to the shipowner by another shipowner. These are likely to be considered legitimate cases of direct recruitment.63 Alternatively, a shipowner may be recruiting seafarers through a local liaison person or enterprise that is engaged in recruiting seafarers on behalf of a shipowner or placing seafarers with the shipowner, as a service provided to the shipowner or more than one shipowner. Such a person or enterprise might be considered as falling within the definition of a recruitment and placement service in Article II()(h). Another potentially challenging development for some governments is the new64 requirement out in Standard A., paragraph (c)(vi) respecting the 62
Committee No. Report, supra note , para. . If the flag State has ratified the MLC, , there should be no problem about substandard treatment of seafarers. If the flag State has not ratified, the labour supply country should advise its seafarers about possible problems of signing on to a ship flying the flag of a country that has not ratified the Convention (Standard A., para. ). 64 Standard A., paragraph (c)(vi) is based on Article , paragraph (f), of Convention No. . At the PTMC in , this provision was further developed to include the phrase relating to failure by the relevant shipowner (that is, the client of the service). This change in wording was not discussed at the th ILC. At the PTMC this provision, the then numbered paragraph (c)(vii), was adjusted to contain the phrase ‘or the relevant shipowner under the seafarers’ employment agreement’. (The phrase had been placed in ‘curly’ { } brackets for consideration by Technical Committee of the PTMC, an approach which the Officers of the HLTWG had proposed to distinguish between proposals for wording that were considered controversial and matters that needed discussion and a decision. Curved or soft brackets with broken underlining, that is, {xxxx}, were used to indicate proposals that had not yet been discussed (which might or might not 63
title : minimum requirements
operation of private recruitment and placement services. Paragraph sets out the matters that must be addressed in connection with private services through laws, regulations, or other measures. Paragraph (c)(vi) provides that a Member: (vi) establish a system of protection, by way of insurance or an equivalent appropriate measure, to compensate seafarers for monetary loss that they may incur as a result of the failure of a recruitment and placement service or the relevant shipowner under the seafarers’ employment agreement to meet its obligations to them.
It should be noted that the provisions in Standard A., paragraph , do not require that the Member establish the specific system of protection. Rather it calls on States to ensure that private recruitment and placement services (if any) establish protection by way of insurance or an equivalent appropriate measure. In connection with paragraph (c)(vi), a question might arise as to whether it means that if a shipowner fails to pay the salary of a seafarer, then their recruitment and placement service has the obligation to pay the salary on behalf of the shipowner. The MLC, does not explicitly address this point however, it could involve a country requiring that the service have insurance or other measures for its own failure and also that the service ensure some form of protection vis-à-vis failures by its clients. With respect to the meaning of the term ‘monetary loss’, the Convention does not specify the scope of that term, which covers any financial loss suffered, particularly due to the non-payment or insufficient payment of the seafarers’ entitlements (e.g., unpaid wages) and costs incurred by the seafarer because of the shipowner’s non-compliance (e.g., repatriation costs). The PTMC records do not set out the reasons for the acceptance of this change in wording, but it may be linked to the development of views on this issue after and the adoption of Convention No. . In particular, in May , a Tripartite Meeting of Experts on Working and Living Conditions of Seafarers on board Ships in International Registers adopted a “Consensual Statement of the meeting of experts”.65 One of the principles set out in the Consensual Statement was:
be controversial).) The text had been initially proposed at a HLTWG meeting in Nantes. There appears to have been no concerns expressed about inclusion of this phrase when it was adopted by the PTMC as the report of the meeting states only that: “The Committee agreed to take out the curly brackets in paragraph , subparagraph (c), clause (vii)”. Committee No. Report, supra note , para. . 65 Final Report, Meeting of Experts on Working and Living Conditions of Seafarers on board Ships in International Registers, Geneva, – May , ILO Doc. No. MEWLCS//, available at http://www.ilo.org / public / english /dialogue /sector /techmeet /mewlcs /mewlcs-.pdf, para. .
chapter seven
. In States where manning agencies are legally established, the manning agencies shall be made jointly and severally liable with shipowners, regardless of their domicile, for breach of the contract of employment and/or articles of agreement.
There may be questions about the potential scope of the liability in light of the many provisions in the MLC, where shipowners are already required to provide some form of insurance or other financial guarantees to cover potential monetary losses, for example, repatriation under Regulation . (repatriation), Regulation . (shipowners’ liability in the event of illness, etc.), and Regulation . (ship’s foundering). As noted above, the meaning of the term ‘monetary loss’ is not defined. However, a service might be entitled to rely on a duty of diligence on the part of the seafarer allowing a restriction to several months of unpaid salary, for example.66 The requirement in Standard A., paragraph (c)(vi), could also be seen as an indirect means of achieving the key objective of a level playing field for quality shipowners. It should discourage recruitment and placement agencies from providing their services to shipowners that are a poor risk and are likely to fail to meet the requirements of the MLC, and their obligations under seafarer employment agreements. Finally, it should be noted that paragraph of Standard A. contains an important requirement, derived from the Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, (No. )67 that is more generally applicable than the topic of Regulation .. It requires that ratifying countries advise their nationals about the possible problems of signing on to work on a ship of a State that has not ratified the Convention. Conclusion This chapter has considered Title which comprises the first four regulations and related Code of MLC, . It has explored the linkages between these provisions for example in connection with minimum age, and the provisions in 66 A shipowner’s default with respect to a seafarer’s employment agreement and the requirements of the Convention, including payment of wages, are matters that can be the subject of an inspection and a complaint in the context of both flag State inspections and port State control. This means that, in addition to the existing remedies relating to maritime liens, a ship could also potentially be detained for nonpayment of wages or other failures. This suggests that, even in the absence of a national limitation relating to ‘monetary loss’, a situation in which the recruitment and placement services could be held liable for an extended period of default on the part of a shipowner seems unlikely. See: Final Report, Preparatory Tripartite MLC, Committee, , ILO.Doc. No. PTMLC// available at: http://www.ilo.org/global/standards/maritimelabour-convention/WCMS_/lang--en/index.htm, paras –. 67 Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, (No. ), Geneva, October , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm, Art. .
title : minimum requirements
other Titles, particularly Title on compliance and enforcement, and the question of fundamental rights, especially in connection with ship-level enforcement actions. The requirements in Title , in particular, also have a significant overlap with the STCW Convention. The extracts in this chapter demonstrate that there was a conscious policy of integration—even to the point of transferring responsibility to another competent UN organization—to avoid conflicting requirements in international agreements. The examination in this chapter has also shown the development and modernization of provisions found in earlier maritime labour conventions.
chapter eight TITLE 2: CONDITIONS OF EMPLOYMENT
General Introductory Note1 Chapters to examine each of the regulations and associated Code provisions in Titles to of the MLC, highlighting points of particular interest or difficulty. The annotated version of the Convention (see Appendix ) provides additional information regarding the ILO conventions and recommendations that are consolidated in the MLC, . Additional interpretive resources2 for the MLC, include the Article Report,3 which provides supplementary information on the expectations of the ILO’s international supervisory system4 regarding ratifying States’ obligations to implement the Convention. The Guidelines for Flag State Inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, 5 (hereinafter Guidelines for Flag State Inspections) and the Guidelines for Port State Control Officers Carrying Out Inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, 6 (hereinafter Guidelines for Port State Officers) address the
1
This introductory note is included in Chapters to as an aide-memoire to summarize key information about the structure and approach adopted in the MLC, . Chapters and explore these issues in detail. 2 See Chapter at p. . 3 The Article report form for the MLC, can be found in Appendix IV of ILO Doc. No. GB.// (Rev) (ILO, Governing Body, Reports of the Committee on Legal Issues and International Labour Standards: Second report: International labour standards and human rights, Geneva, March ), pp. –, available at http://www.ilo.org/global/standards/maritimelabour-convention/WCMS_/lang--en/index.htm. 4 See Chapter . 5 See also Chapter , pp. –, on the role of these guidelines in implementing the MLC, . International Labour Office, Guidelines for Flag State Inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, (Geneva: ILO, ), available at http://www.ilo.org/wcmsp/groups/public/ed_norm/-normes/documents/publication/wcms_.pdf. 6 International Labour Office, Guidelines for Port State Control Officers Carrying Out Inspections under the Maritime Labour Convention, (Geneva: ILO, ), available at http://www .ilo.org/wcmsp/groups/public/-ed_norm/-normes/documents/publication/wcms_.pdf. These guidelines are called for in the MLC, (Guideline B.., para. ), and both guidelines are the result of resolutions adopted by the th ILC in when it adopted the Convention (See: Reports of the Selection Committee, Second Report, ILC, th (Maritime Session), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. PR– (Rev.), pp. –/–/ and –/–/). Initially it was thought that the port State control guidance would be adopted as a priority, with adoption of flag State
chapter eight
more practical implementation and matters, such as ‘how to check’ for compliance, at the shipboard level, with national legislation or other measures implementing the MLC, . This chapter examines the regulations and the provisions in Part A (Standards) and Part B (Guidelines) of the Code of the MLC, in Title . As discussed in Chapter of this book these provisions are organized in a topical and vertically integrated manner with each Title comprising a number of regulations and the associated Parts A and B of the Code setting out more detailed requirements to implement the relevant regulations.7 Each regulation has a purpose clause indicating its objective in ‘plain language’.8 In turn, these regulations and the Code provisions set out more detailed specific implementation of the social and employment rights (and related obligations) generally set out in Article IV and the implementation and enforcement obligations under Article V.9 The provisions in the Titles are, as a matter of international law, directed to States, primarily as flag States, with an international obligation to regulate conditions on board ships that fly their flag. As applicable, regulations are also directed to coastal or port State or States that have a labour-supplying interest and require that the State take implementing action at the national level. It will be recalled that under Article IV, paragraph , unless specified otherwise States, can use various approaches to implement these obligations, including adopting legislation or through collective bargaining agreements or other measures.10 The provisions in Titles to and, in part, Title are ‘regulatory’ in that they set specific minimum requirements for working and living condition for seafarers, primarily on board ships.11 In this way the Convention operates at two
guidance following. However, it became clear that the flag State guidance needed to be developed first as it provided the basis for port State control. 7 Regulations, like articles, are not subject to amendment using the more rapid tacit acceptance procedure in Article XV, nor are they subject to substantial equivalence under Article VI. Thus any analysis of the obligations, particularly in connection with exercising flexibility, must carefully consider the obligations in the regulations relative to the mandatory obligations in Parts A and B of the Code that must be given ‘due consideration’. Chapters and discuss the structure of the Convention in detail, as well its effect on future approaches to amendments (Chapter ). 8 Although the approach to interpretation of the application of the concept of substantial equivalence is not yet settled, presumably this would be one source to consider when evaluating whether a measure is ‘conducive’, as required under Article VI, paragraph (a), of the ‘general object and purpose’ of the provision or provisions. See Chapter , footnote . 9 As discussed in Chapter , the articles mainly comprise general statements of principles and rights and obligations directed specifically to ratifying States. 10 See Chapter , pp. –. 11 It must also be recalled that Article II of the Convention regarding the definitions of seafarer and ship represents a fundamental change in the scope of the Convention, which in turn affects national implementation. A much wider group of workers, indeed all persons working at sea with
title : conditions of employment
levels: the State obligation to implement Convention obligations and regulate shipowners and other actors, and through the enforcement and compliance system in Title where they pierce international law’s ‘corporate veil’ of the State to affect the actors that essentially ‘perform’ the majority of the Convention’s obligations. Failure at the shipboard level can, of course, also be evidence of a failure on the part of a State to implement or effectively implement its international obligations to regulate the issue in question. Thus the two levels are intertwined and mutually re-enforcing. It must also be emphasized that there is significant interaction among the provisions of these Titles, particularly in connection with Regulation . on seafarers’ employment agreements, which, especially from a ship inspection perspective, contain aspects that cuts across most Titles. The two Appendices in Title list areas that are drawn from all Titles. These areas are subject to certification for some ships and inspections under port State control. Under Title , flag States will need to address these areas in developing the document12 regarding their national requirements while shipowners must address them in the document13 that they are to prepare. Both documents must14 be carried on board ships GT and over engaged in international voyages or voyaging from or between ports in another country (other than the flag State). Linkages to these provisions will be noted when they arise in each of the regulations. Overview of Title —Regulations .–. and the Code, Parts A and B Title comprises regulations and the related Code Part A, Standards, and Part B, Guidelines on eight topics: – – – – –
Regulation .—Seafarers’ employment agreements Regulation .—Wages Regulation .—Hours of work and hours of rest Regulation .—Entitlement to leave Regulation .—Repatriation
very few exclusions for categories of ships, are now covered as ‘seafarers’ under the MLC, provisions. Further, when a country has made a determination under Article II, paragraph , in connection with ships below GT that do not go on international voyages, the national law or other measures would still need to comply with the regulations. 12 Appendix A-II—Declaration of Maritime Labour Compliance, Part I, see p. of this book. 13 Appendix A-II—Declaration of Maritime Labour Compliance, Part II, see p. of this book. 14 Regulation .., para. . Shipowners may also request their ships be certified even if not within these categories. See: Regulation .., para. . It should be noted that the system established under Title requires that all ships must be inspected by the flag State.
chapter eight
– Regulation .—Seafarers’ compensation for the ship’s loss or foundering – Regulation .—Manning levels – Regulation .—Career and skill development and opportunities for seafarers’ employment
As its name suggests, Title deals with ‘conditions’ of employment. However, as this list of regulations indicates, this Title address a wider range of issues than the conditions of an individual seafarer on board ship and includes matters such as the number of seafarers required on a ship (manning level) and obligations regarding national employment promotion policies. At the same time it does not contain all the key monetary conditions such as subsistence costs and conditions and medical coverage, which are found in Titles and . In general, however, Title can be understood as setting out the basic framework for employment conditions—pay, hours of work, leave, specification of some minimum benefits, etc. Importantly, it contains a regulation that could be considered ‘the heart’ of the Convention: it sets the requirement that each seafarer must have a contract of employment, a seafarers’ employment agreement (SEA), that identifies the responsible employer/shipowner and establishes the minimum information that must be stated in the SEA. This development of the law is important from a number of perspectives. It reinforces the MLC, compliance and enforcement system under Title (see Chapter ), and is a valuable source of information for the flag State inspection. This requirement also introduces some interesting challenges from a contract law perspective. In should also be noted in connection with the ship inspection and certification system established under Title , perhaps surprisingly given that they are ‘conditions of employment’, that not all regulations under Title are matters that must be inspected on the ships to which the Convention applies. Only four of the eight topics are on the list of areas that must be certified by flag States, largely for purposes of port State control, for ships subject to mandatory certification,15 that is, ships GT and above that engage in international voyages or voyages from a port or between ports in another country. However, one of the areas to be certified is the SEA, de facto including, as an aspect of certification, several areas in Titles and that are not expressly subject to certification.16 Further, one of the regulations in Title contains a key issue, how to define ‘rest’, a matter also addressed in the IMO’s STCW Convention, as least for seafarers carrying out duties that are covered by the requirements of the STCW.
15
See: Regulation .., paras and . Namely, Regulation .—Entitlement to leave; Regulation .—Repatriation; and Regulation .—Shipowners’ liability. 16
title : conditions of employment
Thus there is the potential for possible inconsistency or appearance of conflict between provisions adopted in these two different fora. In fact, there is, if not a conflict, at least potential inconsistency between the MLC, and the STCW provisions, which, as will be noted in connection with Regulation ., will be addressed once the Manila Amendments adopted in by the STCW review enter into force.17 The amendments to the STCW Code, while not exactly the same as the MLC, provisions, were expressly drafted to try to avoid, as much as possible, conflict between these two international instruments. Regulation .—Seafarers’ Employment Agreements The purpose of Regulation . is “to ensure that seafarers have a fair employment agreement”. The provisions in Regulation . and the Code deal with both the process of entering into that agreement and the minimum content of the agreement. Both are intended to achieve ‘fairness’. Other than the provisions regarding termination and minimum notice periods, Regulation . does not itself address substantive matters. Fairness, therefore, resides in providing the seafarer, in accordance with the Regulation ., paragraph , and Standard A., paragraph (b), with the opportunity to examine and seek advice on her or his employment agreement and to “freely accept” before signing. The other element of fairness relates to access to information (Standard A., paragraph (d)) and the requirement that the SEA contain, at a minimum, the information specified in national laws and regulations that have been in accordance with Standard A., paragraph . The substantive content of the SEA is established through compliance with the national laws or regulations or collective bargaining agreement (CBA) or other measures implementing the regulations and standards in Titles to of the Convention. This is evident18 in the basic obligations in Regulation ., paragraph , which requires that (emphasis added):
17
IMO, Conference of Parties to the STCW Convention, Adoption of the Final Act and Any Instruments, Resolutions and Recommendations Resulting from the Work of the Conference, Attachment to the Final Act of the Conference Resolution , The Manila Amendments to the annex to the International Convention on Standards of Training, Certification and Watchkeeping for Seafarers (STCW), , Text adopted by the Conference, STCW/CONF./, July , available at http://www.md.go.th/seaman/pdf/STCW-CONF.-.pdf. See note and ff infra. 18 This could be read more narrowly to simply mean Standard A. and Guideline B. rather than the content of other regulations. However, given the obligation to implement all regulations and the express linkages between Standard . and other regulations, the result would be the same.
chapter eight
. The terms and conditions for employment of a seafarer shall be set out or referred to in a clear written legally enforceable agreement and shall be consistent with the standards set out in the Code.
The Code, Standard A., paragraph , provides (emphasis added): . Each Member shall adopt laws or regulations requiring that ships that fly its flag comply with the following requirements: (a) seafarers working on ships that fly its flag shall have a seafarers’ employment agreement signed by both the seafarer and the shipowner or a representative of the shipowner (or, where they are not employees, evidence of contractual or similar arrangements) providing them with decent working and living conditions on board the ship as required by this Convention;
Thus it is clear that the requirements of the MLC, are considered synonymous with ‘decent work’ and are also a fair agreement. It should be noted that Standard A., paragraph , contains wording that is specifically drafted to avoid a possible problem of contracting out of the MLC, .19 Where a seafarer is self-employed, his or her legal arrangements/contract would still need to provide for the same matters. This is also reflected in the inclusive wording of the definition of the term ‘seafarers’ employment agreement’ in Article II, paragraph : (g) seafarers’ employment agreement includes both a contract of employment and articles of agreement;
There was, in fact, no specific legal document in ILO maritime labour conventions called a SEA before the MLC, introduced the term.20 It was adopted 19
Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention (Preliminary Second Draft), Commentary, HLTWG (Fourth Meeting), Nantes, , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS//, available at http:// www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-r-.pdf, Comment (Title ): . . . . For example, Standard A. requires that Members adopt laws and regulations that provide for some basic matters. Comments after the third meeting raised the situation of self-employed personnel. This is now covered by the requirements in Standard A., paragraph (a). That Standard also requires (paragraph ) that Member adopt laws and regulations for the essential terms that must be in each agreement.
20
The first preliminary draft considered in October (First Preliminary Draft of Provisions for the New Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention, HLTWG (Second Meeting), Geneva, – October , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/ english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-.pdf) used the heading “Regulation .. Contracts of employment and articles of agreement”. The report of the second Subgroup meeting in February contained the following description of what the shipowners and seafarers expected: . . . All seafarers shall sign articles of agreement, which shall incorporate an agreed written and enforceable contract setting out the terms and conditions of employment incorporating any applicable collective bargaining agreement.
title : conditions of employment
to cover a wide range of documents that exist in various jurisdictions. It also reflects the terminology and practice in countries that have ratified the convention consolidated by Regulation ., the Seamen’s Articles of Agreement Convention, (No. ), a convention that has a very high ratification level.21 As noted in the June Commentary to the draft of the Convention in which this term first appeared in Article II and Regulation .: . Some concerns had been raised about use of the terms “contract of employment” and “articles of agreement”. It appeared that they posed difficulties for some legal systems. In addition the system of articles was seen by some Members as falling into disuse. Other Members had raised the situation of lump sum task-oriented arrangements. The all embracing term “seafarers’ employment agreement” is proposed in this first draft.22
A further aspect of this inclusive definition relates to the relationship of the SEA to CBAs. Regulation ., paragraph , provides: . To the extent compatible with the Member’s national law and practice, seafarers’ employment agreements shall be understood to incorporate any applicable collective bargaining agreements.
This point is also alluded to in paragraph , which speaks of terms being “set out or referred to”. The wording with respect to this relationship was a topic of some debate on two matters.23 First, there was concern that this would mean that each Final Report, Tripartite Subgroup of the HLTWG (Second Meeting), Geneva, – February , ILO Doc. No. STWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/ sector/techmeet/stwgmls/stwgmls-.pdf, Annex , Joint paper by the Shipowners’ and Seafarers’ groups on the principles to be embodied in the consolidated Convention Articles of agreement. 21 Seamen’s Articles of Agreement Convention, (No. ), Geneva, June , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm, has been ratified by countries as of October . 22 Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention (First Draft) Commentary, HLTWG (Third Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/ english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-r-.pdf, Comment (on Title , Regulations and Code, Parts A and B). 23 Final Report, HLTWG (Fourth Meeting), Nantes, – January , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS / / , available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/ twgmls/twgmls-r-.pdf, Working Party D: . This provision generated a great deal of discussion over two days. Paragraph retained square brackets on “sign” and “signify acceptance”. The requirement for signature was a problem for one Government representative. The Seafarers’ group were unable to accept what they viewed as a less than legally binding arrangement. It was agreed that paragraphs and , regarding the relationship between a collective bargaining agreement (CBA) and a seafarers’ employment agreement could be collapsed into one provision and the square brackets removed around paragraph and around the word “shall”. “May” is deleted as is paragraph . It was clarified that the term “incorporation” did not require
chapter eight
seafarer’s SEA would have to include the entire text of a CBA, an instrument to which he or she would not be a party. It was clarified that the wording such as ‘incorporates’ simply means that the individual SEAs would only have to identify the relevant CBA rather than reproduce the entire text.24 The relationship with the CBA is dealt with more specifically and clearly in Standard A., paragraphs (d), , and (j). These three provisions deal with, as paragraph (d) indicates, the informational aspect of ‘fairness’ and to the role that the SEA plays in compliance and enforcement. Where a CBA applies, the SEA will indicate the relevant provision, as required under Standard A., paragraph (j). Paragraph then clarifies: . Where a collective bargaining agreement forms all or part of a seafarers’ employment agreement, a copy of that agreement shall be available on board. Where the seafarers’ employment agreement and any applicable collective bargaining agreement is not in English, the following shall also be available in English (except for ships engaged only in domestic voyages): (a) a copy of a standard form of the agreement; and (b) the portions of the collective bargaining agreement that are subject to a port State inspection under Regulation ..
As this indicates, the MLC, envisages a situation where, aside from individual identification and position information and signatures, the entire content of a SEA could, in principle, be in a CBA, if all the matters required under Standard A., paragraph , are contained in the CBA. The requirement regarding English language relates, as it also states in Standard A., paragraph (d), to the port State control responsibilities under Title and to the importance of having on board documentation that can be read in foreign ports.25 The requirement under paragraph (b) appears to require, to the extent that the CBA addresses them, that only the matters listed in Appendix -III need to be translated. However, in cases where a CBA applies the physical inclusion of the CBA text in the seafarers’ employment agreement but only required a reference to the applicable CBA. The term “incorporation by reference” best captures this idea. 24 Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention: Commentary to the Recommended Draft, PTMC, Geneva, – September , ILO Doc. No. PTMC//, available at http://www.ilo .org / public / english / standards / relm / ilc / ilc / ptmc / pdf / cmlc-comment.pdf, Comment (on Title , Regulation .), para. . 25 Final Report, supra note , Working Party D (emphasis added):
. Square brackets were added to subparagraph (d) of Standard A. around the reference to “collective bargaining agreement” to respond to the concern some felt about translating into English collective agreements on international voyages. The Seafarers’ group proposed that only the sections of an agreement that relate to port state control be translated if it was major problem. It was decided that this was a matter for Working Party C in connection with port state control.
title : conditions of employment
and addresses matters listed in Standard A., paragraph , that are not on the port State control list (e.g., repatriation or annual leave), these provisions would also need to be translated. The reference to a standard form is again an example of the interplay of pragmatism with law in this Convention. It means that the SEA of each seafarer does not have to be translated into English. Rather the ‘standard form’, if one exists, that sets out the relevant terms and conditions would need to be carried on board ship for review. The second issue regarding the CBA related to concerns by some governments that there might be a problem if it was mandatory that a SEA incorporate a CBA. Thus the wording ‘to the extent compatible with the Member’s national law and practice’ and subsequent references to ‘any applicable’ or ‘where’ or ‘if applicable’ are included. There are several other aspects of the wording in Standard A. that are of interest. These will be discussed below, particularly in connection with the interaction between the SEA and the requirements in other regulations and the inspection system in Title . From a legal perspective, the expanded coverage under the MLC, to include a much wider group of workers, including ships’ masters, as ‘seafarers’ introduces the most complexity. There is also, of course, the fraught conflict of law questions about the applicable contract law, especially in light of potentially applicable instruments such as the Rome Convention, (for European Union countries).26 26
Although not a comment specifically directed to the MLC, , an article by Patrick Chaumette, “The evolution of seafarers’ employment law—Deconstruction/Reconstruction,” () Revue Hellénique de Droit Maritime, Athènes, presented at the Maritime Labour in Europe Conference, Department of Employment Law, Faculty of Law, Genoa University, May (references removed) is instructive in terms of the potential legal complexity of this issue, especially for the EU Member States that are subject the Rome Convention on the law applicable to contractual obligations (consolidated version) Official Journal C , //, pp. – , available at http://eur-lex.europa.eu/LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=CELEX:A :EN:NOT. Chaumette explains (emphasis added): Traditionally, the crew is subject to the law of the Flag State. But the law of flag of convenience States nearly always provides only for individual employment contracts, sometimes supplemented by a company-wide agreement or an ITF [International Transport Workers’ Federation] agreement. . . . German law seems to be part of a wider trend challenging the applicability of the law of the Flag State. In , the Federal Labour Court ruled out the application of the law of the Flag State to a ferry cashier. This ferry was sailing under the German flag, but the [cashier’s] contract contained close links to the United Kingdom, which entailed the application of British law by taking into account the employee’s nationality and place of residence. The contract contained no express or explicit reference to the law selected to govern the contract; the court therefore ruled out the application of the law of the Flag State, as well as the connection with the state in which the hiring company was located—in this case, coincidentally, Britain, though there was some uncertainty in this regard. Since this ruling, the ship has no longer been recognised as a workplace endowed
chapter eight
In what is, perhaps a legally naïve manner, Standard A. simply obliges flag States to adopt laws or regulations requiring that seafarers working on ships under its flag have a SEA signed by the seafarer and the shipowner (or with a nationality. International industrial relations have since then had to be connected, in the absence of the employment contract’s explicitly selecting a law to govern it, to the national law with which the contract is most closely connected. This ruling seemed to anticipate the application of the Rome Convention of June , which came into effect on April , on conflicts of law with respect to contractual obligations. The judge did not seek to invent an implied law selected by the contracting parties on the basis of a joint intention that they had not expressed, but strove to objectivise the contractual relationship, which does not explain the disappearance [sic!] of the ship and its flag. The Federal Labour Court has continued this trend challenging the applicability of the law of the Flag State to the crew: Indian seafarers were working on a German-flagged ship that was registered on the German international register; the law of the Flag State, as the law of the place where their work was carried out, was ruled out, on the grounds that a ship is not a State, a piece of detached territory; the same went for the law of the place where the employer, i.e. the shipowner commercially operating the ship, was established, i.e. German law. The employment contracts were therefore most closely connected to India, irrespective of whether or not they expressly referred to the seafarers’ nationality or their places of residence. The Rome Convention of June deals only with Community relations, internationalisation within the territory of the Community. Article thereof states that the law designated by this Convention shall be applied even if this is a law of a State that is not a party to the Convention. The Convention has universal applicability; it comes into play as soon as a judge of a member state of the European Union is competent. It is as much international law as Community law. It is leading to uniformity in dispute resolution for Community countries with respect to international contracts. . . . Article is especially devoted to the employment contract . . . The parties may select only the law of the contract, not the contractual provisions. Whichever law they have selected, the employee may not be deprived of the protection afforded him by the law of his customary workplace; the concept of industrial public order is clearly at work here. The nationality of the employee or the employer is irrelevant. The Rome Convention stipulates that the law of the workplace shall apply to any employee working in the Community . . . The Convention provided for complementary points of attachment, relating to employees who carry out their activities in several countries. The permanent point of connection will be the establishment that hired the employee (which is not necessarily the same thing as the company’s registered office). This rule holds for sales reps and workers in international transport. Workers on oil rigs would be connected to the company’s registered office . . . The determination of the law of the customary workplace has given rise to debate on mobile workers, seconded employees, flight personnel, and work carried out on oil rigs. When there is no one country in which the employee customarily perform his work, the Convention states that he shall be governed by the law of the place where he was hired. This would seem to apply to pilots and oil-rig workers. For the seafarer, the law of his customary workplace is traditionally that of the country under whose flag his ship is sailing, which may leave room, to a greater or lesser extent, for the employment contract concluded with the shipowner or a crewing agency, which may be subject to a law other than that of the Flag State . . . The underlying rationale is that the applicable law should be the law of proximity. But what is meant by proximity? The law applicable to the contract governs its interpretation, the discharging of the obligations contained therein, the consequences of failing to discharge those obligations, the termination of the obligations, statutes of limitations, the effects of nullity, and the terms applicable to and consequences of the contract’s being breached. As regards the form of the employment contract, Article of the Convention
title : conditions of employment
representative, usually the ship’s master). The flag State is to adopt national laws and regulations that require that the SEA contain, at a minimum, the information listed in Standard ., paragraph . These are essentially matters of form. Irrespective of where the SEA is signed or questions such as applicable law, it is a flag State obligation, and shipowners would need to make sure that the SEA they use complies, at a minimum, with the flag State requirements on form. However, the actual content of the SEA is also primarily a flag State responsibility. This is in accordance with the LOSC regarding the responsibilities of flag States for ships on the high seas.27 It could, as noted provides a choice: either the law governing the contract’s content or the law of the country where the contract was concluded. The grounds for voiding the contract flow from this law of form. Community Directive / of October requires a document, and applies to all contracts that are subject to the law of a member state . . . The situation would be different for seafarers recruited to serve on board a ship, which always sails under the flag of a State. Nevertheless, the shrinking influence of the law of the Flag State is tending to favour the application of the law selected by the shipowner or crewing agency, except with respect to disciplinary matters. The international market tends to “de-territorialize” the ship as much as possible, so that the seafarer works abroad and not on the territory of a member state; it also tends to loosen the ties between the seafarer and the shipping company, and even with the shipowner, in favour of ties to the crewing agency, an intermediary that is also “deterritorialized”. Could the internationalised maritime employment contract end up with no points of connection to any nation state? 27
Chaumette, ibid. (references removed; emphasis added), but quaere views on the territorial sea: The status of the ship The fact that the law of the Flag State no longer reigns supreme on board ship, due to the inroads made by the law selected by the parties to the employment contract, seems to be modifying the status of the ship, which of course remains a workplace for the crew, but also clears the way for connections to various different legal systems. The status of the ship—a thing endowed with a nationality, a name and a port of registry, a registered movable that is often treated as real estate due its value, the collateral of maritime creditors, a centre of competing interests—is therefore directly at stake. The civil, merchant, fishing or cruise ship is not an extension of the territory of the Flag State. Despite the ruling of the Standing Court of International Justice in the Lotus case of September , the theory of territoriality has not flourished, because the ship leaves international waters, the high seas, to enter the territorial waters of a State and put in at a port. In registering a ship, the Flag State thereby confers its nationality on it. This mark of the Flag State’s sovereignty creates a connection, which should be substantial. This connection has been exclusive on the high seas since the Brussels Convention of May on criminal jurisdiction in the event of collisions; this exclusivity was confirmed by the Geneva High-Seas Convention, and then by the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea of . . . . However, this does not apply in the territorial waters of a State whose flag the ship is not sailing under, all the more so since the inertia of many Flag States is leading to the growth of complementary connections. . . . With respect to the international registers, it is widely accepted that the seafarers work abroad, outside the territory of the Flag State. The income of Community officers is thus exempted from taxation, which constitutes a subsidy to the shipping companies. This mechanism does not appear to be limited to taxation,
chapter eight
above, in some cases, give rise to questions of potentially conflicting laws. However, one of the impacts of international conventions that are regulatory in their approach is that they promote a high level of uniformity, at least with respect to the minimum needed to achieve compliance. The question of whether this provision is also directed to States with laboursupply interests was settled during the development of the Convention. At the fourth meeting of the HLTWG in January it was decided to remove text in the Regulation that would have also established labour-supplying obligations. The report of the meeting states: . There was an extended debate relating to the phrase “in their territory” and whether Standard A. should cover both flag state obligations and labour-supply obligations to regulate the content of seafarers’ employment agreements. Several Government representatives were opposed to legislating for other than their flagships in this matter. This resulted in the deletion of the phrase “in its territory” and the inclusion in the chapeau of a phrase limiting the provision to seafarer contracts on the Members’ flagships. It also resulted in the consequential deletion of paragraph . The Seafarers’ group strongly supported the idea of highlighting the flag state responsibility under paragraph (a) in the chapeau and of the deletion of paragraph . However, in their view, although their primary concern is directed to ensuring flag state responsibility, the need to also put in place an equally strong system of labour-supply responsibility is also required. There is a need to require that labour-supply governments also legislate in the same way as flag state governments to ensure that the coverage is comprehensive. For this reason the Seafarers’ group did not want to delete the provision on this matter in Regulation ., paragraph .28
It will also be recalled from the discussion of Article V, and in connection with Title , Regulation .,29 that a preliminary draft of Article V, paragraph (then paragraph ), considered by the HLTWG at its June meeting, read as follows (emphasis added): . Each Member shall exercise effective jurisdiction and control over seafarer recruitment and placement services in its territory, as well as effective jurisdiction over seafarers’ employment agreements that are concluded in its territory.
The decision to focus on flag State responsibility and the resulting potential conflict of laws questions relate to the fact that Standard A. consolidates Article from the Seamen’s Articles of Agreement Convention, (No. ): but is implicitly extended to the terms of employment on board, including those of nonCommunity seafarers. This whole issue requires clarification, at a time when the law of the workplace seems to be disappearing to the benefit of the seafarer’s personal status. . . . 28
Final Report, supra note , Working Party D. See: Chapter at footnote . See also: Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention (First Draft) Articles and Regulations, HLTWG (Third Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. 29
title : conditions of employment
. Articles of agreement shall be signed both by the shipowner or his representative and by the seaman. Reasonable facilities to examine the articles of agreement before they are signed shall be given to the seaman and also to his adviser. . The seaman shall sign the agreement under conditions which shall be prescribed by national law in order to ensure adequate supervision by the competent public authority. . The foregoing provisions shall be deemed to have been fulfilled if the competent authority certifies that the provisions of the agreement have been laid before it in writing and have been confirmed both by the shipowner or his representative and by the seaman. . National law shall make adequate provision to ensure that the seaman has understood the agreement. . The agreement shall not contain anything which is contrary to the provisions of national law or of this Convention. . National law shall prescribe such further formalities and safeguards in respect of the completion of the agreement as may be considered necessary for the protection of the interests of the shipowner and of the seaman.30
However, this convention dates from a period before the rise of international registers and the transnational maritime work force. It assumes considerable oversight of this sector by governments that are both the flag State and the State in which the SEA/articles of agreement are signed and apply. This provision is also the basis for the process aspects of ‘fairness’. However, in the current context, a flag State may not be able to regulate this issue if the SEA was signed in another country. It can, however, require that shipowners verify their practice, and the practice of companies that recruit seafarers on their behalf, on this point. The scope of flag State responsibility for seafarers that enter into SEAs elsewhere also relates to the enforcement of the requirements under Regulation ., where recruitment services are used. The Office Report for the th ILC explains: . Regulation . deals with the conditions under which a seafarer signs an employment agreement. As much as possible it seeks to ensure that they are signed under conditions that ensure informed consent by the employee to the terms governing their employment. The extent to which a Member can monitor each situation is, of course, limited. This is a problem common to all areas of regulatory activity.31
TWGMLS / / , available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/ twgmls/twgmls-r-.pdf. 30 Supra note , Art. . 31 Adoption of an Instrument to Consolidate Maritime Labour Standards, ILC, th (Maritime) Session, Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. Report I(A), available at http://www.ilo.org/public/ english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/rep-i-a.pdf, Note (Regulation .). In terms of compliance and enforcement at the shipboard level, this is a matter that would most likely be checked through private interviews with seafarers by flag State inspectors or emerge in complaints by seafarers to the flag State or in the context of port State control.
chapter eight
The requirement under the MLC, that each seafarer must have an original32 of the SEA signed by the seafarer and the shipowner (or representa32
Report of the Committee of the Whole, ILC, th (Maritime) Session, Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. PR(Part I), available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/pr-i.pdf. There was a surprisingly lengthy debate at the th ILC about the question of whether the SEA can be a copy of the original. . The Government member of the Russian Federation, speaking also on behalf of the Government members of Estonia and Latvia, submitted amendment D. to replace, in subparagraph (c) before the word “copy”, the word “a” by “an equally authentic”. While the Office text merely required a copy, national legislation in his country required equally authentic copies to be in the possession of the seafarer and the shipowner. The Office text failed to make this clear. His delegation could accept different wording as long as it ensured that both copies had equal force under the law. . The Employer Vice-Chairperson stated that his group had initially opposed the amendment due to concerns with regard to the term “authentic”, which seemed to imply that notarization would be required. The problem could be overcome by wording such as “original copy” that would ensure that both parties had copies bearing the signatures of both parties. . The Worker Vice-Chairperson indicated that his group had also expressed concern about the possible cost implications of the amendment. He was prepared, however, to accept the wording proposed by the Employers’ group on the understanding that an original copy meant that the shipowner and the seafarer each had a copy signed by both parties. . The Government member of the Bahamas drew attention to the problem of cruise ships with several hundred crew members using articles of agreement saying that providing a signed original of the articles for each crew member was impractical. . The Government member of Malaysia affirmed that in his country, articles of agreement were used as seafarers’ employment agreements. It would be problematic for each seafarer to have a signed original copy of the articles of agreement. . The Chairperson suggested that the expression “a signed original of the seafarers’ employment agreement” might be an acceptable alternative. He referred to Article II, paragraph (g), which defined “seafarers’ employment agreement” to include both a contract of employment and articles of agreement. . The Government member of the Russian Federation found this formulation more accurate and supported it, as did the Government members of Algeria, Brazil, Cyprus, Denmark, Ghana, Kenya, Mexico, Pakistan, Singapore and Sri Lanka. . The Government member of France summarized the discussion. The employment contract was to be signed by both the shipowner and the seafarer. Each would receive a copy which had the original signatures of both parties. Two original copies were essential. . The representative of the Secretary-General drew the Committee’s attention to the Seamen’s Articles of Agreement Convention, (No. ), Article of which read: . Articles of agreement shall be signed both by the shipowner or his representative and by the seaman. Reasonable facilities to examine the articles of agreement before they are signed shall be given to the seaman and also to his adviser. . The seaman shall sign the agreement under conditions which shall be prescribed by national law in order to ensure adequate supervision by the competent public authority. . The foregoing provisions shall be deemed to have been fulfilled if the competent authority certifies that the provisions of the agreement have been laid before it in writing and have been confirmed both by the shipowner or his representative and by the seaman.
title : conditions of employment
tive33) also generates further complexity, especially for seafarers that are (also) employees of subcontractors carrying out business on a ship, for example, retail outlets. This situation would arise most often for seafarers working on passenger or cruise ships, where there may be several thousand seafarers working on board in various capacities and involving differing land-based employers. Put most simply, a question will arise as to who should sign the SEA if the seafarer is hired by an employer that is not covered under the definition of a shipowner in Article II, paragraph (j). The answer under the MLC, remains the same: the seafarer must have a SEA and it must be signed by the ‘shipowner (or representative)’. Although the issue of other employers and the situation of cruise ships were considered in the development of the Convention, Regulation . and the Code only obliquely address the practical implications. In order to understand a possible legal solution to the requirement that a SEA be signed by the shipowner (or representative) the requirement must be viewed in terms of its objectives and the overall approach adopted in the Convention. The major concern, as reflected in the approach adopted by the MLC, , is that the shipowner should have overall responsibility for all aspects of working and living conditions on board: seafarers should not have to deal with more She noted that even though this instrument made no provision for a copy to be given to the seafarer, it explicitly provided for individual signature. For the countries using articles of agreement, she saw no issue with providing seafarers with signed original copies of the documents they had signed. . The Worker Vice-Chairperson referred to Regulation ., which required the terms and conditions for employment of a seafarer to be set out or referred to in a clear written legally enforceable agreement. It was also required that seafarers’ employment agreements be agreed to by the seafarer under conditions which ensured that the seafarer had an opportunity to review and seek advice on the terms and conditions in the agreement and freely accepted them before signing. He recalled from discussions at previous meetings that the primary concern had been to prevent problems with enforcement. To be legally enforceable both the shipowner and the seafarer needed an original copy of the employment contract signed by both parties It seems clear, therefore, that the seafarer must be given a signed original. However, with respect to the question of photocopies, although not clearly addressed, it seems to meet the basic flag State inspection and port State inspection concern as well as possible questions about legal enforceability: if a jurisdiction requires originals, then a photocopy of a SEA could be carried on board. This is supported by the provision in Standard A., paragraph , for cases where the SEA in part or whole takes the form of a CBA. In these cases, a copy must be on board and, if not in English, relevant portions must be translated into English, or where the SEA is not in English, then a standard form version in English must be on board ship. See also the Guidelines for Flag State Inspections, supra note . In the future it also seems possible that the SEAs or standard agreements produced for port State control or flag State inspection may take the form of electronic copies of the signed SEAs. 33 This would be understood as covering the ship’s master. However, since the ship’s master is also a seafarer, he or she must also have a SEA. Importantly in a globalized workforce, this means that the seafarers can identify their responsible employer (shipowner).
chapter eight
than one person with respect to their working and living conditions, and that one person should be the shipowner, who should take responsibility for ensuring that those conditions conform to the requirements of the MLC, and are respected. At the fourth HLTWG meeting, the Commentary prepared for the meeting notes that, in connection with the definition of shipowner in Article II, paragraph (j) (emphasis added): . The definition of “shipowner” in paragraph (i) is based on the definition in Convention No. . It may need to be revisited in the light of decisions taken on other provisions referring to the “shipowner”, such as Standard A., paragraph (b). It is based on the principle of the shipowner’s responsibility with respect to all seafarers, without prejudice to the right of the shipowner to recover the costs involved from other employers responsible for particular seafarers. This is expressly stated in Standard A. (paragraph ) on repatriation.34
From a legal perspective this may seem problematic in that the worker concerned may already have an employment contract with his/her employer, who will be responsible for honouring the obligations in that agreement, in particular those relating to the payment of wages and allowances and social protection obligations, matters that must be included in the SEA. However, it is equally clear that there are certain important elements in the SEA contractual relationship that are of concern to the shipowner rather than to the land-based outside employer (e.g., relating to policies regarding behaviour on board, the authority of the master, and safety at sea).35 This would not mean that the shipowner has to renegotiate an existing agreement between the seafarer and the outside employer: a SEA could, for example, set out the ship-related conditions of employment and then provide, much like the incorporation by reference of a CBA, that all other terms and conditions are contained in the existing agreement concluded between the seafarer and the outside employer. That agreement would be annexed as a schedule to the SEA (and would be subject to flag and port State inspection). The shipowner would, however, have to make sure that the annexed agreement was consistent with the flag State’s national requirements implementing the MLC, and contained no gaps in coverage.36 34
Preliminary Second Draft Commentary, supra note , Comment (on Article II). In view of their personal nature, it seems understandable that the related obligations should be entered into by the seafarers themselves (as required by Standard A.) rather than by their outside employer acting as their representative. In principle, the Standard would also allow the outside employer to sign the SEA as a representative of the shipowner, if authorized by the shipowner. However, it seems unlikely that shipowners would consider it advisable to give carte blanche to outside employers to represent them in this way or that an employer would accept all of these responsibilities. Accordingly, the shipowner (or the shipowner’s representative, such as the master) would need to sign some kind of an agreement with seafarers supplied by outside employers. 36 It may also be advisable for the shipowner to conclude a ‘hold harmless’ agreement with a 35
title : conditions of employment
Leaving aside these legal complexities, Regulation . and the SEA can be seen as the ‘heart’ of the MLC, . This is because of their multiple and essentially ‘arterial’ connection to many other regulations and in regard to the enforcement and compliance system under Title . Specifically, the SEA is a matter on the list of areas that must be inspected for all ships, and certified for some ships, and is subject to port State control under Appendices A-I and A-III. This means that the SEA is a useful inspection tool on a number of points, most importantly for those matters that are not themselves subject to certification. The connection between the minimum information required in a SEA under Standard A., paragraph , and other regulations, is indicated below with cross- references to other provisions added to illustrate this point (shown in italics): . Each Member shall adopt laws and regulations specifying the matters that are to be included in all seafarers’ employment agreements governed by its national law. Seafarers’ employment agreements shall in all cases contain the following particulars: a) the seafarer’s full name, date of birth or age, and birthplace (Regulation .) b) the shipowner’s name and address; c) the place where and date when the seafarers’ employment agreement is entered into; d) the capacity in which the seafarer is to be employed (Regulation .); e) the amount of the seafarer’s wages or, where applicable, the formula used for calculating them (Regulation .); f) the amount of paid annual leave or, where applicable, the formula used for calculating it (Regulation .); g) the termination of the agreement and the conditions thereof (Regulation ., paragraphs and ): h) the health and social security protection benefits to be provided to the seafarer by the shipowner (Regulation ., Regulation ., Regulation ., and aspects of Regulation . (see Guideline B., paragraphs and )); i) the seafarer’s entitlement to repatriation (Regulation .); j) reference to the collective bargaining agreement, if applicable; and k) any other particulars which national law may require.
Clearly, in reviewing a SEA, information can be obtained about compliance with many other key requirements of the Convention. This makes the SEA an essential inspection resource for flag States.37 subcontractor/outside employer to make sure that the shipowner is promptly compensated for any financial loss suffered by the shipowner because of the outside employer’s failure to honour the annexed agreement, such as arrears of wages, repatriation, or medical expenses which the shipowner may have had to pay. 37 This approach is reflected in the Guidelines for Flag State Inspections, supra note , and the Guidelines for Port State Control Officers, supra note , that were adopted by a tripartite meeting of experts in .
chapter eight
There are several important points to note with regard to the wording of paragraph . First, national implementation of the requirement that SEAs contain this minimum level of information must be through laws and (as opposed to ‘or’) regulations. Second, subparagraphs (e) and (f) contain a phrase “where applicable the formula used to calculate them”. This provision was included “to accommodate a country that calculates annual leave pay on a percentage basis (and therefore could not designate a specific amount and can only provide the formula for calculation)”.38 Subparagraph (h) was also initially controversial “because of concerns that it might require the legislation of each country to be included; however, it was agreed that the idea of including information about the shipowners’ obligations to the seafarer is not controversial and the text should be developed to make it clearer”.39 Further, during the development of the MLC, the nature of social security protection for seafarers under Regulation . was controversial. In the draft text considered by the PTMC40 paragraph (h) read: (h) the health and social security protection benefits to be provided to the seafarer by the shipowner [including a statement as to applicable national provisions];
It was decided that the phrase in square brackets requiring information about applicable national legislation on social security should be deleted.41
38
Final Report, supra note , para. . This tentative reference in connection with wages also addresses the point that that some countries do not regulate particular wage levels for seafarers. They are not required to do so under Regulation . of the MLC, . But see Guidelines for Flag State Inspections, supra note , pp. –, and Guidelines for Port State Control Officers, supra note , pp. -. 39 Ibid., para. . 40 Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention, Recommended Draft, PTMC, Geneva, – September , ILO Doc. No. PTMC//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/ standards/relm/maritime/pdf/cmlc-draft.pdf. 41 Report of Committee No. , PTMC, Geneva, – September , ILO Doc. No. PTMC/ /–, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/standards/relm/ilc/ilc/ptmc/pdf/ptmc--.pdf: . When the discussion was resumed, the Shipowner Vice-Chairperson stated that the sheer volume of social security law in some countries would make it very difficult for shipowners to keep track of changes. . The Seafarer Vice-Chairperson agreed it would be difficult to update employment agreements. But seafarers needed to be aware of the rights available to them in a specific flag State, especially where there were entitlements for non-residents. Information in some form should be available on the vessel. . The Shipowner Vice-Chairperson stressed that it was not possible for shipowners to inform seafarers of constantly changing social security laws. This was to be the responsibility of the appropriate government agencies in the member States. . It was agreed that the words in square brackets [, including a statement as to applicable national provisions] be deleted from paragraph (h).
title : conditions of employment
The precise termination periods referred to in paragraph (g) and paragraphs and of Standard A. were also the subject of debate at the PTMC.42 Paragraph does not set any minimum periods but does envisage various contract scenarios and requires that information about termination be included in the SEA. Under paragraph , ratifying countries must adopt national laws or regulations to establish minimum notice periods for termination. The minimum period is to be determined after consultation with the shipowners’ and seafarers’ organizations concerned and must not be less than seven days unless it is an exception provided for in paragraph . Paragraph allows for shorter periods in circumstances “recognized under national law or regulations or applicable collective bargaining agreements as justifying termination” with shorter notice or even without notice. Specifically, the situation of seafarers that may need to terminate a SEA for compassionate or other urgent reasons is noted. There is a further point that is not in the MLC, text but was added in by the tripartite meeting of experts that adopted the Guidelines for Flag State Inspections and the Guidelines for Port State Officers. They added, as an example of a possible deficiency, “The SEA contains clauses that violate seafarers’ rights”.43 As noted in the beginning of this chapter, these guidelines are simply guidance and not binding. However, they are viewed as authoritative tripartite advice as to application of the MLC, at the shipboard level and are also going to form the basis for the development of guidance within the regional port State control regime.44 This requirement is not in Regulation . or Standard A. so it may be difficult to see how it could be a violation of this regulation. However, this could also be seen as implicit in the Title provisions referring to ‘requirements of this Convention (including seafarers’ rights)’ for flag State inspection and port State control for compliance. It could also perhaps be viewed as implicit in the obligation that a ratifying State satisfy itself with respect to the matters listed in Article III. 42 Ibid., paras –. The final text adopted was developed by the Drafting Committee to address various concerns about wording:
. The Shipowners’ and the Seafarers’ groups agreed that the text should provide for a minimum number of seven days, but were averse to specifying a maximum number. As to the last paragraph, provision should be made for waiving the minimum requirement on compassionate or urgent grounds, and that the Office should be requested to provide guidance accordingly. 43
Guidelines for Flag State Inspections, supra note , p. ; Guidelines for Port State Control Officers, supra note , p. . 44 As of December the relevant guidelines under the Paris MOU on Port State Control are not finalized. However, internal discussion drafts, for the most part, follow the wording and approach in the ILO Guidelines. The Paris MOU guidelines will provide the basis for the guidelines to be adopted by the other regional MOUs. See Chapter , at note , and Chapter , at note .
chapter eight
Guideline B. has only one paragraph providing guidance as to what would be needed to meet the requirement under Standard A., paragraph (e), that a seafarer be given a record of employment.45 It clarifies that the traditional discharge book would satisfy this requirement. A certificate (with a translation into English) identifying the positions held by a seafarer and the periods when those positions were held should be regarded as sufficient as a record of employment for seafarers without a seafarer’s discharge book. Regulation .—Wages Regulation . has a simply stated purpose “to ensure that seafarers are paid for their services”. The Regulation has only one paragraph. . All seafarers shall be paid for their work regularly and in full in accordance with their employment agreements.
Perhaps surprisingly, given the importance of a salary or wages for workers, no maritime labour convention contained the basic proposition that seafarers are to be paid for their work.46 The text of Regulation . and Standard A. are, therefore, new text as they do not consolidate any existing convention. At the same time the propositions and concepts they contain were considered “uncontroversial”47 and, indeed, did not attract discussion at the th ILC.48 A brief history of the issue of seafarers’ wages is, however, useful to fully understand the scope of the obligations contained in Standard A., particularly the wording in paragraph (see below). Under Article X, the MLC, consolidates two conventions that appear to address the issue of wages. They are the Wages, Hours of Work and Manning (Sea) Convention (Revised), (No. ) and Wages, Hours of Work and 45 An interesting problem arises in connection with flag State inspection of this requirement on ships, especially where the ship is newly entered into service or the seafarer is new to a ship. The Guidelines for Flag State Inspections, supra note , address this problem by suggesting that inspectors could require that this information be submitted at a later date. 46 Although there are conventions of general application such as the Convention Concerning the Protection of Wages, (No. ) that provide workers with a right be paid regularly. 47 Commentary to the Recommended Draft, supra note , Comment (on Regulation .):
. Regulation . deals with wages. Standard A. contains several mandatory requirements relating to payment methods that are not based on any current international labour Convention but are believed to be uncontroversial. 48
Committee of the Whole Report, supra note :
. Regulation . and Standard A. were adopted without amendment. . Guidelines B. and B.. were adopted without amendment. . Guideline B.., paragraphs , and , were adopted without amendment.
title : conditions of employment
Manning (Sea) Convention (Revised), (No. ), which revised Convention No. . However, neither convention, both of which sought to establish minimum wage levels, entered into force. They were eventually revised49 in by the Seafarers’ Hours of Work and the Manning of Ships Convention, (No. ), a convention that is now also revised by Regulation . of the MLC, . As the title of Convention No. indicates, it does not address the issue of wages. Although minimum wage levels and the calculation of wages are matters not set out in a binding international legal instrument, provisions relating to establishing wage levels and a basis for the calculation of wages are set out in an important recommendation, the Seafarers’ Wages, Hours of Work and the Manning of Ships Recommendation, (R). The content of this recommendation is included in the MLC, as Guideline B..50 Although Guidelines in Part B of the Code are to be given due consideration when implementing obligations under the regulations and the Code, Part A, Standards, the 49 Article of the Seafarers Hours of Work and the Manning of Ships Convention, (No. ), Geneva, October , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm, provides:
This Convention revises the Wages, Hours of Work and Manning (Sea) Convention (Revised), ; the Wages, Hours of Work and Manning (Sea) Convention (Revised), ; the Wages, Hours of Work and Manning (Sea) Convention, ; and the Hours of Work and Manning (Sea) Convention, . As from the date this Convention has come into force, the above-listed Conventions shall cease to be open to ratification. 50
There were a few adjustments made to update the wording in line with the Standard. See: Compendium of Proposed Amendments to the Draft Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention, , Tripartite Intersessional Meeting on the Follow-up of the PTMC, Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. PTMC//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/ptmc /ptmc-.pdf, Amendment : C./D., Guideline B.., paragraph (d), Submitted by the Seafarers: Proposal: In subparagraph (d) of paragraph , replace the words “at regular intervals” by the words “at no greater than monthly intervals”. Context: “records of all overtime worked should be maintained by the master, or a person assigned by the master, and endorsed by the seafarer at no greater than monthly intervals.” Comment: The proposed amendment concerns a provision which is there for the guidance of Members covered by paragraph of Standard A.. These Guidelines are based on Recommendation No. and linked to the global minimum wage setting process carried out by the Joint Maritime Commission of the ILO. The proposed amendment appears to be linked to the proposal under C./D. (Amendment above) and could be regarded as consequential, if the proposal in D. were adopted. See also: Report of the Discussion, Intersessional Meeting on the Follow-up of the PTMC, Geneva, – April , ILO Doc. No. PTMC//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/ dialogue/sector/techmeet/ptmc/ptmc-.pdf, para : Amendment : C./D., Guideline B.., paragraph (d) . The amendment received tripartite support.
chapter eight
situation is more complex in the case of wages. This is to respond to the problems posed by a possible obligation to regulate wage levels and to verify the calculation of individual wage payments. Despite the problem of including details on wage payment in a mandatory instrument, the topic of wages was included in an early draft of the MLC, . In February , a preliminary draft contained the following text: Regulation .—Wages . All seafarers shall have the right to appropriate compensation in the form of wages and other remuneration, with due regard to the principle of equal remuneration for work of equal value in the context of the maritime industry. . All seafarers shall on a regular basis be paid their agreed remuneration. Section A.—Wages . Seafarers shall receive their wages every month or at more frequent intervals. . In the establishment and calculation of the wages and other entitlements of seafarers, full account shall be taken of the guidance contained in Section B. of this Code as well as of amounts or criteria established under procedures recommended in that Section.51
The Commentary52 on this text presented to the Tripartite Subgroup of the HLTWG explained: Comment (on Regulation .; Section A.) Regulation ., relating to wages, refers to the principle of equal remuneration for work of equal value. This principle is enshrined in the preamble to the ILO Constitution and is expressed in the Seafarers’ Wages, Hours of Work and the Manning of Ships Recommendation, (No. ) (Paragraph (a), reproduced in the preliminary draft as Section B. I, paragraph (a)). At the second meeting of the High-level Tripartite Working Group, the Shipowners’ and Seafarers’ representatives presented a proposal on the main content of the Convention, but were unable to reach agreement on the inclusion of the principle referred to. There was insufficient time for their proposal to be discussed at the meeting and the Government representatives have not therefore expressed their views. Regulation . of the preliminary draft tentatively seeks a solution on the assumption that the disagreement relates not so much to the validity of the principle itself, but rather 51
Preliminary Draft for a Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention, Tripartite Subgroup of the HLTWG (Second Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. STWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/stwgmls/stwgmls-r.pdf, pp. and . 52 Preliminary Draft for a Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention (Annex), Tripartite Subgroup of the HLTWG (Second Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. STWGMLS / / (Annex), available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/stwgmls/ twgmls-r-ax.pdf, pp. –.
title : conditions of employment
on how it is to be interpreted in a multinational environment like that of the maritime industry. Paragraph of Section A. relates to the actual obligation to pay wages, which is not contained in existing Conventions.
This wording as it pertains to levels of payment was not accepted.53 The draft considered at the next meeting provided: Regulation .—Wages Purpose: To ensure that seafarers are paid for their services All seafarers shall be paid regularly for their work in accordance with their employment agreements. Standard A.—Wages Members shall take any necessary measures to ensure that seafarers are able to transmit their earnings to their families. (new) Guideline B.—Wages B.. Specific definitions For the purpose of this Guideline: . . ..54
The final text as adopted now contains a provision explaining what is meant by the term ‘regularly’ and also provides for a monthly account of wages due and allotments (a term used to describe a process whereby seafarers can send their 53
First Draft Commentary, supra note : Comment (on Title , Regulations and Code, Parts A and B) . Regulation . deals with the wages. At present there is no international labour standard explicitly requiring that seafarers are to be paid for their work. An express provision to that effect is now proposed. The principle of equal remuneration for work of equal value is enshrined in the Preamble to the ILO Constitution and is expressed in the Seafarers’ Wages, Hours of Work and the Manning of Ships Recommendation, (No. ). At the second meeting of the High-level Tripartite Working Group, the Shipowner and Seafarer representatives presented a proposal on the main content of the Convention, but were unable to reach agreement on the inclusion of the principle referred to. There has also been some concern expressed by Governments about its inclusion in the mandatory part of the Convention. The principle as contained in Recommendation No. has been retained in Guideline B., which also provides detailed guidance as to the calculation of wages as set out in that Recommendation.
54
Articles and Regulations, supra note ; Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention (First Draft) Code, Part A, HLTWG (Third Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-r- .pdf; and Consolidated Maritime Labour Convention (First Draft) Code, Part B, HLTWG (Third Meeting), Geneva, , ILO Doc. No. TWGMLS//, available at http://www.ilo.org/public/ english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/twgmls/twgmls-r-.pdf.
chapter eight
wages back to families). However, the overall approach is substantially similar to the draft in June . There still remained a concern that the provisions in Part B of the Code would oblige governments to regulate wage levels. The inclusion of this obligation, particularly as it is also included in the list of topics for potential port State control in the MLC, , was resolved through the wording of Standard A., paragraph . Paragraph was developed as a result of the meeting of the HLTWG in January 55 and reviewed at the PTMC. Paragraph provides (emphasis added): . Each Member that adopts national laws or regulations governing seafarers’ wages shall give due consideration to the guidance provided in Part B of the Code.
As the following extract from the discussion suggests, a concern remained whether this would make regulating wage levels mandatory: Standard A.—Wages Paragraph . It was pointed out by the Chairperson that the provision referring to “Members that adopted national laws . . .” was not intended to suggest that Members should adopt national laws. . The Shipowner Vice-Chairperson wished the text to be deleted, considering that it was unnecessary. . The Special Adviser of the Committee explained the text had been included in order to address the concerns of countries which did not regulate wages, as well as to clarify the application of the provisions in Part B of the Code, which referred to the minimum wage.56
The Office Report for the th ILC explains (emphasis added): . Paragraph is worded to reflect the fact that some countries may regulate seafarers’ wages in national laws while others may not. The purpose is to make it clear that Guideline ., in Part B of the Code, is addressed only to countries that choose to regulate seafarers’ wages by law as the Standard in Part A does not contain a requirement to regulate wages. The Guideline covers methods of calculation of wages and overtime and other matters. Its text is drawn from the Seafarers’ Wages, Hours of Work and the Manning of Ships Recommendation, (No. ). . In paragraph (d) of Guideline B.., the seafarers’ endorsement of overtime records “at no greater than monthly intervals” rather than simply “at regular intervals”, as in the PTMC draft Convention, results from an amendment obtaining tripartite support at the Intersessional Meeting.
55 As noted above in connection with Regulation . at footnote referencing Final Report, note . 56 Report I(A), supra note , p. .
title : conditions of employment
. Guideline B.. contains the provisions for the international negotiation of the basic pay or wages of able seafarers . . . 57
Although the wording of paragraph is not entirely clear, this drafting history supports that view that the reference to ‘adopt laws or regulations governing wages’ is intended to address governments that choose to regulate the level of seafarers’ wages, as opposed to the requirement only that the wages be paid, as set out in the Regulation and the rest of Standard A.. This view is also supported in connection with the reference to wages in the SEA under Regulation . and the inclusion of the phrase ‘payment of wages’ in the list in Appendices A-I and A-III for flag State inspection and port State control. It is phrased to address serious concerns by governments that flag State inspectors and port State control officers might have to inspect the details of individual calculations as to whether a seafarer has been paid the correct wage, as opposed to the simpler but still complicated58 question of whether they have been paid in accordance with their SEA and/or CBA. 57
Report I(A), supra note , Note (Regulation .). The practical question of what documentation might be on board a ship for inspection as opposed to in the shipowners’ company office regarding payments, particularly with electronic transfers, was the subject of some debate at the th ILC. See: Committee of the Whole Report, supra note : 58
. The Government member of Norway signalled the sponsors’ intention to withdraw the amendment, but wished to explain its reasoning. The amendment was not about the payment or non-payment of wages, but rather about port state control. Appendix A-III provided a list of general areas that were subject to port state inspection. With the exception of “payment of wages”, all the items on that list could either be inspected on board or were documented on board. Seafarers’ wages did not fall into this category of items however. Seafarers’ wages went into bank accounts on shore and while seafarers might keep monthly bank statements on board, these were private documents that they could not be obligated to share. Companies’ accounts confirming the transfer of wages were not available on the vessel either. This made it difficult to find confirmation on the vessel that wages had been paid. In addition, the wide scope of the definition of “seafarer” created problems. A number of seafarers covered by the proposed Convention were not employed by the shipowner. It would, therefore, be impossible to require that their information should be shared with the captain or the shipowner. Non-payment of wages was a serious problem, but it was addressed through the Convention’s complaint procedures. Therefore, the speaker’s delegation wished to state, for the record, that when implementing the Convention, Norway would understand that ships would not be required to carry wage accounts on board for all seafarers. Norway would implement the Convention nationally on the understanding that ships were not required to carry wage accounts on board, and in doing so would cooperate with other Paris MOU States. On a separate issue, the speaker noted that Appendices A-I and A-III were identical. The Committee might wish to ask the Drafting Committee to combine them into a single appendix. . The Worker Vice-Chairperson noted that non-payment of wages was a serious issue and needed to be addressed. The International Transport Workers’ Federation (ITF) had recovered tens of millions of dollars of back pay annually in recent years and these sums represented only the tip of the iceberg. Therefore, the speaker was pleased that
chapter eight
The particular wording of the phrase “no greater than monthly”59 in Standard A., paragraph , was the subject of an amendment at the Intersessional Meeting held after the PTMC. Amendment : C./D. Standard A., paragraph Submitted by the Seafarers Proposal: In paragraph , replace the words “monthly or at some other regular interval” by the words “at no greater than monthly intervals”. Context: “Members shall require that payments due to seafarers working on ships that fly their flag are made at no greater than monthly intervals and in accordance with any applicable collective agreement.” Comment: The proposed amendment would require that seafarers be paid once a month as a minimum standard. This could be seen as consistent with the monthly accounting for payments due under paragraph . The existing formulation was originally developed to suggest monthly payment as the appropriate “regular” interval (or whatever is provided for in the relevant employment agreement), but at the same time to seek to provide sufficient flexibility to account for situations where seafarers may be paid under differing contractual arrangements respecting the timing of receipt of payment for services.
The issues that might arise now concerning the current wording are largely matters of practical application in various situations and costs.60 In addition, the amendment would be withdrawn and appreciated the recognition given to this issue. Referring to the proposal to combine Appendices A-I and A-III, it would be best to keep them separate. Although the appendices were identical at this time, they might evolve separately in future. . The Government member of Norway withdrew amendment D.. See also the guidance in the Guidelines for Flag State Inspections, supra note , and the Guidelines for Port State Control Officers, supra note , which deal with this practical question. 59 Compendium of Proposed Amendments, supra note , p. ; see also, Report of the Discussion, supra note , p. : Amendment : C./D. Standard A., paragraph . The representative of the Government of Greece proposed to add “. . . unless otherwise provided for in any applicable collective agreement.” His concern was that the stipulation of monthly intervals should not contradict any larger interval agreed upon in other collective agreements. . The representative of the Government of the Islamic Republic of Iran proposed to change “and in agreement with any applicable collective agreement” to “or in agreement with . . .” in order to take care of the Greek Government representative’s concern. . The amendment received tripartite support, without subamendment. 60
For example, questions might arise concerning charges imposed by banks (or other e-transfer
title : conditions of employment
there is some uncertainty, as discussed above, regarding application of Part B of the Code. Regulation .—Hours of Work and Hours of Rest Regulation . and the Standard and Guideline (along with Regulation . on Manning levels) consolidate the Seafarers’ Hours of Work and the Manning of Ships Convention, (No. ). The purpose of Regulation . is simply stated as “[t]o ensure that seafarers have regulated hours of work or hours of rest”. This purpose is re-stated in paragraph of Regulation ., which does not require the adoption of laws or regulations, but does require that a ratifying country ensure that hours of work or rest are regulated. It also establishes maximum hours of work or minimum hours of rest over a given period which are “consistent with the provisions in the Code”. Preventing seafarer fatigue is a subject of concern that the ILO shares with the IMO. Fatigue, particularly in seafarers with watchkeeping responsibilities, is linked to ensuring ship safety and avoiding the risk of maritime incidents. This is a matter that is regulated for watchkeeping personnel under the STCW Convention and is considered as part of ‘fitness for duty’.61 This overlapping concern is recognized in the MLC, in Standard A., paragraph , which
services) for transfer of funds to families. Standard A., paragraph , requires that seafarers must be able to transmit their earnings to their families through, for example, paragraph (a), allotments of a proportion of their wages for remittance at regular intervals by bank transfer. In the case of such allotments a reasonable charge can be made (paragraph ). In terms of what is a ‘reasonable charge’, this may be a matter addressed in national laws or regulations. If not, however, a common sense approach suggests that the charge could be expected to reflect the extra amount, in time or bank charges, that the shipowner incurs in making two or more different bank transfers, instead of just the one to the account of the seafarer concerned. In addition, payment would not be ‘in full’, as required under Regulation ., paragraph , if unauthorized deductions are made, including unreasonable charges for the allotment of earnings, currency exchange, or travel to or from the ship. 61 As noted earlier, the current text of the STCW Convention has similar but different hours of rest provisions from ILO Convention No. , the text of which was followed in the MLC, . The STCW Code, Part A, Chapter VIII, Standards regarding watchkeeping provides: Section A-VIII/ . All persons who are assigned duty as officers in charge of a watch or a rating forming part of a watch shall be provided a minimum of hours of rest in any -hour period. . The hours of rest may be divided into no more than two periods, one of which shall be at least hours in length. . . . . Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraphs and , the minimum period may be reduced to not less than consecutive hours provided that any such reduction shall not extend beyond two days and no less than hours of rest are provided each seven-day period.
chapter eight
requires that, when “determining the national standards [of minimum hours of rest or maximum hours of work], each Member shall take account of the danger posed by the fatigue of seafarers, especially those whose duties involve navigational safety and the safe and secure operation of the ship”. As will be discussed below, the two regimes differ both in their approach62 and in the specific requirements and their wording. The IMO requirements, consistent with its mandate, address seafarers with navigational and safety duties on board ship, although the recent Manila Amendments appear to have widened this somewhat, at least in connection with fitness for duty and watchkeeping, to expressly include seafarers with safety and security and marine pollution prevention duties.63 In addition, consistent with the IMO approach in other conventions, to the extent that there is flexibility, it is explicitly provided for in the interests of uniformity and consistency. The ILO approach, as discussed below, consistent with the focus on tripartism and its mandate, addresses all seafarers, and provides for autonomy/flexibility in the standards at the national level through CBAs and consultation with the national social 62 In fact ‘working time regulation’ has been the subject of standard setting by the ILO since its inception in . See, for example, Hours of Work (Industry) Convention, (No. ), Washington, November ; Hours of Work (Commerce and Offices) Convention, (No. ), Geneva, June ; Forty-Hour Week Convention, (No. ), Geneva, June ; all available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm; and Reduction of Hours of Work Recommendation, (R), Geneva, June , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/ english/recdisp.htm. The concern in the ILO context relates not only to worker health but also to wider socio-economic dynamics. Research done by the ILO and others argues that that the impact of working time regulation ‘can contribute to economic efficiency’ (as opposed to constituting a ‘brake on economic growth’). This former argument is a factor in a wide range of variables: workers’ physical and mental health, workplace safety, family and personal life, employment, wage income, labour costs, labour productivity, and economic growth. See, inter alia, a paper and sources cited therein, “How to defend labour Standards: A case study on working hours limits,” presented by Deirdre McCann and Sangheon Lee at the Workshop on the Economic Dynamics of International Labour Standards, ILO, Geneva, – June . Reported in Project on Economic Dynamics of International Labour Standards, Governing Body, Committee on Legal Issues and International Labour Standards, st Session, Geneva, November , ILO Doc. No. GB./LILS/. 63 See Manila Amendments, supra note and also infra notes – for the final text (emphasis added): Regulation VIII/
Fitness for duty Each Administration shall, for the purpose of preventing fatigue: . establish and enforce rest periods for watchkeeping personnel and those whose duties involve designated safety, security and prevention of pollution duties in accordance with the provisions of section A-VIII/ of the STCW Code; and . require that watch systems are so arranged that the efficiency of all watchkeeping personnel is not impaired by fatigue and that duties are so organized that the first watch at the commencement of a voyage and subsequent relieving watches are sufficiently rested and otherwise fit for duty.
title : conditions of employment
partners. In addition, the ILO provisions also address the concepts of ‘normal’ working hours and work week, which in turn relates to questions of wages and overtime, again within the framework of possible flexibility through collective bargaining. The fact that two international conventions with somewhat different standards exist does, however, provide some difficulty in terms of a State’s ability to implement its obligations. To the extent that either the ILO or IMO standard is higher, from a strictly legal perspective, compliance with a higher standard inherently complies with a less stringent standard so it would be possible to comply with both. However, in an industry where certainty and clarity are critical, particularly in the context of increased inspections in foreign ports under the regional port State control MOUs, these differences caused some uncertainty in connection with the earlier ILO Convention No. and the STCW.64 To some extent this has been addressed, as mentioned earlier and explained below, in the amendment to the STCW Code adopted by the IMO in Manila in June . The amendment is based on the text in the MLC, with respect to the minimum hours of rest, although there are some differences that remain, and as will be discussed below, they largely reflect differing mandates and focus of the two organizations. The terms ‘hours of work’ and ‘hours of rest’ are specifically defined in Standard A., paragraph : . For the purpose of this Standard, the term: (a) hours of work means time during which seafarers are required to do work on account of the ship; (b) hours of rest means time outside hours of work; this term does not include short breaks. 64
In the course of the preparatory meetings for Convention No. , the Report of the Committee on the Revision of the Wages, Hours of Work and Manning (Sea) Convention (Revised), (No. ), and Recommendation, (No. ) states that the requirements of Article , paragraph , of Convention No. were regarded as consistent with the IMO’s STCW. This concern was further emphasized by a resolution adopted in along with Convention No. , stating, inter alia, that, . . . nothing in this Convention is intended to enable Members ratifying the Convention which are also Parties to the revised Standards of Training, Certification and Watchkeeping (STCW) to apply provisions to watchkeeping seafarers that are less favourable than those contained in the revised STCW Convention and are inconsistent with the minimum rest period provisions of that Convention. Subsequently, to try to alleviate uncertainty, the IMO and ILO formed a Joint IMO/ILO Working Group on the Seafarers’ Hours of Work and the Manning of Ships Convention, (No. ) which met in London, – January , to develop the IMO/ILO Guidelines for the development of tables of seafarers’ shipboard working arrangements and formats of records of seafarers’ hours of work or hours of rest. These guidelines were subsequently published by both organizations.
chapter eight
Standard A., paragraph , provides (emphasis added): . Each Member shall, within the limits set out in paragraphs to of this Standard, fix either a maximum number of hours of work which shall not be exceeded in a given period of time, or a minimum number of hours of rest which shall be provided in a given period of time.
The word ‘either’ is important because although the title of the Regulation refers to hours of work and hours of rest, the obligation is ‘or’. Governments may choose to regulate by establishing (‘fixing’) either minimum hours of rest or maximum hours of work. The two options65 for these limits and the period of time concerned under paragraph are as follows: (a) maximum hours of work shall not exceed: (i) hours in any -hour period; and (ii) hours in any seven-day period;
or (b) minimum hours of rest shall not be less than: (i) ten hours in any -hour period; and (ii) hours in any seven-day period.
Paragraph provides a further important parameter on this limitation, while paragraphs and deal with the treatment of fire and other drills and seafarers whose jobs require that they be ‘on call’. Paragraph provides: . Hours of rest may be divided into no more than two periods, one of which shall be at least six hours in length, and the interval between consecutive periods of rest shall not exceed hours.
This paragraph, like paragraph , simply follows the text of Convention No. 66 and was not the subject of debate during the development of the MLC, or the predecessor convention. However, it was subject to significant scrutiny and debate by the maritime industry throughout and when the MLC, provisions on hours of rest were included in the STCW Code 65 Interestingly, the two options on limits under Standard A., paragraph , do not add up to the same amount of work/rest. The hours of rest parameters would allow seafarers to work more hours in a seven-day period. Not surprisingly, the minimum hours of rest is the option usually selected, perhaps because it also is closer in approach to the STCW. It is unclear why this difference, which was established in the predecessor Convention No. , exists. However, in deciding to follow as closely as possible the content of Convention No. , there was no consideration given to altering either of these formulas in the MLC, . 66 The wording in paragraphs and and other provisions consolidates (and does not change) Article , paragraphs and of Convention No. , supra note , as adopted in .
title : conditions of employment
text amendment proposals.67 The fact that this clause had been in existence and apparently implemented by ratifying countries68 for more than a decade without much question is perhaps indicative of the relative impact of the two conventions on the maritime sector. The proposals and subsequent adoption of text in June by the IMO to amend the STCW Code on this and other matters to mirror the MLC, is an important step to align the two regimes. As mentioned earlier and discussed below, in connection with Standard A., paragraph , the STCW 67 See: IMO, Conference of Parties to the STCW Convention, Consideration of the Draft Amendments to the Seafarers’ Training, Certification and Watchkeeping (STCW) Code, Draft amendments to Part A of the Seafarers’ Training, Certification and Watchkeeping (STCW) Code, Note by the Secretariat, IMO Doc. No. STCW/CONF./, February , Annex, Chapter VIII, Standards regarding watchkeeping, p. [footnotes omitted] (see also notes – infra):
Section A-VIII/, Fitness for duty Administrations shall take account of the danger posed by fatigue of seafarers, especially those whose duties involve the safe and secure operation of a ship. All persons who are assigned duty as officer in charge of a watch or as a rating forming part of a watch and those whose duties involve designated safety, prevention of pollution and security duties shall be provided with a rest period of not less than: . a minimum of hours of rest in any -hour period; and . hours in any -day period. The hours of rest may be divided into no more than two periods, one of which shall be at least hours in length, and the intervals between consecutive periods of rest shall not exceed hours. The requirements for rest periods laid down in paragraphs and need not be maintained in the case of an emergency or in other overriding operational conditions. Musters, fire-fighting and lifeboat drills, and drills prescribed by national laws and regulations and by international instruments, shall be conducted in a manner that minimizes the disturbance of rest periods and does not induce fatigue. Administrations shall require that watch schedules be posted where they are easily accessible. The schedules shall be established in a standardized format* in the working language or languages of the ship and in English. When a seafarer is on call, such as when a machinery space is unattended, the seafarer shall have an adequate compensatory rest period if the normal period of rest is disturbed by call-outs to work. Administrations shall require that records of daily hours of rest of seafarers be maintained in a standardized format, in the working language or languages of the ship and in English, to allow monitoring and verification of compliance with the provisions of this section. The seafarers shall receive a copy of the records pertaining to them, which shall be endorsed by the master or by a person authorized by the master and by the seafarers. 68
As of December , countries have ratified Convention No. : Belgium; Bulgaria; Denmark; Finland; France; Germany; Greece; Ireland; Latvia; Luxembourg; Malta; Morocco; Netherlands; Norway; Romania; Saint Vincent and the Grenadines; Seychelles; Slovenia; Spain; Sweden; and United Kingdom. Of course the influence is much wider since Convention No. is one of the conventions listed in the appendix to the Protocol of to the Merchant Shipping (Minimum Standards) Convention, (P), which has been ratified by countries.
chapter eight
Code amendments adopted by the IMO differ in connection with flexibility regarding the application of the constraints under paragraph . The main concern regarding the application of paragraph is whether the maximum “two periods” constraint applies only to the minimum ten hours in any hour period or to all hours of rest (including the minimum hours). Related questions are also raised in connection with the treatment of a one-hour meal break69 and the situation for some specific categories of seafarers involved in passenger meal or other entertainment services on board cruise ships.70 The concern is that if ‘hours of rest’ does not refer to the -hour minimum, then all the hours of rest have to be taken in no more than two periods, one of which has to be of at least six hours’ duration, with a maximum between rest periods of hours. This is likely to be extremely difficult for compliance. Whether the hours of work and rest are compliant may also depend on when the -hour period is considered to have started. Clearly the wording in the Convention does present some difficulties. However, several approaches are possible to achieve the purpose of these provisions, that is, to avoid fatigue, whilst also recognizing the need to mesh with industry needs and practices. One approach, based on a strict or ‘literal’ reading of paragraph of Standard A., is that it refers to ‘hours of rest’, a term which is defined in paragraph (b), and not to the minimum hours of rest required by paragraph (b) of that Standard.71 In this respect paragraph of Standard A. contrasts with paragraph of Standard A., which establishes a requirement that applies only to “the minimum annual leave with pay prescribed in this Standard” (emphasis added). There is, therefore, at least a presumption that it was 69
Under the definition of hours of rest, a ‘short break’ of, for example, minutes, is not considered rest. Some collective bargaining agreements also do not regard a meal break as a rest period. 70 While hours of rest periods often meet the parameters set by Standard A., paragraph , the maximum division into two under paragraph can create problems because of meal service schedules. One solution, where it is not possible for certain categories of seafarers to have only two rest periods per day, might be CBAs that provide (on the basis of Standard A., paragraph ) for working schedules based on a three rest period system, with one of those rest periods always being at least six hours in length. In light of the object and purpose of paragraph , the minimum hours of rest in any -hour period could then be set at eleven hours instead of the ten hours provided for in paragraph . 71 A contrary argument might be made to the effect that, at the time of adoption of Convention No. , the current provisions (see above notes –) of the STCW existed and must be understood as being in the contemplation of the delegates, particularly in light of the resolution. The current text of the STCW does not include the definition of hours of rest. It could, as worded, be understood as relating only to the STCW minimum rest periods, called ‘hours of rest’ (ten hours in any hours), when it provides that “the hours of rest may be divided into no more than two periods, one of which shall be at least six hours in length”. The amendments that were recently adopted (see above note ff infra), with a potential exception of three periods, support this view. However, the STCW amendments include neither the definitions nor the same form of flexibility provided under the MLC, , paragraph .
title : conditions of employment
not intended to refer to the minimum (e.g., ten) hours of rest in Standard A., paragraph , since there is no clear link between the ten-hour minimum and the maximum of two rest periods. A more purposive approach to the requirements of paragraph could be seen as being less strict than that implied by a reference to the phrase “in any -hour period”. That approach is relevant to the calculation of the length of periods of rest, which is contained in paragraph of Standard A.. It is not used in paragraph and could result in undue rigidity if it were applied to the calculation of the number of rest periods. The tripartitism that is central to the ILO approach and to the MLC, is important in resolving these issues. The Convention leaves the details of the way in which the Convention’s requirements are implemented to be decided in the national laws or regulations of the countries ratifying it or, in many cases, through other measures such as CBAs in that country. As a starting point, national measures to implement may result in some differences in approach, but must take into account the essential purpose of the requirement for relatively uninterrupted periods of rest, that is, the avoidance of fatigue, as stated in Standard A., paragraph . If seafarers are provided with uninterrupted periods that significantly exceed the minimum ten hours, the purposes of the Standard are clearly being met, and a flexible approach can be adopted with respect to the details of the national requirements. This flexibility is provided in the MLC, , particularly by Standard A., paragraph , and also by determinations based on substantial equivalence in accordance with Article VI, paragraphs and . The other important point that may be easily misunderstood is the issue of reconciling the provisions in Standard A., paragraph , regarding the “normal working hours standard” of an eight-hour day with one day of rest per week, with paragraph which appears to envisage a maximum hours of work in days (or minimum hours of rest). While paragraph may be an optimal work schedule, essentially its role can be best understood as also relating it to the calculation of pay for overtime. Since the content and the text of Standard A. is almost exactly the same as an existing ILO convention adopted within a decade of the MLC, , in principle, it would seem unlikely to be controversial during the development of the MLC, . However, Standard A. proved to be extremely difficult with significant divisions in the Government Group. The difficulty in connection with the text arose not from the requirements but from their application in the context of the definition of a seafarer, which now includes a much larger group of seafarers (and ships). The predecessor Convention No. allowed for a national determination regarding ‘seagoing ship’ and the question of who is a seafarer was also subject to similar national discretion in Article (d):
chapter eight
(d) the term “seafarer” means any person defined as such by national laws or regulations or collective agreements who is employed or engaged in any capacity on a seagoing ship to which this convention applies.
In many countries ships’ masters, and often engineers, are not considered ‘seafarers’ for purpose of the application of hours of work or rest. During the negotiation to develop the MLC, many governments did not agree that the master should be covered by hours of work or rest provisions. The Shipowners’ Group largely agreed with this view. Other governments were equally opposed to not requiring that masters be covered. The Seafarers’ Group agreed with this view. As explained in the Commentary72 to the PTMC: Comment (on Regulation .) . Regulation . deals with hours of work or rest. Paragraphs and of Standard A. provide the ability to respond to specific situations at a national level and to emergency events. However, some Governments feel that they need to specifically exclude masters and/or chief engineers from the hours of work and rest requirements. Others feel that the issue is already provided for in the current text and that it is not appropriate to make exceptions, especially in light of growing concerns about the impact of fatigue on safety. The Seafarer representatives have expressed significant concern about the idea of excluding any seafarers from the hours of work and rest provisions and believe that it is contrary to understandings reached with respect to the Seafarers’ Hours of Work and the Manning of Ships Convention (No. ). The Shipowner representatives have indicated support for the concerns of the Governments that wish to have such an exclusion. The High-level Group has on a number of occasions stressed that the new Convention should closely follow the provisions of Convention No. , whose adoption had been the subject of extensive debate and delicate compromises. . The recommended draft includes—inside square [ ] brackets—the two alternative proposals with respect to exclusions from the Regulation that were made by Government representatives at the High-level Group’s last meeting. One is in paragraph of Regulation .;73 the other is in paragraph of Standard A..74
The difference between the two alternatives, aside from some subtleties in wording with the text proposed for the standard providing for coverage but allowing for some flexibility, was the significant impact of the choice of place72
Commentary to the Recommended Draft, supra note . . [Seafarers employed in positions such as master and chief engineer which require flexibility in their hours of work and rest are not covered by this Regulation.] 74 . [Nothing in this Standard shall prevent a Member from having national laws or regulations or a procedure for the competent authority to set out different limits on hours of work or rest, subject to paragraph above, for masters and chief engineers not ordinarily engaged in watchkeeping duties.] 73
title : conditions of employment
ment in a regulation rather than a standard. Inclusion in a standard would allow for more rapid amendment in the future. These two proposals were heatedly debated at the PTMC. The following extract from the Technical Committee meeting report75 provides a flavour of the debate and principles involved. . The Chairperson referred to Convention No. regarding scope issues, and reminded the Committee that masters were included in the definition of a seafarer contained in this Convention. . The Chairperson of the Government group reported that the governments were divided on this issue. . The Government member of the United Kingdom said this text had serious implications. In Convention No. , a seafarer was defined as anyone employed on a ship, which definitely included the master and chief engineers. The human element was recognized as a priority in international maritime regulations. Fatigue was a hazard and consequently a prime concern for those seeking to learn from accidents at sea. Indeed, fatigue was often identified as a primary cause of major maritime accidents. How could one set of regulations condone, or implicitly encourage, ships to be operated by people who were unfit because of fatigue? The Shipowners’ alternative text was not acceptable either. His Government refused to accept any exceptions or relaxations in the consolidated Convention to the minimum periods of rest for any seafarers, including masters and chief engineers. . The Government members of France, Germany, Ghana, the Netherlands, Norway and the Syrian Arab Republic supported the position taken by the Government member of the United Kingdom. . The Government member of Japan did not disagree that a master was by definition a seafarer, but considered that the nature of his job was different. Masters had full responsibility for maintaining order on the ship, in both normal and emergency conditions. No one could substitute for the master when he was on board ship, and flexibility was required in terms of hours of rest. The Government member of the Republic of Korea agreed with the Government member of Japan and said that the nature of the work of masters and chief engineers not engaged in regular watchkeeping duties on board was different from that of other seafarers. They had full responsibility for ensuring the safety and health of seafarers, the safe operation of ships and the protection of the marine environment in any circumstances. Therefore a strict limit on hours of work or rest should not be applied to masters and chief engineers. . A show of hands indicated that a large majority of governments were in favour of deleting paragraph of Regulation .. . The Shipowner Vice-Chairperson was only requesting a relaxation of the requirements, citing the many everyday duties incumbent on the master, including the frequent obligation to be present for compulsory inspections while in port. . The Seafarer Vice-Chairperson considered the text ambiguous, especially the word “flexibility”. The master had a critical central role to play, but in order to retain the capacity to lead, the master needed to rest. 75
Committee No. Report, supra note , pp. –.
chapter eight
. The Chairperson announced he would inform the Steering Committee that an impasse had been reached on this issue, which would be returned to subsequently.
A decision was made to delete both proposals.76 However, the issue was not resolved and surfaced at the th ILC. Again, it divided the Government Group and the Seafarers’ and Shipowners’ Groups, when an amendment aimed again at allowing flexibility on this question was proposed, this time formulated as a new guideline in Part B.77 Because of its importance the discussion is set out at length below. . The Government member of Japan, speaking also on behalf of the Government members of Indonesia, Republic of Korea, Malaysia, New Zealand, Pakistan, Philippines, Russian Federation and Thailand, submitted amendment D., which sought to add, after paragraph , the following new paragraph: National laws and regulations may, after consultation with shipowners and seafarers concerned, stipulate that masters are covered by paragraphs , and of this Standard only when engaged in regular watchkeeping and as a consequence to add the following new Guideline B..: Guideline B..—Masters In applying paragraph of Standard A., the competent authority should pay particular attention to fatigue, and should take into account the nature of masters’ duty, which includes the overall safety and management responsibilities on board the ship. . The speaker explained that masters were the supreme commanders of their vessels and bore heavy responsibility in all matters, including maintenance and discipline on board. It was, therefore, inappropriate to regulate their hours of work even though Standard A., paragraphs and , did provide for some degree of flexibility. Referring to the situation in his country, he stated that the regulations governing masters’ watchkeeping were stricter than the provisions of the STCW Convention limiting watchkeeping to eight hours, especially in view of the fatigue factor. He believed, therefore, that the Government of Japan took masters’ fatigue more seriously than most other countries. Masters exercised a multitude of functions being responsible, among other things, for port state control issues, complaint procedures and scheduling the crew’s hours of service. Furthermore, in Japan there were about Laws delegating authority to ship masters, including policing. Masters were expected to fulfil their duties at all times and therefore could not be subject to the ordinary eight-hour per day schedule nor the maximum hours of work per day. Masters should be able to manage their working hours freely. This view represented the tripartite consensus in Japan. If their hours of work were to be strictly regulated, two or three masters might be required for each ship, which would prevent the normal operation of the ship. 76
Ibid., p. ,
. On the suggestion of the Chairperson, the Committee agreed to delete the text of Regulation ., paragraph and that of Standard A., paragraph . 77
Committee of the Whole Report, supra note .
title : conditions of employment
. The Employer Vice-Chairperson recalled that the master of the ship bore ultimate responsibility for the safety of the ship, the passengers, the cargo, the crew and the conservation of the marine environment. Masters required flexibility in the arrangement of their hours of work and rest. He accordingly supported the amendment. . The Worker Vice-Chairperson strongly opposed the amendment. One position which required enhanced protection was that of the master who carried an extensive list of responsibilities and was held accountable for practically everything that happened on board. Most importantly, the master was responsible for the lives of all persons on board. Excluding the master from the application of hours of work and rest regulations was unacceptable. Referring to Annex , paragraph , of the IMO resolution A.() of concerning principles of safe manning, he stressed that it was widely recognized that every company had the responsibility to ensure that the master, officers and ratings did not work more hours than was safe. He also referred to the Seafarers’ Hours of Work and the Manning of Ships Convention, (No. ), Article , which required the shipowner to ensure that the master was provided with the necessary resources for the purpose of compliance with obligations under that Convention, including those relating to the appropriate manning of the ship. . Turning to the issue of fatigue, the speaker quoted an excerpt from the June study by the United Kingdom Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB) which referred to a worrying number of merchant ships involved in collisions or near misses. While the details of the accidents might vary, the fundamentals remained depressingly consistent: fatigued crews, due to undermanning; falsified hours of work records; no dedicated lookout on the bridge; and poor situational awareness, anticipation and judgment by officers of the watch. These were classic symptoms of fatigue. In , MAIB had conducted a safety study covering , accidents over the last ten years, of which were examined in detail. The results showed conclusively that poor manning levels and fatigue were major causal factors in collisions and groundings. The speaker would welcome the idea of having three masters on a ship and could not see what might be objectionable with such an eventuality. It was unacceptable for masters to be exempt from the hours of work and rest coverage of the new Convention. Neither the Seafarers’ Hours of Work and the Manning of Ships Convention, (No. ) nor the European agreement on the organisation of working time of seafarers () provided for such an exemption. He believed that, in any event, Regulation A., paragraph , offered sufficient flexibility. Many governments took safety seriously. He therefore sought the support of Government members . . . . The Government member of the United Kingdom expected that this new Convention properly recognized the rights of seafarers, the most fundamental of which was the right to life. Seafarers should not be placed at risk of losing their life while serving on board a ship. The master was responsible for everyone on board, and also for adhering to international maritime regulations. Both the IMO and the ILO recognized the importance of addressing the issue of fatigue. Indeed it was the responsibility of all parties to ensure safe manning levels at all times. Fatigue had been identified as the underlying cause of many maritime accidents. The new Convention must not condone nor indeed permit ships to be operated by seafarers who were not fit to perform their duties due to fatigue. There should
chapter eight
be no exceptions to minimum hours of rest, particularly for masters. Amendment D. was not acceptable. . The Government member of the United States stated that hours of work and rest was a complex matter related to manning, trade patterns, type of ship, type of trade and the issues of responsibilities. The United States had strict hours of work regulations and would therefore, not be affected either way by this amendment. For this reason, her delegation neither opposed nor supported the amendment. She urged the Committee not to resort to a vote; it would be a pity if one side were to win at the expense of the other.
Ultimately the amendment was withdrawn and the matter resolved on the basis of the following, very important, clarification provided by a representative of the ILO’s Secretary-General of the Conference (the Office) regarding the current wording of paragraphs and of Standard A.: . The Government member of Japan requested clarification from the Office on the flexibility contained in paragraphs and . . The representative of the Secretary-General responded to the request of the Government member of Japan. Paragraph provided that: Nothing in paragraphs and of this Standard shall prevent a Member from having national laws or regulations or a procedure for the competent authority to authorize or register collective agreements permitting exceptions to the limits set out. Such exceptions shall, as far as possible, follow the provisions of this Standard but may take account of more frequent or longer leave periods or the granting of compensatory leave for watchkeeping seafarers or seafarers working on board ships on short voyages. This paragraph was almost identical in its wording to paragraph of Article , of the Seafarers’ Hours of Work and the Manning of Ships Convention, (No. ). In the first sentence of paragraph , it seemed important to note the reference to collective agreements “permitting exceptions” to the limits in paragraphs and . Thus, the competent authority might authorize exceptions to be permitted in certain circumstances. The second sentence in paragraph specified that these “exceptions shall, as far as possible, follow the standards set out, but may take account of more frequent leave periods etc. . . .”. The second part of the sentence, with its use of the word “but”, indicated a contrast with the previous statement. The speaker would understand it as implying that exceptions should seek to follow the standards of the Convention “as far as possible”, except where the variations to the limits were appropriately combined with other elements in the agreement concerning more frequent or longer leave periods or compensatory leave for specified groups of seafarers. Of course, any exception would need to avoid any risk of fatigue. Compatibility between a collective agreement and paragraph would depend upon whether or not the collective agreement followed the limits set out in paragraphs and of the Convention “as far as possible”, and whether sufficient account had been taken of the exceptional nature of reductions of those limits. Such reductions could be regarded as
title : conditions of employment
. .
. .
permissible for specific categories of seafarers (including masters) and/or in specific circumstances in which it could reasonably be considered not possible to follow the normal standards. Paragraph stated that: Nothing in this Standard shall be deemed to impair the right of the master of a ship to require a seafarer to perform any hours of work necessary for the immediate safety of the ship, persons on board or cargo, or for the purpose of giving assistance to other ships or persons in distress at sea. Accordingly the master may suspend the schedule of hours of work or hours of rest and require a seafarer to perform any hours of work necessary until the normal situation has been restored. . . . Although a master could not really deliver orders to him or herself, a reasonable reading would require the same flexibility to apply, above all, to the master in the emergency situation concerned. The Government members of Indonesia, Japan and Malaysia withdrew the amendment, in light of the clarification provided by the Office. The Government member of the Republic of Korea supported the withdrawal of the amendment, but asked whether paragraph covered issues such as marine pollution, security matters, the detention of the ship or other overriding operational circumstances. In response, the representative of the Secretary-General stated that paragraph could be interpreted to cover those cases as highlighted by the Government member of the Republic of Korea.78 Standard A. was adopted without amendment.
The wording in paragraph needs to be carefully considered as the English language version might be read as permitting a country to have national laws or regulations generally permitting derogations. However, the French language 78 Given the debate on the wording, this reported statement is puzzling. However, it should be noted the issue was subsequently clarified in . The ILO’s Governing Body convened a meeting of a Preparatory Tripartite MLC, Committee in Geneva – September to consider various issues in preparation for entry into force of the Convention. The question was asked about the scope of matters under paragraph and the following view expressed by the Deputy Secretary-General of the meeting. See Final Report, Preparatory Tripartite MLC, Committee, , ILO.Doc. No. PTMLC// available at: http://www.ilo.org/global/standards/ maritime-labour-convention/WCMS_/lang–en/index.htm: . The representative of the Government of the Republic of Korea raised a question regarding interpretation of Standard A., paragraph of the Convention, and asked whether it covered issues such as marine pollution, security matters, the detention of the ship or other overriding operational circumstances. He drew attention to paragraphs and of Provisional Record No. , Part I, Report of the Committee of the Whole, th (Maritime) Session, Geneva, . . The Deputy Secretary-General noted that the question raised by the representative of the Government of the Republic of Korea concerned a ship’s master’s right to suspend the hours of rest under Standard A., paragraph . In her view the overriding operational circumstances of the kind referred to would, in any event, often be covered as they would also involve one or more of the kinds of emergency circumstances referred to in paragraph .
chapter eight
version would not support this reading. Rather, the point is that derogations ‘to the limits’ must be provided for in collective agreements, which are either authorized or registered under ‘national laws or regulations’ or ‘a procedure’. This is an important point to note in connection with the wording of the flexibility option that was adopted, instead of paragraph , in the Manila Amendments to the STCW Convention. A paragraph similar to the flexibility provided in paragraph was subsequently proposed for inclusion in the STCW Code amendments in .79 Two proposals for a flexibility clause80 proved to be controversial, with seafarers concerned about the potential for contracting out application of the minimum hours of rest.81 Ultimately the clear, if complex, exception in paragraph was 79 Report to the Maritime Safety Committee, Sub-Committee on Standards of Training and Watchkeeping, February , IMO Doc. STW //Add., Annex . 80 The proposed amendments to the text of the STCW Code that were to be considered at the Conference provided two alternatives. See above text at note ff.; Report to the Maritime Safety Committee, Sub-Committee on Standards of Training and Watchkeeping, st Session, February , IMO Doc. STW //Add., Annex , p. :
[ Nothing in this Convention shall prevent Parties from applying exceptions to the above limits, as provided for by other relevant international Conventions. These exceptions shall under no circumstances be less than hours of rest in any -day period. bis Such exceptions shall, as far as possible, follow the standards set out, while taking into account the guidance regarding prevention of fatigue laid down in section B-VIII/.] [ Parties may grant exemptions from the required hours of rest in paragraph . above provided that the rest period under no circumstances is less than hours in any -day period. Such exemptions shall not be given for more than two consecutive weeks and shall, as far as possible, take into account the guidance regarding prevention of fatigue laid down in section B-VIII/.] 81 Draft Report to the Maritime Safety Committee, Sub-Committee on Standards of Training and Watchkeeping, st Session, January , IMO Doc. STW /WP., p. :
.. ITF (STW //), commenting on documents STW // and STW //, expressed the opinion that any proposal to remove, exclude or exempt the provisions of paragraphs and of section A-VIII/, should be rejected as sufficient flexibility, within the -hour work [day] was provided for in the proposed paragraph . Furthermore, reference to exemptions under other non IMO conventions contained in the proposed paragraph or section B-VIII was inappropriate and should not be included. .. The delegation of the United States, supported by others, expressed their preference for the proposal by Norway. .. The delegation of the Bahamas expressed the opinion that the regulations should be in harmony with those of MLC , otherwise Administrations would have difficulties in implementing the conflicting requirements. .. The delegation of Greece, supported by others, expressed their preference for the proposal by Austria et al., as it would harmonize the requirements of different international conventions as well as provide the necessary flexibility. .. After an in-depth discussion, the Sub-Committee, recognizing that the divergence of opinion could not be resolved at this stage, agreed to retain both proposals in square brackets for a decision by the Conference.
title : conditions of employment
adopted, as set out in the extract below from the text that was finally adopted in June (emphasis added; footnotes omitted).82 It reflects a clear effort to coordinate requirements for two international organizations with overlapping interests. At the same time the clear difference between the two organizations in terms of approaches based on concerns for uniformity and the role of tripartism in flexibility is evident. CHAPTER VIII Standards regarding watchkeeping Section A-VIII/ Fitness for duty Administrations shall take account of the danger posed by fatigue of seafarers, especially those whose duties involve the safe and secure operation of a ship. All persons who are assigned duty as officer in charge of a watch or as a rating forming part of a watch and those whose duties involve designated safety, prevention of pollution and security duties shall be provided with a rest period of not less than: . a minimum of hours of rest in any -hour period; and . hours in any -day period. The hours of rest may be divided into no more than two periods, one of which shall be at least hours in length, and the intervals between consecutive periods of rest shall not exceed hours. The requirements for rest periods laid down in paragraphs and need not be maintained in the case of an emergency or in other overriding operational conditions. Musters, fire-fighting and lifeboat drills, and drills prescribed by national laws and regulations and by international instruments, shall be conducted in a manner that minimizes the disturbance of rest periods and does not induce fatigue. Administrations shall require that watch schedules be posted where they are easily accessible. The schedules shall be established in a standardized format in the working language or languages of the ship and in English. When a seafarer is on call, such as when a machinery space is unattended, the seafarer shall have an adequate compensatory rest period if the normal period of rest is disturbed by call-outs to work. Administrations shall require that records of daily hours of rest of seafarers be maintained in a standardized format, in the working language or languages of the ship and in English, to allow monitoring and verification of compliance with the provisions of this section. The seafarers shall receive
82
See also notes and ; IMO, Conference of Parties to the STCW Convention, Adoption of the Final Act and Any Instruments, Resolutions and Recommendations Resulting from the Work of the Conference, Draft Resolution , Adoption of Amendment to the Seafarers’ Training, Certification and Watchkeeping (STCW) Code, Agenda item , STCW/CONF./DC/, June .
chapter eight a copy of the records pertaining to them, which shall be endorsed by the master or by a person authorized by the master and by the seafarers. Nothing in this section shall be deemed to impair the right of the master of a ship to require a seafarer to perform any hours of work necessary for the immediate safety of the ship, persons on board or cargo, or for the purpose of giving assistance to other ships or persons in distress at sea. Accordingly, the master may suspend the schedule of hours of rest and require a seafarer to perform any hours of work necessary until the normal situation has been restored. As soon as practicable after the normal situation has been restored, the master shall ensure that any seafarers who have performed work in a scheduled rest period are provided with an adequate period of rest. Parties may allow exceptions from the required hours of rest in paragraphs . and above provided that the rest period is not less than hours in any -day period. Exceptions from the weekly rest period provided for in paragraph . shall not be allowed for more than two consecutive weeks. The intervals between two periods of exceptions on board shall not be less than twice the duration of the exception. The hours of rest provided for in paragraph . may be divided into no more than three periods, one of which shall be at least hours in length and neither of the other two periods shall be less than one hour in length. The intervals between consecutive periods of rest shall not exceed hours. Exceptions shall not extend beyond two -hour periods in any -day period. Exceptions shall, as far as possible, take into account the guidance regarding prevention of fatigue in section B-VIII/. Each Administration shall establish, for the purpose of preventing alcohol abuse, a limit of not greater than . blood alcohol level (BAC) or . mg/l alcohol in the breath or a quantity of alcohol leading to such alcohol concentration for masters, officers and other seafarers while performing designated safety, security and marine environmental duties. . . .
Several interesting questions have arisen subsequently83 as to the potential interaction between the flexibility cited above in paragraph of the STCW and the flexibility under Standard A., paragraph , of the MLC, . Do they conflict? For States that are bound by both conventions, does this mean that flexibility under paragraph can only be exercised for STCW personnel in accordance with parameters in the STCW Convention, paragraph and, conversely, does it mean the paragraph STCW flexibility can only be exercised under a collective bargaining agreement as required under the MLC, paragraph ? The answer to the first, as noted in earlier comments, is that the two flexibility provisions, while differing in approach, do not necessarily 83
See supra note . The Preparatory Tripartite MLC, Committee meeting in Geneva, – September , considered various issues in preparation for entry into force of the Convention. At the meeting, these questions arose and views along these lines were expressed by the Deputy Secretary General of the Meeting. See: Final Report, supra note , at para. , and paras –. It was also noted that at the Manila meeting the ILO representative had indicated that, for the ILO, a one hour meal break could not be counted in this minimum as an hour of rest. This information was noted in the records of the Conference.
title : conditions of employment
conflict, although there may be instances where a government in allowing for an exception would need to comply with the higher standard, if they differed, in a particular case. With respect to the interaction between the two provisions, the answer to both questions appears to be, yes. The result of the combination of these two requirements in these two conventions would mean that flexibility for seafarers governed by the STCW provisions would need to be excised in way that complies with both conventions. However, the IMO and ILO respectively would be concerned only with compliance by the State with the particular convention adopted by the organization. Finally, in line with Guideline B., Guideline B .. of the MLC, , contains special provisions for young seafarers. However, paragraph clarifies that young seafarers are not exempt from the general obligation on all seafarers to work during emergencies as provided for in paragraph of Standard A., the scope of which was explained above in the extract from the Report of the Committee of the Whole at the th ILC. Regulation .—Entitlement to Leave Regulation . is to ensure that seafarers have adequate leave. It is intended to address concerns that seafarers often work for extended periods without actually taking annual leave. It is difficult to prohibit workers, particularly in the context of globalized employment and short-term contracts, from taking consecutive employment. The notion of paid annual level also presupposes an ongoing employment situation. There are also difficulties in reconciling these kinds of rights and ideas about the details of basic minimum annual leave, which varies considerably from country to country, even among developed countries. This regulation and Code consolidates the Seafarers’ Annual Leave with Pay Convention, (No. ),84 which provided for calendar days85 per year, a detail that was difficult for many countries. However it is notable that the Regulation itself only contains two generally worded provisions, paragraph , regarding annual leave, and paragraph , regarding the grant of shore leave. The latter, which complements the provisions of Regulation .—Access to shore-based welfare facilities, is based on “the principle that shore leave should be understood as an important aspect of seafarers’ health and well-being”.86 84
Seafarers’ Annual Leave with Pay Convention, (No. ), Geneva, October , available at http://www.ilo.org/ilolex/english/convdisp.htm, has been ratified by countries. It consolidates the Paid Vacations (Seafarers) Convention (Revised), (No. ) and the Holidays with Pay (Sea) Convention, (No. ). 85 All days in a month, including weekends and holidays. 86 Report I(A), supra note , Note (Regulation .), para. .
chapter eight
Importantly Standard A., paragraph , requires adoption of laws and regulations determining minimum leave. This appears to require that both must be adopted.87 The requirements for specific minimum leave set out in Standard A. allows for amendment in the future or the use of substantial equivalence under Article VI. The basic obligation under the Standard is that flag States are to require that seafarers be given paid leave which, unless calculated differently in a collective bargaining agreement or in law or regulations providing for an appropriate method of calculation, is calculated on the basis of . calendar days per month of employment. On this point it is noted that Standard A., paragraph , uses the expression ‘subject to’ to indicate that the formula of a minimum of . calendar days per month can be overridden by CBAs or laws and regulations, but only insofar as the method of calculation of leave is concerned and only to meet the special needs of seafarers. For example, the amount of leave could be expressed (by law or in a CBA) as . calendar days per quarter ( × .), if such a solution were designed to take account of the special needs of seafarers. But any lowering of the resulting amount of days as compared with the minimum . per month, could give rise to a representation or complaint under the ILO Constitution. Part B of the Code, Guideline B., reproduces most of the provisions found in the existing Convention No. and provides guidance as to how matters such as public holidays, etc. should be dealt with in calculating leave entitlements. Importantly, in terms of the principles behind the Regulation, Guideline B.. sets out the concepts of taking annual leave in the place where the seafarer has a substantial connection and for the seafarer to be recalled only in cases of “extreme emergency” and with the seafarer’s consent. This again points to the idea that the purpose is to ensure that seafarers are not only entitled to, but actually take, a break between work periods and, at a minimum, on a yearly basis. It also, as noted above, may reflect ideas about continuing employment with the same shipowner and on ships under the same flag. Despite the importance placed on annual leave, it is not a matter that must be certified on ships that are to be certified as well as inspected except indirectly through the SEA (see Standard A., paragraph (f)). Regulation . and the Code provisions were not especially controversial during the development of the MLC, and were not discussed at all during the PTMC. Although one minor wording matter was amended88 at the th 87 88
See discussion in Chapter at pp. –. Committee of the Whole Report, supra note : Regulation .—Entitlement to leave
. Paragraph of Regulation . was adopted without amendment.
title : conditions of employment
ILC, Regulation . and Standard A. were not the subject of extended discussion. There are, however, some changes in the wording of Standard . from similar provisions in Convention No. that may tighten up some flexibility. Paragraph provides: . Any agreement to forgo the minimum annual leave with pay prescribed in this Standard, except in cases provided for by the competent authority, shall be prohibited.
The predecessor provisions were Articles and of Convention No. : Article In exceptional cases, provision may be made by the competent authority or through the appropriate machinery in each country for the substitution for annual leave due in virtue of this Convention of a cash payment at least equivalent to the remuneration provided for in Article . Article Any agreement to relinquish the right to the minimum annual leave with pay prescribed in Article , paragraph , or—except as provided, exceptionally, in pursuance of Article of this Convention—to forgo such leave, shall be null and void.
Clearly, the overall thrust of the Regulation is to try to encourage avoidance of fatigue and to prevent health and other risks related to fatigue. However, in the context of short-term employment contracts, this is difficult to enforce. . The Government member of Norway introduced amendment D. submitted by the Government members of Germany and Norway to replace the text of paragraph by the following: “Seafarers shall be granted shore leave to ensure their health and well-being and consistent with the operational requirements of their positions.” The amendment was immediately subamended to replace the word “ensure” by “benefit”. The Office text could conceivably be interpreted as meaning that seafarers were to be granted shore leave only if such leave fulfilled two requirements: that it be consistent with their health and wellbeing, and that it be consistent with the operational requirements of their positions. It was to avoid that ambiguity that the sponsors had submitted their amendment. . The Employer Vice-Chairperson said that his group supported the amendment, but suggested that the word “promote” would be preferable to “benefit”. . The Worker Vice-Chairperson also supported the amendment, but preferred the word “benefit”. . The Government members of Germany and Singapore supported the amendment and expressed a preference for the word “benefit”. . The amendment was adopted as subamended by the Government member of Norway. It was referred to the Drafting Committee with a request to pay special attention to the other language versions. . Paragraph was adopted as amended. . Regulation . was adopted as amended. . Standard A. and Guidelines B., B.., B.., B.. and B.. were adopted without amendment.
chapter eight
A question that might arise is how this obligation would work in the case of short-term contracts and also whether this means seafarers must, that is are obliged, to take leave (rather than money). One answer could be that the concept of ‘leave’ implies that, during the leave period, seafarers will enjoy all the benefits of the SEA (including social protection) and not just their wages, but will not be required to work or to be in the workplace. In other words, the contract itself would need to include this period of leave. Obviously the policy intention behind this regulation is to try to encourage seafarers’ to take annual leave rather than undertake back-to-back voyages and risk fatigue. However this is difficult to implement in light of contracts that are often of less than months duration89 and a right to be repatriated in periods less than months. A further question is what is meant by an “agreement to forgo minimum annual leave with pay”? To ‘forgo’ means to give up a right. If a seafarer chooses to take the pay and then freely decides to work for additional pay, often for a new employer on another contract, during a ‘paid leave’, it is not clear that he or she is necessarily agreeing to forgo an entitlement, as opposed to exercising it. Standard A., paragraph ,90 seems to envisage the case where the SEA states, for example, that they will be paid a specific amount in lieu of (instead of) annual leave. Clearly, unless permitted by the flag State, this would be prohibited.91 It also prohibits agreements that allow a seafarer to take annual leave but with no pay during the leave. At the same time it may be that for contracts for a short period, seafarers could be given only a right to payment in lieu of leave and this may be the kind of case where payment in lieu would be permitted by the competent authority under Standard A. paragraph . Regulation .—Repatriation Repatriation is an extremely important element of working conditions for the international workforce that is involved in seafaring. It refers to the basic need for a worker/seafarer to be able to return home, either at periodic intervals 89
For example, the “ITF uniform TCC collective agreement for crews of flag of convenience ships –” envisages a nine-month contract with paid leave at the voyage end. See: ITF, “ITF Uniform ‘TCC’ Collective Agreement,” available at http://www.itfglobal.org/files/extranet///ITFUniformTCCCBA-.pdf. 90 It should also be noted that Standard A., paragraph , only refers to “the minimum annual leave prescribed in this Standard”, that is, calendar days per year. For example, if a SEA provides for calendar days of leave per year, presumably the extra days would not be covered by the prohibition in paragraph . 91 As noted on page under the earlier Convention No. , Article , such an agreement to relinquish the right would (unless an exceptional situation) be ‘null and void’.
title : conditions of employment
during an ongoing contract of employment, or on completion of a contract. Regulation . is intended “[t]o ensure that seafarers are able to return home”. The main issue involved in the right to repatriation is not a question of immigration or border control but rather, under what circumstances it is to occur, who pays for it, and the conditions for travel. A related issue is, of course, what happens if there is a default by the responsible party. Repatriation is a long-standing right and practice in the maritime sector and the idea that the shipowner is to pay for seafarers to return home is not controversial. In fact the first convention on the matter, the Repatriation of Seamen Convention, (No. ), was adopted years before the MLC, and revised in by the Repatriation of Seafarers Convention (Revised), (No. ). Both are revised by the MLC, . The Convention has ratifications but the Convention has only been ratified by countries. One of the reasons for this relatively low ratification is believed to be the high level of detail regarding costs, mode of transport, etc. set out in Convention No. . The MLC, responds to this issue by comprising a brief regulation, with only two paragraphs, and Code, Part A, Standard A., containing a statement of the general rights and principles. The majority of the details in Convention No. are now found in the guidelines in Part B of the Code. The current text of Regulation . and Standard A. were relatively uncontroversial except for its potential interaction with a parallel discussion in the Joint IMO/ILO Ad Hoc Expert Working Group on Liability and Compensation regarding Claims for Death, Personal Injury and Abandonment of Seafarers that had been meeting since .92 The Working Group, chaired by the President of the PTMC and the th ILC, was to address a related problem of abandonment of seafarers, as well as other claims related to Regulation . of the MLC, . These issues remained largely unresolved until a meeting in where principles for a future mandatory text were agreed.93 92 The Joint IMO/ILO Ad Hoc Expert Working Group was established in to consider questions of liability and compensation in connection with crew claims; to ensure, through the operation of appropriate international instruments, the rights of crew members/seafarers to adequate compensation for loss of life, personal injury and abandonment; and to formulate suitable recommendations to the IMO Legal Committee and the Governing Body of the ILO, as appropriate. 93 The ninth session of the Joint IMO/ILO Ad Hoc Working Group on Liability and Compensation Regarding Claims for Death, Personal Injury and Abandonment of Seafarers was held – March . See: Provision of Financial Security, Progress report on the work of the Joint IMO/ILO Ad Hoc Expert Working Group on Liability and Compensation regarding Claims for Death, Personal Injury and Abandonment of Seafarers, Note by the IMO Secretariat, Legal Committee, th Session, July , IMO Doc. LEG //, Annex, pp. –:
. She [the Representative of the International Labour Office] indicated that the draft related to the substance of an agreed proposal for an amendment to the MLC, , which would
chapter eight
If endorsed by the Tripartite Committee to be established under Article XIII of the Convention, these principles will take the form of amendments to the Code of the MLC, . Two aspects of this discussion influenced the MLC, and resulted in the inclusion in Regulation ., paragraph , and in Standard A., paragraph (b), of new requirements that a flag State must require that ships/shipowners provide financial security to assure the relevant responsibility. Neither provision addresses the particular form for the security, which could be a State-run system, private insurance, or another form of security such as a bond.94 Regulation ., paragraph , is expected to assist, at least in part, with reducing the number of cases where seafarers are abandoned in foreign countries and unable to return home because a shipowner is not solvent or for other reasons. follow Regulation . and the Standard and Guidelines under it. The proposed text had been developed as a proposal for development of amendments to the Code of the MLC, , using the Article XV procedure. The Special Tripartite Committee to be established under the MLC, , would need to give further consideration to the question of the precise placement and language of the proposed amendments to the MLC, , Code. In particular, consideration would need to be given to the way in which the Standards and Guidelines under Regulation . would be numbered in the amended version of the Convention. In the proposal, the paragraph numbering had not yet been changed so as to enable the text to be more easily compared with previous drafts and to avoid mistakes in cross-referencing. . The representative of the Office further stated that it was understood that there was agreement that the proposed certificate would be a matter for inspection by port States as well as flag States. This could be achieved fairly simply under the MLC, . The proposal for the amendment would also include a proposal for an amendment to the list of inspection areas in Appendices A-I and A-II of the MLC, , with consequential amendments to the Appendix A-III model documents. This would then eliminate the need for specific and perhaps confusing provisions relating to port State control. The precise wording would depend on whether the intention was to address port State control in connection with abandonment only or whether the amendment would relate to Regulation . and Standard A. as a whole. There might also be an amendment proposed for Standard A., paragraph (i), or the addition of a new provision for the seafarers’ employment agreement. The “plain language” purpose provision in connection with Regulation . might also be amended. The principles accepted by this session of the Joint Working Group will be considered by the Special Tripartite Committee to be established under Article XIII of the MLC, by the ILO Governing Body once the Convention enters into force. 94 As noted in the Office Report for the th ILC, supra note , Note : . In the light of the serious concerns about repatriation, and in view of the discussions still under way within the framework of the Joint IMO/ILO Ad Hoc Expert Working Group on Liability and Compensation regarding Claims for Death, Personal Injury and Abandonment of Seafarers, the PTMC included a new provision (paragraph ) in the Regulation which obliges each Member to require that ships that fly its flag provide some form of financial security to ensure that seafarers are duly repatriated in accordance with the Code.
title : conditions of employment