The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Linguistik Aktuell/Linguistics Today (LA) Li...
13 downloads
923 Views
15MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Linguistik Aktuell/Linguistics Today (LA) Linguistik AktueU!Linguistics Today (LA) provides a platform for original monograph studies into synchronic and diachronic linguistics. Studies in LA confront empirical and theoretical problems as these are currently discussed in syntax, semantics, morphology, phonology, and systematic pragmatics with the aim to establish robust empirical generalizations within a universalistic perspective.
General Editors VVerneri\braharn
Elly van Gelderen
University ofVienna I Rijksuniversiteit Groningen
Arizona State University
Advisory Editorial Board Josef Bayer University of Konstanz
Christer Platzack University of Lund
Cedric Boeckx ICRENUniversitat Autonoma de Barcelona
Ian Roberts Cambridge University
Guglielmo Cinque University of Venice
McGill University
Liliane Haegeman University of Ghent
StenV!kner University of Aarhus
Hubert Haider University of Salzburg
C. Jan-Wouter Zwart University of Groningen
Lisa deMena Travis
Terje Lohndal University of Maryland
Volume173 The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German by Christopher D. Sapp
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German Christopher D. Sapp University of Mississippi
John Benjamins Publishing Company Amsterdam I Philadelphia
The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences - Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI z39.48-1984.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Sapp, ChristDpher D. The verbal complex in subordinate clauses from medieval to modem German I Christopher D. Sapp.
p. em. (Linguistik.Ak:tueU!Linguistics Today, ISSN o166-o829; v.173) Includes bibliographical references and index. 1.
German language--Verb phrase. 2. German language--Syntax. 3· Grammar, Comparative and general--Verb phrase. I. Title.
PF3315.P52S27
2011
435:6--dc22 ISBN 978 90
272 5556 3 (Hb ; alk. paper)
ISBN 978 90
272 8725 o (Eb)
© 2011- John Benjamins B.V. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form, by print, photoprint, microfilm, or any other means, without written permission from the publisher.
John Benjamins Publishing Co.· P.O. Box 36224 • 1020 ME Amsterdam· The Netherlands John Benjamins North America· P.O. Box 27519 ·Philadelphia PA 19118-0519 • usA
Table of contents
Acknowledgements
v
CHAPTER 1
Inrroduction 1.1 The verbal complex in modern and older German 1 1.2 Previous scholarship on diachronic German verb order 1.2.1 The sentence-frame analysis 4 1.2.2 The verbal complex in MHG and ENHG 5 1.2.3 The verbal complex in contemporary German 13 1.3 Organization 14
1
4
CHAPTER 2
Factors influencing verb order in MHG 2.1 Introduction 15 2.1.1 Basic facts 15 2.1.2 The database 17 2.1.3 Analysis with GoldVarb X 19 2.1.4 Organization of this chapter 19 2.2 Complexes of two verbs in MHG 20 2.2.1 Introduction 20 2.2.2 Phonological, morphological, and syntactic factors 2.2.3 Diachronic, dialectal, and sociolinguistic variation 2.2.4 Conclusion 36 2.3 Complexes of three verbs in MHG 36 2.3.1 Introduction 36 2.3.2 Phonological, morphological, and syntactic factors 2.3.3 Diachronic, dialectal, and sociolinguistic variation 2.3.4 Conclusion 43 2.4 Conclusion 44 2+1 Summary of findings 44 2+2 The combined effect of the favoring factors 44
15
20
31
38 41
VI
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
CHAPTER 3
Factors influencing verb order in ENHG 3.1 Introduction 47 3-1.1 Basic facts 47 3.1.2 The database 50 3.1.3 Organization of this chapter 53 3.2 Complexes of two verbs in ENHG 53 3.2.1 Introduction 53 3.2.2 Non-favoring factors 53 3.2.3 Favoring factors 56 3.2.4 Diachronic, dialectal, and sociolinguistic variation 66 3.2.5 Conclusion 75 3·3 Complexes of three verbs in ENHG 76 3.3.1 Introduction 76 3.3.2 Non-favoring factors 77 3.3.3 Favoring factors 79 3·3·4 Diachronic, dialectal, and sociolinguistic variation 85 3·3·5 Conclusion 90 3·4 Discussion 91 3.4.1 Favoring factors in individual texts and dialects 91 3.4.2 Dialect groups in ENHG 92 3·4·3 Developments from MHG to ENHG 95 3·5 Conclusion 97 3.5.1 Summaryoffindings 97 3.5.2 The combined effect of the favoring factors 98
47
CHAPTER 4
Verbal complexes in contemporary German 4.1 Introduction 101 4.2 Previous studies 101 4.2.1 Introduction 101 4.2.2 Two-verb complexes 102 4.2.3 Three-verb complexes no 4.2.4 Complexes of four or more verbs 120 4.2.5 Verbal complexes with an intervening constituent 4.2.6 Conclusion 129 4·3 Focus and two-verb complexes in dialects 129 4.3.1 Introduction 129 4.3.2 Swabian and Austrian 130 4·3·3 Zurich German 137 4·3·4 Conclusion 149
101
124
Table of contents
4·4 Focus and three-verb complexes in Standard German 4.4.1 Introduction 150 4.4.2 Schmid & Vogel (2004)
150
150
4·4·3 Magnitude estimation experiment 153 4·4-4 Discussion 160 4·5 Conclusion 161 4·5-1 Summary of findings 161 4.5.2 From ENHG to Modern German 162 CHAPTER
5
German clause structure and the prosody-syntax interface 5.1 Introduction
165
165
5.2 The structure of German subordinate clauses 165 5.2.1 Introduction 165 5.2.2 Diachronic approaches 166 5.2.3 The OV approach to German clause structure 167 5.2.4 The VO approach to German clause structure (Zwart 1996) 5.2.5 The OV and VO approaches compared 176 5·3 Focus, prosody; and verb order 179 5.3.1 Observations that need to be accounted for 179 5.3.2 Formal syntactic analyses of focus and verb order 181 5·3·3 Accounting for prosodic factors 186 5·3·4 Focus marking and its prosodic and syntactic effects 199 5·3·5 Summary 204 5·4 Conclusion 205
175
CHAPTER 6
Conclusions 6.1 Summary of findings 207 6.2 Implications 2o8 6.2.1 The origin of Standard German 208 6.2.2 The clause structure of German 210 6.2.3 The peripheral nature of verbal complex phenomena 6.2.4 Syntactic change in German 212 6.3 Outlook 213
207
211
Bibliography Primary sources from the Bochumet· Mittelhochdeutschkotpus 215 Primary sources from the Bonner FrUhneuhochdeutschkorpus 215 Secondary sources 217
215
Inde."
223
VII
Acknowledgements
This project began as a brief paper comparing Verb Projection Raising in Swiss German with the same phenomenon in West Flemish. At the end of the paper, I asked why these two non-contiguous dialects share this construction, which exists in neither Standard Dutch nor Standard German. My advisor, Rex A. Sprouse, encouraged me to seek an answer by investigating the verbal complex from a diachronic perspective, thus I owe him a debt of gratitude for shaping this project from its beginning. I would like to thank several other people for facilitating this research. KlausPeter Wegera and Sandra Waldenberger gave me access to the Bochum Middle High German Corpus, which forms the basis of Chapter 2. I conducted the surveys discussed in Chapter 4 during stays in Tiibingen where I worked with the SFB 441, in Vienna by invitation of Werner Abraham and Richard Schrodt, and in Zurich where I received valuable aid from Claudia Bi.icheli-Berger. I would also like to acknowledge all of the participants in my surveys. Allison Burkette, Owen Davis, Robert D. Fulk. Kari Ellen Gade, Stefanie Hirscher, Barbara Vance, an anonymous reviewer, and the editors at John Benjamins provided invaluable proofreading and comments. Participants at the following conferences also engaged me in helpful discussions on the more recent stages of this research: the 2007 International Workshop on Information Structure and Word Order Variation in older Germanic at Humboldt University, the 15th Germanic Linguistics Annual Conference in Banff, the 24th Comparative Germanic Syntax Workshop in Brussels, and the 11th Diachronic Generative Syntax conference in Campinas. This book is dedicated to the memory of two friends and fellow Germanisten: Marshall Billings and Prof. Jim Knowlton.
CHAPTER 1
Introduction
1.1
The verbal complex in modem and older German
A well-known characteristic of Modern Standard German is the asymmetry between main-clause and subordinate-clause word order. In main clauses, the finite verb occupies the second position of the clause (la-d), and any non-finite verb (lb) or verbal particle (lc) will occur at the end of the clause. If there is more than one non-finite verb, these will occur adjacent to each other at the end of the clause (ld), forming a "verb cluster" or "verbal complex" (VC), in which the verbs appear in a prescribed order relative to each other (le).l (1) a. Klaus liest heute das Buch. K. reads6n today the book 'Klaus reads the book today: b. Klaus will heute das Buch lesen. K. wantsfin today the book readmf 'Klaus wants to read the book today.' c. Klaus liest heute das Buch durch. K. readsfin today the book through 'Klaus reads through the book today.' d. Klaus will heute das Buch lesen kiJnnen. K. wantsfin today the book readmr canmr 'Klaus wants to be able to read the book today: e. *Klaus will heute das Buch kiJnnen lesen. K. wantsfin today the book Catl;.0 f readinr
Throughout this work. parts of the verbal complex will be italicized In addition, extraposed or intervening constituents will be indicated by bold face.
1.
2
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
In subordinate clauses introduced by complementizers, on the other hand, all verbs, finite and non-finite, occur at the end of subordinate clauses (2a).2 If the subordinate clause has two or more verbs, these will form a verbal complex. Word order within the VC is fixed, at least when the complex consists of only two verbs. I will call the finite verb 1, and the non-finite verb selected by the finite verb will be labeled 2. (Any dependent verb selected by verb 2 will be labeled 3, and so on.) In Standard German, the only possible order for a two-verb complex in a subordinate clause is 2-1, i.e. the non-finite V followed by the finite Vas in (2b). (2) a.
. .. dass Klaus heute das Buch liest. that K. today the book reads that Klaus is reading the book todaY:
b.
. .. dass Klaus heute das Buch lesen will. that K. today the book read2 wants 1 that Klaus wants to read the book today:
c.
. .. dass Klaus heute das Buch wiU le.sen. that K. today the book wants 1 read2 '... that Klaus wants to read the book today:
The word-order asymmetry between main and subordinate clauses goes back to Old High German, the earliest recorded stage of the language: main clauses strongly tend toward V2, while subordinate clauses have later placement of the finite verb (Axel 2007: 6). Because verbs in subordinate clauses tend to occur late, earlier stages of German, like the modern language, exhibit verbal complexes. However, medieval varieties of German (like many contemporary continental West Germanic dialects) show considerable variation in word order within the VC. This variability can be illustrated with clusters of two verbs in Early New High German (ENHG), the language of the central and southern German-speaking areas from 1350 to 1650. In addition to the 2-1 order (3a), we find the opposite order 1-2 (3b). Furthermore, some material may occur between the verbs, resulting in an order that we willlabel1-x-2 (3c). Finally, independently of verb order, a constituent may be extra posed, i.e. placed to the right of the verbs (3d).
Unintroduced subordinate clauses, typically the complements of bridge verbs, display main-dause-like, verb-second word order:
2.
(i) Ich habe gesagt, Klaus will heute das Buch lesen. I have said K. wants 1 today the book read2
'I said Klaus wants to read the book today.'
Chapter 1. Introduction
(3) a.
das er in kainer sund verczweiffeln sol that he in no sin despair2 shall1 'that he shall not despair in any sin'
(Pillenreuth 161)
b. das der mensch alle sein lebttag nicht anders scholt thun that the person all his life.days nothing else should1 do2 'that man should do nothing else all the days of his life' (Pillenreuth 206) c.
das der mensche nicht scholt sein rew sparen ... that the person not should 1 his regret sav~ 'that one should not hold back his repentance .. .' (Pillenreuth 212)
d. Wye man fragen sol dy krancken how one ask2 shall 1 the sick 'how one should ask the sick'
(Pillenreuth 166)
Word order variation within the verbal complex is the subject of this study. Although VCs occur in both main and subordinate clauses, this study is limited to subordinate clauses. This is because in main clauses, the finite verb is always in the second position, so that VCs can occur only when there are three or more verbs in the clause, as in (ld). Given that the vast majority ofVCs contain only two verbs, especially in older texts, subordinate clauses provide the most fruitful ground for searching for complexes. Moreover, comparing VCs in main and subordinate clauses may be comparing unlike types, since main clauses have complexes of only non-finite verbs, while subordinate-clause verbal complexes usually contain a finite verb. This study investigates these VCs in the history of German, beginning with medieval German and continuing to some modern varieties of German. For medieval and early modern German, I will attempt to describe as accurately as possible the frequencies of particular word orders, the linguistic factors that favor some orders over others, and the diachronic and dialectal spread of these phenomena. For Modern German, I investigate similar phenomena, both in the standard language and in several dialects, resulting in a more complete understanding of synchronic grammar and diachronic developments. There are at least two reasons why the changes in the relative order of verbs that occur in the history of German are interesting, not only for philologists of German but also for those interested in language change and syntactic theory. First of all, many changes in word order have been argued to be related to other changes in the language, such as the loss of inflectional morphology. However, the inflectional system of German has remained remarkably stable throughout its attested history. Therefore, the diachronic developments within the German VC present an interesting case, because the change in word order appears to be motivated by factors other than morphological change.
3
4
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
The second reason that this phenomenon is worthy of diachronic treatment is because it has increasingly received synchronic attention. There has been a flurry of research in the last twenty years seeking the best analysis for the 1-2 and 2-1 orders in Dutch and varieties of German (see Chapter 5). Because written Standard Dutch shows variation in the VC, it can be adequately investigated using corpus studies, as in de Sutter et al. (2008). Contemporary dialects of German, on the other hand, are rarely written, thus a large-scale corpus study of variation in the VC is necessarily limited to older stages of the language. Earlier stages of German appear to allow even more variation than most of the modern dialects, thus providing additional data that the synchronic analyses should take into account. Moreover, investigating earlier stages of contemporary varieties may help explain some aspects of these orders that have not been understood. The rest of this chapter is organized as follows. Section 1.2 presents some previous scholarship on the VC in earlier stages of German. Section 1.3 outlines the organization of the rest of this book.
1.2
Previous scholarship on diachronic German verb order
1.2.1
The sentence-frame analysis
Despite an enormous body of diachronic research on the word order of German, the verbal complex has been relatively neglected. Most scholarship on syntactic change in German has concentrated on two aspects of German word order. First, the verb-second (V2) phenomenon of main clause word order has received substantial diachronic treatment e.g. by Lenerz (1985) and more recently by Axel (2007). Secondly; extraposition (both in main and subordinate clauses) has been a major topic in German grammar, being an object of research in many historical studies of word order in German. This state of aftrurs is, I believe, largely a result of the traditional sentenceframe analysis of German word order (e.g. Wollstein-Leisten et al. 1997:53-54). Under this model, illustrated in Table 1, the verbs in main clauses "frame, the rest of the sentence, with the finite verb forming the so-called "left bracket" and the non-finite verb the "right bracket': In subordinate clauses, the complementizer forms the "left bracket" and the verb duster the "right bracket': The positions before, between, and after the "brackets, are labeled the "pre-field~ "middle field~ and "post-field~ respectively.
Chapter 1. Introduction
Table 1. The sentence-frame analysis of German
maind
sub. d.
pre-field
L bracket
middle field
Rbracket
Klaus
will dass
heute das Buch Klaus heute das Buch
lesen. lesen will.
post-field
Modern German strictly limits what kinds of constituents can be extraposed, i.e. found in the post-field. However, as discussed above and illustrated in (3), earlier stages of German are much freer in this respect. Thus much of the scholarship on the history of German word order has focused on the development of the sentence frame, i.e. the decreasing frequency of extra position. The relative order of the verbs in the VC is often either ignored (because the variation is within the so-called right bracket) or as in Admoni (1990: 156), the 1-2 order is treated as an instance of extraposition (i.e. the non-finite verb is in the post-field). Lenerz (1985: 105) similarly downplays changes in the VC, noting that there is synchronic and diachronic variation but labeling this an example of"stylistic reorderings" that "do not concern the syntactic structures of German as such."
1.2.2
The verbal complex in MHG and ENHG
1.2.2.1
Behaghel (1932)
For many years, most discussion of Middle High German (MHG) grammar was limited to the poetic texts from the high point of courtly literature. Many earlier grammars such as Paul (e.g. 1966) hardly discuss the position of verbs at all. The exception is Behaghel's Deutsche Syntax, which discusses word order in older Germanic prose texts in great detail, from Old English through Old High German to ENHG. This includes a lengthy treatment of verbal complexes in subordinate clauses (1932: 86-118). Regarding two-verb complexes, Behaghel notes that both orders are possible and claims that the 2-1 order is increasingly preferred under Latin influence (1932: 87). In addition, a rhythmic principle influences verb order: the combination of a stressed word plus a verbal complex with the 1-2 order produces the sequence "Hochton, Unton, Hochton" ('stressed word, unstressed word, stressed word'), while the combination of a light word and the 2-1 order produces the sequence "Unton, Hochton, Unton" (1932:87). Finally. Behaghel finds that constructions with infinitives behave differently from those with participles, with the participial construction preferring the 2-1 order (1932: 105).
5
6
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Prell (2001) Prell (2001) provides a very thorough study of MHG syntax, based primarily on prose rather than courtly poetry. He analyzes word order in main and subordinate clauses from twenty-four MHG prose texts from an early version of the Bochumer MHG corpus.3 Prelfs work forms the basis of the thoroughly revised syntax section ofPaufs (2007) MHG grammar. Of the 901 instances of two-verb complexes in subordinate clauses in Prell (2001:83), 28% have the 1-2 order. Prell finds several factors that have an effect on verb order. First, there is an increasing tendency for VCs in the 2-1 order to appear clause-finally: at the beginning of the 12th century, nearly half of the 2-1 complexes have extra position, while by the 14th less than a quarter do (2001: 84). On the other hand, VCs with the 1-2 order continue to occur with a high degree of extraposition throughout the period (2001:84), a trend that is found in several ENHG studies. Secondly, there is a strong effect of syntagm: 39% of modalinfinitive syntagms have the 1-2 order, while 24.7% of perfects and only 16.8% of passives do (2001:85). Thirdly, when the non-finite verb has a stressed separable prefix (SSP), the 1-2 order occurs more frequently than expected: there are 21 instances of the 2-1 order but 22 instances of 1-2 (2001: 87). With respectto complexes of three verbs, Prell ( 2001: 88) finds only 16 instances in subordinate clauses. Of these, 7 are in the 1-3-2 order, 5 are 3-1-2, and4 are 1-2-3. The majority of these examples involve a modal verb with the passive voice. Prell finds no instances of 3-2-1, the prevalent order in Modern Standard German. Prell concludes from this data that MHG, like Modern German, is a verb-final language with movement of the finite verb to COMP in main clauses (2001: 119). For Prell, the topological fields in the two stages of German are exactly the same, so that the structure for both is as in Table 1 above. The differences are that the postfield is a "strong" position in MHG (i.e. extraposition was frequent) but has weakened in the modern language, while the 2-1 order in the right bracket was "weak" in MHG (i.e. there was variation in the VC) but has become "strong (2001: 119). Prell suspects that these two changes may be related, with the result that Modern German subordinate clauses nearly always end in a finite verb (2001: 119).
1.2.2.2
Hammarstrom (1923) By Early New High German (ENHG), prose texts range across many dialects and genres, and thanks to an increasingly literate population, there are many texts such as personal letters that may more accurately reflect the speech of the time. Hammarstrom (1923) looks at verb placement in ENHG in both chancery
1.2.2.3
3· Although this is the same corpus from which I selected texts for my study (Chapter 2), only five texts were selected by both Prell (2001) and my study: Notker, Buch der Konige, Speculum ecdesiae, Schwarzwalder Predigten, and Muhlhauser Reichsrechtsbuch.
Chapter 1. Introduction
documents and popular literature. The earliest chancery documents, from the first half of the 14th century, have the 1-2 order 12-16% of the time. By the 16th century, this has fallen to 0-1%. The rates of 1-2 are higher for popular literature of the 16th century. ranging from 5-37%. In all time periods and text types, the rate of the 1-2 order is higher for the modal-infinitive construction than for the participial constructions.4 Hammarstri:im (1923: 150-162) also looks at subordinate clauses with three verbs, but the number of tokens is quite small. Generally speaking, he finds a preference for the 3-2-1 order in official documents but for 1-3-2 with the IPP construction. Hammarstrom's (1923: 199-200) conclusion is that the word order of the chancery documents was influenced by Latin (although he does not explicitly discuss what form that influence took), and the chancery documents, in turn, served as the model for the emerging written standard. However, Hammarstrom's selection of texts is very uneven, with the chancery documents much older than the literary texts and, as Maurer (1926: 84) points out, not distinguished by dialect.
Maurer (1926) Maurer (1926) places much more emphasis on dialect differences. He investigates a large number of both official documents and literary texts, from different dialect areas from 1300 to 1700. Unlike Hammarstrom (1923), Maurer looks only at perfect constructions. Although he does not give the results for perfects with haben 'have' in tabular form, his results for perfects with sein 'be' are repeated in Table 2. Based on these results, he concludes that the Alemannic areas (Switzerland, Alsace, Swabia, and Baden) have the highest rates of 1-2, while East Middle German (EMG) and North Bavarian (i.e. Nuremberg) have the lowest rates.
1.2.2.4
Table 2. Frequency of 1-2 order with sein perfects in Maurer (1926) Region
Percentage of 1-2 order (1400-1600)5
High Alemannic (Swiss) Low Alemannic (Swiss) Alsatian Swabian S. and M. Bavarian N. Bavarian (Nuremberg) Rhine Franconian EMGdialect EM G written language
30% 12% 50%-+ 33% 50% -+60% 8% 3% 10%-+ 30% 60% -+20% 5% -+0%
4· See Sapp (2006) for a more detailed discussioiL
s.
Adapted from Maurer (1926: 148). Maurer's table is more complicated than this, with some variation over time for some dialects.
7
8
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Maurer (1926: 151) concludes that the EMG and North Bavarian dialects prefer the 2-1 order because they were already under the influence of the written language at this early stage. The tendency to have 2-1 in the written ENHG language, according to Maurer (1926: 123), is a direct result of Latin influence. Maurer (1926: 180) claims that late-medieval Latin school grammars prescribed the 2-1 word order for perfect passives like quod dictum est 'which was said', which then provided the model for ENHG word order.6 Maurer (1926: 165) finds that verb clusters translated from Latin may vary in word order when the Latin original is a simplex verb (4), but are 2-1 when the original is a cluster with 2-1 order (5). (4) a. b.
(5) a.
Latin original:
a quo lingua latina nomen accepit from REL language Latin name receives
translation:
von deme latinisch tunge ist genannt from REL Latin tongue is named 'for which the Latin language is named'
Latin original:
Qui postea dictus est Sedechias who afterward said is S.
b. translation:
geMten was Sedechias der dar rul who afterward called was S. 'who was later called Sedechias'
Furthermore, in Latin-based texts, Maurer (1926: 164) finds a higher frequency of the 2-1 order with perfects formed with sein than with haben, supporting his conclusion that the Latin perfect passive (which is formed with the verb esse 'to be') played an important role. Finally. in addition to Latin influence, Maurer (1926: 159) attributes a certain role to so-called rhythm: some combinations of verbs prefer specific orders, to maintain an alternation of stressed and unstressed syllables, and verbal prefixes affect the rhythmic structure as well. Maurer (1926: 161-162) also claims that falling intonation favors 2-1 order, so 2-1 is more likely to occur in a sentence-final subordinate clause than in a sentence-initial one. Besides the problems with Maurer's Latin hypothesis pointed out by Ebert (1981) (discussed in Section 1.2.2.6 below), there are several problems with the way his study is conducted. First of all, it does not look at modal plus infinitive constructions, which Hammarstrom and later studies show to have a higher rate of 1-2. Secondly, it mixes text types, so it is not clear how much of the variation is due to dialect and how much is due to genre. The EMG data in Table 2 are especially telling in this regard: that dialect shows both the highest and lowest
However, Burridge (1993: 115) and Ebert ( 1998: 116) demonstrate that medieval grammars of German do not make any such prescriptions.
6.
Chapter 1. Introduction
percentages of the 1-2 order, because it is divided into two categories. Thirdly, as Hard (1981: 26) points out, the number of tokens from each text is quite small. It is unclear whether the differences between Hamrnarstrom's and Maurer's results are due to the fact that Maurer takes into account texts from various dialects. or due to the problems with his study. Finally, like Hammarstrom (1923), Maurer (1926) does not give any indication of whether his results are statistically significant.
Hard (1981) Hard (1981) is a studyof17,073 clusters of three or more verbs, from 1450 to 1975. We will be concerned here only with his first period (1450-1580), from which he has 2,704 tokens. The details of his study will be discussed and compared to my results in Chapter 3, but here I will summarize his basic findings. First of all, Hard (1981:75) finds that, although ENHG has an increasing tendency to have the finite verb at the end of a two-verb cluster (2-1), it has the opposite tendency in three-verb clusters, with an increasing preference for the 1-3-2 order. Secondly, Hard (1981: 54) finds this trend mainly in the High German dialects, with Low German preferring the 3-2-1 order. Finally, after the ENHG period, Hard (1981: 174) demonstrates that the downward trend in the 3-2-1 order reverses for all constructions except the IPP, becoming the norm by the 20th century.
1.2.2.5
Ebert (1981) Ebert (1981) examines a variety of text types written by forty-four people from Nuremberg from the 14th to 16th centuries. By investigating texts from just one city, Ebert is able to pinpoint some of the social and stylistic variables that determine the variation between the 2-1 and 1-2 orders.7 He thus avoids Maurer's pitfall oflumping all types of texts together while dodging the problem of dialect differences. Moreover, Ebert uses a sophisticated statistical model (Generalized Linear Interactive Modeling) that controls the variables stress, time, style, class, education, and occupation. Ebert (1981: 219-228) finds that the following factors have an eftect on verb order. The stress of the word preceding the VC turns out to be a significant factor. When the preceding word is a noun (i.e. stressed according to Ebert), there is no clear preference for either order, but when the preceding word is a pronoun (assumed to be unstressed), the 2-1 order is strongly preferred. Time is also a significant variable, with a general decline in the 1-2 order as has been shown in other studies. The results for style are significant as well, with more formal letters having
1.2.2.6
7. Ebert (1981) treats only VCs where the two verbs are adjacent, thus excluding instances of 1-x-2.
9
10
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
higher rates of 2-1. Combining the factors class, education, and occupation gives the following hierarchy: administrators have the highest rates of 2-1, followed by merchants, artisans, students, nuns, and secular women. The type of syntagm is significant as well: werden + participle has the highest rate of 2-1, followed by haben + participle, modals/wet·den + infinitive, and finally sein + participle. Ebert considers other "rhythmic" factors, which have been given primary importance since Maurer (1926). First. Ebert (1981: 206) disproves Maurer's contention that sentence-final subordinate clauses show a higher rate of 2-1 and thus that the 2-1 order is linked to falling intonation. Secondly, Ebert (1981: 229) confirms Maurer's findings (1926: 159) that verbs with stressed separable prefixes are the least likely to show the 2-1 order. Thirdly, Ebert (1981: 208) finds that the alternation of stressed and unstressed syllables in the VC "may affect the choice" of orders, but the number of examples is too small for statistical analysis. Finally, Ebert (1981: 209) notices that the placement of the VC within the clause may have an effect on the ordering within the duster: when the verbs are in clause-final position, the 2-1 order is preferred. Based on these findings, Ebert concludes that Latin influence on the 2-1 order has been overstated. First of all, the preference for 2-1 is not tied to an individual's knowledge of Latin: merchants and artisans, who would not have had much schooling in Latin, show a higher rate of 2-1 than students, who received their education in Latin. Secondly, although Maurer claimed that Latin perfect passives like quod dictum est 'which was said' influenced the German passive das gesagt ist 'which is said: sein + participle is the syntagm which shows the lowest rate of 2-1. Ebert (1981: 231) maintains that this "soundly refutes" the Latin hypothesis. a According to Ebert (1981: 237), the tendency to show the 2-1 order more and more over time is an example of "change from above~ passed down from the chancery style, rather than an imitation ofLatin syntax.9
Ebert (1998) Ebert (1998) studies verb placement primarily in the language of teenagers from 16th-century Nuremberg. Ebert (1998:65-67) finds several factors that influence verb order in the writings of these individuals. First, as seen in earlier research,
1.2.2.7
8. Ebert's examples of sein + participle are all the perfect active use of sein; he excludes the sein passive (1981: 204). Other studies find that the sein passive has very high rates of 2-1, see the discussion of Ebert (1998) below and Chapters 2 and 3. This somewhat weakens Ebert's refutation of Latin hypothesis, since Maurer (1926) would predict high rates of2-1 with the sein passive, not necessarily the sein perfect. 9· However, as Burridge (1993: 117) points out, this still does not rule out indirect Latin influence, since Latin word order could have influenced chancery style.
Chapter 1. Introduction
different syntagms favor the 2-1 order to different degrees, following the hierarchy -wet·den passive > sein passive > haben perfect > infinitive constructions > sein perfect. Second, the stress or category of the preceding word affects verb order (as in Ebert 1981). Third, Ebert claims that the rhythmic structure of the non-finite verb affects word order, although essentially this is reducible to the type of prefix on the verb. Fourth, Ebert finds that for some individuals the lexeme of the nonfinite verb plays a role, but this is possibly reducible to prefix type and syntagm. The highest rates of 2-1 occur with the verbs vernehmen/vernommen 'perceive (inf./PPP)' and empfangen 'receive (inf./PPP): which have an unstressed prefix, while the lowest rates occur with the forms gewest 'been' and wet·denlworden 'become (inUPPP)'. Ge-west and worden occur only in the sein perfect, and -werden is an infinitive, thus these forms necessarily occur in the syntagms with the lowest rates of 2-1.10 Fifth, some individuals show lower rates of the 2-1 order when the finite verb is subjunctive. Finally, the 2-1 order increases over time, and the effect of some factors (the stress of the preceding word, the lexeme of the non-finite verb) diminishes over time. In addition, most of the individuals show increasing rates of 2-1 over their lifetimes. Ebert investigates not only the linguistic factors that affect verb order with these teenagers, but also the social circumstances that may have influenced them. Although individuals show higher rates of 2-1 with increased schooling (and young men more than young women), the above factors continue to favor the 1-2 order, leading Ebert (1998: 102) to conclude that children acquired the effect of those factors on VC order from the spoken language of the time, rather than learning them in school. Moreover, Ebert (1998: 116) finds no mention of VC order in school books or grammars of the time. Ebert's (1998: 154) examination of printed texts from Nuremberg reveals much higher rates of 2-1, with only syntagm having a significant efiect on verb order. Ebert (1998: 154) concludes from this that the teenagers' increasing tendency to use the 2-1 order was influenced by contemporary printed texts, but that the factors that favor the choice of word orders are genuine features of spoken ENHG.
Bies (1996) Another recent study of ENHG word order is Bies (1996). Bies compiles a corpus of over 5,000 clauses (900 of which are subordinate clauses) mainly from letters, including material from a wide range of dialects. Assuming that ENHG, like Modern Standard German, is an underlyingly SOY language, she investigates two aspects of ENHG syntax: extraposition and the 1-2 order.
1.2.2.8
On the other hand, gewesen 'bee.O: an alternative form to gewest, has the same syntagmatic distribution but a much higher frequency of 2-1.
10.
u
12
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
In the section on extraposition, Bies (1996: 66) points out that ENHG, like Modern Standard German, allows the extraposition of clauses, PPs, and heavy NPs. Unlike Modern Standard German, however, ENHG also allows the extraposition of non-heavy NPs. When heavy NP shift has been controlled for, Bies (1996: 39) finds that NPs extrapose to force a narrow focus interpretation. This focus-driven extraposition is lost by the Modern German period (1996:65). In her study of the 1-2 order, Bies (1996:61) confirms some of Ebert's (1981) results, establishing that the rate of 1-2 falls over time and agreeing with Ebert that ENHG is undergoing a change from above. Although Bies (1996:54) determines only a weak effect of social class, she does find a significant effect of style, with higher rates of 1-2 in "less monitored styles': She also generally confirms Ebert's hierarchy of syntagms. However, Bies disputes some other results of Ebert. First, Bies (1996:59) finds that the stress of the word preceding the VC has no significant impact on the order of verbs. She believes that this may be "due to a comparison of unlike objects across corpora" (1996:60).11 Secondly, Bies (1996:60) concludes that the placement of the VC within the clause is insignificant, i.e. extraposition has no effect on verb order. However, her data do show an effect of extraposition on word order, if one looks at different types of extraposition separately. In Bies' Table 17 (1996:61), the 1-2 order occurs more often than expected with an extraposed NP (37.1% versus the expected rate of27.3%), whereas extraposed PPs have the 1-2 order at 29.2%, close to the expected rate. Reifsnyder (2003) Reifsnyder (2003) is a study of the ENHG dialect of Augsburg, using a corpus with a wide variety of text types from the period 1500-1660. Her study covers orthographic, morphological, and syntactic variation in Augsburg, with the three syntactic variables being double negation, position of the verb within the clause (i.e. extraposition), and order within the VC. Only the results for the latter variable will be discussed here. There are three factors that affect verb order in her study. First, as in previous studies, Reifsnyder (2003: 229) finds a general decline of 1-2 over time. Secondly, Reifsnyder (2003: 224-225) confirms the importance of text type for verb order. The text types assumed to be removed from the spoken languagechronicles, city ordinances, letters from schoolmasters, official letters and reports, and printed pamphlets-have the lowest rates of the 1-2 order. Personal letters, personal narratives, and guild books are assumed to be most reflective of the 1.2.2.9
11. My own study, like Bies, finds no such effect across dialects in ENHG, but like Ebert I find the effect in particular dialects (see Chapter 3.2.3.2).
Chapter 1. Introduction
spoken language and indeed have the highest rates of 1-2. Thirdly, Reifsnyder (2003: 226-227) determines an effect of clause type: clauses starting with a whword or with the relative complementizer so have the highest rates of 2-1. For Reifsnyder (2003:245), the prevalence of the 2-1 order in official texts, as well as its increasing frequency over time, is the result of the adoption of a standard language ideology. Summary Because traditional philological study of MHG concentrated on the poetic language of the most famous literary works, the study of its prose syntax has only begun to receive much attention, for example by Prell (2001). There is a larger body of scholarship on ENHG syntax, although tew studies address word order within the verbal complex. The studies that do treat the relative order of verbs are all incomplete in some sense. Hammarstrom (1923) investigates a variety of texts over the whole ENHG period, but does not take dialect differences into account. Maurer (1926) covers a wide range of dialects but has tew tokens from each text. Moreover, these early studies do not use any kind of test for statistical significance. Hard (1981) uses a very large corpus of three-verb complexes but ignores those with only two verbs altogether. Ebert (1981, 1998) treats only two-verb clusters and only in writings from Nuremberg, and Reifsnyder (2003) does the same for Augsburg. Bies (1996) looks at two-verb dusters from a broader geographic distribution but does not give detailed information on dialect differences. Finally, only Ebert (1981, 1998) pays serious attention to the factors that favor particular orders. In attempting to establish linguistic factors that afiect word order in the VC, the following factors are discussed by more than one of these studies: syntagm type, rhythm, extra position, prefix type, dialect, sociolinguistic factors, and Latin influence. However, no study to date has tested all of these factors against each other using a large corpus and sophisticated statistical tools. The historical studies presented in Chapters 2 and 3 attempt to fill this gap in the research by including a wide variety of prose texts from many dialects, addressing clusters of two and three verbs, and statistically testing multiple linguistic and social factors.
1.2.2.10
1.2.3
The verbal complex in contemporary German
Like the previous scholarship on word order in ENHG, studies of contemporary German verb order have focused almost exclusively on extraposition. It is relatively rare to find a description of a German dialect that gives details on the relative order of the verbs. Even rarer is a discussion of the linguistic factors that influence VC order. (Those few studies that do address these phenomena will be
13
14
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
discussed in detail in Chapter 4 below.) Thus the chapter on Modern German seeks to broaden the synchronic description of these orders in present-day standard and dialectal German. Moreover, since the phenomena investigated are the same as for ENHG, the study of the contemporary language allows for a better understanding of the diachronic developments involved.
1.3
Organization
The remainder of this book is organized as follows. Chapter 2 treats verb order in subordinate clauses in Middle High German (1050-1350), based on a database compiled from the Bochumer Mittelhochdeutschkorpus. Chapter 3 examines similar phenomena in Early New High German (1350-1650) using the Bonner Frithneuhochdeutschkorpus. These chapters establish the frequencies of the various word orders, the linguistic factors that favor them, and their diachronic, dialectal, and sociolinguistic distributions. Chapter 4 covers Modern Standard German and several contemporary dialects of German. After reviewing existing descriptions of these varieties, the chapter presents three new studies: a questionnaire-based study of word order in Austrian dialects and Swabian, a more detailed questionnaire study of the effect of focus on these orders in Zurich German, and a Magnitude Estimation study of Standard German word order. This will allow a comparison with the data from MHG and ENHG. Note that Chapters 2 through 4 are primarily descriptive in nature, and I attempt to avoid terminology that assumes a particular syntactic analysis. Therefore, purely descriptive labels such as 1-2 and 1-x-2 are used instead of the more familiar terms Verb Raising and Verb Projection Raising, which imply an analysis like that of Haegeman (1992). Likewise, in these descriptive chapters the term extra position should not be taken to imply a specific analysis (such as rightward movement), but instead is used to simply describe the occurrence of a constituent to the right of the verbal complex. Chapter 5 builds on the descriptive and empirical work of the previous chapters to addresses the theoretical aspects of this research. The two primary goals of this chapter are to establish the best analysis of German clause structure and to determine the nature of the relationship between focus, prosody, and word order in the VC. At that point, I will make more explicit assumptions about the syntax of these word orders. Chapter 6 concludes the book, summarizing the most important findings and discussing their broader synchronic and diachronic implications for German word order.
CHAPTER 2
Factors influencing verb order in MHG
2.1
Introduction
2.1.1
Basic facts
Middle High German (MHG) is a term that encompasses central and southern dialects of German from approximately 1050 to 1350. MHG is often associated with the courtly poetry of the high Middle Ages in the German -speaking realms, and many previous descriptions of the language are based primarily on this narrow range of texts. This was the case, for example, with the first twenty-four editions of the standard Mittelhochdeutsche Grammatik edited by Hermann Paul et al., although the twenty-fifth edition of the Mittelhochdeutsche Grammatik (Paul 2007) and the new grammar by Klein et al. (to appear) are based on a much wider variety of text types, including both verse and prose texts. In the present study; only prose texts are analyzed, since rhyme and meter could have effects on word order in the verbal complex that might not be present in prose or in everyday speech. In MHG, subordinate clauses are generally distinguishable from main clauses by word order (Paul 2007: 396).1 This certainly holds true in the texts examined here: of the 1,133 subordinate clauses analyzed in this study, only 52 have the finite verb in the second position of the clause. Within the verbal complex, there are three possible orderings when the VC consists of two verbs. In the 2-1 order, the finite verb follows the non-finite verb (1), which is the dominant order according to this study and Paul (2007: 455). Also possible is the 1-2 order as in (2), in which the finite verb immediately precedes the non-finite verb. When the finite verb precedes, a non-verbal constituent may be found between the two verbs (1-x-2) as seen in (3).
As in Modern German, there are also subordinate clauses which are not introduced by a conjunction; these are verb-first or verb-second and often use the subjunctive mood (Paul 2007: 400-401 ). Because the object of this study is the clause-final VC, unintroduced subordinate clauses will not be treated further.
1.
16
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
(1) (wier daz volk verflvchet) daz got gefegent het. how he the people cursed, REL God blessed 2 had 1 '(How he cursed the people) whom God had blessed: (Buch der KlJnige 04va) (2) (alle die) den got gewalt ufi geriht hat verlihen. all those REL God power and rule has 1 granted2 '(all those) whom God has granted power and rule: (Buch der KiJnige OSra) (3) (daz dv vnf vergrebest) swaz wir vbelf heten an dir geta.n. that you us torgive REL we evil had1 to you done2 '( ... that you forgive us) whatever evil we have done to you:
(Buch der KlJnige 03va) A fourth logically possible order would be for the verbs to be in the order 2-1 but with an intervening constituent. This order is unattested in my MHG corpus.2 Thus MHG follows the generalization tor the West Germanic verb-raising languages discussed in Chapter 4.2.5, that no constituents can intervene between the verbs when in the left-governing (2-1) order. In addition to variation in the position of the verbs relative to each other, the verbs need not be in the clause-final position. Some constituents may follow the VC, and this extraposition can occur regardless of the relative order of the verbs (4a-b), even with the 1-x-2 construction (4c). (4) a.
Do iofeph gelebt het hvnd't iar vn zehn iar when ]. lived2 had1 hundred years and ten years 'When Joseph had lived 110 years .. : (Buch der KlJnige 03vb)
b.
alf and' din genoz hant getan. in Ierufalem ... as other your companions have 1 done 2 in ]. 'as other companions of yours have done in Jerusalem
c.
daz ein iclich man hie ... fal vrfdf habi in fimf huis ... that an every man here shall1 peace have2 in his house 'that every man here ... shall have peace in his house
(Buch der Konige 10va)
(Mahlhauser R. b2ra)
2. The only item that may come between the verbs in the 2-1 order is the negative particle ne-, which may be prefixed to the auxiliary:
(i)
(Neheine zungen ... ne fint) da iro predige gehoret tae fin. no tongues NEG are where their sermons heard2 NEG are 1 '(There are no languages) where their sermons are not heard.' (Notker 030ra)
This construction occurs in the two earliest texts in the database, Notker and Williram (which could be considered late OHG), and in four other texts. If one treats the particle as being part of verbal morphology. these are straightforward examples of the 2-1 order.
Chapter 2. Factors influencing verb order in MHG
VCs with three verbs are much rarer, but also display variation within the complex. Four of the six logically possible orders are attested in my MHG database: there is one instance of the 3-2-1 order (5), five of the 1-3-2 order (6), seven of the 1-2-3 order (7), and ten of3-1-2 (8):
(5) uuanta er geb6ran uutrdan uuolta uon armen u6rderon. wanted 1 of poor ancestors because he born3 be2 (Williram lOr) 'because he [Christ] wanted to be born of humble origins: (6) daz elliv werlt die er gefaphen Mte. folti verlorn werdfn. that all world REL he created had should 1 lost3 be2 'that the whole world that he had created should be lost: (Speculum eccL 08r) (7) wie er och Joelte wtie gemarterot an de (heiligen) cvce. how he also should 1 be2 martyred3 on the holy cross '... how he should also be martyred on the holy cross:
(Schwarzw. Pred. 009v) (8) daz daz chint befnitin folti werdin. that the child circumcised3 should1 b~ '... so that the child should be circumcised .. .'
(Speculum eccL llv)
These four orders are also reported for MHG by Paul (2007:456). In addition, extraposition can occur with these VCs, and there are three instances where a constituent intervenes within a 1-3-2 cluster: (9) daz fiv niene mahti mit handen gervoret wtiin ... that she not could 1 with hands touched3 be2 'that it could not be touched with hands .. : (Zaricher Pr. lOSva) The other two logically possible orders for three-verb clusters, 2-1-3 and 2-3-1, are unattested in my MHG database. (10) *uuanta er uutrdan 2 uuolta1 geb6ran3 (11) *uuantaer uutrdan 2 geb6ran3 uuolta 1 There are no instances of a VC with four verbs in the database, which should come as no surprise given the scarcity of three-verb complexes.
2.1.2
The database
The MHG database analyzed in this study consists of 1,133 subordinate clauses. These clauses are taken from thirteen prose texts of the Bochumer Mittelhochdeutschkorpus (BoMiKo). Although the BoMiKo has many more prose texts than this, this selection of texts attempts to represent one text from each century and
17
18
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
dialect in the corpus. In some cases, there is no text in the corpus for a given century/dialect, and in other cases, the text for a century/dialect was not analyzed because it is a gloss and thus might not be a reliable source for analyzing syntax. Where a century/dialect has more than one appropriate text and one of those was a sermon, I chose the sermon so that the database would have texts most reflective of spoken language. Table I. Texts in my MHG database3 Dialect
1070-1100
1150-1200
1250-1300
Bavarian
Wiener Notker
Physilogus Speculum ecdesiae
Buch der KCJnige Stadtbuch Augsburg
Ztlricher Predigten
Schwarzwalder Predigten Satzungsbuch Ntlrnberg
Swabian, ind W. Bavarian Alemannic East Franconian
Williram
(1302-1315) Middle Franconian Hessian Thuringian
Frankfurter Predigtfragmente
DieLilie Mitteldeutsche Predigten Mtlhlhauser Reichsrechtsbuch
Clauses were selected for the database if they are introduced by a subordinating conjunction or relative pronoun and contain at least one finite and one non-finite verb (except for embedded infinitival clauses).4 Of the 1,133 subordinate clauses in the database, 1,109 clauses have two verbs, 23 have three verbs, and one was excluded from analysis because it contained two finite verbs (like example (15) in Chapter 3). In the case of shorter texts, the entire text was analyzed, and from longer texts the first 100 or so relevant clauses were analyzed. The number of clauses taken from each text ranges from 28 to 107, with an average of 87.2 clauses per text. Each clause in the database was coded for the following variables: verb order (the dependent variable), syntagm type, constituent preceding the VC, constituent intervening in the VC, constituent following the VC, focus type (new vs. contrastive), focused constituent, whether an intervening constituent is part of the focus,
3· For complete philological information about these texts and others in the corpus, see Wegera (2000). 4· Because of the ambiguity between relative and demonstrative pronouns in German, apparently relative clauses with V2 are ambiguous with main clauses (Paul 2007: 396). Likewise, wande 'because' may be either a coordinating or subordinating conjunction (Paul2007: 396). Clauses introduced by a (relative) pronoun or wande were included in the database, but any V2 clauses were tagged as such.
Chapter 2. Factors influencing verb order in MHG
whether an extraposed constituent is part of the focus, prefix type, scrambled object, and verb second.s Each text in the database was tagged for century, dialect, genre, and the sex, occupation, and education of the author. 2.1.3 Analysis with GoldVarb X
The analyses were conducted using the statistics package GoldVarb X (Sankoff et al. 2005). This program was originally developed for sociolinguistic studies, and allows the researcher to determine the extent of the effect of several independent variables (linguistic and sociolinguistic factors) on a dependent variable. GoldVa.rb can be a useful tool in historical linguistics as well, since time can be treated as an independent variable. Sets of independent variables are called factor groups, and each value of the variable is called a factor. For example, syntagm is a factor group with the factors passive, perfect, modal-infinitive, etc. A powerful feature of GoldVarb is the ability to recode the factors during the analysis. If the researcher is not certain whether a particular distinction will be significant, e.g. the difference between present perfect and pluperfect, they can be initially tagged as separate factors. Then during the course of the analysis, one can recode, combining these specific factors into more general ones, and test which combination has the most significant effect. There are three statistical outputs of GoldVarb X that will be utilized in this chapter. The first is statistical significance. Note that this represents the statistical significance of the entire factor group, e.g. syntagm, but does not indicate which factor or factors have the significant effect For that, one has to look at the second output, the factor weight. The factor weight is expressed as a probability between 0 and 1, with 0.5 indicating no effect. The further the factor weight is from 0.5, the greater that factor's effect is on the dependent variable. Finally, GoldVarb has a step-up/step-down analysis, which tests all possible combinations of factor groups to determine which combination results in the most statistically significant model. For details on GoldVarb, see Tagliamonte (2006).
2.1.4
Organization of this c.hapter
This chapter is organized as follows. Section 2.2 presents the results of the analysis of the MHG database for complexes of two verbs, and Section 2.3 presents the results for complexes of three verbs. This chapter is concluded in Section 2.4. 5· Two additional factors, clause type and VP coordination, had no effect and will not be discussed further here.
19
20
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
2.2
Complexes of two verbs in MHG
2.2.1
Introduction
My MHG database contains 1,109 subordinate clauses with one finite and one non-finite verb. Ofthose, 320 clauses (28.9%) have the 1-2 (or the 1-x-2) order.6, 7 Thus a rate of 1-2 higher than 28.9% in a given context indicates that the order is favored in that context, which should be expressed as a factor weight greater than 0.5 by GoldVarb. In Section 2.2.2, I discuss the linguistic factors that affect verb order: syntagm type, the category and weight of the word preceding the VC, extraposition, focus, and verbal prefixes. Section 2.2.3 discusses variation in the rate of the 1-2 order over time, across dialects, and sociolinguistically. Of the factors that have a significant aftect on verb order, six were selected by GoldVarb's step-up/step-down function as the most significant combination of factors: syntagm, constituent before the VC, focus, dialect, genre, and occupation.
2.2.2
Phonological, morphological, and syntactic factors
2.2.2.1
Syntagm type
Many previous studies of historical and contemporary West Germanic dialects have shown a correlation between VC order and syntagm type. In modern varieties that have some word -order freedom, there is a general tendency to have 2-1 in constructions with participles and 1-2 in those involving infinitives (Wurmbrand 2006: 237; Chapter 4 below). As shown in Table 2 below, MHG follows this trend. The syntagms are listed in order of the rate of 1-2, from least frequent to most frequent. The passives are the least likely to have the 1-2 order, occurring less often that the total rate of 1-2 and with low factor weights. The perfects have the 1-2 order very close to the expected rate of 28.7%. The modal-infinitive syntagm somewhat favors 1-2 at 35.5%, while other syntagms with an infinitive favor that order even more strongly. (In addition, there are a handful of instances of the progressive, a syntagm which will be discussed in more detail in Chapter 3.2.3.1.) The effect of syntagm is statistically significant and was selected in GoldVarb's step-up/step-down function as one of the most significant factor groups.
6.
Throughout this section, these two orders are treated together unless indicated otherwise.
7. This rate of the 1-2 order is quite similar to that found by Prell, in whose corpus 27.9% of the two-verb dusters are 1-2 (2001: 84, cited inPaul2007:455).
Chapter 2. Factors influencing verb order in MHG
Table 2. Effect of syntagm on 1-2 order Syntagm
2-1
1-2
Factorwt.
sein passive progressive werden passive perfect with sein perfect with haben modal +in£ other V + inf. future
127 (90.1%) 5 (83.3%) 145 (82.9%) 52 (71.2%) 181 (70.7%) 272 (64.5%) 7 (25.9%) 0 (0%)
14 (9.9%) 1 (16.7%) 30 (17.1 %) 21 (28.8%) 75 (29.3%) 150 (35.5%) 20 (74.1%) 6 (100%)
0.233 0.355 0.362 0.526 0.532 0.602 0.887
Total
789 (71.3%)
317 (28.7%)
n/a
p < 0.001 These numbers are very similar to Prell's (2001) findings for MHG (see Chapter 1.2.2.2).8 The hierarchy from my MHG corpus (12a) can be compared to those found by Prell (12b): ( 12) a. b.
sein pass. > werden pass. > sein perf. > haben pert~ > modals sein pass. > werden pass. > pedtd > modals (Prel12001: 85, cited in Paul 2007: 455-456)
In both my MHG study and Prell (2001), the statal passive with sein has the 1-2 order considerably less often than the werden passive does. Other than that, the hierarchies are similar to that in ENHG, all showing the general pattern of passive> perfect> modal. Note also that this is likely a genuine effect of syntagm independently of the effect of the auxiliary or the type of non-finite verb (participle vs. infinitive): both the sein passive and sein perfect involve the auxiliary sein plus a participle, yet the two syntagms show quite difierent word order preferences. 2.2.2.2
Word/phrase preceding the verbal complex
Ebert (1981: 206) finds that the distinction noun vs. pronoun influences verb order in ENHG texts from Nuremberg. In this section, we examine whether the preceding word, not only noun vs. pronoun but other categories as well, has any effect in MHG. First of all, let us see what effect the previous word may have on the VC in terms of category. As shown in Table 3, a preceding non-pronominal noun phrase ("noun'') favors the 1-2 order at 36.4%, well above the expect rate of 1-2 (28.7%).
8. Recall from Chapter 1 that my database overlaps with Prell's by five texts.
21
22
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Quantified NPs behave similarly. On the other hand, pronouns occur with the 1-2 order only 22% of the time, somewhat less than expected.9 Table 3. Effect of the category of the preceding word on 1-2 order Class of preceding word
2-1
1-2
Factorwt.
noun pronoun quantified NP adjective adverb prepositional phrase stranded preposition clause (infinitival or finite) nothing precedes Totallo
185 (63.6%) 202 (78.0%) 27 (64.3%) 15 (53.6%) 162 (76.8%) 170 (74.2%) 7 (77.8%) 2 (66.6%) 18 (64.3%)
106 (36.4%) 57 (22.0%) 15 (35.7%) 13 (46.4%) 49 (23.2%) 59 (25.8%) 2 (22.2%) 1 (33.3%) 10 (35.7%)
0.593 0.418 0.586 0.688 0.435 0.469 0.421 0.560 0.586
788 (71.6%)
312 (28.4%)
p < 0.001 In addition to non-pronominal NPs, adjectives strongly favor the 1-2 order. Both of the remaining frequently occurring categories, adverbs and prepositional phrases, have rates that are close to or slightly below the expected rate of 1-2. (Possible reasons for the effect of stranded prepositions and clauses with nothing preceding the VC will be discussed in more detail in Chapter 3.2.3.2.) This raises the question of why the category of the preceding word should have any effect on verb order. Ebert (1981: 207), who found similar effects in ENHG, attributed the differing effect of nouns and pronouns on verb order to phonological stress. This is based on an earlier claim by Behaghel (1932:IV, 87), that the combination of a stressed word such as a noun plus a VC with the 1-2 order produces the sequence heavy word, light word, heavy word, while the combination of a light word plus verbs in the 2-1 order produces the alternation light, heavy, light According to this claim, other combinations result in disfavored sequences of two stressed words or two unstressed words. To test this claim, I recoded pronouns, short adverbs, the negator, and da-compounds as unstressed and other categories as stressed. As can be seen in Table 4, the rate of 1-2 is somewhat higher
9· Throughout this section, "NP" includes both nouns and pronouns. When pronouns are meant to be excluded, the terms "noun" or "non-pronominal NP" will be used No distinction will be made between NP and DP.
The total for this table is lower because the analysis excludes six cases where the preceding "word" was a verbal prefix.
10.
Chapter 2. Factors influencing verb order in MHG
than expected following a stressed word (34%) and somewhat lower following an unstressed word, confirming Behaghel's claim. Table 4. Effect of the stress of the preceding word on 1-2 order Stress of preceding word
2-1
1-2
Factorwt.
stressed unstressed Totaln
420 (66.0%)
216 (34.0%)
0.570
351 (79.4%)
91 (20.6%)
0.401
771 (71.5%)
307 (28.7%)
p < 0.001 Alternatively, the differing effect of nouns versus pronouns on verb order could be due to a difterence in definiteness. As seen in Table 5, when the preceding NP is indefinite (including QPs withjeder, kein, aile), the rate of 1-2 is much higher than expected at 42.4%, but when it is definite (including pronouns and proper names), the rate is close to the expected rate. Thus, definiteness could partially explain the differing behavior of nouns versus pronouns. Table 5. Effect of definiteness of the preceding NP on 1- 2 order Preceding NP
2-1
1-2
Factorwt.
indefinites (including QPs) definites
57 (57.696)
42 (42.496)
0.634
357 (72.4%)
136 (27.6%)
0.473
Total
414 (69.996)
178 (30.196)
p = 0.005 However, there are two arguments against the possibility that definiteness accounts for the noun/pronoun distinction found in Table 3. First, note that the results in Table 5, although statistically significant, have a lower p score than those in Table 3 or 4. Secondly, in GoldVarb's step-up/step-down analysis, the factor group preceding constituent is selected as one of the most significant factor groups when coded by part of speech or heaviness, but not when coded by definiteness. The log likelihood (an output of GoldVarb indicating the best model fit for a combination of factor groups) was worst with this factor group coded by definiteness (-494.350), better when coded by part of speech (-484.571 ), and best when coded by weight (-480.682). Therefore, definiteness is the least likely reason for the effect of the preceding constituent on the order of verbs within the VC, and heaviness is the most likely reason, confirming Behaghefs ( 1932) hypothesis.
The totals for this table are lower because the analysis excludes cases where no word precedes the verbal complex.
11.
23
24
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
2.2.2.3
Extraposition
As mentioned above, although the VC tends to be clause-final in MHG, some constituent (or more rarely, more than one constituent) may appear be extraposed, i.e., located to the right of the VC (Paul2007: 458). Based on the high frequency of extra position, Lehman claims that medieval German is an SVO language, unlike the SOV structure of Modern Standard German (1971: 19). Because the 2-1 order is frequently associated with SOV typology (Greenberg 1963: 85), one might expect non-SOV clauses (i.e. those with extraposition) to have the 1-2 order. As can be seen in Table 6, there is indeed such a correlation.12 This is a statistically significant factor group, although it was not selected as one of the most significant groups in the step-up/step-down analysis. Table 6. Effect of extraposition on 1- 2 order Extraposition
2-1
1-2
Factorwt.
extraposed argument NP/PP extraposed adjunct PP nothing extraposed
34 (55.7%) 109 (69.4%) 602 (73.4%)
27 (44.3%) 48 (30.6%) 218 (26.6%)
0.670 0.530 0.481
Total
745 (71.8%)
293 (28.2%)
p = 0.014 When there is no extraposed constituent, the rate of the 1-2 order is 26.6%, slightly less than the expected rate. Likewise, when an adjunct PP is extraposed, the rate of the 1-2 order is slightly greater than expected at 30.6%; the factor weight, being close to 0.5, indicates that extraposed adjunct PPs have very little effect on the order of the verbs. On the other hand, an extraposed argument (including both NPs and PPs) favors the 1-2 order at 44.3%, considerably higher than expected, with the factor weight indicating a strong effect. Similar results have been found for ENHG (see Chapter 3). Finally, of the 1,106 clauses in the MHG database, 218 have some extraposed constituent, yielding a rate of extraposition of 19.7%. This is consistent with the data for MHG reported in Prell (2001), who also finds higher rates of 1-2 with extra position. 2.2.2.4
Focus
A constituent is considered to be focused if it introduces new information into the discourse or is contrastive. Note that focus is not identical to stress: 12. When extraposition is broken down into the category of the extraposed constituent (NPs versus pronouns, etc.) the result was not statistically significant (p = 0.063). Note that Table 6 excludes the following low frequency types: multiple extraposed constituents, extraposed adjective, extraposed comparison, and extraposed second conjunct
Chapter 2. Factors influencing verb order in MHG
although a focused constituent may be stressed, a given stress pattern can often be associated with different focus interpretations. This can be illustrated using a Modern German example, in which a single sentence with the same stress (indicated with all capitals) can answer very different questions: in (13a) only the object is new to the discourse and thus focused, while in (13b) the entire clause is focused: (13) a.
What did Karl give to the child yesterday? Gestern hat Karl dem Kind [poe das BUCH) geschenkt. yesterday has K. the child the book given b. What happened yesterday? Gestern hat [Foe Karl dem Kind das BUCH geschenkt]. 'Karl gave the book to the child yesterday.' (Stechow & Sternefeld 1988:461)
In order to test the effect of focus on word order in the VC, each clause in the database was examined within its section (or within one or two pages, if the text was not divided into sections) in order to determine what elements of the clause are contrastive or discourse-new. The clause was then tagged as having focus on the entire clause (14a), the subject, the object (14b), the verb, the VP (14c), or some other constituent. (14) a.
[Foe
daz di fvginden kint durch vnfirs h'ren willen our Lord's sake that the nursing children tor
worden irjlagfn.] were 1 killed 2 '(the day) that the infants were killed because of our Lord:
(Mitteldt. Pred. alra) b.
die !Foe finin willin ] heton getan. his will had1 done 2 'who had done his will' daz ir [Foe fin' gutdete muzit gen{zen ]. that you his good.deeds might1 enjoy2 'that you might enjoy his good deeds'
REL
c.
(Zaricher Pr. 109rb)
(Mitteldt. Pred. a1ra)
Moreover, the focused constituent was characterized as representing newinformation focus or contrastive focus. If there were no new or contrastive constituents, the clause was tagged as old information. Table 7 presents the results for focus, regardless of which constituent is focused. Both new and contrastive focus favor the 1-2 order at 33.7% and 31%, respectively, slightly higher than the expected rate of 28.7%, while clauses with all old information disfavor 1-2. However, unlike ENHG (see Chapter 3.2.3.4) where the favoring effect of contrastive focus was stronger than that of new
25
26
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
information, in MHG there is little difference between the two types of focus.B (Although statistically significant, this factor group was not selected as one of the most significant in GoldVarb's step-up/step-down analysis, probably because it largely overlaps with the next group.) Table 7. Effect of focus on 1-2 order (general) Focus
2-1
1-2
Factorwt.
contrastive focus new information focus old information
49 (69.0%) 490 (66.3%) 250 (84.5%)
22 (31.0%) 249 (33.7%) 46 (15.5%)
0.539 0.569 0.324
Total
789 (71.3%)
317 (28.7%)
p < 0.001 Having established that focus in general has an effect on the order within the VC, the next factor group is the particular constituent that is focused. As seen in the table below, focus on an object is the most favorable context for the 1-2 order at 50.7%, well above the expected rate of 28.7%. The other favoring focus context is focus on the entire clause, which has the 1-2 order 38.3% of the time. Two other contexts, VP focus and focus on some other constituent (e.g. an adjunct) have the 1-2 order somewhat more frequently than expected, but neither has a factor weight much above 0.5, indicating at most a slight favoring effect. Finally, verb focus and subject focus disfavor the 1-2 order. This factor group was selected as one of the most significant in the step-up/step down analysis. Table 8. Effect of focus on 1-2 order (specific constituents) Focus constituent
2-1
1-2
Factorwt.
object focus clausal focus VP focus focus on another constituent verb focus subject focus nothing (old information)
34 (49.3%) 71 (61.7%) 158 (65.6%) 74 (67.3%) 185 (73.4%) 17 (73.9%) 250 (84.5%)
35 (50.7%) 44 (38.3%) 83 (34.4%) 36 (32.7%) 67 (26.6%) 6 (26.1%) 46 (15.5%)
0.684 0.566 0.525 0.506 0.433 0.426 0.470
Total
789 (71.3%)
317 (28.7%)
p < 0.001
13. New and contrastive focus appear to behave similarly for a given focus constituent as well, although there are too few examples of each type of contrastively focused constituent to draw any firm conclusions.
Chapter 2. Factors influencing verb order in MHG
To corroborate the effect of object focus on the 1-2 order, two related factors were tested. The first, the definiteness of an NP, was presented above in Table 5, which demonstrates a strong and significant correlation between indefinite NPs and the 1-2 order. Because indefinite NPs tend to be discourse-new and thus focused, while definite NPs generally represent old information, the correlation between definiteness and verb order may support the finding that focus effects verb order. The second factor that correlates to focus is scrambling; however, there were too few examples of this in the database to draw any conclusions. Finally, let us examine the interaction between focus on an object, the position of that object relative to the VC, and verb order. First let us examine cases where a constituent intervenes in the VC, i.e. the 1-x-2 order. There are 35 instances of this construction in the MHG database. Only two of these, as in (15), involve narrow focus on only the intervening constituent, so clearly, this is not a typical position for narrow focus. Perhaps crucially, both of these are ambiguous between a relative clause with 1-x-2 order and a main clause, as the relative pronoun is homophonous with the demonstrative. In 15 instances, the intervening constituent and some other constituent (usually the lexical verb) are focused, thus this construction may be used to focus the VP or a larger projection such as the entire clause. In (16), the focus, indicated in brackets, is on all of the clause except the subject pronoun. In the remaining 18 instances. there is VP or clausal focus but the intervening constituent is not part of the focus, as in (17), where the pronoun 'you' is mentioned in the matrix clause.
Jolte [poe ane vlecken] fin (15) (efn lfip flahen.) daz a lamb slaughter REL/DEM should 1 without spots be 2 'slaughter a lamb, which should be without spots .. .' 'slaughter a lamb. That should be without spots .. .' (Mitteldt. Pred. b4ra) (16) daz fi [Foe fnden oitem }olden efn lap flahen]. that they in the Easter should 1 a lamb slaughter 2 '... that they should slaughter a lamb at Easter (Mitteldt. Pred. b4ra) wir [poe vbeli] heten an dir geta.n. (17) ... swaz whatever we evil had on you done '( ... we ask you to forgive) whatever evil we have done to you.'
(Buch der KiJnige 03va) Thus it appears that the position between the two parts of the VC has two functions: the constituent there may be part of wide focus or it may be defocused. That position, however, is very unlikely to be a focus position.14 14. No statistical analysis is possible, since intervening constituents are necessarily found with only one word-order type, 1-x-2.
27
28
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
The relationship between focus and extraposition is less clear. Extraposed constituents may be narrowly focused (18), part of wider (usually VP) focus (19), or defocused (20). (18)
(div bihte.) die wir tun fuln [Foe untern priftern]. the confession REL we do 2 should 1 our priests '(the confession) which we should make to our priests:
(19)
die
(Mitteldt. Pred. b4va-b) dir tievil hate gebvndin mit den fvndon]. REL the devil had 1 bound2 with the sins whom the devil had bound by sin: [Foe
(Zitricher Fred. b4ra)
(20) alf fi wol [Foe verdinet] hat an dem armen manne. as she well deserved2 has 1 on the poor man 'as she [Jezebel] well deserved because of the poor
man:
(Buch der KCln ige 07vb) As seen in Table 9 below, 48 of the extraposed constituents are defocused,lS 59 are narrowly focused, and 111 are part of a wider focus projection. Neither the extra position of defocused nor of narrowly focused constituents has an effect on verb order, since the rates of 1-2 are similar in these contexts to the expected rate and the factor weights are close to 0.5. However, when an extraposed constituent is part of wider focus, the 1-2 order is favored at 40.5%, well above the expected frequency. Thus, the conclusion from Section 2.2.2.3 above that extra position of an argument has an effect on verb order must be revised somewhat: instead, it appears that extraposition of an argument that is part ofVP focus favors 1-2. Table 9. Effect of the focus of an e.x:traposed constituent on 1-2 order Extraposed constituent
2-1
1-2
Factorwt.
not focused narrowly focused part ofVP focus nothing extraposed
34 (70.8%) 43 (72.9%) 66 (59.5%) 602 (73.4%)
14 (29.2%) 16 (27.1%) 45 (40.5%) 218 (26.6%)
0.513 0.488 0.636 0.481
Total
745 (71.8%)
293 (28.2%)
p = 0.034
15. Of the defocused extraposed constituents, most are adjunct PPs, leaving only 26 cases where a non-focused argument is extraposed.. Recall from Section 2.2.2.3 above that adjunct PPs extrapose at higher rates than other types of constituents in MHG and also in Modern German.
Chapter 2. Factors influencing verb order in MHG
Summing up this section, it seems that focus on an object plays some role in determining verb order. Narrowly focused, unscrambled, and indefinite NPs favor the 1-2 order, while wide focus favors the 1-x-2 orders and the 1-2 order with extraposition. However, because focus is associated with stress, it is difficult to determine whether these are effects of focus pet· se or of the phonological manifestation of focus. In Chapter 5, we will see that stress turns out to be the best way of accounting for the relationship between focus and word order. 2.2.2.5
Prefix type
The continental West Germanic languages have two kinds of verbal prefixes: unstressed prefixes such as ge- (21a), and stressed, separable prefixes (also known as converbs or verbal particles), most of which are derived from prepositions (21b ). (21) a. b.
daz got gefegent het REL God blessed2 had 1 daz im Ionathaf wa.z ab gega.nge. that him Jonathan was 1 away-gone 2 'that J. had departed him'
(cf. (1a) above)
(Buch der KiJnige 12rb)
The stressed prefixes tend to be adjacent to the verb when the verb is in the clausefinal position (usually appearing as prefixes, hence the name) but may also be stranded in clause final position when the head verb is finite and in the V2 position. Prell (2001:87) finds that stressed separable prefixes favor the 1-2 order, and Ebert (1981: 207; 1998 passim) has similar results from ENH G. Therefore, the present study tests whether the effect in MHG is significant. As can be seen in Table 10, my MHG database, like Prell's, shows a favoring eftect of stressed-prefix verbs on the 1-2 order, which occurs 40.4% of the time in that context, considerably higher than the total rate of 28.7%. In addition, verbs with no prefix also favor the 1-2 order at 38.1 %. Thus the most important distinction is between verbs with a stressed or no prefix, which favor 1-2, and verbs with an unstressed prefix, which slightly disfavor 1-2. Table 10. Effect of prefix type on 1-2 order Prefix type
2-1
1-2
Factorwt.
stressed no prefix unstressed Total p < 0.001
31 (59.6%) 203 (61.9%) 555 (76.4%)
21 (40.4%) 125 (38.1%) 171 (23.6%)
0.620 0.547 0.470
789 (71.3%)
317 (28.7%)
29
30
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
This state of affairs suggests that it is not prefixation per se that affects word order, but rather the syntagms involved. Past participles typically have the unstressed prefixge-, while infinitives may have no prefix, a stressed prefix, or an unstressed prefix. Therefore, the apparent preference for the 2-1 order with unstressed prefixes may be because many of these are syntagms with participles, which favor the 2-1 order (Section 2.2.2.1 above). In fact, of the 726 verbs with an unstressed prefix, 396 have the prefix ge-. The interaction between syntagm type and prefix type may explain why only one of these two factors, syntagm, was selected during the step-up/step-down analysis as one of the most significant factor groups. This kind of interaction can be tested using the cross-tabulation function of GoldVarb. The cross-tabulation of prefix type and syntagm type, given in Table 11, suggests that the factors prefix type and syntagm type overlap to a great extent but are still independent of each other. For all three factors in the factor group prefix type, the frequency of 1-2 is higher with infinitival constructions (54%, 39%, and 33% respectively) than with participial constructions (27%, 24%, and 21%, respectively). Likewise, for both past participles and infinitives, the frequency of 1-2 is highest with stressed prefixes (27% and 54% respectively), lower with no prefix (24% and 39%), and lowest with unstressed prefixes (21% and 33%). Table 11. Cross-tab of prefix type with syntagm type Prefix type stressed
word order 1-2
7 (27%)
14 (54%)
21 (40%)
no prefix
2-1
35 (76%)
166 (61%)
201 (63%)
1-2
11 (24%)
107 (39%)
118 (37%)
unstressed
2-1
451 (79%)
101 (67%)
552 (77%)
1-2
122 (21%)
49 (33%)
171 (23%)
2-1
505 (78%)
279 (62%)
784 (72%)
1-2
140 (22%)
170 (38%)
310 (28%)
Total
2-1
participial syn. 19 (73%)
infinitival syn. 12 (46%)
Total 31 (60%)
In sum, the presence of a stressed separable prefix on the non-finite verb favors the 1-2 word order, and this effect is somewhat independent of syntagm type. Having discussed four internal linguistic factors that favor the 1-2 order in MHG, in the next section I will present the variation in subordinate clause word order over time, across dialects, and sociolinguistically.
Chapter 2. Factors influencing verb order in MHG
2.2.3
Diachronic, dialectal, and sociolinguistic variation
2.2.3.1
Date
As will be seen in the next chapter, the 1-2 order decreases over the course of the ENHG period from approximately 35% in the 14th century to just 11% in the 16th, disappearing by Modern Standard German. However, it appears that the decrease in ENHG begins in that period. As can be seen in Table 12, at both the beginning and end of the MHG period, rate of the 1-2 order is roughly the same as at the beginning of ENHG: about 32% and 34%, respectively. Table 12. Effect of time period on 1-2 order Century
2-1
1-2
Factorwt.
1070-1100 1150-1200 1250-130016
139 (67.8%) 253 (83.8%) 397 (66.3%)
66 (32.2%) 49 (16.2%) 202 (33.7%)
0.560 0.451 0.504
Total p < 0.001
789 (71.3%)
317 (28.7%)
On the other hand, there is an inexplicable drop in the rate of 1-2 in the middle of the MHG period. It is difficult to say whether this dip represents any linguistic reality or is merely a result of the four texts selected for this century. In any case, although the factor group is statistically significant, it was not selected as one of the most significant factor groups by GoldVarb's step-up/step-down analysis. Having seen that the 1-2 order (in the general sense that the finite verb precedes the non-finite verb) remains mostly stable throughout MHG, let us examine the difference between the 1-2 order in the narrow sense (the finite verb immediately precedes the non-finite verb) and the 1-x-2 order. As shown in Table 13, both the 1-2 order in the stricter sense and the 1-x-2 order show the same trend as in the table above, with the eleventh and thirteenth centuries roughly the same, but a drop in the twelfth century.l7 However, the frequencies of 1-x-2 and
16. Recall that the text representing this time period for Nuremberg is slightly later, having been written between 1302 and 1315.
17. Gold Varb X is not equipped for multi-variate analyses, i.e., although it can calculate the
raw nwnbers and percentages for several values of the dependent variable, it can statistically test only two values. Thus the data for 1-x-2 order are given without factor weights or statistical significance.
31
32
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
the 1-2 order in the strict sense remain very stable relative to each other, with the 1-x-2 order making up roughly 10-12% of the cases where the finite precedes the non-finite verb. Table 13. Effect of time on 1-2 and 1-x-2 orders Century
2-1
1-2
1-x-2
1070-1100 1150-1200 1250-1300
139 (67.896) 253 (83.8%) 397 (66.3%)
58 (28.396) 44 (14.6%) 180 (30.1%)
8 (3.9%) 5 (1.7%) 22 (3.7%)
Total
789 (71.3%)
282 (25.5%)
35 (3.2%)
Recall from Section 2.1.2 above that some subordinate clauses with the verb in the second position (but introduced by an unambiguously subordinating conjunction) were coded as potentially V2 in the database. This makes it possible to exclude such clauses in a GoldVat·b analysis. Excluding potential verb-second clauses is especially important in the case of 1-x-2 clauses, to rule outthe possibility that they involve main clause word order rather than true, unambiguous 1-x-2 (with more than one constituent preceding the finite verb). Excluding these subordinate clauses with possibly main clause word order results in a smaller number of 1-2 clauses (especially 1-x-2 clauses), as can be seen by comparing Table 14 with Table 13. The remaining 1-2 and 1-x-2 subordinate clauses must then be treated as true verbal complexes. Table 14. Effect of time on 1-2 and 1-x-2 orders, V2 clauses removed Century
2-1
1-2
1-x-2
1070-1100 1150-1200 1250-1300
139 (71.6%) 253 (86.3%) 397 (66.3%)
53 (27.3%) 37 (12.4%) 160 (28.0%)
2 (1.0%) 3 (1.0%) 14 (2.4%)
Total
789 (74.6%)
250 (23.6%)
19 (1.8%)
2.2.3.2
l)ialect
Having examined the relative stability of subordinate-clause verb order over time, let us now consider dialectal variation in MHG. As seen in Table 15, the frequency of the 1-2 order (in the wider sense, i.e. including 1-x-2) varies greatly by dialect, ranging from about 11% in the text from Thuringia up to 81.7% in one text from the Black Forest.
Chapter 2. Factors influencing verb order in MHG
Table 15. Effect of dialect on 1-2 order Dialect
2-1
1-2
Factorwt
Bavaria Swabia (incl. W. Bavaria) Alemannic: SwissJs Alemannic: Black Forest is
Hesse Thuringia Is
177 (68.1 %) 175 (87.5%) 86 (86.9%) 19 (18.3%) 133 (80.6%) 24 (53.3%) 84 (64.1 %) 91 (89.2%)
83 (31.9%) 25 (12.5%) 13 (13.1 %) 85 (81.7%) 32 (19.4%) 21 (46.7%) 47 (35.9%) 11 (10.8%)
0.494 0.336 0.262 0.894 0.447 0.830 0.525
Total
789 (71.3%)
317 (28.7%)
E. Franconian CologneJs
0.434
p < 0.001
There is no clear pattern here that might correspond to traditional dialect divisions: for example, the two Alemannic texts behave very differently. There is something of a geographic pattern when plotted onto a map of the German-speaking area, as in Figure 1. The three dialects with relatively high rates of 1-2 (and factor weights above 0.5) cluster along the Rhine: Black Forest, Hesse, and Cologne. However, combining these three dialects into a western group and all others into an eastern group results in a worse model fit. Moreover, note that many of these dialects are represented by just one text, so the apparent dialectal variation may be reducible to differences between individual texts.
Figure 1. Frequency of the 1-2 order by dialect
18. Each of these dialects is represented by only one text.
33
34
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Nor does one see a clear pattern when looking at the rate of 1-2 across the dialects and by century. As can be seen in Table 16, the rate of the 1-2 order increases from the 11th to the 13th century in the Bavarian texts but decreases in the East Franconian texts. With this kind of variation, it is difficult to draw any conclusions about the dialectal or diachronic distribution of 1-2 in MHG. Whatever the reason for this variation, the factor group is clearly an important one, having been selected as one of the most significant in the step-up/stepdown analysis. Table 16. Effect of dialect and century on 1-2 order
Dialect
1070-1100
1150-1200
1250-1300
Total
Bavaria
24.5%
11.7% 18.0%
41.2% 8.8%
31.9% 12.5% 13.1%
81.7% 11.1%
81.7% 19.4% 46.7%
Swabia Swiss Black Forest E. Franc. Cologne
13.1% 39.8%
Hesse Thuringia
37.0%
46.7% 35.6% 10.8%
35.9% 10.8%
2.2.3.3 Sociolinguistic factors
In several studies ofENHG syntax (Hammarstrom 1923; Ebert 1981 and 1998; Bies 1996; and Reifsnyder 2003), subordinate-clause word order varies greatly by sociolinguistic factors and text type. In my MHG database, clauses were coded for four sociolinguistic factors: the genre of the text and the sex, education, and occupation of the author. However, none of the texts in the database are written by women, and the level of education is only known for one of them. Therefore, the only factor groups that may yield any relevant results are occupation and genre. Unfortunately for the factor group occupation, the only two occupations tagged in the database are clerics and unknown. Still, these two groups have quite different word-order preferences, as seen in Table 17. The clerics have the 1-2 order somewhat more often than expected (35.7%), and the texts by authors of unknown occupation have that order somewhat less than expected (19%). Although this effect is not a very strong one, as evidenced by the fact that the factor weight in both cases is very dose to 0.5, it is statistically significant and was even selected as one of the most important factor groups in the step-up/ step-down analysis.
Chapter 2. Factors influencing verb order in MHG
Table 17. Effect of occupation on 1-2 order Occupation (number of texts)
2-1
1-2
Factorwt.
clerics (7) unknown(6)
410 (64.6%) 379 (81.0%)
228 (35.7%) 89 (19.0%)
0.508 0.490
Total
789 (71.3%)
317 (28.7%)
p < 0.001 Genre was also selected by step-up/step-down as one of the most significant factor groups. All texts in the database were tagged as one of four types: chronicle, chancery document, sermon, and other religious text, and the effect of these text types on word order is presented in Table 18. The most formal text type in the corpus, chancery documents, has the lowest frequency of 1-2 at 9.8%, well below the expected rate of 1-2. Sermons, on the other hand, favor the 1-2 order at 37.4%, while other types of religious texts have roughly the same rate of 1-2 as the expected rate. The one chronicle in the database strongly favors 1-2, but it is unclear whether that is a property of chronicles per se or an idiosyncratic feature of the particular text. One might tentatively conclude from these data that since sermons are the genre closest to the spoken language and strongly favor 1-2, the 1-2 order is more prevalent in spoken MHG, while the most formal written language tends to shun that order. Table 18. Effect of genre on 1-2 order Genre (number of texts)
2-1
chancery docwnent (3) sermon(5) other religious text (4) chronicle (1)
240 271 231 47
Total
1-2
Factorwt.
(90.2%) (62.6%) (70.6%) (58.8%)
26 (9.8%) 162 (37.4%) 96 (29.4%) 33 (41.2%)
0.406 0.557 0.433 0.754
789 (71.3%)
317 (28.7%)
p < 0.001 Finally, given the fact that sermons and other religious texts were mostly written by clerics, let us examine whether the effects of genre and occupation are independent of each other. This is presented in the cross-tabulation of genre and occupation in Table 19.19 Of the texts written by clerics, sermons have a higher rate of the 1-2 order at 37% than other religious texts written by clerics at 32%. Of the texts by persons of unknown occupation, religious texts have a higher rate
19. We will set aside the one instance of a chronicle.
35
36
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
of 1-2 (25%) than chancery documents (10%). Religious texts by clerics use the 1-2 order more frequently (32%) than the religious texts by non-clerics (25%). Thus the two factors are indeed somewhat independent of each other and have a cumulative effect on verb order. Table 19. Cross-tab of genre with occupation Genre
word order
clerics
occup. unknown
sermons
2-1
271 (6396)
1-2
162 (3796)
0 (096)
162 (3796)
other religious
2-1
139 (6896)
92 (7596)
231 (7196)
1-2
66 (3296) 0 (096)
30 (2596) 240 (9096)
96 (2996) 240 (9096)
0 (096)
Total 271 (6396)
chancery
2-1 1-2
0 (096)
26 (1096)
26 (1096)
Total
2-1
410 (6496)
332 (8696)
742 (7296)
1-2
228 (3696)
56 (1496)
284 (2896)
2.2.4 Conclusion In this section, I have discussed the results of my analysis of word order variation in MHG complexes of two verbs, based on a database of 13 texts. Several factors were determined to affect verb order: syntagm type, the category and weight of the word preceding the VC, extra position, focus, verbal prefixes, dialect, occupation of the author, and genre. Of these, the following combination was found to be the most significant factors by GoldVarb's step-up/step-down analysis: syntagm type, preceding word, focus, dialect, occupation, and genre. The next section will test all of these factors on subordinate clauses with clusters of three verbs.
2.3
Complexes of three verbs in MHG
2.3.1 Introduction Perhaps unsurprisingly, there are few examples in my MHG database ofVCs containing three verbs. One reason for this is that MHG still has robust use of the preterit tense, so in complex syntagms such as the past tense of the passive, MHG has two verbs (the preterit passive) where later stages of the language tend to have three verbs (the present perfect passive). In my database of 1,133 clauses with a VC, just 26 have three verbs and none have four verbs. Given the small number
Chapter 2. Factors influencing verb order in MHG
of tokens, this section will report the numbers, percentages, and statistical significance, but factor weights will only be reported in the few instances where the factor has a statistically significant effect. Recall from Section 2.1.1 that the following orders for three-verb complexes are attested in MHG (repeated here for the reader's convenience): the 3-2-1 order (5), the 1-3-2 order (6), the 1-2-3 order (7), and 3-1-2 (8): (5) uuanta er geb6ran uuerda.n u.uolta uon armen u6rderon. wanted1 of poor ancestors because he bom3 be2 (Williram lOr) 'because he [Christ] wanted to be born of humble origins: (6) daz elliv werlt die er gefaphen Mte.folti verlorn werdfn. that all word REL he created had should 1 lost3 b~ 'that the whole world that he had created should be lost: (Speculum eccL 08r) (7) wie er och Joelte wi:ie gemarterot an de (heiligen) cvce. how he also should 1 bez martyred3 on the holy cross '... how he should also be martyred on the holy cross: (Schwarzw. Fred. 009v)
Jolti werdin. (8) daz daz chint befnitin that the child circumcised3 should1 be 2 '... so that the child should be circumcised .. .'
(Speculum eccL llv)
Moreover, recall that a constituent may break up the VC with the order 1-3-2, resulting in what I call1-x-3-2 (9). Throughout this section, no distinction will be made between 1-3-2 proper and 1-x-3-2. Having four possible word orders presents a number of methodological challenges. The first has to do with the fact that GoldVarb X allows only binomial analyses, and having four word orders requires a multinomial analysis. To get around this limitation, I ran three separate analyses for each factor group.2o I tested the order 1-3-2 against the combined orders 3-2-1, 1-2-3, and 3-1-2. Then I tested the 1-2-3 order against the other three combined, etc. This allowed me to test for factor weights and statistical significance for each dependent variable. The second problem is the low number of tokens. There are only 26 clauses with three-verb complexes to begin with, and this is compounded by having four dependent variables. Thus in this section, statistical significance is not achieved in any of the analyses, unless otherwise noted. Other recodes were attempted in many cases, but in no case did recoding result in increased significance, thus such recodes will not be discussed further.
20.
Since only one clause has the 3-2-1 order, that order is not tested for signlli.cance at all
37
38
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
The third problem is one of presentation, thus I will briefly explain how to interpret the tables for this section. Taking Table 20 as an example, there are two occurrences of the order 1-2-3 with the modal+ perfect syntagm. These two instances make up 66.7% of the three total instances of that syntagm. To determine whether this is a favoring factor for the 1-2-3 order, this percentage should be compared notto the percentages of the other word orders, hutto the expected rate of 1-2-3 in the database, which is 26.9%. Thus it appears that the modal + perfect syntagm strongly favors the 1-2-3 order, since the order appears more frequently in that context (66.7%) than its overall expected rate (26.9%). Of course, to determine whether that really is a strong favoring effect, the factor weight needs to be consulted. In this section, factor weights will be reported in the body of the text when relevant. This section is organized as follows. In Section 2.3.2, I examine whether the linguistic factors that affect two-verb clusters also affect three-verb clusters. Section 2.3.3 discusses the effect of date, dialect, and sociolinguistic factors on threeverb clusters in MHG.
2.3.2
Phonological, morphological, and syntactic factors
2.3.2.1
Syntagm type
In Section 2.2.2.1 above, I showed that syntagm type plays a major role in subordinate clauses with complexes of two verbs. This is also the case for complexes of three verbs, as shown in Table 20. Several examples of modal + passive are given in (5)-(8) above, and the other three syntagms are modal+ perfect (22), modal+ modal+ infinitive (23), and other, such as modal+ causative (24):
han (22) den er von im genomen Jolte REL he from him tak.en3 should1 have 2 'which he should have taken from him:
(Stadtbuch Aug. 20va)
(23) Swenne wir alliz daz nit uollfn grundfn mvgfn if we all that (... REL ••• ) not want1 prove3 can2 'If we do not want to be able to prove all (that we have heard)'
(Mitteldt. Fred. b4va) (24) daz er daz hus nider Jol haizzen Jlahen ... that he the house down shall1 order2 strike3 'that he shall order the house struck down .. :
(Sta.dtbuchAug. 19ra)
Chapter 2. Factors influencing verb order in MHG
Table 20. Effect of syntagm on three-verb complexes Syntagm
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
3-1-2
modal + passive modal + perfect21 modal + modal + in£ other Total
1 (5.3%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)
6(31.6%) 0(0%) 1 (100%) 1 (33.3%)
4 (21.1%) 2 (66.7%) 0 (0%) 1 (33.3%)
8 (42.1%) 1 (33.3%) 0 (0%) 1 (33.3%)
1 (3.8%)
8 (30.8%)
7 (26.9%)
10 (38.5%)
Although not statistically significant, we can perhaps draw some preliminary conclusions from the data above. First, note that as in Paul (2007:456), modal verbs governing an auxiliary plus participle (i.e. the first two syntagms in the table above) make up the overwhelming bulk of the three-verb complexes in my database.22 Secondly, as in Paul (2007:456), the modal+ passive syntagm can occur with any of the four word orders. Thirdly, there is only one instance of the 3-2-1 order in my database, and Paul concurs that the order is extremely rare in MHG (2007:456). As a final note, I find no examples of the infinitivus pm participio (IPP) or Ersatzinjiniti11 construction,23 although Paul does find two instances (2007: 456). The three orders other than 3-2-1 are about equally frequent in my study as in Prell's (2001:88). In each of these three orders (1-3-2, 1-2-3, and 3-1-2), finite verb (V1) precedes the verb it modifies (V2). This seems to be the opposite preference from that in complexes of two verbs, where 71% of the VCs have the finite verb in the final position (2-1). However, note that in almost all of the three-verb complexes in the database, the finite verb is a modal which tend to favor the 1-2 order in MHG. Thus it is an open question whether the preference for a finite verb to occur early in the three-verb complex is a property of three-verb complexes per se or due to the fact that modal verbs tend to occur before the verbs they select. 2.3.2.2
Word/phrase preceding the verbal complex
In Section 2.2.2.2 above, it was demonstrated that in VCs with two verbs, thecategory and phonological weight of the word preceding the VC influenced the order of the verbs. When a non-pronominal NP or a QP preceded, the rate of 1-2 was
21. Actually, two of these are the modal+ perfect as in (22), and the other is a verb of perception plus perfect: uuanot ergezzen haben 'believe to have forgotten' (Notker 014ra). 22.
Recall that the syntax section of Paul (2007) is written by Prell, largely based on Prell (200 1).
23. See Chapter 3 for a description and examples of this phenomenon in ENHG.
39
40
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
higher than expected, and that order was lower than expected when preceded by a pronoun. When recoded according to phonological weight, preceding stressed words were found to favor the 1-2 order while unstressed ones disfavored it For complexes of three verbs, this factor group is not significant for any of the word orders, neither when coded by part of speech as shown in Table 21, nor when coded by stress as in Table 22. The numbers are very small and no clear pattern can be seen in the distribution of the factors across the various word-order types. Table 21. Effect of the preceding category on three-verb complexes Cat. of prec. word
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
noun pronoun adverb prepositional phrase nothing precedes
0 (0%) 1 (33.3%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)
4 (33.3%) 0 (0%) 2 (66.7%) 0 (0%) 2 (50.0%)
4 (33.3%) 1 (33.3%) 1 (33.3%) 0 (0%) 1 (25.0%)
3-1-2 4 (33.3%) 1 (33.3%) 0 (0%) 4 (100%) 1 (25.0%)
Total
1 (3.8%)
8 (30.8%)
7 (26.9%)
10 (38.5%)
Table 22. Effect of the preceding stress on three-verb complexes Stress of prec. word
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
3-1-2
stressed unstressed nothing precedes
0(0%) 1 (16.7%) 0(0%)
5 (27.8%) 2 (33.3%) 1 (50.0%)
5 (27.8%) 2 (33.3%) 0 (0%)
8 (44.4%) 1 (16.7%) 1 (50.096)
Total
1 (3.8%)
8 (30.8%)
7 (26.9%)
10 (38.5%)
2.3.2.3 Extraposition Like the previous factors, NP/PP extraposition has an effect on VCs with two verbs but not on those with three verbs. As seen in Table 23, clauses with nothing extra posed are about evenly distributed across the three common word orders, as are clauses with extraposed adjunct PPs. Moreover, none of the tests of the word orders yielded statistically significant results. Table 23. Effect of extraposition on three-verb complexes Extraposition
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
3-1-2
extraposed argument nothing extraposed extrapos. adjunct PP
1 (33.3%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)
0(0%) 6 (37.5%) 2 (28.6%)
0 (0%) 5 (31.2%) 2 (28.6%)
2 (66.7%) 5 (31.296) 3 (42.9%)
Total
1 (3.8%)
8 (30.8%)
7 (26.9%)
10 (38.596)
Chapter 2. Factors influencing verb order in MHG
2.3.2.4 Focus In Section 2.2.2.4 above, I showed that focus favors the 1-2 order, while old information disfavors it. As seen in Table 24, there is no dear efiect of focus on VCs with three verbs. Clauses with new/contrastive focus are about evenly distributed across the three common word orders, and the results are not significant for any order. Table 24. Effect of focus in three-verb complexes Focus
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
new I contrastive old information Total
1 (4.8%) 0 (0%)
8 (38.1%) 0 (0%)
5 (23.8%) 2 (40.0%)
7 (33.3%) 3 (60.0%)
1 (3.8%)
8 (30.8%)
7 (26.9%)
10 (38.5%)
3-1-2
2.3.2·5 Prefix tvpe As with other factor groups, prefix type does not have a discernable effect on the choice of verb orders with three verbs. As shown in Table 25, the number of clauses representing any given word order and prefix type is quite small, and this factor is not significant for any order. Moreover, this factor group largely overlaps with syntagm., as the numbers for unstressed in this factor group are nearly identical to those for modal+ passive in Table 20. Finally, note that the only two instances of a VC with a stressed prefix are in the 1-2-3 order. Table 25. Effect of prefix type on three-verb complexes Prefix: type
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
Stressed No prefix Unstressed Total
0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (4.8%)
0 (0%) 1 (33.3%) 7 (33.3%)
2 (100%) 1 (33.3%) 4 (19.0%)
0 (0%) 1 (33.3%) 9 (42.9%)
1 (3.8%)
8 (30.8%)
7 (26.9%)
10 (38.5%)
3-1-2
2.3.3 Diachronic, dialectal, and sociolinguistic variation 2.3.3·1 Date Turning now to date, we find first of all that there are only two instances of threeverb complexes in the 11th century, as seen in Table 26. From the 12th to the 13th centuries, the 1-3-2 order changes little, the 3-1-2 order becomes less frequent, and the 1-2-3 order greatly increases in frequency. Only this last development is statistically significant. changing from a factor weight of 0.198 in the 12th century to 0.837 in the 13th.
41
42
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Table 26. Effect of time on three -verb complexes Century
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
3-1-2
1070-1100 1150-1200 1250-130024
1 (50.0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)
1 (50.0%) 4 (33.3%) 3 (25.0%)
0 (0%) 1 (8.3%) 6 (50.0%)
0 (0%) 7 (58.3%) 3 (25.0%)
Total
1 (3.8%)
8 (30.8%)
7 (26.9%)
10 (38.5%)
s ignificance2s
n/a
p =0.568
p = 0.012
p = 0.191
2.3.3.2 Dialed
As might be expected given the rather random dialectal distribution of twoverb complexes (Section 2.2.3.2 above), the distribution of three-verb complexes is even less clear. Given the small number of tokens per dialect, for none of the four word orders is this factor group statistically significant, as shown in Table 27. However, a few remarks may still be made. First, note that the 3-1-2 order is the most frequent order in Bavaria, Swabia, and Switzerland, dialects that favor that order both in ENHG (see Chapter 3) and the modern period (see Chapter 4). Secondly, note that the 1-2-3 order is the only one found in the text from the Black Forest, an Alemannic dialect, while Swiss, also an Alemannic dialect, does not have any instances of that order. This may indicate that these differences are due to idiosyncrasies of the representative texts, rather than true dialectal variation. Table 27. Effect of dialect on three-verb complexes
Dialect
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
3-1-2
Bavaria Swabia Black Forest26 E. Franconian Cologne26 Hesse Thuringia26
1 (50.0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)
0 (0%) 3 (30.0%) 1 (20.0%) 0 (0%) 1 (50.0%) 0 (0%) 3 (100%) 0 (0%)
0 (0%) 2 (20.0%) 0 (0%) 3 (100%) 1 (50.0%) 1 (100%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)
1 (50.0%) 5 (50.0%) 4 (80.0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)
Total
1 (3.8%)
8 (30.8%)
7 (26.9%)
10 (38.5%)
Swiss26
24. Recall that the text representing this time period fur Nuremberg is slightly later (1302-1315). 25. Statistical significance for each order was calculated by combining the 11th and 12th centuries. 26. Each of these dialects is represented by only one text
Chapter 2. Factors influencing verb order in MHG
2.3.3.3 Sociolinguistic factors In Section 2.2.3.3 above, I demonstrated that occupation and genre have an effect on word order in two-verb complexes, with clerics and religious texts favoring the 1-2 order. However, with three-verb complexes, no such preferences emerge, probably due to the very small number of tokens for each of the four word orders. As seen in Table 28, sex/occupation does not have a significant effect on any verb order. However, the 1-3-2 order is disfavored in texts by unknown authors (factor weight= 0.286). The other orders are more evenly distributed, and the factor weights are close to 0.5, indicating little favoring effect.
Table 28. Effect of sex/occupation on three-verb complexes Sex/occupation27 males/clerics (7) unknown(6) Total
3-2-1 1 (5.3%) 0 (0%) 1 (3.8%)
1-3-2 7 (36.8%) 1 (14.3%) 8 (30.8%)
1-2-3 4 (21.1%) 3 (42.9%) 7 (26.9%)
3-1-2 7 (36.8%) 3 (42.9%) 10 (38.5%)
As seen in Table 29, genre has no statistically significant effect on any word order either. Chancery documents do slightly disfavor 1-3-2 (factor weight= 0.351) while favoring 1-2-3 somewhat (factor weight= 0.635). Again, the number of tokens is quite small, and it would be hasty to draw any conclusions from this. Table 29. Effect of genre on three-verb complexes Genre chancery doc. (3) sermon(5) other religious (4) chronicle (1) Total
3-2-1 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (33.3%) 0 (0%) 1 (3.8%)
1-3-2 1 (20.0%) 6 (35.3%) 1 (33.3%) 0 (0%) 8 (30.8%)
1-2-3 2 (40.0%) 4 (23.5%) 1 (33.3%) 0 (0%) 7 (26.9%)
3-1-2 2 (40.0%) 7 (41.2%) 0 (0%) 1 (100%) 10 (38.5%)
2.3.4 Conclusion
In this section, I have attempted to establish whether the factors that affect twoverb clusters also affect clusters of three verbs. Because of the small number of tokens for each word order, few significant effects could be found. However, two preliminary conclusions may perhaps be drawn. First, the 3-2-1 order is rare, while the other three orders are about equally frequent. Secondly, the 1-2-3 order increases greatly from the 12th to the 13th century. 27. Recall that all non-anonymous texts in the database are by male clerics, thus these two categories are identical
43
44
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
2.4
Conclusion
2.4.1 Summary of findings This chapter reports on a study of verbal complexes in subordinate clauses in thirteen MHG texts. Although few conclusions can be made about VCs containing three verbs, there are a number of interesting results for two-verb complexes. First of all, syntagm has a significant effect on verb order, with participial constructions favoring the 2-1 order and infinitival constructions favoring 1-2 (Section 2.2.2.1). Secondly, the category and phonological weight of the word preceding the VC influences the order within the complex (Section 2.2.2.2). Thirdly, focus plays an interesting role in the choice of verb orders, with narrow object focus favoring the 1-2 order, wide focus favoring 1-x-2 and 1-2 with extraposition, and old information favoring 2-1 (Section 2.2.2.4). Fourthly, the effect of dialect is significant (2.2.3.2). Finally, genre and occupation have significant effects, with clerics and religious texts independently favoring the 1-2 order (Section 2.2.3.3). The above factors in combination were found to have the most significant effect on verb order in GoldVarb's step-up/step-down function. In addition, extraposition (2.2.2.3) and prefix type (2.2.2.5) influence the relative order of the verbs, although these effects are largely the result of interactions with other factors, namely focus and syntagm. Time is also a significant fuctor, although rather than a steady development, we find that the 1-2 order dipped in the 12th century before rising again in the 13th (Section 2.2.3.1). The next chapter will test these same effects on a corpus of Early New High German, with largely the same results.
2.4.2 The combined effect of the favoring factors In this chapter, I have discussed a number offactors that favor the 1-2 order in MHG. However, none of these alone can account for the high frequency of the 1-2 order in the database. However, when all of these factors are considered together, they account for the vast majority of the occurrences of that order. As seen in Table 30, just 13 of the 317 clauses with the 1-2 order, or 4.1%, have none of the favoring factors. Thus, although no individual factor forces the 1-2 order, the relatively high frequency of 1-2 in these texts can be understood as the result of the cumulative favoring effect of a number of factors.
Chapter 2. Factors influencing verb order in MHG
Table 30. All favoring factors for 1- 228 Favoring factor
1-(x)-2
Syntagm with infinitive Preceding stressed word Separable prefix verb Focus Extraposition No scrambling None ofthe favoring factors Total
170 216 21 271 28 9 13
317
Throughout this chapter, we have seen that several prosodic factors have an effect on word order within the verbal complex: a preceding stressed word, a stressed prefix, and focus (which is expressed through prosody). Table 31lists only those factors that are arguably related to prosody and focus. With only the prosodic/ focus factors considered, the majority of 1-2 clauses are still accounted for. Only 21, or 6.6%, of the clauses are not accounted for by a prosodic factor. Table 31. Prosody-related favoring factors for 1-2 Favoring factor
1-(x)-2
Preceding stressed word Separable prefix verb Focus Extraposition No scrambling None of the prosodic factors Total
216
21 271
28 9
21 317
In Chapter 3, we will see that these factors have largely the same effect in ENHG as in MHG. Chapter 4 will investigate variation in verb order in some varieties of Modern German: we will see that syntagm type and prosodic factors continue to be the major factors impacting verb order today.
28. Many clauses are represented in this table more than once, since a clause may have two or
more of the favoring factors.
45
CHAPTER3
Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
3.1
Introduction
3.1.1 Basic facts Early New High German (ENHG) is the stage of the language spoken approximately from 1350 to 1650. This period of European history represents the transition from the Middle Ages to the modern world, and is characterized (among many other developments) by the rise of the city, the invention of the printing press, and the Protestant reformation. It is a time of increasing mass literacy, including literacy in vernacular languages, and as a result this period sees a dramatic increase in the type and number of texts produced. ENHG is also an age of linguistic transition: over those three hundred years the language gradually takes on many of the phonological morphological, and syntactic features that characterize Modern Standard German. In traditional scholarship on the history of German, ENHG was not considered a separate stage of the language at all (Schmidt 1996: 27), so that texts before about 1500 were often characterized as corrupt or dialectal late MHG, while those after 1500 were seen as the New High German language forged by Martin Luther. Most recent reference works, however, recognize ENHG as a separate stage, albeit one that is characterized by much dialectal and diachronic variation. We shall see in this chapter, in fact, that subordinate-clause verb order at the beginning of ENHG is quite similar to that of MHG, while many of the later texts approximate the syntax of modern German. As in prior stages of the language, the 2-1 order (i.e. the Modern Standard German order in which the finite verb follows the non-finite verb), is a frequent word order in ENHG: (1) daz er chain todsund nymmer mer tuen wolt
that he no death-sin never more do2 would 1 'that he would never again commit a deadly sin'
(Pillenreuth 160)
In addition to the 2-1 order, there are also clauses in which the finite verb precedes the non-finite verb, either directly, resulting in the 1-2 order (2), or separated by some constituent, in the 1-x-2 order (3):
48
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
(2) das der mensch aile sein lebttag nicht anders scholt thun that the person all his life.days nothing else should 1 do 2 'that man should do nothing else all the days of his life' (Pillenreuth 206) (3) das der mensche nicht scholt sein rew sparen an das todpett that the person not should 1 his regret save2 on the deathbed 'that one should not hold back his repentance on his deathbed'
(Pillenreuth 212) The fourth logically possible order, in which the verbs are in the order 2-1 with an intervening constituent, is virtually unattested in my ENHG corpus.! In addition to variation within the verbal complex. its position within the clause mayvary. As in MHG, constituents maybe extraposed whether the VC is in the 2-1 or 1-2 order, even with the 1-x-2 order (3). Thus ENHG largely continues the word-order possibilities found in MHG. In complexes of three verbs, the four word orders of MHG are also found in ENHG (albeit in much greater numbers): the 3-2-1 order (4) with each verb selecting its complement verb to the left. the 1-2-3 order (5) with each verb selecting its complement verb to the right, and two mixed orders, 1-3-2 (6) and 3-1-2 (7): (4) das so darvorgesetzt ist in fragweis verstanden werden soll that REL before.set is in question understood3 be 2 should 1 'that what is set before should be understood as a question' (Eunuchus 14) (5) so er dan den menschen nicht ha.t mugen vberwinden when he then the person not has 1 can2 overcome3 'when he has not been able to overcome the person' (Pillenreuth 158) (6) als er des tages scholt begraben werden as he the day should1 buried3 be 2 'when he should be buried on that day'
(Pillenreuth 212)
t. There are only three examples in which this order does occur, all of which are from a single text, the Oxforder Benediktinerregel from the 14th century. Perhaps crucially, in all three examples, the intervening constituent is the negator, with a negative prefix on the finite verb: (i) daz sie mit missetroste virloren nit inwerde that she with false.comfort 1ost2 not NEG-be1 'that she not be lost because of false comfort' (Benediktinerregel16)
This does not necessaril ypose a challenge to the observation that no constituents can intervene between the verbs in their base order (Bobaljik 2004: 139), if one assumes that in these cases nit is part of the verbal inflection. Note that this is quite unlike the cases in MHG, where only the particle ne- but never the free-standing negator was found in this position.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
er ... getan solt haben he done 3 should1 have2 'that he should have done'
(7) dy
REL
(Pillenreuth 159)
The other two logically possible orders, 2-1-3 and 2-3-1, are unattested in my ENHG database, as in MHG.2 In addition, with two of these orders, 1-3-2 and 1-2-3, some constituent may break up the VC. In all eleven instances involving the order 1-3-2 (some of which are V2 and thus ambiguous with main clauses), the intervening constituent appears just before the non -finite verb of which it is the complement, i.e. V 3 (8). The fact that no constituent may break up the 3-2-1 order, or appear between V 3 and in the 1-3-2 order, follows the generalization discussed above, that no constituent can intervene between verbs in the left-governing order. On the other hand, in the four instances involving the 1-2-3 order, the intervening constituent appears once between verbs 1 and 2 (9), once between verbs 2 and 3 (10), and once between all three verbs (11):
v2
(8) die sich niemals haben Schande vbergehen lassen REL REFL never have 1 disgrace come.upon3 let2 'who have never let disgrace come upon themselves'
(Bange Chronik 7r)
(9) wie si ain wuenderlich ding hiet vor dem ofen gesehen ligen how she a miraculous thing has 1 before the oven seen 2 lie3 'how she saw a miraculous thing lying in front of the overi
(Denkwitrdigk. 17) (10) das er seinen Sohn fuer vns hat lassen ein Schlachtopffer werden that he his son for us has 1 let2 a sacrifice.victim become3 'that he has let his son become a sacrificial victim for us' (Passionale 46v) (11) das jhr euch dis Capitel wollet ja lassen Iiebi angelegen vnd that you REFL this chapter will1 yes let2 dear fitting and befohlen sein recommended be3 'that you will indeed let this chapter be dear, fitting, and recommended to you' (Passionale 35r)
2. It may be safe to claim that these word orders were ungrammatical in ENHG, first because they are unattested in my corpus. and secondly because they are ungrammatical or extremely rare in modern German dialects (Chapter 4.2.3).
49
so
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
There is only one attested order for complexes of four verbs: 1-2-4-3, which occurs just three times. Two of these clauses exhibit the infinitivus pm participio (IPP) construction plus either another infinitive (12) or a passive (13), and one involves a modal plus causative lassen plus passive (14). (12) das Gott wunderbarlicher wyB hat lassen herfiirwallen geschinen REL God miraculous way has 1 let2 forth.flow4 appear3 'which God miraculously caused to appear to flow forth' (Gespenster 19v) (13) das sie mehr fiir ein Rilst- dann Schlaffkammer ... hette moegen that it more for an armor than sleep.chamber had 1 can2
gehalten werden held4 be3 'that it could have been considered more an armory than a bedroom'
(Beschreibung 13) (14) das die selben jre Prediger jnen sollen lassen befolhen sein that the same their pastors them shalh let2 ordered4 be3 'that they should let their pastors be ordered to them' (Sum maria 19v) Finally, as discussed in Section 3.3.2.2 below, extraposition may occur with threeverb complexes, regardless of the order of the verbs.
3.1.2 The database
My ENHG database consists of 2,906 subordinate clauses from thirty texts available on the on-line Bonner Frithneuhochdeutschkorpus. These thirty texts represent three texts each from ten dialect areas: Cologne, Hesse, Alsace, Zurich, Swabia, Nuremberg, Thuringia, Saxony, Augsburg, and Vienna. Within each dialect, there is one text each from the 14th, 15th, and 16th centuries} There are 2,737 clauses with VCs consisting of two verbs, 166 clauses with complexes of three verbs, and three clauses with four verbs. Approximately 100 clauses from each text were selected according to the following criteria.4 First of all, the database contains only finite subordinate clauses with complexes of at least two verbs, not counting the infinitive of any embedded infinitival clause. Not included in this study are participles with no auxiliary,
3· The Bonner corpus has texts from 4 time periods: 1350-1400, 1450-1500, 1550-1600, and 1650-1700. I have not included any texts from the last period, since I consider that to be the NHG era and presume that the rate of1-2 would be too low for statistical analysis. 4· Pillenreuth ~stik is written in two hands; I took 97 clauses from the first hand and 80 clauses from the second hand
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
Table 1. Texts in my ENHG databases Dialect
1350-1400
1450-1500
1550-1600
Cologne Hesse Alsace Zurich Swabia Nuremberg Thuringia Saxony Augsburg Vienna
Buch ]((jln Benedictinerregel Mannen Naturlehre Altvater Namen Psalter Dresden Altdeutsche Pred. ThJja Rationale
Koellwff Chronik Hortus Santitatis Chirurgie Edlibach Chronik Eunuch us Pillenreuth M1stik Rothe Chronik Sermon Vita Denkwurdigkeiten
Gegenwartigkeit Walter Ralegh Nachbarn Gespenster Beschreibung Summaria Bange Chronik Passionale Nachtmahl M.oscouia
which are fairly common in ENHG (for a discussion, see Reifsnyder 2003:231234). Also excluded are two tokens with a repeated finite verb as in (15), another construction discussed in Reifsnyder (2003: 237 -241). rache ist gehaissen ist revenge is 1 called2 is 1 'which is called revenge'
(15) der da
REL PART
(Altdeutsche Fred. 7)
Secondly, only unambiguous subordinate clauses were selected.6 Frequently, clauses with 1-2 or 1-x-2 order had to be rejected because they were ambiguous with verb-second (V2) main clauses. Many potential relative clauses were rejected, since the relative pronoun is usually homophonous with the demonstrative pronoun, resulting in clauses that are ambiguous between a main clause and a subordinate clause (16a). Thus relative clauses were included in the database only if at least one constituent intervened between the pronoun and the verb, indicating an unambiguous subordinate clause (16b).
werden vergeben sein sund be 1 forgiven2 his sin 'that one I whom will be forgiven his sin' b. der in dem himel nicht mocht sein vnter got REL in the heaven not could 1 be2 under God 'who could not be in heaven with God'
(16) a.
dem
DEM/REL
(Pillenreuth 176)
(Pillenreuth 162)
5· Complete titles are found in the bibliography, and additional information can be found on the website for the Bonn corpus: http://www.korpora.org/Fnhd!
These criteria are stricter than those used in the MHG study (Chapter 2), which included V2 clauses introduced by wande and even those introduced by an ambiguous relative/demonstrative pronoun.
6.
51
52
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Also frequently ambiguous are clauses with wan. According to Reichmann & Wegera (1993:473) wan is subordinating in the meaning 'when' (17), but in the meaning 'for/because: wan may be coordinating (18a) or subordinating (18b ). (17) wan sich dy sel sol abschaiden von dem leib when REFL the soul shall1 part2 from the body 'when the soul shall leave the body'
(Pillenreuth 161)
wan er mag nymer mer sunden for he can 1 never more sin2 'for he can never sin again' (Pillenreuth 158) b. wan er kain menschen lest mer angefochten werden for he no person lets 1 more tempted3 be 2 'for he does not let anyone be more tempted' (Pillenreuth 166)
( 18) a.
With wa.n 'for/because, clauses are only included in the database in cases where it is dearly subordinating, i.e. when at least two constituents intervene between the complementizer and the finite verb, as in (18b ). Finally, if the complementizer is unambiguously subordinating but the clause is V2, as in (19), the clause is kept in the database but coded as V2. This allowed me to include such clauses in the database (under the assumption that they involve extra position), while maintaining the option of excluding them if more restrictive criteria seemed necessary later on. (19) ob er wolt leben in aynem rechten cristenlichen glauben if he would1 live2 • • • in a correct Christian faith 'whether he would live ... in a true Christian faith' (Pillenreuth 167) The analyses were conducted using the statistics package GoldVarb X (Sankoff et al. 2005). For more information about GoldVarb and on how to interpret the tables, see Chapter 2.1.3. The clauses were coded for the following factor groups: verb order (the dependent variable), syntagm type, constituent preceding the VC, constituent intervening in the VC, constituent following the VC, clause type, focus type (new vs. contrastive), prefix type, scrambled object, coordination, and verb second.7 Each text in the database was tagged for century; dialect, genre, and the sex, occupation, and education of the author.
7. Two of these factors, clause type and VP coordination, had no effect and will not be discussed further here, but they were discussed in detail in Sapp (2006). A pilot study (Sapp 2005) tested two additional variables that had no effect and thus were not coded in the complete database: position of the clause within the sentence and the alternation of stressed and unstressed syllables (see Section 2.1 below). Finally, note that some factors were tested in MHG (see Chapter 2) but not in ENHG: constituent focused, whether an intervening constituent is part of the focus, and whether an extraposed constituent is part of the focus.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
3.1.3 Organization of this chapter
This chapter is organized as follows. The analyses of VCs consisting of two verbs are presented in Section 3.2. Section 3.3 treats three-verb complexes. Section 3.4 discusses the factors that influence word order in individual texts and in the various dialects, uses those data to propose dialectal divisions in ENHG, and compares the MHG results with those from ENHG. This chapter is concluded in Section 3.5.
3.2
Complexes of two verbs in ENHG
3.2.1 Introduction
In my database of 30 texts from the Bonner Friihneuhochdeutschkorpus, there are 2,737 subordinate clauses with exactly one finite and one non-finite verb. In 671, or 24.5%, of these clauses, the finite verb precedes the non-finite verb. I refer to these instances as "the 1-2 order~ and unless otherwise noted, this refers to all cases with a fronted finite verb, i.e. it includes both the 1-2 order proper and the 1-x-2 order. As a rough approximation, a rate of 1-2 higher than 24.5% indicates a favoring effect. A favoring effect on the 1-2 order should be expressed by GoldVa.rb as a factor weight greater than 0.5, with a higher factor weight signifying a stronger effect In Section 3.2.2, I discuss factors that do not have any effect on verb order, contrary to the claims of previous scholarship: the position of the subordinate clause within the sentence and the pattern of stressed and unstressed syllables in the VC. In Section 3.2.3, I discuss the five factors that do affect verb order: syntagm type, the category of the word preceding the VC, extraposition, focus, and verbal prefixes. Section 3.2.4 discusses the diachronic, dialectal, and sociolinguistic variation in the rate of the 1-2 order in ENHG. Of the factors that have a significant favoring effect on the 1-2 order, eight were determined to be the most significant combination of factors by GoldVarb's step-up/step-down function: syntagrn., constituent before the VC, focus, prefix type, date, dialect, genre, and occupation. 3.2.2 Non-favoring factors 3.2.2.1 Position of clause Using a small sample of ENHG clauses, Maurer finds that the position of the subordinate clause within the sentence affects word order (1926: 161-162). In his data, sentence-final clauses tend to have the order 2-1 and non-sentence-final
53
54
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
clauses 1-2. He argues that the 2-1 order is preferred in sentence-final clauses due to the falling intonation at the end of the sentence and the tendency for auxiliaries to be located in phonologically weak positions. I examined this factor in a pilot study of four texts (Sapp 2005).8 The data from that study do not support Maurer's findings. Table 2 shows that whether the clause is sentence-final or not, the rate of the 1-2 order is very similar to 27%, the overall rate of 1-2 in these four texts. The distinction between sentence-final and non-sentence-final clauses is very slight: 26% versus 28%, with factor weights very close to 0.5. Furthermore, this distinction is not statistically significant.
Table 2. Effect of the position of the clause on 1-2 order (Sapp 2005)9 Position of clause
2-1
sentence final not sentence final
87 (73%) 251 (71%)
1-2 32 (26%) 98 (28%)
Total
338 (72%)
130 (27%)
Factorwt. 0.469 0.510
p = 0.102 Thus the effect of the position of the subordinate clause within the sentence on the choice of verb orders could not be confirmed. Nor was Ebert able to confirm any effect in his study of texts from Nuremberg: "there is no consistent pattern here of influence due to occurrence in a 'Vordersatz' vs. 'Nachsatz'" (1981: 206). Since neither Sapp (2005) nor Ebert (1981) could verify this effect, it was not tested on the whole ENHG database and will not be discussed further. 3.2.2.2
Alternation of stressed and unstressed syllables
ENHG, like the other continental West Germanic languages, has a series of verbal prefixes. There are a number of stressed, separable prefixes (SSPs), like auff in (20). There are also unstressed prefixes, which are inseparable from the verb, such as ver- in (21).
8. For the pilot study, I selected clauses from four 15th-century texts from the Bonner FrUhneuhochdeutsch-Korpus: Eunuchus, Edlibach Chronik, Rothe Chronik, and Pillenreuth Mystik. 9· This analysis was conducted using GoldVarb 2001 (Robinson et al. 2001), an earlier version of the program than was used for the other analyses in this book GoldVarb 2001 does not round up percentages, so they add up to 99% rather than 100%. Moreover, in Sapp (2006) I analyzed the data with the 2-1 order as the default variable, thus factor weights greater than 0. 5 indicate a favoring effect on the 2-1 order in these two analyses.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
(20) dye got der her pannherczi.gklich hat auffgenumen REL God the Lord mercifully has 1 up.taken2 'whom God the Lord has mercifully received'
(Pillenreuth 160)
(21) das er in kainer sund verczweiffeln sol that he in no sin despair2 shall1 'that he shall not despair in any sin'
(Pillenreuth 161)
Ebert (1981: 207; 1998 passim), like Maurer (1926: 159), finds that non-finite verbs with a SSP favor the 1-2 order as in (20), while non-finite verbs with an unstressed prefix favor the 2-1 order as in (21). This observation holds true in my database as well, as demonstrated by Section 2.3.5 below. Ebert (1981: 208) attempts to account for this eftect of prefix type by hypothesizing that the verb order is sensitive to the alternation of stressed and unstressed syllables within the VC.IO According to Ebert, some patterns should favor either order (SOLlen SCHREiben - SCHREiben SOL/en 'should write'), since both orders produce an alternation of stressed and unstressed syllables. For other patterns, reordering to 1-2 results in consecutive stressed or unstressed syllables (beRICHten SOLlen ~ *SOLlen beRICHten 'should report') and thus should not favor 1-2. Likewise, the 1-2 order should be favored when it results in alternating stressed and unstressed syllables. However, this explanation does not hold for the texts analyzed in Sapp (2005), as shown in Table 3. In fact, the results here are the opposite of what one would expect under Ebert's hypothesis. When the underlying 2-1 order has alternating stressed and unstressed syllables but reordering to 1-2 removes that alternation, the frequency of 1-2 order is actually higher (44%) than the expected rate of 27%. Moreover, when the 2-1 order involves consecutive stressed (or unstressed) syllables but reordering to 1-2 would produce an alternating pattern, the rate of 1-2 is lower than expected (19%). Finally. clusters like schreiben sollen, which Ebert finds to have a high frequencyof1-2, have 1-2 at close to the expected rate (22%).11 Given the failure of the pilot study to find the expected effect, and given the difficulty of coding syllable structure in a large corpus, this factor was not tested on the complete database of thirty texts.
Ebert concedes that his sample is too small to for statistical significance. He does not maintain this explanation in a later study; however, he continues to find that when the V has the pattern as in beRICHten, 2-1 is fuvored (1998: 162). Note that this pattern is exclusively found in verbs with an unstressed prefix. which do slightly favor 2-1 in my corpus.
10.
Ebert limited his conclusions to modal + infinitive clusters. I tested this again excluding syntagms other than modal + infinitive and found very similar results to those in Table 3.
11.
55
56
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Table 3. Effect of syllable pattern on 1-2 order (Sapp 2005) 12 Alternating syllables
2-1
1-2
Factorwt.
both orders result in clash both orders alternate 2-1 alternates, 1-2 dashes 2-1 dashes, 1-2 alternates
14 (70%) 168 (77%) 64 (55%) 92 (80%)
6 (30%) 50 (22%) 52 (44%) 22 (19%)
0.448 0.515 0.434 0.548
Total p < 0.001
338 (72%)
130 (27%)
Thus there does not seem to be a general effect of alternating stressed and unstressed syllables within the VC. However, as discussed in Section 3.2.3.5 below, there is an effect of prefix type per se. 3.2.3 Favoring factors 3.2.3.1 Syntagm type In those West Germanic dialects (including Standard Dutch) that allow 1-2, there is a preference for 2-1 in constructions with participles, and for 1-2 with a modal plus infinitive (see Chapter 4 for details and references). As discussed in Chapter 1, several earlier studies have found a similar effect in earlier stages of German, and the current study confirms this for MHG in Chapter 2. The data from my ENHG database match this tendency. as can been seen in Table 4. The passive syntagms have the lowest rates of 1-2 at around 11%. The perfect syntagms display frequencies of the 1-2 order that are fairly close to the expected rate of24.5%, and the factor weights indicate little efiect on verb order. On the other hand, syntagms with an infinitive favor 1-2, with frequencies higher than the total and factor weights well above 0.5. The effect of syntagm was selected in GoldVarb's step-up/ step-down function as one of the most significant factor groups. In addition to the participial and infinitival syntagms, there is a relatively rare third type, the progressive tense. The ENHG progressive consists of the auxiliary sein or werden plus either the infinitive or present participle:13
was (22) do nue die Junk.chfraun vnd y-eder man slaffen when now the virgins and every man sleep-inf2 was 1 'now when the virgins and everyone were sleeping' (Denkwardigk. 15) 12.
Analysis was conducted with GoldVarb 2001 (see footnote for Table 2 above for details.)
13. The 24 instances of subordinate clauses with the progressive tense in my corpus come from only five texts. Ten of these have the infinitive as in (22)-(23). All14 instances with the present participle come from a single text, Mannen.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
Table 4. Effect of syntagm on 1-2 order
Syntagm
2-1
sein passive werden passive
236 (89.4%) 446 (89.0%) 20 (83.3%) 520 (77.4%) 49 (76.6%) 177 (70.8%) 592 (65.5%) 26 (44.8%)
28 (10.6%) 55 (11.0%) 4 (16.7%) 152 (22.6%) 15 (23.496) 73 (29.2%) 312 (34.5%) 32 (55.296)
2066 (75.5%)
671 (24.5%)
progressive perfect with haben future perfect with sein modal +inf other V + inf. Total
1-2
Factorwt. 0.287 0.295 0.404 0.498 0.509 0.583 0.641 0.806
p < 0.001 (23) do sich sein sach pessern ward when REFL his case improve-inf2 was 1 'when his case was improving'
(Denkwardigk. 14)
(24) sider ich dise bekentnisse von dir habende bin since I these confessions from you having2 am 1 'since I have these confessions from you'
(Mannen 4)
(25) das ich ... frvege alleine wart sitzzende that I early alone was 1 sitting2 'that I was sitting alone early (in the morning)'
(Mannen 3)
Although the number of tokens is too small to allow one to draw any firm conclusions, the progressives appear to pattern with the participial constructions. The resulting hierarchy can now be compared to those in previous studies. The hierarchy from my ENHG corpus (26a) is largely similar to the hierarchies in Bies' (26b) and Ebert's (26c) ENHG corpora. These are also comparable to the hierarchy I find in MHG, repeated in (27) from Chapter 2. (26) a. b.
sein pas.> werden pas.> haben pf. > fut. > sein pf. >mod. werden pas. > sein pas. > haben pf. > sein pf. > fut. > mod. (Bies 1996: 58)
c.
werden pas. > sein pas. > haben pf. > fut. > mod. > sein pt~ (Ebert 1992: 5)14
(27) sein pass.> werden pass.> sein perf.> haben perf.> mod.
14. As reportedinBies (1996: 58); this is verysimil.artothehlerarchy reported in Ebert (1998:65), see Chapter 1. Ebert (1981) is not compared here because sein passives were not included The direction of the arrows here indicates the descending preference fur the 2-1 order.
57
58
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
The hierarchies do not correspond exactly, but the general trend of passive >perfect> modal does hold. 3.2.3.2 Word preceding the verbal complex Ebert (1981: 206) finds that a noun preceding the VC favors 1-2 while a preceding pronoun favors 2-1, and I have found similar results in MHG (see Chapter 2). However, as can be seen in Table 5, in my ENHG database there is no difference at all between the rate of the 1-2 order after a noun versus after a pronoun. In both cases, the rate is close to 24.5%, the expected rate of 1-2. This indicates that Ebert's (1981:206) claim about the effect of word stress on verbal order in Nuremberg does not hold for all of ENHG. Table 5. Effect of the category of the preceding word on 1-2 order Class of preceding word
2-1
1-2
Factorwt.
noun pronoun quantified NP adjective adverb prepositional phrase stranded or da-preposition clause (infinitival or finite) nothing precedes Total
519 (75.596) 302 (75.996) 49 (68.196) 39 (60.0%) 436 (75.096) 598 (79.0%) 6 (27.3%) 45 (81.8%) 72 (72.0%)
168 (24.5%) 96 (24.1%) 23 (31.9%) 26 (40.0%) 145 (25.0%) 159 (21.0%) 16 (72.2%) 10 (18.296) 28 (28.096)
0.502 0.498 0.594 0.675 0.509 0.453 0.892 0.409 0.548
2066 (75.5%)
671 (24.596)
p < 0.001 Although the predicted noun/pronoun distinction does not hold, this factor group is statistically significant, probably because of the effects of other parts of speech, to be explained to some degree below. (Moreover, this was selected as one of the most significant factor groups by GoldVarb's step-up/step-down analysis.) The categories that have a favoring effect on verb order are adjectives, stranded prepositions, and nothing preceding. With an adjective preceding the VC, the rate of the 1-2 order is 40%, considerably higher than the expected rate of 24.5%. I have no explanation for the fact that adjectives seem to favor 1-2; however, note that the number of tokens with adjectives is relatively low. ENHG, unlike Modern Standard German, allows preposition stranding: (28) (durch die wuisti) da anthonius inne was gewesen through the desert REL A. in was been 'through the desert that Anthonius had been in'
(Altvater73v)
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
When preceded by a stranded preposition (or ada-compound), the 1-2 order is more frequent than expected, at a rate of over 70%. This fact is easily accounted for by the interaction with time. Of the ten occurrences of preposition stranding, six are from the 14th century (three of which are nearly identical clauses from a single text, Altviitet·), when the rate of 1-2 is the highest, and none at all are from the 16th century; when 1-2 is rare. When no constituents occur between the complementizer or relative pronoun and the VC, the 1-2 order occurs at a rate of 28%, somewhat higher than the expected rate. This is also easily accounted for: most instances of 1-2 with nothing preceding the VC come from second conjuncts, and thus are best analyzed as instances of anacoluthon, i.e., a sentence starts as one type but after some syntactic break continues as another type. One of the most frequent kinds of anacoluthon in earlier stages of German involves conjoined subordinate clauses: although the second conjunct should have subordinate-clause word order, it sometimes has main-clause word order instead (Paul1920: 381). This is especially clear when the second conjunct contains several arguments, as in (29), for which the most likely analysis is that the finite verb wil is in the V2 position while the constituents dir and ring are in the middle field, rather than assuming that wil dir ring machen is a VC in the 1-x-2 order: (29) das ich mich in dein sel pergen mufi vnd wil dir ring that I REFL in your soul hidez must1 and want1 you humble machen alles das make 2 all that 'that I must hide myself in your soul and want to make all of that humble for (Pillenreuth 223) you' Thus apparent instances of 1-2 with nothing preceding the finite verb are probably best treated as having main-clause-like V2 word order. Recall from Chapter 2 that Ebert (1981: 207) attributed the differing effect of nouns and pronouns on verb order to phonological stress, speculating that the heavier stress of nouns compared to pronouns favors the 1-2 order. In a later, much more detailed study; Ebert (1998:65) finds stress to be a significant factor, independent of the noun vs. pronoun distinction. Likewise, in my MHG analysis presented in Chapter 2, both the part of speech and the stress of the word preceding the VC had significant effects. So, although the analysis presented Table 5 fails to show any effect of the noun/pronoun distinction in my ENHG database, perhaps the phonological weight of the preceding word plays some role. Treating pronouns, short adverbs, the negator, and da-compounds as unstressed, with all other categories considered stressed (including the significant types adjective
59
6o
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
and stranded preposition), stress has no effect at all.15 As can be seen in Table 6, the rate of 1-2 is nearly exactly the same whether the VC follows a stressed or an unstressed word. Table 6. Effect of the stress of the preceding word on 1-2 order Stress of preceding word
2-1
1-2
Factorwt.
stressed unstressed
1295 (75.5%) 699 (75.9%)
421 (24.5%) 222 (24.1%)
0.502 0.497
Total
1994 (75.6%)
643 (24.4%)
p = 0.777 These results, together with Bies' (1996:59) findings, indicate that the stress of the preceding word has no efiect on the order of the verbs in general ENHG. However, such an effect exists in ENHG at the dialectal level, as determined by Ebert for Nuremberg. In fact, Sapp (2006) analyzes each dialect individually, determining that the 1-2 order is favored by a preceding noun in most dialects (see Table 40 below for details). One of these dialects is. perhaps not coincidentally, Nuremberg, the subjectofEbert's studies. On the other hand, some dialects show the opposite effect, i.e. preceding nouns disfavor and pronouns favor 1-2. Thus the favoring effect of preceding nouns on the 1-2 order, which is present in much of the ENHG-speaking area, is probably cancelled out in the analysis of the entire database by texts that show the opposite behavior. Perhaps the conclusion from this should be that there was indeed a strong favoring effect of preceding nouns on the 1-2 order in MHG (perhaps due to Behaghel's "rhythmic" principle), an effect which by ENHG has become limited to certain dialects and which soon becomes obsolete in written German with the disappearance of the 1-2 order. 3.2.3.3 Extraposition Ebert (1981: 209) notes that when the VC is in clause-final position, the 2-1 order is preferred. To put it differently, there is a correlation between the 1-2 order and the extraposition of some constituent, usually an NP or a PP. This holds true in my data as well, as can be seen in Table 7. When an argument occurs to the right of the VC, the 1-2 order occurs nearly 35% of the time, well above the expected rate of24.3%. (Although statistically significant, this was not selected as one of the most significant groups in the step-up/step-down analysis.)
15. This method of determining stressed vs. unstressed words is the same as Ebert's (1998:7), so the difference between my study and his is not due to differing criteria
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
Table 7. Effect of e.xtraposition on 1-2 order NP/PP extrapositionl6
2-1
1-2
extraposed argument extraposed adjunct PP nothing extraposed
143 (65.3%) 152 (72.4%) 1742 (77.0%)
76 (34.7%) 58 (27.6%) 520 (23.0%)
Total
2037 (75.7%)
654 (24.3%)
Factorwt. 0.625 0.545 0.484
p < 0.001 When there is no extraposition, the rate of the 1-2 order is 23%. very dose to the expected rate. The one category of extraposed constituent that behaves difterently from other categories is adjunct PPs, such as an das todpett in (3). When an adjunct PP is extraposed, the rate of 1-2 is just 27.6%, also close to the expected rate.l7 Finally. note the rate of extra position in the corpus. Of the 2,691 clauses, 210 or 7.9% have a extraposed adjunct PP, while 219 or 7.9% have some other constituent extraposed. The total rate of extraposition is 15.9%, which has decreased somewhat from the rate of extra position in MHG (19.7%). This leads to an interesting comparison with Modern Standard German. First of all, nearly half of the extraposed constituents in my ENHG corpus are adjunct PPs. Secondly, the fact that adjunct PPs have 1-2 at a lower rate than other types of extraposed constituents suggests that they are not subject to the same restrictions on extraposition. This is not surprising, since adjuncts also extrapose more easily than NPs and argument PPs in Modern Standard German. In Lambert's (1976: 137) corpus of written and spoken Standard German, 16.5% of the sentences have an extraposed adverbial phrase, which includes adverbial PPs, while only 3.5% of the sentences have an extraposed argument PP. Bies (1996:65) concludes that focus-driven extra position of NPs and argument PPs was lost in the transition to NHG, while extraposition of adjuncts continued. The data presented in this section are consistent with that conclusion. 3.2.3.4 Focus In the previous chapter, it was determined that focus affects verb order in MHG. In this section, focus effects in ENHG are tested. Unlike in my MHG database, in the ENHG database no distinction is made between focus on difierent constituent 16. This table excludes a small number of extraposed constituents that are neither adjunct PPs nor arguments. 17. Recall from Chapter 1 that Bies' data also show that NP extraposition affects verb order,
while PP extraposition does not. In fact, her numbers are strikingly similar to mine: 1-2 occurs 37.1% of the time with NP extraposition and 29.2% with PP extraposition. versus the expected rateof27.3% (Bies 1996:61).
61
62
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
types, e.g. direct object focus versus focus on a verb. Rather, clauses were tagged as either having new information focus on some constituent, contrastive focus on some constituent, or no focus (i.e. all old information). For example, in (30) the context is the sufferings of Christ, thus 'I have done everything' is discourse-old, and du.rch die mensch is the new information in the clause. Examples (31) and (32) illustrate cases where contrastive focus can be detected, with the NP nicht anders in (31) contrasting with the following clause, and the two verbs in (32) contrasting with each other. (30) das ich alles lFoe durch die mensch] hab getha.n. that I all for the person have done 'that I have done everything for the sake of
man:
(Pillenreu.th 220)
(31) das der mensch alle sein Iebttag [Foe nicht anders] scholt thun, denn that the person all his life.days nothing else should do than 'that man should do nothing else all the days of his life, than ..: (Pillenreuth 206) (32) das ein cristenmensch in dem stat getar (Fleben], in dem er nicht that a christian. person in the place dares live, in REL he not gern wolt [Foe sterben] gladly would die '(It is a wonder), that a Christian dares LIVE in a place where he would not like to DIE' (Pillenreuth 211) Clauses were tagged new if an argument was new within the section of the text, or new within one or two pages if the text was not divided into sections. Clauses were tagged contrastive regardless of whether an argument was new or given in the discourse, if it could be interpreted as contrastive. If there were no new or contrastive arguments, the clause was tagged as old. As seen in Table 8, if there is contrastive focus, the 1-2 order is very strongly favored, occurring more than 53% of the time. With new information focus, 1-2 is also favored at the rate of nearly 31%, still considerably higher than the expected rate of24.5%. On the other hand, old information has a disfavoring effect on 1-2, occurring only 19% of the time. The effect of focus is not only statistically significant but was also selected in GoldVarb's step-up/step-down function as one of the most significant factor groups. Using context for determining the focus structure of a sentence in a nonliving language can be quite difficult, and that is especially true for contrastive focus. It is possible that in some cases the 1-2 order has biased me into reading the clauses with a special intonation, and there are no doubt instances of focus that I have overlooked. However, there are some additional data that lend support to the argument that focus influences verb order.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
Table 8. Effect of focus on 1-2 order Focus
2-1
1-2
contrastive focus new information old information
15 (46.9%) 815 (69.1%) 1236 (81.0%)
17 (53.1 %) 365 (30.9%) 289 (19.0%)
Total
2066 (75.5%)
671 (24.5%)
Factorwt. 0.782 0.587 0.426
p < 0.001
Therefore, let us attemptto corroborate the effect ofinformation structure by looking at two additional factors: the definiteness of the NP immediately preceding the VC and scrambling. It is well known that indefinite NPs tend to represent new information while definite NPs and pronouns tend to represent old information, thus one would predict that indefinites favor the 1-2 order and definites do not. However, in my database, there is no favoring effect of indefinite NPs preceding the VC, as seen in Table 9. When the preceding NP is indefinite (including QPs withjeder, kein, or aile), the rate of 1-2 is 21.9%, and when it is definite (including pronouns and proper names), the rate is 25.8%. Note, however, that the definiteness of the preceding constituent would only be able to capture new information focus, since contrastive focus may involve a preceding definite NP.
Table 9. Effect of the definiteness of the preceding NP on 1-2 order Preceding NP
2-1
1-2
Factorwt.
indefinites (including QPs) definites
235 (78.1%) 635 (74.2%)
66 (21.9%) 221 (25.8%)
0.461 0.514
Total
870 (75.2%)
287 (24.8%)
p = 0.176 The second piece of supporting evidence that focus influences verb order is the correlation between lack of scrambling and the 1-2 order. An object is considered to be scrambled if it appears to the left of a sentential adverb or negator, like den menschen in (33), and is not scrambled if it is to the right, like the word sundt in (34): (33) so der teutel [den menschen] nit vberwinden mag if the devil the person not overcome can 'if the devil cannot overcome that person' (34) als ob du nie [sundt] habst gethan as if you never sin have done 'as if you have never committed sin'
(Pillenreuth 163)
(Pillenreuth 223)
63
64
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
When an object is new information or contrastive it should not undergo scrambling but remain inside the VP, whereas old information NPs tend to scramble to the left. In the database, clauses were tagged as unscrambled if an object appeared to the right of a negator or adverbial (i.e. immediately left of the verbs) and scrambled if an object was separated from the VC by some constituent. As seen in Table 10, clauses with unscrambled objects favor the 1-2 order at a rate of 38.4%, well above the expected rate. In clauses with scrambled NPs, on the other hand, the rate of 1-2 is closer to the expected rate, although there does seem to be a slight favoring effect. The fact that the 1-2 order is favored with unscrambled objects may confirm the effect of focus on that order; however, it may also be a result of the so -called rhythmic effect of an NP immediately preceding the V C. Table 10. Correlation between scrambling and 1-2 order Scrambled object
2-1
1-2
object not scrambled object is scrambled cannot tellls
45 (61.6%) 115 (71.4%) 1906 (76.1%)
28 (38.4%) 46 (28.6%) 597 (23.9%)
Total
2066 (75.5%)
671 (24.5%)
Factorwt. 0.657 0.553 0.492
p = 0.013 Finally, Section 3.2.3.2 above showed that extraposition favors the 1-2 order. This fact may also support the favoring effect of focus on 1-2, because according to Bies (1996) extraposed constituents in ENHG tend to be focused. 3.2.3.5 Prefix type In his studies of ENHG texts from Nuremberg, Ebert (1981: 207; 1998 passim) finds that stressed separable prefixes (SSP) favor the 1-2 order. The same effect is also found in my MHG study (Chapter 2). As seen in Table 11, this also holds for my ENHG corpus: when the non-finite verb has a stressed prefix, the 1-2 order occurs 35.7% of the time, well above the expected rate of 24.5%. The factor weight, well above 0.5, confirms that this factor strongly favors the 1-2 order. Verbs with no prefix have a slight favoring effect on 1-2, while those with an unstressed prefix disfavor it The effect of prefix type was selected in GoldVarb's step-up/step-down function as one of the most significant factor groups.
18. I have included pronouns in this category. Pronouns do scramble since they are always old
information, and tend to appear much earlier in the clause than other NPs, with pronominal objects often coming even before the subject When this factor is removed from the analysis, so that only the dear cases of scrambling versus non-scrambling are tested, the significance is improved top = 0.003.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
Table 11. Effect of prefix type on 1- 2 order Prefix type
2-1
1-2
Factorwt. 0.636 0.576 0.442
stressed no prefix unstressed
187 (64.3%) 531 (69.9%) 1348 (80.0%)
104 (35.7%) 229 (30.1%) 338 (20.0%)
Total
2066 (75.5%)
671 (24.5%)
p < 0.001 A conceivable reason for the correlation between prefix type and word order could be an interaction with syntagm type. Past participles usually have an unstressed prefix, especially the perfective marker ge-, whereas infinitives do not necessarily. (Either form may have an SSP.) GoldVarb X has a cross-tabulation function, which allows the researcher to test for interactions of this kind. The result of the cross-tabulation of prefix type and syntagm type, given in Table 12, suggests that the factors prefix type and syntagm type are independent of each other, and that their effect on verb order is cumulative. For all three factors in the factor group prefix type, the frequency of 1-2 is higher with infinitival constructions than with participial constructions (stressed prefix: 51%> 25%; no prefix: 33% > 22%; unstressed prefix 34% > 17%). Likewise, for both types of syntagms, the frequency of 1-2 is highest with stressed prefixes and lowest with unstressed prefixes (past participles: 25% > 17%; infinitives: 51%> 34%). Table 12. Cross-tab of prefix type with syntagm type Prefix type
word order
stressed
2-1
128 (75%)
57 (49%)
1-2
43 (25%)
59 (51%)
102 (36%)
no prefix
2-1
106 (78%)
409 (67%)
515 (69%)
1-2
30 (22%)
197 (33%)
227 (31%)
unstressed
2-1
1145 (83%)
201 (66%)
1346 (80%)
1-2
235 (17%)
103 (34%)
338 (20%)
2-1
1379 (82%)
667 (65%)
2046 (75%)
1-2
308 (18%)
359 35%)
667 (25%)
Total
participle
infinitive
Total 185 (64%)
In conclusion, the presence of a stressed separable prefix on the non-finite verb favors the 1-2 word order, and this effect is independent of syntagm type. Because prefix type has a significant, independent effect, and Section 3.2.2.2 above demonstrates that Ebert's account for the efiect of prefix type does not hold in my ENHG database, another explanation must be sought. Perhaps there is a syntactic reason for this preference, such as the fact that a verb and its SSP form a complex predicate (Muller 2002:409). On the other hand, phonology could be the reason,
65
66
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
but not in the way Ebert claims. While Ebert claims that the prosody of prefixed verbs plays a role due to a preference for alternating stressed syllables in the VC, I suggest in Chapter 5 that SSPs may result in a clash of word stresses with the word preceding the VC. Alternatively, one might appeal to Behaghel's (1932:III, 367) Gesetz der wachsenden Glieder ('Law of the growing constituents'), which states that in German, heavier items tend to be placed as late as possible in a clause. Since a verb with an SSP is phonologically heavier than a verb without an SSP, it follows that complexes including such verbs would be a favoring environment for the 1-2 order. Having discussed four linguistic factors that favor 1-2 in ENHG subordinate clauses, in the next section I will present the variation in subordinate clause word order over time, across dialects, and sociolinguistically.
3.2.4 Diachronic, dialectal, and sociolinguistic variation 3.2.4.1 Date As discussed in Chapter 1, it is well established that the 1-2 order decreases over time, becoming ungrammatical in Modern Standard German. At the end of the MHG period, the 1-2 order occurred in 33.7% of two-verb complexes (see Chapter 2). In the ENHG corpus, there is a sharp decrease in the rate of 1-2 order from the 14th to the 16th centuries, as seen in Table 13. In the 14th century, the rate of 1-2 is 35.5%, considerably higher than the overall rate of 24.5%. By the 15th century, the rate of 1-2 has dropped to 22%, just below the overall rate. The frequency of 1-2 in the 16th century is lower still. The effect of the date of the text is significant, and in fact was selected in GoldVarb's step-up/step-down function as one of the most significant factor groups. Table 13. Effect of time on 1-2 order
Century
2-1
1-2
Factorwt.
1350-1399 1450-1499 1550-1599
544 (64.596) 783 (78.096) 739 (83.196)
300 (35.596) 221 (22.096) 150 (16.996)
0.638 0.475 0.395
2066 (7 5.596)
671 (24.596)
Total
p < 0.001 The relatively high rate of 1-2 in the 16th century in the table above may be a bit misleading, due to the presence of one text, Walter Ralegh. In Walter Ralegh, 69% of the VCs with two verbs have the 1-2 order, more than twice as high as any other 16th-century text, and more than triple the earlier Hessian texts. I believe
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
the extremely high frequency of 1-2 is a result of the fact that the ENHG Walter Ralegh is a translation from Dutch.19 With that questionable text removed from the analysis, the following distribution obtains, with the frequency of 1-2 in the 16th century reduced to 11.5%. Table 14. Effect of time on 1-2 order, excluding Walter Ralegh Century
2-1
1-2
Factorwt.
1350-1399 1450-1499 1550-1599
544 (64.596) 783 (78.096) 714 (88.596)
300 (35.596) 221 (22.096) 93 (11.596)
0.666 0.505 0.321
2041 (76.996)
614 (23.1 96)
Total
p < 0.001 This result is largely similar to trends found in previous studies. In Hammarstram (1923), Ebert (1981), and Bies (1996), 1-2 generally declines over time, as seen in Table 15. For all three corpora, the frequency of 1-2 is highest at the beginning of the period and lowest at the end. However, unlike my ENHG corpus and Hammarstrom's study, which show a steady decrease of 1-2 over time, both Ebert's and Bies' data have an increase in the middle of the period (1500-1550 and 1450-1500, respectively) before decreasing in the end. According to Bies (1996:50), this kind of discrepancy across corpora is "suggestive of widespread synchronic variation and the normative pressure of a change from above=' Table 15. Effect of time on 1-2 order: Comparison to previous studies Period 1300-1350 1350-1400 1400-1450 1450-1500 1500-1550 1550-1600
Hammarstr0m20
Ebert (1981)21
12.696
30.796
5.096
25.296
096
32.396 23.696
Bies (1996) 36.196 20.696 19.296 34.896 24.296
Table 14 35.596 22.096 11.596
19. Walter Ralegh had to be removed from the time, dialect, and sociolinguistic analyses, where one text could have a strong influence on the results. However, Walter Ralegh is included in the other analyses because the favoring factors are the same as other ENHG texts (see Sapp 2006
for analyses of each individual text). 20.
Percentages for imperial and princely documents. For details, see Sapp (2006).
21. As reported in Bies (1996: 52). Bies converts Ebert's ratios to percentages. Moreover, I have averaged the percentages for sentence-internal and sentence-final, to ease comparison.
67
68
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Having seen the decrease over time of 1-2 in the wider sense (the finite verb precedes the non-finite verb), let us look at the difference between the 1-2 order in the narrow sense (the finite verb immediately precedes the non-finite verb) and the 1-x-2 order. As seen in Table 16, the rate of the 1-2 order in the narrow sense decreases over time, while the 1-x-2 order decreases only slightly..22 As a result, over time the 1-x-2 order makes up a larger percentage of the VCs in which the finite verb precedes, from 36 out of300 (12%) in the fourteenth century to 24 out of93 (nearly 26%) in the sixteenth. Table 16. Effect of time on 1-2 and 1-x-2 orders Century
2-1
1-2
1-x-2
1350-1399 1450-1499 1550-159923
544 (64.4%) 783 (78.0%) 714 (88.5%)
264 (31.3%) 170 (16.9%) 69 (8.6%)
36 (4.3%) 51(5.1%) 24 (3.0%)
2041 (76.9%)
503 (18.9%)
111 (4.2%)
Total
Recall from Section 3.1.2 above that some clauses introduced by unambiguously subordinating conjunctions but with the verb in the second position were tagged as V2, making it possible to exclude such clauses in a GoldVa.rb analysis. Doing so is especially important with 1-x-2 clauses, to rule out the possibility that they involve main clause word order rather than unambiguous 1-x-2. Excluding these subordinate clauses with potentially main clause word order results in a smaller number of 1-2 clauses (especially 1-x-2 clauses), as can be seen in Table 17, although a comparison with Table 16 shows that this difierence is very slight. In any event, those 1-x-2 subordinate clauses that remain cannot be accounted for by main clause word order, indicating that ENHG, like some contemporary West Germanic dialects (see Chapter 4), allows VCs with an intervening constituent (the so-called Verb Projection Raising construction). The rate of the 1-x-2 order is fairly stable throughout the period, both as a percentage of the total clauses, and as a percentage of the 1-(x)-2 orders. Thus most of the decrease over time of the non- 2-1 word orders is a result of the decrease of the 1-2 order in the strict sense rather than a decrease of the 1-x-2 order.
GoldVarb X is not equipped for multi-variate analyses, i.e., although it can calculate the raw numbers and percentages for several values of the dependent variable, it can statistically test only two values. Thus the data for 1-x-2 order are given without fuctor weights or statistical 22.
significance. 23.
Excludes Walter Ralegh.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
Table 17. Effect of time on 1-2 and 1-x-2 orders, V2 clauses removed Century
2-1
1-2
1-x-2
1350-1399 1450-1499 1550-159924
544 (68.0%) 783 (80.9%) 714 (89.0%)
227 (28.4%) 152 (15.7%) 68 (8.5%)
29 (3.6%) 33 (3.4%) 20 (2.5%)
Total
2041 (79.4%)
447 (17.4%)
82 (3.2%)
3.2.4.2 lJialect As one might expect from a linguistic feature that shows great variation by linguistic context and over time, verb order in subordinate clauses in ENHG varies widely by dialect As seen in Table 18, the frequency of the 1-2 order (in the wider sense, i.e. including 1-x-2) ranges from a low of 8.6% in texts from Cologne to a high of 41.7% in texts from Swabia. The effect of dialect on word order is one of the most significant factor groups, according to GoldVarb's step-up/step-down function. Table 18. Effect of dialect on 1-2 order 1-2
Dialect
2-1
Cologne Alsace Hesse25 Thuringia Zurich Augsburg Vienna Saxony Nuremberg Swabia
256 (91.4%) 247 (88.2%) 155 (87.6%) 179 (85.2%) 192 (83.8%) 216 (76.1%) 215 (75.7%) 193 (68.7%) 226 (64.2%) 162 (58.3%)
24 (8.6%) 33 (11.8%) 22 (12.4%) 31 (14.8%) 37 (16.2%) 68 (23.9%) 69 (24.3%) 88 (31.3%) 126 (35.8%) 116 (41.7%)
2041 (76.9%)
614 (23.1%)
Total
Factorwt. 0.259 0.332 0.346 0.392 0.418 0.539 0.544 0.629 0.674 0.727
p < 0.001 The geographical distribution of the 1-2 order is clearest when seen on a map of the German-speaking area, as in Figure 1. It appears that the main division is between the northern and western dialects (Cologne, Alsace, Hesse, Thuringia, and Zurich), with a frequency of 16% or less, and the southern and eastern dialects (Augsburg, Vienna, Saxony, Nuremberg, and Swabia), with a frequency of 23% or more. With the exceptions of Zurich and Saxony, this division roughly
24. Excludes Walter Ralegh. 25. Excludes Walter Ralegh.
69
70
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
corresponds to the isogloss bundle between Middle German or Mitteldeutsch (with varying degrees of the High German consonant shift) and Upper German or Oberdeutsch (with the complete consonant shift). The correspondence with phonological isoglosses suggests that this north-west/south-east distribution is a genuine one. Note, however, that this distribution is somewhat different from that in MHG, where the northwestern dialects had among the highest rates of the 1-2 order (see Chapter 2, Figure 1).
Figure 1. Frequency of the 1-2 order by dialect
Looking at the rate of 1-2 across the dialects and by century, however, complicates this picture a great deal. The percentages are given in Table 19 (the raw numbers can be found in Sapp 2006). Note that since the BFnhdK has only one text per dialect per century, the percentages here represent the results for just one individual text, which may account for much of the fluctuation seen here. For example, the drop in Augsburg from 58% in the 14th century to 7% in the 15th may reflect the fact that the 14th-century text is literary while the 15th-century representative is a chronicle (see Section 3.2.4.3 below for the effect of genre). As Ebert (p.c.) points out, given the fact that word order varies sociolinguistically, a single text cannot accurately represent a dialect.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
Table 19. Effect of dialect and century on 1-2 order Dialect Cologne Hesse Alsace Zurich Swabia Nuremberg Thuringia Saxony Augsburg Vienna
1350-1399
1450-1499
1550-1599
Total
5%
19%
0%
9%
6% 18%
21% 7%
69% 8%
28% 7896 43%
13% 19% 33%
12% 25% 32%
30% 12% 16%
23% 46%
21% 32%
6% 13%
58% 3496
7% 34%
4% 2%
42% 36% 15% 31% 24% 24%
Nevertheless, there are several points to be made here. First of all every dialect shows a decrease in the rate of 1-2 from the 14th to the 16th century, some with a slight increase in the 15th (the obvious exception is Hessian, see footnote 19 above). Secondly, the north-west/south-east distinction is much less clear than before. In the 14th century, Cologne and Hesse have very low rates of 1-2, while Zurich and Thuringia have considerably higher rates (although still lower than 35.5%, the 14th-century average). Then in the 15th century, Cologne, Hesse, and Thuringia have higher rates of the 1-2 order (close to the overall rate for the 15th century, 22%), while Alsace and Zurich have somewhat lower rates. In the 16th century, the south-eastern dialects have very low rates of 1-2, patterning more with the north -western dialects. Because of the complexity of the data, it is necessary to use GoldVarb to determine the best dialect groups. The best model fit resulted from the following grouping, with the percentages given in Table 20, illustrated graphically in Figure 2. Table 20. Effect of time and most significant dialect groups on 1-2 Dialect group West (Col., Hes., Als., Zur.) Central (Swabia, Nuremb.) EMG (Saxony, Thuringia) Bavarian-Austrian
1350-1399
1450-1499
1550-1599
Total
12%
15%
7%
12%
61% 43% 46%
28% 27% 21%
28% 9% 3%
38% 24% 24%
71
7:2.
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Rata of 1-2 ordar ovar time by most slgnlftcant dalact groups --+--West
70% 60%
50%
J
::!!
40%
"'
~
~-
~ 30% 20% 10%
..
--Q..-.
""' ··. .... ·..... ~""' ~
---6--EMG
••'I<
~
~
.
·~ -)(
0% 14th cent
Central
15th cent
- • ~ • BavarianAustrian
16th cent.
Figure 2. Frequency of the 1-2 order by century and dialect group
The first group is a we~ern group consisting of dialects along the Rhine. including Cologne. Hesse. Alsa.ce. and Zurich.26 As can be seen in Tables 19 and 20. these dialects have a low rate of 1-2 order in the 14th century. with a slight decrease from the 15th to the 16th century; resulting in a very low rate by the end of the period Zurich is something of an outlier in this group. with slightly higher rates of 1-2 order. The second group consists of two dialects in the center of the ENHG area. Nuremberg and Swabia These two dialects have a high rate of 1-2 in the 14th century. with a sharp drop in the 15th century. followed by little change from the 15th to the 16th century. The frequency of 1-2 order in this group is higher than in all other groups. especially at the end of the period The third group is East Middle German (Thuringia and Saxony). and the fourth group is Bavarian/Austrian (Augsburg and Vienna). These two groups behave very similarly.27 In the 14th century. they have a relatively high rate of 1-2. which decreases steadily in the 15th century along the lines of the central dialects. In the 16th century. however. the 1-2 order continues to decrease to the point where it is as infrequent as in the western dialects. These groups will need to be modified somewhat in the light of additional data. but this division based on the frequency of 1-2 alone is a good first approximation.
:2.6. Walter Ralegh is excluded. :2.7- In fact, the model fit is improved if they are combined. However, I treat them as separate
dialect areas because they are not geographically contiguous.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
3.2.4.3 Sociolinguistic factors As discussed in Chapter 1 above, previous studies have found that subordinateclause word order in ENHG is subject to a great deal of sociolinguistic variation. Therefore, in my ENHG database, clauses were coded for four sociolinguistic factors: the author's sex. education, and social class, and the genre of the text. There are only two texts by women in the corpus (Denkwiirdigkeiten and Pillenreuth Mystik), so no conclusions can be made about the influence of sex on word order. In addition, the Bonn corpus only gives education level for three of the authors, so this study can draw no conclusions about the effect of education either. Two remaining factors, occupation and genre, were among those selected in GoldVarb's step-up/step-down analysis as the most significant factor groups. The effect of occupation is obvious, with the higher-status occupations having the lowest rates of 1-2 and vice versa, as seen in Table 21.28 The two university officials and the two nobles have the 1-2 order at a rate of 8.3% and 11.7%, respectively, well below the expected rate of 17.6%. The texts by scribes, printers, and physicians have the 1-2 order at frequencies close to the expected rate. The six texts in the corpus written by clerics have the highest rate of 1-2 at 24.5%. Recall from Chapter 2 that the texts written by clerics also had the highest rates of 1-2 in MHG. Table 21. Effect of occupation on 1-2 order Occupation(# of texts)
2-1
university officials (2) nobles (2) scribes/printers (6) physicians (3) clerics (6)
166 (91.7%) 121 (88.3%) 408 (85.2%) 214 (82.3%) 415 (75.5%)
15 (8.3%) 16 (11.7%) 71 (14.8%) 46 (17.7%) 135 (24.5%)
Total p < 0.001
1324 (82.4%)
283 (17.6%)
1-2
Factorwt. 0.309 0.395 0.462 0.515 0.616
This generally confirms the findings of previous studies of ENHG. In Ebert (1981:222-223), patrician administrators have lower frequencies of 1-2 than do merchants and artisans. In Bies (1996:56), nobles and merchants do not significantly differ from each other, but clerics have 1-2 at a significantly higher rate than the other two groups. Taken together, these two studies confirm the general
28. This data excludes the many anonymous texts, most of which are early,. so the overall rate ofl-2 for this factor group (17.6%) is lower than for the corpus as a whole (24%). Furthermore, the occupations judge and merchant, which had only one representative each, are excluded. The text Walter Ralegh is excluded by virtue of (the ENHG translation) being an anonymous text
73
74
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
hierarchy in Table 21, with clerics having the highest rates of 1-2, followed by middle-class professions, with nobles having the lowest rates of 1-2. In Reifsnyder (2003: 224), however, private letters by patricians have a much higher rate of 1-2 (56.76%) than letters written by scribes on behalf of artisans (28%), letters by schoolmasters (10.34%), and official letters (4.76%). The fact that private letters by patricians differ so much from letters written by scribes in Reifsnyder's study suggests that the intended audience of the text may be as important as the class of the writer. Note that there may be some interaction between time and occupation in my study. For example, the two texts written by the university officials are from the 16th century, which could be the main reason why they have the lowest rates of 1-2. However, time alone cannot account for the high rate of 1-2 with clerics: even in the 14th and 15th centuries, clerics have a higher frequency of 1-2 than do other occupations. Genre has an eftect on word order in the current study, as can be seen in Table 22. The most formal text type in the corpus, chronicles, has the lowest frequency of 1-2 at 13.8%, well below the expected rate of 23.1%. Technical prose also has a relatively low rate of1-2 (19.4%).29 The two less formal genres, literature and religious prose, have higher-than-expected frequencies at 29.5% and 28.1% respectively. Table 22. Effect of genre on 1-2 order
Genre
2-1
1-2
Factorwt.
literature religious technical prose chronide30
196 (70.596) 941 (71.996) 249 (80.696) 655 (86.296)
82 (29.596) 367 (28.196) 60 (19.496) 105 (13.896)
0.592 0.575 0.456 0.358
2041 (76.996)
614 (23.1 96)
Total
p < 0.001 These findings are confirmed by previous scholarship. Hammarstrom (1923) finds higherrates of 1-2 in literature than in chancery documents. Ebert ( 1981: 221 ), who looked primarily at letters, found that less formal letters had higher rates of 1-2. Ebert's (1998: 166) studyof16th-centuryNurembergfound thatchanceryandother official documents had the lowest rates of1-2 (7-8%). followed by religious texts
29. Note that three of the four texts in this category were written by physicians, so it is difficult to separate genre from profession in this case. 30. Excludes Walter Ralegh.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
(19%), technical writings (26%), and private letters (23-35%).31 In Bies (1996:54), expository essays and government writings also have a lower rate of 1-2 (16.9% and 21.1 %, respectively), while literary texts have the highest frequency (43.5%). In Reifsnyder (2003: 224), official letters and city ordinances have the lowest rates of 1-2 (4.76% and 5.07%, respectively), chronicles rank in the middle (24.29%), and the highest rates are in text types closest to the spoken language, such as flyers (32.06%), guild records (48.36%), and personal letters (56.76%). It is not immediately obvious that religious texts are a less formal genre. Some of the religious texts in the corpus are less formal such as sermons, while others are more formal like the Oxfarder Benedictinerregel (the rules of a Benedictine monastery). The high rate of the 1-2 order in religious texts maybe primarily due to the fact that religious texts are overrepresented in the 14th-century. when the frequency of 1-2 was highest. Of the ten 14th-century texts in the corpus, seven are religious in nature. In contrast, only two 15th-century and five 16th-century texts are religious. Another explanation for the high rate of 1-2 in religious texts could be that many of them (but not all) are written by clerics, who show higher rates of 1-2 than other occupations, as mentioned above.
3.2.5 Conclusion In this section, I have discussed the results of my analysis of word order variation with VCs consisting of two verbs, based on a corpus of30 ENHG texts. Of the variables examined, two were not found to affect verb order: the position of the subordinate clause relative to the main clause and the alternation of stressed and unstressed syllables. On the other hand, five morpho-syntactic factors were found to affect verb order: syntagm type, the part of speech of the word preceding the VC, extraposition of an argument, new-information or contrastive focus, and type of verbal prefix. Among the sociolinguistic factors, the date, dialect, and genre of the text, as well as the occupational status of the author, play a major role in the choice of word orders. Eight of the significant factor groups were selected by GoldVarb's step-up/step-down function as the most significant combination: syntagm, constituent before the VC, focus, prefix type, date, dialect, genre, and occupation. The next section will test these same factors on subordinate clauses with complexes containing three verbs.
31. The percentages reported here are from the period 1510-1560, since fewer genres are represented in the following period (1560-1600).
75
76
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
3·3
Complexes of three verbs in ENHG
3.3.1 Introduction Of the nearly 3,000 subordinate clauses in my ENHG corpus, 166 clauses have VCs containing three verbs, and three clauses have VCs made up of four verbs.32 The basic facts regarding the four-verb complexes were given in Section 3.1.1 and will not be discussed further. Recall from Section 3.1.1 that four of the six logically possible orders for three-verb complexes are attested in ENHG: the left-selecting 3-2-1 order (4), the right-selecting 1-2-3 order (5), and two mixed orders, 1-3-2 (6) and 3-1-2 (7). (The examples are repeated here for convenience.) Of these, only 3-2-1 and 1-3-2 are widely accepted in Modern Standard German. (4) das so darvorgesetzt ist in fragweis verstanden werden soli that REL before.set is in question understood3 bez should 1 'that what is set before should be understood as a question' (Eunuchus 14) (5) so er dan den menschen nicht hat mugen vberwinden when he then the person not has 1 can2 overcome3 'when he has not been able to overcome the person' (Pillenreuth 158) (6) als er des tages scholt begraben werden as he the day should1 buried3 be2 'when he should be buried on that day'
(Pillenreuth 212)
(7) dy er ... geta.n solt ha.ben REL he done 3 should 1 have2 'that he should have done'
(Pillenreuth 159)
Moreover, recall that a constituent may intervene in verbal complexes with the orders 1-3-2 and 1-2-3. These orders were described in Section 3.1.1 above, and hereafter will be treated with the other instances of 1-3-2 and 1-2-3. Recall that GoldVarb X allows only binomial analyses, thus I ran four separate analyses for each factor group. (See Chapter 2.3.1 on how to interpret these tables.) Because there are only 169 clauses in my database with three-verb clusters and these are divided among four dependent variables, statistical significance is only rarely found. Any analyses for which no p value is indicated can be assumed to be not significant.
32. Hereafter, the four-verb complexes will be analyzed together with the others. Recall that these display the order 1-2-4-3; they are treated here as instances of 1-2-3.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
This section is organized as follows. In Section 3.3.2, I will present two factors that do not affect word order in three-verb complexes, although they did have an effect in VCs with two verbs: preceding word and extraposition.33 Section 3.3.3 discusses the three factors that do affect verb placement in these VCs: syntagm type, focus, and verbal prefixes. Finally, Section 3.3.4 discusses the effect of date, dialect, and sociolinguistic factors on three-verb complexes. 3.3.2 Non-favoring factors 3·3·2.1 Word/phrase preceding the verbal complex In Section 3.2.3.2 above, I found that the category of the word preceding the VC had little effect on the order of the VC with two verbs. Likewise, for complexes of three verbs, this factor group is not significant for any of the word orders, as shown in Table 23. Thus no firm conclusions can be drawn. For the record, however, note that for the more frequent categories adverb and prepositional phrase, the percentages for each word order are close to the expected rates. On the other hand, after NPs the 3-2-1 order is disfavored, occurring at just 9.8%, well below the expected 17.8%, while the order 3-1-2 is favored, occurring 31.4% of the time, above the expected rate of 23.1 %. Although not significant, these results are surprising, since NPs had no effect on the order of two-verb clusters. Table 23. Effect of the preceding category on three-verb complexes
Cat. of prec. word noun I pron./ QP
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
3-1-2
adjective adverb prepositional phrase nothing precedes
5 (9.896) 2 (40.0%) 7 (15.6%) 11 (20.496) 5 (35.796)
18 (35.3%) 1 (20.0%) 22 (48.9%) 24 (44.4%) 5 (35.7%)
12 (23.596) 1 (20.096) 8 (17.896) 7 (13.0%) 2 (14.396)
16 (31.496) 1 (20.0%) 8 (17.8%) 12 (22.296) 2 (14.396)
Total
30 (17.896)
70 (41.4%)
30 (17.8%)
39 (23.196)
In Table 24, the effect of the word preceding the VC is shown, this time coded by phonological weight rather than part of speech. Analyzed this way, the preceding word still has no statistically significant effect on complexes of three verbs, and the factor weights are fairly close to 0.5 in all cases.
33· The other two fuctors that had no effect on two-verb dusters, position of the subordinate clause in the sentence and alternation of stressed and unstressed syllables, were not tested on three-verb dusters in the pilot study (Sapp 2005) and will not be treated here.
77
78
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Table 24. Effect of the preceding stress on three -verb complexes Stress of prec. word
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
3-1-2
stressed unstressed nothing precedes
23 (20.5%) 5 (10.0%) 2 (28.6%)
44 (39.3%) 25 (50.0%) 1 (14.3%)
20 (17.9%) 8 (16.0%) 2 (28.6%)
25 (22.3%) 12 (24.0%) 2 (28.6%)
Total
30 (17.8%)
70 (41.4%)
30 (17.8%)
39 (23.1%)
3.3.2.2 Extraposition The previous factor group had no efiect on either two-verb or three-verb complexes. NP/PP extraposition, on the other hand, has an effect on two-verb complexes (as shown in Section 3.2.3.3 above), but no effect on VCs with three verbs. As seen in Table 25, the effect of this factor group is not statistically significant for any of the four word orders.34 Table 25. Effect of extraposition on three-verb complexes Extraposition
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
3-1-2
extrap. argument nothing extraposed extrap. adjunct PP
1 (16.7%) 26 (17.1%) 3 (27.3%)
1 (16.7%) 65 (42.8%) 4 (36.4%)
1 (16.7%) 28 (18.4%) 1 (9.1 %)
3 (27.3%) 33 (21.7%) 3 (50.0%)
Total
30 (17.8%)
70 (41.4%)
30 (17.8%)
39 (23.1%)
Although no firm conclusions can be drawn concerning the efiect of extraposition on verb order in three-verb complexes, the following observations can be made about extraposition in these clauses. First of all, of the 169 clauses with three-verb complexes, 17 clauses or just over 10% have extraposition. This rate is lower than the rate of extraposition with two-verb complexes (15.9%), suggesting that the larger VCs may be more difficult to extrapose around. Secondly, note that while adjunct PPs made up just half of the cases of extraposition with twoverb complexes, adjunct PPs make up more than half of the cases of extraposition with three-verb complexes (11 out of 17, or 65%). This suggests that whatever the impediment for extraposition over three-verb complexes may be, it is easier to extra pose adjunct PPs than other constituents. Having discussed two factors which do not affect word order in clusters of three verbs, in the next section we turn to three factors that do. These are syntagm type, focus, and verbal prefixes.
34· Further tests did not result in improved significance, neither combining extraposed adjunct PPs with other extraposed constituents, nor combining extraposed adjunct PPs with clauses without extraposition.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
3·3·3 Favoring factors 3·3·3·1 Syntagm type In Section 3.2.3.1 above, we saw that syntagm type plays a major role in subordinate clauses with VCs consisting of two verbs. Table 26 and Table 27 demonstrate that this is also the case for complexes of three verbs. Table 26 shows the distribution of the attested syntagms, which are illustrated in (35) -(43): (35) als er des tages scholt begra.ben werden as he the day should1 buried3 be2 'when he should be buried on that day' (36) das auB Guiana gellracht worden ist REL from G. brought3 b~ is 1 'which has been brought from Guyana' (37) dy er ... getan solt haben REL he done3 should 1 hav~ 'that he should have done ...
(modal + passive)
(Pillenreuth 212) (perfect of passive)
(Wa.lter Ralegh iv) (modal+ perfect)
(Pillenreuth 159)
(38) so er dan den menschen nicht hat mugen vberwinden (IPP) not has 1 can2 overcome3 when he then the person 'when he has not been able to overcome the person' (Pillenreuth 158)
hat gehoert reden (39) das thais phedriam ee that T. P. more has 1 heard2 speak.3 'that Thais heard Phedria speak, rather (than saw him)' (40) dz si es ... willen behaben mugent that they it want2 have3 can1 'that they may want to have it'
(pertect + ACI)35
(Eunuchus 23) (mod.+ mod.+ int~)
(EdUbach Chr. 9)
(41) Weyl sie an disen zeichen sich nicht wo 6 llett settigen lassen(causative) because they on these signs REFL not want1 satisty3 let2 'because they do not want to be satisfied by these signs' (Summaria 21r) (42) wenn . . . Jesus . . . wird . . . herrlich gemacht werden when J. wil11 glorious made3 be 2 'When ... Jesus ... will ... be made glorious'
(future passive)
(Passionate 42v)
(43) da6 wir also eine ... Heymfahrt wuerden gehabt haben (future perfect) that we such a return-trip would 1 had3 have 2 'that we would have had such a ... return journey' (Wa.ltet· Ra.legh 5)
35· Both instances of this construction have gehoert as the second verb.
79
so The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Table 26. Effect of specific syntagms on three-verb complexes Syntagm
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
3-1-2
modal + passive perfect of passive modal + perfect IPP perfect + ACI modal + modal + inf modal + causative future + pass./perf Total
20 (25.096) 7 (26.9%) 1 (12.5%) 0 (0.096) 0 (0.0%) 1 (25.0%) 1 (7.1%) 0 (0.0%)
36 (45.0%) 9 (34.6%) 5 (62.5%) 10 (30.3%) 0 (0.096) 1 (25.0%) 7 (50.0%) 2 (100.0%)
2 (2.5%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 22 (66.7%) 2 (100.0%) 1 (25.0%) 3 (21.4%) 0 (0.096)
22 (27.596) 10 (38.5%) 2 (25.0%) 1 (3.096) 0 (0.0%) 1 (25.0%) 3 (21.4%) 0 (0.0%)
30 (17.8%)
70 (41.4%)
30 (17.8%)
39 (23.1 %)
Note that there are many syntagms that have no occurrences with a given word order. These zeros are known in GoldVarb as knock-out factors, and preclude GoldVarb from running a statistical analysis. Thus there is no statistical significance available for Table 26. In Table 27, the minor syntagms perfect+ ACI and future passive/perfect have been removed. The remaining ones are analyzed in the most significant combination, with the three main kinds of syntagms containing a participle (35)-(37) combined, the IPP (38) left separately, and the two syntagms containing a modal plus two infinitives (modal+ causative and modal +modal+ infinitive) combined. Table 27. Effect of general syntagm type on three -verb complexes Syntagm
3-2-1
1-3-2
modal + passive, perfect of passive, modal + perfect IPP modal + inf + inf Total significance
28 (23.7%)
52 (44.1%)
4 (3.4%)
34 (28.8%)
0 (0.0%) 2 (11.1%) 30 (17.896)
10 (30.3%) 8 (44.4%) 70 (41.4%)
22 (66.7%) 4 (22.2%) 30 (17.8%)
1 (3.0%) 4 (22.2%) 39 (23.196)
p = 0.075
p = 0.351
p < 0.001
p =0.003
1-2-3
3-1-2
The results for three-verb complexes are similar to those with two verbs. Recall from Table 4 that in two-verb clusters, syntagms with a participle slightly disfavor the 1-2 order. Similarly, three-verb syntagms with participles strongly disfavor the 1-2-3 order, occurring just 3.4% of the time versus the expected rate of 17.8% (factor weight 0.262), while slightly favoring the other orders. Recall also from Table 4 that in two-verb complexes, syntagms with an infinitive strongly favor the 1-2 order and disfavor the 2-1 order. Likewise, three-verb syntagms with infinitives strongly disfavor the 3-2-1 order: this order is unat-
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
tested for IPP and occurs only twice for modal plus two infinitives.36 The IPP construction overwhelmingly favors the 1-2-3 order at a rate of 66.7% (factor weight= 0.860). To an equal degree, IPP disfavors the 3-1-2 order, with a rate of only 3% versus the expected 23.1% (factor weight= 0.117). Finally, note that the frequency of the 1-3-2 order for each syntagm is close to the expected rate (41.4%), indicating that syntagm has little effect on this word order (which is probably the reason for the low significance of the factor group). The fact that the 1-3-2 order is the most frequent, plus the fact that syntagm type has little effect on it, indicates that it may be the unmarked order inENHG. Since the number of tokens with three verbs in my corpus is small. my results should be compared to those in the much larger study by Hard (1981). For the period 1450-1580, Hard has 2,704 tokens with three or more verbs. Results from Hard for this period are presented in Table 28.37 Table 28. Verb orders by syntagm in Hard (1981 :46-52) Syntagm (Hard's class)
3-2-1
1-3-2
modal + pass. I perf. (III) perfect of passive (I) perfect + IPP (IV) modal + in£ + in£ (V, VI) werden + pass. I perf (II)
15.8% 23.2% 2.3% 15.1% 17.8%
56.7% 26.3% 28.8% 43.3% 72.1%
1-2-338
56.9% 30.4%
3-1-2 27.5% 40% 8.3% 11.1% 10.1%
Hard's results are remarkably similar to my data in Table 26, with identical rankings for all syntagms except modal + two infinitives. As in my corpus, the modal+ passive and modal + perfect have 1-3-2 as the most frequent order (56.7% in Hard, versus 45% and 62.5% in mine), followed by 3-1-2 and 3-2-1. The perfect of the passive favors the 3-1-2 order (40% in Hard and 38.5% in my study), followed by 1-3-2 and 3-2-1. The IPP construction strongly prefers the
36. In another test of the 3-2-1 order, I combined these two factors, testing them against the participial syntagms. The result, which was significant (p < 0.001), was that the two infinitival syntagms strongly disfavor the 3-2-1 order (factor weight= 0.130). 37· Hl1rd refers to these orders by the position of the finite verb: "Endstellung" (3-2-1 ), "Voranstellung" (1-3-2 and 1-2-3), and "Zwischenstellung" (3-1-2). 38. Hl1rd (1981:59) only distinguishes 1-3-2 from 1-2-3 in the IPP and modal+ inf. +in£ constructions. He claims that the 1-2-3 order is rare for the other constructions, except in Low German, and thus does not give separate percentages for 1-3-2 vs. 1-2-3 for those syntagms..
81
82
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
1-2-3 order in both studies (56.9% and 66.7%, respectively), followed by 1-32 and 3-1-2, with the 3-2-1 order being nearly unattested in Hard (2.3%) and unattested in my study. Finally, a finite verb plus two infinitives favors the 1-3-2 order in Hard's corpus (43.3%), and in my study the 1-3-2 order accounts for 8 out of 18 examples (or 44.4%) of the two types modal+ modal+ infinitive and modal + causative. The overwhelming agreement between the current study and Hard (1981) confirms that the data in Table 26 and Table 27, despite the small number of tokens and statistical insignificance, are indeed representative ofENHG as a whole. 3·3·3·2 Focus In Section 3.2.3.4 above, I showed that contrastive focus and new information focus favor the 1-2 order, while old information favors the 2-1 order. The effect of focus on complexes of three verbs can be seen in Table 29 (with contrastive focus and new information combined due to the small number of tokens). Just as old information favors the 2-1 order with two-verb complexes, in threeverb complexes it favors the 3-2-1 order, at a rate of 24.4% versus the expected 17.8% (factor weight= 0.612). Contrastive focus and new information favor the combination of the other three orders, occurring 87.9% of the time versus the expected 82.2%. Table 29. Effect of focus on three-verb complexes Focus
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
3-1-2
new/contrastive old information Total significance
11 (12.1%) 19 (24.4%)
40 (44.0%) 30 (38.5%)
17 (18.7%) 13 (16.7%)
23 (25.3%) 16 (20.5%)
30 (17.8%)
70 (41.4%)
30 (17.8%)
39 (23.1%)
p = 0.040
p = 0.478
p = 0.737
p =0.473
Although focus favors the 1-3-2, 1-2-3, and 3-1-2 orders combined (tested against 3-2-1), no effect could be detected on these word orders individually. The results for these orders alone were not statistically significant. For all three orders, the frequency with focus is just one or two percentage points over the expected rate, with factor rates very close to 0.5. It was not possible to corroborate the effect of focus on three-verb complexes by comparing it to scrambling. Out of the already small number of clauses with three verbs, there were only a handful with both an object and an adverb.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
3·3·3·3 Prefix tvpe Section 3.2.3.5 above demonstrated for two-verb complexes that the type of verbal prefix afiects verb order. A similar efiect is found in VCs with three verbs, as shown in Table 30. Just as two-verb complexes containing a separable prefix favor 1-2, in three-verb complexes, the rate of the 1-2-3 order with such verbs is 45.5% (factor weight= 0.843), well above the expected rate of 17.8%. Likewise, just as stressed prefixes disfavor the 2-1 order with two verbs, with stressed prefixes the rate of 3-2-1 order is quite low at just 9.1% (factor weight= 0.353). The 3-1-2 order patterns very similarly to the 3-2-1 order in this factor group, with a rate of only 9.1% with stressed prefixes (factor weight= 0.275) versus 23.1% overall. As with syntagm type and focus, this factor group has no effect on the 1-3-2 order, again suggesting that it is the default order in ENHG. Table 30. Effect of prefix type on three-verb complexes
Prefix type
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
3-1-2
stressed no prefix unstressed
2 (9.196) 1 (3.796) 27 (22.596)
8 (36.496) 13 (48.196) 49 (40.896)
10 (45.596) 11 (40.796) 9 (7.596)
2 (9.196) 2 (7.496) 35 (29.296)
Total
30 (17.896)
70 (41.496)
30 (17.896)
39 (23.196)
significance
p = O.Q18
p =0.689
p < 0.001
p =0.008
An interesting difference between the two-verb and three-verb complexes is the effect of verbs with no prefix. Recall from Table 11 that prefixless verbs had no effect on verb order, patterning with the verbs with unstressed prefixes. With three verbs. however, the percentages and factor weights for verbs with no prefix are remarkably close to those for verbs with stressed prefixes (factor weight= 0.816 for 1-2-3, versus 0.174 for 3-2-1 and 0.233 for 3-1-2). The fact that in three-verb complexes, verbs with no prefix pattern with the SSPs rather than the unstressed prefixes suggest that something other than prefix type is really at play. This pattern is most likely due to an interaction with syntagm type. The vast majority of past participles in ENHG have an unstressed prefix, usually ge-. On the other hand, infinitives may have a stressed, unstressed, or no prefix depending on the lexical item. To illustrate this interaction, Table 31 compares the top line of Table 27 with the "Unstressed" line of Table 30. Note that the numbers are almost exactly the same, indicating that the exact same tokens are involved.
83
84
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Table 31. Comparison of tokens with participle and unstressed prefix Factor
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
3-1-2
syntagms with participle unstressed prefix
28 27
52 49
4 9
34 35
For two-verb complexes, the cross-tabulation in Table 12 illustrated that the effect of the prefix on verb order was independent of syntagm type. For complexes of three verbs, however, this interaction cannot be ruled out, as illustrated by the cross-tabulation in Table 32. In syntagms with a participle, with a stressed or no prefix the 1-3-2 order is most frequent (62% vs. the total rate of 44% for that word order with participles), but with an unstressed prefix all four word orders are close to the expected (total) frequencies. In syntagms with infinitives, on the other hand, the rate of 1-2-3 order is higher than expected with a stressed prefix or no prefix (58% vs. the expected 51% of 1-2-3 with an infinitive). The fact that the factor stressed/no prefix strongly prefers one order with participles (1-3-2) but another with infinitives (1-2-3) suggests that the effect of prefix type is subordinate to the effect of syntagm. Table 32. Cross-tab of prefix type with syntagm type (three verbs) Prefix type stressed I no prefix
unstressed
Total
word order
participle
infinitive
Total
3-2-1
2 (12%)
1 (3%)
3 (6%)
1-3-2
10 (62%)
11 (33%)
21 (43%)
1-2-3
2 (12%)
19 (58%)
21 (43%)
3-1-2
2 (12%)
2 (6%)
4 (8%)
3-2-1
26 (25%)
1 (7%)
27 (22%)
1-3-2
42 (41%)
7 (39%)
49 (41%)
1-2-3
2(2%)
7 (39%)
9 (8%)
3-1-2
32 (31%)
3 (17%)
35 (29%)
3-2-1
28 (24%)
2 (4%)
30 (18%)
1-3-2
52 (44%)
18 (35%)
70 (41%)
1-2-3
4(3%)
26 (51%)
30 (18%)
3-1-2
34 (29%)
5 (10%)
39 (23%)
Having discussed some linguistic factors that affect word order in VCs with three verbs, in the next section we turn to the distribution of these word orders by century, dialect, and sociolinguistic variables.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
3·3·4 Diachronic, dialectal, and sociolinguistic variation 3·3·4·1 Date In Section 3.2.4.1 above, we saw that there is a decrease in the rate of1-2 from the 14th to the 16th century. The picture with three-verb complexes is more complicated, as seen in Table 33. The only order with statistically significant results is the 3-1-2 order, which shows a rise in frequency in the 15th century (factor weight= 0.771), followed by a sharp drop to just 13.5% in the 16th century (factor weight= 0.376). The low frequency of 3-1-2 near the end of the ENHG period should not be surprising, since this order is ungrammatical in most written varieties of Modern Standard German. Table 33. Effect of time on three -verb complexes
Century
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
3-1-2
14th century 15th century 16th century
1 (7.7%) 6 (13.3%) 23 (20.7%)
8 (61.5%) 13 (28.9%) 49 (44.1%)
1 (7.7%) 5 (11.1%) 24 (21.6%)
3 (23.1%) 21 (46.7%) 15 (13.5%)
Total
30 (17.8%)
70 (41.4%)
30 (17.8%)
39 (23.1%)
significance
p = 0.304
p =0.068
p = 0.165
p <0.001
The results for the other orders are not statistically significant; however, some basic trends can be seen. First, the 3-2-1 order (with only one attestation in MHG and just one in the 14th century) shows a gradual increase from century to century, which is expected since this is the most common order for three-verb complexes in Modern Standard German. Secondly; the 1-3-2 order fluctuates in inverse proportion to the 3-1-2 order, suggesting that the increase in the 3-1-2 order in the 15th century discussed above was at the expense of 1-3-2. Finally; the 1-2-3 order gradually increases over the course of the period, which is surprising given the fact that this order is ungrammatical in Modern Standard German. To test whether the results from my small number of tokens are representative for ENHG as a whole, let us compare them to the much larger study by Hard (1981). As can be seen in Table 34, the results from the two studies are largely similar. In the period 1450-1500, both studies have similar rates of the "Voranstellung" word orders 1-3-2 and 1-2-3 (41% and 40%), and the rates of 3-1-2 in both studies are also similar. In both studies, the least frequent order in this period is 3-2-1. For the second period (1550-1580), the frequencies are also similar across the two studies, with the vast majority of the tokens (71% and 66%) having the 1-3-2/1-2-3 orders. The diachronic trends also show similarity; with
85
86
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
the frequency of the 1-3-2/1-2-3 orders sharply increasing from the first period to the next, while the 3-1-2 order declines sharply. The major difference is that my study shows the 3-2-1 order increasing, from 13% to 21%, while Hard finds that the 3-2-1 order decreased from 26% to 14%. Table 34. Effect of time on three-verb complexes: Comparison to Hiird
Period
3-2-1
1-3-2/1-2-3
3-1-2
Hil.rd: 1450-150039
105 (26%) 6 (13%)
198 (41%) 18 (40%)
182 (36%) 21 (47%)
93 (14%) 23 (21%)
489 (71%) 73 (66%)
99 (15%) 15 (14%)
Table 33: 1450-1500 Hil.rd: 1550-158040
Table 33: 1550-1600
To sum up the findings of this section in light of Hard (1981), the 3-1-2 order declines sharply over the ENHG period, while the 1-3-2 order increases sharply. The status of the 1-2-3 order is less dear, since my results are not statistically significant and Hard's are split by syntagm. 41 Finally, despite being the most typical order in Modern Standard German, the 3-2-1 order remains relatively infrequent in ENHG. 3·3·4·2 Dialect As might be expected given the rather complex dialectal distribution ofVCs with two verbs (Section 3.2.4.2 above), the picture with three verbs is even more complicated, as shown in Table 35. Given the small number of tokens per dialect, for none of the four word orders is this factor group statistically significant The four main dialect groups suggested for VCs consisting of two verbs in Section 3.2.4.2 above do not hold for complexes of three verbs. For example, in the proposed Western group of dialects, Cologne, Alsace, and Zurich each prefer a different order for three-verb complexes.
39. Calculated from the tables in Hard (1981: 38-39). I took the 485 tokens containing three verbs (ignoring those with an elided verb form or more than four verbs) from texts 1-16. All ofthese texts were begun in the period 1450-1500, although some were completed as late as 1519. 40. Calculated from the tables in Hil.rd (1981: 38-39). I took the 681 tokens (same criteria as above) from texts 43-55. 41. The IPP construction maintains a high rate of 1-2-3, while this order declines for the modal + in£ + in£ constructions, and the rate of 1-2-3 order is unreported for other constructions
(Hil.rd 1981: 61).
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
Table 35. Effect of dialect on three-verb complexes Dialect42
3-2-1
Cologne Hesse Alsace Zurich Swabia Nuremberg Thuringia Saxony Augsburg Vienna
9 (45.0%) 2 (8.3%) 3 (16.7%) 2 (11.1%) 3 (18.8%) 0 (0.0%) 0 (0.0%) 3 (17.6%) 4 (25.0%) 4 (26.7%)
Total
30 (17.8%)
1-3-2
1-2-3
3-1-2
8 (40.0%) 10 (41.7%) 8 (44.4%) 5 (27.8%) 6 (37.5%) 8 (40.0%) 4 (80.0%) 9 (52.9%) 7 (43.8%) 5 (33.3%)
1 (5.0%) 7 (29.2%) 1 (5.6%) 6 (33.3%) 4 (25.0%) 5 (25.0%) 0 (0.0%) 3 (17.6%) 2 (12.5%) 1 (6.7%)
2 (10.0%) 5 (20.8%) 6 (33.3%) 5 (27.8%) 3 (18.8%) 7 (35.0%) 1 (20.0%) 2(11.8%) 3 (18.8%) 5 (33.3%)
70 (41.4%)
30 (17.8%)
39 (23.1%)
The best model fit for dusters of three verbs requires the dialects to be divided up in a slightly different way, with Zurich moved to the proposed Central group, as in Table 36. This represents the best recode for the 1-2-3 order, but the recode is statistically significant only for that order. The combined dialects Zurich, Swabia, and Nuremberg strongly favor 1-2-3 at 27.8% versus the expected 15.9% (factor weight= 0.706). Note that the p number of the 3-2-1 order is quite low, although still not statistically significant. 43 Although not significant, in this recode, 3-2-1 is favored in Cologne-Hesse-Alsace at 27.3% and in Bavaria-Austria at 25.8%. Table 36. Effect of dialect on three-verb complexes (most significant) Dialect
3-2-1
1-3-2
Col-Hes.44-Als.
12 (27.3%)
16 (36.4%)
3 (6.8%)
13 (29.5%)
5 (9.3%) 3 (13.6%) 8 (25.8%)
19 (35.2%) 13 (59.1%) 12 (38.7%)
15 (27.8%) 3 (13.6%) 3 (9.7%)
15 (27.8%) 3 (13.6%) 8 (25.8%)
Zur.-SWab.-Nuremb. EMG (Thur.-Sax.) Bavarian-Austrian
1-2-3
3-1-2
Total
28 (18.5%)
60 (39.7%)
24 (15.9%)
39 (25.8%)
significance
p=0.074
p = 0.243
p= 0.023
p = 0.404
42. All of the data for Hessian are included in this table, but statistical analyses were conducted without the text WaltEr Ralegh, which has a very high rate of3-2-1. Furthermore, the 3-2-1 order was tested without Nuremberg and Thuringia, and the 1-2-3 order was also tested without Thuringia, since those dialects had no instances of the respective word orders. 43· This recode was the closest to statistical significance for the 3-2-1 order.
44· Excludes Walter Ralegh.
87
88
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
In Table 37, I have taken the percentages from Hard (1981) and my data from Table 35, and combined them into the dialect groups discussed above. The conclusion reached above that the dialect area containing Cologne, Hesse, and Alsace favors the 3-2-1 order is untenable, since in Hard's study this area has this order at a rate of only 24%, which is comparable with other dialects. Doubt is also cast on my conclusion that the 1-2-3 order is favored in Switzerland, Swabia, and Nuremberg, since their rate of the 1-3-2/1-2-3 orders is much lower in Hard's study (43%) than in mine (63%). On the other hand, the comparison with Hard (1981) lends some support to my conclusions that the 1-3-2 order is favored in East Middle German while the 3-2-1 order is favored in BavarianAustrian. Table 37. Frequency of orders by dialect group: compared to Hiird
Dialect Hitrd: Sapp: Hitrd: Sapp: Hitrd: Sapp: Hard: Sapp:
Hesse-Alsace Cologne-Hesse-Alsace Switz.-Swabia-Franc. Zurich -Swabia-Nuremb. Thuringia-Saxony Thuringia-Saxony Bavaria Bavarian-Austrian
3-2-1 45 (24%) 12 (27%) 257 (24%) 5 (9%) 44 (23%) 3 (14%) 129 (44%) 8 (26%)
1-3-2/1-2-3
3-1-2
128 19 456 34 117 16 107 15
16 (8%) 13 (30%) 341 (32%) 15 (28%) 31 (16%) 3 (14%) 60 (20%) 8 (26%)
(68%) (43%) (43%) (63%) (61%) (7296) (3696) (4896)
This data will be weighed against that regarding two-verb complexes and additional data in Section 3.4.1 below, which will settle on a final dialect division for ENHG. 3·3·4·3 Sociolinguistic factors In Section 3.2.4.3 above, I showed that occupation and genre have an effect on word order in two-verb complexes, with higher status writers and more formal genres preferring the 2-1 order. However, with three-verb complexes, the picture is much less clear, probably due to the very small number of tokens for each of the four word orders. As seen in Table 38, the 3-2-1 order is disfavored only by physicians, and is slightly favored by all other occupations, although these results are not significant. The 1-3-2 and 1-2-3 orders are not statistically significant either, but for therecord, 1-3-2 is favored by scribes/printers and clerics, and 1-2-3 is favored by university officials and clerics. Finally, in the only significant result, the 3-1-2 order is favored by nobles (factor weight= 0.716) and physicians (factor weight= 0.809).
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
Table 38. Effect of occupation on three-verb complexes Occupation45 university officials nobles scribes/printers physicians clerics Total significance
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
3-1-2
5 (26.3%)
7 (36.896)
4 (21.1%)
3 (15.8%)
4 (33.3%) 6 (28.6%) 1 (4.5%) 8 (19.0%)
3 (25.0%) 10 (47.6%) 5 (22.7%) 19 (45.2%)
0 (0.096) 1 (4.8%) 4 (18.2%) 10 (23.8%)
5 (41.7%) 4 (19.0%) 12 (54.5%) 5 (11.9%)
24 (20.7%)
44 (37.996)
19 (16.4%)
29 (25.0%)
p =0.110
p =0.237
p =0.230
p =0.005
There are a few parallels between the distributions of two-verb complexes and three-verb complexes. First, recall from Table 21 that nobles (along with university officials) had the highest rate of 2-1; likewise, nobles have the highest rate of the 3-2-1 order. Second, clerics had the highest rates of 1-2, and indeed they have a high rate of the 1-2-3 order. On the other hand, there are a number of facts that do not correlate with the distribution of two-verb complexes, such as the very high rate of the 3-1-2 order among nobles and physicians. Genre is statistically significant only for the 1-2-3 and 3-1-2 orders, as seen in Table 39. However, for completeness' sake I briefly discuss the favoring effect on all four orders. The 3-2-1 order is favored in chronicles and literary texts. Literary texts also favor the 1-3-2 order. The 1-2-3 order is favored in religious texts (factor weight= 0.632) but strongly disfavored in chronicles (factor weight= 0.166). Finally, the 3-1-2 order is favored in chronicles (factor weight= 0.680) and technical texts (factor weight= 0.804). Table 39. Effect of genre on three-verb complexes Genre
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
3-1-2
literature religious technical prose chroniclf46
5 (27.8%) 13 (16.9%) 1 (4.5%) 9 (26.5%)
9 (50.096) 35 (45.596) 5 (22.7%) 11 (32.4%)
3 (16.7%) 16 (20.8%) 4 (18.296) 1 (2.9%)
1 (5.6%) 13 (16.9%) 12 (54.5%) 13 (38.2%)
Total significance
28 (18.5%)
60 (39.7%)
24 (15.996)
39 (25.8%)
p = 0.100
p = 0.137
p = 0.050
p < 0.001
45· This data excludes the many anonymous texts (including Walter Ralegh), as well as the occupations judge and merchant, which had only one representative each. 46. Excludes Walter Ralegh.
89
90
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Note first of all that all of the texts in the genre technical prose are written by physicians, thus the distributions of the different word orders are exactly the same for those two factors. Disregarding technical prose and literature, which have few tokens, the following parallels between the two-verb complexes and three-verb complexes obtain. Recall from Table 22 that chronicles have the highest frequency of the 2-1 order, and similarly they favor the 3-2-1 order and strongly disfavor the 1-2-3 order. Conversely, religious texts have the highest rate of 1-2, and indeed they favor the 1-2-3 order as well. On a final note, the high frequency of 3-1-2 order in chronicles, a relatively formal genre, is surprising, since this order is ungrammatical in (written) Modern Standard German. This section also found a high rate of this order with nobles. Recall from 3.3.4.1 that this order sharply decreased from the 15th to the 16th centuries. Sociolinguistic pressures may have caused the increase in the 3-2-1 and 1-3-2 orders, as argued by Hammarstrom (1923), who found higher rates of 3-2-1 in official documents than in literature. However, the reason for the decline of the 3-1-2 order is much less clear, since it was frequent in formal genres and among the highest-status writers. 3·3·5 Conclusion In this section, I have discussed the factors that do and do not favor various word orders in VCs with three verbs in ENHG and drawn comparisons where possible with the more extensive study by Hard (1981). Preceding constituent, which does not affect verb order in ENHG two-verb complexes, has no effect in three-verb complexes either, and extraposition, which does affect two-verb complexes, has no effect on three-verb clusters. Syntagm plays a major role in the choice of word orders, with the IPP construction favoring the 1-2-3 order and most other syntagms favoring 3-2-1 and 1-3-2. Focus disfavors the 3-2-1 order, and slightly favors the others. The type of prefix on the lexical verb also affects word order, although this is largely due to interaction with syntagm type. The frequency of the different orders varies in somewhat unpredictable ways by date, dialect, occupation of the author, and genre of the text. Finally, I have suggested that 1-3-2 is the unmarked order in ENHG, since it exhibits the least syntactic and sociolinguistic variation.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
3·4
Discussion
3-4-1 Favoring factors in individual texts and dialects In Sapp (2006), the most significant favoring factors in the database as a whole were used to conduct separate GoldVarb analyses on each dialect and each text in the database. Although the details for each text and dialect will not be discussed here, a few important conclusions result from those studies. In general the factors that favor the 1-2 order in the whole ENHG corpus also favor it in the individual analyses (albeit with reduced significance due to the lower number of tokens). Thus the results for ENHG discussed above are genuine features of the language, rather than some accidental result of the combination of the texts in the database. Four factors have a consistent favoring effect on the 1-2 order in every dialect, and indeed in almost every text. In fact, these are the four factors that were shown to favor that order in the whole ENHG database in Section 3.2.3 above: syntagm, extraposition, focus, and prefix type. As expected, syntagms with infinitives favor the 1-2 order in every dialect and in most of the individual texts (Sapp 2006: 174 ). Prefix type has an effect on word order in every dialect except Alsatian (Sapp 2006: 175). Focus also favors 1-2 in all dialects (Sapp 2006: 175), although due to the small number of tokens no difference between new information and contrastive focus could be determined, nor could the effect of focus be supported by evidence from scrambling. Extraposition favors the 1-2 order in every dialect, although in many dialects this effect disappears by the 16th century. Recall from Section 3.2.3.3 above that in the database as a whole, the extraposition of an adjunct PP has a weaker favoring effect on the 1-2 order than the extraposition of other constituents. This is also true in almost all of the individual dialects, except Swabia and Nuremberg, where adjunct-PP extraposition actually favors 1-2 more strongly than other types of extraposition (Sapp 2006: 180). Preceding constituent was the most inconsistent factor group. Recall that Ebert (1981) found that preceding non-pronominal NPs favor and pronouns disfavor the 1-2 order in letters from Nuremberg, and similar results obtain in my MHG database (Chapter 2 above). However, as shown in Section 3.2.3.2, no such effect was found in my ENHG database as a whole. The analyses of individual dialects in Sapp (2006: 179) find a number of dialects that do indeed show the favoring effect of preceding NPs on 1-2: Cologne, Hesse, Saxony, Thuringia, Nuremberg, and Swabia. On the other hand, three dialects actually show the opposite effect: Augsburg, Vienna, and Swiss. The remaining dialect, Alsatian, shows no effect at all. Thus it appears that the lack of any difference between preceding
91
92
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
non-pronominal NPs and pronouns in Section 3.2.3.2 above is due to the fact that the dialects where NPs favor the 1-2 order are cancelled out by those where NPs disfavor 1-2. Finally, note that in the 16th century, several texts have such a low frequency of the 1-2 order that it is difficult to determine what factors, if any, favor the 1-2 order (Sapp 2006: 180). Cologne has no instances of 1-2, Vienna has some instances but with no favoring effects, and in Augsburg only syntagm shows any effect. In the other dialects, however, many favoring factors are still detectable despite the very low rate of 1-2.
3.4.2 Dialect groups in ENHG The favoring factors discussed in the previous section can now help complete the discussion of the dialect groups begun in previous sections. Recall that in Section 3.2.4.2, using the frequency of the 1-2 order as the criterion, a Western group was proposed, which included Cologne, Hesse, Alsace, and Zurich. In Section 3.3.4.2, this group was modified to exclude Zurich based on the behavior of three-verb complexes. Now, let us draw in a third line of argument: the factors that fuvor the 1-2 order in individual dialects in Sapp (2006). Three differences in the favoring factors are summarized in Table 40: the effect of an NP immediately preceding the VC, the effect of adjunct-PP extraposition, and whether any factors have an effect in the 16th century. Table 40. Differences in the favoring factors, by dialect Dialect
precedingNP favors 1-2
lower% of 1-2 with adj.-PP extraposition
favoring factors in 16th century
Cologne Hesse47 Alsace Zurich Swabia Nuremberg Thuringia Saxony Augsburg Vienna
yes yes no effect no yes yes yes yes no no
yes yes yes yes no
no n/a yes yes yes yes yes yes no no
no yes yes yes yes
47· This excludes the problematic text Walter Ralegh, thus there is no result for 16th-century Hessian.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
Using these criteria, five different dialect groups emerge, each consisting of two regions. First, Cologne and Hesse show a favoring effect of the preceding nonpronominal NP on the 1-2 order and a lower rate of the 1-2 order with the extraposition of adjunct PPs. (The third criterion is inconclusive, due to the exclusion of Walter Ralegh.) Second, Alsace and Zurich show either a disfavoring or no effect of a preceding NP on 1-2, a lower rate of 1-2 with adjunct-PP extraposition, and the effect of favoring factors in the 16th century. Third, in Swabia and Nuremberg, a preceding NP and adjunct-PP extraposition favor 1-2, and some factors continue to favor 1-2 in the 16th century. Thuringia and Saxony have the favoring effect of preceding NPs on the 1-2 order, a reduced effect of adjunct-PP extra position, and the presence of favoring factors in the 16th century. Finally, in Augsburg and Vienna, a preceding NP disfavors 1-2, adjunct-PPs have a lesser effect on verb order than other types of extraposition, and favoring factors disappear in the 16th century. Note that in each of these five groups, the two dialects are geographically contiguous. Note also that each group differs in at least one feature from every other group. Finally, each group except Swabia-Nuremberg is consistent with the conventional classification for German dialects: Cologne and Hesse are Franconian, Alsace and Zurich are Alemannic, Thuringia and Saxony are East Middle German, and Augsburg and Vienna are Bavarian. Now, let us re-examine the first two criteria (the frequency of verb orders in two- and three-verb complexes) in light of the best groups for the third criterion (the favoring factors). Beginning with the two-verb complexes, when placed into these five dialect groups. the frequency of the 1-2 order has the distribution shown in Table 41. This result is very similar to Table 20, and both are extremely significant (p < 0.001). In light of the different behavior of Cologne-Hesse versus AlsaceZurich with respect to the favoring factors, and in light of the fact that this analysis is also significant, it thus makes sense to split up the Western group this way. Table 41. Effect of dialect and century on 1-2 order, five best groups Dialect group
1350-1399
1450-1499
1550-1599
Total
Cologne-Hesse4s Alsace-Zurich Central (Swabia, Nurem.) EMG (Saxony, Thuringia) Bavarian-Austrian
5% 21%
19% 10%
0% 10%
10% 14%
61%
28%
28%
38%
43% 46%
27% 21%
9% 3%
24% 24%
48. Excludes Walter Ralegh.
93
94
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
With respect to complexes of three verbs, grouping the dialects this way gives the result shown in Table 42. These groups are less statistically significant than those in Table 36, aside from the 3-2-1 order, which is nearly the same (p = 0.072 versus p = 0.074). The largest difference between the two groupings is the 1-2-3 order, which is significant in Table 36 but not here. This is probably because Alsace, which disfavors 1-2-3, is grouped with Zurich, which favors it. However, recall from Section 3.3.4.2 that the preference for 1-2-3 in the ZurichSwabia-Nuremberg was not found by Hard (1981). Moreover, the other Western dialects, Cologne and Hesse, showed different word-order preferences for three-verb complexes. The only coherent groups in terms of their favoring effect on three-verb complexes were East Middle German and Bavarian -Austrian. Thus grouping the dialects according to the favoring factors is no worse than the analysis in Table 36 for three-verb complexes, since it keeps the two coherent groups and dispenses with the two incoherent ones (Western and ZurichSwabia-Nuremberg). Table 42. Effect of dialect on three-verb complexes, five best groups Dialect
3-2-1
1-3-2
1-2-3
3-1-2
Cologne- Hesse49 Alsace-Zurich Central EMG Bavarian-Austrian Total significance
9 (34.6%)
8 (30.8%)
2 (7.7%)
7 (26.9%)
(36.1%) (38.9%) (59.1%) (38.7%)
7 (19.4%) 9 (25.0%) 3 (13.6%) 3 (9.7%)
11 (30.6%) 10 (27.896) 3 (13.6%) 8 (25.8%)
28 (18.5%)
60 (39.7%)
24 (15.9%)
39 (25.8%)
p=0.072
p = 0.330
p= 0.260
p=0.550
5 (13.9%) 3 (8.3%) 3 (13.6%) 8 (25.8%)
13 14 13 12
In conclusion, the five groups determined in this section are probably the best ones. Each of these five groups consists of two geographically contiguous dialects that behave similarly with respect to the favoring factors and have similar distributions of the 1-2 order over time. Moreover, two of these groups. EMG and Bavarian-Austrian, have coherent preferences for complexes of three verbs. Finally, with the exception of the Central group, these groups correspond largely to conventional dialect divisions (see Figure 1).
49· Excludes Walter Ralegh.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
3-4-3 Developments from MHG to ENHG As seen in Figure 3, the frequency of the 1-2 order remains roughly stable from the eleventh century (32.2%) to the fourteenth (35.5%), aside from the drop in the twelfth century discussed in Chapter 2. However, in the fifteenth century, the order begins to decline, falling to just 11.5% by the end of the ENHG period. This decline sets the stage for the complete loss of the 1-2 order in Modern Standard German, although it continues to be found in some modern dialects (see Chapter 4 for details).
60%
~ ~
50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0%
10701100
11501200
12501300
13501400
14501500
15501600
Figure 3. Frequency of the 1-2 order from MHG to ENHGSO
The change in word order preference from MHG to ENHG in various dialects is far from clear. As can be seen in Table 43, some dialects have wildly different frequencies of the 1-2 order in the two periods: in Cologne, for example, 1-2 appears to drop from a rate of 46.7% in MHG to just 8.6% in ENHG.
so.
Compiled from the data in Table 12 from Chapter 2 and Table 13 above.
95
96
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Table43. Effect of dialect on 1-2 order, MHG vs. ENHGSl Dialect (MHG I ENHG area)
% of1-2inMHG
% of1-2inENHG
Cologne Alsace Hesse
46.7% n/a 35.9% 10.8% 13.1% 12.5% 31.9% n/a 19.496 81.7% 28.796
8.6% 11.8% 12.4% 14.8% 16.2% 23.9% 24.3% 31.396 35.896 41.7% 23.196
Thuringia
Switzerland (Eastern) Swabia I Augsburg Bavaria I Vienna Saxony E. Franconia I Nuremberg Black Forest I Swabia Total
On the other hand, the favoring factors are quite consistent across the two time periods. In both MHG and ENHG, syntagm, focus, prefix type, extraposition, genre, and occupation have a significant effect on the choice of verb orders in complexes of two verbs. The one factor that behaves somewhat difierently is the word preceding the VC: in MHG, this factor had a significant effect both when analyzed by part of speech and by phonological weight. In ENHG, however, such an effect was only detected in certain dialects, with no effect in the database as a whole. The changes from MHG to ENHG in three-verb complexes are less clear. This may be due to the smaller number of tokens, or because many three-verb syntagms such as the IPP have not yet become common in MHG. In MHG, 3-2-1 is very rare, with the other three orders about evenly distributed. By ENHG all orders are robustly attested, with 1-3-2 the most frequent, and the distribution of orders is largely determined by syntagm type.
51. Percentages from Table 15 in Chapter 2 and Table 18 above. Note that the dialect areas do
not correspond exactly, due to slightly different classifications used by the Bochumer and the Bonner corpora. For example, I have decided to compare the MHG text from the Black Forest to the ENHG texts from (Western) Swabia, while comparing the MHG texts from (Eastern) Swabia (including Augsburg) to ENHG Augsburg, an eastern Swabian dialect.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
3·5
Conclusion
3·5-1 Summary of findings This chapter reports on a study of verb order in ENHG subordinate clauses. Unlike some previous research (Ebert 1981, 1998; Reifsnyder 2003), the corpus used in this study includes materials from many ENHG dialects. Unlike others (Hard 1981; Bies 1996), this study examined both two-verb and three-verb complexes and attempted to determine what linguistic factors favor the various orders. Finally, unlike some early research (Maurer 1926; Hammarstrom 1923; and even Hard 1981), this study presented not only the raw data, but also a statistical analysis. A number oflinguistic and sociolinguistic factors were tested for an effect on word order. This study refutes some findings of previous scholarship, confirms others, and makes some new findings as well. For two factors, little or no effect on verb order was determined. First of all contra Maurer (1926), no effect of the position of the subordinate clause within the sentence could be found (see Section 3.2.2.1). Secondly. this study was unable to confirm Ebert's (1981) hypothesis that the syllable structure of the verbs helps determine their relative order (Section 3.2.2.2). The following factors did have an effect on the order of verbs. First of all, as has been pointed out by most previous studies, syntagm had a significant effect on verb order, with passives and perfects favoring the 2-1 order, while infinitival constructions favor 1-2 (Section 3.2.3.1). This effect was even stronger with complexes of three verbs, where some constructions appear to be ungrammatical with certain word orders (Section 3.3.3.1). Secondly. the category of the word preceding the VC has an effect on verb order in two-verb complexes, although unlike Ebert's (1981) results for Nuremberg and my own results from MHG (Chapter 2 above), this cannot be attributed to a preference for the 1-2 order after phonologically heavy words (Section 3.2.3.2) and there were no discernable effects in threeverb complexes (Section 3.3.2.1). Thirdly. Ebert's (1981) observation that NP/PP extraposition favors the 2-1 order was confirmed (Section 3.2.3.3), although no effect on complexes of three verbs could be determined (Section 3.3.2.2). Fourth, new information and contrastive focus favored the 1-2 order for two verbs (Section 3.2.3.4), and every order but 3-2-1 for three verbs (Section 3.3.3.2). Finally. as pointed out by Ebert (1981), verbs with stressed, separable prefixes favored the 1-2 order, while verbs with unstressed prefixes favored the 2-1 order (Section 3.2.3.5). In complexes of three verbs, however, the effect of prefix type was not distinct from that of syntagm (Section 3.3.3.3).
97
98
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Over the course of the ENHG period, the 1-2 and 3-1-2 orders decreased in frequency, while the 2-1 and 1-3-2 orders became firmly established in the written language (Sections 3.2.4.1 and 3.3.4.1). The frequencies of these orders varied widely by dialect (Sections 3.2.4.2 and 3.3.4.2). Finally, as argued in previous studies, the social status of the author and genre of the text played a major role in word order variation, with less formal styles preferring the 1-2 and 1-2-3 orders but more formal styles favoring 2-1 and 3-2-1 (Sections 3.2.4.3 and 3.3.4.3).
3.5.2 The combined effect of the favoring factors This chapter has discussed a number of factors that favor the 1-2 order in ENHG. However, the high frequency of 1-2 in ENHG cannot be attributed to any single factor. Rather, only when taken together do they account for this word order. As seen in Table 44, only 50 of the 671 clauses with the 1-2 order, or 7 .5%, have none of the favoring factors (excluding sociolinguistic factors of the text or author). Thus the frequency of 1-2 in the database can be understood as the result of the slight favoring effect of a number of factors. Ebert (1986: 122) calls this "one of the best examples in ENHG of the interaction of linguistic and extralinguistic factors in syntactic variation and change."52 Lotscher (1978: 11) makes a similar point regarding modern Swiss German: "The additional complication, that one single rule type is hardly sufficient to account for word order, must be taken into account as well" (translation in Schmid & Vogel2004: 242). Table 44. All linguistic favoring factors for 1-253 Favoring factor
1-(x)-2
Syntagm with infinitive Preceding stressed word Separable prefix verb Focus Extraposition No scrambling None ofthe favoring factors Total
359 421 104
382 151
28 50
671
52. My translation of "zu den scMnsten Beispielen des Zusammenwirkens von spracb.lichen
und auSersprachlichen Faktoren bei der syntaktischen Variation und dem Sytaxwandel" 53· Many clauses are represented in this table more than once, since a clause may have two or more of the favoring factors.
Chapter 3. Factors influencing verb order in ENHG
For MHG, I argued that prosody plays a major role in verb order. This appears to be the case in ENHG as well: the prosodic factors that affect VC word order are the preceding word (at least dialectally), verbal prefixes, focus, and the other focus-related factors (scrambling and extraposition). These factors, which are listed in Table 45, account for the vast majority of the 1-2 clauses in the database. Only 113, or 16.8%, of the clauses are not accounted for by at least one of the prosodic or focus-related factors. Clearly, prosody plays a prominent role in the choice of orders in the verbal complex, in conjunction with syntagm.54 Table 45. Prosodic favoring factors for 1-2 Favoring factor
1-(x)-2
Preceding stressed word Separable prefix verb Focus Extraposition No scrambling None of the prosodic factors Total
421 104
382 151
28 113
671
Having discussed the distribution of verbal complexes in MHG and ENHG, Chapter 4 will investigate variation in verb order in Modern Standard German and several modern dialects. Among the factors that continue to influence the choice of verb orders in these varieties are syntagm and prosody.
54· Although syntagm can to some degree imply prosody (because of the characteristic prefix ge- on most participles), recall that the effects of prefix type and syntagm are independent of each other.
99
CHAPTER4
Verbal complexes in contemporary German
4.1
Introduction
The previous chapters address word order within subordinate-clause verbal complexes in Middle and Early New High German. This chapter will discuss VC order in subordinate clauses in Modern Standard German and contemporary dialects of German. In previous chapters, I claim that prosodic factors have an effect on the choice of verb orders within the VC in MHG and ENHG. Because focus and stress must be deduced from historical texts, one of the main goals of this chapter is to determine what role prosody plays in the VC today, in order to support my claims about earlier stages of the language. Section 4.2 reviews previous scholarship on VC word order in contemporary standard and dialectal German. Section 4.3 reports on new research that I conducted on Swabian, Austrian German, and Zurich German VCs. Section 4.4 discusses verb order in the Standard German werden + modal construction, based on a survey using the magnitude estimation method. A summary of the contemporary German data and a discussion of the implications for MHG and ENHG are presented in Section 4.5.
4.2
Previous studies
4.2.1 Introduction This section reviews some of the literature on VC order in subordinate clauses in Modern Standard German and contemporary dialects of German. There are, of course, many more grammars of German dialects than could be discussed here. The dialects presented here were chosen based on two criteria. First, the descriptions of these dialects specifically address subordinate-clause verb order, providing information about ungrammatical as well as grammatical orders. For example, although VCs in varieties of Thuringian display very interesting morphological phenomena (see Spangenberg 1993:262-270 for an overview), I have not found good descriptions of the relevant word orders. Secondly, these dialects are more or less direct descendants of the ENHG dialects treated in
102
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Chapters 2 and 3 above. Therefore, well-described dialects such as Low German (Matras & Reershemius 2003) and Moselle Franconian (Bruch 1973) are excluded from this study. This part of the chapter is organized as follows. First, Section 4.2.2 discusses complexes of two verbs in several varieties of German. Three-verb complexes in these varieties are treated in Section 4.2.3. Section 4.2.4 provides a brief discussion ofVCs consisting of more than three verbs. Finally, VCs with an intervening constituent (1-x-2 or Verb Projection Raising) are covered in Section 4.2.5.
4.2.2 4.2.2.1
Two-verb complexes
Modern Standard German
In Modern Standard German (MSG), the 2-1 order is the only possible word order for two-verb complexes in subordinate clauses (Duden 1995: 786). This is true for all syntagms: (1)
dass Klaus heute das Buch lesen wilL that K. today the book read.INF2 wants 1 that Klaus wants to read the book today:
(2)
dass Klaus gestern das Buch gelesen hat. that K. yesterday the book read.PPP2 has 1 that Klaus read the book yesterday:
The 1-2 order (3) and the 1-x-2 order (4) are completely ungrammatical according to prescriptive grammars. (3) * ... dass Klaus heute das Buch will lesen. that K. today the book wants 1 read 2 that Klaus wants to read the book today.' (4) * ... dass Klaus heute will
das Buch lesen. that K. today wants 1 the book read2 that Klaus wants to read the book today.'
These orders are not only disallowed by prescriptive grammars but are also extremely rare in written German: Grubacic (1965: 9) found only eight instances in a corpus of 16,000 pages of 20th-century German. To my knowledge, there are no studies showing exactly how infrequent the 1-2 and 1-x-2 orders are in spoken Standard German; however, in informal discussions with native speakers of German, these orders are consistently judged as completely ungrammatical or possible "only in poetry':
Chapter 4. Verbal complexes in contemporary German 103
There are, of course, other word-order possibilities in colloquial forms of the standard language. The subordinate clause must display main clause word order if the clause is not introduced by a complementizer (Duden 1995: 784): (5) Ich glaube, Klaus will heute das Buch lesen. I think K. wants 1 today the book read 2 'I think Klaus wants to read the book today.' Additionally, some constituent may be extraposed, i.e. may appear to the right of the VC, as in (6) and (7). Extraposition is far less frequent in written Standard German than in colloquial varieties, but even in the written language it is possible under certain discourse conditions (Duden 1995:790-791). Extraposed arguments (6) are more marked than extraposed adjuncts (7), as Lambert's (1976) corpus study of extraposition in Standard German shows. (6) ·... dass Klaus heute lesen will das Buch. that K. today read 2 wants 1 the book that Klaus wants to read the book today.' (7) ·... dass Klaus das Buch lesen will heute. that K. the book read wants 1 today that Klaus wants to read the book today.' 4.2.2.2
Cross-dialect studies
In his seminal research on German dialects, Wenker (1888-1923) presents some information on subordinate-clause word order. Participants were asked to translate into their dialect a Standard German sentence beginning with the following clause: (8) Als wir gestern Abend zurllck kamen ... when we yesterday evening back came 'When we came back yesterday evening .. .' Speakers of southern dialects, which lack the preterit tense, rendered the preterit in (8) with a present perfect as in (9). Wenker reported the following word orders (as discussed in Maurer 1926:33 and Konig 1994: 163): (9) a.
b. c. d.
wie mir gestern abend heim komme sinn when we yesterday evening home come.PPPz are 1 'When we came home yesterday evening .. .' wie mir gestern abend heim sinn 1 komme2 wie mir gestern abend sinn 1 heim komme2 wie mir sinn 1 gestern abend heim komme2
104
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Southern Alsace, Baden, northern Swabia, northern Bavaria, and Franconia have the 2-1 order (9a). Northern Alsatian and Rhine Hessian have only the 1-2 order (9b). Dialects of the Palatinate, along the river Main, and in most of Bavarian display both of these orders plus 1-x-2 (9c). Finally, Swabian speakers also reported the order in (9d), which is ambiguous between a 1-x-2 order and a V2 order, given the limited data. In a more recent study, Wurmbrand (2004b) reports on a questionnaire-based survey of possible word orders in German, Austrian, and Swiss dialects. The first task on the questionnaire presented the participants with words in random order in standard German orthography and asked them to form a sentence from those words, including changing the orthography to reflect pronunciation. The second task asked participants to give grammaticality judgments of sentences written in standard German orthography, based on whether the word order would be natural in their dialect. Most of the sentences involved VCs with three and four verbs (discussed in Section 4.2.3 below), with only two sentences per task involving two-verb complexes. Wurmbrand's (2004b: 60) result for complexes of two verbs is that German and Austrian speakers only allow the 2-1 order, as in Modern Standard German. Wurmbrand's results for Swiss German will be discussed in Section 4.2.2.8 below. Wurmbrand's study indicates that 2-1 is the most natural order in these dialects; however, her finding that no German or Austrian speakers accepted the 1-2 order contradicts the findings of other studies, including those discussed below in this section and my own surveys of Swabian and Austrian German in Section 4.3. As Wurmbrand points out (2004b: 69, fn. 3), the format of her study makes it difficult to rule out influence of the standard language on the participants' judgments. Moreover, the study may have shown so little word-order variation because the sentences did not have any factors which favor the 1-2 order, such as focus or extra position. 4.2.2.3 Austrian dialects Since Wenker's study does not include information from outside the former German Empire, Maurer (1926) supplements Wenker's data with the following information about Austrian dialects. According to Maurer (1926:60-63) the dialects of Upper Austria and Lower Austria mainly have the 2-1 order, while Tyrolean has both the 2-1 and 1-2 orders. These observations about Austrian dialects are largely confirmed in the more recent study by Patocka (1997). He finds, however, a great deal of variation not only by dialect, but also by syntagm. First of all the passive with wet·den allows only the 2-1 order, in all dialects:
Chapter 4. Verbal complexes in contemporary German
(10) daB des Flaisch a weng gmischt wiad
that the meat a bit rnixed 2 AUX 1 'that the meat is mixed a little bit'
(Patocka 1997:271)
The modal-infinitive (11) and perfect syntagrns (12), on the other hand, allow both word orders, depending on the dialect wM(l) i dA mit n Wagl so wMtfdan muafl because I there with the wagon so far travel2 rnust1 'because I had to travel there so far by wagon b. wo des a HAathulz muafl sai(n) where that a hardwood rnust1 be2 'where there must be hardwood' (Patocka 1997:275)
(11) a.
wia rna da VAta voa zwoanzg JAh(r)n s Haus gebm hat how me the father ago twenty years the house given2 has 1 'how my father gave me the house twenty years ago' b. dea den Gaia hat ahagschossn REL the hawk has 1 down-shot2 'who shot down the hawk' (Patocka 1997: 290)
(12) a.
Judging by a comparison of Patocka's map 5 (1997: 277) and map 9 (1997: 292), the 1-2 order is possible (sometimes alongside the 2-1 order, sometimes the only possible order) in both of these syntagrns in the western and southern regions of Austria, i.e. most of Tyrol, Carinthia, and Styria.l Only the 2-1 order is possible in the more northerly dialects (Upper Austria, most of Salzburg, and western Lower Austria). The eastern part of the country (Vienna, eastern Lower Austria, and Burgenland) forms a transitional zone where only 2-1 is allowed for infinitives but both orders are attested for perfects.
4.2.2.4 Bavarian According to WeiB (1998), both the 2-1 and 1-2 orders are possible in Bavarian, although 2-1 is the unmarked order: (13) a.
b.
daB'a'da des gschengd hod that he her that given2 has 1 'that he gave that to her' und wia's a soo hand furtganga midanand and how they too thus have 1 away-gone 2 with-eachother 'and how they left together like that too' (WeiB 1998: 51)
1. The westernmost province, Vorarlberg, is not included in Patocka's study. as the dialect there is Alemannic.
105
106
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
The 1-2 order is more acceptable, however, when an element that is "closely associated with the verb" is extraposed, as in (13b). This observation is especially interesting given the correlation between extraposition and the 1-2 order in ENHG (see Chapters 2 and 3). WeiB (1998: 52) finds that both orders are also possible when a modal selects an infinitive, although as with perfects, the 2-1 order is preferred. 4.2.2.5 West Central German Dubenion-Smith (2008) analyzes a corpus of spoken West Central German and presents results of a questionnaire of dialect speakers from that region.2 In the corpus study, which represents speech samples collected from 1955 to 1970, the 1-2 order is relatively rare with perfects and passives (7.6%), but it is far more frequent (25.1 %) in the modal-infinitive syntagm (2008: 85). Respondents to Dubenion-Smith's questionnaire, on the other hand, did not provide the 1-2 order with perfects in a sentence-completion task, and only four of the 51 respondents produced that order with modals (2008: 169).3 4.2.2.6 Swabian Steil (1989: 39) finds that the 1-2 order is possible in Swabian, although as in Bavarian, the 2-1 order is preferred. The 1-2 order occurs mainly in the perfect tenses: (14) ... bis di(a) Franzosa sen' komm(e)n ... until the French are 1 come.PPP 2 '... until the French came .. :
(Steil1989: 40)
According to Steil (1989:40), the 1-2 order "very rarely" occurs in the modal+ infinitive construction. This state of affairs, like the situation in eastern Austrian dialects, is the opposite of the pattern found in some other West Germanic dialects, such as Dutch and ENHG, where 1-2 is preferred with infinitives. 4.2.2.7 Alsatian According to Heitzler (1975), Alsatian also prefers the 2-1 order (15), as indialects in Germany and Austria. However, when the syntagm is the modal plus infinitive, both orders are allowed (16). 2. This larger dialect area includes both the Hessian and Cologne dialects that are discussed in Chapters 2 and 3 above.
3· In a grammaticality-judgment task, only 7.8% of respondents judged the 1-2 order acceptable with the perfect, and none preferred it In the modal syntagm, 1-2 was judged acceptable or preferred by 29.4% of respondents (Dubenion-Smith 2008: 172).
Chapter 4. Verbal complexes in contemporary German
(15) van ar Ama sundig sbod ufg5danda e5 when he on Sunday late up-stood 2 is 1 'when he got up late on Sunday' (16) a.
b.
van ar amol fordge vel if he even away-go2 wants1 'if he even wants to go away' van ar amol veltfordgi!z
(Heitzler 1975: 34)4
(Heitzler 1975: 35)
This is similar to the state of affairs in Dutch, Swiss German, and Tyrolean but unlike that in eastern Austrian dialects and Swabian, where the 1-2 order is more acceptable in the perfect. 4.2.2.8 Swiss dialects In Swiss German, the 1-2 order is much more frequent than in dialects of Austria and Germany. However, there seem to be dialect differences within Swiss German with respect to the acceptability of the 1-2 order with participial syntagms. In the dialect of Zurich (Lotscher 1978), participial syntagms allow only the 2-1 order (17). In syntagms with infinitives, however, both orders are possible, although the 1-2 order is preferred (18).5 (17) wil mer em Hans es vela gschankt hand because we the Hans the bike given2 have 1 'because we have given Hans the bike'
(Wtscher 1978:2)
(18) wil mer em Hans es vela wand schitnke because we the Hans the bike want1 give2 'because we want to give Hans the bike'
(Wtscher 1978:4)
In Hadler's (1969:691) study of texts from the Bern region, both orders are attested for both syntagms. For perfects, Hodler finds that the 2-1 order is somewhat preferred, with 133 instances versus 81 examples of 1-2. For infinitives, the opposite is true, with only 23 instances of 2-1 versus 76 occurrences of 1-2. Thus a difference between the Bern and Zurich dialects is that Bernese is more tolerant of the 1-2 order with participles. Wurmbrand's (2004b:53) Swiss data confirm one of the basic findings here, that 2-1 is preferred with perfects: all five of her participants accepted this order, with only one accepting the 1-2 order. On the other hand, her study does not confirm the preference for 1-2 with modals that Hadler and Lotscher found. Each
4· I do not reproduce all of the diacritics in Heitzler's transcription system here. 5· St. Galler German behaves sinlilarly to Zurich German (ScMnenberger 1995: 366).
107
108
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
order was accepted by four out of five participants, so the two orders appear to be equally grammatical, although this does not rule out the possibility that some of the participants prefer the 1-2 order.
4.2.2.9 Summary and discussion The data for complexes of two verbs in contemporary German are summarized in Table 1. Table 1. Word order in two-verb complexes Dialect
modalinfinitive
auxiliaryparticiple
Standard German German & Austrian dialects (Wurmbrand) S and W Austria N Austria EAustria Bavarian West Central German Swabian Alsatian Swiss
2-1 2-1 1-2/ (2-1) 2-1 2-1 2-1/ (1-2) 2-1/ (1-2) 2-1 2-1/ (1-2) 1-2/ (2-1)
2-1 2-1 1-2/2-1 2-1 1-2/2-1 2-1/ (1-2) 2-1 2-1/ (1-2) 2-1 2-1/ (1-2)
Wurmbrand's (2004b) survey found that speakers of German and Austrian dialects accepted only the 2-1 order. However, those data look more like the prescriptive rules of Standard German than the results of the studies of individual dialects, which show 1-2 as a possible order in Bavarian, West Central German, Swabian, and Alsatian, and as the preferred order in some syntagms in certain Austrian dialects. Either Wurmbrand's survey elicited only the preferred order (perhaps due to the methodology), or dialect speakers today are more strongly influenced by Standard German than was previously the case. Indeed, in my dialect surveys (see Section 4.3 below), younger dialect speakers seem to have more Standardlike word order than earlier studies indicate. Based on the results of this dialect survey, as well as other West Germanic languages, Wurmbrand reaches this generalization: "if the '1-2' order is possible in an auxiliary-participle construction it is also possible in the modal-infinitive constructions (but not vice versa)" (2004b: 44). In Dutch and Swiss German, both orders are possible, but 1-2 is preferred with infinitives and 2-1 in perfects. Some varieties, including West Flemish and Afrikaans, allow only 1-2 with infinitives and only 2-1 with perfects (see Wurmbrand 2004b: 45 for references). Recall from Chapters 2 and 3 above that ENHG shows similar preferences. However, when
Chapter 4. Verbal complexes in contemporary German 109
more of the German dialects are taken into account, Wurmbrand's generalization is weakened. Although it holds for Swiss German, West Central German, Alsatian, and southern and western Austrian dialects, Swabian and eastern Austrian dialects show the opposite pattern: the 2-1 order is allowed for perfects but not for the modal + infinitive syntagm. Finally, let us compare these contemporary dialects with their ENHG predecessors as shown in Table 2. Recall from Chapter 3 that all dialects of ENHG showed a preference for the 2-1 order, especially in the participial syntagms. Not surprisingly, most of the dialects prefer the 2-1 order in both the ENHG period and currently. Two oddities stand out, however. First, early-modern Swabian shows a very high frequency of the 1-2 order with modals, and yet, unlike neighboring dialects (Bavarian, Alsatian, and Swiss), this order is ungrammatical with modals today. On the other hand, earlier Swabian has a relatively high rate of 1-2 with perfects, which is still grammatical in the contemporary dialect.6 Table 2. Two-verb complexes, ENHG vs. contemporary dialects Dialect
German & Austrian dialects (Wurmbrand) EAustria Bavarian West Central German Swabian Alsatian Swiss
modal-infinitive
auxiliary-partidple
% of1-2 inENHG
preferred order today
%of1-2 inENHG
preferred order today
35%
2-1
18%
2-1
35% 34% 30% 48% 17% 25%
2-1 2-1 2-1 2-1 2-1 1-2
18% 18% 15% 37% 7% 12%
2-1 2-1 2-1 2-1 2-1 2-1
Secondly, modern Swiss German is reported to prefer the 1-2 order with modals; however, in the ENHG period the rate of 1-2 with infinitives in Switzerland is surprisingly low at just 25%, lower than the ENHG average for infinitives (34%). This could simply be a result of the genres of the texts selected in the Bonner Fruhneuhochdeutschkorpus: they consist of one scientific text and two chronicles. Lotscher (2000: 201) finds that early-modern Swiss chronicles have a much lower rate of the 1-2 order than personal letters from the same
The percentages for ENHG for "German and Austrian dialects" are taken from Chapter 3 above. Those for individual dialects ofENHG come from Chapter 3 ofSapp (2006), with West Central German represented by the average of the percentages from Hesse and Cologne.
6.
uo The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
period. On the other hand, in Lotscher's (2000: 207) study, the word-order difference between the modal-infinitive and auxiliary-participle syntagms starts to increase at the end of the 16th century, so the strong preference for 1-2 with modals appears to be a relatively recent phenomenon in Swiss German. Therefore the low rate of 1-2 in the ENHG Swiss texts vis-a-vis the modern language may be due in part to the genres represented but also reflects a real increase in this order over time. 4.2.3 Three-verb complexes 4.2.3.1 Modern Standard German For most syntagms involving three verbs, the left-governing order 3-2-1 is the only possible order in MSG (Duden 1995:786). This is the case when a modal verb selects another modal and infinitive (19), a perfect (20), or a passive (21), and in the perfect of the passive (22).
(19) weil er es kaufen kiJnnen muss because he it buy3 can2 must1 'because he must be able to buy it' (20) weil er es geka.uft ha.ben muss because he it bought3 hav~ must1 'because he must have bought it' (21) weil es gekauft werden muss because it bought3 AUX2 must1 'because it must be bought' (22) weil es gekauft worden ist because it bought3 AUX z Aux1 'because is has been bought' In the IPP (infinitivus pro participio or Ersatzinfinitiv) construction, i.e. in the present perfect of a modal which governs an infinitive, 1-3-2 is the only possible order (Duden 1995:786): (23) weil er es hat kaufen mtissen because he it has 1 buy3 must.INF 2 'because he had to buy if Although prescriptive grammar rules allow only 1-3-2 in this construction, in an experiment Bader & Schmid (2009) found that as many as 28% of Standard German speakers accepted the 3-2-1 order with the IPP and fully 61% accepted 3-1-2. •
Chapter 4. Verbal complexes in contemporary German
When the IPP effect is optional e.g. when the perfect auxiliary governs an ACI verb, the 1-3-2 order occurs with the IPP (24a) but the 3-2-1 order with the participle (24b) (Duden 1995:786). (24) a.
b.
well er sie hat singen hiiren because he her has 1 sinS,:~ hear.INF 2 'because he (has) heard her sing' well er sie singen gehort hat because he her si1183 heard 2 has 1 'because he (has) heard her sing'
Finally; when the future auxiliary werden governs two infinitives, both the 3-2-1 and 1-3-2 orders are possible (Duden 1995: 786): (25) a.
b. c.
weil er es ka.ufon kOnnen wird because he it buy3 can2 will1 'because he will be able to buy it' weller es winl 1 kaufen 3 konnen 2 'll>weil er es kaufon3 winl1 konnen2
In addition, the 3-1-2 order (25c) may be becoming more frequent in colloquial Standard German (Tilman Hohle, Wolfgang Sternefeld, p.c.). Bader & Schmid ( 2009) found that native speakers of Standard German judged the 3-1-2 order acceptable with the syntagm nearly as frequently as 3-2-1. According to Schmid & Vogel (2004: 239), 3-1-2 is also a possible order for this syntagm under the right focus conditions. The effectoffocus on the choice between 3-2-1, 1-3-2, and 3-1-2 in this construction in Standard German will be discussed in Section 4.4 below.
4.2.3.2 Cross-dialect studies In Wurmbrand's (2004b) questionnaire-based study, dialect speakers in Germany show judgments that agree with the standard language for some syntagms but not others. The syntagms that, according to Duden, only allow the 3-2-1 order in the standard also strongly favor 3-2-1 in these dialects. For the syntagms modal+ modal+ infinitive (19), modal+ perfect (20), modal+ passive (21), and the perfect of the passive (22), Wurmbrand's participants from Germany overwhelmingly (above 80%) rejected any order besides 3-2-1 (2004b: 55).7 The judgments in Wurmbrand (2004b: 55) for the IPP construction ( 23) show much more deviation from the standard language. Adding the scores for "yes" and "maybe~ the standard-like 1-3-2 order received 100%, followed by 3-1-2 (73.3%), 7. Wurmbrand's (2004b) results for Austria will be treated in the next section and those for Switzerland in Section 4.2.3.8.
111
112
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
3-2-1 (65.2%), and 1-2-3 (41.1%). The other logically possible orders, 2-3-1 and 2-1-3, were strongly rejected. For the werden + modal construction (25), Wurmbrand's participants found 3-2-1, one of the standard orders, to be grammatical (83.9%), but were less certain about the other standard order, 1-3-2, with 54.5% accepting it and 43.6% unsure (2004b: 55). The 3-1-2 was accepted by very few speakers (3.6%), with the remainder of participants evenly split between ungrammatical and unsure. Schmid & Vogel (2004) examine the word order possibilities in the ·werden + modal construction in various dialects. The results for some specific dialects will be discussed in the following sections, and their study will be evaluated in Section 4.4.2 below. One general result is that all non-Swiss dialects pattern with MSG in strongly preferring the orders 3-2-1 and 1-3-2 (Schmid & Vogel2004: 239). 4.2.3.3 Austrian dialects First of all, let us look at Wurmbrand's (2004b: 55) general findings for Austrian dialects. Austrians showed similar judgments to Germans for the syntagms modal+ perfect (20), modal+ passive (21), and the perfect of the passive (22), in strongly rejecting all orders other than 3-2-1. However, Austrians less decisively rejected the 1-3-2 order with two modals (19): only 36.4% of them found it ungrammatical and 54.5% were unsure. Austrians' judgments of the IPP construction (23) and werden + modal construction (25) were also similar to GermanS, except that they were much more tolerant of the 3-1-2 order. Patocka's (1997) corpus study treats only two syntagms -the perfect of the passives and the IPP. In the perfect of the passive, the 3-2-1 and 3-1-2 orders are usual, with only one attestation of 1-3-2: (26) a.
b.
c.
daB ameli biuU woa.dn wa(r) that once buillPPP3 AUX.PPP2 were.SUBJ 1 'that (it) would have been built once' daB in Triant aa oans gmartart isch woadn that in Trent also one tortured.PPP3 is 1 AUX.PPP 2 'that one was also tortured in Trent' wArm a Kind is taaft gwoadn when a child is 1 baptized.PPP3 AUX.PPP 2 'when a child was baptized' ( Patocka 1997: 289)
Patocka does not show the distribution of these orders geographically.
8. He treats the werden-passive separately from sein- passive, but they behave largely the same.
Chapter 4. Verbal complexes in contemporary German
Patocka finds three word orders for the IPP in Austrian dialects, the standardlike 1-3-2, the "typically Austrian, 3-1-2, and the "more conservative" 1-2-3: wiar i mit Knecht und Dian hd.un daba.tn miassn how I with servant and maid have 1 work3 mustiNF 2 'how I had to work with servants and maids' b. da rna wAs leana hettn soin that wir something learn3 had1 shall.INF 2 'that we should have learned something' c. daB i s hab miassn lau.ssn that I it have1 mustiNF 2 leave3 (Patocka 1997:278) 'that I had to leave it'
(27) a.
Although there are few examples of each type, the following geographical distribution emerges in Patocka (1997: 281): 1-3-2 is found mainly in the east of the country, and it is not clear whether this is chiefly due to the influence of standard German. The 3-1-2 order is found in all parts of Austria, and seems to be the normal order in colloquial speech, even appearing in writing. The 1-2-3 order is rarer, but is also evenly distributed geographically. Patocka's results are somewhat at odds with Wurmbrand's (2004b ). First of all, Wurmbrand's participants accepted only the 3-2-1 order for the perfect of the passive, while Patocka's study finds that 3-1-2 is also frequent Secondly, in Wurmbrand (2004b), 1-3-2 is the most grammatical order for the IPP, while Patocka shows that 3-1-2 is more common than 1-3-2. It is striking that Wurmbrand's participants show preferences similar to the standard language, which may indicate a methodological difference or the possibility that Patocka's study highlights moribund features, while Wurmbrand's is more reflective of contemporary Austrian speech. Schmid & Vogel (2004: 238) examine the ·werden + modal syntagm in one dialect that is closely related to Austrian dialects: South Tyrolean, spoken in northern Italy. Of the dialects they investigate, this one shows the greatest number of wordorder possibilities, and is the only one to display the 2-1-3 order. With stress on the auxiliary, three orders are possible (3-2-1.1-2-3, and 1-3-2), but with stress on any other word in the clause, five orders are possible: 3-2-1, 1-2-3, 1-3-2, 3-1-2, and 2-1-3. It is unclear why this dialect shows such tolerance for so many word orders - whether it is a genuine difference from other Austrian dialects or results from Schmid & Vogel's method of data collection (see Section 4.4.2 below).
113
114
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
4.2.3.4 Bavarian According to WeiG (1998), three orders are possible in the perfect of the passive and in the double pertect9 construction: 3-2-1, 3-1-2, and 1-3-2 (Weill1998:51). (28) a.
b.
c.
wia Bayern zum K~nigreich gmocht woarn ist how Bavaria to kingdom made.PPP 3 AUX.PPP 2 is 1 'how Bavaria was made a kingdom' hod ghod wia'ra des gheerd how he it heard.PPP3 has 1 had.PPP2 'how he had heard it' wia de Doudn e da Schdum am Bred ha.nd afbohrd woa.n how the dead in the room on.the board have 1 out-laid3 AUX2 'how the dead were laid out on the board in the parlor' (WeiB 1998: 52)
Although both syntagms allow all three orders, the perfect of the passive strongly prefers the 3-2-1 order as in (28a), and the double perfect strongly prefers the 3-1-2 order as in (28b). It is not clear what the distribution of 1-3-2 is, since WeiG (1998: 52) states that it is only possible with sein, but his only example (28c) has haben. For the IPP construction, WeiG reports that the orders 3-1-2, 1-2-3, and 1-3-2 are grammatical: (29) a.
b.
c.
wa a nimmer reen hod kina I kind what he never say3 has 1 can.INF 2 can.PPP 2 'what he never could say' woa 's heijd sooln hairaddn where they had.SUBJ 1 shall.INF 2 marry3 'where they should have married' daB ned a jeda Firmd~d extra hod einspanna brau.ha. that not an every sponsor extra has 1 team.up3 need.INF2 'that not every confirmation sponsor needed to team up (the horses)' (WeiB 1998: 53)
According to Weill (1998:53), the 3-1-2 order, as in (29a), is the unmarked and most common order, while 1-2-3 (29b) and 1-3-2 (29c) are marked. WeiG (1998:53) claims that the orders 2-1-3, 2-3-1, and 3-2-1 are ungrammatical in Bavarian with this construction. Although WeiG (1998) does not mention the werden +modal construction, Schmid & Vogel (2004: 238) provide some information from the Bavarian Forest.
9· Dialects without a preterit tense cannot form the pluperfect in the usual ws:y (with preterit of the perfect auxiliary), so the pluperfect is expressed by perfect tense of the auxiliary plus the participle of the lexical verb, as in (28b).
Chapter 4. Verbal complexes in contemporary German
When the subject, object, or auxiliarywerden is stressed, the orders 3-2-1, 1-3-2, and 3-1-2 are possible, and when the lexical verb or modal verb is stressed, those orders plus 1-2-3 are possible.
4.2.3.5 West Central German Dubenion-Smith's (2008) corpus of spoken West Central German contains fewer instances of three-verb complexes, so here I only report on the syntagms that are most robustly attested. In the perfect of the passive, VCs are evenly split between 3-2-1 and 3-1-2, with the other orders unattested. The modal plus passive prefers the 3-1-2 order, followed by 3-2-1 and 1-3-2. Finally, the IPP is attested with all four orders, with ten instances of 3-1-2, six of 1-2-3, four of 1-3-2, and three of 3-2-1 (Dubenion-Smith 2008:94). In Dubenion-Smith's questionnaire, respondents overwhelmingly completed sentences in the perfect of the passive and sentences containing a modal verb plus a perfect, passive, or other modal with the 3-2-1 order, with 1-3-2 and 3-1-2 trailing distantly. No respondent used 3-2-1 with the IPP syntagm, instead preferring 1-3-2, with a few respondents giving 3-1-2 or 1-2-3 (2008: 169). Similar results obtained from the grammaticalityjudgment task (2008: 172). These results largely support the corpus data. 4.2.3.6 Swabiatt Steil (1989) deals only with VCs that have haben, werden, or a modal as the finite verb. In general, Steil finds that the most common word order in Swabian is the one used in Standard German, but that Swabian allows for additional orders (1989: 1). In the double modal construction, two orders are possible:lO (30) a.
b.
Glaubsch, da6 mr des rad nomolrichda lasse ka? think:-2SG that we the wheel again straighten3 let2 can1 'Do you think we can have the wheel straightened again?' (Steil1989: 19) Glaubsch, daB mr des rad nomoi ka 1 richda3 lasse2?
to. Two additional orders are possible when the second verb is helfen 'to help': (i) a. Frag dr vaddr, ob r dir d kardoftl ka haifa scheela. ask the father if he you the potatoes can1 help2 peel3 ~k Father if he can help you peel the potatoes: b. Frag dr vaddr, ob e m haifa kocha soli. ask the father if he me help 2 cook3 shall 1 ~k Father ifhe will help me cook: (Steil1989: 19) The verb helfen in Swabian generally shows very different word orders from other verbs that take an infinitive (Steil1989: 103).
115
116
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Note that these are the two orders that occur in Standard German, although for this syntagm, only 3-2-1 is allowed in the standard language. In the IPP construction, four word orders are possible (five when helfen is the second verb): (31) a.
b. c. b.
I glaub, daB d Anna ons bsuacha wella hat. I think that the A. us visit3 wil1INF 2 has 1 'I think that Anna wanted to visit us: I glaub, daB d Anna ons hat1 bsuacha3 wella 2• I glaub, daB d Anna ons bsuacha3 hat1 wella 2• I glaub, daB d Anna ons hat1 wellaz bsuacha3•
(Steil1989: 17)
This is much more variation than is allowed in the standard language, where only 1-3-2 is possible. In the werden + modal syntagm, only the two standard German orders are possible:ll (32) a.
b.
Moinsch, daB r des fahrrrad macha kenna wird? think.2sG that he the bicycle make3 can2 will1 'Do you think that he will be able to build the bicycle?' Moinsch, daB r des fahrrrad wird1 macha3 kennaz?
(Steil1989: 19)
However, in this case Swabian actually shows a more restricted distribution than does the standard language (Steil 1989: 18): when the modal is sollen 'shall' or durfen 'maY, only the 1-3-2 order is possible. Schmid & Vogel show a different picture for the werden + modal syntagm in Swabian. Whereas Steil accepts only 3-2-1 and 1-3-2, Schmid & Vogel (2004: 238) find that two additional orders are possible, depending on the stress. Their data for Swabian is the most complex of any dialect they investigate, and bears repeating in full: Table 3. Orders in Swabian werden + modal syntagm (S&V 2004) Stressed word
Possible orders
subject object lexical verb modal auxiliary
123 132 123 132 312 123 132 312 132 312
11.
321
Again, when helfen rather than a modal is the second verb, 1-2-3 and 2-3-1 are allowed
Chapter 4. Verbal complexes in contemporary German
There may be two reasons for the differences between Steil's and Schmid & Vogel's data for Swabian. First, it is possible that Steil did not take stress differences into account. Secondly, perhaps this is due to dialect differences within Swab ian: Steil is from greater Stuttgart, while Schmid & Vogel's participant was from Tubingen, about 40 km south of Stuttgart. 4.2.3.7 Alsatian Heitzler (1975) gives only one example of a three-verb complex in Alsatian, which happens to be the double perfect syntagm:
hed (33) van ar gasa khed when he eaten3 had.PPP 2 has 1 'when he had eaten'
(Heitzler 1975: 34)
Heitzler gives no indication as to whether other word orders are possible in this or any other three-verb syntagm. 4.2.3.8 Swiss dialects In the Swiss dialect of St. Gallen (Schonenberger 1995), four out of the 6logically possible orders are allowed for the IPP construction: (34) a.
b. c. d.
das de Jonas schwimme maese hat that the J. swim3 musliNF 2 has 1 'that Jonas had to swim' das de Jonas hat1 schwimme3 maese2 das de Jonas schwimme3 hat1 maese2 das de Jonas hat1 maese2 schwimme3
(ScMnenberger 1995: 367)
In Wurmbrand's more general study, word order judgments vary wildly by syntagm in Swiss German. Because the data are not broken down by dialect, it is difficult to know how much of this variation is due to differences among Swiss dialects. For the IPP, all of Wurmbrand's (2004b:56) participants liked 1-2-3, and most liked 1-3-2 and 3-1-2; however, a majority rejected 3-2-1, contrary to Schonenberger's acceptance of this order. Other syntagms are very difterent. With the modal +perfect, the 3-1-2 and 1-3-2 orders are grammatical, 3-2-1 is marginal, and 1-2-3 (the best order for the IPP) is ungrammatical. With two modals, the situation is reversed: 1-2-3 and 3-2-1 are grammatical and the other two orders ungrammatical. Wurmbrand's (2004b: 60) participants allowed only 3-2-1 in the perfect of the passive. Finally, in the werden + modal syntagm, Wurmbrand (2004b: 56) finds that 1-2-3, 1-3-2, and 3-1-2 are grammatical, while the majority of participants were unsure about 3-2-1.
117
us The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Schmid & Vogel (2004: 238) show a possible dialect difference between St. Galler German and Bernese with respect to the werden + modal syntagm. Their participant from Bern allowed only the 1-2-3 order, while the one from St. Gallen additionally allowed 3-1-2 when the lexical verb was stressed and 2-1-3 when the modal was stressed.
4.2.3.9 Summary and discussion The data for three-verb complexes in MSG and contemporary dialects of German are summarized in Table 4.12 Judging from this table, it looks as if the werden + modal syntagm shows the greatest word-order variability. That may indeed be the case, since it is the only syntagm to allow any variation in written Standard German. On the other hand, this may be merely due to the fact that this construction is the object of Schmid & Vogel's (2005) study, which reports very detailed and stress-sensitive results. A few generalizations can be drawn from the data on three-verb complexes presented here. First of all, it appears that if a dialect displays the 1-2-3 order at all, it will do so at least in the IPP construction, followed by the werden + modal syntagm, and with the double modal syntagm only in Swiss. Secondly, the IPP does not force a particular word order: even 3-2-1 can occur with the IPP (also noted by Zwart 2005). Thirdly, the 1-2-3 order is ungrammatical if the complex contains a participle, even in Swiss.l3 Fourthly; the werden + modal syntagm tends to show a mixture ofiPP and participial word orders, as seen most clearly in Standard German, but also in Bavarian and Swabian. Finally, the 2-1-3 and 2-3-1 orders are extremely rare, with the former being found only under certain focus conditions in Austrian and Swiss, and the latter found only with the verb helfon in Swabian. Recall from Chapter 2 that the 2-1-3 and 2-3-1 orders did not occur in my ENHG corpus. However, the similarities between the three-verb complexes in ENHG and Modern German seem to end there, as seen in Table 5. Whereas all modern (non-Swiss) varieties treated here prefer the 3-2-1 order for the syntagms with participles, this was not the most frequent order in ENHG. In my ENHG corpus (excluding the Swiss data), in the perfect of the passive 3-1-2 is the most All data are from the dialect studies discussed in the previous sections. In this table, the superscripts are used as follows: the percentage sign has its conventional value, i.e. grammatical in one (micro-)dialect and ungrammatical in another. For other judgments that are split by dialect, the slash is used, so e.g. *I! indicates that the order is reported to be ungrammatical in one dialect, but possible under the appropriate focus conditions in another.
12.
13.
According to Wurmbrand (2004b: 48), this also holds true for Afrikaans, but not for Dutch.
Chapter 4. Verbal complexes in contemporary German
Table 4. Word orders in three-verb complexes Dialect
modal+ passive
modal+ perfect
passive perfect
double perfect
double modal
werden+ modal
IPP
MSG
3-2-1
3-2-1
3-2-1
n/a
3-2-1
1-3-2
German dialects (Wurmbrand) Austrian
3-2-1
3-2-1
3-2-1
3-2-1
3-2-1 1-3-2 3-2-1 1-3-2 13-1-2
3-2-1
3-2-1
3-2-1 3-1-2
3-2-1 11-3-2
Bavarian
W.Cen.G.
3-2-1 1-3-2 3-1-2 3-2-1 13-1-2 11-3-2
3-2-1 13-1-2 11-3-2
3-2-1 1-3-2 3-1-2
3-2-1 13-1-2 11-3-2
3-2-1 11-3-2 13-1-2
Swabian
Alsatian Swiss
3-2-1 1-3-2
3-2-1 1-3-2 3-1-2 1-2-3 *1!2-1-3 3-2-1 1-3-2 3-1-2 !1-2-3 11-3-2 13-2-1 13-1-2 11-2-3 3-2-1 1-3-2 *1!3-1-2 *1!1-2-3
3-2-1 1-3-2 3-1-2 11-2-3 3-2-1 1-3-2 3-1-2 11-2-3 1-3-2 3-1-2 1-2-3 1-3-2 13-1-2 11-2-3 3-2-1 1-3-2 3-1-2 1-2-3
3-2-1 13-2-1 1-3-2 3-1-2 *1-2-3
3-2-1 11-3-2 13-1-2 1-2-3
*113-2-1 ok/!1-3-2 ok/!3-1-2 1-2-3 *1!2-1-3
%3-2-1 1-3-2 3-1-2 1-2-3
frequent order (nine times), followed by 3-2-1 (seven times) and 1-3-2 (six times). In the modal+ passive and modal+ perfect syntagms, 1-3-2 is the most frequent (twenty-seven times), with only sixteen instances of3-2-1 and fifteen of3-1-2. In the IPP construction, the least common order in the modern dialects (1-2-3) is the most frequent in ENHG with fourteen instances, followed by eight examples of the modern order 1-3-2 and just one of the 3-1-2 order. Thus it appears that the preference in Standard German and in modern Austrian and German dialects for the 3-2-1 order with participles and the 1-3-2 order with the IPP arises after the ENHG period.
119
120
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
Table 5. Three-verb complexes, ENHG vs. contemporary dialects14 Passive _£erfect
Modal+ partici_£le
IPP
ENHG
Wurmbrand
ENHG
Wurmbrand
ENHG
Wurmbrand
Germany &Austria
3-1-2 > 3-2-1 > 1-3-2 >
3-2-1 > 1-3-2
1-3-2 > 3-2-1 > 3-1-2 >
3-2-1
1-2-3 > 1-3-2 > 3-1-2
Swiss
1-3-2 > 3-2-1/ 3-1-2
3-2-1 > 1-3-2 > 3-1-2
3-1-2 > 1-3-2/ 3-2-1
3-1-2 > 1-3-2 > (3-2-1)
1-2-3
1-3-2 > 3-1-2 > 3-2-1 > (1-2-3) 1-2-3 > 1-3-2 > 3-1-2 > (3-2-1)
Dialect
On the other hand, there is much more agreement between my ENHG results from Switzerland and Wurmbrand's (2004b) results from modern Swiss German. Modern Swiss prefers the 1-2-3 order for the IPP, and indeed all four instances of the IPP in my data from Zurich are in that order. For the modal+ perfect, modern speakers prefer the 3-1-2 and 1-3-2 orders, with 3-2-1 marginal and 1-2-3 ungrammatical and in ENHG 3-1-2 is most frequent with three occurrences, with one attestation each of 1-3-2 and 3-2-1 and none of 1-2-3. In the passive perfect in Swiss German, 3-2-1 is clearly preferred, 1-3-2 and 3-1-2 are marginal, and 1-2-3 is ungrammatical. Early Modern Swiss German shows somewhat difierent rankings, with three instances of 1-3-2 and one each of3-2-1 and 3-1-2; however, here 1-2-3 is unattested as well. In sum, the preference in Modern Swiss German for the 1-2-3 order with the IPP and for other orders with participial syntagms has clear parallels in the ENHG data from Switzerland.
4.2.4 Complexes of four or more verbs 4.2.4.1 Modern Standard German According to Duden (1995:786-787), the normal order in MSG complexes of four verbs is 4-3-2-1. The 1-4-3-2 may optionally occur with werden plus two infinitives (35) and is obligatory in the so-called high IPP construction, i.e. when ha.ben is the finite verb in the complex (36). In the low IPP, i.e. when haben is an infinitive selected by another verb, the 1-2-4-3 order is found (37).
14. Data under "Wurmbrand" are from Wurmbrand (2004b), discussed in Sections 4.2.3.2 and 4.2.3.8 above. ENHG data are those from Chapter 3, Table 28, with the Swiss numbers counted separately.
Chapter 4. Verbal complexes in contemporary German
weil er es kaufen kiinnen massen wird because he it buy4 can3 must2 will 1 'because he will have to be able to buy it' b. weil er es wird kaufen kiinnen milssen because he it will1 buy4 can3 must2
(35) a.
(36) weil er es ha.t kaufen kiinnen milssen because he it has 1 buy4 can3 must.INF 2 'because he must have been able to buy if (37) weil er es wird haben kaufen kiinnen because he it will1 have2 buy4 can.IPP3 'because he will have been able to buy it'
(Duden 1995:786-787)
There are certainly other word order possibilities in the standard language than Duden (1995) prescribes. In addition to the 1-4-3-2 order, Haegeman & van Riemsdijk (1986) claim that the high IPP allows the 1-2-4-3 order: (38) a.
b.
dass er hatte kommen wollen kiinnen that he has.SUBJI come4 want3 can.INF 2 'that he could have wanted to come' dass er hatte1 kiinnen 2 kommen4 wollen 3 (Haegeman &van Riemsdijk 1986:427)
Wollstein-Leisten et al. (1997: 70-71) indicate that lassen 'to let' behaves like werden, allowing both the usual verb-final order (39a) and the 1-3-2 order (39b ). When itself selected by another verb, la..~en may additionally show either IPP-like order (40b-c). Finally, in a complex of five verbs, a total offour orders are possible (41).15 (39) a.
b. (40) a.
b. c.
. .. daB man ihn hier liegen bleiben lasst that one him here lie3 remain 2 lets 1 '... that one lets him remain lying here' . .. daB man ilin hier lasst1 liegen3 bleiben 2 . .. da6 man ihn hier liegen bleiben lassen kann that one him here lie4 remain3 let2 can 1 '... that one can let him remain lying here' . .. daB man ilin hier kann 1 liegen4 bleiben3 lassen 2 . .. da6 man ilin hier kann 1 lassen 2 liegen 4 bleiben3
In an informal survey of four native speakers of German, (41d) was consistently rated as ungrammatical Therefore, although WOllstein-Leisten et al. list it as grammatical, I give it a question mark.
15.
121
122
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
(41) a.
b. c. d.
daB man ihn hier liegen bleiben lassen kiinnen wird that one him here lie5 remain. let3 can2 will1 that one will be able to let him remain lying here' da6 man ihn hier wird 1 liegen 5 bleiben4 lassen 3 kiinnen 2 daB man ihn hier wird 1 kiinnen 2 liegen 5 bleiben4 lassen 3 da6 man ihn hier wird 1 kiinnen 2 lassen3 liegen 5 bleiben4 (\Wllstein-Leisten et al1997:70-71)
The generalization from these examples is that the two lowest verbs in the complex must remain in the descending order.
4.2.4.2 l)ialects Wurmbrand (2004b) included in her questionnaire a section involving VCs containing four verbs with the high and low IPP constructions. Participants completed two tasks: first they arranged a scrambled-up clause into the best order, and then they judged the grammaticality of several orders. Wurmbrand (2004b: 14) notes that many speakers commented that these constructions were rare in their dialect, and some participants simplified the VCs in the re-arranging task. For the high IP P construction, the majority of German and Austrian participants accepted only the 1-4-3-2 order, as in the standard language, while the Swiss preferred 1-2-3-4 and 1-2-4-3 while also accepting other orders (Wurmbrand 2004b: 85). For the low IPP construction, speakers of all three nationalities rejected every word order in the second task (Wurmbrand 2004b: 85), although in the first task the most frequent arrangement was 1-4-2-3, followed by 4-3-2-1 and the standard-like 1-2-4-3 (Wurmbrand 2004b:59). According to Steil (1989: 36), with the high IPP in Swabian, the orders 1-4-3-2, 1-2-4-3, and 4-3-1-2 are possible when V2 is a modal:16 (42) a.
b. c.
Woisch du, worom mr den ned had ganga lassa wella? know you why we him not have1 go 4 let3 wantiNF 2 'Do you know why we did not want to let him go?' Woisch du, worom mr den ned had1 wella 2 ganga 4 lassa 3? Woisch du, worom mr den ned ganga4 lassa3 had1 wella 2? (Steil1989: 36)
When a modal governs lassen, as in the Standard German examples in (40), the 4-3-2-1 and 1-4-3-2 orders are possible:
16. When V2 is lassen, only 1-4-3-2 and 1-2-4-3 are acceptable.
Chapter 4. Verbal complexes in contemporary German
Glaubsch, daB mr den rna so liega bleibe lassa ka? think-2sG that we him PART so lie4 stay3 let2 can 1 'Do you think we can just let him remain lying like that?' b. Glaubsch, daB mr den rna so ka 1 liega4 bleibe3 1assaz? c. *Glaubsch, daB mr den rna so ka 1 Iassaz liega 4 bleibe3? d. *Glaubsch, daB mr den rna so liega4 bleibe3 ka1 lassa2? (Steil1989: 38)
(43) a.
Oddly, although Swabian allows 1-2-4-3 for the IPP, it does not allow it for modal+ lassen (43c), although that is grammatical in Standard German (40c). Not surprisingly. Swiss German shows much more variation with four-verb complexes than other varieties of German. There are eight, perhaps nine, possible word orders in the dialect of St. Gallen: 17
(44) a.
b. c. d. e. f.
hat wlJle
chiJne kampfe
has 1 want.INF 2 can3 figh4 'has wanted to be able to fight' hat1 wiJle2 kitmpfe4 chiine3
hat1 kampfe4 chiJne3 wlJle2 kitmpfe4 hitt1 wiile2 chiine3 wiile2 hat1 kitmpfe4 chiine3 wiile2 hitt1 chiine3 kampfe4 g. chiine3 kampfe4 hitt1 wlJle2 h. kitmpfe4 chone3 hiit1 wiile2 h'. kiimpfe4 chiine2 hitt1 wole3
(Scbonenberger 1995:383-384)
This state of affairs is largely in agreement with the results from the second fourverb task in Wurmbrand's (2004b) questionnaire: the majority of Swiss respondents agreed with Schonenberger in allowing 1-2-4-3, 1-2-3-4, 4-1-2-3, and 1-43-2, but unlike Schonenberger also accepted 1-4-2-3. Like Schonenberger, they rejected 4-3-2-1 and 4-1-3-2, and only 30% of them accepted 4-3-1-2, the order that Schonenberger is not sure about. IS
4.2.4.3 Comparison to ENHG Recall from Chapter 3.1.1 that there are only three instances of a four-verb complexin ENHG, and all of these are in the 1-2-4-3 order. One of them has a modal
17. ScMnenberger is unsure about the interpretation of (44h). If it means 'has wanted to be
able to fighf, then it has the structure indicated by the subscripts in (44h). However, if it means 'has been able to want to fight; then in represents a ninth order as in (44h'). 18. These judgments are found in Table 16 in an earlier version of the Wurmbrand's paper,
accessible at http://wurmbrand..uconn.edu/Papers/WG-empirical.pd.f However, in the print version, the Swiss data are not in the table (2004"b: 85).
123
124
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
as the finite verb governing lassen, and two are IPP constructions. Although three examples are not sufficient to make any firm claims, the tendency to have the 1-2-4-3 order in ENHG is supported by Hard's (1981) data from 1450-1580. Of the forty IPP four-verb complexes in Hard's study. twenty-two display the 1-2-4-3 order, eight are 1-2-3-4, and there are just a few examples of each of the other five orders (1981:63-64). Thus it appears that there is a strong ENHG tendency in VCs with four verbs, as with three verbs, to place the finite verb at the front of the complex. Moreover, 1-2-4-3 is the preferred order. This is quite different from the state of affairs in Modern German. Although the standard language requires 1-2-4-3 with the low IPP, Wurmbrand's (2004b) participants preferred 1-4-3-2 even with the low IPP. and in Swabian 1-2-4-3 is not possible when the finite verb is a modal. Thus it appears that there has been a trend from 1-2-4-3 to 1-4-3-2 in both the standard language and (non-Swiss) dialects. Hard (1981: 175) finds that these word order preferences arise in the early 19th century in Standard German.
4.2.5 Verbal complexes with an intervening constituent (1-x-2, etc.) 4.2.5-1 Modern Standard German This section deals with VCs that are split by some constituent. In the generative literature, this phenomenon is called Verb Projection Raising (see Chapter 5.2.3.2), but here as in previous chapters, the orders are given the theory-neutral descriptive labels 1-x-2, 1-x-3-2, etc. In my ENHG data, there is a robust generalization that a VC can never be broken up if the verbs are in their left-governing order, i.e., the orders *2-x-1 and *3-{x}-2-{x}-1 do not occur. Not surprisingly, this generalization holds for MSG. This means that breaking up VCs is limited to the two syntagms which allow 1-3-2, the only possible rightgoverning order in the standard language. According to Duden (1995:787), the 1-x-3-2 order is possible only in the IPP construction (45) and with werden plus two infinitives (46). This is confirmed by Kefer & Lejeune (1974), who find what they term "Einklammerung" only in these two syntagms: ... obwohl ich mich hatte niitzlich machen konnen ... although I REFL have.SUBJ 1 useful make3 can.INFz '... although I could have made myself useful ... (Kefer & Lejeune 1974: 330) ( 46) ... daB er mich wird an die Front schicken lassen. that he me will1 on the front send 2 let3 '... that he will have me sent to the front' (Kefer & Lejeune 1974: 322)
(45)
Chapter 4. Verbal complexes in contemporary German
4.2.5.2 l)ialects Some contemporary dialects of German are much more tolerant ofbreaking up the VC than the standard language is. A similar state of affairs exists in Dutch, where dialects such as West Flemish, but not Standard Dutch, display 1-x-2 and similar orders (Haegeman 1992). In what follows, examples are given of these orders in some dialects of German. Note that most of the studies that report on these orders do not indicate whether they differ in meaning from other orders. For Austrian dialects, Patocka (1997: 298-317) finds the orders 1-x-2 (47), 1-2-x-3 (48), and 1-x-3-2 (49). (47) und wia s san friah wegganga. and how they are 1 early away.gone2 'and how they went away early'
( Patocka 1997: 30 5)
(48) und wAs rna dA habm miassn rulchar aafiegn and what we there have 1 must-INF 2 afterwards on.lay3 'and what we had to put on there afterwards' ( Patocka 1997: 299)
(49) wAnn i wein hab aus da Not htJ(l)fa kina when I someone have 1 out the need help 3 can-INF 2 'when I was able to help someone in need' ( Patocka 1997: 299) Note that Patocka does not report an order which is found in ENHG, 1-x-2-3 (see Chapter 2.1.1 above). Patocka (1997: 317) finds that these orders are completely optional, although he speculates that they may be favored by factors such as focus and semantic closeness between the intervening constituent and the verb. Weill (1998) shows that the verbal complex can be split by some constituent in Bavarian main clauses: (50) der hod wolln sei Sau abstecha he has 1 want-INF 2 his sow slaughter3 'he wanted to slaughter his sow'
(WeiB 1998: 54)
He refers to this as main-clause phenomenon, not indicating whether breaking up the VC is possible in subordinate clauses. Dubenion-Smith finds twenty instances of the 1-x-2 order in West Central German (2008: 89). In eleven of these cases the intervening item is a stressed separable prefix (51a),19 with two to four examples each of intervening adjectives/adverbs (51b), PPs (51c), and indefinite NPs (51d).
19. Note that in Chapters 2 and 3, I do not consider verbal prefixes to be intervening constitu-
ents, treating such cases as instances of the 1-2 order, rather than the 1-x-2 order.
125
126
The Verbal Complex in Subordinate Clauses from Medieval to Modern German
(51) a.
b.
c.
d.
dass man so frlih musste aufstehen that one so early must1 stand-up 2 'that you had to get up so early' die so frUh wollten fertig sein who so early wanted 1 finished be 2 'who wanted to be finished so early' dass er jeden Augenblick musste hinter eine Heeke laufen that he any moment must1 behind a hedge run2 'that he had to run behind a hedge at any moment' dass sie da massen einen ordentlichen Korb . . . kochen that they there must1 a decent basket cook2 'that they have to cook a decent basketful of food' (Dubenion-Smith 2008:89)
Dubenion-Smith only finds four instances of three-verb complexes with an intervening constituent, all of which are in the 1-x-3-2 order (2008: 96): (52) well die ja massen warm gemacht werden because they yes must 1 warm made3 be2 'because they must be made warm' (Dubenion-Smith 2008: 96) Steil ( 1989: 85-9 3) discusses intervening constituents only in three-verb complexes. (This may be taken to imply that 1-x-2 is ungrammatical in Swabian, which I find to be the case in Section 4.3.2.2 below.) The orders 1-x-3-2 (53), and 1-2-x-3 (54) are grammatical as in Austrian dialects. Also as in Austrian, the 1-x-2-3 order (55) is ungrammatical. Oddly. a similar yet more complex order, 1-x-2-x-3 (56) is more acceptable.zo (53) ... , wenn se han da Kuu(r)zkratta traga kenna. when they have1 the short-basket carry3