This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
(for a doublet <S2>= 0.75) and therefore the wavefunction is appreciably contaminated by states of higher multiplicity. Brown and Williams196 performed a singleannihilation on their UHF wavefunction in their work on the potential energy surfaces of some small free radicals. Nevertheless, they find that in the dissociation of NH2 in its ground and first-excited states (2B1and aA1) the values of (S2>deviate sharply from 0.75 as the N-€€ bond lengths are increased. States of multiplicity greater than quartets are evidently mixing-in and the necessity for a complete projection is indicated. A similar situation is found by these authors in the BH2 and CH + dissociation calculations. It appears that one must approach the use of the UHF method warily, being prepared to l95
A. W. Salotto and L. Burnelle, J. Chem. Phys., 1970,52,2936;J. Chem. Phys., 1970,53, 335. D. Brown and G. R. Williams, Mol. Phys., 1973, 25, 673.
lQ6R.
48
Theoretical Chemistry
undergo the additional computational effort required to use spin projection to whatever extent is needed to ensure that the final wavefunction is spin-pure. The IEPA Method.-Another method of including electron correlation has found growing use in the calculation of potential energy surfaces. In this technique, called the ‘independent electron pair approach’ (IEPA), the total correlation energy in a system is expressed as a sum of the correlation energies of pairs of electrons in the field of the other electr0ns.19~To a good approximation, it can be shown1828198 that the total energy of the system can be written as follows: E
N
EHF +
zeta i
+ i< zeal j
where ~ i isg the energy associated with the correlation between electrons in the same orbital (intrapair correlation) and represents the energy resulting from the correlation of electrons in different orbitals (interpair correlation). Examples of this method are the recent work of Driessler, Ahlrichs, Staemmler, and KutzelnigglgQon the equilibrium geometries and other properties of CH3, C H t , the inversion barrier in CH, and the potential surface for LiHi referred to previously.lo5 6 H
+
A Benchmark Reaction Progress in the calculation of complete potential energy surfaces can best be followed by considering in detail the work that has been done on one of the simplest of exchange reactions, namely H H2-+H2 H. Semi-empiricalCalculations.-Many groups have used both semi-empirical and ab initio methods to produce potential energy surfaces for the ground state of Ha. A thorough bibliography of the work prior to 1967 is given by Hayes and Parr200 and an excellent review of the earlier results in this field can be found in reference 201. Because much of the earlier work involved the use of semi-empirical methods and the fact that the authors have chosen to restrict this work to a discussion of ab initiu calculations, we will describe, for the purpose of comparison, only one semi-empirical potential energy surface, the one which Porter and Karplus 22 calculated for H3 in 1964. The Porter and Karplus (PK) H3 surface is based on a modification of the London-Eyring-Polanyi (LEP) method.19 All overlap and three-centre terms were included. Empirical values were introduced for two-centre integrals by a modified Sat0 technique,20 and analytical approximations were used for the more complex integrals. Linear and non-linear configurations for H3 were considered. A linear symmetrical col or saddle-point configuration was found at an H-H separation of R = 1.701 a.u. with a barrier height of 38.2 kJ mol -l. [The barrier height E b = Ecalc(H H2)-Ecalc(H3 at saddle point), the energies of all species being calculated the same way.] When the zero-point vibrational energy is included, this becomes 36.8 kJ mol-l. As we will discuss below, this value is in very good agreement with the cu. 38 kJ mol-l predicted from experiment. Earlier semiempirical calculations predicted the presence of a basin or well in the saddle-point H2:
+
+
+
197 198 109 200 201
For a review of this method, see; R. K. Nesbet, Adv. Chem. Phys., 1969, 14, 237. 0. Sinanoglu, J. Chem. Phys., 1962, 36, 706, 3198. F. Driessler, R. Ahlrichs, V. Staemmler, and W. Kutzelnigg, Theor. Chim. A d a , 1973,30, 3 15. E. F. Hayes and R. G. Pam, J. Chem. Phys., 1967, 47, 3961. K. J. Laidler, ‘Theories of Chemical Reaction Rates’, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1969.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
49
12.0
-
8.0
-E"mu
'
4.0
0.0 0.0
1.o
2.0
3.0
R1a.u.
Figure 4 Comparison of energy profiles along the reaction path for linear Ha. (-Shavitt, Stevens, Minn, and Karplus, ref. 112; ---- Liu, ref. 210; Porter and Karplus, ref. 22; - - - - Conroy and Bruner, ref. 207)
--
9
9
+
region of the surface. No well was found in the barrier region of the PK surface. It is interesting to note that this is the thinnest of the theoretical surfaces computed for Hs to-date (see Figure 4). Ab Imzio Calculations.--The first ab initio calculation on H3 was performed by Hirschfelder, Eyring, and Rosen202on the linear symmetric system in 1936. The valence bond method with the inclusion of ionic states was used. The wavefunctions were composed of 1s atomic orbitals. A barrier height (Eb) greater than 40kcd mo1-1 was obtained, a value which was clearly much too high. In 1954, Barker et aZ.203 performed similar calculations on linear H3, but with independent variation of the effective charges on the middle and outer atoms. The barrier height found was in close agreement with that of Hirschfelder et al. Although the next few years show some activity in the field 205 improvements in results had to await the perfection of high-speed digital computers. An example is the variational calculation made on a few configurations of the H3 system by Boys and Shavitt205 in 1959. The barrier height of 62 kJ mol-1, while an improvement over previous ab initio work, still did not compare with the experimental or the semi-empirical results given by the PK surface. 204p
20%
*03 *04
205
J. 0. Hirschfelder, H. Eyring, and H. Rosen, jun., J. Chem. Phys., 1936, 4, 121, 130. R. S. Barker, H. Eyring, C. J. Throne, and D. A. Baker, J. Chem. Phys., 1955, 22, 699; R. S. Barker and H. Eyring, J. Chem. Phys., 1957, 26, 971. B. J. Ransil, J. Chem. Phys., 1957, 26, 971; R. Snow and H. Eyring, J. Phys. Chem., 1957, 6 1 , l ; G . E. Kimball and J. G. TruIio,J. Chem. Phys., 1958,28,493; V . Griffing, J. L. Jackson, and B. J. Ransil, J. Chem. Phys., 1959, 30, 1066. S. F. Boys and I. Shavitt, University of Wisconsin Naval Research Laboratory Tech. Rept. WIS-AF-13 (1959).
50
Theoretical Chemistry
In 1967, Hayes and Parr200did studies on linear symmetric H3 at separations of 1.6, 1.7, and 1.8 a.u. between adjacent protons using a 70-configuration CI calculation. The basis set was composed of single-centreSTO’s. The energy of - 1.6358 a.u. for the symmetrical H3 complex with an H-H separation R = 1.80 a.u. was an improvement over previous ab initio calculations. Hayes and Parr did not perform calculations for the separated species H2 + H and therefore a barrier height Eb as defined above, cannot be ascertained for their work. We can, however, define another barrier height Eb in the following way:
&xact(H
+
H2) = Eexact(H) = 0.5000
+
+
Eexact(H2)
1.1745 = 1.6745 a.u.
The value for H2 is taken from the work of Kolos and Wolniewicz.206 Hayes and Pam’s results yield a value of E’, of 101.6 kJ mol-1, again too high for agreement with experiment. But 1967 was a year of great activity in the ab initio calculation of potential energy surfaces of H3, for three other groupsl12~18*~ 207 had also entered the field. We will discuss the three other computations in the following paragraphs. In 1964, Conroy had developed a method207a for solving the molecular Schrodinger equation using variational trial functions that explicitly included the interelectronicco-ordinates and thus took account of the correlation effect. He had applied the method to various small systems. In 1967, Conroy and B r ~ n e r ~ O ~ applied this method to the H3 surface. The potential energies of 41 different linear arrangements and 27 triangular arrangements of H3 were calculated. The minimum energy path was found to pass through a maximum 32.4kJmol-1 above the reactants at a linear symmetric configuration with R = 1.76 a.u. The energy at this geometry was reported as - 1.6621 a.u. The data in Table 6, which summarize the results of the most recent calculations on the H3 surface, indicate that to-date this is the lowest energy found at the saddle-point geometry of H3. It is important to note, however, that Conroy’s method of calculation does not necessarily yield Table 6 Calculations on the linear H3 molecule R/a.u. E1a.u. &/kJ mol-1 E2/kJmol-1 Force constants1a.u. symmetric stretch bending asymmetric stretch a
Ref. 22.
206
207
@
PKa HPb 1.701 1 .so - 1.6600 - 1.6358 38.2 38.1 101.6 0.36 0.024 -0.124
Ref. 200. Ref. 207.
-
-
CBc 1.76 - 1.6622 32.4 32.4 0.32 0.026 ca. 0.00
Refs. 184 and 209.
EKd 1.80 -1.6493 56.5 66.1
-
-
SSMKe 1.764 -1.6521 46.0 58.6
LIUf 1.757 -1.6581 41 .O 43 .O
0.31 0.024 -0.061
0.320 - 0.058
Ref. 112. f Ref. 210.
W. Kolos and L. Wolniewicz, J. Chem. Phys., 1965, 43, 2429. (a)H.Conroy and B. L. Bruner, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,47,921; (b) H. Conroy,J. Chem. Phys., 1964,41, 1327, 1331, 1336, 1341.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
51
an upper bound to the energy.* Thus, the usual criteria for comparing calculations (Le. how low is the energy?) cannot be applied here. The method appears to produce results whose accuracy is inconsistent from point-to-point on the surface. This leads to two unexpected results, one being a very flat barrier top and the other being the H2 ca. 2 a.u. away from the presence of an energy minimum with respect to H col (see Figure 4). At about the same time, pseudonatural orbitals were used by Edmiston and Krauss184~209 as a basis for a 65-configuration CI calculation on the linear H3 surface. Five s, two pa, three pnx, and two pn, type GTO’s were centred on each of the three nuclei and the energies at 28 geometries were computed. At the linear symmetricgeometry, a minimum energy of - 1.6493 a.u. was found at R = 1.8 a.u. This value was further reduced to - 1.65492 a.u. by extrapolating the values of the computed correlationerror. This corresponded to a barrier height Eb of 50 kJ mol -l. The energy of the dominant contiguration in the CI expansion is - 1.5922 a.u., which closely approaches the HartreFock limit. It is interesting to note the change in the correlation energy along the reaction path computed in this work. The correlation H, is ca. 0.04 a.u. and this increases steadily to a value error of the reactants, Hz of ca. 0.06 a.u. at the saddle point. This significant change is to be expected in the light of the previous discussion on the importance of including correlation effects in a system of this type. The fourth group to work on the theoretical calculation of the H3 surface in 1967 was Shavitt, Stevens, Minn, and Karp1us.ll2 An STO basis set composed of Is, ls’, 2pz, 2pV,2pz on each of the three hydrogens was used in calculations on both the linear and triangular geometries of the system. All possible determinants were used in a configuration interaction calculation (200 in the linear symmetric and 402 in the linear asymmetric). In this work, as in all previous work, the linear geometries were found to yield the reaction path. For the linear geometries, potential energies at 158 points were calculated and at 26 of these, the orbital exponentswere optimized. The saddle point was found at R = 1.765 a.u. (again no well appeared at the top of the barrier) with a potential energy of - 1.6521 ax. This corresponds to a barrier height (4%) of 46 kJ mol -l. The most thorough work to-date on the H3 surface is that reported in 1973 by Liu.210 An STO basis set was used consisting of Is, ls’, 2s, W ,2p, 2p’, 3p’, 36 and 4d functions on each hydrogen atom. Here we see the first inclusion of d-type functions in H3 calculations. The exponents were optimized for the ground state of Hz at a separation of 1.4 a.u. This optimization was conducted by minimizing the complete configuration interaction (126 configurations). The SCF energy obtained with the major configuration is within 5.0 x 10-5 a.u. of the Hartree-Fock limit. Comparing his CI curve of H2(X1Z3 with the essentially exact results of Kdos and Wolniewicz,206 Liu found that the CI curve is very nearly parallel to the exact curve near the equilibrium separation. The energy difference between the two results at
+
+
*
See ref. 208 and footnote 30 in ref. 112.
208
209 210
H. Conroy and B. L.Bruner, J. Chem. Phys., 1965, 42,4047. C. Edmiston and M. Krauss, J. G e m . Phys., 1965, 42, 1119. B. Liu, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 1925
.
52
Theoretical Chemistry
a nuclear separation of 1.4 a.u. is 7.7 x 10 -4 a.u., evidence of a sufficiently adequate wavefunction, at least for Ha. Considering the large basis set involved (27 o-type, 15 n-type, and six 6-type functions) a complete CI, while within the capabilities of available computers, is certainly using these capabilities to their limits. In this work, Liu tests yet another method for truncating a full CI wavefunction. The method begins with an MCSCF calculation on a severely truncated CI wavefunction. Configurations are then systematically added in order to establish a convergence pattern which could be extrapolated to the complete CI limit. The nparticle space is partitioned into a set of configurations including all dominant terms in the full CI expansion for all nuclear geometries considered, and a set containing the remainder of the n-particle space. The first of these is composed of what Liu calls the internal approximate natural orbitals (ANO) which are those associated with large occupation numbers. The second set is further divided into a finite number of sub-spaces according to the following rule: the ith-order sub-space contains those and only those n-particle functions which are orthogonal to all lower-order subspaces and have non-zero Hamiltonian matrix elements with at least one function in the (i- l)th-order sub-space. In the case O f €33, Liu's first-order sub-space contains all configurationswith one or two electrons in internal orbitals and the other electron or electrons in the remaining or external orbitals. The second-order sub-space contains configurations with all three electrons occupying external orbitals. Using this method, Liu extrapolates his results to produce a minimum energy of - 1.6581 a.u. on the linear reaction path at a saddle-point geometry of R = 1.757 a.u. This yields H. a barrier which is 41 kJ mol-1 above the calculated energy of H2 Rate constant measurements211 and quasi-classical trajectory calculations2 1 2 s 213 indicate a barrier height of ca. 38 kJ mol-1 for the H + H2 exchange reaction. The 38.2kJmol-1 barrier height of the Porter-Karplus surface and the 41 kJ mol-1 value obtained by Liu, therefore, are in good agreement with the experimental results. The situation is much different, however, regarding the reported hydrogen-hydrogen distances at the col. Note from Table 6, for example, that three of the a6 initio calculations, those of Conroy and Br~ner,~o'Shavitt and coworkers,ll2 and Liu,210 agree on a value of 1.76 a.u., whereas two others, Hayes and Parrz*Oand Edmiston and Krauss18* report a higher value of 1.80 ax. The PorterKarplus surface, on the other hand, predicts an H-H distance of only 1.701 a.u. The preponderance of theoretical evidence, then, seems to be on the side of the larger values, and the Porter-Karplus value is probably too small. Table 6 shows that the variation in the reported symmetric stretch and bending force constants is relatively small. For the asymmetric stretching force constant only the Shavitt et al. and Liu values of -0.061 a.u. and - 0.058 a.u., respectively, are in substantial agreement, the PK surface yielding a value of -0.124 a.u. which is more than a factor of two greater. Figure 5 shows the minimum energy path for three of the computed linear H3 surfaces considered here. Shavitt et al. who gave a similar plot112noted a peculiar
+
211
W. R. Schulz and D. J. LeRoy, J. Chem. Phys., 1965, 42, 3869; R. E. Weston, jun., ibid.,
212
1959, 31, 892; I. Shavitt, ibid., 1959, 31, 1359. M. Karplus, R. N. Porter, and R. D. Sharma, J. Chem. Phys., 1964,40, 2033. M. Karplus, R. N. Porter, and R. D. Sharma, J. Chem. Phys., 1965,43, 3259.
213
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
1.o
2.0
53
3.0
R,/a.u.
Figure 5 Comparison of reactionpaths for linear Hs surface. See Figure 4 for details feature which is found in all semi-empirical surfaces. This is the 'kink' which is found in the saddle-point region of the Porter-Karplus plot. The minimum energy path for the Conroy and Bruner207surface (not shown in Figure 5 ) very closely parallels that of Liu except for what appears to be a very small 'kink' at the col. Note that in both Figures 4 and 5 the Liu210 surface is very nearly parallel to the surface of Shavitt et In comparing these latter two sets of calculations, one notes that there are just two major differences: the Liu surface approaches the equilibrium H2 geometry more quickly and its barrier height is lower. The H3 potential surface which has been most widely used in transition stateY2l4 classical dynamicaly213,215 and quantum mechanical dynamical216 -218 calculations has been the semi-empirical surface of Porter and Karplus.22 Because of the thin potential barrier of the PK surface, one would expect a larger amount of quantum mechanical tunnelling to be predicted at room temperature (this has been found to be the case in calculations performed by Johnston219 on barriers in the very similar LEPS surfaces). However, Karplus et aL2139215 compared classical and quantum mechanical calculations on the PK surface and found that reaction cross-sections for both are very similar, and therefore that the tunnelling effect in the Hs system is small. Transition-statetheory was applied to the SSMK surface1l2by Shavitt22* in 1968. The plots of the log of the rate constant against the reciprocal of the temperature calculated by Shavitt are in excellent agreement with experimental results on 214
216 216
217 d18
219 220
3
K. Morokuma, B. C. Eu, and M. Karplus, J. Chem. Phys., 1969,51, 5193. M. Karplus and K. T. Tang, Discuss. Faraday Soc., 1967, 44, 56. J. W. Duff and D. G. Truhlar, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 23, 327; D. J. Diestler, J. G e m . Phys., 1971, 54, 4547; S. Wu and R. D. Levine, Mol. Phys., 1971, 22, 881; B. R. Johnson, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 13, 172. D. J. Diestler and M. Karplus, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 5832. S.-F. W u , B. R. Johnson, and R. D. Levine, Mol. Phys., 1973, 25, 609 H. S. Johnston, Ado. Chem. Phys., 1960, 3, 131. I. Shavitt, J. Chem. Phys., 1968, 49, 4048.
Theoretical Chemistry
54
+
+
H Hz, H D2, D + H2, and D + D2,221although it was necessary for him to scale his surface to a barrier height of 41 kJ mol-1. This 11% reduction in the barrier height was applied uniformly along the total reaction path. The asymmetric force constant given in Table 1 has been scaled down by the same amount. Shavitt includes the quantum-mechanical tunnelling effect by fitting an Eckart 222 barrier to the calculated SSMK barrier. Kupperman et al.223 -226 compared transition-state, classical, and quantum mechanical thermal rate constants using the SSMK surface.l12In ab initio potential energy surface calculations, the potential energy is known only as a list of values at selected geometries of the system. It becomes necessary, then, if trajectory calculations are to be made, to fit the calculated points to a smooth and continuous ‘map’. In their calculations, Kupperman et al. fit the collinear SSMK surface by the rotating Morse function procedure of Wall and Porter.227 Koeppl228 has applied transition-state theory to the Liu surface. Again, a plot of log k 1:s 1/ T agrees with the experimental results cited above.221Since the barrier height was computed by Liu to be 41 kJmol-l, no barrier height scaling was necessary in this case. Truhlar and Kupperman229have shown that tunnelling calculations from Eckart potential fits to the potential energy barrier lead to systematic errors and that agreement with experiments must be considered the result of fortuitous cancellation of errors. For this reason, Koeppl takes no account of tunnelling in his work. More recently, Yates and Lester230 fitted Liu’s surface with a slightly modified form of the Porter-Karplus formulas after first fitting Liu’s H2 potential to a simple Morse function. They then use the resulting surface to calculate the three-dimensional classical trajectory of the system. Their empirical fit very closely duplicates Liu’s saddle-point properties. Reaction probabilities on this surface are compared with those on the PK surface. All things considered, it appears that the Liu surface probably approaches very closely to the true potential energy surface of H3. In addition, Liu’s method of selecting configurations is certainly one which will find wider application in future CI calculations. It is uncertain at present, however, how large a molecular system can thus be accommodated.
7 Potential Energy Surfaces from Correlated Wavefunctions H;.--In 1970, Csizmadia et aZ.231 carried out an extensive SCF-CI calculation on the potential energy surface of H l . Four or five s-type GTO’s and at least onep-type (a) B. A. Ridley, W. R. Schulz, and D. J. LeRoy, J. Chem. Phys., 1966, 44,3344; (b) A. A. Westenberg and N. deHaas, ibid., 1967, 47, 1393; (c) D. N. Mitchell and D. J. LeRoy, ibid., 1973,58, 3449; ( d ) W. R. Schulz and D. J. LeRoy, Canad. J. Chem., 1964,42, 2480. 222 C. Eckart, Phys. Rev.,1930, 35, 1303. 223 J. M. Bowman and A. Kuppermann, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 6524. 224 J. M. Bowman and A. Kuppermann, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 12, 1. 225 D. G. Truhlar and A. Kuppermann, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 9, 269. *26 D. G. Truhlar and A. Kuppermann, J. Chem. Phys., 1970, 52, 3841. 2 2 7 F. T. Wall and R. N. Porter, J. Chem. Phys., 1962, 36, 3256. 208 G. W. Koeppl, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 3425. 229 D. G. Truhlar and A. Kuppermann, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 1971, 93, 1840. 230 A. C. Yates and W.A. Lester, jun., Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 24, 305. 231 I. G. Csizmadia, R. E. Karl, J. C. Polanyi, A. C. Roach, and M. A. Robb, J. Chem. Phys., 1970, 52, 6205. 221
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
55
GTO was centred on each atom in the SCF calculation. A CI calculation was then performed using 120 configurations involving 15 of the molecular orbitals. The excitations were to the virtual orbitals produced by the SCF method. The equilibrium geometry was found to be an equilateral triangle with bond lengths of 1.66 a.u. which is in general agreement with previous ~ o r k . A ~ study 3 ~ of the effect of changes in the basis set showed that the addition of a singlep-type function resulted in a reduction in the energy of the system by cn. 0.02 a.u. at the equilibrium geometry before CI. The effect is even greater with the CI wavefunction. The SCF energy at the equilibrium geometry (with a 5s,2p GTO set) is reported to be - 1.29930 a.u. which, after CI, is reduced to -1.3397 a.u. Similar CI calculations performed at collinear symmetric geometries produced a minimum energy of - 1.2765 a.u. at an H-H separation of 1.54 a.u. Csizmadia and co-workers233 then used a smaller basis set (5sJp) in a CI calculation at 250 points on the H: potential surface. Threedimensional classical trajectory calculations for the reaction D + + H2+H + + HD were then carried out. In a subsequent work, Preston and TullylS discuss the limited value of these latter calculations due to the neglect of a non-adiabatic interaction of the ground state, with a second state which describes the dissociation of the system into the products H + HD+. More recently, Carney and P 0 r t e r ~ 3used ~ a GTO basis set of 21 functions, six of which have centres outside of the molecule, to calculate the potential energy for 42 equilateral geometries of H:. A limited optimization of the exponents was performed. The SCF energy at a calculated internuclear distance of 1.64 a.u. was found to be - 1.299 273 a.u. A second calculation involving a 309-configuration CI gave an energy of - 1.339 358 a.u. at R = 1.649 984 a.u. The close agreement with the work of Csizmadia et al.231 is obvious even to a comparison of the cuts through the two potential surfaces which are shown in ref. 234. There is also good agreement with the energy and equilibrium bond lengths predicted by Salmon and P o ~ h u s t a . ~ ~ ~ The avoided intersection of the two potential surfaces in the H i system was studied in detail in a full CI calculation by Bauschlicher et aZ.236 An uncontracted 5s and 2p GTO basis set was used. The lowest surface was found to be attractive, with a binding energy of 444 kJ mol -1 for relative to H and €12. The second surface which represents H H;f is reported to be repulsive in nature. He + H;-+HeH+ + H.-Two different approaches of He to the H i ion were investigated by Edmiston et aZ.116 using the same method they applied to H3.184. 209 An uncontracted GTO basis set with polarization functions ( 6 4 2pz, 3pz,von helium and 4s, lp,, 3px,tlon each hydrogen) was used and pseudonatural orbitals were calculated for the 102 pair. A 65-configuration CI followed in which ca. 90 % of the correlation energy was accounted for. The energies of 22 different linear He-H-H + geometries were calculated. A minimum which lies about 21 kJ mol-1 below the separated reactants is found at He-H and H-H+ bond distances of ca. 2.0 a.u.
+
232
z33 234
235 236
Hl
+
R. E. Christoffersen, J. Chem. Phys., 1964, 41, 960; W. Kutzelnigg, R. Ahlrichs, I. LabibIskander, and W. A. Bingel, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1967, 1, 447. I. G. Csizmadia, J. C. Polanyi, A. C. Roach, and W. H. Wong, Canad. J. Chem., 1969, 47, 4097. G . D. Carney and R. N. Porter, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 4251. C. Salmon and R. D. Poshusta, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 3497. C . W. Bauschlicher, jun., S. V. O'Neil, R. K. Preston, H. F. Schaefer, and C. F. Bender, J. Chem. Phys.,:1973, 59, 1286.
56
Theoretical Chemistry
The barrier height is about 75 kJ mol-l. The authors consider this to be a type of hydrogen-bonding arising from the polarization of the He atom by the HZ. A potential energy barrier of 105 kJ mol-1 is found for the dissociation of the symmetric H at H-H and He-H distances of ca. 2.1 a.u. complex H-He-H+ into HeH+ (12 points were calculated for this geometric configuration). Comparing this to the value for the linear approach, forces one to rule out the insertion of He into the H-H+ bond along a CzVpath as a reaction path. Note that an electron pair is neither made nor broken along the reaction path. As discussed earlier in this chapter, one would expect that in this case a HartreeFock wavefunction would be sufficient to describe the system. The results of Edmiston et al. show that this is indeed the case, for the correlation energy is found to be approximately constant along the reaction path. Thus, the HF and CT paths are nearly parallel. With this in mind, a non-CI calculation was performed at a large number of points (82) in the He-H-H+ system by Brown and Hayes.185 The results are in general agreement with Edmiston et al. An He-H-H bond angle variation at four values of the angle at the minimum energy bond lengths indicates that the linear form is most stable. KuntzZ3'used the diatomics-in-molecules(DIM) approximation to fit a function to the surface of Brown and Hayes.ls5 The resulting collinear potential surface is in qualitative agreement. However, extrapolation to non-linear geometries appears to indicate that the isosceles geometries are energetically as favourable as the linear ones, which is in disagreement with Brown and Hayes. Clearly, further ab initio work on the non-linear geometries of this system is needed. HeH2.4ordon and SecrestllO used various numbers of STO's in an SCF-CI calculation on the HeH2 system. The smallest basis set used was composed of two s-type functions on He and one s-type function on each of the hydrogens. This set was sequentially built up to a set of two s-type and threep-type functions on He and one s-type and threep-type functions on each hydrogen. The combined energy of the separated species, helium atom plus hydrogen molecule, was calculated with a.u. from the Hartree-Fock limit. At a the largest basis set to be within 6 x fixed H-H distance of 1.40 a m , the distance of the He atom to the centre of the H-H bond (X) and the angle 8 between X and the H-H internuclear axis was varied from 2.8 to 7.0 a.u. and from 0 to go", respectively. Eighty configurations were mixed in a CI. This latter wavefunction gave a total energy of the separated products of -4.04921 a.u. which is 99.3 % of the experimental energy for He H2. The effect of orbital optimization was studied with the smaller basis set at X = 2.80 and 3.80 a.u. and with 8 at 90 and 0".Only at the shorter distance at the linear geometry is there a change in interaction energy, the effect at the other three geometries being negligible. This effect is seen with and without CI. Gordon and Secrest used an analytical function in the form proposed by Roberts2S8 and Krauss and Mies239to approximate the interaction potential as a function of X, 8, and the H-H internuclear distance. A plot of their results closely approximates
+
+
237
238 239
P. J. Kuntz, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 16, 581. C . S . Roberts, Phys. Rev., 1963, 131, 203. M. Krauss and F. N. Mies, J. Chem. Phys., 1965, 42, 2703.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
57
the experimental results240 in the range 2.8 < X <5.2 a.u. It is also found that at the small X values, the interaction energies found with and without CI are very similar. Note that this is a situation in which the products of dissociation are both closedshell systems and therefore another case in which an SCF potential energy surface properly described the dissociation. The interaction potentials calculated by Gordon and Secrest have subsequently been used in scattering calculations by Eastes and Secrest 241 and Alexander and Berard.242 Electron density maps at various points on the reaction path were generated by Gordon, Secrest, and L l a g u n ~using , ~ ~ the ~ Gordon-Secrest SCF wavefunctions. Schaefer et al.244investigated the interaction potential between ground-state He and the B state of HZusing a (6sY2p)GTO basis on helium contracted to a [3sY2p]set. For the hydrogen molecule, a (4s) set was contracted to [2s]and then an additional s function was added and optimized for the B state of H2 at R = 2.43 a.u. in order to describe properly the very diffuse nature of the 1cu orbital. As many as 706 configurations were included in a CI calculation. A large van der Waals interaction between He and the B state of H2 is found at R = 3.72 a.u. with a depth of 0.05 eV. H2 + D2-+2HD.-The theoretical search for the probable shape of the transition state in the four-centre exchange reaction Ha D2+2HD has been under way for many years (a review of the earlier work in this field may be found in ref. 245). The controversy is centred on the inability of thorough ab initio calculations to find a mechanism for the reaction with a barrier height as low as that suggested on the basis of shock-tube experiments.246~247 Three studies were done recently, two with ~~ de full CI 245,248 and one explicitly using interparticle c o - o r d i n a t e ~ ,a~method scribed above in conjunction with the work of Conroy and Bruner207on H3. Wilson and Goddard248 used a minimal Slater basis set (one ls-type function on each hydrogen) in a full (36 configuration) CI. A doublezeta basis set (two ls-type Slater functions on each hydrogen) was used in the CI calculations (up to 176 configurations) of Rubenstein and S h a ~ i t t . ~Although 4~ the energies of the latter work are lower, both groups report results which are essentially the same. Table 7 shows that the barrier heights reported by Rubenstein and Shavitt relative to two H2 molecules at infinite separation are, except for the linear system, all above 400 kJ mol-1. Wilson and Goddard 248 investigated three additional configurations, a regular trapezoid, centred equilateral triangle and a kite-shaped molecule. The barrier heights for these systems were also over 400 kJ mol -l. The problem that arises in these works is that the shock-tube experiments indicate that the activation energy for the reaction is only 176 kJ mol -l. As can be seen
+
240
241 242
243 244
z45 246
247 248 249
I. Amdur and A. P. Malinauskas, J. Chem. Phys., 1965, 42, 3355. W. Eastes and D. Secrest, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 56, 640. M. A. Alexander and E. V. Berard, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60,3950. M. D. Gordon, D. Secrest, and C. Llaguno, J . Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 1046. H. F. Schaefer, D. Wallach, and C. F. Bender, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 56, 1219. M. Rubinstein and I. Shavitt, J. Chem. Phys., 1969, 51, 2014. S. H. Bauer and E. Ossa, J. Chem. Phys., 1966, 45, 434. A. Burcat and A. Lifshitz, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,47,3079; D. Lewis and S. H. Bauer, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1968,90, 5390. C. W. Wilson, jun. and W. A. Goddard, J. Chem. Phys., 1969, 51, 716; 1972,56, 5913. H. Conroy and G . Malli, J. Chem. Phys., 1969, 50, 5049.
58
l'koretical Chemistry
Table 7 Barrier heights calculated by Rubinstein and S h a ~ i t for t ~ various ~~ transition states for the reaction H2 -+ D2 -+ HD System
Linear equidistant Rectangular (4 : 5) Square Rhombic (70")
Tetrahedral
Rmin/a.u. 1.7 2.09; 2.61 2.47 2.5 3.8
AE/kJ mol-1 180 456 594 632 757
from Table 7, the linear path has approximately the right barrier height. Note, however, that this path cannot serve as a transition state for the four-centre exchange reaction. The other systems produce barrier heights over twice as great as the experimental results. In fact, from the ab initio results, one would be led to the conclusion that the breaking of an H2 bond (ca. 448 kJ mol-l) followed by the reaction H + D2+D + HD would be energetically more favourable. Transition states which correspond to two unequal-length HZmolecules are consistent with the mechanism proposed by Bauer and co-workers 246 which involves a vibrationally excited Hz molecule reacting with a normal one. Wilson and Goddard's investigation of systems with unequal H-H bond distances, however, proved to be equally unfruitful. As stated before, one cannot directly equate the barrier heights to experimental activation energies; trajectory calculations must be performed on the surface in order to arrive at a theoretical activation energy. One can make an order-of-magnitude comparison, however, by noting that in the H2 + H system the activation energy was calculated213to be lower than the barrier height by about 8 kJ mol-l. A lowering of this order of magnitude will certainly not alter the situation. Tapia and Bessis250 investigated four geometric conformations in a CI study of H4 in which polarization functions were added, Although their results do not shed further light on the problem of the mechanism of the reaction (a very small set of geometric variations were investigated) they did find a minimum in the van der Waals region for the linear configuration close to the one predicted by Gordon and Cashion.251 Bender and Schaefer252 performed a set of full CI calculations on the linear symmetric H4 system using a GTO basis set which included p-functions. More recently, Silver and Stevens253extended the work even further by optimizing the orbital exponents and including more geometrical configurations in the study (the perpendicular approach, an alternative kite, and a parallelogram). Although a path was still not found in these latter two works which allowed a bimolecular mechanism for exchangerequiring less energy than a single H Zdissociation,Silver and Stevens253 found a path which requires c 25 kJ mol -1 of energy above this limit. This path is one which leads from trapezoidal to linear structures. In calculating portions of potential energy surfaces, it is only natural, considering the computer time used for ab initio calculations with CI, for investigators to choose 250
251
2s2 253
D. Tapia and G . Bessis, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1972, 25, 130. R. G. Gordon and J. J. Cashion, J. Chem. Phys., 1966, 44, 1190. C. F. Bender and H. F. Schaefer, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 217. D. M. Silver and R. M. Stevens, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 3378.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
59
to study first those portions of the surface with high symmetry. In the present case, however, it appears that a complete hypersurface for H4 may have to be calculated before the question of the mechanism of the exchange reaction is fully resolved. HeH+ + Ha+He + H$.-If the problems of the potential energy surface of the tetra-atomic H4 system are difficult to surmount, the HeHf system which, because it is heteronuclear lacks the symmetry of the former case, could have proven to be intractable. Nevertheless, three groups in recent years have attacked the problem of the reaction HeH+ + H2+He + H l using ab initio rnethods.104~254~255 The most recent of these is the work of Benson and McLaughlin.104 While this work was discussed earlier, details of their calculation are given here. An uncontracted GTO basis set composed of 9s- and lp-type function on He, and 4s- and lp-type function on each hydrogen (a total of 33 functions) was used. An estimate of the completeness of this set was obtained by calculating the single-determinant SCF energies of the four dominant fragments in the reaction: HeH+, Hz, He, and Hi. The results approached within 0.003 a.u. (8 kJ inol-1) of the Hartree-Fock values. As in the H Icase, the major problem that had to be resolved was the geometry of the reaction path. For this purpose the following four paths were investigated:
czw:
HeH+ approaching perpendicularly (with the H leading) to the Hz bond on the approach, and He leaving the triangular H8+ on the same path in the reverse direction. He brought into the centre of the H i triangle along a line 30" off Cs(planar): the altitude of the triangle and at various points the H2 was made to recede from HeH+. Cs(non-planar): Similar to CzVexcept that the He atom was tilted out of the H,f plane. c3u: He leaving perpendicularly from the centroid of the H,+triangle.
It was found that the CzUpaths were the lowest in energy. On the CzWpaths, three co-ordinates are needed to define the system. Benson and McLaughlin defined the following: the H-He distance R ; the distance r between the hydrogens of what originally is the H2 molecule; and the distance h from the hydrogen which was originally bonded to He to the centre of the axis of the other two hydrogens. Ten values of R and h (nine between 1.4 and 5.0 a.u. and one at 50.0 a.u.) were considered and three values of r (the calculated Hz equilibrium distance of 1.3950 a.u., the caIculated H: equilibrium distance of 1.6405 ax., and an intermediate value of 1.5000 a.u.). Thus, 300 points on the potential energy surface were computed. The energies at three points on the surface (see Table 8) were then recalculated. after optimization of the Gaussian orbital exponents. Point A represents conditions near the beginning of the reaction. Point C is near the end of the reaction and point El is near the middle of the reaction. The total energy was found to change by no more than 1% and since the lowering is uniform at these three points, it was assumed that it would remain uniform over the entire surface. 254
255
I. Funke, H. Preuss, and G. Diercksen, Mol. Phys., 1967, 13, 517. R. D. Poshusta, J. A. Haugen, and D. F. Zetik, J. Chem. Phys., 1969,51, 3343.
60
Theoretical Chemistry
Table 8 Co-ordinates (1a.u.) of three points on the Czv surface of HeH: selected for detailed investigation by Benson and McLaughlinl O4 Point
A B
c
a
R(HeH +) 1.4650a 2.oooo 4.oooo
Equilibrium value for HeH+.
h 4.94717 1.94717 1 .42075b
Equilibrium value for H + .
1.375OC 1SO00 1.640S’ Equilibrium value for H2.
+
The reaction HeH+ + H w H e + H$, like that of He + H$-+HeH+ H, does not involve the making or breaking of electron pairs. As such, the HartreeFock results should parallel those of a CI calculation. To verify this, Benson and McLaughlin performed a CI using the iterative natural orbital method for the reactants at infinite separation, the products at infinite separation and at the points defined in Table 8. The five helium s functions with the largest exponents were contracted to a single s function using helium atom orbital coefficients. The computed correlation energies, which accounted for 80% of the total amount, were found to range from 0.0730 to 0.0767 a.u. indicating, as noted before, that the Hartree-Fock results are indeed nearly parallel to the correlated results over the entire surface. This reaction was found to be exothermic by 2.63 eV (254 kJ mol-1) in general agreement with the 2.3 eV found by Funke, Preuss, and Diercksen 254 using a restricted basis set. These latter workers predicted a path in which the H2 molecule lies initially on the HeH+ axis but swings perpendicular to this axis as the reaction proceeds, i.e. ending up with the geometrical configuration which Benson and McLaughlin use throughout the path. The results of Benson and McEaughlin104 indicate that no barrier to reaction exists, nor do they show a minimum, which is in contrast to the stable HeH; complex bound by 0.44 eV reported by Poshusta, Haugen, and Zetik255 using a minimal valence-bond CI technique. Hez-+He; + He.-Vauge and Whitten%6using a GTO basis set with polarization functions did single and double excitation CI calculations on the He: system and determined that the linear symmetric structure was more stable than the equilateral triangle. The minimum energy with respect to symmetric dissociation was found to be -7.83198 a.u. at an internuclear distance of 2.340 a.u. The dissociation energy of 0.07 eV which, although low compared with the experimental value reported by Patterson,267 (0.17+. 0.03 eV) verifies that the ion is loosely bound. F + H2+FH + H.-Bender et ~21.~5~ recently reported the results of two different sets of calculations on the potential energy surface for the reaction F + H2-’ FH H. This work is of interest from three points of view. First, it is truly a rigorous quantum mechanical calculation typifying the current state of the art for systems of this size: a GTO basis set of double-zeta quality is used (9s5p/4s)for a total of 32 GTO’s, and this is contracted according to the Dunning method51 to
+
256
257 258
C. Vauge and J. L. Whitten, Chem. Pfiys. Letters, 1972, 13, 541. P. L. Patterson, J. Chem. Phys., 1968, 48, 3625. C. F. Bender, P. K. Pearson, S. V. O’Neil, and H. F. Schaefer, J. Chem. Phys., 1972,56,4626; C. F. Bender, S. V. O’Neil, P. K. Pearson, and H. F. Schaefer, Science, 1972,176, 1412.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
61
[4s2p/2s]:polarization functions are added (d’s on the fluorine andp’s on hydrogens) yielding a basis set of 48 GTO’s - (9sSp2d/4slp)contracted to [4s2pld/2slp]:and the iterative natural orbital (INO) technique is used on 214 configurations in a CI calculation - typically four iterations were needed to obtain convergence. These calculations were performed at each of 150 linear geometries using both basis sets and 200 non-linear geometries using the [4s2p/2s] basis set for the FH2 system. Secondly, the final potential surface produced should be of high enough accuracy to allow for dynamical studies of the reaction. Thirdly, the values of the properties of the surface computed in four different ways can be compared.
Table 9 Summary of the results of Bender et al.258on the reaction F in diferent ways Without polarizationfunction SCF CI
Barrier height/ kJ mol-1 Exothermicity/ kJ mol-1 Saddle-point geometry/A F-H H-H Total energy/a.u. F H2 Total energy/a.u. FH + H
+
With polarizationfunction SCF CI
14.4
24
123
-2.4
85
55
1.06 0.81
1.37 0.81
+ Ha culculuted
1.18 0.836
6.9
144 1.54 0.767
Experimental 7.1s
133b L
- 100.5208
- 100.5424
- 100.5257
- 100.5620
-
- 100.5191
-
100.5726
- 100.5470
- 100.6169
-
A. F. Trotman-Dickenson,J . Chem. SOC.,1960, 1064.) J. Berkowitz, W. A. Chupka, P. M. Guton, J. M. Holloway, and R. Spohr, J. Chem. Phys., 1971,54, 5165. a Experimental activation energy (G. C. Fettis, J. H. Knox, and
The minimum energy path was found to be the one for the linear arrangement F-H-H. Table 9 shows the results of the four different calculations: the basis set lacking polarization functions with and without CI, and the same basis set with polarization functions with and without CI. If we compare the exothermicities we see that one needs the added flexibility of the d functions on F and the p functions on the H’s, plus a rather extensive CI in order to approach the experimental value. Mu~kermanz5~ suggests that the barrier height should be cu. 2.9 kJ mol-1 less than the activation energy. This would give a barrier height of ca. 4 kJ mol-1 and again the CI calculation with polarization functions gives the best value. The great improvement in the total energies of the system F + H2 with the F at infinite separation and the system FH H with the H at infinite separation further illustrates this point. Note in particular the difference in the effect of the polarization functions on the reactants and the products. The energy is lowered by only 0.0195 a.u. for F H2 but the decrease is 0.0443 a.u. for FH + H. This, of course, accounts for the greater exothermicity reported for the final calculation, a value very close to the reported experimental value.
+
+
x59
J. T. Muckerman, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 54, 1155.
62
Theoretical Chemistry
The saddle point occurs early in the inlet channel with and without CI but earlier in the former case, corresponding to a small displacement from the H-H equilibrium bond distance (ca. 0.03 a.u.) while the H-F distance is ca. 1.1 a.u. greater than that in HF. H F2-+HF F.-After their success with the 11-electron H2F system, Bender and co-workers1f5then attacked the 19-electron HF2 problem. A double-zeta GTO basis set is again used, (9s5p on F and 4s on each H contracted to a [4s2p/2s]set, a total of 52 basis functions in this case). The addition of the same polarization functions as were used in the H2F surface would increase the basis set to 75 GTO’s and would make the calculation of as many points needed to define the potential energy surface prohibitively time-consuming. Noting that the non-polarization function results of H2F were at least of qualitative accuracy, Bender et al. decided to do what they called a ‘first study’ on this system leaving the polarization function out. Using the I N 0 method, 555 carefully selected configurations were mixed in a CI calculation. Linear and non-linear approaches of the H atom were investigated and, as in the H2F case, the results predicted a linear approach. The saddle point in this case again occurs early in the inlet channel, the F-F bond having separated by only 0.06 a.u. while the F-H distance is more than twice that for the isolated diatomic. Table 10 summarizes the results of this work. The exothermicity predicted by the
+
+
Table 10 Summary of results of Bender et al.l15on the reaction H Barrier height/kJ mol-l Exothermicity/kJ mol-l Saddle-point geometry/A H-F F-F a
Experimental activation energy (ref. 260).
SCF
CI
51
4.2 369
554 1.56
1.49
+
Fa
Exper-intental lo? l a 429b
2.05 1.57
I
-
See footnote 12 in ref. 115.
CI calculation is found to be smaller than the experimental value by 60 kJ mol --I. A glance at Table 9 will show that without polarization functions, the exothermicity in the I: Hz was too small by the same order of magnitude (48 kJ mol-l). The activation energy reported in Table 10 is, of course, not exactly comparable to the barrier heights reported here. Bender et al. report the results of an unpublished work by Muckerman wherein he reports that the barrier height in this case should be 5 kJ mol-I less than the activation energy for this system. The experimental activation energy is reported to be lo+ 1 kJ mol -1,260 and this correction gives an experimental barrier height of ca. 5 kJmol-1 which is in excellent agreement with the barrier height computed with the CI wavefunction. Comparison of the poor results obtained without polarization functions in the H2F work with these results leads one to believe that the good agreement with experiment may just be fortuitous. On the other hand, one may also conclude that the basis set produces an entrance
+
260
R. G. Albright, A. F. Dodonov, G. K. Lavronskaya, I. I. Morosov, and V. L. Tal’rose, J. Chem. Phys., 1969,50, 3632.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfues
63
+
channel H F2 -+ H-F-F which is more closely parallel to the true entrance HF to the true exit channel than is the calculated exit channel H-F-F -+ H channel. This would account for good agreement with the experimental barrier height in spite of poor agreement with the experimental exothermicity. Surfaces for X + M2 and M + Xs.-The potential energy surfaces for the two exothermic reactions considered immediately above, F H2 and H F2, are repulsive in the nomenclature of Polanyi,l4915 i.e. a surface in which most of the exothermicity is released as the products separate. The other possible extreme of behaviour of a potential energy surface for an exothermic reaction is denoted by characterizing the surface as being of the ‘early downhill’ or ‘attractive’ type.l4~l5 In these systems, most of the exothermicity of reactions appears as vibrational excitation of the newly formed bond. The alkali metal (M), halogen (X) reactions of the type X M2 + MX M and X2 MX X M
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
both possess this type of potential surface, and both have been the subject of experimental studies by molecular beam techniques. Struve, Kitagawa, and Herschbach261have investigated the reactions of C1 atoms with Na2 and Kz, in which they observed electronic excitation of alkali atoms. Zare and co-workersz62 have performed crossed molecular beam experiments on the I K2 system, in which they detected a chemiluminescence spectrum which may be due to a bound IK2 species. Miller, Safron, and H e r s c h b a ~ h ,in~ ~crossed-beam ~ studies of the reaction M2 M1 + M2X + MlX
+
+
have established the importance of a long-lived collision complex XMlMZ in the interpretation of the dynamics of these simple reactions. The family of reactions, XZ -+ MX X, has been extensively studied by crossed molecular beam M techniques.264 Potential energy surfaces for both types of reactions have now been calculated by ab initio techniques; for the system Li + F2 -+ LiF + F by Balint-Kurti and Liz -+ LiF + Li by Pearson et aZ.267 KarplusZ65p266and for F Pearson et aZ.267 have carried out a single configuration SCF and a twoconfiguration SCF calculation of the potential surface for the FLi2 system. They point out that the single configuration SCF approximation itself, in general, provides a relatively good description of ionic species, such as are involved in this reaction. The added configuration, for most regions of the surface, insured the correct
+
+
+
W. S. Struve, T.Kitigawa, and D. R. Herschbach, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 54, 2759. R. N. Zare, unpublished work referred to in ref. 267. 26-W. S. Struve, MoI. Phys., 1973, 25, 777. 263 W. B. Miller, S. A. Safron, and D. R. Herschbach, Discuss. Faraday Soc., 1967, 44, 108. 264 J. H. Birely, R. R. Herm, I S.R. Wilson, and D. R. Herschbach, Discuss. Faraduy SOC.,1967, 44, 176; R. Grice and P. B. Empedocles, J. Chern. Phys., 1968,48, 5352. 265 G. G. Balint-Kurti and M. Karplus, Chern. Phys. Letters, 1971, 11, 203. G. G. Balint-Kurti, MoI. Phys., 1973, 25, 393. 267 P. K. Pearson, W. J. Hunt, C . F. Bender, and H. F. Schaefer, J . Chern. Phys., 1973,58,5358. 261 262
64
Theoretical Chemistry
asymptotic description of the system for infinite separation of all three nuclei. Although the added configuration does not properly describe this separated atom limit for the portions of the surface describing CzUgeometries of LiFLi, it does provide the most important single correction to the wavefunction in the region of the predicted equilibrium geometry for this species. A large s-p basis set (doublezeta quality) of GTO’s was employed with added polarizing d-type functions on F. In addition, a diffuse set of p-type functions was added to the F basis set. Duke and Baderas have pointed out that without this added diffuse function, Dunning’s (9~,5p)-+[4~,2p] set51 for F provides a much better description of the neutral F atom than it does of the F - ion, with the consequence that even the Hartree-Fock estimate of the electron affinity of fluorine is not obtainable with the use of the unaugmented set for the description of both F and F-. Use of the augmented set yields 97 % of the Hartree-Fock estimate of the electron affinity of fluorine.88 A minimum energy path was obtained for the collinear reaction. However, a point of particular interest in these calculations was a search of the potential surface to verify the postulated existence of a stable collision complex263or even a stable molecule262 for the system FLi2. Both the single- and double-configurations predict a potential well of ca. 17 kJ mol -l depth with respect to LiF + Li for the linear F-Li-Li species. A much deeper well with a depth of ca. 34 kcal mol -l was found for the LiFLi speciesof CZ2, symmetry. Struve,262aby employing the pseudopotential method of Child and Roach,23 has calculated a potential energy surface for the FLiz system. He obtains a collinear well of ca. 38 kJ mol -1 for F-Li-Li and an isosceles triangle well depth of ca. 84 kJ mol -l. While the reliability of the ab initio results are difficult to assess in this case, the authors267 conclude that certain salient features of their surface findings could be included in a LEPS-type formulation of the surface and employed in a dynamical study of the F + Liz and/or LiF Li reactions to obtain information concerning the importance of complex formation in such systems. In the theoretical determination of the potential surface for the LiFz system by Baht-Kurti and Karplus2659 266 a multistructure valence-bond approach was used. This method of calculation was augmented by the so-called orthogonalized Moffit method. This latter technique was applied to correct for the relatively large errors made in the ab initiu description of F - relative to F. Their calculation provided the first fully theoretical prediction that the potential surfaces for the M XZsystems are indeed of the ‘attractive’ or ‘early downhill’ type. Model studiesl4*I5had indicated that the observed high vibrational excitation of the newly formed M-X bond was a characteristic feature of such surfaces, a point which has now been theoretically substantiated. The dynamic consequences of this calculated surface are X2 reactive systems. The compared266with those of previous models for the M possibility of non-adiabatic contributions to the reactive scattering is also considered.266 CH2 + CH2-+C2H4.-The coplanar approach of two methylenes to form ethylene was investigated by Basch268 using the MCSCF method. The states of bent methylene that correlate with the ground state of ethylene are the triplet states. It is found that for two closed-shell singlet-state methylenes,the reaction path is purely repulsive.
+
+
+
a*8
H. Basch, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 1700.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
65
The Valence Bond Approach.-In two papers on the potential energy surfaces of BeHl and H4+,Poshusta and c 0 - w o r k e r s ~ ~ ~used ~ 2 ~a0 combination of SCF and valence bond configuration interaction (VBCI) methods. For the reaction Ha Be++BeH,+,2G9a large portion of the potential energy surface was evaluated with the SCF method and then the VBCI technique was applied along the reaction path thus defined. For the lowest state (2A1symmetry) a minimum is found on the Cavpath with H-Be-H angle of 20.5" and BeH distance of 4.17 a.u. The binding energy is reported as 0.11eV. In these calculations, ca. 40 % of the correlation energy was accounted for. For the reaction Ha + Ha+-+Hs+ H,270 VBCI calculations were performed on all the points considered. Five attitudes of approach of H2 and H i and three attitudes of retreat of H i and H were considered, while the geometries of H2, H i , and H,+were fixed at their respective calculated equilibrium values. The steepest approach potential is found to be one in which the H i axis bisects the H2 axis. The steepest retreat potential is one in which the H atom leaves the triangular H,+ ion on the same axis on which it entered. With this general reaction path defined, the calculations were repeated with the optimization of the H-H bond distance. A minimum was found at H-H and H-H + distances of 1.66 a.u. and 4.1 1 a.u., respectively, while the distance from the leading H atom of the H i ion to the bisector of the H2 molecule is 1.44 a.u. The binding energy is found to be 3.6 kJ mol-l. Close examination of the studies reviewed in this chapter reveals a very important fact. Although the general approaches used in all the problems discussed have their similaritiesand although general rules can be stated, the field of ab initio calculations of potential energy surfaces has not yet reached the point where the computations can be routinely carried out. Although it is true that if one picks a large enough basis set of either GTO's or STO's and performs a full CI at a large enough number of points on the hypersurface, one will be reasonably assured of obtaining meaningful potential energy surfaces, the problem of time expended posed by even the largest and fastest computers available today requires that each system be treated differently. Until the day either when newer and faster computational methods are devised which will attain the same degree of accuracy, or when computers are made with speeds many orders of magnitude greater than those in existence today, the quantum chemist who attempts to produce meaningful potential surfaces will have to study his problem very carefully. It is in this respect that one can call this area of theoretical chemistry an art.
+
+
269
270
R. D. Poshusta, D. W. Klint, and A. Liberles, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55,252. R. D. Poshusta and D. F. Zetik, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 118.
2 Intermolecular Forces BY J.
G. STAMPER
1 Introduction The theory of intermolecularforces poses the same problem as the theory of valence, but in a slightly different form. The fundamental difficulty in calculating bond energies is that they appear as small differences between large numbers (the total energies of the molecules and atoms concerned), so that a much greater percentage accuracy is needed in the calculations than is aimed at in the dissociation energy itself. In the case of intermolecular forces this problem is even more serious. Typical binding energies at the van der Waals minimum between non-polar molecules are of the order lo-* ax., so that an attempt to calculate such a quantity by direct comparison of the calculated energies of the two separated molecules and of the ‘supermolecule’ made up of the two together requires an accuracy of at least 1 part in lo7 even for quite small systems. Nevertheless, such calculations have been and are being made and some examples are referred to in Section 3. In principle, however, the intermolecular force problem has a compensating advantage. Because of the very small changes introduced by the interaction, at least until the repulsive part of the potential surface is reached, this is an ideal situation for the application of perturbation theory which has not, in general, been a particularly powerful tool in valence problems. Even so, except at large distance where the overlap of the wavefunctions of the two molecules is negligible, the application of perturbation theory raises some problems. In the main these were sorted out in the years around 1970, but work in this area continues and some of it is discussed in Section 2. Actual calculations that have been carried out are still confined almost entirely to atoms, so that the title ‘Intermolecular Forces’ is almost a misnomer, ‘Interatomic Forces’ being much closer to the state of the art. Some calculations are aimed primarily at understanding the short-range, repulsive region of interaction. These are discussed in Section 3, while Section 4 covers recent results on the long-rangeregion. A number of other topics are collected together in Section 5. These include systems containing more than two molecules, the hydrogen bond, the eRect of intermolecular forces on the properties of molecules, and a brief survey of recent work o n empirical potentials and on van der Waals molecules, which are likely in the future to provide more and more detailed information for the theoretician to interpret, 2 General Theory Almost all the work in this area recently has been concerned with the difficultiesof applying perturbation theory in the region in which overlap is non-negligible. The
66
Intermolecular Forces
67
origin of this difficulty can be thought of in several different ways, but it is perhaps most easily seen by considering the symmetry of the unperturbed Hamiltonian Ho. The natural choice for this Hamiltonian is that for the separated molecules, so that it will contain only that part of the total potential which is due to interactions of electrons with their ‘own’ nuclei and with the other electrons in their ‘own’ molecule. Such a Hamiltonian will not be invariant to the antisymmetrizing operator A which permutes all the electrons, including those belonging to different molecules. The total Hamiltonian H is of course invariant to this operator, so that we may write
AH-HA = 0 However, when we write
H = Ho+ V it follows that
AHo-HoA = VA-AV of which neither side is zero. Here we have an equality between an apparently zeroorder expression and an apparently first-order expression which shows that any simple perturbation theory in which the various terms are considered order by order is bound to fail. The various methods of surmounting this difficulty which have been developed in the past few yearsl-5 have been brought within a common framework by Chipman, Bowman, and Hirschfelder.6 They start by writing the exact wavefunction for the pair of interacting molecules which has a definite symmetry as vy = ~ A @ ( Y ) where v labels the particular irreducible representation to which yy must belong, and vA is the corresponding projection operator. The equation which @(v) must satisfy is
which only defines the component of O(v) in the space of functions of The authors express this by writing
Y
symmetry.
( H - E ) @ ( y ) = (1 - ’A)F(v) which must hold for any F(v) whatever. They show that the various kinds of perturbation theory correspond to different choices of F(v) and develop a formalism for choosing an optimum F(v), i.e. an optimum form of perturbation theory. In the succeeding paper they apply this formalism to the case of He * OH+and provide a detailed discussion of the relative success of the various theories, i.e. the various possible choices of F(v). None of them seems to be conspicuously preferable and the reader is referred to the paper for details. By choosing a variationally 1 2 8
4 6 6 7
J. 0. Hirschfelder and R. Silbey, J. Chem. Phys., 1966, 45, 2188. J. N. Murrell and G. Shaw, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,46, 1768. J. I. Musher and A. T. Amos, Phys. Rev., 1967,164, 31. A. van der Avoird, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1967, 1, 24, 41 1. J. 0. Hirschfelder, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1967, 1, 325, 363. D. M. Chipman, J. D. Bowman, and J. 0. Hirschfelder, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59,2830. D. M. Chipman and J. 0. Hirschfelder, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 2838.
68
Theoretical Chemistry
optimized form for F(v), Chipman and Hirschfelder obtain an energy to first order which is within 6 kJ mol-1 of the exact value at an internuclear distance of 1 a.u., which is quite remarkable for a perturbation theory. In addition to this very general theory, two other ways of dealing with the problem have appeared in the past year. Berrondos points out that the eigenvalues of the antisymmetrizing operator (A) are highly degenerate and that there are, therefore, an infinite number of orthonormal transformations that can be applied to a basis set of simple product functions to diagonalize the representation of A. He suggests ways in which a particular choice of transformation may be made before carrying out any standard kind of perturbation theory such as Rayleigh-Schrodinger in the transformed basis. It is not easy to see how practical an approach this is likely to be; certainly the transformations that the author chooses as examples are cornplicatedlooking ones which involve the continuum. Gouyet 9 has applied the formalism of second quantization and diagrammatic perturbation theory to the problem. In a basis of non-orthogonal orbitals, diagrammatic perturbation theory becomes more difficult; Gouyet follows previous authorslo~llin transforming to a new basis of ‘biorthogonal’ orbitals in which the Hamiltonian is no longer Hermitian. He is able to show that certain classes of diagrams corresponding to intramolecular terms cancel exactly, but it is not clear whether the formalism is likely to be computationally attractive. In a second paper l2 he extends his work to situations with degeneracy. A number of other formalisms of various kinds have appeared. Kirtman and his co-workers have extended their ‘distinguishable electron method’13 to the inter.~~ mediate distance region14 and also to a discussion of quadrupole t e r m ~ChanglS has applied this method to the case of nuclear permutation symmetry and used it for the repulsive regions of the H: and HHe2+ potential. A combined variational and perturbation method which is applicable at all internuclear distances has been described.17 The method is, however, limited to one-electron systems, and the authors themselves say that it will probably be difficult to extend to polyelectronic cases. Daudey et al.18 choose to develop perturbation expansions for the isolated molecules and for the two molecules together and compare terms in the two expansions to find which are intermolecular terms. The approach does not seem to be too promising since they find that for the model case of two helium atoms l9 they need to go as far as the fifth order of perturbation to get even a qualitatively correct form for the potential curve. This appears to be partly because of difficulties with intraatomic correlation effects, and partly because of the orthogonalization procedure that they employ. They also apply their formalism to the water dimer.20
*
M. Berrondo, Mol. Phys., 1973, 26, 329. J. F. Gouyet, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 4637. D. J. Newman, J. Phys. and Chem. Solids, 1969, 30, 1709; 1970, 31, 1143. l1 M. Moshinsky and T. H. Seligman, Amer. Phys., 1971, 66, 31 1. l 2 J. F. Gouyet, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 3690. l 3 B. Kirtman and R. L. Mowery, J. Chem. Phys., 1971,55, 1447. l 4 T. J. Venanzi and B. Kirtman, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 523. l5 T. J. Venanzi and B. Kirtman, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 2158. l 6 S . - Y . Chang, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 1790. l7 T.-S. Nee, R. G . Parr, and S.-Y. Chang, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 4911. J. P. Daudey, P. Claverie, and J. P. Malrieu, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1974, 8, 1. l9 J. P. Daudey, J. P. Malrieu, and 0. Rojas, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1974, 8, 17. 2 o J. P. Daudey, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1974, 8, 29. lo
Intermolecular Forces
69
The intermolecular potential, which is the objective of all the work mentioned so far, has several applications. One of these is in the understanding of the properties of gases, typically by the calculation of virial coefficients. Baer and his co-workers have been concerned with the possibility of going directly from the Hamiltonian of the system to the virial coefficients without calculating a potential function explicitly. Initially21 they confined themselves to the Coulomb forces, but they have now22 extended their formalism to include exchange effects. Their method consists essentially in working in an interaction representation, and making a Dyson expansion for the perturbation. They have also been able23 to obtain an expression for the virial coefficients in the zero-overlap approximation in terms of the polarizabilities of the isolated molecules at imaginary frequencies analogous to the familiar corresponding results for the dispersion f0rces.2~This work is very elegant, but whether it has any significant computational use remains to be seen. A few ‘loose ends’ have been tidied up. It has been generally believed that at the level of a restricted HartreeFock calculation, the interaction between pairs of closed-shell atoms must be asymptotically repulsive at large distances. This was shown to be true for a pair of helium atoms some years agoZ5 but has now been proved to be generally true.26 Steinera? has explained an apparent paradox in the treatment of the long-range interaction of two hydrogen atoms by means of the Hellman-Feynman theorem in which different orders of perturbation appear to be mixed. There continue to be calculations on model systems in order to look at the nature of the various terms which arise in the perturbation expansions. The work of Himwelder et al.? on H. -H+ is of this kind. Chdasiliski and Jeziorski have particularly concerned themselves with various second-order terms. They have obtained28 a multipole expansion for the exchangepolarization energy for H- H+, and they also give some approximations and limiting forms which give 99% of the exact value at the van der Waals minimum. In a further paper,29 they have investigated the second-order induction energy for the He OHsystem. This energy is, of course, asymptotically zero since the potential due to a neutral atom is zero at long distances. At short range, however, there is an exponentially decreasing potential due to the detailed structure of the atom, and it is the effect of this that the authors have considered. They have obtained an ‘exact’ ht-order wavefunction and secondorder energy using a Green’s function method. They find that most of the change in the wavefunction of one atom occurs near the nucleus of the other. At distances of the order of the chemical minimum, this part of the second-order Coulombic energy is much more important than the dispersion part, as is shown in Table 1. The authors also note that the combination of the Heitler-London energy and EEL at the chemical minimum is very close to the exact value, showing that E!t\ contains most
-
-
S. Baer and A. Ben-Shaul, J. Chem. Phys., 1972,56, 3773. Baer and E. Bergmann, J. Chem. Phys., 1974,60,440. 23 S . Baer and A. Ben-Shad, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59,2229. 24 A. Dalgarno, Adv. Chern. Phys., 1967, 12, 143. 25 N. R. Kestner, J. Chem. Phys., 1968, 48, 252. aa A. M. Lesk, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 44. 27 E. Steiner, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 2427. 28 G. Cha€asidskiand B. Jeziorski, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1973, 7 , 63, 745. z9 G. Chalasihki and B. Jeziorski, Mol. Phys., 1974,27, 649. 21
a2 S.
70
Theoretical Chemistry
Table 1 Relative importance of induction and dispersion in Ha * * H29 Internuclear distance/a.u. EGblE&,
8 0.087
4
6 0.06
0.6
ca.
2 3.5
of the effects due to ‘ionic’ terms, and that exchange polarization and higher-order terms are relatively unimportant. 3 Short- and Intermediate-range Forces At long range, a perturbation method is the obvious choice for the calculation of intermolecular interactions. At short ranges the standard methods of valence calculation are an equally obvious choice, and quite a lot of work of this kind is being reported. This type of calculation is also being carried out at intermediate distances at which perturbation theories of the type mentioned in Section 2 are also appropriate. Straight self-consistent field calculations have been carried out on the interaction of water with neon and arg0n.~0Here it is possible to obtain some of the attractive contribution to the intermolecular force since there will be an inductive secondorder interaction caused by the large dipole of the water molecule. Such interactions appear at the SCF level and the authors find a minimum in the potential at an 0.- *Ne distance of 3.63 A, with a binding energy of 0.71 kJ mol-1. There is a shallower minimum in the case of argon. Calculations at a similar level of sophistication have been carried out on the Hz. -He system,sl primarily, however, from the viewpoint of the hydrogen atom recombination reaction. The authors comment on the fact that the potential they obtain can be fitted to within ca. 10%as the sum of pairwise interactions. An SCF calculation has also been carried out32 on the He. * -Be2+system. The repulsive potential agrees quite well with scattering data down to an internuclear distance of ca. 0.4& after which the results disagree. * Ne and Be Ar, while Kaufman 33 has reported similar calculations on Be Poshusta and Zetik in a valence-bond cal~ulation3~ find a small binding (3.6 kJ mol-l) between HZand HZ. The majority of calculations of this kind, however, go beyond the SCF limit, either by ordinary configuration interaction, or by a fully fledged multiconfiguration SCF calculation. Both of these methods are capable of including dispersion effects and are therefore to be expected to be useful at larger distances than the straight SCF calculation. Two provisos must be made at this point, both of which have been commented on by authors cited below. One is that the kind of excited configuration needed to include dispersion forces is rather different from that appropriate for intramolecular correlation, so that it is necessary, in calculations using relatively modest basis sets, to include additional functions of appropriate symmetry with rather small and carefully chosen exponents. The second is that, particularly in the region where interaction is small, a spurious binding effect may arise because the
-
--
-
3O 3l 32
39 34
-
M. Losonczy, J. W. Moskowitz, and F. H. Stillinger, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 32.64. C. W. Wilson, jun., R. Kapral, and G. Bums, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 24, 488. S. W. Hamson, L. J. Massa, and P. Solomon, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 263. J. J. Kaufman, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58,4880. R. D. Poshusta and D. F. Zetik, J. Chern. Phys., 1973, 58, 118.
Intermolecular Forces
71
basis functionscentred in one atom or molecule can provide additional flexibility for the wavefunction of the other atom or molecule, resulting in a lowering of the intramolecular or intra-atomic energy. Liu and McLean,35 taking considerable care to avoid the overcomplete basis set problem, have carried out a large configuration interaction calculation on He He. Their stated aim was an accuracy of 0.1 K and they calculate the depth of the van der Waals minimum as 9.23 K at an internuclear distance of 3.02 A. Tsapline and Kutzelnigg36 have made somewhat less accurate calculations on the H2- -He system around its van der Waals minimum. They attempt to avoid the problems outlined above by transforming their SCF orbitals to a localized basis and then calculating intermolecular pair correlation energies. They ignore the variation of intramolecular correlation with distance and, what is probably more important, the coupling between inter- and intra-molecular correlation. For the linear configuration there is a minimum 21 K in depth, and for the CZ,configuration there is a saddle point with a binding energy of 14 K. The result averaged over all orientations is slightly too low, while the anisotropy is slightly larger than the asymptoticvalue, which is supported by the experimentalevidence. A somewhat similar calculation 37 has been carried out on Hz- *HZ in four configurations. In this case a rather smaller basis set which included polarization orbitals with exponents adjusted to obtain the deepest van der Waals minimum was used. The authors believe that they have not eliminated all the spurious binding energy. All the data on the H2 - - - H2 potential at short range obtained by ab initio calculations have been reviewed by McMahon et R Z . , ~ who ~ discuss them from the point of view of scattering experiments. SCF-CI calculations have also been carried out for Ne - - * -Ne39in much the same way as in ref. 37, attempting to extend the calculations to quite large distances and including a d-orbital in the basis. The results at long distances cannot quite match the semi-empiricalmultipole ones. SCF-CI calculations40similar to those of ref. 36 have also been carried out on the systems He. * -HzO and He. * H Fto see how this type of calculation performs in a polar situation. The more difficult multi-configuration SCF method, which has already been applied to He. .He,41has now been applied to Ne. * *Ne42and to Ar. .H.43In each case only an approximation to the exact solution within the chosen basis set has been obtained in order to avoid the problem of spurious energies. The authors have been particularly interested to see how their results behave at the larger distances, They define a quantity AEvan der Waals as the difference between their total energy and the SCF energy, and find that it can be well represented by an expression of the c1o/R1O. In the case of Ne, their AEvan der wsals values are form C6/R6 + Cs/R8 within a few K of the calculations of Starkschall and Gordon.44 The c6 and c8
-
-
+
35 36 37 38 39 40
41 42 43 44
B. Liu and A. D. McLean, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59,4557. B. Tsapline and W. Kutzelnigg, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 23, 173. E. Kochanski, B. ROOS,P. Siegbahn, and M. H. Wood, Theor. Chim. A d a , 1973, 32, 296. A. K. McMahan, H. Beck, and J. A. Krumhansl, Phys. Reu. (A), 1974,9, 1852. E. Kochanski, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 25, 381. H. Lischka, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 21, 448. P. Bertoncini and A. C. Wahl, Phys. Rev. Letters, 1970, 25, 991. W. J. Stevens, A. C. Wahl, M. A. Gardner, and A. M. Karo, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60,2195. A. F. Wagner, G. Das, and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1974,60, 1885. G. Starkschall and R. G. Gordon, J. Chem. Phys., 1971,54,663; 1972,56,2801.
72
Theoretical Chemistry
values for Ar * - * H agree with earlier ~ a l u e s . 245~The ~ He - . - - He calculation has also been refined46 to allow for the variation in intra-atomic correlation energy with distance. This has the effect of reducing the well depth by ca. 1.2 K. The well depths and positions are given in Table 2. Table 2 Potential minima calculated by multiconfguration SCF
Ne.
Well depth/K
Rmin/a.u.
10.79 39.20 48.22
5.60 5.824 6.75
He. *He46 sNe42
&. ..H43
The most extensive calculation reported recently on a simple system is that of Kolos and W o l n i e w i c ~on ~ ~the intermediate and long-range parts of the hydrogenhydrogen potential for the lowest singlet and triplet states. Using a 60 term variational function, they calculate the energies of the two states for internuclear distances between 6 and 12 a.u. By comparing their curves for the two states they can separate the exchange and polarization contributions to the interaction energy and compare their magnitudes and how well they are given by asymptotic approximations. Tables 3 and 4 present some of their results. It can be seen that the exchange energy Table 3 Analysis of the interaction energy (cm-1) for two H atoms ( X l C ; R1a.u. 6 8 10 12
Exchange energy - 112.6 -3.87 -0.118 -0.0035
Polarization energy -71.5 -8.30 - 1.800 -0.556
Asymptotica exchange -97.63 -3.671 -0.117 - 0.0034
Variationalb polarization - 71.47 -8.27 - 1.80 -
Total energy 183.088 12.168 1.918 0.559
Calculated from the expression490.821 x R5/2exp (-2R). Calculated in the same way as the total energy but leaving out all exchange terms in the wavefunction.
Table 4 Analysis of the interaction energy (cm-1) of two H atoms (b3Cfstate)47 Asymptotic exchangea Variational polarization 26.2 -4.60 -- 1.68
+
R1a.u. 6 8 10 a
See notes to Table 4.
b
First-order exchangeb f Variationul polarization 27.6 -4.84 - 1.70
First-order exchange Asymptotic second-order polarization 33.2
+
-5.6
- 1.74
Total calciilated energy 41.26 -4.42 - 1.68
Heitler-London wavefunction.
can be approximated well by the asymptotic formula in the singlet case and by a simple Heitler-London first-order calculation in the triplet state, but that the asymptotic approximation to the polarization interaction is unsatisfactory in the 45 46 47
W. D. Davison, J. Phys. (B)., 1969,2, 1110. P. J. Bertoncini and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 1259. W.Kolos and L. Wolniewicz, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 24, 457.
Intermolecular Forces
73
region of the van der Waals minimum for the triplet state (R = 7.85 a.u.). Taking only the leading term in the R-l expansion gives even poorer agreement. In significantly larger systems, the SCF level is all that is at present attainable. Clementi and his co-workers have been carrying out a series of SCF studies48of the interaction between singly-charged ions and a water molecule. Some of their results are presented in Table 5. Where comparison is available it can be seen that the agree-
Table 5 SCF data on the interaction of an ion with a water molecule48 Ion Li+ Na+
a
AHcalc.a/kJmol-l 140.6
K+
97.1 65.7
Fc1-
A Ug calca/kcal mol-1 98.5 49.6
For the process M=t,H,O = M=t
+
H,O.
AHexpt. 01b / k J mol-1 142.3 100.4
b
Re(M-0)la.u. 3.58
4.25
74.9
5.08
L F -H -0 4.5" 14.6"
4.75
6.26
Ref. 50.
ment with experiment is remarkably good. The investigation of the potential surfaces is very much more extensive in this work than is represented by the data in the table. Calculations for halide ions surrounded by a whole co-ordination sphere of water molecules have also been carried out51but only at the CNDO level. On this basis, the optimum co-ordination number is found to be 8. The system H2CO - Li+ has also been the subject of an SCF cal~ulation.~~ The binding energy is found to be 181 kJ mol-1 and the equilibrium 0 - * .Li distance 1.77 A. Both molecule and ion are extensively polarized. Calculations which do not involve the SCF approach are also being made. Conway and Murrell53have calculated the exchange energy for Nee *Nearound the van der Waals minimum by 'first-order' perturbation theory. They find that a very accurate SCF function for the atom is needed for a satisfactory result. 'Double-zeta' wavefunctions, for example, are not sufficient. They compare their results with the analytic fits to other kinds of calculation and find that they agree well with an SCF cal~ulation5~ but poorly with a Thomas-Fermi-Dirac calculation.55 This type of approach does not appear to be adequate near the potential minimum. Combining their calculation with the dispersion results of Starkschalland Gordon,44 Conway and Murrell obtain a potential curve which is in agreement with the experimental one to within the somewhat large experimental error. KochanskiSO has made similar calculations for the H2 - . H2 system, while Brumer and Karplus57 have applied the same kind of formalism to the interaction of alkali and halide ions, obtaining a
-
-
--
H. Kistenmacher, H. Popkie, and E. Clementi, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58,1689,5627;59,5842. C. Herring and M. Flicker, Phys. Rev., 1964,134A, 362. 60 I. Diidit and P. Kebarle, J. Phys. Chem., 1970,74, 1466. 61 B. Kh. Bunyatan, D. A. Zhogolev, and F. Ritschl, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974,24, 520. 6% P. Russegger and P. Schuster, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973,19, 254. 6% A. Conway and J. N. Murrell, Mol. Phys., 1974,27, 873. 54 T. L. Gilbert and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,47, 3425. 66 A. A. Abrahamson, Phys. Rev., 1969,178,76. 66 E . Kochanski, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58,5823. 67 P . Brumer and M. Karplus, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58, 3903.
48
49
74
Theoretical Chemistry
formal derivation of the Rittner58 potential. At a much more semi-empirical level, Schug and Dyson5Q have used this formalism to investigate the interaction of benzene with the halogens. Their approximations give significantly too small a binding energy, but they do suggest that there are many configurations of comparable stability for the complex. Only two kinds of geometry, in fact, give no binding at all. An alternative to the perturbation theory approach is the approximate method of Gordon and JSim.60 In this method the electron density is first calculated as the s u m of the densities of the separate atoms and the energy is then obtained as the s u m of a Coulomb term calculated exactly, and kinetic energy, exchange, and correlation terms calculated from the free electron gas model. Though it worked well for larger systems, this calculation was not very satisfactoryfor He. * .He. Rae61 has pointed out that, as originally employed, the method of Gordon and Kim included an additional spurious electron self-energy. While this is unimportant for heavier atoms, it becomes very significant in a four-electron system like He. - *He. He shows how this error may be corrected and also adds dispersion terms to the corrected potential, obtaining potential curves for all the homonuclear inert gas pairs from He* * .He to Kr- .Kr. A further improvement has been suggested by Lloyd and Pugh,62 who apply the electron-gas expressions to a density due to the valence electrons only. This leads to an improvement over the results obtained by Rae for both A r e *Ar and Kr - - - *Kr. In the former case there is almost exact agreement with experiment, but the latter one is less satisfactory, though possibly within the experimental error. The method of Gordon and Kim has also been applied to the system Ar - w H C ~ . ~ Here it gives moderate agreement with the experimental data including the anisotropic part, especially at the shorter distances, but the potential well is too shallow, probably because of the neglect of dispersion terms. Schneidere4has also used this method for the interaction of Xe with itself and the other rare gases. Except in the case of Xe. .He where, for the reasons already mentioned, good agreement is not to be expected, he obtains values for the well depth, the position of the potential minimum, and the point at which the potential curve recrosses the zero-energy line which are within 10%of the experimental values, where these are known. +
-
-
-
-
4 Long-range Forces The theoretical understanding of the interaction between molecules at distances where the overlap is negligible has been well established for some years. The application of perturbation theory is relatively straightforward, and the recent work in this area has consisted in the main of the application of well-known techniques. In the case of neutral molecules, the first non-zero terms appear in the second order of perturbation, so that some method of obtaining the first-order wavefunction, or of approximating the infinite sum in the traditional form of the second-order energy expression, is needed. 58 59
Bo 61
62 6s
64
E. S . Rittner, J . Chem. Phys., 1951, 19, 1030. J. C. Schug and M. C. Dyson, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58,297. R. G. Gordon and Y.S. Kim, J. Chem. Phys., 1972,56,3122. A. I. M. Rae, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 18, 574. J. Lloyd and D. Pugh, Chem. Phys. Lerters, 1974,26, 281. S. Green, J. Clzem. Phys., 1974, 60,2654. B. Schneider, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58,4447.
75
lntermolecular Forces
The oldest approximation, in which the energy denominators are approximated by a single average excitation energy, allowing the summation to be evaluated in closed form, is still of use. Alvarez-Riggatti and Mason,65 for example, have used this approximation to obtain some relations between the coefficients in the asymptotic expressions. They give two expressionsfor the ratio cS/c6for a pair of unlike atoms in terms of properties of the isolated atoms and the corresponding pairs of like atoms. One of them had been obtained previously,s6 but the other, derived variationally, is new, and does not involve the average excitation energies explicitly. The authors state that they can estimate values of CSto 10-15 % accuracy. An alternative, and more recent, idea is the pseudo-spectral expansion, 67 in which Ho is diagonalized in some large basis of convenient functions and the summation in the second-order energy is evaluated exactly over the resulting eigenfunctions. This method has been used most recently by Bukta and Meath, who use it to obtain thirdand fourth-order terms intheH. * * -Hinteraction,e*andalso to obtain the asymptotic form of the interaction between a hydrogen atom in its ground state and one in its first excited ~tate.6~ They point out that in this case there is a resonant interaction which gives rise to a term in R-9 which has no other contribution. They also show that the whole expansion is of dubious value in this case since it appears to be strongly divergent. The same pseudo-spectral expansion has also been applied to the case of two lithium at0ms.70 In this, owing to the more complicated nature of Ho, difficulties arise from the finite size of the basis set. The authors use an extrapolation procedure to surmount this difficulty. Because the summation in the second-order energy is dominated by the first term, whose magnitude can be obtained experimentally from the excitation energy and oscillator strength of the corresponding electronic transition, the authors plot the calculated value of C6 against the calculated first term for various sizes of basis set, and choose for c6 that value which corresponds to the experimental value of the first term. In this way they obtain Cs(Li- - - .Li) =
-
- 1458
8 a.u.
0.711 and Ce(Li - - *He) They also obtain values for Cs(Li- * .H) [ -(67.4 [-(22.7 0.2)] which are not, however, corrected by an extrapolation procedure since in this case the second-order expansion is not dominated by a single term. Both these problems have been attacked recently by other authors, the groundstate-excited-state hydrogen case by Deal and Young,71 the lithium-lithium case by Caves,72who gives values for Ct3 and CSfor two ground-state atoms, and also c6 values for the interaction of a ground-state atom with atoms in the 3s, 45,5s, and 6s states. Another approach to the evaluation of higher-order energies is to obtain the perturbed wavefunction, or some approximation to it, explicitly. This method has
+
65 O7 68
69 70
71 7a
+
M. Alvarez-Rizzatti and E. A. Mason, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 518. H. L. Kramer and D. R. Herschbach, J. Chem. Phys., 1970, 53, 2792. R. E. Johnson, S. T. Epstein, and W. J. Meath, J. Chem. Phys., 1967, 47, 1271. J. F. Bukta and W. J. Meath, Mol. Phys., 1974,27, 1235. J. F. Bukta and W. J. Meath, Mol. Phys., 1973,25, 1203. J. E. Kouba and W. J. Meath, MoI. Phys., 1973,26, 1397. W. J. Deal and R. H. Young, Infernat. J. Quantum Chem., 1973, 7, 877. T. Caves, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59,6177.
76
rneoretical Chemistry
been used in several recent calculations, usually by finding the wavefunction variationally. Thus Arrighini et aZ.73have calculated the third-order dispersion energy for the interaction of a pair of hydrogen atoms, obtaining EF&, = 3.475x 103R-ll + 2.914x 105R-13
+
2.305 x 107R-15 (a.u.)
Their leading term agrees well with the even more accurate value obtained in the pseudo-spectral calculation cited above 68
c:)
=
3474.898 a.u.
-
Stewart and Webster74have solved the first-orderequation for the H * H case by a finite difference method. A much simpler series of calculations of this kind has been the investigation of the use of very simple trial functions as approximations to the first-order wavefunction by Teixeira-Dias and Varandas. Using a single Slater-type p-orbital or d-orbital they have calculated dipole and quadrupole polarizabilities at imaginary frequencies for hydrogen75 and heli~rn,~e and using a singlef-orbital they have obtained the octupole terms also for hydrogen.77 A few long-range calculations have also been carried out for larger atoms. These have, as usual, concentrated on obtaining the imaginary frequency polarizabilities and hence the various expansion coefficients,Doran 78 has extended his earlier work 79 on neon to argon, krypton, and xenon, using Brueckner-Goldstone perturbation theory. Table 6 lists the values for the leading coefficients of the dipole (D), quadru-
Table 6 Leading multipole dispersion coeflcients (in a.u.) for pairs of like inert-gas atoms 79 Gas Ne
C(DD) 6.882
Ar
66.89 135.11 281.15
Kr Xe
CWQ) 73.87 1176.4
2580.9 7033.5
C(QQ ) 379.68 10180 24275 83101
C(D0) 585.36 19116.9 41 191 157146
pole (Q), and octupole (0)interactions that he derives. The imaginary frequency polarizabilities are also accessible experimentally, in principle, via the oscillatorstrength distribution. Saxon 80 has reviewed the available evidence for neon and derived new values for the polarizabilities. Her resulting value for the CScoefficient is 6.352 a.u., which seems to be significantlydifferent from the value quoted in Table 6. Kestner 81 has extended his calculations using double-perturbation theory and the interchange theorem to the imaginary frequency polarizabilities of Ne, and gives He - *Neand Ne . .Ne asymptotic coefficients.These values differ from those just
-
73 74
75 76 77 i8
79 80
81
G . P. Arrighini, F. Biondi, and C. Guidotti, MoZ. Phys., 1973, 26, 1137. R. F. Stewart and B. C. Webster, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 19, 462. J. J. C. Teixeira-Dias and A. J. C. Varandas, Mot. Phys., 1973, 25, 1 1 85. J. J. C. Teixeira-Dias and A. J. C. Varandas, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 26, 197. A. 3. C. Varandas and 3. 3. C. Teixeira-Dias, Mol. Phys., 1973, 26, 241. M. B. Doran, J. Phys. ( B ) , 1974, 7 , 558. M. B. Doran, J . Phys. (B), 1972, 5, L151. R. P. Saxon, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 1539. J. T. Broussard and N. R. Kestner, J. C b m . Phys., 1973, 58, 3593.
77
Intermolecular Forces
quoted by up to 20%, showing that higher orders of, particularly, the correlation perturbation need to be considered. The problem of the effect of an inaccurate zeroth-order wavefunction on dispersion calculations has been looked at again by Magnasco82 using double perturbation theory for the He * He case. Using hydrogenic, screened hydrogenic, and approximate Hartree wavefunctions he obtained for cf3the values 0.702,1.057,and 1.304a.u., compared with the exact value 1.47. Riera and Meaths3 have done almost the only long-range calculations of intermolecular forces between molecules as opposed to atoms that have appeared recently. They have been interested in what they call the ‘non-diagonal’ terms in the secondorder energy which have both odd and even terms in the R-1 expansion. They give expressions for such terms and point out that they vanish on averaging over the various possible angular positions of the two molecules. Abdulnurg4 has given upper and lower bounds to the various Cn coefficients in terms of various sum rules that are available either experimentally,semi-empirically, or theoretically. Similar rules have previously been given, but the present ones give narrower bounds than are obtained by the application of correspondingmethods to the imaginary frequency polarizabilities. McRury and Linder85 have given a general formulation of the long-range interaction between a number of molecules, obtaining a diagrammatic expansion of the free energy of the system and also reformulating their results to emphasize collective behaviour. Mackrodt 86 has used diagrammaticmethods to investigate the effect on multipole forces of an external electric field.
- -
5 Miscellaneous Topics
Systems of more than Two Molecules.-Although most calculations in the field of intermolecular forces are still concerned with pairwise interactions, a number of calculations are being made on larger systems. The interest is usually in the departures from additivity which may be found, as in the SCF calculations on He3.87988 These calculations are restricted to the short-range region and show that for a linear configuration the non-additive part of the energy is positive and very nearly a function of the sum of the two short intermolecular distances, while for isosceles triangle configurations it is negative except at very short distances, when it increases rapidly. This system, and also He4, has been looked at by Magnasco and his co-workers though with the use of a less flexiblewavefunction.They obtain quite good agreement with the results just mentioned for He3, which suggests that their He4 results should also be at least qualitatively reliable. Perhaps their most interesting observation is that if they expand their energy terms in powers of the overlap integral (S),then 893
82
83 84 85 86
87 88 89 90
V. Magnasco, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 26, 192. A. Reira and W. J. Meath, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1973, 7 , 959. S. F. Abdulnur, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58,4835. T. B. McRury and B. Linder, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58, 5388,5398. W. C. Mackrodt, Mol. Phys., 1971, 27, 933. 0. A. Novaro and V. BeltrBn-Lbpez, J. Chem. Phys., 1972,56, 815. L. GonzBlez-Tovany, V. BeltrBn-LSpez, and 0. Novaro, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 1694. V. Magnasco and G. F. Musso, J. Chem. Phys., 1974,60, 3744. G. F. MUSSO, V. Magnasco, and M. P. Giardina, J . Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 3749.
Theoretical Chemistry
78
truncating the expansion after terms of order S2 gives the wrong sign for the nonadditive part of the energy even when S is as small as 0.03. In the region of negligible overlap, the three-body interactions can be calculated, just like the two-body ones, from imaginary frequency polarizabilities. This has been done, for example, by Doran 78 for interaction of triplets of noble-gas atoms. He gives the coefficients for dipole-dipole-dipole, dipoledipole-quadrupole, dipole-quadrupole-quadrupole, quadrupole-quadrupoleequadrupole, and dipole-dipoleoctupole terms. Most of the other calculations which involve more than two molecules raise the question of what is meant by a molecule. A number of SCF calculations have been carried out on assemblies of small atoms and ions which do not form familiar chemical species but which nonetheless appear to have larger dissociation energies than would normally be thought of as intermolecular. These include HeH3+,91 XeH+,92HenH, and HenH+ where n = l-4kg3 It is concluded that linear symmetric He2H+ is stable while HesH+ and He4H+ are not. Another calculation that is of interest, but difficult to classify, is that of Wilson et al.94 on the Hz- - .He system. They are primarily interested in obtaining a potential surface on which to study the role of He as a third body in hydrogen atom recombination reactions, so that they include in their study configurations in which the Ha - H distance is as large as 5 a.u., where the H-H interaction is quite small. They find that even in a calculation which does not include intermolecular correlation there are quite long-range contributions to non-additivity. Properties.-In the past few years there has begun to be an emphasis on calculating other properties of weakly interacting systems beside the energy. For example, systems of interacting identical non-polar molecules can develop a dipole moment which is responsible for the appearance of pressure-induced i.r. spectra. In the zerooverlap region the dipole can be expanded in powers of R-l just like the energy, and the leading term turns out to be of order R-7. The coefficient of this term, which is usually denoted by D7,has been calculated95by Whisnant and Byers Brown for the systems He. * - H and He. .He exactly, and they also suggest an approximate method which could be used for larger systems. They note that the dispersion contribution to the dipole at the collision diameter is of opposite sign to the exchange contribution, which the same group has also calculatedg6for a variety of inert-gas pairs. In this case they find that it is adequate to consider only the leading term in the expansion in terms of the square of the overlap. They also find, as has previously been noted for energy calculations (see e.g. ref. 53), that it is necessary to use accurate atomic wavefunctions; double-zeta functions, for example, are not adequate. Extrapolation from molecular SCF calculationsat shorter distances, as was done, for example, by Matcha and Nesbet, 97 is also unsatisfactory. Earlier, Byers Brown and Whisnant98 considered the calculation of D7 for pairs of H atoms, and they have
-
91 92
93 94 95 96 97 98
R. D. Poshusta and V. P. Agrawal, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 2477. C. Kubach and V. Sidis, J. Phys. ( B ) , 1973, 6, L289. M. B. Milleur, R. L. Matcha, and E. F. Hayes, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60,674. C. W. Wilson, jun., R. Kapral, and G. Burns, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 24, 488.
D. M. Whisnant and W. Byers Brown, Mol. Phys., 1973,26, 1105. A. J. Lacey and W. Byers Brown, Mol. Phys., 1974, 27, 1013. R. L. Matcha and R. K. Nesbet, Phys. Rev., 1967,160,72. W. Byers Brown and D. M. Whisnant, Mol. Phys., 1973,25, 1385.
Intermolecular Forces
79
given an approximate formula that is accurate to 1%. D7 can also be evaluated in terms of sum rules, and the necessary expressionshave been given by Abdulnur 99 for dissimilar S-state atoms. Unfortunately, many of the sum rules needed are not easily available, and the c8 coefficients from the energy expressions are also needed. Abdulnur has given some results for H, He, and Ne, however. Dipole moments for various configurations of Ha** * Hand H2* *H2have been calculated by ab initio methods.lO0 Martin101 has calculated the long-range dipole moment for systems of three identical atoms. For the H . .He O Hsystem he has used a pseudo-spectral perturbation method, while for He...He...He he has used the closure approximation. These quantities could be experimentally accessible via a pressure-induced i.r. absorption whose intensity varied as the cube of the pressure. Polarizabilities of pairs of interacting atoms have also continued to be studied. In this case the leading term at large distances is A&-6 and there are parallel and perpendicular componentsto be calculated. Buckingham and his co-workerslo2 have studied H - - .H and obtained both components of A6 and As. They find them to be larger than previous estimates. They have also studied He - -He, using both coupled Hartree-Fock and finite perturbation theories (which agreed).l03 They fmd that the limiting calculation is inaccurate even at large distances and they suspect that the polarizability changes sign twice as R increases. Another property which has been considered is the hyperfine shift in hydrogen. Fortune and Certain lo4have cakulated the effect on this quantity of the interaction with a helium atom at large distances and give an estimate of the R-*coefficientof the change. Hydrogen-bonded Systems.-The hydrogen bond may be looked upon as the weakest chemical bond, or as the strongest intermolecular interaction, but however it be classified, it continues to attract the theoretician; the number of SCF calculations continues to increase rapidly. The earlier calculations on water polymers have been summarized and discussed critically in terms of the size of basis set used.105 All the calculations give a similar description of the general features of the system. The nature of the hydrogen bond in water dimers has also been reinvestigated using bond orbitals by Bowers and Pitzer106 and using the formulation discussed earlier18 by Daudey.2O Both groups come to the familiar conclusion that there are three contributions to the interaction of approximately equal magnitude, two bonding (the electrostatic and charge transfer contributions) and one antibonding (the exchange contribution), the net energy of the hydrogen bond being equal in magnitude to all of them. The water dimer has also been studied experimentally in the molecular beam,107 the results agreeing well with the earlier calculations discussed in ref. 105. A new and very extensivecalculationhas been made for the water dimer by Clementi S. F. Abdulnur, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 23, 355. R. W.Patch, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 6468. 101 P. H.Martin, Mol. Phys., 1974, 27, 129. loa A. D. Buckingham, P. H. Martin, and R. S. Watts, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 21, 186. loS A. D. Buckingham and R. S. Watts, Mol. Phys., 1973, 26, 7 . 104 P. J. Fortune and P. R. Certain, J. Phys. ( B ) , 1973, 6, L39. 105 J. E. Del Bene and J. A. Pople, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 3605. 106 M. J. T. Bowers and R. M. Pitzer, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 163. l o 7 T. R. Dyke and J. S, Muenter, J. Chern. P h p , 1974,60,2929,
loo
80
17teoretical Chemistry
and his co-workers, logwho go on to use their potential-energy surface in a MonteCarlo calculation for liquid water. They find good agreement with ‘experiment’, except that no second neighbour peak appears in their oxygen-oxygen radial distribution function. They attribute this to their use of a potential calculated for the dimer only. Water polymers have also been considered by Lentz and Scheraga.lo9 They were particularly interested to see if there were any additional non-additive effects in cyclic polymers in comparison with linear ones. Considering systems up to the tetramer, they found no evidence for such effects. They also used their results to calculate the lattice energy of Ice I. SCF calculations have also been made on the dimers of HFllO and formaldehyde.11l In the latter case two potential minima were found of comparable energy, one hydrogen-bonded and the other held together by the electrostatic interactions of the two carbonyl dipoles. The barrier between the two is, however, very low, and the two forms could almost certainly not be isolated. The situation in HCN is similar.l12 Other systems that have been studied in a similar way include : HF * * HCN, 113 in which the equilibrium structure is with the HF hydrogen-bonded to the HCN CHz0,114with R = H, nitrogen and there are no other potential minima; ROH. CH3, NH2, OH, or F, where the strength of the H bond parallels the o-withdrawing power of the substituent; ROH. -NH3,l15where the situation is similar; the intramolecular hydrogen bond in HOCH~CHZCH~OH, 116for which a strength of only 3.9 kJ mol-1 was found ; and CH3CONHCH3 -H20,117 a model system for proteins. The calculations on H2O- - aC1-48 have already been mentioned. Calculationshave been made on the interaction of a water molecule with formaldehyde in its lowest triplet and first excited singlet states.118-120The two calculations agree in locating the hydrogen bond between the water oxygen and the formaldehyde carbon because of the shift of charge in the carbonyl group on excitation. Reference 119 reports two rotational isomers in the triplet complex (separated by only a very small barrier) but only one in the singlet. Reference 118 reports blue shifts of 1100 cm-1 for the singlet and 1420 cm-1 for the triplet. The singlet value is confirmed in ref. 120, which also gives shifts for a number of other hydrogen-bonded formaldehyde complexes. In addition to these ab initio calculations, CNDO calculationscontinue to be made on hydrogen-bonded systems. The influence of substituents on acetic acid dimers, for example, has been investigated at this level of approximation.lZ1
-
0
H. Popkie, H. Kistenmacher and E. Clementi, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 1325. B. R. Lentz and H. A. Scheraga, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58, 5296. 110 D. R. Yarkony, S. V. O’Neil, H. F. Schaefer, C. P. Baskin, and C. F. Bender, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 855. 111 J. E. Del Bene, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 3812. 113 J. E. Del Bene, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 24, 203. J. E. Del Bene and F. T. Marchese, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 926. 11* J. E. Del Bene, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 3139. J. E. Del Bene, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1973, 95, 5460. 116 A. Johansson, P. Kollrnan, and S. Rothenberg, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 18, 276. 11‘ A. Pullman, G.Alagona, and J. Tomasi, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1974, 33, 87. 118 S. Iwatu and K. Morokuma, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 19, 94. ll9 J. E. Del Bene, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 23, 287. l a o J. E. Del Bene, J. Amer. Chem. Suc., 1973, 95, 6517. 121 B. M.Rode, A. Engelbrecht, and W. Jakubetz, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 18, 285. lo8
lo9
Intermolecular Forces
81
Empirical Potentials and Related Topics.-Although this review mainly deals with the calculation of intermolecular potentials either ab initio, or at least from parameters such as sum rules which are derived from experiments not directly concerned with molecular interactions, nevertheless, there have recently been so many attempts to derive more accurate empirical potentials (with which any calculation must be compared) from new experimental data that it seems appropriate to mention some of this work. The noble gases have received most attention. New evidence which has been obtained from the spectra of the van der Waals molecules involving these atoms has been reported.122, 123 From this and other data, potential curves have been obtained by Maitland et al. f o r k . * .Ar,124Ne* .Ne,125Kr** .Kr,126andXe. * .Xe.12'They give numerical potentials and also an empirical form with a variable exponent in the repulsive part, i.e.
--
where n = 13.0
+
r* =
y(r*-l)
r/Ymin
-
which they suggest 128 is superior, at least for Ar - .Ar, to both that of Barker e f al.lZg and of Smith and Thal~kar.1~0 These latter authors have recently refined their potential, in which they use Hermite interpolation between a Morse potential at short distances and an R-n expansion at large distances, in the light of the recent evidence for all the noble-gas pairs.131 Taylor and Weis~man,13~ however, suggest that none of the empirical potentials that they have tested, which includes that of Maitland et al., as well as the traditional Lennard-Jones and Buckingham ones, has sufficient flexibilityto fit their thermal diffusion data on 2ONe. .22Ne.The sensitivity of thermal diffusion has also been discussed by Nenfeld and A~iz.1~3 The Buckingham (exp - 6) potential has been modified by Toennies, 134 who has added theoretical estimates44of R-* and R-l0 terms and obtains what are probably fortuitously accurate positions for the potential minima in the noble-gas dimers. Present 135 has considered the derivation of the A r e .Ar potential and suggests that a revised value should be used for the dissociation energy. Spectral data on a wide variety of van der Waals molecules are now becoming available. The noble-gas dimers have already been mentioned, but many others are now yielding detailed data on, especially, the angular dependenceof potentials, which
-
lZ2 lZ3 124
lZ5 126 lZ7
lZ8 129 130 131 132 133 l34 135
Y.Tanaka, K. Yoshimo, and D. E. Freeman, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 564. M. C. Castex and N. Damany, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 24, 437. G. C. Maitland and E. B. Smith, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 22, 443. G. C. Maitland, MoZ. Phys., 1973, 26, 513. D. W. Gough, E. B. Smith, and G. C. Maitland, Mol. Phys., 1974, 27, 867. D. W. Gough, E. B. Smith, and G. C. Maitland, Mol. Phys., 1973, 25, 1433. A. N. Dufty, G. P. Matthews, and E. B. Smith, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 26, 108. J. A. Barker, W. Fock, and F. Smith, Phys. Fluids, 1964, 7 , 897. V. H. Smith, jun. and A. J. Thakkar, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 17, 274. A. J. Thakkar and V. H. Smith, jun., Mol. Phys., 1974,27, 191 (Ar, Kr,Xe), 593 (He, Ne). W. L. Taylor and S. Weissman, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 3684. P. D. Neufeld and P. A. Aziz, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59,2234. J. P. Toennies, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 20, 238. R. D. Present, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 2659.
Theoretical Chemistry
82
represents something of a challenge to the theoretician. The subject has been reviewed to 1973 in a paper on the i.r. spectrum of 0 2 - .Ar by Henderson and Ewing, 136 who mention, beside the noble-gas pairs, (02)2, (HF)2, (C02)2, (N2)2, (H2)2, and H2- * -Ar. A list of preliminary observations by molecular beam methods is given by Novick et aZ.137 More detailed results have recently been given on Ar- * .HCl and Ar * * DCI 138 and Ar - HF,139 from molecular beam measurements, and on Ar...H214* from the i.r. spectrum. The i.r. spectrum of hydrogen in an argon matrix has been interpreted in terms of a van der Waals molecule Ar - - .H2,141while evidence on the anisotropy of the He. .H2 and Ne. .H2 potentials has been obtained by n.m.r. relaxation-time measurements.142 The long-range part of the halogen-halogen potential correlating with the B3n[ouf excited state of the diatomic molecule has been obtained by the RKR method, yielding c5, CS, and c8 coefficients for I - - .I,143Br - - - Br, and C1-
-
-
136 lS7
G . Henderson and G. E. Ewing, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 2280. S. E. Novick, P. B. Davies, T. R. Dyke, and W. Klemperer, J . Amer. Chem. SOC.,1973, 95, 8547.
13*
139 140 141 142
143 144
S. E. Novick, P. B. Davies, S. J. Harris, and W. Klemperer, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 2273. S. J. Harris, S. E. Novick, and W. Klemperer, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 3208. G. Henderson and G. E. Ewing, Mol. Phys., 1974, 27, 903. S. S. Cohen, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 18, 369. J. W. Riehl, C. J. Fisher, J. D. Baloga, and J. L. Kinsey, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 4571. K. K. Yee, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 21, 334. K. K. Yee and T. J. Stone, Mul. Phys., 1973, 26, 1169.
3 Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules BY C. THOMSON
1 Introduction This Report deals with recent theoretical work on small molecules, and covers the literature to 1 July 1974. Discussion is restricted to molecules containing up to four atoms, and work on molecules containing approximately 5-12 atoms will be reviewed in Vol. 3. This Report does not aim to be in any sense comprehensive, especially since the literature on quantum chemistry is expanding so rapidly, and discussion is restricted to those results in the field of calculations on small molecules which are judged by this Reporter to be of particular importance. Both non-empirical (ab initio) and semi-empirical calculations will be dealt with, but since most work on small molecules in recent years has used ab initio methods, this type of calculation will be emphasized. Most of the papers cited refer to work published during the period 1972-74, but there are also references to work of particular importance prior to 1972 if necessary. Developments in the theoretical methods as such will not be dealt with in any detail, the emphasis being on the results of calculations. Results are usually quoted in atomic units* @istances/bohr, energies/hartree), but there are occasional exceptions to this. A number of books and review articles dealing with the subject matter of this chapter should first be mentioned. The most comprehensive introduction to recent work is by Schaefer,l whilst a more recent book on ab initio calculations, by Cook, is also recommended.2A fairly comprehensive bibliography (up to 1974) on a b initio calculations is provided by Richards et aL3 Volume 1 of the MTP Review of Science4 deals with theoretical chemistry and contains several articles of interest, particularly an article by Wahl on diatomic molecules, and a review of the work of Pople’s group. There have also been several books dealing with semi-empirical methods in
H. F. Schaefer, tert., ‘ElectronicStructure of Atoms and Molecules’, Addison Wesley, Boston, 1972. D. B. Cook, ‘Ab-Initio Valence Calculations in Chemistry’, Wiley, London, 1974. W. G. Richards, T. E. H. Walker, and R. Hinkley, ‘Bibliography of Ab-Initio Molecular Wave Functions’, Oxford University Press, 1971, 1974. ‘Theoretical Chemistry’, ed. W. Byers-Brown, ‘MTP International Review of Science: Physical Chemistry, Series One’, 1972, Vol. 1.
* 1 bohr = 0.529 18 A; 1 hartree
= 27.21 eV.
83
84
Theoretical Chemistry
quantum chemistry, and of particular note are those by Beveridge and Pople,5 and by Murrell and Harget.6 Among many recent review articles, Browne and Matsen’ have given a thorough review of recent work on three- and four-electron molecules, particularly He2, He:, LiH, and LiH+, and a series of articles dealing with many aspects of ab initiu work have appeared in two recent books which collect together the proceedings of two conferences.8. A detailed review on electron correlation surveys recent work and defines some of the problems in this areasloThere has been an excellent review of Walsh diagrams and molecular geometry from the point of view of csb initio calculations,ll and also a survey of ab initiu methods in chemistry.12 The recent developments in generalized Valence Bond (GVB) theory have been reviewed by Goddard and co-w0rkers,~3and also the use of natural orbitals in theoretical chemistry,l4,15 and the accuracy of computed one-electron properties.ls The XCC method has been reviewed by Johnson,17 and Hurley has discussed highaccuracy calculations on small molecules.18 Several other reviews of interest have appeared in Advances in Quantum Chemistry.l7 Localized orbital theory has been reviewed by England, Salmon, and Ruedenberg,lg and the bonding in transitionmetal complexes discussed by Brown et aL2O Finally, the recent developments in computational quantum chemistry have been reviewed by Ha1LZ1 2 Diatomic Molecules containing up to Four Electrons It is appropriate to review first the recent work on HZ and Hz. A. H i and H2.-Hl and H2 are particularly important molecules, which have been used both for testing new methods in quantum chemistry and also for investigation of the inclusion of small terms in the molecular Hamiltonian. The extensive earlier work has been reviewed by Kolos.22s23 Most ab initio calculations on molecules with more than three electrons have involved the assumption of the Born-Oppenheimer ( S O ) appr0ximation.l HowD. L. Beveridge and J. A. Pople, ‘Approximate Molecular Orbital Theory’, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1970. 6 J. N. Murrell and A. J. Harget, ‘Semi-empirical Self-consistent Molecules’, Wiley, London, 1972. 7 J. C. Browne and F. A. Matsen, Ado. Chem. Phys., 1973, 23, 161. a ‘Energy Structure and Reactivity’, ed. D. W. Smith and W. B. McRae, John Wiley, New York, 1973. 9 ‘Computational Methods for Large Molecules and Localized States in Solids’, ed. F. Herman, A. D. McLean, and R. K. Nesbet, Plenum Press, New York, 1973. 10 W. Kutzelnigg, Fortschr. Chem. Forsch., 1973, 41, 31. 11 R. J. Buenker and S. D. Peyerimhoff, Chem. Rev., 1974, 74, 127. 12 J. L. Whitten, Accounts Chem. Res., 1973, 6, 238. 13 W. A. Goddard, tert, T. H. Dunning, jun., W. J. Hunt, and P. J. Hay, Accounts Chem. Res., 1973, 6, 383. 14 E. R. Davidson, Adv. Quantum Chem., 1972, 6, 235. 15 E. R. Davidson, Rev. Mod. Phys., 1972, 44, 451. 16 S. Green, Adv. Chem. Phys., 1974,25, 179. 17 K. H. Johnson, Adv. Quantum Chem., 1973, 7 , 143. 18 A. C. Hurley, Ado. Quantum Chem., 1973,7, 315. 19 W. England, L. S. Salmon, and K. Ruedenberg, Fortschr. Chem. Forsch., 1971, 23, 31. 20 D. A. Brown, W. J. Chambers, and N. J. Fitzpatrick, Inorg. Chim. Acta, 1972, 6, 7. 21 G. G. Hall, Chem. SOC.Rev., 1973, 2, 21. 22 W. Kolos, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1968, 2, 471. 23 W. Kolos, Ado. Quantum Chem., 1970, 5, 99. i)
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
85
ever, a recent series of papers by Bishop and co-workers has examined the use of a higher level approximation (the adiabatic approximation), which is based on the Born expansion of the total wavefunction, with neglect of non-diagonal nuclear terms. This approximation still allows the concept of a single potential-energy curve for a given electronic state. Bishop and Wetmore24p25 have calculated the adiabatic energy curves, dissociation energies, and vibrational energy levels for Hi, HD, and Daf.26 The non-adiabatic corrections were calculated using second-order perturbation theory. Most of the discrepancy between theory and experiment was shown to be due to the non-adiabatic terms, which amount to 1 cm-1. Bunker27 has also discussed the adiabatic correctionsto the B-0approximation for diatomic molecules. In a later paper, Bishopz8 has derived values for the equilibrium internuclear distances and force constants from the adiabatic calculations for Hl, E D + , and Dl, and these are the most accurate yet calculated without a full non-adiabatic treatment. The highly accurate James-type wavefunction for HZ has been improved using perturbation theory, yielding energies which agree with the exact solutions over the range of R from 0 to 5 A variety of calculations on the excited states of H l have appeared, covering a wide range of internuclear separations. Spectroscopic properties of the 2pnu(211u)and 3dag(2X3 states were computed by numerical integration of the Schrodinger e q u a t i ~ n . ~ The * ~ ~2pnu l and 3dng states were also studied by the one-centre method.32 The use of different types of basis functions in molecular calculations continues. The ‘0s’ or Hulthkn-type function has been used in calculations on Ha+and H2,33 and is more effective than the 1s-typefunction. Hi-type elliptical orbitals have also been employed in variational calculations on Hi, H2, He:’, and Hi.34 The H i orbitals were also used as basis orbitals for SCF calculations. A four-function basis set with two (non-linear) variational parameters yields 99% of the Hartree-Fock energy. The floating spherical Gaussian orbital method (FSGO), used so successfully by Frost et 41.,35-37 has been extended to deal with open-shell molecule~,~7 and, among other diatomics, Hzf and H2 were studied (we refer to other calculations by this method throughout this article). A generalization of the FSGO idea, in which the orbitals are ellipsoidal (FEGO) has been proposed and tested on Hz and a variety of small molecules.38 The method seems to give more accurate energies and bond angles but bond lengths are longer than those obtained in FSGO calculations.
-
D. M. Bishop and R. W. Wetmore, Mol. Phys., 1973,26, 145. D. M. Bishop and R. W. Wetmore, MoI. Phys., 1974, 27, 279. 26 D. M. Bishop and R. W. Wetmore, J. Mol. Spectroscopy, 1973, 46, 502. 27 P. R. Bunker, J. Mol. Spectroscopy, 1972, 42, 478. 28 D. M. Bishop, J. Mol. Spectroscopy, 1974, 51, 422. 29 R. P. McEachran and M. Cohen, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973,20,298. 80 C . L. Beckel, M. Shafi, and J. M. Peck, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 5288. 31 M. Shafi and C. L. Beckel, J . Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 5294. 32 R. F. Stewart, MoZ. Phys., 1973, 25, 1451. S . Ishimaru, K. Tanaka, and T. Yamabe, Bull. Chem. SOC.Japan, 1973,46, 3577. 34 C. T. Llaguno, S. K. Gupta, and S. M. Rothenstein, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1973,7, 819. 95 A. A. Frost, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,47, 3707. 38 A. A. Frost, Ado. Chem. Phys., 1971,21, 65. 87 P. H. Blustin and J. W. Linnett, J.C.S. Faraday 11, 1974,70, 327. 38 G. Simons and A. K. Schwartz, J. Chem. Phys., 1974,60,2272. 24
25
4
Theoretical Chemistry
86
The discrepancies between theory and experiment for HZ have been studied in detail over the past few years, and Kari and co-workers39 have presented a complete variational of,H2 using uthe full electronic Hamiltonian. In this work, the --- -------treatment " r,e,gy I . . , . 1 " . " . , . . ~ U . * "..
AJLS,,&+&,G.IJ
L.1
)I
kJmol-l. Also surprising were the observations that the reactions of H-, NH;j ,OH-, C a H , and CN- with CHsF were observed to be at least 100 times slower, than the corresponding reactions with CH3Cl. For reaction @) above, Bohme et al: measured an activation energy of 15 kJ mol-1 compared to the value of 16 IkJ mol -l calculated by Dedieu and Veillard.120 r This experimentalverification of the existence and even, in one case, the magni-: tude of activation barriers to gas phase s N 2 displacementson CHsF is very encour-) aging. While the reactions are all closed-shell systems with overall retention in the: number of electron pairs, the transition states do represent a significantly different: arrangement of two electron pairs. In gross terms, one lone pair of the nucleophile. and the pair binding the leaving group in the substrate are both transformed into extended bonded pairs in the transition state. The experimental agreement with the suggests that no significant change in the cord theoretical barrier for reaction 0) relation energy is encountered in the formation of the [H-CHpF]- transition1 ]state. The reader is asked to recall that the magnitudes of simple inversion barriers :are well accounted for in the HartreeFock method. Dedieu and Veillard120 have,\ ]infact, reported a limited calculation of the correlation corrections to the energiies: 'of the reactants and transition state for reaction (B). The contributions of the: !correlation energy to the reactants and transition state differed by Zess than 4 kJ: jmol -l. However, Dyczmons and Kutzelnigg123have also performed SCF calcula-;tions and calculations of part of the correlation energy for CH4, H - and the C H ~ I ]transitionstate of Dan symmetry. They found an SCF activation barrier of 293 kJ: Imol-l for reaction (A) (compared with ca. 250 kJ mol-1 obtained by Veillardi let U Z . ~ ~ a~ value ) , which is reduced to 230 kJ mol -1 with the inclusion of correlation ,intothe wavefunctions. It is clear, however, that neither set of authors has approached lthe Hartree-Fock limit in their single-determinant SCF calculations. Thus, DyczImons and Kutzelnigg obtain a somewhat better energy than Veillard et al. for (CH4 H-, but a somewhat poorer one for CH,, A striking feature of all five of these reactions is the delayed departure of the: cleaving group. Dedieu and Veillard120 have given a detailed discussion of the energetics and changes in charge density along the reaction pathways for reactions I(A)-(D), including comparisons with the empirical rules for sN2 reactions of Hammond,l24 Thornton,l25 and Bunton.126 Bader, Duke, and Messe1-127 have presented an analysis of the changes in the energy and charge density for reactions ((B)and (E) using the virial partitioning procedure. This is a partitioning method fdeterminedby the topological properties of the charge distribution, which yields a ppatial partitioning of the charge and energy for a molecular system. The kinetic ~4m~q~k1~ wPrFie%crfLtbkznrlfireltsLf.;lg-n&ry'-htnirAhir3bt- mafFnr' phnxl$he t
+
39 41 42
43 44
R. E. Kari, A. C. H. Chan, G . Hunter, and H. 0. Pritchard, Canad. J. Chem., 1973,51,2055. W. Kolos and L. Wolniewicz, J . Chem. Phys., 1964, 41, 3663. T. Orlikowski and L. Wolniewicz, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 24, 461. V. Staemmler and M. Jungen, Theor. Chim.Acta, 1972,24, 152. IS. Helfrich, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1973, 30, 169. G . Das and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 19615~44,87.
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
87
determine exact solutions to the molecular Schrodinger equation by first solving for a wavefunction which is least distorted from a product of atomic wave function^.^^ An application of the method to H2 has since been successfully carried out. Using a Slater-type orbital (STO) basis, the energies obtained were better than HF, and differed from the exact values mainly through the omission of angular correlations. This novel approach would be very useful if it could be extended to larger molecules. One of the major advances in recent years in attempts to calculate more exact wavefunctions, including electron correlation, has been the implementation by Boys and Hand~,469~~ of a computational scheme based on the method of moments, called the transcorrelated wavefunction method. In this method, a correlation factor is built into the wavefunction, which is written in the form (l), where @ is a Slater
Y
=
c@
determinant and C is of the form (2) (for n-electrons); fcan depend explicitly on ~ t j ,
and very accurate wavefunctions and energies may be obtained through the use of the operator C-lS'C. Details of the method are to be found in the series of papers by Boys and 47 Handy has recently extended this w0rk.~8The earlier calculations on He, Be, Ne, and LiH47 used numerical integration to obtain the necessary six-dimensional integrals. However, following a suggestion of Boys, Handy showed that if thef(rt, r j ) are written as linear combinations of gaussians such as exp ( -ar;) and exp (-b&) then all the integrals in the full transcorrelated equations can be evaluated analytically. Handy has described the results of calculations on He, LiH, H2, and H20,m using a small gaussian basis set (which of course makes @ a bad approximation to the best determinant).The results for the SCF and correlation energies together with the exact values are given in Table 1. The high accuracy
Table 1 Computed SCF and correlation energies by the transcorrelated wav mth0d.48 Exact correlation energy in parentheses Molecule He H2 LiH Ha0
SCF
Total energy Exact SCF
-2.710 -0.976 -7.589 -64.23
-2.862 -1.133 -7.987 -76.07
Correlationenergy -0.0399 (- 0.0420) -0,0419 (-0.0405) -0.0759 (-0.082)
-0.254 (-0.364)
achieved with a small number of functions both for Re and also at R = 2. in the case of H2 is encouraging, and leads one to hope that accurate molecular correlation energies might be obtained by this method when larger basis sets are used. 45 46 47
48
W. H. Adams, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 11, 4 4 1 . S . F. Boys and N. C. Handy, Proc. Roy. Soc., 1969, A309,209; ibid., A310,43, 63. S. F. Boys and N. C. Handy, Proc. Roy. SOC.,1969, A311, 309. N. C. Handy, Mot. Phys., 1972,33, 1.
88
Theoretical Chemistry
Bernardi and B0ys4~have examined the problem of the accuracy of the energy and other variables in this method, and give explicit formulae for improving the calculations. The original formulation of the method to cover the calculation of expectation values was given by Handy and Epstein in 1970.5OArmour 51has examined the method of moments and the transcorrelated wavefunction method (which is a particular form of the method of moments) in some detail. Several expectation values were evaluated in the course of applications of the former method to H2, and in general fairly accurate results were obtained, but numerical problems can occur, and further study is needed. In a later paper, h o u r s 2 examined the accuracy of previous transcorrelated wavefunctions for H2 by evaluating the variance of the wavefunction numerically, and comparing it with the variance of conventional variational wavefunctions. Despite the high accuracy of the energy, the transcorrelated wavefunction is only of the same accuracy as the variational function using the same basis, but both are much less accurate than the Kolos-Roothaan (KR)function.53It is, however, rather easy to improve the transcorrelated function to give a wavefunction which, though better than the variational, is still inferior to the KR wavefunction. In a later paper, Armour evaluated expectation values and compared these with the KR and variational results.54 In this case the transcorrelated wavefunctionsare substantially worse than variational functions, and in addition, the expectation values are much more difficult to evaluate. The calculation of molecular properties is as important as the evaluation of the energy, and a recent paper on spin-rotation interaction and magnetic shielding in 1X molecules, using the Kolos-Wolniewicz (KW) wavef~nction,~~ shows that theory and experiment are in good agreement, if an old approximation in the spin-rotation interaction theory is removed.55 Calculations of the dependence of the nuclear shielding on bond length in H2 appeared some years ag0,56 and the authors have recently calculated the magnetic susceptibility using their wavefunction and compared it with the KW function.57 Several important predictions of this work remain to be experimentally verified. The polarizability 0: is an important second-order molecular property. Its variation with internuclear separation has been investigated for H i and Hz by Zeroka,58 using the method of Das and Bersohn. Spectroscopic constants calculated from the BO and adiabatic KW functions for HZwere also studied by Wu and B e ~ k e l . ~ ~ Nuclear spin-spin coupling constants (JAR) are among the most difficult of molecular properties to compute by ab initio methods, because of the need to include the excited states in the expression for J. In recent years, a variety of calculations have appeared using ground-state SCF-MO’s, and expressing the coupling constant 49 50
51
52
53 54 56 57
58 59
F. Bernardi and S. F. Boys, Mol. Phys., 1973, 25, 35. N. C. Handy and S. T. Epstein, J. Chem. Phys., 1970, 53, 1392. E. A. G. Armour, Mol. Phys., 1973, 25, 993. E. A. G . Armour, Mol. Phys., 1973, 26, 1093. W. Kolos and C. C. J. Roothaan, Rev. Mod. Phys., 1960,32, 205. E. A. G. Armour, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 25, 614. R. V. Reid, jun., and A. H.-M. Chu, Phys. Rev., 1974, 9A, 609. D. B. Cook, A. M. Davies, and W. T. Raynes, Mol. Phys., 1971,21, 113. W. T. Raynes, J. P. Riley, A. M. Davies, and D. B. Cook, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974,24, 139. D. Zeroka, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1974, 8, 91. F. M. Wu and C. L. Beckel, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1973, 57, 135.
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
89
in terms of the usual second-order perturbation theory sum-over-states formula. Apart from problems inherent in the latter approximation, one other reason for the poor agreement with experiment usually obtained is the use of an uncorrelated zeroth-order function and an incomplete basis set. Kowalewski et aZ.60 have studied the removal of these restrictions in calculations on HD. The zeroth-order wavefunction is substantiallyimproved via a large CI, and the first-order correction to the wavefunction may be computed by expansion in all singly and doubly excited triplets, with the expansion coefficients being found iteratively. The computed value of JHD = 43.48 Hz is in good agreement with the experimental value of 42.94i-0.1 Hz.With the exception of earlier calculationsby Moulson and Lowe,61 Meyer,g2 and Dutta et this represents a significant improvement, especially since the method should be readily extendible to other larger systems. The above calculations on the ground state have been supplemented by calculations on a variety of excited states of H2. The IT states have been very thoroughly investigated by McLean and co-workers."-66 These workers used double-configuration wavefunctions of the type (3), where @HF = (q,ztu), @HF' = (cung)for the
Y = A@HF + B@HF' (3) states, and @HF = (cgzg), @HF' = ( g u n U ) for the 1~3n,states. Alimited basis set was used (Is, 23, 2pc, 2pn, 3dz) and the exponents were separately optimized for all four states at various R values. The exponents were found to be strongly dependent on state and distance. Various approximatewavefunctionswere also studied and P.E. curves constructed. For the best wavefunction, the shapes were in agreement with earlier, more extensive calculations.409 g79 68 One-electron expectation values were calculated, and the effects of a-n separation studied.66 The results of the latter study are of relevance for semiempirical 0-n theories. Colbo~1-1169has also investigated the I l l u and 31Tu states, using a larger basis set than Jug et al.,64-66 derived from the smaller basis set for which exponents were optimized over a range of internuclear separations. The determinationof singlet-triplet energy differencewas the main aim of this study, using ST0 basis functions and CI calculations. Less accurate calculations at the SCF level for the 311u state have been presented by Truhlar, using a STO basis set.70 This work was carried out in order to be used for calculations of electron-impact cross-sections, and P.E. curves and some one-electron properties were calculated. The 1#3C+excited states of H2 have been discussed by Huestis and Goddard 71 in an important paper dealing with the general construction of excited-statewavefunctions, and the well-known Hund-Mulliken correlation diagrams. One problem with SCF 13311u
60
62
63 64
65 66 67 68
69
70
71
J. Kowalewski, B. Roos, P. Siegbahn, and R. Vestin, Chem. Physics, 1974, 3, 70. T. Moulson and J. P. Lowe, Mol. Phys., 1971, 22, 723. W. Meyer, 2.Physik., 1969, 239,452. C. M. Dutta, N. C. Dutta, and T. P. Das, Phys. Rev. Letters, 1970, 25, 1695. K. Jug, P. G . Lykos, and A. D. McLean, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1972, 25, 10. K. Jug, P. G. Lykos, and A. D. McLean, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1972, 25, 17. K. Jug, A. D. McLean, and P. G. Lykos, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1972, 25,41. W. T. Zemke, P. G . Lykos, and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1969,51,5635. W. M. Wright and E. R. Davidson, J. Chem. Phys., 1965,43, 840. E. A. Colbourne, J. Phys. (B), 1973, 6, 2618. D. G. Truhlar, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1973, 7 , 1175. D. L. Huestis and W. A. Goddard, tert., Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 16, 157,
90
%oretical Chemistry
methods is that the wavefunction often incorrectly describes the dissociation of the rn~lecule.~ The generalized valence-bond wavefunctions (GVB) extensively studied by Goddard and co-workersl3 (see Section 3A for further details) do not have this disadvantage, and it is shown that a qualitative discussion of the energies and wavefunctions and correlation diagrams can be easily obtained. Quantitative calculations on H2 were reported in this paper. Extensions of this work to other molecules have been reviewed recently.l3 Mulliken has also investigated the a l l s state of H2.72 The inclusion of correlation effects in the calculation of second-order properties, such as the polarizability, has been examined by Bartlett and co-workers, and an application to H2 reported.73 A very accurate CI wavefunction due to Liu has been used to calculate the Compton profile for molecular Hz, with results in good agreement with experiment.74 Rather few papers have dealt with the computation of thermodynamic functions from the results of ab initio calculations, but for H2, where the latter are of spectroscopic accuracy, Kosloff, Levine, and Bernstein have computed the thermodynamic properties of H2, D2, and HD, using the best theoretical results.75 This work represents the first example of an accurate determination of a bulk, macroscopic property from first principles. The slow-convergence problem in CI calculations is well known, and several attempts to circumvent this have been proposed. A recent example is the suggested use of natural orbitals76 determined using first-order perturbation theory. This procedure results .in substantial improvements in speed for less than complete CI calculations, and the results for HZand LiH were almost identical to those obtained in more conventional CI treatments, Finally, we should mention some approximate calculations on H2. Jug 77 has developed a semi-empiricalversion of the multiconfiguration SCF (MCSCF) method, using CNDO- and INDO-type approximations, and has reported the results of a double-configuration approach to H2. It was shown that the eigenvalues of the EHF operator have physically interpretable characteristics and follow dissociation properly. Further results of this method should be very interesting. Roby78 has given details of an approximate non-empirical method in which a minimal basis of symmetrically orthonormal atomic orbitals is used, and all integrals are evaluated non-empirically. Extending this approach to include complete CT, Koster and Ruttink79 have examined H2 and H3 by this method (essentially a non-empirical NDDO method). Results are in good agreement with ordinary ab initio calculations, but CI has almost no effect on the total energies at Re. Bond lengths are well predicted, however, and optimization of the orbital exponent is possible in this method, unlike other semi-empirical methods, e.g. CND0/2. B. HeH, HeH+, and Hez.-These small molecules have also been studied by a variety of methods. Calculations on HeH+ by the FSGO method were reported in 72
73
74
75
76 77 c8
79
R. S. Mulliken, Chem. Letters, 1972, 14, 141. R. J. Bartlett, J. C. Bellum, and E. J. Brtindas, Internat. J . Quantz4m Chem., 1973, 7,449. R. E. Brown and V. H. Smith, jun., Phys. Rev., 1972, A5, 140. R. Kosloff, R. D. Levine, and R. B. Bernstein, MoZ. Phys., 1974, 27, 981.
A. K. Q. Siu and E. F. Hayes, J. Chern. Phys., 1974,61, 37.
K. Jug, Thew. Chim. Acta, 1973, 30, 231. K. R. Roby, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 11, 6 ; ibid., 1972, 12, 579. J. L. Koster and P. J. A. Ruttink, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 17,419.
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
91
ref. 37, and the HeH2+system has been used as a test case for a method for calculating potential-energy surfaces for complex values of the nuclear co-ordinates,sO a procedure which is useful in the theoretical investigation of collision phenomena. The dissociation of HeH+ under electron impact has been studied, using an elliptic orbital basis, assuming the Born-oppenheimer approximation.81 Banyard and coworkers 82 have re-formulated extensive one-centre CI wavefunctions as a natural expansion and examined electron correlation in this species as a function of R. The effects on the P.E.curve and the spectroscopic constants are fairly small. Bartlett and Brhdas have examined the ground states of HeH+ and Hz, and the excited states (fX+)of HeH+, using a new method, called the reduced partitioning procedure, in extensive CI studies.83, 84 This procedure, which makes use of Lowdin's partitioning technique, provides a set of systematic corrections to a Hartree-Fock or truncated CI wavefunction, and yields a series of dramatic energy improvements as converging upper bounds to the full CI result. Computationally attractive, the results give accurate ground-state energies in low orders. For the excited states of HeH+, potential curves were obtained,84 and again rapid convergencewas achieved, i.e. an eighth- or lower-order solution yields at least 99.9 % of the full CI result. The use of this procedure in investigating second-order properties has already been mentioned-73 Model potential calculations on HeH+ have been reportedySsusing techniques developed earlier.86 Results were in good agreement with more rigorous ab initio results. He: has been the subject of three papers, the first being concerned with a onecentre calculation of the direct ionization of He by He+ impact, which is considered to arise from a molecular autoionization of the 22; state of He: as it crosses the boundary of the continuum @Id++ e-).S7 A second paper describes a groundstate calculation with a Slater basis,88and the third a FSGO study.37 A number of papers, several years ago, dealt with the species HeH (see ref. 37), and recently it has been observed e~perimentally.~~ FSGO calculations by Blustin and Linnett37 gave a small binding energy for a two-determinant wavefunction, and predict the HeH system to be more stable than Hz...H, in agreement with experiment. C. He~.-Work on He2 and He: has been thoroughly reviewed recently.7 The repulsive curve has been extensively studied in the past, and the various components have been analysed. The recent calculations by Bertoncini and Wahl90 and McLaughlin and Schaefer,91 who studied the long-range attraction, have been supplemented by two recent studies not reviewed in ref. 7. Liu and McLeanQ2have K. Morukuma and T. F. George, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 1959. K. Mullick, T. K. D. Pai, and A. K. Barna, J. Phys. ( B ) , 1974,7, 288. 82 K. E. Banyard, M. Dixon, and A. D. Tait, J. Phys. ( B ) , 1972,5,2160. 83 R. J. Bartlett and E. J. Brbdas, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 56, 5467. a4 R. J. Bartlett and E. J. Brlndas, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 2032. 85 C. Botcher, J. Phys. (B), 1973, 6, 2368. 86 C. Botcher, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 18, 457. 87 V. Sidis, J. Phys. (B), 1973, 6, 1188. 88 Z . Cirule and A. B. Bologin, Lief. Fiz. Rinkinys, 1973, 13, 63. 89 J. Gray and R. H. Tomlinson, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1969, 4, 251. 90 P. Bertoncini and A. C. Wahl, Phys. Letters, 1970, 25, 991. 91 D. R. McLaughlin and H. F. Schaefer, tert., Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 12, 244. 92 B. Liu and A. D. McLean, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59,4557. 81
92
Theoretical Chemistry
reported an extremely large CI calculation which should be within 0.1 K (3 x 10-7 hartree) of the exact clamped-nuclei interaction energy [AE(R) = E(R)- E(co)]. The discrepancy between the best calculation and experiment is 1.5 K. This discrepancy is currently under investigation. It should be stressed, however, that the calculation is of a very small quantity, and the accuracy attained is impressive. It should also be noted that the RHF approximation cannot predict any asymptotic attractive interaction for systems consisting of two like rare-gas atoms.93 A recent perturbation procedure for the calculation of intermolecular energies94 has been applied to the above problem.95The resulting well depth is only about twothirds of that observed, but the calculations throw some light on the energetics of interacting atoms. The second-order calculation does not predict binding, and the best calculation giving a qualitatively correct curve necessitated a fifth-order calculation. The work on the excited states is of importance in interpreting the rich molecular spectrum of helium, and there have been a number of papers not reviewed by Browne and Matsen.7 Calculations of the potential maximum for the AIZG state by Mukamel and Kaldor,96 using MO-CI wavefunctions with a large number of configurations, gave a potential curve that was quite accurate near its minimum. Agreement for the higher vibrational levels was not so good. This calculated potential was subsequently used to calculate the AlX: t X1Z,f absorption spectrum.97 Agreement was quite good for most quantities which could be compared with experiment. Similar calculations on the A1Zi and ClCgf states of He2 were carried out 98 using Goddard’s GVB method.13 Results were in excellent agreement with experiment. The repulsive nature of these states at large R results from non-bonding interactions between the singlet pairs of orbitals located on different centres. The explanation of the humps in the PE curves does not agree with some earlier proposals. The potential curves for the ‘Cb, 3Zi, and 52; states arising from two triplet metastable He atoms are important in the study of Penning and associative ionization. These have recently been studied by Garrison et aZ.,99using a large CI expansion, and ionization cross-sections have been calculated. Coupled Hartree-Fock perturbation theory has been used to calculate the polarizability of a pair of He atoms as a function of R. However, the authors conclude that further work is needed, including electron correlation.1° O Two rather more unusual calculations on He2 have appeared. Carrington and DoggettlOl have used a non-orthogonal pair theory (see for example ref. 1) in which the wavefunction Y has the form (4). Such functions have received relatively N
Y
=
dA1(l, 2)A2(3, 4).
. . AN(2N- 1 , 2 N )
(4)
little attention in the past because of difficultiesin working with non-orthogonal pair functions. The authors present a version in which there are no inter-pair orthoA. M. Lesk, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 44. J. P. Daudey, P. Claverie, and J. P. Malrieu, Iirternat. J. Quantum Cheni., 1974, 8 , 1. 9 5 J. P. Daudey, J. P. Malrieu, and 0. Rojas, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1974, 8, 17. ‘JG S. Mukamel and U. Kaldor, Mol. Phys., 1971, 22, 1107. ~ 3 7 S. Mukamel and U. Kaldor, Mol. Phys., 1973, 26, 2. 8 8 S. L. Guberman and W. A. Goddard, tert., Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 14, 460. Qg B. J. Garrison, W. H. Miller, and H. F. Schaefer, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59,3193. loo A. D. Buckingham and R. S. Watts, Mol. Phys., 1973, 26, 7. lol P. J. Carrington and G. Doggett, Mol. Phys., 1973, 26, 641. 93 94
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
93
gonality constraints, and the method was applied to H2 and He. - -He. Calculations with different pair functions were carried out. It turns out that the shape of the interaction potential does not come out well, but the general results should encourage applications to bigger molecules. Within the Hartree-Fock approximation, calculations on molecules have almost all used the matrix SCF method, in which the HF orbitals are expanded in terms of a finite basis set of functions. Direct numerical solution of the H F equations, routine for atoms, has, however, been thought too difficult, but McCullough has shown that, for diatomic molecules, a partial numerical integration procedure will yield very good results.102 In particular, the He2 results agree well with the usual calculations, and it is claimed that the orbitals are likely to be of more nearly uniform accuracy than in the matrix HF calculations. Extensions to larger molecules should be very interesting; so far, published results are available for He, He2, and LiH. 3 Diatomic Hydrides of First-row Atoms, AH A. LiH and LiH*.-LiH has been a favourite molecule of theoreticians, and many calculations have been reported in recent years. Early work has been listed in Richards' bibliography,3 and Browne and Matsen' have discussed more recent work. Calculations of molecular properties for a variety of small molecules, including LiH and various other hydrides, have been reviewed by Lipscomb.1°3 The bulk of previous work has concentrated on the X I P ground state, but there is now an increasing number of studies on the excited states, particularly with wavefunctions beyond HartreeFock, and therefore including electron correlation. For comparison with this work, the near-HF calculation of Cade and Hu0104 remains a useful comparison point. Docken and Hinzelos have presented a 'very detailed study of the potential-energy curves for five valence excited states of LiH by the MCSCF method. In this type of calculation, the wavefunction, expressed in the form (3, is variationally optimized
Y
= ~ C I @ I I
(5)
with respect to both the Cr and the orbitals in terms of which the @ I are expanded. Docken and Hinze considered only valence-electron correlation, and 15 configurations were included for the 1X+ states, the orbitals being expanded in terms of a large STO basis set with exponents optimized in the molecule at Re.This basis yielded the Hartree-Fock limit in the single-configuration approximation. The dependence of the wavefunction on the internuclearseparation R is well shown in these calculations. The computed De of 0.089 hartree is in good agreement with the experimental value of 0.092 hartree. The PE curves were used to calculate the dipole and quadrupole moments, field gradients at the nuclei, and other properties.loSSome of these were averaged over the appropriate rotational-vibrat ional wavefunctions, and various electronic transition moments were also computed. In general, the agreement with experiment was very good. The best energy obtained at R = 3.015 was -8.02131, 108 1°3 lo4 105 106
E. A. McCullough, jun., Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 24, 55. W. N. Lipscomb, in ref. 4, Ch. 5, p. 167. P. E. Cade and W. M. Huo, J. Chem. Phys., 1967, 47, 614. K. K. Docken and J. Hinze, J Chem. Phys., 1972,57,4928. K. K. Docken and J. Hinze, J. Chem. Phys., 1972,57,4936.
94
nteoretical Chemistry
which is still above the best previous CI calculation of Bender and Davidson,lo7 who obtained - 8.0606 hartree. The transcorrelated wavefunction calculation of Boys and Handy47 still gave the lowest energy yet calculated for LiH, and Handy48 has obtained the same energy ( E = - 8.063 hartree) in calculations using gaussian basis functions such as were described above for H2.48 Although the emphasis in ab initio calculations in recent years has been on calculations using the MO approach, alternative methods have not been neglected, particularly Valence Bond (VB) methods of various types. Particularly promising has been the work of Goddard and co-workers with the so-called Generalized Valence Bond (GVB) method.13 The GVB method avoids a major deficiency of the HF method, namely the incorrect dissociation behaviour of the wavefunction, by taking the wavefunction to be of is a group operator that simultaneously takes care of the form (6),108 where Pauli's principle and of spin symmetry. @ is a product of spatial orbitals (7) and x is a @ =
41a(l)42a(2).
. . $ns(n)$lb(n
f
1).
- . +m b ( N )
(7)
product of one-electron spin functions @).Awavefunction of the above form has no
x
= a(l)a(2).
. . a(n)@(n
+
1).
. . B(fV>
(8)
restrictions on the form of the 0rbitals,10~~ l10 which are solutions of a set of coupled integro-differential q u at ions
2ida
= 8icja
i
=
la, l b , .
..
(9)
The orbitals may be self-consistently optimized,lll and this leads to a set of two one-particle equations to be solved, the resulting orbitals being called the GVB (or G1 or GI) orbitals. This method differs from the Hartree-Fock method in that one obtains two orbitals, one for each electron, rather than a doubly occupied orbital. If 4la = 4 l b the GI wavefunction reduces to the HF function. The fact that the orbitals are not constrained to be doubly occupied means that such wavefunctions can correctly describe molecular dissociation,and do include a certain amount of electron correlation. The different GVB methods differ in the spin-coupling schemes used.112 Calculations on LiH by Palke and Goddard (Gl),lOQand by Ladner and Goddard,ll2 in which the spin coupling was optimized (SOGI method), give essentially the same results apart from spin-dependent properties. Calculations on the ground statelog and the form of the orbitals are described in several papers. These calculations give an energy of E = - 8.01605 hartree, which is substantially less than the SCF result. The excited-state results are considered below. It should be emphasized that although this method has been implemented and many results have been described for small molecules, its extension to larger molecules at the present time seems likely to be computationally expensive. There is no doubt, however, that the insight obtained 107
C. F. Bender and E. R. Davidson, J. Phys. Chem., 1966,70,2675. A. Goddard, tert., Phys. Rev., 1967, 157, 81. W. E. Palke and W. A. Goddard, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1969,50,4524. W. A. Goddard, tert., and R. C. Ladner, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1971,93, 6750. W. J. Hunt, P. J. Hay, and W. A. Goddard, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 738. R. C. Ladner and W. A. Goddard, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1969, 51, 1073.
lo8 W.
110 l11
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
95
into molecular bonding is considerable, and for details the many papers of Goddard and co-workers should be consulted.11S The relationship of the method to others, such as the MCSCF and I N 0 4 methods, has been discussed by Hunt, Hay, and Goddard,lll who also examined the effect of the various possible restrictions on the energy and other quantities for LiH and various other small molecules. Another important use of these calculations has been an investigation of the component parts of the total energy, particularly those parts responsible for binding. Wilson and Goddardll4~ have reported the results of such an analysis for Hz, LiH, and several other diatomic molecules. The original VB method has been difScdt to use in practice because of the nonorthogonality of the atomic orbital basis, but there has been a revival of interest in it recently. Gallup and co-workers116-118 have described a new technique for carrying out such calculations, and the results of applications to the first-row hydrides. Calculations were carried out using a minimal basis set constructed from gaussian lobe orbitals. The orbitals were scaled to their best atom value and also optimally scaled in the molecule. Atomic populations were also computed.118 Calculations based on the many-electrontheory of Sinanoglu119 have been carried out by Ahlrichs and co-workers.120s121 Their method, called the IndependentElectron-Pair Approximation (IEPA), starts with an SCF calculation, followed by a transformation to localized orbitals. Then for any two electrons of the system, the energy increment Bit or 8 t j ( i # t j ) is calculated by an algorithm which is equivalent to admixing all possible doubly substituted functions with respect to QHF. The pair functions are calculated in terms of their natural orbital expansion. Using a basis of gaussian lobe functions, the relative importance of intra- and inter-pair correlations was studied for a variety of hydrides, including LiH,120Sl21where all the valence correlation is intra-pair. About 85% of the correlation energy was obtained in this calculation. Kirtman and co-workers,122 in an interesting series of papers, have described a method related to both the VB and the Atoms in Molecules method, and also to the GVB methods developed by Goddard et al.13 The method, called the Distinguishable Electron Method @EM), involves the use of a variation perturbation treatment to correct an unrestricted orbital-product approximation to the unsymmetrized molecular wavefunction. This method avoids the problems of using a Hartree-Fock Y 0, and uses an initial approximation to the wavefunction which is not symmetric with respect to electron exchange. Consequently, each electron moves in a different potential field, and the orbitals are obtained as solutions of one-electron perturbation-type equations. The success of this method hinges on the initial orbital approximation. If the best orbitals are determined self-consistently, the method reduces to that of Goddard (GVB). However, in a perturbation treatment, this is not necessary, For extensive references, see ref. 13. C. W. Wilson, jun., and W. A. Goddard, tert., Chem. Phy3. Letters, 1970, 5, 45. 116 C. W.Wilson, jun. and W. A. Goddard, tert., Theor. Chlm. Acta, 1972, 26, 195, 211. 116 G. A. Gallup, Internat. J. Quantum. Chem., 1972, 6, 899. 1 1 7 G.A. Gallup, Adv. Quantum Chem., 1973, 7 , 1 13. 118 J. M. Norbeck and G. A. Gallup, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1973, 7S, 161. 119 0. SinanGglu, Ado. Chem. Phys., 1964, 6, 315; ibid., 1969, 14, 237. 120 R. Ahlrichs and W. Kutzelnigg, J. Chem. Phys., 1968,48, 1819. 1 2 1 M. Jungen and R. Ahlrichs, Theor. Chim. Actu, 1970, 17, 339. l P 8 T. J. Venanzi and B. Kirtman, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 523, and references therein.
118
114
96
Theoretical Chemistry
and a simpler orbital model based on the distorted atoms-in-moleculesidea has been pr0posed.12~Each orbital consists of a pure atomic function, which is rescaled in the molecule, and then polarized by a variable effective internal field. Thus the MO’s are expressed in terms of known atomic polarization functions. Illustrative calculations on H2, LiH, and BeH+were presented at Re. The energies obtained lie about halfway between the RHF and GVB values. Properties were computed in fairly good agreement with experiment. Further calculations of the static polarizability for LiH have given encouraging resu1ts.l2* It seems likely that this method can easily be used on small molecules (8-10 electrons), but for larger molecules it may become timeconsuming. Calculationsby the separated-electron-pairmethod, described above,lO1 have been reported for LiH. The energy obtained ( E = - 8.0109 hartree) was very good, and the calculationsare not too difficult to carry out. The semi-numericalSCF method102 has also been tested on LiH, with results in excellent agreement with the Cade-Huo calculation. Of particular note is the improvement in the cusp, and it is likely therefore that the overall wavefunction is more accurate. The success of calculations including correlation, described above, should not obscure the fact that such calculations are (i) relatively expensive, and (ii) not easy to apply to much larger molecules. Therefore, attempts to compute the correlation energy semi-empiricallythat can be applied to larger molecules are of considerable interest. Clementi has for many years advocated such an approach, and in a recent series of papers, Lie and Clementi 125 have demonstrated one such method for firstrow hydrides (AH) and diatomics (Az). The authors 1z5 propose that the correlation energy be calculated semi-empirically in terms of a functional of the Hartree-Fock density p, since H F wavefunctions are relatively easy to obtain. This type of approach, of which earlier examples have been given by Gornbas,lZ6expressed Ec in the form (10). EC =
1p&(p)du
(10)
Clementi and Lie introduce an empirical parametrization of &(p) such that Ec is given by (ll), where pm, the modified density, is given by (12) and ni is the orbital Ec =
10.02096(1.2 +
p%)-lp% dv
+
s
0.02096ln(l
+
2.39p2)pmdv (11)
occupation number. This form ensures that the computed values of the atomic correlation energies are in good agreement with experiment for both closed- and open-shell states. This functional was then used in calculations of Ec for first-row hydrides, with p obtained either from H F calculations or MCSCF calculations. In the latter the calculations were carried out including linear combinations of enough determinants to ensure that the molecule dissociates correctly (up to three in most cases). The 123 124
125 128
B. Kirtman, S. Y.Chang, and W. R. Scott, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 3304. D. P. Chong, W. R. Scott, C. P. Yue, P. S. C. Wang, M. L. Benston, and W. E. Palke, Internat. J. Quantum. Chem., 1974, 8, 137. G. C . Lie and E. Clementi, J. Chem. Phys., 1974,60, 1275. P. Gombas, ‘Pseudopotentials’, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1967.
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
97
resultant PE curves for the HFPD (Hartree-Fock with Proper Dissociation) functions were obtained and the values of Ec computed. Agreement with experiment for the binding energies was much improved, and in particular, the incorrect prediction of HF calculations (or HF plus Ec) of a gradual increase in binding along the series LiH, BeH, and BH was corrected. The HFPD results show a different trend, i.e. LiH is nearly as binding as BeH, and BH is N 1 eV more strongly bound. Spectroscopic constants were also improved with this treatment, particularly De, which was in error by only a few per cent. The method looks promising for calculations on larger molecules. Table 2 gives the computed spectroscopic constants for the first-row hydrides computed by Lie and Clementi.
Table 2 Computed spectroscopic constantsa for first-row hydrides by HF and HFPD methods,l25 and also including correlation semi-empirically Molecule Method WeXe me Be ae Re De LiH XIC+ HF 23.26 7.426 1433 0.1945 3.034 1.49 22.46 3.077 1.91 HFPD 7.156 1306.1 0.216 Eqn. (11) 19.61 7.394 1359.2 0.203 2.999 2.36 23.20 Exptl. 7.513 1405.6 3.015 2.52 0.213 BeH P I C + HF 34.60 10.392 2147 0.2647 2.528 2.18 HFPD 27.61 2137.6 2.532 2.10 10.358 0.249 Eqn. (11) 0.258 28.17 10.607 2197.5 2.502 2.32 Exptl. 10.316 2060.78 36.31 0.3030 2.538 (2.2; 2.5) BH XIC+ HF 49.04 2.305 2.78 12.273 0.3726 2499 HFPD 48.56 11.693 2281.9 2.361 3.18 0.418 Eqn. (11) 47.36 11.992 2378.6 2.326 3.76 0.396 Exptl. 49 12.016 0.408 2367.5 2.336 3.58 HF 14.882 0.4712 CH X211 55.50 3053 2.086 2.47 HFPD 70.13 2766.0 2.139 2.97 14.156 0.576 Eqn. (11) 14.550 2881.4 65.70 0.554 3.60 2.110 Exptl. 63.0 2858.5 2.116 3.65 14.457 0.534 NH XSZ- HF 66.78 17.319 3556 1.923 2.10 0.5715 HFPD 28.805 95.13 1.352 3176.5 1.976 2.73 85.46 3305.2 Eqn. (11) 29.495 1.951 3.41 1.250 Exptl. 73 (3125.6) 0.646 16.668 1.9614 3.40 74.54 1.795 3.03 HF 0.6501 4062 19.712 OH X21T HFPD 99.19 3677.9 0.809 18.809 1.838 3.62 91.83 3801.6 Eqn. (11) 0.763 19.198 1.818 4.37 Exptl. 82.81 3735.2 18.871 1.8342 4.63 0.714 21.868 1.696 4.38 HF XIX+ HF 80.34 4469 0.7693 21.063 97.78 HFPD 4128.3 0.904 1.730 4.95 21.205 1.713 5.77 Eqn. (11) 93.39 4244.6 0.775 1.7328 6.12 Exptl. 90.44 4139.0 0.797 20.949 All units are given in inverse centimetres, except Re (in atomic units) and De (in electron volts).
-
N
The atttractive prospect of treating only the valence electrons in ab initio calculations, by devising an effective potential formulation for the core electrons, is not new, and the pseudopotential idea in Hartree-Fock calculations has been extensively explored.127 Kahn and Goddard128,129 have, however, shown how a unique and 127
J. D. Weeks, A. Hazi, and S. A. Rice, Adv. Chem. Phys., 1969, 16, 283.
128
L. R. Kahn and W. A. Goddard, tert., Chem. Phys. Letters, 1968,2, 667. L. R. Kahn and W. A. Goddard, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1972,56, 2685.
la9
98
Theoretical Chemistry
local effective potential on atoms can be obtained from GVB wavefunctions. This is possible because, unlike the HF orbitals, the GVB orbitals are non-orthogonal, nodeless, and unique. Consequently an ab initio effective potential can be obtained from calculations on atoms, and used to replace the core orbitals in molecules. Comparison with full ab initio GVB calculations on LiH and various other molecules shows that these two wavefunctions are in excellent agreement. Bond lengths and dipole moments are well predicted. This procedure appears to hold some promise for applications to larger molecules. Applications to excited states are discussed below. A model potential approach in MO calculationshas been described by Schwartz.,l30 and comparative calculations with full ab initio results have been presented for LiH and 132 Excellent agreement between the two sets of calculations of the total valence energy was found. The basic atomic model potential consists of a core-charge coulomb potential modified by the addition of a short-range gaussian screened coulomb potential. A simple model that has been shown to give accurate oneelectron properties is the point-charge model due to Tait and Hall,133e134which has been applied to LiH. Other papers dealing with molecular properties of LiH are those by Slepukhin et al. on polarizabilities,l35where agreement with experiment was not very good, and discussionsof dipole-moment calculations by Green.16 A detailed discussion of the electron pair in diatomic molecules has been given by Daudel et al. 136 with respect to first-row hydrides, using the concept of loges.137 The authors find, from an analysis of near-HF wavefunctions, that the most probable partitioning of the system is one in which electrons are localized in well-defined spatial regions or loges. Although calculations on the XIC+ ground state have been the most common, two important papers have dealt with various excited states of LiH. Melius and Goddard have computed GVB138wavefunctionsfor a variety of lX+, 3C+,ill,and 3II states of LiH at R = 3.015 bohr. Comparison with the Bender and Davidson CI results107 shows that most energy values are -0.02 hartree lower, primarily because the (1s)Z core double occupancy is relaxed in the GVB method. It is shown that the molecular excitations giving rise to these states can be interpreted as excitationsfrom only the most loosely bound orbital, 42a. A detached discussion of the excited states in terms of orbital-correlation diagrams was very revealing. It should be noted, however, that the R value is in fact quite far from Re for the excited states. The effective-potential method129used for the excited states gives excellent agreement with the full GVB treatment . A more comprehensive study of the ME+, BII1,3C+ and 311 excited states was reported by Docken and Hinze,lo5who computed ab initio PE curves and a variety of properties by the MCSCF procedure. The calculated values of Re of 5.12,4.175, and 3.76 bohr for AIX+, BlII, and 311 were much longer than the value of R used by 130 131
M.E. Schwartz and J. D. Switalski, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 4125, 4132.
M. E. Schwartz, Discuss. Faraday Soc., 1972, 54, 21. M. E. Schwartz, Chem. Phys. Lerrers, 1973, 21, 314. l33 G.G. Hall, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 6, 501. 134 A. D. Tait and G. G. Hall, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1973, 31, 311. 135 A. Yu. Slepukhin, M. A. Kovner, and K. I. Gur'ev, Teor. i eksp. Khim., 1973, 9, 799. 1 3 6 R. Daudel, R. F. W. Bader, M. E. Stephens, and D. S. Barrett, Canud.J. Chem., 1974,52, 1310. IR7 C. Aslangul, R. Constanciel, R. Daudel, and P. Kottis, Ado. Quantum Chem., 1972, 6, 93. 138 C. F. Melius and W. A. Goddard, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 56, 3348. 132
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
99
Goddard, and compare with the experimental values of 4.9064 and 4.494 bohr for A1C+ and BlJJ. The calculated values of De, one-electron properties, and transition moments were in reasonable agreement with experimental values where these were known. The open-shell molecule LiH+ has been rather less studied. Goddard’s GVB calculation 138 gave an energy of - 7.74309 hartree, leading to a predicted ionization potential (IP) of LiH of 7.600eVYwhich is similar to that obtained by Browne.139 The bond length for LiH+ was studied also by Linnett et al. in FSGO cal~ulations.~7 this species seems to be rather uncertain, different calculationsgiving values between 3.0 and 4.25 bohr. SCF calculations using a GTO basis but with a set of s-GTO placed in the bond region have been carried out on LiH+.140 The calculations give almost the same energy as obtained by Cade and H~0.104 B. BeH, BeHf, and BH.-There have been fewer calculations on BeH and its ions than on most other hydrides AH. Cade and Huo’s104 H F calculation was supplemented by Mulliken, who extended the calculations to larger values of R.141 One interesting conclusion is the simultaneous existence between 4 and 5 bohr of two MO solutions of different forms, energies, and populations. The results also indicated the presence of a barrier in the H F potential curve. Bender and Davidson,l42 and Jungen and Ahlrichs,143 computed wavefunctions beyond HF, by including CT and by the IEPA method, respectively, for the experimental values of Re. Excited states were discussed by Chan and D a ~ i d s o n ,using l ~ ~ a large CI based on natural orbitals, and these were also used by Popkiel45 to calculate spectroscopicconstants and transition probabilities between the A211 and X2E+states. In an attempt to clarify the experimental results, Bagus et al.146 have presented the results of complete-valence-shell CI calculations of the PE curves of the A2JJ and XaZ+ states, including all single, double, and triple replacements in the HartreeFock reference function. This large calculation yields results in excellent agreement with experiment, and with the qualitative features of the X2X+state obtained by Mulliken at the SCF 1e~el.l~’ However, the potential maximum disappears when all configurations are included in the CI.The predicted De(BeH X2Z+) of 3.1 15 eV is in good agreement with recent experimental work, and these calculations show that precise values of molecular properties can be computed even if the core electrons are not correlated. The calculated properties in Lie and Clementi’s work on BeH125 are in good agreement with the CI results; however, the HFPD wavefunction can be obtained with much less computational effort. Absorption spectra of BeH and BeD have been observed recently, and Colin et al. have computed the H F energy of BeH+ with the same basis set as used by Bagus.14’ Combined with an estimate of the molecular correlation energy, the authors derive IP(BeH) = 8.19 5 0.06 eV, which is in excellent agreement with the experimental value of 8.21 f 0.09 eV. The BeH+ ground state was also studied by the DEM method, as recently modified and 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 148 l4’
J. C. Browne, J. Chem. Phys., 1964, 41, 3495. S. Y . Chu, Thew. Chim. Actu, 1972, 25, 200. R. S. Mulliken, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1971, 5 , 951. C. F. Bender and E. R. Davidson, Phys. Rev., 1969, 183, 23. M.Jungen and R. Ahlrichs, Thew. Chim. Acta, 1970, 17, 339. A. C. H.Chan and E. R. Davidson, J. Chem. Phys., 1968,49, 727. H.E. Popkie, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 54, 4597. P. S. Bagus, C. M. Moser, P. Goethals, and G. Verhaegen, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 1886. R. Colin, D.De Greef, P. Goethals, and G. Verhaegen, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 25, 70.
100
Theoretical Chemistry
described above.123 In a slightly different type of calculation, Hinkley148 et al. have used the Cade and Huo SCF wavefunctions to calculate the A doubling constants in the 2II states of a variety of hydrides, including BeH, where excellent agreement was found if Van Vleck’s hypothesis of ‘pure precession’ was assumed.l** Calculations on BeH and BeD for other than the lowest rotational state were also reported in a later paper.149 BeH and BeH+ were also studied, and are described in Daudel’s paper.136 Several groups have investigated BH including electron correlation. Lie and Clementi investigated BH in the paper dealing with HFPD wave function^,^^^ and several groups have included correlation in a strictly ab initio fashion. The IEPA method, previously described,l20)121has been used to study the variation of the correlation energy in BH with R, using a gaussian lobe basis The best calculated E of -25.26318 hartree at R = 2.28 bohr was not quite as low as in Bender and Davidson’s best calculation,l42but the dependence of the different pair-correlation energies on R could be determined. Although the inter-pair correlation energy is only 17% of the total, its variation with R is much more pronounced than that of the intra-pair correlation energy. A detailed semi-empirical study of effective paircorrelation energies has been given by Pamuk, with applications to BeH, CH, NH, OH, and HF.151The method is based on the Many Electron Theory of S i n a n o g l ~ , ~ ~ ~ and full details are to be found in ref. 151. Houlden and Csizmadia152 have carried out a variety of CI calculations on the ground and various excited states of BH. Their contracted gaussian (CGTO) basis set was augmented by orbitals which increase the electron density in the bonding region. Valence-shell CI, both limited and full, was carried out, and the results were analysed in terms of the average natural orbitals (ANO) which are formed by averaging the density matrices of a set of wavefunctions resulting from intermediate calculations (double substitutions in the CI). These ANO, used as basis orbitals for a more extensive valence-shell CJ, give results comparable in accuracy to more extensive CI calculations. BH has been extensively studied by Goddard during the development of the GVB methods. Early calculations were reported both with (SOGI) and without spin optimization (GI).153,Is* Contributions from other spin functions than the usual VB function (13) are negligible, and the SOGI and GVB calculations give very similar
-
XI =
4 w - P 4 a P - Pa)
(1 3) energies and orbitals. A later paper154 devoted to a discussion of methods of optimizing the orbitals of the GVB wavefunction compared this method with other related work. In particular, the strong orthogonality and perfect pairing restrictions were investigated, both for the ground state and the A3II and AlII excited states. In the case of the latter there are significant changes in the spin coupling as R changes. A detailed discussion of the orbitals, geometries, symmetry, and form of the PE surfaces for the low-lying states was also presented by Goddard and BIint.155 R. K. Hinkley, J. A. Hall, T. E. H. Walker, and W. G. Richards, J. Phys. ( B ) , 1972, 5, 204. R. K. Hinkley, T. E. H. Walker, and W. G. Richards, J. Phys. (B), 1972, 5, 2016. l50 M. GBlus, R. Alilrichs, V. Staemmler, and W. Kutzelnigg, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1971, 21, 63. l5I H. 0. Pamuk, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1972, 28, 85. 152 S. A. Houlden and I. G. Csimadia, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1973, 30, 209. 153 R. J. Blint and W. A. Goddard, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 5296. 154 W.J. Hunt, P. J. Hay, and W. A. Goddard, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 738. ’ 5 5 W. A. Goddard, tert., and R. J. Blint, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 14, 616. 148
149
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
101
A very recent paper by Blint and Goddard,l58 using the SOGI method, has given more details of the wavefunctions and properties of the XIX+, a3H, All& and 3X+ states of BH. The PE curve for the N I T state was found to have a hump at N 3.9 bohr, due to the recoupling of the orbitals which must occur as R decreases from R = 00 to Re. The dipole and quadrupole moments, and the electric field gradient, were calculated as a function of R. BH was also studied using the GVB effective-potential method referred to ab0ve.1~~ A method of calculating the correlation energy, intermediate between the IEPA approximation and the total pair excited variational function, has been described.157 The results of an application to lZ+BH are in good agreement with other calculations. Mulliken158 has carried out near-HF calculations on the 3 X + and 1X+ excited states of BH. Convergence problems for the lZ+ state at R > 2.8 bohr were found but the two curves had the expected hump between 2.6 and 2.8 bohr. Browne and Greena~ a l t ,using l ~ ~CI, however, did obtain a double minimum for the 1X+ state. Calculations on the N I T state at R = 2.316 bohr have been reported by Green.16 The SCF X-A transition energy of 2.48 eV compares with the experimental value of 2.86 eV. Molecular Rydberg states are currently of considerable interest to theoreticians. These states arise when the outermost electron occupies a diffuse orbital, such as, in the case of first-row atoms, 3s, 3p, . ..There have been a number of recent papers devoted to such states, including the BIZ+ and lowest 3 2 + states of BH. Near Re, such states are usually well described by a single configuration, but this is not the case at large R values. The BIZ+ and 3Z+states of BH arise from the orbital configuration la22a2304a,and the work of Blint and Goddard156 and of Mullikenl68 on these was described above. Schaefer et aZ.,lso using a contracted STO basis set, carried out extensive CI calculations on the X1Z+, Ill;)=+,and 3Z+ states. Included in the basis were a set of Rydberg functions. Electron correlation was introduced via the first-order wavefunction method. This is a particular form of CI which places special emphasis on valence orbitals not occupied in the SCF configuration.1, 161 The 102 core remained doubly occupied. The necessary proper dissociation behaviour for the BIX+ state required the inclusion of the three configurations (14). The iterative
.
1 a24a25a2 1023a4oSa2
(14)
natural orbital (INO) method was ~sed.10~ For the ground state, the ab initio dissociation energy obtained was 3.27 eV (expt. : 3.54 i-0.04 ev). Spectroscopic constants and AE for the X-B separation were also in good agreement with experiment. The double minimum predicted in ref. 159 was found. The lowest 3Z+ state was predicted to be Rydberg-like, with a minimum at R = 1.173 A, for short R but valencelike (repulsive) for large R. A maximum in the 3 Z + curve occurs at 1.45 A. 156
15' 168 159 160
R. J. Blint and W. A. Goddard, tert., Chem. Physics, 1974, 3, 297. E. L. Mehler, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1973, 7S, 437. R. S. Mulliken, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1971, 3, 83. J. C. Browne and E. M. Greenawalt, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1970,7, 363. P. K. Pearson, C. F. Bender, and H. F. Schaefer, tert., J. Cirem. Phys., 1971,55,5235. H. F. Schaefer, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 54, 2207,
Theoretical Chemistry
102
An interesting application of many-body perturbation theory using a discrete orbital basis has been reported by Robb.162In calculations on BH,comparison was made between the results and those of Houlden et ~ 1 . 1 5 2using CI. Most of the pairpair interaction energy can be recovered by this method. The ions BH+ and BH- have been relatively little studied in comparison with the neutral species. Cade and Huo 1°4 investigated BH+ several years ago, and recently Blustin and Li11nett1~~ reported FSGO calculationson the X2C+ and A2l-I states. The direction of the increase in bond length, R ( T I )> R(2Z+),was successfully accounted for. The dissociation energy for the process BH++ Bf H is positive, but not for BH++ H+ B. The ion BH- is not predicted to be stable in the 211 state, but the 4 Z - state might be bound. Gaussian lobe calculations on BH+ have also been carried out, and spin-orbit coupling constants successfully calculated.1~4 C. CH and CH+.-CH has been investigated in some detail recently, particularIy in view of its importance in astrophysics. Most of the earlier calculations have been SCF calculationson the ground state, X W ,and only a few calculationson the excited states appeared prior to a thorough study by Lie et al. on the A2A, BZC-, and a4Cstates, involving CI calcuIations.165 Computed PE curves were used to obtain vibrational-rotational levels. Results were in good agreement with experiment. The a4C- state, which has not been observed experimentally,was predicted to lie between 0.52 and 0.75 eV above the ground state. More accurate calculations by Lie et al.166 have also been reported, with bigger basis sets and more configurations. A variety of CI calculations were compared, and the X2rI and PI;+ states were also considered. 4147 Configurations were included in the most extensive calculation. Results in essentially quantitative agreement with experiment were obtained, but it should be noted that only the most extended CI predicts, correctly, the bound B2Z- state, whereas the less extensive CI calculations did not predict this. A further paper167 dealt with one-electron properties. Table 3
+
+
Table 3 C0rnputedl6~and experimental spectroscopic constants for the ground and various excited states of CHa State C2Z+
B2C-
A2A a 4 2 X2I-I
a
Zero-point energy 1403.1 (1381.7) 1015.1 ( N 1068) 1454.4 (1418.1) 1555.4 1424.9 (1415.5)
All quantities are given in cm-1.
162 163 164 165
b
weXe
W?
m0
32406.7 (31778.1) 25854.9 (25698.2) 23590.6 (23217.5) 5395.5 0.0
2887.5 (2840.2) 2147.7 ( 2250) 2970.3 (2930.7) 3145.7 2886.1 (2858.5) N
106.8 (125.96) 223.2 ( 229) 98.5 (96.65) 71.8 82.0 (63.0) N
Experimental quantities in parentheses.
M. A. Robb, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 20, 274. P. H. Blustin and J. W. Linnett, J.C.S. Faraday II, 1974, 70, 826. P. W. Abegg and T.-K. Ha, Mol. Phys., 1974, 27, 763. G. C. Lie, J. Hinze, and B. Liu, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 625. This paper contains extensive
references to earlier work. 186 167
Be 14.763 (14.603) 13.51 (13.39)Q 14.976 (14.934) 5.364 14.498 (14.457)
G. C. Lie, J. Hinze, and B. Liu, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 1872. G. C. Lie, J. Hinze, and B. Liu, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 1887,
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
103
compares some of these with experimental values. Most of the results are predictions, but the dipole moment of 1.41 D is in excellent agreement with the experimental value of 1.46 f.0.06 D. These studies represent highly accurate and useful calculations, and are a further landmark in computational chemistry. Again, Clementi's HFPD wavefunctions will give values comparable to the CI functions, at much lower cost.125 Analysis of the wavefunctionsof these calculations is not easy, and the GVB method seems to be somewhat more useful in this regard; the bonding in CH has been reviewed recently.13,168 It is of some significance first to consider the 3P state of C. The usual MO description (10)~(2s)~(2p)~ has doubly occupied orbitals. The GVB wavefunction has essentially the same 1s and 2p orbitals, but there is a splitting of the 2s orbitals into a pair which have the form of sp hydrids ( 17% p-character). These two orbitals and the two 2p orbitals are the four carbon orbitals involved in bonding. In CH, the H 1s orbital pairs with a 2p orbital to give a 2 I I state, which is the ground state. The GVB lone-pair orbitals are a split sx and SX pair and are bent back at 128" from the bond axis, whilst the 2pz orbital incorporates some s-character to maintain the orthogonality. The low-lying 4 2 state is also easily explained, since it arises from bonding of H to one of the sx lobes. This is calculated to be 0.36 eV above the X211 state. CI calculations can also be carried out using the GVB orbitals as basis. Such calculations of excitation energies for various states of CH are also reported by Hay et Many-body perturbation theory has proved very useful in atomic calculations, and a recent calculation on CH, using a single-centre expansion with a complete set of basis states appropriate to the neutral C atom, gives a total energy of - 38.482 10.02 hartree and Re = 2.10 b0l1r.l~~ This energy is lower than the previous best calculation and is very close to the experimental energy. The full PE curve, accurate to second order, was also calculated for the X211 state. The difference in correlation energy between C and CH was also evaluated in an earlier paper.170 Several excited states of CH that have Rydberg character have been studied by Mulliken.171 Rather surprisingly, an energy of -38.4255 hartree was claimed by Tandardini and Simonetta in a VB calculation using a minimal basis set, including 300 struo tures in the usual way.172 This low energy is surprising because of the use of an inflexible basis set, although many configurations were included. The authors also calculated proton and 13C hyperfine coupling constants. A Doubling constants148 and spin-orbit coupling constants have been reported for CH.164 The gaussian lobe calculations are inferior to the STO basis-set calculations of Richards and coworkers.148 The FSGO calculations on CH give a fairly accurate bond length.163 The bonding was also examined from an orbital standpoint :however, the conclusion that the C-H bond has almost entirelyp character is not in accord with the GVB results.l 6 8 The ion CH+, also important in astrophysics, has been the subject of a thorough study by Green et aZ.,173using both SCF and SCF/CI. The quoted errors in the results are 0.3 eV. There is no evidence for the quasi-bound 3Z+ Rydberg state, although N
N
N
168
P.J. Hay, W. J. Hunt, and W. A. Goddard, tert., J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1974, 94, 8293.
T. E. H. Walker and H. P. Kelly, Phys. Rev., 1972, A5, 1986. T. E. H. Walker and H. P. Kelly, Internat. J. Quantum Chem,, 1972, 6, 19. R. S. Mulliken, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 14, 141. 1 7 2 G. F. Tantardini and M. Simonetta, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 14, 170. 173 S. Green, P. S. Bagus, B. Liu,A. D. McLean, and M. Yoshimine, Phys. Rev., 1972, AS, 1614. 169 170 171
104
Theoretical Chemistry
-
this was predicted for the isoelectronic BH.160 Oscillatorstrengths for the AlIT-XlC+ transition were computed by Yoshimine et al. to an estimated accuracy of 10%.I74 The agreement with calculations by the equations-of-motion method was very g00d.175 Earlier work on hyperfine splittings in CH has recently been reviewed.176 D. NH, NH+, and 0H.-The NH radical has been studied at various levels of accuracy in recent years. A survey of calculations prior to 1971 has been given by O’Neil and S ~ h a e f e rwho, ,~~~ using a contracted set of STO’s, computed PE curves for the three lowest PX-, alA, and blC+ states, using CI with the I N 0 rnethod.lO7 Various levels of CI were investigated. The ground-state energy is almost as good as an earlier calculation by Bender and Davids0n.1~~ Spectroscopic constants were calculated, and the dissociation energy, De. The latter quantity has been in dispute experimentally,and Steven~,l7~ using the Optimized Valence Configuration (OVC)179 version of the MCSCF method, has also computed De. O’Neil et al. obtained 3.06 eV, and Stevens 3.43 eV, both calculations supporting the lower of the experimental values. In a later paper, Das and co-workerslsOcomputed a variety of spectroscopic properties of NH. Using 10 configurationsin an OVC calculation, the energy obtained for X3C- of -55.0245407 hartree was slightly higher than O’Neil and Schaefer’s177 result (- 55.083968 hartree). However, of more significance are the spectroscopic constants. Solution of a one-dimensional Schrodinger equation for these, and the alternative (and usual) Dunham analysis yield different values, and the former are in better agreement with experiment. General rules for OVC calculations have been summarized by Karo et aZ.18l Spectroscopicconstants were also discussed by Lie and Clementi in their paper on correlation energies of the hydrides.125 SCF calculations on the l11 and 3rI states, 5C-,3C-, lX-, 3A, and 3C+Rydberg states have been reported for NH,17l more accurate thanearlier calculations by Liu and Verhaegen.182 Spin-orbit coupling constants ls3 and semi-empirical studies of the correlation energy have been reported.l51 A comparison of recent computations on the X211 state of NH is given in Table 4. Table 4 Comparison of some recent calculations on X211 NH CaIculation SCF CI HFPD
OVC(MCSFC) First-order CI Experiment
Elhartree -54.97806 -55.1620 -55.0010 -55.02454 -55.083968 -55.252
Rlbohr DeleV w,/cm-l 1.997 2.10 3556 1.976 2.73 3176 3.06 3287 1.967 1.967 3.06 3300 3125.6 1.9614 3.40
B,/crn-l 17.32 28.80 16.34 16.56 16.65
,u/D Ref: -1.627 104 -1.587 142 125 -1.537 178,180 177
-
M. Yoshimine, S. Green, and P. Thadeus, Astrophys. J., 1973, 183, 899. P. H. S. Martin, D. L. Yeager, and V. McKoy, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 25, 182. 176 C. Thomson, in ‘Electron Spin Resonance’, ed. R. 0. C . Norman (Specialist Periodical Reports), The Chemical Society, London, 1974, Vol. 2, p. 1. S. V. O’Neil and H. F. Schaefet, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 394. l i e W. J. Stevens, J . Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 1264. G. Das and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 56, 1769. G. Das, A. C . Wahl, and W. J. Stevens, J . Chem. Phys., 1974, 61,433. lel A. M. Karo, M. Krauss, and A. C. Wahl, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1973, 7 S , 143. 182 H. P. D. Liu and G . Verhaegeen, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1971, 5S, 103. 183 R. K HinMey, T. E. H. Walker and W. G. Richards, MoI. Phys., 1972,24, 1095. 174 I75
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecule,s
105
NH+ has not been investigated recently, apart from a FSGO calculation.1e3 The most recent large calculation is by Liu et uZ.lS4 The OH radical has been the subject of a large number of papers, partly prompted by recent detailed experimental information by both microwave spectroscopy and electron resonance.la5The theoretical calculation of these fine-structure parameters is a challenge to the theoretician; GVB wavefunctions for OH ( P U ) have been reported by Gukrman and Goddard1S6 and also OVC wavefunctions have been computed by Karo et aZ.lal The PE curves reported in the latter were obtained from a 14-configurationwavefunction and are N 0.1 eV off the experimental curve, indicating the high accuracy attainable by this method. Bondybey et have computed PE curves via ht-order wavefunctions for OH. The calculated De of 4.26 eV (expt. : 4.63 eV) is much improved over the SCF result. The bond length is rather accurately predicted. The detailed charge distribution has been studied for the SCF wavefunctions by Cade et aZ.la8The PE curves of the 2X- and 41=- Rydberg states have been computed by Lefeb~re-Brion~l8~ who found these states to be unstable. The current interest in the hyperfine structure and dipole moment of OH and OD has led to several attempts to compute these quantities accurately. Green190 has computed SCF wavefunctions with various basis sets, and also CI wavefunctions. The experimental and computed values were in good agreement for the CI wavefunction. The computed dipole moment has an uncertainty of kO.06 D and the high accuracy enables a choice to be made between alternative experimental values. The hyperhe splitting constants were in very good agreement with experiment.l’* Many-body perturbation theory (MBPT)lgl has been used to calculate the proton hypedine splitting constant in OH,lg2with results in better than 15 % agreement with experiment. The energy for this wavefunction was not reported. OH- has been studied by Lishka,lg3the only earlier calculation being that of Cade.194 Using the IEPA method, the bond lengths and harmonic force constants are corrected in the right direction, but Re tends to be too long. Protonation energieswere computed and were in reasonable agreement with experiment. The separated-pair approach has been used to calculate electronic wavefunctions for the lX+ state of OH-, yielding a geminal description of the bond.lg5 N
E. HF and HF+.-The HF molecule has probably been as much studied theoretically as any other hydride except for LiH. The ground state of HF was recently investigated by Bondybey et uZ.la7Using extended STO basis sets, their computed SCF wavefunction gave an energy which was within 0.0028 hartree of Cade and Huo’s va1ue.l O4 Correlated wavefunctions were obtained by the first-order pro1B4 185
H.P. D.Liu and G. Verhaegen, J. Chem. Phys., 1970, 53, 735. A.Carrington, ‘Microwave Spectroscopy of Free Radicals’, Academic Press, New York, 1974.
l a 6 S. L. Guberman and W. A. Goddard, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1970, 53, 1803. 187 188
180 190
101 1g 2 193 19* 195
V. Bondybey, P. K. Pearson, and H. F. Schaefer, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 1123. P. E. Cade, R. F. W. Bader, and J. Pelletier, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 54, 3517. H. Lefebvre-Brion, J. Mol. Structure, 1973, 19, 103. S. Green, J . Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 4327. 0. Sinan6glu and K. A. Bruekner, ‘Three approaches to Electron Correlation in Atoms’, Yale U.P., New Haven, Connecticut, 1970. J. E. Rodgers, T. Lee, T. P. Das, and D. Ikenberry, Phys. Rev., 1973, 7A, 51. H.Lishka, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1973, 31, 39. P. E. Cade, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,47, 2390. J. D. Allen and H. Shull, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 9, 339.
106
*oretical
Chemistry
cedure, and a 43-configuration calculation via the IN0 method was used to compute the PE curves. The best dissociation energy obtainable by this approach (estimated to be between 5.95 and 6.00 ev) is in error by 0.14.15 eV. The spectroscopic constants are much improved over the SCF results. Lie and Clementi’s 125 semi-empirical calculation of the correlation energy gave reasonable agreement with the full ab initio results for HF. An extension of the HF calculations is reported in a later paper by Lie196 in which the theoretical dipolemoment function and i.r. transition matrix were computed for the X1X+ state. The value of p was calculated over a wide range of R values from two-coniiguration MCSCF wavefunctions, the second configuration ensuring proper dissociation as R-+ m. A large (13s8p2d/8s2p)GTO basis was contracted to a [7s4p2d/5s2p]CGTO set. The results show a qualitative and quantitative improvement in p and its derivatives. The calculated result for the vibrationally averaged dipole moment for the tl = 0 level is in excellent agreement with experiment. The Dunham method of analysis of PE curves is well known, but Simons and Parr 197 have presented an alternative method. Calculations on HF and CO show the method [which involves the expansion parameter (R- Re)/Rinstead of (R-&)/Re] to be superior. The IEPA calculations by Lishkalg3also included applicationsto HF. His total energy of - 100.4005 hartree was only 0.03 hartree from Bender and Davidson’s large CI r e ~ u 1 t . l ~ ~ A comparison of minimal-basis perfect-pairing and MO wavefunctions for HF and HFf has appeared,l98 in which complete exponent optimization was carried out. A series of OVC calculations on first-row hydrides has aimed at accurate values for dissociation energies and onselectron moments of the charge distribution, and we have already referred to the calculations on NH.1789 l80 Krauss and Neumann lS9 have recently examined HF at the experimental value of Re. Using eight configurations in an OVC calculation, the dominant correlation effects in HF are accounted for. Good agreement with experiment was found for the dissociation energy, dipole moment, and quadrupole moment. Table 5 compares the results with experimental values and other recent calculations. Table 5 Comparison of some recent calculations on HF Method Hartree-Fock HFPD First-order CI CI Perfect pairing min STO-MO MCSCF(0VC) IEPA
Energylhartree - 100.0703 - 100.0917 - 100.1274 - 100.3564 -99.5456 -99.5356 -100.1397 - 100.3258
DeJeV co,Jcm-l B,Jcm-l 4469 21.87 4.38 4128 21.06 4.95 4210 20.8 5.88 __ -_ 6.18 _ ~ _ I
pJD 1.934 --
1.816 1.72 1.41 1.805
-
Ref. 125,104 125 187 142 198 198 199 193
Localized MO’s have been computed by von Niessen200for HF and a variety of other small molecules (LiF, BF, BN, CO, etc.),using a previously described localizalgG I97 198 199 200
G. C . Lie, J . Cliem. Phys., 1974, 60, 2991. G . Simons, R. G . Parr, and J. M. Finlan, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 3229. R. E. Bruce, K . A. R. Mitchell, and M. L. Williams, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 23, 504, M. Krauss and D. Neumann,Mol. Phys., 1974,27, 917. W. von Niessen, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1973, 29, 29.
Quantum Mechanical Calculationson Small Molecules
107
tion methody201* 202 in which the orbitals are density localized, i.e. the localization is based on the minimization of the sum of the charge-densityoverlap integrals of the orbitals. Agreement with the results of other localization methods was good. With the exception of LiF, BN, and COYthe localized orbitals are in agreement with the concepts of inner shells, lone pairs, and bonding pairs. One reason for interest in more accurate calculations on HF has been the measured dissociation energy Do(HF), which can be obtained from photoionization or photoelectron spectra. Since HF+ dissociates correctly within the Hartree-Fock approximation to H+ and F(2P) in both the X2II and 2C+ states, PE curves were calculated by Julienne et aLY2O3 and later by Bondybey et U Z . , ~ both ~ ~ of whom obtained values of D Oin good agreement with experiment for the S C F calculation. The bond length in HF+ of 1.OOO bohr is less than the experimentalresult, which the authors call into question. Julienne et al. give a detailed discussion of the adiabatic dissociation process. HF+ was also considered in the calculations of ref. 198. Richards and co-workers have reported several calculations of the PE curves of HFf, including the A2X+ state, which is correctly predicted to be b0und.~04 HF-has been little studied, but Bondybey et al. found that for their first-order calculations the PE curves were all rep~1sive.l~~ We may summarize the results on first-row hydrides by concluding that a variety of calculations with a large number of different methods have appeared, but, with rather few exceptions, most calculations have not attained the accuracy of Bender and Davidson's work of some five years ago. This latter fact emphasizes the fact that it is not easy to obtain a large fraction of the correlation energy for these. molecules, but fortunately many interesting molecular properties and potential curves can be computed with high accuracy despite this. 4 Hydrides of Second and Higher Rows, AH
A definitive paper dealing with near-HF calculations was presented some years in which the hydrides NaH, MgH, AlH, SiH, PH, and ClH were studied. Recent work has been rather fragmentary, but more experimental information on SHYSeH, and TeH has recently been obtained.185 Wirsam206has reported combined SCF and CI results on SiH, predicting the location of a variety of low-lying states and their properties. Gaussian lobe functions were used in this work. Bondybey et aZ.187 studied NeH+ and NeH. The ground-state curve of NeH is repulsive but those of the excited states are not. The Ar-H long-range interaction has been evaluated by the MCSCF method.207 These results are of use in the analysis of scattering experiments of H off Ar. Scott and RichardsaoScalculated approximate SCF wavefunctions for TiH, whose ground state is predicted to be 4@. The dissociation energy is predicted to be 1.6eV, similar to that observed for CaH. FeH has been 201 202
203 204
205 206 207 208
W. von Niessen, J. Chem. Phys.,-l972,56, 4290. W.von Niessen, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1972, 27, 9. P. S. Julienne, M. Krauss, and A. C. Wahl, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 11, 16. J. Raftery and W. G. Richards, J . Phys. ( B ) , 1972, 5, 425. P. E. Cade and W. M. HUO,J. Chem. Phys., 1967,47, 649. B. Wirsam, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 10, 180. A. F. Wagner, G. Das, and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1974,60, 1885. P. R. Scott and W. G. Richards, J. Phys. ( B ) , 1974,7, 500.
Theoretical Chemistry
108
examined by Walker et aL210The high-spin
aZ.,209
and a detailed study of MnH reported by Bagus et
7X+and 'II states were computed at an accuracy near to the level
of HF calculations. A detailed discussion of the bonding was given. Of particular interest is the fact that the Mn 3d orbitals are essentially unchanged within the molecule. The magnetic properties of AIH have been investigated by Laws et ~ 2 . ~ 1 1 The (XeH)+molecule has not been previously studied, and SCF calculations using a STO basis and including spin-orbit interactions semi-empirically have been reported by Kubach and Sidk212 In a significant paper, Bauschlicher and Schaefer213 have examined the flexibility of atomic orbitals in a molecular environment, and they have shown in calculations on diatomics involving second-row atoms (among these the 3X- state of PH) that only the outermost orbitals are altered during molecular formation, and hence essentially fully contracted GTO can be used for the inner-shell orbitals. We will return to this point later. For PH the contraction procedure that was used recovered 89% of the energy obtained with an uncontracted basis set. The HCI molecule has been extensively studied by SCF methods in the past, and this work is referenced in a more recent paper by Petke and Whitten,214who have examined the effect of the size of the basis set on the geometry, bonding, and physical properties of HCI. The results were compared with previous calculations. A gaussian lobe basis set was used, including d-functions on C1 and p- and dfunctions on H, and finally a 206-configuration CI calculation yielded the most accurate wavefunction computed to date for HCI. Although the best SCF calculation gave 99.55 % of the experimental energy, the 206-configuration wavefunction only recovered "4% of the correlation energy. Inclusion of C1 d-functions improves the total energy and all molecular properties significantly.The d-functions result in well-defined charge shifts, charge being shifted from H to CI in MO's made up mainly of CI s-orbitals, while charge is shifted from CI to H and into the bonding region for orbitals containing Cl p-functions. The C1 d-functions are particularly important in the calculation of the dipole and quadrupole moments. The effect of CI was rather small, only the dipole moment being significantly altered. Finally, we mention briefly an interesting series of papers by Bader and cow0rkers,~16who have partitioned the charge distribution in a variety of hydrides in a particular way. Details and references to this series of papers are given in ref. 215. 5 Homonuclear Diatomic Molecules of First-row Elements We have referred above to Clementi and Lie's work on the correlation energy of the first-row hydrides.125 The authors 216 have also presented results for the homonuclear diatomics of the first row, namely the molecules H2(XlZi), Li2(X1C;), Be&VZ:), 209
210 211 212
213
214 215 a16
J. H.Walker, T. E. H. Walker, and H. P. Kelly, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 2094. P. S. Bagus and H. F. Schaefer, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 1844. E.A. Laws, R. M. Stevens, and W. N. Lipscomb, J. Chem. Phys., 1971,54, 4269. C. Kubach and V. Sidis, J. Phys. (B), 1973, 6, 289. C. W.Bauschlicher, jun. and H. F. Schaefer, tert., Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 24, 412. J. D. Petke and J. L. Whitten, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 56, 830. R. F. W. Bader and R. R. Messer, Canad.J. Chem., 1974,52, 2268. G. C. Lie and E. Clementi, J. Chem. Phys., 1974,60, 1288.
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
109
Bz(X3Z;), C2(X1Zi), N2(X1Zi), Oz(X 3C,), and F2(X1Xi), and before considering calculations on individual molecules, it is convenient to describe this important work. Using the same functional of the electronic density as used in the calculations on atoms and on AH, PE curves were computed for these molecules over a wide range of R. The HFPD functions used initially were only those necessary to ensure that &+ 2A. The energies were then corrected by using equation (11). The computed values of De are again much improved over the Hartree-Fock values. However, it is found that for four cases, uiz. Liz, Bz, CZ,and 0 2 , agreement was not within 1 eV of experiment. The reason for this was that the chosen reference function, although correctly describing the dissociation behaviour, does not include configurations which have been shown to be important in CI calculations. For Liz for instance, the configurations 1oil ok30; and 1ail eln; must be added to the two original functions 10il0i20i (HF configuration) and 1 ~ ~ 1 4 2The 0 ~ mixing . coefficients of the added configurations add up to 0.214. When a more appropriate reference function is used for these four molecules, much improved agreement with experiment is obtained. The lC, state of Be2 is repulsive. Agreement with experiment is not, however, as good as for the hydrides AH,125but since it is a simple matter to use the method and the method is almost certainly capable of refinement, these two papers do demonstrate that it might be possible to compute quite reliable correlation energies for larger systems. We now review some of the more important calculations on specific homonuclear diatomic molecules. A. Liz and Liz . T h e PE curve of Liz at large values of R (between 5 and 30 bohr) has been investigated, using a multiconfiguration approach to valence-shell correlat i ~ n . The ~ l ~dispersion contribution to the binding energy was computed and turns out to be practically equal to the London energy, EL = - 66R-6for R 2 10 bohr. This work is interesting as being appropriate for the study of long-range intermolecular forces. The authorsZ1shave also examined by the same method the PE curve of the lowest (3C,')state of Liz, using a gaussian lobe basis. The van der Waals minimum is quite deep, N" 0.0012 hartree (380 K). The calculations confirm previous 8 6 values which are still in disagreement with experimental estimates. This paper also gives a refined calculation on the 1Ci ground state, the lowest binding energy obtained being - 0.0366 hartree (expt. : - 0.0385 hartree). Early calculations by the OVC method were presented by D a ~ , ~who l 9 obtained E = - 14.90260 hartree. Calculations by GoddardzZOof GVB wavefunctions for Liz and a discussion of the bonding have appeared. Using an STO basis set, the orbitals obtained are very similar to the Li atomic orbitals, except that there is small amount of sp mixing, and a subsidiary 2s peak comes from the other centre. Goddard's128t129later papers on the use of effective potentials (GAEP) in these calculations also discuss the XIZB+state of Liz. The orbital description implies, as is found, a rather weak bond. The close agreement between the orbitals in the GAEP and GI methods is gratifying. Electronic properties were also computed, agreement being good except for the field gradient at the Li nucleus. This method was also 217
als 219 220
W. Kutzelnigg and M. GClus, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1970, 7, 296. W. Kutzelnigg, V. Staemmler, and M.Gelus, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 13, 496. G. Das, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,46, 1568. W. A. Goddard, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1968, 48, 1008.
110
Theoretical Chemistry
applied to Lil, where it was shown that the valence orbital in this case has far morep character and larger amplitude in the internuclear region, leading to a stronger bond. 82% of the experimental binding energy was obtained even with an sp GTQ basis.221 Li: was also investigated by Hendersen et aZ.,222 who obtained a near-HF PE curve, and who give references to earlier work on Li:. Properties were calculated for the 2 X i and 211 states. An FSGQ 163 calculation gives 85 % of the SCF energy, and a reasonable value of De. Liz has not been previously studied, and Blustin and Linnett 16s have reported FSGO calculations on the 2X: and 211u states. The latter was calculated to be bound, with the unpaired electron in the lIIU bonding orbital. This result is surprising. SCF calculations for Liz using bond functions in the basis set have been reported by Chu.223 B. Be2, B2, C2, Ci, and Ci.-Apart from the calculations of Lie and CIementi,216 there has been no recent work on Be2 or B2. C2 has been re-investigated by B a r ~ u h n , ~who ~ 4 gives references to many earlier calculations. Using an extensive basis set of gaussian lobe functions, SCF orbitals were obtained and used in two CI calculations at R values near Re. A calculation involving only virtual a-orbitals agrees qualitatively with experimental data on the three known Rydberg states. The most extensive CI treatment over-estimates the excitation energies by up to 1.7 eV. Similar calculations by the same author were carried out on C;.225 These calculations were prompted by recent optical spectral observations. This ion is so far the only negative molecular ion known that has bound excited states. Using a contracted gaussian lobe basis set, the 2 X l , 211u, and 2X: states were investigated at eight internuclear distances. In the SCF approximation, the 211u state is predicted to be the ground state, which is not the case when CI is included. The excitation energy of the 2Ei state is over-estimated. Two hitherto unobserved states, 2nuand "i, are predicted. C. N2 and N;.-The nitrogen molecule is one of the most extensively investigated of homonuclear diatomics. Extended-basis-set SCF calculations by Cade et af. were reported some years ago (see ref. 1 for full references). Mulliken, who pioneered MO correlation diagrams, has carried out an SCF calculation at 17 internuclear distances from 0.1 bohr to Re and has optimized the 5 value of each exponent at Re, which results in a computed MO correlation diagram.226 A Mulliken population analysis shows how the composition of the orbitals changes with R . The correlation diagrams are as expected qualitatively in most respects, but the quantitative features are not all as expected. For instance, - d for the 2ag orbital at first increases with decreasing R, then decreases surprisingly to smaller values than at Re before again increasing steadily towards the 2s united-atom orbital values. The 3ag orbital is particularly interesting, especially the variation between p - and s-character as R decreases. Near 0.6 bohr, it is almost pure 3 4 i.e. it is of the form og3s, derivable from the 3s penetrating Rydberg atomic orbital, instead of being predominantly ag2p, as at Re. N
221 222 223 224
225 226
W. A. Goddard, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1965, 48, 5337. G. A. Henderson, W. T. Zemke, and A. C. Wahl, J. C h m . Phys., 1973, 58, 2654. S. Y . Chu, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1972, 25, 200. J. Barsuhn, 2. Nuturfursch., 1972, 27a. 1031. J. Barsuhn, J. Phys. (B), 1974, 7, 155. R. S. Mulliken, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 14, 137.
Quaraturn Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
111
Finally, the 20, orbital (which at Re resembles 2pa of the UA) shows steadily increasing s- and decreasing p-character as R decreases. The value of B increases until R = 0.9 bohr but then suddenly decreases to a surprising minimum at R-0.6 before increasing again to the 3pa form in the UA. This quantitative analysis is very interesting, and it is hoped that further results on other A2 will show if the subtle effectsare common to the other molecules. Other papers by Mulliken, dealing with N2, have also a~peared.~271 228 Another interesting class of molecular states are those are predicted.228 involved in V-N transitions. Two types, V, and V, (OD* and m*), Cederbaum has pointed out that the breakdown of Koopmans theorem for the ionization potentials of N2 and F2 can be rationalized using simple symmetry arguments.229 Kaijser et aZ.230have calculated momentum densities for the ground and singly ionized states of Nz.These are calculated from the Fourier transform of the NSO of the wavefunction, evaluated in a minimal STO calculation with valence-shell CI. Interpretation of these quantities is discussed in the paper. There has been little recent work on the excited states of N2, except for some calculations involving the . ~variety ~ ~ of excited states of N2,02, and CO use of a different SCF H a m i l t ~ n i a nA were investigated using a CGTO basis set. Results were mostly in good agreement with experiment, but the b' 1Xi state of N2 could not be reliably located by this method. Attempts to improve molecular wavefunctions so as to be able to calculate properties more accurately continue to be made, particularly via the constrained variational procedure. Two-particle hypervirial constraints were considered by Bjorna within the SCF formation,232and he presented a perturbational approach to their s0lution.~3~ Using Scherr's wavefunction, and constraining # to satisfy the molecular virial theorem, a calculation on Nz led to rapid ~onvergence.~s*~235 The constrained SCF orbitals are believed to be a closer approximation to the true t,b nearer the nucleus than further out. A later paper discussed the electron-density maps in comparison to the SCF derived maps, which confirm the conclusion that the wavefunction near the nucleus is impr0ved.~3~ Electron scattering from molecules is receiving increasing attention, and theoretically it can be treated by calculation of the static potential (the interaction potential of an electron with the unperturbed charge distribution). Ab initio calculationsfor NZ using wavefunctions varying between minimal-basis and near-HF quality have been reported by Truhlar et Q I . , ~and ~ ' compared with semi-empirical INDO calculations. The anisotropy of the potential is only correctly described if d-functions are included in the basis set. Probably the most extensive calculation yet carried out on N2 is that of Langhoff R. S. Mulliken, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 14, 144. R. S. Mulliken, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 25, 305. 229 L. S. Cederbaum, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 25, 562. m o P. Kaijser, P. Linder, A. Andersen, and E. Thulstrup, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 23, 409. 2s1 J. B. Rose and V. McKoy, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 5435. 2s2 N. Bjorna, J. Phys. ( B ) , 1971, 4, 424. 233 N. Bjorna, J. Phys. (B), 1972, 5, 721. 234 N.Bjorna, J. Phys. (B), 1972, 5, 732. 235 N. Bjorna, Mol. Phys., 1972, 24, 1. 236 N. Bjorna, Physica Norvegica, 1972, 6, 8 1. 237 D. G. Truhlar, F. A. Van-Catledge, and T. H. Dunning, J . Chem. Phys., 1972,57,4788. 227 228
112
Theoretical Chemistry
and D a v i d s ~ nwho , ~ ~obtained ~ 63 % of the correlation energy in a large CI calculation using a GTO basis set. In this set of calculations, a comparison was made between the sum of the pair-correlation energies and the total correlation energy. Calculations were carried out using both ICSCF 239 and canonical orbitals. The sum of pair energies was 17% bigger than the correlation energy in both cases. It was expected that N2 would be a particularly unfavourable case for the independent-pair method. The effect of quadruple excitations was also studied and found to be 8 % of the total. Second-order perturbation theory over-estimates Ec by 23-50 % depending on how 0 is chosen. In connection with calculations of pair-correlation energy, we should refer to an extensive set of OVC results, not published in full, carried out some years ag0.~40 We must finally mention two papers dealing with approximate methods in which NZhas been studied. Firstly, the X, multiple-scattering SCF method2419242 has been applied to N2,02, and F2 by Weinberger and Konowalow 243 and the PE curves have been calculated over a wide range of R values. Although qualitatively correct curves are obtained, the calculated values of De are much too small, and of Re are much too large. Note, however, that calculations by the same method on Liz244 give more realistic results. ‘Transition state’ calculations of the ionization excitation energies for N2 give ionization potentials virtually identical to those calculated directly, and are in fair agreement with experiment. Much further work is needed in order to establish and refine this method for calculations on small molecules. A comparison of properties calculated by the INDO method, such as dipole and quadrupole moments of the charge distribution, with ab initio results has been given for N2, H2, COYand HF.245Suggested improvements in the INDO procedure were given. N l has been the subject of two papers. The 2Xl, 2rIu, and 2 X i vertical ionization potentials of N2 were computed by Chen et aZ.246 The method 247 used permits direct calculation of ion-molecule energy differences, and contributions to the IP are analysed. Several low-lying quartet states of N2f have been studied using valence-shell CI with up to 270 configurations per symmetry.248 The 2s and 2 p exponents for the ground state of Nz were optimized for the molecule. Several states were found to be bound, and they have lower energies and larger Re than previously assumed, particularly the 411, state. D. 0 2 , Oi, and O;.-Although Cade, many years ago, obtained a near-HartreeFock wavefunction for the X3C; state of 0 2 , the wavefunction was not published, although a detailed discussion of the charge distribution and how it changes upon N
-
238
239 240
241 242 243
244 245
246 247
24*
S. R. Langhoff and E. R. Davidson, Internat. J. Quantum Chenz., 1974 8 , 61. E. R. Davidson, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 1999. P. Sutton, P. Bertoncini, G. Das, T. L. Gilbert, A. C. Wahl, and 0. Sinandglu, Internat. J . Quantum Chem., 1970, 3S, 479. J. C . Slater, A h . Quantum Chent., 1972, 6, 1 . K. H. Johnson, Adv. Quantum Chem., 1973, 7 , 143. P. Weinberger and D. D. Konowalow, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1973, 7 S , 353. See ref. 9, p. 161. F. A. Van-Catledge, J. Phys. Chem., 1974, 78, 763. T.-T. Chen, W. D. Smith, and J. Simons, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 26, 296. J. Simons and W. D. Smith, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 4899. A. Andersen and E. W. Thulstrup, J. Phys. ( B ) , 1973, 6, 211.
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
113
ionization or excitation has been given by Cade et a1.249 The computed HartreeFock De of 1.43 eV, is however, only 27 % of the experimental value. Schaefer 250 has gone beyond the Hartree-Fock approximation and computed the ground-state PE curve, using first-order wavef~nctions.~5l A contracted STO basis set has been used, with 128 configurationsincluded. The molecule now dissociatesto two oxygen atoms, and De was computed to be 4.72 eV (expt. : 5.21 ev). Spectroscopic constants were usually in better agreement with experiment than a previous minimal-basis full CI calculation. The value of Re obtained was close to the experimental value. Goddard and co-workers have also studied 0 2 by the GVB method.154 This molecule is particularly interesting for this method, since one of the difficulties of the earlier VB method was its failure to predict the triplet ground state. The GVB wavefunction is of the form (1 3,where ( o ~ ais~the ) 0-0 a-bonding pair. It differs from
by the presence of a split 0-0 cr pair, which involves the 3ag and 3au natural orbitals. The correct ordering of the 3X;, lZg, and lA; states was predicted. GVB-CI calculations give good results for De and the excitation energies, although the energy of Schaefer’s FO wavefunction is lower by -0.06 hartree. In a later paper Cartwright et aZ.252 have examined the n = 3,4, and 5 Rydberg series in 0 2 and correlated the results with experimental studies of electron energyloss spectra. The calculations were carried out using a method recently proposed by Hunt and Goddard.253 In this method, the form of the Hartree-Fock 2 is modified so that the virtual orbitals are good approximationsto the SCF excited-state orbitals, and are called improved virtual orbitals (IVO). A 4s3p CGTO basis set was used, with a set of diffuse functions added to obtain a good description of the Rydberg states. Results for the ordering of the states and the excitation energies were in generally good agreement with experiment. M ~ r u k u m has a ~ ~also ~ investigated the PZ;, clC& P A u , and A3Z: states of 0 2 with various CI wavefunctions. The oscillator strength of the B3&+ X3Z; transition was in good agreement with experiment. An interesting comparison of the use of 3d polarization functions and bond functions (GTO placed in the bond) has been presented by Vladimir0ff,~5~ using NZ and 0 2 as examples. It was found that three optimized bond functions perform about as well as six 3d-functions, and the computer time required is substantially less. A variant of the MsX, method has been proposed in which a is ~ a r i e d , ~and 5~ applicationsto N2 and 0 2 have been reported.257 For a = 0.70, results were in good agreement with experiment, mainly because of the removal of the muffin-tin approximations. #HF
249
250 251
252 25s 254
255 256
257
P. E. Cade, R. F. W. Bader, and J. Pelletier, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 54, 3517. H. F. Schaefer, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 54, 2207. H. F. Schaefer, tert., and F. E. Harris, J. Chem. Phys., 1968, 48, 4946. D. C. Cartwright, W. J. Hunt, W.Williams, S. Trajmar, and W. A. Goddard, tert., Phys. Rev., 1973, 8A, 2436. W. J. Hunt and W. A. Goddard, tert., Chem. Phys. Letters, 1969, 6, 414. K. Morukuma and H. Kohnishi, J. Chem. Phys., 1971,55, 402. T. Vladimiroff, J. Phys. Chem., 1973, 77, 1983. E. J. Baerends, D. E. Ellis, and P. Ros, Chem. Physics, 1973, 2,41. E. J. Baerends and P. Ros, Chem. Physics, 1973, 2, 52.
114
Theoretical Chemistry
Calculations of the fine-structure parameters by V e ~ e t h , ~the ~ 8spin-orbit contribution to the zero-field ~plitting,~5~ and the Verdet constant for 0 2 have also been reported. ti O Photoelectron spectral measurements have prompted high-accuracy nearHartree-Fock calculations on the 1s hole states of 0,+.261Calculations were reported at Re for molecular 0 2 . The frozen-orbital approximation evaluated the energy of 0;from the RHF calculations of Schaefer250 reported above. Then the IP are the energy. The IP obtained difference between the 0 2 ground-state energy and the 0,' was 563.5 eV. Direct hole-state calculations for the relevant states of O,*,with the MO constrained to be of g or u symmetry, were also carried out. For the orbital occupancy (16), the computed IP was 554.4 eV. Finally, the restriction to g and u
symmetry was relaxed, giving an IP of 542.0 eV. The latter is in good agreement with the experimental value of 543.1 eV. The interpretation of this result shows that the singly occupied 1s orbital is essentially localized on one of the two oxygen atoms. The electron affinity of 0 2 is an important quantity, and its direct calculation by Zemke et ~1.262has been carried out, from a computation of De for 0; in conjunction with the Hess cycle (17). The OVC procedure gave De(Oz) = 4.14 eV and thus EA(02) = De(OC)-De(Oz)
+ EA(0)
(17)
EA(02) = 0.42 eV, in good agreement with the experimental value of 0.440k 0.008 eV. Krauss and co-workers263have also studied various excited states of 0; by both OVC and PNO methods. All excited states were found to have Re at least 1 bohr larger than the ground state. E. F2, Fi, and q.-"he status of calculations on F2 up to 1970 has been summarized by WahL4 who, together with Das, published a six-configuration OVC wavefunction which gives a De value in good agreement with experiment.264 Minimal-basis-set CI calculations on this molecule give rather poor results,265De being too high. In a recent paper, Das and Wahl266 discuss improved techniques for the computation of MCSCF wavefunctions, and discuss briefly the case of F2. A more recent267 minimal-basis-set full CI calculation of the PE curves has been and F; (see below). published, although this paper deals primarily with the ions F,* Kasseckart26shas carried out both SCF-CI and VB-CI calculations on the ground and lower excited states of F2.The results were no better energetically for the ground state than those from much earlier work, but the location of a variety of excited states was predicted. The experimentally observed orange bands are possibly due to the L. Veseth and A. Lofthus, MoZ. Phys., 1974, 27, 51 1 . J. A. Hall, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 410. 260 Y.J. I'Haya and F. Matsuka, walnternat. J. Quantum Chem., 1973, 7 S , 181. 261 P. S. Bagus and H. F. Schaefer, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 56, 224. 262 W. T. Zemke, G. Das, and A. C. Wahl, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 14, 310. 2G3 M. Krauss, D. Neumann, A. C. Wahl, G . Das, and W Zemke, Phys. Rev., 1973, 7A, 69. 264 G. Das and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1972,56, 3532. 265 F. E. Harris and H. H. Michels, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1970, 3S, 461. s0 G. Das and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 56, 1769. 267 D. J. Ellis, K. E. Banyard, A. D. Tait, and M. Dixon, J. Phys. ( B ) , 1973, 6, 233. 268 E. Kasseckert, 2. Naturforsch., 1973, 28a, 704. 268
259
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
115
lrIut+fE; and 1ng4X: transitions. Goodisman269 has reported the results of Thomas-Fed-Dirac calculations of the one-electron energies of F2. Cederbaum et aL270have calculated the vertical ionization potentials (VIP’s) of F2 using a recently developed theory involving Green’s functions.271 Results were in good agreement with experiment, which is not the case if the VIP’s are derived via Koopman’s theorem. Calculations on FZ+have been carried out by Balint-K~rti2~2 and by Ellis and COw0rkers.26~References to previous work are given in ref. 267. Ellis et aZ.267carried out minimal-basis (STO) complete CI calculations of the PE curves. The ground state is 2r]Ig, and an energy of - 197.5625 hartree was obtained in a 4O-configuration calculation. Fa+has a shorter bond length than F2. Calculations on Fif predict it to be unbound. Balint-Kurti 272 has investigated 13 electronic states of FZ+using several different methods, with results in reasonable agreement with the two experimentally observed states. The anion Fi was also studied by Ellis et aZ.,267 but only using a small number of configurations. The results were inferior to those of Baht-Kurti and K a r ~ I u and s~~~ of Copsey et aZ.,274who used more extended basis sets. Gilbert and Wahl reported the results of near-HF calculations in 1971 for the ground and various low-lying excited states of Fa.275 6 Homonuclear Diatomic Molecules of Second and Higher Rows There have been only a few studies of these molecules, containing between 22 and 34 electrons, and the most extensive set of calculations has been on the interaction between two Ne atoms. For such species, the balance between the repulsive force due to the overlap of two neutral closed-shell atoms and the attractive dispersion force determines the position of the van der WaaIs minimum. Near-HF calculations of the repulsive curve were published several years The best a6 initio calculations, including electron correlation, produce good agreement for H e 0 2 Conway and Murrell 277 have calculated the interatomic energy for Ne2 directly from an antisymmetrized product of atomic Ne SCF wavefunctionsin the range R = 4-8 bohr. The best wavefunction was obtained using a 6s4p STO basis set. The binding energy is 20 % less than the experimental value. The dispersion energy was obtained from a multipolar expansion given by Starkschall and Gordon.278An ab initio calculation of the dispersion energy by K0chanski2~~ using a GTO basis set (including dfunctions) gave results close to the multipole-expansion results. Stevens et al.,280 using the MCSCF method, have also investigated this problem at R = 5.726, 6.0,
-
269 270
c71
273
273 274
276 277 278
279
J. Goodisman, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1972, 25, 205. L. S. Cederbaum, G. Hohlneicher, and W. von Niessen, MoZ. Phys., 1973, 26, 1405. L. S. Cederbaum, G. Hohlneicher, and W. von Niessen, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 18, 503. G. G. Ralint-Kurti, Mol. Phys., 1971, 22, 681. G. G. Balint-Kurti and M. Karplus, J. Chem. Phys., 1969, 50, 478. D. N. Copsey, J. N. Murrell, and J. G. Stamper, MoZ. Phys., 1971, 21, 193. T. L. Gilbert and A. C. Wahl, J . Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 5247. T. L. Gilbert and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,47, 3425. A. Conway and J. N. Murrell, Mol. Phys., 1974, 27, 873. G. Starkschall and R. G. Gordon, J. Chem. Phys., 1971,56, 2801. E. Kochanski, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 25, 380. W. J. Stevens, A. C. Wahl, M. A. Gardner, and A. M. Karo, J. Chem. Phys., 1974,60,2195.
116
Theoretical Chemistry
and 6.2 bohr. The results were in good qualitative agreement with the semi-empirical potential. An X, calculation of this potential has also appeared recently.281 Na2 has been investigated by the MCSCF procedure, with a computed De that is in good agreement with experiment.lS1Cl2 has been studied at near-HF leve1,275 and a complete VB-CI calculation has also been carried out by Heil et aZ.,282 using a basis of H F atomic orbitals. However, the calculated value of De was only 0.71 eV, which is only 29 % of the experimental value, and not very different from the nearHE; value of 0.87eV. Clearly, it is much more difficult to calculate this quantity accurately for second-row molecules. The ionic species CI;, Nei, and Arl were also investigated in ref. 275, and the results compared with experimental data. Finally, we mention an interesting paper dealing with P2 and PO. Mulliken and Liu283 have reported accurate SCF calculations on this molecule, with a view to examining the influence of 3d-orbitals on the bonding. At Re, the d population is -0.34 electron, and it increases markedly at smaller values of R. The increase in energy on deletion of the d-functions at Re is 2.53 eV. The calculations are compared with calculations on N2, C12, and F2. Participation of d- andf-functions in NZis smaller, but their effect on the energy is about the same (2.58 eV): in Cl2 the effect is somewhat smaller (1.61 eV). The bonding in N2 and P2 is discussed in some detail in this interesting paper. N
7 Heteronuclear Diatomic Molecules A. Rare-gas Compounds.-The recent preparation of a number of rare-gas compounds has led to a significant number of calculations on these molecules, particularly on diatomic species. The repulsive interaction and dispersion interaction between like rare-gas atoms has been dealt with above. Several years ago Matcha and Nesbet 284and Gilbertand Wahl 276 presented calculationson the species NeHe, ArHe, and NeAr. The interaction of two dissimilar rare-gas diatoms gives rise to a dipole moment, which leads to far4.r. collision-induced spectra of rare-gas mixtures. For this reason, the dipole moments of such species are of interest, but dispersion contributions are not described in the HF approximation and have to be computed by an empirical expression p = B exp (- R/p). Much more work is needed on this problem. Wahl and co-workers have reported the numerical results of OVC calculations on HeNeY240 but no detailed discussion was given. In cases like these, the H F model should yield reliable interaction potentials, since A and B are both closed systems. The interaction-energy curves for alkali metal-rare gas pairs are also of interest experimentally in scattering and radiation problems, and theoretically because of the expected reliability of the HF energy for this class of half-open-closed-shell systems. Calculations on LiHe and NaHe ( X 2 Z + , AzrI, B2C+)and their X1C+ ions have been reported by Krauss et al. 285 from R = 3 to 10 bohr. Both STO and GTO expansion bases were used, with comparable results except for theA2II state of NaHe. The variation of dipole and quadrupole moments with R was investigated. The X2Z+ curve is 281 282 283
284
285
13. D. Konowalow, P. Weinberger, J. L. Calais, and J. W. D. Connolly, Chem. Phys. Lettcm, 1972, 16, 81. T. G. Heil, S. V. O’Neil, and H. F. Schaefer, tert., Chem. Phvs. Letters, 1970, 5 , 253. R,S. Mullikeii and B. Liu, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 1971, 93, 6738. R. L. Matcha and R. K. Nesbet, Phys. Rev., 1967, 160, 72. M. Krauss, P. Maldonado, and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 54,4944.
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
117
purely repulsive, and the AZII and X1Z+curves are very similar owing to the penetration of the He within the sphere containing the 2p or 3p charge densities of Li or Na. The long-range repulsive behaviour of the B2C+ curve, compared with estimates of Ec, shows that the E(R)dependence in the region of 10 bohr is dominated by the H F repulsive curve. Chargedensity plots were presented. The long-range interaction has been studied by the MCSCF method in the case of HeH and LiHe (for R > 10 bohr).286 Results were in good agreement with Dalgarno’s estimate of a,but this is quite different from a semi-empirical result. The interactions between a rare gas and an alkali-metal ion and also between rare gas and alkaline earth dications are of interest in scattering calculations. Results have been reported for He-Lif287 and more recently for He-Be2+, using singleconfiguration SCF calculations, with a GTO bask288 There is a large discrepancy between theory and experiment for small internuclear distances, but the results are within 25 % of experiment between 0.4 and 0.8 A. The He-Li+ and He-Be2+ system has also been studied with the FSGO method.37 The computed binding energy of 1.5 x hartree was an order of magnitude larger than that found for HeH. A preliminary report of work on %He289 was followed by detailed calculations on the lowest lC+ states of BeNe and Be&, using a large GTO basi~.~90 Neither BeH, BeNe, nor BeAr were predicted to be stable. However, this paper showed that from the population analyses it should be possible to see which virtual MO’s correlate with which occupied orbitals. Also,contraction schemes for the second-row basis sets were investigated. We turn now to an interesting series of papers by Allen and co-workers on diatomic molecules containing a rare-gas atom and one of the atoms F, 0, B, or N. This work was initiated in 1966 by Allen et aZ.,291who showed by a6 initio valencebond calculations (including extensive CI) that the PE curves for the diatomics HeO, HeF, NeO, and NeF were repulsive, the least repulsion being found for HeO. However, the singly charged species should have at least one bound state, and in a subsequent paper most of the lower electronic states of Hex+ and NeX+ were investigated (X was F or N).292It was found that HeFf and NeF+ have bound 1C+ states of sufficient stability (140 and 130 kJ mol-1, respectively) that they might possibly participate in compounds such as HeF+PtF; or NeF+SbF;. However, HeN+ and NeN+ are not bound sufficientlystrongly to be likely cations. It is also expected that XeN+ will be bound. A separate paper on ArF+ and A r 0 2 9 3 showed ArO to be repulsive but ArF+ to be strongly bound ( 290 kJ mol-l), and hence ArF+PtF; might be isolable. Calculations on HeO+, NeN+, and ArO+294 show that for each of these ions De is small, but at least one stable state is predicted, which might be observed in an ionmolecule reaction. N
286
288 290
291 292
293 294
5
G. Das and A. C. Wahl, Phys. Rev., 1971,4A, 825. G. W. Catlow, M. C. R. McDowell, J. J. Kaufman, L. M. Sachs, and E. S. Chang, J. Phys. (B), 1970, 3, 833. S. W. Hamson, L. J. Massa, and P. Solomon, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 263. J. J. Kaufman and L. M. Sachs, J. Chem. Phys., 1970, 42, 3534. J. J. Kaufman, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 4880. L. C. Allen, A. M. Lesk, and R. M. Erdahl, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1966, 88, 615. J. F. Liebman and L. C. Allen, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1970, 92, 3539. J. F. Liebman and L. C. Allen, Chem. Comm., 1969, 1355. J. F. Liebman and L. C. Allen, Internut. J. Mass. Spectrometry lon Phys., 1971, 7 , 27.
118
Theoretical Chemistry
In the case of noble-gas compounds HeB+,NeB+, and ArB+, repulsive curves were c0mputed,~~5 but it was suggested that XeB+ might be bound. Finally, an extensive SCF calculation near the H F limit was reported by Liu and Schaefer for KrF and KrF+.296v297KrFf is predicted to be bound (Re = 1.68 A; De = 0.02 eV). Firstorder wavefunctions still predict KrF to be repulsive, but for KrF+, Re = 1.75 & De = 1.90 eV. The latter has been observed experimentally (D:xp> 1.58 eV) and KrSbFiz (KrF+SbFJ has been synthesized. Several molecular properties were computed in this work. More recently, potential curves for the lowest 2C+ and 211 states of XeF have been computed.29*Only a weak van der Waals attraction between Xe and F is predicted (- 0.15 kcal mol-I). This result is not consistent with the way in which a variety of experiments have been inter~reted.~g* Classification of the remaining heteroiiuclear diatomic molecules is somewhat arbitrary, and we have grouped together those molecules containing some particular electronegative element B, rather than consider isoelectronic species. B. Oxides of Elements of Groups I, 11, and 111.-LiO has been thoroughly studied recently. The PIE curves of the X z I l and A2C+states were computed using a large CI (valence shell only).299 The computed spectroscopic properties, including De,are in good agreement with the few experimental values which are known. In a later paper,sOo the problem of computing spectroscopic band intensities was reviewed in detail, and using the above wavefunctions and those computed in a similar manner for A10 (X2C+, A W , and B2C+),calculations were reported for these quantities for both molecules. One interesting observation is that there is no adequate single-configurationdescription of the 2Z,+ state of AlO. Predictions for the A2.Z-X2H system of LiO were also made by Wentink et aZ.,301using Yoshimine's wavefunction. Accurate SCF wavefunctionsfor the next alkali-metal monoxide, NaQ, have been reported for the 2 I l and 2C states, and also for the 3Cstate of NaO+ and the 3II, 3C, and l C states of NaO-.302 From the wavefunctions, several spectroscopicproperties and some thermodynamic data have been derived, particularly for several reactions involving NaQ and WaQ+. In addition to the paper cited above, dealing with AIQ, an extended DZ basis SCF calculation of the energy spectrum has been reported by S ~ h a m p sSix . ~ states ~ ~ of A10 and three of AIO+ were investigated. Correlation-energy dieerences were estimated semi-empirically. The alkaline-earth oxides are particularly interesting from a theoretical point of view, because of experimental uncertainty as to the nature of the ground state. Schaefer et al. have reported a series of calculations on Be0 which attempt to resolve J. F. Liebman and L. C. Allen, Innorg. Chem., 1972, 11, 1143. B. Liu and H. F. Schaefer, tert., J . Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 2369. 297 P. S. Bagus, B. Liu, and H . F. Schaefer, tert., J. Amer. Chem. SOC., 1972, 94, 6435. 298 D. H. Liskow, H. F. Schaefer, tert., P. S. Bagus, and B. Liu, J . Anier. Chem. SOC., 1973, 95, 4056. 299 M. Yoshimine. J . Chern. Phys., 1972, 57, 1108. 300 M. Yoshirnine, A. D. McLean, and B. Liu, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 4412. 301 T. Wentink, jun., and R. J. Spindler, jun., J . Quant. Spectroscopy Radiative Transfer, 1973,13, 595. 302 P. A. G. O'Hare and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 56,4516. 303 J. Schamps, Chern. Physcis, 1973, 2, 352. a'J5
2y6
119
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
earlier conflicting predictions. In the first paper,304 a first-order wavefunction for the lowest 1C+state was obtained using a contracted STO basis of DZ P quality. The calculated E = - 89.58455 hartree leads to De = 6.58 eV compared with the experimental value of 6.69 k 0.04 eV. All of the most important configurations involve the valence orbitals, and in particular the . . . 5021n2configuration is not as important as suggested in some earlier work. In a second paper,305 an investigation of the 3C- and low-lying 3C+ states with the same type of wavefunction was carried out. The 3X- state is repulsive and the (unobserved) 3C+state is predicted to lie 1.91 eV above the X1C+ state, and a variety of spectroscopic constants were calculated. In the third paper,306 the other possible contender for the ground state, the 3 l l state, was investigated. The authors show this state to be 0.73 eV above the lX+ state. This result is in contrast to that of a near-HF calculation,307where E(311)< E(lX+), and emphasizes the crucial role of electron correlation in determining the order of these states. A further calculation of the 3C- state confirmed it to be repulsive. It seems clear that the most obvious difference between Be0 and the isoelectronic C2 is that the 3X- state of the latter is attractive. It is also of interest that the 3C- state of the isoelectronic BN is bound but only 0.3 eV above the 311 state.308 MgO, the next oxide in this series, has been the subject of numerous experimental and theoretical studies. An extensive series of calculations at the SCF level for six differentconfigurations was reported by Schamps and Lefebvre-Bri~n,~O~ who give references to earlier work. These calculations used an extended DZ basis set and are consequently more accurate than previous work. The HF calculations predict a 311ground state, which is the same as found for CaO, but as noted above, CI might well reverse this ordering, and it is clear that very extensive calculations are needed before this question is definitely settled. A very recent paper reporting PE curves for BeO, Mgo, and CaO, using DZ P basis sets, has also appeared,3lO and the authors also discuss the dissociation behaviour of the ground state. Calculation of the spin-orbit matrix elements shows that 3II and lC+ states are not significantly mixed. Be0 has also been the subject of an OVC calculation by Wahl et aZ.,240 but full results have not appeared. C. Metal Oxides of Other Groups.-Despite the large number of electrons, some of these have been recently studied. The 90-electron molecule PbO has been studied with a minimal basis set in order to assess the importance of relativistic effects in such calculations.311Since for 2 = 82(Pb) relativistic energies are expected to be large (for the atom, = 1390 hartree), this molecule is an ideal test case, and comparison with CO, which has the same electronic structure in its vaIence shell, was carried out. The errors in the calculated De are comparable, and the predicted
+
+
Ez
304
306 307
308 309 310 311
H. F. Schaefer, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 176. S. V. O’Neil, P. K. Pearson, and H. F. Schaefer, tert., Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 10, 404. P. K. Pearson, S. V. O’Neil, and H. F. Schaefer, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 56, 3938. W. M. Huo, K. F. Freed, and W. Klemperer, J. Chem. Phys., 1967, 46, 3556. M. P. Melrose and D. Russell, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 470. H. Schamps and H. Lefebvre-Brion, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 56, 573. N. J. Stagg and W. G. Richards, Mol. Phys., 1974, 27, 787. G. M. Schwenzer, D. H. Liskow, H. F. Schaefer, tert., P. S. Bagus, B. Liu, A. D. McLean, and M. Yoshimine, J. Chern. Phys., 1973, 58, 3181.
120
Theoretical Chemistry
spectroscopic constants are in about as good agreement with experiment as in the case of CO. Thus the authors conclude that this type of wavefunction might well be useful for predictions of geometry. A near-HF calculation of the low-lying states of FeO has also appeared.312 Once again, experimental evidence is ambiguous on the ground-state configuration. Limited CI calculations were also carried out on various states, and extensive CI on the lowest 5X+state. It was concluded that this state is not the ground state, and at the moment the nature of this state is not completely clear. D. Non-metal Oxides.-CO, SiO, and CS. The literature on CO is very extensive, and much early work is discussed in ref. 1, together with an analysis of recent extensive calculations on the valence excited states. O’Neil and Schaefer313 carried out minimal-basis full CI calculations on 72 states of CO at nine values of R . Seventeen bound states were predicted, eight of which have been observed experimentally, and the ordering is in agreement with experiment except for the a3II and Aln states. Very detailed information is available in this investigation. Siu and Davidson,314 at about the same time, reported what is currently the most accurate ground-state wavefunction of CO, with a very large CI calculation. 70 of the correlation energy was obtained. The most important configurations were used to obtain the natural geminals. A pair-energy approach to the correlation energy gave significantly different results. Green16 has recently reviewed the accurate calculation of dipole moments, and, in a series of papers from 1970-1973, studied CO and CS. A large RHF calculation of the PE curve and the incorrect dissociation behaviour were discussed315before a series of papers dealing with CI calculations. A procedure for selecting <200 configurations based on perturbation theory was developed,316 and the computed dipole moment was then within 0.01 D of the experimental value. It should be recalled that the RHF value has the wrong sign. In later papers the open-shell a311state of CO was investigated,317 particularly the effect of the quality of the basis set.318It was shown that a CI function will contain essentiallythe same error due to the choice of basis set as the SCF function upon which it is based. The best calculation gave an error for this state of 0.06D. More recently, the a’3X+ state was investigated.31g Results were 0.4D differentfrom experimental ones, and the possible reason for this was given. An interesting recent study of the perturbations of the a311 and AlII states of CO due to spin-orbit and rotational-orbit interactions has a~peared.3~0 By including CI functions built from HF orbitals optimized for each state, good agreement was obtained between theory and experiment in most cases, but the single-configuration approximation is seriously in error. Gaussian basis calculationson diatomics have been rather rare, but Vladimiroff321 312 313 314 315
316
317 319 s20
821
P. S. Bagus and H. J. T. Preston, J. Chern. Phys., 1973, 59, 2986. S. V. O’Neil and H. F. Schaefer, tert., J. Chem Phys., 1970, 53, 3994. A. K. Q. Siu and E. R. Davidson, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1970, 4, 223. S. Green, J. Chem. Phys., 1970, 52, 3100. S. Green, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 54, 827. S. Green, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 56, 739. S. Green, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 2830. S . Green, Ado. Chem. Phys., 1974, 25, 179. J. A. Hall, J. Schamps, J. M. Robbe, and H. Lefebvre-Brion, J . Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 3271. T. Vladimiroff, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 24, 340.
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
121
has reported the results of a (9s5p)+ [4s3p] calculation on CO using Is, 2pz, and 2py functions centred within the bonding region. By optimization of the exponents and the position of the centre, an energy lower than that obtained in an earlier calculation with a more extensive basis322 was obtained, but one-electron properties were not quite so accurate. Green317 has also reported calculations on CS, both for the ground and A l I I excited states. Agreement between theory and experiment for p was very good for both states. Spin-spin and spin-orbit constants for CO have been investigated using semiempirical methods, for states which can be described by a single configuration.323 SCF calculations on CO and CO+ have been reported by Certain et aZ.,324who computed a dipole moment of 2.5 f0.5 D and discussed the differences between the value in CO, CO+, and CN. GVB calculations on CO have been reported.325 SO has been studied relatively little, although a near-HF wavefunction was obtained in 1967.326 The PE curves for 72 states have been investigated by Heil and Schaefer.327 In these a minimal STO basis was used with full CI, with results very similar to those described above for CO. The limitations of minimal-basis full CI have been summarized by Schaefer,l but the method does yield reliable PE curves. The predicted ordering of the state is X1X+, a3H7d 3 C + ,3A, $2, PC-, AlH, 1A, 6E+, and 511.This paper illustrates how useful such calculationscan be in analysingspectra. NO, NO+,and PO. Until quite recently there had been few theoretical studies of the X2n state of NO, although unpublished calculations by Cade have been quoted. Using these near-HF wavefunctions, Politzer and Harris328 have computed the electron-densitydistribution in NO and NO+ and analysed the bonding in these molecules. The NO difference density was also computed. Comparison with the isoelectronic 0; shows there to be less charge in the internuclear region in NO. In the case of CO the increased charge build-up in this region and the localization of charge in lone pairs also explains the higher value of De. NO+ has a substantially altered charge distribution, with much greater concentration in the internuclear region, and this is in accordance with its stronger bond. Kouba and ohm have gone beyond the SCF approximation and calculated a limited CI wavefunction, using NS0.329The lowest energy obtained was - 129.2599 hartree. This is still above the estimated HF limit. The computed dipole moment of 0.121 D is in fair agreement with the experimental value of 0.148 D. The spin density at the two nuclei was also computed. A more extensive study was carried out by Green.s3O Using a large STO basis, both ground X 2 n and excited A2X+ states were studied. The calculated energy is -0.05 hartree above the RHF limit, and computed properties were in reasonable agreement with experiment (within 10%). However, a later limited CI study331 gave better spin 322
323 324 325 326
327
328 329
330 881
D. B. Neumann and J. W. Moskowitz, J. Chem. Phys., 1969,50, 2216. R. W. Field and H. Lefebvre-Brion, Acta Phys., 1974, 35, 51. P. R. Certain and R. C. Woods, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 5837. A. P. Mortola and W. A. Goddard, tert., J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1974, 96, 1. A. D. McLean and M. Yoshimine, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1967, lS, 313. T. G. Heil and H. F. Schaefer, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 56, 958. P. Politzer and R. R. Harris, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1970, 92, 1834. J. E. Kouba and Y . Ohm, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1971, 5, 539. S. Green, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 13, 552. S. Green, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 23, 115.
122
fieoretical Chemistry
densities for the 2C+ state, but the dipole moment and quadrupole coupling constant are not in good agreement with experiment. NO+ is also a molecule that was relatively little studied until recently. An SCF calculation of the quadrupole moment giving a value in reasonable agreement with experiment has been reported;3s2and a more detailed OVC wavefunction was computed by B i l l i n g ~ l e y in~order ~ ~ to calculate the absolute i.r. intensities for the 0-1, 0-2, and 1-2 vibration-rotation transitions. Thulstrup and have computed full PE curves for NO and NO+, using a minimal basis set and full CI. Assignments were presented for the photoelectron spectra, and were in reasonable agreement with experiment. Theoretical studies of PO have been carried out recently by Mulliken and Liu,2*3 who obtained a wavefunctionclose to the Hartree-Fock limit. An investigation of the Rydberg states has also been rep0rted.3~~ The first calculations using CI were those of Tseng and who have studied a variety of PE curves for the low-lying 211, 4l7, 2X+, 2C-, 4E-, 2A, and 2@ states. A minimal STO basis and full valence-shell CI were used. The relative positions of the states agree well with experiment, and several predictions were made for as yet unobserved states. Roche and Lefebvre-Brion 337 have also recently investigated PO, performing valence-shell CI calculations for several states, including several also studied by Tseng and Grein.336 Spin-orbit coupling constants for the 2IT states showed a larger variation with R than does the experimental constant for the first excited 2n state. Schaefer et al. also investigated PO in their work on the representation of valence orbitals using contracted C T O ’ S . ~ ~ ~ C10 and FO. Interest in these species has stimulated near-HF calculations by O’Hare and Wah1.338~339 Using previously developed methods for estimating the correlation energy, the binding energy of FO was estimated to be 3.0 eV, in fair agreement with experimental estimates. Calculations on OF+(3C), OF(211), and OF-(lC) allowed estimates of the VIP and EA.338 Similarcalculationsfor ClO and its ions were reported in a later paper.339 Calculated properties were in good agreement with experimental data where available: however, in common with many recent calculations on unstable species, a great many of the properties stand as predictions. E. Halides.-Metal Halides. E.s.r. spectra of various diatomic fluorides in 2C states have been observed, such as MgF, CaF, SrF, and BaF.340Ab initio calculations on these species should be of interest. The alkali-metal fluoride wavefunctions previously rep0rted3~69341 have been used to calculate the electric field gradient in these and other halides by Laplante and Bandrauk.342 It was found that simple models can give unreliable predictions, and a detailed analysis of the contributing terms was
-
332 333 334 335 33fi
337 338 339
340 341 342
Ch. Jungen and H. Lefebvre-Brion, J. Mol. Spectroscopy, 1970, 33, 520. F. P. Billingsley, tert., Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 23, 160. E. W. Thulstrup and Y . Ohm, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 3716. F. Ackermann, H. Lefebvre-Brion, and A. L. Roche, Canad. J. Phys., 1972, 50, 692. T. J. Tseng and F. Grein, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 6563. A. L. Roche and H. Lefebvre-Brion, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 1914. P. A. G. O’Hare and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1970, 53, 2469. P. A. G . O’Hare and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 54, 3770. L. B. Knight, jun., W. C . Easley, W. Weltner, jun., and M. Wilson, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 54, 322. A. D. McLean and M. Yoshimine, supplement to I.B.M. J. Res. Develop., 1968, 12, 206. J.-P. Laplante and A. D. Bandrauk, Canad. J. Chem., 1974, 52, 2143.
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
123
made. There is a differencebetween the behaviour of c- and n-electrons, exchange distortions of the o-electrons are important, and also polarization of the n-electrons. The photoelectron spectra of AlCl and GaCl were interpreted in terms of NO'S computed both by ab initiu and semi-empiricalmethods.343 LiF, being the simplest fluoride, has been extensivelystudied, and in a recent paper Williams and Streitweiser344 have examined the effect of variation in the size of the basis set on the charge distribution and molecular properties in SCF calculations. The basis sets used ranged from a minimal (STO4G) to a Ss4p GTO set on F, 8s on Li, to which was added lithium 2po and 2pn functions and a set of 3d functions on F. It was shown that the minimal basis set overweights Li and gives unrealistic bond properties. In extended basis sets, the inclusion of 3d functions polarizes the electron density from behind F towards Li. It is encouraging to note that the basis without 3d functions on F gives reliable values for the bond length, force constant, and dipole moment. Comparison with the near-HF wavefunction was made. Classical VB theory has been relatively neglected because of the orthogonality problem until quite recently, However, computational methods have been recently proposed for evaluating the relative matrix elements more efficiently,and Carrington and Walton have investigated the molecule TiF3+ using a limited number of chemically significant structures.345 It was necessary to devise and use a pseudopotentialfor the core electrons in order to handle these, and to use a STO-GTO expansion to simplify the integral computations. Comparison of the results with conventionalSCF calculations shows that the method is competitiveregarding computing time and has an additional advantage that the excited triplet- and singlet-state wavefunctions are also obtained. Minimum-basis-set (STO) calculations on GaF were reported in 1970 by Stevenson and Lipscomb.346 Halides of B, C, and Si. Recent work has been confined to the fluorides of C and Si. CF has been the subject of a near-HF calculation by O'Hare and Wah1,347together with CF+ and CF-. Spectroscopic constants were evaluated and compared with experiment. One interesting result is that the dipole moment of CF was computed to be 0.48 D, with polarity C-F+. This surprising result needs confirming by MCSCF calculations, because although near-HF dipole moments can be in error if p is small, i.e. CO, it is estimated that an error of 0.5 D in these calculations is unlikely. The sign is not determined experimentally. It is noteworthy that BF is also predicted to be B-F+, with ,uz 1 D. The correlation energies of the first-row diatomic fluorides were also deduced in this study. LCAO-MO-SCF calculations on the ground state and several low-lying states were carried out later by Hall and Richards.348 The basis set used was not as large, but the sign of the dipole moment was confirmed. The computed spin-orbit coupling in the ground state was in good agreement with experiment. The related molecule SiF was also studied by Wahl and co-workers, and its properties were computed.347 In this case p = 1.20 D (Si+F-), which is substantially less than the value for SiO (3.40 D) despite the fact that R(SiO) < R(SiF). A later 343
s44 s45 346 347
848
J. Berkowitz and J. L. Dehmer, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 3194. J. E. Williams and A. Streitweiser, jun., Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 25, 507.
P. J. Carrington and P. G . Walton, Mol. Phys., 1973, 26, 705. p. E. Stevenson and W. N. Lipscomb, J. Chem. Phys., 1970, 52, 5343. P. A. G. O'Hare and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 666. J. A. Hall and W. G. Richards, Mof. Phys., 1972, 23, 331.
124
Theoretical Chemistry
paper examined the computed PE curves obtained using a faster computer.349The computed dipole moments d8er by several per cent for the computed Re, compared with those at RFP. Goddard has also computed GVB wavefunctions for CF, but details are not a~ai1able.l~ However, the GVB wavefunctionswere compared with those of CH, and it was shown that additional repulsive interactions with the lone pairs on F should make the state of CF much more strongly bound than the *Z- state. (The calculated AEs 2.8-2.9 eV.) Fluorides of N, P, S, Se, and As. Extended-basis-set near-HF calculations on the X 3 Z - , alA, and blX+ states of NF and the 211states of NF+ and NF- were reported by O’Hare and Wahl in 1971.350N F is isoelectronic with 0 2 and has similar lowlying excited states. The calculations were carried out at e P for the neutral molecules. Values of De derived with the use of semi-empirical correlation energies were in excellent agreement with experiment. The dipole moments of the low-lying states are different, unlike the case of NH, because of variations in bond length. The NF bond is slightly more ionic than the NH bond. Results for PF and its ions were also discussed.350Little is known about this species experimentally. CI calculations on NF and NF+ have been reported by Anderson and Full PE curves were computed, using a full CI with a minimal STO basis set. The X3Z- energy was substantially higher than the near-HF result, despite the CI. The computed value of De (3.6 eV) obtained by Wahl et a2.850 is also different from that obtained by Anderson (2.2 ev). The predicted IP of 9.7 eV is much lower than the experimental value or the value obtained by Wahl(l3 ev). Several predictions were made, but since the wavefunctionis not as good as the near-HF function, one would tend to trust the latter. Very similar calculations on NF and NF- were also reported by Ellis et uZ.267 However, the above 3 sets of workers used slightly different values of Re for computing properties. The energies attained by Anderson et aZ.351 and by Ellis et aZ.,2e7 as well as the properties, are, however, almost the same. The bond length of NF- is slightly longer than in NF. However, only Anderson and Ellis have so far studied the low-lying excited states. PF was also studied, and the PE curves were calculated, together with the electron affinity and dipole moment, in the calculations of ref. 349.
SF, SeF, and AsF. These diatomics have only recently been synthesized, and there have been no calculations prior to 1970, when Wahl and co-workers reported nearHF wave function^.^^^ In the light of the known accuracy of these, it is suggested that the experimental appearance potentials are too high by 2 eV. Thermodynamic calculations suggest that SF- and SeF- might be moderately stable. A later, more extensive study of the PE curves of SF has appeared.349 A large number of predictions were made for the spectroscopic constants. A very recent PE curve has been computed for SeF and its ions.353 The value of D Ois estimated to be 3.2k0.1 eV. The computed p is significantly different from the experimental value. The AsF mole-
-
349
350 952 355
P. A. G. O’Hare, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 3842. P. A. G. O’Hare and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1971,54,4563. A. Anderson and Y. Ohm, J. Mol. Spectroscopy, 1973,45, 358. P. A. G. O’Hare and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1970,53, 2834. P. A. G. O’Hare, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60,4084.
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
125
cule has also been the subject of recent near-HF calculation~.~5~ The wavefunctions were used to computeideal-gas thermodynamicfunctions for AsF in this investigation. F. Nitrides and Carbides.-A number of recent papers have dealt with BN, which was studied some years ago by Verhaegen et al.355 The lZ+, lIT, 3rI, and 3Zf states were investigated, and computed bond lengths obtained. The 3rI state is the ground state. The 1C+ excited state was studied by Moffat using three GTO basis sets of different quality.356 The computed bond length decreases as the size of the basis set goes up, the computed value being in good agreement with experiment for the (9,5) basis, although the energy is -0.08 hartree above the HF limit. Two papers by MeIrose and Russell have dealt with the excited s t a t e ~ . ~ 358 ~7~ Extensive calculations of the PE curves of a large number of states of CN have been carried out by O’Neil and Schaefer.359 A number of as yet unobserved states were predicted, using a minimal basis set and full CT. Configurations differing by up to 7 orbitals from the reference configuration were included. The calculated order of the eight known doublet states agrees with experiment, and it is thus likely that the positions of the unobserved states are correctly predicted. It is interesting that recent experimental work has determined the hyperfine, p-doubling, and rotational constants from observation of the CN molecule in an interstellar cloud.360 The dipole moment of the a2rI state has also recently been measured.861 CN- has been studied by Doggett and M~Kendrick,3~~ and one-electronproperties have been computed and listed in a later paper.363 The structure of CN- was also discussed in a review by Clementi.364 NS is an unstable radical, which has recently been investigated by O’Hare, together with its ions.365The EA was also computed in this work. The diatomic BC has been studied by Kouba and h n . 3 6 6 The ground state is *Z-, according to calculations using full-valence-shell CI. 54 low-lying states were investigated. G. InterhaIogens.-ClF is the most extensively studied of these molecules, and several calculations have been reported recently. Guest et al.,367 using a STO-GTO expansion basis, calculated Re = 1.67 a (expt.: 1.628 A) but gave no total energy. Breeze et al.36salso carried out an SCF calculation at RYP, using a moderatssize basis. They obtained a total energy of - 557.306 hartree in their most extensive calculation. 354 355 356 357 358 359 860
381 864
363 3G4 365 366 3G7 368
P. A. G.O’Hare, A. Batana, and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 6495. G. Verhaegen, W.G. Richards, and C. M. Moser, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,46,160. J. B. Moffat, J. Mol. Structure, 1973, 16, 307. M.P. Melrose and D. Russell, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 470. M. P. Melrose and D. Russell, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 2586. T. G. O’Neil and H. F. Schaefer, tert., J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 54, 2573. A. A. Penzias, R. W. Wilson, and K. B. Jefferts, Phys. Rev. Letters, 1974, 32, 701. T. J. Cook and D. H. Levy,J. Chern. Phys., 1973,59,2387. G . Doggett and A. McKendrick, J . Chem. Soc. ( A ) , 1970, 825. M. Dixon and G. Doggett, J.C.S. Fnraday 11, 1973, 69,298. E. Clementi, in ‘ElectronicStructure of Molecules, Especially in Cyano Compounds’, Ch. 1 of the book ‘C=N’, Interscience, New York, 1970. P. A. G.O’Hare, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 54, 4124, J. E. Kouba and Y . Ohrn, J. Chem. Phys., 1970,53, 3923. M. F. Guest, M. B. Hall, and I. H. Hillier, J.C.S. Furuduy 11, 1973, 69, 182. A. Breeze, D. W. J. Cruickshank, and D. R. Armstrong, J.C.S. Faraday II, 1972, 68, 2144.
126
Theoretical Chemistry
The dipole moment is very sensitive to the basis set, but the largest basis gives polarity CI+F-. The 3d-orbital exponent was optimized in these calculations. Green,36ghowever, carried out a much bigger calculation, since experimentally the direction of the dipole was found to be Cl-Ff. The computed value in Green’s calculation was 1 .OW, with polarity Cl+F-, and other spectroscopic properties were in moderate agreement with experiment. It was concluded that the experimental sign is in error. In his review of errors in dipole-moment calculation,l6 Green has reported CI calculations of p, including single and double excitations. The value p = 0.84 D was obtained, with a positive value, i.e. Cl+F-. Evidence that delta orbitals are important was presented. The 200-configuration CI wavefunction gave an energy of - 559.1112 hartree, which is 2 hartree lower than in Breeze’s calculation. A calcufation using a larger basis set (30o18n)gave an SCF error of 0.0017 hartree and changed p by only 0.1 D. Hence it is clear that the experimental sign of p(CIF) is incorrect. An approximate SCF method treating only the bonding electrons but allowing split shell orbitals, and using approximate integrals, has been reported and applied to the interhal0gens.3~~ Rather good agreement with experiment was found, using only one adjustable parameter. A much more extensive study of diatomic halides, interhalogens, and halogen hydrides has been described by Straub and McLean.571 DZ + P basis sets were used for all molecules except IBr and 12, where single zeta + polarization basis sets were used. The expected errors in basis sets of this kind for computations on molecules containing heavy atoms were described. Total energies were used to compute dissociation energies and enthalpies. The computed Re values were in satisfactory agreement with experiment. Several properties were computed with fairly high accuracy. This series of calculations again emphasized the usefulness of near-HF SCF wavefunctions. The disagreement between theory and experiment over p (hence the charge distribution) has been further studied by measurement of the core binding energies in ClF,372 where the results are consistent with the charge distribution Cl+F-. H. Miscellaneous Calculations on Diatomic Molecules.-A variety of more approximate treatments have been tested on diatomics. Naray-Szabo has tested a method for approximate H F calculations373 (in which the integrals are approximated) in applications to various first-row diatomics. The results were reasonable for non-polar molecules but the method fails for molecules where the atoms have very different 2, i.e. Be0 and BeF, amongst others, did not give a minimum in the PE curve. An interesting molecule that has been little studied is SiS lZ+,which should be similar to the isovalent CO, CS, and SiQ. BA P calculations at Re by GreenI6 give a value of /A that is -0.5 D larger than the experimental value. The diatomic molecules PN and PC were also studied by Bauschlicher and S~haefer.~ls In concluding this section, we draw attention to a paper by Roby,374 who has
-
+
ntiq
370 371 372
373 37*
S. Green, J. Cliem. Phys., 1973, 58, 3117. A. B. Sannigrahi and S. Noor Mohamrnad, Zitternat. J. Quantum Cliem., 1973, 7 , 1183. P. A. Straub and A. D. McLean, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1972, 32, 227.
T. X. Carroll and T. D. Thomas, J. Chem. Phys., 1974,60, 2186. G.NAray-Szab6, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1973,7 , 569. K. R. Roby, Mol. Phys., 1974, 27, 81.
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
127
examined in detail the question of the definition of a charge in a molecule, and has examined several diatomic molecules using the results of HF calculations. Extensive references to earlier work on this topic are given in this paper. 8 Linear Triatomic Molecules The past three years have seen considerable advances in the study of the electronic structure of triatomic molecules, and calculations of comparable accuracy to those reported on diatomics are now feasible. Calculations of PE surfaces are dealt with elsewhere in this volume, and in this section we deal with calculations on isolated molecules. An extensive compilation of the wavefunctions of linear molecules was published several years and a great many recent calculations have attempted to extend the list of molecules for which near-HF wavefunctions are available. Furthermore, in a certain number of cases, wavefunctions including electron correlation have been obtained. We will consider linear and non-linear molecules separately. A. He/H2 and &.-It is convenient to consider first these species. Tsapline and Kutzelnigg375 have applied the IEPA-PNO method, previously described, to the ground state of the He/H2 system. The van der Waals minimum was computed, using a gaussian lobe basis set with carefully optimized exponents. The collinear arrangement with a depth of 21 K was found for the van der Waals minimum, with a saddle point of -14K for the CzVgeometry. The computed surface was compared with experiment and with the term. The anisotropy of the potential is larger than that predicted asymptotically. Knowledge of an accurate H3 potential surface is of considerable importance, and accurate wavefunctions have been obtained during the past few years. Goddard, in 1969,112reported SOGI calculations for several nuclear configurations, and showed H+H H2 reaction. that the spin coupling changes significantly during the H2 Changes in the orbitals were studied, and it is apparent that the orbitals change continuously during the course of the reaction.l1° Approximate non-empirical calculations on H3 were in good agreement with early ab initio calculations.79 The most accurate calculations reported to date are those of Liu.376, 377 In 1973, a very large CI calculation was reported using a large STO basis set for the linear species. The calculated surface was believed to lie between 0.8 and 3.4 kJ mol-1 above the exact surface. These calculations also are a landmark in computational work. B. Hydrides AH2.-HeHi has been investigated at SCF level, using a CGTO basis set. The ground-state PE surface was computed in this work.378 The semi-empirical diatomics-in-moleculesmethod 379 has been used to study the PE surface of linear HeHl,380 and later it was further used in studies of a variety of fist-row hydrides, including linear B ~ H ZBeH2 . ~ ~has ~ been rather extensively
+
375 376 =?? 378 379
380
881
B. Tsapline and W. Kutzelnigg, Chern. Phys. Letters, 1974, 23, 173. B. Liu, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1971, 5, 123. B. Liu, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 1925. P. J. Brown and E. F. Hayes, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 922. F. 0. Ellison, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 1963, 85, 3540. P. J. Kuntz, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 16, 581. J. C . Tully, J. Chem. Phys., 1963, 58, 1396.
+
128
Theoretical Chemistry
studied recently, following an extended GTO basis-set calculation in 1968.382The ground state was also investigated with the IEPA method by Ahlrichs and Kutzelnigg,383who investigated the physical properties and predicted experimental conditions under which it might be observed. A later paper dealt with the inter- and intrapair correlation energies.121 There have been a few VB calculations on this molecule, particularly since the recent advances in computer capability make the problem of non-orthogonality of the orbitals less serious. Maclagan and Schnuelle384 have reported the results of a minimal-basis STO calculation, including all configurations which do not involve excitation of the Be core electrons. Comparison with a MO calculation was made. A VB equivalent to the CND0/2 method was proposed. Gallup e f d 3 8 5 have also carried out a similar calculation and proposed a population analysis scheme for VB wavefunctions. Other calculations on BeH2 by these workers have appeared.1l6-1l8 Further comparative calculations by both VB and MO methods on BeH2 have been reported, using a minimal STO basis, with exponents optimized for various R.386With choice of particular VB configurations, it is shown that a model based on the resonance valence state, including ionic configurations, is particularly useful. Both methods show a localized-pair bond description to be useful. The most recent large calculation on BeH2 is a large CI calculation by Hosteny and Hagstrom,387 who obtained a total energy of - 15.8478 hartree, which accounts for 55% of the correlation energy. An STO basis set was used and a discussion of the wavefunction was given. LiH2 has been discussed by Kahn and Goddard, using GVB w a v e f ~ n c t i o n s . ~ ~ ~ C. Compounds of the Inert Gases.-Several groups have examined theoretically whether species such as HeO2, HeO:, KrF2, XeF2, and Be2+He2are expected to be stable. Matrix-isolation spectroscopy prompted theoretical studies of ion-induced dipole clusters, and Be2+He2in particular is predicted to have a stable linear configurati0n.~8*These calculations, using a large GTO basis set, gave a near-HF wavefunction, and D e z 74.3 kJ mol-l. It should be interesting to see if this prediction is borne out experimentally. The compound KrF2 is of great importance in the chemistry of krypton, and the nature of the binding is a challenge to the theoretical chemist. Early calculations at the minimal-basis-set level were reported by Collins et a p 9 ,390 using STO-3G expansions. Extra valence orbitals were added to the basis set. Electron-density plots showed the three-centre nature of the bond. A much more extensive set of calculationswere carried out by Bagus et a1.,s91 who calculated both SCF and first-order wavefunctions, the latter with up to 993 configurations. The best energy was considerably lower than that obtained by Collins 382
383 384 385 386 387 388
389 390 391
J. J. Kaufman, L. M. Sachs, and M. Geller, J. Chem. Phys., 1968, 49, 4369. R. Ahlrichs and W. Kutzelnigg, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1968, 10, 377. R. G. A. R. Maclagan and G . W. Schnuelle, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 5431. G . A. Gallup and J. M. Norbeck, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 21, 495. K. A. R. Mitchell and T. Thirunamachandran, Mol. Phys., 1972, 23, 947. R. P. Hosteny and S. A. Hagstrom, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 4396. S. W. Harrison, L. J. Massa, and P. Solomon, Chem. Phys. Letters. 1972, 16, 57. G . A. D. Collins, D. W. J. Cruickshank, and A. Breeze, Chem. Comm., 1970, 884. G. A. D. Collins, D. W.J. Cruickshank, and A. Breeze, J.C.S. Faraday 11, 1974,70, 393. P. S. Bagus, B. Liu, and H. F. Schaefer, tert., J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1972, 94, 6635.
129
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
et al. It was also shown, as expected, that polarization functions are much less important than suggested by Collins. The SCF result shows that KrF2 is unstable with respect to dissociation into Kr F2, but the CI calculation corrects this. The best calculation gives reasonable values for R(Kr-F), but De is only ca. 3 of the experimental value. The most interesting feature of the PE curve is the prediction of a maximum, which results from avoided crossing of an attractive ionic and a repulsive covalent curve. The details of the binding were very dependent on electron-correlation effects. This calculation illustrates very well the usefulness of ab initio calculations on unusual molecules. XeF2 was first investigated by ab initio SCF calculations in 1971, using a limited basis ~et.89~ Population analyses of the wavefunction were compared with experimental ESCA binding energies in a paper by Carroll ef a1.393 There are several puzzling features, since the derived fluorine charges seem too small compared with calculations. Calculations using an extended basis set are needed here. D. The Bihalide Ions .-Spectroscopic observations on these species have been made, but there are a number of interesting and unresolved questions which theoretical calculations should be able to clarify. Matrix-isolation studies are in disagreement as to whether vacuum-u.v. photolysis of HCl in an argon matrix produces ClHCl or the ClHCl- anion.394 Semi-empirical studies of hydrogen bonding have been 396 but recently some extensive ab initio calculations have appeared. Almlof 397 has investigated using a large GTO basis for the linear configuration. Calculated properties were in good agreement with experiment, and the symmetricconfiguration was found to be the most stable. A more extensive basis set was used by Noble and K o r t z e b ~ r n who , ~ ~ ~also investigated linear HF2 and HeF2. The calculations predicted a weak (- 13 kJ mol-l) bond in HF2 and a long F a * H Fbond. HeF2 was predicted to be an unstable repulsive state. A more recent study of ClHCl- has appeared, by JanoshekY3g9 who varied both C1. * *C1and the position of H. He calculated the energy levels, frequencies,and various other observables. Results were in reasonable agreement with experiment. A more extensive investigation recently by Clark et al.40° has attempted to resolve this question. Calculationswith a DZ P STO basis set show ClHCl- to be bound, unlike ClHCl, with a nearly symmetric hydrogen bond. E. HAB Molecules.-The most common and extensively studied of these is HCN. Near-HF wavefunctions were computed some years agoY34lbut Doggett and coworkers 362s 363 have reported DZ basis calculations on HCN, using approximations for some of the integrals. Various one-electron properties were computed, and
+
m-
-
+
a02
s93
H. Basch, J. W. Moskowitz, C. Hollister, and D. Hankin, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 1922. T. X. Carroll, R. W. Shaw,jun., T. D. Thomas, C. Kindle, and N. Bartlett, J . Amer. Chem. SOC.,
1974,96, 1989. For references see A. J. Downs and S. C. Peake in ‘Molecular Spectroscopy’, ed. R. F. Barrow, D. A. Long, and D. J. Millen (Specialist Periodical Reports), The Chemical Society, London, 1973, Vol. 1, Ch. 9. s95 G. J. Jiang and G. R. Anderson, J. Phys. Chem., 1973, 77, 1764. s96 G. J. Jiang and G . R. Anderson, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 3258. 397 J. Almlof, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 17, 49. Sg8 P. N. Noble and R. N. Kortzeborn, J. Chem. Phys., 1970,52,5375. 399 R. Janoschek, Theor. Chim. A d a , 1973, 29, 57. 400 D. A. Clark. C. Thomson, and T. C. Waddington, to be published. 394
130
Theoretical Chemistry
except for the electric field gradient they were in reasonable agreement with experiment. Absar and McEwen 401 have also employed all-valence-electroncalculations to study various non-linear excited states of HCN. The isomer of HNC has been rather neglected until recently, apart from semiempirical studies,*02but, following the reported detection of an emission from HNC from a galactic source, Pearson et aZ.403 carried out ab initia calculations with a DZ + P quality GTO basis set. The predicted geometries and properties of both HCN and HNC were given. Furthermore, first-order wavefunctions (6343 configurations) were also computed. The computed HCN geometry was in excellent agreement with experiment, and therefore the predicted bond lengths in HNC of R(H-N) = 0.995 A and R ( N - 4 ) = 1.169 A are believed to be reliable to within -0.003 A. The calculated value of Be of 90.48 GHz was within 0.2 % of the ‘experimental’value. Hyperfine structure of the line was also computed. A new method for obtaining SCF orbitals has been described by Davids~n.~O~ In this msthod, a particular form of the orbitals is derived, known as the internally consistent SCF orbitals (ICSCF). In contrast to the usual canonical SCF orbitals, the sum of the orbital energies bt is equal to the total energy, and the values of bt - &j are expected to be close to the excitation energies for transitions between valence orbitals. Stenkamp and Davidson investigated4o5HCN and a variety of other triatomics by this method, and also AH2 species, studying particularly the equilibrium bond angle. The resulting orbital-energy diagrams were similar in appearance to those derived from canonical orbitals, and also the ICSCF valence-orbital energy sum correlates better with the equilibrium bond angle than the sum of the canonical orbital energies. A recent paper by Schwenzeret aL4o6has outlined a novel approach to calculations on a variety of excited states that is applicable to several states of the same symmetry. After selecting a physically meaningful set of orbitals appropriate to the various states, and a single-configuration reference function for the state in question, CI is performed, including all configurations differing by one orbital from any one of the selected reference states. Detailed predictions for 12 low-lying states of HCN were made, and compared with experiment and the Walsh diagrams. It was concluded that the experimental assignment of the @A” state was wrong. Where the predictions disagree with those from the Walsh diagram, this is usually due to the inadequacy of the singleconfiguration approximation. Two isoelectronic molecules that have recently been studied spectroscopically have been the subject of near-HF calculations. HCP is the phosphorus analogue of HCN, and a study of the computed wavefunction407indicates the existence of a G P bond; this is the only known example of this bond. A variety of properties 401
*02 403 404 *05
406 407
I. Absar and K. L. McEwen, Canad. J. Chem., 1972, 50, 653. G . Loew, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1971, 20, 203. P. K. Pearson, G. L. Blackman, H. F. Schaefer, tert., B. ROOS,and U. Wahlgren, Astrophys. J., 1973, 184, L19. E. R. Davidson, J. Chem. Phys., 1972. 57, 1999. L. Z. Stenkamp and E. R. Davidson, rheor. Chim. Acta, 1973, 30, 283. G. M. Schwenzer, S. V. O’Neil, H. F. Schaefer, tert., C. P. Baskin, and C. F. Bender, J . Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 2787. C. Thomson, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1974, 35, 237.
Quantum Mechanical Calculationson Small Molecules
131
were computed and compared with experiment and with earlier calculations with a GTO basis,408 which gave a poorer energy and especially a poor value of p. HBS has also been studied by Thom~on.~O~ In both sets of calculations, basis sets of BA + P quality were used. Computed bond lengths were in good agreement with experiment, and in both cases a large number of one-electron properties were computed, and these stand as predictions.409 The HCC (ethynyl) radical has apparently been detected in stars,410 and also trapped in argon matrices at 4 K.411 The ground state is 2Z+, and this was confirmed by SCF calculations.410 The computed rotational J = 1 4 0 line was in good agreement with thzt observed,412 and it is thus likely that CCH has been observed. The HBO molecule is a further example of an unstable intermediate which has only recently been detected in matrix-isolation e~periments.~l~ SCF calculations by Thomson and Wishart 414 have yielded reliable values for the bond lengths, and the authors have discussed the bonding and one-electron properties. It is hoped that such calculations will stimulate further experimental work on this and similar unstable triatomic molecules. F. C02,CS2, Li20, and Al2O.-Although C02 has been much studied in the past, its normal vibrational modes have not been studied theoretically, and these have been the subject of a recent SCF calculation by Ohrn and c o - ~ o r k e r s . ~The ~ 5 basis set used was a 7s3p GTO basis with added 3d-functions. This must be considered a near-minimal basis, not a DZ + P, as quoted by the authors. The quadrupole moment was calculated in this work. The generally good agreement for the force constants is gratifying. Theoretical work on the low-lying excited states has been confined to rather small 417 but a recent very detailed study using a GTO DZ P calculations in the basis set has appeared.418 Open-shell SCF calculations were carried out for 13 low-lying valence states, including five Rydberg states, and in addition a pi-electron CI calculation was carried out, including all single and double excitations for eight of these states. The calculated transition energies provided definitive assignments for various states observed by optical and electror,-impact studies. There are four states (lAl, 3B2, 3 A ~ , lA2) which are bound relative to CO(lC+) O(3P). The accuracy of the calculations was impressive. CS2 had onIy been studied by CNDO previous to a 1971 calculation by Fischer and K e m m e ~ , who ~ l ~ used a large GTO basis with 3d-functions. Comparison calculations on C02 were also carried out. The charge distribution indicates transfer of
+
+
408
409 410
*l2
413 414
415 416 417 418 *19
J.-B. Robert, H. Marsmann, 1. Absar, and J. R. Van Wazer, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1971, 93 3320. C. Thomson, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 25, 59. J. Barsuhn, Astrophys. Letters, 1972, 12, 169. W. R. M. Graham, K. I. Dismuhe, and W. Weltner, jun., J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60,3817. D. Buhl and L. E. Snyder, Nature, 1970, 228, 267. R. F. Porter and E. R. Lory, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1971, 93, 6301. C. Thomson and B. W. Wishart, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1974,35, 267. M. VuEelid, Y.Ohm, and J. R. Sabin, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 3003. M. Krauss, S. R. Mielczanck, D. Neumann, and C. E. Kuyatt, J. Geophys. Res., 1971,76,3733. P. S. Julienne, D. Neumann, and M. Krauss, J. Atmos. Sci., 1971, 28, 833. N. W. Winter, C. F. Bender, and W. A. Goddard, tert., Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 20, 489, C. R. Fischer and P. J. Kemmey, Mol. Phys., 1971, 22, 1133.
132
Theoretical Chemistry
charge to S from C. The molecular quadrupole moment was computed and found to be negative. Two interesting linear molecules whose geometries were slightly unexpected are Liz0 and Al2O. These are highly ionic species, and the linear structure of Li2O was predicted several years ag0.420 In the case of AhO, the experimental results are ambiguous. Wagner has recently published a study of the PE surfaces of these mole~ules,4~1 for which semi-empirical methods predict bond structures with acute apex angles and long bonds. Both molecules are predicted to be linear. Large contracted GTO basis sets were used (without polarization functions). The computed vibrational frequencies were in reasonable agreement with experiment. Liz0 has also been studied by the separated-electronpair method.422 A STO basis set of DZ quality was used. Doubly occupied geminals were used in constructing the wavefunction, and hence electron correlation is included. The molecule was again predicted to be linear. The best energy was -0.15 hartree lower than in the above SCF calculations. A detailed analysis of the MO’s was given in this paper. G. CCO and TiC0.-These two species have little in common, but it is convenient to examine them together. OCC425 has been the subject of a near-HF study.It is an unstable species, as yet characterized only in matrix-isolation experiment~.~~4 The computed bond lengths were R(0-C) = 2.121 bohr, R(C-C) = 2.58 bohr, and several one-electron properties were predicted. The computed force constants were in fair agreement with experiment. The simplest carbonyls to be studied theoretically are T i c 0 and TiCO+.325The GVB method has been applied to these molecules, using a minimal STO basis set with added Ti(4p) orbitals. The orbitals were found to have basically the same shape as in CO. Both c-and z-bonding occur, but not to such an extent that the orbitals of separated Ti and CO change much. The back-bonding is considerably weaker in TiCO than in TiCO+, and the former is less stable than the latter. Extension of the qualitative ideas gives a useful discussion of the bonding in more complex carbonyls.
H. Molecules containing B, C, and N.-An extensive set of calculations, in many cases of near-HF accuracy, on various linear molecules containing B, C,and N has been reported by Thomson.424 This study was prompted by the observation of several species such as B2C, BC2, and BCN (or BNC) in mass spectra, but little was known about their structure prior to this work. Calculations approaching HF accuracy showed that BNC should be more stable than BCN, BCC more stable than CBC,and BCB more stable than BBC.424 Combined with estimates of the correlation energy, the atomization energy of BNC was predicted to be -0.48 hartree, in good agreement with experiment. The groundstate X2X+configuration of BCC is consistent with the results of e.s.r. measurements, which show BCC to be a a-radical. A similar study of the molecules NCN, NNC, CNC, and C C N 4 S 5 was carried out 420 421 422 423
424 425
R. J. Buenker, and S. D. Peyerirnhoff, J. Chem. Phys., 1966,45, 3682. E. L. Wagner, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1974,32, 295. T.K.Liu and D. D. Ebbing, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1972, 6, 297. C.Thomson and B. J. Wishart, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1973,31, 347. C . Thomson, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58,216. C.Thomson, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58, 841.
133
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
later. These molecules (except for NNC) are all known from Herzberg's spectral inve~tigations,~~s and calculations at the DZ + P level gave bond lengths in reasonable agreement with experiment, and for NNC the predicted bond lengths of R(N-N) = 2.53 bohr, R(N-C) = 2.19 bohr should be reasonably accurate. One particularly important point emphasized in this series of papers concerns the use of Mulliken population analyses to interpret the charge distribution and the contributions of d-functions to the bonding. Many papers have discussed this question, and in particular, workers on larger molecules with minimal or DZ basis sets often use these quantities. The results of Thomson and c o - ~ o r k e r s , ~ ~425 ~ - who have computed wavefunctions for many linear molecules at DZ, DZ P, BA P, and near-HF accuracy, show quite clearly that computed population analyses are very sensitive to the wavefunction, and even at BA + P level they should be used with caution. Smaller basis sets than DZ + P are likely to give serious errors in populations, and the sign of the charge may be incorrect. As an example we show in Table 6 the results for six of the molecules considered. It is clear that variations can be quite large, and hence conclusions based on small populations computed with basis sets of less than DZ + P quality may be quite wrong. 4239
+
+
Table 6 Total atomic population Gt on atom i in some linear X Y Z molecules with different basis sets 424 XYZ
BCN BNC
BCC CBC BBC BCB
Basis set DZ DZ P BA + P DZ DZ P BA + P DZ DZ + P BA P DZ DZ P BA P DZ
+
+
+ + + DZ + P BA + P DZ DZ + P BA + P
GX
GY
4.58 4. a4 4.71 4.57 4.85 4.65 4.40 4.59 4.56 5.91 6.10 4.80
6.18 5.99 6.05 7.76 7.14 7.58 6.68 6.27 6.47 5.18 4.80
GZ
-
7.23 7.16 7.23 5.67 6.01 5.76 5.92 6.14 5.97 5.91 6.10 -
4.79
5.23 5.05
6.15
4.61 4.74
6.77 6.52
4.61 4.74
5.97
A few other studies on these molecules have appeared. BCN was the subject of a calculation with a small GTO basis set,427 and the spin-spin interaction in the ground states of NCN, CNN, and CCO has been computed by Williams, using a STO-4G and an extended 4-31G basis set.428 Results were not in very good agreement with experiment. Although spin-orbit contributions were believed to be the main reason 426
G. Herzberg, 'Electronic Spectra of Polyatomic Molecules', Van Nostrand, New York, 1966.
427
J. B. Moffat, J. Mol. Structure, 1971,7, 474.
4aa
G. R. Williams, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 25, 602.
Theoretical Chemistry
134
for the discrepancy, it seems likely that the wavefunctions are themselves not accurate enough to compute this small quantity accurately. There have been many other papers dealing with various aspects of theory relevant to linear molecules, but space does not permit discussion of these. 9 Non-linear Triatomic Molecules A. A H 2 Molecules, including H,f.-The simplest of these species is H3+,which has been the subject of a number of recent studies. Work previous to 1970 is listed by B ~ r k m a nThe . ~ ~ground ~ state is triangular (D3h) and it has been studied using a basis set of elliptical orbitals. Contracted GTO basis sets were used in near-HF calculations by Harrison et a1.,430 and correlated wavefunctions were computed by Salmon and Poshusta,431and by Handy.4a2 In the latter calculation a new form for the correlation factor was used, and the good results suggest that it might be useful for other small molecules. The ion BeH; should be linear, like BeH2, according to Walsh's rules. However, explicit calculations,433both SCF and VB-CI, show that the ground state is an electrostatically bound complex with 2A1 symmetry, and the nearby excited state is a metastable bound state of 2B2symmetry. The HBeH angle is 20"and R(Be-H) = 4.43 bohr, whereas the excited state has an angle of -70". Explicit orbital-energy diagrams show a crossing of the 2a1 and lbz energies near loo", but in the ground state the H-H distance is nearly that in H2, suggesting a description of the molecule as an ionic complex. The results strongly indicate that the two states should be observable mass-spectroscopically. BH2 has been less studied than most of the first-row AH2 molecules, although BH; was studied some years ago by Kaufman et a1.434 However, with the recent advances in computing power, more accurate calculations on open-shell systems are now feasible, and three separate studies of BH2 have appeared. Bender and Schaefer435 have computed first-order wavefunctions for CH,' and BH2, using a contracted GTO (9s5pl4s) basis, and for BH2, the 2Ai and 2B1 states were investigated. The computed bond angle is within 2" of experiment, and the prediction for CH; is that the ground state is bent and the first excited state linear, a conclusion at variance with earlier semi-empirical calculations436 which predicted the ground 2A1 state to be linear. Goddard and co-workers155 have computed GVB wavefunctions for BH2 with similar results to Schaefer, and have discussed the H in terms of the GVB orbitals. It is interesting that formation of BH2 from BH the tervalent nature of B is already apparent from the 2 P ground-state boron orbitals. Staemmler and Jungen437 have obtained the PE surfaces for these two states using the IEPA method and obtained a similar but somewhat lower total energy. A large number of properties were computed for both states. It is claimed
-
+
419 430 431 432
433 434
435 436 437
R. F. Borkman, J. Chem. Phys., 1970,53, 3153. S. W. Harrison, L. J. Massa, and P. Soloman, Nature Phys. Sci.,1973, 245, 31. L. Salmon and R. D. Poshusta, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 3497. N. C. Handy, MoI. Phys., 1973, 26, 169. R. D. Poshusta, D. W. Klint, and A. Liberles, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 252. L. M. Sachs, M. Geller, and J. J. Kaufman, J. Clzem. Phys., 1970, 52, 974. C. F. Bender and H. F. Schaefer, tert., J. MoI. Spectroscopy, 1971, 37, 423. P. C. H. Jordan and H. C. Longuet-Higgins, MuZ. Phys., 1962, 5 , 121. V. Staemmler and M. Jungen, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 16, 187.
135
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
that the experimental value of the differencein zero-point energies of the two states is incorrect. Unpublished calculations by Meyer on BH2 have been quoted by Staemmler,437 but no details have appeared except the total energy. The BH,f cation, which is linear, has been studied by Jungen by the IEPA method.438 A discussion of Walsh’s rules and the first-row hydrides has been given by Wasserman now that quantitative calculations have been carried These rules have also been reviewed by Buenkerll and further studied by Davidson et al.405 CH2, the next hydride in the series, is the classic example of the power of a6 initio calculations in that the clear prediction was of a non-linear geometry, and this led to a consequent revision of the experimental data by Herzberg. Several recent calculations on this species should be mentioned. The calculations prior to 1971 have been summarized in Schaefer’s book, and some of the results of later work are given in Table 7. There are two particularly important questions: (i) the grsund-state geometry, and (ii) the ~ A I + - + ~energy BI separation. Successive calculations by Lathan et al.,440,441 del Bene,4*2 O’Neil Table 7 Results of ab initio calculationson CH2, energy of 3B1groundstate, geometry, 3B1-1A1 energy separation AE3-11
Elhartree
hartree
Method SCF SCF SCF SCF SCF SCF SCF SCF SCF
STO-3G ST04-31G Gaussian lobe GTO GTO GTOa GTO GTOa C-H bond function
- 38.4362 - 38.8696 - 38.892 - 38.9078 -38.9123 - 38.9136 - 38.9202 -38.921
1.11 1.11 1.06 1.07 1.06 1.11 1.075 1.11
SCF SCF SCF VB-CI CI CI VB-CI CI GVB-CI CI CI CI CI IEPA
GTO GTO GTO minSTO GTO GTO Gaussian lobe GTO GTOa GTO GTO GTO a GTO GTOa
- 38.9264 - 38.9308 - 38.9327 - 38.877 -38.904 - 38.908 - 38.915 - 38.9248 -38.9598 -38.9696 - 38.9826 - 39.0121 - 39.0319 - 39.0754
1.096 1.069 1.072 1.11 1.12 1.08 1.06 1.06 1.11 1.092 1.095 1.088 1.095 1.081
a
Basis
-
N
100.5 105.4 133 130 130 126 130.4 135
-
135 128.5 129.5 127.5 129 136 140 130 135 131.7 133.3 134 134 134.2
Re1.73 440 1.60 440 1.76 446 1.45 442 1.50 450 445 1.08 1.39 443 1.03 449 1.17 Meyer 1968 (see 451) 1.40 455 1.09 451
-
444
1.71 1.06 1.04 1.39 0.88 0.50 0.97
448 452 447 446 450 449 443
0.40
455 451
-
444
444
Including d-functions on C.
438 439 440
441 443
M. Jungen, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1970, 5, 241. E. Wasserman, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 24, 18. W. A. Lathan, W. Hehre, and J. A. Pople, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1971, 93, 808. W. A. Lathan, W. Hehre, L. A. Curtiss, and J. A. Pople, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1971,93, 6377. J. del Bene, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 9, 68.
136
Theoretical Chemistry
et a1.,443McLaughlin et and Bender and co-workersY445 using SCF calculations with large basis sets, or SCF plus large CI, predict the 3B1 state to be bent, and the most extensive calculation of ref. 444 predicts R(C-H) = 1.088 A, 8 = 134", in good agreement with experimental estimates. There have also been a few VB calculations. An early calculation by Harrison and Allen used a small gaussian lobe basis ~et,~46 and included 20 primary structures. The resulting lowest energy of -38.915 hartree and bond angle of 140" were similar to the values obtained by MO cal~ulations.4~~ Another VB calculation by Tandardini and co-workers44* used a minimal STO basis set, and a h e d CH distance. Various excited states were studied with up to 150 VB structures. Although the total energies were not particularly good, owing to the limitation of the basis set, the computed properties were very similar to those of O'Neil et al., who used a much more extensive MO calculation. GVB calculations on CH2 have also been reported,449so a value of 134 _+ 2"seems well established. Other SCF-CI calculations on the low-lying states have been reported,450 and it now seems clear that the HCH angle in the ground state is 134k2". However, the size of the singlet-triplet gap [AE(1Al++3B1)]has been much harder to compute. A survey of previous work on this question has been included in refs. 445 and 451, where the following conclusions are drawn. All SCF calculations without d-functions predict A E to be between 134 and 168 kJ mol-l, but inclusion of dfunctions lowers this to 105 kJ mol-l. However, the inclusion of electron correlation is even more important. CI without d-functions gives values of 84-105 kJ mol-1, which is reduced to 50 kJ mol-1 with polarization functions. The extensive calculations by Bender et aZ.443-445and S t a e m n ~ l e r ~ (who ~ l used the IEFA method) are in general agreement in that A E is 38 k 12 kJ mol-l. This value should be more accurate than current experimental estimates, but it is of interest that the small value is primarily the result of a differential lowering of the energy of the lA1 state by the d-polarization functions. A large number of molecular properties for CX32were computed by Staemn~ler,~~l and in particular the binding energy of 187 kcal mol-1 is in fair agreement with experiment. A recent MIND0/3 semi-empirica1453calculation gives a value of A E that is in agreement with the ab initio results, and which is superior to MIND0/2. The spin-spin splitting parameters D and E have also been the subject of several recent ab initio calculations. Limited CI calculations by Harrison gave D in good agreement with experiment, but E was too large.454 More extensive CI calculations
-
N
443 *44 445
4J6
447 448 449
450 451
452 453 454
S. V. O'Neil, H. F. Schaefer, tert., and C. F. Bender, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 162. D. R. McLaughlin, C. F. Bender, and H. F. Schaefer, tert., Theor. Chim. Acta, 1972, 25, 362. C. F. Bender, H. F. Schaefer, tert., D. R. Franceschetti, and L. C. Allen, J. Amer. Chem. SOC., 1972,94, 6888. J. F. Harrison and L. C. Allen, J. Amer. Chem. Sor., 1969, 91, 807. J. F. Harrison, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1971, 93, 4112. G . F. Tantardini, M. Raimondi, and M. Simonetta, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1973, 7 , 893. P.J. Hay, W. J. Hunt, and W. A. Goddard, tert., Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 13, 30. S. Y. Chu, A. K. Q. Siu, and E. F. Hayes, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1972, 94, 2969. V. Staemmler, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1973, 31, 49. J. M. Foster and S. F. Boys, Reu. Mod. Phys., 1960, 32, 305. M. J. S. Dewar, R. C. Haddon, and P. K. Weiner, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1974, 96, 253. J. F. Harrison, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 54, 5413.
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
137
have been reported recently by Langhoff and Davidson,455 using a contracted gaussian lobe basis, and also by Harrison and Liedtke.456 The best wavefunction was comparable to that of McLaughlin et a2.444 and gave D = 0.781 cm-l, E = 0.050 cm-l. These values give, if combined with estimates of the spin-orbit contribution, a value of D of 0.9 k 0.1 cm-l, which is higher than the experimental value; this latter is, however, subject to some uncertainty (see ref. 456 for details). The second-order effect of spin-orbit coupling on the angular dependence of the zero-field splitting has been investigated by Hall and Han1eka.~5' NHS, NH;, and NH;. The radical NH2 was the fist polyatomic free radical to be observed experimentally, and it has since been extensivelystudied spectroscopically. Bender and Schaefer458 have referenced calculations on NH2 prior to 1970, and have presented results for the most accurate calculations yet carried out, to which we return below. However, del Bene,459at about the same time, reported the results of an SCF study, using small (STO-3G) or (ST04-31G) basis sets. The predicted 2B1 ground state of the radical has 8 = 108", R(N-H) = 1.01 A, and for the 2A1state 8 = 144", R(N-H) = 0.98 A. The more extensivecalculations of Bender and Schaefer,458 using a DZ P basis set, evaluated both SCF and first-order wavefunctions. 252 configurations were included for the 2B1 state, and 387 for the 2A1 state. The computed bond lengths and other properties are given in Table 8. The ~BI-~AI splitting is predicted to be 1.67 eV from the best CI calculation. The SCF wavefunction is a rather good approximation to the total wavefunction.
+
Table 8 Computed geometries and force constants for N H 2 (experimental values in parentheses)458 aAi & FO SCF FO 0.997 1.010 (0.975) 1.055 (1.024) 141.9 144.7 (144+5) 102.7 (103.3) -55.6799 -55.5237 -55.6185
2Bl 7
Bond length/A Bond angle/" Interpolated total E/ hartree Stretching force constant/ mdyn A-1 Bending force constant/ mdyn A-1 a
SCF 1.019 105.4 -55.5757 7.77
6.50
7.94
7.05
0.71
0.64
0.48
0.31
First-order wavefunction.
Pople and c o - ~ o r k e r shave ~ ~ l also studied NH2 in various states and geometries, but with rather smaller basis sets. However, a very recent paper has used more extensive basis sets460 (ST0431G), with results close to the limit for singledeterminant wavefunctions. However, R(N--H) is slightly lower than observed. 455
S. R. Langhoff and E. R. Davidson, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1973, 7 , 759. J. F. Harrison and R. C. Liedtke, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 3106. W. R. Hall and H. F. Hameka, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 226; ibid., 1974, 60, 4104. C. F. Bender and H. F. Schaefer, tert., J . Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 4798. J. del Bene, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 54, 3487. P. C. Hariharan and J. A. Pople, Mol. Phys,, 1974, 27, 209.
4 5 ~
457
458 459 460
meoretical Chemistry
138
A number of papers have dealt with the calculation of the isotropic hyperfine coupling constants in NH2, but these are reviewed e1~ewhere.l~~ NH;, which is isoelectronic with CH2, has been studied again relatively recently, first by Chu, Siu, and Hayes,450 then by Pople and co-w0rkers,~*1and finally by Harrison and E a k e r ~ .The ~ ~ l3B1, I&, 1.41, and 1AT states were investigated by Chu et aZ.,450using a gaussian lobe basis: both SCF and CI calculations were reported. The computed PE curves show that the ground3B1statehas a bond angle of 130".Of particular interest is the fact that the singlet-triplet separation (~AI-~BI) for NH; is predicted to be about twice as big as in CH2. The results obtained by the other workers are in reasonable agreement generally, but Lee and M ~ r u k u m a in , ~an ~ ~earlier CI study with a larger basis set, found the ground state to be linear. However, since the barrier to linearity is small, these calculations cannot yet have completely resolved the question. A recent study of some other excited states of NH2 by Brown and Williams463 uses the UHF method. Of particular interest is the 2B2 state, with R(N-H) = 3.04bohr, 0 = 26.6".Thomson and Brotchie4G4have repeated the calculations with a basis set giving near-HF accuracy and confirm these results. However, the species is not bound, and it seems to correspond to a H2 + N* system. However, it is also possible for the SCF to converge to another apparently bound state, which population analysis shows to be an erroneous conclusion. However, some analogous states of BF2 are bound (see below). OH2 and OH:. The water molecule is of paramount importance, and its structure and chemistry have recently been extensivelyre~iewed.~~5 Numerous recent theoretical studies have appeared, and only a few of these will be mentioned. Considering first the SCF calculations,early work has been discussed by Schaefer,l and a recent paper by Goddard and Hunt 466 gives a complete list of references up to 1974. Pople and co-workers reported STO-3G + ST04-31G calculations of the equilibrium geometry in 1971.*40 Davidson, in an interesting paper, has explored the use of the internally consistent orbitals (ICSCF) in the case of H20,467and he found these to be better for describing spectra than the traditional canonical orbitals. The most comprehensivenear-HF calculation on H2O was carried out by Dunning, Pitzer, and Aung,46*who examined the use of a variety of GTO and STO basis sets in a study of a large number of one-electron properties of the ground state. About 70 % of the dissociation energy was obtained, with the energy 0.003 & 0.002 hartree above the H F limit. The computed VIP's were N 1-1.5 eV too low, and the force constants were in error by 15-20 %. Kern and co-workers have made an extensive st~dy46~-472 of zero-point vibrational corrections to one-electron properties.
-
4131 J.
-
F. Harrison and C. W. Eakers, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 1973, 95, 3467. S. T. Lee and K. Morukuma, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 1971, 93, 6863. 46s R. D. Brown and G. R. Williams, Mol. Phys., 1973, 25, 673. 4154 C. Thomson and D. A. Brotchie, Mol. Phys., 1974, 28, 301. 465 C. W. Kern and M. Karplus in 'Water: A ComprehensiveTreatise', Plenum Press, New York, 1972. 466 W. A. Goddard, tert., and W. J. Hunt, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 24, 464. 467 S. T. Elbert, S. P. Langhoff, and E. R. Davidson, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 2005. 4 6 8 T. H. Dunning, jun., R. M. Pitzer, and S. Aung, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 5044. 469 W. C. Ermler and C. W. Kern, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55,4851. 47* W. C. Ermler and C. W. Kern, J. Chem. Phys., 1971,55,4851. 471 L. L. Sprandel and C. W. Kern, Mol, Phys., 1972, 24, 1383. 47a B. J. Krohn, W. C. Ermler, and C. W. Kern, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60,22. 462
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
139
The coupled Hartree-Fock method has been reviewed and applications to the computation of one-electron properties of H20 have been described by Thomsen and were generally in good agreement with Swanstrsm in two p a p e r ~ . ~474 7 ~Results * experiment when a near-HF wavefunction was used, particularly second-order force constants. However, the electric polarizability was not well reproduced. Bendazzoli et aZ.475have also computed a variety of properties using the Pople STO-3G method, and also a method in which only two-electron integrals were approximated, with all one-electron integrals evaluated exactly using STO’s. Total energies were better in the second method owing to a better description of the 1s orbitals. Afzal and Frost476have recently made a detailed analysis of the energy terms which contribute to the total energy in FSGO calculations. A point-charge model of H20 was also found to be capable of yielding accurate values of various one-electron properties.477 The MsX, method has been shown to predict incorrect bond angles in H2O and N H 3 . 4 7 8 Antoci et al.479 have shown that this is due to the way the one-electron molecular potential is treated. Turning now to calculations by other than MO methods, there have been a number of recent VB calculations. Peterson and Pfeif€er4Sohave implemented a conventional multi-structure VB scheme, using gaussian lobe basis functions. Results on the ground state of H2O included calculation of the dissociation energies for H20+ HO + H (DI = 316kJ mol-l)and OH+ 0 + H (D2 = 230 kJ mol-l), in reasonable agreement with experimen