A Specialist Periodical Report
Theoretical Chemistry Volume 2
A Review of the Recent Literature
Senior Reporters R. N. Dixon, Department of Theoretical Chemistry, Universify of Bristol C. Thornson, Department of Chemistry, University of St Andrews Reporters
R. F. W. Bader, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada B. J. Duke, University of fancaster R. A. Gangi, McMasfer University, Hamilton , Ontario, Canada J. G. Stamper, University of Sussex
0 Copyright 1975
The Chemical Society Burlington House, London, WIV
OBN
ISBN :0 85186 764 2
ISSN : 0305 9995
Library of Congress Catalog Card No. 73-92911
PRINTED IN GREAT BRITAIN BY ADLARD AND SON LIMTED, BARTHOLOMEW PRESS, DORKING
Foreword
This second volume of the Specialist Periodical Reports on Theoretical Chemistry is the first of the series covering the broader aspects of the subject, and contains four articles. Quantum chemical calculations on small molecules are reviewed by Thomson, and calculations on large molecules by Duke. It is hoped that the cIasses of calculation not dealt with in this report will be reviewed in Vol. 3. One of the growth areas in theoretical chemistry has been the attention paid to the potential energy surfaces for inolecules and interacting molecules, rather than just equilibrium properties. Bader and Gangi provide a very detailed and comprehensive review of ab initio calculations on potential energy surfaces, and Stamper deals with the subject of intermolecular forces. Other topics in theoretical chemistry will be covered in the next volume. May 1975
R. N. Dixon C. Thomson
Contents Chapter 1 Ab lnitio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces By R. F. W. Bader and R. A, Gangi
1
1 The Concept of a Potential Energy Surface
1
2 Scope of the Review
4
3 Hartree-Fock and Self-Consistent-Field Calculations Properties of Hartree-Fock Wavefunctions Roothaan’s Self-Consistent-FieldProcedure Comparison of Hartree-Fock and Near Hartree-Fock SCF Results with Experiment
6 10 10 12
4 Hartree-Fock Potential Energy Surface Calculations Asymptotic Behaviour of Single Determinantal Wavefunctions Early Examples of Surface Calculations for Closed-shell Systems Tests of Parallel Nature of HF and Correlated Surfaces for Closed-shell Systems HF Surfaces for A: + B. Interactions HF Surfaces for sN2 Reactions Other Closed-shell HF Results Corrections for Improper HF Asymptotic Behaviour HF Description of Addition to Double Bonds Electrocyclic Reactions Ion Solvation
18 18 20
5 BeyondHartme-Fock Minimal Configuration Interaction Truncated CI Wavefunctions Unrestricted Wavefunctions The IEPA Method
36 37 37
48
6 H + H2: A Benchmark Reaction Semi-Empirical Calculations Ab Initio Calculations
48 48 49
7 Potential Energy Surfaces from Correlated Wavefunctions
54 54 55 56
H3f
+ +
He Hi-, HeH+ HeH2 H2 D2-+2HD HeHf + Hz-, He He:+ He,+ + He
F
+H +
+ Ra4FH + H
21 24 25 28 29
34 35
35
41
57
Hi
59
60
60
vi
Contents
+
+
H Fz+HF F SurfacesforX + Mzand M CH2 + CH2+ C2H4 The Valence Bond Approach
+ X2
Chapter 2 Intermolecular Forces By J. G. Stamper
62 63 64 65
66
1 Introduction
66
2 General Theory
66
3 Short- and Intermediate-range Forces
70
4 Long-range Forces
74
5 Miscellaneous Topics Systems of more than Two Molecules Properties Hydrogen-bonded Systems Empirical Potentials and Related Topics
77 77 78 79 81
Chapter 3 Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules By C. Thomson
83
1 Introduction
83
2 Diatomic Molecules containing up to Four Electrons A. H i a n d H z B. HeH, HeH+, and He: C. He2
84 84 90 91
3 Diatomic Hydrides of First-row Atoms, AH A. LiH and LiHf B. BeH, BeH+, and BH C. CH and CM+ D. NH,NHf, and OH E. H F a n d H F f
93 93 99 102 104 105
4 Hydrides of Second and Higher Rows, AH
107
5 Homonuclear Diatomic Molecules of First-row Elements A. Liz and Li; B. Be2, B2, CZ,Cl, and C, C. N2 andiNi D. 02, Oz, and 0, E. Fa, F;, and F,
108 109 110 110 112 114
Contents
vi i 6 Homonuclear Diatomic Molecules of Second and Higher Rows
115
7 Heteronuclear Diatomic Molecules A. Rare-gas Compounds B. Oxides of Elements of Groups I, 11, and I11 C . Metal Oxides of Other Groups D. Non-metal Oxides COYSiO, and CS NO, NO+, and PO C10 and FO E. Halides Metal Halides Halides of B, C, and Si Fluorides of N, P, S, Se, and As SF,SeF, and AsF F. Nitrides and Carbides G. Interhalogens H. Miscellaneous Calculations on Diatomic Molecules
116 116 118 119 120 120 121 122 122 122 123 124 124 125 125 126
8 Linear Triatomic Molecules A. He/H2 and H3 B. Hydrides AH2 C. Compounds of the Inert Gases D. The Bihalide Ions HX; E. HAB Molecules F. C02, CS2, Li20, and A h 0 G. CCO and TiCO H. Molecules containing B, C, and N
127 127 127 128 129 129 131 132 132
9 Non-linear Triatomic Molecules A. AH2 Molecules, including H3+ NH2, NH;, and NH; OH2 and OH$ H2Ff B. HAB Molecules C. ABz Molecules A02 AF2 D. ABC Molecules
134 134 137 138 141 141 143 143 147 149
10 Tetra-atomic Molecules A. A H 3 Molecules B. A B 3 Molecules C. A4 Molecules D. A2Bz and A2H2 Molecules E. Dimers of Diatomic Molecules, AB *AB F. Miscellaneous Tetra-atomic Molecules 9
150 150 153 154 155 156 156
viii
Contents
Chapter 4 Electronic Calculations on Large Molecules By B. J. Duke
159
1 Introduction
159
2 The Linear Combination of Atomic Orbitals-Molecular Orbital Approach Introduction Ab Initio LCAO-MO Methods Approximate LCAO Methods
160 160 162 184
3 The X, Exchange Approximation The SCF-X, Scattered-wave Method Other Related Methods
191 191 194
4 Beyond the Molecular Orbital Approach Introduction The PCLLO Method Other CI Methods
195 195 196 200
5 Concluding Remarks
20 1
Author Index
203
Abbreviations Average Natural Orbitals AN0 Best Atom (basis set) BA P Best Atom + Polarization functions BA Born-0 ppenheimer BO Contracted Gaussian Type Orbitals CGTO Configuration Interaction CI Complete Neglect of Differential Overlap CNDO DEM Distinguishable Electron Method DIM Diatomics in Molecules Double Zeta (basis set) DZ Polarization functions DZ P Double Zeta Extended Hartree-Fock EHF ESCA Electron Spectroscopy for Chemical Analysis FEGO Floating Ellipsoidal Gaussian Orbital FSGO Floating Spherical Gaussian Orbital Generalized Atomic Effective Potential GAEP GTO Gaussian Type Orbital GVB Generalized Valence Bond: particular forms are denoted G1, G1 & G F Hartree-Fock HF Hartree-Fock with Proper Dissociation HFPD Internally Consistent Self Consistent Orbitals ICSCF Independent Electron Pair Approximation IEPA Intermediate Neglect of Differential Overlap INDO Intermediate Retention of Differential Overlap IRDO Iterative Natural Orbital IN0 Ionization Potential IP Kolos-Roothaan (wave function for Hz) KR LED0 Limited Expansion of Diatomic Overlap Kolos-Wolniecwicz (wave function for H2) KW LCAO Linear Combination of Atomic Orbitals MBPT Many Body Perturbation Theory MCSCF Multi-configuration Self Consistent Field MIM Molecules in Molecules MIND0 Modified INDO procedure of Dewar, also MIND0/2, MIND0/3 Molecular Orbital MO Neglect of Diatomic Differential Overlap NDDO Natural Spin Orbital NSO Optimized Double Configuration ODC Optimized Valence Configuration ovc Potential Energy PE Perturbative Configuration Interaction over Localized Orbitals PCILO PNO Pseudo-natural Orbital or (PSNO)
+
+
+
Abbreviations
X
PDDO PRDDO RHF SAM0 SCF SOGI STQ STO-nG UA UHF VB VIP
Projectors of Diatomic Differential Overlap Partial Retention of Diatomic Differential Overlap Restricted Hartree-Fock Simulated ab initio Method Self Consistent Field Spin Optimized GVB method Slater Type Orbit a1 Slater Type Orbital expanded in terms of nGTO United Atom Unrestricted Hartree-Fock Valence Bond Vertical Ionization Potential
Units
A number of different sets of units are used throughout this volume. Conversions to SI units are as follows: Energy:
1 a.u. (Hartree) = 4.359828 aJ
1 eV
= 0.160210 aJ
= 2625.47 kJ mol-1
= 96.4868 kJ mol-l
1 cm-l = 1.98631 x 10-23J = 11.9626 J mol-l 1 K = 1.38054~10-23J= 8.3143 J mol-f
Length:
1 a.u. (Bohr) = 0.529177~10-lo m
Dipole moment: 1D (Debye) = 3.33564 x
Cm
I Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces ~
BY R. F. W. BADER AND R. A. GANG1
1 The Concept of a Potential Energy Surface This chapter is concerned with the calculation of potential energy surfaces by nonempirical methods, i.e. by obtaining solutions to Schrodinger's equation within the Born-Oppenheimer approximation. The concept of a potential energy surface is a consequence of the separation of the nuclear and electronic motions as proposed by Born and Oppenheimer.1 The nuclei may be considered to move under the infiuence of a potential determined by their mutual electrostatic repulsion and by the total energy of the electrons, an energy which is determined for every possible static configuration of the nuclei. The gain in conceptual simplicity afforded by the Born-Oppenheimer procedure is enormous and its use underlies many of our chemical concepts. For example, energies of activation or energy barriers in general, potential constants, the frequencies of vibrational and rotational motions, and bond lengths and bond angles as determined by an energy minimum, are all concepts defined in terms of the properties of a potential surface. To obtain information concerning a system of n electrons and N nuclei in the absence of external fields, one must solve the timeindependent Schrodinger equation
RTY~(x, R)
= EzPi(x, R)
(11
where the properties of the zTh stationary state of the system of energy Et are obtainable from the eigenfunctions Yi(x,R)which in turn depend upon the space and spin co-ordinates of all the electrons and nuclei (whose collective co-ordinates are denoted by x and R,respectively) in the system. The total Hamiltonian operator is
RT
=
R! + 3%
+
0
(2)
where Pe and PN are the kinetic energy operators of the electrons and nuclei, respectively, and where the potential energy operator in atomic units is,
One can distinguish three levels of approximation in obtaining solutions to equation (1):a (i) the Born-Oppenheimer approximation, often referred to as the a
M. Born and R. Oppenheimer, Ann. Phys., 1927,84,457. P. G. Wilkinson and H. 0. Pritchard, Cunad. J. Phys., 1969,47,2493.
1
2
Theoretical Chemistry
clamped-nucleus approximation; (ii) the adiabatic approximation; and (iii) the non-adiabatic approximation. The solutions to equation (1) provided by the first of these are entirely adequate for most problems of chemical interest. For example, use of this approximation in the calculation of the low-lying vibrational and rotational levels of Hl yields results which are correct within experimental In the Born-Oppenheimer approximation, one fist transforms to a centre-of-mass, molecule-fixedco-ordinate system, thereby yielding a kinetic energy operator for the electrons referred to nuclei that are fixed with respect to their centre of mass and a nuclear kinetic energy operator5 which refers only to their internal motions, i.e. their vibrations and rotations and the various couplings between them.* Because of the large disparity in the masses of the electrons and the nuclei, the average kinetic energy of the former will be many times that of the latter, the ratio being proportional to mK/me-2000 in the least favourable case when mKrefers to the mass of a proton. Thus, in the limiting classical case, one obtains a picture of the electrons undergoing very rapid motion relative to the nuclei and adjusting almost instantaneously to changes in the nuclear positions. This suggests that the electronic motions are determined to a good approximation by just the static field of the nuclei, i.e. the electronic motion is determined by where the nuclei are but not by how fast they are moving. The motions of the nuclei in this separation of co-ordinates are governed by a potential whose negative gradient is simply the electrostatic force of repulsion between the nuclei and the attractive force exerted on the nuclei by the electronic charge distribution, a distribution whose form is determined by the electronic wavefunction evaluated for each configuration of the nuclei. Mathematically, this separation of the kinetic motions of the electrons and nuclei amounts to approximating the total wavefunction !Pi(x, R) by a simple product of electronic and nuclear wavefunctions
The electronic function yi(x; R) is obtained by solving the electronic Schrodinger equation for a fixed nuclear configuration, where
The use of the semi-colon in the notation yi( x; R)is to denote the explicit dependence of yi on the electronic space-spin co-ordinates x and its implicit dependence, along with Ei on the nuclear co-ordinates R. Clearly, the solution of equation (5) for all spatial arrangements of the nuclei will generate an energy (hyper)-surface, the
*
For a recent discussion of the nuclear kinetic energy operator and of its application to nuclear motions in the water molecule the reader is referred to ref. 6. l
G. Hunter and H. 0. Pritchard, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,46,2153.
* C. L. Beckel, B. D. Hansen, and J. M. Peek, J. Chem. Phys., 1970, 53, 3681.
B. T. Darling and D. M. Dennison, Phys, Rev,, 1940,57, 128, C. W. Kern and M. Karplus, ‘Water-A Comprehensive Treatise’, ed. F. Franks, Plenum, New York, 1974, vol. 1, p. 21.
3
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
potential energy surface, which governs the motion of the nuclei as obtained by solving the nuclear eigenvalue equation
Equation (7) and its implied assumption of the separability of the electronic and nuclear motions is called the Born-Oppenheimer approximation. The exact Schrodinger equation of motion, equation (l), may be equivalently stated in a manner which shows the neglected terms arising from the assumption of the product form for the wavefunction, equation (4). The exact eigenstate Ya(x, R) is expanded in terms of the complete orthonormal set of functions yi(x; R) obtained from the solutions of the electronic equation, equation (5), in which case the nuclear wavefunctions xt(R) appear as the coefficients in the expansion. This procedure yields the following infinite set of coupled equations for the xi(R)6 [FN -k Ei(R)
+
< ~ a I ~ N I ~ t ) - ~ i ] X i (= R)
- ~ < W l ~ N ] ~ j ) x j ( R )(8) i #j
From this formal, but exact statement of Schrodinger's equation, which corresponds to the non-adiabatic approximation referred to above, one sees that the approximation made in obtaining equation (7)is to assume that
for all i and j. In another order of approximation, with the expansion of Yi(x, R) truncated to the single product term as given in equation (4), one obtains in place of equation (8),
[?"
+ E4R) +
(10)
for the nuclear eigenfmction xiv(R). The term
4
Tireoretical Chemistry
or Rennerll effects. In these cases, the non-adiabatic terms, < y i l p ~ l y j >can , become very large as the energies approach one another. The large mixing of the electronic levels by the nuclear kinetic energy operator implies a strong dependence of the electronic wavefunction on the nuclear motion and results in a complete breakdown of the Bom-Oppenheirner approximation.l2 2 Scope of the Review
The theoretical study of any chemical problem which falls within the domain of the Born-Oppenheimer approximation involves two basic steps : (a) the solution of Schrodinger’s electronic equation, equation (3, for one or more electronic states over the range of nuclear configurations demanded by the problem; and (b) solving the nuclear equations of motion on the potential energy surface, or surfaces, thus obtained.* The calculations in part (b) may be of two types; the determination of the nuclear energy levels for bound states of the system, i.e. the quantized vibrational and rotational levels of the system, or the study of the dynamics of the chemical changes described by the surface in terms of quantum reactive scattering or classical trajectory calculations. It is the purpose of this review to discuss and illustrate the methods presently employed to obtain potential energy surfaces by approximate, but non-empirical solutions to Schrodinger’s electronic equation. In addition to discussing the different levels of approximation employed in these ab initio calculations, we emphasize the type of chemical system (in terms of its electronic structure) to which each level of calculation may be expected to yield usable results, i.e. results with acceptable errors or with predictable bounds on the error. Our interest will be primarily in surfaces which have been determined for the prediction and understanding of chemical reactions. This will include a survey of those calculations which have concentrated on determining the reaction path, and the geometry and properties of the system at points on this path, as well as those in which an essentially complete surface has been determined. The latter type of calculation coupled with either classical or quanta1treatments of the nuclear motion on such a surface provides a total theoretical prediction of a chemical reaction. This ultimate objective has been achieved in the case of the H + H2 exchange reaction. A recent review of the dynamics of bimolecular reactions by Polanyi and Schreiberl4 provides a detailed account of the cZassicaE trajectory method for treating the motion of a reactive system on a potential energy surface. Such classical motion studies on three-dimensional surfaces are now commonplace and have yielded a great deal of information regarding the microscopic dynamical behaviour
*
When the nuclear motion may be described as occurring on a single surface, it is referred to as being adiabatic. In some systems, more than one potential surface must be employed in the description of the nuclear motion and these cases are referred to as 110n-adiabatic.l~
l1
12 13 14
R. ReMer, Z . Physik, 1934, 92, 172. W. D. Hobey and A. D. McLachlan, J. Chem. Phys., 1960,33, 1695. J. C. Tully and R. K. Preston, J. Chern. Phyx., 1971, 54, 4297. J. C. Polanyi and J. L. Schreiber, ‘Physical Chemistry - An Advanced Treatise,’ ed. H. Eyring, W.Jost, and D. Henderson, Academic Press, New York, 1974, vol. 6.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
5
of reactive systems. The majority of these studies, those by Polanyi et a1.,15 Bunker et al.,le Grice et aZ.,17 and Karplus et a1.,18 for example, have employed potential energy surfaces determined by semi-empirical methods. Most notable of these is the 20 Other semi‘extended LEPS (London, Eyring, Polanyi, and Sato) function’.fQ* empirical or purely empirical surfaces have been introduced and used in trajectory studies by Blais, Bunker, and and by Porter and Karplw22 Roach and Child 23 have developed a pseudopotential method for semi-empirical variational calculations of a potential surface. Quantum calculations of reactive scattering on a potential surface are much more diflicult than the corresponding classical trajectory studies and are not as far advanced. Progress in this field has been reviewed recently by L e ~ i n e , ~ ~ Karplus,26 and Light.27 Fortunately, it appears from the limited comparisons of the quanta1 and classical studies and from a comparison of the classical results with experimental findings, that the classical approach to the study of reaction dynamics is sufficiently accurate to yield informative and useful res~lts.1~ The classical trajectory studies in particular have resulted in a cataloguing of the properties of potential surfaces with respect to the possible observed types of reaction dynamics. Thus, one desires a knowledge of the principal features of a surface which determine the distribution of energy in the products, whether it appears primarily as vibrational excitation of the newly formed bond, as rotational energy, or as relative translational motion of the product molecules. Information regarding the product energy distribution over vibrational and rotational states is obtained from the i.r. chemiluminescence method developed by Polanyi (for a recent review, see ref. 28). In addition, crossed molecular beam studies, by measuring the angular distribution as well as the translational energy distribution of the scattered molecules, require that predictions be made regarding the relative probabilities of ‘forward‘, ‘back’ and P. J. Kuntz, E. M.Nemeth, J. C. Polanyi, S. D. Rosner, and C. E. Young, J. Chem. Phys., 1966,44, 1168;J. C. Polanyi and W. H. Wong, ibid., 1969,51, 1439; M. H.Mok and J. C. Polanyi, ibid., 1969,51, 1451; 1970, 53, 4588;B. A. Hodgson and 3. C. Polanyi, ibid., 1971, 55,4745. 1 6 D. L . Bunker, ‘Methods in Computational Physics,’ ed. B. Adler, S. Fernbach, and M. Rotenberg, Academic Press, New York, 1971,vol. 10, p. 287;T.B. Borne and D. L. Bunker, J. Chem. Phys., 1971,55,4861. 17 J. C . Whitehead and R. Grice, Mol. Phys., 1973,26, 267. 18 M. Karplus, R. N. Porter, and R. D. Sharma, J. Chem. Phys., 1965, 43, 3259; M. Karplus and K. T. Tang, Discuss. Faraday Soc., 1967,44, 56. 1s H.Eyring and M. Polanyi, 2.phys. Chem., 1931,B12, 279; for a review and summary of earlier references, see J. C. Polanyi, J. Quant. Spectroscopy and Radiative Transfer, 1963,3, 471. 20 S. Sato, J. Chem. Phys., 1955,23,592,2465. 21 D.L. Bunker and N. C. Blais, J. Chem. Phys., 1964,41,2377;D.L. Bunker and C. A. Parr, ibid., 1970,52, 5700. 22 R.N.Porter and M. Karplus, J. Chem. Phys., 1964,40,1105. 23 A. C. Roach and M. S. Child, Mol. Phys., 1968, 14, 1. 24 R. D.Levine, ‘Quantum Mechanics of Molecular Rate Processes’, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1969. 26 J. Ross, in ‘Molecular Beams and Reaction Kinetics’, ed. Ch. Schlier, Academic Press, New York, 1970,p. 392. 26 M. Karplus, ref. 25, p. 407. 27 J. C. Light, in ref. 16, p. 11 1. 28 T. Carrington and J. C. Polanyi, in ‘Chemical Kinetics’, ed. J. C. Polanyi, MTP lntemational Review of Science, Physical Chemistry Series One, Medical and Technical Pub. Co., Oxford, 1972, p. 135. 15
Theoretical Chemistry
6
angularly uniform scattering of the product molecules. For a recent review of the crossed molecular beam method, the reader is referred to an article by K i n ~ e y . ~ ~ This type of categorization of the properties of potential energy surfaces is well documented in the recent review by Polanyi and Schreiberl4 and will be referred to in discussing the potential energy surfaces obtained for particular reactive systems. Through the use of the Rayleigh-Ritz variational principle, approximate solutions to Schrodinger’s electronic equation, equation (5), may be obtained to any desired degree of accuracy for a many-electron system. Because of the formidable computational problems involved in obtaining these solutions, chemical accuracy (generally taken to imply errors of a few kcal mol-1 or less) has been achieved in only a few two- and three-electron systems. Considerable progress is being made, however, by methods reviewed here, and complete potential surfaceswith an accuracy acceptable for trajectory studies for systems with up to 30 electrons and four nuclei now lie within the present bounds of accomplishment.30 In addition, of course, many questions concerning the electronic mechanisms of particular reactions may be answered by calculations performed at lower levels of approximation. Of paramount importance in this latter category is the Hartree-Fock approximation. The so-called ‘Hartree-Fock limit’ represents a well-defined plateau, in terms of its methematical and physical properties, in the hierarchy of approximate solutions to Schrodinger’s electronic equation. In addition, the Hartree-Fock solution serves as the starting point for many of the presently employed methods whose ultimate goal is to achieve solutions to equation ( 5 ) of chemical accuracy. A discussion of the Hartree-Fock method and its associated concept of a self-consistent field thus provides a natural starting point for the discussion of the calculation of potential surfaces, 3 Hartree-Fock and Self-Consistent-FieldCalculations The orbital approach to the problem of electronic structure reduces a many-electron problem to a corresponding number of oneelectron problems. The Hartree-Fock solution represents the best attainable description of the electronic structure of a many-electron system in terms of the one-electron orbital approach. In the orbital description of electronic structure, the motion of each electron is determined by a spin-orbital, ut, a simple product of a space function q5i and a spin function crt
where ut may denote either an ct or /Ispin function. By analogy with a system in which each electron moves independently of the others, the total wavefunction is taken to be a product of the oneelectron spin orbitals, one for each electron in the system. To satisfy the additional restrictions of the Pauli principle, and simultaneously to allow for the indistinguishability of the electrons, an antisymmetrized sum of such product functions must be used to L. Kinsey, in ref. 28, p. 173. D, R. Yarkony, S. V. O’Neil, and H. F. Schaefer, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 855.
as J. 30
7
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
approximate the many-electron wavefunction for the system. This is most conveniently done by expressing the wavefunction in the form of a determinant, O(x; R) = (n!)-1I2det [ul(l)u2(2).. .un(n)]
(1 1)
since on expansion, a determinant equals a sum of such product terms [asrepresented in equation (11) by its diagonal element] representing all possible permutations of the n electrons among the n spin-orbitals(n! in number), each term in the sum being multiplied by (+ 1) or (- 1) depending on whether the number of permutations is even or odd. The factor (n!)- 1 is ~ required to normalize @(x; R) to unity when the spin-orbitals are orthonormal, i.e. Jui(k)uj(k)drk =
&j
(12)
where the orthonomality obtains for both space and spin functions separately. The energy of such a determinantal wavefunction, @POI; a),is obtained by the quantum mechanical averaging of the electronic Hamiltonian operator given in equation (6) E(R) = <@(x; R)lfieI@(x;R)>
(13)
or N
R
where hi = Jaj
=
and Kaj
= [z&k)uj(k)(
I rk - rl 1) -l4(l)ui(Z) dtr dtt
(16)
The kinetic energy of the electron described by ug together with its energy of interaction with all of the nuclei in the system is represented by hi. The s u m over Jij and Kij in equation (14) represents the energy of repulsion between the electrons in the system, the Coulomb integral Jij representing the electrostatic repulsion between the two charge distributions g(k)Ui(k) and uj*(Z)uj(Z)and the exchange integral Ksj correcting this classical estimate of the repulsion in a manner dictated by the antisymmetry principle. The forms of the orbitals us are determined by demandingthat the energy obtained in equation (13) be a minimum with respect to arbitrary variations in the orbitals. This procedures1leads to a set of n coupled equations, the Hartree-Fock equations, of the form F(k)ui(k) = eiut(k) (1 7) The HartreeFock operator p(k) is generally expressed as a sum of the two terms, 81
C. C . J. Roothaan, Rev. Mod. Phys., 1951, 23, 69.
8
Theoretical Chemistry
+ G(k) where H(k) is the Hamiltonian for motion of the electron in orbital u&) in the field of the bare nuclei and where the operation of G(k) on ut(k) is given by
p(k) = k ( k )
(1 8) The first summation in equation (18) determines the repulsive Coulomb field exerted on electron k at r k by the total charge distribution including the distribution z$(Z)ut(Z). This self-repulsion of the electron described by ut is removed throughout space in a particular manner as described by an exchange distribution Cj ui(Z)ui(Z) which vanishes on integration over the spins unless ut and uj possess identical spin functions. Thus, the effect of antisymmetrization on the simple product wavefunction is to replace the intuitively obvious coulomb repulsion of the form Z j +t &Z)&(Z) with a repulsion involving the charge distribution of all the orbitals, from which is removed the equivalent of the repulsion from the one electron in 4i.32This selective removal of charge density throughout space of electrons with the same spin is called the 'Fermi hole'? Thus, each orbital in the system is determined by a Schrodinger-like eigenvalue equation, equation (17), with a Hamiltonian whose potential field is determined by the attractive field of the nuclei and the average repulsive field of the remaining electrons in the system. The equations for all n orbitals are coupled since the potential field for any one orbital is determined by the distribution of charge described by the remaining orbitals. Thus, to solve the Hartree-Fock equations, one must fkst assume some form for all the orbitals in the system, construct the resulting potentials G(k),solve the equations to generate a new set of orbitals which are then employed over again in the same manner. This procedure is repeated until the potentials &(k)used in the determination are indistinguishable from or converge to the potentials obtained in the calculation. That is, the process is continued until self-consistency in the assumed and calculated potentials is achieved. When the orbitals are determined in this manner, with the only restriction being the orthonormality constraint, equation (12), they yield the best possible antisymmetrized product wavefunction (i.e., a single determinant wavefunction) for the system in question since the resulting @(x; R) yields the lowest possible value for E(B). The heart of the Hartree-Fock model is to replace the detailed and accurate description of the repulsions between every pair of electrons in the system by the average field that each electron exerts on every other. This is a consequence of the oneelectron or orbital basis of the model which leads to a product wavefunction. The probability, P2(rl7ra)dr1dr2,that electron 1 be in some small volume element about r l when electron 2 is simultaneously in some small volume element about r2 is, in a simple product-type wavefunction, given by the product of the two singleparticle probabilities,
sa
J. C. Slater, 'Quantum Theory of Molecules and Solids', McGraw-Hill, New York, 1963, Vol. 1.
33
R. McWeeny and B. T. Sutcliffe, 'Methods of Molecular Quantum Mechanics', Academic Press, New York, 1969, p. 76f.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
9
where, for a closed-shell system nl2
mrl)
=
(2/n)
c $i+(l)+r(l)
i=l
This result for Pz(r1,rz) can only be true in the limit that the motion of electron 1 and hence its probability of being at a certain point in space is totally independent of the motions of electron 2, i.e. there are no forces acting between the two electrons and their motions are totally uncorrelated. The best that can be done in a model which employs an expression of the form of equation (19) for the pair probability function is to determine the ui (which in turn determine the one-particle probability function) in such a way that the electron it describes experiences the average field of the other electrons, a situation which is attained in the Hartres-Fock limit of the orbital model. The Hartree-Fock wavefunction is not a simple product function, but an antisymmetrized sum of such products. As pointed out above, the effect of the antisymmetrization is to selectively remove, from the region of space about a given electron, charge density of electrons with the same spin. Thus, the pair probability function for electrons with the same spin is not of the form given in equation (19) but instead is
where
and where na denotes the number of orbitals occupied with a spins in a closed-shell system. Notice that ps"(rl, r2) [or Pfb(rl, rz)], equals zero when rl = 1-2, and hence the antisymmetrizationof a simple product wavefunction results in a 100 % negative correlation between the motions of electrons with identical spins as required by the Pauli principle.ss The pair probability of electrons with opposite spins predicted by a Hartree-Fock wavefunction is, however, given by the simple product expression, equation (19). This is the source of the inherent error in a Hartree-Fock wavefunction and because of its fundamental importance, it is given a special name, the correlation error. Correspondingly, the correlation energy is defined34*35 as the difference between the Hartree-Fock energy and the exact energy of the system.* The methods for obtaining approximate solutions for Schrodinger's electronic equation which go beyond the Hartree-Fock limit are specifically designed to reduce the correlationerror, i.e. they are constructed so as to obtain a more detailed and more accurate description of the pair probability function for electrons of opposite spin.
(a,
The electronic Hamiltonian, equation does not include relativistic effects and hence cannot yield the true total energy of a system. Thus, its contribution to the energy is accounted for in the definition of the correlation error.85 84
P.-0. Lowdin, Adu. Chem. Phys., 1959,2, 207. E. Clementi, J. Chem. Phys., 1963, 38,2248.
10
Theoretical Chemistry
Properties of Hartree-Fock Wavefmctions.-A Hartree-Fock wavefunction satisfies36,37 the virial theorem38 and the Hellmann-Feynman theorem,39, theorems which have been referred to by Slaterg1as being two of the most powerful theorems applicable to molecules and solids. Hartree-Fock wavefunctions also satisfy a theorem derived by Brillouin,42 which is discussed in Section 5. As a result of this very important theorem, one can prove that a molecular charge distribution obtained from a Hartree-Fock wavefunction and the properties determined by it are predicted with surprisingly high accuracy. For example, the charge distribution is probably accurate to within 2--5z.43 As explained below, all properties predicted by a Hartree-Fock wavefunction are, because of Brillouin’s theorem, correct up to second-order. A comparison of Hartree-Fock and experimental results for molecular properties must be prefaced with the methods employed in obtaining wavefunctions at or close to the Hartree-Fock limit in molecular systems. Roothaan’s Self-Consistent-Field Procedure.-While numerical integration techniques may be used to solve the Hartree-Fock equations in the case of atoms by the iterative method described above, the lower symmetry of the nuclear field present in molecules necessitates the use of an expansion for the determination of the molecular orbitals by a method developed by R ~ o t h a a nIn . ~Roothaan’s ~ approach, it is assumed that each molecular orbital may be adequately represented by a linear expansion in terms of some (simpler) set of basis functions xj, i.e. N
Two kinds of basis functions (or basis orbitals) are commonly used in the expansions of the orbitals in both atomic and molecular calculations, being either of the Slatertype (STO’s) or of the Gaussian-type (GTO’s). Substituting the expansion, equation (22), for each molecular orbital in the Hartree-Fock expression for the energy, and again demanding that E m ) be a minimum with respect to variations in the uz, results in a set of matrix equations (of dimensions N x N ) for the coefficients cij. These equations are solved by an iterative method starting with some initial guess of the cip, until self-consistency has been achieved. This method is termed (Roothaan’s) LCAO-MO SCF approximation to the Hartree-Fock limit.*
* The term Restricted Hartree-Fock (RHF) is applied to those cases in which all the possible spin pairing in a system is allowed for by having electrons of both a and B spin occupy the same space orbital. If this restriction is relaxed in writing out the determinantal wavefunction, the method of calculation is referred to as the Unrestricted Hartree-Fock (UHF) method. Unless otherwise stipulated, the calculations referred to in this chapter are of the RHF variety.
36
37
C. W. Kern and M. Karplus, J. Chem. Phys., 1964,40, 1374. A. C. Hurley, ‘Molecular Orbitals in Chemistry, Physics, and Biology’, ed. P.-0. Lowdin and B. Pullman, Academic Press, New York, 1964, pp. 161-191; C. A. Coulson, Mol. Phys., 1971,20, 687.
J. C. Slater, J. Chem. Phys., 1933, 1, 687. se H. Hellmann, ‘Einfuhrung in die Quanten-chemie’, Franz Deuticke, Leipzig, Germany, 1937, 38
41 42
p. 285. R. P. Feynman, Phys. Reu., 1939,56, 340. J. C. Slater, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 2389. (a) L. Brillouin, Actualities Sci. I d . , 1933-34, 71, Secs. 159, 160; (b) C. Moller and M. S. Plesset, P h p . Reu.. 1934, 46, 618.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
11
Use of a complete (necessarily infinite) set of basis orbitals in the expansion for the molecular orbitals would insure absolute convergence to the Hartree-Fock limit. In practice, this is both impossible and unnecessary, and only a finite number of basis functions is employed in the expansion. The selection of the finite basis set is, therefore, of crucial importance in determining how closely one approximates the true Hartree-Fock solution. A complete review of the characteristics of various types of basis sets has been given recently by Schaefer.44The radial form of STO’s is similar to the (nodeless) hydrogenic atomic orbitals, rn -le -Cr where n is the principal quantum number and C is a variable exponent.45Their angular dependence is described by multiplication by a spherical harmonic Y z , ~ ( ~ , The $ ) . use of GTO’s in molecular calculations was first suggested by Boys.46 These functions are usually employed in their Cartesian form, xpyrrZ8e-cr2 where different angular dependences are obtained by assigning values to the integersp, 4,and s. STO’s with their exponential dependence on r are better able to approximate the atomic solutions in the region of a nucleus than are GTO’s with the r2 dependence. In particular, STO’s can properly describe the cusp behaviour which the wavefunction should exhibit at the positions of the nuclei,47 while GTO’s cannot, Thus, an expansion of the molecular orbitals in terms of an STO set yields a better approximation to the Hartree-Fock orbitals than one expressed in terms of the same number of GTO’s. However, as pointed out by B o ~ s , ~ ~ the two-electron multicentre integrals which are encountered in molecular calculations are much more rapidly evaluated when the orbitals are expressed in terms of GTO’s rather than STO’s. This saving in the time required for integral evaluation is obtained even when the size of the GTO set is increased to the point where it yields results of accuracy comparable with those obtained using an STO set.44 One may use any size basis set above some minimal size in the SCF procedure to obtain orbitals, a wavefunction and an energy of an atomic or molecular system. However, only very large basis sets possess the flexibility required to obtain good approximations to the true Hartree-Fock orbitals for a system. Thus, one must distinguish between those SCF calculations which use basis sets large enough so that the results closely approximate the Hartree-Fock limit, and those which do not. One finds that the SCF energy, since it always represents an upper bound to the true energy, converges smoothly to the limiting Hartree-Fock value as the size of the basis set is increased. The values of properties other than the energy, such as the Hellmann-Feynman force or the electric field gradient, however, may fluctuate erratically around the Hartree-Fock value until this limit is very nearly attained.48 The minimum size basis set which can be used in an SCF calculation includes one ST0 for each occupied atomic orbital with distinct n and I values as determined by the electronic configuration of the atom in question. While of conceptual and 43
44
45 46 47
48
R. F. W. Bader, in ‘Theoretical Chemistry’, ed. C. A. Coulson and A. D. Buckingham, MTP International Review of Science, Physical Chemistry Series Two, Butterworths, London, 1975. H. F. Schaeler, ‘The Electronic Structure of Atoms and Molecules’, Addison Wesley, Reading, Mass., 1972. J. C. Slater, Phys. Rev., 1930, 36, 57. S. F. Boys, Proc. Roy. SOC.,1950, A200, 542. T.Kato, C ~ m mPure . Appl. Math., 1957,10, 151. P. E. Cade, Trans. Amer. Cryst. Assoc., 1972, 8, 1.
12
Theoretical Chemistry
historic importance, such a minimum basis set is usually inadequate for molecular calculations. A great improvement in calculated energy and properties is obtained by doubling the size of the minimum basis set, i.e. representing each occupied atomic orbital with distinct n and I values by two STO basis functions. This is termed a double-zeta basis set. The use of such a basis set in atomic SCF calculations yields results close to the Hartree-Fock limit. Roetti and Clementi49 have determined double-zeta basis sets with optimized exponents for the ground-state functions of all atoms from He(lfl through to Xe(W). In all cases, the calculated energies are close to the Hartree-Fock limiting values. For example, the double-zeta SCF energies for C(3P), F(2P)and Br(2P) lie above the Hartree-Fock values by 5, 21, and 6 kJ mol -l, respectively. As’ discussed below, the double-zeta set when complemented with suitable polarizing functions is a widely used and rather accurate set for use in molecular SCF calculations. Basis sets composed of GTO’s which are equivalent to the doublezeta Slater sets have been devised by Whittens* and Dunning.51 A considerable saving in computation time can be achieved with only a small sacrifice in flexibility by employing what are called contracted sets of GTO’s. That is, the original set of GTO’s, referred to as primitives, are grouped into a smaller number of linear combinations with fixed coefficients. Thus, the double-zeta set of Dunning51 which consists of nine s- and five p-type Gaussian functions is, in a typical calculation, usually contracted to four s- and twop-type functions. This information is summarized in the notation (9sSp)+ [4s, 2pl. Dunning52has also provided (10s6p)-+[5s,4p] or [5s, 3p] sets which exceed double-zeta quality. While basis sets composed of a sufficient number of s- and p-type functions will yield the Hartree-Fock results for atoms up to scandium,53such s-p saturated sets are not suitable for molecular SCF calculations. Instead, the basis sets must be augmented with ‘polarizing’ functions, i.e. those functions, p for hydrogen and d and f f o r first- and second-row atoms, which are absent in the description of the isolated atoms, but whose presence is essential for a proper description of the distortions in the charge distribution caused by chemical bonding. As the examples in the following section illustrate, the inclusion of polarizing functions in the basis set is essential in the calculation of potential surfaces. Comparison of H-Fock and Near Hartree-Fock SCF Results with Experiment.The properties of the water molecule described by an SCF single determinant wavefunction have been determined with a number of GTO and STO basis sets, ranging in size from minimal to near Hartree-Fock. A detailed tabular summary of these results, which are typical of such SCF calculations on molecular systems, has been given by Kern and Karplus.6 The Hartree-Fock estimate of the total energy for water is estimated to be - 76.066 & 0.002 a.u.,54 compared to the experimental value of - 76.431 a u . An SCF calculation using a Gaussian (1ls7p2d/5slp)primitive set 49
50
51
j2 j3
54
C. Roetti and E. Clementi, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 4725. J. L. Whitten, J. Chem. Phys., 1966, 44, 359. T. H. Dunning, J. Chem. Phys., 1970, 53, 2823. T. H. Dunning, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 716. E. Clementi, ‘Tables of Atomic Functions’, International Business Machines Corp., San Jose, California, 1965. T. H. Dunning, quoted by C. W. Kern and M. Karplus in ref. 6.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
13
contracted to a [6s5p2d/3slp]* yields an energy of -76.0621 I L . u . A ~ ~smaller set of STO's (5s4pld/3slp) yields an energy of -76.0631 a.u., in very close agreement with the estimated Hartree-Fock limit.55 A minimal STO set yields an energy more than 11 eV above that obtained from the best function.56 The Gaussian basis set which is equivalent to the doublezeta Slater set and augmented with two d functions, the set (9s5p2d/4slp) contracted to [4s3p2d/2slp], yields an energy of - 76.0504 a.u., or 0.44eV above the HartreeFock limit.55 In addition to the energies, the values predicted by these S C F calculations for a number of the one-electron properties of the water molecule are also compared by Kern and Karplus.6 As anticipated, the values predicted for these properties by the near Hartree-Fock functions are in good agreement with the experimental values. The molecular dipole moment, for example is calculated to be 2.054 D by the best STO set compared with an experimental value of 1.884D.57(HartreeFock estimates of molecular dipole moments are generally too large by ca. 0.2 D.) Ermler and Kern58 have computed the potential energy surface for the water molecule in the neighbourhood of its energy minimum using the [4s3p2d/2slp] contracted set of GTO's (equivalent to a double-zeta set plus the polarizing functions). The theoretical minimum in the energy surface was found to occur at a geometry with bond lengths of 1.779 a.u. and a bond angle of 106.1", compared with the experimental values60 of 1.8089 a.u. and 104.52".The energy in the neighbourhood of the equilibrium geometry was expanded in a Taylor series so as to obtain all the harmonic and cubic potential constants. A comparison of the calculated and experimental results59 is given in Table 1. The harmonic constants are overestimated by amounts ranging from ca. 10% to 20 %. This agreement is typical for Table 1 Comparison of (SCF)calculated and observedforce constantsfor H20 Force constanta fr
fa f i p
ha firr faaa
fm* fira
h a fraa 4
b
*
Computed valueb 9.876 0.881 -0.079 0.258 - 10.505 -0.145
- O.Oo04 -0.033
-0.526 -0.149
Observed value" 8.454 0.761 -0.101 0.228 - 9.55 -0.14 -0.32 0.16 - 0.66 0.15
% Error 16.82 15.82 21.39 12.98 - 10.00 -3.64 99.88 - 120.63 20.26 - 199.20
All values quoted in units of 105 dyn cm -1 (see ref. 59 for the definition of the force field). Ref. 58. C Ref. 59.
The solidus separates the basis functions centred on oxygen from those centred on each of the hydrogens.
55 56 58
59 6o
T. H. Dunning, R. M. Pitzer, and S. Aung, J. Chem. Phys., 1972,57, 5044. S. Aung, R. M. Pitzer, and S. I. Chan, J. Chem. Phys., 1968,49, 2071. M. L. Lichtenstein, V. E. Derr, and J. J. Gallagher, J. Mol. Spectroscopy, 1966, 20, 391. W. C. Ermler and C. W. Kern, J. Chem. Phys., 1971,55,4851. K. Kuchitsu and Y . Morino, Bull. Chem. SOC.Japan, 1965, 38, 814. W. S. Benedict, N. Gailar, and E. K. Plyler, J. Chem. Phys., 1956,24, 1139.
14
Theowticnl Chemistry
results obtained from wavefunctions at or near the Hartree-Fock limit, for polyatomic or diatomic619 62 systems.* Pulay65has developed a method for calculating the potential force constants for polyatomic systems, by analytically evaluating the first derivatives of the SCF determined energy surface, a problem also considered by Gerratt and Mills.66 Forces for only a few different nuclear configurations are required to determine the complete force field by this method, as opposed to the many such configurations required for obtaining second derivatives of the energy surface by numerical methods. This method has been applied to NH3,67aC2H6, C2H4, and and CH4.68 Using a large basis set of GTO’s, Meyer and Pulay68 obtained theoretical estimates of the symmetry force constants for CH4 which differed from the experimental values by amounts ranging from 0 to 12%.They concluded that the values obtained at the true Hartree-Fock limit would deviate by no more than 5 % from the experimental ones. A similar approach, for use with extended Huckel and MIND0 wavefunctions has been developed by McIver and Komornicki.69 While non-negligible errors are found in the curvatures of a HartreeFock potential energy surface in the region of the equilibrium geometry, the heights of small energy barriers separating geometrical conformers are accurately predicted. It was to explain the low-temperatureheat capacity data of ethane that Kemp and Pitzer70 first postulated the existence of barriers to internal rotation. The same system was studied in the first ab initiu calculation of an internal rotation barrier by Pitzer and Lipscomb.71 They used a minimum Slater basis set to determine the relative energies of staggered and eclipsed ethane and obtained a barrier of 13.8 kJ mol -l, compared with the then best experimental value of 12.7k 1.3 kJ mol -1. A number of other calculations have since been carried out which confirm this prediction and indicate that the barrier height in this case is insensitive to basis set composition. Thus, Veillard,72 using a large set of GTO’s for carbon and hydrogen, (1 ls7pld/6slp) contracted to [5s3pld/3slp], in a calculation which included careful optimization of the geometries of both eclipsed and staggered forms of ethane,
*
A relatively recent review of the theoretical calculation of potential curves and their derived properties for diatomic molecules has been given by Wahl.G3A massive review of the theoretical determination of the ground state properties of diatomic molecules by Goodisman 6* has recently been published. The reader is referred to these two sources, particularly the latter, for information regarding the calculation and properties of potential curves for diatomic species.
62
63 64
6s 66
13’
69
70
71 72
P. E. Cade, K. D. Sales, and A. C . Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1966, 44, 1973. P. E. Cade and W. M. Huo, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,47, 614, 649. A. C. Wahl, in ‘Theoretical Chemistry’, ed. W. Byers-Brown, MTP International Review of Science, Physical Chemistry Series One, Medical and Technical Pub. Co., Oxford, 1972, p. 41. J. Goodisman, ‘Diatomic Interaction Potential Theory’, Academic Press, New York, 1973, VOl. 1. P. Pulay, Moi. Phys., 1969, 17, 197. J. Gerratt and I. M. Mills, J. Chem. Phys., 1968, 49, 1719, 1730. (a) P. Pulay and W. Meyer, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 3337; (b) P. Pulay and W. Meyer, Mol. Phys., 1974, 27, 473. W. Meyer and P. Pulay, J. Chem. Phys., 1972,56,2109. J. W. McIver and A. Kormornicki, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 10, 303. J. D. Kemp and K. S. Pitzer, J. Chem. Phys., 1936,4, 749. R. M. Pitzer and W. N. Lipscomb, J. Chem. Phys., 1963, 39, 1995. A. Veillard, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1969, 3, 128.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
15
obtained a barrier height of 12.8 kJ mol-I. This value is in excellent agreement with the most recent experimental estimate of 12.3 kJrnol-1,73 and is nearly unchanged in value from the minimal basis set result. Even the more complicated double barrier present in HzO2 is well predicted at the near Hartree-Fock limit. The experimental geometry of Ha02 lies between the cis- and trans-forms, the two 0-H bonds forming a dihedral angle $ 0 of 111.5". The cis- and trans-conformers lie 31.8 kJ mol-1 and 4.6 kJ mol -l, respectively, above the energy minimum of the equilibrium ge0metry.7~~ 75 Dunning and Winter,76 using a large and carefully contracted set of GTO's for 0 and H, (9s5pld/4slp) contracted to [4s3pld/2slp], and performing a detailed geometry variation, obtained the results listed in Table 2. The barriers are very well predicted as are the parameters defining the equilibrium geometry. Table 2 Comparison of Calculated (SCF)a and observedb barriers and geometry for H202
Barriers (in cm-1) V(cis) V(trans) Geometry 90
L HOO
ROH Roo
CaIculated 2921 384 113.7' 102.5' 1,788 a.u. 2.632 a.u.
Observed 2649 3 86
111.5" 94.8" 1.795 a.u. 2.787 a.u.
Ref. 76. b R. H. Hunt, R. A. Leacock, C. W. Peters, and K. T. Hecht, J. Chem. Phys., 1965,42, 1931; C . S. Ewig and D. 0. Harris, ibid., 1970, 52, 6268.
a
The theoretical determination of the barrier height to inversion in NH3 by an SCF single-determinant calculation illustrates the importance which the inclusion of polarizing functions may have in such calculations. The experimental value for the inversion barrier in NH3 is 24.3 kJ mol-1.77 Three early attempts to account for this barrier using the SCF approach with either STO or GTO basis sets without polarizing functions centred on nitrogen yielded discouraging results.78~ 80 Using a GTO basis set not too different from one employed previously79 but with a d function centred on nitrogen, Body, McClure, and Clementi81obtained a theoretical value for the barrier which was ca. 20 % too large. With this encouragingresult, two near Hartree-Fock determinationsof the barrier were attempted, one using GTO'S,~~ the other S T O ' S , ~and ~ both yielded barrier values in very close agreement with 799
75 74
75 76 77 78 79
Bo sl 82 88
S. Weiss and G. E. Leroi, J. Chem. Phys., 1968, 48, 962. C. S. EWig and D. 0. Harris, J. Chem. Phys., 1970,52, 6268. R. H. Hunt, R. A. Leacock, C. W. Peters, and K. T. Hecht, J. Chem. Phys., 1965,42, 1931. T. H. Dunning and N. W. Winter, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 11, 194. J. D. Swalen and J. A. Ibers, J. Chem. Phys., 1962, 36, 1914. U. Kaldor and I. Shavitt, J. Chem. Phys., 1966, 45, 888. E. Clementi, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,46, 3851. W. H. Fink and L. C. Allen, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,46, 2276. R. G. Body, D. S. McClure, and E. Clementi, J. Chem. Phys., 1968,49, 4916. A. Rauk, L. C. Allen, and E. Clementi, J. Chem. Phys., 1970,52, 4133. R. M. Stevens, J. Chem. Phys., 1971,55, 1725.
16
Theoretical Chemistry
experiment. The calculation employing GTO's was performed by Rauk, Allen, and Clementis2 using a (13s8p2d/8s2p) basis set contracted to [8s5p2d/4s2p]. The predicted equilibrium geometry, R = 1.90 a.u. and 8 = 107.2" agrees well with experiment, R = 1.91 a.u. and 8 = 106.7'. The barrier obtained is 21.3 kJ mol-l, also in good agreement with experiment. These authors repeated the calculation of the barrier with the d functions omitted and obtained a value of only 5.0 kJ mol --l. The calculation of the NH3 inversion barrier using a large set of STO's, (5s4pld/2slp), was performed by Stevens.83 The energies obtained by both Stevens and Rauk et al. for the pyramidal equilibrium geometry, - 56.2212 a.u. and - 56.2219 a.u., respectively, are believed to lie within 8 kJ mol-1 of the Hartree-Fock limit. Stevens' calculated barrier height of 24.7 kJ mol-1 is in almost perfect agreement with the experimental value. Stevens also computed a potential curve for the inversion motion in NH3 by determining the minimum energy path. Schrodinger's equation for nuclear motion, equation (7), was solved for this system, treating the inversion motion as a one-dimensional problem. The vibrational energy levels thus obtained are listed in Table 3 for both NH3 and ND3, together with the experimental values.
Table 3 Computed (SCF)a and observed inversion energy levels in NH3 and N D 3 Level
Computed 0 1.133 987.96 1037.97 1684.9 2030 2579.50 3 154.02
0s OA
1s fA
2s 2A 3s 3A a
Ref. 83.
b
NHs Experimental 0 0.7935 932.51 968.32 1597.6 1910 2383.46 2895.48
ND3
Computed 0 0.068 804.7 809.5 1451 1543 1960 2286.0
Experimentalb 0 0.053 745.7 749.4 1359 1429 1830 2106.6
W. S. Benedict and E. K. Plyler, Canad. J. Phys., 1957, 35, 1235.
There is fair agreement between the theoretical and experimental values. Stevens points out that the inversion frequency is very sensitive to the barrier width, and it is because the calculated barrier is too narrow, that the predicted inversion frequencies are too large. Almlof 84 has computed the SCF potential surface for the linear degrees of freedom in the neighbourhood of the equilibrium geometry for HF; using an (9,5,1/4,1)set of GTO's contracted to [4,2,1/2,1].A potential function was generated by fitting the SCF energies with a nine-term polynomial in the symmetry co-ordinates Ql and Q z . The vibrational Schrodinger equation was then solved by expanding the nuclear wavefunction in products of linear harmonic-oscillator eigenfunctions, that is, products of the form &(Ql)$j(Q2). From a thorough investigation of the convergence properties of this expansion of the two-dimensional nuclear wavefunction, it was concluded that an expansion employing 160 such product terms was sufficient to insure an accuracy of k 5 cm -l for frequencies up to 5000 cm -l from what would 84
J. Almlof, Chern. Phys. Letters, 1972, 17,49.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
17
be obtained using the full, infinite set. While the calculated values of the vibrational frequencies tend to be high [e.g. vl(ca1c.) = 660 cm-1, vl(exp.) = 631 cm-11, the general agreement between the theoretical and calculated frequencies appears to be about as good as the agreement between the different sets of experimental values.84 Radom and Pople 85 have provided a comprehensivesummary of SCF calculations of rotation and inversion barriers and a comparison of these results with known experimental values. It appears that Hartree-Fock theory yields acceptable values for the heights (but not necessarily the curvature and shape) of such barriers. In fact, barriers which result from the passage of the system through a series of geometries not involving a change in hybridization about some central atom, such as the barrier to internal rotation in C2H6, for example, are well-predicted by SCF calculations above the Hartree-Fock limit. The inversion barrier in NH3, which in a simple model involves geometries with very different hybridizations on the nitrogen, is well described only when the SCF calculation approaches the HartreeFock limit. In particular, polarization functions must be centred on the atom which undergoesthe change in hybridizationif the height of the barrier, or even its presence, is to be properly predicted. As a further example of the importance of d functions in determining barrier heights we refer to calculations by Veillard et a1.86-87 and by Duke and Bader88 of the classid energy of activation for s N 2 reactions. While these calculations are discussed in more detail below, we mention here that both sets of authors found that basis sets which did not include polarizing functions gave results for the activation barriers which were radically different from those obtained near the Hartree-Fock limit. For example, both sets of authors found that in SCF calculations using large basis sets but with d functions absent, the F CH3F displacement reaction was predicted to proceed via a symmetrical (FCH3F) - intermediate stable by ca. 13 kJ mol -1 relative to reactants. With d functions included, the same reaction is predicted to occur via a transition state species with a symmetrical structure lying ca. 29 kJ mol-1 above the energy of the reactants. The existence of activation barriers for s N 2 displacements of F- from CH3F in the gas phase has been verified experimentallyby Bohme et ~1.89One associates a considerable change in the hybridization of carbon in the formation of the transition state for an s N 2 reaction, and the inclusion of d functions in the basis set is again found to be essential if a single determinant SCF calculation is to provide a proper description of the accompanying change in energy. The examples discussed so far serve to illustrate the ability of a Hartree-Fock or near Hartree-Fock SCF wavefunction to describe a polyatomic system in the neighbourhood of its equilibrium geometry (or geometries). Equilibrium geometries are predicted rather well by the Hartree-Fock SCF procedure. Predicted bond lengths are, in general, too short by 0.01--0.03a.u. and bond angles too large by ca. one degree. This is found for systems larger than those reported above. For example, Duke and Bader 88 performed an extensive geometry
+
85
86 88
L. Radom and J. A. Pople, in ref. 63, p. 71. G. Berthier, D. J. David and A. Veillard, Theor. Chim. Acta., 1969, 14, 329. A. Dedieu and A. Veillard, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1970, 5, 328. A. J. Duke and R. F. W.Bader, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 10, 631. D. K. Bohme, G. I. Mackay, and J. D. Payzant, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1974,96,4027.
18
Theoretical Chemistry
optimization for CH3F and CH3CN using an s and p GTO basis set of above double-zeta quality. The calculated and experimental (in brackets) values of the geometry parameters are for CHsCN; R(C-N) = 2.1539 a.u. (2.1864 a.u.), R(C-C) = 2.7661 a.u. (2.7553 a.u.), R(C-H) = 2.0471 a.u. (2.0853 a.u.), = 110.09" (109.31"); for CH3F; R(C-F) = 2.6498 a.u. (2.6147 6(H-C-CN) a.u.), R(C--H) = 2.0387 a.u. (2.0731 a.u.), 6(H-C-F) = 109.19"(108.45'). Since Hartree-Fock theory underestimates bond lengths, slightly better estimates of the molecular geometries are usually obtained using a basis set which falls short of that required for the HartreeFock limit. The set used in CH3F and CH3CN, for example, did not contain polarizing functions. A minimal basis set frequently yields better results, with errors of ca. 1 or 2 z.90As a further example, Pullman and Port (see ref. 137) predict that the preferred conformation of the acetylcholine molecule is gauche, on the basis of minimal basis set SCF calculations. This result is in agreement with the observed conformations of this molecule in the crystalline phase and in solution. The absolute energies obtained in a Hartree-Fock calculation are, of course, in considerabIe error (the correlation error), but for most problems of chemical interest one is concerned with energy differences and errors in the absolute energies are unimportant. It is now well established that the correlation error in the HartreeFock energy remains relatively constant in the neighbourhood of the minimum or minima of the potential energy surface. Consequently, the HartreeFock energy surface approximately parallels the true surface in these regions, and the ability of HartreeFock theory to provide acceptable predictions of molecular geometries and estimates of rotational and inversional barrier heights is understandable. Nesbet pointed out some time ago that the correlation energy should be insensitive to changes in molecular conformation. Stanton 92 has argued, on the basis of the fact that a HartreeFock wavefunction satisfies the Hellmann-Feynman theorem, that a Hartree-Fock potential energy surface and the exact surface should be parallel over short distances. There are certain types of system for which this approximate parallelism between the Hartree-Fock and exact potential energy surfaces holds not only in the region of the equilibrium geometry, but over the total surface. In such cases, one can obtain a Hartree-Fock description of the complete chemical change, a description at a level of approximation, which, from the above examples, is clearly adequate for answering many if not most of the questions concerning the static behaviour of the system along the so-called reaction pathway. It is to a discussion of such systems that we now turn. 4 Hartree-Fock Potential Energy Surface Calculations Asymptotic Behaviour of Single Determinantal WavefunCtions.-In general, a single determinantal wavefunction, whether or not it is at the Hartree-Fock limit, does not provide an adequate description of a molecular system over the complete range of internuclear separations, because of the failure of such a function to describe go 91 g2
M. D. Newton, W. A. Lathan, W. J. Hehre, and J. A. Pople, J. Chem. Phys., 1970,32,4064; J. A. Pople, Accounts Chem. Res., 1970,3, 217. R. K. Nesbet, J. Chem. Phys., 1965,43, 530; Ado. Chem. Phys., 1965,9, 321. R. E. Stanton, J. Chem. Phys., 1962, 36, 1298.
Ab initio Calciilation of Potential Energy Surfaces
19
properly the possible dissociation products of the system. The classic example of this behaviour is provided by the H2 molecule in which case the energy of the single determinantal wavefunction corresponds to the mean of the energies of H+ H-(lS) and 2H(2S)rather than that of 2H(2S).32A corresponding situation always arises when one attempts to describe the formation of a single bond in a singlet molecular state from two doublet states, e.g. H2, lX; from 2H(2S) or F2(lZ;) from 2F(2P). The energy at the dissociated limit for such a wavefunction is always greater than that of the true dissociation products calculated properly at the same level of approximation. Thus, in general, a Hartree-Fock potential energy surface increases too steeply along a co-ordinate which leads to dissociation. This over-steep behaviour on the dissociativearm or portion of a Hartree-Fock potential surface is usually cited as the cause for the too-short bond lengths and too-large force constants usually obtained in the Hartree-Fock description of a system. There are, however, certain types of system which constitute exceptions to this incorrect asymptotic behaviour of Hartree-Fock wavefunctions. An important example is one in which the electronic structures of the dissociation products correspond to closed-shell systems, i.e. each spatial orbital (including spatially degenerate sets) is doubly occupied in their molecular orbital descriptions. In this case, the single determinantal wavefunction reduces properly to a product of wavefunctions which describe the dissociation products. The elementary example of this situation is provided by the dissociation of He2(1C,') into 2He(1S),32but the correct behaviour is also obtained in more complicated closed-shell systems. For example, in the reaction of CN-(lZ+) with CH3F(lA) to form CH3CN(lA) F-(lS), the reae tants, products, and the nature of the reactive complex along the reaction coordinate joining the two ends of the reaction are all properly described by a single determinantal wavefunction. One way of accounting for the correct asymptotic behaviour of the Hartree-Fock (or single determinantal) wavefunction in closed-shell systems is via the observation that in such systems the number of electron pairs remains constant. In those cases where dissociation leads to a decrease in the number of electron pairs, a single determinantal wavefunction is unable properly to describe the products. Thus, by the definition of correlation energy, as the difference between the true (non-relativistic) energy and the Hartree-Fock energy, one anticipates that major changes in
+
+
the correlation energy will occur only when the number of electron pairs predicted by the orbital model of the system changes during the course of the reaction. Therefore, reactions involving closed-shell reactants and products should be accompanied by only small changes in the correlation energy, and consequently, as first pointed out by Snyder,g3 HartreeFock energies should yield reasonable estimates when used to calculate the heats of reaction for such systems. Snyder and Baschg4have confirmed this prediction in an extensive series of calculations using an extended basis set. Pople and co-workers95 have since employed this concept of near conservation in the correlation energy to determine energies of reactions in which not only the number of electron pairs, but also the number of bonds of each particular type, is gS 84
95
L. C. Snyder, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,46, 3602. L. C. Snyder and H. Basch, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1969,91, 2189. R. Ditchfield, W. J. Hehre, J. A. Pople, and L. Radom, Chern. Phys. Letters, 1970, 5, 13; W. J. Hehre, R. Ditchfield, L. Radom, and J. A. Pople, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1970,92,4796.
Theoretical Chemistry
20
conserved. Mean absolute errors of ca. 13 kJ mol -l are found in these calculated energies of reaction using a rather small GTO basis set. The nuclear motions involved in internal rotation and inversion do not, in general, correspond to dissociative co-ordinates. Thus, one anticipates that the accompanyingchanges in correlation energy should be small. The ability of HartreeFock theory to provide reasonable estimates of the barriers to these motions as referred to previously, is thus understandable. In the case of diatomic systems, numerous calculations of the interaction potentials for two closed-shell atoms, e.g. He2, Ne2, A r 2 , Q 6 HeNe, ArNe, ArHe,97 or an atom and an ion, e.g. Li +Ne,Na +He,gs have demonstrated that the Hartree-Fock SCF method yields results which are accurate to within 0 . 1 4 . 5 eV over the total range of internuclear separations. Wahl 63 classifies the Hartree-Fock potential energy surfaces obtained for such systems as being ‘semi-quantitative’. The dispersion forces which operate between systems at large distances are a result of a small but significantcorrelativeinteraction of the motions of the electrons in the two systems. Thus, the polarization of the two systems resulting from this long-range correlative effect and the accompanying small change in energy are not accountedfor in the Hartree-Fock descriptionof the combined system. For example, the Hartree-Fock potential curves for He2, Ne2, and A r 2 , yield very good agreement with experimental data except for phenomena related directly to the van der Waals region of the curves.96The inability of the Hartree-Fock method to describe the long-range dispersive interactions is a relatively unimportant failing when one or more of the interacting systems is a polar or ionic species. In these instances, the shallow van der Wads minimum is eclipsed in importance by the much larger charge-dipole, or dipole-induced dipole interactions. In summary, the results in this and the preceding section illustrate that the LCAO-MO SCF approximation to the Hartree-Fock limit is a method which is capable of yielding semi-quantitative potential energy surfaces for closed-shell systems, with geometrical parameters characterizingminima in the surface given to within 1 or 2 %, with energy barriers given to ca. 4 kJ mol -l, and energies of reaction given to f.12 kJ mol-1 in favourable cases, and usually to within k 30 kJ mol -1. Early Examples of Surface Calculations for Closed-shell Systems.-The first LCAOMO SCF calculation of a reaction pathway on a potential surface for a reaction for the system between two closed-shell species was performed by ClementiQQ NHs HCl to form NH4CI. The calculation employed contracted sets of GTO’s; (I ls,7p)-+[5s,3p]for N, (6s,p)-+[3s,p] for H and ( 1 1 ~ ~ 7 ~[5s,4p] )for C1. Since the basis set does not contain any polarizing functions on the N and C1 centres, it will not yield results at the Hartree-Fock limit. For example, this basis set predicts a barrier height for the inversion motion in NHs which is almost twice as large as the experimental value, while as pointed out before, this same barrier is quantitatively accounted for at the Hartree-Fock limit. The HCl molecule was constrained to
+
98
y7 98
g9
T. L. Gilbert and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1967, 47, 3425. R. L. Matcha and R. K. Nesbet, Phys. Rev., 1967, 160, 72. M. Krauss, P. Maldonado, and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1971,54,4944. E. Clementi, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,46, 3851.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
21
approach, H end first, the N of NH3 along the CsVsymmetry axis. Any accompanying relaxation of the N H 3 geometry during the approach of HC1 was not allowed for. NO potential barrier was found along this reaction pathway, the energy decreasing monotonically to yield the N H K l molecule, with a predicted stability relative to separated NH3 and HCl of ca. 80 kJ mol-1. It had been anticipated that the reaction pathway for a proton transfer reaction should be characterized by a double minima in the potential surface.100 The failure of Clementi’s calculation to predict a barrier along the reaction pathway for the transfer of H + from HCl to NH3 to form NHaCl -, must be accepted with some caution in view of the lack of polarizing functions on N and C1 in the basis set. This work, however, broke new ground and Clementi99 includes in his paper a detailed discussion of the merits and faults to be expected for the Hartree-Fock method in the different regions of the potential surface. In the year following Clementi’s work, Ritchie and King reported LCAO-MO SCF calculations of the reaction pathways for the abstraction of a proton by Hfrom H2 and HF,101 from H20,102 and from NH3 and CH4.103 Only in the case of H- reacting with H2, did they predict a barrier to reaction (of 63 kJ mol-l in the linear approach). Intermediates were predicted in the reaction of H - with HF, a linear HHF- stable by 33 kJ mol-1 relative to reactants and with HzO, an HOH‘Hspecies, with an HOH bond angle of 105” and a linear arrangement for OHH predicted to be stabilized by 42 kJ mol -l relative to the products OH- and H2. The basis sets used in these calculations were reasonably large sets of GTO’s but consisted only of s- and p-type functions on all centres, While no d-type functions were included on the C, N, and 0 centres, no large changes in the bond angles about these centres were involved along the reaction pathways. Thus, their prediction of the absence of an energy barrier in the abstraction of a proton from CH4, N H 3 , or H2O may be correct, but the absence of any polarizing functions on the heavy-atom centres leaves the question in some doubt. The (5s,3p) set of GTO’s used in the HH2 calculation should yield results reasonably close to the Hartree-Fock limit (p-type functions account for most of the polarization in the region of a proton) and, a barrier to reaction was predicted just for this case. Tests of Parallel Nature of HF and Correlated Surfaces for Closed-shell Systems.To illustrate the sufficiency of an s- and p-type basis set for the description of a potential surface for a reaction involving only hydrogen and helium centres and to further illustrate the ability of a near Hartree-Fock surface for closed-shell systems to parallel a surface with much of the correlation included, we consider the reaction of H2 with HeH+ to form He H:. The relevant portions of this surface have been calculated by Benson and McLaughlinlo4in the near Hartree-Fock approximation using a GTO basis set consisting of (9s,lp) on He and (4s,lp) on H. The minimum energy pathway was found to exhibit a continuous CzVsymmetry with HeH + approaching along the bisector of the H2 internuclear axis. The reaction was
+
+
R. S. Mulliken and W. B. Pearson, ‘Molecular Complexes; A Lecture and Reprint Volume’,
loo
John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1969. C. D. Ritchie and H. F. King, J. Amer. Chem. SOC., 1968, 90, 825. C. D. Ritchie and € F. I. King, J . Amer. Chem. SOC.,1968, 90, 833. lo3C. D. Ritchie and H. F. King, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1968, 90, 838. 104 M. J. Benson and D. R. McLaughlin, J. Chem. Phys., 1972,56, 1322. lol
2
22
Theoretical Chemistry
predicted to be exothermic by 2.63 eV and no energy barriers or local minima were found along the reaction pathway. Benson and McLaughlin104 also calculated the energy of the system beyond the Hartree-Fock limit for five nuclear configurations; for the separated reactants and products and for three intermediate geometries along the reaction pathway.* These extended calculations yielded ca. 80% of the total correlation energy (i.e. 80% of the error in the Hartree-Fock approximation) for both sets of separated twoelectron species. The correlation energy calculated at each of these five points on the surface differed by no more than 10 kJ mol-1 from point to point. Thus, the Hartree-Fock SCF and nearly exact potential surfaces in the regions of the minimum energy pathway probably parallel one another to within 10 kJ mol-l. This result would not obtain over the complete surface for HeH;, a portion of which would correspond to the extension and breaking of the bond in H2. Fortunately, motion along the minimum energy pathway involves only a slight extension in the internuclear separation of H2, where Re(calc.) = 1.4 a.u., to form the product Hi, where Re(calc.) = 1.6 a.u. The calculations performed beyond the Hartree Fock limit sample geometries with both extremes of the H-H separation on the surface and in the product. The gross extension of one bond in a closed-shell system without the concomitant shortening of another, or a radical change in the manner in which the charge density of one bonded pair is distributed, will result in a loss of the parallel nature of the Hartree-Fock surface and the correct one. This situation has been thoroughly investigated and nicely illustrated for the four-electron system LiHi by Kutzelnigg, Staemmler, and Hoheisel.105 The scattering of Li+ ions by H2 molecules has been extensively studied by molecular beam techniques.106 The energies used in the experimental scattering studies are sufficient to allow the H2 molecule to be vibrationally excited into its sixth quantum level. Since the classical turning points of this vibrational level in H2 are 0.9 and 3.0 ax., it was necessary to calculate the potential hyper-surface over a region which included this range of H-H internuclear separations. Kutzelnigg et aZ.105 performed calculations for the LiHi system by a method which accounts for most of the correlation energy, the so-calledIEPA PNO method.? The implementation of this method of calculating the correlation energy, however, requires as its starting point a conventional Hartree-Fock SCF calculation. Consequently, these authors provide a description of the LiH; potential surface at the Hartree-Fock SCF level and at the (nearly) fully correlated level. A basis set of Gaussian lobe functions was employed, whose size was sufEcient to yield energies very close to the Hartree-Fock limit for H2 and Li+. The potential surface calculated with correlation included is claimed to parallel the true surface to within a maximum overall error of less than 0.002 a.u. (ca. 5 kJ mol -l).
* t
The calculations beyond the Hartree-Fock approximation were configuration interaction calculations (as discussed in Section 5) which employed the configurations arising from all the single and double excitations from the single, ground-state dete~ninant.10~ The details of the IEPA PNO method are given in Section 5 which deals with calculations beyond the Hartree-Fock limit.
lo5 108
W. Kutzelnigg, V. Staemmler, and C. Hoheisel, Chern. Phys., 1973, 1, 27. J. Schottler and J. P. Toennier, 2.Physik, 1968,214, 472; Chern. Phys. Letters, 1972, 12, 615.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
23
The LiHl potential energy surface was found to be characterized by the presence of an absolute energy minimum of 0.22 eV with respect to Li + H2 corresponding to an intermediate of CzVgeometry with an H-H separation r = 1.4 a x . and a Li to H-H bond midpoint separation R = 3.75 a.u. There is also a saddle point in the linear H-H-Li geometry for Y = 1.4 a.u. and R = 4.7 a.u. with a binding energy of 0.06 eV. The same LiH: surface has been investigated by Lester107,10* at close to the Hartree-Fock SCF limit. Lester’s calculations, however, were performed for only three values of the H-H separation r, 1.0. 1.4, and 2.0 a.u. Lester argued that the H2 correlation energy should be independent of R for a given r value, i.e. independent of the distance of the Li + ion from the midpoint of H2 for a given H-H separation. Kutzelnigg et ~71.105were able to demonstrate that this assumption, while nearly correct for small r, introduced errors for values of r greater than 2.0 a.u. Thus, in the linear approach of Li+ to H2 they found the correlation energy of the H2 electron pair for r = 3.0 a.u. to decrease from 0.0680 a.u. for R = 00 to 0.0437 a.u. for R = 2.0 a.u. This is explained by noting that in linear (LiHH)+, the bonded pair of Ha for close approach of Li+ is strongly polarized towards Li+ and the correlation energy approaches that of H-. For the CzV geometry, the correlation energy of the H2 electron pair changed by only 1.5 and 4.6 kJ mol-1 for R = a0 to R = 2.0 a.u. when r = 1.0 and 1.4 a.u., respectively. This same change in R values for r = 2.1 a.u. causes a change of 12.0 kJ mol-l in the H2 correlation energy, a value which increases to 30.2 kJ mol-1 for r = 3.0 a.u. Kutzelnigg et aZ.lo5also provided an analytical fit for their surface calculations suitable for trajectory calculations. White and Hayes lo9 have carried out quantum mechanical scattering studies on the Li+ + H2 system using a parametrized form of the Hartree-Fock SCF surface calculated by Lester.108 Gordon and Secrestl10 in calculating the potential surface for the He-H2 system also find that the near-Hartree-Fock SCF results parallel those obtained using correlated wavefunctions for those portions of the surface for which the H-H separation is held fixed at its equilibrium value. The portion of the surface for the HeHf-Hz system calculated by Benson and McLaughlin,lO* and referred to above, lies within the range of H-H separations found by Kutzelnigg et ~1.10~ to be adequately described at the Hartree-Fock limit. Their Hartree-Fock SCF results should, therefore, be accurate enough to warrant their use in classical trajectory calculations. Such calculations have indeed been performed by McLaughlin and Thompson.111 Spline interpolation functions were used to express the tabular near-HartreeFock energies in analytical form. The trajectory calculations for the reaction
+
HeH+
+
H2-+He
+ Hi +
2.6 eV
constrained to follow reaction pathways of CzVsymmetry, were performed for various values of the relative translation energies of approach and for internal vibrational W. A. Lester, J. Chem. Phys., 1970, 53, 1511. A. Lester, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 54, 3171. log R. A. White and E. F. Hayes, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 2985. no M. D. Gordon and D. Secrest, J. Chern. Phys., 1970, 52, 120. 111 D. R. McLaughlin and D. L. Thompson, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59,4393. lo7
lo8W.
24
Theoretical Chemistry
states of the reactants with quantum numbers 0 and 2. A detailed analysis of the partitioning of the available energy among the relative translational motion and the vibrational modes of the products is given, It is found that most of this energy ends up as vibrational energy in Hi, more than one-half of the collisions producing greater than 90 % vibrational energy conversion. HIi‘ Surfaces for A: + B.1nteractioms.There is another general class of diatomic AB systems for which the HartreeFock wavefunction for large internuclear separation passes properly into the product of the Hartree-Fock wavefunctions for A and B. This occurs when A possesses a closed shell and B has a half-filled orbital. Again, as Wahl has documented,63the Hartree-Fock SCF method yields ‘semi-quantitative’ potential curves for such systems. In the diatomic examples of such systems, no electron pair initially present is broken and no new one is formed, for example, Na(2S) He(%’) to form NaHe(2Z+) or He(4S’) + F(2P) to form HeF(211). While the same proper asymptotic behaviour of the Hartree-Fock wavefunction is also obtained in those cases where A and/or B are diatomic or polyatomic systems, e.g. H2 C1 to yield H + HCl, the Hartree-Fock method, in general, does not yield a ‘semi-quantitative’energy surface for such systems. In these cases the bonded pair and the unpaired electron exchange centres between reactants and products. The change in the correlation energy along the reaction pathway which is responsible for the loss of the parallel behaviour of the Hartree-Fock and correlated surfaces is frequently very large in the portion of the surface describing the transition state of the reaction. For example, in the reaction H + H2, the height of the barrier to reaction predicted at the single determinantal SCF level is approximately twice that obtained with a properly correlated function.112 The reaction of H2 + Cl to yield H HCl has been studied by Rothenberg and Schaeferll3 in a single determinant SCF calculation using a relatively large basis set of GTO’s with added polarizing functions. A linear reaction pathway is predicted, with a barrier height of 110 kJ mol -l and a saddle point geometry of R(H-H) = 1.78 a.u. and R(H-CI) = 2.76 ax., i.e. at a point where both the H2 and HCI equilibrium distances are expanded by ca. 0.37 a.u. The experimental Arrhenius activation energy is known for this system and is reported to be 23 kJ mol-1.114 While a calculated classical barrier height and the Arrhenius activation energy are not one and the same quantity,l12the calculated SCF barrier is obviously far too large. Another example of this type of behaviour is provided by the reaction H + F2-+HF + F for which a potential surface has been calculated by O’Neil and co-workers115 at the single-determinant SCF level of approximation and at a level which includes a significant fraction of the correlation energy. The transition state is again found to be linear with R(H-F) = 3.87 a.u. and R(F-F) = 2.97 a.u. These values correspond to more than a doubling of the H-F equilibrium separation and to an increase of 0.06 a.u. in the F-F equilibrium separation. This study is referred to in more detail later in this review. Here we wish to note that the height of the reaction barrier calculated for the above saddle point geometry was 51 kJmol-l at
+
+
+
112 113 114 115
I. Shavitt, R. M. Stevens, F. L. Miim, and M. Karplus, J. Chem. Phys., 1968,48, 2700. S. Rothenberg and H. F. Schaefer, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 10, 565. P. G. Ashmore and J. Chanmugan, Trans. Faraday SOC.,1953,49, 254. S. V. O’Neil, P. K. Pearson, H. F. Schaefer and C . F. Bender, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 1126.
25
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
the SCF level and only 4.2 kJ mol-l in the calculation which included electron correlation. The experimental activation energy is 5.0 kJ mol -1. Edmiston et al.116 have calculated the potential energy surface for the linear He%+ system at the Hartree-Fock SCF level and beyond this approximation. It was found that both the SCF and the correlated wavefunctions for HeHH+ predicted a potential energy minimum ca. 20 kJ mol -1 deep for R(J3e-H) N 2.0 a.u. and R(H-H) = 2.0 a.u. The correlation energy changed by ca. 7.1 kJmol-l when R(He-H) changed from 7.0 to 2.0 a.u. with R(H--H) held fixed at 2.0 a.u. However, the correlation energy changes by ca. 30 kJ mol -1 along the pathway for the formation of the linear symmetrical intermediate HHeH +. The above results indicate that the Hartree-Fock SCF method is, in general, not a suitable one for calculating the potential surface of a system in which a bonded pair and an unshared electron are exchanged between reactants and products, i.e. reactions of the type
-4-B
+
C.
A.
+B-4
In general, a significant change in the correlationenergy occurs between the reactants and the transition state and this appears to be true whether or not there is a correspondingly large change in the correlation energy between reactants and products. Thus, the reaction of H-H with C1*is predicted to be endothermic by 13 kJ mol-1 and the near Hartree-Fock estimate is 10 kJmol-1.113 Still, the barrier height for the reaction was approximately three times too large in the single-determinant SCF calculation. In the F-F + H-reaction the experimental and SCF values for the exothermicity of the reaction are very different, 429 and 554 kJmol-l, respe~tively.~15 and here again the barrier height predicted by the SCF calculation is many times too large. The only known exception to this inadequate description at the SCF level for this type of system appears to be that obtained for linear H e m + . This is understandable as the only strongly correlated pair in this system is the ls2 pair on He and this pair is not broken but rather only polarized in the formation of the intermediate HeHH + from H i and He. HF Surfaces for s N 2 Reactions.-We now return to the review of the reactions which have been studied at the single-determinantal SCF level of approximation. The majority of these studies have concentrated on mapping out the minimum energy pathways between reactants and products. Such reaction pathways for a number of s N 2 displacement reactions have been determined. The systems which have been most thoroughIy investigated are the following:
H-
+ CH4
3
[H-CHS-HI-
+ CH3F + [F--cE-IrF]H- + CH3F + [H-CH2F-H]H - + CH3F + [H--CH3-F]CN- + CH3F mC--CH3-F]F-
3
116
+ HCH3F + F+ CH3F + H + CH4 + F--+ CH3CN + F -
+ 4
CH4
(A) (B)
(C)
@I (E)
C.Edmiston, J. Doolittle, K. Murphy, K. C . Tang, and W. Wilson, J. Chern. Phys., 1970, 52, 3419.
26
Theoretical Chemistry
Van der Lugt and R o s ~ ~have ‘ investigated the geometry of the transition state for reaction (A). Mulder and Wright 118 have reported an energy barrier of 289 kJ mol-1 for (A) using an STO double-zeta basis set. They found that the minimum energy geometry for C q is of D3h symmetry, the transition state geometry required to explain the Walden inversion which is characteristic of s N 2 reactions. Other geometries for CH; were found to lie at least 230 kJ mol-1 above that for the D3h species. (The same authorsllS however, found that various geometrical configurationsof CH; differed very little in energy.) Ritchie and Chappell 119 have determined the pathway for reaction (A) using a (Ss, 3p/3s) set of GTO’s. The most thorough and detailed investigations of these reactions have been given by Veillard and co-workers86s87~120for reactions (A)-*@) and by Duke and Bader 88 for reactions (B) and (E). Both sets of workers used large GTO basis sets with polarizingp-type functions on the hydrogens and d-type functions on the carbon, nitrogen, and fluorine. For example, Duke and Bader used a basis set of above double-zeta quality to perform the geometry searches. (As mentioned before, geometrical parameters are better predicted employing a basis set short of that required for the Hartree-Fock limit.) The final energy calculations employed Huzinaga’s121 6s set for hydrogen contracted to three groups of two plus a set of p-type functions and Dunning’s (lOs, 6p) set for the first-row atoms contracted to [5s,3p]. Because of the diffuse nature of the charge distribution on CN- and F-, the basis sets for these species were further augmented by (optimized) diffuse s- and p-functions. Finally, a full set of d-functions were added to the basis sets for all first-row atoms. Without polarizing functions, both Veillard et aZ.86 and Duke and Baderas predict an intermediate rather than a transition state for reaction @). With polarizing functions, Veillard et al. obtain a reaction barrier of 33 kJ mol-1 for reaction (B) while with their slightly larger set, Duke and Bader obtain a value of 31 kJ mol-l. Both sets of authors, through thorough geometry searches, find the linear [FCH3F] complex of Dan symmetry to be the point of highest energy on the minimum energy path. Duke and Bader 88 repeated the determination of this energy barrier using two complete sets of polarizing d-type functions on all the first-row centres. Only a small change (- 0.8 kJ mol-1) in the activation energy was obtained, indicating that the basis sets containing the singte d functions were yielding results close to the s, p, d-type saturated description of the binding. Energy barriers were found for all five of the above reactions. Values of ca. 250 kJ mol-1 were calculated for reactions (A) and (C), 92 kJ mol -l for reaction (E), 29-33 kJ mol -l for reaction (B) and 17 kJ mol -l for reaction (D). Bohme et aLS9have experimentally measured the activation energies for a number of sN2 reactions in the gas phase using a flowing afterglow system.122They found the reactions of H -,NH,, OH -,F -, and C2H - with CH3C1 to proceed rapidly in the apparent absence of any significant activation barrier. In contrast, the reaction of C N - with CH3CI was surprisingly slow with an activation energy in excess of 21 117
118 119 l20
121
122
W, Th. A. M. Van der Lugt and P. Ros, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1969, 4, 389. J. J. C.Mulder and J. S. Wright, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1969, 5, 445. C. D. Ritchie and G. A. Chappell, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1970, 92, 1819. A. Dedieu and A. Veillard, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1972, 94, 6730. S. Huzinaga, J. Chem. Phys., 1965, 42, 1293. D. K. Bohme, R. S. Hemsworth, H. W.Rundle, and H. I. Schiff, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58,
3504.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
27
kJ mol-l. Also surprising were the observations that the reactions of €3-, NH,, OH-, C2H-,and CN- with CHsF were observed to be at least 100 times slower than the corresponding reactions with CH3Cl. For reaction @) above, Bohme et al. measured an activation energy of 15 kJ mol-1 compared to the value of 16 kJ mol -l calculated by Dedieu and Veillard.120 This experimental verification of the existence and even, in one case, the magnitude of activation barriers to gas phase s N 2 displacementson CHSFis very encouraging. While the reactions are all closed-shell systems with overall retention in the number of electron pairs, the transition states do represent a significantly different arrangement of two electron pairs. In gross terms, one lone pair of the nucleophile and the pair binding the leaving group in the substrate are both transformed into extended bonded pairs in the transition state. The experimental agreement with the theoretical barrier for reaction (D) suggests that no significant change in the correlation energy is encountered in the formation of the [I-I-CH3-F]- transition state. The reader is asked to recall that the magnitudes of simple inversion barriers are well accounted for in the Hartree-Fock method. Dedieu and Veillard120 have, in fact, reported a limited calculation of the correlation corrections to the energies of the reactants and transition state for reaction (B). The contributions of the correlation energy to the reactants and transition state differed by Zess than 4 kJ mol -l. However, Dyczmons and Kutzelnigg123 have also performed SCF calculations and calculations of part of the correlation energy for CH4, H - and the CH; transition state of Dan symmetry. They found an SCF activation barrier of 293 kJ mol-1 for reaction (A) (compared with ca. 250 kJ mol-1 obtained by Veillard et al.120),a value which is reduced to 230 kJ mol -1 with the inclusion of correlation into the wavefunctions. It is clear, however, that neither set of authors has approached the Hartree-Fock limit in their single-determinant SCF calculations. Thus, Dyczmons and Kutzelnigg obtain a somewhat better energy than Veillard et al. for CH4 + H-, but a somewhat poorer one for CH,. A striking feature of all five of these reactions is the delayed departure of the leaving group. Dedieu and Veillard120 have given a detailed discussion of the energetics and changes in charge density along the reaction pathways for reactions (At-@), including comparisons with the empirical rules for s N 2 reactions of Hammond,l2* Th0rnton,l2~ and Bunton.126 Bader, Duke, and Messer127 have presented an analysis of the changes in the energy and charge density for reactions (B) and (E) using the virial partitioning procedure. This is a partitioning method determined by the topological properties of the charge distribution, which yields a spatial partitioning of the charge and energy for a molecular system. The kinetic and potential energies of the molecular fragments obtained in this method obey the quantum mechanical virial and hypervirial (for the operator r- V) theorems.128 The fragment properties and changes in the fragment properties thus obtained possess direct physical significance. 123
lZ4 la5
l27 128
V. Dyczmons and W. Kutzelnigg, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1974,33, 239. G. S. Hammond, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1955, 77, 334. E. R. Thornton, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1967, 89, 2915. C. A. Bunton, ‘Reaction Mechanisms in Organic Chemistry’, ed. J. H. a d d , Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1963, vol. 1. R. F. W. Bader, A. J. Duke, and R. R. Messer, J. Amer. Chem. Soe., 1973, 95, 7715. S. Srebrenik and R. F. W. Bader, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 61,2536.
28
%oretical
Chemistry
Other Closed-shell HF Results.-Biirgi, Lehn, and Wipff 12Q have calculated the minimum energy pathway for the addition of H - to formaldehyde using an s-p GTO basis set. The system was chosen as a simple model for the nucleophilic addihave determined the reaction pathtion to a carbonyl group. Schaefer et ~21.~309131 way for the isomerization of CH3NC to CH3CN using a GTO basis set of doublezeta quality. This work was prompted by the prediction of Harris and Bunker132 that the isomerization of CH3NC may not follow RRKM theory of unimolecular reactions. Of particular importance to this argument was the nature of the barrier to the internal rotation of the methyl group as a function of the angle governing the extent of the swing of the isocyano group from the configuration -NC to -CN. In addition, Dewar and Kohn,I33 on the basis of semi-empirical MIND0 calculations, had predicted the existence of a stable triangular n-complexed intermediate along the reaction co-ordinate. Schaefer et aZ. have determined the potential energy surface as a function of the methyl rotational angle as well as a function of the swing angle of the isocyano group. They did not find a minimum in the potential path corresponding to the intermediate predicted by Dewar and Kohn. Yarkony et aL30 have calculated the potential surface for the interaction of two rigid HF molecules in an SCF calculation using a GTO basis set equivalent to double-zeta plus polarizing functions. The surface is to serve as the potentialfunction governing the pure rotational excitation and relaxation of H F gas. Because of the significant dipole-dipole interaction which leads to the formation of hydrogen bonded dimers in hydrogen fluoride, the inability of the Hartree-Fock method to account for dispersion forces is of only minor importance in these calculations. There is now a considerable body of evidence which suggests that the single-configuration SCF theory provides a qualitatively correct description of hydrogen bonding.134 A complete tabulation of their final energies for this HF-HF surface is presented. The authors experienced considerable difficulty in their attempt to cast their results into a convenient analytical form. Bader, Novaro, and Beltr6n-LopCz 135 have calculated the potential surface for various geometries of three and four helium atoms near to the Hartree-Fock limit to determine the deviation of the HartreeFock energies of interaction from pair-wise additivity. L i ~ c h k a has l ~ ~performed SCF calculations, using an s-p GTO basis set with polarizing functions, of the interaction potentials for the following pairs of systems; He-HF, H e H 2 0 , H2-HF, and H2-H20 all at large and intermediate separations. A calculation of the energy arising from the cross correlation of the electrons between the two systems was also performed. For these non-polar-polar molecule interactions at large distances, the SCF energies and the correlation corrections were found to be of almost equal magnitude in determining the potential energy minima. 129 130 131
l33
134 135 136
H.B. Biirgi, J. M. Lehn, and G. Wipff, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1974, 96, 1956. D. H.Liskow, C. F. Bender, and H. F. Schaefer, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1972, 94, 5178. D. H. Liskow, C. F. Bender, and H. F. Schaefer, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57,4509. H. H. Harris and D. L. Bunker, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 11, 433; D. L. Bunker, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 332. M.J. S. Dewar and M. C. Kohn, J. Am. Chem. SOC.,1972,94,2705. P. A. Kollman and L. C. Allen, Chem. Rev., 1972,72,283. R. F. W. Bader, 0. A. Novaro, and V. BeltrAn-Lopez, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 8, 568; 0. A. Novaro, and V. Beltrb-LopCz,J. Chem. Phys., 1972,56, 815. H.Lischka, Chem. Phys., 1973, 2, 191.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
29
Correctionsfor ImproperHF AsymptoticBehaviour.-There are two techniques which m a y be used to obtain results at what is essentially the Hartree-Fock limit over the complete range of some dissociative co-ordinate in those cases where the single deteminantal approximation goes to the incorrect asymptotic limit. These techniques are: (i) to describe the system in terms of a linear combination of some minimal number of determinantal wavefunctions (as opposed to just one);137 and (ii) to employ a single detenninantal wavefunction to describe the system but to allow different spatial orbitals for electrons of different spins - the so-called unrestricted Hartree-Fock method. Both methods have been used to determine the potential surfaces for the reaction of an oxygen atom in its 3Pand 1D states with a hydrogen molecule,138and we illustrate them through a discussion of this work. In general,63the correlation error in the Hartree-Fock method may be associated with two distinct causes: (a) the increase in correlation energy caused by forming new electron pairs and bringing more electrons into closer proximity with one another; and (b) the inability (in some cases) to describe correctly the dissociation of the molecule into fragments. As discussed in the next section, the correlation error m a y be eliminated by expanding the wavefunction in some complete set of determinantal wavefunctions, each of which represents a different arrangement or configuration of the electrons among the set of spin orbitals for the system. Hence the method is called configuration interaction. The interesting point for the present discussion is that in general the configurations which must be added to correct for the two possible deficiencies of the Hartree-Fock method, (a) and (6) above, are usually quite distinct. Thus, one may add some minimum number of configurations to obtain the correct Hartree-Fock description of the dissociation products. The contributions of such configurationsare, however, generally not important for those ~ ~ internuclear separations requiring close separations where bonding O C C U T S , ~ i.e. the type of correlation in (a) above. For such regions, one must add additional configurations which exist for the molecule, but which vanish formally in the atoms. They are termed molecular configurations and their contribution to the energy lowering of the system is called extra-molecular correlation energy.63 There is a long and continuing interest in the differences which exist between the chemistry of the singlet and triplet forms of one reactant, e.g. O(P,lD); S(3P,1D,1S), and C H Z ( ~ B ~ , ~In A~ particular ). is the differing abilities of the singlet and triplet forms to undergo insertion and abstraction reactions. To gain an understanding of these systems, potential surfaces were determined for the model system of O(3P,1D) with Ha(lX;) to yield HzO(3B1,lAl) on insertion or OH(2II) H(2S)on abstraction. In the study of the insertion of O(1D)into H2(lZ;) to yield ground state HiO(lA1) it is possible to augment the Hartree-Fock single determinantal wavefunction for this system with just two determinantal wavefunctions such that one obtains the correct limiting Hartree-Fock description of O(1D) and H2(1Xl). At the same time, however, these two configurations make a negligible contribution to the description of the water molecule in the region of its equilibrium geometry. Thus, one has what
+
137 188
180
A. Pullman and G. N. J. Port, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1973, 32, 77. R. F. W. Bader and R. A. Gangi, Chern. Phys. Letters, 1970, 6, 312; R. F. W. Bader and R. A. Gangi, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1971, 93, 1831. E. R. Davidson, Rev. Mod. Phys., 1972,44,451.
Theoretical Chemistry
30
is an essentially Hartree-Fock description of the total dissociation process of HzO(lA1) into O(1D) + Hz(lZi). The two added configurations become increasingly important as the separation of the products increases and provides a smooth and continuous correlation of the energy surface with that of the Hartree-Fock energies of the products. One must avoid the indiscriminate mixing of additional configurations in configuration interaction calculations, if one is to avoid spurious results because of an 'unbalanced' ~ e t . Thus, ~ 3 it is best either to add the minimum number of configurations to just correct the asymptotic difficulties, or to add a very large number of configurations using selection criteria, as discussed below. The ground-state electronic configuration of H2O is given by (lai)2(~i)2(lbz)2(3a1)2(lbi)2 'A1, @ I
In a minimal basis set description, la1 corresponds to the Is on oxygen, 2a1 to 2s on oxygen plus some mixing in of H' 1s orbitals, 162 is the 2py on oxygen and its overlap with the H 1s orbitals, 3al is primarily 2pz on oxygen plus some H 1s orbitals and lbl is the 2pz orbital, a lone pair on oxygen perpendicular to the molecular plane. In the neighbourhood of the equilibrium geometry, the first virtual orbital is 4a1, a diffuse s-like (3s) Rydberg orbital centred on oxygen. At the limit of separation of H2 from O(lD), the 3al and 1b2 orbitals interchange their energy ordering and 3a1 passes smoothly into the 1offorbital of HZand lbz becomes a pure 2pu orbital on oxygen. At this same limit, the 4al orbital becomes the 2pz orbital on oxygen. The orbital description of one component of the open-shell H2O system at the H2(lX;) O ( l 0 ) limit is given by
+
where @pz and
Ip3
are determinantal wavefunctions derived from the configurations (la1)z(2a1)2(3a1>2(1b2)2(4a1)2lAi, @ 2
(1 a1)2(2a1)2(3a1)2( 1b ~ ) ~ ( k'iA)1,~@ 3
All three component wavefunctions involve double occupation of the 3ai (= 1og of H2) orbital. The description of O(1D) is given by the linear combination Pwith the 3a1 orbital omitted. Hence, Y as written above corresponds to an (antisymmetrized) product of the HartreeFock wavefunctions for H2 and O(l0). It is generally found that if one increases the flexibility of a single-determinantal wavefunction by allowing each space orbital to assume an independent form (rather than insisting on double occupation by an ~1 and a electron for those orbitals which would otherwise be so occupied as dictated by the electronic configuration) that the asymptotic difficulties of the wavefunction are removed. Thus, the unrestricted Hartree-Fock method usually predicts the correct dissociation products of a molecular system.140 The symmetrical (CZ,)insertion of O(V) into H2 yields the 3B1 state of the HzO system. The electronic configuration of this state expressed in terms of the unrestricted set of orbitals is
A. W.Salotto and L. Burnelle, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1969, 3, 80.
31
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
where the bar denotes a @ spin function and its absence an oc spin function. The asymptotic forms of the orbitals are the same as the restricted counterparts for the lA1 state and the single determinantal wavefunction composed of the unrestricted orbitals correctly yields a product wavefunction for ground state Ha and O(3P). The singlet insertion reaction was determined using the limited configuration interaction treatment outlined above.l3* The singlet abstraction reaction O(1D)
+ H2('2;)
+
OHH(2U)
OH(2II)
+ H(2S)
and the triplet insertion and abstraction surfaces were calculated using the unrestricted Hartree-Fock method. The surfaces were first mapped out using a (5s3p/2s)STO basis set for the singlets and a (6s3pl2s) set for the triplets, the extra (low exponent) s function in the triplet case being required to describe the very diffuse nature of the triplet charge distribution. Calculations were then performed for selected points along the minimum energy paths using a large basis set which consisted of (lOs,5p,2d/4s,lp)+ [5s,3p,2d/2s,lp],for the singlets and the same set but with 11s functions contracted to 6s functions for the triplet surfaces. The minimum energy pathways for the singlet and triplet insertion reactions with geometries determined by the small basis set but with energies determined at the corresponding points using the large basis sets are shown in Figure 1 . After a small initial increase in energy at large separations, the symmetrical insertion of O(1D)
-75-7
1 1 (2.76) .
-75.8
--
(3.43)
(1.55) .
J
-*
~
----- - - - - __ _ _
/
(1.41) i-
O('m H,+(IZg+)
. 0(3P) + Hd'&
Figure 1 The minimum energy paths for the singlet and triplet symmetrical insertion reactions to produce the IAI, 3 B ~and , IBI states of HaQ. The bracketed values are the optimum H-H internuclear separations for each value of ro, the distance of the oxygen from the midpoint of H-H axis (Reproduced by permission from J. Chem. Phys., 1971,55,5369)
32
Theoretical Chemistry
into H2(lZi) is an energy releasing process to yield ground-state H20(1A1). The continued approach of oxygen along the Cz2)co-ordinate yields the linear form of ground-state water, which is predicted to lie 138 kJ mol -l above that of the equilibrium geometry. Further calculationsl41indicate that the CzUapproach is the minimum energy one until the oxygen is ca. 3 a.u. from H2. When the oxygen is in the region between 3 and 2 a.u. from the midpoint of the H2 molecule, the potential surface assumes a double minimum character with respect to motion of the oxygen off the C Zsymmetry axis. In this region of the surface, the minimum energy approach corresponds to the oxygen lying ca. 30" off the bisector. For distances less than 2 a.u. the preferred approach of oxygen is again along the C2 axis, The symmetrical insertion of O(3P) into H2 results in a barrier of approximately 335 kJ mol-1 and yields a linear metastable intermediate. For distances of approach of O(3P)to H2 less than 3.0 a.u., the triplet insertion path is unstable to an unsymmetrical motion of the nuclei which leads to OH(211) and H(2S). The energy minimum on the symmetric triplet path is therefore, a saddle point and does not represent a stable nuclear configuration for triplet water. The linear abstraction reaction possesses an energy of activation of 103 kJ mol-l.13* However, at an acute angle of approach of O(lD) towards Hz, the activation energy for the formation of OH(2II) and H(2S) decreases to 70 kJmol-1. This energy is small enough to account for the formation of OH radicals which are also found as products in O(1D) insertion reactions. The linear triplet abstraction reaction requires an activation barrier of 147 kJ mol-l. All points on the triplet surface were found to be connected by downhill paths to either the reactants or H(2S) OH(2II). One can summarize the chemistry contained in these potential surfaces by stating that singlet oxygen inserts by choice and abstracts by chance, while triplet oxygen abstracts by necessity. The lB1 surface of the H2O system has also been calculated and a general discussion of the correlation of the states produced when singlet and triplet oxygen are added to H2(1Zi) has been given.141 From these latter considerations, the existence of a conical intersection, of the type first postulated by Teller,142was predicted to occur as a result of the crossing of the 1 C l and lIT surfaces which result when the ground and first excited 1A1 states assume linear geometries. This conical intersection yields a pathway for the dissociation of ground-state water into H(2S)and OH(2Z f) as opposed to OH(211). Also, if the B ~ A state I of water is linear in its most stable configuration, as now seems certain,l43$144 and if there is an energy barrier to dissociation from this state when the molecule is bent, but not when it is linear, then one would expect that dissociation into OH(211) H(2S) would occur when the molecule is excited into the BIA1 state. Flouquet and Horsley145 have recently published a study of the potential energy surface of the B1A1 surface of H2O in the SCF approximation and with some limited configuration interaction. They found the form of the surface for this state
+
+
R. A. Gang and R. F. W. Bader, J. Chem. Phys., 1971,55, 5369. E. Teller, J. Phys. Chem., 1937, 41, 109. 143J. A. Horsley and W. H. Fink, J. Chem. Phys., 1969,50, 750. 144 J. W. Moskowitz and M. C. Harrison, J. Chem. Phys., 1965,43,3550; C. R. Claydon, G. A. Segal, and H. S. Taylor, ibid., 1971, 54, 3799. 146 F. Flouquet and J. A. Horsley, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 3767. 141 141
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
33
to be dominated by the conical intersection with the ground-state surface in the linear geometry, as postulated above. The dissociation of H2O into the BlAl state to give the OH(2E+) fragment with a highly abnormal rotational distribution is discussed in the light of the calculated surface. Murrell, Pedley, and Durmazl46 in a study of the potential surface for the symmetrical (C2,) insertion of singlet and triplet CH2 into H2(1C,'), obtain results similar in their principal features to those shown in Figure 1 for the corresponding insertion of O(l0) and O(3P) into H2. Methylene and the oxygen atom are isoelectronic and the three lowest states of linear (or bent) CH2 correlate in terms of symmetry and in terms of the states produced in reaction with H2 on C2, approach with those of the O(3P,lD) H2(lCi) system. Thus, the ground state of CH2 is 3C,(3B1) which gives a 3B1 surface on combination with H2, corresponding to the lowest 3B1surface of H20 from O(3P).The first excited singletstateis 1A&A1 + 1B1) and as in the reaction of O(1D) with H2, gives rise to lA1 and 1B1 states for the adduct with H2. Their calculations were performed using a minimum set of STO's without configuration interaction or the use of the unrestricted Hartree-Fock method. Consequently, their computed surfaces and reaction paths are not continuous from reactants to products. Their overall results, however, parallel those found for the H2O system. (Compare their Figure 7 with Figure 1 here.) The insertion of the singlet form of CR2 into H ' 2 to form ground state CH4 is found to be energetically favourable with little or no activation barrier when the system is allowed to distort from CzVsymmetry. The insertion of triplet methylene into Ha requires passage of the system over a large energy barrier and into a small well to form the triplet state of CH4, the most stable geometry of which is found to have a square-planar structure. This behaviour is again analogous to the O(3P) H2(lc,') CzVinsertion path. Baskin et aZ.147 have calculated the reaction pathway for the abstraction of H from H2 by methylene at both the SCF level and at a level which yielded a considerable fraction of the correlation energy. A doublezeta basis set of contracted GTO's was employed in the calculation. The surface was calculated as a function of three geometrical parameters: R,the distance of the carbon atom from the closer of the two hydrogen atoms of H2; r, the H-H separation of H2 and 8, the methylene bond angle. The study was restricted to an end-on approach of H-H along the CzVaxis of CH2. The reaction exothermicity was predicted to be 22.5 kJ mol -1, compared to the experimental value148 of 19 kJ mol-l. The saddle point was found to OCCUT at R = 2.640 a.u., r = 1.702 a.u., and 6 = 126.5", a geometry intermediate between that of reactants and products. An activation barrier of 65 kJ mol-l was calculated for this abstraction, a value which is consistent with the observation that no abstraction of H from H2 by CH2 could be detected at 300 K.149 The geometry determined at the SCF level of approximation was very similar to that obtained with the correlated wavefunction, but the activation barrier predicted by the SCF procedure was much higher, 105 kJ mol -l. The authors concluded their
+
+
N. Murrell, J. B. Pedley, and S. Durmaz, J.C.S. Faraday ZI, 1973, 69, 1370. C. P. Baskin, C. F. Bender, C. W. Bauschlicher, jun., and H. F. Schaefer, J. Amer. Chem. SOC., 1974,96,2709. R. W. Carr, J. Phys. Chem., 1972,76, 1581. W. Braun, A. M. Bass, and M. Pilling, J. Chem. Pltys., 1970, 52, 5131.
1413 J. 147 148 149
34
Theoretical Chemistry
paper with a discussion of possible definitions of ‘reaction pathways’ or ‘reaction co-ordinates’. Guest, Murrell, and Pedley150have used a minimum basis set of STO’s in an SCF study of the potential surface of CH,+and its formation from H2 and CHg. The approach of H2 to CH$ was found to proceed with no barrier to activation to yield CH; whose most stable geometry was found to be of Cssymmetry. Dixon,l51 using a GTO basis set of double-zeta quality has determined a potential surface for CH; to study the Jahn-Teller distortions which occur in the 2T2 state of tetrahedral geometry. The most stablizing distortion is found to be a tetragonal one, leading to a geometry of D2a symmetry. This leads to an energy lowering of 1.41 eV as compared with the next most favourable motion which yields a species of CsV symmetry stablized by 1.22 eV. Vibronic perturbation parameters are derived from this surface and employed in a discussion of the 2Tz_1A~ photoelectron transition. Single determinant unrestricted Hartree-Fock calculations have been carried out for the H CH4 system in a study of the reaction pathways for hydrogen exchange and abstraction reactions.152 The same technique has been used to determine the is predicted to have a pyramidal possible dissociative paths of H ~ 0 . This l ~ radical ~ equilibrium geometry with a low inversion barrier of ca. 8 kJ mol-l. The barrier to dissociation into H20(lA1) + H(2S) is found to be 28 kJ mol-1. The NH4 system, again studied by the unrestricted Hartree-Fock method, was found to have a tetrahedral equilibrium geometry, a 2A1 electronic state, and exist in a potential well isolated from the products NH3(lA1) + H(2S) by a minimum barrier (for a C3e dissociative pathway) of ca. 92 kJ mol-1.154 The work of Ehrenson and Newton152has shown that the most stable geometry of CH5, a structure of D3h symmetry, corresponds to a saddle point on the reaction pathway for hydrogen exchange. Thus, of the three radicals, A H n +I, CH5 is unstable, OH3 possesses only a slight stability, but NH4 is predicted to require at least 84 kJ mol-1 for its decomposition and should be an isolatable species. €IFDescription of Addition to Double Bonds.-Another interesting aspect of the chemistry of the singlet and triplet species of 0, S, and CH2 concerns the stereospecificity or its absence in their addition to substituted ethylenes. Strausz et aZ.155 have used as s-p GTO basis set to study the addition of S(3P) and S(l0) to ethylene in an SCF calculation. The addition of S(3P) to an ethylene is a stereospecific one in contradistinction to the additions of O(3P)or C H Z ( ~ B ~Strausz ). et al. find that the lower triplets of the addition product of S(3P) and ethylene, thiirane, all possess a ring-opened geometry in which the terminal methylene is in a plane perpendicular to the CCS plane and that a considerable energy barrier exists with respect to rotation of the terminal methylene group. This description of the adduct nicely accounts for the stereospecificity of the addition reaction with S(3P). In the addition of O(3P) to ethylene, a ring-opened geometry is again ~ r e d i c t e d . 1However, ~~ the barrier to
+
150 151 152 153 154
155 156
M. F. Guest, J. N. Murrell, and J. B. Pedley, Mol. Phys., 1971, 20, 81. R. N. Dixon, Mof. Phys., 1971, 20, 113. S. Ehrenson and M. D. Newton, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 13, 24. R. A. Gangi and R. F. W. Bader, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 11, 216. J. Pelletier and R. F. W. Bader, unpublished results. 0. P. Strausz, H. E. Gunning, A. S. Denes, and I. G. Csizmadia, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 1972, 94, 8317. M. E. Stephens, R. A. Gangi, and R. F. W. Bader, unpublished results.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
35
the rotation of the end methylene group is, in this instance, calculated to be only ca. 17 kJ mol -l. Thus, theory predicts a non-stereospecific reaction in the addition of O(3P)to substituted olefins as is indeed found to be true experimentally. Haines and C~izmadia15~ have investigated possible modes of addition of NH to ethylene to form aziridine in an SCF calculation using an s-p GTO basis set. Aziridine is predicted to be formed in its first excited triplet state, a state which again corresponds to a ring-opened intermediate. Shih et d 1 5 * have performed SCF and SCF plus configuration interaction calculations of the reaction surface for the addition of NH2 to ethylene. They found a high energy of activation (150-170 kJmol-l) for this addition, which again is predicted to yield a ring-opened intermediate. Electrocyclic Reactions.-Peyerimhoff, Buenker, and co-workers have carried out very detailed studies of the electrocyclictransformations159between cyclic and openchain hydrocarbons. The calculations employ a large GTO set of s-and p-type basis functions. In every study, the necessity of including limited configuration interaction was carefullyinvestigated. The prototype electrocyclictransformation of cyclobutene to cis-butadiene via the thermochemical process has been studied in detail.l6O9161 The same authors also give an analysis of the qualitative theories for such reactions based on their ab initio calculations.16a A similar study of the electrocyclic transformations of cyclopropyl and alIyl systems has also been made.163 Horsley et al.164 have determined a reaction pathway for the geometrical isomerization of cyclopropane by a calculation and search of the full 21-dimensional hypersurface! The calculations were performed using a minimal basis set of STO’s in a modified SCF calculation using the restricted Hartree-Fock formalism suggested by Nesbet.165 In the region of the trimethylene diradical, a 3 x 3 configuration interaction calculation was included. Ion Solvatiom-Clementi and co-workers have embarked on an ambitious study of the hydration of simple ions and the structure of liquid water and ionic solutions. The studies are primarily at the SCF single determinantal level using relatively large basis sets of GTO’s with added polarizing functions. Potential energy surfaces have been determined for a water molecule in the fields of a Li + ion,f66 Na + and K ions 167 and F- and Cl- ions.168 The geometry searches in all of these studies were wide ranged and very detailed. In two further publicationsl69g.170a very detailed Hartree-Fock computation of the potential surface for the water dimer (with rigid +
I57 158
W. J. Haines and I. G. Csizmadia, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1973, 31, 283. Shingkuo Shih, R. J. Buenker, S. D. Peyerimhoff, and C. J. Michejda, J. Amer. Chem. SOC., 1972,94,7620.
R. B. Woodward and R. Hoffmann, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1965, 87, 395. 160 K. HSU,R. J. Buenker, and S. D. Peyerimhoff, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1971,93, 2117. 161 K. HSU,R. J. Buenker, and S. D. Peyerimhoff, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1972,94, 5639. l a a R. J. Buenker, S. D. Peyerimhoff, and K. Hsu, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 1971, 93, 5005. 163 P. Merlet, S. D. Peyerimhoff, R. J. Buenker, and S. Shih, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1974,96, 959. 164 J. A. Horsley, Y.Jean, C. Moser, L. Salem, R. M. Stevens, and J. S. Wright, J . Amer. Chem. SOC.,1972, 94, 279. 165
166 167
16* 169
R. K. Nesbet, Rev. Mod. Phys., 1963, 35, 552. E. Clementi and H. Popkie, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 1077. H. Kistenmacher, H. Popkie, and E. Clementi, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 1689. H. Kistenmacher, H. Popkie, and E. Clementi, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 5627. H. Popkie, H. Kistenmacher, and E. Clementi, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 1325. H. Kistenmacher, H. Popkie, E. Clementi, and R. 0. Watts, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 4455.
36
Theoretical Chemistry
internal geometries) was performed and subsequently used in a Monte Carlo simulation of the liquid state of water. This was done by fitting an analytical expression to the computed interaction potential and then using this analytical expression as an effective pair potential for the description of liquid water. The Monte Carlo calculations were performed with the SCF potentia1169.170 and with the SCF potential modified by a semi-empirical correction for the correlation energy. The Hartree-Fock effective pair potential gave a realistic representation of the structure of liquid water but predicted poor thermodynamic properties. The discrepancies were reduced with the empirically correlated pair potential. Schuster and Preuss 171 have also carried out calculations, near to the Hartree-Fock limit for the systems Li +-H20 and Be2+-H20. Pullman and co-workers172.173 have initiated a study of the hydration of molecules of biochemical interest at the SCF level of approximation. The hydration of formamide by a single water molecule has been studied at the SCF level using a (7s,3p/3s) set of GTO’s contracted to one of minimal size.174 Various possible configurations of the H20-NH2CHO complex are considered - hydrogen bonding with the carbonyl group, to the amino group, in the C-H region and finally the possibility of n hydrogen bonding. The relative conformations of the H2O and formamide molecules were also carefully studied for each of these configurations. A similar study on the hydration of methyl and ethyl ammonium ions has also been carried out 175 using a minimal STO basis set, with each STO approximated by three GTO functions.l76 Alkylammonium groups occur frequently in pharmacologically active molecules and changes in the interaction of such groups with water on modification of the alkyl groups is thought to account for the accompanying changes in the drug’s activity.
5 Beyond Hartr-Fock The motion of each electron in the HartreeFock approximation is solved for in the presence of the average potential of all the remaining electrons in the system. Because of this, the Hartree-Fock approximation, as discussed earlier, does not provide an adequate description of the repulsion between pairs of electrons. If the electrons have parallel spin, they are effectively kept apart in the Hartree-Fock method by the antisymmetric nature of the wavefunction, producing what is commonly known as the Fermi hole. Electrons of opposite spin, on the other hand, should also avoid each other, but this is not adequately allowed for in the HartreeFock method. The avoidance in this latter case is called the Coulomb hole. Thus, if a proper account of electronic interactions is to be made, the motion of all the electrons must be correlated so that the position of one depends on the instantaneous position of the other, rather than on the average position of the other
174
P. Schuster and H. W. Preuss, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 11, 35. A. Pullman and M. J. Port, Compt. rend., 1973, 277,2269. M. Dreyfus, B. Maigret, and A. Pullman, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1970, 17, 109. G.Alagona, A. Pullman, E. Scrocco, and J. Tomasi, Internat. J. Peptide Protein Res., 1973,
176
5, 251. G. N. J. Port and A. Pullman, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1973, 31, 231. W. G. Hehre, R. F. Stewart, and J. A. Pople, J. Chem. Phys., 1969,51, 2657.
171 172 179
37
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
electrons. The method of configuration interaction first discussed by Hylleraasf77 in 1928, is one of the oldest techniques used to surmount this problem. In configuration interaction (a), one mixes states arising from different spinorbital configurations.In theory, one may expand the exact solution to Schrodinger’s electronic equation (equation 5 ) in terms of the complete (infinite) set of determinantal wavefunctions, which in turn are constructed from some complete set of oneelectron spin orbitals.33 This is obviously not a practical solution, and one must find instead, a smaller number of determinantal functions formed from the complete set which will give a close approximation to the true solution. A CI state function Yi is expressed as a linear combination of the determinantal wavefunctions @5 formed from configurations of identical symmetry and spin,
vt
= CCS@5,
= 1,2,3,...
(24)
j
The coefficients of mixing, Ccp, and the energies E(CI)r of the resulting CI states are found by solving the set of secular equations:sa [H-E(CI)bqC = 0
A restricted Hartree-Fock calculation on a closed-shell n-electron system using a basis set of N orbitals will produce n/2 doubly-occupied molecular orbitals and N-n/2 vacant or virtual orbitals. In a standard CI calculation, the excited-state determinants are formed by systematically promoting electrons from the occupied orbitals of the ground-statedeterminant to the vacant or virtual orbitals. The number of configurations which can be formed in this way from N electrons and n basis functions17*is of the order of nN. Thus, even with today’s high speed computers, a ‘full’ CI is possible only for very small systems. Minimal Co&guration Interaction.-A minimum requirement of a potential energy surface is that the wavefunction continuously describe the system as the reaction takes place, producing reactants and products in their correct states. In order for this situation to be obtained, the correlation error must either be taken fully into account or at the very least, be approximately constant over that portion of the potential energy surface under consideration. As discussed and illustrated in the previous section, one should at least perform a limited configuration interaction in which those configurations needed to provide the correct description of the dissociation products are included. Truncated CI Wavefunctions.-Between the limits of a minimal and a ‘full’ configuration interaction one is faced with the problem of choosing how many configurations and more importantly, which configurations are to be included. A computational problem arises because of the very slow convergence, generally 1’7 17*
E. A. Hylleraas, Z. Physik, 1928, 48,469. Z. Gershgorn and I. Shavitt, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1968, 2, 751.
Theoretical Chemistry
38
obtained in the CI expansion. The convergence is slow in a standard CI calculation because the virtual orbitals used to form the excited configurations do not occupy the same physical space as do the occupied orbitals. Thus, the electrons in the virtual orbitals move in the field of all N electrons and not in the field of N- 1 electrons as do those in occupied orbitals. Within the standard CL framework, there are three methods of selecting the ‘most important’ configurations to be included. The first is achieved by disregarding configurations which, because of Brillouin’s theorem,42a have vanishing coefficients. For closed-shell systems, this occurs when the ground state differs from the excited state by only one spin-orbital. The matrix element between two configurations p in q, can be written as and q differing in just one spin-orbital, ua in p and Hpq =
+ j #i,m C (
rzI -l)udk)uj(l)>
-
) This can be rewritten in terms of the Hartree-Fock operator (equations 17 and 18) as H P 4
= (ui(k)lA(k)
+
CG(k)lum(M) j
From equation (17) w p q
= Em
The orthogonality relationship given in equation (12) then leads us to H p q =
0
It is important to note that Brillouin’s theorem does not state that singly-excited states do not contribute to the total energy of the system since matrix elements between this state and states other than the ground state, doubly-excited states for example, will in general be non-zero. What is stated is that they will make no firstorder contribution to the total energy. An important implication of Brillouin’s theorem is the guarantee of no first-order errors for all one-electron operators provided the exact Hartree-Fock wavefunctions are used.42b This follows because the first-order correction to the correlation effect is derived from two-electron excitations. The second approximation often used to truncate CI wavefunctions is to neglect configurations formed by more than two-electron excitations. It is easily seen that they cannot mix into the CI wavefunction in first order. The third method comes from perturbation theory. If one takes the Hartree-Fock energy as the zeroth-order approximation to the energy Eo =
(281
and assumes that the Hartree-Fock function 00dominates the wavefunction, then the energy correct to second order is
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
39
The denominator of the second term on the right is merely the ‘excitation energy’ between the ground state and the excited state k. Therefore, if the state k is one of very high energy, it will contribute relatively little to the total energy of the system. In obtaining an approximate CI wavefunction, one usually neglects states of this type with small introduction of error. The above methods of truncating the ‘full’ CI wavefunction can be greatly improved upon by transforming the molecular orbitals into natural orbitals - a method which will now be discussed. The generalized oneelectron density function is defined as
s
P(’)(xI;x~= N @(XI,~
..
2 , . XN)@*(X;,
.
~ 2 , . .XN) dx2..
.dxnr
(30)
Using the determinantal wavefunction given in equation (11) one can expand p(l)(xr,xi) in terms of spin-orbitals
where the &/ are numerical coefficients. For the CI wavefunction given in equation (24) the density matrix can be written as
where pgL is the first-order transition matrix defmed as in equation (30)where @ and @* are replaced by @ K and ,@: determinants which differ only in one spinorbital (uk:in @ K and uzin @L) and the spin-orbitals are assumed to be orthonormal. The first-order density matrix can now be written in terms of these spin-orbitals as
Since p(l)(xl;x;) is Hermitian, i.e.,
the coefficients form a Hermitian matrix so that a unitary transformation exists which diagonalizes the y. UfyU
=
n
If we now define a new set of spin-orbitals by Xk
= XuZUZk E
the first-order density matrix can be written in terms of the transformed orbitals P(’)(xI;xi) = Cxm(xl)xXxhn 112
The Xm are called the natural spin-orbitals (NSO) of @ and the rtm are the occupation numbers. The occupation numbers indicate the importance of each orbital Xm to the total CI wavefunction.
40
Theoretical Chemistry
The natural spin-orbitals, which were first introduced by Lowdin179in 1955, were shown to produce the most rapidly convergent expansion of the first-order density matrix.lsOThus, the number of determinants needed for any required degree of accuracy in the wavefunction can be greatly reduced if the determinantal wavefunctions are constructed from natural orbitals at each stage in the calculation. The most dramatic indication of the convergence property of NSO’s can be seen in the work of Hagstrom and Shulll*l on H2. Using a basis set of 15 functions, a full configuration interaction (33 configurations) was performed. The first-order density matrix was then diagonalized and the occupation numbers of all but 15 of the natural spin-orbitals were found to be zero. The energy of - 1.1731 a.u. accounts for 97 % of the correlation energy. The energy was then evaluated after eliminating those NSO’s with small but non-zero occupation numbers. The energies computed with the three and five spin-orbitals with highest occupation numbers were - 1.1607 a.u. (66% of the correlation energy) and - 1.1704 a.u. (90% of the correlation energy), respectively. The effectiveness of NSO’s in reducing the expansion size in systems with more than two electrons is not as great and, in fact, for larger systems, their use is not practical. The loss in practicality is immediately obvious when one realizes that in order to obtain them, one must diagonalize the first-order density matrix of the ‘exact’ wavefunction, i.e. a ‘full’ configuration interaction must first be performed. Two methods have been introduced in order to regain the initial usefulness of natural orbitals: the pseudonatural orbital method and the approximate or iterative natural orbital method. In the pseudo-natural orbital (PSNO) method,l82 a natural orbital calculation is performed on selected pairs of electrons in the Hartree-Fock field of the n-2 electron core. These orbitals are then used as a basis for a CI calculation. In their work on the HeH+ system, for which the orbital occupancy is l
1B0 181
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
41
repeated until successive iterations yield no change. In their work on LiH, Bender and Davidsonlss began with 50 configurations. Their final 45-configuration wavefunction contains ca. 87% of the correlation energy. It is of interest to compare these results with a calculation done later by the same investigators,l87 in which they included all single and double excitations. This latter work resulted in an energy 0.0002 a.u. higher than the IN0 calculation. Although as many as four or five CI calculations may be needed to achieve convergence using this method, the scope of each CI calculation is much smaller than that needed for one extensive conventiond CI including many configurations (938 in the LiH case). In contrast to the relationship between virtual and occupied orbitals, natural orbitals are localized in the same regions of physical space. The strong coupling thus produced by the overlap of ground-state and excited orbitals effectively lowers the energy of the system. Another method which achieves the same purpose and therefore improves the convergence of a CI expansion is the multiconfiguration selfconsistent field (MCSCF) method. The method can be described as one which ensures that both the CI coefficients [Ctj in equation (24)] and the molecular orbital coefficients [crj in equation (22)J have been varied to minimize the energy. A doublyiterative process is used which, upon convergence, yields the optimum orbitals and the optimum configurationalmixing coefficientsfor the basis sets used. The optimization of the orbitals ensures that the virtual orbitals are in the same physical space as the occupied orbitals. This means that generally, many fewer configurations are needed in the MCSCF method as compared to a conventional CI calculation in order to achieve the same results. This MCSCF method was first used on the oxygen atom by Hartree, Hartree, and Swirles in 1939.lS8A recent example of the application of the MCSCF method is found in the work of Das and Wahllsga on the F2 molecule. As in a conventional CI calculation, the problem of selecting important configurations still exists in the MCSCF method. Das and Wahl considered three classes of configurations in what they call the optimized valence configuration (OVC) method. These are: (i) those necessary for proper dissociation of the molecule to the Hartree-Fock atoms; (ii) those that exist in the molecule but vanish formally in the dissociated atoms; and (iii) those that describe mainly atomic correlation but whose contribution changeswithin a numerically defined threshold of significance as the molecule forms. The F a potential energy curve thus produced is very similar to the experimentally derived one and the spectroscopic constants, dissociation energy, vibrational frequency, and F-F equilibrium distance of 1.67 eV, 942 cm-l, and 2.67 a.u. compare very favourably with the experimental values of 1.68 eV, 932 cm-1, and 2.68 a.u. Hosteny, Hinds, and Wahlls9 b have recently calculated a portion of the surface for the 3B1 state of H2O by the MCSCF method. Unrestricted Wave€iinctions.-Up to this point, little has been said about the form of the molecular orbitals used in the determinantal wavefunction. Since the choice
188 189
C. F. Bender and E. R. Davidson, Phys. Rev., 1969,183,23. D. R. Hartree, W. Hartree, and B. Swirles, Phil. Trans. Roy. SOC.,1939, A238, 229. (a) G. Das and A. C. Wahl, Phys. Rev. Letters, 1970, 24, 440; Adv. Quantum Chem., 1970, 5, 261; J. Chern. Phys,, 1972, 56, 3532; (b) R. P. Hosteny, A. R. Hinds, and A. C. Wahl. Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973,23, 9.
42
Theoretical Chemistry
of the orbitals can have an effect on the correlation problem, we will discuss the two commonly used restrictions placed on the orbitals. In the restricted Hartree-Fock (RHF) method, two restrictions are placed on the molecular orbitals ug in equation (11). The first is chat each uztransform according to one of the irreducible representations of the point group of the molecule. The second restriction is that the space functions $i, come in identical pairs one with spin function a and the other with spin function /I.These are called, respectively, the symmetry and equivalence restricti0ns.1~0 When the second of the equivalence restrictions is removed, a single determinant wavefunction of lower energy is usually obtained. In fact, it is possible for a wave function obtained in this way, a so-called unrestricted Hartree-Fock (UHF) wavefunction lgl (perhaps more properly called a spin-unrestricted Hartree-Fock wavefunction) to go beyond the Hartree-Fock approximation and thus include some of the correlation energy. Lowdin192 describes this as a method for introducing a Coulomb hole to supplement the Fermi hole already accounted for in the RHF wavefunction. The obvious advantage of this method is the retention of the single-determinant wavefunction. The drawback is that the resulting wavefunction is no longer an eigenfunction of the spin operator <S2>.There are cases where the eigenvalue equation S2Y = S(S + 1)Y is almost satisfied. This was found to be the case in the calculations on the insertion of O(3P)into the ground state hydrogen molecule reported by Bader and Gangi.138 Table 4 shows the values of <S2> along the reaction path which, for a spin-pure
Table 4 Values of <S2> along the Czvpath of the insertion of O(3P) into H2(1X,+)138 r 0la.u.
rHH/a.u.
<s2>
3.00 2.00 1.84 1.11 0.00
1.56 2.66 2.99 3.72 4.61
2.01 2.01 2.01 2.01 2.04
tripiet, should be 2. If <S2>is found to diverge from the anticipated value, one must apply a projection operator in order to recover a spin-pure or nearly spin-pure state. This can be done in several ways. Amos and Snyder193 have proposed a method which annihilates only the contaminant of next higher spin multiplicity (i.e. the triplet for a singlet state, quartet for a doublet, etc.) under the assumption that this is the major contaminant. A method of complete projection194 has also been proposed but since in this and the previous method the variational principle is applied lgoR. K. Nesbet, Proc. Roy. SOC.,1955, A230, 312. 191 J. A. Pople and R. K. Nesbet, J. Chem. Phys., 1954, 22, 571. lQ2 P.-0. Lowdin, Adv. Chem. Phys., 1959, 2, 207. 193 T. Amos and L. C. Snyder, J. Chem. Phys., 1964,41, 1773. 194
P.-0. Lowdin, Rev. Mod. Phys., 1960,32,328; 1964,36,966; A. Hardisson and J. E. Harriman, J. Chem. Phys., 1966,46,3639; J. E. Harriman, J. C'hern. Phys., 1964,40,287.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
43
before projection, the final wavefunction suffers from the lack of proper opt*tion. The spin-extendedHartree-Fock (EHF) method corrects for this by projecting before optimization on each iteration. In their work on the insertion of triplet oxygen to the hydrogen molecule, Bader and Gangi138found it necessary to use the UHF method in order to investigate the changes of polarization of electron spins at various points on the potential energy surface. The spin density distribution function a(r) is defined as
In other words, o(r) is the number of excess a[a(r)>O] or B[o(r)
4r) =
2cdr)c;o - XMM;(d i j
where the sums run over only the singly occupied orbitals containing the unpaired a- or &electrons. In the UHF approximation, which allows for different spatial orbitals with different spins, all the orbitals are singly occupied and hence all of the orbital densities contribute to a(r) at every point in space. The results of this work show that there is an unpairing mechanism corresponding to the localization of charge density with identical spin components on both centres of the substrate bond to yield an unstable triplet insertion product, and an uncoupling mechanism corresponding to a separate localization of the a and B spin distributions on both centres of the substrate bond to yield abstraction products of OH(2rr) H(2S). These two principal forms of spin polarization account nicely for the observed differences in the chemistry of O(3P) and O(1D) in both insertion and abstraction. For example, Figure 2 illustrates the total charge distribution p(r) of the H2O system at various points along the minimum energy CzU insertion pathways, (ro = distance of oxygen from midpoint of H-H and rH is H-H separation). Shown on these diagrams are the 'zero-flux' surfaces S(r), i.e. those surfaces satisfying Vp(r)-n = 0 VrES(r)
+
which partition the system into two hydrogen fragments and an oxygen fragment.l2', 128 The quantum mechanical virial theorem, and the hypervirial theorem for the operator - r . V are both obeyed over the individual fragment volumes defined by these surfaces. In addition, all properties of such fragments (a) are uniquely defined, including a total energy for each fragment (Q), E ( n ) which, because of the satisfaction of the virial theorem, has the property of equalling minus the kinetic energy of the fragment, E ( a ) = -T(Q), when no external forces are exerted on the system. The populations and kinetic energies of the (El) fragments during the course of these two insertion reactions are listed in Table 5, together with the net charge C O ,where C(H) = Z H - N ( H ) . The population figuresmake quantitative the observationsmade from the changes in the charge distributions, Figure 2. At ro = 4.00 a.u. (not shown in the Figure)
44
Theoretical Chemistry SINGLET
TRIPLET
ro
= 3.00
1.58
1.54
Figure 2 Contour maps of the total charge distributions in the plane of the nuclei for the symmetrical singlet and triplet insertion reactions to form IAI and 3B1 states of HaO, respectively. The contours increase in value from the outermost member, in the order 2 x lo-", 4 x lo-", 8 x a.u. for decreasing values of n, beginning with n = 3
45
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
Table 5 Kinetic energies andpopulationsof (H) in singlet and triplet insertion reactions r0la.u.
3.0 2.0 1.1 0.0
Singlet surface T(H)/a.u. N(H) 0.5013 0.893 0.3644 0.575 0.3474 0.398 0.2614 0.259
C(H) 0.107 0.425 0.602 0.741
Triplet surface T(H)/a.u. N(H) 0.5496 0.953 0.3756 0.748 0.3506 0.6621 0.761 0.4290
C(H) 0.047 0.252 0.339 0.239
the perturbations are quite small and the charge distributions resemble closeIy those of the isolated reactants. At ro = 3.00 a.u. the effect of the increasing H-H separation is apparent in the pinching up of the high-density (0.2 a.u.) contour encircling the protons in both the singlet and triplet systems. For values of ro < 3.00 a.u. the energy of the singlet path decreases while that of the triplet beings a rapid increase. Correspondingly,marked differencesappear in the charge distributions of the singlet and triplet systems. After an initial scission of the 0.2-a.u. contour encompassing the protons due to the further increase in rH in both systems (ro = 2.00 a.u.), the singlet system is characterized by a complete merging of the hydrogen and oxygen charge distributions into a singIe, compact distribution with contours of high value encompassingand binding all three nuclei. The result (ro = 1.1 1 a.u.) is the stable, low-energy insertion product, H20(1A1). In the triplet system, motion along the minimum energy path leads to a marked expansion of the charge density into the nonbonded regions of the protons (roG2.00 a.u.). This expansion results in a very diffuse distribution in the regions of the protons and in low concentrations of charge density between each pair of nuclei. These effects are maximized at ro = 0.00 a.u. and in addition there is a separate localization of the charge density in the region of each nucleus. In contrast, even when the singlet system is forced into the linear geometry at a cost of ca. 138 kJ mo1-1, the charge distribution is still compact with all three nuclei encompassed by contours up to ca. 0.3 a.u. in value. We now attempt to account for the gross differences in the charge distributions of the singlet and triplet systems and hence for their different reaction co-ordinates in terms of the spatial distribution of spin density u(r). Spin-density distributions in the plane of the nuclei for configurations along the minimum energy triplet path are illustrated in Figure 3. The contour maps of c(r) are for the Ms = 1 spin component of the triplet state, i.e. with two unpaired a electrons which initially are localized on the oxygen atom. One of the unpaired spins remains almost entirely localized in a distribution which has its maximum values in a plane perpendicular to the plane of the nuclei shown in the diagram. Even at ro = 4.00 a.u. a spin polarization is evident in the system, corresponding to the creation of excess a spin density in the charge distribution of the hydrogen molecule. Simultaneous with this, is the appearance of excess B spin density in the region of the oxygen. Both of these effects are enhanced as ro is decreased, with the excess a spin population forming diffuse, expanded distributions of increasing extent in the regions of the protons. A comparison of the contour values in the p(r) and a(r) distributions for ro = 2.00 a.u. and 1.11 a.u. indicates that almost 100% of the outermost non-bonded charge density on the protons represented by the 0.002, 0.004, and 0.008 a.u. contours in the p(r) maps is composed of a spin density. The
46
Theoretical Chemistry
,
, ,
---
1 0.00
u ro = 3.00
ro = 4.00
f
ro = 2.00
_-------.. \
ro= 1.11
ro = 0.00 Figure 3 Contour maps for the spin-density distributions for the symmetrical triplet insertion reaction. Excess cc spin density is denoted by solid contours, and excess /3 spin density by dashed contours. The solid and dashed contours increase (excess a) or decrease (excess /3), respectively,from the zero contour in the order & 2 x 10 -*, 4 x 10 -n, +_ 8 x 10 -n a.u. for decreasing values of n beginning with n = 3
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Enepgy Surfaces
47
separation, localization, and enhancement of positive spin density increases until, in the linear configuration, the a spin density accounts for SCr-lOo% of the total charge density in the spatial region of each proton. Although the integral of a(r) over all space will yield two electrons (or spins), the appearance of negative spin density in the o(r) distribution indicates that charge density previously paired has been unpaired. That is, integration of just the positive contours of a(r) over all space will yield more than two electrons. The behaviour of the spin-density distribution along the reaction co-ordinate does account for the major differences in the charge distributions and chemistry of the singlet and triplet species. At ro = 2.00 and 1.11 a.u. the extreme localization of charge density with an identical spin component on each proton results in a great reduction in the total charge density in the region between the protons. This follows as a consequence of the requirements of the Pauli principle on the two-electron charge density33 that Pr(I-1, r2)-*O for r1+r2. The spin polarization very effectivelyweakens the bond in the hydrogen molecule. In effect the spin polarization caused by the approach of O(sP) corresponds to a quasi-excitation of H2 from its singlet ground state to its unbound 3Ci state, a state characterized by a localization of charge density on each nucleus, each distribution being polarized away from the other into its non-bonded region. The two localized, almost pure CY spin distributions on each proton are most widely separated and the energy minimized in the linear configuration. Thus the mechanism of triplet insertion corresponds to an inducement of identical spin distributions on each centre of the substrate bond, an effect which weakens the bond and leads to the formation of a loosely bound metastable intermediate. Thus, along the singlet path there is considerable charge transfer from the hydrogen fragments to (0)to yield an overall tightly bound distribution. In the triplet reaction the net charge transfer from (H) to (0)is much less and the final distribution is diffuse and separately localized on all three centres. The UHF method was used in 1970 by Salotto and Burnellel95 in their investigation of the potential energy surfaces of HNO and H2NO. More recent work includes that of Ehrenson and Newton152 on CH5, referred to above. It is noteworthy that obtained in their calculation on CH5, range from 0.795 to 0.846 the values of (for a doublet <S2>= 0.75) and therefore the wavefunction is appreciably contaminated by states of higher multiplicity. Brown and Williams196 performed a singleannihilation on their UHF wavefunction in their work on the potential energy surfaces of some small free radicals. Nevertheless, they find that in the dissociation of NH2 in its ground and first-excited states (2B1and aA1) the values of (S2>deviate sharply from 0.75 as the N-€€ bond lengths are increased. States of multiplicity greater than quartets are evidently mixing-in and the necessity for a complete projection is indicated. A similar situation is found by these authors in the BH2 and CH + dissociation calculations. It appears that one must approach the use of the UHF method warily, being prepared to l95
A. W. Salotto and L. Burnelle, J. Chem. Phys., 1970,52,2936;J. Chem. Phys., 1970,53, 335. D. Brown and G. R. Williams, Mol. Phys., 1973, 25, 673.
lQ6R.
48
Theoretical Chemistry
undergo the additional computational effort required to use spin projection to whatever extent is needed to ensure that the final wavefunction is spin-pure. The IEPA Method.-Another method of including electron correlation has found growing use in the calculation of potential energy surfaces. In this technique, called the ‘independent electron pair approach’ (IEPA), the total correlation energy in a system is expressed as a sum of the correlation energies of pairs of electrons in the field of the other electr0ns.19~To a good approximation, it can be shown1828198 that the total energy of the system can be written as follows: E
N
EHF +
zeta i
+ i< zeal j
where ~ i isg the energy associated with the correlation between electrons in the same orbital (intrapair correlation) and represents the energy resulting from the correlation of electrons in different orbitals (interpair correlation). Examples of this method are the recent work of Driessler, Ahlrichs, Staemmler, and KutzelnigglgQon the equilibrium geometries and other properties of CH3, C H t , the inversion barrier in CH, and the potential surface for LiHi referred to previously.lo5 6 H
+
A Benchmark Reaction Progress in the calculation of complete potential energy surfaces can best be followed by considering in detail the work that has been done on one of the simplest of exchange reactions, namely H H2-+H2 H. Semi-empiricalCalculations.-Many groups have used both semi-empirical and ab initio methods to produce potential energy surfaces for the ground state of Ha. A thorough bibliography of the work prior to 1967 is given by Hayes and Parr200 and an excellent review of the earlier results in this field can be found in reference 201. Because much of the earlier work involved the use of semi-empirical methods and the fact that the authors have chosen to restrict this work to a discussion of ab initiu calculations, we will describe, for the purpose of comparison, only one semi-empirical potential energy surface, the one which Porter and Karplus 22 calculated for H3 in 1964. The Porter and Karplus (PK) H3 surface is based on a modification of the London-Eyring-Polanyi (LEP) method.19 All overlap and three-centre terms were included. Empirical values were introduced for two-centre integrals by a modified Sat0 technique,20 and analytical approximations were used for the more complex integrals. Linear and non-linear configurations for H3 were considered. A linear symmetrical col or saddle-point configuration was found at an H-H separation of R = 1.701 a.u. with a barrier height of 38.2 kJ mol -l. [The barrier height E b = Ecalc(H H2)-Ecalc(H3 at saddle point), the energies of all species being calculated the same way.] When the zero-point vibrational energy is included, this becomes 36.8 kJ mol-l. As we will discuss below, this value is in very good agreement with the cu. 38 kJ mol-l predicted from experiment. Earlier semiempirical calculations predicted the presence of a basin or well in the saddle-point H2:
+
+
+
197 198 109 200 201
For a review of this method, see; R. K. Nesbet, Adv. Chem. Phys., 1969, 14, 237. 0. Sinanoglu, J. Chem. Phys., 1962, 36, 706, 3198. F. Driessler, R. Ahlrichs, V. Staemmler, and W. Kutzelnigg, Theor. Chim. A d a , 1973,30, 3 15. E. F. Hayes and R. G. Pam, J. Chem. Phys., 1967, 47, 3961. K. J. Laidler, ‘Theories of Chemical Reaction Rates’, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1969.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
49
12.0
-
8.0
-E"mu
'
4.0
0.0 0.0
1.o
2.0
3.0
R1a.u.
Figure 4 Comparison of energy profiles along the reaction path for linear Ha. (-Shavitt, Stevens, Minn, and Karplus, ref. 112; ---- Liu, ref. 210; Porter and Karplus, ref. 22; - - - - Conroy and Bruner, ref. 207)
--
9
9
+
region of the surface. No well was found in the barrier region of the PK surface. It is interesting to note that this is the thinnest of the theoretical surfaces computed for Hs to-date (see Figure 4). Ab Imzio Calculations.--The first ab initio calculation on H3 was performed by Hirschfelder, Eyring, and Rosen202on the linear symmetric system in 1936. The valence bond method with the inclusion of ionic states was used. The wavefunctions were composed of 1s atomic orbitals. A barrier height (Eb) greater than 40kcd mo1-1 was obtained, a value which was clearly much too high. In 1954, Barker et aZ.203 performed similar calculations on linear H3, but with independent variation of the effective charges on the middle and outer atoms. The barrier height found was in close agreement with that of Hirschfelder et al. Although the next few years show some activity in the field 205 improvements in results had to await the perfection of high-speed digital computers. An example is the variational calculation made on a few configurations of the H3 system by Boys and Shavitt205 in 1959. The barrier height of 62 kJ mol-1, while an improvement over previous ab initio work, still did not compare with the experimental or the semi-empirical results given by the PK surface. 204p
20%
*03 *04
205
J. 0. Hirschfelder, H. Eyring, and H. Rosen, jun., J. Chem. Phys., 1936, 4, 121, 130. R. S. Barker, H. Eyring, C. J. Throne, and D. A. Baker, J. Chem. Phys., 1955, 22, 699; R. S. Barker and H. Eyring, J. Chem. Phys., 1957, 26, 971. B. J. Ransil, J. Chem. Phys., 1957, 26, 971; R. Snow and H. Eyring, J. Phys. Chem., 1957, 6 1 , l ; G . E. Kimball and J. G. TruIio,J. Chem. Phys., 1958,28,493; V . Griffing, J. L. Jackson, and B. J. Ransil, J. Chem. Phys., 1959, 30, 1066. S. F. Boys and I. Shavitt, University of Wisconsin Naval Research Laboratory Tech. Rept. WIS-AF-13 (1959).
50
Theoretical Chemistry
In 1967, Hayes and Parr200did studies on linear symmetric H3 at separations of 1.6, 1.7, and 1.8 a.u. between adjacent protons using a 70-configuration CI calculation. The basis set was composed of single-centreSTO’s. The energy of - 1.6358 a.u. for the symmetrical H3 complex with an H-H separation R = 1.80 a.u. was an improvement over previous ab initio calculations. Hayes and Parr did not perform calculations for the separated species H2 + H and therefore a barrier height Eb as defined above, cannot be ascertained for their work. We can, however, define another barrier height Eb in the following way:
&xact(H
+
H2) = Eexact(H) = 0.5000
+
+
Eexact(H2)
1.1745 = 1.6745 a.u.
The value for H2 is taken from the work of Kolos and Wolniewicz.206 Hayes and Pam’s results yield a value of E’, of 101.6 kJ mol-1, again too high for agreement with experiment. But 1967 was a year of great activity in the ab initio calculation of potential energy surfaces of H3, for three other groupsl12~18*~ 207 had also entered the field. We will discuss the three other computations in the following paragraphs. In 1964, Conroy had developed a method207a for solving the molecular Schrodinger equation using variational trial functions that explicitly included the interelectronicco-ordinates and thus took account of the correlation effect. He had applied the method to various small systems. In 1967, Conroy and B r ~ n e r ~ O ~ applied this method to the H3 surface. The potential energies of 41 different linear arrangements and 27 triangular arrangements of H3 were calculated. The minimum energy path was found to pass through a maximum 32.4kJmol-1 above the reactants at a linear symmetric configuration with R = 1.76 a.u. The energy at this geometry was reported as - 1.6621 a.u. The data in Table 6, which summarize the results of the most recent calculations on the H3 surface, indicate that to-date this is the lowest energy found at the saddle-point geometry of H3. It is important to note, however, that Conroy’s method of calculation does not necessarily yield Table 6 Calculations on the linear H3 molecule R/a.u. E1a.u. &/kJ mol-1 E2/kJmol-1 Force constants1a.u. symmetric stretch bending asymmetric stretch a
Ref. 22.
206
207
@
PKa HPb 1.701 1 .so - 1.6600 - 1.6358 38.2 38.1 101.6 0.36 0.024 -0.124
Ref. 200. Ref. 207.
-
-
CBc 1.76 - 1.6622 32.4 32.4 0.32 0.026 ca. 0.00
Refs. 184 and 209.
EKd 1.80 -1.6493 56.5 66.1
-
-
SSMKe 1.764 -1.6521 46.0 58.6
LIUf 1.757 -1.6581 41 .O 43 .O
0.31 0.024 -0.061
0.320 - 0.058
Ref. 112. f Ref. 210.
W. Kolos and L. Wolniewicz, J. Chem. Phys., 1965, 43, 2429. (a)H.Conroy and B. L. Bruner, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,47,921; (b) H. Conroy,J. Chem. Phys., 1964,41, 1327, 1331, 1336, 1341.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
51
an upper bound to the energy.* Thus, the usual criteria for comparing calculations (Le. how low is the energy?) cannot be applied here. The method appears to produce results whose accuracy is inconsistent from point-to-point on the surface. This leads to two unexpected results, one being a very flat barrier top and the other being the H2 ca. 2 a.u. away from the presence of an energy minimum with respect to H col (see Figure 4). At about the same time, pseudonatural orbitals were used by Edmiston and Krauss184~209 as a basis for a 65-configuration CI calculation on the linear H3 surface. Five s, two pa, three pnx, and two pn, type GTO’s were centred on each of the three nuclei and the energies at 28 geometries were computed. At the linear symmetricgeometry, a minimum energy of - 1.6493 a.u. was found at R = 1.8 a.u. This value was further reduced to - 1.65492 a.u. by extrapolating the values of the computed correlationerror. This corresponded to a barrier height Eb of 50 kJ mol -l. The energy of the dominant contiguration in the CI expansion is - 1.5922 a.u., which closely approaches the HartreFock limit. It is interesting to note the change in the correlation energy along the reaction path computed in this work. The correlation H, is ca. 0.04 a.u. and this increases steadily to a value error of the reactants, Hz of ca. 0.06 a.u. at the saddle point. This significant change is to be expected in the light of the previous discussion on the importance of including correlation effects in a system of this type. The fourth group to work on the theoretical calculation of the H3 surface in 1967 was Shavitt, Stevens, Minn, and Karp1us.ll2 An STO basis set composed of Is, ls’, 2pz, 2pV,2pz on each of the three hydrogens was used in calculations on both the linear and triangular geometries of the system. All possible determinants were used in a configuration interaction calculation (200 in the linear symmetric and 402 in the linear asymmetric). In this work, as in all previous work, the linear geometries were found to yield the reaction path. For the linear geometries, potential energies at 158 points were calculated and at 26 of these, the orbital exponentswere optimized. The saddle point was found at R = 1.765 a.u. (again no well appeared at the top of the barrier) with a potential energy of - 1.6521 ax. This corresponds to a barrier height (4%) of 46 kJ mol -l. The most thorough work to-date on the H3 surface is that reported in 1973 by Liu.210 An STO basis set was used consisting of Is, ls’, 2s, W ,2p, 2p’, 3p’, 36 and 4d functions on each hydrogen atom. Here we see the first inclusion of d-type functions in H3 calculations. The exponents were optimized for the ground state of Hz at a separation of 1.4 a.u. This optimization was conducted by minimizing the complete configuration interaction (126 configurations). The SCF energy obtained with the major configuration is within 5.0 x 10-5 a.u. of the Hartree-Fock limit. Comparing his CI curve of H2(X1Z3 with the essentially exact results of Kdos and Wolniewicz,206 Liu found that the CI curve is very nearly parallel to the exact curve near the equilibrium separation. The energy difference between the two results at
+
+
*
See ref. 208 and footnote 30 in ref. 112.
208
209 210
H. Conroy and B. L.Bruner, J. Chem. Phys., 1965, 42,4047. C. Edmiston and M. Krauss, J. G e m . Phys., 1965, 42, 1119. B. Liu, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 1925
.
52
Theoretical Chemistry
a nuclear separation of 1.4 a.u. is 7.7 x 10 -4 a.u., evidence of a sufficiently adequate wavefunction, at least for Ha. Considering the large basis set involved (27 o-type, 15 n-type, and six 6-type functions) a complete CI, while within the capabilities of available computers, is certainly using these capabilities to their limits. In this work, Liu tests yet another method for truncating a full CI wavefunction. The method begins with an MCSCF calculation on a severely truncated CI wavefunction. Configurations are then systematically added in order to establish a convergence pattern which could be extrapolated to the complete CI limit. The nparticle space is partitioned into a set of configurations including all dominant terms in the full CI expansion for all nuclear geometries considered, and a set containing the remainder of the n-particle space. The first of these is composed of what Liu calls the internal approximate natural orbitals (ANO) which are those associated with large occupation numbers. The second set is further divided into a finite number of sub-spaces according to the following rule: the ith-order sub-space contains those and only those n-particle functions which are orthogonal to all lower-order subspaces and have non-zero Hamiltonian matrix elements with at least one function in the (i- l)th-order sub-space. In the case O f €33, Liu's first-order sub-space contains all configurationswith one or two electrons in internal orbitals and the other electron or electrons in the remaining or external orbitals. The second-order sub-space contains configurations with all three electrons occupying external orbitals. Using this method, Liu extrapolates his results to produce a minimum energy of - 1.6581 a.u. on the linear reaction path at a saddle-point geometry of R = 1.757 a.u. This yields H. a barrier which is 41 kJ mol-1 above the calculated energy of H2 Rate constant measurements211 and quasi-classical trajectory calculations2 1 2 s 213 indicate a barrier height of ca. 38 kJ mol-1 for the H + H2 exchange reaction. The 38.2kJmol-1 barrier height of the Porter-Karplus surface and the 41 kJ mol-1 value obtained by Liu, therefore, are in good agreement with the experimental results. The situation is much different, however, regarding the reported hydrogen-hydrogen distances at the col. Note from Table 6, for example, that three of the a6 initio calculations, those of Conroy and Br~ner,~o'Shavitt and coworkers,ll2 and Liu,210 agree on a value of 1.76 a.u., whereas two others, Hayes and Parrz*Oand Edmiston and Krauss18* report a higher value of 1.80 ax. The PorterKarplus surface, on the other hand, predicts an H-H distance of only 1.701 a.u. The preponderance of theoretical evidence, then, seems to be on the side of the larger values, and the Porter-Karplus value is probably too small. Table 6 shows that the variation in the reported symmetric stretch and bending force constants is relatively small. For the asymmetric stretching force constant only the Shavitt et al. and Liu values of -0.061 a.u. and - 0.058 a.u., respectively, are in substantial agreement, the PK surface yielding a value of -0.124 a.u. which is more than a factor of two greater. Figure 5 shows the minimum energy path for three of the computed linear H3 surfaces considered here. Shavitt et al. who gave a similar plot112noted a peculiar
+
211
W. R. Schulz and D. J. LeRoy, J. Chem. Phys., 1965, 42, 3869; R. E. Weston, jun., ibid.,
212
1959, 31, 892; I. Shavitt, ibid., 1959, 31, 1359. M. Karplus, R. N. Porter, and R. D. Sharma, J. Chem. Phys., 1964,40, 2033. M. Karplus, R. N. Porter, and R. D. Sharma, J. Chem. Phys., 1965,43, 3259.
213
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
1.o
2.0
53
3.0
R,/a.u.
Figure 5 Comparison of reactionpaths for linear Hs surface. See Figure 4 for details feature which is found in all semi-empirical surfaces. This is the 'kink' which is found in the saddle-point region of the Porter-Karplus plot. The minimum energy path for the Conroy and Bruner207surface (not shown in Figure 5 ) very closely parallels that of Liu except for what appears to be a very small 'kink' at the col. Note that in both Figures 4 and 5 the Liu210 surface is very nearly parallel to the surface of Shavitt et In comparing these latter two sets of calculations, one notes that there are just two major differences: the Liu surface approaches the equilibrium H2 geometry more quickly and its barrier height is lower. The H3 potential surface which has been most widely used in transition stateY2l4 classical dynamicaly213,215 and quantum mechanical dynamical216 -218 calculations has been the semi-empirical surface of Porter and Karplus.22 Because of the thin potential barrier of the PK surface, one would expect a larger amount of quantum mechanical tunnelling to be predicted at room temperature (this has been found to be the case in calculations performed by Johnston219 on barriers in the very similar LEPS surfaces). However, Karplus et aL2139215 compared classical and quantum mechanical calculations on the PK surface and found that reaction cross-sections for both are very similar, and therefore that the tunnelling effect in the Hs system is small. Transition-statetheory was applied to the SSMK surface1l2by Shavitt22* in 1968. The plots of the log of the rate constant against the reciprocal of the temperature calculated by Shavitt are in excellent agreement with experimental results on 214
216 216
217 d18
219 220
3
K. Morokuma, B. C. Eu, and M. Karplus, J. Chem. Phys., 1969,51, 5193. M. Karplus and K. T. Tang, Discuss. Faraday Soc., 1967, 44, 56. J. W. Duff and D. G. Truhlar, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 23, 327; D. J. Diestler, J. G e m . Phys., 1971, 54, 4547; S. Wu and R. D. Levine, Mol. Phys., 1971, 22, 881; B. R. Johnson, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 13, 172. D. J. Diestler and M. Karplus, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 5832. S.-F. W u , B. R. Johnson, and R. D. Levine, Mol. Phys., 1973, 25, 609 H. S. Johnston, Ado. Chem. Phys., 1960, 3, 131. I. Shavitt, J. Chem. Phys., 1968, 49, 4048.
Theoretical Chemistry
54
+
+
H Hz, H D2, D + H2, and D + D2,221although it was necessary for him to scale his surface to a barrier height of 41 kJ mol-1. This 11% reduction in the barrier height was applied uniformly along the total reaction path. The asymmetric force constant given in Table 1 has been scaled down by the same amount. Shavitt includes the quantum-mechanical tunnelling effect by fitting an Eckart 222 barrier to the calculated SSMK barrier. Kupperman et al.223 -226 compared transition-state, classical, and quantum mechanical thermal rate constants using the SSMK surface.l12In ab initio potential energy surface calculations, the potential energy is known only as a list of values at selected geometries of the system. It becomes necessary, then, if trajectory calculations are to be made, to fit the calculated points to a smooth and continuous ‘map’. In their calculations, Kupperman et al. fit the collinear SSMK surface by the rotating Morse function procedure of Wall and Porter.227 Koeppl228 has applied transition-state theory to the Liu surface. Again, a plot of log k 1:s 1/ T agrees with the experimental results cited above.221Since the barrier height was computed by Liu to be 41 kJmol-l, no barrier height scaling was necessary in this case. Truhlar and Kupperman229have shown that tunnelling calculations from Eckart potential fits to the potential energy barrier lead to systematic errors and that agreement with experiments must be considered the result of fortuitous cancellation of errors. For this reason, Koeppl takes no account of tunnelling in his work. More recently, Yates and Lester230 fitted Liu’s surface with a slightly modified form of the Porter-Karplus formulas after first fitting Liu’s H2 potential to a simple Morse function. They then use the resulting surface to calculate the three-dimensional classical trajectory of the system. Their empirical fit very closely duplicates Liu’s saddle-point properties. Reaction probabilities on this surface are compared with those on the PK surface. All things considered, it appears that the Liu surface probably approaches very closely to the true potential energy surface of H3. In addition, Liu’s method of selecting configurations is certainly one which will find wider application in future CI calculations. It is uncertain at present, however, how large a molecular system can thus be accommodated.
7 Potential Energy Surfaces from Correlated Wavefunctions H;.--In 1970, Csizmadia et aZ.231 carried out an extensive SCF-CI calculation on the potential energy surface of H l . Four or five s-type GTO’s and at least onep-type (a) B. A. Ridley, W. R. Schulz, and D. J. LeRoy, J. Chem. Phys., 1966, 44,3344; (b) A. A. Westenberg and N. deHaas, ibid., 1967, 47, 1393; (c) D. N. Mitchell and D. J. LeRoy, ibid., 1973,58, 3449; ( d ) W. R. Schulz and D. J. LeRoy, Canad. J. Chem., 1964,42, 2480. 222 C. Eckart, Phys. Rev.,1930, 35, 1303. 223 J. M. Bowman and A. Kuppermann, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 6524. 224 J. M. Bowman and A. Kuppermann, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 12, 1. 225 D. G. Truhlar and A. Kuppermann, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1971, 9, 269. *26 D. G. Truhlar and A. Kuppermann, J. Chem. Phys., 1970, 52, 3841. 2 2 7 F. T. Wall and R. N. Porter, J. Chem. Phys., 1962, 36, 3256. 208 G. W. Koeppl, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 3425. 229 D. G. Truhlar and A. Kuppermann, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 1971, 93, 1840. 230 A. C. Yates and W.A. Lester, jun., Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 24, 305. 231 I. G. Csizmadia, R. E. Karl, J. C. Polanyi, A. C. Roach, and M. A. Robb, J. Chem. Phys., 1970, 52, 6205. 221
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
55
GTO was centred on each atom in the SCF calculation. A CI calculation was then performed using 120 configurations involving 15 of the molecular orbitals. The excitations were to the virtual orbitals produced by the SCF method. The equilibrium geometry was found to be an equilateral triangle with bond lengths of 1.66 a.u. which is in general agreement with previous ~ o r k . A ~ study 3 ~ of the effect of changes in the basis set showed that the addition of a singlep-type function resulted in a reduction in the energy of the system by cn. 0.02 a.u. at the equilibrium geometry before CI. The effect is even greater with the CI wavefunction. The SCF energy at the equilibrium geometry (with a 5s,2p GTO set) is reported to be - 1.29930 a.u. which, after CI, is reduced to -1.3397 a.u. Similar CI calculations performed at collinear symmetric geometries produced a minimum energy of - 1.2765 a.u. at an H-H separation of 1.54 a.u. Csizmadia and co-workers233 then used a smaller basis set (5sJp) in a CI calculation at 250 points on the H: potential surface. Threedimensional classical trajectory calculations for the reaction D + + H2+H + + HD were then carried out. In a subsequent work, Preston and TullylS discuss the limited value of these latter calculations due to the neglect of a non-adiabatic interaction of the ground state, with a second state which describes the dissociation of the system into the products H + HD+. More recently, Carney and P 0 r t e r ~ 3used ~ a GTO basis set of 21 functions, six of which have centres outside of the molecule, to calculate the potential energy for 42 equilateral geometries of H:. A limited optimization of the exponents was performed. The SCF energy at a calculated internuclear distance of 1.64 a.u. was found to be - 1.299 273 a.u. A second calculation involving a 309-configuration CI gave an energy of - 1.339 358 a.u. at R = 1.649 984 a.u. The close agreement with the work of Csizmadia et al.231 is obvious even to a comparison of the cuts through the two potential surfaces which are shown in ref. 234. There is also good agreement with the energy and equilibrium bond lengths predicted by Salmon and P o ~ h u s t a . ~ ~ ~ The avoided intersection of the two potential surfaces in the H i system was studied in detail in a full CI calculation by Bauschlicher et aZ.236 An uncontracted 5s and 2p GTO basis set was used. The lowest surface was found to be attractive, with a binding energy of 444 kJ mol -1 for relative to H and €12. The second surface which represents H H;f is reported to be repulsive in nature. He + H;-+HeH+ + H.-Two different approaches of He to the H i ion were investigated by Edmiston et aZ.116 using the same method they applied to H3.184. 209 An uncontracted GTO basis set with polarization functions ( 6 4 2pz, 3pz,von helium and 4s, lp,, 3px,tlon each hydrogen) was used and pseudonatural orbitals were calculated for the 102 pair. A 65-configuration CI followed in which ca. 90 % of the correlation energy was accounted for. The energies of 22 different linear He-H-H + geometries were calculated. A minimum which lies about 21 kJ mol-1 below the separated reactants is found at He-H and H-H+ bond distances of ca. 2.0 a.u.
+
232
z33 234
235 236
Hl
+
R. E. Christoffersen, J. Chem. Phys., 1964, 41, 960; W. Kutzelnigg, R. Ahlrichs, I. LabibIskander, and W. A. Bingel, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1967, 1, 447. I. G. Csizmadia, J. C. Polanyi, A. C. Roach, and W. H. Wong, Canad. J. Chem., 1969, 47, 4097. G . D. Carney and R. N. Porter, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 4251. C. Salmon and R. D. Poshusta, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 3497. C . W. Bauschlicher, jun., S. V. O'Neil, R. K. Preston, H. F. Schaefer, and C. F. Bender, J. Chem. Phys.,:1973, 59, 1286.
56
Theoretical Chemistry
The barrier height is about 75 kJ mol-l. The authors consider this to be a type of hydrogen-bonding arising from the polarization of the He atom by the HZ. A potential energy barrier of 105 kJ mol-1 is found for the dissociation of the symmetric H at H-H and He-H distances of ca. 2.1 a.u. complex H-He-H+ into HeH+ (12 points were calculated for this geometric configuration). Comparing this to the value for the linear approach, forces one to rule out the insertion of He into the H-H+ bond along a CzVpath as a reaction path. Note that an electron pair is neither made nor broken along the reaction path. As discussed earlier in this chapter, one would expect that in this case a HartreeFock wavefunction would be sufficient to describe the system. The results of Edmiston et al. show that this is indeed the case, for the correlation energy is found to be approximately constant along the reaction path. Thus, the HF and CT paths are nearly parallel. With this in mind, a non-CI calculation was performed at a large number of points (82) in the He-H-H+ system by Brown and Hayes.185 The results are in general agreement with Edmiston et al. An He-H-H bond angle variation at four values of the angle at the minimum energy bond lengths indicates that the linear form is most stable. KuntzZ3'used the diatomics-in-molecules(DIM) approximation to fit a function to the surface of Brown and Hayes.ls5 The resulting collinear potential surface is in qualitative agreement. However, extrapolation to non-linear geometries appears to indicate that the isosceles geometries are energetically as favourable as the linear ones, which is in disagreement with Brown and Hayes. Clearly, further ab initio work on the non-linear geometries of this system is needed. HeH2.4ordon and SecrestllO used various numbers of STO's in an SCF-CI calculation on the HeH2 system. The smallest basis set used was composed of two s-type functions on He and one s-type function on each of the hydrogens. This set was sequentially built up to a set of two s-type and threep-type functions on He and one s-type and threep-type functions on each hydrogen. The combined energy of the separated species, helium atom plus hydrogen molecule, was calculated with a.u. from the Hartree-Fock limit. At a the largest basis set to be within 6 x fixed H-H distance of 1.40 a m , the distance of the He atom to the centre of the H-H bond (X) and the angle 8 between X and the H-H internuclear axis was varied from 2.8 to 7.0 a.u. and from 0 to go", respectively. Eighty configurations were mixed in a CI. This latter wavefunction gave a total energy of the separated products of -4.04921 a.u. which is 99.3 % of the experimental energy for He H2. The effect of orbital optimization was studied with the smaller basis set at X = 2.80 and 3.80 a.u. and with 8 at 90 and 0".Only at the shorter distance at the linear geometry is there a change in interaction energy, the effect at the other three geometries being negligible. This effect is seen with and without CI. Gordon and Secrest used an analytical function in the form proposed by Roberts2S8 and Krauss and Mies239to approximate the interaction potential as a function of X, 8, and the H-H internuclear distance. A plot of their results closely approximates
+
+
237
238 239
P. J. Kuntz, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 16, 581. C . S . Roberts, Phys. Rev., 1963, 131, 203. M. Krauss and F. N. Mies, J. Chem. Phys., 1965, 42, 2703.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
57
the experimental results240 in the range 2.8 < X <5.2 a.u. It is also found that at the small X values, the interaction energies found with and without CI are very similar. Note that this is a situation in which the products of dissociation are both closedshell systems and therefore another case in which an SCF potential energy surface properly described the dissociation. The interaction potentials calculated by Gordon and Secrest have subsequently been used in scattering calculations by Eastes and Secrest 241 and Alexander and Berard.242 Electron density maps at various points on the reaction path were generated by Gordon, Secrest, and L l a g u n ~using , ~ ~ the ~ Gordon-Secrest SCF wavefunctions. Schaefer et al.244investigated the interaction potential between ground-state He and the B state of HZusing a (6sY2p)GTO basis on helium contracted to a [3sY2p]set. For the hydrogen molecule, a (4s) set was contracted to [2s]and then an additional s function was added and optimized for the B state of H2 at R = 2.43 a.u. in order to describe properly the very diffuse nature of the 1cu orbital. As many as 706 configurations were included in a CI calculation. A large van der Waals interaction between He and the B state of H2 is found at R = 3.72 a.u. with a depth of 0.05 eV. H2 + D2-+2HD.-The theoretical search for the probable shape of the transition state in the four-centre exchange reaction Ha D2+2HD has been under way for many years (a review of the earlier work in this field may be found in ref. 245). The controversy is centred on the inability of thorough ab initio calculations to find a mechanism for the reaction with a barrier height as low as that suggested on the basis of shock-tube experiments.246~247 Three studies were done recently, two with ~~ de full CI 245,248 and one explicitly using interparticle c o - o r d i n a t e ~ ,a~method scribed above in conjunction with the work of Conroy and Bruner207on H3. Wilson and Goddard248 used a minimal Slater basis set (one ls-type function on each hydrogen) in a full (36 configuration) CI. A doublezeta basis set (two ls-type Slater functions on each hydrogen) was used in the CI calculations (up to 176 configurations) of Rubenstein and S h a ~ i t t . ~Although 4~ the energies of the latter work are lower, both groups report results which are essentially the same. Table 7 shows that the barrier heights reported by Rubenstein and Shavitt relative to two H2 molecules at infinite separation are, except for the linear system, all above 400 kJ mol-1. Wilson and Goddard 248 investigated three additional configurations, a regular trapezoid, centred equilateral triangle and a kite-shaped molecule. The barrier heights for these systems were also over 400 kJ mol -l. The problem that arises in these works is that the shock-tube experiments indicate that the activation energy for the reaction is only 176 kJ mol -l. As can be seen
+
240
241 242
243 244
z45 246
247 248 249
I. Amdur and A. P. Malinauskas, J. Chem. Phys., 1965, 42, 3355. W. Eastes and D. Secrest, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 56, 640. M. A. Alexander and E. V. Berard, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60,3950. M. D. Gordon, D. Secrest, and C. Llaguno, J . Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 1046. H. F. Schaefer, D. Wallach, and C. F. Bender, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 56, 1219. M. Rubinstein and I. Shavitt, J. Chem. Phys., 1969, 51, 2014. S. H. Bauer and E. Ossa, J. Chem. Phys., 1966, 45, 434. A. Burcat and A. Lifshitz, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,47,3079; D. Lewis and S. H. Bauer, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1968,90, 5390. C. W. Wilson, jun. and W. A. Goddard, J. Chem. Phys., 1969, 51, 716; 1972,56, 5913. H. Conroy and G . Malli, J. Chem. Phys., 1969, 50, 5049.
58
l'koretical Chemistry
Table 7 Barrier heights calculated by Rubinstein and S h a ~ i t for t ~ various ~~ transition states for the reaction H2 -+ D2 -+ HD System
Linear equidistant Rectangular (4 : 5) Square Rhombic (70")
Tetrahedral
Rmin/a.u. 1.7 2.09; 2.61 2.47 2.5 3.8
AE/kJ mol-1 180 456 594 632 757
from Table 7, the linear path has approximately the right barrier height. Note, however, that this path cannot serve as a transition state for the four-centre exchange reaction. The other systems produce barrier heights over twice as great as the experimental results. In fact, from the ab initio results, one would be led to the conclusion that the breaking of an H2 bond (ca. 448 kJ mol-l) followed by the reaction H + D2+D + HD would be energetically more favourable. Transition states which correspond to two unequal-length HZmolecules are consistent with the mechanism proposed by Bauer and co-workers 246 which involves a vibrationally excited Hz molecule reacting with a normal one. Wilson and Goddard's investigation of systems with unequal H-H bond distances, however, proved to be equally unfruitful. As stated before, one cannot directly equate the barrier heights to experimental activation energies; trajectory calculations must be performed on the surface in order to arrive at a theoretical activation energy. One can make an order-of-magnitude comparison, however, by noting that in the H2 + H system the activation energy was calculated213to be lower than the barrier height by about 8 kJ mol-l. A lowering of this order of magnitude will certainly not alter the situation. Tapia and Bessis250 investigated four geometric conformations in a CI study of H4 in which polarization functions were added, Although their results do not shed further light on the problem of the mechanism of the reaction (a very small set of geometric variations were investigated) they did find a minimum in the van der Waals region for the linear configuration close to the one predicted by Gordon and Cashion.251 Bender and Schaefer252 performed a set of full CI calculations on the linear symmetric H4 system using a GTO basis set which included p-functions. More recently, Silver and Stevens253extended the work even further by optimizing the orbital exponents and including more geometrical configurations in the study (the perpendicular approach, an alternative kite, and a parallelogram). Although a path was still not found in these latter two works which allowed a bimolecular mechanism for exchangerequiring less energy than a single H Zdissociation,Silver and Stevens253 found a path which requires c 25 kJ mol -1 of energy above this limit. This path is one which leads from trapezoidal to linear structures. In calculating portions of potential energy surfaces, it is only natural, considering the computer time used for ab initio calculations with CI, for investigators to choose 250
251
2s2 253
D. Tapia and G . Bessis, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1972, 25, 130. R. G. Gordon and J. J. Cashion, J. Chem. Phys., 1966, 44, 1190. C. F. Bender and H. F. Schaefer, J. Chem. Phys., 1972, 57, 217. D. M. Silver and R. M. Stevens, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 3378.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
59
to study first those portions of the surface with high symmetry. In the present case, however, it appears that a complete hypersurface for H4 may have to be calculated before the question of the mechanism of the exchange reaction is fully resolved. HeH+ + Ha+He + H$.-If the problems of the potential energy surface of the tetra-atomic H4 system are difficult to surmount, the HeHf system which, because it is heteronuclear lacks the symmetry of the former case, could have proven to be intractable. Nevertheless, three groups in recent years have attacked the problem of the reaction HeH+ + H2+He + H l using ab initio rnethods.104~254~255 The most recent of these is the work of Benson and McLaughlin.104 While this work was discussed earlier, details of their calculation are given here. An uncontracted GTO basis set composed of 9s- and lp-type function on He, and 4s- and lp-type function on each hydrogen (a total of 33 functions) was used. An estimate of the completeness of this set was obtained by calculating the single-determinant SCF energies of the four dominant fragments in the reaction: HeH+, Hz, He, and Hi. The results approached within 0.003 a.u. (8 kJ inol-1) of the Hartree-Fock values. As in the H Icase, the major problem that had to be resolved was the geometry of the reaction path. For this purpose the following four paths were investigated:
czw:
HeH+ approaching perpendicularly (with the H leading) to the Hz bond on the approach, and He leaving the triangular H8+ on the same path in the reverse direction. He brought into the centre of the H i triangle along a line 30" off Cs(planar): the altitude of the triangle and at various points the H2 was made to recede from HeH+. Cs(non-planar): Similar to CzVexcept that the He atom was tilted out of the H,f plane. c3u: He leaving perpendicularly from the centroid of the H,+triangle.
It was found that the CzUpaths were the lowest in energy. On the CzWpaths, three co-ordinates are needed to define the system. Benson and McLaughlin defined the following: the H-He distance R ; the distance r between the hydrogens of what originally is the H2 molecule; and the distance h from the hydrogen which was originally bonded to He to the centre of the axis of the other two hydrogens. Ten values of R and h (nine between 1.4 and 5.0 a.u. and one at 50.0 a.u.) were considered and three values of r (the calculated Hz equilibrium distance of 1.3950 a.u., the caIculated H: equilibrium distance of 1.6405 ax., and an intermediate value of 1.5000 a.u.). Thus, 300 points on the potential energy surface were computed. The energies at three points on the surface (see Table 8) were then recalculated. after optimization of the Gaussian orbital exponents. Point A represents conditions near the beginning of the reaction. Point C is near the end of the reaction and point El is near the middle of the reaction. The total energy was found to change by no more than 1% and since the lowering is uniform at these three points, it was assumed that it would remain uniform over the entire surface. 254
255
I. Funke, H. Preuss, and G. Diercksen, Mol. Phys., 1967, 13, 517. R. D. Poshusta, J. A. Haugen, and D. F. Zetik, J. Chem. Phys., 1969,51, 3343.
60
Theoretical Chemistry
Table 8 Co-ordinates (1a.u.) of three points on the Czv surface of HeH: selected for detailed investigation by Benson and McLaughlinl O4 Point
A B
c
a
R(HeH +) 1.4650a 2.oooo 4.oooo
Equilibrium value for HeH+.
h 4.94717 1.94717 1 .42075b
Equilibrium value for H + .
1.375OC 1SO00 1.640S’ Equilibrium value for H2.
+
The reaction HeH+ + H w H e + H$, like that of He + H$-+HeH+ H, does not involve the making or breaking of electron pairs. As such, the HartreeFock results should parallel those of a CI calculation. To verify this, Benson and McLaughlin performed a CI using the iterative natural orbital method for the reactants at infinite separation, the products at infinite separation and at the points defined in Table 8. The five helium s functions with the largest exponents were contracted to a single s function using helium atom orbital coefficients. The computed correlation energies, which accounted for 80% of the total amount, were found to range from 0.0730 to 0.0767 a.u. indicating, as noted before, that the Hartree-Fock results are indeed nearly parallel to the correlated results over the entire surface. This reaction was found to be exothermic by 2.63 eV (254 kJ mol-1) in general agreement with the 2.3 eV found by Funke, Preuss, and Diercksen 254 using a restricted basis set. These latter workers predicted a path in which the H2 molecule lies initially on the HeH+ axis but swings perpendicular to this axis as the reaction proceeds, i.e. ending up with the geometrical configuration which Benson and McLaughlin use throughout the path. The results of Benson and McEaughlin104 indicate that no barrier to reaction exists, nor do they show a minimum, which is in contrast to the stable HeH; complex bound by 0.44 eV reported by Poshusta, Haugen, and Zetik255 using a minimal valence-bond CI technique. Hez-+He; + He.-Vauge and Whitten%6using a GTO basis set with polarization functions did single and double excitation CI calculations on the He: system and determined that the linear symmetric structure was more stable than the equilateral triangle. The minimum energy with respect to symmetric dissociation was found to be -7.83198 a.u. at an internuclear distance of 2.340 a.u. The dissociation energy of 0.07 eV which, although low compared with the experimental value reported by Patterson,267 (0.17+. 0.03 eV) verifies that the ion is loosely bound. F + H2+FH + H.-Bender et ~21.~5~ recently reported the results of two different sets of calculations on the potential energy surface for the reaction F + H2-’ FH H. This work is of interest from three points of view. First, it is truly a rigorous quantum mechanical calculation typifying the current state of the art for systems of this size: a GTO basis set of double-zeta quality is used (9s5p/4s)for a total of 32 GTO’s, and this is contracted according to the Dunning method51 to
+
256
257 258
C. Vauge and J. L. Whitten, Chem. Pfiys. Letters, 1972, 13, 541. P. L. Patterson, J. Chem. Phys., 1968, 48, 3625. C. F. Bender, P. K. Pearson, S. V. O’Neil, and H. F. Schaefer, J. Chem. Phys., 1972,56,4626; C. F. Bender, S. V. O’Neil, P. K. Pearson, and H. F. Schaefer, Science, 1972,176, 1412.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
61
[4s2p/2s]:polarization functions are added (d’s on the fluorine andp’s on hydrogens) yielding a basis set of 48 GTO’s - (9sSp2d/4slp)contracted to [4s2pld/2slp]:and the iterative natural orbital (INO) technique is used on 214 configurations in a CI calculation - typically four iterations were needed to obtain convergence. These calculations were performed at each of 150 linear geometries using both basis sets and 200 non-linear geometries using the [4s2p/2s] basis set for the FH2 system. Secondly, the final potential surface produced should be of high enough accuracy to allow for dynamical studies of the reaction. Thirdly, the values of the properties of the surface computed in four different ways can be compared.
Table 9 Summary of the results of Bender et al.258on the reaction F in diferent ways Without polarizationfunction SCF CI
Barrier height/ kJ mol-1 Exothermicity/ kJ mol-1 Saddle-point geometry/A F-H H-H Total energy/a.u. F H2 Total energy/a.u. FH + H
+
With polarizationfunction SCF CI
14.4
24
123
-2.4
85
55
1.06 0.81
1.37 0.81
+ Ha culculuted
1.18 0.836
6.9
144 1.54 0.767
Experimental 7.1s
133b L
- 100.5208
- 100.5424
- 100.5257
- 100.5620
-
- 100.5191
-
100.5726
- 100.5470
- 100.6169
-
A. F. Trotman-Dickenson,J . Chem. SOC.,1960, 1064.) J. Berkowitz, W. A. Chupka, P. M. Guton, J. M. Holloway, and R. Spohr, J. Chem. Phys., 1971,54, 5165. a Experimental activation energy (G. C. Fettis, J. H. Knox, and
The minimum energy path was found to be the one for the linear arrangement F-H-H. Table 9 shows the results of the four different calculations: the basis set lacking polarization functions with and without CI, and the same basis set with polarization functions with and without CI. If we compare the exothermicities we see that one needs the added flexibility of the d functions on F and the p functions on the H’s, plus a rather extensive CI in order to approach the experimental value. Mu~kermanz5~ suggests that the barrier height should be cu. 2.9 kJ mol-1 less than the activation energy. This would give a barrier height of ca. 4 kJ mol-1 and again the CI calculation with polarization functions gives the best value. The great improvement in the total energies of the system F + H2 with the F at infinite separation and the system FH H with the H at infinite separation further illustrates this point. Note in particular the difference in the effect of the polarization functions on the reactants and the products. The energy is lowered by only 0.0195 a.u. for F H2 but the decrease is 0.0443 a.u. for FH + H. This, of course, accounts for the greater exothermicity reported for the final calculation, a value very close to the reported experimental value.
+
+
x59
J. T. Muckerman, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 54, 1155.
62
Theoretical Chemistry
The saddle point occurs early in the inlet channel with and without CI but earlier in the former case, corresponding to a small displacement from the H-H equilibrium bond distance (ca. 0.03 a.u.) while the H-F distance is ca. 1.1 a.u. greater than that in HF. H F2-+HF F.-After their success with the 11-electron H2F system, Bender and co-workers1f5then attacked the 19-electron HF2 problem. A double-zeta GTO basis set is again used, (9s5p on F and 4s on each H contracted to a [4s2p/2s]set, a total of 52 basis functions in this case). The addition of the same polarization functions as were used in the H2F surface would increase the basis set to 75 GTO’s and would make the calculation of as many points needed to define the potential energy surface prohibitively time-consuming. Noting that the non-polarization function results of H2F were at least of qualitative accuracy, Bender et al. decided to do what they called a ‘first study’ on this system leaving the polarization function out. Using the I N 0 method, 555 carefully selected configurations were mixed in a CI calculation. Linear and non-linear approaches of the H atom were investigated and, as in the H2F case, the results predicted a linear approach. The saddle point in this case again occurs early in the inlet channel, the F-F bond having separated by only 0.06 a.u. while the F-H distance is more than twice that for the isolated diatomic. Table 10 summarizes the results of this work. The exothermicity predicted by the
+
+
Table 10 Summary of results of Bender et al.l15on the reaction H Barrier height/kJ mol-l Exothermicity/kJ mol-l Saddle-point geometry/A H-F F-F a
Experimental activation energy (ref. 260).
SCF
CI
51
4.2 369
554 1.56
1.49
+
Fa
Exper-intental lo? l a 429b
2.05 1.57
I
-
See footnote 12 in ref. 115.
CI calculation is found to be smaller than the experimental value by 60 kJ mol --I. A glance at Table 9 will show that without polarization functions, the exothermicity in the I: Hz was too small by the same order of magnitude (48 kJ mol-l). The activation energy reported in Table 10 is, of course, not exactly comparable to the barrier heights reported here. Bender et al. report the results of an unpublished work by Muckerman wherein he reports that the barrier height in this case should be 5 kJ mol-I less than the activation energy for this system. The experimental activation energy is reported to be lo+ 1 kJ mol -1,260 and this correction gives an experimental barrier height of ca. 5 kJmol-1 which is in excellent agreement with the barrier height computed with the CI wavefunction. Comparison of the poor results obtained without polarization functions in the H2F work with these results leads one to believe that the good agreement with experiment may just be fortuitous. On the other hand, one may also conclude that the basis set produces an entrance
+
260
R. G. Albright, A. F. Dodonov, G. K. Lavronskaya, I. I. Morosov, and V. L. Tal’rose, J. Chem. Phys., 1969,50, 3632.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfues
63
+
channel H F2 -+ H-F-F which is more closely parallel to the true entrance HF to the true exit channel than is the calculated exit channel H-F-F -+ H channel. This would account for good agreement with the experimental barrier height in spite of poor agreement with the experimental exothermicity. Surfaces for X + M2 and M + Xs.-The potential energy surfaces for the two exothermic reactions considered immediately above, F H2 and H F2, are repulsive in the nomenclature of Polanyi,l4915 i.e. a surface in which most of the exothermicity is released as the products separate. The other possible extreme of behaviour of a potential energy surface for an exothermic reaction is denoted by characterizing the surface as being of the ‘early downhill’ or ‘attractive’ type.l4~l5 In these systems, most of the exothermicity of reactions appears as vibrational excitation of the newly formed bond. The alkali metal (M), halogen (X) reactions of the type X M2 + MX M and X2 MX X M
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
both possess this type of potential surface, and both have been the subject of experimental studies by molecular beam techniques. Struve, Kitagawa, and Herschbach261have investigated the reactions of C1 atoms with Na2 and Kz, in which they observed electronic excitation of alkali atoms. Zare and co-workersz62 have performed crossed molecular beam experiments on the I K2 system, in which they detected a chemiluminescence spectrum which may be due to a bound IK2 species. Miller, Safron, and H e r s c h b a ~ h ,in~ ~crossed-beam ~ studies of the reaction M2 M1 + M2X + MlX
+
+
have established the importance of a long-lived collision complex XMlMZ in the interpretation of the dynamics of these simple reactions. The family of reactions, XZ -+ MX X, has been extensively studied by crossed molecular beam M techniques.264 Potential energy surfaces for both types of reactions have now been calculated by ab initio techniques; for the system Li + F2 -+ LiF + F by Balint-Kurti and Liz -+ LiF + Li by Pearson et aZ.267 KarplusZ65p266and for F Pearson et aZ.267 have carried out a single configuration SCF and a twoconfiguration SCF calculation of the potential surface for the FLi2 system. They point out that the single configuration SCF approximation itself, in general, provides a relatively good description of ionic species, such as are involved in this reaction. The added configuration, for most regions of the surface, insured the correct
+
+
+
W. S. Struve, T.Kitigawa, and D. R. Herschbach, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 54, 2759. R. N. Zare, unpublished work referred to in ref. 267. 26-W. S. Struve, MoI. Phys., 1973, 25, 777. 263 W. B. Miller, S. A. Safron, and D. R. Herschbach, Discuss. Faraday Soc., 1967, 44, 108. 264 J. H. Birely, R. R. Herm, I S.R. Wilson, and D. R. Herschbach, Discuss. Faraduy SOC.,1967, 44, 176; R. Grice and P. B. Empedocles, J. Chern. Phys., 1968,48, 5352. 265 G. G. Balint-Kurti and M. Karplus, Chern. Phys. Letters, 1971, 11, 203. G. G. Balint-Kurti, MoI. Phys., 1973, 25, 393. 267 P. K. Pearson, W. J. Hunt, C . F. Bender, and H. F. Schaefer, J . Chern. Phys., 1973,58,5358. 261 262
64
Theoretical Chemistry
asymptotic description of the system for infinite separation of all three nuclei. Although the added configuration does not properly describe this separated atom limit for the portions of the surface describing CzUgeometries of LiFLi, it does provide the most important single correction to the wavefunction in the region of the predicted equilibrium geometry for this species. A large s-p basis set (doublezeta quality) of GTO’s was employed with added polarizing d-type functions on F. In addition, a diffuse set of p-type functions was added to the F basis set. Duke and Baderas have pointed out that without this added diffuse function, Dunning’s (9~,5p)-+[4~,2p] set51 for F provides a much better description of the neutral F atom than it does of the F - ion, with the consequence that even the Hartree-Fock estimate of the electron affinity of fluorine is not obtainable with the use of the unaugmented set for the description of both F and F-. Use of the augmented set yields 97 % of the Hartree-Fock estimate of the electron affinity of fluorine.88 A minimum energy path was obtained for the collinear reaction. However, a point of particular interest in these calculations was a search of the potential surface to verify the postulated existence of a stable collision complex263or even a stable molecule262 for the system FLi2. Both the single- and double-configurations predict a potential well of ca. 17 kJ mol -l depth with respect to LiF + Li for the linear F-Li-Li species. A much deeper well with a depth of ca. 34 kcal mol -l was found for the LiFLi speciesof CZ2, symmetry. Struve,262aby employing the pseudopotential method of Child and Roach,23 has calculated a potential energy surface for the FLiz system. He obtains a collinear well of ca. 38 kJ mol -1 for F-Li-Li and an isosceles triangle well depth of ca. 84 kJ mol -l. While the reliability of the ab initio results are difficult to assess in this case, the authors267 conclude that certain salient features of their surface findings could be included in a LEPS-type formulation of the surface and employed in a dynamical study of the F + Liz and/or LiF Li reactions to obtain information concerning the importance of complex formation in such systems. In the theoretical determination of the potential surface for the LiFz system by Baht-Kurti and Karplus2659 266 a multistructure valence-bond approach was used. This method of calculation was augmented by the so-called orthogonalized Moffit method. This latter technique was applied to correct for the relatively large errors made in the ab initiu description of F - relative to F. Their calculation provided the first fully theoretical prediction that the potential surfaces for the M XZsystems are indeed of the ‘attractive’ or ‘early downhill’ type. Model studiesl4*I5had indicated that the observed high vibrational excitation of the newly formed M-X bond was a characteristic feature of such surfaces, a point which has now been theoretically substantiated. The dynamic consequences of this calculated surface are X2 reactive systems. The compared266with those of previous models for the M possibility of non-adiabatic contributions to the reactive scattering is also considered.266 CH2 + CH2-+C2H4.-The coplanar approach of two methylenes to form ethylene was investigated by Basch268 using the MCSCF method. The states of bent methylene that correlate with the ground state of ethylene are the triplet states. It is found that for two closed-shell singlet-state methylenes,the reaction path is purely repulsive.
+
+
+
a*8
H. Basch, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55, 1700.
Ab initio Calculation of Potential Energy Surfaces
65
The Valence Bond Approach.-In two papers on the potential energy surfaces of BeHl and H4+,Poshusta and c 0 - w o r k e r s ~ ~ ~used ~ 2 ~a0 combination of SCF and valence bond configuration interaction (VBCI) methods. For the reaction Ha Be++BeH,+,2G9a large portion of the potential energy surface was evaluated with the SCF method and then the VBCI technique was applied along the reaction path thus defined. For the lowest state (2A1symmetry) a minimum is found on the Cavpath with H-Be-H angle of 20.5" and BeH distance of 4.17 a.u. The binding energy is reported as 0.11eV. In these calculations, ca. 40 % of the correlation energy was accounted for. For the reaction Ha + Ha+-+Hs+ H,270 VBCI calculations were performed on all the points considered. Five attitudes of approach of H2 and H i and three attitudes of retreat of H i and H were considered, while the geometries of H2, H i , and H,+were fixed at their respective calculated equilibrium values. The steepest approach potential is found to be one in which the H i axis bisects the H2 axis. The steepest retreat potential is one in which the H atom leaves the triangular H,+ ion on the same axis on which it entered. With this general reaction path defined, the calculations were repeated with the optimization of the H-H bond distance. A minimum was found at H-H and H-H + distances of 1.66 a.u. and 4.1 1 a.u., respectively, while the distance from the leading H atom of the H i ion to the bisector of the H2 molecule is 1.44 a.u. The binding energy is found to be 3.6 kJ mol-l. Close examination of the studies reviewed in this chapter reveals a very important fact. Although the general approaches used in all the problems discussed have their similaritiesand although general rules can be stated, the field of ab initio calculations of potential energy surfaces has not yet reached the point where the computations can be routinely carried out. Although it is true that if one picks a large enough basis set of either GTO's or STO's and performs a full CI at a large enough number of points on the hypersurface, one will be reasonably assured of obtaining meaningful potential energy surfaces, the problem of time expended posed by even the largest and fastest computers available today requires that each system be treated differently. Until the day either when newer and faster computational methods are devised which will attain the same degree of accuracy, or when computers are made with speeds many orders of magnitude greater than those in existence today, the quantum chemist who attempts to produce meaningful potential surfaces will have to study his problem very carefully. It is in this respect that one can call this area of theoretical chemistry an art.
+
+
269
270
R. D. Poshusta, D. W. Klint, and A. Liberles, J. Chem. Phys., 1971, 55,252. R. D. Poshusta and D. F. Zetik, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 118.
2 Intermolecular Forces BY J.
G. STAMPER
1 Introduction The theory of intermolecularforces poses the same problem as the theory of valence, but in a slightly different form. The fundamental difficulty in calculating bond energies is that they appear as small differences between large numbers (the total energies of the molecules and atoms concerned), so that a much greater percentage accuracy is needed in the calculations than is aimed at in the dissociation energy itself. In the case of intermolecular forces this problem is even more serious. Typical binding energies at the van der Waals minimum between non-polar molecules are of the order lo-* ax., so that an attempt to calculate such a quantity by direct comparison of the calculated energies of the two separated molecules and of the ‘supermolecule’ made up of the two together requires an accuracy of at least 1 part in lo7 even for quite small systems. Nevertheless, such calculations have been and are being made and some examples are referred to in Section 3. In principle, however, the intermolecular force problem has a compensating advantage. Because of the very small changes introduced by the interaction, at least until the repulsive part of the potential surface is reached, this is an ideal situation for the application of perturbation theory which has not, in general, been a particularly powerful tool in valence problems. Even so, except at large distance where the overlap of the wavefunctions of the two molecules is negligible, the application of perturbation theory raises some problems. In the main these were sorted out in the years around 1970, but work in this area continues and some of it is discussed in Section 2. Actual calculations that have been carried out are still confined almost entirely to atoms, so that the title ‘Intermolecular Forces’ is almost a misnomer, ‘Interatomic Forces’ being much closer to the state of the art. Some calculations are aimed primarily at understanding the short-range, repulsive region of interaction. These are discussed in Section 3, while Section 4 covers recent results on the long-rangeregion. A number of other topics are collected together in Section 5. These include systems containing more than two molecules, the hydrogen bond, the eRect of intermolecular forces on the properties of molecules, and a brief survey of recent work o n empirical potentials and on van der Waals molecules, which are likely in the future to provide more and more detailed information for the theoretician to interpret, 2 General Theory Almost all the work in this area recently has been concerned with the difficultiesof applying perturbation theory in the region in which overlap is non-negligible. The
66
Intermolecular Forces
67
origin of this difficulty can be thought of in several different ways, but it is perhaps most easily seen by considering the symmetry of the unperturbed Hamiltonian Ho. The natural choice for this Hamiltonian is that for the separated molecules, so that it will contain only that part of the total potential which is due to interactions of electrons with their ‘own’ nuclei and with the other electrons in their ‘own’ molecule. Such a Hamiltonian will not be invariant to the antisymmetrizing operator A which permutes all the electrons, including those belonging to different molecules. The total Hamiltonian H is of course invariant to this operator, so that we may write
AH-HA = 0 However, when we write
H = Ho+ V it follows that
AHo-HoA = VA-AV of which neither side is zero. Here we have an equality between an apparently zeroorder expression and an apparently first-order expression which shows that any simple perturbation theory in which the various terms are considered order by order is bound to fail. The various methods of surmounting this difficulty which have been developed in the past few yearsl-5 have been brought within a common framework by Chipman, Bowman, and Hirschfelder.6 They start by writing the exact wavefunction for the pair of interacting molecules which has a definite symmetry as vy = ~ A @ ( Y ) where v labels the particular irreducible representation to which yy must belong, and vA is the corresponding projection operator. The equation which @(v) must satisfy is
which only defines the component of O(v) in the space of functions of The authors express this by writing
Y
symmetry.
( H - E ) @ ( y ) = (1 - ’A)F(v) which must hold for any F(v) whatever. They show that the various kinds of perturbation theory correspond to different choices of F(v) and develop a formalism for choosing an optimum F(v), i.e. an optimum form of perturbation theory. In the succeeding paper they apply this formalism to the case of He * OH+and provide a detailed discussion of the relative success of the various theories, i.e. the various possible choices of F(v). None of them seems to be conspicuously preferable and the reader is referred to the paper for details. By choosing a variationally 1 2 8
4 6 6 7
J. 0. Hirschfelder and R. Silbey, J. Chem. Phys., 1966, 45, 2188. J. N. Murrell and G. Shaw, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,46, 1768. J. I. Musher and A. T. Amos, Phys. Rev., 1967,164, 31. A. van der Avoird, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1967, 1, 24, 41 1. J. 0. Hirschfelder, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1967, 1, 325, 363. D. M. Chipman, J. D. Bowman, and J. 0. Hirschfelder, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59,2830. D. M. Chipman and J. 0. Hirschfelder, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 2838.
68
Theoretical Chemistry
optimized form for F(v), Chipman and Hirschfelder obtain an energy to first order which is within 6 kJ mol-1 of the exact value at an internuclear distance of 1 a.u., which is quite remarkable for a perturbation theory. In addition to this very general theory, two other ways of dealing with the problem have appeared in the past year. Berrondos points out that the eigenvalues of the antisymmetrizing operator (A) are highly degenerate and that there are, therefore, an infinite number of orthonormal transformations that can be applied to a basis set of simple product functions to diagonalize the representation of A. He suggests ways in which a particular choice of transformation may be made before carrying out any standard kind of perturbation theory such as Rayleigh-Schrodinger in the transformed basis. It is not easy to see how practical an approach this is likely to be; certainly the transformations that the author chooses as examples are cornplicatedlooking ones which involve the continuum. Gouyet 9 has applied the formalism of second quantization and diagrammatic perturbation theory to the problem. In a basis of non-orthogonal orbitals, diagrammatic perturbation theory becomes more difficult; Gouyet follows previous authorslo~llin transforming to a new basis of ‘biorthogonal’ orbitals in which the Hamiltonian is no longer Hermitian. He is able to show that certain classes of diagrams corresponding to intramolecular terms cancel exactly, but it is not clear whether the formalism is likely to be computationally attractive. In a second paper l2 he extends his work to situations with degeneracy. A number of other formalisms of various kinds have appeared. Kirtman and his co-workers have extended their ‘distinguishable electron method’13 to the inter.~~ mediate distance region14 and also to a discussion of quadrupole t e r m ~ChanglS has applied this method to the case of nuclear permutation symmetry and used it for the repulsive regions of the H: and HHe2+ potential. A combined variational and perturbation method which is applicable at all internuclear distances has been described.17 The method is, however, limited to one-electron systems, and the authors themselves say that it will probably be difficult to extend to polyelectronic cases. Daudey et al.18 choose to develop perturbation expansions for the isolated molecules and for the two molecules together and compare terms in the two expansions to find which are intermolecular terms. The approach does not seem to be too promising since they find that for the model case of two helium atoms l9 they need to go as far as the fifth order of perturbation to get even a qualitatively correct form for the potential curve. This appears to be partly because of difficulties with intraatomic correlation effects, and partly because of the orthogonalization procedure that they employ. They also apply their formalism to the water dimer.20
*
M. Berrondo, Mol. Phys., 1973, 26, 329. J. F. Gouyet, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 4637. D. J. Newman, J. Phys. and Chem. Solids, 1969, 30, 1709; 1970, 31, 1143. l1 M. Moshinsky and T. H. Seligman, Amer. Phys., 1971, 66, 31 1. l 2 J. F. Gouyet, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 3690. l 3 B. Kirtman and R. L. Mowery, J. Chem. Phys., 1971,55, 1447. l 4 T. J. Venanzi and B. Kirtman, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 523. l5 T. J. Venanzi and B. Kirtman, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 2158. l 6 S . - Y . Chang, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 1790. l7 T.-S. Nee, R. G . Parr, and S.-Y. Chang, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 4911. J. P. Daudey, P. Claverie, and J. P. Malrieu, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1974, 8, 1. l9 J. P. Daudey, J. P. Malrieu, and 0. Rojas, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1974, 8, 17. 2 o J. P. Daudey, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1974, 8, 29. lo
Intermolecular Forces
69
The intermolecular potential, which is the objective of all the work mentioned so far, has several applications. One of these is in the understanding of the properties of gases, typically by the calculation of virial coefficients. Baer and his co-workers have been concerned with the possibility of going directly from the Hamiltonian of the system to the virial coefficients without calculating a potential function explicitly. Initially21 they confined themselves to the Coulomb forces, but they have now22 extended their formalism to include exchange effects. Their method consists essentially in working in an interaction representation, and making a Dyson expansion for the perturbation. They have also been able23 to obtain an expression for the virial coefficients in the zero-overlap approximation in terms of the polarizabilities of the isolated molecules at imaginary frequencies analogous to the familiar corresponding results for the dispersion f0rces.2~This work is very elegant, but whether it has any significant computational use remains to be seen. A few ‘loose ends’ have been tidied up. It has been generally believed that at the level of a restricted HartreeFock calculation, the interaction between pairs of closed-shell atoms must be asymptotically repulsive at large distances. This was shown to be true for a pair of helium atoms some years agoZ5 but has now been proved to be generally true.26 Steinera? has explained an apparent paradox in the treatment of the long-range interaction of two hydrogen atoms by means of the Hellman-Feynman theorem in which different orders of perturbation appear to be mixed. There continue to be calculations on model systems in order to look at the nature of the various terms which arise in the perturbation expansions. The work of Himwelder et al.? on H. -H+ is of this kind. Chdasiliski and Jeziorski have particularly concerned themselves with various second-order terms. They have obtained28 a multipole expansion for the exchangepolarization energy for H- H+, and they also give some approximations and limiting forms which give 99% of the exact value at the van der Waals minimum. In a further paper,29 they have investigated the second-order induction energy for the He OHsystem. This energy is, of course, asymptotically zero since the potential due to a neutral atom is zero at long distances. At short range, however, there is an exponentially decreasing potential due to the detailed structure of the atom, and it is the effect of this that the authors have considered. They have obtained an ‘exact’ ht-order wavefunction and secondorder energy using a Green’s function method. They find that most of the change in the wavefunction of one atom occurs near the nucleus of the other. At distances of the order of the chemical minimum, this part of the second-order Coulombic energy is much more important than the dispersion part, as is shown in Table 1. The authors also note that the combination of the Heitler-London energy and EEL at the chemical minimum is very close to the exact value, showing that E!t\ contains most
-
-
S. Baer and A. Ben-Shaul, J. Chem. Phys., 1972,56, 3773. Baer and E. Bergmann, J. Chem. Phys., 1974,60,440. 23 S . Baer and A. Ben-Shad, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59,2229. 24 A. Dalgarno, Adv. Chern. Phys., 1967, 12, 143. 25 N. R. Kestner, J. Chem. Phys., 1968, 48, 252. aa A. M. Lesk, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 44. 27 E. Steiner, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 2427. 28 G. Cha€asidskiand B. Jeziorski, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1973, 7 , 63, 745. z9 G. Chalasihki and B. Jeziorski, Mol. Phys., 1974,27, 649. 21
a2 S.
70
Theoretical Chemistry
Table 1 Relative importance of induction and dispersion in Ha * * H29 Internuclear distance/a.u. EGblE&,
8 0.087
4
6 0.06
0.6
ca.
2 3.5
of the effects due to ‘ionic’ terms, and that exchange polarization and higher-order terms are relatively unimportant. 3 Short- and Intermediate-range Forces At long range, a perturbation method is the obvious choice for the calculation of intermolecular interactions. At short ranges the standard methods of valence calculation are an equally obvious choice, and quite a lot of work of this kind is being reported. This type of calculation is also being carried out at intermediate distances at which perturbation theories of the type mentioned in Section 2 are also appropriate. Straight self-consistent field calculations have been carried out on the interaction of water with neon and arg0n.~0Here it is possible to obtain some of the attractive contribution to the intermolecular force since there will be an inductive secondorder interaction caused by the large dipole of the water molecule. Such interactions appear at the SCF level and the authors find a minimum in the potential at an 0.- *Ne distance of 3.63 A, with a binding energy of 0.71 kJ mol-1. There is a shallower minimum in the case of argon. Calculations at a similar level of sophistication have been carried out on the Hz. -He system,sl primarily, however, from the viewpoint of the hydrogen atom recombination reaction. The authors comment on the fact that the potential they obtain can be fitted to within ca. 10%as the sum of pairwise interactions. An SCF calculation has also been carried out32 on the He. * -Be2+system. The repulsive potential agrees quite well with scattering data down to an internuclear distance of ca. 0.4& after which the results disagree. * Ne and Be Ar, while Kaufman 33 has reported similar calculations on Be Poshusta and Zetik in a valence-bond cal~ulation3~ find a small binding (3.6 kJ mol-l) between HZand HZ. The majority of calculations of this kind, however, go beyond the SCF limit, either by ordinary configuration interaction, or by a fully fledged multiconfiguration SCF calculation. Both of these methods are capable of including dispersion effects and are therefore to be expected to be useful at larger distances than the straight SCF calculation. Two provisos must be made at this point, both of which have been commented on by authors cited below. One is that the kind of excited configuration needed to include dispersion forces is rather different from that appropriate for intramolecular correlation, so that it is necessary, in calculations using relatively modest basis sets, to include additional functions of appropriate symmetry with rather small and carefully chosen exponents. The second is that, particularly in the region where interaction is small, a spurious binding effect may arise because the
-
--
-
3O 3l 32
39 34
-
M. Losonczy, J. W. Moskowitz, and F. H. Stillinger, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 32.64. C. W. Wilson, jun., R. Kapral, and G. Bums, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 24, 488. S. W. Hamson, L. J. Massa, and P. Solomon, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 263. J. J. Kaufman, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58,4880. R. D. Poshusta and D. F. Zetik, J. Chern. Phys., 1973, 58, 118.
Intermolecular Forces
71
basis functionscentred in one atom or molecule can provide additional flexibility for the wavefunction of the other atom or molecule, resulting in a lowering of the intramolecular or intra-atomic energy. Liu and McLean,35 taking considerable care to avoid the overcomplete basis set problem, have carried out a large configuration interaction calculation on He He. Their stated aim was an accuracy of 0.1 K and they calculate the depth of the van der Waals minimum as 9.23 K at an internuclear distance of 3.02 A. Tsapline and Kutzelnigg36 have made somewhat less accurate calculations on the H2- -He system around its van der Waals minimum. They attempt to avoid the problems outlined above by transforming their SCF orbitals to a localized basis and then calculating intermolecular pair correlation energies. They ignore the variation of intramolecular correlation with distance and, what is probably more important, the coupling between inter- and intra-molecular correlation. For the linear configuration there is a minimum 21 K in depth, and for the CZ,configuration there is a saddle point with a binding energy of 14 K. The result averaged over all orientations is slightly too low, while the anisotropy is slightly larger than the asymptoticvalue, which is supported by the experimentalevidence. A somewhat similar calculation 37 has been carried out on Hz- *HZ in four configurations. In this case a rather smaller basis set which included polarization orbitals with exponents adjusted to obtain the deepest van der Waals minimum was used. The authors believe that they have not eliminated all the spurious binding energy. All the data on the H2 - - - H2 potential at short range obtained by ab initio calculations have been reviewed by McMahon et R Z . , ~ who ~ discuss them from the point of view of scattering experiments. SCF-CI calculations have also been carried out for Ne - - * -Ne39in much the same way as in ref. 37, attempting to extend the calculations to quite large distances and including a d-orbital in the basis. The results at long distances cannot quite match the semi-empiricalmultipole ones. SCF-CI calculations40similar to those of ref. 36 have also been carried out on the systems He. * -HzO and He. * H Fto see how this type of calculation performs in a polar situation. The more difficult multi-configuration SCF method, which has already been applied to He. .He,41has now been applied to Ne. * *Ne42and to Ar. .H.43In each case only an approximation to the exact solution within the chosen basis set has been obtained in order to avoid the problem of spurious energies. The authors have been particularly interested to see how their results behave at the larger distances, They define a quantity AEvan der Waals as the difference between their total energy and the SCF energy, and find that it can be well represented by an expression of the c1o/R1O. In the case of Ne, their AEvan der wsals values are form C6/R6 + Cs/R8 within a few K of the calculations of Starkschall and Gordon.44 The c6 and c8
-
-
+
35 36 37 38 39 40
41 42 43 44
B. Liu and A. D. McLean, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59,4557. B. Tsapline and W. Kutzelnigg, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 23, 173. E. Kochanski, B. ROOS,P. Siegbahn, and M. H. Wood, Theor. Chim. A d a , 1973, 32, 296. A. K. McMahan, H. Beck, and J. A. Krumhansl, Phys. Reu. (A), 1974,9, 1852. E. Kochanski, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 25, 381. H. Lischka, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 21, 448. P. Bertoncini and A. C. Wahl, Phys. Rev. Letters, 1970, 25, 991. W. J. Stevens, A. C. Wahl, M. A. Gardner, and A. M. Karo, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60,2195. A. F. Wagner, G. Das, and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1974,60, 1885. G. Starkschall and R. G. Gordon, J. Chem. Phys., 1971,54,663; 1972,56,2801.
72
Theoretical Chemistry
values for Ar * - * H agree with earlier ~ a l u e s . 245~The ~ He - . - - He calculation has also been refined46 to allow for the variation in intra-atomic correlation energy with distance. This has the effect of reducing the well depth by ca. 1.2 K. The well depths and positions are given in Table 2. Table 2 Potential minima calculated by multiconfguration SCF
Ne.
Well depth/K
Rmin/a.u.
10.79 39.20 48.22
5.60 5.824 6.75
He. *He46 sNe42
&. ..H43
The most extensive calculation reported recently on a simple system is that of Kolos and W o l n i e w i c ~on ~ ~the intermediate and long-range parts of the hydrogenhydrogen potential for the lowest singlet and triplet states. Using a 60 term variational function, they calculate the energies of the two states for internuclear distances between 6 and 12 a.u. By comparing their curves for the two states they can separate the exchange and polarization contributions to the interaction energy and compare their magnitudes and how well they are given by asymptotic approximations. Tables 3 and 4 present some of their results. It can be seen that the exchange energy Table 3 Analysis of the interaction energy (cm-1) for two H atoms ( X l C ; R1a.u. 6 8 10 12
Exchange energy - 112.6 -3.87 -0.118 -0.0035
Polarization energy -71.5 -8.30 - 1.800 -0.556
Asymptotica exchange -97.63 -3.671 -0.117 - 0.0034
Variationalb polarization - 71.47 -8.27 - 1.80 -
Total energy 183.088 12.168 1.918 0.559
Calculated from the expression490.821 x R5/2exp (-2R). Calculated in the same way as the total energy but leaving out all exchange terms in the wavefunction.
Table 4 Analysis of the interaction energy (cm-1) of two H atoms (b3Cfstate)47 Asymptotic exchangea Variational polarization 26.2 -4.60 -- 1.68
+
R1a.u. 6 8 10 a
See notes to Table 4.
b
First-order exchangeb f Variationul polarization 27.6 -4.84 - 1.70
First-order exchange Asymptotic second-order polarization 33.2
+
-5.6
- 1.74
Total calciilated energy 41.26 -4.42 - 1.68
Heitler-London wavefunction.
can be approximated well by the asymptotic formula in the singlet case and by a simple Heitler-London first-order calculation in the triplet state, but that the asymptotic approximation to the polarization interaction is unsatisfactory in the 45 46 47
W. D. Davison, J. Phys. (B)., 1969,2, 1110. P. J. Bertoncini and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 1259. W.Kolos and L. Wolniewicz, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 24, 457.
Intermolecular Forces
73
region of the van der Waals minimum for the triplet state (R = 7.85 a.u.). Taking only the leading term in the R-l expansion gives even poorer agreement. In significantly larger systems, the SCF level is all that is at present attainable. Clementi and his co-workers have been carrying out a series of SCF studies48of the interaction between singly-charged ions and a water molecule. Some of their results are presented in Table 5. Where comparison is available it can be seen that the agree-
Table 5 SCF data on the interaction of an ion with a water molecule48 Ion Li+ Na+
a
AHcalc.a/kJmol-l 140.6
K+
97.1 65.7
Fc1-
A Ug calca/kcal mol-1 98.5 49.6
For the process M=t,H,O = M=t
+
H,O.
AHexpt. 01b / k J mol-1 142.3 100.4
b
Re(M-0)la.u. 3.58
4.25
74.9
5.08
L F -H -0 4.5" 14.6"
4.75
6.26
Ref. 50.
ment with experiment is remarkably good. The investigation of the potential surfaces is very much more extensive in this work than is represented by the data in the table. Calculations for halide ions surrounded by a whole co-ordination sphere of water molecules have also been carried out51but only at the CNDO level. On this basis, the optimum co-ordination number is found to be 8. The system H2CO - Li+ has also been the subject of an SCF cal~ulation.~~ The binding energy is found to be 181 kJ mol-1 and the equilibrium 0 - * .Li distance 1.77 A. Both molecule and ion are extensively polarized. Calculations which do not involve the SCF approach are also being made. Conway and Murrell53have calculated the exchange energy for Nee *Nearound the van der Waals minimum by 'first-order' perturbation theory. They find that a very accurate SCF function for the atom is needed for a satisfactory result. 'Double-zeta' wavefunctions, for example, are not sufficient. They compare their results with the analytic fits to other kinds of calculation and find that they agree well with an SCF cal~ulation5~ but poorly with a Thomas-Fermi-Dirac calculation.55 This type of approach does not appear to be adequate near the potential minimum. Combining their calculation with the dispersion results of Starkschalland Gordon,44 Conway and Murrell obtain a potential curve which is in agreement with the experimental one to within the somewhat large experimental error. KochanskiSO has made similar calculations for the H2 - . H2 system, while Brumer and Karplus57 have applied the same kind of formalism to the interaction of alkali and halide ions, obtaining a
-
-
--
H. Kistenmacher, H. Popkie, and E. Clementi, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58,1689,5627;59,5842. C. Herring and M. Flicker, Phys. Rev., 1964,134A, 362. 60 I. Diidit and P. Kebarle, J. Phys. Chem., 1970,74, 1466. 61 B. Kh. Bunyatan, D. A. Zhogolev, and F. Ritschl, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974,24, 520. 6% P. Russegger and P. Schuster, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973,19, 254. 6% A. Conway and J. N. Murrell, Mol. Phys., 1974,27, 873. 54 T. L. Gilbert and A. C. Wahl, J. Chem. Phys., 1967,47, 3425. 66 A. A. Abrahamson, Phys. Rev., 1969,178,76. 66 E . Kochanski, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58,5823. 67 P . Brumer and M. Karplus, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58, 3903.
48
49
74
Theoretical Chemistry
formal derivation of the Rittner58 potential. At a much more semi-empirical level, Schug and Dyson5Q have used this formalism to investigate the interaction of benzene with the halogens. Their approximations give significantly too small a binding energy, but they do suggest that there are many configurations of comparable stability for the complex. Only two kinds of geometry, in fact, give no binding at all. An alternative to the perturbation theory approach is the approximate method of Gordon and JSim.60 In this method the electron density is first calculated as the s u m of the densities of the separate atoms and the energy is then obtained as the s u m of a Coulomb term calculated exactly, and kinetic energy, exchange, and correlation terms calculated from the free electron gas model. Though it worked well for larger systems, this calculation was not very satisfactoryfor He. * .He. Rae61 has pointed out that, as originally employed, the method of Gordon and Kim included an additional spurious electron self-energy. While this is unimportant for heavier atoms, it becomes very significant in a four-electron system like He. - *He. He shows how this error may be corrected and also adds dispersion terms to the corrected potential, obtaining potential curves for all the homonuclear inert gas pairs from He* * .He to Kr- .Kr. A further improvement has been suggested by Lloyd and Pugh,62 who apply the electron-gas expressions to a density due to the valence electrons only. This leads to an improvement over the results obtained by Rae for both A r e *Ar and Kr - - - *Kr. In the former case there is almost exact agreement with experiment, but the latter one is less satisfactory, though possibly within the experimental error. The method of Gordon and Kim has also been applied to the system Ar - w H C ~ . ~ Here it gives moderate agreement with the experimental data including the anisotropic part, especially at the shorter distances, but the potential well is too shallow, probably because of the neglect of dispersion terms. Schneidere4has also used this method for the interaction of Xe with itself and the other rare gases. Except in the case of Xe. .He where, for the reasons already mentioned, good agreement is not to be expected, he obtains values for the well depth, the position of the potential minimum, and the point at which the potential curve recrosses the zero-energy line which are within 10%of the experimental values, where these are known. +
-
-
-
-
4 Long-range Forces The theoretical understanding of the interaction between molecules at distances where the overlap is negligible has been well established for some years. The application of perturbation theory is relatively straightforward, and the recent work in this area has consisted in the main of the application of well-known techniques. In the case of neutral molecules, the first non-zero terms appear in the second order of perturbation, so that some method of obtaining the first-order wavefunction, or of approximating the infinite sum in the traditional form of the second-order energy expression, is needed. 58 59
Bo 61
62 6s
64
E. S . Rittner, J . Chem. Phys., 1951, 19, 1030. J. C. Schug and M. C. Dyson, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58,297. R. G. Gordon and Y.S. Kim, J. Chem. Phys., 1972,56,3122. A. I. M. Rae, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 18, 574. J. Lloyd and D. Pugh, Chem. Phys. Lerters, 1974,26, 281. S. Green, J. Clzem. Phys., 1974, 60,2654. B. Schneider, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58,4447.
75
lntermolecular Forces
The oldest approximation, in which the energy denominators are approximated by a single average excitation energy, allowing the summation to be evaluated in closed form, is still of use. Alvarez-Riggatti and Mason,65 for example, have used this approximation to obtain some relations between the coefficients in the asymptotic expressions. They give two expressionsfor the ratio cS/c6for a pair of unlike atoms in terms of properties of the isolated atoms and the corresponding pairs of like atoms. One of them had been obtained previously,s6 but the other, derived variationally, is new, and does not involve the average excitation energies explicitly. The authors state that they can estimate values of CSto 10-15 % accuracy. An alternative, and more recent, idea is the pseudo-spectral expansion, 67 in which Ho is diagonalized in some large basis of convenient functions and the summation in the second-order energy is evaluated exactly over the resulting eigenfunctions. This method has been used most recently by Bukta and Meath, who use it to obtain thirdand fourth-order terms intheH. * * -Hinteraction,e*andalso to obtain the asymptotic form of the interaction between a hydrogen atom in its ground state and one in its first excited ~tate.6~ They point out that in this case there is a resonant interaction which gives rise to a term in R-9 which has no other contribution. They also show that the whole expansion is of dubious value in this case since it appears to be strongly divergent. The same pseudo-spectral expansion has also been applied to the case of two lithium at0ms.70 In this, owing to the more complicated nature of Ho, difficulties arise from the finite size of the basis set. The authors use an extrapolation procedure to surmount this difficulty. Because the summation in the second-order energy is dominated by the first term, whose magnitude can be obtained experimentally from the excitation energy and oscillator strength of the corresponding electronic transition, the authors plot the calculated value of C6 against the calculated first term for various sizes of basis set, and choose for c6 that value which corresponds to the experimental value of the first term. In this way they obtain Cs(Li- - - .Li) =
-
- 1458
8 a.u.
0.711 and Ce(Li - - *He) They also obtain values for Cs(Li- * .H) [ -(67.4 [-(22.7 0.2)] which are not, however, corrected by an extrapolation procedure since in this case the second-order expansion is not dominated by a single term. Both these problems have been attacked recently by other authors, the groundstate-excited-state hydrogen case by Deal and Young,71 the lithium-lithium case by Caves,72who gives values for Ct3 and CSfor two ground-state atoms, and also c6 values for the interaction of a ground-state atom with atoms in the 3s, 45,5s, and 6s states. Another approach to the evaluation of higher-order energies is to obtain the perturbed wavefunction, or some approximation to it, explicitly. This method has
+
65 O7 68
69 70
71 7a
+
M. Alvarez-Rizzatti and E. A. Mason, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 518. H. L. Kramer and D. R. Herschbach, J. Chem. Phys., 1970, 53, 2792. R. E. Johnson, S. T. Epstein, and W. J. Meath, J. Chem. Phys., 1967, 47, 1271. J. F. Bukta and W. J. Meath, Mol. Phys., 1974,27, 1235. J. F. Bukta and W. J. Meath, Mol. Phys., 1973,25, 1203. J. E. Kouba and W. J. Meath, MoI. Phys., 1973,26, 1397. W. J. Deal and R. H. Young, Infernat. J. Quantum Chem., 1973, 7, 877. T. Caves, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59,6177.
76
rneoretical Chemistry
been used in several recent calculations, usually by finding the wavefunction variationally. Thus Arrighini et aZ.73have calculated the third-order dispersion energy for the interaction of a pair of hydrogen atoms, obtaining EF&, = 3.475x 103R-ll + 2.914x 105R-13
+
2.305 x 107R-15 (a.u.)
Their leading term agrees well with the even more accurate value obtained in the pseudo-spectral calculation cited above 68
c:)
=
3474.898 a.u.
-
Stewart and Webster74have solved the first-orderequation for the H * H case by a finite difference method. A much simpler series of calculations of this kind has been the investigation of the use of very simple trial functions as approximations to the first-order wavefunction by Teixeira-Dias and Varandas. Using a single Slater-type p-orbital or d-orbital they have calculated dipole and quadrupole polarizabilities at imaginary frequencies for hydrogen75 and heli~rn,~e and using a singlef-orbital they have obtained the octupole terms also for hydrogen.77 A few long-range calculations have also been carried out for larger atoms. These have, as usual, concentrated on obtaining the imaginary frequency polarizabilities and hence the various expansion coefficients,Doran 78 has extended his earlier work 79 on neon to argon, krypton, and xenon, using Brueckner-Goldstone perturbation theory. Table 6 lists the values for the leading coefficients of the dipole (D), quadru-
Table 6 Leading multipole dispersion coeflcients (in a.u.) for pairs of like inert-gas atoms 79 Gas Ne
C(DD) 6.882
Ar
66.89 135.11 281.15
Kr Xe
CWQ) 73.87 1176.4
2580.9 7033.5
C(QQ ) 379.68 10180 24275 83101
C(D0) 585.36 19116.9 41 191 157146
pole (Q), and octupole (0)interactions that he derives. The imaginary frequency polarizabilities are also accessible experimentally, in principle, via the oscillatorstrength distribution. Saxon 80 has reviewed the available evidence for neon and derived new values for the polarizabilities. Her resulting value for the CScoefficient is 6.352 a.u., which seems to be significantlydifferent from the value quoted in Table 6. Kestner 81 has extended his calculations using double-perturbation theory and the interchange theorem to the imaginary frequency polarizabilities of Ne, and gives He - *Neand Ne . .Ne asymptotic coefficients.These values differ from those just
-
73 74
75 76 77 i8
79 80
81
G . P. Arrighini, F. Biondi, and C. Guidotti, MoZ. Phys., 1973, 26, 1137. R. F. Stewart and B. C. Webster, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 19, 462. J. J. C. Teixeira-Dias and A. J. C. Varandas, Mot. Phys., 1973, 25, 1 1 85. J. J. C. Teixeira-Dias and A. J. C. Varandas, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 26, 197. A. 3. C. Varandas and 3. 3. C. Teixeira-Dias, Mol. Phys., 1973, 26, 241. M. B. Doran, J. Phys. ( B ) , 1974, 7 , 558. M. B. Doran, J . Phys. (B), 1972, 5, L151. R. P. Saxon, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 1539. J. T. Broussard and N. R. Kestner, J. C b m . Phys., 1973, 58, 3593.
77
Intermolecular Forces
quoted by up to 20%, showing that higher orders of, particularly, the correlation perturbation need to be considered. The problem of the effect of an inaccurate zeroth-order wavefunction on dispersion calculations has been looked at again by Magnasco82 using double perturbation theory for the He * He case. Using hydrogenic, screened hydrogenic, and approximate Hartree wavefunctions he obtained for cf3the values 0.702,1.057,and 1.304a.u., compared with the exact value 1.47. Riera and Meaths3 have done almost the only long-range calculations of intermolecular forces between molecules as opposed to atoms that have appeared recently. They have been interested in what they call the ‘non-diagonal’ terms in the secondorder energy which have both odd and even terms in the R-1 expansion. They give expressions for such terms and point out that they vanish on averaging over the various possible angular positions of the two molecules. Abdulnurg4 has given upper and lower bounds to the various Cn coefficients in terms of various sum rules that are available either experimentally,semi-empirically, or theoretically. Similar rules have previously been given, but the present ones give narrower bounds than are obtained by the application of correspondingmethods to the imaginary frequency polarizabilities. McRury and Linder85 have given a general formulation of the long-range interaction between a number of molecules, obtaining a diagrammatic expansion of the free energy of the system and also reformulating their results to emphasize collective behaviour. Mackrodt 86 has used diagrammaticmethods to investigate the effect on multipole forces of an external electric field.
- -
5 Miscellaneous Topics
Systems of more than Two Molecules.-Although most calculations in the field of intermolecular forces are still concerned with pairwise interactions, a number of calculations are being made on larger systems. The interest is usually in the departures from additivity which may be found, as in the SCF calculations on He3.87988 These calculations are restricted to the short-range region and show that for a linear configuration the non-additive part of the energy is positive and very nearly a function of the sum of the two short intermolecular distances, while for isosceles triangle configurations it is negative except at very short distances, when it increases rapidly. This system, and also He4, has been looked at by Magnasco and his co-workers though with the use of a less flexiblewavefunction.They obtain quite good agreement with the results just mentioned for He3, which suggests that their He4 results should also be at least qualitatively reliable. Perhaps their most interesting observation is that if they expand their energy terms in powers of the overlap integral (S),then 893
82
83 84 85 86
87 88 89 90
V. Magnasco, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 26, 192. A. Reira and W. J. Meath, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1973, 7 , 959. S. F. Abdulnur, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58,4835. T. B. McRury and B. Linder, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58, 5388,5398. W. C. Mackrodt, Mol. Phys., 1971, 27, 933. 0. A. Novaro and V. BeltrBn-Lbpez, J. Chem. Phys., 1972,56, 815. L. GonzBlez-Tovany, V. BeltrBn-LSpez, and 0. Novaro, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 1694. V. Magnasco and G. F. Musso, J. Chem. Phys., 1974,60, 3744. G. F. MUSSO, V. Magnasco, and M. P. Giardina, J . Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 3749.
Theoretical Chemistry
78
truncating the expansion after terms of order S2 gives the wrong sign for the nonadditive part of the energy even when S is as small as 0.03. In the region of negligible overlap, the three-body interactions can be calculated, just like the two-body ones, from imaginary frequency polarizabilities. This has been done, for example, by Doran 78 for interaction of triplets of noble-gas atoms. He gives the coefficients for dipole-dipole-dipole, dipoledipole-quadrupole, dipole-quadrupole-quadrupole, quadrupole-quadrupoleequadrupole, and dipole-dipoleoctupole terms. Most of the other calculations which involve more than two molecules raise the question of what is meant by a molecule. A number of SCF calculations have been carried out on assemblies of small atoms and ions which do not form familiar chemical species but which nonetheless appear to have larger dissociation energies than would normally be thought of as intermolecular. These include HeH3+,91 XeH+,92HenH, and HenH+ where n = l-4kg3 It is concluded that linear symmetric He2H+ is stable while HesH+ and He4H+ are not. Another calculation that is of interest, but difficult to classify, is that of Wilson et al.94 on the Hz- - .He system. They are primarily interested in obtaining a potential surface on which to study the role of He as a third body in hydrogen atom recombination reactions, so that they include in their study configurations in which the Ha - H distance is as large as 5 a.u., where the H-H interaction is quite small. They find that even in a calculation which does not include intermolecular correlation there are quite long-range contributions to non-additivity. Properties.-In the past few years there has begun to be an emphasis on calculating other properties of weakly interacting systems beside the energy. For example, systems of interacting identical non-polar molecules can develop a dipole moment which is responsible for the appearance of pressure-induced i.r. spectra. In the zerooverlap region the dipole can be expanded in powers of R-l just like the energy, and the leading term turns out to be of order R-7. The coefficient of this term, which is usually denoted by D7,has been calculated95by Whisnant and Byers Brown for the systems He. * - H and He. .He exactly, and they also suggest an approximate method which could be used for larger systems. They note that the dispersion contribution to the dipole at the collision diameter is of opposite sign to the exchange contribution, which the same group has also calculatedg6for a variety of inert-gas pairs. In this case they find that it is adequate to consider only the leading term in the expansion in terms of the square of the overlap. They also find, as has previously been noted for energy calculations (see e.g. ref. 53), that it is necessary to use accurate atomic wavefunctions; double-zeta functions, for example, are not adequate. Extrapolation from molecular SCF calculationsat shorter distances, as was done, for example, by Matcha and Nesbet, 97 is also unsatisfactory. Earlier, Byers Brown and Whisnant98 considered the calculation of D7 for pairs of H atoms, and they have
-
91 92
93 94 95 96 97 98
R. D. Poshusta and V. P. Agrawal, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 2477. C. Kubach and V. Sidis, J. Phys. ( B ) , 1973, 6, L289. M. B. Milleur, R. L. Matcha, and E. F. Hayes, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60,674. C. W. Wilson, jun., R. Kapral, and G. Burns, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 24, 488.
D. M. Whisnant and W. Byers Brown, Mol. Phys., 1973,26, 1105. A. J. Lacey and W. Byers Brown, Mol. Phys., 1974, 27, 1013. R. L. Matcha and R. K. Nesbet, Phys. Rev., 1967,160,72. W. Byers Brown and D. M. Whisnant, Mol. Phys., 1973,25, 1385.
Intermolecular Forces
79
given an approximate formula that is accurate to 1%. D7 can also be evaluated in terms of sum rules, and the necessary expressionshave been given by Abdulnur 99 for dissimilar S-state atoms. Unfortunately, many of the sum rules needed are not easily available, and the c8 coefficients from the energy expressions are also needed. Abdulnur has given some results for H, He, and Ne, however. Dipole moments for various configurations of Ha** * Hand H2* *H2have been calculated by ab initio methods.lO0 Martin101 has calculated the long-range dipole moment for systems of three identical atoms. For the H . .He O Hsystem he has used a pseudo-spectral perturbation method, while for He...He...He he has used the closure approximation. These quantities could be experimentally accessible via a pressure-induced i.r. absorption whose intensity varied as the cube of the pressure. Polarizabilities of pairs of interacting atoms have also continued to be studied. In this case the leading term at large distances is A&-6 and there are parallel and perpendicular componentsto be calculated. Buckingham and his co-workerslo2 have studied H - - .H and obtained both components of A6 and As. They find them to be larger than previous estimates. They have also studied He - -He, using both coupled Hartree-Fock and finite perturbation theories (which agreed).l03 They fmd that the limiting calculation is inaccurate even at large distances and they suspect that the polarizability changes sign twice as R increases. Another property which has been considered is the hyperfine shift in hydrogen. Fortune and Certain lo4have cakulated the effect on this quantity of the interaction with a helium atom at large distances and give an estimate of the R-*coefficientof the change. Hydrogen-bonded Systems.-The hydrogen bond may be looked upon as the weakest chemical bond, or as the strongest intermolecular interaction, but however it be classified, it continues to attract the theoretician; the number of SCF calculations continues to increase rapidly. The earlier calculations on water polymers have been summarized and discussed critically in terms of the size of basis set used.105 All the calculations give a similar description of the general features of the system. The nature of the hydrogen bond in water dimers has also been reinvestigated using bond orbitals by Bowers and Pitzer106 and using the formulation discussed earlier18 by Daudey.2O Both groups come to the familiar conclusion that there are three contributions to the interaction of approximately equal magnitude, two bonding (the electrostatic and charge transfer contributions) and one antibonding (the exchange contribution), the net energy of the hydrogen bond being equal in magnitude to all of them. The water dimer has also been studied experimentally in the molecular beam,107 the results agreeing well with the earlier calculations discussed in ref. 105. A new and very extensivecalculationhas been made for the water dimer by Clementi S. F. Abdulnur, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 23, 355. R. W.Patch, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,59, 6468. 101 P. H.Martin, Mol. Phys., 1974, 27, 129. loa A. D. Buckingham, P. H. Martin, and R. S. Watts, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 21, 186. loS A. D. Buckingham and R. S. Watts, Mol. Phys., 1973, 26, 7 . 104 P. J. Fortune and P. R. Certain, J. Phys. ( B ) , 1973, 6, L39. 105 J. E. Del Bene and J. A. Pople, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 3605. 106 M. J. T. Bowers and R. M. Pitzer, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 163. l o 7 T. R. Dyke and J. S, Muenter, J. Chern. P h p , 1974,60,2929,
loo
80
17teoretical Chemistry
and his co-workers, logwho go on to use their potential-energy surface in a MonteCarlo calculation for liquid water. They find good agreement with ‘experiment’, except that no second neighbour peak appears in their oxygen-oxygen radial distribution function. They attribute this to their use of a potential calculated for the dimer only. Water polymers have also been considered by Lentz and Scheraga.lo9 They were particularly interested to see if there were any additional non-additive effects in cyclic polymers in comparison with linear ones. Considering systems up to the tetramer, they found no evidence for such effects. They also used their results to calculate the lattice energy of Ice I. SCF calculations have also been made on the dimers of HFllO and formaldehyde.11l In the latter case two potential minima were found of comparable energy, one hydrogen-bonded and the other held together by the electrostatic interactions of the two carbonyl dipoles. The barrier between the two is, however, very low, and the two forms could almost certainly not be isolated. The situation in HCN is similar.l12 Other systems that have been studied in a similar way include : HF * * HCN, 113 in which the equilibrium structure is with the HF hydrogen-bonded to the HCN CHz0,114with R = H, nitrogen and there are no other potential minima; ROH. CH3, NH2, OH, or F, where the strength of the H bond parallels the o-withdrawing power of the substituent; ROH. -NH3,l15where the situation is similar; the intramolecular hydrogen bond in HOCH~CHZCH~OH, 116for which a strength of only 3.9 kJ mol-1 was found ; and CH3CONHCH3 -H20,117 a model system for proteins. The calculations on H2O- - aC1-48 have already been mentioned. Calculationshave been made on the interaction of a water molecule with formaldehyde in its lowest triplet and first excited singlet states.118-120The two calculations agree in locating the hydrogen bond between the water oxygen and the formaldehyde carbon because of the shift of charge in the carbonyl group on excitation. Reference 119 reports two rotational isomers in the triplet complex (separated by only a very small barrier) but only one in the singlet. Reference 118 reports blue shifts of 1100 cm-1 for the singlet and 1420 cm-1 for the triplet. The singlet value is confirmed in ref. 120, which also gives shifts for a number of other hydrogen-bonded formaldehyde complexes. In addition to these ab initio calculations, CNDO calculationscontinue to be made on hydrogen-bonded systems. The influence of substituents on acetic acid dimers, for example, has been investigated at this level of approximation.lZ1
-
0
H. Popkie, H. Kistenmacher and E. Clementi, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 1325. B. R. Lentz and H. A. Scheraga, J. Chem. Phys., 1973,58, 5296. 110 D. R. Yarkony, S. V. O’Neil, H. F. Schaefer, C. P. Baskin, and C. F. Bender, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 855. 111 J. E. Del Bene, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 3812. 113 J. E. Del Bene, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 24, 203. J. E. Del Bene and F. T. Marchese, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 926. 11* J. E. Del Bene, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 3139. J. E. Del Bene, J. Amer. Chem. SOC.,1973, 95, 5460. 116 A. Johansson, P. Kollrnan, and S. Rothenberg, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 18, 276. 11‘ A. Pullman, G.Alagona, and J. Tomasi, Theor. Chim. Acta, 1974, 33, 87. 118 S. Iwatu and K. Morokuma, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 19, 94. ll9 J. E. Del Bene, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 23, 287. l a o J. E. Del Bene, J. Amer. Chem. Suc., 1973, 95, 6517. 121 B. M.Rode, A. Engelbrecht, and W. Jakubetz, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 18, 285. lo8
lo9
Intermolecular Forces
81
Empirical Potentials and Related Topics.-Although this review mainly deals with the calculation of intermolecular potentials either ab initio, or at least from parameters such as sum rules which are derived from experiments not directly concerned with molecular interactions, nevertheless, there have recently been so many attempts to derive more accurate empirical potentials (with which any calculation must be compared) from new experimental data that it seems appropriate to mention some of this work. The noble gases have received most attention. New evidence which has been obtained from the spectra of the van der Waals molecules involving these atoms has been reported.122, 123 From this and other data, potential curves have been obtained by Maitland et al. f o r k . * .Ar,124Ne* .Ne,125Kr** .Kr,126andXe. * .Xe.12'They give numerical potentials and also an empirical form with a variable exponent in the repulsive part, i.e.
--
where n = 13.0
+
r* =
y(r*-l)
r/Ymin
-
which they suggest 128 is superior, at least for Ar - .Ar, to both that of Barker e f al.lZg and of Smith and Thal~kar.1~0 These latter authors have recently refined their potential, in which they use Hermite interpolation between a Morse potential at short distances and an R-n expansion at large distances, in the light of the recent evidence for all the noble-gas pairs.131 Taylor and Weis~man,13~ however, suggest that none of the empirical potentials that they have tested, which includes that of Maitland et al., as well as the traditional Lennard-Jones and Buckingham ones, has sufficient flexibilityto fit their thermal diffusion data on 2ONe. .22Ne.The sensitivity of thermal diffusion has also been discussed by Nenfeld and A~iz.1~3 The Buckingham (exp - 6) potential has been modified by Toennies, 134 who has added theoretical estimates44of R-* and R-l0 terms and obtains what are probably fortuitously accurate positions for the potential minima in the noble-gas dimers. Present 135 has considered the derivation of the A r e .Ar potential and suggests that a revised value should be used for the dissociation energy. Spectral data on a wide variety of van der Waals molecules are now becoming available. The noble-gas dimers have already been mentioned, but many others are now yielding detailed data on, especially, the angular dependenceof potentials, which
-
lZ2 lZ3 124
lZ5 126 lZ7
lZ8 129 130 131 132 133 l34 135
Y.Tanaka, K. Yoshimo, and D. E. Freeman, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 564. M. C. Castex and N. Damany, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 24, 437. G. C. Maitland and E. B. Smith, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 22, 443. G. C. Maitland, MoZ. Phys., 1973, 26, 513. D. W. Gough, E. B. Smith, and G. C. Maitland, Mol. Phys., 1974, 27, 867. D. W. Gough, E. B. Smith, and G. C. Maitland, Mol. Phys., 1973, 25, 1433. A. N. Dufty, G. P. Matthews, and E. B. Smith, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1974, 26, 108. J. A. Barker, W. Fock, and F. Smith, Phys. Fluids, 1964, 7 , 897. V. H. Smith, jun. and A. J. Thakkar, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1972, 17, 274. A. J. Thakkar and V. H. Smith, jun., Mol. Phys., 1974,27, 191 (Ar, Kr,Xe), 593 (He, Ne). W. L. Taylor and S. Weissman, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 3684. P. D. Neufeld and P. A. Aziz, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59,2234. J. P. Toennies, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 20, 238. R. D. Present, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 2659.
Theoretical Chemistry
82
represents something of a challenge to the theoretician. The subject has been reviewed to 1973 in a paper on the i.r. spectrum of 0 2 - .Ar by Henderson and Ewing, 136 who mention, beside the noble-gas pairs, (02)2, (HF)2, (C02)2, (N2)2, (H2)2, and H2- * -Ar. A list of preliminary observations by molecular beam methods is given by Novick et aZ.137 More detailed results have recently been given on Ar- * .HCl and Ar * * DCI 138 and Ar - HF,139 from molecular beam measurements, and on Ar...H214* from the i.r. spectrum. The i.r. spectrum of hydrogen in an argon matrix has been interpreted in terms of a van der Waals molecule Ar - - .H2,141while evidence on the anisotropy of the He. .H2 and Ne. .H2 potentials has been obtained by n.m.r. relaxation-time measurements.142 The long-range part of the halogen-halogen potential correlating with the B3n[ouf excited state of the diatomic molecule has been obtained by the RKR method, yielding c5, CS, and c8 coefficients for I - - .I,143Br - - - Br, and C1-
-
-
136 lS7
G . Henderson and G. E. Ewing, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 2280. S. E. Novick, P. B. Davies, T. R. Dyke, and W. Klemperer, J . Amer. Chem. SOC.,1973, 95, 8547.
13*
139 140 141 142
143 144
S. E. Novick, P. B. Davies, S. J. Harris, and W. Klemperer, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 59, 2273. S. J. Harris, S. E. Novick, and W. Klemperer, J. Chem. Phys., 1974, 60, 3208. G. Henderson and G. E. Ewing, Mol. Phys., 1974, 27, 903. S. S. Cohen, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 18, 369. J. W. Riehl, C. J. Fisher, J. D. Baloga, and J. L. Kinsey, J. Chem. Phys., 1973, 58, 4571. K. K. Yee, Chem. Phys. Letters, 1973, 21, 334. K. K. Yee and T. J. Stone, Mul. Phys., 1973, 26, 1169.
3 Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules BY C. THOMSON
1 Introduction This Report deals with recent theoretical work on small molecules, and covers the literature to 1 July 1974. Discussion is restricted to molecules containing up to four atoms, and work on molecules containing approximately 5-12 atoms will be reviewed in Vol. 3. This Report does not aim to be in any sense comprehensive, especially since the literature on quantum chemistry is expanding so rapidly, and discussion is restricted to those results in the field of calculations on small molecules which are judged by this Reporter to be of particular importance. Both non-empirical (ab initio) and semi-empirical calculations will be dealt with, but since most work on small molecules in recent years has used ab initio methods, this type of calculation will be emphasized. Most of the papers cited refer to work published during the period 1972-74, but there are also references to work of particular importance prior to 1972 if necessary. Developments in the theoretical methods as such will not be dealt with in any detail, the emphasis being on the results of calculations. Results are usually quoted in atomic units* @istances/bohr, energies/hartree), but there are occasional exceptions to this. A number of books and review articles dealing with the subject matter of this chapter should first be mentioned. The most comprehensive introduction to recent work is by Schaefer,l whilst a more recent book on ab initio calculations, by Cook, is also recommended.2A fairly comprehensive bibliography (up to 1974) on a b initio calculations is provided by Richards et aL3 Volume 1 of the MTP Review of Science4 deals with theoretical chemistry and contains several articles of interest, particularly an article by Wahl on diatomic molecules, and a review of the work of Pople’s group. There have also been several books dealing with semi-empirical methods in
H. F. Schaefer, tert., ‘ElectronicStructure of Atoms and Molecules’, Addison Wesley, Boston, 1972. D. B. Cook, ‘Ab-Initio Valence Calculations in Chemistry’, Wiley, London, 1974. W. G. Richards, T. E. H. Walker, and R. Hinkley, ‘Bibliography of Ab-Initio Molecular Wave Functions’, Oxford University Press, 1971, 1974. ‘Theoretical Chemistry’, ed. W. Byers-Brown, ‘MTP International Review of Science: Physical Chemistry, Series One’, 1972, Vol. 1.
* 1 bohr = 0.529 18 A; 1 hartree
= 27.21 eV.
83
84
Theoretical Chemistry
quantum chemistry, and of particular note are those by Beveridge and Pople,5 and by Murrell and Harget.6 Among many recent review articles, Browne and Matsen’ have given a thorough review of recent work on three- and four-electron molecules, particularly He2, He:, LiH, and LiH+, and a series of articles dealing with many aspects of ab initiu work have appeared in two recent books which collect together the proceedings of two conferences.8. A detailed review on electron correlation surveys recent work and defines some of the problems in this areasloThere has been an excellent review of Walsh diagrams and molecular geometry from the point of view of csb initio calculations,ll and also a survey of ab initiu methods in chemistry.12 The recent developments in generalized Valence Bond (GVB) theory have been reviewed by Goddard and co-w0rkers,~3and also the use of natural orbitals in theoretical chemistry,l4,15 and the accuracy of computed one-electron properties.ls The XCC method has been reviewed by Johnson,17 and Hurley has discussed highaccuracy calculations on small molecules.18 Several other reviews of interest have appeared in Advances in Quantum Chemistry.l7 Localized orbital theory has been reviewed by England, Salmon, and Ruedenberg,lg and the bonding in transitionmetal complexes discussed by Brown et aL2O Finally, the recent developments in computational quantum chemistry have been reviewed by Ha1LZ1 2 Diatomic Molecules containing up to Four Electrons It is appropriate to review first the recent work on HZ and Hz. A. H i and H2.-Hl and H2 are particularly important molecules, which have been used both for testing new methods in quantum chemistry and also for investigation of the inclusion of small terms in the molecular Hamiltonian. The extensive earlier work has been reviewed by Kolos.22s23 Most ab initio calculations on molecules with more than three electrons have involved the assumption of the Born-Oppenheimer ( S O ) appr0ximation.l HowD. L. Beveridge and J. A. Pople, ‘Approximate Molecular Orbital Theory’, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1970. 6 J. N. Murrell and A. J. Harget, ‘Semi-empirical Self-consistent Molecules’, Wiley, London, 1972. 7 J. C. Browne and F. A. Matsen, Ado. Chem. Phys., 1973, 23, 161. a ‘Energy Structure and Reactivity’, ed. D. W. Smith and W. B. McRae, John Wiley, New York, 1973. 9 ‘Computational Methods for Large Molecules and Localized States in Solids’, ed. F. Herman, A. D. McLean, and R. K. Nesbet, Plenum Press, New York, 1973. 10 W. Kutzelnigg, Fortschr. Chem. Forsch., 1973, 41, 31. 11 R. J. Buenker and S. D. Peyerimhoff, Chem. Rev., 1974, 74, 127. 12 J. L. Whitten, Accounts Chem. Res., 1973, 6, 238. 13 W. A. Goddard, tert, T. H. Dunning, jun., W. J. Hunt, and P. J. Hay, Accounts Chem. Res., 1973, 6, 383. 14 E. R. Davidson, Adv. Quantum Chem., 1972, 6, 235. 15 E. R. Davidson, Rev. Mod. Phys., 1972, 44, 451. 16 S. Green, Adv. Chem. Phys., 1974,25, 179. 17 K. H. Johnson, Adv. Quantum Chem., 1973, 7 , 143. 18 A. C. Hurley, Ado. Quantum Chem., 1973,7, 315. 19 W. England, L. S. Salmon, and K. Ruedenberg, Fortschr. Chem. Forsch., 1971, 23, 31. 20 D. A. Brown, W. J. Chambers, and N. J. Fitzpatrick, Inorg. Chim. Acta, 1972, 6, 7. 21 G. G. Hall, Chem. SOC.Rev., 1973, 2, 21. 22 W. Kolos, Internat. J. Quantum Chem., 1968, 2, 471. 23 W. Kolos, Ado. Quantum Chem., 1970, 5, 99. i)
Quantum Mechanical Calculations on Small Molecules
85
ever, a recent series of papers by Bishop and co-workers has examined the use of a higher level approximation (the adiabatic approximation), which is based on the Born expansion of the total wavefunction, with neglect of non-diagonal nuclear terms. This approximation still allows the concept of a single potential-energy curve for a given electronic state. Bishop and Wetmore24p25 have calculated the adiabatic energy curves, dissociation energies, and vibrational energy levels for Hi, HD, and Daf.26 The non-adiabatic corrections w