Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Editors: P.P. De, N. Roy Choudhury, and N.K. Dutta
Author
Thermal ...
251 downloads
2913 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Editors: P.P. De, N. Roy Choudhury, and N.K. Dutta
Author
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Editors: Namita Roy Choudhury Prajna P De Naba K Dutta
iSmithers - a Smithers Group Company Shawbury, Shrewsbury, Shropshire, SY4 4NR, United Kingdom Telephone: +44 (0)1939 250383 Fax: +44 (0)1939 251118 http://www.iSmithers.net
First Published in 2010 by
iSmithers Shawbury, Shrewsbury, Shropshire, SY4 4NR, UK
©2010, Smithers Rapra Technology Ltd
All rights reserved. Except as permitted under current legislation no part of this publication may be photocopied, reproduced or distributed in any form or by any means or stored in a database or retrieval system, without the prior permission from the copyright holder. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Every effort has been made to contact copyright holders of any material reproduced within the text and the authors and publishers apologise if any have been overlooked.
ISBN: 978-1-84735-103-6 (hardback) ISBN: 978-1-84735-102-9 (softback) ISBN: 978-1-84735-104-2 (ebook) Typeset by SA Hall Typesetting, Brixham Printed and bound by Lightning Source UK
Intelligent Tyres
This book is dedicated to the curious minds:
The pioneering researcher in the field of thermal analysis of rubbery materials; Professor Anil K. Sircar, formerly of the University of Dayton, Ohio, USA
Budding scholar Ankit K. Dutta, currently at the University of Adelaide, Australia
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Contents
Contents
Preface .............................................................................................................xiii 1
Introduction ................................................................................................1 References ....................................................................................................7
2
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials ...............................................................................11 2.1
Introduction ......................................................................................11
2.2
Differential Thermal Analysis (DTA) .................................................12 2.2.1
DTA Instrument ....................................................................13 2.2.1(a) Sample Holders ....................................................... 14 2.2.1(b) Furnace and Furnace Temperature Programmers .... 15 2.2.1(c) Differential Temperature Detection System.............. 16 2.2.1(d) Low Level DC Voltage Amplifier ............................ 16 2.2.1(e) Recorder.................................................................. 16 2.2.1(f) Atmosphere Control ............................................... 17
2.3
2.4
2.5
Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC)...........................................17 2.3.1
Heat-flux DSC .......................................................................17
2.3.2
Power Compensated DSC......................................................18
2.3.3
Temperature Modulated DSC (TMDSC) ...............................20
Thermogravimetry (TG) ....................................................................22 2.4.1
Thermobalance......................................................................24
2.4.2
Temperature Detection in TG or TGA ...................................24
2.4.3
Furnace and Furnace Temperature Programmers ...................24
2.4.4
Controlled Atmosphere .........................................................25
2.4.5
Sample Containers.................................................................25
2.4.6
Recorders ..............................................................................25
2.4.7
Software ................................................................................26
Derivative Thermogravimetry (DTG) ................................................27 i
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
2.6
Evolved Gas Analysis (EGA) or Evolved Gas Detection (EGD) .........28
2.7
Thermomechanical Analysis (TMA) and Thermodilatometry (TD) or Thermodilatometric Analysis (TDA) ....................................31
2.8
2.7.1
Parallel Plate Rheometry (PPR) .............................................34
2.7.2
Fibre Tension Spectrometry ...................................................35
2.7.3
Stress Relaxation Spectrometry .............................................36
Dynamic Mechanical Analysis (DMA) ..............................................36 2.8.1
2.9
Torsional Braid Analysis (TBA) .............................................39
Thermally Stimulated Current (TSC) .................................................41 2.9.1
Principle ................................................................................41
2.10 Relaxation Map Analysis (RMA) ......................................................44 2.11 Differential Photo Calorimetery (DPC)..............................................46 2.11.1 DPC Instrument ....................................................................47 2.11.2 Principle of Operation ...........................................................48 2.11.3 Uses of DPC ..........................................................................49 2.12 Dielectric Analysis (DEA) or Dielectric Thermal Analysis (DETA).....49 2.12.1 Technique ..............................................................................50 2.13 Newly Developed Thermal Analysis ..................................................52 2.14 New Combined Methods of Thermal Analysis ..................................53 2.14.1 Coupled Thermogravimetry – Infra red Spectroscopy (TG-IR) .............................................53 2.14.2 Coupled Thermogravimetry – Fourier Transform Infra red Spectroscopy (TG-FT-IR) ..........54 2.14.3 Coupled Thermogravimetry – Mass Spectrometry (TG-MS) .................................................55 2.14.4. Coupled Thermogravimetry – Gas Chromatography (TG-GC) .............................................56 2.14.5 Coupled TG-GC-IR ................................................................58 2.14.6 Coupled TG-GC-MS ..............................................................59 2.15 Conclusion ........................................................................................60 Acknowledgements .....................................................................................60 ii
Contents
References ..................................................................................................60 3
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials ...............................................................................65 3.1
Introduction .....................................................................................65
3.2
Differential Scanning Calorimetry of Rubbery Materials ...................65 3.2.1
Measurement of Specific Heat and Glass Transition Temperature .........................................................66
3.2.2
Significance of Tg ...................................................................67
3.2.3
Factors Affecting Tg ..............................................................69
3.2.4
Effect of Molecular Weight on Tg ..........................................69
3.2.5
Effect of Polymer Architecture on Tg .....................................71
3.2.6
Effect of Composition, Morphology and Thermal History on the Tg of Polymers ...............................................76
3.2.7
Effect of Crosslinking of Rubbers on Tg ................................85
3.2.8
Monitoring Vulcanisation of Rubber Using DSC ...................86
3.2.9
Characterisation of Melting and Crystallisation of Polymer ..88
3.2.10 Decomposition of Polymer ....................................................96 3.2.11 Oxidation Induction Time .....................................................99 3.2.12 Other Miscellaneous Applications of DSC ............................99 3.3
3.4
Thermogravimetric Analysis of Rubbery Materials .........................100 3.3.1
Thermal Degradation and Stability of Rubbers by TGA ......102
3.3.2
Compositional Characterisation of Rubbers by TGA ..........113
3.3.3
Study of Rubber Blend Compatibility Using TGA ...............117
3.3.4
Study of Rubber Degradation Kinetics Using TGA ..............118
3.3.5
Miscellaneous Applications of TGA ....................................124
Conclusion ......................................................................................124
References ................................................................................................124 4
Dynamic Mechanical Analysis (DMA) for Characterisation of Polymers, Polymer Blends and Composites ...............................................149 4.1
Introduction ....................................................................................149
iii
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
4.2
4.3
4.1.1
Mechanical Models Describing Viscoelasticity.....................149
4.1.2
Linear Viscoelastic Behaviour of Amorphous Polymers .......149
4.1.3
Zones of Viscoelastic Behaviour ..........................................152
4.1.4
Time-Temperature Superposition Principle ..........................154
Instrumentation ...............................................................................156 4.2.1
Working Principle of a Dynamic Mechanical Analyser ........156
4.2.2
Selecting a Clamp for a DMA Experiment...........................157
4.2.3
Running a DMA Experiment...............................................158
Interpretation of Dynamic Mechanical Spectra of Polymers: Case Studies ....................................................................................159 4.3.1
Glassy Polymers ..................................................................159
4.3.2
Crystalline Polymers ............................................................160
4.3.3
Elastomers ...........................................................................162
4.4
Dependence of Storage Modulus on Frequency and Strain ..............180
4.5
Various Other Applications .............................................................182
4.6
Conclusion ......................................................................................182
References ................................................................................................182 5
iv
Characterisation of Rubbers, Polymers and Their Composites Using TMA ..............................................................................................187 5.1
Introduction ....................................................................................187
5.2
Instrumentation ...............................................................................188
5.3
Applications ....................................................................................189 5.3.1
Determination of Tg.................................................................................................189
5.3.2
Effect of Plasticiser on Tg.....................................................................................195
5.3.3
Creep and Stress Relaxation ................................................196
5.3.4
Use of TMA - Parallel Plate Rheometer (PPR) for Curing of Thermoset Polymers ......................................197
5.3.5
Evaluation of Crosslink Density by TMA ............................199
5.3.6
TMA for Fibre Analysis.......................................................203
5.3.7
Why Fibre Properties are Important ....................................206
Contents
5.3.8 5.4
TMA for the Analysis of Composites ..................................208
Use of TMA in Industry ..................................................................210 5.4.1
TMA in the Electronics Industry .........................................210
5.4.2
TMA in the Automotive Industry ........................................212
5.5
Conclusion ......................................................................................213
5.6
Acknowledgments ...........................................................................214
References ................................................................................................214 6
Micro-thermal Analysis of Rubbery Materials ..........................................217 6.1
Introduction ....................................................................................217
6.2
Basic Principles of μTA ....................................................................218
6.3
Modes of Micro-thermal Analysis ...................................................219
6.4
Micro-thermal Analysis of Rubbery Material ..................................220
6.5
Morphological Investigation in Polymer Blends...............................221
6.6
Thin Films/Coating on the Substrate ...............................................226
6.7
Multilayer Material Characterisation ..............................................233 6.7.1
Thermal Properties of Rubbery Micro-Particles...................235
6.8
Thermal Characterisation of Micro-spheres ....................................238
6.9
Powder Particle Characterisation.....................................................239
6.10 Characterisation of Micropores .......................................................240 6.11 Characterisation of Nanostructured Material ..................................240 6.11.1 Micro-thermal Analysis Combined with Chemical Characterisation Techniques ................................................244 6.12 Future Outlook ...............................................................................248 References ................................................................................................249 7
Miscibility, Morphology and Crystallisation Behaviour of Rubber Based Polymer Blends .........................................................................................253 7.1
Introduction ....................................................................................253 v
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
7.2
Miscibility and Crystallisation of Biodegradable Polymer/Rubber Polymer Blends .....................................................254
7.3
Morphology and Crystallisation of Polyamide/Rubber Polymer Blends ................................................................................260
Acknowledgement ....................................................................................273 References ................................................................................................273 8
Thermal Characterisation of Polymer Nanocomposites ............................277 8.1
Introduction ....................................................................................277
8.2
Thermo-Gravimetric Analysis (TGA) ..............................................277
8.3
8.4
8.2.1
Introduction ........................................................................277
8.2.2
The Apparatus.....................................................................278
8.2.3
Methodology .......................................................................279
8.2.4
Typical TGA Curves ............................................................280
8.2.5
Applications of TGA in Nanocomposites Characterisation ..................................................................282
Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC).........................................290 8.3.1
Conventional DSC...............................................................290
8.3.2
The Apparatus.....................................................................291
8.3.3
Procedure ............................................................................293
8.3.4
Typical Data ........................................................................296
8.3.5
Temperature-Modulated DSC (TMDSC) .............................299
8.3.6
Applications of DSC for Thermal Characterisation of Polymer Nanocomposites ................................................301
8.3.7
Applications of TMDSC for Thermal Characterisation of Polymer Nanocomposites ................................................306
Other Characterisation Techniques..................................................309 8.4.1
Thermal Conductivity .........................................................309
8.4.2
Micro-Thermal Analysis (μTA)............................................311
References ................................................................................................313 9
vi
Thermal Analysis in Understanding Rubbery Matrix and Rubber-Filler Interactions .........................................................................321
Contents
9.1
Introduction ....................................................................................321
9.2
Thermal Analysis and Investigation of Heterogeneous Materials .....321
9.3
Structure-Properties Relationships in Particulate Filler/Rubbery Matrix Systems ........................................................322
9.4
Description of the Shape and Space Distribution of Filler Particles ..................................................................................325
9.5
Filler-to-Matrix and Filler-to-Filler Interactions as Investigated by Thermal Analysis ........................................................................325
9.6
9.5.1
Thermogravimetry...............................................................326
9.5.2 etry
Dielectric Thermal Analysis (DETA) and Thermoconductom326
9.5.3
Magnetic Thermal Analysis .................................................327
9.5.4
Dynamic Mechanical Analysis .............................................328
9.5.5
DTA and DSC .....................................................................329
Concluding Remarks .......................................................................329
References ................................................................................................329 10 Study of Crystallisation of Natural Rubber with Differential Scanning Calorimetry ..............................................................................................335 10.1 Introduction ....................................................................................335 10.2 Crystallisation .................................................................................335 10.2.1 Overall Crystallisation.........................................................335 10.2.2 Solution-grown Crystallisation ............................................338 10.3 Stem Length and Stem Length Distribution .....................................342 10.4 Effect of Fatty Acids ........................................................................344 10.5 Summary .........................................................................................351 Acknowledgements ...................................................................................351 References ................................................................................................351 11 Thermal Properties of Chemically Modified Elastomers ...........................353
vii
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
11.1 Introduction ....................................................................................353 11.2 Hydrogenation ................................................................................353 11.3 Epoxidation.....................................................................................356 11.4 Halogenation, Hydrohalogenation ..................................................357 11.5 Chemical Modification by Grafting .................................................360 11.6 Chemical Modification by Introducing Ionic Groups.......................367 11.7 Miscellaneous ..................................................................................372 Summary ..................................................................................................374 Acknowledgements ..................................................................................375 References ................................................................................................375 12 Thermal Analysis of Rubber Products ......................................................381 12.1 Introduction ....................................................................................381 12.2 Thermal Analysis of Rubber Based Vibration Control Devices .......383 12.2.1 Introduction ........................................................................383 12.2.2 Vibration Damping .............................................................383 12.2.3 Vibration Isolation ..............................................................384 12.2.4 Selection of Rubbers for Vibration Damping Application and the Role of Thermal Analysis ....................386 12.2.5 DMA for the Comparison of Different Rubber Based Shock Mounts ...........................................................390 12.2.6 Interpenetrating Polymer Networks (IPN) as Vibration Dampers ..............................................................391 12.2.7 Air Springs .........................................................................393 12.3 Thermal Analysis of Rubber Seals ...................................................395 12.3.1 Introduction ........................................................................395 12.3.2 Major Rubbers used for Seal Manufacturing .......................396 12.3.3 Role of Thermal Analysis in the Formula Reconstruction of Rubber Seals ...........................................396 12.3.4 Other Thermal Studies on Rubber Seals .............................402 12.3.5 Automotive Window Seal ....................................................403 viii
Contents
12.4 Thermal Analysis of Rubber-Based Cable Sheathing Compounds ....406 12.5 Thermal Analysis of Rubber Based Adhesives .................................409 12.5.1 Introduction ........................................................................409 12.5.2 Testing of Adhesives ...........................................................409 12.6 Thermal Analysis of Rubber Based Insulators .................................412 12.7 Thermal Analysis of Thermal Interface Materials (TIM) .................415 12.8 Thermal Analysis of Automobile Tyres ............................................417 12.8.1 Introduction ........................................................................417 12.8.2 Identification of Polymer in an Automobile Tyre Using Thermal Analysis ...............................................417 12.8.3 Isothermal TGA of Tyre Tread Compound ..........................419 12.8.4 Thermal Analysis for the Development of a Tyre Tread Compound ........................................................422 12.9 Concluding Remarks .......................................................................423 Acknowledgements ..................................................................................424 References ................................................................................................424 13 Thermal Analysis in Recycling of Waste Rubbery Materials .....................429 13.1 Introduction ....................................................................................429 13.2 Utilisation of Scrap Elastomers for Material Recovery ...................430 13.2.1 Characterisation of Recycled Rubber .................................430 13.2.2 Polymer Blends Containing Recycled Rubber ......................440 13.2.3 Recycled Rubber Modified Bitumen, Concrete and Composites ...................................................................451 13.3 Pyrolytic Utilisation of Waste Rubber .............................................453 13.3.1 Degradation and Recovery of Monomer, Gas and Carbon .........................................................................453 13.3.2 Energy Recovery Through Incineration ...............................455 13.4 Concluding Remarks .......................................................................456 Acknowledgement ....................................................................................456
ix
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
References ................................................................................................456 14 Thermal Analysis of Biological Molecules and Biomedical Polymers ........463 14.1 Introduction ....................................................................................463 4.2
Structure and Phase Behaviour of Cells, Membranes and Lipid Bilayers Using TA ...................................................................464 14.2.1 Lipid Blends and Alloys .......................................................468 14.2.2 Liposomes ...........................................................................470 4.2.3
Phospholipid-Additive Interactions .....................................472
14.3 Molecular Dynamics, Conformational Change and Swelling Behaviour of Biopolymers Using TA ..................................475 14.3.1 Level of Hydration on Thermal Characteristics of Proteins ...........................................................................478 14.3.2 State of Water and Molecular Dynamics in Biomaterials by DSC ...........................................................481 14.4 Collagen and Collagen Based Biomaterials ......................................488 14.4.1 Denaturation of Collagen from Different Origins ................491 14.4.2 Collagen Based Composite Biomaterial ...............................491 14.5 Thermal Stability of Silk, and Other Elastic Biomaterials ...............494 14.6 Thermal Characteristics of Biopolymers for Drug Delivery and Drug-Polymer Interaction ........................................................496 14.6.1 Protein-Protein, Protein-DNA and Protein-Ligand Interactions .........................................................................499 14.7 Thermal Characteristics of Synthetic Hydrogels and Scaffolds for Tissue Engineering .....................................................................500 14.8 Thermal Characteristics of Biomimetic Protein Based Hydrogels .....505 Acknowledgement ....................................................................................508 References ................................................................................................509 Abbreviations ..................................................................................................523 Index ...............................................................................................................531
x
Contributors
Contributors
Anil K. Bhowmick Rubber Technology Centre Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur – 721302 India Namita Roy Choudhury Ian Wark Research Institute University of South Australia Mawson Lakes Campus Mawson Lakes Boulevard Mawson Lakes South Australia 5095 Australia Prajna P. De Retired Professor Rubber Technology Centre Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur-721 302 India Naba K. Dutta Ian Wark Research Institute University of South Australia Mawson Lakes Campus Mawson Lakes Boulevard Mawson Lakes South Australia 5095 Australia
Yuko Ikeda Kyoto Institute of Technology Faculty of Engineering and Design Matsugasaki Kyoto 606-8585 Japan Takayuki Ikehara Department of Applied Chemistry Faculty of Engineering Kanagawa University 3-27-1, Rokkakubashi Kanagawa-ku Yokohama 221-8686 Japan Luminita L. Ionescu-Vasii Department of Chemical Engineering McGill University Montreal Canada H3A 2B2 Musa R. Kamal Department of Chemical Engineering McGill University Montreal Canada H3A 2B2
xi
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials Seiichi Kawahara Department of Chemistry Faculty of Engineering Nagaoka University of Technology Nagaoka Niigata 940-2188 Japan Shinzo Kohjiya Kyoto University Institute for Chemical Research Uji Kyoto 611-0011 Japan Ivan Krakovsky Charles University Faculty of Mathematics and Physics Department of Polymer Physics V Holesovickach 2 180 00 Prague 8 Czech Republic Suman Mitra Rubber Technology Centre Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur – 721302 India Amit K. Naskar Department of Chemical Engineering and Center for Advanced Engineering Fibers and Films Clemson University Clemson SC 29634 USA Kinsuk Naskar Rubber Technology Centre Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur – 721302 India xii
Toshio Nishi Department of Organic and Polymeric Materials Graduate School of Science and Engineering Tokyo Institute of Technology 2-12-1 Ohokayama Meguro-ku Tokyo 152-8552 Japan Zhaobin Qiu College of Materials Science and Engineering Beijing University of Chemical Technology Beijing 100029 China R.S. Rajeev Institute of Space Technology and Aeronautics Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency 6-13-1 Osawa Mitaka-shi Tokyo-181 0015 Japan Kinnari Shelat Ian Wark Research Institute University of South Australia Mawson Lakes Campus Mawson Lakes Boulevard Mawson Lakes South Australia 5095 Australia Nikhil K. Singha Rubber Technology Centre Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur – 721 302 India
Contributors N.D. Tran Ian Wark Research Institute University of South Australia Mawson Lakes Campus Mawson Lakes Boulevard Mawson Lakes South Australia 5095 Australia
xiii
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
xiv
Introduction
1
Introduction Prajna P. De, Namita Roy Choudhury and Naba K. Dutta
Since the early days of smelting of copper and iron, application of heat to manipulate the properties was known to man. Development of thermometer in eighteenth century gave an impetus to thermal studies of materials. In 1877, Hannay [1] was the first to find out that an examination of the rate at which the volatile constituent of a compound is driven off at a constant temperature may provide valuable information as to the constitution of the body and found out a relation between the vapour tension of a decomposing body and its chemical constitution. Ramsay [2] suggested that the composition and constitution of many of the amorphous hydrates such as aluminum oxide and iron oxide hydrate whose compositions are somewhat indefinite might be accurately determined by this method. In 1886 Le Chatelier [3, 4] obtained heating curves for various minerals in which endothermic (absorption of heat) and exothermic (evolution of heat) effects were distinguished. Gradually the science of thermometry for measurement of temperature of materials and their change of state with temperature changes was developed. In 1891 Roberts-Austen [5] introduced a differential thermocouple, which measured the differences in voltage between thermocouples placed in experimental sample and a control (inert sample). Principles of thermal analysis are based on thermometry [6] and thermodynamics [7]. Thermometry consists of plain measurement of temperature and is used in the study of phase transition or in recording temperatures as a function of time in the form of heating and cooling curves. But in thermodynamics, kinetic parameters of a reaction can be studied [8-11] and the most popularly used method is Arrhenius equation [12], correlating the rate of the reaction and activation energy. Similar kinetic equation in differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) has been used by Borchardt and Daniels [13] for thermoset cure, polymerisation process and chemical decomposition with single heating rate method. The ASTM E698 method is the only means to analyze the reactions with irregular baselines [14] and reactions with multiple exotherms [15] as well as a precursor to isothermal studies [16, 17]. As in the case of DSC and differential thermal analysis (DTA), kinetic equations have also been used in thermogravimetry and the most popular method is the single heating rate method by Freeman and Carrol [18, 19] for determining the order of the reaction and activation energy. Anderson [20] used the multiple heating rates and the kinetic parameters such as order of reaction and activation energy can be deduced from the different thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) curves. Reich [21, 22], 1
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials Doyale [23, 24] and Ozawa [25] also introduced several methods to follow the kinetic parameters for decomposition reactions. Modern development of thermal analysis started in 1940s by the use of recorders, sample holders, weighing balance, thermocouples and improved instrumental techniques. Description of DTA, TGA and dilatometry has been reported by Smothers and Chiang [26], Garn [27], Wendlandt [28] and Mackenzie [29]. Other methods of thermal analysis include DSC, derivative thermogravimetrc analysis (DTG), dynamic mechanical thermal analysis (DMTA) [30, 31], thermomechanical analysis (TMA) [32]. Combination of two or more of these methods along with non-thermal techniques such as spectroscopy [33, 34] and microscopy form the basis of versatile tools for studying macromolecules, nano particles [35, 36], ceramics [37], medicines and biopolymers [38, 39]. Although there has been a large number of publications on thermal analyses, it is only in 1970 that a concerted effort was made by International Confederation of Thermal Analysis (ICTA) to standardise the nomenclature and experimental procedures to allow direct interlaboratory comparison of data. In 1970 ICTA merged with North American Thermal Analysis Society. Simultaneously publication of two journals namely Journal of Thermal Analysis (Wiley) and Thermochimica Acta (Elsevier) were started in 1969-1970. Though there have been dozens of books published on thermal analyses, books on thermal analysis of polymers, in particular books on thermal analysis on rubbers and rubbery materials have been very few. Rubber is different from other polymeric materials in the sense that it needs to be crosslinked or vulcanised and mixed with several additives like fillers to achieve its shape and strength. Mauer [40] was the first to publish a review on application of thermal analysis techniques in the study of the elastomer system and subsequently contributed a book chapter in ‘Thermal Characterisation of Polymeric Materials’ [30]. A few researchers have contributed chapters on thermal analysis of rubber in books [30, 31]. Several scientists have made contribution in this field and the pioneering work of Sircar and Lamond [41-47] and Brazier and Nickel [48-51] has opened new vistas of research. In view of the surge of research activities in this field, we felt the need of compilation of research work on thermal analysis of rubbers and rubbery materials in the form of a book. The present volume is the outcome of this thinking. The book consists of fourteen chapters, including the Introduction. The second chapter entitled ‘Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials’ by Prajna P. De deals with the instrumentation components in the techniques of thermal analysis used for characterisation of rubbers, rubbery materials, and the different constituents in their products. The techniques discussed are DTA, DSC, thermogravimetry (TG), DTG, evolved gas analysis, TMA, dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA), thermally stimulated current spectroscopy, 2
Introduction relaxation map analysis, differential photo calorimetry and dielectric thermal analysis (DETA). Combined methods of thermal analysis provide complete analyses of the constituents of rubber products. The techniques include coupled thermogravimetryinfrared spectroscopy, coupled thermogravimetry-mass spectrometry (MS), coupled thermogravimetry-gas chromatography (TG-GC), coupled TG-GC-infrared (IR), coupled TG-GC-MS. Amit K. Naskar and Prajna P. De contributed the third chapter dealing with the ‘applications of DSC and TGA for the characterisation of rubbers and rubbery materials’. DSC finds applications in locating phase transitions (such as glass-rubber transition, crystalline melting), chemical reactions (such as crosslinking, oxidation and degradation) and micro and macro morphological changes. Glass-rubber transition temperature can be used to study composition and morphology of block copolymers, rubber blends, interpenetrating polymer networks, filled polymers and crosslinking. DSC scans are useful in characterising melting of crystalline polymers and crystallisation of molten polymers. DSC scans along with TG thermograms provide useful information on the pyrolytic decomposition and oxidative degradation of polymers at elevated temperatures. Compositional characterisation of rubber products can be made by TGA, when performed under nitrogen and air environments. TGA can be used to study blend compatibility and rubber degradation kinetics. Combination of other analytical tools such as Fourier transform infrared (FT-IR), gas chromatography and mass spectrometry is extensively used for the analysis of evolved gases in TGA. Recent developments in instrumentation and of software based data analysis made these tools easy and less time consuming for faster qualitative and quantitative evaluation of the components in rubber products. The fourth chapter entitled ‘Dynamic Mechanical Analysis (DMA) for characterisation of polymers, polymer blends and composites’ by Suman Mitra, Kinsuk Naskar and Anil K. Bhowmick deals with theoretical considerations on viscoelasticity of polymeric materials, instrumentation, and application areas. The authors discuss case studies on interpretation of dynamic mechanical spectra of glassy polymers, crystalline polymers, and elastomers. DMA provides useful information on modified rubbers, crosslinking of rubbers, influence of fillers on rubber properties, composition and compatibility of rubber blends, block copolymers and rubber-based nano-composites. Dependence of dynamic properties on frequency and strain is useful in understanding the processing characteristics, tyre performance, vibration isolation and fatigue behaviour. R.S. Rajeev and P.P. De contributed the fifth chapter on ‘Characterisation of rubbers, polymers and their composites using TMA’. TMA conducted with zero load is known as thermodialometric analysis (TDA). An interchangeable sample probe permits the determination of penetration, expansion, tension and dilatometry of samples. The dilatometer mode is used to measure the coefficient of thermal expansion of polymers. TMA of elastomers via a penetrometer probe produces thermograms that closely resemble the master curves obtained by conventional time-temperature superposition 3
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials of modulus data. The most commonly used probe is expansion probe. TMA is believed to be more sensitive than DSC for the measurement of glass transition temperature (Tg) of crosslinked materials, filled materials and composites. Thermally stimulated creep, thermally stimulated recovery and thermally simulated stress relaxation are different ways of performing thermo-mechanical experiments. TMA appears to have high potential in polymer rheology, in which it uses its accessory parallel plate rheometer for measuring the ‘gel time.’ TMA can be used to measure the crosslink density. TMA is widely used in the analysis of fibres. It measures coefficient of thermal expansion, thermal shrinkage, shrinkage force, Tg and Tm and kinetics of shrinkage and shrinkage force phenomena. The sixth chapter of the book is entitled, ‘Micro-Thermal Analysis of Rubbery Materials’ contributed by Kinnari Shelat, Namita Roy Choudhury and Naba K. Dutta. Integration of thermal analysis and microscopic imaging at the micron level resulted in micro-thermal analysis (μTA). The authors discuss the basic principles of μTA and its modes. Imaging of the sample and obtaining thermal conductivity and diffusivity images provide visualisation of sample morphology and spatial arrangement in complex systems. Characterisation of scanned surface involves different forms of localised thermal analysis. This feature provides the facility to perform localised thermo-mechanical analysis, localised dynamic mechanical analysis and localised rheometry experiments. Furthermore, the mode can be used in combination with other techniques such as FT-IR and GC-MS. The authors review the application of μTA in morphological investigation of polymer blends, thin films or coatings for specialised applications such as paints, protective layers, electronic devices and automotive products. μTA can be used to estimate the thickness and homogeneity of the coated film. ‘Miscibility, morphology and crystallisation behaviour of rubber based polymer blends’ by Z. Qui, T. Ikehara and T. Nishi is the subject matter of seventh chapter. In the first section the authors review the miscibility and crystallisation behaviour of polymer blends based on biodegradable polymers and rubber. The second section deals with the morphology and crystallisation behaviour of thermoplastic elastomers (TPE) based on polyamide (PA). While the miscibility studies in the first section are based on changes in Tg and melting temperature (Tm), the spherulite morphology and growth were studied by using polarising optical microscope. Role of compatibilisers on the morphology of thermoplastic vulcanisates based on dynamically vulcanised ethylene-propylene diene terpolymer (EPDM)/PA blends have been studied by measuring crystallisation kinetics and atomic force microscopy images in the second section. An immiscible or partially miscible blend does not typically show depression in melting point, in contrary to what is observed in the case of a miscible blend wherein there occurs depression in melting point with increasing content of the amorphous phase. The melting point is affected not only by thermodynamic factors, but also by the morphological factors such as the crystalline lamellar thickness.
4
Introduction Chapter 8 entitled ‘Thermal characterisation of polymer nano-composites’ is a contribution made by Musa R. Kamal and L.L. Ionescu-Vasii. In the beginning the authors have dealt with principles, instrumentation and methodology of TGA and DSC. They then discussed thermal stability of nano-fillers and nano-filler –polymer composites by using TGA. Final section deals with applications of DSC and temperature modulated DSC (TMDSC) for thermal characterisation of polymer nano-composites. For example, DSC can be used to study the isothermal and non-isothermal crystallisation kinetics providing insight into the nucleating agents for crystallisation, while the heat capacity and the glass transition behaviour of polymer nano-composites can be determined by using TMDSC. The authors conclude by providing a brief description of new thermal characterisation techniques and their application to nano-composites such as thermal conductivity and micro-thermal analysis. Ivan Krakovsky, Yuko Ikeda and Shinzo Kohjiya deal with ‘Thermal analysis in understanding rubbery matrix and rubber-filler interactions’ in Chapter 9. The authors begin their chapter with classification of the methods of thermal analysis on the basis of thermodynamics. Next the authors review the structure-property relationships in particulate filler/rubbery matrix systems and description of the shape and space distribution of filler particles. Finally, the authors describe applications of the following thermal analysis techniques to understand filler-to-matrix and filler-to-filler interactions: TG, DETA and thermo-conductometry, magnetic thermal analysis, DMA, DTA and DSC. For example, DSC is used mainly for the investigation of the presence of filler on the mobility of polymer chains, which is reflected in the change of Tg of the elastomer. The change is most pronounced in the case of nano-fillers. Filler reinforcement of rubber can be understood from DMA studies at small deformations and at large strains. Dependence of magnetic susceptibility on temperature depends strongly on geometrical form of carbon blacks. Curie’s paramagnetism originating from localised spins at structural defects of carbon black crystalline structure can be followed by magnetic thermal analyses. Chapter 10 entitled ‘Study of crystallisation of natural rubber with differential scanning calorimetry’ is contributed by Seiichi Kawahara. The overall rate of crystallisation of natural rubber (NR) may be estimated from the half-life of the crystallisation as an inflection point determined in a plot of degree of crystallinity versus crystallisation time. The fatty acids and branching points play important roles in the crystallisation. Removing free fatty acids that are present as a mixture may suppress the crystallisation, whereas it is recovered to the original level by mixing with stearic acid 1 wt%. The saturated fatty acids may play a role of the nucleating agent for crystallisation of NR. Chapter 11 contributed by Nikhil K. Singha deals with ‘Thermal properties of chemically modified elastomers’. Polymers can be chemically modified to induce changes in important properties such as weatherability, oxidation resistance, adhesion properties, biodegradability, fire resistance, thermal resistance, polarity and reactivity towards specific groups or ions and so on. Modifications include hydrogenation, epoxidation, halogenation, hydrohalogenation, and the thermal techniques include DSC, TGA and 5
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials DMTA. Chemical modification by the grafting of maleic anhydride (MA) is a very useful way to induce polarity in conventional elastomers. Mechanism of maleation can be understood from the changes in Tg. For example, MA-grafting in the case of NR causes an in increase in Tg due to possible interchain interaction between the polar groups. However, there is a decrease in Tg in the case of MA-grafted EPDM due to maleation occurring in the pendant ethylidene norbornene site, thereby increasing the bulkiness of the pendant group and subsequent plasticisation in intermolecular chains. Changes in thermal stability can be followed by TG. Elastomers can also be modified by introducing ionic groups in the form of sulfonate, phosphonate and carboxylate groups. Ionomers are interesting polymeric materials which have a small amount (less than 10%) of ionic groups. The presence of a low amount of ionic groups has a dramatic effect on the physical and mechanical properties of polymers. The elastomeric ionomers can be identified by DMTA. ‘Thermal analysis of rubber products’ by R.S. Rajev and P.P. De is the subject matter of Chapter 12. In the case of product analyses or reverse engineering with the aim for formula reconstruction, single technique will not serve the purpose. Combination of thermal techniques, jointly with spectroscopic, chemical and microscopic techniques is required for qualitative and quantitative analyses of the components of the product. The authors have chosen representative rubber products such as rubber based vibration control devices, rubber seals, rubber-based cable sheathing compounds, rubber-based adhesives, rocket motor insulator, thermal interface materials, and automobile tyres. The authors have provided lists of rubbers and other additives normally used in such applications. Thermal analyses techniques used include DSC, TG, DTG and DMTA in combination with other methods of analyses. In Chapter 13, Amit Naskar deals with ‘Thermal analysis in recycling of waste rubbery materials’. Disposal of solid wastes is a serious challenge to the society and scrap polymeric materials make a major contribution to the solid wastes. Recycling of waste rubbery materials is thus an important area of research from environmental and resource constraints point of view. The authors discuss thermal techniques for characterising waste rubbers and for evaluation of blends and composites based on recycled or waste rubber. DSC, TG and DTG in combination with DMTA and spectroscopic techniques are useful in characterising the rubbers and the additives present in the waste. Chemical modification of ground waste rubber has been studied with a view to enhance its compatibility with other polymers. In the case of TPE based on rubber-plastic blends, considerable proportion of the rubber phase can be replaced by waste finely ground rubber with little deterioration in final properties. The blend morphology can be studied by measuring the Tg, tan and microscopic studies. DMTA is also useful in evaluating recycled rubber modified bitumen, concrete and other composites. A pyrolytic TG study of waste rubber helps in estimating the operating conditions for converting waste rubbery materials into activated carbon.
6
Introduction ‘Thermal analysis of biological molecules and biomedical polymers’ by N.D. Tran, N.K. Dutta, N. Roy Choudhury forms the contents of the last chapter. DSC and isothermal titration calorimetry are emerging as the important tools in the functional analysis of proteins, lipids and nucleic acid molecules, ligand binding and fundamental understanding of DNA-drug, phospholipid-ligand and protein-protein interactions. Thermal behaviour of biopolymers and the effect of water on the molecular dynamics can be studied by DSC. It is emphasised that most hydrated biopolymers have glass transitions is affected due to the freezing of the cooperative motions of biopolymers and bound waters. The authors have discussed important roles played by thermal techniques in elucidating the morphological structure of collagen, collagen-based biomaterials, bio-artificial polymeric materials and biopolymers for drug delivery.
References 1.
J.B. Hannay, Journal of the Chemical Society, 1877, 32, 399.
2.
W.M. Ramsay, Journal of the Chemical Society, 1877, 32, 395.
3.
H. Le Chatelier, Comptes Rendus, 1886, 102, 1243.
4.
H. Le Chatelier, Comptes Rendus, 1887, 104, 1517.
5.
N.C. Roberts-Austen, Proceedings of Royal Society, 1891, 49, 347.
6.
W.E. Knowles Middleton, A History of the Thermometer and its use in Metrology, John Hopkins Press, Baltimore, MD, USA, 1966.
7.
W.J. Moore, Physical Chemistry, 4th Edition, Prentice-Hall Englewood Cliffs, NJ, USA, 1972.
8.
K.E.J. Barrett, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1967, 11, 1617.
9.
R.N. Rogers and E.D. Morris, Jr., Analytical Chemistry, 1966, 38, 412.
10. S. Arrhenius, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1927, 49, 3033. 11. G.O. Piloyan, I.D. Ryabchikov and O.S. Novikova, Nature, 1966, 212, 1229. 12. S. Glasstone, Textbook of Physical Chemistry, 2nd Edition, Macmillan, London, UK, 1962, p.1098. 13. H.J. Borchardt and F.J. Daniels, Journal of American Chemical Society, 1956, 79, 41.
7
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials 14. N.S. Schneider, J.F. Sprouse, G.L. Hagnauer and J.K. Gillham, Polymer Engineering and Science,1979, 19, 304. 15. T.A.M.M. Mass, Polymer Engineering and Science, 1978, 18, 29. 16. R.B. Prime in Thermal Characterisation of Polymeric Materials, Ed., E.A. Turi, Academic Press, New York, NY, USA, 1981, Volume 1, Chapter 5. 17. A.A. Duswalz, Thermochimica Acta, 1974, 8, 57. 18. E.S. Freeman and B. Carroll, Journal of Physical Chemistry, 1958, 62, 394. 19. E.S. Freeman and D.A. Anderson, Journal of Polymer Science, 1961, 54, 253. 20. H.C. Anderson, Journal of Polymer Science: Part B, 1964, 2, 115. 21. L. Reich, H.T. Lee, D.W. Levi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1965, 9, 351. 22. L. Reich, Journal of Polymer Science: Part B, 1964, 2, 621. 23. C.D. Doyle, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1961, 5, 285. 24. C.D. Doyle, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1962, 6, 639. 25. T.J. Ozawa, Journal of Thermal Analysis, 1970, 2, 301. 26. W.J. Smothers and M.S. Yao Chiang, Handbook of Differential Thermal Analysis, Chemical Publishing Co., New York, NY, USA, 1966. 27. P.D. Garn, Thermoanalytical Methods of Investigation, Academic Press, New York, NY, USA, 1965. 28. Thermal Analysis, Eds., W.W. Wendlandt and L.W. Collins, Dowden Hutchinson and Ross Publishing Company, Stroudsburg, PA, USA, 1976. 29. Differential Thermal Analysis, Volumes 1 and 2, Ed., R.C. Mackenzie, Academic Press, London, UK, 1970. 30. J.J. Maurer in Thermal Characterisation of Polymeric Materials, Ed., E.A. Turi, Academic Press, New York, NY, USA, 1981, Volume 1, Chapter 6. 31. A.K. Sircar in Thermal Characterisation of Polymeric Materials, Ed., E.A. Turi, Academic Press, New York, NY, USA, 1997, Volume 2, Chapter 5. 32. J.L. Leblanc, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1977, 21, 2419. 8
Introduction 33. D.E. Smith, Thermochimica Acta, 1976, 14, 370. 34. G.J. Mol, Thermochimica Acta, 1974, 10, 259. 35. R. Sengupta, S. Sabharwal, A.K. Bhowmick and T.K. Chaki, Polymer Degradation and Stability, 2006, 91, 131. 36. S.K. Srivastava, M. Pramanik and H. Acharya, Journal of Polymer Science: Part B - Polymer Physics, 2006, 44, 471. 37. A.C. Momin, E.B. Mirza and M.D. Mathews, Thermochimica Acta, 1991, 180, 191. 38. V. Samouillan, C. Ande, J. Dandurand and C. Lacccabanne, Biomacromolecules, 2004, 5, 958. 39. N.A. Grunina, T.V.Belopolskaya and G.I. Tsereteli in Statistical Physics of Ageing Phenomena and the Glass Transition, Eds., M. Henkel, M. Pleimling and R. Sanctuary, Journal of Physics: Conference Series, Volume 40, 2006, p.105. 40. J.J. Mauer, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1969, 42, 110. 41. A.K. Sircar and T.G. Lamond, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1972, 45, 329. 42. A.K. Sircar and T.G. Lammond, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1973, 46, 178. 43. A.K. Sircar and T.G. Lammond, Thermochimica Acta, 1973, 7, 287. 44. A.K. Sircar and T.G. Lammond, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1975, 48, 301. 45. A.K. Sircar and T.G. Lammond, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1975, 48, 631, 640, 653. 46. A.K. Sircar and T.G. Lammond, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1973, 17, 2549. 47. A.K. Sircar and T.G. Lammond, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1978, 51, 647. 48. D.W. Brazier and G.H. Nickel, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1975, 48, 26. 49. D.W. Brazier and G.H. Nickel, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1975, 48, 661. 9
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials 50. D.W. Brazier and G.H. Nickel, Thermochimica Acta, 1978, 26, 399. 51. D.W. Brazier, G.H. Nickel and Z. Szentgyorgyi, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1980, 53, 160.
10
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
2
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials Prajna Paramita De
2.1 Introduction A single property by which a material can be indentified is its thermal behaviour. Characterisation of materials by thermal analysis was introduced by Le Chatelier [1] in 1886, who used differential thermal analysis (DTA) for the first time to study the thermal characteristics of clay materials. The method consisted of direct determination of the rate of change in temperature of the sample during regular heating. The reactions followed in this way gave a series of plateaux on temperature versus time plots, but their determination was rather inaccurate. In 1891 Roberts-Austen [2] introduced a differential thermocouple which measured the difference in voltage between thermocouples placed in the sample and in an inert standard. After this, continuous developments were made, which included high pressure DTA and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), thermogravimetry (TG), derivative thermogravimetry (DTG) and simultaneous thermal analysis like TG-DTA, TG-DTG-DTA. A detailed account of the developments of thermal analysis can be found in Smothers and Chiang [3], Garn [4], Wendlandt [5] and Blazek [6]. The term ‘thermal analysis’ now applies to a series of techniques, all of which subject a sample to a programmed temperature treatment, and use a variety of transducers to sense property changes continuously and automatically. Thermoanalytical techniques are presented in Figure 2.1, in which thermal changes related to mass, temperature, energy, dimension and mechanical properties of materials are exhibited as TG, DTG, evolved gas analysis (EGA), evolved gas detection (EGD), (DTA), (DSC), thermo dilatometry (TD), thermo mechanical analysis (TMA), dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA). There are also many other thermoanalytical techniques related to acoustic, optical, electrical and magnetic properties of the materials as shown in Figure 2.1. In general, thermal analysis is important for the study of thermal decomposition, solid state reaction, determination of moisture and volatile matter, pyrolysis of coal, petroleum, wood, decomposition of explosive materials, adsorption, desorption, rate of evaporation and sublimation but for polymers and rubber, thermal analysis is used for determination 11
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 2.1 Classification of thermoanalytical techniques
of glass transition temperature (Tg), melting of polymers, crystalline transition, thermal stability, assessment of life of finished products, development of a new compound, miscibility of polymers and rubbers, shrinkage, rigidity and so on. Popular techniques of thermal analysis of rubbers and polymers, are given in Table 2.1. The details of thermal analysis instruments, principles, and techniques will be discussed next.
2.2 Differential Thermal Analysis (DTA) It is a technique in which the difference of temperature ( T) between a substance and a reference material ( - Al2O3) against either time (t) or temperature (T) is recorded as the two specimens are subjected to an identical temperature regime in an environment 12
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Table 2.1 Common techniques of thermal analysis used for characterisation of polymers and rubbers 1 2
3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10 11
DTA DSC: a. Heat flux DSC b. Power compensated DSC c. Modulated DSC (MDSC) or temperature modulated DSC (TMDSC) a. Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) or TG b. DTG a. EGA b. EGD TMA: a. Parallel plate rheometry (PPR) b. Fibre tension spectrometry. c. Stress relaxation spectrometry. d. TD or thermo dilatometric analysis (TDA) DMA Torsional braid analysis (TBA) Thermally stimulated depolarisation current (TSDC) Relaxation map analysis (RMA) Differential photo calorimetry (DPC) Dielectric thermal analysis (DETA) or dielectric analysis (DEA)
heated or cooled at a controlled rate. In a DTA curve the temperature difference ( T) is usually plotted on the ordinate and T or t on the abcissa increasing from left to right. In a DTA curve an endothermic peak is a peak where the temperature of the sample falls below that of reference material i.e., T is negative. An exothermic peak is a peak, where the temperature of the sample rises above that of reference material, i.e., T is positive. In general, in an endothermic reaction heat is absorbed and in exothermic reaction heat is evolved. With respect to the fixed position of reference and sample, the endothermic peak is always downwards, while the exothermic peak is upwards in T versus T(t) plots. Generally, the phase transition like melting, solvent evaporation, dehydration and decomposition reactions are endothermic in nature, whereas crystallisation, oxidation, adsorption and certain solid state reactions are exothermic.
2.2.1 DTA Instrument A typical DTA apparatus [7] is illustrated schematically in Figure 2.2. The apparatus consists of: 13
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials a. sample holders, b. furnace and furnace temperature programmers, c. differential temperature detection system i.e., a temperature sensor, d. a low level dc voltage amplifier, e. recorder, and f.
atmosphere control.
There are numerous DTA systems described in literature, many of which use novel designs of sample holders, furnace, heating device, differential temperature (Ts-Tr) detectors such as thermocouples, platinum resistance thermometers (PRT) and thermopiles and recorders. Details of each part are given in the next sections:
Figure 2.2 Schematic diagram of a typical DTA apparatus [8]
2.2.1(a) Sample Holders Sample holders are of various shapes, sizes, depending on the nature of the reaction to be studied. Hence, common containers have been constructed from aluminium (crimples used by TA Instruments), stainless steel, nickel, platinum or platinum alloys, 14
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials fused quartz, boron nitride and graphite according to the temperature requirement for the experiment. Wendlandt and co-workers [8] described these sample containers in ‘Thermal Characterisation of Polymeric Materials’.
2.2.1(b) Furnace and Furnace Temperature Programmers A wide variety of DTA/DSC furnaces are available each designed for a specific temperature range from –150 to 2800 ºC. Most of the furnaces have resistance heater elements, but some use infra red heating for extremely rapid heating and cooling rates. Maximum temperature limits for the various resistance heater elements for the furnaces are shown in Table 2.2. Requirements for a good DTA/DSC furnace include symmetry in heating and the ability of the heater elements to heat uniformly. The furnace temperature distribution must be uniform in the area of the sample container for good results. For operation at low temperature, the furnace may be surrounded by a Dewar flask and precooled with liquid nitrogen. Most temperature programmers do not function efficiently unless a thermal reservoir at least 30 ºC below the temperature is available. The type of temperature controller varies from the simple variable voltage transformer, coupled to a synchronous motor to the more sophisticated feedback, proportional type controller. On the other hand, controllers of the on-off type cannot be used, because the fluctuating power outputs give rise to severe thermal gradients in the furnace and sample holder system. Most commercially available thermal analysis equipment, however, comes
Table 2.2 Approximate maximum temperature limits for furnace resistance elements Serial Element Number 1 Nichrome 2 Chromel A 3 Kanthal 4 Platinum 5 Platinum - 10% rhodium 6 Kanthal Super 7 Rhodium 8 Molybdenum 9 Tungsten Ox = Oxidising Nox = Non oxidising (inert, vacuum)
Approximate Temperature, °C 1000 1100 1350 1400 1500 1600 1800 2200 2800
Required Atmosphere Ox Ox Ox Nox, Ox Nox, Ox Ox Nox, Ox Nox, H2 Nox, H2
15
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials with a specially matched and prepackaged controller as for example, the Model QC25 controller, provided by the Omnitherm corporation, TECO Model TP-2000 Thermocouple Temperature programmer, or TA Instruments furnace temperature programmer.
2.2.1(c) Differential Temperature Detection System The choice of the temperature detection device depends on the nature of the instrument, maximum temperature desired, chemical reactivity of the sample. The most common means of differential temperature detection is with thermocouples, thermistors thermopiles, or platinum-resistance thermometers. Commonly used thermocouples are given in Table 2.3.
2.2.1(d) Low Level DC Voltage Amplifier The output voltage from a differential thermocouple is in the order of 0.1-100/V, depending on the type of thermocouples used (Table 2.3) and the temperature difference between them. Hence, unless a very sensitive recording system is used (<100/V), the Ts-Tr signal must be amplified. The amplifiers must have low noise, low drift and high stability to be used in DTA instrument. The Spectrum Scientific Company manufactures a line of active electronic filters that provide a wide range of adjustable time constants and amplification.
2.2.1(e) Recorder Generally, three types of analog recorders are used in modern thermal analysis instruments: the time-base potentiometric strip chart and multipoint recorders and the temperature-based X-Y or X-Y1Y2 function plotters. One advantage of time-base
Table 2.3 Thermocouples commonly used for DTA, DSC, TGA Serial Name of Thermocouple Number 1 Copper – Constantan 2 Iron – Constantan 3 Chromel – Constantan 4 Chromel – Alumel 5 Platinum – Platinum - 10% rhodium 6 Tungsten – Tungsten - 26% rhenium 7 Chromel – Constantan differential thermocouple
16
Approximate Maximum Temperature, oC 250 450 1000 1350 1600 2400 -150 to 600
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials strip chart recorders is that the furnace heating rate can be observed and checked for variation. However, modern thermal analysis instruments are computer-controlled and capable of collecting data digitally and simultaneously comparing them with results from previous experiments.
2.2.1(f) Atmosphere Control In DTA and DSC instruments, during experimental work, control of the atmosphere is important, an inert gas like nitrogen, argon, helium is passed through the instrument to drive the effluent gases generated during heating out. The purging of gases takes place with extremes of pressure from 1.33 x 10-4 Pa to hundreds of pascals. Depending on the nature of the experiment, air or oxygen is also purged. Generally, the flow rate is maintained at 20-30 ml/min, so that the efficiency of temperature programming is not affected.
2.3 Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) Watson and co-workers [9] developed a DSC instrument, in which H the difference of heat flow is plotted against temperature, T. Unlike DTA, the apparatus maintains a sample temperature equal to a reference substance by supplying heat to the sample or reference material. Basically three types of DSC instruments are used, the heat-flux DSC (e.g., TA Instruments Q2000, Q200, Q20 DSC, Mettler Toledo DSC 1, Mettler DSC 30), power compensated DSC (e.g., Perkin Elmer DSC, Setaram 101 DSC and temperature modulated DSC (TMDSC) or modulated DSC of TA Instruments (MDSC).
2.3.1 Heat-flux DSC Figure 2.3 shows the schematic diagram of Dupont DSC cell [10], which uses a constantan disk as its primary means of heat transfer to the sample as well as reference positions. The sample and reference are placed in pans that sit on raised platforms on the constantan disk. The constantan disk serves as the major path of heat transfer to and from the sample and also as one-half of the measuring thermocouple. The differential heat flow to the sample and reference is monitored by a chromel-constantan differential thermocouple formed by the function of the constantan disk and a chromal wafer that covers the underside of each platform. The chromel and alumel wires are connected to the underside of the chromel wafers and the resultant chromel-alumel thermocouple is used to monitor the sample temperature directly. Constant calorimetric sensitivity is maintained throughout the usable range of cells via electronic linearisation of the cell calibration co-efficient. This system is usable in the temperature range, -150 to 600 °C in an inert atmosphere. 17
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 2.3 Disk type thermocouple used for Heatflux DSC [10]
2.3.2 Power Compensated DSC The Perkin-Elmer DSC system is different from Heatflux DSC and was introduced by Watson and co-workers [9]. A schematic diagram [7] of power compensated DSC is presented in Figure 2.4. The Pyris 1 DSC is one such differential scanning calorimeter. It maintains sample temperature equal to the reference compound by supplying heat to the sample or reference material. The amount of heat required to maintain the isothermal condition is recorded as a function of time or temperature. The instrument contains two control loops, one for the average- temperature control and the other for differential-temperature control. In the former, a programmer provides an electrical output signal that is proportional to the desired temperature of the sample and reference holders. The programmer signal that reaches the average-temperature amplifier is compared with signals received from platinum resistance thermometers permanently embedded in the sample and reference holders and then the necessary power supplied equally to both heaters. Actually, when an exothermic (heat yielded) or endothermic (heat absorbed) change occurs in the sample, power or energy is applied or removed from one or both the calorimeters to compensate for the energy change occurring in the sample. The power compensated DSC system is maintained in a ‘thermal null’ state at all times. The amount of power required to maintain the system in an equilibrium condition is directly proportional to the energy changes occurring in the sample. The power compensated DSC therefore provides a true measure of the calorimetric properties of the sample since the fundamental measurement with the power compensated DSC is energy flow. 18
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 2.4 Schematic diagram for power compensated Perkin-Elmer DSC [7]
In contrast, the more common heat-flux DSC instruments have the sample and reference in a single furnace. Thermocouples measure the temperature differential (not energy differential) between the sample and reference platforms. With the heat-flux DSC units, the temperature differential is converted to energy flow via a mathematical equation and is a more indirect approach as compared to the pure energy flow measurements obtained via the Pyris1 power compensated DSC. Besides measuring the enthalpy, the DSC unit is useful to measure the specific heat, particularly with the software package available from the manufacturers. One major advantage of the power compensated design over the heat-flux DSC cell is that the masses of the individual furnaces of the power compensated system are much lower than that of the heat-flux DSC. The faster response time of the power compensated DSC also provides a much higher degree of resolution compared to heat-flux DSC this may be due to the use of a PRT, used for the measurement of temperature. Like the DTA apparatus, the DSC instruments also consist of specimen holder, furnace having 19
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials low thermal inertia, temperature programmer-controller system for atmosphere control and an X-Y multipen recorder. Details of the previously mentioned accessories have already been described.
2.3.3 Temperature Modulated DSC (TMDSC) TMDSC was recently introduced by some TA instrument manufacturers for their temperature modulated differential scanning calorimeter [11]. In a heat-flux DSC, the difference in heat flow between a sample and inert reference material is measured as a function of time, as both the sample and reference are subjected to a controlled temperature profile. The temperature profile is generally linear (heating or cooling) varying in the range from 0 K/min (isothermal) to 60 K/min. Thus the programmed sample temperature T(t) is given by: T(t) = To + t
(2.1)
Where To (K), (K/min) and t (min) denote the starting temperature, linear constant (heating or cooling) rate and time, respectively. TMDSC uses the heat-flux DSC instrument design and configuration to measure the differential heat flow between a sample and an inert reference material as a function of time. However, in TMDSC, a sinusoidal temperature modulation is superposed on the linear (constant) heating profile to yield a temperature programme in which the average sample temperature varies continuously in a sinusoidal manner: T (t) = To + t +AT Sin t
(2.2)
Where AT ( K) denotes the amplitude of the temperature modulation, (s-1) is the modulation frequency and = 2/p, where p (s) is the modulation period. Figure 2.5 illustrates a modulated temperature profile for a TMDSC heating experiment, which is equivalent by decomposition to applying two profiles simultaneously to the sample: a linear (constant) heating profile and a sinusoidal heating profile. The temperature profiles of these two simultaneous experiments (constant heating profile and sinusoidal heating profile) are governed by the following experimental parameters: • constant heating rate ( = 0-60 K/min) • modulation period (p = 10-100 s) • temperature modulation amplitude (AT = 0.01-10 K) The total heat flow at any point in a DSC or TMDSC experiment is given by: dQ C p f (T ,t ) dt
20
(2.3)
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 2.5 Typical TMDSC heating profile - a sinusoidal temperature modulation [11]
Where Q (J) denotes heat, t (s) time, Cp (J/K) sample heat capacity and f (T, t), the heat flow from kinetic processes, which are absolute temperature and time dependent. Like conventional DSC, TMDSC also measures the total heat flow, but by effectively applying two simultaneous temperature profiles to the sample, this can estimate the individual contribution to Equation 2.3. The constant heating profile (dashed line in Figure 2.5) provides total heat flow information, while the sinusoidal heating profile (solid line in Figure 2.5) gives heat capacity information corresponding to the rate of temperature change. The heat capacity component of the total heat flow, Cp is referred to as the reversing heat flow and the kinetic component, f (T, t) is referred to as the non-reversing heat flow. TMDSC data are calculated from three signals: time, modulated heat flow, modulated heating rate. But raw data for TMDSC is very complicated, it requires deconvolution to obtain standard data. TMDSC measures the heat capacity, Cp, using the equation: Q p C p K amp Tamp 2
(2.4)
where K denotes heat capacity calibration constant, Qamp, the heat flow amplitude, Tamp, the temperature amplitude. Heat capacity calibration is performed using a sapphire standard reference material. For data analysis, TA Instrument’s Thermal Solutions Software is used. 21
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials The following trademarks are used by different TA instrument manufacturers for their temperature modulated differential scanning calorimeters: Modulated DSC (MDSC) of TA Instruments Inc, Oscillating DSC (ODSC) of Seiko Instruments Inc., alternating DSC (ADSC) of Mettler – Toledo Inc, and dynamic DSC (DDSC) of Perkin – Elmer Corporation. DTA/DSC provide important information that can be used to characterise materials especially polymers and rubbers, design rubber products, predict product performance, optimise processing conditions, improve quality, and select the best materials for specific applications. Thus, specific measurements made by DSC include: 1. Tg, 2. Melting temperature (Tm), 3. Purity, 4. Crystallisation time and temperature, 5. Percentage crystallinity, 6. Polymorphism, 7. Heat of fusion and heat of reaction, 8. Specific heat and heat capacity, 9. Oxidative stability, 10. Rate of cure, degree of cure, completeness of cure 11. Reaction kinetics, and 12. Thermal stability.
2.4 Thermogravimetry (TG) Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) is the most important tool for quantitative analysis of rubber vulcanisates and their additives. The standard test method for compositional analysis by TGA describes a general technique to determine the quality of four arbitrarily defined compounds such as: a. highly volatile matter, b. matter of medium volatility, 22
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials c. combustible material, and d. ash left after decomposition (mainly inorganic components in rubber vulcanisates. The principle of thermogravimetry is based on a ‘thermobalance’ which describes an instrument, that continuously measures the weight changes of a substance at gradually varying temperatures [12]. The modern thermobalance [13] is illustrated schematically in Figure 2.6. It consists of the following components: a. recording balance, b. furnace, c. furnace temperature programmer or controller, and d. recorder. The specific details of each component depend on the particular application that is required of the instrument, for example, furnaces can be obtained that operate up to 2800 °C (Table 2.2).
Figure 2.6 Schematic diagram of TG apparatus [13]
23
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
2.4.1 Thermobalance The most important component of TGA is the recording thermobalance. Recording balances can be divided into three types, based on their mode of operation: a) deflection type of instruments, b) null type instruments, and c) those based on changes in a resonance frequency – which give tremendous sensitivity. The null-type balance principle is now used in almost all commercially available thermo balances, e.g., TGA 2050 of TA Instruments. The system operates on a null-balance principle, using a highly sensitive transducer coupled to a taut-band suspension system to detect minute changes in the mass of sample. Actually an optical servo loop maintains the balance arm in the horizontal reference (null) position by regulating the amount of current flowing through the transducer coil. An infra red light source and a pair of photosensitive diodes detect movement of the beam. A flag at the top of the balance arm controls the amount of light reaching each photosensor. As sample weight is lost or gained, the beam becomes unbalanced, causing the light to strike the photodiodes unequally. The unbalanced signal is fed into the control programme, where it is zeroed. This changes the amount of current supplied to the meter movement, causing the balance to rotate back to its null (zero) position. The amount of current required is directly proportional to the change in mass of the sample.
2.4.2 Temperature Detection in TG or TGA In TG or TGA, the mass change of the sample is continuously recorded as a function of temperature. The temperature in this definition, may be that of the furnace chamber, or the temperature near the sample. A thermocouple is used for temperature detection, it should be in contact either with the sample or with the sample container. For maximum temperature accuracy, temperature calibration is done with either well characterised curie temperature materials or high purity metals with well documented melting points. Various types of thermocouples used are shown in Table 2.3.
2.4.3 Furnace and Furnace Temperature Programmers A wide variety of furnaces are available for thermobalances, each designed for a specific temperature range from –150 to 2800 oC. Maximum temperature limits for various resistance heater elements are shown in Table 2.2. Various types of furnaces are used according to the needs of the experiment. The furnace may be positioned above, below or parallel to the balance. Each configuration has its own advantages and disadvantages. Placing the furnace above the balance appears to be the preferred configuration for high temperature ranges, where as for lower temperatures the furnace below the balance is more convenient. 24
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials In the DuPont thermobalance, a furnace parallel to the balance is used, whereas in the Perkin-Elmer Model, TGS-2, a novel microfurnace is placed inside the sample space on a ceramic tube. A thermocouple in close proximity to the sample pan is provided as an alternative measure of sample temperature. The type of temperature controller varies from the simple variable voltage transformer to a synchronous motor to the more sophisticated feed back, proportional type controller. Furnace programmers and controllers are of course, available from a wide variety of manufacturers like the DuPont furnace temperature programmer, TECO model TP-200 programmer [8]. The calibration of the temperature of the furnace and sample chamber has been discussed by various workers such as Stewart [14] and Norem and co-workers [15]. The criteria that are considered characteristic of an ideal standard are the following: 1. The transition must be sharp, 2. Should be unaffected by the chemical nature of the atmosphere, 3. Should be readily observable using a standard sample in the milligram range.
2.4.4 Controlled Atmosphere Purging of gas during the TG experiment is very important. Purge gases can be inert or reactive. A positive flow of inert gas (N2, He) from the balance chamber into the furnace protects delicate components against back diffusion of furnace purge gases or sample effluents.
2.4.5 Sample Containers Numerous sample containers are available for containment of the sample in a thermobalance. The type employed usually depends on the nature, amount and reactivity of the sample and the maximum temperature desired. Common materials of construction include alumina, platinum, platinum - 10% rhodium, aluminum, quartz, nickel, tungsten and graphite. A detailed description of sample containers is given by Wendlandt and co-workers [8].
2.4.6 Recorders Like DSC, three types of analog recorders are currently used in modern thermobalances – the timebase potentiometric strip chart and multipoint recorders and temperature based X-Y and X-Y1Y2 function plotters. However, all modern TGA instruments are 25
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials computer-controlled and capable of collecting data digitally and then simultaneously comparing it with results from previous experiments.
2.4.7 Software Special software libraries provide complete analysis capabilities for all thermal techniques including microthermal analysis (TA). With the help of software for thermal analysis today’s material characterisation problems are solved. Hence, for data analysis, special software is used. The DuPont software library provides a wide range of data analysis software, which enables the user to choose from standard routines, calibration and advanced methods through to writing their own software. All DSC, TGA, TMA modules require a moduleinterface for running the software, for example, IBM personal systems are packaged with TA Instruments. DSC software can determine: 1. Tg 2. crystallisation time and temperature, 3. heat of fusion, melting point, 4. oxidative stability, 5. temperature of transition, 6. kinetic parameters, 7. generic equation, 8. curve overlay. Similarly modern TGA loaded with software can determine: a. the composition of multicomponent systems of material, b. thermal stability of the materials, c. oxidative stability of the materials, d. the lifetime of a product through reaction kinetics, e. decomposition kinetics, f.
the effect of reactive atmosphere on materials, and
g. moisture and volatile content of the materials. 26
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials In addition to universal analysis, an extensive library of optional specialty data analyses programs are available for interpretation, evaluation and optimisation of DSC/TGA experiments. These programmes include software for: 1. Borchardt and Daniel’s kinetics [16], 2. Method of Freeman and Carroll [17, 18], 3. Thermal stability by ASTM E698 [19, 20], 4. Isothermal Method for analysis of cure exotherm [21], 5. Heat capacity.
2.5 Derivative Thermogravimetry (DTG) DTG describes the rate of weight change with respect to time or temperature and is d d or represented as . In order to study the multicomponent systems, the role of dt dT DTG is very important, as it easily distinguishes two or more components, when the rate of weight change is reflected in the form of peaks. This is not surprising as the thermal stabilities of many materials in the component are very similar. Although it is apparent that the rate of weight loss changes with temperature, it is difficult to determine the exact temperature range associated with a loss of a specific component from the mixture. The DTG thermogram could be constructed from the TG curve by manual methods or by data processing and this would present little difficulty where the weight loss events are well separated on the temperature scale. For overlapping events DTG peaks are important as shown in Figure 2.7, where TG/DTG curves of a tyre compound based on NR/BR blend are recorded [22]. The primary weight loss in TG curve shows a continual weight loss over the temperature range 150 to 400 °C, then the rate of weight loss becomes slow for a short time, then again the rate of weight loss increases until the temperature reaches 510 ºC, after which the weight loss becomes constant. It is difficult to determine the exact temperature range associated with a loss of a specific component from the mixture; to measure this DTG is required. The presence of oil is not observed in the TG curve (Figure 2.7) but a small peak in the DTG curve, shows the existence of oil. In the TG curve, the line of demarcation of natural rubber (NR) and polybutadiene rubber (BR) is not clear, but the two peaks (maximum at 365 and 450 °C) clearly indicate that the first peak is due to NR and the second peak is due to BR. Thus, the DTG curve is used for quantitative analysis. The experimental details under which TG/DTG curves are obtained should be given with each analysis. The experimental factors to be considered in obtaining TG/DTG data have been reviewed by several authors [22, 23].
27
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 2.7 TG/DTG Curve of a tyre compound based on NR/BR blend [22]
Commercial thermal analysis (DTA, DSC, TGA) instruments are listed in Table 2.4 and 2.5, so that choices can be made according to the requirements of the polymer analyst.
2.6 Evolved Gas Analysis (EGA) or Evolved Gas Detection (EGD) EGA is the general term for any technique, which determines the nature and amount of volatile products evolved by a sample as it is subjected to a controlled temperature programme. EGA is preceded by EGD, which merely detects the presence of evolved gases. When used in tandem with TG or DTA, EGA is primarily employed to determine the composition and concentration of evolved gases from mass loss reactions. Wendlandt [7, 13], Lodding [24] and Langer [25] have discussed the details of the instrumentation for EGD and EGA. In many cases, EGD/EGA is determined simultaneously with other thermal analysis techniques such as DTA and TG. It is a simple matter to add a thermal conductivity detector to a TG/DTA apparatus and determine the EGD curve of the sample. The schematic diagram of EGA is shown in Figure 2.8, where a thermal conductivity detector is connected to a Netzsch DTA system [8]. Here the evolved gases from the samples are swept from the furnace by means of a carrier gas and detected by the thermal conductivity detector (Figure 2.8). A flow meter permits adjustment of carrier gas (He, N2) flow rate. The output voltage of the detector is proportional to the concentration of the reaction products (evolved gases or carrier 28
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Table 2.4 Name of common commercial thermal analysers (DTA, DSC) Serial Name of Instrument No.
Temperature Range, in an Inert Atmosphere, °C
1
DuPont DSC Cell, Model 910*
2
DuPont DTA 990*
60 to 1600
3
Perkin-Elmer DTA 1700
20 to 1500
4
Perkin-Elmer DSC-2 Calorimeter
5
MettlerToledo TGA/DSC1 (Simultaneous TG – DSC) Room temperature to 1200
6
Mettler DSC 20
- 20 to 600
7
Mettler DS, Mettler Toledo DSC 1
- 170 to 600
8
Stanton Redcroft DTA Systems: a. DTA 6713 b. DTA 672 c. DTA 673 d. DTA 674
-150 to 500 25 to 500 25 to 1000 25 to 1500
9
a. Netzsch TG-DTA b. Model DSC M444
-180 to 1600 -180 to 500
10
Setaram a. DTA 2000K b. DTA 1500K c. Micro DTA M5 d. DSC
25 to 1750 25 to 1250 -170 to 1500 -123 to 827
Theta DTA System a. TG – DTA
25 to 1600
Hungarian Optical Works, MOM Derivatograph (TG-DTA-DTG)
25 to 1100
ULVAC (Sinku-Riko) DTA, HPTGD-3000-M, High pressure TG-DTA
25 to 800
11 12 13
- 150 to 725
- 175 to 725
14
Perkin-Elmer Pyris1 DSC (Power compensated)
-150 to 1000
15
TA Instrument DSC 2010, Q20, Q200, Q2000
-180 to 725
16
a. DuPont 920 Auto DSC or 2920 Auto DSC* b. DuPont DSC 10 cell base*
17
a. b. c. d.
MDSC of TA Instruments ODSC (Seiko Instrument, Inc. ADSC of Mettler – Toledo Inc. DDSC, Perkin Elmer Corporation.
-180 to 700, 62 Samples at a time -170 to 725 Ambient to 1000 Ambient to 1000 Room temperature to 1000 Ambient to 1000
*: Currently TA Instruments
29
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Table 2.5 List of common commercial thermogravimetric analysers (TGA, DTG) Serial Number 1 2 3
4
5
6 7 8 9 10
Name DuPont Model 951* Perkin Elmer Model TGS – 2 a. Mettler TA-1, Thermoanalyzer (Simultaneous TG-DTG-DTA) b. Mettler TA-2 (TG-DTG-DTA) c. Mettler 2000C (TG-DTG-DSC) Netzsch Model STA 429 (TG-DTA)
Theta Instrument a. Cahn Model 1000 (TG-DTA) b. Cahn Model 2000 Setaram Model G 70 Shimadzu Thermo balances a. TGA-20B Micro Thermo Balance Rigaku TG – DTA or TG-DSC
Temperature, °C RT to 1000 RT to 1000 RT to 2400 25 to 1000 20 to 1200 a. –150 to 420 b. 25 to 1000 c. 25 to 1350 d. 25 to 2400 (furnaces are different) RT to 1400 RT to 1400 or 1600 -196 to 2400 Option for 5 furnaces RT to 1000 RT to 1000 RT to 1500 RT to 1000 RT to 1100
Stanton Redcroft TG-750 (Thermobalance) Hungarian Optical Works (MOM Derivatograph) TG-DTA RT to 1000 11 a. TGA 2950a TA Instrument b. TGA 2050a TA Instrument RT to 1000 c. SDT, 2960 (DSC – TGA) RT to 1500 a : An optional quartz-lined evolved gas analysis (EGA) furnace can replace the normal TGA furnace RT: Room temperature *: Currently TA Instruments
gas absorbed). Langer [25] has discussed the various types and applications of EGA, involving gas chromatography (GC) and mass spectrometry (MS). Pyroprobe Model 100 are pyrolysis probes available for coupling with gas chromatography to provide the temperature capabilities. The use of mass spectrometers for EGA has been particularly rewarding because of their high sensitivity, which gives them an ability to directly identify the vapour species. The Netzsch simultaneous TG-DTA-EGA apparatus provides a line of sight-path so that readily condensable species can be measured. 30
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 2.8 Schematic diagram of a typical EGA apparatus [8]
Fourier transform infra red (FT-IR) spectroscopy, continuously monitors the purge gas as a function of time or temperature, when attached to EGA. Some problems due to condensation of gases, time lag, reaction between gases, sensor selectivity, differences in diffusion rate, should be avoided, in order to achieve good results. In order to compile a complete EGA report with the results from a TG-EGA experiment, the following points should be considered: •
Record of the evolved gas spectrum,
•
Description of gas components,
•
Flow rate, total volume, design type and temperature of the interface between the TG and EGA instruments,
•
Delay between evolution and analysis of gas,
•
Relationship between the signal amplitude and concentration of evolved gases.
2.7 Thermomechanical Analysis (TMA) and Thermodilatometry (TD) or Thermodilatometric Analysis (TDA) Thermomechanical analysis (TMA) is a technique in which the deformation of a substance is measured under non-oscillatory load as a function of temperature programme. 31
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials Thermodilatometry (TD) or thermo dilatometricanalysis (TDA) on the other hand is a technique in which the dimension of a substance is subjected to a controlled temperature programme [26]. Both of these techniques may be obtained using the same apparatus; only the sample probe or probe loadings are different. With TMA, the dimensional properties of a sample are measured as the sample is heated, cooled or held under isothermal conditions. The loading or force applied to the sample can be varied with TMA. The technique is used to assess the following important properties of polymers: 1. Softening temperature, 2. Melting temperature, 3. Co-efficient of thermal expansion, 4. Dimensional compatibilities of two or more different materials, 5. Relative degree of cure of thermosets, 6. Composite delamination temperature, 7. Percentage shrinkage of films and fibres, 8. Shrinkage forces, 9. Testing of coatings on metal films. A typical thermomechanical analyser [7], such as is incorporated in Perkin-Elmer TMS-2, is shown in Figure 2.9(a). In the penetration and expansion modes, the sample is placed on the platform of a quartz sample tube. The quartz probe is connected to the armature of linear variable differential transformer (LVDT) and any change in the position of the armature results in an output voltage from the transformer, which is then recorded. The probe assembly includes a weight tray, which permits a choice of loadings on the sample surface. The weight tray on the probe assembly is supported by a plastic float rigidly fixed to the shaft and totally immersed in a high density fluid such as mercury, glycerol, paraffinic oil, depending on the plastic used in the float. When the expansion of the sample takes place, it will disturb the float, then by adding weight on to the tray, it will be adjusted. The sensitivity of the apparatus provides an amplification in displacement of 4 x 10-5 on a 10 mV recorder. Two furnaces are used to cover the ranges, -150 to 325 °C and 25 to 725 °C. A first derivative computer accessory can be fixed to Perkin-Elmer TMS-2 for simultaneous recording of TMA and DTMA. The TMA probes offered by PerkinElmer includes, expansion, penetration, compression, flexure, extension, dilatometry, a few are shown in Figure 2.9(b). 32
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 2.9(a) TMA apparatus, Perkin-Elmer TMS–2 [7]
Figure 2.9(b) Probes of TMA apparatus [7]
33
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials TMA is used to determine the linear thermal expansion co-efficient ( ) of polymers and also co-efficient of thermal expansion (CTE), which is a quantitative assessment of the expansion of material over a temperature interval. But in order to measure the volume expansion co-efficient, dilatometry (TDA) is used, as this cannot be measured from TMA data, because Poisson’s constant is not 1.0 for many polymers. Thus, in TDA, glass capillary dilatometers were designed and built by individual researchers using mercury as a filling medium. The full description of TDA is given by Hatakeyama and co-workers [27]. The sample (1-2 g) is inserted into the glass tube of the dilatometer followed by a glass rod, which fits the inner diameter of the glass tube and acts as a spacer. The inner volume of the dilatometer is measured with mercury. Now the dilatometer containing the sample is placed in an oven and heated at a programmed rate. The height of the mercury in the glass capillary of the dilatometer is measured as a function of temperature. By this method the volume expansion co-efficient of the sample can be calculated, if the sample mass and its density at room temperature are known, since the mass expansion co-efficient of mercury and the diameter of the dilatometer capillary are known. The DuPont Model 943 Thermomechanical Analyser module TA Instruments’ DMA Q400 is capable of handling samples in the form of plugs, films, powders or fibres in the temperature range −180 to 800 °C. Interchangeable sample probes permit the determination of penetration, expansion, tension and dilatometry of the samples. 943 TMA has wide selections of optional accessories like: i)
Parallel Plate Rheometry,
ii) Fibre Tension Spectrometry, iii) Stress Relaxation Spectrometry.
2.7.1 Parallel Plate Rheometry (PPR) Time-temperature viscosity data on thermosets can be generated during the early stages of cure, when the TMA is employed as a parallel-plate rheometer. Bartlett [28] has applied the PPR technique for characterisation of fibre–reinforced resins. a. Two types of experiments are possible when a sample fills the space between the plates and exudes from between them after the load is applied, e.g., Wallace plastimeter. b. When the radius of the test plates is larger than that of the sample throughout the test and the sample volume is constant, e.g., Williams plastimeter.
34
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials Both methods require a flat ended cylindrical sample as shown in Figure 2.10. Viscosities from 10-107 Pa-s can be measured with low shear rates of 10-3 to 10°/s. The viscosity is calculated as: 1 [ 4F / 3R 2 ] / [ d / dt ] h2
(2.5)
Where, F = applied force, R = sample radius, h = distance between the plates, and t = time. For method (b) experiments, the relationship is slightly different: 1 8F 3V 2 / d / dt h4
(2.6)
Where, V = sample volume. The parallel plate method actually measures the creep compliance, which has elastic, time-dependent elastic (viscoelastic) and viscous components. Cessna and Jabloner [29] used TMA-PPR for thermoset cure studies.
2.7.2 Fibre Tension Spectrometry It is used to measure shrinkage tension of fibres as a function of temperature held under constant elongation. In this case the primary transducer is a load cell with a low spring constant in series with the LVDT sensor of TMA.
Figure 2.10 Schematic diagram of parallel plate rheometry Dupont Company Instrument System, Concord Plaza, Wilmington, Delaware, 1989, USA
35
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
2.7.3 Stress Relaxation Spectrometry It is used for measurement of relaxation modulus versus time on viscoelastic materials. A similar transducer to the fibre tension spectrometer is used, with a high force load cell and using steel probes for up to 1 kg load.
2.8 Dynamic Mechanical Analysis (DMA) It is a technique in which dynamic modulus or damping of a substance is measured under oscillatory load as a function of temperature as the substance is subjected to a controlled temperature programme. So in DMA, the sample is clamped into a frame and the applied stress (which varies sinusoidally) of frequency can be presented as : (t) = o sin (t + )
(2.7)
where o is the maximum stress amplitude and the stress proceeds the strain by a phase angle . The strain is given by: (t) = o sin (t)
(2.8)
where o is the maximum strain amplitude. These quantities are related by: ( t ) * ( ).(t )
(2.9)
where E*() is the dynamic modulus, and: *( ) i
(2.10)
where E () and E () are the dynamic storage modulus and the dynamic loss modulus, respectively. For a viscoelastic polymer, E characterises the ability of the polymer to store energy (elastic behaviour) while Ereveals the tendency of the material to dissipate energy (viscous behaviour). The phase angle is calculated from: tan
(2.11)
Normally E, E and tan are plotted against time or temperature. DuPont Model 981 DMA module [8] is illustrated schematically in Figure 2.11 where the sample is oscillated at its resonant frequency and an amount of energy, equal to that lost by the sample, is added on each cycle to keep the sample in oscillation at constant amplitude. The logarithm of this extra energy (called damping) and the frequency are displayed digitally as well as recorded as a function of sample temperature [26].
36
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 2.11 Dupont Model 981 DMA module [8]
In Figure 2.11, the sample is clamped between two arms, one of which is a passive support, while the other is driven by an electromechanical transducer. Rotation of the driven arm a few tenths of a millimetre, puts the sample in flexure stress, so that, when the displacing force is released, the deflection energy started in the sample, causes it to go into the resonant oscillator. The frequency and amplitude of this oscillator are deflected by the LVDT positioned at the opposite end of the active arm. The LVDT signal is fed to the driver circuit, which then feeds back enough energy to the electromechanical transducer to keep the sample in oscillation at a constant amplitude. The temperature range is –150 to 500 ºC (with an optional accessory). Software is fixed with DMA instruments, so that values of E, E and tan are directly calculated. Not only this, computer controlled DMA instruments allow the deforming force and oscillating frequency to be selected and to be scanned automatically through a range of values, in the course of the experiment. Hence, DMA can be applied to a wide range of materials using the different clamping configurations and deformation modes as shown in Table 2.6. 37
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Table 2.6 DMA probes and deformation modes for different applications Sample Solid polymers
Film, fibre, coatings
Viscous fluids, gel
Parameter Dynamic modulus Glass transition temperature Melting temperature Crosslink density Relaxation behaviour Crystallinity Cure behaviour Dynamic modulus Glass transition temperature Creep Cure Relaxation behaviour Viscosity Gelation Gel-sol transition Cure behaviour
Clamp/mode Clamp with sharp teeth Deformation mode
Clamps which are flat type Deformation mode
Clamps with a small nipple to retain material Shear mode
Hard samples or samples with a glazed surface use clamps with sharp teeth to hold the sample firmly in place during deformation. Soft materials and films use clamps which are flat to avoid penetration or tearing. When operating in shear mode flat-faced clamps, or clamps with a small nipple to retain the material, can be used. From the variation in the temperature of the tan peak of a DMA curve as a function of frequency, a transition map can be compiled from this map, and an activation energy for the phenomenon, can be calculated using the Arrhenius relationship or William–Landel– Ferry (WLF) equation [30]. While reporting TMA or DMA results, the following things should be included: •
The type of TMA or DMA instrument used,
•
Method of sample preparation, including dimensions and orientation,
•
Deformation mode,
•
Shape and dimensions of probe (TMA),
•
Size and type of clamps and frame (DMA),
•
Temperature range, heating/cooling rate, isothermal conditions,
•
Atmosphere,
38
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials •
Flow rate,
•
Exact location and type of sample thermocouple, and
•
Description of temperature.
Popular instruments for TMA and DMA are shown in Table 2.7.
Table 2.7 Manufacturers of TMA and DMA systems Manufacturer
Model Number
Temperature, °C
TMA 7/DMA 8000
RT to 800
2. Netzsch
TMA 402
-160 to 1700
3. Stanton-Redcroft
TMA 691
-180 to 500
Numerous*
-150 to 3000
5. DuPont*
DMA 981
-150 to 500
6. DuPont*
DMA 2980
-150 to 600
7. DuPont*
TMA 2940
-150 to 1000
8. TA Instruments
DMA 800
-150 to 500
9. DuPont**
TMA 943
-180 to 800
Rheovibron (DVP-II-EP)
-150 to 400
1. Perkin Elmer
4. Theta
10. Orientec Corporation
* Furnaces are different ** TA Instruments was divested from the DuPont Company in 1990
2.8.1 Torsional Braid Analysis (TBA) The technique of torsional braid analysis (TBA) was first introduced by Gillham [31] for the investigation of the mechanical properties of polymeric substances. It permits thermomechanical ‘fingerprints’ of polymer transitions in the temperature range, -190 to 500 °C in controlled atmospheres. The apparatus used in TBA determines the frequency (less than 1 Hz) and decay of a freely oscillating pendulum, which provides information on the modulus and mechanical damping of the polymer under examination [32]. TBA measures the rigidity of the material and is used for the curing of thermosets. Here the sample is prepared by impregnating a glass braid or thread substrate with a solution of the polymeric material to be tested, followed by evaporation of the solvent [33]. During the heating of the sample impregnated braid, it is subjected to free torsional oscillations. An electrical analog of the decaying pendulum oscillation is obtained by attenuating light with a circular transmission disk, which features a linear relationship between light transmission and displacement angle (Figure 2.12). 39
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 2.12 Sketch of a TBA pendulum [33]
From these oscillations, the relative rigidity parameter: 1 p2 1 Where, p = the period of oscillation in seconds and the mechanical damping index n (n = number of cycles for the damping peak amplitude to decrease by a fixed amount) are obtained intermittently through the isothermal cure of a thermoset. The relative rigidity is proportional to the shear modulus (G) and the mechanical damping index is a measure of the logarithmic decrement, which is proportional to the ratio of the outG of-phase shear modulus(G´´) to the storage shear modulus (G). Hence, tan G can easily be found. Sykes and co-workers [34] describe a novel use of TBA, in which a 200 x 2 mm composite specimen replaces the braid. Using this technique, they show that absorption of moisture causes a decrease in rigidity, a broadening and a decrease in
-transition and increase in intensity of -transition. Their results lead them to conclude that polymer is plasticised by absorbed water, which is in part reversible. Hence, TBA is used to find out the gel point of a thermosets. Schneider and co-workers [35] determined the gelation and vitrification times of epoxy-dicyandiamide during isothermal curing from TBA experiment.
40
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
2.9 Thermally Stimulated Current (TSC) Thermally stimulated depolarisation current (TSDC) or thermally stimulated current (TSC) spectroscopy is used to characterise the relaxation processes and structural transitions occurring in samples that have been polarised at a temperature greater than the temperature where molecular motion in the sample is enhanced and subsequently quenched so that the high mobility state is frozen. TSC was first discovered by Lacabanne and her coworkers [36]. TSC is ideal for the investigation of the fine structure of polymers, semicrystalline polymers, co-polymers and blends, polymer complexes and resins and is uniquely suitable to study the influence of additives, and plasticisers [37].
2.9.1 Principle The principle of TSC is to orient polar molecules (pendant polar groups) of macromolecules, by applying a high voltage field at a temperature, then quenching the material to a much lower temperature, where molecular motion ceases. After this polarisation, the material is heated at constant rate causing it to depolarise and in so doing – it creates a depolarising current. This thermally stimulated depolarisation current relates directly to molecular mobility, giving the research analyst a true opportunity to study the physical and morphological structure of material. Here in Figure 2.13, the mobile units of the samples are oriented by a static electric field (E) at a given polarisation temperature Tp. When the polarisation (P) has reached its equilibrium value, the temperature is decreased to ‘freeze’ this configuration, then the field is to cut off. The method is to polarise the sample at temperature Tp for the time tp. Now the sample is quenched to temperature Td (10 ºC below Tp), then the polarisation voltage is cut off and is kept at Td for a time td, which allows depolarisation of another fragment to oriented dipoles. Next the sample is quenched to T0 << Td. The sample is reheated at a constant rate and the current is measured. The spectrum, described by single relaxation time, is a function of temperature. The depolarisation current (J) flowing through the external circuit is measured by an electrometer indicating the dipolar conductivity (Figure 2.13). A TSC apparatus is schematically illustrated in Figure 2.14. The sample is mounted between parallel condenser-type electrodes and heated to the depolarisation temperature, Tp, under a controlled atmosphere. A DC voltage up to 500 V is applied across the electrodes for a time, tp, producing an electric field which polarises the sample. A TSC curve plots the thermally stimulated current versus temperature or depolarisation current J ersus time as shown in Figure 2.13. If isothermal polarisation varies exponentially with time, then: (relaxation time) =
P
(2.12) 41
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 2.13 Windowing polarisation of TSC, Solomat Instrumentation, Glenbrook Industrial Park, Stanford, CT, USA, 1989
42
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 2.14 Schematic diagram of TSC Instrument, Solomat Instrumentation, Glenbrook Industrial Park, Stanford, CT, USA, 1989
Where P = polarisation = dipolar conductivity E = electrical field. Assuming a Debye-type relaxation process, where all dipoles have a single relaxation time and there are no interactions between dipoles, the instantaneous thermally stimulated current J(t) or depolarisation current J is given by: J(t) = (t) P (t)
(2.13)
1 Where P(t) denotes the polarisation decay and (t) the relaxation frequency t . Heating at a constant rate () the temperature dependent relaxation time is described by Arrhenius relationship:
T o exp H
KT
(2.14)
Where 0, H and K denote the pre-exponential factor, activation enthalpy and Boltzman constant, respectively. The relaxation time is: 43
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials P(T ) ) (T ) J(T ) P(T J(T )
(2.15)
This is the ratio of the area under the peak of depolarisation at temperature (T) and of the value of depolarisation current density J at that temperature (Figure 2.13). Equation 2.15 is known as Kelvin – Voigt model. The following items should be included when presenting the results of TSC measurement: •
Type of TSC apparatus,
•
Method of sample preparation including dimensions,
•
Type and configuration of electrodes,
•
Electric field, polarisation temperature, polarisation time,
•
Quenching rate, and
•
Heating rate and final temperature.
2.10 Relaxation Map Analysis (RMA) It is a unique method that reveals a material’s physical properties and discovers more about the solid state matter than ever before. It has the sensitivity to monitor the influence of external stress, processing conditions, degree of cooling or annealing, chemical composition and percentage of crosslinking on molecular mobility. By varying the value of Tp (as shown in Figure 2.13) and repeating the process, the elementary modes can be isolated or ‘windowed’ and used to construct the material’s ‘relaxation map’. Hence, TSC/RMA is the only quasi-equilibrium technique that operates from liquid nitrogen to about 100 degrees above the Tg, showing all transitions along the way, which is free of the annoying problems that plague calorimetry. From low temperatures up to the molten state, for example, it can indicate why an adhesive or paint has formed a good bond, or show how to identify a good matrix/fibre composite and specify its conditions of use. Research and development conducted with a Solomat spectrometer (Model 41000 or 41000 plus) fitted with a powerful software (Multitasking) so that it can analyse data while the determinations are in progress. TSC/RMA is ideally suited to the investigation of the effects of molecular weight, chemical structure, internal stress, orientation, curing, crystallisation and thermodynamic 44
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials history or individual relaxation modes and thus it supercedes other techniques like DSC, DTA, DMA TMA. Hence, the Solomat TSC/RMA Spectrometer performs an entire series of complex experiments, without operator attention, as the software remembers the complete experimental set up. For semicrystalline materials, the power resolution with RMA makes it possible to specify the difference between macromolecules trapped in the interlamellar regions and those which belong to the true amorphous region. In TSC, amorphous polymers display a very strong relaxation mode at the Tg, which is attributed to microbrownian motions of the amorphous chains (e.g., Figure 2.15(a), drawn and undrawn PP). In Figure 2.15(b), the window polarisation analysis reveals two distinct relaxation modes at the lower temperatures, clearly indicating the existence of a fine structure within the amorphous region. The relaxation component observed at the lower temperature is attributed to those regions free from constraint – the inter-spherulite regions. The component at the higher temperature corresponds to the amorphous chains under constraints from crystallites i.e., inter-crystalline regions where both ends of the chains may be included in crystallites. Lacabanne and co-workers [37] studied the structure of polyether block amide (PEBA) adhesives, and characterisation of latex co-polymers with Solomat 41000. Similarly the thermal transitions of toluene diisocyanate based polyurethane elastomers with polytetramethylene oxide were characterised by TSC/RMA [38]. Using TSC/RMA Shin and co-workers [39] characterised the low temperature relaxation of epoxy-resin modified with amine-terminated butadiene acrylonitrile copolymers (ATBN). TSC and
Figure 2.15(a) TSC spectrum for (……….) undrawn and _________ drawn polypropylene Solomat Instrumentation, Glenbrook Industrial Park, Stanford, CT, USA, 1989
45
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 2.15(b) Relaxation map analysis for undrawn polypropylene Solomat Instrumentation, Glenbrook Industrial Park, Stanford, CT, USA, 1989
RMA were used to characterise the molecular behaviour of several coating systems [40], thermal transitions and relaxations in styrene-butadiene block and random co-polymer samples, both unfilled and compounded with SBR tyre reclaim.
2.11 Differential Photo Calorimetery (DPC) DPC is a new tool for understanding photosensitive materials. It is the key to the development of new materials. DPC applies the well-known principle of DSC for the measurement of chemical reactions, which are initiated by UV or visible light. DPC measures the heat absorbed or released by a sample as it and an inert reference, are exposed simultaneously to radiation of known wavelength and intensity in a temperaturecontrolled environment. It also measures Tg, curie temperature, and degree of cure of a photopolymer. As DPC is quantitative and objective it can be used to characterise a wide range of light sensitive materials used in many end-use applications, such as: 1. Coatings for paper and wood, plastics, metals, fibre optics. 2. Films for imaging, protection (solder mask), electrical insulation. 46
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials 3. Adhesives. 4. Dental fillings. 5. UV stabilisers. 6. Printing inks. 7. Photo initiators.
2.11.1 DPC Instrument The DuPont 930 DPC is an instrument with the dual capability of a DPC and a DSC system, which is a versatile, cost effective instrument, having automated analysis, and producing very fast and accurate results. It is a good marketing aid with advanced software. It can calculate the heat flow of a curing polymer. Figure 2.16(a) shows the instrument, which consists of 1) lamp compartment, 2) Optical system, 3) DSC cell, 4) DPC power supply, 5) DSC cell base.
Figure 2.16(a) DPC spectrophotometer DuPont Company Instrument System, Concord Plaza, Wilmington, Delaware, 1989, USA
47
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 2.16(b) Optical system of DPC spectrophotometer DuPont Company Instrument System, Concord Plaza, Wilmington, Delaware, 1989, USA
Figure 2.16(b) shows the optical system in detail which contains: 1. Pressurised xenon lamp, 2. Pressurised mercury - xenon arc lamp or high pressure mercury arc lamp, 3. Spherical collection mirror, 4. Photo feedback sensor, 5. Collimating optics, 6. Heat sink. It also has a shutter, filter holder, and a DSC cell with radiometer probe.
2.11.2 Principle of Operation DPC exposes a sample to a precisely controlled beam of high intensity UV or visible light. The sample as either a liquid or a solid is placed in an open pan in a DSC cell. The DSC 48
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials cell provides precise temperature control, high sensitivity for quantitative measurement of heat of reaction associated with thermal and photo initiated reactions. It needs a light source, i.e., a lamp and the type used depends on wavelengths required: i)
High pressure mercury arc lamp for UV light, while pressurised mercury-xenon lamp is used for visible light.
ii) The light beam passes through a series of focusing lenses, which provide constant beam focus for all wavelengths. iii) The focus beam then strikes an infra red (IR) absorbing mirror, which reflects UV and visible wavelength absorbing all IR radiation. Heat buildup in the mirror, is dissipated by a metallic heat sink (Figure 2.16(b). A computer controlled photo feedback censor (No. 4 in Figure 2.16(b)) mounted near the heat-sink, monitors and controls light intensity. Light reflected from the IR absorbing mirror, passes through specially designed optics, which assure uniform intensity across the entire beam. The computer controlled shutter assures precise sample exposure. While performing DPC experiments, a precisely machined silver lid with openings above the sample positions and quartz window are used to cover the sample compartment of the cell. These assure superior baseline performance and permit absolute control of the atmosphere.
2.11.3 Uses of DPC The oxidation induction time (OIT) is measured by DPC, which was used as a tool for evaluating the UV stability of isotactic polypropylene [41]. DPC appears to be an efficient tool in the evaluation of photo-initiated, free radical polymerised systems like a newly synthesised tertiary aromatic amine methacryloxy substituted 4-N,N-(dimethylamino) phenylacetamide [42]. DPC was used for estimating the degree of cure of photo curable coatings composed of Ebecryl 270 resin, 1,6 hexanediol diacrylate and Darocur 1173 photo initiator [43].
2.12 Dielectric Analysis (DEA) or Dielectric Thermal Analysis (DETA) DEA or DETA measures the changes in the properties of a polymer, when it is subjected to a periodic electric field (sinusoidal electric field). This produces quantitative data from which the researcher can determine the capacitative and conductive nature of the materials characterising different molecular motions present in the polymeric system. In the dielectric experiment, the molecules are required to interact with an applied electric field and thus forces are only imposed on dipolar or charged species. Polarisation 49
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials is the basic property of any dielectric material which measures the extent of restricted displacement of charged particles present in any dielectric material under the influence of electric field. Polarisation is a vector quantity, which depends on the density of charge particles in a particular direction depending on the impressed electric field [44, 45]. In the dielectric technique a small sinusoidal electric field is applied to the sample and dQ
. Extent the electric displacement (charge Q) is usually followed via current ‘i’, as i dt of polarisation which also measures the capacitative nature of the material is measured by the dielectric constant (permittivity). If the material is subjected to an alternating electric field, the polarisation lags behind the field by phase angles [44].
The complex dielectric permittivity (*) is obtained from the amplitude and phase measurement which allows resolution into the storage part (dielectric constant: ‘) and the loss part (dielectric loss: ‘’). Then the loss tangent is: tan e
dissipation factor
(2.16)
Dielectric analysis measures the two fundamental electrical characteristics of a material: capacitance and conductance as a function of time, temperature and frequency. The capacitive nature of a material is its ability to store electric charge and the conductive nature is its ability to transfer electric charge. Hence, DEA or DETA has four major properties: 1. = permittivity also called the dielectric constant 2. = loss factor 3. Tan = dissipation factor
4. = dielectric specific conductivity = mhos/cm i.e., (ohm-cm)-1
is proportional to capacitance, and
is proportional to conductance
, conductivity is derived from measurement of
2.12.1 Technique Dupont 2970 Dielectric analyser (DEA), is used for measuring the capacitative and conductive nature of the material. The instrument (Figure 2.17) consists of: 1) two parallel electrodes, 2) frequency generator, 3) module microprocessor, 4) response interface, 5) A/D converter, 6) digital signal processor (DSP), and 7) controller/analyser.
50
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials The technique involves placing a sample between two electrodes and exposing it to an alternating electric field. The field is created by applying a sinusoidal voltage from a frequency generator to the input electrode (Figure 2.17). The output electrode receives the response current from the sample and it passes to the response – interface which amplifies the signal and passes it to A/D Converter, which transforms the signal to a digital format passing it to DSP. The processed phase and gain signals are sent to the module microprocessor, where they are combined with sample thickness measurement signals from LVDT to calculate (permittivity) and (loss factor). The polarisation produced within the sample causes an oscillation, which is at the same frequency as the field but with a phase angle () shift. The phase angle shift is measured by comparing the applied voltage to the measured current. Values for capacitance and conductance are measured as follows: Capacitance (C) faraday = I measured Sin . V applied 2f Figure 2.17 Schematic diagram of dielectric thermal analyser Dupont 2970 Dielectric Analyzer, (2000) Dupont Company, Instrument system, Wilmington, Delaware, USA, 1989
= (2f ).0
Conductance 1 I measured .Cos mho V applied R
(2.17)
(2.18)
Where, f = applied frequency (Hz) R = resistivity (ohms) (2.19)
Where, 0 absolute permittivity of free space. , both provide valuable information about molecular motion, measures the alignment of dipoles, while represents the energy required to align dipoles and move ions. 51
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials The technique of operation is similar to DSC, only the sample holder is simply a changeable disposable sensor, like a ceramic parallel plate, ceramic single surface, or a remote single surface. The temperature range is –150 to 500 ºC and the frequency range is 0.001 kHz to 100 kHz. The atmosphere is inert (He, N2). DETA measures several relaxations of polymeric materials like , , , where the relaxation corresponds to microbrownian motion of the whole chain and is operative only above the Tg, the process corresponds to dipolar group orientation occurred through limited mobility of small section of polymers and occurs at lower temperature. Like DMA, DETA can measure the compatibility and incompatibility of polymers/ rubbers. For example, SBR-nitrile-butadiene rubber (NBR) blend, is dominated by NBR due to strong cyano dipoles, and as a result it is an incompatible blend [46]. Radhakrishnan and Saini [46] studied the dielectric relaxation properties of polyvinyl chloride/thermoplastic elastomer (Hytrel grade 5526) blends of different composition and found a single -transition, which indicated the compatibility of the blend. The applications of DETA for polymers are as follows: 1. Molecular relaxations, 2. Oxidation, 3. Ageing, 4. Change in crystallinity, 5. Curing and rheological studies, and 6. Filler analysis.
2.13 Newly Developed Thermal Analysis There are many newly developed thermal analysis methods [47], which are also used nowadays for characterisation of polymers, these are: 1) Thermo microscopy, 2) Thermoluminescence 3) Alternating current calorimetry, 4) Thermal diffusivity (TDF), 5) Microthermal Analysis (TA), 6) Optothermal Transient Emission Radiometre (OTTER), 7) Specific Heat Spectroscopy, and 8) Thermal conductivity measurements. But these methods are very expensive, so they are not used very frequently for the characterisation of rubbers. 52
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
2.14 New Combined Methods of Thermal Analysis The capability of thermal techniques for material characterisation can be greatly increased if techniques other than thermal are connected to the thermal analyser to identify further either the residue or the effluence during a certain thermal event. Such techniques include, infra red spectroscopy (IR/FT-IR), MS, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, X-ray methods, ultraviolet and visible light spectrophotometer, electrochemical methods, emission and atomic absorption spectroscopy. For complex mixtures, a separation step may be desired before identification. Gas or liquid chromatography (GC, LC) is most convenient for this purpose. Analytical techniques [48] commonly considered for coupling with TG are IR, MS, GC. But many factors are to be considered for such combination. The heating rate in TG is relatively slow under typical operating conditions and some adjustments may have to be made to make it compatible with the evolved gas technique. A TG analysis is normally performed in a flowing gas atmosphere, thus, the gas flow rate has to be carefully chosen to allow proper evolved gas analysis. For some analytical techniques such as MS, only vacuum or very low pressures are permitted. Sample size is also an important parameter. If the sample is too large, it cannot be tolerated, whereas if it is too small, then it cannot be detected by others. For optimum operations of a typical TG analyser, sample weights should be in the range 1-100 mg, which may be beyond the limit of some gas analysis techniques. Good judgment should always be exercised when the analysis of off-gases from the TG analyser is performed. Thermal decomposition, recombinations, thermal reactions, condensations on cold spots may all occur. Hence, a combination of two or more major analytical techniques require multiple skills of the user. Of course the increased cost of investment in either capital or maintenance should be considered. A few popular processes of combined techniques will be discussed.
2.14.1 Coupled Thermogravimetry – Infra red Spectroscopy (TG-IR) The simplest and most inexpensive approach was described by Smith [49] as shown in Figure 2.18. The volatile effluents were drawn by slight vacuum via a 0.6 m long and 1.25 mm id (internal diameter) stainless steel hypodermic tubing through a Grubb Parson (1 m, 45 ml volume) multireflection IR cell mounted in the infra red beam of a Pye Unicom Sp1000 spectrophotometer to collect total volatiles - an evacuated PerkinElmer (1 m, 1 litre gas) cell was used. The gas transfer tubing was connected through silicone rubber septa to an IR cell and to a glass ball joint at the end of furnace tube. A DuPont 950 TG analyser was used because of its horizontal balance configurations. This technique has been used to distinguish many homopolymer blends [49] from copolymers, e.g., polyethylene (PE)-polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) blends. Evidently, this technique is only good for analysis of major components in the sample gas stream and the precision is inadequate for critical work. 53
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 2.18 Coupled thermogravimetry infrared spectroscopy (TG-IR) [49]
2.14.2 Coupled Thermogravimetry – Fourier Transform Infra red Spectroscopy (TG-FT-IR) With the advent of sophisticated commercial instrumentation of FT-IR in recent years, the potential of using IR for analysis of evolved gases from the TG analyser is greatly increased. One typical setup was described by Cody and co-workers [50, 51]. The interfacing system [48] is shown schematically in Figure 2.19. A Dupont 951 TG Analyzer controlled by a Dupont 1090 programmer/plotter was used in conjunction with a Nicolet 7199 FT-IR. A Nicolet GC/FT-IR sampling attachment served as the interface [50, 51]. Volatiles from TG were carried by dry nitrogen to a gold coated light – pipe via a heated 1.6 mm stainless steel transfer line. A broad band mercury-cadmium-telluride detector measured the signal transversing the light pipe. The
Figure 2.19 Coupled TG-FT-IR [50]
54
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials computer system associated with the FT-IR, stored the data in interferogram, performed phase calculation and Fourier transform and displayed the resulting spectrum in less than 2 seconds. The computer programme also allowed addition and subtraction of spectra. FT-IR is widely used in EGA owing to its relatively high sensitivity and short spectrum acquisition time. Corrosive and reactive decomposition products are more easily handled by TG-FT-IR coupling mechanism than by TG-MS.
2.14.3 Coupled Thermogravimetry – Mass Spectrometry (TG-MS) MS is a high-sensitivity, non specific technique used to identify unknown compounds. Infra red spectra identify the functional groups of polymer, but sometimes it is difficult to analyse the mixtures of compounds with similar functional groups. In MS, when bombarded by electrons all substances ionise and fragment in a unique manner. The mass spectrum, which records the mass and relative abundance of the ion fragments gives a fingerprint for each compound. Hence, MS using quadrupole mass spectrometers, is most commonly used with TG/EGA. MS have the capability of analysing simultaneously and independently a number of volatile components from a weight loss step. Direct connection of two instruments (TG and MS) is only possible, when the TG experiment can be performed only under high vacuum [52, 53] or under certain types of reagent gas to allow chemical ionisation in the MS [54, 55]. For flexible control of atmosphere and easy adaptation to various types of instrumentation, an interface is used to reduce the atmospheric pressure normally used in TG to below 0.01 Pa encountered in most MS operations. The general principle of the interface is to allow a small portion of effluent gas to leak into the MS so as not to reduce its vacuum below its tolerance limit. By doing so, the sampled gas should also be reasonably, reproducible and representative of the original gas stream. Different types of interfaces [56-58] were used with different types of thermal analyser. Yuen and co-workers [57] interfaced a ‘Mettler’ thermoanalyser with a Hewlett–Packard quadrupole mass spectrometer. A schematic diagram of TG-MS [57] is shown in Figure 2.20, where (A) is a HP-5992 quadrupole mass spectrometer, (B) is a Varian leak valve, (C) is a GC oven (D) is a fore pump (a mechanical pump which exhausts to the atmosphere and maintains a specific pressure in the inlet)), (E) is a leak valve from control shaft for fine adjustment, (F) is a TA/MS transferline, and (G) is a 9.5 mm to 6.35 mm stainless steel swagelock union. Two HP-9825 calculators were used for data acquisition and retrieval. Both thermal and mass spectral data were collected once every 10 seconds. All DTA, TG, DTG and selected mass abundance scans were plotted simultaneously. Another versatile and inexpensive interface based on the capillary principle has been reported by Chiu [58]. It is simple to construct, easy to maintain and readily adaptable to most TG and MS instruments, without modification. Some of the biggest problems for the TG-MS interface for routine use are contamination and clogging, a main advantage of this interface is its easy removal for cleaning by a suitable solvent (hydroflouric acid). 55
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 2.20 Coupled TG – MS using a leak valve as an interface [57]. A - HP 5992 quadrupole mass spectrometer; B - Varian leak valve; C - GC oven; D - Fore pump; E Leak valve from control shaft; F - TA-mass transfer line; G - Swage lock union
The interface samples the TG effluence for MS analysis directly and continuously as the TG experiment progresses, thus providing selective monitoring of individual components independent of each other. Chiu and co-workers [58] used this method to distinguish polymer blends of polystyrene (PS)-PMMA and a copolymer of PS-PMMA. Slusarski and co-workers [59] calculated the activation energy of destruction of cis-1,4 polybutadiene using TG-FT-IR and TG-MS methods and also determined the various products of thermal destruction of the elastomer cis-1,4 polybutadiene.
2.14.4 Coupled Thermogravimetry – Gas Chromatography (TG-GC) Pyrolysis gas chromatography has long been established as a powerful technique for polymer characterisation. The use of TG preceding GC is essentially equivalent to oven-pyrolysis GC. It thus possesses both the advantages and drawbacks of the latter except that TG-GC has the additional benefit of gaining weight loss information, which is important for quantitative examination of the original sample and guidance to the pyrolysis process. For TG, the addition of GC provides a means for separation and identification of volatile products at various weight loss steps, which is vital for the correct interpretation of a TG curve. One immediate benefit is the prior separation of 56
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials solvents, monomers and additives from the polymer by TG, thus avoiding the polymer degradation process. The use of TG-GC for polymer characterisation was first reported by Chiu [60, 61]. In contrast to TG-MS which requires a reduction in pressure, in most cases, TG-GC demands pressurisation of the TG effluent for efficient introduction of the sample into the GC. Also GC is a batch analysis and sampling from the continuous flow of TG effluence has to be intermittent. A sampling loop is typically used to accomplish this purpose by applying a pressurised carrier gas to sweep periodically the TG effluent into the GC column. A typical flow diagram of TG-GC is presented in Figure 2.21. A series of four switching stop cocks is used to direct the gas flow. After TG starts, the effluent gas flows through stopcocks A and B and the two traps to the atmosphere. If the concentration of the sample of interest is too small, a proper refrigerant may be added to the trap to collect a large segment of the effluent along the weight loss curve. After trapping, both stopcocks A and B are closed to the outside and connected to stopcocks C and D. Trap 1 is then heated to volatilise the condensed products. Now stopcock D is switched toward stopcock A to pressurise the system before stopcock C is turned to inject the vapourised sample as a plug to the GC column. If the concentration of sample gas is high no trapping is necessary. By rotating the stopcock, the trap becomes full of gas which can be used for weight loss measurements. A similar interface was built with larger capacity allowing eight samples to be collected for each weight loss measurement.
Figure 2.21 Schematic diagram of coupled TG-GC system [60]
57
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
2.14.5 Coupled TG-GC-IR Although GC can identify materials on the basis of their retention time in the column, its analytical capability is greatly enhanced if GC is further combined with IR or MS for positive identification of the components already separated by GC. Once TG has been coupled with GC as described previously, combinations of TG-GC-IR or TG-GCMS are straight forward and constitute extremely powerful tools for rubber product characterisation. Figure 2.22 shows the schematic diagram of TG-GC-IR [63]. A DuPont 950 thermogravimetric analyser, a Perkin Elmer 900 gas chromatograph, and a PerkinElmer 700 Infra red Spectrophotomer, equipped with a Wilks 41C vapour phase cell are combined [63]. The interface between TG and GC is a condensation trap connecting to a sampling valve. The effluent gas from the GC column is split so that 0.0625 of the gas goes to a flame ionisation detector and the rest to a hot wire thermal conductivity detector. The exhaust of the hot wire detector is connected to a series of microtraps each having a volume of 0.7 ml and equipped with inlet and outlet valves made of Teflon. The vapour fraction of each microtap is fed to the vapour phase infra red cell positioned in the spectrophotometer through a diverter valve as shown in Figure 2.22. Cukor [63] uses this technique to analyse a coating used to protect photographic emulsion masks from scratching. In TG, it shows weight losses in three steps (95%, 4%, 1%) in temperature ranges 30-150 ºC, 275-375 ºC and 430-500 ºC. GC scan from retention time and IR spectra identify the fractions as acetaldehyde, water, acetic acid, a mixture of butyric acid and butyraldehyde. Since these products have resulted from decomposition of polyvinyl alcohol, then the coating is nothing but a solution of polyvinyl alcohol. Of course, both sensitivity and speed will be much improved, if FT-IR is used in place of IR. Hence, use of TG-GC FT-IR will be more fruitful than TG-GC-IR.
Figure 2.22 Schematic diagram of coupled TG-GC-IR [63]
58
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
2.14.6 Coupled TG-GC-MS Like TG-GC-IR, the principle of combining TG-GC with MS is the same. MS has greater sensitivity than IR, so TG-GC-MS is more frequently used than TG-GC-IR. Chang and Mead [64] first reported TG-GC-MS, in which interface was constructed from an 8-way valve, a 6-way valve and two collecting traps, while the TG effluent was collected in one trap, the contents of other trap were analysed by GC-MS. The interface for GC-MS was a standard Biemann-Watson molecular separator used in conjunction with a GC stream splitter. The pyrolysis of PS foam and ethylene vinyl acetate co-polymer was studied by this apparatus. However, most recent devices of TG-GC-MS have capability for TG-MS alone and a combination of TG-GC-MS. A typical setup [58] is shown in Figure 2.23. Here a Dupont 951 TGA is connected to HP 5710A GC through a TG-GC interface, which is a six port microvalve connected with a condensation trap, which can introduce the condensed volatiles into either GC or MS. For selective ion monitoring, a TG-MS capillary interface shown in Figure 2.23 has been used. The GC-MS interface is a jet separator provided by Hewlett-Packard for its GC-MS instrument. All the transfer lines are heated to prevent pre-condensation of volatile products. For easy connection transfer lines are made of 1.6 mm stainless steel tubing. Here analysis of sample less than 1 mg is possible. A HP 21 Max computer and TEKTRONIX 4012 CRT are used for data analysis. Few examples of TG-GC, TG-MS and TG-GC-MS are reported here for characterisation of rubber/polymer analysis. Bart and Raemaekers [65] have studied several ethylenepropylene-diene rubber (EPDM) products and EPDM-SBR blends by TG-MS method.
Figure 2.23 Schematic diagram of TG-GC-MS [58]
59
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials Möhler and co-workers [66] have reported TG-DSC-MS of the thermal decomposition of the vulcanisation accelerator tetramethyl thiuram disulfide in rubber. Meuzelaar and coworkers [67] have used high pressure TG-GC-MS to simulate a solvent-free thermal and catalytic liquefaction reaction for co-processing of waste polymers (non vulcanised SBR or a mixture of waste plastics composed of PE, PS and waste rubber tyres) with coal. Gorman [68] has proposed a controlled thermal desorption (TDS) and concentration method for separating volatile additives from vulcanisable rubber in a TD-GC-MS configuration without the need for prior sample preparation. A major challenge in TG/DTG based analysis of elastomer vulcanisates is to demarcate oil/plasticiser and elastomer regions, which often show overlapping TG events. Deconvolution of the overlapping oil/plasticiser and oil/elastomer TG curves is expected to be feasible with high resolution thermogravimetry (HRTG), MS and principal component analysis (PCA) i.e., HRTG-MS-PCA, which would substitute the dated methods for graphical resolution of oil and polymer weight loss [69]. There are many other coupled TG methods like coupled thermogravimetry – photometry [70], coupled thermogravimetry – electrochemical analysis [71], which are not so popular for characterisation of polymers and rubber.
2.15 Conclusion It is concluded that, the previously mentioned thermal analysis procedures (DSC, DTA, TGA) give information on qualitative and quantitative analyses of rubbers, rubbery materials, rubber-blends, rubber-products. Mechanical properties like modulus, creep, stress relaxations of polymers and rubbers are obtained by TMA and DMA. Optical and electrical properties of rubbers and rubbery materials are determined by DPC and DETA. Modern coupled TG-GC, TG-IR, TG-MS, TG-GC-IR, TG-GC-MS give the complete analyses of the constituents of rubber compounds and rubber products.
Acknowledgements Thanks are due to Mr. Anjan Bhattacharjee, Mr. Ajoy Gayen, Ms. Subhra Dutta for assistance in preparing the manuscript.
References 1. H. Le Chatelier, Comptes Rendus des Seances de l’Academie des Sciences, 1886, 102, 1243. 60
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials 2. N.C. Roberts-Austen, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, 1891, 49, 347. 3. W.J. Smothers and Y. Chiang, Handbook of Differential Thermal Analysis, Revised Edition, Chemical Publishing Company, New York, NY, USA, 1966. 4. P.D. Garn, Thermoanalytical Methods of Investigation, Academic Press, New York, NY, USA, 1965. 5. W.W. Wendlandt and L.W. Collins in Benchmark Papers in Analytical Chemistry, Volume 2, Dowden, Hutchinson and Ross, Inc., Stroudsburg, PA, USA, 1976. 6. A. Blazek, Thermal Analysis, Van Nostrand Reinhold, London, UK, 1973. 7. W.W. Wendlandt, Thermal Methods of Analysis, Volume 19, 2nd Edition, Wiley Interscience, New York, NY, USA, 1974,. 8. W.W. Wendlandt and P.K. Gallagher in Thermal Characterisation of Polymeric Materials, Ed., E.A. Turi, Academic Press, New York, NY, USA, 1981, Chapter 1. 9. E.S. Watson, M.J. O’Neill, J. Justin and N. Brenner, Analytical Chemistry, 1964, 36, 7, 1233. 10. R.A. Baxter in Thermal Analysis, Eds., R.F. Schwenker, Jr., and P.D. Garn, Academic Press, New York, NY, USA, 1969, Volume 1, p.65. 11. T. Hatakeyama and F.X. Quinn, Thermal Analysis: Fundamentals and Applications to Polymer Science, 2nd Edition, John Wiley and Sons, New York, NY, USA, 2000, p.13. 12. C. Duval, Inorganic Thermogravimetric Analysis, 1st Edition, Elsevier Publishing Company, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1953. 13. W.W. Wendlandt, Handbook of Commercial Scientific Instruments, Volume 2, Marcel Dekker, New York, NY, USA, 1974, p.144. 14. L.N. Stewart in Proceedings of the 3rd Toronto Symposium on Thermal Analysis, Toronto, Canada, 1969, p.205. 15. S.D. Norem, M.J. O’Neill and A.P. Gray, Thermochimica Acta, 1970, 1, 1, 29. 16. J.H. Borchardt and F. Daniels, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1956, 79, 1, 41. 17. E.S. Freeman and B. Carroll, Journal of Physical Chemistry, 1958, 62, 4, 394. 18. D.A. Anderson and E.S. Freeman, Journal of Polymer Science, 1961, 54, 159, 253. 61
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials 19. T.J. Ozawa, Thermal Analysis, 1970, 2, 3, 301. 20. ASTM D698-07e1, Standard Test methods for the Laboratory Compaction Characteristics of Soil using Standard Effort [12,400 ft-lbf/ft3 (600 kN-m/m3)], 2007. 21. D.N. Waters and J.L. Paddy, Analytical Chemistry, 1988, 60, 1, 53. 22. D.W. Brazier and G.H. Nickel, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1975, 48, 4, 661. 23. J.J. Maurer, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1969, 42, 1, 110. 24. W. Lodding, Gas Effluent Analysis, Marcel Dekker, New York, NY, USA, 1967. 25. H.J. Langer in Treatise on Analytical Chemistry, Part 1, 2nd Edition, Eds., I.M. Kolthoff, P.J. Elving and E.B. Sandell, Wiley, New York, NY, USA, 1980, Chapter 15. 26. G. Lombardi, For Better Thermal Analysis, 2nd Edition, Institute of Minerology, Rome, Italy, 1980, p.18. 27. T. Hatakeyama and F.X. Quinn, Thermal Analysis: Fundamentals and Applications to Polymer Science, 2nd Edition, John Wiley and Sons, New York, NY, USA, 2000, p.133. 28. C.J. Bartlett, Journal of Elastomers and Plastics, 1978, 10, 4, 369. 29. D.P. Bloechle, Journal of Elastomers and Plastics, 1978, 10, 4, 377. 30. M.L. Williams, R.F. Landel and J.D Ferry, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1955, 77, 3701. 31. J.K. Gillham in Thermoanlysis of Fibers and Fiber-Forming Polymers, Ed., RF Schwenker, Jr., Applied Polymer Symposium, Interscience, New York, NY, USA, 1966, 2, 45. 32. J.K. Gillham, Polymer Engineering Science, 1979, 19, 10, 676. 33. R. Bruce Prime in Thermal Characterisation of Polymeric Materials, Ed., E.A. Turi, Academic Press, New York, NY, USA, 1981, Chapter 5. 34. G.F. Sykes, H.D. Burks and J.B. Nelson in Proceedings of the Natural SAMPE Symposium Exhibition, 1977, 22, 350. 35. N.S. Schneider, J.F. Sprouse, G.L. Hagmauer and J.K. Gillham, Polymer Engineering Science, 1979, 19, 4, 304. 62
Instrumental Techniques used for Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials 36. C. Lacabanne, Contribution à l’étude des Propriétés Diélectriques des Polysulfonamides,1974, University of Toulouse, France. [PhD Thesis] 37. C. Lavergne and C. Lacabanne, IEEE Electrical Insulation Magazine, 1993, 9, 2, 5. 38. J-M. Hsu, D-L. Yong and S.K. Huang, Journal of Polymer Research, 1999, 6, 2, 67. 39. S.M. Shin, D.K. Shin and D.C. Lee, Polymer Bulletin, 1998, 40, 4–5, 599. 40. C.M. Neag, J.P. Ibar, J.R. Saffell and P. Denning, Journal of Coatings Technology, 1993, 65, 826, 37. 41. J.E. Volponi, L.H.I. Mei and D.S. Rosa, Polymer Testing, 2004, 23, 4, 461. 42. R.E. Kerby, A. Tiba, B.M. Culbertson, S. Schricker and L. Knobloch, Journal of Macromolecular Science A, 1999, A36, 9, 1227. 43. C.S.B. Ruiz, L.D.B. Machado, J.A. Vanin and J.E. Volponi, Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry, 2002, 67, 2, 335. 44. B.M. Tareev, Physics of Dielectric Materials, Mir Publishers, Moscow, Russia, 1975. 45. N.G. McCrum, B.E. Reed and G. Williams, Anelastic and Dielectric Effects in Polymeric Solids, Wiley, London, UK, 1967. 46. S.R. Radhakrishnan and D.R. Saini, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1994, 52, 11, 1577. 47. T. Hatakeyama and F.X. Quinn, Thermal Analysis: Fundamentals and Applications to Polymer Science, John Wiley and Sons, New York, NY, USA, 2000, Chapter 6. 48. Jen Chiu in Applied Polymer Analysis and Characterisation: Recent Developments in Techniques, Instrumentation and Problem Solving, Ed., J. Mitchell, Jr., Hanser Publishers, Munich, Germany, 1987, Chapter IIG. 49. D.E. Smith, Thermochimica Acta, 1976, 14, 3, 370. 50. C.A. Cody, L. Dicarlo and B.K. Faulseit, American Laboratory, 1981, 13, 1, 93. 51. C.A. Cody, L. Dicarlo and B.K. Faulseit in Proceedings of the 10th North American Thermal Analysis Society Conference, 1980, Boston, MA, USA, p.137. 52. E.K. Gibson, Jr., and S.M. Johnson, Thermochimica Acta, 1992, 4, 1, 49. 63
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials 53. G.J. Mol, Thermochimica Acta, 1974, 10, 3, 259. 54. S.M. Dyszel in Analytical Calorimetry, Volume 5, Eds., J.F. Johnson and P.S. Gill, Plenum Press, New York, NY, USA, 1984, p.277. 55. S.M. Dyszel, Thermochimica Acta, 1983, 61, 1-2, 169. 56. F. Zitomer, Analytical Chemistry, 1968, 40, 7, 1091. 57. H.K. Yuen, G.W. Mappes and W.A. Grote, Thermochimica Acta, 1982, 52, 1-3, 143. 58. J. Chiu in Analytical Calorimetry, Volume 5, Eds., J.F. Johnson and P.S. Gill, Plenum Press, New York, NY, USA, 1984, p.197. 59. G. Janowska and L. Slusarski, Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry, 2001, 65, 1, 205. 60. J. Chiu, Analytical Chemistry, 1968, 40, 10, 1516. 61. J. Chiu, Thermochimica Acta, 1970, 1, 3, 231. 62. D.W. Brazier and N.V. Schwartz, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1978, 51, 5, 1060. 63. P. Cukor and E.W. Lanning, Journal of Chromatographic Science, 1971, 9, 487. 64. T-L. Chang and T.E. Mead, Analytical Chemistry, 1971, 43, 4, 534. 65. K.G.H. Raemakers and J.C.J. Bart, Thermochima Acta, 1997, 295, 1-2, 1. 66. H. Möhler, A. Stegmayer and E. Kaisersberger, Kautschuk und Gummi Kunststoff, 1991, 44, 4, 369. 67. K. Liu, E. Jakab, W. Zmierczak, J.S. Shabtai and H.L.C. Meuzelaar, ACS Preprints, Division of Fuel Chemistry, 1994, 39, 2, 576. 68. W.B. Gorman, Jr., inventor; Bridgestone/Firestone Inc., assignee; US 5,191,211, 1993. 69. S.J. Swarin and A.M. Wims, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1974, 47, 5, 1193. 70. B.B. Johnson and J. Chiu, Thermochimica Acta, 1981, 50, 1-3, 57. 71. S.G. Fischer and J. Chiu, Thermochimica Acta, 1983, 65, 1, 9. 64
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
3
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials Amit K. Naskar and Prajna P. De
3.1 Introduction Thermal analysis is an essential technique to measure the temperature or time dependent response of physical and chemical changes that occur in materials. In these techniques the sample is placed in a small chamber whose temperature can be controlled by a multi-step program. During each test scan, the temperature is usually set constant or altered periodically. Any change that occurs in sample against time or temperature is detected by a specific electronic device and recorded. In differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) mode, difference in heat flux between sample and an inert reference placed in the chamber is measured. Sometimes difference in temperatures between sample and reference is recorded and the technique is called differential thermal analysis (DTA). In a thermogravimetric analyser (TGA), change in mass of the sample is measured with variation in temperature or time using a force transducer. These techniques are extensively used to characterise polymeric materials [1]. Details of instrumentation for these techniques have been discussed in an earlier chapter (Chapter 2). This chapter summarises various applications of DSC and TGA for the characterisation of rubbers and rubbery materials.
3.2 Differential Scanning Calorimetry of Rubbery Materials In general, DSC is used for many applications including characterisation of materials by measuring parameters associated with phase transition (such as temperature and activation energy of phase transition), chemical reaction (such as crosslinking, oxidation and degradation) and micro- or macro- morphological alteration. For polymeric materials, morphological characteristics and thermo-chemical reactivity are important to control the physico-mechanical properties, processability and stability. A schematic of a generalised DSC thermogram of a polymer is displayed in Figure 3.1. Endothermic baseline shift at the lower temperature region indicates glassy to rubbery transition (Tg) of the polymer. For rubbery materials this temperature is below the ambient temperature. Like semi-crystalline thermoplastics a few rubbery materials often show cold crystallisation (exotherm) and a subsequent melting (endotherm) during a heating scan. Cis-1,4-polybutadiene, for 65
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 3.1 Schematic DSC thermogram of an imaginary rubbery material: (a) baseline shift indicating glass-rubber transition, (b) cold crystallisation exotherm, (c) melting endotherm or endotherm for volatilisation of plasticiser, (d) curing and/or oxidative degradation and (e) pyrolytic thermal degradation
example, displays a Tg at –100 °C, a cold crystallisation at –56 °C and a melting transition at –6 °C, when scanned at 20 °C/min [2]. Polyisoprene and natural rubber exhibit a cold crystallisation temperature at –35 to –23 °C [3]. Rubbery materials containing volatile plasticiser display endothermic broad peak due to loss of plasticisers [4]. Curative compounded rubbers display a crosslinking exotherm at a temperature ranging from 100-200 °C. Oxidative degradation of rubbers is also exothermic in nature. At very high temperature (250-500 °C) rubbery materials usually pyrolyse and display an endotherm. It can be reasonably stated that a rubbery material does not necessarily exhibit all these transitions shown in Figure 3.1 in a single DSC run. For polymeric materials, in general, DSC is used for the determination of following: i)
Specific heat and Tg,
ii) Melting point (Tm) and heat of fusion, iii) Curing characteristics, iv) Decomposition characteristics.
3.2.1 Measurement of Specific Heat and Glass Transition Temperature Specific heat (CP) of any material can be measured easily in a DSC apparatus using a constant rate of heating scan, a calibration run of empty cell and a controlled scan on a calibration specimen (sapphire, in general) following standard ASTM E1269 method [5]. Modulated temperature DSC is used to measure CP from a single experimental run 66
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials of the material using a calibrated instrument (ASTM E 1952). Temperature modulated DSC analyses of polymers have been broadly reviewed by various authors [1, 6]. Amorphous polymeric molecules, at low temperature, exist in a glassy state where molecular motions are frozen (such a state is called super-cooled liquid). With rise in temperature a subnano-scale process involving segmental molecular motion starts in the glassy polymer. The temperature (actually a range of temperatures), where segmental mobility in the polymer chain starts is called the Tg. With increase in degrees of freedom at a temperature beyond Tg, the heat capacity of the polymer increases. Therefore, in a DSC scan of a polymer, usually a shift in baseline is observed at the Tg. The most precise determination of Tg is done by cooling an equilibrium melt (rubbery) at a specified cooling rate and finding the temperature at half freezing [7]. Tg of a polymer depends on temperature scan rate, thermal history, molecular structure and composition of the material. It also depends on the experimental methods, e.g., DSC, dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA), thermomechnical analysis (TMA), dilatometry, etc., used to measure the Tg. However, for the DSC measurements, different methods of locating Tg (such as, extrapolated on-set, half height (ASTM E1356), derivative plot), are reported by Sircar and co-workers [8]. Commonly the point on thermal curve corresponding to half of the heat flow difference between the shifted base line is called the Tg. More precisely, Tg represents the temperature corresponding to the point on the curve at half heat capacity difference between the extrapolated baselines.
3.2.2 Significance of Tg Glass to rubber transition occurs during heating of the polymer from very low temperature, where amorphous molecular chains cannot exhibit segmental mobility. With increase in temperature, at a certain point, the segmental mobility starts and the polymer chains behave as flexible, rubbery material. The most successful theory behind Tg is the free volume theory of Flory [9]. It states that the glass transition (from rubbery state) occurs in a polymer when the fraction of free or unoccupied volume in a material reaches a constant value, which cannot be lowered further by cooling the material. For practical applications a Tg of a polymer represents the lower end use temperature. A polymer cannot be processed at a temperature below its Tg. For elastomeric products a rubbery polymer with very low Tg is desired. For example natural rubber (cispolyisoprene) has a Tg of –70 °C and is extensively used in rubber products. However, the trans-polyisoprene (Gutta percha) is a semi-crystalline plastic material and has a Tg of 20 °C to 35 °C depending on the molecular weight [10]. It has very limited applications (used in golf ball covers and adhesives only). Polybutadiene and polyisobutylene both are rubbery but the former having a lower Tg (–80 °C) exhibits a higher degree of rebound resilience than the latter (Tg = –60 °C). Silicone has the lowest Tg (–120 °C) and its oligomer acts as a lubricant. 67
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials Glass transition temperature of a polymeric material is used to characterise polymers, polymer blends and their compatibility, block copolymers, degree of plasticisation, and extent of crosslinking in elastomer systems. Table 3.1 summarises the Tg of different rubbery materials.
Table 3.1 Glass transition temperatures (Tg) of some common rubbers and polymers* Name of Polymers Cis-Polyisoprene or natural rubber (NR) Polybutadiene (syndiotactic) (BR) Styrene butadiene rubber (SBR) Neoprene or chloroprene (CR) Ethylene propylene diene rubber (EPDM) Polyurethane rubber Butyl rubber (IIR) Epoxidised natural rubber (ENR) Silicone rubber Polyethylene Polypropylene (PP) Polycaprolactam (Nylon 6) Polystyrene (PS) Polyvinyl chloride (PVC) Polyacrylonitrile (PAN) Polymethyl acrylate Polyethyl acrylate Polybutyl acrylate Fluoro rubber (FKM) Fluoro silicone rubber (FVMQ) Acrylonitrile butadiene rubber (NBR)
Tg (°C) -75 to -70 -100 to -85 -65 to -50 -45 to -20 -60 to -55 -45 to -20 -70 to -65 -40 to -20 -125 to -120 -120 (linear) to -80 (branched) -19 to -8 50 to 57 100 83 (neat), -8 (40% plasticised) 105 (when moisture free) 9 to 0 -20 to -25 -63 to -55 -50 to -18 -70 -45 (low nitrile content) -34 (medium nitrile content) -20 (high nitrile content) Halogenated butyl rubber (BIIR or CIIR) -66 to -60 Chlorinated polyethylene (CM) -40 to -25 (depends on content of Cl) Chlorosulfonated polyethylene (CSM) -25 (depends on level of Cl and SO2) Polyepichlorohydrin (CO) -26 Polyacrylate rubber (ACM) -44 to -22 Ethylene acrylate rubber (EAM) -40 (depends on monomer ratio) Polyfluorophosphazene (PNF) -66 Polyethylene glycol -50 Ethylene vinyl acetate (EVA) copolymer -30 (depends on monomer ratio) *Tg depends on experimental condition e.g., rate of heating, reference used, atmosphere and thermal history, and morphology/microstructure of the polymer
68
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
3.2.3 Factors Affecting Tg Various factors that affect polymer chain mobility control the Tg. Those factors can be classified as follows: i)
Molecular weight,
ii) Molecular architecture, iii) Morphology, composition and thermal history, and iv) Degree of crosslinking. The following sections illustrate the effect of these factors on Tg for different elastomer systems.
3.2.4 Effect of Molecular Weight on Tg The physical characteristics of a polymer depend on its molecular weight. Monomers are generally gas or liquids. Oligomers are mostly liquid. In general, high molecular weight polymers are solid (often termed as super cooled liquid, if totally amorphous). Fox and Flory established a mathematical relationship between Tg and molecular weight (MW) as given in Equation 3.1 [11]: Tg Tg () (MW)1
(3.1)
()
where, Tg is the limiting Tg at infinite molecular weight and Kg is a constant, characteristic of the polymer.
3.2.4.1 Chain Length Effect Cowie and McEwen used DSC to measure the Tg of silicone oligomers and polymers [12]. The Tg values for silicones of different molecular weight are presented in Table 3.2. The Tg() and Kg values, obtained from Tg – MW-1 plot, correspond to 148 K and 5.9 x 103 K.g/mol, respectively. A similar trend in Tg and MW has also been found for glassy polymers such as PS [13], and a polysulfide [14]. Kow and coworkers investigated dependence of Tg of polyisoprene (IR) with MW [15]. Sometimes Tg – MW-1 plot for IR does not follow the Fox-Flory equation. This is due to the variation in proportion of 3,4-, cis-1,4 and trans-1,4 microstructures in IR.
69
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Table 3.2 Tg of polydimethylsiloxanes (PDMS) of varying chain length [12] Mn Tg ( °C) (± 1 °C)* 236 -150 540 -137 2400 -127 7700 -125 19000 -125 57000 -125 * Onset Tg data obtained using DuPont DSC 900 module at 10 °C /min heating rate Mn: number average molecular weight Reproduced with permission from J.M.G. Cowie and I.J. McEwen, Polymer, 1973, 14, 9, 423. ©1972, Elsevier
Table 3.3 Effect of end groups on the Tg of perfluoro oligomers E-CF2O[(CF2CF2O)p(CF2O)q]CF2-E [16] Degree of polymerisation = [p + q + 3], where p/q ~1
Tg ( °C) * of the polymers having end group -CH2OCH3 –CH2OSi(CH3)3 -CH2OH 9 -97.5 -127.8 -120.0 14 -107.0 -126.6 -121.6 24 -113.9 -124.2 -120.7 42 -117.9 -122.5 -121.3 * Measured by DSC (Mettler TA 3000) cooling scans from 35 to –175 °C at 10 °C/min Reproduced with permission from F. Danusso, M. Levi, G. Gianotti and S. Turri, Polymer, 1993, 34, 17, 3687. ©1993, Elsevier
3.2.4.2 End Group Effect Low MW polymers have a large number of end groups that have greater mobility compared to that of the molecular body. Thus, cohesive state of the system progressively loosens with decrease in chain length. This is true when body and end units are similar. For telechelic oligomers or telomers, however, the chemical dissimilarity of body and end units affects the trend. For example, oligomers of perfluorinated chain E-CF2O[(CF2CF2O)p(CF2O)q]CF2-E with two equal foreign end groups (E) show both increase and decrease in Tg with increase in MW depending on how dissimilar the end groups and body chain are [16]. The representative data for such cases are shown in Table 3.3. When the end groups are similar to the backbone chain, (i.e., when E is –OCF3 or –CH2OCH3), body and end groups have improved cohesion due to compatibility and hence display an increase in Tg with a rise in MW [17]. If the body and end groups significantly differ chemically, incompatibility causes sub-phase or phase separation. 70
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
3.2.4.3 Cyclic Polymers For cyclic polymers the dependence of Tg on MW is different from that of the linear polymers. Clarson and co-workers measured the Tg of cyclic and linear counterparts of polydimethylsiloxane PDMS and polyphenylmethylsixonaes (PPMS) [18-19]. Non-linear Tg – MW-1 dependence in cyclic PPMS suggested that ring structure, size and strain affects glass formation during cooling. The disparity in Tg – MW-1 plots of cyclic PDMS and cyclic PPMS was attributed to the manifestation of difference in molecular topology, i.e., replacement of the methyl group by a bulkier phenyl ring in the cyclic siloxanes.
3.2.4.4 Block-copolymers For elastomeric block copolymers of the A-B-A type, generally, a soft rubbery segment is connected to the hard segments in both ends. The segmental MW affects the Tg of the material. However, the segmental MW are less influential than the morphology of the phases and processing conditions to control the Tg. Ikeda and coworkers found that Tg of the hard phase in styrene-butadiene-styrene (SBS) block copolymer randomly varied between 95 °C to 105 °C with increase in MW [20].
3.2.5 Effect of Polymer Architecture on Tg 3.2.5.1 Linear Homopolymer As discussed in the previous section about the difference in Tg – MW-1 plots of cyclic PDMS and PPMS, it is clear that polymer chain architecture is a key factor to control the Tg. At a similar MW range linear PPMS displays higher Tg than that of the linear PDMS. The limiting Tg for PDMS and PPMS are –123 °C and –33 °C, respectively [18-19].
Presence of Polar Group
Incorporation of a polar group in a polymer chain, usually, increases Tg. Polyethylene (PE) displays a Tg at –120 °C. Replacement of hydrogen in the PE repeat unit by a methyl group (polypropylene) or a chlorine group (PVC) increases Tg to -20 °C or 83 °C, respectively. Due to the strong dipolar interaction, the Tg is very high in PVC. Acrylic rubber obtained from acrylic esters exhibits different a Tg range depending on the alkyl group present on the ester moiety. For example, if the alkyl groups are methyl, ethyl, propyl, and butyl, the Tg of the polymers are 0 °C, -23 °C, -51 °C and –63 °C, respectively [21].
71
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials Cis-trans Isomerism
Microstructure of the diene rubbers is very critical to control the physical properties. Cis-1,4-poybutadiene is amorphous and displays a Tg of –100 °C. However, the trans1,4-BR is crystalline and it melts in the temperature range of 40-60 °C [22]. The Tg of the trans-isomer is very indistinct by thermal analysis. Tg values depend on the degree of crystallinity present in the trans-1,4-BR. Cis-1,4-BR crystallises during stretching, like NR [23]. In the actual BR composition 1,2-BR segment also exists along with cisand trans-1,4 microstructure. With increase in 1,2 microstructure content in BR the Tg of the polymer increases and the polymer becomes semi-crystalline [24-26]. Table 3.4 displays the Tg of BR having different microstructure content. Like butadiene rubber, Tg of isoprene rubber also depends on the polymer microstructure. Onset of Tg for cis-1,4polyisoprene is -65 C. However, trans-1,4-polyisoprene exhibits onset of Tg at a higher temperature (-60 C) [27]. Presence of the 3,4-isomer increases the Tg of polyisoprene [27-28]. Polyisoprene containing 76% cis-1,4-; 16% trans-1,4-; and 8% 3,4- shows the lowest Tg (-63 C), whereas that containing 28% cis-1,4-; 12% trans-1,4-; 56% 3,4- and 4% 1,2- shows the highest Tg (-20 C). For a tyre tread formulation having excellent skid and rolling resistance, Tg of the base rubber is a critical factor. Thus, physical characteristics of the tailored base polymer (elastomer) with varied proportion of microstructure can be predicted from thermal analysis data.
Table 3.4 Tg of BR with different microstructures* Microstructurea 1,2-BR 1,4-cis 1,4-trans 6 41 53 8 36 56 17 35 48 35 27 38 52 21 27 56 15 29 65 12 23 78 9 13 90 3 7 * molecular weights (Mn) of the polymers are high 10,000-100,000 a 13 C-NMR data b DSC cooling @10 °C/min data [26] c DSC heating @10 °C/min data [25]
72
Tg (°C) -95.0 b -95.2 c -87.5 c -72.3 c -59.6 c -51.8 b -45.0 b -29.6 c -16.2 c
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials Tacticity
Tacticity of a polymer is also a critical factor that controls Tg. Hydrogenated 1,2-polybutadiene of atactic microstructure displayed a Tg onset at –28.8 °C. However, the syndiotactic counterpart at similar MW range exhibited slightly higher Tg (–24.9 °C) [29]. Hydrogenated 1,4-poly(2,3-dimethyl-1,3-butadiene) (H-PDMB) displayed lower Tg than that of its non-hydrogenated counterpart (PDMB: 74% trans, 23% cis and 3% 1,2 units) [30]. H-PDMB is completely amorphous elastomeric material that has a Tg 17 °C lower than that of the atactic head-to-tail polypropylene.
3.2.5.2 Random Copolymer The Tg of a random copolymer is an intermediate temperature between two Tg temperatures of the corresponding homopolymers. The following mathematical equations correlate Tg of a co-polymer with that of the homopolymers: (1) Gordon and Taylor Equation [31]: Tg
Tg A .w A K.Tg B .w B w A K.w B
(3.2)
where wA and wB are the weight fractions of the homopolymers, TgA and TgB are the Tg temperatures of the respective homopolymers, and TgB > TgA. K is the volume additivity parameter and defined as K = (l/2)( 2/ 1), where 1 and are the density and 1 and 2 are the change in coefficient of thermal expansion of two constituent polymers. (2) Couchman-Karasz Equation [32]: This equation considers that the copolymer is a statistical mixture of individual components. The equation is given as: TgB Tg w B C PB .ln Tg A ln
w A CPA w B C PB Tg A
(3.3)
(3) Fox Equation [33]: w w 1 A B Tg Tg A TgB
(3.4)
The Fox equation can be derived from Gordon-Taylor equation, considering the fact that Tg is constant for linear polymers and l/2 1 [34]. 73
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials Wood experimentally verified the Gordon-Taylor equation with different copolymer systems [35]. Penzel and co-workers also utilised DSC data of various copolymers to verify the Gordon-Taylor Equation [36]. De Sarkar and coworkers utilised DSC to measure the Tg of SBR rubbers having different styrene contents and found that the Tg of copolymers follows the GordonTaylor Equation [37]. The relationship between percentage styrene content and Tg of SBR is shown in Figure 3.2. Increase in styrene content linearly increases the Tg of the copolymer. However, refractometric Tg data of such compositions, published in the earlier original work, displayed deviation from linearity [38]. Figure 3.2 also shows the Tg of polyethylene-co-vinyl acetate EVA at different vinyl acetate content (wt%) and the Tg of polyacrylonitrile-butadiene (NBR) at different acrylonitrile contents. It is apparent that the data for EVA does not follow a linear equation, but both SBR and NBR follow a linear trendline [37, 39-40]. For epoxidised SBR, increase in epoxy content increases Tg of the SBR rubber. An SBR with 43% epoxy content displayed a Tg of -10 °C, when epoxy content was 68% the Tg was 2 °C [41]. Bhattacharjee and co-workers analysed EPDM produced by a slurry process at different ranges of ethylene content [42]. The Tg of the statistically random terpolymers at constant diene (ethylidene norbornene) level of ~5% increased with increase in ethylene content. At a very high level of ethylene content, the material turned semi-crystalline and displayed a melting endotherm. The physical properties and the
Figure 3.2 Relationship between percentage monomer content, (- -) styrene in SBR; (- -) vinyl acetate in EVA; (- -) acrylonitrile in NBR and the Tg of different copolymers. Tg values were measured using DSC at 10 °C/min for SBR [37], 20 °C/min for EVA [39] and 3.5 °C/min in modulated DSC mode for NBR [40]
74
-38 46 980
-57 48 702
-63 50 1000
-84
Hard segment wt(%) Soft segment Mn 1000
a
Polyurethane a
Polyimide b
Polyester a
PTMO
20 °C/min heating rate [48]
b
20 oC/min heating rate [49]
-
Hard segment
additive mixing characteristics of the polymer depend on the Tg of the terpolymer. It is desired that the Tg of the EPDM be low and the material be amorphous. Thus, DSC analysis provides an excellent tool for the characterisation of EPDM elastomers that are applicable at low temperature.
3.2.5.3 Block Copolymers
Soft segment Polymer type
Table 3.5 DSC Tg of PTMO segment in homopolymer and different block copolymers
Tg ( °C) of soft segment
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Diblock or triblock copolymers display a broader Tg of the segments than that of homopolymer segments. This is due to mixing of microphases [43] and also the rigidity imparted by the adjacent hard phases to the soft segments [44]. For a pom-pom shaped star polystyrene-block-polyisoprenestar polystyrene polymer [S4-I-S4] the Tg of isoprene (-40 C) is higher than that of S-I-S triblock copolymer (-49 C) or linear polyisoprene (-73 C). For uncoupled S4-I block copolymer the T g of isoprene segments is -57 C, which is simply due to more mobility of the openended isoprene chain [44]. Thermoplastic polyurethane elastomeric block copolymers of (A-B)n type consisting of siloxanes and urethane phases having 60/40soft/hard phase ratio displayed a Tg of siloxane phase at -97 °C. However, if the siloxane soft segment is block copolymerised with polytetramethylene oxide (PTMO) of MW 2000, the Tg is further lowered to –102 °C [45]. 75
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials For block copolymers, molecular structure of the adjacent hard segment affects the Tg of the specific soft segment. For example, let us consider thermoplastic elastomeric block copolymers based on common PTMO soft segment but different chemical structure of hard segments as shown in Table 3.5. All these samples had approximately similar soft segment molecular weight and hard phase content (wt%). Variation in soft segment structure keeping MW the same, also affects the Tg of the elastomers having similar hard phase structure [46-47].
3.2.6 Effect of Composition, Morphology and Thermal History on the Tg of Polymers
3.2.6.1 Composition and Morphology of Block Copolymers A block copolymer having two or more dissimilar homopolymer segments along the chain backbone segregate and form micro-phases. These polymers are mostly used as thermoplastic elastomers. A particular block copolymer elastomer can have different morphology depending on prior thermal history or annealing conditions. DSC offers a striking tool to characterise the morphology of such block components.
Figure 3.3 DSC scans of elastomeric PU block-copolymer taken after annealing at 170 °C for 5 minutes, followed by post annealing at room temperature for different period: (1) non-annealed a control; (2) 5 minutes after annealing; (3) 20 minutes after annealing; (4) 2 hour after annealing; (5) 7 days after annealing [50] Reproduced with permission from Journal of Applied Physics, 1975, 46, 4148. ©1975, American Institute of Physics
76
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials Block copolymers of hard and soft segments at room temperature display a Tg of the soft segments at equilibrium phase morphology. At this condition the soft segments exists in extended form. With increase in temperature, during annealing, relaxation of soft segment (extended to coiled form) pulls out hard phase segments and causes phase mixing. As a result Tg of the soft phase increases. After annealing, however, quenched annealed samples show time dependent phase separation and display gradual decrease in Tg [47, 50]. Figure 3.3 shows a DSC scans of elastomeric polyurethane before and after annealing at 170 °C. The Tg of the block copolymer also depends on the composition (ratio of hard and soft segment masses). Increase in the hard phase content usually increases the Tg of the soft phases. Compression moulded polyether esters (similar structure to that shown in Table 3.5) having hard phase content (wt%) 33, 57, and 84 display Tg of –68 °C, -55 °C, and –9 °C, respectively [51]. A similar trend was observed with multiblock poly(ether-ester-amides).
3.2.6.2 Rubbery Blends Plasticised thermoplastics can act as melt-processible rubber. For this purpose a plasticiser or a rubber is usually blended with thermoplastics. In these cases, phase morphology affects the physical characteristics of the material. DSC is used to measure the Tg of a blend’s components. If Tg of the components in the blend does not alter, then the blend is incompatible. However, if the Tg of the polymer having a lower Tg is increased and that of the high Tg polymer is lowered, the blend is compatible. The extent of shortening the Tg interval is a measure of the degree of compatibility. If both the Tg merge, the blend is miscible. Characterisation of different miscible and immiscible rubbery blends using various thermal analysis tools are reviewed elsewhere in this book.
Miscible and Partially Miscible Blends
A simple example of a blend could be plasticised thermoplastics. Plasticisers enhance segmental mobility of the plastics and lower the Tg of the plastics. For example, PVC is not processable without plasticisers. Depending on the loading of plasticiser the material behaves as plastic, leathery or rubbery. Brennan studied the effect of plasticisation of PVC using DSC [52]. The Tg of the PVC phases at different dosage of di(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (DOP) decreased from 95 C (for PVC without DOP). For example, PVC containing 50% loading of DOP exhibits a Tg of -51 C [52]. Tg of hydrocarbon blends used in pressure sensitive adhesives is very critical for the performance of products. The Gordon-Taylor equation (Equation 3.2) was found to be useful to predict the desired composition of the pressure sensitive adhesive for practical usage [53]. Ethylene-propylene rubber mixed with N-hexane displayed reduced Tg of the extended rubber [54]. 77
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials Wang and Cooper reported the DSC analysis of the blends of PVC and acrylonitrilebutadiene rubber (NBR). It was observed that the miscibility or compatibility criteria depends on the acrylonitrile content in NBR [55]. An NBR with 31% acrylonitrile (NBR31) was miscible with rigid PVC. DSC scans of such blends are displayed in Figure 3.4a. Blends displayed a single Tg between –27 °C (Tg of NBR31) and 84 °C (Tg of PVC). However, blends of NBR with 44% acrylonitrile content (NBR44) exhibit partial miscibility with PVC. DSC traces of these blends are shown in Figure 3.4b. The reason for the immiscibility of the NBR44 and PVC is likely to be the strong dipolar interaction between acrylonitrile and the PVC segments, which excludes the mixed phase from the butadiene rubbery phases. Manoj and co-workers investigated similar miscible blends of PVC and NBR and observed that the properties of such miscible blends improve if sufficiently melt-mixed over longer period [56]. Increase in rheological torque with time at high temperature and insolubility (swelling) in solvents of melt-mixed blends indicated crosslinking, which was further supported by spectroscopic measurements. Authors termed such polyblends as self-crosslinkable rubber blends. Pruneda and coworkers recently reported the thermal characterisation of such blends [57]. Addition of tribasic lead sulfate, as stabiliser, in PVC based rubbery blends plays a crucial role in the morphology. Stabilised PVC is miscible with epoxidised NR containing
Figure 3.4 DSC scans of various NBR-PVC blend compositions for NBR with (a) 31% acrylonitrile content and (b) 44% acrylonitrile content: (1) neat NBR; (2) NBR/PVC, 75/25; (3) NBR/PVC 50/50; (4) NBR/PVC, 25/75; (5) neat PVC [55] Reproduced with permission from C.B. Wang and S.L. Cooper, Journal of Polymer Science: Polymer Physics Edition, 1983, 21, 1, 11. ©1983, John Wiley and Sons
78
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials 50 mol% epoxy group (ENR-50) [58, 59]. However, the non-stabilised blend appears immiscible [60]. Immiscible blends exhibit interfacial crosslinking during thermal annealing. Miscible blends based on stabilised PVC cannot crosslink and such blends are soluble in tetragydrofuran (THF). Addition of carboxylated nitrile rubber (XNBR) in the immiscible ENR-50/PVC blend composition, at a critical loading, makes the blend miscible, which is self-crosslinkable too. A blend consisting of 1:2 ENR-50 and XNBR is miscible and self-crosslinkable [61]. Addition of intermediate super abrasive carbon black enhances self-crosslinking behaviour without affecting the miscibility criterion [62]. Examples of other miscible and self-crosslinkable blends are Hypalon/XNBR [63], ENR/Hypalon [64], and CR/ XNBR/ENR [65]. The blend of CR and ENR-50 was partially miscible and addition of XNBR made the blend miscible [66]. Roland and co-workers have reported that CR epoxidised polyisoprene with 25 mol% epoxy group blends (EPI-25) were miscible and displayed a single Tg depending on the composition, within a temperature ranging from –44 °C to –42 °C [67] and the relaxation time of EPI segments became shorter in the blends [68]. Hypalon/ENR blends were miscible at lower epoxy content (25 mol%) in ENR rubber at all blend ratios. However, the blends of Hypalon with ENR having higher epoxy level (50 mol%) appeared immiscible when ENR content was low [69]. Hydrogenated NBR/PVC blends were miscible [70-71]. Blends of cis-1,4-IR and atactic 1,2-BR are always miscible [72]. Interaction parameters for miscible blends of cis-1,4-IR and 1,2-BR is more when the latter is syndiotactic [73]. DSC scans of miscible blends of IR and 1,2-BR are shown in Figure 3.5. At higher IR contents the Tg shifts to a higher temperature and the crystallinity in the 1,2-BR segments diminishes. Yamada and Funayama investigated the miscibility of IR and a copolymer of cis-1,4-BR and 1,2-BR [74]. Blends of BR and SBR are partially miscible [75-76]. Several authors reported single broad Tg of the SBR/BR blend vulcanisates [76-77]. A broad Tg that was observed in a 60/40 SBR/BR blend actually consisted of two Tg, as indicated in a differential heat flow curve [78]. This indicates incomplete homogenisation of the blend. Hourston and Song measured the interface content in an SBR/BR partially miscible blend using modulated DSC data from blend and unmixed samples in the same proportion in the DSC pan [79]. Figure 3.6 shows the glass transition behaviour of the polyblend and a non-blended physical mixture of 50/50 SBR/BR. Overlapped transition in the blend indicates partial miscibility of SBR and BR. Analysis showed that with increasing styrene content in SBR of SBR-BR blends, the amount of interfacial mix is decreased [79]. Poly(ethylene oxide) and EVA are miscible at all compositions in the amorphous phase [80]. Similarly FKM and ACM also form a miscible elastomeric blend [81]. Addition of a polyacrylate plastic phase to the miscible binary FKM/ACM blend produced thermoplastic 79
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 3.5 Representative DSC thermograms of blends of 1,2-BR and IR at different volume fractions of IR: (1) 0%; (2) 10%; (3) 25%; and (4) 40% [72] Reproduced with permission from C.M. Roland, Macromolecules, 1987, 20, 10, 2557. 1987, American Chemical Society
Figure 3.6 dCP/dT versus temperature plots for the SBR–BR (50:50 by weight) processed blend (- - -) and the granular mix ( ) placed in a DSC sample holder [79] Reproduced with permission from D.J. Hourston and M. Song, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 2000, 76, 12, 1791. ©2000, John Wiley and Sons
80
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials elastomeric (TPE) blend, which is (i) processable like thermoplastics and (ii) elastic like crosslinked rubber. In such blends, however, immiscibility of the rubber and plastic phases are desired. For improved properties of such blends the interaction at the interphase should be high. For a miscible blend, however, a single Tg is observed. Thus, DSC offers a measurement of compatibility of such blend components by the measurement of Tg. Coran and co-workers studied extensively and developed TPE formulations based on different rubber plastic blends using dynamic vulcanisation technique [82-83]. Choudhury and co-workers studied the compatibility of NR/PP blends using DSC. Increase in Tg of NR phase after dynamic vulcanisation of the blend in comparison to that of the neat NR indicated compatibilisation [84]. DSC was used to characterise dynamically vulcanised thermoplastic elastomeric blends of PP/oil extended EPDM [85] and SAN/NBR [86]. Tg of semi-crystalline plastic phases such as PP, PE is very difficult to detect in DSC but here DSC scans are used to detect the melting transition of such blends. Phase morphology of thermoplastic elastomeric rubber-plastic blends based on recycled rubbers are also characterised by DSC and other thermal analysis tools [86]. DSC was used to study the compatibility or partial miscibility of the following rubberplastic blends: Santoprene/Nylon 66 [87], epoxy resin/styrene-butadiene block copolymer [88], polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA)/polyvinyl acetate (PVAc) [89], S-I-S/PPO [89], PMMA/CO blends [90], ENR-50/PE-co-acrylic acid) [91], ENR/ethylene-methyl acrylate copolymer [92].
Immiscible Blends
Different rubber blends are used in many applications because of technological requirements. For example, in tyre formulations, blends of NR, SBR, BR, IIR, and EPDM are used because of specific properties of each component. BR has excellent wear resistance but poor tear resistance. NR has excellent tear resistance but moderate wear resistance. SBR exhibits very good road holding characteristics in comparison to NR and BR. IIR and EPDM show excellent ageing resistance [93]. Blends of all the combinations are not always compatible, although filler loaded co-vulcanised blends are used in actual applications. Thermal analysis provides an excellent tool to determine the optimum level of homogeneity that can be reached in such blends by appropriate mixing conditions. NBR/EPDM blends are incompatible blends. However, addition of chlorinated PE or Hypalon at the 5 wt% level was found to be effective for compatibilisation of the system [94]. NBR/linear low-density PE incompatible blends were also compatibilised by gamma irradiation [95]. Bair and coworkers studied the blend of PVC and acrylonitrilebutadiene-styrene terpolymer (ABS) and found that the blends are incompatible [96]. Yehia and co-workers suggested that measurement of Cp for Tg of each phase at different blend ratios could indicate incompatibility of the blends [97]. This technique showed incompatibility of NR-BR, NR-NBR, and CR-NBR blends. Typical DSC scans showing 81
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials variation of Cp with temperature for NR/BR blends are shown in Figure 3.7. Several authors described incompatibility of different blend systems, earlier, using DSC; such blends are NR-BR [75-76], SBR-NR [75-76], SBR-IR [75, 98], NR-ENR [99], BR-SBR with high styrene content [79], NBR-NR [75], NR-acrylic rubber [100], NR-CR [101], and ENR50-cis-1,4-BR [102], to name a few. PS-BR blends are immiscible but BR-SBS or PS-SBS blends are compatible. The Tg of compatible blends follows the Couchman equation (Equation 2.3) [103]. Chlorobutyl rubber and carboxylated NBR are immiscible but self-vulcanisable as detected by DSC and DMA [104]. CR and EPDM produce incompatible blends. However, replacement of neat EPDM by dibutyl maleate grafted EPDM (DBM-g-EPDM) or CM narrowed down the breadth of Tg indicating compatibilisation of the blend [105]. The shifting in Tg towards each other as observed from the DSC traces, shown in Figure 3.8, proves that addition of 5-10% of DBM-g-EPDM or CM are effective in making the CR/EPDM blends technologically compatible. The DSC scans of neat components, incompatible and compatible blends are also displayed in Figure 3.8. Poly(3-hydroxybutyrate), a biopolymer, is incompatible with ENR-50. However, they react during high temperature annealing (190 °C) and form a mixed phase [106]. PU elastomer is immiscible with silicone rubber. However, grafting of vinyl triacetoxy silane onto urethane rubber made a compatible blend with silicones [107]. Many technologically compatibilised blends such as, PVC/polyether-ester elastomer blends [108], EPM/Hypalon blends [109], CR/polyacryamide blends [110] and SBS/asphalt mixes [111] were reported by various authors.
Interpenetrating Polymer Network
Another way of developing technologically important polyalloys is the formation of interpenetrating polymer network (IPN). In such cases, components mostly form separated phases with little compatibility. In the immiscible IPN two distinct Tg could be identified. A very broad Tg indicating partial miscibility was reported by Hermant and co-workers in a system based on PU-PMMA [112]. Various other authors also characterised semi-compatible IPN based on PU/methacrylates using DSC [113-114]. PU-based semi-IPN with polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) displayed the Tg for PU phase and two Tg for PVP phase in the DSC scans [115]. Incomplete phase separation was believed to be the cause for two Tg for the PVP phase. Incompatible IPN based on thermoplastic PU (TPU) and cis-polyisoprene was developed for improved mechanical properties [116]. DSC analysis was shown to be useful for the characterisation of morphology of IPN based on polysiloxane-polytetrafluoroethylene [117], PDMS/PS [118], PDMS/polyacrylate (PAC) matrix with polymethacrylate (PMAC) [119], NBR/EVA [120], and PU/PAN [121] systems. 82
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 3.7 Temperature dependence of the heat capacity, Cp of (1) pure BR; (5) pure NR; and their blends (2) NR/BR, 25/75; (3) NR/BR, 50/50; (4) NR/BR, 75/25 [97] Reproduced with permission from A.A. Yehia, A.A. Monsour and B. Stoll, Journal of Thermal Analysis, 1997, 48, 1299. ©1997, Springer Publishers
Figure 3.8 DSC curves of control CR, EPDM and their blends, showing shift of Tg towards each other for compatibilised systems: (1), CR; (2), EPDM; (3), CR/EPDM or CR/DBM-g-EPDM blends; (4), CR/EPDM/DBM-g-EPDM compatibilised blends; (5), CR/ EPDM/CM compatible blends [105] Reproduced with permission from A.K. Kalidaha, P.P. De, A.S. Bhattacharyya and A.K. Sen, Angewandte Makromolekulare Chemie, 1993, 204, 1, 19. ©1993, Wiley-VCH
83
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials Ionomeric Polyblends
A polymer containing ionic group is called an ionomer. Ionically terminated ends of two immiscible polymers when mixed form a technologically compatible polyblend [122]. Grafting potential ionomeric short chains onto two incompatible polymers also makes compatible ionomers. The physical properties of such blends are superior to those of the non-ionomeric blends because of the ion-ion interaction in the blend. Ionomeric polyblends exhibit various morphologies and hence properties depending on the processing and/or thermodynamic conditions. Thermal analysis is one of the tools that characterise the morphology of such materials. In an ionomer, non-polar polymeric chains exhibit their own Tg along with new Tg of restricted polymeric segments bound with micro-phase separated ionic domains [123-124]. As shown in Figure 3.9, Mandal and co-workers found that ionomeric polyblends based on XNBR/zinc oxide/stearic acid/zinc-stearate exhibited two T g, one at –19 °C due to XNBR and the other at +34 °C due to the restricted segment of XNBR associated with an ionic cluster. At low temperatures zinc-stearate strengthens the ionomer formation in the XNBR-ZnO system and at high temperature it functions as an ionic domain plasticiser [125]. Several other ionomeric blends were characterised using thermal analysis tools. These are zinc salts of sulfonated EPDM [126-127], blends
Figure 3.9 DSC thermograms of XNBR/ZnO/stearic acid/Zn-stearate system. 100/12/2/0 ( ); 100/12/2/15 (----); 100/12/2/30 ( - ), 100/12/2/60 ( ~ ); zinc stearate ( - - ) [125] Reproduced with permission from U.K. Mondal, D.K. Tripathy and S.K. De, Polymer Engineering Science, 1996, 36, 2, 285. ©1996, John Wiley and Sons
84
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials of EPDM/Na-salt of poly(ethyl-co-acrylic acid) (Surlyn) [128], SBS block copolymer/ polyacrylamide blend compatibilised with sodium salt of maleic anhydride grafted SBS [129], ionomeric PS-PIB-PS triblock copolymer-silicate nanocomposite containing sulfonated PS segments based on benzyltrimethylammonium [130] or sodium salts [131] prepared by the sol-gel method, and statistical polymethacrylate comb copolymers with tail-end 4-(dimethylamino) pyridinium mesogen ionic groups synthesised by partial quaternisation of high molar mass poly(12-bromododecyl methacrylate) [132].
3.2.6.3 Filled Elastomers For the reinforcement of elastomers or elastomer blends carbon black is used extensively. Kenny and co-workers observed that the Tg of a neat NR and carbon black filled NR did not differ significantly [133], indicating loose binding of rubber on the filler particles. Mansencal (and co-workers) characterised different polybutadiene rubbers having different microstructure (1,2-PB content) but having constant (33.3%) loading of super abrasion furnace (SAF) black [134]. It was observed that Tg of the gum, filled and bound rubber (residue after solvent extraction of filled rubber) remained almost same. However, DSC data revealed that normalised Cp values associated with Tg for each bound rubber sample was always less than that of the gum and filled samples. This indicated that part of the bound rubber was not detected by the DSC for the response of the Tg, i.e., part of the bound rubber displayed reduced mobility. The observation was very significant when 1,2-PB content was very high or the original chain flexibility was a little reduced. Essawy and El-Nashar observed that montmorillonite filler acts as compatibilising agent for the vulcanisate blends of SBR and NBR [135]. Tg of both the components increased slightly after addition of montmorillonite clay, indicating a specific interaction between the clay and rubber components. DSC analysis of TPU filled with mica, revealed that with increase in mica loading the Tg of the TPU soft segment significantly increased, but that of the hard segment remained almost unchanged [136].
3.2.7 Effect of Crosslinking of Rubbers on Tg It is well known that crosslinking of polymer chains increases the Tg [137-138]. Crosslinking of cis-1,4-BR to a higher degree increased the Tg of the rubber from –103 °C to –96 °C [139]. Cook and co-workers investigated variation in Tg of various rubber vulcanisates at different crosslinking densities using DSC and NMR spectroscopy [140]. The Tg versus crosslinking density data followed a linear regression. The NR and BR vulcanisates display similar Tg versus crosslinking density plot, but the increase in Tg of SBR with crosslink density was much greater than that of the NR or BR.
85
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
3.2.8 Monitoring Vulcanisation of Rubber Using DSC Kinetic study of the vulcanisation process for compounded rubbers provide an elastomer technologist with valuable information such as optimum temperature and time for curing, activation energy, kinetic order and frequency factor of the vulcanisation reaction. Usually, cure monitoring of rubber is performed using a rheometer to measure the torque required to shear a specimen undergoing curing process at elevated temperature. Since crosslinking reactions are exothermic, i.e., the reactions are accompanied by a measurable heat effect, DSC can be used to monitor the curing reaction of thermosets. Different methods that are used for the cure characterisation of rubber using DSC are i)
Borchardt and Daniels method [141],
ii) ASTM E698 method [142, 143A] and iii) Isothermal method [144, 145]. Borchardt and Daniel method was developed to calculate kinetic parameters from the area of a DTA or DSC curve. The method mainly assumes that the curing reaction essentially completes before the highest temperature is reached in a dynamic DSC scan and the rate of reaction is very small at the lowest temperature [141]. The method also assumes that there is no mass loss during the reaction and it follows nth order kinetics. Therefore, the rate equation can be expressed as: d k(T)(1 )n dt
(3.5)
where, = the fractional conversion usually obtained from fractional area under the DSC curve; k(T) = the specific rate constant at temperature T and that presumably follows the Arrhenius equation [i.e., k(T) = A.e-E/RT , where, A is frequency factor, E is the activation energy and R is the universal gas constant] and n = order of the reaction. Brazier and Schwartz used this method to calculate apparent activation energies for dicumyl peroxide (DCP) curing of elastomers [146]. The enthalpy of curing followed the order: BR> SBR ~ NBR (34% ACN) > NBR (27% ACN) > NR> EPDM ~EPM. Jana and co-workers used the same method for characterisation of DCP curing of low-density polyethylene (LDPE) - silicone rubber blends [147]. Incorporation of LDPE in silicone rubber increased the activation energy of vulcanisation. Peroxide curing of PE-co-methyl acrylate-silicone, and EVA-EPDM blends was also investigated using similar methodology [148, 149]. DCP curing of rubber was found to be mostly first order reaction [147-149]. Brazier and co-workers reported a drawback of DSC measurements of curing kinetics of rubbers indicating several parallel exothermic reactions such as formation of noncrosslinking sulfidic products, and maturation or 86
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials subsequent polysulfide reactions were taking place [150]. Rheometric measurement of kinetics appeared to be more accurate as the rheometer responds only to crosslinking and chain scission reactions [151]. An advantage of DSC cure monitoring of rubber is the unique exotherm patterns (‘fingerprint’) for different cure systems [152]. Manna and co-workers investigated exothermic crosslinking of ENR by ISAF carbon black in the presence of silane coupling agent using DSC [153]. Usually the Borchardt and Daniel method is not applicable in any of the following: (i) overlapping reaction peaks, (ii) decomposition occurring during curing, and (iii) autocatalytic reactions. To overcome limitations of Borchardt and Daniel method ASTM E698 method [142, A] was developed based on the Ozawa method of studying kinetics using DSC [143]. Again the Ozawa method is a modified form of Kissinger’s method. According to Kissinger’s method [154], it is assumed that the reaction rate varies with temperature, and at the temperature corresponding to the DSC exotherm maximum (Tm) the rate of reaction is the maximum. Lee and co-workers studied the curing kinetics of rubber modified epoxy resin using both the Kissinger and the Ozawa (isoconversional) methods [155]. Chough and Chang measured the kinetics of sulfur vulcanisation of NR, BR and SBR using the Ozawa method [156]. It was observed that the overall rate of vulcanisation followed the order: SBR>BR>NR. Vulcanisation kinetics of octadecyl amine modified clay-NR nanocomposite indicated influence of modified clay to lower the activation energy of vulcanisation [157]. Ginic-Markovic and co-workers utilised the modulated DSC kinetics results to match the curing characteristics of automotive seals based on EPDM rubber and PU coating for enhanced adhesion between rubber and coatings [158]. Crane and co-workers used both differential-integral analysis of a single dynamic DSC data and multiple scan at different scan rate method to obtain E, n and heat of crosslinking of adhesives [159]. Hayes and Seferis studied curing and high temperature degradation kinetics of epoxy using the Ozawa method [160]. Isothermal curing can be modeled as nth order kinetics as expressed in Equation 3.5. Another model includes autocatalytic curing reaction and the rate equation is expressed as: d k(T) m (1 )n dt
(3.6)
Isothermal curing of silicone elastomers applicable in electronics was found to be Arrhenius type with strong temperature dependence [161]. The kinetic data was useful to solve surface contamination of the product due to deposition of the nonvolatile fraction of uncrosslinked material. Deng and Isayev applied isothermal rubber curing kinetic data at different temperatures to estimate state of curing of rubbers in an injection mould and a compressive press using a nonisothermal model [162, 163]. A modified rate equation, as expressed next, for the isothermal curing of thermoset is also useful for the estimation of kinetic parameters [164, 165]: 87
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials d (k1 k2 m )(1 )n dt
(3.7)
Keenan validated Equation 3.7 for autocatalytic curing of epoxy adhesives by DSC measurement [166]. The autocatalytic model for cure characterisation of fluororubberclay [167] and NBR-clay [168] nanocomposite was found to be in good agreement with experimental data. Cure kinetic data differed for the composites based on chemically modified and unmodified clay.
3.2.9 Characterisation of Melting and Crystallisation of Polymer Semi-crystalline polymers have a distribution of crystal size in their morphology. Hence, during DSC heating scans, such polymers display a melting endotherm over a broad range of temperatures. The temperature corresponding to the peak of the melting endotherm is termed as the melting point. Characterisation of melting behaviour of polymers is important for predicting the structure and its correlation to the properties. After melting transition in a dynamic DSC, if molten polymer is cooled back at a programmed cooling rate, the melt crystallises and a crystalline exotherm is observed. From a DSC scan, melting point, crystallisation temperature, heat of fusion and heat of crystallisation of the polymers can be estimated. In the cases of binary mixtures, usually the melting point of the polymer matrix is lowered by the diluent. The melting point depression can be expressed by the Flory equation as shown next [169]: 1 1 0 Tm Tm BV R V2 [1 1 1 ] Hu V1 1 R Tm
(3.8)
where, Tm0 and Tm are the melting point of pure and diluted polymers, 1 is the volume V2 fraction of diluent, V is the ratio of molar volume of polymer repeat unit and diluent, 1 Hu is the heat of fusion per repeat unit of polymer, B is the interaction energy density for the system, and R the gas constant. A plot of (1/Tm -1/Tm0)/ 1 versus 1/Tm gives the true heat of fusion and the interaction energy density for the system. Heat of fusion is calculated from a melting endotherm by integrating the area under the curve using a proper baseline. The DSC unit should be calibrated with indium, tin or zinc, whose melting point and heat of fusion are known. From the measured heat of fusion ( Hf), % crystallinity in the polymer can be estimated using following relationship: 100.
88
H f H 0
(3.9)
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials where, H0 indicates the theoretical heat of fusion for a 100% crystalline polymer. The reference H0 values are established and can be obtained from literature or polymer handbook [170]. Molecular structure, MW, thermal history and composition are key factors that affect the melting characteristics of polymers. Other than the thermoplastic semi-crystalline materials a few classes of rubbery materials such as thermoplastic elastomers (rubber/plastic blend, block copolymers), and linear rubber molecules (BR, IR, NR, PDMS, CR) display crystallinity.
3.2.9.1 Melting and Crystallisation of Flexible Chain Rubbers Molecular architecture, morphology, composition, and presence of foreign matter are the different factors that affect crystallisation and melting behaviour of elastomeric materials. It has been shown that the green strength of NR is higher than that of the other synthetic rubbers at room temperature. The reason for that is the strain-induced crystallisation of NR at the ambient testing condition [171-173]. NR being of 100% cis-polyisoprene undergoes crystallisation due to orientation of polymer chains during stretching. Generally the crystallisability of the synthetic cis-polyisoprene rubbers correlates with the average cis sequence lengths of the polymer main chain [174]. Decrease in average cis sequence length decreased the heat of fusion of the crystallised samples. Strain induced crystallisation of cis1,4-polybutadiene [175-177], polyisobutylene [178, 179], EPDM [180], and polychloroprene [181, 182] are also well known. Degree of crystallisation obtained by stretching follows the order BR
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Table 3.6 Melting transition temperatures of different rubbers Rubber Cis-1,4-IR (natural rubber) Cis-1,4-IR (synthetic rubber) Trans-1,4-IR (natural) (Gutta percha) Trans-1,4-IR (synthetic) Cis-1,4-BR Trans-1,4-BR IIR CR EPR PDMS
Tm (°C) * (-12, 2) a (-20, 10) b 1 (-16, 13) b 2 30 10 c (-10, 1) a (-7, 2) a (58, 67) b 3 52 a (60-67, 50-55) a 60-65 a 3 a , 13 d 150 a 129-142 e 15 f 42-47 a 47 -45 g -40 a
Reference [186] [191] [23] [192-193] [4] [191] [194] [195] [196] [23] [194] [197] [179] [4] [42, 198] [199] [18]
* Two melting peaks observed in IR does not represent metamorphic crystals rather similar crystals of different lamellar sizes [3] a DSC, 10 °C/min b DSC, 0.3 °C/min: (b 1, stored at –25 °C for 6 months, b 2, crystallised at –25 °C for 16 h, b 3, crystallised at 54 °C) c Partially crosslinked samples stretched up to 200% after crystallising at -25 °C, DSC, 10 °C/min d Crosslinked samples stretched up to 200% after crystallising at -6 °C, DSC, 10 °C/min e Dilute solution grown crystals, DSC 20 °C/min f Stress-strain-temperature measurement (non DSC data) g DSC, 6 °C/min
copolymer [200]. High ethylene content EPDM rubber exhibits more strain-induced crystallisation [180]. It can be noted that the melting transition of EPR occurs at a temperature far lower than that of the PE. The morphology of the EPR is also influenced by the catalyst system used to produce EPR. Silicone (PDMS) elastomers show a melting transition at a temperature ranging from –40 °C to –45 °C [18, 199]. Maxwell and coworkers reported cold crystallisation of PDMS around –60 °C [201].
3.2.9.2 Transitions in Liquid Crystalline Elastomers Liquid crystalline elastomers that are lightly crosslinked molecules containing rigidrod, mesogenic moieties either in main backbone or side chains, display special optical, mechanical and piezoelectric properties. Other than polarised microscopy and x-ray scattering, DSC thermal analysis also provides a tool for characterisation 90
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials of liquid crystalline behaviour of the elastomers. Smectic liquid crystalline elastomers generally display four transition zones in their DSC thermograms. The first zone is the glassy smectic region, which changes to soft smectic phase during heating through a baseline shift in the thermogram. Further heating registers a tiny endotherm indicating transformation of smectic to nematic form. Continued heating makes the material isotropic through an endothermic transition [202]. Sometimes the smectic to nematic and nematic to isotropic transitions are indistinguishable. Transition temperatures depend on the structure of the polymers. Figure 3.10 shows the DSC traces of side chain polyisoprene liquid crystalline block copolymers [203]. PI blocks containing 34% 1,2 addition, 59% 3,4- addition and 7% 1,4-addition microstructures were first hydroxylated via hydroboration/oxidation reaction. A liquid crystalline monomer 6-[(4-cyano-4´-biphenyl)oxy]hexanoic acid (5CNCOOH) was grafted onto the hydroxylated PI producing side chain liquid crystalline PI. Incorporation of rigid mesogens increases the Tg of elastomers. The endotherm in each trace indicates clearing temperature (Ti, anisotropic to isotropic transition). The higher the content of grafted liquid crystalline monomers, the higher is the clearing temperature. Saenger and Gronski modified polybutadiene and SBS block copolymers by attaching similar side chain liquid crystalline mesogens (5CN-COOH) having an aliphatic chain
Figure 3.10 DSC traces of (1) polyisoprene (Mn = 3600 g/mol) and liquid crystalline derivatives of the same polyisoprene containing different levels of grafted 6-[(4-cyano-4´biphenyl)oxy]hexanoic acid: (2) 5%; (3) 50%; (4) 80%; (5) 100% during second heating scan at 20 °C/min [203] Reproduced with permission from K.M. Lee and C.D. Han, Macromolecules, 2002, 35, 8, 3145. ©2002, American Chemical Society
91
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials as soft spacer to the hydroxylated butadiene segments [204]. Other than the clearing transition (Ti) it was also observed that an endothermic transition, which is heating rate (annealing) dependent, appeared at an intermediate temperature between Tg and Ti. During the cooling cycle, however, a corresponding exotherm to the previous enthalpy relaxation could not be detected due to supercooling. Such a monotropic behaviour is common to many other liquid crystalline polymers [205]. Zhang and co-workers synthesised liquid crystalline elastomers based on silicones containing rigid mesogens as crosslinker and side chains [206]. The polymers exhibited a melting transition due to aliphatic long chains in the crosslinkers and a tiny liquid crystalline-isotropic transition. The transitions overlap and form a broad endotherm at a high level of crosslinking mesogen content. Further increase in crosslinking mesogen content causes disappearance of mesophase behaviour due to the ‘inhibiting effect of high crosslinking on the liquid crystalline order’ [207]. Main chain liquid crystalline, segmented PU elastomers are high performance materials. Morphological characterisation of such materials has been extensively studied using DSC [208]. Liquid crystalline phases of different thermodynamic stability in those PU materials have been detected. The heat of isotropisation depends on the molecular architecture of the liquid crystalline elastomers. The presence of higher mole fraction of soft segment spacer decreases the heat of isotropisation. It has been established that the mesophase formation through microphase separation is both thermodynamically and kinetically controlled phenomenon. At higher annealing temperature (below the Ti) it takes longer time to develop mesophase, conversely, at a lower annealing temperature it takes a shorter time to develop the mesophases. Thermotropic liquid crystalline elastomers of polyester [209] and polyester-amide [210] types have also been characterised by thermal analysis. Mesophase formation in such materials depends on the structure of the hard phase and hard to soft segment ratio.
3.2.9.3 Melting and Crystallisation in Filled and Blended Elastomers Presence of impurity or foreign matter influences crystallisation of rubbery materials. Addition of trans-PI in cis-PI enhances strain-induced crystallisation of the latter [211]. Trans-PI acts as a nucleating agent for cis-PI. Addition of carbon black initially lowers the rate of crystallisation of NR but at high filler loading the rate of crystallisation increases [212]. Crystallisation temperatures of rubbers usually increase with increase in carbon black loading. Addition of black increases the extent of shear and hence molecular alignment during the mixing process. This causes ready nucleation during cooling scans of the samples. In a study by Lee and Singleton, SBR/BR 80/20 blend was mixed with carbon black (20 phr) for different durations and the compounds were then analysed thermally [213]. As shown in Figure 3.11, it was observed that with increase in mixing time the crystallisation exotherm and the melting endotherm 92
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 3.11 DSC scans of a filled rubber blend containing 80 parts SBR, 20 parts BR, and 20 phr carbon black blends as a function of mixing time: (a) 0.5 min, (b) 1.1 min, (c) 3.2 min and (d) 8.7 min. These blends were prepared by a free black mixing process [213] Reproduced with permission from B-L. Lee and C. Singleton, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1979, 24, 10, 2169. ©1979, John Wiley and Sons
of BR phase was significantly reduced. Increase in mixing time caused enhanced immobilisation of BR molecules on black surface (formation of bound rubber) and improved interfacial mixing of SBR and BR phases. Therefore, less BR remained available for crystallisation and subsequent melting. SBR/BR blends at certain black loading and different mixing times could have differential filler distribution in two phases. The DSC scans displaying decrease in heat of fusion of BR with increase in mixing time also indicated migration of filler from SBR to BR, and the results were verified by electron microscopy [213]. Measurement of crystallisation temperatures of IR/BR blends was shown to be a useful technique to quantify dispersion of carbon black in the polymeric phases [214]. DSC analysis could detect the difference in the polymer dispersion in NR/IR blends, by measuring the crystallisation behaviour of the compounds [215]. Crystallisation of NR was more adversely affected by addition of IR than the addition of carbon black. Addition of 20 phr IR caused 80% reduction in the heat of fusion of the polymer. 93
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials In situ formation of nano-silica in semicrystalline trans-polybutadiene reduced the rate of hexagonal crystallisation of the matrix [216]. Crosslinking of rubber lowers cold crystallisation of polybutadiene [190]. In an attempt to develop thermo-reversible crosslinking in polybutadiene, the rubber was first hydrochlorinated via epoxydation and then a sulfonyl isocyanate derivative was added to incorporate hydrogen bonding in the system [217]. The modified rubber displayed excellent improvement in mechanical properties. The cold crystallisability of the rubber gradually diminished with increase in degree of such modification. PP based thermoplastic elastomeric blends are commercially important. Addition of rubber in to the PP matrix lowered the crystallisation rate and heat of fusion of PP in PP/ NR [84], PP/IIR and PP/EPR blends [218]. For all the blends the rubbery phase acts as a nucleating agent for PP. However, net crystal growth of PP remains low for blends of PP/ NR and PP/IIR. It was claimed that the NR and IIR phases act as diluents in the PP melt. For PP/EPM blends, the EPM phase accelerates the crystal growth at a very high ethylene content in EPM (>60 wt%) [218]. Consequently, the Tm and the crystallinity of the PP phase in blends of EPM with high ethylene content exceed the values of the neat PP. Wenig and Asresahegn extensively studied the crystallisation kinetics of PP in PP/EPDM blends using DSC and a polarising microscope [219]. Crystallisation kinetics is influenced by the interface layer formed between two components through diffusion of PP molecules in EPDM domains. Dynamically vulcanised PP/EPDM blends displayed a narrower melting endotherm than the non-vulcanised blends [220]. Zerjal and co-workers investigated crystallisation kinetics of PP/CaCO3/EPDM blend system using DSC [221]. Addition of CaCO3 or CaCO3 filled EPDM also lowered the crystallisation rate of PP. Heat of fusion and hence, crystallinity of PE/NR thermoplastic elastomeric blends decreased with increase in loading of NR [222]. The Tm of the PE phase was lower for blends than that for pure PE. Kalfoglou also made a similar observation in blends of high-density polyethylene (HDPE) and EPM or EPDM, however, the % crystallinity of the HDPE phase remained almost constant [223]. Rubber molecules nucleate small crystals of PE are shown during heating scans of the blends, particularly at high PE loadings. These tiny crystals melt at a lower temperature. Crystallisation rate is also decreased by addition of rubbers in the PE phase. Silane and peroxide induced crosslinked blends of PE and EPM exhibit reduced Tm, and low crystallinity in comparison to those of the neat PE [224]. The reduction in Tm and crystallinity is prominent in the case of peroxide crosslinked materials. The crystallisation and melting behaviour is a function of the sol content and network density of gel present in PE.
3.2.9.4 Melting and Crystallisation in Elastomeric Block Copolymers Elastomeric block copolymers having glassy or semicrystalline hard phase segments and soft segments are commercially important materials. Morphological characterisation of such materials is necessary to quantify interaction between two segments that leads to 94
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials microphase-separated structure. In an earlier section the role of DSC to detect the Tg of block copolymers has been summarised. Here, in this section, we review the melting or crystallisation transition in semi-crystalline elastomeric block copolymers. Block copolymers of polyisobutylene (PIB) and polybutylene terephthalate (PBT), synthesised by condensation of telechelic PIB, butane diol, and di-methyl terephthalate, displayed melting transition of PBT in the range of 200 to 220 °C depending on the block composition [225]. Ionic polyurethane elastomers containing bulky side groups in the hard phase segments sometimes display a small endotherm (at 80 °C) in the initial DSC scans due to the liberation of water from the coordination environment of anions and vaporisation [226]. Thermal analysis data of segmented polyether ester elastomers are presented in Table 3.7. DSC analysis of such elastomers based on polytetramethylene terephthalate (PTMT) and PTMO as hard and soft segments, respectively, revealed that with increase in hard segment weight fraction the Tm and heat of fusion increased. Polymers containing 45, 54 and 72 wt% hard segments displayed a Tm of 173, 197, and 216 °C, respectively, [51, 227-228]. A similar trend was observed in polymers based on PTMT and polyethylene oxide (PEO) [229-230]. Heat of fusion and percentage crystallinity of these polymers depend on the annealing temperature and time. During annealing of the polymers below the Tm the crystals becomes more perfect and the Tm increases [231]. Segmented polyether urethanes based on PTMO of different molecular weights and 4,4 diphenylmethane diisocyanate (MDI) having almost 50 wt% hard segments displayed differential melting transition and morphological characteristics under similar annealing conditions [48]. When the PTMO MW was 980, no soft segment melting transition
Table 3.7 Thermal analysis data of polyether ester Soft Segment (MW)
Hard Segment
Wt% Tm (soft Tm (Hard Wt% of Reference of Hard Segment) Segments) Crystallised Segment (°C) (°C) Hard Segment a 162 30 [231] PTMO (1000) PTMT 36 173 -b [228] PTMO (1000) PTMT 45 -a a 197 42 [228] PTMO (1000) PTMT 54 a 216 54 [228] PTMO (1000) PTMT 72 [229] PEO (6000) PTMT 20 52 162 -b b [229] PEO (6000) PTMT 40 44 212 b [229] PEO (6000) PTMT 80 20 223 PEO (1000) PTMT 79 220 40 [230] PEO (1000) PTMT 50 -12 185 32 [229-230] PEO (1000) PTMT 24 11 [230] a PTMO soft segments below 2000 MW do not exhibit crystallinity b Data not reported
95
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials was observed in the PU copolymer, but the soft segment melting appeared prominent (at 14 °C) when the PTMO MW was 2000 in the PU. The former displayed a melting transition at a temperature ranging from 150 to 200 °C depending on the annealing conditions, however, the latter displayed melting transition at a higher temperature range (210 to 235 °C). Larger soft segment facilitates phase separation and causes more perfect crystal formation during annealing. Samuels and Wilkes have shown that the multiple melting behaviours of thermoplastic urethanes depend on the thermal history not on the lack or availability of hydrogen bonding sites in the hard segment [232]. Polyether-ester-amide block copolymers based on carboxyl terminated polyamide 6 (PA6) (obtained by polymerising -caprolactam in presence of adipic acid) and polyethylene glycol (PEG) of different PA6/PEG ratio displayed different morphology and melting behaviour, as shown in Table 3.8 [233]. Increase in PEG content lowered the Tm and heat of fusion and increase in PEG molecular weight increased the Tm and heat of fusion of the polymers.
Table 3.8 Thermal analysis data of poly(ether-ester-amide) block copolymer and the homopolymer segments [233] Soft Segment (MW)
Hard Segment
Wt % Tg ( °C) Tm (°C) Tm ( °C) H of Fusion of Hard Soft (Hard for (J/g) Hard Segment Segment Segment) Segment PEG (1000) PA6 80 -45 214 45.5 PEG (1000) PA6 70 -47 0 207 41.0 PEG (1000) PA6 52 -42 0 195 32.0 PEG (400) PA6 74 -42 189 23.0 PEG (400) PA6 66 -44 178 19.5 PEG (400) PA6 51 -46 175 17.0 PA6 100 28 220 68.0 PEG (1000) -67 38 158 PEG (400) -67 -6 Reproduced with permission frm S. Fakirov, K. Goranov, e. Bosvelieva and a. Du Chesne, Makromoleculare Chemie, 1992, 193, 9, 2391. ©1992, Wiley-VCH
3.2.10 Decomposition of Polymer Usually pyrolytic decomposition and oxidative degradation of polymers at elevated temperature are associated with absorption and liberation of heat, respectively. Hence, measurement of heat exchange occurring during thermal degradation of polymers allows one to determine oxidation induction time and kinetic parameters associated with the overall decomposition reactions. DSC has been widely used to study rubber degradation [234-235]. Details of different methods that can be used for the kinetic evaluation of a 96
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials decomposition reaction using DSC is similar to that have been summarised in the earlier section on monitoring vulcanisation (Section 3.2.8). Rubbers can be classified into different categories based on the nature of pyrolytic decomposition under an inert atmosphere. Sircar and Lamond have used DSC as a ‘fingerprint’ tool in the identification of elastomeric systems [76]. Diene rubbers (BR, SBR, NR, IR, NBR, and CR) mostly display an exotherm under nitrogen due to cyclisation prior to an endotherm for the decomposition reaction. Polyolefinic (EPM, EPDM) rubbers exhibit an endotherm for the decomposition reaction. Halogenated polyolefinic rubbers (halobutyl, Hypalon), depending on the halogen content, could display an endotherm due to elimination of halogen, then an exotherm for the cyclisation followed by endothermic decomposition reaction(s). In oxygen or an air atmosphere all rubbers display exothermic transitions. Oxidative decomposition temperature is diffusion controlled, and hence depends on sample size (less reproducible). Vulcanisation of rubber, usually, causes an increase in the thermo-oxidative decomposition temperatures. DSC results for degradation of different rubbers are summarised in Table 3.9. As shown in Table 3.9, microstructure of BR influences its decomposition temperature. Therefore, it is expected for all other polymers that the decomposition temperature of rubber may alter depending on the variation in grade and microstructure content. With increase in vinyl content, oxidative decomposition temperature of BR increases [236]. Decomposition behaviours of elastomer systems containing carbon black and other additives follow a more or less similar trend as that of the neat rubbers under a nitrogen atmosphere. Commercial elastomer products based on NR or IR exhibited similar degradation behaviour even with different formulation recipes. A tyre carcass compound of NR had a decomposition temperature of 369 °C while that of an IR based compound was 349 °C. Single elastomeric vulcanisate of NR and IR showed decomposition temperature of 372 °C and 340 °C, respectively [237]. For NR/IR blends, a single peak at the intermediate temperature of individual rubbers is observed depending on the ratio of the blends. Curatives used in vulcanisation of CR influence the decomposition of the vulcanisate both in inert and oxidative atmosphere [101]. Presence of sulfur accelerates dehydrochlorination and subsequent crosslinking exotherms in CR. Based on these decomposition temperatures not only single elastomers but also some blends of elastomers can be identified [101, 238-240]. Fluoroelastomers are thermally more stable than the general-purpose elastomers. They usually display higher exothermic decomposition temperatures (a large peak at 460510 °C and a small peak at 500-585 °C) at static air atmosphere [241]. The homogeneity of litharge (PbO) dispersion in a fluoroelastomer and other rubbers can be detected by exothermic decomposition of PbO and conversion to elemental lead [242].
97
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Table 3.9 Decomposition temperatures of different rubbers by DSC analysis Polymer
Transition Temperatures (ºC) Under O2 Atmosphere N2 Atmosphere Exotherm Endotherm Exotherm c c 470 [4] 466 b [245] BR 382 [4] 466 c [246], Cis-1,4 BR 370 c [246-247] 460 c [247] 462 c [247] Trans-1,4 BR 387 c [247] c 1,2 BR 355 [247] 470 c [247] 460 c [4] 188, 378 c [4] SBR 381 c [4] SBR (vulcanised) 240, 430 c [4] c c 460 [4] NBR 372 [4]; 330 d [248] ABS 380 c [239] 412, 440 c [239] 225, 370, 390 c [239] c c 460 [4] CR 382 [4] CR (S Vulcanised) 316 c [4] 293 c [4] c 252, 318 c [4] EPDM 392, 474 [4] 432 c [4] 397 c [4] IIR 315 (small) c [4] 228, 403 c [4] 205, 271, 277 [4] CIIR 285 c [4] c c 330, 390 [4] 170 b [240] NR 377 [4] NR (vulcanised) 378 c [4] Balata 388 c [287] c Balata (Cured) 351 [237] IR 363 c [4] 337, 387 c [4] 155 b [240] 410 c [237] 242, 453, 475 c [4] IR (vulcanised) 350 c [4] Hypalon [chlorosulfonated PE] 188, 308, 475 c [4] 234, 293, 367 c [4] d Viton [poly(hexafluoro508, 585 [241] propene-vinylidene fluoride)] PU (Conathane 3010/AH 31) 360, 400 a [243] 290, 385 a [243] Scan rates : a 2 °C/min; b 8 °C/min ; c 10 °C/min; d 20 °C/min
PU usually display endothermic decomposition under nitrogen and exothermic oxidation in air [243]. Endothermic decomposition is mainly the depolymerisation of an elastomer to produce isocyanates. Toluene diisocyanate based PU decomposes in a single step at a temperature less than 400 °C, whereas, 4,4 diphenyl methane diisocyanate based PU decomposes at a temperature above 400 °C [244]. 98
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
3.2.11 Oxidation Induction Time Oxidation induction time (OIT) of polymers is determined by using DSC. Samples are isothermally scanned at a temperature between 180-220 °C under an oxygen atmosphere and the time required for the onset of exotherm due to oxidative degradation is used as a measure of OIT [236]. The OIT can also be used to determine the apparent activation energy for the oxidative degradation (using Equation 3.10, given next). Montanari and co-workers utilised DSC OIT data to compare the performance of high voltage cable insulating compounds [249]. Mason and co-workers found that the OIT of EPM and crosslinked polyethylene (XLPE) insulating compounds decrease exponentially with increasing radiation dose and with decreasing antioxidant concentration [250]. Stenberg and Bjoerk measured OIT by DSC to compare the effectiveness and minimum dosage requirement of different types of antioxidants in NR vulcanisates [251]. Lye and Toh [252] studied oxidation of NR vulcanisates using DSC analysis methods developed by Kissinger [154], Doyle [253] and Ozawa [143]. The major advantage of such analysis is that the estimation of isothermal OIT of several hours for a particular sample in a relatively short time. Activation energy for the oxidation calculated by Kissinger [154] or Ozawa-Doyle method [143] can be used to calculate the OIT for a low temperature oxidation (T0) following Doyle’s approximation: log t 0 log
E E E 2.315 (log e) 0.4567 R RT0 RTP
(3.10)
where TP = exotherm peak temperature, T0 = reference temperature, = scan rate, and t0 = isothermal induction time or isothermal equivalent for the reaction. This equation E can only be used if RT > 20, below which the approximation differ significantly from the exact value [253]. Nichols and Pett correlated OIT and tearing energy of chlorinated PE and chlorosulfonated PE vulcanisates after thermoxidative ageing for different periods [254]. Considering the reciprocal of OIT as the kinetic rate constant, for the degradation reaction, an Arrhenius plot can be obtained. Based on the Arrhenius plot and tearing energy data correlation curve, one can fairly easily predict the life of products or OIT at ambient temperature. Goh observed that the OIT at 127 °C and reciprocal of dynamic DSC oxidation peak temperature (1/TP) follows a linear relationship for most of the rubbery materials [255]. The curve fits better if the dynamic scan rate is low (2 °C/min).
3.2.12 Other Miscellaneous Applications of DSC DSC analysis has been shown to be effective in detecting the ageing effects of thermoplastic elastomeric materials. An aged material would display enthalpy relaxation at the Tg of the 99
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials material [26]. Sircar and Wells modified a DSC unit and used that to measure the thermal conductivity of rubbery materials [256]. A DSC unit equipped with a photo-cell can be used to study photon-initiated reaction(s) of the materials [257]. It is also called differential photo-calorimetry. Modulated DSC units provide increased transition sensitivity and these are used extensively nowadays [258]. DSC units with a pressure controllable cell can be used to study pressure-sensitive transitions. Since vaporisation is a pressure-sensitive transition, such units are useful for studying loss of plasticiser in a rubbery formulation at different pressure and temperature [259]. For medical or pharmaceutical grade rubbery products, calorimetric purity of the material gives useful data for quality control purposes. High sensitivity micro DSC is useful for these applications [260].
3.3 Thermogravimetric Analysis of Rubbery Materials TGA of rubbery materials is a useful tool for the investigation of various products in terms of thermal degradation, compositional characterisation, and life of finished materials. The technique is very useful for the analysis of processes such as oxidative degradation, pyrolytic decomposition, and volatilisation and for the evaluation of kinetic parameters involved in these processes. The following sections of this chapter review the utility of TGA in those areas. Usually a plot of weight loss data against temperature or time is obtained in this study. In derivative TG (DTG) analysis rate of weight loss data is plotted against temperature or time. In a dynamic TGA study mass loss is monitored as a function of temperature; in isothermal TGA mass loss is monitored as a function of time at constant temperature. The dynamic TGA or DTG is used extensively for rubbery materials. Isothermal scans are usually done for quality control purpose when volatilisation or degradation temperature of a compound is well known. In dynamic TGA, the temperature corresponding to the derivative weight loss peak of a rubber is dependent on temperature scan rate, medium of environment, composition and thermal history. An increase in heating rate shifts the DTG peak to a higher temperature. Under nitrogen the rubber thermally degrades, but in air or oxygen degradation is thermo-oxidative in nature. Presence of filler, vulcanising agent, and antioxidant also influence the thermal degradation of rubber. Representative TGA thermograms of a gum and carbon black filled SBR vulcanisates are shown in Figures 3.12a and 3.12b, respectively. The weight losses (and derivative weight losses) of the rubber in air and nitrogen atmospheres are shown at temperatures ranging from 50 to 800 °C. Under nitrogen the DTG peak appears at a higher temperature than that, that occurs in oxygen (Figure 3.12a). Decomposition in oxygen is diffusion controlled and hence depends on sample size and nature of the rubber. The gum vulcanisate leaves no carbon residue in either air or nitrogen atmosphere. Carbon black filled rubber vulcanisate leaves the filler residue beyond 500 °C, under nitrogen (Figure 3.12b). In an oxygen atmosphere, however, carbon black filled vulcanisate leaves 100
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 3.12 TGA and DTG thermogram of (a) gum SBR vulcanisate and (b) black filled SBR vulcanisates under nitrogen (- - -) and oxygen ( ) atmosphere [261] Adapted with permission from G.T. Mohanraj, T. Vikram, A.M. Shanmugharaj, D. Khastgir and T.K. Chaki, Journal of Materials Science, 2006, 41, 15, 4777. ©2006, Springer
no residue. Carbon black oxidises, in presence of oxygen, at a temperature above 500 °C and the filled vulcanisates show mainly a two-step decomposition involving oxidative degradation of rubber in the first step and oxidation of carbon black in the second step. Thus, by altering the gaseous environment one can identify the relative ratio of polymer and fillers in a rubber compound. The details of compositional characterisation will be discussed later. The following section illustrates thermal stability of various rubbers and their vulcanisates. 101
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
3.3.1 Thermal Degradation and Stability of Rubbers by TGA Thermal degradation of rubbers is evaluated by measuring the weight loss with constant rise in temperature in a thermogravimetric analyser. The temperature corresponding to maximum weight loss (determined from the maxima in derivative weight loss plots) under inert (nitrogen) atmosphere and is usually termed as the decomposition temperature. Under an oxygen atmosphere the weight loss occurs due to oxidative degradation through chain scission. The higher is the degradation temperature the greater is the thermal stability of the material. The following sections describe the thermal degradation behaviour of various general purpose and specialty rubbers, their derivatives and vulcanisates. Table 3.10 summarises different decomposition temperatures of rubbers under nitrogen and oxygen atmospheres. Representative DTG thermograms of general purpose elastomers and polyolefin elastomers under a nitrogen environment are displayed in Figure 3.13a and Figure 3.13b, respectively.
Table 3.10 Decomposition temperature of rubbers by TGA Rubber NR
Temperature ( °C) * 365-370, 430 [76, 237]; 387 [264]; 408 [265] 360, 490 [263] 375 [262] Hydrogenated NR ** 400-449 [264] CNR (Chlorinated NR) 150, 300, 350-450 [274]; 300 [271] 290, 510 [271] BNR (Brominated NR) 160, 410-450 [274] ENR (ENR-50) 428 [273] Hydrogenated ENR 455 [273] Chlorinated ENR (ENR-25) 110, 270, 405 [274] Brominated ENR (ENR-25) 150, 375 [274] IR 360, 420 [237] 394, 534 [270] BR 355, 465 [76]; 373, 470 [275] Cis-1,4 BR 447 [277]; 486 [278] 430, 500 [281] Trans-1,4 BR 330, 475 [216] 1,2 BR 461 [277] SBR 420-430, 447 [76, 284]; 473 [265] 380, 420, 445 [284] High vinyl SBR 340-440 (80-10 % styrene content) [287] Hydrogenated SBR ** 425[284]; 462 [285]; 473 [286] 380, 400[284]; 407, 424, 448, 488 [285]
102
Conditions N (10 °C/min) Air (10 °C/min) O (10 °C/min) N (20 °C/min) N (10 °C/min) O (10 °C/min) N (10 °C/min) N (20 °C/min) N (20 °C/min) N (10 °C/min) N (10 °C/min) N (10 °C/min) Air (20 °C/min) N (10 °C/min) N (10 °C/min) Air (10 °C/min) N (20 °C/min) N (10 °C/min) N (10 °C/min) O (10 °C/min) Air (5 °C/min) N (10 °C/min) Air (10 °C/min)
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Table 3.10 Cont’d... Rubber Epoxidised SBR NBR Hydrogenated NBR XNBR oligomer Hydrogenated XNBR oligomer CR IIR BIIR CIIR EPDM EVA CM CSM PU Polyether-urethane Polyester-urethane siloxane chain extended FKM ACM Silicone (PDMS) Trimethylsilyl-terminated Dimethylvinylsilylterminated
Temperature ( °C) * 450 [41] 400, 430, 496 [292]; 433, 476 [294] 300, 395, 460, 570 [57] 495 [294] 380, 460 [297] 465 [297]
Conditions N (20 °C/min) N (20 °C/min) Air N (10 °C/min) N (10 °C/min) N (10 °C/min)
346, 439 [101]; 360, 450 [301] 428 [262] 301, 420 [262] 300-310, 430-440 [262] 399 [262] 484 [262]; 469 [313]; 490 [265] 340, 470 [318] 328, 465 [307] 321, 456 [309] 285, 475 [310] 323, 390 [325] 341, 539 [325] 335, 410 [325]
N (10 °C/min) N (10 °C/min) N (10 °C/min) N (10 °C/min) O (10 °C/min) N (10 °C/min) N (20 °C/min) N (2.5 °C/min) Air (10 °C/min) N (20 °C/min) N (10 °C/min) Air (10 °C/min) N (10 °C/min)
493 [334]; 500 [333]; 535 [336] 411 [325, 352] 575 [340] 418, 512 [340] 390, 485 [340]
N (20 °C/min) N (20 °C/min) N (10 °C/min) Air (10 °C/min) N (10 °C/min)
408, 442 [340] Air (10 °C/min) * X1, Y1, ...Z1; X2, Y2, ...Z2 temperature data sets indicate multi-step degradation, where first maximum weight loss occurs at Xi °C and the second one at Yi °C and the last weight loss maximum appears at Zi °C ** depends on degree of hydrogenation
3.3.1.1 Natural Rubber and Polyisoprene NR exhibits two-step degradation under nitrogen. In the first step (DTG maximum around 370 °C) major depolymerisation along with cyclisation occurs and the cyclised residue is eliminated by a second step at higher temperature (400-430 °C) [237]. Synthetic polyisoprene (IR) also decomposes in two steps under nitrogen (350 and 414 °C) [237]. For IR, the weight loss in the first step is usually a little less than that occurs in the first 103
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 3.13a DTG thermogram of peroxide cured general purpose elastomers under nitrogen ( , NR); ( SBR); ( BR) [76] and ( , CR) [101] at 10 C/min
Figure 3.13b DTG thermogram of olefinic elastomers under nitrogen at 10 C/min: , EPDM) [262] and tyre liner compounds, ( + , IIR); ( O , BIIR); and ( uncrosslinked fluororubber ( , Aflas) [336]
104
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials thermal decomposition step of NR. The presence of natural fatty acids in NR enhances the depolymerisation reaction in the first step [263]. Singha and co-workers [264] and Zeyen [265] reported single step decomposition of NR under nitrogen with a maximum at 387 °C and 408 °C, respectively. Possibly, the decomposition steps (depolymerisation and decomposition of cyclised NR) were overlapped. Schneider showed that cis-1,4-polyisoprene is less stable than the PI containing 50% 1,2 microstructure [266]. The activation energy for the depolymerisation of 1,4IR is lower than that of the 1,2 product. Vinyl side groups cyclise during thermal decomposition and form a stable network, which enhances thermal stability. Like NR and synthetic cis-1,4-IR, distinction between natural trans-1,4-polyisoprene (balata) and it’s synthetic counterpart could be made by DTG data [237]. Trans-IR has a two-step decomposition temperature (350-360 °C and 400-410 °C) that is a little lower than the cis-isomer (370 °C, 420-430 °C). Balata (unless purified) usually contains other resin impurities and hence starts decomposing at 270 °C [237]. Vulcanisation ingredients sometimes affect the decomposition characteristics of the rubber. The gum NR, peroxide and sulfur vulcanised NR exhibit more or less similar TGA thermograms [237]. However, for the IR vulcanisates, with increase in sulfur content, the first peak in the DTG thermogram becomes obtuse and short, whereas the second DTG peak becomes sharp and intense [237, 267]. An increase in carbon black loading at relatively high sulfur dosage (2-2.5 phr) also shows a similar effect in DTG thermograms of IR vulcanisates [237, 267]. However, in these cases particle size of carbon black is an important factor. Larger size carbon black particles (medium thermal (MT) black or fast extrusion furnace (FEF) black) does not cause an increase in intensity of the second degradation peak of IR [268]. Addition of silica and or feldspar mineral powder as filler improved the thermal stability of NR vulcanisates [269]. Oxidative decomposition usually starts at a temperature lower than that observed under nitrogen. However, the process is diffusion controlled. For thick specimens incomplete combustion leaves a pyrolysed carbonaceous residue which oxidises at elevated temperatures. IR shows DTG maxima at 394 °C and 534 °C under an air atmosphere at 20 °C/min heating rate [270]. The first peak represents the oxidative decomposition temperature of IR, whereas the second peak is related to the combustion of char formed during the first step. NR vulcanisates usually oxidatively decompose at 375 °C [262]. Hydrogenation of NR enhances thermal stability. Fully hydrogenated NR displayed a decomposition temperature of 449 °C [264]. Modified NR such as halogenated NR derivatives display two or multiple step degradation where the first step occurs around 100 °C due to elimination of volatile matter (water, residual solvents). The next step is dehydrohalogenation around 150 °C and final decomposition is at temperatures ranging from 300 to 450 °C [271]. Epoxidation of natural rubber enhances thermal stability. Epoxy modification of NR up to 50 mole% epoxidation increased the DTG maximum from 388 °C to 419 °C [272]. ENR with 100 mole% epoxidation, however, 105
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials shows a TGA curve like NR with a DTG maximum at 397 °C [272]. Hydrogenation of a 50 mole% epoxidised NR (ENR-50) further enhanced the DTG maximum [273]. Halogenated ENR decomposes in multiple steps involving dehydrohalogenation and final decomposition of cyclised hydrocarbon [274].
3.3.1.2 Polybutadiene and Butadiene-Based Rubbers BR, in general, decomposes in two steps under nitrogen atmosphere, a little weight loss occurs at 355-375 °C and major degradation occurs at 460-470 °C [76, 268, 275]. The first step is due to the volatile depolymerisation and the second step is attributed to the decomposition of cyclised and crosslinked BR residue resulting after the first step [275]. Unlike NR or 1,4-IR, 1,4-BR exhibits cis-trans transformation and cyclisation at a very low temperature (~200 °C), even before detectable weight loss in a TGA thermogram [276]. Heating rate affects the butadiene decomposition significantly. With increase in heating rate the peaks shift to a higher temperature and the extent of first weight loss stage increases [268, 275]. Microstructure of the BR is a key factor on the decomposition behaviour of the rubber. Usually decomposition temperature follows the order: trans-1,4-BR < cis-1,4-BR < 1,2-BR [277]. Yildirim and co-workers reported that under a nitrogen environment cis-1,4 BR decomposes at 486 °C at 10 °C/min heating rate [278]. Zhou and Mark found that trans-1,4 BR decomposes at 475 °C with little devolatilisation at 330 °C under nitrogen at 20 °C/min scan rate [216]. The 1,2 BR cyclises under nitrogen [277, 279] and produces more carbonaceous residue than that formed by BR with other microstructures [276]. Grassie and Heaney showed that in a butadiene rubber containing both vinyl (1,2) and trans (1,4) unsaturation, the vinyl group thermally cyclised at a faster rate than with the trans moiety [280]. Compounded BR vulcanisates decompose similarly as gum BR under nitrogen, but those decompose at a broad temperature ranging from 400-450 °C in oxygen [76]. Irradiation (both in oxic and inert media) of 1,4-BR decreased the onset degradation temperature of rubber [281]. Oxic irradiated BR produced more non-volatile residue in the TGA scans under air. During oxidative degradation of BR both chain scission and crosslinking reaction occurs [282]. SBR under a nitrogen atmosphere degrades in two steps: the first step involves cyclisation and isomerisation of BR units at 380-420 °C and the second broad step deals with the scission of cyclised residue with a DTG maximum at 450-460 °C [76, 283-284]. The major broad peak involves a doublet and with increase in styrene content, the doublet nature of the DTG peak becomes more prominent with shift of the peak towards a lower temperature [268]. In an air atmosphere SBR oxidatively decomposes around 390460 °C with relatively higher weight loss in the first step of degradation in comparison to that under nitrogen [284-287]. With increase in styrene content, the decomposition temperature of SBR in air decreases [287]. Both hydrogenation and epoxidation of SBR enhance the decomposition temperature. Hydrogenated SBR (HSBR) [284-286] and 106
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials epoxidised-SBR (ESBR) [41] decompose in a single step under nitrogen atmosphere due to lack of unsaturation. HSBR decomposes in multiple steps under an oxygen atmosphere [284-285]. In air, hydrogenated SBR of high vinyl content degrades at a faster rate than the SBR due to pendant groups [284]. Degradation behaviour of block copolymer (di, tri and star blocks) of styrene and butadiene are similar to that of the random copolymer SBR [284, 288]. Vulcanisation of SBR by either peroxide or sulfur does not significantly affect the decomposition behaviour under a nitrogen atmosphere [289]. Ahmed and co-workers reported that peroxide-cured SBR has slightly higher thermal stability than the sulfurcured SBR vulcanisate, although the former has a lower temperature for onset of degradation than the latter [290]. Under oxygen the sulfur vulcanisates of SBR decompose at a very broad temperature ranging from 360 to 450 °C [76]. Loading of conducting carbon black in the SBR vulcanisates does not significantly affect degradation behaviour of the polymer under nitrogen or oxygen [261]. NBR exhibits thermal decomposition at a temperature higher than that of the butadiene rubber. Acrylonitrile units undergo cyclisation and form carbonaceous residue which enhances thermal stability of the overall polymer. Polyacrylonitrile homopolymer thermally cyclises at 250-350 °C and eliminates hydrogen cyanide and ammonia gases [291]. NBR containing 30 mol% acrylonitrile displays a DTG maximum at 496 °C [292]. With increase in acrylonitrile content in NBR the initial decomposition temperature decreases and the carbonaceous residue content increases [293]. NBR under oxidative atmosphere degrades in multiple steps with a major degradation at 460 °C [57]. Hydrogenated NBR displayed a higher decomposition temperature than that of the pure NBR [294]. However, hydrogenation of NBR significantly lowers the carbonaceous residue content after TG decomposition under nitrogen at a temperature above 550 °C [295]. The amount of carbonaceous residues formed by thermal cyclisation reaction is much more for NBR (than the HNBR) because of the presence of an unsaturated butadiene segment (in NBR). Electron beam cured HNBR exhibits slightly higher carbonaceous residue than the uncured HNBR [295]. The vulcanisation system plays a key role in the thermal stability of an NBR compound. The onset temperature for degradation and the temperature at DTG maxima for NBR vulcanisate follow the trend: sulfur-cured elastomer < peroxide-cured elastomer < E-beam cured elastomer [290]. Carbon black filled NBR vulcanisates show improved thermal stability compared to the unfilled NBR vulcanisates [296]. Addition of phenolic resin in black filled vulcanisate further improves thermal stability of the elastomer compound. Liquid XNBR decomposes in two steps under nitrogen. The first step at 380 °C involves elimination of compounds during cyclisation of acrylonitrile and butadiene units; while the second step at 460 °C involves volatilisation of depolymerised material [297]. Hydrogenation of the liquid XNBR (with 26 mol% acrylonitrile content) makes the polymer thermally stable and almost eliminates the first step of decomposition.
107
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
3.3.1.3 Chloroprene Rubber and its Derivatives CR undergoes multi-step decomposition under nitrogen. The first step at 320-380 °C involves dehydrohalogenation and cyclisation, [101, 298-300]. The fi nal pyrolytic depolymerisation occurs at 440-455 °C. CR usually forms 20-23% carbonaceous residue (char) under a nitrogen atmosphere. GC/Mass spectra analysis of CR pyrolysis indicates CR monomer and dimer in the pyrolysis off-gas [301]. CR vulcanisates often show multiple DTG peaks due to loss of volatile ingredients and plasticisers [299]. The presence of fillers also influences the degradation behaviour of CR vulcanisates. Addition of silica, clay or carbonates lowered the first decomposition temperature of CR vulcanisates, however, presence of carbon black did not affect the same [298]. Ageing of CR vulcanisates in air caused lowering in the decomposition temperatures [299]. Hydrogenated CR displays improved thermal stability [302].
3.3.1.4 Isobutylene-isoprene Rubber or Butyl Rubber IIR vulcanisates decompose at 420-428 °C [262]. Halogenated derivatives of IIR display two-step decomposition, where the first step involves dehydrohalogenation (around 300 °C) [238, 262]. The second decomposition temperature (405-420 °C) of the halobutyl rubber is slightly lower than that of the IIR [262, 303]. Gum uncrosslinked IIR exhibits a lower decomposition temperature (370-400 °C) than the vulcanisates [268, 300, 304]. Cure system and type of carbon black has little or no effect on decomposition temperature of vulcanised IIR [303]. Isobutylene and styrene block copolymer usually decompose in a single step at 417 °C under nitrogen. Sulfonated ionomers of such copolymer exhibit improvement in thermal stability [305]. Acrylate grafted IIR prepared by electron beam modification showed two-stage decomposition-where the first step involves decomposition of acrylates [306].
3.3.1.5 Thermal Degradation of Specialty Rubbers
Ethylene-based Rubbers
CM decomposes in two steps: the first step of dehydrochlorination (328 °C) is followed by the degradation of dehydrochlorinated mass (450 °C) that leaves little carbon residue [307]. Increase in the degree of chlorination lowers the temperature associated with the first step [308]. In air, CM decomposes in multi-steps, the first step is the liberation of hydrogen chloride and the next steps involve thermo-oxidative decomposition of the unsaturated residue. The main chain degradation occurs, in air, at a lower temperature than that, that occurs in nitrogen [309]. CSM decomposes in two major steps under 108
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials nitrogen. The first step involves elimination of hydrogen chloride and sulfur dioxide at temperatures ranging from 260 °C to 340 °C, whereas, in the second step the residual polymer chain decomposes at 475-480 °C through formation of 2-3% char [310]. Smith reported that during the initial decomposition of CSM, loss of a –SO2Cl group occurs first, and then dedydrochlorination occurs [311]. Very high chlorine contents (~50%) and very high sulfur contents (>2%) significantly lowered the thermal stabilities of the CSM polymers. Varma and co-workers reported that among a series of synthesised CSM those having chlorine and sulfur contents in the range of 27-37% and 0.6-1.6%, respectively, were thermally the most stable [312]. EPDM, which exhibits excellent ozone resistance, degrades at 470-490 °C under nitrogen [262, 265, 313]. Under air, EPDM decomposes at a temperature lower than that, that occurs in nitrogen [314]. As shown in Figure 3.14, an increase in ethylene to propylene ratio in EPDM rubber increases the degradation onset and DTG maximum to higher temperatures [315]. Incorporation of antioxidant (0.1 to 1.5 phr level) in the radiation cured EPDM vulcanisate improves the thermal stability of the compound [316]. Vulcanisation of EPDM by conventional sulfur curatives and silanes improves thermal stability of EPDM and its thermoplastic blends [314]. Addition of reinforcing fillers such as silica, or carbon black improves thermal stability of EPDM elastomers [298, 317].
(
Figure 3.14 TGA thermograms of the EPDM rubbers with of different PP/PE ratio: ) PP/PE, 60/40; ( ) PP/PE, 41/59; ( ) PP/PE, 22/78; ( O ) PP/PE, 0/100 at 2 °C/min [315]
Reproduced with permission from C. Gamlin, N. Dutta, N. Roy-Choudhury, D. Kehoe and J. Matisons, Thermochimica Acta, 2001, 267-368, 185. ©2001, Elsevier
109
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials EVA decomposes in two steps and the first step involves the elimination of acetic acid from the vinyl acetate segment through the formation of an unsaturation in the main chain (340 °C) and the second step involves decomposition of a PE rich residue (470 °C) [318-319]. The first step weight loss follows a linear relationship with the vinyl acetate content. Thus, TGA offers an excellent tool for the quality control and compositional identification of EVA copolymers [320]. Under an air atmosphere the extent of the first step decomposition is increased (presumably due to elimination of vinyl acetate along with adjacent CH2 segments under an oxidative environment) and the second-step decomposition maximum is slightly lowered relative to that, that occurs in inert atmosphere [321]. In air, EVA decomposes through hydroperoxidation, which can be hindered by addition of antioxidant [322]. Incorporation of mineral nanoclay particles in the EVA matrix does not significantly alter decomposition temperature under nitrogen, however, it causes an increase in degradation temperature under air due to excellent impermeability of nano-reinforced matrix [321]. In some cases the presence of an organic moiety in the organically modified clay-EVA nanocomposites accelerates the first decomposition step [323]. Thermal stability of polyethylene-co-methacrylate (EMA) rubber follows similar trends as EVA [321]. An EMA containing 21% methyl acrylate showed a DTG maximum at 450 °C under nitrogen (at 10 °C/min scan rate) with a low temperature (350-400 °C) shoulder [324].
Polyurethanes
Polyether-urethanes depolymerise at higher temperatures under inert atmospheres to produce diisocyanate and diol. During decomposition of PU, diisocyanates react and form carbodiimide which subsequently decompose at elevated temperatures [325]. Under nitrogen and at 10 °C/min scan rate, about 40-50% weight loss occurs in the first step (323 °C) and the rest is eliminated in the second step (390 °C). However, the same polymer oxidatively decomposes under air and displays 90% weight loss in the first step with a maximum at 341 °C. The carbonaceous residue burns at 540 °C. Polyester-polyurethane shows better thermal stability than the polyether-polyurethane [325-326]. Under nitrogen, the former shows a two-step degradation with the first step (335 °C) of 20% mass loss, and the second step decomposition at 410 °C. Chuang and co-workers observed two-step decomposition in different PU samples under a nitrogen atmosphere [327]. Incorporation of siloxane chain extender in the PU improved the thermal stability [327]. Addition of layered silicate clay in the PU matrix slightly improves thermal stability under nitrogen but it causes a significant improvement in thermal stability under air [328]. Layered silicate improves the barrier property and causes formation of thermally decomposed products (in the absence of air) such as crosslinked substituted urea from carbodiimide and diol and an isocyanurate product from trimerised isocyanate ending chains. Polyhedral oligomeric silsesquioxane (POSS) when used as a nanofiller and crosslinking agent in the PU networks, also improves the thermal stability of the PU elastomers [329]. 110
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials Koscielecka and Dzierza reported that thermal stability of PU is independent of the crosslinking density and the structural characteristics of crosslinks and hard segments [330]. However, Stanciu and co-workers reported that poly(ester-siloxane)urethanes based on different diisocyanate (hard segments) exhibited different thermal stability in the following order: 2,4-toluylene diisocyanate (TDI) < 4,4-methylene diphenyl diisocyanate (MDI) < hexamethylene diisocyanate (HDI) [331]. Structure of soft segments always appeared to be a controllable factor for the thermal stability of the PU [332]. PU based on polytetramethylene glycol (PTMG) is more stable than PU based on polyethylene glycol (PEG) and polypropylene glycol (PPG). Increase in soft-segment molecular weight of PTMG and PEG improved the thermal stability of the PU [326; 331-332]. PPG chains, because of the steric effect, reduce the inter-chain hydrogen bonding and hence the thermal stability. UV irradiation of PU block copolymers improved thermal stability of the polymers due to UV assisted crosslinking or structural modification of the polymer [326].
Fluorinated Rubbers
Flouroelastomers (such as copolymer of vinylidene fluoride (VDF) and hexafluoropropylene (HFP), Viton A, and terpolymer of VDF, HFP and tetrafluoroethylene (TFE), Viton B-50), commonly termed FKM, are thermally stable. They decompose under nitrogen, in a single step, with a maximum rate at a temperature ranging from 490-500 °C [311, 333-334]. Copolymer of tetrafluoroethylene and propylene (Aflas) is the first fluoroelastomer containing non-fluorinated alkene comonomer. Increase in propylene content lowers the degradation temperature [335]. These copolymeric fluororubbers decompose at an intermediate temperature between decomposition temperatures of polytetrafluoroethylene and PP [336]. A -radiation crosslinked polytetrafluroethyleneco-perfluoromethyl vinyl ether shows inferior thermo-oxidative stability to that of the uncrosslinked rubber [337]. Fluorinated polysiloxanes are excellent materials that provide both high thermal stability and low temperature resistance. Incorporation of long fluorinated chains onto siloxane improves low temperature behaviour but causes low temperature elimination of the chain during TGA scans. However, beyond the first elimination temperature modified polymer shows better thermal stability than the polymethyltrifluoropropyl siloxane and comparable thermal stability as that of the PDMS [338]. Incorporation of as low as 20 wt% perfluorocyclobutane-containing silphenylene repeat unit in a poly(3,3,3trifluoropropylmethyl siloxane) fluorosilicone backbone minimised isothermal weight loss at a temperature above 250 °C [339].
Silicone Rubbers
PDMS rubber exhibits high thermal resistance. Under nitrogen neat trimethylsilylterminated PDMS displays a DTG maximum at 575 °C at 10 °C/min heating rate [340]. 111
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials Dimethylvinylsilyl-terminated PDMS exhibits a two-step thermal degradation (390 °C and 485 °C) under nitrogen and the decomposition temperatures are much lower than that of the trimethylsilyl-terminated PDMS. Obviously, the decrease in thermal stability is due to the presence of vinyl group at the end of PDMS chain. Under air both the siloxanes exhibit two-step decomposition but the vinyl terminated PDMS again exhibits reduced thermo-oxidative stability [340]. Incorporation of cation exchanged montmorillonite clay [341], precipitated silica [342-343], and conductive carbon black [343] into PDMS vulcanisate improved thermal stability of the rubber. Conductive carbon black enhanced thermal stability of the PDMS more than that caused by silica [343]. A crosslinked product of liquid PDMS rubber exhibits slight hygrothermal degradation after prolonged treatment (2 y) under boiling water leading to ~20% decrease in volume. The treated vulcanisate however has an identical TGA thermogram to that of the untreated control vulcanisate [344]. During the life time of silicone rubbers as electrical insulator, surface degradation occurs and it produces volatile products that are eliminated at the temperatures ranging from 150-250 °C during TGA scans of used insulators [345]. Insulating silicone compounds are usually filled with alumina trihydrate (ATH). Degradation of ATH produces Al2O3 and water at a temperature ranging from 250-350 °C. The %weight of water released from ATH can be used to determine ATH content in such silicone formulation [346]. Silphenylene siloxane elastomer shows very high thermal stability (TGA: 50% weight loss temperature is above 600 °C) under nitrogen and oxygen and excellent low temperature flexibility [347-348]. Incorporation of a vinyl group in p-silphenylene siloxane segment improves thermal stability significantly and causes more formation of nonvolatile residues due to thermal polymerisation and cyclisation of vinyl segments [349-350]. Polyester-siloxane block copolymer of polybutylene terephthalate (PBT) and PDMS shows slightly improved thermal stability compared to the neat PBT under nitrogen. However, under an oxygen atmosphere copolymers exhibit multi-step decomposition. The first step involves decomposition of siloxane segments to form gaseous silicon compounds, CO, CO2, HCOOH and so on, whereas the second and third step involves the elimination of cyclised siloxane oligomers and degradation of PBT [351].
Miscellaneous Rubbers
Polyacrylic rubber (ACM) decomposes under nitrogen at around 410 °C [334, 352]. Poly[oxy(chloromethyl)ethylene] (or polyepichlorohydrin), under nitrogen, mostly degrades in a single step with a decomposition temperature of 344 °C, whereas poly[oxy(ethylthiomethyl)ethylene] decomposes at 354 °C. Although the former decomposes at lower temperature it leaves more nonvolatile residue (char) than the latter [353]. Polynorbornene (PNBE) prepared by ring opening metathesis showed a two-step decomposition with a major peak at 455 °C and a minor degradation peak at 520 °C [354]. 112
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
3.3.2 Compositional Characterisation of Rubbers by TGA TGA or DTG data provides useful information for the quantitative analysis of the rubber vulcanisates. A vulcanisate usually consists of several chemical ingredients (other than raw rubbers) that are used as filler, emulsifier (in emulsion polymerised raw rubber), processing oil (for filler dispersion and mixing), vulcanising agents and accelerators, antioxidants, and activator to accelerator. Broadly, a rubber vulcanisate consists of polymer rubber, fillers (inorganic, organic and carbon black) and acetone extractable volatiles (plasticising oil, antioxidant, unutilised vulcanising agents, and so on). In a TGA scan volatiles leave the samples in the low temperature region followed by decomposition of polymers at higher temperature. The weight loss due to plasticisers and polymers are usually overlapped, therefore, it is very difficult to distinguish volatile content in a rubber vulcanisate from a single TGA run [303, 355]. Both carbon black and inorganic fillers are left as residue after TGA runs under nitrogen. Generally, the polymer is completely decomposed under nitrogen at 600 °C. At this temperature the TGA gas environment is usually changed to air/oxygen. Carbon black oxidises at 600-800 °C and inorganic fillers are left as an ash residue during this TGA scan in air/oxygen. Thus inorganic ash content (say, A) and carbon black content (say, B) in wt% can be estimated from TGA scans in air and nitrogen. The amount of acetone extractable volatiles is removed by an acetone extraction (using Soxhlet extractor) of the vulcanisate at reflux temperature (60 °C). Ratio of polymer to carbon black content (say, R) of acetone extracted rubber can be used to back calculate the percentage of polymer (say, P) in the unextracted rubber, P = B/R. Then volatiles (V) in the original rubber can be estimated from V + P + B + A = 100. A schematic of a TGA thermogram of a vulcanisate is shown in Figure 3.15. A detailed methodology for the compositional estimation (formulation reconstruction) of elastomer compounds was reviewed by Zeyen [265]. Macaione and co-workers found that TGA data for percentage inorganic varied in different runs, mostly due to heterogeneity in sample. Ash content obtained on a large mass of sample by a simple gravimetry after combustion in a muffle furnace appeared close to the known value for a vulcanisate [356]. DTG data of various rubber compounding ingredients are summarised in Table 3.11. Under a nitrogen atmosphere, thermal stability of the plasticising oils follows the order: paraffinic oil (DTGmax, 381 C) > highly aromatic oil (295 C ) > naphthenic oil (253 C) [265]. Swarin and Wims established decomposition temperatures for various plasticisers used in NBR vulcanisates [357]. The type of carbon black present in a butyl elastomer influences the decomposition step involving oxidation of black. High surface area carbon black decomposed in air at a lower temperature than that, that occurred with the low surface area carbon black [303]. Structure of the carbon black (high versus low structure) affects decomposition temperature/time of the black [358]. For a type of carbon black, cure system also 113
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 3.15 Schematic of a TGA thermogram of a rubber vulcanisate for compositional analysis
Table 3.11 Decomposition temperature various rubber compounding ingredients Material Plasticiser, Naphthenic oil Highly aromatic oil Paraffinic oil Dibutyl phthalate Dioctyl adipate Dioctyl phthalate Dioctyl sebacate Carbon black: HAF FEF GPF SRF Graphite Calcium carbonate
Temperature (°C)
Environment
253 [265] 295 [265] 381 [265] 220 [357] 255 [357] 264 [357] 282 [357]
Nitrogen Nitrogen Nitrogen Nitrogen Nitrogen Nitrogen Nitrogen
545 [265]; 542-607 [368]
Oxygen
567-621 [368] 550 [265] 585-632 [368] 760 [357], 800 [265] 825 [265]
Oxygen Oxygen Oxygen Oxygen Nitrogen/oxygen
influences the black decomposition temperature in air [358, 303]. The oxidation temperature of carbon black residue from a pyrolysed vulcanisate depends on mixing procedure and loading of carbon black in the elastomer [358]. Therefore, unless otherwise the black surface area or particle sizes are distinctly different, in a vulcanisate containing different types of black, it is very difficult to identify the types of blacks by 114
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials dynamic TGA [359]. Sometimes isothermal scans at ~540 C under a mild oxidising atmosphere are useful in identifying different blacks in a vulcanisate of char forming Neoprene [358, 360].
Blend Vulcanisates
Elastomer blends containing two or three rubber components can be analysed by TGA, easily, if the components have significantly different thermal stabilities. In this case the DTG thermogram indicates distinct peaks for different components. If the thermal stability of the individual components is close, the decomposition of the rubbers in the blend is usually overlapped. DTG plots for both the types of blends can be used to identify the elastomer composition. Many DTG data (at a specified heating rate) for known blend compositions available in literature can be used as a fingerprint to detect the unknown blend composition [238, 268]. DTG peak temperature of a rubber usually depends on the presence of other rubbers (if any), type of filler and cure system [303]. For qualitative and quantitative prediction of rubber formulation other complementary techniques such as pyrolysis-FTIR, pyrolysis GC-mass spectroscopy, sulfur analysis, and DSC are also used [77]. Sircar and co-workers in a series of works characterised various blend composition of rubber vulcanisates using TGA [76, 101, 237-239, 262]. Maurer [360], Brazier and Nickel [268], Amraee and co-workers [361], Shield and co-workers [367] and Swarin and Wims [357] also employed TGA as a primary tool for compositional characterisation of various elastomer blends. DTG curves of the vulcanisates displayed characteristic peaks of the rubber components. The specific peak intensity depends on the content of the corresponding rubber component in the vulcanisate. For example, in a blend of NR/SBR the peak due to the decomposition of NR in blends would increase with increase in NR content in the blend composition [76]. For quantitative analysis of the DTG data a calibration plot of peak height ratio against composition is usually used to predict relative proportion of the rubbers in the blend [237, 268, 360, 361]. Shield and co-workers [367] found that for the blend of SBR and NBR, temperature corresponding to 70% weight loss linearly decreased with increase in SBR content in the blend. Such statistics are useful to predict composition of an unknown SBR/NBR blend. Comparative TGA data of known compositions of NR/BR, NR/SBR and NR/EPDM blends are displayed in Figure 3.16. As discussed earlier the decomposition temperatures of the rubber components follow the trend EPDM > BR ~ SBR > NR. Therefore, from Figure 3.16 individual blends can be clearly identified. It is noteworthy that for the distinction of BR and SBR other characterisation tools such as DSC, FTIR and GC/mass spectrometer is necessary. TGA data of an unknown tyre rubber vulcanisate is shown in Figure 3.17. It can be found that the vulcanisate is a multi-component rubber blend. It was estimated from the peak positions that the vulcanisate consists of BR, SBR and NR. The FTIR spectroscopy results of the pyrolysates qualitatively confirmed the predicted composition [77]. Maurer 115
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Figure 3.16 DTG thermogram of elastomer blends under nitrogen at 10 C/min: peroxide cured 40/60 NR/SBR ( ); peroxide cured 50/50 NR/BR ( ) [76], and tyre sidewall 40/60 NR/EPDM elastomer ( ) [238]
Figure 3.17 DTG thermogram of an unknown tyre rubber under nitrogen at 10 C/min [77]
in an early work discussed the utilisation of TGA in analysing the vulcanisate composition based on NR/EPDM and NR/SBR/EPDM blends [360]. Brazier and Nickel in their early work successfully demonstrated utilisation of DTG data to predict composition of NR/ BR, NR/SBR and NR/SBR/EPDM blend vulcanisates [268]. 116
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials Results on TG and DTG analysis of different elastomer blends has been reviewed by various authors [362-364]. A list of prior works on quantitative TG and DTG analysis of various binary/ternary/quaternary rubber blends is displayed in Table 3.12 for further reference. Requirement of an extensive database/library of TGA/DTG plots for various blend compositions with known cure systems is a severe drawback of compositional characterisation of blend vulcanisates using TGA only.
Table 3.12 A list of prior works on compositional characterisation of rubber blend vulcanisates using TGA Blend System NR/BR NR/SBR NR/SBR/BR NR/CR NR/CR/Hypalon NR/CIIR NR/EPDM NR/EPDM/SBR NR/EPDM/CIIR NR/SBR/CIIR NR/SBR/EPDM/CIIR NR/IR SBR/BR SBR/NBR SBR/EPDM SBR/CIIR SBR/EPDM/CIIR BR/CIIR CR/Oil extended BR CR/Oil Extended SBR NBR/EPDM IIR/EPDM
Standard Compound Tyre sidewall (black) Tyre sidewall Truck tyre tread Tyre sidewall (white) Tyre sidewall (white) Tyre innerliner Tyre sidewall (white) Tyre innerliner Tyre sidewall (white) Passenger tyre tread Oil seal Tyre innerliner Tyre sidewall (white) Tyre innerliner Tyre sidewall (white) Tyre sidewall (white) Automotive products -
Reference [76], [268], [365] [76], [268], [366] [76] [101] [101] [262] [360], [238] [360], [268] [238] [262] [238] [237] [361] [367] [360] [262] [238] [262] [101] [101] [357] [368]
3.3.3 Study of Rubber Blend Compatibility Using TGA Thermal analysis is a very common tool to detect polymer compatibility in blends. For these studies, however, DMA, DSC, and dielectric thermal analysis (DETA) are used extensively. TG and DTG data are sometimes useful to detect physico-chemical interactions between blend components. Specific interaction usually leads to either more overlapped degradation region of the polymers or, enhanced thermal stability indicated 117
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials by a higher decomposition temperature of the compatibilised phase or, earlier degradation of the compatibilised phase by mutual catalysed degradation. Co-vulcanisation of individual rubber components sometimes causes compatibility by exhibiting higher mechanical properties and thermal stability [369]. Kader and Bhowmick reported that ACM/FKM miscible vulcanisates containing polyfunctional acrylate exhibited improved thermal stability compared to the individual component vulcanisates containing similar dosage of polyfunctional acrylate [334]. Compatibilised blend vulcanisate of CR and IIR exhibited improved thermal stability as shown by a high temperature degradation of the compatibilised interphase [300]. Reactive compatibilised ethylene methylacrylate (EMA) and PDMS blends with EMA/PDMS ratio of 50/50 and 30/70 exhibited an increased decomposition temperature of EMA phase and decreased decomposition temperature of siloxane phase due to free radical assisted crosslinking of the two phases [324]. Similar results were obtained with NR/ EPDM gum unvulcanised blend compatibilised by mercapto-modified EPDM. The compatible blend formed a crosslinked gel due to the reaction of the mercapto group and NR [370]. The EMA/ENR compatible blends also exhibited similar results [371]. PVC/NBR blends are miscible. Recycled PVC/NBR blends show lower properties compared to that of the virgin PVC/NBR blend. Use of compatibiliser such as acrylic acid enhanced the properties of the blends, but lowered the thermal stability possibly due to mutual catalysed degradation [372]. In a ternary blend system of PVC/EVA/PS-co-acrylonitrile (SAN) blend, PVC acts as compatibiliser for the immiscible SAN/EVA system and the overall thermal stability of the ternary blend appears superior to the homopolymers and PVC/SAN and SAN/ EVA blends [373]. A conjugated structure formed by degradation of a polymer (like dehydrohalogenation of PVC) acts as free radical scavenger to enhance the thermal stability of the other component in the blend [374]. Both NBR and EVA exhibit twostep degradation. With increase in NBR content in the NBR/EVA blend, an increase in the initial and final decomposition temperatures were observed due to interfacial interaction [375]. The peroxide cured blend composition exhibited higher decomposition temperature than the sulfur vulcanisation system due the stable C-C bonding in the former. Decomposition temperature of ENR/PMMA partially miscible blend increased with increase in ENR content and the degree of epoxidation in ENR [376]. TGA studies on various other compatibilised blend compositions such as PP/EPDM [377], PE/EPDM [314], LDPE/PDMS [378], polyaniline/EPDM [379], SBR/NBR [367], silicone/EPDM [380], NBR/CSM and CR/CSM [381] have been reported in literature.
3.3.4 Study of Rubber Degradation Kinetics Using TGA In earlier sections (Section 3.2.8), the role of DSC in monitoring kinetics of rubber vulcanisation has been summarised. Similar methods are applicable for thermal degradation of rubber or melt crystallisation of semi-crystalline thermoplastic elastomers. 118
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials In those methods rate of heat flow associated with the reaction or phase changes was monitored. Kinetics of thermal and oxidative degradation of elastomers and raw rubbers can also be monitored by recording rate of weight loss during thermal treatment under a specific environment. Here, again, two basic approaches in measuring kinetic parameters are isothermal methods and non-isothermal (dynamic) methods. The dynamic analysis is the most commonly followed method [311]. In TG analysis the fraction of materials reacted at time t is estimated as , where:
ms m ms mf
and ms, m, mf are initial mass, mass at time t and the final mass at the end of reaction. d dW where W is the mass reading (in TGA) data which corresponds Therefore, dt dt to (1- ). The Freeman and Carroll method is used extensively for the analysis of TG degradation of rubbers and other polymers [382]. According to this method: d dt n E d(1 / T) d ln(1 ) R d ln(1 ) d ln
(3.11)
where, n is the order of degradation reaction, E is the activation energy of the reaction, and T is the temperature that is function of time and . d d(1 / T) dt Data of d ln(1 ) against d ln(1 ) would result in a linear plot with a negative slope of E/R and intercept n. For accurate estimation of n, usually the data in the vicinity of DTG maxima is plotted. However, the kinetic parameters determined in this method were found to be dependent on sample mass and heating rate [382]. d ln
Another general method, commonly known as multiple heating rate method, proposed by Friedman [383] deals with comparison of rates of conversion (d /dt) at different levels of conversions measured at various heating rates q. In this method: ln q
d E n ln(1 ) ln A dT RT
(3.12)
d For various constant isoconversion method, ln q versus 1/T data would give different linear plots for the estimation of n and E. dT
Other than the previous differential approaches, various integrated methods were proposed for evaluation of degradation kinetic parameters. In these methods: 119
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials q
d d A (E/RT) A.e(E/RT) f() or, e dT dT f() q
(3.13)
The integral function of conversion of above is usually expressed as g( ). Based on various approximations to find g( ) several methods were proposed to find the activation energy (E) and frequency factor (A). Commonly used methods were proposed by Doyle [384], Flynn and Wall [385], Ozawa [386], Kissinger [154] and Coats and Redfern [387]. Later Flynn and Dickens proposed a method for estimation of kinetic parameters where effect of sample history was minimised [388]. Various approximations, advantages and limitations of all these methods have been extensively reviewed by Hatakeyama and Quinn [389], Wendlandt [390], and Flynn [391]. Table 3.13 summarises the published kinetic parameters for a few selected raw rubbers and the compounded vulcanisates. Activation energy (E) of NR varied with degree of conversion indicating complex decomposition reactions of NR involving multiple steps and alteration of overall rate of reaction with extent of conversion. However, two major decomposition peaks were observed in the DTG curve of NR [392]. Similar results were also obtained with car tyre rubber [393]. Based on an assumption that degradation of rubber is a single order reaction, Williams and Beslar found that with increase in heating rate the E and frequency factors for NR and SBR degradation decreased significantly [394]. The value of E for thermal degradation of IR was reported to be 157 kJ/mol [298]. Addition of fillers increased the activation energy [298]. The greater the filler-rubber interaction, the greater the activation energy associated with degradation. Chlorinated NR (CNR) under oxidative environment decomposes in two steps but leaves no residue. However, single step degradation of CNR under nitrogen leaves 32% carbonaceous residue. The activation energies and frequency factors of the steps increased with increasing heating rate without significantly affecting the order of reaction [271]. The values of true E and frequency factor (i.e., values corresponding to 0 C/min heating rate) were extrapolated from the plots of those at various heating rates. Conesa and Marcilla investigated kinetic parameters of different SBR rubber [395]. Presence of volatiles in oil extended SBR, changes the kinetic parameters significantly. For SBR, the activation energy of decomposition under nitrogen is increased with addition of carbon black, however, the same under oxygen atmosphere is decreased [261]. Filled SBR followed fractional order degradation kinetics under nitrogen, but a first order degradation under oxygen. Under nitrogen the value of E measured by isoconversion method (Flynn-Wall-Ozawa) increased with increase in degree of conversion at a lower black loading, but at higher black loading E remained more or less constant. Under oxygen, E at lower conversion levels was slightly higher. Lin and co-workers attributed BR thermal degradation to two reactions involving two distinct mass losses [396]. The first step involves only 20% weight loss with an activation 120
SBR vulcanisate (30 phr carbon black)
SBR (30% St) SBR-OE (44% St) SBR gum
BR
Medium Number Fractions Activation of Steps Contributed Energy by Each Step (kJ/mol) N 2 0.80 80-210 0.20 125-150 Air 2 239 N 3 0.30 68.4 0.38 219.7 0.32 225.7 O 2 0.60 101.7 0.40 125.0 N 1 1.00 98.6 N 2 0.20 59.8 0.80 197.0 N 3 0.23 45.1 0.64 211.8 0.13 290.1 N 2 0.15 232.2 0.85 289.0 N 2 0.36 72.9 0.64 462.5 N 3 0.35 52.2 0.50 150.6 0.15 169.4 N 1 1.00 251.0 256.4 240.7 O 1* 1.00 169.1 173.0 175.2 -
2.3 x 103 1.5 x 1010 3.5 x 1010 -
-
-
4.7 x 108 2.38 x 108 2.32 x109 2.8 x 103 1.9 x 1013 -
-
-
-
1 4.4 1.2 1.6 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.3 1.5 1.8 2.1 1.4 3.0 1.0 3.7 1.6 2.1 1.3 1.9 -
Frequency Order of Factor Reaction (min-1) -
Flynn-Wall-Ozawa, Friedman, Kissinger [261] Flynn-Wall-Ozawa, Friedman, Kissinger [261]
Friedman [397]
Statistical numerical analysis [395]
Statistical numerical analysis [395]
Statistical numerical analysis [395]
Friedman [396]
Coats–Redfern [271]
Statistical numerical analysis [395]
Freeman and Carroll [263]
Friedman [392]
Method and Reference
Table 3.13 Summary of kinetic parameters for degradation of various rubbers and vulcanisates
CNR (65% Cl)
IR-OE
NR
Rubber
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
121
122 2 3
N
N
N
Hypalon 20
CR
2
0.38 0.62 1.00
-
0-0.15 1-0.85 0.04 0.34 0.62 -
1.00
0.13 0.87 0.19 0.81 1.00 7.5 x 1010
147.6 § 140-200 330-365 92.0 112.9 246.6 202.6 94.5 152 ± 25 147 ± 24 281 ± 28 127.0 215 111.8
5.9 x 1013
1.1 1.1 0
-
-
1.5 x 1012 6.5 x 1017 -
-
1 1 -
1.9
2.9 0.6 2.9 1.6 -
-
-
-
-
155.7 260.1 155.7 260.1 140.0
Kissinger [401]
Ozawa [299]
Friedman [298]
Coats–Redfern [311]
Friedman [315]
Friedman [393]
Kissinger [398]
Numerical analysis [399]
Numerical analysis [399]
Kissinger [398]
Method and Reference
Silicone N 1 Freeman-Carroll [343] *Decomposition of carbon black is ignored **Oxidative degradation of EVA at relatively lower temperature than the major degradation step is ignored §Average value of activation energies at different conversion levels §§Polyether polyol and aromatic diisocyanate based PU
N
2
N 3
1
N
Passenger Car Tyre EPDM
2
O 1
2
N
O
Polyurethane §§
Table 3.13 Cont’d ...
Medium Number Fractions Activation Frequency Order of of Steps Contributed Energy Factor Reaction by Each Step (kJ/mol) (min-1) O 1** 122 5.5 x 1012 -
NBR vulcanisate
EVA (28% VA) EVA (18% VA)
Rubber
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials energy value of 60 kJ/mol, whereas, that of the second step is 197 kJ/mol. Kleps and co-workers reported that E for the thermal degradation of BR at Tmax is 263 kJ/mol [298]. Incorporation of inorganic fillers (silica, calcium carbonate, clay) increased the activation energy of thermal degradation, but addition of carbon black lowered the same [298]. Gamlin and co-workers analysed EPDM rubbers of different PE/PP compositions [315]. It was observed that for a pseudo-first order thermal degradation at lower temperature (0-15% conversion) the activation energy was low (140-200 kJ/mol); however, the same at higher temperature range was very high (330-365 kJ/mol). Smith also reported similar range of E values for different grades of EPDM [311]. The values of E did not follow any trend with the composition of EPDM [315]. It was likely that morphology or microstructure of the rubber controlled the complex degradation reaction. Kleps and co-worker reported that average activation energy of EPDM rubber is 214 kJ/mol [298]. Addition of filler to the vulcanisate increased the value of E. Hypalon (chlorosulfonated PE) exhibited a three-step thermal decomposition. The major degradation occurred at the high temperature region (400-500 C) with the highest activation energy being 246.6 kJ/mol [311]. CR undergoes two-step degradation under nitrogen and leaves carbon residue. The activation energies of the two steps are 203 kJ/mol (Tmax 376 C) and 95 kJ/mol (Tmax 452 C) [298]. Denardin and co-workers employed multi-Gaussian curve fitting of DTG data to obtain multi-step CR degradation (in air or nitrogen) kinetic parameters [299]. Addition of mineral fillers lowers the thermal stability and activation energy for the first step. However, addition of carbon black improves thermal stability of the rubber. Thermal decomposition of EVA is also two-step as found in high resolution TGA studies [400]. The activation energy for the second step is higher than that of the first step (Table 2.13). Oxidative degradation of EVA also followed a similar trend. Under oxygen the fractional conversion involved in first step was higher [399]. PU too, exhibit a two-step thermal degradation. Applying Kissinger’s method Agi and co-workers determined the values of E for PU of different compositions [401]. The E varied from 115 kJ/mol to142 kJ/mol and 197 kJ/mol to 233 kJ/mol for the first and second steps, respectively. The activation energy for thermal degradation of silicone rubber is temperature sensitive [343]. With increase in temperature, the E decreases initially then increases at the very high temperature region. Addition of conductive black lowers the activation energy for thermal degradation of silicone at certain temperature regions, however, addition of silica as filler increases the activation energies. Tyre derived rubber usually consists of various rubber components and the activation energy of degradation lies in the range of 140-200 kJ/mol [402]. Isothermal TGA analysis of rubbery materials is also used to study the kinetics of thermal or oxidative degradation [403-405]. According to the isothermal method: ln
dW n ln W ln k dt
(3.14) 123
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials where, k(T) = Ae(–E/RT). Therefore, the Arrhenius plot of ln k against 1/T gives the activation energy from the slope and ln A from the intercept. Isothermal TGA data is also effective to predict the lifetime of the product [406-407].
3.3.5 Miscellaneous Applications of TGA TGA is widely used to analyse raw materials of the rubber product manufacturing industry and the processed materials at various stages. The ability to measure volatile content by TGA is exploited to control the quality of the products. Other than the quantitative compositional analysis of rubber products, TGA is extensively used in (a) determining the effectiveness of antioxidants in compounds [408] or ageing characteristics of raw rubber and finished rubber products [254, 299, 409], (b) evaluation of (composition/ homogeneity) in rubber mixes [355-356, 410], (c) qualitative identification of carbon black or other fillers [358-359, 411-412], and (d) finding optimum processing/storage/ degradation parameters for various rubber ingredients such as plasticisers [357], blowing agents [413], curatives [414-415] and so on. Continued efforts in the development of instrumentation and software-based data analysis further increased the scope of TGA applications in research/quality control activities of rubber products. For example, modulated thermogravimetry, a recently developed tool, is very useful for obtaining continuous kinetic parameters for rubber degradation in a simple dynamic TGA run [416-417].
3.4 Conclusion Different applications of DSC and TGA for the analysis of rubbery materials has been discussed. A combination of other analytical tools such as FTIR, GC, and MS, are also extensively used for the analysis of evolved gases in TGA. Recent development of user friendly equipment and software-based analysis made these tools easy to use and less time consuming for faster qualitative and quantitative evaluation of rubber products.
References 1.
B. Wunderlich, Thermal Analysis of Polymeric Materials, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Germany, 2005, p.279.
2.
T-L. Cheng and A-C. Su, Polymer, 1995, 36, 1, 73.
3.
B.C. Edwards, Journal of Polymer Science, Polymer Physics Edition, 1975, 13, 7, 1387.
124
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials 4.
A.K. Sircar and T.G. Lamond, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1972, 45, 1, 329.
5.
E. Gmelin and, St.M. Sarge, Pure and Applied Chemistry, 1995, 67, 11, 1789.
6.
Modulated Temperature Differential Scanning Calorimetry: Theoretical and Practical Applications in Polymer Characterisation, Eds., M. Reading and D.J. Hourston, Hot Topics in Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry, Volume 6, Springer, Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 2006.
7.
B. Wunderlich in Thermal Characterisation of Polymeric Materials, Ed., E.A. Turi, 1981, Academic Press, Inc., New York, NY, USA, p.91.
8.
A.K. Sircar, M.L.Galaska, S. Rodrigues and R.P. Chartoff, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1999, 72, 3, 513.
9.
P.J. Flory, Principles of Polymer Chemistry, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY, USA, 1953, Chapter 12.
10. I. Arvanitoyannis, I. Kolokuris, J.M.V. Blanshard and C. Robinson, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1993, 48, 6, 987. 11. T.G. Fox, Jr., and P.J. Flory, Journal of Applied Physics, 1950, 21, 6, 581. 12. J.M.G. Cowie and I.J. McEwen, Polymer, 1973, 14, 9, 423. 13. A.S. Marshall and S.E.B. Petrie, Journal of Applied Physics, 1975, 46, 10, 4223. 14. S. Lazcano, C. Marco, J.G. Fatou and A. Bello, European Polymer Journal, 1988, 24, 10, 991. 15. C. Kow, M. Morton, L.J. Fetters and N. Hadjichristidis, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1982, 55, 1, 245. 16. F. Danusso, M. Levi, G. Gianotti and S. Turri, Polymer, 1993, 34, 17, 3687. 17. G. Marchionni, G. Ajroldi, M.C. Righetti and G. Pezzin, Polymer Communications, 1991, 32, 3, 71. 18. S.J. Clarson, K. Dodgson and J.A. Semlyen, Polymer, 1985, 26, 6, 930. 19. S.J. Clarson, J.A. Semlyen and K. Dodgson, Polymer, 1991, 32, 15, 2823. 20. R.M. Ikeda, M.L. Wallach, and R.J. Angelo, in Block Polymers: Proceedings of the Symposium on Block Polymers at the Meeting of the American Chemical Society in New York City in September 1969, Eds., S. L. Aggarwal, Plenum Press, New York, NY, USA, 1970, p 43. 125
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials 21. D.C. Blackley Synthetic Rubbers: Their Chemistry and Technology, Applied Science Publishers, New York, NY, USA, 1983, p.279. 22. X. Yang, J. Cai, X. Kong, W. Dong, G. Li and E. Zhou, Macromolecular Chemistry and Physics, 2001, 202, 7, 1166. 23. A.N. Gent and L-Q. Zhang, Journal of Polymer Science, Part B: Polymer Physics, 2001, 39, 7, 811. 24. E.W. Duck, Proceedings of the 12th Annual Meeting of International Institute of Synthetic Rubber Producers, Kyoto, Japan, 1974, p.17. 25. R. Krishnamoorti, W.W. Graessley, L.J. Fetters, R.T. Garner, and D.J. Lohse, Macromolecules, 1998, 31, 7, 2312. 26. J. Roovers and P.M. Toporowski, Macromolecules, 1992, 25, 3, 1096. 27. D.R. Burfield and K.L. Lim, Macromolecules, 1983, 16, 7, 1170. 28. Y.X.Yi and P. Zoller, Journal of Polymer Science, Part B, Polymer Physics, 1993, 31, 7, 779. 29. Y. Doi, A. Yano, K. Soga and D.R. Burfield, Macromolecules, 1986, 19, 9, 2409. 30. D. Khlok, Y. Deslandes and J. Prud’homme, Macromolecules, 1976, 9, 5, 809. 31. M. Gordon and J.S. Taylor, Journal of Applied Chemistry, 1952, 2, 493. 32. P.R. Couchman and F.E. Karasz, Macromolecules, 1978, 11, 1, 117. 33. T.G. Fox, Bulletin of the American Physical Society, 1956, 1, 123. 34. R. Simha and R.F. Boyer, Journal of Chemical Physics, 1962, 37, 5, 1003. 35. L.A. Wood, Journal of Polymer Science, 1958, 28, 319. 36. E. Penzel, J. Rieger and H.A. Schneider, Polymer, 1997, 38, 2, 325. 37. M. De Sarkar, P.P. De and A.K. Bhowmick, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1999, 71, 10, 1581. 38. M. Gordon and J.S. Taylor, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1953, 26, 2, 323. 39. I. Šics, T.A. Ezquerra, F.J Baltá Calleja, V. Tupureina and M. Kalninš, Journal of Macromolecular Science, Part B: Physics, 2000, B39, 5-6, 761. 126
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials 40. S.J. Ahn, K.H. Lee, B.K. Kim and H.M. Jeong, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 2000, 78, 11, 1861. 41. M.A. de Luca, T.E. Machado, N.B. Notti and M.M. Jacobi, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 2004, 92, 2, 798. 42. S. Bhattacharjee, H. Bender and D. Padliya, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 2003, 76, 5, 1057. 43. S. Krause, Z-H. Lu, and M. Iskandar, Macromolecules, 1982, 15, 4, 1076. 44. M-K. Lai, J-Y. Wang and R.C-C. Tsiang, Polymer, 2005, 46, 8, 2558. 45. X. Yu, M.R. Nagarajan, C. Li, P.E. Gibson and S.L. Cooper, Journal of Polymer Science, Part B, Polymer Physics, 1986, 24, 12, 2681. 46. W. Goyert and H. Hespe, Kunststoffe, 1978, 68, 12, 819. 47. S. Abouzahr and G. L. Wilkes, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1984, 29, 9, 2695. 48. T.R. Hesketh, J.W.C. Van Bogart and S.L. Cooper, Polymer Engineering and Science, 1980, 20, 3, 190. 49. X. Yu, C. Song, C. Li and S. L. Cooper, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1992, 44, 3, 409. 50. G.L. Wilkes and R. Wildnauer, Journal of Applied Physics, 1975, 46, 10, 4148. 51. A. Lilaonitkul, J.C. West and S.L. Cooper, Journal of Macromolecular Science Part B: Physics, 1976, 12, 4, 563. 52. W.P. Brennan, Thermal Analysis Application Study, Perkin Elmer Corporation Order number TAAS 22, 1977, 22, p.16. 53. A.S. Cantor, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 2000, 77, 4, 826. 54. M. Vitali and M. Pizzoli, Macromolecular Chemistry and Physics, 1998, 199, 3, 429. 55. C.B. Wang and S.L. Cooper, Journal of Polymer Science, Polymer Physics Edition, 1983, 21, 1, 11. 56. N.R. Manoj, P.P. De and S.K. De, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1993, 49, 1, 133. 127
Thermal Analysis of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials 57. F. Pruneda, J.J. Sunol, F. Andreu-Mateu and X. Colom, Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry, 2005, 80, 1, 187. 58. K.T. Varughese, G.B. Nando, P.P. De and S.K. De, Journal of Materials Science, 1988, 23, 11, 3894. 59. K.T. Varughese, P.P. De, S.K. Sanyal and S.K. De, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1989, 37, 9, 2537. 60. P. Ramesh and S.K. De, Journal of Materials Science, 1991, 26, 11, 2846. 61. R. Alex and P.P. De, Kautschuk Gummi Kunststoffe, 1990, 43, 11, 1002. 62. R. Alex, P.P. De and S.K. De, Polymer Communications, 1990, 31, 3, 118. 63. S. Mukhopadhyay, P.P. De and S.K. De, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, 1991, 43, 2, 347. 64. S. Mukhopadhyay and S.K. De, Journal of Materials Science, 1990, 25, 9, 4027. 65. R. Alex, P.P. De, and S.K. De, Polymer Communications, 1990, 31, 9, 366. 66. R. Alex, P.P. De, and S.K. De, Kautschuk Gummi Kunststoffe, 1991, 44, 4, 333. 67. J.B. Nagode and C.M. Roland, Polymer, 1991, 32, 3, 505. 68. C. M. Roland, P.G. Santangelo, Z. Baram and J. Runt, Macromolecules, 1994 27, 19, 5382. 69. S. Mukhopadhyay and S.K. De, Polymer, 1991, 32, 7, 1223. 70. N.R. Manoj, S.K. De and P.P. De, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1993, 66, 4, 550. 71. H-Q. Xie, Y-J. Pan and J-S. Guo, Journal of Macromolecular Science, Physics, 2003, B42, 2, 257. 72. C.M. Roland, Macromolecules, 1987, 20, 10, 2557. 73. C.A. Trask and C.M. Roland, Macromolecules, 1989, 22, 1, 256. 74. K. Yamada and Y. Funayama, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1990, 63, 5, 669. 75. P.A. Marsh, A. Voet, L.D. Price, and T.J. Mullens, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1968, 41, 2, 344. 128
Applications of DSC and TGA for the Characterisation of Rubbers and Rubbery Materials 76. A.K. Sircar and T.G. Lamond, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 1975, 48, 2, 301. 77. A.K. Naskar, S.K. De, A.K. Bhowmick, P. Pramanik and R. Mukhopadhyay, Rubber Chemistry and Technology, 2000, 73, 5, 9