Trollope and the Magazines Gendered Issues in Mid-Victorian Britain
Mark W. Turner
Copyright material from www.palgra...
24 downloads
1335 Views
15MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Trollope and the Magazines Gendered Issues in Mid-Victorian Britain
Mark W. Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
TROLLOPE AND THE MAGAZINES
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Also by Mark W. Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
FROM AUTHOR TO TEXT: Re-reading George Eliot's Romola (co-editor with Caroline Levine)
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Gendered Issues in Mid-Victorian Britain Mark W. Turner
flfl
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Trollope and the Magazines
PA
First published in Great Britain 2000 by
MACMILLAN PRESS LTD Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS and London Companies and representatives throughout the world
ISBN 0-333-72982-X
First published in the United States of America 2000 by
flfl
ST. MARTIN'S PRESS, INC., Scholarly and Reference Division, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010 ISBN 0-312-22176-2 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Turner, Mark W. Trollope and the magazines : gendered issues in mid-Victorian Britain / Mark W. Turner. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-312-22176-2 1. Trollope, Anthony, 1815-1882 —Political and social views. 2. Periodicals, Publishing of—England—History— 19th century. 3. Trollope, Anthony, 1815-1882—Relations with publishers. 4. Literature and society—England—History— 19th century. 5. Literature publishing—England—History— 19th century. 6. Serial publication of books—History — 19th century. 7. Social problems in literature. 8. Sex role in literature. I. Title. PR5688.P6T87 1999 823\8-dc21 98-55438 CIP
© Mark W. Turner 2000 All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P 0LP. Any person who does any unauthorised act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The author has asserted his right to be identified as the author of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. 10 09 08
9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 07 06 05 04 03 02 01 00
Printed and bound in Great Britain by Antony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham, Wiltshire
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
For my parents, and in memory of Joe Walsh
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
This page intentionally left blank
List of Abbreviations
viii
Acknowledgements
ix
List of Illustrations
xi
1 2 3 4
5
Introduction: Trollope in the 1990s
1
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space in Cornhill Magazine
7
Uncovering Periodical Identities: Good Words and the Rejection of Rachel Ray
48
Launching a Hybrid: The Belton Estate in the Fortnightly Review
92
Transitions: Phineas Finn and Masculinity in Saint Pauls Magazine
141
The Editor as Predator in Saint Pauls Magazine
183
Conclusion: Towards a Cultural Critique of Victorian Periodicals
227
Appendices
241
Bibliography
243
Index
259
vn 10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Contents
A Letters
Anthony Trollope, An Autobiography The Letters of Anthony Trollope, 2 vols, ed. N. John Hall Wellesley Wellesley Index to Victorian Periodicals, 5 vols, ed. Walter Houghton Full details of these works appear in the Bibliography. Note that I usually refer to Trollope's fiction in its periodical form (novel chapter, periodical volume, and page number) rather than subsequent book editions.
vm 10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Abbreviations
I was introduced to the fiction of Anthony Trollope by Mary Saunders, under whose tutelage I read through the Barchester novels as an undergraduate. Her enthusiasm became my addiction, for which many thanks. I began this project on Trollope and magazines at Birkbeck College, University of London, working with Laurel Brake, whose research into the nineteenth-century press remains a model for my own and whose tremendously sharp critical eye helped to improve my own thinking about nineteenthcentury cultural production and gendered issues. Thanks to her for her example and friendship. The Postgraduate Theory Seminar at Birkbeck College was important in helping me think through some of the theoretical issues with which my study engages. John Sutherland, Joanne Shattock, and Michael Slater made helpful suggestions, and Linda K. Hughes read parts of several chapters and her comments always led to improvements. The Department of English at Roehampton Institute has been a congenial and supportive place in which to finish the manuscript and to discuss ideas offered here. Jane Pringle and Ishtla Singh at Roehampton were invaluable in offering computing advice when producing the final manuscript. I gratefully acknowledge the many conversations (and cups of coffee) in the company of Caterina Albano, Gill Gregory, Julian Sheather, and Caroline Levine. Caroline, in addition to being a model of intellectual liveliness, is a wonderful colleague and collaborator, and an even more wonderful friend. Other friends who have been supportive over a number of years include Ella Bennett, Tim Burton, Neil Constable, Julian Cowley, Carter Foster, Erik Friedly, Michaela Giebelhausen, Chris Goodhart, Elaine Huxley, Nicole Pohl and Rebecca Wilson. Joe Clement was very important personally in the final stages of this project. This study could not have been completed without the loving support of Corin Bennett, whose generosity and understanding (and proofreading) enabled me throughout. My work was only made viable through the support of my parents, who made this project much less a struggle than it might have been, and to whom this book is happily dedicated. To them my debt is greatest. IX
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Acknowledgements
Acknowledgemen ts
I wish to acknowledge the support of a number of institutions, which have helped in different ways. For research materials, I wish to thank the following: Birkbeck College Library, Bodleian Library, British Library, Library of Congress, Michigan State University Library, New York Public Library, Reform Club Library and University of London Library. The Department of English at Birkbeck College, the Department of Literary Studies at University of Luton, and the Research Centre and the Department of English at Roehampton Institute London all provided me with funds to deliver conference papers based on my research. The Research Society for Victorian Periodicals conferences provided a stimulating forum to discuss many of the issues presented here, and a congenial way to tap into the network of others working in the field. My thanks to the British Library for permission to reproduce the illustrations in Chapters 2 and 4. Versions of some of the chapters here have appeared previously in different forms, as articles or chapters in books. My thanks to the publications and editors for permission to reprint from the following: 'Gendered Issues: Intertextuality in The Small House at Allington in Cornhill Magazine, Victorian Periodicals Review 26:4 (Winter 1993), 228-34. 'Towards a Cultural Critique of Victorian Periodicals', Studies in Newspaper and Periodical History, 1995 Annual, 111-26. 'Hybrid Journalism: Women and the Progressive Fortnightly, in Reading Journalism and Literature: New Perspectives on Gender, Modernity and Modernism, ed. Kate Campbell (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, forthcoming). 'Saint Pauls Magazine and the Project of Masculinity 7 , in NineteenthCentury Media and the Construction of Identities, ed. Laurel Brake, Bill Bell and David Finkelstein (Basingstoke and London: Macmillan, forthcoming).
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
X
1.1 1.2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 4.1
'Will His Eyes Open?', Cornhill Magazine (July 1863) 'Manoli', Cornhill Magazine (September 1862) Cover of Good Words (January 1860) Advertisement for Good Words (January 1861) Frontispiece to The Leisure Hour Cover of The Christian Guest (May 1859) Cover of Good Words (February 1860) Cover of Good Words (January 1861) Advertisement for Saint Pauls Magazine
XI
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
32 33 60 61 65 69 82 83 143
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Illustrations
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
This page intentionally left blank
The 1990s in Britain has proved an interesting cultural moment to be studying the work of Anthony Trollope. His novels appear to be more popular now than ever before, and a great deal of interest has been taken in his life. No fewer than four biographies have been published in roughly a decade, each emphasizing various aspects of the popular Victorian's work, each producing a slightly different version of the man. Trollope's entire oeuvre is being republished in a uniform series by Penguin, and other publishers are rushing to print his most popular novels. The large and influential Trollope Society has a project under way to republish all of his novels in hardback form by the year 2000, and their efforts to promote the author have led to a Trollope plaque in Poets' Corner, Westminster Abbey When the former Prime Minister John Major announced on a popular British radio programme his love of Trollope and especially of Lily Dale (with numerous dutiful ministers following suit), it seemed that Trollope's place as a cultural icon of the establishment was secured. In many ways, Trollope has been taken up for what is loosely termed Victorian values. Just what those values are is difficult to define, as anyone who has seriously studied the period will determine. But it must be acknowledged that, at least popularly, there is a prevalent conservative version of Trollope in the 1990s. Conservative readings of his work fit neatly into a heritage version of Britain which constructs an imaginary past of green hills and rural comfort, an image promulgated in the numerous films and novels in recent years which reconstruct Britain's past in particular ways. It is perhaps not surprising that at a time when rural sporting pastimes such as foxhunting are violently opposed in the Home Counties, Trollope seemingly represents an era when the countryside could manage its own affairs. On the surface, many of Trollope's contemporaries who are still widely read do not offer the same comfortable image of town and country. For example, Dickens's novels do not typically provide the reassurances 1 10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Introduction: Trollope in the 1990s
Trollope and the Magazines
of a Trollope text, since Dickens takes pains to articulate the effects of industrialism in cities and in the lower classes. Trollope, for a fin-de-siecle, multi-cultural Britain searching for a coherent national identity, represents a golden age of Victorian optimism. Scholars, however, have not necessarily shared this view of Trollope's conservatism. In 1992, in an article in Literature Interpretation Theory, several authors of important full-length studies of Trollope were asked to consider how they would approach his works now, given 'the newer trends of theory and criticism'. 1 James Kincaid declares that he would 'try to deconstruct the liberal position I took then, the liberal position and its formal extensions into the discussions of the novels' (176). Ruth apRoberts claims she would 'lean on Bakhtin', asserting that 'Trollope is the most Bakhtinian of the Victorians' (178). Robert Polhemus, too, considers that Trollope is 'positively Bakhtinian and even neo-Bakhtinian' (184). Juliet McMaster, recognizing Trollope's nuanced depictions of character, believes 'characters who are so busy constructing themselves almost cry out for deconstruction' (179). Robert Tracy deems Trollope 'a prime candidate for critical attention in terms of the Barthes-Foucault notion of ecriture: writing that attains an impersonal objective existence of its own, ind e p e n d e n t of author or circumstance' (181). John Halperin rejects the usefulness of 'French post-structuralism of the last two decades' but accepts that feminist criticism offers ways of understanding the vexed question of Trollope's position on the single woman. This exercise in returning to the Trollope critics is revealing, not least because they all are eager to engage with contemporary theoretical thinking - deconstruction, feminism, new historicism, Marxism - in re-evaluating an author embraced by a conservative establishment. In the chapters that follow, I engage with a number of theoretical debates while rethinking Trollope's fiction in the context of periodicals. This study is not only (or even primarily) about Trollope; it is not a traditional single author study While Trollope is the figure that in some sense unifies my discussion of middleclass periodicals in the 1860s, I am not concerned to make broad claims about the author's oeuvre. Most full-length studies of Trollope - including those of the critics above - are involved in strictly author-based criticism. Even an estimable study of Trollope's serial fiction, Writing by Numbers by Mary Hamer, narrowly focuses on the author's writing method without considering other ways of
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
2
3
discussing fiction in parts. 2 By contrast, I use Trollope as a case study which grounds a theoretical consideration of the periodical as a cultural form within the broadly defined fields of literary and cultural criticism. While Trollope studies and our understanding of his fiction are a focus, my work can equally be seen in other discourses around gender, nineteenth-century print culture, media history and current debates about the nature of English studies broadly. One consequence of studying Trollope's serials in the context of periodicals is that the single author often disappears in chapters. However, my remit is to study not the single author or the single work exclusively, rather the relationship between author, serial, periodical and literary culture generally. This requires a certain amount of juggling; therefore, chapters move from discussions of individual serial parts, articles and single periodical issues to discussions of broader cultural issues in other periodicals and texts. Sometimes this creates tensions and gaps in chapters, but such disruptions are in the spirit of periodical literature, in which seams expose the nature of the work. What links (if not unifies) my study of Cornhill, Good Words, the Fortnightly Review, and Saint Pauls, is Trollope, but I am concerned primarily to explore the cultural discourses with which his serializations are engaged and the ways these discourses circulate within the periodical text. Trollope and the Magazines is not a comprehensive overview of literary periodicals in the 1860s, nor is it an attempt to discuss all of the magazines with which Trollope was associated. One of the approaches in periodical studies in the past has been to try to get hold of a stable archive, to provide an encyclopaedic range of knowledge about Victorian periodicals. The results of such work - for example, the invaluable Wellesley Index - have benefited scholars immeasurably. However, I am not writing a history of magazines and I am not concerned to document all of Trollope's interventions in the magazine marketplace; rather, I focus on a range of different periodicals for which he contributed, in order to show the ways cultural debates in and around the magazines enliven and enlighten our reading of his fiction. I borrow from various theoretical methods - from cultural materialist to recent media theories - to indicate the numerous ways in which periodical literature can be fruitfully considered. My point is to open out the study of periodicals, to argue for the
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Introduction
Trollope and the Magazines
richness of this literature as a site for a range of critical thinking, to suggest to readers of Victorian fiction the need to consider the materiality of the text and context. Chapter 1 introduces two different ways of approaching a periodical text. In the first part of the chapter, I look at The Small House at Allington in Cornhill and consider differing conceptions of the domestic ideology of gendered spheres in a single number of the magazine. How is the single woman constructed differently by Trollope and in Cornhill non-fiction? How does it relate to the magazine's manifesto to present non-controversial family reading, and how does it relate to discussions of single women outside the text? I go on to discuss the way that gendered space within the magazine is constructed by the non-fiction, which is written by a core group of men. Chapter 2 considers a serialization that never was. Rachel Ray was intended to be published in the popular monthly Good Words, a magazine that patterned itself on Cornhill but was cheaper and more religious. However, despite widespread advertising heralding Trollope's upcoming serial, Rachel Ray was rejected. I argue that the novel had to be sacrificed because of the difficulty the magazine was having in establishing its own identity. Good Words was not in a strong enough position to hold off the Evangelical protests which accompanied the thought of a Trollope serial in a religious magazine. In Chapter 3, I continue to consider periodical identity in my discussion of the radical Fortnightly Review. The periodical was a hybrid of Review journalism and popular magazine elements. The tone of the magazine was partly defined by the all-male Positivists who largely guided the magazine's nonfiction. I argue that Trollope's serial The Belton Estate was an (unsuccessful) bid for women readers, engaging in women's reform issues which the non-fiction almost completely ignores. I also discuss the magazine's primary legacy to mid-Victorian periodicals - signed journalism - and show how the question 'to sign, or not to sign' (as one periodical put it) can be seen in the context of the rise of the celebrity author, the star. Chapters 4 and 5 examine Saint Pauls Magazine, edited for three years by Trollope at the end of the 1860s. In a competitive shilling monthly market which appeals to the family reader, Trollope seems largely to target male readers. He wanted to edit a political magazine, and his fiction and non-fiction indicate that his focus was on male subjects and male readers. The inaugural serial, Phineas Finn, was Trollope's first overtly parliamentary novel, and I read
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
4
5
it as a male Bildungsroman; this preoccupation with male subjects continues in the story series, 'An Editor's Tales', and in the supplement, Ralph the Heir. I also consider how Trollope uses the periodical to generate books and how the ambiguous functions of author and editor are negotiated and defined. I have limited my discussion of Trollope and periodicals to the 1860s for a number of reasons. In 1860, Trollope returned to London from Ireland, and his first serialization, Framley Parsonage, launched the Cornhill Magazine. Cornhill essentially defined and opened up a new periodicals market in Britain - the middle-class family market. These readers, together with the circulating-library readers (and the two were not necessarily different), formed the bulk of Trollope's audience. In the 1860s Trollope's position as a market leader continually grew and he perhaps reached his peak of popularity in this decade, publishing in family magazines, political reviews, and religious periodicals. Certainly, in the 1870s, he was earning less money from his serials and was less enthusiastically received by critics. The reasons why Trollope's popularity in the periodicals market declined are worth rethinking, but could form a separate and distinct full-length study At the end of the 1860s, in the context of a saturated shilling monthly market and after numerous years of experience in a variety of periodicals, Trollope edited his own magazine. It was a watershed moment for Trollope, and it was a particularly interesting moment for a new shilling monthly trying to define itself in a glutted market. The 1860s, then, provides a full and varied period in which to consider Trollope's movements in the periodicals market and to explore developments in middle-class periodical culture generally. I pick u p Trollope's story in the network of magazine publishing at a time when he was consolidating his position in the system, and I leave him at the point when his presence in that market (as editor and contributor) was greatest. As I have stressed, Trollope and the Magazines is not simply a study of Trollope. I hope to encourage readers to go back to the periodicals and to consider exactly what it means to read fiction in this specific context. In my conclusion, I pull together a number of the theoretical questions which arise in the study of serial fiction and periodical literature. First, I map out, in a general way, the field of periodical studies, an expanding and exciting interdisciplinary field which borrows from literary criticism, history, media studies and other disciplines. As the title of my conclusion
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Introduction
Trollope and the Magazines
suggests, this book is not presented as the final word on how to study periodical literature. Rather than provide a rigid model for working with Victorian periodicals, I indicate some of the problems I have had to consider and the ways I have sought to address questions around issues such as collective authorship, textual plurality, and cultural production. Part of what makes working with Victorian periodicals so lively and challenging are the difficult questions one must pose - about the nature of reading and production, for example. In my Conclusion, I suggest some of the ways we might consider such questions. One of the joys in writing about Trollope and Victorian magazines in the 1990s has been in watching the field of periodical studies grow into a lively and interdisciplinary field of study. I hope that Trollope and the Magazines complements the interesting work being written on a range of issues in the nineteenth-century press and adds to our understanding of the vast literature of Victorian periodicals.
Notes 1. N. John Hall, James R. Kincaid, Ruth apRoberts, Juliet McMaster, Robert Tracy, Robert M. Polhemus, and John Halperin, 'Trollopians Reduces/ Literature Interpretation Theory 3:3 (1992), 175. Further references to this article are noted parenthetically in the text. 2. Other critics have noted the tendency of Trollope critics to make general claims about the whole of his work. See Walter Kendrick, The NovelMachine: The Theory and Fiction of Anthony Trollope (Baltimore, MD and London: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1980), xi: the usual method of criticizing Trollope involves 'surveying the whole of his work a novel at a time, saying a little about every novel and always too little about each/ Note that some subsequent studies have tried to narrow the focus; for example, see Stephen Wall, Trollope and Character (London and Boston: Faber and Faber, 1988), which emphasizes the importance of the two series.
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
6
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space in Cornhill Magazine One of the ways we can begin to appreciate the complexity of serial literature is to focus on the relationship between the serial novel and the periodical. Such an approach poses its own set of questions: what are some of the ways we might read the fiction both as an integral part of the magazine and as only one element of the single magazine issue rubbing up against all of the other contributions? How do the articles and fiction in a magazine intersect with cultural debates outside the magazine? How does the magazine carve out its own identity - create its niche market - from the other literary magazines and texts continually in circulation? I assume that intertextuality is the most useful methodological approach to help us understand the intersections and overlappings which occur within and across magazines. This suggests that periodicals are essentially dialogic literary texts. Serialization, in which only a small part of a larger text is put into play alongside all sorts of different texts, provides the opportunity to see how debates and discourses within a periodical reverberate in the wider cultural world outside the magazine. In this chapter, I want to consider two ways of reading the periodical which point to the importance of intertextuality in reading magazine literature. Firstly, I read closely a single issue of Cornhill Magazine and consider the ways we might read an instalment of Trollope's The Small House at Allington in relation to other contributions in the same issue, and in relation to other cultural material outside the magazine. Secondly, I focus on the non-fiction contributions in Cornhill during the early years of the magazine in the 1860s, when The Small House was being serialized, and I suggest that the non-fiction, written by a core of male writers, 7 10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
1
8
Trollope and the Magazines
TROLLOPE IN CORNHILL The Small House at Allington was serialized in Cornhill Magazine between September 1862 and April 1864. Trollope began the manuscript written for the 20-part serial form in May of 1862 and had completed it in February 1863. The serialization appeared six months after his novel The Struggles of Brown, Jones and Robinson, also serialized in Cornhill, and just before the last part-issue of Orley Farm.1 Trollope received £2500 from CornhilVs publisher George Smith, two and a half times what he received for Framley Parsonage only two years before, a mark of both the marketconsecrated a u t h o r ' s popularity and Smith's generosity and business acumen. 2 The Small Llouse continued the mutually beneficial relationship between the author and the periodical begun by Trollope's Framley Parsonage success which inaugurated the magazine in 1860 under Thackeray's editorship. Although not all of Trollope's novels in the early 1860s were equally successful, they remained continually in print. 3 All of Trollope's novels after Framley Parsonage were conceived of and written in serial parts, so his method of writing serials should be integral when considering the publication details of any of his works. His writing habits were first revealed publicly in his posthumously published Autobiography (1883) and have been commented upon extensively ever since. He would write for three hours each morning at a pace of 250 words per quarter-hour, a process which he guessed would produce three full triple-deckers in a year had he not other writing and rereading to slow his pace. As it was, he was able to produce a backlog of at least one novel, sometimes as many as three, awaiting publication (A 272-3). Trollope kept his day job at the Post Office until 1867, but his rapid method of production points to a writer who regarded his art as a full profession open to men, a viewpoint less acceptable for men during the early decades of the century. As Gaye Tuchman argues in Edging Women Out, 'before 1840 at least half of all novelists
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
speaks largely to a male readership despite the open intentions of the magazine when it was founded. Overall, I am interested in the ways gender is conceptualized by reading an instalment of a novel in a single issue, and in the ways textual space is demarcated by and in the circulating discourses of the magazine.
9
were women; by 1917 most high-culture novelists were men.' 4 She refers to the period 1840-79 as 'the period of invasion' when the novel was revalued by men as a legitimate form of culture. Increasingly throughout this period, as fiction attracted status, more men became novelists, and with new publishing technology controlled by men, the business of the novel was redefined by men (such as Trollope) as a male profession. 5 Trollope's meticulous writing diaries and method of production attest to how seriously he regarded novel writing as a profession, and it was precisely this very businesslike approach to his fiction that led detractors after the publication of the posthumous Autobiography to devalue his writing as unartistic. Like all good realists, Trollope claimed that 'a vast proportion of the teaching of the day' could be found in the pages of novels, and he insisted that novelists appreciate the 'excellence of their calling' (A 217, 220). A professional attitude and writing method place him at the very centre of a publishing industry whose interests in writing were increasingly associated with mass production and mass sales. After all, the phenomenon of serialization in the nineteenth century was partly conceived of as a marketing plan to sell the expensive three-volume novel in large numbers to the circulating libraries: there is a commercial system, then, which links the serial, the book form, the circulating library and the subscriber-reader. Between the covers of all midcentury novels and periodicals lurk the businessmen of the circulating library and publishing giants: fiction and finance were intricately interwoven at mid-century (not for the first time, of course), and Trollope's Autobiography bears witness to the life of a professional writer within a revolutionizing and increasingly competitive culture industry 6 Trollope began using the serial part to organize the production of his novels at the same time that he became associated with Cornhill late in 1859. He published his last Cornhill serialization beginning in 1866 but never abandoned serialization as a creative and organizing principle. During the first half of the 1860s, he was still learning how to manage the constraints and realize the possibilities inherent in serial writing; this decade found him gradually mastering the serial form and enjoying the period of his greatest popularity. 7 The implications of such a situation are significant: he gained control over and managed subtlety in his multi-plot structures, and he satisfied his personal need for public
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
Trollope and the Magazines
acceptance so obvious in the Autobiography. Neither of these would have been possible without the sort of relationship the author enjoyed with Cornhill and its huge readership. The importance of Trollope's association with Cornhill should not be underestimated. He submitted Framley Parsonage at a time when he was planning a move from Ireland back to London, acting on his belief that a novelist 'ought to live within the reach of the publishers, the clubs, and the dinner parties of the metropolis' (A 132). George Smith's jovial, club-like dinners for Cornhill contributors offered an entree into the literary culture which Trollope so coveted. 8 However, Smith had as much reason for thanks as Trollope since it was largely Framley Parsonage which secured the legendary early circulation figures for the magazine. As John Hall recognizes, there was an interdependent relationship between Smith and Trollope in the early years of magazine. 9 In May 1859, three years before the serialization of the Small House, Trollope was regarded as the most popular writer of his day by E.S. Dallas at The Times, who (in something of a backhanded complement) called him 'the most successful author - that is to say, of the circulating library sort.' 10 Orley Farm, Brown, Jones and Robinson, The Small House, North America, Tales of All Countries (second series), Rachel Ray, and Can You Forgive Her? - all of these overlapped either in book or serial form between 1862 and 1864. n Dallas's comment, therefore, might be equally applicable in the autumn of 1862, when the story of Lily Dale was beginning to unfold in Cornhill. Why such a special Trollope-Cornfo'// relationship should appear and the reasons for its popular appeal with the circulating library reader need to be explained. Thackeray's open letter to potential contributors in November 1859 describes what he and Smith had envisioned for the new periodical: . . . fiction of course must form a part, but only a part, of our entertainment. We want, on the other hand, as much reality as possible - discussion and narrative of events interesting to the public, personal adventures and observations, familiar reports of scientific discovery, description of Social Institutions - quicuid agunt homines - a 'Great Eastern/ a battle in China, a RaceCourse, a popular Preacher - there is hardly any subject we don't want to hear about, from lettered and instructed men who are competent to speak on it.12
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
10
11
Thackeray is keen here to emphasize that his literary magazine would not be dominated by fiction, and in a letter to Trollope a few days earlier, he says 'one of our chief objects in this magazine is the getting out of novel spinning, and back into the real world'. 13 The 'real world' is presumed by Thackeray to be defined through the non-fiction articles which were predominantly written by men. But the editor-novelist modifies what is to be Cornhill's construction of reality later in the open letter: If our friends have good manners, a good education, and write in good English, the company, I am sure, will be all the better pleased; and the guests, whatever their rank, age, sex be, will be glad to be addressed by well-educated gentlemen and women. . . . There are points on which agreement is impossible, and on these we need not touch. At our social table, we shall suppose the ladies and children always present; we shall not set u p rival politicians by the ears; we shall listen to every guest who has an apt word to say; and, I hope, induce clergymen of various denominations to say grace in their turn. 14 And Leonard Huxley, writing in the Cornhill in 1922, affirmed how the magazine 'stood aside from current politics, bookreviewing, ephemeral topics, the clash of controversial opinion and such, along with theology'. 1 5 The discussion of reality Thackeray hopes to induce is intended to be void of controversy - no political or religious partisanship - and caters to particular and unmistakably class- and gender-specific assumptions. And it was Thackeray's own Roundabout Papers which set the magazine's gentlemanly tone. 16 Cornhill's 'real world', as denned by Thackeray's open letter to contributors, was limited and specific, and what is absent in the magazine indicates an editorial policy. Reality, then, was a construct within the periodical's pages, defined and regulated by a type of censorship. When Trollope comments in his Autobiography on the virtues of Framley Parsonage it is the lifelike quality of Mary Robarts that he highlights, and, indeed, it was his true-to-life representations that would continually interest his contemporaries. 17 But even Trollope, along with Elizabeth Barrett Browning and John Ruskin, were censured under Cornhill's code of morally sound reality during Thackeray's two and a half years.18 The editorial outlook largely guided the magazine long after Thackeray's resignation in March 1862, although his shadow was
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
Trollope and the Magazines
longer than declining circulation figures might merit. 19 Preconceptions in Cornhill contributions, like the particular definition of 'reality', need to be kept in mind when examining closely the contents of a particular issue or the periodical as a whole. On becoming editor in 1871, Leslie Stephen wrote in a letter, 'what can one make of a magazine which excludes the only subjects in which reasonable men take any interest; politics and religion'. 20 Stephen was reacting to the Thackeray legacy of noncontroversial contributions, but his comment also demarcates the boundaries of a magazine defined by constructions of gendered reading. The absence of overtly male subjects like politics and religion in effect privileged women readers, and women's reading regulated Cornhill contributions, in so far as anything deemed unsuitable for women would not be published. Thackeray is explicit in his wish that Cornhill be suitable for women and children 'always present', and thereby a family magazine. Cornhill's version of reality constructed female readers and female reading (along with male readers and reading), and the contents of each issue were restricted accordingly. Choosing Cornhill contributions to suit a female audience, the editors were defining the magazine according to gender, and the exclusion of politics and religion was, in a sense, an emasculation. Although many articles published were specifically aimed at men and written within a male discourse, none approached a serious discussion of theological or political ideas controversial to the reader in the way the heavy quarterlies or even a monthly like Blackwood's might. Cornhill, the most successful of the new shilling monthlies, participated in defining a new periodical literature in Britain - the middle-class family shilling monthly - demarcated by gendered boundaries, but family periodicals were also guided by their role in the larger publishing industry. Cornhill fiction like Trollope's, so popular at Mudie's and the other circulating libraries, was destined for the drawing-room for all eyes to see. However, the prerequisite for drawing-room fiction was morality as defined by men like Mr. Mudie. Reacting to the tyranny of the circulating libraries, George Moore writes in the Pall Mall Gazette in 1884 that at the head . . . of English literature, sits a tradesman, who considers himself qualified to decide the most delicate artistic question that may be raised, and who crushes out of sight any artistic aspiration he may deem pernicious. 21
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
12
13
Men like Mudie could denounce a new novel, as happened to George Moore, and thereby severely limit its readership and sales. For a publisher to realize a profit on a new three-volume novel, it had to sell large numbers to the circulating libraries, and publishers depended on the libraries to buy the expensive triple-deckers before cheap editions of novels were published. Serialization in magazines like Cornhill was advance advertising for new novels; however, serialized novels destined for the libraries had to adhere to Mudie's moral code. Businessmen like Mudie, at least indirectly, influenced the content of serialized novels in middle-class family magazines aimed at the circulating-library audience. Trollope's Cornhill fiction fits comfortably into such a publishing system, but much of Cornhill's domestic fiction was precisely what writers like Moore and others a generation later would react against so strongly. Again in the Pall Mall article, Moore laments that English literature was so limited in its subjects by the moral imposition of the libraries: 'What is nature but religion and morals? and the circulating library forbids discussion on such subjects.' The subtraction of these two important elements of life throws the reading of fiction into the hands of young girls and widows of sedentary habits; for them political questions have no interest, and it is by this final amputation that humanity becomes headless, trunkless, limbless, and is converted into the pulseless, non-vertebrate jelly-fish sort of thing which . . . is sent from the London depot and scattered t h r o u g h the drawing-rooms of the United Kingdom. 22 Moore genders fiction as female. He believes that men have been cut off, disembodied from literature because serious male subjects had been censored in fiction since at least mid-century. A novel like The Small House might have been objected to a generation later, it could be argued, because its appeal was perceived to have been primarily to female readers. The introduction of gender, then, is central when examining circulating-library fiction at mid-century, partly because the g e n d e r i n g of both magazines and novels defined a middle-class, popular literature that would be fervently opposed by the 1880s. Serialized between 1862-64, The Small House appeared in a periodical which followed the principles of Thackeray's editorial legacy: avoid controversy and assume a female reader. During
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
Trollope and the Magazines
this time, George Smith undertook responsibilities as editor, with G.H. Lewes and Frederick Greenwood as sub-editors. 23 The magazine maintained high standards in both fiction and essays, relying on a core of frequent male contributors. Random examinations of Cornhill issues during The Small House serialization show common class and gender positions. For example, the November 1862 issue (which will be discussed at length below) contains instalments of George Eliot's Romola, Trollope's Small House, Anne Ritchie's Story of Elizabeth, in addition to a 'Roundabout Paper', a travel article by Trollope, and non-fiction pieces on the use of tobacco, the life of professional thieves, the supply of Indian cotton, and the sensational case of a female murderer. The fiction is mostly domestic, with courtship and marriage plots; the non-fiction addresses a comfortable middle-class reader, one who would appreciate Trollope's comments about travelling to Holland or Francis Anstie's defence of the male indulgence, tobacco. In the July 1863 issue, we find similar concerns. Both Romola and The Small House continue, and articles range from professional etiquette to stage adaptations of Shakespeare. Another middle-class pleasure, food, is discussed, and we are warned that overeating by the wealthy may be as harmful as undereating among lower classes. There is a description of how amateur music is no longer confined to the upper classes and how performance is becoming part of the middle-class evening routine. The final instalment of The Small House in April 1864, appeared with Thackeray's Denis Duval and Frederick Greenwood's Margaret Denzil's History. One article gossips about royal christenings, another about hunting with the French emperor's hounds. One contributor dismisses biographies which have nothing pleasant to say, while Matthew Arnold distinguishes between pagan and Christian sentiment. The April 1864 issue is less cosy than the earliest Cornhills, but we see Thackeray's non-controversial editorial policy apparent in each issue; a watchful eye is cast to the female reader, and the tone is constructed to please and comfort, almost to pet, the middle classes. The fiction, poetry and non-fiction rarely rebuke the readership, and then only mildly, whereas middle-class ideological assumptions - about leisure, manners, marriage, class - are generally reinforced and perpetuated. Although there is a definite sense of homogeneity of intent in the contents, no periodical (indeed, no literary text) presents a wholly uncomplicated view of society Within the non-fiction and fiction, as we shall see below, there
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
14
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
15
READING A SINGLE ISSUE To begin to unpack some of the ideological baggage within the periodical, it is useful first to examine a single periodical issue as text. I am not concerned here to provide a historical reconstruction of the Victorian serial-reading experience, although this method of reading across an issue inevitably raises questions about how contemporary readers would have approached magazines. We cannot presume, for example, that readers started at the beginning and read through an issue, front to back as one would read a book, and some contributions were more likely than others to be read depending upon the reader's gender; simply put, how we understand the larger text changes according to how the issue is read. Considering the arrangement of fiction and non-fiction in the November 1862 issue, we notice how evenly the two are interleaved. Until the turn of the century, and with few exceptions, serial fiction would remain the first entry in all Cornhill issues, even though the magazine was supposedly dominated by nonfiction. The same cannot be said of comparable magazines like Blackwood's and Macmillan's, which led with both fiction and nonfiction. The arrangement of the textual space and the whole physicality of an issue might also influence the reading of it, unlike the book, which generally presents only one way of reading. Although I am less interested in the problems of readers' responses than in the textual possibilities of reading periodicals, it has to be acknowledged that alongside the periodical number is a reader who can alter the text - by choosing what to read and in what order. It is necessary to draw out the implications of reading periodicals to understand how this essentially contextual approach to literature is part of the overall intertextuality within any given periodical issue. 24 Following the work of Mikhail Bakhtin, Julia Kristeva interprets his conception of the 'literary word' as an intersection of textual surfaces rather than a point (a fixed meaning), as a dialogue
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
was some space for discussion, if not vehement debate, of topical issues. And the role of intertextuality in the scene of periodical reading creates numerous individual readings which challenge any notion of unity in a single issue.
16
Trollope and the Magazines
The interaction between the various components of a given periodical number - whether that interaction creates contradiction, debate, tension, or cohesion - is integral to the way ideology is formed within the periodical press. The function of intertextuality in such a reading also relates to remarks by Michel Foucault pointing to ways we have traditionally delimited our understanding of literature - on approaches to 'the book' and 'the oeuvre'. 26 Using the periodical issue as text decentres traditional literary study, which has focused on reading the novel, for example, in continuum, that is, in book form. Such a tradition has privileged the position that novels are and ought to be read as books. The presumption that to read a novel means to read a book would be, for Foucault, a 'unity of discourse' which needs to be avoided: the frontiers of a book are never clear-cut: beyond the title, the first lines, and the last full stop, beyond its internal configuration and its autonomous form, it is caught up in a system of references to other books, other texts, other sentences: it is a node within a network. 27 This by now familiar (but still provocative) poststructural assertion of the fallibility of the book becomes more significant if we accept that literature, like so many Victorian novels, is not always in the first instance published as a book. The Small House at Allington was gradually unfolding as a serial for two years before its twovolume publication, and the original serialized text ought to be as valid a form of study as the books which followed. But reading literature in magazine requires a different approach to the text. What changes when we look at literature in periodicals are the 'rules of formation' - the conditions of existence - within a given discourse, 28 in this case the single periodical issue. The issue is subject to other textual influences brought to it by the writer, the reader, and historical context. Within the space of the issue, the text becomes a literary collective of interacting components which depend on how the text is read: novel chapters may move into a travel article, a poem, a short story, a science article, etc. And as Bakhtin notes, within a single individual text (in this case, the novel),
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
among several writings: that of the writer, the addressee (or the character) and the contemporary or earlier cultural context.25
17
the boundaries between fiction and nonfiction, between literature and non-literature and so forth are not laid up in heaven. Every specific situation is historical. And the growth of literature is not merely development and change within the fixed boundaries of any given definition; the boundaries themselves are constantly changing. 29 In the rest of this chapter and in the chapters that follow, I discuss both the individual text (an article, image, chapter, etc.) and the magazine as text (or, the text within a text), so the changing boundaries Bakhtin describes are especially relevant to the examination of periodical literature. In the end, I want to suggest a range of different approaches we might bring to bear on reading magazine literature. CORNHILL MAGAZINE (NOVEMBER 1862)30 Several critics have already demonstrated how the binary opposition of gendered space - woman/man, inner/outer, private/public, domestic/political, etc. - was constructed in literature from late in the eighteenth century through to the mid-nineteenth century. Nancy Armstrong argues that both male and female writers inscribed in domestic fiction a redefinition of sexual, and therefore social, relations to construct a politically powerful gendered space. 31 Mary Poovey discusses how gendered spheres were constructed ideologically within many discourses 'intimately involved in the development of England's characteristic social institutions, the organization of its most basic economic and legal relations, and in the rationalization of its imperial ambitions'. 32 Marriage was increasingly seen as a moral safeguard and the domestic hearth as the centre of stability. John Ruskin, writing in 1865, called the home 'the place of Peace; the shelter, not only from all injury, but from all terror, doubt and division'. 33 Furthermore, gendered spheres helped delineate class boundaries and create an identity for the middle classes specifically; in this way, the family ideal was used ideologically as a way of consolidating socio-political power. 34 Although there are a number of different, individual voices in the pages of our Cornhill issue, I would argue there is a common conceptualization of issues in terms of gendered spheres. By way of example, examination of
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
Trollope and the Magazines
an instalment from The Small House and an article by H.W. Holland can demonstrate how each participates in contemporary constructions of the domestic ideal. The contributions work intertextually within the magazine by supporting the ideologically gendered space, but also by introducing outside texts into the discussion, either directly or indirectly. Chapters 7, 8, and 9 of The Small House at Allington continue the courtship plots between the girls at the small house and the men staying at the great house. Lily Dale has become engaged to Adolphus Crosbie, a London man-about-town staying with his friend and Lily's cousin, Bernard Dale. The November instalment contrasts Lily's total dedication to Crosbie with his uncertainty about deciding to marry a country girl with no guaranteed fortune. Lily's doctrine of marriage is that, as a girl should never show any preference for a man till circumstances should have fully entitled him to such manifestation, so also should she make no drawback on her love, but pour it forth for his benefit with all her strength, when such circumstances had come to exist. But she was ever feeling that she was not acting up to her theory, now that the time for such practice had come. (ch. 7, 669) Lily's conventional view of love places all responsibility for declarations on the man, who is meant to be the initiator of love while the woman remains dormant until such desire is awoken in her. But once that passion has been set free, she may show it through fidelity and dedication. Lily's inability to follow her theory arises from her rightful belief that 'her lover was not all that he should be' (ch. 7, 667) in his attentions to her. Rather than acknowledge that the problem is Crosbie's and not hers, she blames herself in a long passage of self-deprecating doubt: 'I didn't behave well to h i m / she said to herself; 'I never do. I forget how much he is giving up for me; and then, when anything annoys him, I make it worse instead of comforting him.' And upon that she made accusation against herself that she did not love him half enough, - that she did not let him see how thoroughly and perfectly she loved him. (ch. 7, 669)
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
18
19
Lily tortures herself because she thinks she is not acting as an engaged woman ought to do. She accuses herself when her theory of marriage fails, although the reader knows that it is Crosbie who second-guesses the domestic ideal offered by his engagement to Lily. The instalment opens with Bernard Dale, who hopes to wed Lily's sister Bell according to their uncle's wishes, expressing his total indifference to love and marriage, thereby threatening the code of social cohesion familiar to the Cornhill reader. 35 The following scene shows Crosbie doing the very same thing with regard to Lily; he is only willing to undergo the domestication of marriage if a substantial financial arrangement can be negotiated. Marriage is destructive in Crosbie's eyes, the ruin of his fashionable life as a London bachelor: Was he absolutely about to destroy all the good that he had done for himself throughout the past years of his hitherto successful life? . .. But there was the misery very plain. He must give u p clubs, and his fashion, and all that he had hitherto gained, and be content to live a plain, h u m d r u m , domestic life, with eight hundred a year, and a small house, full of babies. It was not the kind of Elysium for which he had tutored himself. (ch. 7, 668) The implied Cornhill reader coming to such an attack on the virtues of home and family would sympathize with Lily Dale. So taken with Lily's plight were contemporary readers that Trollope mentions how they continually wrote to him begging that Lily marry another suitor (A 179). The serialization of the novel over the following year and a half depicts how jilted Lily rejects the idea of ever marrying, and how Crosbie finds unhappiness in an aristocratic match. The comic resolution of marriage is denied to Lily, and apart from Bell's match with Dr. Crofts, the domestic ideal is continually thwarted. By the third instalment in November, we already see 'the beginning of troubles', announced in the title to Chapter 7. The distinction between city and country, so central in all the Barchester novels, helps delineate gendered spheres: Lily-Country/ Crosbie-City, Country-Private/City-Public. James Kincaid sees the overriding pattern in all of the Barchester novels as an invasion
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
Trollope and the Magazines
by the city of the pastoral country, where the family ideal is nowhere stronger in Trollope's fiction.36 Although Trollope did not initially consider The Small House among the Barchester novels, some readers would have connected cameo appearances like Mr Harding's to the earlier texts and to Trollope's moral centre, located in the countryside of Barsetshire. The intertextual relationship between The Small House and its Barchester predecessors, especially the most recent Framley Parsonage, would have comforted the readers who thought they knew exactly what they would be getting. Readers' concern for Lily, who remains unmarried even in The Last Chronicle of Barset (1867), illustrates their unease with the denial of the expected Barchester comic resolution. Contemporary readers would have seen Crosbie's rejection of the domestic ideal in terms of the ongoing debate over the position of unmarried women. In April 1862, W.R. Greg published an article entitled 'Why Are Women Redundant?' which describes society as diseased because of the existence of so many unmarried women. 37 Several ideological forces operate in Greg's essay, but of importance here is how Greg not only universalizes the domestic ideal but also elevates marriage as the raison d'etre in mid-century England. Describing the rules of Nature, he writes that by the sentiments which belong to all healthy and unsophisticated organisations even in our own complicated civilisation, marriage, the union of one man with one woman, is unmistakably indicated as the despotic law of life. This is the rule. We need not waste words in justifying the assumption. 38 For Greg, the real tyranny of nature's despotic law is the constraint of male freedom; similarly, in The Small House Crosbie's fear of the domestic is partly due to the impending loss of a bachelor's life. Greg is especially relevant when considering Lily Dale: he says thousands of women are redundant 'because one abortive love in the past has closed their hearts to every other sentiment'. 39 Compare Greg's statement with Trollope's description of Lily in the Autobiography, and we see that the two are addressing a similar concern: Lily 'became first engaged to a snob; and then, though in truth she loved another man who was hardly good enough, she could not extricate herself sufficiently from the collapse of her first great misfortune' (A 179). The end result of
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
20
21
both Greg's article and Trollope's narrative is to conceptualize gender in relation to the domestic sphere relegated to women. The novel is ambiguous toward the mores of marriage and it approaches a critique of the domestic ideal, but an acceptable alternative within the framework of the novel is never given. In the Greg article, domesticity is the despotic law of life, and in the novel, domesticity is simply thwarted. The question is w h e t h e r Greg's text would have worked intertextually - either brought in consciously or not by the reader or the author - with the fiction as a point of debate in the topical Woman Question. Greg's article appeared in the National Review, a Unitarian-influenced quarterly read by the educated (male) middle and upper classes.40 Like Cornhill it was available at Mudie's and the two periodicals could well have had an overlapping readership; certainly, Trollope would have been familiar with topical debates in a number of periodicals. But Greg was not alone in addressing the question of redundant women at this time. Early in April 1862, The Times published an exchange of letters to the editor addressing the efforts of Emily Faithfull and others to employ women and to initiate female emigration schemes. 41 'To marry, to bear children, to guide the house, to lodge strangers, to wash the saints' feet, to relieve the afflicted' is how a Saturday Review article in April describes the boundaries of women's work. 42 A week earlier in the Spectator, a writer discussing university exams for women insists that 'we cannot have home happiness endangered for any conceivable improvement to the minds or powers of either sex'.43 The conservative feminist Frances Power Cobbe published 'What Shall We Do With Our Old Maids?' in Eraser's Magazine (November 1862), as a direct response to the Greg article. Cobbe assumes her readers' familiarity with the Greg and mentions that his article was 'quoted as of the soundest common sense'. 44 Therefore, the problem of redundant women or old maids was a prominent element of middle-class public discourse at the time The Small House was being written and serialized. Trollope's writing diaries indicate that he began writing the manuscript in May, a month after the Greg article and the Times letters had appeared, and the third instalment was written mostly at the end of June. 45 The Cobbe article appeared in the same month as the third instalment discussed above. Whether or not Greg's article was directly influential, Trollope and his readers
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
Trollope and the Magazines
would have brought to the text pre-understandings about the Woman Question which places the fiction in the wider context of a public, cultural discourse. It is likely that a reader would have connected the detailing of Lily's waste with the public discourse on the Woman Question, which helps explain readers' anxiety in wishing to marry off Lily Dale. Another article in the November Cornhill works similarly by constructing a criminal class in terms of the domestic ideal and with references to outside texts. H.W. Holland's article 'Professional Thieves' 46 is an attempt to consider thieving as an art. He places his piece within a context of at least 30 years of formal study of criminals and their practices, and like so many Victorian sociological studies, his begins with a catalogue of statistics. But Holland's article differs from other studies, notably Henry Mayhew's articles which became London Labour and the London Poor (1862), of which Holland states, 'the nature of its topics excludes it from the family circle' (641). Holland, by writing in Cornhill, has placed the discussion of criminality in the presence of ladies and children, so his report is accordingly ambiguous toward distasteful but significant criminal distinctions. Nancy Armstrong says of Mayhew's well-known and influential study that it 'can be viewed as a blatant attempt by a middle-class intellectual to transform the problem of an impoverished working class by translating this social dilemma into sexual terms'. 47 The Holland article, like Trollope's novel, works by conceptualizing his discussion in terms of the domestic. The thieving population is organized by a familial structure, with actual or pretended parental figures educating children in the art of crime. However, it is the woman who is responsible for the early education of child criminals: Pocket-picking is the boy's first lesson, and he practises on his instructor, and on the woman who may reside with the thief. When he can quickly and quietly pick the pocket of his new friends, the woman takes him out, generally into some crowded shop. . . . The woman has nearly always most to do with the education of the boy. When she has done with him, the man takes him in hand, and they go out together. (644)
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
22
23
Notice how gendered spheres are constructed: the woman is responsible for the homespun, early initiation before the boy thief is fully accepted in the man's public arena. But the thieving family is a perversion of the domestic ideal because the woman, the moral centre in middle-class homes, is an immoral, unnatural influence in the criminal home. Holland says that the women thieves 'are always connected with male thieves', a way of distinguishing 'between female thieves and another class of vicious women', meaning prostitutes (647). The delicate treatment of prostitution is part of what Jeffrey Weeks has called the Victorian double standard that 'familial ideology was accompanied by, and often relied on, a vast underbelly of prostitution'. 48 Setting up the family model among thieves and perverting the moral influence of woman, the contributor implicitly upholds and reinforces the middle-class domestic ideal by showing the reader a diseased domesticity. The thieving class is, to a large extent, the result of the fallen woman unable morally to safeguard the home. Holland neglects to mention the range of possible economic hardships which encourage a criminal underclass, in the same way that Mayhew concentrates on sexual rather than socio-economic aspects of criminal life.49 By faulting the woman, whose responsibility it is to educate, Holland's article would have resonances with Fitzjames Stephen's piece, 'Circumstantial Evidence - the Case of Jessie M'Lachlan', also in the November Cornhill. Stephen's piece offers a defence of circumstantial evidence, based on the sensational case of a female murderer, and it focuses on the criminal acts and the murderer's deceit. In the Saturday Review of 25 October 1862, a story appeared about Catherine Wilson, the first woman to be executed by the Old Bailey in 14 years. 50 The article describes her 'foulest personal vices', and concludes that 'it was only a woman, with a woman's arts, a woman's insinuating craft, a woman's admittance to sick rooms, and to the sacred confidences of her sister, a woman's womanliness, that could have perpetrated this string of crimes'. 51 The Holland, Stephen, and Saturday Review articles depict the danger of woman when she fails to live up to her position as the moral centre; the articles work intertextually, albeit in varying degrees, to offer a glimpse of the fallen woman. If Trollope's chapters in the third instalment depict the steadfast woman wronged by a man who refuses the family ideal, then the Holland article shows what happens when woman fails
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
Trollope and the Magazines
as the angel in the house. Both in different ways use the ideological positioning of gendered spheres, and the domestic ideal in particular, that Cornhill promotes. Read in a different context, either the Trollope or the Holland might not become ideological in the same way, but because Cornhill endorses a specific value system, the text becomes ideologically, and therefore politically, charged. Terry Eagleton usefully suggests that 'you could not decide whether a statement was ideological or not by inspecting it in isolation from its discursive context, any more than you could decide in this way whether a piece of writing was a work of literary art'. 52 The discursive context includes contemporary texts outside of Cornhill which could have directly influenced the reading of an issue, or generally informed the understanding of public discussions. The Small House read with knowledge of the Greg essay or of the Woman Question debate has political implications. Trollope thwarts the domestic at a time when readers were anxious about and sensitive to single women, as seen in letters to The Times and other periodical literature. Reading how women educated thieves at a time when female crimes were sensationalized in the press again makes the middle-class positioning of women all the more poignant. Intertextual readings show explicitly how implications which move from text to text participate in blurring the boundaries between fiction and non-fiction. 53
THE NON-FICTION CLUB: MEMBERS ONLY There is no doubt that on Magazine Day in the early 1860s, the primary attraction of periodicals like Cornhill was the illustrated serial fiction and not the non-fiction articles. It was the next episode in the plight of Lily Dale, and to a far lesser extent that of George Eliot's Romola, which readers eagerly awaited each month, and not articles describing medieval bookselling or the history of sea-fights which were leaved between the novels, stories and poetry. The Economist of 9 March 1861 wrote that Cornhill 'relies for its sale mainly on the fictions it contains', although it adds that the non-fiction articles are 'well-informed and good of their kind'. 54 Although it seems that non-fiction was of secondary importance to readers, the articles did participate in ideological discourses which when examined reveal a complexity within Cornhill that is easy to miss.
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
24
25
By classifying broadly and comparing the non-fiction contents of a few contemporary magazines, during the serialization of The Small House at Allington, we can gain insight into how Cornhill's interests differed from other periodicals. Unlike Cornhill, Blackwood's is overwhelmingly weighted with articles on foreign affairs which partly give the periodical its imperialist tone. Macmillan's favours foreign-affairs articles but also includes many contributions on science and literature. Cornhill differs from both by publishing many more articles on culture and society, followed by science. There are limits to a crude content classification, but as a preliminary analysis it can indicate the general concerns and ideological presentations of a periodical. For instance, Cornhill's concentration on culture-based articles enforces their overall commitment to non-controversial non-fiction subjects. By avoiding foreign affairs, the American Civil War, political economy 55 and religion and by favouring 'factual' science and middle-class culture, the editors attempted to present an apparently uncomplicated version of the real, non-fiction world of its readers. However, these articles are complex and engaged with ideological discourses both inside and outside the magazine. By limiting the range of acceptable topics, the magazine broadens the range of subjects within culture and society available to be discussed. A glance at the Wellesley Index list of attributions for non-fiction articles indicates the frequency with which Cornhill relied on a core of mostly male contributors. Thackeray's expectation of a diverse number of contributors from the public, as stated in the 1860 announcement of the magazine, only shows how far Cornhill was in 1862 from its initial self-projection. Whereas the fiction is balanced by having serials, stories, and poems by men and women (George Eliot, Anne Ritchie, Elizabeth Gaskell, Trollope, and others), the non-fiction is almost exclusively dominated by middle-class men. But these contributors were not just brilliant amateurs, like the physician and frequent contributor Francis E. Anstie, who earned their livelihoods in other professions. A few of the inner circle of non-fiction contributors are recognizable as professional journalists. Fitzjames Stephen, Cornhill's most frequent occasional non-fiction contributor, wrote 12 articles in this period, mostly about social and moral issues. According to his biographer, Fitzjames Stephen as primary contributor lacked an outlet for more serious non-fiction, and so found himself turning to magazines like Fraser's which would publish articles Cornhill would not. 56
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
Trollope and the Magazines
Before his Cornhill t e n u r e , Stephen wrote for the Saturday Review, and he would become the chief leader writer in the late 1860s for another of Smith's ventures, the innovative evening Pall Mall Gazette, where 'he was able to speak out with perfect freedom u p o n the graver topics of the day'. 5 7 Another Cornhill contributor, and one of Smith's co-editors during this period, was Frederick Greenwood, who would be the first editor of the Pall Mall Gazette from 1865. In 1862, George Smith was 35 years old, Frederick Greenwood was 32, and Fitzjames Stephen 33. Thackeray (who was no longer editor) and Trollope, both of whom wrote some non-fiction but represented the genteel side of the magazine's fiction, were 51 and 47 respectively. What is interesting is that many of the younger key players involved in Cornhill would become pioneers in the Pall Mall Gazette's professionalization of journalism later in the decade and into the 1870s. There is a tension within the contents which belies the fact that there were at least two types of male contributor, the middle-aged, gentleman writer and the up-and-coming young professional. Although Cornhill is often identified as the pre-eminent literary magazine of the middle and upper classes, the contents were no less ideologically complicated because of its policy excluding subjects of potential controversy Some articles written by men seem to address women readers; however, within the male-dominated core of nonfiction, contributors produced articles which more often affirm a male reader. It is as if the male writers were trying to maintain their own gendered space within the Cornhill's new fictiondominated, but still hybrid, type of shilling monthly. Those contributions which can be identified as culture and society subjects in Cornhill range from articles about the royals to prison reform, from a travel piece to a discussion of cosmetics. If the spectrum of articles which form the bulk of the magazine's non-fiction offers limited debate on a number of cultural and social issues, it also confirms the middle-class readers' self-satisfaction with their own education, prosperity, temperance and philanthropy. Fitzjames Stephen, using Victor Hugo's Les Miserables as an illustration, concluded in an article entitled 'Society' that '"society"' has no precise meaning at all' and that the basis of society, if one does exist, is the benevolent relations between men. 58 There is an echo of precisely this debate in late twentieth-century British politics, best illustrated by Margaret Thatcher's assertion as Prime Minister in Woman's Own in 1987 that 'there is
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
26
27
no such thing as Society. There are individual men and women, and there are families.' 59 The Victorian argument over the collective responsibility of communities remains very much with us, and the debates about socially responsible market economies continue to divide the middle-classes in post-Thatcherite, New Labour Britain. Stephen's article discusses society's responsibility to redress social ills by setting in opposition the individualist and the socialist. The socialist, of course, sees society as a corporate body with collective responsibility, but the writer favours the individualist, paradigmatically represented in the form of the prosperous Englishman, whose individual pursuits somehow naturally lead to a good society There's a whiff of Carlyle's Captains of Industry here - trickle-down social reform, we might now call it. Stephen's article, which at first appears to question social evils, is actually a Whiggish liberal defence 60 of middleclass prosperity, an attempt to reassure readers that the human by-products of industrialization and increasing capitalism described in Les Miserables dire best remedied by maintaining the comfort of the middle class. There is no question about the socioeconomics causes of human suffering, only an attempt to reassure the reader that blame cannot be placed on the diligent middle classes by the socialists. The article, by appearing in a middle-class periodical and by being written at all, belies a class anxiety during a time of burgeoning reform campaigns in a number of social areas. As had been conventional since the founding of the Edinburgh and Quarterly Reviews in the early nineteenth century, non-fiction journalism was linked to book-reviewing, so using fiction as a way into discussing politics, religion, and other serious discourses was common. Les Miserables was widely reviewed in the periodical press, and its subject-matter affords the opportunity to discuss aspects of social reform. 61 Women's education and expatriation, the distress in Lancashire, public-school and university education, the penal system - these were some of the other reform topics which featured prominently in newspapers and periodicals in late 1862. For example, The Times ran 13 leaders from August to December on the treatment of convicts, and throughout 1862 there were no fewer than 51 leaders on the distress and relief efforts in the cotton districts. 62 Elsewhere, as in the reform-minded English Woman's Journal published by Emily Faithfull's Victoria Press, there is an ongoing discussion of the Woman Question. Less well known
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
Trollope and the Magazines
today than Faithfull's magazine is The Rose, the Shamrock, and the Thistle, a Scottish m a g a z i n e p u b l i s h e d by the w o m e n - l e d Caledonian Press, which ran many articles on topics related to the Woman Question including a series called 'Our Six Hundred Thousand' in 1862-63. Stephen's argument in his Cornhill article can be read as a defensive response which seeks to allay some of the self-doubt and anxiety of the middle classes, w h o were increasingly being asked in the periodicals to consider and accommodate substantial social change. 'The Working Man's Restaurant' (February 1863) describes efforts around Britain, but specifically the Great Western Cooking Depot in Glasgow, to provide inexpensive food to the struggling working classes. 63 The article takes as its subject a specific social ill, the hardship of the working class, but like Fitzjames Stephen above, it neglects any consideration of the causes of the social inequality. 'The Working Man's Restaurant' supports the philanthropic experiment in Glasgow because it provides clean, attractive eating-halls 'equivalent to elegance', and tasty, filling food, 'quite as much as it is healthful to take with the prospect of an afternoon's active work before us' (254). But the advantages to the working classes do not stop at the culinary delights. The halls are operated as businesses and so instil pride in the guests, who must pay for their food and not have to receive charity. Such establishments provide competition for the pubs and gin-houses frequented by the working classes; no alcohol is served in the halls, which is 'essential when large numbers from the very poorest districts of the city are assembled together' (258). There are reading-rooms with daily papers and a women-only room 'so that timid girls may not have to run the gauntlet through a room full of strangers' (258). The writer recommends that similar eating-halls be established in other cities, especially in the poorer quarters. A number of topical discourses run through 'The Working Man's Restaurant'. Mentioning the no-alcohol policy would almost certainly have brought to mind the temperance hall movement aimed at working-class improvement. As Lilian Shiman has observed in her book on Victorian temperance movements, the working-class family unit suffered from a lack of space and lack of facilities.64 Temperance halls were founded by temperance societies beginning in the 1830s to provide meeting-places and educational classes for struggling families, since the assumption was that the working classes turned to drink as a way of escaping hardships at
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
28
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
29
The best cure for the drunkenness of the lower classes is not a Maine Liquor Law - but soup and sausages, pudding and pies; is not to shut the beershops, but to open the poor man's kitchen.66 The specific subject of the food depots was picked up by other periodicals, notably Good Words (December 1862), which reiterated the benefits of the Glasgow experiment. So 'The Working Man's Restaurant' is part of a wider topical debate on the use and abuse of alcohol, and one Cornhill reader (an individualist of whom Stephen would doubtless approve) is shown to be actively involved in a philanthropic experiment aimed at alleviating one social ill of the day. What the writer finds most admirable in the hall are those attempts to create a semblance of middle-class comfort: a bright, almost elegant establishment with reading-rooms and a separate woman-only space. But the writer is most emphatic in conveying the entrepreneurial aspect of the venture; not merely a charitable soup kitchen, this restaurant is a profit-making venture which in turn nurtures working-class pride. 67 The Cornhill article reaffirms a middle-class model of prosperity, and also shows a point of intersection for different discourses which are at least implicitly addressed: the temperance debate, an acceptance of gendered spaces, and the right-headedness of the capitalist businessman. Criminality has always held a sensational value in newspapers and periodicals, and in the early 1860s, when sensation novels were glutting the market and gaining currency with middle-class readers, Cornhill carried several articles aimed at the reader interested in descriptions of crime and punishment. Many of these articles make references to recent sensational crimes, like the execution of Catherine Wilson in October 1862, a case which received wide periodical attention because the criminal was a woman and because she was convicted purely on circumstantial evidence. 68 While Cornhill was not initially known for serializing highly popular sensation novels (unlike Eraser's, say, which at
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
home. In the 1860s, attempts were made by teetotallers to introduce prohibition legislation, and the virtues and vices of alcohol were much discussed in Cornhill and other periodicals. 65 In fact, we are told that the idea for the restaurant described in the article came from a previous Cornhill article of June 1860, which states:
Trollope and the Magazines
this time was running Mary Braddon's Aurora Floyd), its links to sensational press reports, generally staples of both the metropolitan and regional newspapers, can be seen in male-dominated non-fiction articles linked to sensational news events. To present itself as a sensational magazine would not have been proper for Cornhill at this time (although Frederick Greenwood's Margaret Denzil's History is pretty sensational), but under the guise of respectable, male non-fiction, sensational events could find their way into Cornhill's discourse. And in such articles, depictions of gender transgression, particularly affronts to conventional femininity, could be more visible than in the fiction. Thus in 'The Medical Evidence of Crime' (March 1863), Francis Anstie begins his discussion by referring to 'the trial of the woman Wilson'.69 Of course nothing as graphic as the Saturday Review's bloodthirsty and misogynistic account of the case (25 October 1863) could ever appear in Cornhill, but a subtle, discreet mention like the one above would be enough to bring the case to the (male) reader's consciousness, and it suggests the reader's familiarity with and interest in the sensational criminal news items of the day. The November 1862 issue carried two articles which approach sensational coverage, those on 'Circumstantial Evidence: The Case of Jessie M'Lachlan' and on 'Professional Thieves'. Jessie M'Lachlan was a woman sentenced to death for murder but who was given a commuted sentence at Her Majesty's pleasure for life by the Home Secretary. The case provided the impetus for the press to discuss judicial reform, capital punishment, and circumstantial evidence, and The Times took particular interest in the case, as shown by the four leaders in October and November devoted to the Home Secretary's decision.70 As discussed in this chapter above, the article on thieves describes the framework of a criminal family as a corrupted domestic ideal. And as in 'The Working Man's Restaurant' we see how different discourses intersect in the nonfiction: we are in the underworld of the professional thief but recognize the language and familial structure associated with the domestic ideal. To an extent, crime is also addressed in Cornhill's fiction, for example through Romola's Tito, who moves between the centre of political power to the margins of treachery. His criminal mind leads him away from the domestic haven offered by Romola to his secret peasant mistress, Tessa. Although his crimes are whitecollar and enmeshed in the volatile political circumstances of
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
30
31
Renaissance Florence, his deceit and perversion of the domestic ideal are no less poignant than the Victorian professional thief's discussed in the non-fiction. Furthermore, the illustrations to fiction and poetry offered visual images of sensational events. Consider the confrontation between Baldassare and Tito from Romola, illustrated in 'Will His Eyes Open?' in July 1863 (Fig. 1.1), or the drawing accompanying the poem 'Manoli' in September 1862 (Fig. 1.2). Both demonstrate how sensationalism can enter even the most discreet middle-class shilling monthly. In February 1863, Fitzjames Stephen wrote the closest thing to a political reformist article that can be found in Cornhill in the early 1860s. 'The Punishment of Convicts' argues that sentencing reform is necessary to ensure proper punishments for crimes. He asserts that the judicial system spends too long capturing the criminal and pays too little attention to him afterward. Stephen's analogy reveals something about the middle-class men he addresses: A pack of hounds, and a number of men, dogs, and horses will spend hours in hunting a fox, which, when caught, is abandoned to the dogs without an observation. 71 To make his point, he uses a male-bonding analogy that appeals to his reader's sporting sentiments: not punishing convicts properly is like releasing a well-chased fox. And if that fails to hit the mark with some, he appeals a second time to the professional ethics of his reader: failure to sentence convicts consistently would be like a doctor taking the utmost care in diagnosis but ignoring the prescription completely. For Stephen, sentencing reform is a question of responsibility or duty. By making recognizable comparisons to the all-male professional and social lives of the reader, the writer makes his point about reform with greater impact at the same time as he distinguishes the convict as a being separate from the middle-classes. But even in the male space of the nonfiction article, Stephen finds that he must maintain discretion, as when classifying types of crimes. Defining the third type, those odious in nature, he mentions cruelty to animals and 'others on which it is better not to be too explicit',72 which I presume to mean a sexual deviancy or some similar perversity which dare not speak its name, or have its name spoken. Like so many of Cornhill's non-fiction articles, 'The Punishment of Convicts' is part of a wider cultural discourse, in this case the debate over prison
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
I
I
\A.,f
/ / /
m
m Jtfy.0- ' # ^ = : \ ^ > '
,-
Fig. 1.1 'Will His Eyes Open?7, Cornhill Magazine (July 1863) 10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect 2011-03-15
to
?
f . .
Fig. 1.2 'Manoli', Cornhill Magazine (September 1862)
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
33
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
Trollope and the Magazines
reform; although the Westminster Review's treatment of the topic in January 1863 provides a more thorough analysis of the subject,73 Cornhill in this instance is contributing directly to the debate about a controversial social reform. Middle-class shared knowledge or experience was another area which contributors took every opportunity to mention. References to those things which 'everyone knows', whether a recent murder trial or a scientific publication, helps create a union of readers with similar backgrounds, tastes, and interests. This projected configuration may not be absolutely accurate, but the impression given is one of a large community of readers with equal access to and interest in a number of events, and, of course, the gentleman's club projected precisely this unanimity of experience. In an article about the 32 volumes of the State Trials, a collection of legal trials in England beginning in the reign of Henry I, Fitzjames Stephen wants to illustrate 'the great general interest' which the trials can excite.74 He assumes the reader's familiarity with the most important historical cases: The case of ship money, the impeachment of Lord Strafford, the trial of Charles I, the trials for the Popish plot, the trials for Monmouth's insurrection on the Western Circuit, and the trial of the seven Bishops, are familiar to those who have even the most popular acquaintance with English history. (353) Whether or not readers were well acquainted with the particulars of these and other historical cases may be questioned, but Stephen's projection of his readership unites them under the banner of shared knowledge. The club-like bonding of the article also works because the writer appeals to the w o r k i n g professionalism of readers. Stephen, a lawyer by training, writes from within the respectable, male preserve of the law, and his discourse would have been intimate and familiar to a legal readership. He prefers the legal case histories to political histories because of their professional quality: Men are never so much themselves as when they are actively engaged in the practice of their professions; for, of all the influences by which character is moulded, the influence of a profession is the widest and the most searching. (354)
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
34
35
Read carefully, Stephen's assertion makes the case that men are at their best when they are with other men, at work. This definition, which links professionalism and manliness, automatically excludes women, who generally were not professionals. It is another way of appealing to the unity of the Cornhill non-fiction reader. The point here is about gendered spaces within periodicals which are predicated upon exclusions. This is not to say that women did not read non-fiction or that men ignored the fiction, rather that the contributions appear, even generically, to be gendered with an ideal or implied male reader in mind. As I understand it, the exclusion at work in the non-fiction was grounded upon exclusions similar to those which defined the allmale club. Stefan Collini's study of the writers of the higher journalism in the nineteenth century shows how the social network of the intellectual journalists centred around club life and around the Athenaeum in particular. 75 Nigel Cross writes of professional journalists that 'the club was the adhesive of Bohemian life. It was more than simply a haven from family life - or lack of it. It provided writers, who by definition have to work alone, with an opportunity to meet together.' 76 Cross constructs a particular version of the isolated writer which I would question, 77 but his point about male writers and clubs is an important one. The social configuration of the men's club and its links to the cultural formation of periodicals informs my readings of periodicals in later chapters, but here it is enough to understand that Cornhill's non-fiction writers were themselves in a similarly unified, professional, all-male circle. Discussing the 'Effect of Railways on Health' in October 1862, G.H. Lewes also targets a professional male reader. His argument revolves around various truths and fallacies about living in the country and commuting to the city for work. Therefore he has defined his audience as those prosperous middle-class members who increasingly left London for the clean air of country living: But it is not the young and healthy we are specially addressing; it is the men whose health is the chief motive for living out of town, and who are, therefore, called upon to consider this one question of health. 78 That those very same commuters may have been reading this article during their morning or evening trip into town further unites the periodical with its male readership. Whereas serial fiction
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
Trollope and the Magazines
was often read communally, as in the family circle, non-fiction articles were designed to be personal and digested individually, and periodical literature suited the men's daily commute into town, whether that be London, Liverpool, Manchester or another regional urban centre. The sort of literature pioneered by George Smith in the Pall Mall Gazette a few years later is even more directed to the commuter. Temperance and moderation were highly regarded virtues in the non-fiction, as seen in a series of articles by Francis Anstie on overeating and the effects of alcohol and tobacco. In 'Tobacco: Its Use and Abuse', Anstie refers to 'the young lad', 'a boy', 'the boy-smoker', and 'the men at the universities' who use tobacco, and we immediately understand that the implied reader is male. 79 More interestingly, Anstie positions middle-class moderation between the working classes who need tobacco as the lesser of evils and the upper classes who use it because they are idle: On behalf of the ill-fed, ill-clad, and anxious classes, I feel driven to lift up a protest against the mistaken spirit, as I think it, of philanthropic reform which would drive tobacco completely out of use, or limit its use to the rich and the irredeemably lazy sections of society. The result of my own observations has been the production of the conviction in my mind, that the majority of the poor and anxious classes, in London at any rate, after reaching a certain age, begin to indulge in one of three cheap luxuries - alcohol, opium, or tobacco: and, moreover, in the existing state of things, that it is hopeless to expect them to do anything better than choose the best of these three. 80 The working classes are presented as somewhat pitifully tending toward chemical dependencies of one type or another; the upper classes are practically immoral in their sedentary lifestyles; and somewhere between these social polarities are the Cornhill readers who, Anstie hopes, will prove middle-class superiority by moderating their behaviour unlike the poor and the rich. Note that the magazine masks its own self-interest in maintaining comfort because the article is written on behalf of the underprivileged. Comparing Anstie's assertion that philanthropic reform is futile with the reform-minded, entrepreneurial position in 'The Working Man's Restaurant' (discussed above) suggests that, in terms
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
36
37
of a single, coherent social ideology, the Cornhill contributors were not necessarily of like mind. In another article by Anstie about 'Overeating and Undereating' the poor and the rich are used as extremes of behaviour which the middle classes ought to avoid.81 Child mortality in poor classes results from poorly nourished, overworked mothers who breastfeed, and the overeating in wealthier classes is caused simply by their own ignorance. Again, the middle classes must find their way through moderation between the extremes of squalor and indulgence seen in the lower and upper classes. Women were suspect of overindulgence as well as men. G.H. Lewes, unusually addressing women readers by writing about the use of cosmetics in Aids to Beauty, Real and Artificial' in March 1863, describes how the improving qualities of cosmetics are most often a false way of covering over Nature's defects. He asserts: Fortunes are made by cosmetics. Large sums, we know, are paid to artists who undertake to 'enamel' the skins of ladies bestowing the radiance of health where nature or disease has set a very different sign. Dear madam, it is all a fiction! Cosmetics are impositions. The credulity of vanity, supported by blank ignorance, may induce you to spend time and money on such appliances to create a 'complexion;' but if you knew how your skin was constructed, how it grew, how it breathed, and how it assumed its 'complexion/ you would as soon think of rendering hieroglyphics legible by whitewashing a monument. 82 Like cosmetics, his perception of the woman reader's attention to fashion also comes under attack: Fashion in all its hideousness is despotic, and can only be rebelled against by very exceptional people. There is, however, a rational and aesthetic obedience no less than an irrational and hideous servility. Perhaps in nothing does the feminine intellect more markedly betray its weakness than in this matter of costume. 83 Lewes's remedy for a clear complexion is a healthy overall body, and he advocates that by the clever use of colours and form in dress to aid beauty, 'the tyranny of fashion would be reduced to moderation'. 84 However, this article does not simply offer advice
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
Trollope and the Magazines
to the woman reader; it derides female behaviour and intelligence and promulgates a male critique of femininity. Serial non-fiction is an occasional element in Cornhill, although it appears more frequently in other magazines. In Macmillan's, for example, there are two-part stories on 'Progress in China', 'A Visit to Lutzen in October', and 'Across the Channel', and an article on the American Civil War was practically a monthly feature. Cornhill contained some serial non-fiction - for example, Lewes's 'Notes on Science' and 'Our Survey of Literature and Science' and Thackeray's 'Roundabout Papers' - and such non-fiction unites the reader in a way the serial does, by creating a network of references to other articles which have appeared earlier, a practice which links the magazine's non-fiction and demonstrates the unity of the contributors. The suggestion is not that contributors were consciously and purposefully self-referential (although they may have been), but that by referring back and forth through the issues and volumes, an experience similar to serial reading was produced. Although I have singled out particular contributors, Cornhill's policy of anonymity, as with most periodicals and newspapers at this time, did not privilege the author over the periodical. Anonymity was a genteel tradition which not only put the full weight of a periodical behind an article's ideas but also prevented individual achievement or notoriety. As an article in Blackwood's in 1859 describes it, the 'secresy of its organization' 85 was crucial in the press because it acted as a type of restraint against a total invasion of privacy. The writer defines the recent proliferation of new periodicals by the increase in narrow interests, and 'class' specificity as the character of the English press: To sign or not to sign? - that is the question; but as applied to the English press it is only another form of the question, To be or not to be? The anonymous is the corner-stone of class journalism .. .86 Without anonymity, as the allusion to Hamlet implies, the English press would commit self-slaughter, or at the very least become something rather too resembling American journalism. Cornhill, although formally maintaining a policy of anonymity, was not a completely secret organization. Often, poems were initialled, as were explosive articles such as Ruskin's 'Unto This Last'. Poems
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
38
39
deserved signature because they were high art, and Ruskin had to be attributed because the magazine needed to distance itself from the ideas he expressed. However, from the start Cornhill was lax about the need for anonymity, and in the very first issue clues to the fiction contributors are given in the editorial note. Also, the trade journal Publishers' Circular often identified both fiction and non-fiction writers in periodicals, and advertisements often named contributors, a point to which I will return in Chapter 4. Cornhill, while not approaching the heterogeneity of, say, the Fortnightly Review a few years later, was not impenetrable in the way the Blackwood's article suggested periodicals needed to be. Still, on balance Cornhill's authority is located in the weight of the magazine and the editor, and not in the individual contributor. I am making two points about the non-fiction articles: first, that they were mostly written by men who carved out a textual space for male readers within the family magazine, and secondly, that they helped promote a unified, continuous reading experience for men. Educated, professional, prosperous, moderate - all of these were ideological constructions in the non-fiction of the middle-class Cornhill reader, and all of these helped gather the reader under one banner. Simply put, non-fiction relied on a core of male writers who wrote with their male peers in mind. The approach reproduces the atmosphere of the gentleman's club, which in many ways galvanized middle-class male aspirations. Laurel Brake has discussed how the network of 'Metaphysical Society' members dominated variously both the Contemporary Review and Nineteenth Century in the 1870s, and how the Nineteenth Century format 'approximates that of the Society'. 87 Mary Ann Clawson, in writing about the development of fraternal organizations in America, observes that fraternalism was offered in opposition to women's domestic sphere. The fraternal organization provided an all-male, morally improving space for men. 88 These observations can be useful in understanding how the Cornhill non-fiction writers were creating their own space and discourse within a domestic, drawing-room magazine. And George Smith's jovial monthly dinners for Cornhill contributors furthered the club-like comradery and network of non-fiction writers. In a Cornhill article in February 1863, on sarcastic, malicious popular journalism, the writer distinguishes this 'other class of writing' by the effeminacy of its practitioners. 89 They are misogynistic because they have no women friends or have been ill-treated
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
Trollope and the Magazines
by them, but the further implication is that the writers are not manly. The writer gives the example of Alphonse Karr in France, who, it is coyly suggested, was unsuccessful with the other sex and who was wildly eccentric in his dress; whether Karr is being described in veiled terms as homosexual is uncertain, but what is obvious is that his offensiveness is a consequence of his unmanliness. Karr (1808-90) was best known for his satiric writings in the periodical Les Guepes (The Wasps); the poison of his ink was his eccentric behaviour and dress, described by a contemporary biographer: Bientot la pose devint chez lui une occupation serieuse, une manie, un systeme, un besoin de chaque jour et de chaque heure. II s'appliqua constamment a mettre son individualite en relief et a faire saillir aux yeux du public ce qu'il y a de particulier dans sa personne et dans son caractere. 90 He is further described as 'un feroce original' who greeted editors wearing elaborate turbans and slippers and whose bedroom was painted black.91 The ideological positioning of journalism in the Cornhill article posits Cornhill-style non-fiction at the centre of manly male discourse, while other forms of lesser, bitchy and gossipy journalism are denigrated as effeminate and 'beneath the dignity of men of sense to meddle'. 92 The same article states: In England, a magazine, a periodical, or a journal must represent either an interest or a principle, and in proportion to the breadth and importance of that interest, or the deepness and indestructibility of that principle, will be the extent of the influence enjoyed. 93 But even the spaces within a periodical are directed at particular readers and interests. An article in Temple Bar in 1862, discussing periodicals, fiction and literature, states that 'the literature of Fiction is the literature of Society', 94 and I would claim, the literature of non-fiction was the literature of politics, religion and other serious discourses; it was the literature of men. On the whole, the non-fiction in Cornhill represented the interests and principles of its male readers. It functioned in balance with the domestic fiction and maintained a gendered ideological framework within
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
40
41
the magazine. Within the scope of acceptable subjects, nonfiction engaged, however subtly and discreetly, in a number of discourses, some of which actually questioned and challenged the types of gender convention upheld in the textual space of the magazine. Transgressive women and effeminate men, for example, both found their way into the early Cornhills; but both enter largely t h r o u g h the male-dominated non-fiction. What remains to be decided, perhaps in another sort of study, is whether anyone actually read the non-fiction in the same huge numbers as enjoyed the fiction, and if not, why not.
Notes 1. Mary Hamer, Writing By Numbers: Trollope's Serial Fiction (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987). See her appendix, 'The Initial Publication of Trollope's Novels in England', which lists publication details for all his novels, 182-6. 2. Trollope was actually offered three and a half times more, or £3500, but accepted £2500 in order to retain the copyright. See N. John Hall, Trollope: A Biography (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1991). 3. For example, in An Autobiography Trollope discusses the lack of success of Brown, Jones, and Robinson: T do not know that I heard any opinion expressed of it, except by the publisher, who kindly remarked that he did not think it was equal to my usual work. Though he had purchased the copyright, he did not republish the story in book form until 1870, and then it passed into the world of letters sub silentio, 161. 4. Gaye Tuchman with Nina E. Fortin, Edging Women Out: Victorian Novelists, Publishers and Social Change (London: Routledge, 1989), 7. 5. Ibid., 7-10. Tuchman makes large claims about the the gendered dimension of novel writing in the nineteenth century, and it should be noted that her conclusions are based on a relatively small archive of material. While more work in this area needs to be undertaken, her conclusions are extremely suggestive about the gendered construction of literature. 6. The best overall discussion of the Victorian publishing system remains J.A. Sutherland, Victorian Novelists and Publishers (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1976). Tuchman's Edging Women Out introduces gender differentiation in novel writing. Hamer, Writing by Numbers, offers a good overview of the publishing industry with particular attention to the development of serialization. 7. See Hamer, Writing by Numbers, x-xi. 8. Hall, Trollope, 199. 9. Ibid., 197. 10. [E.S. Dallas,] Anthony Trollope , / The Times (23 May 1859), 12. Also quoted in Hall, Trollope, 189.
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
Trollope and the
Magazines
11. In Writing by Numbers, Hamer notes, 'there was no month between January 1860 and July 1867 which did not see the release of a further instalment of at least one current Trollope novel', 88. 12. Gordon N. Ray, ed., The Letters and Private Papers of William Makepeace Thackeray IV (London: Oxford University Press, 1946), 160. 13. Ibid., 158. 14. Ibid., 161. 15. Leonard Huxley, 'Chronicles of "CornhiH"', Cornhill Magazine 52 n.s. (1922), 370. 16. See Barbara Quinn Schmidt, 'In the Shadow of Thackeray: Leslie Stephen as the Editor of the Cornhill Magazine in Joel Wiener, ed., Innovators and Preachers: The Role of Editor in Victorian England (New York: Greenwood Press, 1985), 78, in which she states that Thackeray 'provided a narrator, a man of the world who was able to merge wisdom with nostalgia and mellowness as he would at a dinner party, telling anecdotes, frankly admitting his prejudices, making moral and social pronouncements, and commenting sympathetically on the contradictions and the caprice of everyday life'. 17. For a comprehensive look at reviewers' responses to Trollope's realism and for an overview of their uses of realism, see David Skilton, Anthony Trollope and His Contemporaries (London: Longman, 1972). 18. Thackeray rejected Browning's poem 'Lord Walter's Wife', Trollope's story 'Mrs. General Talboys' and discontinued Ruskin's Unto This Last. Browning's and Trollope's good-natured responses to these censorings are documented in Ray's Letters and Papers. Cornhill, of course, was not unique among periodicals in its censorship. See David Skilton, 'The Trollope Reader', in Jeremy H a w t h o r n , ed., The Nineteenth-Century British Novel (London: Edward Arnold, 1986): 'most authors, editors and publishers were operating a voluntary moral censorship or self-restraint which accorded happily with much middleclass public opinion, and there seems to have been a temporary, though surprisingly broad consensus - morally suffocating though it would later seem - about what should and should not go into a novel', 143. See also my discussion of the censoring of Trollope's Rachel Ray in Chapter 2. 19. Jenifer Glynn, Prince of Publishers: A Biography of George Smith (London: Allison and Busby, 1986) provides a circulation list for Cornhill during the 1860s. By December 1869, circulation was at 27,000 (143). Still, in the early 1860s Cornhill was among the most popular shilling monthlies, and several newer magazines patterned themselves on Cornhill. 20. Quoted in ibid., 144-5. 21. George Moore, 'A New Censorship of Literature', Pall Mall Gazette 40 (10 December 1884), 1-2. 22. Ibid., 1. 23. Glynn, Prince of Publishers, 137. 24. Andrew Blake, Reading Victorian Fiction: The Cultural Context and Ideological Content of the Nineteenth-Century Novel (London: Macmillan, 1989) takes a similar approach in looking at Framley Parsonage in
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
42
25. 26. 27.
28.
29. 30.
31. 32. 33.
34. 35. 36.
Ideology and Gendered Space
43
Cornhill: 'This novel provides an excellent illustration of the intertextuality of fiction in the periodical press: a mutuality of concern with the rest of the magazine's contents runs throughout its pages', 91. Julia Kristeva, 'Word, Dialogue and Novel' (1966), in Toril Moi, ed., The Kristeva Reader (London: Basil Blackwell, 1986), 36. Michel Foucault, The Archaeology of Knowledge (1969), A. M. Sheridan Smith, trans. (1972; reprinted London: Routledge, 1991), especially 21-40. Ibid., 30. In his chapter on the 'unities of discourse', Foucault insists on the need to overcome pre-existent notions like tradition, development, spirit, and influence within the theme of continuity, 21-2. This leads us naturally to rethink the ways in which we define, divide, and group discourses like literature, which, in turn, helps elucidate how vital study of the periodical press can be in challenging traditional methods of literary scholarship. See Foucault's discussion in Archaeology: 'The rules of formation are conditions of existence (but also of coexistence, maintenance, modification, and disappearance) in a given discursive division', 39. M.M. Bakhtin, The Dialogic Imagination, Caryl Emerson and Michael Holquist, trans., and Michael Holquist, ed. (Austin: University of Texas Press, 1981), 33. All Cornhill references are to vol. vi unless otherwise noted parenthetically in the text with a roman numeral to indicate the volume number. Nancy Armstrong, Desire and Domestic Fiction: A Political History of the Novel (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1987), especially the Introduction and Chapter 2. Mary Poovey, Uneven Developments: The Ideological Work of Gender in Mid-Victorian England (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1988), 2. John Ruskin, Sesame and Lilies (London: Smith, Elder, 1865), 148. Jeffrey Weeks, Sex, Politics and Society: The Regulation of Sexuality Since 1800 (London: Longman, 1981), 29, comments on Ruskin's statement that 'such an elevated tone was obviously not universal. But in all social discourse a stable home was seen both as a microcosm of stable society and a sanctuary from an unstable and rapidly changing one.' See also Walter E. Houghton on Ruskin's passage in The Victorian Frame of Mind (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1957), 343-4. Weeks, Sex, Politics and Society, 28. Ibid., 37. James Kincaid, The Novels of Anthony Trollope (Oxford: Clarendon, 1977), 92. However, he does call The Small House 'the darkest novel in the series', 96. Raymond Williams's The Country and the City (1973; reprinted London: Hogarth, 1985) compares 'the ease' of Dr. Thome, the third Barchester novel, with 'the disturbance, the unease, the divided construction' of George Eliot's later novels. He says that 'Trollope, in his Barchester novels, is at ease with schemes of inheritance, with the interaction of classes and interests, with the lucky
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Domestic
37. 38. 39. 40.
41.
42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53.
Trollope and the
Magazines
discovery and the successful propertied marriage. His interest is all in how it happens, not how it is done', 174-5. [W.R. Greg,] 'Why Are Women Redundant?' National Review 14 (April 1862), 434-60. Ibid., 438. Ibid., 440. See Alvar Ellegard, The Readership of the Periodical Press in Mid-Victorian Britain (Gothenburg: Goteborg Universitets Arsskrift, 1957), 32. Josef Altholz, The Religious Press in Britain, 1760-1900 (New York: Greenwood Press, 1989) says that National Review 'became the most distinguished Unitarian review and something more, fully the equal of the three great quarterlies', 75. Wellesley 3 calls the National Review 'clearly one of the great quarterlies of the Victorian age', 135. 'Sisters, Help Sisters', The Times (3 April 1862), 7, mentions the success of sending women to the colonies, but also stresses the need to find work for women in Britain. See two separate replies by Emily Faithfull and Maria S. Rye, 'The Employment of Women' (7 April 1862), 6, which again call on wealthier ladies to help out and which document efforts to organize emigration procedures for women. A follow-up letter by Maria Rye and Jane E. Lewin, 'Female Middleclass Emigration' (9 April 1862), 12, lists the donors who have contributed to their emigration campaign. However, not all letters were as supportive: Charles Kingsley's response, 'The Emigration of Women' (11 April 1862), 5, doubts Miss Faithfull's employment scheme and women's ability to work in general. He says that woman 'is physically weaker; her health is more uncertain; she is (at least, at present) worse trained at methodical labour; and the power of work ceases at least ten years sooner than the man's, leaving her destitute in old age. But why should she compete with the man? She was not meant to do so. All attempts to employ her in handicraft are but substitutes for that far nobler and more useful work which Nature intends for her - to marry and bear children.' Kingsley does support Rye's emigration fund as a way of marrying off single women. 'The Ladies Sanitary Association', Saturday Review 13 (12 April 1862), 413-14. 'Girl Graduates', The Spectator (5 April 1862), 377. Frances Power Cobbe, 'What Shall We Do With Our Old Maids?' Eraser's Magazine 66 (November 1862), 595. 'The Trollope Papers', Bodleian Library, MSS Don.c.9. [H.W Holland] 'Professional Thieves', Cornhill 6 (November 1862), 640-53, hereafter noted in the text parenthetically by page number. Armstrong, Desire and Domestic Fiction, 180. Weeks, Sex, Politics and Society, 30. Armstrong, Desire and Domestic Fiction, 180-2. 'The Gallows', Saturday Review 14 (25 October 1862), 500-1. Ibid., 500. Terry Eagleton, Ideology: An Introduction (London: Verso, 1991), 9. The blurring of boundaries between fiction and non-fiction can also
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
44
54. 55. 56.
57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62. 63. 64. 65.
66. 67.
68.
69. 70.
45
be seen more directly in the 1860s in sensation fiction which often used real events of murder or scandal as the basis for the narrative. 'General Literature', The Economist (9 March 1861), 260. See also R.R. Tiemersma, 'Fiction in the Cornhill Magazine January 1860-March 1871' (Ph.D. dissertation, Northwestern University, 1962), 90. Cornhill began publishing Ruskin's series Unto This Last, but discontinued it because of its controversial views on political economy. See note 21 above. Leslie Stephen, The Life of Sir James Fitzjames Stephen 1 (2 vols.; London: Smith, Elder, 1895), 183-4. That Leslie Stephen was Fitzjames's brother, and that he later became editor of Cornhill, further attests to the very tight network. Ibid., 214. [Fitzjames Stephen,] 'Society', Cornhill 7 (January 1863), 31-41. Quoted in Hugo Young, One of Us: A Biography of Margaret Thatcher (1989; reprinted London: Pan Books, 1990), 490. Stephen stood for Parliament as a Liberal in 1873 but was defeated. On the links between politics and Reviews, see Joanne Shattock, Politics and Reviewers: The Edinburgh and the Quarterly (London, Leicester, and New York: Leicester University Press, 1989). See the Times Index, 1862. [H. McCroskey,] 'The Working Man's Restaurant', Cornhill 7 (February 1863), 252-8, hereafter noted in the text parenthetically by page number. Lilian Lewis Shiman, Crusade Against Drink in Victorian England (London: Macmillan, 1988). See the chapters on temperance reformation and legal suasion. See [Francis E. Anstie,] 'Is It Food, Medicine, or Poison?' Cornhill 5 (June 1862), 707-16; [Francis E. Anstie,] 'Does Alcohol Act as Food?' Cornhill 5 (September 1862), 319-29; and [William Benjamin Carpenter,] 'Alcohol: What Becomes of It in the Living Body?', Westminster Review 19 n.s. (January 1861), 33-56. [E.S. Dallas,] 'Poor Man's Kitchen', Cornhill 1 (June 1860), 754. Note that 'Cooking Depots for Working People', Good Words 3 (December 1862), 732-5, takes up the issue of whether such enterprises ought to be profit-driven. The proprietor's letter, in which he states that the scheme was 'purely for the public benefit' and not for profit, was published in Good Words 4 (January 1863), 80. See 'Secret Poisoning', Temple Bar 6 (November 1862), 579-84; 'The Gallows', Saturday Review (October 25, 1862), 500-1; 'The Case of Catherine Wilson', London Review 5 (4 October 1862), 296-8; leaders in the Times (29 September and 22 October 1862). [Francis E. Anstie,] 'The Medical Evidence of Crime', Cornhill 7 (March 1863), 338. Leaders in the Times concerning the case of Jessie M'Lachlan can be found on 31 October, and on 4, 10 and 27 November 1862. This type of sensationalism remains very much a part of contemporary media. While there are levels of sensational coverage, from the salacious to the sanguine, subjects such as capital punishment still offer
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
71. 72. 73. 74. 75. 76. 77.
78. 79. 80. 81. 82. 83. 84. 85. 86. 87. 88. 89. 90.
Trollope and the Magazines the broadsheets the opportunity to place sensational crimes on the front page under the label of topical, news journalism. In America especially, through tabloid television programmes such as Hard Copy, the links between sensationalism and 'news' are even more pronounced. [Fitzjames Stephen,] 'The Punishment of Convicts', Cornhill 7 (February 1863), 190. Ibid., 196. See [Walter F. Crofton,] 'English Convicts: What Should Be Done With Them', Westminster Review (January 1863), 1-31. [Fitzjames Stephen,] 'The State Trials', Cornhill 6 (September 1862), 351, hereafter noted parenthetically in the text by page number. Stefan Collini, Public Moralists: Political Thought and Intellectual Life in Britain, 1850-1930 (Oxford: Clarendon, 1991), chapter 1, especially 16 ff. Nigel Cross, The Common Writer: Life in Nineteenth-Century Grub Street (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987), 107. He notes that the Garrick was founded for writers in 1831. One could look to the collaborative work of John Stuart Mill, Harriet Taylor Mill and Helen Taylor to refute the romantic notion of the lone writer. See Ann P. Robson and John M. Robson, eds., Sexual Equality: Writings by John Stuart Mill, Harriet Taylor Mill and Helen Taylor (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1994), especially the Introduction. [G.H. Lewes,] 'Effect of Railways on Health', Cornhill 6 (October 1862), 483. [Francis E. Anstie,] 'Tobacco: Its Use and Abuse', Cornhill 6 (November 1862), 605-15. Ibid., 614. [Francis E. Anstie,] 'Overeating and Undereating', Cornhill 8 (July 1863), 391-400. [G.H. Lewes,] 'Aids to Beauty, Real and Artificial', Cornhill 7 (March 1863), 392. Ibid., 399. Ibid., 400. [E.S. Dallas,] 'Popular Literature - The Periodical Press, Part II', Blackwood's Magazine (February 1859), 180. Ibid., 184. Laurel Brake, 'Theories of Formation. The Nineteenth Century: vol. 1, No. 1, March 1877. Monthly. 2/6', Victorian Periodicals Review 25:1 (Spring 1992), 17. Mary Ann Clawson, Constructing Brotherhood: Class, Gender, and Fraternalism (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1989), especially the first two chapters. [Coke Richardson,] 'The Sharpshooters of the Press: In England, France, and Germany', Cornhill 7 (February 1863), 238-51. Eugene de Mirecourt, Histoire contemporaine, portraits et silhouettes au XlXeme siecle: Alphonse Karr, no. 38 (Paris: Achille Faure, 1867), 30: 'Posing had become a serious business, a mania, a system, a daily
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
46
91. 92.
93. 94.
47
and hourly need. He constantly threw into relief his individuality and made his peculiar manner and character a public spectacle' (my translation). Karr is perhaps best known for his witty epigrams, such as 'Plus c,a change plus c'est la meme chose', written in 1849 about the recent revolutions. Ibid., 31 ff. [Richardson,] 'Sharpshooters of the Press', 242. A great deal of work remains to be done on the subject of cross-dressing in journalism, e.g. those men who adopted a female pose in writing articles or in editing magazines. Ibid., 238. [Robert W Buchanan,] 'Society's Looking Glass', Temple Bar 6 (August 1862), 131.
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Domestic Ideology and Gendered Space
Uncovering Periodical Identities: Good Words and the Rejection of Rachel Ray Less than a month after finishing writing the final parts to The Small House at Allington, Trollope began his next serial, Rachel Ray, to be published in the religious monthly Good Words beginning July 1863. Although Trollope completed the commissioned novel and the serialization was advertised, Rachel Ray was never serialized in the magazine, but published in two volumes by Chapman and Hall in October 1863. The editor of Good Words, a Scottish Queen's Chaplain, Dr Norman MacLeod, refused Trollope's novel on the grounds that it would be offensive to his readers. Intensive criticism of Good Words and Trollope from the Evangelical extreme led to the rejection of Rachel Ray. This rejection provides not only an interesting case of serial and book publishing history, but also an example of the difficulty for a purportedly religious magazine such as Good Words to serialize a popular secular novelist such as Trollope. By 1864, Good Words had become the most popular monthly magazine, outselling even Cornhill. What, then, was the conflict between an increasingly popular periodical and perhaps the leading novelist of the circulating libraries? What are the apparently conflicting interests between two types of popular literature, religious and secular? Generally, the cheap religious market in the 1850s and 1860s, as with the cheap secular market, consisted mostly of weeklies whose readership included the lower middle and working classes. But in 1861, after only a year as a weekly, Good Words became a monthly and leaned increasingly towards Cornhill's popular secularism rather than strictly the cheap religious market. In Good Words and his previous periodicals, MacLeod was genuinely committed to redefining cheap religious literature in 48 10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
2
Uncovering Periodical Identities
several ways - by maintaining a non-denominational policy, by extending the range of its quality fiction, and by repositioning Good Words in the monthly market. However, at a particular moment in the process of broadening the scope of cheap religious literature, Rachel Ray was caught in the tension between stasis and change and so did not reach the pages of the periodical press until some years after volume publication.
PURE MORALS Trollope was no stranger to rejection at the time Rachel Ray was refused. A letter to Thackeray in 1860 acknowledges the rejection of the story 'Mrs. General Talboys' for Cornhill: I trust you to believe me when I assure you that I feel no annoyance as against you at the rejection of my story. An impartial Editor must do his duty. Pure morals must be supplied. And the owner of the responsible name must be the index of purity. A writer for a periodical makes himself subject to this judgment by undertaking such a w o r k . . . (Letters 1, 206) Trollope disagreed with Thackeray's judgement, because he maintained the belief that novelists ought to write 'for the best and wisest of English readers; and not mainly for the weakest' (Letters 1, 207). As head of the largest circulating library, Charles Mudie was the overriding figure of importance in considering the morality of a work of fiction. According to Guinivere Griest, 'what Mudie thought good became more and more important as his library flourished and expanded'. 1 However, it is difficult to assess how Mudie's moral code constructed the contents of periodicals, or how Mudie's censorship reflected what many circulating library subscribers wanted to read. Griest believes that, like other institutions of the age, the circulating library extended and emphasized the ideas with which it began, solidifying them until, at the height of its influence, it appeared to be the originator of these ideas, and was so attacked. 2
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
49
Trollope and the Magazines
Griest's analysis of this great 'institution of the age' tends to unify the library system in a way which Michel Foucault has called total history, the attempt to present an uncomplicated, coherent version of an historical period. 3 By assuming that Mudie's 'reflected the tastes and attitudes of his readers', 4 Griest's study of Mudie's, while invaluable in providing a portrait of one of the most significant players in the cultural field, tends to ignore the possible conflicts which occurred within the cultural politics of the publishing industry. Whether Mudie was a moral guardian of middle-class literary culture or not, the active agency of individuals like the editor in constructing, not reflecting, readership needs to be examined. Even Griest asserts that Thackeray's Cornhill policy (as described in the previous chapter) was 'even more restrictive than that of the libraries'. 5 In Cornhill the editor constructs the reading audience, determined by the presence of women and children. Relative to other shilling monthlies, Cornhill initially published little highly popular sensational material, which the libraries stocked and which was almost assuredly not familycircle material. Furthermore, there were cases when readers reacted against Mudie's moral code, as in the case of Charles Reade's Cream, which Griest discusses. 6 We cannot assume that Mudie's or the periodicals were passively reflecting what they knew readers wanted; such an approach defuses tensions where they almost certainly existed. Although there were cases of repression by periodicals and libraries, most writers exercised self-censorship as well and it was unusual for most novelists to be banned from a circulating library 7 Writing about literary censorship in the nineteenth century, Donald Thomas asserts that the most important form of moral censorship was one with which the law was not directly concerned. It was a censorship exercised ultimately by booksellers and libraries, penultimately by publishers or editors, and in the first place by authors themselves. And when all this was done, there still remained the individual censorship of the buyer or borrower. 8 The Obscene Publications Act of 1857 attempted to pornographic literature, but the more ambiguous area offensive literature was left to the industry and the Reservations about the circulating library network of
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
deal with of morally consumer. periodicals
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
50
51
and triple-deckers began to be expressed vigorously as early as the 1860s, focusing on the popularity of sensation novels by writers such as Mary Braddon. 9 However, Trollope was not a literary rebel, and his fiction was found acceptable by the mass of circulating library readers. The network of moral safeguards described by Thomas above - author, bookseller, publisher, editor, library, consumer - was what George Moore would react against so strongly in Literature at Nurse (1885). Moore protested that 'the librarian rules the roost; he crows, and every chanticleer pitches his note in the same key. He, not the ladies and gentlemen who place their names on the title-pages, is the author of modern English fiction.'10 What, then, happened to Rachel Ray? In fact, the novel is a simple comedy of rural love. Rachel, a young girl who lives with her mother and sister, falls in love with an ambitious young man new to town. A series of obstacles prevents the two from being together. The young man leaves town; the obstacles are overcome; the young man returns and marries Rachel. End of story. There are familiar Trollopian themes woven into the main narrative and thin subplots, such as the pastoral myth of the country, the tension between progress and tradition, and the difficult position for young women whose fate is often determined by others. But none of these things caused Rachel Ray to be rejected by Good Words. It was Trollope's often caustic attacks on the clergy's role as society's moral guardians which forced the magazine's editor to refuse the novel. In fairness to the editor of a religious magazine, it would have been difficult to accept a novel which targets the Low Church and Evangelicals. 11 Robert Polhemus believes that 'Trollope hated Evangelicalism as much as it was in him to hate anything human, and he saw love as a potential influence to counteract its lifedespising mentality'. 12 Rachel's sister, Mrs. Dorothea Prime, is a strictly Low Church widow approaching the important threshold of 30, and a committed member of the local Dorcas Society. Rachel says of the Dorcas women, 'they talk nothing but scandal all the time they are there, and speak any ill they can of the poor young girls whom they talk about'. 13 Trollope's attacks on the Dorcas Society continue throughout the novel, and Miss Pucker the Dorcas hostess is depicted as bitter and spiteful, revelling in Rachel's troubles. The assault on charitable Dorcas women alone would not have been enough to censor the novel, but it is
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Uncovering Periodical Identities
Trollope and the Magazines
interesting to note that other contemporary religious magazines were discussing Dorcas Societies in far more exalting tones. The Family Treasury of Sunday Reading, for example, ran a series of occasional articles (from February 1860 to June 1861) entitled 'Our Dorcas Society', 1 4 in which topics include dress, p e r s o n a l appearance, and home duties - the very points which Trollope derides in Baslehurst's Dorcas women. Founded a year before Good Words, the Family Treasury was also edited by a Scotsman, the Reverend Andrew Cameron, and the two periodicals shared some contributors such as Thomas Guthrie. MacLeod could not really have serialized a novel so scathing about Dorcas Societies when religious contemporaries were so clearly sober about them, unless he was prepared to signal that Good Words was definitely refiguring itself within another, less sober magazine market. Mrs Prime is criticized not merely for being a Dorcas woman, but also because 'she had taught herself to believe that cheerfulness was a sin' (4). An opponent of young love (who is considering her own marriage proposal for most of the novel), she moves out of the cottage when her mother condones Rachel's relationship with the young man, Luke, and so shields herself from worldiness. Mrs Prime's zealously Evangelical Reverend and suitor, Mr Prong, fares the worst in the novel because of his Evangelical intolerance: Mr. Prong was an energetic, severe, hardworking, and, I fear, intolerant young man, who bestowed very much laudable care upon his sermons. The care and industry were laudable, but not so the pride with which he thought of them and their results. He spoke much of preaching the Gospel, and was sincere beyond all doubt in his desire to do so; but he allowed himself to be led away into a belief that his brethren in the ministry did not preach the Gospel, - that they were careless shepherds, or shepherds' dogs indifferent to the wolf. . . (51) PD. Edwards believes Trollope's harsh treatment of the Evangelicals is related to class prejudices, and that Trollope and 'his characters patently compound, and confuse, sectarian prejudice'. 15 Much is made of Mr. Prong not being educated at one of the Oxford colleges, and we are reminded 'that sometimes he forgot his "h's"'
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
52
53
(52). Like Mrs Tappitt at the brewery, who sometimes speaks coarsely and becomes 'a little forgetful of niceties learned somewhat late in life' (224), Mr Prong tries to present himself as someone he is not. These social pretensions in the religious and secular realms form the basis of Trollope's satire. He never really attacks the doctrines of clergymen and refrains from discussing the finer points of dogma. His approach, seen throughout the Barchester novels especially, is to parody what he perceives as the overearnestness and superficial hypocrisy of the clergy. Mr Comfort, Mrs Ray's Low Church Reverend, is more kindly than Prong but he covets worldly things: When he endeavoured to teach his flock that they should despise money, he thought that he despised it himself. When he told the little children that this world should be as nothing to them, he did not remember that he himself enjoyed keenly the good things of this world. If he had a fault it was perhaps this, that he was a hard man at a bargain. He liked to have all his temporalities, and make them go as far as they could be stretched. (62) He condones dancing in private but condemns worldiness from the pulpit on Sundays. As his name implies, Mr. Comfort fails to live up to the standard he vehemently preaches. The High Churchman Dr. Harford, whose appearance is relatively brief, suffers from an inability to change and tolerate new ideas: But, now in his old age, he was discontented and disgusted by the changes which had come upon him; and though some bodily strength for further service remained to him, he no longer had any aptitude for useful work. A man cannot change as men change. (234) The difficulty for MacLeod was not simply in accepting Trollope's severe treatment of the strict Evangelicals, but in finding any redeemable clergyman in the novel at all. Trollope, of course, did not hold his clergymen to the same standard that the editor of a
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Uncovering Periodical Identities
Trollope and the Magazines
religious periodical would. A few years later, in Clergymen of the Church of England, Trollope writes that 'it almost seems that something approaching to hypocrisy were a necessary component part of the character of the English parish parson, and yet he is a man always on the alert to be honest'. 16 The rural parish priest must preach sternly but remain mild, walk loudly but carry a soft stick. Dr Harford, Mr Comfort and even Mr Prong mean no harm, however much disturbance they inadvertently cause. Whether MacLeod misjudged his author - especially considering the treatment of the Low Church in, say, Barchester Towers (1857) - or was pressured by external forces is another matter. Implicit in Trollope's criticisms of the clergy in Rachel Ray is the opinion that individuals ought to be able to take responsibility for their own lives, and this is presented in gendered terms. Rachel Ray is partly a novel about female duty, Mrs Prime's fixation, and the tensions arising from the conflict between personal and external forms of authority. This is explicit in the first sentence of the novel which introduces the t h e m e of female dependence: There are women who cannot grow alone as standard trees; for whom the support and warmth of some wall, some paling, some post, is absolutely necessary; - who, in their growth, will bend and incline themselves towards some such prop for their life, creeping with their tendrils along the ground till they reach it when the circumstances of life have brought no such prop within their natural and immediate reach. (i) Mrs Ray's inability to make her own decisions, and her need to be guided by a surrogate husband and master, are immediate causes of disruption and anxiety in the novel. Jane Nardin is correct to argue that Mrs Ray is the 'prototype of the angel in the house', but 'her inability to think and act for herself makes her atypical in the novel and undermines this Victorian ideal of womanhood. 1 7 Had Mrs Ray been confident enough in her own moral strength, she need not have sought advice from Mr Comfort, to 'be guided altogether by his counsel' (61). The narrator states, 'I do not know that a widow, circumstanced as was Mrs Ray, could do better than go to her clergyman for advice' (61), but
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
54
55
the rest of the novel demonstrates that the need to be guided so exclusively by others is a weakness which potentially threatens the comic resolution. Duty to others, then, entails personal integrity and confidence in one's own moral strength. Even after obtaining Mr Comfort's blessing that Rachel should encourage Luke's advances, Mrs Ray was 'not altogether at ease in her mind as to the question, - what line of moral conduct might best befit a devout Christian' (63). Her confusion betrays a belief that her clergyman's advice is contradictory or misguided. Mrs Ray's indecisiveness and perpetual clinging to others are shown alongside her clergyman's failure to provide sound counsel consistent with his preaching. Even the autocrat Mrs Prime turns to Mr Prong because 'he would tell her in what way she had better live' (113), but such advice as he offers appears uncharitable and rigid. Part of Rachel's attractiveness is her insistence that she will not be guided by anyone other than her mother and eventually Luke, and she absolutely refuses to accept her domineering sister's judgements of her behaviour. There are other gendered issues which intersect in the novel which could have made the first volume an uncomfortable read for MacLeod. For example, Mrs Prime's engagement to Mr Prong raises questions about women's property and marriage, and the solution here is that it is better for a woman to keep her property than relinquish her economic power in marriage. As Mrs Ray indicates to her clergyman, money is more important than marriage for Mrs Prime: 'Do let her look sharp after her money', said Mr Comfort. 'Well, that's just it. She's not a bit inclined to give it up to him, I can tell you.' (243) Independence, finally, outweighs duty for Mrs Prime. Ownership of property as it relates to gender is a perennial concern in Trollope's fiction, as we will see in the following chapter in my discussion of The Belton Estate. Here, it is enough simply to realize that Mrs Prime's worries about her independence echo those being articulated in debates in periodicals about single women generally.
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Uncovering Periodical Identities
Trollope and the Magazines
We might also consider that Rachel is described in ways that invoke discourses about the fallen woman. Her sister calls her a 'castaway' (47), a word for fallen women in the mid-nineteenth century. In his Preface to The Vicar of Bullhampton (1870), Trollope calls the fallen woman Carry Brattle a castaway, and in the same year Augusta Webster published her dramatic monologue entitled A Castaway', about an upper-class prostitute. 18 The cultural currency of the word signals Mrs Prime's severity and Rachel's sexual awakening. At the Tappitts' ball, when the joys of physical (sexual) expression are available to her through dancing, Rachel feels 'that her head was sinking beneath the waters' (84), a reference to the drowning woman image implicitly linked to the fallen woman. 19 Later in the novel, Mrs Butler Cornbury links Rachel to mermaids, again connecting water imagery to sexuality (348). That Rachel should be described as a sexualized woman is significant, since, as we shall see later in this chapter, it was sensationalism which formed the basis of objections to Trollope's fiction by strict Evangelicals. The drowning, submerging images serve another purpose, however: to rewrite the symbols of baptism in terms of worldly pleasure. The secularizing of religious imagery also occurs in the figure of the inviting arm in the clouds that Luke shows Rachel in C h a p t e r 3; it is not a religious symbol, as in Michelangelo's God and Adam or in depictions of Christ's outstretched arms, but a sign of earthly love and passion. Discourses about intemperance surround Mr Tappitt, who often finds himself 'detained, by business, in the bar of the Dragon Inn' (296). Mrs Tappitt mixes a strong gin and water to obtain her husband's consent for her extravagances at the ball (70), and his drunkenness after an evening in the Dragon increases her leverage in arguing for his early retirement. His recklessness is linked to his drinking, and there is at least the suggestion that fewer evenings in the Dragon would lead to clearer judgement. After the Tappitts have moved to Torquay, we learn that Tappitt, too, could never again stray away from home with mysterious hints that matters connected with malt and hops must be discussed at places in which beer was consumed. He had no longer left to him any excuse for deviating from the regular course of his life even by a hair's breadth . . .20 (396)
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
56
57
Tappitt's drinking, which takes him away from the home, weakens his power overall because it demeans his stature as a husband (Mrs Tappitt ultimately ensures the family's security) and blurs his business judgement (Mr Tappitt is shown simply to be wrong). It is at least plausible that a number of discourses which enter the novel - women's property, sexual women, intemperate men - made Rachel Ray uncomfortable for MacLeod at a time of exceptionally intense pressure from Evangelicals. Such cultural discourses, together with the representation of a lax clergy, would have posed a significant problem for the clergyman-editor MacLeod. But at least as meaningful is the indirect assumption that individuals ought to accept responsibility for their own actions, to become their own counsellors, which reduces the position of the clergy as moral guardians in the community. Furthermore, the novel demonstrates that women's reliance on m e n ' s advice and aspirations is m o r e often t h a n not wrongheaded. Recurrently, women are disappointed by men, although in the end Rachel is not. 21 Mr Tappitt is self-deluded in his single-mindedness about Luke, and as in so much Victorian fiction, it is up to the wife, bully though she is, to prevent the ruin of her family. Such subversions of accepted Christian gender roles appearing in a purportedly Evangelical periodical would have been, at the very least, unusual. If we accept that Trollope believed in the educative nature of fiction as he states in the Autobiography (220), then we should also accept that 'the novelist, if he have a conscience, must preach his sermons with the same purpose as the clergyman, and must have his own systems of ethics' (A 222). The novelist becomes the preacher, replacing the clergyman in an increasingly secular society. Rachel Ray demonstrates Trollope's own ethical system in which the need for individuals, and women particularly, to become their own moral guardians is more important than following the strict advice of the pastoral adviser who is probably somewhat hypocritical anyway. Unless he was prepared to promote a value system which undermined the eminence and influence of the clergy, MacLeod had to reject Rachel Ray.
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Uncovering Periodical Identities
58
Trollope and the Magazines THE PROBLEM OF VISIBLE UNITY
'Good Words' will contain instructive and original Articles on various topics of interest to the Christian Family: such as Expositions of Scripture for Sabbath-evening reading; Devotional Papers; Biographical Sketches of the great and good; Illustrations of the glory of God as displayed in His material works: Papers on Social Duties; Travels in Palestine, illustrative of the Bible, &c, &c. It is unnecessary to add, that 'Good Words' will have no denominational connexion, but is intended to be a medium of communication between writers and readers of every portion of the Church of Christ. . .22 The editor stresses the broad acceptance of Christian faiths, and fiction is conspicuously absent from the list of contents. In December 1860 MacLeod published another editor's note reasserting the exact mission of his Good Words: When I accepted the editorship of this Magazine, my principal motive was the desire to provide a Periodical for all the week, whose articles would be wholly original, and which should not only be written in a Christian spirit, or merely blend 'the religious' with 'the secular', but should also yoke them together without compromise.. . . The tens of thousands who buy the Magazine confirm me in the opinion, that I have not misinterpreted the wishes or the wants of the great mass of our Christian community . . . . .. The faithful exhibition of Evangelical truth shall go handin-hand with every department of a healthy literature. 23 While MacLeod may claim to be interpreting his readers correctly, the need for such a statement of purpose at all, 12 months after the first issue and original mission statement had appeared, indicates that the Good Words message was not being conveyed and needed reinforcing. The statement reads more like a justification for editing a magazine which seeks to blend the secular with the religious, and this identity crisis is one that would remain prob-
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
On the inside front cover of the first issue in January 1860, MacLeod stated the magazine's original intentions as a religious weekly:
59
lematic for the periodical and its editor, and one which its publisher, Alexander Strahan, was already recognizing. 24 A month later, in January 1861, the magazine changed format. Hitherto, they had relied on the format of the traditional cheap weekly magazine published at a penny or two but also issued in monthly numbers costing usually between five and seven pence. The contents of these magazines were often divided into four sections to indicate the weekly bias, as seen on the January 1860 cover of Good Words (Fig. 2.1). In the changed format, Good Words was bidding for the popular secular monthly market, which did not make distinctions in weekly, let alone Sunday reading. 25 MacLeod may be slightly defensive in the December 1860 issue before he enters the monthly market to compete with mostly non-religious, middle-class, more expensive magazines like Cornhill, and it is interesting to note that he mentions the change in publication, together with a commitment to signature at the end of his editorial note, almost in passing. However, these modifications were momentous and pivotal, especially since an emphasis on individual contributors lessens MacLeod's responsibility for the religious contents, and opens up a space for several denominations to speak independently. An advertisement in January 1861 (Fig. 2.2) confirms the emphasis on named contributors. The move away from the cheap weekly market and the publicizing of individual contributors indicate that Good Words was seeking to combine two 'mass' readerships, the religious and the secular. Eventually seizing on Good Words's unstable identity, and with the prospect of a Trollope serial looming, extreme Evangelical critics would respond harshly in condemning MacLeod's project in 1863. Discussing the culture industry in the Dialectic of Enlightenment, Theodor Adorno and Max Horkheimer describe the 'unity of opposites' which are the marketplace and independence. 2 6 Although their term is part of a critique of mid-twentieth-century mass culture, it bears considering in relation to Victorian popular literature, and it may be helpful to think of Good Words as trying to negotiate its way between these competing forces. In the case of Good Words there is tension between an essentially commercial publisher (albeit one who believed in the educative power of literature) and his clergyman-editor whose name adorns each page of the magazine: 27 how to negotiate between creating and expanding a 'mass' market while maintaining a theological dedication and broad-mindedness. The earliest years of Good Words
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Uncovering Periodical Identities
60
Trollope and the Magazines
K<-VJfEEKLY*MK easts! BY
JWWUARY, 1800
£ * 331
?«»
•*<• v i * y . « & &**$ 8/.»-r*.:a.'' !>«*< «&? ti<«tX.-J. B$M>*3> ....,...,..• ...,,,:•: :•:•:• * a»siCT>n .....v. .»«»,«»« * t s w * » »a«{«fs-r* ** ©****$* s | J*y s*w«i«*f*s **<£*** , ••„—•.. S Jtaffigfegtf f< Mr » « « .:<• Ssriifi ••,•-, B Sirtxtes « 8****: Hi»wy...4&*ft«3.$g w« Bfttos >>*<««$. 8>.-. *.. ? ! •—•<-. * H»**K-x. Jx KsfeHOci (+;•«>»••<.• ~>Xlt& * S « t^v. | • s>(x<¥S«fo tfo r«C»J«. ,..,:,,• "SflWll' •»:?*) |x, ««S>>y.f ..... 1»: 8*<> S / * ? . < * « * t:-^r • X) *, ,v:. m<-<>» <•* t<«Fsi !¥**«&*»«» % » f » m i%»^ f.. &**<*)* now«*<4« <*i Kifefo ?J»8p«i* •.,„, * •.,,.,.,.•„,, * ,...,^.v.,,,.. „,., *a T*»W-<**»«&*.,.. | i » &«)?<• i*«/ *» *&* X&X 13 i
la. I? ^"ft^Pw**<••»«»»
,,..,.<:»-
« ^W«*i»»4...... ,,,.,. A V*fe»r«f t.i?» ..,,•,.,,
J«js -J* rtj; *te». S& 1. -•••••3*W M*>*™4* ftSftfetfil&wi'j...:. ,.„,,..,,,.„,,„.,..., S3
ftX$*fe*»$fa
fc-Pwaw*
t'** *<**. V«W.,.,.,-
ft<«<(;« t>*}^. »}***iy..w.v
-,,.,*: ...,„•.,,.•• * *
, S3
.,.„„.. -..;•:•;.. •.«•>.• v -
i lit*: «<>>>? :»> S ^ v i i * t:j#<«<>^«^>».,•,,,.
victim- wrmwoz v&$i'im-i>
Fig. 2.1
Cover of Good Words (January 1860)
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
miw M*
t&m J*
Uncovering Periodical Identities
{it w
>
TII
r\/K»
61
^
MI. *iinikirz sr^' ^?«,
< '»t >
Ht E J*X».vs v ^V W < * '
h>s'/„t.
) * j<
Li
',
^ a - V ^ A * . * * i<
ili
PAS*
>,SXXT --^5 (
TM
»pi Sx-*>» <^ • V 4-X* W / x « ; f< ^ « v ' * V \j<
*•»•»»
'
> ^
r<
* tt*"-'** w * * * (• J^*xi**ax#
SEW STOftt
i*
II
^
!
fly 5!*?^. MT'LMi'K.
X hit
f \ \r\
f ,
<0\
"/' "\\ ^\ »>*: > *,, K r;^;
Fig. 2.2 Advertisement for Good Words (January 1861)
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
rs
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
»Cft
Trollope and the Magazines
demonstrate precisely the conflict between the secular 'mass' and the 'Christian community' which MacLeod hopes to transform. Without relying too heavily on speculation, it is worth noting that MacLeod's second editorial note appears on the very last page of the December 1860 issue, perhaps indicating a reluctance and unease at having to explain the magazine's approach; a bolder, more confident and more common alternative would have been to place the editorial message first in the number and confront any d i s p a r a g i n g r e a d e r s h e a d on. The m a g a z i n e announces the change casually, without addressing either the significance of concentrating on the monthly market or the augmented presence of named contributors. In January 1861, however, Good Words became fully a monthly periodical, and the shift from a cheap religious weekly to a wholesome monthly magazine was signified. Norman MacLeod had previous experience editing both a weekly and monthly religious magazine before he agreed to oversee Good Words for Strahan. In 1849 he became editor of the Edinburgh Christian Magazine, a cheap religious monthly (priced at between two and four pence) at a time when the Church of Scotland had few of its own periodicals. WJ. Couper in Scottish Notes and Queries (1902) called the Christian Magazine 'a kind of understudy . . . of the better known Good Words'}* In a number of editorial notes throughout his ten-year editorship, MacLeod shifted the emphasis of his magazine from one merely reinforcing Church of Scotland views to one more outward-looking. In Volume 3, he writes: But the Editor hopes never to forget, that there are other branches of Christ's Church in Scotland and out of it, in whose well-doing in God's sight we should, as Christians, rejoice, and whose ill-doing we should, as Christians, deplore. 29 The other 'branches' of the Scottish Church are, of course, the Evangelicals to whom MacLeod was both sympathetic and on good terms. Responding to complaints by readers that the magazine was not religious enough for Sabbath-day reading, MacLeod writes in 1856: The Editor takes this opportunity of replying, once [and] for all, to one or two anonymous correspondents, by protesting that he never announced or intended the Magazine 'solely for
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
62
63
Sunday reading', and will not involve himself in so nice a question, as to what this or that reader may deem suited for the holy day. Each must select articles out of the Magazine for himself, as he does books out of the library, or subjects out of his own mind, and such as he deems most suitable for Sabbath. Those who 'cannot stand the temptation'(l) may fly from it.30 Religious periodicals at this time were still largely sectarian and exclusive, rather than catholic in their tolerances, and were often intended for Sunday reading; MacLeod's attempt to shift the religious emphasis of the Edinburgh Christian Magazine was therefore significant. As MacLeod acknowledges at the time of the attacks on Good Words some years later, I had tried the very same experiment in the old Edinburgh Christian Magazine for ten years.. .. But while I met with constant opposition from the weaker brethren, I held on with the hope of emancipating cheap religious literature from the narrowness and weakness to which it had come. 31 Responding to an Edinburgh professor's objections to Good Words, MacLeod accepts 'the bold experiment of revolutionizing to some extent popular religious literature, by placing it on a wider, truer, and therefore more lasting basis than it had before occupied'. 32 The project dared to redefine what constituted religious reading. MacLeod's dedication to a freer religious literature is rooted in his personal belief that Christians may be united in purpose but differ in particular worship. At the time of the Church of Scotland Disruption in 1843, when the Free Church split from the established Church over the question of patronage, MacLeod remained aloof from the controversy until positioning himself as one of 'The Forty' hovering between the radical Evangelicals and the moderates. He was very close to Thomas Chalmers, an Evangelical leader under whom he studied at Edinburgh, but MacLeod believed that schism was misguided. Referring to the Disruption three years later, he writes, 'I detest Church controversy; it is rarely profitable to writer or reader; it is apt to darken our mind and injure our best affections.' 33 Similarly in 1846, he replies to a colleague:
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Uncovering Periodical Identities
Trollope and the Magazines I think there may be all the one-ness which Christ ever intended to exist in the Church, without that kind of visible unity which you seem to contend for. The grand problem is how to obtain the greatest amount of one-ness in essential doctrine - in affection - in work - with the greatest amount of personal and congregational freedom as to government and worship. 34
In the same year, MacLeod attended the Evangelical Alliance and also travelled to America, two experiences of which he records, 'I have mingled more with other minds - got hold of more than during my whole lifetime.' 35 MacLeod was also influenced by the example of Thomas Arnold, who ran his own short-lived cheap religious periodical in 1831. Arnold's weekly Englishman's Register was intended to be a 'real Poor Man's Magazine', but his venture lasted only a few months. 3 6 As noted by his brother, MacLeod 'had long cherished the conviction that a periodical was greatly required of the type sketched by Dr Arnold, which should embrace as great a variety of articles as those which give deserved popularity to publications professedly secular, but having in spirit and aim distinctively Christian'. 37 MacLeod, rather like Arnold, was a Churchman more interested in the broadness of Christian thought than in the particulars of Ecclesiastical government; he brought this attitude and Arnold's example with him to the Edinburgh Christian Magazine in 1849, and later to Good Words. The Edinburgh Christian Magazine, of which the circulation was never more than 5000, was not the only periodical attempting to renegotiate the borders of healthy religious reading. Throughout the 1850s, a number of cheap religious periodicals were established in an attempt to capitalize on the growing family-reading market for weeklies. 38 The Religious Tract Society, for example, began publishing two weeklies priced one penny in the early 1850s, The Eeisure Hour (1852-1908) and Sunday at Home (18541940). Like many weeklies, as noted above, the magazines were also issued in monthly parts for five pence. That the Tract Society was targeting the family circle is best indicated in their magazine's subtitles: The Eeisure Hour was A Family Journal of Sabbath Reading'. The frontispiece to The Eeisure Hour included an illustration of paterfamilias reading to his family (Fig. 2.3). Both magazines, as cheap weeklies, sought to include working-class readers among their circulation. In 'A Word With Our Readers' in the first issue of The Eeisure Hour, the magazine states,
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
64
m -m
Fig. 2.3 Frontispiece to The Eeisure Hour (1852)
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
65
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Uncovering Periodical Identities
66
Trollope and the Magazines
The periodical often led with fiction, and included at least one large illustration in each issue. As a Sabbath magazine, Sunday at Home was more sober in its presentation and contents than the weekly Eeisure Hour. There are very few illustrations, and advertisements are strictly religious in nature. However, Sunday at Home was intended to be non-denominational, believing that 'to read only one's own Church Magazine is apt, and almost sure indeed, to foster a narrow spirit'. 40 This statement could be read as a theological justification for a commercial change in periodical literature seeking a larger readership. With these two publications, the Religious Tract Society began to push cheap religious periodicals toward the popular, family weekly market, although a distinction between weekday and Sunday reading is maintained. There was a spectrum of so-called family papers in the decades preceding Good Words, many of which were not intended as religious reading. For example, the Family Magazine of 1830 was 'a work peculiarly adapted to the FAMILY CIRCLE'41 but was not a religious magazine. The Family Friend which began in 1849 (the same year as MacLeod's Edinburgh Christian Magazine) tried to find a middle ground between religious and secular periodical literature: Twelve months ago it occurred to the writer that a Serial was needed, differing in character from its predecessors - in its tone, more chaste than some, but less austere than others. A medium between two extremes was to be struck out, without the sacrifice of a principle, or the omission of a duty. For years pernicious emanations from Salisbury Square and Holywell Street had poured out their baneful influences upon the rising and inquiring mind of the nation, mingling poison with sufficient sweetness to partially disguise it; an evil which Paternoster Row had done too little (though, indeed, it had done much) to counteract. The religious publications - being exclusive in their character - were unaccepted by miscellaneous society, and hence they were like seed scattered upon soil already teeming with pro-
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
we dedicate our pen to the thoughtful of every class. We aspire to catch the attention of peer and peasant, of master and man. From the highest to the lowest, there is no circle from which we desire to exclude ourselves; and none, we would hope, which will be desposed [sic] to exclude us. 39
Uncovering Periodical Identities
67
This monthly magazine quickly became fortnightly and by the end of 1850 announced a circulation of 80,000. In 1853, John Cassell began his highly successful Cassell's Illustrated Family Paper, published weekly for one penny or in monthly parts at five or six pence. Cassell's was heavily illustrated, more than most cheap weeklies, and led with serial fiction. There were miscellaneous essays, a weekly chess game, and personal classifieds to broaden appeal. Cassell's was not strictly religious, but it was intended as family reading, and its circulation reached a staggering 250,000. However, other periodicals used the 'family magazine' rubric to endorse firmly Sunday reading, as in the case of the twopenny weekly Family Sunday Book, 'Designed to supply interesting and suitable Reading for the Leisure Hours of Sunday' (1851), the Family Treasury of Sunday Reading (1859-79), and the British Evangelist and Christian Magazine for the Home Circle (1861). There was no single doctrinal ideology conveyed in the notion of family papers, which were not necessarily religious at all. At the time Good Words went monthly in 1861, Cassell founded the Quiver, a more religious penny weekly (also issued monthly) which was not illustrated although it carried fiction. As announced in the subtitle, its goal was 'the advancement of religion in the homes of the people'. It was this cheap, hybridized, popular, family market with weekly and monthly issues toward which religious periodicals in the 1850s were moving, 43 and MacLeod recognized the potential for a religious weekly while editing the Edinburgh Christian Magazine. The final issue of the Christian Magazine appeared in March 1859, and by May, MacLeod was associated with the Christian Guest, which became Good Words in 1860. The Guest was launched in February 1859, priced one halfpenny weekly and three pence monthly, published by Strahan, and subtitled A Family Magazine for Leisure Hours and Sundays'. Note how this title combines the titles from magazines such as Eeisure Hour (a phrase also used in the subtitle to The Family Friend), the 'Sunday' periodicals and the 'Family' periodicals. Such hybridity indicates that magazine identities were in flux, not fixed definitively within either the religious or secular markets, that these two markets overlapped and shared certain qualities. 44 Upon MacLeod's arrival in May, the Guest cover changes and the periodical is now subtitled A
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
ductiveness: they did not sufficiently fertilize the barren waste. These opinions gave birth to The Family Friend}2
Trollope and the Magazines
Family Magazine for Sunday Reading' 'Revised by the Rev. Norman M'Leod, D.D., Glasgow' (Fig. 2.4). Interestingly, MacLeod emphasized 'Sunday Reading' when that is precisely what he argued against in the Edinburgh Christian Magazine; such an emphasis changes the target market. Strahan was also courting MacLeod to be editor of the envisioned Good Words. Few magazines displayed the editor's name on the cover as the Guest did with MacLeod; most, in fact, remain anonymous and do not mention the editor at all. The Guest's 'revised by' is reminiscent of an altogether different weekly, Household Words, A Weekly Journal Conducted by Charles Dickens,' 45 which ceased publication at the end of May 1859, the month MacLeod began at the Guest. In the final issue of the Guest in December 1859, when it is announced that the magazine would become Good Words, MacLeod's prospectus for Good Words states: It may seem unwarrantable in the minister of a large and populous city parish to u n d e r t a k e the labours and accept the responsibility of conducting a weekly magazine. I have been induced, however, to engage heartily and hopefully in this new and catholic enterprise by the cordial promises of literary aid which I have received from many well known and tried writers connected with almost every branch of the Church of Christ, whose 'Good Words' have become as 'household words' in our Christian homes. 46 MacLeod echoes Dickens by using both the unique term for Dickens's editing and the title of the periodical itself. In a direct way, this indicates a bid for the popular, secular, weekly Household Words market which Dickens's journal was just vacating. Having tried unsuccessfully to popularize a cheap religious monthly during the 1850s, MacLeod moved into the cheap weekly market, hoping to synthesize his Arnoldian ideas of an inclusive, cheap, popular, religious periodical.
THE 'MINGLE-MANGLE' OF SECULAR AND SACRED Good Words, as a weekly, and Cornhill, a monthly, both started up in the magazine boom year of 1860 and published their first issues on the same day. While Thackeray's magazine broke
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
68
Uncovering Periodical Identities
A FAMILY MAOAmE tm mmnkY rnt
m.mm,
REVX NORMAH M'LEOO, a s ,
GLASGOW.
FAJtT I?#--MAT 185$. £ aide ids, No. 1*.
No, 13, *&•&***!* <•? RvSvy* I5< : * • / % ! ? . $•****.*:
£ !..:*«,. VV.
**•* •
.>. 5J>«x> >'»*•»»> ?,? ('*»<<*<«:.
S<-iVSM f : » v ( > i<<, : ^,.<< :><-jfe #..f.,»^*> . l y ^ T + H i ' ^ ">' ":v. :•.'••. :^' :! <:<:'('•; " y ^ l ' c W i V<-\<£:
;-iv
• l){ ^ '•« . ^ . < : / V , ^ « x ^ l :i< S'xiiii
V-. *<<*•<<* * : :-v
;
KX Mi VA v,f VA.
n>- !>«< ^ 1 *}*•$••»$•. !?»•• li>,<xs-s.<** Hi* ;J*!::i< ••»:>»•> v < i : w x * M •.:>*•<* :* • v.. •::•• '^«-;«:*«lb«
JSfy:::><<:<::.•> <>? V. >*::,v>:. .!«,< • f i * . l ; v « « - * f ^ !
•;:•*«;*< h» f W w c t i * .-, <.;.v;.f:jJ :>!..;iv-v:<. •{*• 11. W BsrfxKfca
,
><• <;*,<• U * K * * « : : < * W *
n?
«»><«<** {.•••>i
;?<«>.* %
% Sir* 8. i t .
. ' . ' • . ' . •
*>A'it:--<* >*•;<>. »..):<••
M ')! > MX?
$'•*&>> A>{ ;:i<:- Y««S:j£-~ >.
$**'.<•.•
&:>"
M 4 * •#*»«*«*«
i
3W«, i©.
i ViX-Aiy i * , / v <,>.>.>••: *. MMiM?* iSM., !i<, ({.>»: l k « . v S » • • { . * ? « i ' . P . .
^ >:»:<svrf? <*. !:<•««•): >«;>«.
y ,
•>•> iU'.l,:?
:trov t*.
i-*M:t>:'wj>*»
T O
ii*
fbttfeci %'>!*?:;(>: •>" !:»: <J'v-». tfrtlfia it*. ^•::v,::v:> <4 £**>*.< VM'.-y.t. M > . SfevW^:*
08 *{** ft**:. £ .
H'>
1*1
im,i itMtJwwww . T}*xiii <><> *lw <.»h-M,
: « <*•>: V : « i x > : , > ?
t*?
.». K >;* >; < >. wirrScfiwi
t^..
&W:-4.':*v* :•<> i'«,*V J.>>'•: l !***>:* < i x « $ .
{::•?,
fjj >}„<•. f&V
>..•>:*<» « ' f . S x : « . ;>.{>. . •?)•<<<<:-<<< V >,:-*>:»»< J>: <.:«..:«> I V ^ , S w ^ i S »
Jy««*S ¥>%*«);x : ;fc>
ife^ MONTHLY PARTS, PftlCE THREEPENCE.
Figure 2.4 Cover of T/ze Christian Guest (May 1859)
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
W E & Y NUMBERS, PRICE ONE HALFPENNY.
Trollope and the Magazines
circulation records with its huge initial sales, Good Words, although outselling Cornhill in Scotland, built up its circulation gradually, often looking and learning from the Cornhill lead. 47 Patricia Srebrnik, Strahan's biographer, sees the early years of Good Words as a competition to outsell Cornhill. In 1862 Strahan stepped up the competition against Cornhill, since the circulation of Good Words was within 'striking distance' of the more popular monthly. 48 According to Srebrnik, 'the next step in Strahan's campaign to make Good Words the most popular monthly magazine of the day must have seemed obvious', 49 so in April MacLeod approached Trollope 'seeking crumbs from a rich man's table' (Fetters 1, 177). Good Words's circulation was about 70,000, compared to Cornhill's 72,500 in December of 1862. The religious periodical lacked a widely popular serial novelist of Trollope's standing, and by approaching him for a serial, the men behind Good Words sought to redress that omission. In 1862, there were fiction serials by Sarah Tytler (the pen name of Henrietta Keddie) and Dinah Mulock (author of the popular 1856 novel ]ohn Halifax, Gentleman), w h o was marginalized as a 'women's novelist' by most reviewers. 50 That MacLeod may have had his reservations about courting an author like Trollope is best indicated later in the same letter: 'I think you could let out the best side of your soul in Good Words better far than even in Cornhill' (Fetters 1, 178). Presumably, for MacLeod and Good Words, Trollope's best side would be his least worldly and least religiously antagonistic side. The details of the arrangement between Trollope and the periodical were negotiated by Strahan and the author. It was agreed in December 1862 that Trollope would write a serial of two-volume length to begin in July 1863, for which he would receive £1000. Strahan must have been pleased to have a circulating-library author of the most popular order commissioned for his periodical, especially since Trollope's The Small House at Allington had begun in September 1862 in Cornhill, with favourable indicators from the press and public. Meanwhile, Trollope contributed a short story, 'The Widow's Mite', to the January 1863 Good Words which seems ideally suited to the magazine. The title of the story refers to a parable from the Bible (Mark 12:43) in which a widow offers a pittance, though a significant amount for her, to the poor. The plot describes a young woman's decision to wear ordinary Sunday clothes, rather than a new wedding outfit, to her own wedding in order to give the money saved to cotton famine relief. Perhaps
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
70
Uncovering Periodical Identities
a gentle story such as this, but extended over several months, was what MacLeod hoped Trollope would produce. Rachel Ray, however, was not such a story. The next mention of the publishing of Rachel Ray in Trollope's surviving letters is in June 1863. Writing to the intended illustrator, Millais, Trollope rails playfully: X. (a Sunday magazine) has thrown me over. They write me word that I am too wicked. I tell you at once because of the projected, and now not-to-be-accomplished, drawings. They have tried to serve God and the devil together, and finding that goodness pays best, have thrown over me and the d e v i l . . . . I am unfit for the regenerated, and trust I may remain so, wishing to preserve a character for honest intentions. (Fetters 1, 220) Trollope, no doubt with tongue in cheek, states here that Good Words is a Sunday magazine, although that is too strict a definition for the periodical by this time. In a letter to Strahan of 10 June, he defends himself in a more businesslike fashion: I am sorry that you and Dr MacLeod have been forced to the conclusion at which you have arrived with reference to my story I claim for myself however to say that the fault in the matter is yours, & not mine. I have written for you such a story as you had a right to expect from me, - judging as you of course did judge by my former works. If that does not now suit your publication I can only be sorry that you should have been driven to change your views. (Fetters 1, 221) Trollope believed he was 'thrown over' because of vehement attacks on MacLeod and Good Words by strict Evangelicals. Owen Chadwick describes Evangelicals as 'men of the Reformation, who preached the cross, the depravity of man, and justification by faith alone'. 51 In the strictest sense this is true, although by the 1860s distinctions between, for example, Evangelicals and Low Churchmen were blurred and the terms used interchangeably. Elisabeth Jay describes Anglican Evangelicalism somewhat more loosely as a
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
71
Trollope and the Magazines
movement in which 'an emphasis on a personal relationship with God, its rejection of the corporate authority of the church, and the premium it placed upon the individual's judgement assured a man of a significance frequently denied him in secular society'. 52 But there was divergence within the Evangelical movement; Jay distinguishes, for example, between the Evangelicalism represented by the Record and the more moderate Christian Observer.53 It was the most extreme faction which attacked Good Words and Trollope particularly. We need to keep in mind the events leading u p to the rejection of Rachel Ray: Good Words changed format from a weekly to a monthly in January 1861; the agreement for Rachel Ray was finalized in December 1862; Trollope's story 'The Widow's Mite' was published in January 1863; and adverts for the Rachel Ray serial appeared in January 1863. Most importantly, in the first few weeks of April 1863, the Evangelical paper the Record published a series of articles questioning the soundness of MacLeod's theology and that of several contributors such as Principal Tulloch, Dr John Caird, and Dr Stanley.54 The Record was a tri-weekly Anglican Evangelical newspaper with a circulation of between 3000 and 4000. It denounced all Catholicism, Anglo or otherwise, preached sternly for the observance of the Sabbath, and campaigned strongly against Essays and Reviews in the 1860s.55 The Record states unequivocally that 'Good Words is doing about as dangerous a work as any journal of the present day', especially in the 'mingle-mangle' of the secular with the sacred (2). The zealous Evangelical publication rejects the 'liberalism of the day which permits such a free mix of opinion together', meaning the appearance of Low Church side by side with other groups in Good Words (3). The magazine's popularity is also a cause of great concern: 'We do not wonder that the magazine is popular. Give us our times for God, and our times without God, and the mammon; and no man can serve two masters' (26). And the Record singles out Trollope, along with the Christian Socialist Charles Kingsley and others, as those to whom Good Words offers its 'services to carry the deadly dose to the lips of our sons and daughters' (7). Adelaide Proctor is called 'a relatively recent convert to Popery', while the illustration to Dora Greenwell's poem in April 1863 is also Popish (55). Remarkably, the Record manages to discover sensation novels in Good Words, in which 'the most ungodly sentiments are uttered, and left to work their evil effects on the young mind',
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
72
Uncovering Periodical Identities
and it names Anthony Trollope, this year's chief sensation-writer for Good Words' (57). Because these articles were also circulated in pamphlet form, their visibility was increased and longevity assured. Although Trollope's letter to MacLeod about the rejection does not survive, MacLeod's response does, and is worth quoting at length: What I tried to explain and wished you to see when we met here, was the peculiar place which Good Words aimed at occupying in the field of cheap Christian literature. I have always endeavoured to avoid on the one hand the exclusively narrow religious ground - narrow in its choice of subjects & in its manner of treating them - hitherto occupied by our 'Religious' Periodicals; and on the other hand to avoid altogether whatever was either antagonistic to the truths or spirit of Christianity, and also as much as possible whatever was calculated to offend the prejudices, far more the sincere convictions and feelings of fair & reasonable Evangelical man. Within these extremes it seemed to me that a sufficiently extensive field in which any novelist might roam & find an endless variety of life & manners to describe with profit to all & without giving offence to a n y . . . . . . . . You do me wrong however in thinking .. . merely because of your Name I have sacrificed you to the vile Record & to the cry it & its followers have raised against you, as well as against me. . . . my only pain is that the Record will suppose that its attack has bullied me into the rejection of your story! (Fetters 1, 222-5) It certainly seems that MacLeod was bullied, although, again, we see the difficulty MacLeod and Strahan have in publishing a magazine for all the week, broadly Christian with Evangelical truth, together with a popular serial novelist. The Eiterary Times would not have made the situation easier for MacLeod when in the middle of the controversy it asserted that Good Words was 'as highly interesting and amusing as the most secular reader could desire'. 56 MacLeod recognizes in the letter to Trollope that the market he wishes the periodical to occupy is an anxious one, and his earnest defence of his editorial policy is appealing. But it is hard not to see a link between the Record attacks and the
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
73
Trollope and the Magazines
rejection of Trollope's serial, which was heavily advertised well in advance of its projected commencement in July 1863. Furthermore, Strahan had approved of the early chapters of Rachel Ray already set in type by the time MacLeod intervened and subsequently rejected the novel. 57 Reviewing what they saw as a dull July 1863 issue of Good Words, the Illustrated Eondon News judged that it 'seems to have been more affected by the rebukes of the Record than its directors will allow'. 58 The Record's assertion that Trollope was chiefly a sensation writer for Good Words appears based on little evidence. With its guilty secret at the centre, Orley Farm, published in part issue by Chapman and Hall in 1861-62, approaches some of the conventions of the sensation novel, but it was not sensational in the style of Mary Braddon's or Wilkie Collins's novels. Appearing in the same month as the Record attacks was an article in the Quarterly Review on sensation novels, 59 which discusses the three chief reasons why sensation novels flourish: periodicals, circulating libraries, and railway bookstalls. It is worth remembering that Trollope, by 1863, only wrote in serial form (although not all novels were published periodically), and he was among the most popular circulatinglibrary authors. In the article, divisions are made between types of sensation novel - the bigamy novels, the newspaper novels, and the theological novels, to name but a few. The theological sensation novel is defined as describing particular religious doctrines offensively, so that a novel might be anti-Dissenter or anti-Low Church. Rachel Ray could have been seen in these terms when it was eventually published several months after this article, and, in fact, MacLeod may have rejected Rachel Ray with the idea of Trollope as theologically sensational in mind. Certainly, Trollope's treatment of clergymen is inflexible and uncharitable, especially when it comes to the Evangelical Mr Prong. However, Trollope attacks manner rather than doctrines, and the Quarterly Review does not single out Trollope as a sensation writer as the Record does. Perhaps picking u p the debate over Trollope's place in popular literature, a Scottish periodical, The Rose, the Shamrock, and the Thistle, published an article in June 1863 which defends contemporary novels and states that Trollope among others is not sensational, rather one of those writers who when 'we read them we rise with a better appreciation of them than before'. 60 The magazine defends the morality of popular serials because of the intense examination novels must tolerate:
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
74
Uncovering Periodical Identities
75
In April 1863, Trollope was at the mercy of Good Words' Tittle world'. 'The principal organ of the Anglican evangelicals', 62 the Christian Observer, also entered the debate about Good Words. With a circulation of about 1000, and occupying the moderate Evangelical middle ground, however, the Observer did not cause the stir that the more extreme Record repeatedly did. Acknowledging 'the recent ferment that has lately been caused about [Good Words]', an Observer article goes on to praise the magazine's contributions. 63 They approve of the fiction and most of the secular, occasional pieces, and although they are anxious about the rigour of MacLeod's editorial eye, they are hopeful for the future. In November 1865 an article on sensation novels appeared in the Christian Observer which, perhaps surprisingly for an Evangelical publication, states that neither fiction nor sensationalism are necessarily evil.64 With a sensible understanding of public tastes, the article recognizes strategically that the way to guide fiction is to accept it but keep an eye on it, rather than oppose it outright. The Observer, at least, is resigned to the fact that 'it is a magazine age: there can be no doubt about that'. 65 The Record attacks on Good Words did not go unanswered. A nonconformist, Congregational paper, the Patriot, rallied around Good Words and its editor.66 The Patriot articles warn of the danger of overzealous Evangelicals and point out inconsistencies in the Record attacks. However, the Patriot articles (also circulating in pamphlet form) are rather more concerned to attack the Record than to defend Good Words. MacLeod, for example, is not vindicated unreservedly, as the Patriot also believes that Good Words would be better off without the services of Trollope: We regret the employment of Mr. Trollope and others of his class, believing that in thus entering into competition with the 'sensation' magazine, Good Words is abandoning its own proper position, and departing, in some measure, from its original design. 67
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Having passed the editorial scrutiny and been deemed worthy of insertion they have next to undergo the criticism of the little world among whom the periodical circulates, and the press, when everything of an injurious nature is certain to be most mercilessly exposed and denounced. 61
Trollope and the Magazines
A few lines later, the article asserts that Good Words' 'extraordinary success' is leading the magazine down. Strahan was hoping to imitate to an extent the Cornhill, a secular magazine par excellence. Although Cornhill was not a sensational magazine in the broad shilling monthly market, in 1863 it was serializing a sensational bigamy novel, Frederick Greenwood's Margaret Denzil's History, and Evangelical Record readers would certainly have disapproved. Even MacLeod's defenders feel that to publish Trollope (whose serialization of The Small House at Allington was being widely praised in many periodicals) is to take too significant a step in the wrong direction. Furthermore, and perhaps more telling, the Patriot, like the Record, worries that the very popularity of Good Words is a sign of degradation. At a time when Strahan is chasing Cornhill for sales, and has sought to employ Trollope as one means to that end, the outcry against Good Words is underlined by a fear that a mass readership is incompatible with religious dedication. Publicly, circulation leaders such as Good Words and Cornhill were associated, as the Eiterary Times made clear in April 1863: 'Good Words' continues to take the lead in the circulation of our magazines. This is not surprising, considering that it contains, for half price of the 'Cornhill', as much entertaining and instructive reading as that renowned periodical. 68 The huge popularity of the magazines is further connected to the institution of the libraries, as the article on sensation novels in the Quarterly Review asserts: 'the circulating library has been the chief hot-bed for forcing a crop of writers without talent and readers without discrimination.' 69 The writer of this article proposes that circulating libraries be formed which only make available books over 20 years old.70 And in that suggestion we have the crux of the argument against Trollope and others: contemporary popular culture is seen to be not only valueless but also, for the Record and the Patriot, dangerous. 71
GOOD BRACING AIR Trollope was doubtless aware that his position as a leader in circulating-library novels made him open to attack from those
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
76
Uncovering Periodical Identities
77
You know that my novels are not sensational. In Rachel Ray I have attempted to confine myself absolutely to the commonest details of commonplace life among the most ordinary people, allowing myself no incident that would be even remarkable in every day life. I have shorn my fiction of all romance. (Fetters 1, 238) Trollope was not alone in thinking his fiction, especially Rachel Ray, unsensational. George Eliot, writing to Trollope thanking him for his gift, responds: But there is something else I care yet more about, which has impressed me very happily in all those writings of yours that I know - it is that people are breathing good bracing air in reading them - it is that they, the books are filled with belief in goodness without the slightest touch of maudlin. They are like pleasant public gardens, where people go for amusement, & whether they think of it or not, get health as well. (Fetters 1, 238) As one writer complimenting another, Eliot may simply be overgenerous in her enjoyment of Rachel Ray, however, her belief in Trollope's hearty, healthy realism is probably genuine. Reviews of Rachel Ray tended to support Eliot in her appreciation. Many reviewers agreed on the simplicity of the novel and its lack of sensationalism. The Athenaeum review is typical: In these days of mysterious romances it is remarkable for absence of mystery; from first to last it has neither riddle nor surprise, - no point of harrowing anxiety, no trick for stimulating the curiosity of readers greedy for strange stories. 72 The Illustrated London News declared that there was 'not a single sensational incident' 73 in the novel. Whether the reviewers actually thought highly of the novel or not, none found anything
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
who denigrated popular literature. In a note to George Eliot which he included with the two volumes of Rachel Ray in October 1863, Trollope writes:
Trollope and the Magazines
shocking or extraordinary in Rachel Ray. As if to put an end to any further rumours that Good Words lacked religious conviction, in July 1863, the month when Rachel Ray was to have begun serialization, the magazine published an article entitled A Word of Remonstrance with Some Novelists', attacking the vogue for sexualized heroines and arguing that 'falseness, dishonesty, murder even, are rapidly claiming our most intense sympathies'. 74 The void left by the sacrificed novel was in a sense filled by the proclamations against wicked literature. In fact, the Saturday Review found Rachel Ray too realistic and too unsensational. Trollope is described as writing for a particular market and supplying 'the article in demand'. 75 The reviewer enjoys Trollope but feels there is a 'satiety' in any author of realism, and he hopes the next fashion in fiction will be 'more exciting and poetical'. 76 Here, Trollope fails to please because he is not sensational enough, rather than too suggestive. It should be noted, however, that the Saturday Review was no fan of fiction, and that although its reviewers generally approved of Trollope, his brand of photographic realism would eventually be slated by the periodical in the mid-1860s.77 In the Rachel Ray review, Trollope's fiction has become, like realism generally, too similar. In this argument, the Saturday Review's reservations about mass culture looks forward to Adorno and Horkheimer. In their critique of reproduced mass culture 80 years later, they suggest that sameness in cultural products is one result of mass culture. For them, popular culture has become 'rubbish', a value judgement I wish to avoid. But their belief that the culture industry is 'a constant reproduction of the same thing' 7 8 is relevant to the Victorian publishing industry, especially the network between serializations and circulating libraries in which self-censorship and imposed morals demarcated boundaries of popular fiction. It is true that Trollope and others were supplying a market hungry not simply for novels in general but for domestic fiction and realism in particular, and the effect on the mass market was undoubtedly an element of sameness.
GOLD AND SILVER The difficulty for Strahan as publisher was in exploiting the popular, secular monthly market to the full, while retaining the theologi-
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
78
79
cal soundness Good Words professed to have. Again, the conflict is the same as that outlined in MacLeod's editorial in 1860: how to blend the secular, which is to say the popular, with the religious in a seamless way. In an 1861 letter, MacLeod describes his difficult task: 'The spirit and teaching of the Magazine form a constant subject of anxiety. I want to intone all its services more with the direct Christian spirit, and shall do so, or give it up.' 79 Strahan's commercial commitment to Good Words, obvious in his race with Cornhill, is apparent in his response to the Record attacks. According to Srebrnik, Strahan welcomed the additional sales which the negative attention brought the magazine, whereas MacLeod became increasingly sensitive to criticism and insisted that all contributions be cleared through him before printing: I beseech you to let me see every MS. or proof before being printed off. I, as a minister, am more conversant than you can be with religious topics and the pulse of the religious world. Besides, as you know, my chief delight in Good Words is its power of doing good. God knows this is more precious to me than all the gold and silver on earth could be.80 Of course, Strahan as publisher was responsible for the gold and silver side of Good Words. Perhaps not surprisingly, by June 1862 Strahan had moved his firm from Edinburgh to Ludgate Hill, London, just round the corner from Paternoster Row and the centre of the publishing industry. MacLeod remained in his Glasgow parish. It seems Strahan believed 'that the magazine might benefit from a bit of remodelling, or at least a new public image', 81 especially after some recent criticisms which made Good Words appear bland and static. It was at this time that Trollope was approached for 'The Widow's Mite', the belief being that by enlisting a popular writer, the changing of the image could begin. As noted, Trollope's intended serialization was heavily advertised, as was Millais's expected contribution as illustrator. The team which had proven so successful for Cornhill had been poached by Strahan in an attempt to revamp and commercialize Good Words. Strahan's bid to overtake Cornhill did not come cheaply, and the move to London only added to the firm's substantial debts. In 1863 Strahan and Company borrowed £4000, and a year later an additional £6000, from their stationers, Spalding and Hodge. In an 1866 financial agreement, Strahan used the copyrights to
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Uncovering Periodical Identities
Trollope and the Magazines
Good Words, the Sunday Magazine, the Contemporary Review, and the Argosy to secure an additional sum from Spalding and Hodge and from J.S. Virtue and Company. Although he was frequently embarking on new periodical v e n t u r e s , Strahan was never without the looming shadow of large debts, and by 1872 he had lost the copyright to Good Words and other magazines. In a much-publicized battle for the Contemporary Review in 1876-77, Strahan maintained links with strict Evangelicals which forced his editor, James Knowles, to separate and found his own freethinking periodical, The Nineteenth Century.82 In the early history of Good Words we see the characteristics which would mark Strahan's publishing career - lavish expenditure and controversy around his religious commitments. On 28 January 1863, a full-page advertisement appeared in The Times providing excerpts from many of the articles from the January issue of Good Words.83 The advertisement is 'disguised' as copy from the paper; there are no distinct variations in type as in other advertisements, and the same number of columns are retained. It has the look of news, and one could flip though the pages of the paper and never notice that the whole of page 5 is an advertisement for Good Words. In fact, as the Publishers' Circular recognized, Strahan's advertisement was a novelty in Victorian publishing: The advertisement of Good Words in the Times on Thursday last constitutes a new feature in the advertising of our popular periodicals - copious specimens being given of each paper, extending in some cases to almost an entire article; the advertisement, which occupies an entire page in small type, costing about one hundred and thirty pounds. The January number of this publication is stated to have reached a circulation of 110,000 copies. 84 If this circulation figure is true, or even close to true, Good Words had outsold Cornhill by several tens of thousands. The tremendous cost of the advertisement, more than Trollope was paid for 'The Widow's Mite', is further evidence of Strahan's commitment to popularizing Good Words. The magazine's identity problem and the gradual move towards commercialization can also be seen by looking at Good Words covers in the early 1860s. The original January 1860 cover (Fig. 2.1)
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
80
81
de-emphasizes the religious nature of the magazine; apart from the list of contents and MacLeod's 'D.D.', there is no striking visual indication that the magazine is dedicated to religion broadly, although there is a discreet cross motif in the border. A month later, there is a different illustration on the cover, the typeface is bolder and the prominence of the illustrations highlighted (Fig. 2.5). Strahan firmly believed that illustrations ought to be an integral part of the magazine's educative purpose. 85 In March, 'one of Her Majesty's Chaplains for Scotland' is placed under MacLeod's name to emphasize his religious authority. As noted above, unlike in almost all comparable periodicals, the editor's name also appeared across the top of the pages inside, augmenting his authoritative presence. Although the March inside cover and several subsequent inside covers list the range of contributors who have published in the magazine to date, contributions remain unattributed on the front cover. The identity of the magazine, then, is based on the authority of the editor, but his authority is qualified by the discreet attribution of some contributors. Laurel Brake has argued, in discussing the Nineteenth Century's formation from Strahan's Contemporary Review, that 'signature underlines the diversity for the reader'. 86 In the case of Good Words, evidence shows a dual approach to signature: to promote a homogeneous image under the editor's banner waved on each page, yet to allow some distance from particular contributors at the same time. In 1861 the cover changes dramatically, with a new illustration emphasizing the familial, religious, and educative nature of the periodical (Fig. 2.6). In bold type beneath 'Good Words' is written A Magazine for all the Week'. The subtitle reminds us of the original mission statements, to provide a periodical with contents suitable for Sabbath reading and also entertaining weekday reading. Interestingly, the cover change occurs a month after MacLeod's editorial defence of the periodical in December 1860, discussed earlier in this chapter. 'Edited by Norman MacLeod, D.D'. appears beneath the subtitle, maintaining the authority figure of the editorclergyman. MacLeod's name continues to appear at the top of every single page in the issue. Also in 1861, the contents section begins listing contributors, a way of distancing each contribution from the individual theology and authority of MacLeod. The July 1862 cover notes the move to London, and a month later we notice several more changes. Beneath MacLeod's name is written 'one of Her Majesty's Chaplains for Scotland', reiterating
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Uncovering Periodical Identities
Sk^
GOOD WORDS
¥im|
mmm
MACLEOD, D.D. U.UWJATEr> 'RY
i|
IAS. DEIIMMOim, SJSJL; 3A& AMHEB, BJ5UL;
Btmum Xfc
f m
>*<*• ,.*
<<
*'
f
*& TO
**s* i
*
$S>x V « * < * » * • » >? * * • « < ' * «
***« |
« * > ' ' > ^ i ' ... ; X;<*'i--**« • <Mv,<>
! :;;s ! *««: <j^f>- ,.'^c'^'>:.;<^y.':. ".'."'.'"'':
v:i?v^ivi: ; >,^...
( , > }v
«*-.•««-:.v>x.
j K : - ! . r rf;v;
. ;:;. : r-.-y *,S,v<>!i..
.
Pj 3 ** 1 ... U£
J
Jtv gfe V I .
f
??* v o t
A -'
,.j
•?
. >:'; i i x i y
'J ,.s { > , , « ,
-> ,
it«
f l U l ^ :
>:•<>:>:-•,>: > y.j>:
^•.ixmui;?r: H <\nww ST,
iTitimMf,
Figure 2.5 Cover of Good Words (February 1860)
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Trollope and the Magazines
82
Uncovering Periodical Identities
'% Mwanm w an iht Wx*%1 &:;*n..t;.u a
NORMAN MACLEOD. D.B.
l£r&^&'$?&M&i i CONTENTS. p s S I l
3:&fe '*»:gg^S-f«#®8.:Ji •:>*•
tt.«!IJ!A«
«>; y"5yi
• :' ••: ' • • y : v \ : ,
&
J'£!>:*•. M X H ' V
%$Figure 2.6 Cover of Good Words (January 1861)
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
fj
Trollope and the Magazines
the religious authority particularly of the editor. Beneath MacLeod's name and title is written, 'And illustrated under the superintendence of Dalziel Brothers'. The brothers Dalziel were among the great woodcut printers of the 1860s, and they, along with Swain, did most of Cornhill's highly regarded illustrations. The prominence of the woodcut printers on the cover was also a way to advertise the illustrations, an extremely popular feature in the weeklies but also, after Cornhill, in some monthlies. 'The right of Translating Articles from Good Words is reserved by the Authors' appears at the bottom of the cover, under the price of sixpence (half the price of Cornhill), to indicate the internationalism of the Good Words readership. The price difference between the two leading monthlies indicates the different readerships which each periodical was creating. Cornhill aimed at a more affluent reader, while Good Words maintained its roots in cheap literature and probably had a broader socio-economic range of reader. Since both were family magazines, the readerships would have had a large proportion of women readers, as is partly demonstrated by the prominence of domestic fiction. By 1863, less advertising space on the inside front and the back covers is taken up by Strahan, who hitherto advertised past Good Words volumes or book publications. More precisely, the last regular advertisement for Good Words appearing in the magazine itself is in August 1862, and the last Strahan publishing advertisement two months later. Either Strahan was now attracting more and diverse advertisers and no longer felt the need to promote his own business or, more probably, he needed money. For whatever reason, by 1863 there are advertisements for rollerskates, medical products, stationers, clocks, starch, and, perhaps surprisingly for a religious periodical, whisky. By the end of the year there are also advertisements for wines, sherry, port and champagne, which continue throughout the 1860s. Other religious periodicals, such as Strahan's own Sunday Magazine and the Christian Observer, have very similar advertisements, but none for alcohol. Generally, advertisements in the front and back covers in other religious periodicals promote other religious publications, and the advertisements are less illustrated and more sober than in Good Words. According to a Victorian advertising agent, Henry Sell, the editorial policy of a newspaper or periodical influences how the advertisements are read, and 'Sell finds proof of this in the "extraordinary success" of advertising in the much respected
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
84
85
religious papers'. 87 Therefore, by virtue of their inclusion in a publication like Good Words, the alcohol advertisements were validated, even consecrated, as acceptable commodities. Like Mr Comfort in Rachel Ray, Good Words was positioned on the fine line between religion and worldliness, but the magazine's advertising base, a large portion of revenue for periodicals even in the 1860s, relied mostly on secular products. By 1864, however, even the emphasis on Good Words as suitable for Sunday reading is removed. The subtitle for the periodical is now An Illustrated Monthly Magazine', and the link between the Dalziel name and MacLeod's name, so close before, has been weakened; the original intention of blending Sabbath and weekday reading has been consumed by the more commercial and unreligious 'illustrated monthly magazine'. It is precisely during this period of identity crisis in the first few volumes - of changing covers, shifting emphasis, and expansion - that MacLeod rejects Rachel Ray for Good Words. It is true that Trollope's novel is critical of the clergy, but the Evangelicals particularly are singled out only slightly more than the other Churchmen. Did the attacks in the Record merely incite Trollope to greater parody rather than temper his teasing irreverence? That he was able to write a wholesome story for Good Words is shown in 'The Widow's Mite'; why he chose not to write about religion in a similar vein in Rachel Ray is another question entirely. Trollope held no grudge against MacLeod or Good Words, and a second tame story, 'The Two Generals', appeared in December 1863. What is more telling of the peculiar position of Good Words is the appearance in 1864 of Mrs Henry Wood's Oswald Cray, the most sensational novel serialized in the periodical in the early 1860s.88 It was advertised as 'by the author of "East Lynne"', Wood's hugely successful sensation novel of 1861, without any anxiety that the wrath of the Recordites would be brought down upon the magazine. If Trollope caused so much trouble, surely Mrs Henry Wood would be seen as equally, if not more, harmful? The central plot in Oswald Cray is a mystery to discover whether a rich old heiress was murdered with chloroform by her heir, a respectable doctor. The novel was universally slated, and the Athenaeum wondered whether the story was so tedious because it 'appeared in the pages of Good Words, a periodical in which a writer of fiction is placed under some limitations'. 89 Compared to Oswald Cray (and almost any other novel), Rachel Ray is gentle domestic
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Uncovering Periodical Identities
Trollope and the Magazines
fiction and its rejection appears somewhat unjustified; but, as Srebrnik believes, 'MacLeod seems to have slipped back into the habit of allowing Strahan a free hand'. 90 He was revising rather than editing. By 1864, the transformation of Good Words had been complete, from 'magazine for all the week' to 'an illustrated monthly magazine', and circulation nearly tripled that of Cornhill. Pierre Bourdieu argues of the field of cultural production that, choosing the right place of publication, the right publisher, journal, gallery or magazine is vitally important because for each author, each form of production and product, there is a corresponding natural site in the field of production, and producers or products that are not in their right place are more or less bound to fail. All the homologies which guarantee a receptive audience and sympathetic audience and sympathetic critics for producers who have found their place in the structure work in the opposite way for those who have strayed from their natural site.91 One could have supposed, as Strahan and MacLeod initially did, that Good Words was a 'natural site' for Rachel Ray. But, Trollope was caught in an unenviable position at a particular cultural moment in 1863. As the most popular serial writer of the day, he was asked to contribute to a magazine in the throes of identity crisis. Being attacked by the extreme elements of his readership, as debates about sensationalism raged in the pages of the periodical press, MacLeod had to defend what he maintained was a workable mission for his periodical: the fusion of the religious with the secular. He sacrificed Trollope in the doing. Meanwhile, Strahan was attempting to remodel his periodical and emulate Cornhill, and as the covers show, the position of the magazine was gradually shifting away from its roots as a religious weekly and more towards the secularism so heavily criticised by the Evangelical extreme. Strahan came to realize the difficulty in amalgamating two distinct popular audiences. In such a configuration, the tension in attempting to unite two opposites becomes too strong and one of the competing elements must yield. However, Strahan did not give up his belief that there ought to be a quality Sabbath magazine, and in 1864, as Good Words was becoming more sensational than ever before, he started up the Sunday Magazine.
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
86
Periodical
Identities
87
M a c L e o d r e m a i n e d c o m m i t t e d to his conviction t h a t a b l e n d of t h e secular w i t h t h e religious w a s possible, a n d Trollope s u p p o r t e d his friend's beliefs. Writing in t h e Fortnightly Review in J a n u a r y 1866, Trollope d e f e n d e d a recent speech given by MacLeod w h i c h a s s e r t e d t h a t t h e r i g o u r s of S a b b a t h - d a y practices as dict a t e d b y t h e F o u r t h C o m m a n d m e n t w e r e u n f o u n d e d . By t h e n , however, there was a strong Anti-Sabbatarian m o v e m e n t advocating t h a t a m u s e m e n t o n a S u n d a y w a s n o t i n h e r e n t l y sinful. H a d M a c L e o d b e e n g i v e n Rachel Ray to j u d g e t h e n , p e r h a p s it w o u l d h a v e b e c o m e a Good Words serial, as it w a s originally written a n d i n t e n d e d to b e .
Notes 1. Guinivere Griest, Mudie's Circulating Eibrary and the Victorian Novel (Bloomington: University of Indiana Press, 1970), 35. For a discussion of Mudie's and censorship in the late nineteenth century, see Nicholas Hiley, '"Can't You Find Me Something Nasty?": Circulating Libraries and Literary Censorship in Britain from the 1890s to the 1910s', in Robin Myers and Michael Harris, eds, Censorship and the Control of Print in England and France 1600-1910 (Winchester, UK: St. Paul's Bibliographies, 1992), 123-47. 2. Griest, Mudie's, 37. 3. Michel Foucault, The Archaeology of Knowledge (1969), A.M. Sheridan Smith, trans. (1972; reprinted London: Routledge, 1991), 9. 4. Griest, Mudie's, 46. 5. Ibid., 140. 6. Ibid., 141-2. 7. Donald Thomas, A Fong Time Burning: The History of Fiterary Censorship in England (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1969), 239. 8. Ibid., 239. 9. See Publishers' Circular 26 (1 and 15 May 1863), which responds to the Quarterly Reviews assessment that the circulating library system forces the public to buy what they do not want, specifically sensation literature. 10. George Moore, Fiterature at Nurse, or Circulating Morals (London: Vizetelly and Co., 1885), 20. This pamphlet is a slightly revised form of an article which appeared in the Pall Mall Gazette. 11. The terms 'Low Church' and 'Evangelical' overlap somewhat when discussing the mid-nineteenth century. Generally, I contend that the Evangelicals were more extreme than other Low Church Anglicans, but neither wished to follow the Dissenters in leaving the Church outright. 12. Robert M. Polhemus, The Changing World of Anthony Trollope (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1968), 99.
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Uncovering
Trollope and the
Magazines
13. Anthony Trollope, Rachel Ray (1863), ed. P.D. Edwards (Oxford: Oxford University Press, World's Classics, 1990), 21. All subsequent references are from this edition and are noted parenthetically in the text. 14. The Family Treasury (1859-79) was monthly, priced 6d., and not illustrated. It was strictly religious and intended for Sabbath reading. The eight articles which constitute 'Our Dorcas Meetings' (signed 'C.C'.) run from Family Treasury 3:2 (February 1860) to 5:6 (June 1861). 15. Edwards, 'Introduction' to Rachel Ray, xv. 16. Anthony Trollope, Clergymen of the Church of England (London: Chapman and Hall, 1866), 63. The articles which make up this volume first appeared in the Pall Mall Gazette in 1865. 17. Jane Nardin, 'Comic Convention in Trollope's Rachel Ray', Papers on Fanguage and Fiterature 22:1 (Winter 1986), 45. Her argument is that the novel is subversive because it undermines the comic plot through the unsatisfactory negotiation of power relations. 18. See Augusta Webster, Portraits (London: Macmillan, 1870), 35-62. My thanks to Gill Gregory for suggesting Webster's poem to me. 19. See Lynda Nead, Myths Of Sexuality: Representations of Women in Victorian Britain (1988; reprinted Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1990), 131. 20. Note that the narrator denies that Mr Tappitt is intemperate (364), but this smokescreen is necessary because he so clearly is a drinker. 21. Nardin, 'Comic Convention', does not believe that the Rachel/Luke match will be a happy one, although I'm not wholly convinced by her argument. 22. Prospectus, Good Words 1 (January 1860), inside front cover. 23. [Norman MacLeod,] 'Note by the Editor', Good Words 1 (December 1860), 796. 24. Patricia Thomas Srebrnik, Alexander Strahan: Victorian Publisher (Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, 1986), 39. There is no full-length study of Good Words, and there are few scholarly articles dedicated to Good Words. Srebrnik's study provides an excellent account of the founding of the magazine, and the relationship between editor and publisher. 25. Even the Family Treasury mentioned above which only published monthly (6d.) makes explicit that the monthly numbers should be read weekly, on Sundays. On the inside front cover, the pages are divided in various weeks, indicating a religious weekly format. Yet another hybrid form. 26. Theodor Adorno and Max Horkheimer, Dialectic of Enlightenment (1944), John Cumming, trans. (1972; reprinted London: Verso, 1992), 157. 27. This practice changes in June 1865, when across the top of the pages appears 'Good Words' and the date. 28. W.J. Couper, 'A Bibliography of Edinburgh Periodical Literature', Scottish Notes and Queries 3, second series (May 1902), 164. 29. [Norman MacLeod,] 'Note by the Editor', Edinburgh Christian Magazine 3 (March 1852), 380. 30. [Norman MacLeod,] 'Note by the Editor', Edinburgh Christian Magazine 7 (March 1856), 380.
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
88
Periodical
Identities
89
31. Revd Donald MacLeod, Memoir of Norman MacFeod. D.D. (2 vols.; London: Dalby, Isbister & Co., 1876), hereafter cited as Memoir. See MacLeod's journal entry in the spring of 1863, Memoir 2, 185. 32. Quoted in Alexander Strahan, 'Norman MacLeod', Contemporary Review 20 (July 1872), 295. 33. Memoir 1, 254. 34. Letter to Principal Tulloch of Aberdeen, Memoir 1, 262. 35. Journal entry for September 1846, Memoir 1, 261. 36. See Arnold to Revd Augustus Hare (24 December 1830) (letter 18) in Arthur Penrhyn Stanley, The Fife and Correspondence of Thomas Arnold, D.D. 1 (2 vols.; London: B. Fellows, 1844), 262. 37. Memoir 2, 97. 38. Josef Altholz, The Religious Press in Britain, 1760-1900 (New York: Greenwood Press, 1989), 39. 39. 'A Word with Our Readers', Eeisure Hour 1:1 (1 January 1852), 9. 40. 'Address by the Editor', Sunday at Home 1:1 (October 1864), inside front cover. 41. 'Preface', Family Magazine 1 (1830), iii. 42. 'Preface', Family Friend 1 (1849-50), iii. 43. Not all religious periodicals followed the weekly, family-magazine trend. The British Evangelist, for example, was founded in 1858 as a cheap monthly (three pence). The subtitle indicates that the magazine was in no way attempting to attract the more secular market: 'The British Evangelist for promoting Unity, Zeal, and Activity in the Christian Churches, and Advancing the Knowledge and Love of Christ In the World'. 44. Note that the Reader 4 (13 February 1864), 198, reviewed Good Words, Leisure Hour, and Sunday at Home together under the title 'Popular Serials'. 45. Like MacLeod's 'revised by' to indicate his editorial role, Dickens's 'conducted by' was also unusual; however, other magazines, not surprisingly, followed Dickens's lead: the short-lived Robin Goodfellow, inaugurated with Mary Braddon's Lady Audley's Secret in 1861, was 'conducted by Charles MacKay'. 46. Good Words prospectus in the Christian Guest (December 1859), 546, my emphasis. The prospectus also appeared on the inside front cover of the first issue of Good Words, January 1860. 47. Srebrnik, Alexander Strahan, 39. 48. Ibid., 46. 49. Ibid., 46-7. 50. Sally Mitchell, Dinah Mulock Craik (Boston: Twayne Publishers, 1983), 59, states that after 1860 (and after John Halifax, Gentleman), Mulock was generally regarded as a women's novelist and was reviewed less seriously than before. Mulock's Mistress and Maid was serialized in Good Words in 1862. 51. Owen Chadwick, The Victorian Church 1 (2 vols.; London: Adam & Charles Black, 1966), 440-1. 52. Elisabeth Jay, The Religion of the Heart: Anglican Evangelicalism and the Nineteenth-Century Novel (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1979), 7.
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Uncovering
Trollope and the
Magazines
53. Ibid., 23. MacLeod recognized the differences within the Evangelical movement; see a letter from MacLeod to Mrs MacLeod, 27 June 1863 in Memoir 2, 154. 54. The Record articles were published as a pamphlet entitled Good Words': The Theology of Its Editor, and of Some of Its Contributors (London: The Record, 1863). Subsequent references to these articles are taken from this Record pamphlet and noted parenthetically in the text. 55. Altholz, Religious Press, 17-19. 56. 'Short Notices', Literary Times, no. 6 (18 April 1863), 74. 57. Srebrnik, Alexander Strahan, 59. 58. 'The Magazines', Illustrated London News 43 (11 July 1863), 43. 59. [H.L. Mansel,] 'Sensation Novels', Quarterly Review 113 (April 1863), 481-514. 60. Herbert Graham, 'Periodical Literature and Its Influences', The Rose, the Shamrock, and the Thistle 3 (June 1863), 137. 61. Ibid., 133. 62. Altholz, Religious Press, 16-17. 63. 'Good Words', Christian Observer 63 (July 1863), 502-3. 64. 'Sensational Literature', Christian Observer 65 (November 1865), 809-13. 65. Ibid., 812. 66. The Patriot articles responding to the Record were also published as a pamphlet, to which all subsequent notes refer: An Exposure of The 'Record' Newspaper in Its Treatment of 'Good Words' (London: Simpkin, Marshall, & Co., 1863). 67. Ibid., 4. 68. 'Short Notices', 74. 69. [Mansel,] 'Sensation Novels', 484. 70. Ibid., 513. 71. Although I focus on the debate about Trollope as a sensationalist, the Record attacks were taken up by other periodicals and discussed in other ways. Specifically, the fact that the Record was also edited by a Presbyterian Scotsman helped to lessen the damage against Good Words. See Srebrnik, Alexander Strahan, 62-3. 72. Review of Rachel Ray review, Athenaeum 1863 II (17 October 1863), 492. See other reviews: Westminster Review 25 n.s. (February 1864), 291-3; Spectator (24 October 1863), 2660-1; Reader (17 October 1863), 437-8; London Review (31 October 1863), 467-8; Times (25 December 1863), 4. 73. Review of Rachel Ray, Illustrated London News 43 (14 November 1863), 502. 74. H.K., 'A Word of Remonstrance with some Novelists', Good Words 4 (July 1863), 525. 75. Review of Rachel Ray, Saturday Review 16 (24 October 1863), 556. 76. Ibid., 555. 77. Merle Mowbray Bevington, The Saturday Review 1855-1868: Representative Educated Opinion in Victorian England (New York: Columbia University Press, 1941), 154. 78. Adorno and Horkheimer, Dialectic, 134. 79. MacLeod to Revd W.F. Stevenson (14 August 1861), Memoir 2, 114.
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
90
Periodical
Identities
91
80. Quoted in Srebrnik, Alexander Strahan, 59. 81. Ibid., 52. See the details of Strahan's remodelling efforts, 52-3. 82. See Srebrnik on Strahan's business troubles, and Laurel Brake, 'Theories of Formation: The Nineteenth Century: Vol. 1, No. 1, March 1877. Monthly, 2/6', Victorian Periodical Review 25:1 (Spring 1992), 16-20. 83. Good Words advertisement, The Times (28 January 1863), 5. 84. Publishers' Circular 26 (2 February 1863), 56. 85. Srebrnik, Alexander Strahan, 3 and 33. 86. Brake, 'Theories of Formation', 16. 87. Quoted in Diana and Geoffrey Hindley, Advertising in Victorian England 1837-1901 (London: Wayland, 1972), 35. 88. Srebrnik, Alexander Strahan, 64. 89. Review of Oswald Cray, Athenaeum 1864 II (24 December 1864), 859. 90. Srebrnik, Alexander Strahan, 64. 91. Pierre Bourdieu, The Field of Cultural Production, Randal Johnson, ed. (Oxford: Polity Press, 1993), 95-6.
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Uncovering
Launching a Hybrid: The Belton Estate in the Fortnightly Review In May 1865, Trollope's The Belton Estate launched the Fortnightly Review. In the first part of this chapter, I explore the cultural formation of the Fortnightly and consider the nature of the magazine's liberalism in relation to the network of male writers which defined it. I believe that, for all its radical policies, there is an absence of the female voice in its contents because of what might be termed its Positivist political stance. The Belton Estate (serialized between May 1865 and January 1866) was the second Trollope novel to launch a periodical, but rather than defining the magazine in the way Framley Parsonage seemed to do in the Cornhill, it sits oddly in the Fortnightly under its first editor, G.H. Lewes. The tensions which I think The Belton Estate generates as a bid for women readers are directly related to its context in a hybrid periodical - not quite a traditional review, not quite a popular monthly. In the second part of the chapter, I discuss the question of signature in the context of anxiety over creating what has been called a star system of criticism. Although star journalism had not yet been fully introduced in the mid-1860s, it can be argued that the rise of individual personalities within a burgeoning mass culture had already begun. The Fortnightly was part of the foundation for a middle-class culture which, as the century moved on, became hooked on personality and celebrity. The anonymity debate, then, can be examined not simply for its effect on honesty in writing but also for its contribution to a culture of celebrity.
92 10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
3
Launching a Hybrid
93
Founded by a collective of proprietors including Trollope, the Fortnightly was avowed in the prospectus to be an experiment. Frequency, signature, non-partisanship, and fiction signalled that the Fortnightly, modelled on the French Revue des Deux Mondes, hoped to break with traditions in English periodical culture. The experimental elements, however, were only variously successful. Twenty months after the Fortnightly began, difficulties with the publishing trade forced the magazine to change its format to the more conventional monthly. Either consumers would not alter their reading habits or distributors would not accommodate the unusual fortnightly pattern. 1 In addition to frequency, signature was revealed implicitly in the prospectus: .. . we propose to remove all those restrictions of party and of editorial 'consistency' which in other journals hamper the full and free expression of opinion; and we shall ask each writer to express his own views and sentiments with all the force of sincerity. He will never be required to express the views of an Editor or of a Party. He will not be asked to repress opinions or sentiments because they are distasteful to an Editor, or inconsistent with what may have formerly appeared in the Review. He will be asked to say what he really thinks and really feels; to say it in his own responsibility, and to leave its appreciation to the public. 2 Discussion concerning anonymous journalism was not new. In the 1830s Edward Lytton Bulwer argued for signed journalism in England and the English, whilst the New and Monthly Magazine and Literary Journal asserted that the mysteriousness of anonymity was its particular appeal. 3 By the 1890s, as the so-called New Journalism was altering the face of the press, signature had become widespread, although anonymous articles still appeared. The Fortnightly's decision to include signature was just one moment, however significant, in a century of debate about the question of anonymous journalism. 4 In addition to signature and fortnightly production, the magazine's prospectus proclaimed, 'the Review will be liberal, and its liberalism so thorough as to include great diversity of individual opinion within its catholic unity of purpose'. Unlike the great quarterlies or even weeklies such as the Saturday
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
THE MALE CONFIGURATION
Trollope and the Magazines
Review, the Fortnightly espoused a move away from party politics, 'to further the cause of Progress by illumination from many minds'. While the editor, G.H. Lewes, did wish 'to seek its public amid all parties', one suspects that the continued use of the word 'liberal' in the prospectus ought really to be spelled with a capital L.5 The experiment of a non-partisan open forum style was never realized in full, partly because, as Trollope wryly observed, liberalism, free-thinking, and open inquiry will never object to appear in company with their opposites, because they have the conceit to think that they can quell those opposites; but the opposites will not appear in conjunction with liberalism, free-thinking, and open inquiry. As a natural consequence, our new publication became an organ of liberalism, free-thinking, and open inquiry. (A 190) Trollope drifted away from the Fortnightly and its progressive politics after November 1866, when Lewes resigned owing to poor health. Trollope, James Cotter Morison, Frederic and Edward Chapman, Frederic Flarrison, and E.S. Beesly were among the original allmale company of nine which invested £9000 in founding the Fortnightly with Lewes as editor. The connections between the men are noteworthy: the Chapmans were cousins and Frederic had recently taken over Chapman and Hall after Edward's retirement; Chapman and Hall had already published seven Trollope novels; Morison was a member of the Positivist Society, wellknown as a Saturday Review contributor, and a friend of fellow Positivists and writers including George Meredith (who also became a Fortnightly writer); Lewes, too, was a Positivist and a well-known journalist who had been friends with Trollope at the Cornhill; Harrison and Beesly were both committed Positivists. Such connections impress the fact that middle-class publishing then (as now) was an intricately networked and cosy business, and for the most part a male domain. The social configuration around a range of magazines in the mid-nineteenth century shows similarities in the male network of editors, publishers, and contributors which generally ran the publications. For example, the weekly Punch dinners initiated in
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
94
Launching a Hybrid
95
Here let us sport, Boys, as we sit; Laughter and wit Flashing so free. Life is but short When we are gone, Let them sing on, Round the old tree. 6 Describing the Punch club, one of the original founders of the magazine recalled that 'its object was to form a little society amongst ourselves to talk over and settle upon subjects for the paper of the coming week'. 7 Macmillan's (founded in 1859) originated in Thursday evening gatherings at the firm's Covent Garden branch. Established men such as Tennyson, Huxley, and Kingsley gathered with young up-and-comers such as Edward Dicey and Alfred Ainger to smoke, drink, and talk at what came to be called the 'Tobacco Parliament', 8 a name which resonates with class, leisure, and politics. The Cornhill began a month after Macmillan's and was the brainchild of publisher George Smith and his author Thackeray. At its centre were a half-dozen male contributors who formed the core of the magazine's non-fiction and who gathered with other contributors at Smith's jovial monthly dinners. Many firms involved in publishing periodicals were located at Paternoster Row or more generally in the area running from Fleet Street to Bank, and until the 1980s migration to Wapping this area remained the centre of the newspaper industry in London. The press industry had grown up in an environment of court, church, and crown, especially dominated by male professions around the fields of law and commerce. Publishing offices were places where men might drop in, talk business, drink some tea and perhaps meet others in passing. The area was a focus for men. Punch, Cornhill, Macmillan's, and, as we shall see, the Fortnightly all share a similar social formation: it was in the spirit of the men's club that many periodicals were conceived. The founding of the Fortnightly presents a familiar pattern. A group of well-off men most of whom were friends with social
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
1841 were well known and immortalized by Thackeray in his playful rhyme, 'Mahogany Tree', so named for the table around which the Punch diners sat:
Trollope and the Magazines
and business connections, at the very least acquaintances, decided to found a periodical. They had a few meetings and chose an experienced journalist friend to edit, who in turn rounded up an impressive list of friends and acquaintances as contributors to make an impact with the first issue: Walter Bagehot, George Eliot, and Frederic Harrison. The first issue came off smoothly and the periodical was generally well received, its eminent contributors duly remarked. Noticeably innovatory in this periodical's roots is the absence of a publishing house; there is no Smith, no Bentley, no Macmillan, no Blackwood and subsequently no house style. But the all-male, club-like configuration of house journals is replicated in what is avowed in the prospectus to be a radical departure in periodical literature.
COMTE, POSITIVISM AND THE FORTNIGHTEY Although the Fortnightly hoped to achieve an open forum for a number of debates, by the time Lewes left in 1866 it was already known as partisan and Liberal, and Lewes's successor, John Morley, extended the radical base. Lewes had been editor at the Leader in the early 1850s, where he earned his reputation as a liberal and even a radical. In those pages he heralded the virtues of Auguste Comte's Positivism, to which he had been enthusiastically attached since the 1840s. Lewes's recent biographer Rosemary Ashton suggests that during his Leader years, 'Lewes was a Comtist, and Comte placed women squarely in the centre of the home and family'.9 She believes that by 1859, Lewes was 'an emphatic ex-Comtist',10 and Ashton generally follows Gordon Haight's biography of George Eliot in playing down the attachment of Lewes to Comte. However, we must be careful not to read Lewes through Eliot. Whether or not Lewes's attachment to Comte declined, in public discourse he was unequivocally linked to Positivism, as an 1868 Edinburgh Review article on the philosophy suggests: Than Mr. Lewes Positivism has no more earnest, intrepid, or persevering advocate in England. Some are more fanatical in their devotion, and have resigned their reason and judgment more entirely to the thoughts of the great master; others, like Mr. John S. Mill, less affiliated to the system, have expounded it, in our view, with a higher, or at least a more discriminating
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
96
97
success; but there is no one who has been more faithful to it in his whole mode of thought, or who has more frequently recurred to its characteristic ideas, and explained them with more clearness, comprehension, and force. It has been Mr. Lewes's mission to develope [sic] and spread these ideas in opposition to the old modes of thought, as the destined means of regenerating human knowledge and society.11 The anonymous writer of the article was John Tulloch, a High Anglican Scotsman who would have been opposed to Lewes's devotion to science. Lewes was not the missionary zealot Tulloch suggests, but he had advocated early Comtism in the Fortnightly in its first 18 months. Lewes's connection to Positivist philosophy, if not to Comtist religion, is important to establish here, because it suggests one reason 12 for the near-absence of women contributors and women's issues in the Fortnightly in its first 18 months. Comte was first translated by Harriet Martineau, whose Positive Philosophy of Auguste Comte was published by John Chapman in 1852. Her two-volume work was a condensed version of Comte's Cours de la philosophic positive, published in Paris in six volumes from 1830 to 1842. In volume II Martineau discusses the intellectual inferiority and the moral superiority of women and the importance of the family, which were central in Comte's social reorganization. Richard Congreve's translation of Comte's Catechisme, in which a 'submissive woman asks a confident priest to explain' Positivism, appeared in 1858; it was Comte's way of spreading the word to women who would be so necessary for social regeneration. In 1865, Comte's Discours was published in English as A General View of Positivism, translated by J.H. Bridges, himself a dedicated Positivist. Late in the 1870s four more volumes of Comte's work were translated by Bridges, Frederic Harrison, Richard Congreve, and Edward Spencer Beesly. Three of those four men were Fortnightly contributors recruited by Lewes (Bridges came in under Morley), and were friends of Eliot and Lewes and regulars at their Sunday salon. Lewes became familiar with Comtism in the original French and did not need the assistance of later English translations before becoming a follower. He was an acquaintance of Comte and visited him in Paris. A letter from Comte to Lewes in October 1848 acknowledges the Englishman's appreciation of Comte's Positivism:
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Launching a Hybrid
98
Trollope and the Magazines
Lewes had written a letter to Comte in which he said how much he thought of the Discours, especially the 'chapter on women'. 14 This chapter was translated by Bridges in 1865 as 'The Influence of Positivism on Women'. In Comte's social reorganization, philosophers, women, and the working classes were an important triumvirate who would unite to regenerate society. He advocates the chivalric spirit of medievalism, when women were properly honoured, and finds a model for the treatment of women in the cult of the Virgin. The role of woman is to modify the actions of men through affection and superior morality: Morally, therefore, and apart from all material considerations, she merits always our living veneration, as the purest and simplest impersonation of Humanity, who can never be adequately represented in any masculine form. But these qualities do not involve the possession of political power, which some visionaries have claimed for women, though without their own consent. In that which is the great object of human life, they are superior to him; but in the various means of attaining that object they are undoubtedly inferior. In all kinds of force, whether physical, intellectual, or practical, it is certain that Man surpasses Woman, in accordance with a general law which prevails throughout the animal kingdom.. . . Hence we find it the case in every phase of human society that women's life is essentially domestic, public life being confined to men. 15 Women, whose dedication to the cause is essential to Positivism, are responsible for the early education of children, and their influence on public life is exerted through the institution of the salon. Apart from the salon, the family remains the 'distinctive sphere of work' for women. 16 Theology will be replaced, in a practical way, by the worship of women. Men will kneel down and pray to Woman rather than to God (as Comte himself did in worshipping his dead beloved, Clotilde de Vaux), and the object of Positivist prayer will be Humanity. 1 7 These are the primary points from the chapter on women which Lewes said he found
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Je suis charme que mon recent Discours vous ait tant satisfait. C'est d ' u n bon augure p o u r le succes moral et social du positivisme qui, dans votre pays, est encore loin de correspondre a son succes intellectuel. 13
99
especially rewarding in his reading of Comte in the late 1840s. T.R. Wright, evaluating the influence of Comte's Positivism in Victorian Britain, asserts that Lewes's 'exposition and dissemination of Comte's ideas were his chief contribution to philosophy and that Positivism imparted clarity, structure and a sense of certainty to his criticism while providing him with what amounted to a religious faith'. 18 There was more to Comte than his views on women, and the reliance of Positivism on science and rationalism as a principle for faith would seem to have been the primary appeal to Lewes. But Lewes did not always champion Comte's cause uncritically, and in the late 1850s his position on Comte was far less enthusiastic than when he wrote for the Eeader several years earlier. However, by the mid-1860s Comte was again on the public agenda, partly because of Bridges's translation and partly because J.S. Mill had written a critique of Comte also published in 1865. Mill essentially accepted the early Comte but diverged from his later speculations. Bridges in 1866 wrote a response to Mill called The Unity of Comte's Life and Doctrine which supported Comte's later writings. These books were taken up by most periodicals of higher journalism, 19 and Lewes responded with two articles in the Fortnightly. In 'Comte and Mill', Lewes criticizes the dogma of later Comte while maintaining a deep respect for his earlier ideas (much like Mill), and he is careful not to detract from the general notion of Comte as a great mind. 20 Lewes's position on Comte is difficult to ascertain. At first he was an enthusiastic Comtist who did much to popularize the philosophy in England. He broke with Comte for reasons that are uncertain, but renewed his interest at the time he began editing the Fortnightly. In his 1857 edition of the Biographical History of Philosophy, Lewes writes of Comte's Cours that it is 'the grandest, because on the whole the truest system which Philosophy has yet produced'. 21 Wright claims that Lewes's Problems of Life and Mind (1874-79) is permeated with Comtism. 22 He also notes that Lewes gave to the Sacerdotal Fund, and he asserts that much Positivism can be seen in George Eliot's works, such as The Spanish Gypsy (which Eliot herself called a 'mass of Positivism'23), Daniel Deronda, Romola and some of the poems. Richard Congreve, who founded the Church of Humanity, and his wife were intimate friends of Eliot and Lewes, whose support of the Congreves comes through in George Eliot's letters. 24 But one cannot be labelled a Comtist because one's friends are. 25 To a greater or lesser degree
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Launching a Hybrid
Trollope and the Magazines
Lewes respected and adhered to the rationalism of some Positivist principles, which can be distinguished from Comtism in its later, more religious formulation. If by the mid-1860s he and George Eliot were not dedicated to Comtism, they certainly moved in Positivist circles and there is support of Positivist views in both of their writings. Discussing the press reaction to Comte and Positivism, Wright believes that 'the Fortnightly Review was the nearest thing to a Positivist periodical before the foundation of the Positivist Review' by Beesly in 1893.26 Christopher Kent has established how the higher journalism was largely the means by which Positivism was disseminated in Britain. 27 Of the several serious journals which reviewed Bridges's translation and Mill's critique, most were negative about the value of Positivism generally. The Fortnightly was the most sympathetic, but others like the Contemporary Review treated the subject with due seriousness. Under Morley, the Fortnightly became increasingly identified as Comtist, so much so that he tried to deny that reputation in public in an article in 1870.28 Whether or not the Fortnightly was Comtist or Positivist, there seems to have been a distinct public feeling, at least among the serious journals, that the magazine identified itself as such. Lewes as the first editor had a great deal to do with the progressive tendency the Fortnightly projected. And it is my contention that his liberalism was informed by a deep respect for and acceptance of Positivism. The cultural formation of the Fortnightly focused around the male-dominated Positivist circle. Richard Congreve, recording a history of Positivists in a private notebook, remembers how he first came upon Positivist thinking: By the publication of Mill's Logic attention had been called to [Comte's] high importance as a thinker, and I can remember in the society in which I then mixed at Oxford [and?] Rugby, that from time to time discussion arose as to the value of his thought. My more intimate personal friends had many of them read parts of his writings, and consequently we talked over his conclusions. 29 Congreve and his friends discussed the intellectual possibilities of Positivism, in much the same way as the Apostles at Cambridge might have gathered earlier in the nineteenth century. Richard Dellamora has considered the gender construction of the Apostles
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
100
101
and discussed how the homosexual desires shared between the men can be seen in, for example, Tennyson's In Memoriam.30 Similarly, the works of English Positivists were affected by their roots in an all-male intellectual forum, albeit one less formalized than the Apostles, or than a later group such as the Metaphysical Society which dominated the discourse of the Nineteenth Century. As I understand it, the configuration of these male intellectual discussion groups is analogous to that of the gentlemen's clubs venues where men of like minds and the same class meet to talk and to (homo)socialize. Christopher Kent has argued persuasively that the professional network of the class of men who were Positivists (Oxford g r a d u a t e s , often with i n d e p e n d e n t means) strengthened a unified, club mentality. 'Even the profession to which so many of the Comtists belonged', Kent observes, 'was organized like a club: one became a barrister, after all, by eating dinners at one of the Inns of Court.' 31 Of course, many of the Positivists were also club members; Beesly, for example, wrote several letters to Congreve from the Reform Club,32 where several Fortnightly contributors were also members. 33 This is not to say, however, that because the intellectual milieu of the Positivists functioned as an all-male club their thinking was necessarily linked to the Establishment. Quite the contrary: the political mission of Positivism was distinctly anti-Establishment. The political aspect of Positivism was an important part of the project. In his annual lecture-sermon to the Church of Humanity in 1859, Congreve concentrates on China, Italy, and the relation of the labourer to the capitalist. He admits that such political issues are not usually discussed from the pulpit, but the nature of Positivism was to stand 'in lively contrast to' Christian tradition. 34 In 1866 a collection of foreign-relations essays, International Policy, was published by Chapman and Hall (reviewed in the Fortnightly, 15 July 1866). The title-page epigraph is from Comte ('The fundamental doctrine of modern social life is the subordination of Politics to Morals') and the Preface states that 'certain principles are adopted equally by all the contributors, and they are adopted from the political and social system known as Positivism'. 35 Contributors included the usual suspects - Congreve, Harrison, Beesly, and Bridges. At the time of the Franco-Prussian War, Congreve, Beesly, and Bridges published the pamphlet Religion of Humanity, Republic of the West36 which declared the Positivists anti-war stance (although they supported France) and called
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Faunching a Hybrid
Trollope and the Magazines
for a united, perhaps federal, Republic comprising France, Italy, Spain, Germany, and England. In the days of Empire, this call for a European Community was indeed radical in its political implications. The Positivists, whose interests in foreign affairs aligned them with the Fortnightly'^ internationalism, had a significant political element in their objective. The group which functioned like other all-male intellectual forums replicated their structures in the Fortnightly.
THE ABSENCE OF WOMEN The cultural and social formation of the contributors - the closeness, shared beliefs, sense of mission, and similar backgrounds around the Fortnightly may go some way to explain the absence of the female voice in the periodical in 1865-66. Of 131 different contributors under Lewes, only four are identified by the Wellesley Index as women. These four women wrote seven contributions in total. Two were critical notices, and five were full-length articles. One article and one notice were by George Eliot and appeared signed in the very first number, to lend prominence to the journal. Catherine Helen Spence helped write an article but was not actually given credit in the magazine, so her contribution is, in effect, silenced, 37 which leaves just three articles after the first number. Two on music were written by Leonora Schmitz and one on housing for the poor was by the reformer Octavia Hill. The articles signed by women (if we include Eliot's in the first issue) account for 1.6 per cent of all the articles written under Lewes's editorship; 38 by comparison, the conservative Edinburgh Review in 1865-66 had three women reviewers accounting for 3.8 per cent of the articles. As would be expected, more miscellaneous magazines published a greater number of articles by and about women. During 1865-66, Macmillan's carried serial fiction by Margaret Oliphant, Charlotte Yonge, and Caroline Norton, in addition to a range of non-fiction by Frances Power Cobbe, Frances Verney, Lucy Duff-Gordon, and others. In Blackwood's, Margaret Oliphant, Anne Mozley, and Elizabeth J. Hassell wrote more than a dozen articles between them, many of which addresses women's issues directly. By comparison, the experimentalism of the Fortnightly did not extend to redressing the gender imbalance in non-fiction.
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
102
103
Perhaps even more noteworthy than its lack of women contributors is the Fortnightly s poor showing of articles devoted to women. In 1865-66 the quarterly Westminster Review carried one article largely about Frances Power Cobbe and there was one woman contributor, and the Edinburgh's three women contributors included Harriet Martineau. A more popular magazine, Macmillan's, carried fiction by several women, devoted space to women and the arts and to individual women, and included several women contributors. Macmillan's would have had a large number of women readers, and its target audience was presumably different from the Fortnightly, but it shows how other magazines which discussed serious topics included women as target readers and contributors of non-fiction. What we see broadly is that other magazines are at least addressing in some form the woman reader and women's issues directly. Lewes's magazine was comparatively silent about women, considering the amount of space its frequency permitted relative to other magazines. This is directly connected to the Fortnightly's target market, for, as Lewes observes, 'the REVIEW has its special objects, and has to cater for a special public', rather like all magazines. 39 The 'special public' is gendered male, as Lewes make explicit when discussing the periodical's contributors: A glance at the list of our contributors will show that men of high reputation in Letters, Philosophy, and Science - men of position in the world, men of professional and official character, no less than men quite unknown beyond their own immediate circles - have given their countenance to the plan and availed themselves of the opportunity of addressing a cultivated public without thereby incurring the disagreeable and almost inevitable penalty attached to writing anonymously, that of having attributed to them articles which they have not written, and which they would indignantly repudiate. 40 This passage is part of an explanation of the magazine's signature policy, but by emphasizing the gender of the writers, we also see the importance of men as contributors and implicitly as readers within the periodical's own identity. 41 In the first two years of John Morley's editorship (1867-68) of the Fortnightly, articles by and about women were more numerous than under Lewes. Frances Power Cobbe wrote on progress, 42
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
Eaunching a Hybrid
Trollope and the Magazines
Millicent Fawcett on women's education, and R.M. Pankhurst on women's right to vote. There were a couple of critical notices by women as well. With Morley we see a shift in policy, for the absence of women under Lewes may not have been a conscious and articulated policy, so much as the result of a personal bias which excluded women from a public forum.43 Considering Lewes's unconventional 'marriage' to George Eliot and the precarious position in which the relationship put them socially, he perhaps shied away from advocating women's issues too strongly in order not to attract unnecessary attention to his own position. It is speculative, but at least plausible, that as editor he toed the conventional, hegemonic line with regard to women (unlike, for example, the Westminster) for personal reasons. The absence of both women and any official declaration on women's issues can be registered, perhaps, as an outcome of Comtist attitudes alongside more personal considerations. While no full-length articles address women or women's issues directly, other non-fiction such as the reviews do to an extent. For example, John Dennis's review of John Malcolm Ludlow's Woman's Work in the Church asserts that 'it is the mere reiteration of a truism to affirm that a woman's best place is home, that her highest duties are those of a wife and mother', granting, however, that there are numerous single women to whom 'official duties' could be assigned. 44 Not surprisingly, Mary Braddon's sensation novel Only a Clod was reviewed unfavourably by Dennis in July 1865. Volumes II (August-November 1865) and V (MayAugust 1866) of the Fortnightly under Lewes reviewed no books by women, and generally books by women which were reviewed in the first six volumes were not enthusiastically recommended. 45 Certainly the political climate in 1865-66, in the run-up to the Reform Bill debates in 1867, provided ample opportunity to discuss women's issues. Progressive women's periodicals such as the Englishwoman's Review of Social and Industrial Questions and Victoria Magazine kept women's issues in the public domain, and private groups such as Emily Davies's Kensington Society discussed questions such as women's franchise.46 Both were part of the discourse of burgeoning middle-class feminism and were responding to the absence of women's discussion of political issues within the clubland formation of the higher journalism particularly. In June 1866, J.S. Mill presented a petition to Parliament for women's suffrage which went unmentioned in both the 'Public Affairs'
10.1057/9780230288546 - Trollope and the Magazines, Mark Turner
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-15
104
105
and 'Causeries' sections. 47 A whole range of women's issues was being discussed elsewhere in public and in private. Morley does enlist well-known women's reformers like Cobbe and Fawcett to discuss women's reform whereas women under Lewes are not given a similar space. The gendering of the Fortnightly is related to its attempt to be both a review and a magazine. The title signals hybridity a Review which appears fortnightly rather than quarterly - and the combination of forms can be seen in in the contents. The 'Public Affairs' section provides news summaries similar to weeklies like the Saturday Review and the fortnightly frequency creates a sense of topicality and news value which the quarterly Reviews clearly did not wish to project. A number of articles in the Fortnightly were based on recent book publications and so were review-like, but the books were not foregrounded at the beginning of the article as they were in the quarterlies. Furthermore, a single book was often reviewed rather than a clutch of books on a single topic, as in the traditional quarterlies. Alongside these review articles were individual pieces on socio-political topics (especially about reform and the franchise) and also pieces more closely resembling m