(UN)MASKING BRUNO SCHULZ NEW COMBINATIONS, FURTHER FRAGMENTATIONS, ULTIMATE REINTEGRATIONS
STUDIES IN SLAVIC LITERATU...
31 downloads
1210 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
(UN)MASKING BRUNO SCHULZ NEW COMBINATIONS, FURTHER FRAGMENTATIONS, ULTIMATE REINTEGRATIONS
STUDIES IN SLAVIC LITERATURE AND POETICS VOLUME LIV
Edited by
J.J. van Baak R. Grübel A.G.F. van Holk W.G. Weststeijn
(UN)MASKING BRUNO SCHULZ NEW COMBINATIONS, FURTHER FRAGMENTATIONS, ULTIMATE REINTEGRATIONS
EDITED BY
DIETER DE BRUYN AND KRIS VAN HEUCKELOM
Amsterdam - New York, NY 2009
Cover design: Aart Jan Bergshoeff The paper on which this book is printed meets the requirements of “ISO 9706:1994, Information and documentation - Paper for documents Requirements for permanence”. ISBN: 978-90-420-2694-0 E-Book ISBN: 978-90-420-2695-7 ©Editions Rodopi B.V., Amsterdam - New York, NY 2009 Printed in the Netherlands
CONTENTS DIETER DE BRUYN & KRIS VAN HEUCKELOM Introduction: Seven Decades of Schulzology
9
NEW COMBINATIONS: LITERATURE KAREN UNDERHILL Ecstasy and Heresy: Martin Buber, Bruno Schulz, and Jewish Modernity
27
ANDREA MEYER-FRAATZ Exposing and Concealing Jewish Origin: Bruno Schulz and Bolesaw Lemian
49
SAWOMIR JACEK UREK As One Kabbalist to Another… On Arnold Sucki’s Mystical Visions of the World in the Poem ‘Bruno Schulz’
67
DIETER DE BRUYN “The Lie Always Rises to the Surface like Oil”. Toward a Metafictional Reading of Karol Irzykowski’s Pauba and Bruno Schulz’s Fiction
83
ANNA LIWA “I Drew a Plan of an Imaginary City”. The Phenomenon of the City in Bruno Schulz and Miron Biaoszewski
135
ALFRED GALL Mythopoetic Traditions and Inserted Treatises: Bruno Schulz and Danilo Kiš
153
DOROTA WOJDA Bruno Schulz and the Magical Realism of Gabriel García Márquez in One Hundred Years of Solitude
173
6
Contents
NEW COMBINATIONS: ART MARTA SKWARA “A (Wo)man on a Sofa” in Bruno Schulz’s Art and Writings. Schulz as a “Painterly” and “Writerly” Artist
195
ARIKO KATO The Early Graphic Works of Bruno Schulz and SacherMasoch’s Venus in Furs: Schulz as a Modernist
219
JAN ZIELISKI Zuloaga (Rilke?) Schulz
251
ESTHER SÁNCHEZ-PARDO Bruno Schulz and Djuna Barnes: Border-crossing and Artistic Practice
267
DANIEL WATT Bruno Schulz’s Incomparable Realities: From Literature to Theatricality
289
FURTHER FRAGMENTATIONS MIECZYSAW DBROWSKI Aesthetics of Melancholy in Bruno Schulz’s Writings
307
JERZY JARZ BSKI Bruno Schulz and Seductive Discourse
327
SHLOMIT GORIN Thinking About Absurdity with Bruno Schulz: Paradox and Potential
339
MARTA SUCHASKA-DRAYSKA Jewish Mysticism – A Source of Similarities Between Bruno Schulz’s Writings and Psychoanalysis
361
Contents
7
JÖRG SCHULTE The Clepsydra of Empedocles and the Phenomena of Breath and Wind in Bruno Schulz’s Fiction 379 THOMAS ANESSI The Great Heresy of the Varsovian Center
397
OKSANA WERETIUK The Ukrainian Reception of Bruno Schulz’s Writings: Paradox or Norm?
419
ULTIMATE REINTEGRATIONS MICHA PAWE MARKOWSKI Text and Theater. The Ironic Imagination of Bruno Schulz
435
THEODOSIA ROBERTSON Bruno Schulz’s Intimate Communication: From the “True Viewer” of Xiga bawochwalcza to the “True Reader” of ‘Ksi ga’
451
ALFRED SPROEDE Bruno Schulz: Between Avant-Garde and Hasidic Redemption
473
JANIS AUGSBURGER Poetical Fluidization and Intellectual Eclecticism in Bruno Schulz’s Writings
499
Index
519
Introduction: Seven Decades of Schulzology Dieter De Bruyn & Kris Van Heuckelom When the Polish artist Bruno Schulz (1892-1942) eventually managed to publish his first collection of phantasmagoric stories in 1933, he could not have imagined that his modest literary output would ever lead to an accumulation of critical readings. Even more, when working in complete privacy on his drawings and graphic works in the 1920s, he would not even have believed that someone would ever be interested in writing an academic essay on this part of his creative activity. When looking back to the past seven decades of “Schulzology” (schulzologia in Polish), however, one can only find that the assemblage of critical and scholarly writings has been growing steadily, to such an extent even that the presentation of a comprehensive “state of the art” appears to be almost impossible. For those interested in an exhaustive overview of Schulzology, the only advice is to check the online shrine for the Polish artist at www.brunoschulz.org, where Branislava Stojanovi has gathered virtually all available bibliographical references, together with many other valuable sources. In this introduction to yet another collection of Schulzological papers, then, we will limit ourselves to a more modest critical discussion of the key figures and important currents in Schulzology. At the same time, however, some remarks should be made on the issue of critical and scholarly overproduction. Few people will object if we state that what we are living today is nothing less than some kind of “Schulzomania”. Indeed, Schulz nowadays is an international literary star who is worshipped by readers and critics alike. Looking back on the history of Schulzology, however, we must admit that the reception of Schulz’s creative output started in the 1930s with what could be called pure “Schulzophobia”. As Wodzimierz Bolecki has already demonstrated in his major study on the “poetic prose model” (“poetycki model prozy”; 1996 [1982]) in
10
Dieter De Bruyn & Kris Van Heuckelom
the Polish interwar period, Schulz’s stories, immediately after their publication in the 1930s, conflicted with the horizon of expectations of many Polish critics. In many cases, this conflict could be resolved by applying the rules for reading lyrical works: “One could appreciate the plastic or poetic values in it (the ‘images’ or the ‘metaphors’), but there was clearly the lack of a ‘theme’, a ‘leading idea’, a ‘problem’, etc.” (“[m]o na byo w niej ocenia walory plastyczne (‘obrazy’) lub poetyckie (‘metafory’), ale oczywisty by brak ‘tematu’, ‘idei przewodniej’, ‘problemu’ etc.”; 1996 [1982]: 305). As soon as critics tried to extract a consistent world view from Schulz’s stories, however, the strictly axiological character of their approach was immediately exposed. As Bolecki has pertinently remarked, this attempt at reading Schulz’s literary world according to existing moral standards led not only to accusations of “antihumanism and establishment of chaos” (“antyhumanizm i utwierdzanie chaosu”; Wyka and Napierski 2000 [1939]: 422) but also to the attribution of immoral elements in Schulz’s prose to the author’s conduct in real life. Whereas Kazimierz Wyka and Stefan Napierski are still rather polite in their notorious diatribe against Schulz’s prose (‘Dwugos o Schulzu’ or ‘Dialogue on Schulz’, 1939), the most severe personal attack against Schulz and such contemporaries as Witold Gombrowicz and Stanisaw Ignacy Witkiewicz (Witkacy) was launched by the Marxist critic Ignacy Fik in his essay on what he terms a “literature of sick maniacs” (‘Literatura choromaniaków’, 1935). In order to have an impression of what Fik thought of Schulz and the like, we may have a look at the following fragment of his essay: Czy nie jest zastanawiaj ce, e pisz cy [tak literatur ] autorzy s to ludzie, którzy w rozwoju zatrzymali si na fazie dojrzewania pciowego, e s to homoseksualici, ekshibicjonici i psychopaci, degeneraci, narkomani, ludzie chronicznie chorzy na o dek, mieszkaj cy na stae w szpitalach, ludzie nie rozró niaj cy jawy od snu, hipochondrycy, neurastenicy, mizantropi? (1961 [1935]: 126) (Isn’t it striking that the authors who write such literature are people whose development was arrested during the phase of sexual maturation, that they are homosexuals, exhibitionists and psychopaths, degenerates, narcomaniacs, people who chronically suffer from stomach trouble, who permanently live in hospitals, people who don’t distinguish between sleeping and waking, hypochondriacs, neurasthenics, misanthropes?)
Introduction: Seven Decades of Schulzology
11
When reading such merciless tirades against Schulz and his creative activities, one may indeed have difficulties believing that a movement in the opposite way, toward Schulzomania, would ever take place. It is commonly known that postwar critical interest in Schulz was temporarily halted in the difficult years before the Polish October. In his overview of the reception of Schulz’s oeuvre between 1945 and 1976, Andrzej Sulikowski calls the period from 1945 until 1955 the “years of silence” (“lata milczenia”; 1978: 282). From 1956 onwards, Schulzology gradually started flourishing under the impulse of Artur Sandauer and Jerzy Ficowski. Whereas Ficowski has mainly been important for the collection and publication of all kinds of Schulziana and for the reconstruction of the biographical portrait of the writer (cf. his 1967 and 1986 monographs, published in one volume in 2002), Sandauer was the first to map out several routes for a more academic approach of Schulz’s stories in his 1956 essay ‘Rzeczywisto zdegradowana (Rzecz o Brunonie Schulzu)’ (‘The Degraded Reality (A Contribution on Bruno Schulz)’; 1964 [1956]). On the one hand, his analysis of Schulz’s fiction against the background of twentiethcentury socio-economic developments was continued by such critics as Czesaw Samojlik (1965), Tomasz Burek (1966), and Wiesaw Pawe Szymaski (1970). On the other hand, his suggestion that Schulz should be studied in the framework of early twentieth-century experimental currents was further elaborated in discussions about the surrealistic (Dubowik 1971, Speina 1971, Jarz bski 1973) and expressionistic (Speina 1974, Wyskiel 1980) traits of his stories. In addition to this, the reading strategy of “applying the rules for reading lyrical works” was further developed in three subsequent articles by Krzysztof Miklaszewski (1966, 1971a, 1971b). Academic criticism of Schulz’s works received its next stimulus in 1974, when Wojciech Wyskiel organized the first conference devoted to the writer from Drohobycz. In the wake of this event, a structuralist turn took place in Schulzology, as exemplified in the writings of such influential scholars as Wadysaw Panas (1974a, 1974b, 1976), Krzysztof Kosiski (1976), Wojciech Wyskiel (1977a, 1977b), Jerzy Jarz bski (1976, 1984), and Wojciech Karkowski (1976, 1980). Their valuable thoughts on Schulz’s stories were seconded by a few of the first foreign Schulz scholars, such as Colleen Taylor Sen (1969, 1972) and Elisabeth Golicki-Baur (1972).
12
Dieter De Bruyn & Kris Van Heuckelom
Despite this structuralist turn, a closer look at the growing corpus of critical accounts toward the end of the 1970s reveals two major methodological trends that would continue to dominate Schulzology. First, many critics proposed a mimetic reading of Schulz’s stories (focusing on the distorted literary reality they produce) instead of a reflexive one (focusing on the process underlying the production of this particular literary reality). In other words, the approach many of them took was ontocentric instead of logocentric (cf. Stala 1993 for this distinction). Second, critics tended to treat the many seemingly self-informing comments in Schulz’s stories as authoritative clues that could be easily interpolated into their own particular interpretation of the text. As a result, such critics were caught in a kind of circular reasoning because discursive parts of the text were used in order to elucidate the same text. In the early 1980s, this ontocentric and mimetic model of reading Schulz’s stories was attacked by Wodzimierz Bolecki. In what is undoubtedly the most valuable and comprehensive study on the fiction of such interwar writers as Schulz, Witkacy, and Gombrowicz, he focuses on generations of readers’ difficulties to construct a consistent story world out of these very alienating and unusually discursive narrative accounts. More specifically, Bolecki argues that the interwar authors under scrutiny have propagated a new “poetical prose model” (“poetycki model prozy”) as an alternative to the prevailing “vehicular prose model” (“wehikularny model prozy”; 1996 [1982]: 14). Whereas in the latter case literary language is overshadowed by its referential function (as in Realism), in the former case it “draws attention to its autonomy” (“zwraca uwag na swoj autonomi ”) and thus takes on a “reflexive character” (“character samozwrotny”; 12). With respect to Schulz’s stories, Bolecki argues that his literary world is the result of linguistic rather than of mimetic processes: “The narrative utterance stops being a story about what once existed because it turns out to be itself an event in language” (“Wypowied narracyjna przestaje by opowiadaniem o tym, co niegdy zaistniao, albowiem sama okazuje si zdarzeniem w j zyku”; 300). Though Schulzology continued flourishing in the 1980s and early 1990s (e.g. Steinhoff 1984, Chwin 1985, Robertson 1990, 1991, Brown 1991), only few critics elaborated on the turn toward the logocentric reading that had been promoted by Bolecki.
Introduction: Seven Decades of Schulzology
13
Characteristically, those critical accounts that addressed Schulz’s reflexive treatment of the creative possibilities of language (Rachwa 1985, van der Meer 1990, Schönle 1991) all focused on the subcycle on tailors’ dummies (manekiny) in Sklepy cynamonowe (Cinnamon Shops, 1934) and more specifically on the rich metaphorical power of such motives as the tailor’s dummy and “trash” (tandeta). In the wake of the 1992 jubilee year, the popularity of Bruno Schulz in literary and artistic criticism could not be stopped. What is typical of this new phase in Schulzology is the heterogeneity of critical approaches and research subjects – a situation which is, of course, completely in accordance with the typically postmodern plurality of philosophical, literary theoretical and culturological discourses that was gaining prominence in independent Poland (cf. D browski 2000 for a discussion of Schulz in this context). In an everincreasing number of publications (e.g. in two influential conference volumes: Kitowska-ysiak 1992 and Jarz bski 1994b), scholars began to devote attention to “new” topics such as the feminine element in Schulz, the local, Galician or Habsburg background of Schulz’s works, his creative reworking of biblical, kabbalistic, and Jewish elements, and eventually to Schulz’s visual output and its relation to his literary works. The position of Schulz’s artwork within Schulzology deserves a separate discussion. Although his pictorial works received critical attention in the 1920s and 1930s (Lauterbach 1929, Vogel 1930, Dresdner 1935, Witkiewicz 1935), they remained in the shadow of his literary works for many decades. The first steps toward rediscovering Schulz’s visual output were taken in the 1960s, with an exhibition of Schulz drawings in the Adam Mickiewicz Literary Museum and the subsequent publication of thirty Schulz reproductions (Schulz 1967). Although these initiatives coincided with an increasing interest in Schulz’s pictorial oeuvre (Witz 1967, Becker 1967) and were followed by some introductory articles in the foreign press (e.g. Kosko 1976), in-depth discussions of Schulz’s graphics and drawings began to appear only in the 1980s. Whereas Jerzy Ficowski’s archaeological approach led to the discovery and gradual publication of a wide variety of Schulz drawings and graphics (Ficowski 1967, 1975, 1988), the first researcher to map out a more scientific approach to Schulz’s artwork was Magorzata Kitowska-ysiak (1979, 1981, 1986). Her exploratory research eventually amounted to the inclusion of a wide
14
Dieter De Bruyn & Kris Van Heuckelom
range of art-related entries in the Bruno Schulz dictionary (Bolecki, Jarz bski and Rosiek 2003). For a long time, critical discussions of Schulz’s artwork have tended to remain in line with some of the main ideas expressed in Witkacy’s well-known “written interview” with Schulz (‘An Interview with Bruno Schulz’ and ‘An Essay for S.I. Witkiewicz’, Witkiewicz 1935). On the one hand, Schulz’s bold assertion of “having expressed [him]self more fully in [his] literary works” has been an incentive for many critics to treat his graphics and drawings as mere preliminaries to his literary works. On the other hand, Witkacy’s characterization of Schulz as a “demonologist” has paralleled a strong interest in the position of obsessive eroticism in Schulz’s pictorial output. From a biographical perspective, Schulz’s “demonological” art has tended to be linked to the artist’s personal obsessions and erotic perversions. In art-historical terms, the issue of demonic femininity and male masochism has often been discussed within the context of fin de siècle decadence and grotesque art (Kasjaniuk 1993, Kulig-Janarek 1994, Kitowska-ysiak 1994). Much attention has been paid, then, to Schulz’s artistic and thematic affinity with a wide variety of predecessors such as Francisco Goya, Aubrey Beardsley, Félicien Rops, etc. Notwithstanding the seemingly monothematic, anachronistic and repetitive character of Schulz’s graphics and drawings, the “pictorial” branch of Schulzology has gained more prominence and relevance in recent years. First of all, it has been pointed out that his illustrative works are more than mere illustrations and add a particular twist to his fiction (Wysouch 1992, Shallcross 1994). Also, in line with similar developments in the discussion of Schulz’s fiction, increasing attention has been drawn to the function of Jewish and Judaist elements in Schulz’s graphics and drawings, particularly kabbalistic messianism (Panas 1997, 2001). Apart from that, the repetitive character of Schulz’s pencil sketches and drawings has been increasingly differentiated from the more complex character of his early graphics (Van Heuckelom 2006, Kato 2009). To a certain extent, the aforementioned research currents seem to reflect the main shift that took place in the discussion of Schulz’s fiction, moving from mimetic approaches (focusing on the reality represented) toward more reflexive approaches (focusing on the process of representation). Emblematic for a more balanced approach toward Schulz’s artwork is
Introduction: Seven Decades of Schulzology
15
Sikorski (2004), whose critical discussion of Schulz’s “symbolical world” draws both on Schulz’s literary and pictorial works. Although Schulz’s artwork will perhaps always remain in the shadow of his fiction, there seems to be a growing consensus that his graphics are artistic works in their own right rather than constituting a mere backdrop to his literary works. With regard to Schulz’s fiction, another popular critical strategy has been to compare Schulz’s works to an ever-increasing number of well- and less-known writers and literary trends. Parallel to this, the literary historical role of Schulz had to be reconsidered. Back in the 1980s, this issue had been already addressed by Jerzy Jarz bski, who proposed to locate the works of such “atypical avant-gardists” (1987: 160) as Schulz, Gombrowicz, and Witkacy “in either a broadly-conceived modernism or as a particular tendency in an equally widely-conceived avant-garde” (161). A few years later, then, Jarz bski signaled a shift in critical attention from Schulz as a modernist to Schulz as a postmodernist (1994a: 14) – which is also a shift from the idealism of ‘Mityzacja rzeczywistoci’ (‘The Mythologizing of Reality’) to the ironic stance of ‘An Essay for S.I. Witkiewicz’, and from the cycle ‘Traktat o manekinach’ (‘Treatise on Tailors’ Dummies’) to the novella ‘Wiosna’ (‘Spring’). Although this tendency to treat Schulz as a harbinger of postmodernism was soon (and with good reason) criticized (cf. Bolecki 1999, Shallcross 1997: 255), stories such as ‘Ksi ga’ (‘The Book’), ‘Genialna epoka’ (‘The Age of Genius’), and ‘Spring’ proved to be extremely receptive to (more or less) poststructuralist readings (cf. Czabanowska-Wróbel 2001, Gowacka 1998, 1999 [1996], Hyde 1992, Kony 1995, Lachmann 1992, 1999 [1996], Markowski 1994, Ritz 1993, Rybicka 2000, Schönle 1998, Stala 1993, Waszak 2002). No matter how interesting the discussion of Schulz’s literary historical position may be, it is unclear whether or not it adds something substantial to our understanding of Schulz’s creative output. Indeed, as the pile of Schulzological writings keeps growing and growing, we should ask ourselves if there is any clear research agenda behind this occasionally blind worship of Schulz. Or, in plain words: what is it that makes us devote so much energy to the analysis of this quantitatively modest body of stories and graphic works? In order to gain an insight into this crucial problem of Schulzology, we should take a look at what some other critics have said about the
16
Dieter De Bruyn & Kris Van Heuckelom
problematic reception of Schulz’s fiction. In his groundbreaking monograph, On the Margins of Reality: the Paradoxes of Representation in Bruno Schulz’s Fiction, Krzysztof Stala comes up with the following observation: Why is it that these tales […] so stubbornly resist critical analysis and interpretation? Why do these critical essays only propose some fragmentary, marginal reading, being rather aware of the inexhaustibleness of Schulz’s prose than trying to define this inexhaustibleness, domesticate it with some proposal richer than “expression of the inexpressible”? (1993: 1)
What Stala suggests here is that Schulz’s stories merely evoke fragmentary, marginal readings which slavishly imitate the language of their subject of research, domesticating it over and over again with such poor proposals as “expression of the inexpressible”. According to us, what is hidden behind these readings is the same methodological fallacy which we already mentioned: more often than not, the same set of discursive and metafictional comments uttered in Schulz’s stories is used for interpreting these stories, which inevitably leads to a kind of circular (tautological) reasoning. Stala suggests that critics should try more to define Schulz’s literary world themselves rather than merely accepting the unreliable interpretative clues which are offered by the “author-like” first-person narrator. Contrary to Stala, Stanislaw Eile focuses on readings in which Schulz’s linguistic world is treated as an open structure which can be filled up with the most extraordinary content: Despite many digressions and metafictional comments articulated by the first-person narrator and the main character, his father, the extensive use of figurative language renders [Schulz’s] message rather confusing and consequently open to a variety of esoteric readings, which often demonstrate the inventiveness of critics rather than representing a convincing explication of the text. (1996: 97)
Eile seems to signal that such readings often misuse Schulz’s equivocal message in order to impose the most far-fetched meaning on it. Whereas the reading strategy discussed by Stala could be called “description without interpretation”, we could consider the one proposed by Eile as “interpretation without description”. In the former case, we get critical accounts which describe Schulz’s literary world
Introduction: Seven Decades of Schulzology
17
by using its inherent terminology, whereas in the latter case the critic merely singles out what he needs from the text in order to substantiate his interpretation. According to us, the key to the future of Schulzology lies exactly in the liminal space between the two reading strategies: on the one hand, we should continue to scrutinize new and interesting influences and similarities and adopt new methodological frameworks, but on the other hand, we must always start from a clear description of what is actually happening in these stories or in their graphic counterparts. As we have seen in this brief overview of Schulzological writings, whatever critical scalpel one selects for dissecting Schulz’s fiction, there will always be a certain degree of textual resistance which cannot be broken, or in other words, taking off one of Schulz’s many masks, one will probably never avoid the impression that a new mask has emerged. Being fully aware of the relativity of each particular reading, the present volume aims to contribute to what we believe are the three main currents in Schulzology: combinations with other writers, trends, and traditions, fragmentations within new historical and theoretical contexts, and reintegrations of the ultimate sense of Schulz’s artistic universe. In addition, the book sets out to explore all of Schulz’s creative output (i.e. his stories as well as his graphic, epistolary and even literary critical works), as one of Schulz’s main goals was to cross artificially set up boundaries between, among other things, different artistic media of expression. In this way, the book should be seen as a continuation of the inspiring panels and fruitful discussions at the International Conference “The World of Bruno Schulz/Bruno Schulz and the World: Influences, Similarities, Reception” (Leuven, Belgium, May 25-26, 2007), which was organized in preparation to this volume by its editors. The first two parts of the book, “New Combinations: Literature” and “New Combinations: Art”, offer new comparative approaches to Schulz’s artistic legacy. Whereas some contributions further explore the problem of concrete influences on and creative reception of Schulz’s oeuvre, other articles present authors, trends and traditions which share typological similarities with his works. A first selection delves into the Jewish background of Schulz and his writings. Karen Underhill’s contribution sheds new light on Schulz’s ambivalent relationship with Jewish tradition by bringing into view the artistic and intellectual currents prominent within the generation of
18
Dieter De Bruyn & Kris Van Heuckelom
acculturated, “de-racinated” Jews to which Schulz belonged (including Martin Buber, Walter Benjamin, Gershom Scholem and Franz Kafka). Andrea Meyer-Fraatz’s article draws on similar premises but focuses on the problem of assimilation and acculturation within the context of modern Polish literature. In particular, she draws an interesting comparison between the diverging strategies of “literary” assimilation embodied by Schulz and his contemporary Bolesaw Lemian. Sawomir Jacek urek in turn discusses the influence of Schulz’s usage of “kabbalistic” motifs and ideas on the writings of another Polish author of Jewish descent, Arnold Sucki. Other chapters draw on all kinds of parallels between Schulz’s fiction and the works of twentieth-century Polish and foreign writers: Dieter De Bruyn employs the concept of “metafiction” as an interpretative tool for connecting Schulz’s stories with Karol Irzykowski’s novel Pauba (1903). According to De Bruyn, both authors demonstrate that no matter how hard literature tries to add a third dimension (depth, signifié), the reader will always be confronted with the two-dimensional reality of the text (surface, signifiant). While directing our attention to the position of Schulz within postwar Polish literature, Anna liwa puts Schulz’s work next to the poetry of Miron Biaoszewski. As her detailed analysis of Schulz’s and Biaoszewski’s “mythologization of the city” shows, the presence of striking (albeit superficial) convergences in the domain of “urban imagery” helps to highlight the differentia specifica of Schulz’s and Biaoszewski’s writings. The contributions of Alfred Gall and Dorota Wojda, finally, venture into the domain of world literature and “combine” Schulz’s works with respectively Yugoslav and Latin American literature. While Wojda compares Schulz’s usage of irony with Gabriel García Marquez’s magical realism in One Hundred Years of Solitude, Gall explores Schulzian echoes in the works of Danilo Kiš (in particular the ‘Treatise on the Potatoe’ chapter from Hourglass). As his analysis shows, the sophisticated intertextual play created by Kiš functions as a literary response to the Shoa. The second, art-related series of “combinations” starts with Marta Skwara’s elaborate discussion of the “(wo)man on a sofa” motif that often recurs in Schulz’s literary and plastic output. It allows Skwara to highlight the artist’s creative, unconventional, and transgressive application of traditional schemes and motifs. Schulz’s position as a (non-)traditional artist also comes to the fore in Ariko
Introduction: Seven Decades of Schulzology
19
Kato’s contribution, which discusses the masochist and modernist aspects of Schulz’s early graphic works in relation to Leopold von Sacher-Masoch’s novel Venus in Furs. Jan Zieliski, in turn, draws some interesting thematic and formal parallels between Schulz’s works and the paintings of one of his favorite artists, the Basque Ignacio Zuloaga y Zabaleta. The issue of typological similarities between Schulz and other Modernist artists (in terms of biography and artistic practice) is central to Esther Sánchez-Pardo’s article on the American writer and visual artist Djuna Barnes. Daniel Watt’s closing article exposes the “incomparable reality” of Schulz’s stories by examining theatrical and cinematic “adaptations” of his works (for instance the Quay Brothers’ Street of Crocodiles). In the third part of the book, “Further Fragmentations”, detailed studies of single ideas or motives or of hitherto unnoticed subtexts will demonstrate once more that Schulz’s artistic universe allows for ever new fragmentary approaches, which merely reinforce its superficial polyvalence without ever disclosing its semantic core. The first of these approaches, as proposed by Mieczysaw D browski, is a discussion of Schulz’s works through the prism of the aesthetics of melancholy, which closely cooperates with the ironic aspects of Schulz’s writings. Another analytical approach is taken by Jerzy Jarz bski, who focuses on the “seductive activities” performed by the protagonists of Schulz’s stories and by the author himself. Shlomit Gorin in turn proposes to reconsider Schulz’s works from the perspective of the absurd. A strongly psychoanalytic stance is taken in Marta Suchaska-Dra yska’s contribution which relates the parallels between Schulz’s works and Freudian psychoanalysis to their common Jewish roots. Jörg Schulte’s contribution reconsiders Schulz’s knowledge of Greek mythology and cosmology by focusing on the recurrent usage of breath and wind metaphors throughout Schulz’s stories. The article by Thomas Anessi is strongly concerned with literary sociological matters and discusses Schulz’s paradoxical position of a writer both disconnected from and connected with the literary center of his time. While Anessi’s analysis focuses on Schulz’s links with Warsaw literary and cultural circles in the 1930s, Oksana Weretiuk’s contribution focuses on the particular reception of Schulz’s work in its “peripheral” place of origin, particularly among Ukrainian artists, writers, scholars, and the general public from the 1930s to the present.
20
Dieter De Bruyn & Kris Van Heuckelom
The last part of the book, “Ultimate Reintegrations”, attempts to gather all these bits and scraps of a unity long gone, “like fragments of a broken mirror” (dixit Schulz), in order to reintegrate our picture of Schulz’s artistic world. It remains to be seen, however, whether these final remarks conclude once and for all the ongoing discussion on Schulz’s essence, or if they bring new problematic issues into existence. According to Micha Pawe Markowski, central to Schulz’s ironical universe is the permanent deconstruction of apparent oppositions, such as the metaphysical dualism between essences and appearances and the opposition between high and low culture. Theodosia Robertson perceives a close link between Schulz’s early graphics and his later stories in the sense that they both aim to establish a form of intimate communication between the artist and his “select” audience. Alfred Sproede’s contribution breaks with the image of Schulz as a respectful propagator of Hasidic and kabbalistic thought by relating the author’s particular re-enactment of Hasidic tales and motifs to his dispute with the avant-garde movement. Janis Augsburger, finally, links the interpretative openness of Schulz’s fiction to the intellectual eclecticism that lies at the heart of his writings. The present volume would have never been completed without the help and support of some of our colleagues. First of all, we would like to extend our gratitude to our reviewers for their critical evaluation of the articles considered for publication, in particular Brian Banks, Rolf Fieguth, Theodosia Robertson, Katarzyna Ruchel-Stockmans, and Krzysztof Stala who took up the role of discussants during the 2007 Schulz conference in Belgium. We are also indebted to Marek W. Podstolski for granting permission to include reproductions of Schulz’s artwork and to Carol M. Richards for proofreading the articles. Bibliography Becker, Jan. 1967. ‘Bruno Schulz’ in Przegld artystyczny 5. Bolecki, Wodzimierz. 1996 [1982]. Poetycki model prozy w dwudziestoleciu midzywojennym. Kraków: Universitas. ——. 1999. ‘Le Postmodernisme? Ou peut-être un modernisme méconnu?: Witkacy – Gombrowicz – Schulz’ in Delaperrière, Maria (ed.) Modernisme en Europe Centrale. Les avant-gardes. Paris: L’Harmattan: 173-192.
Introduction: Seven Decades of Schulzology
21
Bolecki, Wodzimierz, Jerzy Jarz bski and Stanisaw Rosiek (eds). 2003. Sownik schulzowski. Gdask: sowo/obraz terytoria. Brown, Russell E. 1991. Myths and Relatives: Seven Essays on Bruno Schulz. München: Verlag Otto Sagner. Burek, Tomasz. 1966. ‘Ogromny fragment. Uwagi na marginesie lektury ksi gi zbiorowej Z problemów literatury polskiej XX wieku’ in Kultura i Spoeczestwo 10(4): 263-272. Chwin, Stefan. 1985. ‘Twórczo i autorytety. Bruno Schulz wobec romantycznych dilematów tworzenia’ in Pamitnik Literacki 76(1): 69-93. Czabanowska-Wróbel, Anna. 2001. ‘Fantazmaty dziecistwa: glosa do “Wiosny” Schulza’ in Ruch Literacki 42(1): 57-66. D browski, Mieczysaw. 2000. ‘Bruno Schulz w kontekcie wspóczesnych dyskursów o kulturze’ in Rocznik Towarzystwa Literackiego im. A. Mickiewicza 35: 23-35. Dresdner, Karol. 1935. Kultura i sztuka ludu ydowskiego na ziemiach polskich. Zbiory Maksymiljana Goldsteina. Lwów: M. Goldstein. Dubowik, Henryk. 1971. Nadrealizm w polskiej literaturze wspóczesnej (Prace Wydziau Nauk Humanistycznych B5). Pozna: Bydgoskie Towarzystwo Naukowe. Eile, Stanisaw. 1996. Modernist Trends in Twentieth-Century Polish Fiction. London: University of London, School of Slavonic and East European Studies. Ficowski, Jerzy. 1967. Regiony wielkiej herezji. Szkice o yciu i twórczoci Brunona Schulza. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie. ——. 1975. Regiony wielkiej herezji. Szkice o yciu i twórczoci Brunona Schulza. (2nd ed.) Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie. ——. 1986. Okolice sklepów cynamonowych. Szkice, przyczynki, impresje. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie. ——. 2002. Regiony wielkiej herezji i okolice. Bruno Schulz i jego mitologia. Sejny: Pogranicze. Fik, Ignacy. 1961 [1935]. ‘Literatura choromaniaków’ in Wybór pism krytycznych. Warszawa: Robotniczy Spódzielnia Wydawnicza: 125-134. Gowacka, Dorota. 1998. ‘The Heresiarchs of Form: Gombrowicz and Schulz’ in Ziarek-Ponowska, Ewa (ed.) Gombrowicz’s Grimaces: Modernism, Gender, Nationality: Albany: State University of New York Press: 65-88. ——. 1999 [1996]. ‘Sublime Trash and the Simulacrum: Bruno Schulz in the Postmodern Neighborhood’ in Prokopczyk, Czesaw Z. (ed.) Bruno Schulz: New Documents and Interpretations. New York: Peter Lang: 79-134. Golicki-Baur, Elisabeth. 1975. Die Prosa von Bruno Schulz. Bern: Lang. Hyde, George. 1992. ‘State of Arrest: The Short Stories of Bruno Schulz’ in Eile, Stanisaw and Phillips, Ursula (eds). New Perspectives on TwentiethCentury Polish Literature: Flight from Martyrology. London: Macmillan: 47-67. Jarz bski, Jerzy. 1973. ‘Sen o ‘zotym wieku’’ in Teksty 2(2): 104-121. ——. 1976. ‘Uwagi o semantyce przestrzeni i czasu w prozie Brunona Schulza’ in Czaplowa, Kazimiera (ed.) Studia o prozie Brunona Schulza (Prace naukowe Uniwersytetu l skiego w Katowicach 115). Katowice: Uniwersytet l ski: 49-73.
22
Dieter De Bruyn & Kris Van Heuckelom
——. 1984. ‘Czasoprzestrze mitu i marzenia w prozie Brunona Schulza’ in Powie jako autokreacja. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie: 170-226. ——. 1987. ‘Witkacy, Schulz and Gombrowicz versus the Avant-garde’ in Nilsson, Nils Äke (ed.) The Slavic Literatures and Modernism: a Nobel Symposium, August 5-8 1985. Stockholm: Almqvist & Wiksell International: 151-165. ——. 1994a. ‘Wst p: czytanie Schulza’ in Jarz bski (1994b): 5-17. ——. 1994b. Czytanie Schulza. Kraków: T.I.C. Karkowski, Czesaw. 1976. ‘System kultury Brunona Schulza’ in Czaplowa, Kazimiera (ed.) Studia o prozie Brunona Schulza (Prace naukowe Uniwersytetu l skiego w Katowicach 115). Katowice: Uniwersytet l ski: 3147. ——. 1980. Kultura i krytyka inteligencji w twórczoci Brunona Schulza. Wrocaw: Zakad Narodowy im. Ossoliskich. Kasjaniuk, Halina. 1993. ‘Rodowody i symbole w grafikach Schulza’ in Ciechowicz Jan and Kasjaniuk Halina (eds). Teatr Pamici Brunona Schulza. Gdynia: s.n.: 10-25. Kato, Ariko. 2009. ‘Obraz i Ksi ga. O autoreferencyjnoci w twórczoci Brunona Schulza’ in Kitowska-ysiak, Magorzata (ed.) Biae plamy w schulzologii. Lublin: Wydawnictwo KUL (forthcoming). Kitowska, Magorzata. 1979. ‘Czytaj c “Xi g Bawochwalcz ” in Twórczo 3: 157160. Kitowska-ysiak, Magorzata. (ed.) 1981. ‘Xiga Bawochwalcza – grafiki oryginalne (cliché verre) Brunona Schulza’ in Biuletyn Historii Sztuki 4: 401-410. ——. 1986. ‘Brunona Schulza “Xi ga Bawochwalcza”. W sprawie analogii’ in Akcent 3: 154-161. —— (ed.) 1992a. Bruno Schulz in memoriam. 1892-1942. Lublin: Wydawnictwo FIS. ——. 1992b. ‘Bruno Schulz – “Xi ga Bawochwalcza”: wizja - forma – analogie’ in Kitowska-ysiak (1992a): 133-151. Kosiski, Krzysztof. 1976. ‘Schulzowskie modele komunikacji’ in Czaplowa, Kazimiera (ed.) Studia o prozie Brunona Schulza (Prace naukowe Uniwersytetu l skiego w Katowicach 115). Katowice: Uniwersytet l ski: 91102. Kosko, Allan 1976. ‘L’œuvre graphique de Bruno Schulz à la Sorbonne’ in Opus International 59. Kony, Witold. 1995. ‘“Bo czym e jest wiosna, jeli nie zmartwychwstaniem historyj”. (Zu Bruno Schulz’ Erzählung “Wiosna”)’ in Zeitschrift für Slavische Philologie 55(2): 313-322. Kulig-Janarek, Krystyna. 1992. ‘Erotyka – groteska – ironia – kreacja’ in Kitowskaysiak (1992a): 153-177. ——. 1993. ‘Schulzowska mitologia: Motywy, w tki, inspiracje w Xidze Bawochwalczej’ in Kresy 14: 37-49. Lachmann, Renate. 1992. ‘Dezentrierte Bilder. Die ekstatische Imagination in Bruno Schulz’ Prosa’ in Hansen-Löve, Aage (ed.) Psychopoetik. Beiträge zur Tagung “Psychologie und Literatur” München 1991 (Wiener Slawistischer Almanach, Sonderband 31). Wien: Gesellschaft zur Förderung slawistischer Studien: 439-461. ——. 1999 [1996]. ‘Demiurg i jego fantazmaty: spekulacje wokó mitologii stworzenia w dziele Bruno Schulza’ in Teksty Drugie 10(6): 103-119.
Introduction: Seven Decades of Schulzology
23
Lauterbach, Artur. 1929. ‘Talent w ukryciu. O grafikach Brunona Schulza’ in Chwila 3740. Markowski, Micha Pawe. 1994. ‘“Wiosna”: mi dzy retoryk a erotyk ’ in Jarz bski, Jerzy (1994): 286-295. Miklaszewski, Krzysztof. 1966. ‘Cena wiadomoci. (Próba analizy opowiadania Bruno Schulza pt. ‘Pan’)’ in Ruch Literacki 7(6): 285-295. ——. 1971a. ‘Poeta prozy. (O poetyckiej materii prozy Brunona Schulza)’ in Poezja 7(7): 46-51. ——. 1971b. ‘O pewnej modernistycznej waciwoci prozy B. Schulza (na przykadzie Sklepów cynamonowych)’ in Zeszyty Naukowe Uniwersytetu Jagielloskiego. Prace historycznoliterackie 21: 49-66. Panas, Wadysaw. 1974a. ‘‘Regiony czystej poezji’. O koncepcji j zyka w prozie B. Schulza’ in Roczniki Humanistyczne 22: 151-173. ——. 1974b. ‘Apologia i destrukcja (‘Noc wielkiego sezonu’ Brunona Schulza)’ in Bartoszyski, Kazimierz, Jasiska-Wojtkowska, Maria and Sawicki, Stefan (eds). Nowela. Opowiadanie. Gawda. Interpretacje maych form narracyjnych. Warszawa: Pastwowe Wydawnictwo Naukowe: 191-205. ——. 1976. ‘‘Zst pienie w esencjonalno’. O ksztatach sowa w prozie Brunona Schulza’ in Czaplowa, Kazimiera (ed.) Studia o prozie Brunona Schulza (Prace naukowe Uniwersytetu l skiego w Katowicach 115). Katowice: Uniwersytet l ski: 75-89. ——. 1997. Ksiga blasku. Traktat o kabale w prozie Brunona Schulza. Lublin: Towarzystwo Naukowe KUL. ——. 2001. Bruno od Mesjasza. Lublin: Wydawnictwo UMCS. Rachwa, Tadeusz. 1985. ‘Remityzacja sowa. Rzecz o manekinach w prozie Brunona Schulza’ in Prace Naukowe Uniwersytetu lskiego w Katowicach 668: 116-124. Ritz, German. 1993. ‘Die Fahrt in die Krokodilstraße als ein Verlassen des mythischen Raums: Zu einer Erzählung von Bruno Schulz’ in Zeitschrift für Slawistik 38(2): 207-216. Robertson, Theodosia S. 1990. ‘Time in Bruno Schulz’ in Indiana Slavic Studies 5: 181-192. ——. 1991. ‘Bruno Schulz and Comedy’ in The Polish Review 36(2): 119-126. Rybicka, El bieta. 2000. ‘B dzi w czytaniu: proza Brunona Schulza’ in Rybicka, El bieta, Formy labiryntu w prozie polskiej XX wieku. Kraków: Universitas: 102-127. Samojlik, Czesaw. 1965. ‘Groteska – pisarstwo wszechstronnie banalne… Sprawa prozy Brunona Schulza’ in Brodzka, Alina and abicki, Zbigniew (eds). Z problemów literatury polskiej XX wieku. II: Literatura midzywojenna. Warszawa: Pastwowy Instytut Wydawniczy: 266-296. Sandauer, Artur. 1964 [1956]. ‘Rzeczywisto zdegradowana (Rzecz o Brunonie Schulzu)’ in Schulz, Bruno, Proza. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie: 743. Schönle, Andreas. 1991. ‘Cinnamon Shops by Bruno Schulz: the Apology of Tandeta’ in The Polish Review 36(2): 127-144. ——. 1998. ‘Of Sublimity, Shrinkage, and Selfhood in the Works of Bruno Schulz’ in Slavic and East European Journal 42(3): 467-482.
24
Dieter De Bruyn & Kris Van Heuckelom
Schulz, Bruno. 1967. Prace Brunona Schulza. Blok-notes Muzeum Mickiewicza 5.1. Warszawa: Muzeum Literatury im. A. Mickiewicza. ——. 1988. Xiga Bawochwalcza. (ed. J. Ficowski). Warszawa: Interpress. Shallcross, Bo ena. 1994. ‘Pencil, Pen and Ink: Bruno Schulz’s Art of Interference’ in Pula, James (ed.) The Heart of Nation. Proceedings of PIASA International Congress. New York: PIASA & Columbia University Press: 57-68. ——. 1997. ‘Introduction: Bruno Schulz and Modernism’ in East European Politics and Societies 11(2): 254-256. Sikorski, Dariusz K. 2004. Symboliczny wiat Brunona Schulza. Supsk: Wydawnictwo Pomorskiej Akademii Pedagogicznej w Supsku. Speina, Jerzy. 1971. ‘Bruno Schulz a nadrealizm’ in Hutnikiewicz, Artur and Zaworska, Helena (eds). O prozie polskiej XX wieku (Z Dziejów Form Artystycznych W Literaturze Polskiej 24). Wrocaw: Zakad Narodowy im. Ossoliskich: 183-198. ——. 1974. Bankructwo realnoci. Proza Brunona Schulza. Warszawa: PWN. Stala, Krzysztof. 1993. On the Margins of Reality: the Paradoxes of Representation in Bruno Schulz’s Fiction. Stockholm: Almqvist & Wiksell International. Steinhoff, Lutz. 1984. Rückkehr zur Kindheit als groteskes Denkspiel. Ein Beitrag zum Motiv des ‘dojrze’ do dziecistwa in den Erzählungen von Bruno Schulz. Hildesheim: Georg Olms. Sulikowski, Andrzej. 1978. ‘Twórczo Brunona Schulza w krytyce i badaniach literackich (1934-1976)’ in Pamitnik Literacki 69(2): 264-303. Szymaski, Wiesaw Pawe. 1970. ‘O twórczoci Brunona Schulza’ in Ruch Literacki 11(5): 295-306. Taylor Sen, Colleen. 1969. ‘Childhood Revisited: The Writings of Bruno Schulz’ in Slavic and East European Journal 13(4): 455-472. ——. 1972. Polish Experimental Fiction 1900-1939: A Comparative Study of the Novels of Karol Irzykowski, Stanisaw Ignacy Witkiewicz, Witold Gombrowicz and Bruno Schulz. PhD thesis. Columbia University. van der Meer, Jan Y. 1990. ‘On Bruno Schulz’s “Tailors’ Dummies”’ in de Haard, Eric, Thomas Langerak and Willem G. Weststeijn (eds). Semantic Analysis of Literary Texts. To Honour Jan van der Eng on the Occasion of his 65th Birthday. Amsterdam: Elsevier: 385-405. Van Heuckelom, Kris. 2006. ‘Artistic Crossover in Polish Modernism. The Case of Bruno Schulz’s Xi ga Bawochwalcza (The Idolatrous Booke)’ in Image [&] Narrative. Online Magazine of the Visual Narrative 15. On line at: http://www.imageandnarrative.be/iconoclasm/heuckelom.htm (consulted 18.05.2008). Vogel, Debora. 1930. [‘Bruno Schulz’] in Judisk tidskrift 3: 224-226. Waszak, Tomasz. 2002. ‘Die Republik der Texte. Bruno Schulz’ Das Sanatorium zur Todesanzeige als utopisches Dokument’ in Orbis Linguarum 22: 37-49. Witkiewicz, Stanisaw Ignacy. 1935. ‘Wywiad z Brunonem Schulzem’ in Tygodnik Ilustrowany 17: 321-323. Witz, Ignacy. 1967. Obszary malarskiej wyobra ni. Eseje. Kraków: Wyd. Literackie. Wyka, Kazimierz and Stefan Napierski. 2000 [1939]. ‘Dwugos o Schulzu’ in Wyka, Kazimierz, Stara szuflada i inne szkice z lat 1932-1939. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie: 419-427.
Introduction: Seven Decades of Schulzology
25
Wyskiel, Wojciech. 1977a. ‘Brunona Schulza porozumienie z czytelnikiem’ in Bujnicki, Tadeusz and Janusz Sawiski (eds). Problemy odbioru i odbiorcy. Wrocaw etc.: Ossolineum: 257-267. ——. 1977b. ‘wiat i j zyk w dziele Brunona Schulza’ in Ruch Literacki 18(2): 119135. ——. 1980. Inna twarz Hioba. Problematyka alienacyjna w dziele Brunona Schulza. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie. Wysouch, Seweryna. 1992. ‘Ilustracja autorska – casus Brunona Schulza’ in Teksty Drugie 5(17): 116-122.
Ecstasy and Heresy: Martin Buber, Bruno Schulz, and Jewish Modernity Karen Underhill Abstract: Bruno Schulz’s complex and ambivalent relationship with Jewish tradition and subject matter, and his use of Hasidic and kabbalistic tropes and imagery, are viewed alongside modern intellectual and artistic currents prominent within the Jewish community at the time he was writing. Specifically, the essay discusses the trend dubbed “fin de siècle Orientalism” and the influence of Martin Buber’s work on the perception of Hasidic culture among the generation of acculturated, “de-racinated” Jews in the Austro-Hungarian Empire to which Schulz belonged. The article goes on to explore the divergent paths through which Buber and Schulz engaged and incorporated elements of Jewish tradition in their respective forms of “remythologization”.
Introduction By proposing a dialogue between the texts of Bruno Schulz and Martin Buber, I would like to engage Schulz as a Jewish writer and artist in the context of what Benjamin Harshav has called “the modern Jewish revolution” (Harshav 1993). His phrase refers to the period of a few decades from the end of the nineteenth century until World War II in which Jews negotiated the complex paths of entry into modern European society. Given the complex and often uneasy relationship that Schulz’s work has with Jewish heritage and the Jewish cultural currents of his time, I would like to examine some of the motivations and strategies for engaging that tradition which existed among assimilating, cosmopolitan Jewish artists and thinkers in the early twentieth century. Schulz and his work can fruitfully be placed within a constellation of assimilated Jewish intellectuals of his generation, whose work reveals an attempt to incorporate Jewish philosophical and mystical heritage into modern, often secular systems of thought: including Walter Benjamin, Gershom Scholem, Franz Kafka, Martin
28
Karen Underhill
Buber and Franz Rosenzweig. All chose to engage that tradition in different ways – from philosophical, scientific, artistic, or theological perspectives, respectively – but all are illustrative of a certain intellectual genealogy, a recognizable trend among assimilated Jewish intellectuals in the early part of the twentieth century: their work and the type of philosophical “solutions” they propose are influenced by, and have incorporated into their language and imagery, elements of Jewish mystical and messianic philosophy – including attitudes toward language drawn from kabbalah, certain elements drawn from Hasidic philosophy, and the Hasidic storytelling tradition. My interest in placing Schulz within this constellation is to consider his own positioning within a range of choices made by assimilated Jewish writers and artists, about how to engage Jewish, and in particular Eastern European Hasidic tradition, and how to give it a vital continuity within their modern, cosmopolitan, and broadly European context. In particular, I look at two members of this generation, Schulz and Buber, who placed the idea of modern myth-making or “remythologization” at the center of their work and for whom the relationship with myth is simultaneously a relationship to Jewish tradition of the Galician region. For both writers, the search for authenticity and meaning in the modern world involves negotiating a relationship with the Jewish past – but one that is not only not traditional but also entails an emphatic rejection of traditional religious practice or belief and the construction instead of an association of that which is “truly Jewish” with that which is strongly heretical. The divergent ways in which Buber and Schulz negotiated that relationship are as expressive of the modern Jewish experience as is the overlap in their vocabularies and thematics.1 While for Buber this relationship would take the form of commitment to the Zionist cause and to Cultural Zionism, Schulz’s solution takes a more decadent modernist turn: it involves envisioning Jewish spirit and 1
Both writers were the children of assimilated Jewish parents in the AustroHungarian Empire. Both grew up near Lwów, and were educated in Polish gymnasia. A decisive difference lies in their exposure to Jewish languages and traditional religious practice. Buber was raised at the home of his grandparents; and while Buber wrote that “it was not Hasidism alone from which I was alienated at that time, but Judaism as a whole” (Buber 1958: 47), even so his grandfather Salomon Buber was a devoted Midrash scholar. Alongside Classical and European languages, Buber learned Hebrew, which Schulz did not.
Ecstasy and Heresy: Buber, Schulz, and Jewish Modernity
29
heritage as a source of marginalized or repressed inspiration and authenticity, an underground or hidden source of vitality, more powerful precisely for its very sublimation; fertile not despite but because of its degradation, like the decayed material of an organic compost which contributes to the most fertile humus. Considering the very different models Buber and Schulz present involves engaging the problems both of continuity and authenticity: what keeps a tradition vital? What is the role of the heresiarch in negotiating the path from tradition into modernity? I argue that a consideration of Buber’s influential early work with Hasidic culture can help to shed light on the context in which Schulz himself encountered this complex challenge. Hence, the present study will specifically highlight the significant influence that Buber’s work had on the attitudes of assimilated Jewish intellectuals of Central Europe in the early twentieth century toward Hasidic culture, philosophy, and storytelling. Schulz as a Jewish Writer Over the past decade or so, scholars of Schulz have taken a number of different approaches in discussing Jewish themes and sources in his work: Jan Boski (1994) emphasizes the traditional biblical culture and the culture of the book, the late Wadysaw Panas (1997) examines how kabbalistic tropes – of creation through a process of contraction and emanation, of repair through the recuperation of sparks of divinity scattered in the lower world; or of the divine spirit or Shekhinah in exile in the world – are woven throughout the stories. Eugenia Prokop-Janiec (1994) provides an important overview of the historical background of the Galician crossroads in which Schulz developed as a Polish Jewish writer, working amidst a melting pot of cultures. Bo ena Shallcross (1997) considers Schulz’s modernist retextualization of aspects of Lurianic kabbalah, while David Goldfarb’s in-depth reading of ‘Noc wielkiego sezonu’ (‘The Night of the Great Season’) explores Schulz’s use of elements from Jewish mythology and tradition, and more broadly his adaptation of a Talmudic model for imagining both what it is to write – the story as a commentary or exegesis in the margins of an original text – and how Schulz encourages us to read and interact with his text (1994). Jörg Schulte (2003) has analyzed Schulz’s use of allusions to the Jewish calendar, and Shalom Lindenbaum (1994) uncovers the extensive
30
Karen Underhill
references throughout Schulz’s work to elements of Jewish mysticism and messianism. All of these contributions testify to a complex engagement on Schulz’s part with Jewish culture, played out within his prose writings and graphic works. Throughout his prose, this engagement with Jewish tradition is not a sideline or simply a recurring motif: it is closely connected, though in an uneasy dance of push and pull, to the search for authenticity in the modern world. It is also true that the ways that Jewish elements appear in Schulz’s texts – often coded in allusive or allegorical references that also become some of his most powerful, many-layered metaphors – reveal a simultaneous rejection of and embracing of Jewish sources – less an erasure than a sublimation of Jewish content. While the studies I mentioned above successfully tease out a multitude of allusions to Jewish tradition and culture in Schulz’s work, he can also be seen as a writer who goes to some length to de-ethnicize and de-contextualize his writing, seeking its entry into a non-marked community of European letters that shares a broadly modern, cosmopolitan sensibility. In this sense Schulz’s work reveals a tension characteristic of the modern Jewish experience, between competing urges. One involves negotiating a vital relationship with Jewish tradition, and writing oneself and one’s work into the literary lineage of that tradition. As Schulz writes: Ach, i spisuj c te nasze opowiadania, szereguj c t histori o moim ojcu na zu ytym marginesie jej tekstu, czy nie oddaj si tajnej nadziei, e wrosn one kiedy niepostrze enie mi dzy z óke kartki tej najwspanialszej, rozsypuj cej si ksi gi, e wejd w wielki szelest jej stronic, który je pochonie? (Schulz 1989: 98)2 (Ah, when writing down these tales, revising the stories about my father on the used margins of its text, don’t I, too, surrender to the secret hope that they will merge imperceptibly with the yellowing pages of that most splendid, mouldering book, that they will sink into the gentle rustle of its pages and become absorbed there?; Schulz 1988: 87)3
The other involves striving both to create and to inhabit an intellectual community – and within the texts themselves, a narrative space – that transcends ethnic specificity; that escapes history or the temporary forms into which the human mythologizing urge temporarily gels. A 2 3
All further references will be given as Op. All further references will be given as TF.
Ecstasy and Heresy: Buber, Schulz, and Jewish Modernity
31
hopeful striving, but also a self-effacing one: for it expresses a yearning to belong to an intellectual and spiritual community in which Jewishness is not a factor – or in which it is something to be overcome. Given this ambivalence, a relevant question becomes: how can we understand the presence and use of Jewish themes in Schulz’s work? It is far from self-evident that an assimilated Jewish intellectual who did not receive a Jewish education or read Jewish religious texts in their original languages would develop a poetics influenced by kabbalistic philosophy or imagery, kabbalistic theories of language, or the Hasidic storytelling tradition. What then is the nature of Schulz’s engagement with Jewish tradition? According to the distinctions proposed by Benjamin Harshav in his seminal study of the modern Jewish experience, Language in Time of Revolution, Schulz would belong to that group of Jewish intellectuals of his generation who reflect the “extrinsic” route of entry into modern European culture. Harshav writes: What occurred in this period [within the Jewish community] was a multidirectional, centrifugal movement away from the old existence, symbolized by the religious culture of the Eastern European small town, the shtetl, as mythologized in Jewish fiction. […] [T]he movement went in two directions, extrinsic and intrinsic. (1993: 14) In other words: either go to the center of culture (in both the physical and spiritual sense), master its language, literature, ideologies, behavior, and science, and become a member of that language community (German, Russian, English),4 or create a parallel culture in Jewish languages [Yiddish and Modern Hebrew] that would have similar genres, norms, ideas, institutions, and achievements. Through either of those, you join cosmopolitan European culture as a whole. (1993: 5)
If we accept this perhaps too-easy dichotomy, then Schulz clearly embraced the extrinsic route, choosing to write in Polish and attach himself to the Polish literary community – as opposed to joining, for example, the Yiddishist movement, as did Debora Vogel, or actively identifying with the young Zionist art movement that was strong in Lwów, or striving for the articulation of a space for a demonstratively Polish-Jewish literature (cf. Prokop-Janiec 1994). This bears mentioning because while Schulz may have been raised with Polish as a mother tongue, as the language of the home and the school, even so 4
I will add here, Polish, which interestingly goes unmentioned in Harshav’s study.
32
Karen Underhill
his decision to enter Polish letters represents a choice and not a given. As Harshav writes, it was impossible to remain oblivious to the debate: The hostilities between all the intrinsic trends and the assimilationists, between the Socialists and the Zionists, […] between Yiddish and Hebrew, between Western Jews and Eastern Jews, were in the center of social consciousness and public debate. No Jew in this secularized period seemed able to live without active consciousness, and in Jewish behavior there was no consciousness without a position in a debate. (1993: 16)
In order to help elucidate the context for Schulz’s particular engagement with Jewish and Hasidic tradition, the present article will discuss one important element of the intellectual environment in which Schulz was developing his artistic identity and his unusual oeuvre: namely, the influence of Martin Buber’s writings, and charismatic speeches, on an entire generation of assimilating Jews. In particular I will discuss some of the themes put forward in Buber’s early lectures on Judaism – later published in two collections Drei Reden über das Judentum (Three Addresses on Judaism, 1911) and Vom Geist des Judentums (The Spirit of Judaism, 1916) – which he was invited by the Bar Kochba Students’ Association of Prague to deliver to the sizable assimilated public of Prague between 1909 and 1914. These lectures had an enormous impact on those members of the younger generation who attended them or later read them. Martin Buber and Fin de siècle Orientalism Buber’s early lectures on Judaism and his and his wife Paula Buber’s retellings in German of Hasidic tales appealed particularly to those who had moved away from traditional religious practice, had been educated in German, Polish, or Czech, and had joined, or hoped to join, a cosmopolitan, secular European culture as citizens of their respective countries. Estranged from their ethnic and religious traditions, and often no longer speaking a Jewish language, whether Hebrew or even Yiddish, many in this generation developed a more or less-articulated longing for a revived relationship with Jewish tradition (even as their European compatriots around them were discovering new romanticized conceptions of traditional European folk culture) and sought possibilities for an affirmative relationship with that
Ecstasy and Heresy: Buber, Schulz, and Jewish Modernity
33
tradition that did not require adherence to halakhic law or the separation of the Jew from the larger society and culture in which he or she lived. Buber’s lectures became a kind of bellwether and inspiration for a generation of Jewish intellectuals – transforming the attitudes toward their Jewish heritage of such thinkers as Franz Kafka, Max Brod, Georg Lukács, Ernst Bloch, and Gustav Landauer; individuals who, like Schulz, took an “extrinsic” path of participation in European letters, and aligned themselves neither with Zionism nor with Buber’s modern religiosity. Left-wing anarchist Gustav Landauer writing on Buber’s influence said: If I now say that […] it is precisely through the mediation of Martin Buber that I have found Judaism, I must caution all who do not know the world of Jewish spirit to which Buber brings us, not to conjure up a formal religion and ritual practices. (in Mendes-Flohr 1991: 107)
What Landauer responded to in Buber’s collection of Hasidic tales, Die Legende des Baalschem (The Legend of the Baal Shem, 1908), was rather a way of understanding his Judaism as an “‘inalienable’ spiritual sensibility” (Mendes-Flohr 1991: 107) which he shared with his fellow Jews, and which was independent of formal belief and affiliation. Drawing on categories proposed by his teacher Georg Simmel, Buber introduced the division between religion and religiosity (Schaeder 1973: 51). Religion – as practice, observance of halakhic law – was staunchly rejected as no longer valid for the modern Jew. But “religiosity” was brought forward as a primary value, a quality present in the individual who was open to the perception of authenticity and wholeness or unity and who sought in affirming this perception to restore meaning to life in modern Europe. For Buber, this sensitivity or openness was characteristic of the Jewish spirit, was latent in the soul of even the most deracinated modern Jew. Of relevance to our study of Schulz, Landauer “also learned from Buber that often those Jews who were most faithful to this sensibility were aligned with an unofficial, indeed heretical tradition” (MendesFlohr 1991: 107). This idea was central to Buber’s reevaluation of Jewish tradition and his understanding of the revitalizing role Hasidism had played in that tradition. What Martin Buber offered, then, was a discourse and a new way of thinking about Judaism that this assimilated generation was looking for – and it was based in a revaluing of precisely the culture of
34
Karen Underhill
the so-called Ostjuden – a negative epithet which referred to unassimilated Polish Jewry, and in particular Hasidim. Writes Paul Mendes-Flohr: [Buber] rendered Hasidism respectable, as it were, by integrating this most distinctive manifestation of East European Jewish spirituality into the general discourse and idiom of the New Romanticism (and later, of Expressionism). By virtue of Buber’s inspired presentation, Hasidism – and the millenial Jewish tradition from whence it emerged – was deemed relevant to the concerns of the educated individual involved in the spiritual quest of the fin de siècle. (1991: 14)
As Mendes-Flohr points out, the call that Buber made to his contemporaries, in these lectures and in his early writings on Hasidic culture, represents a specifically Jewish manifestation of a wider trend, or movement at the fin de siècle, and on into the interwar period, then dubbed the “New Romanticism”. The name was coined by German publisher Eugen Diederichs, who published Buber’s collection entitled Ekstatische Konfessionen (Ecstatic Confessions) in 1909, and whose publishing house sought to promote “a return to a higher transcendent reality” (Mendes-Flohr 1991: 80). For Jews and non-Jews, this was a period of vigorous interest in mysticism, and, under the strong influence of Schopenhauer, particularly in many forms of Eastern or “Oriental” spirituality, including Hinduism and Buddhism and, as a result of Buber’s efforts, later Hasidism – hence the term “fin de siècle Orientalism”. Adherents of the New Romanticism sought, and found in the teachings of the Orient, material and language for a revived spirituality, while at the same time vehemently rejecting organized religion, whether Christian or Jewish. They turned for inspiration, both spiritual and artistic, to mysticism, folklore, and the occult, and sought meaning and even potential salvation in art, poetry, theater, music – in forms of cultural expression that were based on a return to myth and reconnecting with mythic consciousness. Almost paradoxically, within the Jewish world, this new interest in Oriental spirituality and culture offered an opportunity to radically transform the relationship of assimilated Jewish intellectuals to their own past – to Jewish tradition. For within European discourse Judaism itself had been considered an Oriental religion and culture – with all the negative connotations that that had previously carried. By
Ecstasy and Heresy: Buber, Schulz, and Jewish Modernity
35
the turn of the century, and since the Jewish Enlightenment or Haskalah and the entry of Jews into wider European society in Western Europe, the relationship of assimilated Jews to their “unenlightened” neighbors to the East had become a strongly conflicted and even pained one. Assimilating Jews, particularly in Germany and the West but also in Poland and Russia, had internalized Europe’s negative image of the Jew as Oriental and transformed their own discomfort with Jewishness into a fear and scorn for the Orthodox and Hasidic Jewry of Poland and Eastern Europe. Viennese writer Karl Emil Franzos, also born in Galicia, referred to this Polish region in his very popular novels as Halb-Asien – “an exotic world characterized by squalor, ignorance, and superstition, and ruled by a fanatic mystical sect known as Hasidim” (in Mendes-Flohr 1991: 83). In the climate of fin de siècle Orientalism, however, with the rise of interest in Eastern religions and the new respect for eastern spirituality and mysticism, it became possible for Buber to effect a complete turn-around of this attitude among many members of his generation and the generations to follow. He was able to appropriate the image of the Jew as Oriental, to make it a sign of how Jews had in themselves and in their tradition a source of deep spirituality that modern European intellectuals and artists were now seeking. Hasidic culture and tradition, reexamined and repackaged as Oriental spirituality in the positive sense, could be seen as a source of living spirituality and still vital myth and legend, which should be an inspiration not only to modern Jews but to European culture. In his speech ‘The Spirit of the Orient and Judaism’, Judaism – in particular Hasidism – becomes, in fact, the highest expression of the Oriental spirit, and modern, secular Jews as the inheritors of this tradition are invested with a world-historical mission; they are a promise of spiritual hope to all nations. He concluded his lecture by saying: For this world-historical mission, Europe has at its disposal a mediating people that has acquired all the wisdom and the skills of the Occident without losing its original Oriental character, a people called to link Orient and Occident in fruitful reciprocity, just as it is perhaps called to fuse the spirit of the East and the West in a new teaching. (Buber 1967: 78)
As part of this shift in perception, Hasidic legends and mythology drawn from popular kabbalah and the Hasidic oral storytelling tradition, could also become a rich source of inspiration
36
Karen Underhill
for modern and modernist literature, in its many incarnations in several languages. The Bubers’ German-language renditions of Hasidic legends, and Martin Buber’s essays which introduced Hasidic philosophy and basic principles of the kabbalah, opened the tradition up to assimilated Jewish writers and artists, who would not have had access to this tradition in any Jewish language. Buber’s translations were certainly not the only work on Jewish mysticism available in German; there were numerous scholarly studies on the kabbalah published in German, including work by Marcus Ehrenpreis, the uncle of Debora Vogel. But they reached an incomparably larger audience of secular, assimilated Jews who likely would not have expected to be drawn to this material – in a way, at the time, and with a message that many of them wanted to hear. It is also true that Polish-Jewish readers from Galicia would have brought a different perspective to Buber’s Hasidic tales and essays than their German and Austrian neighbors. For them the Hasidic culture that Buber was re-presenting was neither foreign nor exotic but a part of everyday life in Galician cities, and Hasidim were a sizable portion of the Jewish population of the region. Buber’s revaluation, then, could instead have served to complement and complicate their own exposure to the Hasidic world and to its philosophy and storytelling traditions and to change their intellectual and artistic engagement with the heritage of that culture, which thrived in the towns and cities of Galicia, like Drohobycz. As David Goldfarb writes: Schulz probably did not have intimate direct knowledge of Zohar or Talmud or Maimonides in Hebrew and Aramaic, but he could have read them in German, and it would have been difficult to avoid absorbing their style and fragments of their substance from the conversation of Orthodox and Hasidic Jews in Galicia at the time of Schulz’s youth. (1997: 265)
Indeed, Schulz’s exposure to Hasidic culture, and to the Hasidic oral storytelling tradition, would have begun in childhood – as it did for Buber. It is neither possible nor necessary to our study to establish whether and which titles by Martin Buber Schulz himself may have read though it is likely that he would have read Die Geschichten des
Ecstasy and Heresy: Buber, Schulz, and Jewish Modernity
37
Rabbi Nachman (Tales of Rabbi Nachman, 1906)5 or discussions in periodicals concerning Buber’s presentation of Hasidic philosophy, as so many of his generation did. More importantly, however, in negotiating his relationship to Hasidic culture and choosing to build his poetics and many of the most powerful images in his stories around a re-working of aspects of Hasidic culture, Schulz reveals sympathy with the wider trend within the Jewish intellectual community that Buber pioneered. It is my conviction, then, that this context of fin de siècle Orientalism – in particular the positive reinterpretation of Jewish mysticism, Hasidic legend and myth, and a perception of the vital and heretical elements of the Jewish spirit – can help us to situate Schulz’s uses of elements from these Jewish traditions. As I will suggest, Schulz’s prose works and poetic theory can be read as a modernist – at times irreverent – literary answer to the call that Buber made to his generation. Ecstasy and Heresy: Making the World “God-Real” What were the specific elements of that call, as Buber formulated them in his early lectures, and in the introductions to his two most widely-read collections of Hasidic tales? I will summarize here a number of key elements and also suggest points of overlap between Buber’s discussion and Schulz’s poetics. Essentially, Buber identifies the need for a revived perception of “unity” in the world and connects the search for authentic life with an innate striving to restore a lost unity, or original state of wholeness. He understands this “striving for unity” as the most elemental drive in mankind and that which connects him to the Divine. Schulz’s poetics also adopts this basic premise but mapped onto the field of language and the Word. If for Buber “being” is in a state of duality, for Schulz it is language that is splintered, in shards, and longs to be restored to its home in myth. 5
Also influential and widely read were the three essays on Hasidic thought which were published in this edition (Buber 1906) and provide an introduction to the Tales: ‘Die jüdische Mystik’, ‘Rabbi Nachman von Bratzlaw’ and ‘Worte des Rabbi Nachman’. Numerous other editions of Buber’s works on Hasidism were also available before the mid-1930s, including Buber 1908, 1918, 1930 and 1935. In a 1903 album profiling a number of modern Jewish artists that was edited by Buber, he already makes reference to the significance of Hasidic tradition for the modern or “new” Jewish artist.
38
Karen Underhill
Buber writes: “The Orient perceives that […] the primally intended unity is split and distorted; […] Man is called upon to change being from duality to unity. The world is waiting for man, to be unified by him” (1967: 62). And Schulz writes, in ‘Mityzacja rzeczywistoci’ (‘The Mythologizing of Reality’): Sowo w potocznym dziesiejszym znaczeniu jest ju tylko fragmentem, rudymentem jakiej dawnej wszechobejmuj cej, integralnej mitologii. Dlatego jest w nim d no do odrastania, do regeneracji, do uzupeniania si w peny sens. […] Poezja odpoznaje te sensy stracone, przywraca sowom ich miejsce, czy je wedug dawnych znacze. U poety sowo opami tuje si niejako na swój sens istotny, rozkwita i rozwija si
spontanicznie […] odzyskuje sw integralno. (Op 385) (The word in its common usage today is only a fragment, remnant of some former all-embracing, integral mythology. That is why it possesses a tendency to grow back, to regenerate and complete itself in full meaning. […] Poetry recognizes these lost meanings, restores words to their places, connects them by the old semantics. In the poet’s mind, the word remembers, so to speak, its essential meaning, blossoms, unfolds spontaneously […] regains its wholeness; Schulz 1998: 372)
Buber describes a particular type of individual (variously described as the Oriental, the Jew, the mystic) who is open and susceptible to the perception of that authenticity and wholeness. Such an individual experiences a call or command, in the form of an ecstatic revelation that manifests itself viscerally, as light, color, and a sense of the intense interconnectedness of all things in the physical world. He is a person – in one of his stranger formulations Buber calls him the motorischer-mensch or “motor-type man” – for whom all of the senses are interconnected. Schulz’s particular poetics, so full of synaesthesia, rich layers of metaphor and metonymy, and the permanent mutability of forms, offers an excellent corollary in prose of the type of perception that Buber discusses. For Buber, the individual who is gifted with such perception experiences it as a “demand”: he takes on the burden, as a life task, of working to express his perception of that unity and divine presence. Similarly, young Joseph in ‘Ksi ga’ (‘The Book’) states: “I knew then that The Book [the Authentic] is a postulate, that it is a goal. I carried upon my shoulders the burden of a great mission” (TF 129; “Wiedziaem, e Ksi ga jest postulatem, e jest zadaniem. Czuem na barkach ci ar wielkiego posannictwa”; Op 118). For Buber, the revelation experienced by the ecstatic can be
Ecstasy and Heresy: Buber, Schulz, and Jewish Modernity
39
described as a “God image”; and it is this that is captured in true myth. He writes: Myth, where it really is myth and therefore different from and greater than fable, is an account not imagined by man but impressed upon him, impressed, that is, upon that human being who is alive with a burning sense of color and shape. (1967: 6)
Schulz’s ‘The Book’, together with the story ‘Genialna Epoka’ (‘The Age of Genius’), in which the protagonist experiences his ecstatic initiation into the life of the artist, again provides a modernist poetic rendition of these elements of Buber’s discussion. In his ecstatic state of heightened perception, the young Joseph experiences an intensity of color and shape, an invasion of brightness – literally, he has “a burning sense of color and shape”: [W]skazuj c na sup ognisty, na zot belk , która tkwia ukonie w powietrzu, jak zadra, i nie daa si zepchn – pena blasku i kr cych w niej pyów – krzyczaem: – Wydrzyj j , wyrwij! […] wyci gni tymi, wydu onymi palcami pokazywaem […] wypr ony jak drogowskaz i dr cy w ekstazie. (Op 131) (Pointing to the column of fire, a golden bar that shot through the air like a splinter and would not disappear – full of brightness and spiraling dust specks – I cried: “Tear it out, tear it out!” […] I stood rigid like a signpost, with outstretched, elongated fingers […] hand trembling in ecstasy; TF 141)
Buber presents the heritage of Jewish myth and legend as a powerful expression of the “unitary spirit”. Myth for him is “the living force of God-consciousness” (1967). But crucially, Buber emphasizes that true, living myth is that which has always escaped – as heresy, mysticism, or oral, folk tradition – from the calcifying and deadening effects of organized religion and institutions. It exists in the margins, as it were, of the tradition and of the texts. In one paean to the power of subterranean myth in Judaism, he writes: To be sure, rabbinism, in its blind zeal to build a fence around Judaism, endeavored to restore a faith in God that was “purified” of myth; but the result of this endeavor was a miserable homunculus. And this homunculus was the eternal exilarch: it held sway over the galut generations; under its tyranny the living force of Jewish God-consciousness, myth, had to lock itself in the tower of the Kabbalah, or hide behind the women’s distaff, or
40
Karen Underhill flee from the walls of the ghetto into the world. It was tolerated as an esoteric doctrine, or scorned as superstition, or banished as heresy, until Hasidism established it on a throne, a throne of a short day’s duration, from which it was pushed down to slink around, like a beggar, in our melancholy dreams. (1967: 100)
We are reminded of Schulz’s principle question: “Where is Truth to shelter, where is it it to find asylum if not in a place where nobody is looking for it: in fairground calendars and almanacs, in the canticles of beggars and tramps…” (TF 189; “Gdzie ma schroni si wykl ta, gdzie znale asylum, jeli nie tam, gdzie jej nikt nie szuka – w jarmarcznych kalendarzach i komeniuszach, w tych ebraczych i dziadowskich kantyczkach…”; Op 189). Buber’s tirade against rabbinism is strongly reminiscent of Schulz’s opposition in ‘Wiosna’ (‘Spring’), between the prosaic world of Franz Joseph, and the Divine and heretical power of the stamp album. Where Buber speaks in religious categories, Schulz maps this ostensibly Jewish tradition of “heretical mythmaking” onto the realm of secular, modernist – and Polish – literature. Whereas Buber sets the vital regenerative power of Hasidic myth and legend in opposition to the rabbinic authorities, in ‘Spring’ it is the appearance of the stamp album on the scene – an incarnation of Schulz’s “authentic” – that offers Joseph escape from the suffocating domination of Franz Joseph’s world of prose: Ale gdy ju wi zienie zamyka si nieodwoalnie, gdy ostatni otwór jest zamurowany, gdy wszystko sprzysi go si , a eby ci przemilcze, o Bo e, gdy Franciszek Józef I zatarasowa, zalepi ostatni szpar , a eby ci nie dojrzano, wtedy powstae w szumi cym paszczu mórz i kontynentów i kam mu zadae. Ty, Bo e, wzi e wtedy na siebie odium herezji i wybuchn e na wiat tym ogromnym kolorowym i wspaniaym blunierstwem. O herezjarcho wspaniay! Uderzye wtedy we mnie t pon c ksi g […] (Op 156) (But when the prison seemed irrevocably shut, when the last bolt-hole was bricked up, when everything had conspired to keep silent about You, Oh God, when Franz Joseph had barred and sealed even the last chink so that one should not be able to see You, then You rose wearing a flowing cloak of seas and continents and gave him the lie. You, God, took upon yourself the odium of heresy and revealed this enormous, magnificent, colourful blasphemy to the world. Oh splendid Heresiarch! You struck me with the burning book […]; TF 159-60)
Ecstasy and Heresy: Buber, Schulz, and Jewish Modernity
41
The heretic, for Buber (the Baal Shem Tov, eighteenthcentury founder of Hasidism being the best example) is privileged as the true purveyor of what is vital in the tradition, as the true prophet. Schulz’s prophet, too, may be a madman, a criminal, a child, but he speaks from the margins, from outside of power. Buber also emphasizes the concept, drawn from Hasidic philosophy, that truth is to be found in the low places: “Revelation”, he writes, “does not flash from the cloud, but from the lowly things themselves; it whispers to us in the course of the ordinary every day, and it is alive quite near us, quite close” (1967: 6). Summarizing his call in the Preface to the 1923 edition of collected essays Reden über das Judentum (Essays on Judaism), Buber writes: We ought to understand that to “realize God” means to prepare the world for God, as a place for His reality – to help the world become God-real (gottwirklich); it means, in other and sacred words, to make reality one. This is our service in the Kingdom’s becoming. Are we capable of that much? (1967: 9)
In the sense that Buber uses it, participating in the work of making the world “God-real” means participating, through one’s deeds, in the repair of a broken or divided universe. For Buber, this means not only to be open to the perception of the unity of all being, but also most importantly to strive to make that unity a reality in the world. He writes, “the unified world must not only be conceived, it must be realized. It is not merely given to man, it is given to him as a task; he is charged with making the true world an actual world” (1967: 60; emphasis mine). For Schulz, working in the realm of literature, the task of the poet is likewise to make the “true” world exist again, to bring it into being through his act of poetry. This is precisely what he calls for in ‘The Mythologizing of Reality’: a reconnection with the authentic and originary state of language and myth – sens ‘meaning’ – through a poetic transformation of the everyday into timeless myth; a bringing of the divine or primordial world, of mythic perception, into experience in time, in the modern world. If the concept of an actual divine or of God has ceded its place in Schulz’s work to the spirit that lies in the “Authentic”, or in true myth, then this poetic practice is precisely the writer’s enactment of the call to “make the world Godreal”.
42
Karen Underhill
Remythologization and Modernity: Divergent Paths As we have seen, both Buber and Schulz see the remythologization of reality as central to their literary and philosophical work; and they both undertake a modern revival and transformation of Jewish myth, particularly drawn from Hasidic lore and kabbalah. However, their work represents two opposed poles with regard to the final form that the movement of Jewishness into modernity will take: a centripetal vs. a centrifugal motion, respectively; the concentration of ethnically and nationally-determined mythic elements (Buber) vs. (Schulz) their dispersal into a universalist narrative landscape filled with remnants from the myths of many, disparate cultures. Within Jewish art and letters of Eastern and Central Europe, the connection between mythical consciousness and nationalism (the embracing of myth as part of the construction of ethnic and national self-consciousnesses) also had its place in the imagery and cultural expressions of Zionism. Indeed, Martin Buber’s own turn to Cultural Zionism, his work to rehabilitate Jewish myth and symbolism and employ their power in attracting others to the Zionist movement, represents a participation in neo-romantic, myth-based affirmations of ethnic identity taking place throughout Central Europe. Schulz, however, engages myth in a very different way. He uses the revaluation of myth and mythic consciousness specifically not to reaffirm connection to or identification with a specific ethnic or national tradition, or to show the continuity of that tradition from the historical present to a time in the past on the same soil, for example. On the contrary, in Schulz’s work the move to mythologize reflects the desire, the will, to step out of ethnic and historical bonds and boundaries. It becomes a strategy, or a dream, to escape ethnic identification, to build a space – narrative, artistic, philosophical – of meaning in the modern world that precisely transcends ethnic divisions and historical realities. As Schulz wrote of his first book, Sklepy cynamonowe (Cinnamon Shops), “This book, however, is not a repository of a mythology culturally grounded in res gestae, bearing the stamp of history” (Schulz 1998a: 412-413). This mythic space is instead a narrative space of belonging in language; it is a textual homeland that eschews historical or political realities, or materials, or operates alongside them. Schulz’s prose exists in an oneiric borderland of its own creation, which – not unlike the narrative spaces
Ecstasy and Heresy: Buber, Schulz, and Jewish Modernity
43
of Franz Kafka – also depends for its mythic resonance on the erasure of any one culture. In a line from Schulz’s ‘Republika marze’ (‘The Republic of Dreams’), the countryside of his narrator’s childhood, or of his dreams, becomes “no man’s land, or God’s land” (Op 329; “kraj ju niczyj i bo y”; Schulz 1998b: 269):6 W tych dniach dalekich powzi limy po raz pierwszy z kolegami ow myl niemo liw i absurdaln , a eby pow drowa jeszcze dalej, poza zdrojowisko, w kraj ju niczyj i bo y, w pogranicze sporne i neutralne, gdzie gubiy si rubie e pastw, a ró a wiatrów wirowaa b dnie pod niebem wysokim i spi trzonym. (Op 329) (In those far-off days our gang of boys hit on the outlandish and impossible notion of straying even further, beyond that inn, into no man’s or God’s land, of patrolling borders both neutral and disputed, where boundary-lines petered out and the compass role of the winds skittered erratically under a high-arching sky; CW 269)
Where it diverges from Buber’s, I suggest that Schulz’s conception of myth accords closely with that of Thomas Mann, whose work, in particular his mythic novel Joseph und seine Brüder (Joseph and His Brothers, 1933-43), had a great influence on Schulz.7 It is in ‘Spring’ that Schulz most fully develops the idea of a genealogy that circumvents history, ethnicity, and cultural specificity by invoking the idea of a universally accessible realm of myth. In his essay for Stanisaw Ignacy Witkiewicz he writes: Do jakiego rodzaju nale Sklepy cynamonowe […] S one autobiografi albo raczej genealogi duchow , genealogi kat’ exochen, gdy ukazuj rodowód duchowy a do tej g bi, gdzie uchodzi on w mitologi , gdzie gubi si w mitologicznym majaczeniu. Zawsze czuem, e korzenie indywidualnego ducha, dostatecznie daleko w g b cigane, gubi si w mitycznym jakim mateczniku. To jest dno ostateczne, poza które niepodobna juz wyj. (Op 446) (To what genre does Cinnamon Shops belong? The work is […] a spiritual genealogy, a genealogy par excellence in that it follows the spiritual family tree down to those depths where it merges into mythology, to be
6
All further references will be given as CW. As Ficowski writes, “Schulz’s admiration for Mann’s Joseph und seine Brüder (1933-43) knew no bounds, and tributes to it occurred frequently in his conversations and letters. Schulz regarded Mann as the greatest writer among his contemporaries and knew his works from many readings in the original” (in Schulz 1998a: 475). 7
44
Karen Underhill lost in the mutterings of mythological delirium. I have always felt that the roots of the individual spirit, traced far enough down, would be lost in some matrix of myth. This is the ultimate depth; it is impossible to reach further down; CW 370)
What Schulz seeks in this line of thought is to affirm a genealogy of the spirit and of creative energy or ferment – a storyteller’s and poet’s genealogy – that draws on a timeless magma or humus of human culture that is otherwise envisioned as a perpetual eating of the dead, a journey into the underworld: Teraz dopiero widzimy na czym wiosna ronie […] oto s ciepe jeszcze groby, próchno i mierzwa. Prastare historie. […] Tu s te kolumbaria, te szuflady na umarych, w których le zaschni ci, czarni jak korzenie i czekaj na swój czas. (Op 158-159) (It is only now we realize what the soil is on which Spring thrives […] Here are graves that are still warm, the litter, and the rot. Age-old tales. […] Here are columbaria, the drawers for the dead, in which they lie dessicated, blackened like roots, awaiting their moment.; TF 168)
These references to the underworld resonate strongly with Thomas Mann’s invitation into the underworld that prefaces his revisitation of the biblical story of Joseph und seine Brüder (Joseph and His Brothers, 1934). “Very deep is the well of the past”, he writes in the opening to the first volume, entitled ‘Vorspiel: Höllenfahrt’ (‘Prelude: Descent into Hell’): Shall we not call it bottomless? […] For the deeper we sound, the further down into the lower world of the past we probe and press, the more do we find that the earliest foundations of humanity, its history and culture, reveal themselves unfathomable. No matter to what hazardous lengths we let out our line they still withdraw again, and further, into the depths. (1999: 3)
Once again, Schulz’s concerted attempts to articulate this prehistorical genealogy also say something about his complex and uneasy relationship with Jewishness. They represent a choice as an artist to openly distance himself from his own “real”, historical, and culturally specific genealogy. In his 1935 essay for S.I. Witkiewicz, cited above, Schulz continues:
Ecstasy and Heresy: Buber, Schulz, and Jewish Modernity
45
Mann pokazuje, jak na dnie wszystkich zdarze ludzkich, gdy wyuska je z plewy czasu i wieloci, ukazuj si pewne praschematy, “historie”, na których te zdarzenia formuj si w wielkich powtórzeniach. U Manna s to historie biblijne, odwieczne mity Babilonii i Egiptu. Ja staraem si w skromniejszej mej skali odnale wasn , prywatn mitologi , wasne “historie”, wasny mityczny rodowód. Tak jak staro ytni wyprowadzali swych przodków z mitologicznych ma estw z bogami, tak uczyniem prób statuowania dla siebie jakiej mitycznej generacji antenatów, fikcyjnej rodziny, z której wywodz mój ród prawdziwy. (Op 446; italics mine) (Mann shows that beneath all human events, when the chaff of time and individual variation is blown away, certain primeval patterns, “stories”, are found, by which these events form and re-form in great repeating pulses. For Mann, these are the biblical tales, the timeless myths of Babylon and Egypt. On my more modest scale I have attempted to uncover my own private mythology, my own “stories”, my own mythic family tree. Just as the ancients traced their ancestry from mythical unions with gods, so I undertook to establish for myself some mythical generation of forebears, a fictitious family from which I trace my true descent; Schulz 1998a: 370; italics mine)
Conclusion This last is a complex and dense statement of confession. Far from reflecting a simple movement away from Jewish identification, which the above testimony and others seem to imply, Schulz’s specific form of deracinated, de-historicized myth reflects an unexpected reaffirmation and recuperation of Jewish identification, a vital sublimation of Jewish content and of Jewish genealogy. In negotiating this relationship with tradition Schulz can be seen to engage in a storyteller’s sleight-of-hand, producing a storytelling mechanism not unlike the chess-playing puppet described by Walter Benjamin in his “Theses on the Philosophy of History” (also: “On the Concept of History”, “Über den Begriff der Geschichte”, 1939, published posthumously). In Benjamin’s allegory, a mechanical figure dressed in Turkish attire, at a chess table, consistently plays a winning game, operated from within by a hunchbacked dwarf who is hidden from the sight of the audience. For Benjamin, the successful chess-player, which represents historical materialism, is triumphant only because it “enlists the services of theology, which today, as we know, is wizened and has to keep out of sight” (1968: 253). I would suggest that in Schulz’s breathtakingly original literary performance, Jewishness
46
Karen Underhill
functions similarly to the hunchback, theology, in Benjamin’s parable. On the one hand, Schulz pushes Jewishness to the margins and proclaims it dead, banishing direct discussion of it from the body of the text. On the other hand, his entire oeuvre works to enshrine precisely marginality, and the Underworld – the land of the dead. Thus, in Schulz’s work we confront both the subtle identification of Jewishness with death, marginality and misshapenness, and the constant recuperation of that which is marginal – of the scrapheap or the shards – and of that which is dead, abandoned, or decayed, lying in the tomb awaiting its own Spring (waiting for the living, hungry poet to digest it and make it part of his present). Schulz’s hope for poetic and artistic relevance, and for authenticity of perception and expression, centers around adoration of the Underworld and the margin as the sources of creative energy and, indeed, of life energy. We are reminded once again of Buber’s claim that true myth, in the Jewish tradition, has always been pushed to the margins, “to slink around, like a beggar, in our melancholy dreams”. I would like to conclude by suggesting that in an unexpected fashion, Schulz’s prose bolsters this claim and even adds itself to Buber’s noble lineage of heretics – perhaps precisely there, where his use of myth diverges most strongly from Buber’s own. Bibliography Benjamin, Walter. 1968. ‘Theses on the Philosophy of History’ in Sontag, Susan (ed.) Illuminations. New York: Schocken: 253-264. Boski, Jan. 1994. ‘wiat jako ksi ga i komentarz’ in Jarz bski 1994: 68-84. Buber, Martin. 1906. Die Geschichten des Rabbi Nachman. Frankfurt am Main: Rütten & Loening. ——. 1908. Die Legende des Baalschem. Frankfurt am Main: Rütten & Loening. ——. 1918. Mein Weg zum Chassidismus. Irinnerungen. Frankfurt am Main: Rütten & Loening. ——. 1930. Hundert chassidische Geschichten. Berlin: Schocken Verlag. ——. 1935. Deutung des Chassidismus. Berlin: Schocken Verlag. ——. 1967. On Judaism (ed. N.M. Glatzer). New York: Schocken Books. Buber, Martin (ed.) 1903. Juedische Kuenstler. Berlin: Juedischer Verlag. Goldfarb, David A. 1994. ‘A Living Schulz: “Noc Wielkiego Sezonu” (“The Night of the Great Season”)’ in Prooftexts: A Journal of Jewish Literary History 14(1): 25-48. ——. 1997. ‘The Vortex and the Labyrinth: Bruno Schulz and the Objective Correlative’ in East European Politics and Societies 11(1): 257-269. Harshav, Benjamin. 1993. Language in Time of Revolution. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Ecstasy and Heresy: Buber, Schulz, and Jewish Modernity
47
Jarz bski, Jerzy (ed.) 1994. Czytanie Schulza: Materiay midzynarodowej sesji naukowej Bruno Schulz – w stulecie urodzin i w pidziesiciolecie mierci, Instytut Filologii Polskiej Uniwersytetu Jagielloskiego, Kraków, 8-10 czerwca 1992. Kraków: T.I.C. Lindenbaum, Shalom. 1994. ‘Wizja mesjanistyczna Schulza i jej podo e mistyczne’ in Jarz bski (1994): 33-67. Mann, Thomas. 1999. Joseph and His Brothers (tr. H.T. Lowe-Porter). London: Vintage. Mendes-Flohr, Paul. 1991. Divided Passions: Jewish Intellectuals and the Experience of Modernity. Detroit: Wayne State University Press. Panas, Wadysaw. 1997. Ksiga Blasku: traktat o kabale w prozie Brunona Schulza. Lublin: Towarzystwo Naukowe Katolickiego Uniwersytetu Lubelskiego. Prokop-Janiec, Eugenia. 1994. ‘Schulz a galicyjski tygiel kultur’ in Jarz bski (1994): 95-107. Schaeder, Grete. 1973. The Hebrew Humanism of Martin Buber (tr. N. J. Jacobs). Detroit: Wayne State University Press. Schulte, Jörg. 2003. ‘Wielka Kronika Kalendarza’ in Kitowska-ysiak, Magorzata and Wadysaw Panas (eds). W uamkach zwierciada…Bruno Schulz w 110 rocznic urodzin i 60 rocznic mierci. Lublin: Towarzystwo Naukowe KUL: 163-172. Schulz, Bruno. 1988. The Fictions of Bruno Schulz (tr. C. Wieniewska). London: Picador. ——. 1989. Opowiadania, wybór esejów i listów (ed. J. Jarz bski). Wrocaw: Zakad Narodowy im. Ossolinskich. ——. 1998a. ‘A Description of the Book Cinnamon Shops’ in Schulz (1998b): 412414. ——. 1998b. The Collected Works of Bruno Schulz (ed. J. Ficowski). London: Picador. Shallcross, Bozena. 1997. ‘Fragments of a Broken Mirror: Bruno Schulz’s Retextualization of the Kabbalah’ in East European Politics and Societies 11(2): 270-285.
Exposing and Concealing Jewish Origin: Bruno Schulz and Bolesaw Lemian Andrea Meyer-Fraatz Abstract: Bruno Schulz and Bolesaw Lemian are two Polish writers of Jewish origin who deal differently with that fact in their works. Lemian only implicitly reflects his double identity of an assimilated Polish poet by referring to oriental themes. Hiding behind his texts, he represents a typically modernist author. Schulz exposes his Jewish origin, and as an avant-garde author he creates a recognizable alter ego in his texts. Creating an esoteric layer, he writes for a Jewish in-group while at the same time representing a Jewish avant-garde for a broader public.
Introduction Bruno Schulz has been compared more than once to his older contemporary Bolesaw Lemian. Besides many differences, there are plenty of parallels in their poetics and philosophical background, some of which have already been analyzed by various researchers. Czesaw Karkowski (1978), for example, discussed Lemian’s and Schulz’s reference to Bergson. Herta Schmid (1998) compared their theories on poetic language and their relationship to myth, pointing out the differences, whereas Jerzy Jarz bski (1999: 119-120) underlined the similarity of their mythopoetics due to their teacher-disciple relationship, hinting at the fact that Schulz as a young man became acquainted with Lemian’s poetry and poetic writings in the bookshop of his colleague’s father, Mundek Pilpel (Jarz bski 1999: 33). Both Lemian and Schulz developed similar poetics: they are inclined to use bold metaphors; typical for both of them is the grotesque. They share common themes, such as depicting an abundant nature, fantastic or erotic motifs, and create worlds and myths of their own. Stefan Chwin (1994) worked out the similarities and differences in poetological and ontological respect when comparing Schulz and
50
Andrea Meyer-Fraatz
Lemian with regard to the motif of metamorphosis and the theme of creating worlds. Moreover, both of them are of Jewish origin and specifically deal with that fact in their works. This common biographical fact, however, forms at the same time a difference between the two authors. Whereas on the one hand Lemian created an “assimilated” poetry, saturated with motifs of Polish folk poetry, the depiction of Polish (or East European) landscapes and Christian themes, and did not expose any specific elements of Jewish culture or religion, in this way “concealing” his Jewish origin, Schulz on the other hand not only exposes Jewish themes but also creates a poetics which is based on Talmudic exegesis in a heretical way. This “poetics of revelation” (Schulte 2004), however, is only recognized by those who are familiar with Jewish tradition. My thesis is that Schulz on the one hand avoids the open treatment of Jewishness when he uses motifs (such as nature, outsiders, or eroticism) that he shares with Lemian, who concealed his Jewish origin. (Although such motifs in Schulz’s stories often contain hidden references to Jewish religious writings, they are known only to those who are acquainted with them). Schulz, on the other hand, exposes Jewish themes with regard to the father, calling him, for example, an Old Testament prophet on more than one occasion. In this last respect he differs from Lemian. In their disparate attitudes toward dealing with their Jewish origin in their texts, both of them stand for two different models of authorship. The following investigation will demonstrate this and at the end will attempt to explain the younger author’s relationship to the older one. Each author’s relationship to his Jewish origin and its treatment in their texts will be related to the problem of authorship, which in Lemian’s case is linked with orientalism, identity, and alterity and their correlation to modernism, and in Schulz’s case is linked to the positioning of his work in contemporary Polish literature in general.
Exposing and Concealing Jewish Origin: Schulz and Lemian
51
Bolesaw Lemian: Oriental Motifs as a Concealed Reflection of Jewishness Bolesaw Lemian was the first assimilated Polish poet of Jewish Origin writing for a Polish public in general.1 He was baptized and grew up in an assimilated family of the Warsaw bourgeoisie. During his lifetime he published, besides his theoretical writings and his fairy tales, three books of poetry: Sad rozstajny (Crossroads Orchard, 1912), ka (Meadow, 1920), and Napój cienisty (Shadowy Drink, 1936). The fourth volume, Dziejba lena (Forest Happenings) was published posthumously in 1938. His first book was published seventeen years after the first publication of a poem in a journal. Whereas other poets and a handful of critics appreciated his work, literary critics in general faulted it for nominally containing too many foreign influences; for example, one anonymous critic pointed out the similarity of Lemian’s poetry to the works of Baudelaire and Verlaine (cf. opuszaski 2000: 105). A rejection of the poet’s works as strange to the Polish public can be interpreted as a hidden form of anti-Semitism: ignoring the fact that there are many references to Polish romanticism and contemporary Polish poetry, Lemian’s work is suggested to be French rather than Polish, i.e. not to be rooted in Polish culture.2 Rochelle Stone (1976: 22-27) notes other critical harassments against Lemian: for example, Brzozowski’s attacks against Lemian’s nominally epigonic modernism. Obviously, the critics transfer a biographical fact to the author and thus to a literary fact, so the assimilated poet who wrote “assimilated” poetry is actually judged by his origin and not by his work. In a certain sense, Lemian himself transfers the problem of his twofold identity as a 1
Although there have been minor poets of Jewish origin since the nineteenth century, “the presence of these authors in the Polish literature of the 19th century is only of documental significance. Outstanding Polish writers of Jewish origin appear only in the 20th century” (“obecno tych pisarzy w literaturze polskiej XIX wieku ma znaczenie jedynie dokumentalne. Wybitni pisarze polscy pochodzenia ydowskiego pojawiaj si dopiero w XX wieku” ; Panas 1996: 18). Interestingly enough, Panas investigates only Jewish authors who deal with Jewish themes and consequently does not mention Lemian at all in his monograph on the problems of Jewishness. 2 Rochelle Stone (1976: 147-181) thoroughly demonstrates the relationship of Lemian’s poetry to contemporary Russian symbolism and thus explains his strangeness to Polish readers.
52
Andrea Meyer-Fraatz
baptized Jew to his work, to his “double” (“sobowtór”, cf. Przybylski 1987), the implied author. In general, references to Jewish culture or religion can hardly be identified in Lemian’s poetry. An exception might be found in the “heretical” long poem ‘Eliasz’ (‘Eliah’) in Shadowy Drink, but the prophet Eliah is not only important for Jewish messianism but also in Christian tradition and folklore. The title ‘Kabaa’ (‘Fortune-Telling’) in Crossroads Orchard does not directly refer to Jewish mysticism. The word means “fortune-telling”, and the text does not support a link to Jewish tradition. All other texts refer to Polish or Ukrainian folklore, to myths of various origins, and to the New Testament, first and foremost the Birth of Christ as in ‘ ka’ (‘Meadow’) or ‘Betleem’ (‘Bethlehem’), though in both cases it is in a syncretistic and heretical way. A reflection of the author’s own double identity can be established only implicitly. This problem is related to motifs of metamorphosis, doubling, and to oriental themes; the motif of doubling and oriental themes appear to be related. In Lemian’s first book of poems there are two texts referring to the tales of the Arabian Nights – ‘Sidi-Numan’ and ‘Nieznana podró Sindbada-eglarza’ (‘Sindbad the Sailor’s Unknown Journey’); in the following year Lemian published his adaptations of tales of the Arabian Nights for children: Przygody Sindbada- eglarza (Sindbad the Sailor’s Adventures, 1913) and Klechdy Sezamowe (Old Tales of Sesame, 1913). In several respects these texts can be understood as a sublimation of the author’s dual identity. On the one hand, there are thematic elements: for example, the question of the equality of all religions in ‘Rybak i geniusz’ (‘The Fisher and the Genius’) and ‘Opowiadanie króla Wysp Hebanowych’ (‘The Story of the King of the Ebony Islands’). Uncle Tarabuk in Sindbad the Sailor’s Adventures, Lemian’s own invention which does not correspond with the tales of Sindbad in the original of Arabian Nights, can be understood as the author’s ironic self-portrait: like the real author who for many years had not been able to publish a book, his character discovers various unconventional methods of saving his graphomaniacal verse, one after the other turning out to be useless, but does not publish them as a book. Moreover, Uncle Tarabuk’s calembours and neologisms are typical for Lemian’s own poetic language.
Exposing and Concealing Jewish Origin: Schulz and Lemian
53
On the other hand, characters with a dualistic conception represent the author’s dual identity: for example, the girl in ‘Sindbad the Sailor’s Unknown Journey’, the last long narrative poem of Crossroads Orchard. Every morning and every evening she changes the colour of her hair and her eyes, representing thus an “oriental” and an “occidental” identity, which is underlined by the paraphrase of “East”, “od wschodu soca” (“from sunrise”; 1965: 103). When the lyrical subject kills her at the end of the poem, only her black hair continues growing. The poem can be understood as a nightmare in which the implied author tries to kill one part of his identity and to expose the other, namely the “oriental” one. The whole poem does not share much more than the title with the oriental tales of the Arabian Nights. The depicted landscape is more similar to East and Middle European landscapes than to oriental ones. Exposing typical traits of Lemian’s work in general, ‘Sindbad the Sailor’s Unknown Journey’ represents the Orient as something familiar rather than as something strange. The same applies to the poem ‘Sidi-Numan’ of the cycle ‘Poematy zazdrosne’ (‘Jealous poems’). The underlying narrative is based on the Arabian Nights, but Lemian added significant changes which integrate the story and the poem into his own work. Traits which could be interpreted as “orientalistic” in the notion of Edward Said (1978), for example, cruelty, sensuality, sexual mania, abundance, are at the same time typical of movements such as symbolism and decadence, to which Lemian’s poetry belongs. Ironic, self-conscious phrases at the same time create a personal distance and are a means of overcoming the modernist tendencies of Young Poland literature. Oriental themes in the first book of poems and in the fairy tales for children are indebted to a current tendency of the time. Lemian, however, does not represent the Orient as something strange but as something of his own; he identifies with the oriental traits of his work and represents himself as something exotic, thus subverting a common anti-Semitic cliché. Parallels can be found in Polish culture as well as in other European cultures. The Polish painter of Jewish origin Maurycy Gottlieb, for example, in 1876 created a self-portrait titled Ahasver, showing an “oriental”-looking man. The German poet of Jewish origin Else Lasker-Schüler created a fantastic Orient in her novels Die Nächte der Tino von Bagdad (Tino of Bagdad’s Nights, 1907) or Der Prinz von Theben (The Prince of Thebes, 1914) which serve as an expression of her Jewish identity in the German literary
54
Andrea Meyer-Fraatz
scene.3 Last but not least, in 1948, Marc Chagall illustrated the Arabian Nights and chose texts mainly of Jewish origin (cf. Chagall 1999). This aesthetic practice corresponds to a discourse founded by Martin Buber and other Prague Jews, who appealed against assimilation and postulated an “oriental” way of life around 1910 (cf. Berman 1996: 281-286). Although Lemian lived in Poland where unassimilated Hasidism dominated, he belonged to an assimilated family and tried to conceal his Jewish origin. The identification with oriental themes can be understood as a means of concealed reflection with the dual identity which was imposed on him by his origin and by the society in which he lived. The “oriental” texts belong to the first book of poems, which was published almost at the same time as the oriental fairy tales. In the first and last book of poems, the texts containing a sublimed discussion of the author’s dual identity are positioned at the end and therefore in an exposed position. Lemian who carefully conceived his books of poems as meta-cycles cannot have done this by chance. The first book of poems was published long after the author’s debut as a poet. Dual oppositions that are overcome by a “third” element are characteristic of the second book of poems, Meadow, which seems to present the possibility of overcoming the problem of dual identity. The book finds the resolution in poetry which lasts forever and triumphs over the dualism of soul and body (cf. Meyer-Fraatz 2000). The dualistic motifs, however, are again insurmountable in the third book of poems, Shadowy Drink, which is dominated by a pessimistic, melancholic tone. The motif of death is implicitly expressed by the adjective cienisty ‘shadowy’ in the title and is reinforced in the ultimate poem which is about the doubling of a man who is unable to eradicate his doppelganger until his own death. This poem is preceded by ‘Eliah’, the only text with an identifiable Jewish (but also Christian) subject, even though it is treated in a heretical way because Eliah wants to eliminate God. Similarly the motif of metamorphosis represents the changing of identity. This is best shown in the poem ‘Akteon’ from the cycle ‘Postacie’ (‘Characters’) in Shadowy Drink. ‘Akteon’ is the only poem referring to Greek mythology. In the first stanza, the story of Akteon’s metamorphosis into a stag is narrated in the third person, whereas the 3
Cf. Berman (1996: 291-345) for a detailed analysis of Else Lasker-Schüler’s “oriental” works as an expression of Jewish identity.
Exposing and Concealing Jewish Origin: Schulz and Lemian
55
second stanza represents the words of the stag himself who feels like a human. In both stanzas it is stated that it is awful to die in a shape other than the primordial one. In this way, the motif of metamorphosis is another way of concealing the consciousness of Lemian’s dual identity.4 Despite both Lemian’s election to the Literary Academy and the “Golden Laurel” the Academy conferred to him, his situation in the mid-thirties when his third book of poems was published had not really improved. The circumstances of his death in 1937 confirm this judgement: although as a member of the Academy he should have received a national funeral and have been represented in the Alley of Honor, this was not the case. A number of documents prove that the act of disrespecting his rights as a Member of the Academy was motivated by anti-Semitism.5 As an author Lemian reacted to his complicated situation implicitly through his work. Reflecting his dual identity by using oriental motifs and by creating dual characters, he hides behind his texts. This is typical for modernist authors, as the Swiss Slavicist Felix Philipp Ingold (1992) has demonstrated. In a certain sense, Lemian’s situation is comparable to that of the Russian poet Pasternak: both of them are poets of Jewish origin but baptized, and both of them hide behind their texts as modernist authors.6 Moreover, it is typical that the modernist author does not live on his poetry (cf. Ingold 1989). Lemian was not able to earn his living by writing poetry; he was forced to work as a lawyer. Another proof that he separated poetry from “ordinary” life is his choice to adopt the phonetically similar Polish surname Lemian for the poet, whereas the man and lawyer until the end of his life bore the original name Lesman (cf. Rymkiewicz 2001: 238-239). Lemian’s concealment of his Jewish identity thus coheres with the modernist author’s attitude to his own work.
4
Chwin (1994: 114) names Lemian’s poem ‘Przemiany’ (‘Changes’) as a model for Schulz. 5 Stone (1976: 11) even mentions that Lemian’s body lay unburied for weeks because the Academy denied him the funeral honours. 6 As for Pasternak, however, his Jewishness does not form a part of the relation between author and text (cf. Ingold 1992: 175-194).
56
Andrea Meyer-Fraatz
Bruno Schulz: Exposing Jewishness as Avant-Garde Although Bruno Schulz, like Lemian, grew up in an assimilated, Polish-speaking family, he in no way conceals his Jewish origin in his texts. On the contrary, there are many details in his texts which expose this fact. Unlike Lemian, Schulz did not live in the capital but on the Galician periphery in the small town of Drohobycz, where Hasidic traditions were dominant. Although it is doubtful that Schulz spoke Yiddish, he understood the language because of his profound knowledge of German, and he was familiar with the Jewish tradition. He learnt Hebrew and even met a Zaddik in the 1930s. Although he was not religious, his literary work proves his knowledge of the rabbinic tradition (cf. Schulte 2004). Plenty of books and articles deal with the Jewish element in Schulz’s prose: first and foremost literary critics are concerned with Hasidism, messianism, mysticism, gnosis, kabbalah (Lewi 1989; Kaków 1992; Lachmann 1992, 1999, 2002; Goldfarb 1993; Shallcross 1997; Panas 1997, 2001; Sproede 2000). Stala (1993) links Schulz’s creation of various realities to Jewish philosophers; MeyerFraatz (2001, 2005) and with profound judaistic knowledge, Schulte (2004) interpret Schulz’s cycles by means of traditional Talmudic exegesis. As for Schulz’s graphical works, Jewish elements have been discussed by Panas (2001) and Sikorski (2004) and by Van Heuckelom (2006) with regard to iconoclasm. As previously mentioned, there are two ways of representing Jewish elements in Schulz’s texts. On the one hand, they exhibit Jewish motifs as prophets and the Messiah; on the other hand, there are hidden hints toward Jewish religious texts and exegetic practices, which are recognizable only to those who are acquainted with them. Unlike the explicit thematizations of Jewishness, they are present throughout his prose; one example, is the underlying principle of the calendar described by Schulte (2004). This article does not intend to continue this kind of analysis, but instead tries to determine the function of Jewish elements in Bruno Schulz’s prose with regard to the implied as well as the real author. By understanding the exposition of Jewish origin as related to Schulz’s position in literary history, it will be possible to explain his attitude to Jewishness in his texts as contrary to Lemian’s.
Exposing and Concealing Jewish Origin: Schulz and Lemian
57
When Schulz started writing, poets of Jewish origin were no longer something special in Polish literature: Julian Tuwim, Antoni Lange, Aleksander Wat, Józef Wittlin, and others had followed Lemian into Polish literary life although as Henri Lewi points out, anti-Semitism was a crucial force in new independent Poland (1989: 54). Schulz was being promoted by Zofia Nakowska, one of the most influential Polish writers in the 1930s, and he had a close relationship with Stanisaw Ignacy Witkiewicz and Witold Gombrowicz, the most outstanding avant-garde writers at that time. Although Schulz became a writer more or less by chance, encouraged by his friend Debora Vogel to whom he sent his stories accompanying his letters, he was quickly accepted by the literary scene.7 His friend Romana Halpern, who lived in Warsaw, introduced him to people such as Witkacy, who became of great importance for him. In his study on Hasidism and avant-gardism in Schulz’s prose, Alfred Sproede (2000) states that Schulz is sceptical toward the avantgarde and uses Jewish elements in order to ridicule avant-garde literature. He understands Schulz’s stories, even though they show the author’s familiarity with avant-garde devices, as embodied in Hasidism and as a continuation of this tradition. My aim is to demonstrate that it is the opposite: Schulz uses Hasidic elements to expose or rather stage himself as a Jewish avant-garde author. This can be illustrated by the status of the real and the implied author in his texts. The implied author is the one who conceives the represented world of the narrative; using Ryszard Przybylski’s term (as I previously mentioned), the implied author is the author’s doppelganger in the text and is responsible for the occurrence of Jewish motifs such as prophets or the Messiah as well as for the esoteric references to the rabbinic tradition. Whereas the esoteric layer extends throughout the two cycles Sklepy cynamonowe (Cinnamon Shops, 1934) and Sanatorium pod klepsydr (Sanatorium Under the Sign of the Hourglass, 1937) as well as the stories which are not included in the cycles, it is not comprehensible for those who are not familiar with the Jewish tradition; Jewish motifs recognizable to everyone are mostly confined to the depiction of the father who is frequently characterized as weak, moribund, and eccentric at the same 7
This does not imply that he was accepted by all critics. Jarz bski (1999: 52) mentions anti-Semitic attacks by the right-wing critics of the 1930s.
58
Andrea Meyer-Fraatz
time. The most outstanding example seems to be the following: straddling the chamber pot, he is blasphemously compared to an Old Testament prophet – as in ‘Nawiedzenie’ (‘Visitation’). The noises of emptying his bladder and his gestures are interpreted as Moses’s dialogue with God on Sinai, culminating in the emptying of the chamber pot through the window. The heretical ‘Traktat o manekinach’ (‘Treatise on Tailors’ Dummies’), consisting of three parts, is called ‘Wtóra Ksi ga Rodzaju’ (‘The Second Book of Genesis’), and the father who plays the role of a demiurge is defeated each time by Adela, a character who has much in common with Lilith, Adam’s first wife who later becomes the wife of Satan (cf. Lachmann 1999: 142). In the last story of Cinnamon Shops, the father, once more compared to Moses on Sinai, creates an ephemeral world out of bales of cloth, a “fantastic Canaan” (Schulz 1989b: 91; “fantastyczny Kanaan”; Schulz 1989a: 99) containing wise Jews and prophets: Gdzie indziej stay grupy ydów w kolorowych chaatach, w wielkich futrzanych kopakach przed wysokimi wodospadami jasnych materyj. Byli to m owie Wielkiego Zgromadzenia, dostojni i peni namaszczenia panowie, piel gnowane brody i prowadz cy wstrzemi liwe i dyplomatyczne rozmowy. (1989a: 101) (In other places in front of the waterfalls of light fabric stood groups of Jews in coloured gabardines and tall fur hats. These were the gentlemen of the Great Congregation, distinguished and solemn men, striking their long well-groomed beards and holding sober and diplomatic discourse; 1989b: 92)
But at the end of the story, after the return of the birds, which the father bred under his roof and which Adela expelled in the story ‘Ptaki’ (‘Birds’), and their sudden death, the landscape vanishes and the father returns early in the morning to the kitchen where Adela is already – perhaps even triumphantly – grinding coffee. The father is characterized once more as a broken and defeated man who must capitulate in front of his satanic housekeeper and his subjects. Thus combining Jewish motifs with the world of the dying father, which is often depicted comically, this manner of exposing Jewishness attains an ironic touch. The esoteric layer of Jewish elements confirms an ironic treatment of the Jewish tradition: the underlying structure of an achronological calendar (cf. Schulte 2004), the structuring of the cycle after the principle of the Talmudic
Exposing and Concealing Jewish Origin: Schulz and Lemian
59
interpretation of the Book of Genesis, in which a “Pentateuch” is positioned at the end of the cycle (cf. Meyer-Fraatz 2005: 331). Also, the grotesque comparison between the father sitting on the chamber pot and Moses who communicates with God and other grotesque depictions of the father (for example, in ‘Traktat o manekinach, ci g dalszy’ (‘Treatise on Tailors’ Dummies. Continuation’) which are identified with the world of Jewish tradition, demonstrate a certain irony on behalf of Hasidism. The episode of aunt Perasia, from the story ‘Wichura’ (‘The Gale’), who burns together with the paper she used to make a fire and whose family does not care for her as well as the father’s metamorphosis into a crab which is served at the table, yet nobody can decide to eat it, belong to the esoteric layer of Jewish “injokes”,8 and thus represent further examples of the comic treatment of Hasidic elements. Such a self-ironic attitude toward tradition is part of the Jewish tradition. Walter Benjamin (1985: 293) once said about Kafka that to understand him properly, it is necessary to discover the comical side of Jewish theology. This is at the same time a key to the Jewish element in the prose of Schulz, who commented that Kafka wrote “in the conventional language of certain esoteric communities and schools” (“w j zyku umownym pewnych gmin i szkó ezoterycznych”; 1989a: 413), thus recognizing a common method. Another proof for the ironic treatment of Jewish traditions is the fact that the son hardly communicates with his father in Sklepy cynamonowe; mostly he watches his father’s grotesque behavior like a spectator in the theatre, fascinated by the father’s strange show.9 The son is outside of the father’s world. In the second cycle, Sanatorium Under the Sign of the Hourglass, the son speaks with his father in several stories and shares the bed with him for one night in the title story. At the end of the cycle, in ‘Ostatnia wycieczka ojca’ (‘Father’s Last Escape’), when the father is cooked and served as a crab, the son comes close to incorporating the father when he nearly eats him. 8
As Sproede (2000: 150) pointed out, the episode of the burning aunt can be interpreted as a comical allusion to Jewish meditation, whereas the father’s various metamorphoses can be explained as gilgul, the Hasidic transmigration of souls (cf. Sproede 2000: 154; Meyer-Fraatz 2004: 361-362). 9 The intrinsic theatrality of Schulz’s prose has been described and interpreted by such critics as Wyskiel (1977, 1980), Robertson (1994), Sproede (2000), Meyer-Fraatz (2001, 2004, 2005). Nonetheless, it is related to the Jewish tradition (cf. Sproede 2000) and of importance with regard to the relationship of father and son (cf. MeyerFraatz 2004).
60
Andrea Meyer-Fraatz
Nevertheless, the son is also watching him as a spectator, for example, when the father is sitting in a café and is ordering a plethora of food while flirting with the waitress and other women around him. The son’s attitude toward the father is best symbolized in an Ex-Libris for Stanisaw Weingarten: a Harlequin or a Pierrot is looking at a frivolous scene, in which he does not take part, but because of his disguise, he is a potential actor as well.10 The question is whether he has stopped playing or still participates. At any rate, the presentation of the father as an actor in a grotesque tragicomedy implies his distance from the son who does not always take part in the play. By confining those Jewish motifs which are discernable by readers who are unfamiliar with the Talmudic tradition to the father and excluding the son from the father’s world, the implied author underlines his ironic attitude toward the Jewish tradition, at least in the first book. Schulz himself pointed out the authenticity of his personal myth depicted in the cycle Cinnamon shops (cf. Schulz 1992a: 326). This specific authenticity is underscored by the fact that the father bears the same name as Schulz’s father, whereas the son is called Józef, referring to Jacob’s son in the Book of Genesis and thus highlighting the mythological aspect of the stories. Although the son bears a name other than that of Jakub Schulz’s real-life third son, he is nevertheless recognizable as the real author’s alter ego. In this way, the author has not only an implied but also a fictionalized presence in the texts. This fact is confirmed by the illustrations to his stories in which Józef is always represented by the author’s self-portrait. In his graphic cycle Xiga bawochwalcza (The Idolatrous Book), Schulz presents himself as a masochist male surrounded by or facing female nudes. The title is a citation of a Jewish book of the Hasidic tradition, directly translated into Polish (cf. Schulte 2004). Referring idolatry to the masochist adoration of women means an even higher degree of idolatry. The topic of the The Idolatrous Book is not only highly heretical but also shocking for the mostly catholic public because of the depicted nudes and situations among which the painter depicts himself (though the pictures were actually known to only a few
10 The Ex-Libris is reproduced in Jarz bski (1999: 179) and in Panas (2001). Panas (970) describes and interprets the Ex-Libris very thoroughly, pointing out its position in the whole history of arts on the one hand and the importance for Schulz’s whole work on the other, drawn and written later. My own interpretation reduces the picture to the mere aspect of spectator and scene.
Exposing and Concealing Jewish Origin: Schulz and Lemian
61
people). Additionally, even the Jewish theme itself was most unusual for an author who wrote for a Polish-speaking public. In the stories erotic themes are either less exposed or restricted to characters other than Jacob and Joseph (except ‘Manekiny’ (‘Mannequins’), where the father examines Pauline’s knee and the ‘Sanatorium Under the Sign of the Hourglass’, in which the father flirts with waitresses and the son waits for the pornographic books that he ordered by mail); however, both the illustrations and The Idolatrous Book (to an even greater degree) expose erotic themes. This attitude toward shocking the petite bourgeoisie is typical for the avant-garde, as well as the exposition of the “authorial I”. Van Heuckelom (2006) pointed out the aspect of iconoclasm with regard to the prohibition of pictures by the Ten Commandments. A prototype of an avant-gardist author exposing his own identity is the Russian poet Vladimir Maiakovskii who wrote an autobiography titled Ia sam (I Myself) and a tragedy titled Vladimir Maiakovskii. Felix Philipp Ingold points out that Maiakovskii exposes his own identity in order to dissolve it, fragment it in the collective crowd while at the same time identifying his fictional self in his literary text with his real self in the text of his life (1992: 145-174). Although Maiakovskii and Schulz do not have much in common, there is a parallel in the exposition of the authorial subject. Similarly, Schulz’s fictional identity is partly identical to his real identity. In spite of all the differences between the two authors, the model of fictionalising one’s self and thus combining literature and life is valid for both of them. Witkacy, Schulz’s literary and artistic companion, also created a great number of self-portraits. By fictionalizing himself and depicting the father as representing the dying Jewish world, Schulz exposes his Jewish origin but at the same time demonstrates his own estrangement from his roots by means of irony. He paradoxically demonstrates that he belongs to the literary avant-garde by referring to traditional Hasidic methods. Panas (2001: 191) points out that on Schulz’s drawing ‘Przyjcie Mesjasza’ (‘The Coming of the Messiah’) there is no Messiah, but due to the happy faces of the people in the picture, he supposes that the Messiah must be near. Although Panas negates Isaac Bashevis Singer’s cited words “Death is the Messiah” (Panas 2001: 121), I am inclined to apply them to the case of Schulz; such a comprehension of a major Jewish theologeme would fit to his ironic
62
Andrea Meyer-Fraatz
and heretical treatment of Jewish tradition. Similarly, his novel on the Messiah, which was announced more than once and has been missing since Schulz’s death, might have been a metaphor for something which will never come. Thus the exposition of his Jewish origin is tightly knitted to the real author Bruno Schulz. Conclusion Both authors, Bolesaw Lemian and Bruno Schulz, were Polish authors of Jewish origin who contributed works of hitherto unknown poetic qualities to Polish literature. Besides important differences, they shared central traits in their poetic practices, such as the use of the grotesque, the depiction of an abundant nature, and bold, complex metaphors. Both of them were confronted with anti-Semitic harassment by literary critics. However, one main difference between them is the treatment and reflection of Jewish origin in their work. Interestingly, this difference manifests itself in the common motif of metamorphosis. Whereas Lemian’s metamorphoses focus on the mourning over a double identity (for example in ‘Akteon’, see above), Schulz’s metamorphoses are related to the esoteric layer of his prose, representing his Jewish identity. At the same time, the different treatment of their Jewish origin as a literary fact makes it evident that they belong to different phases of modernism. Lemian only implicitly reflects his dual identity through the use of oriental motifs, motifs of double identity or metamorphosis, and thus hides behind the text, represents a typically modernist author of the turn of the century. Although some motifs can be recognized as autobiographical, Lemian by no means exposes his own personality in his texts. Schulz, on the other hand, exposes his Jewish origin by using motifs of prophets and the Messiah and creating a poetics of revelation based on the rabbinic tradition of Thora exegesis in the Talmud and the Midrashim. Although the latter is comprehensible only to insiders, Schulz’s illustrations to his stories and his other drawings showing Hasidic Jews underline the Jewish theme which ultimately refers back to the Jewish identity of their author. In his prose he created a recognizable alter ego and thus fictionalized himself and obscured the border between fiction and reality, literature and life. This is typical of the avant-garde. Neither Schulz nor Lemian belonged to any literary group, but Schulz, unlike Lemian, was lucky to have influential
Exposing and Concealing Jewish Origin: Schulz and Lemian
63
friends, for example, Zofia Nakowska, in the literary scene. Forming a trio with Witkacy and Gombrowicz, he soon belonged to the most important newcomers of Polish literature in the 1930s. In these circumstances, Schulz exposes his Jewish origin in his work as a specific form of avant-garde.11 Some of Schulz’s stories thematically recall the motifs of Lemian’s poetry: the abundant nature of ‘Sierpie’ (‘August’) or ‘Pan’, ‘Wiosna’ (‘Spring’) and other stories are depicted with a similar metaphorical expression. Gabriel Moked (1994: 88-89) speaks of “Lemianesque landscapes” (“krajobrazy Lemianowskie”) in Schulz’s prose. Some of his outsider characters as Touya, Pan, or Dodo evoke respective outsiders in Lemian’s poetry (cf. Karkowski 1978: 64). Chwin (1994: 119) mentions the theme of cosmic creation as the most common trait shared between the two poets and relates them both to fantastic romanticism. Schulz appreciated Lemian and read his poems repeatedly. In 1938, he wrote to his friend Romana Halpern that he just received Lemian’s Meadow (2002: 170), which suggests that Lemian was important for him throughout his life. Outlining a model of writing strategies of Jewish writers in Poland in the 1930s, Eugenia Prokop-Janiec (1994: 97) confirms that Lemian was a fully assimilated Polish poet of Jewish origin. According to her model, Schulz was a semi-assimilated author, using Jewish themes and motifs only in certain situations and contexts. She concludes that Schulz’s strategy of assimilation was moderate: he chose a “private Jewishness with Polish or European aspirations” (“prywatn ydowsko z polskimi czy europejskimi aspiracjami”; 1994: 98) and “functioned” in a twofold way, in a Jewish and in a Polish surrounding. His treatment of Jewish elements in his texts as outlined in this article can explain this assertion in more detail. Whereas the esoteric layer of his texts is understandable only for a Jewish in-group for whom he is a Jewish author, the unconventional poetics which are a result of his “in-jokes” turn him into an avantgardistic author for a wider audience.12
11 Herta Schmid (1998: 57) comes to the conclusion that Schulz is stylistically rooted in the Krakow avant-garde and futurism but surpasses both of them by creating a poetics of his own. 12 The question of whether or not the ridiculing of avant-garde manifests in the ‘Treatise on Tailors’ Dummies’ by the father can be referred to the author himself.
64
Andrea Meyer-Fraatz
Nonetheless, Schulz’s Lemianesque landscapes seem to be more than a typological similarity, no less than his heretical and blasphemous treatment of biblical motifs and his presentation of outsiders. When Schulz confines openly Jewish motifs mostly to the world of the father and composes those stories in which he seems to be an adept of Lemian but with hidden Jewish elements, he obviously in a certain sense surpasses his older contemporary. Schulz’s twofold authorial strategy represented by the two layers of Jewish elements in his prose corresponds to Lemian’s treatment of his Jewish identity in his poems. Whereas Lemian conceals his Jewishness behind motifs of dual identity or metamorphosis by staying on the level of the implied author, Schulz acts out his dual identity on the levels of both the real and the implied author. One might speculate whether or not this is a case of Bloom’s “anxiety of influence”. Bibliography Benjamin, Walter. 1985. W. Benjamin, G. Scholem. Briefwechsel 1933-1940. Frankfurt/M.: Suhrkamp. Berman, Nina. 1996. Orientalismus, Kolonialismus und Moderne. Zum Bild des Orients in der deutschsprachigen Kultur um 1900. Stuttgart – Weimar: Metzler. Chagall, Marc. 1999. Arabische Nächte. Vier Erzählungen aus 1001 Nacht. München – London – New York: Prestel. Chwin, Stefan. 1994. ‘Schulz a Lemian’ in Jarz bski, Jerzy (ed.) Czytanie Schulza. Materiay midzynarodowej sesji naukowej Bruno Schulz – w stulecie urodzin i w pi dziesi ciolecie mierci. Kraków: T.I.C.: 108-126. Goldfarb, David A. 1993. ‘Czytaj c Schulza: “Noc wielkiego sezonu”’ in Kresy 13: 15-21. Ingold, Felix Philipp. 1989. ‘Schöpfertum und Führungskraft. Zum Wandel der “Funktion Autor” in der Moderne’ in Wunderlich, Werner (ed.) Der literarische Homo Oeconomicus. Vom Märchenhelden zum Manager. Beiträge zum Ökonomieverständnis in der Literatur. Bern – Stuttgart: Haupt: 171-195. Ingold, Felix Philipp. 1992. Der Autor am Werk. Versuche über literarische Kreativität. München: Hanser. Jarz bski, Jerzy. 1999. Schulz. Wrocaw: Wydawnictwo Dolnol skie. Karkowski, Czesaw. 1978. ‘Poezja na mietniku’ in Poezja. 13(6): 64-68. Kaków, Robert. 1992. ‘Wielki teatr paschy. O akcentach ydowskich w twórczoci Brunona Schulza’ in NaGos 7: 34-47. Lachmann, Renate. 1992. ‘Dezentrierte Bilder. Die ekstatische Imagination in Bruno Schulz’ Prosa’ in Wiener Slawistischer Almanach. Sonderband 31: 439-461. ——. 1999. ‘Der Demiurg und seine Phantasmen. Schöpfungsmythologische Spekulation im Werk von Bruno Schulz’ in Kosta, Peter, Holt Meyer and
Exposing and Concealing Jewish Origin: Schulz and Lemian
65
Natascha Drubek-Meyer (eds). Juden und Judentum in Literatur und Film des slavischen Sprachraums. Die geniale Epoche (Jüdische Kultur 5). Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz: 131-153. ——. 2002. Erzählte Phantastik. Zu Phantasiegeschichte und Semantik phantastischer Texte. Frankfurt/M.: Suhrkamp. Lemian, Bolesaw. 1965. Poezje (ed. J. Trznadel). Warszawa: Pastwowy Instytut Wydawniczy. Lewi, Henri. 1989. Bruno Schulz et les stratégies messianiques. Paris: La Table Ronde. opuszaski, Piotr. 2000. Lemian. Wrocaw: Wydawnictwo Dolnol skie. Meyer-Fraatz, Andrea. 2000. ‘Das Rätsel der dritten Rose. Bolesaw Lemians Zyklus “Trzy ró e” im Kontext des Gedichtbands ka’ in Ibler, Reinhard (ed.) Zyklusdichtung in den slavischen Literaturen. Frankfurt/M. etc.: Lang: 367379. ——. 2001. ‘Zasady cyklizacji w prozie Brunona Schulza’ in Jakowska, Krystyna, Olech, Barbara and Sokoowska, Katarzyna (eds). Cykl literacki w Polsce. Biaystok: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu w Biaymstoku: 283-299. ——. 2004. ‘Söhne und Väter: Überlegungen zu einer thematischen Konstante bei Franz Kafka, Bruno Schulz und Danilo Kiš’ in Hansen-Kokoruš, Renate and Richter Angela (eds). Mundus narratus. Festschrift für Dagmar Burkhart zum 65. Geburtstag. Frankfurt/M. etc.: Lang: 359-374. ——. 2005. ‘Zasady cyklizacji w twórczoci narracyjnej Brunona Schulza (ci g dalszy)’ in Demska-Tr bacz, Mieczysawa, Jakowska, Krystyna and Sioma, Radosaw (eds). Semiotyka cyklu. Cykl w muzyce, plastyce i literaturze. Biaystok: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu w Biaymstoku: 327-336. Moked, Gabriel. 1994. ‘Dwie galaktyki pónego modernizmu. wiat przeszoci i modernizm w twórczoci dwóch ydowskich pisarzy z Galicji – Brunona Schulza i Samuela Josefa Agnona’ in Jarz bski, Jerzy (ed.) Czytanie Schulza. Kraków: T.I.C.: 85-94. Panas, Wadysaw. 1996. Pismo i rana. Szkice o problematyce ydowskiej w literaturze polskiej (Critice literaturae judaicae). Lublin: Dabar. ——. 1997. Ksiga blasku. Traktat o kabale w prozie Brunona Schulza. Lublin: Towarzystwo Naukowe Katolickiego Uniwersytetu Lubelskiego. ——. 2001. Bruno od Mesjasza. Lublin: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Marii CurieSkodowskiej. Prokop-Janiec, Eugenia. 1994. ‘Schulz a galicyjski tygiel kultur’ in Jarz bski, Jerzy (ed.) Czytanie Schulza. Kraków: T.I.C.: 95-107. Przybylski, Ryszard K. 1987. Autor i jego sobowtór. Wrocaw: Ossolineum. Robertson, Theodosia. 1994. ‘Bruno Schulz i komedia’ in Kitowska-ysiak, Magorzata (ed.) Bruno Schulz. In memoriam. 1892-1942. Lublin: Wydawnictwo FIS: 101-109. Rymkiewicz, Jarosaw Marek. 2001. Lemian. Encyklopedia. Warszawa: Sic! Schmid, Herta. 1998. ‘Sprachursprungstheorien bei Bolesaw Lemian und Bruno Schulz’ in Grözinger, Karl Erich (ed.) Sprache und Identität im Judentum (Jüdische Kultur 4). Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz: 43-57. Schulz, Bruno. 1989a. Opowiadania. Wybór esejów i listów (ed. J. Jarz bski). Wrocaw: Zakad Narodowy im. Ossolinskich.
66
Andrea Meyer-Fraatz
——. 1989b. The Complete Fiction of Bruno Schulz. New York: Walker and Company. ——. 1992a. ‘Exposé über das Buch “Zimtläden” von Bruno Schulz’. Die Wirklichkeit ist Schatten des Wortes. Aufsätze und Briefe (ed. J. Ficowski). München: Hanser: 325-328. ——. 1992b. Ilustracje do wasnych utworów (ed. J. Ficowski). Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Reprint. ——. 2002. Ksiga listów (ed. J. Ficowski). Gdask: sowo/obraz terytoria. Schulte, Jörg. 2004. Eine Poetik der Offenbarung. Isaak Babel’, Bruno Schulz, Danilo Kiš (Jüdische Kultur 12). Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz. Shallcross, Bo ena. 1997. ‘“Fragments of a Broken Mirror”: Bruno Schulz’s Retextualization of the Kabbalah’ in East European Politics and Societies. 11(2): 270-281. Sikorski, Dariusz K. 2004. Symboliczny wiat Brunona Schulza. Supsk: Wydawnictwo Pomorskiej Akademii Pedagogicznej w Supsku. Sproede, Alfred. 2000. ‘Expérimentations narratives après la fin de l’avantgarde: notes sur Bruno Schulz, ses lecteurs et ses incantations’ in Konicka, Hanna and Hélène Wodarczyk (eds). La littérature polonaise du XXe siècle: textes, styles et voix. Paris: Institut d’Etudes Slaves: 135-165. Stala, Krzysztof. 1993. On the Margins of Reality: the Paradoxes of Representation in Bruno Schulz’s Fiction. Stockholm: Almqvist & Wiksell International. Stone, Rochelle. 1976. Bolesaw Lemian. The Poet and his Poetry. Berkeley – Los Angeles – London: University of California Press. Van Heuckelom, Kris. 2006. ‘Artistic Crossover in Polish Modernism. The Case of Bruno Schulz’s Xi ga Bawochwalcza (The Idolatrous Booke)’ in Image [&] Narrative. Online Magazine of the Visual Narrative 15. On line at: http://www.imageandnarrative.be/iconoclasm/heuckelom.htm (consulted 18.05.2008). Wyskiel, Wojciech. 1977. ‘Brunona Schulza porozumienie z czytelnikiem’ in Bujnicki, Tadeusz and Janusz Sawiski (eds). Problemy odbioru i odbiorcy. Wrocaw: Ossolineum: 257-267. ——. 1980. Inna twarz Hioba. Problematyka alienacyjna w dziele Brunona Schulza. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie.
As One Kabbalist to Another… On Arnold Sucki’s Mystical Visions in the Poem ‘Bruno Schulz’ Sawomir Jacek urek Abstract: Bruno Schulz and Arnold Sucki (1920-1972) have several things in common: their place of birth (shtetl), their Jewish origin (Polish-Jewish roots), their assimilation to Polish culture, their attachment to the history of Polish literature, and their fascination with Jewish mysticism and philosophy, primarily with medieval kabbalistic thought. They are not only writers, but also Jewish philosophers and kabbalistic thinkers. This article is a hermeneutic effort to show influences of Schulz’s output on Sucki’s poetry in the context of Judaism and first of all – kabbalah. It analyzes one of Arnold Sucki’s poems, entitled ‘Bruno Schulz’.
Introduction Two distinguished Polish writers, Bruno Schulz and Arnold Sucki (1920-1972), have several things in common. Both came from a shtetl – a small Jewish town – Schulz from Drohobycz, Sucki from Tyszowce on the Huczwa river; both were born into Jewish families; both were assimilated into Polish culture; and today they are both famous as Polish writers. There is also one other connection between them, namely their fascination with Jewish mysticism and philosophy, primarily with medieval kabbalah.1 Looking at their output, one could call these two writers “Jewish philosophers and kabbalistic thinkers” because one can find in their poems and novels not only inspirations from Jewish philosophy but also connections with its mystical vision of worlds and cosmic ideas. One Polish mystic literally talks to another, as one kabbalist to another…
1
Cf. Panas (1997) and urek (1999) for a discussion of connections between the works of Polish writers and Jewish mystical tradition.
68
Sawomir Jacek urek
“The Constant Temptation of Matter” The basic philosophical category operating in Arnold Sucki’s poetic text ‘Bruno Schulz’ is the principium individuationis. The term originates in the Middle Ages. Like many other modern terms, it harkens back to Thomas Aquinas, who in Summa Theologica (Question 75: Of Man Who is Composed of a Spiritual and a Corporeal Substance: And in the First Place, Concerning What Belongs to the Essence of the Soul (Seven Articles), Fourth Article: Whether the Soul is Man?) describes a human being in the following way: The assertion the soul is man can be taken in two senses. First, that man is a soul; though this particular man, Socrates, for instance, is not a soul, but composed of soul and body. I say this, forasmuch as some held that the form alone belongs to the species; while matter is part of the individual, and not the species. This cannot be true; for to the nature of the species belongs what the definition signifies; and in natural things the definition does not signify the form only, but the form and the matter. Hence in natural things the matter is part of the species; not, indeed, signate matter, which is the principle of individuality; but the common matter. For as it belongs to the notion of this particular man to be composed of this soul, of this flesh, and of these bones; so it belongs to the notion of man to be composed of soul, flesh, and bones; for whatever belongs in common to the substance of all the individuals contained under a given species, must belong to the substance of the species. (1981)
Aquinas points to a certain tension between individuality and universality, and between the subjective and objective aspects of their perception. Stefan Swie awski comments on the above fragment of the medieval thinker’s ontological argument in this way: W okrelenie rzeczy materialnych wchodzi materia wspóna, nie za materia ilociowo oznaczona, stanowi ca o ujednostkowieniu, indywidualizacji, czyli o rozdrobnieniu na jednostki. Zasad , czynnikiem jednostkowienia (principium individuationis) jest to, co sprawia, e dany byt nie jest tylko jedynym w gatunku, lecz e na gatunek tego bytu skadaj si liczne jednostki. Zasad t jest materia, która podobnie jak ka da mo no jest ródem mnogoci. Materia pierwsza jest czyst mo noci , ale mo noci stania si ciaem; i dlatego tym, do czego jest ona w pierwszym rz dzie w mo noci, jest rozci go i wszelkie okrelenia ilociowe (quantitas). Tote zasad jednostkowienia dla w. Tomasza nie jest materia pierwsza bez adnych bli szych wyjanie, ale materia uj ta jako pozostaj ca w mo noci do okrele ilociowych:
As One Kabbalist to Another… Schulz and Sucki
69
quantitate signata. Jest to ta materia, która – po czywszy si z form substancjaln – wyst puje w danym jednostkowym bycie, ukonstytuowanym przez po czenie si tej formy substancjalnej z materi pierwsz . Czym zupenie innym jest materia wspólna czy powszechna (materia communis); oznacza ona ten element materialny, który jest istotny nie dla danej jednostki, ale dla gatunku, gdy istoty jestestw cielesnych nie stanowi nigdy sama forma, lecz zespolenie formy i wanie owej materii wspólnej. (in z Akwinu 1956: 726). (Material entities are determined by the common matter rather than by matter circumscribed qualitatively. The common matter individuates particular entities. The principle of individuation (principium individuationis) makes it possible for many particulars to share the same species. Matter constitutes the principle of individuation, which – like other possibilities – is the source of variety. Primary matter is the pure possibility of acquiring a body. Thus, extension and quantity (quantitas) constitute its primary potential. Therefore, Aquinas considers primary matter to be the principle of individuation only insofar as it encompasses the possibility of quantitative determination (quantitate signata). It is a type of matter that occurs in a particular in combination with the substantial form, and the particular is constituted by this combination. The common matter (materia communis) is totally different, as it refers to the material component, which is not essential to a particular, but only to the species. For the essence of material entities is never constituted by form alone, but by its combination with the common matter.)2
Beginning his lyrical philosophical treatise, pointedly entitled ‘Bruno Schulz’, Sucki writes: Tak urealnia si principium individuationis: kuszenie substancji ci ge, upynniony ar pogardy sennej, mioci… (1966) (It is in this way that principium individuationis becomes real: the constant temptation of matter, the fluid heat of dreamy disdain, of love…)
Considering Schulz’s way of understanding reality and his metaphysical and ontological vision, it appears that Sucki is trying to indicate at the beginning of his poetic argument the principle that both orders Schulz’s vision and provides a means for understanding it cosmologically and anthropologically. Following Aquinas (and, as we will see shortly, Schopenhauer, Nietzsche, and Jung), Sucki seeks the 2
Translation into English by P. Kawalec.
70
Sawomir Jacek urek
central axis of all the processes to which both cosmos and man (and all beings) are subject in the category of the principium individuationis: that is, in the category of the principle of individuation mentioned by Aquinas, and in its natural objectives, understood in Schopenhauer’s sense as the objectification of the transcendental will, conceived as the thing in itself. In his poetry, Schulz asks an important question about the universal principle that would explain all the processes of transformation and becoming for both the human being and, more broadly, the world. According to Sucki, in Schulz’s system, this principium applies to both the individual and human community or nature. Man and the world become actual not through the process of having their being objectively confirmed by a number of other individuals, but through individuation, which takes place in an individual and subjective manner, somewhere in the human ego, where the hidden principle of life is being discovered. According to Jung’s theory wszystko wi e si zarówno z aspektem procesualnym zmian w obr bie bytu (zarówno bytu jako takiego, jak i bytu psychicznego w szczególnoci), ale nade wszystko z wymiarem teleologicznym (celowociowym) tego . Prawo to wyra a wi c bezporednio d enie jednostki jako caoci do „wyra enia” siebie jako niepowtarzalnej, jedynej w swoim rodzaju indywidualnoci, kieruj cej si wasnym cho powszechnym wewn trznym prawem – apriorycznie dan , potencjalnie w nim tkwi c struktur . Na gruncie psychologii analitycznej zasada ta oznacza przede wszystkim proces wyodr bniania si , ró nicowania bytu wiadomego z wszechogarniaj cej macierzy niewiadomoci. (Kumicki 2006) (everything is linked to the process of changes in being (both being itself and as a particular mental state of being), and above all to its teleological (design) dimension. This principle therefore expresses the aspirations of the individual as a whole for “expressing” oneself as a unique individuality, guided by internal laws that are one’s own yet also universal – an a priori structure, a potential lying deep within. At the basis of analytical psychology, this principle denotes first of all a process of separating, of differentiating a conscious being from the all-embracing mother of unconsciousness.)
Jung’s understanding of the principium individuationis seems closer to Schulz’s ontological conception than to Schopenhauer’s understanding of individuation as a source of human suffering (as it is in Buddhism). In both Schulz’s and Jung’s conceptions, it is above all the principle responsible for the creative transformations of the
As One Kabbalist to Another… Schulz and Sucki
71
individual, for the individuals’ development toward higher goals, namely, wholeness, the uniqueness of existence, and higher forms of order (Kumicki 2006). We should give some attention here to the historical context, pointed out by Stefan Chwin (1994) in his article ‘Grzeszne manipulacje. Historia sztuki, a historia medycyny’ (‘Sinful Manipulations: the History of Art and the History of Medicine’). We have to remember that Schulz’s lifetime (1920s and 1930s) was marked by very intensive development of the sciences. In his essay, Chwin shows the extent of Schulz’s fascination with biology and medicine. According to Chwin, the artist from Drohobycz was deeply interested in discoveries made by Alexis Carrel in the area of transplantation, which had changed the understanding of the human body (the shift of the border between life and death) and of human identity (the transcendence of sexual differences). These discoveries were accompanied by unusually rapid – at least for that time – development of other medical sciences, especially the creation of genetics and the emergence of eugenics. For Chwin, the description of these fascinations in Schulz’s case can be found in the dreams that the hero of Schulz’s prose has about creating a human being in the form of a tailor’s dummy, about experiments consisting of the exclusion of the principium individuationis from an ontological (and, consequently, axiological) perspective, and then reversing the order and trying to turn the principium individuationis into the primary principle of the cosmic order, which also pertains to inanimate objects. All of this acquires a new form within the aesthetic domain where the artist attempts to create new textual worlds without paying attention to the limitations of matter because such limitations have been overcome. For this reason, some critics have opted for the theory that this principium individuationis (a term which appears only once in Schulz’s work, in the story ‘Kometa’ (‘The Comet’)) has a Nietzschean genealogy in the case of the author of ‘Traktat o manekinach (‘Treatise on Tailors’ Dummies’), or as Jerzy Jarz bski (1998a: c-cv) suggests, it is deployed parodically by Schulz. As Wodzimierz Bolecki forcefully asserts: [P]rincipum individuationis […] funkcjonuje w schulzowskiej koncepcji literatury niew tpliwie w takim sensie, w jakim u ywa jej Nietzsche w Narodzinach tragedii, tzn. jako kryterium podziau na sztuk apollisk i dionizyjsk . (2003: 20)
Sawomir Jacek urek
72
(Principium individuationis undoubtedly works in Schulz’s conception of literature in the sense in which Nietzsche used it in The Birth of Tragedy, that is, as the criterion for dividing art into Apollonian and Dionysian.)
According to Nietzsche, kategoria ta implikuje podzia bytu na odizolowane, indywidualne elementy. [J]est […] wyznacznikiem sztuki apolliskiej. A sam Apollo zosta nazwany […] “boskim obrazem principium individuationis”, “ubóstwieniem” i “geniuszem tej zasady”. [Z]asada [ta] stanowi fundament sztuki, która ten ywio [istnienie, byt] zasania i która zatem nie jest przedstawieniem istnienia, lecz jego pozorem. […] eby rozerwa zason zasaniaj c rzeczywisto, aby dotrze do istoty bytu, trzeba przede wszystkim unicestwi zasad principium individuationis. [T]ej destrukcji dokonuje wanie Dionizos. (Bolecki 2003: 21-22) (this category implies the division of being into isolated, individual elements. This is the determinant of Apollonian art. Apollo himself was called “the divine image of principium individuationis”, “its divinization” and “the genius of this principle”. This principle constitutes the basis of art, art which covers up this element [existence] and which therefore does not depict existence but rather its illusion. To tear this veil covering reality, to reach the core of being, one must first of all destroy the principle of principium individuationis. This destruction is carried out by Dionysus.)
In this approach, the breaking of this principle is an artistic phenomenon, which is not wholly negative since it is connected with a return to the sources of culture. As Bolecki further observes: Tymczasem Schulz – si gaj c do tych samych nietzscheaskich róde – nadawa amoralizmowi sens ontologiczny. Dla Schulza bowiem aetyczny jest nie artysta (“kapan sztuki” w terminologii Przybyszewskiego), lecz byt – samo istnienie. […] Schulz rozwija w nim koncepcj , zgodnie z któr dawna jedno sowa zostaa rozerwana na izolowane fragmenty. Jedno tym elementom mo e przywróci jedynie sztuka, a dokadniej – zabieg zwany przez Schulza mityzacj . Celem mityzacji jest odzyskanie utraconej jednoci, mit jest bowiem w koncepcji Schulza rzeczywistoci pierwotn . W pierwotnej rzeczywistoci ukryty jest sens istnienia, którego nie ma w sztuce wspóczesnej, zbudowanej na odizolowanych od siebie fragmentach dawnych kultur i mitów. […] Poezja, czyli sztuka – pisa Schulz – to “regeneracja pierwotnych mitów”. (Bolecki 2003: 23-27) (Meanwhile Schulz, using Nietzschean sources, gives an ontological sense to amoralism. This is because for Schulz it is not the artist who is ethical (the artist who was called “the priest of art” by Stanisaw Przybyszewski)
As One Kabbalist to Another… Schulz and Sucki
73
but being, existence itself. Schulz develops the concept according to which the old unity of the word has been broken into isolated elements. The unity of these elements can be restored only by art, and, more precisely, by the operation which Schulz called “the mythologizing of reality”. The goal of this mythologizing is the restitution of lost unity, as myth, for Schulz, constitutes original reality. In this original reality, there is hidden the sense of existence, which no longer exists in modern art, which is created from the isolated fragments of old cultures and myths. Poetry, that is, art – Schulz wrote – is the “regeneration of the original myths”.)
This is not the first or only case of the existence of the motif of the principium individuationis in Polish literature. This term appears, for example, in Czesaw Miosz’s poetry: “What happened and when to the principium individuationis? Where is the smell of ‘ajer’3 near the river bank, for me only and nobody else?” (“O, co si stao i kiedy z principium individuationis? Gdzie zapach ajeru nad rzek , mój tylko i dla nikogo?”; 1980: 124). The poet – as Jan Boski wrote musi nazwa matk dawnym, jedynym imieniem, inaczej zostanie policzony w tum, zmierzony, zapomniany… Bo imi nowe, pospolicie stosowane, uogólnia i str ca w abstrakcj , pozbawiaj c jednostkowoci, któr ocali mo e tylko poezja. Jak ocali principium individuationis? Za spraw “ajeru nad rzek ”, który by “mój tylko i dla nikogo”… Zgodnie ze wi tym Tomaszem, wanie materialno funduje principium individuationis. (2008) (must call his mother by the old, the only name, or else he will become part of the crowd, calculated, forgotten… Because the new name, colloquially used, generalizes and turns into an abstraction, depriving one of his or her individuality, which can be saved only by poetry. How can one save the principium individuationis? Thanks to the “‘ajer’ on the river bank”, which was “only mine and no one else’s”… According to Thomas Aquinas, it is materiality that is at the core of the principium individuationis.)
“This Migration of Forms is the Essence of Life” How does Schulz himself understand the meaning of individuality or individualization of beings? In a letter to Witkiewicz, he wrote:
3
“Ajer” is a liquor, also known as “advocaat”.
74
Sawomir Jacek urek Wszystko dyfunduje poza swoje granice, trwa tylko na chwil w pewnym ksztacie, a eby go przy pierwszej sposobnoci opuci. […] Rzeczywisto przybiera pewne ksztaty tylko dla pozoru, dla artu, dla zabawy. Kto jest czowiekiem, a kto karakonem, ale ten ksztat nie si ga istoty, jest tylko rol na chwil przyj t , tylko naskórkiem, który za chwil
zostanie zrzucony. Statuowany tu jest pewien skrajny monizm substancji, dla której poszczególne przedmioty s jedynie maskami. ycie substancji polega na zu ywaniu niezmiernej iloci masek. Ta w drówka form jest istot ycia. (Schulz 1998a: 444-445).4 (Everything diffuses beyond its borders, remains in a given shape only momentarily, leaving this shape behind at the first opportunity. […] Reality takes on certain shapes merely for the sake of appearance, as a joke or form of play. One person is a human, another is a cockroach, but shape does not penetrate essence, is only a role adopted for the moment, an outer skin soon to be shed. A certain extreme monism of the life substance is assumed here, for which specific objects are nothing more than masks. This migration of forms is the essence of life; Schulz 1990: 113)
“This migration of forms is the essence of life” seems to be the key to Schulz’s ontology. Beings only exist in their essence deep beneath the epidermis, which peels off periodically. Everything is only a “mask” under which one can find the “essence”. Beings are in constant motion; they mutate but only in their external forms, while their inner essence remains unchanged. Should this ontological understanding of reality be treated as a distant echo of gilgu neshamot, the Jewish mystical conception of a regenerated, post-mortem incarnation of the essence of each being (in Hebrew gilgulim means a turn, a circle, a wheel), that is, of its soul (or spirit, in Hebrew, neshama) into another physical form or human figure, which would happen thanks to the energy stored in each being?5 Initially, this concept was popular only in circles close to the Karaits (it was popularized by Anan ben David), who had taken it from Indian thought (samsara – the circle of forms; cf. Ochman 1995: 31-32). This teaching later infiltrated the kabbalah, but it was not – which must be stressed here – in agreement with Orthodox Judaism. Some kabbalists searched for the model of gilgul neshema in the history of Moses, who led the Jewish people out of 4
All further references will be given as Op. Wadysaw Panas (2001: 120) signalized the presence of this motif in Schulz’s prose.
5
As One Kabbalist to Another… Schulz and Sucki
75
Egypt.6 In the kabbalah, the concept of gilgul neshamot appeared for the first time in a treatise entitled Sefer ha-Bahir. Later, it was popularized by Isaac Luria,7 who, according to Panas, strongly influenced Schulz.8 According to the Lurian notion, the souls of the dead could be reincarnated into animals, and those who did not find a place in the world of animate nature took their place in stones. Luria liberated the souls imprisoned in stones and ordered them to continue the restitution and repair of the world (Hebr. tikkun) because liberating souls from these inanimate forms and sending them on to develop further were the role of a mystic-kabbalist. In kabbalistic visions, stones, thanks to the souls hidden in them, behave like live bodies to such an extent that they themselves can become a source of light (cf. Unterman 1994: 294-295). In the kabbalah, the entire cosmos is understood as the realm of forms, where all beings undergo development from a mineral state, to vegetal and animal states, and toward the stage of incarnate humanity. In the Jewish tradition, man occupies a special place in the hierarchy of created beings: higher than angels. This position is a result of two features. First, man has a second soul, which guarantees him eternity, and second, thanks to this soul, man is a mirror of the Absolute (En-Sof). Does Sucki also point to such a kabbalistic interpretation of Schulz’s ontology and cosmogony? 6
Cf., for example, Halevi (1994: 19). Gershom Scholem (1996: 128) claims that after Luria’s death the theory of the wandering of souls, known as the banishment of souls, achieved an important place in the worldview of the subsequent generations of Jews. 8 Cf. Panas (1997: 99-100): “We are sure that there exists an intellectual and conceptual context for interpretation, which helps us to explain the mystery of Schulz’s vision of cosmogony. We see it in the kabbalistic doctrine cimcum, which was created by the Palestinian mystic Isaac Luria (1534-1572). In our opinion, this is the only possible link, because in all known systems of cosmogonic ideas – mythological, religious, philosophical – there is nothing analogical to this collection of ideas and the pictures accompanying it, which we have discovered in Schulz’s world” (“S dzimy, e istnieje pewien intelektualny i wyobra eniowy kontekst interpretacyjny, który pomo e wyjani tajemnic Schulzowskiej wizji kosmogonicznej. Dostrze emy go w kabalistycznej doktrynie cimcum, któr wykreowa palestyski mistyk Izaak Luria (1534-1572). W naszym przekonaniu to jedyne mo liwe odniesienie, poniewa we wszystkich znanych systemach myli kosmogonicznej – mitologicznych, religijnych, filozoficznych – nie znajdujemy praktycznie adnej analogii dla tego zespou idei i towarzysz cych im obrazów, jaki wykrylimy u Schulza”). 7
76
Sawomir Jacek urek
“At the Blind Spot of its Circumference” It is interesting that in his interpretation of Schulz’s works, Sucki instantly moves from ontological matters to the figure of the father, directly addressed with the words “Father, father”: Ojcze, ojcze, kondor pi, przelatuje soce nad Drohobyczem i przejrzyst machinacj szykuj na niebie oboki w lepym punkcie obwodu. Blask: Pantha rei, Alleluja woa ruchem r k Bóg guchoniemy (Father, father, the condor is sleeping, the sun flies above Drohobycz and the clouds prepare a transparent machination in the sky at the blind spot of its circumference. A brilliance: Pantha rei, Hallelujah – cries the deaf-and-dumb God with a waving of his hands)
The father is invoked as a concrete person, the hero of the prose written by Schulz, addressed as a sleeping condor (the father is reincarnated as the condor in another story, ‘Ptaki’ (‘Birds’)). He “flies” together with the sun above Drohobycz, which becomes very important with regard to my discussion earlier, specifically in the cosmic context evoked by the poem and, as we will see in a moment, in the context of cosmogonist speculation. This cosmogony is a mysterious act, a physically unusual action (“clouds prepare a transparent machination in the sky”), which is connected to some cycle (“at the blind point of its circumference”), in which the movement takes place along a circular trajectory (the sun is circling, “flying” along a “circumference”). It is at this very moment that the cosmogonist elements start to appear in the text: light (“shine”) and visualized sound (“Hallelujah” – he cries “with a waving of his hands”). From this point forward, everything starts moving: panta rhei. In his story ‘Kometa’ (‘The Comet’), Schulz puts the words of Heraclitus into the father’s mouth, which is most interesting precisely in the context of principium individuationis: – Panta rei! – woa i zaznacza ruchem r k wieczne kr enie substancji. Od dawna pragn zmobilizowa kr ce w niej utajone siy, upynni jej sztywno, torowa jej drogi do wszechprzenikania, do transfuzji, do wszechcyrkulacji, jedynie waciwej jej naturze. – Principium individua-
As One Kabbalist to Another… Schulz and Sucki
77
tionis furda – mówi i wyra a tym sw bezgraniczn pogard dla tej naczelnej ludzkiej zasady. (Op 339-340) (“Panta rhei!” he exclaimed, and indicated with a movement of his hands the eternal circling of substance. For a long time he had wanted to mobilize the forces hidden in it, to make its stiffness melt, to pave its way to universal penetration, to transfusion, to universal circulation in accordance with its true nature. “Principium individuationis – my foot”, he used to say, thus expressing his limitless contempt for that guiding human principle; Schulz 1998b: 88)
The essence of being here is movement and ceaseless change, while its matter is light and sound, as in the kabbalah. A silent and closed “deaf-and-dumb God” enters history, a God who lost some of His divine attributes to man, a God who performs an act of self-limitation through his creative gesture, as Luria and Schulz claim. This is the way in which Sucki introduces the reader to his lyric treatise on Schulz, on a great philosopher who wrote down his ontological and cosmological discoveries in literary texts. Bruno Schulz, a writer and kabbalistic philosopher, is described by Arnold Sucki, a poet and kabbalist. “A Shy Philosopher” Toward the end of his poem, Sucki writes: wstydliwy filozof incognito szmacian tog
rozwija na wszechwiat, na miasteczko, jak wdowi pantofel rzucony w zorz za ogrody i ju jest za drzwiami (a shy philosopher incognito unfolds a rag toga over the universe, over the little town, like a widow’s slipper, thrown into the dawn beyond the gardens and it is already beyond the door)
At precisely this moment in the poem, the eponymous hero appears, entering history in God’s footsteps. Sucki defines him as a “shy philosopher incognito”. This modest, emotionally marked thinker makes an important gesture by covering with the flaps of his coat both the macro reality (“the universe”) and the microcosm (“little town”). It
78
Sawomir Jacek urek
is a quick and unique movement, which one can understand in two ways: on the one hand, he covers reality, but on the other hand, he tries to join it in a kind of “material” unity. A moment later, Sucki compares this act to the gesture of throwing away the “widow’s slipper” toward the source of light (“dawn”) coming from mythical gardens. These poetic acts can be understood as the process of uncovering the woman’s feet, a very important gesture in the iconography of Bruno Schulz. The entire role of “a shy philosopher”, who appears in the room (on stage?), is reduced to this symbolic manifestation of his cosmic unity with all beings because immediately he “is already beyond the door”: i ju jest za drzwiami, gdzie rozwi ze szmery traw i teksty dosowne kwiatów przepoczwarzaj si w ruchomy telegram stamt d, stamt d a dochodziy nas fale snu w rytmicznych pulsach. (and it is already behind the door, where the lustful whispers of grass and literal texts of flowers metamorphose into a mobile telegram from there, from where the waves of dream came to us in rhythmical pulses.)
The cosmos (“beyond the door”) consists of a mysterious system of signs, a code. In Schulz’s story ‘Wiosna’ (‘Spring’), there are mysterious worlds beyond the “glass-fronted door” (“szklane drzwi”; Op 138). In Sucki’s text, outside of this caesura, there is hidden a textual code, that is, the literary world and Bruno Schulz’s world. There are “wanton whispers of grass”, “literal texts / of flowers” there, and everything has taken on an ontological meaning; this world, as Sucki states following Schulz, is a “mobile telegram from over there” into which these biological-textual charades have metamorphosed. This juxtaposition of biological and textual orders, exploited by the author, appears at the beginning of Schulz’s ‘Spring’: Oto jest historia pewnej wiosny, wiosny, która bya prawdziwsza, bardziej olniewaj ca i jaskrawsza od innych wiosen, wiosna, która po prostu wzi a serio swój tekst dosowny, ten manifest natchniony, pisany najjaniejsz , wi teczn czerwieni , czerwieni laku pocztowego i kalendarza, czerwieni oówka kolorowego i czerwieni entuzjazmu, amarantem szcz liwych telegramów stamt d… (Op 133-134)
As One Kabbalist to Another… Schulz and Sucki
79
(This is the story of a certain spring that was more real, more dazzling and brighter than any other spring; a spring that took its text seriously, an inspired script, written in the festive red of a sealing wax and of calendar print, the red of coloured pencils and of enthusiasm, the amaranth of happy telegrams from far away; Schulz 2008: 141)
The metaphysical substance of these worlds – in Schulz’s text and Sucki’s text – are, like in the Book of Zohar, sounds (“whisper” – Sucki), signs (“literal text” – Schulz), and nature (spring – Sucki and Schulz). The hero of the poem is “walled up” in his meaning; he “knock[s] everywhere”, and transmits “from over there” through “waves of dream […] in rhythmical pulses”. In Schulz’s text (‘Spring’), we can find a similar interpretation of these events: Bo tekst wiosny znaczony jest cay w domylnikach, w niedomówieniach, w elipsach, wykropkowany bez liter w pustym b kicie, i w wolne luki mi dzy sylabami ptaki wstawiaj kaprynie swe domysy i swe odgadnienia. Dlatego b dzie ta historia, wzorem tego tekstu, ci gn a si
na wielu rozga zionych torach i caa przetykana b dzie wiosennymi mylnikami, westchnieniami i wielokropkami. (Op 138) (Because the text of spring is marked by hints, ellipses, lines dotted on an empty azure, and because the gaps between the syllables are filled by the frivolous guesses and surmises of birds, my story, like that text, will follow many different tracks and will be punctuated by springlike dashes, sighs, and dots; Schulz 2008: 142)
In Sucki’s poem, the vision of resurrection directly accompanies the cosmic visions: trumny wiate otwieraj si , jak antyki na wiosn
(coffins of light open up like antiques in spring)
And what can we see? In the open “coffins of light”, let us recall, “the treasures of our questions” (“skarby naszych pyta”), “shining bank drafts” (“weksle olniewaj ce”), “blind piles / in a panic full of explosions and breakneck hopes” (olepe pliki / w panice, pene eksplozji i karkoomnych nadziei”) are lying ready to be resurrected. In the coffins, there are different sources of light, a kind of energy which makes it possible to see the potential for resurrection in the man
80
Sawomir Jacek urek
sleeping in the grave. This light indicates the double nature of humanity: humanity belongs to the order of nature (“there our herbarium” / “tam zielniki nasze”) and, at the same time, to the order of revelation (“cardboard rolled up into scrolls” / “w roda zwini te brystole”). But “the yellow flame” (“ óty promie”) has changed this situation of division, once again reuniting both orders. First, this bracing light (“flame”) destroys: it “bites” (“zagryza”), “threatens” (“wygra a”, kills like a virus, but it can also “regenerate” (“regeneruje”) like a “medium from far away” (“jak medium z daleka”). All creatures undergo this process of destruction and regeneration: seeds which “sharpen their genes” (“geny swoje ostrz ”) in glass cases, as well as human beings (“sisters shine in bed linens there with the particles of their bodies” / “siostry wiec w pocieli drobinami ciaa”). And everything takes place “in a universe open like a dolphin’s wound” (“we wszechwiecie otwartym, jak rana delfina”) and tight “like an astral cake of angels after a slaughter” (“jak astralne ciasto anioów po rzezi”). Conclusion The poem ‘Bruno Schulz’ is a story about various worlds in which we must live. It is a story about worlds with unusual structures, multifariously reflected in each being, so that it can finally bring hope to man that the very composition of our being is marked by the perspective of resurrection. This is a very beautiful and joyful vision, like the stories and myths that Jewish parents tell their children in the spring during Seder. Bibliography z Akwinu, Tomasz. 1956. Traktat o czowieku – Suma teologiczna 1, 75-89. Pozna: Pallottinum. Aquinas, Thomas. 1981. The Summa Theologica of St. Thomas Aquinas (5 Vols) (tr. Fathers of the English Dominican Province). Westminster, MD: Christian Classics. Boski, Jan. 2008. ‘Epifanie Miosza’. On line at: http://www.milosz.pl/o_jb_em.php (consulted 17.08.2008). Bolecki, Wodzimierz. 2003. ‘Principium individuationis. Motywy nietzscheaskie w twórczoci Brunona Schulza’ in Teksty Drugie 14(5): 17-33. Chwin, Stefan. 1994. ‘“Grzeszne manipulacje”. Historia sztuki, a historia medycyny’ in Jarz bski, Jerzy (ed.) Czytanie Schulza. Kraków: T.I.C.: 278-285.
As One Kabbalist to Another… Schulz and Sucki
81
Halevi, Z’ev Ben Shimon. 1994. Kabaa. Tradycja wiedzy tajemnej (tr. B. Kos). Warszawa: Artes. Jarz bski, Jerzy. 1998. ‘Wst p’ in Schulz, Bruno. Opowiadania. Wybór esejów i listów. Wrocaw: Ossolineum: C-CV. Kumicki, Andrzej. 2006. ‘C.G. Jung i A. Schopenhauer – Niewiadomo’. On line at: http://www.jungpoland.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view &id=57&Itemid=86 (consulted 17.08.2008). Miosz, Czesaw. 1980. ‘Nad miastami’ in Gdzie wschodzi soce i kdy zapada. Kraków: Znak: 124. Ochman, Jerzy. 1995. redniowieczna filozofia ydowska. Kraków: Universitas. Panas, Wadysaw. 1997. Ksiga blasku. Traktat o kabale w prozie Brunona Schulza. Lublin: Wydawnictwo Towarzystwa Naukowego KUL. ——. 2001. Bruno od Mesjasza. Rzecz o dwóch ekslibrisach oraz jednym obrazie i kilkudziesiciu rysunkach Brunona Schulza. Lublin: Wydawnictwo UMCS. Scholem, Gershom. 1996. Kabaa i jej symbolika (tr. R. Wojnakowski). Kraków: Znak. Schulz, Bruno. 1990. ‘Bruno Schulz: An Essay for S.I. Witkiewicz’ in Letters and Drawings of Bruno Schulz (ed. J. Ficowski). New York: Fromm International: 110-114. ——. 1998a. Opowiadania, wybór esejów i listów. Wrocaw: Ossolineum. ——. 1998b. The Collected Works of Bruno Schulz (ed. J. Ficowski). London: Picador. ——. 2008. The Street of Crocodiles and Other Stories (tr. C. Wieniewska). New York: Penguin. Sucki, Arnold. 1966. ‘Bruno Schulz’ in Eklogi i psalmodie. Warsaw: Czytelnik: 5960. Unterman, Alan. 1994. Encyklopedia tradycji i legend ydowskich (tr. O. Zienkiewicz). Warszawa: Ksi ka i Wiedza. urek, Sawomir Jacek. 1999. …lotny trud póistnienia. O motywach judaistycznych w poezji Arnolda Suckiego. Kraków: Ksi garnia Akademicka.
“The Lie Always Rises to the Surface like Oil”. Toward a Metafictional Reading of Karol Irzykowski’s Pauba and Bruno Schulz’s Fiction Dieter De Bruyn Abstract: In this article, Karol Irzykowski’s canonical autothematic novel Pauba (1903) is confronted with Bruno Schulz’s multifaceted fiction. Whereas Pauba, with its dominant discursive layer, has been systematically received as an autothematic novel, Schulz’s stories, with their manifold form, keep resisting any similar interpretative model. However, free of the yoke of their seemingly univocal selfinforming tendency (Irzykowski) or of their supposed ultimate inexhaustibility (Schulz), these texts emerge as representations of a similar literary critical discourse. On this metafictional level, they incessantly display a significant interaction between the conventional illusion of a third dimension (depth, signifié) and the reflexive consciousness of the inevitable two-dimensionality of the text (surface, signifiant).
Introduction: From Autotematyzm To Metafiction In almost every national tradition one can find literary works whose titles are referred to all the time, but which are hardly ever read from cover to cover. It goes without saying that Joyce’s Ulysses is the classic example of such “most unread novels”. One of the most obvious Polish specimens, however, is undoubtedly Karol Irzykowski’s highly experimental novel Pauba (1903). Although Pauba has been referred to as an important literary composition by generations of critics and readers alike, one could posit that only few people actually know what the novel is all about. Even those critics who have tried to grasp the novel’s main ideas seem to have difficulty getting to its very core. The same certainly holds true for both of Bruno Schulz’s collections of stories, Sklepy cynamonowe (Cinnamon Shops, 1934) and Sanatorium pod klepsydr (Sanatorium Under the
84
Dieter De Bruyn
Sign of the Hourglass; 1937),1 of which Stanislaw Eile has correctly remarked that “the extensive use of figurative language renders [the] message rather confusing and consequently open to a variety of esoteric readings, which often demonstrate the inventiveness of critics rather than representing a convincing explication of the text” (1996: 97). It seems that both Pauba and Schulz’s complete fiction, notwithstanding their many differences in form and content, at least share one particular feature: in both cases, the reader is faced with a certain formal residue, some kind of narrative distortion, which causes a continual postponement of the text’s explication. Despite this common characteristic, hardly any attempt has been made to propose a similar reading of both Irzykowski and Schulz. This is all the more surprising if one takes into consideration the many literary critical accounts, in which both authors are treated as belonging to the same experimental or avant-garde vein of Polish Modernism (e.g. Taylor Sen 1972, Nycz 1997, Bolecki 1999). The main reason for the absence of one single approach to both Irzykowski and Schulz (apart from the aforementioned general literary historical categories) is of course the completely different impression which these authors’ texts make at first glance. For many years, due to its heterogeneous structure and its peremptory self-informing layer,2 Pauba could only be “naturalized” with recourse to the concept of autotematyzm or, more specifically, to the genre of the “powie autotematyczna” (“autothematic novel”). Since it was first introduced 1
All further references to these collections will be given as SC and SpK. Quotations of the original Polish text are taken from Schulz 1964, the English translations are from Schulz 1989 (hereafter referred to as CF). 2 The novel consists of five different parts: the introductory novella ‘Sny Marii Dunin (palimpsest)’ (‘The Dreams of Maria Dunin (A Palimpsest)’), in which an anonymous archaeologist reports how he was initiated into the hidden “Brotherhood of the Great Bell” (“Bractwo Wielkiego Dzwonu”), then fell in love with the leader’s daughter Maria, and eventually married her sister Hermina, after which the narrator admits that the entire story is a falsification; the “actual” novel ‘Pauba (studium biograficzne)’ (‘Pauba (A Biographical Study)’), which tells the story of Piotr Strumieski’s married life with Angelika and, after her suicide, with Ola; and three explanatory essays, respectively entitled ‘Uwagi do Pauby’ (‘Remarks to Pauba’), ‘Wyjanienie Snów Marii Dunin i zwi zek ich z Paub’ (‘An Explanation of The Dreams of Maria Dunin and Its Connection with Pauba’), and ‘Szaniec Pauby’ (‘The Rampart of Pauba’). The point to note is that even the actual novel consists mainly of explanatory digressions, discussing, for example, the protagonists’ psychology and – most prominently – the form of the novel which is being written.
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 85
by the famous literary critic Artur Sandauer, the concept of autotematyzm has made a stunning career in Polish criticism, which eventually led to its complete exhaustion (cf. De Bruyn 2007a). The problem with this term is that it mainly focuses on explicit thematizations of the artistic genesis and the textual process, thus excluding more implicit techniques of literary reflexivity. Furthermore, by treating such self-informing tendencies in literary texts as fully reliable approaches to the same literary texts, propagators of autotematyzm usually end up in a kind of circular reasoning: discursive parts of a certain text are used in order to elucidate the same text. Due to this methodological fallacy, for instance, Irzykowski’s truly equivocal anti-Modernist3 commentaries were interpolated rather unequivocally into many literary critical accounts, so that Pauba started functioning as a univocal, more or less novelistic critique of conventional literary techniques and reading habits, rather than as an extraordinary artistic representation of the highly sophisticated literary critical self-consciousness of the author.4 Schulz’s fiction, on the other hand, even though it contains a similar but less dominant and univocal self-informing layer, has hardly ever been read as an example of “autothematic” writing. At the same time, however, this most enigmatic collection of narrative pieces has posed even larger interpretative problems. Immediately after its publication in the 1930’s, as Wodzimierz Bolecki has sufficiently proved, Schulz’s prose conflicted with the horizon of expectations of most Polish critics in two particular ways: “First, it urged to violate the generally accepted rules for reading epic literature, and second – it aroused such readerly reactions which were reserved for reading lyrical works” (“Po pierwsze, zmuszaa do pogwacenia spoecznie zaakceptowanych regu czytania epiki, po drugie – wywoywaa takie reakcje czytelnicze, jakie zrezerwowano dla lektury utworów lirycznych”; 1996 [1982]: 304). It could be argued that this twofold orientation holds true to a certain extent for the majority of critical readings of Schulz’s fiction up to now. Whereas “poetic” or 3
In this case, “anti-Modernist” refers to the traditional Polish interpretation of literary Modernism, according to which this current is limited to the early, 1890-1900 period of Moda Polska, instead of encompassing the entire 1890-1930 period. 4 This tradition includes such postwar critical works as Wyka 1977 [1948], Lipiski 1949, Zengel 1958, D browska 1963, Werner 1965, Gowiski 1969, St pnik 1973, Taylor Sen 1972, Budrecka 1981, Drozdowski 1987, and Eile 1996: 42-45.
86
Dieter De Bruyn
“logocentric” readings of this prose generally do injustice to its narrative core, any approach starting from the rules and conventions of traditional epic literature will always struggle with the many narrative inconsistencies in the stories under scrutiny.5 Consequently, as Krzysztof Stala has argued, too many critics limit themselves to “some fragmentary, marginal reading, being rather aware of the inexhaustibleness of Schulz’s prose than trying to define this inexhaustibleness, domesticate it with some proposal richer than ‘expression of the inexpressible’” (1993: 1). One of the main reasons for this difficult critical reception is that many of these interpretations are methodologically fallacious in much the same way as the already mentioned “autothematic” readings of Pauba. Again, discursive parts of the text are interpolated rather recklessly in the critic’s account as reliable sources for interpreting the same text. As a result, many of these readings are, indeed, merely marginal commentaries on the text’s discursive dimension rather than thorough analyses of the text as a literary representation. In recent years, some scholars have tried to establish new ways of interpreting the formal or “nonnarrative” residue which both authors’ texts clearly display. In one way or another, all these attempts build on an earlier interpretative model by Wodzimierz Bolecki. In what is undoubtedly the most valuable and comprehensive study on the narrative prose of such interwar writers as Bruno Schulz, Stanisaw Ignacy Witkiewicz (Witkacy), and Witold Gombrowicz, Bolecki (1996 [1982]) for the first time focuses on generations of readers’ difficulties to construct a consistent story world out of these most alienating and unusually discursive narrative accounts rather than repeating once more the texts’ main philosophical ideas, presenting themselves in the ready-made form of unequivocal selfcommentaries. More specifically, Bolecki argues that the interwar authors under scrutiny have propagated a new “poetical prose model” (“poetycki model prozy”) as an alternative to the prevailing “vehicular prose model” (“wehikularny model prozy”; 14). Whereas in the latter case literary language is overshadowed by its referential function (as in Realism), in the former case it “draws attention to its autonomy” (“zwraca uwag na swoj autonomi ”) and thus takes on a “reflexive character” (“character samozwrotny”; 12). What the critic is aiming at 5
Cf. the introduction to this volume for a critical discussion of the key figures and important currents in Schulzology.
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 87
is not necessarily the numerous metapoetic utterances in many of these works but first and foremost a manifest “semiotic overorganization” (“nadorganizacja znakowa”; 13) on all narrative levels – i.e., including the lexical (stylistic) as well as the compositional, fabular, or semantic structure of the text. Although Bolecki explicitly excludes Pauba from his “poetical prose model” for reasons of periodization and because of the alleged “cognitive uniformity of the narration” (“jednolito poznawcza narracji”; 92), the novel will later return in his critical writings as an important predecessor of this “poetical” vein of Polish Modernist fiction because of its reflexive, parodic and grotesque attitude toward literary conventions (cf. Bolecki 1999, 2003). The idea of a “parodic-grotesque current” (“nurt parodystyczno-groteskowy”) that connects Pauba with the fiction of Schulz, Witkacy and Gombrowicz was further developed by Brygida Pawowska-J drzyk (1995: 155). According to her, the “autothematic” character of Irzykowski’s novel has always overshadowed its parodic and grotesque effects. In order to restore the balance, PawowskaJ drzyk draws attention to the parodic evocation of existing literary conventions in all kinds of (either literally or figuratively) inserted “texts” (i.e., both Strumieski’s and Gasztold’s literary projects Ksiga mioci (The Book of Love) and Chora mio (A Sick Love), and the introductory novella ‘The Dreams of Maria Dunin’) as well as to the eventual self-parodic attitude toward the evolving novelistic product itself. More important, though, is the use of the grotesque as a parodic device. Whereas most critics had focused predominantly on the discursive (or the narrator’s) level of the text, Pawowska-J drzyk for the first time stresses the (less overtly) parodic function of its narrative and stylistic structure. On the level of the story, for instance, she perceives a recurrent grotesque transformation of “sublimity” (“wznioso”) into “stupidity” (“mieszno”; 156), as in the scene where Piotr Strumieski kisses Berestajka while observing a centipede on the wall (cf. Irzykowski 1976 [1903]: 339).6 Furthermore, both on the discursive and the narrative level of the text, the critic observes a grotesque deformation of conventional literary language, e.g. through the use of awkward neologisms and strained metaphors, through the deliberate combination of different stylistic registers, or more simply 6
All further references will be given as P.
88
Dieter De Bruyn
by incessantly putting typical phrases between ironic quotation marks (161-163). According to Pawowska-J drzyk, it is exactly this particular combination of grotesque scenes with a systematic use of the “linguistic grotesque” (“groteska lingwistyczna”; 161) which makes Pauba similar to Schulz’s fiction. Indeed, whereas the presence of grotesque situations in the latter’s stories is self-evident, his baroque style reaches a comparable degree of “semiotic overorganization” through a continuous flow of metaphors. In a book-length study on the entire “parodic-grotesque current” in Polish Modernism, Pawowska-J drzyk further develops her initial findings on Irzykowski’s novel. More specifically, she introduces the concept of “mediocrity” (“bylejako”) as a new interpretative tool. “Mediocrity (in a descriptive, and not in an axiological sense)”, she argues, “is a term which is used for denoting the specificity of the poetics of works which stand out with a deliberate carelessness of their artistic execution” (“Bylejako’ (w znaczeniu opisowym, a nie oceniaj cym) to termin stosowany […] dla okrelenia swoistoci poetyki utworów wyró niaj cych si celow niedbaoci wykonania artystycznego”; 2002: 89). In her classification of devices of mediocrity, Pawowska-J drzyk makes a distinction between “static motives” (“motywy statyczne”), such as the representation of “shoddy” objects or physical deficiencies, and “dynamic motives” (“motywy dynamiczne”), such as inadequacies in the narrative structure of the text (90-91). Whereas the “static” version of the poetics of mediocrity brings to mind Schulz’s fascination with tandeta (“trash”), a more “dynamic” approach can be discerned in Pauba. More specifically, Pawowska-J drzyk stresses the central role of the “‘anti-aesthetic’ word-symbol” (“‘antyestetyczne’ sowosymbol”; 105) pauba in Irzykowski’s poetics.7 Unlike tandeta, she argues, the concept of pauba induces a dynamics of “mediocrity” on 7
Pauba is a dialectal form in Polish, which may take on a lot of meanings. Irzykowski continuously plays with this polysemy in his novel (cf. infra). Quite surprisingly, the enormous poetical relevance of the word has been underestimated by virtually all earlier critics. Moreover, as we have seen, critics tend to limit themselves to some kind of critical repetition of those discursive parts of the texts in which the meaning of pauba is discussed by the narrating “author” (i.e. the “author-like” narrator who incessantly comments on the story told). One of the few exceptions can be found in Ewa Szary-Matywiecka’s brilliant, though quite idiosyncratic, monograph on the Polish “autothematic novel”, in which this symbolic keyword is even considered to be a forerunner of Sandauer’s concept of autotematyzm (1979: 13-18).
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 89
several levels of the text of the novel.8 Of course, Pauba as a whole, with its intricate heterogeneous structure, is already a “shoddy” artifact in itself, but what Pawowska-J drzyk is particularly aiming at is the interplay between the level of the story and the level of the narration. On the level of the story, Piotr Strumieski and the other protagonists cannot but accept that their conventional ideals (of love, fidelity, etc.) are constantly compromised by the very nature of everyday reality. On the level of the narration, this conflict is described as the clash between the “constructive element” (“pierwiastek konstrukcyjny”) and the “‘palubic’ element” (“pierwiastek paubiczny”). As a result, a dual dynamics of “mediocrity” is generated: Demaskowanie stereotypów i zafaszowa odbywa si w utworze na drodze dyskursywnej rewizji fantazmatów (metoda wiwisekcji), a tak e poprzez fabularne sprowadzanie ich ad absurdum, w czym nieocenione usugi oddaj pisarzowi parodia i groteska. Obydwie wymienione paszczyzny dziea – narracyjna i fabularna – stanowi domen swoicie poj tej “bylejakoci”. (106) (In the work, the unmasking of stereotypes and imitations is implemented not only through the discursive revision of the phantasms (method of vivisection) but also by leading them ad absurdum on the level of the story, in which the writer receives valuable support of the devices of parody and grotesque. On both the levels mentioned above – of the narration and of the story – a specifically conceived “mediocrity” comes to the surface.)
In other words, by introducing the idea of a poetics of “mediocrity”, Pawowska-J drzyk now gives a more particular interpretation of the “parodic-grotesque” clash between the ideal (sense) and reality (chaos) in such novels as Pauba – a problem which she had already touched upon in her earlier writings. No matter how valuable Pawowska-J drzyk’s notion of the poetics of mediocrity might be for the critical reassessment of the fiction of such writers as Irzykowski, Schulz, Gombrowicz, and Witkacy, the focus of her analysis is predominantly on these works’ “predisposition to the extra-discursive evocation of philosophical contents” (“predyspozycja do pozadyskursywnego ewokowania treci 8
As I will demonstrate in the last section of this article, the concept of tandeta in fact lies at the basis of an intricate semiotic “dynamics” as well.
90
Dieter De Bruyn
filozoficznych”; 5), or, more specifically, on their search for some ultimate signifié that is behind the represented chaos of reality. What she seems to overlook, however, is that these works’ protest against any schematic rendering of reality is eventually directed against the evolving literary product itself. In other words, the represented “migration of forms” (“w drówka form”; Schulz 1964: 682) – the chaos of reality – is strongly interrelated with the representing “dispersion of signifiants” – the chaos of language. As we have seen, in order to go behind this problematic signifying form, Bolecki proposes a “poetic” reading of these narrative works. As Krzysztof Kosiski has argued, however, by introducing this “new, alternative readability” (“nowa […], alternatywna czytelno”), Bolecki in fact tactfully evades the often indicated problem of the “unreadability” (“nieczytelno”) and the subsequent “incomprehensibility” (“niezrozumialstwo”) of these extraordinary fictions (2000: 20). According to Kosiski, these texts are never completely “unreadable” or “incomprehensible”. What should be done, then, is exactly to define this complicating factor, this paradoxical “growth” (“narost”; 21) or “formal residue” (cf. supra). In his paper, Kosiski proposes to use the notion of “stylization” (“stylizacja”; 21). What makes Kosiski’s analysis particularly interesting, is that it points at Pauba as the first Polish novel which explicitly discusses its own “stylized character” (“stylizacyjny charakter”; 24). On the second last page, more exactly, one can read as follows: A teraz gdy si wie, jak Pauba nie jest, pojmie si te , czym ona jest: Jest ona monstrualn ruin – a i to tylko stylizowan. Czy tak jak j powinno si pisa ka de dzieo? Czy to jest program poezji, poezji przyszoci? I znów mamy b dne koo. Wszak e program Pauby dotyczy tylko jej samej, znika razem z ni . W ka dym dziele autor na nowo bierze rozmach i na nowo stosunkuje si do kwestii “poezji” […], dzieo jest tylko ladem tego stosunkowania si . (P 586; italics mine) (So, now that we know what Pauba is not like, it should also be clear what it is: it is a monstrous ruin – be it merely a stylized one. Should every work be written like this one? Is this the program of poetry, of the poetry of the future? And again we have a vicious circle. Indeed, the program of Pauba only touches the work itself – it expires together with it. In each work the author gathers momentum again and once more determines his position about the question of “poetry” – the work is merely a trace of this act of positioning.)
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 91
In this fragment, Irzykowski not only puts into perspective his own destructive literary practice (“it is a monstrous ruin – be it merely a stylized one”) but also clearly describes the technique of stylization: its function is to somehow put into words what in fact cannot be put into words, to show what precedes its verbal phase, to “reveal its own usurping nature” (“ujawni swoje uzurpatorstwo”; Kosiski 2000: 24). In this way, stylization mediates between what the literary work eventually conveys (a text which is merely a “trace”) and the creative process by which it is preceded (the “positioning” of the author toward the question of poetry). Whereas the majority of literary texts tend to create the illusion of a particular reality or a particular meaning – thus concealing their “own usurping nature” (toward reality, toward meaning), – the technique of stylization makes this “lie” to come to the surface.9 In my opinion, what all these approaches of the specificity of the experimental vein of twentieth-century Polish fiction share is, in fact, a particular sensitivity to these texts’ reflexivity. More specifically, each particular approach focuses on certain textual signals which – to a larger extent than in more conventional works of fiction – refer to their own literary (linguistic, fictional) form: to their own poetics (poetycko), to their own deformity (groteskowo), to the “carelessness of their own artistic execution” (bylejako), or to the “usurping nature” of their own language (stylizacja). At the same time, critics have always been conscious of the presence of explicit “autothematic” statements in the majority of these texts. Due to the conceptual rigidity of the notion of autotematyzm, however, no attempts have been made to link together both these reflexive techniques, i.e. the inclusion of “autothematic” comments and the more implicit device of “foregrounding” certain literary conventions. Of course, one could quite simply treat all these works within the framework of literary reflexivity, but due to the wide variety and omnipresence of reflexive devices in all of them, it seems better to introduce the concept of metafiction as a new literary critical tool. Unlike autotematyzm (which suggests a thematic subgenre) and reflexivity (which primarily denotes the general device), metafiction 9
As Kosiski correctly remarks, the “stylistic over-organization” – to use a variant of Bolecki’s notion of “semiotic over-organization” – is not limited to the narrative level of Pauba because on the discursive level one may come across many passages in which the “narrating author” loses himself in a mixture of various discursive styles.
92
Dieter De Bruyn
emphasizes the permanent bifurcation of the fictional discourse into a referential and a reflexive level (cf. Waugh’s definition of metafiction as “the construction of a fictional illusion […] and the laying bare of that illusion”; 1984: 6). More exactly, whereas autotematyzm manifests itself in the form of a separate metalinguistic discourse beside the common discourse of the object language, metafiction can best be defined as a specific “borderline discourse […] between fiction and criticism” (Currie 1995: 2) that is represented in the text in ever varying manners. In fact, these different textual devices (either forms of foregrounding or forms of commentary) are merely representations of a discourse that, on the other side of the borderline between fiction and criticism, should be answered with a similarly self-conscious literary critical discourse. With regard to Irzykowski and Schulz, the question is whether the metafictional discourse that their respective texts represent in a different way bears certain resemblances. Do both metafictional projects stem from a (more or less) similar attitude toward the essence of literary practice? In order to answer this question, one could start from Pawowska-J drzyk’s hypothesis that what is behind the grotesque strategies of both authors is the philosophical ambition to grasp the sense (sens) of the chaos of reality. Applied to literary practice, one could posit that both authors show a specific interest in the dynamics between surface (the text) and depth (meaning, sense). What they seem to diagnose is that no matter how hard literature, by analogy with reality itself, tries to add a third dimension (depth, signifié), the reader will always be confronted with the twodimensional reality of the text (surface, signifiant). In order to substantiate my hypothesis, I will first focus on those textual features which expose the search for depth, for illusion or representation, and then on the various ways in which this pursuit is disillusioned by a foregrounding of the textual surface, of the materiality of the text. In the concluding section, I will argue that this metafictional dynamics between depth and surface crystallizes, as it were, into such reflexive metaphors as pauba, manekin, and tandeta. Irzykowski and Schulz between Surface and Depth In their respective works, both Schulz and Irzykowski push forward the absolute “truth” as an almost unattainable ideal. More specifically,
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 93
the ill-fated ambition to get to the core or the essence of things is characteristic of the tragicomic fate of several of their protagonists. In Schulz’s stories, the search for truth is the main preoccupation of both Jacob and Joseph; whereas the former is often busy with carrying out the most subversive experiments, the latter is repeatedly depicted when undertaking bizarre nightly quests. Examples of Jacob’s experiments can be found in such stories as ‘Ptaki’ (‘Birds’) and ‘Kometa’ (‘The Comet’); characteristic of his endeavours is that they are systematically thwarted by Adela, who represents the conventional order of everyday reality. Joseph, on the other hand, is struggling with the labyrinthine quality of (nocturnal) reality in such oft-discussed stories as ‘Sklepy cynamonowe’ (‘Cinnamon Shops’), ‘Ulica krokodyli’ (‘The Street of Crocodiles’), ‘Wiosna’ (‘Spring’), and ‘Sanatorium pod klepsydr ’ (‘Sanatorium Under the Sign of the Hourglass’). During these journeys, the world reveals itself to the young Joseph as an arbitrary configuration of signs which misleads him again and again. In ‘Cinnamon Shops’, for instance, the boy is incessantly led away from his initial goal to visit the “cinnamon shops” with their exotic goods. His journey brings him to a series of imaginary places (dark streets, a gymnasium, an art room, the principal’s private rooms, etc.) that momentarily seem to materialize, after which they merge into something new. After a final ride in a carriage, the boy ends up somewhere on the countryside while being completely under the spell of the mystery of the night. Whereas ‘Cinnamon Shops’ comes to an end with a timid prostration for the nocturnal element, the novella ‘Spring’ leads Joseph into a complete fiasco due to the protagonist’s usurping attitude toward fictional reality. Though he wanted to win Bianca for himself, Joseph cannot but come to the conclusion that his manipulation of the course of events has eventually lead to the successful seduction of Bianca by Rudolph: W zalepieniu moim podj em si wykadu pisma, chciaem by tumaczem woli boskiej, w faszywym natchieniu chwytaem przemykaj ce przez markownik lepe poszlaki i kontury. czyem je niestety tylko w dowoln figur . Narzuciem tej wionie moj re yseri , podo yem pod jej nie obj ty rozkwit wasny program i chciaem j nagi , pokierowa wedug wasnych planów. (SpK 264) (In my blindness, I undertook to comment on the text, to be the interpreter of God’s will; I misunderstood the scanty traces and indications I believed
94
Dieter De Bruyn I found in the pages of the stamp album. Unfortunately, I wove them into a fabric of my own making. I have imposed […] my own direction upon this spring, I devised my own program to explain its immense flourishing and wanted to harness it, to direct it according to my own ideas; TCF 202)
Similar tragic attempts to grasp reality and lay bare its “truth” appear in numerous variants in Pauba, too. The most striking examples are, of course, the subsequent “próby w g b” (“attempts to get to the core”) that are undertaken by Piotr Strumieski in order to get to the bottom of the mystery of his first marriage (the so-called “Angelika case” or sprawa Angeliki). While trying to sort out the past and to uphold the ideal of absolute, platonic love, however, he is permanently thwarted by the sensual aspect of love, which systematically leads him away from his “underground life” (“podziemne ycie”) and incites him to have sexual relations. Irzykowski represents this conflict discursively by means of the dialectics between the “constructive element” (“pierwiastek konstrukcyny”) and the “palubic element” (“pierwiastek paubiczny”), which in fact refers to the struggle between nature and culture in man.10 The same dynamics of delving in search of a particular core without eventually disclosing it reappears in the introductory novella ‘The Dreams of Maria Dunin’ in the form of the allegorical digging for the Great Bell. In this case, the victim is Maria Dunin, who comes so close to the ideal of platonic love, that the Brotherhood of the Great Bell has no other option than to sentence her to death, since its paradoxical task is exactly to suggest the existence of the ideal (by digging for the Great Bell) while simultaneously hiding its secret (that is, the nonexistence of the Great Bell) for humanity. By repeatedly representing the tragedy of striving for the ideal, both Irzykowski and Schulz appear to be conscious of the inevitable fiasco of the enterprise. The same consciousness of this striving being eventually led away by other motives manifests itself even more distinctly on the discursive level of the respective texts. Toward the end of Schulz’s story ‘Manekiny’ (‘Tailors’ Dummies’), for example, the narrator reports that
10 This kind of oppositions is, of course, particularly important in Schulz’s stories as well (cf. the struggle between Jacob and Adela). Cf. Bolecki 2005 and Ritz 2005 for recent discussions of gender aspects in Irzykowski and Schulz.
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 95
[j]est godne uwagi, jak w zetkni ciu z niezwykym tym czowiekiem rzeczy wszystkie cofay si niejako do korzenia swego bytu, odbudowyway swe zjawisko a do metafizycznego j dra, wracay niejako do pierwotnej idei, a eby w tym punkcie sprzeniewierzy si jej i przechyli w te w tpliwe, ryzykowne i dwuznaczne regiony, które nazwiemy tu krótko regionami wielkiej herezji. (SC 79) ([i]t is worth noting how, in contact with that strange man, all things reverted, as it were, to the roots of their existence, rebuilt their outward appearance anew from their metaphysical core, returned to the primary idea, in order to betray it at some point and to turn into the doubtful, risky, and equivocal regions which we shall call for short the Regions of the Great Heresy; CF 30)
In other words, any attempt at “getting to the core” is presented as some kind of heresy, as an improper usurpation that must necessarily lead to deviations. In Pauba this same idea is depicted as a selfregulating mechanism in man. In ‘The Dreams of Maria Dunin’ the principle of self-regulation is represented in an allegorical way in the form of the “Hall of the Manometers” (“Hala Manometrów”) where Acheronta Movebo, the leader of the Brotherhood, monitors a series of manometers that are connected with reality in order to check whether the pressure of mankind on the “ideal” is still under control. As soon as the pressure starts to be threatening, the Brotherhood disposes of the principle of the “Safety Valve” (“Klapa Bezpieczestwa”) in order to keep the secret of the Great Bell. Maria Dunin could be called the most prominent victim of this principle: eliminating her should rescue the rest of mankind. Whereas the mechanism is merely suggested in guarded terms in the mysterious novella, its functioning is described at large in ‘An Explanation of The Dreams of Maria Dunin and Its Connection with Pauba’. The starting point is the “theory that certain ideals, as well as the sciences and finally also love and poetry, contain a centrifugal element; if they would be taken seriously and carried through to the end, they would have to destroy man” (“teoria, e niektóre ideay, dalej nauki, wreszcie mio i poezja maj w sobie pierwiastek odrodkowy, bo wzi te na serio i przeprowadzone a do koca, musiayby zniszczy czowieka”; P 565). This theory can be linked with the old manuscript from ‘The Dreams of Maria Dunin’, which contains the warning that “earth is covered with a certain fluid, the existence of which existence nobody knows but which will ignite once, on some small point, shaken up by the tones of the awoken Bell
96
Dieter De Bruyn
and blow up the world” (“w wiecie rozlane jest pewne fluidum, o którego istnieniu nikt nie wie, które jednak kiedy na jakim maym punkcie, wstrz ni te dwi kami zbudzonego Dzwonu, zaponie i wiat rozsadzi”; P 28). This is exactly what makes Maria Dunin’s behavior so threatening: by taking the ideal of platonic love so seriously, she is drawn apart from her human core by a centrifugal element. Her death is a safety valve that should save the rest of mankind. In order to counter their own disintegration, however, real human beings have their own safety valve at their disposal: Z pierwiastkiem odrodkowym walczy jednak pierwiastek dorodkowy, instynkt samozachowawczy ludzi i wiata. wiat wytrzymuje tylko pewne maximum brania rzeczy na serio, w ostatecznej bowiem chwili dziaa wentyl, który nadmiar wyrzuca, a idea redukuje do przyzwoitej miary […] Naturalnie w wiecie psychicznym odbywa si funkcjonowanie wentyla mniej lub wi cej niewiadomie. Bractwo WD za jest jakby uwiadomionym dziaaniem tego instynktu samozachowawczego natury ludzkiej, jego hipostaz , najwy szym centralnym urz dem. (P 565-566) (The centrifugal element, however, is counteracted by a centripetal element, that is, the instinct for self-preservation of people and the world. The world tolerates only a certain maximum of taking things seriously, since at the very last moment a valve is put into operation, which allows the surplus to escape and reduces the ideal to acceptable dimensions. Obviously, in the psychic world this valve operates more or less unconsciously. The Brotherhood of the GB, then, could be considered the conscious operation of the instinct for self-preservation of human nature, its hypostasis, its highest central body.)
What this passage illustrates is that Piotr Strumieski and the other protagonists from Pauba are conditioned by the same mechanism as Maria Dunin. What is demonstrated in ‘The Dreams of Maria Dunin’ on the level of the story, by means of the allegorical activities of the Brotherhood, reappears in the actual novel on the level of the narrator’s psychoanalytical comments. In fact, by repeatedly compromising the human pursuit of the ideal, Irzykowski primarily wants to elucidate the complexity of the psychological motives that lie at the basis of all human deeds. In the ‘Trio autora’ (‘Author’s Trio’) chapter, which seems to be crucial for understanding the poetical principles that govern Pauba, this ambition to probe into the “subterranean psychic life” (“podziemne ycie psychiczne”; P 447) of man is expressed as follows:
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 97
Dotychczasowym b dem byo, e si gano albo za pytko, albo – przeskakuj c cae ycie nast pcze – za g boko, tj. tam, gdzie ju nic by nie mo e, i robiono rzekome wizje kosmiczne zamiast uprawia introspekcj . Mnie si zdaje, e zbada warstw na kilkaset metrów pod tzw. powierzchni duszy – to mo e wystarczy, nie trzeba szuka nadiru. (P 447) (Until now, the mistake has been made of probing either not deeply enough, or – while skipping the entire secondary life – too deeply, that is, where nothing can be found anymore, and of producing so-called cosmic visions instead of doing an introspection. In my opinion, it is probably sufficient to probe into the layer a few hundred metres below the so-called surface of the soul – to search for the nadir is rather unnecessary.)
What is suggested here is that by confining oneself to an examination of the human psyche on a “relative” depth, one can gain insight into the problem of “secondary life” – that is, the human habit of organizing life by means of a number of “absolute” concepts (love, truth, faithfulness, etc.) which separate us from “real” life without bringing us closer to the ideals we strive for. The only way, then, to represent the problematic mental life of mankind in literature, or in any verbal form at all, is by continually exposing the relativity of its representation, which can never escape the tension between surface and depth, lie and truth, or signifiant and signifié. In their attempt to reveal a certain “truth”, whether it is the “soul” (Irzykowski) or “myth” (Schulz), both authors are aware of the inevitable defeat right from the very start. Schulz explains this awareness in his essay for Witkacy: W ze, na który dusza zostaa zasupana, nie jest faszywym w zem, rozchodz cym si za poci gni ciem koca. Przeciwnie, coraz cianiej si
zw la. Manipulujemy przy nim, ledzimy bieg nici, szukamy koca i z tych manipulacyj powstaje sztuka. (1964: 681) (The knot the soul got itself tied up in is not a false one that comes undone when you pull the ends. On the contrary, it draws tighter. We handle it, trace the path of the separate threads, look for the end of the string, and out of these manipulations comes art; 1990: 111)
To put it another way, striving for the unattainable ideal while being fully conscious of the inevitable failure of such an attempt, manifests itself most prominently in (or rather as) art. A similar thought is
98
Dieter De Bruyn
expressed in the continuation of ‘An Explanation of The Dreams of Maria Dunin’: [Z]waszcza ludzie, którzy najwi cej bij we Wielki Dzwon, wi c myliciele (tacy jak Nietzsche, Ibsen, Schopenhauer) i poeci – u tych funkcjonuje klapa bezpieczestwa najwybitniej. W rozstrzygaj cej chwili cofaj si oni przed konsekwencj i morduj Mari Dunin w sobie. (P 566) (In particular people who ring the Great Bell most often, that is, thinkers (such as Nietzsche, Ibsen, Schopenhauer) and poets – in such people the safety valve functions best. At the critical moment they shrink from the consequences and kill Maria Dunin in themselves.)
What Irzykowski suggests, is that every literary or philosophical work is a construction to the second power, as it additionally renders the ideal, whose representation in man is already problematic, in a closed linguistic form. Although both Schulz and Irzykowski reveal this mechanism in different ways, they continually display the awareness that even their own apparently “open” or “self-conscious” texts are merely constructions; this is why Schulz refers to his own artistic “manipulations” and why the narrating “author” in Pauba confesses without hesitation that he also “belongs to the Brotherhood, from which escape is simply impossible” (“[nale y] do Bractwa, przed którym w ogóle nie ma ucieczki”; P 568).11 From all this, the question arises why both authors, despite their awareness of the inevitable “secondariness” of every literary operation, have decided to produce their texts at all. When even the most self-ironical literary form appears to be a construction, and if every attempt to get to the truth eventually exposes its own deceitfulness, is it then not more authentic to simply refuse to create such constructions? In order to find a way out of this tautological circle, it seems important to stress the role of the reader. More specifically, opposed to the “tragedy” of the (stable, definitive) literary product is always the “pleasure” of the three-dimensional (unstable, provisional) reading process. By exposing in various ways their own two-dimensionality (or grafemiczno ‘graphemicity’ as 11
In another part of Pauba, Irzykowski summarizes the dynamics of the entire novel in the following oft-quoted aphorism: “The lie always rises to the surface like oil, while the truth sinks to the bottom because it is hard and heavy” (“Kamstwo wypywa na wierzch jak oliwa, prawda opada, bo jest cie ka i trudna”; P 289).
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 99
Szary-Matywiecka (1979: 6) would call it), both authors’ texts incite the reader to become aware of his/her own “role” in the textual “game”, or of his/her own “pose” which is merely a “comedy”.12 Both authors have explicitly stressed the constructive dimension of their destructive literary practices. As to Irzykowski, the following striking self-commentary from Beniaminek (Little Benjamin; 1933) could be mentioned: “[D]emaskuj c” i wymiewaj c bohatera, zsolidaryzowaem si z nim […] prawie na caej linii, a zasad swoj wypowiedziaem nawi zuj c do sów Mignon Goethego (która to mówi, gdy j przebrano za anioa): “So laßt mich scheinen, bis ich werde!” […] – to znaczy e tzw. komedia, gest, pozór, obuda itp. maj swoje g bokie uprawnienie. (1976c: 447) (While “demasking” and making fun of the hero, I had almost complete solidarity with him, and I expressed my point of view by repeating the words of Goethe’s Mignon (who is saying this as she is being dressed up as an angel): “So laßt mich scheinen, bis ich werde!” […] – which means that the so-called comedy, gesture, appearance, hypocrisy and the like are entirely legitimate.)
In his essay for Witkacy, Schulz in a similar way draws on the legitimacy of his destructive practices and on the possibility of deriving some indeterminate kind of pleasure from it: Jaki jest sens tej uniwersalnej deziluzji rzeczywistoci, nie potrafi
powiedzie. Twierdz tylko, e byaby ona nie do zniesienia, gdyby nie doznawaa odszkodowania w jakiej innej dymensji. W jaki sposób doznajemy g bokiej satysfakcji z tego rozlunienia tkanki rzeczywistoci, jestemy zainteresowani w tym bankructwie realnoci. (1964: 683) (What the meaning of this universal disillusioning reality is I am not able to say. I maintain only that it would be unbearable unless it was compensated for in some other dimension In some sense we derive a profound satisfaction from the loosening of the web of reality; we feel an interest in witnessing the bankruptcy of reality; 1990: 113)
Although neither Irzykowski nor Schulz mention the actual reader in these passages, they are clearly behaving as “readers” of their own literary world. Only on this level (or in this dimension) of literary
12 Quite remarkably, such concepts as “comedy” (komedia), “role” (rola), and “pose” (poza) are omnipresent in Irzykowski’s and (to a lesser extent) Schulz’s character descriptions.
100
Dieter De Bruyn
communication does it seem possible to escape from the finiteness of the two-dimensional text and to enter into the infinity of the threedimensional act of reading. Particularly when the text presents itself as a “game”, as a finite repertory of rules (conventions) and signs (words), the reader may partake in it as a “player”, repeating his act of reading over and over again as he pleases. Just like a player in a game is forced to play a particular, provisional role, Schulz’s and Irzykowski’s readers are made aware of their temporary task as “readers”. When determining the most dominant signals by which these texts stress their two-dimensionality, the dynamics of surface and depth once more proves extremely useful: after the texts have revealed themselves as the result of a recursive graphic activity (in the form of palimpsests, cryptograms, or arabesques) in order to break the illusion of the ultimate depth, the horizontal orientation of their literary reality is semantically embedded in two specific metaphors of maximal arbitrariness (pauba and tandeta). In this way, the (vertical) search for the unique, authentic truth is transformed into the (horizontal) reality of the recursive, inauthentic act of reading. Palimpsests, Cryptograms, Unattainable Original
Arabesques.
Exegesis
of
the
As has already been sufficiently demonstrated, Schulz’s prose in many ways “vegetates” on the repertory of existing stories or on the primeval “myth”, revealing itself, as it were, as a “palimpsest” or as the “book of arabesques”.13 In both cases the text appears to be the result of a particular graphic activity: either it conceals a number of underlying texts of which certain traces can still be discerned, or it behaves as mere commentary or ornamentation in the margin of the actual yet invisible text. Whatever the case may be, the text always
13 At the center of the discussion of this particular characteristic of Schulz’s prose is, of course, the story triptych ‘Ksi ga’ (‘The Book’), ‘Genialna epoka’ (‘The Age of Genius’), and ‘Spring’. Cf. Lachmann (1992) for the concept of the “book of arabesques” (“So wie das Sinnzentrum, das das Urbuch zu verheißen scheint, im Aufschub bleibt, befinden sich die Bildphantasmen, in denen die Suche nach dem Buch inszeniert wird, in einem Sinnschwebezustand. Da sie in wuchernder, metamorphotischer Bewegung nich auf einen Sinnkern orientiert sind, stürzen sie zentrifugal auseinander. Aber in dieser metamorphotischen, zentrifugalen Bewegung, die ihre punktuelle Identität ständig aufkündigt, schreiben sie selbst ein Buch, das Buch der Arabesken”; 454).
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 101
manifests itself as a mere “text”, that is, as a horizontal configuration of signs which does not pretend to carry within itself a particular semantic core or essence, which is explicitly situated outside (or rather, next to) itself. The palimpsest, on the one hand, conceals a more important text (the Original) of which it is merely a “superscription” or yet another superscription of a single Original. In the case of the arabesque, on the other hand, the text suggests a particular mythic core around which it incessantly circles but which itself is unattainable. The text, which explicitly is a “text” (the result of a graphic activity), urges the reader to the active exegesis of its deeper meaning, though it already carries the unavoidable fiasco of this exegetic act within itself; the actual, (more) authentic text is always elsewhere. As the exegetic act must be repeated over and over again, it is itself foregrounded, as it were, as a process. A similar situation appears in Pauba. Due to its multilayered structure and heterogeneous composition, critics have always questioned the textual and generic status of the novel. More particularly, they had the impression that the actual work (the artistic core) had been overshadowed by the abundant commentary. Immediately after its publication, for instance, Wadysaw Jabonowski called Pauba “an unusual commentary, a great and masterly scaffold for a work which is almost invisible apart from this” (“niepospolity komentarz, wielkie i misterne rusztowanie do dziea, którego po za nim prawie nie wida”; 1903: 407-408). What such critical commentaries suggest is that Irzykowski was mainly interested in contextualizing the actual novel or adding ever new points of view on its rather lame story. In the terminology of this section, one could posit that these critics received the novel as “arabesques” of commentary in the margins of an absent “masterpiece”. Furthermore, such early critics as Kazimierz Wyka also mentioned the palimpsestic structure of the novel, stressing, for example, that it was “a true interlacement of a couple of novels being written simultaneously, without, however, containing one single novel that was fully completed” (“istna plecionka kilku powieci naraz pisanych, ale nie zawiera ani jednej powieci naprawd dopenionej”; Wyka 1977 [1948]: 184). The interpretation of Pauba as some kind of palimpsest that had been written over the actual “text” or “novel” in various layers or versions could easily be legitimized by referring to the following metapoetical utterance in the novel:
102
Dieter De Bruyn Tzw. dzieo sztuki, o ile robione jest pod naporem wewn trznej potrzeby, a nie z myl “obdarzenia ojczystej literatury nowym arcydzieem”, o tyle jest tylko ladem, echem przeomów w duszy “twórcy”. lad mo e by niezupeny, nie dopowiedziany, bo to, co jest dla autora najwa niejsze, najciekawsze, rozegrao si poza utworem. (P 559) (As far as the so-called work of art is made under the pressure of an inner need, and not with the intention of “offering a new masterpiece to national literature”, it is merely a trace, an echo of the changes in the soul of the “creator”. The trace can be incomplete, unfinished, for that which is the most important and interesting for the author is what happened outside the work.)
In other words, beside or under the realized text there is always an eternally absent “text” that is completely consistent with the inner feelings of the author. As Szary-Matywiecka has demonstrated, the dynamics of rewriting and overwriting in Pauba is more complex than can be concluded from the text’s discursive layer. According to her, the novel is characterized by a “different functional application of fiction” (“inne funkcjonalne zu ytkowanie fikcji”; 1979: 23), because the text is not, as is usually the case, producing a story, but it is the other way round: the story is a “prefabrication” that generates a series of textual variants. As a result, the story’s semantic core is always absent, whereas the texts that keep emerging are merely attempts at reading its unattainable essence. What this continual exegesis of the story through an accumulation of provisional readings (“texts”) eventually demonstrates is that every concretization of a text (every “reading”), including that of the actual reader, is dubious and provisional. In other words, by textually dramatizing the reader’s unstable position, Irzykowski’s novel effectuates a foregrounding of the specific role of the reader in any form of literary communication. Whereas Szary-Matywiecka mainly focuses on the “possible” (both realized and merely suggested) textual incarnations of the story of Strumieski’s platonic love for Angelika,14 I (as a reader of the only existing text of the novel) would like to draw attention to the more subtle signals by which the text either directly or indirectly discloses 14
As the critic demonstrates, both Strumieski (in the biography Ksiga mioci/The Book of Love) and his rival Gasztold (in the novel Chora mio/A Sick Love) at a certain point seek to evade the “palubic element” by producing real (semi-)autobiographic texts in which they can easily construct their high ideals of love.
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 103
its deficient, provisional, or palimpsestic character. On many occasions, for instance, the narrating author, who pretends to be in the middle of writing a novel with the same title, suggests that the present version is but one possibility in a long chain of textual representations of his novelistic concept: Pauba already not only has a prehistory (cf. the account of an evening gathering at which the “author” reads an earlier version of his novel to “a circle of invited literators”/“grono zaproszonych literatów”; P573), but also anticipates such future versions as “a popular edition” (“popularne wydanie”; P362), “a school edition” (“szkolne wydanie”; P 419, P 533), and even “the ideal Pauba, the one that should have been written” (“idealna Pauba, taka, jak si powinno byo napisa”; P 569). The question of the possibility of a definitive version of the novel and its relation to the text at hand is further complicated by the addition of the novella ‘The Dreams of Maria Dunin’. Again, notwithstanding the presence of the unifying discursive layer (and, more specifically, the explanatory essay ‘An Explanation of The Dreams of Maria Dunin and Its Connection with Pauba’), the position of the novella in the complete textual reality is far from stable. First of all, in chapter XII of the actual novel the novella ironically enters the fictional reality of Strumieski and Ola. Being some kind of allegorical mirror text of Strumieski’s story (cf. supra), it immediately starts to influence both him and Ola. The latter, for instance, plans to “write a new ‘Maria Dunin’” (“[napisa] now ‘Mari Dunin’”) and even calls Strumieski in passing “the male Maria Dunin” (“m ska Maria Dunin”; P 237). For his part, Strumieski, who is used to devising all kinds of “symmetries” or “constructions” in any given situation, immediately discovers certain parallels between Maria Dunin and himself. His “reading” of the novella is, however, far from unequivocal, and his attitude toward its author similarly hesitates between praise and attempts to “denigrate” him “as a romantic, a decadent, a neurasthenic who worships an erotomaniac, and suchlike” (“poni y […] jako romantyka, dekadenta, neurastenika, który uwietnia erotomank itp.”; P 238). What this example once more illustrates is that as soon as a text serves as a function of the unstable position of the reader, it may “incarnate” in ever new versions. The presence of the novella and its author in the fictional framework of the actual novel also causes a fundamental ontological
104
Dieter De Bruyn
distortion. Not only does it unsettle the conventional closedness of the novelistic text (as the novella is both part of and prior to Pauba), but it also puts into question the author’s authority (as the novella’s author is both said to have passed away and identified with the narrating “author”). Few critics have noted that the novella itself in a similar way distorts the convention of the text as a closed structure and of the narrating “author” as a reliable mediator of the story. The opening lines already hint at this in many ways: Wskutek o ywionej i serdecznej pogadanki, któr a do pónej nocy toczylimy w salonie pastwa X-ów, oproszono mnie, abym w mojej formie, formie szkicu z podró y, opisa pewien wypadek z swego ycia, maj cy zwi zek ze sferami idealnymi, mistycznymi. […] Rzeczywicie mam co takiego w bibliotece swoich wspomnie […] (P 7) (On the occasion of an animated and warm conversation I had well into the night in the salon of Mr and Ms X, I was asked to describe in my form, in the form of a travel account, one of my personal adventures having a connection with the ideal, mystical spheres. I indeed carry something like that in the library of my memories.)
Although this passage suggests a classical story within a story, expressions such as “travel account” and “library of my memories” indicate that the narrative situation might be more stylized than expected. When the narrator occasionally interrupts his account in the following chapters, the initial situation even appears to have disappeared. In the beginning of chapter IV “a certain guy to whom I [the narrator] have read the hitherto collected memories” (“[p]ewien jegomo, któremu przeczytaem dot d spisane wspomnienia”; P 29) is mentioned. A bit further this same “clever guy who has read the beginning of these sheets” (“bystry jegomo, który czyta pocz tek tych lunych kartek”; P 34) reappears. Both examples stress the textual character of what is narrated, thus problematizing the initial narrative situation. This situation is similar to what happens in the actual novel: the story’s essence is “read” in various ways and turned into provisional “texts”. As a result, the reader’s attention is temporarily distracted from the content of the story to the form in which it is passed on. At the same time, the narrator appears to be unreliable and loses his “authorial” status. The novella ends with a true coup de théâtre when it appears that all that preceded was but a mystification. It turns out that the
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 105
narrator (the archaelogist who pretended to have discovered the secret Brotherhood) has become a royal librarian who likes to produce “artifical palimpsests” (“sztuczne palimpsesty”), which he renders more authentic by inserting them into rumpled originals. His surprising conclusion is that “of all these palimpsests this one is the most sophisticated, since I am one of the most excellent members of the Brotherhood of the Great Bell myself!” (“z owych palimpsestów ten wanie celuje wyrafinowaniem, bo ja sam jestem najznakomitszym z Bractwa Wielkiego Dzwonu!”; P 51). This is why the novella carries the subtitle ‘A Palimpsest’; the supposedly authentic story of Maria Dunin is an ingenious construction whose artificiality is disclosed at the end. In ‘An Explanation’, the “author” explains the subtitle as follows: ‘Maria Dunin’ jest palimpsestem, to znaczy tyle co mistyfikacj . […] Autor wypowiada oficjalnie przekonania, pod którymi nale y dopatrywa si innych jego przekona, wr cz przeciwnych tamtym. Poniewa za przy kocu autor nawet i te drugie przekonania ujmuje w cudzysów, przeto mo na powiedzie, e ‘Maria Dunin’ jest palimpsestem do kwadratu. (P 560) (‘Maria Dunin’ is a palimpsest, or in other words, a mystification. The author officially expresses his beliefs, under which one ought to detect his other beliefs, which are diametrically opposed to the former. Given that at the end of the novella even these other beliefs are put in quotation marks by the author, one could state that ‘Maria Dunin’ is a palimpsest to the second power.)
It should be clear that the complex structure of ‘The Dreams of Maria Dunin’ is treated here as a palimpsest only in a symbolic or allegorical way; indeed, having betrayed himself on several occasions in the course of the story (e.g. when reading part of the manuscript or when adding fake “spiritological” texts to existing documents in order to manipulate Maria), the narrator eventually relativizes the entire “text” by presenting it as a mystification. According to Aleksandra Budrecka, the importance of the novella’s last sentence cannot be underestimated. When read as a logical paradox of the Epimenides type (“All Cretans are liars”), it simply suggests that in language “nothing can be stated either on the actual or on the represented reality” (“niczego nie da si orzec o rzeczywistoci, tak realnej jak i przedstawionej”; 1981: XV) because every statement on the truth inevitably calls forth its antithesis (the
106
Dieter De Bruyn
lie). When the closing sentence is separated from the rest of the novella, however, then it may reveal itself as the only truthful statement, of which the “linguistic reality” (“rzeczywisto j zykowa”; XIX) is brought to the surface. As a result, attention is diverted from the “false” world of the archaeologist and Maria Dunin to the “real” world of the narrator, “someone who utters sentences and who establishes their falseness” (“kto, kto wypowiada zdania i kto konstatuje ich faszywo”; XIX). According to Budrecka, the function of this sentence is identical to the many comments in the actual novel; in both cases the inauthentic or linguistic nature of what is narrated is reflexively brought to the surface. What both Budrecka and the narrator in ‘An Explanation’ seem to overlook is that the creative use of the principle of the palimpsest also results in a foregrounding of the textual character of Pauba. The act of “overwriting” other texts confronts the reader with the finiteness of the visible text as opposed to the infinity of all possible texts. As soon as the reader is aware of the (partial) absence of a text that is potentially richer than the text that is before him, the latter may transform before his eyes into an insufficient ornament (an “arabesque”) that merely represents the absence of a more “original” text that has become unattainable. The idea that a text may hide more than it actually discloses is thematized in ‘The Dreams of Maria Dunin’ through the appearance of a mysterious manuscript. Although its content plays an essential role in the further development of the story, the narrator signals that it lacks “a lot of pages, probably the most important ones, as well as the complete conclusion” (“brak byo wielu kartek, prawdopodobnie najwa niejszych, oraz caego koca”; P 28). The motive of an incomplete document that nevertheless is considered to be highly significant also appears in Schulz’s story ‘The Age of Genius’ in the form of the famous szparga or “script”. The resultant readerly tendency to fill in a text’s “blank spaces” (that is, the textual options that could have been rendered but were erased from the textual surface as in a palimpsest) has also been dramatized in Pauba in a particular way. Indeed, both in the novella and, to a lesser extent, in the actual novel certain textual elements are explicitly suppressed, as a result of which the reader is invited to actively bridge the gaps. This strategy ranges from simple omissions – cf. references to “Mr and Ms X” (cf. supra) or to the “vicinity of N… Q.” (“okolice N… Q.; P 9) – to a more general narratorial attitude of
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 107
openly concealing certain (often embarrassing) details. This strategy is also present in Schulz’s stories (e.g. in Joseph’s descriptions of his father’s behavior in ‘Traktat o manekinach’/‘Treatise on Tailors’ Dummies’), and it seems to have its prehistory in ‘The Dreams of Maria Dunin’, in which the narrator, for instance, quotes a letter he received from the Brotherhood “leaving out the words that could be misunderstood (“z opuszczeniem sów, które by mo na faszywie zrozumie”; P 32). Quite ironically, what is left after this act of censorship is completely incomprehensible. Since many of the novella’s lacunae are filled in ‘An Explanation’ (where, for example, the full text of the letter from the Brotherhood is rendered), critics have never questioned this narrative technique. Because the inaccuracies in the account of the novella’s narrator are adjusted by the narrating “author” through whom the rest of the novel is mediated, the latter is considered to be fully reliable. When taking a closer look at this narrator’s account, however, one may discover similar reservations toward what is told. The narrator not only constantly puts his own language between quotation marks or suggests that he might have rendered certain passages in a more poetic way, but also is responsible for the kind of omissions for which he blames the novella’s narrator. In a passage that strikingly resembles the novella’s narration, Strumieski discovers a farewell letter on Angelika’s chest after her suicidal fall in a well: “Part of it was illegible, since the ink had dissolved in the water, but the part that he could decipher – it ended with the question: “All right?” – deeply touched him” (“Cz jego bya nieczytelna, bo atrament rozpuci si
w wodzie, lecz to, co odczyta, zakoczone pytaniem: ‘czy dobrze?’, przej o go do g bi”; P 93). Once again, the reader is confronted with the existence of an important text of which the narrator knows the full content, the protagonist merely the outlines, and the reader nothing but an unimportant detail. In ‘The Rampart of Pauba’ the idea of the complete novel as a text that is deliberately left incomplete for the reader (in other words, as a “palimpsest” that is merely an “echo” or “trace” of an unattainable essence) is commented on as follows: Ja […] nie troszcz si o miny, wygody i kaprysy czytaj cego, nie gram na “strunach jego duszy”, lecz urz dzam mu wykady o Paubie, tej, która gdzie tam napisana cakiem inaczej spoczywa w mojej gowie, a wykadam mu jak profesor, który cz prelekcji mówi gono i
108
Dieter De Bruyn przyst pnie, a druga cz , o której w tpi, czy j kto zrozumie, mówi obrócony do ciany, czasem mrucz c pod nosem. (P 579) (I don’t care about the grimaces, the conveniences, and the whims of the reader; I don’t “pluck his heart’s strings”, but I’m giving him lectures on Pauba, on the version that rests somewhere in my head in a completely different form, and I teach him just like a professor who reads part of his lecture aloud and clearly; the other part, however, of which he doubts that someone will understand it, he utters with his face turned to the wall, just muttering something every now and then.)
As the reader is confronted with a text that openly omits essential information, he might feel tempted to look for certain hidden connections himself. This inevitable reaction will manifest itself particularly when reading those parts in which the cryptographic character of the novel is revealed. As soon as the text manifests itself as a cryptogram, it explicitly becomes a “text” to be deciphered by a reader in order to lay bare the connections underlying the visible “signs”. In many cases, this typically readerly attitude is further influenced by the behavior of the protagonists, who constantly tend to look for hidden meanings themselves. The first target of both readers and protagonists seems to be the choice of proper names. In what is perhaps the most striking example of this characteristic, Piotr (Piotru) Strumieski (born Wosek) draws a parallel between his surname and the “stream” (strumie) in which his future lover Berestajka has just dropped a ring by accident; his conclusion is that Berestajka is now symbolically engaged with him. On the one hand, this association seems to be a quite ironical attempt by Strumieski to (once more) take advantage of certain symmetries between the signs that surround him – ironical, as he got his surname only after having been adopted by a nobleman named Adam Strumieski. On the other hand, however, the parallel between the surname and the concept of a “stream” could be interpreted as more than just a coincidence, as Strumieski’s impulse to organize reality by means of all kinds of “constructions” does indeed seem to be an attempt at escaping the (“palubic”) “stream” of life. A similar manipulation of proper names can also be found a bit earlier in the novel, where Strumieski names his son Pawe/Paweek (Paul) “after the name of the apostle who did not like women” (“od imienia apostoa, który nie lubi kobiet”; P 180). What is suggested here is that Strumieski once more tries to impose a certain scheme on reality; more specifically, by establishing a
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 109
connection with the apostle, he hopes that Paweek will stay away from his mother Ola, who in Strumieski’s model represents physical (as opposed to platonic) love. Moreover, in a way that reminds of the situation in Schulz’s stories (in which the narrator and his father are named Joseph and Jacob respectively), Strumieski also seems to want to connect his son’s fate with his own ambitions (Piotr-Pawe, or Peter-Paul). As we will later see, all these aspirations will eventually prove a failure. It should be clear that this focus on the practice of manipulating and wrongly interpreting names is part of a more general strategy in the novel of mocking the typically human tendency to impose all kinds of “constructions” (words, names, forms, concepts, symbols) on the world. The narrator seems to be particularly aiming at those moments in which such “errors in reasoning” (“b dy mylowe”; P 519 and passim) result in a complete fiasco. Most of these “errors” go back to the idyllic “ideal” love between Strumieski and Angelika, who are reported to be completely obsessed with “the conviction that love is a problem, a cryptogram of the world that has to be solved” (“przekonanie, e mio jest problemem, kryptogramem wiata, który nale y rozwi za”; P 80; italics mine). As we have seen, in his pursuit of the ideal of posthumous love, Strumieski is permanently thwarted by the chaos of life. Until now, critics of Pauba have mainly discussed this clash between the ideal and reality as a psychological problem, much in the same way as it is commented on in the novel’s discursive layer, that is, by means of the dialectics between the “constructive element” and the “palubic element” (cf. supra). However, what has too often been overlooked is that Irzykowski’s protagonists, as they experience the world explicitly as a “text” (a cryptogram, a selection of signs), confront the reader with the inevitable fiasco of his own reading. As a matter of fact, the text abounds in examples of (mis)readings, thus stressing the problematic nature of any exegetic practice. First of all, both the narrator (in his many comments) and the protagonists (e.g. when a copy of the novella falls into their hands) often use literary models in order to “model” their thoughts and behavior. In the novella, then, one of the crucial “texts” to be read by both the protagonists and the reader is the mysterious configuration of three small islands in a local pond, each of which stands for a letter (B, W, and D). This acronym – a “mysterious monogram” (“tajemniczy
110
Dieter De Bruyn
monogram”; P 14) in the narrator’s words – of course refers to the Brotherhood’s full name (Bractwo Wielkiego Dzwonu). Both the archaeologist (when visiting the islands) and the reader (when confronted with a schematic presentation of the three islands), however, are invited to find out the truth of this cryptogram themselves, of “reading” its hidden meaning. In the course of the story, the archaeologist reveals himself as a detective-like figure who attempts to make every insinuation, every detail, and every noise fit into the scheme of his exegesis. In the actual novel the situation is more comparable than is generally assumed. First of all, by adding a map depicting the scene of the action and commenting on it on the opening pages of the novel, Irzykowski seems to want to stress the two-dimensionality of the story world, which is presented as a closed configuration of lines, dots, and letters (A, B, C, D… for indicating the main places) rather than as an illusion of a three-dimensional, “real” reality. Not surprisingly, during his frequent “attempts to get to the core” (cf. supra), Piotr Strumieski approaches this reality primarily as a “text” of which the essence may be revealed through intensive exegesis. Immediately after Angelika’s suicide, for instance, Strumieski starts exploring the estate’s vicinity in search of “signs” that could help him to unravel the mystery of Angelika’s death: Nieraz […], kiedy si […] intensywnie wpatrywa w kontury, ksztaty i barwy naokoo siebie, […] wówczas zakulisowym ruchem fantazji wywoywa w sobie wra enie, e ksztaty te i barwy poruszaj si na swych kraw dziach, jakby maszerowa chciay, zmieniaj si , przepywaj w siebie, e cay wiat chwieje si , dr y i mruga na niego tajemniczo, jakby mu dawa znaki, jakby w nim byo co zakl tego, co si
chce zdradzi, e nie jest takim, jakim si by wydaje. (P 99-100) (Sometimes, when he looked intensively at the contours, the shapes, and the colors around him, he then furtively activated his fantasy in order to evoke the impression in himself that these shapes and colors were set in motion at their edges, as if they wanted to march, to change, to merge into each other, that the entire world was staggering, trembling and secretly winking at him, as if it was giving him signs, as if a curse rested on him that wanted to reveal itself, in brief, that the world was different than it seemed.)
This “trembling” and “winking” of nature reminds us, of course, of the way in which Schulz’s narrator experiences reality. One of the
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 111
most striking examples of this may be found in the opening pages of ‘Spring’, in which this most inspiring season is represented as a whirl of signs, as a loose configuration of signifiers still to be “read” by the narrator.15 In a similar way, Strumieski imposes his “constructions” on the open “text” of reality – to such an extent even that he experiences these constructions “as if he was reading a book” (“jakby ksi k czyta”; P 385). Another striking characteristic is that Strumieski’s “attempts to get to the core”, which are, after all, attempts to grasp nature in cultural schemes, at a certain point start to manifest themselves in the form of artistic activities. In a similar way as Jacob in Schulz’s story ‘Birds’ wants to maintain his ideals of poetry by setting up a colorful colony of birds in the attic of his house, Strumieski attempts to “construct” an ideal picture of his matrimonial life with Angelika by means of a series of creative experiments. He not only sets up a cult of Angelika in the museum which he has created to her memory, but also, in the course of time, tries to initiate his son Paweek into this cult through the most diverse creative activities. One of these activities consists of writing Angelika’s artistic biography (The Book of Love) – an undertaking which ends in a complete fiasco. Just like his ideal of platonic love is permanently thwarted by the sensual aspect of love (cf. supra), Strumieski now cannot but conclude that he must constantly suppress all kinds of (mainly sexual) details when writing down the “ideal” history of Angelika. In the concluding chapter the deforming effect of the palubic element on his creativity is expressed as follows: “What else was this entire history of Angelika than arabesques around the most ordinary obscenities” (“Czym e bya caa historia Angeliki, je eli nie arabeskami naokoo cakiem prostych wistw?”; P 474). After having broken off his biographical project and having devoted himself to the study of the “sexless relations of plants” (“bezpciowe stosunki rolin”; P 285), Strumieski’s impulse to “express himself in some work of art” (“wypowiedzenie si w jakim dziele sztuki”; P 290) soon resurfaces. After a double and once more disappointing architectural enterprise, however, Strumieski starts to concentrate his artistic ambitions on living material, that is, on his son Paweek. As the boy functions as some kind of incarnation of 15
Cf. De Bruyn (2008a) for an analysis of Schulz’s narrator as a “reader” of the “text” of reality.
112
Dieter De Bruyn
Angelika, Strumieski expects him to be predestined to be a painter (just like Angelika) and therefore is tempted to “sow artistic impressions in him” (“zasiewanie w nim wra e artystycznych”; P 299). In the conviction that “nature is abundant in allusions” (“[n]atura jest obfita w aluzje”; P 302), he takes Paweek to a forest and confronts him with the reflection of the palace that he has ordered to be built: [W] wodzie widzieli […] drugi daleko pi kniejszy paac, […] zbudowany […] przez tajemnicze duchy podziemne, na przekór budowlom nadziemnym tu pod nimi wanie, przez duchy, które swoj czynno kryj zazdronie przed okiem ludzkim za pomoc zudzenia, i to jest tylko zwyky fenomen optyczny. (P 302-303) (In the water they saw another, far more beautiful palace, which had been built by mysterious ghosts of the underground in spite of the aboveground buildings right below by ghosts that kept their activity hidden from sight by means of the illusion that it was merely an ordinary optical phenomenon.)
Having roused Paweek’s interest in this kind of mystification, Strumieski can now proceed to his main objective: projecting the ideal image of Angelika onto her “spiritual son”. To this end, he sets up a sophisticated construction in the museum in which Angelika’s paintings are exhibited. Each time Paweek secretly enters the building, he sees a three-dimensional image of a woman through an optical illusion. Instead of making Paweek partake in the cult of Angelika, however, a “completely unexpected, nearly grotesque turn” (“cakiem niespodziewany, groteskowy niemal obrót”; P 427) takes place: after his father has closed down the museum, Paweek, who has gradually and completely arbitrarily started to refer to the phantom with the name Pauba (cf. P 317, 458-459), associates the anonymous effigy which he adores (his ideal woman) with the loose village idiot Kseka (whom the shepherds nickname Pauba). As soon as the licentious Kseka has initiated him into the physical (instead of the platonic or cultural) aspects of love, the image of Angelika is transformed, as it were, into its dialectical negation. This “grotesque turn” appears to have a lot in common with a similar event in Cinnamon Shops. As has already been mentioned, one of Jacob’s most remarkable “attempts to get to the core” is the establishment of a colony of birds in the attic of his house. At the peak
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 113
of the experiment, however, the by then extensive collection of all kinds of breeds is chased away by Adela. When the birds eventually return to their spiritual father in the final story of the cycle (‘Noc wielkiego sezonu’/‘The Night of the Great Season’), they appear to have developed into an “brood of freaks” (“sztuczne potomstwo”) that is “degenerated and overgrown” (“zwyrodniae i wybujae”), a “malformed, wasted tribe of birds” (CF 93; “zdegenerowane plemi
ptasie, zmarniae wewn trznie”; SC 157). After the birds have been knocked down with stones thrown by a bunch of jesters Jacob cannot but “notice the wretchedness of that wasted generation, the nonsense of its second-rate anatomy” (CF 94; “obserwowa ca lichot tej zubo aej generacji, ca mieszno jej tandetnej anatomii”; SC 158; italics mine). In spite of its high aspirations, the experiment turns out to have yielded nothing but tandeta (“trash”), that is, defective copies of the birds that he had intended to create: Byy to ogromne wiechcie piór, wypchane byle jak starym cierwem. U wielu nie mo na byo wyró ni gowy, gdy pakowata ta cz ciaa nie nosia adnych znamion duszy. Niektóre pokryte byy kudat , zlepion sierci , jak ubry, i mierdziay wstr tnie. Inne przypominay garbate, yse, zdeche wielb dy. Inne wreszcie byy najwidoczniej z pewnego rodzaju papieru, puste w rodku, a wietnie kolorowe na zewn trz. Niektóre okazyway si z bliska niczym innym jak wielkimi pawimi ogonami, kolorowymi wachlarzami, w które niepoj tym sposobem tchni to jaki pozór ycia. (SC 158) (They had been nothing but enormous bunches of feathers, stuffed carelessly with old carrion. In many of them, one could not recognise where the heads had been, for that misshapen part of their bodies was unmarked by the presence of a soul. Some were covered with a curly matted fur, like bison, and stank horribly. Others reminded one of hunchbacked, bald, dead camels. Others still must have been made of a kind of cardboard, empty inside but splendidly coloured on the outside. Some of them proved at close quarters to be nothing more than large peacock’s tails, colourful fans, into which by some obscure process a semblance of life had been breathed; CF 94)
The analogy with Pauba could be expressed as follows: just like Strumieski sets up a complex construction in order to “mould” Paweek into something that he is not in reality, Jacob attempts to impose his will on matter and bring it to life. Both “creative” projects, however, take revenge on their creators: Paweek shatters the ideal his father was aiming at and shows his human instincts, while Jacob’s
114
Dieter De Bruyn
birds shake off the illusion and disclose their “trashy” nature. The ambition “to get to the core” that Strumieski and Jacob share collides in a grotesque way with reality, with pauba and tandeta; the illusory symmetry between the idea and its representation has to give way to the asymmetry of the final result. Moreover, the fiasco of both protagonists’ experiments had already been hinted at beforehand: Jacob’s birds might have been merely the result of his reading of “large ornithological textbooks” (“wielkie ornitologiczne compendia”) from whose pages “these feathery phantasms seemed to rise” (Cf 21; “zdaway si ulatywa […] te pierzaste fantazmaty”; SC 69), while Strumieski already knew from his personal experiences that man will always be thwarted in his higher aspirations by the physical aspects of love. Although both grotesque turns in some way result in a defeat, both protagonists stubbornly continue their illusory activities. In Jacob’s case, this continuation is mainly the effect of the cyclic nature of Schulz’s literary reality. As has been sufficiently demonstrated by many critics, Schulz’s stories are characterized by a circular rather than a chronological temporal structure, as a result of which each motive may be perpetually repeated. A striking example of this is exactly Jacob’s constant struggle with the grayness and stability of everyday reality, which is perhaps best revealed in his repeated yet each time provisional metamorphoses. Strumieski, for his part, does not seem to calm down either in the wake of the clash between his “construction” and the “palubic element”; after he has shot Kseka (who had come to visit Paweek at his sickbed), he is convinced he has averted the sensual branch of the myth of Angelika. At once the “Angelika case” starts with a new cycle: “Strumieski experienced a moment in life at which he, after having passed through a particular cycle, had reached the same point for the second time” (“[Strumieski mia] chwil w yciu, w której niejako po przebyciu pewnego koa drugi raz by w tym samym punkcie”; P 481). After Paweek’s death in particular, he cannot restrain himself from linking all he experiences in life to one single scheme: “Seduced by the extraordinary, though in fact only superficial, symmetry of the events, he connected their peaks with lines, created a historiosophy of his own life, searched for pseudoconnections in it and drinked in these” (“Uwiedziony nadzwyczajn , chocia pozorn tylko symetrycznoci zdarze, czy
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 115
ich punkty szczytowe liniami, tworzy historiozofi wasnego ycia, doszukiwa si w nim pseudozwi zków, którymi si upaja”; P 489). On the very last page of the novel, Strumieski’s “mythologizing of reality” finally seems to have reached its apogee: “The Angelika case entered the stadium of the highest, already unattainable spiritualization” (“Sprawa Angelika wst pia w stadium najwy szego, nienaruszalnego ju uduchowienia”; P 490). The spiral in which Strumieski seems to be caught, however, cannot even be broken by his own death, as he will then enter “into that land, where he will eventually find out how things really are at the other side of the canvas” (“w ten kraj, gdzie wreszcie zobaczy, jak to tam jest po drugiej stronie kanwy”; P 490). It should be clear that the choice of the symbolically charged kanwa (“canvas”) as the last word of the novel once more strengthens the hypothesis of the horizontal orientation of Strumieski’s reality. Strumieski’s tragedy is in fact identical to what happens to Joseph in such stories as ‘Spring’ (cf. supra). Both protagonists attempt to impose a particular scenario on their realities, even though they are (to a different extent) aware of the inevitable fiasco. Their tragedy is first and foremost the result of the “exegetic paradox”: reality is perceived as a “text” from which a certain meaning should be drawn, which nonetheless slips through their fingers again and again. As a matter of fact, this is exactly what eventually affects the actual reader of their texts. In Pauba the reader is even made aware of his inclination to chase blindly after some ultimate signifié by devising illusory symmetries between the signs of a given text: “I know that my sober protest against Strumieski’s behavior will be some kind of humiliation for three-fourths of my readers, who, while being equally influenced by the suggestion of the facts, might feel exactly the same as Strumieski” (“Wiem, e ten mój trzewy protest przeciw zachowaniu si Strumieskiego b dzie rodzajem upokorzenia dla trzech czwartych moich czytelników, którzy, ulegaj c równie sugestii faktów, ewentualnie tak samo by czuli jak Strumieski”; P 477). In other words, Pauba does everything to thwart a traditional reading toward some kind of closure. Although it is possible to distinguish particular connections as the act of reading proceeds, these eventually turn out to be “pseudoconnections” that are as deceitful as provisional.
116
Dieter De Bruyn
What we can learn from Irzykowski and Schulz is that the asymmetric, three-dimensional, and infinite reality cannot be grasped in an inevitably symmetric, two-dimensional, and finite text. In their respective works this conflict is dramatized by laying bare the horizontal, textual character of the literary reality in question, after which the characters are exposed to the tragedy of the circular, recursive exegesis of their own textual reality. Eventually, the narrating “author” himself has to admit that his own “text” is but a “trace” of an unattainable original: Po analizie przedmiotu przychodzi kolej na mikroskop. Speni to, co w wiecie fizycznym równaoby si widzeniu wasnych oczu. Sprawa Strumieskiego tkwi we mnie samym […] Mia ebym wi c pisa swoj wasn Paub? Zdaje mi si , e zapomniaem na chwil , w jakim si
towarzystwie znajduj . Czy mam sam jeden – w literaturze – gra w otwarte karty? tam gdzie si gra nawet faszywymi? (P 450-451) (Now the object has been analyzed, let us focus on the microscope. Let us fulfill what in the physical world would be equal to looking at one’s own eyes. The Strumieski case is inside myself. Do I have to write my own Pauba then? Apparently I have forgotten for a moment in which company I am. Do I have to be the only person – in literature – who shows his cards? While others even play with false ones?)
What this passage suggests is that it is impossible to fully “show one’s cards”: when “looking at our own eyes” in a mirror, all we can see is but a representation that confronts us with the limits of our own visual range. The illusion that reality can be fully grasped dashes against the surface of the mirror; the own eye is a “residue” whose ultimate signifié will remain concealed forever. Even the metafictional text, which looks at itself as in a mirror, cannot possibly pass this limit; just like any other text, it will always remain an inauthentic construction – pauba or tandeta. Pauba, Manekin, Tandeta. Apology of the Inauthentic Art As has been suggested earlier, the constructive dimension of both Irzykowski’s and Schulz’s destructive literary practices cannot be denied. After the illusion of an attainable semantic core has been shattered, the reader is offered the perspective of an active, recursive, and reflexive reading of the respective texts’ “transformativity” (“transformacyjno”; cf. Szary-Matywiecka 1979: 36). More specifi-
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 117
cally, the reader may feel challenged by the text to a complex “game”, an alternative series of rules (conventions) and signs (words), in which one has to play a particular “role” that may offer a certain “pleasure”. Indeed, between the reader and his illusion of a three-dimensional reality a two-dimensional text is placed, like a chessboard on which the reader may freely arrange all kinds of temporary constructions. The reader becomes a “player” who is well aware of his exceptional role. What the reader may learn from all this is that this “game” is the only kind of authenticity that literature has to offer. In ‘Author’s Trio’ this positive value of the “role” and the “comedy” each human being inevitably has to play in life is underscored as follows: Mam e wyranie powiedzie, e jestem po stronie Strumieskiego? Gdyby taki czowiek y […], rad bym si z nim spotka i pomówi. Powiedziabym mu mo e: Panie Strumieski, ty, który chciae urzeczywistni frazes, w jaki to wpade chaos! Dlaczego ci nie przyszo na myl, e nie ty skompromitowae ide , ale e idea skompromitowaa si przed tob ! […] Widziaem np., jak odkrywszy w sobie pewn warstw komedii, zu ytkowae to odkrycie i wycofae si . Mam e ci bra to za ze? Potkn e si tylko na wasnej szczeroci. Bo có to znaczy komedia? Pokazuje si , e jest ona niezb dn cz ci dziaania ludzkiego; a je eli czowiek wybiera sobie wy sze formy ycia, ma jakie wzory lub plany przed oczyma, wówczas musi mu towarzyszy uczucie roli. […] W ogóle zanadto si ulega rozró nianiu dwóch kontrastów: pozoru i istoty rzeczy, a tylko Goethe mia pomys powiedzie: “So, laßt mich scheinen, bis ich werde.” (P 428-430) (Do I have to state explicitly that I sympathize with Strumieski? If such a person would exist, I would be happy to meet him and talk to him. I would probably tell him: Mr. Strumieski, you who wanted to execute a cliché, in which chaos have you ended up! Why haven’t you realized that it was not you who has compromised the idea, but the idea which has compromised itself in front of you! I have noticed, for instance, how you, after you had discovered a certain layer of comedy in yourself, took advantage of this discovery and then withdrew. Should I hold this against you? You have only stumbled over your own sincerity. For what does that mean, comedy? Apparently, it is inextricably part of human conduct; so, if someone chooses higher forms of life for himself or has certain models or plans in mind, then he must be accompanied by a sense of role. In general, we reconcile ourselves too easily to the distinction between these two opposites – the appearance and the essence of things – and only Goethe came up with the idea to state: “So lasst mich scheinen, bis ich werde”.)
118
Dieter De Bruyn
In other words, those who take their ideals too seriously and ignore the “sense of role” will inevitably end up in chaos. Only those who are aware of the relativity of every human act, of the comedy that lies at the basis of every human aspiration, may experience a certain degree of authenticity. A similar stress on the playful dimension of being, on the undermining of seriousness, can be found in Schulz’s work. In his essay for Witkacy, the writer describes his literary reality as follows: Obecna tam jest nieustannie atmosfera kulis, tylnej strony sceny, gdzie aktorzy po zrzuczeniu kostiumów zamiewaj si z patosu swych ról. W samym fakcie istnienia poszczególnego zawarta jest ironia, nabieranie, j zyk po bazesku wystawiony. (682-683) (Thus an all-pervading aura of irony emanates from this substance. There is an ever-present atmosphere of the stage, of sets viewed from behind, where the actors make fun of the pathos of their parts after stripping out their costumes. The bare fact of separate individual existence holds an irony, a hoax, a clown’s stuck-out tongue; 1990: 113)
In other words, both authors explicitly stress that the exposure of the characters’ tragedy causes a turn that reveals the positive, playful, and comical side of their tragic roles. The awareness that all seriousness is but a provisional “costume” (a “form”) that can be “stripped off” without any problem, reduces their drama to reasonable proportions. Even the cyclical repetition of the drama in ever new forms is not disadvantageous, as the laugh and the “stuck-out tongue” will always function as “safety valves” through which the surplus of seriousness can be temporarily reduced. The last issue to be addressed, then, is in which ways Irzykowski and Schulz have embedded this awareness of the eventual “superficiality” of each human act (and, as a consequence, also of their own literary practice) into their texts. It should be clear that characters such as Maria, Strumieski, and Jacob are not so much responsible for their fortunes, as they are victims of a specific (literary) role. Therefore, ons should also pay some attention to the reliability of the narrator of their stories. Schulz’s stories are characterized by a type of narration that Alfred Sproede, because of its dialectic of seduction and deception, has appropriately called “a kind of humbug” (“une espèce de boniment”; 2000: 148). Indeed, on numerous occasions, the characters and their reality (the merchandise) as well as the reader (the potential buyer) are
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 119
explicitly twisted around the finger of the “humbugging” narrator (the seller). Irzykowski’s narrator too is not as balanced as many critics have thought he was.16 In ‘Author’s Trio’ the narrator even openly confronts himself as “author”: Bo có s dzisz ty sam, szanowny autorze? […] Czy jeste jednym z tych autorów, którzy wyszydzaj , wydrwiwaj swe postacie, aby przez to narzuci czytelnikowi opini , e oni sami wi cej wiedz , e s m drzejsi? Czy nie przerzucasz wanie swego wasnego chaosu na Strumieskiego? (P 428) (Now what’s your opinion, dear author? Are you one of those writers who make fun of their characters and ridicule them in order to force the reader to believe that they know more themselves, that they are more intelligent? Aren’t you in fact shifting your own chaos onto Strumieski?)
In other words, the narrator is clearly aware of the relativity of his own narrative construction. He even doubts if the use of reflexive devices will offer a way out of this aporia: “Until now, there were certain accents in your story that made me hope that you would lead me behind the coulisses of the coulisses of your art” (“[W] twym opowiadaniu byy takie akcenty, które mi si ka spodziewa, e wprowadzisz mnie za kulisy kulis swej sztuki”; P 429). What the narrator suggests here is that even the exposure of his own narrative procedures is no guarantee for a stable, reliable, and “ordered” account, as new coulisses will continue to turn up behind the coulisses that have already been exposed. The reason why both Schulz’s and Irzykowski’s narrators also eventually undermine their own stability is that they are convinced that any attempt at “ordering” their world or making essentialist statements will inevitably lead them into chaos and that only the “appearance” and the “game” are legitimate. For similar reasons, both authors not only seem to have reconciled themselves in advance to the provisional and defective nature of their literary constructions, but also deliberately stick to an aesthetics for which Pawowska-J drzyk has coined the term “mediocrity” (“bylejako”) – “a term which is used for denoting the specificity of the poetics of works which stand out with a deliberate carelessness of their artistic execution” (cf. 16
Cf. De Bruyn (2007b, 2008) for more detailed analyses on narrative unreliability in Irzykowski and Schulz.
120
Dieter De Bruyn
supra). Pawowska-J drzyk pertinently remarks that this aesthetic attitude in both authors’ works has crystallized, as it were, into two “anti-aesthetic” concepts: tandeta and pauba. Whereas tandeta manifests itself in Schulz’s stories primarily in the form of all kinds of “shoddy” characters and objects, Irzykowski’s concept of pauba seems to be the driving force behind the exposure of all usurping “constructions” of the various protagonists. What Pawowska-J drzyk seems to overlook, however, is that both “symbols” have much more in common than merely their shared emphasis on the “mediocrity” of the literary construction in which they have found themselves. In a revealing article, Andreas Schönle (1991) has already shed light on the ambiguity and wide range of applications of the concept of tandeta. The word and its derivatives as well as the idea of cheap and “shoddy” form are indeed omnipresent in Schulz’s stories: tandeta appears as parasitic vegetation (e.g. in ‘Sierpie’ (‘August’) and ‘Pan’), as “shoddy” goods (e.g. in ‘Cinnamon Shops’ and ‘The Street of Crocodiles’), as disabled characters (e.g. in ‘Emeryt’ (‘The Old-Age Pensioner’), ‘Edzio’ (‘Eddie’) and ‘Dodo’), as metamorphoses of humans into lower or marginal forms of life (e.g. not only Jacob’s transformations but also the dog-man in ‘Sanatorium Under the Sign of the Hourglass’, the transsexual seller in ‘The Street of Crocodiles’, and uncle Edward as a doorbell in ‘The Comet’), etc. The most “perfect” form in which tandeta manifests itself, however, is the manekin or “(tailor’s) dummy”. More specifically, due to the incongruity between what is represented (a human being) and the inadequacy of the image, the manekin draws some attention on its own material quality of “sign” (cf. Schönle 1991: 132). Quite interestingly, in this same conceptual framework of the poorly executed doll, Schulz also employs the rarely used pauba – not only with reference to the less suitable (for apparently more perfect) “figury panopticum” (“figures in the panopticum”) or “pauby woskowe” (“waxworks”), but also for designating the quality of “shoddy” matter, its “paubiasta niezgrabno” (“dummy-like clumsiness”). Because Schulz was familiar with Pauba (cf. his mention of it in his review of Gombrowicz’s novel Ferdydurke), it is not unlikely that he wanted to insert Irzykowski’s “text” into his own literary reality. A similarly significant connection between tandeta and pauba can be found in the following description of luxuriant vegetation in ‘August’:
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 121
Na tych barach ogrodu niechlujna, babska bujno sierpnia wyolbrzymiaa w guche zapadliska ogromnych opuchów, rozpanoszya si patami wochatych blach listnych, wybujaymi ozorami mi sistej zieleni. Tam te wyupiaste pauby opuchów wybauszyy si jak babska szeroko rozsiade, na wpó po arte przez wasne oszalae spódnice. Tam sprzedawa ogród za darmo najtasze krupy dzikiego bzu, mierdz c mydem, grub kasz babek, dzik okowit mi ty i wszelk najgorsz tandet sierpniow . (SC 50-51; italics mine) ([On the back of the garden] the untidy, feminine ripeness of August had expanded into enormous, impenetrable, clumps of burdock spreading their sheets of leafy tin, their luxuriant tongues of fleshy greenery. There, those protuberant bur clumps spread themselves, like resting peasant women, half enveloped in their own swirling skirts. There, the garden offered free of charge the cheapest fruits of wild lilac, the heady aquavit of mint and all kinds of August trash; CF 6; italics mine)
Whereas tandeta in this fragment stresses the cheapness and “shoddiness” of the parasitic vegetation in the periphery of the garden, pauba (which in this case rather stands for an “old and ugly woman”, a “hag”; cf. infra) links up with those expressions (e.g. the various variations on baba) that designate the impudent femininity and fertility of the plants in question. Apart from this, the word was most probably also chosen for its alliteration (cf. “te wyupiaste pauby opuchów wybauszyy si ”), which in a way causes an “overgrowth” of the text’s meaning by its poetic “sound”. In Pauba the sound of the word plays an important role, too. When pauba is mentioned for the first time on the occasion of the projection of Angelika’s image on one of her paintings, it even seems to represent mere sound without meaning: Paweek mówi c o kobiecie na obrazie nazywa j czasem […] “paub ”, “nasz paub ”. Dwi k tego sowa przypomina Strumieskiemu co ohydnego i ordynarnego zarazem, co by to jednak byo, nie pami ta. Wprawdzie jeszcze dawniej dowiedzia si Strumieski od Paweka, e on to sowo “pauba” zasysza od parobków i pastuchów wiejskich, w jakim jednak sensie tego sowa u ywano, Paweek wytumaczy nie umia. (P 317-318) (When Paweek talked about the woman on the painting, he sometimes called her “pauba”, “our pauba”. The sound of this word reminded Strumieski of something disgusting and ordinary at the same time, but he could not remember what it was. Admittedly, he had already learned from Paweek that he had heard the word “pauba” from the servants and the
122
Dieter De Bruyn shepherds from the village, but Paweek had not managed to explain in what sense the word was used.)
Although it is clear that Paweek had taken over the popular word from the villagers in order to designate in a completely arbitrary way the phantom for which he could not find a name on his own, it now appeals to Strumieski as if it were a cryptogram. As a result, he starts interpreting the word in his own way. In a remarkable scene in Angelika’s museum, Strumieski responds in the following way to Ola’s accusation that he may have killed Angelika himself: Patrz na ten martwy manekin (tu przypomniao mu si sowo Paweka), na t paub za tym szkem, ona ust nie otworzy i nic ci nie powie, je eli si
to nie przecinie samo na moje usta, jak prze eraj cy wyrzut sumienia, bo tego nikt nie wie na wiecie prócz mnie i tej tu niemej pauby, która skoczya samobójstwem – ha ha pyszne samobójstwo! (P 374; italics mine) (Look at this dead dummy (now he remembered Paweek’s word), at this pauba behind the glass, she will not open her mouth and she will not tell you anything, unless it escapes from my mouth itself, just like devastating remorse, for nobody on earth knows this except for me and this stupid pauba, who has committed suicide – ha ha a marvelous suicide!)
As soon as Strumieski imitates Paweek in connecting the word pauba with Angelika, his late wife transforms, as it were, into an imperfect image of her, into a dead and dumb dummy, a pauba or (by analogy with Schulz) manekin. By associating Angelika with something ordinary and “shoddy”, he apparently wants to close the “Angelika case” in language, too. Some time later, however, he will also consider this innocent association to be one of the main causes of Paweek’s fatal relationship with Kseka Pauba. Unlike Strumieski, Paweek does not seem to want to express something specific when using the word pauba: Paweek nie zna dokadnie zastosowa sowa “pauba”, nie oznaczao te ono dla zrazu nic wstr tnego ani ohydnego, tak e niemal tylko przypadkiem przeniós je ywcem na obraz Angeliki. Latao mu ono w gowie samopas bez odpowiedniego wyobra enia, a poniewa wydawao mu si sowem b d co b d niezwykym, wi c sczepi je z tym, co byo dla bezimiennym i równie niezwykym, tj. z obrazem Angeliki. (P 458459)
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 123
(Paweek did not know the uses of the word “pauba”, and it did not immediately mean anything horrible or disgusting for him, so he almost only accidentally and integrally applied it to Angelika’s image. It flew around in his head unguardedly and without any corresponding representation, and since it seemed to him to be an unusual word after all, he connected it with something that for him was anonymous and unusual at the same time, that is, with Angelika’s image.)
After the museum has been closed down by Strumieski and mainly under the influence of his father’s hinting at the “Angelika case”, Paweek increasingly starts to associate the word with all kinds of inappropriate meanings, as a result of which his positive memory of the image in the museum transforms into something mysterious and disgusting against his will. As he gets in touch with Kseka, whom the shepherds also use to nickname pauba (in the sense of “shrew”, “hag”), a “huge cataclysm” (“wielki kataklizm”) takes place inside him, after which he concludes “that this is not another, but the same Pauba” (“i to jest ta sama a nie inna Pauba”; P 466). Although both of Paweek’s fascinations (for Angelika’s image and for Kseka) seem to have something in common through the association with one single word, their respective objects are completely different: while Kseka quite simply is responsible for Paweek’s sexual initiation, Angelika is but a phantom who haunts his imagination. Or as the narrator stresses, “in fact this was not the same case anymore, but a new one, a new piece of reality with its own autonomy, so Paweek’s history, which is entitled “Angelika-Pauba” on the outside, only superficially radiates uniformity” (“[w]aciwie nie bya to ju ta sama sprawa, ale nowa, nowy pat rzeczywistoci, o wasnej autonomii, […] a historia Paweka, zatytuowana na zewn trz “Angelika-Pauba”, byszczy tylko pozorn jednolitoci ”; P 468). What Irzykowski suggests is that both Strumieski and Paweek establish the “pseudoconnections” between Angelika and Kseka merely on acoustic facts (the “unusual” sound of pauba). Hence, all additional emotions and meanings that are subsequently associated with (the complex surrounding) this word are merely artificial “constructions” that do not correspond with reality. What the reader can learn from this is that he should not put a particular meaning on the word pauba. In an important passage in which the choice of the title of the novel is explained, the narrating “author” stresses that the only criterion was to “drum into the reader the matter
124
Dieter De Bruyn
that he wanted to raise” (“wbi w pami czytelnika to, co chcia wyuszczy”; P 482). As the novel’s theme is the absence of any theme (the “disintegration of any thematicity” / “rozchwianie si
tematowoci”), the “author” opts for pauba because “something which itself is different from anything else should also have a name which is different from anything else” (“to, co samo nie jest do niczego podobne, powinno mie tak e nazw do niczego niepodobn ”; P483). In other words, the “author” acts in exactly the same way as Paweek: he arbitrarily selects a name for his “case” (the novel he is writing), which is as “unusual” as what it is supposed to designate. However, because he is merely an “actor” who plays a “role” in his text, he cannot prevent himself from making illusory associations as well. At a certain point, for instance, the narrating “author” reduces the numerous meanings (up to ten according to Kak 1976: 123) of pauba to only three: a pile driving ram, a tailor’s dummy (manekin), and a hag (P 458). Although these meanings seem to be selected completely at random from the ones in the dictionaries, they appear to be less accidentally chosen upon closer examination. As we have seen, pauba is used both as a synonym for manekin and as a nickname for the loose village idiot Kseka. Furthermore, the association with the pile driving ram is suggested by the narrator when stating that he wishes to “drum into the reader the matter that he wanted to raise”. In other words, the choice of pauba is not arbitrary at all. One could argue that the novel did not necessarily need a title but that the title needed a novel: the word pauba has produced a heterogeneous novel of the same name. Due to its polysemy, the word lends itself to ever new variations and, as a consequence, to the intended “disintegration of any thematicity”. As a result of every subsequent variation by the narrator or interpretation by the reader, however, the meaning of the word becomes more complete (it “reintegrates”, as Schulz would have it), which makes it comparable to the “original word” (“pierwotne sowo”; 1964: 443) at which Schulz is aiming. By analogy with Schönle’s analysis of Schulz’s use of tandeta and manekin, therefore, one could argue that pauba “represents a sign only partially oriented towards its signified, remains vaguely motivated, while already including some conventionality, and thus draws some attention on its signifying shape as such” (1991: 132). In
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 125
his article on the technique of stylizacja (cf. supra), Kosiski interprets the function of pauba in a similar way: Funkcja tego sowa, które jest przezw , staje si imieniem, w kocu tytuem ksi ki, od którego pochodzi kluczowa kategoria podmiotu (pierwiastek paubiczny), pozostaje funkcj czystego signifiant. […] W symbolice przestrzennej charakteryzuje go ruch z dou do góry, od chopów do Paweka […], od Paweka do Strumieskiego […], od Strumieskiego do autora, od autora do sowników […], jakby od natury do kultury. (2000: 35-36) (The function of this word, which begins as a nickname, then becomes a name, and eventually the title of the work, of which even the narrator’s key concept (the palubic element) is derived, continues to be the function of a pure signifiant. In the spatial symbolics it is characterized by a bottom-up movement, from the peasants to Paweek, from Paweek to Strumieski, from Strumieski to the author, from the author to the dictionaries, as it were from nature to culture.)
According to Kosiski, Irzykowski’s novel also illustrates how each word originates from acoustic stimuli (in this case from the succession of “a” and “u”), and in this way, it even offers some kind of “meticulous reconstruction of the fortunes of the word and its changing meanings” (“dokadna rekonstrukcja losów sowa i jego zmiennych znacze”; 2000: 36). One of these meanings – a “hood” of a carriage – even turns pauba into a symbol of the “word” itself, which is also some kind of “covering” or “mould” with a variable content. Just like tandeta imposes a loose and provisional form upon matter, pauba symbolizes the formative word, the word that has not yet fossilized into a fixed meaning. Instead of conventionally referring to the final product of (literary) communication, both deliberately unconventional concepts apparently focus on the semantic process itself. Within the respective texts, they function as metaphors of maximal arbitrariness: by constantly postponing their final signifiés, they reveal themselves as “pure signifiants”. In their role of a covering or loose form for ever new but equally provisional contents, they initiate a complex textual process. The provisional texts that result from this process (the actual works of both authors) may be merely read in their transformacyjno (cf. supra), as a “migration of forms” (cf. supra) or infinite dissemination of signifiers that refer to anything and nothing at the same time. Without the metaphors that have initiated the entire process, the reader would be lost. In other words,
126
Dieter De Bruyn
after pauba and tandeta have played their metaphorical role, they reflexively start focusing attention on themselves. By exposing their maximal arbitrariness they have transformed (in the reader’s eyes) from meaningless coverings into a powerful experience of reality, or as Stala puts it with reference to Schulz’s metaphors: “The word, returning to reality from its metaphorical journey is no longer the same word; it is the liberated, forming and creative word, full of energy” (1993: 92). The role that pauba and tandeta perform in their respective literary realities is indeed thoroughly ambivalent. Although both words continually aim at concretization, at mimesis and semiosis, they eventually always withdraw from this ill-fated mission. In this way, they implicitly criticize any construction of meaning that does pretend to bring this circle to a closure. This critical function is, of course, primarily directed against any literary text and its concretization by the reader. Against the illusion of an authentic reality which the reader of a narrative is traditionally pursuing, both concepts oppose their plea in favour of an art that is as inauthentic as possible, an art that does not aspire to coincide with the object to which it refers and evokes this illusion only to immediately expose it. This attitude not only reveals itself in these works’ own artificial and “shoddy” form (for both words are part of a subcultural, “ordinary” and even vulgar dimension of language), but also even more in their most striking incarnation: the manekin or (tailor’s) dummy. In his illuminating article on the concept of tandeta in Schulz’s fiction, Schönle has convincingly determined the semiotic value of the “trashy” or “carelessly executed” tailor’s dummy as opposed to the waxwork figure, which is supposed to be nearly identical to its model. As Jacob argues in ‘Treatise on Tailors’ Dummies’, the waxworks are “fairground parodies of dummies” (CF 35; “kalwaryjskie parodie manekinów”; SC 87) because they are forced to be fully similar to an unattainable model. In other words, whereas the waxwork tries to conceal at any cost the inevitable dissimilarities from its model, the tailor’s dummy continuously displays its mere referential task. According to Schönle (cf. supra), the reflexive dimension of the latter way of representing man should be clear: Put into the vocabulary of semiotics, the waxwork is a sign transparent towards its signified, since it is motivated by a full visual similarity,
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 127
whereas the dummy represents a sign only partially oriented towards its signified, remains vaguely motivated, while already including some conventionality, and thus draws some attention on its signifying shape as such. (1991: 132; italics mine)
Undoubtedly, many readers will be tempted to interpret Jacob’s preference for the tailor’s dummy as an unequivocal plea for “antimimetic” or abstract forms of art because the manekin could be considered an abstract representation of man. Upon closer examination, however, father’s argument appears to be more subtle. More specifically, Jacob seeks not the (supposedly artistic) creation of tailors’ dummies “in the image and likeness” of man but just the opposite – viz., the establishment of a “generatio aequivoca” (SC 89) by re-creating man “in the image and likeness of a tailor’s dummy” (“na obraz i podobiestwo manekina”; SC 83). Hence, what he seems to be attacking is not so much the faithful depiction of man (as in traditional mimesis) but any artistic depiction of man, which is always but an artificial copy of a (mental) picture of real man – of a provisional abstraction “for one gesture, for one word alone” (CF 32; “dla jednego gestu, dla jednego sowa”; SC 82). In Jacob’s opinion, when compared to God’s “first” creation, any kind of human creation is secondary and inauthentic, and the best man can do is to reveal the inauthenticity of his creation as much as possible. It should be clear that Schulz rejects the conventional creation of “illusions of humans” (that is, of puppets) in favor of the creation of “illusions of illusions of humans” (that is, of copies of puppets). In other words, instead of modeling his literary world and its inhabitants after the real world, he prefers to use artistic (man-made) products as a model. Moreover, by choosing the explicitly artificial tailor’s dummy as a model (instead of the more perfect waxwork figure, as the realistic writer unconsciously does), it is more likely that the reader will perceive the intended “illusion of an illusion of man” than some new illusion (of an authentic puppet). Obviously, Schulz’s approach is also more subtly reflexive when compared, for instance, to a painting which directly depicts both another painting and a painter’s easel or a novel which includes not only the representation of a fictional reality but also a description of the artistic genesis of this literary construction (as Irzykowski has done). In all these examples, however, the same artistic principle is at work: instead of denying that what has been portrayed is merely a construction of reality (as in Realism),
128
Dieter De Bruyn
reflexive forms of art expose their delusive practices in one way or another. In Schulz’s fiction, the technique of creating “in the image and likeness of a tailor’s dummy” reveals itself most prominently in the exposure of the inadequacies of reality, of its tandetno. As for the characters inhabiting his literary world, their artificiality and defectiveness is almost complete; some of them (e.g. father, aunt Perasia, uncle Edward) are ruled by what Schulz himself (in his essay for Witkiewicz) has called the principle of “panmasquerade” (“panmaskarada”; 1964: 682), which makes them assume new masks again and again, whereas others clearly display physical deficiencies (e.g., Edzio, Dodo) or even explicit “mannequinesque” traits: in ‘August’ (‘Sierpie’), for instance, the narrator reports of his cousin ucja that “[s]he stretched out to [him] a small doll-like hand” (CF 9; “[p]odaa [mu] r czk lalkowat ”; SC 55). Similar conclusions can be drawn regarding the material side of Schulz’s literary world. The illusoriness and defectiveness of the setting in which the subsequent stories take place can best be observed in the periphery, on the margins of the represented world. Indeed, like a painting which betrays its own construction the most at its margins (where the frame begins and the order of the work merges with the chaos of reality), Schulz’s fictional settings display their shoddiness particularly on the outskirts. In ‘The Street of Crocodiles’, for example, the narrator offers a description of a peripheral city district on the basis of an old map of his hometown. In this part of town, the degree of imitativeness is almost unlimited: Jest to szary dzie, jak zawsze w tej okolicy, i caa sceneria wydaje si
chwilami fotografi z ilustrowanej gazety, tak szare, tak paskie s domy, ludzie i pojazdy. Ta rzeczywisto jest cienka jak papier i wszystkimi szparami zdradza sw imitatywno. Chwilami ma si wra enie, e tylko na maym skrawku przed nami ukada si wszystko przykadnie w ten pointowany obraz bulwaru wielkomiejskiego, gdy tymczasem ju na bokach rozwi zuje si i rozprz ga ta zaimprowizowana maskarada i, niezdolna wytrwa w swej roli, rozpada si za nami w gips i pakuy, w rupieciarni jakiego ogromnego pustego teatru. Napi cie pozy, sztuczna powaga maski, ironiczny patos dr y na tym naskórku. (SC 127) (It is, as usual in that district, a grey day, and the whole scene seems at times like a photograph in an illustrated magazine, so grey, so onedimensional are the houses, the people and the vehicles. Reality is as thin as paper and betrays with all its cracks its imitative character. At times
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 129
one has the impression that it is only the small section immediately before us that falls into the expected pointillistic picture of a city thoroughfare, while on either side, the improvised masquerade is already disintegrating and, unable to endure, crumbles behind us into plaster and sawdust, into the lumber room of an enormous, empty theatre. The tenseness of an artificial pose, the assumed earnestness of a mask, an ironical pathos tremble on this façade; CF 67-68)
Such descriptions perfectly illustrate Schulz’s method of using a “trashy” (tandetny), explicitly artificial version of reality as a model for literary mimesis rather than reality itself. Moreover, in much the same way as the tailor’s dummy, this kind of setting may evoke a double perception: on the one hand, the temporary illusion of a human being (in the case of the dummy) or a real (big) city thoroughfare (in the case of the Street of Crocodiles district), and on the other hand, the enduring reality of a shoddy artifact – made of “plaster and sawdust”. Although Irzykowski’s techniques are often less subtle, his novel does not pretend to be more than merely an inauthentic image of the construction that “rests somewhere in [his] head in a completely different form” (cf. supra). By analogy with Schulz’s stories the “monstrous ruin” (cf. supra) entitled Pauba incessantly exposes its own secondary, “derivative” character. First of all, the narrating “author” regularly betrays his literary sources of inspiration, from which he now and then directly quotes. Furthermore, many of the works of art that turn up in the novel appear to be thoroughly “shoddy”. This is certainly the case for the literary works that Gasztold and Strumieski produce, both of which are based on second-rate models from the popular circuit and which the narrator criticizes as worthless efforts that would better not be published. ‘The Dreams of Maria Dunin’, then, abounds in inconsequences and eventually turns out to be a mystification. Angelika, who shares both her first and surname with the historical painter Angelika Kauffmann (1741-1807) and as such is already some kind of “copy”, is openly accused of plagiarism at a certain point. Angelika’s museum appears to contain for the most part all kinds of trash and kitsch. Apart from the exotic knickknacks and Angelika’s pathological portraits and landscapes it also accommodates a remarkable “plaster moulding representing a man who was sculpturing himself in stone” (“odlew gipsowy, który przedstawia czowieka wykuwaj cego samego siebie w kamieniu”; P 167). What makes this example so worth mentioning
130
Dieter De Bruyn
is not only its imitative and “kitschy” nature but also most of all its reflexive dimension, as if Irzykowski wished to evoke some kind of plastic equivalent of his own novel. The most striking manifestation of manekinowato (“dummy-likeness”) is the image of Angelika that Strumieski creates through an optical illusion. Whereas the image of his dead wife until then had only existed as an ideal construction in his head, he now transforms it into an inferior, overtly artificial variant: Tumaczy Oli cay mechanizm optyczny. e rzecz nie polega wcale na jakich wynalazkach, które maj by dopiero wynalezione, jak cudownoci Poego lub Vernego, ale na znanych ju fenomenach, na interferencji wiata i na sekretnych farbach profesora Lipmanna, i wcale nie wymaga koncesji prawdopodobiestwa. Ola niewiele z tego rozumiaa, ale rozumiaa przecie tyle, e cudowno nie odgrywa tu adnej roli, i jej oczekiwania zawiody j nieco, zwaszcza gdy Strumieski kad nacisk na t naturalno, tj. tak zwan sztuczno zjawiska. (P 364-365) (He explained the complete optical mechanism to Ola. That it had nothing to do with any particular inventions that still had to be discovered, like the curiosities of Poe and Verne, but with existing phenomena, with the interference of light and with the secret colors of professor Lipmann, and that it did not require any concessions to probability. Ola did not understand a lot of this, but she did nonetheless understand that it had nothing to do with illusionism, and she was slightly disappointed, particularly when Strumieski emphasized this naturalness, that is, the socalled artificiality of the phenomenon.)
After this explanation, the confusion turns out to be almost complete. Although the image is characterized as completely natural and authentic, it actually is a visualization of Strumieski’s ideal image of his wife and as such should be considered an inauthentic construction “to the second power” when compared to the “real” Angelika. In fact, both interpretations of the optical illusion are correct: either one ignores the underlying construction and perceives an authentic optical effect or one becomes aware of the double defectiveness of the image with regard to its original (cf. the manekin as an “illusion of an illusion of man”). Strumieski initially still defends the authenticity and mimetic power of the spectacle, but by renaming the image into a “dead dummy” and a “stupid pauba” (cf. supra), he exposes his work as a mystification and once again yields to the power of the “palubic element”.
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 131
Conclusion As we have seen, although the works of Irzykowski and Schulz do not seem to have a lot in common, both authors in a similar way put into perspective all possible cultural constructions and “stylizations” (words, ideas, texts, etc.) As the relativistic and cultural critical discourse of both authors is represented in the form of a narrative, this critique is primarily directed against all “actors” that play a “role” in the “game”, which this literary construction appears to be: the author and his text, the narrator and his story, the characters and their reality. Because the text continually displays its own artificiality and its own two-dimensional nature, the reader may realize that his reading of this text, of every text, and by extension of every cultural construction is merely a temporary “pose” or a necessary “comedy”. Unable to trace back the horizontal orientation of the text (its palimpsests, cryptograms, and arabesques) to a stable semantic core, he cannot but activate, for the duration of his reading, the “mediocre”, “shoddy”, and “inauthentic” artifact at hand as an aesthetic object. Or as Irzykowski almost casually puts it in his novel: “Do you feel the poetry of this apoetry after all?” (“Czy jednak czujecie poezj tej apoezji?”; P 435). Bibliography Bolecki, Wodzimierz. 1996 [1982]. Poetycki model prozy w dwudziestoleciu midzywojennym. Kraków: Universitas. ——. 1999. ‘Le Postmodernisme? Ou peut-être un modernisme méconnu?: Witkacy – Gombrowicz – Schulz’ in Delaperrière, Maria (ed.) Modernisme en Europe Centrale. Les avant-gardes. Paris: L’Harmattan: 173-192. ——. 2003. ‘Metaliteratura wczesnego modernizmu. Pauba Karola Irzykowskiego’ in Arkusz 2, 3: 4-5, 13. ——. 2005. ‘Gender and Sex in Early Modernist Polish Fiction: Przybyszewski, Irzykowski, Witkacy, Schulz’ in Grimstad, Knut Andreas and Ursula Phillips (eds). Gender and Sexuality in Ethical Context. Ten Essays on Polish Prose (Slavica Bergensia 5). Bergen: University of Bergen, Department of Russian Studies, IKRR: 98-123. Budrecka, Aleksandra. 1981. ‘Wst p’ in Irzykowski, Karol, Pauba. Sny Marii Dunin. Wrocaw: Zakad Narodowy im. Ossoliskich: III-XC. Currie, Mark (ed. and intr.) 1995. Metafiction. New York: Longman. D browska, Krystyna. 1963. ‘Struktura artystyczna Pauby Irzykowskiego’ in Zeszyty Naukowe Uniwersytetu Mikoaja Kopernika w Toruniu (Nauki Humanistyczno-Spoeczne 9, Filologia Polska IV): 159-197.
132
Dieter De Bruyn
De Bruyn, Dieter. 2007a. ‘The Problem of Autotematyzm in Polish Literary Criticism, or How to Immobilize a Perpetuum Mobile of Nothingness’ in Danaher, David S. and Van Heuckelom, Kris (eds). Perspectives on Slavic Literatures. Proceedings of the First International Perspectives on Slavistics Conference (Leuven, September 17-19, 2004) (Pegasus OostEuropese Studies 6). Amsterdam: Pegasus: 127-139. ——. 2007b. ‘The Janus-Faced Author: Narrative Unreliability and Metafiction in Karol Irzykowski’s Pauba and Witold Gombrowicz’s Ferdydurke’ in Russian Literature 62(4): 401-422. ——. 2008. ‘An Eye for an I. Telling as Reading in Bruno Schulz’s Fiction’ in D'hoker, Elke and Gunther Martens (eds). Narrative Unreliability in the Twentieth-Century First-Person Novel (Narratologia 14). Berlin: de Gruyter: 209-227. Drozdowski, Piotr Joran. 1987. Arcydzieo graniczne: Pauba Karola Irzykowskiego na tle Pozytywizmu i Modej Polski. PhD Thesis. The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Eile, Stanisaw. 1996. Modernist Trends in Twentieth-Century Polish Fiction. London: University of London, School of Slavonic and East European Studies. Gowiski, Micha. 1969. Powie modopolska: Studium z poetyki historycznej. Wrocaw, Warszawa: Zakad Narodowy im. Ossoliskich, Wydawnictwo Polskiej Akademii Nauk. Irzykowski, Karol. 1976 [1903]. Pauba. Sny Marii Dunin. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie. Jabonowski, Wadysaw. ‘Karol Irzykowski. Pauba’ in Ksika 3(11): 406-408. Kak, Zofia. 1976. ‘O filozoficznych i psychologicznych koncepcjach w Paubie Karola Irzykowskiego’ in Materiay midzynarodowej sesji naukowej zorganizowanej przez Koo Polonistów IFP UJ z okazji jubileusza 75-lecia istnienia Koa w dniach 20-24 maja 1974. Kraków: Uniwersytet Jagielloski, Instytut Filologii Polskiej: 121-145. Kosiski, Krzysztof. 2000. ‘Prolog. Przemiany prozy XX wieku’ in Kosiski, Krzysztof, Eros. Dekonstrukcja. Polityka. Katowice: l sk: 15-37. Lachmann, Renate. 1992. ‘Dezentrierte Bilder. Die ekstatische Imagination in Bruno Schulz’ Prosa’ in Hansen-Löve, Aage (ed.) Psychopoetik. Beiträge zur Tagung ‘Psychologie und Literatur’ München 1991 (Wiener Slawistischer Almanach Sonderband 31). Wien: Gesellschaft zur Förderung slawistischer Studien: 439-461. Lipiski, Jacek. 1949. ‘Pauba jako program literacki Karola Irzykowskiego’ in Prace polonistyczne 7: 137-157. Nycz, Ryszard. 1997. Jzyk modernizmu. Prolegomena historycznoliterackie. Wrocaw: Fundacja na Rzecz Nauki Polskiej. Pawowska(-J drzyk), Brygida. 1995. ‘Parodia i groteska w Paubie Karola Irzykowskiego’ in Przegld Humanistyczny 39(5): 153-168. ——. 2002. Sens i chaos w grotesce literackiej. Kraków: Universitas. Ritz, German. 2005. ‘Does Paluba Have a Sex? Irzykowski’s Paluba in the Light of Gender Studies’ in Grimstad, Knut Andreas and Ursula Phillips (eds). Gender and Sexuality in Ethical Context. Ten Essays on Polish Prose
Toward a Metafictional Reading of Irzykowski’s Pauba and Schulz’s Fiction 133
(Slavica Bergensia 5). Bergen: University of Bergen, Department of Russian Studies, IKRR: 124-154. Schönle, Andreas. 1991. ‘Cinnamon Shops by Bruno Schulz: the Apology of Tandeta’ in The Polish Review 36(2): 127-144. Schulz, Bruno. 1964. Proza. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie. ——. 1989. The Complete Fiction of Bruno Schulz (tr. C. Wieniewska). New York: Walker and Company. ——. 1990. Letters and Drawings of Bruno Schulz (ed. J. Ficowski). New York: Fromm International Publishing Corporation. Sproede, Alfred. 2000. ‘Expérimentations narratives après la fin de l’Avant-garde: notes sur Bruno Schulz, son lecteur et ses “Incantations”’ in Konicka, Hanna and Hélène Wodarczyk (eds). La littérature polonaise du XXe siècle. Textes, styles et voix. Paris: Institut d’études slaves: 135-165. Stala, Krzysztof. 1993. On the Margins of Reality: the Paradoxes of Representation in Bruno Schulz’s Fiction. Stockholm: Almqvist & Wiksell International. St pnik, Krzysztof. 1973. ‘Ogólne wyznaczniki paradygmatu literackiego Pauby i jego organizacja estetyczna’ in Studia Estetyczne 10: 215-238. Szary-Matywiecka, Ewa. 1979. Ksika, powie, autotematyzm: od Pauby do Jedynego wyjcia. Wrocaw: Zakad Narodowy im. Ossoliskich. Taylor Sen, Colleen. 1972. Polish Experimental Fiction 1900-1939: A Comparative Study of the Novels of Karol Irzykowski, Stanisaw Ignacy Witkiewicz, Witold Gombrowicz and Bruno Schulz. PhD Thesis. Columbia University. Waugh, Patricia. 1984. Metafiction. The Theory and Practice of Self-Conscious Fiction. London & New York: Methuen. Werner, Andrzej. 1965. ‘Czowiek, literatura i konwencje: refleksja teoretycznoliteracka w Paubie Karola Irzykowskiego’ in Kwiatkowski, Jerzy and Zbigniew abicki (eds). Z problemów literatury polskiej XX wieku. I: Moda Polska. Warszawa: Pastwowy Instytut Wydawniczy: 327-369. Wyka, Kazimierz. 1977 [1948]. ‘Wst p do Pauby’ in Wyka, Kazimierz, Moda Polska. II: Szkice z problematyki epoki. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie: 175-204. Zengel, Ryszard. 1958. ‘Pauba po latach’ in Twórczo 14(11): 126-133.
“I Drew a Plan of an Imaginary City”. The Phenomenon of the City in Bruno Schulz and Miron Biaoszewski Anna liwa Abstract: The aim of this article is to investigate the degree of similarity between Bruno Schulz’s and Miron Biaoszewski’s writing. The problem will be researched by comparing both writers’ spatial imagery using a method of close-reading. When thinking about the spatiality in Schulz’s and Biaoszewski’s literary works, we have to admit that it is almost impossible to imagine without the city. Their writing is strongly filled with urban space, and the status of the civilian plays an important role in forming the identity of the subject. Particular attention will be paid to the aspect of “mythologizing” the city.
Introduction The comparison of Bruno Schulz’s prose and Miron Biaoszewski’s poetry may seem risky considering that these two writers never met. In the year of Schulz’s tragic death (1942), Biaoszewski was twenty years old. He never mentioned Schulz in his writing, but it is hard to avoid the impression that the imagery in his debut volume Obroty rzeczy (The Revolution of Things, 1956) contains something Schulzian. Critics such as Artur Sandauer (1981) and Kazimierz Wyka (1959) pointed at similarities between Schulz’s prose and some of Biaoszewski’s poems, but they did not expand on the subject. The main aim of this article is to critically revise this observation and investigate the real degree of similarity between Schulz’s and Biaoszewski’s writing. The problem will be researched on the field of spatial imagery – the theme of a city. The analysis of the city in Schulz’s prose will be mainly limited to the story ‘Ulica krokodyli’ (‘The Street of Crocodiles’). The question about similarity in Schulz’s and Biaoszewski’s imagery may be posed more directly and ironically: is there something
136
Anna liwa
that links the literary works of Schulz and Biaoszewski other than the Polish literary historian Artur Sandauer? Or is it only a coincidence that Sandauer, who gained his status as a literary critic on interpreting Schulz’s and Gombrowicz’s prose, promoted Biaoszewski and helped him to publish the debut volume? Of course, the questions formulated in this way sound provocative, but they are worth consideration, especially because the possible answers seem ambivalent. Even if we agree that Sandauer’s presence in the critical reception of Schulz’s and Biaoszewski’s writings cannot be a satisfactory, serious, and above all, scientific argument for these writers’ similarity, there still remains a matter of literary taste that cannot be omitted. Schulz’s prose and Biaoszewski’s early poetry must have suited Sadauer’s individual taste; otherwise he would not assume the role of Biaoszewski’s promoter. It is important to repeat and emphasize the reference here to Biaoszewski’s early work because his next volumes – Rachunek zachciankowy (An Account of Whims, 1959) and Mylne wzruszenia (Deceptive Emotions, 1961) – met with rejection by Sandauer. During the period of Sandauer’s fascination with The Revolution of Things, he characterized Schulz as Biaoszewski’s main predecessor which was the first critical comparison between Schulz and Biaoszewski. The aspects that allowed Sandauer to compare both writers were the chosen literary space – “the world of underculture” (“wiat podkultury”; Sandauer 1981: 372) – and the “mythologizing of reality” (“mityzacja rzeczywistoci”; Sandauer 1981: 372-375) present in Schulz’s prose as well as in some of Biaoszewski’s poems. Unfortunately, the critic’s article remains rather casual and superficial. Sandauer limits his analysis to the repetition of some Schulzian mechanisms (e.g. connection between naturalistic observation and “mythologizing”) in Biaoszewski’s poems without investigating further. The same situation may be observed in Wyka’s article. The comparison of Schulz and Biaoszewski appears as a polemic with Sandauer. According to Wyka, the main difference between both writers is Schulz’s “deadly serious” (Wyka 1959: 186) approach to myths contrasted with Biaoszewski’s humor; however, Wyka does not develop his suggestions. It is quite interesting that in this article Biaoszewski is not only the successor of Schulz but also of Cyprian Kamil Norwid, Tadeusz Peiper, Julian Przybo, Józef Czechowicz,
The Phenomenon of the City in Schulz and Biaoszewski
137
Julian Tuwim, Bolesaw Lemian, Stanisaw Ciesielczuk, and Albin Dziekoski. Despite his extensive literary inheritance, Biaoszewski remains isolated.1 The main problem is that the question about similarities between Schulz’s and Biaoszewski’s literary works has been posed but not answered. As we have already noticed, Sandauer’s and Wyka’s texts might be classified as reviews, quick first-drafts rather than comprehensive research. That is why some critics’ ideas are only mentioned but not explored. To formulate a satisfactory answer, we should look at more recent studies into the authors’ poetic imagery and ways of perceiving reality. The territory on which we can compare these two imageries and artistic creations is the theme of city space. First, however, we must find some similarities between the two writers in other fields, such as critical reception and biography. The critical reception of Schulz and Biaoszewski has much in common. Their debut volumes, published after years of writing for themselves (in Polish we would say do szuflady ‘for the drawer’), obtained very good reviews. While interpreting their writing, many critics used autobiographical information, provoked by the autobiographical quality of Schulz’s prose and Biaoszewski’s realistic writing. Similarities in Schulz’s and Biaoszewski’s attitudes toward life make our comparison even more interesting. Their youth was disturbed by world wars (in the case of Schulz, World War I and in the case of Biaoszewski, World War II), and both had to quit their studies, but this did not stop their interests and passions. Both writers were fascinated by film and dreams and both were individualists. As such they were not accepted by the communist regime and had to wait until 1956 for public recognition – Biaoszewski for his debut and Schulz for post-war and posthumous mementos. When we approach the role of the city in both writers’ biographies, spatial imagery, and literary works, we can find as many similarities as differences. Biaoszewski, like Schulz, lived in the city, specifically Warsaw, throughout his entire life, unlike his provincial “predecessor” from Drohobycz. Biaoszewski had extremely welldeveloped orientation skills, and all cities seemed familiar to him. 1
Marian Kisiel (1999: 100-103) links this mix of tradition with the change in literary consciousness characteristic for the period 1955-1959. After Stalin’s death and the end of Socialist Realism, critics tried to show the continuity of Polish literature and look for analogies.
138
Anna liwa
Sandauer, to his surprise, discovered that Biaoszewski knew Paris better than he did after only a few days even though the critic had lived in the capital of France for over a year (Biaoszewski 1976: 60). Schulz, on the contrary, felt safe and familiar only in his native Drohobycz. He easily got lost in other cities, even in Warsaw. Some interesting differences also can be found with regard to the city in their literary works. In spite of the fact that both writers placed a stimulus for their imagery in the real urban space, only Biaoszewski kept original names of districts, streets, and squares. All the topographical names in his poetry refer to real locations. Schulz never used the name Drohobycz in his prose and always protested against the simple identification between reality and fiction. Of course, that did not change the fact that to the majority of his readers, the city described in Sklepy cynamonowe (Cinnamon Shops) resembles Drohobycz and Crocodile Street seems to be an artistic recreation of Stryjska Street, the main street in Drohobycz. It is worth adding that Schulz’s imagery only focuses on a Drohobycz-like city, whereas Biaoszewski found inspiration also in little towns located near Warsaw (Kobyka, Woomin, Otwock, Misk Mazowiecki, Garwolin, etc.) as well as in the Southeast region of Poland, Rzeszowszczyzna (Binarowa, Biecz, Krosno, Dukla, etc.). Despite the aforementioned differences, there cannot be any doubt about the importance of city space in Schulz’s prose and Biaoszewski’s poetry. Both writers’ artistic inspiration came not from the lime tree branches or idyllic rural landscapes but directly from the daily life: a street, a house, or a town square. When thinking about the spatiality in Schulz’s and Biaoszewski’s literary works, we have to admit that it is almost impossible to imagine them without the city.2 Their writing is so strongly filled with urban space, and the status of the civilian plays an important role in forming the identity of the subject. According to Bohdan Budurowicz (1994: 10), Schulz was in love with Drohobycz since his early childhood, and the city never stopped fascinating him. Biaoszewski also never tried to hide his
2 It is interesting that the authors of Sownik schulzowski or The Schulz Dictionary (Bolecki, Jarz bski and Rosiek 2003) decided to omit the entry “city”, especially since there is an entry for “home”. Instead of “city”, they placed real, geographical names as entries: “Drohobycz” and “Ulica Stryjska” (“Stryjska Street”). The theme of the city in Bruno Schulz’s prose was interpreted by Jarz bski (2005: 88-108).
The Phenomenon of the City in Schulz and Biaoszewski
139
attachment to the city. In one of his narratives entitled Szumy, zlepy, cigi (Noises, Conglomerates, Sequels) he even wrote: Nie jestem dzieckiem natury. Mam w sobie jeszcze t
siedemnastowieczn niech do marszczonego od wiatru bota i do podje d aj cego na zimnie zawiewu zielska, mam tak jak mój Ojciec, a Ojciec po Dziadku, p d do miasta, do haasu i toku. (1976: 177). (I am not a child of nature. I have inside me this seventeenth-century aversion to the mud wrinkled by the wind and the smell of weeds brought by cold wind, I have, just like my Father and Father just like Grandfather, an urge for the city, for noise and crowd.)3
Although we accept all of the similarities mentioned above and remember the differences, there remains an unanswered question: can Schulz really be seen as Biaoszewski’s forerunner? I will use close-readings to investigate the degree of similarity between Schulz’s and Biaoszewski’s spatial imagery. First, I will explain how both writers understood the term “city”. Second, I will analyze the spatial differentiation between the centre and the peripheries, which seems to be crucial. Special attention will also be paid to the aspect of “mythologizing” the city. The City-Creative Factors Biaoszewski wrote ‘I Drew a Plan of an Imaginary City’ (‘Rysowaem plan miasta wymylonego’) when recalling his childhood in his prose piece Rozkurz (Pulverization, 1980). The plan or a map, as a visual, schematic representation of a city, has always been a form of controlling space. The childish game of drawing a map can be understood as the equivalent to the act of founding a city, a repetition of cosmogony. Since the main role of a map is to provide orientation and help in finding the proper way, the elements placed on it must be well-chosen in order to avoid disorientation. A glance at city maps allows one to enumerate elements which define a city: a market with a church and town hall, a main street, particular districts and possibly even city walls. Mircea Eliade concludes that it is 3
All translations of Miron Biaoszewski’s works are mine, except for the poems ‘Garwolin – miastko wieczne’ (‘Garwolin – A Little Town For Ever’) and ‘Rozprawa o stolikowych baranach’ (‘An Essay on Bazaar Rams’), which were translated in Biaoszewski (1974: 17-19).
140
Anna liwa
impossible to live in the chaos of homogeneity and uniformity characteristic of profane space (Eliade 1991: 15). Man needs the sacred that brings hierarchy, sets a centre, and demarcates borders. The city plan shows an effect of such divisions. The map which Schulz extensively describes in the beginning of his story ‘The Street of Crocodiles’ is also the result of (in this case artistic) differentiation and transformation. It is an extraordinary map precise and detailed in the centre and vanishing as it depicts suburbs. In Schulz’s story, the real city exists only in the centre, the sacred sphere; everything placed outside of or distant from the centre remains a poor imitation. Jerzy Jarz bski (2005: 91-92) interpreted this process as a confusion of values and noticed that it has an equivalent in the language in which it is described more elaborate while portraying the city-centre and modest in presentation of suburbs. But the truth is that even while depicting the centre, the author does not mention any typical city-creative factors, such as presence of a temple or a location, such as the town hall, of city authorities. The city is seen as a sum of streets and houses. Differences between them are limited only to external “architectonic polyphony”4 (“polifonia architektoniczna”; Schulz 1989: 71)5 – in Schulz’s words. So it is not the “real” city that attracts Schulz’s attention, but an imaginary one where Crocodile Street is scarcely marked on a map. What is interesting is that the paperlike nature of the city spreads also on the labyrinth-like Crocodile Street: “grey windows cross-ruled many times like sheets of chancellory paper” (“szare okna, kratkowane wielokrotnie, jak arkusze papieru kancelaryjnego”; Op 73); “grey and parchment-like” salesgirls (“szare i papierowe, jak ryciny”; Op 74); “reality […] as thin as a sheet of paper” (“rzeczywisto […] cienka jak papier”; Op 76); and “trams made of papier-mâché” with “sides battered and crumpled after many years of use” (“wozy, zrobione z papier-mâché, o cianach powyginanych i zmi tych od wielokrotnego u ytku”; Op 77). Crocodile Street seems to be a “paper imitation, as in a photomontage made up of cuttings from last year’s mouldered newspapers” (“papierowa imitacja, jak na fotomonta zo ony z wycinków zle aych, zeszorocznych gazet”; Op 80).
4 All quotations from ‘The Street of Crocodiles’ are taken from John Curran Davis’s translation (Schulz 2007). 5 All further references will be given as Op.
The Phenomenon of the City in Schulz and Biaoszewski
141
In Biaoszewski’s debut volume, we do not find a poem related to a city plan in such an explicit manner as is found in ‘The Street of Crocodiles’, but there is one poem that can be compared with Schulz’s story. ‘redniowieczny gobelin o Bieczu’ (‘A Medieval Tapestry about Biecz’) begins like Schulz’s prose with the presentation of a city panorama. While in ‘The Street of Crocodiles’ the role of vocabulary was to create an impression of paper-like imitation, the key to Biaoszewski’s poem can be found in its title. The tapestry may be understood as an extraordinary genre created by the author to emphasize correspondence between a decorative weave and literature. One may suppose that the choice of a medieval background was influenced by Biecz’s reception of city rights in the Middle Ages (1363) as well as by the preserved medieval urban structure of the city (city walls, a market square with an originally Gothic town hall rebuilt in Renaissance style in the sixteenth century, and a Gothic parish church). The most splendid days of Biecz may be traced back to the second half of the fourteenth century, the period of Queen Jadwiga’s patronage. In the poem, Biaoszewski depicts the moment the keys to the city are handed to King Wadysaw Jagieo and Queen Jadwiga; this moment seems to summarize best the history of Biecz, and the form of tapestry best commemorates the city, which is famous for weaving. The tapestry described in the poem is fictional (Dan-Bruzda 1961: 426), just like the map in ‘The Street of Crocodiles’. The poem does not refer to any real object of art, as may be thought at first, especially since all metaphors seem to try to convince us of its actuality. By drawing a parallel between spinning and the story that is spun, the poem itself becomes a decorative tapestry woven from words instead of colorful wool. It becomes a contemporary tapestry presenting medieval Biecz. Following the sequence of events presented in the poetic tapestry, it is hard to dismiss the impression that the main character of this atypical story is the city of Biecz. The structure of a phrase included in the title – ‘A Medieval Tapestry about Biecz’ – recalls titles of numerous medieval hagiographies or chansons de geste (songs/stories/legends about a saint/knight, etc.), which were constructed in the same way. Critics have observed the influence of painting techniques (Cubism, Impressionism) in the way the author presents the world in
142
Anna liwa
the poem (Wyka 1959: 173-176; Dan-Bruzda 1961: 428). Although I do not deny this fact, I also want to suggest that more attention should be paid to the tapestry-like qualities of the poem. It is a fictional tapestry (rather than a Cubist painting) that becomes the object of poetic description. Of course, geometrical tendencies in poetic imagination are clearly visible and cannot be omitted – roofs (triangles), towers (circles), even whole quarters (squares) were transformed into geometric figures. But at the same time it may be interpreted as evidence of simplifications characterizing a tapestry – a woven “painting” – rather than of Cubist curiosity leading to an object’s deconstruction into basic elements. The lexis of the poem incessantly reminds us that it is the tapestry that is the main focus. For example, instead of “they built in Gothic style”, we read “they wove Gothic” (“utkali gotykiem”; Biaoszewski 1987: 20). The elements of a real world are transferred to a context of forms presented on the tapestry. Let us take a look at the following example: “[…] livid threads of a wood / sewed to the sky / into a peak crown” (“[…] sine nici lasu / przyszyte do nieba / w koron spiczast ”; 21). In other lines of the poem we read about “sky’s threads” (“nici nieba”; 23) and “Peter and Paul [who are made] from shiny thread” (“Piotr i Pawe z byszcz cych nici”; 28). Metaphors are also used to emphasize the structure of a tapestry, e.g. “a rough / texture of a pavement” (“szorstka / tkanina bruku”; 23). Beginning from the “Gothic miracle” (“gotyckie cudo”), which “inclined the whole city / on a green hill / although it stayed flat” (“przechylio si cae miasto / w zielonym wzgórzu, / cho pozostao paskie…”; 21), we can find throughout the poem many signals that remind us about simplifications which are an effect of transforming the scenes of life into a tapestry. The members of a particular guild seem to be “portraits of one face” (“portrety jednej twarzy”; 25), and their steady moving procession became “one tower of movement” (“na jednej wie y porusze”; 24). The metaphorical image of the “tower of movement” is completed by a synecdoche, in which proceeding lines of guild members are named “black hats’ stories” (“pi trami czarnych kapeluszy”; 24). Uniformity and loss of individuality are strongly marked by a comparison with the descending representatives of a guild, a monotonous ring of a bell, or a flowing stream. Steadiness of rhythmical motion permeates the poem.
The Phenomenon of the City in Schulz and Biaoszewski
143
The precision in portraying the city is due to numerous adjectives, especially those in superlative degree, and an extremely extended scale of colours that does not omit even one particular tint. The Sownik terminologiczny sztuk piknych (Terminological Dictionary of Fine Arts) explains that tapestries from the period of fifteenth century to seventeenth century differed in range of colors (twenty-five) in comparison to later ones (Kozakiewicz 1969: 126). The number of colors with their tints that are mentioned in the poem also fluctuates around twenty-five. The color red has the highest number of tints and thus dominates the poem, perhaps because it is the color of tiles and because the executioner’s guild played an important role in medieval Biecz. As previously noted, the colorful tapestry presents medieval Biecz. The first lines of the poem offer information about localization of the city: “On the green hill / they wove Gothic / city” (“W zielonym wzgórzu / utkali gotykiem / gród”; Biaoszewski 1987: 20). The choice of localization of the city was dictated by the need of selfdefense. City walls with towers and gates function similarly. Directly behind them the dominant space is created by the guild’s seat gables and towers, with the highest one belonging to the city hall. The first sight of the city seems to be taken from the bird’s-eye view and this perhaps explains why the shapes of city walls, towers, and quarters become geometrical or even similar to a chessboard. Indeed, medieval cities, following the example of Roman camps, usually chose a chessboard plan, in which streets crossed at a right angle and created rectangular plots around a market square (Kozakiewicz 1969: 232). But Biaoszewski takes this comparison a bit further. It is not individuals who go up “on the most spectacular city walls” (“na najznamienitsze mury”) but “red figures” (“czerwone figury”; 20). After a general sketch of Biecz, a series of close-ups follow, beginning from a parish church, through a city hall and a market square with a well and figure of Saint Florian (a patron of firemen). These images mark the city centre with its main buildings representing the sacred (a parish church) and profane (a city hall) power. Although there will be no representatives of the clergy in the procession proceeding to meet the royal couple, the parish church catches the first sight and the poem ends with a recollection of Biecz’s arms that present “Peter and Paul […] / with the second keys to the city” (“Piotr i Pawe […] / z drugimi kluczami do miasta”; Biaoszewski 1987: 28).
144
Anna liwa
Placing the city into a sacral perspective seems obvious in the context of a medieval spirituality. Homo religiosus feels a need to build his own city by orienting it toward the sacred, to a constant point, a centre. From this perspective, the act of locating a city is tantamount to the act of world creation and becomes similar to cosmogony insofar as it reveals and resets the centre. Therefore, a line in which we read that a parish church’s roof “falls each triangle / on four sides” (“spada trójk tem / na strony cztery”; 22) does not seem to appear here by chance and could not be only a result of geometrical tendencies in a presented world. It emphasizes the centre as creating the role of a church – an indispensable point in any medieval city. The space beyond the city centre is divided into squares and quarters that belong to every guild. There is a Jewish square, an executioners square and a painters square. The space provided for each guild seems to reflect citizens’ occupations, and so the specificity of Jewish traders left imprints on their quarter. Even a shadow takes the shape of Jewish side curls. The mobility and activity of Jewish merchants are expressed by dynamic verbs. In the medieval Biecz, which is presented as a tapestry, nothing is lacking, not even the lanes and blind alleys. Sunken windows and thatched roofs or “a black rectangle of gate / knotted by a hunched old woman” (“bramy czarny prostok t / zasupany staruch zgarbion ”; 23) also appear. Thanks to the variety of presented space – from city centre to bystreets – the city on a green hill appears to be truly complete and ready to be imagined in all its detail. Even the sounds and colors are precisely described. The medieval city seems to become immortalized on a tapestry woven from words. As we may observe, even though Schulz and Biaoszewski used similar techniques in presenting a city – both began with a city panorama and then focused on specific spaces (Schulz on Crocodile Street and Biaoszewski on particular districts) – the final effect is completely different. Crocodile Street as an “open addition” is a contradiction of Biecz as a complete and enclosed space. Schulz’s colorless, illusive, labyrinth-like city contrasts with Biaoszewski’s colorful and well-ordered one. This is perhaps a consequence of the fact that both authors tried to transfer the material of visual representation of a city into language: for Schulz, a paper map and for Biaoszewski, a tapestry.
The Phenomenon of the City in Schulz and Biaoszewski
145
Periphery – Centre The next issue with regard to Schulz’s and Biaoszewski’s perceptions of the city, and at the same time further similarities and differences between both writers’ poetic imagery, is the problem of the periphery and the centre. In recalling Schulz’s story ‘The Street of Crocodiles’ we could recognize how seemingly unattractive, illusive suburbs became interesting for the author, how trashy items appealed to him (cf. Schönle 1994). The same fascination with rubbish and crippled or deficient things may be found in Biaoszewski’s debut volume. That is why Sandauer (1981) called ‘The Revolution of Things’ the poetry of oddments. Agnieszka Karpowicz (2006) compared the function of objects in Biaoszewski’s prose with ready-made and environment in twentieth-century art. With regard to city space, the abode of trash and shoddy goods is a bazaar. In Biaoszewski’s debut volume, between poems about Warsaw, we can also find one about this special place. What is significant is that Warsaw was always the most important space for Biaoszewski. It was the place of his birth. He lived there almost his entire life and survived the difficult days of the Warsaw Uprising during World War II. Recalling the pre-war appearance of his city, the poet observed with a reporter’s flair every detail of the changing capital. Biaoszewski’s inspiration, taken from reality and concrete space, can also be easily seen in his poem ‘Rozprawa o stolikowych baranach’ (‘An Essay on Bazaar Rams’). Praga, Warsaw’s district mentioned in the poem, really is famous for bazaar folklore and a prototype of “bazaar rams” – the golden Easter Ram – was bought in that district (Chabowska-Brykalska 1996: 97). According to Biaoszewski’s friends’ recollections, the author was fascinated by the world of local markets and church fairs (Chotomska 1996: 107, 109; Prudil 1996: 78). However, the fact that a bazaar and bazaar rams became an inspiration, a poetic topic, means much more than following memories and being interested in shoddy, trashy goods. It seems to be an answer to a socialist culture’s centralism, especially because in Stalin’s period, when this poem was written, markets existed but only in a very restricted way (some change was brought by the government of Gomuka). The author indicates that a real urban life is hidden in all places that are marginalized and rejected by an official culture.
146
Anna liwa
The choice of this poetic topic may be explained in another way. Biaoszewski – a city connoisseur – would not have forgotten about such an essential place, a market, and its role as a city creator. It is not accidental that huge metropolises were built along main trade routes because the trade of commodities guaranteed the citizens’ prosperity and safety as well as the city’s economic development. The title of the poem – ‘An Essay on Bazaar Rams’ – includes two pieces of information. It mentions a genre (“an essay”) typical for scientific theses and a subject of analysis – “bazaar rams”. The title strongly suggests that the poem should be taken seriously. However, an opening apostrophe addressed to “a bazaar of left-bank Warsaw” (“fantazjo warszawskiej Pragi”; Biaoszewski 1987: 44) warns us that the poem is much closer to a bazaar’s bunkum than to an essay that requires seriousness. The reader receives in that way a signal that he enters a poetic market where everything is possible. The bazaar is a game in which you must be aware all of the time and not let anyone trick you. In order to produce an image of Warsaw’s bazaar in poetic words, Biaoszewski made use of an interesting trick: he split a poetic subject into two persons, each having different points of view on a location presented in the poem. For the first person, the bazaar is a centre of interest, attracts attention as a new, colorful, fascinating microcosm; the first person is an outsider observing the market’s customs with both interest and distance. At the same time, the second person, who is a tradesman and insider, offers his articles for sale. As an effect of this division, we are given not only two different yet complementary points of view but also an opportunity to hear this difference. The bazaar’s explorer uses long, extensive sentences and tries to formulate general conclusions. In contrast, the tradesman – an integral part of the bazaar world – prefers abridgement and detail. Thus his statements are limited only to information about his products – bazaar rams – and seem to be characteristic of a negligent tradesman’s language with false etymology or borrowings repeated without understanding. In a metaphorical apostrophe to Praga, Biaoszewski names another object of the bazaar reality: a table on “one leg / varnished / red” (“masz assyryjskie rogi / i jedn nog / czerwono / lakierowan ”). Both the table, which is said to have “Assyrian horns”, and the rams put on it – equivalents of a bazaar’s trash and junk – are
The Phenomenon of the City in Schulz and Biaoszewski
147
placed in the context of an ancient art and are at the same time ennobled by this comparison. Cultural references, mainly to prehistoric (palaeolithic) and ancient art, did not appear here by chance. In some ways, the Praga bazaar, preserved somewhere in the Warsaw suburbs despite the centralized economy and nationalized shops, seems to belong more to remote antiquity than to the communist present. Drawing a comparison between a bazaar and an ancient excavation appears quite reasonable. Both spaces give their explorer a chance to discover something sensational (in terms of price or artistic and historical value) and worth attention. Both demand from the explorer some special qualities, like quick wits and intuition. As archeology provides information about ways of living and occupations of ancient people, so a market – an institution as old as human history – preserves customs and local folklore that have completely disappeared in other areas of contemporary life. The bazaar’s articles – Easter rams –– appear to be not so different or distant from ancient statuettes and cult’s sculptures. For example we can recall Neolithic clay figures representing rams that have served in magical practices as a guarantee of wealth. In ancient Egypt a ram was considered to be a saintly animal of the god of the air and harvest, Amon, who was later identified with the god of the sun, Re. Thus a temple of Amon in Karnak is preceded by an alley of sphinxes with rams’ heads. Ancient analogies of “bazaar rams” widen the context of the poem. It refers not only to Warsaw’s market but also to a mechanism that forms human civilization. The poem’s subject – the bazaar’s explorer – surprised by this permeation of past and present and of cultural values, asks: “What tropic is it? / ‘Which epoch? – What time?’” (“Jaki zwrotnik? / ‘Wiek który? – – Czas który?’”). This question, in which we can recognize a slightly modified text borrowing from a Norwid poem entitled ‘List do Bronisawa Z.’ (‘A letter to Bronislaw Z.’), seems to concern the two most important aspects organizing the human condition – space and time. However, what is most interesting is that the passage of time does not change much. “Religions – rituals – and magic” (“Magie – religie – rytuay”) are situated outside time or more precisely, become part of a cyclical, sacral time, and this is why they seem eternal. Paradoxically, the bazaar located in the outskirts of Warsaw may at the same time be in the centre of existence; it is where civilization is being born, inside a
148
Anna liwa
crucible of mixed products, offers, and cultural values,. The bazaar obtains the status of a chosen space, one appropriate for the fulfillment of timeless ritual, in which various people and elements meet with each other and mutual contact between human thought and experience is possible. At this point, the fundamental difference between Schulz’s and Biaoszewski’s way of perceiving the periphery and the centre appears. In Schulz’s prose, the choice of Crocodile Street as a literary topic does not change the traditional hierarchy and order of values. The centre of the town remains central as a possessor and dispatcher of values, and Crocodile Street, though appealing, must be seen as an inferior, secondary, and imitative space. Biaoszewski decentralizes the centre. He suggests the peripheral bazaar as a city origin and centre – not a communist House of Party or the Palace of Culture – to emphasize that the pulse of civilization can be felt right there on the market. “Mythologizing” the City The main aspect of Schulz’s prose is the “mythologizing of reality” (“mityzacja rzeczywistoci”), the conviction that “reality is a shadow of the word” (“rzeczywisto jest cieniem sowa”; Schulz 1989: 368). The city space actively participates in this process. It is the power of language that changes provincial Drohobycz into “wschodni Bagdad, […] egzotyczne miasto jak z Bani tysica i jednej nocy” (“an oriental Bagdad, the exotic city from One Thousand and One Nights”) as Adam Zagajewski (1994: 21) accurately observed. The consequences of “mythologizing” might be seen especially in the description of Crocodile Street – a mysterious and tempting metamorphosis of Stryjska Street. The paper-centric, book-like or newspaper-like existence of this street is closer to dream or imagination than to reality. Biaoszewski did not use the term mityzacja in The Revolution of Things, but rather wrote about “undetermined reality” (“rzeczywisto nieustalona”; Biaoszewski 1987: 69) or “doubtful presence” (“obecno niepewna”; 46-47). In many poems, however, he transformed reality into myth through his ability to perceive uniqueness in everyday life not only in Warsaw but also in Warsaw’s surroundings. He changed the ordinariness of daily duties into
The Phenomenon of the City in Schulz and Biaoszewski
149
mysterious rituals and extolled their repetition as mythical ceremony. From Warsaw’s surroundings, it was Garwolin that appeared in poems most frequently. This small city situated southeast of the capital became an inspiration for two separate poetical cycles and other narrative ones. Biaoszewski often visited Garwolin – a city where his mother had lived since her second marriage. The poet’s mother always seems to be present in his Garwolin poems. As a result, if we appeal to a conception of Gaston Bachelard, Garwolin can be viewed as the archetypal Mother’s Home (Lege yska 1996: 73). Even preparations for the journey and the route to Garwolin were marked by positive emotions. The coziness of home was guaranteed by not only the poet’s mother but also the proximity of Stefa and aunt Wacka. It was also more visible because it is contrasted with Garwolin’s cold and frosty landscape. It is interesting that we become acquainted with Garwolin mainly at winter time. Winter was also chosen for a background in the first poem dedicated to Garwolin entitled ‘Garwolin – miastko wieczne’ (‘Garwolin – A Little Town For Ever’). “A little town for ever”, a phrase included in the title of the poem, brings to mind cultural references connected with ancient Rome. Of course, in comparison to Rome – the Eternal City of European civilization – everlasting Garwolin can only be a little town and not a city. But it is not the comparison with Rome that provides Garwolin with prestige. Its main advantage and quality is its provincial identity. A key to this explanation was hidden in a motto placed under the title: “garlic like a pearl… why? – garlic is garlic” (“czosnek jak pera… – dlaczego? czosnek jak czosnek”; Biaoszewski 1987: 121). The truth about garlic is told by its own shape. No sophisticated comparisons are needed. The variety of associations can be found in garlic itself. Peeling garlic brings to mind Roman legions (it is believed that legionaries ate a lot of garlic, which protected them against infections) and Spain (garlic is commonly used in Spanish cuisine) which means the subject can pose a question: “don’t you [also] feel by any chance” (“nie czujecie przypadkiem” Biaoszewski 1987: 121) this civilization’s pulse in the European continent? Garlic’s route to Garwolin became identified with the route of European culture: from East (Greece), through the South of Europe and Spain, then to the North, and to Garwolin as well. The question is
150
Anna liwa
also a bit ironical considering garlic’s strong smell. Although ordinary days in little towns seem to be similar to each other like a garlic’s plait, commonplaceness appears archetypal. Peeling garlic recalls a ceremony in which Garwolin becomes included into a community of culture’s history. In the end, we should return to the poet’s mother – Garwolin’s inhabitant. It could be thought that this poem completely forgets to mention her. The title, like the rest of the poem, does not even mention her name. Similarly, the reason for designating Garwolin as “a little town forever” and the poetic comparison between Garwolin and Rome still stays unresolved. The answer for both conundrums surprisingly combines and complements them. We can find it in a proverb: all roads lead to Rome, which was slightly modified by Biaoszewski. In his poem, all roads lead to mother – to Garwolin, and that is the reason for Garwolin’s eternity, for becoming a little Rome. The role of Mother in Biaoszewski’s poetry may be compared with the role of Father in Schulz’s prose. The similarity between them is only superficial. It should be emphasized that Father in Schulz’s prose is someone special, an artist, a demigod creating new worlds as well as becoming an object of metamorphoses. Mother in Biaoszewski’s poetry never claimed such a role. However, there is something that links those two characters in the analyzed literary works. Their presence can be perceived as a stimulus to “mythologizing”. In ‘The Street of Crocodiles’ Father is absent, but the map belongs to him – it is the starting point to the whole story. In ‘Garwolin – A Little Town For Ever’, garlic braids, presumably hanging in Mother’s kitchen, play a similar role. Conclusion During three stages of research into Schulz’s and Biaoszewski’s spatial imagery we tried to answer the question of whether or not – and to what degree – Schulz can be thought of as Biaoszewski’s forerunner. Of course, the answer is ambivalent and far from simple. We observed some similarities as well as differences in both writers’ perception of the city. In-depth analysis shows that even striking convergences of both writers’ imageries or artistic means do not confirm Biaoszewski’s subordination to Schulz and may appear superficial. Biaoszewski was an original and innovative writer. He
The Phenomenon of the City in Schulz and Biaoszewski
151
usually took his own paths, as shown in his debut volume; however; reading of The Revolution of Things with Schulz’s prose as a context seems productive and fruitful. It calls our attention to some topics of his writing that might be less appealing without this comparison and less investigated by critics. It also allows one to recognize the specificity of Biaoszewski in terms of poetic language as well as the emphases each writer highlights and the artistic choices he makes. Bibliography Biaoszewski, Miron. 1974. The Revolution of Things. Selected Poems of Miron Bialoszewski (tr. A. Busza and B. Czaykowski). Washington: Charioteer Press. ——. 1976. Szumy, zlepy, cigi. Warszawa: Pastwowy Instytut Wydawniczy. ——. 1980. Rozkurz. Warszawa: Pastwowy Instytut Wydawniczy. ——. 1987. Utwory zebrane, vol. 1. Warszawa: Pastwowy Instytut Wydawniczy. Bolecki, Wodzimierz, Jerzy Jarz bski and Stanisaw Rosiek (eds). 2003. Sownik schulzowski. Gdask: sowo/obraz terytoria. Budurowicz, Bohdan. 1994. ‘Galicja w twórczoci Brunona Schulza’ (tr. M. Adamczyk-Grabowska) in Kitowska-ysiak (1994): 9-17. Chabowska-Brykalska, Teresa. 1996. ‘34 lata bliskiego znania si ’ in Kirchner (1996): 95-106. Chotomska, Wanda. 1996. ‘Pan Mironczewski’ in Kirchner (1996): 107-120. Dan-Bruzda, Stanisaw. 1961. ‘O obrotach rzeczy Mirona Bialoszewskiego’ in Pamitnik Literacki 52(4): 425-476. Eliade, Mircea. 1991. ‘wiat – miasto – dom’ (tr. I. Kania) in Znak 12: 12-22. Ficowski, Jerzy. 2002. Regiony wielkiej herezji i okolice. Bruno Schulz i jego mitologia. Sejny: Pogranicze. Jarz bski, Jerzy. 2005. ‘Miasto Schulza’ in Jarz bski, Jerzy. Prowincja centrum. Przypisy do Schulza, Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie: 88-108. Karpowicz, Agnieszka. 2006. ‘Ready made. Przedmiot w prozach Mirona Biaoszewskiego’ in Pamitnik Literacki 97(1): 125-139. Kirchner, Hanna (ed.) 1996. Miron – wspomnienia o poecie. Warszawa: TENTEN. Kisiel, Marian. 1999. ‘Lektury Kazimierza Wyki’ in Zmiana. Z problemów wiadomoci literackiej przeomu 1955–1959 w Polsce. Katowice: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu l skiego: 100-103. Kitowska-ysiak, Magorzata (ed.) 1994. Bruno Schulz. In memoriam. 1892–1942. Lublin: Wydawnictwo FIS. Kozakiewicz, Stanisaw (ed.) 1969. Sownik terminologiczny sztuk piknych. Warszawa: Pastwowe Wydawnictwo Naukowe. Lege yska, Anna. 1996. ‘Dom Mirona Biaoszewskiego’ in Dom i poetyka bezdomnoci w liryce wspóczesnej, Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Naukowe PWN: 71-94. Prudil, Irena. 1996. ‘Znaam kiedy chopca’ in Kirchner (1996): 59-86.
152
Anna liwa
Sandauer, Artur. 1981. ‘Poezja rupieci (Rzecz o Mironie Biaoszewskim)’ in Zebrane prace krytyczne, vol. 1. Warszawa: Pastwowy Instytut Wydawniczy: 358392. Schönle, Andreas. 1994. ‘Sklepy cynamonowe Brunona Schulza: apologia tandety’ (tr. J. Szpyra) in Kitowska-ysiak (1994): 59-77. Schulz, Bruno. 1989. Opowiadania. Wybór esejów i listów (ed. J. Jarz bski). Wrocaw: Zakad Narodowy im. Ossoliskich. ——. 2007. ‘Ulica krokodyli’ (tr. J.C. Davis). On line at: http://www.schulzian. net/translation/shops/krokodyli.htm (consulted 12.02.2007). Wyka, Kazimierz. 1959. ‘Na odpust poezji’ in Rzecz wyobra ni. Warszawa: Pastwowy Instytut Wydawniczy: 173-194. Zagajewski, Adam. 1994. ‘Drohobycz i wiat’ in Kitowska-ysiak (1994): 19-24.
Mythopoetic Traditions and Inserted Treatises: Bruno Schulz and Danilo Kiš Alfred Gall Abstract: The article focuses on the reception of Bruno Schulz’s fiction in Danilo Kiš’s novel Peš anik (Hourglass, 1972). It deals with the complex patterns of intertextual relationship one can observe in this novel, where the ‘Traktat o krompiru’ (‘Treatise on the Potato’) alludes to Schulz’s ‘Traktat o manekinach’ (‘Treatise on Tailors’ Dummies’). Comparative inquiry into the functions of these striking textual echoes has seldom been undertaken. This essay tries to cast light upon the way in which Kiš refers to Schulz’s text. In summary, the sophisticated intertextual play is considered to be a mode of literary response to the Shoah.
Introduction The mythopoetic literary practice of Bruno Schulz has been the focus of critical studies including comparative approaches (e.g. Koschmal 1987: 193-214). Among the authors usually considered to be influenced by Bruno Schulz, the Yugoslav writer Danilo Kiš – he declared himself to be the only Yugoslav writer – must certainly be mentioned. This influence is especially strong in Kiš’s autobiographical trilogy. The trilogy (also called the “family trilogy”, or the “family circus”) is composed of the volumes Rani jadi (Early Sorrows, 1969), Bašta, pepeo (Garden, Ashes, 1965) and Peš anik (Hourglass, 1972) all reflecting, though in very different ways, the experience of the author’s family during the Second World War and focusing on Kiš’s father, who fell victim to Nazi genocide.1 The similar cultural contexts of these two outstanding writers, both situated in Jewish traditions as well as in the culture of Habsburg Central Europe, delineate a common frame of reference for literary study that focuses on a comparative approach (e.g. Bukwalt 2003: 5 ff.; Fiut 1999: 279-302). However, one must remember the gap that 1
Cf. Deli (1997: 65 ff., 143 ff., 227 ff.) for a general orientation.
154
Alfred Gall
separates these two writers. It is hardly appropriate to merge Schulz’s experience of the Habsburg cultural background with Kiš’s experience, bearing in mind the latter lived from 1935 to 1989, long after the breakdown of the Habsburg Monarchy; nevertheless, as far as Kiš’s novel is concerned, it certainly makes sense to consider different forms of notable intertextual references to Bruno Schulz’s texts. Furthermore, any attempt to trace the complex pattern of Kiš’s literary practice (at least in his famous family trilogy) will inevitably lead to the conclusion that his texts are made from elements found among others in Schulz’s stories. Of course, Kiš is definitely not an epigone. He instead pays homage to the Polish writer by referring to his literary work. The point to note here is that the broader context of a similar cultural background and the Jewish origin of both writers mark a certain affinity. In addition, the fact that Bruno Schulz was gunned down by a German officer in the ghetto of Drohobycz immediately refers to the Shoah, a break in civilization that also deeply affected Kiš’s family. Hence, cultural affinity, biographical correlation and the impact of the Shoah appear to have led Danilo Kiš to pay special attention to the Polish writer, for he actually constructs his textual world in Hourglass from elements found in Schulz’s stories. Thus, the aim of this study is to examine certain aspects of this intertextual dimension. Studies that have recently appeared cover a wide range of questions arising from the comparison between the two authors although descriptions and literary criticism prevail and far-reaching conclusions are still to be drawn.2 In order to confirm a comparative approach, most authors refer to Kiš’s alleged remark “Schulz is my God” in a conversation with John Updike (1988: 3),3 yet there is no evidence in Kiš’s legacy that he actually said this. In recent times the affinities between Kiš and Schulz have been analyzed in different studies which focus on key topics appearing in texts of both writers (and thereby establishing a common framework for comparative study), such as the idea that reality is a 2
Cf., for instance, Bukwalt (2003) for a comparison of the literary creation of Jewish fathers, a motif equally crucial for Danilo Kiš and Bruno Schulz. A comparative approach based on key motifs is offered by Pijanovi (1992: 80-96). 3 Cf. Schulz (1988: 120) and Brown (1990: 234) for a mention of the remark and Stojanovi (2002: 171-183) for a discussion of this issue.
Mythopoetic Traditions and Inserted Treatises: Schulz and Kiš
155
book, subsequently the idea that reality can be understood as a peculiar textual configuration or even as labyrinth where one has to orientate oneself – which is sometimes linked to the influence of Gnostic traditions (cf. Lachmann 2002: 344 ff.). But attention is also paid to the fact that literary texts resemble a palimpsest, and of course, the all-embracing role of the father in the literary imagination of both writers has attracted interest (Olchanowski 2001: passim), just as the mythopoetic traits as well as the palaeontological and archaeological imagery at work in their texts has (Pijanovi 1992: 80-96; Fiut 1999: 279-281, 287-298). Danuta irli-Straszyska stressed the fact that Kiš was not immediately influenced by Bruno Schulz.4 However, Branislava Stojanovi casts a different light on this matter (2002: 171-183). In her seminal article concerning the reception of Schulz’s texts in former Yugoslavia, she convincingly presents concrete sources of literary reception, which clearly indicate that Danilo Kiš must have known Bruno Schulz’s works at least to some extent. For instance, Sklepy cynamonowe (Cinnamon Shops, 1934) appeared in 1961 in Belgrade in a Serbian translation.5 In the discussion whether Kiš was influenced by authors like Schulz, Borges, Joyce, Proust or Nabokov, it should be kept in mind that influence is too meagre a concept. Instead of naively searching presupposed sources, we must face the question of reflexivity in a literary text. Kiš can be understood as an author who relies on other texts which are then transformed in a subtle intertextual play; hence, the emerging textual configuration cannot be deduced from the evoked texts. They instead serve as a multi-layered background for literary applications and adaptations that create new semantic schemes by inscribing one text in a variety of others. To put it bluntly, there is no way to accuse Kiš of plagiarism.6 Writing with the consciousness to be part of a self-chosen tradition is not comparable to writing as an epigone.7 Instead it alludes to the evermore actual idea (Ingold 1992: 11 ff., 345 ff.) that creativity and 4
Danuta irli-Straszyska’s opinion is expressed in her afterword to the Polish translation of Hourglass (cf. Kiš 1978: 244). 5 A translation of parts of Cinnamon Shops appeared in Subotin (1969: 187-241). 6 Cf. the affair aroused after the publication of Grobnica za Borisa Davidovi a (A Tomb for Boris Davidovich, 1976); cf. Krivokapi (1980: passim) for statements in this campaign against Kiš. 7 Danuta irli-Straszyska (1988: 259) seems to identify these two notions.
156
Alfred Gall
innovations are realized in a constant application and simultaneous transformation of given and chosen texts of reference and are thus emerging qualities that occur in a basically dialogical process (Wierzbycki 1988: 240 ff).8 This dialogue is not necessarily bound to a similar cultural background, but in our case the relationship between Bruno Schulz and Danilo Kiš can be identified as such a literary dialogue.9 A closer scrutiny showed that it is highly probable that Kiš knew Schulz’s texts at least to some extent. In this context Kiš’s selfreflexive literary practice can be described as postmodern in the sense that it marks a different attitude in comparison to other texts with their concomitant idea of reaching or constructing a reality of its own without reference to underlying sign systems (Lawson 1985: passim; Vladiv-Glover 2003: 7 ff., 35 ff). Now special attention is paid to two key features we meet in Schulz’s prose as well as in Kiš’s texts. My interest is focused on the one hand on metatextual devices such as inserted treatises and on the other hand on mythopoetic traditions permeating the literary text. I intend to combine these two features and will focus on two selected passages where they are intertwined. I will concentrate on the story cycle ‘Traktat o manekinach’ (‘Treatise on Tailors’ Dummies’) in Cinnamon Shops and on the ‘Traktat o krompiru’ (‘Treatise on the Potato’), which is part of ‘Beleške jednog ludaka’ (‘Notes of a Madman’) in Danilo Kiš’s Hourglass. Bruno Schulz’s ‘Traktat o manekinach’ (‘Treatise on Tailors’ Dummies’) Mythopoetic narrative in Schulz’s texts is often described in reference to his article ‘Mityzacja rzeczywistoci’ (‘The Mythologizing of Reality’), where the ontological basis of reality is defined by the idea of a general, all-embracing but at the present time dissolved text (Schulz 1989: 385 ff.) For Schulz, this text lies underneath the different mythological and religious traditions that form the basis of literary practice which is trying to adjust these traditions to the modern world. In this way, a mythopoetic text relates the contemporary world to mythological traditions which form a certain canvas for actual texts. Writing means facing the challenge of 8
Kornhauser (2001: 187-202) argues in the same vein. Cf. Baraczak (1996: 173) for the notion of a dialogue on the common ground of cultural and historical experience in Central Europe.
9
Mythopoetic Traditions and Inserted Treatises: Schulz and Kiš
157
reconstructing the original text that has been lost. This double-layered process of writing combines the reference to different mythological traditions and fragments with the construction of literary visions that transcend empirical structures of reality. Because the frame of reference for any understanding and modelling of reality is anchored in myth, the structure of the real can be compared to language, i.e. to a certain system of signs that must be deciphered. The primary word is an expression of this metaphysically established order that still can be found whenever the given reality is related to its hidden metaphysical structure. In any case, mythopoetic devices are meant to build a certain reality founded on regained sense. Literary practice, with its imaginary way of representing patterns of mythological traditions, offers insights into a hitherto unseen totality that can be visualized at least in some fragments. These fragments result from aesthetic revision of myths. Parcels and fragments of mythologies are recombined and actualized in the process of literary writing (Kuprel 1996: 100-117). Moreover, the performative aspect of literary imagination is closely linked to the idea that in contemporary desacralized and secularized reality only the newly gained access to myth offers the possibility of at least a fragmentary presence of lost sense which cannot be re-established in a metaphysical order. Mythopoetics is thus a literary ars memoria recalling ancient cultural traditions and thereby transcending immediate reality.10 Reality loses its firm ground and stable structure (Stala 1995: passim). The genealogy of myth offers sense, but does not necessarily establish a newly found reality, as there is no centre in Schulz’s texts that would integrate totality in a manifest way.11 The antecedent idea prevails that lost sense has to be found and re-established by the work of the literary text that recollects mythological beginnings where word and reality, sign and substance, were once identical. Literary practice, however, as a way of dealing with the archive of culture including myths, does not regain metaphysical or ontological stability (Jarz bski 1984: 196, 205), but instead enforces the process of disintegration by evoking also minor or 10
Speina (1974: 54) sees a child’s imagination at work here. According to Kasperski (1993: 79-94), reality as the corollary of literary imagination using and transforming myths (or fragments of them) is denied any substantial ground and should instead be described as a floating process with no attainable or clearly defined centre.
11
158
Alfred Gall
only fragmentary realizations full of ironical flavour indicating the second-rate as well as second-hand character of the reapplied mythological fragments (Wiegandt 1997: 73). Amongst other things this is meant when the phantasmagoric character of imagined realities in Schulz’s prose is stressed (Jarz bski 1973: 120; Okopie-Sawiska 1973: 8). Bruno Schulz’s Cinnamon Shops is an important example of literary activation of myths. Fragments of mythological and religious traditions can be found in the ‘Traktat o manekinach’, where the subtitle ‘Wtóra ksi ga Rodzaju’ (‘The Second Book of Genesis’) clearly indicates the textual interplay that takes places with the biblical text. This inserted treatise engenders an intertextual play which transforms biblical traditions. The treatise contains a heretical vision of the process of creation. Jacob, the father of the first-person narrator, explains his own point of view on creation and creativity. Man-made creation, though of minor quality, is accepted as a consciously developed second-rate creation that rivals with God and his creation. The quarrel with God in the treatise is grounded in a religious code – also found elsewhere in Cinnamon Shops – that realizes the idea of regaining a mythological framework for the description of reality. In the treatise Jacob reflects to a certain degree his own ornithological experiments that seem to be experiments with the ontological foundations of reality. The birds and their appearance, after they underwent far-reaching deformations, resemble the tailor’s dummies of the treatise: they are distorted and the product of a secondary imagination which fails to realize itself in comparison with the power of God but does indeed fulfil its own premises and self-declared idea of a second Genesis. This “treatise” containing the quarrel with a demiurge and the idea of a man-made creation that substitutes God’s creation can be identified as an obvious literary travesty of metaphysical and religious debate. There is no way to identify the treatise with a clear-cut religious concept although one can see obvious references to the Gnostic idea of a minor world or creation that has to be transcended (Jarz bski 1994: 310).12 The inserted treatise can also be read as a metatextual frame of reference as it comments on the process of derealization as well as of depersonalization that takes place in other texts of Cinnamon Shops, 12
Cf. also Bukwalt (2003: 64 ff.).
Mythopoetic Traditions and Inserted Treatises: Schulz and Kiš
159
where the undermining of any stable place leads to ontological instability. In Schulz’s text we cannot find any hint of concrete historical circumstances. The whole scenery of Cinnamon Shops is embedded in the nearby reality of a provincial town in Galicia and is focused on the narrator’s family and their home. This setting is the starting point of the process of derealization. Reality is evolving as a form of permanent instability without any given aim to reach and lacking ontological firmness. History appears in the form of economical and social modernization that undermines the father’s position and thus threatens the family’s home. Additionally, the treatise refers, even in its form as an inserted text, to a generic tradition that includes accounts in the sense of a systematic exposition including a methodical discussion of the facts and principles involved and conclusions reached. The father claims to be a new creator; in this way he rivals with the demiurge: – Demiurgos – mówi mój ojciec – nie posiad monopolu na tworzenie – tworzenie jest przywilejem wszystkich duchów. Materii dana jest nieskoczona podno, niewyczerpana moc yciowa i zarazem uwodna sia pokusy, która nas n ci do formowania. (Schulz 1998: 35)13 (“The Demiurge,” said my father, “has had no monopoly of creation, for creation is the privilege of all spirits. Matter has been given infinite fertility, inexhaustible vitality, and, at the same time, a seductive power of temptation which invites us to create as well”; Schulz 1988: 39)14
Jacob claims that the material world does not have any stable structure, and in spite of its seeming stability, it is bound to be reverted. This means that a creative force can interfere and exert influence on the floating process of the material world: Materia jest najbierniejsz i najbezbronniejsz istot w kosmosie. […] Wszystkie organizacje materii s nietrwae i lune, atwe do uwstecznienia i rozwi zania. (Op 35) (Matter is the most passive and most defenceless essence in the cosmos. […] All attempts at organizing matter are transient and temporary, easy to reverse and to dissolve; TF 39)
13 14
All further references will be given as Op. All further references will be given as TF.
160
Alfred Gall
Jacob’s intentions to create a new world that will be founded on the accepted knowledge of the ever-floating substance of the real transcend the given world. In his world-making, the creation he faces goes far beyond the given material reality that seems to be reduced to a playground of creative energy, constantly changing the appearance of what we call the real: “[…] the second Genesis of creatures which was to stand in open opposition to the present era” (TF 41; “[…] obraz tej drugiej generacji stworze, która stan miaa w otwartej opozycji do panuj cej epoki”; Op 37). The father explains in detail the idea of creating man a second time; creation is in this treatise especially concentrated on man, who has to be created in a new form that will actually not be lasting: “‘In one word,’ Father concluded, ‘we wish to create a man a second time – in the shape and semblance of a tailor’s dummy’” (TF 41; “– Sowem – konkludowa mój ojciec – chcemy stworzy po raz wtóry czowieka, na obraz i podobiestwo manekina”; Op 38). As far as these new human beings the father intends to create are concerned, they form a simulacrum of God’s creation; they are equal but ontologically different because of their lack of stability and their minor substance in comparison with the creation they are meant to imitate. In summary, they are a minor substitute to man created by God: Byy to w istocie istoty amorfne bez wewn trznej struktury, pody imitatywnej tendencji materii, która, obdarzona pami ci , powtarza z przyzwyczajenia raz przyj te ksztaty. (Op 43) ([…] they were amorphous creatures, with no internal structure, products of the imitative tendency of matter which, equipped with memory, repeats from force of habit the forms already accepted; TF 44)
The floating material substance, gaining new shapes that are doomed to perish and giving way to new evolving forms, is equal to a permanent metamorphosis affecting every single element. In his deliberations, Jacob stresses the fact that even his own brother fell victim to the ever-changing material world in its never ending unfolding of new forms: – Czy mam przemilcze – mówi przyciszonym gosem – e brat mój na skutek dugiej i nieuleczalnej choroby zamieni si stopniowo w zwój
Mythopoetic Traditions and Inserted Treatises: Schulz and Kiš
161
kiszek gumowych, e biedna moja kuzynka dniem i noc nosia go w poduszkach, nuc c nieszcz liwemu stworzeniu nieskoczone koysanki nocy zimowych? Czy mo e by co smutniejszego ni czowiek zamieniony w kiszk hegarow ? […]. (Op 48) (“Am I to conceal from you” he said in a low tone, “that my own brother, as a result of a long and incurable illness, has been gradually transformed into a bundle of rubber tubing, and that my poor cousin had to carry him day and night on his cushion, singing to the luckless creature endless lullabies on winter nights? Can there be anything sadder than a human being changed into the rubber tub of an enema? […]”; TF 51)
The metamorphosis with its concomitant effects of depersonalization and dehumanization will play a key role in Hourglass and then also encompass historical contexts. In the ‘Treatise on Tailors’ Dummies’ the material world is a product of imagination and indicates the basic instability of any ontological order. Kiš’s Hourglass also displays the connection of a treatise with mythopoetics. In this context Schulz’s devices and their rearrangement form a certain literary descriptive vocabulary (Rorty 1989: 3 ff.) that is meant to be used in the wake of the necessity of self-positioning after the Shoah. More accurately, Hourglass presents a metatextual rearrangement of Schulz’s prose. One has to be reminded that Kiš reworked different literary traditions in his text and was not following just one textual pattern. It is important to note that Hourglass is on one level the reconstruction of the life of E.S. – a literary double of Kiš’s own father – who as a Jew fell victim to the Nazis. The reconstruction relies on documents, especially on a letter E.S. wrote to his sister Olga. For any comparison, we should carefully remember that Nabokov in his novel The Gift, in the second chapter, deals with a similar problem: writing the biography of his own father leads the main protagonist, Fedor Godunov-erdyncev, to archival studies and evaluations of documents until he finally resigns because he does not want to falsify his father’s life in his own biographical study that he is about to complete. Kiš and the resonances of Schulz’s works: ‘Traktat o krompiru’ (‘Treatise on the Potato’) The novel we focus on now is the third and concluding volume of the so-called family trilogy. Hourglass appeared in 1972 and is an
162
Alfred Gall
archaeological novel reconstructing the world lost in the course of World War II. Unlike the other two parts of the trilogy, Hourglass is a text without a first-person narrator. It offers a wide range of different narrative devices, but none of them can be attributed to a single narrator. The core motif is the experience of a break in civilization caused by the Shoah. The break separates two different worlds. Whereas the former world of the main protagonist E.S. who perished in Auschwitz is irreversibly lost, the actual world associated with the narrator is deeply marked by the impact of the Shoah. The text is an attempt to close the gap between past and present, but it is exactly this intention that exposes the inadequacy of any successful representation of the past in a given literary text. Furthermore, the idea of adequacy itself evaporates (Rorty 1989: 160-161). Yet even the antecedent idea of representing and regaining a lost world is refuted. The text thus accomplishes the paradoxical movement between the idea of reconstructing the past world of a single protagonist in all its variety and the disclosure of the elusiveness of any such endeavour. The oscillation between reconstruction and disclosure is thus characterized as a paradoxical narrative discourse. This paradox refers to the Shoah as a historical break which undermines any stable textual representation. Therefore, the novel Hourglass is the complete disruption of time and ontological embedding of humanity. The autobiographical trilogy as a narrative return to childhood does not rest upon any a priori supposed continuity. Because of the irreparable break the Shoah caused, individual existence is deeply marked by traumatic experiences which disrupt the continuous flow of history.15 The main protagonist is described as E.S. (obviously Eduard Sam, as he is called in the two former novels of the trilogy). In Hourglass the topic of reconstruction is all-embracing and based on the letter E.S. wrote to Olga. Cited in full length and quoted in italics, the letter is the underlying document for the whole reconstructive work in the novel. E.S., the father who is depersonalized, reduced to his initials and appears in the other parts of the autobiographical cycle, functions as personification. He is a multi-layered protagonist alluding to mythological and religious traditions: Ahasverus, Narcissus, Jesus Christ, Moses, Jeremiah, Don Quixote, Charlie Chaplin, a clown, a 15
Cf. atuszyski (1997: 78 ff) for a discussion of the motif of return to one’s own childhood.
Mythopoetic Traditions and Inserted Treatises: Schulz and Kiš
163
genius, a pantheist, a madman, a pharaoh, a chess-player, smoker, anarchist, drunkard, tyrant, alcoholic etc. (Panti 2000: 42). E.S. thus appears in a fragmentary vision, in a series of different appearances and masks without any substantial identity (Bukwalt 2003: 116; Deli 1997: 180). The novel functions as a “parable of the creation of the world” and therefore begins in a biblical setting: darkness and the beginning of literary recreation in the process of reconstruction (Kiš 1995: 212). Reconstruction means utmost objectivity (Kiš 1995: 216). The epic is predominantly developed but includes lyric layers. The first person singular is completely reduced and even eliminated. The narrative lacks any form of personal reminiscences. Reconstruction of a past and lost world is an objective aim not related to a concrete person undertaking it. The whole narrative is based on one single document that has been found and saved: the letter at the end of the book (and this letter is in fact a real letter written by Kiš’s father, the only document Kiš possessed of his father).16 The letter is like a bone that has been found and must be analyzed in order to gain knowledge about past worlds. Literature is thus correlated to the scientific approaches of archaeology and palaeontology. Archaeology and anthropology go hand-in-hand, they complete each other. The reconstruction of a lost world is at the same time the reconstruction of past human beings in their everyday experience, even if no full representation is reachable and even if the idea that a text can actually grasp the past is proven false (Kiš 1995: 243-244). The novel is itself a combination of anthropology, archaeology, and ontology (Kiš 1995: 283). Hourglass consists of four mutually exclusive and not intertranslatable discursive sections (and two framing texts: the ‘Prolog’ (‘Prologue’) at the beginning and the abovementioned letter at the end of the book). The four sections include ‘Slike s putovanja’ (‘Travel Scenes’), ‘Istražni postupak’ (‘Criminal Investigation’), ‘Ispitivanje svedoka’ (‘A Witness Interrogated’), and the ‘Notes of a Madman’. Hourglass, in its objective approach, resembles a protocol and offers a large-scale inventory but contains no narrative that might embrace the disseminating pieces of memory. The devices of registration and description plainly lack the idea of a pertaining totality. 16
The real letter was dated: 5.4.1942 (cf. Kiš 1995: 229).
164
Alfred Gall
The novel contains different mythopoetic elements stemming from various sources. Mythological, religious, and theological traditions intermingle in their literary application. One recurrent motif is the biblical flood indicating the devastating force of history. The biblical flood is associated with the Pannonian Sea which highlights the fact that a concrete surrounding – Pannonia, i.e. also the Vojvodina and Hungary – is the playground of forces transcending concrete geographical and historical contexts. This combination of concrete geographical and historical spaces with a mythological as well as religious frame of reference marks the disruption of historical time which is “out of joint”. In its textual appearance the flood is not a symbol and certainly does not integrate the reconstructed horror of Nazi genocide into a religious totality. It is instead part of the literary imagery accentuating the break of history and of civilization as well. What is left behind after the flood ought to be treated as a relic of a distant past, but in the meantime, it provokes and compels interpretation and needs to be put into a broader context that revives the former and lost world. Literary practice as archaeology and anthropology is orientated toward the remnants that have to be recollected. Writing is akin to remembering; the recollection of relics and their inventory is the basic literary strategy in Hourglass. A comparable paradox can also be seen in the ‘Treatise on the Potato’ where religious and philosophical thinking is annihilated by the drastic historical context. The ‘Treatise on the Potato’ belongs to the so-called ‘Notes of a madman’ written by E.S. himself. A closer look offers fertile insights into the way Kiš adopts the textual patterns of Schulz’s prose. In a discussion of Baruch Spinoza, E.S. first declares his agreement with the philosopher: reality and history are determined. Then he differs from Spinoza: the philosopher’s position in this determined world order is, for E.S., not linked to the idea of pure knowledge, an absolute point-of-view where one perceives and comprehends things sub specie aeternitatis, but is instead rooted in a position sub specie mortis. The outlined mythopoetic literary practice can be understood as a certain play on mythological and theological or philosophical systems of descriptions as well as with their referential schemes (Goodman 1978: 2 ff.). The mythopoetic devices in Kiš’s text differ strongly from Schulz’s mythopoetic writing in Cinnamon Shops, where it constructs counterworlds. Furthermore, in Schulz’s
Mythopoetic Traditions and Inserted Treatises: Schulz and Kiš
165
texts it creates other worlds transcending empirical and established realities, and destroys given realities that transcend toward their hitherto unnoticed other side. However, the approach to mythopoetics is quite different in Hourglass, where emphasis is put on the disruptive impact of the Shoah. In the ‘Notes of a madman’ and especially in the short ‘Treatise on the Potato’, E.S. focuses on the idea of a second creation that annihilates the given world, a world that seems to have been made by a bad demiurge. The pseudo-gnostic theory is concretized in the theory of the potato. According to E.S., the treatise is a parable referring to the history of the Jews: Došla su vremena kada moramo misliti o sebi iz aspekta života i smrti, ne kao sebine individue, nego iz aspekta itave svoje rase, tog božanskog korova zemlje, raseljene po svetu, raširene po svim kontinentima, baš kao i taj nesreni krompir (solanum tuberosum) […]. (Kiš 1999: 292) (The time has come when we must think about ourselves from the standpoint of life and death, not as self-seeking individuals, but as representatives of our entire race, that divine weed scattered over all the continents of the earth, just like the lowly potato (Solanum tuberosum) […]; Kiš 1997: 49)
The potato incorporates the depersonalized, degraded, and dehumanized essence of men. The potato – an obvious analogy to the tailor’s dummy in Cinnamon Shops – marks the minor reality of degraded humanity. E.S. links the potato and its history with the Jews. E.S. sees in the history of the potato a simile of mankind having lost its integration into a metaphysical order vaulted by a transcendent frame of reference. As a perfect symbol of the homunculus, the potato, in a way resembling Schulz’s tailor’s dummy, incorporates a human reality of a second and minor degree. The core of human reality has vanished, and all that is left are phantasmatic and disintegrated homunculi: [T]e je postao idealna slika zemlje i oveka od zemlje sazdana, meso i koža, bez srži i bez srca, pravi homunculus (homo-homulus-humus), sasvim po liku ovekovu, oveka bez duše, oveka iz koga je prognan Bog. (Kiš 1999: 293) (It has thus become a perfect symbol of the earth and earth-made man, all flesh and skin, without heart or essence, a regular homunculus (homo-
166
Alfred Gall homulus-humus), just like a man, a man without a soul, a man from whom God has been banished; Kiš 1997: 50)
In his treatise that might be best understood as a short parable on human history and its disaster, E.S. compares the potato – the second degree and degraded human being, and for E.S. especially, the Jew – to the apple and the tomato. The latter is described by reference to the Austrian expression Paradiesapfel (Solanum lycopersicum). Of course, both words refer to the biblical myth of paradise, thereby integrating the mythological framework into the discourse on human history. The difference between potato and apple or tomato (in the sense of the Paradiesapfel) is the metonymical expression of the difference between man made by God and man driven as well as torn by history and dispossessed of any metaphysical order. In comparison to the apple or the tomato, the imperfect shape of the potato reflects the elementary difference between the mythical order of biblical tradition and the prevailing force of history. A biblical narrative is also applied when E.S. refers to Noah and the deluge, claiming that another, even more profound cataclysm takes place. The only remnants will be degraded and devastated human beings of a potato-like appearance. The minor reality of the potato and its broken substance that cannot be combined to the biblical fruit, the apple, is caused by the fact that the potato is created by some pseudodemiurge and not by God. This ontological difference obviously evokes the idea of an inferior creation as well as an inferior reality in the ‘Treatise on Tailors’ Dummies’. In the meantime it locates this problem in the context of historical experience, that is, the Shoah. The Jews are separated from other human beings and systematically exterminated. The ontological difference between man made by God and man as result of a second creation, the difference between tomato/apple on the one hand and the potato on the other hand, is part of the discourse of E.S. who tries to grasp through such queer analogies – notably in the ‘Notes of a madman’ – the essence of his own experience as a Jew as well as of his fellow people. The potato – i.e. the Jew – is not made by God but is the essential outcast, an ontological outsider separated violently from his environment: I, vidiš, danas, dok prosjaim taj krompir, ne mogu da se ne setim te udesne slinosti izmeu krompira i oveka, i, s druge strane, dozvolite,
Mythopoetic Traditions and Inserted Treatises: Schulz and Kiš
167
izmeu krompira i Jevrejina. […] I ja poinjem ozbiljno da verujem, makar to bilo za ljubav slike i fantazije, da je krompir (Kartoffel, patate) jedini stvor na svetu – i neka mi Bog za to oprosti – koji nije sazdan voljom Božjom i rukom Tvorca, nego da je delo nekog jalovoplodnog i mahnitog šamana, plod neke jalove alhemije […]. (Kiš 1999: 293-294.) (And today, you see, when I ask for a potato, I can’t help thinking about the amazing resemblance between potato and man, and, at the same time, begging your pardon, between potato and Jew. […] I’m beginning to believe in earnest that the potato (Kartoffel, pomme de terre) is the only thing on earth – may God forgive me – that was not created by the will of God and the hand of the Creator, but is the work of some insane, sterilefertile shaman, the fruit of some sterile alchemy […]; Kiš 1997: 50-51)
Kiš’s text is in a certain sense correcting history because it covers individual aspects, remembers lost human beings and gives them a voice of their own in the silence of history, and this is all done under circumstances where essential insights into one’s own life are not made from an absolute point of view (sub specie aeternitatis) but in the shadow of death (sub specie mortis). Kiš’s text blurs the distinction between mythopoetics and thanatopoetics (Lachmann 2004: 277-291). Literature is in its basic principles directed against the appalling indifference to an individual’s and his fellow people’s history. In that sense, literature is counter-history (Kiš 1990: 145).17 Conclusion The ‘Treatise on Tailors’ Dummies’ is obviously a parody of the biblical book of Genesis. In the meantime, it represents in a ludistic way a Gnostic concept of the creation of a counter-world transcending the bad reality of the demiurge. In the ‘Treatise on the Potato’ we are confronted with yet another version of this biblical narrative. Here we observe an intense intertextual play that takes place between Kiš’s ‘Treatise on the Potato’ and Schulz’s ‘Treatise on Tailors’ Dummies’. The common 17
Here we see some clear affinities with Walter Benjamin’s notion of history: “Es ist niemals ein Dokument der Kultur, ohne zugleich ein solches der Barbarei zu sein. Und wie es selbst nicht frei ist von Barbarei, so ist es auch der Prozeß der Überlieferung nicht, in der es von dem einen an den andern gefallen ist. Der historische Materialist rückt daher nach Maßgabe des Möglichen von ihr ab. Er betrachtet es als seine Aufgabe, die Geschichte gegen den Strich zu bürsten” (1997a: 696-697).
168
Alfred Gall
background for this intertextual relationship is the idea of a minor creation (second creation) as well as the idea of a minor existence, a second degree human being lacking a stable core and ontological identity. In both cases, the literary disclosure of other worlds is not to be understood in terms of multiple alternatives to a single actual reality but has to be conceived as emergence of actual multiple worlds. In Kiš’s ‘Treatise on the Potato’, just as in Schulz’s ‘Treatise on Tailors’ Dummies’, the emerging multiplicity amounts to a decomposition of ontological stability.18 Although quite close in its inner structure and imagery, the literary imagination at work in the mentioned texts pursues different aims in the process of unfolding an actual multiplicity of worlds and therefore realizes a divergent range of functions. The idea of a second creation for Kiš is not only reflected as a problem of a minor reality that eventually emerges but is also correlated with the disruptive force of history and linked to another biblical notion, the cataclysm of the flood irreversibly devastating a given world. The second genesis, which for Schulz is part of an aesthetic and Gnostic imagination, is transformed to a basic element in the self-description of E.S. facing his death. In the ‘Treatise on the Potato’ the idea of a minor creation and of a dissolved human existence is embedded in historical circumstances. The mythopoetical imagination is intended to render possible the self-description in the aftermath of the Shoah, whereas Schulz hardly ever confronts history openly and does not make it his central topic. In the ‘Treatise on Tailors’ Dummies’ the idea of a second genesis is based on Jacob’s defiance of God. In this second creation the imagined new creation evolves in a ludistic, even absurd new world lacking order, transparency, and even stability. The metaphysical debate arising from the challenge to God is in Schulz’s text linked to an absurd countercurrent disenabling the construction of a single sense (Lachmann 2002: 341). Kiš’s literary practice is completely different because he is facing the disseminating force of history and making it the core of his texts. The idea of a second or minor creation is not meant to open the 18
This reminds us of constructionalist concepts that negate the existence of one single reality containing multiple possible alternatives to a single actual world. Cf., for instance, Goodman: “We are not speaking in terms of multiple possible alternatives to a single actual world but of multiple actual worlds” (1978: 2).
Mythopoetic Traditions and Inserted Treatises: Schulz and Kiš
169
way to some different reality or to transcend given realities. It leads in contrast to the heart of darkness of history. Kiš – and his protagonist E.S. – does not want to create an imaginary world, but tries to grasp the horror of the real. It is, however, noteworthy that Kiš applies similar mythopoetical devices and develops his own writing as a double-encoded literary practice based on an intertextual play with antecedent texts. The mythopoetical devices Kiš borrows from Schulz are intended to facilitate a literary self-positioning in the aftermath of the Shoah. Schulz’s ‘Treatise on Tailors’ Dummies’ offers a textual pattern for a literary practice facing the extreme experience of the Shoah. The following conclusions may be drawn: Schulz’s text can be discerned as a pattern for Kiš’s Hourglass. Kiš stresses and unveils the profound disruption that separates the contemporary culture in its post-Shoah condition from mythic traditions, but uses myth to reflect the break in civilization caused by the Shoah. Although the Holocaust occurred in the past, it is not entirely of the past. Quite the contrary, the Holocaust haunts the present. Kiš responds by transforming literary intertexts (Riffaterre 1990: 141-162) and offering concrete conceptual schemes as well as vocabularies for self-description and self-positioning in a post-Shoah context. In the ‘Treatise on the potato’ this is realized from a protagonist’s perspective, as it is E.S. who writes down his conclusions about what is going on. But against the idea of some adequate self-description or self-positioning against historical trauma we stress the fact that the key concept is the process of self-positioning without the antecedent idea of a reachable or realizable description. The break in civilization permanently changes one’s own position and causes an impossibility of regaining a stable position that might not be further undermined (Rosenfeld 2003: 27). Kiš’s text functions as a Reflexionsmedium (“medium of reflection”) – not in quite the sense Walter Benjamin gave to this word (1997b: 36, 62) – in which descriptive vocabularies, literary traditions and codes as well as different semantic and generic traditions are reworked and re-actualized.19 In our case this goes for the intertextual play with Schulz’s ‘Treatise on Tailors’ Dummies’ in the ‘Treatise on the Potato’. The way Kiš’s Hourglass refers to Schulz’s inserted treatise resembles the kind of deconstruction Derrida has in mind, when he writes that deconstruction operates from within a given text. Kiš 19
Cf. Weigel (1994: 9 ff.) for a further discussion of the emergence of a cultural memory and the different ways of remembering the Shoah in post-Shoah culture.
170
Alfred Gall
operates within Schulz’s text and reworks thereby concrete features of literary tradition in order to develop a hybrid descriptive vocabulary and conceptual scheme for finding his own position in the post-Shoah era. For Kiš, ontological instability means the loss of any key idea (the idea of a great book or any other master narrative) that might be revealed or function as an aim in the process of imagination. The Shoah has completely destroyed any idea of stable human order. Past and present are intertwined. Any nostalgia for unity or integrity is illusory. Bibliography Baraczak, Stanisaw. 1996. Poezja i duch uogólnienia: Wybór esejów 1970-1995. Kraków: Znak. Benjamin, Walter. 1997a. ‘Über den Begriff der Geschichte’ in Gesammelte Schriften, vol. I, 2. Frankfurt/Main: Suhrkamp: 691-704. ——. 1997b. ‘Der Begriff der Kunstkritik in der deutschen Romantik’ in Gesammelte Schriften, vol. I, 1. Frankfurt/Main: Suhrkamp: 9-122. Brown, Russell E. 1990. ‘Bruno Schulz and World Literature’ in Slavic and East European Journal 34(2): 224-246. Bukwalt, Miosz. 2003. Literackie portrety ydowskich ojców w prozie Brunona Schulza i Danila Kiša. (Slavica Wratislaviensia CXXV). Wrocaw: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Wrocawskiego. irli-Straszyska, Danuta. 1988. ‘Danila Kiša ogród, literatura’ in Literatura na wiecie 1: 258-261. Deli, Jovan. 1997. Kroz prozu Danila Kiša. Beograd: Beogradski Izdavako-Grafiki Zavod. Fiut, Aleksander. 1999. By (albo nie by) rodkowoeuropejczykiem (Obrazy wspóczesnoci). Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie. Goodman, Nelson. 1978. Ways of Worldmaking. Indianapolis: Hackett. Ingold, Felix Philipp. 1992. Der Autor am Werk: Versuche über literarische Kreativität. München – Wien. Jarz bski, Jerzy (ed.) 1973. ‘Sen o “zotym wieku”’ in Teksty 2: 104-121. ——. 1984. Powie jako autokreacja. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie. ——. 1994. Czytanie Schulza: Materiay midzynarodowej sesji naukowej “Bruno Schulz – w stulecie urodzin i pidziesiciolecie mierci”. Kraków: T.I.C. Kasperski, Edward. 1993. ‘Mit maciczny – Bruno Schulz i Kresy’ in Przegld Humanistyczny 3: 79-94. Kiš, Danilo. 1978. Klepsydra (tr. D. irli-Straszyska). Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie. ——. 1990. Gorki talog iskustva. Beograd: Beogradski Izdavako-Grafiki Zavod. ——. 1995. Homo poeticus. (Sabrana dela Danila Kiša). Beograd: Beogradski Izdavako-Grafiki Zavod. ——. 1997. Hourglass (tr. R. Manheim). Evanston: Northwestern University Press.
Mythopoetic Traditions and Inserted Treatises: Schulz and Kiš
171
——. 1999. Porodi ni cirkus: Rani jadi – Bašta, pepeo – Peš anik. Split: Feral Tribune. Kornhauser, Julian. 2001. wiadomo regionalna i mit odrbnoci: o stereotypach w literaturze serbskiej i chorwackiej. Kraków 2001: Scriptum. Koschmal, Walter. 1987. ‘Zur mythischen Modellierung von Raum und Zeit bei Andrej Belyj und Bruno Schulz’ in Schmid, Wolf (ed.) Mythos in der slavischen Moderne (Wiener Slawistischer Almanach, Sonderband 20). Wien: Institut für Slavistik der Universität Wien: 193-214. Krivokapi, Boro (ed.) 1980. Treba li spaliti Kiša. Zagreb: Globus. Kuprel, Diana. 1996. ‘“Errant Events on the Branch Tracks of Time”: Bruno Schulz and Mythical Consciousness’ in Slavic and East European Journal 40(1): 100-117. Lachmann, Renate. 2002. Erzählte Phantastik. Zu Phantasiegeschichte und Semantik phantastischer Texte. Frankfurt/Main: Suhrkamp. ——. 2004. ‘Faktographie und Thanatographie in Psalam 44 und Peš anik von Danilo Kiš’ in Hansen-Kokoruš, Renate et al. (eds). Mundus narratus: Festschrift für Dagmar Burkhart. Frankfurt/Main etc.: Peter Lang: 277-291. atuszyski, Grzegorz. 1997. W wiecie wykltych. Szkice o literaturze serbskiej i chorwackiej. Warszawa: Agawa. Lawson, Hilary. 1985. Reflexivity: The Post-Modern Predicament. London etc.: Hutchinson. Okopie-Sawiska, Aleksandra. 1973. ‘Sny i poetyka snu’ in Teksty 2: 7-23. Olchanowski, Tomasz. 2001. Jungowska interpretacja mitu ojca w prozie Brunona Schulza. Biaystok: Trans Humana. Panti, Mihajlo. 2000. Kiš. Beograd: Filip Višnji. Pijanovi, Petar. 1992. Proza Danila Kiša. Priština – Gornji Milanovac – Podgorica: Jedinstvo – Deje Novine – Oktoih. Riffaterre, Michael. 1984. ‘Intertextual Representation: On Mimesis as Interpretive Discourse’ in Critical Inquiry 11: 141-162. Rorty, Richard. 1989. Contingency, Irony, and Solidarity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Rosenfeld, Alvin H. 2003. Podwójna mier. Rozwaania o literaturze Holocaustu (tr. B. Krawcowicz). Warszawa: Cyklady. Schulz, Bruno. 1988. The Fictions of Bruno Schulz (tr. C. Wieniewska). London: Picador. ——. 1998. Opowiadania. Wybór esejów i listów (ed. J. Jarz bski). Wrocaw: Zakad Narodowy im. Ossoliskich. Speina, Jerzy. 1974. Bankructwo realnoci. Proza Brunona Schulza. Pozna: Pastwowe Wydawnictwo Naukowe. Stala, Krzysztof. 1995. Na marginesach rzeczywistoci. O paradoksach przedstawiania w twórczoci Brunona Schulza. Warszawa: Instytut Bada Literackich Polskiej Akademii Nauk, Stowarzyszenie “Pro Cultura Litteraria”. Stojanovi, Branislava. 2002. ‘Recepcija Bruna Schulza u Srbiji. Prvo poglavlje: Danilo Kiš’ in Slavistika 6: 171-183. Subotin, Stojan (ed.) 1969. Antologija poljske fantastike. Beograd: Nolit. Updike, John. 1988. ‘The Visionary of Drohobycz’ in The New York Times: Book Review, 30 October 1988. On line at: http://query.nytimes.com/gst/
172
Alfred Gall
fullpage.html?res=940DE3DF1139F933A05753C1A96E948260 (consulted 10.04.07). ——. 1992. ‘Skromny geniusz Bruno Schulz’ in NaGos 7: 85-87. Vladiv-Glover, Slobodanka. 2003. Postmodernizam od Kiša do danas. Beograd: Prosveta. Weigel, Sigrid. 1994. Bilder des kulturellen Gedächtnisses. Beiträge zur Gegenwartsliteratur. Dülmen-Hiddingsel: Tende. Wiegandt, Ewa. 1997. Austria felix czyli o micie Galicji w polskiej prozie wspóczesnej. Pozna: Bene Nati. Wierzbycki, Jan. 1988. ‘Serbska proza (m. in. o I. Andriciu)’ in Literatura na wiecie 1: 233-257.
Bruno Schulz and the Magical Realism of Gabriel García Márquez in One Hundred Years of Solitude Dorota Wojda Abstract: The aim of this article is to indicate analogies between the writing of Bruno Schulz and the magical realism in Gabriel García Márquez’s Cien años de soledad (One Hundred Years of Solitude, 1967) and consider them in the postcolonial perspective. The irony created by both writers is a strategy that disarms the authoritarian divisions of colonial discourses. Performativeness of narration is significant in the works by Schulz and Márquez because it indicates that magical realism – as the poetics, ontology, and strategy of postcolonial discourse – is not only a literary creation which problematizes discourses of power but also a practice which induces thought, writing, and action.
Introduction The conviction has already been expressed that Bruno Schulz’s work has numerous ties with magical realism (cf. Gazda 2005); however, a more profound exploration of these relationships has not been performed yet. In the meantime, the context of magical realism literature, read from the postcolonial perspective, might nevertheless be beneficial in casting a new light on Schulz’s writing, that is, as a creative expression of a cross-cultural borderland with features close to postcolonial discourse. The aim of the present article is to indicate analogies between the writing of Bruno Schulz and the magical realism in Cien años de soledad (One Hundred Years of Solitude, 1967). The most significant comparison would be to show how both writers create a reality in which the ordinary, one’s own, turns out to be the space for the articulation of the other. This otherness takes center stage thanks to a poetics which combines the realist convention with fantasy and creates a special form of mimesis. It is not a mimesis of adequate representation but an autothematic mimesis of process, in which the text imitates both itself and other text-creating practices and not just general cultural
174
Dorota Wojda
mechanisms (Elbanowski 1983; Stala 1995; Gowacka 1996). In the writings of Schulz and García Márquez, this mimesis consists of the displacement and ironic demonstration of tensions between centre and periphery, the personal and the strange, a rule and an exception. As a result, hybridized creatures are shown – transvestites, mannequins, characters somewhere between life and death, like Jacob or Melquíades – as well as borderline areas, like Crocodile Street or the Street of the Turks. The status of these forms is compatible with the concepts of plural identity, as proposed by Homi Bhabha (1990, 1995) or Stephen Slemon (1989). For the sake of explaining hybridization, Wilson Harris employs the figure of Teiresias: “[T]he contrary but mutually necessary and inextricably linked principles of male and female, natural and supernatural, life and death are held in productive tension and do not resolve into a stable final synthesis” (in MooreGilbert 1997: 183). Such non-solubility poses an important feature of the works of Schulz and García Márquez, combining radically different realities, what may be described with the expressions of magical realism theoreticians: lo real maravilloso (“the marvel of trivial things”) by Alejo Carpentier, el realismo mágico by Luis Leal (“the mystery does not descend to the represented world but rather hides and palpitates behind it”) or lo extraño (“strangeness”, opposed to lo verídico and lo sobrenatural) by Enrique Anderson Imbert (Pindel 2004: 211 ff.) Although “magical realism” raises much doubt among researchers (Elbanowski 1983: 10-11; Slemon 1995: 407; Pindel 2004: 212-214) as an imprecise and ambiguous term, it is still useful for naming the poetics of combining various conventions and offers a paradoxical ontology. García Márquez often indicated that in his prose a merger of separate worlds – real and fictional, regular and miraculous – matching the coexistence of those dimensions takes place in reality. Consequently, he valued Italian neorealism. Reviewing a movie by Vittorio de Sica, he wrote: The story told in Miracolo a Milano is a real fairy tale even if only because it takes place in an unusual setting, where the real blends in a brilliant way with the fantastic, making it often impossible to discern where the former ends and the latter begins. (translated from the Polish text in Ploetz 1997: 49-50)
Schulz and Magical Realism in One Hundred Years of Solitude
175
Schulz, in turn, evoked the convention of arabesque both in the literary form by mixing the mundane with the fantastic and in the floral ornament by creating a miraculous, dynamic world. The writer presented the essence of arabesque art when he described Father’s experiments: W jadalni naszej krzesa miay wysokie pi knie rzebione oparcia. Byy to jakie girlandy lici i kwiatów w gucie realistycznym, ale wystarczyo prztykni cie ojca, a rzeba ta nabieraa nagle niezwykle dowcipnej fizjonomii […] i ten i ów z obecnych zaczyna wykrzykiwa: – Ciocia Wandzia, jak mi Bóg miy, ciocia Wandzia! […] Cuda ojca unicestwiay si same, bo nie byo to adne widmo, bya to rzeczywista ciocia Wandzia w caej swej zwyczajnoci i pospolitoci, która nie pozwalaa nawet na myl o jakim cudzie. (Schulz 1998: 359)1 (We had in our dining room a set of chairs with tall backs, beautifully carved in the realistic manner into garlands of leaves and flowers; it was enough for Father to flip the carvings and they suddenly acquired an exceptionally witty physiognomy […] and one or another of those present would suddenly exclaim: “Aunt Wanda, by God, Aunt Wanda!” […] Father’s miracles cancelled themselves out automatically, for he did not produce a ghost but the real Aunt Wanda in all her ordinariness and commonness, which excluded any thought of a possible miracle; 1988: 103)2
The form revives here so to speak, in order to, receive a grotesque shape without losing its realism, thanks to which anthropomorphization as a figure of poetry, will be fulfilled. A conjuring trick constitutes in this case, as Viktor Shklovskii would put it, a bizarre effect: the ordinary Aunt Wanda shows herself to the spectators in an extraordinary way, different than in the texts where poetry is supposed to convey extraordinary things with ordinary depiction (Looby 2003). Magical realism may be identified by a characteristic mimesis of difference, where the personal is confronted with the other in the process of disturbing systemic oppositions (Durix 1998). According to Slemon, the paradox of this form is matched by the articulation of incompatible worlds, of which “neither one can fully come into being, and each remains suspended, locked in a continuous dialectic with the “other”, a situation which creates disjunction within each of the separate discursive systems, rending them with gaps, absences, and 1 2
All further references will be given as Op. All further references will be given as TF.
176
Dorota Wojda
silences” (1995: 409). Magical realism has become an important category for the postcolonial studies because it can be perceived as a strategy of postcolonial discourse, where a dispute of anti-colonialism and colonialism is arranged in order to, through the exposure of their dialectics, loosen the structures of imperial power (Pawyszyn 1998; Podgórniak 2004; 2006). Here the poetics of magical realism is useful, conveying the collision of intellect with irrationality. This poetics strikes at the binary divisions, thus turning against diversifying the world into the values of the colonizers and the colonized (Baker 1993). Moreover, the formula of magical realism – nowadays extended to texts from outside the Latin-American literature – allows readers to recognize significant relations between contemporary and past texts and to compare very different postcolonial works (Slemon 1995: 409). Some assert that magical realism was one of the first literary phenomena questioning postcolonial discourse. Such is the opinion of Alfred López, convinced that thanks to “a mimesis of excess […], which paradoxically turns out to be a more ‘realistic’ mode of representation than the conventional Western conceptions of literary ‘realism’”, works of magical realism definitely are “under the sign of the postcolonial” (2001: 210). Both the prose of Schulz and One Hundred Years of Solitude can be situated against colonial discourses. The first case concerns mythologizations which emerged due to the centuries-old Polish domination of the “Kresy” (the “Borderlands”) and the partition of Poland which took place in the eighteenth century, leaving the country without statehood for a long period. The other case concerns the colonialism of Latin America, particularly the Caribbean. While locating the novel by García Márquez against colonial discourse is obvious, analogous placing of the work of Schulz requires a commentary. At first, colonialism had been associated with cultural domination on overseas territories. These days, however, the manifestations of colonialism have also been recognized in other areas. One may distinguish the real colonialism, linked with racial discrimination, from the “white colonialism”, while at the same time assuming that postcolonialism is not an exclusive feature of the cultures of the so-called Third and Fourth World ethnic groups but also concerns the “white communities” dependent on the imperial power. That is of significance, for instance, to Ireland as well as to Poland, where more and more frequently the need has been indicated
Schulz and Magical Realism in One Hundred Years of Solitude
177
to assume the postcolonial perspective (Cavanagh 2003; Thompson 2006; Skórczewski 2006; Bakua 2006; Janion 2007). In One Hundred Years of Solitude magical realism has a complicated nature: it is created and problematized. Such a strategy Adam Elbanowski calls magical irony: Ironia u Márqueza, nie pozbawiona tak e pierwiastków komicznych, prowadzi wprost do parodii […] realizmu magicznego. Jest “naladowaniem” wzoru i jego regu i równoczenie jego karykatur , przekroczeniem. Parodia byaby zatem jedn z funkcji “ironii magicznej”, jako gry sprzecznych znacze, nieustannego przechodzenia elementów powieciowych w swoje przeciwiestwo, staego podwa ania sensów, przechodzenia afirmacji w negacj i odwrotnie. (1983: 15–16) (Irony in Márquez, not deprived of comic elements, leads straight to a parody […] of magical realism. It is an “imitation” of the pattern with its principles and at the same time its caricature, contravention. Parody would thus be one of the functions of “magical irony” treated as a game of contradictory meanings, constant evolving of the novel’s elements into their opposites, constant undermining of meanings, turning affirmation into negation and vice versa.)
Magical realism has a similar character in the tales of Schulz. The author of Cinnamon Shops creates a mythical reality in which what is in accordance with doxa blends with the fantastic in order to perform demythologization and keeps evolving from one level to another. The target solution in Schulz is not the “aesthetics of the binary opposition” (Kaufer 1983) but the very dialectics that are being struck. Seditiousness in the texts by both writers is close to the form of irony found in the writings of Friedrich Schlegel by Paul de Man (1996), who claims that permanent parabasis is a deconstruction: constant severing of the consistent narrative, exposing fiction, disturbing the identity of the subject, form and history. Such irony destabilizes the concepts of otherness from the colonial and anti-colonial models. In this sense, the ironic poetics of magical realism, determining the paradoxical ontology, may be called the strategy of the postcolonial discourse. Reading Kafka At first glance, Bruno Schulz and Gabriel García Márquez have not so much in common. The former, born in Galician Drohobycz in 1892,
178
Dorota Wojda
came from a Jewish merchant family; the latter was born in a Colombian village of Aracataca in 1927, as a son of a descendant of a prominent family, Márquez Iguarán and a telegrapher. Schulz’s fate seems unfulfilled. His biography includes health problems, nuisances of the teaching profession standing in the way of his creative work, unsuccessful relationships with women, and finally, a tragic death. Even though Schulz published prose and exhibited paintings, he did not have a brilliant career. Only the future showed how great an artist he was. García Márquez also experienced poverty and difficulty combining gainful employment with writing; however, after the success of One Hundred Years of Solitude (1967) and El otoño del patriarca (The Autumn of the Patriarch, 1975), honored with the Nobel Prize in Literature (1982), a happy husband and father, he could freely devote himself to artistic work. Schulz spent most of his life in Drohobycz and concentrated on art, whereas García Márquez, who kept changing his whereabouts, was involved in politics and humanitarian actions. Where, in this case, are the similarities between the writers whose stories are so different? Just where their roots are. Both the writings of Schulz and the prose of García Márquez are stimulated by genius loci and, related to it, by phantasms of childhood. The author of ‘Ksi ga’ (‘The Book’) did not create an epos, though his work is one fragmented story in which the themes of home, the streets and outskirts of Drohobycz recur. Similarly, the themes of home can also be found in García Márquez. The first book that García Márquez wanted to write was about the house in which he spent his childhood and was to be entitled La casa. Yet it was La Hojarasca (Leaf Storm, 1954) that emerged; nevertheless, the setting remained the same. Finally, the outcome of all those exercises appeared – One Hundred Years of Solitude. Even though the novel was acknowledged as a national epic, it consisted of micronarratives arising from the most personal experiences, memories, and dreams about home. Just like Schulz built his textual world from the elements of the Galician province, García Márquez transformed the peripheral region of Magdalena into the literary Macondo. They both were able to present their homelands so that they would radiate with an aura of everyday life, uncanny yet at the same time universal. This is largely what the essence of magical realism in the works of those writers consists of:
Schulz and Magical Realism in One Hundred Years of Solitude
179
the universalization of localness due to the work of the memory, dream, and imagination. Created in such a way, however, literary provinces are not static and unchanging but quite the opposite – things are subject to metamorphoses, transgress their boundaries, evolve from one form to another. These changes happen sometimes in the joke convention, sometimes in the spirit of parody or a dissonant clash; this is matched in Schulz by the motif of blinking that becomes a figure of the ironic form: Tylko p k piór pawich […] nie da si utrzyma w ryzach. By to element swawolny, niebezpieczny, o nieuchwytnej rewolucyjnoci, jak rozhukana klasa gimnazjalistek, pena dewocji w oczy, a rozpustnej swawoli poza oczyma. widroway te oczy dzie cay i wierciy dziury w cianach, mrugay, toczyy si , trzepocz c rz sami […]. (Op 87). (These feathers were a dangerous, frivolous element, hiding rebelliousness, like a class of naughty schoolgirls who are quiet and composed in appearance, but full of mischief when no longer watched. The eyes of those feathers never stopped staring; they made holes in the walls, winking, fluttering their eyelashes […];TF 79).
García Márquez directly describes the form of One Hundred Years of Solitude as dissonant: “Everything will be on the borderline between sublime and kitsch. Like bolero” (translated from the Polish text in Ploetz 1997: 85). Conveyed in such a form, the outskirts are not at all idyllic. Their residents are affected not only by love but also by suffering, betrayal, and death. What links the protagonists of Schulz and García Márquez in particular is solitude. Similarly to Jacob, José Arcadio Buendía cuts himself off the world and plunges into experimenting, and Úrsula, similarly to Adela, has difficulty finding allies in her passion for establishing order. One Hundred Years of Solitude is a study of the isolation of the whole community and its individual members. Many characters live here in seclusion, like Rebecca, who condemns herself to the solitary confinement of her own house. A similar existence is led by a character of Schulz, the pensioner from ‘Samotno’ (‘Loneliness’), alien even to his mirror look-alike. A similar motif of a strange mirror reflection is found in Diálogo del espejo (Dialogue with the Mirror, 1949), the novel by García Márquez. Contaminated by civilization, Macondo faces
180
Dorota Wojda
complete extinction; the world in Schulz’s tales is similarly headed for collapse. The reflections on the fatalism of individuals’ solitary fate, on the decline of community and the whole world, as well as placing the provinces in the universal dimension link the works of Schulz and García Márquez with the writing of William Faulkner (Obehelman 1988; Maszewski 2003). In his works, the region of Lafayette is transformed into the land of Yoknapatawpha, for which there is no future. The author of One Hundred Years of Solitude will allude to this catastrophism, saying: “I’m not forgetting that the county of Yoknapatawpha borders on the Caribbean Sea” (translated from the Polish text in Ploetz 1997: 36). Yet, the texts of both writers are even more strongly linked with the works of Franz Kafka (Hahn 1994; Owczarski 2004; Gazda 2006). The indicated lines of literary creation – the motif of metamorphosis, a dissonant form, irony, an alienated protagonist enclosed within four walls, as well as fatalism and the universalization of ordinariness – lead to Der Prozeß (The Trial, 1925) or Die Verwandlung (The Metamorphosis, 1915). The writers became fascinated with Kafka’s writings for the portrayal of man as dual, dead in his own lifetime, and the world as a closing trap. In ‘Vor dem Gesetz’ (‘Before the Law’, 1919) we can see a man in front of the door that he cannot get through, whereas in Schulz’s story ‘Loneliness’ we read: Otó to wanie: dla dobrej woli nie ma zapory, intensywnej ch ci nic si
nie oprze. Musz sobie tylko wyobrazi drzwi, dobre stare drzwi, jak w kuchni mego dziecistwa, z elazn klamk i ryglem. Nie ma pokoju tak zamurowanego, eby si na takie drzwi zaufane nie otwiera, jeli tylko starczy si, by mu je zainsynuowa. (Op 327) (That is just it: where there is a will, there is a way; a passionate determination can conquer all. I must only imagine a door, a good old door, like the one in the kitchen of my childhood, with an iron handle and a bolt. There is no walled-in room that could not be opened by such a trusted door, provided one were strong enough to suggest that such a door exists; TF 297–298).
However, the thought about “a trusted door” here does not lead to imagining it and liberating from the walled reality. ‘In der Strafkolonie’ (‘In the Penal Colony’, 1919) shows how the island,
Schulz and Magical Realism in One Hundred Years of Solitude
181
where the ruthless machine of power has been working, can be abandoned only by the traveller, whereas all the others have to remain on it. The text may, just like Kafka’s other works, be read as a presentation of a modern system of “discipline and punish” (Foucault 1975), but one may also observe in it a figure of the primordial world order. Through descriptions of the repressive structures, Kafka creates fantastic realities, yet he sets them in ordinary backgrounds, thus demystifying the apparatus of power as ubiquitous. A similar assessment can be made in Schulz’s tales ‘Wiosna’ (‘Spring’) or ‘Sanatorium pod klepsydr ’ (‘Sanatorium Under the Sign of the Hourglass’) and in One Hundred Years of Solitude. Just like in Kafka’s ‘Before the Law’ it is the peasant who is put to the test, in the works of Schulz and García Márquez, ordinary provincial people are put to the test. The residents of the Galician town must confront the mercenary power of Crocodile Street, and the Buendías must face the economic settlement of the Street of the Turks. Nothing special, except for the desire for freedom, distinguishes Joseph N., who, just like Joseph K. from The Process, cannot escape the “mills of justice”. For both writers, the reading of Kafka was an important experience which they used while creating their own literary works. In the case of Schulz and García Márquez, magical realism is pushed to the limit – negating the apparatus of power turns into affirmation and vice versa. Jacob experiments on Uncle Edward, and is himself disciplined by Adela. While killing the cockroaches, he becomes similar to them, comprehending the dialectics of attraction and repulsion triggered by what is strange. Aureliano Buendía fights for the ideal of liberalism in order to become a dictator – charismatic but also repugnant and pity-arousing. After One Hundred Years of Solitude, García Márquez has written books which were studies of ambivalent rulers: The Autumn of the Patriarch and El general en su laberinto (The General in his Labyrinth, 1989), the story of Simón Bolívar. Such extensive studies cannot be found in the works of Schulz; however, the creation of Franz Joseph from ‘Spring’ is also ambiguous. In the works of Schulz and García Márquez, the poetics of magical realism, where mimetic codes interact with fantasy codes, and irony, which complicates this poetics, are a means to reflect upon the complicated relations of power. Since such a strategy does not
182
Dorota Wojda
explicitly turn against the systems of cultural domination but imitates their mechanisms and mythologies in order to problematize them on different levels, it corresponds with postcolonial discourse. A simple negation of these systems would create an effect of dialectical reflection, whereas postcolonialism expresses “distrust toward precise names, simple categories, myths that can explain all, unambiguous historical stories, and is rather inclined to present the world ironically” (“nieufno w stosunku do jasnych hase, prostych kategorii, mitów, które wszystko potrafi wyjani, jednoznacznych opowieci historycznych, a skonny jest raczej do ironicznego ujmowania wiata”; Pawyszyn 1998: 531). Periphery, Events and People in Time Loops As Robert Rawdon Wilson indicates, in works of magical realism there emerges a “space in which the spatial effects of canonical realism and those of axiomatic fantasy are interwoven […] in magic realism, space is hybrid (opposite and conflicting properties are copresent)” (1990: 204). It is of great significance for postcolonial revisions because it allows readers to perceive the region’s history, identity, and language of its residents, in general, the culture of the colonized area as a palimpsest in which layers of different civilizations show through each other (Brooke-Rose 1983). Magical realism defines the rhetoric of resistance in relation to the methods of representation that aspire to exclusivity, such as the traditional realist novel or the historiography promoting the ideology of conquest. There are three fundamental methods of loosening the colonial system: firstly, a “representation of transformational regionalism” where a particular local space poses the metonymy of a colony in general; secondly, a “foreshortening of history” – metaphorical condensation in the represented time of the whole history of the colonization and its consequences; thirdly, a “thematic foregrounding” of blank pages in the histories of the compared cultures, resulting in the destruction of the simple division into centre and periphery (Slemon 1995: 411-412). In One Hundred Years of Solitude a “representation of transformational regionalism” is evident. Macondo is a fictional space, yet it possesses features drawing attention to a reference to the province of Magdalena. At the same time, the place constitutes a closed universe, thus created as a figure of a human awareness
Schulz and Magical Realism in One Hundred Years of Solitude
183
developing from scratch. The depiction of Macondo is full of contradictions; in this world, “geographical space meets mythical space, and elliptical space is specified” (“przestrze geograficzna styka si z przestrzeni mityczn , przestrze eliptyczna jest dookrelona”; Elbanowski 1983: 17). The village has love and death in its origins. José Arcadio Buendía marries Úrsula, his cousin, and kills Prudencio Aguilar when the latter jeers at the spouses’ sexual abstinence. Consequently, the Buendías leave Riohacha to found Macondo. The novel may also be read as a history of mankind that starts with breaking the prohibition against incest and a founding murder. These contraventions recur in both the story of the Buendías and the history of the world. The initial parts of the narrative abound in different images of violence. The very first sentence presents an execution; then there are weapons of war, the colonization of Latin America, felling trees for the future village, and setting traps for singing birds. José Arcadio Buendía has a conqueror’s instinct – having learned to use navigational instruments, “he conceived a notion of space that allowed him to navigate across unknown seas, to visit uninhabited territories, and to establish relations with splendid beings” (1973: 4). At first independent from institutional power, Macondo will eventually surrender to it, and be drawn into political conflict and war; finally, it will be exploited by the Banana Company. Capitalism will become the cause of the crisis leading to the defeat of Macondo. Therefore, in One Hundred Years of Solitude there takes place a “foreshortening of history” – the represented time is a metaphor of the history of mankind that turns out to be a streak of offence, conquest, and aggression. The fall of the civilization is presented as a consequence of the incompetent management of natural and cultural resources and at the same time, as revenge taken by nature on the people hostile to it. In the last years of its existence, the Buendías’ household deteriorates from a plague of rain, an invasion of ants, and prolific growth of flora, finally being wiped off the surface of the earth with the whole Macondo by a hurricane. Fatalism of this event is highlighted by the last words of the novel: “races condemned to one hundred years of solitude did not have a second opportunity on earth” (1973: 422). In his Nobel Prize speech, however, the writer will call literature an anti-utopia able to offer resistance to the atrocities of the world thanks to a vision of life “where the races condemned to one hundred years of solitude will have, at last and forever, a second
184
Dorota Wojda
opportunity on earth” (translated from the Polish text in Ploetz 1997: 124). Just as in the case of topography, temporariness, measured with events and thus being a function of the storyline, has an explicit reference in the novel, and is connected with the developments in which the writer’s family took part. The model here is the time of the Thousand Days’ War, the time of violencia, which ravaged Colombia between 1940s and 1960s, and the time of neocolonialism in the beginning of the twentieth century, dominated by American capital, which resulted in economic exploitation, the influx of hojarasca (hired workers), moral decline of the population, and the loss of historical memory of the region. These phenomena had already been given attention by García Márquez in Leaf Storm. Ernesto Volkening depicts how the writer experienced the impoverishing humanization of the tropics, acting in defence of the exploited nature and against the colonial ideology that destroys anything contrary to its idea of the world (Volkening 1963). One Hundred Years of Solitude also exposes the cruelty of the power apparatus – what takes place here is a “thematic foregrounding” of the repressions perpetrated by the colonial system. José Arcadio Segundo continues telling the story of the striking workers’ massacre about which history books say nothing. The Buendías perceive the historic events in a different way than the authority; they also see temporariness and spatial relations differently. What is accepted in the official order, has little value for them or is thoroughly false although at times they do admire alien values, but then they explain them in their own way. In this way, there is a change in the way the elements of colonial discourse are marked; qualities regarded as central by the colonizers turn out to be peripheral in Macondo and vice versa. The narrative perspective, however, is displaced in such a way that it passes from one judgement to another, thereby drawing attention to the relativity of culture and its hybrid structure in a typically postcolonial way. Determining references in One Hundred Years of Solitude is connected with adopting codes of realist representation, whereas the relativization of values is connected with applying the fantasy convention. Strictly speaking, the magic of the represented world contains fantastic and miraculous elements (Todorov 1970). The former appear when the protagonists find the space, events, or time incompatible with their own vision of reality, what, on the whole,
Schulz and Magical Realism in One Hundred Years of Solitude
185
coincides with the appearance of technological developments in Macondo. To the village’s residents, cinemas, railways, or the gramophone seem to be supernatural phenomena: “Dazzled by so many and such marvelous inventions, the people of Macondo did not know where their amazement began” (1973: 229). Miracles, on the other hand, emerge with the appearance of irrational things yet in accordance with the order of the local microcosm. People perceive the excesses of time (such as loops, condensations, or the eternal return) as natural (Michaowski 1983). However, they perceive any intervention of the historical time, which is measured with the chronometers of the rational culture, as a disruption. The time is absorbed by the magical reality in order to become the matter of the mythical cycle. In a different aspect, the events of Macondo reflect Latin-American history (Elbanowski 1983: 17). An important part is played by reiteration – when the time loops, the people’s lives also overlap, which makes us read the novel as a universal parable. The world created in One Hundred Years of Solitude is built on the reality outside the text in order to transform it in a literary way and return to the point of departure, that is, become a metaphor of the human condition. It is, however, a world given to irony. Miraculousness receives the status of a literary convention and plays with the reader. The magic is sometimes so grotesque and the figures of violence so great in numbers and so odd that the parable seen in the novel seems to be true (Danow 2004). Consequently, the criticism of cultural domination performed in the novel saves it from becoming an ideology analogous to the negated form of the claiming power. The presence of colonization issues is not as obvious in the tales of Schulz as it is in the novel by García Márquez. It may be noticed, however, if we assume that the Polish writer, using the poetics of magical realism, transforms the Galician reality and imitates not the reality itself but general cultural processes filtrated by the artist’s perception and imagination. The space of Schulzian prose, similarly to that of García Márquez, refers to specific places. Father’s map depicts the real valley of the River Tysmienica; Crocodile Street is a literary counterpart of Stryjska Street; Górka and the tavern are located on the way to Truskawiec. Simultaneously, the Galician province is a self-contained area, isolated from the world, constituting a setting for the story of Joseph’s family. Just like in One Hundred Years of Solitude, a family story in Schulz’s tales can be read as a
186
Dorota Wojda
metaphor of the history of mankind. Nonetheless, the author of ‘The Book’ concentrated on one particular protagonist. The life of Joseph becomes a figure of man’s lot. Also similarly to the novel by García Márquez, the topography of the tales has a paradoxical nature. Geography turns into a myth; space emerges from the language and characterizes the form of the prose on its own; a room evolves into a jungle or into a “nightly forest train” (TF 197; “w lenym poci gu nocnym”; Op 211). In such a space, the character tries to find a way to the Book that founded the world and the nature of man. Its distance or elusiveness (the spread of forgeries made to resemble the Book) is the reason for the decline of the world because in the absence of the authentic, reality makes no sense and is full of violence. The demiurge here is Franz Joseph, destroying the pricelessness of the world with his police ideology, or Father, seemingly favourably inclined toward multiplicity but in fact, causing its extinction. Similarly to One Hundred Years of Solitude, violence here assumes the form of aggressive capitalization, as evident in ‘The Street of Crocodiles’. Read as a text about the consequences of neocolonialism, the work also induces the interpretation of Schulz’s prose as a “representation of transformational regionalism” and a “foreshortening of history”. It may be stated that the changes depicted in the tale, which take place in the province as a result of the invasion of foreign capital, are metaphors of the decline of the civilization – a brief presentation of a cultural crisis that has spanned considerable time. Moreover, the method of evaluation from ‘The Street of Crocodiles’ turns against Polish stereotypes concerning the centre and periphery, including the mythologization of the Eastern borderlands. According to the myth of “Kresy”, the borderland is a bastion of homeland and cultural achievements and at the same time, an area with a mission to civilize and a dangerous but fascinating authenticity (Czaplejewicz 1996: 16). Schulz creates the space, plot, and character in such a way that the borderland becomes something different. The old business culture contrasts here with the modern economy spreading on the outskirts of the town. The location of the district characterized by progress makes the centre/periphery opposition lose its clarity. Crocodile Street is called the space “of breaking down the barriers of hierarchy” (TF 70; “zniwelowania granic i hierarchij”; Op 77) – moral principles decline here, and the new merges with the old, resulting in the appearance of new hybrid forms. Three attitudes were taken toward this region:
Schulz and Magical Realism in One Hundred Years of Solitude
187
approbative, critical, and ironic. The first attitude conforms with the colonial idea of the centre/periphery layout, according to which action recognized as a civilizing mission receives a positive opinion. The second bears the hallmarks of an anti-colonial world view. Crocodile Street is criticized by most of its natives, including the narrator, who sees its appearance and rubbish. At the same time, the figure betrays his fascination with this world, thus pointing to another difference between Schulz’s presentation and colonial discourse: cultural artificiality is charming here, whereas, the authenticity of nature is charming there. Furthermore, the explorer’s experiences are presented in a different way as the protagonist reaches no destination but keeps wandering about the street that is subject to constant metamorphoses. The realist convention is broken with the fantasy code, resulting in the blurring of the difference between a rule and an exception. In its process of invalidation, the play between the topography and character creation manifests itself as an ironic subject that creates illusions of different conditions in order to dispel them. The ironic subject changes the perspectives of evaluation and consequently, interprets the cultural borderland. Owing to that, the dialectic of the centre/periphery is set in motion – it is established, inverted, and finally, ironically problematized. It may be described as a “thematic foregrounding” of the repressions of colonial discourse and a shifting to the postcolonial vision of the borderland, where irony accompanies reflection on cultural difference beyond the unequivocal dimension of the identity-based culture. Not only in ‘The Street of Crocodiles’ but also in other tales by Schulz, the relativization of values occurs thanks to the fantasy element, which also links the prose with the novel by García Márquez. It is difficult, however, to speak here of a division into fantastic and miraculous elements. Father experiments in the field of technology as well as nature, and he treats all forms on which he works as ordinary elements of reality, which are at the same time possible places for the articulation of the mystery of the other. In this aspect, the magical realism of Schulz differs from the magical realist poetics and ontology of García Márquez. From the poetological perspective, it can be presented in the categories developed by the Russian formalists – as a defamiliarization that allows us to perceive the extraordinary in the ordinary. With regard to the ontological perspective, Schulz’s ideas bring to mind the Freudian concept of Unheimlichkeit, where the
188
Dorota Wojda
uncanny manifests itself in the natural. Despite the indicated differences, there exists a certain similarity between the presentations of the two writers – in both cases literature opposes the categorization of rationalism, whereas motion, fluidity of matter, madness, and nonsense are evaluated positively. This is visible in the creations of José Arcadio Buendía and Jacob, behind whom is the fatherhood authority. Buendía searches for the philosopher’s stone and finds an ice block to be the greatest invention: he imagines the beauty of tropical Macondo built of icy crystals. Jacob’s laboratory works according to the panta rhei principle. The demiurge experiments with matter in order to “pave its way […] to transfusion, to universal circulation in accordance with its true nature”; (TF 101; “torowa jej drogi […] do tranfuzji, do wszechcyrkulacji, jedynie waciwej jej naturze”; Op 356). We are dealing with a different way of evaluation than in colonial discourse, where motion is regarded as modus operandi, which is supposed to make the power consolidate and where man struggles to control the nature with the power of his mind. Such a worldview translates in Schulz’s tales into the peculiarity of the temporal form. A history is told correspondingly to One Hundred Years of Solitude; the plot is not identical with the fictional pattern. Only after its reconstruction there emerges a linear story that progresses from Joseph’s childhood through his adolescence, Jacob’s successive metamorphoses, until ‘Father’s Last Escape’ (‘Ostatnia ucieczka ojca’), and from the period of the Book’s absence until its loss in the time of forgeries. Both of these processes, linked with each other, constitute the time of myth, simultaneous perpetuation of different fragments of history. Such simultaneity also appears in the novel by García Márquez: “Melquíades had not put events in the order of man’s conventional time, but had concentrated a century of daily episodes in such a way that they coexisted in one instant” (1973: 421). The events which have their equivalents in reality do not play as important a role in Schulz’s texts as they do in One Hundred Years of Solitude, but when they appear, they also become objects of fantastic transformation. And just like in García Márquez, the literary representations of those events become a means of conveying the general evaluation of culture. The temporal fantasy conventions used by Schulz in many ways resemble the means used later by the Colombian writer. Among the conventions used are – next to
Schulz and Magical Realism in One Hundred Years of Solitude
189
simultaneity and inversion – ellipses, condensations, loops, and various kinds of reiteration. The last two techniques especially combine the different ways of building time in the works of Schulz and in One Hundred Years of Solitude. The author of ‘Spring’ constructs the text in such a way as to create the temporal paradoxes and the cyclical nature of events, especially of seasons and the times of the day as well as the stages of human life (Jarz bski 1998: LVI). A similar form appears in García Márquez, except that he pays special attention to the recurrence of the biographical patterns. The images of the palimpsests and temporal apocrypha are characteristic of Schulz’s prose. In both of the literary creations, the arrangement of time turns against rational discourse and triggers the parabolic mode of reading. Schulz’s parable is so multidimensional that its meanings should not be narrowed to just one superior sense. It certainly underlines the significance of the whole, the myth, integrity of the world, and literary form on the one hand and fragmentariness, demythologization, division of existence, and literature on the other. This duality, passing from one order to another and thus playing with the conventions of realism and fantasy, is matched by irony. Read in the postcolonial context, this irony becomes a strategy that disarms the authoritarian divisions of colonial discourses. Conclusion: Figures of Narration The final part of the article concerns a matter that must be addressed separately: narration in the prose of Schulz and the novel by García Márquez, which also constitutes the summary of the preceding discussion. Narration ought to be discussed separately and undertaken in the part that contains conclusions because it has a dimension extremely significant for postcolonial discourse, that is, performativity, which pertains to how the message is formulated simultaneously in the direct, objective articulation of the text and through use of the articulated meanings. The nature of both the writing of Schulz and the work of García Márquez is intertextual and self-referential. A wide range of references may be found in them, including the Bible, mythology, and various philosophical currents – writings of the Jewish and Polish traditions in Schulz, and works from the Latin American world in García Márquez. Jarz bski indicates that Schulz was indebted to
190
Dorota Wojda
writers such as Rilke, Kubin, Meyrink, and Mann. Among the writer’s philosophical inspirations, the scholar mentions the works of German Romanticism: Jung, Bergson, and Nietzsche (Jarz bski 1998: XCVII). García Márquez, as Elbanowski notices, creates in One Hundred Years of Solitude a synthesis of Latin American literature (reminiscences from Borges, Carpentier, Fuentes, and Cortázar are found in the text) as well as a certain summa of his own work. One of the characters in the novel is Gabriel Márquez, who leaves Macondo for Paris, where he starts writing (Elbanowski 1983: 19–20). Similarly in the work of Schulz, a range of references between his tales, paintings, and drawings may be found. In the context of such intertextual and self-referential techniques, one ought to examine the way both writers lead the narrative. They insert into their texts sections that characterize the poetics of magical realism. In ‘Spring’, the narrator describes Bianca’s villa not only to define the style of the girl but also of Schulzian prose: W tych wyszukanych i ruchliwych liniach o przesadnej wytwornoci […] byo co fertycznego, arliwego, zbyt jaskrawo gestykuluj cego – co jednym sowem kolorowego kolonialnego i ypi cego oczyma… Tak jest, styl ten mia na dnie swym co niesychanie odra aj cego – by rozpustny, wymylny, tropikalny i niesychanie cyniczny. (Op 183) (In those elaborate and mobile lines of exaggerated elegance […] there was something fidgety, too eager, to showy – something, in a word, colourful and colonial… Indeed, the style was in effect rather repulsive – lustful, over-elaborate, tropical, and extremely cynical; TF 177).
A previously mentioned metaphor that was important for Schulz was lost in the translation of this quote. Its meaning would correspond to that of the idiom “to give someone the glad eye”. The style of the author “winks” at the reader, showing its multidimensional character. In the quoted paragraph, a metonymy also appears which allows the text to become performative – the “winking” means that the fragment refers to the whole, and its form is revealed here. In other words, the text practises exactly what it describes. Similar techniques are employed by García Márquez: It was as if God had decided to put to the test every capacity for surprise and was keeping the inhabitants of Macondo in a permanent alternation between excitement and disappointment, doubt and revelation, to such an
Schulz and Magical Realism in One Hundred Years of Solitude
191
extreme that no one knew for certain where the limits of reality lay. (1973: 230)
On the surface, the paragraph concerns the reality of Macondo which dawns with the appearance of new technological inventions, yet those words also have another meaning – they simultaneously explain and create the dual, magical realist form of the novel. The self-referentiality of the narration in Schulz’s tales and in One Hundred Years of Solitude is fulfilled on higher levels that are modal frames of the texts. In the first case, the reader may speculate that the events of the novel are described in the Book. This guess is based on the narration of ‘Spring’, a key tale of Schulz, where the stamp album, which is a counterpart of the Book, turns out to be the text of spring as a season, and at the same time, a piece of prose with the same title. In One Hundred Years of Solitude, the reader finally learns that all he has read had already been written in the Manuscript of Melquíades, which the protagonists had been trying to decipher for one hundred years. The same moment Aureliano reaches the last words of the manuscript, Macondo is wiped off the face of the earth, and the reader finishes reading. Performativeness of narration is significant in the works by Schulz and García Márquez because it indicates that magical realism (as the poetics, ontology, and strategy of postcolonial discourse) is not only a literary creation, in which realism and fantasy problematize the discourses of power in an ironic way, but also a practice which induces thought, writing, and action. Requested action may be explained in different ways – either as creating postcolonial literature or as action meant to change the violence-supporting culture. Bibliography Baker, Suzanne. 1993. ‘Binarisms and Duality: Magic Realism and Postcolonialism’ in SPAN: Journal of the South Pacific Association for Commonwealth Literature and Language Studies 36: 82-87. Bakua, Bogusaw. 2006. ‘Kolonialne i postkolonialne aspekty polskiego dyskursu kresoznawczego. (Zarys problematyki)’ in Teksty Drugie 6: 11-33. Bhabha, Homi K. 1990. Nation and Narration. London and New York: Routledge. ——. 1995. The Location of Culture. London and New York: Routledge. Brooke-Rose, Christine. 1983. Rhetoric of the Unreal: Studies in Narrative and Structure, Especially of the Fantastic. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
192
Dorota Wojda
Cavanagh, Clare. 2003. ‘Postkolonialna Polska. Biaa plama na mapie wspóczesnych teorii’ (tr. T. Kunz) in Teksty Drugie 2/3: 60-71. Czaplejewicz, Eugeniusz. 1996. ‘Czym jest literatura kresowa?’ in Czaplejewicz, Eugeniusz and Edward Kasperski (eds). Kresy w literaturze. Twórcy dwudziestowieczni. Warszawa: Wiedza Powszechna: 7-73. Danow, David K. 2004. The Spirit of the Carnival: Magical Realism and the Grotesque. Lexington: University Press of Kentucky. de Man, Paul. 1996. ‘The Concept of Irony’ in Warminski, Andrzej (ed.) Aesthetic Ideology. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press: 163-184. Durix, Jean-Pierre. 1998. Mimesis, Genres and Post-Colonial Discourse. Deconstructing Magical Realism. London: Macmillan Press. Elbanowski, Adam. 1983. ‘Márquez : od realizmu magicznego do ironii magicznej’ in Literatura na wiecie 9: 10-23. Foucault, Michel. 1975. Surveiller et punir. Naissance de la prison. Paris: Gallimard. García Márquez, Gabriel. 1973. One Hundred Years of Solitude (tr. G. Rabassa). London: Penguin. Gazda, Grzegorz. 2005. ‘Mityzacja rzeczywistoci a realizm magiczny (glosa komparatystyczna)’ in Kita, Magorzata and Bo ena Witosz (eds). Spotkanie. Ksiga jubileuszowa dla Profesora Aleksandra Wilkonia. Katowice: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu l skiego: 212-219. ——. 2006. ‘Bruno Schulz i Franz Kafka (glosy komparatystyczne)’ in Bolecki, Wodzimierz and Ryszard Nycz (eds). Dziea, jzyki tradycje. Profesorowi Januszowi Sawiskiemu na siedemdziesite urodziny przyjaciele, koledzy, wspópracownicy. Warszawa: Wydawnictwo IBL PAN: 314-326. Gowacka, Dorota. 1996. ‘Wzniosa tandeta i simulacrum. Bruno Schulz w postmodernistycznych zaukach’ in Teksty Drugie 2/3: 72-91. Hahn, Hannelore. 1994. The Influence of Franz Kafka on Three Novels by Gabriel García Márquez (Comparative Cultures and Literatures 4). New York: Peter Lang. Janion, Maria. 2007. Niesamowita sowiaszczyzna. Fantazmaty literatury. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie. Jarz bski, Jerzy. 1998. ‘Wst p’ in Schulz (1998): V-CXL. Kaufer, David S. 1983. ‘Irony, Interpretative Form, and the Theory of Meaning’ in Poetics Today 4(3): 451-464. Looby, Robert. 2003. ‘Formalizm i parodia w twórczoci Brunona Schulza’ in Kitowska-ysiak, Magorzata and Wadysaw Panas (eds). W uamkach zwierciada…Bruno Schulz w 110 rocznic urodzin i 60 rocznic mierci. Lublin: Towarzystwo Naukowe KUL: 261-274. López, Alfred J. 2001. Posts and Pasts. A Theory of Postcolonialism. Albany: State University of New York Press. Maszewski, Zbigniew. 2003. William Faulkner and Bruno Schulz: a Comparative Study. ód: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu ódzkiego. Michaowski, Piotr. 1983. ‘Sto lat samotnoci – powie o czasie’ in Literatura na wiecie 9: 24-34. Moore-Gilbert, Bart. 1997. Postcolonial Theory. Contexts, Practices, Politics. London and New York: Verso.
Schulz and Magical Realism in One Hundred Years of Solitude
193
Obehelman, Harley D. 1980. The Presence of Faulkner in the Writings of García Márquez (Graduate Studies Texas Tech University 22). Lubbock: Texas Tech University Press. Owczarski, Wojciech. 2004. ‘Schulz i Kafka. Poetyka egzystencji’ in Kasperski, Edward and Tomasz Mackiewicz (eds). Franz Kafka na progu XXI wieku. Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Wydziau Polonistyki Uniwersytetu Warszawskiego: 247-262. Pawyszyn, Marko. 1998. ‘Ukraiski postkolonialny postmodernizm’ (tr. A. Korniejenko and A. Hnatiuk) in Nycz, Ryszard (ed.) Odkrywanie modernizmu. Kraków: Universitas: 530-537. Pindel, Tomasz. 2004. Zjawy, szalestwo i mier. Fantastyka i realizm magiczny w literaturze hispanoamerykaskiej. Kraków: Universitas. Ploetz, Dagmar. 1997. Gabriel García Márquez (tr. J. ukosz). Wrocaw: Wydawnictwo Dolnol skie. Podgórniak, Alexandra. 2004. ‘Realizm magiczny jako strategia postkolonialna’ in Er(r)go 8(1): 189-192. ——. 2006. Magic Realism. Postcolonial Literary Theory and Practice. PhD thesis. University of Silesia. Rawdon Wilson, Robert. 1990. In Palamedes’ Shadow: Explorations in Play, Game and Narrative Theory. Boston: Northeastern University Press. Schulz, Bruno. 1988. The Fictions of Bruno Schulz (tr. C. Wieniewska). London: Picador. Schulz, Bruno. 1998. Opowiadania. Wybór esejów i listów (ed. J. Jarz bski). Wrocaw: Zakad Narodowy im. Ossoliskich. Skórczewski, Dariusz. 2006. ‘Postkolonialna Polska – projekt (nie)mo liwy’ in Teksty Drugie 1/2: 100-112. Slemon, Stephen. 1989. ‘Reading for Resistance in the Post-Colonial Literature’ in Maes-Jelenek, Hena, Kirsten Holst Petersen and Anna Rutherford (eds). A Shaping of Connections. Sydney, Coventry, Aarhus: Dangaroo Press: 100115. ——. 1995. ‘Magical Realism as Postcolonial Discourse’ in Parkinson Zamora, Lois and Wendy B. Faris (eds). Magical Realism. Theory, History, Community. Durham and London: Duke University Press: 407-426. Stala, Krzysztof. 1995. Na marginesach rzeczywistoci. O paradoksach przedstawiania w twórczoci Brunona Schulza. Warszawa: Wydawnictwo IBL PAN. Thompson, Ewa M. 2006. ‘Sarmatyzm i postkolonializm. O naturze polskich resentymentów’ in Europa. Tygodnik Idei 46: 11. Todorov, Tzvetan. 1970. Introduction à la littérature fantastique. Paris: Seuil. Volkening, Ernesto. 1963. ‘Gabriel García Márquez o el trópico desembrujado’ in Eco. Revista de la Cultura de Occidente 40: 273-293.
“A (Wo)man on a Sofa” in Bruno Schulz’s Art and Writings. Schulz as a “Painterly” and “Writerly” Artist Marta Skwara Abstract: This article analyzes Bruno Schulz’s creative application of the motif of “a (wo)man on a sofa” in order to indicate the various games that Schulz plays both with tradition and his spectators/readers, and the ways in which he transgresses the conventions of art and literature. The essay demonstrates how Schulz creates texts which unsettle all the reader’s assumptions by displacing his or her cultural memory and explains in what sense his text has to be created anew in each reader, who is part of the seductive theatre of love.
Introduction When trying to explore the limits of the comparability of Schulz’s works one profitable thing to focus on is a particular motif employed by Schulz in both his art and writing. “A (wo)man on a sofa”, understood as a version of “a reclining woman”, is a good place to begin this discussion because the iconographic scheme has been exploited in European art ever since Titian, and not only is the tradition rich and evergreen (e.g. Rainer Fetting’s Reclining Nude on Sofa, 1988) but it also provokes questions about different kinds of transgressions in both art and stylistic conventions. Because it is also possible to point to a literary motif as a specific counterpart of the iconographic scheme in question, “the pictorial character of Schulz’s prose” and “the literary character of his drawings” (Ficowski 1998: 514), or an iconic layer of Schulz’s prose, “a sort of pictorial screen, or filter, modeling the mode of representation” (Stala 1993: 100-101), can be put into a comparative perspective and discussed within world literature and art. What I want to do is demonstrate Bruno Schulz’s modes of creative usage of the widespread art tradition and the various games he plays with his spectators/readers. Through interpreting Schulz’s creative applications of one particular motif, I do not propose
196
Marta Skwara
to demonstrate his (dis)similarity to other painters and writers but will instead attempt to discern particular aspects of his technique and artistic imagination, the ways in which he creates his radically plural world and makes it function as a conduit for the disruptive potential of interdisciplinary and intertextual relations. First I will try to establish the framework of the iconographic scheme that I will use to interpret Bruno Schulz’s art, then I will demonstrate possible comparative approaches to his realizations of the iconographic scheme. After that, I will attempt to specify in what manner Schulz’s art and writing differ while applying the same iconographic scheme followed by an interpretation of the motif in question in Schulz’s writing. In conclusion, I will present possible ways of defining Schulz’s art and writing technique, which makes him a limitlessly comparable yet also boundlessly transgressive artist, more in his literature than in his art. Art It is obvious that “a reclining woman” is a general iconographic scheme denoting a picture of a (dressed/half-dressed/naked) woman resting somewhere (in nature1/a salon/a bedroom) on something (for example, the ground, a sofa, just a bed, or sometimes in an armchair). This general scheme is far too generic to be the scheme to which I would like to refer. When we take Schulz’s drawings and graphics into account, it becomes clear that his interests were focused on a particular version of the scheme: in almost every case, his women are half-naked or naked and recline on a sofa (bed) that is situated in some kind of an interior. It does not seem that Schulz was interested in explorations of the iconographic scheme in the way Egon Schiele (Reclining Woman, 1917) or Marc Chagall (Reclining Nude, 1914) were, producing pictures with a female figure reclining in an unspecified space.2 Neither was Schulz attracted to explorations of the shapes which the female body can take as, for example, Matisse (Pink Nude, 1935) or Modigliani (Reclining Nude on a White Cushion, 1917-1918) were. Surrealistic devices typical of Magritte (Bather Between Light and Dark, 1935) were also out of the mainstream of his 1
The tradition dates back to Lucas Cranach the Elder (Reclining Nymph, 1530-34) and Giorgione (Sleeping Venus, 1510). 2 With the exception of some sketches which seem to be unfinished (see drawings in Schulz 1992: 241-242, 254).
“A (Wo)man on a Sofa”. Schulz as a “Painterly” and “Writerly” Artist
197
fine art. It does not mean, however, that Schulz did not discuss the tradition as his famous contemporaries did; instead, he tended to allude to a particular type of tradition – by using and combining its characteristic elements – rather than invent new forms of artistic expression. What he created were more or less discursive versions of well-known iconographic schemes, connected to various extents to their prototypes. Drawings such as Reclining Nude (c. 1933) and Reclining Woman (c. 1933), for example, can be seen as the simplest cases of using tradition; they are almost exercises in the style of Goya’s Naked Maja or Manet’s Olympia or as Magorzata Kitowskaysiak argues, Zuloaga’s Irena (Sownik schulzowski: 428). Kitowskaysiak also sees Schulz’s depiction of draperies as a characteristic link to Zuloaga’s manner of creating space. By not ignoring this possibility, one could also point out a connection to Delacroix’s manner of rendering cloth, e.g. in his Female Nude Reclining on a Divan (1830), especially in the context of the third cover of Schulz’s The Idolatrous Book with the woman reclining on the sofa wrapped in sophisticated draperies. This cliché-verre also alludes to the traditional air of a female bedroom: warm, cozy, and erotically attractive (the yellow brownish light used by many painters – beginning with Rembrandt and Rubens – was perhaps symbolically replaced by Schulz with candles burning in candleholders). The fifth cover of The Idolatrous Book alludes to elements known from Velazquez’s Venus at the Mirror (1649-51), with the figures and symbols being playfully changed. Instead of presenting the naked beautiful back of the goddess and hiding her face (in Velazquez’s version the face is seen vaguely only in a mirror held by Cupid), Schulz places the dressed woman frontally (only her legs and arms are naked) and lets us see her face, while the mirror held by Pierrot is empty. One may discuss how this cliché-verre can be interpreted (it should be noted that it is not the only example of Schulz playing with Velazquez’s scheme: two drawings, Venus and Cupid and Venus and Cupid [II] (before 1933) should be recollected here). Yet it is clear that without putting Schulz’s book covers into the context of Velazquez’s painting, the possibilities of discovering Schulz’s art games are lost. What Jerzy Ficowski (1988: 52) called “a deliberate archaization” typical of The Idolatrous Book seems to be a conscious artistic choice bringing forth the main issue of Schulz’s art; it is as though he manifestly declares on the covers of his Book: “this is not how I see a woman but how I
198
Marta Skwara
see (play with) what other artists and their spectators had already seen”. Inside the Book one finds more examples of such playing: one of them, titled ‘The Book of Idolatry II’, alludes to the classical images of a woman on a sofa, this time more in the Titian manner. Yet the woman who lies on the sofa in the pose of Venus of Urbino is only half-naked; her characteristically full body is covered in the upper part, just like her face is partly covered by the hat. Her bosom seems to be shaped in the manner of the other Venus of Titian (“with the organ-player”), and this is not the only link between these pictures. In both the woman is accompanied by a man. Instead of Titian’s organplayer who is distracted from his job of playing the instrument, Schulz presents a man who is distracted from reading a book. Neither man looks at the instruments of art but gazes at the woman. The direction of the organ-player’s glance, toward the division of Venus’s legs, makes his interest in her more obvious than that of Schulz’s man, who tries to catch the woman’s eyes, while kneeling in the pose of both respect and fear. The open book is as empty as the mirror held by Pierrot. This may symbolically connect both of Schulz’s pictures on “idolatry”: the one from the cover and the one from the inside of The Idolatrous Book. Could it be said that the man with the book – resembling Schulz himself – serves as a kind of mediator between the spectator and the erotic object: the voyeur placed within the composition as a surrogate for the voyeur who cannot enter it?3 Or perhaps in Schulz’s case the mediator does not dare to be the voyeur because he can see less than the spectator? The book of idolatry is to be written, the story to be told, and as Schulz seems to suggest, it is a more complex story than the story of sexual attraction. Because Schulz’s Venus holds a kind of a whip instead of red roses symbolizing carnal love (an attribute of Titian’s Venus), she alludes to a different kind of sensuality of which Sacher-Masoch’s Venus became a symbol. Nevertheless, by combining different traditions, Schulz deliberately recalls many Venuses (one could fill the line of tradition with other classical representations among which Paris Bordone’s Venus with Cupid (1520-1530) should be most obvious), intentionally expanding and multiplying meanings. Schulz’s presupposed masochistic interest in women – for which drawings such 3
As Edward Lucie-Smith interprets Titian’s picture (1995: 173).
“A (Wo)man on a Sofa”. Schulz as a “Painterly” and “Writerly” Artist
199
as Reclining Female Nude with Self-portrait (before 1936) could provide more arguments – is an element of a very complex play rather than a feature of both Schulz’s personality and art, as his contemporary Witkacy (Witkiewicz 1990: 108-109) and later other interpreters claimed; I agree here with Wodzimierz Bolecki’s standpoint (1994: 128-129). Exploring further the art scenes in which a woman on a sofa is placed in the center of the composition and is the center of artistic endeavors, I would point to one more cliché-verre, ‘Stallions and Eunuchs’, in which Schulz alludes to the characteristic position of the woman lying on her stomach with slightly spread legs, introduced by François Boucher (Odalisque, 1743; Mademoiselle O’Murphy, 1751). Instead of an exclusive boudoir, the typical interior of eighteenthcentury “pink pornography”, Schulz creates a half-open interior and fills the complex expressionistic setting around the woman on the sofa with horses (called stallions in the title, which emphasizes their sexual function) and figures of men (called eunuchs, which emphasizes their asexual function). In this case, disputable “pornographic aspects” of Schulz’s art can be discussed within a comparative perspective. Boucher, according to Edward Lucie-Smith’s interpretation, retains sufficient traces of the individual identity of a desirable young woman to make one wonder what it would be like to go to bed with her (Lucie-Smith 1995: 99), which would mean that by doing so, Boucher crosses the thin line beyond which we talk about pornography.4 Schulz, however, makes one wonder who would go to bed with the somewhat generalized type of woman, devoid of individual traces, and gives the possible answers by contrasting active animals with passive human beings. Through ironic expressions of wishes and fears rather than suggestions of sexual pleasure, Schulz shifts from causing reactions to talking about them; he starts to tell the story of adoration and idolatry, while not necessarily being pornographic (i.e., not necessarily causing sexual reactions, which, in all honesty, can never be unarguably denied). In The Idolatrous Book as a whole, the most characteristic (because they are the most numerous) scenes show the woman placed on the sofa and exercising her power over the man with her naked foot on his face or head (a naked beauty, like Undula, is sometimes 4
Understood in the simplest way as erotic material intended to cause sexual excitement.
200
Marta Skwara
replaced by her dressed maid, traditionally connected with the literary heroine Adela). Even Biblical Susanna (who is surprisingly wearing stockings, which make her look more like Félicien Rops’s Cythera than the biblical symbol of virtue) is placed naked on a type of sofa and put on display. Schulz, an art student and art lover, seems to retain connections to the long tradition of an old man watching a sleeping nude. One may recall Rubens’s Angelica and the Hermit (1626-28), where the possibly dishonest wishes of the hermit are symbolized by the dark screaming face in the background (likewise, in the background of Schulz’s sleeping Susanna, we can also notice such an inhuman face). In the other graphic, still naked and asleep, she is adored by the elders, one of them kissing her foot. The group of elders plays the same role as the group of artists/pariahs/pilgrims in Schulz’s other graphics or drawings: they adore the beauty who (naked or halfnaked, lying, half-lying, or just sitting on a sofa, sometimes on a bench or a chair) pays no attention to them. These group scenes go beyond the iconic tradition of a woman on a sofa and begin to explore new contexts too complex to discuss here. One element, however, should be stressed: the role of a female leg. The line of demonologists, which Witkacy evoked in the context of images of a woman torturing a man with her leg (Cranach, Dürer, Grünewald, Goya, Munch, Beardsley), could be recalled here, yet Schulz starts to play not only with the pictures we have seen but also with the scenes about which we have read. Sacher-Masoch’s demonic women, like Lola kicking the face of the male servant kneeling before her or Venus in furs humiliating her lover, become the most obvious yet, perhaps, overused contexts (Bolecki 1994: 129). Why should we forget Frida stepping on the poor surveyor hidden under the counter at their first meeting in Das Schloss? While a female leg is an element of the sexual play in Schulz’s graphics and drawings, a sofa (bed) seems to be a necessary prop, the sign of being put on display and being watched, the iconic sign of demonstrating sexual attraction and sexual captivation in a recognizable manner. Schulz creates his message as if he were a mediator between the pictures already seen and those he creates himself. Such an attitude seems to have been symbolically presented in an India ink drawing titled Masochistic scene; above the sofa and the naked woman displaying her back temptingly to the naked man lying flat on the rug below, we can see a frame which is left empty. It
“A (Wo)man on a Sofa”. Schulz as a “Painterly” and “Writerly” Artist
201
can be interpreted as a mirror,5 one of many mirrors in Schulz’s art that reflects nothing; yet the pose of the woman can also be recognized as a transformation of the famous Grand Odalisque (1814) by Ingres, which was said to be a transformation of David’s Madame Recamier (1800). Thus the spectator might move backwards in his or her interpretation: from Schulz’s erotic (masochistic) scene in which the naked woman deliberately puts on a provocative pose while looking indifferently toward the spectator/admirer present in the picture to the equally indifferent though less provocative Odalisque looking at the spectator placed outside the picture, and finally to the modest and noble Madame – whose potential erotic appeal is only gently suggested by her naked feet – fully dressed and placed on the sofa in a manner which suggests a salon rather than a bedroom scene. The empty frames above the sofa can be filled with images to which Schulz seems to allude by using both the well-known scheme and the symbolically empty frame (which becomes the metaframe), as if he constantly (also by means of repetitions) moves along the line of tradition, between the salon and the boudoir; between the innocent beauty (goddess) and the indifferent torturer; between the spectator who watches the scene from outside the frames and the spectator present inside (who is sometimes the artist himself); between this which can be demonstrated in a particular picture and that which can be expressed by a series of particular pictures and their reinterpretations. Art and Literature The connection between Schulz’s visual and literary representations, which manifests as a disruptive tension arising between the same motif depicted in Schulz’s art and literature, can be demonstrated by a scene from the story titled ‘Edzio’ (‘Eddie’). The well-known illustration presented in the London edition (1998) with a caption taken from the story – “Every night he presses his white, fat face to the window pane” (1998: 242;6 “Jak co nocy, przyciska sw blad 5
This would be quite unusual, however, because pictures were commonly placed above sofas, and this tradition was still respected by expressionists (Erich Heckel, Lying woman (1909)). 6 All further references will be given as CW.
202
Marta Skwara
tust twarz […] do szyby”; 1989: 292)7 – shows a man behind a window, with an ecstatic (painful) expression on his face, and a naked woman sleeping on a big flat bed, with her head on a pillow. While the spectator can see her naked front, the man behind the window can only see her back, yet he does not look.8 The full moon illuminates the scene in which the interior mingles with the exterior; since the room opens into the city, the woman is placed in an open space, while the man seems to be caged, painfully separated from the woman by the window that he touches powerlessly with his open hands. The whole scene could be interpreted in typical sexual terms: the man suffers from desire, while the woman sleeps indifferently and out of his reach. When we go back to Schulz’s text, however, the interpretation must be changed considerably because Edzio does not occupy the same position as the other “Peeping Toms”, young shop-assistants who would stand in front of Adela’s window singing dirty songs and trying to spy on her. On the contrary, disabled Edzio cries for help and because his crutches are locked in the cupboard, so must jump on all fours like a dog. Alas, Adela sleeps indifferently and ecstatically: “She has no strength even to pull up the blanket over her bare thighs” (CW 243; “Nie ma si nawet, by wci gn kodr na obna one uda”; Op 292). Surprisingly, it is not sexuality but dreamlike transformations of leaf-like insects running over Adela’s naked body which are explored in the literary scene. The manner in which they are depicted creates a separate and suggestive picture of which nothing is present in the “illustration”: S to paskie torebki na krew, rude mieszki na krew, bez oczu i bez fizjonomii, i teraz maszeruj caymi klanami, wielka w drówka ludów podzielona na pokolenia i na rody. Biegn od nóg krociami, niezliczon promenad , coraz wi ksze, tak wielkie jak my, jak paskie pugilaresy, jak wielkie czerwone wampiry bez gowy, lekkie i papierowe na nó kach subtelniejszych od paj czyny. (CW 292) They are flat receptacles for blood, reddish blood bags without eyes or faces, now on the march in whole clans on a migration of the species subdivided into generations and tribes. They run up from her feet in scores, a never-ending procession, they are larger now, as large as moths,
7
All further references will be given as Op. His eyes are closed, his mouth half-open; the woman’s mouth is half-open, and her eyes are closed too while her face is turned in the opposite direction, which emphasizes the effect of separation. 8
“A (Wo)man on a Sofa”. Schulz as a “Painterly” and “Writerly” Artist
203
flat red vampires without heads, lightweight as if cut out of paper, on legs more delicate than the web of spiders. (Op 243)
While the drawing depicts the story of desire, the literary text goes much further, depicting the story of the mysterious life of small creatures which develops into the image of all the sleeping creatures in the house. Thus, while the “illustration” is kept within a wellknown convention, in accordance with the idea that female nakedness causes male suffering, the literary scene goes beyond the description of the sexual attractiveness of a naked female body or its aesthetics. Schulz’s literary scenes open the areas of transformations and transgressions, which always diverge from the pictures, even though they are called “illustrations”. Literature The first strong indication of a meaningful shift of notions is seen in a literary depiction of Touya. After having seen and analyzed all of the fine art scenes where a woman placed on a sofa was admired, adored, and feared, when we turn to Schulz’s first short story ‘Sierpie’ (‘August’), the Touya scene strikes us as a unique one, not a typical realization of the scheme. However, some of the iconic layer is still easily recognizable. Touya “sits hunched up” on a bed, “among the yellow bedding and odd rags” (CW 11; “siedzi przykucni ta wród ótej pocieli i szmat”; Op 7). The bed itself is an unaesthetic and defunct object – “propped up on two bricks where one leg was missing” – and so is the heroine, the “half-naked idiot girl” (CW 11; “podparte zamiast brakuj cej nogi dwiema starymi cegami”, “na wpó naga i ciemna kretynka”; Op 7-8). The scene is set in a garden, which we seldom see in Schulz’s drawings and graphics. When he once placed the woman on an antique bed against a landscape, it was a city landscape (Akt w antycznym ou na tle miejskiego krajobrazu, 1930). In the drawing, the naked woman reclines gracefully on a pillow, with her body put on display and meant to be adored. Touya cannot be adored because her inhuman ugliness is emphasized in the description, yet the moment she rises on her feet and stands like a pagan idol (“on short childish legs”; CW 11; “na krótkich, dziecinnych nó kach”; Op 8), she becomes more than an object to be
204
Marta Skwara
seen and not touched.9 Instead of torturing men with her sexuality and playing with their sexual wishes, she turns out to be a self-sufficient erotic creature reaching sexual fulfillment without a man. There is, however, still someone who watches and describes Touya, a voyeur without whom we would not see the half-wit, half-naked girl on the bed, “the autobiographical boy Joseph, passive, tolerant, a watcher and a learner” (Brown 1991: 54). Is this scene supposed to function as a simple negation of aesthetic categories? It seems to be highly subversive in comparison to literary scenes in which a woman on a sofa used to be placed in the middle of a salon, for example, Jules Barbey D’Aurevilly’s baroness de Mascranny reclining on the sofa as if she were Cleopatra, or more ironically rendered yet exploring the same scheme, Witkacy’s Akne who lies on a sofa in a traditional pose and teases her admirer Bungo with her leg intentionally dressed in a black stocking and black shoe (Witkiewicz 1996: 133). By replacing beauty with ugliness, the salon with the garden, civilized and controlled poses with savage wild gestures, erotic passive attractiveness with sexual active selffulfillment, Schulz confronts his voyeur/spectator/reader with a scene which could hardly be accepted as pleasurable or alluring. The question he asks is no longer about what we want to see and who wants to be watched but is instead about what we refuse to see or realize. Schulz obviously does not ask his imaginary question in the manner of naturalism, but he instead confronts us with what we have already seen through using a pictorial screen. His device can be compared to grotesque devices introduced by the Polish modernistic writer Roman Jaworski (Historie maniaków / The Stories of Maniacs, 1910). In one of his stories he presents us with Honorcia, who has a disproportionately ugly body marked by warts and thin wisps of oily hair and seems to be a parody of the fin de siècle beauties, especially when her image is contrasted with well-known paintings. Honorcia, after her death, leaves her husband an unusual set of pictures called “the past tokens of the secret cabaret”. Among them, not surprisingly, are Goya’s Maja desunda, Rembrandt’s Danae, and Titian’s Venus
9 It seems as if two scenes known from Schulz’s graphics, the woman reclining on the bed and the woman standing up on her beautiful legs, were united in one movie-like sequence. When we look at Touya from this perspective, her “short legs” in contrast with “long legs” of women from the pictures become one more visible sign of aesthetic discussion.
“A (Wo)man on a Sofa”. Schulz as a “Painterly” and “Writerly” Artist
205
from Urbino (which itself is the proof of the diffusion of the tradition in the epoch). All pictures are less attractive and devoid of charm because the face of Honorcia was glued to all of them (Jaworski 1978: 118). Both Jaworski and Schulz do not create a grotesque representation of the world but a grotesque representation of the representations; they “glue” new pictures on those to which we were accustomed. Additionally, Schulz sets the pictures in motion using a cinema-like technique. The narrative character of his graphics turns into a real narration; the passive idol adored in a set of sequences becomes an active anti-idol playing its own game, still in front of the spectator/voyeur, present both inside and outside the scene. The artistic credo of The Idolatrous Book, which can be specified as the cult of the freedom of artistic expression aimed against the Old Testament ban on idolatry (Van Heuckelom 2007: 570), expands to the region of new transgressions; The Idolatrous Book (a set of pictures) indeed becomes a book (a story told). An analogy can be drawn between the manner in which Touya is presented and the way in which the pornographic cards are displayed to the young Joseph at the ending of the same story. The cards with pictures of “naked women and boys in strange positions” (“nagie kobiety i chopcy w dziwnych pozycjach”) are first watched by the boy “with distant, unseeing eyes” (“dalekimi, niewidz cymi oczyma”), then the moment of “sudden comprehension” (CW 14; “nage zrozumienie”; Op 12) inevitably comes. Both scenes seem to be good examples of “iconic intertextuality – an interplay of pictures and images” (Stala 1993: 102) because sexuality is shown through some medium, through cards, through pictures. In each case the moment of realization is needed. The realization of how pornography works, however, is not the realization of how art works. Touya on the bed in “her immobile frame” refers to other frames (although the word frame should not be seen as double-coded in Schulz’s text),10 to other pictures shaking them as she shakes the bed with her moves, and it is not so much the realization of our sexuality that we are faced with as the realization of how sexuality was (or was not) depicted. Because the well-known and widespread convention is subverted, the effect becomes staggering. 10
In the Polish sentence: “Muchy obsiadaj nieruchom g stym rojem” (8; “A dense swarm of flies gathers around the immobile [Touya]”), a frame does not appear.
206
Marta Skwara
It could be argued that the interpretation of the Touya scene is more or less disputable; the bed, for example, can be seen as too weak a link with the tradition. Had Touya been placed on the ground, it could be argued, not much would have changed. Nevertheless, Schulz avoids putting his models and heroines on the ground and seems to keep the sofa (bed) as the prop which gives him an opportunity to subvert social codes, especially salon codes (repeated in less majestic yet equally pretentious drawing rooms) and perhaps also, with an ironic wink, middle-class morality. What was ironically rendered by Flaubert as Madam Bovary’s enchantments with drawings on which ladies “lay on sofas […] gazing dreamily at the moon” (Flaubert 1995: 51) is one more convention which should be kept in mind while interpreting Schulz’s scenes. The element of Madam Bovary’s dreamlike life, ladies on sofas resting in salons, well-established both in literary and art depictions11 (at least Claude Monet’s Madame Monet on the Couch (1871) should be called to mind), is usually set apart from fine art representations of “reclining women” because it seems to be devoid of eroticism, yet the same prop – the sofa – is in operation here (which Toulouse-Lautrec masterfully used in In the Salon at Rue des Moulins (1894)). Let us see what Schulz did with that salon (drawing room) context. At the beginning of ‘Karakony’ (‘Cockroaches’) we find a mother who, suffering from a migraine (one more stereotypical sign of social codes), “was lying down on the sofa in the drawing room” (CW 65; “le aa na sofie w salonie”; Op 82) with her son sitting near. He was “absent-mindedly touching with two fingers the delicate fabric of her housecoat” (CW 66; “badaj c dwoma palcami, jakby w zamyleniu, delikatn materi jej szlafroka”; Op 82) while his conscious efforts were directed at learning what had happened to his father, whether he had been really transformed into the condor. The mother becomes embarrassed at the question and casts down her eyes. Nevertheless, after a moment, she starts to masterfully use all the tricks of a flirtatious woman: she blinks her eyes; her lips tremble lightly, then they swell but at the same time become smaller. It is no surprise that the son soon felt “she was being coy, like a woman with 11
Ladies on sofas are also well-established in readers’ imaginations as the cover of the popular edition quoted above seems to suggests; one can see a charming lady on a sofa looking straight into a future reader. Le Sphinx by James Tissot turns into Madame Bovary herself.
“A (Wo)man on a Sofa”. Schulz as a “Painterly” and “Writerly” Artist
207
a strange man” (CW 66; “[…], e mnie kokietuje, jak kobieta m czyzn ”; Op 83). As in the case of the Touya scene, there is also an element of movement in the salon scene. Like the black flies around Touya’s bed which rise in a buzzing cloud, the peacock’s feathers standing in a vase (the “frivolous element” (“element swawolny”) out of Adela’s control) do not stop “winking, fluttering their eyelashes” (CW 66; “robiy perskie oczko”; Op 82). That uncontrolled movement seems to suggest that something will be unsettled: in Touya’s case, it is our aesthetic sense whereas in the mother’s case, it is our moral sense. Schulz’s play goes far beyond a simple moral rebellion or a representation of what is really hidden beneath the salon games around a sofa, which can be demonstrated by evoking some literary contexts. Proust, commonly regarded as one of Schulz’s literary fathers (Brown 1991: 56-57), and his rendition of the intimate mother-son rendezvous by the bed, seems to be the most obvious literary context. Again, as in case of some of Schulz’s graphics, the elements which might be reversed by Schulz would be easy to indicate; instead of a nervous boy trying to keep his mother at his bed with his charming poses and small lies, we are presented with an ailing mother who pretends that she does not know the truth. She uses all her charm to distract the son from his duty, just as Proust’s son would use all his charm to distract his mother from her duty. In both cases, the intimate mother-son rendezvous by the bed is used against fathers (symbolizing the painful truth that one must grow up and accept the harsh reality). In Schulz’s scene the innocent child’s game was replaced with a villainous mother’s game, with the shift emphasized by the mother’s erotic attractiveness. Beyond this literary context (or beneath it) an archetypal situation emerges because it is the young Joseph who is being seduced. That Putifar’s wife, despite being older, was not a mother could be argued here but only while disregarding the arguments of Thomas Mann’s Mut. When Joseph tells her that his master Putifar is like a father to him and that sleeping with his wife would be like sleeping with his own mother, Mut ridicules his childishness announcing that “everybody sleeps with his mother” because a woman is “the mother of the world and her son is a man who begets in his mother” (“Mit der Muter schläft jeder […]. Das Weib ist die Mutter der Welt; ihr Sohn ist der Mann, und jeder Mann zeugt in der Mutter […]“ (Mann 1983: 511). Mut, like Schulz’s mother “with a bandage
208
Marta Skwara
round her head”, also bears the sign of illness, an intentionally hurt tongue (which she cut herself at the moment she thought about killing her husband, a thought of which Schulz’s Joseph also accuses his mother in the course of action), and most obviously, her attempts to seduce Joseph focus on drawing him into her bed. Both Josephs, Mann’s (or the biblical, see Schulz 1990: 114) and Schulz’s, protest with virtuous indignation in the name of their fathers. Seen from this angle, Schulz’s hero repeats the mythical story of failed seduction which is in accordance with one of the levels of Schulz’s programmatic “mythologizing of reality”: Nie ma okruszyny wród naszych idei, która by nie pochodzia z mitologii – nie bya przeobra on , okaleczon , przeistoczon mitologi . Najpierwotniejsz funkcj ducha jest bajanie, jest tworzenie “historyj”. Si motoryczn wiedzy ludzkiej jest przewiadczenie, e znajdzie ona na kocu swych bada ostateczny sens wiata. […] Ale elementy, których u ywa do budowy, ju byy raz u yte, ju pochodz z zapomnianych i u ytych “historyj”. (Op 366) (Not one scrap of an idea of ours does not originate in myth, isn’t transformed, mutilated, denatured mythology. The most fundamental function of the spirit is inventing fables, creating tales. The driving force of human knowledge is the conviction that at the end of its researches the sense of the world, the meaning of life, will be found. [T]he building materials it uses were used once before; they come from forgotten, fragmented tales or “histories”; Schulz 1990: 116)
Despite the fact that Schulz ironically transforms “the history”, rendering the seduction of Joseph as a salon game around a sofa, he makes the episode meaningful in the context of the whole story because at the end Joseph’s transformed father vanishes definitively while his mother eliminates and takes over the position of Adela the rival. By doing so, she makes her sexuality, which is strongly emphasized in the analyzed scene, triumphant. Despite its visibility, the scene with the mother attempting to seduce her son by “playing coy on a sofa” was not noticed by interpreters. Whether one reads the entry in Sownik schulzowski (The Schulz Dictionary; 2003: 210) or the whole article devoted to the image of the mother in Schulz’s prose (Kitowska-ysiak 2003: 351), the sexual connotations of the sofa scene are not evoked; perhaps the iconic and mythical layer of the scene had not been decoded (despite the obvious mythical connotation to Venus, so often represented in Schulz’s graphics and
“A (Wo)man on a Sofa”. Schulz as a “Painterly” and “Writerly” Artist
209
drawings, who was Cupid’s mother); or perhaps the interpreters had found the scene too unsettling. Having subverted our aesthetic and moral sense and having played with all the kitsch which attracts the readers for whom Madam Bovary is the immortal symbol, Schulz crosses one more line, that of gender. The creature on the sofa can be attractive not because she is a woman but because the poses and the sofa have had sexual connotations for ages. Whoever assumes the right pose in the convenient situation becomes sexually attractive. The salesman from the ‘Ulica krokodyli’ (‘The Street of Crocodiles’) story arranges “a sham comedy” as if illustrating Joseph’s father’s “extravagant concept of mimesis inverted” (Stala 1993: 102) introduced in ‘Druga jesie’ (‘A Second Autumn’); yet it is not nature that imitates art (or the expression of pure convention, “third- and fourth-rate painters”) but a human being. By manipulating a piece of cloth like “a screen ironically placed to hide the true meaning of things”, the salesman is not only a director but also an actor within that comedy, “prancing around like a transvestite” (CW 59; “przymila si i kryguje i chwilami robi wra enie transwestyty”; Op 74). His actions lead from trademarks on the material which embody just “transparent symbolism” into the realm of meanings marked by “the most peculiar trademarks” and “highly questionable” books and private editions. Once more we are faced with “books, drawings, photographs” symbolizing “the depths of corruption”. This time the private scene which took place between Joseph and his cousin in ‘August’ becomes more public, everyone who enters the shop is subjected to “varieties of licentiousness” manifested by visual objects; the change in narration, with “I” being replaced by “we”, emphasizes the common level of the experience which, with time, turns into a “general lasciviousness” (CW 60). At this point, the main actor changes his tactics from “active importuning” to “feminine passivity”; thus the subject becomes the object. His show culminates in a well-known display: “He now lay on one of the many sofas which stood between bookshelves, wearing a pair of deeply cut silk pyjamas” (CW 60; “Le y teraz na jednej z wielu kanap, porozstawianych wród rejonów ksi ek, w jedwabnej pi amie, odsaniaj cej kobiecy dekolt”; Op 75). The original says much more: his pyjamas expose “a female cleavage” (“kobiecy dekolt”). This small detail, omitted in translation, goes beyond the conventions of a
210
Marta Skwara
woman on a sofa; by adding it, Schulz enters a new realm of transgression: transsexuality. It seems it was easier (or perhaps safer) for Schulz to transgress the images created by words than those represented in pictures. No similar scene is to be found in Schulz’s drawings or graphics; it is always a woman who is placed on a sofa, though for a long time the tradition of fine arts has also known other representations (e.g. Giovanni Lanfranco, Young Boy on a Bed, c. 1620). Schulz’s transvestite also deviates from the well-established modernistic pattern of a hermaphrodite. Let us recall Huysmans’s famous Miss Urania, whose sex was being changed “artificially” in a single moment from a typical, lovely woman, through an androgynous phase, and finally to a complete man (Huysmans 1997: 145-146); in one of Witkacy’s dramas (Maciej Korbowa i Bellatrix, 1918), the hermaphrodite Bellatrix exhibits the same type of transformations. Schulz does not present us with a scene of a deliberate change of sex – which more or less belongs to the fantastic (grotesque) world to which hermaphrodites themselves belong (in ancient art often placed alongside satyrs) – but with the question of deliberately pretending to belong to the different sex. From the world of symbolic (mythical) figures, we move to the world of real (i.e., existing in the real world) attitudes, from symbols of ambiguous human nature to the real examples of such ambiguity.12 The sham comedy becomes an ironic play with our (our being emphasized in narration) modes of perception because the presentation takes the shape of a performance played in the theatre with well-known props: a sofa and various licentious pictures. If the woman on the sofa has always been used to attract attention in art (and in life), which can be easily accepted and agreed upon, then the easiest way of arousing the same interest is to assume the same pose. When Schulz’s transvestite does it (s)he does not subvert the convention itself but subverts our way of interpreting conventions and sexuality by fitting into the convention. (S)he becomes the center of attention but his/her pose is also that of the 12
Needless to say, it is a transvestite and not a hermaphrodite who became the cult figure of the late twentieth century and played a special role, for example, in the socalled “camp literature” for which Schulz’s sentence from the analyzed story could be a motto: “Reality is as thin as paper and betrays with all its cracks its imitative character” (CW 61; “Ta rzeczywisto jest cienka jak papier i wszystkimi szparami zdradza sw imitatywno”; Op 76).
“A (Wo)man on a Sofa”. Schulz as a “Painterly” and “Writerly” Artist
211
spectator; (s)he watches the girls who demonstrate the poses “of the drawings” in front of the sofa, while “the excited onlooker” is ignored. The performance becomes an inner one which is played regardless of our wishes; the convention goes on by itself. Escape is the only action one can take when confronted with ironically stripped iconic layers of our perception: “[W]e slip back into the street. No one stops us” (CW 61; “Skorzystajmy z tego momentu nieuwagi, a eby […] wydosta si
na ulic . Nikt nas nie zatrzymuje”; Op 75-76). The roles of actors and spectators, passive and active figures are inverted as well as gender roles in the spectacle traditionally played out in front of the sofa. Having subverted our aesthetic and moral sense, Schulz uses the same iconic pattern to subvert our sense of the sexes and their roles by shifting from literary modernistic patterns (hermaphrodite) to the theatre of life patterns (transvestite). All the elements discussed above seem to merge in the poses which Bianca assumes. In the 28th section of ‘Wiosna’ (‘Spring’), she is seen in “a shining, open landau as broad and shallow as a conch” (CW 150; “lni ca, otwarta landara z pudem szerokim i pytkim”; Op 174). “In that white, silk-lined shell” Bianca is “half-lying, in a tulle dress” (CW 150; “W tej biaej, jedwabnej muszli […] na wpó le c w tiulowej sukience”; Op 174). The aesthetics of this scene serve as an illustration of Huysmans’s Duke’s opinion on furniture which, with its shapes imitating the shapes that a woman’s body takes, would cloak the woman in the sinful atmosphere of the eighteenth century.13 What was the symbol of sin becomes in Schulz’s image the symbol of innocence, which is emphasized by the whiteness. However, the conch-shaped seat in which Bianca reclines evokes sexual connotations. The same shape is easy to find in Schulz’s drawing called Sadystki (1919); the tradition of using the shell shape dates back to Botticelli (Sownik schulzowski 2003: 231). The play between innocence and sin becomes more visible in Schulz’s illustrations of the scene, which directly allude to sexuality. In one of them Bianca’s legs are shown; in the other one she is naked, which clashes with the innocence of her pose in the conch. In the course of the story, during the night, her poses become even more ambivalent: from the conch she is moved to the bed, the whiteness of the day scene is replaced by
13 “[S]eul, en effet, le XVIIIe siècle a su envelopper la femme d’une atmosphère vicieuse, contournant les meubles selon la forme de ses charmes, imitant les contractions de ses plaisirs, les volutes de ses spasmes” (Huysmans 1997: 105).
212
Marta Skwara
the pink glow of the bed lamp. She “rests on enormous pillows” (CW 167; “spoczywa wród ogromnych poduszek”; Op 198), though in fact she sails on the bedding like on a night tide and the implied movement crosses the female passivity connected with the pose on the bed. Her power over the male spectator (Joseph again but this time in a role of a secretary, sometimes called “regent”) is symbolized by the conscious control of her glamour; flaws in her beauty seen from nearby disappear from a distance where her beauty “regenerates” and becomes unbearable (and from a distance is the only way of seeing the woman on the sofa). Bianca’s indifference is emphasized by her book reading, which irritates the busy secretary. Yet the only reaction he deserves is irony. Later, with a characteristic gesture, Bianca puts her pale arm under her head and mischievously plays the role of the capricious kid, who sends all important papers to the floor with one kick of her foot under the bedclothes. Again, as with many of Schulz’s graphics, we are presented with a scene in which the man is ruled by the female leg and finds himself below the woman, this time crouching and picking up papers. The scene, just like the Touya, the mother, and the transvestite scenes, is everything but a stable frame; the crazy rustle of the trees behind the open window “evoke in the room visions of landscapes” with “innumerable trees and bushes moving past the bed” (CW 168; “Coraz nowe odcinki lasu przesuwaj si i w druj , korowody drzew i krzewów, cae scenerie lene pyn , rozprzestrzeniaj c si przez pokój”; Op 200). This is only the beginning of the transformations as the bedroom changes into a compartment, “rolling slowly along a ravine in the wooded outskirts of the city” (CW 168; tocz cym si
wolno brzegiem parowu po lesistej okolicy miasta”; Op 200). Even a conductor with a lantern appears from nowhere and punches tickets with his machine. This surrealistic transformation is far from the plays one can find in Schulz’s pictures; it is as if the surrealistic domain was reserved (mainly) for his literary world. Nevertheless, the sense of “a bed scene” does not disappear as Bianca wriggles “like a lizard under her counterpane” (CW 169; “jak jaszczurka pod kodr ”; Op 200) before the last act of humiliation. Having accused Joseph of a betrayal (and having praised his rival Rudolf), she finally asks a surprising question: “Do you remember Lonka, the washerwoman Antonia’s daughter, with whom you played when you were small?” (CW 169; “Czy pami tasz Lonk , córk Antosi, praczki, z któr bawie si ,
“A (Wo)man on a Sofa”. Schulz as a “Painterly” and “Writerly” Artist
213
b d c may?”; Op 200) and answers it giggling: “It was I […] only I was a boy at that time. Did you like me then?” (CW 169; “To byam ja […] tylko, e byam jeszcze wówczas chopcem. Czy podobaam ci si wtedy?”; Op 200). The hermaphrodite motif comes back, and it does not seem to me that it is only a sign of Bianca’s androgyny (Sownik schulzowski 2003: 46-49), to which I will revert. The Bianca scene embodies the richest version of the “(wo)man on a sofa” scenes rendered in Schulz’s prose. It contains all the symbolic elements crucial for the iconographic scheme and transgresses them in the course of action: a majestic pose of a woman – high on pillows – changes into a series of a lizard-like movements; her characteristic gestures vary from expressions of indifference to exercises of power, including the characteristic movement of a leg. The figures of the men, in their different roles at the bed, are also multifariously evoked: a subdued man (who is the spectator of the display and the actor on whom the game is played), the figure of a rival (Rudolf), and a conductor whose status is surprisingly not that of another actor or spectator but that of a controller (who, in fact, cannot control anything). All of these elements are set in the interior of the bedroom which changes into a moving landscape. Just like the frame of the scene is unsettled, all the other categories are subverted: the moral (Bianca’s presupposed innocence is crossed by her betrayal), the aesthetic (her alluring beauty changes according to the distance), and the sexual (she is not the woman but the boy who became the woman). All of these elements can be linked to particular fine art and literary traditions or even sometimes to specific scenes. Bianca’s poses allude to a tradition from which various gestures were adopted and taken up in Schulz’s own art (the white arm under her head, the mischievously playful leg); the changes of objects and landscapes refer to a surrealistic tradition, such as the one built up by Kafka, for example. Yet, as Russell E. Brown (1991: 91) remarked, Kafka’s erotic scenes take place in the most inconvenient places, where floors or benches are much more conspicuous than beds; Bianca’s sadistic or at least hostile actions can be seen as an allusion to Sacher-Masoch’s stories, which are, however, devoid of any surrealistic devices (especially surrealistic lightness in the sense Italo Calvino spoke of in his American lectures). The two texts seem to be particularly in agreement with the Bianca scene and can be used to illuminate further interpretations. However, let us look once more at Schulz’s “literary
214
Marta Skwara
father”, Thomas Mann, and his heroine Clawdia Chauchat. At the beginning of the novel she is set typically in the center of the group, on the sofa and admired from a distance by Hans Castorp. At the culmination of his enchantment, during Walpurgis Night, later called “the additional time” (the Bianca scene takes place during an extra night, called “noc zamarginesowa”), the young admirer brings a soft armchair in which Clawdia adopts “almost a lying pose”. Although she places her knees too high, she still crosses her legs and keeps rocking one of them (the fact that it was dressed in a black stocking and a shining black shoe should not surprise us).14 It is no wonder that Hans ends up kneeling before her and declares his passionate love, only to be dismissed. Equally as capricious as Bianca, Clawdia also bears a similar sign of transsexuality; her eyes are the eyes of Prybislaw, the boy with whom Hans was infatuated as a youth. When we keep Prybislaw/Clawdia in mind, Bianca’s revelation that she was a boy once does not seem astonishing; her figure obviously goes beyond the mythical context of androgyny and enters the realm of literary dialogue. Mann’s Clawdia is also put on pillows in a sledge, first when she leaves the sanatorium with her compatriot, then when she comes back with Hans’s rival at her side. Perhaps it should not be surprising that the integral elements in Bianca’s appearance are all found in Mann’s story which is shaped by the same tradition though considerably condensed (to the length of two pages!), transformed, and put into a surrealistic domain, into Schulz’s specific world. Also, Marcel and Albertina should not be forgotten in the context of great love scenes in which a kneeling admirer is dismissed and humiliated by an indifferent woman lying on a bed. As Marcel approached too closely, he lost his balance and dared to try kissing the one who was only supposed to be watched (Proust 1991: 752-753). (Bianca, in her wisdom, spared her admirer that destructive closeness.) The humiliated Marcel at last conquers the object of his admiration during a “reverted scene” (as he himself says), when he lies down in a bed, and Albertina sits near. Perhaps that change of position turned him from the victim into the conqueror. Such a change never happens to Schulz’s Joseph who always remains on the verge of the sexual 14
“Sie ihrerseits lag allzu tief in dem Plüschgehänge, ihre Knie waren emporgehoben, doch schlug sie trotzdem das eine über das andere und ließ ihren Fuß in der Höhe wippen, dessen Knöchel über dem Rande des schwarzen Lackschuhs von der ebenfalls schwarzen Seide des Strumpfes überspannt war” (Mann 1981: 470).
“A (Wo)man on a Sofa”. Schulz as a “Painterly” and “Writerly” Artist
215
activities of an adult, while retaining the timidity and diffidence of a middle-class child (Brown 1991: 60). Conclusion Regardless of how many contexts of a particular motif one can indicate,15 trying to fulfill the encyclopedic Stoffgeschichte task, the way in which Schulz uses well-known art and literary motifs, has less to do with intertextuality between specific works than with the entire cultural code comprised of discourses, stereotypes, clichés, and various modes of artistic and literary representations. Schulz’s astonishing ability to transgress them makes his text a “writerly” one in Barthes’s sense – the text of bliss that “imposes a state of loss, the text that discomforts (perhaps to the point of certain boredom), unsettles the reader’s historical, cultural, psychological assumptions, the consistency of his tastes, values, memories […]” (Barthes 1975: 14). Because of this, Schulz’s works will always seem to be simultaneously similar to a particular tradition and different from it16 as his constant play with well-established literary and fine art images is far from being limited. For the same reason, his texts remain modern and seductive, especially because they deal with the theatre of love we all share, the theatre in which a woman who is watched and admired and a man who watches and admires her have played their (and not only their) parts for ages. Schulz puts us all in the position of spectators/voyeurs – not only in his art but also in his writing – and does not allow us to forget that we are voyeurs of some higher degree;
15 One could also ask about the traditions which are not evoked, like women dying in beds, as it often happens in Poe’s stories, especially since Poe is one of a few writers evoked by name in Schulz’s prose though he is characteristically mistaken for Baudelaire. Illness and death are not connected with a woman in neither Schulz’s stories nor his pictures; the other tradition of a man in bed, ill and dying, could be explored instead. 16 In the case of the motif discussed it could be said that Schulz resembles Kafka while employing surrealistic transformations yet not while applying an iconic layer, or that he seems to be close to Proust’s autobiographical narration yet goes much further in the transgressions of salon codes; or that he is close to Mann when reaching for an archetypal layer while being more ironic; or that he delves into the world of art like Huysmans and Kubin (and that his Crocodile Street reminds one of Huysmans’s Rivoli Street or Kubin’s French district) yet is more deeply embedded in the world of nature; or that, at last, he alludes to Sacher-Masoch’s stories while operating on a level which goes far beyond set stereotypes.
216
Marta Skwara
we are the spectators of scenes watched before and witnessed many times in many different circumstances, both in art and literature as well as in life. In a masterful way, he makes us see them differently, not beside the broad tradition but through it and beyond it, with new meanings to be discovered. In his many drawings and graphics, from simple sketches to complex scenes, Schulz seems to practice his ability of unsettling our assumptions by playing with well-known elements and displacing them (as it happens with a book which is no longer reserved for a woman on a sofa) rather than by transgressing conventions; in this sense his art could be called a “painterly” one. In his published books, not accidentally limited to two collections of perfectly wrought short stories, he transgresses both conventions and our expectations.17 Annette Lavers’s definition of the “writerly” text seems to suit Schulz’s world perfectly; his text “has to be created anew in each reader, the observer being part of the observed” (Lavers 1982: 202). The mode, however, in which Schulz creates his world is far from postmodern free play. Despite the fact that he witnesses the bankruptcy of reality, the “ever-present atmosphere of the stage, of sets viewed from behind, where the actors make fun of the pathos of their parts after stripping off their costumes” (Schulz 1990: 113; “atmosfera kulis, tylnej strony sceny, gdzie aktorzy po zrzuceniu kostiumów zamiewaj si z patosu swych ról”; Op 445) – the varieties of the “(wo)man on a sofa” scenes seem to illustrate this excellently – he also constantly searches for “primeval patterns”, “stories”, “matrices of myth” out of which he creates his own private mythology, and this is what has to be created in each reader anew, the reader being part of the reading. Bibliography Barthes, Roland. 1975. The Pleasure of the Text (tr. R. Miller). New York: Hill and Wang. Bolecki, Wodzimierz. 1994. ‘Witkacy-Schulz, Schulz-Witkacy’ in Jarz bski, Jerzy (ed.) Czytanie Schulza. Kraków: Instytut Filologii Polskiej UJ: 127-151.
17
Schulz himself put it this way: “A drawing sets narrower limits by its material than prose does. That is why I feel I have expressed myself more fully in my writing.” (Schulz 1990a: 112; “Rysunek zakrela cianiejsze granice swym materiaem ni proza. Dlatego s dz , e w prozie wypowiedziaem si peniej”; Op 443-444).
“A (Wo)man on a Sofa”. Schulz as a “Painterly” and “Writerly” Artist
217
Brown, Russell E. 1991. Myths and Relatives. Seven Essays on Bruno Schulz. München: Verlag Otto Sagner. Flaubert, Gustave. 1995. Madame Bovary (tr. T. Russell). London: Penguin. Ficowski, Jerzy. 1988. ‘Introduction’ in Schulz, Bruno. Xiga Bawochwalcza (ed. J. Ficowski). Warsaw: Interpress: 5-54. Ficowski, Jerzy. 1998, ‘Introduction to Drawings’ in Schulz (1998): 505-522. Huysmans, Joris-Karl. 1997. À rebours. (ed. D. Mortier). Paris: Pocket. Jaworski, Roman. 1978. Historie maniaków. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie. Kitowska-ysiak, Magorzata. 2003. ‘Matka wychodzi z cienia’ in Kitowska-ysiak, Magorzata and Wadysaw Panas (eds). W uamkach zwierciada…Bruno Schulz w 110 rocznic urodzin i 60 rocznic mierci. Lublin: Towarzystwo Naukowe KUL: 341-355. Lavers, Annette. 1982. Roland Barthes: Structuralism and After. London: Methuen. Lucie-Smith, Edward. 1995. Sexuality in Western Art. London: Thames and Hudson. Mann, Thomas. 1981. Der Zauberberg. Frankfurt am Main: Fischer Verlag. ——. 1983. Joseph und seine Brüder III. Frankfurt am Main: Fischer Verlag. Proust, Marcel. 1991. A la recherche du temps perdu. A l’ombre des jeunes filles en fleurs. (ed. J. Yoshida). Paris: Éditions Robert Laffont, S.A. Schulz, Bruno. 1989. Opowiadania. Wybór esejów i listów (ed. J. Jarz bski). Wrocaw: Zakad Narodowy im. Ossoliskich. ——. 1990. ‘An Essay for S. I. Witkiewicz’; ‘The Mythologizing of Reality’ in Letters and Drawings of Bruno Schulz with Selected Prose (ed. J. Ficowski, tr. W. Arndt and V. Nelson). New York: Fromm International Publishing Corporation: 110-114, 115-117. ——. 1992. Bruno Schulz 1892-1942: Rysunki i archiwalia ze zbiorów Muzeum Literatury im. Adama Mickiewicza w Warszawie (ed. W. Chmurzyski). Warszawa: Muzeum Literatury im. Adama Mickiewicza w Warszawie. ——. 1998. The Collected Works of Bruno Schulz (ed. J. Ficowski). London: Picador. Sownik schulzowski. 2003. (ed. W. Bolecki et al.) Gdask: sowo/obraz terytoria. Stala, Krzysztof. 1993. On the Margins of Reality: the Paradoxes of Representation in Bruno Schulz’s Fiction. Stockholm: Almqvist & Wiksell International. Van Heuckelom, Kris. 2007. ‘Koncepcja idolatrii w twórczoci Brunona Schulza z punktu widzenia studiów wizualnych’ in Czermiska, Magorzata et al. (eds). Literatura, kultura i jzyk polski w kontekstach i kontaktach wiatowych. Pozna: Wydawnictwo Naukowe UAM: 563-571. Witkiewicz, Stanisaw Ignacy. 1990. ‘Interview with Bruno Schulz’ in: Letters and Drawings of Bruno Schulz. With Selected Prose: (ed. J. Ficowski, tr. W. Arndt and V. Nelson). New York: Fromm International Publishing Corporation: 107-110. ——. 1996. 622 upadki Bunga, czyli Demoniczna kobieta. (ed. A. Miciska). Warszawa: PIW.
The Early Graphic Works of Bruno Schulz and SacherMasoch’s Venus in Furs: Schulz as a Modernist Ariko Kato Abstract: This article discusses the early graphic works of Bruno Schulz in relation to Leopold von Sacher-Masoch’s novel Venus im Pelz (Venus in Furs, 1870). First, it demonstrates that some pictures from Xiga bawochwalcza (The Idolatrous Book) were inspired by Sacher-Masoch’s novel. Second, it illustrates the similarity between Schulz and Sacher-Masoch with regard to the issue of mimesis. Finally, based on an examination of the reception of Sacher-Masoch’s works and the popularity of Freudian theory in Polish-speaking circles prior to WWII, the essay reconsiders the “Schulz-masochist” discourse that was first proposed in the 1930s.
Introduction This article discusses the early graphic works of Bruno Schulz in relation to Leopold von Sacher-Masoch’s novel Venus im Pelz (Venus in Furs, 1870). Edmund Löwenthal’s remembers that Schulz made illustrations for Sacher-Masoch’s Venus in Furs by using the technique of cliché-verre (Schulz 1984: 55).1 Jerzy Ficowski, who included this reminiscence in his books on Schulz, regarded Schulz’s explanation to be a mere camouflage to hide his real nature, which was apparent in his graphics (Ficowski 1986: 32; 2002: 246). The reminiscence has been largely ignored and little attention has been paid to Sacher-Masoch’s novels in discussions on Schulz’s works.2 In general, Schulz’s graphic works that portray a specific conceptualization of women and men (e.g., Xiga bawochwalcza) are described as “masochistic” or “sadomasochistic”, which has caused 1
Löwenthal was a friend of Schulz’s nephew who lived with Schulz in Drohobycz. An exception is Nella Cassouto, who briefly reminded of this reminiscence and admitted the influence of Sacher-Masoch’s novel on Schulz’s works (1990: 22-27). Krystyna Kulig-Janarek also made reference to Venus in Furs in her article on the graphic works of Schulz (1994: 155).
2
220
Ariko Kato
confusion between his own life and the subjects in his works.3 Schulz’s early graphic works are often regarded as an output of his hidden sexuality; alternatively, the graphic works are viewed as if they were created as illustrations for his later novels. In accordance with the stereotypical views of Schulz as a masochist, Sacher-Masoch’s name tends to be taboo in any discussion on Schulz. Discussions of Schulz’s graphic works have often centered on the subjects in his works, without considering the years of production. In this article, I will concentrate on his works produced in the 1910s and 20s, before his literary debut, in order to uncover common features in his early graphics and later prose. First, I will compare the images in Xiga bawochwalcza (The Idolatrous Book) with the text of Venus in Furs in order to examine Löwenthal’s reminiscence. Second, by focusing on the self-referential motif in the early graphics of Schulz and Sacher-Masoch’s novel and the manner in which mythological motifs are adapted in them, I will present the common concerns of Schulz and Sacher-Masoch with regard to the issue of mimesis. Finally, I will suggest a reconsideration of the post-1930 discourse on “Schulz-masochist”, based on an examination of the reception given to Sacher-Masoch’s works and the popularity of Freudian theory in Polish-speaking circles before World War II. The last examination supports my assumption that Schulz, who could also read German, was influenced by Venus in Furs. Based on the entire discussion, I will present Sacher-Masoch as an important figure in the study of Schulz’s works and Schulz as a modernist whose works took up important issues with regard to artistic representation. Comparison of The Idolatrous Book with Venus in Furs: Undula/Wanda To begin with, I compare The Idolatrous Book with the text of Venus in Furs. In Venus in Furs, the physical appearance of the heroine, 3
Irena Kossowska and ukasz Kossowski (2002: 26) also suggested distinguishing between what was represented in Schulz’s images from the life of the artist. There are many academic articles on his graphic works. Krystyna Kulig-Janarek (1993) has provided iconological analyses. Jan Gondowicz (2006) has discussed Schulz’s graphic works in the wide contexts of culture and history. Cf. also Kitowska-ysiak (1994b, 2002) and Kasjaniuk (1993) for in-depth discussions of Schulz’s graphic works.
The Early Graphic Works of Schulz and Sacher-Masoch’s Venus in Furs
221
Wanda, is introduced to the readers as a figure portrayed in a picture. The narrator describes the image as follows: A beautiful woman, with a sunny smile on her fine face, with rich, classically knotted hair covered with white powder like soft frost: naked in a dark fur, she reclined on a sofa, leaning on her left arm, her right hand playing with a whip, her bare foot casually propped on the man, who lay before her like a slave, like a dog. And this man, who revealed salient but well-shaped features infused with brooding melancholy and devoted passion, this man, who peered up at her with the burning, enraptured eyes of a martyr, this man, who served as a footstool for her feet – this man was Severin, but beardless and apparently ten years younger. (2000: 8)4
Krystyna Kulig-Janarek (1994: 155) also cited this depiction to draw similarities between Venus in Furs and The Idolatrous Book. This image of Wanda, depicted three times in Venus, agrees with the portrayal of the woman named Undula5 in Schulz’s The Idolatrous Book. The Idolatrous Book is a portfolio comprised of ten or more cliché-verre works. The selection of cliché-verre works is different in each portfolio. Jerzy Ficowski (2002: 252-253), the pioneering scholar on Schulz and the editor of Schulz’s graphic albums in Poland and abroad, wrote that Schulz signed his name and sometimes provided a title under his graphics. In addition, Schulz sometimes gave a different title to the same picture. Through my investigations,6 I noticed that the graphics included in a set of The Idolatrous Book owned by the National Museum of Krakow (NMK), along with some of the graphics 4
All further references to the English text of Venus im Pelz will be given as ViF. The Polish translation of the fragment does not closely follow the original and interestingly lends a sadomasochistic tone to the scene (Sacher-Masoch 1989: 24), as will be discussed below. 5 The drawing reprinted in 1930, in the second issue of Cusztajer (Gift), a Yiddish journal published in Lviv, is similar to that known as ‘Zaczarowane miasto’ (‘The Enchanted City’) in The Idolatrous Book; however, it is titled as ‘Undula oyfn shpatsir’ (‘Undula Takes a Walk’) though the women are not similar to Undula. It seems that Undula was the name that was symbolically used by Schulz for the heroine in his graphics even after The Idolatrous Book. 6 I examined the copies of The Idolatrous Book that are in the National Museum of Warsaw (NMW), the National Museum of Krakow (NMK), the Library of Jagiellonian University (JU), and the Museum of Literature in Warsaw (ML). I thank the curators of these museums for their timely help and suggestions, as well as Krystyna Kulig-Janarek, a curator of NMK, for the detailed information with regard to the issue of the titles and signatures of Schulz’s graphics.
222
Ariko Kato
included in The Idolatrous Book owned by the National Museum of Warsaw (NMW), and the Museum of Literature (ML), are entitled and signed by Schulz. Moreover, a frontispiece of the set owned by the NMW presents a list of titles, although the list does not completely correspond with the contents (Kitowska-ysiak 2003: 420). However, from the titles of these graphics, we can identify the female figure that appears in several graphics as Undula. In this article, I limit my discussion to those graphics wherein the described titles or circumstances indicate that the heroine is Undula. The pose of Wanda described in the above quotation is represented in the image of Undula. Schulz’s graphic entitled ‘Jeszcze raz Undula’ (‘Undula, Once Again’ [il. 1, ML]) depicts Undula sitting on a bed, with her foot on the neck of a man. ‘Xi ga bawochwalcza’ (‘The Idolatrous Book’ [il. 2, NMK]) shows Undula7 reclining on a bed with a whip.8 We should also not overlook the conformity of their hairstyles (‘awka’ (‘Bench’ [il. 3, NMW]), ‘Undula, Once Again’ and ‘Undula u artystów’ (‘Undula with the Artists’ [il. 4, NMW])9. Some of the women in The Idolatrous Book, including Undula, tie their hair in a knot, sometimes with a ribbon, which Jan Gondowicz (2006: 66) described as “à la grecque”. In fact, the “classically knotted” (ViF 8) hairstyle of Wanda in the portrait, described later, is fastened with a green ribbon.10 Given the contextual backdrop, we also discern that the hairstyle is similar to that of the statue of Venus.11 Incidentally, this knotted hairstyle was commonly used for goddesses in European paintings on mythological narratives. 7
The Idolatrous Book possessed by the NMK includes two pictures portraying the same woman with a hat. Schulz entitles them as ‘Undula w nocy’ (‘Undula at Night’) and ‘Xi ga bawochwalcza’. We can guess, based on the former title, that the woman in the latter picture is Undula as well. 8 The woman in ‘Jej garderobiana’ (‘The Dresser’ [il. 16, NMW]) also poses in a similar manner. 9 In the Polish version, however, there is no description of Wanda’s hairstyle but a description of fur that is “rich and dark” (“futrem o obfitym ciemnym wosie”; Sacher-Masoch 1989: 24). 10 “[Wanda] then had me tie her heavy, electric hair into a large chignon held together by the green velvet ribbon” (ViF 90). 11 In the opening pages, the narrator dreams that he talks with a living statue of Venus wearing fur in the cold North Country. Awoken by a servant, the narrator then visits Severin and finds the portrait of Wanda, who is exactly like the Venus of whom he dreamt.
The Early Graphic Works of Schulz and Sacher-Masoch’s Venus in Furs
223
Let us compare the picture called ‘Bench’12 with a scene in Venus in Furs. The woman in this picture resembles Undula, who is explicitly represented in other pictures (for example, ‘Undula, once Again’). The hero Severin proposes to Wanda: “[…] If you can't be a decent, faithful wife, then be a devil.” […] I no longer know what I said, but I do recall that I kissed her feet and finally picked up her foot and placed it on the nape of my neck. (ViF 39)
This scene takes place in a park and “she [Wanda] sat down on one of the stone benches” (ViF 39). The picture ‘Bench’ completely agrees with this scene. This is the only picture that has the background drawn in the real view, which strengthens the assumption that the depiction is based on Venus in Furs. Moreover, a man kissing or throwing himself at a woman’s feet is typical in Schulz’s graphics while Severin also frequently adopts this pose. ‘The Idolatrous Book’ depicts a man sitting at Undula’s feet and reading a book to her. In fact, Venus in Furs has many scenes in which Severin reads a book to Wanda. For instance, “I [Severin] sat down at her feet and read her a little poem that I had penned for her” (ViF 22). In addition, a poem titled ‘Venus im Pelz (‘Venus in Furs’) begins as follows: “Gracious, devilish, mythical lady. / Put your foot upon your slave […]” (ViF 23). The picture titled ‘Undula w nocy’ (‘Undula at Night’ [il. 5, NMK]) and the one identified with the title ‘Undula idzie w noc’ (‘Undula Walks into the Night’ [il. 6, NMW])13 depict a man respectfully accompanying Undula. These pictures can also be understood with reference to the novel. Severin plays the part of Wanda’s servant and follows her during a trip to Florence. In one of these scenes, Wanda wears a Russian hat and attracts attention on the street, which is consistent with Undula’s depiction in the second of the two pictures. It is important to note that at the beginning of the novel, Wanda was Severin’s witty and tender lover; he was the one who awakened her latent demonic character and urged her to behave cruelly with him. Among the women portrayed in The Idolatrous Book, Undula is the only one who has such a sympathetic expression
12 The picture ‘Bench’ owned by the NMW is not titled by the author (it only bears his signature). 13 This picture is not titled by the author (it only bears his signature).
224
Ariko Kato
which contrasts to her masterful pose. Moreover, she and Zuzanna are the only two recurring figures in The Idolatrous Book to be given names. It is true that Schulz’s images do not always have a one-to-one correspondence with the novel; however, his graphics, which he created for his novels in the 1930s, reveal to us that what he termed “illustrations” were not precise visualizations of a concrete scene. The moderate appearance of the image of fur might be explained simply by the disagreement with the artist’s intention or by the technical difficulty in representing fur in black-and-white cliché-verre works. In fact, it is rather difficult to distinguish fur-like objects from a background of black shadows.14 Based on this analysis, we can validate Löwenthal’s reminiscence about some images in The Idolatrous Book. The graphics depicting Undula have many similarities with the descriptions in Venus in Furs; so much so that Undula can be considered to represent Wanda. ‘Bench’ and Undula’s images are directly inspired by Venus in Furs and were supposed to be illustrations for this novel. The question that remains to be asked is whether Schulz designed these graphics as part of an order for the publication of Sacher-Masoch’s Venus in Furs or created them of his own accord. The Idolatrous Book is thought to have been produced around the years 1920 to 1922. Meanwhile, the Polish version of Venus was first published in Lviv in 1913, with the second edition also published in Lviv in 1919.15 Incidentally, neither of these publications have illustrations except for a picture of a slender woman in a fur coat and a fur hat on the cover of the second edition, though it is drawn in a style different from that of Schulz. Little is known about his life in those years, yet it is more likely that he created these illustrations for this novel of his own accord, before his debut as a graphic artist. In either case, it is likely that the reissue of the Polish version of this novel 14
We can find the depiction of fur in ‘Plemi pariasów’ (‘Tribe of Pariahs’). Black shadows of ‘Undula, Once Again’ and ‘The Idolatrous Book’ look like fur, though this remains no more than speculation. In other pictures, only fur-like articles on women’s costumes are found. 15 The reissue, from 1989, provides its original as that published in 1920 by the same publisher (Sacher-Masoch 1989); however, I could not find this edition.
The Early Graphic Works of Schulz and Sacher-Masoch’s Venus in Furs
225
gave Schulz, who could also read German, the idea to create illustrations for this novel. Similar Concerns between Schulz and Sacher-Masoch: The Issue of Artistic Representation After comparing Schulz’s images with the descriptions from SacherMasoch’s novel, let us now examine the usage of the mythological motif of Venus and the representation of art in Schulz’s graphics made in the 1910s and 1920s and Sacher-Masoch’s Venus in Furs. These works are usually regarded as representing masochistic motifs in a naturalistic style; in reality, they addressed the issue of mimesis from a modernistic perspective. As the title Venus in Furs indicates, the goddess Venus is the central motif in the novel. It is important to note that Wanda represents the pagan world of the “South” as opposed to the Christian world of the “North” to which Severin – a Galician landlord – belongs. Wanda is the modern personification of goddess Venus. Their romance represents the encounter between ancient spirituality and modern Christian spirituality. Not just Wanda’s mentality but also her looks are compared to those of Venus. The German painter who painted Wanda’s portrait, quoted in the first section of this article, explained that he imagined the Goddess of Love, who has left Mount Olympus and descended for the sake of a mortal man in the modern world (ViF 93). He explains his understanding of the portrait as follows: “Like many paintings of the Venetian school, this should be both a portrait and a narrative”; (ViF 92; “Das Bild soll, wie viele der venezianischen Schule, zugleich ein Porträt und eine Historie werden”; Sacher-Masoch 1980: 109; italics mine). The German painter’s idea of the portrait reminds us of historical paintings that visualize mythological, biblical, or historical narratives. In De pictura (On Painting, 1435), which served as one of the seminal works on European painting until the end of the nineteenth century, Renaissance theoretician Leon Battista Alberti proposed the notion of istoria as paintings of a new age. He discussed in detail the characteristics of the concept, which refers to a depiction of an event largely extracted from an ancient written source, and the way to realize it. He regarded istoria as “the greatest work of the painter, in which there ought to be copiousness and elegance in all things” (Alberti 1976: 95). Referring
226
Ariko Kato
to the mythological narrative, the German painter therefore follows the tradition of istoria and the later historical painting; however, by modifying the concept that was originally supposed to depict “high” literature and featuring a secular woman’s portrait instead, he creates a new narrative in his painting. This idea of the painter also agrees with that of Schulz. The Greek mythological motifs in Schulz’s early graphics have already been pointed out.16 As a matter of fact, some of the women presented in these graphics, not only from The Idolatrous Book, have iconographic references to goddess Venus. We find several attributes of Venus: Amor17 and Shell18. Schulz even drew two pencil sketches (‘Venus and Amor’ and ‘Venus and Amor [II]’, both before 1933 [il. 10, il. 11, ML) whose compositions were similar to that of Velázquez’s ‘Venus at Her Mirror’. In addition, some picture titles in The Idolatrous Book contain references to goddess Venus – ‘Wiosna’ (‘Spring’), ‘wi to wiosny’ (‘Rite of Spring’), and ‘Na Cyterze’ (‘On Cythera’ [il. 13]).19 Venus is associated with spring in historical paintings (Battistini 2005: 34-35), and the island Cythera was the place where Venus drifted after her birth. This picture depicts a woman who has just arrived, which agrees with this mythological plot.20 Schulz thus compares the woman to the goddess in his early graphics. However, many of the women represented in the early graphics of Schulz, including the above three works from The 16
The important articles on this topic include the following: Kulig-Janarek (1993), Kitowska-ysiak (1994c). Kitowska-ysiak (1994c: 255) also pointed out the inspiration of the myth of Venus in Schulz’s graphics. 17 ‘Swawolne kobiety’ (‘Playful Women’, 1916 [il. 7]), ‘Autoportret przy pulpicie rysowniczym’ (‘Self-portrait Before an Easel’, 1919 [il. 8]), ‘Odwieczna ba’ (‘The Eternal Fairy Tale’, from The Idolatrous Book [il. 9]), ‘Wenus i Amor’ and ‘Wenus i Amor (II)’, both before 1933 [il. 10, il. 11]). 18 ‘Self-portrait before an Easel’ and ‘Kobiety, sadystki’ (‘Women, Sadists’, 1919 [il. 12]). The same remark is also found in Kulig-Janarek’s article (1994: 155). 19 The following are the three graphics that Schulz gave titles to: ‘Wiosna’ (‘Spring’ [NMK]), ‘wi to wiosny’ (‘Rite of Spring’ [NMW]), and ‘Na Cyterze’ (‘On Cythera’ [NMW]). 20 This picture also literally visualizes what Wanda says: “But the person who wants pleasure….mustn’t shy away from indulging at other people’s expense, he must never feel pity. He must harness others to his carriage, to his plow like animals” (ViF 115). However, we cannot regard it as a direct inspiration of Sacher-Masoch’s novel because this type of image of men harnessed to a carriage was popular in Europe since the latter half of the nineteenth century. Cf. Noyes (1997), especially chapter 4, for a discussion of this topic.
The Early Graphic Works of Schulz and Sacher-Masoch’s Venus in Furs
227
Idolatrous Book, are dressed in modern clothes if they are not naked. Moreover, the backgrounds in these pictures convey the impression that the scenes depicted take place in modern times. Both SacherMasoch and Schulz compared the woman to Venus; however, they transferred the subject to modern settings and adopted the motif, which was taken from the original mythological context, in a manner that enabled them to recreate history on their own. In this way, Schulz’s graphics and the portrait of Wanda in Venus in Furs remodelled the history of Venus; in modern contexts, Venus appeared as a cruel woman with a whip, reflecting the zeitgeist of the modern period. It seems that Schulz consciously challenged and parodied historical paintings, which were considered the highest form of art. An example is ‘Self-portrait Before an Easel’ (1919 [il. 8]). It depicts two framed paintings hung on the wall against which the artist, Schulz, stands before an easel. These two paintings parody religious and mythological paintings. In one of the paintings, a man dressed in a monk’s habit is shown kneeling down similar to what is shown in the religious paintings; however, he is not kneeling before Christ or the Madonna but before a naked woman. In the other image, the motif of Judith is adopted and mingled with that of Venus. A naked woman with a smiling face is sitting on the edge of an open shell, which is filled with a black, blood-like liquid. The head of a man lies at her feet. Two women hold his headless body at the other side of the shell’s edge. These examples prove Schulz’s sound knowledge of mythological and biblical motifs in the tradition of European paintings and his critical reconsideration of its conventions. Apart from parodying historical paintings, Sacher-Masoch and Schulz also questioned the conventional understanding of works of art as imitative representations of nature or narrative. Schulz’s ‘Autoportret ze Stanisawem Weingartenem’ (‘Self-portrait with Stanisaw Weingarten’, 1921 [il. 14]) presents the elements related to a picture at different levels: the artist gazing directly at viewers; the portrayed person; the works of plastic art (pictures, sculptures); models or figures represented in a picture; and a picture frame drawn on the edge of the mat board on which the “main” drawing is glued. The drawing is shown as a painting whose composition adopts the common juxtaposition of the images of a man and his dreams or the divine revelation in historical paintings of biblical narratives.
228
Ariko Kato
However, this juxtaposition fulfills a role that is different from those fulfilled by historical paintings depicting biblical stories. It takes up a theoretical question on representation in the work of art. According to Alberti,21 a figure looking at viewers in traditional narrative paintings sometimes plays a role in calling our attention to a picture. In this drawing, the artist, Schulz, standing in the back and gazing at viewers, plays this role. The drawn Schulz indicates that he depicted all human figures that were supposed to belong to different levels – the artist, the person portrayed, posing models or figures represented in a picture – simply as represented figures in a plan. After the traditional composition of historical painting, Schulz paradoxically questions the ground on which it stands and rejects the traditional understanding of works of art as an imitative representation of nature or narrative.22 In addition, in Venus in Furs, the motif of works of art is scattered and shows a similar view on art.23 The figure of Venus appears in various forms – as a plaster sculpture, as a figure in a picture, and as the heroine Wanda. This also reminds us of ‘Undula with the Artists’ from The Idolatrous Book. Venus in Furs is a frame story, consisting of two narratives by two narrators at two different times – narration in the present time frames the manuscript written by Severin about the past episodes between him and Wanda. This structure enables the story to develop in a manner such that it gives the reader the illusion that reality imitates artistic representation.24 Moreover, by using language to describe visual art, the distinctions between reality and representation in art and between the original and
21 “In an istoria I like to see someone who admonishes and points out to us what is happening there; or beckons with his hand to see; or menaces with an angry face and with flashing eyes, so that no one should come near; or shows some danger or marvellous thing there; or invites us to weep or to laugh together with them. Thus whatever the painted persons do among themselves or with the beholder, all is pointed toward ornamenting or teaching the istoria” (Alberti 1976: 78). 22 Kris Van Heuckelom (2006) discussed The Idolatrous Book as an embodiment of artistic crossover of the verbal and the visual. 23 I owe the inspiration to consider the issue of representation in Leopold von SacherMasoch’s works to the following studies: Hirano (2004) and Tanemura (2004). 24 Severin even confesses that Wanda reminds him of the legend of the sculptor Pygmalion, whose statue of a woman came to life: “Yes, she had to come alive for me, like that statue that had started breathing for her creator” (ViF 15).
The Early Graphic Works of Schulz and Sacher-Masoch’s Venus in Furs
229
copy are suspended.25 This novel challenges the basic understanding of artworks as a copy of reality. As mentioned earlier, in Venus in Furs, there are three depictions of Wanda’s portrait: first, as a portrait through the narrator’s eyes; second, as an actual occurrence between Wanda and Severin; and finally, the scene in which they again pose before the German painter who made the portrait in the first depiction.26 After the second depiction of Wanda’s image in the novel, Severin found their image reflected in a mirror: […] she, placing her one foot upon me as if on a footstool, rested on the cushions in the large velvet mantle. The supple fur lasciviously snuggled around her cold marble body, and her left arm, on which she propped herself like a slumbering swan, remained in the dark sable of the sleeve, while her right27 hand carelessly played with the whip. I [Severin] happened to glance at the massive mirror on the opposite wall and I cried out, for I saw us in its golden frame as if in a painting […] (ViF 90-91; italics mine)
This scene clearly reflects Sacher-Masoch’s awareness of the issue of mimesis. He suspends the clear distinction between reality and artistic representation. Furthermore, the scene captures the moment of the birth of an artwork; here, a real-life scene has been transformed into an image through the eyes of a man who has defamiliarized reality. In the above quotation, the frame of the mirror is a device that encourages us to notice the boundary between a plan of a picture and its external environment. In this scene, the frame might be a part of the picture; however, at the same time, it belongs to the external world. This scene, therefore, reminds us of the concept of parergon that Jacques Derrida renewed based on Kant’s Kritik der Urteilskraft (The Critique of Judgment). As observed above, Schulz’s graphics ‘Self-portrait with Stanisaw Weingarten’ and ‘Self-portrait before an Easel’ also present picture frames. In the former, Schulz represented the ambiguity of the frame as a parergon in concord with Derrida’s 25
Incidentally, suspension is a key term in Gilles Deleuze’s study on Sacher-Masoch (1998). 26 “Wanda, dressed only in the sable and clutching the whip, came downstairs and once more stretched out on the velvet cushions. I lay at her feet, and she put one foot on me while her right hand played with the whip” (ViF 92). 27 “Left” in the German original.
230
Ariko Kato
meaning. Moreover, he makes the viewers aware of the system on which their reception of the painting relies.28 We observed in this chapter that Sacher-Masoch and Schulz share a similar modernist concern with regard to the issue of mimesis. In their stylistically naturalistic works, they questioned the conventions of traditional European paintings after the Renaissance and tried to represent this issue in their own way. Analysis of Schulz’s early graphics leads us to believe that he was well-versed in European paintings. His later career as an art teacher at the local gymnasium supports this view. Thus his stay in Vienna during World War I, before he made the abovementioned graphics, also becomes meaningful. Based on his knowledge of the European paintings from the Renaissance to the first period of modernism, Schulz critically reconsidered the conventions used in historical paintings and the issue of representation in this tradition, consciously raising relevant issues in his graphics. Reception of Sacher-Masoch’s Novel in the Polish-Speaking Sphere before World War II I would like to focus further on how Sacher-Masoch’s novels were introduced into the Polish-speaking sphere prior to World War II.29 A reconstruction of the common perception of Sacher-Masoch in that period helps us to reconsider the unquestioned discourses presenting Schulz as a masochist. Until the end of World War I, south-eastern Poland and Lviv belonged to the Austro-Hungarian Empire. Unsurprisingly, the Polish intellectuals in Galicia read German during that era. Schulz, who was born in 1892, in Drohobycz, was no exception. The first Polish translation of Sacher-Masoch’s works was published in Warsaw in 1904. It was Warjat z Firlejówki (A Madman from Firlejówka), a Poe-like Gothic story that did not have so-called strikingly masochistic scenes. However, the other two titles published 28
I discussed parergon and Schulz’s graphic works in a conference paper titled ‘Obraz i Ksi ga. O autoreferencyjnoci w twórczoci Brunona Schulza’ (Lublin, forthcoming in Biae plamy w schulzologii). 29 I searched for the Polish translations of Sacher-Masoch’s novels at libraries in Poland and Lviv (the National Library in Warsaw, the Library of Warsaw University, the Library of Jagiellonian University, and the Stefanyka Library in Lviv).
The Early Graphic Works of Schulz and Sacher-Masoch’s Venus in Furs
231
in Polish concentrated solely on cruel women and were published in Lviv: Wenus w futrze (Venus in Furs) and Gro ne kobiety (Cruel Women). In 1911, the first two volumes of the six-volume series Grausame Frauen (Cruel Women, 1907)30 were published, along with its original subtitles Gro ne kobiety: Sfinksy (Dangerous Women: Sphinxes) and Gro ne kobiety: Silne Serca (Dangerous Women: Strong Heart), in Lviv by the publisher “Kultura i Sztuka” (“Culture and Art”).31 A year or two later (1912 or 1913),32 they were combined into one book and republished with a slightly changed title: Demoniczne kobiety (Demonic Women). Incidentally, Schulz was a student of the Polytechnic College in Lviv until the outbreak of World War I. Around 1920, even a third edition of the book was published. As briefly mentioned above, the first translation of Venus in Furs was published in 1913, by the publisher Globus in Lviv. In 1919, the second revised edition of this book was published by “Culture and Art” in Lviv.33 To sum up, before World War I, people had already read Sacher-Masoch’s novels in Polish and knew him for his writings about the specific relationship between men and women. On the back pages of the book Demonic Women (1913), Sacher-Masoch’s short stories were advertised as those portraying the cruelty inflicted by women on men. The following was written about Venus in Furs: Sacher-Masoch odsania nam miao smutn prawd o okruciestwie drzemi cem na dnie duszy kobiecej. Jest on przedstawicielem pogl du, e pi kna kobieta posiada w sobie pierwiastki dzikiego despotyzmu i e stosuje ten despotyzm do m czyzny, jeli on tylko nie potrafi zapanowa nad ni bezwzgl dnie. St d ma Sacher-Masoch suszn saw jako z
30
It was published in Leipzig, twelve years after the death of Sacher-Masoch. Given the volume numbers, it seems that the Polish publisher planned to publish the complete series in Polish. 32 According to the central catalogue of the National Library in Warsaw, the first edition of Demonic Women was issued in 1912. However, it is not held by the library. The second and third editions, published in 1913, and around 1920, respectively, are in several libraries. 33 The main publisher of Sacher-Masoch’s novels, “Culture and Art”, published novels and literary works on spiritualism, Freemasonry, psychology, and sexology. This publisher appears to have introduced and popularized the then up-to-date topics into the Polish-speaking sphere. 31
232
Ariko Kato jednej strony niezmiernie powa ny i pilnie czytany, a z drugiej strony bardzo znienawidzony powieciopisarz. (Sacher-Masoch 1913a) (Sacher-Masoch bravely revealed the sad truth about the cruelty hidden in women’s souls. He presents the view that a beautiful woman has the ingredients for wild despotism and that she applies it to him only if he does not manage to rule her mercilessly. This is the reason why SacherMasoch has garnered fame as an extremely important and urgently read author as well as a very hated novelist.)
His books must have gained popularity considering that the second and third editions were published in independent Poland. A noteworthy fact is that the translation does not closely follow the original. Furthermore, the translator’s name is not mentioned. As a result of countless omissions and modifications, the Polish translation ultimately emphasizes Wanda’s demonic character and simply transforms Severin’s love or adoration into an abnormality. According to the advertisement, the anonymous translator clearly and dramatically assigned sadistic and masochistic attributes to Wanda and Severin, respectively; in contrast, the other contexts were not shown as distinctly. What mostly changed the characters of this novel were the several deletions of the key term “suprasensual” (übersinnlich, nadzmysowe). This word, which was repeatedly used in the original to characterize Severin, was once replaced by the word anormalno ‘abnormality’ (Sacher-Masoch 1989: 51). The title of Severin’s manuscript, Bekenntnisse eines Übersinnlichen (Confessions of a Suprasensual Man; Sacher-Masoch 1980: 17), was altered to Zwierzenia gupiego fanatyka (Confessions of a Foolish Fanatic; Sacher-Masoch 1989: 27) even though the term suprasensual responds to the manuscript’s motto, which is a variation of Mephistopheles’ verses from Goethe’s Faust.34 In addition, some interesting modifications were made from the Polish perspective. It has been known that Sacher-Masoch often set his stories in the pluralistic society of eastern Galicia. As a matter of fact, he projected the exotic image of the “East” on the Slavic world, which indeed appealed to Western readers. However, in the Polish version, the translator projected the images of “East” or “Asia” 34
“You suprasensual sensual suitor, / A woman leads you by the nose!” (ViF 10; “Du übersinnlicher sinnlicher Freier, Ein Weib nasführet dich!”; Sacher-Masoch 1980: 17). Cf. Goethe’s “Du übersinnlicher sinnlicher Freier, Ein Mägdalein nasführet dich” (Goethe [s.d.] :120).
The Early Graphic Works of Schulz and Sacher-Masoch’s Venus in Furs
233
on Russia and eastward. The demonic heroine Wanda, who was from Lviv in the original, was from Moscow in the translated version. The figure of the unsophisticated Polish peasants disappeared from the text, while negative Jewish stereotypes – typical to the anti-Semitic discourse during the interwar period – were added and emphasized. The exotic image of Galicia depicted from the Austrian perspective was displeasing to the Polish readers; this is confirmed in the only study on Sacher-Masoch published in the Polish-speaking sphere before World War I, in 1907. Leon Wachholz – author, doctor, and professor of the Jagiellonian University – criticized Sacher-Masoch for distorting the images of Poles and characterizing the Slavs as masochists (Wachholz 1907). Moreover, the pluralistic background had faded away from the translated Venus in Furs; this novel simply went on to become a work on a sensational “masochistic” subject. It is important to note that the Polish translations of SacherMasoch’s novels are still limited to the two titles that are actually reissues of the publications by “Culture and Art” before World War II.35 In addition, the translations have not been revised since then. This could be a reason for the neglect of Sacher-Masoch in the discussion on Schulz. Reconsidering the Discourse on “Schulz-Masochist” Finally, I would like to reconsider the discourse on “Schulzmasochist” by comparing it to the cultural background in those days. Aleksander Wat’s wife recalled that Schulz was regarded as a masochist in Warsaw because of his paintings (Watowa 2000: 16). In fact, in the mid-1930s, his literary contemporaries published some texts alluding to his or his works’ masochistic tendency in literary magazines: an open letter to Schulz from Stanisaw Ignacy Witkiewicz (1935) and Witold Gombrowicz (1936a, 1936b) as well as Józef Nacht’s report on his meeting with Schulz (1937). In Witkacy’s open letter to Schulz, the former interpreted Schulz’s graphic works as those representing female sadism and male masochism (Witkiewicz 1935: 321-322, Witkiewicz 1988: 108). As revealed in Witkacy’s novels such as Poegnanie jesieni (Farewell to Autumn, 1927), his 35
The reissue of Demonic Women, from 1986, reproduces the text as it was published in Lviv by “Kultura i Sztuka” in 1922.
234
Ariko Kato
understanding of masochism was based on the binomial opposition of masochism and sadism assigned to men and women, respectively.36 His view must have influenced the response to Schulz’s graphics37 and helped form the discourse on “Schulz-masochist”. However, it is important to pay attention to the fact that in those days, Freudian theory and the topic of the subconscious attracted a great deal of attention in Poland as well as in other European countries. In all likelihood, this was true in Galicia, which belonged to the Austro-Hungarian Empire when Freud began his theory in Vienna. Since the first decade of the twentieth century, Freudian theories, like the novels of Sacher-Masoch, have been translated into Polish. In 1936, in the second open letter to Schulz, Gombrowicz wrote, “I know that if someone today talks about thighs, people say Freud and that’s all” (“wiem, e teraz, jak tylko kto wspomni o ydce, to zaraz mówi , e z Freuda i koniec”; Gombrowicz 1936a: 220). Moreover, Witkacy directly mentioned Freud or his theory in his novels without trying to conceal his hatred or contempt for it. Krystyna Kulig-Janarek pointed out that the motifs in Schulz’s early graphics agreed with the Freudian schema to a great extent (1993: 47). It seems, therefore, more important to discuss these motifs against their cultural background rather than to psychoanalyze them. In 1937, the Encyclopaedia of Sexology was published in Warsaw. It was the expanded Polish version of the original German Handwörterbuch der Sexualwissenschaft edited by Max Marcuse in Bonn in 1923. The article titled ‘Literature and Psychoanalysis’ in the Polish encyclopedia described Schulz as one of the Polish writers influenced by Freudian theory, along with Witkacy and Karol Irzykowski (Marcuse 1937: 73). The article ‘Masochism’ in this encyclopedia explained that masochism can be associated with fetishism, especially for boots, and that masochism is not found among people who culturally belong to the lower class (Marcuse 1937: 156). This definition of masochism
36 The demonic heroines in Witkacy’s novels, such as Akne in 622 upadki Bunga czyli Demoniczna kobieta (The 622 Downfalls of Bungo or the Demonic Woman, 19101911, republished in 1968) and Hela in Farewell to Autumn, have characters similar to the heroines in Sacher-Masoch’s novels. The similarities between the works of Schulz and Witkacy were closely discussed in an article by Wodzimierz Bolecki (1994). 37 Indeed, Schulz’s graphics have often been compared to the painters with whom Witkacy compared Schulz in his open letter to Schulz (i.e. Goya, Rops, Munch, and Beardsley) (Witkiewicz 1935: 321; Witkiewicz 1988: 108).
The Early Graphic Works of Schulz and Sacher-Masoch’s Venus in Furs
235
helps us understand the discourse on “Schulz-masochist”. In his report, which seems to be partly fictitious – especially the section that takes the form of dialogue – Józef Nacht expressed sympathy toward Schulz with regard to his graphics. Nacht parodied Hegel’s masterslave dialectic, applying it to the relationship between man and woman. He wrote, “The whole world is just to rule or to stop ruling. There are rulers and slaves everywhere” (“Cay wiat przecie yje po to tylko, aby panowa lub znosi panowanie. Wsz dzie sa wadcy i niewolnicy”; 1937: 5). This view is repeated in Venus in Furs and apparently adapted from it.38 However, Nacht expressed a negative view on Sacher-Masoch’s novels by regarding them as describing only masochistic practices. In fact, his article represented the common conceptions of Sacher-Masoch in those days because a similar neglect was found in the abovementioned encyclopaedia (Marcuse 1937: 56).39 Nacht continued by stating the following: “Many people view masochism as snobbism; however, the possibility of the ‘fashion’ of masochism, which could cause a sexual revolution, is far more dangerous” (“ró ni ludzie nazywaj masochism snobizmem, ale znacznie groniejsza jest mo liwo mody masochizmu, która mogaby wywoa rewolucj seksualn ”; 1937: 5). Let us recall that at the beginning of the open letter to Schulz, Gombrowicz alluded to Schulz’s masochistic tendency, quoting a possibly fictitious comment made by a doctor’s wife: “Bruno Schulz, she said, he’s either a sick pervert or a poseur, but most probably a poseur. He’s only pretending” (Schulz 1988a: 117; “Bruno Schulz – powiedziaa – to albo chory zboczeniec, albo pozer; lecz najpewniej pozer. On tylko udaje tak”; Gombrowicz 1936a: 209). Considering that masochism was quite a popular topic among the intellectuals of Schulz’s time, the discourse on “Schulz-masochist” becomes understandable as intellectual play among Schulz’s contemporaries. The allusion to masochism by the artist whose works depicted such motifs was by itself an intellectual discussion. Schulz, to some extent, played his part as a masochist – a part that was given to him – in Polish literary circles.
38 The narrator, in his dream, explained the living statue of Venus about his view on the relationship between men and women, adopting Hegelian rhetoric. Indeed, the narrator had been reading Hegel before he fell asleep; interestingly, the name Hegel was deleted in the Polish version (Sacher-Masoch 1989: 23, 2000: 5). 39 Cf. the article titled ‘Belles Lettres’.
236
Ariko Kato
After World War II, Gombrowicz wrote in his Dziennik (Diary) that Schulz was a masochist (Gombrowicz 2001: 8-13). Irena Kejlin-Mitelman also observed that Schulz posed like the men in his paintings (Schulz 1984: 49). We refrain from any discussion on his masochism since the subject is beyond the scope of our discussion. At the same time, Kejlin-Mitelman’s statement reminds us of Sacher-Masoch whose novels contained scenes that replicated his real life. Incidentally, the composition of the picture, which SacherMasoch had taken and which was published in Dresden in 1901, after his death [il. 15], is similar to ‘Jej garderobiana’ (‘The Dresser’ [il. 16]) in The Idolatrous Book. Conclusion The comparison of Venus in Furs with The Idolatrous Book can lead us to the conclusion that Schulz must have been inspired by the novel when he made The Idolatrous Book, especially ‘Bench’ and the pictures portraying Undula. Moreover, this article has made clear the similarity between Schulz and Sacher-Masoch: they questioned the traditional understanding of artworks as imitative representations of reality or existing narratives, and represented this problem of mimesis in their naturalistic works. An examination of the then popularity of Freudianism and the reception accorded to Sacher-Masoch’s novels has led us to reconsider the discourse on “Schulz-masochist”, and it appears that Schulz, to some extent, played his part in furthering this discourse. The analysis of Schulz’s early graphics reveal him to be a theoretic-artist who, based on his knowledge of European paintings, critically reconsidered its conventions and succeeded in representing his own views in his works. His early graphics, although they seem to be inspired by the traditional painting styles, substantiate his twentieth-century modernistic views on art, which are reflected in his later prose. Bibliography Alberti, Leon Battista. 1976. On Painting. (tr. J.R. Spencer). Westport, Connecticut: Greenwood Press. Battistini, Matilde. 2005. Symbole i alegorie (tr. M. Witczak). Warszawa: Arkady.
The Early Graphic Works of Schulz and Sacher-Masoch’s Venus in Furs
237
Bolecki, Wodzimierz. 1994. ‘Witkacy-Schulz, Schulz-Witkacy’ in Jarz bski (1994): 127-151. Bolecki, Wodzimierz, Jerzy Jarz bski and Stanisaw Rosiek (eds). 2003. Sownik schulzowski. Gdask: sowo/obraz terytoria. Cassouto, Nella. 1990. ‘“She Walked up to Father with a Smile and Flipped Him on the Nose”: Schulz and the Wars of the Sexes’ (tr. V. Barsky) in Drawings of Bruno Schulz: From the Collection of the Adam Mickiewicz Museum of Literature, Warsaw. Jerusalem: The Israel Museum: 22-27. Deleuze, Gilles. 1998. Masoch to Sade (tr. S. Hasumi). Tokyo: Shobun-sha. Derrida, Jacques. 2003. Prawda w malarstwie (tr. M. Kwietniewska). Gdask: sowo/obraz terytoria. Ficowski, Jerzy. 1986. Okolice sklepów cynamonowych: Szkice, przyczynki, impresje. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie. ——. 2002. Regiony wielkiej herezji i okolice: Bruno Schulz i jego mitologia. Sejny: Fundacja Pogranicze. Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von. [s.d.] Faust: Der Tragödie. Erster Teil. Berlin and Leipzig: Hermann Seemann Nachfolger. Gombrowicz, Witold. 1936a. ‘List otwarty do Brunona Schulza’ in Studio 7: 209-211. ——. 1936b. ‘Do Brunona Schulza’ in Studio 7: 217-220. ——. 1988. ‘Open Letter to Bruno Schulz’ in Schulz (1988a): 117-119. ——. 2001. Dziennik: 1961-1969. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie. Gondowicz, Jan. 2006. Bruno Schulz [1892-1942]. Warszawa: Edipresse Polska. Hirano, Yoshihiko. 2004. Sacher-Masoch. Tokyo: Seido-sha. Jarz bski, Jerzy (ed.) 1994. Czytanie Schulza. Kraków: T.I.C. ——. 1999. Schulz. Wrocaw: Wydawnictwo Dolnol skie. Kasjaniuk, Halina. 1993. ‘Rodowody i symbole w grafikach Schulza’ in Ciechowicz J. and Kasjaniuk H. (eds). Teatr Pamici Brunona Schulza. Gdynia: s.n.: 1025. Kitowska-ysiak, Magorzata. (ed.) 1981. ‘Xiga Bawochwalcza – grafiki oryginalne (cliché verre) Brunona Schulza’ in Biuletyn Historii Sztuki 4: 401-410. —— (ed.) 1994a. Bruno Schulz. In memoriam. 1892-1942. Lublin: Wydawnictwo FIS. ——. 1994b. ‘Bruno Schulz – “Xi ga Bawochwalcza”: wizja – forma – analogie’ in Kitowska-ysiak (1994a): 133-151. ——. 1994c. ‘Wizje kobiecoci w Xi dze Bawochwalczej: Salome i androgyne’ in Jarz bski (1994): 251-263. ——. 2002. ‘“Bezlik nieskoczonych historyj”: O reinterpretacji mitologicznych pierwowzorów na kartach Xigi Bawochwalczej’ in Schulz (2002b): 9-22. ——. 2003. ‘Xiga bawochwalcza’ in Bolecki, Wodzimierz, Jerzy Jarz bski and Stanisaw Rosiek (eds) (2003): 420-425. Kitowska-ysiak, Magorzata and Wadysaw Panas (eds). 2003. W uamkach zwierciada…Bruno Schulz w 110 rocznic urodzin i 60 rocznic mierci. Lublin: Towarzystwo Naukowe KUL. Kossowska, Irena, and ukasz Kossowski. 2002. ‘Wanie: humor Schulza’ in Schulz (2002b): 23-33. Kulig-Janarek, Krystyna. 1993. ‘Schulzowska mitologia: Motywy, w tki, inspiracje w Xidze Bawochwalczej’ in Kresy 14: 37-49.
238
Ariko Kato
——. 1994. ‘Erotyka – groteska – ironia – kreacja’ in Kitowska-ysiak (1994a): 153177. Marcuse, Max (ed). 1937. Encyklopedia wiedzy seksualnej: dla lekarzy, prawników i socjologów. Vol. II. (tr. S. Higier). Warszawa: Wydawnictwo Lekarskie “Eskulap”. Nacht, Józef. 1937. ‘Wywiad drastyczny (Rozmowa z Brunonem Schulzem)’ in Nasza opinja 77 (204): 5. Noyes, John K. 1997. The Mastery of Submission: Inventions of Masochism. Ithaca & London: Cornell University Press. Sacher-Masoch, Leopold von. 1904. Warjat z Firlejówki: Opowiadanie. Warsaw: Skad u F. Kasprzykiewicza i S-ki. ——. [1911a]. Gro ne kobiety (Sfinksy). Lviv: Kultura i Sztuka. ——. [1911b]. Gro ne kobiety (Silne Serca). Lviv: Kultura i Sztuka. ——. [1913a]. Demoniczne kobiety (2nd ed.) Lviv: Kultura i Sztuka. ——. [1913b]. Wenus w futrze. Lviv: Globus. ——. [1919]. Wenus w futrze (2nd ed.) Lviv: Kultura i Sztuka. ——. [ca. 1920]. Demoniczne kobiety (3rd ed.) Lviv: Kultura i Sztuka. ——. 1980. Venus im Pelz. Frankfurt am Main: Insel. ——. 1986. Demoniczne kobiety. Warszawa: Wydawnictwa Artystyczne i Filmowe. ——. 1989. Wenus w futrze. ód: Wydawnictwo “Res Polona”. ——. 2000. Venus in Furs (tr. J. Neugroschel). New York: Penguin. Sandauer, Artur. 1964. ‘Rzeczywisto zdegradowana (Rzecz o Brunonie Schulzu)’ in Bruno Schulz. Proza. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie: 7-43. ——. [1992]. Trójca nowoczesnych. Kraków: Miniatura. Schulz, Bruno. 1936. ‘Do Witolda Gombrowicza’ in Studio 7: 211-217. ——. 1984. Listy, fragmenty: Wspomnienia o pisarzu. (ed. J. Ficowski). Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie. ——. 1985. ‘Xi ga Bawochwalcza’ in Twórczo 7/8: 124-152. ——. 1988a. Letters and Drawings of Bruno Schulz: With Selected Prose. (ed. J. Ficowski, tr. W. Arndt and V. Nelson). New York: Harper & Row Publishers. ——. 1988b. Xiga Bawochwalcza. (ed. J. Ficowski). Warszawa: Interpress. ——. 1992. Bruno Schulz 1892-1942: Rysunki i archiwalia ze zbiorów Muzeum Literatury im. Adama Mickiewicza w Warszawie (ed. W. Chmurzyski). Warszawa: Muzeum Literatury im. Adama Mickiewicza w Warszawie. ——. 1995. Bruno Schulz 1892-1942: Katalog-Pamitnik Wystawy “Bruno Schulz. Ad Memoriam” w Muzeum Literatury im. Adama Mickiewicza w Warszawie (ed. W. Chmurzyski). Warszawa: Muzeum Literatury im. Adama Mickiewicza. ——. 1998. The Collected Works of Bruno Schulz. (ed. J. Ficowski). London: Picador. ——. 2002a. Ksiga listów. (2nd ed.) (ed. J. Ficowski). Gdask: sowo/obraz terytoria. ——. 2002b. Mityzacja rzeczywistoci: Bruno Schulz 1892-1942. Lublin: Wydawnictwo UMCS. ——. 2003. Bruno Schulz. Olszanica: BOSZ. Stala, Krzysztof. 1993. On the Margins of Reality: the Paradoxes of Representation in Bruno Schulz’s Fiction. Stockholm: Almqvist & Wiksell International. Tanemura, Suehiro. 2004. Leopold von Sacher-Masoch.Tokyo: Heibon-sha.
The Early Graphic Works of Schulz and Sacher-Masoch’s Venus in Furs
239
Van Heuckelom, Kris. ‘Artistic Crossover in Polish Modernism. The Case of Bruno Schulz’s Xiga Bawochwalcza (The Idolatrous Booke)’ in Image [&] Narrative. Online Magazine of the Visual Narrative 15. On line at http://www.imageandnarrative.be/iconoclasm/heuckelom.htm (consulted 09.11.2007). Wachholz, Leon. 1907. Sacher Masoch i masochizm: Szkic literacko-psychiatryczny wedug collegium publicum. Kraków: Drukarnia Uniwersytetu Jagielloskiego. Watowa, Ola. 2000. Wszystko co najwaniejsze…(2nd ed.) Warszawa: Czytelnik. Witkiewicz, Stanisaw Ignacy. 1935. ‘Wywiad z Brunonem Schulzem’ in Tygodnik Ilustrowany 17: 321-323. ——. 1988. ‘Interview with Bruno Schulz’ in Schulz (1988a): 107-110. ——. 2001. Poegnanie jesieni (ed. A. Miciska). Warszawa: Pastwowy Instytut Wydawniczy. ——. 2005. 622 upadki Bunga czyli Demoniczna Kobieta. Kraków: Zielona Sowa.
Ariko Kato
240
Illustrations
[il.1] Jeszcze raz Undula [Undula, Once Again], 9.5x15 (ML Bibl. II 14606/2)
[il.2] Xi ga bawochwalcza [The Idolatrous Book], 14.5x23.9 (NMK: III7474)
The Early Graphic Works of Schulz and Sacher-Masoch’s Venus in Furs
241
[il.3] awka [Bench], 13x18.1 (NMW: Gr.W.6007/7)
[il.4] Undula u artystów [Undula with the Artists], 9.9x15 (NMW: Gr.W.6008/5)
242
Ariko Kato
[il.5] Undula w nocy [Undula at Night], 15x10.5 (NMK: III7468)
The Early Graphic Works of Schulz and Sacher-Masoch’s Venus in Furs
[il.6] Undula idzie w noc [Undula Walks into the Night], 11.6x8.4 (NMW: Gr.W.6007/6)
243
244
Ariko Kato
[il.7] Swawolne kobiety [Playful Women], 26.8x35.8 (Jewish Historical Institute Warsaw (JHI): A-738)
[il.8] Autoportret przy pulpicie rysowniczym [Self-portrait Before an Easel], 43x29.5 (JHI: A-460)
The Early Graphic Works of Schulz and Sacher-Masoch’s Venus in Furs
245
[il.9] Odwieczna ba [The Eternal Fairy Tale], 16.8x12.2 (NMW: Gr.W. 6007/3)
246
Ariko Kato
[il.10] Wenus i Amor (II) [Venus and Amor (II)], 17.5x27 (ML: K.725)
[il.11] Wenus i Amor [Venus and Amor], 15.5x25.5 (ML: K.726)
The Early Graphic Works of Schulz and Sacher-Masoch’s Venus in Furs
[il.12] Kobiety, sadystki [Women, Sadists], 29x40 (JHI: A-462)
[il.13] Na Cyterze [On Cythera], 11.4x18 (NMW: Gr.W 6008/7)
247
248
Ariko Kato
[il.14] Autoportret ze Stanisawem Weingartenem [Self-portrait with Stanisaw Weingarten], 24x31 (JHI: A-739)
The Early Graphic Works of Schulz and Sacher-Masoch’s Venus in Furs
249
[il. 15] Picture of Leopold von Sacher-Masoch with Fanny Pistor (reproduced from Carl Felix von Schlichtegroll. Sacher Masoch und der Masochismus. Dresden: Verlag von H. R. Dohrn, 1901)
[il.16] Jej garderobiana [The Dresser], 12x16 (NMW: Gr.W.6008/4)
Zuloaga (Rilke?) Schulz Jan Zieliski Abstract: The article discusses some thematic and stylistic affinities between Bruno Schulz and the Basque painter Ignacio Zuloaga y Zabaleta (1870-1945). Rainer Maria Rilke is treated as a potential mediator. After a survey of Polish themes in Zuloaga and Spanish ones in Schulz, a parallel is drawn between the motif of a wounded horse in Zuloaga’s art and Schulz’s imagery. The article ends with the presentation of the similarities in the treatment of a human head by both artists and a discussion of the role of physical deformation for Zuloaga and Schulz.
Introduction Ignacio Zuloaga y Zabaleta (1870-1945) was one of Schulz’s favorite painters, if not the favorite, according to the testimony of Bruno Schulz’s pupil, Feiwel Schreier: Przynosi na lekcje ró ne albumy dzie malarzy, objania ich obrazy […] Utkwi mi w pami ci szczególnie hiszpaski malarz Zuloaga – zdaje si , by to jego ulubiony malarz – a tak e El Greco. (in Ficowski 2002: 119). (He used to bring along art publications with works of different painters, explaining their meaning […] Especially the Spanish painter Zuloaga – who was, as it seems, his favourite painter – stuck in my memory, as well as El Greco.)
Zuloaga has a short but dense entry in Sownik schulzowski, the famous dictionary on Schulz. Magorzata Kitowska-ysiak starts from Schreier’s testimony and describes one particular painting, Irene, a young nude female reclining on a sofa, with a picturesque shawl across her left arm (2003: 428). Kitowska-ysiak discerns two aspects that could particularly interest Schulz in Zuloaga: his direct, emotional treatment of erotic subjects and the theatricalization of the space, visible especially in the form of suspended curtains creating the background of his compositions, representing either the sky or a
252
Jan Zieliski
distant small town. However, according to Kitowska-ysiak, all these possible inspirations were treated by Schulz with his characteristic refinement. To begin, let us compare their respective biographies. Schulz was a contemporary of Zuloaga who, born twenty-two years earlier, died three years after Schulz was killed by a Nazi. Both were minoritarian: Zuloaga, known as a Spanish painter, was Basque, like his great predecessor Zurbaran; Schulz, one of the greatest Polish writers, was born into a Jewish family. Both were provincial and came from small towns: Zuloaga from Eibar in the Basque Country and Schulz from Drohobycz, now part of Ukraine. Apart from Schulz’s short studies in Lwów/Lemberg (1913) and Vienna (1917), and some short trips to Warsaw, Zakopane, Kudowa, the village of Boberka, Stockholm, and Paris, he spent practically his entire life in Drohobycz. But Zuloaga, unlike Schulz, was a restless spirit, moving constantly between Rome, Paris, Florence, Madrid, Segovia, Seville, and Zumaya, a Basque fishermen’s village. Zuloaga and Schulz were born respectively into the families of craftsmen and merchants: Zuloaga into that of armorers, whereas Schulz’s father, an accountant, owned a textile wholesale shop. Both felt attached to their ancestors and families, especially to some particular wizardly figures. In the case of Zuloaga, it was his uncle Daniel, called el alchimista de San Juan de los Caballeros: Painter as well as potter, he leads the life of a sixteenth-century craftsman, and when you see him, bearded and clad in long, flowing blouse, adding a touch of colour to some ornate composition or feverishly firing the clay, your mind travels back to Faust’s kitchen and the spell of mediaeval necromancy (Sargent 1916: 18).
In the case of Schulz, it was his father; when remembering that Sklepy cynamonowe (Cinnamon Shops, 1934) was initially going to be called Recollections of My Father, one is tempted to compare Daniel Zuloaga with the father from Schulz’s prose, an “inspired heresiarch” (Schulz 1989a: 33;1 “herezjarcha natchniony”; Schulz 1989b: 37)2 with the “terrible eye of a prophet” (“grone oko prorocze”; Op 39): 1 2
All further references will be given as CF. All further references will be given as Op.
Zuloaga (Rilke?) Schulz
253
Broda jego zje ya si dziwnie, wiechcie i p dzle wosów, strzelaj ce z brodawek, z pieprzów, z dziurek od nosa, nastroszyy si na swych korzonkach. Tak sta dr twy, z gorej cymi oczyma, dr c od wewn trznego wzburzenia, jak automat, który zaci si i zatrzyma na martwym punkcie. (Op 39) (His beard bristled grotesquely, the tufts of hair growing from warts and moles and from his nostrils stood on end. He became rigid and stood with flaming eyes, trembling from an internal conflict like an automaton of which the mechanism has broken down; CF 35)
A question arises: which of Zuloaga’s vast output of paintings could Schulz have actually seen? One picture hangs now in the Lviv museum – A Spanish Woman on a Street. It shows a woman in blue dress with a fan and some people and houses in the background. It has not been determined if the painting was a part of the collection during Schulz’s lifetime. During his stay in Vienna he could have seen the portrait of the folk-poet Don Miguel from Segovia, offered in 1903 by the count Lanckoroski to the newly founded Moderne Galerie, now called Österreichische Galerie Belvedere (Anonymous 2003: 9). Schulz certainly saw many of Zuloaga’s paintings in Paris in 1938, although that was after both of his books had been published. Of the numerous publications – books and articles – on Zuloaga, Schulz most probably knew those published in German. The most important of these was the German edition of Léonce Bénédite’s (the director of Musée du Luxembourg) book on Zuloaga, published in 1911, by Otto Beckmann Verlag “mit 1 Gravure und 51 Originalreproductionen”, with titles of the pictures given in French, German, and English. Then, almost simultaneously, the German translation of Camille Mauclair’s study, Ignacio Zuloaga, was published in the October 1, 1911, issue of Die Kunst für Alle, with twenty-two black-and-white and two colour illustrations. These two publications provided a rich survey of Ignacio Zuloaga’s early work. Rilke the Go-Between? As a possible missing link between Zuloaga and Schulz, one should consider Rainer Maria Rilke. He and his wife, Clara Rilke-Westhoff, became friends with Zuloaga in 1902, in Paris, and in 1904, they went to Düsseldorf to see his exhibition. For a few years (1902-06), Rilke and Zuloaga exchanged letters, which were full of admiration and
254
Jan Zieliski
devotion on the part of the poet. After 1906, their friendship waned, and Rilke did not visit Zuloaga during his travels in Spain. He never wrote a book or even an article on Zuloaga.3 On the other hand, Rilke was one of the most important literary influences on Schulz, who admired his poetry and prose and liked to read aloud from his book in German and make improvised comments.4 The correspondence between Rilke and Zuloaga was prepared for publication by Jean Gebser and even published during Schulz’s lifetime, but it is unlikely that Schulz ever had it in his hands. The text was written by Gebser in Spanish in spring 1936, but the civil war made the planned publication impossible and almost cost the author his life. The German version was published in 1940, in Zurich by Emil Oprecht, a well-known anti-Nazi publisher. It is very doubtful, albeit not totally impossible, that the book could find its way to Drohobycz during the Nazi occupation. Spanish Themes – Polish Themes The main Spanish subject in the written work of Bruno Schulz is Bianca, the heroine of ‘Wiosna’ (‘Spring’). The form of this first name, used by Shakespeare for a meek young daughter in The Taming of the Shrew and for a courtesan in Othello, is Italian, not Spanish, but the heroine of ‘Spring’ has many Spanish characteristics. There is a close affinity between Bianca and the heroine of Schulz’s engraving ‘Infantka i jej kary’ (‘The Infant and her Dwarfs’, 1920), who resembles some historical Spanish female figures: first and foremost, la infanta Blanca de Castila, who at the age of twelve married the future king of France, Louis VII, and was a dominant political and military personage; as well as Blanca de la Cerda, through whom the Basque province Vizcaya passed into the hands of the Castilian kings. Bianca is the daughter of a certain de V. What we hear about her presumed and rejected maternal ancestors all sounds very Spanish: Có z tego, e nie wywodzia si ona ani od prawowitej cesarzowej Meksyku, ani nawet od owej ma onki po lewej r ce, morganatycznej
3
Their relationship was recently the subject of the paper delivered by Justus Lange during the meeting of the International Rilke Society in Dresden (September 2006). 4 On Rilke’s influence on Schulz, cf. Zieliski (1999) and Kuczyska-Koschany (2004).
Zuloaga (Rilke?) Schulz
255
Izabeli d’Orgaz, która ze sceny w drownej podbia arcyksi cia sw pi knoci ? Có z tego, e matk jej bya owa maa Kreolka, której nadawa pieszczotliwe imi Conchity i która pod tym imieniem wesza do historii – niejako przez kuchenne schody? (Op 187) (What if she was not descended either from the legitimate empress of Mexico or even from the morganatic wife, Izabella d’Orgaz, who, from the stage of a touring opera, conquered Archduke Maximilian by her beauty? What if her mother was a little Creole girl whom he called Conchita and who under that name has entered history through the back door as it were; CF 186).
D’Orgaz was the stage name of the Mexican actress Elena Delgado de Baviera (1919-47), quite popular in the thirties. First of all, however, the surname, d’Orgaz, sends a reader to the famous painting by El Greco. One should mention here that Zuloaga, who owned several paintings by El Greco, was so fascinated by The Burial of the Count Orgaz that he once travelled day and night from Paris to Seville, woke the local priest, demanded to see the picture, contemplated it, and went directly back to Paris.5 In the description of Bianca, Schulz emphasizes her whiteness several times. One is tempted to compare these passages with the picture by Zuloaga, which presents a lady in a wide white gown and is entitled The Duchess of Alba (1925). Her surname, one of the best Spanish families, can be translated as white, just as Bianca can be. Another Spanish theme in the work of Schulz is the corrida motif in his open letter to Witold Gombrowicz. I will discuss this case separately below. All these references are treated here not as direct indicators of the influence of Zuloaga but as the most recognizable motifs of Spanish culture in general. There are reciprocally some Polish subjects in Zuloaga’s paintings. In 1912, he painted a portrait of the red-haired beauty Vittoria Malinowska, called La Rusa. The nickname means Russian, but her name sounds Polish. Definitely Polish was the soprano singer Aga Lahowska, another beautiful woman, painted by Zuloaga in 1919. Joaquín Turina composed Poema en forma de canciones (1911) for
5 “El Greco también tuvo un papel fundamental en su vida. Durante su estancia en París, si sentía el deseo de contemplar El entierro del conde de Orgaz era capaz de viajar día y noche. Una vez en Toledo, y fuese la hora que fuese, pedía al capellán que por favor le abriese la iglesia. Lo admiraba y después emprendía viaje de regreso a la capital francesa” (Garcia 2000).
256
Jan Zieliski
Lahowska. She was a friend and performer of the works of Manuel de Falla (another friend of Zuloaga). In October 1917, Lahowska, Falla, and Zuloaga participated in the inauguration of a school complex near the birth house of Goya in Fuendetodos (del Pino 2006). But most interesting for us is the portrait of the Polish musician and politician Ignacy Paderewski. In 1924, Zuloaga went specially to Riond-Bosson, near Morges in Switzerland, to paint this picture, commissioned by Steinway. According to the New York Times article from 1925: The painting shows Paderewski standing before his piano, which is on a balcony and in the background is Warsaw, with the famous monument there brought out. […] About him are the trappings of a statesman – a few law books on a stool near by and the eagle of Poland is seen in the folds of the red emblem that is thrown loosely over the end of the piano. […] But the details of the picture are lost in the strength of the figure and especially the face, which shows all the vigor and strength that the erstwhile Premier of Poland has. (Anonymous 1925)
This description reveals the importance of the symbolic value of background in Zuloaga’s pictures, especially in his portraits. The background is frequently a distant view of a city, like Toledo in the magnificent portrait of the French writer Maurice Barrès. Sometimes it is simply a street or some separate houses. There is a passage in the prose of Schulz, namely the twenty-fourth chapter of ‘Spring’, that seems to comment on this technique of using architecture as a background: Odkryem tajemnic tego stylu. Tak dugo linie tej architektury w swej natarczywej swadzie powtarzay ten sam niezrozumiay frazes, a poj em ten szyfr zjadliwy, to perskie oko, t askotliw mistyfikacj . Bya to zaprawd zbyt przejrzysta maskarada. W tych wyszukanych i ruchliwych liniach o przesadnej wytwornoci bya jaka papryka nazbyt ostra, jaki nadmiar gor cej pikanterii, byo co fertycznego, arliwego, zbyt jaskrawo gestykuluj cego – co jednym sowem kolorowego, kolonialnego i ypi cego oczyma… Tak jest, ten styl mia na dnie swym co niesychanie odra aj cego – by rozpustny, wymylny, tropikalny i niesychanie cyniczny. (Op 172) (I have discovered the secret of the villa’s style. The lines of its architecture repeated one incomprehensible pattern so many times and so insistently that I finally understood their mystifying code: the masquerade was really quite transparent. In those elaborate and mobile lines of exaggerated elegance there was too much spice, an excess of hot piquancy, something fidgety, too eager, too showy – something, in a
Zuloaga (Rilke?) Schulz
257
word, colorful and colonial… Indeed, the style was in effect rather repulsive – lustful, overelaborate, tropical, and extremely cynical; Schulz CF 173).
Fighting Bull and Wounded Horse In the year 1936, the editor of the Warsaw monthly Studio encouraged Witold Gombrowicz and Schulz to exchange some letters. Three of the letters were published in the July issue of Studio. In his first letter, Gombrowicz attempted to provoke Schulz and quoted (or rather fabricated) the opinion of a doctor’s wife (from Wilcza Street in Warsaw); the quote suggested that Schulz was either a pervert or a poseur. Gombrowicz was challenging Schulz to descend from his usual heights and face the allegation. In his answer, Schulz used a peculiar argument, taken from the Spanish reality but adapted to his own situation. He compared the action taken by his friend against him with a corrida, with Schulz as a bull and Gombrowicz as a torero, hidden behind the doctor’s wife in her red underwear. Schulz, however, refused to step into the trap and declared himself ready to challenge the convention by fighting directly with Gombrowicz instead of attacking the lady in red: “Not to bump you off your feet, O noble toreador, but to take you on my back […] and carry you out of the arena, beyond the confines of its rules and statutes” (Schulz 1988: 120; “Nie, eby Ci zwali z nóg, szlachetny Toreadorze, ale eby Ci
wzi na grzbiet […] i wynie Ci poza obr b areny, jej prawide i kodeksów”; Op 450). He even proposed challenging convention by abandoning the tauromachy and with the muttters of the disappointed crowd rising behind us, walk side by side at an easy gait, bull and toreador, to the exit, freedom, absorbed in intimate conversation even before we leave behind the outer circle of the arena. (Schulz 1988: 120-121) (maj c gwar rozczarowanej publicznoci za sob , ruszyli rami przy ramieniu – byk i jego toreador – ku wyjciu, na wolno, swobodnym spacerowym krokiem – pogr eni w intymnej rozmowie, zanim jeszcze wyszlimy z ostatnich kr gów teatru; Op 451)
This exchange was the subject of numerous speculations; some commentators were trying to discover its hidden meaning (Salamon 1996). I would like to propose a modest explanation. Schulz’s answer clearly reminds the reader of the following
258
Jan Zieliski
description of a corrida in Granada, taken from a book, published first in Sweden, here in German translation: Ich befinde mich in diesem Augenblick im “feindlichen” Lager. Mein menschliches Solidaritätsgefühl lässt mich im Stich und ich fühle mich solidarisch mit dem gemarterten Tier. Ich hatte das Gefühl, als ob die Rollen hier vertauscht wären: die Menschen benehmen sich wie Tiere, das Tier dagegen wirkte in seiner hilflosen Bestürzung so ganz und gar menschlich. War aber nicht auch meine eigene Stimmung in jener Stunde etwas verworren? In dieser von Leidenschaft aufgepeitschten Luft werden die moralischen Instinkte umnebelt und die Rechtsbegriffe von oberst zu unterst gekehrt. Wer hatte hier recht? Wer war moralisch verworrener: die Toreadore in ihrem sinnlosen Angriff auf das überrumpelte Tier, das blutdurstig verwilderte Publikum oder ich selbst, der ich mit dem Tier gegen die Menschen mitfühlte? [A]ls ich mitten im, fortgesetzten, Spiele, die Arena verließ, hatte ich das Gefühl, dass mich das Publikum als Barbaren betrachtete. (Ehrenpreis 1928: 123-124)
The similarities between these passages are striking: the identification of the writer with the bull, the need to overturn the conventions, the final escape. The book about Spain was written by Marcus Ehrenpreis (1869-1951), born in Lviv, a Jewish journalist from Sweden, publisher of the Judisk Tidskrift, and chief rabbi of Sweden; there were two ways how this passage could quite probably have reached Schulz. Firstly, at the Iberian Peninsula, Ehrenpreis had a guide, Samuel Schwarz, from Zgierz near ód (Lodz). Schwarz, a mining engineer, discovered a community of crypto Jews when he went to Portugal just before the outbreak of World War I. His brother Marek was a painter, active in Paris, a member of the artistic group Junge Jidysz. Schulz himself had good contacts with Jewish artists in ód. One of them, Nathan Spiegel, encouraged him to go to Paris in 1938, to try and organize an exhibition of his works. Secondly, and this seems even more probable, Ehrenpreis was the uncle of Debora Vogel, a writer and a friend of Schulz. In 1930, he published in his Judisk Tidskrift Vogel’s article on the art of Schulz, illustrated by Spotkanie (Meeting) and The Infanta and her Dwarfs (Chmurzyski 1995: 163). Also in 1930, Ehrenpreis published the Polish version of his Spanish book, Kraj midzy Wschodem a Zachodem – Podró yda po Hiszpanii (The Country Between East and West – The Journey of a Jew Through Spain). Six years later Schulz used the motif of a reversal of the roles in corrida in his polemic with Gombrowicz.
Zuloaga (Rilke?) Schulz
259
Although Schulz, of course, was not known to partake in an actual bull fight, Zuloaga was an active participant in the bull-fighting scene when he was a young man. On a corrida poster from 1897, we see his name as one of two matadors, with a nickname El Pintor (The Painter). Because of pressure from his family, he quit after being wounded, but corrida was present in his work until the end.6 Later in his life, his attitude toward corrida became milder, full of compassion. Another animal seems to be directly related to Zuloaga. In one of the most lyrical fragments of Schulz’s prose, the short story ‘Cinnamon Shops’, which was the title to the original edition of his first collection of short stories, there appeared “an old, wise cabhorse” (“stary, m dry ko doro karski”), a horse that “inspired confidence” (“budzi zaufanie“) and even “seemed smarter than its driver” (CF 60; “wydawa si m drzejszy od wonicy”; Op 67). This passage was often interpreted as a deep personal recollection. The ride with the wise horse became a special, mystical experience for the hero of the story, who confessed: “I shall never forget that luminous journey on that brightest of winter nights” (CF 61; “Nie zapomn
nigdy tej jazdy wietlistej w najjaniejsz noc zimow ”; Op 68). The culminating point of that journey is worth quoting in full: Wreszcie usta. Wyszedem z doro ki. Dysza ci ko ze zwieszon gow . Przytuliem jego eb do piersi, w jego wielkich czarnych oczach lniy zy. Wtedy ujrzaem na jego brzuchu okr g czarn ran . – Dlaczego mi nie powiedziae? – szepn em ze zami. – Drogi mój – to dla ciebie – rzek i sta si bardzo may, jak konik z drzewa. Opuciem go. Czuem si
dziwnie lekki i szcz liwy (Op 68). (At last we stopped. I got out of the cab. The horse was panting, hanging its head. I hugged its head to my breast and saw that there were tears in his eyes. I noticed a round black wound on its belly. “Why did not you tell me?” I whispered, crying. “My dearest, I did it for you”, the horse said and became very small, like a wooden toy. I left him and felt wonderfully light and happy; CF 61)
The wounded horse is the subject of one of the best-known pictures by Zuloaga, called The Victim of a Fiesta (1910), where, to use the words of Camille Mauclair, “ein alter, sich über sein blutendes Pferd neigender Pikador [der] vor einem Himmel à la Delacroix vorüberreitet, frösteln macht” (Mauclair 1911: 13). In 1923, in an 6
Cf. Claretie (1905) on Zuloaga and corrida.
260
Jan Zieliski
interview Zuloaga declared his wish to keep that painting to himself and explained the story of its creation: I bought the old horse right from the bull-ring, and he lived just long enough for me to paint him. I did it more as a protest than anything else, and it has made such an impression on the minds of the Spanish people, that now, when a white horse comes into a bull-ring, a shuddering whisper passes through the crowd: “Zuloaga’s horse!” (Sangree 1923).
The following year this passage gave an anonymous author from the same newspaper inspiration for a witty remark: There is a case of a horse, who sat, or stood, for The Picador. Legend has it that he died as a result of being gored in a bullfight. Zuloaga assured the reporters that it was quite true. “That horse watched me painting, and when I came to the very last stroke of my brush he turned to me and said, ‘Well, goodbye, old man!’ and then he dropped over dead.” But that, of course, was after he had seen his portrait. (Anonymous 1924)
On the one hand, we can hardly assume that Schulz could have seen these publications in the American daily press; on the other hand, those stories were widely spread, and he could have read about this legend of the dying horse who speaks to its creator somewhere in the German or Polish press. An Evening Stroll and the Desire One of the most spectacular examples of the affinity between Zuloaga’s and Schulz’s subjects is the picture Evening Promenade and the sixteenth chapter of ‘Spring’. Let us start with two opening paragraphs from Schulz: W parku miejskim gra teraz codziennie wieczorem muzyka i przez aleje przesuwa si promenada wiosenna. Kr i nawracaj , mijaj i spotykaj si w symetrycznych, wci powtarzaj cych si arabeskach. Modzi ludzie nosz nowe wiosenne kapelusze i trzymaj niedbale r kawiczki w doni. Przez pnie drzew i ywopoty wiec w s siednich alejach sukienki dziewcz t. Id te dziewcz ta parami, koysz c si w biodrach, napuszone pian szlar i wolantów, nosz ze sob , jak ab dzie, te ró owe i biae napuszenia – dzwony pene kwitn cego mulinu i czasami osiadaj nimi na awce, jakby zm czone ich pust parad – osiadaj ca t wielk ró gazy i batystu, który p ka, przelewaj c si patkami. I wtedy odsaniaj si
nogi zao one jedna na drug i skrzy owane – splecione w biay ksztat
Zuloaga (Rilke?) Schulz
261
peen nieodpartej wymowy, a modzi spacerowicze, mijaj c je, milkn i bledn , ra eni trafnoci argumentu, do g bi przekonani i zwyci eni. Przychodzi chwila przed samym zmierzchem i kolory wiata pi kniej . Wszystkie barwy wst puj na koturny, staj si odwi tne, arliwe i smutne. Szybko napenia si park ró owym werniksem, lni cym lakierem, od którego rzeczy staj si naraz bardzo kolorowe i iluminowane. Ale ju w tych barwach jest jaki lazur zbyt g boki, jaka pi kno zbyt askawa i ju podejrzana. Jeszcze chwila i g szcz parku ledwie przysypany mod zieleni , ga zisty jeszcze i nagi, przewieca cay na wskro ró ow godzin zmierzchu, podbit balsamem chodu, napuszon niewymownym smutkiem rzeczy na zawsze i miertelnie pi knych (Op 154-155). (A band is now playing every evening in the city park, and people on their spring outings fill the avenues. They walk up and down, pass one another, and meet again in symmetrical, continuously repeated patterns. The young men are wearing new spring hats and nonchalantly carrying gloves in their hands. Through the hedges and between the tree trunks the dresses of girls walking in parallel avenues glow. The girls walk in pairs, swinging their hips, strutting like swans under the foam of their ribbons, and flounces; sometimes they land on garden seats, as if tired by the idle parade, and the bells of their flowered muslin skirts expand on the seats, like roses beginning to shed their petals. And then they disclose their crossed legs – white irresistibly expressive shapes – and the young men, passing them, grow speechless and pale, hit by the accuracy of the argument, completely convinced and conquered. At a particular moment before dusk all the colors of the world become more beautiful than ever, festive, ardent yet sad. The park quickly fills with pink varnish, with shining lacquer that makes every other color glow deeper; and at the same time the beauty of the colors becomes too glaring and somewhat suspect. In another instant the thickets of the park strewn with young greenery, still naked and twiggy, fill with the pinkness of the dusk, shot with coolness, spilling the indescribable sadness of things supremely beautiful but mortal; CF 160-161)
The first sentence contains a direct reference to Zuloaga’s title, visible especially in Polish original: “codziennie wieczorem […] przez aleje przesuwa si promenada wiosenna” (italics mine; “every evening […] people on their spring outings fill the avenues”). In the second paragraph we find terms taken from the technique of a painter – “ró owym werniksem” (“with pink varnish”) or “lni cym lakierem” (“with shining lacquer”) – another hint that the scene was borrowed from Zuloaga’s painting. Evening Promenade is one of many works by Zuloaga that develop the subject of awakening sexuality, seduction, and courtship. It is enough to mention such well-known
Jan Zieliski
262
paintings as Spanish Lady, The Spicy Joke, Weariness, The Lady with the Fan, Paulette the Dancer, Spanish Ladies at a Bull-fight. Two of them deserve closer attention in the context of Schulz’s writing and art. The Old Women’s Admirer shows an elderly gentleman with an umbrella under his right arm who eagerly follows two beautiful Spanish ladies, one of them looking with a knowing smile at the viewer – a parallel motif to numerous drawings and engravings by Schulz, such as ‘Zaczarowane Miasto I’ (‘The Enchanted City I’). Zuloaga’s The Street of Desire evokes the dubious atmosphere of the Street of Crocodiles. Both Zuloaga and Schulz were exploring the borderland between religious devotion and sensual admiration. From that point of view it seems interesting to compare Schulz’s The Tributary Procession on the Streets of a Town with Zuloaga’s The Scourgers. There are also some similarities in the use of particular motifs, like that of a pilgrim’s stick. Particularly striking from that point of view is the similarity between Schulz’s sketch ‘W drówki sceptyka’ (‘The Wanderings of a Sceptic’, 1936) and Zuloaga’s dwarf Gregorio in The Old Castile. Self-portraits and Portraits To all these similarities I would finally like to add another one: the means of self-presentation, more specifically, the presentation of the human head. Let us start with the striking affinity between Zuloaga’s Sketch for a Portrait of Pérez de Ayala (1931) and the way Schulz used to draw his own face. Apart from the accidental similarity of the features between Pérez de Ayala and Schulz, there is a deeper affinity in the way the human head is presented in such a way which allows the skull to emanate from under the skin. The structure of the skull is visible through the shape of a drawn or painted head, especially when you look at it diagonally from a certain angle. Schulz gives an apt description of this particular angle in his short story ‘Samotno’ (‘Loneliness’): Czasem widz si w lustrze. Rzecz dziwna, mieszna i bolesna! Wstyd wyzna. Nie widz si nigdy en face, twarz w twarz. Ale troch g biej, troch dalej stoj tam w g bi lustra nieco z boku, nieco profilem, stoj
zamylony i patrz w bok. (Op 311).
Zuloaga (Rilke?) Schulz
263
(Sometimes I see myself in the mirror. A strange, ridiculous, and painful thing! I am ashamed to admit it: I never look at myself full face. Somewhat deeper, somewhat farther away I stand inside the mirror a little off center, slightly in profile, thoughtful and glancing sideways; CF 309)
Schulz’s interest in skulls probably originated in his visit to the Schädelkapelle near Kudowa, in the Sudety Mountains in 1921.7 Pride of the Dwarfs Another common trait is the interest in physical deformation. Let us compare some cases of swollen faces. In Schulz’s work we have the face of the defecating vagabond in ‘Pan’: Wieche brudnych kaków wichrzy si nad czoem wysokim i wypukym jak bua kamienna, utoczona przez rzek . [T]en grymas rós, bra w siebie tamten ob d i natchnienie, p cznia nim, wybacza si coraz bardziej, a wyama si rycz cym, charcz cym kaszlem miechu. (Op 53) (A tuft of filthy hair bristled over his broad forehead rounded like a stone washed by a stream […] The grimace intensified, taking in the previous madness and tension, swelling, becoming broader and broader, until it broke into a roaring, hoarse shout of laughter; CF 47)
Schulz also describes Charles/Karol, who has something growing inside his body: Gdy tak siedzia w bezmylnym, wegetatywnym osupieniu, cay zamieniony w kr enie, w respiracj , w g bokie pulsowanie soków, rosa w g bi jego ciaa, spoconego i pokrytego wosem w rozlicznych miejscach, jaka niewiadoma, nie sformuowana przyszo, niby potworna narol, wyrastaj ca fantastycznie w nieznan dymensj . (Op 56) (While Charles sat there in a thoughtless, vegetative stupor, completely surrendered to circulation, respiration, and the deep pulsation of his natural juices, there formed inside his perspiring body an unknown, unformulated future, like a terrible growth, pushing forth in an unknown direction; CF 50)
Zuloaga has a predilection for dwarfs and other cases of deformation of the human body. There are several paintings showing the dwarf named Gregorio. A fragment of one of them, the abovementioned 7
See the recollection of Irena Kejlin-Mitelman in Schulz (1984: 48).
264
Jan Zieliski
picture The Old Castile, was titled Hypothyroid Dwarf in a book on nutritional deficiency in Spain (Fernandez 1990). That example shows the ambivalence of Zuloaga’s treatment of dwarfs, a certain pride in deformity. In the work of Bruno Schulz – both literary and artistic – there are many dwarfish male figures with disproportionately large heads.8 They crawl under the feet of women, begging for a glance or a touch of the shoe. Some of them have Schulz’s face, and despite the submissive attitude, there is a distinct touch of pride in them. Zuloaga’s toreros in dance-like poses proudly present their elaborate costumes and carefully coiffed hair. One of the best pictures of this subject, representing three young toreros and sometimes called The Young Bull-fighters, also has a metaphorical title: The Idols of the Future. One recalls immediately the title of Schulz’s map of engravings: Xiga bawochwalcza (The Idolatrous Book, 1920-1922). Both artists, the Spanish-Basque and the Polish-Jew, meet again in their critical description of the aspirations of the modern society, a description which mingles humility with pride and distance with admiration. The comparison between Zuloaga and Schulz certainly has some limitations. On the one hand, it is definitely more visible in the prose than in the art work of Schulz. On the other hand, the influence of Zuloaga is attested not only by several (more or less) direct borrowings, which are usually ingeniously refined but also by the testimony of Schulz’s pupil. One can well imagine a Spanish edition of Bruno Schulz’s prose illustrated with reproductions of works by Ignacio Zuloaga y Zabaleta. Bibliography Anonymous. 1924. ‘Portraits as Art’ in The New York Times (17 December 1924). ——. 1925. ‘Paderewski Portrait by Zuloaga on View’ in The New York Times (29 November 1925). ——. 2003. “Die neuesten Bestrebungen der Kunst documentieren…” Die Moderne Galerie 1903. Wien: Österreichische Galerie Belvedere. Chmurzyski, Wojciech. 1995. ‘Nieznany “szwedzki” artyku Debory Vogel o Brunonie Schulzu’ in Chmurzyski, Wojciech (ed.) Bruno Schulz 18921942: Katalog-Pamitnik Wystawy “Bruno Schulz. Ad Memoriam” w
8
They were recently discussed by Owczarski (2007) in his book on Lemian, Schulz, and Kantor.
Zuloaga (Rilke?) Schulz
265
Muzeum Literatury im. Adama Mickiewicza w Warszawie. Warszawa: Muzeum Literatury im. Adama Mickiewicza: 165-166. Claretie, Jules. 1905. ‘Bravo Toro!…’ in Je sais tout 1: 501-516. del Pino, Rafael. 2006. ‘Falla ante Goya: una romería spiritual’ in La Opinión de Granada (26 November 2006). Ehrenpreis, Marcus. 1928. Das Land zwischen Orient und Okzident. Spanische Reise eines Juden. Berlin: Welt-Verlag. Fernandez, Renate Lellep. 1990. A Simple Matter of Salt: An Ethnography of Nutritional Deficiency in Spain. Berkeley: University of California Press. On line at: http://ark.cdlib.org/ark:/13030/ft2d5nb1b2/ (consulted 24.12.2008). Ficowski, Jerzy. 2002. Regiony wielkiej herezji i okolice. Sejny: Fundacja “Pogranicze”. Garcia, Amaya. 2000. ‘Un pintor con una visión muy peculiar de España’ in Aula del mundo (30 October 2000). Kitowska-ysiak, Magorzata. 2003. ‘Zuloaga (y Zabaleta) Ignacio’ in Bolecki, Wodzimierz, Jerzy Jarz bski and Stanisaw Rosiek (eds). Sownik schulzowski. Gdask: sowo/obraz terytoria: 428-429. Kuczyska-Koschany, Katarzyna. 2004. Rilke poetów polskich, Wrocaw: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Wrocawskiego. Mauclair, Camille. 1911. ‘Ignacio Zuloaga’ in Die Kunst für Alle (1 October 1911). Owczarski, Wojciech. 2007. Kantor, Lemian, Schulz – miejsca wspólne, miejsca wasne. Gdask: sowo/obraz terytoria. Salamon, Joanna. 1996. ‘Schulz hermetyczny’ in Gnosis 8-9. On line at: http://www.gnosis.art.pl/numery/gn08_salamon_schulz_hermetyczny1.htm (consulted 24.12.2008). Sangree, Constance L. 1923. ‘Ignacio Zuloaga His Own Architect’ in The New York Times (1 July 1923). Sargent, John S. 1916. ‘Foreword’ in Exhibition of Paintings by Ignacio Zuloaga. New York: Redfield-Kendrick-Odell Co., Printers. Schulz, Bruno. 1984. Listy, fragmenty. Wspomnienia o pisarzu (ed. J. Ficowski). Kraków: Wydawnictwo Literackie. ——. 1988. Letters and Drawings of Bruno Schulz with Selected Prose (ed. J. Ficowski, tr. W. Arndt with V. Nelson). New York: Harper & Row. ——. 1989a. The Complete Fiction (tr. C. Wieniewska). New York: Walker. ——. 1989b. Opowiadania, wybór esejów i listów (ed. J. Jarz bski). Wrocaw: Zakad Narodowy im. Ossoliskich. Zieliski, Jan. 1999. ‘Schulz a Rilke. Hipotetyczna próba rekonstrukcji lektury’ in Ritz, German and Gabriela Matuszek (eds). Recepcja literacka i proces literacki / Literarische Rezeption und literarischer Prozess. Kraków: Universitas: 231-242.
Bruno Schulz and Djuna Barnes: Border-crossing and Artistic Practice Esther Sánchez-Pardo Abstract: Bruno Schulz and Djuna Barnes (1892-1982) are two unclassifiable modernist artists. A closer look at their works, superficially disparate and unrelated, reveals striking similarities in both form and content. Their fierce independence as self-taught writers and visual artists distinguished them from a bourgeois milieu in which the artist no longer occupied an autonomous realm. Their relative isolation also enabled their transformation into icons of the decadence and bohemianism of the avant-garde. This essay will examine their convergences and differences in order to elucidate their methods of work and sources of inspiration as well as their engagement with their audiences and societies.
Introduction When the careers of these two great writers and artists, Bruno Schulz (1892-1942) and Djuna Barnes (1892-1982) are examined, striking similarities, which connect them across a European and American 1 cultural divide at the time after “the world broke”, are perceived. Their creative production bears witness to a world in a state of permanent instability. Apart from the fact that they were both born in 1892, Schulz in a rural area in Poland (Drohobycz) and Barnes in upstate New York (Cornwall on Hudson), their lives were completely dissimilar. Barnes lived a long life; she outlived Schulz by forty years. Barnes also disappeared from view in 1940, when she moved to a
1
American writer Willa Cather’s much-quoted dictum that “[t]he world broke in two in 1922 or thereabouts” reflects her awareness of the radical social alterations, most notably in the areas of sex and gender, that were consolidated in Europe and in the United States in the years following the First World War (1936: v)
268
Esther Sánchez-Pardo
small apartment in Greenwich Village and lived in complete 2 isolation. Critics coincide in their appraisal of Schulz’s and Barnes’s works as primarily the product of writers rather than visual artists. As they gradually developed their own styles, they decided to jettison their role as illustrators and concentrate on their struggle to resolve through their writing the continual rapid transformation of the world in the period between the two world wars. We may also ask ourselves if it is not precisely in their passion and need to write rather than in the illustrations to their written work where we find Schulz’s and Barnes’s clearest statement of their inner world. In literary history, social upheavals, including shifts in social relations and in sex and gender, appeared both in the publication of alternative literary traditions by women, minorities (Jewish, AfricanAmerican), and non-heterosexuals, and in the professionalization of literary studies that marginalized these literatures. Authorship in the modern era could be seen as both feminine, insofar as it was an uncertain, part-time occupation, and masculine, insofar as it was a financially profitable one, even though writing could actually be lucrative for a woman or unreliable for a man. In this article, I will focus on Schulz’s and Barnes’s early work, and I will expand more on Barnes due to the familiarity and the expertise of the readership of this volume with the work of Schulz. This contribution is part of a larger project that compares the achievements of both artists along the different stages of their careers – fatally cut short in the case of Schulz and voluntarily in the case of Barnes. Schulz and Barnes: Intersections Schulz and Barnes were both born into middle-class households that did not provide them with a university education. The progress and 2
Philip Herring, Barnes’s biographer, writes: “The longevity of the Barnes family was for Djuna an inherited curse. She had tried to end her life in London in 1939; in the late 1970s, she tried again, undertaking to swallow all the pills on her night table, though somehow she missed the sleeping pills […] But [even if] daily life and simple tasks became increasingly difficult…the alternative to staying in Patchin Place drove Barnes to even more intense anxiety: a nursing home would be a fate far worse than death itself, for it would mean the end of creativity” (1995: 295-296).
Bruno Schulz and Djuna Barnes: Border-crossing and Artistic Practice
269
evolution in their writing and art was self-taught. They both found themselves faced with the necessity of making a living and thus practiced their creative work on the side. Schulz and Barnes worked in solitude, almost in complete isolation; they never belonged to a literary or artistic group. They were also terribly protective of their independence and had no masters. They differ in their openness to the world; whereas Schulz spent his entire life in his birthplace, Drohobycz, except for a few 3 short visits abroad, Barnes crossed the Atlantic several times. She lived in Paris and London and moved around freely in Europe. Schulz and Barnes were both influenced by the Decadent movement and specifically by Aubrey Beardsley (1872-1898). They both shared similar concerns with turn-of-the-century artists interested in representing and writing about the obscene and the grotesque. Beardsley’s thin line-style of drawing was particularly well suited to the grotesque. The use of the grotesque, which deliberately plays with forms that are exaggerated, bizarre, and ugly, is an accepted artistic convention and an important element in much of Beardsley’s work. It tends to express a particularly disillusioned view of life, and this underpinned Beardsley’s occasionally morbid philosophical outlook. He once famously remarked: “I have one thing, the grotesque. If I am not grotesque, then I am nothing” (Slessor 2000: 27). Schulz’s art, original and unique as it is, comes also from Viennese expressionism and the Old masters. In Jerzy Ficowski’s view, the dynamic arrangement of figures and bright spots surrounded by complete darkness are signs of Goya’s influence, especially from the series of Los Disparates, Los Caprichos, and The Naked Maja – a direct source of Schulz’s Undula in The Idolatrous Book. Scholars of Schulz’s work have stated that it is almost impossible to place his oeuvre in mainstream Polish literature, to find affinities, influences, and identify trends present in his work. Schulz was a loner living in a world of his own. In Celina Wieniewska’s words, [He was a man] with an intense, formidable inner life, a painter’s imagination, a sensuality and responsiveness to physical stimuli which
3
With the help of friends in Poland and France, Schulz did manage to visit Paris during the summer of 1938. He spent three weeks visiting museums and discussing art and literature. This visit had quite an impact on him.
270
Esther Sánchez-Pardo most probably could find satisfaction only in artistic creation… (in Schulz 1988: 12)
The world of Schulz is an eminently private one where his family and especially his father occupy center stage. Apart from his family, Schulz’s universe is populated by the inhabitants of Drohobycz. His characters are people who stuck to the old way of life before a new wave of entrepreneurs and fortune seekers moved to the region. When oil was struck near the city and prosperity brought about major changes in their lifestyles, the old patriarchal order collapsed. Nazi expansionist policies presented a threat to peace in central Europe. The Polish-German pact of 1934 intensified the spread of Nazi ideas in some sections of Polish society. When war broke out in September 1939, Drohobycz was for a time occupied by the Russians. Schulz could still teach and was able to write, but his type of writing was too personal and confessional to be acceptable during wartime. He, therefore, had to return to painting and to try to make a living as a traditional craftsman when, during the German advance into Soviet territory, Drohobycz was occupied by the Nazis in the summer of 1941. In the Jewish quarter of the city, in November 1942, Schulz was shot dead on the street by a Gestapo officer. Regarding Djuna Barnes, we know Oscar Wilde had an important influence on the early plays she wrote for the Provincetown Players. The 1906 American edition of Salomé, which Barnes probably owned, was adorned with Beardsley’s enigmatic illustrations. These stories, the drawings, the decadent aura, and the curiously stilted dialogue of many of Barnes’s plays point to the styles of Wilde and Beardsley as crucial influences in her formative years. Barnes’s Nightwood, written at the peak of her career, is a rereading, from the grim perspective of 1936, of the alternatives available to men and women after the collapse of the American economy and the worldwide depression had constrained the possibilities for avant-garde literary communities, and after the ascendance of the National Socialists in Germany who had begun to enforce ordered and hierarchical social patterns with deadly power.4 In what follows, we will examine similarities and differences between Schulz’s and Barnes’s formal and thematic concerns appearing in their early work. This comparative framework will lead 4
Jane Marcus (1991) has documented Nightwood’s relation to the rise of Nazism.
Bruno Schulz and Djuna Barnes: Border-crossing and Artistic Practice
271
us to further cross-cultural reflections on the unexplored connections between the Anglo-American and the Eastern European avant-gardes and on the yet uncharted territories of modernism. Bruno Schulz’s and Djuna Barnes’s Forms There are clear formal similarities in Schulz’s and Barnes’s work. First, Schulz and Barnes shared ideas on visual artistic practice as the “illustration” of the textual. As Jerzy Ficowski has remarked, Schulz was fully aware of the divergence of the two realms of the visual and the verbal; Schulz wrote in one of his letters: If I were asked whether the same thread recurs in my drawings as in my prose, I would answer in the affirmative. The reality is the same only the frames are different. Here material and technique operate as the criteria of selection. A drawing sets narrower limits by its material than prose does. That is why I feel I have expressed myself more fully in my writing (in Ficowski 1990: 4).
This is also the case with Barnes, as I will try to show later in this article. In terms of style, both Barnes and Schulz manifest love for the archaic, the grotesque, and the uncanny. They were extremely interested in metamorphosis and in profound transformation and experimentation. Barnes and Schulz usually shape their narratives as life-writing, a part of their autobiographies-in-progress. As it is wellknown in Schulz’s case, his Sanatorium Under the Sign of the Hourglass (1937) is a poetic recreation of his autobiography. Schulz delves into his past, and with the sensitivity of an artist merged with the capacity to recollect as a grown-up child, he embarks on a journey to reconstruct a lost and happier time. In this sense, we may understand the collection of stories in Sanatorium as a Künstlerroman, in which the discovery of Schulz’s artistic vocation goes hand-in-hand with a growing awareness of the loneliness, sadness, and near despair of his daily existence. The fatal accident that brought about his brother’s premature death in 1936 made his financial responsibilities grow; he became the sole supporter of his widowed sister, his nephew, and an aged cousin. His correspondence in these years reveals frequent bouts of depression lasting for longer periods of time.
272
Esther Sánchez-Pardo
Schulz and Barnes both painted their friends and acquaintances. The majority of Schulz’s early drawings were destroyed or lost during the war. From his extant works, the author’s self-portrait in pencil (1919) together with portraits of friends (Stanislaw Weingarten, Maria Budratzka) bear the mark of his characteristic style, which moves from realistic academic compositions to pictures full of imaginary scenes, mythological figures, and pastoral vision. In the late 1910s and early 1920s, Barnes produced detailed portrait drawings, primarily in pencil and using color and shading. A good number of her early portraits were of the Provincetown Players – e.g., a pen-and-ink portrait of Eugene O’Neill showing the highly textured style of her early, more Beardsleyesque work (a reptile is growing out of his shoulder, but the drawing is sensitive and frank) or the portrait of actress Helen Westley, with whom Barnes had a personal as well as a professional connection; the portrait of Westley appears as an illustration in her short story collection, A Book. The portrait of her friend Emily Coleman also appears in A Book; it shocks the viewer because of its distorted character. This and other images show Barnes’s peculiarly bleak view of the human being. As it has been noted, the more emotionally involved Barnes was with the subject, the more likely she was to represent that person in accordance with her own inner world, producing an image simultaneously deformed and transformed, terrifying and true. If it was the emotional proximity and intimacy that caused Barnes to reshape and deform those she loved, the origin of this process may be seen in her own early experience of intimacy. In creating the illustrations and text of Ryder, Barnes concealed fragments of her autobiography amid a true explosion of styles and genres. The illustrations of Ryder and Ladies Almanack show a marked break from Barnes’s early work. Between 1923, when A Book was published, and 1928, Barnes moved to Paris and became the lover of sculptor Thelma Wood, whose work consisted of sculpture and etchings. We wonder to what extent the fact that Wood was an artist contributed to Barnes’s decision to derive her illustrations from existing images. Barnes herself was using what Frances Doughty has called a strategy of “literal representation, hidden by borrowed and highly stylized forms that seems to have no experiential referent [which is]
Bruno Schulz and Djuna Barnes: Border-crossing and Artistic Practice
273
especially clear in these illustrations, which contain direct copies of folk images from popular culture into which Barnes inserted the faces of her family and friends” (1991: 140-141). Duchartre and Saulnier’s L’Imagerie Populaire appeared in 1926 and it was the source of many images that Barnes produced between 1926 and 1928, later on to appear in Ladies Almanack and Ryder. It is a collection of eighteenthand nineteenth-century imagiers. As Carolyn Burke has noted, Barnes’s radicalism in her visual work downplays the values of originality and creativity through her open acknowledgement of her sources and her adaptation, which is a type of “visual quotation” (1991: 77). Barnes certainly challenged the concept of artistic authority. Intrigued by the “atemporal quality” (1991: 76) of the French illustrations, Barnes used the past as a source and model; she was paradoxically engaging in a cyclical return while creating her own images. Once we acknowledge this process of “visual quotation”, we are no longer able to see her as a traditional author or to function as traditional readers. Yet Barnes’s illustrations are not as innocent as they might seem. Doughty argues that although the images are mimetically tied to the text, the passages that they illustrate are not only the most emotionally disturbing kind but also generally those that cannot be fully understood without the help of a visual image (1991: 142). Barnes uses the double-coding of visual and verbal art in many of her works in order to subvert the social structure of her time. Barnes challenges her readers and the whole social order by using canonically sanctioned writing styles (from the Elizabethan in Ryder to the avantgarde in Ladies Almanack and high modernism in Nightwood) to place her narratives in a safe, unquestionable position. Schulz’s and Barnes’s Contents With regard to content, Schulz and Barnes also share similar creative concerns. For both artists, the realm of private fantasies and the imagination coexists alongside a “realistic” rendering of human types. They are also attracted by the representation of sexuality in its multiple forms, especially the complex power relations between men and women. Their own families are central to their creative processes. They show a tendency to create self-portraits and to appear as
274
Esther Sánchez-Pardo
characters in their respective works. Their lives were also marked by loss, and their art testifies to the traumatic effects of that loss. In the case of Schulz, the loss of his father and the burning of the family home and business as a consequence of German occupation and in the case of Barnes, the deprivation of parental love, abuse, and an obligation to grow up fast and abandon the family household had a profound impact on their careers. Schulz and Barnes were both interested in transiency, bohemianism, and the precarious existence of the artist. This is shown in their interest in representing life at the circus. Anyone who has read Nightwood, with Dr. O’Connor’s splendid description of Nikka, a performer of the Cirque de Paris, would be aware of how important the visual was to Barnes.5 In Schulz’s The Idolatrous Book, several engravings pay tribute to the grotesque world of the circus (see ‘The Infanta and her Dwarfs’, ‘Mademoiselle Circe and her Troupe-circus’) Both Schulz and Barnes were also censored in their writings and visual productions. Schulz’s later drawings were never presented to the public. The intimate subject matter, bordering on obscenity, did not seem appropriate for public display, and he had to consider the consequences his drawings might have had on his reputation as a teacher in the local gymnasium. What is more, as Ficowski has written, some artistic circles would not have looked favorably upon the “dilettante”, and others, especially in the provinces, rejected his work as mere pornography (1990: 12). Under such circumstances, his drawings could only be presented as illustrations of his literary works – this was certainly the case with the illustrations Schulz designed for Sanatorium after the success of the 1934 story collection Cinnamon Shops (originally with no illustrations due to the editor’s decision to cut production costs). Barnes’s 1928 novel Ryder was censored, and its original and subsequent versions appear with a foreword by the author who explains that her work is missing fragments that are marked by blanks within the text. This was also the case with several of her explicitly 5
Barnes’s work is notorious for its interest in democratic forms of entertainment. The circus is among those forms of popular culture that undoubtedly influenced Barnes’s literary creations. Nightwood draws precisely from the cult of the circus, the sideshow and the theatre, to populate its pages, expanding on the experiences she had already written about in her earlier work as a reporter for various journals in New York City (see Marcus 1991: 221-250).
Bruno Schulz and Djuna Barnes: Border-crossing and Artistic Practice
275
sexual illustrations to the text. Ladies Almanack faced similar circumstances due to the fact that this booklet was self-published and circulated furtively among the circles of the Paris Left Bank in the late 1920s. Djuna Barnes: Early Work The majority of Barnes’s early drawings were originally published in newspapers along with her interviews, stories, and essays. Her first four books (Book of Repulsive Women, Smoke, Ladies Almanack, Ryder) also interweave illustrations and text. Even in her great novel Nightwood (1936), which contains no drawings, Barnes focuses much of her concern on linguistic descriptions of tableaux vivants. It is impossible to separate the visual from the verbal in Barnes’s work. This has led scholars of Barnes to describe her writing as emblematic, “both text and visual image are given equal weight, each comprehensible on its own terms, but together redefining and reshaping the other” (Messerli 1995: 7). For both Barnes and Schulz, the interplay between the textual and the visual is of paramount importance; one dimension cannot exist without the other because they are complementary, and full meaning is only produced through the creative convergence of the two. As Douglas Messerli has noted, Barnes often sketched her subjects during her interviews as she recorded her conversations with her interviewees (1995: 5). There is also a tendency in her written works to describe the visual appearances of those with whom she has spoken. In her journalism, with the urgency and artistic limitations of the genre, Barnes’s drawings served as snapshots that captured, among other things, the reality of life in the streets of Paris and New York. In her novels, it is through the visual that Barnes reveals her characters and the rationale behind their acts. Barnes struggled to situate her work within a specific style in line with her sensitivity and her concerns. She recasts many of her subjects in fin de siècle contexts and established a fruitful dialogue with her revolutionary predecessor, Beardsley. Around 1915, Barnes began to borrow the style of Beardsley and set her Greenwich Village bohemians and her early literary characters in a world of decadence; this was an art world divorced from the realistic portrayal of her previous New York scenes. She embraced this Beardsleyesque style
276
Esther Sánchez-Pardo
up to the 1920s when she started to incorporate other sources into her work, especially emblem books, chapbooks, and almanacs from earlier centuries. By the late 1920s, from the Ladies Almanack on, Barnes’s style manifests a profound change; once again the imitation of older art forms takes her subjects out of a contemporary context and places them in a remote world, the world of art. This is apparent in her sketches and descriptions of figures from that time when Barnes’s interest in the grotesque becomes obvious. Bruno Schulz and the Enigma of The Idolatrous Book Even before he was a writer, Schulz came closest to creating a complete book with his early The Idolatrous Book (1920-22), a portfolio of black-and-white engravings with titles like ‘Tribe of Pariahs’ and ‘The Infanta and her Dwarfs,’ all depicting women with men abasing themselves at their feet. Schulz was a brilliant caricaturist, and his own face was used many times as a recurrent motif in his work. In The Idolatrous Book, Schulz appears as part of the crowd, center stage with his face tilted and with a small dwarfish body crawling toward the foot of a woman. Systematically, the women are indifferent and take no notice of their suitors. The book contains a series of engravings in which women are depicted as superior beings while men adapt to their role of subordinate creatures, praising and adoring the all-powerful women and their qualities. It is clear and highly significant that the primary opposition on which the book is based is that of gender, and from there a second binary emerges: the opposition of the visual and the verbal. On the cover illustration Schulz designed for The Idolatrous Book, he shows the female idol sitting on a throne that looks very much like a book. The Idolatrous Book is Schulz’s only series of engravings, created in 1920-22. The series is governed by the idea of idolatry, the veneration of a Woman-idol by a submissive Man-slave. That motif dominates the majority of Schulz’s graphic works: the celebration of gynocracy, the rule of women over men who find satisfaction in pain and humiliation at the hands of their female rulers. Suffering seems to be the condition of love. Throughout the entire portfolio, books are presented as the male domain par excellence whereas the idol is given an obvious
Bruno Schulz and Djuna Barnes: Border-crossing and Artistic Practice
277
female shape. Most of the engravings in The Idolatrous Book are characterized by the pattern of looking and being looked upon. The female figure is always the object of looking – usually the object of the male gaze, or by extension the object of her own gaze as reflected in a mirror – whereas the male, apparently in a subservient position, governs the field of vision (Van Heuckelom 2006). Critics have described these female figures as “idealized” or “goddesses,” but their poses, the faces full of ennui and the surprisingly stylish dress could well represent the “New Women” of the turn of the century. These women may be enthroned or languidly reposing on a bed or divan or carriage seat. A persistent motif in The Idolatrous Book is that of a carriage sweeping through the dark, sometimes drawn by horses, sometimes drawn by the Schulz figure himself. In The Idolatrous Book Schulz manages both to approach and to stay out of the woman’s way simultaneously with a peculiar mixture of longing and detachment. The series is clearly obsessed with masochism and deviant sexuality. Masochism as a sexual deviation becomes a ritual of prostration in front of the idol and is shown in scenes of transformation of humans into beasts, in gestures of worship, genuflection, abjection, and slavery. As Ficowski writes, In these drawings the stigma of slavery marking the faces of the men (sometimes little Negroes, as a symbol of slavery) is combined with teratoid deformation of their whole figures, their dwarfing and animalization – in short, with a metaphor of degradation. Such a caricature or “black magic” transformation affects only the Idolaters and never the Idol. The woman is untouchable, not only free of deformation but idealized, as if presented with greater care for her beauty and charm than for the pictorial quality of the drawing, its stylistic and formal unity. (1990: 6)
In Ficowski’s view, the drawing shows the self-contained perfection of the woman and even the line of the drawing is different from those of the rest of the composition. One of the demonic elements Ficowski identifies as central in The Idolatrous Book is fetishism, which is clearly present in the attention to detail, especially to feminine attire, from shoes to clothes to body parts. As Ewa Kuryluk states, when Schulz was working on The Idolatrous Book, he told his students that he had been illustrating
278
Esther Sánchez-Pardo 6
Sacher-Masoch’s novel Venus im Pelz (Venus in Furs), indeed a book “of idolatry” and the founding literary text of masochism (1990: 32). As Kuryluk writes, Schulz’s women, evocative of powerful pagan goddesses seem to be superior. But their superiority is also a form of degradation. The erotic prominence of femaleness is associated with the all-encompassing but inferior quality of womb, mother, and earth, and connected, like in the Old Testament and in Platonic philosophy, to matter, ignorance, and immortality. This archaic vision of femininity as omnipotent nature and low culture prevails in Schulz’s texts and pictures where women represent a physical threat and an irresistible temptation. (1990: 33)
Ficowski has proved that Schulz’s art finds also a rudimentary source, which he himself speaks about in his story ‘The Book’: advertisements and personal announcements from old magazines. Schulz brought these dead pictures to life making them unfold in stories that develop their hidden potential. The innovative and self-reflective character of The Idolatrous Book has recently been underlined by Kris Van Heuckelom (2006) who writes: This proclaimed autoreferential character of The Booke ensues directly from the fact that the title of the books seems to have a twofold application. It refers firstly, to the material product created by the artist (a portfolio of engravings). Secondly, it designates a similar object (a book) being depicted on the engravings themselves (creating thus the effect of a sui generis mise-en-abîme). The double position of the book, both inside and outside of the depicted world, enables and urges the reader to reflect upon the function and the status of the artifact he is dealing with.
This extreme self-reflexivity manifests itself in how the book shows the act of its own creation and in the presence of the book-within-thebook motif. The final stage of the process of creation is evident on the final engraving, which has the same title as the entire portfolio (‘The Idolatrous Book’). The work-in-progress is also shown in the seventh engraving (‘Undula with the Artists’), which depicts the female idol Undula looking at a sheet of paper and surrounded by a group of male artists, who are apparently sculptors and painters. The separate sheets 6
As Ewa Kuryluk aptly remarks, Sacher-Masoch’s and Schulz’s preoccupation with male degradation do not reflect simply their personal choice for analysis; they instead testify to the masochism of late nineteenth-century Europe (Schulz 1990: 34)
Bruno Schulz and Djuna Barnes: Border-crossing and Artistic Practice
279
lying at Undula’s feet may be regarded as drafts or as final revisions of the engravings that will eventually constitute the “idolatrous book”. (Van Heuckelom 2006) The enigmatic Idolatrous Book still possesses an aura of mystery with its eclectic mixture of themes and motifs and shows the contradictions that stem from this unique combination of worship and demonism, elegance and abjection, initiation and knowledge. Schulz delves into an atmosphere where everything, even the human body, transmutes into dead matter, and this finally translates into stories. Barnes’s Critique in The Book of Repulsive Women Originally published by Guido Bruno as part of his chapbook series, The Book of Repulsive Women contains eight poems and five illustrations. As Burke has noted, there is something troubling about the eroticism of the images (1991: 70), and when we place them within the context of the verbal text, we begin to see how the book as a whole constitutes an attempt to write radically with pictures. In 1912, a twenty-year-old Barnes moved with her mother to New York from her home in Cornwall-on-Hudson, thereby joining the mass exodus from country to city which occurred in these years. She was young, but she had already lived through incest in her childhood and a broken marriage in her teens. A year after her arrival in New York, Barnes began publishing articles in the Brooklyn Eagle and entered an American tradition by joining the ranks of notable journalist-cum-fiction writers such as Mark Twain, Stephen Crane, and Theodore Dreiser. Journalism, like everything else, was undergoing changes in these years. Gone was the comfortable reporting of the nineteenth century when the journalist from a cool distance objectively stated the facts of an event. Many felt that this detached, god-like poise was entirely inadequate in this fast, rapidly changing, and fragmentary world where the journalist felt just as bewildered as other mortals. It is known that Barnes carried out participatory journalism as a means of closing the distance between the reporter and the event: firstly, in order to better guarantee the validity of her angle; and secondly, as a means of imbuing news with human warmth and thereby affecting her readership. Her experience as journalist would leave its mark on some of her early work, such as
280
Esther Sánchez-Pardo
her first book of poetry, The Book of Repulsive Women, published in 1915. Just as a newspaper is necessarily made up of fragments of news forming a collage so too is Barnes’s little book, subtitled 8 rhythms and 5 drawings. It is a collage of drawings and poems, each with a headline, often hinting at some piece of news caught by the camera lens as the journalist travels around New York. In this sense, just as Dos Passos’s Manhattan Transfer is a portrait of the city, this book constitutes an angle on New York. Interestingly, it is also piece of Barnes’s intimate autobiography in those years of apprenticeship away from the family household, when she was trying to establish herself as a writer. In The Book of Repulsive Women, however, we are not shown the hustle and bustle, the skyscrapers, and the fast cars of the big city. Here there is no rendering of the rich and successful. On the contrary, and in keeping with Barnes’s later work, we are shown some of the realities that perhaps the establishment would rather not emphasize. Barnes depicts marginal figures that society would prefer to ignore; she makes news of those who would never be news unless, as in the final poem, it were through their final capitulation before the system – her poem ‘Suicide’ closes this collection. The sweeping eye of the journalist captures the dark side of life and treats its inhabitants with warmth and sympathy, giving them a place of equal right in the fabric of society. In this sense, The Book of Repulsive Women prefigures Nightwood, which concentrates on marginal groups and, as Jane Marcus puts it, “[it] figures by absence the authoritarian dominators of Europe in the thirties, the sexual and political fascists” (1991: 221). This little book of poems also figures by absence the upright, hegemonic power against which its women protagonists are measured and found wanting. This sense of otherness is signaled by Shari Benstock, who maintains that “the fall from innocence […] results from the realization that woman in Western society is defined by her difference from the masculine norm” (1986: 241). Benstock reads The Book of Repulsive Women as “part of a developing critique of woman’s place in modern society. The decadence and depravity of [the] women […] is an effect of patriarchal culture” (1986: 241). Along the same lines, Marcus points out with reference to Nightwood that Barnes’s aim was “to assert that the outcast is normal and truly
Bruno Schulz and Djuna Barnes: Border-crossing and Artistic Practice
281
human… Barnes makes us all misfits claiming that in human misery we can find the animal and divine in ourselves” (1991: 233). If Barnes intended an embracing of difference, what made her focus The Book of Repulsive Women on women’s loss of innocence, on women’s destruction? What made her choose precisely “repulsive women” as her subject matter? It is a fact that The Book of Repulsive Women has been relatively ignored in Barnes scholarship. Despite the poems directness and lack of sophistication when compared with her mature work, they remain a troubling part of the Barnes canon. Apart from the shocking ending with feminine suicide, one of the answers to this neglect can be found in the accompanying illustrations heavily influenced by Beardsley. As we move through the cycle of poems, which in some way mirrors one day and night, we first encounter the woman in ‘From Fifth Avenue Up’ who is called upon to reveal her sexual orientation, while the protagonist in ‘From Third Avenue On’ has “a vacant space…in her face” (1994: 20). Their companion in ‘Seen from the L’ stands naked with a “risky” body (24). She is certainly an appropriate precursor to the women in ‘Twilight of the Illicit’ and ‘To a Cabaret Dancer’ who start as dangerous and bestial but end up defeated, thus leading finally to the corpse of ‘Suicide’ – powerless, voiceless. On the one hand, the poems create portraits of women who experience brief moments of freedom outside the conventions that would capture and silence them. On the other hand, these women are ultimately defeated by those societal conventions. In this sense, these women are “repulsive” because like the suicide they prefigure, they end their own lives, thereby suffocating their protest and negating themselves and their voices. ‘In General’ and ‘In Particular’ are two very short and very obscure poems that can be considered to constitute a diptych. As their names suggest we move from the general to the particular, from a sense of bitter disillusionment to the concrete reason for this disillusionment, and this reason is once again the abuse suffered. ‘In General’ starts with “altar cloth” and its sacred connotations then moves on immediately to question this sacredness with the use of the oxymoron “rag of worth”. “Unpriced” also allows the double reading of priceless or with no price, i.e., worthless. The next lines introduce us into a game of chance, yet the “Undiced” of the next line suggest that in this case, there was no chance. The last lines, “And you we
282
Esther Sánchez-Pardo
valued still a little / More than Christ” (17), give us a final clue to the meaning of the poem. Christ, as both God and son of God, simultaneously connotes the sacrifice of the child at the hands of the father and the father figure itself, imbued with all the power and authority that a father has for a child. These lines give us a poignant vision of the extent of the disillusionment the child suffers when her father, her god who can do no wrong, stoops to abuse. ‘In Particular’ ratifies this reading with its overt references to “loin”, “wrong”, “body”, and “lust”, and again the last two lines, now with “valued” substituted by “Worshipped” (25) – a word which suggests the blind faith that the religious place in their God – a reiteration of the bitter accusation of the child toward her father, her god. The five original black-and-white illustrations present images of women, animals, and inanimate objects. Four of the five drawings have clear borders, but all of the images challenge these borders with off-center subjects and large areas of either blankness or black background. The women of the poems are always off-center, paradoxically surviving and thriving on the margins. This power of the margin is exemplified in the first drawing in the series in the original chapbook, opposite the poem ‘From Third Avenue On’. Against a black rectangle, Barnes creates a white image of a tall woman, walking out of the frame, accompanied by two birds. The woman is dressed in a white-patterned jacket, wide-legged pants, and white shoes. She smiles as she walks, projecting a seemingly positive image of her independence, creativity, and freedom. That the birds would seem to be “cocks” and that one is positioned between her legs seems to reinforce further an impression of power. Yet this woman is restricted to only a third of the picture space. She is off-center; the two birds, including the “cock”, seem to occupy a more prominent position. Even more disturbing is the thick blackness of the image. Although the woman seems to be liberated and powerful, she is simultaneously marginalized, pushed to the edges of a bounded illustration, never to escape the frame. As a prototypical “New Woman” of the turn-of-the-century, single and professional, Barnes did not fit into the societal scheme nor did her writing entirely correspond to the writing of high modernism. As Louis Kannenstine pointed out, “although Barnes’s work displays certain affinities with the major literary movements of the early years of the twentieth century, it cannot be said to wholly conform to any of
Bruno Schulz and Djuna Barnes: Border-crossing and Artistic Practice
283
these movements” (in Benstock 1986: 233) and “it is precisely Barnes’s relation to literary tradition that so troubles assessments of her work: readers do not know where to ‘place’ her” (in Benstock 1986: 242). Finally, why does Barnes remain on the margins of literature and art? We might answer the question by focusing on her emphasis on the body: she exalts it, sings its intricacies, hidden places, and dark desires. Barnes writes about the emotions as opposed to cool rationalism; she writes herself fearlessly into her work, and from this personal perspective, she addresses many themes, all of which constitute an attack on the values of the day. In The Book of Repulsive Women, she shows prostitution, the hypocrisy of the upright, “perverse” sexuality, suicide, loneliness, squalor, and underlying all these she deals with the taboo subjects of incest and rape. These themes and attitudes were more than sufficient to convert her, in the eyes of her society, as a real danger to the way of life supported and promoted by the capitalist system; it was necessary for the good of all that these women’s voices be silenced and so it came to pass, through feigned indifference and ridicule. The Convergences of Schulz and Barnes Schulz’s visual and verbal art has many features in common with Barnes’s: their stories converge on the absurd and the grotesque; they deal with conflicts within the family and specifically between childhood and adulthood; and their production is to a large extent autobiographical. In their visual artwork, the figure of the artist is central and constantly appears in self-portraits; and they both refuse to devalorize the popular culture from which they draw many of their images. Their themes were common to German expressionist prose and poetry and to French decadent art: the mechanization and dehumanization of life, the anthropomorphic character of the natural world, teratoid figures, and dummies and dolls that may come to life. Barnes’s early journalism includes several stories about the sideshow, the circus, the zoo, and other forms of mass entertainment where bodies are displayed before paying audiences; this is shown in her best known novel Nightwood. Understanding Barnes’s characters as “freaks” sheds light on her attempt to portray radical forms of sexual
284
Esther Sánchez-Pardo
difference and to find an appropriate stylistic form to depict Otherness. Thus, contemporary scholars interested in the novel’s lesbian themes focus on the relationship between Robin, Nora, and Jenny whereas others concentrate on its marginal characters. In Nightwood, there are multiple allusions to dolls, and, as it has been noted, the doll as a substitute for the child is a reference to nonreproductive sexuality.7 In Schulz’s story ‘Tailors’ Dummies’ – included in Cinnamon Shops – a dressmaker’s shop assistants work under the gaze of an anthropomorphized dummy. The dummy’s control over the situation creates ambiguity around her inanimate figure, and what follows is the father figure’s growing obsession with the animation of dummies. He becomes fascinated with the idea that human beings, as well as God, are capable of creating life. The father’s preoccupation with the animation of nature is grotesque because it so strongly emphasizes the mechanical aspect of the body. Both Schulz and Barnes present us with the irruption of the grotesque in their work. The grotesque depends on an unexpected and unsettling contrast to achieve its effect, and it requires some grounding in reality in order not to be classified as purely absurd or frightening. In the grotesque, the human body is a common focal point. When the given limits of the body are transgressed, the result can be either disturbing or comical with an emphasis on artificiality and ambiguity. Often Schulz’s and Barnes’s works describe the old world coming to an end in a context of natural disasters and decay, usually interspersed with observations on the state of the bourgeois world. The idea of a natural phenomenon behaving in unnatural ways echoes the expressionist idea that the unexpected has become commonplace. Modernity, it is implied, requires a reordering of accepted beliefs and the casual acceptance of the grotesque in everyday life. In The Idolatrous Book, the grotesque effect is magnified by the fact that the reader is aware from the start that there is a mixture of real-life characters and fictional characters. In The Book of Repulsive Women something analogous occurs. The mysterious figures that often appear in the background blur the line between reality and the 7
For discussions about the novel’s lesbian themes, see Julie Abraham (1996), Carolyn Allen (1996), and Frann Michel (1989). Karen Kaivola (1991) and Jane Marcus (1991) pay special attention to Nightwood’s marginal characters.
Bruno Schulz and Djuna Barnes: Border-crossing and Artistic Practice
285
imagined fears and dangers to which women are exposed, making the figures grotesque and even uncanny – familiar yet unfamiliar as in the Freudian sense.8 In any event, the ambivalent nature of Schulz and Barnes’s visual and verbal production complicates interpretation and keeps their work from being simply comical or horrifying. In literary history, the effectiveness of these resources carries over from times of confrontation and conflict – the interval between the two world wars – into the periods of peace that follow. They appear not only to make sense of contemporary crises but also to make sense of, or at least give voice to, the emotional aftereffects of such a crisis. I would like to draw attention to the importance of the grotesque with regard to the effect a text has on a reader. Because the grotesque thrives on the inability to synthesize two opposing forces, it provides us with a useful way of looking at the impossibility of “closure” in the texts we are examining. The grotesque requires an intense negotiation of meaning and the transgression of boundaries, and it depends on the reader’s response to achieve full effect. It opens up new perspectives by revealing a hidden reality, and it inspires, particularly as a result of its fragmentary nature, reflection that reaches beyond the text. Finally, we should also note that Schulz and Barnes were warding off silence in their dense and complex works, in part because of their suspicion that not all could be said in words and that the silence of the visual image was an ideal that language could emulate but never attain. In The Idolatrous Book, Schulz probably felt visual images were somehow superior to literary ones; in The Book of Repulsive Women, Barnes, preoccupied with the relationship between words and images, repeatedly reflected on the impossibility of conveying adequate images of women. From their different gender positions, Schulz and Barnes show a deep concern about the functions of representation and interpretation. 8
Hoffmann’s novella Der Sandmann (1817) is considered the definitive grotesque text of the nineteenth century, in large part because of Freud’s treatment of it in his essay ‘Das Unheimliche’ (1919). Freud writes about a familiar object or event that returns in unfamiliar form (1955 [1919]). In literature, the uncanny can be used as a way of dealing with moments of crisis, even collective trauma, since incomprehensibility in literature enacts the same situation in life.
286
Esther Sánchez-Pardo
Conclusion Neither Barnes’s repulsive women nor Schulz’s “women idols” fit into conventional formats; they are never perfect models that lend themselves to mimetic realism. These women are all powerful and powerless, always restrained by a society that is unable to accept them in their emotional and sexual freedom. They walk away from the center but are paradoxically contained by the borders – a visual contradiction that mirrors the verbal contradictions present in Barnes’s series of poems about strong women who end up as suicides. In the case of Schulz, women are constrained as objects of the male gaze. As a response to the ironic centrality of the “New Woman” of the fin de siècle who was frequently observed and feared by men (Showalter 1990: 127-8), Barnes’s women, our most extreme instance, ignore the masculine gaze and instead celebrate their own freedom by quitting society altogether.9 With The Book of Repulsive Women, Barnes challenges the canonical through a combination of radical visual and verbal techniques. She came to realize that the only way for her to gain entrance into this space was to play by its rules and to subvert it from within. Schulz and Barnes placed emphasis on physicality, on the body when the entire western world wanted to forget physicality by focusing on the superphysical. They showed humankind with raw animality, stripped bare of the comforting veils of humanity. And they proudly showed and wrote fearlessly about themselves. They constructed a poetics of the body and spoke to us in many voices, moving from the margins to perform a true polyphony, a magnificent chorus that grants Modernist texts their privileged status in contemporary literary history. How can one write about oneself from a position of marginality and expect to be read? The complex terrain between visual and verbal art was undoubtedly a privileged medium with which to violate the barrier of 9
In this way, Barnes is addressing what Carol Laing identifies as the structures of gender that surrounded Barnes in 1920s Paris: “Barnes describes the conditions of abjection before the fact, simultaneously beseeching and pulverizing her female subjects because they are impossible, ambiguous, and in perceptual danger, preempted by the One who has already set everything in its place, with whom she cannot identify without becoming him” (1992: 70). Barnes conveys a dark message, to live only in the conventional world amounts to choosing silence and suicide.
Bruno Schulz and Djuna Barnes: Border-crossing and Artistic Practice
287
repression and circumvent the institution of censorship. Schulz and Barnes, each in their own way, refused the symbolic constructs that humankind used to make life more bearable and opposed the dominant trends of thought in their time. In their oeuvres they actively work against replacing the flesh with a cultural construct. They also predict the dilemmas of contemporary artists before their radical alienation from the self, and they perhaps also predict a time when the body will regain its precedence over the Word and humanity will be once more humanized. Finally, the eclecticism of current definitions of the avantgarde does not necessarily fit in with the singularity of its major representatives. Why should we exclude Barnes or Schulz as important contributors to twentieth-century European avant-garde? As other scholars and critics sympathetic to Barnes’s and Schulz’s engagement with their own work, we would also heartily endorse complementing the well-known facade of modern art with the ignored backstage: the stylistic revolution of Djuna Barnes and Bruno Schulz, whose escape into the past ended in the future. Bibliography Abraham, Julie. 1996. Are Girls Necessary? Lesbian Writing and Modern Histories. New York: Routledge. Allen, Carolyn. 1996. Following Djuna: Women Lovers and the Erotics of Loss. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. Barnes, Djuna. 1994. The Book of Repulsive Women (ed. D. Messerli). Los Angeles: Sun & Moon Press. ——. 1995. Poe’s Mother. Selected Drawings of Djuna Barnes (ed. D. Messerli). Los Angeles: Sun & Moon Press. Benstock, Shari. 1986. Women of the Left Bank: Paris, 1900-1940. Austin: University of Texas Press. Broe, Mary Lynn (ed.) 1991. Silence and Power. A Reevaluation of Djuna Barnes. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press. Burke, Carolyn. 1991. ‘Accidental Aloofness: Barnes, Loy, and Modernism’ in Broe (1991): 67-79. Cather, Willa. 1936. Not Under Forty. New York: Knopf. Doughty, Frances. 1991. ‘Gilt on Cardboard. Djuna Barnes as Illustrator of Her Life and Work’ in Broe (1991): 137-154. Herring, Philip. 1995. Djuna. The Life and Work of Djuna Barnes. New York: Viking. Freud, Sigmund. 1955 [1919]. ‘The Uncanny’ in Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud. Vol XVII. London: Hogarth Press: 217-256. Kaivola, Karen. 1991. All Contraries Confounded. Iowa: University of Iowa Press.
288
Esther Sánchez-Pardo
Laing, Carol. 1992. ‘Rhetoric and Ornament: Reading (S)exchanges and Violence in Work by Women’ in Public 6: 65-80. Marcus, Jane. 1991. ‘Laughing at Leviticus. Nightwood as Woman’s Circus Epic’ in Broe (1991): 221-250. Messerli, Douglas (ed.) 1995. ‘Introduction’ in Barnes (1995): 5-9. Michel, Frann. 1989. ‘Displacing Castration: Nightwood, Ladies Almanack and Feminine Writing’ in Contemporary Literature 30(1): 33-58. Schulz, Bruno. 1988. The Fictions of Bruno Schulz (tr. C. Wieniewska). London: Picador. ——. 1990. The Drawings of Bruno Schulz (ed. J. Ficowski). Evanston, Il.: Northwestern University Press. Showalter, Elaine. 1990. Sexual Anarchy. Gender and Culture at the Fin de Siècle. New York: Penguin. Slessor, Catherine. 2000. The Art of Aubrey Beardsley. London: Chancellor Press. Van Heuckelom, Kris. 2006. ‘Artistic Crossover in Polish Modernism. The Case of Bruno Schulz’s Xi ga Bawochwalcza (The Idolatrous Booke)’ in Image [&] Narrative. Online Magazine of the Visual Narrative 15. On line at: (consulted http://www.imageandnarrative.be/iconoclasm/heuckelom.htm 18.05.2008)
Bruno Schulz’s Incomparable Realities: From Literature to Theatricality Daniel Watt Abstract: Bruno Schulz’s fiction has influenced fantastical literature profoundly without engendering attempts to replicate it directly. Rather the stories have generated a mood and atmosphere which resists any clear critical strategy to interpret them. It is interesting therefore that “reading” the work seems to call for some form of representation, in the form of art, theatre, or film. This essay examines the theatrical representation of his texts (Complicite’s Street of Crocodiles and Double Edge Theatre’s Republic of Dreams), its influence on other dramatic events (Tadeusz Kantor’s Dead Class), and the ensuing creation of phantasmagorical worlds of eroticised objects (The Quay Brothers’ Street of Crocodiles).
Introduction: An “Illegal Event’, a “Doubtful Manoeuvre” or a “Cul-de-sac”? What might a faithful adaptation of Schulz’s work consist of? It is a question that arose from teaching, not from research. I have been attempting to teach Schulz’s texts and their various stage and film adaptations for an undergraduate module on “adaptation”. For this course we use an admirable text, Julie Sanders’ Adaptation and Appropriation (2006). In it Sanders distinguishes two broad strategies for the transformation of prose to stage, or a variety of media in their migration to other forms of “entertainment”. These are, as the title might well suggest: adaptation – the relatively straightforward transposition of one work into the new medium, in an attempt to render a faithful repetition in the new form; and appropriation – the essential characters, themes, or issues, transposed and represented in a somewhat changed or even entirely different setting. This essay begins therefore by asking: are stage and screen adaptations of Schulz’s work “doubtful manoeuvres” or “cul-de-sacs” in understanding his work? Schulz himself provides something of an answer concerning transformations:
290
Daniel Watt There is no dead matter…lifelessness is only a disguise behind which hide unknown forms of life. The range of these forms is infinite and their shades and nuances limitless. The Demiurge was in possession of important and interesting creative recipes. Thanks to them he created a multiplicity of species which renew themselves by their own devices. No one knows whether these recipes will ever be reconstructed. But this is unnecessary, because even if the classical methods of creation should prove inaccessible for evermore, there still remain some illegal methods, an infinity of heretical and criminal methods. (Schulz 1998: 30)
Of course, the matter of which Father speaks is precisely that: matter. The ever-present mood of ‘Tailors’ Dummies’ is the props cupboard, the storeroom of old children’s toys fashioned variously from tubing, canvas and cardboard, whitewashed and emblazoned with memory and imagination. So to extend my question in light of the transformation of matter that Schulz is so obsessed with, is it possible that theatre and film are just materials in the “heretical and criminal” methodology of Schulz criticism? Do these “multiple species”, originating from the Schulzian fermenting matter of the p