Wild Crop Relatives: Genomic and Breeding Resources
.
Chittaranjan Kole Editor
Wild Crop Relatives: Genomic and Breeding Resources Millets and Grasses
Editor Prof. Chittaranjan Kole Director of Research Institute of Nutraceutical Research Clemson University 109 Jordan Hall Clemson, SC 29634
[email protected]
ISBN 978-3-642-14254-3 e-ISBN 978-3-642-14255-0 DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-14255-0 Springer Heidelberg Dordrecht London New York # Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011 This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer. Violations are liable to prosecution under the German Copyright Law. The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Cover design: deblik, Berlin printed on acid-free paper Springer is part of Springer Science+Business Media (www.springer.com)
Dedication
Dr. Norman Ernest Borlaug,1 the Father of Green Revolution, is well respected for his contributions to science and society. There was or is not and never will be a single person on this Earth whose single-handed service to science could save millions of people from death due to starvation over a period of over four decades like Dr. Borlaug’s. Even the Nobel Peace Prize he received in 1970 does not do such a great and noble person as Dr. Borlaug justice. His life and contributions are well known and will remain in the pages of history of science. I wish here only to share some facets of this elegant and ideal personality I had been blessed to observe during my personal interactions with him. It was early 2007 while I was at the Clemson University as a visiting scientist one of my lab colleagues told me that “somebody wants to talk to you; he appears to be an old man”. I took the telephone receiver casually and said hello. The response from the other side was – “I am Norman Borlaug; am I talking to Chitta?” Even a million words would be insufficient to define and depict the exact feelings and thrills I experienced at that moment!
1
The photo of Dr. Borlaug was kindly provided by Julie Borlaug (Norman Borlaug Institute for International Agriculture, Texas A&M Agriculture) the granddaughter of Dr. Borlaug.
v
vi
I had seen Dr. Borlaug only once, way back in 1983, when he came to New Delhi, India to deliver the Coromandal Lecture organized by Prof. M.S. Swaminathan on the occasion of the 15th International Genetic Congress. However, my real interaction with him began in 2004 when I had been formulating a 7-volume book series entitled Genome Mapping and Molecular Breeding in Plants. Initially, I was neither confident of my ability as a series/book editor nor of the quality of the contents of the book volumes. I sent an email to Dr. Borlaug attaching the table of contents and the tentative outline of the chapters along with manuscripts of only a few sample chapters, including one authored by me and others, to learn about his views as a source of inspiration (or caution!) I was almost sure that a person of his stature would have no time and purpose to get back to a small science worker like me. To my utter (and pleasant) surprise I received an email from him that read: “May all Ph.D.’s, future scientists, and students that are devoted to agriculture get an inspiration as it refers to your work or future work from the pages of this important book. My wholehearted wishes for a success on your important job”. I got a shot in my arm (and in mind for sure)! Rest is a pleasant experience – the seven volumes were published by Springer in 2006 and 2007, and were welcome and liked by students, scientists and their societies, libraries, and industries. As a token of my humble regards and gratitude, I sent Dr. Borlaug the Volume I on Cereals and Millets that was published in 2006. And here started my discovery of the simplest person on Earth who solved the most complex and critical problem of people on it – hunger and death. Just one month after receiving the volume, Dr. Borlaug called me one day and said, “Chitta, you know I cannot read a lot now-a-days, but I have gone through only on the chapters on wheat, maize and rice. Please excuse me. Other chapters of this and other volumes of the series will be equally excellent, I believe”. He was highly excited to know that many other Nobel Laureates including Profs. Arthur Kornberg, Werner Arber, Phillip Sharp, G€ unter Blobel, and Lee Hartwell also expressed generous comments regarding the utility and impact of the book series on science and the academic society. While we were discussing many other textbooks and review book series that I was editing at that time, again in my night hours for the benefit of students, scientists, and industries, he became emotional and said to me, “Chitta, forget about your original contributions to basic and applied sciences, you deserved Nobel Prize for Peace like me for providing academic foods to millions of starving students and scientists over the world particularly in the developing countries. I will recommend your name for the World Food Prize, but it will not do enough justice to the sacrifice you are doing for science and society in your sleepless nights over so many years. Take some rest Chitta and give time to Phullara, Sourav and Devleena” (he was so particular to ask about my wife and our kids during most of our conversations). I felt honored but really very ashamed as I am aware of my almost insignificant contribution in comparison to his monumental contribution and thousands of scientists over the world are doing at least hundred-times better jobs than me as scientist or author/editor of books! So, I was unable to utter any words for a couple of minutes but realized later that he must been too affectionate to me and his huge affection is the best award for a small science worker as me! In another occasion he wanted some documents from me. I told him that I will send them as attachments in emails. Immediately he shouted and told me: “You know, Julie (his granddaughter) is not at home now and I cannot check email myself. Julie does this for me. I can type myself in type writer but I am not good in computer. You know what, I have a xerox machine and it receives fax also. Send me
Dedication
Dedication
vii
the documents by fax”. Here was the ever-present child in him. Julie emailed me later to send the documents as attachment to her as the ‘xerox machine’ of Dr. Borlaug ran out of ink! Another occasion is when I was talking with him in a low voice, and he immediately chided me: “You know that I cannot hear well now-a-days; I don’t know where Julie has kept the hearing apparatus, can’t you speak louder?” Here was the fatherly figure who was eager to hear each of my words! I still shed tears when I remember during one of our telephone conversations he asked: “You know I have never seen you, can you come to Dallas in the near future by chance?” I remember we were going through a financial paucity at that time and I could not make a visit to Dallas (Texas) to see him, though it would have been a great honor. In late 2007, whenever I tried to talk to Dr. Borlaug, he used to beckon Julie to bring the telephone to him, and in course of time Julie used to keep alive all the communications between us when he slowly succumbed to his health problems. The remaining volumes of the Genome Mapping and Molecular Breeding in Plants series were published in 2007, and I sent him all the seven volumes. I wished to learn about his views. During this period he could not speak and write well. Julie prepared a letter based on his words to her that read: “Dear Chitta, I have reviewed the seven volumes of the series on Genome Mapping and Molecular Breeding in Plants, which you have authored. You have brought together genetic linkage maps based on molecular markers for the most important crop species that will be a valuable guide and tool to further molecular crop improvements. Congratulations for a job well done”. During one of our conversations in mid-2007, he asked me what other book projects I was planning for Ph.D. students and scientists (who had always been his all-time beloved folks). I told him that the wealth of wild species already utilized and to be utilized for genetic analysis and improvement of domesticated crop species have not been deliberated in any book project. He was very excited and told me to take up the book project as soon as possible. But during that period I had a huge commitment to editing a number of book volumes and could not start the series he was so interested about. His sudden demise in September 2009 kept me so morose for a number of months that I could not even communicate my personal loss to Julie. But in the meantime, I formulated a 10-volume series on Wild Crop Relatives: Genomic and Breeding Resources for Springer. And whom else to dedicate this series to other than Dr. Borlaug! I wrote to Julie for her formal permission and she immediately wrote me: “Chitta, Thank you for contacting me and yes I think my grandfather would be honored with the dedication of the series. I remember him talking of you and this undertaking quite often. Congratulations on all that you have accomplished!” This helped me a lot as I could at least feel consoled that I could do a job he wanted me to do and I will always remain grateful to Julie for this help and also for taking care of Dr. Borlaug, not only as his granddaughter but also as the representative of millions of poor people from around the world and hundreds of plant and agricultural scientists who try to follow his philosophy and worship him as a father figure. It is another sad experience of growing older in life that we walk alone and miss the affectionate shadows, inspirations, encouragements, and blessings from the fatherly figures in our professional and personal lives. How I wish I could treat my next generations in the same way as personalities like Mother Teresa and Dr. Norman Borlaug and many other great people from around the world treated me!
viii
Dedication
During most of our conversations he used to emphasize on the immediate impact of research on the society and its people. A couple of times he even told me that my works on molecular genetics and biotechnology, particularly of 1980s and 1990s, have high fundamental importance, but I should also do some works that will benefit people immediately. This advice elicited a change in my thoughts and workplans and since then I have been devotedly endeavoring to develop crop varieties enriched with phytomedicines and nutraceuticals. Borlaug influenced both my personal and professional life, particularly my approach to science, and I dedicate this series to him in remembrance of his great contribution to science and society and for all his personal affection, love and blessings for me. I emailed the above draft of the dedication page to Julie for her views and I wish to complete my humble dedication with great satisfaction with the words of Julie who served as the living ladder for me to reach and stay closer to such as great human being as Dr. Borlaug and express my deep regards and gratitude to her. Julie’s email read: “Chitta, Thank you for sending me the draft dedication page. I really enjoyed reading it and I think you captured my grandfather’s spirit wonderfully. . .. So thank you very much for your beautiful words. I know he would be and is honored.” Clemson, USA
Chittaranjan Kole
Preface
Wild crop relatives have been playing enormously important roles both in the depiction of plant genomes and the genetic improvement of their cultivated counterparts. They have contributed immensely to resolving several fundamental questions, particularly those related to the origin, evolution, phylogenetic relationship, cytological status and inheritance of genes of an array of crop plants; provided several desirable donor genes for the genetic improvement of their domesticated counterparts; and facilitated the innovation of many novel concepts and technologies while working on them directly or while using their resources. More recently, they have even been used for the verification of their potential threats of gene flow from genetically modified plants and invasive habits. Above all, some of them are contributing enormously as model plant species to the elucidation and amelioration of the genomes of crop plant species. As a matter of fact, as a student, a teacher, and a humble science worker I was, still am and surely will remain fascinated by the wild allies of crop plants for their invaluable wealth for genetics, genomics and breeding in crop plants and as such share a deep concern for their conservation and comprehensive characterization for future utilization. It is by now a well established fact that wild crop relatives deserve serious attention for domestication, especially for the utilization of their phytomedicines and nutraceuticals, bioenergy production, soil reclamation, and the phytoremediation of ecology and environment. While these vastly positive impacts of wild crop relatives on the development and deployment of new varieties for various purposes in the major crop plants of the world agriculture, along with a few negative potential concerns, are envisaged the need for reference books with comprehensive deliberations on the wild relatives of all the major field and plantation crops and fruit and forest trees is indeed imperative. This was the driving force behind the inception and publication of this series. Unlike the previous six book projects I have edited alone or with co-editors, this time it was very difficult to formulate uniform outlines for the chapters of this book series for several obvious reasons. Firstly, the status of the crop relatives is highly diverse. Some of them are completely wild, some are sporadically cultivated and some are at the initial stage of domestication for specific breeding objectives recently deemed essential. Secondly, the status of their conservation varies widely: some have been conserved, characterized and utilized; some have been eroded completely except for their presence in their center(s) of origin; some are at-risk or endangered due to genetic erosion, and some of them have yet to be explored. The third constraint is the variation in their relative worth, e.g. as academic model, breeding resource, and/or potential as “new crops.” ix
x
The most perplexing problem for me was to assign the chapters each on a particular genus to different volumes dedicated to crop relatives of diverse crops grouped based on their utility. This can be exemplified with Arabidopsis, which has primarily benefited the Brassicaceae crops but also facilitated genetic analyses and improvement in crop plants in other distant families; or with many wild relatives of forage crops that paved the way for the genetic analyses and breeding of some major cereal and millet crops. The same is true for wild crop relatives such as Medicago truncatula, which has paved the way for in-depth research on two crop groups of diverse use: oilseed and pulse crops belonging to the Fabaceae family. The list is too long to enumerate. I had no other choice but to compromise and assign the genera of crop relatives in a volume on the crop group to which they are taxonomically the closest and to which they have relatively greater contributions. For example, I placed the chapter on genus Arabidopsis in the volume on oilseeds, which deals with the wild relatives of Brassicaceae crops amongst others. However, we have tried to include deliberations pertinent to the individual genera of the wild crop relatives to which the chapters are devoted. Descriptions of the geographical locations of origin and genetic diversity, geographical distribution, karyotype and genome size, morphology, etc. have been included for most of them. Their current utility status – whether recognized as model species, weeds, invasive species or potentially cultivable taxa – is also delineated. The academic, agricultural, medicinal, ecological, environmental and industrial potential of both the cultivated and/or wild allied taxa are discussed. The conservation of wild crop relatives is a much discussed yet equally neglected issue albeit the in situ and ex situ conservations of some luckier species were initiated earlier or are being initiated now. We have included discussions on what has happened and what is happening with regard to the conservation of the crop relatives, thanks to the national and international endeavors, in most of the chapters and also included what should happen for the wild relatives of the so-called new, minor, orphan or future crops. The botanical origin, evolutionary pathway and phylogenetic relationship of crop plants have always attracted the attention of plant scientists. For these studies morphological attributes, cytological features and biochemical parameters were used individually or in combinations at different periods based on the availability of the required tools and techniques. Access to different molecular markers based on nuclear and especially cytoplasmic DNAs that emerged after 1980 refined the strategies required for precise and unequivocal conclusions regarding these aspects. Illustrations of these classical and recent tools have been included in the chapters. Positioning genes and defining gene functions required in many cases different cytogenetic stocks, including substitution lines, addition lines, haploids, monoploids and aneuploids, particularly in polyploid crops. These aspects have been dealt in the relevant chapters. Employment of colchiploidy, fluorescent or genomic in situ hybridization and Southern hybridization have reinforced the theoretical and applied studies on these stocks. Chapters on relevant genera/species include details on these cytogenetic stocks. Wild crop relatives, particularly wild allied species and subspecies, have been used since the birth of genetics in the twentieth century in several instances such as studies of inheritance, linkage, function, transmission and evolution of genes. They have been frequently used in genetic studies since the advent of molecular markers. Their involvement in molecular mapping has facilitated the development of mapping
Preface
Preface
xi
populations with optimum polymorphism to construct saturated maps and also illuminating the organization, reorganization and functional aspects of genes and genomes. Many phenomena such as genomic duplication, genome reorganization, self-incompatibility, segregation distortion, transgressive segregation and defining genes and their phenotypes have in many cases been made possible due to the utilization of wild species or subspecies. Most of the chapters contain detailed elucidations on these aspects. The richness of crop relatives with biotic and abiotic stress resistance genes was well recognized and documented with the transfer of several alien genes into their cultivated counterparts through wide or distant hybridization with or without employing embryo-rescue and mutagenesis. However, the amazing revelation that the wild relatives are also a source of yield-related genes is a development of the molecular era. Apomictic genes are another asset of many crop relatives that deserve mention. All of these past and the present factors have led to the realization that the so-called inferior species are highly superior in conserving desirable genes and can serve as a goldmine for breeding elite plant varieties. This is particularly true at a point when natural genetic variability has been depleted or exhausted in most of the major crop species, particularly due to growing and promoting only a handful of so-called high-yielding varieties while disregarding the traditional cultivars and landraces. In the era of molecular breeding, we can map desirable genes and polygenes, identify their donors and utilize tightly linked markers for gene introgression, mitigating the constraint of linkage drag, and even pyramid genes from multiple sources, cultivated or wild taxa. The evaluation of primary, secondary and tertiary gene pools and utilization of their novel genes is one of the leading strategies in present-day plant breeding. It is obvious that many wide hybridizations will never be easy and involve near-impossible constraints such as complete or partial sterility. In such cases gene cloning and gene discovery, complemented by intransgenic breeding, will hopefully pave the way for success. The utilization of wild relatives through traditional and molecular breeding has been thoroughly enumerated over the chapters throughout this series. Enormous genomic resources have been developed in the model crop relatives, for example Arabidopsis thaliana and Medicago truncatula. BAC, cDNA and EST libraries have also been developed in some other crop relatives. Transcriptomes and metabolomes have also been dissected in some of them. However, similar genomic resources are yet to be constructed in many crop relatives. Hence this section has been included only in chapters on the relevant genera. In this book series, we have included a section on recommendations for future steps to create awareness about the wealth of wild crop relatives in society at large and also for concerns for their alarmingly rapid decrease due to genetic erosion. The authors of the chapters have also emphasized on the imperative requirement of their conservation, envisaging the importance of biodiversity. The importance of intellectual property rights and also farmers’ rights as owners of local landraces, botanical varieties, wild species and subspecies has also been dealt in many of the chapters. I feel satisfied that the authors of the chapters in this series have deliberated on all the crucial aspects relevant to a particular genus in their chapters. I am also very pleased to present many chapters in this series authored by a large number of globally reputed leading scientists, many of whom have contributed to the development of novel concepts, strategies and tools of genetics, genomics and breeding and/or pioneered the elucidation and improvement of particular plant
xii
genomes using both traditional and molecular tools. Many of them have already retired or will be retiring soon, leaving behind their legacies and philosophies for us to follow and practice. I am saddened that a few of them have passed away during preparation of the manuscripts for this series. At the same time, I feel blessed that all of these stalwarts shared equally with me the wealth of crop relatives and contributed to their recognition and promotion through this endeavor. I would also like to be candid with regard to my own limitations. Initially I planned for about 150 chapters devoted to the essential genera of wild crop relatives. However, I had to exclude some of them either due to insignificant progress made on them during the preparation of this series, my failure to identify interested authors willing to produce acceptable manuscripts in time or authors’ backing out in the last minute, leaving no time to find replacements. I console myself for this lapse with the rationale that it is simply too large a series to achieve complete satisfaction on the contents. Still I was able to arrange about 125 chapters in the ten volumes, contributed by nearly 400 authors from over 40 countries of the world. I extend my heartfelt thanks to all these scientists, who have cooperated with me since the inception of this series not only with their contributions, but also in some cases by suggesting suitable authors for chapters on other genera. As happens with a megaseries, a few authors had delays for personal or professional reasons, and in a few cases, for no reason at all. This caused delays in the publication of some of the volumes and forced the remaining authors to update their manuscripts and wait too long to see their manuscripts in published form. I do shoulder all the responsibilities for this myself and tender my sincere apologies. Another unique feature of this series is that the authors of chapters dedicated to some genera have dedicated their chapters to scientists who pioneered the exploration, description and utilization of the wild species of those genera. We have duly honored their sincere decision with equal respect for the scientists they rightly reminded us to commemorate. Editing this series was, to be honest, very taxing and painstaking, as my own expertise is limited to a few cereal, oilseed, pulse, vegetable, and fruit crops, and some medicinal and aromatic plants. I spent innumerable nights studying to attain the minimum eligibility to edit the manuscripts authored by experts with even life-time contributions on the concerned genera or species. However, this indirectly awakened the “student-for-life” within me and enriched my arsenal with so many new concepts, strategies, tools, techniques and even new terminologies! Above all, this helped me to realize that individually we know almost nothing about the plants on this planet! And this realization strikingly reminded me of the affectionate and sincere advice of Dr. Norman Borlaug to keep abreast with what is happening in the crop sciences, which he used to do himself even when he had been advised to strictly limit himself to bed rest. He was always enthusiastic about this series and inspired me to take up this huge task. This is one of the personal and professional reasons I dedicated this book series to him with a hope that the present and future generations of plant scientists will share the similar feelings of love and respect for all plants around us for the sake of meeting our never-ending needs for food, shelter, clothing, medicines, and all other items used for our basic requirements and comfort. I am also grateful to his granddaughter, Julie Borlaug, for kindly extending her permission to dedicate this series to him. I started editing books with the 7-volume series on Genome Mapping and Molecular Breeding in Plants with Springer way back in 2005, and I have since
Preface
Preface
xiii
edited many other book series with Springer. I always feel proud and satisfied to be a member of the Springer family, particularly because of my warm and enriching working relationship with Dr. Sabine Schwarz and Dr. Jutta Lindenborn, with whom I have been working all along. My special thanks go out to them for publishing this “dream series” in an elegant form and also for appreciating my difficulties and accommodating many of my last-minute changes and updates. I would be remiss in my duties if I failed to mention the contributions of Phullara – my wife, friend, philosopher and guide – who has always shared with me a love of the collection, conservation, evaluation, and utilization of wild crop relatives and has enormously supported me in the translation of these priorities in my own research endeavors – for her assistance in formulating the contents of this series, for monitoring its progress and above all for taking care of all the domestic and personal responsibilities I am supposed to shoulder. I feel myself alien to the digital world that is the sine qua non today for maintaining constant communication and ensuring the preparation of manuscripts in a desirable format. Our son Sourav and daughter Devleena made my life easier by balancing out my limitations and also by willingly sacrificing the spare amount of time I ought to spend with them. Editing of this series would not be possible without their unwavering support. I take the responsibility for any lapses in content, format and approach of the series and individual volumes and also for any other errors, either scientific or linguistic, and will look forward to receiving readers’ corrections or suggestions for improvement. As I mentioned earlier this series consists of ten volumes. These volumes are dedicated to wild relatives of Cereals, Millets and Grasses, Oilseeds, Legume Crops and Forages, Vegetables, Temperate Fruits, Tropical and Subtropical Fruits, Industrial Crops, Plantation and Ornamental Crops, and Forest Trees. This volume “Wild Crop Relatives – Genomic and Breeding Resources: Millets and Grasses” includes 16 chapters dedicated to Agrostis, Bromus, Cenchrus, Cynodon, Dactylis, Dichanthium, Eleusine, Eragrostis, Festuca, Lolium, Panicum, Paspalum, Pennisetum, Phleum, Setaria and Zoysia. The chapters of this volume were authored by 48 scientists from 11 countries of the world namely Algerie, Argentina, Australia, France, India, Japan, New Zealand, Poland, Portugal, Turkey, and the USA. It is my sincere hope that this volume and the series as a whole will serve the requirements of students, scientists and industries involved in studies, teaching, research and the extension of millets and grasses with an intention of serving science and society. Clemson, USA
Chittaranjan Kole
.
Contents
1
Agrostis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 B.S. Ozdemir and H. Budak
2
Bromus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . W.M. Williams, A.V. Stewart, and M.L. Williamson
15
3
Cenchrus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . S. Goel, H.D. Singh, and S.N. Raina
31
4
Cynodon . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Yanqi Wu
53
5
Dactylis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Alan V. Stewart and Nicholas W. Ellison
73
6
Dichanthium . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Vishnu Bhat, C. Mahalakshmi, Shashi, Sunil Saran, and Soom Nath Raina
89
7
Eleusine . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 113 Susana S. Neves
8
Eragrostis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 135 Mahmoud Zeid, Vivana Echenique, Marina Dı´az, Silvina Pessino, and Mark E. Sorrells
9
Festuca . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 153 Toshihiko Yamada
10
Lolium . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 165 Hongwei Cai, Alan Stewart, Maiko Inoue, Nana Yuyama, and Mariko Hirata
11
Panicum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 175 Hem S. Bhandari, Masumi Ebina, Malay C. Saha, Joseph H. Bouton, Sairam V. Rudrabhatla, and Stephen L. Goldman
12
Paspalum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 197 W.M. Williams, M.L. Williamson, and D. Real
xv
xvi
Contents
13
Pennisetum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 217 Thierry Robert, Nadra Khalfallah, Evelyne Martel, Franc¸oise Lamy, Valerie Poncet, Cle´mentine Allinne, Marie-Stanislas Remigereau, Samah Rekima, Magalie Leveugle, Ghayas Lakis, Sonja Siljak-Yakovlev, and Aboubakry Sarr
14
Phleum . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 257 Alan V. Stewart, Andrzej J. Joachimiak, and Nicholas W. Ellison
15
Setaria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 275 Henri Darmency and Jack Dekker
16
Zoysia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 297 Shin-ich Tsuruta, Makoto Kobayashi, and Masumi Ebina
Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 311
Abbreviations
5S A/L ABA ACCase AFLP ALS ANTC APO ASGR ASGR AusPGRIS BAC BADH BC BP BSA CAD CCoAOMT CCR cDNA CENARGEN CGIAR CHCH CIAT CID CISP cM CMS COMT COMT cpDNA CPPSE CP-sHSP Crs-1 CTAB cTBP
rDNA gene coding for the 5S rRNA Accumulation/loss mechanism Abscisic acid Acetyl coenzyme A carboxylase Amplified fragment length polymorphism Acetolactate synthase Anthocyanin Aposporous locus Apospory-specific genomic region Apomixis-related gene region Australian Plant Genetic Resource Information Service Bacterial artificial chromosome Betaine-aldehyde dehydrogenase Backcross Before present Bulked segregant analysis Cinnamyl alcohol dehydrogenase Caffeoyl-CoA O-methyltransferase Cinnamoyl CoA reductase Complementary DNA Centro Nacional de Pesquisa em Recursos Gene´ticos e Biotecnologia Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research Coiled-coil-helix–coiled-coil-helix International Centre for Tropical Agriculture Carbon isotope discrimination Conserved intron scanning primers Centi-Morgan Cytoplasmic male sterility Caffeic acid O-methyltransferase Caffeic acid/5-hydroxyferulic acid O-methyltransferase Chloroplast-DNA Centro de Pesquisa de Pecua´ria do Sudeste Chloroplast-localized small HSP Creeping bentgrass specific-1 gene Cetyl trimethyl ammonium bromide Combinatorial tubulin-based polymorphism xvii
xviii
cv. CWR DAF DAPI DDBJ DEF DM EMBL EMBRAPA EST FAA FAME FISH GAI GBSSI GC GFP GI GIS GMM GR GRIN GSS hph HSP IBC IBONE ICRISAT IGER IGFRI ILRI IMI INDEL INTA ISSR ITS IVDMD LEA LG LLR MAS MDA mRNA NADP NADP-ME NBPGR NBS NCBI NDF
Abbreviations
Cultivar Crop wild relative DNA amplification fingerprinting 40 ,6-Diamidino-2-phenylindole DNA Data Bank of Japan Diferentially expressed fragment Dry matter European Molecular Biology Laboratory Empresa Brasileira de Pesquisa Agropecua´ria Expressed sequence tag Formalin: acetic acid: ethyl alcohol Fatty acid methyl ester Fluorescence in situ hybridization Gene of agronomic interest Granule-bound starch synthase I Gas chromatography Green fluorescent protein Genes index Genomic in situ hybridization Genotype matrix mapping Glyphosate resistant Germplasm Resource Information Network (USDA-ARS) Genome survey sequence Hygromycin phosphotransferase (gene) Heat shock protein Institute of Biodiversity Conservation Instituto de Bota´nica del Nordeste International Crops Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics Institute of Grassland and Environmental Research Indian Grassland and Fodder Research Institute International Livestock Research Institute Imidazolinone Insertion/deletion National Institute of Agriculture of Argentina Inter-simple sequence repeat Internal transcribed spacer In vitro dry matter digestibility Late embryogenesis abundant Linkage group Leucine-rich repeat Marker-assisted selection Malondialdehyde Messenger-RNA Nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate NADP-malic enzyme National Bureau of Plant Genetic Resources Nucleotide binding site National Center for Biotechnology Information Neutral detergent fiber
Abbreviations
xix
ndhF nirK, nirS NMDH NOR nosZ NPGS NPK OMT PAC PACC PAL PC PCA PCR PD PGR PHYB PIC PSII Q-PCR QTA QTL QTN R gene RAPD rDNA RFLP RGL RIL RNAi RT-PCR RWC s.str. SC SCAR SDRF SINGER SNP SRAP SSR STS TBP TDF TNL tRNA uidA UNED UPGMA
NADH dehydrogenase F Nitrite reductase genes NADP-dependent malate dehydrogenase Nucleolar organizer region Nitrous oxide reductase gene National Plant Germplasm System Nitrogen phosphorus potassium O-Methyl transferase Plasmid artificial chromosome Panicoid-arundinoid-chloridoid-centothecoid Phenylalanine ammonialyase Principal component Principal component analysis Polymerase chain reaction Power of discrimination Plant growth regulator Phytochrome B Polymorphic information content Photosystem II Quantitative real-time PCR Quantitative trait allele Quantitative trait loci Quantitative trait nucleotide Resistance gene Random(ly) amplified polymorphic DNA Ribosomal DNA Restriction fragment length polymorphism R-gene-like sequence Recombinant Inbred Line RNA-interference Real-time quantitative PCR Relative water content sensu stricto Secondary constriction Sequence-characterized amplified region Single dose restriction fragment System-wide Information Network for Genetic Resources Single nucleotide polymorphism Sequence-related amplified polymorphism Simple sequence repeat Sequence tagged site Tubulin-based polymorphism Transcript derived fragment TIR-NBS-LRR Transfer-RNA b-Glucuronidase (gene) United Nations Conference on Environment and Development Unweighted pair group method with arithmetic mean
xx
USDA USDA-APHIS USDA-SCS USGA WUE
Abbreviations
United States Department of Agriculture USDA-Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service USDA Soil Conservation Service United States Golf Association Water use efficiency
List of Contributors
Cle´mentine Allinne Laboratoire Ecologie Syste´matique et Evolution UMR (8079) CNRS, Agroparitech, Universite´ Paris XI, B 360, 91405 Orsay, France, Clementine.
[email protected] Hem Bhandari Forage Improvement Division, The Samuel Roberts Noble Foundation, Inc., 2510 Sam Noble Parkway, Ardmore, OK 73401, USA,
[email protected] Vishnu Bhat Department of Botany, University of Delhi, Delhi 110007, India,
[email protected] Joseph Bouton Forage Improvement Division, The Samuel Roberts Noble Foundation, Inc., 2510 Sam Noble Parkway, Ardmore, OK 73401, USA,
[email protected] H. Budak Engineering and Natural Sciences, Biological Sciences and Bioengineering Program, Sabanci University, Orhanli, 34956 Tuzla, Istanbul, Turkey,
[email protected] Hongwei Cai Forage Crop Research Institute, Japan Grassland Agriculture and Forage Seed Association, 388-5, Higashiakata, Nasushiobara, Tochigi 329-2742, Japan,
[email protected] Henri Darmency INRA, Weed Biology and Management, 17 rue Sully, BP 86510, 21065 Dijon, France,
[email protected] Jack Dekker Weed Biology Laboratory, Agronomy Department, Iowa State University, Ames, IA 50011, USA,
[email protected] Marina Dı´az Departamento de Biologı´a, Bioquı´mica y Farmacia, Universidad Nacional del Sur, San Juan 670, 8000 Bahia Blanca, Argentina,
[email protected] Masumi Ebina Forage Plant Breeding and Biotechnology, The National Institute of Livestock and Grassland Science, 768 Sembonmatsu, Nasushiobara, Tochigi 329-2793, Japan,
[email protected] Viviana Echenique Departamento de Agronomı´a, Universidad Nacional del Sur, CERZOS-CONICET, San Andre´s 800, 8000 Bahia Blanca, Argentina,
[email protected] Nicholas W. Ellison AgResearch, Private Bag 11008, Palmerston North, New Zealand,
[email protected]
xxi
xxii
S. Goel Department of Botany, University of Delhi, Delhi 110007, India,
[email protected] Stephen L. Goldman Department of Environmental Science, The University of Toledo, 2801 W. Bancroft, Toledo, OH 43606, USA,
[email protected] Mariko Hirata Forage Crop Research Institute, Japan Grassland Agriculture and Forage Seed Association, 388-5, Higashiakata, Nasushiobara, Tochigi 329-2742, Japan,
[email protected] Maiko Inoue Department of Plant, Soil, and Insect Science, University of Massachusetts, 8 French Hall, 230 Stockbridge Road, Amherst, MA 01003, USA,
[email protected] Andrzej J. Joachimiak Department of Plant Cytology and Embryology, Institute of Botany, Jagiellonian University, Grodzka 52, 31-044 Cracow, Poland,
[email protected] Nadra Khalfallah Laboratoire de Ge´ne´tique, Biochimie et Biotechnologies ve´ge´tales, Universite´ Mentouri Constantine, Constantine, Alge´rie, khalfallah@ wissal.dz Makoto Kobayashi National Institute of Livestock and Grassland Science, Forage Plant Breeding and Biotechnology, 768 Sembonmatsu, Nasushiobara, Tochigi 329-2793, Japan,
[email protected] Ghayas Lakis Laboratoire Ecologie Syste´matique et Evolution UMR (8079) CNRS, Agroparitech, Universite´ Paris XI, B 360, 91 405 Orsay, France,
[email protected] Franc¸oise Lamy Laboratoire Ecologie Syste´matique et Evolution UMR (8079) CNRS, Agroparitech, Universite´ Paris XI, B 360, 91 405 Orsay, France,
[email protected] Magalie Leveugle Laboratoire Ecologie Syste´matique et Evolution UMR (8079) CNRS, Agroparitech, Universite´ Paris XI, B 360, 91 405 Orsay, France,
[email protected] C. Mahalakshmi Department of Botany, University of Delhi, Delhi 110007, India,
[email protected] Evelyne Martel Universite´ Lyon 1, UMR CNRS 5023 ‘Ecology of Fluvial Hydrosystems’, 43 Bd du 11 novembre, F-69622 Villeurbanne Cedex, France,
[email protected] Susana S. Neves Plant Cell Biotechnology Laboratory,ITQB, Instituto de Tecnologia Quı´mica e Biolo´gica, Universidade Nova de Lisboa, Apartado 127, 2781-901 Oeiras, Portugal,
[email protected] B.S. Ozdemir Engineering and Natural Sciences, Biological Sciences and Bioengineering Program, Sabanci University, Orhanli, 34956 Tuzla, Istanbul, Turkey,
[email protected]
List of Contributors
List of Contributors
xxiii
Silvina Pessino Facultad de Ciencias Agrarias, Universidad Nacional de RosarioArgentina, Parque Villarino, S2125ZAA Zavalla, Santa Fe, Argentina,
[email protected] Soom Nath Raina Amity Institute of Biotechnology, Amity University, Noida 201303, Uttar Pradesh, India,
[email protected] Daniel Real Department of Agriculture and Food, Western Australia (DAFWA), South Perth, WA 6151, Australia,
[email protected] Samah Rekima Laboratoire Ecologie Syste´matique et Evolution UMR (8079) CNRS, Agroparitech, Universite´ Paris XI, B 360, 91 405 Orsay, France,
[email protected] Marie-Stanislas Remigereau Laboratoire Ecologie Syste´matique et Evolution UMR (8079) CNRS, Agroparitech, Universite´ Paris XI, B 360, 91 405 Orsay, France,
[email protected] Thierry Robert Laboratoire Ecologie Syste´matique et Evolution UMR (8079) CNRS, Agroparitech, Universite´ Paris XI, B 360, 91 405 Orsay, France,
[email protected] Malay Saha Forage Improvement Division, The Samuel Roberts Noble Foundation, Inc., 2510 Sam Noble Parkway, Ardmore, OK 73401, USA,
[email protected] R.V. Sairam Pennsylvania State University-Harrisburg, The School of Science Engineering and Technology, Middletown, PA 17057, USA,
[email protected] Sunil Saran Amity Institute of Biotechnology, Amity University, Noida 201303, Uttar Pradesh, India,
[email protected] Aboubakry Sarr Laboratoire Ecologie Syste´matique et Evolution UMR (8079) CNRS, Agroparitech, Universite´ Paris XI, B 360, 91 405 Orsay, France,
[email protected] Shashi Department of Botany, University of Delhi, Delhi 110007, India,
[email protected] Sonja Siljak-Yakovlev Laboratoire Ecologie Syste´matique et Evolution UMR (8079) CNRS, Agroparitech, Universite´ Paris XI, B 360, 91 405 Orsay, France,
[email protected] H.D. Singh Department of Botany, University of Delhi, Delhi 110007, India,
[email protected] Mark E. Sorrells Department of Plant Breeding and Genetics, Cornell University, 240 Emerson Hall, Ithaca, NY 14853-1902, USA,
[email protected] Alan V. Stewart PGG Wrightson Seeds, PO Box 175Lincoln, Christchurch 7640, New Zealand,
[email protected] Shin-ich Tsuruta University of Miyazaki, Faculty of Agriculture, 1-1 Gakuen Kibanadai-nishi, Miyazaki 889-2192, Japan,
[email protected]
xxiv
Warren M. Williams AgResearch, Grasslands Research Centre, Private Bag 11008, Palmerston North 4442, New Zealand,
[email protected] Michelle L. Williamson AgResearch, Grasslands Research Centre, Private Bag 11008, Palmerston North 4442, New Zealand, michelle.williamson@ agresearch.co.nz Yanqi Wu Department of Plant and Soil Sciences, Oklahoma State University, 368 Ag Hall, Stillwater, OK 74078, USA,
[email protected] Toshihiko Yamada Field Science Center for Northern Biosphere, Hokkaido University, Kita 11, Nishi 10, Kita-ku, Sapporo 060-0811, Japan, yamada@fsc. hokudai.ac.jp Nana Yuyama Forage Crop Research Institute, Japan Grassland Agriculture and Forage Seed Association, 388-5, Higashiakata, Nasushiobara, Tochigi 329-2742, Japan,
[email protected] Mahmoud Zeid Department of Plant Breeding and Genetics, Cornell University, 418 Bradfield Hall, Ithaca, NY 14853-1902, USA,
[email protected]
List of Contributors
.
Chapter 1
Agrostis B.S. Ozdemir and H. Budak
1.1 Introduction The grass family (Poaceae) emerged 60 million years ago (Kellogg 2001) and it is one of the largest families that include various species with high economical importance, especially the essential cereal crops that are obligate in the daily diet. Grasses are used for many purposes such as in food production, industry, lawns, and sports fields. Turfgrasses are used in sports fields and recreation areas whereas they prevent soil erosion in natural habitats. In the United States, turfgrass constitutes the second place in the seed market (Lee 1996). Agrostis spp., bentgrass, contains more than 200 perennial turfgrass species as a genus in the Poaceae family (Hitchcock 1971), but five species of this genus are mainly used as turfgrass, which are all outcrossing, perennial, and cool-season grasses: colonial (Agrostis capillaris L.), velvet (Agrostis canina L.), creeping (Agrostis stolonifera L.), redtop (Agrostis gigantea Roth), and dryland (Agrostis castellana Boiss. and Reut.). Agrostis spp. is taxonomically classified under Gramineae (Poaceae) family, Pooideae subfamily, Aveneae tribe, and Agrostis genus (Warnke 2003). Bentgrasses are cool-season grasses that are widely used on golf courses (tees, fairways, and greens) at
H. Budak (*) Engineering and Natural Sciences, Biological Sciences and Bioengineering Program, Sabanci University, Orhanli, 34956 Tuzla, Istanbul, Turkey e-mail:
[email protected]
temperate regions due to their dense nature, low mowing heights without damage, and green appearance. They are also used for parks and forage. They are cross-pollinating, self-incompatible, and pollinated by wind. Agrostis can exhibit both clonal growth and seed reproduction. It is hard to classify Agrostis genus taxonomically. Due to the similar morphological characters among this genus, others features are needed to be included for identification of new germplasms. Laser flow cytometry for the determination of ploidy level was found to be effective in differentiating between diploid, tetraploid, and hexaploid forms by evaluating six Agrostis species; A. canina L. subsp. canina, A. canina L. subsp. montana (Hartm.) Hartm., A. stolonifera var. palustris (Huds.) Farw., A. capillaris L., A. castellana Boiss. & Reut., and Agrostis alba L. (Bonos et al. 2002).
1.2 Three Major Bentgrass Species 1.2.1 Creeping Bentgrass (A. stolonifera L.) Creeping bentgrass is a cool-season grass species that is native to Western Europe. It is not only adapted to cool and humid areas but also preferred to be used in warmer places at golf courses due to its fine texture. Creeping bentgrass has high density and mowing height as low as 3 mm; these features make it suitable to be used especially in greens though it is also used in tees and fairways of the golf courses (Warnke 2003). It requires high maintenance, so it is not ideal for home
C. Kole (ed.), Wild Crop Relatives: Genomic and Breeding Resources, Millets and Grasses, DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-14255-0_1, # Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
1
2
lawns. It has low growth habit and aggressive spreading (Casler 2006). Creeping bentgrass is commonly referred to as A. stolonifera L., but other synonyms are also used such as Agrostis palustris Huds. and A. stolonifera L. var. palustris (Huds.). It is a strict allotetraploid with a genome A2A2A3A3 (2n ¼ 4x ¼ 28) (Warnke 2003). Complete chloroplast genome sequence of A. stolonifera (136,584 bp) was presented and compared with other grass species. The chloroplast genome contains 53.6% coding regions (44.7% protein coding genes and 8.9% RNA genes), and the rest is noncoding regions (Saski et al. 2007). Creeping bentgrass requires vernalization, and flowering occurs generally in late spring to early summer (Warnke 2003). Interspecific hybridization of creeping bentgrass is possible with five different Agrostis species (A. canina L., A. castellana Boiss. & Reut, A. gigantea Roth, A. capillaris L., and A. vinealis Schreb). Due to its stoloniferous growth, thick thatch layers can be formed, if it is not managed properly. This then serves as a good environment for pathogens and insects. It is susceptible to many diseases, but dollar spot (Sclerotinia homeocarpa), brown patch (Rhizoctonia solani), Typhula blight (Typhula incarnata or Typhula ishikariensis), the so-called gray snow mold, and Fusarium blight (Fusarium roseum and Fusarium tricinctum), also named as pink snow mold, are the main concerns. A study with rhizobacteria, isolated from roots of bentgrass and bermudagrass located from USGA golf putting greens, showed that Pseudomonas was the dominant genus in the roots of bentgrass for denitrification. For both species, 17% of the isolates were identified by GC-FAME (gas chromatography – fatty acid methyl ester) and 16S rDNA analyses. Besides, nitrous oxide reductase (nosZ) and nitrite reductase genes (nirK and nirS) were recognized (Wang and Skipper 2004).
1.2.2 Colonial Bentgrass (A. capillaris L.) Colonial bentgrass is both referred as A. capillaris L. and Agrostis tenuis Sibth. Origin of colonial bentgrass is Europe and temperate Asia. It is a cool-
B.S. Ozdemir and H. Budak
season grass and also named as brown top. While it is used in lawns and sports fields such as tennis courts and golf courses, it is also a choice for erosion control (Hubbard 1984). It is compatible with other species (Casler 2006). Colonial bentgrass is preferred on fairways and tees at golf courses with a mowing height of 1.0–2.5 cm; hence, it is not much suitable for greens. It has lower maintenance needs than creeping bentgrass; instead it has more limitations (Ruemmele 2003). Colonial bentgrass can adapt to different environments with forming specific ecotypes (Busey 2003). The colonial bentgrass (A. capillaris L.) with the genome A1A1A2A2 and creeping bentgrass (A. stolonifera L.) with the genome A2A2A3A3 are both allotetraploid and have 14 chromosome pairs (2n ¼ 4x ¼ 28) (Ruemmele 2003; Warnke 2003). Since they are sexually compatible, hybrids can be produced. Genomics studies facilitate analysis of many species for their origin and evolution with the use of many tools it provides. Expressed sequence tag (EST) sequence analysis of colonial and creeping bentgrass A2 genomes suggested that these genomes diverged from a common ancestor at about 2.2 million years ago and supported the previous studies that A2 genomes were common for both species. Their findings also showed that both creeping and colonial bentgrasses were closer to tribe Poeae than tribe Aveneae that are actually closely related tribes (Rotter et al. 2007).
1.2.3 Velvet Bentgrass (A. canina L.) Velvet bentgrass is referred as A. canina L., which is native to Europe. It is diploid (2n ¼ 2x ¼ 14) with genome designation of A1A1. It is confused widely with A. vinealis (2n ¼ 4x ¼ 28) which is an autotetraploid of A. canina. Velvet bentgrass is a cool-season grass with very fine texture, maintaining a good putting surface at golf courses, and it has stoloniferous growth habit. It is the most shade-tolerant among other Agrostis spp. It has good heat, low temperature, and drought tolerance. Besides, it is more tolerant to acidic soils then all other bentgrasses. However, it needs high maintenance (Brilman 2003) and it has low growth habit (Casler 2006).
1 Agrostis
3
1.3 Three Minor Bentgrass Species
1.4 Marker Systems
1.3.1 Redtop (A. gigantea Roth)
The origin of colonial bentgrass is temperate Asia and Europe. It is well adapted to low temperatures and partial shade and mostly used for tees and fairways of the golf courses. In order to study genetic variation and relation among colonial bentgrass populations, random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) marker analysis was applied, revealing high degree of genetic diversity. The accessions introduced from Europe to USA had genetic resemblance with the European cultivars; however, accessions from Bulgaria and Turkey showed the lowest genetic similarity, though these two regions are not geographically distant from each other (Rajasekar et al. 2007). Twenty-two different colonial bentgrasses (A. capillaris L.) from different countries, including few commercial cultivars, were analyzed with 128 amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) markers, resulting in high level of genetic biodiversity. Diverse gene pool availability was especially investigated in the accession rather than the commercial cultivars (Zhao et al. 2006). It is natural that during domestication events, through breeding, cultivated species loses its genetic diversity and gains uniformity. So that wild relatives or other species play an important role in plant improvement programs. Colonial bentgrass is a good source with its diverse germplasm for the improvement of other Agrostis species or turfgrass types. Creeping bentgrass (A. stolonifera L.), colonial bentgrass (A. capillaris L.), and velvet bentgrass (A. canina L.) are the extensively used bentgrasses (Agrostis spp.) on putting greens, tees, and fairways of the golf courses at temperate regions. They are highly difficult to be identified using their morphological features. However, it was investigated that RAPD markers were effective in differentiation and identification of bentgrass species at molecular level (Hollman et al. 2005). Besides the use of RAPD markers, sequence characterized amplified region (SCAR) markers were designed for colonial and creeping bentgrasses. They were found to be effective to differentiate between these two bentgrasses and these from other Agrostis spp. This technology was also recommended to be used for selecting the progenies produced from interspecific hybridization between colonial and creeping bentgrasses (Scheef et al. 2003).
Redtop is a cool-season, perennial grass, which is referred as A. gigantea Roth or A. alba. Redtop bentgrass (A. gigantea Roth) is allopolyploid with the genome A1A1A2A2A3A3 (2n ¼ 6x ¼ 42), which are the inclusion of the genomes of both creeping and colonial bentgrasses. It can be crossed with creeping bentgrass to produce infertile hybrids. Redtop is used as forage or turf or for reclamation purposes for revegetation of disturbed areas. It has low maintenance (Brede and Sellmann 2003). It has rapid establishment (Casler 2006). It is tolerant to high metal concentrations and is the most salt-tolerant among other bentgrasses. It can be used in breeding programs for enhanced tolerance. It has the potential to be improved as forage or turf (Brede and Sellmann 2003).
1.3.2 Highland Bentgrass (A. castellana Boiss. and Reuter) Highland bentgrass is a dense turf that has good color in winter times. It is tetraploid, but its hexaploid types can also be found. It is adapted to warmer and less humid areas than A. capillaris. A. castellana has mowing heights ranging from 1.0 to 1.9 cm and can be used for turf purposes. But it is better if used as a low maintenance grass or for reclamation purposes (Brede and Sellmann 2003); it is a drought-tolerant species (Casler 2006).
1.3.3 Idaho Bentgrass (Agrostis idahoensis Nash) Idaho bentgrass is a cool-season, perennial grass species, which is native to North America. Depending on its mowing height, it shows more tolerance to diseases than any other bentgrass types. It can be used for improvement of Agrostis germplasm in pest resistance (Brede and Sellmann 2003).
4
Few creeping bentgrass cultivars were identified using restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) markers (Caceres et al. 2000), which is one of the first marker types to be used in linkage studies and an important tool for genetic mapping. Moreover, molecular marker-based linkage map was developed for creeping bentgrass using AFLP, RAPD, and cDNA-RFLP markers. Further use of this map would be useful in detection of quantitative trait loci (QTL) and marker-assisted breeding of agronomically important traits like disease resistance (Chakraborty et al. 2005). Transcript polymorphism analysis using SRAP system in three different bentgrasses (colonial, creeping, and velvet bentgrass) was the first study to be reported on turfgrasses. The ESTs obtained from this study could be used in turfgrass improvement programs (Dinler and Budak 2008). AFLP analysis for tetraploid creeping bentgrass and hexaploid redtop bentgrass was performed to investigate genetic diversity of the old and new cultivars, European plant introductions, and gray snow mold (T. incarnata Lasch) resistant genotypes of creeping bentgrass and could be used in plant improvements and gene mapping studies (Vergara and Bughrara 2004). For dollar spot disease, QTL analysis was performed to deeply understand the genetics of the resistance to this disease. It was found that dollar spot resistance is a quantitative trait and highly heritable. RAPD markers tightly linked to this QTL could be a useful tool in breeding programs of Agrostis spp. (Chakraborty et al. 2006).
1.5 Heat Stress and Drought Tolerance Plants are affected from temperature changes since all metabolic activities take place at a certain temperature. Heat stress tolerance level differs according to the plant species. Some plants can become tolerant to high levels of heat stress by time, and that can be exhibited as a genetic character. In cool-season grass species, heat stress causes leaf senescence that is regulated by cytokinins. The decrease in cytokinin content causing an increase in leaf senescence process was reported in Agrostis species (Xu and Huang 2007). Chlorosis followed by leaf senescence causes a decline in chlorophyll content and photosynthetic capacity resulting in reduced plant
B.S. Ozdemir and H. Budak
growth (John et al. 1995) and, especially for turfgrass, loss of deep green color, which is an important parameter for its economic value. SAG12-ipt (ligation of ipt, adenine isopentenyl transferase gene to SAG12, senescence-activated promoter) gene integration into creeping bentgrass resulted in transgenic lines that had faster growth under normal temperatures and increased ipt gene expression and cytokinin production suppressed heat-induced leaf senescence (Xu et al. 2009) resulting in an improvement for coolseason grasses exposed to heat stress. The main problem of growing cool-season grasses in temperate areas is the increasing temperature in summer time causing a decline in plant productivity. Using differential display analysis, upregulated genes (18 in A. stolonifera and 22 in A. scabra) in response to heat stress were identified and most genes were found in both species. A. scabra is a heat-tolerant species for which the significant decline in soluble protein content was observed at 40 C, whereas A. stolonifera is nontolerant under heat stress, and protein content conservation was up to 30 C (Xu and Huang 2008a, b). Only three of these genes were expressed in A. scabra, and it was reported that these genes might have been serving for the heat tolerance. Previous analysis of thermal and nonthermal A. scabra with 60 RAPD loci showed that they were not clustered independently but they were distantly related although they were morphologically similar (Tercek et al. 2003). If it is the case, this might enlighten the mechanism of plants’ tolerance to heat stress and facilitate development of in heat tolerant cultivars (Xu et al. 2008). Heat shock proteins (HSPs) in plants are synthesized in response to heat stress for protection. The small HSPs that are localized in chloroplasts (CP-sHSPs) are essential in heat tolerance expressing varying levels of its isoforms. Two additional isoforms of CP-sHSPs in heat-tolerant variants of creeping bentgrass (Penncross cultivar), which were generated under heat stress and selected for heat tolerance, were accumulated with respect to heat-sensitive variants that were not subjected to heat stress. These isoforms were genetically linked to heat tolerance (Park et al. 1996; Luthe et al. 2000). The study of CP-sHSP encoding genes isolated from heat-tolerant and heat-sensitive variants showed that the differences and variation in the expression of CP-sHSPs were related with the environmental adaptation and suggested that the amount of CP-sHSPs
1 Agrostis
might have been the source of heat tolerance (Wang et al. 2003; Wang and Luthe 2003). During the growth of creeping bentgrass species, the temperature was increased gradually. Following heat acclimation, the creeping bentgrass showed an improved tolerance under heat stress. In consecutive studies, it was found that heat acclimation was associated with suppressed lipid peroxidation (Larkindale and Huang 2004), enhanced heat shock protein expression (He et al. 2005), and enhanced photosynthetic activity by higher pigment content and rubisco activity (Liu and Huang 2008). A. scabra is a thermal species found to be tolerant to high temperatures like 40–45 C and to be living at the Yellowstone Natural Park (Tercek et al. 2003). For heat tolerance capacity, cool-season, perennial grasses, A. scabra with two genotypes and commercially important A. stolonifera with ten genotypes were investigated for the expression of AsEXP1 gene under heat stress. Heat tolerance of the treated plants differed according to the Agrostis species and genotypes and fell into three classes as being most tolerant to most sensitive. Heat tolerance level was positively correlated with the level of AsEXP1 gene expression. Totally, four genotypes, two from A. scabra and two from A. stolonifera, exhibited the highest level of gene expression with response to heat stress, being the most heat-tolerant ecotypes. This expansin gene, AsEXP1, was found to be highly upregulated in shoots and affected the heat tolerance of both species as “wholeplant.” The identification of this gene as response to heat tolerance in C3 Agrostis species for the first time was suggested to be important both for the study and investigation of the heat tolerant germplasm of grasses (Xu et al. 2007). In a further study, novel heat responsive genes were identified in A. scabra by subtractive suppression hybridization approach. The differentially expressed genes were classified based on their role in stress and defense mechanism, signaling and transcription, and protein or carbon metabolism (Tian et al. 2009) For plants, the soil temperature is more important than temperature of the air. The soil temperature primarily affects the roots. Heat-tolerant A. scabra is adapted to high soil temperatures at geothermal locations, whereas heat-sensitive A. stolonifera, adapted to cool climatic regions, cannot survive at high temperatures. When compared to A. stolonifera, whole-plant carbon balance and root carbon utilization was maintained positively,
5
and the root respiration rate was low or downregulated in A. scabra at high temperatures. Both factors were suggested to be the reason for root thermotolerance adaptation of cool-season grasses (Lyons et al. 2007). Both short-term and long-term respiratory acclimation was investigated to be accompanied with root thermotolerance A. scabra at increasing temperatures. A. scabra was found to be giving less response, in terms of root respiration, than A. stolonifera. The adjustment of root carbon utilization was stated to be caused by respiratory acclimization that the need for increased respiratory energy was lowered at high temperatures, resulting in increased root survival (Rachmilevitch et al. 2008). Thermal A. scabra has higher root viability than heat-sensitive A. stolonifera. The protein and phosphoprotein patterns of A. scabra and A. stolonifera were mainly different under heat stress. It was proposed that sucrose synthase, glutathione S-transferase, superoxide dismutase, stress-inducible heat shock protein, and aldolase phosphorylation might have been associated with root thermotolerance in cool-season grasses under heat stress (Xu and Huang 2008a, b). Since carbon utilization and accumulation are thought to have a role in heat tolerance and enhancement of plant survival in perennial grass species, three species of cool-season turfgrasses, colonial bentgrass (A. capillaris L.), creeping bentgrass (A. stolonifera L.), and velvet bentgrass (A. canina L.), were examined based on their shoot and root carbon partitioning and carbohydrate accumulation. Measuring the turf quality and relative leaf water content revealed that velvet bentgrass was the most tolerant under drought conditions and colonial bentgrass had the most amendatory potential. According to total nonstructural carbohydrate content measurements, increased carbon accumulation in roots after initial drought application and then its gathering in stems and leaves at increased drought durations suggested an adaptive response for drought survival (DaCosta and Huang 2006a, b, c). Other study with creeping bentgrass with different irrigation applications resulted in enhanced carbohydrate levels in leaves and roots when irrigating at wilt (Fu and Dernoeden 2008). Velvet bentgrass was found to be the most droughttolerant bentgrass species among others. In colonial, creeping, and velvet bentgrasses, prolonged drought stress caused a decrease in antioxidant enzyme activities and an increase in lipid peroxidation. However, in velvet bentgrass, oxidative damage was prevented for
6
a longer period of time under drought stress compared to other two bentgrasses that resulted in maintenance of higher turf quality and leaf relative water content (DaCosta and Huang 2007a, b). Besides, velvet bentgrass had higher degree of osmotic adjustment, which is crucial for cell turgor pressure maintenance, and this osmotic adjustment was accompanied with increased proline content and deposition of water-soluble carbohydrates both in velvet and creeping bentgrasses (DaCosta and Huang 2006a, b, c). Velvet bentgrass exhibited less injury and more ABA (abscisic acid) accumulation under drought conditions with respect to colonial and creeping bentgrass. On the other hand, creeping bentgrass exhibited higher recovery from drought stress and, at the same time, showed rapid decline in ABA and incline in cytokinin content, where ABA and cytokinin are regulators in decreased water availability for plant consumption (DaCosta and Huang 2007a, b).
1.6 Salt Tolerance Efficient irrigation management results in higher turf quality, water saving, and less cost on golf courses by evaluating the water requirements of the species that were found to be depending on species and time of the year (DaCosta and Huang 2006a, b, c). However, water availability and quality is decreasing in today’s world and at the same time, the demand for salt-tolerant cultivars is increasing. Salt-tolerant and sensitive cultivars were determined among creeping, colonial, and velvet bentgrass species (McCarty and Dudeck 1993; Marcum 2001), and red top bentgrass (McCarty and Dudeck 1993).
1.7 Invasion Properties and Weed Control Invasion Cultural management of weed in turfgrass is important in the fight of weed invasion since it is a more combined system. Healthy plants are less prone to weed colonization. Environmental stresses, both abiotic and biotic, cause weed colonization. The use of mowing, cultivation, fertilization, irrigation, turfgrass selection,
B.S. Ozdemir and H. Budak
adaptation to biotic and physiological stresses, and planting in cultural management of weed in turfgrass is reviewed by Busey (2003). Bentgrasses are grown as monoculture on golf courses. Weed control is the main problem of golf course maintenance. Poa annua L. is the major weed that shows similar tolerance responses to herbicides like creeping bentgrass. There is no effective control of this weed, so it causes severe problems. So, genetic manipulation of turfgrass species for glyphosate or glufosinate type resistance is mainly to fight with P. annua in greens and unwanted grasses in other areas of golf courses (Duncan 2004). A. capillaris grows in patches with its dense tillers. Leaf growth of A. capillaris is postponed in spring time. It is a rhizomatous species. A. capillaris was found to be vegetatively the most competitive and invasive temperate grass species when compared with Festuca rubra, Holcus lanatus, Lolium perenne, and Poa trivialis, though their time of vegetative spreading differed during the growing season (Barthram et al. 2006). It was proposed that the varied invasion properties of different grass species and the physical resistance was not only related with lamina density but also other lamina characteristics should have been involved (Barthram et al. 2005).
1.8 Diseases in Agrostis Species Fungal diseases are tried to be prevented with extensive fungicide application, which generates both environmental problems and economical losses. So, improvement of turfgrass species for resistance to fungal diseases such as dollar spot or brown patch, which cause serious problems in turfgrass management, has crucial importance (Chakraborty et al. 2006). Dead spot disease is a newly occurring disease caused by Ophiosphaerella agrostis and effective in creeping bentgrass. It is a major problem of greens in the golf courses. The disease occurs within the first and sixth years of the established greens, and in older greens, it might be seen after fumigation with methyl bromide. This disease appears first in 1–2 cm diameter area with reddish brown spots and later the patches become 8–10 cm in diameter (Dernoeden et al. 1999; Caˆmara et al. 2000; Kaminski and Dernoeden 2006).
1 Agrostis
Gray snow mold is another fungal disease to which the creeping bentgrass is susceptible and caused by T. incarnata (Wu and Hsiang 1998). It is favored by cold and humid conditions like under snow cover. Dollar spot (Sclerotinia homoeocarpa F.T. Bennett) is one of the major diseases of turfgrasses. Fungal diseases cause serious problem in all grasses. Disease control is mostly done through fungicide application (Dai et al. 2003). Treatment trials of creeping bentgrass with fungicides and fungicides plus plant growth regulators (PGRs) resulted in a better quality of creeping bentgrass after treatment with fungicides plus PGRs rather than fungicides alone (Fidanza et al. 2006). Differences in day and night temperatures and high humidity fortify the dollar spot disease. Though the disease resistance in creeping bentgrass has been genetically identified, its tolerance varies partially with environmental conditions (Bonos et al. 2003; Bonos 2005). In creeping bentgrass species, it was proposed that the dollar spot disease was most probably a quantitatively inherited trait, and parent selection was crucial for improvements in disease resistance (Bonos 2006). While creeping bentgrass is susceptible to dollar spot disease and shows different levels of sensitivity among its cultivars, colonial bentgrass species has resistance to this severe disease. Interspecific hybrids between these two species were performed and in some of the hybrids produced, high resistance to dollar spot disease and even no disease symptoms were observed (Belanger et al. 2004). During studies with resistance to dollar disease with creeping and colonial bentgrass species, it was found that a gene loss was occurring in the Agrostis genus. The creeping bentgrass-specific-1 gene, Crs-1, was examined in creeping bentgrass plants conferring the loss in most of the individuals, which occurs rarely, but the function of the protein has not been investigated yet (Li et al. 2005). Resistance (R) genes are important for genetic improvement of plant species. There are more than five different classes of R-genes. In a study of Budak and co-workers, constitutively expressed R-gene-like sequences (RGLs) from different Agrostis species (creeping, colonial, and velvet bentgrasses) were isolated and characterized by PCR-based motif-directed RNA fingerprinting. It was found that RGLs from these Agrostis species were highly conserved and some shared conserved motifs with other disease-resistant genes. Two TNL (TIR-NBS-LRR)-type RGLs were isolated
7
conferring the presence of these types of genes in grasses (Budak et al. 2006).
1.9 Plant Transformation in Agrostis Species In order to achieve improvements in agricultural traits, plant transformation technologies are important to use with classical breeding methods. Today’s molecular biology and plant biotechnology techniques enable us to study the structure and function of desired gene, isolate it from its wild relatives, other cultivars, and even from other species, and transfer that gene of interest to the existing cultivar that is in the process of improvement. Application and integration of the modern science into conventional breeding methods reduce the time spent for plant improvement studies and also provide us the ability of transferring defined gene or set of genes without contamination of undesired genes. The desired gene(s) to be integrated into the existing cultivar can be obtained from its domestic cultivars, wild relatives, and related genera (or any other organism) by expanding the availability of gene pool. In turfgrass species, although microprojectile bombardment and protoplast transformation are the major gene transfer systems to achieve transgenic plants, Agrobacterium-mediated transformation is used to get low copy number of the transgene in the transformed cultivars. Agrobacterium-mediated transformation is efficiently used in dicot plants since they occur as a natural host for Agrobacterium tumefaciens. However, by the improvements and modifications of the bacterial strains in this system, many monocots, especially the important cereal crops, can be transformed. Turfgrass was also transformed by using silicon carbide fibers or whiskers, electroporation, and polyethylene glycol-mediated techniques. Herbicide resistance, disease or insect resistance, and stress tolerance were the main traits to be improved in plant transformation studies. The transgenic Agrostis species with different transformation methods, marker systems, and transgene types are outlined in Table 1.1. By using green fluorescent protein (GFP) as a reporter gene, the first study of creeping bentgrass (A. stolonifera L.) by Agrobacterium-mediated transformation was done by Yu et al (2000). In a latter report, higher efficiency with large number of
8
B.S. Ozdemir and H. Budak
Table 1.1 Genetic transformation of bentgrass species with different transgene expression [modified from Wang and Ge (2006)] Plant species Transgenes Method Outcome References Agrostis alba (redtop) npt2 (neomycin phosphotransferase II) Protoplasts Transgenic plants Asano and Ugaki (1994) gusA (b-glucuronidase) Biolistics Transgenic plants Zhong et al. (1993) Agrostis stolonifera (creeping bar (phosphinothricin acetyltransferase) Biolistics Transgenic plants Hartman et al. bentgrass) (1994) bar (phosphinothricin acetyltransferase) Protoplasts Transgenic plants Lee et al. (1996) hph (hygromycin phosphotransferase), Biolistics Transgenic plants Xiao and Ha (1997) gusA (b-glucuronidase) bar (phosphinothricin acetyltransferase) Protoplasts Transgenic plants Asano et al. (1998) hph (hygromycin phosphotransferase), Whiskers Transgenic plants Dalton et al. (1998) gusA (b-glucuronidase) gfp (green fluorescent protein) Agrobacterium Transgenic plants Yu et al. (2000) Biolistics Transgenic plants Chai et al. (2002) hs2 (chitinase-like protein from American elm), bar (phosphinothricin acetyltransferase) PAPII, PAP-Y (pokeweed antiviral proteins), Biolistics Transgenic plantsa Dai et al. (2003) hph (hygromycin phosphotransferase) PR5K (receptor protein kinase gene from Biolistics Transgenic plantsa Guo et al. (2003) Arabidopsis thaliana) Biolistics Transgenic plantsa Wang et al. (2003) RCH10 (chitinase gene from rice), ALG (glucanase gene from alfalfa), bar (phosphinothricin acetyltransferase) bar (phosphinothricin acetyltransferase) Agrobacterium Transgenic plants Luo et al. (2004) TLPD34 (thaumatin-like protein from rice), Agrobacterium Transgenic plantsa Fu et al. (2005a, b) bar(phosphinothricin acetyltransferase) hph (hygromycin phosphotransferase), Agrobacterium Transgenic plants Han et al. (2005) gusA (b-glucuronidase) bar (phosphinothricin acetyltransferase), Agrobacterium Transgenic plants Wang and Ge (2005) gusA (b-glucuronidase) Agrostis tenuis hph (hygromycin phosphotransferase), Agrobacterium Transgenic plants Chai et al. (2004) (colonial bentgrass) gusA (b-glucuronidase) a Transgenic plants transformed with agronomically important traits
transgenic herbicide (bar gene integration)-resistant creeping bentgrass plants was achieved with low copy number of transgene integration by using super binary vector system (Luo et al. 2004). Transgenic herbicideresistant creeping bentgrass plants were produced recently using Agrobacterium-mediated transformation (Kim et al. 2007). Transgenic turfgrass was first produced via bombardment of A. palustris Huds. embryogenic callus tissues (Zhong et al. 1993). On the other hand, A. alba L. (redtop) plants were regenerated from protoplasts that were achieved from suspension culture of embryogenic calli (Asano and Sugiura 1990). The importance of tissue culture parameters in the efficiency of plant transformation system is well known. In order to obtain higher number of transgenic lines, first step is to establish an efficient tissue culture system. In genetic transformation studies, especially in monocots, immature or mature embryo-derived callus
cultures or directly the embryos are used as explant sources. But either way, calli formation is required before or after the transformation process, which is time-consuming. Mature embryo-derived embryogenic calli was used to transfer uidA (b-glucuronidase) and hph (hygromycin phosphotransferase) gene to creeping bentgrass with Agrobacterium-mediated transformation (Han et al. 2005). For creeping bentgrass species, stolon nodes were used with Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. This procedure maintained shoot formation directly from infected nodes by-passing the callus formation step (Wang and Ge 2005). Also, different tissues of creeping bentgrass cultivar Penn A4 were compared for their nuclease activity and its effect on transient GUS expression efficiency after bombardment (Basu et al. 2003). Using the whole vector construct during transformation results in integration of vector backbone sequences
1 Agrostis
into the genome. Using a simple cassette rather than the whole plasmid in transformation of creeping bentgrass by the bombardment of tissues with GFP reporter gene increased the low copy number of transgene integration since the system eliminates the nonessential insertions (Jayaraj et al. 2008) by time eliminating the disadvantage of biolistic transformation. Plant biotechnology is also widely used in improvement of disease resistance. Creeping bentgrass is sensitive to many insects, weeds, disease-causing fungi, and bacteria; hence, this species is used in many genetic improvement studies. Biolistic transformation of creeping bentgrass expressing three forms of pokeweed antiviral proteins (ribosome-inactivating proteins) was established via biolistics (Dai et al. 2003). Creeping bentgrass cultivar was transformed with the CP4 EPSPS gene that confers resistance to glyphosate herbicide. This Roundup Ready® glyphosate-resistant creeping bentgrass is under USDA-APHIS regulated status and for production control studies. It was planted for a four-year trial. Since creeping bentgrass is an outcrossing species with wind dispersal mechanism, at the end of the fourth year its dispersal area was heavily widened. Though in situ hybrids were not found, the potential transgene flow from creeping bentgrass and the possibility of its dispersion via water ways due to its vegetative growth by stolon formation was expressed. The importance of wind for pollen dispersal was emphasized and reported. Moreover, the study of Watrud et al. (2004) emphasized the importance of pollen dispersal by wind and demonstrated the long distance of viable pollen movement and gene flow using CP4 EPSPS as a marker. Also, Reichman et al. (2006) reported the identification of glyphosate-resistant creeping bentgrass plants outside the control area and the transgene escape from cultivated area to the native population area. Not for all transgenic crop species but especially the outcrossing ones were suggested to be evaluated for risk assessment more strictly (Zapiola et al. 2008). Factors affecting gene flow and the status of glyphosate-resistant (GR) crops including the GR creeping bentgrass that are commercially available or under deregulation in the USA were all reviewed by Mallory-Smith and Zapiola (2008). Overexpression of late embryogenesis abundant (LEA) proteins was shown to cause improved tolerance to water deficit in various species. Transformation of creeping bentgrass with barley hva1 gene, member of LEA protein family, using constitutive or
9
stress-inducible promoters was done, and transgenic plants with improved tolerance to drought were developed (Fu et al. 2007). Creeping bentgrass differs in color from a range of olive green to pale green. For ornamental purposes, creeping bentgrass was transformed with maize flavonoid/anthocyanin biosynthetic pathway transcription factor genes, Lc (leaf color) and Pl (purple leaf) via Agrobacterium-mediated gene transfer technique to obtain purple colored creeping bentgrass and the result was three different phenotypes (Han et al. 2009). The RTS gene expressed in tapetal cells was isolated from rice panicles. It was shown that this gene had a role in pollen development and its promoter conferred cell-specific expression. Transformation of rice, Arabidopsis, and creeping bentgrass with RTS promoter and cytotoxic barnase gene induced male sterility showing the promoter’s anther-specific expression, its role in pollen development, and use in male sterility both in dicot and monocot plants (Luo et al. 2006). The use of FLP/FRT site-specific DNA recombination system was evaluated using transgenic creeping bentgrass for yeast FLP recombinase expression and site-specific recombination was suggested to be a useful system for genome modification and transgene manipulation in turfgrass by altering the gene escape due to outcrossing and vegetative growth (Hu et al. 2006). Agrobacterium-mediated transformation was done with mature embryo-derived calli of A. stolonifera. PMI/mannose selection and GFP screenable marker system was used in this study by transferring GFP gene and E. coli manA (also termed as pmi and codes for phosphomannose isomerase) gene. This system was suggested to be environment and ecosystem friendly when compared with the use of herbicide or antibiotic selection systems (Fu et al. 2005a, b).
1.10 Hybridization Studies and Gene Escape Interspecific and intergeneric hybridization between glyphosate-resistant transgenic creeping bentgrass and nontransgenic species from both Agrostis and Polypogon genus was performed. From A. capillaris and P. fugax fertile hybrids were achieved, which makes the transgene movement possible within and
10
between species. This increased the risk of contamination of the weeds with herbicide resistance like genes and the possibility of new weed occurrence (Zhao et al. 2007). Interspecific hybridization between transgenic creeping bentgrass (A. stolonifera L.) that conferred resistance to glufosinate herbicide and four other nontransgenic Agrostis species (A. castellana Boiss. and Reut., A. gigantea Roth, A. canina L., and A. capillaris L.) were examined under field conditions. Interspecific transgenic hybrid frequency was at a lower rate with respect to intraspecific hybridization (0.631%). While the interspecific transgenic hybrids were formed between creeping bentgrass and A. capillaris (0.044%) and A. castellana (0.0015%), no transgenic hybrids with A. gigantea or A. canina were observed. The flowering time difference between the Agrostis species and the only substantial overlap of flowering between A. stolonifera and A. capillaris was the main concern of these hybridization rates (Belanger et al. 2003). Using the data from the previous study, transgene pollen dispersal model was performed. It was shown that pollen dispersal varied from site to site with the environmental conditions. It was stated that there was risk of transgene escape, but the persistence of this trait was possible only with herbicide selection, and the herbicide application was also causing natural resistance in weed populations. They suggested that the results of such gene flow could cause minimum problem at ecological aspect, and mismanagement of herbicide application could cause more serious problems (Meagher et al. 2003). Herbicide-resistant transgenic A. stolonifera was produced by engineering the CP4 EPSPS gene. It would have been the first transgenic wind-pollinated perennial crop grown in open areas, but it was reported that pollen-mediated transgene flow was causing a serious risk. Cytoplasmic male sterility or plastid engineering might be the solution in these cases to prevent transgene escape through pollen dispersal.
References Asano Y, Sugiura K (1990) Plant regeneration from suspension culture-derived protoplasts of Agrostis alba L. (Redtop). Plant Sci 72(2):267–273 Asano Y, Ugaki M (1994) Transgenic plants of Agrostis alba obtained by electroporation-mediated direct gene transfer into protoplasts. Plant Cell Rep 13:243–246
B.S. Ozdemir and H. Budak Asano Y, Ito Y, Fukami M, Sugiura K, Fujiie A (1998) Herbicide-resistant transgenic creeping bentgrass plants obtained by electroporation using an altered buffer. Plant Cell Rep 17:963–967 Barthram GT, Elston DA, Mullins CE (2005) The physical resistance of grass patches to invasion. Plant Ecol 176:79–85 Barthram GT, Elston DA, Griffiths JH, Bolton GR, Wright G (2006) Within-year variation in the vegetative spread of five temperate grasses. J Veg Sci 17:315–322 Basu C, Luo H, Kusch A, Chandlee J (2003) Transient reporter gene (S) in creeping bentgrass (Agrostis palustris) is affected by in vivo nuclease activity. Biotechnol Lett 25:939–944 Belanger FC, Meagher TR, Day PR, Plumley K, Meyer WA (2003) Interspecific hybridization between Agrostis stolonifera (creeping bentgrass) and related Agrostis species under field conditions. Crop Sci 43:240–246 Belanger FC, Bonos S, Meyer WA (2004) Dollar spot resistant hybrids between creeping bentgrass and colonial bentgrass. Crop Sci 44(2):581–586 Bonos SA (2005) Creeping bentgrass cultivars with improved dollar spot resistance. Golf Course Manag 73:96–100 Bonos SA (2006) Heritability of dollar spot resistance in creeping bentgrass. Phytopathology 96(8):808–812 Bonos SA, Plumley KA, Meyer WA (2002) Ploidy determination in Agrostis using flow cytometry and morphological traits. Crop Sci 42(1):192–196 Bonos SA, Casler MD, Meyer WA (2003) Inheritance of dollar spot resistance in creeping bentgrass. Crop Sci 43:2189–2196 Brede DA, Sellmann MJ (2003) Three minor Agrostis species: Redtop, Highland Bentgrass, and Idaho Bentgrass. In: Casler M, Duncan RR (eds) Turfgrass biology, genetics and breeding. Wiley, Hoboken, NJ, USA, pp 207–223 Brilman LA (2003) Velvet bentgrass (Agrostis canina L.). In: Casler M, Duncan RR (eds) Turfgrass biology, genetics and breeding. Wiley, Hoboken, NJ, pp 201–205 Budak H, Su S, Ergen N (2006) Revealing constitutively expressed resistance genes in Agrostis species using PCR-based motifdirected RNA fingerprinting. Genet Res 88:165–175 Busey P (2003) Cultural management of weeds in turfgrass: a review. Crop Sci 43:1899–1911 Caceres ME, Pupilli F, Piano E, Arcioni S (2000) RFLP markers are an effective tool for the identification of creeping bentgrass (Agrostis stolonifera L.) cultivars. Genet Resour Crop Evol 47:455–459 Caˆmara MPS, O’Neill NR, van Berkum P, Dernoeden PH, Palm ME (2000) Ophiosphaerella agrostis sp. nov. and its relationship to other species of Ophiosphaerella. Mycologia 92:317–325 Casler MD (2006) Centenary review: perennial grasses for turf, sport and amenity uses: evolution of form, function and fitness for human benefit. J Agric Sci 144:189–203 Chai B, Maqbool SB, Hajela RK, Green D, Vargas JM Jr, Warkentin D, Sabzikar R, Sticklen MB (2002) Cloning of a chitinaselike cDNA (hs2), its transfer to creeping bentgrass (Agrostis palustris Huds.) and development of brown patch (R. solani) disease resistant transgenic lines. Plant Sci 163:183–193 Chai ML, Senthil KK, Kim DH (2004) Transgenic plants of colonial bentgrass from embryogenic callus via Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. Plant Cell Tissue Organ Cult 77:165–171
1 Agrostis Chakraborty N, Bae J, Warnke S, Chang T, Jung G (2005) Linkage map construction in allotetraploid creeping bentgrass (Agrostis stolonifera L.). Theor Appl Genet 111: 795–803 Chakraborty N, Curley J, Warnke S, Casler MD, Jung G (2006) Mapping QTL for dollar spot resistance in creeping bentgrass (Agrostis stolonifera L.). Theor Appl Genet 113: 1421–1435 DaCosta M, Huang B (2006a) Changes in carbon partitioning and accumulation patterns during drought and recovery for colonial bentgrass, creeping bentgrass, and velvet bentgrass. J Am Soc Hortic Sci 131(4):484–490 DaCosta M, Huang BR (2006b) Osmotic adjustment associated with variation in bentgrass tolerance to drought stress. J Am Soc Hortic Sci 131(3):338–344 DaCosta M, Huang BR (2006c) Minimum water requirements for creeping, colonial, and velvet bentgrasses under fairway conditions. Crop Sci 46(1):81–89 DaCosta M, Huang BR (2007a) Changes in antioxidant enzyme activities and lipid peroxidation for bentgrass species in response to drought stress. J Am Soc Hortic Sci 132(3):319–326 DaCosta M, Huang BR (2007b) Drought survival and recuperative ability of bentgrass species associated with changes in abscisic acid and cytokinin production. J Am Soc Hortic Sci 132(1):60–66 Dai WD, Bonos S, Guo Z, Meyer WA, Day PR, Belanger FC (2003) Expression of pokeweed antiviral proteins in creeping bentgrass. Plant Cell Rep 21:497–502 Dalton SJ, Bettany AJE, Timms E, Morris P (1998) Transgenic plants of Lolium multiflorum, Lolium perenne, Festuca arundinacea and Agrostis stolonifera by silicon carbide fibermediated of cell suspension cultures. Plant Sci 132:31–43 Dernoeden PH, O’Neill NR, Caˆmara MPS, Feng Y (1999) A new disease of Agrostis palustris incited by an undescribed species of Ophiosphaerella. Plant Dis 83:397 Dinler G, Budak H (2008) Analysis of expressed sequence tags (ESTs) from Agrostis species obtained using sequence related amplified polymorphism. Biochem Genet 46:663–676 Duncan RR (2004) Exchange of science between turf & field crops: commonalities between turf & field crops and lessons. “New directions for a diverse planet”. Proceedings for the 4th International Crop Science Congress, 26 Sep–1 Oct 2004, Brisbane, Australia, pp 1–7 Fidanza MA, Wetzel HC III, Agnew JE, Kaminski JE (2006) Evaluation of fungicide and plant growth regulator tank-mix programmes on dollar spot severity of creeping bentgrass. Crop Prot 25:1032–1038 Fu JM, Dernoeden PH (2008) Carbohydrate metabolism in creeping bentgrass as influenced by two summer irrigation practices. J Am Soc Hortic Sci 133(5):678–683 Fu D, Tisserat Ned A, Xiao Y, Settleb D, Muthukrishnanc S, Liang GH (2005a) Overexpression of rice TLPD34 enhances dollar-spot resistance in transgenic bentgrass. Plant Sci 168:671–680 Fu D, Xiao Y, Muthukrishnan S, Liang GH (2005b) In vivo performance of a dual genetic marker, manA-gfp, in transgenic bentgrass. Genome 48:722–730 Fu D, Huang B, Xiao Y, Muthukrishnan S, Liang GH (2007) Overexpression of barley hva1 gene in creeping bentgrass for improving drought tolerance. Plant Cell Rep 26:467–477
11 Guo ZF, Bonos S, Meyer WA, Day PR, Belanger FC (2003) Transgenic creeping bentgrass with delayed dollar spot symptoms. Mol Breed 11:95–101 Han N, Chen D, Bian H-W, Deng M-J, Zhu M-Y (2005) Production of transgenic creeping bentgrass Agrostis stolonifera var. palustris plants by Agrobacterium tumefaciensmediated transformation using hygromycin selection. Plant Cell Tissue Organ Cult 81:131–138 Han Y-J, Kim Y-M, Lee Y-J, Kim SJ, Cho K-C, Chandrasekhar T, Song P-S, Woo Y-M, Kim J-I (2009) Production of purplecolored creeping bentgrass using maize transcription factor genes Pl and Lc through Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. Plant Cell Rep 28:397–406 Hartman CL, Lee L, Day PR, Tumer NE (1994) Herbicide resistant turfgrass (Agrostis palustris Huds.) by biolistic transformation. Biotechnology 12:919–923 He Y, Liu X, Huang B (2005) Protein changes in response to heat stress in acclimated and nonacclimated creeping bentgrass. J Am Soc Hortic Sci 130:521–526 Hitchcock AS (1971) Manual of the grasses of the United States, 2nd edn. Dover Publications, New York, USA Hollman AB, Stier JC, Casler MD, Jung G, Brilman LA (2005) Identification of putative velvet bentgrass clones using RAPD markers. Crop Sci 45(3):923–930 Hu Q, Nelson K, Luo H (2006) FLP-mediated site-specific recombination for genome modification in turfgrass. Biotechnol Lett 28:1793–1804 Hubbard JCE (1984) Grasses: a guide to their structure, identification, uses and distribution in the British Isles, 3rd edn. Viking Penguin, New York, USA Jayaraj J, Liang GH, Muthukrishnan S, Punja ZK (2008) Generation of low copy number and stably expressing transgenic creeping bentgrass plants using minimal gene cassette bombardment. Biol Plant 52(2):215–221 John I, Drake R, Farrell A, Cooper W, Lee P, Horton P, Grierson D (1995) Delayed leaf senescence in ethylene deficient ACCoxidase antisense tomato plants-molecular and physiological analysis. Plant J 7:483–490 Kaminski JE, Dernoeden PH (2006) Dead spot severity, pseudothecia development, and overwintering of Ophiosphaerella agrostis in creeping bentgrass. Phytopathology 96:248–254 Kellogg EA (2001) Evolutionary history of the grasses. Plant Physiol 125:1198–1205 Kim SJ, Lee JY, Kim YM, Yang SS, Hwang OJ, Hong NJ, Kim KM, Lee HY, Song PS, Kim JII (2007) Agrobacterium-mediated high-efficiency transformation of creeping bentgrass with herbicide resistance. J Plant Biol 50(5):577–585 Larkindale J, Huang B (2004) Change of lipid composition and saturation level in leaves and roots for heat-stressed and heat-acclimated creeping bentgrass (Agrostis stolonifera). Environ Exp Bot 51:57–67 Lee L (1996) Turfgrass biotechnology. Plant Sci 115:1–8 Lee L, Laramore CL, Day PR, Tumer E (1996) Transformation and regeneration of creeping bentgrass (Agrostis palustris Huds.) protoplasts. Crop Sci 36:401–406 Li HM, Rotter D, Bonos SA, Meyer WA, Belanger FC (2005) Identification of a gene in the process of being lost from the genus Agrostis. Plant Physiol 138:2386–2395 Liu X, Huang B (2008) Photosynthetic acclimation to high temperatures associated with heat tolerance in creeping bentgrass. J Plant Physiol 165:1947–1953
12 Luo H, Hu Q, Nelson K, Longo C, Kausch AP, Chandlee JM, Wipff JK, Fricker CR (2004) Agrobacterium tumefaciensmediated creeping bentgrass (Agrostis stolonifera L.) transformation using phosphinothricin selection results in a high frequency of single-copy transgene integration. Plant Cell Rep 22:645–652 Luo H, Lee J-Y, Hu Q, Nelson-Vasilchik K, Eitas TK, Lickwar C, Kausch AP, Chandlee JM, Hodges TK (2006) RTS, a rice anther-specific gene is required for male fertility and its promoter sequence directs tissue-specific gene expression in different plant species. Plant Mol Biol 62:397–408 Luthe DS, Krans JV, Park S-Y, Wang D (2000) The presence and role of heat-shock proteins in creeping bentgrass. In: Wilkinson RE (ed) Plant environment interactions, 2nd edn. Marcel Dekker, New York, USA, pp 283–319 Lyons EM, Pote J, DaCosta M, Huang B (2007) Whole-plant carbon relations and root respiration associated with root tolerance to high soil temperature for Agrostis grasses. Environ Exp Bot 59:307–313 Mallory-Smith C, Zapiola M (2008) Gene flow from glyphosate-resistant crops. Pest Manag Sci 64:428–440 Marcum MB (2001) Salinity tolerance of 35 bentgrass cultivars. HortScience 36(2):374–376 McCarty LB, Dudeck AE (1993) Salinity effects on bentgrass germination. HortScience 28(1):15–17 Meagher TR, Belanger FC, Day PR (2003) Using empirical data to model transgene dispersal. Philos Trans Roy Soc Lond B Biol Sci 358:1157–1162 Park S-Y, Shivaji R, Krans JV, Luthe DS (1996) Heat shock response in heat tolerant and non-tolerant variants of Agrostis palustris Huds. Plant Physiol 111:515–524 Rachmilevitch S, Lambers H, Huang B (2008) Short-term and long-term root respiratory acclimation to elevated temperatures associated with root thermotolerance for two Agrostis grass species. J Exp Bot 59(14):3803–3809 Rajasekar S, Fei S-Z, Christians NE (2007) Analysis of genetic diversity in colonial bentgrass (Agrostis capillaris L.) using randomly amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) markers. Genet Resour Crop Evol 54:45–53 Reichman JR, Watrud LS, Lee EH, Burdick CA, Bollman MA, Storm MJ, King GA, Mallory-Smith C (2006) Establishment of transgenic herbicide-resistant creeping bentgrass (Agrostis stolonifera L.) in nonagronomic habitats. Mol Ecol 15:4243–4255 Rotter D, Bharti AK, Li HM, Luo C, Bonos SA, Bughrara S, Jung G, Messing J, Meyer WA, Rudd S, Warnke SE, Belanger FC (2007) Analysis of EST sequences suggests recent origin of allotetraploid colonial and creeping bentgrasses. Mol Genet Genomics 278:197–209 Ruemmele BA (2003) Agrostis capillaris (Agrostis tenuis Sibth.) colonial bentgrass. In: Casler M, Duncan RR (eds) Turfgrass biology, genetics and breeding. Wiley, Hoboken, NJ, USA, pp 187–200 Saski C, Lee S-B, Fjellheim S, Guda C, Jansen R, Luo H, Tomkins J, Rognli OA, Daniell H, Clarke JL (2007) Complete chloroplast genome sequences of Hordeum vulgare, Sorghum bicolor and Agrostis stolonifera, and comparative analyses with other grass genomes. Theor Appl Genet 115:571–590 Scheef EA, Casler MD, Jung G (2003) Development of speciesspecific SCAR markers in bentgrass. Crop Sci 43:345–349
B.S. Ozdemir and H. Budak Tercek MT, Hauber DP, Darwin SP (2003) Genetic and historical relationships among geothermally adapted Agrostis (bentgrass) of North America and Kamchatka: evidence for a previously unrecognized, thermally adapted taxon. Am J Bot 90:130–1312 Tian J, Belanger FC, Huang B (2009) Identification of heat stress-responsive genes in heat-adapted thermal Agrostis scabra by suppression subtractive hybridization. J Plant Physiol 166:588–601 Vergara GV, Bughrara SS (2004) Genetic differentiation of tetraploid creeping bentgrass and hexaploid redtop bentgrass genotypes by AFLP and their use in turfgrass breeding. Crop Sci 44(3):884–890 Wang Z-Y, Ge Y (2005) Rapid and efficient production of transgenic bermudagrass and creeping bentgrass bypassing the callus formation phase. Funct Plant Biol 32:769–776 Wang Z-Y, Ge Y (2006) Invited review: recent advances in genetic transformation of forage and turf grasses. In Vitro Cell Dev Biol Plant 42:1–18 Wang D, Luthe DS (2003) Heat-sensitivity in a bentgrass variant: failure to accumulate a chloroplast heat shock protein isoform implicated for heat tolerance. Plant Physiol 133:319–327 Wang G, Skipper HD (2004) Identification of denitrifying rhizobacteria from bentgrass and bermudagrass golf greens. J Appl Microbiol 97:827–837 Wang Z-Y, Bell J, Ge YX, Lehmann D (2003) Inheritance of transgenes in transgenic tall fescue (Festuca arundinacea Schreb). In Vitro Cell Dev Biol Plant 39:277–282 Warnke S (2003) Creeping bentgrass (Agrostis stolonifera L.). In: Casler M, Duncan RR (eds) Turfgrass biology, genetics and breeding. Wiley, Hoboken, NJ, USA, pp 175–185 Watrud LS, Lee EH, Fairbrother A, Burdick C, Reichman JR, Bollman M, Storm M, King G, Van de Water PK (2004) Evidence for landscape level pollen-mediated gene flow from genetically modified creeping bentgrass using CP4 EPSPS as a marker. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 101: 14533–14538 Wu C, Hsiang T (1998) Pathogenicity and formulation of Typhula phacorrhiza, a biocontrol agent of gray snow mold. Plant Dis 82:1003–1006 Xiao L, Ha SB (1997) Efficient selection and regeneration of creeping bentgrass transformants following particle bombardment. Plant Cell Rep 16:874–878 Xu Y, Huang B (2007) Heat-induced leaf senescence and hormonal changes for thermal bentgrass and turf-type bentgrass species differing in heat tolerance. J Am Soc Hortic Sci 132:185–192 Xu J, Huang B (2008a) Differential protein expression for geothermal Agrostis scabra and turf-type Agrostis stolonifera differing in heat tolerance. Environ Exp Bot 64:58–64 Xu C, Huang B (2008b) Root proteomic responses to heat stress in two Agrostis grass species contrasting in heat tolerance. J Exp Bot 59(15):4183–4194 Xu J, Tian J, Belanger FC, Huang B (2007) Identification and characterization of an expansin gene AsEXP1 associated with heat tolerance in C3 Agrostis grass species. J Exp Bot 58(13):3789–3796 Xu J, Belanger F, Huang B (2008) Differential gene expression in shoots and roots under heat stress for a geothermal and non-thermal Agrostis grass species contrasting in heat tolerance. Environ Exp Bot 63:240–247
1 Agrostis Xu Y, Tian J, Gianfagna T, Huang B (2009) Effects of SAG12-ipt expression on cytokinin production, growth and senescence of creeping bentgrass (Agrostis stolonifera L.) under heat stress. Plant Growth Regul 57:281–291 Yu TT, Skinner DZ, Liang GH, Trick HN, Huang B, Muthukrishnan S (2000) Agrobacterium-mediated transformation of creeping bentgrass using GFP as a reporter gene. Hereditas 133:229–233 Zapiola ML, Campbell CK, Butler MD, Mallory-Smith CA (2008) Escape and establishment of transgenic glyphosate-resistant creeping bentgrass Agrostis stolonifera in
13 Oregon, USA: a 4-year study. J Appl Ecol 45 (2):486–494 Zhao H, Bughrara SS, Oliveira JA (2006) Genetic diversity in colonial bentgrass (Agrostis capillaris L.) revealed by EcoRIMseI and PstI-MseI AFLP markers. Genome 49:328–335 Zhao H, Bughrara SS, Wang Y (2007) Cytology and pollen grain fertility in creeping bentgrass interspecific and intergeneric hybrids. Euphytica 156:227–235 Zhong H, Bolyard MG, Srinivasan C, Sticklen MB (1993) Transgenic plants of turfgrass (Agrostis palustris Huds.) from microprojectile bombardment of embryogenic callus. Plant Cell Rep 13:1–6
.
Chapter 2
Bromus W.M. Williams, A.V. Stewart, and M.L. Williamson
2.1 Introduction Bromus L. is a genus of approximately 150 C3 grass species (Clayton and Renvoize 1986; Watson and Dallwitz 1992) that can be considered to be intermediate between the Festuceae and the Triticeae. The genus is distributed widely in Asia, Europe, Africa, and the Americas, and today, introductions are widespread in the temperate world. There is a high incidence of polyploidy, species ranging from 2x to 12x. Many of the high polyploids are of allopolyploid (hybrid) origin (Stebbins 1981; Armstrong 1991). There is a diversity of annuals and perennials with a range of bunchgrass and rhizomatous morphologies.
2.2 Evolution and Systematics The genus is taxonomically difficult with several unresolved species complexes, especially in section Ceratochloa. For the purposes of this chapter, the classification of Bromus into seven sections (Smith 1970, 1985) will be used (Table 2.1). These sections are: Bromus (30–40 species), Genea Dumort. (seven species), Pnigma Dumort. (about 60 species), Ceratochloa (P. Beauv.) Griseb. (10–16 species), Neobromus (Shear.) Hitchcock (two species), and Nevskiella
W.M. Williams (*) AgResearch, Grasslands Research Centre, Private Bag 11008, Palmerston North 4442, New Zealand e-mail:
[email protected]
(Krecz & Vved.) Tournay. (one species). Section Boissiera (Hochst. ex Steudel) P. M. Smith was included in section Bromus by Smith (1970) and separated as a separate section by Smith (1985). The major agricultural species come from sections Pnigma (B. inermis Leyss.) and Ceratochloa (B. catharticus Vahl, B. sitchensis Trin. in Bong). Polyploidy and hybridization feature strongly in the evolution of many species (Stebbins 1981). The sections are distinguished morphologically according to numbers of nerves in the glumes, spikelet shape, and lemma and awn morphology, as well as karyotypes, genome relationships (chromosome pairing), ploidal levels, and serological differences. Because of its complexity, no worldwide taxonomic treatment exists, but many regional descriptions and identification keys have been published, including those of Alaska (Mitchell 1967), Mexico and Central America (Soderstrom and Beaman 1968), North America (Wagnon 1952; Allred 1993; Pavlick 1995), South America (Pinto-Escobar 1981, 1986; Matthei 1986; Gutierrez and Pensiero 1998; Planchuelo and Peterson 2000), Malesia (Veldkamp et al. 1991), New Zealand (Forde and Edgar 1995), South-East Asia (Chen and Kuoh 2000), and Europe and North Africa (Spalton 2002, 2004). Stebbins (1981) hypothesized that Bromus probably arose in Eurasia, when the Festuceae and Triticeae were separating. The original Bromus species are extinct and were probably wiped out during the dramatic climatic fluctuations of the Pliocene and Pleistocene. During the Pliocene, differentiation of sections Neobromus, Ceratochloa and Pnigma occurred. Sections Neobromus and Ceratochloa spread to North America and later to South America. These sections became extinct in Eurasia, and even
C. Kole (ed.), Wild Crop Relatives: Genomic and Breeding Resources, Millets and Grasses, DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-14255-0_2, # Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
15
16 Table 2.1 Genus Bromus taxonomic delimitation by different authors [modified from Armstrong (1991)] Tzvelev (1976) Smith (1970, 1985) Stebbins (1981) 7 Genera 7 Sections 7 Subgenera Anisantha Genea Stenobromus Bromus Bromus Bromus Bromopsis Pnigma Festucaria Ceratochloa Ceratochloa Ceratochloa – Neobromus Neobromus Boissiera Boissiera Boissiera Nevskiella Nevskiella Nevskiella Littledalea
diploids and tetraploids became extinct in the New World, with the build-up of octoploids in Ceratochloa. In the Pleistocene, section Pnigma spread to Africa and North America, while polyploids increased in Eurasia. Sections Bromus and Genea have evolved more recently. The basic chromosome number is x ¼ 7, like other Poaceae. Chromosome and nuclear genome sizes have changed considerably during speciation (Armstrong 1991). Stebbins (1981) proposed that the trend was towards larger genomes. On this basis, section Ceratochloa would have the most primitive genome size. Comparisons of chloroplast restriction site maps of B. inermis with the cereals have shown that Bromus is closer to the Triticeae than to the Aveneae and, within the Triticeae, it is closer to barley than to wheat and rye (Pillay 1993, 1995). Attempts to intercross species from different sections indicate that the reproductive barriers between sections are strong. Although some intersection hybrids have been produced, none has shown pairing of the chromosomes from the different sections, indicating wide differentiation of the chromosomes (Armstrong 1991). Molecular marker and DNA sequence phylogenies are revealing that some of the old sections are artificial groupings that require revision. A study of 46 species, representing a wide sample of the species diversity in Bromus, was conducted by Saarela et al. (2007), using nuclear and chloroplast DNA sequences. This study showed that current systematic classifications do not fully reflect phylogeny within the genus. Some differences between nuclear and chloroplast sequence
W.M. Williams et al.
phylogenies require clarification, and much wider sampling of the species is also needed.
2.3 Agricultural Status About ten species are used in agriculture and many more have weed status. Two sections contribute important agricultural species: Section Pnigma has the winterhardy Bromus inermis group, B. inermis and B. biebersteinii R. & S. (2n ¼ 56), B. riparius Rehm. (2n ¼ 70), and B. erectus Huds. (2n ¼ 28) with more than 40 cultivars in North America and Europe. Additionally, this section also contains B. auleticus Trin. ex Nees (2n ¼ 42) used to a limited extent in southern Brazil and Uruguay. Section Ceratochloa has the hexaploid B. catharticus complex (2n ¼ 42), including B. stamineus E. Desv. and B. valdivianus Phil. with over 30 cultivars in Argentina, France, Chile, New Zealand, Australia, and USA. The octoploid B. carinatus Hook. and Arn. complex (2n ¼ 56), including B. sitchensis and B. marginatus Nees ex Steud., has over five cultivars in France and USA, while the South American octoploid B. coloratus Steud. has one cultivar in Australia. The duodecaploid B. arizonicus (Shear) Stebbins (2n ¼ 84) has one very winter active annual cultivar, Cucamonga used in USA. In addition, some annual species of section Bromus have had cultivars developed for revegetation uses. For example, B. arvensis Guss. (2n ¼ 14) has a cultivar Dos in Russia and B. mollis L. (2n ¼ 28) has the cultivar Blando in USA. From section Genea, B. rubens L. has the cultivar Panache (Alderson and Sharp 1995). B. mango E.Desv. (section Ceratochloa) was used as a cereal grain crop in Chile. This plant was cultivated as a biennial cereal by the Araucana Indians of Chile until at least the middle of the 1800s. Thought to have become extinct (Scholz and Mos 1994), it is claimed to have been rediscovered and has been classified as a form of B. catharticus ssp. catharticus (Vahl) Herter (Massa et al. 2004). The potential agricultural value of many of the Bromus species for New Zealand was assessed by Rumball (1968) and Rumball and Forde (1976).
2 Bromus
2.4 Mediterranean and SW Asian Annual Species of Section Genea Section Genea (subgenus Stenobromus; Stebbins 1981) consists of seven annual species that are self-fertilizing, with ploidies ranging from 2x to 8x. The diploids are B. sterilis L., B. tectorum L., and B. fasciculatus C. Presl, and the tetraploids B. madritensis L. and B. rubens. In addition, there is a hexaploid B. rigidus Roth and an octoploid B. diandrus Roth. Among the diploid species, B. sterilis and B. tectorum are distinct and widespread in Europe and Eurasia while B. fasciculatus is restricted to the eastern Mediterranean region. However, the widespread tetraploids have variously been classified as subspecies (Sales 1994) or separate species (Oja 2002). The hexaploid and octoploid species occur in the Mediterranean region and southern and western Europe. They have also been variously classified as separate species, subspecies, or varieties, and as a polyploid species complex. Most of the species of this section have become weeds in many countries. An elegant molecular phylogenetic study (Fortune et al. 2008) has shown that all of the polyploid species of the section have hybrid origins and, apart from one unidentified lineage, all three other parental lineages were closely related to the three diploid species. Designating the diploid genomes as B. sterilis (SS), B. fasciculatus (FF), and B. tectorum (TT), the polyploids have been proposed (female donor first) as: B. madritensis (FFSS), B. rubens (FFTT), B. rigidus (XXFFTT), and B. diandrus (XXFFTTSS), where XX is an unidentified parent (Fortune et al. 2008). The two 4x species were demonstrated to be distinct species, and the 8x B. diandrus appears to have originated as a hybrid between 6x B. rigidus and 2x B. sterilis. This last observation has been supported by earlier research (Fortune et al. 2008). Species of this section have apparently donated genomes via hybridization with species of section Bromus to form the tetraploid B. pectinatus Thunb. complex (Stebbins 1981; Saarela et al. 2007) (see Sect. 2.6). The main characteristic of this group of species is their propensity for weediness. B. tectorum is generally considered to be cleistogamous and has become an invasive noxious weed in dry, open areas of North America, where it is called cheatgrass or downy chess. Simple sequence repeat (SSR) marker research has
17
indicated that B. tectorum can outcross, giving populations the capacity to absorb new genetic variation and potentially to increase their invasive capacity (Ashley and Longland 2007). The high polyploids, B. rigidus (6x) (ripgut brome) and B. diandrus (8x) (great brome) are severe weeds of crops in Australia (Kon and Blacklow 1990) and New Zealand (Dastgheib et al. 2003). These weeds form acceptable early spring forage in the early growth stages, but the presence of awns on mature seeds makes them a danger to the health of grazing animals in late spring and summer.
2.5 Section Pnigma Species of this large section (about 60) are native to Eurasia, Africa, and the Americas. Two distinct species groups were proposed by Armstrong (1981, 1983). The first was a group of long-lived perennials (rhizomatous or densely tufted) from Eurasia that were mostly polyploids (4x–10x) with large anthers and small chromosomes. In this group was B. pumpellianus Scribn., which also occurs in North America, as well as the Eurasian species B. inermis, B. erectus, B. variegatus M. Bieb., and B. riparius. The second group included mainly diploid, relatively short-lived, loosely tufted, non-rhizomatous species from North America characterized by small anthers and large chromosomes. This group included the B. ramosus Huds. complex from Eurasia (Armstrong 1981, 1983, 1991; Stebbins 1981). The Eurasian and North American species were reported to be difficult to hybridize (Armstrong 1983), supporting the existence of the groups and suggesting that they may have quite different evolutionary histories. However, further analyses of these species, while confirming the existence of groups with very different chromosome sizes, have not supported a simple evolutionary situation. Analysis has not been helped by difficult taxonomy in which similar taxa with widely different ploidy levels have been given the same species designations. Examples include B. variegatus, which is said to exist in a range of ploidy levels from diploid to decaploid. However, a decaploid is very unlikely to be an autoploid form derived from the diploid. It is far more likely that hybridization has been involved and that these taxa are
18
morphologically similar but probably have very different genomic constitutions. The existence of the two species groups with different chromosome sizes was established by hybridization studies and confirmed by nuclear DNA analyses. Hybrids were used to show that the chromosomes of the Eurasian B. ramosus complex were larger than the other Eurasian species B. inermis, B. variegatus, B. erectus, B. pumpellianus, and B. riparius. However, they were similar in size to B. pacificus Shear and B. richardsonii Link from North America. The North American species may all have variations of a single (L) genome. Interspecific hybrids were made between several of the diploid North American species and, despite good chromosome pairing, they were sterile. This was consistent with these species all containing the same (L) genome and in the process of differentiating by cryptic chromosomal rearrangements (Armstrong 1991). The Eurasian species have so far had two genomes (A and B) identified by cytogenetic analyses (Armstrong 1991) and there may be a third (C) (see Sect. 2.5.1). The A and B genomes are the two genomes in tetraploid forms of B. inermis and B. pumpellianus, one of which (A) is also close to that of tetraploid B. erectus. The B genome has some homology (homeology) with the first but is of uncertain origin. Armstrong (1983) suggested that the species of the B. ramosus complex may be the progenitors, or be related to the progenitors, of the American species. Sutkowska and Mitka (2008) also hypothesized that this Eurasian complex is the source of the L genome. These authors suggested that the L genome may have originated from the B genome, in line with the suggestion (Stebbins 1981; Armstrong 1983) that the large chromosome species were derived from small chromosome species, possibly before the migration to America, and before the evolution of the polyploid species currently found in Eurasia. In support of the existence of two groups of species, there appeared to be little or no pairing homology in hybrids between the large chromosomes of B. ramosus and B. pacificus and the small chromosomes of the Eurasian polyploids (Armstrong 1984). However, there was also little pairing homology between the chromosomes of B. ramosus and B. pacificus, possibly emphasizing the difficulties of using pairing affinities in tetraploids, where genetic control of chromosome pairing can occur (Armstrong 1984).
W.M. Williams et al.
Sutkowska and Mitka (2008) used random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) analyses to obtain evidence consistent with B. erectus and its close relatives being the oldest group of species in the section. This evidence was also consistent with B. variegatus having the B genome. The inconsistencies in chromosome behavior are reflected by the results of molecular phylogenetic analyses. Nuclear DNA (internal transcribed spacer, ITS) sequence analysis has shown that section Pnigma is far from being monophyletic (Saarela et al. 2007). The Eurasian species of section Pnigma did not occur in one clade and the American species formed several well defined clades. The molecular data indicated that section Pnigma is probably an artificial group and that its current status as a section may be inappropriate. This was supported by the results of C-banding and DNA content analyses (Tuna et al. 2005). However, care is needed as reticulate evolution may have mixed the ancestral genomes such that they are apparently now distributed between continents (Sutkowska and Mitka 2008). There are many conflicting observations and there is a clear need to use further molecular analyses to resolve the species relationships in this artificial group so that more effective use of the potentially valuable wild relatives can be achieved. Analysis of chloroplast DNA using species-specific restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) following interspecific hybridization has indicated uniparental maternal inheritance in Bromus species so far investigated (Pillay and Armstrong 2001). In crosses between B. arvensis (2n ¼ 14) as female and B. inermis (2n ¼ 28, 56), and B. erectus (2n ¼ 42, 56, 70), all F1 plants had the female chloroplast restriction patterns. No paternal or biparental inheritance was detected. In summary, there are about 35 Eurasian and 25 American species in this section. To-date, very few species have been studied, and conclusions about the evolution of the groups may be clarified as more species are given close research attention (Armstrong 1984).
2.5.1 B. inermis (Smooth Bromegrass, Russian Brome) One of the most important agricultural species, B. inermis, belongs to this section. ITS DNA sequence
2 Bromus
analysis (Saarela et al. 2007) placed this species in a small clade with four other Eurasian species, B. erectus, B. korotkoyi Drob., B. pumpellianus (also native to North America), and B. riparius. Somewhat surprisingly, these formed a sister clade to a larger group comprising all of the monophyletic sections Genea, Neobromus, and Ceratochloa, as well as B. brachyanthera Doll. from South America. The form commonly grown in North America is autoallooctoploid (2n ¼ 8x ¼ 56). There are also allotetraploid (2n ¼ 4x ¼ 28) and hexaploid (2n ¼ 6x ¼ 42) forms (Tan and Dunn 1977). The >250 accessions held by USDA Plant Germplasm System are predominantly 8x, with a few 4x and no 6x forms (Tuna et al. 2001). The tetraploid has regular meiosis (Carnahan and Hill 1960). The octoploid is irregular at meiosis, forming mostly quadrivalents and bivalents. A chlorophyll mutant has exhibited tetrasomic inheritance and an intermediate chromosome-chromatid type of segregation pattern (Ghosh and Knowles 1964). The genomic constitutions of the octoploid and tetraploid have been proposed to be AAAABBBB and AABB, respectively, and the A and B genomes appear to be closely related (Armstrong 1979). Giemsa C-banding has confirmed the alloploid nature of the tetraploid. However, karyotype analysis and Giemsa C-banding has indicated that the octoploid cytotype is not the same as a doubled version of the tetraploid cytotype (Tuna et al. 2004). There is evidence that the genomic constitution could be AAAABBCC, based on karyotype analyses showing that B. inermis has two pairs of chromosomes with large satellites and only one pair with small satellites (Ghosh and Knowles 1964; Wilton 1965; Armstrong 1973). However, this characteristic appears to be either inconsistent or polymorphic (Rychlewski 1970; Armstrong 1981). Tuna et al. (2004) confirmed the inconsistency of expression of the small satellite chromosomes and generally also confirmed the karyotypic analysis of Armstrong (1977b) showing two large satellite pairs and one small satellite pair. These authors indicated that the AAAABBBB hypothesis of Armstrong (1977b) was not supported by their chromosome analyses. To-date, the genome of B. inermis has remained relatively intractable to cytogenetic analyses using karyotype and C-banding. There is a need for the application of fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) and genomic in situ hybridization (GISH) techniques.
19
Interspecific hybrids indicate that the A genome may come from B. erectus (2n ¼ 4x ¼ 28) (Armstrong 1991; Walton 1980). However, a similar genome also occurs in a diploid form of B. variegatus Bieb. and a diploid that resembles B. inermis (Armstrong 1991). Hybrids between diploid B. variegatus and tetraploid and octoploid B. inermis had chromosome pairing patterns that suggested that the B. variegatus genome was not the same as either the A or B genome but was similar to both (Armstrong 1984). Karyotype and Giemsa C-banding analyses have indicated that the chromosomes of both B. erectus and B. variegatus differ from each other and from those of B. inermis. Therefore, if either species is a progenitor of B. inermis, significant chromosomal change should have occurred post-hybridization and polyploidization (Tuna et al. 2006). Natural B. erectus x B. inermis hybrids have been reported from Ukraine (Sutkowska et al. 2002). Tetraploid and octoploid forms of B. inermis have 2C DNA contents of 11.74 pg and 22.15 pg (Tuna et al. 2001). These values are significantly lower than those that would have resulted from multiples of the proposed diploid progenitors. Therefore, it is likely that significant DNA loss has occurred during polyploidization. Such loss of DNA has been recorded for the Triticeae (Vogel et al. 1999). Hybrids with B. pumpellianus ssp. dicksonii indicated that the two species have similar chromosomes, differing only by inversions and translocations (Armstrong 1982). 2.5.1.1 Genetic Diversity in B. inermis Based on molecular analyses, the present distribution of B. inermis in Poland was attributed to post-glacial migrations from two separate refuges (Sutkowska et al. 2002). North American breeders of B. inermis generally classify the natural variation of the species into two ecotypes – a northern or “meadow” type adapted to valleys and moist regions of eastern Europe and temperate Asia, and a southern, or “steppe” type adapted to dry steppe regions. A third, intermediate group has developed apparently by intermixing of the first two. The ecotypes differ morphologically in root depth and leaf size (Fernandez and Coulman 2004). Amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) analyses of 14 cultivars revealed that the
20
older (pre-1980) varieties based on southern germplasm were distinctive and less diverse than varieties based on northern germplasm and more recent southern or mixed varieties. These results suggest that intermixing of southern and northern ecotypes has occurred recently in North American breeding programs (Fernandez and Coulman 2004). A diversity analysis of cultivars based on morphological characteristics (Casler et al. 2000) indicated that similar morphological types had been developed from very diverse genetic backgrounds. 2.5.1.2 Breeding Progress In recent years, there has been very little private sector breeding of B. inermis and relatively little cultivar development by public sector plant breeders. Emphasis on selection for improved quality has significantly improved digestibility and reduced fiber concentrations. Yield improvement has been slow, not only because of the low effort but also because of the complex polyploid genetics and research emphasis on genetics rather than breeding (Casler et al. 2000). There has been almost no molecular breeding in Bromus. One of very few studies investigated the prospective use of marker-assisted selection for forage quality using neutral detergent fiber (NDF) concentration as a predictor of animal intake (Diaby and Casler 2005; Stendal et al. 2006). Although RAPD markers were difficult to use because of low repeatability, the association of markers with NDF was established. This has opened the way for marker-assisted selection for NDF concentration using more repeatable marker systems. B. inermis is one of the most freezing-tolerant perennial grass species. Consequently, it is the subject of considerable research into the genetics of freezing tolerance, as well as being a potential genetic resource for isolation of important freezing tolerance genes (see Sect. 2.10).
2.5.2 B. riparius Rehm. (Meadow Bromegrass) This species is often called B. biebersteinii and is confused with B. erectus, and its taxonomy is still to
W.M. Williams et al.
be resolved (Pavlick 1995). However, its description fits that for B. riparius according to Smith (1980). It is a long-lived perennial with chromosome numbers of 2n ¼ 2x ¼ 14, 2n ¼ 8x ¼ 56, and 2n ¼ 10x ¼ 70. In addition to being a useful species itself, it is a potential source of germplasm for the improvement of B. inermis, it has lower growing points and so recovers better from defoliation, is less aggressively rhizomatous, and has a longer growing season into the autumn than B. inermis (Armstrong 1991). The common cultivars have 2n ¼ 10x ¼ 70 and are believed to have the same chromosome constitution as B. inermis plus an additional genome of unknown origin (Armstrong 1991). Sutkowska and Mitka (2008) obtained evidence using RAPDs that this additional genome could be closely related to, or ancestral to, the L genome. Diploid B. riparius has a somatic cell (2C) DNA content of 6.14 0.09 pg (Tuna et al. 2001) – very similar to B. erectus (Tuna et al. 2006). Common B. riparius has a 2C DNA content of 22.15 pg (Tuna et al. 2001). The diploid form of B. riparius was found in Kazakhstan and is quite similar to the tetraploid B. inermis from the same region. This led Armstrong (1987) to suggest that diploid B. riparius might be a progenitor of polyploid B. inermis. A C-banding analysis of diploid B. riparius was completed by Tuna et al. (2001), and Tuna et al. (2004) analyzed the respective karyotypes and showed that B. riparius is an unlikely progenitor of B. inermis. Sterile hybrids between B. variegatus and diploid B. riparius have been produced and were reported to have normal chromosome pairing behavior (Armstrong 1991). B. riparius is widely grown in North-central USA and in Canada. It resembles B. inermis in appearance but has shorter rhizomes, awned seeds, and pubescent leaves (Knowles et al. 1993). The cultivar “Regar” was released in 1966 by the Colorado Experiment Station. Introgression of B. riparius traits (e.g., lower growing points and less vigorous rhizomes) into B. inermis would be useful. To this end, Armstrong (1990) obtained fertile hybrids between B. inermis (2n ¼ 8x ¼ 56), as female, and B. riparius (2n ¼ 10x ¼ 70) without difficulty. The F1 plants were backcrossed to B. inermis as male and produced seed when open-pollinated. They had 2n ¼ 63 chromosomes. The F2 population ranged from 2n ¼ 56 to 72 and tended to be in the 63–70 range. Chromosome
2 Bromus
pairing results were equivocal and there was no clear evidence for or against recombination between the genomes of the two species. However, there was a suggestion that reversion to the parental types occurred, as had been observed earlier by Nielsen et al. (1965). Backcross progenies rapidly reverted to the parental chromosome numbers and appeared to lose B. riparius traits as they did so. Cytoplasmic effects were also apparent, and no clear strategy emerged for the use of B. riparius germplasm in the improvement of B. inermis. Nevertheless, a hybrid population was selected and interpollinated for several generations by Knowles and Baron (1990). Selections from this population were analyzed using RAPD markers and compared with the parental cultivars (Fernandez et al. 2001). A hybrid population was genetically intermediate between the parents, although closer to B. inermis, possibly because it had been selected for B. inermis traits. Thus, it is possible that recombination had occurred between B. inermis and B. riparius genomes in that population and that similar hybrids may be useful for the genetic improvement of smooth bromegrass.
21
and other disturbed places, as well as in pastures. It is often confused with B. riparius. Because it probably shares genomes with B. inermis, B. erectus is a potential source of genetic diversity for B. inermis breeding. It also shares a genome with B. pumpellianus (Armstrong 1981).
2.5.4 B. variegatus B. variegatus forms part of the meadow bromegrass complex of decaploid (2n ¼ 70) species, along with B. riparius and B. biebersteinii. A diploid population of this species is one of very few diploids among the Eurasian species of the section. It has a somatic cell DNA content of 6.76 0.05 pg (Tuna et al. 2006). As already discussed, the role of the diploid form in the ancestry of the polyploid species remains unresolved.
2.5.5 B. pumpellianus (Arctic Bromegrass) 2.5.3 B. erectus (Erect Bromegrass) This diploid perennial species has a somatic nucleus (2C) DNA content of 6.19 0.08 pg (Tuna et al. 2006). Armstrong (1973) used B. erectus (2n ¼ 4x ¼ 28) to make 6x hybrids with B. inermis (2n ¼ 8x ¼ 56). On the basis of chromosome pairing and karyotype analysis, he concluded that the B. erectus genome was present in tetrasomic condition in B. inermis. Armstrong (1977b) carried out further analysis of the karyotypes of these hybrids and B. inermis and favored the view that the B. erectus genome constituted the A genome in 8x (AAAABBBB) B. inermis. However, he was unable to rule out the AAAABBCC hypothesis of Ghosh and Knowles (1964). B. erectus is naturally distributed in Europe, Britain, Ireland, and North Africa (Meusel et al. 1965) and is introduced and widespread in the North-Eastern states of USA and sporadically elsewhere (Pavlick 1995). The present distribution of B. erectus in Poland was studied by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and attributed to a single post-glacial expansion (Sutkowska et al. 2002). It is a tufted perennial that occurs on roadsides
This octoploid (2n ¼ 8x ¼ 56) species has populations that are native to Asia, as well as the mountains of western North America, where it provides useful high quality forage in high altitude grasslands up to 3,350 m altitude (Casler and Carlson 1995). Hybrids between 8x B. inermis and 8x B. pumpellianus are fertile, suggesting that they are subspecies (Armstrong 1991). However, there is confusion because, at the tetraploid level, they appear to be different species. Armstrong (1985) suggested that these are very heterogeneous taxa that involve allopolyploidy and have undergone introgression. A variety, “Polar” was developed from such interspecific hybrids (Hodgson et al. 1971).
2.5.6 Other North American Species in Section Pnigma Nodding brome (B. anomalus Rupr. ex Fourn.) and tetraploid (2n ¼ 28) fringed brome (B. ciliatus L.)
22
provide native grazing in the western mountain regions of North America (Casler and Carlson 1995). A diploid form of B. ciliatus is considered to be the ancestral American species (Armstrong 1991). A detailed Giemsa C-banding chromosome analysis of B. ciliatus by Tuna et al. (2005) revealed that the genomes in this American species are quite different from those of any European species in the section Pnigma. In addition, the 2C nuclear DNA content of B. ciliatus was 19.13 pg, contrasting strongly with that of tetraploid B. inermis (11.74 pg). The chromosomes of B. ciliatus were almost double the length of those of Eurasian species – consistent with previous observations that the two groups of species differ in chromosome size. Additionally, the C-banding indicated quite different patterns of constitutive heterochromatin. These observations, along with the strong genetic isolation between the two groups, support the contention that they are not closely related. B. ciliatus is of interest in North America as a potential outcrossing native grass species for restoring vegetation to ecologically important sites. Genetic diversity of Canadian populations was studied by Fu et al. (2005) using AFLPs. This identified regional Canadian forms. However, there was surprisingly little intrapopulation variation, suggesting that perhaps more self-fertilization occurred than was expected. This emphasized the need for proper breeding system studies to be carried out where genetic diversity is an important element in the end-use of a species. Although most North American species are diploid, B. frondosus (Shear) Woot. and Standl., B. richardsonii, and B. pacificus all behave like allotetraploids (Armstrong 1984). B. mucroglumis Wagnon from Mexico and adjacent areas of the USA is similar to B. richardsonii (Peterson et al. 2001), but the other three tetraploid species in North America do not appear to have been studied. Hybrids between tetraploid B. ciliatus and B. frondosus indicated similar genomic structures (Barnett 1957).
2.5.7 South American Species in Section Pnigma Native to southern Brazil and Uruguay, B. auleticus Trin. ex Nees is a perennial allogamous hexaploid (2n ¼ 6x ¼ 42) that provides outstanding forage in
W.M. Williams et al.
native pastures (Martinello and Schifino-Wittmann 2003). It has caught the attention of agronomists and plant breeders, and some isozyme and RAPD characterizations have been done (Yanaka 2002). B. urugayensis is also hexaploid, while B. macranthus has been reported as having 4x, 8x, 10x, and 16x chromosomes (Stebbins 1981). It is uncertain how these species are related to the remainder of section Pnigma.
2.6 Section Bromus This section of about 40 species is considered to be the most advanced. It is native to Europe and Asia and consists of annual or biennial diploid and tetraploid species. The tetraploids are likely to have hybrid origins (Stebbins 1981). Southwest Asia and the eastern Mediterranean regions are the centers of diversity (Stebbins 1981). Several annual or biennial species have spread widely beyond their native regions and have become significant weeds, e.g., B. briziformis Fisch. and C.A. Mey., B. commutatus Schrad. (meadow brome), B. hordeaceus L. (B. mollis), B. japonicus Thunb. in Murr., B. racemosus L., B secalinus L., and B. squarrosus L. are now widespread throughout North America (Pavlick 1995). Only a small number of artificial interspecific hybrids have been made within section Bromus (Armstrong 1991). B. mollis was crossed with B. arenarius (Knowles 1944), leading to an indication that B. mollis contains two distinct genomes and that the same two occur in B. racemosus. One of the genomes in B. mollis was partly homologous with one of the genomes in B. arenarius (4x). B. commutatus, B. macrostachys, and B. secalinus are allotetraploids. Hybrids of B. arvensis (2x) x B. commutatus (4x) and B. secalinus (4x) showed some chromosome pairing, indicating a relationship between the genome of B. arvensis and those in the tetraploid species (Jahn 1959). There were also pairing homologies between some chromosomes of B. macrostachys and B. mollis. Sections Boissiera (one species, B. pumilio (Trin.) P.M. Smith) and Triniusia (two species, B. danthoniae Trin. ex C.A. Mey., B. pseudodanthoniae Drobow), recognized by some authors (Smith 1985; Scholz 1998; Saarela et al. 2007), were included in Section Bromus by Smith (1970). They comprised annual
2 Bromus
species from Asia and the eastern Mediterranean region. ITS and chloroplast DNA sequence analysis (Saarela et al. 2007) confirmed that the species of section Triniusia belong in section Bromus. The B. pectinatus complex (five 4x species ranging from Africa to Asia) is intermediate in morphology between sections Bromus and Genea, leading Stebbins (1981) to suggest that these species arose as hybrids between species of the two sections. The DNA sequence data of Saarela et al. (2007) support this idea. If this is correct, then section Bromus is monophyletic.
2.6.1 B. arvensis (Field Bromegrass) and Its Close Relatives This diploid (2n ¼ 14) winter annual species and its close relatives, B. japonicus and B. squarrosus, form a complex that is taxonomically difficult and has been subject to several different treatments. B. arvensis is allogamous (Oja et al. 2003) unlike the other two, which are almost exclusively self-fertilizing. Serological analysis (Smith 1972), isozyme analysis (Oja et al. 2003), and DNA analyses (Ainouche and Bayer 1997; Ainouche et al. 1999) indicated that B. japonicus and B. squarrosus might be sister species or a species complex distinct from B. arvensis. Oja et al. (2003) suggested that B. japonicus and B. squarrosus are possibly self-fertilizing derivatives of B. arvensis. However, a later morphological separation, using discriminant analysis to determine the most useful characters for distinguishing the taxa (Oja and Paal 2007), indicated that the three species could be fairly reliably separated using floral morphological traits, especially anther length and lemma width. The Mediterranean self-fertilizing diploid B. intermedius Guss. is also very similar in morphology to B. japonicus var. villosus (Oja 2005) and apparently also belongs to this species complex. This is supported by isozyme data (Oja 2005) and ITS sequence analysis (Ainouche and Bayer 1997). It may also be a selffertilizing derivative of B. arvensis (Oja 2005). Isozyme analyses (Ainouche et al. 1995) indicated that North African populations of B. intermedius and its close relative B. squarrosus were much less variable than the tetraploids B. hordeaceus and B. lanceolatus. Nevertheless, heterozygotes were present in higher
23
than expected frequencies, suggesting that outcrossing was a significant evolutionary factor in these predominantly self-fertilized diploids. B. arvensis is native to the Mediterranean and into southern and central Europe and is widespread in Eurasia (Oja and Paal 2007). It has been introduced to Australia and the USA in the 1920s where it became adapted to the corn-belt region and eastward. It provides excellent winter cover, soil stabilization, and green manure as a result of its extensive root system. B. japonicus and B. squarrosus are common in the Mediterranean and Southwest Asia and have become significant weeds in several countries. B. arvensis (2n ¼ 14) has been hybridized with the perennial species B. inermis (2n ¼ 56) and B. erectus (2n ¼ 28) of section Pnigma, but the hybrids were sterile (Armstrong 1977a). This intersectional hybridization does not appear to be a fruitful source of germplasm for the widening of the B. inermis or B. erectus gene pools (Armstrong 1977a). However, Armstrong (1977b) was able to use 5x hybrids between B. arvensis and B. inermis to analyze the alloploid gametic (AABB) chromosome complement of B. inermis because the B. arvensis chromosomes were much larger and could be clearly distinguished.
2.6.2 B. hordeaceus Also known as B. mollis, this is an aggressive species that has a wide climatic range that has enabled it to spread widely within Eurasia, Africa, the Americas, and Australia. It is a probable allotetraploid (2n ¼ 28, Stebbins 1981). It shows wide morphological variation indicative of ecotype differentiation and, in the Mediterranean region, may hybridize with B. lanceolatus., a closely related tetraploid (Ainouche et al. 1995). On the basis of its morphological variation, Pavlick (1995) separated the species into four subspecies. It has been the subject of analyses using isozymes to relate population genetic diversity to habitat diversity in Australia (Brown et al. 1974). This led to the identification of fitness-related polymorphism at the alcohol dehydrogenase locus (Brown et al. 1976). Isozyme analyses have also indicated quite high outcrossing rates in some populations (Brown et al. 1974). However, Ainouche et al. (1995) found high levels of intragenomic homozygosity in North African
24
populations, suggesting high selfing rates in this species (and B. lanceolatus). High levels of intergenomic heterozygosity in these two species were consistent with their allotetraploid genomic structure.
2.7 Section Ceratochloa Section or subgenus Ceratochloa is a small section consisting of up to 16 polyploid perennial and annual species. No diploid or tetraploid species are found in this section. The section Ceratochloa has the smallest genome size in the genus (Armstrong 1991). Hybridization is rife in this section, making species boundaries obscure and the taxonomy very difficult. Section Ceratochloa appears to be monophyletic and most species display almost identical chloroplast DNA sequences (Pillay and Hilu 1990, 1995), suggesting a similar maternal genome. Similarly, the ITS sequence and other nuclear DNA sequence variation is trivial (Saarela et al. 2007), a situation found in most post glacial grass expansions. This suggests that much of Ceratochloa is very recent and post glacial, a conclusion drawn by Stebbins (1981). The agricultural value of many of the species in section Ceratochloa was reviewed by Stewart (1996). The species of section Ceratochloa can be divided into four genomically distinct classes:
2.7.1 The Hexaploid B. catharticus Complex (2n ¼ 42) This group of species is endemic to South America (Massa et al. 2004), with members also present in Africa, B. leptocladis in South Africa and B. runssoroensis in highland Central Africa. The hexaploid species of section Ceratochloa are all found to be strict allopolyploids with genomic formula AABBCC (Stebbins and Tobgy 1944). These genomes are almost indistinguishable and have a nuclear DNA content of 12.7–15.1 pg (mean 1C ¼ 2.32 pg) (Klos et al. 2009). Morphological variation in these hexaploids is large and it is fair to say this group is the oldest of the four groups in Ceratochloa. Originally, this complex was separated into a number of species but, over
W.M. Williams et al.
time, many of these so-called species have become amalgamated into a hyper-variable species. In this sense, it may be fairer to say that the hexaploids are just over the “cusp” of speciating. It is unclear how the African and American species relate. The commonly named taxa that constitute this hexaploid group from South America (following Planchuelo and Peterson 2000) are B. catharticus, B. coloratus, B. lithobius, B. stamineus, B. mango, and B. tunicatus Phil. Using a multivariate analysis of this group, including morphological and molecular data, Massa et al. (2001, 2004) indicated that the variation was consistent with the existence of a single hexaploid species, B. catharticus, with two nearly continuous subspecies, B. catharticus ssp. catharticus (Vahl) Herter and B. catharticus ssp. stamineus (E. Desv.) Massa. B. catharticus ssp. catharticus includes, among others, the following older taxa: B. unioloides Kunth, B. tunicatus, and B. burkartii Munoz, as well as B. mango, while B. catharticus ssp. stamineus includes B. stamineus, B. coloratus, B. lithobius, B. fonkii Phil., and B. valdivianus Phil. These authors identified octoploid forms of B. coloratus and B. lithobius in South America, which they reclassified as B. coloratus Steud. These three newly defined taxa are separable using a simple three-step morphological key. There are also differences in adaptation, the populations of ssp. stamineus being perennial, predominantly cleistogamous and from humid places, while those of ssp. catharticus are facultatively cleistogamous and are from high altitudes in open woodlands of the precordillera as well as the lower slopes of the Andes. Species from this complex have been introduced to many countries and there are more than 30 cultivars marketed in Argentina, France, Chile, New Zealand, Australia, and USA.
2.7.2 Two Disjunct Octoploid Groups These are the B. carinatus Hook. and Arn. complex (2n ¼ 56), found in higher latitudes of North America, and the 8x B. coloratus referred to above, found in the higher latitudes of South America (Massa et al. 2004). They have a genomic constitution ABCL where L is a larger genome, probably from section Pnigma. DNA contents of B. carinatus (20.9–22.9 pg/cell) were more
2 Bromus
than 70% larger than B. catharticus (13.0–14.9 pg/ cell) (Joachimiak et al. 2001). Therefore, the octoploid species of the B. carinatus complex are considered to be intersectional amphidiploids between diploids of section Pnigma and hexaploid species of section Ceratochloa (Stebbins 1956). This was supported by Pillay (1996) who found rDNA sequences common between this group of species and B. inermis. The seven species of the B. carinatus complex are B. aleutensis Trin. ex Griseb., B. carinatus sens. str., B. marginatus, B. maritimus (Pip.) A.S. Hitch., B. polyanthus Scribn., B. sitchensis, and B. subvelutinus Shear. Based on intergrading morphologies and partial interfertilities, some taxonomists believe that all of these taxa belong to a single diverse species, B. carinatus sens. lato (e.g., Soderstrom and Beaman 1968; Stebbins 1981). However, Pavlick (1995) argued that the major differences in morphology and barriers of hybrid sterility justify separation into separate species. A revision of this group using molecular phylogenetic methods is required (Saarela et al. 2007). The main agricultural species of the group are as below.
2.7.2.1 B. carinatus (California Brome) This is annual, biennial, or a short-lived perennial with deep roots, strong leafy growth, and good seed production that is used for grazing animals. It is naturally distributed along the west coast of North America from the Canadian border region to Baja California. Two major varieties are often distinguished (e.g. Pavlick 1995) – var. carinatus generally west of the Sierra Nevada and Cascade mountain ranges and the more perennial var. hookerianus (Thurb.) Shear. to the east in the Columbia River Basin. The two intergrade and var. hookerianus intergrades with B. marginatus and B. subvelutinus at higher altitudes to the east.
2.7.2.2 B. marginatus (Mountain Brome) This perennial occurs generally at high altitudes throughout the western half of North America from Canada to N. Mexico. It intergrades with B. carinatus and B. subvelutinus to the West, B. aleutensis to the North, and B. polyanthus to the Southeast. Several
25
cultivars have been developed and are used in the NW USA and Canada, as well as in New Zealand.
2.7.2.3 B. sitchensis (Sitka or Alaska Brome) Native to mountain meadows of the Pacific coast of North America from Washington state northwards to Alaska. It is closely related to B. aleutensis and is used for pastures in northern Europe.
2.7.3 B. arizonicus (2n ¼ 84) (Arizona Brome) This duodecaploid is native to California and east to Arizona. Morphological and cytological analyses performed by Stebbins et al. (1944) indicated that B. arizonicus is an allopolyploid derived from B. catharticus and hexaploid B. trinii Desv. in Gay (B. berterianus Colla) or an unknown close relative of this species. B. berterianus is the representative of the section Neobromus, native to the Pacific coast of North and South America. The genomic constitution of B. arizonicus was postulated as ABCC’DE (Stebbins 1947). Klos et al. (2009) have shown that all twelve genomes in B. arizonicus are approximately the same average size (2.1–2.3 pg) and the same size as the genomes in the hexaploid Ceratochloa species. A winter active annual cultivar, Cucamonga, is used in California.
2.7.4 Duodecaploid (2n ¼ 84) Accessions Found in Andean Regions of South America Two 12x accessions investigated by Klos et al. (2009) differed markedly from B. arizonicus in nuclear DNA content and in chromosome size. In particular, these South American duodecaploids had some large chromosomes, making up about 37% of the genome. This group potentially has the genomic constitution ABCLLL (Klos et al. 2009) and is clearly different in constitution from the North American duodecaploid, B. arizonicus. These accessions may belong to the species B. ayacuchensis (Saarela et al. 2006), for which a chromosome number has not been determined.
26
W.M. Williams et al.
2.8 Section Neobromus
2.10.3 Protoplast Fusion
This section consists of two annual hexaploids native to the western coasts of North and South America., including B. gunckelli Matthei and B. berterianus (B. trinii, Pavlick 1995).
Fusion of protoplasts from hexaploid (2n ¼ 42) wheat cv. 99P embryo-derived callus and UV-irradiated protoplasts from tetraploid (2n ¼ 28) B. inermis resulted in asymmetric somatic hybridization (Xiang et al. 1999). Three albino hybrid explants were obtained with 42–54 chromosomes, including small chromosomes and chromosome fragments from B. inermis.
2.9 Section Nevskiella This section comprises one species, B. gracillimus Bunge from Asia and the eastern Mediterranean.
2.10 Role of Bromus Species in Crop Improvement Using Biotechnology 2.10.1 Tissue Culture Callus cultures from immature inflorescences of B. inermis have been grown and regenerated into green plants (Wattanasiri and Walton 1993). Significant somaclonal variation was detected for several plant traits, and although none of 10 somaclones was taller than the parent plant in a replicated trial, some had more tillers and larger leaf-stem ratios. It was concluded that this approach should aid the development of superior clones of B. inermis.
2.10.2 Cell Culture Non-embryogenic suspension cell cultures of B. inermis have been used for over 20 years and this system has been thoroughly characterized (Ishikawa et al. 1990; Robertson et al. 1994; Wilen et al. 1996). It has proved to be useful for analysis of the mechanisms of stress tolerance induced either by drought or cold treatment or by abscisic acid (ABA) in warm conditions (e.g., Lee and Chen 1993; Wu et al. 2005). Nakamura and Ishikawa (2006) have successfully transformed B. inermis cell cultures using Agrobacterium tumefaciens, opening the way for the analysis of gene functions through reverse genetics.
2.10.4 Genome Mapping The B. inermis chloroplast genome was physically mapped by Pillay (1993) using barley and wheat chloroplast DNA probes to map restriction sites. The organization of the Bromus chloroplast genome was similar to other grasses, with a pair of inverted repeat regions flanked by single copy regions. DNA sequence colinearity was shared with wheat and other cereal grasses.
2.11 Bromus Species in Genetic Research 2.11.1 Herbicide Resistance B. tectorum (downy brome) has developed resistance to herbicides based on acetolactate synthase (ALS) – inhibitors and PS II inhibitors and ACCase inhibitors. This multiple herbicide resistance was traced, in part, to a single amino acid substitution in protein product of the psbA gene, the target site of PS II inhibitors (Park and Mallory-Smith 2005).
2.11.2 Genetic Diversity and Weediness Molecular markers (mainly AFLP and SSR) have been used to study the population genetics of the spread of B. tectorum in North America. As noted earlier, although this species is treated as an obligate selfpollinator, molecular evidence indicates some outcrossing. Nevertheless, strong associations have been
2 Bromus
found between marker allele presence and phenotypic variation in several adaptive traits (Ramakrishnan et al. 2004, 2006), suggesting that marker diversity can be used to infer adaptive variation.
2.12 Endophytic Fungi in Bromus Many grasses host choke forming Clavicipitaceae endophytic fungi of the genus Epichlo¨e or their asexual derivatives Neotyphodium. The sexual stroma of Epichlo¨e causes “choke disease,” which prevents seedheads emerging. Non-choke inducing asexual Neotyphodium endophytes occur in many grasses such as perennial ryegrass (Lolium perenne) and tall fescue (Festuca arundinacea), and they provide the host with advantages such as improved insect resistance and grazing deterrence (Schardl and Phillips 1997). The Bromus species at present known to host endophytes appear to be restricted to section Pnigma, with reports for B. auleticus, B. brachyanthera, B setifolius, B. benekenii, B. erectus, B. ramosus, B. tomentellus, and B. anomalus (Groppe et al. 2002; Cabral et al. 2007). These endophytes can have significant ecological effects and may well provide insect resistance and other important agricultural effects (Novas et al. 2007). The full relevance of endophyte fungi in Bromus is not known. However, it will be important that endophytes are collected and studied. Germplasm collections will need to monitor and maintain endophytes where they are present.
2.13 Recommendations for Future Action Both partially domesticated groups identified in this review consist of allopolyploid hybrid species. Therefore, there are enormous untapped opportunities for using hybridization and ploidal manipulations among members of the various species groups to achieve new grass varieties for temperate agriculture. It is recommended that grass breeders investigate this approach to using the wealth of diversity present among the wild
27
species. However, this work should be supported by new DNA sequence analyses to resolve species relationships, especially in the large section Pnigma, where hybridization and polyploidy, followed by genomic changes, have mixed the genomes and blurred species relationships. There is an on-going need to collect Bromus species from the wild in both Eurasia and in the Americas in order to realize the potential offered by the genus for agricultural purposes.
References Ainouche ML, Bayer RJ (1997) On the origins of the tetraploid Bromus species (section Bromus, Poaceae): insights from internal transcribed spacer sequences of nuclear ribosomal DNA. Genome 40:730–743 Ainouche ML, Misset MT, Huon A (1995) Genetic diversity in Mediterranean diploid and tetraploid Bromus L. (section Bromus Sm.) populations. Genome 38:879–888 Ainouche ML, Bayer RJ, Gourret JP, Defontaine A, Misset MT (1999) The allotetraploid invasive weed Bromus hordeaceus L. (Poaceae): genetic diversity, origin and molecular evolution. Folia Geobot 34:405–419 Alderson J, Sharp WC (1995) Grass varieties in the United States. Lewis Publ, Boca Raton, FL, USA Allred KW (1993) Bromus section Pnigma in New Mexico, with a key to the bromegrasses of the state. Phytologia 74:319–345 Armstrong KC (1973) Chromosome pairing in hexaploid hybrids from Bromus erectus (2n ¼ 28) x B. inermis (2n ¼ 56). Can J Genet Cytol 15:427–436 Armstrong KC (1977a) Hybrids of the annual Bromus arvensis with perennial B. inermis and B. erectus. Z Pflanzenz€ucht 79:6–13 Armstrong KC (1977b) Karyotypic models for the A and B genomes of Bromus inermis. Z Pflanzenz€ucht 78:244–252 Armstrong KC (1979) A and B genome homologies in tetraploid and octaploid cytotypes of Bromus inermis. Can J Genet Cytol 21:65–71 Armstrong KC (1981) The evolution of Bromus inermis and related species of Bromus sect. Pnigma. Bot Jahrb Syst Pflanzengesch Pflanzengeogr 102:427–443 Armstrong KC (1982) Hybrids between the tetraploids of B. inermis and B. pumpellianus. Can J Bot 60:476–482 Armstrong KC (1983) The relationship between some Eurasian and American species of Bromus section Pnigma as determined by the karyotypes of some F1 hybrids. Can J Bot 61:700–707 Armstrong KC (1984) Chromosome pairing affinities between Old and New World species of Bromus. Can J Bot 62: 581–585 Armstrong KC (1985) Chromosome pairing failure in an intersectional amphiploid of Bromus altissimus x B. arvensis. Can J Genet Cytol 27:705–709
28 Armstrong KC (1987) Chromosome numbers of perennial Bromus species collected in the USSR. Can J Plant Sci 67:267–269 Armstrong KC (1990) Cytology of F1 hybrids and chromosome number of F2 and BC1 progeny of the cross Bromus riparius x B. inermis. Theor Appl Genet 79:137–142 Armstrong KC (1991) Chromosome evolution of Bromus. In: Armstrong KC, Tsuchiya T, Gupta P (eds) Chromosome engineering in plants: genetics, breeding, evolution, Part B. Elsevier Science Publ, Amsterdam, Netherlands, pp 366–377 Ashley MC, Longland WS (2007) Microsatellite evidence of facultative outcrossing in cheatgrass (Bromus tectorum): implications for the evolution of invasiveness. Plant Species Biol 22:197–204 Barnett FL (1957) Cytogenetics of interspecific hybrids in the Bromopsis Section of Bromus. I. Diploid and tetraploid hybrids. Agron J 49:77–82 Brown AHD, Marshall DR, Albrecht L (1974) The maintenance of alcohol dehydrogenase polymorphism in Bromus mollis L. Aust J Biol Sci 27:545–559 Brown AHD, Marshall DR, Munday J (1976) Adaptedness of variants at an alcohol dehydrogenase locus in Bromus mollis L. Aust J Biol Sci 29:389–396 Cabral D, Iannone LJ, Stewart AV, Novas MV (2007) The distribution and incidence of Neotyphodium endophytes in native grasses from Argentina and its association with environmental factors. 6th international endophyte symposium, 26–28 March 2007, Christchurch, Australia, pp 79–82 Carnahan HL, Hill HD (1960) The nature of polyploidy in smooth bromegrass: Bromus inermis Leyss. J Hered 51:43–44 Casler MD, Carlson IT (1995) Smooth bromegrass. In: Barnes RF, Nelson CJ, Collins M, Moore KJ (eds) Forages, vol I, An introduction to grassland agriculture. Iowa State Univ Press, Ames, IA, USA, pp 313–324 Casler MD, Vogel KP, Balasko JA, Berdahl JD, Miller DA, Hansen JL, Fritz JO (2000) Genetic progress from 50 years of smooth bromegrass breeding. Crop Sci 40:13–22 Chen C-H, Kuoh C-S (2000) The genus Bromus L. (Poaceae) in Taiwan: a DELTA database for generating key and descriptions. Taiwania 45:311–322 Clayton WS, Renvoize SA (1986) Genera Graminum: grasses of the world. Kew Bull Add Ser 13:1–389 Dastgheib F, Rolston MP, Archie WJ (2003) Chemical control of brome grasses (Bromus spp.) in cereals. NZ Plant Protec 56:227–232 Diaby M, Casler MD (2005) RAPD marker variation among divergent selections for fiber concentration in smooth bromegrass. Crop Sci 45:27–35 Fernandez YSN, Coulman BE (2004) Genetic relationships among smooth bromegrass cultivars of different ecotypes detected by AFLP markers. Crop Sci 44:241–247 Fernandez YSN, Somers DJ, Coulman BE (2001) Estimating the genetic relationship of hybrid bromegrass to smooth bromegrass and meadow bromegrass using RAPD markers. Plant Breed 120:149–153 Forde MB, Edgar E (1995) Checklist of pooid grasses naturalised in new Zealand. 3. Tribes Bromeae and Brachypodiaceae. NZ J Bot 33:35–42
W.M. Williams et al. Fortune PM, Pourtau N, Viron N, Ainouche ML (2008) Molecular phylogeny and reticulate origins of the polyploidy Bromus species from section Genea (Poaceae). Am J Bot 95:454–464 Fu YB, Coulman B, Ferdinandez Y, Cayouette J, Peterson PM (2005) Genetic diversity of fringed brome (Bromus ciliatus) as determined by amplified fragment length polymorphism. Can J Bot 83:1322–1328 Ghosh AN, Knowles RP (1964) Cytogenetic investigations of a chlorophyll mutant in bromegrass, Bromus inermis Leyss. Can J Genet Cytol 6:221–231 Groppe K, Steinger T, Sanders I, Schmid B, Wiemken A, Boller T (2002) Interaction between the endophytic fungus Epichloe¨ bromicola and the grass Bromus erectus: effects of endophyte infection, fungal concentration and environment on grass growth and flowering. Mol Ecol 8:1827–1835 Gutierrez HE, Pensiero JF (1998) Sinopsis de las species Argentinas del genero Bromus (Poaceae). Darwiniana 35:75–114 Hodgson HJ, Wilton AC, Taylor RL, Klebesadel LJ (1971) Registration of Polar bromegrass. Crop Sci 11:939 Ishikawa M, Robertson AJ, Gusta LV (1990) Effect of temperature, light, nutrients and dehardening on abscisic acid induced cold hardiness in Bromus inermis Leyss suspension cultured cells. Plant Cell Physiol 31:51–59 Jahn A (1959) Cytologische untersuchungen an k€unstlichen artbastarden in der gattung Bromus L. Z Pflanzenz€ucht 42:25–50 Joachimiak A, Kula A, Sliwinska E, Sobieszczanska A (2001) C-banding and nuclear DNA amount in six Bromus species. Acta Biol Crac Bot 43:105–115 Klos J, Sliwinska E, Kula A, Golczyk H, Grabowska-Joachimiak A, Ilnicki T, Szostek K, Stewart A, Joachimiak AJ (2009) Karyotype and nuclear DNA content of hexa-, octo-, and duodecaploid lines of Bromus subgen. Ceratochloa. Genet Mol Biol 32(3):528–537 Knowles PF (1944) Interspecific hybridization of Bromus. Genetics 29:128–140 Knowles RP, Baron VB (1990) Performance of hybrids of smooth bromegrass (Bromus inermis Leyss.) and meadow bromegrass (B. riparius Rehm.). Can J Plant Sci 70:330–331 Knowles RP, Baron VS, McCartney DH (1993) Meadow bromegrass. Agri Canada Publ 188/E Kon KF, Blacklow WM (1990) Polymorphism, outcrossing and polyploidy in Bromus diandrus and B. rigidus. Aust J Bot 38 (6):609–618 Lee SP, Chen THH (1993) Molecular cloning of abscisic acidresponsive mRNAs expressed during the induction of freezing tolerance in bromegrass (Bromus inermis Leyss) suspension culture. Plant Physiol 101:1089–1096 Martinello GE, Schifino-Wittmann MT (2003) Chromosomes of Bromus auleticus Trin. ex Nees (Poaceae). Genet Mol Biol 26:369–371 Massa AN, Larson SR, Jensen KB, Hole DJ (2001) AFLP variation in Bromus section Ceratochloa germplasm of Patagonia. Crop Sci 41:1609–1616 Massa AN, Jensen KB, Larson SR, Hole DJ (2004) Morphological variation in Bromus section Ceratochloa germplasm of Patagonia. Can J Bot 82:136–144 Matthei O (1986) The genus Bromus L. (Poaceae) in Chile. Gayana Bot 43:47–110
2 Bromus Meusel H, Jager E, Weinert E (1965) Vergleichende Chlorologie der Zentraleuropaischen Flora 2. Karten, Veb Gustav Fischer, Jena, Germany Mitchell WW (1967) Taxonomic synopsis of Bromus section Bromopsis (Gramineae) in Alaska. Can J Bot 45:1309–1313 Nakamura T, Ishikawa M (2006) Transformation of suspension cultures of bromegrass (Bromus inermis) by Agrobacteriun temefaciens. Plant Cell Tissue Organ Cult 84:293–299 Nielsen EL, Drolsom PM, Jalal SM (1965) Evaluation of backcross and self-pollination progenies from interspecific hybridization of Bromus. Crop Sci 5:339–342 Novas VM, Collantes M, Cabral D (2007) Environmental effects on grass-endophyte associations in the harsh conditions of south Patagonia. Microb Ecol 61:164–173 Oja T (2002) Bromus fasciculatus Presl – a third diploid progenitor of Bromus section Genea allopolyploids (Poaceae). Hereditas 137:113–118 Oja T (2005) Isozyme evidence on the genetic diversity, mating system and evolution of Bromus intermedius (Poaceae). Plant Syst Evol 254:199–208 Oja T, Paal J (2007) Multivariate analysis of morphological variation among closely related species Bromus japonicus, B. squarrosus and B. arvensis (Poaceae) in comparison with isozyme evidences. Nord J Bot 24:691–702 Oja T, Jaaska V, Vislap V (2003) Breeding system, evolution and taxonomy of Bromus arvensis, B. japonicusand B. squarrosus (Poaceae). Plant Syst Evol 242:101–117 Park KW, Mallory-Smith CA (2005) Multiple herbicide resistance in downy brome (Bromus tectorum) and its impact on fitness. Weed Sci 53:780–786 Pavlick LE (1995) Bromus L. of North America. Royal British Columbia Museum, Victoria, Australia Peterson PM, Cayouette J, Ferdinandez YSN, Coulman B (2001) Recognition of Bromus richardsonii and B. ciliatus: evidence from morphology, cytology, and DNA fingerprinting (Poaceae: Bromeae). Aliso 20:21–36 Pillay M (1993) Chloroplast genome organization of bromegrass, Bromus inermis Leyss. Theor Appl Genet 86:281–287 Pillay M (1995) Chloroplast DNA similarity of smooth bromegrass with other pooid cereals: implications for plant breeding. Crop Sci 35:869–875 Pillay M (1996) Genomic organization of ribosomal RNA genes in Bromus (Poaceae). Genome 39:198–205 Pillay M, Armstrong KC (2001) Maternal inheritance of chloroplast DNA in interspecific crosses of Bromus. Biol Plant 44:47–51 Pillay M, Hilu KW (1990) Chloroplast DNA variation in diploid and polyploid species of Bromus (Poaceae) subgenera Festucaria and Ceratochloa. Theor Appl Genet 80: 326–332 Pillay M, Hilu KW (1995) Chloroplast-DNA restriction site analysis in the genus Bromus (Poaceae). Am J Bot 82: 239–249 Pinto-Escobar P (1981) The genus Bromus in northern South America. Bot Jahrb Syst 102:445–457 Pinto-Escobar P (1986) El genero Bromus en Los Andes Centrales de Suramerica. Caldasia 15:15–34 Planchuelo AM, Peterson PM (2000) The species of Bromus (Poaceae: Bromeae) in South America. In: Jacobs SWL, Everett J (eds) Grasses: systematics and evolution. CSIRO, Melbourne, Australia, pp 89–101
29 Ramakrishnan AP, Meyer SE, Waters J, Stevens MR, Coleman CE, Fairbanks DJ (2004) Correlation between molecular markers and adaptively significant genetic variation in Bromus tectorum (Poaceae), an inbreeding annual grass. Am J Bot 91:797–803 Ramakrishnan AP, Meyer SE, Fairbanks DJ, Coleman CE (2006) Ecological significance of microsatellite variation in western North American populations of Bromus tectorum. Plant Species Biol 21:61–73 Robertson AJ, Reaney MJT, Wilen RW, Lamb N, Abrams SR, Gusta LV (1994) Effect of abscisic acid metabolites and analogs on freezing tolerance and gene expression in bromegrass (Bromus inermis Leyss) cell cultures. Plant Physiol 105:823–830 Rumball W (1968) Patterns of variation in Bromus L. introductions. NZ J Agric Res 11:277–285 Rumball W, Forde MB (1976) Plant introduction trials. Performance of Bromus species at Palmerston North. NZ J Exp Agric 5:93–95 Rychlewski J (1970) Karyology of species of the genus Bromus. Acta Biol Crac Bot 13:23–35 Saarela JM, Peterson PM, Refulio-Rodriguez NF (2006) Bromus ayacuchensis (Poaceae: Pooideae: Bromeae), a new species from Peru, with a key to Bromus in Peru. Sida 22:915–926 Saarela JM, Peterson PM, Keane RM, Cayouette J, Graham SW (2007) Molecular phylogenetics of Bromus (Poaceae: Pooideae) based on chlorplast and nuclear DNA sequence data. Aliso 23:379–396 Sales F (1994) Evolutionary tendencies in some annual species of Bromus (Bromus L. sect. Genea Dum. (Poaceae)). Bot J Linn Soc 115:197–210 Schardl C, Phillips T (1997) Protective grass endophytes: where are they from and where are they going? Plant Dis 81: 430–438 Scholz H (1998) Notes on Bromus danthoniae and relatives (Gramineae). Willdenowia 28:43–150 Scholz H, Mos U (1994) Status and kurze Geschichte des ausgestorbenen Kulturgetreides Bromus mango E. Desv. – und die Genese des Bromus secalinus L. Flora 189:215–222 Smith P (1970) Taxonomy and nomenclature of the bromegrasses (Bromus L. s.l.). Notes Roy Bot Gard Edinb 30: 361–375 Smith PM (1972) Serology and species relationships in annual Bromes (Bromus L. sect. Bromus). Ann Bot 36:1–30 Smith PM (1980) Bromus L. In: Tutin TG, Heywood VH, Burges NA, Valentine DH (eds) Flora Europae, vol 5. Cambridge Univ Press, UK, pp 182–189 Smith PM (1985) Bromus L. In: Davis PH (ed) Flora of Turkey and the East Aegean Islands, vol 9. Edinburgh Univ Press, UK, pp 272–301 Soderstrom TR, Beaman JH (1968) The genus Bromus (Gramineae) in Mexico and Central America. Publ Mus Michigan State Univ Biol Ser 3:465–520 Spalton LM (2002) A new key to the tribe Bromeae in Britain and Ireland. BSBI Newsl 91:22–26 Spalton LM (2004) A key to Bromeae in Mediterranean climatic zones of southern Europe, southwest Asia, and North Africa. BSBI Newsl 95:22–26 Stebbins GL (1947) The origin of the complex of Bromus carinatus and its phylogeographic implications. Contrib Gray Herb Harv Univ 165:42–55
30 Stebbins GL (1956) Cytogenetics and evolution of the grass family. Am J Bot 43:890–905 Stebbins GL (1981) Chromosomes and evolution in the Genus Bromus (Gramineae). Bot Jahrb Syst 102:359–379 Stebbins GL, Tobgy HA (1944) The cytogenetics of hybrids in Bromus. 1. Hybrids within the section Ceratochloa. Am J Bot 31:1–11 Stebbins GL, Tobgy HA, Harlan JR (1944) The cytogenetics of hybrids in Bromus II. Bromus carinatus and Bromus arizonicus. Proc Calif Acad Sci 25:307–322 Stendal C, Casler MD, Jung G (2006) Marker-assisted selection for neutral detergent fiber in smooth bromegrass. Crop Sci 46:303–311 Stewart AV (1996) Potential value of some Bromus species of the section Ceratochloa. NZ J Agric Res 39:611–618 Sutkowska A, Mitka J (2008) RAPD analysis points to old world Bromus species as ancestral to new world subgen. Festucaria. Acta Biol Crac Bot 50:117–125 Sutkowska A, Wilk L, Mitka J, Joachimiak A (2002) DNA polymorphism in Bromus erectus and Bromus inermis from Poland’s territory. Zesz Probl Post Nauk Rol 488:187–195 (Polish with English summary) Tan GY, Dunn GM (1977) Mitotic instabilities in tetraploid, hexaploid, and octoploid Bromus inermis. Genome 19: 531–536 Tuna M, Gill KS, Vogel KP (2001) Karyotype and C-banding patterns of mitotic chromosomes in diploid bromegrass (Bromus riparius Rehm). Crop Sci 41:831–834 Tuna M, Vogel KP, Gill KS, Arumuganathan K (2004) C-banding analyses of Bromus inermis genomes. Crop Sci 44:31–37 Tuna M, Vogel KP, Arumuganathan K (2005) Genome size and Giemsa C-banded karyotype of tetraploid Bromus ciliatus L. Euphytica 146:177–182 Tuna M, Vogel KP, Arumuganathan K (2006) Cytogenetic and nuclear DNA content characterization of diploid Bromus erectus and Bromus variegatus. Crop Sci 46:637–641
W.M. Williams et al. Tzvelev NN (1976) Poaceae URSS Tribe 4 Bromeae Dum. USSR Academy of Science Press, Leningrad, USSR, pp 530–608 Veldkamp JE, Eriks J, Smit SS (1991) Bromus (Gramineae) in Malesia. Blumea 35:483–497 Vogel KP, Arumuganathan K, Jensen KB (1999) Nuclear DNA content of perennial grasses of the Triticeae. Crop Sci 39:661–667 Wagnon HK (1952) A revision of the genus Bromus, section Bromopsis, of North America. Brittonia 7:415–480 Walton PD (1980) The production characteristics of Bromus inermis Leyss and their inheritance. Adv Agron 33:341–369 Watson L, Dallwitz MJ (1992) The grass genera of the world. CAB Int, Wallingford, UK Wattanasiri C, Walton PD (1993) Effects of growth regulators on callus cell growth, plant regeneration, and somaclonal variation of smooth bromegrass (Bromus inermis Leyss). Euphytica 69:77–82 Wilen RW, Fu P, Robertson AJ, Abrams SR, Low NH, Gusta LV (1996) An abscisic acid (ABA) analog inhibits ABAinduced freezing tolerance and protein accumulation, but not ABA-induced sucrose uptake in a bromegrass (Bromus inermis Leyss) cell culture. Planta 200:138–143 Wilton AC (1965) Phylogenetic relationships of an unknown tetraploid. Bromus, section Bromopsis. Can J Bot 43:723–730 Wu G, Robertson AJ, Zheng P, Liu X, Gusta LV (2005) Identification and immunogold localization of a novel bromegrass (Bromus inermis Leyss) peroxisome channel protein induced by ABA, cold and drought stresses, and late embryogenesis. Gene 363:77–84 Xiang F-N, Xia G-M, Zhou A-F, Chen H-M, Huang Y, Zhai XL (1999) Asymmetric somatic hybridization between wheat (Triticum aestivum) and Bromus inermis. Acta Bot Sin 41:458–462 (Chinese with English abstract) Yanaka FY (2002) Caracterizacao molecular e isoenzimatica de acessos de Bromus auleticus Trinius ex Nees. MSc Dissert, Univ Fed Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre
Chapter 3
Cenchrus S. Goel, H.D. Singh, and S.N. Raina
3.1 Introduction Grasses (Poaceae) feed the world either directly as food crops, such as wheat rice, millets, and other grains, or indirectly as primary fodder for the livestock. It is estimated that grasslands cover around 20% of the earth’s total land area. Cenchrus, a member of the tribe paniceae of the Poaceae family, is also one of the important components of major grass cover of the world. It is distributed throughout the arid and semiarid tropical regions of the world (Bogdan 1977). Considering the diversity and present-day distribution, Cenchrus probably originated in the eastern tropical Africa and tropical Asia and is widely naturalized in new world countries. Cenchrus ciliaris and two closely related species, C. setiger and C. pennisetiformis, are three main species of Cenchrus having the potential for forage production across the world. They are well adapted to harsh climatic conditions and flourish vigorously with the availability of soil moisture. C. ciliaris is more widespread and more valued as forage grass for dry areas because of its high biomass production and tolerance to low rainfall conditions. Some of the species of Cenchrus are also potential invader weeds. After invasion, they replace the native species by changing not only the ecophysiological characteristics but also the fire regime. The grass base of Royal Botanical Garden, Kew has recorded 25 species of Cenchrus. However,
S.N. Raina (*) Amity Institute of Biotechnology, Amity University, Sector 125, Noida, Uttar Pradesh, India e-mail:
[email protected]
Germplasm Resource Information Network (GRIN) of USDA recorded 35 different species of Cenchrus. This genus belongs to the tribe Paniceae of Poaceae family. Majority of the taxa in the tribe Paniceae are polyploids with basic chromosome no x ¼ 9 or 10; however, basic chromosome number determination is almost impossible due to the presence of an aneuploid series in this taxa. This aneuploid series results in abnormal meiotic chromosome behavior during sexual reproduction, resulting in sterility and subsequently culminating in predominance of aposporic embryo development (Snyder et al. 1955). But both sexual and apomictic modes of reproduction have been reported in C. ciliaris.
3.2 Morphology, Taxonomy, and Geographical Distribution of Genetic Diversity The name Cenchrus comes from the Greek word “Kenchros” meaning millet. The Latin word Cenchrus was used by Plinius, for an Arabian diamond or an unknown kind of piece, big as a grain of millet (Quattrocchi 2008). Cenchrus belongs to family Poaceae (Gramineae), subfamily Panicoideae, tribe Paniceae. The subfamily Panicoideae includes approximately 208 genera and ~3,300 species. Cenchrus is an extremely variable genus having both annual and perennial species. It is tufted, sometimes shortly rhizomatous grass with branching culms. Culms are ascending, erect, or decumbent and stoloniferous, ranging from 68 to 300 cm in length (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). Some species reach up to 9 feet in
C. Kole (ed.), Wild Crop Relatives: Genomic and Breeding Resources, Millets and Grasses, DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-14255-0_3, # Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
31
32
height. Leaves are with ligules, either with a ciliate membrane or fringe of hairs. Leaf blades are flat, linear, or lanceolate. It is a bisexual plant with an erect or nodding cylindrical spike-like panicle inflorescence with angular rachis. Panicle has an axis bearing deciduous spikelet clusters. Each cluster has one to eight spikelets subtended by a deciduous involucre of flattened and often spiny bristles, which are connate at the base. Spikelets are sessile, lanceolate or ovate, closely compressed, and unawned. Each spikelet has one basal sterile or male floret and one fertile (hermaphodite) floret. Each floret has one or two glumes, which are unequal, shorter, or longer than the adjacent lemmas. Lemmas are as long as the spikelet, membranous to coriaceous, the flat margins of which cover much of palea. Lower glume is minute or is sometimes suppressed. Lodicules are absent in some species and are with two lodicules in some other species. Flowers are with three anthers and two stigmas. Fruit is small, typical of grass, i.e., caryopsis with adherent pericarp, dorsally compressed. The shape of the fruit varies from ellipsoidal, oblong, or ovoid to obovoid. Endosperm is hard, is without lipids, and contains only simple starch grains. Morphologically, Cenchrus is very similar to Pennisetum with few species of Setaria namely Setaria grisebachii and Setaria macrostachya, which often lead to confusion for identification but can be differentiated from each other by the morphology of the involucral bristles. In Cenchrus, bristles are fused with each other at the base, forming a spiny cup, but they are free in Pennisetum (Stieber and Wipff 2000; Tu et al. 2002). In C. ciliaris, the extent of fusion is minimal, which led to its placement in the genus Pennisutum as Pennisetum ciliare (Fisher et al. 1954; Taliaferro and Bashaw 1966; Vielle-Calzada et al. 1996). The membership of the C. ciliaris in genus Cenchrus is justified by its close relationship with C. setiger. In Setaria, the spikelets are borne above the bristles, and the bristles remain attached to the rachis of the inflorescence even after the spikelets fall off, whereas in Cenchrus, the bristles fall off with the spikelet as a unit at maturity. This species comprises many ecotypes differing greatly in their morphogenetic characters across accessions collected from the same locality or natural distribution (Arshad et al. 2007). Even differing number of chromosomes has been discovered between the ecotypes (Hignight et al. 1991).
S. Goel et al.
All species of Cenchrus are very much similar in their morphology. The genus Cenchrus has been separated further to different species level mainly based on the nature of bristles and their degree of fusion. 1. Cenchrus argimonioides Trin., commonly known as agrimony sandbur in US and as kamanomano in Hawaii, is native to North Pacific regions of the world, i.e., western coast of the US and Hawaii Islands (GRIN Taxonomy USDA) and is endemic to this region (Quattrocchi 2008). This is a perennial species with robust culms, which are 25–200 cm long. Leaf blades are 16–41 cm long, 6–16 mm wide, green to bluish green in color. Panicle spiciform, loose, 7–28 cm long. Deciduous spikelets in clusters of 1–2 spikelets subtended by an involucre of numerous deciduous bristles, which connate 2–3 mm forming a cup at the base. Bristles are rigid, retrorsely scaberulous, ciliate and spiny (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). Fertile spikelets with 1 basal sterile and 1 fertile floret. Basal sterile floret barren and is with significant palea. Lemma of lower sterile floret with 5 veins. 2. Cenchrus biflorus Roxb., also known as Indian Sandbur, is native to Indian subcontinent and tropical African countries (GRIN Taxonomy USDA; Clayton et al. 2006 onwards; Quattrocchi 2008). It is an annual species with tufted habit. The culms are 5–90 cm long, ascending to erect and are unequal in length. The upper internodes are longer than the lower (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). Leaf blades 2–25 cm long, 2–7 cm wide. Panicle 2–15 cm long with axis bearing deciduous spikelet in clusters of 1–3 spikelets subtended by a rigid involucre of two whorls of bristles, which connate at the base for 0.5–1 mm, forming a diamond-shaped shallow disc at the base. Involucral bristles ovoid in shape, 4–11 mm long retrorsely barbellate and tenaciously prickly. Inner spines flattened and their abaxial surface with 1–3 grooves. Outer bristles numerous and spiny, shorter than the inner, rarely suppressed. Fertile spikelets with 1 basal sterile and 1 fertile floret. Basal sterile floret barren and is with significant palea. Lemma of lower sterile floret with 5 veins. This species is well adapted to hot and dry tropical areas and it might be a paleotropical invasive weed. Impressions of its seeds were found in
3 Cenchrus
the archeological site of Tichit Chekka III (Mauritania, west Africa) (Quattrocchi 2008). 3. Cenchrus brownii Roem. and Schult is native to coastal plains of southeastern US, Central America, and northern coast of southern America (GRIN Taxonomy USDA; Quattrocchi 2008). This species is distributed in tropical and temperate regions of Asia as well as Australia (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). It is also commonly called as Green Sandbur or Slimbristle Sandbur. This is an annual species with tufted herbaceous habit. Culms 25–100 cm long, ascending or erect. Rooting at the decumbent base, culm nodes are sometimes found in this species (Quattrocchi 2008). Leaf blades 8–30 cm long, 4–11 mm wide. Panicle linear or oblong, 3–12 cm long. Deciduous spikelets in clusters of 2–3 spikelets subtended by involucral bristles connate at the base up to 2.5–4 mm above to form a cup. Inner bristles subequal to outer bristles with the longest slightly emergent, flattened, rigid retrorsely scaberulous and spinose. Fertile spikelets with one basal sterile and one fertile floret. Basal sterile floret barren and is with significant palea. Lemma of lower sterile floret with 5 veins. This species grows in sandy waste places, forest borders, savannah, on beaches, and near the ocean (Quattrocchi 2008). 4. Cenchrus calicalatus Cav., commonly known as Hillside burrgrass or large burrgrass, is native to tropical Southeast Asia, Australia, New Zealand, and Pacific Islands (GRIN Taxonomy USDA; Quattrocchi 2008). This perennial species grows in clumps forming dense mats with its short woody rhizome trailing or scrambling and rooting at the lower nodes. Culms erect or ascending, 30–200 cm long, sometimes reaching up to 300 cm. Leaf blade flat and narrowly lanceolate, 5–56 cm long and 1–19 mm wide. Panicle spiciform, loose and 4–23.5 cm long with axis bearing deciduous spikelet clusters of 1–3 spikelets. Involucral bristles connate at the base to form a disc, which extends above for 0.5 mm above. Bristles numerous, 8–12 in principle whorl. The inner bristles terete, rigid and spinose and are without grooves. Basal sterile florets male or barren, with or without significant palea. Lodicules are absent in this species. This species is found growing on poor soils, on rocky coasts and on open sunny areas.
33
5. Cenchrus ciliaris (L) Link, commonly known as Buffelgrass, is native to tropical Africa and Asia and is naturalized widely in subhumid and semiarid tropics and subtropics (GRIN Taxonomy USDA; Clayton et al. 2006 onwards; Quattrocchi 2008). It is also known with other synonyms “Pennisetum ciliare” and “Pennisetum cenchroids” (GRIN Taxonomy USDA). C. ciliaris is perennial species with tufted habit. Culms are 10–50 cm long at maturity and are ascending to erect, profusely branched, shrub-like in growth habit. Leaf blades 3–25 cm long, 4–10 mm wide and green or bluish green in color. Panicle spiciform, 2–14 cm long, bears spikelets in clusters of 1–4 spikelets. Involucral bristles are numerous and united at the base to form a shallow disc up to 0.5 mm above the rim. The bristles in C. ciliaris are antrorsely scaberulous and not prickly. The inner bristles are flexuous, filiform in shape, and exceed much in length than spikelets, one of them longer and stouter than the rest (DeLisle 1963). Basal sterile florets are barren and are without significant palea. Lemma of the sterile floret with 5 veins. This species grows mainly on sandy soils and alluvial plains, on shallow marginally fertile soils, along roadsides, rocky hillsides, hot and dry areas, and denuded arid lands (Quattrocchi 2008). 6. Cenchrus distichophyllus Griseb. is distributed in Caribbean Islands (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). It is a perennial species with distinct rootstock habit. Culms are erect, 15–40 cm long. Leave sheaths are longer than adjacent internodes. Leaf blade 2.6–3 cm long, 1.5 mm wide. Panicle 2.5–4 cm long with axis bearing spikelet clusters of one spikelet. Involucral bristles connate at the base to form a cup. Basal sterile florets barren and are with palea. Lemma of lower sterile floret ovate and is with 3 veins (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). 7. Cenchrus echinatus L., commonly known as Sandbur or hedhog sandbur, is found in tropical and subtropical regions of the world. This is an annual species with herbaceous to subshrubby habit. Culms are erect and 15–90 cm long. Leaf blades 4–25 cm long, 3–10 mm wide. Panicle linear and interrupted. Axis bears spikelet clusters of 2–3 spikelets. Involucral bristles connate for 2–5 mm at the base into a cup. The inner bristles flattened and outer whorl thinner than the inner
34
and are tereted. Basal serile florets barren and are with palea. Lemmas of the lower sterile floret are with 5 veins. Seed heads of this species are composed of spiny burrs. These spines cause problems in cultivated lands and are very irritating to humans. This species commonly grows on waste ground, coastal dunes near the ocean, open areas, roadsides, and sandy or limestone soils (Quattrocchi 2008). 8. Cenchrus elymoides is found distributed in Australia (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). It is a perennial species with robust habit. Culms are 60–150 cm long. Leaf blades 14–34 cm long and 3.3–10.2 mm wide. Panicle spiciform, dense and 10.5–16 cm long. Spikelet clusters with 1–3 spikelets in a cluster. Involucral bristles connate for 0.5 mm below to form a disc at the base. The inner bristles are longer than the outer bristles with one conspicuously longer than the others, which expand at the base. Bristles are flexible, antrorsely scaberulous, and attenuate. Basal florets barren and are with palea. Lemma of the lower sterile floret is with 3–5 veins. 9. Cenchrus gracillimus Thunb. is commonly called as Slender sandbur and is a native to southeastern US and Caribbean Islands. It is a perennial species (Stieber and Wipff 2000; Quattrocchi 2008) with dense tufted growth habit. Culms are 15–60 cm in length. Leaf blades 4.5–17 cm long, 1.1–3.3 wide. Panicle spiciform, loose and 2–6.8 cm long. Axis bears spikelet clusters of 1–3 spikelets. Involucral bristles connate at the base to form a cup. Bristles rigid, flattened, retrorsely scaberulous, and emerged irregularly from the body of the burr. Basal florets barren and are with palea. Lemma of the lower sterile floret is with 3–5 veins. This weed species grows in sandy soils of pinelands, wet prairies, and river flats, behind the sandy dunes. 10. Cenchrus incertus M.A. Curtis., commonly known as Coastal Sandbur grass or Coastal Sanbur, is native to northern and southern America (GRIN Taxonomy USDA). It is found distributed to other parts of the world – in southwestern, southeastern, and eastern Europe, in tropical Africa, and temperate Asian countries. It is an annual or short lived perennial grass species with tufted, erect with shallow root system. The lower nodes of the prostrate stem give rise to secondary roots. Leaf blade 2–18 cm long and 2–6 mm wide.
S. Goel et al.
Panicle linear, 2–8.5 cm long, and often partially enclosed by the upper leaf sheath (Quattrocchi 2008). Spikelets in clusters of 2–4 spikelets. Involucral bristles connate for 2–7 mm into a cup below with clefts on two sides. Bristles rigid, flattened, and retrorsely scaberulous, with the longest bristle scarcely emergent. Basal florets barren and are with palea. Lemma of the lower sterile floret is with 5–7 veins. This species grows mostly in disturbed areas, dry sites, dry sand in saline meadows, sand hills, road verges, and paddocks. This species often acts as indicator for the poor fertility of the soil (Quattrocchi 2008). 11. Cenchrus longispinus (Hackel) Fernald., commonly known as long spine sandbur or spiny burrgrass, is native to Argentina, Mexico, and US, and is naturalized widely in Australia (GRIN Taxonomy USDA). This is an annual or short-lived perennial spiny species with coarse and tufted habit. Culms are ascending or sometimes decumbent and ranges from 10 to 90 cm in length. Leaf blades 6.3–18.7 cm long and 3–7.2 mm wide. Panicle spiciform and dense, 4.1–10.2 cm in length. Spikelets in clusters of 2–3 spikelets. Involucral bristles connate to form a cup below. Bristles flattened, without grooves, rigid, retrorsely scaberulous, pubescent, and spinose. Basal sterile florets barren and are with palea. Lemma of the lower sterile floret is with 3–7 veins. This is an invasive weed species with low forage value. It is a restricted grass species and is included in aquatic or terrestrial noxious weed and/or noxious-weed seed in U.S. This species grows in disturb soils, dry road side gravel, railroads, and in waste grounds. This species is very similar in morphology and habit with Cenchrus echinatus, hence it is difficult to distinguish from each other (Quattrocchi 2008). 12. Cenchrus melanostachyus A. Camus. is found distributed in eastern Africa at western coastline of Indian ocean and Madagascar (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). This is a perennial species with short rhizomes. Culms are ascending, 40–60 cm in length, and swollen at the base. Leaf blades 25–35 cm long and 4–5 cm wide. Panicle spiciform and 3–8 cm long. Spikelets in clusters of 3 spikelets. Involucral bristles connate for 1 mm into a disc below. Bristles are flattened, rigid, and antrorsely scaberulous and spiny. Basal sterile
3 Cenchrus
floret male and are with palea. Lemma with 5 veins. 13. Cenchrus mitis Anderss. is native to Africa, Tanzania, Mozambique, and Kenya (GRIN Taxonomy USDA; Clayton et al. 2006 onwards; Quattrocchi 2008). It is an annual species. Culms are 20–100 cm long and geniculately ascending or sometimes decumbent. Leaves flat 5–30 cm long and 2–10 mm wide. Panicle spiciform, linear and 4–18 cm long. Spikelets in clusters of 2 sometimes 3 spikelets. Involucres globose to ovoid, body of involucre pubescent but not grooved. Bristles connate for 2–6 mm or 1/3–2/3 of their length to form a cup at the base. Bristles rigid, antrorsely scaberulous, and spiny. Basal sterile floret male and is with palea. Lemma with 5–7 veins. This species grows in bushland, coastal bushland, sandy soils, and abandoned cultivated lands (Quattrocchi 2008). 14. Cenchrus multiflorus J. Presl. is native to Mexico and Mesoamericana (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). It is an annual species with tufted habit. Culms 60–140 cm long. Leaf blades 16–25 cm long and 8–20 mm wide. Panicle linear, dense, and 7–18 cm long. Axis bears spikelets in clusters of 2–4 in spikelets. Involucral bristles connate at the base for 3 mm to form a cup below. Inner bristles longer than outer. Bristles flattened and without grooves, rigid, antrorsely scaberulous, and attenuate. Basal sterile floret male and is with palea. Lemma with 5–7 veins. One distinct character of this species is a reduced or scarcely developed leaf in the early development stage of the plant life (cataphyll) (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). 15. Cenchrus myosuroides Kunth. is commonly called as Big Sandbur and is native to South-central US and northern South American countries and Caribbean Islands (GRIN Taxonomy USDA; Clayton et al. 2006 onwards; Quattrocchi 2008). This is a perennial tall bunchgrass species. Culms are 50–200 cm long, tough, stout, and erect with decumbent base. Leaf blades 12–38 cm long and 4–13 mm wide. Panicle linear 6.5–23 cm long and dense. Spikelets in clusters of 1(-3) spikelets. Bur consists of single whorls of bristles. Bristles united at the base to form a disc below. Bristles as long as the spikelets, flattened, rigid, retrorsely scaberulous, and spiny. Basal sterile floret male
35
and is with palea. Lemma with 3–7 veins. This species is very palatable and grows mostly along roadsides and in other waste places (Quattrocchi 2008). 16. Cenchrus palmeri Vasey. is an annual species found growing in Mexico (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). Culms are solitary, 9–35 cm long. Leaf blades 4.4–10 cm long and 3.8–6.8 mm wide. Panicle 2–4.3 cm long. Spikelets in clusters of 4–8 spikelets. Involucral bristles connate to form a cup below. Bristles numerous, terete, rigid, retrorsely scaberulous, and spiny. Basal sterile floret male and is with palea. Lemma with 5–7 veins (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). 17. Cenchrus pennisetiformis (Hochst. and Steud), commonly known as Cloncurry buffelgrass, White or slender buffelgrass, is native to African countries including Kenya, Ethiopia, Somalia, Sudan, and Asian countries including India, Pakistan, Yemen, and southern Iran (Quattrocchi 2008). It is naturalized in the Mediterranean region, Southeast Asia and northern Australia (GRIN Taxonomy USDA; Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). It is a perennial species behaving occasionally as an annual. Culms are 10–40 cm long and are ascending. Leaf blades linear, 2–20 cm long and 2–5 mm wide. Panicle 2–7 cm long. Axis bears spikelets in clusters of 1–3. Involucral bristles connate at the base for 1–2.5 mm into a cup below. Bristles are numerous, flexible, antrorsely scaberulous, and ciliate. Basal sterile florets are with anthers and palea. Lemma with 5 veins. Morphologically it is similar to small-medium type C. ciliaris. It is differentiated from C. ciliaris by its extent of fusion of the involucral bristles. In C. pennisetiformis, the fusion of inner bristles extends more above the rim of the basal disc. Apart from it, plants of C. pennisetiformis are of smaller stature, usually annual, and favor subdesert habitats (Quattrocchi 2008). 18. Cenchrus pilosus Kunth. It is found distributed in Mexico, northern South America, and southwestern America (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). This is an annual species with dense and tufted habit. Culms 30–60 cm in length. Leaf blades 6–30 cm long and 4–11 mm wide. Panicle spiciform, dense, and 2–13 cm long. Spikelets in clusters of 2–3 spikelets. Involucral bristles connate for 2–4 mm at the base to form a cup. Bristles flattened,
36
19.
20.
21.
22.
S. Goel et al.
flexible, smooth, and attenuate. Basal sterile florets barren and with palea. Lemma with 3–7 veins. Cenchrus platyacanthus. Annual species distributed in western South America (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). Clumps weak, either erect or ascending, 20–90 cm in length. Leaf blades elongate, 4–24 cm long and 2–8 mm wide. Panicle spiciform, dense, and 3.8–8.6 cm long. Spikelet clusters with single spikelet. Involucral bristles connate at the base for 2.8–6 mm into a cup below. Bristles terete, rigid, retrorsely scaberulous, and spiny. Basal sterile florets barren and with palea. Lemma with 3 veins. Cenchrus prieurii (Kunth) Maire. This species is distributed in India and tropical African region (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). It is an annual or short species like perennial tufted species, with erect to ascending habit. Culms 30–75 cm long. Leaf blades 8–30 cm long and 5–10 mm wide. Panicle 6–14 long. Spikelets in clusters of 2. Involucral bristles connate at the base for 1 mm into a disc below. Bristles numerous and are flattened, grooved on the face, rigid, antrorsely scaberulous, and ciliate. Basal sterile florets barren and without significant palea. Lemma with 3 veins. Cenchrus robustus R.D. Webster is found distributed in Australia (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). This is a perennial species with short rhizome. Distinct cataphyll. Culms are 40–100 cm long and erect. Leaf blades 6–22 cm long and 3–7 mm wide. Panicle 4–8 cm long. Axis bears spikelets in clusters of 1–2 spikelets. Bristles connate for 0.5 mm below to form a disc. Bristles numerous, rigid, terete, retrorsely scaberulous, and spiny. Basal sterile florets barren and are with palea. Lemma with 5 veins. Cenchrus setiger Vahl. is commonly known as Birdwood grass and is native to East and Northeast Africa, Northwest India, Arabia, Yemen, Australia, and Brazil (GRIN Taxonomy USDA; Quattrocchi 2008). It is a perennial species, which grows vigorously and rapidly into bunch, more or less erect, forming clumps from a bulbous base. Culms are 40–100 cm long. Leaf blades 6–22 cm long and 3–7 mm wide. Panicle spiciform, 4–8 cm long. Axis bears spikelets in clusters of 1–3 spikelets. Involucral bristles connate below for 1–3 mm into a cup at the base. Bristles numerous, rigid,
terete, retrorsely scaberulous, and spiny. This species can be distinguished from others by its stiff inner spiny bristles and vestigial outer bristles. 23. Cenchrus somalensis Clayton. is a perennial species native to Somalia (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). Plants densely tufted in habit. Culms erect and 25–45 cm long. Leaf blades narrow and convolute, 5–15 cm long and 1 mm wide. Panicle linear to oblong, 2.5–6 cm long. Axis bears spikelets in clusters of 1–2. Involucral bristles connate for 2–4 mm into a cup below. Bristles flattened and flexible, antrorsely scaberulous, and ciliate. Basal sterile florets with anthers and palea. Lemma with 5 veins. This species grows mainly under shade of trees and among the bushes. 24. Cenchrus spinifex Cav. is commonly known as Coastal sandbur. This species is found distributed in US and South America (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards; Quattrocchi 2008). Plants are annual or short-lived perennial, culms 30–100 cm long, geniculately ascending, or decumbent. Panicle 3–5 cm long. Spikelets in clusters of 2–4 and are with sharp spines. Bristles connate at the base for 1.5–2.5 mm into a cup. Bristles numerous, rigid, flattened, retrorsely scaberulous, and spiny. Basal sterile florets are with anthers or barren. Florets are with palea or sometimes absent. Lemma with 5–7 veins. It is a noxious weed growing on sandy soil in both open areas and thin wood, along roadsides, and waste fields and places. It is very similar in morphology with C. longispinus. But it has shorter spikelets, fewer bristles, wider inner bristles, and flattened outer bristles (Stieber and Wipff 2000). 25. Cenchrus tribuloides L., commonly known as American burrgrass, is native to northeastern and southeastern US, Caribbean Islands, and Brazil (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards; Quattrocchi 2008). This is an annual species with sharp spines, which are painful to touch. Culms are 10–70 cm long, erect or ascending, branching and rooting at the lower nodes. Leaf blades 2–14 cm long and 3–14 mm wide and gray green in color. Spikelets hard and prickly, infrequent, not in clusters, articulated, solitarily on the panicle axis, and densely pubescent. Bristles connate into a cup below. Spikelets numerous, flattened, rigid, retrorsely scaberulous, ciliate, and spinose. This is a weed species, which is a useful stabilizer of sand dunes and grows
3 Cenchrus
in moist and sandy dunes, on coastal sands, open dunes, tropical salt marshes, and open grasslands to dense shrub-cultivated fields. The young plants are used as fodder in dry areas. These species of Cenchrus are mainly distributed in the sub-Saharan central and eastern Africa, arid and semi-arid south-central to southwestern US to northern Mexico on the west, temperate Asia (Middle East countries), tropical Asia (India, Pakistan, Indonesia) on the east and semi-arid regions of Australia (Queensland, northern South Wales). Eastern Africa is considered as the center of diversity for tropical grasses with over 90% of the cultivated forage grasses including Cenchrus originated in this region (Suttie et al. 2005). Out of the 25 species, two species are reported in Europe, 11 in Africa, eight in temperate Asia, eight in tropical Asia, 11 in Australia, seven species in North America, and 13 species in South America (Clayton et al. 2006 onwards). Out of the 25 species, 13 species are perennial, 10 are annual, and two behave as both annual and perennial in habit. Cenchrus grows mainly on sandy soils and alluvial plains, on shallow marginally fertile soils, along roadsides, rocky hillsides, hot and dry areas, and denuded arid lands, growing when soil moisture is available.
3.3 Cytology and Cytogenetics The most widespread species of Cenchrus, C. ciliaris, shares the tertiary gene pool of pearl millet (Pennisetum glaucum) along with other apomictic species of Pennisetum (Jessup et al. 2000; Martel et al. 2004). This grass species has a small genome size of ~ 3,200 MB with 1.33 pg of DNA per haploid genome, which is low for a polyploid grass species (Jessup et al. 2000; Roche et al. 2002). However, limited studies have been done so far to identify other species belonging to the primary, secondary, and tertiary gene pool of C. ciliaris. C. setiger may be in the secondary gene pool of this grass species. Cytological examination of meiotic chromosome behavior in tetraploid (4x ¼ 36) accessions of both species show similar pairing patterns (normal disjunction) during metaphase I (Fisher et al. 1954). These two species can cross with each other, producing fertile hybrids. Meiotic chromosome spreads of the hybrids show more bivalents and fewer
37
quadrivalents, but there is no significant difference in the size of the paired chromosomes (Read and Bashaw 1969). This relationship between these two species is well supported by isozyme and DNA-based marker analyses (Chandra and Dubey 2007, 2008; Kellogg et al. 2009). Cenchrus is a much variable genus. It has base chromosome numbers x ¼ 9, 10, 15, 16, 17, 18 (Fisher et al. 1954; DeLisle 1963; Vij and Chaudhary 1981; Morrone et al. 2006). Majority of the species possess chromosome numbers, which are multiple of the original basic number, i.e., are mainly polyploids and also show high degree of aneuploidy. Somatic (2n) chromosome numbers of different species ranges from 18 to 70 (Table 3.1). The available cytological data suggested that majority of the species are stable cytologically with the exception of a few species. Greater instability in chromosome numbers is observed in C. ciliaris, C. Browni, C. biflorus, Cenchrus mysuroides, and Cenchrus setiger (Vij and Chaudhary 1981). Lagging of chromosomes during first meiotic anaphase due to precocious meiotic division is a common phenomenon in cytotypes with multiple diploid chromosome numbers (Fisher et al. 1954). Such
Table 3.1 Chromosome numbers of different species of the genus Cenchrus Species Chromosome numbers C. biflorus 30, 32, 34, 36 C. brownie 34, 36, 66ca C. cathcarticus 34 C. ciliaris 18, 32, 34, 36, 36+0-2Bs, 40, 44, 50, 52, 54, 56 C. echinatus 34, 68 C. glaucus 36, 38 C. gracillimus 34 C. incertus 32, 34 C. inflexus 34 C. longispinus 34 C. mitis 34 C. multiflorum 34 C. mysuroides 54, 68 ca 70 C. palmeri 34 C. parviceps 34 C. pauciflorus 34, 36 C. pennisetiformis 35, 42, 54 C. pilosus 34 C. prieuri 34 C. setiger 34, 36, 37, 54 C. tribuloides 34
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
ASGR
variation in chromosome number in different species of Cenchrus may have aroused due to the natural interspecific or intergenic hybridizations, which occurs frequently in grasses. Majority of these species showing cytological instability are facultative apomicts with the exception of C. ciliaris that reproduces through sexual fertilization also. Therefore, there is more chance of preserving the new chromosome combinations. On the other hand, an increase in chromosome number may induce meiotic abnormalities resulting in sterility and subsequently may have evolved apomictic mode of reproduction to escape the sterility. These variations in chromosome number or genome size might have contributed to the variations in certain morphological features, developmental variations, and productive capacity (Mnif et al. 2005). C. ciliaris alone shows variable ploidy levels with 2n ¼ 18, 27, 32, 36, 43, 45, 48, 54 (Fisher et al. 1954; Snyder et al. 1955; Bashaw and Hignight 1990; Hignight et al. 1991; Mnif et al. 2005), but tetraploid with chromosome no. 36 (2n ¼ 4x ¼ 36) is presumably the most widespread ecotype (Hignight et al. 1991). It behaves like a segmental allotetraploid, showing at the average of two to four quadrivalents and 10–14 bivalents during metaphase I (Bashaw 1962; Hignight et al. 1991). This segmental behavior of the buffelgrass genome is verified genetically by Jessup et al. (2003). Analysis of the polymorphic probes in genetic linkage maps reveal repulsion phase associations of 26 linkage groups indicating preferential pairing of linkage groups. The paternal and maternal chromosomes behave differentially from each other, with the maternal parent having higher frequency of crossing over against the paternal parent (Jessup et al. 2003). The chromosomes are very similar in morphology as well as in size and difficult to distinguish. Akiyama et al. (2005) constructed a quantitative ideogram of tetraploid Buffelgrass (C. ciliaris) using fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) with 5S rDNA, 18s rDNA, and bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) clones containing apomixis-linked markers (C101) as probes to DAPI stained spreads (Fig. 3.1). Thirty-six chromosomes were classified into nine morphologically similar chromosome types with two additional chromosomes with no similarity with other chromosomes. All chromosomes are of metacentric and submetacentric types with arm ratio ranging from 1.1 to 1.7 (Akiyama et al. 2005).
S. Goel et al.
Strange
38
Fig. 3.1 Quantitative ideogram of Mitotic Cenchrus ciliaris chromosome. Red, green, and yellow circles indicate C101, 18S rDNA, and 5S rDNA probes, respectively. Source: Akiyama et al. 2005
Many authors had reported Cenchrus setiger with 2n chromosome number of 34, 36, 37, and 54 (Fisher et al. 1954; Vij and Chaudhary 1981; Ahsan et al. 1994). However, 2n ¼ 34 seems to be most widespread. The chromosomes are of metacentric and submetacentric types with length ranging from 3.61 to 1.00 m, and pollen mother cell meiosis shows variable number of quadrivalents (1–5) and bivalents (Vij and Chaudhary 1981). The somatic chromosome complement of Cenchrus biflorous ranges from 2n ¼ 30, 32, 34, 36 with the base chromosome numbers x ¼ 16, 17, 18 (Vij and Chaudhary 1981; Ahsan et al. 1994). The chromosomes are predominated by submetacentric types with length ranging from 2.73–1.07 m. The chromosomes can be grouped into two types with relatively larger group of size range of 2.72–1.74 m and smaller group of 1.50–1.07 m. The meiotic behavior of the chromosomes differs with different cytotypes showing difference in the number of bivalents of the smaller group of chromosomes. However, cytotype with n ¼ 17, which shows more stability during pollen meiosis, seems to be predominant (Vij and Chaudhary 1981). Majority of the species of Cenchrus reproduce apomictically, but low level of sexuality has been reported in some species. The reduced female gametophyte is of polygonum type with two synergids, an egg cell, two polar nuclei in the central cell, and three antipodals toward the chalazal end (Bashaw 1962). Aposporous unreduced female gametophytes can be identified cytologically by the absence of antipodals in mature embryo sac or presence of multiple embryo sacs in cleared ovules. Ovules can be effectively cleared in methyl salicylate after fixing for 24 h in FAA (formalin: acetic acid: ethyl alcohol) and storing in 70% ethyl
3 Cenchrus
alcohol (Young et al. 1979). In both sexual and apomictic plants, the differentiation of the archesporial cell and subsequent reductional division to form a linear tetrad is similar, but in apomictic ovules, all members of linear tetrad degenerate, although rarely, and the chalazal megaspore develops into 2-nucleate stage (Bashaw 1962). In the meantime, the unreduced nucellar cells undergo two successive equational division and enlarge rapidly to form multiple 4-nucleate unreduced embryo sacs; one egg, two synergids, and one diploid polar nuclei and occupy a large portion of the ovule. Despite its unreduced egg cell reproduction, fertilization of the central cell through cross pollination is needed to develop endosperm to nourish the developing embryo and hence to ensure seed set (Hignight et al. 1991). Presence of such dual mode of reproduction may be reason for the high levels of polyploidy and aneuploidy in different collections of Cenchrus (Fisher et al. 1954). An increase in chromosome number in aneuploid may induce meiotic abnormalities resulting in sterility and subsequently may have evolved apomictic mode of reproduction to escape the sterility. These variations in chromosome number or genome size might have contributed to the variations in certain morphological features, developmental variations, and productive capacity (Mnif et al. 2005).
3.4 Phylogenetic Relationship The subfamily Panicoideae of the large family Poaceae includes approximately 208 genera and ~3,300 species. This large subfamily shows monophyly, which is well supported morphologically by the presence of bifloral spikelets (lower sterile or staminate flower and upper fertile spikelets) and anatomically by the presence of simple starch grains in caryopsis (Aliscioni et al. 2003). The molecular level analysis of nuclear and chloroplast genes also supported the monophyly of this large subfamily (Giussani et al. 2001; Doust and Kellogg 2002; Doust et al. 2007; Kellogg et al. 2009). Panicoideae comprises two tribes: Paniceae and Andropogoneae. The tribe Paniceae is a highly diverse and species-rich assemblage of >200 species comprising one-fifth of the total species of grass (Duvall et al. 2001) and about 60% of panicoideae. This tribe is paraphyletic with two clades that
39
differ in the base chromosome number x ¼ 9 and x ¼ 10. Cenchrus belongs to the x ¼ 9 clade along with the type genera of the tribe, Panicum, and other species-rich genus Pennisetum and Setaria. Most of the relative genera are important forage grasses except one species P. glaucum (Pearl Millet), which is regarded as a major cereal crop of the semiarid tropics. This clade is known informally as “Bristle clade” (Doust and Kellogg 2002) because of the presence of sterile inflorescence bristle, which is unique among grasses. Based on morphological similarity, Cenchrus was earlier placed under genus Pennisetum (Jauhar 1981). Different species have been described in both genera at different times, and several authors also indicated that the two genera may be merged into a single genus (DeLisle 1963; Correlld and Johnston 1970). Presently, two genera are still maintained as separate genus (Doust and Kellogg 2002; Kellogg et al. 2009). Both of them show very similar pattern of early inflorescence development, but the difference appears late in development. In many species of Cenchrus, except C. ciliaris and C. myosuroides, the lateral branches or inflorescence bristles become broadened laterally, while those of Pennisetum remain more or less terete (Doust and Kellogg 2002). Their separation into two separate genera is also supported by the extent of fusion of the inflorescence bristles. In Cenchrus, the lateral edges fuse to variable extent while they are free in Pennisetum and elongate more just before anthesis (Doust and Kellogg 2002). Phylogenetic analysis shows that, within the paraphyletic Pennisetum, Cenchrus forms a derived monophyletic subclade (Giussani et al. 2001; Doust and Kellogg 2002; Martel et al. 2004; Doust et al. 2007; Kellogg et al. 2009; Fig. 3.2). The genus Cenchrus consists of both perennial and annual species. The knotted 1 marker gene analysis of the members of panicoideae including six species of the Cenchrus reveals that three species of Cenchrus, C. ciliaris, C. setiger, and C. echinatus, are very closely related, forming a close monophyletic clade, and other three species C. calycalatus, C. myosuroids, and C. pilosus form a separate group (Doust et al. 2007). Another study with chloroplast ndhF marker shows closer relationship of C. echinatus with C. calycalatus, C. myosuroids, and C. pilosus group and also reconfirms the close relationship between C. ciliaris and C. setiger (Kellogg et al. 2009). The close relationship among these three species, C. ciliaris,
40
S. Goel et al.
Fig. 3.2 ML phylogram for full kn1 dataset. Support values above branches are ML bootstrap/MP bootstrap; below branches are Bayesian posterior probabilities
C. setiger and C. pennisetiformis, may be because of chance hybridization among the three species (Doust et al. 2007). Although separated into two different
species, C. ciliaris and C. setiger are morphologically very similar and a few workers have placed C. setiger as a variety of C. ciliaris. Both apomictic and sexual
3 Cenchrus
forms are reported in C. ciliaris, but sexual reproduction has not been reported in C. setiger (Read and Bashaw 1969). These two species can also cross with each other, producing fertile hybrids. The growth habit of the hybrid is intermediate of the two parents: ranging from upright as C. ciliaris and procumbent as C. setiger. The seed set under open-pollination reach up to 99% and up to 84% under self-pollination, which are comparable to the progenies of sexual buffelgrass. The closer relationship between C. ciliaris and C. setiger is also supported by isozyme, sequence tagged site (STS) and random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) markers (Chandra and Dubey 2007, 2008). It seems that the variation between species is affected by the type of habit of the species. The RAPD, isozyme and STS markers clearly separated the annual forms from perennial species with the exception of C. mysuroides, which is a perennial species grouping with annual species. Two perennial species C. ciliaris and C. setiger are shown to be most closely related and they are most distant from the strictly annual species C. prieurri. This indicates that C. mysuroides may be acting as a bridging species between annual and perennial forms (Chandra and Dubey 2008).
3.5 Ecological Behavior The available distribution data suggested that many of the species of Cenchrus originated from tropical and subtropical India and Africa, where humid warm seasonal bimodial (distributed in two summer growing season) rainfall predominates. Mean minimum and maximum temperatures of the region vary from 21 to 24 C and 31 to 36 C, respectively (Cox et al. 1988). It is a xerophytic C4 grass, which grows in bunches and more often with creeping rhizomes. It spreads predominantly in areas where soil is of coarse texture sandy loam type with marginal productivity on clay soils. Poor soil aeration and limited availability of phosphorous limits the survival and productivity of this grass in clay soils (Ibarra-F et al. 1995). These grass species can be established under minimal level of precipitation ranging from as low as 100 mm to 1,000 mm with a few exceptions to more than 2,500 mm annual average. However, seed germination and establishment of the plants during extended wet periods are affected by allelopathy, infection by insects and pathogens, and
41
competition with other grasses, thus reducing its productivity (Cox et al. 1988). Growth initiated in the spring season continues to grow during the hot summer temperature and produces new growth with seasonal rain. Many species of Cenchrus are also potential invasive weeds, which displace native species. They modified to a good extent natural plant communities in California, Texas, and Hawaii in US, Sonora in Mexico, and in Australia (Martin et al. 1995; Tix 2000; Tunyalee 2000; Chen and Kuoh 2004; Franklin et al. 2006). Spines on the surface and the seeds of the C. echinatus, C. tribuloides, and C. biflorus are very irritating, and one cannot walk bare footed in the areas naturalized by these plant (Quattrocchi 2008). Like other invasive grasses, Cenchrus is very efficient in water usage. Its rhizomatous root draws soil moisture rapidly as compared to other plants. C. ciliaris also exudes some allelopathic chemicals, which inhibit the germination of other plants (Tunyalee 2000), and as a result, C. ciliaris once established in an area rapidly modifies the physiochemical properties of natural habitat and makes the soil unfit for others. Following invasion, this weed species forms dense thicklets. The dense growth habit of this rhizomatous grass has the potential to carry the fire rapidly across broad areas and change the fire regime of the ecosystem, where fire does not normally play important role. Like most others, this grass penetrates the soil, and hence, fire has minimal negative effect on this grass and it recovers very quickly. Recurrent fire in the area maintains C. ciliaris populations and the ecological result is the conversion of native scrub communities to African type Savannah with reduced native biological diversity (Tu et al. 2002). It also imposes economic cost through need to manage fire and to protect biodiversity and also the infrastructural establishments.
3.6 Traits of Agronomic Importance and Scope for Domestication Since new to cultivation, C. ciliaris has not yet gone through bottleneck of domestication, and extreme variability exists in wild at intraspecific level also. During 1880–1930, frequent droughts in Africa, North America, and Australia resulted in reduction of
42
livestock numbers. Many botanists, even the military personnel, were sent to many parts of the world in search for grass species, which produced abundant forage in the minimum level of precipitation. Many seeds from harsh climate were collected that undergone many trials. From these thousands of trials, a few grass species were collected for their ease of establishment and forage production in harsh environments (Cox et al. 1988) and C. ciliaris was one of them. This grass species occupies the major component of Dichanthium–Cenchrus–Lasiurus grass cover of India. It was one of the most commercially significant sown pasture grasses in Australia during 1960s and also planted as a valued pasture grass in Texas. Altogether, 34 different cultivars with different eco-physiological characteristics such as high forage quality and high yield have been released for pasture improvement in US, Australia, Brazil, South Africa, Mexico, India, and tropical African countries (Cook et al. 2005). This grass can grow in minimum amount of water as compared to other grass species (Osman et al. 2008), suggesting that the potential of buffelgrass could be harnessed in dry Arabian Peninsula to develop grasslands and reclamation of degraded rangelands with minimum irrigation. Various traits are known to exist in wild species of genus Cenchrus, although due to lack of enough studies, full potential of these species in improvement of cultivated C. ciliaris has not been realized. C. ciliaris although adapted to arid zone conditions, is susceptible to frost and various biotic stresses. More resistance to frost has been reported in C. setiger, but studies are required to establish the source of resistance to biotic stresses at intra and interspecific level.
3.7 Breeding and Crop Improvement C. ciliaris is a perennial warm season grass species quite tolerant to drought conditions and with good forage characteristics. On the contrary, buffelgrass establishment in other regions is limited due to lack of winter hardiness and salt tolerance in this plant. It can adapt to only a narrow range of soil types and is susceptible to several diseases (Jessup et al. 2000), the most destructive being a rampant leaf spot disease (Rust) caused by the fungus, Magnaporte grisea (anamorph Pyricularia grisea), which reduces quality and
S. Goel et al.
production of forage and in some cases destroys stands (Cook et al. 2005). In addition to C. ciliaris, other two closely related species, C. pennisetiformis and C. setiger (birdwood grass), are also potential grass for pasture plantation, but they are less common than C. ciliaris (Weed Management 2008). C. pennisetiformis is adapted to arid conditions and slightly alkaline soils. This grass species shows more tolerance to drought and dry conditions and survives seasonal flooding. It grows commonly on deep sandy soils of semi-desert habitats and is very useful for the stabilization of sand dunes. C. setiger can adapt to more wide range of soil types as compared to C. ciliaris; however, it prefers light textured sandy soils. C. Setiger shows more resistance to heat and frost compared to C. ciliaris; however, it has lower yield as compared to C. ciliaris and C. pennisetiformis. This species is well adapted to arid and semiarid regions with a long dry season and is very effective in stabilizing the moving sand. These agronomic traits if incorporated in C. ciliaris can yield rich dividends. Importance of wild species in improvement of C. ciliaris can be realized with these two species (C. pennisetiformis and C. setiger), although more studies are warranted in wild species of the genus Cenchrus.
3.8 Application of Molecular Techniques in Crop Improvement Compared to other members of the family Poaceae, limited studies have been done so far to assess the diversity at genetic level in tropical grasses such as Cenchrus. RAPD, AFLP (amplified fragment length polymorphism), ISSR (inter-simple sequence repeat), and STS markers have been used to reveal genetic distance at interspecific and intraspecific level (Gustine et al. 1996, Griffa et al. 2006; Chandra and Dubey 2007, 2008; Gutierrez-Ozuna et al. 2009). RAPD analysis with 106 primers in 10 populations of C. ciliaris consisting of a sexual line, an apomictic line, and eight progenies of the cross between two lines generated 569 distinct bands, out of which 495 bands showed differential expression among the lines (Gustine et al. 1996). In another RAPD study (Chandra and Dubey 2008), a higher degree of polymorphism was recorded among eight species of Cenchrus collected from
3 Cenchrus
different regions of the world. One hundred and eighty-seven decamer primers generated a total of 1,296 scorable bands, out of which 1,204 (92.9%) showed polymorphism among the eight species (Chandra and Dubey 2008). This result is the indication of a broad genetic base in the genus. Gutierrez-Ozuna et al. (2009) investigated the genetic diversity among pasture and colonized roadside populations of northwestern part of Mexico using ISSR markers. The genotypic parameters analysis demonstrated that populations have low level of genetic diversity between the roadside populations and pasture populations. These high frequencies indicate that the genotype of the region may be maintained by agamospermy or probably due to founders effect, or the populations sampled may represent the original introduced genotypes (Gutierrez-Ozuna et al. 2009). However, low level of polymorphism shown in vegetative characters and at the DNA level may be a result of occasional sexual reproduction or chance fertilization of unreduced gametes (Hignight et al. 1991). Somatic variation can also be responsible for the low level variation. Griffa et al. (2006) employed AFLP markers in assessing genetic diversity in buffelgrass. According to the authors, it was the first report of utilization of the technique in buffelgrass. Their analysis using three primer combinations produced 152 scorable bands among six apomictic cultivars, one sexual line and 15 putative hybrids of the cross between apomictic male cultivar and sexual female lines. These markers segregate most of the putative F1 hybrids towards the female parent with the exception of two putative F1 hybrids, which cluster neither with their parents nor with the other putative hybrids. The closeness of the hybrids to the female parent indicates that these hybrids may have originated through self-pollination of a sexual line. The two putative hybrids, which form a separate cluster, may represent the true hybrids. The hybrid nature of the two F1 putative hybrids was confirmed cytologically with observation of aposporous embryo sacs and with the amplification of sequencecharacterized amplified region (SCAR) marker “ugt 197”. Chandra and Dubey (2007) demonstrated that the STS markers developed on the basis of functional gene sequences of other non-related grass species can be successfully employed to analyze the level of genetic diversity between eight different species of Cenchrus.
43
Among the 17 Stylosanthes STS primers tested, 14 STS primers amplified 195 scorable bands, out of which 162 showed polymorphism between five species, indicating high amplification success of 82%. These bands show reasonable genetic distance ranging from 0.51 to 0.79 between species. This result provides an opportunity to use the primer sets in deciphering the diversity at both inter and intraspecific level. The authors also demonstrated that the isoenzyme variation between different species of Cenchrus is affected by the breeding system of the species. The perennial species show more polymorphism than the annual species. Out of nine isoenzymes tested, esterase produced more variable loci showing three and two polymorphic loci in perennial and annual species, respectively. Chandra and Dubey (2008) also assessed the differential response of eight species of Cenchrus using drought tolerant physiochemical parameters such as malondialdehyde (MDA), proline content, specific leaf area, and carbon isotope discrimination (CID). Generally, the level of MDA and proline accumulation increases in response to water stress in wheat (Zhang and Kirkham 1994), indicating a higher peroxidation of lipids. The same result of MDA accumulation was observed in most of the eight species subjected to water stress, with the exception of C. ciliaris, which shows significant drop in MDA accumulation. There is also significant increase in proline content with the exception of C. prieuri, which is an annual species. The percent increase in the MDA and proline accumulation was maximum in C. pennisetiformis, thus indicating higher tolerance of this species to water stress conditions.
3.9 Genetic Map Genetic map has been reported in C. ciliaris, but no reports could be found in other species. A full genetic map, which covers approximately 70–80% of the genome, has been reported in buffelgrass (Jessup et al. 2003; Fig. 3.3). A total of 100 cDNA probes consisting of clones from a cDNA library from the pistils of an apomictic buffelgrass and other cDNA clones, which show differential expression between sexual and apomictic ovaries in a previous study by Vielle-Calzada et al. (1996), and 360 heterologous polymorphic
44
S. Goel et al. P6C07c
8.8
3.3 7.7
P3C80a
RZ478i P8B05c P6B06c P1H06e P9G08c P9G04a P10A04b
P9F03c
P1H05j
P10H05g P9D10i P7C10o
12.8 CSU410h 25.5
19.4
8.7 5.4
P7A01e
P10H05e P3C08b 21.9 P12C05g 1b 117.5 cM
P12C03d P4F04a P9B07c
10.7 1.7 9.2
P8F01a 26.7 CSU523c CSU742e P10E03e 7b, LOD-4.90 11.7
12.5
P3H07d
23.0
P4A06d CSU5391 P7C03c P10C08c P7H05e P3B106
5.4 CDSR94g
16.5 P7G03a 17.7
P7F01h
15.0 7.5
6.0 8.1 CDSR94i
8.0 4.0 4.9
P1C12f
14.7
14.3
2.1
Pc08b
15.9 P2E06d
P5G09a P8F01c
13.6
P9D09b P7F01e
22.5
P9B09c
18.0 P1C12c P10E03a 2a 171.2 cM
24.7
P9C09c M848d P8H10b P9A09g
P10C12c
26.4
P3A06n
P7G03c P8A02d
Pcs1d
17.5 P12D07a
P4A06b
27.7
P9D10c
19.7
P10F10c P1C12b
10.9
CDSR94J
19.2
P1D01f P9B09a
P7D07a 2a 228.8 cM
23.4
28.0
36.4
P7A01d
20.8
P5F11h
M651d P7A01f
14.0
13.5 3.5 3.1 14.6
20.8
21.2
P9B07e P10C12a
P7G03e
P6B07g 20.7
P9B07d
P10D08f
18.1
P9B07b
Pcs1c 15.9
16.6
C356d
CSU360i
P1C05d C746b
12.9
P8H10c P10H08h
P8A02e P10H05d CSU410i P8C08i
P9C09a
14.6
31.1
P8A05b M891b 19.4 6.5 C356g 3.5 P3H07k P5H09l 3.4 P3B10c 16.8 10.7 CDSR94k 1.0 1.2 1b 1.6 116.2 cM 12.9
13.2
P7H04h
P2C06n
27.8
P3A04k
CSU742f
25.3 26.2
23.3
19.0
P6G04c P1C09g
15.6
P7A08g 16.4
17.6
12.5
22.2
20.5
19.4
Pca3b 23.6
27.4
P11B11f P10C12b
P6B06a P10H05b
23.0
16.4
20.7
19.6
20.7
13.9 4.0 6.3 4.7
P7G01d
16.0 P9H05f
12.1
P12C02d P2E04a
MS48x
P2C03d
P9H08h
P10H05c
11.3
16.1 P10F11d P11C07a
25.2 10.3 1.2 8.3 6.4
SB1541
CSU706b
18.7
P5G09c 2b 190.9 cM
P10D03a 2b 192.2 cM
P10H05f
18.5
1a 293.0 cM
CSU527e 12.4 P3C08c 1a 241.9 cM
P3E08i
CSU455d 12.7
26.7
P1D01i P8A05g
12.7 P9D10f
31.9 2.0
P9H05g P9H05e
24.7
14.7
17.2 2.9 5.2 5.0
30.7 P1D01h
P1B11b 13.3 P9A10c P10H12d 5.5 5.0
P2B11b P9A06d P9B06d CDSR7f
34.2 SB289d
P9D06f P2D11a CDSR7g
6.1 8.1 1.8 5.0
19.3
M891a P4E01b 13.0 P4A06e P4c06e CDSR94l
P3C01g 8.7 P7D12c P9D04d P1C03h 14.3 P1C03e P6A08e 5.5
P7H07k
14.1 3.7 7.5
21.3
23.9
12.5
8.9 P6H03a
CSU360l
8.8 7.6
16.8
11.0
24.8
5.7 6.5
13.4 3.8 5.4 2.2 7.3
P7C03e 13.5 P4C06d P10G06i 11.5 CSU539b CDSR94d
P8D04a 3a 222.4 cM
CDSR7j P7E03g
P6A08c P10C08a
8.9
P5D01m P3C01a
23.5
11.1 3.0 4.6 7.6
PSF11a P1C03d
13.7
P10F06e
7.2 1.5 3.3 6.0
P11D10c
16.9
P8D06c
24.1 P9F06j P9F06h C250d 5a, LOD = 3.17 15.5 9.4 P1D03h 5a, LOD = 4.20 1.4 P3G10a 5a, LOD = 3.18 12.3 3.6 P10C05d 7.8 4.1 P7B12f 8.8 9.9 M737d 8.4 10.2 3.8 CDSR7a 4b 19.5 93.7 cM
P8D06e PSH07e P12E06c
P1D04d P1D04i P1D03f P1D03g P10C05a P10G02k M737b
P7B12g 4a 141.6 cM
6.9 2.7 2.7 5.7 3.1
P1D03a P7C04f P4G04h P10G12b SB289c 34.9 C250b
P10H12c 4b 74.9 cM
12.5
14.0 1.9 1.9 3.5 2.4 2.0 7.1
3b 153.2 cM
P7H01d 4a 200.2 cM
P5H07d P9A10e P11D10e P5H02e P3G08g
16.8 P1D04a P10B12c 27.9
C250c 4b, LOD–4.20
P1A09b 5b 57.2 cM
P5D10g P3F02d CSU460j P7C04g P4B06c P4G04f CSU479g P1D03c P10D04e P3G10c CDSR7i P9D02c M737e P6A06b P10C05f P10B12a
21.1 P4G04b
33.2
P4E03b 12.8 P9B03h 16.7 M248b 5a 186.0 cM
Fig. 3.3 (continued)
CSU351aS
P1B11d
32.3
P7A03g
P7C04h
P9A10i 13.5
P8D04b
17.6
21.9
P9F06i P8G08g P1D03b
11.6 P9D04b
P6A08b
P7D12g
Pca2d
3 Cenchrus
45
P10B12d
CSU351b
P1F011
P9E10g
P10F12h
30.1 C147d
P10G02b P10G07h CDSR7c 1.5 2.9 P7C04c 10.4 P1C01b P3F02c CSU460h 10.7 P9A10j
7.2
15.2 14.5
P6H01b
16.4 P4F01a P8B08a Sub31e
5.8 7.7
P10F04c P3B11d
17.0
P6A08d
P7G10e P9F02c
Sub31f P10D08h
P9G09d
9.6 3.7 2.8
P7H07i P8C02c
14.0 25.3 P7H08c
HHU27a M466a
P8C08h 7b 78.8 cM
8.0 5.6 7.7 5.7
P10C11h P10C11e P9C04a P7E03j P3G11h P3G11b
3.7
P6D01b
P3G11l P3G11a
3.4 3.5
P2B07b P9A08c P10B07c
9.9 P10C11c
12.6 7.3
16.5
P7H09d
P10C11g 10b 48.0 cM
P3A07e P13G07a 8a 59.6 cM
P1F02a 9a 67.9 cM
11.7 P6E08g P6C04c 11a 48.2 cM
3.0
4.2 7.8 8.0 3.8
P9A08g P2B07c
P7H09c M568c
P1H11b 14.5 P9A08k P2B07f
P9C04i
P9C04g 11b 46.4 cM
7.1
P9A08i
21.4
23.4
P2F07c
M568a 11b 34.3 cM
22.6 P8G09e P3E01g CSU428e
9.5 P4D08b 17.8
P1E05i P1H04d
P1F12b P4F02b
14 83.5 cM
13 100.6 cM
Fig. 3.3 (continued)
20.3
P3B11g 21.8
26.5
3.2
2.5
16 57.6 cM
P4D08c 25.0
26.7 P10H08e
9.6 P4E12f 17 54.2 cM
P8C02d 18 48.5 cM
7.6
P2C02d P7G01c
11.9 P7B03a 12b 75.7 cM
P6C10g P10A08f
17.7
C250e 23.0
P1B07e
P7D12f
P6B07c P9B09d
14.9 P1H04c
15 69.3 cM CSU525n
Sub31b
23.0 P10F11e
23.6 P10D08a
12a 84.2 cM
16.0
9.3
36.1
P6G04b
23.7
11.0
18.5
P13F03d RZ_478_2
P10E03c
13.3 P9G04f
13.9
12.1
P1H08e
CSU413a
P11C07c P2A09e P9G04c
13.6
P9C04h
P6C07d
22.6
P10H3d
27.5
3.7
8.1
P7H05f P10H08i
Pca8a 9b 61.0 cM
17.3
18.3
11.8
P5H10h
P5D01d
2.6 2.3 13.0
M466f
P7A05f
P9A08e
8.8
1.5
14.2 8.4
P11F10d 15.6
P9E10f
P9C04f 11a 76.0 cM
21.7
P8F02f
17.2
24.6
9.1
24.6
26.1
CSU479i
Pca5a
P8G08i
P9H09i
P9E02h
17.6
9.0
10a 59.7 cM
P9H09g
2.8 2.1 5.9 20.2
14.2
P2F06e 8b 63.2 cM
16.6
24.4 P7H09f
P9C10b P9c10c P11B11d C746c P1C05a
P8C03c 8a 82.1 cM
P6H01a
P6E08f 21.1
CSU423d
CSU781b 8b 16.9 cM
P5G10b P4D05h Pca5c
28.2
21.7
P12C05b
P3F08e 12.4
9.6
28.0
16.8
PAp01 P8C08j P3A07g
25.1
M466b Pcs4a
P8H05h
7.3
P4D05c 8.1 2.6
19.7
P3A07a 16.9
19.5 P3E01d
12.3 CSU423f
6.3 5.2
18.7 P4D05e
23.4
2.1 8.6 1.4
Pcs5b 7a 100.5 cM
P10E11a
CSU410b
CSU410f
P8H05i
18.8
P8F03a
M812g 6a 131.2 cM
SB1773e
CDSR94a 7a 74.4 cM
8.5
CSU781c 2a, LOD-4.90 7b 72.9 cM
6a 111.6 cM
22.5
P1H02f 5b 171.4 cM
P9F11f
17.6
P8D08b
P8C06g
21.8
P8B12b
P4B11b
P4F01c P8B08c P10D08i
Pcs4d P7E10f P7G12b
18.8
17.0
15.4
15.9
6.2 P6C02c
P1H11a P7G04a 6b 76.8 cM
P4D05f 8.3
14.5
16.4
24.1
M466c
P4D05d
M568b
P9H09c
HHU27d
15.8
15.8
21.5
8.2
9.9
P1F08B
HHU27b Pcs2b SB1773d
15.5
26.4
21.9
SB1773f 8.1
6.4 1.7
26.4
18.6
11.5 5.8 1.1 5.0 8.5
7.1
M869d 13.4
22.8
P1D03d
CDSR7e 5a 22.3 cM
P10G03i
13.4
24.4
22.3
25.8 M869b 19 46.0 cM
P1D02k 22.7 C250f 20 45.7 cM
46
S. Goel et al.
P7E03m
CSU428a 18.4
19.9 4.4 1.7
P4G04d P8B04f P7C06g
P12E05a P5H01a 22.0
P5H01b P12E05b
6.1
P4G01l P4G01e
21.8
18.4 RZ166c 21 44.4 cM
4.4 10.4
P8C02e 22 40.4 cM
P2C03f
15.8 Pca12e 23 32.9 cM
P3E09c 6.4 5.8
P5D01c
2.4
14.0
18.2 P5H10a
P8A07d
P10A08h
P8G01g 17.1
P9E02i RZ478b P1B07f
24 30.4 cM
25.0
24.6
15.1
P1A04c
P8C08e 25 29.1 cM
18.1
P11F08c 26 27.0 cM
P6A07b P8A07j P3E09e P8H11a
1.5 3.5 8.3
15.3
P5H08c M443b
M180a
P9H09h 10.6 5.5
P3B04b P7C07e
26.3 RZ166f 25 82.7 cM
26.6
P7A05k
P1C12d
8.4 7.4 1.3 9.5
P11F08g P10H07g P9H02h
M180f 27 26.6 cM
P12B03b
RG463a
11.8 P10F12c
26.5
24.8
23.7
P8H07d 22 131.1 cM
CSU539d
CSU705c
P6G02e
29 24.8 cM
8.1
22.8
28.1 CSU377l 21.3 P8D02c
5.1 4.6 4.4 2.5 5.5
17.9
CDSR18b 36 50.1 cM
36.0
CSU527a
11.7 P7D12d
M869c 38 40.4 cM
8.8 4.3
29.5
P8G09b P8G09f P8H06a
C250g 18.3
P1E06b 35 108.1 cM
SB41a 42 29.5 cM
CSU413c 39 39.1 cM
7.0 5.0
P9B03g 43 27.3 cM
9.9
P10G2g M834c
18.2
7.3
P7D12i P1E09g
M869e 41 34.2 cM
P2D06b P12F04n
P1A10a
P9H08e 13.8 P12D02c
24.1
12.6 P1F12c 45 26.4 cM
M248c 46 24.1 cM
P8C02b
19.8 CSU460c 47 19.8 cM
P8C02b
P10E11b
SubEe P4E03h
CSU409g 14.3
12.6
P6H09d 40 37.8 cM
P9H08j
P3C04d 44 27.1 cM
CSU399e 16.4 8.0
Pca8d 16.3
15.1
14.2 C250h
15.8
P4H07a
19.2
P9G04d 33 13.4 cM
M466d
P9H10h 19.9
P7G10c 15.9
P2A06f 37 48.0 cM
P7A05c 32 18.1 cM
9.8 P9H09d
13.2
25.6
P9H09b
P6G10l P6B12c P9G01i
27.3
P12B03f
13.4
17.2
12.1 9.3
P10F12f P8H07c P7D05c P12C03e P8H04f P1D02j
P7A05j 31 20.8 cM
11.3
M568e
P3H12d
C250k
6.3
14.2
32.3
30 23.7 cM
P2A09d P3G08f
30.7
RZ166d
CSU706e
P1F01m
P2C02e 18.1
20.8
18.6 P7A09c 28 26.5 cM
P4G01m
P7C12c
18.9 P12C05a 48 18.9 cM
15.5 P9E02k 49 15.5 cM
7.3
P7G01a P7E03k
50 7.3 cM
P1A02c P6G05a 51 6.1 cM
6.1
P8G01h 29.0 P12D02f 34 241.2 cM
Fig. 3.3 Maternal (white linkage groups) and paternal (black linkage groups) RFLP maps of Pennisetum ciliare. Framework map (LOD > 2.0) markers and map distances (Kosambi map units) are shown to the right and left of the horizontal lines, respectively
cDNAs and gDNAs from across the Poaceae were hybridized to 87 F1 hybrids derived from a cross between heterozygous sexual genotype with another highly heterozygous apomictic genotype. The 460 polymorphic probes yielded segregation data for 400 single dose restriction fragments (SDRF) in female parent and 298 SDRF in male parent. MAPMAKER EXP v3.0 assembled 322 SDRFs into 47 linkage groups spanning over 3,464 cm in the mater-
nal parent with an average marker interval of 10.8 cm, while 78 SDRFs did not show any linkage. In the paternal map, 245 SDRFs were assembled into 42 linkage groups spanning over 2,757 cm with an average marker interval of 11.3, while 53 SDRFs did not show any linkage. These linkage maps give an overall estimate of 4,309 Centi Mozgan and 3,679 Centi Mozgan maternal and paternal genome sizes, respectively. More refined genetic maps can be
3 Cenchrus
developed by inclusion of more markers, which will assist in locating quantitative trait loci (QTLs) controlling the major agronomically important traits.
3.10 BAC Libraries Roche et al. (2002) constructed BAC libraries from the apomictic line B-12-9. This buffelgrass bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) library contains 68,736 clones with an average insert size of 109 kb, which covers 4.8 haploid genome equivalents. These BAC clones will serve as a useful tool for more refined mapping of buffelgrass genome through the application of more advanced techniques such as FISH, which will ultimately help in resolving physical location of genome complexes.
3.11 Genetics and Molecular Mechanism of Apomixis in Buffelgrass The genus Cenchrus has been studied extensively due to the existing trait of apomixis and hence needs a special mention. This trait is promising and can play rich economic dividends, if deciphered. Studies focusing on this trait have led to interesting information in the genus Cenchrus. The discovery of sexual lines in C. ciliaris provides an opportunity to study the genetics of apomixis in this grass species. Taliaferro and Bashaw (1966) assayed the inheritance pattern of apomixis in selfed progenies of sexual buffelgrass (B-1s) and F1 progenies of a cross between sexual (B-1s) and two apomictic lines. It was concluded in this study that the gene controlling apomixis is dominant and sexuality is controlled by a gene epistatic to gene controlling apomixis. The genotype of apomictic plants will be “A-bb” and those for sexual will be “aabb,” suggesting that the sexual plant originated as a result of natural mutation of the dominant apomictic gene. A subsequent study by Sherwood et al. (1994) from selfing and intercrossing of sexual B-2s lines and progeny of open-pollinated sexual B-2s and other two apomictic lines concluded that inheritance pattern in buffelgrass shows two loci tetrasomic model. These authors also suggested that the sexual line used by Taliaferro and Bashaw in 1966 was highly sexual but facultatively apomictic because selfing of these lines
47
provided progenies segregating for sexuality and apomixis, although results of such crosses do not seem to be compatible with the models of disomic and allotetrasomic inheritance of apospory locus (Gustine et al. 1997). Segregation analysis of isozyme, protein, and RAPD markers within half-sib progenies of both open-pollinated sexual and apomictic lines by Gustine et al. (1996) does not reveal any marker co-segregating with apospory, although subsequent bulked segregant analysis using RAPD markers in two populations raised through crossing of sexual B-2s apomictic Higgins and B-2s B-12-9 identified two RAPD markers (J16-800, M02-680) tightly linked to aposporus locus (Gustine et al. 1997). Ozias-Akins et al. (1998) reported 12 co-segregating SCAR markers linked to apomixis in Pennisetum squamulatum. Roche et al. (1999) analyzed these markers in two Cenchrus populations raised earlier by Gustine et al. (1997). Out of these 12 markers, 9 markers (UGT-197, P16R, Q8M, U12H, V4, X18R, A10H, C4, and 07M) and another putative marker C16 were found to be associated only with aposporous mode of reproduction in buffelgrass populations. All markers are segregated as dominant locus and these markers are also conserved between P. squamulatum and apomictic C. ciliaris. They concluded that all the markers clustered together at what was called “apospory specific genomic region (ASGR)”. ASGR has been shown to be hemizygous with suppressed recombination in P. squamulatum (Ozias-Akins et al. 1998). Jessup et al. (2002) reported two markers in C. ciliaris, HHU27 and UGT-197, flanking the aposporus locus at a distance of 1.4 cm and 10.7 cm, respectively, although Goel et al. (2006) did not find any recombination between these markers and ASGR in a population of 94 individuals from a cross between P. glaucum (induced tetraploid, 2n ¼ 28) and P. squamulatum (2n ¼ 56). Roche et al. (2002) isolated the BAC clones from the library of two apomictic grasses, P. squamulatum and C. ciliaris, using six low copy SCAR markers tightly linked with ASGR. Fingerprinting analysis of the BAC clones indicates that the markers, although clustered together in a single genomic region, are duplicated several times within the ASGR in both the species (Roche et al. 2002). FISH analysis using the BAC clones containing SCAR markers as probes confirmed the results from the earlier genetic and
48
molecular mapping that apomixis is controlled by a single dominant, hemizygous locus in both P. squamulatum and C. ciliaris (Goel et al. 2003; Akiyama et al. 2005). The FISH results revealed that ASGR in C. ciliaris is located on the short arm, close to the centromere of a chromosome that also contains the 18S rDNA locus (Goel et al. 2003; Akiyama et al. 2005). The ASGR carrying chromosome does not appear to have a morphologically similar chromosome in C. ciliaris genome. Despite its difference in morphology, ASGR carrying chromosome pairs with other chromosomes during meiosis I forms a quadrivalent (Akiyama et al. 2005). This suggests that ASGR carrying chromosome have at least one homeologous chromosome that may undergo synapsis and recombination during meiosis (Akiyama et al. 2005). Physical mapping studies also suggest that suppression of recombination is mainly due to hemizygocity of ASGR (Goel et al. 2006). Lack of recombination in ASGR hampered the construction of a genetic map and further isolation of novel genes controlling the apomixis in buffelgrass because it is unlikely that further recombination studies will provide a finer map of ASGR (Akiyama et al. 2005). An alternative approach to identify the apomictic genes in C. ciliaris has been to analyze genes differentially expressed during the sexual and apomictic reproduction (Vielle-Calzda et al.1996). Two cDNA clones (Pca-2 and Pca-3) were found to be expressed specifically in apomictic ovaries, one clone (Pca-2) only in sexual ovaries and one fragment (Pca-1) in both sexual and apomictic ovaries. Two more genes Pca 21 and Pca 24 that expressed preferentially (Pca 21) and specifically (Pca 24) in apomictic ovaries have been isolated through subtracted cDNA microarray analysis (Singh et al. 2007). Pca 21 shows homology with two wheat genes expressed specifically in flowers and in inflorescence and Pca 24 with a maize cDNA that encode putative CHCH (coiled-coil-helix–coiledcoil-helix) gene, which have developmental roles (Singh et al. 2007), but none of the genes have yet shown to be linked with ASGR in buffelgrass (OziasAkins et al. 2003; Singh et al. 2007). These results show that even the gene expression is conserved between sexual and apomictic ovaries. It may be because of the same pattern of megaspore mother cell differentiation and meiosis in sexual and aposporus ovules up to the tetrad stage (Vielle-Calzada et al. 1996).
S. Goel et al.
3.12 Genomic Database The NCBI database has the record of 87 core nucleotide sequences of Cenchrus (36 of C. ciliaris, 12 of C. echinatus, 9 of C. setiger, 9 of C. pilosus, 8 of C. myosuroides, 5 of C. calyculatus, 4 of C. incertus, 2 of C. argimonoides and 2 of C. brownii), 21,729 expressed sequence tag (EST), 2,145 genome survey sequence (GSS) starting from Genebank accession no ED544199 to ED 546344 and 45 amino acid sequences (28 of C. ciliaris, 9 of C. echinatus and 8 of C. pilosus). The core nucleotide sequences consist of published and unpublished diverse sequences ranging from apomixis-associated mRNA, tRNA, ribosomal protein gene, chloroplast ndhF gene, knotted 1 gene, rbcL, phytochrome B genes to signaling proteinlike mRNA sequences. Out of 36 nucleotide sequences in C. ciliaris, 14 are of apomoixis-associated mRNA submitted by Gustine et al. (1996), Conner et al. (2008), and Singh et al. (2007), and six are of chloroplast marker genes ndhF (Giussani et al. 2001) and knotted 1 (Doust et al. 2007) . The unpublished 21,729 ESTs in the database represent the total transcriptome of the apomictic pistils of C. ciliaris, submitted by A. H. Paterson and S. R. Schulze, Plant Genome Mapping Laboratory, University of Georgia. In addition to these ESTs, A. Hussey Mark submitted eight ESTs that show differential expression between apomictic and sexual ovaries in P. ciliare. These sequences appear in GeneBank, EMBL and DDBJ under the accession numbers U65082, U65383, U65384, U65385, U65386, U65387, U65388, and U65389 (VielleCalzada et al. 1996). GSS data in the GeneBank are the short-gun sequenced high quality BAC clone reads of “ASGR” of C. ciliaris submitted by Peggy Ozias-Akins, University of Georgia, Tifton Campus. These sequences are also available in FUNGEN ASGR database at the web portal http://asgr.uga.edu (Conner et al. 2008). After assembling these sequences in contigs, BLASTX analysis with the Uniport TrEMBL database shows 25 sequence contigs from C. ciliaris similar to proteins with diverse functions reported from other species (Conner et al. 2008). These putative protein coding regions were mostly from the BACs mapped to low copy region of ASGR. The EMBL database has 26,011 nucleotide sequence entry out of which 63 sequences are of
3 Cenchrus
coding sequence. This database also has 178 amino acid sequence entry. These database also include the sequences of the related genus of Cenchrus and nucleotide sequences of the pathogens, which infects these plants.
3.13 Germplasm Banks National Bureau of Plant Genetic Resources (NBPGR), New Delhi, is the nodal organization in India for exchange, quarantine, collection, conservation, evaluation, and the systematic documentation of plant genetic resources. The genebanks of NBPGR and its regional research centers including Indian Grassland and Fodder Research Institute (IGFRI), Jansi, Central Arid Zone Research Institute, Jodhpur, and Agricultural Research Institute, Bikaner, conserve the germplasm collected from different regions of the world, and the samples of the conserved germplasm are made available to the interested sectors through Germplasm Exchange Division of NBPGR. A total 750 accessions of wild species of the genera Pennisetum and Cenchrus, assembled from 50 countries are conserved at the genebank of ICRISAT (India). Many of the wild relatives have evolved surviving drought, floods, extreme heat and cold, and in the process, they have become adapted or developed resistance to the pests and diseases, which cause heavy losses to the crops. These accessions can be a valuable source for research and development. International Livestock Research Institute (ILRI) situated in Kenya and Ethiopia held 294 accessions of Cenchrus. Most of the accessions were collected from the tropical African countries and are predominated by C. ciliaris. The list of germplasm held at this institute can be accessed through the website http:// www.ilri.org/forage/Cenchrus.pdf. The National Germplasm Resources Laboratory, Beltsville, Maryland (GRIN, USDA), has listed 600 accessions of P. ciliare (syn. C. ciliaris) and 12 accessions of other species of Cenchrus available in its genebank. GRIN provides information of the accessions and its availability for distribution. AusPGRIS – the Australian Plant Genetic Resource Information Service holds 453 accessions of Cenchrus collected from 33 countries of the world. The accessions represent ten species; however, the number of
49
C. ciliaris accessions predominates. The list of germplasm hold can be accessed through the website http:// www2.dpi.qld.gov.au/extra/asp/auspgris/. It provides passport information on germplasm collections related to the identity, origin, characteristics, and evaluation of accessions held. Germplasm samples are conserved under long-term storage conditions and made available throughout the world for research, breeding, and conservation. Genetic Resources Program of the International Centre for Tropical Agriculture (CIAT) is another genebank, which is among the top germplasm holdings of tropical forages obtained or collected from over 141 countries. Germplasms are conserved under an agreement with the International Treaty on Plant Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture of the FAO. The genebank has listed 21 accessions of different species of Cenchrus available for distribution. The accessions can be accessed through the website http:// www.ciat.cgiar.org/urg. A total of 444 accessions of different species of Cenchrus have been listed the Genetic Resources Unit of the Institute of Grassland and Environmental Research (IGER). This unit is primarily concerned with the collection, storage, characterization, and documentation of temperate forage grasses and legumes. IGER is also responsible for the European Central Crop Databases for Lolium (rye-grass) and Trifolium repens (white clover), and the information of the crops can be accessed from IGER’s web page.
3.14 Potential and Pitfalls Because of its low cost of establishment in low nutrient habitats and high forage production and relative resistance to drought conditions and overgrazing, C. ciliaris serves as an important fodder grass for the arid and semiarid tropical regions of the world. It has also been reported that the biomass production and water use efficiency of this grass is better than other arid zone grasses like Lasiurus scindicus, Panicum turgidum, and Coelachyrum piercei (Osman et al. 2008). Another aspect prevailing in the genus Cenchrus is the apospory trait. At the first conference on apomixis held in September 1995 at the College Station of the Texas A&M University, it was stated that “harnessing apomixis genes for plant improvement
50
offers the potential for quantum in agriculture production – an ‘asexual revolution’, the benefits of which could dwarf those of green revolution,” C. ciliaris along with a relative species P. squamulatum is more extensively studied to harness the benefit of apomixis mechanism. Most studies in the genus Cenchrus has been conducted considering economic impacts limiting most studies to C. ciliaris and little has been done to study other species in genus. This leaves a huge scope to enrich the information in other species of this genus. Many species in genus Cenchrus are potential invasive weeds threatening many keystone habitats of many plants and animal species. More in-depth knowledge of these species will also be helpful in controlling spread of these weeds. In conclusion, C. ciliaris is a crop, which has not gone through the bottleneck of domestication and still open for exploitation of naturally occurring variation in the species, but occurrence of both sexual and apomictic genotypes provide an excellent opportunity to exploit the variation occurring in other closely related species from the genus. For exploiting these species, a systematic study involving various aspects and carried out on all the species is the need of hour.
References Ahsan SMN, Vahidy AA, Ali SI (1994) Chromosome numbers and incidence of polyploidy in Panicoideae (Poaceae) from Pakistan. Ann MO Bot Gard 81:775–783 Akiyama Y, Hanna WN, Ozias-Akins P (2005) High-resolution physical mapping reveals that the apospory-specific genomic region (ASGR) in Cenchrus ciliaris is located on a heterochromatic and hemizygous region of a single chromosome. Theor Appl Genet 111:1042–1051 Aliscioni SS, Giussani LM, Zuloaga FO, Kellog EA (2003) A molecular phylogeny of Panicum (Poaceae: Paniceae): tests of monophyly and phylogenetic placement within the Panicoideae. Am J Bot 90(5):796–821 Arshad M, Ashraf MY, Ahamad M, Zaman F (2007) Morphogenetic variability potential of Cenchrus ciliaris L., from Cholistan desert, Pakistan. Pak J Bot 39(5):1481–1488 AusPGRIS (2003) Australian plant genetic resource information service. http://www2.dpi.qld.gov.au/extra/asp/auspgris/. Accessed 20 Apr 2009 Bashaw EC (1962) Apomixis and sexuality in buffelgrass. Crop Sci 2:412–415 Bashaw EC, Hignight KW (1990) Gene transfer in apomictic buffelgrass through fertilization of an unreduced egg. Crop Sci 30:571–575
S. Goel et al. Bogdan AV (1977) Tropical pastures and fodder plants. Longman, London, UK Chandra A, Dubey A (2007) Transferability of STS markers for studying genetic diversity within the genus Cenchrus (Poaceae). Curr Sci 92:961–967 Chandra A, Dubey A (2008) Evaluation of genus Cenchrus based on malondialdehyde, proline content, specific leaf area and carbon isotope discrimination for drought tolerance and divergence of species. Acta Physiol Plant 30:53–61 Chen C-H, Kuoh C-S (2004) Cenchrus ciliaris L., a newly naturalized grass in Taiwan. Taiwania 49(4):232–236 Clayton WD, Harman KT, Williamson H (2006 onwards) GrassBase – the online world grass flora. http://www.kew.org/ data/grasses-db.html. Accessed 3 Feb 2009 Conner JA, Goel S, Gunawan G, Marie-Michele C-P, Virgil Ed J, Chun L, Haiming W, Lee HP, John EM, Jeremy D, Lixing Y, Jeffrey LB, Patricia EK, Ozias-Akins P (2008) Sequence analysis of bacterial artificial chromosome clones from the apospory-specific genomic region of Pennisetum and Cenchrus. Plant Physiol 147:1396–1411 Cook BG, Pengelly BC, Brown SD, Donnelly JL, Eagles DA, Franco MA, Hanson J, Mullen BF, Partridge IJ, Peters M, Schultze-Kraft R (2005) Tropical forages: an interactive selection tool. CSIRO, DPI&F (Qld), CIAT and ILRI, Brisbane, Australia. http://www.tropicalforages.info/. Accessed 16 Mar 2009 Correlld S, Johnston MC (1970) Manual of the vascular plants of Texas. Texas Research Foundation, Renner, TX, USA Cox JR, Martin-R MH, Ibarra-F FA, Fourie JH, Rethman JFG, Wilcox DG (1988) The influence of climate and soils on the distribution of four African grasses. J Range Manag 41 (2):127–139 DDBJ: DNA Data Bank of Japan (2009). http://www.ddbj.nig. ac.jp/. Accessed 17 Apr 2009 DeLisle DG (1963) Taxonomy and distributon of the genus Cenchrus. Iowa State Coll J Sci 37:259 Doust AN, Kellogg EA (2002) Inflorescence diversification in the Panicoid “Bristle Grass” clade (Paniceae, Poaceae): evidence from molecular phylogenies and developmental morphology. Am J Bot 89(8):1203–1222 Doust AN, Penly AM, Jacobs SLW, Kellog EA (2007) Congruence, conflict, and polyploidization shown by nuclear and chloroplast markers in the monophyletic “Bristle Clade” (Paniceae, Panicoideae, Poaceae). Syst Bot 32(3):531–544 Duvall MR, Noll JD, Minn AH (2001) Phylogenetics of Paniceae (Poaceae). Am J Bot 88(11):1988–1992 EMBL-EBI Nucleotide Sequence Database (2009). http://www. ebi.ac.uk/embl/. Accessed 17 Apr 2009 Fisher WD, Bashaw EC, Holt EC (1954) Evidence of apomixis in Pennisetum ciliare and Cenchrus setigerus. Agron J 46:401–404 Franklin KA, Lyons K, Nagler PL, Lampkin D (2006) Buffelgrass (Pennisetum ciliare) land conversion and productivity in the plains of Sonora, Mexico. Biol Conserv 127:62–71 Genetic Resources Program, International Centre for Tropical Agriculture (CIAT) (2009). http://isa.ciat.cgiar.org/urg. Accessed 20 Apr 2009 Giussani LM, Nchez JHC-S, Zuloaga FO, Kellogg EA (2001) A molecular phylogeny of the grass subfamily Panicoideae (Poaceae) shows multiple origins of C4 photosynthesis. Am J Bot 88(11):1993–2012
3 Cenchrus Goel S, Chen Z, Conner JA, Akiyama Y, Hanna WW, OziasAkins P (2006) Comparative physical mapping of the apospory-specific genomic region in two apomictic grasses: Pennisetum squamulatum and Cenchrus ciliaris. Genetics 173:389–400 Goel S, Chen Z, Akiyama Y, Conner JA, Basu M, Gustavo G, Hanna WW, Ozias-Akins P (2003) Delineation by fluorescence in situ hybridization of a single hemizygous chromosomal region associated with aposporous embryo sac formation in Pennisetum squamulatum and Cenchrus ciliaris. Genetics 163:1069–1082 Griffa SDD, Ribotta A, Castelli SL, Munoz N, Colomba EL, Luna C, Grunberg K, Biderbost E (2006) Molecular genetic discrimination of Buffel grass genotypes and F1 hybrids for breeding purposes using amplified fragment length polymorphism analyses. Grass Forage Sci 61:454–458 Gustine DL, Sherwood RT, Gounaris Y, Huff D (1996) Isozyme, protein, and markers within a half-sib family of buffelgrass. Crop Sci 36:723–727 Gustine DL, Sherwood RT, Huff D (1997) Apospory-linked molecular markers in buffelgrass. Crop Sci 37:947–951 Gutierrez-Ozuna R, Eguiarte LE, Molina-Freaner F (2009) Genotypic diversity among pasture and roadside populations of the invasive buffelgrass (Pennisetum ciliare L. Link) in north-western Mexico. J Arid Environ 73:26–32 Hignight KW, Bashaw EC, Hussey MA (1991) Cytological and morphological diversity of native apomictic buffelgrass, Pennisetum ciliare (L.) Link. Bot Gaz 152(2): 214–218 Ibarra-F FA, Cox JR, Martin-R MH, Crowl TA, Call CA (1995) Predicting buffelgrass survival across a geographical and environmental gradient. J Range Manag 48:53–59 ILRI-International Livestock Research Institute (2009). http:// www.ilri.org/. Accessed 20 Apr 2009 International Crops Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics (ICRISAT). http://www.icrisat.org/. Accessed 20 Apr 2009 Jauhar PP (1981) Cytogenetics and breeding of pearl millet and related species. Alan R. Liss, New York Jessup RW, Burson BL, Paterson AH, Hussey MA (2000) Breeding apomictic forage grasses: Molecular strategies. Proceedings of the 55th southern pasture and forage crop conference, Raleigh, NC, USA Jessup RW, Burson BL, Burow GB, Wang YW, Hussey MA (2002) Disomic inheritance, suppressed recombination, and allelic interactions govern apospory in buffelgrass as revealed by genome mapping. Crop Sci 42:1688–1694 Jessup RW, Burson BL, Burow GB, Wang YW (2003) Segmental allotetraploidy and allelic interactions in buffelgrass (Pennisetum ciliare (L.) Link syn. Cenchrus ciliaris L.) as revealed by genome mapping. Genome 46:304–313 Kellogg EA, Aliscioni SS, Morrone O, Pensiero J, Zuloaga FO (2009) A phylogeny of Setaria (Poaceae, Panicoideae, Paniceae) and related genera based on the chloroplast gene ndhF. Int J Plant Sci 170(1):117–131 Martel E, Poncet V, Lamy F, Siljak-Yakovlev S, Lejeune B, Sarr A (2004) Chromosome evolution of Pennisetum species (Poaceae): implications of ITS phylogeny. Plant Syst Evol 249:139–149 Martin-R M, Cox JR, Ibarra-F FA (1995) Climatic effects on buffelgrass productivity in the Sonoran Desert. J Range Manag 48:60–63
51 Mnif L, Belgacem AO, Cortina J (2005) A comparative analysis of establishment of Cenchrus ciliaris provenances in arid zone of Tunisia. Arid Land Res Manag 19:341–351 Morrone O, Escobar A, Zuloaga FO (2006) Chromosome studies in American Panicoideae (Poaceae). Ann Mo Bot Gard 93:647–657 National Bureau of Plant Genetic Resources (NBPGR). http:// www.nbpgr.ernet.in/. Accessed 20 Apr 2009 NCBI GenBank. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/Genbank/. Accessed 17 Apr 2009 Osman AE, Makawi M, Ahmed R (2008) Potential of indigenous desert grasses of the Arabian Peninsula for forage production in a water-scare region. Grass Forage Sci 63: 495–503 Ozias-Akins P, Roche D, Hanna WW (1998) Tight clustering and hemizygocity of apomixis-linked molecular markers in Pennisetum squamulatum implies genetic control of apospory by a divergent locus that may have no allelic form in sexual genotypes. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 95:5127–5132 Ozias-Akins P, Akiyama Y, Hanna WW (2003) Molecular characterization of the genomic region linked with apomixis in Pennisetum/Cenchrus. Funct Integr Genomics 3:94–104 Quattrocchi U (2008) CRC world dictionary of grasses. Taylor & Francis Group, Boca Raton, London, New York Read JC, Bashaw EC (1969) Cytotaxonomic relationships and the role of apomixis in speciation in buffelgrass and birdwoodgrass. Crop Sci 9(6):805–806 Roche D, Cong P, Sherwood RT, Ozias-Akins P (1999) An apospory-specific genomic region is conserved between buffelgrass (Cenchrus ciliaris) and Pennisetum squamulatum Fresen. Plant J 19(2):203–208 Roche D, Conner JA, Budiman MA, Frisch D, Wing R, Hanna WW, Ozias-Akins P (2002) Construction of BAC libraries from two apomictic grasses to study the microcolinearity of their apospory-specific genomic regions. Theor Appl Genet 104:804–812 Sherwood RT, Berg CC, Young BA (1994) Inheritance of apospory in buffelgrass. Crop Sci 34:1490–1494 Singh M, Burson BL, Finlayson SA (2007) Isolation of candidate genes for apomictic development in buffelgrass (Pennisetum ciliare). Plant Mol Biol 64:673–682 Stieber MT, Wipff JK (2000) Cenchrus L. http://herbarium.usu. edu/webmanual/info2.asp?name¼Cenchrus_longispinus&type¼treatment. Accessed 25 Mar 2009 Suttie JM, Reynold SG, Batello C (2005) Grasslands of the world. Food and Agriculture Organisation, Rome, Italy Snyder LA, Hernandez AR, Warmke HE (1955) The mechanism of apomixis in Pennisetum ciliare. Bot Gaz 116:209–221 Taliaferro CM, Bashaw EC (1966) Inheritance and control of apomixis in breeding buffelgrass, Pennisetum ciliare. Crop Sci 6:473–476 Tix D (2000) Cenchrus ciliaris Invasion and Control in Southwestern U.S. Grasslands and Shrublands. http://horticulture. cfans.umn.edu/vd/h5015/00papers/tix.htm. Accessed 25 Mar 2009 Tu M, Randall JM, Rice B (2002) Element stewardship abstract for Cenchrus ciliaris L.(African foxtail, buffelgrass, anjangrass). http://www.imapinvasives.org/GIST/ESA/esapages/ documnts/cenccil.pdf. Accessed 25 Mar 2009 Tunyalee M (2000) Cenchrus ciliaris (syn. Pennisetum ciliare L. Link) (buffelgrass, anjagrass, African foxtail grass).
52 Wildland invasive species program, the nature conservancy. http://www.invasive.org/gist/alert/alrtcenc.html. Accessed 13 Apr 2009 USDA (2009) A National Genetic Resources Program. Germplasm resources information network – (GRIN). National Germplasm Resources Laboratory, Beltsville, Maryland, USA. http://www.invasive.org/gist/alert/alrtcenc.html. Accessed 3 Feb 2009 Vielle-Calzada J-P, Nuccio ML, MdA B, Thomas TL, Burson BL, Hussey MA, Wing RA (1996) Comparative gene expression in sexual apomictic ovaries of Pennisetum ciliare (L.) Link. Plant Mol Biol 32:1085–1092
S. Goel et al. Vij SP, Chaudhary JD (1981) Cytological investigation in three species of Cenchrus L. (Gramineae). Cytologia 46: 661–669 Weed Management Guide (2008) Buffelgrass (Cenchrus ciliaris). http://www.weedscrc.org.au/documents/wmg_buffel%20grass.pdf. Accessed Mar 2009 Young BA, Sherwood RT, Bashaw EC (1979) Cleared-pistil and thick sectioning techniques for detecting aposporous apomixis in grasses. Can J Bot 57:1668–1672 Zhang J, Kirkham MB (1994) Drought-stress-induced changes in activities of superoxide dismutase, catalase, and peroxidase in wheat species. Plant Cell Physiol 35(5):785–791
Chapter 4
Cynodon Yanqi Wu
4.1 Introduction Cynodon L. C. Rich. is a small genus of warm-season species in the tribe Cynodonteae, subfamily Chloridoideae of the grass family Poaceae (Gramineae). Though small in number of species, the genus contains species that are economically immensely important as grazed or stored forages, for soil stabilization, and turf. The focus of this chapter is on use of Cynodon species for forage. Although Cynodon species have incidentally provided forage for herbivores for many centuries, it was not until the middle of the twentieth century that large scale monoculture use developed to provide forage for domesticated livestock. This development was in the southern USA and occurred in large measure due to breeding gains, leading to widely adapted cultivars with greatly enhanced forage yield potential. The most important of the Cynodon species as a forage is C. dactylon (L.) Pers. This species consists of six taxonomic varieties that vary substantially in magnitude of natural distribution, genetic diversity, and value for forage. The taxon of greatest importance is C. dactylon (L.) Pers. var. dactylon. This taxon is distributed across all continents and on most ocean islands between latitudes of approximately 45 North and South. It is enormously polymorphic with forms adapted to a range of climatic and edaphic conditions. It is generally known as “common bermudagrass” because of its prevalence.
Y. Wu Department of Plant and Soil Sciences, Oklahoma State University, 368 Ag Hall, Stillwater, OK 74078, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
Common bermudagrass was introduced to colonial America at least by the mid-1700s and spread rapidly with the development of agriculture initially in the southeast and subsequently in southcentral and southwest regions. Early reactions of farmers to bermudagrass were mixed as the grass was a serious weed in row crops, especially cotton (Nelson and Burns 2006). Many southern and central states listed it as a noxious weed. It was not until the middle of the twentieth century that attitudes changed regarding its value to agriculture, and circumstances led to its widespread adoption as a cultivated pasture and hay crop. Harlan (1970) described “the development of C. dactylon var. dactylon as an improved hay and pasture grass suitable for intensive management as almost entirely an American phenomenon.” He cited several factors contributing to bermudagrass becoming a major perennial grass for animal grazing and hay production in the southern USA. Prominent among the factors was the release of “Coastal” bermudagrass in 1943. Coastal was developed by USDA-ARS Geneticist G.W. Burton at the Coastal Plains Experiment Station, Tifton, GA. Release of this high yielding variety coincided with other factors, leading to its widespread adoption in the southern USA. These factors included (1) a decrease in the cotton industry in the southern USA, (2) a concurrent increase in the cattle industry in the same region, and (3) greater availability of nitrogen fertilizer. These circumstances led to greatly increased research effort by state agricultural experiment stations and other research entities on the use of bermudagrass as a pasture and hay crop. The development of specialized sprig harvesting and planting equipment also increased the use of bermudagrass (Taliaferro et al. 2004a). Currently, forage bermudagrass is grown on about 10–12 million ha in the USA as a major
C. Kole (ed.), Wild Crop Relatives: Genomic and Breeding Resources, Millets and Grasses, DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-14255-0_4, # Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
53
54
perennial grass feed base for animal husbandry (Taliaferro et al. 2004). Bouton (2007) estimated the current economic value of the forage systems in the southeastern 14 States to be approximately US$11.6 billion annually, in which forage bermudagrass is a major component along with tall fescue [Festuca arundinacea Schreb., recently Schedonorus phoenix (Scop.) Holub] and bahiagrass (Paspalum notatum Flugge). The remainder of this chapter focuses on the taxonomy, distribution, origin and evolution, and germplasm conservation of C. dactylon var. dactylon and related species relative to their use in the development of new forage cultivars.
4.2 Basic Botany of the Species 4.2.1 Taxonomy, Morphology, and Distribution The genus Cynodon consists of nine species in the revised taxonomic classification of Harlan et al. (1970b). The species are C. aethiopicus Clayton et Harlan, C. arcuatus J. S. Presl ex C. B. Presl, C. barberi Rang. Et Tad., C. dactylon (L.) Pers., C. incompletus Nees, C. nlemfuensis Vanderyst, C. plectostachyus (K. Schum.) Pilg., and C. transvaalensis Burtt-Davy (de Wet and Harlan 1970). de Wet and Harlan (1970) did not include C. x magennisii in the revised system while they listed the taxon as a species in “A guide to the species of Cynodon (Gramineae)” (Harlan et al. 1970b). C. x magennisii is a naturally occurring triploid hybrid between C. dactylon and C. transvaalensis (Harlan et al. 1970a). Clayton et al. (2009) lists 10 Cynodon species in Kew’s online grass database. In this list, C. coursii is ranked as a species, while it was a variety of C. dactylon in the classification of Harlan et al. (1970b); C. radiatus Roth ex Roem. and Schult was described as an annual species and as a synonym of C. arcuatus (Clayton and Harman 2002), while Harlan et al. (1970b) described it as a perennial. C. parviglumis Ohwi is listed as a species by Clayton et al. (2009) but not described by Harlan et al. (1970b). C. aethiopicus is a perennial sod-forming species without rhizomes (Harlan et al. 1970b). The species has low tolerance to freezing temperatures. Its inflorescence is composed of one to three whorls of
Y. Wu
racemes, which usually are dark red in color, similar to those of C. plectostachyus, but relatively smaller. Bright red racemes are digitate from a few to 15, with each raceme being straight and 4–8 cm in length. Spikelets are sessile, normally two rows on a rachis. Glumes are persistent and similar but about 3/4 spikelet length. Florets are laterally compressed, 2.5–3.0 mm long, and red or purple. Lemma is keeled and hairy on the keel. Leaf blades of C. aethiopicus is 3–25 cm long and 3–7 mm wide, linear lanceolate, coarse, stiff and harsh, glabrous or sparsely hairy, and conduplicate (Harlan et al. 1970b; Clayton et al. 2009). Culms are rather woody at maturity, can be 40–100 cm long, and 2–6 mm in diameter. Stolons have long internodes and are stout (Harlan et al. 1970b). Harlan et al. (1970b) indicated that C. aethiopicus was distributed in wet habitat on coastal plains to highlands from Ethiopia to Transvaal of South Africa. In addition to its distribution in Africa, it is distributed in Australia (Clayton et al. 2009). Taliaferro et al. (2004a) indicated that stargrass species, including C. aethiopicus, are indigenous to tropical Africa but have been exported to many other tropical and semitropical regions of the world. C. aethiopicus cultivars have been developed by biotype selection (Taliaferro et al. 2004a). Available evidence indicates some hybridization potential between C. aethiopicus and C. dactylon (Harlan et al. 1969). Harlan et al. (1969) attempted many crosses between plants of the two species with only six triploid hybrids produced from diploid (2n ¼ 2x ¼ 18) C. aethiopicus by tetraploid (2n ¼ 4x ¼ 36) C. dactylon. No hybrids were generated by crossing diploid C. dactylon with diploid and tetraploid C. aethiopicus (Harlan et al. 1969). de Wet and Harlan (1970) subsequently reported that tetraploid C. aethiopicus crossed readily with tetraploid C. dactylon var. dactylon to produce hybrids, which were partially fertile. Based on this information, it would be possible to use C. aethiopicus as a genetic source to improve C. dactylon as a forage grass using traditional breeding procedures. C. arcuatus is a sod-forming grass without rhizomes (Harlan et al. 1970b). Its inflorescence normally has 4–5 racemes, which are long, slender, and flexuous. Spikelets are rather densely arrayed on racemes. Plants of C. arcuatus in our greenhouse are perennial and readily set seed. Glumes are subequal and about one-half the spikelet length. Lemma is hairy on keel. Stolons are slender and have short internodes.
4 Cynodon
One distinct character of C. arcuatus is that its leaf blade is very broadly lanceolate. The grass is distributed in northern Madagascar, adjacent islands to Sri Lanka (Ceylon), South and East India, Southeast Asia, Southern China, Philippines, Indonesia, and Northern Australia (Harlan et al. 1970b). Habitat of the species is in lowland wet areas. C. arcuatus is genetically completely isolated from all other Cynodon species (Harlan et al. 1969). The grass has limited forage value, but its genetic isolation from other Cynodon species precludes its use in interspecific hybridization as a means of breeding (Harlan 1970). C. barberi plants are small in size, rare in abundance, and confined in wet areas and edges of permanent water courses. The species is endemic to southern India and of little value as forage, but it has some local use as turf (Harlan 1970). The grass is perennial and sod-forming, but has no rhizomes, and has low tolerance to freezing temperatures. Culms can ascend up to 25–40 cm tall (Clayton et al. 2009), but stolons form loose mats less than 10 cm in height (Harlan et al. 1970b). An inflorescence normally consists of 2–5 short, slender and delicate racemes. Glumes are unequal, and longest glumes can slightly exceed the length of the lemma, which is somewhat hairy on keel. Leaf blades of C. barberi are short, broadly lanceolate with long, sparse hairs. Harlan et al. (1970b) indicated that this species is somewhat a miniature version of C. arcuatus, except that inflorescences of the two species are very different. C. barberi is genetically well isolated from other species in the genus Cynodon (Harlan et al. 1970c). C. dactylon is the species of greatest genetic diversity, widest geographic distribution, and greatest economic value within the genus. Harlan et al.’s (1970b) taxonomic classification includes six varieties within the species. They are var. afghanicus Harlan et de Wet, var. aridus Harlan et de Wet, var. coursii Harlan et de Wet, var. dactylon (L.) Pers., var. elegans Rendle, and var. polevansii (Stent) Harlan et de Wet (Harlan et al. 1970b). The intraspecific classification was based on data for natural distribution, morphological distinctness, cytogenetic behavior, and ecology (Harlan and de Wet 1969; Harlan 1970). In addition to a living collection of 453 accessions from 28 countries grown at Stillwater, Oklahoma, for the data collection, specimens were examined in Kew, British Museum, Edinburgh, Paris, Honolulu, and Washington (Harlan and de Wet 1969). Among the six varieties, var. dactylon
55
has worldwide distribution in warm and temperate climates, var. aridus is relatively widely distributed, and vars. afghanicus, coursii, elegans, and polevansii are narrow endemics (Harlan and de Wet 1969; Harlan et al. 1970b; de Wet and Harlan 1970). Var. afghanicus is an Afghanistan endemic taxon recognized by Harlan and de Wet. The characteristics of var. afghanicus include no rhizomes in the diploid race but very short rhizome-like structures in tetraploid race, and its racemes bear closely imbricated spikelets. Even without rhizomes, living plants of var. afghanicus overwintered in Stillwater, OK, for several years, demonstrating tolerance to freezing temperatures (Harlan et al. 1970b). The variety is found only in lowland sites of steppes and along irrigation ditches. It seems that tetraploids have a wider natural distribution than diploids. Var. aridus is diverse in morphology, but it has less genetic variability than var. dactylon. A race with relatively small plants is found in southern India while a race with much larger plants occurs in South Africa. Two to several racemes constitute an inflorescence with one or rarely two whorls. Glumes are about 2/3 the length of spikelets, which are loosely arranged on the racemes. Var. aridus plants have little winter hardiness in Stillwater, OK, but their rhizomes can grow deep enough in soil to escape freezing temperatures (Harlan et al. 1970b). Harlan and de Wet (1969) indicated that the variety is distributed in a vast geographic area from South Africa, Zambia, Tanzania, to Israel and then to India and Sri Lanka (Ceylon). The variety is called “giant” bermudagrass in the USA where seed is produced in Arizona and California. Var. coursii is relatively coarse. It can grow 40–50 cm tall. Morphology of its inflorescences, racemes, spikelets, and glumes is similar to var. dactylon while lemmas are pilose on keel (Harlan et al. 1970b). Var. coursii has no rhizomes, and leaves are often bunched and appressed at the tip of culms. The variety is distributed in the central plateau of Madagascar. It has no winter hardiness in Stillwater, OK. Var. dactylon is enormously variable with plants ranging in size from very small, fine textured types suitable for turf use to large and robust ones best suited for forage production (Harlan and de Wet 1969). The variety is distributed across all continents and on most ocean islands between North and South latitudes of approximately 45 . In Europe, it can extend to locations, such as Yorkshire in England, Friesland in
56
Netherlands, Potsdam in Germany, and southern Siberia in the Russian Federation (formerly USSR), all at approximately 53 N latitude (Harlan and de Wet 1969). Inflorescences contain racemes arranged in one whorl, rarely two. Glumes are usually ¾ the spikelet length, occasionally slightly longer. The stolons of var. dactylon are never as large as those of the stargrass species, C. plectostachyus, C. aethiopicus, or C. nlemfuensis (Harlan et al. 1970b). The variety has rhizomes and likes disturbed habitats. Harlan and de Wet (1969) reported finding natural spread of var. dactylon plants in valleys about 3,000 m above sea levels in the southern Tibetan region but not on the high plateau of the northern Tibetan region. Harlan and de Wet (1969) recognized three races as tropical, temperate, and seleucidus on the basis of appearance, adaptation, and geographic distribution. This variety is extremely valuable and extensively used directly or as a parent to develop interspecific varieties as commercial products for forage and turf. Var. elegans is a medium coarse variety confined to southern Africa (Harlan and de Wet 1969). It has a distinctive appearance from sympatric var. aridus. Var. elegans has green foliage rather than glaucous one of var. aridus (Harlan and de Wet 1969). Plants of var. elegans can form a lax, loose sod, and its culms are decumbent with ascending appressed leaves (Harlan et al. 1970b). The variety has no winter hardiness in Stillwater, OK. It is valuable in breeding forage bermudagrass. Var. polevansii is small in plant size. Stolons are rather fine with short internodes forming a dense turf, and leaves are very harsh, rigid, and erect (Harlan and de Wet 1969). The variety has only been collected from one site near Barberspan, South Africa (Harlan et al. 1970b). It has good winter hardiness in Oklahoma and is dark green in color and therefore could be valuable in the development of turf type cultivars. C. incompletus is a South African species. Like several other African Cynodon species, C. incompletus has no rhizomes. The species is subclassified into two varieties, var. incompletus and var. hirsutus (Stent) de Wet et Harlan. de Wet and Harlan (1971) indicated that var. incompletus plants have leaves, which are at most moderately pilose, and lower and upper glumes are about 1/4 and 1/2 the spikelet length, respectively, while var. hirsutus has hirsute leaves and relatively longer glumes, which are 1/2 to 3/4 as long as the spikelet. Lemmas are often somewhat blunt with hairs on keels (Harlan et al. 1970b). Morphologically, plants
Y. Wu
of C. incompletus have fine, slender, reddish stolons, linear-lanceolate somewhat hairy leaf blades, and one whorl of racemes in inflorescence. The two varieties are winter hardy in Stillwater, OK (Harlan et al. 1970b). The species is distributed in southern Africa, primarily in South Africa as far north as 23 South latitude. Var. incompletus predominates in the arid regions, while var. hirsutus predominates in the Bushveld, but their distribution ranges overlap extensively in the western Transvaal (de Wet and Harlan 1971). C. nlemfuensis is an important forage species with robust plants capable of rapid growth and high biomass yield. It is one of the stargrass species from which forage cultivars have been developed, and it has been used in interspecific hybridization with C. dactylon to produce forage cultivars. Typical plants of the species have inflorescences in one or rarely two or three whorls of racemes, which are very long, spreading, and flexuous, usually 5 or more, about 4 or more centimeters in length (Harlan et al. 1970b). Glumes are subequal, about ¾ of the length of a spikelet. The species has no rhizomes and has low tolerance to freezing temperatures. Two botanical varieties were recognized in Harlan et al.’s (1970) taxonomical classification, var. nlemfuensis and var. robustus. The nlemfuensis variety is widely distributed in the wetter parts of East and Central Africa from Ethiopia to Zimbabwe (Rhodesia) and Angola. Compared to variety nlemfuensis, var. robustus is taller and coarser and has bigger stolons. The robustus variety is mainly distributed in high rainfall areas of eastern Africa, ranging from Ethiopia to Zimbabwe and westward to Angola. C. plectostachyus is another non-rhizomatous large East African Cynodon species included in the stargrass grouping. It is distinct from all other Cynodon species because of its minute glumes, which are at most 1/4 to 1/5 of the length of the spikelet (Clayton and Harlan 1970). Its inflorescence is normally arranged in 2–5 whorls. It has robust, erect culms reaching heights of 30–90 cm. The species has low tolerance to freezing temperatures. Its habitat is in areas of relatively high rainfall, particularly along the highlands of East Africa. The species is distributed from Ethiopia to Kenya, Tanzania, Zambia, Malawi, and Uganda to Eastern Congo (Harlan et al. 1970b). C. transvaalensis is an endemic species in South Africa. Typical plants of the species are small in size with yellowish-green, erect leaves and small inflorescences with the spikelets loosely arranged on the
4 Cynodon
racemes (de Wet and Harlan 1970). Its leaf blades are rarely more than 2 mm wide, and its stolons fine, slender, with short internodes. Plants of C. transvaalensis are usually found in damp areas around permanent waterholes and along stream banks (Harlan et al. 1970b). Its natural distribution is in a range from southwestern Transvaal, Orange Free State to the northern part of the central Cape Province of South Africa. It is known as “African bermudagrass” and has been widely used for turf and as a parent in crosses with common bermudagrass in the development of F1 hybrid cultivars. African bermudagrass has little value for forage due to its small size and management requirements.
4.2.2 Cytology, Karyotype, and Genome Size Hurcombe (1947) reported chromosome numbers of several cultivated Cynodon species in South Africa using root tip sections to count chromosomes. Her investigations indicated that chromosomes of C. bradleyi (now considered a hybrid between C. incompletus var. incompletus and var. hirsutus), C. transvaalensis, C. dactylon, and C. magennisii were 18, 20, 40, and 30, respectively. She believed that the base chromosome number of Cynodon was 10. She speculated that the determination of 18 somatic chromosomes for C. bradleyi was due to aneuploidy (Hurcombe 1947). Forbes and Burton (1963) reported chromosome numbers of six Cynodon species using root tip smears. Their study confirmed the base number of Cynodon to be 9 rather than 10. Their results indicated that C. bradleyi, C. incompletus, C. plectostachyus, C. transvaalensis, and C. x magennisii had respective somatic chromosome numbers of 18, 18, 18, 18 and 27, while C. dactylon had both diploid (2n ¼ 2x ¼ 18) and tetraploid (2n ¼ 4x ¼ 36) plants. They indicated that some chromosome satellites could cause misinterpretation of chromosome numbers. Harlan et al. (1970b) published a taxonomic revision of the genus Cynodon, which is presented in Table 4.1. Their revision was based on comprehensive cytotaxonomic investigations and has been widely adopted. Malik and Tripathi (1968) reported three cytotypes of naturally occurring C. dactylon in Udaipur, India.
57 Table 4.1 Cynodon species and their somatic chromosomes (Harlan et al. 1970b) Taxon Somatic chromosome number C. aethiopicus Clayton et Harlan 18, 36 C. arcuatus J. S. Presl. Ex C. B. Presl. 36 C. barberi Rang. Et Tad. 18 C. dactylon (L.) Pers. var. dactylon 36, 45a, 54a var. afghanicus Harlan et de Wet 18, 36 var. aridus Harlan et de Wet 18 var. coursii (A. Camus) Harlan et de Wet 36 var. elegans Rendle 36 var. polevansii (Stent) Harlan et de Wet 36 C. incompletus Nees var. incompletus 18 var. hirsutus (Stent) de Wet et Harlan 18, rarely 36 C. nlemfuensis Vanderyst var. nlemfuensis 18, rarely 36 var. robustus Clayton et Harlan 18, 36 C. plectostachyus (K. Schum.) Pilger 18, rarely 36a C. transvaalensis Burtt-Davy 18 a
Sources: Assefa et al. (1999) and Wu et al. (2006a)
They found that diploid (2n ¼ 2x ¼ 18), tetraploid (2n ¼ 4x ¼ 36), and hexaploid (2n ¼ 6x ¼ 54) races were sympatric. de Silva and Snaydon (1995) studied chromosome numbers in C. dactylon of Sri Lanka. They reported that most populations were tetraploids, while plants from roadsides and lawns in the wet region and from forests in the hill country were diploids. They also added that populations from paddy fields in the wet region contained both diploid and tetraploid plants. Surprisingly, they did not find triploids in any environments (de Silva and Snaydon 1995). Wu et al. (2006a) reported four ploidy levels, triploid, tetraploid, pentaploid, and hexaploid in 119 Chinese C. dactylon accessions. The few triploid plants in the collection were considered likely interspecific hybrids that had been introduced to the collection area. Tetraploids were the most common (88%) cytotype in the collection, which was consistent with previous reports of ploidy levels in Chinese Cynodon germplasm. Pentaploids and hexaploids in the collection were only from eastern provinces of China. They did not find diploids in the collection. Similarly, Kang et al. (2008) reported triploid, tetraploid, pentaploid, and hexaploid cytotypes among 43 Korean Cynodon accessions collected in the southern regions of the Korean peninsula between 34 and 36 N latitude and from 126 to 129 E longitude. It was speculated that triploids were introduced since no diploid
58
plants were ever reported in the nation. More recently, Gulsen et al. (2009) reported diploids, triploids, tetraploids, pentaploids, and hexaploids in 182 naturally occurring Cynodon accessions in the southern provinces in Turkey. They further commented that diploids occurred in three provinces, indicating their indigenousness. Their results supported the statement made by Harlan (1970) that the region from West Pakistan to Turkey is the evolutionary center of C. dactylon. Ourecky (1963) reported the pachytene chromosome morphology of a diploid C. dactylon plant from Afghanistan, which probably was var. afghanicus. Pachytene chromosomes of the Cynodon plant varied from 16.8 to 36.3 mm in length. The shortest one in the genome complement was designated as chromosome 1 and the longest as chromosome 9 (Ourecky 1963). Chromosome 4 contains the nucleolar organizing region. Brilman et al. (1982) reported pachytene chromosome morphology of diploid C. dactylon var. aridus and plants of var. afghanicus x var. aridus. The chromosomes ranged in mean length from 20.5 to 44.6 mm, which was reasonably consistent with the results of Ourecky (1963). Arm ratios were from about 1.5 to 2.14 (Brilman et al. 1982). Brilman et al. (1982) suggested that the genomes of var. afghanicus and var. aridus are completely homologous. Knowledge of genome size is important in plant species being investigated with molecular genetic techniques. The use of flow cytometry to estimate nuclear genome size, or genomic DNA content, of Cynodon species was first reported by Taliaferro et al. (1997). The mean nuclear DNA contents of diploids, triploids, tetraploids, and hexaploids in their study were 1.11 0.04 (1,087.8 39.2 Mbp), 1.60 0.04 (1,568 39.2 Mbp), 2.25 0.13 (2,205 127.4 Mbp), and 2.80 0.14 (2,744 137.2 Mbp) pg/2C, respectively. Their research indicated that nuclear DNA content can be used to estimate ploidy level in Cynodon. Genome sizes of diploid African, triploid Tifway, triploid Tifgreen, and tetraploid “Savannah” as reported by Arumuganathan et al. (1999) were 1.03 0.01 (1,009.4 9.8 Mbp) pg/2C, 1.61 0.00 (1,577.8 0.0 Mbp), 1.37 0.01 (1,342.6 9.8 Mbp) pg/2C, and 1.95 0.01 (1,911 9.8 Mbp) pg/2C, respectively. Recently, Wu et al. (2006a), Kang et al. (2008), and Gulsen et al. (2009) reported genome sizes for various ploidy levels of native Cynodon accessions in China, Korea, and Turkey using flow cytometry (Table 4.2).
Y. Wu
4.2.3 Agriculture Uses Several of the Cynodon species have economic value derived from their agricultural use, principally as grazed or conserved fodder for livestock. The most important of the species is C. dactylon, which includes the ubiquitous common bermudagrass, C. dactylon var. dactylon that is of paramount importance. Stargrasses are also of substantial importance in tropical and subtropical regions. In addition to livestock fodder, these grasses have value in controlling soil erosion and in the remediation of spoil soils. They are also effective sinks for removing excess nutrients from soils receiving large amounts of animal effluent. They also have potential as bioenergy feedstock crops because of their high biomass production capability (Casler et al. 2009). The use of bermudagrass as turf rivals or exceeds its use as livestock fodder. Bermudagrass has had a dramatic effect on the livestock industry in the southern USA (Nelson and Burns 2006). Bermudagrass pastures are managed for grazing or haying or dual purpose in the South. Stargrass is cultivated and used in Florida, Central and South America, the Caribbean, and tropical Africa (Taliaferro et al. 2004a). Taliaferro et al. (2004a) pointed out many characteristics making bermudagrass valuable for use as grazed or harvested forages. These include their relative ease of establishment, high biomass production potential per unit area, relatively good palatability, and high tolerance to biotic and abiotic stresses. Improved cultivars coupled with advanced management techniques enable bermudagrass forage production to be a low cost system. Bermudagrass is a major crop of the turf industry in southern USA and many other countries in the world, where climates are tropical, subtropical, and warm Table 4.2 Genome size for Cynodon native in and Turkey Ploidy (2n) Genome size range (pg/2C) Chinese Korean Cynodon by Cynodon Wu et al. by Kang et al. (2006a) (2008) Diploid (18) N/A N/A 1.42–1.56a Triploid (27) 1.55–1.65a Tetraploid (36) 1.96–2.30 1.94–2.19 Pentaploid (45) 2.37–2.49 2.54 Hexaploid (54) 2.90–3.13 2.77–2.85 a
Likely introduced plants
China, Korea,
Turkish Cynodon by Gulsen et al. (2009) 1.03–1.14 1.44–1.62 1.95–2.36 2.56–2.75 3.13–3.44
4 Cynodon
temperate. Taliaferro (2003) indicated the use of bermudagrass as turf rivals its use as a forage grass. As a matter of fact, bermudagrass used as a turfgrass is much more extensive than for forage on a global scale. Because of its relatively high drought tolerance (Beard 1973), bermudagrass has replaced other turf grasses, particularly cool-season species, in turf applications as the availability of irrigation water becomes limited in many parts of the world. Currently, most bermudagrass turf is established using clonal hybrid cultivars, such as “Tifway”, “Patriot”, etc., derived from crossing C. dactylon with C. transvaalensis. However, seeded cultivars of C. dactylon have been bred and commercialized in an accelerated pace in the recent years. Much of this latter effort is by private industry (Taliaferro 2003). Turf bermudagrass is used on lawns, parks, roadsides, sports fields, and golf courses, to name a few. Bermudagrass has an exceptional ability to develop a dense vegetative cover, which can protect the underlying soil from erosion caused by wind, water, or other physical forces. The sod-forming ability of bermudagrass comes from aggressive growth of stolons and rhizomes, which work together with its fibrous root system in binding the topsoil tightly against erosion movement of soil particles. Bermudagrass can withstand inundation for an extended period so that it is an ideal plant species to grow along water ways, on river banks, and other flooded areas. Bermudagrass generally grows well in disturbed habitats, such as right-ofways, roadsides, and urban areas including parks. The ability of bermudagrass to provide an attractive turf with minimal adverse effects due to biotic and abiotic stresses and protect the environment through prevention of soil erosion, removal of greenhouse gasses, and release of oxygen make it a very valuable grass.
4.3 Conservation Initiatives 4.3.1 Species for Forage As previously mentioned, the value of Cynodon species and varieties as grazed or stored forage for ruminant animals, and their potential value in genetic improvement programs, varies from high to negligent. The taxa C. barberi, C. arcuatus, C. transvaalensis, and C. incompletus are of minor value in grazing and have no value in hay production according to Harlan
59
(1970). Additionally, they have little potential for contributing to the development of improved forage cultivars as genetic sources. It should be reemphasized that C. transvaalensis is crucial in the breeding of hybrid turf bermudagrass cultivars and also has direct use as for turf. The most valuable species for forage use include the stargrass species, C. aethiopicus, C. nlemfuensis, and C. plectostachyus, in addition to the cosmopolitan and ubiquitous species C. dactylon. The Stargrass species are generally well adapted to tropical climates receiving 800 mm or more annual rainfall (Taliaferro et al. 2004a). C. aethiopicus has wider distribution than the other two robust East African species. Harlan (1970) noted that the species is very robust and can grow up to 2 m tall. At maturity, woody culms of C. aethiopicus rattle in the wind. Because of its abundance and apparent productivity, the species had probably been used considerably as a forage grass before it was recognized as a species (Harlan 1970). Under heavily grazed conditions, C. aethiopicus and C. dactylon may look similar, but the absence of rhizomes in C. aethiopicus and their presence in C. dactylon can be used to distinguish them. Genetically, the species is well isolated from the other species, but at the diploid level, C. aethiopicus crosses with C. nlemfuensis Vanderyst var. nlemfuensis, and at the tetraploid level, it crosses readily with C. dactylon var. dactylon to produce partially fertile hybrids (de Wet and Harlan 1970). Accordingly, C. aethiopicus has potential to contribute to the genetic improvement of bermudagrass and stargrass via its hybridization potential with forage C. dactylon and C. nlemfuensis var. nlemfuensis. Forage cultivars of C. aethiopicus were released from ecotype selections of natural collections (Table 4.3). C. nlemfuensis is the most promising of the stargrasses used directly for forage (Harlan 1970) and is highly valuable in the development of hybrid cultivars from interspecific crossing with C. dactylon (Burton 1972; Burton et al. 1993). Harlan (1970) noted that C. nlemfuensis var. robustus was used to establish pastures at the Muguga Research Station near Nairobi and had high yield in field trials at the Henderson Research Station. Compared to var. robustus, var. nlemfuensis is finer, less robust, and less hairy. “IB-8” is a cultivar of C. nlemfuensis var. nlemfuensis, selected and released by H. R. Chheda at the University of Ibadan, Nigeria, in 1968 (Harlan 1970; Crowder and Chheda 1982). Characteristics of IB-8 are high forage
60
Y. Wu
Table 4.3 Forage cultivars of stargrass and hybrid cultivars from bermudagrass by stargrass crosses [after Taliaferro et al. (2004a)] Cultivar Taxon Year of Origin References release Cv No 2 (Rhodesian Cynodon aethiopicus Unknown Zimbabwe Bogdan (1977), No. 2 stargrass) Clatworthy (1985) McCaleb C. aethiopicus 1975 Florida Agricultural Experiment Hodges et al. (1975) Station (FAES) IB-8 C. nlemfuensis var. nlemfuensis 1968 University of Ibadan, Nigeria Crowder and Chheda (1982) Muguga C. nlemfuensis var. nlemfuensis Unknown Zimbabwe Clatworthy (1985) Ona C. nlemfuensis var. nlemfuensis 1979 FAES Hodges et al. (1984) Tifton 68 C. nlemfuensis 1984 USDA-ARS and Georgia AES Burton and Monson (1984) Florico C. nlemfuensis var. nlemfuensis 1988 Florida and Puerto Rico AES Mislevy et al. (1989a) and USDA-ARS Florona C. nlemfuensis var. nlemfuensis 1988 FAES Mislevy et al. (1989b) Coastcross-1 C. dactylon C. nlemfuensis 1967 USDA-ARS and Ga. AES Burton (1972) var. robustus 1982 Tex, La., and Okla. AESs Eichhorn et al. (1984), Brazos C. dactylon var. Taliaferro (1986) afghanicus C. nlemfuensis var. robustus Tifton 85 C. dactylon C. nlemfuensis 1992 USDA-ARS and Ga. AES Burton et al. (1993)
yield, good drought tolerance, and outstanding animal weight gain compared to local bermudagrass. Later in the USA, several C. nlemfuensis cultivars and hybrids derived from crosses of C. dactylon by C. nlemfuensis were developed/selected and released (Table 4.3). C. dactylon is the most valuable and important species as a forage grass for grazing and/or hay production and in the development of improved cultivars using intraspecific and interspecific hybridizations. However, according to Harlan’s evaluation, four varieties in C. dactylon, vars. afghanicus, coursii, elegans, and polevansii, are of relatively minor value as herbage grasses, as they are endemic when compared to var. dactylon and aridus (Harlan 1970). Plants of var. afghanicus are relatively robust, vigorous, and winter hardy but are endemic to the lowland and moist sites in Afghanistan (Harlan 1970). Var. coursii and polevansii are endemic to Madagascar and South Africa, respectively, containing no germplasm attributes that will likely be of importance in breeding new forage cultivars (Taliaferro 1986). Var. elegans is indigenous in southern Africa and relatively common in the south of latitude 13 S. Plants of var. elegans have good yield potential but have moderate to low winter hardiness (Taliaferro 1986). The development of Coastal having var. elegans as a parent and “Midland 99” and “Brazos” both having genetic contributions from var. afghanicus indicates that vars. elegans and afghanicus are of high valuable potential in breeding new forage
cultivars. Var. aridus ranges from small plants in South India to large ones in South Africa. Forms of var. aridus from East Africa are larger and more vigorous (Harlan 1970). Cooper and Burton (1965) evaluated forage and turf potential of giant bermudagrass (var. aridus) in southeastern USA. They reported that giant bermudagrass yielded no more forage than common bermudagrass and only around 55% of Coastal bermudagrass (Cooper and Burton 1965). Var. dactylon is highly important as a herbage grass as it is so widely distributed and has been used to develop numerous improved cultivars for forage use. Harlan (1970) stated that the release of Coastal in 1943 represented a hallmark in the records of plant breeding. Coastal, yielding 2–4 times the biomass yield of naturalized common strains, changed the attitude towards bermudagrass among the southern row crop farmers around the middle of twentieth century (Harlan 1970). More efforts have been initiated on the forage bermudagrass breeding since then, and consequently more cultivars have been released and used in commercial production in the USA (Table 4.4).
4.3.2 Germplasm Collection and Conservation The availability of a genetically diverse germplasm collection is often key to the success of a breeding
4 Cynodon
61
Table 4.4 Forage bermudagrass cultivars released in the USA [after Taliaferro et al. (2004a)] Cultivar Year of release Origin Coastal 1943 USDA-ARS and Ga. AES Midland
1953
USDA-ARS and Okla. AES
Suwannee Greenfield NK-37 Alicia Hardie
1953 1954 1957 Mid-1960s 1974
USDA-ARS and Ga. AES Okla. AES Northrup, King & Co Cecil Greer Grass Farm, Edna, TX Okla. AES
Callie Tifton 44
1974 1978
Miss. AES USDA-ARS and Ga. AES
Guymon Tifton 78
1982 1984
Okla. AES and USDA-ARS USDA-ARS and Ga. AES
Grazer Cheyenne
1985 1989
La. AES and USDA-ARS Jacklin Seed Co.
Russell Florakirk Wrangler Midland 99
1994 1994 1999 1999
Goodwell
2007
Ala. and La. AESs Fla. AES Johnston Seed Co. Okla., Kan. Mo., Ark. AESs, Noble Foundation, and USDA-ARS Okla. AES
program. Genes influencing a range of performance traits can often be found in relatives of commercial cultivars or the breeding populations from which those cultivars originated. Though giant strides have been made in Cynodon breeding, the scope of the breeding effort and the degree to which the total germplasm base has been utilized are small. According to Harlan (1970), the most extensive collections of Cynodon germplasm in East Africa were assembled at the Kitale Research Station in Kenya from about 1951 to 1962 by A.V. Bogdan. Bogdan described his and other’s work with herbage Cynodon germplasm in Tropical Pasture and Fodder Plants (Bogdan 1977). The collections of Bogdan included C. nlemfuensis, C. plectostachyus, and C. aethiopicus. Other significant stargrass collections were housed at the Frankenwald Botanical Research Station in South Africa and the Henderson Research Station in Harare, Zimbabwe (Taliaferro et al. 2004a). However, very little information is available on the magnitudes of phenotypic and genetic diversity in the three East African Cynodon species. Although endemic to Africa, each of the species is not widely distributed in natural environments. Genetic erosion within the respective species has not been
References Myers (1951), Burton (1948, 1954) Hein (1953), Harlan et al. (1954) Burton (1962) Elder (1955) Hanson (1972) Taliaferro et al. (2004a) Taliaferro and Richardson (1980) Watson (1974) Burton and Monson (1978) Taliaferro et al. (1983) Burton and Monson (1988) Eichhorn et al. (1986) Samudio and Brede (1998) Ball et al. (1996) Mislevy et al. (1999) Taliaferro et al. (2004a) Taliaferro et al. (2002) Wu et al. (2008)
characterized, but their limited distributions and population sizes likely make them vulnerable, certainly more so than in C. dactylon. Morphological and genetic diversity of C. dactylon var. dactylon is well documented (Harlan and de Wet 1969; Harlan 1970; Harlan et al. 1970a; Wu et al. 2007). Native collections of C. dactylon from China, Korea, and Turkey studied by Wu et al. (2006a, b, 2007), Kang et al. (2008), and Gulsen et al. (2009), respectively, all provided results indicating tremendous genetic variation within the taxon. Additional reports indicating substantial variation within C. dactylon var. dactylon, indigenous to China, were made by Liu and colleagues at the Institute of Botany, Nanjing (Liu et al. 2003), by Abulaiti and colleagues at Xingjiang Agricultural University (Abulaiti et al. 2003), and by Wu before 2001, and now Zhang and colleagues at Sichuan Agricultural University (Wu et al. 2001; Yi et al. 2008). Cynodon plants may have been introduced to the Americas soon after the discovery of the new world by Columbus in 1492 (Taliaferro et al. 2004a). The first written report of bermudagrass in the contiguous USA was made in 1751 by the then Georgia Governor
62
Henry Ellis as noted by Kneebone (1966) and Burton and Hanna (1995). By the early 1800s, bermudagrass had become one of the most important grasses in the South (Taliaferro et al. 2004a). Today, bermudagrass is the major warm-season perennial used in the southern US for forage and turf, and it has spread to the central and northern states. However, organized collections of Cynodon germplasm for cultivar development and genetic research in the USA occurred in the twentieth century, more intensively after the1930s. In the bermudagrass breeding program initiated by Glenn Burton in 1936 at the Coastal Plain Experiment Station of the Crops Research Division, USDA-ARS in Tifton, GA, bermudagrass and stargrass germplasm from Africa and other countries were assembled via collection trips, gifts, and exchange (Burton 1951). The efforts of Burton and subsequently Wayne Hanna and Bill Anderson and their colleagues have accumulated a worldwide collection of more than 600 forage bermudagrass accessions (Anderson 2005). The collection is highly genetically diverse. It has contributed to the development and release of numerous hybrid cultivars over the last half century and continues to be used for improvement in forage traits. Anderson (2005) selected a core collection from the large forage bermudagrass accessions using phenotypic data sampled in the field in cluster analysis. The core collection was to be used for the assessment of chemical composition or stress tolerance. Jack R. Harlan, Wayne W. Huffine, J.M.J. de Wet, and colleagues assembled a worldwide bermudagrass collection at the Oklahoma State University (OSU) in the late 1950s and early 1960s by making germplasm collection trips to Africa, Asia, Australia, and southern Europe (Harlan and de Wet 1969). The collection contained about 700 accessions and was used in an extensive and comprehensive biosystematic investigation of Cynodon (Wu and Taliaferro 2009). Charles M. Taliaferro initiated and directed the bermudagrass breeding program at OSU from 1968 to 2006 in the development of forage and turf bermudagrass cultivars. He and colleagues added more Cynodon accessions from Africa, Australia, Europe, and Asia to the OSU germplasm pool by Harlan (Taliaferro et al. 2004b). The OSU bermudagrass germplasm has been used to develop and release numerous elite forage and turf cultivars by Taliaferro and colleagues. A total of 435 Cynodon accessions are currently maintained in the National Plant Germplasm System
Y. Wu
(NPGS) of the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) as indicated by the Germplasm Resources Information Network (GRIN) database records as of June 2009 (GRIN 2009). Compared to the number of accessions in the collection in 1995, the current USDA NPGS Cynodon collection contains 22% fewer accessions. Among the US Cynodon collection, 379 accessions can be listed as forage germplasm (Table 4.5) as discussed above. C. aethiopicus, C. nlemfuensis, and C. plectostachyus are represented by one, three, and 32 accessions, respectively, while C. dactylon is represented by 318 accessions. It is evident that the national collection does not contain ample genetic diversity in the East African Cynodon species. Of the 318 C. dactylon accessions, 272 belong to var. dactylon and have been collected from 36 countries. C. dactylon varieties afghanicus, aridus, coursii, elegans, and polevansii are represented by 1, 1, 5, 2, and 4 accessions, respectively, and accessions from each taxon originated from only one country. Even with C. dactylon var. dactylon, the potential to increase the diversity by more comprehensive germplasm collection is large. The data further indicate that comprehensive germplasm collection in major geographic regions is required to sample the full extent of the available variation. In both South and North Americas, introduced Cynodon plants have spread over wide geographic expanses and have become naturalized to specific climatic and edaphic conditions. Consequently, genetic diversity has increased in these populations due to gene recombination, gene mutation, new gene generation, and natural selection under diverse environments since and during their introduction and dispersion, respectively. Thus, germplasm collected from these new world environments is of potential value to genetic enhancement efforts. Certainly, there should be effort to
Table 4.5 Forage Cynodon collections in the US National Plant Germplasm System by species and origin as of June 2009 Species Accessions Continental origin C. aethiopicus 1 Africa C. dactylon 318 Africa, Asia, Australia, Europe, N. America, S. America C. nlemfuensis 3 Africa, N. America C. plectostachyus 32 Africa, Asia C. species 25 Africa, Asia, Australia Total 379
4 Cynodon
increase the sample size of Cynodon taxa now poorly represented in the NPGS collection, but even the number of C. dactylon var. dactylon accessions in the collection likely poorly samples the total germplasm pool of that taxon. Preservation and maintenance of a large bermudagrass germplasm collection is essential to a breeding program and provide research materials for scientific efforts from basic to applied investigations. Widely used techniques for the preservation include maintenance of living clonal plants in the greenhouse or field germplasm nursery, or both, and storage of seed samples in a dry and cold room at 5–10 C. Viability of seed can be maintained for a long term if stored at 18 C or lower. However, genetic preservation of clonal germplasm requires daily care of potted plants, such as watering, trimming, and fertilizing in the greenhouse, or careful management of individual plots in the field to avoid contamination due to encroachment of plants from adjacent plots or by dissemination of seed from plot to plot. Herbicides such as glyphosate are effective in maintaining alleys between neighboring plots. More challenging is to control the contamination from volunteer seedlings derived from seed produced on the plant through outcrossing. One way to reduce or eliminate seed set is mowing the plants before seed is produced on the plant. Alternative forms of preservation techniques have been studied. Reed et al. (2005) reported a cryopreservation protocol for storing bermudagrass shoot tips in liquid nitrogen (196 C). The protocol is most effective when combined with a 1–4 weeks cold acclimation period and dehydration to 19–23% moisture before shoot tips are exposed to liquid nitrogen (Reed et al. 2005). The protocol was used to store 25 bermudagrass germplasm accessions at the National Clonal Germplasm Repository, Corvallis, Oregon, and at the National Center for Germplasm Resources Preservation in Fort Collins, Colorado.
4.4 Origin and Evolution The geographic center of origin of common bermudagrass [C. dactylon (L.) Pers. var. dactylon] has long been of scientific interest because the grass is so widely distributed. About 200 years ago, bermudagrass was recorded in Mease’s Geological Account of
63
the United States, as cited by Tracy (1917), as one of the most important grasses in the southern States. Tracy believed bermudagrass was a native grass in the “Old World,” probably India. Tracy (1917) speculated that bermudagrass probably was introduced to the American colonies by way of the Bermuda Islands (Tracy 1917). Later, Burton in 1951 noted that Thomas Spalding of Sapaloe Island documented in his diary that Henry Ellis, the then Governor of Georgia, introduced bermudagrass to Savannah, Georgia, in 1751. But Spalding did not indicate where Henry Ellis obtained the bermudagrass from (Burton 1951). Burton (1951) assumed that bermudagrass came to Americas much earlier than 1751, probably in the hay brought by the Spanish conquistadors to feed their horses. He believed Africa was the primary center of origin as the bermudagrass introductions from Africa showed greater diversity. Harlan et al. (1970b) noted that Africa has more Cynodon species than other continents (Table 4.6). Clayton et al. (2009) reported that there are seven Cynodon species in the African continent, surpassing the number found on all other continents. Cynodon diversity at species level is obviously highest in Africa and appears to be second highest in Asia, third in Australia, and least in Europe. Beard and Watson (1982) stated that lower East Africa is generally recognized as the center of origin of bermudagrass. Cosmopolitan tetraploid C. dactylon var. dactylon was likely derived from diploid progenitors (Wu and Taliaferro 2009). Diploid Cynodon taxa include C. aethiopicus, C. barberi, C. dactylon var. afghanicus, C. dactylon var. aridus, C. incompletus, C. plectostachyus, and C. transvaalensis. Collectively, those diploids are distributed in a range from South Africa, to East Africa, then Eastern Mediterranean region, and then West and South Asia (Fig. 4.1). Among the diploid Cynodon species, C. aethiopicus, C. barberi,
Table 4.6 Continental distribution of native Cynodon species Continent Number Species name of species Africa 7 C. aethiopicus, C. dactylon, C. incompletus, C. x magennisii, C. nlemfuensis, C. plectostachyus, C. transvaalensis Asia 3 C. arcuatus, C. barberi, C. dactylon Australia 2 C. arcuatus, C. dactylon Europe 1 C. dactylon
64
C. nlemfuensis, C. plectostachyus, and C. incompletus may not contribute to the formation of rhizomatous tetraploid C. dactylon var. dactylon in any way due to the absence of rhizomes in the five species. The research of Harlan and colleagues indicated that diploid C. aethiopicus, C. barberi, C. nlemfuensis vars. nlemfuensis and robustus, and C. plectostachyus have limited or no hybridization potential with C. dactylon var. dactylon, further indicating that these likely did not contribute to the formation and diversity of tetraploid C. dactylon var. dactylon. Harlan and de Wet (1969) summarized that C. dactylon is completely isolated genetically from C. barberi and C. plectostachyus and that it is difficult to cross C. dactylon with C. aethiopicus. Harlan and de Wet (1969) also believed that C. nlemfuensis was an unlikely contributor to the variability of C. dactylon. Diploid C. transvaalensis can readily hybridize with C. dactylon artificially and in nature (Harlan and de Wet 1969). But the species may not have contributed much to the formation of C. dactylon var. dactylon and its enormous diversity since the South African species is narrowly endemic in distribution. However, C. dactylon var. aridus is different. The taxon has well devel-
Fig. 4.1 Geographic distribution of diploid Cynodon species
Y. Wu
oped rhizomes and its natural distribution ranges from South Africa, Zambia, Tanzania, Israel, to India and Sri Lanka. The contributions of var. aridus to the formation of tetraploid var. dactylon are basic (Harlan and de Wet 1969). Harlan and de Wet (1969) believed that introgression between species was not significant in the evolution of C. dactylon var. dactylon. Vars. aridus and afghanicus are the only two diploid forms within C. dactylon. As mentioned above, var. aridus is rhizomatous, relatively widely distributed, and ranges from small plants in India to tall plants in South Africa, while var. afghanicus is endemic and has no rhizomes. Presumably, var. aridus or its direct ancestor is the diploid progenitor of the cosmopolitan tetraploid var. dactylon, and var. afghanicus also contributed to the great variability in var. dactylon (Harlan and de Wet 1969) (Fig. 4.2). According to its variation patterns, morphological variation, adaptation, geographic distribution, and possible genetic origin, the cosmopolitan var. dactylon was subdivided into tropical, temperate, and seleucidus races by Harlan and de Wet (1969) (Fig. 4.2). The tropical race presumably originated from diploid
4 Cynodon
65 Union of unreduced gametes
Var. aridus (2x = 18)
Tropical race of var. dactylon (4x = 36) Union of unreduced and reduced gametes
Evolution Union of reduced gametes
Diploid Cynodon ancestor (2x = 18)
Temperate race of var. dactylon (4x = 36)
Triploids (3x = 27)
Hexaploid var. dactylon (6x = 54)
Union of reduced gametes
Pentaploid var. dactylon (5x = 45) Seleucidus race of var. dactylon (4x = 36)
Evolution
Var. afghanicus (2x = 18)
Union of unreduced gametes
Var. afghanicus (4x = 36)
Fig. 4.2 Cynodon dactylon var. dactylon and its genetic variability are derived from two putative diploid progenitors, C. dactylon var. aridus and var. afghanicus, and genetic events, such as union of unreduced gametes of diploid ancestors, union of reduced and unreduced gametes of tetraploid var.
dactylon, union of reduced gametes of diploid var. aridus and tetraploid var. dactylon, and union of reduced gametes of hexaploid and tetraploid var. dactylon (Harlan and de Wet 1969; Wu et al. 2006a; Gulsen et al. 2009)
var. aridus. Therefore, the geographic origin of tropical var. dactylon might be in the region along the Indian Ocean from southern India to East Africa. The temperate race possibly was derived from evolution of tropical var. dactylon as it spread beyond tropical climates. The seleucidus race may have originated from hybridization between temperate tetraploid var. dactylon and tetraploid var. afghanicus. Tetraploid var. afghanicus likely originated directly from diploid var. afghanicus by union of unreduced gametes of parent plants. Harlan observed various intermediate forms between temperate var. dactylon and var. afghanicus in the region from West Pakistan to Turkey, where the Seleucid Empire existed (Harlan et al. 1970a). From this evolutionary center, the seleucidus race spread outward and merged into a temperate race in Europe (Harlan and de Wet 1969). More recently, hexaploid cytotypes of the var. dactylon were reported in the southeast part of China and the southern region of Korea (Wu et al. 2006a;
Kang et al. 2008). The origin of the hexaploid forms most likely resulted from the union of reduced and unreduced gametes of tetraploid parents (Wu et al. 2006a). Obviously, the evolutionary events in producing hexaploid var. dactylon are internal within C. dactylon var. dactylon. Numerous hexaploid Cynodon plants were reported in collections from a region south of the Taurus Mountains along the Mediterranean coast in Turkey as well (Gulsen et al. 2009).
4.5 Cynodon Genetic Diversity Revealed by Molecular Markers DNA molecular markers, neutral to environment, have been extensively used to measure genetic diversity of Cynodon species. Assefa et al. (1999) reported high genetic diversity in the genus using DNA
66
amplification fingerprinting (DAF) to assess molecular marker polymorphisms of eight species and seven varieties, including C. aethiopicus, C. arcuatus, C. barberi, C. dactylon var. dactylon, C. dactylon var. afghanicus, C. dactylon var. aridus, C. dactylon var. coursii, C. dactylon var. elegans, C. incompletus var. incompletus, C. nlemfuensis var. robustus, C. plectostachyus, and C. transvaalensis. Of 539 bands scored, 92% (496) bands were polymorphic, indicating enormous genetic diversity in Cynodon at the genomic DNA sequence level. Respective accessions of C. dactylon var. dactylon and C. dactylon var. afghanicus were clustered in separate groupings suggesting higher genetic diversity in the two varieties while other accessions from the same taxa were generally clustered. They reported accessions within taxa, differing in ploidy (2x vs. 4x) clustered in all instances indicating that diploid and tetraploid forms are closely related. Using amplified fragment length polymorphisms (AFLP), Wu et al. (2004) assessed genetic diversity and relatedness among 28 disparate C. dactylon var. dactylon accessions originating from 11 countries (Australia, Bulgaria, China, Germany, France, Italy, Japan, South Africa, Spain, Zimbabwe, and the United Arab Emirates) on 4 continents. Of the 590 bands scored, 75% (443) were polymorphic. Genetic similarity coefficients ranged from 0.53 to 0.98 for the 28 accessions. Accessions originating from Australia, Asia, Africa, and Europe were placed in distinct groups, indicating that geographic origin was a significant factor in their genetic differentiation. This suggests that the genetic isolation of plant populations would provide opportunities for the respective populations to be further genetically differentiated by selective forces for adaptation to specific environments. Later, their expanded AFLP study continued on a C. dactylon var. dactylon collection of 119 accessions from 11 provinces in China (Wu et al. 2006a). Among 763 scored AFLP bands generated by 13 primer combinations, 61.1% (466) were polymorphic. Their results indicated the Chinese tetraploid accessions contained much higher genetic variation than hexaploid accessions while pentaploids had very low genetic diversity. Though the accessions from the same or nearby regions tended to cluster, genetic differentiation among accessions from distinct regions was not evident. The results may be associated with the cross-pollination and self-incompatibility reproductive behavior of bermudagrass. Cross-pollination results in
Y. Wu
gene flow between natural populations, which likely prevents formation of distinctly differentiated genetic groups. Although morphologically, hexaploids and pentaploids were similar to tetraploids in the Chinese C. dactylon collection, genetic differentiation among the three ploidy levels was discernable but not fully separate. The close genetic relatedness of the three different cytotypes indicates that they have a recent common ancestry. Kang et al. (2008) reported genetic diversity of 40 Korean bermudagrass (Cynodon spp.) accessions as assessed using the AFLP marker system. They scored 2,256 bands generated from PCR reactions of 29 selective primer combinations. Among the scored AFLP markers, 87.8% (1,982) were polymorphic. Genetic diversity was high in the Korean Cynodon accessions as evidenced by their genetic similarity coefficients ranging from 0.42 to 0.94. As the triploids included in the Korean collection likely are introduced, the true genetic diversity of indigenous Korean bermudagrass could be much lower. There were no native diploid Cynodon reported in Korea (Kang et al. 2008). Genetic separation of tetraploids, pentaploids, and hexaploids did not occur in the AFLP marker data, though their genome sizes were significantly different. Gulsen et al. (2009) reported genetic diversity in 182 Turkish Cynodon accessions and its variance partitioning for ploidy, geographic region, and province. The Cynodon accessions were genotyped by combinational use of four molecular marker systems, encompassing sequence related amplified polymorphism, peroxidase gene polymorphism, intersimple sequence repeat, and random amplified polymorphic DNA. The accessions were considerably diverse and their genetic similarity coefficients ranged from 0.50 to 0.98. Major portions of the genetic variation in the large collection resided within ploidy level (91%) and provinces (94%), respectively. Genetic differentiation was not significant among ploidy levels. Similarly, genetic variation pattern in adjacent regions was not significant as well. The results were basically consistent with those of Wu et al. (2006a). Interestingly, several diploid Cynodon accessions existed in the Turkish collection of Gulsen et al. (2009) but not in the Chinese and Korean collections by Wu et al. (2006a) and Kang et al. (2008), respectively. Karaca et al. (2002) assessed genetic diversity for some released forage bermudagrass cultivars and
4 Cynodon
related selections using four molecular marker systems including AFLP, chloroplast-specific simple sequence repeat length polymorphism, random amplified polymorphic DNA, and directed amplification of minisatellite-region DNA. Among a total of 1,423 DNA fragments scored, 472 (33%) were polymorphic, indicating low genetic diversity in the forage cultivars. The narrow genetic base of forage bermudagrass cultivars was also evidenced by the high genetic similarity coefficients ranging from 0.608 to 0.977. Comparing the genetic diversity of the forage bermudagrass cultivars with the above mentioned genetic diversity in Cynodon germplasm, we can see that high potential exists to develop new cultivars if the naturally occurring diverse germplasm is used in fuller extent.
4.6 Breeding Interspecific Hybrid Cultivars Development of improved bermudagrass cultivars for forage and turf utilization has been tremendously successful since the 1940s. In the review report on the 50-year grassland science achievements, Nelson and Burns (2006) note that improved forage bermudagrass has had a dramatic effect on the livestock industry in the southern USA. In a sister report of the 50-year turfgrass research in the USA, Shearman (2006) indicates that improved turf bermudagrass is the most widely grown warm-season turf grass internationally. The breeders have extensively and effectively used interspecific and intraspecific crosses to create segregating populations for selection and evaluation. For forage cultivar development, elite parents from C. dactylon and C. nlemfuensis have been used in interspecific crosses. Similarly, selected plants of C. dactylon and C. transvaalensis have been routinely used in interspecific crosses to develop interspecific hybrid turf bermudagrass cultivars. Bermudagrass can reproduce asexually and sexually. Vegetative propagation of bermudagrass is realized using its shoot cuttings, stolons, rhizomes, or combinations of those. In the turf industry, bermudagrass sod is an important asexual form used in the planting of improved vegetatively propagated turf bermudagrass cultivars. Over the years, equipment has been invented and techniques developed to facilitate
67
the use of clonal bermudagrass cultivars. Vegetative reproduction in bermudagrass maximized profitability of the forage industry for cattle (Bos taurus) by using the very best individual genotypes for farmers and ranchers to plant for grazing and hay (Hanna and Anderson 2008). Burton (1956) clearly indicated using the F1 hybrids provided the means to take advantage of the heterosis exhibited by superior plants in segregating populations. F1 hybrids are fixed in genetic make up, if they are reproduced clonally. The systematic interspecific hybridization research among Cynodon species of Harlan and colleagues in the 1960s provided detailed insights and useful information to guide the future development of interspecific forage bermudagrass cultivars. As discussed above, C. aethiopicus, C. dactylon, C. nlemfuensis, and C. plectostachyus are deemed to be valuable forage germplasm resources, since they are productive in biomass. Since the remaining Cynodon species are not productive, they will not be included in the following discussion. Harlan et al. (1969) indicated that C. plectostachyus is genetically well isolated from C. aethiopicus, C. dactylon, and C. nlemfuensis. The conclusion was made on the basis of extensive hybridizations. More than 500 inflorescences containing 18,555 spikelets emasculated by hand were pollinated with pollen sources of other Cynodon species and those produced just two presumptive hybrid plants (Harlan et al. 1969). Therefore, the potential of using C. plectostachyus in an interspecific breeding program would be quite low. The latter C. aethiopicus, C. dactylon, and C. nlemfuensis species are genetically related but have varying hybridization barriers, which, however, do not completely prevent intercrossing among them. In the hybridization research of Harlan et al. (1969), only five hybrid plants were obtained from numerous crosses between a diploid C. aethiopicus and a tetraploid C. dactylon. They reported six hybrid plants from two pollinated inflorescences between a tetraploid C. aethiopicus and diploid C. nlemfuensis. The research indicates the great difficulty in crossability of C. dactylon with C. aethiopicus but relative ease with C. nlemfuensis. However, the crossability between diploid and tetraploid C. nlemfuensis and tetraploid C. dactylon is relatively high. Crosses of 91 emasculated inflorescences of diploid C. nlemfuensis var. nlemfuensis pollinated with pollen of tetraploid C. dactylon produced 78 hybrid plants, and crosses
68
of 124 inflorescences of both diploid and tetraploid C. nlemfuensis var. robustus with tetraploid C. dactylon produced 126 hybrid plants, indicating weak crossing barriers between the two taxa (Harlan et al. 1969). Their study indicated that diploid interspecific hybrids between the two species were very vigorous and productive. The substantial value of C. nlemfuensis in interspecific hybridization with C. dactylon has been clearly demonstrated in the development of several cultivars, most notably “Coastcross 1” and “Tifton 85”. Tifton 85 has largely supplanted Coastal as the cultivar of choice in the southern USA (34 S latitude) and is being extensively used in many countries in mild climatic areas. Released forage cultivars of bermudagrass (C. dactylon), stargrass (C. nlemfuensis, C. aethiopicus, and C. plectostachyus) and interspecific hybrids were derived from ecotype selection and organized breeding procedures (Taliaferro et al. 2004a). “Coastal” bermudagrass, the most widely used forage bermudagrass cultivar, was developed from the bermudagrass breeding program by Burton at the USDA-ARS, Coastal Plain Experiment Station in Tifton, GA. “Coastal” produced more than twice as much forage as naturalized common bermudagrass (Myers 1951). The performance (body weight gain) of animals grazing bermudagrass including Coastal and other cultivars clearly indicated their high production potential per unit area but relatively low potential on an individual animal basis due to relatively low nutritive value (Elder and Murphy 1961; McCormick et al. 1964). Forage dry matter digestibility is significantly correlated with body weight gains on pasture, with correlation coefficient being 0.797 (McCullough and Neville 1959). Burton et al. (1967) reported that bermudagrass can be improved for dry matter digestibility by using interspecific crosses between C. dactylon with highly digestible C. nlemfuensis. The best F1 hybrid derived from “Coastal” bermudagrass by “Kenya 56 #14” (PI 255445) released as “Coastcross-1” had 12.3% better dry matter digestibility than “Coastal” while both had similar forage yields (Burton et al. 1967; Burton 1972). Consequently, results from a 3-year grazing study indicated that average daily gain of steers on “Coastcross-1” bermudagrass was 29% more than average daily gain of steers on “Coastal” bermudagrass (Burton 1972). “Kenya 56 #14” (PI 255445) was obtained from A. V. Bogdan of Grassland Research Station, Kitale,
Y. Wu
Kenya, in 1958 (Burton 1972). PI 255445 was identified as C. nlemfuensis var. robustus by Harlan (1970) (Taliaferro et al. 2004a). “Tifton 85” bermudagrass is a high yielding and highly digestible hybrid cultivar derived from a cross of C. dactylon var. dactylon PI 290884 by a C. nlemfuensis selection, “Tifton 68” (Burton et al. 1993). Tifton 85 produced 26% more dry matter that was 11% more digestible than Coastal bermudagrass in two replicated small plots tests over 3 years (Burton et al. 1993). Hill et al. (2001) noted lower concentrations of either-linked ferulic acid in Tifton 85, explaining the higher digestibility of Tifton 85 than of Coastal hays. Higher dry matter yield and greater forage digestibility of Tifton 85 than many other forage bermudagrasses allows increased stocking rates and better body weight gain per hectare. The forage cultivar has received increased acceptance for hay production and pastures in the southern US and been grown on more than 1 million ha in Brazil (Hill et al. 2001). The same breeding protocol using crosses between C. dactylon by C. nlemfuensis was and will be used to develop nutritive-value-enhanced bermudagrass cultivars.
4.7 Recommendations for Future Actions Plant germplasm is among the most precious assets on the earth and should be conserved for the future generations. Bermudagrass is among the major perennial warm-season forage grasses in the world. Continuing efforts in the genetic improvement of bermudagrass and related stargrass will be greatly facilitated by a much larger, better evaluated, and carefully preserved germplasm collection. Individual research programs have collected and used Cynodon germplasm in scientific studies and for breeding, but such programs are generally not charged with, or funded for, long-term preservation of the germplasm. Effective collection, evaluation, and long term preservation can best be accomplished by agencies like the USDA NPGS, which has those dedicated responsibilities. However, inadequate funding has limited the ability of such agencies to fulfill their mandate, especially for crops with lesser value than the major food crops. Forty years ago, Harlan noted that only a small fraction of the Cynodon germplasm pool had been studied and
4 Cynodon
even less used in plant improvement programs (Harlan 1970). Taliaferro recently noted that the extent of Cynodon germplasm collected, studied, and used in breeding new cultivars remains basically the same as many years ago (Taliaferro et al. 2004a). This clearly indicates the need of greater efforts in collecting, evaluating, and preserving Cynodon germplasm at local, national, and international levels. Governments and their agencies should make larger and sustained investments in support of Cynodon germplasm research. As Cynodon forage cultivars are used in many countries and Cynodon forage germplasm is not distributed evenly across the world, international collaborations are necessary to facilitate collection and exchange of Cynodon germplasm, communication of research and breeding information, and distribution of improved cultivars.
Acknowledgments The author dedicates the humble chapter to his mentor, Dr. Charles M. Taliaferro, Regents Professor Emeritus of the Oklahoma State University, and also thanks him for his review and comments for improving the manuscript.
References Abulaiti SDS, Yang ZM, Li PY, Zhao Q, Sun ZJ (2003) Xingjiang no 1 bermudagrass. Pratacult Sci 20:30–31 Anderson WF (2005) Development of a forage bermudagrass (Cynodon sp.) core collection. Grassl Sci 51:305–308 Arumuganathan K, Tallury SP, Fraser ML, Bruneau AH, Qu R (1999) Nuclear DNA content of thirteen turfgrass species by flow cytometry. Crop Sci 39:1518–1521 Assefa S, Taliaferro CM, Anderson MP, de los Reyes BG, Edwards RM (1999) Diversity among Cynodon accessions and taxa based on DNA amplification fingerprinting. Genome 42:465–474 Ball DM, Eichhorn MM Jr, Burdett RA Jr, Bice DM (1996) Registration of Russell’ bermudagrass. Crop Sci 36:467 Beard JB (1973) Turfgrass: science and culture. Prentice Hall, New Jersey Beard JB, Watson JR (1982) Recent turfgrass plant explorations in Africa. USGA Green Section Record, July/August: 6–8 Bogdan AV (1977) Tropical pasture and fodder plants (grasses and legumes). Longman Group, London, UK Bouton J (2007) The economic benefits of forage improvement in the United States. Euphytica 154:263–270 Brilman LA, Kneebone WR, Endrizzi JE (1982) Pachytene chromosome morphology of diploid Cynodon dactylon (L.) Pers. Cytologia 47:171–181 Burton GW (1948) Coastal bermudagrass. Cir 10. Georgia Agricultural Experiment Station, Georgia
69 Burton GW (1951) The adaptability and breeding of suitable grasses for the southeastern States. In: Norman AG (ed) Advances in agronomy, vol 3. Academic, New York, pp 197–241 Burton GW (1954) Coastal Bermuda grass for pasture, hay and silage. Bull N.S. 2. Georgia Coastal Plain Experiment Station, Tifton, GA Burton GW (1956) Utilization of heterosis in pasture plant breeding. In: Neale GJ (ed) Proceedings of the 7th international grassland congress, Palmerston North, NZ, 6–12 Nov 1956, Wellington, New Zealand, pp 3–12 Burton GW (1962) Registration of varieties of bermudagrass. Crop Sci 2:352–353 Burton GW (1972) Registration of ‘Coastcross-1’ bermudagrass. Crop Sci 12:125 Burton GW, Hanna WW (1995) Bermudagrass. In: Heath ME, Barnes RF, Metcalfe DS (eds) Forages: the science of grassland and agriculture. Iowa State Univ Press, Ames, IA, pp 421–429 Burton GW, Monson WG (1978) Registration of ‘Tifton 44’ bermudagrass. Crop Sci 18:911 Burton GW, Monson WG (1984) Registration of ‘Tifton 68’ bermudagrass. Crop Sci 24:1211 Burton GW, Monson WG (1988) Registration of ‘Tifton 78’ bermudagrass. Crop Sci 28:187–188 Burton GW, Hart RH, Lowrey RS (1967) Improving forage quality in bermudagrass by breeding. Crop Sci 7:329–332 Burton GW, Gates RN, Hill GM (1993) Registration of ‘Tifton 85’ bermudagrass. Crop Sci 33:644–645 Casler MD, Heaton E, Shinners KJ, Jung HG, Weimer PJ, Liebig MA, Mitchell RB, Digman MF (2009) Grasses and legumes for cellulosic bioenergy. In: Wedin WF, Fales SL (eds) Grassland: quietness and strength for a new American agriculture. ASA, CSSA, and SSSA, Madison, WI, p 213 Clatworthy JN (1985) Pasture research in Zimbabwe: 1964–84. In: Kategile JA (ed) Pasture improvement research in Eastern and Southern Africa. Proceedings of the 1st PANESA workshop, Harare, Zimbabwe, 17–21 Sept 1984. Int Dev Res Center, Ottawa, Canada Clayton WD, Harlan JR (1970) The genus Cynodon L.C. Rich. in tropical Africa. Kew Bull 24:185–189, Her Majesty’s Stationery Office, London, UK Clayton WD, Harman KT (2002) World grass species: synonyms. Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew, UK Clayton WD, Harman KT, Williamson H (2009) GrassBase – the online world grass flora. http://www.kew.org/data/ grasses-db.html. Accessed 30 Apr 2009 Cooper RB, Burton GW (1965) Forage and turf potential of Giant bermudagrass in the southeastern United States. Agron J 57:239–240 Crowder LV, Chheda HR (1982) Tropical grassland husbandry. Longman Group, Essex, England de Silva PHAU, Snaydon RW (1995) Chromosome number in Cynodon dactylon in relation to ecological conditions. Ann Bot 76:535–537 de Wet JMJ, Harlan JR (1970) Biosystematics of Cynodon L.C. Rich. (Gramineae). Taxon 19:565–569 de Wet JMJ, Harlan JR (1971) South African species of Cynodon (Gramineae). J S Afr Bot 37(1):53–56
70 Eichhorn MM Jr, Nelson BD, Montgomery CR, Davis AV, Hallmark WB (1984) Brazos – a new bermudagrass for pasture and hay in Louisiana. In: Didier DET (ed) Louisiana agriculture. Louisiana Agricultural Experiment Station, Baton Rouge, FL, pp 18–19 Eichhorn MM Jr, Oliver WM, Hallmark WB, Young WA, Davis AV, Nelson BD (1986) Registration of ‘Grazer’ bermudagrass. Crop Sci 26:835 Elder WC (1955) Greenfield bermudagrass. Bull B-455. Oklahoma Agricultural Experiment Station, Stillwater, OK Elder WC, Murphy HF (1961) Grazing characteristics and clipping responses of bermudagrass. B-577. Oklahoma Agricultural Experiment Station, Stillwater, OK Forbes I, Burton GW (1963) Chromosome numbers and meiosis in some Cynodon species and hybrids. Crop Sci 3:75–79 GRIN (2009) Summary statistics for GRIN. http://www.ars-grin. gov/npgs/stats/. Accessed 6 Jun 2009 Gulsen O, Sever-Mutlu S, Mutlu N, Tuna M, Karaguzel O, Shearman RC, Riordan TP, Heng-Moss TM (2009) Polyploidy creates higher diversity among Cynodon accessions as assessed by molecular markers. Theor Appl Genet 118:1309–1319 Hanna WW, Anderson WF (2008) Development and impact of vegetative propagation in forage and turf bermudagrasses. Agron J 100:S103–S107 Hanson AA (1972) Grass varieties in the United States. USDA-ARS Agri Handbook 170. US Gov Print Office, Washington, DC Harlan JR (1970) Cynodon species and their value for grazing and hay. Herbag Abstr 40:233–237 Harlan JR, de Wet JMJ (1969) Sources of variation in Cynodon dactylon (L.) Pers. Crop Sci 9:774–778 Harlan JR, Burton GW, Elder WC (1954) Midland bermudagrass, a new variety for Oklahoma pastures. Bull B-416. Oklahoma Agricultural Experiment Station, Stillwater, OK Harlan JR, de Wet JMJ, Richardson WL (1969) Hybridization studies with species of Cynodon from east Africa and Malagasy. Am J Bot 56:944–950 Harlan JR, de Wet JMJ, Rawal KM (1970a) Origin and distribution of the seleucidus race of Cynodon dactylon (L.) Pers. var. dactylon (Gramineae). Euphytica 19:465–469 Harlan JR, de Wet JMJ, Huffine WW, Deakin JR (1970b) A guide to the species of Cynodon (Gramineae), Bull B-673. Oklahoma Agricultural Experiment Station, Stillwater, OK Harlan JR, de Wet JMJ, Rawal KM, Felder MR, Richardson WL (1970c) Cytogenetic studies in Cynodon L. C. Rich (Gramineae). Crop Sci 10:288–291 Hein MA (1953) Registration of varieties and strains of bermudagrass, II [Cynodon dactylon (L.) Pers.]. Agron J 45: 572–573 Hill GM, Gates RN, West JW (2001) Advances in bermudagrass research involving new cultivars for beef and dairy production. J Anim Sci 79(E suppl):E48–E58 Hodges EM, Boyd FT, Dunavin LS, Kretschmer AE Jr, Mislevy P, Stanley RL Jr (1975) ‘McCaleb’ stargrass. Circ S-231. Florida Agricultural Experiment Station, Gainesville, FL Hodges EM, Mislevy P, Dunavin LS, Ruelke OC, Stanley RL Jr (1984) ‘Ona’ stargrass. Circ S-268A. Florida Agricultural Experiment Station, Gainesville, FL Hurcombe R (1947) A cytological and morphological study of cultivated Cynodon species. J S Afr Bot 13:107–116
Y. Wu Kang SY, Lee GJ, Lim KB, Lee HJ, Park IS, Chung SJ, Kim JB, Kim DS, Rhee HK (2008) Genetic diversity among Korean bermudagrass (Cynodon spp.) ecotypes characterized by morphological, cytological and molecular approaches. Mol Cells 25:163–171 Karaca M, Saha S, Zipf A, Jenkins JN, Lang DJ (2002) Genetic diversity among forage bermudagrass (Cynodon spp.): evidence from chloroplast and nuclear DNA fingerprinting. Crop Sci 42:2118–2127 Kneebone WR (1966) Bermuda grass – worldly, wily, wonderful weed. Econ Bot 20:94–97 Liu JX, Guo AG, Guo HL (2003) Morphological variation and types of Cynodon dactylon. Acta Pratacult Sin 12:99–104 Malik CP, Tripathi RC (1968) Cytological evolution within the Cynodon dactylon complex. Biol Zent Bl 87:625–627 McCormick WC, Marchant WH, Southwell BL (1964) Effect of stocking level on gains of steers grazing coastal bermudagrass. Georgia Agricultural Experiment Station, Georgia McCullough ME, Neville WE (1959) Some factors affecting weight gains of dairy heifers fed all rough rations. J Dairy Sci 42:1698–1702 Mislevy P, Brown WF, Caro-Costas R, Vicente-Chandler J, Dunavin LS, Hall DW, Kalmbacher RS, Overman AJ, Ruelke OC, Sonoda RM, Sotomayor-Rios A, Stanley RL Jr, Williams MJ (1989a) ‘Florico’ stargrass. Circ S-361. Florida Agricultural Experiment Station, Gainsville, FL Mislevy P, Brown WF, Dunavin LS, Hall DW, Kalmbacher RS, Overman AJ, Ruelke OC, Sonoda RM, Stanley RL Jr, Williams MJ (1989b) ‘Florona’ stargrass. Circ S-362. Florida Agricultural Experiment Station, Gainsville, FL Mislevy P, Brown WF, Kalmbacher RS, Dunavin LS, Judd WS, Kucharek TA, Ruelke OC, Noling JW, Sonoda RM, Stanley RL Jr (1999) Registration of Florakirk bermudagrass. Crop Sci 39:587 Myers WM (1951) Registration of varieties and strains of bermudagrass [Cynodon dactylon (L.) Pers.]. Agron J 43: 240 Nelson C, Burns JC (2006) Fifty years of grassland science leading to change. Crop Sci 46:2204–2217 Ourecky DK (1963) Pachytene chromosome morphology in Cynodon dactylon (L.) Pers. Nucleus 6:63–82 Reed BM, Schumacher L, Wang N, D’Achino J, Barker RE (2005) Cryopreservation of bermudagrass germplasm by encapsulation dehydration. Crop Sci 46:6–11 Samudio SH, Brede AD (1998) Registration of ‘Cheyenne’ bermudagrass. Crop Sci 38:279 Shearman RC (2006) Fifty years of splendor in the grass. Crop Sci 46:2218–2229 Taliaferro CM (1986) Bermudagrass germplasm resources for beef production. In: Visiting scholar lectures, special report 122. Arkansas Agricultural Experiment Station, Fayetteville, AR, pp 5–19 Taliaferro CM (2003) Bermudagrass. In: Casler MD, Duncan R (eds) Turfgrass biology, genetics and breeding. Wiley, New York, pp 235–256 Taliaferro CM, Richardson WL (1980) Registration of Hardie bermudagrass. Crop Sci 20:413 Taliaferro CM, Ahring RM, Richardson WL (1983) Registration of Guyman bermudagrass. Crop Sci 23:1219
4 Cynodon Taliaferro CM, Hopkins AA, Henthorn JC, Murphy CD, Edwards RM (1997) Use of flow cytometry to estimate ploidy level in Cynodon species. Int Turfgrass Soc Res J 8:385–392 Taliaferro CM, Anderson JA, Richardson WL, Baker JL, Coleman SW, Phillips WL, Sandage JL, Moyer JL, Hanson TL, Kallenbach RL, Crawford RJ (2002) Registration of ‘Midland 99’ bermudagrass. Crop Sci 42:2212–2213 Taliaferro CM, Rouquette FM Jr, Mislevy P (2004a) Bermudagrass and stargrass. In: Moser LE, Burson BL, Sollenberger LE (eds) Warm-season (C4) grasses, vol 45, Agron Monogr. ASA, CSSA, and SSSA, Madison, WI, pp 417–475 Taliaferro CM, Martin DL, Anderson JA, Anderson MP, Guenzi AC (2004b) Broadening the horizons of turf bermudagrass. USGA Turfgrass Environ Res Online 3(2):1–9 Tracy SM (1917) Bermuda grass, farmer’s bulletin 814. United States Department of Agriculture, US Gov Print Office, Washington, DC Watson VH (1974) A chronological review of the selection, research, and distribution of a bermudagrass called Callie. Rep Mississippi Agricultural Experiment Station, Starkville, MS Wu YQ, Taliaferro CM (2009) Bermudagrass. In: Singh RJ (ed) Genetic resources, chromosome engineering, and crop improvement, vol 5, Forage crops. CRC Press, New York, pp 229–273
71 Wu YQ, Liu LL, Xiong X, Xu XG, Wang Z, Yan Y (2001) Utilization and evaluation of native germplasm of bermudagrass in Sichuan. Grassl Turf 94:32–34 Wu YQ, Taliaferro CM, Bai GH, Anderson MP (2004) AFLP analysis of Cynodon dactylon (L.) Pers. var. dactylon genetic variation. Genome 47:689–696 Wu YQ, Taliaferro CM, Bai GH, Martin DL, Anderson JA, Anderson MP, Edwards RM (2006a) Genetic analyses of Chinese Cynodon accessions by flow cytometry and AFLP markers. Crop Sci 46:917–926 Wu YQ, Taliaferro CM, Martin DL, Goad CL, Anderson AJ (2006b) Genetic variability and relationships for seed yield and its components in Chinese Cynodon accessions. Field Crops Res 98:245–252 Wu YQ, Taliaferro CM, Martin DL, Anderson AJ, Anderson MP (2007) Genetic variability and relationships for adaptive, morphological, and biomass traits in Chinese bermudagrass accessions. Crop Sci 47:1985–1994 Wu YQ, Taliaferro CM, Kochenower R (2008) Development of ‘Goodwell’ forage bermudagrass. Joint Annual Meeting of GSA, SSSA-ASA-CSSA, and GCAGS, Oct 5–9, Houston, TX, USA Yi YJ, Zhang XQ, Huang LK, Ling Y, Ma X, Li W (2008) Genetic diversity of wild Cynodon dactylon germplasm detected by SRAP markers. Hereditas (Beijing) 30(1): 94–100
.
Chapter 5
Dactylis Alan V. Stewart and Nicholas W. Ellison
5.1 Introduction The genus Dactylis consists of a single perennial forage species, Dactylis glomerata L. known as orchardgrass or cocksfoot. The basic chromosome number is 2n ¼ 14 and, although the species consists of diploids, tetraploids and a hexaploid, the commonly used forage form is tetraploid. Dactylis species have only rarely been crossed with species outside this genus (Nakazumi et al. 1997) and the genus is not closely related to any major crop. Therefore, the story of Dactylis wild relatives is largely one of the diversity within the genus. Although the distribution and diversity of Dactylis is complex, much of this can be readily explained by its evolutionary, migrational and genomic history over the last few hundred thousand years. The understanding of the diversity within the wild relatives of Dactylis has considerable implications for germplasm collection and conservation as well as for the breeding techniques employed. There is considerable urgency to make sure that all the geographically diverse diploid subspecies are collected and represented in genebanks.
fourth most widely used grass genus with 3.3% of the world’s temperate seed, following Lolium, Festuca and Phleum (Bondesen 2007). It is almost never used for turf despite fine dense turf forming types being available. This may be because of the limitations imposed by seed yield and subsequent seed price as well as suitable cultivars.
5.3 Basic Botany of the Species 5.3.1 Morphology D. glomerata is in general a perennial bunchgrass. Forms adapted to more humid habitats usually have large tillers and broad leaves while those adapted to drier conditions exhibit a more xeromorphic form with a greater number of smaller tillers with narrower glaucous leaves. Some forms growing on coastal cliffs have branching stems, which sprawl along the ground, even hanging in some situations.
5.3.2 Taxonomy of D. glomerata L 5.2 Agricultural Status D. glomerata is an important forage grass in the temperate areas of the world. Each year approximately 14,000 tons of seed is harvested making it the A.V. Stewart (*) PGG Wrightson Seeds, PO Box 175, Lincoln, Christchurch 7640, New Zealand e-mail:
[email protected]
As a genus Dactylis is subject to differing taxonomic interpretations in different regions of its natural range (Europe, Asia, North Africa and the Canary Islands). There are no modern taxonomic treatments which interpret all forms on the same basis. Here we interpret D. glomerata to be monotypic consisting of one diverse species complex (Jogan 2002). The genus however, is clearly on the verge of speciation with many diploid, tetraploid and a hexaploid subspecies
C. Kole (ed.), Wild Crop Relatives: Genomic and Breeding Resources, Millets and Grasses, DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-14255-0_5, # Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
73
74
A.V. Stewart and N.W. Ellison
altaica
G 510 T
28 ITS 1 cp
Lamarckia aurea
C 90 T A 613 G
C 55 T A 425 G
G 92 C
judaica
A 571 G lusitanica T 190 C
A 601 G C 649 A C cp444 T
ibizensis G 610 A
izcoi juncinella
G 475 T
592 T insert santai sinensis aschersoniana castellata smithii
parthiana
himalayensis
cpDNA Del 287
C 627 T mairei
woronowii
Fig. 5.1 Molecular descent in diploid Dactylis glomerata using ITS and trnL intron chloroplast sequences (Numbers refer to mutations in the ITS or chloroplast (cp) sequences)
and some reduction in fertility when different diploid forms are crossed (Borrill 1977).
5.3.2.1 Diploid D. glomerata Forms Today almost all diploid populations have restricted ranges, indicative of a remnant distribution from a former widespread range. The populations are usually described as subspecies, or sometimes even species, and publications vary as to their interpretation. Here we will not enter into any taxonomic debate but recognize them as discreet remnant geographic populations. They occur from China across to Portugal and North Africa as well as on to nearby north Atlantic islands such as the Canary Islands and Cape Verde.
5.3.2.2 Origin of Diploids It is very clear that Dactylis originated as a diploid and that the polyploids have developed from them. Molecular information on diploids using the nuclear internal transcribed spacer (ITS) and trnL intron chloroplast sequences, reported here for the first time, support the
hypothesis that the diploid progenitor originated in, and migrated out from Central Asia (Fig. 5.1). This progenitor is probably very similar to subsp. altaica. We have observed no more than 2–7 ITS mutations and only 0 or 1 trnL intron chloroplast mutation in any of the diploid Dactylis lineages and this allows an estimate of timing of the original divergence. The rate at which ITS and chloroplast sequences mutate depends on many factors including effective population size, annual or perennial habit, and the breeding system. In annual grasses, such as barley and maize, the ITS mutation rate has been calculated to be approximately one mutation every 23,000 years (Zurawski et al. 1984), while the rate in perennial grasses is slower and potentially similar to that observed in perennial Phleum, where Stewart et al. (2008) observed the most rapidly changing lineage to be one in 30,000 years. Chloroplast genome trnL intron mutation rates are usually 3–8 times slower, with one per 200,000 years in rice and maize (Yamane et al. 2006) and one per 90,000 years for the most rapidly changing perennial Phleum lineage (Stewart et al. 2008). These rates for Dactylis would suggest that the first divergence occurred in the order of 60,000–210,000 years BP, a date which is far more recent by orders of
5 Dactylis
magnitude than the 10 million years, or more, dating back to the tertiary period postulated by Stebbins and Zohary (1959) who used geological events as the explanation. However, it is only with the recent advent of molecular data that the powerful influence of historical glaciation events on plant migration and evolution have become to be fully appreciated (Hewitt 1999). This relatively recent origin for Dactylis is much more consistent with the perceived interglacial age of many of the tetraploids (Lumaret 1986) and there is no reason to believe that the process of tetraploidy was not initiated early in the development of Dactylis. This time period is also consistent with the observation that, while there is sufficient genetic differentiation to result in reduced fertility among crosses of the diploid subspecies, there are no major structural chromosomal differences (Borrill 1977). One of the closest genera to Dactylis is Lamarckia, and L. aurea diverged from it with more than 28 ITS sequences differences and 1–2 trnlL intron chloroplast differences (Fig. 5.1). As L. aurea is an annual, these differences suggest a divergence time in the order of 200,000–750,000 years BP. The first molecular divergence within Dactylis (Fig. 5.1) divides judaica, himalayensis and the paternal side of parthiana from the remaining diploids. This is consistent with an origin in Central Asia for Dactylis and an early geographic split leaving the ancestors of judaica, himalayensis and parthiana spread widely over the southern regions of Western Asia, and the ancestors of the remaining diploids in the north-west of this region. The remaining diploids exhibit a second divergence (Fig. 5.1) with the Spanish forms lusitanica, izcoi, juncinella and ibizensis splitting off from the group. This is consistent with a migration through the Eurasian temperate forest regions from the Caucasus to Portugal. This most probably occurred during a warm interglacial period, probably 75,000–150,000 years BP, when conditions allowed continuous distribution of temperate forest in Europe. This European form has since migrated into North Africa and over to China as the molecular profiles of aschersoniana, santai, “castellata”, smithii and sinensis are identical, with both woronowii and mairei derived from this group. The lack of molecular differences suggests a relatively recent migration, probably no older than the last glacial period. Glaciation in Europe forced the European flora south into dissected
75
glacial refugia at lower altitudes or latitudes (Hewitt 1999) and allowed Dactylis to expand into the extensive North African grasslands. Subsp. woronowii shows a very similar flavonoid composition to aschersoniana (Lumaret 1988) and exhibits a molecular sequence derived from it, but its morphological characteristics are more similar to other xeromorphic Mediterranean types. It is likely that this entity originated from the forest margin dwelling aschersoniana to become the first xeromorphic form adapted to drier grassland conditions during the interglacial period. Ancestors of smithii would have easily migrated the 100 km from North Africa to the Canary Islands, and it is likely that bird migration was responsible for the larger 1,500 km movement to the Cape Verde Islands. The origin of smithii from aschersoniana and/or woronowii is one of the options put forward by Stebbins. In his opinion smithii was either a very old remnant equally as old as aschersoniana, or a recent migrant via North Africa (Stebbins and Zohary 1959). Its unique morphological characteristics made him favor the former option whereas our molecular data support a more recent migration via North Africa. Sahuquillo and Lumaret (1999) also provide evidence of tetraploid Dactylis migrations from North Africa to the Canary Islands, they used chloroplast molecular markers supported by morphological, allozyme and phenolic indicators. In the post-glacial period as the climate became warmer and drier North African grasslands contracted leaving dissected remnant populations, mairei in the Kerrata Gorge of Algeria, santai and “castellata” in Algeria and Morocco, and smithii in the Canary and Cape Verde Islands. As the glaciated conditions of northern Europe contracted, the northern temperate forms could migrate from their glacial refugia to high altitudes or latitudes. The European progenitor of aschersoniana in particular was able to recolonize northern Europe from a probable refuge in the Caucasus region, even extending to the east to China as sinensis. It seems probable also that the tetraploids also recolonized Europe to cover northern regions so successfully that they excluded the expansion of the remaining diploids. The Iberian lusitanica progenitor was able to migrate throughout Iberia so that today we have a dissected distribution with lusitanica in central Portugal,
76
izcoi in Galicia and juncinella in the Sierra Nevada Mountains. The ancestral form also migrated to the Balearic Isle, where ibizensis occurs today. The Iberian Peninsula is composed of a complex set of different glacial refugia which, if understood, may help explain the relationships between the different forms present today (Go´mez and Lunt 2006). It is also apparent from hybrid ITS sequences of tetraploids in North Africa, the Canary Islands and Spain that many of these forms have resulted from hybridization between North African and Spanish forms. It is clear also that parthiana has been influenced by genetic introgression from overlapping woronowii populations. The probable migration of the diploids determined from the molecular research is outlined in Fig. 5.2. As yet we have been unable to obtain samples of hyrcana, reichenbachii, metlesicsii or smithii from Cape Verde to determine their origins.
A.V. Stewart and N.W. Ellison
Himalayensis D. glomerata subsp. himalayensis Domin occurs in the western Himalayas at altitudes of 1,800–4,000 m in cool temperate forest zones.
Sinensis D. glomerata subsp. sinensis Camus occurs in Sichuan, Hubei, Guizhou, Xinjiang and Yunnan in central China, at altitudes of 1,000–3,800 m in cool temperate forest zones. Although some authors have classified these Chinese forms into himalayensis (Stebbins and Zohary 1959; Borrill 1977) the molecular differences reported here and the genetic differences reported by Lumaret (1987) provide considerable support to maintaining sinensis as separate from himalayensis.
5.3.2.3 The Diploid Subspecies
Altaica
The following are the known diploid remnant populations:
The diploid D. glomerata subsp. altaica (Bess.) Domin occurs in the Alatau Mountains of Kazakhstan (Czerepanov 1981; Mizianty 1991). The one sample
Fig. 5.2 Probable migration routes of diploid Dactylis based on molecular results. (black lines – before glaciation, dashed lines – North Africa during the glaciation; dotted lines – post-glacial, Northern Europe and China)
5 Dactylis
that we have obtained from this region had an ITS sequence basal to all other diploid Dactylis forms (Fig. 5.1). No collections are available in genebanks and collection must be a priority.
77
can not discount the possibility that this genebank accession of parthiana was collected in the zone of hybridization and that those higher altitude forms which may be collected less frequently may be more “pure”.
Aschersoniana D. glomerata subsp. lobata (Drejer) Lindb. subsp. aschersoniana (Graebn.) Thell. D. aschersoniana Graebn. D. polygama Horv. subsp. polygama (Horv.) Domin occurs mostly in deciduous forests from the Caucasus Mountains across central Europe, into Sweden in the north, western Russia in the east, south into Yugoslavia and northern Macedonia. This distribution is typical of a species recolonizing Europe from a glacial refuge in the Caucasus region (Hewitt 1999). The habitats of aschersoniana and himalayensis are similar as they both occur in cool temperate forests in continental climates often at high altitudes and they bear a close resemblance in isozyme allelic patterns (Lumaret 1988), flavone phytochemistry (Lumaret 1988), DNA content (Tuna et al. 2007) and morphology, so much so that the geographic origin is often necessary to correctly assign them to the appropriate taxa (Stebbins and Zohary 1959). This form has potentiality to be used in agriculture (Stuczynski 1992) and there is at least one commercial cultivar, Tosca, bred in the Czech Republic (Mı´ka et al. 1999).
Parthiana D. glomerata subsp. parthiana Parker et Borrill. occurs in the moist oak woodlands on the northern slopes of the Elburz Mountains of Iran between 1,600 and 1,900 m. At lower altitudes its distribution overlaps with woronowii and hybrid plants occur (Borrill and Carroll 1969). Parker and Borrill (1968) showed that artificial hybrids of this cross are fully fertile. Our molecular results provide confirmation of this hybridization in the only genebank accession available, which combines a himalayensis type ITS sequence with a woronowii type chloroplast sequence. Similarly, flavone phytochemistry has shown that both parental pathways are present (Ardouin et al. 1985), and electrophoretic patterns are also more variable than other subspecies (Lumaret 1988). However, we
Reichenbachii D. glomerata subsp. reichenbachii (Dalla Torre et Sarnth.) Stebbins et Zohary D. reichenbachii (Dalla Torre et Sarnth.) Meusel occurs on south-facing meadows on dolomite soils of the European Alps and French Massif Central (Speranza and Cristofolini 1987). Although we were unable to obtain a sample for molecular analysis, flavonoid phytochemistry places this between aschersoniana and lusitanica (Fiasson et al. 1987), while isozyme data places it very close to aschersoniana and himalayensis (Lumaret 1988). Stebbins and Zohary (1959) note that this form is highly variable exhibiting characteristics of both woronowii and aschersoniana, and is likely to be an edaphic remnant of the original European temperate forest flora.
Lusitanica D. glomerata subsp. lusitanica Stebbins et Zohary is restricted to the Serra de Sintra, and a few other localities in central-southern Portugal (Stebbins and Zohary 1959). It appears to be a remnant temperate forest species of the mildest temperate forest zone.
Iscoi D. glomerata subsp. izcoi Ortiz et Rodriguez-Oubina, has also often been referred to as “Galician diploid”. This temperate form occurs in Galicia, Spain, persisting in forest habitats at altitudes of 400–650 m (Ortiz and Rodriguez-Oubin˜a 1993; Lindner et al. 2004). It shows the greatest molecular similarity with juncinella and both must have developed from populations in the same complex glacial refugia of the Iberian Peninsula (Go´mez and Lunt 2006). The UK commercial cultivar Conrad is a diploid izcoi type (Borrill 1977).
78
Woronowii D. glomerata subsp. woronowii (Ovcz.) Stebbins et Zohary D. woronowii Ovcz. is a xeromorphic grassland taxon in the mountain steppes and steppe forests in northern and north-eastern Iran and adjacent Turkmenistan (Stebbins and Zohary 1959). It occurs on dry base-rich limestone outcrops in open thorn scrub up to 1,500 m in the Elburz Mountains (Borrill and Carroll 1969). Sympatric tetraploids are also common in this region (Doroszewska 1963).
Hyrcana D. glomerata subsp. hyrcana Tzvelev is an endemic subspecies of deciduous woods in the Talish plains of Azerbaijan and Iran at 200–300 m altitude (Tzvelev 1983). We were unable to obtain samples so it is unclear how this relates to the others but its habitat appears to be an extension of the range of woronowii and it is likely to be closely related to it.
Mairei D. glomerata subsp. mairei Stebbins et Zohary is confined to shaded limestone cliffs of the Kerrata Gorge in Algeria with a relatively high annual rainfall of 1,100–2,000 mm (Stebbins and Zohary 1959). It is highly probable that since the last glaciation its range has become restricted as the North African grasslands have declined (Borrill and Lindner 1971). Molecular, isozyme (Lumaret 1988) and flavone data (Ardouin et al. 1985) show that it exhibits close phylogenetic affinity to “castellata”, santai, smithii and woronowii. This form is an isolated remnant of a diploid widespread in the North African grasslands since the last glaciation (Borrill and Lindner 1971).
Santai and “castellata” D. glomerata subsp. santai Stebbins et Zohary and subsp. “castellata”. occur in western Algeria to western Morocco at 150–1,500 m in the Tell Atlas, in humid and subhumid bioclimates (Amirouche and Misset 2007). Flavonoid phytochemistry and enzyme data fail to differentiate between “castellata” and santai,
A.V. Stewart and N.W. Ellison
as do morphological comparisons, so these two probably do not deserve separate subspecies status (Lumaret 1988; Amirouche and Misset 2007). The names, however, may remain useful as indicators of geographic origin with “castellata” from Algeria and santai from Morocco. The Moroccan forms of santai show characteristics of the nearby ibizensis diploid (Mousset 2000) and this is also apparent in hybrid ITS sequences which suggest introgression from nearby southern Spanish forms.
Smithii D. glomerata subsp. smithii D. smithii Link. occurs in the wetter sides of the Canary Islands at altitudes of 100–700 m. It has a distinctive growth habit with branching culms with numerous nodes (Stebbins and Zohary 1959). Today its habitat has reduced because of construction in this zone. The form on the Cape Verde Islands at 1,200 m is most probably extinct (Lumaret pers. comm.). Isozyme studies group smithii near mairei, santai and “castellata” (Lumaret 1988). In hybridization studies there was evidence for cytoplasmic and nuclear differentiation in smithii (Parker and Borrill 1968). Clearly smithii is the most differentiated in a range of features. Its habitat is more subtropical and this has influenced its flavonoid chemistry and morphology greatly (Ardouin et al. 1985). Its flowering habit has changed so that it requires little vernalization for flowering and its trailing habit may be due to a lack of apical dominance.
Metlesicii Dactylis metlesicsii Scho¨nfelder et D. Ludwig occurs at a high altitude in the Canary Islands and is potentially a high altitude form of smithii (Scho¨nfelder and Ludwig 1996) or results from a separate migration into the Canary Islands. We have not been able to obtain a sample of this form for analysis. This form is listed as an endangered species in the Spanish Red List, although one could question its species status. Analysis of phenolic compounds showed that high altitude tetraploid forms from Gran Canary Island were well differentiated from the lower altitude forms in the region (Jay and Lumaret 1995). This
5 Dactylis
suggests that diploid metlesicsii may well be substantially different from lower altitude smithii.
79
D. glomerata subsp. juncinella (Bory) Boiss occurs in the Sierra Nevada range in Spain at altitudes of 2,200–2,900 m in the subalpine and alpine herb belt. Its flavonoid phytochemistry exhibits similarity to lusitanica, ibizensis, and less so to izcoi (Ardouin et al.1985). Hybridization studies suggest a close relationship between juncinella and ibizensis and a reasonably close relationship between smithii and juncinella (Wei-Lin Hu and Timothy 1971).
This supports a recent post-glacial change from the temperate form to the more summer dormant xeromorphic Mediterranean form. Judaica is also most probably a relic population of the Eurasian temperate flora that extended into the ancient forests of Lebanon and Israel. However, the rapid post-glacial warming and drying of the climate in this region has forced it to adopt a xeromorphic growth pattern and morphology in response to the Mediterranean climate. This is supported by a heterogeneous flavone phytochemistry with some individuals showing characteristics of “temperate” phenolics (Ardouin et al. 1985), a phenomenon attributed to evolutionary lag between a temperate electrophoretical pattern (Lumaret 1984, 1986) and Mediterranean morphology (Borrill 1977).
Ibizensis
5.3.2.4 Tetraploid D. glomerata Forms
D. glomerata subsp. nestorii Rossello et L. Sa´ez D. ibizensis Gandoger subsp. ibizensis (Gandoger) Stebbins et Zohary. Although renamed subsp. nestorii by Castro et al. (2007), it is still commonly known as ibizensis in almost all of the literature. It occurs on the Balearic Isle near Spain and is derived from the original Spanish forms but with some molecular introgression from nearby North African mairei. Sympatric tetraploid forms also occur on this Island (Castro et al. 2007).
Tetraploids occupy almost the full range of the species and consist of both autotetraploids based on single diploid subspecies, and interecotypic hybrids based on more than one diploid subspecies. These interecotypic tetraploids often have a selective advantage over their diploid counterparts.
Juncinella
Judaica D. glomerata subsp. judaica Stebbins et Zohary, and subsp. lebanotica. Subsp. judaica occurs in the hills of Israel while lebonotica occurs in Lebanon (Stebbins and Zohary 1959; Apiron and Zohary 1961) and potentially also in Syria. Whether these deserve taxonomic differentiation is doubtful but the names at least have value as indicators of geographic origin. It has a Mediterranean summer dormant growth pattern yet the molecular results show that it has developed from a temperate himalayensis progenitor. The heterogeneous flavone phytochemistry of judaica shows some individuals having characteristics of “temperate” phenolics (Ardouin et al. 1985). This heterogeneity could be related to the evolutionary lag between temperate patterns (Lumaret 1984, 1986) and Mediterranean morphology (Borrill 1977).
5.3.2.5 Origin of Tetraploids It seems likely that the process of tetraploidization was initiated early in the development of Dactylis. Unreduced gametes are known to occur frequently in diploid populations and gene flow is largely from diploids to tetraploid with triploids generally being aborted at an early stage (Lumaret and Barrientos 1990; Lumaret et al. 1992). Early tetraploids were most probably autotetraploids in the sense that they were based upon only one diploid population and as such they may never have had any selective advantage over their diploid counterparts. However, with the forced retreat of both diploids and tetraploids into confined glacial refugia during the last glaciation, some tetraploids were able to benefit from gene exchange with a number of ecologically divergent diploid populations. These interecotypic hybrid tetraploids often gain considerable evolutionary success by their hybrid vigor and their enhanced genetic variation (Stebbins 1971). According to Soltis and Soltis (1993) tetraploids have more polymorphic loci than diploids, 0.80 compared
80
to 0.70, higher heterozygosity, 0.43 compared to 0.17, and a greater number of alleles per locus, 2.36 compared to 1.51. The hybrid vigor obtained from these interecotypic tetraploids readily allowed them to dominate the post-glacial expansion to such an extent that we have an almost continuous distribution of tetraploids over the full range of the species today (Lumaret 1986). Autotetraploids frequently have a sympatric distribution with the diploid population that they are based upon (Borrill and Lindner 1971; Lumaret et al. 1989) while interecotypic hybrid tetraploids based on multiple diploid populations are more widespread. It is commonly reported that almost all the diploid entities have a sympatric association of autotetraploids or at least tetraploids derived predominantly from a single diploid. Often this coexistence is dependent upon each occupying different ecological niches (Maceira et al. 1993). The taxonomically distinguishable tetraploid subspecies include the widespread glomerata, the taller calciphilous slovenica, the xeromorphic hispanica, the seaside forms of marina hackelii and oceanica and the cliffside hylodes. However, it is probably fair to conclude that the tetraploid entities merge into one complex species where characters vary along mutually independent clines (Speranza and Cristofolini 1986).
5.3.2.6 The Tetraploid Subspecies
A.V. Stewart and N.W. Ellison
Stebbins also notes that as reichenbachii is similar to woronowii in many features it is possible that some glomerata have developed from the hybridization of reichenbachii and aschersoniana in the Alps where they occur together. Domin (1943) notes that the primary distribution of subsp. glomerata is in Northern Europe but that it has a secondary distribution in the temperate forest regions of Algeria and Morocco. However, in this case it is likely that the ancestral diploids of the two forms may be different. Although subsp. glomerata is usually considered to be summer active and hispanica summer dormant, glomerata forms with summer dormancy are known to occur in the Languedoc-Roussillon Mediterranean climatic region of France (Mousset 1995).
Slovenica D. glomerata subsp. slovenica (Domin) Domin D. slovenica Domin occurs in the mountains of Central Europe mostly at altitudes between 600 and 1,300 m and usually on calcareous or dolomitic soils (Fig. 5.3; Mizianty 1997). One of the most notable characteristics of slovenica is its plant height which can be up to 1.5 m (Domin 1943). It is likely that diploid aschersoniana has contributed to this form as they are both tall and have a hairless keel and margin (or few hairs) (Mizianty and Cenci 1995). The current distribution suggests that it has spread from a glacial refuge in the Alps or Carpathians.
Five tetraploid subspecies are recognized. Hispanica Glomerata D. glomerata L. subsp. glomerata is the most widespread tetraploid entity of temperate forest regions and is the form most widely used in agriculture. Stebbins and Zohary (1959) suggest that it may have developed from the interecotypic hybridization between aschersoniana and woronowii, as artificial hybrids are intermediate between the two and indistinguishable from subsp. glomerata. These subspecies occur in close geographic proximity and both could indeed have provided the very broad interecotypic tetraploids necessary for successful colonization of Europe from the Caucasus glacial refugia.
D. glomerata subsp. hispanica (Roth) Nyman D. hispanica Roth is widespread in the Mediterranean region from the Iberian Peninsula to the Crimea and Caucasus. It is xeromorphic exhibiting a smaller plant size with a compact panicle of limited branching (Speranza and Cristofolini 1986). It usually exhibits early flowering and a summer dormant growth pattern which provides good drought tolerance. Domin (1943) notes that hispanica is a variable complex with one stable feature, having lemmas divided into two blunt lobes from the middle of which is a short awnlet, or a mere point which sometimes does not reach the size of an awn. This lobed
5 Dactylis
81
Fig. 5.3 Distribution of Dactylis glomerata subsp. slovenica [after Mizianty (1997)]
characteristic is less pronounced in the north where it shows a transition towards the large growing glomerata plants used in agriculture. The summer dormant forms in the LanguedocRoussillon Mediterranean region of France represent hybrids, or introgression hybrids, of hispanica and glomerata (Lumaret 1986). A number of summer dormant cultivars developed of hispanica types from Mediterranean germplasm including Uplands, Sendace, Berber, Kasba, (Australia), Jana (Italy), Medly (France), Perouvia and Chrysopigi (Greece), and germplasm of this form offer considerable potentiality for breeding cultivars suited to Mediterranean climates.
provide the plant with an advantage under coastal conditions. The smooth leaf margin trait is believed to enhance palatability (van Dijk 1961) while the herbage has superior digestibility in the order of 2–6%. For this reason marina has attracted the attention of plant breeders (Tyler and Borrill 1983) but as yet this feature has not resulted in any cultivar, presumably because marina crosses have not had adequate yields. Marina is believed to have arisen from diploids closely associated with smithii and ibizensis (Borrill 1961). However, it is also possible that the characteristic smooth leaf margins, papillose epidermis and glaucous appearance could arise in material of different origins as well.
Marina
Oceanica
D. glomerata subsp. hackelii (Asch. et Graeb.) Cif. et Giacom. D. marina Borrill D. glomerata L. subsp. marina (Borrill) Greuter D. smithii Link subsp. marina (Borrill) Parker is localized on sea cliffs of the Mediterranean extending along the coast of Southwest Europe (Portugal and Galicia) and the Atlantic Islands (Borrill 1961; Fig. 5.4). Marina is characterized by smooth leaf margins devoid of silicified teeth, papillose epidermis and a particularly glaucous appearance, all features which
D. glomerata subsp. oceanica G. Guignard occurs on the coast of southern France and the Atlantic and the Channel coasts of north-western France (Guignard 1985). This form could potentially be viewed as an extension of the range of the marina type into northern Europe, however, the marina types of the Mediterranean exhibit many hispanica features while oceanica exhibits many glomerata features. Forms similar to oceanica have been observed along the coast of Cornwall and an Irish island (Lumaret 1988).
82
A.V. Stewart and N.W. Ellison
Fig. 5.4 Distribution of Dactylis glomerata subsp. marina [after Borrill (1961)]
Hylodes D. glomerata subsp. hylodes P.F. Parker is confined to inland cliffs of Madeira, Canary Islands, and Cape Verde whereas marina occurs on the coastal cliffs (Parker 1972). This subspecies is closely related to the diploid smithii with persistent, trailing, woody stems and papillose leaves. Parker (1972) noted that both hybridization and polyploidy have provided a physiological versatility allowing this subspecies to maintain a wider distribution than smithii. Our molecular results show that these tetraploids have profiles from both smithii and Spanish diploids.
5.3.2.7 Hexaploid D. glomerata Hexaploid populations have been reported from a restricted range within Libya and western Egypt (Jones et al. 1961; Jones 1962). Potentially these are also interecotypic polyploids, but little is known of their origin. Two hexaploid plants are reported from the coast near Pontevedra in Galicia, Spain but these are probably rogue individuals within the local tetraploid rather than a self maintaining hexaploid population (Horjales et al. 1995).
5.3.3 Climatic Races The development of climatic races has been part of the continuing process of adaptive radiation with climatic races adapted to drier conditions and also to warmer subtropical conditions. The oldest diploid forms such as altaica, himalayensis and aschersoniana adapted to temperate forest margins, while their derivative woronowii developed xeromorphic features as it expanded into the drier grasslands of western and central Asia. These xeromorphic features are also typical of hispanica tetraploids in the drier Mediterranean, and include smaller, more glaucous leaves and tillers as well as smaller inflorescences. Independently, xeromorphic forms of judaica have developed in the Mediterranean from temperate pre-himalayensis types. The seaside dwelling forms marina and oceanica have developed glaucous characteristics and in the case of marina have papillate epidermises. Those on coastal cliffs (hylodes, smithii) have developed a sprawling branching habit.
5.3.4 Edaphic Adaptation The development of edaphic races has also been part of the continuing process of adaptive radiation so that
5 Dactylis
today many commercial glomerata forms are noted for their tolerance of acidic soils with aluminum, and subsp. slovenica grows on calcareous soils while reichenbachii is adapted to dolomitic soils.
5.3.5 Genome Size Genome size in Dactylis has been reported to decrease with altitude in France and Italy, often by as much as 30% (Reeves et al. 1998). There is also approximately a 15% reduction in the DNA mass of diploids forms, which have developed in southern Iberia, North Africa and the Canary Islands when compared to those in northern Iberia, Europe, Middle East and central Asia (Tuna et al. 2007). Interestingly, these are probably more recent in origin.
5.4 Genetic Resources For plant improvement it is appropriate to divide genetic resources into primary, secondary, tertiary and quaternary gene pools as follows.
83
many Islands. These resources are often explored by plant breeders but they are of lesser significance than the primary pool simply because adaptation to agricultural environments is usually inferior. In general, these resources still occur in nature and in genebank collections. Many of the wild populations are under threat with climate warming and humaninduced habitat changes, while even those in genebanks will only be maintained if adequate resources are available. The secondary gene pool includes tetraploid forms sympatric with diploid populations. The Australian cultivar Porto and the Spanish cultivar Adac 1 are based on natural tetraploids with lusitanica influence. A number of cultivars have been based on tetraploid forms of izcoi from Galicia, such as Grasslands Wana (New Zealand), Cambria (UK) and Artibro (Spain). It is also possible that other cultivars are based on tetraploid forms of diploid populations. The tetraploid forms of many of these diploid populations represent an enormous resource for breeders and representative collections are required. Although many have been collected, few are identified as tetraploid forms of the remnant diploid population.
5.4.3 Tertiary Gene Pool 5.4.1 Primary Gene Pool These can be defined as cultivars and elite breeding lines adapted to the region of agricultural use. This is the primary activity of most effective plant breeders and consists almost exclusively of tetraploids, although the diploids izcoi and aschersoniana have been used commercially. In general, these resources are well used by breeders and their “working” collections largely represent this gene pool. The largest threat to this gene pool would be any decrease in the number of breeding programs in Dactylis.
5.4.2 Secondary Gene Pool This can be defined as those tetraploid populations outside the regions of main agricultural use of the species in Europe, Asia and North Africa and the
These can be defined as those populations from other ploidy levels where introgression into commercial breeding programs is possible. These would largely consist of diploids, but potentially the hexaploids could also be used for tetraploid breeding. Breeders have crossed germplasm from diploid lusitanica into tetraploid material with examples being the two UK commercial cultivars Saborto and Calder, as well as the NZ cultivar Grasslands Kara. Tetraploidy can be induced from the diploids by colchicine treatment as in Saborto, or via unreduced gametes as in Calder (Lewis 1975). In general, these resources are poorly represented in genebanks and are seldom used by breeders. Yet because of the foundation upon which modern tetraploids are based, the remnant diploid populations represent an enormous resource. Many are under threat with climate warming and human induced habitat changes. Even those in genebanks will only survive if adequate funding is provided.
84
5.4.4 Quaternary Gene Pool This can be defined as those species outside Dactylis, which may be a source of genes for breeding. However, only a few species have ever been hybridized with Dactylis, such as Lolium multiflorum (Oertel et al. 1996), Festuca arundinacea (Matzk 1981), and Phleum pratense (Nakazumi et al. 1997), and successful embryos were formed in cereals (wheat, barley, rye) pollinated with D. glomerata (Zenkteler and Nitzsche 1984). As fertility is extremely low these hybrids have never been fully explored in breeding programs and their development does not appear to be a priority.
5.4.5 Conservation Recommendations We can conclude that genetic resources of the primary and secondary tetraploid gene pools are moderately well represented in genebanks and breeders’ collection. The tertiary diploid gene pool is in urgent need of collection as many of the geographic forms are not present in international genebanks or are represented by no more than two accessions (Table 5.1). In particular, altaica, hyrcana, metlesicsii, reichenbachii and smithii from Cape Verde are absent from collections, and sinensis is difficult to obtain for anyone outside China. It is also important to collect and store the autotetraploid forms of the diploid populations such as smithii, woronowii, izcoi, reichenbachii and mairei, and also of any others that occur. Although in situ conservation should be encouraged, it is important to maintain ex situ collections of each form. These can be stored as seed collections in the international agricultural genebanks.
5.4.6 Genomics Resources Bushman et al. (2007) and Robins et al. (2008) are generating Dactylis expressed sequence tag (EST) libraries using four tissues: cold acclimated crowns, etiolated seedlings, salt/drought stressed shoots, and salt/drought stressed roots. They are also using genetic association mapping populations, and trait evaluation field plots to help overcome winter hardiness and to provide tolerance to dry summers. Simple sequence
A.V. Stewart and N.W. Ellison Table 5.1 Diploid accessions of Dactylis glomerata in genebanks of Europe (Eurisco), North America (USDA and Canada) and New Zealand (Margot Forde Germplasm Center) with priority for collection Diploid population Number of Priority accessions for collection altaica 0 Urgent aschersoniana 26 Low “castellata” 3 High himalayensis 4 High hyrcana 0 Urgent nestorii ¼ ibizensis 2 High izcoi 40 Low judaica 10 Moderate juncinella 4 High lusitanica 11 Moderate mairei 10 Moderate metlesicsii 0 Urgent parthiana 3 High reichenbachii 0 High santai 9 Moderate sinensis 0 Urgent smithii (Canary Islands) 10 Moderate smithii (Cape Verde) 0 Urgent woronowii 21 Low Note: these collections are likely to include some duplication
repeats (SSRs) identified from these libraries will be aligned to rice chromosomes to determine predicted locations of the SSR markers. PCR primers designed from 30 UTR regions from other species contain high degrees of polymorphism, and the same is expected for this library. Additionally, the sequence data from the library will be used to identify single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). The USDA-ARS Forage and Range Research Laboratory have an extensive orchardgrass improvement program, and their objective is to identify phenotypic associations, and apply the markers to a marker-assisted selection program for increased salt tolerance and winter hardiness. In order that molecular resources can be applied in an effective and non-dominating balanced way, it is important to ensure that pragmatic field breeding programs continue in all major regions.
5.4.7 Karyotype The karyotypes of many diploid Dactylis forms has been reviewed by Wetschnig (1991). There has been no
5 Dactylis
research on cytogenetic stocks, such as addition or substitution lines. Williams and Barclay (1972) described the transmission of B chromosomes in Dactylis.
5.4.8 Inheritance A number of inheritance studies in tetraploid Dactylis have shown that it essentially behalves as an autopolyploid. The genomes are not greatly differentiated and gene exchange occurs between genomes.
5.4.9 Role in Crop Improvement Through Traditional and Advanced Tools While the majority of D. glomerata cultivars have been developed by traditional breeding, some have been developed using introgression from diploids, notably lusitanica. Some tetraploid lines may be based on interecotypic hybrids while others may be largely single origin tetraploids. Transformation systems to develop transgenic plants have been developed for Dactylis (Cho et al. 2001), but at this stage no transgenic cultivars have been released.
5.4.10 The Future Improvement of Dactylis Using Wild Relatives Germplasm of many of the diploid forms is under serious threat from habitat degradation and climate warming in situ. Unfortunately, many of these forms are absent from or are not well represented in ex situ genebanks and it is critical that a wide range of these forms be collected for storage. It is also crucial that viable large scale breeding programs are maintained internationally to allow adequate cultivar development, germplasm collection, introgressions of wild germplasm and application of molecular resources. Acknowledgements The authors wish to acknowledge the support of PGG Wrightson Seeds and AgResearch, and the numerous people who supplied germplasm.
85
References Amirouche N, Misset MT (2007) Morphological variation and distribution of cytotypes in the diploid-tetraploid complex of the genus Dactylis L. (Poaceae) from Algeria. Plant Syst Evol 264:157–174 Apiron D, Zohary D (1961) Chlorophyll lethal in Natural populations of the Orchard Grass (Dactylis glomerata L.). A case of balanced polymorphism in plants. Genetics 46:393–399 Ardouin P, Fiasson JL, Jay M, Lumaret R, Hubac JM (1985) Chemical diversification within Dactylis glomerata L. polyploid complex (Graminaceae). In: Jacquard P, Heim G, Antonovics J (eds) Proceedings of the NATO symposium on genetic differentiation and dispersal in plants, vol G5. Springer, Basel, Switzerland Bondesen OB (2007) Seed production and seed trade in a globalised world. Seed production in the northern light. Proceedings of the 6th international herbage seed conference in Norway, pp 9–12 Borrill M (1961) Patterns of morphological variation in diploid and tetraploid Dactylis. Bot J Linn Soc 56:441–459 Borrill M (1977) Evolution and genetic resources in Cocksfoot. Annu Rep Welsh Plant Breed Stat, pp 90–209 Borrill M, Carroll CP (1969) A chromosome atlas of the genus Dactylis (part two). Cytologia 34:6–17 Borrill M, Lindner R (1971) Diploid-Tetraploid sympatry in Dactylis (Gramineae). New Phytol 70:1111–1124 Bushman BS, Larson SR, Wang R, Mott IW (2007) New genomic resources for pasture and range grasses. Poster presentation, 5th international symposium on the molecular breeding of forage and turf, 1–6 July 2007, Sapporo, Japan Castro M, Fraga P, Torres N, Rossello JA (2007) Cytotaxonomical observations on flowering plants from the Balearic Islands. Ann Bot Fenn 44:409–415 Cho MJ, Choi HW, Lemaux PG (2001) Transformed T0 orchardgrass (Dactylis glomerata L.) plants produced from highly regenerative tissues derived from mature seeds. Plant Cell Rep 20:318–324 Czerepanov SK (1981) Sosudistye Rasteniia SSSR. Nauka, Leningradskoe Otdnie, Leningrad, Nauka, USSR, p 509 (In Russian) Domin K (1943) Monografica studie o rodu Dactylis L. Acta Bot Bohem 14:3–147 Doroszewska AA (1963) An investigation on the diploid and tetraploid forms of Dactylis glomerata L. subsp. woronowii (Ovczinn.) Stebbins et Zohary. Acta Soc Bot Pol 32: 113–130 Fiasson JL, Ardouin P, Jay M (1987) A phylogenetic groundplan of the specific complex Dactylis glomerata. Biochem Syst Ecol 15:225–230 Go´mez A, Lunt DH (2006) Refugia within refugia: patterns of phylogeographic concordance in the Iberian Peninsula. In: Weiss S, Ferrand N (eds) Phylogeography of southern European refugia. Springer, The Netherlands, pp 155–188 Guignard G (1985) Dactylis glomerata ssp. oceanica, a new taxon of the Atlantic coast. Bull Soc Bot France Let Bot 132:341–346 Hewitt GM (1999) Post glacial recolonisation of European biota. Biol J Linn Soc 68:87–112
86 Horjales M, Redondo N, Pe´rez B, Brown S (1995) Presencia en Galicia de Dactylis glomerata L. hexaploide. Bol Soc Brot 67:223–230 Jay M, Lumaret R (1995) Variation in the subtropical group of Dactylis glomerata L. 2. Evidence from phenolic compound patterns. Biochem Syst Ecol 23:523–531 Jogan J (2002) Systematics and chorology of Cocksfoot Group (Dactylis glomerata agg.) in Slovenia. Doctoral Dissert, Univ of Llubljana, Slovenia Jones K (1962) Chromosomal status, gene exchange and evolution in Dactylis. Genetica 32:272–295 Jones K, Carroll CP, Borrill M (1961) A chromosome atlas of the genus Dactylis. Cytologia 26:333–343 Lewis EJ (1975) An alternate technique for the production of amphidiploids. Annu Rep Welsh Plant Breed Stn 1974:15 Lindner R, Lema M, Garcı´a A (2004) Extended genetic resources of Dactylis glomerata subsp. izcoi in Galicia (northwest Spain). Genet Resour Crop Evol 51:437–442 Lumaret R (1984) The role of polyploidy in the adaptive significance of polymorphism at the GOT 1 locus in the Dactylis glomerata complex. Heredity 52:153–169 Lumaret R (1986) Doubled duplication of the structural gene for cytosolic phosphoglucose isomerase in the Dactylis glomerata L. polyploid complex. Mol Biol Evol 3:499–521 Lumaret R (1987) Differential degree in genetic divergence as a consequence of a long isolation in a diploid entity of Dactylis glomerata L. from the Guizhou region (China). Presentation to the 2nd symposium Paleoenvironment East Asia, Hong Kong, Jan 9–14,1987 Lumaret R (1988) Cytology, genetics and evolution in the genus Dactylis. Crit Rev Plant Sci 7:55–91 Lumaret R, Barrientos E (1990) Phylogenetic relationships and gene flow between sympatric diploid and tetraploid plants of Dactylis glomerata (Gramineae). Plant Syst Evol 169: 1615–6110 Lumaret R, Bowman CM, Dyer TA (1989) Autotetraploidy in Dactylis glomerata L.: further evidence from studies of chloroplast DNA variation. Theor Appl Genet 78:393–399 Lumaret R, Bretagnolle F, Maceira NO (1992) 2n gamete frequency and bilateral polyploidization in Dactylis glomerata. In: Mariana A, Tavoletti S (eds) Gametes with somatic chromosome number in the evolution and breeding of polyploid polysomic species: achievements and perspectives. Forage Plant Breeding Institute, Perugia, Italy, pp 15–21 Maceira NO, Jacquard P, Lumaret R (1993) Competition between diploid and derivative autotetraploid Dactylis glomerata L. from Galicia. Implications for the establishment of novel polyploid populations. New Phytol 124:321–328 Matzk F (1981) Successful crosses between Festuca arundinacea Schreb. and Dactylis glomerata L. Theor Appl Genet 60:119–122 Mı´ka V, Kohoutek A, Smrz J (1999) Dactylis polygama, a nonaggressive cocksfoot for grass/clover mixtures. Grassland ecology V. Proceedings of the 5th ecological conference, Banska´ Bystrica, Slovakia, 23–25 Nov 1999 Mizianty M (1991) Biosystematic studies on Dactylis (Poaceae). 2. Original research. 2.2. Cytological differentiation of the genus in Poland. Fragm Flor Geobot 36:301–320 Mizianty M (1997) Distribution of Dactylis glomerata subsp. slovenica (Poaceae) in Europe. Fragm Flor Geobot 42: 207–213
A.V. Stewart and N.W. Ellison Mizianty M, Cenci CA (1995) Dactylis glomerata L. subsp. slovenica (Dom.) Dom. (Gramineae), a new taxon to Italy. Webbia 50:45–50 Mousset C (1995) Les dactyles ou le genre Dactylis. In: Prosperi JM, Balfourier F, Guy P (eds) Ressources Ge´ne´tiques des Gramine´es Fourrage`res et a` Gazon. INRA-BRG, Paris, France, pp 28–52 Mousset C (2000) Rassemblement, utilisation et gestion des ressources ge´ne´tiques de dactyle a` l’INRA de Lusignan. Fourrages 162:121–139 Nakazumi H, Furuya M, Shimokouji H, Fujii H (1997) Wide hybridization between timothy (Phleum pratense L.) and orchardgrass (Dactylis glomerata L.). Bull Hokkaido Prefectural Agric Exp Stn (Jpn) 72:11–16 Oertel C, Fuchs J, Matzk F (1996) Successful hybridization between Lolium and Dactylis. Plant Breed 115:101–105 Ortiz S, Rodriguez-Oubin˜a J (1993) Dactylis glomerata subsp. izcoi, a new subspecies from Galicia NW Iberian peninsula. Ann Bot Fenn 30:305–311 Parker PF (1972) Studies in Dactylis II Natural variation, distribution, and systematics of the Dactylis smithii Link. Complex in Madeira and other Atlantic Islands. New Phytol 72:371–378 Parker PF, Borrill M (1968) Studies in Dactylis. 1 Fertility relationships in some diploid subspecies. New Phytol 67:649–662 Reeves G, Francis D, Davies MS, Rogers HJ, Hodkinson TR (1998) Genome size is negatively correlated with altitude in natural populations of Dactylis glomerata. Ann Bot 82(suppl A):99–105 Robins JG, Bushman BS, Jensen KB (2008) New genomic resources for orchardgrass. Proceedings of the 27th EUCARPIA symposium on improvement of fodder crops and amenity grasses, 19–23 Aug 2007, Copenhagen, Denmark, pp 202–203 Sahuquillo E, Lumaret R (1999) Chloroplast DNA variation in Dactylis glomerata L. taxa endemic to the Macaronesian islands. Mol Ecol 8:1797–1803 Scho¨nfelder P, Ludwig D (1996) Dactylis metlesicsii (Poaceae), eine neue Art der Gebirgsvegetation von Tenerife, Kanariische Inseln. Willdenowia 26:217–223 Soltis DE, Soltis PS (1993) Molecular data and the dynamic nature of polyploidy. Crit Rev Plant Sci 12:243–273 Speranza M, Cristofolini G (1986) The genus Dactylis in Italy. 1. The tetraploid entities. Webbia 39:379–396 Speranza M, Cristofolini G (1987) The genus Dactylis in Italy. 2. The diploid entities. Webbia 41:213–224 Stebbins GL (1971) Chromosomal evolution in higher plants. Edward Arnold, London, UK Stebbins GL, Zohary D (1959) Cytogenetic and evolutionary studies in the genus Dactylis. I Morphological, distribution and inter relationships of the diploid subspecies. Univ Calif Publ Bot 31:1–40 Stewart AV, Joachimiak A, Ellison N (2008) Genomic and geographic origins of timothy (Phleum sp.) based on ITS and chloroplast sequences. In: Yamada T, Spangenberg G (eds) Proceedings of the 5th international symposium on the molecular breeding of forage and turf, 1–6 July 2007, Sapporo, Japan, pp 71–81 Stuczynski M (1992) Estimation of suitability of the Ascherson’s cocksfoot (Dactylis aschersoniana Graebn.) for field cultivation. Plant Breed Acclim Seed Prod 36:7–42
5 Dactylis Tuna M, Teykin E, Buyukbaser A, Budak H (2007) Nuclear DNA variation in the grass genus Dactylis L. Poster presentation, 5th international symposium molecular breeding of forage and turf, 1–6 Jul 2007, Sapporo, Japan Tyler B, Borrill M (1983) The use of wild species in forage grass breeding. Genetika 15:387–396 Tzvelev NN (1983) Grasses of the Soviet Union. Amerind Publishing, New Delhi, India Van Dijk GE (1961) The inheritance of harsh leaves in tetraploid cocksfoot. Euphytica 13:305–313 Wei-Lin Hu W, Timothy DH (1971) Cytological studies of four diploid Dactylis subspecies, their hybrids and induced tetraploid hybrids. Crop Sci 11:203–207
87 Wetschnig W (1991) Karyotype morphology of some diploid subspecies of Dactylis glomerata L. (Poaceae). Phyton Horn 31:35–55 Williams E, Barclay PC (1972) Transmission of B-chromosomes in Dactylis. NZ J Bot 10:573–584 Yamane K, Yano K, Kawahara T (2006) Pattern and rate of indel evolution inferred from whole chloroplast intergenic regions in sugarcane, maize and rice. DNA Res 13:197–204 Zenkteler M, Nitzsche W (1984) Wide hybridization experiments in cereals. Theor Appl Genet 68:311–315 Zurawski G, Clegg MT, Brown HD (1984) The nature of nucleotide sequence divergence between barley and maize chloroplast DNA. Genetics 106:735–749
Chapter 6
Dichanthium Vishnu Bhat, C. Mahalakshmi, Shashi, Sunil Saran, and Soom Nath Raina
6.1 Introduction The genus Dichanthium Willemet belongs to the tribe Andropogoneae of the family Poaceae, having wide distribution across the tropics and the subtropics of the Old World. It is one of the major components of SehimaDichanthium and Dichanthium–Cenchrus–Lasiurus grass covers of India (Dabadghao and Shankarnarayan 1973). Various species of Dichanthium such as D. annulatum, D. sericeum, D. caricosum and D. aristatum are of economic importance because of their high palatability and nutritional value. D. aristatum is useful for stabilization of waterway and banks and for suppressing invasive weeds such as Phyla canescens. Most of the Dichanthium species are used as pastures for grazing and are suitable for silage and hay. Recent studies have shown that D. annulatum has the highest relative preference value than any other grasses of northern grasslands of Pakistan (Sultan et al. 2008). Dichanthium forms an agamic complex with Bothriochloa Kuntze and Capillipedium Stapf. (de Wet and Harlan 1968, 1970a). It has sexually reproducing diploid representatives and apomictic polyploids with pseudogamous type of apomixis (Brown and Emery 1957; Harlan et al. 1958; Harlan and de Wet 1963a; de Wet and Harlan 1970a; D’Cruz and Reddy 1971). Around 20 species have been reported in this genus from tropical to the subtropical region. The basic chromosome number is 10 and different ploidy levels
V. Bhat (*) Department of Botany, University of Delhi, Delhi 110 007, India e-mail:
[email protected]
have been reported in the D. annulatum complex (Mehra 1961). Diploid species such as D. armatum, D. maccannii, and D. panchaganiense are endemic to India (Harlan 1963), whereas other diploid species such as D. humilis, D. setosum, D. sericeum, and D. superciliatum are of Australian origin but widely distributed (de Wet and Harlan 1962; Fig. 6.1). The tetraploid agamospecies such as D. annulatum, D. aristatum, and D. caricosum have diploids, which are sexually reproducing and are well adapted polyhaploids (de Wet 1968). D. caricosum produce hybrids with both D. annulatum and D. aristatum naturally because of which these species are grouped as one large agamospecies. Development of efficient genetic improvement methods requires comprehensive analysis of various information on the taxonomy, cytology, reproductive biology, and molecular genetics of cultivated Dichanthium species and their wild relatives. The information provided in this chapter can be utilized for systematic exploitation of the gene pool for commercial breeding.
6.2 Taxonomy and Distribution Dichanthium first described by Willemet (1976) belongs to the family Poaceae, Subfamily Panicoideae, Group Andropogonodae, Tribe Andropogoneae. The genus Dichanthium Willemet is closely associated with the genera Bothriochloa Kuntze and Capillipedium Stapf. because of which they were all included under Andropogon Linn. by Hackel (1889), forming Dichanthium–Bothriochloa–Capillipedium agamic complex (de Wet and Harlan 1968, 1970a;
C. Kole (ed.), Wild Crop Relatives: Genomic and Breeding Resources, Millets and Grasses, DOI 10.1007/978-3-642-14255-0_6, # Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2011
89
90
V. Bhat et al.
Fig. 6.1 Diagram showing distribution of four important species, namely D. annulatum (a), D. aristatum (b), D. caricosum (c), and D. sericeum (d), major forage crop species of Dichanthium across the world [From: Cook et al. (2005)]. Leg-
end shows the suitable areas (dark red), i.e., the locations where a species is highly adapted and marginal areas (orange), where the species occurrence is uncertain but can survive in that location
Clayton 1977). It is sometimes very difficult to treat agamic complex taxonomically as every adaptive genotype is maintained as a distinct morphological unit (Baker 1959; Lo¨ve 1960; Valentine 1960). The hybrids and their derivatives are usually included with a species that bridges the gap between the members of agamic complex. Such a species is termed as “compilospecies” (Harlan and de Wet 1963b). In case of Dichanthium–Bothriochloa–Capillipedium, de Wet and Harlan (1970b) suggested Bothriochloa intermedia as a compilospecies. For example, hybrids of B. intermedia and either Capillipedium parviflorum or D. annulatum behave as apomictic allotetraploids and
are recognized taxonomically as B. glabra and B. grahamii, respectively (de Wet and Stalker 1974). Majority of the species of Dichanthium are perennial, herbaceous, branched or simple, erect, sometimes decumbent or geniculate; rhizomatous or stoloniferous, tufted grasses, forming upright tussocks, sometimes with extensive creeping stolons; leaves usually glaucous, sometimes aromatic; hairy or bearded culm nodes; auricles absent; ligule membranous and usually ciliate or fringed; plants bisexual; inflorescence terminal or also axillary, solitary or compound racemes digitately or subdigitately arranged at the summit of the culm; homogamous pairs and obtuse, sessile spikelets, lower
6 Dichanthium
or basal spikelets either male or sterile; sessile spikelets: bisexual and dorsally compressed or imbricate, callus obtuse; fragile rachis, 2 glumes more or less equal or subequal, lower glume boat-shaped and chartaceous to cartilaginous, upper lemma entire and awned, glabrous awn bent about the middle; pedicellate spikelets: male or sterile and unawned, palea absent or present, 2 lodicules free and fleshy, 1–3 stamens, ovary glabrous, 2 stigmas; and fruits compressed, ornamental, and attractive (Jacobsen 1981; Shouliang and Phillips 2006; Quattrocchi 2008; http://www.efloras.org/florataxon.aspx?flora_id¼2& taxon_id¼109887). The diversity in the type of spikelets and the ornamentations of the lower glume of various Dichanthium species has been shown in Fig. 6.2. The taxonomic features of various species based on Quattrocchi (2008) are described as follows: 1. D. affine (R. Br.) A. Camus, commonly known as bluegrass, is native to Australia with its distribution in southern and western Australia,
Fig. 6.2 Different types of inflorescences of few Dichanthium species. (a–d) D. annulatum; (e) D. aristatum; (f) D. armatum; (g–i) D. caricosum; (j–k) D. foveolatum; (l) D. oliganthum;
91
Queensland, Northern Territory, and New South Wales and was introduced to Pakistan as a fodder grass (eFloras). It is a perennial, erect, and geniculate grass with tall and slender clumps, bluish green leaves, nodes hairy or bearded, racemes silky greenish and purplish, very similar to D. sericeum (R. Br.) A. Camus. It is distinguished from D. annulatum by its sessile or subsessile racemes and a subapical ciliate fringe on the lower glume of the sessile spikelet. 2. D. annulatum (Forssk.) Stapf, commonly known as Marvel grass, is native to Southeast Asia, India, China, and tropical Africa and also was introduced to Australia and America. It has been introduced in Texas, South and Southwest America, where it persists as casual weed (Gould 1967). It is very well adapted to most textures of soil, i.e. from coralline sands to heavy black clay soil preferably with neutral to alkaline pH. They show moderate to poor frost tolerance but moderate intolerance to shade (Cook et al. 2005). Plant has twisting and
(m–n) D. panchaganiense and (o) D. sericeum (Courtesy: Dr. Anil Kumar and Prof. S.R.Yadav)
92
ascending to semi-decumbent to prostrate, creeping habits; paniculate inflorescence of compound and several racemes subdigitate and short and glabrous peduncle, racemes densely villous, spikelets subimbricate or closely overlapping, sessile spikelet bisexual, pedicelled spikelets male or neuter, lower floret barren, upper floret hermaphrodite, pedicellate spikelet without a pit, sessile spikelets narrowly oblong and awned, lower glume obtuse or truncate, keel not winged median nerve present, sheath terete, larger ligule, upper lemma awned, 3 stamens, ovary glabrous (Bor 1960; Celarier et al. 1962; Shouliang and Phillips 2006; http://www. efloras.org/florataxon.aspx?flora_id¼2&taxon_id¼ 200025242). Figure 6.3 represents a diagrammatic sketch of D. annulatum showing different taxonomic characters. (a) D. annulatum (Forssk.) Stapf var. annulatum is found mostly in tropical Africa, Southwest Asia, India, and Indonesia. Racemes subdigitate, sessile spikelet with lower glume pubescent to villous and not pitted. (b) D. annulatum (Forssk.) Stapf var. papillosum (Hochst. Ex A. Rich.) de Wet and J.R. Harlan is mostly distributed in southern Africa, Ethiopia, Tanzania, and Kenya. Rhizomatous, ring of hairs around the nodes, leaf blade flattened, leaf sheath glabrous, spikelets paired, sessile spikelet with lower glume not pitted villous and fringed, pedicelled spikelet awnless (Mehra 1964a). 3. D. aristatum (Poir.) C.E. Hubb., commonly known as Angleton grass, is indigenous from tropical India to Indonesia. It has been introduced to many tropical regions and has been naturalized in Australia (Bisset and Sillar 1984), America (Gould 1967), South Africa (Bor 1960; Celarier et al. 1962), and Taiwan and Yunnan region of China (Shouliang and Phillips 2006; http://www.efloras.org/florataxon.aspx?flora_id¼2&taxon_id¼200025243). It is mainly adapted to dark or red soils with neutral to alkaline pH, moderately tolerant to drought, shade, and grazing, poor salt tolerance, and moderate shade tolerance (Cook et al. 2005). It is weakly tufted, characterized by hairy peduncle, culm nodes bearded by very short spreading hairs or glabrous when old, compound racemes sparsely villous, spikelets imbricate and paired, sessile
V. Bhat et al.
4.
5.
6.
7.
spikelets elliptic to obovate, pitless, lower glume pilose and fringed. D. armatum (Hook.f.) Blatter and McCann has its roots of origin in India and is endemic to Western Ghats, Maharashtra (Bor 1960). It is an annual species with characteristic lower glume of pedicelled spikelet armed with marginal bulbousbased bristles and not pitted, lower glume of sessile spikelet pitted (Bor 1960; de Wet and Harlan 1961). D. caricosum (L.) A. Camus Hochst. ex Miq., commonly known as Nadi bluegrass, was first collected at Suva, Fiji Islands in 1936 (Bisset and Sillar 1984). It shows wide distribution in India, Burma, and Ceylon, extending to southern China, Indonesia, and Malaya (Bor 1960; Celarier et al. 1962), where it grows on slightly acidic to alkaline soil with heavy black clay soil texture, intolerant to frost and salinity and moderately tolerant to shade (Cook et al. 2005). It forms small clumps, prostrate habit, peduncle of raceme glabrous, sessile spikelets hermaphrodite, lower floret empty, upper floret bisexual, pedicelled spikelets male, lower glume of the sessile spikelet obovate or oblongtruncated, without a median nerve, sheath compressed, ligule short ciliate membrane, and margins with long and short hairs interspersed, 3 stamens, ovary glabrous (Bor 1960; Celarier et al. 1962; Clayton and Renvoize 1982; Shouliang and Phillips 2006; http://www. efloras.org/florataxon.aspx?flora_id¼2&taxon_id¼ 242317870). Figure 6.4 shows the diagrammatic representation of various taxonomic features of this species. D. compressum (Hook.f.) Jain and Deshpande is a species endemic to India, especially to Western Ghats in Maharashtra, Lonavala, and Khandala, Poona District (Jain and Deshpande 1978). It is a rare and threatened species, with leaf blades linear-lanceolate and finely acuminate, aromatic, and lower glume of sessile spikelets hairy. D. fecundum S.T. Blake, commonly called as Gulf bluegrass, has Australian origin with its distribution in northeastern (Queensland) and western Australia (Jacobsen 1981). It has erect or geniculate habit, forming erect tussocks, glaucous leaves, green or purplish racemes solitary or in group.
6 Dichanthium
Fig. 6.3 Dichanthium annulatum Stapf. (a) Part of the plant with inflorescence; (b) Sessile and Pedicellate spikelet; (c–h) Sessile spikelet: (c) Lower glume; (d) Upper glume; (e) Lower lemma; (f) Upper lemma; (g) Stamens; (h) Pistil and lodicules;
93
(i–l) Pedicellate spikelet: (i) Pedicellate spikelet; (j) Lower glume; (k) Upper glume; (l) Lemma; (m) Collar (Courtesy: Dr. Anil Kumar and Prof. S.R. Yadav)
94
Fig. 6.4 Dichanthium caricosum (L.) A. Camus (a) Habit; (b) Sessile and Pedicellate spikelet; (c–i) Sessile spikelet: (c) Lower glume; (d) Upper glume; (e) Lower lemma; (f) Upper lemma; (g) Palea; (h) Stamens; (i) Pistil and lodicules; (j–o) Pedicellate
V. Bhat et al.
spikelet: (j) Lower glume; (k) Upper glume; (l) Lower Lemma; (m) Upper Lemma; (n) Palea; (o) Stamens; (p) Collar (Courtesy: Dr. Anil Kumar and Prof. S.R. Yadav)
6 Dichanthium
8. D. foveolatum (Delile) Roberty, commonly known as Gandhel is a native species of Africa and tropical and temperate Asia including India, Ceylon, and Pakistan. It is a wiry, very slender, and much-branched plant, with spathiform leaf sheaths, basal sheaths silky, ligule membrane-like, leaves narrow almost filiform, terminal and axillary racemes solitary and long-exserted, awn on one side of spike, lower glume of sessile spikelet pitted, pedicelled spikelet pitted or not, and upper lemma sometimes bidentate (Clayton and Renvoize 1982; GRIN, eFloras). 9. D. humilius (Benth.) J.M. Black is widely distributed in Central Australia. The plant is characterized by sessile or subsessile raceme, hairs on lower glume of sessile spikelets not strictly arranged in a subapical transverse fringe, racemes 2–7 per inflorescence (de Wet and Harlan 1962; GRIN). 10. D. maccannii Blatter is a vulnerable and threatened species, endemic to India, especially to Panchgani Plateau in Western Ghats, Maharashtra. It has racemes solitary or two and characteristic not pitted lower glume of sessile spikelet and marginal bulbous-based bristles on lower glume of pedicellate spikelet (Bor 1960; de Wet and Harlan 1961; Naik 1982). 11. D. mucronulatum Jansen has its distribution in the tropical Asia mainly Indo-China and Malaysia. It is a rare species, ligule eciliate membrane, hairy awn, upper lemma sometimes bidentate (Kew). 12. D. oliganthum (Hochst. ex Steud.) Cope is mainly found in India. It is an annual species (Kew). 13. D. pallidum (Hook.f.) Stapf ex C.E. is reported to be endemic to India, especially Nilgiris, Tamil Nadu, by Bor (1960), and its occurrence was reported in other parts of India namely, Mirzapur, 24 Parganas in West Bengal and Nellore by Bhattacharyya and Uniyal (1973). It is characterized by its small creeping nature, solitary racemes of tightly overlapped spikelets, peduncle glabrous and lower glume of sessile spikelet with shallow longitudinal furrow (GRIN; Bor 1960; Celarier et al. 1962). 14. D. panchaganiense Blatter and McCann is a species endemic to India particularly to Panchgani Plateau, Maharashtra. It is a rare and threatened, annual species, with racemes solitary or digitate, lower glume of pedicelled spikelet always pitted
95
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
and with marginal bulbous-based bristles (Bor 1960; de Wet and Harlan 1961). D. queenslandicum B. Simon, commonly known as king bluegrass, is a native of Queensland, Australia. It is a vulnerable species (Kew). D. sericeum (R. Br.) A. Camus, called as Queensland bluegrass, has a wide distribution in tropical Asia, Papua New Guinea, western Australia, Queensland, Northern Territory, Victoria, and New South Wales and has been introduced to US (Gould 1967). It is usually prevalent in neutral to alkaline soil conditions and very well adapted to heavy black clay soil moderate to poor tolerance to shade and grazing but intolerant to shade (Cook et al. 2005). It is identifiable with its tussocky nature, bluish green and purplish, culm nodes bearded or with long white hairs, racemes 2–7 with white and bluish silky hairs, pedicels usually bilaterally ciliate, spikelets paired and crowded, lowest pairs of spikelets sterile and reduced to glumes, callus shortly bearded, pedicellate spikelets sterile, hairs on lower glume of sessile spikelet arranged in distinct subapical transverse fringe (de Wet and Harlan 1962, Kew). (a) D. sericeum (R. Br.) A. Camus subsp. humilius New South Wales. (b) D. sericeum (R. Br.) A. Camus subsp. polystachyum Australia, Asia. (c) D. sericeum (R. Br.) A. Camus subsp. sericeum New South Wales. D. setosum S.T. Blake is an Australian species, mainly distributed in Queensland, New South Wales, and western Australia. It differs from other species by the presence of few, never strictly digitate racemes, awned pedicellate spikelet, hairs on the lower glumes arranged in a distinct subapical fringe, lower glume of sessile spikelet 5–6 nerved (de Wet and Harlan 1961, 1962; Jacobsen 1981). D. tenue (R. Br.) A. Camus, commonly called as small bluestem, is a species from Australia now confined to Malaya, Polynesia, Queensland, and New South Wales. It has prostrate habit, culm nodes essentially glabrous, glabrous peduncle of raceme, racemes 1–3, lower glume of sessile spikelet with short hairy margins (Celarier et al. 1962). D. tenuiculum (Steudel) S.T. Blake is an Australian species, commonly known as tassel bluegrass. It is widely spread around western Australia,
96
Queensland, Northern Territory, Philippines, Timor and New Guinea. It is a robust grass, leaves bluish green to blue and very scabrous, culms robust and branched, racemes in a terminal and digitate or tasseled inflorescence (Jacobsen 1981). 20. D. woodrowii (Hook.f.) S.K. Jain and Deshpande is a rare grass endemic to India, confined to Mawal and Paud of Pune District, Maharashtra. It is a vulnerable and threatened species with aromatic, tufted, woody rootstock, sessile spikelets oblong-lanceolate (Jain and Deshpande 1978; Mehrotra 1979).
6.3 Cytology and Hybridization Cytogenetic diversity and chromosomal behavior play an important component of any breeding program. The occurrence of natural interspecific and intergeneric hybrids has been reported in Gramineae, and a thorough study of these hybrids enrich our understanding on the fields of genetics, cytogenetics, biosystematics, and phylogenetics. Many workers including Myers (1947) and Carnahan and Hill (1961) have reported many interspecific and intergeneric hybrids, especially in forage grasses. Stebbins (1947) and Lo¨ve (1964) have proposed that natural polyploids, which arise usually, fall between autopolyploids and allopolyploids. Polyploidy played an important role in the evolution of species, especially the grasses. Allopolyploids played significant role in speciation than autopolyploids.
6.3.1 Cytological Characters Dichanthium, like many other members of agamic complex, has autotetraploidy along with haploidy as a mechanism to bridge gap and ensure contact with sexuality (de Wet 1965, 1968). Mehra (1961), de Wet and Harlan (1968) and many others have reported chromosome numbers in the sexually reproducing and agamospecies of Dichanthium. The basic number for the tribe Andropogoneae is 5 or 10 and Dichanthium species show multiples of 10 in sexual and apomictic types (Celarier 1956, 1957; Celarier and Harlan 1957). The sexually reproducing diploid species of Dichanthium, namely D. sericeum, D. affine, D. setosum, D. tenue,
V. Bhat et al.
D. acutiusculum, D. humilius, D. panchganiense, D. maccannii, and D. tenuiculum, and diploid races of D. annulatum, D. aristatum, and D. caricosum have chromosome number 2n ¼ 20. The tetraploid races of facultative apomicts such as Dichanthium annulatum, D. aristatum, D. caricosum, and obligate apomict D. fecundum have 2n ¼ 40, whereas the hexaploid obligate apomict D. papillosum and hexaploid race of D. aristatum have 2n ¼ 60. D. armatum is cytologically unknown (Oke 1950; Gould 1956; Celarier and Harlan 1957; Bor 1960; Bogdan 1977). Morphological data have suggested hybridization and chromosome doubling as the major phenomena in the evolution of Dichanthium Willemet. The meiotic behavior is regular in case of diploids, whereas polyploids show irregularities, which suggest meiotic irregularities in addition to morphological variations in these species. de Wet and Borgaonkar (1963) found that naturally occurring hybrids were euploids and facultative apomicts, but artificial hybrids were either euploid or aneuploid, and very few were strictly sexual. Depending on these observations, it was proposed that apomixis is a dominant trait over sexuality and also that euploids have selective advantage over aneuploids in nature (de Wet and Borgaonkar 1963; Harlan et al. 1964). By cytoecological studies, it was hypothesized that the tetraploids have arisen from doubling of the related diploid species, which, over a period of time, evolved and differentiated cytologically, whereas hexaploids originated through hybridization of tetraploids and diploids. These theories have been postulated by Celarier and his coworkers in 1958, especially in case of D. annulatum. In D. annulatum, four different morphological types can be distinguished, viz. Tropical, Mediterranean, Senegal, and South African types (Harlan et al. 1958, 1961; Mehra 1964b). Tropical ones include prostrate or decumbent, diploid as well as tetraploid types. The Mediterranean types are generally erect with longer inflorescences, tetraploid, and more adapted to desert conditions. The Senegal type, represented by single collection from northwest Africa, is considered to be extreme form of Mediterranean type. The erect-growing South African types are all hexaploids and obligate apomicts (Mehra and Celarier 1958; Mehra 1962, 1964b; de Wet 1968). Morphological and cytological studies of these races and their hybrids show that they are not genetically isolated. It was, therefore, suggested to group three
6 Dichanthium
races, namely the Tropical, Mediterranean, and Senegal types under D. annulatum var. annulatum.
6.3.2 Ploidy Cycles in Dichanthium Various embryological, cytogenetical, and hybridization studies indicated that diploid species of all the three genera of the agamic complex reproduce sexually, while the polyploids (2x, 4x, 6x) are facultative apomicts, although there are a few exceptions (de Wet and Borgaonkar 1963; de Wet 1965, 1968). Diploid Dichanthium spp. are fully sexual and fertile, but occasionally produce autotetraploids as a result of fertilization of the unreduced male and female gametes. The present day diploid races of tetraploid agamospecies of D. annulatum, D. aristatum, and D. caricosum have been found to represent well adapted polyhaploids as they resemble few sexually reproducing artificial polyhaploids (de Wet and Singh 1964; de Wet 1965; de Wet and Harlan 1970a; D’Cruz and Reddy 1971). Polyhaploidy is rare in nature as they are usually completely sterile and poorly adapted. But a few polyhaploids produced from natural facultative apomicts or from natural or artificial hybrids between D. caricosum and D. annulatum, or D. aristatum resemble natural diploids at morphological and chromosomal level (de Wet 1965). Haploids obtained from Mediterranean ecotype (Mehra 1964b) of D. annulatum do not survive and are completely sterile, whereas those from Tropical ecotypes were found to be vigorous, reproduce sexually but sterile, indicating that apomixis is not functional in haploids. Presence of such fertile, sexually reproducing haploids have phylogenetic significance as it helps in maintaining contact with sexuality in predominantly polyploid agamospecies like Dichanthium (de Wet 1968; de Wet and Harlan 1970a). Triploids derived from hybridization within species of sexually reproducing diploid races of tetraploid D. annulatum, D. aristatum, and D. caricosum and between sexual tetraploid D. annulatum and other diploids or from fertilization of diploid female gametes with haploid male gametes have been reported. These triploids were all sterile but quite vigorous and cytologically irregular (de Wet and Singh 1964). Hexaploid D. papillosum, which has hybrid origin from two tetraploid D. annulatum (Mehra 1962), is an obligate apomict.
97
6.3.3 Hybridization Crossing experiments in Dichanthium were started earlier by many workers in order to study the phenomenon of apomixis in this genera. Several combinations of crossings between different species of Dichanthium, Capillipedium, and Bothriochloa and analyses of different characters of the progenies from such crosses revealed that they were morphologically same as maternal types, which were due to apomictic mode of reproduction and not due to maternal inheritance. Celarier and Harlan (1957) were able to establish this when they crossed among diploid and polyploid species of D. annulatum (2n ¼ 20, 40, 60) and D. caricosum (2n ¼ 40); D. annulatum (2n ¼ 40) with diploid and polyploid Bothriochloa sp. [B. intermedia (2n ¼ 40, 60), B. ischaemum (2n ¼ 50, 60), B.venusta (2n ¼ 40)] and Capillipedium sp. [C. parviflorum (2n ¼ 40), C. spicigerum (2n ¼ 40)]. Cytologically reduced or unreduced female gametes can function sexually or develop parthenogenetically in this genera (Harlan and de Wet 1963a). Introgressive hybridization between different species of Dichanthium, for example, D. annulatum with other species such as D. aristatum, D. caricosum, D. papillosum, and D. fecundum (Celarier et al. 1961; Chheda and Harlan 1963; Borgaonkar and de Wet 1964; Mehra 1966) or within different ecotypes as available in case of D. annulatum (Mehra and Celarier 1958; Mehra 1962), or even across genera, for example, Bothriochloa and Capillipedium (Harlan et al. 1958; Harlan 1963; de Wet and Harlan 1968, 1970a) provide a wide platform of variability in the genus Dichanthium Willemet. Studies in this direction were carried out by Harlan et al. (1964), wherein crosses between Bothriochloa grahmii and D. annulatum yielded hybrids, which were apomictic when both parents were apomicts and sexual when both were sexual. Similar results were also obtained by Harlan et al. (1961) and Singh (1968) when they crossed tetraploid D. annulatum with tetraploid B. grahmii; and diploid and tetraploid D. caricosum, respectively. In crosses between apomictic sexual and vice versa, hybrids were mostly apomicts, but frequency of sexuals was high compared to apomict apomict crosses. Harlan and de Wet (1975) were even able to obtain sexual types by crossing facultative apomicts.
98
Hybrids with different ploidy levels were obtained in crosses between facultative apomictic tetraploid D. annulatum and diploid sexuals of D. aristatum and D. caricosum, and their progenies were categorized as sexual and apomictic types (D’Cruz and Reddy 1971). In another study, D. caricosum was found to resemble polyhaploids from F1 hybrids of D. caricosum and D. annulatum, even though diploid D. annulatum and D. caricosum are reproductively isolated. D. aristatum was also indistinguishable from polyhaploid derived from F1 hybrids of D. aristatum and D. caricosum. Thus, D. caricosum acts as a genetic bridge between D. annulatum and D. caricosum at tetraploid level. In a tetraploid cross, when an unreduced female egg cell is fertilized by a reduced male gamete, the resultant progeny is a hexaploid. Best example of this being D. papillosum, which is the result of fertilization of unreduced egg cell of Tropical type with reduced male gamete of Mediterranean type of D. annulatum (Borgaonkar and Singh 1962; Mehra 1964b). It was, therefore, suggested to classify D. papillosum as D. annulatum var. papillosum (Pilger 1954). Similarly, tetraploid D. fecundum show morphological and cytological characters same as D. annulatum and is thus classified as D. annulatum var. fecundum (Hackel 1889). These three species together form an interrelated agamospecies, i.e., the D. annulatum complex (Singh and Mehra 1965). Celarier et al. (1961, 1962) also studied morphological and cytological characteristics of the hybrids between D. tenue (2n ¼ 40) and D. aristatum (2n ¼ 40), which differ in their morphology by the presence of glabrous peduncles and prostrate habit in the former. Three of the hybrids with 2n ¼ 40 chromosomes were decumbent with wooly peduncles, whereas two of them had 2n ¼ 60, which resembled D. tenue when it was used as female parent. The hexaploid was found to be the result of cross between cytologically unreduced female gamete from D. tenue and reduced male gamete from D. aristatum. The reciprocal crosses also yielded a hexaploid with the unreduced gamete coming from D. aristatum and resembled D. aristatum morphologically. Hybrids from such crosses also yielded morphologically intermediate types with semi-decumbent habit and slightly pubescent peduncles. These morphological variations in the hybrids indicate hybridization with limited genetic segregation in facultative apomicts. Celarier
V. Bhat et al.
et al. (1962) along with previous works by de Wet (1954) and Celarier et al. (1961) proposed that species such as D. aristatum, D. caricosum, D. pallidum, and D. tenue form an interrelated agamic complex wherein cytologically reduced and unreduced female gametes function sexually or parthenogenetically to form a series of hybrids with chromosome numbers ranging from 2n ¼ 20 to 2n ¼ 60. The natural tetraploids of D. annulatum are regarded as segmental allopolyploids (Stebbins 1947) and probably originated from hybridization between closely related species or partially isolated races of same species. de Wet et al. (1961) studied the chromosomal association in hybrids of Dichanthium. Hybridizations between two plants of D. annulatum with chromosome complement AAA1A1 and A2A2A3A3 result into hybrids (AA1A2A3), which associate cytologically into 20 bivalents, sometimes as trivalents or tetravalents. Hexaploids have AAA1A1A2A3, thus bringing together whole genome of one parent with half of the other parent. Hexaploid hybrids from D. aristatum (DDD1D1) and D. caricosum (CCC1C1) have chromosome compliment as CCC1C1DD1 and DDD1D1CC1 and behave cytologically as D. annulatum. Hybrids (AA1FF1) between D. annulatum and D. fecundum (FFF1F1) behave like one of the parents. Therefore, de Wet et al. (1961) were able to prove that the hybrids show autosyndetic pairing of the chromosomes in Dichanthium Willemet and also that chromosome pairing can take place within basic genome (n ¼ 10), indicating the original basic number as 5, as earlier suggested by Celarier et al. (1960).
6.4 Embryology The embryological studies and apomixis in Dichanthium have been conducted in detail by many workers (Brown and Emery 1957; Celarier and Harlan 1957; Reddy and D’Cruz 1969a) using microtomy and ovule squash method. Microsporogenesis was found to be slightly irregular with the formation of a few univalents and multivalents at metaphase I and bridges and laggards at anaphase I. Second meiosis was comparatively more regular and forms 3-nucleate pollen grain with thick wall and single germ pore. The female gametophyte development initiates with the differentiation of megaspore mother cell from the
6 Dichanthium
nucellus, which later degenerates (Bhanwra 1988). One or more cells of the nucellus show enlargement and vacuolation and form the aposporous embryo sacs. D. annulatum, being a facultative apomict, has sexual and apomictic embryo sac occurring together in the same ovule or different ovules of same inflorescence. The frequency of apomictic embryo sacs are generally higher than the sexual ones (Brooks 1958). The embryo sacs can be of sexual, reduced type with 8-nuclei or aposporous, unreduced with 4-nuclei. Apart from genotype, environment also plays a role in regulating the type of embryo sac development. According to Heslop-Harrison (1961), photo- and thermo-periods have considerable role in embryo sac development. In D. aristatum, photoperiodic conditions during inflorescence development can be correlated to apomixis and pollen fertility. Knox (1967) correlated the presence of apomictic embryo sacs and day-length in six localities in Australia, which was earlier shown by Knox and Heslop-Harrison (1963) under controlled conditions. The pollen fertility was also found to be affected under short day conditions, which favor apomictic embryo sac production (Knox and Heslop-Harrison 1966). Similarly, in case of D. annulatum, the frequencies of sexual and apomictic embryo sacs fluctuate with season (Gupta et al. 1969). Saran and his coworkers made worldwide collections of different Dichanthium species and studied the variation in these species. They found that all the species were uniform in their characters when collected along the equatorial region, whereas the species showed differences when moved away from equator. They reasoned the kind of uniformity shown among the species along the equator due to the photoperiod, i.e., equal day-length. In this way, the breeders can induce the type of embryo sac development by manipulating the environmental conditions. Experimentally, the shift from sexual to apomictic embryo sac has been tried. For example, Asker (1966) was able to increase the sexual embryo sacs in facultative apomict Potentilla. Apart from the 8-nucleate and 4-nucleate embryo sac distinction for detecting sexuality and apomixis, respectively, Saran and de Wet (1969) found a peculiar opening, which was consistently found in 8-nucleate embryo sacs of D. intermedium [equivalent to Bothriochloa bladhii (Retz.) S.T. Blake according to Quattrocchi 2008] and never in the aposporous embryo sacs. The opening was the result of unequal thickening in the wall layers of the embryo sac. The
99
function of the opening was to provide the least resistance to the growing pollen tube and therefore enhance the chances of fertilization. The presence of such an opening in the facultative apomicts favors the chances of sexuality. Harlan et al. (1964) extensively studied the embryology of six accessions representing different ploidy levels and four species belonging to two genera, viz. Bothriochloa and Dichanthium. They also studied three diploid species of Bothriochloa and 15 collections representing four diploid species of Dichanthium. They found sexuality at the diploid level and apomixis at higher levels and concluded sexuality and asexuality to be dependent on synchronization of different embryological events. With respect to fertilization and post-fertilization events, in case of 4-nucleate embryo sac, only one of the male gametes fuses with the polar nuclei and the other one either enters egg or remain outside. In most of the ovules, single aposporous embryo sac is functional and therefore embryo and endosperm development was observed in only one embryo sac. In case of apomicts, there was precocious development of embryos in the ovules, and embryo formation was observed even before anthesis. Reddy and D’Cruz (1969a) also described the apomictic mode of development of embryo by various mechanisms for elimination of syngamy mechanisms are gamtes either getting degenerated inside the egg cell or fail to enter it or are restricted to the suspensor cell. Other mechanisms include fertilization of both polar nuclei by twomale gametes or development of adventitive embryos from nucellus. Polyembryony in Dichanthium has also been reported in the apomictic species, D. annulatum. The development of twin embryos occurs in two ways. Either the two embryos develop independently in two different embryo sacs or in the same embryo sac. The former one is more prevalent than the latter. In the latter case, one of the embryos enlarges and pushes the other, which remains as a rudimentary structure (Reddy and D’Cruz 1969b).
6.5 Nature and Inheritance of Apomixis in Dichanthium Apomixis is generally defined as asexual reproduction through seeds (apo ¼ away from, and mixis ¼ act of mixing; Asker and Jerling 1992). The increase in
100
number of chromosomes due to polyploidy many a times induces meiotic abnormalities, resulting in sterility. To overcome sterility, species have evolved an alternate mode of reproduction, namely apomixis. The phenomenon of apomixis in Poaceae is quite frequent as reported by Brown and Emery (1957, 1958) and Pullaiah and Febulaus (2000). Apomixis in Dichanthium sp. along with its two closely related members of the tribe Andropogoneae, viz. Bothriochloa O. Kuntze and Capillipedium Stapf., was first studied by Celarier and Harlan (1957). Using hybridization and cytological studies, they were able to establish apomictic reproduction in 12 species of these three genera, excluding the possibilities of maternal inheritance and selffertilization (Celarier and Harlan 1957; Celarier et al. 1958). The type of apomixis in Dichanthium Willemet is of aposporous pseudogamous type (Gustafsson 1947a, b; Brown and Emery 1957; Celarier and Harlan 1957; Harlan et al. 1958; de Wet and Harlan 1970a; D’Cruz and Reddy 1971). In aposporous type of apomixis, all the four megaspores developed from megaspore mother cell degenerate and functional embryo sac is formed from another nucellar cell (called aposporous initial), which is unreduced; pseudogamy is the development of endosperm after fertilization of male gamete with the polar nuclei or the secondary nucleus. Apomixis was reported to be dominant over sexuality and two pairs of genes were found to be involved at tetraploid level, which are heterozygous in case of apomicts and homozygous in sexuals. The tetraploid apomicts were assigned the genotype AaAa and sexual ones aaaa, in the sense that the “A” allele induces formation of 4-nucleate apomictic embryo sac and “a” allele does not (Harlan et al. 1964; de Wet and Harlan 1970a). D’Cruz and Reddy (1971) also concluded sexuality and apomixis to be independent phenomena, associated with ploidy but found its inheritance as complex compared to earlier report by Harlan et al. (1964). They, like many other workers (Harlan et al. 1958 in Dichanthium sp., Chheda et al. 1961 and Borgaonkar and de Wet 1961 in Bothriochloa sp.), also emphasized on delicate nature of genetic balance required for the expression of apomixis in Dichanthium spp. due to sexual reversion of hybrids in F2 generation. Therefore, agamospecies, which were once considered to be genetic dead ends, are now characterized by dynamic genetic system, several mechanisms to facilitate recombination, and capable of high degree of adaptive polymorphism and progressive evolution (de Wet and Harlan 1970a).
V. Bhat et al.
6.5.1 Bothriochloa–Dichanthium– Capillipedium Agamic Complex Grass species have a typical agamic complex, which consists of several basic diploid sexuals and many apomictic polyploids (Harlan and de Wet 1963a, b). The genus Dichanthium forms an interrelated agamic complex (Celarier and Harlan 1957; de Wet and Harlan 1970a; Saran and de Wet 1970; de Wet and Stalker 1974) with two other genera of the tribe Andropogoneae, viz. Bothriochloa and Capillipedium (Fig. 6.5). Gene flow within this agamic complex occurs in different directions but sometimes there are a few incompatibility barriers. Srivastava and Purnima (1990) studied seven polyploid taxa involving Bothriochloa–Dichanthium complex and Heteropogon contortus and Paspalum paspaloides to establish different aspects of apomixis in these species. Species of the genus Bothriochloa, especially B. intermedia (R.Br.) A. Camus [equivalent to B. bladhii (Retz.) S.T. Blake according to Quattrocchi 2008], acts as a bridging species for crosses between Dichanthium and Capillipedium spp. (de Wet and Harlan 1970b; Berthaud 2001). B. intermedia (R.Br.) A. Camus introgresses with B. ewartiana (Domin) C.E. Hubbard, B. ischaemum (Linn.) Keng, Capillipedium parvifolium (R.Br.) Stapf, and D. annulatum (Forssk.) Stapf. Therefore, it was suggested that B. intermedia acts as a compilospecies and is carrying genes from several other species of Bothriochloa O. Kuntze, as well as species of Capillipedium Stapf. and Dichanthium Willemet (Harlan and de Wet 1963a, b; de Wet and Harlan 1966, 1970a, b). It was also suggested by de Wet and Harlan (1968) to combine all the three taxa under Dichanthium genera.
6.6 Breeding and Genomics 6.6.1 Germplasm Collections The online software project namely Germplasm Resources Information Network (or GRIN) of the National Genetic Resources Program of USDA provides germplasm information about plants, animals, microbes, and invertebrates important for food and agricultural production. This project lists different
6 Dichanthium
101
DICHANTHIUM
CAPILLIPEDIUM
parviflorum 2x, 4x
caricosum 2x, 4x
papillosum 6x
aristatum 2x, 4x
annulatum 2x, 4x
assimile 2x, 4x
grahamii 4x, 6x
glabra 4x, 6x
ewartiana 5x, 6x
intermedia 4x
ischaemum 4x, 6x
concanensis 5x
insculpta 5x, 6x
woodrowii 5x
kuntzeana 2x
pertusa 4x
radicans 4x
compressa 2x
BOTHRIOCHLOA
Fig. 6.5 Diagrammatic representation showing relationship among the members of Bothriochloa–Dichanthium–Capillipedium agamic complex [Redrawn from Berthaud (2001)]
species and varieties of genus Dichanthium, and its available accessions are in the National Plant Germplasm System (NPGS). It shows that there are around 80 accessions of D. annulatum with majority of the accessions with Pakistan (29 accessions) and India (28 accessions). There are seven accessions of D. aristatum with majority in US and 14 of D. sericeum with majority available in Australia. There are only two accessions available for D. foveolatum and one each of D. caricosum and D. maccannii.
6.6.2 Development of Cultivars Breeding of apomictic species was a serious challenge due to difficulty in obtaining recombination. With the increasing advances in understanding of the genetics of apomixis and availability of various tools, this task now seems to be achievable (Bashaw 1975, 1980). The
basic methods for cultivar development focuses on selection of useful commercial genotypes from a collection of apomictic genotypes or breeding of synthetic tetraploids with natural tetraploid apomicts. With the available germplasm collections, the major job is to identify the best genotype among the candidate genotypes. The current and previous proposals for breeding involved the perpetuation of heterozygous genotypes but failed to include means to exploit heterosis (Miles 2007). The success of any breeding program depends on the range of variability present in the germplasm collection, the proportion of sexual and apomictic seed production, and variability from crossbred progenies. Like many other grass genera, Dichanthium lacks a collection of different genotypes, and there is a need to look for mechanisms that could create variability. A wide platform of variability is available in case of Dichanthium among its different species such as D. aristatum, D. caricosum, D. papillosum, and
102
D. fecundum and among different ecotypes (as available in case of D. annulatum) or even across related genera, for example, Bothriochloa intermedia, B. ischaemum, B. pertusa, and C. parviflorum (Harlan et al. 1958; Harlan 1963; de Wet and Harlan 1968, 1970a). Also, through genetic segregation and recombination, new types can be developed by the breakdown of genomic relationships among the chromosomes introgressed from the species of Bothriochloa and Dichanthium (Mehra and Singh 1968). Variability can be introduced by the use of mutagenic agents as well. For example, conversion of pedicellate spikelet to bisexual flower in D. fecundum, a character governed by a single gene is an outcome of mutation of the gene governing it (Borgaonkar and de Wet 1960). Dichanthium species are usually the freely available rangeland grasses with high nutritive value. Rai et al. (1981) undertook a study to evaluate the available material and to select the best variety for forage production. They identified two cultivars, S-32 and S-65, of D. annulatum for maximum forage production, whereas the cultivars S-123 and S-128 were found to be suitable for soil conservation purposes. Seeds of native grass like D. sericeum are in great demand for the rehabilitation of landscapes affected by mining or urban development. Many cultivars have also been released in many countries for these forage species of Dichanthium. Following are the promising accessions reported by Cook et al. (2005) that have been released for cultivation: 1. D. annulatum accessions IGFRI-S-495-1 and IGFRI-S-495-5 from Indian Grassland and Fodder Research Institute IGFRI, Jhansi, India, and CPI 84146B from Queensland, Australia. 2. D. aristatum accession CPI 104839 from Australia. 3. D. caricosum accessions from Paraguay and northern Argentina 4. D. sericeum accessions ES-100 and ES-200 from Australia. The cultivar names and countries of origin, along with their features, have been tabulated in Table 6.1.
6.6.3 Genomics Little is known about the genome of Dichanthium, and it is difficult due to the occurrence of Dichanthium– Bothriochloa complex and their hybrids. The genetic
V. Bhat et al.
diversity can be evaluated on the basis of morphological, phenotypic, and genotypic characters. The last is more convenient and authentic than the first two, which are usually time-consuming and under the influence of environmental changes (Tanksley et al. 1989; Powell et al. 1996).
6.6.3.1 DNA Extraction Methodology The preliminary requirement of genetic screening studies is good quality DNA. The common problems observed in tropical grasses are high content of polysaccharides and lignin, which act inhibitory to polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis and other molecular techniques (Pandey et al. 1996). Chandra and Saxena (2007) were able to optimize rapid protocol for isolating genomic DNA from five tropical grass species, viz., D. annulatum, Heteropogon contortus, Sehima nervosum, Chrysopogon fulvus, and Cenchrus glaucus. The method involved modified CTAB procedure based on Murray and Thompson (1980).
6.6.3.2 Protein or Isozyme Markers Although a facultative apomict, D. annulatum shows high level of polymorphism at molecular level. Gupta et al. (2003) studied the phylogenetic relationships in four tetraploid species of Dichanthium– Bothriochloa complex based on isozyme phenotypes. They found D. annulatum to be evolving continuously and D. aristatum and D. caricosum to be isolated from D. annulatum over a period of time. D. caricosum was found to be more closely related to D. annulatum than D. aristatum according to protein marker studies.
6.6.3.3 DNA Markers A high level of polymorphism in the agromorphological characters has been reported in D.annulatum, independent of its geographical distribution (Chandra et al., 2004, 2006; Agrawal et al., 1999). Random amplified length polymorphism (RAPD) markerbased studies in different accessions of marvel grass collected from two contrasting regions including the
6 Dichanthium
103
Table 6.1 Detailed list of released cultivars of four major forage species of Dichanthium [reported by Cook et al. (2005)] S. no. Name of the Name of the cultivar Country of origin Features species 1. Dichanthium “Kleberg” USA (1944) Excellent drought tolerance, good seed annulatum producer, moderate salinity tolerance, relished by cattle. “Pretoria 90” USA (1954) Selected for seedling vigor, rapid growth (PI 188926, and yield. Good drought tolerance, BN-6730, T-20090) leafy; used for pasture, hay and silage. “T 587”, “PMT-587” USA (1981) Derived from a composite of 80 accessions. Suitable for pasture, hay, revegetation of disturbed areas and salt scalds, erosion control, and range reseeding. More cold tolerant than “Gordo”, “Medio”, and “Kleberg”. High forage producer. “Marvel 8” India 40–100% better dry matter yields than (CPI 106073) local strain. 2. Dichanthium “Medio” (NSL 20670, USA (1954) Selected from naturalized ecotype in aristatum NSL 22695) Texas. Best adapted to heavy soils USA (1957) Good seed producer. “Gordo” (PI 190302, BN-6851, T-20062, NSL 22694) “Alabang X” Philippines Slow to establish and susceptible to weed (PI 297430) competition when young. Best on poorer soils Erroneously referred to as var. heteropogonoides, but may in fact be an ecotype of D. caricosum. “T 587”, “PMT-587” USA (1981) Derived from a composite of 50 Dichanthium accessions established in 1962. Suitable for pasture, hay, revegetation of disturbed areas and salt scalds, erosion control, and range reseeding. More cold tolerant than “Gordo”, “Medio” and “Kleberg”. Resistant to leaf rust. High forage producer. “Floren” (CPI 106374) Australia (1995) Leafy, very palatable ecotype. 3. Dichanthium “Marvel 40” India (1971) Produce 40–100% more dry matter than caricosum (CPI 106073) the naturally occurring strain. “Marvel 93” India (1971) Produce 40–100% more dry matter than (CPI 106075) the naturally occurring strain. “Alabang X” Philippines Not available 4. Dichanthium “Scatta” Pending release in Not available sericeum Australia
North Indian plateau and South India revealed South Indian accessions to be more polymorphic, whereas those from central plateau were found to be more suitable for drought stress. Thus, Saxena and Chandra (2006) were able to identify three accessions of D. annulatum suitable for genetic resource management and for isolating genes controlling drought tolerance.
6.6.3.4 Phylogenetic Studies Andropogoneae is a member of monophyletic subfamily Panicoideae and forms a part of large and well-supported panicoid–arundinoid–chloridoid– centothecoid (PACC) clade of the family Poaceae. Andropogoneae is monophyletic based on data from morphology (Kellogg and Watson 1993), chloroplast
104
V. Bhat et al. Andropogon spp. - AN
100
Core Andropogoneae
78
Hyparrhenia hirta - AT Schizachyrium scoparium - AN
64
Bothriochloa odorata - SO
100 98
Capiltlpedium parviflorum - SO Dichanthium aristatum - SO Cymbopogon flexuosus - AN
99
Cymbopogon jwarancuss - AN Heteropogon contortus - AT Cleistachne sorghoides - SO 72
Microstegium nudum - SA Miscanthus japonicus - SA
Origin of Awns
Saccharum officinarum - SA 100
Chrysopogon futvus - SO Chrysopogon gryllus - SO Ischaemum spp. - IS Apluda mutica IS Sorghum bicolor - SO Coelorachis selloana - RO Elionurus muticus - RO 95
Origin of Disarticulating Rachis
Tripsacum dactyloides - TR Zea mays - TR
95
Chionachne koenigii - CH Phacelurus digitatus - RO
100
Coix aqua - CO 52
100
Arundinella hirta Arundinella nepalensis Paspalum spp.
Panicum spp.
71 100
100
Tristachya superba Urochloa mutica Pennisetum alopecuroides Danthoniopsis dinteri
10 changes
Fig. 6.6 Single-most parsimonious tree based on combined sequences of PHYB, ndhF, and GBSSI. Abbreviations following taxon names indicate respective subtribes according to Clayton and Renvoize (1986). AN: Andropogoninae; AT:
Anthistiriinae; SO: Sorghinae; SA: Saccharinae; IS: Ischaeminae; RO: Rottboelliinae; TR: Tripsacinae; CH: Chionachninae; CO: Coicinae. (Mathews et al. 2002)
gene ndhF (Spangler et al. 1999), and nuclear genes, viz., granule-bound starch synthase I (GBSSI) (MasonGamer et al. 1998) and phytochrome B (Mathews et al. 2002). Mathews et al. (2002) combined the three matrices namely PHYB, GBSSI, and ndhF to generate a data
set of different members of Andropogoneae (Fig. 6.6). Among the awned taxa, they identified a poorly supported clade named as “core Andropogoneae,” which included Andropogon, Bothriochloa, Capillipedium, Cymbopogon, Dichanthium, Heteropogon,
6 Dichanthium
Hyparrhenia, Schizachyrium, and Sorghastrum. In case of individual trees, they were able to resolve a clade of Bothriochloa, Dichanthium, and Capillipedium, but in PHYB and GBSSI trees, Bothriochloa was found to be united with Capillipedium, while in ndhF tree, it grouped with Dichanthium. This confirms their relationships and interfertilities as suggested by Harlan and de Wet (1963a) and Kellogg (2000). Giussani et al. (2001) studied the molecular phylogeny of the subfamily Panicoideae and also found Dichanthium– Bothriochloa–Capillipedium to represent together in cladogram when they mapped base chromosome number, anatomical characters including chloroplast structure, position, and number of bundle sheaths, and physiological characters including type of decarboxylating enzyme, viz. NADP-maleic enzyme. Rondeau et al. (2005) studied phylogenetic relationship among the members of this tribe using an enzyme, NADPdependent malate dehydrogenase (NMDH). This enzyme belongs to multigene family and is highly conserved among plants. They found two distinct genes (NMDH-I and NMDH-II) encoding this enzyme, which would have arisen due to gene duplication associated with selection pressure. They also speculated presence of both genes in few species analyzed, e.g., D. aristatum, H. contortus, etc. but could not detect the transcripts of the latter because of its scarcity.
6.6.4 Biotechnological Studies in Dichanthium Tissue culture and genetic transformation tools could be effectively used to generate somaclonal variation and targeted gene transfers, respectively. Due to predominant apomictic mode of reproduction, variability in this taxon can be heritably fixed in the subsequent generations. Hence, optimization of tissue culture protocol was a very essential initial step toward genetic improvement of D. annulatum. In vitro plant regeneration has been reported from immature inflorescence (Gupta et al. 1997), nodal explant (Gupta et al. 1998), shoot tip (Dalton et al. 2003), and mature seeds (Kumar et al. 2005) of D. annulatum. Genetic transformation is a means to alter the genome by introgression of genes from distant or unrelated grass species or by introduction of alien genes. The desired genes for improving the nutritional quality
105
of Dichanthium could be for lowering the lignin content while increasing the protein quality. The high lignin content of tropical forage plants reduces in vitro digestibility and voluntary feed intake by ruminants. Dalton et al. (2003) reported three transgenic plants of D. annulatum containing hygromycin resistance gene, while two of them contained b-glucuronidase gene (GUS) after embryogenic calli were co-transformed with two plasmids encoding either of these genes. Hygromycin resistance varied from 68 to 100% in the progeny of these three transformants (Fig. 6.7). Although DNA gun-mediated genetic transformation is the method of choice for range grasses (Dalton et al. 2003), which are recalcitrant to Agrobacterium tumefaciens, it generally results in transgenics with multiple copies of a gene that may cause gene silencing, whereas the Agrobacterium-mediated transformation method is cheaper, easier, more reliable, while only a single copy of a gene is delivered. Hence, a comparison between these two methods in terms of their transformation efficiencies would help in improving the level of Agrobacterium-mediated transformation efficiency to that of the gene gun-mediated transformation. Towards this, Kumar et al. (2005) compared frequency of GUS expression between both methods of transformation using binary vectors pCAMBIA1305 and pCAMBIA1301. Among two binary vectors used for Agrobacterium-mediated transformation, pCAMBIA1301 showed higher frequency of GUS expression while pCAMBIA1305 recorded more of the GUS spots per callus. Particle inflow gun-mediated transformation resulted in higher GUS expression compared to the Agrobacterium method using pCAMBIA1305. Further optimization is necessary before using Agrobacteriummediated transformation of Dichanthium.
6.7 Primary Productivity and Biomass Production Production, compartment transfer of dry matter, and aboveground production are higher in case of tropical grasslands compared to their temperate counterpart (Misra and Mall 1975). Studies on dry matter, organic matter, and crude protein content for rangeland grasses in Pakistan show the highest relative preference for D. annulatum than other rangeland grasses (Sultan et al. 2008). D. annulatum has been shown to produce
106
V. Bhat et al.
Fig. 6.7 Tissue culture, gene-gun-mediated transformation, regeneration, and progeny screening of transgenic Dichanthium plants. (a) Shoot tip-derived embryogenic calli (8 weeks old) on maltose-based medium (W1). (b) Shoot regeneration in 47 weeks old callus on regeneration medium. (c) Callus after 5 weeks of growth on Hygromycin (0, 50 and 100 mg/l) containing callus medium (top to bottom). (d) Transient GUS expression in callus 48 h after bombardment with plasmid pACT1-F. (e) GUS expression 11 days after bombardment of callus with plasmid
pACT1-F. (f) Bombarded tissue surviving after 6 weeks of selection on callus medium containing 75 mg/l hygromycin. (g) Root growth in transformed plants established in soil: tillers of R1 and R10 (A) and non-transformed tillers (B) grown hydroponically in a solution containing 50 mg/l hygromycin. (h) Flowering in transformed Dichanthium plants. (i) Floral head of transformed plant. (j) Survival of seedlings of T1 progeny of plant R2 germinated on medium containing 50 mg/l hygromycin (right) compared with non-transformed control (left)
maximum organic matter at Magan grassland at Dhakarwara (Trivedi and Mishra 1979). With reference to dry matter yields, data has been collected for the major forage crops of Dichanthium
sp. of D. annulatum range from 2–6 t/ha and even upto 17 t/ha, whereas for D. aristatum and D. caricosum, it is in the order of 10–12 t/ha. In case of D. sericeum, the yield is dependent upon the soil and climatic
6 Dichanthium
condition as D. sericeum has a wide distribution range (Cook et al. 2005). A good D. annulatum stand yields 3 t/ha hay compared to an average of 9 t/ha in case of D. aristatum (Cook et al. 2005). With regard to the animal production or carrying capacity, the four major cultivated crop species of Dichanthium have been studied thoroughly. D. annulatum stand can support up to 7 sheeps/ha in semiarid environment. In case of D. aristatum and D. caricosum, the live-weight gain of an animal is 270 kg/ha/yr and 150 kg/ha/yr, respectively, when grown in combination with legumes. On the other hand, D. sericeum has a comparatively low carrying capacity compared to these species (Cook et al. 2005). The next section discusses various factors, which affect the productivity and biomass production in Dichanthium sp.
6.7.1 Various Factors Affecting Productivity and Biomass Production in Dichanthium 6.7.1.1 Biotic Factors Grazing and Herbage Removal The effect of increase in the density or crowding of D. annulatum and little or no grazing showed initial increase in yield but subsequent decrease in aboveground herbage, biomass, and higher mortality (Tripathi and Gupta 1980). Studies on D. annulatum show high degree of palatability at all stages of its growth, and therefore, it is considered to be grazed preferentially compared to other species. This study on relative palatability is useful for studying the impact of grazing on natural grasslands and also in evolving suitable practices required for their management (Dabadghao and Marwaha 1962). However, recent studies have shown that grazing in rangelands causes weakening and death of native and introduced desirable species and allow less desirable invasive plants. For example, D. annulatum competes with native desirable species as it can persist grazing pressure, high temperature, and less water. Ortega-Santos et al. (2007) found that D. annulatum affects primary productivity of grazing lands for cattle
107
as it is less desirable than the native species such as Cynodon nlemfuencis, Panicum maximum, Brachiaria decumbens, and Digitaria decumbens. The growth performance like seed weight of D. annulatum has also been found to decrease with increase in biotic disturbances, whereas the number of vegetative buds on rhizomes is found to increase, which results in higher biomass and productivity. It has also been found that the habit of the plant changes from erect to prostrate forms in case of protected and grazed grounds, respectively (Ambasht and Maurya 1970).
Diseases and Pests Many fungi have been reported to attack Dichanthium sp., but major damage has not been reported. Balansia sclerotica, Cerebella andropogonis, Cochliobolus cymbopogonis, Curvularia andropogonis, C. lunata, C. robusta, C. gudauskasii, Phyllachora ischaemi (tar spot), Pithomyces graminicola, Puccinia cesatii, P. duthiae, P. propinqua, P. kenmorensis (rust), Sclerospora dichanthicola, Sphacelotheca annulata, S. andropogonis-annulati, Striga lutea, Tolyposporella obesa, Uredo susica, Uromyces andropogonisannulati, and U. clignyi to name a few. Downy mildew fungus, namely Sclerospora sorghi, has been identified as pathogens of D. caricosum in Thailand (GRIN). In 1966, an undescribed species of Curvularia from Texas (later named as C. robusta due to the large size of conidia) was identified to be pathogenic on D. annulatum (Kilpatrick and Luttrell 1967). A list of various smut fungi including Sporisorium dichanthii affecting D. aristatum; S. dichathicola pathogenic on D. caricosum; and S. sahahyai (Wang and Piepenbring 2002), Ustilago duthiei and U. sabourieana on D. annulatum has been reported Va´nky (2004). Claviceps sp., which causes ergot disease pose a significant hindrance in seed production in D. annulatum and D. aristatum. D. caricosum has been found to be susceptible to root-knot nematodes whereas D. aristatum acts as an alternate host for sheath blight of rice caused by Rhizoctonia solani (Cook et al., 2005). Apart from pathogenic fungi, grasslands support a rich fungal population, which exists in the mantle around the roots. These rhizosphere fungi were found to effect seed germination and root growth of the seedlings (Leelavathy 1969a, b).
108
6.7.1.2 Abiotic Factors Seasonal Burning Fire is considered to be a powerful factor to design community structure in rangelands and to manipulate plant population. Burning has shown to stimulate the shoot–root growth of D. annulatum but decrease in belowground biomass. It has been found that burnt plots show higher productivity as a result of improved nutrient status, less shading, and presence of young tillers (Pandey 1988). Fire thus influences the uptake and release of nutrients like NPK and in turn increases the mineral pool (Paulsamy et al. 1995, 2005) encouraging higher productivity.
Factors affecting Seed Germination Various physical factors such as light, temperature, and habitat condition affect seed germination of D. annulatum. Seeds of D. annulatum are photosensitive and show high germination rate during rainy season. Seed cover and increasing depth of sown seeds affects germination capability, whereas continuous light and optimum temperature of 30 C shows maximum germination percentage in D. annulatum (Maurya 1972). On the other hand, the warm season native perennial grass D. sericeum germinates usually during mid-summer to early autumn period.
V. Bhat et al.
growth of D. annulatum seedlings have been found to decrease with increase in salinity level (Akhtar and Hussain 2008; Khan et al. 2009). It was found that the moisture content in seedlings grown under saline conditions was more than control seedlings, which indicating adaptive mechanism in grasses by becoming succulents in saline soils.
Soil Moisture Soil moisture stress along with clipping intensity has shown to increase the water use efficiency (WUE) in D. annulatum. As soil moisture stress increases, the transpiration rate drops down. The drop in transpiration rate is more pronounced in winters than in summers, which indicates that a strong moisture conservation mechanism operates in D. annulatum (Singh and Misra 1985). The root:shoot ratio was found to be higher with increase in soil moisture stress, and studies have indicated that dry matter production was maximum when water potential is between field capacity and saturation percentage (Singh and Sinha 1983). Except for nitrogen, concentration of all other nutrients decrease with increase in soil moisture stress. Nitrogen, potassium, and phosphorus use efficiencies increase with high soil moisture stress (Misra and Singh 1982).
Shade Seed Dormancy In Dichanthium, seed dormancy is imposed by covering of the embryo (i.e., the seed coat) or within the embryo. Smoke-stimulated germination and scarification help to release dormancy due to seed coat, whereas exposure of seeds to fluctuating temperatures releases dormancy imposed by the embryo in D. sericeum (Read and Bellaris 1999; Adkins et al. 2002).
Salinity The germination percentage, plumule–radicle length, shoot–root dry weight, and in turn establishment and
Shade affects chlorophyll accumulation in D. annulatum, i.e., chlorophyll b increases but chlorophyll a decreases. An increase in chlorophyll (a þ b) shows adaptability of this grass under shade. Shade also increases the accumulation of carotenoids, which increases the quality of fodder (Baig et al. 2005). Shade has no effect on C and N influxes in D. aristatum, but there is a preferential allocation of C and N under low irradiance, which changes shoot: root ratio in turn affecting its photosynthetic capacity. K and P accumulation also increases under shade. D. aristatum was not able to use radiation efficiently, which indicated that it is not adapted to silvopastoral system where shade is more (Cruz 1997a, b).
6 Dichanthium
6.8 Conclusion Dichanthium forms a major component of grass covers of tropics and subtropics. So far, around 20 species are known 1200 in this genus, which are widely distributed. Four major species are popular forage crops, whose cultivars are commercially utilized. This genus also encompasses high level