This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
I !W-l
"""'" >
A.. i Arn.t the kit<, (", .. I ,he kit< hm-.,ri~ '" the
"[here i, ..... , ",me c,,,,untmn,,"
~h",
m"tI'pIM" "f ,h." (,,,,ri.m 1""") i, C<>'''''".n,
~'i,h
bip. I><.w,-
,,'oJ""""." So, ,he bi«l_ • goner,"
"''''''''J'';'-''' o f
<1>< ;;<~~ I"" . A, f,>t , h~ ,Ii,';"" ".m. ""', i,;' ~) be furt h"r "'""'pk of ..)/') , ~'h",h "1'1""'«"] ,n diJI..) (§§1 - .1J .nJ Iij (il!') . So) £0. ;, ,,, be und,",_ ,t(~~l ., "I"'~'
<"""ru<J., •
"".,,' '" "'''' n~,'e, ' " 1'1"r," of ,ru",,,~ .'"
18
mlk
'11>",e ;;<><,,"1< gi,'.n <""","ti,,,, lid", (K"lU 1.1 ;" 1 4- 2O< ~) "",I Mo. , uli"g " COl)' (1.4 "~ ii i D- 1 4 ~') . ,\\.-.. ;, '"'" ,Ie«ribed "' ",he kin~ of in J ' ~' I 8, 14. \\' ~ .,,,,m ,,, h>., '< ffi()!'< ,h"" " plentt..J..- of I"',,,n,, '",. II,.,." ~'< = r ""to th,,, b""",ni,,!: ' ki "g i, ,n B:ul', "''''".
'"tt'''''''
<,
,,t. "..u.-.. lo"" 1I",~ ' ... _."",
"",. , '"" ,'''', , 29]_OJ, -'1') (f\<-" r,~ ,ht "". , ~ n ~ .. 'h< '"om.,t, ~.q,. 'n ' h< ;"on' ?"",' to,", ,,,,-,
("'. A''''''-~ ,,,,' k, ''', """ ("'. '''''''' .... >;h,b" " u",' .,""). "" L..... ~ ....."'","" ,,~.. , ~"'. ~'ih,:«ll:'..u.-"
1'Ml, [N . ..;.b.
....,
""<~ ' ''''0, §H2, d..-.>«l 'h" ,,,,-, "'''''~''" ~ Jd""" '" ' .'""",,, " '" "",~. " '"' ,i,,~ ~~ ud< ,~. , ... .. "" , " , • """ d . '""""" .......... hlJ ;, J«""" ~ ~.'
"'''''''''' "' ,,,,-,
,. .. ' ""'. 1""5. H. ,""""" "'-' ,..~' 'h< "''''' " ""'''''''' '1"'",,". ,., "'" "',.." ] """" l2t ~l' _ lO l5/" , 1<--1:'.
''' <:1. " . 42
32
19
I'("OR" (lI' TRIT. """ IX" HW'-,R<W Sro ""
'/y
"tlu; ,om,. of ,,'hid, ,ho bn~~", biboc-.J ..-.J c<~ nn~\o\ I\'e
,,,,,,1<,,,i;'.. 1'''''''''
To ,h< =th (moph<<< 000><) th< ""n of lIul, ,,, ' h< "<J'!'< ,I« .-..n o f 'h< ~h, Ii¢>' PI"...", to tl« "rth (~ , .. Id 1><) th< .-.in of S .... ....1 to ,I>< '''PP< t l>< ,,,,n oftl« ,\10>, I!¢'''''
'n,,, "PI""". liko ""me " th« f,,,.,nul,,,,, P""."" ,n ,he ,ext. ~) be • fr"m. ~'u%·. " 'hi
P''''''''
2tI
,tb'tpt,..
Thi, ",I< " f'>unJ '''tcen cin"". tcn "m", io d", &.I eyel< (KIlJ 1.1---<',), ..-.J ,h",,, ,n I , I 0, ' >
co, {"."'"' t 'WJ. "'. ki.
t ""'!, I '"": K>p<>ul 1')<;2. ,..,.. "" ""'" t "''''- '" I. m"."",,,ru«J ,bt ,;d<, ."". ;, M' ,,,. ~,>
,,"",..-N " ,."' "'''''-''''
(U", .. ,,2U>l.2JL
r" ,,,. ",,' "" "", j . '
,bt , ... "'. .....
'h< '«f'I'< ,bt
,p<».,
,...,..f ,bt ." "" fl 'W<'
>'1'''.' .... ,~ 'h< "'" h ("<, '"'" bt) 'h< ""' ,,.. ~ ... , ....... , ' h< '"'f'I'< ,bt ,..., " I ,bt ." "" fl¢" )
'" "'f>cl"'" ""2. "'--
H
TilE n n n OFTIlE (j{;,\RI'J1I: Sn)R"_"OI)
kn<,,, h,,'e bet,n P"1",..,J ro, ,he b,l<, "R.,Je, or tl", CI<,,,,{,"_ ,,, "Ch.nmee, " r ,he O"".I,"'~_ The pf<'-'''' ron" ,It) no ""r"in d"" "" '0 ,,-hid, of ,I><", i< to b" prd, ......'
"" 'eo
,m,,.
"'pe.",
i"""
,.b..ihd
".,li"" ",,,,,,
". {;.,," 1w,J,
to ,.
(~,,,,,,
,'rlO, '>'J, D,,,,, ,",.\ ". J"",, ,''',,, ,. ("\\" ""''''''''',");
'0"' ..,. ("'" '"
'-""""' ' '''''). !U" . ... , .." ho, .. " ~," ... " 'Ch< .. , """ ct..",,,,,,, ~'I "",," ,,,, .1<_" " ...... '.",.,,', 'Lhi,·", d 'h< _~ ; ... I'- ,~ " "..... '~, 'Kil« "n '"' R"'~""'".· d_ '"' ,"' .... >mI~)' '" ,1., c...... ,'n, "'
. .", 198" "). ,"---'.,.1; '"''"''' ''''''', .17. ,, ""'ko"" ''''''', " I'd« ",I "',,,.,,, Eo-""',f""«""'l, "" (,.",-, ' ''''
fU",.--oh< "". ' ;;b,,,,,
i.,""",'J' Xdl>. 1""-'. " i, ''''''''.); '"f~'
''''''', r
•. U "'r<J....o '0", 61 t'D';""l-
,.. U ' h< "" ,.I "'" ,,'" t.,. h,,~ In ""I1J 1." • 21 '"' "'" '" ' h< ""'f"<". ' '',/h< .~"' "" ,,, 'h< "'I' ,~' "", ' ' '''", "' ...-..JI>< .. ...-....J "f' ., 'h< ,w>"" ,.' '"' ~'"-
19",,_
'''" '. 0"
."j
L1", _\
m<~ '"""",,,
up'"
(\l''''' 2m,. ,.., ''''')
,.. S« ,..,"'" ,.,,,,...,, .... (;""",,,'d 10""_
'" ", U"'"", ,,,,I C" ...
1'f'!, 2'\-.2\ .>1-" (<arl)' _"" ~ ,) .". 45-1<1
, h"o __ "'"",).
'" [,,'""" .... <;~'"~, ' to"". ~_S_
\>0<"
I'("OR" (lI' TRIT. """ IX·IH WI'.R <W STO""
.f< ", I., ''''''''ot"d l'nnuri~' " 'i,h the p"""""" of Pmt(~ I",J,~A'l... n' m ,1>< "'I,"on. the i«""'S""phie ~"''''''''\ " C"""Nt""!, ,,'c ,I>",,"! lool to '~"~>n. "',,I> !l""_gnd . Fi"d), ,,'e h",'e <.rl) "'1'''''«n,.OOn, of. doil,. !d"n,;f",d hy I'.nd ·" II< tl", '\ \<""'I"',"m0.n ""rm_g<xl. F.. rl)· <
''''0
~
f.,
II<
,,,,,,,,,.I '" ,1\" ,,·••
""m",),. '"
,,,,,,lid,,,, "' •
I",,'· ,I", M."",
'1'1""''''
C,,,",
'" \ ·....1'''''-'. ('« "",,' (;""" lOH. "'-) '" Cf. \,,,,,1 t'''''. ' ..... , I''''''' d"o'" .., ....), " • (>'001, tn. 1 L (buI). T" '-... '
0 0 ,", """,,,,' <>i ... ""~'<m< .. ..-.1
u;
, ~ S« .·IX "". " '''-'''. " , h' .. ;;.
cr. "- T.
, " E-jt. ~ U'- '. L. ~-' . '. I-!<\. t ""'. ' ~ S«\l'l" "
,.,." . u. ,,-,-" 1 ... 2-.3, '''. (0, ",hW.,,,,, ~· "h 'h""" h< ....." , WI'"~
*'·1-1
"02, ,.. 1=
"- '"..-
TilE n n n OFTIlE (j{;.\RI'J1I: Sn)R"_"OI)
.oJ " I",,, «",,,,,,,-,1 "' i ndi"'''n~ hy ,I{ ,h~ ,hi rd "",,,,1,,-,, of. ''''''' , ,he .rd"'n/R"', "". """"""I n""''') I"';"g men"",>
"um"", ""1«",;,,,,'"
""",,"".,;., ~ith"u' "chen I>
'!"'"'_
n",
fir>. n",,,,he, "f "",I> • ,e"m, .",1 ,n "n"t!'<~ "r ", "'... "iekling ~'""'''' •• "d" i. i" ,h" gu'''' ,hot I hel",,'< Bul " ... , "n,,!-~"o:-J un_ .b 1>" tid" ,kb '.pt. 'Ihe ',!,un"-",, ",l ie, " " ci",um,,"n,ial ""iJe""", '" he , ure, h u, i. di,,,,I,o:-J h )" ' '''0 p<~"". Fir,,"',' ,mall hmnze ' u"''''<''< of. rai, of
i, .
i,
,h",.
"1'''
" ",'\, U 4 •."'-JII cr<, l'h< - ...... "'.. ,~ ... "'" ,,"'"' ~ t OO x w...., Th< I>t r" ""'-" "" mI~ , ,,(,h< " .... ~ '" ,,., pNIo«l)"" ,,-."" 21m , ''XI, "". ""--M.)
,,,,,'I k ' h< ' ~ s."
-"'of'
'" ,"'" ,,, 1".1:'"i h" ( ~') '" On ' h<
,~
= (", """" ."",
",,,. l 'ro, pi. '- '''', II ~''''' '' A"
~ ..
_.pI»
'''h<' "'" ("",,,", ""'"1"'"' ''' ~,,,,,, , " .1 U , "'F " , ..... '''1
,,t ,w.,
=
"').H ,,,,,-,,
"" y..too
1" ', ""-"" ' ~ Th< " nk" ,", ' """ 'h< ' ) " '" ,,( ,,., '''' ' ~ I"'h>[>< _ _ '" ~Tl) 1..1 n ' 1\ ~' b " h '1'1""" ,,, f ~ """"" I""< '" p' ..... ,~ .L.I f'" "",.-, ...., "''''- .... -' ,,.,,. YO 1,4 , ," ,- (". ..
".o.t f ~ _ ""'. ,...., '" 1""'>1), ,,' , "" ">
.. , to;, ~
~' ,""b ;, ' " ..,""" '" i mp. ~~ f "'. ,\ ",, " ~ ,,.,
u..r, "'.," ",..j",,,,,1"""""
(fl, 6'1 ...
. 'I·
I'"""v .,( ' h<
, ~" ",.j, ~' .' h'' '''
'h< (>« .,(
I'("OR" (lI' TRIT. """ IX'IH WI'.R <W Sro""
Gup,n_.nJ_lJg;.'. 'the !",; n, ",-"" k ,hot ~'" t<,m '"" ("-" n . 6>1) i. u<eJ '" '""ogru'~ h,m (,I><m) on f,>u' ,,,,,,,,
,I>< R>.im' 0"., l ,h,u "'" h i. goH'" (J.,.'TI) L2 i l ll- l9, .\5)
(J...'TI) 1..\ i, bu, ""' ""', n",d(.) "f ,I>< .ood! (KTIJ 1.4>-;;i
]2)' ~
ISJ' ~
11 m,), ""'''' no m<",~ l1"n "'«'
!PI
'lhe t
u,""
fi",
""*""'iJ<.iJ
(~, ,in~
i. V.li="
" .. full 1"'~'i"'l «""ent of ,I>< Ierm !pi" ",'",",n, in '" h.1I,><:e ~'"h ../hi ,n 11", . b b. "".. of "'" A, ,n it< u« ,n om)' 1<",,,1. ."""eJ ,n ,I><
""r<
''',,,,, ;, "...,..,~.-d
("IT
,,"'h.
1.1 . " , -'~).
Th< ..... ~"" "'" ,,,,,,"'" l .tH '
' "' ""'" .Icl (14m" 1.«' ".n_" ,'" ~,~" '"'''' " •
,r"" "- _,.
",od,.,,,
"rl" '''" I, .... \.
'~"'")'" 10:>2. '" '~;", .. ' .. ',('"'~' '~ ",", " I
..,"''2. ""
'l.
TilE n n n OFTIlE (j{;,\RI'J1I: Sn)R,,·C,OI)
11,,0" "f j,,
'"'to
,r.e;,
ilf'P""'" '"
Oth ... _sibl. and dubious
'i,Ie .'~
Th<", "'" ,",n."" ""p'e<<.i'M" in ,he I; go"'''' 'e"" ~'lIlCh nul' he «,,, ,,,,,,,,1 a, of ,h .....,",h
,,,Ie.
22
h'lI",p
Oc.;u'~"g otta
in KTIJ 1.46 .6, ,hi. "1~ "U'e ", di,-in< "ole ~ '., memk"",d b) ""'rd,uJ in II" ,,,,,m,,,,, of Ihal ', title.'· He ",..""k",d ... h", he, It m.), ",I"e '" B", ]" If<"t""'''' "f ,he ellgle. (,h", i" role"".) '01 ,he .-4JmI ,to,,) (KT U 1.19 ii, 1--4S)_'11""e ,10"" "". «em '0 m< ", be .n)' """'g' "'.~'" '" ",," ,he ''''', .",1 ",hilt XolI" , .. n,b,,,,I,, '" ''',.-inb''''!' IlcW",m K.. h"" "",I «d w[>O,,)m ."'On <""h lin i"'e'i""'''~''' de T",>!;<", I~"h tl.., di,';n< ,,,I" ..",,,ld I",,'e til<
,,<.. htp.,.
23
h'l mrym fP" and h'l (b)~," $pn
\X'hil< tI",,,, pit"''''' ore c<~)\m")\I )' ,,,,,,,1;.,,,.1 os "II",] ." ,h" l""gim /,,,,,,,,,,,. of s..pl;,><,,, of "BiW " '1;,, ,I ~..,II, i" ,10" hL'4:h"/rece,,,,. of S"ph<x' '', ;, i, .",,,,,1.1< ,h,, , ;n ,he f(~ l o"""g tl>
i"" •."""
''' <:I. n. N " ".f>
'ox .... , .. "_,,.
co, """"' '''---', '--'" ..
T""""" '"(:..,... ".. ' -' ' ',"" .
I'("OR" (lI' TRIT. """ IX·IH WI'.R <W Sro ""
,,f b'11/>"
(j9 " .we). Tb.
"''''>
,,,,,,,,rn,,.,,,.,, of
Kill U iv 18, 1..1 ,. 22, 1..';, I I, 1.100.9 (ill i "","), K'IU 1.(',-i 12-U r '","); KI1J U i 21_22 (h = " io") .
'Il,,-~, C(m'"'H"~'"
'''-'Y he «>fI,,,,,,,,.1 ~'"h th .. "f b'I....,... ""'. KTl; U " . 1 (I! = "f,,,,,,'')-~'he,,, 1l>.1Il i, ,be di""" (~, ,.,< ! "f. "erb (trJ) "h id , i, ~uIIl i r.
"In"'
w,,_ <"'"
"""<,,,
u
~" 1\1", i, the ""t>' de"b",.,,-,
"",,h
",-,,",, ' 1' '.0" f'- ,,>4 '" ",,", • •• ,'" "f"-,... ..."... _ '' '''. I"", "",1>00 "'''' Cf. I'.-.p< "1"7. ' "<J-"1 , ,,~..., "" ... " ~~h ,~"". ",,"" ~~, """",,oJ ,,", ''1''''', .~
",,"",,~
L'",,- ""_2.' . •~ S«
p",,, ")"2. "" ". "
~.
"""'''''''
(\·.,,,u,, ..... (;''"'. F""". B~" .,-.t ""-",,,kid).
TilE n n n OFTIlE (j{;.\RI'J1I: Sn)R"_"OI)
39
,11<, h)'I""',.,'<---<)f ,II< ""nn.g<)d. '~ I f ".., ""cep,al ~'" I." \';"~'. ,1>< "Pid,,, of R.p'u in KI1] L 108.1. ",,,.JJ be )"et """,,11<, ",Ie. 25
",It. "".
hd<..
In K l1] 1.108 .2-3 ,.'" 10"-,, ,II<
f,~ k)w'ng
,nOf'gu'''g hi<"h""
;/"..',,,, ;/-",. -
)
(M.'),.. ~t) 1" ' '1''''''',1-" th., tll
,\hr!.'u~,
TI", "," omlo"" ...< "," ~-",> rub ;n 1'.1'"'-'"
11 " ,1I<,dn",
"' ~.
tt,l"
.f","".
'" 'x ." ,"" '''''', '07 "- '- " "'"..".... '%". '"'-"0, • ""'" .. hi< .,.......'" h< "1'1"""'"
., di..;n,,.,,,,, ,h<,.."
"
,'" ,.oJ ~.. , ~ ","""." Il..J.M.
,'" ""l"·"" ",""
~""" "'" pio)' .. "'" '" ... """""'"''')'_,,'" ,",,". r-- " ,"" "" 1IllJ" . U
","""' '''"",
~
«p«><'" 'h<
,h, h"..., "f"'<' ,,(
",-W, . ,.,.. """'_ n..,.·,
"''''''" ,ho< 'h< ,; ""'" ~ , " '1""')'" (" """ ". 1_ to,", 1..... '"'.) •• hil< ,'" 1M,,, "''''''' ," , tun"", '1"''''' ,,( H.... 0< . " R_""'"," rI"l ~ + -.). Th< 1>."", f"''f''''''I '" I""~w., ~ , 'eo,'
'''''''M, >nd f"'''''f''' 'h< _ ,..'" ,... " ..... " ......', .'1<' ~ '" " ...,,"" ... P"~
1<'0"" ~,,," .., """"Y.
r«""''-''-) ' ~ ""'l<"'" '''''.
"'" ,","~'" """ ""_'" H.... (H". " "', A"" ... · ,w) ' .... ""'".,
,," ,. ~ ,~
'x",,,,_,,,,' H, .Id. '<>. "",n'"", 2L ",J<"""" ' H, ' .Id:!, ". ,.,..,..
' ~ ':'k"", u . " )~). ' " l-~' .
'ti 'x .'k.~ ")'0, .m.: ,1.. '""2"" n. ''''.
'" 'x .,..~ ''''''. ,",. ,~"',
•• "' ... ",., ., H"Ok. ,'-"" , , ... n
'" '" \,.. "" '" W.,. "', "'" \l')', ,, '""",,,,, ,,,,.
I'("OR" (lI' TRIT. """ IX" HW'-.R <W Sro""
,,,
G"',,o ,I", mg
eo,'"",1
"'''I.'''
"....b<,
"'pe-n ' ~"' .
3 THE PRUNI NG OFTHE V INE IN
KTU 1.23
R,.., puhl;,h"J ;n IJF 24 (19'92) 425--7. Soon l)' befo,.., ,he ;O>'C""bo>g h,,,,, 8- 11 t I""
,,,..1 ;"
.III· ...
.",,1< ..,,;,-;"'" ho)."" on
KTU 1.23. ~..,
J,,., <",hmntd,
in hi, h.oo ,0. , "ff of o.",.'~m<"', in h;' h.oo ,0. ,uff ohidmo.hooo. 1"1", '-;""'fKU"<" f"U"< 1Um. "'" ,·i",,·boo., b"d h im; ,n." '1U'" h i, >hoot, to t.J 1 lih "in<' ,
In . n eorlie, J ;<cu<
i""
;.
, <:I. '"" ~\
rna",,, ..
',,",.., '""7,
' ~jf,c",."," • ."
t'''''.
I'("OR" (lI' TRIT . """ IX'IH WI'.R <W Sro""
fomled I",r"", tl", /mro1h''''''' 10k., pL."" i>"t" '''en r~.nJ h" ",,'0<." i, '0 I", unJ" ..."x>
"","e.
'f<"
" '----4J\.
• I'll""", "'........, " "". , ' " \\')." ''''''~ - ""'"- , ... " • ..-.J "''f>'<' 1 """"- In ,'" "-,,,,, , ,,,,,,' I ,;","""""' . . 0\
,""oi ... , """"" " ,-,~, ......."
·F'""''''·'''....." """, I.... · F'""''''''''........ "".1.152 • FlO",,,,.,,, .....
"
'''ft''''.
""',.
I~ . ) '""'_
"'''''''''w "'"", ..-.J """".
"m. 152
I
, ""'"' •• " ,."..-.l ..
P"'I'''''" '""
•., ri",,,
in ,ufflcoemly i" rom>&! .bout c.""",",,, ('>f lig;.ri,jlln) ci",u,oc"~,,, .00 .10"" .; ". t"",,1 in II.., Bible," r~'~"'hly n"t.n ,n""""~"'> hut 1"''' of ,h~ tfi
oJ,,,.
1''''1'''''''''''
,I> "
ri,"
r""
«""""
"''''''''t,
,h<,,,,, "'
"1 .... ;, ,.
"""""'~
.... , 'h<
."o!
,,"If
1"''''
,"''ll
,:.n...-u,,, P"""""" d"' ........... Th< !'hiIi,_, ...""' ...
~ "'" " ",""""""",,," "' I;""'~ d...""" {,,,. , """"" " "'-' "l'hilo~,",,", ...J
'''''f''<'
U','"''' ~'"h ,,"""" "f'«"'." 'h< f"'>"~'" U~.'" "'" AI.., ",'''-) " "',.. .. p r.
"11w, r ",,"'"
,.,--- J, ..r ..... n:
'" ".-,,,'
L''''7, 1 >Il "" ''''''' , , ' " t '''' 1,
« ', ~f,
' h<
""''''' ..,,,..,,....... '''''''' .... " .... ""'" Ln "', ","""oJ '''' ' h< .-.h<, ...... ,"", ",h<<< ~ '" " .",,,, ~' h , ' "" "">dO "'. ""'f"< n><= •... "h ' ""'"_ Cf. <; .. ,,, , ,,,,,_ - ' '''''' >o>d . "'... Th~ "-1""""". """"'" ,,(,.....' '\4(, .""~. "U
<;""" , _ \1, ~ o . " .
,<.,,""'..,
"'on ""
"1 "'" ' '1'1'" ' ' u""\>I» ' h<,.. '" "' ' h< ""'" 'h< ,"~\ "' <;<",~, -" 'h< f""'" " 'h< ",",,,,",, "f'"
,,(,,,,'.1,,,, ...... ,,, '" ''''P
·"""""A-.....h >o>d ,''''""~''''''.
I'("OR'" lI' TRIT. """ IX'IH WI'.R <W Sro""
",,,a!
in f"" ile pI.n,. """' p"rem]),. tne'''ph"r f,,, hi. peni",' " 'h", h .f,er ,ft< I", "-'ill .dd ",,, I<) it< pmper fw>C'~"' , In ",lJ''''''ng- FJ", "hu,]",.,,]" in L 4fI, <].1",,,,,, :oJ,,) refer '" hi, "".fl", &, .nJ petl"P' ,'!,,,, iflC. n
",ff
(to'), ",.I (..,) of )'"" p<,,;.!h ...1 (j4 ) "
te"" .., " r.f> J.: .. b ••
" hu. b'"<"I", I.. , :oJ,,) p1ly' de""rl)' '''' d >< ",,",,,,.,,,,n of ,J<,.. ,hOI ,he "~,.]" ("«ep""'') i,. 1>h:oJI"" ,he "pi,,,m< of. hu. b.. "d . 'n ", Heb,,, .. ' "'-jui":oJent, "",,"h, 1>", • ""'~,k>gie>l '",",I\in~ in .Jili'km '" il< ph) ,,,Iog-ieol m,'.n,ng. •• ",fib,," . P"n hen"""" '01 I'.>ekid 19: ] I _! ~ i, i, u!<-'<"",n. in
W";,'" .0"""" '"1'1""""" "'. ,\ fi":oJl""'n,,,
,,,e,
funft
c,m,,,,,," ,,,
p=''''''
1""'.'"
""""",m
'-""", t_, YJ, ,"'''''''' h< 010<. "''' p.~«O . , 'h< ",.-du.'"'' ,h.. ,,,,,,,,,.;"-'"" in_
.",,00. ,~ ,~h<, '" ""'.. ," ""',,""'. -nu. ~" ,"", ....'" .... " ",,' f'<'"U"!: ,.,., ••" " , .... ~" "'" ;" " . .." .,,, . .. ~'i
,. The """ yI ""'"
.,,,<1. ph)' '"
' "'
.1.""* ..""" ,~' '""-,,,,- .M -f><'"' - (d, wI''' ""'.
lJ' " ,,~, " ,,,,,,,,," ,", ''f''<''' '" ~ "''"'''''''. ,,'. .... ,to""", .. '" 'h< ~"'"" """"" ~~ ..... h ' <.p«' "",.><1,,, )'"" "","". ,""'"' ,", ",.~". ,~,,"', .",,= '"' "'''''' """'. ,", ",", '"f'I""< '"" '"' ... "..-. ... " , ;""""""'" "' ..... h" I'''U' in "" " .... " "'" '''!I'''""" "f ,", ,; "',
.
,,'«.
" Th""", «< "''''' .\, .., 1'11'). ",,,<J ... ,",~ "
,"'.,.
" ,10.. ,he "H",,<,," ( Oo H ,m".) JjJ ~b'" II", me, but .lou ,b<), ~.<'" "'~ In .n)' "",. C.n,""oi,e._ \\'hether ,he Ugontu,,< ","f<' C." .....", " '''''th." pmblem l (See d '"I,,«4, o. 1 1,<\0"').
'.
' f~'s"
0'"
r
•
-
•
n,'"
""'
I""'
t;i
~";:,,..~
• _~o"
i
...
- f ~f::~ < ~J'
"
0-
L~ i" ~ ~ - !- ~ ,1,. - ,.;: :::: ~<'" ~ _ !ir." '-1'" '_1,[.~~ ~ ,,~5;'.i> ~'i' ~ ,,~d d.~~hi
..
; .... J~ ~. ' ~ i~~~ ~ -" F! .... J~~~;f~§l~e~~ff~
~~. ~
l ,_di~ ~~~ r~ t"'t ; ~n"'.~
. _ c-
~.;~il~llltlji!~I ~ ~i 1.~ "'$ j __ ~~~'" ,1 'j. ~~ ... ~ ~ " _ It~i!;.~ii1
....~'~IC' ,'_ _ "" ~,
' 11! , "
d. . ':' n" 'to . . - y' . t' .j!.~[ i.'~ " 1",;,;.ro~-~ 1 d~ ~ r~ .B~ . ~~ !"~ i~ 0~ ~"1~ • P[~ ..;- "l~~ .r~ •-. 1
_
j f i~~I:i~lJl~~[f-;~
... !'.';;O'
. ". ::: "::-o,,,,~· I:.,"'~ • "I.'~' ," ,.1' -J' -
!"~ - "'1'1-,,~~,.'."lI-:c-. ~ ," T" J- ~"'<•
~,."~_' ~. ~! t ~ !l: • t ~-' ~~='" ~- 11~ ~ " . f~~;~S~i!li:~I!~~; H~ q nt~ p ;{::d~I"'~-
;;o H -~ ; . , g. 0 " ~" ,"_ ""._' ~5~ ", ~,... F·--- ' !l:~","O -
c: <"l
_.<1. ,
~ ~
. ~-,~~-. ~ ~ ~ ~
a.~~~,~
~ ;l"'"", P 5 il'
,
8g-~:~1 ~ "'".~~
~~1r;L.
~ ''< ~'''- ~~
""
~ -' ~~~ "" ~...,~ .
J2~. " .~~ X~~.~~~
=5'~[':>
;S~;?~~
;. E. '" :>- 3 '" "- =A~~§
~~~~~.~ . ~ 5 ~
~
"- ~ ~'~ '''"S "
,~~~5il.:~ -
~
. 5'~
-~',~-::;...'."'~~ ~~ ~;",
;i;;~ 3~.
L-iJ:~~3~
"~",2 ~'-,
~ ~.,,;~~c
-
~ "' 3!<, " 2;L~ Ji~ i5
·· "C~3~ 3 ? -, .." ~
T'>' ~~Bg l;l
::<
', 'if ;~
"r:~·~
~~
"'C ~ -'Z
e
"t
"1
,, -
o
1[
o
, ~
~
"
z .
"0 q 0
~~
>
rl
,,-- :f-"..
~~ ,S
" 0
~
> 0
.
-ZZ 00
~~
~ ~
0"
0
> Z
C
~
I'("OR'" lI' TRIT . """ IX'IH WI'.R <W Sro""
./'I"".ch to " , "" ,he p"" u l~>O<""'" th...or cul,ure" ",101,''''''' beli<[•• ,,' .uthen,ic ~'OIhm ,h~ cul ,ure .•",1 ,h., lucil"nent>.! lx",unng 1,\' ,~"<,,'e,,, i< .;mpl<' .., ;nllj'I"''I'tUte re,p< ~ "., . A 1,"",h'-"<1 "f dott;«. ",'en ~i\;Ie" b«,.,I1)' ,)·mb"li ," • .,,,It",,,1 im!,"", of ,he ",,,,,,,,,,,,,,kn,·· • • , , h ~ ,.me time "'p",,,,,n,, • p l u~.Ji"'c re_
""r
P"''''''''' ']"""",,,'e ..
"""'''y.
=
' I"m« t" ,'" " ,,,, imp,nging (HI. W'e d",,,ng,,,,h, fot <,.mple. '" !lOCi>.! m.",,,u< n,,. ,uch "' ,he P"""""" "f doffotem 1>""'1" m';n,"; ni'lg • lenti,),. fn' ;"""""" ,he l1u,,"" P''P''b.tion of B"",," ,\~'" Ilgo.tit. AI"" of "",k",h",1 " ',,,,ld b" ,t< ,d""",. ,,",h :odl""en, cuitu", •• fot in".""" IJpnt" ..,,,,,,,,,e d'p~,m"ic ,d, t ~"" ,,",h Ix>th ,he I~'''''''' "f tl", d .)'. Eg)l>t .",1 Ib", . >nd M dt>ub , un,il '" domi", ~'OIh ~ b""tln' .. "'
"""" f"",,,,,,,
1,"""
",no..,
, "" I', "''''"',,'''
,():n, .k1 <""" L<<<
19')2, '" "- "1 _ 19'19, " . "- '''-
"",M"" ",,'(,.....j
""'""', "', '" 1',",-, ...""" ' M h>, no< ~"'"" i",,~,. "" ...... ,,<>In' , 9'''. 1 h< """'" ,,( ,0< ... ~ ,,. ,~. "W" ~,I..-..h IJ ...-.., H,"" "''"'"'' I'" .,k,,,,,,,,-
' s, -,;l<'""'''''" I .,,'" ., ,0< <".",... ,.0 ,,'''''' ""~ "' """-;'
~' """ "'
1:"';", (tI>< . """,,,", "'",), ..... ~..._
po,,,"",, m>.\"
... ,,' ;.k,,'~' '1',,", >old ~ "~"",,",,,,~,-...., ' Il<
""",.. .... ",.......... """Ii'" .""" '"'>' b< "",,,"-"«0) &,." ,0< ,"".;,,,,,, " il<,.,,,. • Th< mo ... JoWkoJ ...-..1
po....,",., "", , "~ .~k"-,j ~ , '"
~
,h.. ,,{old ,""",
I~"
111''',)'-
,, _ 11I'i'!.'.l-",,- ><, ..... .It " ,"" '""'" ." ,..,,, I.... ' ""k,· '''''l: >-:" ' 1'" 1,,,"-\ "09-'.~ ",,,, ~. t ... >old "')' ~' '9'.01. ·"-'-.~,
1,;" DFK'T"" D'''';
P<".' T" 'CI.'"
p",hk,m_It io, "e, . ""h fu"her ~"''''k'''' .. ,he "l1~ic.bil i')' ,,f ""u ... ,.,:t_ """" '" ,h" """'. ,n ,,-hid, ,he ,d.:"i,'" f ""j ",,,"')' of ,he u'" of d " -"''' n.m"" i" te"", n,~ of tl",,, , u"i ,-'] ill diff,'",nt t<"'. hu, f,,'1"""")' of "", in ntu_ .1,. migh' he e'pb.i""J '" term. of ,he h. b"u",~,n of ,he ",,,,,muoi,), 'h mugh ,h" me.n, '0 ,he 'u l ~"n i",1 ,)'mhnli< m",ug<' ill,';"" 01.",.,' .....1 ,h.,,, ,he ),"~ I '. ",,,"kl wonmu";".,,, ,hmu),+.>ct ,he ~ ,u>l I )'_ eng>t;",1 ""mmurut)'. ,hu, "'info"'ing ~I<,,'-""';"'] '" n~,,,,1 ,',]""', 1 ~""I'ng J i'-ferem ",,,,i,] gn>up'. m:iln,:il ni '>g hi" ..,,,'ch), • .,,,1 '-,,,,lL An)' "«ful ,,',~ k i" ,he", ....'.. lie< in ,he fu, ure. ho~'e,'"" i, h.. b>,'dl' begun in ,he hmaoler 11 ,, "1 of I,"!." ""ic.· I ,,-.n, '" .. k mo", ..""·",,,!.Ie ~"""'<>''', here, I;.:,,,,e,-,,,. '1'"-,, pmblem, ". imm",li".I), 'rr"'"'' "'h",, ~'. I,;l"'ti,i"" '" lUll' " ,he, 1",1)'1><",,,, f<1igi<" " r,,,tI)' ,he ",1.,;,-,,), ,hat" ,nheren, in ,10" c<~np"r"""n ",Ih.ti"" "f "J",,~." in,,, "'Par.le ""iE<, .",1 «e<mJI)' d", ,,,,.,,I
co"""I'''
,0
"""n,,,,,
'''1ft '" ")'
.1,,,
'1'""'''''
""p<'c"
"""THE EXPE RIENCE OF POLYTI IEISM
I.e' "' ok,]
,,-i,1t ,he ""'''''' "f , ,,I,,;,,,), r",, _IE I"",,,,,,,, • pr..hlem ,,,,I)' ~- I "'n we h ..-e. n>..,.,.II<~'tioc . ... 1 ph,h"phic'] .~"',~ LI ", ",,,'e, h.",J ,'" .,. """",i']l), «mc"l"u,] .ppr<=h_ H", thi,;, ,he 1'""",
j.u" . ,'ro .\="" """"""• 0" ,.., ... """" "..,u""",,,· ,.' ",,,,,,, .... "1><"""" "'" ,",., '" ""-,,. ,"'... _ 'Th< , ...... """'P"~
I'("OR" (lI' TRIT, """ IX' IH WI'.R <W Sro""
To In,i,, on. f"'"",,'
.,,=
!""""
,,,terpret ,, ,,
""",
""""''''f
"'l""""'''''
w,,,,,,,,,, •
, ", '" """""... "")' """'1""" ;. ~." h 'h< ""..... "I .... ~."'" ~"". """"" """.... "" t""" """"",".","", ,,,,,-«,,,,,,,, .... ""'''''''- Tho ,..., "'h ... ".... ,f ~ " " h " lb.,. ' h< ,.h,,, ,.., . i, ,~. Tho "'''' ,,0, ~ "'"' '"" ,,", "'0"" '" bo< " "'" """ """ """'" ,,,," ,'" ""'h" """'" ",,""''' '-I' 0\ "'" ,h, """ '''"t,·........ 'h< ""h: "'" ,,,,",, "'" ,,,,-,. >« , .... d), ... ,,"'''' ., >= '""" ""h "''''' .... ,'" """. "" .. ~ ,. .. ,1""", "'''''''',
. _, . ,.,
...J ,hot • """ •..., "" '.... " " ....... "'" "." b, 'h< "" h ",,,",~, "'""" 'h< • _"',. ' {;
• w . ,,"""'"
.
''''2. "m, ' •."'. ~;'W"-." "W "'"' ,""td.h 1~"." >1","'1"'" "' "'" " ""
ri,~ "-'~"' " " _ ,
S« """,,, ,",
" ...t.. 1'1'-",
......-", ,.0 on.
"
"", j
D.
""'of-
K""" ."""'''" "..,"~ """,-", (I'W, l ...... """"""""",,," ,, ~ """. "'-',,'.-..... '''~ ~"', ~. i< ~ ' h< "",' "'""' ........ ,,(ok .... dof>m<"' ,,' 'h< ......... Mind ""''''I<
1"""""
1,;" DFK'TA" D''''; p<" _, T"
'CI.'"
,eiMkt, mu," h< i..J~,-'I,,~,h<-t d;"nhu,.",. """.u",;" • ""~' ,,,u,,,,", ,I\< migh' ptedi,I""" ,I\< expJ,,,,,",n of ,I\< n<~ ' e,_ I"" ",n«.", ,he oM ,..,rm: ""'t< 1""",;",11)', d", '~"n< ,m"l-" """Ii",,,!: e,_
,,,,1 ,\",
'"'I''''"''''''' ,,-ill
,och.
"'1-""
"'1"""
",."'" ,n")' I'> "'"k"",,, .00 ~"'" h~>f'< "' .......""'. po"';,,, .. """"" oJ.. """ " ""","'''' "'., "'" '''''';ru d "" ........ (A ...d ><, " .. ' ,1m ,'oj' '-'rW"""""""
,~' """r "" ........
"'''.J
""""I' "
\0>""'''' .....'" '" ,'- ,,"" """r""'" """'",..,
~""h ~ 1<', "~'.'>I ...-...0 .... , .... , ""!fI.~ """"" " ,,,..... 1"-__ ' "' 'h< "''''','' • _ ... _ ' , h~ ' h< _"-"" "-.,,~.,, '" I"'~;"" ''''' I'.~~"',..-.d "'" ~"' "'.. (,~"'. f"<j..i ~, ",.." m.." ""t\ ,b ""'-'''!< F< ~ >n "",, "~, " , ," ,he onl"-"'~ '" .-~"'" 'h<
"""
,,,,,,E.n,,,,,,,
"fW'"""'" .. ,",,,,,,,j
'" u,"',;"..-., ,,,,",,,,,.., ,""",' (.. .,.
~."''''''' ..-.d 1"" """ "''''''''', "" "",,"'" " ,., '-
",""",,,
"",«, "
,ht« ~ • ",o.k, ''1'"'' 'Th< '" d • .-ki~' ""'J <1<1"''''-' "" 'h< "'..- ",' . "","" , , _ ;, " ""f"""hI<", <1<-'" '" 10, ,,..,, in"' ~ ~ ,," f"<M<''''', ' h< .. ,,_~ ~ , ,", '''' "''''j' ~' ",,-,' " •• """""" ..... ,.ht """',.. ....... >f'< 'm".r"''''' "'''''''" 1.)' " .. _ 1'1'1_', Th~ .. , ,",= " " b< , ~~ ••'" . , ...-.,,,.- .....' " '" "''''''' "" .h< ,,.,., ,,(. f"=""'-';''" >n_ .. Th< """""" "'" "1>
'f'OO'"
'h ~_.ryhc
'"'«<_
"cr. "'" ""... loci '" 'I'f'<'''''''' ,,( '"' !,,',n ,""
V",,", "' (:ho.mn " ...... "- Tht
1""""" "" •
l""''''''' ~ ,,"""", .... ,~~ ,.... _,...... _ "''''''',.. "" ""_",'"
.. " , ,.-.-.. ,hctt
~.
",..,~" ..' """"" ""l;~
,00, "'1'"" ' "
"""". ,.......... , , ....... """'_
52
I'("OR" (lI' TRIT. A"" IX'IH WI'.R <W Sro""
".n~l,,,,,,...
1""""
'u"'"'11",,,, "
''''!,"''
I>< "ol.n 0' .-..1><""", ""qu,,,,d 10) ."",1\", cul_
p,,,h.l" • c"'o, ,''''""',,,1 ,up" ,-,rull )'. fot ,I><
hn~"'.'i,-,,,;',n
01""",) . it coukl I>< .,);",'
,h"
or••".",.)n.
um< ,,,,.,,,,,,n'j.
fn'
"i,
'e>" '"
".ri.,.,.. p"""",,,,,,, ",,,,
pi""'.
1>"""
,,,,,h.
".\
'I""..
m«li><," '""on« ,,( '....
~""'l: 1"'''''''' " 'h< ,~...... " I 'h< """'" ,,{ s.."", F.,· ,~ ' h< ,.,,'" of """p" (A, "' ~",) . Tht , . ..,,'" "~)' .,f ~"'" ""'i:" " ",-,,,,, ,~ ,.;0,,,,..,,,,,
....-.-..., (,....., " '"om ........, l'. ,~ Ibh)'''' '" ~m ..., ""."" ''''''"'P) "")' .,,~ ""'" " on"," ,,, 'I'I"'f"~"
" R'~ "W, "<-"', d «
,"" .......
1,;" DFK'T"" D'''';
P<".' T" 'CI.'"
"
"'f",~1
h,\'e fnigiOJlted, we m.l' ... n n;«," tl>< .p;mmJ (.",1 ,h""of",< 1><"<_ .. ""I) IX)~'''''' ~tud ,,'''e bd.,,'ed tn ",,'e.1 tbem",k " in ,h~ '11"'1m.,,, pl",,,,,,,,,, ,,,,,,, .. fo' "\