ADVANCES IN
Immunology VOLUME 4
CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS VOLUME SYDNEYCOHEN JOSEPH
D. FELDMAN
ROBERTA. GOOD H. G. KUNK...
14 downloads
1728 Views
28MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ADVANCES IN
Immunology VOLUME 4
CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS VOLUME SYDNEYCOHEN JOSEPH
D. FELDMAN
ROBERTA. GOOD H. G. KUNKEL MACLYNMCCARTY STEPHENI. MORSE J. MUNOZ BEN W. PAPERMASTER RODNEYR. PORTER
RAMSEIER HANSRUEDY EMANUEL SUTER E. M. TAN
ADVANCES I N
Im munology E D I T E D BY
F. J. DIXON, JR.
J. H. HUMPHREY
Divirion of Exporimental Pathology Scrippr Clinic and Reroarch Foundation La lolla, California
Division of Immunology National Indituto for Modical Research Mill Hill London, England
VOLUME
4
1964
ACADEMIC PRESS
New York and London
COPYRIGHT @ 1984, BY ACADEMICPRESSINC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO PART O F THIS BOOK MAY BE REPRODUCED IN ANY FORM, BY PHOTOSTAT, MICROFILM, OR ANY OTHER MEANS, WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHERS.
ACADEMIC PRESS INC. 111 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003
United Kingdom Edition publkhed by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. (LONDON) LTD. Berkeley Square House, London W.1
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOG CARDNUMBEA: 61-17057
First Printing, 1964
Second Printing, 1988
PRINTED I N THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS Numbers in parentheses indicate pages on which the authors’ contributions begin.
SYDNEYCOHEN,Department of Immunology, St. May’s Hospital Medical School, London, England (287) JOSEPHD. FELDMAN, Division of Experimental Pathology, Scripps Clinic and Research Foundation, La Jolla, California (175) ROBERT A. GOOD,Department of Pediatrics, University of Minnesota, Minmapolls, Minnesota ( 1)
H. G. KUNKEL, The Rockefeller Institute, New York, New York (351) MACLYNMCCARTY,The Rockefeller Institute, New York, New York (249) STEPHENI. MORSE,The Rockefeller Institute, New York, New York (249) J. MUNOZ,National Institutes of Health, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, Rocky Mountain Laboratory, Hamilton, Montana ( 397 1
BEN W. PAPERMASTER, Department of Bacteriology, University of California, Berkeley, California ( 1 )
RODNEY R. PORTER, Department of Immunology, St. Mary’s Hospital Medical School, L&, England (287)
HANSRUEDY RAMSEIER, Department of Microbiology, College of Medicine, University of Florida, Gainesuille, F1orid.u (117) EMANUELSUTER,Department of Microbiology, College of Medicine, University of Florida, Gainesuille, Florida (117) E. M. TAN, The Rockefeller Institute, New York, New York (351)
V
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
The fourth volume of Advances in Immunology, like its predecessors, contains reviews which range over the whole field of immunology, from a study of the biological origins of specific immunologic responses, through various aspects of their protective and pathogenic effects, to the present knowledge of the chemical structure of antibodies. We think that by including contributions of so wide a range, we not only recognize the very broad approach of immunologists to their subject but also acknowledge its fundamental unity, For example, the problems of the complexity of the immunoglobulins, on which chemical and genetic analyses are now beginning to shed light, are intimately bound with those of their evolutionary and cellular origins and their biological functions. This is one of the main reasons why immunology fascinates those who study it. The first chapter by Robert A. Good and Ben W. Papermaster provides a comprehensive review and comparison of the ontogeny and phylogeny of adaptive immunity. It deals with the acquisition of passive and active immunity by the developing fetus in relation to the phylogenetic development of active immunologic responses and relates immunologic capacity to the fmction of the thymus and of the bursa of Fabricus-a study which is ripe for review and in which the group at Minnesota has played a notable part. The second chapter by E. Suter and H. Ramseier concerns the killing of parasites by phagocytic cells and discusses the evidence for the existence and importance of mononuclear phagocytes which have an enhanced capacity to destroy intracellular parasites, apart from recognizable assistance by specific antibodies. The possible connection between such cellular immunity and delayed-type hypersensitivity is a matter of great practical interest. Current knowledge of the chemistry of cell wall antigens of gram-positive bacteria is reviewed in the fourth chapter by M. McCarty and S. I. Morse. In contrast to the soluble capsular antigens, especially those of pneumococci, the true cell wall antigens have only relatively recently been available in undegraded form suitable for chemical and immunochemical analysis; and even now it is mainly the carbohydrate and teichoic acid rather than the protein components which have been studied. Since the cell walls appear likely to provide the best source of immunizing antigens, a review of their structure should be timely as well as interesting. The fact that bacteria and their products can affect immune responses other than by acting as a source of antigenic materials has been recognized for many years. In the last chapter J. J. Munoz has Vii
viii
PREFACE
drawn together much relevant information concerning the adjuvant effects of mycobacteria, the action of endotoxins of gram-negative bacteria on antibody responses, and the peculiar activity of Bordutella pertussis in enhancing anaphylactic sensitivity in rodents. Although none of these actions has a satisfactory explanation, the reader will find a full account of the attempts to provide one. The third chapter by J. D. Feldman, Ultrastructure of Immunologic Processes, shows how electron microscopic studies have verified visually some immunologic processes whose nature was already surmised and have deepened our understanding of others, notably of the pathologic consequences of antigen-antibody interaction in the renal glomerulus. H. G. Kunkel and E. M. Tan, in their review on Autoantibodies and Disease, provide both an up-to-date account of the autoantibodies which have been discovered in autoimmune diseases and a comparison of the reactivity against the Gm groups on human y-globulin of rheumatoid factors on the one hand with the “serum normal agglutinators” on the other. The latter are thought to often arise as a result of isoimmunization of the fetus by maternal y-globulin. This chapter includes a discussion of the possible beneficial as well as pathologic effects of certain autoantibodies. Finally, S . Cohen and R. R. Porter have contributed a clear and full review of the Structure and Biological Activity of Immunoglobulins which discusses not only the evidence supporting the current views of the structure and linkages of the four recognized chains of immunoglobulins, the positions of their various genetic markers, and the nature of the antibody-combining sites, but also considers the mounting indirect evidence for the existence of two separate chains within the A or heavy chain. We are deeply grateful to the authors for the effort which they have put forth into making their chapters both informative and stimulating and to the publishers and printers for maintaining their high standards of presentation; we are confident that this volume will prove to be at least as useful as its predecessors.
September, 1964
F. J. DIXON,JR. J. H. HUMPHREY
CONTENTS LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS ..............................................
v
PREFACE ...........................................................
vii
Ontogeny and Phylogeny of Adaptive Immunity
ROBERTA. GOODAND BEN W . PAPERMASTER I. I1. I11. IV.
General Introduction ......................................... Ontogeny of Immunity ........................................ Phylogeny of Adaptive Immunity ............................... Concluding Statement ........................................ References ..................................................
1 4 80 94 98
Cellular Reactions in Infection EMANUEL SUTER AND HANSRUEDY RAMSEIER
I. I1. 111. IV . V. VI .
Introduction ................................................ Chemotaxis ................................................. Phagocytosis ................................................ The Normal Phagocyte in the Postengulfment Period . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Immune Phagocyte ...................................... Conclusion ................................................. References .................................................
117 119 122 129 144 165 167
Ultrastructure of Immunologic Processes
JOSEPHD . FELDMAN
I. I1. I11. IV. V.
Prologue ................................................... Antibody ................................................... Antigen .................................................... Ultrastructure of Immunologic Reactions ........................ Epilogue ................................................... References .................................................
ix
175 176 189 196 235 237
c0”Ts
X
Cell Wall Antigens of Gram-Positive Bacteria
.
MACLYN MCCARTY AND STEPHENI MORSE I. I1 I11 IV V VI .
. . . .
Introduction ................................................ Isolation and Composition of Cell Walls of Gram-Positive Bacteria ... Cell Wall Protein Antigens .................................... Cell Wall Polysaccharide Antigens .............................. Cell Wall Teichoic Acids ...................................... Intracellular. Capsular. and Diffusible Antigens Related to the Cell Wall of Gram-Positive Bacteria ................................ References .................................................
249 250 252 255 269 277 282
Structure and Biological Activity of Immunoglobulins
SYDNEY COHENAND RODNEY R . PORTER I. I1 111. IV V
. . .
Introduction ................................................ Physical Studies ............................................. Chemical Properties .......................................... Biological Properties of Immunoglobulins ........................ Comments .................................................. References .................................................
287 289 291 319 341 342
Autoantibodies and Disease
H. G. KUNKEL AND E . M . TAN I . Introduction ................................................ I1. Widely Prevalent Autoantibodies ............................... I11. Specific Diseases Associated with Autoantibodies .................. References .................................................
351 352 368 389
Effect of Bacteria and Bacterial Products on Antibody Response
.
J MUNOZ
. .
I I1. I11 IV V VI VII
. .
. .
Introduction ................................................ Acid-Fast Bacteria ........................................... Effect of Endotoxins from Gram-Negative Bacteria ............... Effect of Bordetella pertussk ................................... Miscellaneous Bacteria and Bacterial Products ................... Possible Mechanisms of Bacterial Adjuvants ...................... Summary .................................................. References ..................................................
397 400 411 420 428 429 431 431
AUTHORINDEX ......................................................
441
SUBJECTINDEX.....................................................
473
Ontogeny and Phylogeny of Adaptive Immunity' ROBERT A. GOOD2 AND BEN W. PAPERMASTERS Department of Pediatrics, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota, and Deportment of Bacteriology, University of California, Berkeley, California
I. General Introduction ........................................ 11. Ontogeny of Immunity ...................................... A. Relationship of Fetus to Mother .......................... B. The Immunoglobulins ................................... C. Passive Transfer of Immunoglobulins to Developing Embryo ... D. Transfer of Antibodies to Fetus ........................... E. Ontogeny of Immunoglobulin Synthesis .................... F. Ontogeny of Antibody Production ........................ G. Development of the Lymphoid Tissue ...................... H. Ontogenetic Development of Transplantation Immunity . . . . . . . I. Ontogenetic Development of the Delayed Allergic Response . . . J. Immunologic Development As Studied in Cell Transfer Systems K. Immunologic Tolerance in Relation to Development of Full Immunologic Capacity ................................... L. Role of the Thymus and Bursa of Fabricius in Ontogenesis of Adaptive Immunity .................................... 111. Phylogeny of Adaptive Immunity .............................. A. Immune Responses in Invertebrates ....................... B. Immune Responses in Vertebrates ......................... IV. Concluding Statement ....................................... References ................................................
1 4 4
5 6 11 13 18 26 34 37 41 46
49 60 62 71
94 96
1. General Introduction
Although we recognize as hazardous an attempt at a critical review of the broad field we have chosen and appreciate the special treachery of writing a review of the subject during the period of its most rapid change, our own pressing concern with developmental immunobiology permits us to address this task. It seems to us that understanding of the origin of immunity in both ontogenetic and phylogenetic terms could well be a basis of operational answers to some of the most basic questions of immunology, as well as approaches to manipulation and control of immunologic processes. Already observations are at hand which 1 Original studies included were aided by grants from the U.S. Public Health Service, The National Foundation, the American Heart Association, Minnesota Heart Association, and the Minnesota Division of the American Cancer Society. 2 American Legion Memorial Heart Research Professor. 8 This work was done while Dr. Papemaster was a graduate student trainee under grant GM-24-04, Department of Microbiology, University of Minnesota.
1
2
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
sketch out a sequence of events in the ontogeny of immunologic responsiveness and which suggest that true adaptive immunity is a characteristic only of vertebrates, These findings suggest further that the thymus plays a key role in both the ontogenesis and phylogenesis of the specific adaptive process which we recognize as immunity. In spite of the popularity of theorizing about the nature of the immunologic process ( Mudd, 1932; Pauling, 1940; Haurowitz, 1952; Jerne, 1955; Talmage, 1957,1959; Burnet, 1959; Lederberg, 1959; Karush, 1962), neither instructive nor selective theories have yet led to experiments that establish the nature of antigenic stimulation. Further the concept that specific immunologic negativity is based on a single mechanism (Mariani et al., 1959; Martinez et al., 1959; Medawar, 1961; Michie and Howard, 1962), rather than taking many forms, demands even more that these phenomena be fully explained in operational terms. Both of these central problems in immunobiology, the nature of specific positive immunologic adaptation and the nature of specific negative immunologic adaptation, seem approachable in a most direct manner through an analysis of the development of immunologic reactivity. Considerations of ontogeny and phylogeny raise basic questions concerning the process of cell adaptation and the essential role of the immune response in the body economy. Certainly, to consider these problems effectively in this review, it is necessary that we define our conception of the immune response. The group of defenses historically considered to be in the category of acquired, specific, immune responses are those that were distinguished from innate protective mechanisms at the end of the 19th century by such workers as Pasteur (1881), Metchnikoff ( 1905), Behring and Kitasato (1890), Nuttall (1888), and Ehrlich (1892). The classical acquired, immune response is antitoxin formation ( Behring and Kitasato, 1890). During subsequent investigations allergic reactions were defined (von Pirquet, 1906) and grouped into immediate and delayed types (reviewed by Chase, 1958; Lawrence, 1956). Both forms of hypersensitivity are clearly representative of acquired immune responses. Finally, homotransplantation immunity has been shown to be a manifestation of acquired immunity (Medawar, 1943, 1944, 1945; reviewed by Lawrence, 1959). In the mammal, all these responses (antibody formation, immediate allergy, delayed allergy, and homograft immunity) are well developed. All encompass specific recognition of antigenic structural patterns; some-and perhaps all-are based on active secretion of specific globulin molecules; and each is activated with the development of a pattern of spec8c memory or anamnesis. The cellular basis for acquired immunity is the lymphoid family of
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
3
cells, as first postulated by Pfeiffer and Marx (1898) and L. Deutsch (1899). From the studies of Nossal and Makela (1962) and Makela and Nossal (1962), reviewed by Nossal (1962), and those of Urso and Makinodan (196l), and Vazquez (1961, 1964), it is clear that adaptive immunity is essentially a proliferative process, also involving cellular differentiation. Pathologic (reviewed by Good, 1957a), cytologic ( Kolouch, 1938; Bjgrneboe and Gormsen, 1943; Fagraeus, 1948), histochemical (Ehrich et al., 1949; T. N. and S. Harris, 1949), immunohistochemical (Coons et al., 1955; Leduc et al., 1955), and tissue culture studies (Nossal, 1958, 1959a,b, 1960) inextricably link the proliferative process of immunity to the lymphoid system of cells. The consideration of ontogeny in mammals, as well as consideration of the phylogeny of immunity, of necessity becomes, at least in part, a study of the ontogeny and phylogeny of the development, distribution, morphology, and adaptive potentialities of the lymphoid cells. The lymphoid system of cells is a system that develops and differentiates relatively late in the ontogenetic and phylogenetic sequences. Thus, it will be shown in this review that adaptive immunity, which we are here considering, although perhaps having roots in more primitive processes, is primarily a function achieving full expression late in phylogeny and ontogeny. Recently, Burnet (1959) has referred to this system of cells as “immunologically competent cells,” and still more recently, Dameshek ( 1964) used the term “immunocyte” to describe the elements of this line. Whatever terminology ultimately holds sway, it is important to recognize that this system of cells represents an advanced stage of evolutionary adaptation for specific reactivity. The most prominent functional characteristic of these cells is their highly developed capacity to react to antigens, to proliferate in the presence of antigenic stimulation, and, as a line of cells, to remember prior experiences with antigens. In this review, we shall be concerned primarily with the origins of immunity as a biologic phenomenon embodying primary and secondary responses, with antibody synthesis and release, reactions of immediate and delayed allergy, and homograft immunity. We shall not concern ourselves with a whole host of other complex mechanisms of defense such as natural antimicrobial factors, enzymes in body fluids, polyelectrolytes capable of electrostatic interaction, complement, and phagocytosis. Some of these defense mechanisms have been reviewed in recent years (Suter, 1956; Skarnes and Watson, 1957), and the comparative aspects of some of these have been considered (Huff, 1940; Bisset, 1947; Cushing and Campbell, 1957; Sirotinin, 1960). By using this relatively narrow definition of immunity, which we
4
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
prefer to call adaptive immunity, we may, of course, be avoiding a central issue, namely, the basic origin of this process or these processes in other bodily activities such as those involving protein synthesis, protein-protein interactions, transport mechanisms, and functional complementarity of macromolecules. This question concerning the basis of adaptive immunity in pre-existing physiologic processes is, we believe, a separate question, which at this moment has been too little studied and is far too speculative for review. We shall attempt to consider the ontogenesis of immunity in terms of the following relationships and processes : interrelationship of fetus and mother, particularly serum immunoglobulin and antibody transfer; the beginning production of immunoglobulins during fetal and neonatal life; the origins of antibody-producing capacity and ability to initiate and express delayed allergic responses; the development of capacity for homograft rejection and the decrease of susceptibility to production of tolerance in the fetal and neonatal period; and the key role of the thymus and other central lymphoid tissue in the ontogeny of the lymphoid system and adaptive immunity. Further, we shall summarize present knowledge of the phylogeny of immunity and attempt to show that, here too, the development of the lymphoid system, particularly the thymus, plays a key role in development of the potential for adaptive immune response. II. Ontogeny of Immunity
A. RELATIONSHIP OF FETUS TO MOTHER The developing fetus in mammals is essentially in the position of a well-tolerated homograft. Abundant evidence is at hand (reviewed by Greene, 1955; Nace, 1955, 1957; Woerdeman, 1955; Goldstein and Baxter, 195s) that the embryo and fetus develop characteristic individual specificity at an early stage of development and, thus, should be rejected by the mother were normal transplantation immunity to operate. Such a reaction does not regularly occur. Although the well-known lack of immunologic reactivity during early fetal life and the effective separation of the fetus from the cells of the maternal circulation preclude reactivity in the direction of fetus toward maternal antigens, the mechanisms by which rejection of the fetus by the mother is avoided are far from clear. The fetal membranes appear in some species to be lacking certain transplantation antigens ( HaikovP, 1981); however, studies by Dancis et al. ( 1962) suggest that both transplantation immunity and immunologic tolerance can be induced by injection of placental cells. It seems possible from available data that the placental membranes in this situation
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
5
function as does the membrane of the hamster’s cheek pouch in the studies of Billingham et al. (1960). Their experiments have shown that skin homografts to which the hamster was completely reactive at a skin site were well tolerated when the cheek pouch membrane was interposed between the graft and connective tissue bed. If this is, indeed, the basis for toleration of the fetal transplant by the maternal host, it would be essential that the fetal membranes themselves lack effective transplantation antigenicity; then the source of the antigenicity demonstrated in the studies of Dancis et al. (1962) would have to be blood cells or cells on the fetal side of the membrane. Whatever its mechanism, it remains that the fetus is a homotransplant usually well tolerated without evidence of rejection. There can be no question that in spite of the effective separation of maternal and infant serums, cells with antigenic characteristics foreign to the mother occasionally gain access to the maternal circulation, giving rise to an immune response, transmission of the antibody to the fetus, and a destructive attack on fetal cells. Red cells (Pickles, 1949), platelets ( Shulman et al., 1962; Vandenbroucke and Verstraete, 1955; Schoen et al., 1956), and white cells (Stefanini et al., 1959; Hitzig, 1959), are known to accept the brunt of such immunologic attack in man. That maternal cells may gain access to the fetal circulation has also been demonstrated (Lee and Vazquez, 1962), and it has been postulated that such transfers account for the more favorable treatment of maternal skin grafts by offspring (Peer, 1958), and might, under unusual circumstances, provide a basis for cellular chimerism and graft-versus-host reactions as a basis for human disease. Studies by Lengerovd (1957), Nathan et al. ( 1960), and Najarian and Dixon (1963) have shown that manipulations designed to alter the permeability of the placenta result in a high incidence of tolerance to reciprocal skin transplants of mother and offspring. B. THE IMMUNOGLOBULINS Electrophoretic analysis, coupled with immunologic studies, established that, of the proteins of the serum, those with the lowest charge density at neutral or slightly alkaline pH are those that contain the bulk of the circulating antibodies ( Tiselius and Kabat, 1939). These antibodycontaining globulins, the y2- and the yl- or (3Z-globulins7can be further divided into a low molecular weight component(s), 7S, and a high molecular weight component, 19S, on ultracentrifugal analysis (H. F. Deutsch et al., 1946). With the introduction of immunoelectrophoretic techniques by Grabar and Williams (1953), it became clear that four immunochemically distinct fractions comprise the yz and p2 components.
6
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
These include the classical yz-globulins, which are a single, immunochemically identifiable family of protein molecules with electrophoretic mobility extending from the slowest migrating serum protein constituents as far as the a range on electrophoresis (Grabar, 1956); the (32M ( Y l M ) component, which has been shown to be the same as the 19s or yl-macroglobulin fraction (Burtin et al., 1957); and the P2A ( ~ I A )fraction which is said to have a sedimentation constant of 7s and to be characterized by a high carbohydrate concentration (Heremans et al., 1959). The (3zM- and yz-globulins are known to contain antibodies, and some evidence is at hand that the B2* component also contains antibodies (Fireman d al., 1963). The 7s or y2-globulin possesses the bulk of the circulating antibodies, among them virus-neutralizing antibodies, precipitating antibodies, complement-fixing antibodies, antidiphtheria and antitetanus antibodies, incomplete hemolysins, hemagglutinins, and such agglutinating antibodies as antiflagellar antibodies (Enders, 1944; H. F. Deutsch et al., 1946; reviewed by Fahey, 1962). The fhM( y I M ) or 19s globulin contains such antibodies as Wassermann reagins (B. D. Davis et al., 1945), heterophile antibodies (Kunkel, 19€@), rheumatoid factor (Franklin et al., 1957), cold agglutinins ( Gordon, 1953), isohemagglutinins ( Pedersen, 1945), and other agglutinins such as antityphoid 0 ( H. F. Deutsch et al., 1946). The pZlL fraction is less well understood, but evidence is beginning to accumulate that this is the protein containing the heat-labile skin-sensitizing allergens (Rockey and Kunkel, 1962; Fireman et al., 1963; Heremans and Vaerman, 1962). A fourth constituent which appears in the immunoglobulin area on immunoelectrophoresis, but is less clearly classifiable as an immunoglobulin, is the yx of Heremans (1960), subsequently defined as C-reactive protein. The behavior of this protein in specific protein-protein interactions may justify its classification as an immunoglobulin; however, since this protein, unlike the other immunoglobulins, behaves as an acute phase reactant, it will not be considered in any detail in this review. Because of clear differences in the developmental biology of these separate protein fractions, it has been necessary, in considering the development of immunologic potential, to bear in mind the three separate components of this family of immunoglobulins.
C. PASSIVE TRANSFER OF IMMUNOGLOBULINS TO DEVELOPING EMBRYO Although proteins, produced for the most part by the liver (L. L. Miller and Bale, 1954), appear in the serum at an early stage, no species thus far studied produces demonstrable amounts of immunoglobulins
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
7
during normal fetal life. Instead, an elaborate complex has evolved by which antibody-containing proteins are transmitted to the fetus and to the newly hatched or newly born animal. In the chicken, the antibodycontaining (3-globulins are transmitted from the hen to the ova 4 3 days before ovulation via the follicular epithelium (Patterson et al., 1962) and then to the blood of the embryo late in incubation via the yolk sac ( Weller and Schechtman, 1957, 1962). In the porcine and bovine species, probably because of the highly developed placental membrane structure (Mason et al., 1930), no immunoglobulins whatever are transmitted to the fetus during gestation, and, since none are produced by the fetus, these animals are entirely lacking in antibodies and y-globulin at birth. However, antibody-containing lactoglobulins are delivered in high concentration into the colostrum and thence gain access to the circulation of the neonate which remains highly permeable to protein for several days after birth (Mason et al., 1930; Hansen and Phillips, 1949; McCarthy and McDougall, 1953). The permeability of the gut for protein in newborn calves is not entirely selective (Bangham et d.,1958b), and proteins other than the immune lactoglobulins are also absorbed during this period. Studies by Pierce (1959, 1961) have shown that the low molecular weight proteins, absorbed as whole molecules by the newborn calf, are eliminated by a proteinuria which parallels the period of whole protein absorption by the gut. A similar proteinuria was observed earlier in calves by T. Smith and Little (1924) and in lambs by McCarthy and McDougall ( 1953). Apparently the proteinuria is a necessary corollary of the nonselective uptake of so large a protein load over so short a period. In 1953, Moog had observed that alkaline phosphatase appears in the intestinal mucosa of suckling mice at about 14 days of age under normal conditions, but occurs 2 4 days earlier if the animals are given cortisone or ACTH. Halliday (1956, 1957, 1959), using rats and mice, found that corticosteroids, given orally or parenterally, induced premature appearance of alkaline phosphatase in these species, and that this was correlated with premature cessation of transmission of immunoglobulins and antibodies across the gut wall. Thus, in calves, lambs, mice, and rats, antibodies are transferred from maternal serum to offspring via the colostrum. In ruminants the intestinal absorption of the newborn is relatively nonselective; in rats and mice this absorption is more selective (reviewed by Brambell, 1961, 1962) and may be under endocrinologic control. It is apparent that both in the chicken and in these mammals, the means of providing passive immunologic protection to the young during the period of transition from immunologic inactivity to full reac-
8
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
tive capacity involves transmission of antibody-containing globulin across epithelial barriers. Studies by S. L. Clark (1959) and Feldman (196l), indicate that vigorous pinocytosis is involved in the process. Brambell (1958) has shown that transmission of immunity before birth in the rabbit, guinea pig, and rat takes place by way of the fetal yolk sac and not by way of the placenta. This membrane corresponds to the yolk sac of the chicken, long known to be the avenue of transmission of the immunoglobulins in birds (Levaditi, 1906). In rats and mice, passive transmission of antibody occurs also by means of the colostrum and milk. In these animals, y-globulin may be absorbed for a prolonged period, indeed for the entire period of lactation or as long as 19 days post partum in the rat and 16 days in the mouse (Brambell, 1961). Thus, passive immune protection tides these animals over until there has been rather complete development of the ability to respond to antigenic stimulation with vigorous production of competent antibodies. In primates, albumin, y-globulin, and a variety of a- and p-globulins appear in the serum relatively early in the gestational period, and all except the y-globulins are produced by the developing fetus (Dancis et al., 1957). The @2A- and PzM-globulinsare absent from the human circulation until the postnatal period (Hitzig, 1957; Scheidegger and Martin du Pan, 1957); neither is produced by the normal fetus. Following birth, both proteins begin to accumulate, first the @2M and later the S 2 A (Karte, 1959; Roth, 1962). The y2-globulin appears in the human fetal serum during the third gestational month; it derives from the maternal circulation and, like the other immunoglobulins, is apparently not produced by the normal fetus. Although the question of placental production of serum proteins has been raised, the most comprehensive investigations of placental protein synthesis indicate that this is not a significant source of fetal serum proteins (Dancis et al., 1957; Bardawil et al., 1958). Until Brambell's publications (1958) it had been assumed, since the fetus does not produce y-globulin and since both human beings and primates usually complete gestation with a y-globulin level slightly higher than that of the mother, that these proteins gained access to the fetus across the placental barrier. Brambell, reasoning from his studies with rabbits and rodents suggested that the route of transfer of maternal yglobulin to the offspring had not been established, and proposed that, in primates, as in several other species he had studied, the transfer of y-globulin might be by way of the yolk sac into the amnion, and hence across the gut into the circulation of the developing fetus. Studies by Slater (1954), and Bridges et al. (1959) of offspring of hypergammaglobulinemic and hypogammaglobulinemic mothers provided the strongest
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
9
possible argument in favor of the origin of the y-globulins in the maternal circulation, In a most comprehensive study of this problem, Bangham (1960, 1961) and Bangham et al. (1958a) provided clear evidence that placental transfer is indeed the route of passive immunity in primates. y-Globulin is found in the serum of monkey fetuses at 16-20 weeks and reaches a concentration equivalent to that of the maternal serum at about 35 weeks. By contrast, the y-globulin concentration of the amniotic fluid is low, regularly considerably below that of the fetal serum. Labeled maternal proteins turn up in the fetal blood, whereas labeled proteins introduced into amniotic fluid do not appear in fetal serum. The transfer of proteins from mother to fetus appears to be largely unidirectional: if the fetus is injected with labeled y-globulin, little label gets back to the mother and very little goes into the amniotic fluid. However, this work suggests that some albumin and a little y-globulin can be selectively returned by way of the placenta to the maternal circulation. Some maternal albumin is transmitted to the fetus, although not as easily as yglobulin; almost none of the other major serum protein fractions cross the placenta in the monkey (Bangham, 1961). In man, the immunoglobulin transferred during gestation is almost entirely the y2 component, and very little or no /32M- or /3zA-@ObUlingains access to the fetus. The lack of the PzM component in the serum of the neonate is not surprising; since the molecular weight of this protein is nearly 1,000,000, the size of these molecules alone could be invoked as an explanation of failure of transfer. Failure of transfer of the Pz~-globulin is not so easily explained: work to date suggests that the sedimentation constant is in the range of 75 and, thus, the lack of transfer in significant amounts to the fetus cannot readily be explained on the basis of molecular size, since the yz-globulins, which pass with ease, are molecules of similar size. One difference between the PzA- and yz-globulins, in addition to differences in mean charge density of the molecules, is the high carbohydrate content of Pzll (Heremans et d.,1959). However, thus far, there have been few studies of the physical and chemical properties of highly purified preparations of &A, and a number of other factors, not yet investigated, could be responsible for failure of transfer across the placental barrier. It is of interest that the placenta provides a significant barrier to transfer of C-reactive protein (CRP), another yglobulin component ( Rozansky and Berkovici, 1956; Nesbitt et al., 1960; Philipson and TveterHs, 1957; Good, 1952). During acute disease and in many apparently normal pregnancies, the maternal serum may have reIatively high concentrations of CRP, but the cord blood of the infant
10
ROBERT A. GOOD A N D BEN W. PAPERMASTER
can be completely lacking in this component. For example, Rozansky and Bercovici (1956) studied the sera of 119 pregnant women and 71 women in labor. Of this group 32% of the pregnant women and 66% of the women in labor showed positive tests. Only 1 of 23 infants showed CRP in the cord blood sample. In a similar but less extensive study by Good (1952), an analysis was made of women with either malignant disease or acute infection at the time of delivery; although each of 12 patients had strong positive serologic reactions for CRP, in only 1 of the 12 infants was CRP present in the cord blood, and in that instance the positive reaction was equivocal. Mention is made of this relationship since CRP appears among the immunoglobulin fractions on immunoelectrophoretic analysis of the serum and since this protein has a reactivity TABLE I RELATIONSHIPOF PLACENTAL STRUCTUREAND MODEOF PASSIVETRANSFER OF IMMUNOGLOBULINS TO THE FETLJS~
Species Pig Ruminants Carnivores Rodents Ape, man (I
Tissue layers between maternal and fetal circulation at term 0
5 3 2 2
Placental or amniotic transmission
k
+ (placental) (yolk sac) +++
Importance of colostrum
+++ +++ + +-++-
Adapted from Vahlquist (1958).
with pneumococcal polysaccharides very reminiscent of immunologic reactions. Although human milk contains all of the immunoglobulins, yz, P ~ A , and PZM, in appreciable concentration (L. A. Hanson, 1959), there is no evidence that the intestinal route plays a significant role in immunoglobulin transfer to the newborn infant (Gugler and von Muralt, 1959; Schneegans et al., 1962). In summary, in all species of birds and mammals studied thus far, elaborate mechanisms are provided by nature to insure transfer of immunologically active proteins from mother to offspring. Table I summarizes available data concerning the characteristics of the placenta and the major routes of transfer of immune globulin to the fetus. There appears to be an excellent correlation of placental structure and the mechanism for passive transfer of immune globulin to the newborn. The primates, including man, apparently differ from all other species in that transfer of the y-globulins occurs across the placenta and does not involve the gastrointestinal mucosa or the epithelial layers of either the
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
11
mammary gland or yolk sac. These mechanisms provide protection for the offspring during the period of immunologic inadequacy. In man, the immunoglobulin transferred is entirely or almost entirely the yz component; the Pu- and PzM-globulins are neither produced by the fetus nor provided by passive transfer in demonstrable amounts.
D. TRANSFER OF ANTIBODIESTO FETUS In man, where the studies have been most extensive, passive transfer of antibodies to the fetus probably begins at about the same time as the appearance of y-globulin in the fetal circulation. Differences in relationship of mother and baby exist with respect to different antibodies (reviewed extensively by Vahlquist, 1958; Hitzig, 1959; Freda, 1962; von Muralt, 1982), apparently as a consequence of the different types of protein molecules, some having molecular weights as high as 1,000,000 and others as low as 150,000 (Franklin and Kunkel, 1958). Such antibodies as antitoxins against diphtheria, tetanus, and erythrogenic toxin, appear in the fetal circulation at term in essentially the same concentration as that of the maternal circulation. This relationship almost certainly holds true for all the antibodies belonging to the yz-globulins or 7s class of proteins. Included among these may be listed incomplete Rh antibodies ( conglutinins) ( Wiener and Berlin, 1947), certain antipertussis agglutinins (P. Cohen and Scadron, 1943, 1946), and virus neutralizing antibodies such as antimeasles ( Herrman, 1923), antipoliomyelitis ( Aycock and Kramer, 1930), antivaccinia ( Kempe and Benenson, 1953), anti-herpes-simplex ( S. G. Anderson and Hamilton, 1949), and antiJapanese B encephalitis (Hale and Lee, 1954) antibodies. Almost all the complement-fixing antibodies, save the reagins against syphilis, are well transmitted to the offspring (Vahlquist, 1958; Hitzig, 1959; von Muralt, 1962; Freda, 1962). The latter include antibodies to mumps, virus influenza, and toxoplasmosis. Among the antistreptococcal antibodies, antistreptolysin 0 is known to be well transmitted to the fetus (Vahlquist et al., 1950). Thus far, although almost certainly of the yz class (Wannamaker, 1958), the other antistreptococcal antibodies, such as antistreptokinase, antihyaluronidase, antideoxyribonuclease B, and antidiphosphopyridinenucleotidase, might be expected to be well transmitted to the fetus, although no definite studies have been done to our knowledge. Among the antibodies not well transmitted to the fetus, most are known to belong to the yl ( 19s) globulin or PPJd fraction of the serum proteins (Franklin and Kunkel, 1958). These include anti-A and anti-B isohemagglutinins (Wiener and Silverman, 1940), complete or saline Rh agglutinins ( Broman, 1947; Wiener and Berlin, 1947), Wassermann re-
12
ROBERT A. GOOD A N D BEN W. PAPERMASTER
agins ( Dunham, 1932), certain hemolysins against sheep cells (Richou and Ramon, 1945), and certain antibacterial agglutinins such as antityphoid “0”( Timmerman, 1931), and colon bacillus antigens “ 0and “ H( Adamson et al., 1951) . The skin-sensitizing allergens are also very poorly transmitted to the fetus (W. B. Sherman et al., 1940); the mother may possess very high titers of such antibodies, but the neonate will have no sensitivity demonstrable either by direct test or by passive transfer. This observation seems consonant with the finding of Sehon (1959, 1960) that these antibodies, too, belong to the 19s class of y,-globulins. However, more recent studies by Heimlich et al. (1960), in Campbell’s laboratory, suggest that the skin-sensitizing antibodies do not have as high a sedimentation coefficient as the studies of Sehon seem to indicate. Further, chromatography on diethylaminoethyl (DEAE ) cellulose columns ( Augustin, 1960) seem to place these antibodies in a fraction quite distinct from that in which the 19s component is located. Preliminary observations in several laboratories (Fireman et al., 1963; Rockey and Kunkel, 1962; Heremans and Vaerman, 1962) suggest that the skin-sensitizing antibodies may, indeed, be contained in the Pzn or ylA fraction which, although probably having the ultracentrifuge characteristics similar to y2-globulin, does not traverse the placental barrier in significant amounts. The question of access of maternal antibodies to the fetus is of importance in a consideration of the ontogeny of immunity from two points of view. First, the antibodies traversing the placental barrier provide passive immunologic protection of the newborn. There is, however, another side to the coin. It has been observed repeatedly that artificially initiated, active immunologic responses in young infants are adversely influenced by the presence of the specific antibody. Vahlquist et al. ( 19-48), using diphtheria toxoid, showed clearly that passively acquired diphtheria antitoxin interfered with the active production of antitoxin. Osborn et a2. (1952a) confirmed this observation, but concluded that the interference could be overcome by using larger doses of toxoid. Perkins et al. (1959) have shown that such interference occurs in poliomyelitis immunization as well. In experimental animals, Uhr and Baumann (1961) have observed and studied a similar phenomenon. Using soluble, serum protein antigens and specific antibodies, they showed that passively transferred specific antibody not only inhibits the initiation of an immune response, but that passively administered antibody may even stop production of antibody once the active immune response has been initiated. Although the mechanism of the inhibitory effect of antibody may simply be inactivation of
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
13
antigen through immunologic combination, the studies of Uhr and Baumann suggest that a more intricate feedback mechanism may be operating.
E. ONTOGENY OF IMMUNOGLOBULIN SYNTHESIS So far as can be ascertained with present methodology, virtually no synthesis of any of the immunoglobulins occurs in the developing fetus. However, as a consequence of passive transfer of y-globulin from mother to fetus, Longsworth et al. (1945) showed that human infants are born with slightly more y-globulin on the average than their mothers. This observation has been extensively confirmed (Moore et al., 1949; Orlandini et al., 1955; Oberman et al., 19%; Mellander et aZ., 1959), but there is some disagreement as to whether the y-globulin levels are significantly higher in the baby’s serum than in that of the mother (Zak and Good, 1959; von Muralt and Gugler, 1959). In cattle, sheep, and pigs, where y-globulin is not transferred across the placental barrier, the neonate is essentially agammaglobulinemic; however, it seems likely that the lack of y-globulin in these animals is not absolute. For example, Franek et al. (1961) have claimed that a Iow molecular weight y-globulin is already present in low concentration in the newborn pig. The minute amounts of y-globulin were demonstrated by an immunochemical method, and were attributed to the piglet’s own protein productive mechanisms. This y-globulin was considered a precursor of the y-globulin and antibody to be formed later in response to antigenic stimulation. Studies by Hoerlein (1957) and by Segre and Kaeberle (1962a,b), and Segre et al. (1963) have presented these relationships of y-globulin and antibody in the piglet in another dimension. Hoerlein showed that pigs 3-8 weeks of age formed antibody when allowed to suckle colostrum from their dams, suckling that was associated with passive transfer of y-globulin and antibody from the mother in appreciable concentration. Piglets not provided with this source of y-globulin and antibody by passive transfer were most feeble in antibody synthesis. Segre and Kaeberle (1962a) confirmed Hoerlein’s observations and showed that suckling of colostrum, administration of diluted hyperimmune serum of swine and horse origin, or administration of normal serum from older colostrumdeprived pigs would overcome the immunologic deficiency. In addition, they (1962b) confirmed the presence of small amounts of y-globulin in newborn pigs, and found that this small amount declined to even lower levels in colostrum-deprived animals. The immunologic inadequacy of these animals was greatest with reference to antigens not normally en-
14
.
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
countered by pigs. Segre and Kaeberle concluded that initiation of antibody synthesis in the pig is facilitated by the availability of small amounts of y-globulin and specific antibody provided by a minimal transplacental transfer, and that the immunologic inadequacy of colostrumdeprived pigs at 3 to 8 weeks of age reflects the loss of the minute amounts of antibody transferred across the rigid placental barrier in this species. Studies by Kim and Watson (1963), on the other hand, indicate that the neonatal piglet is completely devoid of immunoglobulins and can be induced to antibody synthesis with suitable antigens even when given no colostrum or exogenous source of y-globulin. As indicated earlier, in man, the serum y-globulin level of the newborn is at least as high as that of the mother. Beginning almost immediately after birth, the y2-globulin concentration begins to fall, and for a variable period, usually for several weeks, the y-globulin levels in the serum drop sharply (Bridges et al., 1959; Zak and Good, 1959). Beginning from 3 to 10 weeks after birth in the normal baby, the y-globulin curve levels off, a plateau or trough occurs, and then the curve rises. Adult y-globulin levels are generally reached some time between the end of the first year and the age of four. This y-globulin curve has been attributed to several relationships during development. First, there is the failure of synthesis of y2-globulin by the fetus, combined with passive transfer of y-globulin across the placental barrier. Then, there is the continuing deficiency of synthesis of y-globulin in the neonatal period, combined with the growth of the yglobulin space. Production of sufficient y-globulin to compensate for the decay rate and the growing y-globulin space begins at varying times in individual infants, but usually some time between 3 and 12 weeks. After that time the y-globulin concentration rises until total production and total degradation reach an equilibrium at a circulating y-globulin level between 0.6 and 1.5 gm./100 ml. of serum, the level of healthy immunologically mature persons. During the period of relative deficiency of yglobulin production in human newborns, especially prematurely born babies, the y-globulin can decline to levels quite low by adult standards: y-globulin concentrations of less than 100 mg./100 ml. have frequently been observed in apparently normal infants. Occasionally, assumption of normal y-globulin production by an infant is delayed, and a state of transient agammaglobulinemia of infancy may be observed (N. H. Martin, 1954; Good and Zak, 1956). Although the basis for such a delay has not been ascertained in any instance, a few patients with this entity have been studied in our clinic and elsewhere. The delay in production
ONTOGENY AM) PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMVNITY
15
of normal amounts of y-globulin may extend up to 6 or 8, or even 10 months of age, and at subsequent study a year or two later, the child may be perfectly normal by accepted immunologic and immunochemical criteria, During this period of transient agammaglobulinemia, it is not possible, without recourse to specific antigenic stimulation, to separate such patients from those having true persistent immunologic deficiency disease (Good et al., 1962a). An interesting view of the development of y-globulin production in man has been provided by patients with agammaglobulinemia. During the course of extensive investigations of patients with this disease (Bridges et al., 1959; Zak and Good, 1959; Good et al., 1962a) we have had an opportunity to study two children born of a mother with extreme hypogammaglobulinemia, apparently of the acquired type. In addition, we have now studied 11 children born of 5 mothers who had previously given birth to boys with agammaglobulinemia, presumably of the sexlinked recessive type. The two children born of an agammaglobulinemic mother were agammaglobulinemic at birth, having levels of y-globulin of less than 10 mg./100 ml., in the same range as the maternal y-globulin (Bridges et al., 1959; Zak and Good, 1959). This observation is compatible with the conclusion that the fetus and neonate form little or no yglobulin. Further, in both children, the y-globulin concentration remained at this extremely low level until the 35th-42nd day of life in the first child, and the 21st-28th day of life in the second. Rapidly thereafter, both infants developed full immunologic competence, and levels of yglobulin within the normal range were achieved by the time these children were 6 months old. On the other side of the coin were the children born of 5 mothers who had previously given birth to agammaglobulinemic male offspring. Of these 11 children, 4 were girls who had normal serum proteins and normal immunologic responses; 4 were boys who developed normal immunologic responsiveness; and 3 were boys who had persistent and presumably permanent agammaglobulinemia. All 11 had levels of y-globulin at birth essentially equal to or slightly higher than those of the mother. During the several weeks after birth all showed a decline in y-globulin concentration. From the studies performed, it was not possible to ascertain which of the male children would be immunologically normal until several months after birth. Then, the children destined to develop full immunologic capacity showed a decrease in the rate of y-globulin decline, beginning formation of isohemagglutinins, and ultimately increasing y-globulin concentrations. Those destined to be agammaglobulinemic showed continued, essentially logarithmic decline in y-globulin levels to 20 mg./100 ml. or less. These boys had failure of
16
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
plasma cell development and defective lymphoid tissue, with lack of secondary follicle formation, whereas the other group had normal development of the lymphoreticular tissues. We concluded that in these several groups of patients we had observed the developmental biology of y-globulin in bold relief. Although there are no data in these studies to argue conclusively against the conclusion of Trevorrow ( 1959) that appreciable amounts of y-globulin are being produced in the neonatal period in man, we find little support for this contention in our observations. Further, attributing the decline in y-globulin level in the newborn entirely to growth of the infant seems to be fallacious, since growth is even more rapid during the late fetal period when y-globulin is accumulating by passive transfer from the mother, and since no sudden change in the growth rate occurs during the first year of life which can, by itself, account for the cessation of the decline in y-globulin levels. Finally, the rapid rise in y-globulin concentration between the second and sixth months in both of the children of an agammaglobulinemic mother must reflect either a change in m e of production or rate of destruction of y-globulin. We thus interpret these and all other data to be compatible with the hypothesis that yglobulin is not produced in significant amounts by the fetus or newborn. Initial investigations with the immunoelectrophoretic technique, carried out primarily by the Swiss and French investigators, support these concepts. y2-Globulin is the only one of the immunoglobulins present in the circulation of the human neonate in significant amounts (Hitzig, 1957; Scheidegger and Martin du Pan, 1957). With later variations of the immunoelectrophoretic technique, very minute amounts of P ~ Mand p 2 A have been demonstrated in a significant percentage of cord bloods and sera from infants during the first week of life (von Muralt and Gugler, 1959; von Muralt, 1962; Vivell et al., 1960). In healthy babies, the p2M level begins to rise during the second and third months of life, and the p2.4 usually slightly later (Hitzig, 1957; Scheidegger and Martin du Pan, 1957). The Panl rises quickly to adult levels, whereas the rise in 0 2 6 parallels that of the y-globulin. Koch et al. (1959) showed that, upon falling ill, a newborn infant is ready to produce the y-macroglobulin by three weeks of age, a finding that agrees well with the early appearance of the flzM band, as observed by West et al. (1962) and others (Dietel and Lohmann, 1960; Hitzig, 1961). Further, it appears that P2M can reach full adult concentrations in the face of stimulation at a time when y-globulin production is grossly defective and the component has still not appeared in the serum (West et al., 1962). These observations are particularly significant in the
OF~TOCENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
17
light of the recent observations (R. T. Smith, 1960; Uhr et al., 1962b; Fink et al., 1962), to be discussed in detail below, that the initial immunologic response in both premature and full-term infants involves antibody primarily or entirely of 19s globulins. Immunoelectrophoretic studies of Vivell and Sick (1960), are of real interest. They, in concert with others using the immunoelectrophoretic method, have observed an adult y-globulin band in serum of the newborn, with a lack of P2M and PzA. They noticed, however, that a doubling of the y2-globulin band often occurred at about the time that the infant’s own y-globulin production was, from indirect evidence, presumed to begin. The adult immunoelectrophoretic pattern was again regularly present by 2 years of age. These authors concluded that the y-globulin newly formed by the infant was slightly different in its immunochemical properties from that received across the placenta. Among the most recent studies of the developmental biology of the immunoglobulins are those of Roth (1962) in which quantitative immunochemical techniques have been used. In general, this author’s findings parallel those of West et al. (1962). With a very sensitive immunochemical method, Roth showed that minute amounts of both p 2 A and f 3 2 ~are present in the cord blood serum. Whereas the concentration of p2= averages 160 mg./100 ml. in adults, with a range of 60 to 480 mg./100 ml. in healthy persons, cord blood contains from 3 to 24 mg./100 ml. of this protein. Rising concentrations of P2M may be noted in the first 10 days of life, especially in the presence of perinatal disease. From these studies it appears that adult concentrations of (32M are reached during the third year in normal children. The mean serum level of p2* globulin in normal adults is 200 mg./100 ml., with a range from 75 to 600 mg./100 ml. In cord blood the range of p2* is from 0.1 to 1.0 mg./100 ml., with a mean of 0.3 mg. The P2A concentration does not begin to increase until after the twentieth day, and then shows a gradual increase until adult concentrations are reached sometime after 3 years of age. In summary, it seems clear that little or no immunoglobulin synthesis occurs in the fetus, but that protection is afforded by passive transfer of y2-globulin across the placenta. The production of y2- and PzA-glObulins gets off to a slow start in the neonatal period; however, (32M production may be initiated in the immediate neonatal period, especially in the presence of disease, and appreciable amounts of this protein may accumulate within the first few weeks of life. This may well be an early adaptation to exposure to antigenic stimulation in the extrauterine environment. Far too few comprehensive studies of the developmental biology of
18
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
immunoglobulins have been carried out in animals other than man; consequently, these have not been emphasized in this review. However, the data available indicate that in a number of species there is neonatal sluggishness in establishing production of y-globulins. Both chickens and mammals raised in a germ-free environment show declines in y-globulin concentrations to low levels (Thorbecke et aZ., 1957; Wostmann, 1959). In the most completely genn-free environments obtained, y-globulin concentrations approaching those of agammaglobulinemic patients have been recorded (Gustafsson and Laurell, 1959). Exposure of such animals to antigenic stimulation reveals, here also, a sluggishness in establishing immunologic competence, similar to that ordinarily observed in the neonatal animal.
F.
ONTOGENY OF ANTIBODY PRODUCTION
1. Development of Capacity to Produce Antibody in Response to Specific Antigenic Stimulation Specific antibody production does not ordinarily take place during embryonic development in birds and mammals; and the central issue is whether the embryo is incapable or defective with respect to immunologic response or whether antigenic stimulation is simply not available. Studies attempting to resolve this question go back many years, and it is only very recently that a reasonably clear picture of the developmental biology of antibody production has emerged. Much remains to be done : there have been studies of too few species, with too few antigens, and a lack of recognition of variability from organism to organism, species to species, and extraordinary variability from antigen to antigen, Interpretation is also difficult because much of the work has not been quantitative. As early as 1907, Rywosch reported failure of the chick embryo and young chick to respond to antigens of Escherichia coli. This observation has been confirmed and extended by several investigators using a variety of antigens (Grasset, 1929a; Weinberg and Guelin, 1936; Burnet, 1941; Beveridge and Burnet, 1946; Fox and Laemmert, 1947; Wolfe and Dilks, 1948; Burnet et al., 1950; Wolfe et al., 1957). In these studies, Weinberg and Guelin (1938) showed that neither chick embryos nor newly hatched chicks would respond to antigens of CZostridium sporogenes. Burnet (1941) found that influenza virus inoculated on the twelfth day of incubation did not stimulate antibody production in the developing chick; and later, Beveridge and Burnet ( 1946), in studies designed primarily to produce immunologic tolerance, found no immune response to bacteriophage in chick embryos. Although Fox and Laemmert (1947) confirmed
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
19
these observations in essence, using a yellow fever virus vaccine, they found that the virus persisted in a few embryos until hatching and that the chickens subsequently developed antibody. Wolfe and Dilks (1948) stimulated chicks with serum protein antigens, and found that the deficiency of the newly hatched animal was extreme and that antibodyproducing ability developed gradually up to 4 weeks of age. Between 4 and 5 weeks of age a rather sudden maturation took place and, on the average, antibody titers of birds given antigen at 5 weeks were much greater than that of birds stimulated at 4 weeks. Those injected with antigen at 6-12 weeks produced approximately the same levels of antibody as the 5-week-old birds, and the authors concluded that immunologic maturity in the chicken is reached at about 5 weeks after hatching (Wolfe and Dilks, 1948). Subsequent studies by Wolfe et al. (1957), using quantitative methods, c o n h e d these findings, and extended the observations to a correlation between the size of the spleen in the young chicks and their antibody-producing capabilities. These studies showed, too, that maturation of immunologic capacity continued throughout the life of the chicken; for example, when bovine serum albumin (BSA) dosage was calculated on a weight basis, the l-year-old chicken produced 400% more antibody than the chick stimulated at 6 weeks of age. Burnet et al. (1950) found that stimulation with washed human cells led neither to an immunologic response nor to tolerance in the chick embryo. The studies were extended to mammals, first to the rabbit and later to the guinea pig. Moll (1908), who studied only two 3-week-old rabbits injected with cholera vaccine and horse serum, found that they were grossly deficient in immunologic response compared to adult animals. He concluded that the newborn animal is defective in response to both protein and bacterial antigens. Subsequent studies by Friedberger and Simmel (1913), Coca et a2. (1921), Nattan-Larrier et al. (1927), Grasset (1929b), Polk et al. (1938), Valtis and Saenz (1928), and others seemed to establish that embryos and newly born or newly hatched animals are defective in their response to some antigens. Freund, in 1930, showed clearly the relative refractoriness of the newborn rabbit to antigenic stimulation: in rabbits less than 20 days of age, the response to typhoid bacilli, sheep red cells, horse serum, and ovalbumin was strikingly less intense than in adult rabbits immunized the same way. He showed further that true Arthus reactions could not be produced in young rabbits immunized with horse serum or egg white. Baumgartner, in 1934, reviewed the relation of age to immunologic reactivity, and concluded that the ability to be immunized was qualitatively and quantitatively inferior in the neonatal period.
20
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
In recent years, Sterzl and Trnka ( 1957), Dixon and Weigle (1957), Deichmiller and Dixon (1957), and Bridges et al. (1959) have made similar comprehensive and quantitative studies of the development of responsiveness to protein antigens in the rabbit. In all of these studies the neonatal rabbit was far less responsive than the adult, indeed often unresponsive. The antibody response appeared along with capacity to produce plasma cells during the fourth week after birth. In later experiments, Deichmiller and Dixon (1960) found that large doses of bacterial and erythrocyte antigens in newborns resulted in y-globulin synthesis at an earlier age; Sterzl and Trnka (1957) and Riha (1961) made a similar observation studying antibody responses to bacterial antigens. Bridges et al. (1959) also forced maturation of immunologic response to BSA in the rabbit by administering it with Freunds adjuvant. With this intense stimulus, antibody to BSA was produced as early as 16 days of age, but not earlier. The earliest evidence of the morphologic response of antibody synthesis, pyroninophilia and plasma cell development, occurred 12 days after birth (Bridges et al., 1959). The general conclusion of these several groups of investigators was that immunologic unresponsiveness continues for some days beyond birth, and that adult capacity is not achieved until at least 4 weeks of age in the rabbit. Sterzl and Hrubesova ( 1956) presented observations suggesting that ribonucleic acid (RNA) obtained from spleen cells of adult rabbits experiencing an immunologic response might induce immunologic responsiveness of neonates. Several investigators have attempted to reproduce these results, without success (Stavitsky, 1958; Janovid et al., 1959; Sorkin, 1963), but Hrubesova et d. (1959) were able to obtain very low agglutination titers in very young rabbits by this type of transfer, and concluded that RNA might enhance antibody production in a nonspecific way during the neonatal period. Sterzl et al. (1960) and Franek et al. (1961) studied newborn pigs and found that these animals were also immunologically inadequate. As antigens they used Brmcella, simple protein antigens, and the very E. coli organisms that were providing the first antigenic stimulation by the gastrointestinal route. Unpublished observations from our laboratory (Zak, 19f30) confirmed the immunologic inadequacy of the piglet during the first several weeks of life, revealed by early failure to respond to soluble protein antigens. The studies of Franek et al. (1961) suggested synthesis of a small amount of a y-globulin-like protein even during the period of gross immunologic inadequacy. As noted earlier, the work of Segre and Kaeberle (1962a) appears to indicate that passively transferred specific antibody, either received in the colostrum or by placental transfer,
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
21
or provided artificially, serves to initiate immunologic responsiveness in the pig. Kim and Watson (1963) have shown, however, that with adequate antigenic stimulation and very sensitive antibody detection techniques, antibody synthesis is demonstrable in newborn piglets, even in the absence of colostrum, as early as 3 4 days. Bishop and Gump (1961) studied immunologic responsiveness in neonatal guinea pigs, with interesting results. They found that newborn guinea pigs given bovine y-globulin and adjuvant immediately after birth produce circulating antibody as detected by passive cutaneous anaphylaxis (PCA) but not by agar diffusion. By the fifteenth day all the injected animals gave a positive PCA reaction, but the amount was much less than in adult animals. The authors concluded that humoral antibody synthesis is present in this species, but that the rate of production is reduced. R. T. Smith (1960), using Salmonella flagellar antigens, showed that neonatal rabbits can respond with synthesis of a heavy antibody, presumably 19s; however, its precise characteristics were not determined. S . Harris et al. (1961) have also demonstrated significant antibody response to bacterial antigens in the newborn rabbit, and Condie et al. (1960) have shown that injections of hemocyanin in neonatal mice and rabbits will result in appearance of circulating antibody as early as 1 week after birth. Another recent investigation (Silverstein et ul., 1963) involved antigenic stimulation in utero. Fetal lambs were stimulated with diphtheria toxoid, Bacillus Calmette-Gudrin ( BCG ) , bacteriophage +X 174, ferritin, ovalbumin, and Salmonella, as early as the sixty-sixth day of gestation. Significant amounts of antibody to the phage, ferritin, and ovalbumin were produced, but the other antigens were ineffective under these conditions. The antibody was apparently 19s. Fennestad and Borg-Petersen ( 1962) studied antibody-producing capacity of bovine fetuses. Eight cows were subjected to laparotomy and injected intraplacentally with Leptospiru saxkoebing. Six of the fetuses had produced agglutinins against this antigen when tested 3 M 2 days later. Leptospiru was isolated from the kidneys of two of the fetuses. Plasma cells were found in the kidneys of five of the older fetuses, and transitional cells were present in the spleen and kidney of the youngest fetus, inoculated at 132 days of gestation and examined 32 days later. These authors concluded that bovine fetuses can produce Leptospiru agglutinins at less than 164 days of gestational age, and that, even at this early age, antibody synthesis is accompanied by formation of plasma
22
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
cells. The titers of antibody of these fetuses were appreciable, but comparisons were not made with the adult response to the same antigen. Perhaps the most dramatic of the studies of early antibody synthesis was made in marsupials. This is the investigation reported by Kalmutz (1962). This investigator showed that the opossum embryo can respond to bacteriophage stimulation with antibody production at an extremely early age. These animals are born 12-13 days after copulation when no organ systems have been defined, although the vital ones are functional. Lymphopoiesis begins in the thymus 5 days after birth. A similar development occurs in the lymph nodes 10 days after birth and in the spleen 15 days later (Kalmutz, 1962). Using bacteriophage as the antigen, Kalmutz found antibody synthesis as early as 11 days after birth, at a time when only the thymus and the very earliest lymph nodes are present. By 22 days of age, antibody production of unquestionable significance was at hand. Studies have not yet been made on the nature of this antibody, i.e., whether it is of high molecular weight or of the classical 7s variety, probably, at least in part, because of the difliculty in obtaining samples. Additional studies on the opossum have recently been reported by La Via et al. (1983). The antigen used was a flagellar preparation of Salmonella typhi, and it was administered at various times from the sixth to the sixteenth day after birth. Antibody was detectable in sera from animals stimulated on the eighth day or later. The authors emphasized that this antibody was produced at a time when normal opossums show no lymphoid development in the spleen and have neither plasma cells nor secondary lymphoid nodules. In summary, these studies of antibody synthesis in embryonic and neonatal life in chickens and mammals indicate that all embryos and neonatal animals studied critically are immunologically deficient, and that maturation of the immunologic mechanisms to adequacy by adult standards occurs some time during the first weeks after birth. Some degree of maturation in the chicken and the mouse continues for most of the first year. However, recent studies, using certain bacterial antigens, bacteriophage, and hemocyanin, show that immunologic capacity is present in some species in the neonatal period and during embryonic life. Striking daerences in the development of immunologic responsiveness are revealed by the use of different antigens. Certain antigens, presumably the more potent ones such as hemocyanin and bacteriophage, induce antibody production in animals that appear to be grossly deficient in responsiveness when stimulated with other antigens, e.g., serum protein antigens.
ONTOGENY A N D PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
23
2. The Development of Antibody-Producing Capacity in Man The observations on the development of immunologic capacity in man are strikingly parallel to those described for experimental animals. As early as 1920 (Happ, 1920) it was found that isoagglutinins against heterologous blood groups are absent from the circulation during the first months of life and regularly appear during the second half of the first year or during the second year. Frankenstein (1920) found that infants respond poorly to typhoid antigens: in his series, only 3 of 30 young infants produced significant titers of agglutinins after injection of typhoid vaccine. By contrast, adults regularly responded to the same vaccine. Ribadeau-Dumas et al. (1925) found newborns to be refractory to antidiphtheria immunizations, although some did show slight response. These early observations were confirmed by several investigators, and, together with the findings in experimental animals, were cited by Baumgartner (1934) as evidence for the immunologic inadequacy of the very young mammal, including the human infant. On this basis, it was popular among pediatricians to delay immunization procedures until the second half of the first year or the second year of life. This delay in immunizations, even until 3 months after birth, was unfortunate since, for certain of the diseases against which routine immunization was performed, the earliest possible protection was most contributory. Sako (1947) was perhaps the first to express the view that infants have fully developed capacity to form antibodies against pertussis and other antigens shortly after birth. Sako et al. (1945) had studied routine immunizations initiated soon after birth and showed that such early immunizations provided effective antibody levels. Bradford et al. ( 1949) also pointed out that, from a practical point of view, it is possible to obtain good protective levels of antibody in infants from 1 to 3 months of age against alum-precipitated diphtheria and tetanus toxoids and pertussis vaccine. Vahlquist et al. ( 1948) and di Sant’Agnese (1949) reinvestigated the immunologic responsiveness of human infants, and were forced to the conclusion that, although immunologic responses can be obtained shortly after birth, both premature and full-term infants are slow to form antibody and are somewhat defective in their total immunologic capacity. The subsequent studies of Vahlquist and Nordbring (1952), in Sweden, and Osborn et al. (1952b) in the United States, established clearly the feebleness and slowness of the immunologic response to diphtheria toxoid in both premature and full-term infants. Both investigations also showed that antibody synthesis can be initiated in extremely premature babies and early in the neonatal period. In the studies of
24
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
Osborn et al. (1952a), a rather striking inhibitory effect of passively transferred maternal antibody was demonstrated. Paradoxically, these studies established that immunologic maturation is clearly not a consequence of chronologic maturation alone, since extremely small premature infants seemed to gain full immunologic competence at about the same time after birth as full-term infants. It seemed reasonable to conclude that an environmental factor, possibly antigenic stimulation itself, is responsible for the final stage of maturation of immunologic capacity. Scattered observations, such as those of A. S. Sabin and Feldman (1949) and Shinefield and Townsend (1953), suggested that host immunologic response might be elicited at a very early age by virus or other infections. Koprowski et al. (1956) gave polio virus to infants under 1month of age who showed a surprisingly adequate and prompt ability to form neutralizing antibodies to these live agents. While the response was smaller than that of older children, it seemed sufficient to contain the infection and provide immune protection. Interestingly, passively transferred antibody did not seem to interfere with the antibody response of these newborn infants to polio virus. Stulberg et al. (1956) studied babies involved in an epidemic of E . coli 0127:B8 infection. About one-third of the infants developed antibodies, demonstrable by hemagglutination but not by agglutination techniques; two-thirds showed no antibody at all. By contrast, volunteer adults infected with the same agents developed both rising hemagglutination titers and bacterial agglutinins. Eichenwald and Kotsevalov (1960) reported observations on a number of full-term infants naturally infected with adenovirus types 1, 2, and 3, and ECHO virus 9, 18, and 20, during the first few weeks of life. Serologic studies revealed that these babies responded immunologically, and that their response was independent of age and birth weight, but that it varied with the type of virus involved. Passively transferred antibody specific for the virus agent did not seem to interfere with active formation of antibodies. These authors recognized that successful immune response to virus infections may not be the general rule for premature and newborn infants, and cited the aberrant behavior of newborns to herpes simplex, cytomegalic inclusion virus, and certain Coxsackie viruses as examples. They also raised the important question of whether deficiencies other than those involving the immune response might explain the peculiar vulnerability of the neonate to these virus agents. Bridges et al. (1959) and Zak and Good (1959) studied two infants born of an agammaglobulinemic mother whose immunologic response was extremely defective in the neonatal period. Indeed, these babies did
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
25
not show response to the antigens studied until they were more than 1 month old in one instance and 6 weeks old in the other. Smith and his co-workers (R. T. Smith, 1960) reported their observations that premature and full-term human infants, as well as newborn rabbits, can, indeed, form substantial amounts of antibody against certain antigens within a short time. The antigens used in most of their studies were flagellar antigens of a variety of Salmonella. The antibody response was striking in that it occurred at a time when immunologic response to other antigens, such as somatic antigens of the same organisms, was defective. Further study of this antibody showed it to be a high molecular weight antibody, presumably of the 19s class. This heat-stable 19s antibody was said to be broken down to smaller units with 2-mercaptoethanol, with retention of at least some of the immunologic reactivity (R. T. Smith, 1960). In Smith's studies the 19s type of antibody seemed to be the only one present for a period of about 2 months, followed by appearance of 7s antibody against these antigens. The variance of Smith's data and those of Bridges et al. (1959) and Zak and Good (1959) is probably a reflection of the different antigens used. Fink et al. (1961, 1962) have done similar studies, using flagellar antigens of Salmonella tzjphi. In their investigation, however, the antibody produced seemed to lose all immunologic activity, in usual fashion, upon exposure to 2-mercaptoethanol, The results Uhr et al. (1962b) have obtained, using bacteriophage $X 174 in premature infants, are similar to those of R. T. Smith (1960) and Fink et al. (1961, 1962) with bacterial flagellar antigens. The babies produced antibody to the phage as promptly and in as large amounts as did older children; however, all of the early antibody produced in response to this potent antigen was of the 19s class. These authors pointed out the clash between these observations and the past studies demonstrating the incompetence of premature and full-term human infants toward other antigens. The conclusion seems inescapable: using the right antigens, immunologic capacity of a primitive type can be induced in the human newborn. Kallings and Alvin (1962) have studied inactivation of Tz coliphage by infant sera. They found that neutralizing antibodies against coliphage are absent from cord blood, but appear in some infants during the first 14 days of life and in most by the age of 30 days. The presence of an inhibitor in cord blood was suggested by the finding that cord blood serum inactivated the effect of adult serum on the virus. Thus, the low rate of virus inactivation by cord blood and the apparent rise in phage-
26
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPEXMASTER
neutralizing activity during the first few weeks after birth might reflect loss of an inhibitor rather than an immunologic response. Eichenwald ( 1963) has recently studied several virus infections of the fetus which also give evidence of 19s antibody production. In this instance, the antibody response occurred even before birth of the infant. In summary, the studies of immunologic response in human infants appear to establish the existence of an immunologic deficiency which is gradually replaced by adult-type immunologic reactivity during the first few weeks of extrauterine life. The maturation of immunologic potential appears to be more a function of separation from the protected environment of the uterus than a function of chronologic maturation, since this development in prematures parallels that in full-term infants. The earliest antibody response is a partial one, evoked by certain virus infections and antigenic stimulation with bacteriophage or flagellar antigens of Salmonella, and involving 19s or BZM-globulins.The sequence agrees well with the observations of the early appearance of P z M - g l O b U h in infants, especially in association with infections (von Muralt and Gugler, 1960; Roth, 1962). A number of studies, in different species and with different antigens, have suggested that earliest response of the young animal involves 19s globulins (R. T. Smith, 1960; Uhr et al., 1962a,b). There are also preliminary indications, as will be discussed in the phylogeny section, that the antibody response of some lower vertebrates involves high molecular weight globulins. G. DEVELOPMENT OF THE LYMPHOID TISSUE Because of the clear association of lymphoid cells and tissues with all forms of immune response, consideration of the ontogeny of the immunologic processes must focus as well on the development of the lymphoid tissue. Although extensive investigations on the development of the lymphoid tissues were made more than 50 years ago (Saxer, 1896; Kling, 1904; F. R. Sabin, 1905, 1909; Hammar, 1905, 1911; Bell, 1906; Maximow, 1909, 1912), some of the most important contributions have been made only recently ( Ackerman and Knouff, 1959; Ackerman, 1962; Auerbach, 1980, 1961a,b; Ball and Auerbach, 1980). The concepts of the ontogeny of the lymphoid tissues are changing as intensive investigations are pursued in many laboratories, and conclusions must be considered somewhat tentative at present. In mammals, the key organs and tissues containing the lymphoid system and the bulk of the lymphocytic elements are the thymus, lymph nodes, spleen, and organized lymphoid tissue of the gut tract, including the tonsils, adenoids, Peyer’s patches, appendix, and, in such mammals as the
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTnTE IMMUNITY
27
rabbit, the intestinal tonsil or sacculus rotunda. Phylogenetically, lymph nodes were, until very recently (Kent et al., 1964) considered to make their first appearance, in small numbers, in birds. However, most birds have a lymphoid organ not found in other forms, the bursa of Fabricius, originally defined as a lymphoid organ by Forbes (1877) and restudied by Jolly (1915) and others (Boyden, 1922; Calhoun, 1933; Ackerman, 1962; Ackerman and Knouff, 1959, 1964). The bursa is a blind, plicated, saclike outpouching extending posteriorly and superiorly from the cloaca. The parenchyma of this organ consists almost entirely of lymphoid follicles, and recent studies of Glick et a2. ( 1956), Glick (1958, 1964), Chang et al. (1957), and A. P. Mueller et al. ( 1960, 1962, 1964) have established the intimate association of the bursa of Fabricius with the development of immunologic processes in chickens. Consequently, its ontogenetic development deserves detailed consideration in this section of the review. In all animals in which direct comparative studies have been done, the thymus is the first organ to develop as true lymphoid tissue. In man, for example, Hammar (1905, 1921) showed clearly that the thymus has a well-developed lymphocyte population by the third gestational month, prior to the appearance of recognizable lymphoid structure in the other organs that ultimately house lymphoid tissue. Knoll ( 1929), studying the development of hematopoiesis in man, described the following sequence. Lymphopoiesis is well established in the thymus by the 35-mm. stage. The spleen, as late as the 90-mm. stage, shows only erythropoiesis and myelopoiesis, but no lymphopoiesis. The ultimate establishment of lymphopoiesis in the spleen follows by at least 2 months the development of granulopoiesis in that organ. Knoll found further that a low level of circulating lymphocytes is present some time before there is discernible evidence of lymphopoiesis in the spleen. He concluded that the thymus as a source of lymphocytes would explain the small percentage of circulating cells having the staining and morphologic characteristics of lymphocytes, in the absence of evidence of lymphopoiesis in the organ which later assumes the primary lymphopoietic function. Rumpianesi and Finotti (1957), studying the embryologic development of the spleen in man, again pointed out that the spleen is reticular until 2 months of gestation, granulopoietic and myelopoietic until 4 months, and does not become lymphopoietic until 5 months of gestation, fully 2 months following development of lymphopoiesis in the thymus. Studies of the development of lymph nodes in man are also pertinent. It is clear, from the extensive studies of Wischnewezkaja (1932), that this is a late development for the most part, proceeding rapidly during the first year of postnatal life and continuing until puberty. Similar ob-
28
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
servations were made by Campana (1938). Gulland (1894), Saxer (1896), Kling (1904), F. R. Sabin (1905, 1909), A. H. Clark (1912), Latta ( 1921) , Ando ( 1930), Gilmour ( 1941) , and Hellman ( 1921,1943) , as well as Wischnewezkaja (1932), made extensive studies of the ontogenesis of the lymph nodes in man and other mammals. From these investigations, it is clear that the lymph nodes develop at the sites of confluence of the lymph vessels and lymph sacs, with substantial mesenchymal contributions. In each species, primary, secondary, and tertiary nodes can be distinguished, and the primary nodes are the first to develop and become lymphopoietic. There is some dispute about the beginnings of lymphopoiesis. The bulk of the evidence is consistent with the concept that lymphopoiesis begins in the primary lymph nodes, and that this development occurs a good deal later than the establishment of lymphopoiesis in the thymus. For example, the data of Hammar (1905, 1921) and Gilmour (1941) establish the beginning of lymphopoiesis in the thymus prior to the 35-mm. stage in the human embryo. Lymphopoiesis in the primary lymph nodes is described as beginning in the 48-mm. stage by Gilmour (1941), the 50-mm. stage by F. R. Sabin (1905), and at the fourth month by Hellman (1943). In Gilmour’s paper, however, there is the claim that the very earliest lymphopoiesis in the body is in the connective tissue of the lymph plexuses in the 26-mm. embryo. Whether the primary site of lymphopoiesis is at these sites or in the thymus remains to be determined by careful future study. Lymphoid tissue develops in the gut at a considerably later period in most species. In recent years, ontogenetic development of the lymphoid tissues has been reinvestigated, and several important contributions have emerged. Particularly contributory have been the investigations of Auerbach (l960,1961a7b),Ball and Auerbach (1980), Ackennan (1962), and Ackerman and Knouff (1959, 1964). The mouse, like other mammals, shows the first lymphoid development in the thymus. In the 12-day mouse embryo, there is no organized lymphoid tissue; the thymus at this stage consists of an epithelial anlage surrounded by a condensation of mesenchymal tissue (Ball and Auerbach, 1960). The thymus develops lymphopoietic activity by the fourteenth day of gestation, and at 16 days that organ is primarily lymphoid. The lymph nodes and spleen of the mouse do not develop organized lymphoid structure until after birth. Ball and Auerbach (1960) developed a technique for culturing the mouse thymus anlage at a glass clot interface. When the twelfth-day epithelial thymus was cultured in this manner, it spread and showed lobulation, but it remained epithelial, and no lymphoid cells developed.
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
29
However, when the epithelial anlage was grown in the anterior chamber of the eye of a mouse of the same strain, the epithelium became lymphoid within several days. This lymphoid development was extremely sensitive to the homotransplantation reaction, and even in the anterior eye chamber of the allogeneic mouse, differentiation of the epithelial anlage to lymphoid tissue did not occur. Auerbach then made use of an incisive technique developed by Grobstein (1956) for study of embryogenesis of other organs such as the kidney. He placed the epithelial component of the 12-day mouse thymus, separated from the mesenchymal component by tryptic digestion, in tissue culture, using a hanging drop technique; and showed that this epithelial component would develop into lymphoid tissue when brought into contact with mesenchyme. His most critical experiment was to place the epithelial anlage and mesenchymal tissue in direct apposition on the two sides of a millipore membrane in tissue culture. The membrane was 20 mp in thickness, and had pores small enough to prevent ingress or egress of ceIIs. As controls, in the same tissue culture preparation, he used an epithelial anlage isolated from mesenchymal tissue. Surprisingly, perhaps, but in keeping with the earlier contributions of Beard (1894), Bell (1906), and others, the lymphoid cells developed in the epithelial component in the tissue culture rather than in the mesenchymal component. In an extensive series of studies, Auerbach ( 1960, 19f34) then established that mesenchyme from several different sources, and even from different species, would serve to induce development of lymphoid tissue from the epithelium of the thymus anlage. In all these studies, mesenchyme was most effective as an inducer of lymphoid development if it had been taken from an area in contact with epithelial anlagen. Auerbach (1961b) postulated, as had Ruth (1960), that the thymus is a primary lymphoid organ that disseminates lymphoid cells to mesenchymal tissues, such as the spleen and lymph nodes, where their immunologic function might be exercised. The development of the remainder of the lymphoid tissue in the mouse is clearly secondary, from a temporal viewpoint, to the development of the thymus. Recent investigations, to be summarized in a later section, give further support to the thesis that the full development, both morphologically and functionally, of the secondary lymphoid tissues is dependent on thymic function. In a parallel series of studies, Ackerman and Knouff (1959, 1964) and Ackerman (1962) have presented substantial evidence that the bursa of Fabricius of chickens also develops primarily by direct transformation of an epithelial anlage in the presence of a mesenchymal contact. Early investigations by Forbes ( 1877), Stieda ( 1880), Wenckebach ( 1896),
30
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
and Retterer and Lelidvre (1913) had led them to the conclusion that the lymphoid tissue of the bursa of Fabricius was of epithelial origin. However, Jolly (1915) and others (Boyden, 1922; Calhoun, 1933; and Kirkpatrick, 1944) concluded that mesenchymal components invaded the epithelial anlage and contributed the lymphoid development. Hammar ( 1905), Maximow ( 1909), and others ( Badertscher, 1915; Kingsbury, 1915) reached similar conclusions regarding the thymus. The best current evidence argues for direct development of these lymphoid organs from their epithelial anlagen under the inducing, and perhaps organizing, influence of the mesenchyme. In the chicken embryo, the thymus again is the first lymphoid organ to develop. The epithelial component is evident before the ninth day of incubation, and the thymus is a fully developed lymphoid organ by the twelfth day of incubation. Between the twelfth and fourteenth day, budding of the epithelial folds of the bursa of Fabricius is observed, and on the fourteenth, fifteenth, and sixteenth days the lymphoid structure begins to develop by direct transformation of epithelial cells to lymphoid cells. By the eighteenth day of incubation, the bursa has a well-organized lymphoid structure. Thus, 3 days before hatching, only the thymus and the bursa of Fabricius have identifiable lymphoid tissue (Papermaster and Good, 1962). The spleen is still entirely erythropoietic and myelopoietic; the intestine contains no follicular lymphoid tissue; and the skin is lacking in lymphoid nodules. In this species, prevention, by hormonal means, of the lymphoid development of the thymus or bursa, or both, or their surgical removal at hatching or shortly thereafter, inhibits the development of the growing chicken’s immunologic capabilities ( Click et ul., 1956; A. P. Mueller et d.,1960, 1982, 1964; Papermaster et al., 1962a,b; Warner and Szenberg, 1962, 1964; Aspin84 and Meyer, 1964; Szenberg and Warner, 1W2; Warner et ul., 1962). Studying the maturation of the lymphoid tissue of the chicken thymus and the bursa, using the Coulter Counter technique employed by Ball (1963) and Auerbach ( 1964) to estimate the number and size of the free lymphoid cells in the mouse thymus, Peterson and Good (1964) found a very different maturation of the lymphoid cells in the bursa and thymus of the chicken. By the time of hatching, the thymic cells had matured to a population with the largest number of lymphoid cells having a modal volume of 70 p3. By contrast, the bursa1 population, even as late as two or three months after hatching, contained few such small cells but had a preponderance of cells of 106 p3 in volume. These clear differences in the differentiation of thymic lymphoid cells and cells of the bursa of Fabricius might account for the differences in development of potential for im-
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
31
munologic function claimed to exist in the two populations by Warner and Szenberg (1964) and Szenberg and Warner (1962). Recent studies in our laboratories by Kelly (1963) and by Archer et at. (1963a,b, 1964) have been concerned with the sequential development of the lymphoid tissues in a variety of species. The studies of Archer et at. (1963a,b, 1964) demonstrate that, in the rabbit, the thymus is the first organ to become lymphoid, and the spleen, peripheral lymph nodes, and gut become lymphoid secondarily. The apparent “peripheralization” of the lymphoid structure to spleen and lymph nodes is variable about the time of birth in the rabbit, having occurred in some animals as early as the twenty-eighth day of gestation (total period of gestation about 32 days) and occurring in others as late as 1 or 2 days after birth. Neonatal thymectomy in the rabbit interferes with the lymphoid development of the spleen, lymph nodes, and some of the lymphoid tissue of the gut; however, the intestinal tonsil and the appendix apparently have a lymphoid development independent to a degree from thymus. This development occurs in close association with epithelial outpouchings-a development which shows some striking histologic parallels to bursa development in the chicken (Archer et al., 1963b). These authors have suggested that the appendix and intestinal tonsil (sacculus rotunda) may, indeed, in the rabbit be the homolog of the bursa of Fabricius. Indeed, direct evidence for participation of the appendix in development of both morphologic characteristics and functional capacity of the peripheral lymphoid tissue has recently been presented (Sutherland et al., 1964). In these studies it was found that, although neonatal thymectomy reduced the circulating lymphocyte count, depleted organized lymphatic structures in spleen and lymph nodes, and interfered with development of immunologic capacity in the rabbit, these animals seemed to recover to near normal structure and function between nine and 16 weeks after birth. Removal of the appendix also interfered with development of lymphoid structure and immunologic capacity. However, when both the thymus and appendix were removed in the neonatal period, immunologic capacity was depressed more regularly and more completely then when either organ was removed alone, depletion of lymphocyte count and organized lymphoid structure was more profound, and the deficiency thus induced persisted far longer. Paradoxically, however, it was observed (Good et al., 1964b) that rabbits subjected to neonatal thymectomy and appendectomy frequently developed Coombs positive anemia, amyloid lesions in liver, spleen, and kidney, and abundant plasma cells in their otherwise severely depleted lymphoid tissue, These observations suggest that the thymus and appendix (central lymphoid organs) possess mecha-
32
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
nisms for controlling the development of the peripheral lymphoid tissues, not only of great importance in its full functional development, but possibly also important in managing the processes of self-recognition. In the mouse, hamster, and, to a lesser extent, in the rat, neonatal thymectomy has a profound effect on development of immunologic capacity (J. F. A. P. Miller, 1961; Good et al., 196213; Arnason et al., 1962a; Jankovib et al., 1962; Waksman et al., 1962; J. D. Sherman et al., 1963; Roosa et al., 1963; Defendi et al., 1964). In each of these species, Archer et al. (1963a, 1964) found the thymus to be the primary lymphoid organ at birth. In the dog (Kelly, 1963) the developmental sequence is similar: the thymus is lymphoid first, followed in turn by central lymph nodes, spleen, gut, and peripheral nodes; however, the relationship of this development to birth is different. The central lymph nodes (cervical nodes) of the dog develop lymphoid structure between the fortieth and forty-eighth day of gestation and the spleen usually by the fifty-fourth day; all the lymphoid organs have quite well developed structure at birth. In this species, where peripheralization of the lymphoid tissue is highly developed at the time of birth, neonatal thymectomy has little effect on the ultimate development of immunologic capacity. Table I1 presents a summary of the state of development of the lymphoid tissue at birth or hatching in several species, in relation to the effectiveness of neonatal thymectomy in inhibiting their ultimate development of immunologic capacity. Although the most detailed studies of lymphoid development in the opossum have not yet been published (Block, 1964), the data available thus far support the conclusion of the foregoing studies regarding the earliest lymphoid development in the thymus. Kalmutz (1962) demonstrated an antibody response to phage administered 11 days after birth, when only the thymus and some of the lymph nodes show lymphoid development. In the experiments of La Via et al. (1963) a similar correlation of the beginnings of immunologic reactivity and earliest lymphoid development in the thymus and some lymph nodes was observed. Another aspect of the development of the lymphoid tissues which warrants discussion in the context of development of immunologic capacity was emphasized in the studies of Bridges et al. (1959). In most species, whatever the state of peripheralization of the lymphoid tissues at birth, the lymphoid development proceeds in the postnatal period. In man, this maturation is rapid during the first several months of life, slows down to some extent, but certainly continues until puberty (Wischnewezkaja, 1932). Many investigators have shown ( Gundobin, 1906; Barnes, 1909; Nagoya, 1913; Hellman, 1921; Foerster, 1923; Wetzel, 1926;
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
33
W. Ehrich, 1929;Denz, 1947;Gyllensten, 1950; Bridges et al., 1959) that germinal centers, both primary and secondary follicles, are largely a postnatal development in many mammalian species. Plasma cells, the cells responsible for antibody synthesis, are generally not present at birth (D. J. Davis, 1912; Sturgeon, 1951; Glaser et al., 1950; Bridges et al., 1959),except perhaps in some guinea pigs (Gyllensten, 1950),but develop as a consequence of antigenic stimulation after birth. Bridges et al. (1959)showed that, in man as well as in the rabbit, plasma cells develop in the gut, bone marrow, and other tissues in the postnatal period, and that their formation can be accelerated by antigenic stimulaTABLE I1 RELATION OF DEVELOPMENTAL STATUSOF LYMPHOID TISSUE AT BIRTH TO EFFECTIVENESS OF NEONATAL THYMECTOMY IN LIMITING IMMUNOLOGIC DEVELOPMENT
Animal Rabbit Mouse Rat Hamster Chicken5
Dog Cat
Thymus
Spleen
Gut -
Node -
++++ + o r -- - ++++ ++++ + o r -- -- -++++ ++++ ++++ ++++ ++++ ++ ++ ++++ ++++ ++ ++
of immunologic capacity J,
But variable
J, J, J,
J,
Homograft
J/ Antibody
No cffect Not known
5 The first row represents the chicken thymus, and the second the bursa of Fabricius (From Archer et al., 196313).
tion. Nonetheless, a considerable lethargy, with respect to both plasma cell formation and antibody response to soluble protein antigens and certain bacterial antigens, was observed in both the human newborn and the neonatal rabbit. There now seems to be no question that sufficiently intense antigenic stimulation will induce both plasma cell proliferation and antibody production even prior to birth in mammals. Grbgoire (1945) reported that injection of antigens would induce late embryonic and neonatal guinea pigs to develop basophilic lymphocytes as well as germinal centers. In man, in intrauterine infections with several different organisms, plasma cells are often found, and Thorbecke and Benacerraf (1962)have produced plasma cells as early as a few days after birth in the appendix of rabbits stimulated with antigen in utero. Porcile (1904)found plasma cells in the liver of two syphilitic newborns, and Pund (1953) reported plasma cell infiltration in the placenta in congenital lues, as well as plasma cells in the liver of the newborn. Paige
34
ROBERT A, GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
et al. (1942) studied three cases of toxoplasmic encephalitis and observed plasma cells in the lesions in the patients who died in the early neonatal period. In a recent investigation, Silverstein and Lukes (1962) assessed development of the lymphoid tissues and plasmacytosis in 19 fetuses, 16 that had congenital syphilis and 3 congenital toxoplasmosis. Gestational age was estimated at 29 weeks to full-term. All 19 had mature plasma cells, and most had precocious lymphoid tissue development as well. Thus, it seems clear from these studies that most mammals have at least feeble immunologic capacity in late embryonic and early neonatal life, and that antibody synthesis is attributable, at least to some extent, to the capacity for plasma cell development even before birth. There seems to be little question, however, that the characteristic morphologic responses to antigenic stimulation, namely, lymphoid follicle development and plasma cell production, are largely postnatal events. The late embryo and the neonate show considerable inertia in all three capacities, an inertia which is lost during the first few postnatal weeks in man and over a much longer period in some species, including the mouse (Makinodan and Peterson, 1962).
H. ONTOGENETIC DEVELOPMENT OF TRANSPLANTATION IMMUNITY Numerous reviews and symposia in recent years have been concerned, at least in part, with the ontogenetic development of transplantation immunity (Hagek et al., 1961, 1962; Ebert and Delanney, 1960; Brent, 1958; Chase, 1959; Billingham, 1958; Billingham et aZ., 1956; Billingham and Brent, 1959). Although Billingham (1958) has, with some vigor, made the point that maturation of transplantation immunity does not correspond temporally with birth in many species, the development of full capacity to reject homotransplants generally proceeds in the posthatching or postnatal period. On the whole, its development correlates strikingly with the maturation of antibody-producing capabilities. In his early studies of the development of transplantation immunity in the chick embryo, hlurphy (1913, 1914, 1916) showed that foreign grafts of mammalian and avian tissues, as well as a variety of tumors, are not rejected prior to the eighteenth embryonic day. These observations were confirmed and extended by numerous investigators (Stevenson, 1917a,b, 1918; Waddington and Schmidt, 1933; Sandstrom, 1932, 1936, 1940), and many rather fantastic experiments have been performed in transplanting homologous and heterologous tissues to avian embryos.
ONTOGENY AND PHnOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
35
Willier and Rawles, in 1940, discovered that neural crest cells transplanted to embryos of the same species may survive beyond hatching and even into adult life. This appears to involve a kind of tolerance, although the critical test of capacity to accept transplants during adult life was not carried out. On the other hand, Eastlick (1941) found that limbs grafted from embryonic buds of one species to embryos of another species were tolerated up to the sixth week after hatching. Ebert and Delanney (1960) have reviewed this problem, and pointed out that homografts and heterografts are accepted by embryos and are maintained for most, if not all, of the embryonic period. Many of these homotransplants and heterotransplants performed by embryologists produce chimeric conditions in which donor and host components can be distinguished by differences in cell size, chromosome number, or such somatic characteristics as pigment. Early studies by Danforth (1929) and Danforth and Foster (1929) indicate that skin grafts show prolonged survival in newly hatched chickens. This finding agrees well with the later work of Cannon et al. (1958) who not only observed prolonged survival of skin homografts in newly hatched chickens, but found that a relatively small proportion of newly hatched fowl apparently accepted skin from adult or other newly hatched chickens on a permanent basis. The ontogenesis of transplantation immunity in ducks, turkeys, and chickens has been a focus of studies by Hraba and HaSek (1956), HaSek ( 1957,1961) and HaSkovh ( 1957). Prolonged survival of skin homografts regularly occurs in newly hatched ducks, but occurs less often in newly hatched turkeys and chickens. In an excellent study, Schinckel and Ferguson (1953) carried out skin autografts and homografts in fetal lambs between the gestational ages of 80 and 117 days. Using histologic criteria and the second-set homograft response after birth, it was well established that homografts are actively rejected by the fetus in this species. Even grafts taken from the mother were rejected by the fetus, indicating that the rejection was a consequence of immunologic response of the fetus and not the ewe. Studies of in utero transplantation in rabbits, carried out by Egdahl ( 1957), suggested the presence of vigorous homograft immunity even before birth in this species, a finding given further support by the later observation of K. A. Porter (1960) that it is difficult to induce tolerance in rabbits by injection of spleen cells during the last week or so of gestation. By contrast, cells administered prior to the twenty-second gestational day regularly produce a tolerant state in rabbits. In an interesting recent study by IvAnyi and IvAnyi (1961) skin grafts
36
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
exchanged between newborn rabbit siblings had a longer period of survival than those exchanged between unrelated rabbit newborns; some of the grafts between siblings even took permanently. All grafts between unrelated animals were rejected within 20 days, with an average survival of 10.7 days, while 55% of the grafts between siblings survived for more than 20 days, 44% for more than 30 days, 17% for more than 70 days, and 5% for 210 days or more. IvPnyi and IvPnyi concluded that the homograft response of the rabbit is weak enough in the neonatal period to be affected significantly by the diminished antigenic disparity between siblings as compared to unrelated animals. T. N. and S. Harris (1960) also found homograft immunity to be present in newborn rabbits. However, whereas the homograft response to lymphoid cells could be demonstrated as circulating antibody in adult animals, only “cellular immunity” was present in the newborns. Rawles (1955), and subsequently Medawar and Woodruff (1958) showed that newborn rats certainly have a deficient homograft response, and the latter investigations have even demonstrated production of tolerance by skin grafts placed after birth in some rats. A well-developed capacity for homograft rejection is present in newborn piglets, at a time when antibody production, at least to certain antigens, is not demonstrable (Sterzl et al., 1960). Eakin and Harris (1945), and subsequently Hildemann and Haas (1M2), studied development of homograft immunity in bullfrog larvae. They showed that the capacity to reject homotransplants develops at about the time metamorphosis is beginning, and Hildemann found that the time of appearance of homograft immunity coincided with the appearance of small lymphocytes in the animal’s circulation. In a study of homograft immunity in human, premature and fullterm infants, Fowler et al. (1960) noted a vigorous capacity to reject skin homografts. In summary, studies of developmental biology of the homograft reaction reveal gross deficiency in early developmental stages and maturation at or close to the time of delivery or hatching in most species. The period of inadequacy tends to parallel that of the other forms of immunologic reactivity. To some degree, perhaps based on quantitative factors, the capacity to reject homografts appears to develop earlier than most immunologic phenomena. There is considerable variation from species to species. In such animals as sheep, transplantation immunity is well developed before birth. In the mouse, rat, chicken, and duck, full development of the homograft response does not take place until some time following birth or hatching. Even in the rabbit, where the ability
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTlVE IMMUNITY
37
to reject homotransplants is clearly present prior to birth, further development of this capacity takes place after birth, as evidenced in studies in which weaker antigenic stimulation was provided by tissue from siblings.
I. ONTOGENETIC DEVELOPMENT OF THE DELAYED ALLERGIC RESPONSE In early experimental studies, Petroff and Stewart (1926)recognized that young guinea pigs cannot be sensitized to tuberculin by vaccination with killed tuberculin bacilli as readily as can older and larger guinea pigs. This phenomenon was investigated incisively by Freund (1927, 1929). In these experiments Freund demonstrated that young, experimentally infected guinea pigs react poorly or not at all to intradermal injection of aqueous extracts of tubercle bacilli, even though tuberculous lesions were present in the regional lymph nodes and spleens. Valtis (1928)confirmed Freund’s observation, using old tuberculin to test for sensitivity. In the later studies, Freund (1929)found that tuberculous guinea pigs less than 1 month of age had a negative or at most a minimally positive reaction to intracutaneous injection of tuberculin; however, they were about as sensitive to the toxic action of old tuberculin injected intraperitoneally as were adult tuberculous guinea pigs. He concluded that the mechanism which mediates systemic hypersensitivity is fully developed in guinea pigs at less than 1 month of age, when the dermal reaction is very slight or negative. Freund found further that hypersensitivity to the intracutaneous injection of tuberculin is not transmitted from tuberculous female to offspring. The deficiency in the newborn tuberculous guinea pig, Freund concluded, is not in the mechanism of developing sensitivity, shown to be intact upon intraperitoneal injection of tuberculin, but in the anatomic or physiologic characteristics of the skin of the young animal. Several other reports in the late 1920’sserved to underscore the difference in responsiveness of the skin of human infants and young experimental animals. For example, Cooke (1927) found that the skin of newborn babies was not sensitive to the injection of a considerable amount of “scarlet fever toxin,” and showed that this lack of reactivity was not a reflection of antitoxin in the blood of the infants studied. Adelsberger (1927)studied the effect of a number of irritants on infant skin, and found blister formation to be much more easily induced in babies from 8 to 12 months of age than in those under the age of 3 months. In tests involving both human infants and rabbits, Friedberger and Heim (1929)observed less sensitivity to mustard oil and eel serum in infants and newborn rabbits than in control adults or grown rabbits. These authors also concluded from their studies that a negative Schick
38
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
reaction in young infants does not necessarily reflect the action of antitoxin, but may merely be a reflection of the unresponsiveness of the infant's skin to irritation. Calmette and Gubrin (1929) observed that young calves infected with small doses of virulent tubercle bacilli and protected from re-infection did not develop reactions until 4 to 6 months later. Weiss (1958), on the other hand, found that guinea pigs injected with killed tuberculin organisms as long as 45 days before birth frequently showed dermal hypersensitivity when tested 8 weeks after birth. Uhr (1960) and Uhr et al. (1960) have studied development of delayed hypersensitivity in guinea pig embryos and in human neonates, both premature and fullterm. In the guinea pig studies (Uhr, 1960), the embryos were injected in utero from 1to 2 weeks before birth with diphtheria toxoid, ovalbumin, or BSA incorporated in Freunds adjuvant. When skin was tested on the day of birth, 31 out of 83 animals showed the tuberculin-type of hypersensitivity. Of particular interest was a size differential: the guinea pigs weighing more than 90 gm. at birth generally were sensitive at birth, whereas those weighing less than 90 gm. were not. Uhr concluded that delayed allergy can be induced in utero, and that larger fetuses are more susceptible to development of delayed allergy than are the smaller ones. Rees and Garbutt ( 1961) described the development of hypersensitivity in mice by prenatal introduction of tubercle bacilli, but their experiments were not critical with respect to the time of development of delayed allergy during the neonatal period. The results of Sterzl's (1959b) studies in piglets parallel those of Freund in the guinea pig: the animals, although not expressing the skin reaction of delayed hypersensitivity, could in reality develop delayed allergy as revealed by capacity to express systemic sensitivity and transfer the reaction. In 1958, Waksman and Matoltsy, while studying passive transfer of delayed allergy to tuberculin in guinea pigs, found that newborn animals did not serve well as recipients of local passive reactions. Their studies in adults had suggested that passive delayed reactions depend upon proliferation and/or differentiation of the transferred cells at the test site. Consequently, they reasoned that the failure of development of visible reactions in the newborn could reflect lack of differentiation of the transferred cells toward mature histiocytes or macrophages because of the inadequacy of the neonatal cellular environment. Warwick et d. (196Oa) studied the passive transfer of delayed hypersensitivity in the newborn rabbit. By using a streptococcal infection to develop delayed allergy in the adult donors, they observed regular
ONTOCENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
39
failure of passive transfer to recipients during the first and second weeks of life, an irregular response in recipients between 2 and 3 weeks of age, and regular success at 4 weeks and older. The striking parallel with the development of antibody-producing capacity with respect to certain antigens was noted. On this basis, these investigators suggested that perhaps passive transfer of delayed allergy is not entirely passive and that newborns, as well as patients with Hodgkin’s disease, both of which are refractory to the development of delayed allergy and also resist its passive transfer (Kelly et al., 1958; Warwick et al., 1961), may lack the capacity for active participation in the “passive transfer” reaction. Salvin et al. (1962) studied the passive transfer of delayed hypersensitivity in newborn guinea pigs after sensitization of the donor with purified soluble antigens. They found that the neonatal animals did not demonstrate passively transferred delayed allergy by skin testing during the first 2 weeks of life, but developed skin reactions comparable to adults thereafter. On the other hand, tests for systemic delayed allergy in the newborn recipients of cells from sensitized donors demonstrated toxicity and pyrogenicity, interpreted as evidence of passive transfer. Newborn guinea pigs in Salvin’s studies produced antibody and showed Arthus reactivity. However, passive Arthus reactions were not produced as readily in the newborns as in adults. By contrast, contact allergy and allergic encephalitis were produced in newborn guinea pigs. This differentiates the guinea pig from the neonatal rabbit which resists production of allergic encephalomyelitis ( Waksman and Morrison, 1951). Finally, Salvin et al. (1962) showed that newborn guinea pigs which had been actively sensitized to soluble antigen had cells capable of passive transfer of delayed allergy, although they did not themselves show delayed skin hypersensitivity, Studies of the ontogeny of the delayed allergic response in man have been consistent with those reported in experimental animals. The early observations of Bernard and Debre (1929) indicated that the skin sensitivity of tuberculous infants develops slowly and that more than 3 months may elapse before skin hypersensitivity is demonstrable. These observations were confirmed by several investigators ( Amick et al., 1950; Grady and Zuelzer, 1955; S. F. Davis et al., 1960; Kendig, 1954; Kendig and Angell, 1950; Kendig and Rodgers, 1958) studying tuberculosis acquired congenitally and neonatally. Kendig ( 1954), Kendig and Angell ( 1950), and Kendig and Rodgers (1958) have described several infants born with tuberculosis in whom positive Mantoux reactions developed between the nineteenth and thirty-first days after birth. Tudvad et al. (1956) studied a large group of babies immunized in the neonatal period with
40
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
BCG and found that virtually all the children had developed delayed allergy when tested at 2 months of age. Straus (1931) reported successful sensitization of human newborns to poison ivy. In these experiments, the infants were sensitized by topical application of poison ivy paste in the scapular region or were fed a poison ivy extract, After an interval of 2 to 4 weeks, the infants were tested and 73% showed well-developed allergic reactions. A recent study of delayed hypersensitivity in human newborns is that of Uhr et al. (1960),in which contact sensitivity was induced with 2,4dinitrofluorobenzene, These authors found that older infants were readily sensitized by percutaneous application of a vesicant dose of this chemical, but that premature and full-term newborns were sensitized only occasionally. These findings indicate that in the human newborn, delayedtype allergy, like antibody synthesis, can be induced only with difficulty and irregularly, and that the premature babies are no more deficient than the normal newborns. The data of Uhr et al. suggest further that the maturation of the capacity for delayed allergic response is completed during the first year of life. Although it is accepted that mothers do not regularly passively transfer tuberculin sensitivity to their babies, Schlange (1954) reported that tuberculin allergy could be passively transferred to human newborns by exchange transfusions from patients with positive tuberculin reactions. Warwick et d.(1960b), skeptical about the small size of the lesions reported by Schlange, restudied the question of transferability of tuberculin sensitivity to human newborns. Although exchange transfusion alone, peripheral leucocytes alone, exchange transfusion plus peripheral white blood cells, and peripheral white blood cells plus bone marrow cells from donors of known sensitivity were used, none of the neonatal recipients showed delayed reactivity. In separate and simultaneous experiments, passive transfers to immunologically mature recipients with peripheral white blood cells from sensitive donors were successful in most instances. These authors concluded that the human newborn, like the neonatal experimental animal, is defective with respect to the capacity to accept transfers of delayed hypersensitivity. In summary, it is apparent that certain difficulties, particularly focused about reactivity of the skin, make interpretation of experiments on the ontogeny of the delayed allergic response difficult. However, it seems likely that capacity for achievement and expression of delayed reactivity is present in late embryonic life in most species and that its development continues after birth. In all species studied the parallel with develop-
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
41
ment of antibody-producing capacity is close. Present knowledge is deficient, however, and based on woefully inadequate studies from the standpoint of the number of species and kinds of antigenic stimuli investigated, as well as design of critical experiments. It seems probable, considering the late development of this form of immunologic response suggested by current data, that the delayed allergic response would be subject to manipulation and control in late fetal life or the neonatal period. J. IMMUNOLOGIC DEVELOPMENT As STUDIED IN CELL TRANSFER
SYSTEMS 1. Studies of the Development of Immunologic Capacity Employing Transfer of Cells from Adults to Embyos and Newborn Animals Since immunologic competence develops progressively in late gestational life and in the neonatal period, as outlined in the foregoing sections, it seemed likely that important contributions to understanding of the immunologic deficiency of young animals might be made by study of the immunologic function of adult cells in the neonatal environment, on the one hand, and the function of neonatal cells in an adult environment, on the other. With these techniques, many investigators have contributed to understanding of immune processes; the extensive recent literature was recently ably reviewed by Cochrane and Dixon (1962) and need not concern us here. The studies attempting to utilize these transfer techniques to analyze the ontogenetic development of immunologic competence have, unfortunately, been contradictory. The earliest experiments addressing this problem, using rabbits, were presented by Dixon and Weigle (1957). Indeed, their findings appeared to provide a rational explanation for the deficiency of antibody production in neonatal rabbits. They found that sensitized lymphoid cells from adult donors failed to produce antibody in newborn recipients. The transferred cells appeared to survive, but did not undergo maturation toward plasma cells in the milieu provided by the neonatal rabbit. By contrast, after similar transfer of stimulated adult lymphoid cells to irradiated adult recipients, maturation to plasma cells occurred, and antibody was produced and released (Dixon and Weigle, 1957). These authors concluded that neonatal rabbits do not provide an adequate environment for synthesis of antibody by adult cells. These early studies suggested further that, once under way, synthesis of antibody by transferred adult cells could proceed quite well in the newborn rabbit. Early experiments based on transfer
42
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
of stimulated neonatal rabbit cells to adult rabbit recipients indicated that, in many instances, the neonatal cells functioned quite well in the adult environment ( Dixon and Weigle, 1959). Although studies by Nossal (1959a), using neonatal rats and Hall Institute mice, an outbred stock, seemed to support the observations of Dixon and Weigle ( 1957), neonatal C3H mice, a highly inbred line, appeared to support antibody production by syngeneic adult cells quite well. In the latter situation, the role of homograft immunity was eliminated. Observations by Sparck (1959) were consonant with the findings of Dkon’s group. Here, too, rabbits were employed, and its was found that cells stimulated 4-96 hours prior to transfer could produce antibody in the neonatal rabbit. Cells stimulated a shorter or longer time prior to transfer functioned poorly in the neonatal environment. Sparck concluded that the prime difEculty in the newborn was maintaining the adult cells in the neonatal environment long enough to get antibody synthesis started. Even in the earliest studies of this problem, Sterzl (1954) concluded that neonatal rabbits will support antibody synthesis by adult cells. He even presented evidence that nucleic acids derived from adult lymphoid cells might enable neonatal rabbits to respond more vigorously to antigenic stimulation than untreated animals (Sterzl and Hrubesova, 1956). Then Trnka ( 1958), studying antibody synthesis by isolated hen spleen cells injected into young chicks, concluded that extremely young animals, although feeble in their own immune response, will support antibody synthesis by adult mesenchymal cells. Sterzl ( 1958a,b) reconsidered the problem in the light of the data presented by Dixon and Weigle (1957), and suggested that the deficiency of the environment of the neonatal rabbit was probably a reflection of rejection of the transplanted cells by the neonate before they could make an adequate immune response. As evidence, he showed that adult lymphoid cells transferred to neonatal recipients could respond to delayed injections of antigen for only 3 to 4 days after transfer (Sterzl, 1958b). Sterzl (1958a,b, 1959a) and Sterzl and Rychlikova (1958) maintained that neonatal rabbits, whatever the immunologic deficiency characteristic of their age, had the capacity to exercise a homograft reaction. These findings were in keeping with the observation of Egdahl (1957) that skin transplants placed on rabbits several days before birth may already be in the process of rejection at birth. This problem was then approached by Sibal and Olson (1958) who
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
43
studied the capacity of adult chicken spleen cells inoculated onto the chorioallantoic membrane (CAM) of the chick embryo. These investigators found that injection of cells on the CAM with BSA, or injection of cells on the CAM following exposure to BSA, resulted in no antibody formation. By contrast, spleen cells taken from adult animals and stimulated with BSA 36-48 hours before injection on the CAM produced antibody. Spleen cells taken 7 days after stimulation with antigen again produced no antibody when injected on the CAM. Here again, there seemed to be evidence that ongoing synthesis of antibody might be supported by the embryonic environment but that initiation of antibody synthesis in this environment is difficult. Trnka and Riha (1959), in similar studies, showed that adult chicken spleen cells stimulated in vitro with either bacterial or protein antigens produced excellent antibody responses when injected onto the CAM of the developing chick embryo. The antibody response in the 18-day chick embryo was much greater than that produced by adult cells similarly stimulated and administered to 2-day-old chicks. These investigators concluded that a primary antibody response by adult cells can be made to proceed in embryos, and vigorously supported the concept of Sterzl (1958a,b) that the only deficiency of the neonatal milieu is the homograft reaction of which many neonatal animals are capable. Returning to studies in neonatal rabbits, Holub and Riha (1960) transferred adult rabbit spleen cells to newborns, but placed the cells in millipore chambers to protect them from the homograft reaction of the neonatal recipient. In these experiments they obtained primary responses of the adult cells to both bacterial and soluble protein antigens; however, the evidence for the primary response was not good, the antibody appearing very late and only in chamber fluids. In further studies in the chicken, Sterzl and Trnka (1959a) carried out experiments in 2-day-old chicks comparable to those carried out earlier in rabbits by Sterzl (1958b). They found that adult chicken spleen cells remain responsive in the newly hatched chick for a very short time, even shorter than that of adult rabbit cells in the newborn rabbit. Dixon and Weigle (1959) reasoned that if the homograft reaction were to account for the inadequacy of the neonatal rabbit in supporting production of antibody by transferred adult cells, the neonatal rabbit must be more vigorous in exercising homograft rejection than is the adult. The studies of Najarian and Dixon (1962)seem to indicate that this may, indeed, be the case. In their comparison of rejection time for skin homografts in neonates and adults, they showed the neonates rejected the skin
44
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
in 8-7 days, and the adults in 8-9 days. By the fourth day there was good microscopic evidence of rejection in the neonate. Barnett and Grey (1962)found that irradiation of neonatal rabbits interfered with homograft rejection and fostered antibody synthesis by transferred adult cells in the neonatal environment. Grey (1962) reported, however, that antibody formed by adult cells in the neonatal environment was qualitatively different from that formed by adult cells transferred to other adults. Mark and Dixon (1963) compared antibody synthesis in syngeneic and allogeneic neonatal mice. Using soluble protein antigens as the stimulus, they showed clearly that syngeneic newborn mice will foster immunologic function of transferred adult spleen cells although not to as complete a degree as adults, whereas allogeneic neonatal mice will not do so. Studies by T. N. Harris et al. (1962)also indicated that the neonatal rabbit supports antibody synthesis by transferred adult cells but to a lesser degree than adult recipients. They concluded that either the homograft reaction of the neonate is better than that of the adult, or the transferred cells were able to get an antibody response under way faster in the adult than in the newborn. Harris et a2. also found that, when transfers were made to the neonate, a greater antigenic stimulus to the adult cells was required to invoke an immune response. In further studies, S. Harris et al. (1962) compared the homograft reaction to injected leucocytes in newborn and adult rabbits. They showed that administration of leucocytes in the neonatal period produces immunization resulting in rejection of donor leucocytes and inhibition of formation of antibody by transferred cells, It was of significance, however, that circulating antibody did not seem to be involved in this response of the neonate, in contrast to the role of antibody in adult animals similarly stimulated. Thus, serum from rabbits given spleen cells in adult life readily transferred immunity to spleen cells, but such transfer was not possible with serum from animals injected with leucocytes in the neonatal period. Cellular transfer was effective, however. We conclude, then, from this group of studies that the neonatal tissues will support antibody production by adult cells, probably somewhat less efficiently than the adult environment, but that the capacity for homograft rejection, often quite well developed in newly hatched or newly born animals, is of sufficient vigor to interfere with immunologic function of allogeneic adult lymphoid cells. Consequently, studies employing transfers of functioning lymphoid cells to neonates should take this reaction into account.
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
45
2. Anulysis of Ontogenesis of Immunity by Studies of Transfer of Neonatal Cells to Adult Recipients In the early work of Dixon and Weigle (1959), as cited above, lymphoid cells from neonatal donors, stimulated with antigen in uitro and injected into adults, produced a respectable immune response in many instances. By using neonatal cells stimulated with bacterial antigens before transfer to adult rabbits, S. Harris et aZ. (1962) also observed an antibody response, but a much less vigorous one than that formed by adult cells under the same circumstances. Indeed, in one study (S. Harris et al., 1961) it was reported that the stimulated neonatal rabbit cells were not capable of significant antibody synthesis upon injection into an adult environment until the donor rabbits had reached 1 month of age. Makinodan and Peterson (1962) studied antibody formation by transferred spleen cells in mice as a function of age of the donor. Using an in uiuo culture model presented by 12-week-old syngeneic mice treated with 800 r total body irradiation, they compared antibody formation of spleen cells of donor mice between the ages of l week and 29 months. In these studies they were able to demonstrate a gross deficiency of lymphoid cells from mice sacrificed at 1 week of age. Indeed, at this age the amount of antibody produced was approximately 1% of the levels reached at immunologic maturity. They found that the immunologic capacity of these cells increased rapidly between 1 week and 1 month of age and that it continued to increase until the donors were 8 months old. Following this peak, immunologic capacity decreased to the end of the observation period, 29 months. Although the most rapid development of immunologic capacity occurred during the first month of life, it is of interest that, in this test system, the spleen cells of %monthold mice were only capable of one-third the response of cells of 8-monthold donors. In a recent review of the earIier observations from his laboratory, coupled with a reassessment of the problem, Sterzl (1963) has presented observations, now confirmed in many quarters (Mitchison, 1957; Papermaster et al., 1959, 1962a; Nossal, 1959a; T. N. Harris et al., 1959, 1962), that neonatal or newly hatched animals can support antibody synthesis well enough to permit study of the problem. With this model, he found that, in rabbits, the peripheral lymphoid cells are deficient immunologically during the first few weeks of life, as revealed by transfer studies employing newborn rabbits as recipients. By the time donors are 30 days of age, the lymphoid cells of rabbits are capable of vigorous immunologic
46
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
response even when placed, following stimulation, in the neonatal environment. We would conclude from these observations that much more extensive study, using appropriate cell transfer systems, especially those employing irradiated inbred animals, might clarify the controversy which exists and, more importantly, supply critical information on the development of the immunologic capacity of the lymphoid cells through life. The limited data now available demonstrate that, in one strain of mice at least, the immunologic capabilities of the peripheral lymphoid tissues and the lymphoid cells may increase for a very long period of time-far beyond the neonatal period. Recent studies in mice by Dalmasso et al. ( 1963,1964),employing the Simonsen graft-versus-host reaction ( a homotransplant reaction) as an assay system (Cock and Simonsen, 1958), seem to support these observations of Makinodan and Peterson (1962). In this system, too, development of immunologic capacity of the peripheral lymphoid tissue was shown to proceed far beyond the immediate neonatal period. The development of the peripheral lymphoid tissues was shown by the study of Dalmasso et al. (1963) to be dependent upon the thymus. Removal of the thymus in the neonatal period or at 6, 14, 25, or 35 days of age appeared to arrest the development of the lymphoid tissue at the stage reached when thymectomy was carried out. The rabbit, too, appears to show at least some degree of development of the immunologic capacity of its peripheral lymphoid cells during the early weeks of life. Whether the development of the immunologic capabilities of peripheral lymphoid cells in early life is primarily a result of increased cellularity of the peripheral lymphoid tissues or of maturation of the capacity of the individual cells themselves needs to be studied critically.
K. IMMUNOLOGIC TOLERANCE IN RELATIONTO DEVELOPMENT OF FULL IMMUNOLOGIC CAPACITY An additional way to view the ontogeny of immunity is to consider it in terms of susceptibility to production of specific immunologic negativity. This phenomenon, commonly referred to as immunologic tolerance, had its origin in the observations of Owen (1945) and Owen et al. (1946) that fraternal twin cattle often have two blood types-their own and that of their fraternal twin. From this most provocative experiment of nature, Owen reasoned that fraternal twin cattle, frequently synchorial (Lillie, 1917) had exchanged their unique blood cell precursors during fetal life, and that each had accepted these precursors as functioning homovital grafts which produced red blood cells for a prolonged period
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
47
in postnatal life. D. Anderson et at. (1951) and Billingham et al. (1952) showed further that these chimeric fraternal twins will accept skin grafts from one another, although they are fully capable of rejecting grafts from both parents and from siblings of separate birth. Reasoning from the observations of Owen (1945) and Owen et al. (1946), and from the finding of Traub (1935a,b, 1936a,b,c, 1938, 1939) that intrauterine infection with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus renders mice incapable of later immunologic response to the virus, Bumet and Fenner (1949) postulated that antigen administered during embryonic life might thereafter be considered as “self” and thus incapable of giving rise to a positive immune response in such a conditioned host. The initial experimental attempts to test this hypothesis in the chicken embryo yielded negative results (Bumet et al., 1950). In 1953, Billingham et al. showed, in their classical experiment, that immunologic tolerance of homografts in inbred mice can be produced by injection of cells from the prospective donor strain into the prospective recipients during late fetal life. During recent years, the phenomenon of immunologic tolerance has been studied most extensively and has been the subject of a number of most provocative reviews (Billingham and Brent, 1959; Billingham et al., 1956; Brent, 1958; Chase, 1959; Lawrence, 1959; Woodruff, 1960; Mitchison, 1961; Haiek et al., 1961). Indeed, an entire volume devoted to expression of the present state of knowledge of immunologic tolerance has recently been published (HaXek et al., 1962). Tolerance, or as we prefer to consider the phenomenon “specific immunologic negativity,” can be produced not only with living cells of prospective donors of tissue homografts, but by simple defined protein antigens (Cinader and Dubert, 1955, 1956; Dixon and Maurer, 1955; Hanan and Oyama, 1954; Wolfe et al., 1957; R. T. Smith and Bridges, 1958; Tempelis et al., 1958; Terres and Hughes, 1959; Dresser, 1961); bacteria and bacterial products (Felton and Ottinger, 1942; Felton, 1949; Buxton, 1954; Felton et al., 1955a,b; Friedman and Gaby, 1960; Gowland and Oakley, 1960; Weiss and Main, 1962); viruses (R. J. C. Harris and Simons, 1958; Hotchin and Weigand, 1961); and parasites (Kerr and Robertson, 1954). This phenomenon has been produced in many different species and certainly occurs in man as well (Woodruff, 1957; Woodruff and Lennox, 1959; Good, 1957b, 1960; Fowler et al., 1980; Albert et al., 1959; Lejeune, 1962). Although immunologic tolerance at first seemed to be interpretable in terms of Burnet’s postulate, further study has indicated that susceptibility to tolerance induction varies greatly from species to species (Woodruff
48
ROBERT A. GOOD AM) BEN W. PAPERMASTER
and Simpson, 1955) and from strain to strain (Billingham and Brent, 1957; Martinez et al., 1958), and that it is also, in part, a function of the nature and quantity of the antigen (reviewed by R. T. Smith, 1961 and Halek d al., 1961). Initially, a “tolerance responsive period” was proposed (Billingham et al., 1956; Billingham and Brent, 1959). However, it became clear, particularly from work with defined antigenic systems (R. T. Smith and Bridges, 1958), that production of tolerance is, at least to some degree, dependent on dosage of antigen administered over a rather extended period around the time of birth. Further studies by Dixon and Maurer ( 1955), by Johnson et al. ( 1955), by our own group with a variety of systems (Condie et al., 1957; Aust et al., 1957, 1960; Mariani et al.,1959, 1960a,b; Martinez et al., 1959, 1960a,b, 1963a,b; Shapiro et al.,1961; LaPlante et al.,1962; Forsen and Condie, 1963), and by Simonsen ( 1960) indicated that specific immunologic negativity, tolerance if you will, can be produced not only in the newborn but through adult life. This concept and its experimental support, deriving both from work in our own laboratory and that of others, using techniques of persistent antigen overloading (Condie et al., 1957; Mariani et al., 1959, 1960a,b; Shapiro et al.,1961; Brent and Gowland, 1962; Wigzell, 1962; Martinez et al., 1963a,b; HaBek, 1963), parabiosis (B. A. Rubin, 1959; Mariani et al., 1959, 1960a,b; Martinez, 1960a,b; Naki6 and SilobrEi6, 1958; Naki6 et al., 1960; Skowron-Cendrzak and Konieczna-Marczynska, 1959; Edgerton and Morrell, 1961; Hardin and Werder, 1961; E. Jensen and Simonsen, 1962), or administration of antigen by unusual routes (Battisto and Miller, 1962) or in special form (Dresser, 1962), now establish beyond reasonable doubt that a state entirely comparable to classical immunologic tolerance can be produced during adult life in several species. Indeed, the long-lasting tolerance produced by neonatal allogeneic cell injection in mice may be a function of tolerance of host antigens induced in the injected adult cells (Martinez et al., 1962d). The “tolerance responsive period has proved to be a variable one, depending upon the tolerance-inducing stimulus, an observation quite compatible with findings indicating that the vigor of the immunologic response develops gradually in late gestation and in early neonatal period in certain mammalian species and that its evocation in the early period depends in large measure on the nature of the stimulus. Viewing the phenomenon of immunologic tolerance in terms of the development of the lymphoreticular system and immunologic responsiveness, the most reasonable thesis seems to be that specific immunologic negativity is not a phenomenon peculiar to embryologic development or
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
49
neonatal life, as was originally postulated, but a phenomenon that can be produced at any time during life, and is inversely related to the state of development of the lymphoid tissue (see Section 11, G of this review, and Archer et al., 1964) and directly related to the dose of antigen administered (R. T. Smith and Bridges, 1958; Mariani et d., 1959). It is also, in a manner as yet unknown, a function of the quality of the antigenic material employed (Dresser, 1962) and possibly even a function of the route of administration of the antigen or hapten (Battisto and Miller, 1962). A corollary is that the relative ease of induction of specific immunologic negativity during embryonic life and the neonatal period is a reflection of the relatively poor development of the lymphoreticular mass at this stage of life and the consequent inadequacy of the positive adaptation to antigenic stimulation, i.e., antibody production and graft rejection. Thus, it is attractive to consider immunologic tolerance as an example of a general phenomenon, specific immunologic negativity, which must ultimately be based on the same mechanisms as those responsible for Felton’s immunologic paralysis (Felton and Ottinger, 1942; Felton, 1949; Felton et al., 1955a,b), now known to be a central failure of immune response (Sercarz and Coons, 1959; Gitlin et al., 1958), and the immunologic failure (Chase, 1946) produced by feeding haptenic materials to guinea pigs. Predictable from this view as well would be the observations which establish that manipulations such as X-irradiation (Main and Prehn, 1955; Trentin, 1956) and treatment with 6-mercaptopurine (Sclbwartz and Dameshek, 1959; LaPlante et al., 1962; Forsen and Condie, 1963) facilitate production of specific negativity during adult life by bringing about a regression toward the fetal or neonatal state of relative inadequacy of the lymphoreticular system of cells and consequent inadequacy of positive immune response. In summary, then, it is relatively easy during gestation and early postnatal life to overload the lymphoreticular system with antigen and produce tolerance. With further development of the peripheral lymphoid tissue and the growing capacity for positive immunologic adaptation by t h i s system of cells, it becomes more difficult-but not impossible-to produce a specific negative adjustment to antigenic exposure.
L. ROLEOF
THE THYMUS AND BURSAOF FABRICIUS IN ONTOGENESIS ADAPTIVEIMMUNITY Until a few years ago two of the most enigmatic organs in experimental biology were the bursa of Fabricius of birds and the mammalian thymus. Studies of the bursa had suggested that it participated in some endocrinologic relationships ( reviewed by Glick, 1964); similar sugges-
OF
50
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
tions had been made for the thymus on the basis of experimental findings (Gyllensten, 1953; Ehrich and Seifter, 1948) and clinical links to thyroid disease and conditions involving adrenal-pituitary dysfunction (reviewed by Fisher, 1964). The mouse thymus was known to be the site of development of many leukemias, and in 1944 it had been shown that removal of the thymus at the appropriate time sharply reduced the incidence of such leukemias ( McEndy et al., 1944). An increasing number of studies had linked the mammalian thymus to lymphocytopoiesis: Metcalf ( 1956) had prepared a lymphocytosis-stimulating factor from thymus which was an effective stimulus to lymphocyte production in baby mice, and Schooley and Kelly ( 1964), Bierring ( 1960), Metcalf (1960), Yoffey (1957)) and others had demonstrated that thymectomy of adult animals depressed lymphocyte levels in thoracic duct lymph and circulating blood, and reduced the weight of peripheral lymphoid organs. Fichtelius (1953, 1958), in a series of experiments with PS2 labeling, had suggested that thymocytes were involved in immunologic processes. The thesis of an immunologic function of the thymus was not new; this had been advanced repeatedly by such investigators as Hammar (1938) and T. N. Harris et al. (1948), but their extirpation experiments in young or adult animals showed no significant effect on antibody production. Two developments in the early 1950’s set the stage for a renewed experimental attack on the problem of the thymus. The first of these was the finding, in 1953, that a patient with acquired agammaglobulinemia had developed a thymoma at about the time of onset of his clinical disease (Good, 1954; Good and Varco, 1955; MacLean et al., 1956, 1957). This was considered by Good (1954) to be a highly provocative linking of two very rare conditions, and it prompted further pursuit of a link between the thymus and immunologic function. In experiments involving thymectomy of young rabbits and subsequent stimulation with BSA, no effect could be demonstrated ( MacLean et al., 1958, 1957). The second development occurred in 1954, when the bursa of Fabricius was linked to antibody production in the chicken by the serendipitous discovery of Glick and associates (Glick et al., 1956; Glick, 1958; Chang et al., 1957, 1958). Their studies established that when the bursa was excised during the first 2 weeks after hatching, the birds were deficient antibody producers in adult life. At the University of Wisconsin, a second group of investigators was engaged in endocrinologic studies which ultimately led to the first experiments on neonatal thymectomy in mammals. Meyer et al. (1959) had been studying the effects of administration of various hormones during egg incubation on the development of the bursa of Fabricius. They had found that with appropriate dosage
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
51
of 19-nortestosterone before the lymphoid development of the bursa began, they could arrest this development. A. P. Mueller et d. (1960) studied the antibody responses of chickens treated with 19-nortestosterone on the fifth day of incubation, and found that their antibody response was even more severely affected than that of surgically bursectomized birds. These findings were confirmed by Papermaster et al. (1962a,b), who also showed that hormonal bursectomy of the host greatly enhanced the graft-versus-host activity of injected adult homologous cells, and permitted allogeneic adult spleen cells to function more effectively in antibody synthesis in hormonally bursectomized recipients than in controls. The resemblance of the bursa to the thymus has been noted repeatedly; the bursa has been called the cloaca1 thymus. The studies of Glick and of the Wisconsin group showed clearly that antibody production is affected only if the bursa is removed early in life, and A. P. Mueller et al. (1960) suggested that neonatal thymectomy might reveal a parallel in the mammal. Three entirely independent groups of experiments showed that neonatal thymectomy has a significant effect on immunologic reactivity: ( 1 )the studies by Fichtelius et al. (1961) in young guinea pigs; ( 2 ) the experiments of Archer, Martinez, Good, Papermaster, and associates in rabbits (Archer and Pierce, 1961; Archer et al., 1962; Good et al., 1962b) and mice (Good, 1961; Martinez et al., 1962a,b; Dalmasso et al., 1962b; Good et al., 196213); and ( 3 ) the studies by J. F. A. P. Miller (1961, 1962a,b, 1963, 1964). In rabbits, the effect of neonatal thymectomy on antibody production is variable both from animal to animal and antigen to antigen (Archer et al., 1962); in guinea pigs, relatively mature animals at birth, the depression of antibody response is slight but significant (Fichtelius et al., 1961); but in the mouse transplantation immunity is sufficiently affected by neonatal thymectomy to permit skin transplants across the H-2 histocompatibility barrier and even across species barriers in some instances, and antibody production to certain antigens is almost entirely eliminated (Martinez et al., 1962a,b; Papermaster et al., 1962d; J. F. A. P. Miller, 1962a,b). Parrott and East (1964) have shown clearly that the effect on antibody production is a quantitative one, and that with such potent antigens as hemocyanin and pneumococcal polysaccharides, many of the neonatally thymectomized mice produced significant amounts of antibody. As a matter of fact with these antigens antibody synthesis was almost as good as in control mice. M. Hess et al. (1963) used tetanus toxoid in recent studies; the effects of neonatal thymectomy were noted in the primary response, but were much more evident in the secondary response.
52
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
Neonatally thymectomized mice are particularly vulnerable to homologous disease when injected with parent strain lymphoid cells (Parrott, 1962; Martinez et al., 1962~).Their lymphoid tissues show minimal lymphoid development and their circulating lymphocyte levels are greatly reduced, although most strains have adequate levels of y-globulin and appreciable, if not entirely normal, numbers of plasma cells. The cells of spleen and lymph nodes of neonatally thymectomized mice are very low in immunologic activity, evident when cell suspensions of these tissues are injected into F1 hybrid recipients; splenomegaly and other manifestations of graft-versus-host reactivity are not evident unless the dosage of cells is multiplied several times (Dalmasso et al., 1962a, 1963, 1964; J. F. A. P. Miller, 1964). The experimental evidence to date is consistent with the thesis that the mouse has one primary central lymphoid organ, the thymus, and that this is a key source of cells or humoral substances, or both, necessary to normal maturation of the peripheral lymphoid tissues and to normal development of immunologic capabilities. As indicated in the section on the ontogeny of the lymphoid tissues, the newborn mouse has no detectable organized lymphoid cells in spleen or lymph nodes; however, the fact that the neonatally thymectomized mouse retains a small measure of immunologic reactivity suggests that the thymus' influence on immunologic development may already have been exercised to some extent before birth. As will be indicated shortly, studies on the effect of thymectomy in young but not newborn mice indicates that, in this species, birth is a point on a continuum of thymus-dependent immunologic development, a continuum which extends back to the embryonic period and extends well into young adult life. Thus, in the mouse, the effect of thymectomy varies with both the time of thymectomy and the nature of the challenge to the animal's immunologic capabilities. This is well illustrated in the skin homografting and immunologic runting models. In early studies, Martinez et al. (1962a) demonstrated not only the profound effects of neonatal thymectomy on transplantation immunity but also the effects of thymectomy as late as 30 days of age on the response to skin grafts when donor and host differed at certain non-H-2 histocompatibility loci. This was true when Ce skin was grafted on C,H recipients, for example. When tumor tissue was used as the transplant, DBA/2 mice thymectomized as late as 40 days of age accepted a Balb/C multiple myeloma tumor that was rejected by sham-operated animals of the same age (Martinez et al., 1964). Thymectomy at 40 days of age also affected the susceptibility of certain F1 hybrids to runt disease following injection of parental strain spleen cells (Martinez et d.,1962c; Good et al., 1962b).
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
53
A series of studies by Dalmasso et d.(1983,1964) demonstrates graphically that the thymic contribution to the development of immunologic reactivity in the mouse continues beyond 35 days of age, and that the degree of immunologic capability is correlated with age at thymectomy. They demonstrate, too, that animals thymectomized during this early period suffer a kind of immunologic arrest: their immunologic status remains roughly at the stage of development it had reached by the time of thymectomy, and they neither “catch up” to animals thymectomized at later ages or normal animals, nor show significant regression. The model used was the spleen assay of graft-versus-host reaction in Fl hybrid recipients of spleen cells from parent strain animals that had been thymectomized at 1, 6, 14, 25, or 35 days of age, and sacrificed 2 or 6 months later. For comparison, animals of the same hybrid strain received parental strain cells from animals sacrificed at 14 and 35 days of age, and at 2-3 months. Some recipients of cells from donors thymectomized at 14 days of age showed slight splenomegaly. Those given cells from the 25-day group had a higher incidence of graft-versus-host response and had larger spleens. Recipients of cells from parent strain donors thymectomized at 35 days all showed splenomegaly, again with an appreciable increase in the average spleen weight over the %day group; the activity of these cells was still much less than that of cells from normal 2-3-month-old donors. When the graft-versus-host activity of cells from normal 14- and 35-day-old donors is compared with that of cells from 2%- to 3-month-old donors thymectomized at 14 and 35 days, the parallel is striking. Speculation on the reason for immunologic failure following neonatal thymectomy has centered on the thymus as a source of cells or humoral factors essential to normal lymphoid development and immunologic maturation. Although until recently the evidence for egress of lymphoid cells from the thymus had been indirect, a recent study by Nossal and Gorrie (1964) provides direct evidence that such emigration does occur. They labeled thymic cells directly in situ with tritiated thymidine without labeling other lymphoid organs, and showed that small numbers of labeled cells gradually appeared in the mesenteric lymph nodes. However, the quantity of cells distributed from the thymus is very small in adult guinea pigs, and only 5 to 10 times as great in the neonatal guinea pig (Nossal, 1964). In light of the extensive proliferation that characterizes the thymus, it is clear that many cells must both arise in the thymus and be destroyed there. The recent work of J. E. Harris et al. (1964) seems to establish that bone marrow lymphocytes enter the thymus and may ultimately leave the organ. Sainte-Marie and Leblond (1964) have presented substantial evidence that thymus cells gain the peripheral
54
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
blood. Other evidence of dispersion of thymic cells to peripheral lymphoid tissues is found in the studies of J. F. A. P. Miller (1962a) and of Dalmasso et at. (1963, 1984). Miller thymectomized newborn (Ak x T6)F1mice, and 2 days later grafted them subcutaneously with homologous thymus tissue; he showed, using the T6 marker, that cells of the thymus donor strain appeared in the spleen, although they were in all instances in the minority. Dalmasso et al. (1963, 1964) have reported similar findings, using the graft-versus-host capabilities of the peripheral lymphoid cells of the thymus-grafted animals in appropriate F1hosts as the criterion of the relative proportions of donor and host cells in the chimera. Both donor and host type cells were found in the spleen, but the host cells predominated. Reconstitution of immunologic capacity of neonatally thymectomized mice has been approached by J. F. A. P. Miller (1962a, 1983, 1984), by Parrott and East (1964), and by Dalmasso et al. (1963), with some variability in results. J. F. A. P. Miller (1982a) has reconstituted immunologic capacity of neonatally thymectomized mice by subcutaneous grafting of homologous thymus tissue from newborn donors during the first 3 weeks of life. He also restored 10-week-old neonatally thymectomized mice bearing skin grafts with isologous lymphoid cells from 8week-old donors presensitized against the strain of the graft donor. Restoration is defined in terms of a second-set homograft response to skin from the same strain as the original graft donor; when cells from nonsensitized donors were used the results were equivocal (J. F. A. P. Miller et al., 1962). In a later report J. F. A. P. Miller (1963) indicated that he had been able to restore neonatally thymectomized mice to the point of an adequate homograft response with lymphoid cells. Parrott and East (1964) used prevention of wasting disease as the criterion of restoration, and did this in neonatally thymectomized mice grafted in the kidney capsule at 12-15 days of age with whole thymus glands. They also prevented wasting disease with isologous spleen cells administered intravenously 1-2 days after thymectomy. Subcutaneous thymus grafts were not effective in preventing wasting disease in their animals. In the studies of Dalmasso et al. (1963) several regimens were used. All efforts to restore immunologic activity with cell-free preparations failed. Effects of cell administration were evaluated by three criteria: long-term survival (most neonatally thymectomized mice are short-lived), rejection of skin homografts, and immunologic activity of peripheral lymphoid tissues as assessed by graft-versus-host reactions in appropriate hybrid recipients. All the regimens, whether spleen or thymus cells were administered, increased the life span of the animals. Only adult spleen cells restored the homograft response: this was effective whether
ONTOGENY A N D PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
55
the cells were administered intraperitoneally at 2 days of age or intravenously at 40 days of age. With respect to restoring immunologic competence of spleen cells in the graft-versus-host model, intravenous injection of 100 million adult spleen cells in the neonatally thymectomized animal at 40 days of age was most effective. Intraperitoneal injection at 2 days of age of 10 million adult spleen cells had a definite effect, although it was less consistent than that observed in the older recipients. The inference drawn from these studies, showing that immunologic function can be restored in neonatally thymectomized mice by isologous spleen cells-not thymus cells-from immunologically mature donors is that the immunologic defect of neonatally thymectomized mice involves primarily a lack of cells. The thymic contribution is not thus explained, however, since the studies with neonatally thymectomized mice bearing thymus homografts have indicated that host cells predominate in the peripheral lymphoid tissues and that cells of the thymus-donor strain constitute a significant minority of such cells. The results cited above, involving a large measure of immunologic restoration with peripheral lymphoid cells in the complete absence of a thymus, suggest that the effect of the homologous thymus on proliferation of host cells is mediated by cells from the thymus graft. Recently, Yunis et al. (1964) have succeeded in reconstituting neonatally thymectomized mice completely from the standpoints of growth potential, immunologic capacity, and longevity, by injection of a sufficiently large number of adult syngeneic spleen or adult syngeneic thymus cells, again pointing to the essential defect in the lymphoid cells of the neonatally thymectomized mice. Further, Hilgard et al. (1964) have shown that injection of a sufficiently large number of spleen or adult thymus cells will even reverse the wasting process, whereas transplantation of whole thymuses from either newborn or older donors will not. Recently, however, Levey et al. (1963) and Osoba and Miller (1963, 1964) presented evidence arguing strongly for a humoral or preferably hormonal effect of the thymus on the development of the lymphoid tissues. These investigators placed immature syngeneic mouse thymuses in cell-tight millipore chambers implanted intraperitoneally in neonatally thymectomized mice, and showed that such treatment would permit the development of the lymphoid structure and its immunologic potential. These observations argue strongly for a hormonal effect produced by the thymus, in confirmation of the prior experiments of J. F. A. P. Miller ( 1962a) and Dalmasso et d. (1963). These findings do not, however, exclude the possibility that the thymus may function, especially early in embryonic life, as a source of lymphoid cells seeding the other, more peripheral lymphoid tissues. In two other species, the chicken and the rabbit, the thymus is the
56
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
first organ to become lymphoid (as it is in all species that have been studied carefully from this point of view) ; however, both apparently have a second central lymphoid organ which contributes significantly to immunologic development (Archer et al., 1963b; Warner and Szenberg, 1982). These relationships have been discussed in the section on the ontogeny of lymphoid tissues. In both of these species, there is evidence of recovery from the immunologic depression induced by bursectomy in the chicken (A. P. Mueller et d.,1964) and thymectomy in the rabbit (Archer et al., 196313). Mueller et al. (1964) have emphasized that the latest primary antigenic stimulation in their bursectomized chickens was given at 22 weeks. Secondary stimulation at 34 weeks in animals not responding at 22 weeks resulted in significant antibody production. They have also documented late acquisition of rabbit hemagglutinins in neonatally bursectomized chickens, and have postulated a degree of recovery from the effects of bursectomy. It has not been possible, although extensive efforts in this direction have been made by Aspinall and Meyer (1964) and by Warner and Szenberg (1964) to interfere with development of the chick thymus during the embryonic period without affecting the bursa. However, data from both of these laboratories indicate that neonatal thymectomy of the chicken produces a defect in homograft immunity without affecting antibody production significantly (Aspinall and Meyer, 1964; Szenberg and Warner, 1962; Warner and Szenberg, 1962, 1984; Warner et al., 1962). In the rabbit, the thymus is sometimes but not always the only lymphoid organ at birth, and Archer et al. (1984) originally postulated that the variable effect of neonatal thymectomy on antibody production reflected the degree of “peripheralization” of lymphoid tissues at the time the thymus was removed. As indicated in the section on the ontogeny of the lymphoid tissues, more recent studies suggest that the rabbit has a second central lymphoid organ, the appendix, whose development is, to a degree at least, independent of the thymus. The postulate of Archer et al. (1963b) is that removal of both the thymus and the appendix of the rabbit in the neonatal period would result in more profound depression of immunologic reactivity than that observed as a result of thymectomy alone. There are two animals that present unique opportunities for study of the role of the thymus in immunologic development. One is the opossum, born after only 1213 days of gestation and completely lacking in lymphoid development at birth. Kalmutz (1962) has shown that here again the thymus is the first organ to become lymphoid, and that until this
ONTOGENY A N D PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
57
development occurs there is nothing approaching immunologic reactivity. He showed, too, that some degree of immune response is possible before the peripheral lymphoid tissues develop. Recent studies by Block (1964) show clearly that the thymus is the first lymphoid organ in the opossum, followed in turn by development of central lymph nodes and then spleen. He correlates development of immunologic potential with development of the lymphoid tissue, beginning with the thymus, in this animal. The hamster also presents an unusual model: hamsters thymectomized in the neonatal period have, in the studies of J. D. Sherman and Dameshek (1963, 1964), been y-globulin and plasma cell deficient. Defendi et al. (1964) noted unusual susceptibility to tumor development in thymectomized hamsters receiving polyoma viruses, and preliminary reports by J. D. Sherman et al. (1963) and Roosa et al. (1963) indicate that neonatally thymectomized hamsters are very deficient immunologically. Neonatally thymectomized rats have been studied extensively by Waksman et al. (1962), Arnason et a2. (1962a), and Jankovib et al. (1962), and the status of their transplantation immunity has been investigated by Defendi et d. (1964). Arnason et al. (1962,b) have emphasized the suppression of delayed allergic responses in these animals, but have demonstrated significant deficiencies of antibody production, Arthus reactivity, and homograft response. In general, the effects were less profound than those observed in mice. The rat is similar to the mouse in that the thymus is usually the only lymphoid organ at birth (Archer et al., 1963a, 1964).Whether the results documented by Waksman et a2. and by Defendi et al. reflect incomplete thymectomy, or a degree of “peripheralization” at birth not evident histologically, or the presence of thymusindependent lymphoid tissue which develops after birth, is not known. The dog has been studied by Kelly ( 1963) : in this species the thymus is lymphoid early, and the spleen and lymph nodes are also lymphoid well before birth. Neonatal thymectomy has little effect on the antibody response of the dog. In man, the best data also indicate that the thymus is the first lymphoid organ to develop (Hammar, 1905; Knoll, 1929), followed in turn by the primary central lymph nodes, spleen, peripheral lymph nodes, and gut, as in the dog. However, the human fetus shows peripheralization of the lymphoid tissue long before birth. In summary, of the animals studied so far, the mouse typifies the dependence of immunologic development-structural and functionalon the presence of the thymus during the first weeks of life. The development is a continuum extending back before birth and continuing to 40 days of age and beyond, and the effect of thymectomy at various times
58
ROBERT A. GOOD A N D BEN W. PAPERMASTER
during this period depends on the immunologic response tested and the intensity of the stimulus, In the chicken, the bursa of Fabricius and the thymus are both related to the maturation of immunologic capabilities, the bursa affecting primarily antibody production and perhaps some forms of transplantation immunity, and the thymus affecting primarily the homograft response. In the rabbit, removal of the thymus in the newborn period affects antibody production to a variable degree and has no effect on skin homograft rejection. In both the chicken and the rabbit there seems to be a degree of immunologic recovery, most clearly documented in the rabbit; the mechanism of this recovery has not been delineated, but in the rabbit it has been proposed that the thymus-independent lymphoid tissue of the appendix exercises a function similar to that of the thymus in restoring lymphoid tissues and lymphocyte levels, and presumably immunologic function. Less is known about the degree of independence or interrelationship of the chicken thymus and bursa of Fabricius, but it may well be that the thymus ultimately compensates in part for the loss of the bursa, a development which occurs relatively late in the chicken. There are several clinical observations which serve to underline the importance of a functional thymus to immunologic development in man as well. A small group of patients has been reported who are immunologically deficient: not only hypogammaglobulinemic but lymphopenic as well. Unlike patients with classical agammaglobulinemia and hypogammaglobulinemia, whose thymus is relatively normal (Good et al., 1964a), a number of these patients have had vestigial thymus tissue weighing less than a gram in most instances, and almost completely lacking in lymphoid cells (Good et al., 1964a; Tobler and Cottier, 1958; Hitzig et al., 1958). It is of interest that, in several of these patients, the thymus was not only very small and very deficient in lymphoid development, but showed a failure of descensus. Thus, a true failure of development of the epithelial anlagen of the thymus can be postulated to lie behind the failure of development of the peripheral lymphoid tissues in these children. These patients have been unusually susceptible not only to bacterial infections, the major threat to the classical agammaglobulinemic patients, but also to viral and fungal diseases. One of these children, reported by Rosen et al. (1962) was grafted with thymus tissue, but in the 40 days before the child's death there was no restoration of lymphocyte levels or immunologic function. He had a deficient homograft response. There is another possible link of thymic deficiency to immunologic inadequacy in the human being. Ataxia-telangiectasia is a disease of chil-
ONTOGENY A N D PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
59
dren, characterized principally by neurologic abnormalities, but accompanied by unusual susceptibility to infection of the sinuses and lungs in most of the patients (Boder and Sedgwick, 1958). It has recently been discovered that about one-third of these patients have definable deficiencies of the immunoglobulins (Peterson et al., 1963). One patient (Peterson et al., 1963) has a very deficient antibody response, a failure of delayed allergy, and an abnormal homograft response. Interestingly, in the single post mortem mentioning the thymus at all, this organ was reported to be lacking (Boder and Sedgwick, 1958). In two additional cases of ataxia telangiectasia (Lemli, 1963; Bowden, 1963) the thymus could not be found on post-mortem examination. The initial observation that acquired agammaglobulinemia and thymic abnormality were associated has gained support over the last few years: there are now 8 cases to our knowledge (Good, 1954; C. M. Martin et al., 1956; Ramos, 1956; Lambie et al., 1957; Gafni et al., 1960; Wollheim and Waldenstrom, 1962; Rotstein and Good, 1961 ). Although the classical agammaglobulinemia of Bruton appears at this writing to be a peripheral immunologic failure, it is suggested that at least some hypogammaglobulinemia-lymphopeniapatients ( so-called Swiss agammaglobulinemia ) , and possibly ataxia-telangiectasia patients who are immunologically deficient, may have primary failure of thymus development. The finding of Page et al. (1963) that children with congenital sexlinked recessive agammaglobulinemia have an unusually high incidence of acute leukemia and lymphoma may even link this form of agammaglobulinemia to thymic malfunction, even though the thymus of most of the children with congenital sex-linked agammaglobulinemia who have died has been normal in the gross and microscopically. Recent experimental data and clinical observations have been underlining the association of thymic abnormality with a group of diseases involving immunologic dysfunction. Burnet and Holmes ( 1962, 1964) have studied a mouse strain which regularly develops a Coombs positive hemolytic anemia and abnormal thymic lesions; and Strauss et al. ( 1960), Beutner et al. (1962), White and Marshall (1962), E. V. Hess et al. (1964), and others have emphasized the association of thymic lesions, myasthenia gravis, and antimuscle and antinuclear antibodies. It has been known for some years that the most characteristic lesion of the thymus of myasthenia gravis patients is the formation of germinal centers, with plasma cells-a development rare in the human thymus under normal conditions (Castleman and Norris, 1949). Wolf et al. (1963) studied a patient with a thymoma and classical systemic lupus erythematosus (S.L.E.). Interestingly, this man was a member of a perfectly extra-
60
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
ordinary kinship in which a number of hematologic dyscrasias and a variety of diffuse mesenchymal disorders were observed, as well as a high incidence of immunologic disorders : one patient with acquired agammaglobulinemia, three with low y-globulin levels and lack of one or both of the ~2-immunoglobulins,three with hypergammaglobulinemia, and five with significant but not diagnostic levels of antinuclear antibody. Funkhouser (1961) studied a patient with a thymoma and L.E. cells, but lacking in other evidence of lupus erythematosus. Several instances of the simultaneous occurrence of lupus erythematosus and myasthenia gravis have been summarized by E. V. Hess et al. (1964). This seems to be more than a chance incidence. Thymic tumor has also been associated with myositis and myocarditis, in the apparent absence of myasthenia gravis; aregenerative anemias and pancytopenias; endocrinologic disorders; and nephrosis (reviewed by Fisher, 1964; and Good d ul., 1964a). Although, as indicated earlier, there is evidence that histologic abnormality of the thymus is associated with immunologic dysfunction in adult life, it is clear from the rapidly accumulating experimental data on a variety of experimental animals that the major immunologic role of the thymus is exercised, depending on the species, in the late embryonic period and the early postnatal or posthatching period. Clinical observations have just begun to fit into the picture, and it seems evident, from the point of view of the role of the thymus in human disease, that we have merely glimpsed the tip of the iceberg. At this writing the thymus has been linked to a number of human diseases, although only the crudest indices of abnormality have been applied: very small size, failure of normal descent, very large size, and extremely disturbed histology; as yet, only hints of what is cause and what effect have been available. The nature of many of these relationships will undoubtedly be established as understanding of the thymus increases and as improved methods of assessing thymic function are developed. 111. Phylogeny of Adaptive Immunity
A comprehensive survey of the phylogeny of the immune response would include its origins in the invertebrate Metuzoa and its evolution to the higher vertebrates. However, it will be evident in the sections to follow that comparative immunology is still in its early stages, despite the fact that the earliest work of Metchnikoff (1884) in this field dates back to the 1880's. The effort has often been diffuse and complicated by lack of critical quantitative methodology and appropriate controls for specificity of response.
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
61
In this review, we shall limit ourselves to adaptive immune responsiveness for the most part, defining this type of response in terms of ability to respond to antigenic material by production of specific combining substances, and to show an anamnestic response to these same antigens on subsequent exposure. Our emphasis will be on studies involving:
1. Chemical definition of the combining system. 2. Definition of the cellular basis for adaptive immunity. 3. Observations, in various species, of the capacity to react with delayed sensitivity and homograft rejection, and the relationship, if any, to the capacity for antibody synthesis. So far as is known, all antibody activity in mammals is localized in the serum globulins. Their properties have recently been discussed by Fahey ( 1962). A comparative study of y-globulin evolution might provide further insight into the structure and formation of these proteins. It is also possible that substances produced by primitive animals in response to antigenic stimulation warrant designation as antibodies although they do not fulfill the physicochemical criteria of y-globulins. In all species, evidence for an anamnestic response is of interest because of the association of plasmacytic proliferation with the secondary response (Kolouch, 1938;Kolouch et al., 1947;Fagraeus, 1948;Leduc et al., 1955;Urso and Makinodan, 1961; Nossal and Makela, 1962;Baney et al., 1962).The lymphoid cell family is the primary cellular basis for adaptive immune response in vertebrates and will be discussed in detail in a later section, emphasizing particularly the most primitive animals in which plasma cells or lymphocytes can be identified. However, the possibility that another cell system may mimic adaptive immune responses in an invertebrate species cannot be excluded at this time. The y-globulins are distinct among the mammalian serum proteins in their affinity with antigens, and the lymphoid cell family is a particularly intriguing example of differentiation. Our understanding of both the y-globulins and lymphoid cell differentiation is still very incomplete, however, and we believe that undue restriction of inquiry in the lower animals would neglect biologic adaptations of great interest. The lower forms also offer unusual opportunities for structural studies or analyses of cellular events which would be difficult or impossible in higher homothermic vertebrates. Indeed, it may be possible to dissect the complex cellular events leading to antibody synthesis phylogenetically, and to find arrested levels of maturation in various species both at the cellular and molecular levels. Finally, there may be organisms in which there is dissociation of
62
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
adaptive immunologic responsiveness : that is, animals in which the homograft response, delayed sensitivity, or antibody-producing capacity is present in the absence of one or both of the other types of responsiveness. Such species would be of extreme interest. In the following sections, the principal focus will be adaptive immunologic responsiveness in invertebrates and poikilothermic vertebrates. Studies on innate immunity and phagocytosis will be included only where they seem to be related to the emergence of adaptive responses. A. IMMUNERESPONSESIN INVERTEBRATES Most biologists agree on the phylogenetic relationships of the various classes within the subphylum Vertebrata, but more often disagree on the phylogeny of the invertebrates. Much of this controversy is based on the lack of paleontologic evidence of the soft-bodied invertebrates. Systemic classification of the invertebrates has been discussed by Hadzi (1953) and Marcus (1958), and the general aspects of such species classification, evolutionary history, and ecology have been reviewed by E. D. Hanson (1961).A complete manual of invertebrate zoology and classification is that of Hyman (1940-1959).There is general agreement on the evolution of the Metazoa from protozoan ancestors, and on the classification of coelenterates and flatworms as simpler and more primitive than arthropods and protochordates. There have been several reviews of immunity in invertebrates (Cantacuzhe, 1923; Huff, 1940; Baer, 1944; Bisset, 1947), but none has focused specifically on induced responses. In the following sections, evidence will be presented indicating that, to the time of writing, adaptive immunologic responsiveness has not been demonstrated in invertebrates. Exceptions may, of course, be found in the future; however, if such responses are observed, they will doubtless be exceptional rather than typical. 1. Reactions to Infection with Microorganisms Reactions of higher vertebrates to infectious organisms involve many physiologic responses in addition to antibody formation. The following studies are reviewed to indicate that invertebrates are subject to infection, and to suggest, on the basis of the accumulated evidence, that their defenses are nonspecific. The response tends to vary with species, and is often relatively unpredictable even within species. Metalnikov (1920) studied the bee moth larva, Galleria mellonella, and found it to be resistant to Mycobactem'um tuberculosis, Corynebacterium diphtheriae, Pasteurella pestis, and streptococci, but susceptible
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
63
to a variety of Gram-negative organisms, particularly Proteus and Pseud o m m , not ordinarily pathogenic in many mammals. Tarr (1937) reported that the honey bee larva was highly susceptible to Bacillus larvae infection. Infection of the crustacean sand flea, Orchestia, with a luminous bacterium was reported by Inman (1927). Other types of infection in invertebrates were discussed by Bisset ( 1947) and Huff ( 1940). Detailed studies of infections with microorganisms were carried out by Cameron (1932, 1934) in earthworms and caterpillars. Earthworms TABLE I11 PATHOGENICITY OF VARIOUS BACTERIAFOR Galleria mellonell@ Nonpathogenic Mycobacterium tuberculosis (human, bovine, avian) Bacterium dysenteriae Vibrio cholerae Bacterium typhosum Clostridium tetani Clostridium sporogenes Pneumococcus Bacterium paratyphosum B (Schottmuller) Pasteurella pestis Gonococcus Hemophilus influenzae Mycobacterium smegmatis Staphylococcus pyogenes aureus Coynebacterium
Pathogenic Streptococcus pyogenes Streptococcus faecalis Cmynebacterium diphtherhe Proteus vulgaris Bacillus mycoides Pseudomonas pyocyanez Bacterium coli communis
Variable Bacillus subtilis Staphylococcus pyogenes albus Clostridium oedematiens Vibrion septique Clostridium welchii
hofmannii 0
From Cameron ( 1934)
.
tolerated large doses of bacteria pathogenic for human beings: some were resistant to diphtheria toxin in doses as high as 300 times the lethal guinea pig dose, although the toxin induced vacuolation and destruction of the coelomic corpuscles, and necrosis of the body wall. Some degeneration of the coelomic corpuscles was also noted after injection of Shigellu dysenteriue, but it was milder than that resulting from diphtheria toxin. No pathogenic effects were noted upon administration of Staphylococcus aureus, Proteus, Vibrio cholera, hemolytic and nonhemolytic streptococci, pneumococci, and paratyphoid A. In further studies, Cameron (1934) described the effects of human parasitic and saprophytic bacteria on Galleria mellonellu, as well as the
64
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
response to organisms common in this species and its environment. Wide variations in susceptibility were noted, and in some instances virulent and nonvirulent variants of the same bacterial strain were isolated. A summary of Cameron’s bacteriologic studies on lepidopterous larvae is given in Table 111. He concluded that saprophytic organisms were generally more virulent in this species than human pathogens, but that variation in the individual properties of the bacterium determined its effectiveness in overcoming the host’s defenses. 2. Responses to Immunization with Killed or Attenwzted Bacteriu and Other Nonliving Antigens a. Humoral Immunity. Cantacuzene (1922) isolated a Vibrio from the marine worm, Sipunculus nudus, and prepared killed suspensions for vaccination. Both pathogenicity and deaths were reduced in worms inoculated with the vaccine before administration of a living culture. Paillot (1920) found that Agrotk segetum, a caterpillar, demonstrated immunity to a virulent culture of a Bacillus species 24 hours after vaccination with 3-week-old cultures of the same organism. This early immunity has been reported repeatedly in studies of invertebrates, and some investigators have presented evidence that this rapidly developing immunity is both phagocytic and humoral (Paillot, 1920; Metalnikov and Gaschen, 1921; Toumanoff, 1927). However, Zernoff ( 1928) claimed that it was possible to transfer this early immunity by inoculation of homologous cell-free hemolymph. The nature of the humoral mediators of immunity in invertebrates was only meagerly investigated in the early work. Cantacuzene demonstrated agglutinins and lysins in ascidians (1919), snails (1916), and several types of crabs (1912). A compilation of many of the other studies on humoral immunity in invertebrates was presented by Huff ( 1940). Many of these experiments did not test specificity adequately, and others had no controls for nonspecific reactions. In some instances, the nature of the protective capacity, i.e., that it was, in fact, humoral, was not ascertained. Two early reports (Chorine, 1927; Zernoff, 1931) are of particular interest in that immunity to test organisms was produced by unrelated bacteria, horse serum, and beef broth. Bernheimer et al. (1952) re-examined humoral immunity in caterpillars, using Escherichia coli B, Tz coliphage, streptolysin 0, and human erythrocytes as antigens. Hemolymph was collected by cutting tubercles of the thoracic segments, and repeated bleedings were possible. In no instance was there definite evidence for antibody formation following single or repeated injections of the antigens. When agglutination re-
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
65
actions occurred, as with undiluted hemolymph and suspensions of E . coli, they were observed in both control and experimental groups. When the hemolymph was diluted there was no specific agglutination. Ability to agglutinate human erythrocytes was stimulated by ovalbumin as well as the red cell antigen. This agglutinin was labile and was lost after storage in the cold. Further studies by Bernheimer (1952) established that caterpillar hemagglutinins for mammalian erythrocytes were heat labile, and did not produce hemolysis in the presence of guinea pig complement. Hemolymph from Sarnia cecropia was tested for ABO specificity, but failed to differentiate these blood groups. Comparable results were obtained (Triplett et al., 1958) when the sipunculid worm, Dendrostomum zostericolum, was immunized with red cells and protein antigens. Further studies on heat-stable bactericidins in lepidopterous larvae have been reported by Briggs ( 1958). Studies of a different nature have been conducted by Phillips (1960) and Phillips and Yardley (1980) with the sea anemone, among the most primitive invertebrates of the Coelenterata. After single and multiple injections of BSA, the animals were ground and extracts tested for their ability to interfere with the combination of BSA and antibody to BSA prepared in rabbits. The extracts did interfere with this reaction, and the degree of interference increased with time after immunization. The activity of the extracts was specific to some extent, since precipitation of human serum albumin and rabbit antibody to human serum albumin was unaffected. Further studies by Phillips (1962) have indicated that the extracts from BSA-treated anemones do interfere with other antigenantibody systems, however. Experimental evidence suggests that certain invertebrates produce humoral factors following immunization which react with antigens. Chemical studies of the type described by Isliker (1957), R. R. Porter (1960), and Kabat ( 1961)would be useful in assessing the resemblance, if any, of these combining substances to the antibody y-globulins of higher animals. Neither complementarity nor inducibility per se is an adequate criterion for y-globulin-antibody formation. Mora and Young ( 1962) showed that such polyelectrolyte macromolecules as heparin, protarnine, DNA, RNA, and polyglucose sodium sulfate can interfere with phage neutralization by rabbit antibody. Indeed, electrostatic attractions, hydrogen bonding, and the stereochemical complementarity and close fitting characteristic of antigen-antibody bonding may occur when chemical groups of two macromolecules are in appropriate apposition (Talmage and Cann, 1961) , However, the careful chemical characterization of any induced, specific substance produced in response to antigenic
66
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
stimulation in an invertebrate would be of great interest even without resemblance to y-globulins. b. “Cellular Immunity,” Phagocytosis, and the In$.ummatoy Reaction. The concept of cellular immunity and the role of phagocytosis in protection of the organism was originated and developed most thoroughly by Metchnikoff. In his classical report of 1884, he described the result of infection of the fresh water crustacean, Daphnia, with the blastomycete, Monospora bicuspidata. The course of infection and resistance was followed in the small transparent animals under the microscope. When introduced into the animal, the spores penetrated the intestinal wall and came into contact with phagocytic leucocytes which engulfed and digested them. On the other hand, little or no phagocytosis was observed when spores of the fungus Saprolegnia germinated outside the animal and infected it by inward penetration of the mycelia (Metchnikoff, 1892). Further research on phagocytosis is chronicled in Metchnikoffs lectures on the comparative pathology of inflammation (1892) and in his book on immunity (1905). Experiments were done in most of the phyla and in many vertebrates including the higher fishes. The inflammatory process in invertebrates consists of phagocytosis and digestion of the foreign material. When indigestible material is involved, the process is one of encapsulation, the formation of one or more layers of leucocytes around the material, which may remain within the organism or be extruded through nephridia, external pores, or other channels. In almost all species there are certain organisms that do not stimulate phagocytosis or continue to multiply actively within the phagocytes, achieving either destruction of the host or a symbiotic relationship within host cells. Many subsequent investigations of phagocytosis in invertebrates were conducted, a number of them by MetchnikoEs students. None of these studies was as complete as Cameron’s (1932) experiments with the earthworm. He studied phagocytosis and the reactions of the cells lining the coelomic cavity to India ink, carmine particles, milk and fat globules, colloidal iron, dust, and coal, as well as homologous and heterologous cells, and endogenous and foreign bacteria. All the inert materials, except fat or milk, were phagocytized within a few minutes, and the phagocytic process seemed to be autonomous in each segment. Mammalian blood cells and spermatozoa were all taken up within 48 hours. The reaction to bacteria varied with the organism, as noted in the last section. One of the most interesting findings was that homologous annelid spermatozoa remained within the coelomic cavity longer ( 4 or 5 days) than mam-
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
67
malian spermatozoa, suggesting a degree of heterologous tissue recognition. Further studies by Cameron involved the reaction to injury with a hot needle or strong acid. This reaction consisted of: an increase in the number of coelomic corpuscles within the first hour, proliferation of parietal coelomic epithelium near the site of injury, formation of undifferentiated tissue at the site with the appearance of numerous acidophilic cells, removal of dead tissue by desquamation and phagocytosis, ingrowth of epithelial cells from the superficial epithelium of the healthy margin, and gradual formation of muscle and fibrous tissue with ingrowth of new blood vessels. Complete repair was effected within 10 days. The process is not unlike the repair effected after removal of segments in annelids. In subsequent studies with caterpillars, Cameron (1934) showed that the cells of the hemolymph were most active in phagocytosis, but that pericardial cells and cells of the fat body were also phagocytic. Cells which Cameron identified as lymphocytes seemed to show a relative increase during the course of a reaction and to decline when the foreign material had been removed. Tubercle bacilli remained viable within cells of the blood and the pericardial cavity throughout metamorphosis, and were virulent for guinea pigs after isolation from adult moths. Response to other organisms was variable, as shown in Table 111. Recent studies of inflammation in invertebrates are those of Schlumberger (1952) who used methylcholanthrene and talc in the body cavity of the cockroach, and of Bang (1961) who investigated reactions to injury in the oyster. Little attention was given to the immunologic aspects of inflammation and phagocytosis in the early literature, although Metalnikov (1927) mentioned that immunized caterpillars showed an increased phagocytic rate for bacteria. Triplett et al. (1958) found no increase in either the phagocytic rate or the number of phagocytes during immunization in the marine worm, Dendrostomum zosterico2um. Phillips’ recent results (1982) suggest that, in the anemone, the rate of specific intracellular digestion of BSA conjugated with C14-labeled p-aminobenzoic acid, and the uptake of Tz and Ts coliphages, are both enhanced by prior injections of the antigen. These observations suggest an induced cellular uptake of antigenic material and bear on the question of the nature of cellular sensitization to protein materials. The studies of the specificity of this reaction have not been completed, but these experiments are a beginning in the study of cell reactions to well-defined proteins in invertebrates.
68
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
Clearly, phagocytosis and intracellular digestion are the major determinants of immunity in the invertebrates. The inflammatory reaction of earthworms resembles that of the vertebrates, except that the characteristic sequence of granulocytes followed by lymphocytic and monocytic infiltration does not occur. Instead, the coelomic corpuscles proliferate and differentiate at the site of injury to form fibrous connective tissue support for the ingrowing muscle fibers and epithelial cells. So far, no reports of increased proliferation of any cell type as a specific response to antigenic stimulation have been confirmed. Of particular relevance is the absence of evidence of recall, as indicated by increased proliferation of phagocytes or free cells of the blood, hemolymph, or coelom in immunized animals. However, exhaustive efforts to demonstrate cellular sensitization to antigens have not been made. Attempts to elicit specific phagocytic proliferation, and even production of humoral substances, should be continued with relatively well-defined soluble or particulate antigens, the responses to which are detectable by precise means and, in the case of circulating antibodies, in small quantities. An example of such an antigen is bacterial viruses, such as the coliphages, which have the added advantage of being readily detectable in small quantities themselves as a consequence of their biologic activity. Only after such antigens have been administered over a period of months, and no immune response observed, can it be concluded that a given species lacks immunologic reactivity. All such studies should include rigid controls for specificity, as well as attempts at chemical definition of the substances apparently reacting with the antigen, 3. Invertebrate Blood Cells The blood cells of invertebrates are not easily classified along the lines established for the higher vertebrates. Kollmann (1908) made a rather complete study of invertebrate blood cells, and regarded the leucocyte with scanty cytoplasm as the most primitive cell type. In the earthworm, Cameron ( 1932) identified acidophilic and basophilic cells, and granular chloragogen cells whose granules had great affinity with many anionic and cationic dyes. Only the basophilic and acidophilic cells were active in phagocytosis. Cameron (1934) described the cells of the hemolymph of caterpillars as lymphocytes, granular leucocytes, and spherule cells. The lymphocyte-like cells were the most active during phagocytosis; they appeared to proliferate during the course of an infection, but not in a manner specific to any one organism. Further infonnation on invertebrate blood cells is included in Cameron’s (1932, 1934) papers, and in reviews by Huff (1940) and Jordan (1938).
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
69
We believe that important distinctions between vertebrate and invertebrate immunity have been blurred by application of terms used for higher vertebrate leucocytes to blood cells of invertebrates. Little is known about the developmental sequence of any of the cell types in invertebrates, and, aside from phagocytosis, virtually nothing is known about function of the different cell types and their contents, e.g., the granules. Although the small basophilic cells with scanty cytoplasm in invertebrates have been called ‘lymphocytes,” there is no evidence that the analogy with the cells of higher vertebrates is valid. Indeed, it seems to us that one of the important distinctions between immunity in vertebrates and invertebrates rests on the presence or absence of definitive lymphoid tissues and lymphoid cells. Cuenot ( 1896) described lymphogenous organs along blood sinuses in invertebrates, but did not establish their role in lymphopoiesis. Moreover, lymphocytes and other cells of the lymphoid series have been clearly linked with specific immunologic reactions in the higher vertebrates, whereas circulating monocytes, and macrophages and reticular cells of the lymphoreticular organs have been associated with phagocytosis. As noted earlier, Cameron (1934) attributed a major role in phagocytosis to lymphocytes in the caterpillar. In the section dealing with immunity in vertebrates, evidence for the association of the evolution of lymphoid tissue with the development of adaptive immunity will be presented. For the present, in the absence of critical functional or chemical markers, conclusions about phylogenetic homologies among the blood cells are purely speculative. 4. Homotransplantation Immunity Homotransplantation is easily achieved in most invertebrates. Loeb ( 1945) reviewed the evidence for successful homotransplantation in coelenterates, planarians, earthworms, insects, and echinoderms. Additional data on transplantation in invertebrates were presented by Cushing and Campbell (1957)and discussed in a review by Favour (1958). In annelids, heterologous grafts do not succeed as well as homologous ones, and rejection time seems to be related to genetic distance: the greater the disparity, the more rapid the rejection. Plagge (1939)transplanted caterpillar organ rudiments between members of different genera and even different families. The transplants survived and developed normally in the foreign host, and success or failure seemed to depend more on graft size than on degrees of donor-host relationship. Ovaries transplanted from Drosophila melunogaster to Drosophilu funebris did
70
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
not function, a failure attributed to species specificity of a hormone necessary for maturation of the ova (Vogt, 1940). Recent experiments in marine invertebrates have been conducted by Cushing ( 1957, 1962). In the mollusk, Pecten irrudiuns, homografts were retained for 14 days; however, the series was too small to be conclusive. Triplett et al. (1958) studied skin and tentacle transplants in the marine sipunculid worm, Dendrostomum. Technical difficulties prevented adequate assessment of skin graft reactions, since neither autografts nor homografts healed. However, tentacle transplants in the coelomic cavity permitted studies of graft survival up to 70 days. The reaction to autografted or homografted tentacle was encapsulation by coelomic cells. Second set grafts were studied in worms preimmunized with injections of chopped tentacle. Encapsulation was less evident in the preimmunized group than in the controls. Thus, these experiments suggest that there is not only an absence of homograft recognition in this organism, but also a lack of ability to replace cells which had encapsulated the small bits of tentacle injected. Preliminary experiments on transplantation immunity in the octopus by Cushing (lSe2) suggest that there is no difference between the response to homografts and autografts up to 40 days after grafting. In summary, present evidence indicates that invertebrates fail to distinguish between autologous and homologous tissue, and, in some instances, between these and heterologous tissue. When grafts were not retained, the failure was attributable to technical failure or nonimmunologic mechanisms.
5. Anaphylaxis and Hypersensitiuity Several claims of active anaphylaxis in invertebrates were included in the early literature. Krafka (1929) described anaphylaxis in crawfish made sensitive to human serum. Studies by Ramsdell (1927a,b) were quoted by Huff (1940) as evidence for hypersensitivity in invertebrates. In these experiments the smooth muscle reaction in the earthworm and the swimming motion in the paramecium were lost following passive sensitization with ovalbumin and rabbit antibody. However, none of these results has been substantiated when adequate controls for specificity and reaction in noninjected animals were included. We are aware of no reports dealing with delayed sensitivity in invertebrates. 6. Proteins in Body Fluids Studies on the protein chemistry of invertebrate blood, hemolymph, and coelomic fluid have been reviewed by Engle and Woods (1960),
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
71
and comparative electrophoretic patterns, by paper and moving boundary electrophoresis, have been compiled by H. F. Deutsch and Koenig ( 1956). Proteins with the electrophoretic mobility of y-globulins have not been detected in most studies of invertebrate body fluids; however, Condie (1962) has isolated a protein from the keyhole limpet, a mollusk, which has electrophoretic and ultracentrifugal properties of y-globulin. The functional properties of this material are not known.
7. The Nature of Immunologic Activity in Inuertebrates Invertebrates are clearly capable of protecting themselves from pathogenic and saprophytic microorganisms; yet this protective capacity does not appear to be closely related to the specific mechanisms that characterize adaptive immunity in mammals. Reactions against parenterally introduced foreign substances commonly involve phagocytosis and encapsulation by the ameboid cells of the blood or coelomic fluid. The evidence relating any of the free cells of the invertebrates to the lymphoid cells of the higher vertebrates is meager and difficult to interpret in view of the lack of specific functional markers for lymphoid cells. There is no evidence of organized lymphoid tissue in invertebrates. The ability to distinguish antigenic surface patterns appears to be limited in most invertebrate species. When observations suggesting such capabilities have been presented, evidence for their immunologic nature has been lacking. The studies reviewed here do not exclude the possibility that a prototype of the adaptive immunologic response exists in some invertebrates. The time factor has not been considered carefully enough in previous studies, including the interval between presentation of the antigen and subsequent test, and the duration of exposure to the antigen. Reactions should be tested weeks or even months after repeated antigenic stimulation before concluding that there is no response.
B. IMMUNE RESPONSES IN VERTEBRATES Interpretations of immune responses in vertebrates are less difficult. Vertebrates are all members of a single subphylum, whereas the invertebrates represent many phyla. The phylogenetic relationships among the various vertebrate classes are also more definite, since they have been based on studies of fossils and correlated closely with geologic time. In addition, homologies of organ structure and anatomic position in living vertebrate representatives are more obvious, with less deviation from a basic body form; and similarities in the circulatory system and blood
72
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
permit use in lower vertebrates of many of the techniques developed for study of mammals. Immune responses in vertebrates have been reviewed by Bisset ( 1947), Cushing and Campbell ( 1957), Favour ( 1958), Sirotinin ( 1960), and Hildemann (1962). Recent advances in the study of immune responses in the lowest vertebrates (Papermaster et al., 1962c, 1963) have suggested that adaptive immunity evolved in the lower marine vertebrates and that this development was correlated with the earliest appearance of a thymus and definitive lymphoid tissue. 1, Reactions to Infection with Microorganisms
Studies of the reaction of poikilothermic vertebrates to various pathogens and saprophytes were a natural extension of the work on invertebrates by Metchnikoff and his associates, Their experiments indicated that survivors of a first exposure to a pathogen were less susceptible to the same organism upon re-exposure ( Metchnikoff, 1905). Studies on the effect of temperature on pathogenicity of infections such as anthrax have yielded variable results (Gibier, 1882; Sabrazhs and Colombot, 1894; Mesnil, 1895). Gibier (1882) found that high temperatures resulted in loss of “immunity” to anthrax in frogs, but Sabrazhs and Colombot (1894) and Mesnil (1895) found susceptibility to anthrax in cold-blooded vertebrates to be unaffected by temperature changes. The Sabrazhs and Colombot findings were, however, an exception to the general rule ( Bisset, 1947) that poikilothermic animals are completely “immune” to anthrax. Bisset (1947) suggested that some of the contradictions reflected the focus on the host’s defenses alone, without consideration of the effects of temperature on the invading organism. In addition, the inconsistencies may be attributable to changes in other physiologic processes which in turn affect host-parasite relationships. More typical is the response of trout to a Gram-negative rod, Bacterium salmonicida, which causes furunculosis ( Bisset, 1948). Young fish are more susceptible to this disease than older ones, and outbreaks are more common in warm, slow-moving water. Gee and Smith (1941) showed that protection from this organism could be conferred by immunization with killed organisms.
2. Response to Immunization with Killed Organisms and Other Antigens and the Effect of Temperature The studies of Metchnikoff and his associates had clearly demonstrated that resistance to infectious microorganisms in poikilothermic vertebrates is temperature dependent; however, in many of their studies
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
73
the effects of temperature were not controlled. The variable results in studies of fish, frogs, and alligators prompted a study by Widal and Sicard (1897) on frogs and other animals placed at their disposal by Metchnikoff. In frogs, they found that a variety of species produced agglutinins above 21" but not at 12"C, but they emphasized that large doses of antigen were needed to elicit agglutinin formation in these animals. Similar results in frogs were reported by Friedberger and Seelig (1908), Wollman (1938), and F. W. Allen and McDaniel (1937), and in fish by Nybelin (1934) and Pliszka ( 1939). In all these studies it was apparent that poikilothermic animals formed antibody more rapidly at warmer temperatures, and that they produced it at a slower rate and in smaller amounts than mammals and birds. That antibody production is not completely inhibited in fish at colder temperatures was reported by W. Smith (1940) who showed that agglutinins to Bacterium salmonicida were formed at 1O"C, provided the antigen was given in sufficient quantity and sufficient time allowed following immunization. A study by Cushing (1942) on the rate of antibody production by fish to sea urchin spermatozoa at 15" and 20°C also showed a delay in antibody response in the cold. The animals were bled at 3-4 day intervals up to 25 days after the injection of the sperm suspension. The fish kept in the warm tank showed a rise in antibody titers by the eleventh day, while those kept at 15°C did not show a rise in titer until the fifteenth day. Bisset (1948) found that frogs immunized at 8°C produced no antibody, but that antibody rapidly appeared in the serum when the animals were warmed to 20°C. Conversely, frogs immunized at 20°C and then kept at 8°C had much lower titers than control animals which remained at 20°C. In further experiments, Bisset (1949) demonstrated that the antibody titers of fish and frogs at low temperatures could be raised significantly by injections of corticosteroids. No further investigations of this phenomenon have been reported, and the mechanism of adrenal steroid action on immunity in lower vertebrates remains ill-defined. This topic will be considered further in the section on vertebrate lymphoid tissue. Use of a sensitive detection technique, bacteriophage neutralization, enabled us (Papermaster et al., 1962~)to detect small amounts of neutralizing antibody to Tz coliphage in the bullhead, Ameiurus melas, held at 10°C for 14 days after a single injection of 1O1O phage particles (Fig. 1). The temperature at which antibody formation may be inhibited apparently reflects the temperature of the animal's normal habitat. With the California hagfish, an animal adapted to cold marine waters, the temperature could not be raised above 25°C because of aberrant myo-
74
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
cardial contraction and other physiologic dysfunction. An animal adapted to high temperatures, the desert iguana, Dipsosuurus dorsalis, was studied by Evans and Cowles ( 1959).Agglutinin formation to Salmonellu typhosa H antigen was indicated by titers of 1:lO or less at 25°C and by titers of 1:80 to 1:640 at 35°C.Thus, the animal's normal environment must be considered in studies of the effect of temperature, and in many instances, comparisons of response among groups of animals may not be possible. The inhibitory effects of low temperatures on antibody formation in
I
Heterologops PLTzz
(P
0
=--.-.-..+ .-.-.-.
C
.-0 F LL $ .-
\\
c
U
Tz
4*Bullhead 20' 4 days
-
**Bullhead 10' 14 days
I -I
L >
2 0 0
J
-2
t I
\ I
I
I
20
40 Time (min.)
60
FIG.1. Relative neutralization rates of T, phage by serum from immunized hagfish, bullheads, and mice. The number of days between stimulation with 1010 phage particles and bleeding are indicated for each curve. In the hagfish the results were the same at 4 and 7 days, regardless of the temperature. (From Papermaster et al., 1982c, with permission of Nature.)
many poikilothermic animals deserves further investigation. Indeed, such problems as the mitotic rate of antibody-forming cells, effects of steroids on cell lysis or secretion, inhibition of antibody production by 6-mercaptopurine and other metabolic antagonists, immunologic paralysis, and separation of the sensitization and secretory phases of antibody production, might be profitably investigated at lower temperatures in poikilothermic animals. 3. Evolution of Antibody-Forming Capacity in Vertebrates
Although much controversy remains concerning the systematics of vertebrate evolution, the evidence available appears to indicate pro-
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
75
gressive development of complexity in body form which should be considered together with the development of immunologic capacity. The important characteristics of the chordate phylum are: gill clefts in the adult or young larva and embryo; dorsal, hollow nerve chord; notochord; segmentation; a coelomic cavity; and a tail (Young, 1950; E. D. Hanson; 1961; Romer, 1962). Study of existing species has suggested that the vertebrates arose from the tunicates whose body form is bilaterally symmetrical and has a dorsal nerve chord, notochord, gill slits (Berrill, 1955); however, the origin of the vertebrates is still contentious, since the fossil records of the protochordates are incomplete. A further step toward vertebrate evolution is represented by Amphioxus (the lancelet) ; this animal lacks jaws, is a filter feeder, and has segmentally arranged axial musculature ( Young, 1950). The vertebrates presumably evolved from similar forms, and the most primitive lacked jaws but had a notochord and other chordate characteristics. These primitive, jawless fish were the ostracoderms. Romer (1962) believes that they developed in fresh water; however, Robertson (1957) concluded that the earliest vertebrate forms arose in salt water on the basis of paleontologic evidence and recent studies of the plasma osmolarity in cyclostomes. Much anatomic evidence indicates that the cyclostomes are the living representatives of the most primitive vertebrates. Among the most significant characteristics are the lack of jaws and complete vertebrae, the cartilaginous skeleton, the persistent notochord, spherical gill pouches, and two semicircular canals in the internal ear (Hubbs, 1961). The two major groups of cyclostomes are the hagfishes (Eptatretidae) and the lampreys (Petromyzonidae) . Lampreys are found in both fresh and salt water, but the marine forms spawn in fresh water. The hagfishes, on the other hand, are entirely marine, and are considered to be more primitive than the lampreys on the basis of anatomic features (Hubbs, 1961), physiologic studies of the heart ( D. Jensen, 1961), and biochemical studies of the plasma ionic concentration (Robertson, 1954) and hemoglobin structure and function ( Manwell, 1958; Ingram, 1962). Indeed, hagfish hemoglobin resembles that of the invertebrate sea cucumber. These vertebrate ancestors probably developed in the late Ordovician period about 480 million years ago. The higher vertebrate fishes evolved from cyclostome-like precursors in the late Silurian and early Devonian seas. From progenitors probably resembling the placoderms, now extinct, two branches of fish evolution proceeded, the bony fishes and the cartilaginous fishes ( Colbert, 1955; Romer, 1962). Modern representatives of the early bony fishes are the sturgeon, garpike, paddlefish, and the dogfish or bowfin. The cartilaginous fishes include the sharks, skates, and
76
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
rays. Amphibia evolved from a specialized group of bony fish, the crossopterygians, of which the African and Australian lungfish are existing species. Primitive reptiles developed from the amphibians toward the close of the Paleozoic era, with birds and mammals evolving in the Mesozoic, and finally man in the Quaternary period about 1 million years ago (Colbert, 1955; Romer, 1962). Figure 2 summarizes Class Osteichthyes BONY FISHES
Boss
Class Chondrichthyes CARTILAGINOUS FISHES
Sturgeon
Bowfin
Pike Perch Bullhead
TO PRIMITIVE AMPHIBIANS
,c ,' Coeioconths
Chimeras
Class Agna tha
?
OSTRACOOERMS JAWLESS VERTEBRATES
OF SILURIAN 8 DEVONIAN PERIODS
RAT FISHES
PLACODERMS PALEOZOIC JAWED VERTEBRATES
II I
FIG. 2. A simplified evolutionary development of the fishes, showing the position of the bowfin, lamprey, haghhes, rays, and other fishes included in the studies documented. (From Finstad et al., 1964.)
the taxonomic relationships of the several groups of fishes, and indicates those we consider to be key forms for studies of the evolution of immune reactions. Many of the relationships among genera, species, and phyla are being examined with the use of iminunogenetic and immunochemical techniques. Immunogenetic blood grouping in fowl was described by Irwin (1947,1949) and in fishes by Cushing and Sprague (1953) and Fujino and Cushing ( 1959). Immunochemical protein analysis and studies of serum protein relationships in primates by Goodman (1961,1962) and
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
77
in reptiles by E. Cohen (1955) have been useful in establishing phylogenetic relationships. A comprehensive discussion of comparative serology is beyond the scope of this paper, but some of the studies have been reviewed by Cushing and Campbell (1957), in two recent symposia (C. Cohen, 1962; Cushing and Stormont, 1962), and in the papers cited above. The coupling of immunologic data with biochemical and physiologic findings may well help to resolve some of the problems of taxonomy and evolution of organ systems in ontogeny and phylogeny. Further studies in this expanding field of research may elucidate the role of antigenic polymorphisms in evolution and differentiation. Previous work on the evolution of antibody formation has focused either on the invertebrates or vertebrates at the level of the teleost fishes or above it. We are aware of no previous studies on the cyclostomes and the lower ganoid fishes. Engle and Woods (1957) and Woods and Engle (1957), and more recently Clem and Sigel (1963) have studied the electrophoretic patterns of elasmobranch sera. With the exception of a study by CantacuzBne (1919) on ascidians, the protochordates have also been neglected. Thus, the transitional protochordates, cyclostomes, and lower fishes appear to provide the most promising area of research on the evolutionary origins of adaptive immune responses. a. Protochorhtes. Although studies on the natural bacteriolysins of ascidians have been reported by CantacuzBne (1919), no experimental attempts at active immunization of the protochordates were found. The ascidians and Amphioxus are of particular interest in this group, since they represent the most likely forebears of the primitive vertebrates. b. Cyclostomes. The cyclostomes are the most primitive of the true vertebrates and, as such, represent a unique group for studies on the phylogenetic origin of the antibody response and other forms of immunologic reactivity. Our studies started with the hagfish, Eptatretus stoutii (Good and Papermaster, 1961; Papermaster et al., 1962~).These animals are marine thoughout their life cycle and spawn at the ocean bottom. The embryo develops directly into a form resembling the adult without a larval stage (Young, 1950). The hagfish preys upon dead or dying fish, entering their mouths and eating the flesh from the inside. In our laboratory, hagfish were maintained in buckets of sea water at 10°C for most experiments, without feeding, for up to 7 months in good condition. All attempts to induce antibody formation in the hagfish with diverse antigens have been unsuccessful. The antigens used for immunization included killed Brucella abortus, typhoid-paratyphoid A and B vaccine, BSA, hernocyanin, and the bacterial viruses Tz (Escherichia coli phage)
78
ROBERT A. GOOD A N D BEN W. PAPERMASTER
and MSP-8 ( Streptomyces griseus actinophage ) . Numerous injections were given over periods up to 3 months, and many of the antigens were administered with complete Freunds adjuvant in an effort to elicit an antibody response; but no agglutinating, complement-fixing, or neutralizing antibodies, or antigen-binding globulins were found. As a control on conditions of temperature and starvation, the freshwater teleost bullhead, Ameiurus mehs, was immunized with 1Olo T2 phage at 10°C and kept without feeding for the same periods of time as the hagfish. Under these conditions, neutralizing antibody to T2 phage could be demonstrated in the serum by the fourteenth day after immunization in the bullhead but not in the hagfish. No circulating phage particles could be detected in the 1Cday sample of the bullhead, while as many as 4OOO particles/ml. were found in the serum from hagfish given the same amount of phage. At U)"C, a temperature barely tolerated by the hagfish, a 7-day study was completed. Both hagfish and bullheads received an injection of 1Olo particles of phage, and their serum was tested for the presence of phage or neutralizing antibody. In the bullhead, no phage particles were detectable by the fourth day after injection, and neutralizing antibody was present in small amounts (Fig. 1).The hagfish had neither cleared the phage nor formed antibody by the seventh day, at which time the experiment was terminated because the hagfish appeared moribund. In these studies, incubation of phage and serum was continued for periods up to 72 hours at 0" and 37°C in order to detect neutralizing activity, but in no case was the rate of neutralization greater in immunized hagfish serum than in the diluent control or in normal undiluted hagfish serum. In all studies with bullhead or other fish sera, a heterologous phage was included in the reaction tubes as a control on the specificity of antibody inactivation. A next step in vertebrate evolution is represented by the lamprey, Petromyzon. As indicated earlier, the marine forms are anadromous, but in the Great Lakes and other areas, these animals have adapted completely to fresh-water existence. An opportunity was available in the spring of 1962 to study the immune response in spawning lampreys collected by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. In the early experiments, no significant difference in the primary response of nonimmunized control lampreys and those intensively stimulated with Tz phage was observed. More recent studies by Finstad d d.(1964) and Good and Finstad ( 1964) have established that the lamprey possesses an epithelial thymus with occasional lymphoid cells, has a family of lymphocytes, including
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
79
large, medium, and small, in the peripheral blood, and has small foci of lymphocytes in the primitive spleen and primitive bone marrow. Immunologic responses to bovine albumin and bovine y-globulin are lacking. Formation of neutralizing antibody against bacteriophage is at best equivocal and hemagglutinating antibody production against hemocyanin is feeble or lacking entirely. Agglutinating antibodies are, however, produced against Brucella antigens, and these animals accept autografts and reject homografts of skin. Evidence for a delayed immune response was also obtained. Thus, at this writing, we have evidence that the lamprey possesses a very primitive lymphoid tissue and has a low level of immunologic competence. C. Elasmobranchs. The chondrichthyes and osteichthyes represent independent lines of development from placoderm-like forebears which became extinct at the end -of the Devokan period (Fig. 2 ) (Romer, 1962). In an effort to include the principal groups of lower fishes in our study, antibody formation was followed in the guitarfish, Rhinobatos productus, and other elasmobranchs. In the guitarfish group, a welldeveloped response was demonstrated in a 7-day bleeding following secondary antigenic stimulation with lo1' phage particles. The primary response was poorly developed, and the formation of neutralizing antibody and clearance of phage from the serum were considerably slower than in the secondary response (Table IV). Sharks were capable of producing high antibody titers to influenza PR-8 virus in the studies of Sigel and Clem (1963).In our own studies (Papermaster et al., 1964) the relatively primitive shark, Heterodontus francisci, produced antibody against both hemocyanin and bacteriophage, although not with great vigor. d . Chondrosteans and Holosteans. The lower bony fishes were of particular interest since they include, we believe, several modern representatives of evolutionary stages ( actinopterygians or ray-finned fishes ) from which the teleosts developed; to our knowledge immune responsiveness had not been studied in any of these forms. The representative of this group included in our series was the holostean fish, Amia calua, the bowfin or dogfish of the northern United States. The antibody response was similar to that found in the elasmobranchs, in that secondary and tertiary stimulation with T2 phage resulted in increasing amounts of neutralizing antibody. The evolutionary development of immunologic competence, as revealed using hemocyanin and bacteriophage T2 as antigens, is set down in Table IV. Further studies are being pursued in
TABLE IV PINLOGENETIC DEVELOPMENT OF IMMUNITYIN THE LOWERFISHES
Fish studied Bullhead (Ameium melas) Bass (Microptow dnwides) Bowfin (Amia calva) Shark (Heterodontus francisci) Guitar6sh (Rhinobatos productus) Lamprey (Petromyzon mudnus) Hagdish (Eptatretus stoutii)
Antibody to hemocyanin PrecipiHemagglutating tinating Not studied Not studied
++
-
-
++ +
Neutralizing antibody to phage
+ Not studied +
+
+ +
2
2
-
4
Spleen develop ment
+ ++ + + + 2
Thymus develop ment
+ ++ + +
+(Larval) - (Adult -
8 tr
2 3 z
3 cd
3*
E $i
I
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
81
the bowfin, sturgeon, garpike, paddlefish, and other representatives of the primitive bony fishes. e. Teleosts and Higher Vertebrates. The many references cited in earlier sections of this review attest to the ability of all vertebrates above the level of the lower fishes to make antibody following appropriate antigenic stimulation. Other aspects of immune response in these animals will be covered in subsequent sections. f. Summary. The studies on the cyclostomes and the cartilaginous and lower bony fishes have indicated that the capacity to form circulating antibody and demonstrate immunologic memory is present in the elasmobranchs and lower bony fishes, may be developed to a slight degree in the lamprey, and is not present in the hagfish. Thus, the capacity for this particular adaptation appears to have evolved in the fishes of the Devonian period. Correlation of this response with the evolution of the lymphoid tissue will be discussed later. Knowledge of the developmental sequence involved in this large step of evolution, namely the establishment of all the different forms of immunologic reactivity, may be filled in by further study of the lamprey and the primitive fishes, including representatives of the actinopterygians or crossopterygians. A less pleasing alternative may be final burial of these evolutionary steps with the fossil forebears of the recent fishes, placoderm-like forms. 4. Churacterization of Antibodies and y-Globulins The y-globulins in mammals are now known to include a heterogeneous group of serum proteins. Details of nomenclature and electrophoretic behavior have recently been reviewed by Fahey (1962). Designation of a protein as a y-globulin merely on the basis of its migration toward the cathode at pH 8-9 in an electrophoretic pattern is at best tenuous, without further physicochemical characterization. This would hold particularly fcr the lower vertebrates, where none of the correlations of chemical properties with antibody activity exist as they do in mammals and avians. Nevertheless, electrophoretic analysis under similar conditions can provide an initial guideline and can indicate the species in which further physicochemical studies are warranted. Engle and Woods ( 1960) have reviewed electrophoretic analyses of invertebrate and vertebrate serum proteins. In original studies by these authors (Engle and Woods, 1957; Woods and Engle, 1957; Engle et al., 1958), none of the invertebrates gave evidence of proteins migrating with the characteristics of y-globulin in human sera, whereas eight species of elasmobranchs all had bands which behaved electrophoretically like
82
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
y-globulin. Preliminary studies on immunoelectrophoretic characterization of serum proteins in cyclostomes have recently been completed ( Papermaster et al., 1 9 6 2)~. Immunoelectrophoretic studies of hagfish sera indicated that no bands in the regions associated with y-globulin migration in human serum could be detected (Fig. 3). In the lamprey, a single band migrating with the mobility characteristic of p- or fast y-globulin in mammals was found in occasional sera; further chemical studies of this material are being made. In the holostean fish, Amia calua, bands with the immunoelectrophoretic properties of y-globulins were clearly demonstrable. These results on the serum proteins of the hagfish support the data on their lack of antibody-forming ability. The occurrence of y-globulins in amphibians has been reported by Evans and Horton (1961) and by Elek et al. (1962), and in reptiles by Baril et al. ( 1961). Other electrophoretic studies of higher vertebrate sera are summarized by Engle and Woods (1960). Recently, Uhr et al. (1962a) have studied the antibody produced by teleost fish, frogs, and chickens to the coliphage +X 174. In all three species, the antibody activity was found in electrophoretic fractions corresponding to human y-globulin. A shift from a component which sediments rapidly in the ultracentrifuge (19s) and is mercaptoethanol sensitive, to a slowly sedimenting ( 7s ) mercaptoethanol-resistant fraction occurred in the course of immunization in the chicken. In both the goldfish and the frog, however, phage neutralizing activity from both early and late sera was lost following treatment with B-mercaptoethanol. Studies on the sera of the elasmobranch guitarfish (Rhinobatos productus) used in our experiments, shown to have Tz phage neutralizing activity and antibody to hemocyanin following immunization with these antigens, have been performed by Grey (1963a). Grey’s study indicated that the globulin antibody was 2-mercaptoethanol sensitive and sedimented rapidly as 19s. The antibody to hemocyanin could be specifically localized in the cyptoplasm of lymphoid cells from spleen imprints by the fluorescent antibody method. As with the ontogenetic development of y-globulin in mammals, in which a shift from 19 to 7s y-globulin occurs during the neonatal period (see section on ontogeny) , the most primitive form of y-globulin of proved antibody activity in phylogenetic development may also be the 19s type, as seen in the guitarfish. Continued study of the y-globulins in elasmobranchs and other primitive fishes may provide worth-while information on the composition and
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
83
FIG. 3. Immunoelectrophoresis of serum from hagfish (top), lamprey, Amla calua, and immunologically normal human being. The increasing complexity of the y-globulins is evident in the higher forms. (From Papemaster et al., 1984.)
84
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
evolution, not only of the y-globulin components, 19 and 7S, but of y-globulin subunits. The clarification of the sedimentation properties of lower fish y-globulins may indicate that the ontogenetic pattern of antibody formation recapitulates a phylogenetic sequence at the molecular level. Support of this possibility could well derive from studies of the subunit developments in both ontogeny and phylogeny. The specificity of lower vertebrate antibody and its ability to distinguish small structural differences in hapten groups compared to mammalian antibodies should also be studied in more detail. Our phage neutralization studies indicated that bowfin and guitarfish antisera would not neutralize antigenically unrelated phage. Further studies to clarify the limits of resolving power with lower vertebrate antibody would be of interest, since clues for the evolutionary development of the pattern for active site assembly may result. Subunit analysis might also clarify the nature of peptide chain assembly, in that primitive vertebrate yglobulins might differ altogether in the types of peptide chains they exhibit, or give evidence of a simpler chain structure that is retained along with further chain addition, as in hemoglobin evolution (Manwell, 1958; Ingram, 1962). 5. Antigenicity in Lower Vertebrates Bacterial antigens uniformly stimulate agglutinating antibody production in elasmobranch and teleost fishes, and in amphibians and reptiles. Bacterial and other viruses also appear to induce production of neutralizing antibody. Precipitating antibodies are rarely observed: to the present time the only precipitating antibody we have observed in lower vertebrates has been antibody to hemocyanin in the holostean bowfin. Numerous attempts have been made by us and by Grey (1963b) to stimulate fish with BSA, with and without emulsification in Freund's adjuvant, but no precipitating or hemagglutinating antibodies or antigencombining globulins have been demonstrated. BSA continues to circulate for more than 30 days when administered to elasmobranchs, teleosts, and frogs. Similar results with BSA in turtles were obtained by Thorbecke (1961). These findings may mean that BSA is not very antigenic in the lower vertebrates, or that the animals are easily paralyzed with this protein. They may also reflect the relative insensitivity of methods for detecting small amounts of antibody to serum proteins when compared to the bacteriophage neutralization technique; however, it seems most likely to us that they reflect the inadequacy of serum proteins as antigens, perhaps related to differences in particulate size of these proteins compared to viruses and bacteria. Anaphylactic reactions to whole serum
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
85
in teleost i&h were reported by Dreyer and King (1948), as will be described in the next section. Small doses of bacteriophage and bacteria appear to be less effective in stimulating antibody production in fish and frogs than in mammals and birds. We were able to provoke what we interpret as secondary responses to TS phage in elasmobranchs and teleosts with doses of 10'l to 10l2 phage particles, whereas Uhr et al. (1962a) were not able to elicit a secondary response in goldfish with 1O1O (pX174 phage particles. With each species a very wide dose range must be used to evaluate antibodyproducing capacity. 6. Immediate and Delayed Sensitivity
Early studies on anaphylaxis in the lower vertebrates were reported by Friedberger and Mita ( 1911) . Goodner, in 1926, reported unsuccessful attempts to sensitize frogs to sheep serum, and attributed failure to differences in smooth muscle innervation in the frog. The Schultz-Dale phenomenon could not be demonstrated in frog smooth muscle. Some reaction could, however, be demonstrated in the heart after intracardiac injection of small amounts of sheep serum. Downs (1928) produced active anaphylaxis in turtles by injection of mammalian serum proteins. Anaphylactic reactions of the affected heart included a decrease in the rate and force of auricular and ventricular beats. More critical studies were reported by Dreyer and King, in 1948. One immunizing injection of horse serum was given intraperitoneally to a variety of common teleost fish (perch, sunfish, rock bass, and goldfish) held at 18°C. Anaphylactic sensitization was indicated by fanning of the dorsal fin, increased excursions of the gill clefts, and sinking to the bottom of the container with the dorsal fin contracted against the body within 10 minutes of the second injection of protein. The reaction was specific for horse serum, and could be diminished by epinephrine. In the frog, no evidence of anaphylactic sensitization could be demonstrated using similar immunization procedures. We are aware of no previous literature dealing with delayed sensitivity in the lower vertebrates. In our own laboratories, several preliminary investigations of delayed reactions have been undertaken. In the hagfish, no evidence of delayed reactions to BCG or old tuberculin could be demonstrated, despite repeated attempts at sensitization ( Papermaster et al., 1962~).In Amia calva, the dogfish, a well-defined indurated area could be detected in the axial musculature, the skin of the sides, and on the upper lip, 3 days after challenge with Ascaris antigen. The challenging dose was administered 30 days after initial sensitization with Ascaris
86
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
antigen in complete Freund’s adjuvant. Reactions of this type were not observed in nonsensitized controls. Induction of delayed sensitivity in chickens was recently reported by Warner and Szenberg ( 1964). Comparative studies on immediate and delayed sensitivity reactions are meager, and interpretation is difficult. Anaphylactic reactions are variable in mammals, and even more so in the lower vertebrates. Such factors as temperature, length of time for immunization, amount of antibody produced, and the nature and extent of the inflammatory reaction need to be evaluated in the interpretation of hypersensitivity reactions in lower vertebrates. The present studies represent only a beginning in this important area. 7. Transplantation Zmmunity Although the literature on homotransplantation in mammals and avians is extensive, comparatively few detailed studies have been performed with poikilothermic vertebrates. The early investigations were conducted to elucidate patterns of inductive tissue interaction and were not concerned with tissue incompatibilities. A complete compilation of the early work is included in the monograph by h e b (1945).More recent reviews of comparative transplantation are available in several of Hildemann’s papers (Hildemann, 1957,1962;Hildemann and Haas, 1959, 1962) and an article by Favour ( 1958). Quantitative studies on scale homograft reactions were reported by Hildemann in 1957 and 1958 on the goldfish, Carassius uuratus. The highly significant observation contributed by this study was the more rapid breakdown of second-set scale homografts in sensitized recipients, as measured by the median survival time and the inflammatory reaction. Thus, rejection of scale homografts in this teleost species was shown to be unequivocally immunologic in nature. Although rejection was slower in fish kept at lower temperatures, significant differences in rejection time of first- and second-set grafts were still evident at 10°C. Genetic studies of histocpmpatibility differences in teleost fish were described by Kallman and Gordon (1958).Fins were grafted in inbred strains of platyfish (Xiphophorus maculatus) at temperatures varying between 21 and 27°C. Isografts and parent to Fl hybrid grafts were completely accepted. The patterns of rejection of grafts from F1 hybrid to parent and from parent to Fz were similar to those established for mammals. Thus, where genetic diiferences existed, fin grafts were rejected, the interval between grafting and rejection varying from 3 days to 3 months, depending on the genetic relationship between donor and host.
ONTOGENY AND PHnOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
87
The ability to reject homografts correlates well with the development of other immune mechanisms. Moreover, the homograft reaction can be inhibited by metabolic antagonists in teleost fish (Goss, 1961) as in mammals (Meeker et al., 1959). Many of the earlier contradictory reports on homograft reactions in amphibian larvae can now be interpreted in the light of the data of Hildemann and Haas (1962)on the ontogeny of the homograft reaction in bullfrogs. In their studies larvae were tolerant of homografts to about 40 days posthatching; this was followed by a transitional period of several days, and finally establishment of well-developed rejection mechanisms. The median survival time in the species studied, Ram cutesbeianu, at a temperature of 25"C., was 12-14 days for h t - s e t homografts and 5 days for second-set grafts. There was approximately a threefold prolongation of rejection time when the temperature was maintained at 15°C. In a study by Erickson (1962)skin graft rejection did not develop as rapidly in the salamander, Triturus uiridescens, as in the fish and anurans studied by Hildemann and Haas. Survival times averaged 23 days for primary skin grafts and from 9 to 17 days for second-set grafts. The variation in graft rejection times among various vertebrate species is influenced by temperature and degree of immunologic maturation at the time of grafting. However, as indicated above, intraspecies antigenic polymorphism may account for the largest differences. Compared to rabbits and random-bred mice, adult Syrian hamsters reject homologous grafts slowly over periods of months ( Billingham and Hildemann, 1958). Likewise, graft rejection in Triturus is slower than in the anuran species studied. Studies with isolated bullfrog populations, nearly all of whose skin grafts were rejected, indicated that every tadpole had at least one isoantigen different from those occurring in any other tadpole (Hildemann and Haas, 1981). Such studies are amenable to population genetic analysis (Owen, 1959); such a study was recently performed on mice by Owen (1962). The subject of sexual dimorphism and its relationship to histocompatibility reactions of amphibia has been discussed by Pizzarello and Wolsky ( 1960). The evolution of the homograft reaction may or may not follow the same pattern as the antibody response: the evidence is not yet complete. The studies on invertebrates, discussed in an earlier section, indicate that recognition of allogeneic tissue as antigenic is not characteristic of this group. We attempted to study the homograft response in the hagfish. Adequate evaluation of skin transplants was prevented by failure of
88
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
both autografts and homografts to heal properly (Papermaster et al., 1982c), as in the studies of Triplett et d. (1958) in Dendrostornum. Implantation of presumable allogeneic liver failed to provoke an inflammatory reaction; however, these studies are not complete, and a final evaluation of the homograft reaction in the hagfish is dependent on further experimentation. Similar studies on lampreys, elasmobranchs, and holostean fishes should be completed.
8. Evolution of the Lymphoid Tissue Present evidence suggests that the evolution of lymphoid tissue as well as the specific immune reaction takes place within the vertebrates. Although a precise definition of the lymphocyte in functional terms is not yet available, the phylogenetic origin of lymphoid cells can now be sketched on the basis of recent experimental studies. a. Hematogenous Organs and Evolution of the Spleen. As in the developing mammalian embryo, erythrogenic cells are the first hematogenous cells to be encountered in the lowest vertebrates, as described by Jordan (1938) and Jordan and Speidel (1930). In hagfish peripheral blood, large nucleated erythroid cells are the most nbmerous cell type. Occasional cells with granules, and with bilobed or multilobed nuclei, are presumed to be protogranulocytes. Another distinctive cell type is the spindle cell, thought to be a thrombocyte. A smaller round cell, with a thin rim of basophilic cytoplasm, reminiscent of the lymphocytes of higher vertebrates, is seen in the hagfish. Jordan (1938) described this cell as a lymphoid hemoblast, and suggested that it is a primitive precursor of the other blood cells. In the absence of studies with isotope labels and other markers, conclusions about the interrelationships of the blood cells in this species must remain tentative. However, the failure of immunologic response, the apparent lack of lymphocytopoietic centers, and the absence of other cells resembling the lymphoid cell line of higher vertebrates suggest that the small round cell of the hagfish peripheral blood may be a precursor of the erythrocyte or thrombocyte cell lines rather than a lymphocyte as we conceive of this cell in mammalian blood. It is clear, from extensive studies of the hagfish involving vigorous efforts at immunization with a variety of antigens, that it lacks cells morphologically identifiable as being of the plasma cell system. Further evidence of the hagfish's lack of a lymphoid cell system comparable to that of higher forms is derived from examination of the hemocytopoietic tissue in the submucosa of the gut tract and liver. The gut tract accumulation of cells represents the most primitive state of splenic
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
89
development. These cells, budding from the vascular endothelium in the gut and liver, are the main source of the primitive erythroblasts of the peripheral blood; however, there is little difference in the stages of cellular development observed in the peripheral blood and in these hematogenous centers scattered diffusely throughout the length of the gut tract. Most significant from the immunologic standpoint is the absence of focal accumulations of lymphocytes anywhere in the hagfish-a conclusion we reached after thorough examination of sample serial sections through these animals. In the lamprey, there is an advance of splenic organization into a central hemocytopoietic organ. The epithelium forms a fold inward and surrounds the hemocytopoietic tissue more or less as a pedicle in the anterior gut. This is true of the larval lamprey and recently transformed young adult; but in the spawning lamprey, the gut tract spleen has been replaced with fibrotic tissue, and the hematogenous tissue is found in the cartilaginous vertebral arch. This represents the most primitive beginning of intramedullary hematopoiesis. No clear lymphoid follicles or aggregates have been seen in these hematopoietic centers; however, the lamprey's peripheral blood contains cells which appear to represent a lymphoid developmental sequence. In the elasmobranch and holostean fishes, and in all higher vertebrates, the spleen, in addition to being erythropoietic and granulocytopoietic, also contains focal accumulations of large, medium, and small lymphocytes, and, after antigenic stimulation, basophilic cells resembling the plasma cell series. There is red and white pulp in the spleen of elasmobranchs and bony fishes, but the follicular accumulations of lymphoid cells are not as well organized as in chickens and mammals. Thus, the mere appearance of splenic tissue in evolution does not correlate with the evolution of adaptive immunity, but the appearance of organized lymphoid tissues in the fishes above the cyclostome level correlates very well with the presence of immunologic reactivity (Papermaster et ul., 1963). This relationship becomes even more obvious after a consideration of the phylogenetic development of the thymus and its role in lymphocytopoiesis. b. Evolution of the Thymus. In contrast to the paucity of studies on the immune response, hemocytopoietic tissue, and blood cells of lower vertebrates, is the abundant literature on the comparative anatomy, embryology, and histology of the thymus up to the 1930's, stimulated by the intense interest in the thymus as an endocrine organ around 1900. Studies on the phylogeny of the thymus have been reviewed by Maurer
90
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
(1906), Salkind ( 1915), and Hammar (1936). Miiller ( 1871) found no evidence of definitive thymus tissue in the protochordates and hagfish. His observations were confirmed by Cole (1906) and Stockard (1906) in their studies of the hagfish thyroid. In the lamprey, there is no clear indication of development of a lymphoid thymus, but a primitive epithelial thymus seems to exist (Salkind, 1915). Our own studies on the hagfish and on larval and adult lampreys have confirmed the findings of these early investigators. An epithelial thymus is evident in the early embryonic thornback ray, but in newborn rays the thymus is lymphoid and remains SO, as was demonstrated by Beard in 1894 and 1900. Studies on the thymus of teleost fish were reported by Maurer (1886) and Hammar (1908). All species of teleost fish studied possess a clearly definable lymphoid thymus ( Salkind, 1915). A relatively complete study of the development of the thymus in the dogfish, Amia culua, was reported by Hill (1935). Investigations on the development of the thymus in amphibia before, during, and after metamorphosis were first reported by Maurer (1887) and extended by others (Rogers, 1918; Baldwin, 1918; B. M. Allen, 1920; Hoskins, 1921; Choi, 1931a,b). Hammar (1936) reviewed anatomic studies of the thymus of reptiles, avians, and mammals. Earlier reviews were those of Salkind (1915) on fish, reptiles, and avians, of Jolly (1923) on avians, and of Maximow (1909) on mammals. In those fishes in which'the thymus is unequivocally present as a lymphoid organ, elasmobranchs and all higher fishes, it is usually associated with every gill pouch, where it develops in a position dorsal to the gill arch epithelium. Examination of our own material has confirmed the histologic observations of Beard ( 1894). A well-developed cortex and medulla were noted in the thymus above the gill arches in the day-old guitarfish (Rhinobatos productus), a common California ray referred to earlier. A similar situation exists in Amia culuu and the higher bony fishes. In amphibians, during the larval period, the thymus is intimately associated with the gill arch, but during metamorphosis, these form more compact bodies (Maurer, 1886) and are more like the structures encountered in higher vertebrates, avians, and mammals. In reptiles and avians, the thymus is a lobulated mass of tissue running the length of the neck, bilaterally, whereas in mammals the thymus is a pair of glands in the anterior, ventral part of the thorax. The thymus may, however, be cervical in mammals, as in the guinea pig, and cervical and thoracic bodies may be present. In other instances, as in man, the thymus may be primarily thoracic, but ectopic thymus tissue may reflect the complex embryologic origin in the gill pouches of the embryo.
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
91
9. The Vertebrate Immunologic System and the Cellular Basis of Adaptive Immunity
a. Vertebrate Zmmunologic System. The foregoing discussion has emphasized the difference between the protective mechanisms of invertebrates and vertebrates. That the invertebrates have ample means of protection from saprophytic and pathogenic microorganisms is evident, particularly from the studies of Cameron (1932, 1934). These protective devices consist primarily of phagocytosis and encapsulation; however, humoral bactericidal substances are also a protective adjunct, and have been most extensively investigated in Lepidoptera (Bernheimer et al., 1952; Briggs, 1958).Surviving infection in the invertebrates depends on the outcome of the host-parasite relationship just as it does in mammals; and, from studies reported thus far, the invertebrate host seems to be no less successful than the mammal in the outcome of infection. The evolution of the vertebrate immunologic system, if it is considered in a broader biologic perspective, presents a more complicated picture. Even a superficial examination of the reactive elements in an advanced vertebrate’s immunologic armamentarium discloses that all or nearly all the invertebrate mechanisms are retained in some form. Histiocytes and macrophages in tissues, and polymorphonuclear leucocytes of the peripheral blood actively phagocytize foreign particles. The distribution and function of these cells was quite completely described by Aschoff (1924) who termed the functioning elements the reticuloendothelial system. Most authors have also included immunologically competent cells as part of the reticulo-endothelial system in mammals, and justifiably so. As Thorbecke and Benacerraf (1982) and Biozzi et al. (1960) have shown, the phagocytic uptake of bacteria is enhanced in the immune host. Also, in the in uitro system of antibody production under study by Fishman (1959, 1961), phagocytic elements seem to play a key role in initiation of antibody synthesis. The normally occurring bactericidal substances in mammalian serum have also been studied carefully; a complete discussion of these is found in the review by Skarnes and Watson (1957). Thus, with the evolutionary legacy from the invertebrates consisting of both humoral and cellular components, we may usefully inquire into the reasons for the development of immunologically reactive cells in the more advanced vertebrates. b. Immunocytes (Lymphoid Cells). In earlier portions of this review, the lymphoid cells of the vertebrates above the level of cyclostomes have been deaIt with as a group, with little consideration of
92
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
specific cell types. As has been noted, present knowledge of these cells is inadequate: nomenclature, based on morphology, is controversial, and functional markers for lymphocytes are lacking. Most morphologists agree that lymphocytes can be classified as small, medium, or large, on the basis of cell diameter, and nuclear and cytoplasmic morphologic features. Another cell of the lymphoid series, of obvious importance as an immunocyte, is the plasma cell, the antibody-secreting cell. The relationship of lymphocytes and plasma cells has been discussed in previous reviews by Sundberg (1955,1960) and Good ( 1957a). Recently, Gowans (1962) has completed experiments on the transformation of the small lymphocytes to the immunocyte system in immune reactions in rats. By using lymphocytes labeled with Hs-adenosine, Hs-thymidine, and HSleucine, and chromosome marker differences between rat and mouse cells, he has shown that the small lymphocytes can transform, directly or by division, into cells with the morphologic appearance of young plasma cells. Production of a thoracic duct fistula, with subsequent depletion of the circulating small lymphocytes, removes the ability of the deprived animal to give a primary response to antigenic stimulation ( McGregor and Gowans, 1963). In bullfrog larvae, Hildemann and Haas (1962) were able to correlate the ontogenetic development of homograft immunity with the appearance of small lymphocytes in the peripheral blood. In chickens, both Terasaki (1959) and Szenberg and Warner (1961) have found large lymphocytes to be the reactive cells in the graft-versus-host reaction. Species differences, notwithstanding conflicting studies on the nature of reactive immunocytes, will likely be resolved when the entire cycle of lymphocytopoiesis and lymphocyte maturation is understood more completely. The inclusion of the thymus in this process has been discussed in the section on ontogeny. At present, the following concepts appear to be consistent with experimental data. Antigens in the form of cells, particulate macromolecules, or smaller soluble polysaccharides are taken up by macrophages in the reticulo-endothelial organs (Campbell and Garvey, 1960) and perhaps by lymphoid cells directly. At some stage of their development, lymphoid cells-presumably small lymphocytes in most species-become sensitized to antigens and mature into antibody-producing cells or participate directly in cytotoxic reactions. The advance in vertebrate immunologic evolution appears to lie in the ability of certain cells, presumably lymphoid cells, to discern antigenic structural differences. The studies quoted above have indicated that this ability most likely became manifest early in the evolution of
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNJTY
93
the primitive fishes. The association of the thymus with this process was also emphasized. Recently, Triplett ( 1962) has demonstrated that the immunologic recognition process can be analyzed in the ontogeny of amphibian vertebrates. In his experiments, removal of the adenohypophysis at the early larval stage, propagating it in allogeneic embryos and re-implanting it at a later stage of maturation in the host of origin led to rejection of the organ. We would suggest that the development of immunologic recognition in this species parallels the development of the thymus in the early larva. The change from a state of tolerance to recognition of antigenic properties may reflect the maturation of the thymus from a primarily epithelial organ to a lymphoid one. Triplett’s experiments illustrate the usefulness of these lower vertebrates with prolonged maturation periods in analysis of problems in developmental immunobiology. The use of amphibians in the ontogenetic studies of the cellular basis for immunologic recognition is now well established as a result of this work of Hildemann and Haas and Triplett. A concerted effort in these animals, with more detailed analysis at the morphologic level, would appear to be worth while in efforts to establish the reactions of various cell types to a variety of antigenic stimuli during development. c. The Vertebrate Immune Response and Tumor Immunity. A more refined immunologic recognition system is clearly evident in the evolution of higher vertebrates. We can hardly afford to restrict the scope of immunologic inquiry to the classical concept of infectious diseases and protection mechanisms, when the infectious nature of nucleic acids from viruses and tumor cells has been clearly demonstrated (Holland et al., 1959; Ito and Evans, 1961) in intact mammals and mammalian cells cultured in oitro. A recent report (Johnstone, 1962) collecting current information on tumor immunity provides evidence from a number of laboratories that tumor cells may be antigenically different from normal somatic cells. Antigenic differences between methylcholanthreneinduced sarcomas and normal host tissues have been reported by Prehn and Main ( 1957) and by Klein et al. ( 1960). Tumors induced by polyoma virus contain antigens not found in normal cells (Habel, 1962). Recent studies by H. Rubin (1961, 1962a) on the immunologic reactions to Rous sarcoma in chickens indicate that birds made tolerant to Rousassociated virus were susceptible to progressive tumor growth. In further studies, H. Rubin (1962b) was able to relate the limitation of tumor spread in d u o and the destruction of tumor cells in vitro directly to the cytotoxic activity of lymphocytes, With the evolution of definitive organ sites for specialized functions
94
ROBERT A. GOOD AM) BEN W. PAPERMASTER
and the concomitant development of appropriately differentiated cells, a process for the sorting out and maintenance of cell structure might have evolved concurrently. Malfunction of differentiated cells in vertebrates is often characterized by tumorous or malignant growth. Balls (1962) has reviewed the types of cancer in amphibians. Huxley (1956) has indicated that metastatic tumors of a lethal nature, comparable to those in vertebrates, are poorly documented in invertebrates. The publication of Scharrer and Lochhead (1950) suggests that tumors may occur in invertebrates, but they are unusual and have often not been clearly separated from the inflammatory and walling-off reactions in these animals. We are aware of no reports of malignancy in cyclostomes. Thus, lymphoid cells, and an organ associated with their formation and control, the thymus, may have evolved to subserve the peculiar function of “policing somatic cell surfaces by detecting antigenic changes. Such surface changes may herald the formation of a cell line no longer susceptible to aggregational and other ordering forces associated with the differentiation and maintenance of normal organ structure. Immunologic regulation of somatic cell changes, and subsequent malignant development, as a result of mutation or virus cell transformation, has been suggested by Thomas (1959) and Burnet ( 1962). Indeed, adaptive immunity in vertebrates may have evolved as a mechanism for facilitating tumor cell recognition and disposal. The finding of Prehn and Main (1957) that tumors which overcome the host’s natural defenses and thus arise spontaneously in mice do not have recognizable antigenicity would be compatible with this hypothesis. IV. Concluding Statement
Without attempting to summarize what are, in reality, already summary statements on the wide range of topics considered under the overall heading of the ontogeny and phylogeny of immunity, we should like, very briefly, to suggest a view of the areas of most significant development in recent years. Surely one of these is that immunologic maturation starts earlier than we supposed, say 5 years ago, and probably continues longer. At least two major factors played a role here: the tendency to think of birth or hatching as more of a break in the continuum of immunologic development than it probably is, and the overgeneralization of findings of studies employing simple protein antigens in the newborn. It is clearly possible, with appropriate antigens, to evoke plasma cell formation and antibody production before birth in a number of mammalian species, including man. The immunologic inertia of late fetal life
ONTOCENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
95
and the early months of postnatal life is real and certainly has important implications for the clinician, but a latent capacity to respond when the stimulus is sufficiently intense is clearly present well before birth in man. The role of the 19s ( fi2Y7 or yla) globulins in t h i s development is particularly significant. The progression of immunologic development well beyond the newborn period, in some experimental animals at least, and probably in mammalian species generally, has also been emphasized, in the findings of the growing immunologic competence of peripheral spleen cells of mice well into adult life, and in the experiments on “immunologic arrest” in mice totally thymectomized well after the neonatal period. A parallel development has been the shift away from the concept of “tolerance responsiveness” as an exclusive function of immunologic immaturity. Age is clearly a relative barrier here, and evidence of development of immunologic reactivity is also observed in development of the increasing barrier to production of specific immunologic negativity as the animals proceed toward maturity. Immunologic negativity, whether to homografts or other forms of antigenic challenge, and whether induced in young or older organisms, seems to be basically the same kind of specific central immunologic failure. The role of the thymus in mammals, and the bursa of Fabricius in chickens, in the development of immunologic competence both before and after birth has placed a new focus on the ontogeny of the lymphoid tissues and the lymphoid system of cells. Data on a wide range of species are accumulating indicating that the thymus is the first organ to show lymphoid development, whether this occurs well before birth, as in man, or shortly before birth or hatching, as in the mouse or chicken, or after birth, as in the opossum. It seems probable that there is no immunologic reactivity of the embryo before there is lymphoid development of the thymus. Both clinical and experimental data are accumulating in support of the thesis that absence of the thymus during the period of development of the peripheral lymphoid tissues results in both abnormal lymphoid development and immunologic deficiency. A consideration of the role of other primary lymphoid tissue, presumably thymusindependent, is just beginning. In phylogeny, the data suggest that the transition to adaptive immunity occurs in the lower vertebrates and that it is paralleled by the development of a lymphoid thymus, other organized lymphoid tissues, and the lymphoid system of cells. However, thus far, the studies of the lower fishes have not been sufficiently comprehensive, and much remains to
96
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
be done, particularly with the more sophisticated methods of protein chemistry which are yielding such important information concerning the nature and interrelationships of the immunoglobulins (R. R. Porter, 1959; Nisonoff et al., 1960, 1961; Fudenberg et al., 1962; Franklin et al., 1962; Harboe et al., 1962; review of R. R. Porter and E. M. Press, 1962). REFERENCES
Ackerman, G. A. ( 1962). J . Cell Biol. 13, 127-148. Ackerman, G. A., and Knouff, R. A. (1959).Am. J. Anut. 104, 183-205. Ackerman, G. A., and Knouff, R. A. (1984).In “The Thymus in Immunobiology” (R. A. Good and A. E. Gabrielsen, eds. ), pp. 123-146.Hoeber-Harper, New York. Adamson, C. A., Lofgren, S . , and Malmnas, C. (1951). S c a d . J. Clin. Lab. Inuest. 3, 52-57. Adelsberger, L. ( 1927). 2. Kfnderheilk. 43, 373-390. Albert, F., Lejeune-Ledant, G., Moureau, P., and Andrk, A. (1959).In “The Biological Problems of Grafting,” Symposium, Liege (F. Albert and G. LejeuneLedant, eds. ), pp. 369-379.Thomas, Springfield, Illinois. Allen, B. M. (1920).J. Exptl. Zool. 30, 189-197. Allen, F. W., and McDaniel, E. C. (1937).J . Immunol. 32, 143-152. Amick, F. E.,Alden, M. W., and Sweet, L. K. (1950).Pediatrics 6, 384-390. Anderson, D.,Billingham, R. E., Lampkin, G. H., and Medawar, P. B. ( 1951). Heredity 5, 379-397. Anderson, S . G., and Hamilton, J. (1949).Med. 1. Australia I, 308-311. Ando, S . ( 1930).Kaibo 2. ( Tokyo) 3, 781-780,781-795,827-833,834-837,979-998 (abstr. in Japan. J . Med. Sci. (Anut.) 3, 108-109,1933). Archer, 0.K., and Pierce, J. C. (1961).Federation Proc. a0, 26. Archer, 0. K., Pierce, J. C., Papermaster, B. W., and Good, R. A. (1982).Nature 195, 191-192. Archer, 0. K., Papermaster, B. W., and Good, R. A. (1984).In “The Thymus in Immunobiology” (R. A. Good and A. E. Gabrielsen, eds.), pp. 414-431.HoeberHarper, New York. Archer, 0. K., Kelly, W. D., Papermaster, B. W., and Good, R. A. (1983b).Federation Proc. 22, 599. Archer, 0.K., Sutherland, D. E. R., and Good, R. A. (lgmb).Nature 200, 337-339. Amason, B. G., Jankovib, B. D., Waksman, B. H., and Wennersten, C. (1962a). J . Exptl. Med. 116, 177-188. Amason, B. G., Jankovi6, B. D., and Waksman, B. H. (1962b).Nature 194, 99-100. Aschoff, L. (1924).Ergeb. Inn. Med. Kinderheilk. 26, 1-118. Aspinall, R. L., and Meyer, R. K. ( 1984). In “The Thymus in Immunobiology” ( R. A. Good and A. E. Gabrielsen, eds.), pp. 376-392.Hoeber-Harper, New York. Auerbach, R. (1980).Deuelop. Biol. 2, 271-284. Auerbach, R. (1981a).Deuelop. Biol. 3, 338-354. Auerbach, R. (1961b).Proc. Natl. Acud. Sci. U.S . 47, 1175-1181. Auerbach, R. ( 1964). In “The Thymus in Immunobiology” (R. A. Good and A. E. Gabrielsen, eds. ), pp. 95-111.Hoeber-Harper, New York. Augustin, R. (1980).I n “Mechanisms of Antibody Formation” (M. Holub and L. JaroHkovP, eds. 1, pp. 94-104. Publishing House Czech. Acad. Sci., Prague.
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
97
Aust, J, B., Martinez, C., and Good, R. A. (1957). Proc. Am. Assoc. Cancer Res. 2, 185. Aust, J. B., Martinez, C., and Guttmann, R. D. (1960). Surg. Forum 10, 26-27. Aycock, W.L., and Kramer, S. D. (1930). 1. Erptl. Med. 52, 457-464. Badertscher, J. A. (1915). Am. 1. Anut. 17, 437-493. Baer, J. G. (1944). Schweiz. 2. Allgem. Pathol. Bakteriol. 7 , 442-462. Baldwin, F. M. (1918). J. Morphol. 30,605-675. Ball, W. D. (1963). Exptl. Cell. Res. 31, 82-88. Ball, W. D., and Auerbach, R. (1960). Exptl. Cell Res. 20, 245-247. Balls, M. (1962). Cancer Res. 22, 1142-1154. Baney, R. N., Vazquez, J. J., and Dixon, F. J. (1962). Proc. SOC. Exptl. Biol. Med. 109, 1-4. Bang, F. B. (1961). Biol. Bull. 121, 57-68. Bangham, D. R. (1960). J. Physiol. (London) 153, 265-289. Bangham, D. R. (1961). Proc. Roy. SOC. Med. 54, 993-996. Bangham, D. R., Hobbs, K. R., and Terry, R. J. (1958a). Lancet 11, 351-354. Bangham, D. R., Ingram, P. L., Roy, J. H. B., Shillam, K. W. G., and Terry, R. J. (1958b). Proc. Roy. SOC. (London) B149, 184-191. Bardawil, W. A., Toy, B. L., and Hertig, A. T. (1958). Am. 1. Obstet. Gynecol. 75, 708-717. Baril, E. F., Palmer, J. L., and Bartel, A. H. ( 1961). Science 133, 278-279. Barnes, H.A. (1909). Trans. Am. Laryngol. Assoc. 31, 156-161. Bamett, J. A., and Grey, H. ( 1962). Unpublished observations. Battisto, J. R., and Miller, J. (1962). Federation Proc. 21, 27. Baumgartner, L. (1934). Yale J . Biol. Med. 6, 403-434. Beard, J, (1894). Anut. Anz. 9, 476-486. Beard, J. (1900). Anut. Anz. 18, 550-560, 561-573. Behring and Kitasato. (1890). Deut. Med. Wochschr. 16, 1113-1114. Bell, E. T. (1906). Am. J. Anat. 5, 29-62. Remard, Lo, and Deb& R. (1929). Cited by Calmette ( 1929). Bemheimer, A. W. (1952). Science 115, 150-151. Bemheimer, A. W., Caspari, E., and Kaiser, A. D. (1952). J . Exptl. Zool. 119,23-35. Berrill, N. J. ( 1955). “The Origin of Vertebrates.” Oxford Univ. Press (Clarendon), London and New York. Beutner, E. H., Witebsky, E., Ricken, D., and Adler, R. H. (1962). J . Am. Med. Assoc. 182, 46-58. Beveridge, W. I. B., and Burnet, F. M. (1946). Med. Res. Cuuncil (Brit.), Spec. R e p . Ser. 258. Biemng, F. (1960). Ciba Found. Symp., Haemopoiesis pp. 185-198. Billingham, R. E. (1958). In “The Chemical Basis of Development” ( W . D. McElroy and B. Glass, eds.), pp. 575-592. Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore, Maryland. Billingham, R. E., and Brent, L. (1957). Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 69, 678-680. Billingham, R. E., and Brent, L. (1959). Phil. Trans. Roy. SOC. B W , 439-477. Billingham, R. E., and Hildemann, W. H. (1958). Ann. N . Y. Acad. Sci. 73, 676685. Billingham, R. E., Lampkin, G. H., Medawar, P. B., and Williams, L. H. (1952). Heredity 6, 201-212. Billingham, R. E., Brent, L., and Medawar, P. B. (1953). Nature 172, 603-606.
98
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
Billingham, R. E., Brent, L., and Medawar, P. B. (1956). Phil. Trans. Roy. SOC. B239, 357-414. Billingham, R. E., Ferringan, L. W., and Silvers, W. K. (1960).Science 132, 1488. Biozzi, G., Howard, J. G., Halpem, B. N., Stiffel, C., and Mouton, D. (1960). Immunology 3, 74-89. Bishop, D. W., and Gump, D. (1961).Proc. SOC. Exptl. B i d . Med. 108, 24-27. Bisset, K. A. (1947).J . Hyg. 45, 128-135. Bisset, K. A. (1948).J. Pathol. Bacteriol. 60, 87-92. Bisset, K. A. (1949). J. EndocFinol. 6, 99-103. Bymeboe, M., and Gormsen, H. (1943).Acta Pathol. Microbiol. Scand. 20, 649-692. Block, M. ( 1964). Ergeb. Anat. Entwicklungsgesch. 37, 234-366. Boder, E.,and Sedgwick, R. P. (1958).Pedtutrics 21, 526-554. Bowden, D. H.( 1963).Personal communication. Boyden, E. A. (1922).Am. J. Anat. 30, 163-201. Bradford, W. L., Day, E.,and Martin, F. (1949).Pediatrics 4, 711-718. Brambell, F. W. R. (1958). Btol. Reu. 33, 488-531. Brambcll, F. W. R. (1961).Proc. Roy. SOC. Med. 54, 992-993. Brambell, F. W. R. (1962).Proc. Conf. on Immunoreproductton, La Jolla, Calif., 1962 pp. 231-239 (Population Council, New York). Brent, L. (1958).Progr. Allergy 5, 271-348. Brent, L., and Gowland, G. (1962). Nature 198, 1298-1301. Bridges, R. A., Condie, R. M., Zak, S. J., and Good, R. A. (1959).J. Lab. Cltn. Med. 53, 331-357. Briggs, J. D. (1958).1. Ezptl. Zool. 138, 155-188. Broman, B. (1947). Actu Paediat. 36, 585-598. Bumet, F. M. (1941).Australian J. Exptl. Biol. Med. Sct. 19, 291-295. Bumet, F. M. (1959).“The Clonal Selection Theory of Acquired Immunity,” Abraham Flexner Lecture, 1958. Vanderbilt Univ. Press, Nashville, Tennessee. Bumet, F. M. ( 1962). “The Integrity of the Body.” Harvard Univ. Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts. Bumet, F. M., and Fenner, F, (1949). “The Production of Antibodies,” 2nd ed. Macmillan, Melbourne ( New York, 1950 ) . Bumet, F. M., Stone, J. D., and Edney, M. (1950).Australian J. Exptl. Btol. Med. S C ~ 28, . 291-297. Bumet, F. M., and Holmes, M. C. (1962).Nature 194, 146. Burnet, F. M., and Holmes, M. C. (1964). In “The Thymus in Immunobiology” (R.A. Good and A. E. Gabrielsen, eds.), pp. 655665. Burtin, P., Hartmann, L., Heremans, J. F., Scheidegger, J. J., Westendorp-Boerma, F., Wieme, R., Wunderly, C., Fauvert, R., and Grabar, P. (1957). RBU. FranF. Etudes Clin. Btol. 2, 161-177. Bwton, A. (1954).1. Gen. Mlcroblol. 10, 398-410. Calhoun, M. L. (1933).Iowa State Coll. J. Sct. 7 , 261-382. Calmette, A. (1929).2. Tuberk. 53, 193-198. Calmette, A., and Gubrin, C. (1929).Cited by Calmette (1929). Cameron, G. R. (1932).J. Pathol. Bacteriol. 35, 933-972. Cameron, G. R. (1934). J . Puthol. Bacteriol. 38, 441-466. Campana, L. (1938).Mondtme Zool. Ital. 48, Suppl., 287-289. Campbell, D. H., and Garvey, J. S. (1960).J. Infectious Diseases 107, 15-28. Cannon, J. A., Terasaki, P. I., and Longmire, W. P. (1958). Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 73, 862-868.
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNJTY
99
Cantacuzhne, J. (1912). Compt. Rend. SOC. Bid. 73, 663-664, Cantacuzhe, J. (1916).Compt. Rend. SOC. B i d . 79, 528-530. Cantacuzhne, J. (1919). Compt. Rend. SOC. B i d . 82, 1019-1022. Cantacuzkme, J. ( 1922). Compt. Rend. SOC. Biol. 87, 264-267. Cantacuzhne, J. (1923).I n “CBlbbration du 75me anniversaire de la fondation de la SociBtB de Biologie,” pp. 48-119. Masson, Paris. Castleman, B., and Norris, E. A. (1949).Medicine 28, 27-58. Chang, T. S., Rheins, M. S., and Winter, A. R. (1957).Poultry Sci. 36, 376-378. Chang, T. S., Rheins, M. S., and Winter, A. R. (1958).Poultry Sci. 37, 1091-1093. Chase, M.W. (1946).Proc. SOC. Exptl. B i d . Med. 61, 257-259. Chase, M. W. ( 1958). In “Bacterial and Mycotic Infections of Man” (R. J. Dubos, ed. ) , 3rd ed., pp. 149-196. Lippincott, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Chase, M. W. (1959).Ann. Rev. Microbial. 13, 349-376. Choi, M. H. (1931a).FoZia Anat. Japon. 9,487-494. Choi, M. H. (1961b).FoZia Anut. Japon. 9, 495-503. Chorine, V. (1927).Compt. Rend. SOC. Biol. 97, 1395-1397. Cinader, B., and Dubert, J. M. (1955).Brit. J. Ex$. Pathol. 36, 515-529. Cinader, B., and Dubert, J. M. (1956).Proc. Roy. SOC. (London) B146, 18-33. Clark, A. H. (1912).Am. J . Anat. 14, 47-62. Clark, S. L. (1959).J. Biophys. Biochem. Cytol. 5, 41-50. Clem, L. W., and Sigel, M. M. (1983).Federation Proc. 22, 1139-1144. Coca, A. F.,Russell, E. F., and Baughman, W. H. (1921).1. Immunol. 6, 387-398. Cochrane, C. G., and Dixon, F. J. (1962).Aduan. Immunol. 2, 205-239. Cock, A. G., and Simonsen, M. (1958).Immunology 1, 103-110. Cohen, C., ed. (1962).Ann. N . Y. Acad. Sci. 97, 1-328. Cohen, E. (1955).BioZ. Bull. 109, 394-403. Cohen, P., and Scadron, S . J. (1943).J. Am. Med. Assoc. 121, 658-662. Cohen, P., and Scadron, S. J. (1946).J. Pediat. 29, 609-619. Colbert, E. H. (1955).“Evolution of the Vertebrates: A History of the Backboned Animals through Time.” Wiley, New York. Cole, F. J. (1906).Anut. Anz. m, 323-326. Condie, R. M. ( 1962) . Personal communication. Condie, R. M., Kelly, J. T., Campbell, B., and Good, R. A. (1957).Federation Proc.
16, 24. Condie, R. M., Miller, C., Pih, K., and Monsen, G. ( 1960).Unpublished observations. Cooke, J. V, (1927).Am. J. Diseases Children 34, 969-978. Coons, A. H.,Leduc, E. H., and Connolly, J. M. (1955).J . Exptl. Med. 102, 49-60. Cuenot, L. (1896).Compt. Rend. Acad. Sci. 123, 1078-1079. Cushing, J. E., Jr. (1942).J. Immunol. 45, 123-126. Cushing, J. E.,Jr. (1957).B i d . Bull. 113, 327. Cushing, J. E., Jr. (1962).Proc. Conf. on Immunoreproductbn, La J o b , Calif., 1962 pp. 205-207 (Population Council, New York). Cushing, J. E., Jr., and Campbell, D. H. (1957).“Principles of Immunology.” McGraw-Hill, New York. Cushing, J. E., Jr., and Sprague, L. (1953).Am. Naturalist 87, 307-315. Cushing, J. E.,Jr., and Stormont, C. (1962).Am. Naturalist 96,193-246. Dalmasso, A. P., Martinez, C., and Good, R. A. (1962a).Proc. SOC. Exptl. B i d .
Med. 110, 205-208. Dalmasso, A. P., Martinez, C., and Good, R. A. (1962b).Proc. SOC. Erptl. Biol. Med. 111, 143-146.
100
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
Dalmasso, A. P., Martinez, C., and Good, R. A. (1964).In “The Thymus in Immunobiology” (R. A. Good and A. E. Gabrielsen, eds.), pp. 478-489.Hoeber-Harper, New York. Dalmasso, A. P., Martinez, C., Sjodin, K., and Good, R. A. (1983).J. Exptl. Med. 118, 1089-1109. Dameshek, W. ( 1964).In “The Thymus in Immunobiology” (R.A. Good and A. E. Gabrielsen, eds. ), p. 738. Hoeber-Harper, New York. Dancis, J,, Braverman, N., and Lind, J. (1957).J. Clin. Inuest. 38, 398-404. Dancis, J., Samuels, B. D., and Douglas, G. W. (1962).Science 138, 382-383. Danforth, C.H. (1929).Arch. Entwicklungmech. Organ. 118, 242-252. Danforth, C. H., and Foster, F. (1929).1. Erptl. Zool. 52, 443-470. Davis, B. D., Moore, D. H., Kabat, E. A., and Harris, A. (1945).J . Immunol. 50, 1-20. Davis, D. J. (1912).J. Infectious Diseases 10, 142-181. Davis, S. F.,Finley, S. C., and Hare, W. K. (1960).J. Pediat. 57, 221-224. Defendi, V., Roosa, R. A., and Koprowski, H. (1984).In “The Thymus in Immunobiology” (R. A. Good and A. E. Gabrielsen, eds.), pp. 504-521.Hoeber-Harper, New York. Deichmiller, M. P., and Dixon, F. J. (1957).Federation Proc. 18,410-411. Deichmiller, M. P., and Dixon, F. J. (1960).J . Cen. Physiol. 43, 1047-1059. Denz, F. A. (1947).J . Pathol. Bacteriol. 59, 575-591. Deutsch, H.F., and Koenig, V. L. (1956).In “Handbook of Biological Data” (W. S. Spector, ed. ), pp. 55-56. Saunders, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Deutsch, H. F., Alberty, R. A,, and Gosting, L. J. (1948).J. B i d . Chem. 185, 21-35. Deutsch, L. (1899).Ann. Inst. Pusteur 13, 689-727. Dietel, V., and Lohmann, D. (1960).Z.Kinderheilk. 84, 560-584. di Sant’Agnese, P. A. (1949).Pediatrics 3, 333-344. Dixon, F. J., and Maurer, P. H. (1955).J. Exptl. Med. 101, 245-257. Dixon, F. J., and Weigle, W. 0. (1957).J. Exptl. Med. 105, 75-83. Dixon, F. J., and Weigle, W. 0. (1959).J . Exptl. Med. 110, 139-146. Downs, C. M. (1928).J . Immunol. 15, 77-81. Dresser, D. W. (1961).Immunology 4, 13-23. Dresser, D. W. (1962).Immunology 5, 378-388. Dreyer, N. B., and King, J. W. (1948).J. Immunol. 80, 277-282. Dunham, E. C. (1932).Am. J. Diseases Chtldren 43, 317-321. Eakin, R. M., and Harris, M. (1945).J. Exptl. Zool. 98, 35-64. Eastlick, H. L. (1941).Physiol. 2061. 14, 136-143. Ebert, J. D., and Delanney, L. E. (1960).Natl. Cancer Inst. Monograph 2, 73-111. Edgerton, M. T., and Morrel, S. C. (1961).Surg. Forum. 12, 471-472. Egdahl, R. H. ( 1957). Ph.D. Thesis, University of Minnesota. EMch, W. (1929).Am. I . Anut. 43,347-383. Ehrich, W.E., and Seifter, J. (1948).A.M.A. Arch. Pathol. 45, 239-245. Ehrich, W. E., Drabkin, D. L., and Forman, C. (1949).J. Ezptl. Med. 90, 157-187. Ehrlich, P. (1892).Z.H y g . Infectionskrankh. 12, 183-203. Eichenwald, H. F. ( 1963).Personal communication. Eichenwald, H. F., and Kotsevalov, 0. (1960).Pediatrics 25, 829-839. Elek, S. D., Rees, T. A., and Cowing, N. F. (1962). Comp. Biochem. Physiol. 7 , 255-267. Enders, J. F. (1944).J. Clin. Inuest. 23, 510-530.
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
101
Engle, R. L., Jr., and Woods, K. R. (1957). Biol. BUZZ. 113, 363. Engle, R. L., Jr., and Woods, K. R. (1960). In “The Plasma Proteins,” (E. W. Putnam, ed.), Vol. 2, p. 183. Academic Press, New York. Engle, R. L., Jr., Woods, K. R., and Pert, J. H. (1958). J. Cltn. Inoest. 37, 892. Erickson, R. P. (1962). Transplant. Bull. 30, 137-141. Evans, E. E., and Cowles, R. B. (1959). Proc. SOC. Exptl. Biol. Med. 101, 482-483. Evans, E. E., and Horton, S. L. (1961). Proc. SOC. Exptl. B i d . Med. 107, 71-74. Fagraeus, A. (1948). Acta Med. Scand. Suppl. 204, 1-122. Fahey, J. L. (1962). Advan. Immunol. 2, 41-109. Favour, C. B. (1958). Ann. N . Y. Acad. Sci. 73, 590-598. F e l h a n , J. D. (1961). Lab. Inuest. 10, 238-255. Felton, L. D. (1949). J. Zmmunol. 61, 107-117. Felton, L. D., and Ottinger, B. (1942). J . Bacterial. 43, 94-95. Felton, L. D., Kauffmann, G., Prescott, B., and Ottinger, B. (1955a). J. Immunol. 74, 17-26. Felton, L. D., Prescott, B., Kauffmann, G., and Ottinger, B. (1955b). 1. Immunol. 74, 205-213. Fennestad, K. L., and Borg-Petersen, C. (1962). Acta Pathol. Microbiol. Scand. Suppl. 154, 307-308. Fichtelius, K. E. (1953). Acta Anut. 19 Suppl., 1-78. Fichtelius, K. E. (1958). Tram. 6th Congr. Eur. SOC. Haematol., Copenhagen, 1957 pp. Sll-S13 (Karger, Basel). Fichtelius, K. E., Laurell, G., and Philipsson, L. (1961). Acta Pathol. Microbiol. S c a d . 51, 81-86. Fink, C. W., LoSpalluto, J., Miller, W. E., Jr., and Donvard, B. (1961). Am. J. Diseases Children 102, 460-461. Fink, C. W., Miller, W. E., Jr., Donvard, B., and LoSpalluto, J. (1962). J. Clin. Inoest. 41, 1422-1428. Finstad, J., Papermaster, B. W., and Good, R. A. (1984). Lab. Inuest. (in press). Fireman, P., Vannier, W. E., and Goodman, H. C. (1963). J. Erptl. Med. 117, 603620.
Fisher, E. R. (1964). I n “The Thymus in Immunobiology” (R. A. Good and A. E. Gabrielsen, eds. ), pp. 676-726. Hoeber-Harper, New York. Fishman, M. (1959). Nature 183, 1200-1201. Fishman, M. (1961). J. Exptl. Med. 114, 837-856. Foerster, A. (1923). Arch. Pathol. Anut. Physlol. 241, 418-427. Forbes, W. A. (1877). Proc. Zool. SOC. (London) pp. 304-318. Forsen, N. R., and Condie, R. M. (1963). Federation Proc. 22, 500. Fowler, R., Jr., Schubert, W. K., and West, C. D. (1960). Ann. N . Y. Acad. Sci. 87, 403-423. Fox, J. P., and Laemmert, H. W., Jr. (1947). Am. J . H y g . 46, 21-40. Franek, F., Riha, I., and Stenl, J. (1961). Nature 189, 1020-1022. Frankenstein, C. (1920). Z. Kinderheilk. 25, 12-27. Franklin, E. C., and Kunkel, H. G. (1958). J . Lab. Clin. Med. 52, 724-727. Franklin, E. C., Holman, H. R., Miiller-Eberhard, H. J., and Kunkel, H. G. (1957). J . Erptl. Med. 105, 425-438. Franklin, E. C., Fudenberg, H., Meltzer, M., and Stanworth, D. R. (1962). Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. US. 48, 914-922. Freda, V. J. (1962). Am. J . Obstet. Gynecol. 84, 1756-1777.
101,
ROBERT A. GOOD AND BEN W. PAPERMASTER
Freund, J. (1927).J. Immunol. 13, 285-288. Freund, J. (1929).J. Immunol. 17, 485-471. Freund, J. (1930).J. Immunol. 18, 315-324. Priedberger, E.,and Heim, F. (1929).Deut. Med. Wochschr. 55, 132-133. Friedberger, E.,and Mita, S. (1911).2.Immunituetsfor3ch. 10, 382-387. Friedbcrger, E.,and Seelig, A. (1908).Zentr. Bakterfol. 48, 421-433. Friedberger, E.,and Simmel, H. ( 1913).2. Immunituetsforsch. 19, 480-487. Friedman, H., and Gaby, W. L. (1980).J. Immunol. 85,478-482. Fudenberg, H., Mandy, W. J., and Nisonoff, A. (1982).J. Clin. Inuest. 41, 21232134. Fujino, K., and Cushing, J. E. (1959). Sci. R e p . Whales Res. Inst. (Tokyo) 14, 101-108. Funkhouser, J. W. ( 1981). N e w Engl. J . Med. 264, 34-36. Gafni, J., Michaeli, D., and Heller, H. (1960).N e w Engl. J. Med. 263, 538-541. Gee, L. L., and Smith, W. W. (1941).1. Bactertol. 41, 288-267. Gibier, P. (1882).Compt. Rend. Acad. Sd. 94,1605-1808. Gilmour, J. R. (1941).J. Pathol. Bucterfol. 52, 25-55. Gitlin, D.,Monckeberg, F., and Craig, J. M. (1958).Am. J. Diseases Children 96, 498. Glaser, K., Limani, L. R., and Poncher, H. G. (1950).Pedtatrics 8, 789-824. Glick, B. (1958).PoUlty Sd.37, 240-241. Glick, B. ( 1984). In “The Thymus in Immunobiology” (R. A. Good and A. E. Gabrielsen, eds. ), pp. 343-358.Hoeber-Harper, New York. Glick, B., Chang, T. S., and Jaap, R. G. (1958).Poulty Sci. 35, 224-225. Goldstein, M., and Baxter, H. (1958).Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sd.73, 584-569. Good, R. A. (1952).Unpublished observations. Good, R. A. (1954).Bull. Uniu. Minn. Hosp. 243, 1-19, Good, R. A. (1957a). In “Host-Parasite Relationships in Living Cells” (H. Felton, ed.), pp. 78-155.Thomas, Springfield, Illinois. Good, R. A. (1957b).Am. J . Diseases Children 94,387. Good, R. A. (1980).Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 87, 425-428. Good, R. A. ( 1961 ) , Ann. Meeting Assoc. Immunologists, Atlantic City, New Jersey. Unpublished discussion. Good, R. A., and Papermaster, B, W. (1981).Federation Proc. 20, 26. Good, R. A,, and Varco, R. L. (1955).J.-Lancet 75, 245-271. Good, R. A., and Zak, S. J. (1958).Pediatrics 18, 109-149. Good, R. A., Kelly, W. D., Rotstein, J., and Varco, R. L. (1982a).Progr. Allergy 8, 187-319. Good, R. A,, Dalmasso, A. P., Martinez, C., Archer, 0. K., Pierce, J. C., and Papermaster, B. W. (1982b). J. Exptl. Med. 118, 773-798. Good, R. A., and Finstad, J. (1984). Ann. N . Y . Acad. Sci. (in press). Good, R. A., Martinez, C., and Gabrielsen, A. E. (1984a).In “The Thymus in Immunobiology” (R. A. Good and A. E. Gabrielsen, eds.), pp. 3-47. HoeberHarper, New York. Good, R. A,, Peterson, R. D. A., and Archer, 0. K. (1984b). Manuscript in preparation. Goodman, M. (1981).Human Biol. 33, 131-182. Goodman, M. (1982).Human B b l . 34, 104-150. Goodner, K, (1926).J. Immund. 11, 335-341.
ONTOGENY AND PHYLOGENY OF ADAPTIVE IMMUNITY
103
Gordon, R. S., Jr. (1953). J. Immunol. 71, 220-225. GOSS,R. J. (1981). Biol. BuU. 121, 182-172. Gowans, J. L. (1962). Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci. 99, 432-455. Gowland, G., and OaMey, C. L. (1960). J. Puthol. Bacteriol. 80, 373-378. Grabar, P. (1958). Proc. 3rd Intern. Congr. Blochem., Brussels, 1955 pp. 37-41 (Academic Press, New York). Grabar, P., and Williams, C. A. (1953). Blochim. Biophys. Actu 10, 193-194. Grady, R. C., and Zuelzer, W. W. (1955). A n . J . Diseases Children 90, 381-391. Grasset, E. (1929a). Compt. Rend. SOC.Biol. 101, 1102-1104. Grasset, E. (19291,). Puhl. S . Afr. Inst. Med. Rcs. 4, 171-190. Greene, H. S. N. ( 1955). In “Biological Specificity and Growth” (E. G. Butler, ed.), pp. 177-194. Princeton Univ. Press, Princeton, New Jersey. Grbgoire, C . L. (1945). Arch. Btol. (Lidge) 56, 325-350. Grey, H. (1982). Immunology 5, 803-609. Grey, H. (1963a). J . Immunol. 91, 819-825. Grey, H. ( 1983b). Personal communication. Grobstein, C. (1958). Exptl. Cell Res. 10, 424-440. Gugler, E., and von Muralt, G. (1959). Schweiz. Med. Wochschr. 89, 925-928. Gulland, G. L. (1894). J . Puthol. Bacteriol. 2, 447-485. Gundobin, N. (1908). Juhrb. Kinderhellk. 44, 529-539. Gustafsson, B. E., and Laurell, C. B. (1959). J . Exptl. Med. 110, 875-883. Gyllensten, L. (1950). Acta Anut. 10, 130-180. Gyllensten, L. (1953). Actu Anut. 17 Suppl. 18, 1-183. Habel, K. (1982). J . Exptl. Med. 115, 181-193. Hadzi, J. (1953). Systematic Zool. 2, 145-154. Hale, J. H., and Lee, L. H. (1954). J . Pathol. Bucteriol. 88