Advances in
MARINE BIOLOGY VOLUME 6
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
MARINE BIOLOGY VOLUME 6 Edited...
25 downloads
2976 Views
26MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in
MARINE BIOLOGY VOLUME 6
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
MARINE BIOLOGY VOLUME 6 Edited by
SIR FREDERICK S. RUSSELL Plymouth, England
and
SIR MAURICE YONGE Edinburgh, Scotland
Academic Press London and New York
1968
ACADEMIC
PRESS INC. (LONDON) LTD.
BERKELEY
.----.?. L
/ti
/ "
-
'
SQUARE HOUSE
BERKELEY
SQUARE
LONDON, W l X 6BA
U.S. Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS INC.
111
FIFTH AVENUE
NEW YORK, NEW YORK
10003
Copyright 0 1968 by Academic Press Inc. (London) Ltd.
All rights reserved
NO PART OF THIS BOOK MAY BE REPRODUCED IN ANY FORM B Y PHOTOSTAT, MICROFILM, OR ANY OTHER MEANS, WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHERS
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 6 3 - 1 4 0 4 0
PRINTED I N GREAT BRITAIN B Y THE WHITEFRIARS LONDON AND TONBRIDOE
PRESS LTD.
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 6 J. E. CARROZ, Legislation Research Branch, Department of Relations and Legal Affairs, F.A.O., Rome, Italy. .
Public
E. GHIRARDELLI, Istituto d i Zoologia oe Anatomia Gomparata della Universita d i Trieste, Ituly.
J. A. GULLAND, Department of Fisheries, F.A.O., Rome, Italy. W. MACNAE, Department of Zoology, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg,South Africa.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CONTENTS
..
..
v
..
..
..
1
11. The Need for Management . . .. .. A. The Depletion of Marine Resources. . B. Theoretical Studies . . .. ..
..
.. .. ..
7
16
111. Methods of Regulation .. .. .. A. Types of Regulation . . .. .. B. Limitation of the Amount of Fishing
.. ..
..
25
..
25
..
..
29
The Mechanics of Management and InternationalLaw . . A. Territorial Sea and Fishing Zones . . .. .. B. Specialized Fishery Bodies . . .. .. ..
34
45
..
.. .. .. ..
CONTRIBUTORSTO VOLUME6
..
..
..
of Fishery Resources
Management
J. A. GULLAND and J. E. CARROZ
I. Introduction . .
IV.
V.
VI.
VII.
..
..
..
Problems and Prospects for FutureProgress A. Achievements of Present Bodies .. B. The Need for FurtherResearch .. C. InternationalManagement . . ..
.. .,
.. ..
..
7
35
39
45 50 53
..
..
..
..
..
56
..
..
..
..
..
56
Appendix : Table of InternationalBodies Concerned with .. .. .. .. .. Fishery Management
62
Acknowledgements . . References
..
..
vii
...
CONTENTS
Vlll
A General Account of t h e Fauna and Flora of Mangrove Swamps and Forests i n t h e Indo-West-Pacific Region WILLIAMMACNAE
I. Introduction . . .. .. .. A. The Word “Mangrove” .. B. Early Historical References . . C. Indo-west-Pacific Shores .. D. Sea-shore Plant Associations. .
..
.. ..
..
74
..
.. ..
.. .. ..
75 77
..
..
..
85
.. .. .. ..
..
89
..
.. .. .. ..
..
..
.. ..
. . 108 . . 112
..
..
115
.. ..
..
.. .. .. ..
.. .. .. 111. Adaptations Shown by the Flora . . A. Adaptations to Growing in Ill-consolidated Muds. B. Specializations of Stems and Leaves .. ..
136
11. Zonation of Mangroves .. .. A. The Landward Fringe .. .. B. Zone of Ceriops Thickets C. Zone of Bruguiera Forests . . D. Zones of Rhizophora Forests E. Seaward Avicennia Fringes . . F . SonneratiaZone .. .. G. Variations .. .. .. H. Mangrove Soils .. .. I. Control of Zonation . . ..
.. ..
..
..
..
.. ..
.
76
91 103 105
118 121 124
136 140
C. Relationship between the Mangrove Root and Shoot .. .. . . 144 Systems .. .. .. .. .. . . 145 D. Viviparity .. .. .. .. .. . . 148 E. Succession .. .. .. IV. Distribution of Terrestrial Animals within the Mangal. . A. Birds Associated with Mangals .. .. .. B. Amphibians and Reptiles . . .. .. ..
C. Mammals D. Insects . .
.. ..
..
..
.. 1 .
.. ..
.. ..
.. ..
150 153 156 157 157
ix
CONTENTS
V.
VI.
Distribution of Marine Animals within the Mangal . . 165 A. Vertical Zonation Affecting Tree Dwelling Animals 165 B. “Horizontal” Zonation through the Mangal . . 167 Specializations Shown by the Fauna .. .. A. Birds, Mammals, Reptiles and Amphibians B. Insects . . .. .. .. .. .. C. Marine Animals .. .. .. ..
., .
181 181
I
..
182
.,
184
VII. Geographical Distribution . . .. .. .. ., 219 A. Extratropical Extensions of Mangroves and their Associated Fauna . . . . .. .. . . 219 B. Biogeographical Comment . . .. .. . . 222
VIII. Uses Made by Man of the Mangal and its Products A. Uses of the Timber . . .. .. .. B. Pond Culture of Fish and Prawns . . .. C. Reclamation . . .. .. .. .. D. Salt Production .. .. .. ..
..
233 233
..
. . 238 . . 240
..
241
..
..
..
..
..
241
X. Bibliography and References
..
..
..
..
241
IX. Acknowledgements . .
Some Aspects of the Biology of the Chaetognaths ELVEZIOGHIRARDELLI
..
..
..
..
271
11. General Morphology. . .. .. A. The Eyes, Hooks and Teeth . . B. Integument, Fins and Tail . . C. Corona ciliata . . .. ..
..
..
271
..
..
.. ..
..
.. .. ..
..
..
I. Introduction . .
..
..
273 274 281 .1
X
COXTEXTS
111. Reproduction. . .. .. .. .. .. A. The Male Genital Apparatus. . .. .. B. The Female Reproductive Apparatus. General .. C. Spermatogenesisand Oogenesis .. .. D. Fertilization . . .. .. .. .. E. Laying of Eggs .. .. .. F. Habitat and Cycles of Sexual Maturity . . IV. V.
Regeneration . .
..
..
289
.. .. .. .. .. ..
289 292 309 322 335 343
..
..
..
. . 351
Affinities and Systematic Position . .
..
..
.
..
VI. Laboratory Experiments VII, Acknowledgements . .
*
355
..
..
..
..
..
..
..
..
..
. . 365
364
..
..
..
..
..
..
. . 366
AUTHORINDEX . .
..
..
..
..
..
. . 377
TAXONOMIC INDEX ..
..
..
..
..
..
. . 387
..
..
..
..
..
..
. . 395
VIII. References
SUBJECTINDEX
Adv. mar. B i d , Vol. 6, 1968, pp. 1-71
MANAGEMENT OF FISHERY RESOURCES* J. A. CULLAND? Department of Fisheries, F.A.O., Rome, Italy and
J. E. CARROZ Legislation Research Bran,ch, Department of Public Relations and Legal Affairs, F.A.O., Eome, Italy I. Introduction .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 11. The Need for Management .. .. .. .. .. A. The Depletion of Marine Kesources .. .. R. Theoretical Studies . . .. .. .. .. 111. Methods of Regulation . . .. .. .. .. .. 4 .. Types of Regulation . . . . .. .. .. B. Limitation of the Amount of Fishing .. .. IV. The Mechanics of Management and InternationalLaw .. A. Territorial Sea and Fishing Zones . . . . .. R. Specialized Fishery Bodies . . .. .. .. V. Problems and Prospects for Future Progress .. .. A. Achievements of Present Bodies . . .. .. B. The Need for FurtherResearch .. .. .. C. InternationalManagement . . . . .. .. VI. Acknowledgements .. .. .. .. .. .. VII. Roferences .. .. .. .. .. .. .. Appendix: Table of International Bodies Concerned with Management . . . . .. .. .. .. ..
.. .. ..
..
. . ..
.. .. .. .. .
I
..
..
..
.. ..
.. .. .. .. . . .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ..
1 7 7 16 25 25 29 34 35 39 45 45 50 53 56 56
Fishery
..
..
62
I. INTRODUCTION The estimated world production of fish has more than doubled in the last two decades, from less than 20 million metric tons in 1948 to over 50 million tons in 1965 (see Table I ;F.A.O., 1966a). This increase, which is considerably faster than the increase of either the human population or the production of food as a whole, means that fish are making an increasingly important contribution to the world's food supply, particularly of animal protein. In the world as a whole, fish * This paper was first published, undcr the same title, as Chapter I V in "The State of Food and Agriculture 1967 "(F.A.O., Rome, 1967). Some changes have been made from the original version, principally in order to make the presentation more suitable for a scientific audience. I n so far as there are differences from tho earlier publication, these represent the views of the authors and are not necessarily those of the F.A.O. Formerly of the Fisheries Laboratory, Lowestuft, England. 1
2
J. A . GULLAND A N D J. E. CARROZ
contribute about 10% of the total animal protein intake, but con siderably more in some areas such as the Far East (see Table 11). While a n increasing proportion of the total catch is not used directly for human consumption but is converted to fish meal, this fish is used for producing human food in commercially more attractive forms by feeding it to chicken, trout, etc. ; recent developments in marine fish culture suggest that in the future further supplies of fish meal will be needed to produce valuable marine fish such as plaice (Pleuronectes platessa L.), sole (Solea solea (L.)) or yellowtail (Xeriola quinqueradiata (Temminck & Schlegel)) (Shelbourne, 1964), or shellfish such as prawns or lobster. The increased catches, due both to increased local fishing and especially the rapidly increasing number of mobile factory and other vessels operating far from their home bases, have intensified the TABLEIA. WORLDFISH PRODUCTION, 1948-65 Million metric tons live weight. (FromF.A.O., 1966a.)
Total world production:.
.
Africa . North America South America Asia . . Europe . Oceania . U.S.S.R. .
.
1948
1958
1960
1962
1963
1964
1965
19.6
32.8
39.5
46.4
47.6
52.0
52.4
2.6 4.5 8.3 18.6 8.7 0.1 3.6
2.7 4.4 8.4 19.0 9.0 0.1 4.0
3.0 4.3 11.0 19.3 9.7 0.2 4.5
3.1 4.4 9.0 19.9 10.8 0.2 5.0
6.4 29.0 3.5 0.6
6.5 35.3 3.8 0.8
6.7 36.1 4.1 0.7
6.8 40.7 3.8 0.7
7.2 40.4 4.1 0.7
17.5 5.7 8.1 4.8 15.3 1.0
Continent (region)
.
.
. .
. .
. .
1.0 3.6 0.5 6.8 6-1 0.1 1.5
2.1 4.0 1.6 14.6 7.8 0.1 2.6
2.3 4.1 4.4 17.4 8.1 0.1 3.1
Group of species Vrcshwatcr fishes. . 2.5 Marine fishes . . 14.7 Crustaceans, molluscs . . 2.0 Other aquatic animalsand plants 0.4
5.4 23.9 2.9 0.6
Utilization Human consumption Fresh . Breezing . Curing . Canning . Other purposes Reduction . Miscellaneous .
.
14.5 2-7 7.3 3.0
16.3 3.4 7.5 3.7
16.9 4.3 8.1 4.1
17.3 4.7
.
9.7 1.0 5.0 1.4
4.1
17.6 5.1 8.4 4.4
.
1.5
.
1.0
4.3 1.0
7.6 1.0
12.0 1.0
12.0 1.0
15.5 1.0
. ,
8.5
3
MANAGEMENT O F BTSHERY RESOllRCES
TABLEIB. MARINEFISHES PRODUCTION, 1948-65 Million metric tons livc weight. (FromF.A.O., 1966a.) 1948
1958
1960
1962
1963
1964
1965
14.7
23.9
29.0
35.3
36.1
40.7
40.4
Species 0.5 0.8 3.6 4.5 1.2 2.2 0.5 1.8 4.7 7.4 0.4 1.0 0.6 1.0 0.3 0.3 2.9 4.9
1.2 5.0 2.4 1.7 10.2 1.0 1.1 0.4 6.0
1.2 5.5 2.6 2.1 14.8 1.2 1.1 0.4 6.4
1.0 5.9 2.7 1.9 15.1 1.2 1.2 0.4 6.7
1.0 6.0 2.9 2.0 18.7 1.2 1.4 0.4 7.1
1.0 6.5 3-0 2.1 17.4 1.2 1-7 0.4 7.1
Principal marine fishing areas 8.0 9.1 9.8 10.3 North Atlantic . . 5.1 2.2 3.4 4.3 Central and South Atlantic . 0.8 0.7 0.8 0.8 MeditcrraneanandBlackSeas 1.7 1.5 1.8 Indian Occan . . 1.0 4.1 4.6 3.7 2.5 North Pacific . . 3.1 8.2 8.8 9.9 Contra1Pacific . 7.7 0.2 1.3 4.0 South Pacific . .
10.9 5.2 0.9 1.7 4-5 10.2 7.8
11.5 5.6 1.0 1.9 4.9 10.0 10.5
12.7 6.2 0.9 1.9
Total marine fishes:
.
.
Flounders,halibuts, soles . Cods, hakcs, haddocks . . Redfish, basses, congers . Jacks, mullcts . . Herrings, sardines, anchovies. Tunas, bonitos, skipjacks . Mackerels . . . Sharks, rays . . Unsorted and other . .
.
5-4 10.3 8.4
problems of overfishing, and the possible need of regulations and management t o make the best use of the resources. At the time of the 1949 U.N. Scientific Conference on the Conservation and Utilization of Resources a t Lake Success, the only overfished stocks were a limited number of stocks of high-priced species, mainly in the North Atlantic and North Pacific (e.g. the plaice in the North Sea, the halibut and salmon in the north-east Pacific), and the Conference drew up a map showing some thirty stocks then believed t o be underfished (see Fig. 1). Of these stocks about half are now probably in need of proper management, including the cod (Gadus morhua L.), redfish (Sebastes spp.) and herring (Clupea harengus L.) in the North Atlantic, and a t least some species of tunas in most of the oceans. The classical response of the fishing industry t o overfishing in one stock has been to move to other, usually more distant stocks, but it is clear that this process cannot continue much longer. Some blank spaces in the Lake Success map have been filled by more recently discovered resources, e.g. oil sardine (Xardinella spp.) and Rastrelliger spp. in the Arabian Sea, or hake (Merlucciusspp.) off the west coasts of the Americas, but it is significant
15'
5 0'
45" 3 On 15O O0 15O
3 On
4 !I0 6 On I
I
150"
I
I
12O0
,
I
gon
1
I
6 0"
I
I
3 '0
I
I
Do
I
I
3 0"
I
I
6 0"
I
I
90n
I
1
120'
I
I
150"
I
I
I
180n
FIG. 1. Map showing latent marine fishery resources (fish stocks believed to be underfished in 1949). Circled stocks are those now certainly or probably in need of management (the "pilchard " off the west coast of South America presumably refers to the anchoveta stock). Of the tunas, the yellowfin is probably heavily exploited in all areas, but further expansion may be possible for other species such as skipjack or bonito. (From United Nations, 1931.)
5
MANAGEMENT O F FISHERY RESOURCES
TABLE11. PER CAPUT PROTEIN SUPPLIES, BY REGION(RECENT PERIOD) Prom "State of Food and Agriculture 1964 ",F.A.O. Rome.
Fish
Anirnal protein -~
Total protein
Region
~
-~
U.S.S.R.
.
North Amorica. . Oceania . Latin Amorica . . Far East (incl. mainland China) . . Near East . Africa . High-calorie countries* Low-calorie countricst
.
_.________
As "/b of A s yo of total Total total protein protein ( g per caput per day)
A s yo of animal protein
~____
_ _
~~~~
Wcsterri Europe . Eastern Europe and
World
Total
-
.
83
39
47
2.4
2.9
6.2
.
94 93 94 67
33 66 62 24
35 71 66 36
1.9 2.5 2.2 1.5
2.0 2.7 2.3 2.2
5.8 3.8 3.5 6.3
56 76
8 14
14 18
2.2 1.1
3.9 1.4
27.5 7.9
.
61 90 58
11 44 9
18
.
49 16
1.3 2.4 1.9
2.1 2.7 3.3
11.8 5.5 21.1
.
68
20
29
2.3
3.4
11.5
. f
.
. . .
* Europe, North America,
Oceania, Hiver Plate countries.
?- Latin America, P a r East and Near East, Africa.
that these additions have been in the areas (IndianOcean, south-east Pacific) away from the old centres of fishery development, and no major new resources have been discovered in the North Atlantic, or north-west Pacific. At the present rate of development few substantial unexploited stocks of fish accessible to the present types of gear will remain in another twenty years. Thus the problem of international management is becoming increasingly urgent. This problem is not confined t o the high seas, but occurs also in inland waters, especially in the larger rivers and lakes where the biological problems are essentially the same as in the sea, even though the problems of international fishing may be much less. For certain stocks which are particularly vulnerable, e.g. salmon going upstream to spawn, the problems of overfishing may become more intensive than in any purely marine fishery. Inlandwaters also present other problems, such as pollution, and the alternative use of water resources-power, irrigation etc.-which may conflict with fisheries. These are less pressing in the sea, though there are similar problems, for instance the use of the other resources of the sea-bed such as minerals or oil, which
6
J. A. GULLAND AND J. E. CARROZ
may also conflict with fisheries. However, these problems will not be considered further here; nor will this article be concerned with the problems of fish culture in ponds, brackish water or enclosed parts of the sea, except that such culture may have an indirect effect on the open water fisheries by increasing the demand for cheap supplies of food for the choicer varieties of fish being farmed. The problems of overfishing arise because, in default of definite arrangements, the fishery resources are not the responsibility of any single person or body. Next year’s catches depend on how much is taken this year, but in the open sea the individual fisherman can do little to ensure better fishing for himself next year-if lie does not catch fish while he can, someone else will catch them. Thus effective management depends on the participation of all, or at least of the great majority, of those exploiting a given stock of fish. The problems are more complex when many countries are concerned or when more than one species of fish is caught (especially when there may be biological interactions between the stocks, e.g. one species being the main food of another),but the main problems are essentially the same even when a single stock is exploited by a single country. The first problem is biological: t o understand the population dynamics of the stock or stocks concerned, and thus make quantitative assessments of the probable effect on the stocks and on future catches of any regulatory measure. Until this biological understanding is available, it is unrealistic to consider the other problems of regulation, though at first the biological study need not be very intense. A simple study may show that a stock is in urgent need of regulation, and any effective measure would be bound to improve matters; only as the first measures take effect will more detailed biological data be needed to determine the precise needs for further measures. Too often conservation measures have been delayed, and great damage done to the stock and the fishery on it by the demand for complete and conclusive biological evidence; the final conclusive proof that a stock is being depleted is when it becomes extinct. Biological considerations are, of course, only the first step; the aim of fishery management is not primarily to maintain the stocks of fish, but to make the best use of the resources in terms of larger or cheaper supplies of fish to the consumer, better income to the fishermen, etc. The desired result of regulation, especially when the objective is t o take about the same catch more cheaply, can therefore only be ensured by taking into account the probable economic and other non-biological effects of proposed regulation. Economic and similar considerations will also become increasingly important in resolving disputes between
MANAGEMENT O F FISHERY RESOURCES
7
groups of fishermen with conflicting interests, e.g. one group fishing herring and another group taking cod which feed on herring. However, problems of management, and indeed some of the outstanding examples of the failure to achieve proper management, have occurred when there has been no conflict of long-term interests, but merely a conflict between the long-term interest for the fishery as a whole and the immediate desire of the individual fisherman to catch as much as he can today. It is natural not to be greatly concerned with a problem until it becomes urgent; thus so long as most fish stocks were not too heavily fished, and there remained alternative unexploited stocks t o which the fleets exploiting the overfished stocks could turn, the problems of fishery management have received too little attention. This is particularly unfortunate because of the need, from several considerations, to take action as early as possible. Biologically, the assessment of any fishery depends on measuring the effect on the stock of changes in fishing. This assessment is made much easier and more precise if data are available from periods of very light fishing. Detailed and expensive biological studies of the stocks after the fishery has become very intense cannot substitute for reliable data on such simple things as the average size of fish, or the average catch per boat, from the periods of light fishing. Similarly, the practical problems of regulations are much less if regulatory measures are considered well before the stocks are clearly overfished ;the social problems in limiting further entry t o a fishery are much less than those in reducing the existing number of boats or number of fishermen. For all these reasons, therefore, the various problems relating to proper management of fishery resources deserve urgent attention.
11. THENEEDFOR MANAGEMENT A. The depletion of marine resources A hundred years ago most people, including leading scientists, believed that the living resources of the sea were essentially inexhaustible-" there are more good fish in the sea than ever came out of i t ". K,epeated experience since then, a t first for the most valuable or vulnerable species, has shown how false this assumption was. The first stocks to show depletion were those close to the ports of the industrial nations. Shortly after the development of the steam trawler-one of the earliest applications of modern industrial techniques to fishing-the stocks of plaice in the North Sea showed signs of depletion. The average annual landings of plaice by individual trawling smacks was clearly decreasing as early as 1880, even though the total landings were still
8
J. A . (:ULLAND A N D J.
E. CARROZ
increasing (Wimpenny, 1053). Convincing proof that this decline, and the decline in stocks of other valuable species, was due to fishing was provided by the severe restrictions on fishing during the two world wars. Immediately after each war the catches of the individual trawlers were several times the pre-war avesages (see Fig. 2) (Wimpenny, 1953 ; Margetts and Holt, 1948). Similar recoveries were noted in other stocks where the amount of fishing was greatly reduced, e.g. the haddock (Melanogrammus aegle,finus (L.)) in the North Sea and a t Faroes (Parrish and Jones, 1953), the hake (Merluccius mqrluccizcs L.) to the south-west of the British Isles (Hickling, 1946) and yellow sea bream (Taius tumifrons (Tanaka & Schlegel))in the East China Sea (Shindo, I -+
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
c L
-
920 -
200 - m
c c
I
c
r: g 1 5 2; -
'sc ma)
3s -a
9 P-4,
- 1 0 - tr
G -m c x 342 b
a
Q\
c
?, 5-
A ma L J
0
-50 I
I
I
I
I
a
1
1960). These and other similar changes show clearly not only how fish stocks can be depleted by fishing but also that the process is reversible. Thus with proper management stocaks can build up again, even such vulnerable stocks as whales ; for instance, the southern right whale (Eubalaena australis (Desm.)) is returning to Ncw Zealand waters (Gaskin, 1964), and the numbers of California gray whales, after having been very severely reduced by unrestricted catches, were given complete protection and have incrcased at around 10% per year-close to the rate for the Antarctic stocks of blue and fin whales calculated from their reproductive and mortality rates (Rice, 1961). Because of the difficulties, discwssed later, in achieving proper management of major mariiie resources, especially in international waters, there are far more examples of stocks declining in the absence of proper managements. One example of an important stock being
MANAGEMENT
O F FISHERY RESOVRCES
9
built up by regulation is the Pacific halibut. This large, long-lived and ecouomically valuable fish is particularly vulnerable to overfishing and by the 1920s the stocks had been severely depleted. As a result of conventions between the two countries concerned (U.S.A. and Canada) the amount of fishing in 1960 was about half w h a t it was in 1930; the stock has been increascd one- to threefold, and the catches have increased from a minimum of 43 million lb in 1931 to more than 65 million lb in 1960 (ChapmanP t al., 1962). The management of this stock has thus been highly successful in maintaining the stock and the catch, but the full benefits of management have not been achieved. Although the amount of fishing, in terms of the impact on the stock, has been halved, the costs have been nowhere near halved, since the number of ships operating has increased while the length of season has been very severely reduced. Both the catching and marketing side of the industry are therefore operating at a very low level of efficiency (Crutchfieldand Zellner, 1963). I n the absence of regulation and management of the over-exploited stocks, the response of the industries concerned has been to turn to other, more distant or less immediately attractive stocks. After the North Sea had shown itself to be capable of producing only limited quantities of the preferred species-cod, plaice, etc.-the fishing industries of the industrial nations, such as England and Germany, turned to the "distant water " grounds, especially Iceland and the Barents Sea. I n the North Sea, fishing was continued with the existing vessels which were not suitable for fishing the more distant grounds, and as these vessels were lost or scrapped without being replaced the level of exploitation in the North Sea by countries with interests on distant water fishing fell. Thus, even in 1050, virtually all the English North Sea trawlers then operating were built before 1925." As a result the level of fishing on the North Sea plaice stocks has recently been lower than a t any time (other than during the war periods) for the past eighty years ; this, combined with favourable natural conditions has provided record catches in 1964 (incidentally confirming the predictions, by Russell (1942), Bevcrton and Holt (1957) and others, based on the analysis of the heavily fished stocks of the 1930s, that a moderate decrease in the amount of fishing would give an increase in total catch) (Gulland,1967, 1968a). The catches of other iiiiportant demersal species (cod and haddock) have also been very high in recent years. These fish are caught by rather different groups of vessels from plaice, haddock
* VcsscIs of other countries, especially Uenmark, rrmained fishing in the North Sea but changed in part t o other stocks, such as hcrring or sand-eels.
10
J. A . GULLAND AND J. E. CARROZ
especially being a major interest to Scottish fishermen, and Scottish fishing has not expanded to distant waters to anything like the same extent as English fishing. Thus it is not clear whether the fishing on these species has declined to the same extent as the fishing on plaice though the cod stocks in the central North Sea seem to have also benefited from reduced fishing (M.A.F.F., U.K., 1962). Certainly the recent good catches have been due in part to outstanding year-classes, especially the 1962 haddock year-class (M.A.F.F., U.K., 1966). There may well have been a decrease in effort; also haddock catches in particular are likely t o have benefited from the larger mesh sizes introduced under the 1946 Overfishing Convention (I.C.E.S., 1957). The diversion of the main attention of some of the countries bordering the North Sea has therefore allowed some a t least of the North Sea demersal stocks to recover temporarily t o a level not far from the optimum. However, a t this level of fishing any increase in fishing would, in the long term, reduce the total catch. The recent success of North Sea fishing is attractingsome of the resources of ships and capital back to the North Sea, and without some restriction only a fraction of the resources a t present devoted to distant water fishing could quickly reduce the North Sea stocks again to the low level of the 1930s. Temporarily, though, some North Sea demersal stocks have benefited from diversion of fishing to other stocks, but these latter stocks have in their turn become depleted. The first of the distant water stocks to become depleted were the small but economically attractive stocks, such as the plaice off Iceland and in the Barents Sea; the abundanceof these stocks, as measured by the catch per hour, had been reduced as early as 1925 to a small fraction of their initial level. Russell (1942) and more recently Gulland (1961) describe clearly the decline in catch per hour of plaice and other species by English trawlers fishing a t Iceland, and the relation of this decline to the changes in the total amount of fishing. The larger cod stocks were able to support a greater total amount of fishing, but by the mid-1950s they too werc being heavily exploited. For instance, despite an increasein the amoufit of fishing since 1946 of several times (possibly as much as tenfold), the catches of cod from the Arcto-Norwegian stock (living in the waters between northNorway, Russia and Spitsbergen)has fluctuated between 600 000 and I 300 000 tons with no evidence of any increasing trend (see Fig. 3) (I.C.E.S., 1966). I n the last decade the further expansion of European fishing, including diversion of some of the effort formerly engaged in fishing the depleted stocks of the north-east Atlantic, and also increasing numbers of new freezer and factory trawlers (Fig. 4), especially from eastern
11
MANAGEMENT O F FISHERY RESOURCES
I400
m v1
0
t 0 c
7
x
c 0
v)
L
0 2
Cn
II:
D t
c + 0
500 0 L
+
d
Total effort d’
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
1930
35
40
115
50
55
60
0
FIG. 3. Arctic cod. 0-0, Total landings (in thousandsof tons); 0 - - - 0, total effort in English units (ton-hours x 10-8). (From I.C.E.S., 1966, Liaison Committee Report .)
FIG.4. The Ross Vanyuard, a modern British freozer trawler, capable of catching and freezing several hundred tons of fish during a 6-week voyage. (Photo: Pishinq News.)
Europe, has been directed to the north-west Atlantic, and more recently t o the centraI and southernAtlantic. Some of the stocks of the western Atlantic were already heavily fished by local fisheries, as well as by the long-established southern European fisheries for salt cod, but in the last few years some of the stocks, such as those off west Greenland,
12
J . A. GULLAX’IU A N D J . E. CARROZ
which until recently had been only lightly exploited, have become depleted (see the annual reports of the I.C.N.A.F. Assessment subCommittee in the I.C.N.A.F. Red Books ; Beverton and Hodder, 1962) (Figs. 5 an d 6). The exploitation of the pelagic species (particularlyherring)has not (up t o 1965) gone so far as tha t of the bottom-living cod, haddock, etc., but some of the local stocks of herring, such as those in the southern North Sea have been seriously depleted b y fishing, and lately there has been increasing concern about other herring stocks (see recent I.C.E.S. Liaison Committee reports). These events in the North Atlantic may be summarized in the form of a map showing the approximate date at which the fishing on each stock reached a level a t which further increase in the amount of fishing would give no appreciable increase in the sustained yield (see Fig. 7 ) . Most recently a major part of the expansion of Europeanfishing has been outside the North Atlantic, particularly off the west coast of Africa. Even as far away as off the roasts of South Africa and South West Africa by 1965 the country taking the biggest catch of hake (Merluccius cupensis Castlenau), the main bottom-living species, was
FIG. 5. The internationalfishing fleet on the Labrador Uanlrs. Trawlors from East Germany and Russia photographed from a British freezer trawler. (Photo: Fishing News.)
MANAGEMENT
O F FISHERY RESOURCES
13
FIG.6 . Why thc trawlers go t o Labrador;the cod-end of the trawl, with several tons of fish, comes on board a freezer trawler. (Photo: Fishing News.)
Spain (118 000 tons compared with 87 000 tons in 1965 by South Africa, and a total by all countries in 1948 of 39 000 tons). This expansion by industrialized countries has been both directly through increasing numbers of larger and long-rangefreezing and factory ships, especially from Eastern European countries, and also indirectly through investment in locally based fleets in the coast'alcountries. I n addition these countries are developing their own off-shore fisheries. Similar developments have taken place in the other oceans, particularly in the northern Pacific, from where Japanese and more recently Soviet fisheries have been expanding farther and farther afield. European and Japanese vessels are now exploiting the same stocks of fish, such as the hake off the south-west coast of Africa. Even relatively poor countries are rapidly developing long-distance fisheries ; Korea, for instance, has a substantial fleet fishing for tuna in the central Pacific and in the Atlantic.
II
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
FIG.7. The spread of overfishing ” in the North Atlantic. The years are the approximate dates by which fishing on the stocks indkated scnchd u lcvol heyond. which increases in fidiirig givc n o s u s h i i i d incruust: in total ca.tch. G , c:otl; H , ha,ddock; F , plaice; I?, redfish; I I K , h d r c ; Hg, herr,ing. ‘I
MANAGEMENT O F FISIIERY RESOURCES
15
There remain large stocks of fish which are still substantially unexploited, not only in under-developed areas, such as the oil-sardines (Xardinella spp.) and Indianmackerel (Rastrelliger spp.) in the Arabian Sea, but even in centres of intense fishing, such as the blue whiting (Hicromesistius poutassou (Risso)) off the west coast of the British Isles. However, despite the continuing improvement in fishing methods, the fishing gears in use now are fundamentally the same as those in use fifty years ago-the seines, trawls and hooks and lines. Similarly the types of fish being caught are the same, being those in which the diffused production of the sea has been concentrated either in large shoals, such as anchovies or sardines; on the bottom, such as the cods and flounders; or in large animals, such as tuna and whales, for which a single vessel can catch the animals from a very wide area (for instance one vessel long-lining for tuna can shoot 50 miles of line each day). Thus, despite the vast expanse of the open oceans in relation to the areas a t present exploited, the number of unexploited but practicably exploitable stocks of fish is not large, and unless there is a technical breakthrough which would make the harvesting of new types of resources economically feasible, e.g. the direct harvesting of krill (Euphausia superba Dana) in the Antarctic instead of indirectly via whales (Burukovskii and Iarogov, 1965 ; Stasenko, 1965 ; Osochenko, 1965), or of small oceanic fish, the present rate of expansion of the world fish production cannot be maintained indefinitely, possibly for no more than ten or fifteen years. Thus the proportion of the total world catch which comes from heavily exploited stocks needing proper management will rapidly increase, and it will become increasingly difficult to avoid the problems of proper management of an overfished stock by turning to other, less heavily exploited stocks. The need for proper management policies is therefore becoming rapidly more urgent. I n fact, the frequent failure to achieve proper management in the heavily exploited stocks is having immediate effects in several ways on the catches of lightly fished stocks. Most obviously, much more fishing effort in terms of ships, men and other resources is involved in the overexploited fisheries than would be needed under proper management, and these resources could well be directed to other stocks. Thus, for example, it has been estimated that the total effort spent on some of the major stocks of cod and haddock in the north-east Atlantic has increased so far that substantially the same (or possibly slightly greater) catch could be taken with half to two-thirds of the present level of fishing. If the resources, whether of ships, men or capital, represented by the excess half to one-third of the present effort, could be diverted to other less heavily fished stocks, e.g. in the central and south Atlantic,
16
J . A . CIJLLAND AND
J. E. CARROZ
and assuming that the catch rates of the individual vessels might be rather lower, a t least in terms of value, than when fishing for cod in the north-east Atlantic, their total catch would still be probably around half a million tons. Since the north-east Atlantic catch would remain the same, this half million tons would be a net addition to the total world catch taken a t no extra cost. The wrong type of management can also inhibit the development of fishing on unexploited stocks by discouraging or prohibiting the use of the most effective type of gear. Thus on the west coast of North America restrictions on the use of trawls, introduced to protect the catches of the highly priced halibut and the interests of sports fishermen, have hindered the exploitation of the very large stocks of hake and other species. Also the general failure to achieve good management is very likely to discourage governments or commercial interests from investing large sums in developing fisheries whose long-term future is uncertain. For these and other reasons proper management implies far more than merely ensuring, through appropriate regulations on the amount of fishing or the size offish caught, that the maximum sustained yield is taken from those stocks which would otherwise be overfished, important though this is.
B. Theoretical studies The effect of fishing on a stock of fish has been described by means of a range of models of varying mathematical complexity (see, for instance, Ricker, 1958; Beverton and Holt, 1957; Schaefer, 1954, 1967a; Schaefer and Beverton, 1963; Gulland, 1965, 1967); but the implications for rational inanagement are much the same. I n the absence of fishing a stock of fish will be large, including a relatively high proportion of big. old individuals, and the increase in the total biomass due to growth of the individuals arid recruitment of young fish will be balanced over a period by the losses due to naturaldeaths. When fishing begins the large stock gives large catches to each vessel, even though the total catch is small. Any fishing will tend to reduce the stock abundance,but at the reduced stock levels the losses due to natural deaths will be less than the gains due to growth and recruitment. If the catch taken is equal to this surplus, the stock will not change : any catch greater than this sustainable yield will decrease the stock, while a smaller catch will allow the stock to increase. This sustainable yield is small for very large stocks, because natural deaths are only just less than the growth and recruitment; equally it is small for very small stocks, where the absolute value of the increase due to growth and recruitment will be small. Thus the greatest sustainable yield will be taken a t some inter-
MANAGEMENT O F FISHERY RESOURCES
17
mediate stock level. This level may be achieved by some moderate amount of fishing on all sizes of fish, or pssibbly quite heavy fishing selectively applied to the larger fish. An example of this technique applied to a major oceanic fishery, the fishery for yellowfin tuna in the eastern tropical Pacific, is given in Fig. 8. The effect of fishing is best shown by relating the stock level (in this case measured by the catch per day fishing by a standard vessel) to the amount of fishing (here measured by the estimated number of days fishing). Each point in the diagram corresponds to the data for one year in the period 1934-65; the Figure shows clearly the decline in T o t a l catch,millions o f p o u n d s
1
v ) 3 0
L
a -
a L
Z
c '-
V c
m L'
F i s h i n g e f f o r t i n thousands o f s t a n d a r d d a y s FIG.8. Relationships among fishing effort, apparcnt abundance, and catch for yellowfin tuna i n the eastcrn Pacific Ocean, 1034-66. The points connected by thc solid line are based on apparent abundance mcasurcd by baitboat data only, while the isolated points for 1959-66 are h s e t l on apparent abundancc measiired by data from baitboats and seincrs combinctl. (From I.-A.T.T.C., i966.)
stock with increasing fishing, and the straight line which best describes this decline. Also shown in the diagram are curves connectingthe points with the samc total catch. For the observed line the highest catch is a t the point corresponding to an equilibrium catch of some 90 000 short tons, taken with an amount of fishing, in standard units, of 32 000 days. A more analytical approach is to follow the history of a brood of fish from the time they reach a fishable size, as in the models of Ricker (1958) and Beverton and Holt (1957). At low rates of fishing the fish may survive for a long time, so the average age and size are high;
18
J. A. CULLAND AND J. E. CARROZ
however, the total numbers caught, and the total weight, are small. Equally a t very high rates of fishing, applied as soon as the fish are big enough t o be caught, although the numbers caught will be very large, they will not survive long enough to grow much, so that the total catch will be only moderate, consisting of very small fish. The greatest catch from a given brood is taken by allowing the fish to grow to a reasonable size, either by only fishing moderately hard or by using some selective gear (e.g. trawls with large meshes) which will only catch the larger fish, allowing the small ones t o escape and grow. I n addition, it is not improbable that the average number of young produced by the low stocks when fishing is heavy will be less than those produced from larger stocks, although this is not as obvious as it may seem. Most marine fish produce very large numbers of eggs (sometimes millions), so that even a very small adult stock could produce a large brood, and evidence from some stocks shows that the adult stock can be reduced substantially without any significant reduction in the number of young produced which recruit to the fishery in later years (Beverton, 1962). The number of young produced each year often fluctuates very widely quite independently of changesin the adult stock, and these fluctuations make it very difficult within any particular stock of fish t o determine whether a reduction in the number of adults results, on the average, in any significant reduction in the number of young. This uncertainty has often, in practice, led to the assumption that the number of recruits is independent of the adult stock, i.e. that there is no need for regulatory measures to maintain the adult stock. However, this assumption can lead to disaster for the fishery if in fact it is false. The obvious example of the disasters following a failure t o maintain an adequate breeding stock is that of the Antarctic whales. Since they are mammals, producing only one young every other year, there is no doubt that a reduction in the adult stock would result in fewer young animals recruiting t o the future stock. Under proper management these Antarctic stocks could maintain annual catches of around 6 000 blue whales and 20 000 fin whales : a t present the blue whales have had to be given complete protection, but even if hunted intensively only a few hundred could be caught (Chapmanet al., 1964, 1965). I n the 1965-66 season only 2 300 fin whales were caught, and even this small total will only allow the depleted fin whale stock to rebuild rather slowly. Thus failure of proper management has meant a loss in annual catch of 6 000 blue whales, and 18 000 fin whales, which would have yielded about a quarterof a million tons of oil, and equivalent quantities of whale meat and other by-products. Similar disasters to fish stocks are less well established, but a possible example is the California sardine (Xardinops
MANAGEMENT O F FISHERY RESOURCES
19
caerulea (Girard))fishery, which declined from over half a million tons annually around 1940 to only 3 000 tons in 1963, due to failure of recruitment. It is possible that this failure of recruitment was caused a t least in part by the reduction in the adult stock by the heavy fishing of the 1930s and 1940s (MacGregor, 1964 ; Murphy, 1966). I n other major fisheries uncertainty concerning the relation between adult stock and subsequent recruitment is of immediate practical relevance in considering the present need for management. Thus for the Arcto-Norwegian stock of cod a reduction in the amount of fishing to half the high level occurring in 1965 would, if recruitment were independent of adult stock, result in a slight increase in sustained catch (I.C.E.S., 1966). However, there are definite signs that the recruitment is reduced a t the low stock correspondingto the 1965 level of fishing (Garrod, 1966) ;if so, continued fishing a t the 1965 level could very greatly reduce the stock, and result in sustained catches very substantially below those that could be obtained a t lower levels of fishing. Again, in the Peruvian anchoveta fishery, it is fairly clear that increased fishing will not appreciably increase the yield per recruit and any small increase in yield would be accompanied by a substantial fall in catch per unit effort (Boerema et al., 1965), and therefore it is desirable to discourage any further increase in effort. It is, however, possible that increased fishing, by reducing the spawning stock, will reduce the future recruitment; this reduction in recruitment could well cause a loss in total catch of several million tons per year. I n this case it would be not only desirable, but virtually essential, to prevent any appreciable increase in fishing. It is also conceivable, and consistent with the data a t present available, that reduced adult stocks would, because of reduced competition for food between adults and young, result in increased recruits ; increased fishing might therefore substantially increase the total catch. Having stated the uncertainty, it is not easy to resolve it. Certain theoretical models relating stock and recruitment have been developed and curves relating recruitment to adult stock proposed which ranged from the asymptotic to the parabolic (Ricker, 1954; Beverton and Holt, 1957 ; Radovich, 1962). However, the observed data, in the form of pairs of values of adult stocks and subsequent recruitment, are usually few (accumulatinga t the rate of only one pair per year), and are often very variable, so that the form of the stock/recruitment curve often remains very uncertain (Gulland, 1967). Probably the problems can only be resolved by a better basic understanding of the processes determining the survival from egg to adult, particularly the early larval stages. This will probably require both work at sea-detailed surveys
20
J . A. GULLAND AND J. E. CARROZ
of younger stages-to estimate the basic population parameters both of the young fish themselves and also of other relevant populations, especially the food of the larvae (Ahlstrom, 1954, 1965 ; Baranenkova, 1965), and work in the laboratory-estimation of food requirements of the larvae, the effects of reduced food on growth and survival, etc. This adds up to a substantial volume of research, but it is probably the field in which marine biological research has most to offer in improving the scientific advice on fishery management. Using the techniques outlined previously of estimating the population abundance, its rate of change, and the growth, mortality and recruitment rates, the biologist can draw up, with a greater or less degree of precision, sets of curves relating the total catch from a stock of fish to the amount of fishing and to the sizes of fish caught. These curves form the essential basis of proper management. I n drawing up these curves the biologist has to ignore, in the first instance, many of the complexities of the real situation. Thus the simplest, and most frequently used form of the Beverton and Holt yield equation ignores possibIe changes in the growth pattern, or in the naturalmortality rate. However as the authorsshow, any likely changes in these will not alter the general shape of the yield curves, and hence will not affect the nature of the biologists’ advice concerning a fishery which is to any extent “overfished ”. When, perhaps as a result of this advice, the fishery approaches to what may be its optimum condition, then these complexities, and others such as the interaction between different species, etc., may well have to be taken into account in order to define the optimum more accurately. There are other effects, in particular the precise nature of the relation between adult stock and the subsequent number of recruits, which, as discussed above, may alter the whole shape of the yield curves. However, the direction of the change will be generally known-at larger stocks (i.e. with reduced fishing mortality or increased size of fish caught)the recruitment (andhence future stocks and future catches) will almost certainly be greater than predicted on the basis of constant recruitment. Thus the yield curves, and assessments based on them, assuming constant recruitment, will be conservative, in the sense that they will provide a lower limit to the benefits from conservation actions. These relations between yield and effort and between yield and size of fish caught are interdependent, so that the form of the curve relating the yield to the size of fish caught depends on the amount of fishing. It will, except a t very low rates of fishing, have a maximum, and the position of this maximum will depend on the amount of fishing. The greater the amount of fishing, the greater will be the size of fish a t
MANAGEMENT
O F FISHERY RESOURCES
21
which the maximum occurs, and also the greater the catch a t the maximum, i.e. a t high fishing rates most fish will be caught, so that it is worth waiting until the fish are well grown, while a t low fishing rates it is better to start catching them when quite small as otherwise they may not be caught at all. Equally, the relation between the amount of fishing and the catch depends on the sizes of fish caught. At low rates of fishing, the catch will increase nearly in proportion to the increase in fishing, whatever sizes are caught (see Fig. 9). If small fish are caught, the increase in catch will soon become proportionally less than the increase in fishing, and the curve of catch against effort will tend to
FIG.9. The relation between fishing mortality and the averagc long-term catch.
flatten out, reach a maximum a t some moderate level of fishing, and decrease, possibly sharply if recruitment is affected, a t higher levels of fishing. If small fish are protected, e.g. by using large mesh nets, the catch will tend t o continue increasing with increasing fishing to higher levels of efforts, so that the maximum yield will be greater and occur a t higher rates of fishing. If only quite large fish are caught, the catch may continue to increase (but very slowly) with increasing fishing, however intense, and the greatest possible yield from a brood of fish would be taken by waiting until the fish reach optimum size and then harvesting them all. I n open waters such immediate harvesting would require an impossibly large fishing effort, but is, of course, common practice in pond culture or animal husbandry in general. The two families of curves may be combined to give contour diagrams showing the yield for any combination of fishing effort and
22
J. A . GULLAND AND J. E. CARROZ
size a t first capture (Beverton and Holt, 1957 ; Dickie and McCracken, 1955 ; Mako, 1961 ; Misu, 1964). Such curves describe the biological situation, but this is not all that is required for management. I n particular, the value of the catch and the cost of catching it must also be considered. The value of the catch will depend on biological factors such as the size of fish (small fish being nearly always less valuable than medium or large fish), and on their condition-fish which have just spawned, for example, often being not very valuable-as well as on economic factors such as the variation of price with supply. The factors can be introduced into the equation t o give expressions for the catch in value, but to a first approximation it is normally sufficient to take the value as being proportional to the weight caught, though most conservation measures tend t o increase the average size of the fish caught, and hence their average price. Other things being equal (and the results of regulation may well be to make them not equal) the cost of fishing will be closely proportional to the amount of fishing, but little affected by the sizes of fish caught. Therefore, if the size of fish caught can be regulated (and it may not be practicable for some gears, e.g. purse seines),the size should be regulated to give the maximum yield for the current amount of fishing, being adjusted as necessary if the amount of fishing changes. It is not so certain that, for rational management, the amount of fishing on a particular stock should be adjusted to give the maximum catch from that stock, even if such a maximum exists a t a practicable level of fishing. The fact that the well-being of a fishery cannot be measured solely by the total weight of the catch, and that there is a need for an objective of management less narrow than the maximum catch has been pointed out by many authors, both biologists and economists (e.g. Graham, 1943; Beverton and Holt, 1957; Schaefer, 1957b; Bell, 1959; Gordon, 1954; Christy and Scott, 1965; Gulland, 1968b). I n the absence of regulation, the fishery will tend to stabilize a t a level where the value of the catch is about equal to the total costs of catching. If the fish are valuable, and easy to capture, and also if small fish cannot be protected, then it is likely that this equilibrium will be reached a t a level of fishing greater than that giving the maximum sustainable yield. A reduction of effort to the level of the maximum yield should result in an increasein the value of the catch, and reduction of costs, and must therefore be beneficial, but a further reduction is also likely to be desirable. Close to the maximum the curve of catch against effort is very flat, so that a small to moderate reduction in effort will result in a negligible reduction of catch. That is, perhaps 98% of the
23
MANAGEMENT O F FISHERY RESOURCES
maximum catch may be taken with only SOYo of the effort required to take the maximum, and the cost per ton of taking the last 2% would be around ten times that of taking the first 98%. Blmost certainly the resources in ships, men and money in taking the last 2% would be much better employed elsewhere-even when the demand is for fish a t almost any cost there are likely to be alternative and relatively unexploited stocks t o which the surplus effort could be diverted. So long as alternative underfished stocks exist the apparent contradiction between the biological objective of greatest physical yield, and the economic objective of greatest economic yield (cf. Christy and Scott, 1965, p. 219) is valid only if considerationis restricted to the individual heavily fished stock. The greatest physical yield from the oceans as a whole will be possible only if the presently overfished stocks are harvested as efficiently as possible. The objective, therefore, of rational management should be to maintain the fishing effort a t the level giving the greatest net returns (value of catch less cost of capture),i.e. at the level where the marginal cost of adding one unit of effort (one extra vessel) is just equal t o the marginal value of the increase in hhe sustained catch resulting from the extra effort, rather than the marginal value being zero (if the effort is at the level giving the maximum sustained yield), or even negative (if the effort is past the maximum). This is shown diagrammatically in Fig. 10, in which the curve in Fig. 9 relating catch (in terms of weight) to the amount of fishing (basically in terms of the proportion of the stock removed per year) is replaced by a curve relating value of the catch to the cost of catching it. To a first approximation the value of the catch is proportional t o the weight caught, and the cost is proportional t o the amount of fishing. Then the equilibrium position is the point A where the line of equal costs and value cuts the curve. I n this example it is beyond the level of fishing which gives the maximum catch, A,, and a reduction of fishingto produce the maximum sustained yield will also produce a surplus of value over costs equal t o A,&. However, a further reduction of fishing to bring the catch to the point A , will produce an even bigger surplus A$,. This simple statement of the immediate economic aspects of management becomes more complex when considering several stocks of fish, or fishing carried out by several countries. Since each country will have different costs, and set different values to the fish, the optimum position for each country will be different. However, if two countries have been fishing the same stock for some time, without great changes, both will presumably have about the same equilibrium position, so that their optimum positions will also be similar. I n any case, if the total effort has increased beyond the A.M.B.-6
2
24
J. A. CULLAND AND J. E. CARROZ
costs FIG.10. The relation between costs of fishing and value of the catch. Point A , where the line of equal costs and values cuts the curve, is the equilibrium position without regulation. The greatest net return, A,-B,, is obtained by limiting fishing to about one-third of the equilibrium level.
level giving the maximum catch, it will be in the interest of all to reduce the effort, even if the magnitude of the reduction in the effort required to reach the various optimum positions may be different. Difference in national interests, and indeed differences between different groups of fishermen in the same country, are likely to be more serious when several stocks of fish of different species are concerned. No species of fish exists in isolation, but may compete with one species for food, be eaten by a second, and feed on a third, and all these stocks may be exploited by different fishermen whose catches will therefore interact. Also fishermen, while catching one species, may incidentally catch another species which is of primary interest to some other fishermen ; for example, in the North Sea, vessels trawling for herring often catch numbers of small haddock (Sahrhage,1959). In such situations it is normally impossible to take the maximum sustainable yield of all the species being exploited : for instance,the maximum yield of haddock would only be taken if no small haddock were killed by herring trawls, which could only be achieved by prohibiting trawling for herring, and this would reduce the catch of herring (I.C.E.S., 1960). Thus, a unique objective of management cannot easily be defined, though the biologist can, a t least in principle, calculate what the effects of possible regulatory action would be, and hence those regulations can be introduced
MANAGEMENT
O F FISHERY RESOURCES
25
which would improve the fisheries of the area as a whole. Thus the damage done by herring trawlers in reducing the haddock catches is less than the extra value of herring taken by the trawlers; therefore restriction of herring trawling to protect the haddock fishery would not be justified when considering the North Sea as a whole. This example also illustrates an important practical difficulty in complex fisheries. I n a simple fishery the restrictions and benefits of regulation can be equitably shared-if the effort should be reduced by 20%, then each group of fishermen can reduce their effort by SOY0, and their share of the catch will be unaltered. I n the North Sea, the losses are being sustained by the haddock fishermen (mainly Scotsmen) and the herring trawlers (from other countries) are unrestricted ; if the biological conclusionshad been different, and herring trawling should be restricted in order t o increase the total North Sea catch, then the losses would all have been t o the herring fishermen, and the gains to the haddock fishermen. These considerations do not, of course, make the need for proper management any less, but do increase the need for the proper quantitative understanding of quite complex biological situations, and for the balancing of the interests of each group of fishermen. They show that while the ultimate objective of fishery management in a region might well be to ensure the greatest total net yield from all the stocks taken together, this objective must be modified to ensure that the restrictions and gains are equitably shared. It may, however, still be attained if there is some system whereby those with the biggest gains pay compensation in some form to those with small gains, or losses.
111. METHODSOF REGULATION A. Types of regulation Any regulation can affect the stocks of fish and future catches only in one or both of two ways : by changing either the total fishing effort (i.e. the fishing mortality, the proportion of the stock caught each year), or the sizes of fish caught. However, a variety of different methods of regulation can be used to achieve one or other of these results ; they include : (a) limitation on the sizes of fish that can be landed ; (b) closed areas ; (c) closed seasons ; (d) limitation on the type of gear ; (e) limitation on total catch ; and (f) limitation on total effort. The effectiveness of these methods must be judged against the objectives of management, which will generally be to achieve the greatest surplus of total value of catch over the total cost of catching it. Thus, regulations to change the sizes of fish caught should not increase the cost of fishing ; regulations aimed at reducing the fishing mortality by some restriction on the amount of fishing, which are intended to
PG
J. A. GULLAND AND J . E. CARROZ
result in the long run in about the same, or possibly even greater, catches with less fishing, should ensure that the cost of fishing can be reduced roughly in proportion to the reduction in fishing mortality. The need for enforcement must also be considered and a good regulation should be both easy and inexpensive to enforce. An important step towards proper fulfilment of a regulation i s the belief by the fishermen that the regulation is necessary t o produce better catches in the future, and that foreign fishermen are also obeying the regulation (to many fishermen, a foreigner is anyone outside his immediate circle). To reduce this suspicion of “foreigners ”it is important that enforcement is not only effective but also seen to be effective. Lately several international commissions have taken steps towards joint enforcement by inspectors of different nationalities on each other’s vessels. (a) S i z e limits are effective methods of controlling the size of fish removed from the stock for those fisheries where undersized fish which are caught accidentally can be returned to the water alive, or where the fisherman can judge the size of fish before capture. Thus size limits are widely used in lobster (Homarusspp.)androcklobster (Panulirus,Jasus, etc.) fisheries, where the animals are caught in traps, and in whaling, where the gunner can judge the size of the whale quite closely before deciding t o fire the harpoon. I n most fisheries the chances of undersized fish surviving after being returned to the water are small. Even if the fish are alive when brought on deck, the fisherman’sfirst interest is in looking after the fish he is going to market (e.g. gutting them and putting them on ice), and preparing the gear t o catch more fish, and only afterwards may he return the undersized fish to the sea, by which time they will be dead. Even for lobsters a significant proportion of the undersized animalsmay die, either from the direct effort of capture and removal from the sea or from increased exposure to predators (Bowen and Chittleborough, 1966). Where few undersized animals survive, size limits by themselves will only reduce the present landings without helping to improve future catches or landings. However, size limits can be of indirect value by discouraging the fishermen from fishing in areas or with gears that would catch quantities of undersized and hence commercially valueless fish. They can help the enforcement of other regulatory methods, such as mesh regulation or closure of nursery areas, by reducing the economic attractions of infringement. (b) Closed areas and (c) closed seasons can be considered together as they can often be combined, i.e. closure of a certain area for a limited period, have similar effects and, in fact, for some migratory fish may be virtually equivalent. As limitations on the amount of fishing they are
MANAGEMENT OF FISHERY RESOURCES
27
not likely to be ideal ; the fishing mortality may be reduced, but it is most unlikely that the costs can be reduced in proportion. Initially a closure of, say, 10% of the normal fishing season will reduce the fishing mortality and the running costs (but not the capital costs) by about l o % , but the long-term effects are likely to be the same as for uiiallocated catch quotas, discussed in more detail below, i.e. an increasingly wasteful entry of new vessels, etc., as the catfell per unit effort rises, necessitating a progressive shortening of the season to maintain the effort (mortality) a t the desired level. Closed areas or closed seasons can also be used to control the sizes of fish caught if there are areas where or times when small fish are particularly common ; for instance, the smaller fish of several species tend t o remain in inshore or shallower areas, and closure of these nursery areas would give effcctive protection of these smaller fish. I n addition, there nzay be times or places where the fish are in poor condition (e.g. after spawning), and when closure would allow the fish to recover and thus give a larger and more valuable catch. Such closures (other than a closure of all areas to fishing for a season) are particularly valuable when there are alternative grounds which can be fished profitably while the nursery areas are closed. Otherwise such closures would involve temporary lay-up of vessels, or diversion to an unprofitable fishery, and hence add to the cost of the fishery. (d) Regulation of the type of gear may be divided Into those banning or restricting the use of more efficient, or "damaging ", gears, i.e. aimed a t reducing the fishing mortality, and those, such as mesh regulations, aimed a t controlling the sizes of fish caught. The former types have little justification as a permanent feature of fishery management ; they only succeed in reducing the fishing mortality to the extent that they increase the costs of catching a given proportion of the stock. They may be necessary when increased fishing effort will severely reduce the total catch, e.g. by reducing the number of recruits, but when used they are an implicit admission of failure to achieve any ketter management. Regulation of the gear to control the sizes of fish caught, especially mesh regulation of trawls, are useful and have been introduced widely in the North Atlantic, and also in other areas, such as the East China Sea. Generally, they do not affect the cost of fishing, and indeed a trawl with larger meshes may be cheaper and fish more effectively on the larger fish. The selectivity of many gears, such as purse seines, cannot be altered in practice-they catch all the fish in a shoal-while that of others, e.g. long-lines, can only be altered rather imprecisely-larger hooks tend to catch larger fish, but the relation is far from exact. Even
28
J. A. GULLAND AND J. E. CARROZ
for trawls, selection takes place over a range of sizes. If it is desired to take fish of a certain size and bigger, the mesh size can be chosen t o retain half of the fish of the critical size, and release half of them, but some fish considerably smaller will be retained, and others considerably larger than the critical size will escape. If the fisherman sees some of these larger fish escape while he is hauling his net, he will become less willing to use larger meshes, especially as a fish in the water looks larger than one on deck. Because of the range of sizes over which selection takes place, and also because the selection apparently varies with the condition of the fish, the exact material and treatment of the twine in the net (especially the cod-end of the trawl), the magnitude of the catch, duration of haul, etc., the measurement of selection raises many practical problems (Gulland, 1964b). A considerable volume of literature has grown up concerned with the subject (see especially the report of the Joint I.C.N.A.F./I.C .E.S./F.A. 0. Special Scientific meeting (I.C.N.A.F., 1963) which contains papers not solely concerned with selection in trawls, and the reports of the various I.C.E.S. working groups (I.C.E.S., 1964, 1965)). For selectivity experiments outside the North Atlantic, see Aoyama (1961), Cassie (1955) and Longhurst (1959, 1960). A more serious limitation to mesh size and similar regulationsis that many of the fisheries to which they are applied exploit several species, which may be caught in the same haul. Especially when different groups of fishermen prefer different species, i t is impracticable to introduce a mesh size sufficiently large to provide effective regulation for the stocks of the larger species without causing unacceptable reductions in the catches of the smaller species. For example, in the North Sea the biggest catches of bottom-living species are of cod, haddock and plaice, all of which, and the trawl catch as a whole, would be increased by the use of meshes of 100 mm and over-probably for cod and plaice up to a t least 150 mm. However, i t has proved impossible to introduce meshes larger than 80 mm because they would cause losses of the smaller species (especially sole (Xolea solea L.) and whiting (MerZangusrnerlangus (L.)),and these are of major importance to some groups of fishermen. I n any case, even the mesh size (ca 110 mm) which would give the greatest total yield of all species would give considerably less than the sum of the yields from individual species, if the optimum mesh was used for each: ca 80 mni for soles and ca 150 mm for cod, etc. (I.C.E.S., 1957). The most fundamental disadvantage of mesh regulation as the only method of management is that its very success tends to cause changes which lose much of the benefits. The improved catches attract new
MANAGEMENT OF FISHERY RESOURCES
29
entrants to the fishery, thus reducing the stock again until the returns to the individual fishermen are back to their previous level.
B. Limitation of the amount of Jishing Proper management must therefore include some control over the amount of fishing (the fishing mortality), through direct limitation of total catch or total effort, supported where necessary and practicable by measures such as mesh regulation to control the sizes of fish caught. Some of the practical problems depend on whether the amount of fishing is measured as input (fishing effort, e.g. number of hours fishing by a standard vessel, etc.) or as output (catch),but the more important question as far as many of the economic results are concernedis whether the total amount of fishing is set as a simple overall quota, and when this is reached all fishing stops, or whether individual quotas are set for each group of fishermen. If only an overall quota is set, then everyone will scramble to obtain the maximum share for themselves. This scramble, clearly predictable on theoretical grounds, has occurred in all the major stocks regulated by a simple quota ; for example, the Antarctic whaling (until the nations concerned agreed how to share the quota), or the Pacific halibut (Hippoglossus stenolepis Schmidt) (quotas have generally been set in terms of catch, but the same results may be expected if there is a simple effort quota, e.g. fishing continues until the effort totals 1000 days fishing). As a result of the increasing resources invested, and the correspondingreduction of the length of the season, the cost of exerting a unit of fishing effort rose roughly in proportion t o the reduction in total effort, leaving the total cost of capture about the same. Regulation by means of a simple unallocated quota cannot, in the long run, achieve any substantial reduction of cost, and the benefit of regulation and the reduction of effort will be limited to any increase in catch, though this may be substantial for some stocks (e.g. whales ; Gulland, 1966a). If the total quota is allocated to groups of fishermen within which competition is reduced or eliminated, then the dissipation of the potential benefits of regulation by excessive costs should not occur. Each group of fishermen can organize its activities so as to take its share of the catch a t the least cost, or perhaps take advantage of the benefits of regulation in other ways, e.g. one country might wish for social reasons t o ensure a living for the maximum number of fishermen. As regulation becomes effective and the stocks build up, the difference between the value of the catch and the cost of catching it will increase, possibly very greatly, making the right to a share of the catch increasingly valuable.
30
J. A . GULLAND A N D J. E. CARROZ
For instance, it is likely that the cost of harvesting the salmon of the Pacific coast of North America could be reduced by about threequarters by having a management policy which allowed the most effective gears to be used. If such a policy could be introduced then the right to catch, say, $1 000 000 worth of salmon would be worth $750 000, the actual costs of capture, including a reasonable return on capital, accounting for only $250 000. Clearly in such a situation tlie problem of allocating the shares of the quota will become acute. In national fisheries these problems are soluble, a t least in principle. There is a central body which can enforce any decision as to how the quota is allocated, and ensure that fishing is not carried out by those with no quota. An attractive method that has been proposed is that the excess allocation should be reduced by charging a very substantial licence fee, equal to nearly the difference between value of catch and cost of capture (e.g. $700 000 for a licence t o take $1 000 000 worth o f salmon). The money obtained from these licences can then be spent in suitable ways: to offset all the cost of management and associated research, to provide research into alternative stocks, for general welfare of tlie fishermen, as well as a contribution to central government funds. The significanceof this scheme is that there is an explicit realization that in a well-managed fishery there may be a very considerable surplus of the value of the catch above the cost of catching it, and a definite decision is made as to who shall get this surplus. To some extent a t least the primary problem of fishery managemen-that fish stocks are a commoii property resource-has been overcome. Though the stocks do not become the property of tlie government or similar body, the government does have a large degree of authorityover the management. It also would have a direct financial incentive in proper management because the surplus of value over costs, and hence the price the fishermen would be prepared t o pay for licences, depends critically on the management methods. Internationalfisheries present much more complex problems in the allocation of the share of the catch, and particularly to countries wishing to enter a fishery for the first time. Many countries are rapidly expanding their fisheries, and would be most, unwilling to accept allocations based directly on the catches in previous years. If the target figures for future years are known, then a t least in principle they form in the short term an equitable and reasonable basis for allocation. At the least when allocating a quota for, say, 1970, the likely national sharesin 1970 in the absence of any regulation or allocationare probably a better guide to allocation than the catches in 1966. For instance, if a country a t present taking 20% of the catch plans to double its fishing,
31
MANAGEMENT OF FISHERY RESOURCES
and if the othcrs do not change, its share would go up t o about 33%) the share of the others going down accordingly, Quotas allocated in these proportions would then be equitable in the sense that with regulation each country would take the same share of catch as it would have done in the absence of regulation. As the stocks build up under good management the allocation will become more difficult, since fishing will become more attractive and more countries will desire t o increase their fishery. I n whatever way the limit is set, either as a single overall quota or allocated to groups of fishermen, it must be defined either in terms of catch or amount of fishing, e.g. number of days at sea. The objective, in biological terms, is t o achieve a certain fishing mortality, i.e. t o capture a certain proportion of the stock each year. Neither the catch nor the amount of fishing (at least in readily measurable physical terms) will bear an absolutely constant relation to the fishing mortality. The catch corresponding to a desired fishing mortality will depend on the stock abundance,while the amount of fishing effort required to exert a given fishing mortality will depend on the efficiency of the operation chosen as the unit of effort (e.g. a day at sea by a vessel of a certain size) and whether the distribution and behaviour of the fish make them more or less catchable. The catch is readily definable in standard terms (though the increasing numbers of vessels freezing and processing at sea will complicate the precise measurement of the catch in terms of round fresh (live) weight). The definition of fishing effort in standard terms is much more difficult, especially if a limit is set as a single quota requiring the efforts exerted by all the vessels engaged in the fishery t o be expressed in the same terms. The difficulties of effort measurement are less if there is allocation of quota, explicitly or implicitly ; e.g. if all countriesagree to reduce their amount of fishing (as measured in various national units) by a certain percentage, or if limitation is set by issuing licences. I n the latter case the problem of standard measurement of effort may only become serious when a licensed fisherman wishes to improve his efficiency by getting a bigger or newer vessel, or by changing his type of gear. The measurement of the amount of fishing in terms of catch also has its difficulties, chiefly through the need to have a measure of the abundance of the fish stock. Many fish stocks fluctuate widely in abundance due to varying strengths of year-classes, while the quota for a year or a season must be set reasonably in advance of the season. Some system of forecasting the stock is required, and this can usually be done with a varying degree of precision, though sometimes requiring special rescarch effort, e.g. the use of research vessels to survey the 2'
32
J. A. GULLAND AND J. E. CARROZ
abundance of fish as yet too small to be fished. Fortunately, a t least with the longer-lived species, moderate errors in setting the quotas in one year can be corrected by suitable adjustment in the subsequent year without appreciable loss, but this does require that the administrative machinery for setting and adjusting the quota is reasonably rapid. The complexities of regulation are further increased when more than one species of fish is considered. Apart from the fisheries on shoalingfish such as anchoveta, herring, etc., few of the other important fisheries of the world are based exclusively on one species. Within a large fishing region the proportion caught of different species varies from ground t o ground, and also often from season to season on the same ground. The needs for regulation of the various species also tend to vary, possibly very widely; the more valuable species may be seriously over-exploited, while others be hardly exploited a t all. Proper management must therefore ensure suitable regulation for the former species, without discouraging fishing on the others, and this is not easy. Thus the success of the regulation of the Pacific halibut might be judged by comparing the catches in recent years of ca 15 000 tons of halibut in the Atlantic (where there are no special regulations to protect the halibut, which because of its potentially long life, slow growth, and high value is especially vulnerable to too heavy fishing) with nearly 40 000 tons in the Pacific, where halibut fishing is strictly regulated. However, it might possibly equally validly be argued that the failure of the halibut regulation is measured by the comparison of the total catches of all species from the areas in which halibut occur in significant quantities. About 1; million tons of other bottom-living fish (cods, redfishes and flounders) are caught annually off the east coast of Canada (T.C.N.A.F. areas 2-4), but until recently only about 60 000 tons were taken off the west coast of Canada and Alaska from the grounds covered by the Halibut Commission. I n the last few years very large catches have been taken in the area by trawlers from Japan and the U.S.R.R. but these countries are not members of the Halibut Commission. A most serious failurein a rather different way, throughnot considering individual stocks but only the overall total, has occurred in Antarctic whaling, where the stocks of blue, fin and sei whales have been in succession the main object of the industry (Fig. 11). Attention did not switch from the preferred to the next most preferred species (blue t o fin, or fin to sei) until the former had been drastically depleted. Although now only the sei whale stocks (the smallest stock of the three) are abundant enough to support any appreciable catches, the actual catches in any one of the past seasons which have so decimated the
MANAGEMENT O F FISHERY RESOURCES
33
FIG.11. A whale catcher with its catch. A photograph taken in 1952 during the rich years of post-war whaling. (Photo: F.A.O.)
stocks were probably less than the annual catches which could have been sustained indefinitely if all three stocks had been maintained and harvested a t the optimum level. Ideally, therefore, separate limits (catch or effort quotas) should be set for each species, but this raises the problem when two or more species are caught together in varying proportions of what happens when the limit for one species has been reached. Often it is then uneconomic or impracticable to carry on a fishery directed solely on the other species. The experience of the International Whaling Commission does, however, suggest a possible technique for managing multi-species fisheries; that is by setting an overall quota, with catches of each
31
J . A. GULLAND AND J . E. CARROZ
species contributingtowards this quota with different weighting factors. For whales these factors were set to give approximately equal economic value, i.e. one blue whale unit (BWU) is equal to one blue whale, two fin whales or six sei whales; but they could equally well be set (and adjusted as necessary) to take into account the need for protection for each species. Thus in, say, 1955 the blue whde stocks were seriously over-exploited, the fin whales probably a t about the optimum level, and the sei whales virtually untouched. Appropriate factors might then have been 1 BWU = 0.5 blue whales = 2 fin whales = 15 sei whales
so that, provided also that the total quota had been allocated to countries or expeditions, there would be strong discouragement t o kill blue whales, and equally a positive inducement t o go after sei whales. This section cannot include all possible methods of regulation, and more especially all the problems likely to arise where they are introduced. Certain general conclusions can be made. Regulations controlling the sizes of fish caught can only be used in limited types of fisheries (e.g. in trawl nets where the mesh size can be changed). I n these fisheries they can have definite, if limited beneficial effects, but the benefits tend to be dissipated unless there is also control of the amount of fishing. The essential step in f ~ dmanagement l is therefore to control the amount of fishing and this will, in an overfished stock, produce a considerable surplus of value of catch above costs. An important decision should be made as to how, and by whom, this surplus shall be taken, otherwise it is probable that the surplus will be dissipated in some form of excessive costs. Rational management usually involves restriction of free entry into the fishery, which may be relatively easy in a national fishery or when a nation has been allocated a national quota, i.e. where there is a central body, having strong authority and powers of enforcement, but is not so easy in international fisheries. For these, limitation of entry may involve such questions as the extent of exclusive fishery limits, and the powers of internationalcommissions, and these are discussed in the following section.
IV. THE MECHANICSOF MANAGEMENTAND INTERNATIONAL LAW Nations can approach the problem of making fisheries management a reality in two ways: first, the national approach, by taking appropriate measures in sea areas off their shores over which they exercise sovereignty (territorial sea) or over which they claim jurisdiction over fisheries (fishery zones), fishermen of other countries usually being completely excluded ; second, the international approach, by setting
MANAGEMENT
O F FISHERY RESOURCES
35
up international commissions with responsibility for somc particular fishery or groups of fisheries on the high seas. These approaches are closely related to the general questions of the law of the sea and to the principles of conservation of natural resources. Since the seventeenth century, when the development of seabornc trade and the emergence of powerful maritime nations led to a shift from the notion of closed seas claimed by a few countries to the concept of open seas, the two basic principles of the law of the sea have been that a strip of offshorewaters should be under the exclusive sovereignty of the coastal state and that the high seas beyond should be free. These principles were originally intended to satisfy and reconcile reasons of national security and the freedom of trade and navigation. But they applied to all activities in both areas and accordingly defined the legal framework within which fishing activities were carried on. The exclusive fishing rights of coastal states off their own shores and the freedom of fishing on the high seas are still the basic principles on which international fisheries law rests ; efforts have, however, been made recently to define more clearly the extent to which these rights and this freedom may be exercised. A. Territorial sea and fishing zones The exact delimitation of the sea where a coastal state enjoys exclusive fishing rights is of great importance, as it has a direct bearing on the regulation of fisheries and in particular demarcates these waters from the high seas where conservation and management problems are clearly international in nature, though the movements and migrations of many species of fish make such man-made limits often unrealistic. Until recently the sea area where coastal states had exclusive jurisdiction over fisheries was, in all cases, co-extensive with the territorial sea, i.e. the belt of sea immediately offshore where coastal states exercise sovereignty to the same degree as over their own land territory. The area claimed by any state as territorial sea, however, varied greatly between individual states, claims of areas from 3 t o 12 nautical miles being most common, though in exceptional cases claims covered a much wider area. The breadth of the territorial sea was considered by the United Nations Conference on the Law of the Sea in 1958. Although the Conference adopted a convention on the territorial sea, including rules on the baseline for measuring its width, no agreement was reached on the width itself (United Nations, 1958). A second Conference was held in 1960 ; there again no agreement was reached (United Nations, 1960). One proposal, which failed to be
36
J. A. GULLAND AND J . E . CARROZ
adopted by only one vote of the two-thirds majority required, had a definite influence on subsequent national and international measures. The proposal envisaged : (1) Allowing states to claim as territorial sea an area extending up to 6 miles from the coast. ( 2 ) Allowing states to claim exclusive fishing rights in a fishing zone immediately beyond the territorial sea extending up to 12 miles from the coast. States whose vessels had hahitually fished in the outer 6 miles of the fishing zone (i.e. the entire fishing zone if states claimed a 6-mile territorial sea plus a 6-mile fishing zone) for a period of five years immediately preceding 1 January 1958 would have been entitled to continue such fishing for a period of ten years after 31 October 1960. (3) Allowing a coastal state, subject to certain safeguards, to claim preferential fishing rights in any area of the high seas adjacent to its exclusive fishing zone, when it was scientifically established that a special situation or condition made the exploitation of the living resources of the high seas in that area of fundamental importance to the economic development of the coastal state or for food supplies for its population. Since 1960, several states have enacted legislation providing for an exclusive fishing zone extending to 12 miles from the coast. In addition, bilateral agreements have bccn concluded on the basis of the 1960 proposal and a European Fisheries Convention was signed in 1964. While the Convention does not contain any statement on the breadth of the territorial sea, it does provide that the contracting parties have the exclusive right to fish and exclusive jurisdiction in matters of fisheries within the belt of 6 miles measured from the baseline of their territorial sea ;within the belt between the 6 and 12 mile limit, the right to fish shall be exercised only by the coastal state and by any other contracting parties, the fishing vessels of which have habitually fished in that belt between 1 January 1953 and 31 December 1962. Thc right granted t o the fishing vessels of the other contracting parties is not limited in time, but they may not direct their fishing effort towards stocks of fish or fishing grounds substantially different from those which they have habitually exploited. Furthermore,the coastal state may, under the Convention, regulate fisheries within the 6-12 mile belt, provided that there is no discrimination in form or in fact against duly authorized fishing vessels of other contracting parties. The Convention does not specify that contracting parties will claim an exclusive 1 2 mile fishing zone with respect to all states not parties to the Convention.
MANAGEMENT O F FISHERY RESOURCES
37
As can be seen, there is today an obvious lack of uniformity in the delimitation of the offshore area where coastal states have exclusive fishing rights. Thus, national claims vary as to the breadth of the territorial sea. Furthermore, in many countries, there is a trend to dissociate fishery limits entirely from the territorial sca. When states establish a fishing zone extending further than the territorial sea, the zone concerned is not always exclusive and fishing rights may be granted, either for a transitional period or without specified time-limit, to fishing vessels of certain other states. Mention should also be made of the recent practice whereby certain coastal states in Asia, without claiming jurisdiction over fisheries, reserve the right t o regulate fishing in a zone contiguous to their territorial sea and exclusive fishing zone, should this be necessary for conservation purposes. Such additional zone usually extends up to 100 miles.
High seas At the beginning of this century it had already been recognized that the living resources of the sea were not inexhaustible and that, in view of the freedom of fishing enjoyed by all nations on the high seas, it would be necessary to ensure the rational exploitation of the resources through international collaboration. At the same time, it became clear that more research was needed into the biological and environmental aspects of fisheries in the interest of this objective. As a beginning, measures to achieve co-ordination of scientific research and to take positive steps in managing the resources were taken on a regional basis. The InternationalCouncil for the Exploration of the Sea was established in 1902 to encourage and co-ordinate investigation of the eastern North Atlantic Ocean, including the waters off Greenland and Iceland. I n 1911 a convention was concluded for the preservation and protection of fur seals and sea otters in the waters of the North Pacific Ocean. The question arose as to whether it was possible to make a global approach to the problem of conservation and management of the resources of the sea by seeking the widest possible agreement not only on the basic principles which should govern all regional conventions but also on the basic rules t o be observed in areas of potential conflict. The League of Nations considered including the exploitation and conservation of the products of the sea among the subjects to be submitted to an international codification conference. The major fishing countries, however, believed that the diversity of the biological, economic and political problems arising in different fishing areas would
38
J. A. GULLAND AND J. E. CARROZ
make it preferable t o draw up regulations in relation to the needs of particular fishing areas, by agreement between the nations directly concerned. The general problem of the rules applicable t o the high seas was selected by the United Nations in 1949 for consideration as a topic for codification by the InternationalLaw Commission. The draft articles prepared by the Commission in 1951 contained a provision proposing that it would be the duty of states to accept as binding upon their nationals any system of fisheries regulation in any area of the high seas where an international authority believed that such measures were essential for the protection of the resources against waste or extermination. This international authority was to be created within the framework of the United Nations and could have acted at the request of any interested state. The provision concerned was not, however, retained in the final version of the draft articles submitted to the 1958 United Nations Conference on the Law of the Sea. The 1958 Conference adopted several international instruments, including a Convention on Fishing and Conservation of the Living Resources of the High Seas. The Convention, which came into force in 1966, is the first attempt t o deal with the problem generally on a world scale. Its scope is of necessity limited and i t aims mainly at promoting the adoption of conservation measures and a t providing for machinery designed to facilitate the settlement of disputes. It also contains provisions stressing the special interests of coastal states in the maintenance of the productivity of the living resources in any area of the high seas adjacent to their territorial sea and their right to take part on an equal footing in any system of research and regulation for the conservation of the living resources in that area, even though their nationals do not carry on fishing there. The 1958 Conference fully realized that the Convention referred to above would have to be supplemented by special and regional agreements. It adopted a resolution recommending that the states concerned should co-operate in establishing the necessary conservation measures through international conservation bodies covering particular areas of the high seas or particular species of living marine resources. It also recommended that these bodies should be used, in so far as practicable, for the conduct of negotiations on conservation measures envisaged in the Convention, for the settlement of disputes and for the implementation of agreed conservation measures. I n the resolution, the Conference specifically referred t o the report of the International Technical Conference on the Conservation of the Living Resources of the Sea, which had been convened in 1955 to make appropriate scientific and
MANAGEMENT O F FISHERY RESOURCES
39
technical recommendations in preparation for the 1958 Conference on the Law of the Sea (United Nations, 1956). The 1955 Technical Conference had come to the conclusionthat the system of international fishery regulation based on the geographical and biological distribution of marine populations seemed, in general, to be the most suitable way of handling these problems. This system was based upon conventions signed by the nations concerned.
B. Xpecialized Jishery bodies Most of the existing internationalfishery bodies were established by conventions conchded after the Second World War. Five of them were set up under the auspices of F.A.O. pursuant to the relevant provisions of its Constitution. Certain fishery bodies were established to cover a particular sea or specified lake or river systems (e.g. the Joint Commission for Black Sea Fisheries or the Great Lakes Fishery Commission). Others were set up to serve a region of the high seas which is precisely delineated by longitude and latitude (e.g. the International Commission for the Northwest Atlantic Fisheries and the North-East Atlantic Fisheries Commission). The area of competence of many fishery bodies, however, is defined only in general terms (e.g. the Eastern Pacific Ocean for the Inter-AmericanTropical Tuna Commission or the Indo-Pacific area for the Indo-Pacific Fisheries Council). The absence of well-defined geographical limits may sometimes be advantageousin that it allows of flexibility in taking account of surveys and investigations into the biology of the species concerned. It should, however, be noted that each time member countries are requested to provide data to co-ordinate or conduct research, or each time a commission needs t o formulate conservation measures, a specific area has to be defined. What seems important is that the area of competence should be large enough to encompass the entire range of the stocks constituting the resource with which the commission is concerned. It may be mentioned in this connexion that most conventions setting up international fishery bodies include in their area of competence the territorial sea of member countries. The great majority of international fishery bodies were set up to deal with sea fisheries. Actually, a glance a t a map delineating, by oceans and seas, their areas of competence, would show that practically all the marine waters of the planet are covered and even, in certain regions, several times over. This should not, however, lead to the conclusion that all the living resources of the sea are the object of scientific investigation and management measures. I n fact, the
40
J . A. GI’LLANII AND J. E . CARROZ
composition, species coverage, functions, powers and activities of internationalfishery bodies vary considerably. The effectiveness of these bodies depends to a very great extent on the participation and collaboration of all the states concerned. Such states would normally be limited to those whose nationals and vessels carry out fishing operations in the geographic area served in the region. The provisions of the basic instruments concerning eligibility for membership do not always make it possible for all these states to participate. I n several cases the fisheries bodies are, as it were, land-based, since only states whose territories are situated in the area of competenee may become members. These include the Regional Fisheries Advisory Commission for the South-West Atlantic and the Regional Fisheries Commission for Western Africa, both set up under the Constitution of F.A.O. A certain number o f conventions do not provide expressly or implicitly for the possibility of later accessions, but this should not necessarily be interpreted as excluding the acceptance of new members. Several conventions provide that membership of the fisheries body is open, under certain conditions, to states other than the coastal states in the area of competence or t o states other than original members. Thus, any states whose nationals participate in fisheries in the area of competence o f the Inter-American Tropical Tuna Commission may become members of the Commission with the unanimous consent of the contracting parties. Only a few commissions are open to any states which adhere to the basic instrument simply by addressing the required notification to the depositary government. They include the International Commission for the Northwest Atlantic Fisheries, the International Whaling Commission, and the North-East Atlantic Fisheries Commission. When the membership of international fishery bodies is open, acceptance of all rights and duties as a member of such bodies is entirely voluntary. Under existing rules of international law, neither the states whose nationals or vessels carry out fishing operations on the high seas in the area of competence of a fisheries body, nor the coastal states in cases where a stock or stocks of fish inhabit both the fishing areas under their jurisdiction and areas of the adjacent high seas, may be compelled t o become full members of the body or to comply with any conservation measure it may formulate. The 1958 United Nations Conferenceon the Law of the Sea could only adopt recommendations on the subject, urging states concerned to co-operate. Many international fishery commissions and councils were set up to deal with all fisheries resources within their area of competence.
MANAGEMENT OP FISHERY RESOURCES
41
Notable exceptions are the International Whaling Commission, the North Pacific Fur Seal Commission, the International Pacific Halibut Commission, the Inter-American Tropical Tuna Commission, and the InternationalPacific Salmon Fisheries Commission. There are in practice marked differences in the manner in which fishery bodies deal with any particular stock of fish. This depends to a great extent on the functions of the body concerned. A first category of fishery bodies comprises those which deal mainly with the encouragement,promotion, and co-ordination of researchand which, in the course of their activities, may offer advice and make recommendations on the need for conservation measures. Examples of this type of body are the InternationalCouncil for the Exploration of the Sea, the International Commission for the Scientific Exploration of the Mediterranean Sea, and the commissions and councils set up under the Constitution of F.A.O. A second category includes fishery bodies, the main function of which is to formulate conservation measures on the basis of scientific research, but this research is not normally carried out by their own staffs (e.g. the International North Pacific Fisheries Commission, the Joint Commission for Black Sea Fisheries, the North-East Atlantic Fisheries Commission ; the last of these receives its scientific advice from another international body, the International Council for the Exploration of the Sea, included in the first category). A third category comprises the fisheries commissions which formulate conservation measures on the basis of scientific investigations carried out by their own staff. They are the Inter-American Tropical Tuna Commission, the International Pacific Salmon Fisheries Commission, and the InternationalPacific Halibut Commission. Conventions do not always specify the type of conservation and management measures that may be formulated by the international fishery bodies they establish. Detailed listing of conservation measures shows that these are normally confined mainly t o prohibitions and limitations ; these include most of the measures listed a t the beginning of the previous section: open and closed seasons or areas, minimum sizes of mesh of fishing nets, size limits of fish and regulation of the use of certain types of fishing gear, appliances and equipment. I n a few cases, the conservation measures expressly include prescribing a maximum or overall catch limit (e.g. InternationalCommissjoii for the Northwest Atlantic Fisheries, International Whaling Commission, and InternationalPacific Halibut Commission). Few commissions expressly include limitation of effort, and the North-East Atlantic Fisheries Commission places limitation of effort (and catch)in a separate,inactive,
,42
J . A. GCLLAKD
AND J. E. CARROZ
category of regulations which can only be actively considered after a specific recommendation to this effect has been passed by the Commissioii. Very few conventions list specific measures of a positive nature. An exception is the convention setting up the North-EastAtlantic Fisheries Commission which provides that the Commission may elaborate measures for the improvement and the increase of marine resources, which may include artificial propagation and the transplantation of organisms and of young. Before reaching agreement on the type of conservation measure that needs to be formulated, international fishery bodies normally consider not only the biological and simple economic effects outlined in the previous section, but also the problems of feasibility and enforcement. It should be pointed out that in most cases member countries are not under a legal obligation to comply with the conservation and management measures formulated by fishery bodies. The power of the majority of existing commissionsis limited to making recommendations, either because the convention concerned expressly so provides, or because the conservation measures have to be approved by member countries before they can be applied. I n a few cases a procedure has been evolved to facilitate acceptance of the measures formulated by commissions. These measures may be called potentially binding recommendations or conditional decisions. Thus the North-East Atlantic Fisheries Commission may recommend a number of conservation measures and member countries undertake to give effect t o any such recommendation adopted by not less than a two-thirds majority of the delegations present and voting. However, any member country may object to the recommendation within a specified period, in which case it is under no obligation to give effect to its terms. A somewhat similar procedure exists with respect to the measures formulated by the InternationalWhaling Commission and by the Permanent Commission for the South Pacific. When conservation measures are binding on member countries, each country is required t o ensure their application on the high seas by its own nationals and vessels. There is, however, a trend towards a certain measure of international control. I n fact, several conventions establishing fishery bodies (e.g. the International Pacific Salmon Fisheries Commission, the International North Pacific Fisheries Commission, the International Pacific Halibut Commission, the Japanese-Soviet Fisheries Commission for the North-West Pacific, and the North Pacific Fur Seal Commission) grant to each member country
MANAGEMENT OF FISHERY RESOURCES
43
the right to control the general application of conservation measures on the high seas as among the contracting parties. They prescribe, with certain differences of detail, a procedure whereby duly authorized officials of any member country may search and seize vessels of other member countries which are acting in violation of the convention or of regulationsadopted under it. Suchvessels must be delivered as promptly as practicable to the authorized officials of the member country having jurisdiction over them. Only the authorities of that country may conduct prosecutions and impose penalties. Though these commissions with interactional control measures a t present in operation have limited membership (a maximum of four countries), efforts to ensure international control are not restricted to commissions with a small membership or a limited species coverage. The Convention for the Regulation of Whaling was amended to enable the International Whaling Commission to deal with methods of inspection, and an internationalobserver scheme has been devised but it has not yet proved possible to bring it into operation. Both the InternationalCommission for the Northwest Atlantic Fisheries and the North-East Atlantic Fisheries Commission have also concerned themselves recently with the international enforcement of regulations in their area of competence and they have the matter under active consideration. International control will become increasingly important, as i t is gradually being recognized that, when scientific evidence calls for measures t o be taken, the purposes of conservation and management can best be achieved by limiting the amount of fishing (fishing mortality) either by control of the fishing effort or by regulation of the amount of total catch. The full benefit from limitation on fishing will, as mentioned earlier, only be achieved with some system of allocation of the total quota, whether of catch or of effort (e.g. days fishing). Several conventions contain provisions on the manner in which the yield from the resources is to be portioned among member countries. The convention setting up the InternationalPacific Salmon Fisheries Commission lays down the principle that the two member countries (Canada and the U.S.A.) should share equally in the fishery and, consequently, one of the tasks of the Commission is to regulate the fishery with a view to allowing, as nearly as practicable, an equal portion of the fish that may be caught each year to be taken by the fishermen of each member country. The convention establishing the North Pacific Fur Seal Commission, which has four member countries, provides for a system of quotas to
44
J. A . GULLAND AND J. E. CARROZ
ensure the distribution of the resources which migrate between the territory of certain member countries and the high seas. As all member countries agree to restrict killing of fur seals to the home islands and to prohibit sealing on the high seas in the Pacific Ocean north of the 30th parallel of latitude north, a portion of the total yield is granted to those member countries which do not own any islands on which the seals breed and which otherwise would have no share in the fishery as a result of their agreement not t o engage in sealing on the high seas. Of the total number of seal skins taken commercially each season on land, both the U.S.A. and the U.S.S.R. deliver to Canada and Japan 1.5%) each of the gross take in number and value. The convention setting up the InternationalNorth Pacific Fisheries Commission also contains provisions on the subject, as it embodies rules laying down what is known as the princiFle of abstention. According t o this principle, states not fishing a specific stock in recent years are required t o abstain from fishing this resource when states participating in the fishcries have created, built up, or restored the resource through the expenditure of time, effort and money on research and management, and through restraints on their own fishermen. It should, however, be scientifically established that the continuingand increasingproductivity of the resource is the result of and dependent on such action by the participating states, and that the resource is so fully utilized that an increase in the amount of fishing would not result in any substantial increase in the sustainable yield. Most conventions do not, however, prescribe how- the yield from the resource should be allocated. Internationalfishery bodies have thus to face this problem a t the time of fixing the maximum catch to be taken. For example, every year since 1961, the Inter-American Tropical Tuna Commission has recommended the establishment of a total catch limit of yellowfin tuna in a specified area of the eastern Pacific and the closure of fishing operations a t such date as the quantity landed plus the expected landings of vessels a t sea reach an amount slightly less than the total catch permitted. Under this system, fishing countries can freely compete for a maximum share within the total limit set by the Commission. This required, of course, not only the agreement of member countries but also the co-operation of other countries fishing in the area. As certain countries would prefer to be allotted a national quota, efforts are being made to reach a solution. Antarctic whaling may be cited as an example of a shift from the principle of free competition within an overall catch limit to the adoption of national quotas. While for many years the expeditions from the Antarctic whaling countries took part in what were known as
MANAGEMENT O F FISHERY RESOURCES
45
whaling Olympics ”, in an effort t o maximize their share of the total quota set by the Commission, the countries started negotiations in 1958 with a view t o agreeing on national quotas. An instrument was signed in 1962 for a four-year period. The overall limits are fixed by the International Whaling Commission, but the arrangements on the distribution of the total catch are made by the countries concerned. The general problem of allocation of the yield from the resources of the sea was considered to some extent by the 1955 International Technical Conference on the Conservation of the Living Resources of the Sea and to a greater degree by the 1958 United Nations Conference on the Law of the Sea. Discussions a t the 1958 Conference centred on the principle of abstention and on the concept of a preferential share for coastal states. No specific provision pertaining to the apportionment of the yield from the resources was included in the Convention on Fishing and Conservation of the Living Resources of the High Seas. The Conferenceadopted, however, a Resolution on the special situation of countries or territories whose people are overwhelmingly dependent upon coastal fisheries for their livelihood or economic development. The membership, area and scope of responsibility and main measures in use of the various Commissions have been set out in P.A.O. Reports (P.A.O., 1966b). Most of these Commissions issue extensive reports which outline not only the progress made in introducing various regulations, but also the results of the scientific research on which the regulations are based. C<
V. PROBLEMS AND PROSPECTS FOR FUTURE PROGRESS A. Achievements of present bodies Any discussion of the prospects for future progress in fishery management must start with a consideration of what progress has been achieved so far. Earlier sections have described the methods of regulation, and the powers and objectives of the Commissions that have been set up. I n these sections it appeared that regulation of the size of animals caught, though in the long run less important than control of the amount of fishing, presented fewer problems. This has been borne out by the experience of most of the international commissions. I n the fisheriesfor which many commissions are responsible little regulation of the size of fish caught is possible. For instance, the Pacific Halibut Commission limits fishing gears to long-lines, which catch the bigger fish, but further adjustmentof the sizes caught is impracticable though fishing on the “nursery” grounds is discouraged by minimum size limits of 5 lb. Where adjustment of size is possible, it has gen&ally received considerable attention from the commission concerned. Thus,
46
J. A . GULLAND AND J. E. CARROZ
the InternationalWhaling Commission has set size limits which should protect the small, generally immature, whales, and also, for pelagic operations, almost all the female sperm whales (for this species, which is polygamous, rational management is presumably to limit the kill mainly or entirely to the surplus males). Unfortunately, there is good evidence that these size limits have, at least in some years, been extensively violated; this underlines the need for some system of international inspection or enforcement, especially when the incentive for infringement is large. As the experience of the Antarctic baleen whaling shows (in which infringements of the size limits have probably not been serious), size limits by themselves are very far from being a sufficient method of management. Both North Atlantic Commissions have been deeply involved with control of the sizes of fish caught, especially regulation of the size of meshes in trawl nets, and such regnlations are in force, or in the process of being brought into force, in most of the areas with which they are concerned (see Annual Reports of I.C.N.A.F. and N.E.A.F.C.). I n fact in many areas the limit t o which mesh regulations can be usefully applied, a t least under the framework of the present commissions, is being approached. I n part this is because the present mesh size is the optimum a t the present rate of fishing (this may be so, for example, for the sole in the North Sea), but more often because a further increase in mesh size would be unacceptable for other reasons. Earlier it was shown that the presence of relatively small-sized species of fish (e.g. soles in the North Sea), of which the catch would be reduced if larger meshes were used, prevents the use of mesh sizes which would be much better for the larger species (e.g. cod and plaice). This is one example of the inequitable results of mesh (or in fact any other) regulation likely to occur in a heterogeneous fishery. Another example in a single species fishery is that for cod off the west coast of Greenland, which is fished by both otter trawlers and vessels using hooks and lines; the immediate losses of small fish when the larger mesh is used are confined to the trawlers, but the long-term benefits from increased stocks accrue to both groups of fishermen (I.C.N.A.F., 1966). The net long-term benefits to the liners will therefore always be greater than those of the trawlers. Moderate increases in mesh size (up t o and somewhat above those so far proposed) would benefit both gears, but still larger meshes (up to 170 mm) would increase the total catch, but only at the cost of reducing the catch of trawlers. Since the Comlr\ission’sstatutes contain no provision whereby some of the benefits which the liners would gain can be transferredfrom them to the trawlers, such mesh sizes are clearly unacceptable to the trawler fishermen. They would still be unacceptable
MANAGEMENT OF FISHERY RESOURCES
47
in a single national fishery if the nationals concerned used, as do the Portuguese. both types of gear. There have also been various practical and administrative difficulties in putting mesh regulation into force-questions of how precisely to measure meshes, the use of extra pieces of netting t o reduce chafing which may also obstruct the meshes, and, particularly, the question of enforcement. These problems should not be underestimated, but good progress is being made towards solving them. So far as it is possible for them to go, regulations of the sizes caught have been reasonably successfully introduced and the major problem facing all commissions is the control on the total amount of fishing. Most of the commissioiis referred to in the previous section have a t least discussed the problem of restricting the amount of fishing, and several have some effective restriction, generally in terms of a limit to the total catch. The success of effort regulations may be gauged by whether they have achieved both the biological objective (to build up the stock, maintain it at the desired level and hence take the optimum catch), and the economic objective (to reduce costs in proportion to the reduction in fishing mortality, and hence achieve the potential surplus of value over costs). An outstanding example of management t h a t is successful on both counts is that of the fur seal (Callorhinzcs uysinus L.) in the North Pacific. The stocks have built up very greatly (Kenyon et al., 1956; Chapman, 1961), so much so that, since to some extent the fur seals eat fish of commercial valuc, it has been argued that they have increased to an undesirable degree when considering the best use of the marine resources of the North Pacific as a whole. Most of the harvest is taken as surplus juvenile males when they are segregated in compact groups on the breeding islands, so that the cost of operations are presumably low. The figures of resultant net economic yield are not available, but 150/, of the q o s s value of several million dollars of the catch from the Pribilofs is sent to Japan and Canada, in consideration for not carrying out seeling on the high seas, and it is doubtful whether the net profit to the U.S. Government (who carries out the operations) is any less. As mentioned in an earlier section, in biological terms the restriction on the catches of halibut off the uest coast of North America has been successful in building up the stocks of halibut after they had been severely depleted ; between 1031 (when regulations first came into force) and 1960 the stocks in different areas increased two t o three times, and the catches rose by up to 50% (Thompson, 1950; I.N.P.F.C., 1 9 6 2 ~ ;Chapman et al., 1962). However, because of the scramble
48
J. A . GULLAND AND J. E. CARROZ
by fishermen tro secure the greatest share of the quota, there have not been commensurate economic benefits (Crutchfield and Zellner, 1963). While, as is well known, regulation of Antarctic whaling has not been successful (see Annual Reports of the I.W.C., especially the reports by Committee of Three Scientists and the 14th and 16th Annual Reports; Chapman et al., 1964, 1965), this is more because of the biological characteristics of the stock, which make the penalties for any failure to achieve proper management very severe, than because the InternationalWhaling Commission has been so much less diligent than many of the fisheries commissions. I n fact, catches of Antarctic whales have been restricted since 1947, and this restriction has served to slow the decline in the stocks (Gulland, 1966a). I n addition, the more recent agreements on the division of the quota have served to increase the economic efficiency of the industry, and hence delay the time when the decline in the stocks would bring about the economic collapse of the industry (though it is arguable that the latter, by delaying effective management, may not in the long run be a good thing). These examples, and others where limitations of the amount of fishing have been effected (e.g. in some salmon fisheries in the North Pacific), have certain features in common. First, and probably most important in determining whether restriction can be easily introduced, is that the biological situation is comparativdy simple. Only one species, or a group of closely related species (e.g. of whales, or of salmon) is concerned, and it was clear to all, without the need of detailed scientific research and analysis, that the stocks concerned were being or could be severely affected by fishing, though there was argument, especially for the whales, as t o the extent of the depletion. For salnion there has also been very great argument on the details of the effects of fishing, especially on the quantitative effects of the fishery for them on the high seas (I.N.P.F.C., 1962a,b;Taguschi, 1961;Parker, 1963; Gulland, 1964a). The situation in most cases was also simple in that only a few countries were concerned, and they all generally used the same catchingmethods. A second important point is that the fisheries (using the word t o cover sealing and whaling) were isolated in the sense that the surplus effort resulting from restriction would not, a t least clearly and immediately, be applied to some other, possibly equally heavily exploited stock. I n the North Atlantic the realization that any restriction of effort in a limited area, say in the Barents Sea cod fishery, would result in a corresponding increase in effort in Iceland and other areas, with
MANAGEMENT OF FISHERY RESOURCES
49
little or no long-term benefit, is one reason why progress on catch limitation has been slow. This suggests that while for biological reasons regulations should be considered separately for each unit stock, i.e. within quite small areas, the implications of such regulations must be considered over much wider areas, so that the area of interest of the regulatory body must be equally wide. For instance,the whole northern parts of the areas of responsibility of the two North Atlantic Commissions (north of the British Isles and Nova Scotia) must often be considered as a single unit. Also important, in the two cases (fur seals and whales) where allocation of the quota has been made, is that the entry of new countries was not likely (for the whaling agreement it was explicitly stated that the entry of a new country would make the agreement on the division of the total quota void). The high cost of a whaling factory ship, and the low state of the stock, discouraged any other country from entering the industry, while for the fur seals the four countries concernedJapan, U.S.S.R., Canada and U.S.A.-are the only ones with easy access to the stocks, though perhaps the problem of processing and disposing of the catch also deters possible new entrants. For the whales, the failure t o achieve the biological objectives in maintaining the stock by setting a sufficiently low quota more than balanced any economic success in taking the quota in an efficient manner, and there has been no surplus; for the fur seals there is a surplus, and it is being successfully achieved. While the fur seals are not owned by anyone, the Government of the breeding islands does have definite powers of management. The whole of the yield is, in the first instance, taken by the managing Government, only later being shared among the other Governments. I n this way some of the disadvantages of the common property nature of marine resources-that they are no one’s direct interest and responsibility to maintain-have been avoided. Another, and in some ways rather surprising, feature is the lack in some of the cases where limitation of the amount of fishing has been achieved, of any economic uniformity among the countries concerned -both the U.S.A. and U.S.S.R. belong to the Fur Seal Commission, while the Antarctic whaling industries included both the rapidly developing industries of Japan and the U.S.S.R. and the declining industries of Great Britain and the Netherlands. The economic attractions of taking the same or greater catch at substantially reduced costs are likely to be so great that any differences in the valuation of the catch, or the breakdown of costs, will make little difference to the desirability of taking action.
50
J. A. GULLAND AND J. E. CARROZ
B. The need f o r further research From the experience of the commissions which have already taken action to restrict the amount of fishing, and of the other commissions which are actively considering such action, some of the requirements for achieving full management can be deduced. First, the essential basis of any management is the proper biological understanding of the state of the stocks concerned. Unless the administrators know what the probable effects of regulation on the stock and future catches may be, they have no means of assessing the desirability of taking action. The fishery scientist should be able to provide estimates of the effects of any regulatory measure proposed, not only on the stock directly concerned, but on related stocks. For instance, a complete study of thc fishing on the Peruvian anclioveta (Fig. 12), and the need for regulation of the fishery on it, should include an assessment of the effect of different amounts of fishing on the food available to the guano birds, and hence the likely effects on the guano industry. Theoretically the chain of related stocks, the first preying on the second, which competes
FIG.12. A catch of anchoveta off Peru, which supports the biggest fishery in the ~ o r l d . An estimated 583 660 000 individual fish were taken from a single year-class (Boerema et ul., 1965). (Photo: F.A.O.)
MANAGEMENT
O F FISHERY RESOCRCES
51
for food with a third, could be extended almost indefinitely, taking into account the widely ranging movements of many species, so that the scientist should set limits beyond which the possible interactions can, €or practical purposes, be ignored. Any assessment of the effect of proposed regulations, or of the absence of regulations, must be subject to some degree of uncertainty, so that complete scientific advice will include some indication of the degree of uncertainty involved. The nature of the uncertaintiesis such that statistical presentation of confidence limits, etc., are generally not relevant, and the statement has to bc to some degree subjective, including judgments on such things as whether a particular mathematical model is applicable to a given situation. The important question is whether the relative advantages of different regulations (or no regulation) will be changed. For example, calculations may show that in a certain trawl fishery an increase in mesh size will result in an immediate drop in catch in the first year of 5 2 % , followed by an increase %Tithinthree to four years to a level 4.7% above the original level (i.c. regarding the small fish released as an investment, they will nearly as a group double in weight). I n fact, they may rather more than double, making the gain perhaps S%, or the gain may be only 4%, but in any event the larger mesh will give a small gain, and advice in that form can be given t o the regulatory body. Another form of uncertainty is that many stocks fluctuate for reasons quite independent of fishery, e.g. due to variation in year-class strength (Hjort, 1914). I n such fisheries the predictions made are generallynot of the actual catch in the future,but are comparisonsof the catch that would be taken if the proposed regulations were introduced, with the catch taken if different regulations, or if none, were in force. Proper management, therefore, requires good scientific knowledge based on adequate data. They are essential for all stocks, not merely those in immediate need of regulation, since one aspect of proper management is to avoid unnecessary restrictions, and to be sure of this requires a certain minimum supply of data. More important, the proper understanding of a heavily exploited stock depends on the comparison of the characteristics of the stocks (abundance, as measured, say, by catch per unit effort, the proportions of different ages and sizes, etc.) under heavy and light fishing, and therefore requires adequate information from the period when fishing was still light. Though in any fishery a stage could be reached when the possible benefits from improved management based on better scientific information will be less than the additional costs of getting that information,
52
J. 9. GULLAND AND J. E. CARROZ
this stage is nowhere being approached even in the most intensively studied fisheries. I n many areas even the information on total catches is not available, while other basic data that should be collected routinely (the breakdown of total catch by species and by small areas corresponding to biological unit stocks, the effort involved in taking the catch, the size and age composition of the catch, etc.) are lacking or scarce in nearly all areas. There is, therefore, an urgent need for better collection of these data, as well as more original scientific research in interpreting the data as they become available. The other type of action needed to attain proper management lies in the administrative field. As a preliminary there is probably still need for greater awareness of the very large economic benefits that can arise from proper management and, conversely, of the danger of losing most of these potential benefits even when the regulations introduced are successful so far as the biological effects on the stocks are concerned. This does require some degree of economic analysis, but when a stock is in need of regulation the economic implications are likely to be so obvious, once considered a t all, that the analysis need only be very simple, and even major differences in the economic factors in the countries concerned are likely to be unimportant. What the analysis will show is the magnitude of the net economic yield (possible value of catch, less cost of catching)that could be taken from the stock. The next important decision is how this yield is t o be taken and distributed, and it is this decision for which, with the exception of the special case of the fur seal, there is little administrative machinery. A distinction should be made here between two aspects of the yield from a fishery : the gross physical yield, in terms of fish, and the net economic yield, the difference between the value of the catch and cost of catching it. I n an unmanaged fishery this latter yield tends towards zero or is a t least no more than will provide a reasonable returnon the capital, etc., invested, so that discussions on allocation of yield have generally centred round the allocation of catch, although the potential net economic yield from a properly managed fishery can be very high. However, the differing requirements of various countries may mean that the catch is divided in quite different proportions from the economic yield : a country with a low supply of protein might place its emphasis on having a large share of the total catch, while another country might be more interested in the net economic yield. Thus a coastal state might decide to make use of the fishery resources within its territorial waters by allowing a certain number of foreign vessels to fish in these waters for a suitable fee, rather than forbidding foreign fishing entirely; the coastal state might then take a smaller proportion
MANAGEMENT
O F FISHERY RESOURCES
53
of the catch, but a large proportion of the net yield. Some of the failures to achieve the potential benefits of management may be ascribed to the lack of consideration of the net economic yield, as opposed to the gross catch. M'ithout a more or less explicit decision concerning how the net yield should be taken and distributed, it is almost certain that the potential net yield will be dissipated in excess costs of one kind or another.
C. International marmgement The net yield can be taken explicitly if there is a single managing authorityeither carrying out operationsitself (e.g. the U.S. Government for the Pribilof fur seals) or charging a tax or licence fee. For most commissions, however, the assumption seems to be that the benefit will accrue directly to the fishermen, who will be able to reduce their costs in proportion to the reduction in the amount of fishing. But this desirable state of affairs is unlikely to continue if there is no restriction of entry into the fishery. If fishing becomes as attractive as it should, then new countries will want to join in, and those already participating will want to increase their share. Initially, agreement on the shares of the participating countries may be reached reasonably objectively on the basis of existing catches and plans for the immediate future, but later such a basis will become less and less firm. Again the fur seal is an exception, since the allocation of 15% of the gross take to the potentially pelagic countries, and the rest to the owners of the breeding islands, represents something like the shares of the catch under freefor-all conditions where the land-based operations will have advantages. The so-called abstention principle, whereby a country will abstain from entering any fishery which is being properly managed, is one attempt to restrict new entrants, but is attractive only to the countries with established fisheries. Unless the amount a country considers it stands to lose by being kept out of one fishery is balanced by what it gains in an established fishery in another area, or there is some other incentive for abstaining, it may not become an effective principle. Both the problem of new entrants, and of the shares of established participants may be lessened if the shares can be transferred, as was done in fact, though not in form, through the sale and transfer of factory ships under the Agreement on Antarctic Whaling. This would probably work for countries wishing t o increase their share, and who would prefer to pay for an increased share rather than lose their existing share of the benefits of proper management through breakdown of agreements. This constraint would be less effective for countries entering a fishery for the first time.
54
J. A. GULLAND AND J. E. CARROZ
The alternative methods of taking the net economic yield proposed earlier (tax or licences, or a single operating body) would both involve a managing body with very much greater powers than the present commissions. Only in special circumstances would it be feasible for the operations to be carried out directly by the managing authority, and it would be more practicakde for control to be by tax or licence. Since the purposes of such licences would be to reduce the difficulties of allocation of the share of the quota, and of discouragingnew entries, by making fishing only moderately attractive, i.e. t o ensure that the value of the catch is not much greater than the cost of catching plus the licence fee, as regulation becomes effective the licence fee should become substantial. The question of how this large income from licence fees is used will then become very important. Since an immediate redistribution of all the net yield from licence fees among participating countries would not reduce the attractions (and hence also the problems) for new entrants-except for the losses due to administrative costs-a considerable portion of the profits should be shared more widely. The first call on the income might then be to finance all the costs of management, including the closely related research. The profits could also be used for more widely ranging research, not only into the population dynamics of the stocks immediately concerned, and of other stocks in the area, including the development of fisheries on hitherto unexploited stocks, but also more fundamental biological and oceanographic research into more efficient ways of catching and utilizing the potential natural production of fish (at present any improvement in catching techniques only adds to the difficulties of regulation, and in some regulated fisheries is positively discouraged, which is economic nonsense) and into positive methods of increasing the natural production-" farming the sea ". Another part of the profits might go to those actually engaged in fishing, assuming that the managing body did not carry out its own operations directly. If the management of a particular stock was part of a more widespread agreement on fishing (possibly world-wide) then another part of the profits could be shared among all the parties to the agreement. This would give even those not a t present fishing in an area some direct interest in the proper management of that area, and hence make the abstention principle more generally appealing. Finally, the managing body itself might be able to use a share outside the immediate field of fisheries. Thus perhaps on the continental shelf it might be the coastal state andthe money would go to the national treasury, or, especially in the open oceans, the body might be an agency of the United Nations, with the money going to the central
MANAGEMENT
55
O F FISHERY RESOURCES
U.N. budget as suggested by Christy and Scott (1965); for instance, the Ninth General Assembly of the International Union for the Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources approved a resolut.ion urging the early development of a specialized agency under the United Nations for the management and conservation of whales. The possibility that the coastal state should, with international agreement, have some degree of managerial authority over part of a high seas fishery is a quite different concept from a simple extension of exclusive fishery limits. A wide extension of such limits would a t first sight ease the problems of management by removing them from the international to the national sphere. However, it does not seem a practicable solution for many reasons-politically it would be unacceptable t o many countries, and biologically many stocks range over wide areas and cannot be effectively managed by unilateral action in one area. Also, if the fishery limits were applied in the most usual manner of excluding all foreign fishing vessels, possibly with temporary exceptions for nations with traditional rights, many coastal states might not have the economic or technical capacity t o harvest the full potential of the stocks. The potential of such stocks would therefore be wasted by under-exploitation just as much as the potential of some stocks is a t present wasted by over-exploitation. Fuller use in such situations might be achieved by something less than complete banning of foreign fishing, e.g. by charging a licence fee for fishing within the limits. The concept of having t o pay t o fish on the high seas, even to an international body, is not one that will be accepted lightly. The preceding discussion suggests very strongly that without this or some other fundamentally new approach t o management, the full potential net economic yield of the fish stocks of the world will not be attained. The present type of commission is probably capable, given good scientific advice, and a reasonable attitude among its members, of maintaining the stocks with which they are concerned and the catches from these stocks, but not capable of ensuring that the catches are taken a t as low a cost as possible. The wastage involved, and the benefits from proper management, are very large; even a t present the resources wasted in excessive costs of capture in just two groups of stocks-the salmon in the North Pacific and the cod of the north-east Atlanticcould, if rationally utilized, increase the total world catch of fish by perhaps 5%. The present catches of cod in the area could probably be taken with around half the present costs, while, whatever the merits in terms of total catch of taking salmon on the high seas or in coastal waters, none of the methods a t present used seem an efficient way of harvesting an animal which could be persuaded to swim almost inside A.DI.B.-6
3
66
J. A. GULLAND AND J. E. CARROZ
a suitably placed processing plant. This discrepancy between what the resources deployed in fishing do produce, and what they could produce will tend to widen as more and more of the world’s accessible stocks of fish become heavily fished. Without some fundamentally new approach it is doubtful if the fisheries of the world can maintain their recent record of increasing production faster than the increase in world population. VI. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors wish to acknowledge the helpful comments and criticisms of their colleagues in F.A.O., and of the members of F.A.O.’s Advisory Committee on Marine Resources Research, especially of their chairman,Dr C. E. Lucas, a t whose suggestion the original version was revised for a scientific audience.
VII.
REFERENCES
Ahlstrom, A. H. (1954). Distribution and abundance of eggs and larval populations of the Pacific sardine. Fishery Bull. Fish Wildl. Serv. U.S. 93, 83-140. Ahlstrom, A. H. (1965). A rcview of the effects of the environment of the Pacific sardine. Spec. Publs int. CommnN W . Atlant. Fish. 6, 53-74. Aoyama, T. (1961). Tho selective action of trawl nets and its application to the management of Japanese trawl fisheries in the East China and Yellow Sea. Bull. Seikai Reg. Fish. Res. Lab. 23, 63 pp. Baranenkova, A. S. (1965). Notes on the condition of formation of the ArctoNorwegian tribe of cod of the 1959-1961 year-classes during the f i s t year of life. Spec. Publs int. Commn N W . Atlant. Fish. 6, 397-410. Bell, F. H. (1959). Economic aspects of regulations of the Pacific halibut fishery. I n “Biological and Economic Aspects of Fisheries Management ”,pp. 51-55. University of Washington Press, Seattle. Beverton, R. J. H. (1962). Long-term dynamics of certain North Sea fish populations. I n ‘‘The Exploitation of Natural Animal Populations ” (E.D. LeCren and M. W. Holdgate, cds.), pp. 242-259. Blackwells, Oxford. Bcverton, R . J. H. and Hodder, V. M. (1962). Report of the working group of scientists on fishery assessment in relation t o regulation problems. A. Proc. int. Commn N W . Atlant. Fish. Suppl. 11, 81 pp. Beverton, R . J. H. and Holt, S. J. (1957). On the dynamics of exploited fish populations. Fishery Invest., Lond. (2), 10, 533 pp. Boerema, L. K., Saetersdal, G., Tsukayama, I., Valdivia, J. E. and Alegre, B. (1965). Report on the effects of fishing on the Peruvian stock of anchovy. F.A.O. Fish. tech. Pap. 55,44 pp. Bowen, B. K. and Chittleborough, R. G. (1966). Preliminary assessments of stocks of the Western Australian crayfish, Panulirus cygnus George. Aust. J . mar. Freshwat. Res. 1 7 ( 1 ) , 93-121. Burukovskii, R. N. and Iarogov, B. A. (1965). [Studies on the Antarctic krill in the scope to organize a fishery on krill.] I n “Antarkticheskii krill, biologiia i prornysel ”,pp. 5-17. AtlantiNIRO, Kaliningrad. [In Russian.] Cassie, R. M. (1955). The escapement of small fish from trawl nets. New Zealand Mar. Dept. Fish. Bull. 11.
MANAGEMENT OF FISHERY RESOURCES
57
Chapman,D. G. (1961). Population dynamics of the Alaska fur seal herd. Trans. N . A m . Wildl. Conf. 26, 356-369. Chapman, D. G., Myrhe, R . J. and Southward, G. N. (1962). Utilization of Pacific halibut stocks: estimation of maximum sustainable yield. Rep. int. Pacif. Halibut Commn, 1960, 31. Chapman, D. G., Allen, K. R. and Holt, S. J. (1964). Report of the committee of three scientists on the special scientific investigations of the Antarctic whalc stocks. Rep. int. Whal. Commn 14, 32-106. Chapman, D. G., Allen, K. R., Gulland, J. A. and Holt, S. J. (1965). Report of the committee of four scientists on the special scientific investigations of the Antarctic whale stocks. Rep. int. Whal.Commn 15,47-63. Christy, F. T., Jr., and Scott, A. (1965). “The Common Wealth in 0cea.nFisheries. Some Problems of Growth and Economic Allocation ”, p. 219. Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore. Crutchfield, T. A. and Zellner, A. (1963). Economic aspccts of the Pacific halibut fishery. Fishery industr. Res. 1( I ) , 173 pp. Dickie, L. K. and McCracken, F. D. (1955). Isopleth diagram to predict equilibrium yields of a small flounder fishery. J. Fish. Res. B d Can. 12(2), 187-209. F.A.O. (1966a). Catches and landings 1965. Y b . Fish. Statist. 20 pp. var. F.A.O. (196613). Department of Fisheries and Department of Public Relations and Legal Affairs, International Fishery Bodies. Papers presented at the first session of the Committee on Fisheries, Rome, 13-18 June 1966. P.A.O. Fish. tech. Pap. 64, 41 pp. Garrod, D. J. (1966). Stock a,nd recruitment data for Arcto-Norwegian cod. I.C.E.S., CM 1966/g:8 (mimeo). Gaskin, D. E. (1964). Return of the southern right whale (Eubalaenaaustralis Derm.) to New Zealand waters, 1963. Tuatara 12(2), 115-118. Gordon, H. S. (1954). The economic theory of a common property resource: the fishery. J . polit. Econ. 62, 124-142. Graham, M. (1943). “The Fish Gate.” Faber & Faber, London. Graham, M. (1956). “Sea Fisheries.” Edward Arnold, London. Gulland, J. A. (1961). Fishing and the stocks of fish a t Iceland. Fishery Invest. Lond. (2), 32(4), 52 pp. Gulland, J. A. (1964a). Review of Parker (1963) 4.”. J . Cons. perm. int. Explor. Mer 29(1), 117-119. Gulland, J. A. (196413). Variations in selection factors, and mesh differentials. J. Cons. perm. int. Explor. Mer 29(2), 155-165. Gulland, J. A. (1965). Manual of methods for fish stock assessment. Part 1. Fish population analysis. F.A.O. Fish. tech. Pap. 40, Rev. 1, 68 pp. Gulland, J. A. (1966a). The effect of regulation on Antarctic whale catches. J. Cons. perm. int. Explor. Mer 30(3), 308-315. Gulland, J.A. (1966b). North Sea plaice stocks. Lub. Leaf. Fish. Lab. Lowestoft 11, 18 pp. Gulland, J.A. (1967). The effects of fishing on the production and catches of fish. I n “The Biological Basis of FreshwaterFish Production” (S. D. Gerking, ed.). Blackwell Sci. Pub., Oxford. Gulland, J. A. (1968a). Recent changes in thc North Sea plaice fishery. J . Cons. perm. int. Explor. Mer (in press). Gulland, J. A. (1968b). The concept of the maximum sustainable yield and fisherymanagement. F.A.O. Fish. tech. Pap. 70,13pp.
58
J . A. CULLAND AND J . E. CARROZ
Hickling, C. F. (1946). The recovery of a deep-sea fishery. Fishery Invest., Lond. 1 7 ~ ) . Hjort, J. (1914). Fluctuationsin the great fisheries of northern Europe viewed in the light of biological research. R app. P.-v. Re'un.Cons. perm. int. Explor. Mer 20, 228 pp. I.A.T.T.C. (1966). Rep. inter-Am.trop. T u n a Commn, 1965. I.C.E.S. (1957). InternationalFisheries Convention 1946. Report of the Ad Hoc Committee established a t the fonrth meeting of the Permanent Commission, September 1956. J . Cons. perm. int. Explor. Mer 23(1), 7-37. I.C.E.S. (1960). InternationalFisheries Convention 1946. Committee on mesh difficulties. Report of the scientific sub-committee presented a t the seventh meeting of the Permanent Commission, November 1958. Rapp. P.-v. Re'un. Cons. perm. int. Explor. Mer 151, 39 pp. I.C.E.S. (1964). Report of the mesh selection working group. Cooper Res. Rep. int. Coun. Explor. Sea 2, 156 pp. I.C.E.S. (1965). Report of the 1962 Iceland trawl mesh selection working group. Cooper Res. Rep. int. Coun. Explor. Sea 3, 42 pp. I.C.E.S. (1966). Report of the Arctic fisheries working group. Annex 1 to the 1965 Liaison Committee report. Cooper Res. Rep. int. Coun. Explor. Sea (R), 15-32. I.C.N.A.F. (1963). The selectivity of fishing gear. Proceedings of Joint I.C.N.A.F./F.A.O. Special Scientific Meeting. Lisbon, 1957, Vol. 2. Spec. Publs int. Commn N W . Atlant. Fish. 5, 225 pp. I.C.N.A.F. (1966). Standing Committee on Research and Statistics. Proceedings for the annual meeting. Appendix 1. Report of the sub-committee on assessments. Redbk int. Commn N W . Atlant. Fish. 1966, 1, 27-53. I.N.P.F.C. (1962a). The exploitation, scientific investigation and management of salmon (genus Oncorhyncus) stocks on the Pacific coast of Canada in relation to the abstention provisions of the North Pacific convention. Bull. i n t . N . I'acif. Fish. Commn 9, 112 pp. I.N.P.F.C. (196213).The exploitation, scientific investigation and management of salmon (genusOncorhyncus)stocks on the Pacific coast of the United States in relation to the abstention provisions of the North Pacific convention. Bull. int. N . Pacif. Fish Commn 10, 160 pp. I.N.P.F.C. ( 1 9 6 2 ~ ) .The exploitation, scientific investigation and management of halibut (Hippoglossus stenolepis Schmidt) on the Pacific coast of North America in relation to the abstention provisions of the North Pacific fisheries convention. Bull. int. N. Pacij. Fish. Commn 7. Kenyon, A. R., Scheffer, V. B. and Chapman, D. G. (1956). A population study of the Alaska fur seal herd. Spec. scient. Rep. U.S. Fish Wildl. Serv. Fisheries, 48, 77 pp. Longhurst, A. R. (1959). Prediction of selection factors in a tropical trawl fishery. Nature, Lond. 184, 1170. Longhurst, A. R . (1960). Mesh selection factors in the trawl fishery off tropical West Africa. J . Cons. perm. int. Explor. Mer 25(3), 318-325. MacGregor, J.S. (1964). The relation between spawning-stock size and year-class size for the Pacific sardine. Fishery Bull. Fish Wildl. Serv. U.S. 6 3 ( 2 ) , 477-491. M.A.F.F., U.K. (1962). Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries, and Department of Agriculture and Fisheries for Scotland. F ish Stk Rec. 1961, 57 pp.
(a,
MANAGEMENT OF FISHERY RESOURCES
60
M.A.F.F., U.K. (1966). Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, and Department of Agriculture and Il’isheriesfor Scotland. Fieh Stk Rec. 1965, 39 pp. Mako, H. (1961). Studies on the demersal fish resources in the East China and the Yellow Seas, based on fishery statistics by the market categories in fish size. Bull. Seikai Reg. Fish, Res. Lab. 24, 113 pp. Margetts, A. R . and Holt, S. J. (1948). The effect of the 1939-45 war on the English North Sea trawl fisheries. Rapp. P.-v. R&n. Cons. perm. int. Explor. Mer 122, 27-46. Misu, H. (1964). Fisheries biology on the ribbon fish (Trichiuruslepturus L.) in the East China and the Yellow Seas. Bull. Seikai Reg. Fish. Res. Lab. 32, 1-58. Murphy, G. I. (1966). Population biology of the Pacific sardine (Sardinops caerulea). Proc. CaZq. Acad. Sci. (4), 34(1), 1-84. Osochenko, E. I. (1965). [Economic evaluation of utilization of krill for fishmeal production.] In. “Antarkticheskii kril’, biologiia i promysel ”, pp. 78-83. AtlantNIRO, Kaliningrad. [In Russian.] Parker, R . R . (1963). On the problem of maximum yield from North Pacific sockeye salmon stocks. J . Fish. Res. B d Can. 20, 1371-1396. Parrish, B. B. arid Jones, R. (1953). Haddock bionomics 1. The state of the haddock stocks in the North Sea 1946-50, and at Faroes 1914-50. Mar. Res. 1952 4, 1-27. Radovich, J . (1962). Effects of sardine spawning, stock size and environment on year-class production. Calif. Fish Game 48 (2), 123-140. Rice, D. W. (1961). Census of the Californian gray whale 1959j60. Norsk Hvalfangsttid. 6, 219-225. Ricker, W. E. (1954). Stock and recruitment. J . Fish. Res. Bd Can. 2 ( 5 ) , 559-623. Ricker, W. E. (1958). Handbook of computations for biological statistics of fish populations. Bull. Fish. Res. Bd Can. 119, 300 pp. Russell, E. S. (1942). ‘‘The Overfishing Problem.” Cambridge University Press, London. Sahrhage, D. (1959). Untersuchungen iiber die Vernichturig untermassiger Schellfische durch die deutsche Herringschleppnetzfischerei in der Nordsee. Ber. dt. wiss. Kommn Meeresforsch. 15 (2), 105-131. Schaefer, M. B. (1954). Some aspects of the dynamics of populations important to the management of the commercial marine fisheries. Bull. inter-Am.trop. Tuna Commn 1, 26 pp. Schaefer,M. B. (1957a). A study of the dynamics of populations important to the management of the commercial marine fisheries. Bull. inter-Am.trop. Tuna Commn 2, 245-285. Schaefer, M. B. (1957b). Some considerations of population dynamics and economics in relation t o the management of the commercial marine fisheries. J . Fish. Res. B d Can. 14(5), 669-681. Schaefer,M. B. and Beverton, R. J.H. (1963). Fishery dynamics-their analyses and interpretation. In “The Sea” (M. N. Hill, ed.), Vol. 2, pp. 464-483. Wiley, New York. Shelbourne,J.E. (1964). The artificial propagationof marine fish. I n “Advances in Marine Biology ” (F.S. Russell, ed.), Vol. 2, pp. 1-84. Academic Press, London. Shindo, S. (1960). Studies on the stock of yellow seabream i n the East China Sea. Bull. Seikai Reg. Fish. Res. Lab. 20, 198 pp.
60
J. A. GULLAND AND J. E. CARROZ
Stasenko, V. 0. (1965). [Characteristics of rational methods of capture of krill and industrial efficiency of selected fishing methods.] I n “Antarlrticheskii kril’, biologiia i promysel ”, pp. 67-77. AtlantNIRO, Kaliningrad. [In Riissian.] Taguschi, K. (1961). A trial to estimate the instantaneous rate of natural mortality of adult salmon (Oncorhyncus sp.) and the consideration of rationality of offshore fishery. 2 . For red salmon (Oncorhyncusnerka) 1961. Bull. J a p . SOC.scient. Fish. 27, 972-978. Thompson, W. F. (1950). “The Effect of Fishing on Stocks of Halibut in the Pacific.” University of Washington Press, Seattle. United Nations (1951). Proceedings of the United Nations scientific conference on the conservation and utilization of resources. 17 August-6 September, 1949. Lake Success, New York. Vol. 7, Wildlife and Fish Resources. United Nations (1956). Paperspresented at the internationaltechnical conference on the conservation of the living resources of the sea. UN Doc. No. A/Conf. 1017. United Nations (1958). United Nations Conference on the Law of the Sea. Official record, 7 vols. UN Doc. No. A/Conf. 13. United Nations (1960). Second United Nations Confercnce on the Law of the Sea. Official record. UN Doc. No. A/Conf. 19. Wimpenny, R . S. (1953). ‘‘The Plaice.” Edward Arnold. London.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
APPENDIX: INTERNATIONAL BODIES Name of body
Headquarters
Date established and auspices 1902 Conference (now 1964 Convention)
Area of competence
International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (I.C.E.S.)
Copenhagen, Denmark
Atlantic Ocean and adjacent seas (but with particular reference t o the North Atlantic)
International Commission for the Scientific Exploration of the Mediterranean (I.C.S.E.M.)
Monaco
1919 Conference
Mediterranean Sea and adjacent waters
International Pacific Halibut Commission (I.P.H.C.)
Seattle, Washington, U.S.A.
1923 Convention (now 1953 Convention)
Territorial sea of members and high seas off western coasts of Canada and U.S.A., including southern and western coasts of Alaska
International Pacific Salmon Fisheries Commission (I.P.S.F.C.)
New Westminster, British Columbia, Canada
1930 Convention and Protocols of 1937 and 1956
Fraser River and its tributaries ; territorial sea and high seas o f fthe estuary
International Whaling Commission (I.W.C.)
London, 1J.K.
1946 Convention and Protocol of 1956
______~_________-__-_~
_ _ _ _ _ ~ All waters in which whaling is prosecuted by factory ships, land stations and whale catchers under the jurisdiction of members
(Note. This table is based on information available a t l!vi/67) 67
CONCERNEDWITH FISHERY MANAGEMENT Membership
Resources covered
Functions
~
Eligibility
Actual
All
To promote research; to draw up programmes required for this purpose; to publish the results of research carried out under its auspices or to encourage their publication
Any state which signed the 1964 Convention; after its entry into force, any state which makes an application for accession, upon approval of threequarters of the member countries
Belgium, Denmark, Finland, France, Federal Republic of Germany, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, U.S.S.R. and U.K. Canadaand U.S.A. have indicated that they will apply for membership
Not specified
To promote oceanographic and biological studies
Coastal states in the area of competence
Algeria, France, Greece, Israel, Italy, Monaco, Morocco, Roumania, Spain, Tunisia, Turkey, U.A.R., Yugoslavia
Halibut
To carry out research and to publish results; to adopt conservation measures such as catch regulation, size control, open and close season, vessel and gear control, licensing. A system of internationalcontrol of approved regulations is provided for on the high seas as between members
Signatory states
Canada, U.S.A.
Sockeye and pink salmon
To carry out research;to adopt conservation measures such as catch regulation and gear control ; to apportion catch equally between members. &4system of internationalcontrol of approved regulations is provided for on the high seas as between members
Signatory states
Canada, U.S.A.
To encourage or, if necessary, to organize research ; to adopt conservation measures, such as open and close seasons and areas, size control, catch regulation and gear control. Members may submit objections to conservation measures
Signatory states and any state giving notice of adherence
Argentina, Australia, Canada, Denmark, France, Iceland, Japan,Mexico, Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Panama, South Africa, U.K., U.S.A., U.S.S.R.
~
~
Whale stocks
63
S*
APPENDIX: ~
~~~
~
Date established und auspices
Name of body
Hectdqunrters
Indo-Pacific Fisheries Council (I.P.F.C.)
F.A.O. Reg. Office, Bangkok, Thailand
1948 Agreement concluded under aegis of F.A.O. (Article XIV of F.A.O. Constitution)
Inland waters and territorial sea of members and the Indo-Pacificarea (undefined)
International Commission for the Northwest Atlantic Fisheries (I.C.N.A.F.)
Dartmouth, Nova Scotia, Canada
1949 Convention and Protocols of 1956, 1963 and 1965
North-west Atlantic as defined : eastern limit approx. 42"W. latitude ;southern limit approx. 39" N. longitude. The territorial sea of members is excluded
Inter-American Tropical Tuna Commission (I.A.T.T.C.)
La Jolla, California,, U.S.A.
1949 Convention
Eastern Pacific Ocean (not defined)
-
-
General Fisheries Council for the Mediterranean (G.F.C.M.)
Area of competence
-
F.A.O. Headquarters, Rome, Italy
1949 Agreement concluded under aegis of F.A.O. (Article XIV of F.A.O. Constitution)
04
Inland waters and territorial sea of members and Mediterranean Sea and contiguous waters
(continued) Resources covered
Membership
-
Functions
Eligibility
Actual
All
To encourage and co-ordinate research ; to recommend or undertake co-operative research and development projects; to advise F.A.O. and members on fishery matters ;to publish and disseminate information
F.A.O. member nations and, if approved by twothirds majority of the Council, other members of U.N.
Australia, Burma, Cambodia, Ceylon, France, India, Indonesia, Japan, Republic of Korea, Federation of Malaysia, Netherlands, New Zealand, Pakistan, Philippines, Thailand, U.K., U.S.A., Vietnam
All, but with particular referenceto cod group, flatfish and rosefish
To obtain and collate scientific and statistical information; if necessary, to carry out research;to adopt conservation measures such as open and close seasons and areas, size control, gear control and catch regulation. Protocols to the 1949 Convention were signed in 1965 to facilitate the entry into force of conservation measures and to enable the Commission to make proposals for national and internationalmeasures of control on the high seas as among members
Signatory states and any state giving notice of adherence
Canada, Denmark, France, Fed. Republic of Germany, Iceland, Italy, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Roumania, Spain, U.K., U.S.A., U.S.S.R.
Yellowfin and skipjack tuna, fish used as bait for tuna and other fish taken by tuna vessels
To carry out research;to appraise scientific information; to collect statistics on catches and fishing activities ; and to recommend conservation measures to members
Signatory states and other states by unanimous agreement of contractingparties
Costa Rica, Ecuador, Mexico, Panama, U.S.A.
All
To encourage and co-ordinate research ;to recommend or undertake co-operative research and development projects; to advise F.A.O. and members on fishery matters ;to publish and disseminate information
F.A.O. member nations and, if approved by twothirds majority of the Council, other members of U.N.
Cyprus, France, Greece, Israel, Italy, Lebanon, Libya, Malta, Monaco, Morocco, Spain, Tunisia, Turkey, U.A.R., U.K., Yugoslavia
65
APPENDIX: Name of body
Headquarters
Date established and auspices
Area
of
competence
International North Pacific Fisheries Commission (I.N.P.F.C.)
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
1952 Convention
Permanent Commission for the South Pacific
Lima, Peru
1952 Agreement
Japanese-Soviet Fisheries Commission for the North-West Pacific
Meets in member countries in rotation
1956 Treaty
All waters of the North-West Pacific Ocean, including the Sea of Japan,the Sea of Okhotsk and the Bering Sea. The territorial sea of members is excluded
Commission for Fisheries Research in the Western Pacific
Peking, Chinese People’s Republic
1956 Convention
Western Pacific Ocean, including the Sea of Japan, the Yellow Sea and the East and South China Seas. The territorial sea of members is included
North Pacific Fur Seal Commission (N.P.F.S.C.)
Washington,
1957 Interim Convention and Protocol of 1963
North Pacific Ocean
U.S.A.
All waters of the North Pacific Ocean including the adjacent seas. The territorial sea of members is excluded
_______ South Pacific (not defined)
(Note. Internationalagreements on the conservation of N. Pacific fur seals date from 1911.)
66
(continued) Resources covered
Membership Functions Eligibility
All, but with particular reference to halibut, herring and salmon
To study fish stocks and determine stocks requiring conservation measures ; to administer the abstention system ;to compile and study records submitted by members ;and to recommend conservation measures. A system of international control of measures accepted by members is provided for on the high seas
All
To encourage research ; to advise members on fishery matters; to adopt conservation measures such as open and close seasons and areas, protected species, gear control. Members may submit objections to conservation measures
All, but with particular referenceto salmon, trout, herring and crab
To prescribe fishing methods ; to regulate Lhe catch of certain species ; to determine statistics required; and generally to make recommendations concerning the preservation and increase of fishery resources in the area. A system of international control of conservation measures is provided for on the high seas as between members ___~ To prepare plans for joint research ;to organize exchange of information;to elaborate and to recommend Conservation measures
Signatory states
Actual Canada, Japan,U.S.A.
__-_____ Signatory states Chilc, Ecuador, Peru
-
All
Fur seals
To formulate and co-ordinate research programmes; to determine nnniber of seals to be marked ;to consider possibility of pelagic sealing and t o make recommendations thereon. A system of international control is provided for on the high seas as among members
Signatory states
Japan,U.S.S.R.
_____ Signatory states and, Chinese People’s Republic, Mongolia, with the agreement of North Korea, North all ContractingParties, Vietnam, U.S.S.R. any state in the Western Pacific basin Signatory states
Canada, Japan,
U.S.A., U.S.S.R.
67
APPENDIX: Name of body Joint Commission for the Conservation of Seals in the North-East Atlantic
Headquarters Meets in member countries in rotation
Date established and auspices
Area of competence
1957 Agreement
North-east Atlantic Ocean east of Cape Farewell, namely the Greenland and Norwegian Seas, the Denmark Strait, the area of Jan Mayen Island and the Barents Sea L
North-East Atlantic Fisheries Commission (N.E.A.F.C.)
London, U.K.
1959 Convention
Joint Commission for Black Sea Fisheries
Meets in member countries in rotation
1959 Convention
Regional Fisheries Commission for Western Africa (R.F.C.W.A.)
Not yet fixed
1961 F.A.O. regional body (Article VI of F.A.O. Constitution)
Inland waters and territorial sea of members and waters of south-east Atlantic (not defined)
Regional Fisheries Advisory Commission for the South-West Atlantic (C.A.R.P.A.S.)
F.A.O. Reg. Office, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
1961 F.A.O. regional body (Article V I of F.A.O. Constitution)
Inland waters and territorial sea of members and waters of south-west Atlantic (not defined)
Joint Commission for Fisheries Cooperation
Meets in member countries in rotation
1962 Agreement
Not defined (the purpose of the Agreement is t o promote co-operation in marine fishing generally)
All waters of north-east Atlantic and Arctic Oceans and their dependent seas, as defined : western limit approx. 42" W. longitude, southernlimit 36" N. latitude, eastern limit 51' E. longitude. The Baltic and MediterraneanSeas are excluded ~
~ black Sea
_
_
_
-___
_
~
I
88
1
,
(continued) Resources covered
Membership Furactions Eligibility
Actual
Greenland seal, hooded seal and walrus
To propose research programmes to be carried out by members independently or jointly ;to recommend conservation measures and, if necessary, to make proposals concerning implementation of approved regulations
Signatory states and with the consent of Contracting Parties, any state interested in the regulation of hunting operations
Norway, U.S.S.R.
All
To keep all fisheries under review ;to recommend conservation measures such as open and close seasons and areas, size control, gear control and improvement of resources generally. Members may submit objections to conservation measures
Signatory states and any state giving notice of accession
Belgium, Denmark, France, Fed. Republic of Germany, Iceland, Ireland, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, U.K., U.S.S.R.
All
To co-ordinate the planning of research ;to develop co-ordinated measures for regulating fisheries and developing commercial fishing ; to recommend conservation measures and t o prescribe size limits of fish
Signatory states and other Black Sea states giving notice of accession
Bulgaria, Roumania, U.S.S.R.
All
To advise F.A.O. and members on fishery matters ; t o encourage co-operation in fishery exploitation, to promote research, liaison and discussion
F.A.O. member nations with territories in the region or responsible for international relations of non-self-governing territories in the region
Cameroon, Congo (Brazz.), Congo (Kinshasa),Gabon, Ghana, Guinea, Ivory Coast, Liberia, Mauritania,Morocco, Nigeria, Portugal, Senegal, Spain, U.K.
All
To advise F.A.O. and members on fishery matters ; t o encourage co-operation in fishery exploitation, to promote research, liaison and discussions
F.A.O. member nationsof the American continent whose territories have coasts bordering on the western Atlantic Ocean south of the Equator
Argentina, Brazil, Uruguay
All
To prepare plans for scientific and technical co-operation and mutual assistance in the development of fishing in the open sea ;to organize the exchange of experience and information;to make recommendations on fishery matters
Signatory states (however accessions have been accepted)
Bulgaria, Dem. Republic of Germany, Poland, Roumania, U.S.S.R.
-
69
APPENDIX Name of body
Headquarters
Date established and auspices
Area of competence
Japan-Republic of Korea Joint Fisheries Commission
Meets in member countries in rotation
1965 Agreement
Sea areas of mutual interest, including joint control zones as defined and joint resources survey zones
International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas (I.C.C.A.T.)
To be determined
1966 Convention
All waters of the Atlantic Ocean, including the adjacent seas
70
(continued) Resources covered
Membership
___~
Functions
Eligibility
Actual
All
To recommend research;to recommend measures concerning fishing operations, conservation measures and approprkte penalties ; to review situation as regards joint control zones and joint resources survey zones
Signatory statcs
Japan,Republic of Korea
Tuna and tuna-like fishes and other species exploited in tuna fishing
To collect and analyse statistics ; to promote and co-ordinateresearch ; to rccornmend conservation measures
States members of U.N. or of any specialized agenry
Signatories of Convention as a t 30th March 1967 : Brazil, Japan, Republic of Korea, Spain, U.S.A.
71
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Adw. mar. Biol., Vol. 6, 1968, pp.73-270
A GENERAL ACCOUNT OF THE FAUNA AND FLORA OF MANGROVE SWAMPS AND FORESTS IN THE INDO-WEST-PACIFIC REGION WILLIAMMACNAE Department of Zoology, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg,South Africa I. Introduction ,. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 74 A. The Word "Mangrove " . . .. .. .. .. . . 75 B. Early Historical References . . . . .. .. .. . . 76 C. Indo-west-Pacific Shores .. .. .. .. .. ,. 77 D. Sea-shore Plant Associations .. .. .. .. ., 85 11. Zonation of Mangroves . . . . .. .. .. .. .. . . 89 A. The Landward Fringe .. .. .. .. .. 91 B. Zone of Ceriops Thickets .. .. .. .. .. .. 103 C. Zone of Bruguiera Forests . . .. .. .. .. . . 105 .. .. .. .. . . 108 D. Zones of Rhizophora Forests E. Seaward Avicennia Fringes . . . . .. .. .. .. 112 F. Sonneratia Zone .. .. .. .. .. .. . . 115 G. Variations .. .. .. .. .. .. .. . . 118 H. Mangrove Soils .. .. .. .. .. .. . . 121 I. Control of Zonation . . . . .. .. .. .. . . 124 111. Adaptations Shown by the Flora .. .. .. .. .. . . 136 A. Adaptations to Growing in Ill-consolidated Muds . . ,. 136 B. Specializations of Stems and Leaves .. .. .. . . 140 C. Relationship betwccn the Mangrove Root and Shoot Systems . . 144 .. .. .. .. .. .. .. . . 145 D. Viviparity E. Succession .. .. .. .. .. .. .. . . 148 .. .. .. 150 IV. Distribution of Terrestrial Animals within the Mangal A. Birds Associated with Mangals .. .. .. .. . . 153 B. Amphibians and Reptiles .. .. .. .. .. .. 156 C. Mammals .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 157 D. Insects.. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 157 V. Distribution of Marine Animals within the Mangal . . . . . . .. 165 .. 165 A. Vertical Zonation Affecting Tree Dwelling Animals B. "Horizontal "Zonation through the Mangal . . .. ,. 167 VI. Specializations Shown by the Fauna . . .. .. .. .. .. 181 A. Birds, Mammals, Reptiles and Amphibians .. .. . . 181 B. Insects.. .. .. .. .. ,. .. .. . . 182 C. Marine Animals .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 184 VII. Geographical Distribution .. .. .. . . .. .. . . 219 A. Extratropical Extensions of Mangroves and their Associated Fauna .. .. .. .. .. .. .. . . 219 .. .. .. .. .. 222 B. Biogeographical Comment . . 73
74
WILLIAM MACNAE
VIII. Uses Made by Man of the Mangal and Its Products A. Uses of the Timber . . .. .. .. B. Pond Culture of Fish and Prawns . . . . C. Reclamation . . .. .. .. .. D. Salt Production .. .. .. .. IX. Acknowledgements .. .. .. .. .. X. Bibliography and References . . .. .. ..
.. .. ..
..
..
.. ..
..
.. ..
.. ..
.. ..
.. .. ..
233 233 238 240 241
..
241
.. .. . . 241
Tissue of no seam and sk i n of no scale .she weuves this: Dream of a huntsmanpale That in his antlered Mangrove waits Knsnared ; And I cannot touch him. From Virginia R. Noreno,
Batik Maker ".A s i a Magazine, Hong Kong, 23 January1967.
"
It has been said of many ecological papers that since there is no theory of ecology it does not really matter whether they were written five years ago or five years hence. Much descriptive ecology certainly comes under this censure and so may the review which follows. Yet the association of trees and of animals which constitutes a mangrove swamp is an association of which little has been written. We know what trees grow there and what forms the shrub layer ; we do not know the whole story of how these plants cope with the variables in the environment. We know something of some of the animals which are associated with mangroves but we know practically nothing about most of them. We do not know why they are there, unless i t be that they seek shade. We do not know how most of them live. We do not know why some genera have undergone a very wide degree of local speciation often almost parochial, nor why others have maintained a singleness of species which is remarkably widespread. What we do know is summarized below and pointers are given to where more research would be useful.
I. INTRODUCTION Mangroves are trees or bushes growing between the level of high water of spring tides and a level close t o but above mean sea-level. They range all round the oceans of the tropics, only on sheltered shores, a n d they penetrate into the estuaries of rivers where salt water penetrates. Mangrove forests reach their maximum development and greatest luxuriancein parts of South East Asia, Malaya, Sumatra and parts of Borneo where rainfall is high and not seasonal, b u t they occur as scrub thickets even on desert shores. Within these forests live a host of animals, often many individuals of a small range of species and genera. Some of these are derived from
FAUNA AND FLORA O F MANGROVE SWAMPS
75
the land, but most are from the sea. Of the land animals, roosting flocks of fruit bats, fishing and insectivorous birds and many insects are conspicuous. Of the marine animals, crabs and molluscs live permanently in the forest, and prawns and fishes come in on the tide to feed on the apparently abundant nutriment provided by the mangrove soils. The mangrove swamp is clearly one route from sea to land. It is a route followed by the most primitive of the pulmonate snails (Morton. 1955), by land crabs (Harms, 1929, 1930) and perhaps is attempted by some fish. But there seems to be 110 way by which it can be used by land animals to invade the sea. It is also a route from the sea to fresh water as indicated by several neritid snails, and from fresh water towards the sea as indicated by its invasion by various aquatic insect larvae. I n South East Asia man uses mangrove areas for the establishment of ponds for the culture of fish and prawns, and for timber. In East Africa mangroves are exploited for timber alone. A. The word ''mangrove " The English word "mangrove "is commonly used in one or other of two senses. It may be applied to a community of trees or shrubs which grow in the sea, or it may be applied to any one of the individual species which constitute that association. I n the latter sense i t is usual to restrict it to the woody shrubs or trees. The word is of doubtful origin and there is no good record of when it first came into use. It is usually considered to be a compound of the Portuguese word mangue with the English grove. I n Portuguese the word mangue is used in the second of the two senses given above, i.e. it is a mangrove tree or bush; the community is termed mangal. The French manglier is akin and also applies to the individual kinds of tree; pale'tuvier and more recently mangrove are used for the community. All these may be akin to the Malay manygi-manggi, a word not used today in Malaya but persisting in eastern Indonesia where it is used in Ambon for Avicennia (Bakhuizen van der Brink, 1921). Dutch uses vloedbosschen for the community and mangrove for individual kinds of tree. German use seems to follow the English. To avoid confusion I shall use the word mangal when dealing with the forest community, and the word mangrove for individual kinds of tree. The languages of South East Asia distinguish individual trees and tend to apply the name of one or other of these to the community. The name usually chosen for the community is that applied to the genus
76
WILLIAM MACNAE
Rhizophora, which implies that this genus of trees is the most important to these people. B. Early historical references A detailed account of the references to mangroves in European literature is given by Bowman (1917), much of it repeated by Davis (1940). Bretzl (1903) made a study of the references in European classical literature and compared the plants mentioned with those occurring,in his own day, along the shores of the Red Sea and between the Indus delta and the Persian Gulf. Bakhuizen van der Brink (1921) mentions that an inscription found in the Wadi Hamanat on the old caravan route between Koptos and Kosseir mentions mangroves on the Red Sea. The inscription dates from the Egyptian king Assa (3580-3536 B.c.). Theophrastus in his “Historia Plantarum ” (305 B.c.) quotes widely from the reports given by Aristobulus of the voyage by Nearchus in 325 from the Indus delta to the Persian Gulf while Alexander the Great made the journey overland. Nearchus describes trees around 14 m (45 ft) tali, in blossom with white flowers scented like violets, growing in the sea and with trunks ‘‘held up by their roots like a polyp ”. The leaves are described as being like those of a laurel. Such a description would apply to Rhizophora. Pliny in his “Historia naturalis”(A.D. 7 7 ) quotes this and adds that similar trees occurred along the Red Sea. Plutarch in his “Moralia ” ( A . D . 7 0 ) is much concerned with the problem as to how these trees nourish themselves from sea water. Arrian in the “Anabasis ” (A.D. 136) gives a few sentences about trees that grow in the sea. Theophrastus also gives a description of a mangrove swamp or mangal with its creeks through which a boat may pass, but none of the other authors took up this point. Arrian’s mention of mangroves is the last until the Middle Ages. Abou’l Abbas en-Nabaty, a Moorish botanist living in Spain, gave in 1230 an account of a journey through Arabia, Syria and Iraq. His book is no longer extant but one of his pupils quotes from it and from other Moorish and Arab botanists. References t o Rhizophora are clear, it is called by them kendela, a name cognate with the Latin candela, and this name persists in Arabic and Swahili to the present day. (This name, which bears reference to the shape of the seedling, has been given to the least common mangrove genus of the Rhizophoraceae, Kandelia.) These Moorish authors describe how the bark of Rhixophora is used in tanning-a use still current-and ascribe to it medicinal virtues. Reference is also made to Avicennia which they call quorm.
FAUNA AND FLORA O F MANGROVE SWAMPS
77
The next mention of mangroves comes from the reports of the sixteenth-century explorers. Aviedo first described the American mangroves in 1526, but not till 1678 do we find accounts of Indian Ocean mangroves in van Rheede’s “Hortus malabaricus ”. John Ray (1693) gives a sound account drawn from various travellers’ tales, and from then on references become more common so that by the middle of the eighteenth century it was possible for Linnd to give modern names to several species. All these accounts leave many questions unanswered. Nearchus described trees of around 14 m (45 f t ) tall ; yet, if Bretzl’s account is to be accepted, and there is no reason to doubt him, no trees of this height occurred in 1900 anywhere along these shores. Only scrub mangroves occur too, nowadays, along Red Sea shores. Where have the tall trees gone? We know that, for the most part, the Ancients never planted trees, other than fruit trees ; we know that the Arabs and the Persians also never planted trees, yet they built ships and houses in which timber was important. Mangrove timber is still the basis of much Arab domestic architecture, and is collected from the mangrove forests of East Africa. The Arabs sail ships which are known in English by the name of dhow, a word of unknown origin: masts of these dhows are frequently made from the trunk of a mangrove tree, either of Sonneratia, of Rhizophora or of Bruguiera-all trees which give a long, clean, tapering trunk. One is tempted to suggest that the handy occurrence of mangrove trees on Red Sea shores and along the Persian Gulf provided the timber for the first sea-going ships. But no one tells us how, or from what wood, these early boats were made.
C. Indo-west-Pacific shores Mangroves grow only on sheltered shores. Within the tropics many, if not most, of the shores of the Indo-west-Pacific biogeographic region are protected by reefs of coral lying along the edge of the continental shelf. Such reefs, and in certain regions a multiplicity of islands, break the force of the waves so that considerable lengths of coastline, both of continents and of large islands, are not subjected to strong wave action. Other shore lines tend to run parallel to the direction of the prevailing winds and so they, too, come to be, in fact, sheltered shores even though on a map they appear to be open t o the sea. South of the tropics, but within the trade wind zones of the Southern Hemisphere, long stretches of high sand dunes run along the eastern coasts of Africa, Australia and Madagascar. These dunes are ancient formations and reach altitudes of 60 m a t Durban Bluff, of 114 m a t
FIG.1. Map of the Indo-west-Pacificbiogeographic region. Coastlines where mangroves occur have been heavily outlined. Localities mentioned in the text are indicated.
79
FATJNA AND FLORA O F MANGROVE SWAMPS
Inhaca Island off Lourenyo Marques, and of 279 m on Moreton Island a t the same latitude in Queensland. Rivers entering the sea in these dune regions are deflected northwards and large bays develop behind the growing tips of the dune systems. The sheltered parts of Durban Bay, of the Bay of Lourenpo Marques and of Moreton Bay are, or until recently were, occupied by well-developed and well-zoned mangals. Farther north reefs of coral develop off shore. Off Africa, reefs, mostly fringing reefs, are more or less continuous from Pebane in north central Mopmbique to Somalia. Off Australia, the Great Barrier Reef is much better known. I n many areas the sea is shallow and the short but quite high waves disturb the bottom close to the beach making the sea turbid so that corals are rare. The shores do not develop high dunes ; instead, one finds systems of cheniers, low dunes rarely reaching elevations of 20 m and running approximately parallel to one another and to the present shore line. These may occur in several sequences (see Fig. l l ) , especially where the deltas of large rivers bring down, or have in the past brought down, quantities of alluvium which is sorted by wave action and the sand deposited on the cheniers and the finer material elsewhere. Such a succession of cheniers seen .from the air resembles a series of giant ripple marks. The most seaward chenier is typically colonized just above high water mark by a narrow zone, often only one to four trees in width, of Casuarina equisetifolia L. These trees also occur in a similar single series on relatively stable sandy coastlines along oceanic or other shores exposed to wave action. The most famous example of this occurs along almost the entire east coast of the Malay Peninsula (Watson, 1928). Shorter examples are common on all suitable tropical shores of the Indo-west-Pacific. These narrow zones of Casuarinq equisettfolia give the impression of having been planted by man. Why else would they be so regular? Although provision of wind breaks and dune binding has been achieved by planting these trees on coastal dunes on Mauritiusbetween 1945 and 1950 (Sauer, 1962), these long, continental, very narrow belts of Casuarina are not there by human design. Small rivers are deflected northwards in the southern hemisphere and southwards in the northern by the growing tips of cheniers or beach ridges and they may be closed off. Between the successive cheniers the lows are sometimes under freshwater influence, becoming extensive swamps of reeds, sedges or papyrus ; or open ponds ” with water lilies, floating ferns mainly species of Azolla, and nowadays the alien water hyacinth (Eichhornia crassipes (Mart.) Solms.), imported from America. Sometimes the lows are brackish,under marine influence l1
80
WILLLAM
MACNAE
by way of estuaries of the small rivers or as a result of seepage through the base of the chenier, then mangroves encroach and may develop into dense forests. Mangrove forests of this nature are extensive to the north and south of Beira, and in the region formed by the vagaries in the Holocene of the deltas of the Zambezi and neighbouring rivers. Along the shores of Sarawak and other parts of Borneo mangroves occur on shores facing the South China and Java Seas. But these shores, by virtue of their direction, run in such a way that they are sheltered from the strongest winds that prevail in those seas. Winds of gale force are rare in the belt within a few degrees of and on either side of the Equator in the Indo-Australianarchipelago. Elsewhere mangroves are associated with estuaries. Some of the largest mangrove forests in East Africa are associated with the deltas of the Zambezi and Rufiji rivers. The most extensive mangals in the world are associated with the deltas of rivers entering the Bay of Bengal, the Straits of Malacca-both on the Malayan and Sumatran sides (the Straits of Malacca, in fact, constitute a drowned estuary)in southern Borneo, in New Guinea, and in Thailand and adjoining territories t o the eastward. Mangroves are, therefore, almost always estuarine or else have developed in lagoons and lows behind cheniers or in the shelter of fringing or barrier reefs of coral, or of bluffs or islands. Mangal development, as may be expected, shows a relationship to the steepness of the shore and to the range of the tides. The shore exposed between tide-marks, in regions where the tide is appreciable, includes two distinct sections: (1) a portion exposed a t low tides, and this does not concern us for it is never colonized by mangroves, and ( 2 ) a portion entirely covered by water only a t high spring tides. This is the schorre in international terminology-“ salt marsh ”in England, America and Australia. In the tropics and warmer subtropics around the Indian Ocean a zoned mangal occupies almost the entire schorre: but only in the humid tropics will the mangrove zonation tend t o be complete. In drier regions or where rainfallis seasonal only the lower level will be occupied by mangroves. Here a low cliff-“ a salting cliff ”-often divides the schorre into two levels: of these the “low marsh” will tend to be occupied by a more or less well-developed mangal, and the “high marsh )’will be either bare or occupied by a variety of halophytes. Guilcher (1963) records such a pattern in Madagascar and ascribes it “to the long dry season and to the high temperature, which lead to complete desiccation of the surface and crystallization of salt during neap tides so that no plant is able to grow there ”. Such bare areas are
82
WILLIAM MACNAE
described by Fosberg (1961) a t Gladstone in Queensland, and their development is discussed by Macnae (1966, 1967) with conclusions similar to those of Guileher." Mangroves penetrate only a short way upstream in the estuaries of some rivers and very far in others. I n the main channel of the Zambezi delta, the Rio Cuama, mangroves penetrate only some 15 km from the mouth. I n the Rio Maputo, runninginto the Bay of Lourenyo Marques, trees of Avicennia marina (Borsk.) Vierh. with a few Bruguiera gymnorhiza (L.) Lmk. and an occasional Rhizophora mucronata Lmk. extend upstream for less than 8 km. The tide goes far beyond this, above the village of Salamangasome 40 km upstream. At this village an association dominated by Barringtonia racemosa (L.) B1. and peopled by estuarine crabs occupies the "high marsh "which is quite narrow (Macnae, unpublished information). I n the Musi river of southern Sumatramangroves extend as far as Palembang, 50 km inland ; in the Kikori river of Papua they extend some 100 km upstream ; Bruguiera and Xonneratia were found 320 km up the Fly river in southern New Guinea (van Steenis in Ding Hou, 1958). I n the upper parts of tidal estuaries fresh water may be pushed back by the tidal wave, particularly when the discharge of the river is normally high. It has been shown by many authors (see Emery et al., 1957) that salt water penetrates an estuary in the form of a wedge which tapers upstream so that the fresh water lies on the surface and the "salt wedge "creeps along the bottom. As Alexander et al. (1932, 1935) showed, this "salt wedge " creeps farther upstream in the mud on the bottom. Hence it is not surprising that mangroves penetrate far upstream. The short penetration of the Zambezi delta has two causes : the banks are high, indicating that the trees would have to be very deep-rooted to reach the "salt wedge "; also there is a bar across the mouth which impedes the entry of sea water. The mouths of the rivers mentioned by van Steenis probably have no bars, and the banks are low. The Hooghly river, a distributary of the Ganges, is navigable by ocean vessels as far as Calcutta, and has a tidal portion of over 300 km. Mangroves extend beyond Calcutta.
Geological signi$cance of mangroves Davis (1940)has shown that in Floridamangroves have an important function in relation to the accumulation of coastal sediments. This is
* Guilcher (1965) has pointed out that such bare areas occur in the vicinity of Port Moresby in New Guinea on a coast with a seasonal rainfall due to its boing in the rain shadow of the central mountain chain.
FAUNA AND FLORA O F MANGROVE SWAMPS
83
probably always true. Van Bemmelen (1949) records extensive shifts of the coastline of Sumatra,Java and Borneo as the result of accretion in mangrove areas. Van Steenis (in Ding Hou, 1958) commented that Junghuhnin 1853 had pointed out that “the mangrove follows the silting up of a coastal area rather than precedes and initiates the accumulation of mud or other soil and that it establishes itself merely on accrescent coasts ”. Palembang in south-eastern Sumatra was one of the ports visited by Marco Polo in 1292; it was still a coastal or river-mouth port 400 years ago, it is now 50 km inland. The rate of accretion is therefore around 125 m per annum. Near Indramajuin north-western Java it is 108 m per year ; in the Bodri delta an accretion of around 200 m per annum is threatening to close the port of Semarang (East Java). A similar rate of accretion is reported for the retreat of the sea from Hanoi in North Viet Nam (dat)afrom ~7anBemmelen, 1949). Anderson (1964) records that the Baram and Limbang flood plains in Sarawak have been extended seawards a t an estimated rate of 27.8 m (90 ft) per annum since the sea reached its present level there some 5 400 years ago. The silt which forms the mud so characteristic of mangrove areas has its origin in the load brought down by rivers. Guilcher (1963) comments that the mass of material in suspension carried to and fro by the rising and falling tide may be derived from the river or from material being resorted by wave action in the shallows just off shore. At Majunga in Madagascar Lafond (1957) showed that the mud was lateritic, derived from the deforested slopes of’the escarpment drained by the rivers; in Malaya and Indonesia the source is again from the rivers (van Bemmelen, 1949; Schuster, 1952; Carter, 1959). I n some areas with a limestone hinterland or with a coral reef nearby the intertidal deposits are formed of marl (Schuster, 1952 ; Davis, 1940). These materials all settle out a t the slack of the tide. The current velocity of the tide falls off rapidly as it goes farther into the mangal and the water can no longer support its load, which then falls out. Much of the material settles in the seaward fringe, but due to a time lag between the moment a t which the current is no longer able to carry its load and the moment when the material reaches the bottom, some of the material may be carried farther into the swamp. According to Guilcher (1963), this “settling lag effect ” may carry fine silt even to the inner reaches of the marsh. Guilcher goes on to write that “the minimum velocity required to erode a sediment after it has been deposited is higher than the maximum velocity a t which these same particles can settle : this ‘ scour lag ’ favours an excess of deposition ”.
84
WILLIAM MACNAE
Such settlement a t the seaward end of a creek is prevented when the time taken for settlement is longer than the slack of the water at low tide. I n areas where the uppermost intertidal levels are bare of vegetation the deposits are often sandy. This is almost certainly the result of a very short period of inundation, duringwhich the tiny waves waft away any fine material from amongst the sand grains and no time is available for deposition. Many mangrove areas result from accretion on recently submerged coastlands. Obdeyn in several papers published between 1941 and 1944 has followed the history of the Sumatran, Javan and Malayan coastlines from a study of Chinese, Indian and other historical records. He has shown that during the early historical period Sumatra was still joined to the mainland and to Java, and that the Malay Peninsula extended southwards through the Riouw-Lingga archipelago almost as far as the tin islands of Bangka and Billiton. The suggestion follows that the silting up of estuaries in south-east Sumatra followed the opening of the Straits and the subsequent development of backwaters some distance from the tidal rips which run in t,he narrow channels between the islands. Such alterations of shore level are of twofold origin. I n Malaya and the Sunda archipelago, change of sea-level is due both to eustatic changes resulting from the Pleistocene Ice Ages and to epeirogenic movements resulting from the processes of deformation and mountain building which began in the Tertiary and still continue. India, Africa and Australia have been affected by the former ; western Malaya and the Sunda are mainly by the latter. I n many of the niangals of Sarawak there occur odd little clumps of terrestrial forest often only a few acres or less in extent. Anderson (in conversation) has commented that the soils of these islands of terrestrial forest suggest that they have not been derived by normal processes of accretion. But their origin has not been investigated! The Sunda Shelf extends far out into the South China Sea (see Fig. 7 5 , p. 227). This shelf is of interest in relation to the spread of several animals and plants and its eastern and southern margins correspond to “Wallace’s Line ”, the south-eastward limit of purely Asiatic land animals. The Sahul Shelf connected Australia and New Guinea and several islands between, and it forms the limit reached by many purely Australian land animals. The Sofala Shelf off cent,ral Mopambique is probably contemporaneous, as also is the shelf off Queensland within the Great Barrier Reef. All these processes, then, have made the shores of the Indian Ocean
FAUNA AND FLORA O F MANGROVE SWAMPS
85
and the western Pacific Ocean very suitable for the establishment of mangroves and mangrove swamps. The geological history of the mangroves is also quite a long one. Muller (1961, 1964) has shown from a study of cores taken in peat swamp and mangrove forests in Borneo that nypa pollen and a Brownlowia-type pollen were already common a t the beginning of the Eocene ; that pollen of the Rhizophoraceae appeared late in the Eocene or early in the Oligocene; that pollen resembling that of Sonneratia caseolaris (L.) Engl. appeared early in the Miocene, and pollen resembling that of S. alba B1. late in the Miocene; and finally that pollen of an avicennia type appeared in the mid-Miocene. These cores were also of interest, in that they showed the presence of pollen similar to that of Aegialitis and Camptosternon, two mangrove genera no longer growing in Borneo, both now being restricted to more eastern areas in the Molluccas, New Guinea etc. Muller also quotes the following facts about the geological history of mangroves and other associated plants. The fruits of Nypa have been described from the London Clay flora (Eocene) of England (Chandler, 1951) and equivalent deposits in Belgium. Pollen of rhizophora-type has been reported from the Oligocene onwards from Venezuela, Nigeria and New Guinea (Kuyl et al., 1955). Chandler (1951) reports fruits resembling those of Rhizophoraceae from the London Clay. Wood and flowers resembling those of Sonneratiu have been found in India-wood from Pliocene and flowers from Deccan Intertrappean beds attributed to Eocene (Mahabale and Deshpande, 1959 ; Prakash, 1960).
D. Sea-shore plant associations Leaving aside the algal associations which occur on rocky shores, characteristic associations, principally of higher plants, grow on the different types of non-rocky substrata which occur along shores of the Indian and west Pacific Oceans. Schimper (1891) recognized four associations. (a) The Mangal-forests growing below high tide mark, and comprising several species of trees and a few of non-woody herbaceous plants. (b) The Nypa Association-occurring to landward and upstream of a mangal, dominated by the rhizomatous palm, Nypa fruticans Wurmb., and supporting a few isolated trees, chiefly Heritiera littoralis (L.) Dryand. and Excoecaria agallocha L., a few shrubs, lianes and ferns chiefly Acrostichum aureum L. (Fig. 3).
FIG.3. N y p a fruticosu at the edge of a distributary of the Sarawak river below Kuching. I n tho nypa swamp behind, trees of Excoecaria agallocha and Heritiera littoralis were conspicuous. (Mid-tide, January 1967.)
Barringtonia racemosa and associated trees, upstream of mangroves near Inhambane (lat. 23"S.), Mopambique. (Septomber 1966.) (1) B. racemosa; ( 2 ) Brachylaena discolor; ( 3 ) Mimusops caffra; (4) Euclea natalensis; (5) Ozoroa obovata; ( 6 ) Siderozylon inerme and Phragmites communis.
FIG. 4.
87
FAUNA AND FLORA OF MANGROVE SWAMPS
FIG.5. The pes-caprae association a t the foot of sand dunes on Inhaca Island. In the background is a group of tall bushes of the silvery leaved Sophora tomentosa, and in the foreground creepers of Ipomoea pes-caprae.
(c) The BarringtoniaAssociation-dominated by either Barringtoizia
asiatica Kunz. when it occurs behind a pes-caprae association, or by B. racemosa and/or Heritiera sp. if the association occurs behind a mangal. All of these trees prefer a relatively welldrained soil (Fig. 4). Schiniper did not distinguish between these but lumped them together. (d) The Pes-caprae Association-dominated by Ipomoea pes-caprae Roth., usually accompanied by Canavallia sp., by shrubs of Sophora sp. (most commonly S. tomentosa L.), of Xcaevola sp., of a single row of trees of Casuarina equisetifolia, and often planted out with trees of Cocos nucifera L. (Fig. 5 ) . Of these associations the pes-caprae and the barringtonia asiatica associations are always supralittoral, in the sense given to this word by Lewis (1964), and normally characteristic of sandy shores; they will not concern us further. The mangal is always littoral, in the sense of Lewis, and never extends above high water mark. The nypa association and the barringtonia asiatica association are associations of overlap and straddle high water mark of ordinary spring tides, and may extend above extreme high water mark. Both are indicative of strong freshwater influence, but the nypa association tends to occur on more A.M.B.-6
4
88
WILLIAM MACNAE
or less permanently waterlogged soils. The barringtonia racemosa association occurs on relatively well-drained soils which may show a seasonal water-logging. The first three of these associations occur only on sheltered shores ; the fourth is equally characteristically found on open wave-beaten shores. Members of the pes-caprae association are often useful dunefixing agents. To these four associations it may be convenient to add a fifth association which occurs from mean sea-level downwards, on sheltered ;hores or in rock pools on open shores. (e) The Cymodocea Association-dominated by one or other of the species of Cymodocea intermingled with species of Diplanthera, Enhalus, Halodule, Halophila, Syringodium, Thalassia and
Zostera. Again this association does not really concern us except as it may occasionally encroach on the lower zones of the mangal. Schimper (1891) was dealing only with the plant associations in the region between India and western Indonesia, drought-stricken areas did not come within his survey. When evaporation comes to exceed the availability of fresh water Schimper’s first three associations become highly modified. The nypa and barringtonia racemosa associations become less and less conspicuous and in their stead occurs : (f ) The Saltwort Association-dominated by bushes or low shrubs of species of the perennial Arthrocnenum and the annual Xalicornia. When evaporation becomes excessive, bare areas devoid of any vegetation supervene, and then all plant communities are restricted to the vicinity of creeks, occasionally with a fringe of halophytes around high water mark. I n summary, one may recognize on Indo-west-Pacific shores above the level of high water of neap tides, two basic plant associations. ( 1 ) Just above high water mark of ordinary spring tides there occurs
on exposed shores or sandy shores the lpomoea pes-caprae Association, and this with only a few of the associates varying, extends from semi-desert shores t o the ever-wet, where rain may fall abundantly at all seasons. I n the humid tropics this may be associated with a Barringtonia asiatica Association. ( 2 ) On sheltered and muddy shores, the Mangal stretches from near mean sea-level upwards to extreme high water mark. As variants a t higher levels we may find (a) a Nypa Association,
FAUNA AND FLORA O F MANGROVE
SWAMPS
89
(b) a Barringtonia racemosa Association, or ( c ) a Saltwort Association. The first two are diagnostic of areas under freshwater domination where evaporation and transpiration are more than balanced by a high rainfall and/or supply of fresh water from large rivers. The saltwort association occurs where evaporation and transpiration are in excess of the supply of fresh water.
11. ZONATION OF MANGROVES Three schemes have been proposed in descriptions of the zonation of mangroves, two of these base the zonation on physical features of the environment while the third follows more recent practice and names the zones from the genus dominant in each one. 1. Watson (1928) in a pioneering study of Malayan mangroves recognized five classes based on frequency of inundation (Fig. 6). (i) Species growing on land flooded at all high tides: no species normally exists under these conditions but Rhizophora mucronata will do so exceptionally. (ii) Species growing on land flooded by medium high tides: species of Avicennia, A . alba, A . marina (Forst.) Vierh. (= A . intermedia Griff) and Xonneratia griflithii Kurz., and, bordering rivers, R. mucronata. (iii) Species growing where they are flooded by normal high tides: the majority of mangroves thrive under these conditions but the rhizophoras tend t o become dominant. (iv) Species growing on land flooded by spring tides only: such areas are a little too dry for the rhizophoras and suit Bruguiera gymnorhiza and B. cylindrica (L.) B1. better. (v) Species on land flooded by equinoctial or other exceptional tides only : B. gymnorhiza dominant but Rhizophora apiculata B1. and Xylocarpus granatus survive. 2 . De Haan (1931) introduced salinity of soil water as the factor controlling distribution with tidal flooding as a subsidiary factor. His scheme has two main divisions each with subdivisions. A. A brackish to salt water zone with salinities a t flood tide of between lo%, and 30%,. A1. Areas flooded once or twice daily on each of 20 days per month. A2. Areas flooded ten to nineteen times per month. A3. Areas flooded nine times or less in each month. A4. Areas flooded on a few days only, in each year.
Rhizophoro mucronato Rhizophora
1opiculato Bruguiero 1 parvif/ora
1 Rhizophoro styloso
+
*
Bruguiero cylindrico Bruguiero sexongulo Bruguiero qymnorhiza Heritiera
Xylocorpus
f
Xylocorpus molluccense Intsio Forest
1
'? gronotum
Sannerotio griffithii
1 Avicennia
p ZEZ"marino
A vicennio albo Acrostichum auraum Somphires Sesuvium
FIG.6. A diagram (redrawn from Watson, 1928) ''to illustrate the typical, but, by no means inevitable, distribution of the more important mangrove species ". This diagram is based on the distribution of trees on the Malayan west coast.
FAUNA AND FLORA OF MANGROVE SWAMPS
91
B. A fresh to brackish water zone with salinities between O x , and lo%,. B1. Areas more or less under the influence of the tides. B2. Areas seasonally flooded. It is clear that A1 and A4 are equivalent t o Watson’s classes (i) and (v) respectively; A2 overlaps Watson’s classes (ii) and (iii) and A3 overlaps (iii) and (iv). B1 includes both barringtonia racemosa and nypa associations and B 2 includes peat and other swamp forests and areas dominated by Hibiscus tiliaceus L. 3. Walter and Steiner (1936) working on the mangal at Tanga in East Africa named the zones after the dominant tree. This was followed by Macnae and Kalk (1962) (cf. Fig. 19) and developed and extended by Macnae (1966) in a way which may be applied in any mangrove area (see Fig. 7 ) . There are distinguished : (1) The landward fringe. (2) Zone of ceriops thickets. (3) Zone of bruguiera forests. (4) Zone of the rhizophora forests. (5) The seaward avicennia zone. (6) The sonneratia zone. Modifications may be expected in the first three of these zones, and the last is not present on all shores for i t is restricted t o warmer coastlines. Watson’s figure showing the distribution of mangrove species in Malaya (Fig. 6) clearly indicates that he appreciated that the zonation followed this pattern.
A. The landward fringe This zone is the most highly variable of all the zones of the mangal. The soils may be predominantly sandy or predominantly muddy ; they may be well drained or waterlogged ; they may be rich, derived from recent volcanic rocks; or poor, derived from ancient granites and quartzites ; they may be marly, derived from limestones or peaty with much organic matter. The salinity of the soil water may be high or low. Each of these produces some variation but in general the mangals vary within two facies :(1)following on a forested supralittoral,and (2) following on a non-forested supralittoral, i.e. of grassland, scrub or desert. 1. Following o n a forested supralittoral
The word forest is used here to include rain forest only. Where climax rain forest has developed, or is capable of being developed, the
92
WILLIAM MACNAE
FIG. 7. Mosaic of air photographs of a large area of mangrove forest in northern Moqambique, an almost unexploited forest. (1) A bare area between E.H.W. and H.W.M.O.S.T. covered by blue-green algae and occasional clumps of halophytes ; (2) bare area below H.W.M.O.S.T. colonized by Uca universa; (3) Avicennia parkland with Uca lactea f. annulipes, Sesarma eulimene, S. ortmanni and Cerithidea decollata ; (4) Forest of Avicennia marina with Sesarma meinerti and S. guttatum ; ( 5 ) thickets of Ceriops tagal and/or forest of Bruguiera gymnorhiza with Sesarma guttatum, S . meinerti and S . smithii; (6) forest of Rhizophora mucronata; (7) mixed forest of R. mucronata, Sonneratia alba, Avicennia marina and Bruguiera gymnorhiza (in that order of abundance) with Upogebia sp., AZpheus sp. and mud-skippers; (8) seaward fringe of Sonneratia alba. (By courtesy of the Secretary for Lands, Mogambique.)
F A U N A A N D FLORA O F MANGROVE SWAMPS
93
landward fringe of the mangal also contains tall trees-in other words the rain forest continues into the littoral, but there will be an abrupt change in species at the level of extreme high water (see Fig. 8). There may, in fact, be a slight “salting cliff ”marking the change. Observations in Australia (Macnae, 1966) suggest that such a rain forest mangal will only develop in areas with a rainfall of over 2 000 mm (80 in) and then only when there is an appreciable fall during the drier season. I n Malaya the landward fringe constitutes Watson’s (1928) class (v), which is inundated by extreme high tides, and the upper part of his class (iv), inundated by normal high tides. It corresponds alsowith de Haan’s (1931) classes A3 and A4. Each of these three shows slight differences from the others. The forests studied by Watson were clearly under marine domination and the dominant trees were mangroves. Those studied by de Haan appear to have been less saline for the trees of the barringtonia racemosa association were dominant. Watson reports that Bruguiera gymnorhiza may be dominant if the soil is heavy and wet; and with it may occur old trees of Rhizophora apiculata, of Xylocarpus moluccensis Roem. and good stands of Intsia bijuga (Colebr.) 0. Kunz.; lianas and other climbers and also various epiphytes will be common. Avicennia oficinalis L. is common, occasionally abundanta t this level in South East Asia from the Indus delta to New Guinea. I n eastern Africa A. marina extends up to this level. I n the levels reached by normal spring tides Xylocarpus granatum and Lumnitzera littorea Voigt form large trees : Bruguiera parvijlora W & A and B. cylindrica may form dense stands and B. sexangula Poir. may occur with B. cylindrica ; Avicennia lanata Ridl. is also, on the eastern shores of the Malayan peninsula and on the island of Singapore, characteristic of this level. There is almost always an undergrowth of ferns, the short Acrostichum speciosum Willd. in shade, and the larger A. aureum L. in clearings where it may form a stand 3 m high. If the soil is friable R. apiculata will be dominant. Degraded forests of this sort occurring just above high water mark in the centre of “mangrove islands ” off the west coast of Malaya are known to foresters as hutan darat-dry forest. De Haan recognizes three variants, firstly a lumnitzera littorea association which develops on firm shallow soils with banks of marl, with a very uneven surface. The tree layer is thin with occasional well-grown trees of Bruguiera gymnorhiza, Lurnnitzera littorea, Xylocarpus granatum, Heritiera littoralis, Ficus microcarpa L.f., Terminalia catappa L. and Barringtonia racemosa. The undergrowth is a thick wilderness of Xcyphiphora hydrophyllacea Gaertn. and of Acrostichum sp. (de Haandoes not distinguish between A. aureumand A. speciosum).
94
WILLIAM MACNAE
A variant of this develops on firm soils of uneven surface. The tree layer contains Xylocarpus granatum, Heritiera littoralis, Ficus retusa, Intsia bijuga with Nypa in muddy gullies. The undergrowth is a thick layer of Derris he~erophylla(Willd.) Back. and Acrostichum sp. A third variant occurs on moderately firm soils with a tree layer including Bruguiera sexangula, Dolichandrone spathacea (L.f.) K. Schum., Barringtonia racemosa, Terminalia catappa, Ficus microcarpa, Lngerstroemia speciosa Pers., Corypha utan Lam. and along the creeks X ylocarpus granatum and Oncosperma jilanzentosum B1. A dense undergrowth comprises Acanthus ilicifolius L., Derris heterophylla, Acrostichum sp. and Crinum sp. These three associations seem in some unrecorded way to have been determined by the natureof the soil and, in addition, show an increasing dependence on fresh water; they may be considered to be variants merging into the barringtonia racemosa association as described below or into peat swamp forest. The relationshipbetween nature of soil and its associated vegetation in the mangrove areas is hinted a t but not definitely shown by some unpublished observations made in Sarawak by Anderson (personal communication). He has demonstrated that, in a transect from the seaward mangrove fringe to fully developed peat forest, there is a transition from almost purely mineral soils in the seaward avicennia fringes, to muck soils (with up to 65% humic material) supporting an association containing Nypa fruticans, Avicennia officinalis, Acanthus ilicifolius, Sonneratia caseolaris, Acrostichum sp. and with Bruguiera sexangula as the dominant tree, and finally into peat soils with around 95% organic matter. These latter occur only just above high water mark. Comments relating one species or anotherto more friable sandy soils or to clays are common in the literature but without definition of what is meant. I n Australia a luxuriant mangal occurs only in the wettest parts of Queensland between the Hinchinbrook channel and the Daintree river, and there only on heavy volcanic soils. Its development is not so lush on quartzitic soils in this same area. I n eastern Africa such an association occurs only a t the mouth of the Rufiji delta and on Mafia Island, where the rainfall is higher than even a few miles inland. I n north Queensland and in the Rufiji delta the landward fringe contains specimens of each and every mangrove tree occurring in the area, no one species is dominant. Most trees are well grown and only a few saplings are present. This is the area where Heritiera littoralis is normally to be found both in eastern Africa south to Inhambane and
FIG.8. e
The distribution of mangrove species on the Queensland coast in tho region between Mossman and Cardwell. The diagram is based on the air photographs of the area just north of Cairns and personal observation. The rainfall is around 2 000 mm with some rain in the drier months. The transect scheme follows the figures used in Fig. 6. Certain apparently significant tidal levels are indicated, the numbers refer to days per month or per year on which tide reaches this level.
96
WILLIAM MACNAE
in Queensland. Lunznitzera littorea is only found in this zone in Queensland. L. racemosa is characteristic of this zone in eastern Africa but it never becomes a well-grown tree.
The barringtonia msociations Associations dominated by species of Barringtonia occur in two distinct types of environment. (i) The barringtonia asiatica association. An association with Barringtonia asiatica (= B. speciosa L.f.) as dominant or as a very conspicuous associate occurs behind the pes-caprae association on sandy beaches. This is the facies described by Schimper (1891). Although this association does not concernus here, it does in fact, often include several trees which may occur in the ecotone of a mangal. Such are Terminalia catappa, Thespesia populnea and Pandanus tectorius. (ii) The barriiigtonia racemosa association (see Fig. 4). This association would seem t o reach maximum development along the shores of eastern Africa, between Kenya and Natal, and locally in southern Java (de Haan, 1931). I n eastern Africa (personal observation) it tends t o occur on quite well drained soils behind and upstream of a mangal. Thus it is equivalent to the nypa association of so much of South East Asia. I n eastern Africa the trees and bushes of B. racemosa are overgrown by climbers such as Derris trifoliata Lour., Entada phaseoloides (L.) Merr. Caesalpinia bonduc L. Heritiera littoralis is often co-dominant. Hibiscus tiliaceus is conspicuous in wetter localities and Thespesia popuknea in more sandy areas. I n the Zambezi delta Thespesiopsis mossambica Excel1 and Hillcoat and Pandunus livingstoniana Rendle are conspicuous. Other members of the association are indicated in Fig. 4. I n the Sunderbans and other deltaic forests facing the Bay of Bengal this association is represented by forests dominated by Heritiera littoralis and other species of this genus (Champion, 1936). On the banks of distributaries of the Zambezi Delta the barringtonia association occurs on the levees adjoining the river, and a forest of Bruguiera gymnorhiza occurs beyond a t only a slightly lower level. On the banks of the Maputo river (which enters the Bay of Lourengo Marques) above the township of Bela Vista where the river, while still tidal, is not under marked salt-water influence, Barringtonia racemosa occurs on the uppermost part of the banks just below high water mark. It occurs in a pure stand and is overgrown by lianas of Entada phaseoloides, the large bean-like seeds of which are commonly found cast up along high tide mark on tropical and subtropical Indian Ocean a.
FAUNA AND FLORA O F MANGROVE SWAMPS
97
shores. These two plants also occur together in the lagoons of small rivers in southern Natal, just behind the coastal dunes through which the rivers break, when occasional floods raise the level in the lagoon sufficiently (personal observation). b. T h e nypa association The nypa association constitutes one of the most important, and from the air most conspicuous, features of the mangal throughout the Indo-Malaysian and South East Asiatic regions (Fig. 10). It occupies extensive, often very extensive, areas in the region flooded by the highest spring tides (Fig. 19). A notable feature of the area occupied by the association is the large number of huge (up to 3 m high) mounds of Thalassina anomala and these affect considerably the facies shown by the association. When nypa is very dense there may be little else, for other plants are shaded out. I n such an area the palms present a veritable wall along the banks of rivers or creeks. Occasional trees of Heritiera littoralis, of Xylocarpus granutus, X . moluccensis, Bruguiera sexangula, B. gymnorhixa or of Lumnitzera littorea may stand out conspicuously at higher levels and trees of Rhixophora apiculata a t only fractionally lower levels. Excoecaria agallocha, Bruguiera cylindrica and Sonneratia caseoluris are frequent associates. Hibiscus tiliaceus and species of Pandanus will also occur in places where the water is almost fresh. The mounds cast up by Thalassina often reach heights above high water mark. At levels where they may occasionally be flooded they are colonized by Acrostichum speciosum and by the lianas Clerodendron inerme (L.) Gaertn., Cynanchum carnosum Hort., Entada scheferi Ridl. ( ? = E. phaseoloides) as well as by rotans, Calamus aquatilis Ridl. and these will sprawl over the trees rather than over the nypa of which the slippery leaves seem to offer little to grasp. At higher levels terrestrial plants may colonize. I have seen a juvenile coconut tree on such a mound in the Sarawak river delta. Because of its uses to man as thatch and for various other purposes including sugar production, the nypa association is often kept artificially clear. Though not in the usual sense of the word cultivated, it is cared for and as a result of leaf cutting access between palms is easier. Usually the creeks and rivers are lined by a dense wall of the palms but various mangroves may develop between ; these include Avicennia oficinalis, Kandelia Icandel, Brownlowia tersa (L.) Kost., Aegiceras corniculatum and most characteristically, Sonneratia caseolaris. The ecotone or zone of passage between the nypa association and the freshwater swamp forest is often indicated by a narrow and continuous
Nypa swamp
Thalassina large Sesorma spp North Borneo
FIG.9. The pattern of distribution of mangroves a t Sandakanin Sabah (North Borneo) as seen in a typical transect. The nypa swamp is very extensive with occasional trees of Heritiera and Ezcoecaria conspicuous. The zoned forest is dominated by Rhizophora apiculata and has a fringe of Avicennia or of Sonneratia.
FAUNA AND FLORA O F MANGROVE SWAMPS
99
FIG.10. Mosair of air photographs of virgin mangroves in Sabah (North Borneo). (1) Nypa swamp; (2) forest of Rhizophora mucronata; ( 3 ) forest of R. apiculata; (4) mixed mangroves with outstandingtrees of Bruguiera gyrnnorhiza and B. sexangula ; (5) area exploited by indiscriminate felling. The pock marks in zones 2 and 3 are areas where some ten t o twelve trees have been injured by lightning. Note the evenness of the canopy in these areas, seemingly a prerequisite for this type of lightning damage. (Courtesy of the Director, Lands and Survey Dept., Jesselton, Sabah.)
belt of Oncosperma tigillaria (Jack.)Ridl., the nibong palm. This belt is reported to be extensive in Sumatra from whence large numbers of poles of nibong are exported to Malaya for use as piles in jetties, houses, board walks and fish traps. 2 . Following o n a savannah, grassland or desert With a reduction in rainfall the forested landward fringe, whether a mangrove association, a barriiigtonia association or a nypa-hibiscustiliaceus association, thins out, eventually to disappear. My own observations in Australia and eastern Africa indicate that where there is an intermediate rainfall, between 1500 and 500 mm, the landward fringe of mangroves is reduced to a narrow zone, containing well-developed trees, or merely shrubs, of Avicennia marina and shrubs of Lurnnitxera racemosa, and rarely with any admixture of other species. Occasionally where the slope of land is gentle, particularly where the tidal range is considerable, this landward fringe widens and well-developed trees of Awicennia marina some 5-7 m tall are spread as in a parkland, with, beneath, a carpet of Xesuvium portulacastrum or
FIG.11. The distributionof mangroves in the district of Townsville, Queensland. The mangroves are restricted to the edge of the sea and to the vicinity of tho creeks. Osbornia and Ipornoea pes-caprae grow on cheniers. There are extensive bare areas. The rainfall is around 1 000 mm and highly seasonal. Based on air photographs. For explanationof transect, see Figs. 6 and S.
FIG. 12. Air photograph of the mangrove forest in the Sac0 da Inhaca (lat. 26"S.), southern Moqambique. Recognizable are a seaward fringe of Avicennia marina, trees up to 15 m ; creek fringes of Rhizophora mucronata, trees up to 10 m ;and the dense thickets of Ceriops tagal. Avicennia also occurs with Lumnitzera racernoas as stunted shrubs a t the edges of the clear areas. D, Sandy areas occupied by Dotilla fenestrata ; M, areas of sandy m i d with Macrophthalmus grandidieri; S, areas occupied by halophytes and oiily submerged at extreme high waters ;U, areasoccupied hy Uca inversa ( U . lactea f. annulipes is abundant wherever Avicennia trees occur). The transects are lines along which the salinity of the ground water was sampled in July 1963 and the numbers indicate the salinity in g/litre. (By courtesy of the Secretary for Lands, Mopmbique.)
102
WILLIAM MACNAE
Variations in the landward fringe of Avicennia marina in Mopmbique. FIG.13. Avicennia parkland at Inhaca (lat. 26"s.)with Juncus kraussii, Arthrocnemurn decumhens and Sesuuium portulacastrum. Such areas support large populations of Uca lactea f. annulipes, Sesarma ortmanni and Cerithidea decollata, and Macrophthalmus depressus spreads up to this level. (April 1967.)
FIG.14. Dwarfed Avicennia nzarina a t Inhambane (lat. 23"S.), with Chenolea diffusa. The dwarfing is probably due to mineral deficiencies. (Photo: A. 0. D. Mogg, J u l y 1963.)
FATJNA AND FLORA O F MANGROVE SWAMPS
103
FIG.15. Dwarfed Auicennia at Quissanga (lat. 12°K) with Sesuvium portulacastrum and Arthrornemum indicum (right). Note extensive bare areas due to high salinity of ground water-in July 1967 the salt crystals glistened on the surface a t low tide. (July 1967 just after last of spring tide series, mid-tide.)
of saltworts, species of Arthrocnemum(Fig. 19). I n the region between Chinde and Quelimane just to the north of the Zambezi Delta such parklands are extensive and the species of Arthrocnemumis A . indicum Moq. Tand. At Inhaca,in southernMoqambique, A . decumbensTolken is common. South of Townsville and in the Broad Sound area of Queensland such parklands cover many acres and A . leiostachyum (Benth.)Paulsen (if, indeed, this is different from A . indicum)and A . hnlocnemoidesNees var. pergranulntu~ J.M. Black form the field layer. At various places in south Queensland A. quinquejlorumUng.-Stenb. replaces A . leiostachyum. The level of ordinary high water mark is indicated by the presence of Chenolea diflusa L. and by one or other of the forms of Juncus maritimus Lam. (in southern Africa J . kraussi Hochst. ; in Australia J . maritimus). Clumps of Acrostichum aureum occur a t the upper edges of the parklands in Mogambique. A. speciosum does not occur under these conditions a t this level even in Queensland where it alone is present. Where such parklands and fringes have not developed, this zone will, apart from a few clumps of saltwort, be bare (Fig. 15).
B. Zone of ceriops thickets Ceriops tagal occurs from the Moqambique-Natal border along the eastern coast of Africa and Madagascarvia India and Ceylon to Taiwan (Formosa)in the north and t o Queensland and New Caledonia in the south. It is a mangrove which rarely reaches tree dimensions, but rather is a shrub ranging in height from around 1 to 6 m.
--___-
FIG.16. Patternof distributionof mangroves on Magnetic Island, off Townsville, Queensland,based on air photographs and personal observation. I n comparison with Figs. 6 and 8, a zone of Ceriops tagal is interposed between the landwardfringe and the bruguiera forest. This zone of Ceriops is interrupted by bare areas. The rainfall is around 1 500 mm, and seasonal, but seepage water from the mountainkeeps the streams perennial. This type of distribution is typical for areas of intermediate rainfall; it gives way to the pattern shown in Fig. 11 when evaporation and transpirationcome t o be excessive. Explanationof transect as in Figs. 6 and 8.
Canopy: R. mucronato
Canopy: R. apiculato
4
3 2 1
,
Small sesormas
FIGS.17-19. Diagrams of transects to show the distribution of plants and animals in mangrove forests. KEY Eam, Ellobium auk-midce Bb, Boleaphthalmw boddaerti II!, Ilyagrapsus sp. or spp. Caf, Caasidula auris-felis Cc, Cerithidea cingulata La. Leiopecten sordidul w Cm, Clistocoeloma merguiense M a , Macrophthalmus sp. Go, Cerithidea obtusa Mc, Metaplax crenatus M e , Metaplax elegana Eaj, Ellobium auris-judm
In each transect the number of tides per annum reaching certain levels is indicated. Pc, Pk, Ps, Sb,
Periophthalmus chrysospilos Periophthalmus kalolo Periophthalmodon schlosseri Syncera brevicula Sv, Scurtelaos wiridis T m , Teleacop’um spp.
Uc, Ud, Urn, Up,
Ur, ut,
Uca coarctata Uca dussumieri Ucamanii Upogebia sp. Uca rosea uca triangularis
FIG.17. The pattern in deltaic forests in western Malaya, cf. Fig. 6. The snails show a zonation in two directions, vertically in the trees and “horizontally” along the surface of the soil. The animals listed in Fig. 18 occur here as well. FIG.18. The pattern shown on the western seaboard of Malaya, as, for example, south of Kuala Selangor. FIG. 19. The pattern of distribution a t Inhaca in southern Mopambique, in a swamp with abundant seepage water from adjacent freshwater fens.
FAUNA AND FLORA O F MANGROVE SWAMPS
105
I n the ever-wet of Malaya and Indonesia a ceriops zone is not well marked but, rather, species of Ceriops occur within a bruguiera forest or, as in Sabah and peninsular Thailand,in association with Rhizophora spp. where these form well-developed and mature virgin forests. Under these circumstancesC . tagak reaches tree dimensions of upwards of 10 m and some 20 cm in diameter a t the base of the trunk above the buttresses. Trees of this size are mentioned by Watson (1028) without his being explicit as t o where they may be found. I n regions of intermediate rainfall and on soils which are well drained, dense thickets of C. tagal follow the landward fringe a t a level immersed by all spring tides, i.e. a t the lower levels of Watson’s class (iv) and the upper levels of his class (iii) (Figs. 16 and 19). Within these thickets all stages of development from newly germinated seedlings through saplings to mature small trees may be found in almost pure stands. I n Australia the most common associate is Bruguiera exaristata. OccasionaItrees of Avicennia marina, B. gymnorhiza, Xylocarpus granatum and X . moluccensis also occur ; Xcyphiphora hydrophyllacea occurred in this zone along the Hinchinbrook channel. I n eastern Africa only A . marina and B. gymnorhiza are present as associates. The trees of Ceriops are always taller a t the lower margins : where they merge with the trees in the zone of bruguiera forests they reach similar heights to the adjacent bruguiera trees which, in turn, are not so tall as those farther downward.
C . Zone of bruguiera forests Watson recognized three types of bruguiera forest, dominated respectively by B. cylindrica, B. parvijlora and B. gymnorhiza. Forests of B. cylindrica are characteristically developed on stiff, bIue clay soils with a shallow humus layer and a well-marked surface drainage but no creeks. I n Malaya such forests occur along the long stretches of the western coastline which lie between the major rivers (Fig. 17). These forests of B. cytindrica develop behind a seaward fringe of Avicenniu marina (= A. intermedia). The purity of these stands as seen today may be the result of thinning out other species. The soil surface is almost level and few animals were seen, these were mainly small sesarmas (personal observation). B. parvijlora is essentially an opportunist species and not popular with foresters because its timber is said to be inferior to that of other species. I n Australia (Macnae, 1966) and in Burma (Rogers, quoted by Watson, 1928) this species is also opportunist and tall groves occur in areas which have formerly been cleared (Fig. 20). I n Malaya, too, it frequently takes over an area which has been cleared and may then act
106
WILLIAM MACNAE
FIG. 20. Forest of Bruguiera pawi$ora at Nind’s creek, near Innisfail, Queensland: trees 20 cm in diameter and ra 30 m tall. One tree of Rhizophora stylosa can he seen. (Photo: B. Campbell, January 1964.)
FAUNA AND FLORA O F MANGROVE SWAMPS
107
as a nurse tree to the colonization of Rhizophora spp. or other more valuable Bruguiera spp. (Watson, 1928). Watson considers the forests of B. gynznorhiza to be “ t h e final stage in the development of the littoral forests and the beginning of the transition to inland forms ”. He finds that, once established, there is little regeneration beneath these trees and that successive humus deposits and the activities of Thalassina anomala (Herbst) gradually lift the soil level so that in due course it is raised above the reach of the tides. At this stage Xylocarpus moluccensis, Intsia bijuga, Ficus microcarpa, Pandanus spp. and Daerrtonorops leptopus and many other plants come in. I n Watson’s opinion, then, a forest of B. gymnorhiza is the transition t o a well-developed landward fringe. At Tjilatjap in southern Java, de Haan (1931) also described three variants of the bruguiera forests. He recognized a Bruguiera gymnorhiza Association developing in his zones A2-A3 (p. 89) on soils which are mainly firm and flat with few crab hills (i.e. mounds of Thalassina). Here there are tall trees of B. gymnorhiza in the upper part of A2 and in zone A3 these become intermingled with tall trees of Xylocarpus granatum and Heritiera littoralis; clumps of Excoecaria agallocha occur in places where the soil level has been raised. Ceriops tagal and C. decandra (Griff.) Ding Hou are sporadic. Undergrowth is scanty in deep shade, thick in clearings, and consists of Derris heterophylla, Paramignya littoralis Miq., and in the less shady places a dense growth of Acrostichum spp. From this he separated a Bruguiera cylindrica Association and a Xylocarpus-Heritiera Association. These two have much in common, differing only in the dominant species. Both develop in zones A3-A4 and both are intermediate to the landward fringe. Both occur on more or less firm clays ; in both the surface is irregular due to the burrowing activities of crustaceans. These are open forests in which on the one hand B. cylindrica and on the other Xylocarpus granatum and Heritiera littoralis are dominant. With them occur Excoecaria a,gallocha, Xylocarpus moluccensis, Cynometra ramijlora L. and Intsia bijuga. The undergrowth is usually thick, of Derris heterophylla, Acrostichum sp. with Nypa in muddy gullies. I n Australia and Africa forests of B. gymnorhiza extend up to the landward fringe only where there is abundant rain. I n regions of lower rainfallthey are sandwiched between ceriops thickets and the rhizophora forest and occupy the middle of the mangrove area. Bruguiera forests in South East Asia and in Australia frequently
10s
WILLIAM
MACNAE
support a ‘‘herb-layer ” of the fern Acrostichunz speciosunz which tends to be restricted to the mounds cast up by Thalassina anomala (Fig. 5 2 , p. 170) ; the lower lcvels of the soil surface arc bare or colonized by mats of algae, mostly blue-green.
D. Zones of rhixophoraforests I n the popular mind a mangrove swamp is usually visualized as being a forest of species of Rhizophora with arching prop roots making
FIG.21. Forest of Rhizophora upiculuta with trees 30-40 cm in diameter and ca 40 m tall, on a falling tide in the estuary of the Besitang river a t Pangkalan Gusu, Aru Bay, north-eastSumatra. (Photo: C. G. G. J. van Gteenis, April 1937.)
passage difficult, an “antlered ” mangrove (Fig. 21). Such a forest is also in Watson’s (1928) opinion the highest development of a mangal. Three species of Rhixophora occur in the Indo-west-Pacific mangals and they may overlap to some extent. R. mucronata is the commonest and most widespread extending from Malaya to New Guinea, to the Ryii-Kyii Islands and to Africa. R. stylosa occurs from Malaya to
FAUNA AND FLORA O F MANGROVE SWAMPS
101)
l i k . 22. Forest of R. mucronata with trees 30-40 cm in diameter and ca 35 m tall, on a falling title, south of Ranong, peninsular Thailantl (wcst coast). The man is I .80 m tall. (February 1967.)
110
WILLIAM MACRAE
Queensland; R. apiculata from Malaya throughout South East Asia to India and Ceylon and to north Queensland. R. apiculata is more tolerant of fresh water than the others. In Malaya and the northern part of the Indo-Australian archipelago R. stylosa appears to be restricted to shores in the shelter of coral reefs, and those are often sandy. In Australia and southern New Guinea it occurs in the muddy soils which, elsewhere, are colonized by R. mucronata. All may produce tall graceful trees and grow a t several levels from areas flooded at all
FIG.23. Regeneration in a forest of R. apiculata, south of Ranong, trees of R. apiculata up to 40 cm in diameter and 35 m tall. Some of the slender trees me of Ceriops spp. (February1967).
high tides upwards to those which are only flooded occasionally. I n some rhizophora forests undergrowth is rare and then usually of saplings of Rhixophora. I n others, such as the majority of virgin rhizophora forests in South East Asia and the adjoining islands, there is a copious undergrowth of Ceriops tagal, C. decandra, Bruguiera. cylindrica and B. parvi$ora, the first and last being the commonest. All these trees form an understorey reaching some 15-20 m tall in these conditions. As much as two-thirds of the mangal in Sandakan Bay (Sabah, formerly North Borneo) may be occupied by extensive forests of R. apiculata. Along the west coast of peninsular Thailand, just south of the Burma border, some areas are occupied by extensive forests of
FAUNA AND FLORA OF MANGROVE
SWAMPS
111
R. npiculata and others of R. mucronata. Vu van Cuong (1964) reports that R. apiculata is the most important and most abundanttree in the mangals of Cambodia and Viet Nam. I n Queensland and eastern Africa the soil in the rhizophora forests is usually soft. It is aerated by the activities of alpheid prawns when it is semi-fluid and by thalassiiiideanprawns such as species of Upogebia when it is more solid.
FIG.24. Forest of young R. rnucronata, approximately 10 years old growing in an area felled for tannin production in the bay behind Cabo de Bartolomeu Dias (lat. 21"50'S.), Mopmbique. (September 1966.)
A glance a t Watson's sketch plan of the distribution of mangroves in the Malayan mangals will show that in Malaya two types of rhizophora forest occur. This is also true of Thailand, South East Asia and the wetter parts of the Indonesian archipelago. A forest of R. mucronata occurs in areas dominated by sea water, a forest of R. apiculata in areas dominated by fresh water. Hence a forest of R. nzucronata will lie behind a seaward fringe and pass backwards (Fig. 6) and upstream into a forest of R. apiculata. The forest of R. mucronata will run alongside a channel, river or creek where water of salinity around ZO%, or above overflows the banks but will give way t o the other when water with a salinity of less than 15%, floods the forests.
112
WILLIAM MACNAE
E. Beaward nvicenniafringes Along most coasts on which mangroves occur the most seaward zone of trees is made up of a pure stand of one or other of two or three species of Avicennia. There has been a considerable confusion over the identity of several species of Avicennia* and the latest revision by Moldenke (1960), although helpful, does not completely disentangle the confusion. Moldenke presents no evidence that he has seen the trees in the field. Most of the confusion that exists concerns the species which occupy the seaward fringes. Watson (1928) has shown that in Malaya Avicennia alba and A . murina (= A . intermedia)occupy different sectors of this fringe (Fig. 25). After having seen several mangals in Malaya and South East Asia I accept and can confirm Watson’s observations-but there are difficulties! Normally these two species are readily distinguishable-A. albu with pointed leaves and whitish reverse being quite easily separable from A . marina with bluntly tipped leaves and yellowish reverse. However, where they overlap there are intermediates.
* I n the preparationof this review the taxonomy of the genus Avicenniahas presented many difficulties. I n the most recent revision of the genus Moldenke (1960) recognizes six species in the Indo-west-Pacific. These are A . alba Bl., A . balanophoraMoldenke, A. eucalyptifolia Zipp. ex Miq., A . Zanata Ridl., A . marina (Forsk.)Vierh., and A . oficinalis L. Of these A . balanophora need not concern us for it i s recorded only from a few localities in Queensland. Bakhuizen van der Brink (1921) recognized only two species, A . marina and A . offccinalis. (Ridley’s (1920) description of A . Zanata,known only from the mainland of Malaya, would seem to have appeared too late for Bakhuizen’s consideration.) These are in fact the only taxonomic studies on this genus. To both Moldenke and Bakhuizen, A . marinais a polytypic species but to each authorit differs in extent. Both accept that the typical variety is an African and western Indian Ocean form, and that the var. resinijera is south-easternin distribution from New Guinea to New Zealand. Both acccpt the var. rumphiana as representing the species in Malaysian landward fringes. But this variety is clearly difficult. Moldenke recognized one specimen (Watson and Burkill, 3795, 9.viii.l918) both as A . Zanata and as A . marina var. rumphiana. Should these, then, be synonymous? Moldenke considers that Bakhuizen’s var. intermedia Griff. is the typical form of A . marina. I would concur. Bakhuizen considered A . alba to be a, variety of A . marina; Moldenke considers it t o have specific status. The two rarely overlap ecologically, and so behave as good species. Intermediates occur, possibly these are hybrids. Moldenke (1958) has recorded that hybridization may occur in American species. Moldcnke’s A. ezicalyptifolia seems to be restricted t o the highly calcareous beaches of coral shores-either low-wooded-island reefs of the Queensland Great Barrier or coral shores in eastern Indonesia and the Philippines. It may, perhaps, be an ecological variety, an ecotype of A . marina which i t closely resembles. I n this review- I shall accept A. alba, A. lanata, A . marina and A . oficiimlis. A . lanata and A . oficinalis are species characteristic of the landward fringes or of fresh water dominated areas in the mangal. A . aZba and A . marina are characteristicof the seaward fringes but have a wide tolerance (see p. 131). Of these A . marinaispolytypic with both geographical and ccological subspecies or varieties. A . eucalyptifolia seems to me to be an ecotype of A . marina but for the present it may best be left incertaesedis.
FAUNA AND FLORA O F MANGROVE SWAMPS
113
FIG.25. A forest of Avicelznia marina in the seaward fringe a t Quissanga (lat. l2%.), Moqambique. Mud-skippers were common here. (July 1967.)
Ridley (1930) has suggested that A . intermedia was a hybrid between A. nlha and A . oBcinaZis; this must be incorrect. Moldenke (1958) has suggested that hybridization may occur where several species of this genus grow together. With hybridization a feasibility i t is not surprising that confusion has arisen. A . marina.is a very widespread species, the only representative of the genus over most of the Indo-west-Pacific, and as will be shown below has several physiological races. I n Malaya and adjacent areas of South
114
WILLIAM MACNAE
East Asia A . marina (known locally as A . intermedia) occurs on the seaward fringe of a mangal facing the sea rather than a channel, creek or river. On such beaches it is a pioneer. Since these beaches face seaward and are exposed to light wave action the substratum is relatively firm. Behind, this passes into a forest of Bruguiera cylindrica. Along the entrance to channels,etc., A . marina gives way to A . alba and since wave action is less the substratum is very soft. I n the area of overlap individual trees may be difficult to identify as one species or the other. Behind the forest of A . alba, one finds a forest of Rhizophora mucronata. I n India, around Bombay, only A . alba is present and it occupies the entire, or almost the entire, mangal. The trees are kept short by cutting and the young branches fed to water buffalo. I n the absence of A . alba, A. marina occupies the entire seaward fringe. Moldenke (1960) recognizes a third species in this ecological group, Avicennia eucalyptifolia Zipp. ex Miq., and most of the localities from which he records this species are in the vicinity of coral reefs (Fig. 26) or off-shore coral islands from the Philippines to Queensland. On stable coasts the seaward avicennia fringe is very narrow, often only one to three trees deep. On accrescent coasts it may be more than 4 km (4 mile) wide. This is the case on many shores along the Straits of Malacca and parts of Borneo and New Guinea. On such shores seedlings of A. marina or of A . alba colonize the new banks of alluvium, develop into saplings, young trees and finally a well-developed orchard of tall avicennia trees under the shelter of which seedlings of species of Rhizophora develop. The substratum is firmer than the mud banks in front. This firmness is due to the dense mat of nutritive roots lying some 10-35 cm below the surface. Anderson (unpublished data) has shown that in Sarawak the alluvium on which these avicennia trees develop is deficient in organic material which represents only 5-15% of the soil content. On the shore of Trinity Bay near Cairns in north Queensland saplings of Aegiceras corniculaturn occurred with the saplings of Avicennia marina. At this level a considerable quantity of seepage water came out on to the beach, and presumably kept the salinity of the soil water within the range preferred by Aegiceras (Macnae, 1966). The thickets of saplings and seedlings extend down almost to mean sea-level. At the lower levels many seedlings get coated with fine silt, deposited by the tide-these seedlings die. Seedlings and saplings of Avicennia cannot grow well under conditions of shade. Macnae (1963)
FAlTNA AND FLORA OF MANGROVE SWAMPS
115
FIG.26. Avicennia ? m a r i mor A . ?eucalyptifoliaa t Low Isles, Queensland. The appearance of these trees is characteristic of trees growing under the influence of strong winds on the thin soil of coral reefs. (From a colour transparency, March 1962.)
has pointed out that avicennia seedlings die under the shade of their parent and also that even old trees die when they are overtopped by the rhizophora or bruguiera trees, for the development of which they have acted as shading nurses. Sa,plingsmay also be strangled by colonization of barnacles if these are abundantlocally. Sapling development of this type would appear t o influence deposition-the substratumbetween the saplings is very soft. This zone corresponds to the base of Watson’s class (ii) and upper portion of his class (i).
F. Sonneratia zone I n South East Asia Sonneratia griflthii and/or AS.alba, in Africa and Australia S. alba alone and in India from Bombay t o Burma S. apetala
116
WILLIAM MACNAE
FIG.27. Sonneratia alba a t Quissanga (lat. 12"S.),Moqarnbique,growing in a sheltered bay which is very quiet and with little or no freshwater influence. (July 1967.)
may grow t o seaward of the avicennia fringe. These trees grow a t such a level that some of them are wetted daily. They lie below the level of high water of the lowest neaps. I n many places where this zone occurs, but not in all, saplings may grow beyond and push the outer edge further seaward. to be found growing Hardly ever are Sonneratia alba and S. grifithii
FIG.28. t3onneratia alba in the Bako National Park, Sarawak; elderly trees under quite strongwave action a t high tide; there is very little regenerationhere. (January1967.)
FAUNA AND FLORA O F MANGROVE SWAMPS
117
together. But what determines which will occur is difficult to say. In bays protected from the prevailing winds, but not necessarily from other winds, pure stands of Sonneratia develop. Often these show no regeneration at all, nor any conspicuous fauna (Figs. 27 and 28). Along river banks and in other areas where the salinity is reduced by abundant fresh water, S. caseolaris is dominant. This species also occurs alongside creeks a t the back of the mangal. De Haan recognizes a t Tjilatjap an avicennia-sonneratia alba association which develops in zone Al, on soils which are mostly level, soft and deep. These are young unconsolidated soils. The tree layer comprises Avicenniu marina and Sonneratia alba with an undergrowth of Acanthus ilicifolius and of saplings of Aegiceras corniculatum. This association is compounded of my sonneratiazone and seaward avicennia zone. Muller and Hou-Liu (1966) have described suspected hybrids between 8. alba and 8. caseolaris and between X. alba and X. ovata. These were found in the mangals of Brunei. Sonneratia would appear to prefer warmer conditions than do most of the others-it does not come south of Inhambane on the Moqambique coast nor south of Innisfail in Queensland. This zone corresponds to Watson’s class (i). 1. Bostrychietum
The pneumatophores of Avicennia, and of Sonneratia, the prop roots of Rhizophora and the knee roots of Bruguiera gymnorhiza may locally
be densely covered with a bostrychietum which is an association of algae comprising several species of the genera Rostrychia, Caloglossa, Catenella and of Murrayella. For the identity of these see Post (1963, 1964a,b, 1966), where one will find detailed descriptions and distributions of the various species. Many of these appear to be widespread in the Indo-west-Pacific, not only from Africa to Australia and Japan,but also from the cool waters of southern Africa and Victoria to the tropics. A problem associated with this association is its relatively localized distribution within the seaward fringe of a mangal. The roots of one group of trees will be thickly clothed with algae and neighbouringtrees will be bare of them. Does their presence interfere with the proper functioning of the roots, and do the roots, in due course, cast off the bark invested by the algae? The presence of this association on the roots of the mangroves allows comparisons with rocky shores, for this association occurs too on the shaded side of, and under, overhanging portions of the rocks, just a t or just above or just below the level colonized by rock oysters.
118
WILLIAM
MACNAE
G. Variations Variation in development of these zones is t o be expected, yet in each and every mangal visited by the author they are recognizable. The succession is only complete when there is an excess of available fresh water over loss by evaporation and transpiration. Fresh water may be supplied to a mangal from two sources : either it falls as rain or it is kirought down into the area by rivers flowing from an area with a higher rainfall. I n the deltas of both the Rufiji and Zambezi rivers the rainfall is insufficient to account for the dense and well-developed mangrove forests. Over much of these areas the rainfall is around 750 mm and seasonal, but the rivers bring down enough water to influence the water table and give enough to enable proper development of the trees and allow of a complete succession and zonation. When evaporation and transpiration exceed the available fresh water t o the extent that the soil water becomes hypersaline, the zonation becomes interrupted. This interruption appears first in the ceriops zone (Fig. 16, p. 104). Towards the centre of this zone the bushes become stunted, rarely growing above waist height. They die off and recolonization does not follow. With increasing excess of evaporation this bare area expands both t o landward and to seaward. A few ceriops bushes grow alongside the trees in the landward avicennia fringe and a few occur just above the level of the bruguiera forest, narrowed in its turn to an insignificant remnant behind the line of Rhizophora mucronata or R. stylosa along the edges of creeks. This may be seen in Figs. 8, 11 and 16 which represent mangroves in localities differing from one another only in rainfall and in excess of evaporation and transpiration. When the substratum is composed of a well-drained sand rather than a mud, and no silt is availabIe for conversion into mud the entire facies may change. Three mangals of bhis sort are known to me ; one is a t Kosi Bay on the Natal-Mopambique border, anothera t Inhambane some 400 km t o the north a t latitude 23"s. (Fig. 14), and the third within the Bako National Park a t the entrance to the delta of the Sarawak river in Borneo. The streams draining into these areas come from hinterlands which are to a large extent uncultivated with porous sandy soils of recent origin, soils which seem to require much supplementing to grow crops successfully. No silt, then, enters the bays. At Kosi Bay Lumnitxera racemosa has become dominant in the entire mangal behind a seaward fringe of Avicennia m r i n a . Rhizophoraceous mangroves play a minor role alongside creeks where Rhixophora mucronata and Bruguiera gymnorhiza grow on soils enriched
119
FAUNA AND FLORA O F MANGROVE SWAMPS
by decaying mats of phragmites and other grasses which grow on the moist soil behind. At Inhambaneextensive sandbanks are exposed a t times of low tide and almost the entire area capable of colonization by mangroves is occupied by dwarf bushes, mostly close to or just above waist height. Among these Avicennia marina is dominant and bushes of Xonneratia ulba and Ceriops tugal are scarce (Fig. 14). Only upstream in the small rivers where beds of Phragmites and T y p h u provide a mass of decaying leafage do the mangroves reach tree height, and in these stretches they form a river bank fringe t o a narrow forest of Heritiera littoralis and this may be backed by a belt of Acrostichum aureum which in turn gives way to a sward of Xporobolus virginicus and samphires or saltworts, Xalicornia pachystachya Ung.-Sternb., Arthrocnemum indicum and A . natalense (Bunge ex Ung.-Sternb.) Moss in Adamson. As one proceeds farther upstream a barringtonia racemosa association follows.
FIG.29. Distribution of mangroves at Low Isles, Queensland. Here Rhizophora stylosa grows in an area permanently submerged and named the "Mangrove Park "by Stephenson et al. (1931). The map was prepared from that given by Stephenson et al. with emendations from that given by Fairbridge and Teichert (1947). (From Macnae, 1966.) A.X.B.-G
6
120
WILLIAM MACNAE
At the Bako National Park the mangal in the small estuary of the Sungei Lakei besar, a stream which drains virgin forest on a Tertiary sandstone, had also developed .in sand and showed a similar pattern of those mangroves which prefer well-drained soils ; these included Xonneratia alba, Rhizophora apiculata, Ceriops tagal, Excoecaria agallocha and Osbornia octodonta F.v.M. mostly in mixed stands with little tendency to zonation. The mangrove forests associated with the low-wooded-island reefs of the Great Barrier Reef system also depart from the norm. At Low Isles (Big. 29), while the upper part of the mangrove zonation is almost normal, the seaward fringe is peculiar (T. A. Stephenson et al., 1931; W. Stephenson et al., 1958; Macnae, 1966). The landward fringe is very narrow but contains trees such as Osbornia octodonta, Pemphis acidula L., Excoecaria agallocha, Avicennia marina, Aegialitis annulata R. Br. and others. The seaward fringe extends below the level of the water table-if not below mean sea-level-and in a shallow lagoon some 20 cm deep a t low water of springs one finds well-grown trees of R. stylosa forming what Stephenson et al. (1931) termed the "Mangrove Park "(Big. 30). It is quite surprisingin such a locality to see the prop
FIG. 30. Rhizopho~astylosa a t Low Isles, Queensland, a clump of trees in the "mangrove
park ". These trces grow a t a lower level than usual and are always immersed in water; Hippopus and giant anemones grow among the prop roots. (Froma colour transparency,March 1962.)
FAUNA AND FLORA O F MANGROVE SWAMPS
121
roots of Rhizophora associated with the animals characteristic of the midlittoral flats and pools. The trees in this "Mangrove Park )'may go for weeks on end without the surface of the soil drying out. On the seaward side the pioneer is Aegialitis annulata which elsewhere in Queenslandgrows as a sprawling shrub in the landward fringe.
H. Mangrove soils Mangroves live in a habitat characterized by a high salt content and a high water content. The soils have a low oxygen content and abundant hydrogen sulphide. They are fine grained soils, often semi-fluid and ill consolidated, and in parts with abundanthumus-mangrove peat, a fibrous soil composed largely of the remains of roots and other woody structures. Anderson (unpublished information) has sampled the soils in two transects across the mangal from the seaward fringe into the peat forest in Sarawak. The locality is on the Maludam-Triso peninsula, a belt of almost featureless forest lying between the estuaries of the Batang Lupar and the B. Saribas in central Sarawak. The soils here within the mangal are greenish-grey silty clays of apparently marine or estuarine origin. Soluble salts seem to be leached out by rain water and replaced by the tides. At higher levels in the mangal the clays are mined and mixed thoroughly by the mud lobster, Thalassina anornula,and thrown into mounds reaching 3 m high. I n the nypa zones of the mangal these clays come to be covered by peat soils. There is a marked and abrupt change in conductivity (a measure related to salinity), in pH and in loss of weight on ignition a t the interphase where the zone dominated by mangrove trees passes over to the zone dominated by Nypa. The estuarine or marine clays of the seaward avicennia fringe have an average conductivity of between 5 000 and 8 000 p mhos, a pH of more than 7 , and a loss of weight on ignition of between 5 and 15%. Similar figures prevail through the rhizophora forests. On the other hand, the muck soils of the nypa zone show a low conductivity, 0-1 000 p mhos hence a low salinity, a p H falling gradually to the acid Ievel of peat forests and a loss of weight on ignition of up t o 80 and 90%. I n the peat forest soils this loss of weight is more than 95%. The mangrove soils are young soils for the most part, and have been well sorted before deposition. The silt brought in from the sea by the rising tide will containshells of foraminiferansand debris from molluscan and other shells. This calcareous material, together with the brokendown shells of molluscs which live within the mangrove and its mud, forms a most important constituent of mangrove mud, and of other intertidal muds. Much of the calcareous material of molluscan shells is
122
WILLIAM MACNAE
made available to other organisms by the action of sulphur bacteria which, in the anoxic muds, corrode the sulphur-containingconchiolin of the shells. I n this way the shells become more fragile and the water has access t o the crystals of calcium carbonate so raising the alkalinity of the soil. The quality of the soil in mangrove swamps depends ultimately on the source of its alluvium. Rivers draining quartzitic areas carry an alluvium of poor quality. Rivers draining ancient granitic areas also carry silt of poor quality. Rivers drainingareas of recent or moderately recent volcanic soils produce an alluvium of high quality. The effects of soil quality are evident, for example, in Java and in Queensland. I n Java the Braiitas river draws its water from the volcanic mountains of East Java and produces a highly productive alluvium (Schuster, 1952); in Queensland the Barron and Johnstone rivers come from areas with abundant Tertiary volcanics, and on their flood plains is produced much of Queensland’ssugar and their estuaries support high and dense mangroves. I n contrast the marl and limestone areas of the island of Madura off north-east Java yield poor alluvium (Schuster, 1952); this is true, too, of many of the rivers of Africa, a continent of old leachedout soils, and also the quartzites of much of coastal Queensland,which support the scrub forest known as Wallum (Coaldrake, 1961), and produce poor soils and low mangroves. Nutrients are scarce in such soils. But such sources cannot entirely account for the rapid deposition of soils in certain areas. I n an area such as the Straits of Malacca silt and alluvium may be derived from two sources. They may have an origin in the erosive activity of the rivers of Sumatra and of Malaya. But also some silt and alluvium may be derived from now submarine sediments which had been laid down on river flood plains during the Pleistocene and are now being eroded from narrow submarinegullies by tidal currents. The fertility of this “fossil ”alluvium will depend on its history and origins before being deposited. Alluvium deposited in an estuary or mangrove area is not of itself productive. Macnae (1957) has commented that on the banks of the Gaintoos estuary some 60 miles west of Port Elizabeth the intertidal muds are barren since they have been deposited too recently. Schuster (1952) has shown that biological processes are necessary before the alluvium can be utilized by higher plants. These processes involve a number of organisms, bacteria, blue-green algae, diatoms and green algae. Important amongst these are nitrifying bacteria and sulphate reducing bacteria. Schuster (1952) lists several species of algae, which he argues are important food for prawns and fish (Chanoschanos (Forsk.)
FAUNA AND FLORA OF MANGROVE SWAMPS
123
and Tilapia mossambica Peters) in fish ponds developed in mangrove areas. The blue-green and green algae seem t o show substratum preferences and the former may convert a soil into a suitable habitat for the latter. The blue-greens prefer a soft, hydrophilic, biologically active mud with much organic matter, whereas green algae prefer a more or less solid soil with an adequate supply of nitrate and phosphate. These inorganic radicles may have been released by the oxidative action of blue-green algae and bacteria on humus in the soil, converting ammonia to nitrate, and releasing bound phosphate. The faeces of the animals living in the mangal are an important constituent of the surface layers of the soil and must constitute a source of nitrate, phosphate and other substances for the photosynthetic micro-organisms of the soil. Only in the upper layers is the soil well oxygenated. Sulphatereducing bacteria flourish in anoxic conditions and are completely anaerobic. They obtain the sulphate from the soil water or from organic sulphur-containingdebris. The presence of hydrogen sulphide reduces the ferric compounds in the soil t o various hydrated ferrous sulphides which give mangrove soils their characteristic black colour. Only the surface layers to a depth of a few centimetres are oxygenated and show amounts decreasing with depth. Tube dwelling thalassinidean prawns, such as species of Upogebia and Thnlassina, by their activities of fanning a current of water through their burrow systems oxygenate the soils immediately surrounding the burrow. Alplieid prawns create mazes of shallow burrows in water-logged soil and help in keeping the upper layers oxygenated and so assist the bacteria, and other organisms, in making available the ions required by higher plants. It would seem, too, that the presence of shell or other calcareous debris in the soil is essential for the proper development of mangroves, particularly in areas of higher salinity. It is noteworthy that in citrus orchards on the Sundays River Valley (near Port Elizabeth, South Africa) where, perforce, the orchards are often irrigated with brackish water derived from Cretaceous marine shales, a generous dressing of lime prevents the scorching of the leaves on the trees. The presence of calcium ions seems to reduce or prevent any damage which may be done by excess of sodium ions, because calcium reduces the level of internal sodium. When the mangal has been cleared by cutting out the timber, what happens to the mangrove soils? Why do recently cleared areas often become a desert, useful only for salt production? Such areas may be seen along the shores of the Gulf of Thailand both west and east of Bangkok. When cleared areas have been used for prawn and fish
124
WILLIAM MACNAE
cultivation in ponds, can they revert to mangrove forests when the ponds are neglected? So far as I am aware no one has studied the processes of degradation of mangrove forest soils. But one wonders if oxidation of peats with consequent loss of fertility may account for the bare areas so characteristic of the mangals in regions with low or seasonal rainfall.
I. Control of zonation While a zonation is normally found in a mangal colonized by more than one species of tree, the form of zonation described above is not inevitable, though it covers most of the associations which may be found intertidally on the upper shore within the tropics around the Indian Ocean. Macnae (1966) ascribed control of the distribution of mangrove trees and hence their zonation to the interaction of: ( 1 ) frequency of tidal flooding; (2) salinity of soil water; and (3) waterlogging of the soil. All of these are modified by the presence of creeks, gullies, rivers and channels; and the second and third will depend on : (i) rainfall and/or the supply of fresh water; (ii) evaporation and transpiration, and (iii) the nature and quality of the soil. 1. Frequency of tidal Jlooding It is clear that the zones of trees are associated, in the first instance, with rising ground level and the resulting falling off in frequency of tidal flooding. This formed the basis for Watson’s (1928) inundation classes and for de Haan’s (1931) zones. A comparison in tabular form is given in Table I. De Haan took into account in his scheme the effect of fresh water, and so his scheme has a slightly wider coverage than does that suggested by Watson. These zones based on physical features alone are not universally applicable but apply only in regions where the mangal covers the whole of its potential area of development. I n Table I these have been printed in such a way that equivalent zones are on the same line. The zones will vary in width with the nature of the slope of the shore; and with the range of the tide. I n Ceylon where the tidal range has a maximum of 7 5 cm the mangrove zones are telescoped very strongly, and during the wet monsoon the tide may give the appearance of never going out a t all so that the lower, more seaward zones are continuously under water for weeks on end and even the higher zones are flooded more frequently than usual. Where the tidal range is great, and the slope of shore gentle, mangroves may be very extensive and some miles deep; as, for example, at Port Swettenham and several localities in Sumatra, where the tidal range approaches 5 m.
TABLEI. ZONATION
WITHIN
A
MANGAL
De Haan (1931)
Watson (1928)
Brackish t o salt water-salinity at high tide 10-30%, A l . Areas flooded once or twice daily on each of 20 days per month
Dominant plant and system used in this paper
A.
1. On land flooded at all high tides
2 . Areas flooded by ‘‘medium high tides
”
A2. Areas flooded 10-19 times per month 3. Areas flooded by normal high tides A3. Areas flooded 9 times per month
4. Areas flooded by spring tides only 5. Areas flooded by exceptional high tides
A4. Areas flooded on only a few days in each month B. Fresh to brackish water-salinity O-lO%, B1. Areas more or less under the influence of the tide B2. Areas seasonally flooded either by fresh or brackish water
Seaward fringe of Xonneratia alba, or apetala or grifithii Zone of Avicennia marina Zone of rhizophora forest
kU
Zone of bruguiera forests Forests of the landward fringe Xylocarpus granatum or Lumnitzera littorea or Bruguiera sexangula or Mamphire association or Barringtoniaassociation
0
r F P
r
Es
0
Nypa associat,ion
‘(Medium high tides ” seem to be those which enter the lower levels of the mangal, but they do not penetrate far.
‘‘Normal high tides ” seem to be those which enter far into the mangal of the Malayan forests but do not reach H.W.M.O.S.T.
F 3.t 01
126
WILLIAM MACNAE
The shore profile may also affect the manner of deposition of silt, etc., carried in suspension by the tide, and so control the distribution of animals and plants. All shores of sand or mud show a tendency t o flatten out a t one or more intertidal levels. I n regions with a large intertidal range there is usually a succession of flats a t different levels. This phenomenon has been shown by Macnae and Kalk (1962) t o influence the apparent distribution of plants and animals across the flats a t Inhaca, off Lourenqo Marques, and Macnae (1966) (Fig. 31) has shown an extreme example a t and near St. Lawrence in the Broad Sound region of central Queensland. I n many mangrove-bearing coasts visited by the author the same peculiarity is evident. On coasts where material is accruing one normally will find a continuity of slope downwards from the landward fringe to the seaward edge of the mangal. But on others there seems to have been an alternation of periods of accretion and periods of erosion. This naturally gives rise to a differentiation in levels. I n such areas, as for example on the northernshores of Pulau Ketani off Port Swettenham, this will result in a bruguiera forest coming up against a fringe of Sonneratia colonizing a new lower level (Fig. 32). Such an easy explanation is not always offered. I n SandakanBay, north Borneo, as much as three-quartersof the mangal is occupied by a forest dominated by Rhizophora apiculata. Only a narrow zone dominated by Bruguiera parvi$ora with Ceriops tagal and Xylocarpus granatum and with a few scattered bushes of N y p a fruticans and fewer trees of Heritiera littoralis intervenes between the rhizophora forest and the local facies of rain forests growing on sloping ground. This pattern is also shown within the mangals along the western coast of peninsular Thailand between Ranong and Phangnga. Here Ceriops tagal and C . decandra are more abundant in the understorey than is Rruguiern parvi$ora. I n these areas the shore has tended to flatten out a t the level of the rhizophora forests and here only, for the landward fringe and the seaward fringes are quite narrow. I n the estuary of the Lubok river west and slightly north of Sandakan Bay and in other places in Borneo extensive nypa swamps occur in addition to, and following directly on, the rhizophora forests (Figs. 9 and 10). Here, then, the apparent flattening of the shore has extended into a zone under more marked freshwater domination. Along much of the west coast of Malaya the widest zones in the mangal are the zones of bruguieraforests which are separated from the sea by avicennia or sonneratia fringes.
-Halosere
Grassland
St Lawrence, Queensland Rainfoll 1000 rnrn
FIG.31. Diagram to show the pattern of distribution of mangroves at St. Lawrence, Queensland. The tidal range exceeds 8 m and the intertidal region shows several zones of flattening. A very extensive grass-covered plain lies approximately 75 em above extreme high water mark. This is separated by a salting cliff of some 40 cm from a halosere which is covered only by very high tides and this in turn by a n interrupted mangrove forest with trees up to 15-17 m tall. (From Rlacnae, 1966.)
1
Bruguiera etc.
Rhizoohora
FIG.32. Diagram of a transect to show erosion and subsequent regeneration. This is based on a shore north of the township on the island of Pulau Ketam off Port Swettenham in Malaya. It is drawn from air photographs and observations made on the ground. The distribution of animals is similar to that shown in Figs. 17 and 18 apart from the presence of xanthid crabs in the crevices of the ‘‘salting cliff” and the presence of the crab Mucrophthalmus erato occupying a hollowed out and decayed mangrove root (X).
FATJNA AND FLORA O F MANGROVE SWAMPS
129
Each of these levels tends to have its own peculiarities of soil consistency, mineral content and hence of fauna and flora. Exactly why beaches level off in this way has not been fully explained : it must be a function of tidal velocity and of material in suspension. By general consent (Spooner and Moore, 1940; Emery et al., 1957 ; Guilcher, 1963) tidal currents in estuaries and off-shore channels are strongest, when, a t low tide, they are confined within the channels. Although the rate of rise and fall of the tide is highest when it is crossing the flats, the fact that it is crossing these flats causes a slowing down of the current and allows deposition here