$QFLHQW1DUUDWLYH 6XSSOHPHQWXP
$1&,(171$55$7,9(
(GLWRULDO%RDUG 0DDLNH=LPPHUPDQ8QLYHUVLW\RI*URQLQJHQ *DUHWK6FKPHOLQJ8QLYHUVLW\RI)ORULGD*DLQHVYLOOH +HLQ]+RIPDQQ8QLYHUVLWlW7ELQJHQ 6WHSKHQ+DUULVRQ&RUSXV&KULVWL&ROOHJH2[IRUG &RVWDV3DQD\RWDNLVUHYLHZHGLWRU 8QLYHUVLW\RI*ODVJRZ $GYLVRU\%RDUG -HDQ$OYDUHV0RQWFODLU6WDWH8QLYHUVLW\ (ZHQ%RZLH&RUSXV&KULVWL&ROOHJH2[IRUG -DQ%UHPPHU8QLYHUVLW\RI*URQLQJHQ .HQ'RZGHQ8QLYHUVLW\RI%LUPLQJKDP %HQ+LMPDQV(PHULWXVRI&ODVVLFV8QLYHUVLW\RI*URQLQJHQ 5RQDOG+RFN8QLYHUVLW\RI6RXWKHUQ&DOLIRUQLD/RV$QJHOHV 1LNODV+RO]EHUJ8QLYHUVLWl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
$QFLHQW1DUUDWLYH 6XSSOHPHQWXP 6SDFHLQWKH$QFLHQW1RYHO HGLWHGE\
0LFKDHO3DVFKDOLV 6WDYURV)UDQJRXOLGLV
% $ 5 . + 8 , 6 3 8 % / , 6 + , 1 * 7+(81,9(56,7</,%5$ 5<*521,1*(1 * 5 2 1 , 1 * ( 1
*UDSKLFDOGHVLJQ%DUNKXLV3XEOLVKLQJ 3ULQWHGE\'UXNNHULM*LHWKRRUQWHQ%ULQN 7KLVERRNZDVSULQWHGZLWKILQDQFLDOVXSSRUWIURP ,:,²,QQRYDWLH:HWHQVFKDSSHOLMNH,QIRUPDWLHYRRU]LHQLQJ ,661 ,6%1
Table of contents List of illustrations Preface D AVID K ONSTAN Narrative Spaces
VII IX
1
C ATHERINE C ONNORS Chariton’s Syracuse and its histories of empire
12
M ARTIN M. W INKLER Chronotope and locus amoenus in Daphnis and Chloe and Pleasantville
27
S TEPHEN J. H ARRISON Literary Topography in Apuleius’ Metamorphoses
40
L UCA G RAVERINI Corinth, Rome, and Africa: a Cultural Background for the Tale of the Ass
58
M AAIKE Z IMMERMAN On the Road in Apuleius’ Metamorphoses
78
S TELIOS P ANAYOTAKIS The Temple and the Brothel: Mothers and Daughters in Apollonius of Tyre
98
J UDITH P ERKINS Social Geography in the Apocryphal Acts of the Apostles
118
M ICHAEL P ASCHALIS Reading Space: A Re-examination of Apuleian ekphrasis
132
VI
TABLE OF CONTENTS
RICHARD P. M ARTIN A Good Place to Talk: Discourse and Topos in Achilles Tatius and Philostratus
143
N IALL W. S LATER Space and Displacement in Apuleius
161
S TAVROS F RANGOULIDIS The Laughter Festival as a Community Integration Rite in Apuleius’ Metamorphoses
177
Indices
189
Index locorum
189
General index
190
List of illustrations Fig. 1 Girolamo di Benvenuto, The choice of Hercules (Panofsky 1930, fig. 53) 93 Fig. 2 Niccolò Soggi (?), The choice of Hercules (Panofsky 1930, fig. 52)
94
Preface This special issue of Ancient Narrative Supplementum 1, entitled ‘Space in the Ancient Novel’, brings together a collection of revised papers, originally presented at the International conference under the same title organized by the Department of Philology (Division of Classics) of the University of Crete and held in Rethymnon, on May 14–15, 2001. This conference inaugurated what is hoped to become a new series of biennial International meetings on the Ancient Novel (RICAN, Rethymnon International Conferences on the Ancient Novel) which aspires to continue the reputable tradition of the Groningen Colloquia on the Novel, established by Heinz Hofmann and Maaike Zimmerman. Ancient Narrative Supplementum 1 includes two additional contributions by Catherine Connors and Judith Perkins, both originally presented in ICAN 2000 at Groningen in July 25–30, 2000 and included here in revised form, and an article by Stelios Panayotakis, which closely relates to the theme of the Rethymnon conference. The first contribution by David Konstan, ‘Narrative Spaces’, illuminates the concept of independent action spaces in Greek and Latin novels. The novels by Xenophon of Ephesus, Chariton and Longus, exhibit a pervasive doubling of action space as the narrative focuses alternatively on the activities that occur simultaneously in two or more unrelated arenas. The shift of focus from one action space to another is accomplished by the simple antithesis men and de, or by the simple transition de. This model of multiple action spaces, which is atypical of both drama and epic (with certain exceptions), possibly derives from historiography, where writers often shifted their focus abruptly from the military activities of one side to those of the other in accounts of war. By contrast, the Latin novels and that of Achilles Tatius as first-person narratives make use of the device of simple action space. In these novels the narrator, who is also a character in the story, follows the trail of the main characters from one place to another, like a camera tracking an actor. This technique has its model in the first-person narrative of Homer’s Odyssey.
X
PREFACE
Catherine Connors, in her ‘Chariton’s Syracuse and its histories of empire’, advances an allegorical reading of Chariton’s Callirhoe, as she examines the possible implications of its historical setting. The child of Chaereas and Callirhoe, foretold to be the next king of Syracuse, corresponds to the historical Dionysius I, tyrant of Syracuse. Dionysius’ childhood in Ionia and the links of his ‘foster-father’ Dionysius to the Persian king may explain both his name and his tyrannical non-democratic rule. The robber Theron who abducts Callirhoe and initiates her adventures could be associated with Julius Caesar and his starting of civil war, while Chariton’s fictional refashioning of Syracuse under Dionysius I may correspond historically to Augustus’ newly refurbished walls and buildings of Syracuse that mark the end of civil strife. This allegorical reading of the novel’s erotic history as an allusive response to Roman as well as Greek history is reinforced by Chariton’s link to Aphrodisias, a city with a special relationship to Roman emperors. Martin Winkler’s article, entitled ‘Chronotope and locus amoenus in Daphnis and Chloe and Pleasantville’, takes its point of departure from Mikhail Bakhtin’s essay ‘Forms of Time and the Chronotope in the Novel’. The author juxtaposes Longus’ novel with a modern visual text, the 1998 film Pleasantville, written and directed by Gary Ross. Despite the differences of time and space between Daphnis and Chloe and Pleasantville and those of their respective chronotopes, and despite the differences between an ancient and a modern medium, there are noticeable similarities of story and of narrative stance in both works. Their very settings, respectively the pastoral landscape of Lesbos in the Greek novel and the eponymous town and its natural surroundings in Pleasantville, exhibit parallel aspects of the locus amoenus archetype. Two other articles shed new light on interrelated issues of space, literary topography and geographical inspecificity in Apuleius’ Metamorphoses. Stephen J. Harrison’s ‘Literary Topography in Apuleius’ Metamorphoses’ treats two key aspects of Apuleius’ literary topography: (a) the way in which several geographical locations reflect significant literary sources; and (b) the way in which some place-names and their associations point to important ideas and themes in the novel. Harrison’s definition of topography, therefore, becomes an integral part of the work’s literary program. These topographical allusions, which primarily appear in inserted tales, not only reveal familiarity with the elevated genres (epic, tragic) and events (epic battles of Greek and Roman history) but also make clear their parodic and ironic function when
PREFACE
XI
they reappear in the less elevated genre of the Roman novel. The article by Luca Graverini, entitled ‘Corinth, Rome, and Africa: a Cultural Background for the Tale of the Ass’, discusses geographical inspecificity in the novel, in contrast to the pseudo-Lucianic Onos in which the readers are able to follow the main character’s travels with a certain degree of precision. Graverini accepts the traditional interpretation of the novel’s ‘Romanocentric’ readership, which accounts for the geographical inspecificity in the work (the geographical details of Greece would presumably be of little interest to Apuleius’ Roman readers). He explains, however, geographical inspecificity in the novel also as a result of Apuleius’ literary choice to have Lucius come from Corinth and not from Patrai, as it happens in the pseudo-Lucianic Onos, and to place there his restoration to human form. In Apuleius’ time Corinth was a perennial though ambivalent symbol of the relationship between Greece and Rome. The author further proposes the possibility of ‘provincial’ interpretations for parts of the novel and the need for a more nuanced understanding of the notions of Romanization and Hellenization in the work. Hitherto unobserved aspects of metaphor, intertextuality, space symbolism and social geography in the novel are the focus of three contributions by Maaike Zimmerman, ‘On the Road in Apuleius’ Metamorphoses’, Stelios Panayotakis, ‘The Temple and the Brothel: Mothers and Daughters in Apollonius of Tyre’, and Judith Perkins, ‘Social Geography in the Apocryphal Acts of the Apostles’. Maaike Zimmerman’s contribution discusses the varied ways in which the protagonist/narrator describes road conditions in Apuleius’ Metamorphoses, in an attempt to explore their meaningful function. Often these descriptions turn out to be projections of the emotional situation of characters. In the novel’s later part, however, there are moral connotations attached to road descriptions: the slippery road in which Lucius travels with the priests of the Dea Syria may be taken as direct allusion to the deceitfulness of the priests; while the flat and easy road which leads to Corinth may be suggestive of the easy and flat road which in Christian thought becomes equivalent to the road of sin, which had already appeared in the parable of Prodicus as the road of Vice and thus as opposite to the steep and arduous road of Virtue. The article by Stelios Panayotakis examines the function of two specific places in Apollonius, the temple of Diana in Ephesus and the brothel of Priapus in Mytilene, as separate accommodations respectively for Apollonius’
XII
PREFACE
wife and her daughter Tharsia. The temple and the brothel, which are traditionally regarded as places standing for purity against pollution, in Apollonius accommodate female virginity and chastity. Panayotakis discusses aspects of motherhood in this novel and suggests that the spiritual interpretation of motherhood is significant in the light of the possible Christian background of the author of Apollonius, who may have been influenced by contemporary discussions on motherhood and virginity as these are exemplified in the person of the Virgin Mary. The third contribution by Judith Perkins suggests that the narrative of the Apocryphal Acts of the Apostles displays a project to reconstitute contemporary power relations through narrative recoding of some of the spatial categories of their culture. The Apocryphal Acts, by emphasizing how easy it is to penetrate and/or escape from both female quarters and prisons, works to resist the authority of contemporary social arrangements. In stressing boundary crossing/violation Christians metaphorically manifest their intent to ‘break out’ of the order of things and challenge the spatial bases of social boundaries. Michael Paschalis’ ‘Reading Space: A Re-examination of Apuleian ekphrasis’ and Richard P. Martin’s ‘A Good Place to Talk: Discourse and Topos in Achilles Tatius and Philostratus’ focus on the ekphrasis and descriptions of landscape in the novel. Paschalis sets the theoretical parameters of reading sophistic ekphrasis of works of art in the ancient novel. A sophistic ekphrasis differs considerably from classical ekphrasis as we know it from Homer, Hellenistic poetry, Catullus and Virgil. In the sophistic ekphraseis found in the ancient Greek novel, description (‘bodies in space’) takes precedence over narrative (‘actions in time’). Now describing becomes primarily a question of reading space. The person who describes is a professional expected to identify what is represented in a picture or sculpture, in order to be able to tell what is not represented or what is represented differently or what the meaning of the representation is. In sophistic ekphrasis and its antecedents, narrative is assigned the role either of a comment on, and interpretation of, the piece described, or of a discursive exposition on a work of art. These theoretical considerations then become a suitable hermeneutical tool both for reading Apuleian ekphrasis in general. The article examines in detail the description of Diana and Actaeon in 2.4 and briefly the pantomime performance on the judgment of Paris in 10.10–32. The contribution by Richard Martin examines the narrative techniques through which the varied descriptions of landscape in Book 1 of Achilles Tatius’ Leukippe and Kleito-
PREFACE
XIII
phon are deployed with emphasis on the contrasts in ‘speaker’ and ‘plot’ spaces. The rhetoric of place as it relates to narrative makes explicit a deeply felt link between nature and culture. The author further traces the literary heritage and Second sophistic connections of several motifs and especially of the narrator as a gardener figure. Passages from Plato’s Phaedrus, Longus’ Daphnis and Chloe, and Philostratus’ Heroikos are adduced to show that in using the locus amoenus as a place of talk Achilles Tatius stylizes traditional literary and religious conventions: beautiful places are good for talk because divine events have happened within such places and are traditionally localized there. Central to Martin’s thesis is the idea that the Greek novel is more like the aboriginal Australian narratives, in which the entire landscape is organized and understood by its inhabitants in terms of stories from the Dreamtime associated with every natural feature, and less like the so-called ‘novel’ which takes place in New York, London, Berlin or other centers of production. Two related but contrasting aspects of the theme of space, i.e. displacement and integration, in Apuleius’ The Golden Ass are the focus of contributions by Niall W. Slater, ‘Space and Displacement in Apuleius’, and Stavros Frangoulidis, ‘The Laughter Festival as a Community Integration Rite in Apuleius’ Metamorphoses’. Slater presents a detailed examination of Apuleius’ disorienting use of space, first in the novel’s prologue and then in the tales of Aristomenes, Thelyphron and in the narrative of Lucius’ adventures. Lucius is a ‘displaced person’, like Aristomenes, Socrates, Thelyphron and Psyche. This pattern of constant movement through space and persistent displacement contributes substantially to the debate over the novel’s ending and meaning: the primary character Lucius does not return home, as happens in the cyclic pattern of the Greek novels where the hero and heroine ultimately reach home after their series of adventures, but is in a process of continuous motion, never reaching a goal. On the other hand, Stavros Frangoulidis argues against the communis opinio of the Laughter Festival as a scapegoat ritual and suggests instead that the narrative of Met. 3.1–12 represents a kind of integration rite that is enacted in the theatre. In this public space, Lucius and all other participants engage in the performance of ritual roles, the outcome of which leads not to his expulsion from the Hypatan community, but rather to a proposal for integration into it. That being said, there is a major difference between Lucius and all other participants in the festival: the former acts unwittingly, while the latter are conscious of their
XIV
PREFACE
roles. The author further suggests that we contrast Lucius’ rejection of the offer of integration into the Hypatan community and their god of Laughter with the hero’s later acceptance of the offer of integration into the community of Isis. Thanks are due to a number of individuals for their contribution to the organization of the Rethymnon conference and the publication of this volume of proceedings: to all invited speakers, panel chairs and guests; to colleagues and friends in the Department of Philology, and especially to Athena Kavoulaki and Lizianna Delveroudi; to George Motakis, for placing his computer expertise at our disposal; and to Stavros Frangioudakis, Stavros Petropoulos and Manolis Skoundakis, undergraduate students, for their assistance. Special thanks are also due to the administration of the University of Crete, the Rector, Christos Nikolaou, and the Vice Rector, the late Angelos Kranidis, for their generous support that enabled us to cover the cost for this event. We would also like to thank the editorial board of both Ancient Narrative and The Petronian Newsletter Society and their publisher, Roelf Barkhuis, for hosting in the News Rubric of both journals our various conference announcements as the program progressively took shape. Finally, this volume would not have been possible without the support of Maaike Zimmerman and Stephen J. Harrison, who first suggested a special collaboration with Ancient Narrative that would bring together, in a single volume under the title Space in the Ancient Novel, the papers presented in the International conference at Rethymnon and two more presented in the ICAN 2000 at Groningen. Zimmerman and Harrison then collected, read and responded critically and in detail to all submissions featured in this special issue. To both these fellow-editors we would like to express our heartfelt thanks and gratitude. Michael Paschalis and Stavros Frangoulidis Rethymnon, March 2002
Narrative Spaces DAVID KONSTAN
Providence
Impressed by the broad geographical sweep of the ancient romances, and disappointed by what he perceived to be a lack of character development comparable to that found in modern novels, Mikhail Bakhtin drew the conclusion that space was the primary dimension of the genre, with the temporal axis reduced virtually to zero. For reasons I have discussed elsewhere, I do not consider this judgment to be justified.1 Time does matter in the ancient Greek novels: if erôs is to serve as the basis, not just of an infatuation, but of a lasting bond sealed by marriage, it must be put to the test, proved able to endure, and in the process transformed into a stable emotion that transcends the allure of physical beauty that was its origin. Space, however, is also crucial to this evolution, not simply as a way of marking the stages of the protagonists’ progress, but also because it separates them and hence obliges them to follow independent trajectories. This independence is, in turn, fundamental to the theme of the Greek novels, which is to exhibit a romance based on mutual and symmetrical passion; hence, it must be tested in each of the protagonists, not just in one. Space, then, is not just a matter of distance travelled, but also of the creation of separate spheres of action for the hero and heroine. The couple are initially brought together by a mutual attraction based on little more than good looks. This phase is preliminary to the main action, and is accomplished before the end of the first book. Once they have been united, there begins the core of the story, in which the pair resist or overcome obstacles to their bond. In the end they are reunited, and begin their married life as two mature and loyal individuals who have been tried by experience. ————— 1
See Konstan 1994, 11, 46–47; for a spirited defense of Bakhtin’s view, see Branham 2002.
2
DAVI D KONST AN
Not all the novels, however, make use of space in the same way. For the sake of clarity, let me introduce the idea of a ‘continuous action space.’ Every action requires an agent, and that agent, in turn, must be somewhere. If the agent stays in the same place – under a fixed spotlight, so to speak – then the action space is continuous. Of course, new characters may enter or leave the circle illuminated by the spotlight and interact with the primary agent, but this does not affect the spatial continuity. Now, it may happen that all the characters leave the initial scene of action. Imagine – to continue with our theatrical image – that the spotlight tracks them (or one of them), following their actions as they go. According to my definition, such a sequence of actions still constitutes a continuous action space – ‘space,’ rather than ‘place,’ because the place clearly changes. Though characters move from one spot to another, as long as they (or some of them) are continually in sight, so to speak, their movements constitute what I call a trail. If any agent leaves a trail, the action space is continuous. A character may enter the action space and report events that have occurred outside it, as in the case of a messenger speech in tragedy. Such reports do not interrupt the spatial continuity (though they may represent considerable digressions in the narrative), since the action – that of reporting what happens – goes on in the primary space. The effect of such reports is to integrate actions going on elsewhere into those occurring in the action space. Let us call such reports channels. Neither trails nor channels affect the continuity of the action space. An action space is discontinuous if there is temporal interval – a jump to next week or next year – even if the scene remains constant; we may imagine a spotlight winking out to indicate the passage of time. For the sequence of actions is broken or interrupted. If the action resumes in another location, the discontinuity is more radical. If the agents remain the same, however, there may be a kind of implicit trail, since we can imagine that we have followed them, or kept them in view, as they moved from one place to another, despite the leap in time. If the new scene involves different characters, it constitutes a new action space, although if the original characters enter at a later stage, they may connect the two spaces by a kind of splice. Finally, and most importantly, a narrative may contain two or more action spaces that overlap temporally. The theatrical analogy for this is not a spotlight that goes off and on again, but rather two spotlights simultaneously illuminating separate and independent scenes. Here, there is no continuity by
NARRATIVE SPACES
3
means of trails, channels, or splices. Of course, a narrative, unlike the stage, cannot represent two action spaces at the same time; one must be recounted after the other. The narrator simply informs the reader that event Y occurred while event X was happening, as in the stereotyped formula, ‘Meanwhile, back at the ranch….’ Some narratives (and a few plays) are marked by a significant use of multiple action spaces, whereas others are limited to a single space. In the balance of this paper, I comment briefly on how the several ancient novels make use of action spaces (with a glance at some other genres as well), and then offer some suggestions concerning their function in three of the Greek novels. We shall then see whether the concept of action space has at least heuristic value. The Latin novels – to begin with them – by and large restrict themselves to a single action space. Petronius’ Satyrica and Apuleius’ Metamorphoses, like Homer’s Odyssey, are structured on the linear principle of a journey: the narrator follows the trail of the chief character from one place to another like a camera tracking an actor. Since both novels are first-person narratives, moreover, in which the narrator is also a character in the story, the action space is in a sense identical to the place where the narrator stands: he may report events that have occurred elsewhere, like the tales overheard by Lucius in the form of an ass, but these stories function like messenger speeches, bringing news from outside into the primary space. Put differently, situations in these novels do not normally unfold in parallel narrative domains. Within the inset tales, the narrator may recount simultaneous actions in two different spaces, as in the story of Cupid and Psyche, where the scene shifts from Cupid’s mysterious mansion to the homes of Psyche’s sisters, who are plotting her ruin.2 There are also shifts between earth and Olympus, but these are often connected by a trail, as we follow a deity ascending or descending from one realm to the other. The device is familiar from the Iliad, where Thetis’ trips to and from Olympus connect the action on earth to the councils of the gods, or again from the fifth book of the Odyssey, where Hermes carries the orders of Zeus to Calypso, instructing her to release Odysseus.3 ————— 2
3
It is indicative that the word interea appears in Apuleius’ novel for the first time at 4,32,1 and again at 5,4,14, 5,11,9, 6,1,1, 6,22,1, all in the Cupid and Psyche story; after that, only at 8,19,1, 9,34,11 (an inset tale), and 10,15,10. If the Roman novel, and particularly Apuleius’ Metamorphoses, prefers a more continuous action space than the Greek, it compensates by rendering the locale, and particularly
4
DAVI D KONST AN
Among the Greek novels, Achilles Tatius’s is like the Roman novels in being a first-person narrative,4 and in this sense is characterized by a single action space: everything is filtered through Clitopho’s awareness and reported from his perspective, so that even events that have occurred simultaneously are manifested sequentially in the narrator’s own space. Despite the radical experiments with suspense and narrative order in the first five books of Heliodorus’ Aethiopica, in which past events are revealed piecemeal and in reverse sequence,5 once the hero and heroine elope they remain together for virtually the entire journey southward from Thrace to Ethiopia. This linear motion constitutes the trail that defines a continuous action space. The remaining Greek novels, by Xenophon of Ephesus, Chariton, and Longus, exhibit a more pervasive doubling of the action space as the narrative focuses alternately on the activities of the hero and heroine, who follow independent paths that merge only when the couple is reunited at the end of the story.6 These novels make use of discrete action spaces, I suggest, precisely as a way of representing the hero and heroine as autonomous narrative agents in a way that is not paralleled in the other novels. In what follows, I examine the multiplication of action spaces in the final book of Xenophon’s Ephesiaca, preceded by a brief look at illustrative passages in Chariton and Longus.7 After indicating how these novels manage the construction and intersection of multiple action spaces, I conclude with a suggestion about a possible model for this narrative procedure. At the beginning of the fourth book of Chariton’s Callirhoe, the heroine stages a mock funeral for her husband Chaereas, who, she believes, has died at sea. Callirhoe is at this point a slave in the household of Dionysius, the regent of Miletus, who is enamored of her. As it happens, Mithridates, the satrap of Caria, is on a visit to Miletus at the time, and falls in love on the spot with Callirhoe. In fact, as the reader knows, Chaereas is a prisoner in Caria, where he working, under compulsion, on the land of Mithridates. ‘Now, Callirhoe [men oun],’ Chariton writes (4,2,1), ‘was burying Chaereas ————— 4 5 6 7
the beginning and end points of the narrative, geographically more indeterminate than its Greek counterparts; see the article by Niall Slater in this issue. On the role of the first-person narrator in this novel, see Reardon 1994. On Heliodorus’ complex narrative technique, see Winkler 1982; Morgan 1989. For the narrative structure of these novels, see Hägg 1971; Fusillo 1989. On Xenophon’s narrative technique, see O’Sullivan 1995, who emphasizes the oral elements in Xenophon’s style; Kytzler 1996. I agree with O’Sullivan that Xenophon is probably the earliest of five novelists; contra Ruiz-Montero 1994, 1996.
NARRATIVE SPACES
5
in Miletus, but Chaereas [de] was bound and toiling in Caria.’ The transition from one action space to the other is effected by a simple contrast: the resumptive pair of particles, men oun, summarizes the event immediately preceding, while de announces the topic of the following paragraph.8 Shortly afterwards, Chariton continues (4,2,4): ‘Now they [Chaereas and his loyal friend Polycharmus] were [men] in this extremity, having lately learned to forget their freedom; but the satrap Mithridates [de] returned [epanêlthen] to Caria a different man from what he was when set forth [exêlthen] for Miletus.’ Here, the two spaces are joined by the movement of Mithridates, whose departure and return constitute a round-trip trail between Caria and Miletus. Chaereas’ independent action space is thus more like an interlude, sandwiched in as it is between Mithridates’ travels to and fro. It may be that Chariton employed the formula for simultaneous action, rather than make Mithridates’ movements the hinge for the transition, just in order to emphasize the simultaneity of the two spaces. Later, when the focus again returns to Miletus, Chariton manages the shift of scene by way of a letter from Chaereas to Callirhoe that falls into the hands of Dionysius (4,4–5). In Longus’ novel, the hero and heroine are never very far from one another, since the entire story is contained on the island of Lesbos, and mostly within the confines of a small vale. On one occasion, Chloe is carried off on a ship by young men from Methymne, while Daphnis is away in the woods. Daphnis weeps and prays at a shrine of the nymphs, and when he is reassured by a dream of her safe return, he spends the night with his foster parents: ‘He thought this the longest of all nights. During it [ep’ autês], the following things happened. The commander of the Methymnaeans, having pushed on for about ten stades, wished to relieve his soldiers, who were weary after the raid’ (2,24,4–2,25,1). The change of scene is introduced by an explicit marker of simultaneity; the new narrative segment, moveover, begins in asyndeton, indicating the start of an independent episode.9 Toward the beginning of Book V of the Ephesiaca, Xenophon reports (5,2,1): ‘Habrocomes [ho men] bewailed his fortunes, as Aegialeus consoled him, and he remained in Syracuse, where he now [êdê] shared the profession ————— 8
9
On the structural function of ‘transitional’ men oun … de, see Denniston 1959, 472; Immerwahr 1966, 58–62 notes that Herodotus commonly employs the conjunctions men dê or men nun to terminate the first segment. For a similar use of asyndeton to introduce a new incident, cf. 4,7,1. Longus, however, favors this construction even within a continuous stretch of narrative; cf. 1,1,2 for another formula involving a distance marker in stades.
6
DAVI D KONST AN
of Aegialeus [i.e., fishing]; but Hippothous and his companions [hoi de] had by now [êdê] acquired considerable loot, and decided to leave Aethiopia and apply themselves to still greater affairs’ (parallel expressions are indicated typographically). To expedite their movements, it is decided that Anthia, whom the gang is holding captive, should be killed. The shift of focus from Habrocomes’ situation in Sicily to the separate action space in Aethiopia, where Anthia and Hippothous are acting out their drama – two sites about as far removed from each other as romantic fiction can conceive – is accomplished by the simple antithesis of men and de, reinforced by the the contrast between Habrocomes’ unhappy resolve to stay where he is and the optimism of Hippothus’ men as they prepare to move on (note too the repetition of êdê). We are then told how Anthia is rescued by Polyidus, the archon of Egypt, who organizes an expedition and cleans out the bandits, although Hippothous manages to escape and reach Alexandria by night; here he hides out until he can board a ship that is heading for Sicily, where, he believes, he can best repair his fortunes (5,3,3). Unfortunately, Polyidus takes a fancy to Anthia, with the result that his wife, Rhenaea, arranges to have the girl murdered. The slave Clytus, to whom the task is assigned, takes pity on her, however, and sells her instead to a brothelkeeper in Italy. Up to this moment, the action space has been continuous, as the narrator follows Anthia’s movements, which intersect with those of Polyidus, and tracks her to Alexandria and thence to Italy. Xenophon then reports (5,5,8–5,6,2): ‘(1) When the brothel-keeper [ho de] saw in Anthia a beauty such as he had never before beheld, he realized that he stood to gain great profit from the girl, and within a few days he restored her, exhausted as she was from the journey and from the attacks of Rhenaea. (2) Clytus [ho de], in turn, went back to Alexandria and reported to Rhenaea what had happened. (3) Hippothous [ho de] completed his journey and landed in Sicily, not in Syracuse, however, but rather in Taormina, and here he sought an opportunity to acquire new resources. (4) But when Habrocomes [tôi de] had spent some considerable time in Syracuse, he began to experience discouragement and to despair that he would ever find Anthia or return safely to his country. He decided, accordingly, to sail from Sicily and reach Italy, and if there he could not find what he was seeking, to make the sad journey back to Ephesus.’
NARRATIVE SPACES
7
There is a great deal of movement and shifting of focus in these few, spare sentences, in which the only connective is the particle de (joined with the pronominal article). Clytus’ return to Alexandria (2) opens a potential trail to that location, but the focus changes abruptly to Hippothous. Now, we know that Hippothous set sail from Alexandria for Italy (3), so in a sense we have a point of contact here: the camera, as it were, tracks Clytus and Anthia to Italy, follows Clytus back to Alexandria, then makes an abrupt turnabout and catches up with Hippothous as he arrives in Taormina. It is a complex sequence, but perhaps it can just qualify as a continuous action space. The switch to Syracuse (4), however, has no such link, and Xenophon motivates it by the arbitrary device of recording that Hippothous landed ‘not in Syracuse,’ where we left Habrocomes at the end of the previous continuous action, ‘but rather in Taormina.’ There is nothing intrinsically new or radical in such a shift from one action space to another. While Homer prefers in general to maintain continuity, for example by tracking a character to and from the battlefield as in Hector’s return to Troy in Book 6 of the Iliad, he is nevertheless quite capable of representing two simultaneous actions in different locations.10 Thus, in Book 4 of the Odyssey, while Telemachus is being entertained by Menelaus in Sparta, having set out in search of his father, Homer shifts the scene abruptly back to events in Ithaca, where the suitors are arranging their plot to assassinate the boy on his return journey (4.624–26): ‘While they [hoi men] were going about [penonto] their dinner in the halls [of Menelaus], the suitors [de] were playing [terponto] at discus in front of the hall of Odysseus,’ and so forth.11 The transition is softened by the repetition of the term megaron, just as in Xenophon the notice that Hippothus was not going to Syracuse connects his movements indirectly with the place where Habrocomes is in fact living. In Xenophon, the device seems more mechanical or arbitrary, since there are any number of places to which Hippothous is not travelling, ————— 10
11
See Rengakos 1995, Bakker 1997 chh. 4–5, both challenging Zielinksi 1899–1901 (followed by Fränkel 1968), who argued that Homer could only narrate events in succession, so that narrative time in epic moves uniformly forward. Aristotle states the case for simultaneity clearly (Poetics 1459b27–27): ‘in epic [as distinct from tragedy], because it is narrative in character, it is possible to represent many parts [or episodes] as occurring simultaneously’ (esti polla merê hama poiein perainomena). Cf. also Iliad 15,390–394: Patroklos d’, heiôs men…, tophr’ ho g’, etc.; 16,1–2: hôs hoi men per nêos…. Patroklos d’, picked up at 16,101–102: hôs hoi men toiauta…. Aias d’, etc.
8
DAVI D KONST AN
but I suspect that he was concerned to emphasize the coincidental proximity of two distinct action spaces, which would soon intersect in the narrative. So too, Habrocomes’ intention to sail to Italy (4) reminds the reader of the separation between his space and that of Anthia. Following immediately upon the last sentence quoted above, Xenophon introduces still further changes of locale (5,6,2–3): ‘By now, their parents and all the Ephesians were consumed by grief, since neither a messenger nor letters had arrived from Habrocomes and Anthia, and they kept sending people everywhere to seek them. Being unable to endure because of their discouragement and their advanced age, the parents of both departed this life. Habrocomes [ho men], then, set off for Italy, but Leucon and Rhode [ho de … kai hê], who had been reared with Habrocomes and Anthia, once their master in Xanthus had died and had left them his property (which was substantial), decided to set sail for Ephesus.’ In fact, Leucon and Rhode terminate their voyage in Rhodes, once they learn that Habrocomes and Anthia have disappeared and that their parents are now dead, and it is in Rhodes that both Anthia and Habrocomes will turn up as well, thus bringing the several strands of the story together and simultaneously uniting three distinct action spaces. The mention of the fortunes of Habrocomes’ and Anthia’s parents can be seen as a parenthetical aside on the part of the omniscient author, since it has no consequences for the action at this point. Where it does have an effect, namely in inducing Leucon and Rhode to cut short their homeward journey, we are told that it was precisely in Rhodes that they learned (5,6,4, mathontes) the fates of their erstwhile masters and their parents, and so the information concerning events in Ephesus here takes the form of a report (or what I have called a channel). The switch from Habrocomes’ movements en route to Italy to Leucon and Rhode’s decision to abandon Xanthus, however, is an authentic change of locale, and it is marked by contrastive men and de, analogous to the earlier cut (in cinematic terminology) from Habrocomes and the old fisherman in Syracuse to Hippothous and his men in Aethiopia. At this point, in a transition marked simply by de (5,7,1), Xenophon returns to the fortunes of Anthia in the possession of the brothelkeeper in Italy. Later, Xenophon will turn the spotlight briefly on Hippothous in Taormina, the shift of locale marked once more by a simple de (5,9,1). He wraps up events in that town, where Hippothous marries a rich old lady who obligingly dies shortly afterwards, leaving him her money, and then notes Hippothous’ decision to sail from
NARRATIVE SPACES
9
Taormina to Italy (5,9,2, with the tell-tale verb, diagignôskô), where he will intersect with Anthia and end up purchasing her from the brothelkeeper. What conclusions can be drawn from this abbreviated survey of the novelists’ technique in multiplying action spaces? First, I suggest that all three deliberately highlight the distinctness of the action spaces as a way of emphasizing the autonomous actions of their characters, above all the hero and heroine. In this sense, Xenophon, and to a lesser degree Chariton and Longus, manifest through their use of space the sexual symmetry that, I have argued, is characteristic of the Greek novels, at least, as I would now stress, up to the point of the reunion or marriage of the protagonists, when the traditional structures of male authority are typically reasserted12 – though this is least the case, it should be said, in Xenophon of Ephesus’ narrative. That is, Xenophon’s spatial arrangements are as complex as they are because he is expressing by means of them one aspect of his theme. Second, we have noted that the use of multiple action spaces is atypical of drama, for more or less obvious reasons, and also of epic (with certain exceptions). If Xenophon and Chariton had a model for this kind of narrative pattern, what genre might have furnished it? One possibility is historiography, where writers characteristically shifted the focus from the military activities of one side to the other in accounts of war. Herodotus in particular marks such shifts of locus by the paired particles men and de; thus (6,25– 26): ‘When Miletus was captured the Persians immediately took Caria as well…. These events, then [tauta men dê], occurred in the manner described. Histaeus the Milesian [de], however, was in the area of Byzantium, where he assembled the ships of the Ionians that had sailed out of the Pontus and reported what had happened at Miletus.’ The shift from Miletus to Byzantium is facilitated by the echo of ‘Miletus’ in ‘Milesian’; in addition, Histaeus acts as a channel, reporting in Byzantium what occurrred back at Miletus. A little later, Herodotus writes (6,30–31): ‘This [ta men] is what happened with Histiaeus [peri Histiaion]. But [ho de] the Persian fleet wintered at Miletus [peri Milêton],’ etc. The technique for switching from one action space to another is comparable to that exploited by the novelists.13 ————— 12 13
See Couraud-Lalanne 2000. Immerwahr 1966, 59 suggests that ‘the term ‘parallel action’ should not be applied to the work of Herodotus,’ on the grounds that ‘the Histories are based on the single chain of events, with single attachments of smaller accounts, rather than on elaborate synchronous structures’ (60–61). Certainly, there is nothing so sophisticated in Herodotus’ deploy-
10
DAVI D KONST AN
If the novelists found in the historical writers some guidance and motivation in representing the intersection of two independent spheres of action, this might be one additional reason why the earliest of them, at least – that is, Xenophon and Chariton – chose to cast their tales in the form of histories.14
Bibliography Bakker, Egbert J. 1997. Poetry in Speech: Orality and Homeric Discourse. Ithaca: Cornell University Press. Branham, R. Bracht. 2002. ‘A Truer Story of the Novel?’ In R. Bracht Branham, ed., Bakhtin and the Classics (Evanston: Northwestern University Press, 2002) 161– 186. Couraud-Lalanne, Sophie. 2000. Heros et heroïnes du roman grec ancien: Etude d’une paideia aristocratique à l’époque impériale. Paris: dissertation Université de Paris I. Denniston, J.D. 1959. The Greek Particles. 2nd edition. Oxford: The Clarendon Press. Fränkel, Hermann. 1960. [orig. 1931]. ‘Die Zeitauffassung in der archaischen griechischen Literatur.’ In Wege und Formen frühgriechischen Denkens. 2nd ed. (Munich: Beck, 1960) 1–22. Fusillo, Massimo. 1989. Il romanzo greco: Polifonia ed eros. Venice: Marsilio. Hägg, Tomas. 1971. Narrative Technique in Ancient Greek Romances; Studies of Chariton, Xenophon Ephesius and Achilles Tatius. Stockholm: Svenska Institutet i Athen. Hägg, Tomas. 1987. ‘Callirhoe and Parthenope: The Beginnings of the Historical Novel.’ Cl. Ant. 6, 184–204. Reprinted in Swain 1999, 137–160. Hunter, Richard. 1994. ‘History and Historicity in the Romance of Chariton.’ ANRW II.34.2, 1055–1086. Immerwahr, Henry R. 1966. Form and Thought in Herodotus. Cleveland: Western Reserve University Press = American Philological Association Philological Monographs 23. Konstan, David. 1994. Sexual Symmetry: Love in the Ancient Novel and Related Genres. Princeton: Princeton University Press. Kytzler, Bernhard. 1996. ‘Xenophon of Ephesus.’ In Schmeling 1996, 336–359. Luginbill, Robert D. 2000. ‘A Delightfull Possession: Longus’ Debt to Thucydides.’ CJ 97: 233–247. Morgan, John R. 1989. ‘The Story of Knemon in Heliodoros’ Aithiopika.’ JHS 109, 99–113. Reprinted in Swain 1999, 259–85.
————— 14
ment of simultaneous action spaces as what is found in Xenophon of Ephesus and Chariton. On the relationship between the Greek novels and Greek historiography, see Hägg 1987; Hunter 1994. See also Luginbill 2002 for Longus’ debt to Thucydides.
NARRATIVE SPACES
11
O’Sullivan, J.N. 1995. Xenophon of Ephesus: His Compositional Technique and the Birth of the Novel. Berlin: W. de Gruyter. Reardon, B.P. 1994. ‘Achilles Tatius and Ego-Narrative.’ In J.R. Morgan and R. Stoneman, edd., Greek Fiction: The Greek Novel in Context (London: Routledge, 1994) 80–96. Reprinted in Swain 1999, 243–258. Ruiz-Montero, Consuelo. 1994. ‘Xenophon von Ephesos: ein Überblick.’ ANRW II.34.2, 1088–1138. Ruiz-Montero, Consuelo. 1996. ‘The Rise of the Greek Novel.’ In Schmeling 1996, 29–85. Schmeling, Gareth L., ed. 1996. The Novel in the Ancient World. Leiden: E.J. Brill. Swain, Simon, ed. 1999. Oxford Readings in the Greek Novel. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Winkler, John J. 1982. ‘The Mendacity of Kalasiris and the Narrative Strategy of Heliodoros’ Aithiopika.’ YCS 27, 93–158. Reprinted in Swain 1999, 286–350. Zielinski, Thadaeus. 1899–1901. ‘Die Behandlung gleichzeitiger Ereignisse im antiken Epos.’ Philologus suppl. 8, 407–49.
Chariton’s Syracuse and its histories of empire CATHERINE CONNORS
Seattle
The ancient Greek novels tell their stories of young love and high adventure in a realm apart from the everyday world inhabited by their authors and audiences. In his marvellously bold project of constructing a history of novelistic discourse that would embrace the novel’s earliest beginnings, Bakhtin describes the ‘chronotope’ or setting in time and space, of the Greek novels as an ‘alien world in adventure time’ in which largely passive and unchanging characters endure experiences brought upon them by chance. In Bakhtin’s insistent formulation the novels depict their characters in a time and space wholly divorced or abstracted from social, historical and geographical reality (Bakhtin 1981, 100): The world of these romances is large and diverse. But this size and diversity is utterly abstract. For a shipwreck one must have a sea, but which particular sea (in the geographic and historical sense) makes no difference at all. For escape it is important to go to another country; for kidnappers it is important to transport their victim to another country – but which particular country again makes no difference at all....The nature of a given place does not figure as a component in the event; the place figures in solely as a naked, abstract expanse of space. Bakhtin’s larger point is that as a character moves unchanged through this ‘alien world in adventure time’ he ‘keeps on being the same person’; the novels thus function as a ‘test of the heroes’ integrity, their selfhood’ (Bakhtin 1981, 105, 106). The ‘abstract expanse of space’ of the Greek novels – so different from the historically contextualized topographies of Bakhtin’s beloved 19th century realistic novels – serve as the background against which an individual, private identity is constructed and affirmed: we could
CHARITON ’ S SYRACUSE AND ITS HISTORIES OF EMPIRE
13
say that for Bakhtin in the Greek novels space reveals identity, an identity increasing organized around private, rather than political, life. For a long time the Greek novels have been understood, along the same lines sketched by Bakhtin, as artifacts that represent and enact a turn away from engaged political life and toward the secluded pleasures of private life. We are coming now to see this ‘private life’, the identity affirmed on Bakhtin’s testing ground of abstract space, itself more and more as a complex ideological negotiation. At the same time, space too is becoming more complicated. Modern geographers and philosophers use the term space to describe an abstraction that can be measured and charted, whereas place is used to mean a realm that is constructed, narrated, situated in time; as the ideological assumptions which inform even the most abstract representations of space are being increasingly made explicit, all space becomes place. 1 Accordingly, although the novels themselves give generally scanty descriptions of places and peoples, the shared body of geographical and historical knowledge and lore available to educated audiences in antiquity ensured that novelistic travels did not in fact unfold in a space that was ‘naked’ and ‘abstract’. Instead, novelistic characters move through a world of geographically significant and specific places. Within this broader (post-Bakhintian) critical framework, we could now say that in the Greek novels representations of places construct identities. Heliodorus’ Aithiopika, with its sophisticated problematization of the construction of identity and its focus on the immensely fascinating world of the Nile, is perhaps most responsive to this sort of approach. Tim Whitmarsh and Judith Perkins have each excellently analysed how the progress of Heliodorus’ characters up the Nile argues that Greek identity is an individual response to situation and context rather than an unchanging essence.2 I hope to demonstrate here that Chariton’s novel too – especially its historical setting in Syracuse – can contribute to our understanding of constructions of Greek identity under the Roman empire. Chariton’s novel sets romance in an historical frame to tell the story of Callirhoe, daughter of Hermocrates, the Syracusan general who led the defeat of the Athenian expedition against Syracuse in 413. The name of Hermocrates’ daughter is not given in the historical sources; Chariton’s name for her, Callirhoe, meaning ‘beautiful-flowing’, figures her as an embodiment of Syracuse’s famous spring Arethusa. Callirhoe’s swift marriage to Chaereas ————— 1 2
On these terms see: Casey 1997, esp. 75-78; Tuan 1979, and Clarke 1999, 1-45. Perkins 1999; Whitmarsh 1998, 1999.
14
CATHE RI NE CONNORS
in Syracuse ends in apparent tragedy when he is tricked by her rejected suitors into a jealous rage and kicks her, evidently to death. Buried and then awakened from her coma, she is abducted from her tomb by the robber Theron who sells her to the fabulously wealthy Dionysius in Ionia; in time she bears Chaereas’ child but pretends Dionysius is the father. Dionysius becomes embroiled in a dispute over her with a Persian satrap named Mithridates, which is ultimately brought to court before the Persian king Artaxerxes in Babylon only to be interrupted by news of an Egyptian revolt. Reunited with Chaereas in the aftermath of the revolt (in which the Persians are defeated) Callirhoe entrusts the child to Dionysius (keeping the secret of his paternity from Dionysius but not from Chaereas) and she and Chaereas return to Syracuse in triumph. The novel’s opening sentence imitates the openings of Herodotus’ history of the Persian Wars and Thucydides’ history of the Peloponnesian war, and the precise relations of the novel’s plot and settings to historical fact have been charted in detail.3 The tender-hearted Perry maintained that the violent attack on Callirhoe and the decision to leave the child with Dionysius are too cruel not to be derived from historical anecdotes: the next man to emerge as a leader in Syracuse after Hermocrates was named Dionysius; he married the daughter of Hermocrates, who we are told, was attacked by a Syracusan mob and so violated that she committed suicide (Plut. Dion 3,1; cf. Diodorus Siculus 13,112).4 Once we suspect a connection between Callirhoe’s child and the historical Dionysius it is easy enough to speculate that Callirhoe’s child was named Dionysius after his putative father.5 Chariton’s privileging of atmosphere and theme over historical accuracy could simply be an index of the novel’s detachment from real events, its existence in Bakhtin’s ‘adventure time’. But to ignore the implications of Chariton’s history entirely would be a mistake. Even works that do not engage substantially and ————— 3
4 5
On Chariton’s uses of history see: Hunter 1994; Alvares 1993; Bompaire 1977; Billault 1981, 1989; Bartsch 1934. Chariton is untroubled by anachronisms: for example, the Persian king Artaxerxes did not begin his reign until 405, after the death of Hermocrates in 407; Chaereas’ military encounter at Tyre resembles narratives of Alexander’s siege of Tyre in 332 (or a later siege: see Jones 1992). Some features of the text display an outlook characteristic of Roman imperial times but this is not so obtrusive as to seriously undermine the coherence of the story’s setting in the classical period: Reardon 1996, 327; Baslez 1992, 203-204. Perry 1967, 137-140. It was more customary for boys to be named after a grandfather; however, the historical Dionysius was succeeded by his eldest son Dionysius (Plut. Dion 6).
CHARITON ’ S SYRACUSE AND ITS HISTORIES OF EMPIRE
15
directly with historical facts of empire can still illuminate for us the discourses that uphold and justify empire in in the things they take for granted – what Raymond Williams calls their ‘structures of feeling’ or what Edward Said calls their ‘structures of attitude and reference’.6 In other words, just because Chariton’s novel doesn’t mention Rome doesn’t mean that it is not about – or at least a response to – Rome.
Hermocrates’ Syracuse At first sight, Chariton’s historical setting seems typical of much Greek literary and rhetorical discourse during the Roman period: the narrative creates a Greek world where the only real rivals to Greek power are not Roman but Persian, where Greeks always come out on the winning side.7 Here, readers can find refuge from a contemporary reality where Rome is the supreme global power. So, Chariton repeatedly stages the Greek-Persian conflict, – to the advantage of the Greeks, naturally. Greeks are democratic, Persians ruled by a king; Greeks are free, Persians are slavish, and so on. The celebration of Greek values over Persian ones is positively Herodotean. Yet the precise setting of the novel in Syracuse in the aftermath of the defeat of the Athenians by the Syracusans under Hermocrates in 413 brings Thucydidean complications to this picture. Hermocrates’ victory over the Athenians is a constant point of reference, starting in the novel’s second sentence (1,1,1). Saving Chaereas from his lovelorn melancholy will be the best of Hermocrates’ ‘trophies’ (1,1,11). As his daughter, Callirhoe is the embodiment of his success and the Athenian defeat; the Syracusan celebrations of their wedding were greater than their celebrations of victory (1,1,13). Callirhoe’s funeral procession puts on display the entire civic and military community of Syracuse and includes cavalry and infantry bearing semeia of the victory; Hermocrates added many of his war spoils to the funeral offerings (1,6,4). When abducted from the tomb by Theron Callirhoe sees her future as a tragic reversal of the Athenian defeat (1,11,2-3). When Dionysius learns that she is the daughter of Hermocrates, he acknowledges that the king of Persia admires Hermocrates for his victory over the Atheni————— 6 7
Williams 1973, 12; Said 1993, 52. Compare the representation of the Persian wars by Pausanias: see Alcock 1996. On the general plausibility of Chariton’s representations of the Persians see Alvares 1993, 180198.
16
CATHE RI NE CONNORS
ans and is reluctant to force himself on Callirhoe (2,6,3); the king later mentions his own admiration for Hermocrates (5,8,8). When Theron is crucified, he overlooks the sea ‘over which he had carried off the daughter of Hermocrates, she whom even the Athenians had not captured’ (3,4,18). When the Great King’s eunuch Artaxates rebukes Callirhoe for preferring the enslaved Chaereas to the King himself, Callirhoe retorts: ‘Chaereas is well-born, a leading citizen (protos) of the city that defeated the Athenians, the ones who had defeated even your great king at Marathon and Salamis’ (6,7,10). Chaereas offers the Syracusan victory as his credentials when he offers his services to he Egyptians in their revolt againt Persia (7,2,3-4). Memories of the defeat of the Athenian expedition culminate in the return of the couple to Syracuse, when the numerous ships that sail out to escort them into the harbor make the harbor look like ‘the appearance (schema) it had after the battle with Athens’ (8,6,10). The world Chariton invites his readers to linger in is not the Herodotean world of the spectacular Greek repulsion of the Persian invasion, but the Thucydidean world where Athens has just come out on the losing side of what Thucydides ‘the greatest battle of Greek history, the most brilliant for the winners and most unfortunate for those destroyed’ (Thuc. 7,87,5). Even though it took another eight years for Sparta to seize control of Athens, the defeat at Syracuse was seen to mark the end of Athenian aspirations to exert control over distant territories (Thuc. 7,56,2, 7,66,2). Syracuse, then, is not just any Greek city, but a place with imperial stories to tell, stories of one empire giving way to another.
Dionysius’ Syracuse At Syracuse the Athenian empire crumbles and a Syracusan empire emerges. Although democratic institutions are valorized in the novels’ version of Hermocrates’ Syracuse and its contrast with the Persian court, in historical fact democracy did not long survive the defeat of the Athenians. Hermocrates himself attempted to seize sole power in 407 and was killed in the conflict he provoked. Subsequently, Dionysius builds an autocratic and extensive rule lasting from 405-367. He controlled most of Sicily, and his power extended into Italy and the Adriatic as far north as Ancona. As we have noted, the child of Callirhoe and Chaereas, whom Callirhoe has pretended is Dionysius’ child (3,7), is left at the end of the action to be raised by him in Ionia (8,4,5), but there are clear prophecies of his future: he is to come to
CHARITON ’ S SYRACUSE AND ITS HISTORIES OF EMPIRE
17
Syracuse and be received in triumph (2,11,2; 3,8,8; 8,4,6; 8,7,11-12).8 The child’s projected life story would dovetail roughly with some of the facts audiences might remember about the historical Dionysius I: that there were conflicting stories about his origins,9 and that he was connected to Hermocrates through Hermocrates’ daughter, who suffered a violent attack. Certainly, Chariton rewrites history. The historical daughter of Hermocrates does not emerge alive from her tomb, and the historical Dionysius was her husband, not her son. Yet, despite the fact that the historical and fictional Dionysius-stories don’t match up exactly, the novel’s open-ended ending offers an aition for the re-emergence of tyranny in Syracuse. Dionysius’ childhood in wealthy Ionia and the links of his ‘foster-father’ Dionysius to the Persian king serve to ‘explain’ both his name and his tyrannical and nondemocratic rule, while his ultimate status as the child of the true Syracusans Callirhoe and Chaereas –whose wedding was requested and celebrated by the entire demos of Syracuse (1,1,11, 14) – imaginatively legitimates his position. Where Bakhtin would say that the ‘adventure time’ of the novel is totally sealed off from the historical time and circumstances of author and audience, I think we might say instead that this child’s implied future as Dionysius I of Syracuse serves as a portal between the ‘adventure time’ of the novel’s action and historical time. In contrast to the typical view of Dionysius as a bad tyrant, 10 Chariton’s optimistic imagining of the arrival of Callirhoe’s child in Syracuse presents an altogether sunnier picture of the tyrant’s future.
————— 8
9
10
So Naber 1901, 98-99. On Dionysius himself our main source is Diodorus Siculus 14-15; see further Caven 1990, 50-58. Diod. Sic 13,96,4 says that Dionysius started out as a grammateus and and an ordinary citizen; in a passage deriving from Philistus, Cicero (Tusc. 5,57) describes his birth and social position as bonus and honestus but mentions that others characterize Dionysius less favorably; cf. Caven 1990, 19-20. Certainly Diodorus Siculus, writing in the 30 years that precede the battle of Actium, is almost unrelievedly hostile (e.g. 14,2), and Cicero in the Tusculan Disputations uses Dionysius as paradigm of the moral evils of tyranny (Tusc. 5,57-63). The only known ancient biography of Dionysius (now lost) paired him with Domitian: see Caven 1990, 1, citing Photius cod. 131.
18
CATHE RI NE CONNORS
Augustus’ Syracuse It remains to ask how this might reflect Chariton’s own historical situation. As a Latinist, I can’t help noticing that Chariton’s optimistic rewriting of the stories of Dionysius I as a bad tyrant parallels Augustus’ own process of controlling the script of his rise to power, doing everything he could to dissociate himself from the paradigms of tyranny and monarchy while actually gathering sole power unto himself and his successors. Is it reasonable to suppose that a Greek novelist working sometime between mid first and mid second centuries CE would be interested enough in the Roman emperors to construct such an allegorical dimension of his work? Yes, if he comes from Aphrodisias, a city with exceptionally strong links to Rome and its emperors because of its cult of Aphrodite, mother of Rome’s legendary founder Aeneas.11 Aphrodisians were granted freedom from taxation and other special privileges in 39 BCE under the sponsorship of Octavian, who traced his descent back to Aeneas and Aphrodite through his adoptive father Julius Caesar.12 The Sebasteion, a monumental portico complex erected by two wealthy local families, begun under Tiberius and completed under Nero, celebrated the empire, the emperor and the imperial family in an elaborate program of relief sculptures which combined Greek myth with Roman history (itself claiming origins in myths of Troy). 13 The prominence of Rome’s mythic Trojan origins in Aphrodisian civic consciousness, perhaps only fully evident with the publication of the Sebasteion sculptures in the mid -1980’s, brings a new immediacy to the question of Chariton’s uses of Trojan myths, ————— 11
12 13
See Erim 1986; documentation of links to Rome is set out in full in Reynolds 1982. The tradition of honoring Rome’s patron goddess Venus and the eastern origins of her founder Aeneas by making gifts to Aphrodite at Aphrodisias extends as far back as Sulla, who was directed by an oracle to make a dedication of a double axe to her: Appian BC 1,11,97, on which see Reynolds 1982, 3. Julius Caesar dedicated a golden statue of Eros to the goddess which no doubt advertised his claim to descend from Aphrodite via Aeneas: Reynolds 1982, doc. 12 lines 13 ff. He probably gave the right of asylum to the temple: Reynolds 1982, doc. 8 lines 41 f and Tacitus Ann. 3.69, with Reynolds 1982, pp. 5 and 79. Some attention has been paid to Chariton’s Aphrodisian origins: Schmeling 1974, 20-21; Alvares 1993, 172-175; Jones 1992b, 161-7, highlights nuances in the novel by his attention to social history from an Aphrodisian perspective; Edwards 1985 argues that since Aphrodisias claims a special closeness to Aphrodite, the role of Aphrodite in directing the action of the novel operates as an expression of Aphrodisian civic pride; he makes the case in more detail in Edwards 1996, 20-2, 33-6, 60-1, 80-1, 95-100, 130-1. Reynolds 1982, docs. 6-8 On sculpture in the Sebasteion see Smith 1987, 1988, 1990.
CHARITON ’ S SYRACUSE AND ITS HISTORIES OF EMPIRE
19
already suggestively traced by Marcelle Laplace in 1980. She points to the ways that Callirhoe at some times plays a role similar to Helen’s (especially in Euripides’ Helen) and at others is an Aphrodite figure. In particular, Laplace argues, Callirhoe is like Aphrodite in leaving her child to be raised in the east without her: like Aphrodite’s Aeneas, Callirhoe’s child is destined for a westward journey that founds an empire.14 Indeed, she views the novel as an ‘histoire symbolique’, concluding, ‘Rome, the hope and future of Greece, such is the destiny that Chariton extols’.15 On this allegorical level, Chariton’s novel, like the Sebasteion itself, uses Trojan myth to celebrate both Aphrodisian civic pride and the coming of Rome. The shifting function of Syracuse in the Roman political and historical imaginary supports this allegorical interpretation. Syracuse, reputed to be the most beautiful of all Greek cities (Cic. Verr. 2,4,117), was defeated by Marcellus in a siege in 211; he adorned Rome with Syracusan spoils and was said to have boasted ‘even to Greeks,’ that in this way ‘he taught the ignorant Romans to honor and marvel at the beautiful and wondrous works of Greece’ (Plut. Marc. 21,5). This Marcellan narrative traces what is Greek and beautiful in Rome back to a Syracusan source. In the aftermath of Octavian’s conflict with Sextus Pompeius, Syracuse takes on another meaning: for Augustus, as for Chariton, Syracuse is a place where you solve a pirate problem and begin an empire. In the realm of fiction, the events of the novel’s ‘adventure time’ are set in motion when the bandit Theron (apparently based at Syracuse16) abducts Callirhoe from her tomb and it ends when the disruption caused by Theron has been restored to order and the couple returns to Syracuse. In the realm of history, the waters off Syracuse are the scene of events that make way for Augustus’ assumption of sole imperial powers. In a series of campaigns variously characterized as piracy and as political opposition to Octavian, Sextus Pompey had gained control of the ————— 14
15 16
Laplace 1980, 120. Even the name Callirhoe, Laplace adds, may subtly reinforce the imaginative link to Troy: the scholiast to Persius 1,134 says that Callirhoe is the name of a daughter of Scamander ‘abducted by Paris before Helen’; she cites Hermann 19761977 on this point (Laplace 1980, 123). On the parallel between Aphrodite as protectress of Callirhoe and her child and Aphrodite as mother and protectress of Aeneas see Edwards 1996, 35, 131 and, with emphasis on parallels between Aeneas and Callirhoe’s child as founders of a dynasty, Edwards 1991, 195-196. Laplace 1980, 125. Theron knows local men well (1,7) and is eventually recognized by a fisherman who has seen him before down on the docks (3,4,10).
20
CATHE RI NE CONNORS
sea around Sicily, and thus interrupted the flow of grain to Rome.17 Octavian took steps to contain Sextus Pompey’s activities; these were only finally successful when his ‘lieutenant’ Agrippa defeated the Pompeians in 36. 18 In the Res Gestae Augustus refers to his war against Sextus from 42-36 as suppression of piracy.19 Appian marks the end of his narrative of the civil wars with the breaking of Sextus Pompey’s hold on Sicily and surrounding waters in 36 BCE.20 The suppression of Sextus Pompey’s Sicilian piracy was physically commemorated by Augustus in the restoration of Syracuse. Strabo writes: In our own time, since [Sextus] Pompey had mistreated other cities, and especially Syracuse, Augustus Caesar sent out a colony and restored a great part of the old settlement. For in earlier times there was a city of five towns with a wall of one hundred and eighty stadia. While it was not necessary to complete the full circuit, he thought it was necessary to improve only the settled part, which was near the island of Ortygia and which had a perimeter sufficient for a significant city. For Ortygia, which lies near the mainland, is joined to it by a bridge and has the spring Arethusa which sends out its stream straight into the sea. (Strabo 6,2,4) Like the closure of the gates of the temple of Janus at Rome in 29, at Syracuse the newly refurbished walls and buildings themselves mark a point of closure for civil strife. The full details of the Augustan building program – what exactly was rebuilt, what was a new construction – are difficult to recover and need not detain us here.21 After all, there’s no evidence that Chariton ever actually saw Syracuse. But he probably knew the bare fact that Augustus did some building that was described as restoration. The high point of Syracuse’s past, the time when it received its most notable fortifications and buildings, was the reign of Dionysius I: he fortified the island Ortygia (which he made into a gated community for his court and its protectors), ————— 17 18 19
20
21
Appian BC 4,11,83; 5,3,18; 5,9,77; 5,9,80. See de Souza 1999, 185-195. Appian BC 5,121. Augustus Res Gestae 25: mare pacavi a praedonibus. It was elsewhere characterized as the bellum Siculum or the bellum servile. Octavian’s conflict with Antony culminating in the battle of Actium was to be treated in Appian’s ‘Egyptian Wars’ which is lost to us (cf. Appian BC 1,pref. 6). For detailed discussion see Wilson 1990, 33-45.
CHARITON ’ S SYRACUSE AND ITS HISTORIES OF EMPIRE
21
erected public buildings just in front of this wall (Diod. Sic. 14,7,1), and built strategic fortification walls to Epipolai (Diod. Sic. 14,18).22 Augustus’ restoration of Syracuse effaces the traces of its decline after the death of Dionysius. But recent history –the defeat of Sextus Pompey and the rise of Augustus – is clearly legible too. Even though there is little topographic detail in Chariton’s renderings of Syracuse, in offering readers a view of classical Syracuse and pointing forward to its Dionysian future Chariton engages in a project that is parallel to Augustus’ own. In fact, Chariton plants a verbal signal of the playfully allegorical relation between his novel and Roman history at the beginning of the narrative. After Theron sees Callirhoe’s funeral, he spends a sleepless night and asks himself why he should keep risking his life at piracy when he could get rich enough to retire just by robbing her tomb (1,7,1): well might we wonder why it takes a pirate so long to decide on robbery! Putting an end to his reflections he resolves on action with the words 1""4'!#, ‘let the die be cast’, and after thinking overnight about which men to recruit for his venture he assembles the group, ‘an army fit for such a general’ (1,7,3). The military parody here is all of a piece with Chariton’s project of historicizing the novel and novelizing history, while the image of a dice game sounds the theme of tyche (chance), a common feature of the novels, and one of the themes that they take over from New Comedy. 23 Indeed, when Athenaeus has his dinner-sophists discuss the evils of marriage, one of them cites a passage of Menander that contains exactly this expression. Two men discuss the prospect of marriage for one of them; the man embarking on marriage insists that he must go through with what he has started while the other warns of the dangers ahead (Deipn. 13,559d-e): – If you have any sense, you won’t marry and leave behind this life of yours. For I myself have married and that’s the reason I advise you against it. ————— 22
23
It is clear from what Strabo says that Augustus did not rebuild everything that Dionysius had built, but the fact that Strabo goes into such detail about his reasoning suggests that there may have been a perceived need to explain why Augustus didn’t comprehensively rebuild the Dionysian city. That is, the model of Dionysius may have been felt so strongly that Augustus (or Strabo) needs to explain the logistical reasons why it is not being followed in every particular. On the relation of the novel to New Comedy see Fusillo 1989, 43-55; and on Chariton’s use of comic elements: Laplace 1971, 103-111; Borgogno 1971; Corbato 1968.
22
CATHE RI NE CONNORS
– It’s all settled. ‘Let the die be cast [1""4'!# ].’ – Go ahead then. But I hope you survive. You’ll be casting yourself now on a real sea of troubles, not the Libyan or Egyptian... where three ships of thirty survive; not even one man who has married has survived. Menander ironically reverses the typical contrast between the safe stay-athome world of the household and the dangerous world of merchant adventuring. Given this Menandrian context, Theron’s words are more than just a piece of the sententious comic furniture of which the novels are so fond. In a nicely judged ironic reversal of Menander’s already ironic description of the dangers of marriage, Theron chooses the ultimate merchant adventure– piracy. And in the end, chance does destroy Theron when he is discovered at sea through the agency of tyche (3,3,8) and executed for his abduction of Callirhoe (3,4,18). Amid the general atmosphere of military parody in the account of Theron’s decision and action, the specific target of Chariton’s parody is Julius Caesar’s decision to cross the Rubicon, and begin his civil war with Pompeius Magnus, in 49. In Plutarch’s account, Caesar rides eagerly to the Rubicon at night, but slows as he draws near and when he came to the river dividing Cisalpine Gaul from the rest of Italy (it’s called the Rubicon) awareness came over him as he got closer to the terrible deed and was overcome by the magnitude of what he was daring to do, and he halted his swift course and stopped his progress. For a long time he argued in silence with himself, changing his mind in turn, and making repeated changes to his plans. And he talked over his doubts with those friends who were there (one of whom was Asinius Pollio), calculating how great the troubles which the crossing would unleash would be for all men and what great fame for the deed they would leave to posterity. In the end, with some passion, as though hurling himself away from calculation and toward the future, and prefacing it with the expression men usually use when they take difficult and reckless chances, ‘let the die be cast’ [1""4' !#], he rushed toward the crossing; he went full speed the rest fo the way and rushed into Ariminium before daybreak and seized it. (Plut. Caes. 32,5-6)
CHARITON ’ S SYRACUSE AND ITS HISTORIES OF EMPIRE
23
Plutarch specifies elsewhere that Caesar said 1""4' !# in Greek (Pomp. 60,2). Whether or not Caesar (or Plutarch, or Plutarch’s source, probably Asinius Pollio) feels this to be a quote from Menander, when Chariton makes it the opening of the action of his novel, he gives his mixture of the historical/comic/erotic a mischievously Caesarian precedent. Look there, says Chariton, Caesar had been messing about on the boundaries between the historical and the erotic long before I got down to work. And in terms of the novel’s structure, just as Caesar’s plunge across the Rubicon initiates the civil strife that is only fully brought to an end in Augustus’ empire, Theron’s decision initiates the travels of Callirhoe; it is in this sense the foundation of her adventure, an adventure whose happy ending in Syracuse restores to order what Sicilian piracy brought into chaos. Chariton’s ‘pathos erotikon’ (1,1,1) tells the story of one young love but its allusions to history tell stories of empire. Is it too bold to view Chariton’s Greek novel as engaging in the kinds of allegorical and playfully allusive responses to Rome’s imperium that have been traced here? Consider the long and vigorous tradition of writing about Roman history in Greek. In their various ways, Polybius, Diodorus Siculus, Dionysius of Halicarnassus, Plutarch, Appian and Dio make narratives of Rome available to two sorts of audiences: Greeks interested in Roman history and Romans interested in reading Greek versions of their history. Each group of readers could find piquant pleasures in Chariton’s allusions to Roman imperium. We know too, through papyri, that there was an audience for Latin literature translated into Greek, particularly the works of Vergil and Cicero.24 Chariton might not expect every reader to appreciate the Roman resonances of his erotic history, but he could certainly imagine that some – especially those aware of Aphrodisias’ special links to the founders of Rome’s empire – would enjoy this additional layer in his historical collage. Swain has characterized the world of the novels as a self-confident elite affirmation of imperviousness to Roman influence, an ‘expression of their cultural hegemony’,25 Chariton’s novel demonstrates that an elite Greek response to Roman imperium could also include playful mastery of Roman history. I’d like to close with a deliberately provocative question which relates to the problem of dating Chariton’s novel. The papyrological evidence indi————— 24 25
Rochette 1997, esp. ch. 4. Swain 1996, 109.
24
CATHE RI NE CONNORS
cates that Chariton cannot have composed the novel much after mid-second century CE,26 while the relative lack of Atticist forms and language may suggest that he wrote before the Atticist fashion had really taken hold, perhaps in the first century CE rather than the second.27 Nothing I have said so far depends on assigning the novel to a particular time within this relatively short period, for an awareness of the civil wars and Augustus’ consequent establishment of peace would have continued to be central for understanding the history of Roman rule in the Greek east throughout the period. My question pertains to the tantalizing evidence for an early date for Chariton’s novel in the last line of the first satire of Persius, who died in 62. The poem sharply condemns Rome for the popularity of inconsequential literary forms and for the fact that Persius’ biting and harsh satire has no place there. He closes with a sneer of contempt: ‘his mane edictum, post prandium Callirhoen do’ (To these men I leave the morning’s magistrate’s decree [announcing upcoming entertainments], and Callirhoe after lunch, 1,134). Perhaps this bare reference cannot be definitive proof for an early date for Chariton. But just suppose this is Chariton’s Callirhoe being read after lunch at Rome:28 what did Persius hate about it? Just its escapist pleasures? or did Persius, a fierce critic of the principate who laments the loss of the days of the republic when a man could speak his mind, see the novel’s aition for the rise and legitimation of a tyrant’s empire in Syracuse and its allegorical support for Augustus’ version of empire? We’ll never know for sure, but the more we understand the imperial stories Chariton tells at Syracuse the more sense it would make for Persius to hate them.29 Works cited Alcock, S. E. 1996. ‘Lanscapes of Memory and the Authority of Pausanias, in Pausanias Historien, Entretiens sur l’antiquité classique 41, Geneva, 241-267. Alvares, J. 1993. The Journey of Observation in Chariton’s ‘Chaereas and Callirhoe’, Austin: diss. University of Texas.
————— 26 27
28
29
Lucke 1985; Petri 1963, 46-51, quoting correspondence from E. G. Turner. Arguments for an early date on stylistic grounds: Papanikolaou 1973, on which see the cautionary remarks of Giangrande, 1974. Arguments for a date in the late first or early second century: Ruiz-Montero 1989, 1991, 1994, 1008-1012. Among recent critics those who believe Persius is referring to Chariton’s novel include Goold 1995, 4-5, and Reardon 1996, 316-317. I am grateful to audience members at ICAN 2000, and to Denis Feeney, Alain Gowing, Sandra Joshel, Mark Nugent and David Scourfield for their helpful advice.
CHARITON ’ S SYRACUSE AND ITS HISTORIES OF EMPIRE
25
Bakhtin, M. M. 1981. The Dialogic Imagination, trans. C. Emerson and M. Holquist, Austin: University of Texas Press. Bartsch, W. 1934. Der Chariton-Roman und die Historiographie, Leipzig: Diss. Univ. Leipzig. Baslez, M.-F. 1992. ‘De l’histoire au roman: la Perse de Chariton’, in : M.-F. Baslez, P. Hoffmann, M. Trédé eds. Le monde du roman grec, Paris: Presses de l’École Normale Supérieure, 199-212. Billault, A. 1981. ‘Aspects du roman de Chariton’, L’information littéraire 33, 205311. Bompaire, J. 1977. ‘Le décor sicilien dans le roman grec et dans la littérature contemporaine’, REG 90, 55-68. —. 1989. ‘L’histoire au roman: Hermocrate de Syracuse’, REG 102, 540-548. Borgogno, A. 1971. ‘Menander in Caritone’, RFIC 99, 257-263. Casey, E. S. 1997. The Fate of Place: a Philosophical History, Berkeley: University of California Press. Caven, B. 1990. Dionysius I: War-lord of Sicily, New Haven: Yale University Press. Clarke, K. 1999. Between Geography and History: Hellenistic Constructions of the Roman World, Oxford: Oxford University Press. Corbato, C. 1968. ‘Da Menandro a Caritone. Studi sulla Genesi del Romanzo Greco e i suoi Rapporti con la Commedia Nuova’, Quaderni Triestini sul Teatro Antico 1, 5-44. de Souza, P. 1999. Piracy in the Greco-Roman world, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 185-195. Edwards, D. R. 1985. ‘Chariton’s Chaereas and Callirhoe: Religions and Politics do mix’, in: K. H. Richards, ed., Society of Biblical Literature 1985 Seminar Papers, Atlanta: Scholars Press, 175-181. —. 1991. ‘Surviving the web of Roman power: Religion and politics in the Acts of the Apostles, Josephus, and Chariton’s Chaereas and Callirhoe’, in: L. Alexander, ed. Images of Empire, Sheffield: Journal for the Study of the Old Testament Supplementary Series 122, 179-201. —. 1996. Religion and Power: Pagans, Jews and Christians in the Greek East, New York - Oxford: Oxford University Press. Erim, K. 1986. Aphrodisias, city of Venus Aphrodite, London. Fusillo, M. 1989. Il romanzo greco. Polifonia ed eros, Venezia: Marsilio Editori. Giangrande, G. 1974. Review of A. Papanikolaou, Chariton-Studien, JHS 94, 197198. Goold, G. P. 1995. Chariton: Callirhoe. Loeb Classical Library, Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Hermann, L. 1976-1977. ‘La Callirhoe de Publius Celer’, REA 78-79, 157. Hunter, R. L. 1994. ‘History and Historicity in the Romance of Chariton’, ANRW 2.34.2,1055-1086. Jones, C. P. 1992. ‘Hellenistic history in Chariton of Aphrodisias’, Chiron, 91-102. —. 1992b. ‘La personnalité de Chariton’, in: Le monde du roman grec, M.-F. Baslez, P. Hoffmann, M. Trédé eds. Le monde du roman grec, Paris: Presses de l’École Normale Supérieure, 161-7.
26
CATHE RI NE CONNORS
Laplace, M. 1980. ‘Les légendes troyennes dans le “roman” de Chariton, Chairéas et Callirhoé’, REG 93, 83-125. Lucke, C. 1985. ‘Zum Charitontext auf Papyrus,’ ZPE 58, 21-33. Naber, S. E. 1901. ‘ad Charitonem’, Mnemosyne 29, 92-99. Papanikolaou, A. 1973. Chariton-Studien, Hypomnemata 37. Perkins, J. 1999. ‘An Ancient “Passing” Novel: Heliodorus’ Aithiopika’, Arethusa 32.2, 197-214 Perry, B. E. 1967. The Ancient Romances, Berkeley: University of California Press, 137-140. Petri, R. 1963. Über den Roman des Chariton. Beiträge zur klassischen Philologie 11, Meisenheim am Glan: A. Hain. Reardon, B. P. 1996. ‘Chariton’, in: G. Schmeling, ed. The Novel in the Ancient World, Leiden: Brill, 309-335. Reynolds, J. M. 1982. Aphrodisias and Rome, Journal of Roman Studies Monographs 1, London: Society for the Promotion of Roman Studies. Rochette, B. 1997. Le latin dans le monde grec: Recherches sur la diffusion de la langue et des lettres latines dans les provinces hellénophones de l’ Empire romain, Bruxelles: Collection Latomus 233. Ruiz-Montero, C. 1989. ‘Caritón de Afrodisias y el mundo real’, in: P. Liviabella Furiani and A.M. Scarcella, eds. Piccolo mondo antico: Appunti sulle donne, gli amori, i costumi, il mondo reale nel romanzo antico, Napoli: Edizioni Scientifiche Italiane, 106-149. —. 1991. ‘Aspects of the Vocabulary of Chariton of Aphrodisias’, CQ 41, 484-489. —. 1994. ‘Chariton von Aphrodisias: ein Überblick’, ANRW 2.34.2, 1006-1054. Said, E. W. 1993. Culture and Imperialism, New York: Vintage. Schmeling, G. 1974. Chariton, New York: Twayne. Smith, R. R. R. 1987. ‘The imperial reliefs from the Sebasteion at Aphrodisias’, JRS 77, 88-138. —. 1988. ‘Simulacra Gentium: The ethne from the Sebasteion at Aphrodisias’, JRS 78, 50-77. —.1990. ‘Myth and Allegory in the Sebasteion’, in: C. Roueché and K. T. Erim, eds. Aphrodisias Papers Vol. 1: Recent work on Architecture and Sculpture. JRA Supplementary Series 1, 89-100. Swain, S. 1996. Hellenism and Empire: Language, Classicism and Power in the Greek World, AD 50-250, Oxford: Oxford University Press. Tuan, Y.-F. 1979. ‘Space and Place: A humanistic perspective’, in: S. Gale and G. Olsson, eds., Philosophy in Geography, Dordrecht, Holland, 387-427. Whitmarsh, T. 1998. ‘The Birth of a Prodigy: Heliodorus and the Genealogy of Hellenism’, in: R. L. Hunter, ed. Studies in Heliodorus, Cambridge: Cambridge Philological Society, Supplementary vol. 21, 91-124. —. 1999. ‘The Writes of Passage: Cultural initiation in Heliodorus’ Aethiopica’, in: Richard Miles, ed. Constructing Identities in Late Antiquity, London-New York: Routledge, 16-40. Williams, R. 1973. The Country and the City, Oxford: Oxford University Press. Wilson, R. J. A. 1990. Sicily under the Roman empire: the archaeology of a Roman province 36 BC- AD 535, Warminster: Aris and Phillips, 33-45.
Chronotope and locus amoenus in Daphnis and Chloe and Pleasantville MARTIN M . W INKLER
Fairfax, Virginia
Longus’ novel Daphnis and Chloe may be characterized as a “song of innocence and of experience,” to appropriate a famous title by William Blake. In the novel, innocence and experience work on two levels. One is within the story, which describes the protagonists’ journey of erotic self-discovery from a state of naiveté to sexual knowledge, a journey that culminates in their marriage and parenthood. The other and more fascinating level of innocence and experience is the basis of Longus’ narrative strategy: an experienced author writes about inexperienced characters for experienced readers. While the novel’s setting is the idyllic countryside, the author and his readers are urban sophisticates. Longus’ narrative works mainly through the dramatic tension which arises from the difference between the story’s protagonists and its readers and the simultaneous presence of innocence and experience on the two levels mentioned.1 This tension in turn is the basis for the novel’s lasting appeal and for its earlier reputation as a naughty or dirty book. It is also the one aspect that elevates it above the level of a predictable adventure romance, just as Heliodorus’ non-linear plot is the chief glory of the Aithiopika. Nevertheless, the characters in these two as in the other surviving Greek novels firmly remain one-dimensional or, in E. M. Forster’s well-known term, “flat.”2 ————— 1
2
Bowie 1996 surveys the audiences of the Greek novels in general; Morgan 2002 discusses Longus’ readership and narrative strategy. Forster 1985, 67–78, on “flat” and “round” characters, and especially 68–72 on the narrative advantages of flat characters. See also Robert Louis Stevenson’s 1882 essay “A Gossip on Romance,” in Stevenson 1897, 327–343, a defense of formula fiction as eloquent as it is convincing.
MARTIN M . WI NKLER
28
In “Forms of Time and the Chronotope in the Novel,” Mikhail Bakhtin devotes a long first section to “The Greek Romance.”3 In this paper, I will focus first on the aspect of chronos in Bakhtin’s chronotope and then turn to that of topos, closely related as the two of course are in what we today call the “space-time continuum.” My main purpose in doing so is to juxtapose Longus’ novel, a work of ancient popular art, with a work of modern popular art which works in comparable ways, although in a new medium. The latter, too, shows the journey from innocence to experience in matters of love and sexuality and, moreover, touches directly on classical themes. This is the 1998 film Pleasantville, written and directed by Gary Ross. Although Longus’ novel has been filmed three times, I have chosen Pleasantville as a more interesting cinematic reworking of several aspects of the ancient text.4 Thematic connections between works where one would not expect them can be more revealing than more or less straightforward adaptations.
————— 3
4
Bakhtin, “Forms of Time and the Chronotope in the Novel,” in Bakhtin 1981, 84–258, especially 86–110 on Greek romances. Subsequent quotations from and references to the text are according to this translation. I have also consulted “Formen der Zeit und des Chronotopos im Roman,” in Bachtin 1986, 7–209. Bakhtin wrote his long study in 1937– 1938 (with “Concluding Remarks” added in 1973); it was first published in Russian in 1975. For a classical perspective on the text see Branham 1995. Branham 2002 examines the temporal aspects in the ancient novels. Daphnis and Chloe was twice filmed in Greece, first by Orestis Laskos under its original title in 1931, then, more loosely (and indebted to the Idylls of Theocritus as well), as Young Aphrodites (Mikres Afrodites) by Nikos Koundouros in 1963. On the latter see Faulx 1969. A third version appeared in Spain in 1976 as La iniciacion en el amor, directed by Javier Aguirre. On these films see de España 1998, 414–418 and 427, 428, and 430 (filmography). De España, 417, in his caption to an illustration, calls twelve-year old Cleopatra Rota of Young Aphrodites “una Lolita helénica.” His picture explains why. An example of a modern analogy to Longus’ Chloe is Marcel Pagnol’s Manon in Manon des Sources (Manon of the Spring), filmed first by Pagnol himself in 1953 and again by Claude Berri in 1986. In the later version, more readily accessible, Emmanuelle Béart plays Manon. Here are some similarities to her classical predecessor: Manon is a goatherd; she dances and plays the harmonica, a modern equivalent to the rustic instruments played by Longus’ country folk; she innocently bathes naked in a spring by a grotto. The evil character who watches her doing so and immediately falls in love with her but is eventually rejected partly redeems himself in death (overtones of Longus’ Dorcon). When she marries, Manon in her bridal gown combines the purity of her natural beauty with the cultural refinement of society, a point which Longus emphasizes about Chloe (and to which I will turn below).
CHRONOTOPE AND L OCUS AMOENUS
29
I In Pleasantville, two modern teenagers, brother and sister, are supernaturally transported into a 1950s black-and-white television series called “Pleasantville,” which is set entirely within this eponymous town. This Pleasantville might as well be named Perfectville, because it represents the American dream at its suburban ideal: perfect weather, perfect town- and countryscape, perfect people, and no family, social, urban, or natural problems. Crime does not exist. The worst kind of crisis we see in the film involves a treed cat. What Bakhtin said about the Greek romance in the following two quotations is applicable wholesale to Pleasantville: In this kind of time, nothing changes: the world remains as it was, the biographical life of the heroes does not change, their feelings do not change, people do not even age. This empty time leaves no traces anywhere, no indications of its passing. It goes without saying that in this type of time, an individual can be nothing other than completely passive, completely unchanging….to such an individual things can merely happen. He himself is deprived of any initiative. He is merely the physical subject of the action. And it follows that his actions will be by and large of an elementary-spatial sort….he keeps on being the same person and emerges…with his identity absolutely unchanged.5 Since in the black-and-white world of Pleasantville we are in the wholesome 1950s, there is, of course, no eroticism or sex. Teenagers go on a date to the soda fountain, hold hands, sit side by side in a car in Lovers’ Lane looking at the natural surroundings – this is all that happens. But their idyllic existence is radically altered when David and Jennifer, our modern teenagers, arrive from the late 1990s. They, of course, are sexually experienced, Jennifer more so than David. (In an early scene set in the present, we learn that she had bought herself new underwear before an important date.) Longus’ description of Lycaenion partly fits Jennifer: both are “imported…from town” and
————— 5
Bakhtin 1981, 91 and 105.
MARTIN M . WI NKLER
30
“young, pretty, and rather sophisticated.”6 In Pleasantville, Jennifer introduces first her 1950s date and then, indirectly, several other youngsters to their erotic nature. The irresistible spread of sexual knowledge among Pleasantville’s teenagers and adults, despite the futile attempts on the part of the town’s mayor and several other good citizens – in this patriarchal society, all of the latter are middle-aged males – appears on screen in a way as charming as it is clever. Director Ross takes full advantage both of the visual nature of his medium and of modern computer technology to present his characters’ gradual journey toward love and sexuality and, resulting from this, greater self-knowledge, a deeper emotional and intellectual life, and an awareness of the world around them. More and more, Ross infuses individual objects and people with color until, at the completion of this process, the originally black-and-white world of Pleasantville has become entirely polychrome. To his characters in the story as well as to his audiences in the theater, Ross shows the radical changes which knowledge of any sort demands from all who embark on a quest for it. In the biblical story of the tree of knowledge of good and evil, God forbids Adam to eat the fruit of this tree; otherwise, he has to die the same day. 7 But when Eve and Adam eat the forbidden fruit, they do not die at all but acquire consciousness. Their first realization is not knowledge of good and evil but awareness of their nakedness. Nudity here symbolizes their sexual awakening, from which all additional and deeper knowledge may derive. A parallel perspective occurs in Plato’s Symposium, in which Socrates explains the true nature of Eros. Real love transcends the physical and ascends to the ultimate knowledge that “beauty is truth; truth, beauty,” as John Keats put it in the best-known phrase of his “Ode on a Grecian Urn.”8 Knowledge of good and evil and the Platonic ideal are two sides of the same coin. In Daphnis and Chloe, Longus is not quite this philosophical, but the concept that carnal knowledge leads to self-awareness and to a meaningful and happy life is the culmination point of his story. Only when Chloe’s natural beauty ————— 6
7
8
Daphnis and Chloe 3.15.1. I quote Longus in the translation by Christopher Gill in Reardon 1989, 285–348; quotations at 324. Genesis 2.16–17. Sir James G. Frazer’s reconstruction of the myth of the Fall of Man and his analysis of its likely original form is still worth reading (Frazer 1918, vol. 1, 45–77); it is readily accessible, if in the abridged version from a 1923 one-volume edition but with original notes restored, in Dundes 1984, 72–97. Socrates’ exchange with Agathon and his subsequent speech are in Plato, Symposium 198a–212c.
CHRONOTOPE AND L OCUS AMOENUS
31
is supplemented by her elegant bridal dress – when, in other words, nature and culture, physis and technê, are combined – can she embody true perfection, the ideal of both beauty and knowledge. As the narrator puts it toward the conclusion of his story: Then you could learn what beauty is like, when it is properly presented. For when Chloe was dressed and had put her hair up and washed her face, she seemed so much more beautiful to everyone that even Daphnis scarcely recognized her.9 Knowledge of one’s own nature leads to the development of other areas of knowledge: of one’s surroundings and society, of arts and sciences, of civilization. This latter aspect of knowledge is brought to the fore even more in Ross’s film than in Longus’ novel. The ignorant inhabitants of Pleasantville discover in their municipal library a great repository of culture. (This is a plot turn that appears quaint today and is more in keeping with the society of the 1950s.) In the film, culture is represented by two areas, painting and literature. Three novels receive prominence of place: Mark Twain’s Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, J. D. Salinger’s The Catcher in the Rye, and D. H. Lawrence’s Lady Chatterley’s Lover. All three at some time have been banned or censored somewhere. Not only in the case of teenage readers, identification with the protagonists of Twain’s and Salinger’s novels has often been an initiation into literature and, by extension, into the arts – that is to say, into knowledge and civilization at large. This, along with their heroes’ irreverence toward “good society,” may be one of the reasons why the books are banned in some American middle and high schools even today. Lawrence’s novel in particular was as dangerous and notorious in the twentieth century as Daphnis and Chloe had been in the nineteenth. Here again, Bakhtin on the chronotope helps us see both similarity and difference between Daphnis and Chloe and Pleasantville. After stating that “the homogenization of all that is heterogeneous in a Greek romance…is achieved only at the cost of the most extreme abstraction [and] schematization,” Bakhtin goes on to observe:
————— 9
Daphnis and Chloe 4.32.1; quotation from Gill, 345.
MARTIN M . WI NKLER
32
This most abstract of all chronotopes [the one in the Greek romance] is also the most static. In such a chronotope the world and the individual are finished items, absolutely immobile. In it there is no potential for evolution, for growth, for change. As a result of the action described in the novel, nothing in its world is destroyed, remade, changed or created anew. What we get is a mere affirmation of the identity between what had been at the beginning and what is at the end. Adventure-time [the time necessary for the development of the novel’s plot] leaves no trace.10 The latter part of this quotation does not apply to the final state of things in Pleasantville, which has completely changed from its earlier idyllic existence. But even this difference is analogous to the Greek novel, since the affirmation of the country life at the conclusion of Daphnis and Chloe occurs only because the dangers of the external world could be resisted successfully. In Pleasantville, the people from the outside world, the two who have arrived from today’s society, effect a radical change in the idyllic world, which turns out not to have been all that idyllic in the first place. The outside world, we may say, has conquered the idyllic one. But this conquest could take place only with the willing cooperation of most of the inhabitants of the idyllic world. For better or worse, any incursion of knowledge – exemplified by sexuality, as it was in Longus – destroys the paradisal state of innocence and ignorant perfection (or perfect ignorance). This is the price necessary to be paid for evolution, growth, and change.
II After these general connections between Daphnis and Chloe and Pleasantville I now turn to a specific scene in either work which best illustrates the simultaneous presence of innocence and experience from whose inherent tension the narrative development of a love story may derive its most irresistible force and greatest appeal. Both scenes are highly erotic, if in different ways. That in Pleasantville is indeed the most erotically charged one in the entire film. Neither scene is in any way pornographic. Both are presented with great delicacy, with sympathy for and understanding of the character or characters involved, and with a touch of humor. In terms of plot or situation ————— 10
Bakhtin 1981, 110.
CHRONOTOPE AND L OCUS AMOENUS
33
described, the two scenes have nothing at all in common, nor do I wish to imply that writer-director Ross in any way imitated, or was conscious of, Longus. But both very effectively illustrate a specific moment of sexual awakening and do so in analogous ways regarding the narrative moment at which they occur. One of the most charming erotic vignettes in Daphnis and Chloe is the episode with the grasshopper or cicada which flies into Chloe’s dress. This is a particularly significant moment in Daphnis’ and Chloe’s journey toward their discovery of love. The narrator tells us that Daphnis “put his hands between her breasts and took out” the cicada.11 He says nothing else about Daphnis’ act, but experienced readers – that is to say, all readers – know that in order to do so Daphnis must touch her chest. Mentally, readers automatically add this missing detail, the acme of eroticism in the little episode. That the very moment omitted from verbal description is indeed significant, perhaps even a turning point for Daphnis’ awakening to love, becomes evident from two authorial comments which prompt us to fill in the blank, as it were. Before reading that Daphnis put his hand into Chloe’s dress we have been informed that he did so taking advantage of the situation – prophaseôs labomenos. This is by no means an indication of lechery on his part because he is still far too innocent. Instead, his act shows his tender desire to be closer to Chloe than he can usually be and to come to her rescue. (The grasshopper has made her scream twice in surprise and fear.) More importantly, however, this comment is a nudge to the reader. The disarming charm of the moment and the equally disarming naiveté of Daphnis are expressed in the experienced author’s gently ironic phrase “that obliging grasshopper” (ton beltiston tettiga). The moment is one of great intimacy and erotic vulnerability on the part of the two young lovers. The corresponding moment in Pleasantville, also one of intimacy and vulnerability, occurs when Betty, the mother in the film’s central television family, discovers her sexuality. Our two time-travelers have replaced her children, who were of necessity conceived asexually. After she has obtained, to her initial disbelief and surprise, the requisite information about sex from her experienced “daughter” Jennifer, Betty takes a bath and discovers the true nature of her body – its erogenous zones – and of herself. But more importantly, Betty now becomes aware of her mind as well, for after her experience she is no longer willing to play the submissive housewife, her tradi————— 11
Daphnis and Chloe 1.26.3; this and the following quotation are from Gill, 300.
34
MARTIN M . WI NKLER
tional and stereotypical 1950s role, and determinedly emancipates herself from husband and kitchen. (She even acknowledges and acts on her sexual feelings for a man not her husband.) While she is in the process of discovering her erotic self in the bathtub, she begins to see her surroundings in color. Soon after, she leaves behind her black-and-white existence for good and turns into color herself. In an informal audio commentary on his film, director Ross has observed about this scene: The sexual awakening is the first thing that occurs because it’s the most primal, it’s the most basic….If you look at this as kind of a growing up of the world that way, sort of that edenic allegory, this is the first impulse, and it’s a primal thing and it’s one that you can’t deny….But there’s higher levels of evolution than that; it’s only the first….There are so many other things that are on a higher level of evolution and complexity than just that sexual impulse, yet I think if you’re closed off to something that fundamental, it’s very hard to be open to other things….it gives rise to a whole new world of nuance and beauty that’s nonsexual…. Although Ross does not name Plato here, he might as well have done so, because his words are clearly in the tradition of Platonic philosophy. A later scene in the film, in which David takes Margaret, a Pleasantville girl who embodies a Chloe-like perfection of beauty and innocence, on a first date to Lovers’ Lane, equally harks back to the classical tradition, as Ross himself makes clear. The description, in his commentary, of the locus amoenus which we see on screen again sounds rather Platonic: We took to calling the sequence the Athenian sequence because it did have a certain mind-body ideal, and that’s the reason that the design of that gazebo in the background has certain Greek Revival elements in it, because I wanted that tableau across the lake to have almost an Elysian kind of quality to it in the same way that a lot of Greek Revival paintings of England in the eighteenth century would use a piece of Greek Revival architecture across a pond because they were all kind of in a romantic era drunk on that Athenian ideal.
CHRONOTOPE AND L OCUS AMOENUS
35
Readers of Plato will remember a comparable – indeed, a highly Longian – locus amoenus as the setting of the Phaedrus, whose subject, related to that of the Symposium, is the nature of love and beauty.12 The work culminates in the discussion of the true nature of knowledge. Socrates and Phaedrus converse under a high plane tree with a spring at its roots. A nearby grotto is sacred to Pan, the river god Achelous, and the nymphs. Pan and the nymphs will later play major parts in Daphnis and Chloe. (As they are in the novel, cicadas are present in Plato’s dialogue, too.) Obviously, Ross cannot include any gods in his modern story, although his narrative as a whole would not have worked without a supernatural figure. (This is the strange television repairman who makes it possible for David and Jennifer to appear in Pleasantville and who functions as a deus ex machina – indeed, at certain points, as a deus in machina.) But even so, Ross manages to infuse his Lovers’ Lane setting with a high degree of supernatural beauty. When David and Margaret approach in their car, a gentle rain of pink petals descends on them and swirls around their still partly black-and-white environment. On the soundtrack, the old standard “At Last,” a well-known love song from an earlier time of innocence, provides an aural complement to the scene’s visual magic. An observation by the narrator at the beginning of Daphnis and Chloe is applicable to this scene in the film. In the novel’s prologue, the narrator tells us that he saw “a painting that told a story of love” and that this painting inspired in him “a yearning to depict the picture in words.” His verbal account of the painting contains, in part, the following ecphrasis of nature and an evaluation of its artistic quality: The grove itself was beautiful – thickly wooded, flowery, well watered; a single spring nourished everything, flowers and trees alike. But the picture was lovelier still, combining great artistic skill with an exciting, romantic subject.13 These words apply, virtually without a change, to the locus amoenus in Ross’s film.14 ————— 12 13 14
Plato, Phaedrus 229a–230c. Daphnis and Chloe, prol. 1–2; quotations from Gill, 288–289. The tradition of the locus amoenus in ancient and later literature is far too extensive to be addressed here. In classical antiquity, the locus amoenus originally took the form of an
MARTIN M . WI NKLER
36
III In Daphnis and Chloe and in Pleasantville, knowledge causes uncertainties, difficulties, even dangers, and it has unpleasant consequences. Dealing with these consequences brings increased knowledge to those whose lives had previously been simple and easy. But greater knowledge may come to the outsiders, too. In the novel, Chloe’s kidnapper Lampis, for instance, is eventually forgiven and allowed to be present at her wedding, and a full-scale war between the Methymneans and the Mytileneans is avoided with surprising effortlessness. The conciliatory ending of Shakespeare’s As You Like It is an apposite example from the later pastoral tradition. In the film, David and Jennifer also react to the changes they have brought to Pleasantville, but in different ways. Jennifer decides to stay in this world, simple and still backwards as it is despite its changes, whereas David returns to today. In an earlier scene he had comforted Betty by applying make-up to her face to allow her to appear in black and white after she has turned into color so that she might save face in front of her husband and the town’s mayor, both blackand-white reactionaries. In a moving reversal of this moment, David now comforts his real mother, who is stuck in a hopeless love affair after the breakup of her family, by wiping off her make-up to allow her face to regain ————— enclosed garden (paradeisos), beginning with the garden of the Phaeacian king Alcinous in Homer (Odyssey 7.114–131). Xenophon’s park (Anabasis 5.3.7–11) was modeled on Persian gardens; cf. Xenophon, Oeconomicus 4.13–14. For the wider context see Moynihan 1979. Cf. further the Greek and Roman tradition of idyllic, bucolic, and erotic poetry and, in Rome, that of the laudes Italiae. For some examples of loci amoeni see Pliny the Elder, Natural History 35.116–117, with which cf. Vitruvius, On Architecture 7.5.2, and Pliny the Younger, Epistles 5.6.7–13, 8.8, and 9.39. The walled garden at Achilles Tatius, Leucippe and Clitophon 1.15, is an example of such a garden in the Greek adventure-romances. Cf. also Bruno Snell, “Arkadien: Die Entdeckung einer geistigen Landschaft,” most recently in Snell 1984, 257–274 and 320–321 (notes). On the influence of classical literature on medieval culture see especially Curtius 1993, 191–209 (a chapter on ideal landscape), with discussions of Homer, Plato, Theocritus, and Virgil, among others, and with a section on the locus amoenus at 202–206. Curtius, 202–203, quotes and translates Petronius, Satyricon 131.8, and a fourth-century poem by Tiberianus (Anthologia Latina 1.2.809) as prime examples from Roman literature. Snell’s and Curtius’ books are easily accessible in English, albeit in earlier editions: Snell 1953; Curtius 1952. For the Renaissance see the classic overview by Burckhardt 1995, 190–197 (“Discovery of the Beauty of Landscape”), and more recently Jäger 1990, 87–99 and the textual excerpts at 272 (Lorenzo de’ Medici on the paradise garden), 275–276 (Leonardo), 280 (Isabella d’Este), 282–283 (Ariosto), and 303–304 (Armina’s garden in Tasso’s Gerusalemme liberata).
CHRONOTOPE AND L OCUS AMOENUS
37
its natural beauty. David and Jennifer, Ross makes evident, have been both teachers and learners. A question which may arise, both for Daphnis and Chloe and for Pleasantville, is whether these works are instances of the Bildungsroman. Bakhtin’s argument about the Greek romances leads to an answer in the negative for Longus’ novel – rightly so, because the psychological realism of the modern novel in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries cannot be expected from its ancient precursors. The same answer is appropriate for Pleasantville: despite the process of learning and insight and the larger issues of knowledge and recent American history on which the film touches, such as McCarthyism and race relations, the characters even in the film’s modern frame story are intentionally left too schematic to be “round” in Forster’s sense of the word. But nevertheless, one particular aspect of the Bildungsroman to which Bakhtin refers applies, mutatis mutandis, to the film. Bakhtin observes that in the novels of Stendhal, Balzac, and Flaubert the issue is primarily one of overturning and demolishing the world view and psychology of the idyll, which proved increasingly inadequate to the new capitalist world….the capitalist world is…not idealized, its inhumanity is laid bare, the destruction within it of all ethical systems…, the disintegration of all previous human relationships…, love, the family, friendship… – all of these are emphasized.15 In its frame story, Pleasantville shows us a capitalist world whose social fabric is fraying. But we might update Bakhtin’s observations and take them a stage further by replacing the term “capitalist world” with “technological world” to describe the life and society of today. In regard to Pleasantville, supernatural power (the quasi-divine TV repairman) linked to technology makes it possible for David and Jennifer to return to the past – which, being on television, is itself a creation of modern technology. In today’s visual media, such technology creates a new variant on the idyllic chronotope which Bakhtin had found in the ancient novels. More importantly for the art of storytelling today, advanced computer technology has made it possible for writer-director Ross to tell his story the most effectively. All the black-andwhite images that we see on the screen are really color images – that is to say, they were originally filmed in color and then digitally turned into black ————— 15
Bakhtin, 1981, 234–235.
MARTIN M . WI NKLER
38
and white. Only in this way was it possible for him to show both colors and black-and-white side by side in individual frames and entire scenes in a way which appears convincing and realistic to sophisticated and technologically savvy modern viewers. From this perspective, we might be justified to call Pleasantville a kind of visual Bildungsroman: a highly technological world becomes both the subject and the means of telling a story about the journey from innocence to experience and knowledge. That this kind of story has numerous points of comparison with literary works almost two millennia old makes the phenomenon only the more remarkable and attractive. Despite the differences of time and space – of chronos and topos – between Daphnis and Chloe and Pleasantville and those of their respective chronotopes, and despite the even more obvious differences between an ancient literary medium and a modern medium of moving images, the similarities of story and, more importantly, of narrative stance in both works are too noticeable to be overlooked. (Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose.) So those familiar with novel and film may readily think of Pleasantville when they remember what the narrator of Daphnis and Chloe has to say about the purpose he pursues with his attempt to transpose the painting he describes at the beginning into a story. His work is meant to be something for mankind to possess and enjoy. It will cure the sick, comfort the distressed, stir the memory of those who have loved, and educate those who haven’t. For certainly no one has ever avoided Love, and no one will, as long as beauty exists, and eyes can see.16
Works cited Bachtin, Michail M. 1986. Formen der Zeit im Roman: Untersuchungen zur historischen Poetik. Ed. Edward Kowalski and Michael Wegner; tr. Michael Dewey. Rpt. Frankfurt am Main: Fischer Taschenbuch Verlag, 1989. Bakhtin, M. M. 1981. The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays. Ed. Michael Holquist; tr. Caryl Emerson and Michael Holquist. Austin: University of Texas Press; rpt. 1996. Bowie, Ewen. 1996. “The Ancient Readers of the Greek Novel,” in: Schmeling 1996, 87–106.
————— 16
Daphnis and Chloe, prol. 3–4; quotation from Gill, 289.
CHRONOTOPE AND L OCUS AMOENUS
39
Branham, R. Bracht. 1995. “Inventing the Novel,” in: Mandelker 1995, 79–87 and 200 (notes). —. 2002. “Representing Time in Ancient Fiction.” in: Ancient Narrative Volume 1 (2000–2001), 1–31. Groningen: Barkhuis Publishing. Burckhardt, Jacob. 1995. The Civilization of the Renaissance in Italy. Tr. Samuel George Chatwynd Middlemore. 3rd ed. London: Phaidon. Curtius, Ernst Robert. 1952. European Literature and the Latin Middle Ages. Tr. Willard R. Trask. Rpt. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1990. —. 1993. Europäische Literatur und lateinisches Mittelalter. 11th ed. Berne: Francke. Dundes, Alan (ed.). 1984. Sacred Narrative: Readings in the Theory of Myth. Berkeley, Los Angeles, and London: University of California Press. de España, Rafael. 1998. El Peplum: La Antigüedad en el Cine. Barcelona: Glénat. Faulx, Jacques. 1969. “L’antiquité toute proche: ‘Les Jeunes Aphrodites’ de Nikos Koundouros.” Otia 17: 18–22. Forster, E. M. 1927. Aspects of the Novel. Rpt. San Diego, New York, and London: Harcourt Brace, n.d. [1985]. Frazer, Sir James. 1918. Folklore in the Old Testament: Studies in Comparative Religion, Legend and Law. 3 vols. London: Macmillan. Jäger, Michael. 1990. Die Theorie des Schönen in der italienischen Renaissance. Cologne: DuMont. Mandelker, Amy (ed.). 1995. Bakhtin in Contexts: Across the Disciplines. Evanston: Northwestern University Press. Morgan, J. R. 2002. “Nymphs, Neighbours and Narrators: a Narratological Approach to Longus”, forthcoming in S. Panayotakis, M. Zimmerman, W.H. Keulen (eds.), The Ancient Novel and Beyond, Leiden – New York – Köln: Brill Moynihan, Elizabeth B. 1979. Paradise as a Garden in Persia and Mughal India. Rpt. London: Scolar Press, 1982. Reardon, B. P. (ed.). 1989. Collected Ancient Greek Novels. Berkeley, Los Angeles, and London: University of California Press. Schmeling, Gareth (ed). 1996. The Novel in the Ancient World. Leiden – New York – Köln: Brill. Snell, Bruno. 1953. The Discovery of the Mind in Greek Philosophy and Literature. Tr. Thomas G. Rosenmeyer. Rpt. New York: Dover, 1982. —. 1984. Die Entdeckung des Geistes: Studien zur Entstehung des europäischen Denkens bei den Griechen. 6th ed. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck and Ruprecht. Stevenson, Robert Louis. 1897. The Travels and Essays of Robert Louis Stevenson, vol. 13: Virginibus Puerisque: Memories and Portraits. New York: Scribner’s .
Literary Topography in Apuleius’ Metamorphoses S . J . HARRISON
Oxford, UK
Scholarly interest in the topography of Apuleius’ Metamorphoses has largely been concerned with the study of its description of landscapes with an eye to realism, or with exploring Apuleius’ use of symbolic or conventional descriptions of nature.1 Here I want to look specifically at literary topography, and two interconnected aspects in particular: the way in which some geographical locations mentioned and described in the Metamorphoses look back to and reflect significant literary sources, and the way in which some place-names and their associations consequently suggest or point to important themes and ideas in the novel. This amounts to considering topography as part of the work’s literary programme, as part of its self-construction and message to the reader. Prime amongst the extant literary texts related to the Metamorphoses, of course, is the Onos attributed to Lucian. I (with many scholars) regard this work as an accurate epitome of the lost Greek Metamorphoses attributed to Lucius of Patras, which in turn I regard as Apuleius’ major model.2 Here I am interested in how far the locations of the original Greek Metamorphoses, which ( I believe) can accessed by us through the Onos, underlie Apuleius’ version of the story and how far they have been adapted for a Roman readership. But there are also many other literary sources which the descriptions of place in the Metamorphoses evoke, from a wide range of texts and genres, further evidence of the rich literary texture and epideictic demonstration of learning which I believe to be fundamental to the Metamorphoses.3
————— 1 2 3
E.g., De Biasi 2000 for the first, Schiesaro 1988 and Trinquier 1999 for the second. For the issue see Lesky 1941, Walsh 1974, Holzberg 1984, Mason 1999. Cf. Harrison 2000, 211–235.
LITERARY TOPOGRAPHY I N APULE I US ’ METAMORPHOSES
41
1 The Tale of Aristomenes (1.5–19) Omitting the complexities of the prologue, now extensively illuminated by the volume edited by Ahuvia Kahane and Andrew Laird,4 the first significant element of literary topography is to be found in the self-identification of Aristomenes near the beginning of his tale at 1.5:
, Aegiensis. There is of course an issue of whether Aristomenes’ name should be supplied here:5 given Apuleius’ well-known habit of postponing naming for new characters,6 most obviously for Lucius himself, not named until 1.24, it may well be right to keep the transmitted text and not supply the name. But more interesting than the name is the indication of origin: Aristomenes is from Aegium, a small town east of Patras. This piece of evidence has not as far as I know been taken into account in the long-standing scholarly discussion on whether the tale of Aristomenes in fact derives at least part of its content from an original tale in the lost Greek Metamorphoses.7 This seems to be clear in its implication: Aristomenes comes from the area of Patras just as his tale comes from the Metamorphoses attributed to Lucius of Patras. Likewise, the friend whom Aristomenes finds filthy and destitute, the ironically named Socrates,8 also goes to places of literary association. He states that he set off for Macedonia on business, but got only as far as Larissa in Thessaly before being attacked by robbers. The reader infers that Socrates comes from the same region or even city as Aristomenes, since when Aristomenes meets Socrates the first thing he says is that his family at home have given Socrates up for dead (1.6); there is no way of telling whether or not this is an element from the Greek Metamorphoses. Aristomenes encounters Socrates at the place to which both he and Lucius are travelling as the tale is being narrated, Hypata in Thessaly. As has been pointed out,9 this coincidence is meant to be a warning for Lucius that if he goes to Hypata he too will encounter danger in the context of sex and magic, a warning which Lucius characteristically ignores. Scholars have sometimes been puzzled by the hyperbolic description Aristomenes gives of Hypata, quae ————— 4
5 6 7 8 9
Kahane and Laird 2001. The contributions of Katherine Clarke and Doreen Innes to that volume (101–122) both treat in detail the topographical allusions in the prologue. See the discussion by Scobie 1975, 89–90, and that of Keulen 2000, 312. Cf. Brotherton 1934. Cf. esp. Lesky 1941, Keulen 2000. Cf. e.g. van der Paardt 1978, 82. Cf. Tatum 1969, 497 (reprinted in Harrison 1999, 166).
S . J . HARRI SON
42
civitas cunctae Thessaliae antepollet (1.5), since in the Roman Empire Hypata seems to have had some economic importance but was not the most important city in Thessaly, which was Larissa. This phrase appears to be a pun on the derivation of the name ‘Hypata’ from the Greek adjective Y/3# ‘highest, outstanding’ or verb ]/31$'‘be highest, be outstanding’ explicitly made after Apuleius in Heliodorus’ Aethiopica (2.34.2): Yy3/3!ã 3í í Y/311 /~ "%1 h!/2{.10 Since Hypata is Lucius’ destiny in the Onos too (Onos 1), there is every likelihood that Heliodorus shares this etymological play with the lost Greek Metamorphoses, and that its slightly confusing appearance here is a literary allusion rather than a report on the city’s current socio-political status, and possibly also a source of humour.11 Aristomenes’ tale also contains two well-known topographical allusions to Plato, as one might well expect in a narrative where one of the main characters is called Socrates. The Apuleian Socrates in the story is attacked en route to Larissa (1.7); the mention of this Thessalian city as a destination seems to recall a famous philosophical example put by the Platonic Socrates to the Thessalian Meno in Plato’s Meno, arguing that a man who knows the way to Larissa would be able to guide others there (Meno 97a). Equally literary is the moment when Aristomenes invites his friend the Apuleian Socrates to sit down by a plane tree (1.18) which turns out to be beside an attractive river (1.19); this, as many have noted,12 recalls the famous invitation of Phaedrus to the Platonic Socrates in Plato’s Phaedrus to sit down à deux under a plane tree next to the attractive river Ilissus (Phaedrus 229a–b). The effect of these two allusions is in my view a double one: not only literary allusion to some well-known texts (these are not the most obscure Platonic dialogues, and the author’s reading of Plato is meant to be noted),13 but also a programmatic suggestion early on in the novel that Plato may have some importance. This is not to say that the novel is in any sense a Platonic allegory, but rather that knowledge of certain Platonic dialogues will be a useful ————— 10
11
12 13
Scobie 1975, 91 cites the Heliodorus passage but does not note the shared pun. It is noted by Gianotti 1986, 12 n.4, who there regards this praise of Hypata as a major city as simply conventional (but see next note). Gianotti 1986, 22 attractively suggests en passant that the pun is ironically used – Hypata has a big name but a small reality. E.g. Tatum 1979, 27–8. On the prominence of the Phaedrus in the second century AD cf. Trapp 1990, esp. 171 on the popularity of the famous mise en scène in literary imitations.
LITERARY TOPOGRAPHY I N APULE I US ’ METAMORPHOSES
43
tool for the reader’s literary repertoire (to use a reader-response term)14 in interpreting the Metamorphoses.
2 Lucius, Corinth and Patrae One of the clearest modifications to the geography of the Onos in the Metamorphoses is the replacement of Patrae by Corinth as the home city of Lucius.15 The identity of Lucius’ home city is (like Lucius’ name) something that we learn only late in Book 1 of the Metamorphoses and then only by implication (1.22), typical of indirect Apuleian naming technique.16 This alteration seems to be for the benefit of the Roman reader, for whom Corinth was a much more prominent city than Patrae, both because of its richer cultural history and earlier contact with Rome17and because of its greater administrative and economic importance as the capital of the Roman province of Achaia by the second century A.D. (cf. Met.10.18 Corintho, quod caput est totius Achaiae provinciae). But it is also for the benefit of Apuleius’ plot: this relocation of Lucius allows his appearance in the arena at Corinth and his arrival at the Isis-festival at Cenchreae, the port of Corinth, to be a journey home, a kind of nostos, one of a number of ways in which the Metamorphoses echoes the plot-shape of the Odyssey.18 Consequently, in the Metamorphoses Corinth and Achaia replace the Thessalonica and Macedonia of the Onos (49) as the scene of Lucius’ appearance in the arena which forms the dénouement of the plot. This seems unlikely to be an alteration for the benefit of the Roman reader, since by the second century Thessalonica was the capital of the province of Macedonia and one of the major cities of the Empire; it may be that Apuleius wants to restrict his locations to central rather than northern Greece, perhaps reflecting his own career travels (though that can only be speculation). ————— 14
15
16 17 18
Associated with Wolfgang Iser (cf. Iser 1978). ‘Repertoire’ is conveniently defined by Maclean 1986, 131 as ‘the set of social, historical and cultural norms which the reader supplies as the necessary adjunct of his reading, but which the text calls forth and in some sense contains’. For other discussions of the motivation of the change see Luca Graverini’s paper in this volume, and especially Zimmerman 2000, 18 (with bibliography). Cf. n.6 above. See especially Luca Graverini’s paper in this volume. On the Odyssey and the Metamorphoses see the material gathered at Harrison 2000, 223.
S . J . HARRI SON
44
Apuleius’ change of Lucius’ birthplace is accompanied by other significant changes in the names of his family and associates. Lucius’ father in Apuleius is Theseus (1.23), a detail I have argued to be an invention for literary effect in evoking Callimachus’ Hecale;19 in the Onos, the name of Lucius’ father is famously missing when Lucius identifies himself to the magistrate at the arena in Thessalonica (55), most likely through textual damage, but since he is Lucius and identifies his brother in the same passage (55) as Gaius, picking up the two most common Roman praenomina, his father seems unlikely to have had the name of a Greek mythological hero. Lucius’ mother in Apuleius is named as Salvia (2.2), a firmly Roman name, with possible connections with high-ranking Romans of the period;20 in the extant Onos the name of Lucius’ mother is not recorded.21 The person who provides letters of introduction for Lucius in Hypata in the Onos is Decrianus of Patrae, a sophist (2); as we would expect, the Metamorphoses changes this person’s origin to Corinth (1.22), but also suppresses his profession and changes his name to Demeas. The suppression of the word ‘sophist’ may again be a concession to a Roman readership, for whom the word was not so significant; the change of name is certainly such a concession, since it bestows on the character a name which would be readily recognisable as belonging to New Comedy; characters named Demea(s) occur in the fragments of Menander, Caecilius and (most famously) Terence’s Adelphoe; this is one of many indications of Apuleian interest in Roman New Comedy, typical of his archaising age.22
3 Thelyphron – Miletus and Larissa (2.21). In the major tale of Book 2, Thelyphron narrates his own story of how he lost his nose and ears through contact with witches. This begins with two ————— 19 20
21
22
Cf. Harrison 1997, 56–7. Cf. Harrison 2000, 215. It is not clear how this can be related to the claim that Lucius’ mother is related to Plutarch, L. Mestrius Plutarchus (Met.1.2; Harrison 2000, 252). For more symbolic interpretations of the name Salvia cf. Van Mal-Maeder 1998, 82. It is quite possible that it too has fallen out at Onos 55 (though the Greek Lucius of the Onos elsewhere makes nothing of his maternal lineage, something important to Apuleius’ Lucius because of its supposed connection with Plutarch (see n.18 above). This aspect of Apuleius will be fully treated in the forthcoming Oxford doctoral dissertation of Regine May, ‘A Comic Novel: Roman and Greek New Comedy in Apuleius’ Metamorphoses’.
LITERARY TOPOGRAPHY I N APULE I US ’ METAMORPHOSES
45
geographical indications. First, Thelyphron tells us that he comes from Miletus, originally came to mainland Greece to visit the Olympics, and that he only got as far as Larissa where he had his unfortunate experience as a watcher of corpses (2.21): Pupillus ego Mileto profectus ad spectaculum Olympicum… peragrata cuncta Thessalia fuscis avibus Larissam accessi. This story-pattern of only getting as far as Larissa on a longer journey, and of encountering there a life-changing, ghostly and magical experience, clearly links him with the Aristomenes of Book 1, and Thelyphron’s tale clearly resembles that of Aristomenes in providing another unheeded warning to Lucius about the dangers of Thessalian magic.23 It is hard here to attribute any further literary significance to Larissa, apart perhaps from a small Platonic allusion. But plainly literary is Thelyphron’s Milesian origin. As I have noted elsewhere, Thelyphron’s claim to come from Miletus is a claim that his tale is Milesian in literary colour,24 showing the low-life sensationalism and (perhaps) witty reversal associated with the tradition of Milesian Tales associated with Aristides in Greek and Sisenna in Latin. Here a place has almost generic significance as a literary indicator; Thelyphron’s tale may be set amongst the witches of Thessaly, but its literary level and values are firmly Milesian.
4 Failed Expeditions: History, Epic, Tragedy and Robber Tales (4.9–21) The robber tales of Book 4, which may pick up some similar tales from the lost Greek Metamorphoses,25 have been discussed in various ways – as indicative of a whole tradition of robber-tales shared as a source with Greek novels,26 as echoes of suicides in historiography,27 as a confirmation of the existence of divine justice,28 and as parodies of epic heroism.29 Here I want to follow these general lines but to introduce new angles of literary allusion. ————— 23 24
25
26 27 28 29
Cf. Tatum 1969, 500–03 (reprinted in Harrison 1999, 168–71). Cf. Harrison 1998a, 69; the article as a whole attempts to reconstruct the character of the Milesian tradition. See still Lesky 1941, 54–5 and Onos 21 where there are clear indications that (similar?) narratives by the robbers have been omitted in the summarising process. Cf. Mackay 1963. Cf. Loporcaro 1992. Cf. Gianotti 1986, 53–77. Cf. Westerbrink 1978, Frangoulidis 1991, 1992.
S . J . HARRI SON
46
In this group of tales (Met.4.9–21) three sequential stories of robberexpeditions which are presented as glorious failures are narrated by an anonymous survivor who is anxious to defend his part of the robber-band for having seized little plunder. All three episodes concern heroic and tragic deaths of robber commanders – Lamachus, Alcimus and Thrasyleon. The last two names are clearly speaking names (‘Mighty’ and ‘Bold as a Lion’);30 I shall return to the name Lamachus in due course, but what is interesting from the perspective of literary geography is the pair of locations at which these deaths take place: Thebes and Plataea. The expedition led by the bold Lamachus to Thebes, I would argue, is a parody of the legendary epic and tragic expedition of the Seven Against Thebes. When Thebes is first named in the tale, it is named with a reference to its traditional seven gates which specifically recalls the seven doomed heroes of the mythological expedition, one at each gate (4.9 vix enim Thebas heptapylos accessimus).31 Furthermore, there is a clear structural parallel between the heroic failure of the Seven and the heroic failure of Lamachus, praised for his courage as if he were a legendary king or hero (4.8): inter inclitos reges ac duces proeliorum tanti viri memoris celebrabitur. That Lamachus gets his arm nailed to a door trying to break into a house, has to have it amputated to escape and then dies by suicide of course suggests that his expedition is a low-life and incompetent version of that of the Seven Against Thebes, but here as often we are dealing with the accommodation of high literary material of epic and tragedy to the more low-life and humorous world of the novel. In both cases we have a bold heroic enterprise which comes unstuck in ways appropriate to the particular literary genre. While the location of Thebes and the stress on heroic failure look back to the expedition of the Seven in epic and tragedy, Lamachus’ name looks back to another tragically failed expedition, this time from Athenian history. Both in name and in fate he recalls the Lamachus who perished as joint commander of the Sicilian expedition of 415 B.C. The Athenian Lamachus, the initial advocate of a full frontal attack on Syracuse, was killed with a few men in 414 after crossing a ditch and becoming isolated from the rest of the Athenian forces (Thucydides 6.101); this characteristic fatal overboldness is precisely picked up by the similar qualities of the Apuleian Lamachus, who is specifically said to have perished from excessive bravery (Met.4.8.8 sed ————— 30 31
Cf. e.g. Walsh 1970, 158. The seven gates of Thebes of course go back to Homer – cf. Hijmans et al. 1977, 78.
LITERARY TOPOGRAPHY I N APULE I US ’ METAMORPHOSES
47
illum quidem utcumque nimia virtus sua peremit). The bodies of both commanders are recovered and honourably disposed of by their troops; as has been noted, the maritime burial of the Apuleian Lamachus (4.11 mari celandum commisimus) is topographically very improbable as he dies at Thebes, a considerable distance from any coastline, but would be very suitable for the Thucydidean Lamachus killed in Sicily.32 This has been taken by earlier interpreters as a sign of Apuleian carelessness,33 but is better seen as an indication of a literary source and a direction of the reader’s attention to a classic heroic death.34 This echo of Athenian history, and of a tragic episode of Thucydides, is consistent with the location of the last of the three stories of heroic failure. There the robber-band, now under Thrasyleon, ‘bold as a lion’, move on to Plataea after their disasters at Thebes, where Thrasyleon perishes gloriously after a cunning plan to disguise him as a bear goes disastrously wrong. Again to readers of Athenian history this line of march has a notable model, namely the march of Mardonius, Persian commander and brother of Xerxes, towards the battle of Plataea: in Herodotus’account Mardonius goes to Thebes, a friendly power, and then on to defeat and death at nearby Plataea (Herodotus 9.13ff). There are resemblances between Herodotus’ Mardonius and Apuleius’ Thrasyleon other than the place of their death, though as ever the Apuleian version is a comic low-life parody. Both Mardonius and Thrasyleon perish fighting bravely, and in both cases the fate of the hero’s body is somewhat indeterminate: Thrasyleon’s body is abandoned to the men of Plataea still wrapped in its bearskin and nothing more is heard of it after the skin is taken off (4.21), while that of Mardonius disappears and there are many who claim to have buried it (9.84). Once again the echo is culturally plausible: Herodotus’ account of the Persian Wars was eagerly read by the Greeks of the Second Sophistic in their nostalgia for Hellenic greatness, and here, as in his use of Thucydides and in many other aspects of his work, Apuleius reflects the tendencies of the Greek literary culture of his own time.35 ————— 32
33 34
35
Cf. Walsh 1970, 158. There is no extant account of how the Athenian Lamachus was in fact buried. Cf. Walsh loc.cit., Perry 1967, 254. We may compare the evocation of the death of Pompey in that of Priam at Vergil Aeneid 2.554–8, which also involves logistical difficulties – cf. Austin 1964, 214. On the uses of Herodotus and Thucydides in the second century cf Swain 1996, 89–100, 486, 498.
S . J . HARRI SON
48
5 A Fantasy World? Literary Topography in Cupid and Psyche 5.1 Where does Psyche come from? The inserted tale of Cupid and Psyche is notoriously unspecific about its location, especially at its famous beginning, Erant in quadam civitate rex et regina (4.28),36 where neither city nor king and queen are named, an anonymity which persists throughout the tale; Psyche’s evil sisters and their husbands are never named, and even Psyche herself is named only after the tale is well under way (4.30). This lack of specific detail has been viewed as evidence of folk-tale origin, but is is rather a literary feature which is characteristic of this work in particular: the delayed naming of Psyche is a standard technique in the Metamorphoses,37 while the lack of specific names and location is a common feature of many of the inserted tales, perhaps something owed to the similarly anonymous scenarios of Roman declamation, which clearly exercises some influence on the plots of Apuleian sub-narratives.38 With in quadam civitate we may compare (for example) the opening of Seneca Contr.1.7: quidam alterum fratrem tyrannum occidit, alterum in adulterio deprecante patre interfecit. This unspecific monarchy is clearly not at Rome but is likely to be in the Greek world, probably in the Aegean; this can also be inferred from 4.29, which talks of the fame of Psyche’s beauty passing from her native city to neighbouring islands, and from 4.32, where Psyche’s father consults Apollo’s oracle at Didyma, presumably because Delphi is harder to get to. When Psyche is whisked off to the palace of Cupid, all specific geographical hints are abandoned, and the wanderings of Book 5–6 are not located in any recognisable landscape, apart from the use of Laconian Taenarus as the entrance to the underworld (see below). They do, however, as we shall see, refer to specific literary topographies.
————— 36
37 38
On the literariness (and novelistic colour) of the ‘once upon a time’ formula cf. Harrison 1998b, 64. Cf. n.6 above. Cf. Hijmans et al 1995, 297, Zimmerman 2000, 426, 428, and a paper by Danielle van Mal-Maeder at ICAN 3 2000 in Groningen, ‘La mise en scène déclamatoire chez les romanciers latins’ (summary in Zimmerman et al. 2000, 69–70). We look forward to her further researches on this topic.
LITERARY TOPOGRAPHY I N APULE I US ’ METAMORPHOSES
49
5.2 The irruption of Rome Given this general and unspecifically Greek character of the setting of Cupid and Psyche, it is all the more surprising when at Met. 6.8 Venus’ advertisement for the supposed runaway slave Psyche makes specific allusion to a well-known feature of the landscape of the city of Rome: Si quis a fuga retrahere vel occultam demonstrare poterit fugitivam regis filiam, Veneris ancillam, nomine Psychen, conveniat retro metas Murcias Mercurium praedicatorem… Here there is a clear reference to the long-established temple of Venus Murcia in the environs of the Circus Maximus, scornfully referred to by Apuleius’ fellow-African Tertullian a generation later in his attack on the immorality of the Circus (De Spectaculis 8).39 While any consistently realistic effect here is undermined by the evident contradiction that a king’s daughter is a slave-girl, there is clearly a reality jolt for the Roman reader, called back from the fantasy world of Cupid and Psyche to a very specifically Roman environment. This detail surely cannot belong to the perspective of the narrator of the tale of Cupid and Psyche, an anonymous and poor old woman who keeps house for a robber band in Boeotia; nor is it much more likely to belong to the reteller of the story, Lucius of Corinth the exass, even though he will have been living in Rome for some time by the point at which he narrates the events of the Metamorphoses.40 Here we see one of the reminders in the Metamorphoses that its ultimate narrator as author, its extradiegetic narrator, is Apuleius of Madauros, who here refers to a Roman landmark to show his readers his cosmopolitan acquaintance with the great metropolis of Rome itself.41 The reference is there for the Roman reader to get a handle on this otherwise unspecifically located tale, but it is also there as an index of the Latin culture of the writer, working in a province in Roman North Africa which is relatively close to Rome itself and could assume in its élite a knowledge of the imperial capital’s topography.42 ————— 39 40
41 42
Cf. further the discussion of this allusion in Luca Graverini’s paper in this volume. On the diversity of viewpoints in the narrative of Cupid and Psyche see Van Mal-Maeder and Zimmerman, 1998. On Roman colour in the Metamorphoses see Dowden 1994. On the Roman culture of Apuleius see esp. Harrison 2000, 1–3.
S . J . HARRI SON
50
In fact, this evocation of the Roman world in the midst of a Greek environment should not have come as a surprise in the context of the tale of Cupid and Psyche. For already there has been a strong indication of the Roman identity of the ultimate written narrator of the tale, in one of the more famous passages of the novel. At 4.32, when Psyche’s anonymous but kingly father enquires of Apollo’s oracle at Didyma as to what he should do about his daughter’s ill-health, the god replies in Latin: Sed Apollo, quamquam Graecus et Ionicus, propter Milesiae conditorem sic Latina sorte respondit … This reply in Latin is motivated by the Roman identity of the author of this Milesian tale (propter Milesiae conditorem); this can only be an allusion to Apuleius himself, as has been rightly emphasised,43 but it re-introduces an important literary toponym in the form of Milesiae. Here the Milesian links of the novel are stressed, just as they were in its prologue (sermone isto Milesio, 1.1) and in the tale of Thelyphron (see section 2 above). This has seemed paradoxical to some, since the tale of Cupid and Psyche in which this reference occurs is in many ways the least ‘Milesian’ part of the whole novel, with less low-life and sensationalist material. But as I have argued elsewhere, this allusion to Milesian tales may point not to their obscene content but to their narrative framework of inserted tales, a framework which the tale of Cupid and Psyche particularly exemplifies.44 5.3 Epic Topographies in Psyche’s Labours? I have argued elsewhere that the four labours set by Venus to Psyche and performed by the latter at Met.6.10–21 are a suitable reduction in both scale and tone for the context of the novel of the twelve labours of Hercules from Greek epic and tragedy.45 The first labour of sorting out seeds and grains has no specific location (6.10). The second labour of obtaining a tuft of wool from the flock of fierce golden sheep (6.11) is evidently something of a parody of the heroic quest for the Golden Fleece, as has often been noted. But commentators have not noted that the topographical details themselves too ————— 43 44 45
Cf. van der Paardt 1981 (reprinted in Harrison 1999, 237–46). Cf. Harrison 1998a. 69–70. Harrison 1998b, 61–3.
LITERARY TOPOGRAPHY I N APULE I US ’ METAMORPHOSES
51
look to the story of the Argonauts. The sheep with golden wool which are evidently a living version of the Golden Fleece also resemble the Fleece in their location as announced by Venus as she assigns the labour to Psyche (6.11): Videsne illud nemus, quod fluvio praeterluenti ripisque longis attenditur, cuius imi frutices vicinum fontem despiciunt? Oves ibi nitentis auri vero decore florentes incustodito pastu vagantur. Inde de coma pretiosi velleris floccum mihi confestim quoquo modo quaesitum afferas censeo. Here the sheep wander in a fearsome grove next to a river. This is surely an amusing version of the grove of Mars in the Argonaut saga, where the Golden Fleece is guarded by a fierce serpent, which is also close to the great river Phasis by which the Argonauts reach Colchis. In Apollonius’ account, which Apuleius surely knew, the Argonauts can see this grove as they sail up the Phasis (Arg.2.1268–9), and when they go to get the fleece they do so in the Argo, since the grove is close to the bank of the great river (Arg.4.100– 211).46 The third labour of fetching water from a fountain enters a conventional literary topography, that of the Underworld, but the only specific allusion there is to the waters of the infernal rivers of Styx and Cocytus. These conventional streams of the Underworld do suggest a Greek location, since Apuleius’ contemporary Pausanias at least identified them with two real Greek rivers; but their pairing here does not point to a realistic geographical location, since the ‘real’ river Styx was thought to be in Arcadia (Pausanias 8.17.6), the ‘real’ river Cocytus in Epirus (id.1.17.5). The fourth labour, that of bringing back some of the beauty of Proserpina from the Underworld, puts us firmly in the realm of the epic katabasis, though once again this is tempered by comic and parodic details which remind us that we are still in the world of the novel: the only route Psyche can initially think of to the Underworld is through suicide (6.17), but the tower from which she is about to jump in one of the traditional forms of suicide (a version of an old joke
————— 46
These details occur only in the Apollonian version (that of Valerius Flaccus does not describe the grove), though of course the lost version of Varro Atacinus may have been a source here. For the likelihood that Apuleius knew Apollonius directly cf. e.g. Mattiacci 1998, 130,134 and the list of allusions in Cupid and Psyche at Kenney 1990, 240.
52
S . J . HARRI SON
from Aristophanes’ Frogs)47 tells her of another way. Here we find a quite specific geographical location, for the first time in the tale (6.18): Lacedaemo Achaiae nobilis civitas non longe sita est: huius conterminam deviis abditam locis quaere Taenarum. ‘Sparta, that noble city of Achaea, is located not far away; look for its neighbour Taenarus, concealed in an out-ofthe-way region’. Here we have a famous Greek city (Sparta) and its contemporary location in a province of the second-century Roman empire (Achaia), presumably as some kind of realistic detail for the Roman reader who would certainly recognise these names; but we are not dealing with great precision here, since Taenarus, said here to be close to Sparta, is in fact more than fifty miles away across the great range of Taygetus. Taenarus itself, a location which has already occurred in the prologue to the Metamorphoses, apparently as a metonym for Sparta (1.1.Taenaros Spartiatica), has a strongly literary role in Psyche’s katabasis, since (as I have argued elsewhere) it points us towards one of the two Vergilian sources for Psyche’s descent to the world below.48 That Psyche’s katabasis is a version of that of Aeneas in the sixth book of the Aeneas is well known,49 but that katabasis of course took place through an Italian entrance to the Underworld at Lake Avernus on the Bay of Naples. Taenarus as gateway to the world below comes from the other great Vergilian katabasis, that of Orpheus in Georgic 4: Taenarum at Met.6.18 picks up Taenarias… fauces at Georgics 4.472. This is clearly symbolic and intertextual topography, indicating that Psyche’s katabasis will have a significant relationship to that of Orpheus, as indeed it will: both Psyche and Orpheus go to the Underworld to fetch something back to the world above but ruin their enterprises by looking at the object they have been ordered to fetch but also not to look at,50 though of course Apuleius’ story, being in a novel, ends in a happy result which Vergil’s tale does not.
6 Haemus the Thracian (7.5–8) The story of Charite, the narratee of the tale of Cupid and Psyche, who is melodramatically rescued by her fiancé Tlepolemus disguised as a robber, ————— 47 48 49 50
Frogs 129–135; Cf. e.g. Kenney 1990, 212. Cf. Harrison 1997, 68. Cf. esp. Finkelpearl 1990 (reprinted in Harrison 1999, 290–306). Cf. Kenney 1990, 216–7.
LITERARY TOPOGRAPHY I N APULE I US ’ METAMORPHOSES
53
and who then perishes in an equally melodramatic episode of revenge and suicide, is one of the passages from the original Greek Metamorphoses which is most obviously expanded and modified in Apuleius’ version. The Greek original has a much smaller role for the unnamed fiancé, also fails to give any name to the Charite character, and has her and her new husband perish in a tragic accident rather than in a lurid cycle of murder and suicide. Apuleius’ version of Charite’s end has long been observed to owe much to the suicide of Dido in Vergil’s Aeneid,51 and his version of the false story told by Tlepolemus of his daring deeds as the robber-chief Haemus is also heavily elaborated with detail which we can assume is Apuleian, not least the way in which Tlepolemus, with his cunning disguise, his lying tale, his defeat of a hostile group against the odds and his recovery of his rightful wife is a clear version of the Homeric Odysseus.52 Here, however, I want to concentrate on the topography of the lying tale of banditry which Tlepolemus, presenting himself as Haemus, tells to the robbers. The topographical references found near the beginning of the tale clearly form a strategy of detailed authentication, urging respect for and belief in the speaker through detail, as well as a further handle for the Roman reader in mentioning the real province of Macedonia (7.5): Nam praefui validissimae manui totamque prorsus devastavi Macedoniam. Ego sum praedo famosus Haemus ille Thracius cuius totae provinciae nomen horrescunt, patre Therone aeque latrone inclito prognatus … As has been pointed out,53 Haemus’ name both alludes expressively to his bloodthirstiness through its association with Greek /C/ and points to the mountain-range of Haemus in his supposed home region of Thrace. But as has also been pointed out,54 the reference to Haemus’ father Theron (‘Hunter’) is a literary allusion, to the robber Theron in Chariton’s Callirhoe, who kidnaps Callirhoe and sells her into slavery in the first book of that novel but later gets his just deserts in the third where he is crucified. The effect of the double fictionality of Haemus, named with clear improvisation after a Greek mountain landscape and after a previous fictional robber, is here surely ————— 51 52 53 54
Cf. Harrison 1997, 63–5. Cf. Harrison 1990, Frangoulidis 1992. Cf. Hijmans 1978, 115. Hijmans 1978, 116 n.46.
S . J . HARRI SON
54
a clever hint to the reader (if not to the listening Charite) that Haemus’ claimed descent is as fictional and pretended as the rest of his disguise. The main content of the false Haemus’ tale is the story of Plotina, a noble lady who was instrumental both in saving her husband and in destroying Haemus’ own previous robber-band, clearly intended to suggest that Charite too will be reunited with her husband and that the robbers will be destroyed. Here once again we are given some realistic locations: Plotina (a good Roman name, possibly echoing that of Trajan’s empress Pompeia Plotina)55 and her unnamed husband clearly originate in Rome, since the husband is multis officiis in aula Caesaris clarus atque conspicuus, ‘famed and renowned for his many services at the court of Caesar’ (7.6), and their place of exile is set as the Greek Ionian island of Zacynthos (Zante), which they head for by ship. It is on this journey that they supposedly encounter the robber-band of Haemus at a very specific location (7.7): Sed cum primum litus Actiacum, quo tunc Macedonia delapsi grassabamur, appulisset … invadimus et diripimus omnia – ‘but as soon as he landed on the Actian shore, where we were then in operation having come down from Macedonia … we charged in and ransacked the whole lot’. Haemus’ band has come to the western edge of the Roman province of Macedonia, to the shore of Actium. This is a realistic point to intercept a seavoyage from Rome to Zante, but it is also of course an extremely famous military location, and in Latin before Apuleius the adjective Actiacus is used largely in contects referring to the battle of Actium in 31 B.C.56 What we have here is a second, novelistic battle of Actium, suitably transformed to suit the different genre – not a mighty conflict on sea and land to determine the fate of the known world, but a one-sided affair in which the land-based robbers pillage a ship which has put at the shore. The very Roman and virtuous Plotina, travelling supportively with her unnamed husband to exile, can also be seen as an inverted version of the historical Cleopatra, a foreign paramour, but similarly defeated with her husband (though in different ships) at the same place. In conclusion, these examples show that topographical references in Apuleius’ Metamorphoses can operate as bearers of intertextual literary allusion, either by themselves or as part of a larger complex. This is true not ————— 55 56
Cf. Hijmans et al. 1981, 121. Propertius 2.15.44 Actiacum … mare, Manilius 5.52 Actiacosque sinus (= Petronius Sat. 121v.115).
LITERARY TOPOGRAPHY I N APULE I US ’ METAMORPHOSES
55
only in respect of the Greek Metamorphoses, the major putative model of Apuleius’ novel, but also in respect of a wide range of other literary texts. It is therefore not surprising that most of the literary topographical allusions occur in the inserted tales, which allow Apuleius the greatest flexibility of invention. These allusions, characteristically, not only demonstrate knowledge of famous and elevated genres and events (epic, tragedy, the great battles of Greek and Roman history and literature), but also adapt those elements by parody and ironic reprocessing for their reappearance in the less elevated genre of the Roman novel.57
Bibliography Austin, R.G. 1964. P.Vergili Maronis Aeneidos Liber Secundus, Oxford: Oxford UP. Brotherton, B. 1934. ‘The introduction of characters by name in the Metamorphoses of Apuleius’, CPh 29: 36–52. De Biasi, L. 2000. ‘Le descrizioni del paesaggio naturale nelle opere di Apuleio: aspetti letterari’ in G. Magnaldi and G.F. Gianotti, eds., Apuleio: storia del testo e interpretazioni, Alessandria: Turin, 199–264. Dowden, K. 1994. ‘The Roman Audience of the Golden Ass’ in J. Tatum, ed., 419– 34. Finkelpearl, E. 1990. ‘Psyche, Aeneas and an Ass: Apuleius Met. 6.10–6.21’, TAPA 120: 333–348 Frangoulidis, S.A. 1991. ‘Vergil’s Tale of the Trojan Horse in Apuleius’ RobberTale of Thrasyleon’, PP 46: 95–111. Frangoulidis, S.A. 1992. ‘Epic inversion in Apuleius’ tale of Tlepolemus/Haemus’, Mnemosyne 45: 60–74. Gianotti, G.F. 1986. ‘Romanzo’ e ideologia: studi sulle Metamorfosi di Apuleio. Napoli: Liguori. Harrison, S.J. 1997. ‘From Epic to Novel: Apuleius as Reader of Vergil’, MD 39: 53–74. Harrison, S.J. 1998a. ‘The Milesian Tales and the Roman Novel’, Groningen Colloquia on the Novel 9: 61–73 Harrison, S.J. 1998b. ‘Some Epic Structures in Cupid and Psyche’, in M. Zimmerman et al., Aspects of Apuleius’ Golden Ass II: Cupid and Psyche: Groningen, Egbert Forsten, 51–68. Harrison, S.J., ed. 1999. Oxford Readings in the Roman Novel, Oxford: Oxford UP.
————— 57
I would like to thank Michael Paschalis and Stavros Frangoulidis for their kind invitation to speak in Rethymnon, for their organisation of an enjoyable conference, and for their warm hospitality. I am also very grateful to Maaike Zimmerman for her very helpful editorial comments on my paper.
56
S . J . HARRI SON
Harrison, S.J. 2000. Apuleius: A Latin Sophist, Oxford: Oxford UP. Hijmans Jr., B.L., ‘Significant Names and their Function in Apuleius’ Metamorphoses’ in Hijmans and van der Paardt 1978, 107–22 Hijmans Jr,. B.L et. al 1977. Apuleius Madaurensis Metamorphoses Books IV 1–27, Groningen: Egbert Forsten. Hijmans Jr.,B.L et al. 1981., Apuleius Madaurensis Metamorphoses Books VI 25–32 and VII, Groningen: Egbert Forsten. Hijmans Jr., B.L et al. 1985. Apuleius Madaurensis Metamorphoses Book VIII 1–27, Groningen: Egbert Forsten. Hijmans Jr., B.L et al. 1995, Apuleius Madaurensis Metamorphoses Book IX, Groningen: Egbert Forsten. Hijmans Jr., B.L. and van den Paardt, R. Th., eds. 1978. Aspects of Apuleius’ Golden Ass Groningen: Egbert Forsten. Holzberg, N. 1984. ‘Apuleius und der Verfasser des griechischen Eselromans’, WJA 10: 161–78. Iser, W. 1978. The Act Of Reading, London: Routledge. Kahane, A. and Laird, A. eds. 2001. A Companion to the Prologue of Apuleius’ Metamorphoses, Oxford: Oxford UP. Kenney, E.J. 1990. Apuleius: Cupid and Psyche, Cambridge, Cambridge UP. Keulen, W. 2000. ‘Significant Names in Apuleius: A “Good Contriver” and his Rival in the Cheese Trade (Met.1,5)’, Mnemosyne 53: 310–21. Lesky, A. 1941. ‘Apuleius von Madauros und Lukios von Patrai’, Hermes 76: 43–74 Loporcaro, M. 1992. ‘Eroi screditati dal testo: strutture della parodia nelle storie di briganti in Apuleio Met. IV.9–21’, Maia 44: 65–78. Mackay, P.A. 1963. ‘Klephtika: the Tradition of the Tales of Banditry in Apuleius’, G&R 10: 147–52. Maclean, I. 1986. ‘Reading and Interpretation’, in: Ann Jefferson and David Robey, eds., Modern Literary Theory: A Comparative Introduction, London: Batsford, 122–144. Mason, H.J. 1999. ‘The Metamorphoses of Apuleius and its Greek sources’ in H. Hofmann, ed., Latin Fiction: The Latin Novel in Context. London: Routledge, 103–112. Mattiacci, S. 1998. ‘Neoteric and Elegiac Echoes in the tale of Cupid and Psyche’ in M. Zimmerman et al., eds., 127–50. Perry, B.E. 1967. The Ancient Romances. Berkeley: California UP. Schiesaro, A. 1985. ‘Il ‘locus horridus’ nelle ‘Metamorfosi’ di Apuleio, Met.IV.28– 35’, Maia 37: 211–223. Scobie, A. 1975. Apuleius Metamorphoses (Asinus Aureus) I, Peter Lang: Meisenheim am Glan. Swain, S.C.R. 1996. Hellenism and Empire, Oxford: Oxford UP. Tatum, J. 1979. Apuleius and the Golden Ass. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell UP. Tatum, J., ed. 1994. The Search for the Ancient Novel. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins UP Trapp, M.B. 1990. ‘Plato’s Phaedrus in Second-Century Greek Literature’ in D.A.Russell, ed., Antonine Literature, Oxford: Oxford UP, 141–174. Trinquier, J. 1999. ‘Le motif du repaire des brigands et le topos du locus horridus: Apulée, Métamorphoses, IV, 6’, RPh 73, 257–277.
LITERARY TOPOGRAPHY I N APULE I US ’ METAMORPHOSES
57
van der Paardt, R.Th. 1978. ‘Various aspects of narrative technique in Apuleius’ Metamorphoses’ in Hijmans and van der Paardt, 75–94. van der Paardt, R.Th. 1981. ‘The Unmasked ‘I’: Apuleius Met.XI.27’, Mnemosyne 34: 96–106. van Mal-Maeder, D. 1998. Apulée, Les Métamorphoses. Livre II,1–20. Groningen: Rijksuniversiteit Groningen. van Mal-Maeder, D. and Zimmerman, M. 1998. ‘The Many Voices in Cupid and Psyche’ in Zimmerman et al., eds., 83–102. Walsh, P.G. 1970. The Roman Novel. Cambridge: Cambridge UP. Walsh, P.G. 1974. ‘Bridging the Asses’, CR n.s. 24: 215–8. Westerbrink, A.G. 1978. ‘Some Parodies in Apuleius’ Metamorphoses’ in Hijmans and van der Paardt, eds., 63–73. Zimmerman, M. et al, eds., 1998. Aspects of Apuleius’ Golden Ass II: Cupid and Psyche. Groningen: Egbert Forsten. Zimmerman, M. 2000. Apuleius Madaurensis Metamorphoses X. Text, Introduction and Commentary. Groningen: Egbert Forsten.
Corinth, Rome, and Africa: a Cultural Background for the Tale of the Ass LUCA GRAVERINI
Siena – Arezzo
The pseudo-Lucianic Onos, even though its geographical references are not particularly detailed, allows the reader to follow the main character’s travels with a certain degree of precision. Lucius is from Patrae, in Achaia; he arrives in Hypata and then, by travelling northwards in Thessaly and Macedonia, proceeds up to Thessalonike. In that city he is restored to human shape, and from there he sails back to his homeland. In Apuleius’ Metamorphoses, on the other hand, Lucius is from Corinth.1 At the beginning of the novel, we find him on the road to Hypata but then, after his abduction by the robbers, the geographical setting becomes indefinite and it is clear only that he is wandering in Thessaly. We return to a recognisable, concrete world again only when the ass arrives in CorinthKenchreai (10,19,1)2 where the final metamorphosis takes place. Here too, as in the Onos, this metamorphosis is followed by a sea voyage. But instead of travelling to his homeland the hero is taken to Rome (11,26,1) where, in the novel’s final chapter, he undergoes his final initiation. The uncertainty of Lucius’ whereabouts after his initial metamorphosis is normally explained either as a folk-tale feature of the novel, and/or a concession to Apuleius’ ‘Romanocentric readership’:3 his readers, the argument ————— 1
2
3
In 1,22,4 he claims to have a letter of presentation by a Corinthian named Demeas; more explicitly in 2,12,3 Lucius says Corinthi… apud nos (‘at Corinth, where I live’). Cf. Zimmerman 2000, 11 and n. 18; and Niall Slater’s contribution to this volume, p. 173. The arrival of the ass in Corinth has been carefully prepared for in the first two books by the allusions to Lucius’ Corinthian origins: cf. Zimmerman 2000 ad 10,19,1. Anyway, it should be noted that, when he arrives in Corinth, he gives no sign of recognizing the city as his fatherland. Harrison 1998, 64 f.
CORINTH , ROME , AND AFRI CA
59
goes, were probably not interested in details about the geography and landscape of central Greece, and presumably not really able to understand them. I think that these are valid points, and I shall try to offer a more detailed analysis of the second of these in a later part of this paper; but I would also like to suggest that the novel’s lack of geographical specificity results also from other literary choices made by Apuleius, especially his decision to have Lucius come from Corinth and to place there his restoration to human shape. After making these changes to the plot, Apuleius still had to carry through with the plot of his model, now in a different geographical setting. For the most part, then, he leaves Lucius’ travels unmapped. Now we could ask ourselves why, by placing Lucius’ origins and his retransformation in Corinth instead of Patrai and Thessalonike, Apuleius introduced such an important change to the original plot. Scholars of course have already debated this issue, the most important treatment being a contribution by Hugh Mason.4 Here are, briefly, the most important reasons which have been adduced so far for this change: – Corinth was better known to the Latin audience than Thessalonike (again the idea of a ‘Romanocentric readership’). – Corinth was also well known as a rich but corrupt and immoral city: therefore it was, by contrast, a good setting for the chastity and purity of Lucius, converted to the Isiac faith. – Corinth was an important centre of the cult of Isis. There is also the point made made by Stephen Harrison:5 Lucius makes an Odyssean nostos (homeward journey) by returning to Corinth at the end of his wanderings, and this is of course a point well worth considering to explain the high-level structure and the epic flavour of the novel. Anyway, if Lucius is a Roman citizen (this is clear in the Onos, though the point is not stressed in the Metamorphoses6), then maybe his real nostos is the travel to ————— 4 5 6
Mason 1971, 160–165; see also Veyne 1965, 241–251 and Zimmerman 2000, 18. Harrison, in this volume p. 43. In Onos 55 Lucius has the tria nomina of a Roman citizen: ‘my name is Lucius, and that of my brother Gaius, and the other two names we share with our father’. Metamorphoses 9,39,3 makes clear that Lucius can understand the Latin-speaking soldier, and the Latin language is necessary of course also in the forensic activity he will practice in Rome (11,28,6). Cf. also Bowersock 1965, 289; Mason 1983; Mason 1994, 1681 f.; Harrison 2000, 215 f.; a different view in Walsh 1968.
60
LUCA GRAVE RI NI
Rome: a sea voyage, the direction from East to West, and Rome as the final destination also seem more in keeping with Odysseus and Aeneas. The idea of a nostos to Rome could also make more sense in a comparison with the Onos where the hero, as we have seen, sails back to his homeland after the end of his (mis)adventures.7 In my opinion, each of the other arguments considered above has its pros and cons. However, I think that the most important, the one which in a sense encapsulates all the others, is the first: Corinth was more familiar to the ‘intended audience’ of a novel written in Latin. Indeed, even if it was not so rich as Corinth, Patrae was also a very prosperous city;8 and the cult of Isis, Osiris and Sarapis is well attested for Thessalonike too.9 Rome itself was of course very rich, had temples and devotees of Isis, and in terms of its fame for moral corruption the city was probably second to none. Apuleius could have chosen Rome as the setting for the whole plot, or at least for the part from the retransformation onwards, and not only for the last chapters of the novel. On the contrary, we must note that the Metamorphoses also corresponds well enough with the lost Greek original in terms of topography, so much so that almost the whole plot is set in central Greece. The most remarkable exception, which is probably the main cause of the novel’s geographical inspecifity, is the important role played by Corinth: for some reason, the Corinthian setting and the journey from Greece to Rome were tempting choices for Apuleius.10 Corinth was indeed well known for its wealth, moral corruption and the cult of Isis11 but, as we have seen, these facts become meaningful only at the end of the Metamorphoses, when they contrast with the retransformation and conversion of Lucius; they have little point at the beginning, when Corinth is simply introduced as the birthplace of the main character. I also wonder if ————— 7
8
9 10
11
See anyway Niall Slater’s paper in this volume (p. 175), where Lucius’ voyage to Rome is regarded as an exile. Corinth, Athens and Patrae were ‘the three centers of commercial and banking activities in Greece’: Wiseman 1979, 507. Sources in Griffiths 1975, 15 and n. 4; 330; 349 f. As a minor suggestion, it is also worth mentioning the fact that Corinth was a centre of the cult of Pegasus and Bellerophon: see Engels 1990, 99 ff. The mythical couple is alluded to at 6,30,5; 7,26,3; 8,16,3; 11,8,4; the winged horse (a winged ass in the last passage) seems to be a paradoxical symbol for Lucius, who tried to become a bird and was turned into an ass. Wealth and corruption: Wiseman 1979, 508; cult of Isis: Engels 1990, 102 ff.
CORINTH , ROME , AND AFRI CA
61
wealth, corruption, and the cult of Isis were actually the first ideas that a reference to Corinth evoked in the literate Latin reader. I would point rather to a fact which, while obvious perhaps, has always been neglected in this field of study: Corinth was one of the most prosperous Greek cities until it was razed to the ground by a Roman army led by Lucius Mummius in 146 BC; after that year, Corinth was on the whole deleted from Greek geography until it was rebuilt and repopulated as a Roman colony by Caesar.12 In order to evaluate the conjecture that this history of Corinth is somehow meaningful in the Metamorphoses, it is useful to consider briefly the immense resonance that it had in both Greek and Latin culture. The destruction of Corinth, and that of Carthage which occurred a few months earlier, marked a turning point in the Mediterranean politics of Rome: by that time the City was confident in its dominant role and ready to defend its interests at any cost. So Corinth and Carthage, ‘the two jewels of the sea-cost’ (Cicero, ND 3,91), two cities that could ‘bear the weight and the name of an empire’, were destroyed ‘so that they could never rise again’ (Cicero, Agr. 2,87). This Ciceronian embarrassment sets out the reasons for a Roman policy which, however, was not entirely without remorse; the orator himself acknowledges that ‘through a specious appearance of expediency wrong is very often committed in transactions between state and state, as by our own country in the destruction of Corinth’13 (Off. 3,46). Even more telling is Florus, Epit. 1,32,1: ‘as though that age could only run its course by the destruction of cities, the ruin of Carthage was immediately followed by that of Corinth, the capital of Achaea, the glory of Greece… this city, by an act unworthy of the Romans, was overwhelmed before it could be accounted in the number of their declared enemies’.14 If the Romans cried crocodile tears, we can easily imagine the universal mourning that the destruction of Corinth, ‘the bright star of Greece’ (Diodorus Siculus 32,27,1), aroused in the Hellenistic world. As far as I know, its first literary echo is in an epigram by the Egyptian Polystratus (AG 7,297):
————— 12
13 14
On the history and archaeology of Corinth, besides Wiseman 1979 and Engels 1990, see Gilman Romano 2000. On Kenchreai: Hohlfelder 1976. Trans. Miller 1975. Trans. Forster 1984.
62
LUCA GRAVE RI NI
Lucius has smitten sore the great Achaean Acrocorinth, the star of Hellas… and the sons of Aeneas left unwept and unhallowed by funeral rites the Achaeans who burnt the house of Priam.15 The general’s identity is here partially concealed, since only his praenomen Lucius is quoted (whereas the Greek version of his nomen, Mommios, would also have fitted the meter); the result is a generic mention of a Roman destroyer. In Polystratus’ view, the destruction of Corinth is more the nemesis of history than a consequence of the acts of a single general: it is vengeance taken by the descendants of Aeneas on the Greeks for the destruction of Troy. It was an epic deed and Virgil, who alludes to Mummius also in the show of heroes (A. 6,836 f. ‘he… triumphant over Corinth, shall drive a victor’s chariot to the lofty Capitol, famed for Achaeans he has slain’16) seems to share this view in Aen. 1,284 ‘there shall come a day… when the house of Assaracus shall bring into bondage Phthia and famed Mycenae, and hold lordship over vanquished Argos’.17 Servius clears up the mythological reference: ‘house of Assaracus: that is the Trojan family… Assaracus begot Capys, Capys begot Anchises, and he gave birth to Aeneas progenitor of the Romans; from them came Mummius, who defeated the Achaeans’.18 In other texts, a paternalistic attitude replaces the idea of vengeance for Troy: a trend started by Titus Flamininus, who in an inscription in Delphi calls himself the Aineadas Titos vouching for the freedom of the Greeks (Plutarch, Flam. 12,11). Plutarch (Quaest. conv. 9,2,737A) describes to us a Mummius moved to tears at the sight of a young Corinthian slave, who compares his fate with that of the Greeks who died before Troy writing a verse of Homer (Od. 5,306). Mourning for the loss of such an important city and for the countless great works of art that adorned it19 naturally recurs in Greek historians and geogra————— 15 16 17 18
19
Trans. Paton 1960. Trans. Fairclough 1999. Trans. Fairclough 1999. These verses of Virgil, and their interpretation by Servius, are influenced for Nenci 1978, 1016 by a propagandistic tradition started by the same L. Mummius. Anyway, this seems to be impossible, since the idea is already in the epigram by Polystratus quoted above in the text; for a confutation of Nenci’s point see Graverini 2001, 143 ff. Alcock 1993, 179 rightly emphasizes also the religious and political implications of the plunderings suffered by Corinth and other Greek cities: ‘depriving one’s enemy of sacred
CORINTH , ROME , AND AFRI CA
63
phers like Polybius, Pausanias and Diodorus Siculus. However, after the end of the war between Greece and Rome, it became common (and safer) to add to this grief a sense of relief for the generosity of Julius Caesar, who made the city come back to life.20 Even though it was the thoughtlessness of the leaders of the Achaean League that saddled them with full responsibility for the conflict, the severity of the Roman response was hard for the Greeks to accept, even for those most loyal to Rome (like Polybius, who seems to consider the doom of Corinth a just price to pay for a higher purpose). When Pausanias describes the monuments of Corinth, he also thinks back to the history of the city; and, although there is no explicit anti-Roman criticism, nevertheless ‘his detailed narrative reflects his own often expressed concern for Greece’s freedom and dignity’.21 Crinagoras, in Greek Anthology 9,284, regrets in no uncertain terms the quality of the new population of Corinth: What inhabitants, O luckless city, hast thou received, and in place of whom? Alas for the great calamity of Greece!22 As part of the Corinthian war booty, enormous wealth and a massive quantity of works of art arrived in Rome and this was not without effect on Roman society. Pliny the Elder disapproves of the laxity of morals induced by the great Mediterranean victories in the 2nd century BC and specifies that ‘the victory over the Achaean League, from which statues and paintings came to Rome, had a great importance in the decline of morality’ (NH 33,149; cf. also Livy 34,4,4). Eutropius 4,14,2 describes for us the three great triumphs celebrated in Rome in that year 145 BC: Africanus Minor and Metellus had, respectively, Hasdrubal and Andriscus marching before their chariots; but before the chariot of Mummius, who had no captured enemy generals to show, ‘bronze statues and paintings and other ornaments of that most celebrated city were carried’. Here we have no space to discuss the link between the Corinthian booty and the unbridled enthusiasm of the Romans for Greek and Oriental art; nor can we speak about their distinctive eclectic ————— 20 21 22
objects and possessing them yourself served two related purposes: defeating them in perpetuity and adding the power of their gods to your own symbolic arsenal’. Polybius 39,2 (from Strabo 8,6,28); Pausanias 7,17,17; Diodorus Siculus 32,27,1. Swain 1996, 338; see also Bowie 1996, 216 ff. Trans. Paton 1960.
64
LUCA GRAVE RI NI
tastes induced by the continuous stream of works of art flowing from every nation into public and private collections in Rome. Instead it will suffice simply to mention the celebrated ‘Corinthian bronze’: the ancients believed that this alloy had been created in the destruction of Corinth, when the immense heat of the fire melted and mixed bronze and noble metals. Modern scholars debate not only the composition but the very existence of such an alloy. And yet, the metal unquestionably had a long and glorious literary life and this is attested, for example, by a brilliant Petronian parody.23 It was almost inevitable that Corinth should become a perennial symbol of the relationship between Greece and Rome: it was here that Flamininus and later the emperor Nero announced the freedom and independence of Greece;24 between these two announcements there was, in sharp contrast, the armed intervention by Mummius. In the characterization of the city, history seems to echo and/or foreshadow the same ideological patterns we can trace in the literary sources. The Romans, thanks also to the Corinthian booty, intensified their Hellenization and developed a passion for Greek art; the Greeks, however, were always reluctant to lay down the crown of their cultural excellence. It is precisely in Corinth that Favorinus of Arles (an author whose spiritual proximity with Apuleius is stressed by Paul Vallette and Gerald Sandy25) played upon this feeling of superiority, itself deeply rooted in the genetic code of the Greeks, but also powerfully felt among the Romanized Greeks, citizens of a Corinth that was by then a Roman colony: If some one who is… a Roman, not one of the masses but of the equestrian order, one who has affected, not merely the language, but also the thought and manners and dress of the Greeks… – for while the best of the Greeks over there [i. e. in Rome] may be seen inclining toward Roman ways, he inclines toward the Greek,… not only to seem Greek but to be Greek too – taking all this into consideration, ought he not to have a ————— 23
24
25
Petronius 50,5. On the infusion of Greek art into Rome as war booty see Pape 1975; on Corinthian bronze, Jacobson-Weitzman 1995. The cutting of the Isthmus by Nero also gave the opportunity for a dispute concerning Roman and Greek identities: cf. Whitmarsh 1999. On the tight connection of Corinth to Rome, and the ‘informal and symbolic threads’ that bound the Greek city to the capital of the empire, see Alcock 1993, 168 f. Vallette 1908, 187 ff.; Sandy 1997, 93 ff.
CORINTH , ROME , AND AFRI CA
65
bronze statue here in Corinth? Yes,… because, though Roman, he has become thoroughly hellenized, even as your own city has…26 Favorinus praises Corinth as a Roman colony that by that time was thoroughly Hellenized: and it is clear that, for the orator as well as for his audience, this was a remarkable improvement. Favorinus was himself a Roman who became Hellenized, but many others remained true specimens of ignorance. Thus, beyond chastising Mummius as the destroyer of Corinth, Favorinus criticizes him as a typically ‘ignorant’ Roman who wrote the name of Nestor and Priam (two heroes always described in ripe old age) under the statues of two young Arcadian men. The whole population of Rome fell into the same error: the Roman mob, as might have been expected, imagined they were beholding those very heroes, and not mere Arcadians from Pheneus.27 With this brief survey I hope to have enriched the picture of the ideas and emotions that Corinth could awaken in a literate reader of Apuleius’ age, Greek or Roman. Not only was it a rich city, and immoral, and a centre of the cult of Isis; it was, even more, a powerful symbol of cultural identity. Its expressive potential was always ambivalent: a Roman could use the symbol of Corinth to celebrate the greatness of his people and the vengeance of Aeneas’ descendants over the destroyers of Troy. A Greek could use it to lament his loss of freedom, and to give vent to his bitterness for the injustices he had suffered, or even to make of it the emblem of his cultural superiority. In this context, it is not difficult to see the close relationship between the city of Corinth and the Metamorphoses. Corinth is not only the native town of the main character and the place where he regains human shape: it is also mentioned in the prologue – together with Athens and Sparta, the two other symbols of Greek civilization – as the fatherland of the novel itself (of course, I am accepting here Harrison’s hypothesis of the book itself as the speaker of the prologue28). It is at once an ideal and a literary connection: ————— 26
27 28
[Dio Chrysostom] 37, 25–26; trans. Crosby 1986. On the construction of Greek identity in Favorinus’ Corinthian oration see Whitmarsh 2001, 295 ff. [Dio Chrysostom] 37, 42; trans. Crosby 1986. Harrison 1990; cf. also Harrison 2000, 227 f. and Nicolai 1999, who adopts Harrison’s point to some extent. Kahane-Laird 2001 appeared too late to be considered in this paper.
66
LUCA GRAVE RI NI
Athens, Corinth, and Sparta are called ‘fruitful lands preserved for ever in even more fruitful books’.29 The book is thus deeply rooted in a literary tradition which is connected with Greece as a whole. The prologue describes also a book that travels. After an ‘early youth’ spent in Greece, it moves very soon (mox) to Rome, where with hard work (aerumnabilis labor) it improves its language. We can see in this passage a clear allusion to the Greek origins of the ass’s story which Apuleius imported to Rome, translated into Latin and elaborated with hard work to gain higher literary glory. By placing Lucius in Corinth, the novel alludes from its very beginning to the relationship between Greece and Rome, which is indeed an important idea in the Metamorphoses, a Latin adaptation of a Greek original. The main character of the novel follows this pattern, since his adventures begin in Greece and conclude in Rome. Rome itself was full of artworks, marbles, bronzes and paintings which either came from Corinth and Greece as a result of war booty or were imported by art dealers; we can integrate the Metamorphoses, defined as a fabula graecanica by the prologue, into this same trend. The constant exploitation of preceding literature, and the frequent practice of literary furtum, are characteristic of its style and composition: just like the Romans of the 2nd century BC, Apuleius could be defined, with a bit of exaggeration and fancy, as a plunderer of works of art. Of course, when speaking about the idea of Corinth as a literary symbol well suited to the genesis, contents and style of the Metamorphoses I have tackled only a part of the problem. We have seen that Corinth and its history could also be used to define a Greek cultural identity in contraposition to Rome. Is it possible that this side, too, of the ‘Corinthian myth’ is meaningful in Apuleius? Although his use of Corinth seems to be absolutely neutral, I think that the Metamorphoses lends itself to being read, in some measure, as a study in the problem of the relationship between Greece and Rome (or, better, the relationship between the empire’s periphery and its centre). Let us come back for a moment to the Onos, and, through it, to the lost Greek original. Even though the Onos makes no mention of Corinth, it nevertheless offers some opportunities to discuss our problem. In particular, I find it difficult to imagine that a Greek author could describe the transformation of a character named Lucius into an ass, a character clearly identified as a Roman citizen (quite an exceptional case for the ancient novel), without ————— 29
Trans. Hanson 1989.
CORINTH , ROME , AND AFRI CA
67
some small thrill of satisfaction.30 We could ask ourselves if the lost Greek original had a similar attitude,31 and if Apuleius somehow inherited it – or developed it independently. The problem of Apuleius’ cultural identity has been at the forefront, more or less explicitly, of much recent scholarship on the Metamorphoses. Particularly notable here is the useful survey of Apuleius’ Greek culture produced by Gerald Sandy.32 For reasons explained below, I think that Apuleius’ Hellenic underpinnings are only part of his bilingual culture, and probably not the most important.33 The subtitle of Harrison’s book (A Latin Sophist) presents a welcome counterbalance to, or completion of, this view. On the contrary Ken Dowden, in attempting to demonstrate that the Metamorphoses were written during Apuleius’ Roman period (perhaps around A.D. 155), has maintained that the novel was specifically written for an audience of readers living in Rome.34 I will try to reproduce briefly his arguments, at least those which are relevant to my subject (though my selection is of course arbitrary, I will be using Dowden’s words almost verbatim): – there is little evidence for the existence of literature beyond that which was produced for the élite of Rome and for the imperial circle; Latin authors usually wrote and published at Rome; if Apuleius had been primarily addressing provincial audiences and the North African market, he would be practically unique. The Florida and Apologia themselves were written for the Roman market: the Carthaginian audience is painted in Roman colours. – Apuleius’ works survived into the modern era only because they were sent, read and copied in Rome, as is shown by Sallustius’ subscriptio preserved in the manuscript F. ————— 30 31
32 33
34
Cf. Perry 1967, 220 ff.; contra, Walsh 1968. This could seem unlikely, since Photius states that the Onos has a satirical tone, while the lost Metamorphoseis has not. Anyway, Photius’ judgements do not always prove reliable, and the whole problem of the relations between the Onos, the lost Greek Metamorphoseis, and Apuleius’ Metamorphoses, is a vexata quaestio. Sandy 1997. An overestimation of Apuleius’ Greekness is found e.g. in Paratore 19422: Apuleius ‘conservò sempre la mentalità di un Greco’ (p. 71); ‘la sua opera e la sua personalità sono permeate di elementi greci, in quanto si distaccano fortemente dalla tradizione latina’ (p. 79). Dowden 1994.
68
–
LUCA GRAVE RI NI
In a work that contains a number of autobiographical reflections, Carthage is surprisingly absent from the Metamorphoses.
Dowden’s first argument is too general to be fully considered here. I shall limit myself to suggesting that it is a little a priori, while we should at least leave due space for exceptions that prove the rule; and that, after all, the Florida and Apologia seem to have been written at least for both an African and Roman audience.35 The Florida are a selection of Apuleius’ speeches; and, given the relation that so many of the fragments show with Carthage and Africa, it is probable that ‘the anthologist (whether Apuleius himself, or, more likely, someone else) did his work from a personal sense of national pride, or with his eyes set on a clearly marked audience, e.g. the city elite in Carthage’.36 This leads us to the question of the transmission of Apuleius’ works. If it was Rome and not Africa that ensured their preservation, this was due to historical processes, and not necessarily to Apuleius’ intention. Their survival proves only that somebody in Rome read Apuleius, and not necessarily that Apuleius himself intended them to be read primarily in Rome – nor that he was actually read there more than in Africa. Instead, St. Augustine (Epist. 138,19) suggests that Apuleius, as an African, was more familiar to the Africans; and the Historia Augusta relates that Septimius Severus complained about Clodius Albinus’ reputation of being a litteratus, while he used to read only ‘the Milesian stories from Carthage that his friend Apuleius wrote’.37 Regarding the absence of Carthage in the novel, this is indeed very striking, all the more so because almost all the Mediterranean world finds at least a small place in the prologue: Greece (Hymettos Attica et Isthmos Ephyrea et ————— 35
36
37
On the Carthaginian audience of the Florida see e.g. Vössing 1997, 444 ff. The Spanish Martial repeatedly and proudly states that his work is read all over the world: cfr. e. g. 1,1,2; 7,88,1 ff.; 8,3,4; 8,61,3–5; 11,3,3 ff.. An useful collection of similar passages in other authors (especially Ovid) is in Citroni 1975, 15 (ad 1,1,2) and Nisbet-Hubbard 1978, 333 ff. (ad Horace, C. 2,20), who point out that ‘the ambition for world-wide fame is attested as early as Alcman… and becomes a commonplace with Hellenistic and Roman poets’. Generally speaking, a view of Latin literary production less ‘centripetal’ than that of Dowden is offered e. g. by Gualandri 1989a. So Hunink 2001, 13; see also Harrison 2000, 132–134, who is more inclined than Hunink to think that Apuleius himself was the editor of the original four-book anthology from which our extant Florida seems to derive. Hist. Aug. Alb. 12,12 (trans. Magie 1967). For the early diffusion of Apuleius’ works in Africa cf. Stramaglia 1996, 139 ff.
CORINTH , ROME , AND AFRI CA
69
Taenaros Spartiatica), Rome (the urbs Latia), Egypt (papyrus Aegyptia argutia Nilotici calami inscripta), Asia Minor (Milesius sermo). Anyway, this absence can be explained by the fact that the Metamorphoses are after all the adaptation of a preexisting Greek work, so that its Greek setting was an almost unavoidable choice. The other geographical indications in the prologue mark specific literary choices made by Apuleius, i.e. the connection with sermo Milesius, Isiac cult and oriental religion, and the final movement to Rome (on which see supra). Therefore, it was difficult and pointless to integrate Africa into the prologue, or into the plot of the ass’ story. Nevertheless, Africa is not completely absent from the novel. First of all, celsa Carthago is referred to at 6,4,1 with regard to the worship of Juno; but the most interesting passage is the notorious Madaurensem of 11,27,9. At the end of the Onos, there is a near-explicit invitation to identify the main character with the author. We can leave out the question of the author’s name (there are definitely too many Lucii in this story!),38 but I think it is meaningful that the newly reshaped Lucius declares that he is a writer of tales (55: historion eimi syngrapheus). I think that the lost Greek original may have had a similar joke (a fact which possibly contributed to the confusion between the character Lucius, and the writers Lucius of Patrae and Lucian). Apuleius evidently echoes this joke when, near the end of his novel, he unexpectedly identifies himself with his character.39 He chooses to do this with a geographical indication, the Madaurensem, which could very well be, among other things,40 a nice way to give a hint to an African audience, invited to sympathize with an African character-author. Aside from these considerations, the case for an extended and pervasive presence of Roman culture in the Metamorphoses is of course very strong. Modern scholarship has increasingly tended to highlight the importance of the Latin literary tradition for our novel. And in at least one case, I think, we can identify a process of ‘translation’ of literary allusion: where the Onos exploits a Greek intertext, Apuleius seems to ‘reply’ with a Latin one.41 Interesting above all here is the wide influence that Roman culture has on the ‘Realien’ of the Metamorphoses: the languages of Roman law, religion, and ————— 38 39
40 41
For this problem, cf. e. g. Mason 1994, 1669 ff. the Madaurensem passage in book 11 represents, I think, a small but remarkable exception to the standard opinion that ‘the end of book 10 is the point where Met. and Onos diverge permanently’ (cf. Zimmerman 2000, 18, with further references). For the different interpretative possibilities see Harrison 2000, 228 ff. Graverini 2001b, 444 f.
70
LUCA GRAVE RI NI
daily life are frequently employed throughout the novel, and even toponyms referring to places in the city of Rome appear here and there. The details are often duly highlighted by commentaries and have been collected in a well informed paper by G. Rosati.42 These specifically ‘Roman’ cultural notes, he shows, are many in Apuleius’ novel, and could easily form the basis of a book on ‘The Roman World of Apuleius’ – a book that Rosati suggests needs to be written. Nevertheless, I still wonder if there is anything in these details that a literate, Latin-speaking reader in Africa (or in Greece, or elsewhere in the Empire far from the city of Rome) could not understand. Again, since it is impossible here to discuss every single point, I will try to challenge just a few of the strongest arguments that can be used in favour of a Roman audience for our novel. Three times (1,24,3; 1,25,1; 2,2,1) Apuleius mentions a forum cupidinis in Hypata; Scivoletto argues that this is a (very) learned allusion to an old forum cupidinis that existed in Rome three centuries before Apuleius, rather than to a real place in the Greek town of Hypata.43 In other words, the allusion is obscure and utterly ‘Roman’, referring to a particular place that had long ceased to exist in the city of Rome. Anyway, Scivoletto himself emphasizes that Apuleius knew it from antiquarian and literary sources: which of course were available, and read, not only in Rome. The second case, concerning the metae Murtiae in the Circus Maximus, is more interesting, since these structures still existed in the times of Apuleius. In 6,8,2 Mercury mentions them, saying that there Venus will reward with eight kisses the index who reveals the place where the fugitive Psyche has taken refuge. The sketch is even more humorous if one knows that inside the Circus Maximus, where the old shrine of Venus Murtia was located, ‘passeggiavano gli scortilla di maggior pretesa’,44 to whom Venus is playfully assimilated. Because this shrine of Venus Murtia45 is sometimes referred to in literature, I think we have reasonable grounds for doubting that the reference was obscure and unintelligible to people not living in Rome: close to ————— 42 43
44 45
Rosati, forthcoming. Scivoletto 1963, 236 ff. Cf. also van Mal-Maeder 1998, 76 ad loc., who emphasizes the pun (‘pour un Lucius en quête d’une pleine satisfaction des ses désirs… tout les chemins mènent au forum cupidinis’) but is more sceptical about Scivoletto’s conclusions. Marmorale 1965, 203; cf. also Harrison 1998, 64 f. For information about the shrine and the goddess, the best sources are Humphrey 1986, 60 f. and 95 ff.; Coarelli 1996; Coarelli 1999.
CORINTH , ROME , AND AFRI CA
71
Apuleius’ times, we have e. g. Plutarch (Q. Rom. 20, 268E) and Tertullian (spect. 8: curious and well informed Africans abound, as it seems!), who probably did not think of people living in Rome as their primarily intended audience. Of course their writings had certain didactic aims, while the Metamorphoses are more allusive, and difficult to understand. But I think that neither Plutarch nor Tertullian would have dealt with things that were totally abstruse for their readers. Because the Circus was also reproduced in coins, mosaics and reliefs, its shape was familiar throughout the Empire, as were its restorations and reconstructions by various emperors. In these iconographic media, the shrine of Venus Murtia/Murcia is sometimes recognizable (e.g. a relief in Foligno; a mosaic in Piazza Armerina; some coins of Trajan46). Finally, it is worth quoting the elogium of M. Valerius Maximus (CIL I2 p. 189 n. V), originally located in the Forum Augustum, that survived to us in a copy found in Arretium. The inscription says that the dictator obtained the honour of a curule seat ad Murciae spectandi causa, that is in a privileged place in the Circus, near the shrine. The elogia of the Forum Augustum, as well as other monuments, were reproduced in Arretium and elsewhere. It is therefore through literature, inscriptions, iconography, and coins that the shape of the capital of the empire, its monuments, topography, and toponyms, were made familiar even to those who never visited it.47 In any case, the Apuleian text does not seem to make well defined claims regarding its readers’ cultural horizons48 and their knowledge of the city of Rome. Even though a well informed reader (the ‘careful reader’ of 9,30,1) might easily comprehend these references, others could well ignore everything about the forum Cupidinis or the metae Murtiae (taking them at face ————— 46 47
48
Sources in Humphrey 1986, and Coarelli 1996 and 1999. In Carthage, we know of copies of the Ara Pacis Augustae and of the elogium of M. Claudius Marcellus: see Torelli 1975, 99–100 and Galinsky 1996, 150 (with further bibliography). We might also assume that on the periphery of the Empire there were a great number of Roman citizens carrying out their administrative functions, or doing their own business, and that local élites often travelled to Rome: Ann Kuttner suggests to me per litteras that ‘a shared knowledge of the city of Rome’ contributed to the bonding of Roman élites abroad. Of course, poetry and iconography also made the whole empire familiar to the citizens of Rome. For a short but dense survey of geographical and iconographical themes in imperial poetry cf. Connors 2000, 508 ff. On the metae Murtiae and Apuleius’ cultural identity see also Stephen Harrison’s paper in this volume, pp. 49 f. On the readership of the ancient novels, and its degree of literary education, see Wesseling 1988 and Stephens 1994. For the Florida, too, we must imagine a broad Carthaginian audience, provided with highly different levels of culture: cf. Vössing 1997, 444 ff. (esp. 466 f.).
72
LUCA GRAVE RI NI
value, i.e for simple toponyms), and still enjoy the sketches of the curator annonae Pythias trampling the fish Lucius has just bought, or of Mercury advertising the voluptuous reward promised by Venus. Thus, in the end, I think that none of these ‘specific’ references to the city requires an audience living in Rome, or even terribly familiar with it. But is this enough to prove a non-Romanocentric point of view in Apuleius? As I stated above, Corinth does not help us – and e silentio we can also affirm that, if Apuleius really desired to show or suggest a polemical attitude towards Rome, it is strange that he missed the easy occasion that the Corinthian setting offered.49 Nevertheless, there are some points that can be made to challenge still further the idea of a novel ‘written in Rome for the Romans’, and to emphasize the possibility that an African, or more generally a provincial audience was also important for Apuleius. Here is a rough list: –
Rome is the setting of the last chapters of the novel, but it is never described in minute detail; a detailed Roman setting could alienate nonRoman readers much more than the allusive passages that I have mentioned supra, and probably Apuleius did not want to take such a risk. there are two episodes, in which the donkey tries to appeal to the Emperor, or to the people of Rome.50 Of course, this is a joke made at the expense of Lucius, but maybe it is not very polite or respectful for Apuleius (and of the author of the lost Greek original, which had at least one of these episodes) to transform the name of Caesar and of Quirites into the braying of an ass.51 the famous episode of the Latin-speaking soldier who beats the poor gardener who cannot understand him (9,39,2 ff.) is worth quoting as well. The phraseology seems to imply that the superbia shown by this miles is typical of all soldiers, and most probably of all Latin-speaking
–
–
————— 49
50 51
Apuleius also held, in Carthage, the office of sacerdos provinciae, connected with the cult of Rome and the emperor: cf. Florida 16. On the office see Vössing 1997, 429 ff. Anyway, Rives 1995 argues that a truly ‘Roman’ religious identity did not develop in Carthage, where the local elite had strong familiar and religious bonds with Africa. 3,29,2–3; 8,29,5. Cf. also 7,3,3 and 7,13,3. An opposite view is found in Millar 1981, 66: the episode ‘offer a very significant image… of how the Emperor was conceived of as an ever-present protector’. But on the very next page the author states that ‘it was only in special circumstances that the Emperor would make his distant presence felt’.
CORINTH , ROME , AND AFRI CA
73
soldiers (‘a legionary… inquired in a haughty and arrogant tone where my master was taking his empty ass… the soldier, unable to restrain his natural insolence…’52). And certainly the episode is a sharp representation of the brutality and arrogance with which the central imperial power could sometimes manifest itself.53 the character of Charite recalls the Dido of Virgil, but is more faithful than Dido to her husband. This reaction to the literary model could be ascribed, as Ellen Finkelpearl has shown in a well documented study,54 to a kind of African national pride.
–
The praises of Carthage in the Florida (e. g. the famous 20,9–10, where Carthage is commended as ‘heavenly Muse of Africa’, and the Carthaginians as ‘very learned’), and the praise of provincial life in Hypata pronounced by Byrrhena in Metamorphoses 2,19,5–6, make it clear that a provincial milieu did not mean ipso facto frustration of someone’s ambition for an interesting life or even for literary glory – even though, of course, the provincial cities are painted as a ‘derivative Rome’.55 The province offered a vital environment for literary activity and, as the passage of St. Augustine I mentioned above seems to imply, a receptive market for Apuleius’ works. To sum up, I think that we can confidently define Apuleius’ cultural identity as a Latin one (not forgetting his bilingual education), and indeed ‘Romanocentrism’ offers a good interpretative category for the Metamorphoses. However, we should be cautious to place the city of Rome at the centre of Apuleius’ interests and to make its residents his primary ‘intended audience’.56 Of course Apuleius has been read, and intended to be read, also in ————— 52 53
54
55 56
Trans. Hanson 1989. Summers 1970, 526: ‘this scene, which is found in the asinus (44–45), has been adapted by Apuleius to place in clear focus the resentment of provincials toward the system of requisitions by the imperial government’. See also Hijmans et al. 1995, 325 (ad 9,39,2 superbo atque adroganti sermone) and 326 (ad 9,39,4 Graece). Finkelpearl 1998, 131 ff. Of course I also agree with Finkelpearl’s argument (pp. 141– 143) about Apuleius’ intended audience, not limited to the city of Rome. There was also some difference between Roman and Carthaginian cultural identities, as Finkelpearl states; anyway, Gualandri 1989b, 521 correctly points out that ‘l’africanità... difficilmente potrebbe apparire come resistenza culturale a Roma’. Dowden 1994, 423. This is more or less the conclusion also of Méthy 1983, who states (p. 46) that ‘le patriotisme d’Apulée et de Fronton se définit… comme un patriotisme occidental’ (as opposed to Roman, Greek and African patriotism). I recommend her paper for a valuable analysis of a number of points I could not consider here; however, I would not subscribe to the
74
LUCA GRAVE RI NI
Rome. But the Empire was full of learned Romans travelling abroad, and of learned provincials visiting Rome for various reasons and becoming acquainted with its culture, its way of life, its monuments.57 And provinces in general, and Africa in particular, were not short of learned people able to understand the subtleties of language and culture that Apuleius incorporates into his works.58 Since the hypothesis of a stylistic and lexical Africitas in Apuleius has been rightly rejected,59 there have not been many attempts to evaluate the importance that the provincial milieu can have had in the composition of the Metamorphoses; I hope that my arguments are at least suggestive of the possibility of ‘provincial’ interpretations of (parts of) the novel, and of the need for a more nuanced understanding of the role that issues such as Romanization and Hellenization play in this context.60
Bibliography Alcock, S. 1993. Graecia capta. The Landscapes of Roman Greece, Cambridge: University Press. Bowersock, G. W. 1965. ‘Zur Geschichte des römischen Thessaliens’, RhM 108, 277– 289. Bowie, E. L. 1996. ‘Past and present in Pausanias’, in: J. Bingen (ed.), Pausanias historien, Genève: Fondation Hardt, 207–230 + 231–239 (Discussion). Citroni, M. 1975, M. Valerii Martialis Epigrammaton liber primus, Firenze: La Nuova Italia. Coarelli, F. 1996. ‘Murcia’, in: E. M. Steinby (ed.), Lexicon Topographicum Urbis Romae, III, Roma: Quasar, 289–290.
————— 57
58
59
60
use of the term ‘patriotisme’ here, nor am I so completely sceptical as she is about the possibility of identifying sometimes an African, or provincial, point of view in Apuleius. Cf. Noy 2000; in particular, see pp. 252 ss. for people coming from North Africa. See also Fantham 1996, 236 ff. on the African travelling poet Annius Florus; and p. 253 on the cultural level of the African elite. For a similar view cf. Dewar 2000, 521; on the African cultural milieu, see also Fick 1987. Harris 1989, 267 states that ‘only Africa Proconsularis, Numidia, Dalmatia and Narbonensis are likely, as provinces, to have reached Italian levels of literacy’. For an evaluation of the size, wealth, and importance of the city of Carthage from the 2nd century AD onwards, see Hurst 1993, 327–337. Norden 19092, 588 ff. Anyway, Kenney 1990, 29 affirms that Apuleius’ language suggests ‘the experimental exploitation of an adopted tongue’. I am grateful to Alessandro Barchiesi, Ann Kuttner, and Kirk Freudenburg, who gave me useful advice on this paper; Gianpiero Rosati also let me read a preliminary version of his forthcoming paper.
CORINTH , ROME , AND AFRI CA
75
Coarelli, F. 1999. ‘Venus verticordia, aedes’: in: E. M. Steinby (ed.), Lexicon Topographicum Urbis Romae, V, Roma: Quasar, 119–120. Connors, C. 2000. ‘Imperial space and time: The literature of leisure’, in: O. Taplin (ed.), Literature in the Greek and Roman Worlds. A new perspective, Oxford – New York: Oxford University Press, 492–517. Crosby, L. H. 1986. Dio Chrysostom, Cambridge (Mass.) – London: Harvard University Press. Dewar, M. 2000. ‘Culture wars: Latin literature from the second century to the end of the classical era’, in: O. Taplin (ed.), Literature in the Greek and Roman Worlds, Oxford – New York: Oxford University Press, 519–545. Dowden, K. 1994. ‘The Roman Audience of The Golden Ass’, in: J. Tatum (ed.), The Search for the Ancient Novel, Baltimore – London: Johns Hopkins University Press, 419–434. Engels, D. 1990. Roman Corinth, Chicago – London: University of Chicago Press. Fairclough, H. R. 1999. Virgil. Eclogues, Georgics, Aeneid I–VI (revised by G. P. Goold), Cambridge (Mass.) – London: Harvard University Press. Fantham, E. 1996. Roman Literary Culture from Cicero to Apuleius, Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. Fick, N. 1987. ‘Le milieu culturel africain à l’époque antonine et le témoignage d’Apulée’, BAGB, 285–296. Finkelpearl, E. D. 1998. Metamorphosis of Language in Apuleius. A Study of Allusion in the Novel, Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. Forster, E. S. 1984. Lucius Annaeus Florus. Epitome of Roman History, Cambridge (Mass.) – London: Harvard University Press. Galinsky, K. 1996. Augustan Culture, Princeton: Princeton University Press. Gilman Romano, D. 2000. ‘A tale of two cities: Roman colonies at Corinth’, in: E. Fentress (ed.), Romanization and the city. Creation, transformations, and failures. Proceedings of a conference held at the American Academy in Rome to celebrate the 50th anniversary of the excavations at Cosa, 14–16 May, 1998, Portsmouth: Journal of Roman Archaeology, 83–104. Graverini, L. 2001. ‘L. Mummio Acaico’, Maecenas 1, 105–148. Graverini, L. 2001b. ‘L’incontro di Lucio e Fotide. Stratificazioni intertestuali in Apul. met. II 6–7’, Athenaeum 89, 425–446. Griffiths, J. G. 1975. Apuleius of Madauros. The Isis-Book (Metamorphoses, Book IX), Leiden: Brill. Gualandri, I. 1989a. ‘Per una geografia della letteratura latina’, in: G. Cavallo, P. Fedeli, A. Giardina (eds.), Lo spazio letterario di Roma antica, vol. II, La circolazione del testo, Roma: Salerno Editrice, 469–505. Gualandri, I. 1989b. ‘Persistenze e resistenze locali: un problema aperto’, in: G. Cavallo, P. Fedeli, A. Giardina (eds.), Lo spazio letterario di Roma antica, vol. II, La circolazione del testo, Roma: Salerno Editrice, 509–529. Hanson, J. A. 1989. Apuleius. Metamorphoses, Cambridge (Mass.) – London: Harvard University Press. Harris, W.V. 1989. Ancient Literacy, Cambridge (Mass.) – London: Harvard University Press.
76
LUCA GRAVE RI NI
Harrison, S. J. 1990. ‘The Speaking Book: The Prologue to Apuleius’ Metamorphoses’, CQ 40, 507–513. Harrison, S. J. 1998. ‘Some Epic Structures in Cupid and Psyche’, in: M. Zimmerman et al. (ed.), Aspects of Apuleius’ Golden Ass II: Cupid and Psyche, Groningen: E. Forsten, 51–68. Harrison, S. J. 2000. Apuleius. A Latin Sophist, New York: Oxford University Press. Hijmans, B. L. et al. 1995. Apuleius Madaurensis. Metamorphoses Book IX. Text, Introduction and Commentary, Groningen: Egbert Forsten. Hohlfelder, R. L. 1976. ‘Kenchreai on the Saronic gulf: aspects of its imperial history’, CJ 71, 217–226. Humphrey, J. H. 1986. Roman Circuses, London: Batsford. Hunink, V. 2001. Apuleius of Madauros. Florida, Amsterdam: Gieben. Hurst, H. 1993. ‘Cartagine, la nuova Alessandria’, in: A. Momigliano – A. Schiavone (edd.), Storia di Roma. III,2 I luoghi e le culture, Torino: Einaudi, 327–337. Jacobson, D. M. – Weitzman, M. P. 1995. ‘Black bronze and the “Corinthian alloy”’, CQ 45, 580–583. Kahane, A. – Laird, A. 2001. A Companion to the Prologue of Apuleius’ Metamorphoses, Oxford: Oxford University Press. Kenney, E. J. 1990. Apuleius. Cupid & Psyche, Cambridge – New York et al.: Cambridge University Press. Magie, D. 1987. The Scriptores Historiae Augustae, Cambridge (Mass.) – London: Harvard University Press. Marmorale, E. V. 1960, ‘Un appuntamento al Circo Massimo’, in: Id., Pertinenze e impertinenze, Napoli: Armanni, 194–203 (= GIF 11 [1958], 61–65). Mason, H. J. 1971. ‘Lucius at Corinth’, Phoenix 25, 160–165. Mason, H. J. 1983. ‘The distinction of Lucius in Apuleius’ Metamorphoses’, Phoenix 37, 135–143 Mason, H. J. 1994. ‘Greek and Latin Versions of the Ass-Story’, ANRW 34, 1665– 1707. Méthy, N. 1983. ‘Fronton et Apulée: Romains ou Africains?’, RCCM 25, 37–47. Millar, F. 1981. ‘The world of the Golden Ass’, JRS 71, 63–75. Miller, W. 1975. Cicero. De Officiis, Cambridge (Mass.) – London: Harvard University Press. Nenci, G. 1978. ‘Graecia capta ferum victorem cepit. Hor. Ep. II 1,156’, ASNP 8, 1007–1023. Nicolai, R. 1999. ‘Quis ille? Il proemio delle Metamorfosi di Apuleio e il problema del lettore ideale’, MD 42, 143–164. Nisbet, R. G. M. – Hubbard, M. 1978. A Commentary on Horace: Odes, Book II, Oxford: Clarendon Press. Norden, E. 19092. Die antike Kunstprosa, II, Leipzig-Berlin: Teubner. Noy, D. 2000. Foreigners at Rome: Citizens and Strangers, London: Duckworth. Pape, M. 1975. Griechische Kunstwerke aus Kriegsbeute und ihre öffentliche Aufstellung in Rom, diss. Hamburg. Paratore, E. 19422. La novella in Apuleio, Messina: Remo Sandron editore. Paton, W. R. 1960. The Greek Anthology, Cambridge (Mass.): Harvard University Press.
CORINTH , ROME , AND AFRI CA
77
Perry, B. E. 1967. The Ancient Romances, Berkeley – Los Angeles: University of California Press. Rives, J. B., 1995. Religion and Authority in Roman Carthage from Augustus to Constantine, Oxford: Clarendon Press. Rosati, G., forthcoming. ‘Quis ille? Identità e metamorfosi nel romanzo di Apuleio’, in: Proceedings of the Conference on Memoria e identità. La cultura romana costruisce la sua immagine (Florence, October 2000). Sandy, G.N. 1997. The Greek World of Apuleius, Leiden – New York – Köln: Brill. Scivoletto, N. 1963, ‘Antiquaria romana in Apuleio’, in: Id., Studi di letteratura latina imperiale, Napoli: Arimanni, 222–253. Stephens, S. A. 1994. ‘Who Read Ancient Novels?’, in: J. Tatum (ed.), The Search for the Ancient Novel, Baltimore – London: Johns Hopkins University Press, 405– 417. Stramaglia, A. 1996. ‘Apuleio come auctor: premesse tardoantiche di un uso umanistico’, Studi Umanistici Piceni 16, 137–161. Summers, R. J. 1970. ‘Roman Justice and Apuleius’ Metamorphoses’, TAPhA 101, 511–531. Swain, S. 1996. Hellenism and Empire. Language, Classicism, and Power in the Greek World, AD 50–250, New York: Oxford University Press. Torelli, M. 1975. Elogia Tarquiniensia, Firenze: Sansoni. Vallette, P. 1908. L’Apologie d’Apulée, Paris: Klincksieck. van Mal-Maeder, D. K. 1998. Apulée. Les Métamorphoses. Livre II,1–20, diss. Groningen. Veyne, P. 1965. ‘Apulée à Cenchrées’, RPh 39, 241–251. Vössing, K. 1997. Schule und Bildung im Nordafrika der Römischen Kaiserzeit, Bruxelles: Latomus. Walsh, P. G. 1968. ‘Was Lucius a Roman?’, CJ 63, 264–265. Wesseling, B. 1988. ‘The Audience of the Ancient Novels’, in: H. Hofmann (ed.), Groningen Colloquia on the Novel, I, Groningen: Egbert Forsten, 67–79. Whitmarsh, T. 1999. ‘Greek and Roman in dialogue: the pseudo-Lucianic Nero’, JHS 119, 142–160. Whitmarsh, T. 2001. ‘‘Greece is the World’: exile and identity in the Second Sophistic’, in: S. Goldhill (ed.), Being Greek under Rome. Cultural Identity, the Second Sophistic and the Development of Empire, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 269-305. Wiseman, J. 1979. ‘Corinth and Rome I: 228 B.C. – A.D. 267’, ANRW 7.1, 438–548. Zimmerman, M. 2000. Apuleius Madaurensis. Metamorphoses Book X. Text, Introduction and Commentary, Groningen: Egbert Forsten.
On the Road in Apuleius’ Metamorphoses MAAIKE ZIMMERMAN
Groningen
“The most characteristic thing about this novel is the way it fuses the course of an individual’s life (at its major turning points) with his actual spatial course or road – that is, with his wanderings. Thus is realized the metaphor of “the path of life”. The path itself extends through familiar, native territory, in which there is nothing exotic, alien or strange. Thus a unique novelistic chronotope is created, one that has played an enormous role in the history of the genre.” Thus Bakhtin in his essay Forms of Time and Chronotope in the Novel.1 Indeed, the importance of travel as a theme in this novel is highlighted from the Prologue onward. The first sentence of the story proper meaningfully starts with an expression of movement to a place: Thessaliam …petebam (“To Thessaly …I was heading”).2 Any reader of Apuleius’ Metamorphoses will remember the complaints of the protagonist about the hardships suffered during his existence as an ass, and specifically the complaints about the often laborious journeys which he is forced to make at the hands of various masters. In this essay I will examine more closely the roads as an important element in the space of this novel, and the ways in which the narrator describes them to his audience. I will examine how the protagonist’s remarks on the road and on the conditions of the road, made at several stages of his journey, become increasingly meaningful and appear to fully justify Bakhtin’s observation that the metaphor of the “path of life” is realized in this novel.
————— 1 2
Bakhtin 1981, 120. See Clarke 2001, 101 f.
ON THE ROAD IN APUL EI US ’ METAMORPHOSES
79
In general, landscape descriptions in Apuleius’ novel quite often are in some ways ‘symbolic’ of the narrative itself; in this respect, Apuleius employs procedures which may be found in Latin epic and other Latin lyric genres as well. One may, for instance, think of the harbour description in Verg. Aen. 1,159 ff., or Propertius’ elegies 1,17 and 1,18. Many passages in Ovid‘s Metamorphoses reveal a “… strong figurative collusion … between landscape and action”.3 In an interesting article, De Biasi has, with several examples, shown that often the elaborate landscape descriptions in Apuleius’ novel testify to such a figurative collusion; moreover, these sometimes reflect, or are in contrast with, the emotional state of the protagonist.4 In this essay I will single out for discussion precisely those passages on travelling and those roaddescriptions which De Biasi has mentioned only in a cursory way, because he does not consider the descriptions of the landscape in such passages to be functional. Indeed, they are not conceived as literary showpieces, as are some of the landscape descriptions studied by De Biasi, and he is probably right in leaving them out of his investigations. However, they are often meaningful on more than one level, and increasingly so as the novel proceeds.
Entering the world of the novel Our first meeting with the protagonist of Apuleius’ novel is a meeting on the road – the road to Thessaly. The description of his journey to Thessaly, immediately after the prologue, is elaborate and highly stylized: Postquam ardua montium et lubrica vallium et roscida cespitum et glebosa camporum emersi, equo indigena peralbo vehens iam eo quoque admodum fesso, … I had emerged from steep mountain tracks and slippery valley roads, damp places in the meadows and cloddy paths through the fields. I was riding a native-bred pure white horse; as he too was now quite tired, … (Apul. Met. 1,2.2)5 ————— 3
4
5
Hinds 2001, 132 ff. offers an intriguing discussion of this aspect of Ovid’s landscapes, with references to other literature; the quotation in my text is from Hinds 2001,132, with his emphasis. De Biasi 2000, 199–264 (repr. of De Biasi 1990); see esp. pp. 219 ff., on “il collegamento psicologico tra paesaggio e personaggio”. Translations of passages from Apuleius’ Metamorphoses are, unless expressly stated otherwise, from Hanson 1989.
80
MAAIKE ZIMMERMAN
This is a journey over land, and the description especially concerns the conditions of the soil trodden by the traveller, or rather by his mount. The length of the journey is suggested by the elaborateness of the sentence with its four kola of equal length. Lucius’ host Milo is quite right when he later refers to this journey by his guest as ‘quite a difficult and extensive journey’. (Apul. Met. 1,23.8: satis arduo itinere atque prolixo). This description, at the very beginning of the story proper, marks the entrance of the protagonist, and at the same time our own entrance as readers, into the world of the novel. Within this world we will move along with the ass continuously until his flight – at the end of the tenth book – from the interior to the coast, to the beach of Cenchreae, and then further on into the world of Isis. … iam cursu memet celerrimo proripio, sexque totis passuum milibus perniciter confectis Cenchreas pervado, quod oppidum audit quidem nobilissimae coloniae Corinthiensium, alluitur autem Aegeo et Saronico mari. I … hurled myself forward with the utmost rapidity. I covered six whole miles at full speed and arrived at the town of Cenchreae, which is well-known as part of the illustrious territory of the Corinthians, and is washed by the Aegean Sea and the Saronic Gulf. (Apul. Met. 10,35.3) In my view, both the passages just quoted clearly indicate transitional phases, suggesting liminal experiences, as discussed by Margaret Anne Doody in the section ‘Tropes of the Novel’ of her book The True Story of the Novel.6 Book Eleven evolves in a different world: After his flight from Corinth, Lucius the ass enters the sacred places of Isis, the beach of Cenchreae, and the temple precinct there. In the eleventh book of the Metamorphoses, Lucius, who has regained his human shape, and has become an initiate of Isis’ cult, no longer mentions journeys along roads. He stays for some time in Cenchreae, then pays a short visit to his home town, after which he travels to Rome; his journey is swift and also profitable – probably because he has undertaken it ‘at the powerful goddess’s urging’ (deae potentis instinctu):
… digredior et recta patrium larem revisurus meum … contendo paucisque post diebus deae potentis instinctu … nave conscensa Romam ————— 6
Doody 1998, 319 ff., Ch. 14, ‘Marshes, Shores, and Muddy Margins’.
ON THE ROAD IN APUL EI US ’ METAMORPHOSES
81
versus profectionem dirigo tutusque prosperitate ventorum ferentium Augusti portum celerrime pervenio ac dehinc carpento perviolavi … sacrosanctam istam civitatem accedo. I … departed and hurried straight to visit my ancestral hearth … After a few days there, at the powerful goddess’s urging I … boarded a ship, and set out towards Rome, Safely driven by favourable winds, I arrived very quickly at the Port of Augustus, and hurried from there by carriage … I reached the holy, inviolate city. (Apul. Met. 11,26,1–2) From this passage it becomes clear that the world of the eleventh book evolves in a different space, whithout difficult roads to travel. It will therefore be the first ten books on which I will concentrate in this essay ‘on the road’. Equally, I will reserve for brief mention at the end the space of the Tale of Cupid and Psyche (4,28 – 6,24), since that tale does not concern journeys by the protagonist of the novel.
On the road with Lucius, the ass In the first ten books of the novel we encounter numerous passages where roads are being travelled under various circumstances. I will now turn to these. First I will give an overview, while discussing interesting intertextual references and possible connections. Then I will try to answer the question of whether we are entitled to ascribe a meaningful function to the way in which road conditions are described in the first ten books of the Metamorphoses. As soon as Lucius – transformed by error into an ass – has been stolen by the robbers to carry the booty from Milo’s house, he is led through a mountainous region, where there seem to be no roads at all: … nos … per avia montium ducunt concitos. [They] … took us through the trackless mountains at full speed. (Apul. Met. 3,28.6) As Gianotti 1995 remarks,7 many elements of this first journey of Lucius in the shape of an ass, per avia montium (through the trackless mountains) to ————— 7
Gianotti 1995, 117.
82
MAAIKE ZIMMERMAN
the robbers’ cave, suggest his progressive estrangement from the civilized world and from his existence as a human being. The poor ass suffers badly: Iamque rerum tantarum pondere et montis ardui vertice et prolixo satis itinere nihil a mortuo differebam. With the weight of all those goods and the height of the steep mountain and the extreme length of the march, I was as good as dead. (Apul. Met. 3,29.1) At this point, it is useful to remember that in this novel Apuleius is working from the model of a Greek ass tale. This Greek example has not been passed down to us, but is described by the ninth-century Byzantine bishop Photius,8 who mentions the title of this work: 13/!"4
21#, and designates its author as being Loukios of Patras. What we do have, however, is the shortened version of the Greek 13/!"4
21#, an epitome, handed down to us in the corpus of Lucian’s works, and entitled !!#0V!#.9 I will refer to this epitome as ‘the Onos’. Now, also in the Onos Loukios, the ass complains about the hard journey with the robbers, as follows: /~ !]3'# {/ %!# 4{"!3/# -»# !# /!31# 0/$! 1<# 3 P"!#3"3ëM0î4111"
1!3xz!^/3}!X$%' 1<1ÔQ3$/2%10z$03!#2$}#{3"/#L 1/# /' 3!2/ã3/ 21 4{"' ' Despite such a heavy load, they drove us, beating us with sticks, towards the mountain, attempting to escape by an unused path. I can’t say what the other animals felt, but I myself, feet unshod and unused to such travel, moving over sharp rocks and carrying such heavy stuff, I was practically dead. (Onos 16,3 f.)10 It can be seen immediately that at this point the Latin Metamorphoses runs parallel to the text of the Onos.
————— 8 9
10
Photius Bibl. 129. For a recent discussion of the Greek sources of Apuleius’ Metamorphoses, with literary references, see Mason 1999. Translations of passages from the Onos are from Sullivan 1989.
ON THE ROAD IN APUL EI US ’ METAMORPHOSES
83
Only a short while later, remarkably enough, just after the ass has heard the robbers mention that the day’s journey is almost over, the narrator descibes the last part of the road as follows: Nam et secum eos animadverteram colloquentes, quod in proximo nobis esset habenda mansio et totius viae finis quieta eorumque esset sedes illa et habitatio. Clementi denique transmisso clivulo pervenimus ad locum destinatum. I had also gathered from their conversation that we would shortly be making a halt and taking a rest after the end of the journey, and that their headquarters and residence were there. We then climbed a gentle slope and arrived at our destination. (Apul. Met. 4,5.6–7) It is instructive to compare the corresponding passage in the Onos: /~3íÄ23í0z0!$!i#!X1@$3!3Æ#M0!ã!/~Q3 /3/1!ã2 $/ /3/2!$2Ý m231 3/ã3/ y3/ 0"ë !!1/~"3Æ#2{"/#0!11<#3x!<1Ô/ And I heard the bandits saying that there wasn’t much of the journey still left and that they would be staying where they unpacked. So we carried all this stuff at a trot, and we arrived at their home base before dusk. (Onos 20,2 f.) This last passage of Apuleius’ text and its counterpart in the Onos reveal that only in the Latin text is the emotional situation of the protagonist – whose hopes are raised since he has heard that the journey will soon end – reflected in his perception of the road conditions:11 suddenly the last part of the mountain road, which only a short moment ago was steep and unbearable, becomes a clemens clivulus; the use of the diminutive heightens the affective value of this ‘gentle slope’. I do not agree with the Groningen Commentaries on Apuleius,12 which, in line with Junghanns (1932, 62), consider this phrase ironic. We see repeatedly that the narrator’s descriptions of the condition of the roads along which he – being the ‘I’ and the protagonist of this story – travels either reflect his own emotional state at the time, or are in some other way suggestive of the particular situation in which he finds himself. In this ————— 11
12
One may wonder whether in the lost, larger Greek version more extensive remarks on the road conditions were present (see for one possible case below, note 16). However, since we only have the epitome, the Onos must remain our point of comparison. Hijmans et alii, eds. 1977, 54.
84
MAAIKE ZIMMERMAN
connection, it may sometimes be worthwile to note that even the narrator’s silence about the hardships of the road can be meaningful, as will be illustrated by the discussion of the following cluster of passages: The robbers lead their newly acquired beasts of burden, loaded with booty, to their hiding place. The road leading there is, as we might expect, steep and full of sharp rocks and thorny bushes: Mons … in primis altus fuit. Huius per obliqua devexa, quae saxis asperrimis et ob id inaccessis cingitur, convalles lacunosae cavaeque nimium spinetis aggeratae et quaqua versus repositae naturalem tutelam praebentes ambiebant. The mountain was … pre-eminently high. Its precipitous slopes, where it was ringed with jagged and hence inaccessible rocks, were encircled by pitted, hollow gullies, well fortified by thick thorn-bushes and isolated on every side, furnishing a natural defence. (Apul. Met. 4,6.2–3) Later, the robbers take the ass to another hide-out to fetch some loot, and the path to that place is described as very difficult: … multisque clivis et anfractibus fatigatos prope ipsam vesperam perducunt ad quempiam speluncam…toward evening, when we were exhausted from many a hill and winding dale, they brought (us) to a cave … (Apul. Met. 6,25.4) and they follow the same difficult path back again: … unde multis onustos rebus rursum ne breviculo quidem tempore refectos ociter reducunt. Tantaque trepidatione festinabant, ut me plagis multis obtundentes propellentesque super lapidem propter viam positum deicerent, unde crebris aeque ingestis ictibus crure dextero et ungula sinistra me debilitatum aegre ad exurgendum compellunt …, loaded us with quantities of loot, and, not even allowing us a brief moment to regain our strength, started us back again with all speed. They were so agitated and in such a hurry that with their frequent battering and shoving they made me fall over a rock at the side of the road. They continued none the less to rain blows on me, eventually forcing me to get
ON THE ROAD IN APUL EI US ’ METAMORPHOSES
85
up, though I found it difficult, for I had gone lame in my right leg and left hoof. (Apul. Met. 6,25.4 (rest) + 5) And yet, when the ass attempts to escape from the robbers’ den with a beautiful young woman on his back, we hear no complaints about the extremely difficult conditions of the road, which must be the same as when the ass arrived there. He runs with the speed of a racehorse: Ego simul voluntariae fugae voto et liberandae virginis studio, sed et plagarum suasu quae me saepicule commonebant, equestri celeritate quadripedi cursu solum replaudens … I was moved not only by the desire to effect my own self-chosen escape and eagerness to rescue the maiden, but also by the persuasion of the blows which admonished me from time to time; and so I smote the earth in a four-footed gallop with the speed of a racehorse. (Apul. Met. 6,28.1) From the second half of the eighth book of the Metamorphoses and onward Lucius, the ass, travels more regularly. Schlam,13 who structures the novel in terms of travel, has with reason entitled section 8.15 – 10.31 ‘On the road’. I will now turn to some striking passages from that section. After the destruction of the household of Charite and Haemus, the familia of the household, slaves with their family, cattle and possessions, travel as a group to find a new settlement. The narrator has already informed us that he, the ass, is delighted to leave the place where he had been threatened by castration. He does not complain about his burden: Nec me pondus sarcinae, quanquam enormis urguebat, quippe gaudiali fuga detestabilem illum exectorem virilitatis meae relinquentem. But the weight of my load, though enormous, was no burden to me: it was a joyous escape, after all, to leave behind that detestable amputator of my manhood. (Apul. Met. 8,15.4) The road described immediately hereafter, leading from mountainous terrain to more level roads, again reflects the emotional state of the protagonist, who escapes from an imminent danger, and hopes to remain intact. It is ————— 13
Schlam 1992, 30; 36 f.
86
MAAIKE ZIMMERMAN
remarkable that in this description the length of the journey is merely reported, but not, as so often before, complained about. The ass is happy to move very far away from the place where they had planned to castrate him: Silvosi montis asperum permensi iugum rursusque reposita camporum spatia pervecti, iam vespera semitam tenebrante pervenimus ad quoddam castellum frequens et opulens. We crossed the rough ridge of a wooded mountain and traversed the length of the low-lying plain beyond. Just as dusk was darkening the road, we came to a wellpopulated and prosperous hamlet.14 (Apul. Met. 8,15.5) Although the travelling group encounters several dangerous adventures and loses some companions, they finally find a place to settle:
… rursum pergimus dieque tota campestres emensi vias civitatem quandam populosam et nobilem iam fessi pervenimus. Having walked all day across the plain, we now arrived exhausted at a large and famous city. (Apul. Met. 8,23.1) Note the qualification campestres (‘level’) for the roads. This adjective as a qualification of roads is used three times in the Metamorphoses; I will discuss it below, in the section on `Difficult and easy roads’.
Slippery roads The ass is then sold to a travelling band of Galloi, priests of the Dea Syria, described by the narrator with considerable disgust. They are not only sexually perverse, but also devious, greedy, and cruel in their behaviour towards the ass. After having piled up huge amounts of money by deceiving ————— 14
It is instructive to note that the Onos in the parallel passage (Onos 34,4–5) mentions an ‘uncomfortable road’, covered overnight: 0z ,% z 4{"' 4!"3! P!$ !ã p !^ 21!# 3 0! 3!ã3! 3Æ# Æ# 01 y 3!Æ# /~ 3| 3/ Q 31# M0 "/{/ /~ 3"í ' -1"í 3| M0 2/31# "%1/#3Æ#/10!/#û{"!/1y/~!$y"'! I was angry at carrying a real ass’s load, but on the other hand I was happy to get this reprieve from castration. Traveling the whole night on an uncomfortable road, we came to the end of it after three more days and arrived in Beroea, a large and well-populated city of Macedonia.
ON THE ROAD IN APUL EI US ’ METAMORPHOSES
87
gullible villagers, they take to their heels. The road along which they take the ass is described at length:
… rursum ad viam prodeunt, viam totam, quam nocte confeceramus, longe peiorem, quidni? Lacunosis incilibus voraginosam, partim stagnanti palude fluidam et alibi subluvie caenosa lubricam. Crebris denique offensaculis et assiduis lapsibus iam contusis cruribus meis vix tandem ad campestres semitas fessus evadere potui. … they took to the road again, a road from beginning to end far worse than the one we had covered by night. For it was muddy, with the drains full of puddles, in some parts waterlogged by stagnant pools, in other places slippery with slush and mud. As a consequence my legs were by now bruised by the numerous obstacles and constant falls, and only with great difficulty could I finally escape, tired out, on to level paths.15 (Apul. Met. 9,9.1–2) In the Onos, too, the Galloi leave stealthily, and the passage in the Latin novel runs fairly parallel to Onos 41,4; it is, however, only Apuleius’ text that has this elaborate description of the road. Our attention is enlisted all the more by the address to the reader: ‘quidni?’. The emphatic quality of this particle is lost in the translations, which render it by ‘for’, or ‘since’: indeed, it introduces a more detailed explication of the previous statement; the translation by Annaratone 1977 acknowledges its discursive force: Non ci credete? We find here, again, as in the previously quoted passage from Book 8, the combination of a notion of escape (evadere potui) with the qualification of `level-ness’ of the road (campestres semitas). The qualification ‘level’ (campester) will be discussed more extensively below, in the section on `Difficult and easy roads’. The phrase viam … lubricam deserves closer scrutiny. The adjective lubricus, used to denote slippery ground, occurs in the Metamorphoses already earlier, when the young tormentor of the ass refuses to help him after he stumbles heavily laden with wood at a slippery riverbank. The other occurrence is in 1,2.2, quoted above (lubrica vallium, ‘slippery valley ————— 15
Here I have followed the more literal translation of Hijmans, B.L. et alii, eds., 1995, 92– 94, with one change: they have at the end of this sentence: `country roads’; I prefer ‘level paths’ (Hanson: ‘a level path’).
88
MAAIKE ZIMMERMAN
roads’). At other places